S 900 J () Ory JJbl r\_ If )( . I MICHIGAN H iARW^ CQM^flSSlON-/' ' ?|?^?^'^ :i^ .'¦ MICHIGAN HISTORICAL COMMISSION A State Department of History and Archives BULLETIN NO. 2 Suggestions for Local Historical Societies and Writers in Michigan PREPARED BY GEORGE NEWMAN FULLER, Ph. D. SECRETARY WYNKOOP HALLENBECK CRAWFORD CO.. STATE PRINTERS LANSING, MICHIGAN, OCTOBER, 1913 MEMBERS OF THE COMMISSION Governor Woodbridge N. Ferris ex officio Clarence M. Burton, President Detroit William L. Jenks, Vice President - Port Huron ^T. Rev. Monsignor O'Brien Kalamazoo Edwin 0. Wood Flint Lawton T. Hemans Mason Claude H. Van Tyne, Ph. D. Ann Arbor secretary George Newman Fuller, Ph. D. curator Mrs. M. B. Ferrey PREFACE This bulletin aims to meet the request frequently received at the office of the Commission to furnish suggestions for the organization and work of the local pioneer and historical societies. It is no doubt true that the highest usefulness of the local societies can be attained by working together under the direction of the Commission, and to this end some degree of uniformity in organization and activities would be helpful. Attention is specially invited to those points in the suggested constitution and by-laws which bear upon relations between the societies and the Commission. For instance, one of the most helpful sources of information for the so cieties is their mutual needs and experiences in dis covering, collecting and preserving historical materials ; this knowledge the Commission would gladly convey to each society in its bulletins, but of course it can do so only if it is kept duly informed. Questions about means of securing the best results in particular local fields will receive individual attention. There is little need to suggest that a constitution does not insure life in a society. The vitality of any organization depends upon the intelligent interest and work of its members. A half-dozen well-informed and enthusiastic workers would be a fair substitute 8 preface for the best constitution, and there are doubtless to be found in every community of Michigan many more than a half-dozen persons who are intelligently in terested in collecting and preserving the records of the common life. To further aid these workers the Commission will be glad to send its representatives, as occasions arise to visit them and get into personal touch with the officers and members of their societies. In the upper peninsula Mr. A. L. Sawyer of Menominee is in special charge of this work and organizers and officers of societies there should correspond directly with him. In the lower peninsula correspondence should be directed to the Secretary of the Historical Commission, who is also Secretary of the Pioneer and Historical Society, and arrangements will , be made for a con ference either with the Secretary or with the Curator of the Museum, Mrs. M. B. Ferrey. SUGGESTIONS FOR A CONSTITUTION' Constitution of the County Historical Society ARTICLE I NAME We, the undersigned persons, interested in the history of County, by these articles as sociate ourselves under the name of The County Historical Society. ARTICLE II MEMBERSHIP Sec. 1. Any person who is interested in the history of this county and of the State of Michigan may be come an associate and active member of this society on payment of an entrance fee of fifty cents. Sec. 2. Active membership may be retained after the first year by the payment of fifty cents annual dues. Sec. 3. Honorary or life membership, as a recog nition of eminent service rendered to the society, may I. The first draft of this constitution was prepared by Mr. A. L. Sawyer of Menominee. 10 suggestions for a constitution be conferred upon any of the society's members by a vote of two-thirds of the members present at any regular meeting, due notice having been given of the intended action. ARTICLE III purpose The purpose of this society is to aid in the discovery, collection and preservation of every variety of material illustrative of the history of this county and of Mich igan: such as letters, diaries, journals, memoranda, pioneer reminiscences, newspapers, account books, school and church registers, commemorative addresses, genealogies and biographies, photographs, pictures and paintings, aboriginal relics, material objects illus trating the life of pioneers, maps, histories and records of the county and of its cities, towns, villages and institutions. ARTICLE IV depository The depository of this society for all of its col lections shall in the beginning be in the city (or village) of , but may be changed by a majority vote of the members. ARTICLE V meetings Sec. 1. The annual meeting of this society shall be suggestions for a constitution U held at on the day of in each year, at o'clock, M. Sec. 2. In case of failure to hold the meeting at such time the same may be held at any time at such place on ten days' notice, to be given by the president, secretary, or by any five members of the society. Sec. 3. Such notice may be given by publishing the same in any newspaper printed and circulated in this county at least ten days before such meeting, or by sending a copy thereof by mail to each member of the society to his post office address as the same shall appear upon the records of the society. Sec. 4. Special meetings may convene at any time for any purpose upon notice given in like manner. Sec. 5. A quorum for the transaction of business at an annual or special meeting shall consist of at least one-fifth of the enrolled active membership for the year current. Sec. 6. A majority vote of all present and voting on any question shall control. Sec. 7. Notice of all meetings of the societj'^ shall be mailed to the Secretary of the Michigan Historical Commission at the same time notice of such meeting is given to the members of the society. ARTICLE VI officers Sec. 1. The officers of the society shall be a Presi- 12 suggestions for a constitution dent, Vice President, Secretary, Treasurer and His torian. Sec. 2. These officers shall be elected at the annual meeting each year, or in case of failure so to elect then at any other regular meeting. Sec. 3. All officers shall hold office for the period of one year or for the remainder of the period of one year from the date fixed for the annual meeting of the year, and until their successors shall have been elected and shall have duly qualified. Sec. 4. The five officers so elected shall constitute a Board of Directors who shall, as such Board, manage the business of the society, subject to such regulations and restrictions as may from time to time be pre scribed or imposed by the society at any regular meeting of its members. Sec. 5. At each annual meeting the society shall elect a Corresponding Secretary for each township of the county, whose duty it shall be to report to the Secretary such matters as may be of use to the society. ARTICLE VII duties Sec. 1. The duties of the President, Vice President, Secretary and Treasurer, shall correspond to those usually imposed upon such officers in societies of like nature, and special duties may be imposed upon any of them by the society or the Board of Directors. Sec. 2. It shall be the duty of the Historian to take proper care of all collections of the society, to aid and suggestions for a constitution 13 counsel with historical writers among the members of the society, to foster the historical spirit in the mem bership at large, and to make frequent reports thereof, and of the needs of the society, to the Secretary of the Michigan Historical Commission. ARTICLE VIII MEETINGS OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS Sec. 1. The regular meetings of the Board of Di rectors shall be held on the first in January, April, July and October of each year, and at such other times as may be provided in the by-laws. Sec. 2. Special meetings of the Board may be held at any time on three days' written notice by mail to each Director, which notice may be given by either the President or Secretary. Sec. 3. At any meeting of the Board three members shall constitute a quorum, but it shall require the support of a majority of the full Board to carry a motion or adopt a resolution. Sec. 4. The President of the society shall act as chairman of the Board and the Board shall convene at his call. ARTICLE TX DISPOSITION OF COLLECTIONS Sec. 1. Upon the acquisition by the society of any document or article of historical value, its disposition, subject to any restriction placed thereon by its donor 14 SUGGESTIONS FOR A CONSTITUTION or donors, shall be under the direction of the Board of Directors. Sec. 2. In case any such document or article be not preserved in the locality of the society, then the same shall be tendered to the State of Michigan through the Michigan Historical Commission, to be placed in care of said Commission. Sec. 3. In consideration of assistance proffered by the Michigan Historical Commission in the prosecu tion of the work of this society, and because of the society's interest in the work of the Commission, it is hereby provided that in case the society fails in three consecutive years to have a quorum at its annual meeting, which shall be interpreted as the cessation of an effective working organization, then all articles and things belonging to it shall become the property of the State of Michigan, and, subject to the approval and acceptance of the Michigan Historical Commission, shall pass to the State and be in charge of said Com mission. ARTICLE X AMENDMENTS This constitution may be amended by a majority vote of the members present at any annual meeting or at a special meeting called for that purpose, notice of such intended action having been given in each case in writing to each member at least thirty days before such meeting. SUGGESTIONS FOR A CONSTITUTION 15 IN TESTIMONY WHEREOF we have hereunto set our hands and respective post office addresses on the date set opposite our respective names. NAME ADDRESS DATE etc. SUGGESTIONS FOR BY-LAWS By-laws of the County Historical Society. I MEMBERSHIP Editors of newspapers who give the society the ser vice of their papers to record notices and reports of meetings may, at the discretion of the society, be made life members in the same manner as provided in the constitution. On payment of $15, or on receipt of papers or articles valued by the society at $15, any person may become a life member of the society. II BOARD OF DIRECTORS The Board of Directors shall represent and act for the society during the interim between meetings of the society, but any action of the Board may be re scinded at any annual or special meeting of the society. No indebtedness shall be incurred by the Board SUGGESTIONS FOR BY-LAWS 17 greater than can be met by the unappropriated moneys at the time in the hands of the Treasurer except by specific authority of the society. Ill TREASURER The Treasurer shall disburse no funds of the society except by order of the society or the Board of Directors, and shall make to the society at its annual meeting an itemized report of all moneys received and disbursed during the year current. No bills shall be paid by the Treasurer which are not signed by the President of the society. IV CURATOR A Curator may be appointed by the society to arrange, catalogue, and preserve the collections of the society in accord with rules which the society shall make. At the regular meeting of the society the Curator shall make a report of all acquisitions made by the society during the year current, and shall give such information about each paper or thing as shall be deemed of value. A like report shall be made of all papers or things missing from the collection during the year. These reports shall be transmitted by the Historian of the society to the Secretary of the Michigan His torical Commission. 18 SUGGESTIONS FOR BY-LAWS V ELECTIONS The election of officers of the society shall be by ballot unless otherwise decreed by majority of all members present and voting. VI STANDING COMMITTEES The standing committees of this society shall be ¦ ¦ ¦ ' whose duties shall be as follows : VII ORDER OF BUSINESS At the annual meeting of the society the following shall be the order of business: (1) Minutes of the previous meeting; (2) Report of the secretary; (3) Report of the treasurer; (4) Report of committees; (5) Unfinished business; (6) Social recess; (7) Election of officers; (8) New business; (9) Addresses and papers; (10) Adjournment. VIII SOCIAL The society shall provide at its annual meeting for a social gathering or picnic, to be held on a given date and at a place to be decided from invitations extended through the recording secretaries to the society by SUGGESTIONS FOR BY-LAWS 19 members in the different townships of the county. Suitable record of such informal meeting shall be made and preserved. DELEGATES TO STATE SOCIETY A delegate shall be chosen by the society from among its officers to represent the society at the an nual June meeting of the Michigan Pioneer and His torical Society, the transportation of such delegate to and from the place of meeting to be defrayed by the local society. Such member shall attend carefully to such instruction as may be given at such meeting under the auspices of the State society, or of the Michigan Historical Commission, concerning the work of State and local historical societies and report thereon to this society. HINTS FOR PRACTICAL WORK THE FUNCTION OF THE LOCAL HISTORICAL SOCIETY The difficulties encountered by almost all old com munities when they have tried to reconstruct the life of their early past is reason for a strong protest against an opinion commonly voiced in new communities that they are too young to have any history. Of course no community is at any time too young to have some past, and to have some record of that past if only in the memories of the pioneers. It is exactly the time to begin to keep records of the community life when a community is young, for never again will the opportunity be afforded to preserve them so judiciously and completely. It is too true that the present seems commonplace. It is generally true that the individual has little concern for it excepting as it ministers to his needs in the present or the im mediate future. Under these conditions it is not easy to cultivate the historical sense of seeing the present from the viewpoint of the distant future. In this work the service of the local historical society must supple ment individual initiative. THE ELEMENTS OF A SUCCESSFUL SOCIETY In every present-day Michigan community there exist the elements by means of which to effect an HINTS FOR PRACTICAL WORK 21 awakening of the group mind to the social and civic virtues of history. In all of them there are public- spirited citizens of some culture and initiative. In the popular mind there need but be a thorough con viction that the community can never achieve its highest welfare as a community, and hence the highest welfare of every individual in it, except by acting upon the knowledge of its past and of its relationships with the larger environment of which it is a part. The initial organization and work of the local historical society is dependent primarily upon the intelligent, persistent effort of the public-spirited citizens of the community acting through the club, the lodge, the school, the library, the church, the press, all of the local business, social, civic and political organizations of the community. POPULAR INTEREST IN " OLD THINGS" There is an initial advantage in the popular general interest in old things, that is, if they are old enough to have ceased to be commonplace, an interest that is often more than mere curiosity. Personal and family pride in the possession of old objects is not uncommon. The collecting instinct can very profitably be directed through the local press towards the accumulation of such objects, and the press is of course always glad to start ideas and publish results that will interest its readers. Interest in private collecting will lead natural ly to group action by association of interests. 22 HINTS FOR PRACTICAL WORK AROUSING AND DIRECTING POPULAR INTEREST IN COLLECTING; START IN THE HOME Naturally some things are more worthy of col lecting than others, as suggested in Article III of the constitution in this bulletin. A good starting point is the home. Attics and basements would yield many surprises doubtless even to their owners; a rainy day could be spent very pleasantly exploring and in ventorying these much neglected comers. Starting in the home, there may be gathered a variety of useful historical material in the shape of letters, diaries, ac count books, scrap books, family records, genealogies and photographs. Photographs furnish of course ex cellent illustrations of persons, manners and customs. ' ' INTERVIEWING ' ' PIONEERS An exceedingly pleasant entering wedge to develop an interest in the life of the community is to interview the old pioneers, a practice that will often prove as profitable as pleasant. Especially school children can be thus interested, and often through them their families. The memories of pioneers, while sometimes treacherous as to dates and persons, may yield items of much value about early settlement, as illustrated in the many reminiscences in the volumes of the Michigan Pioneer and Historical Collections. There are few means of arousing popular interest in Michigan's early history equal to a few evenings spent in perusing the HINTS FOR PRACTICAL WORK 23 accounts written by the pioneers for these volumes.^ RELICS OF THE INDUSTRIES The farm, the shop, the mill, the tavern, are a few of the places which contain objects that would aid the imagination to reconstruct the past to the end of a more profitable study and appreciation of the present. A collection of such objects is especially valuable in places where there have been radical changes, as from lumbering or mining to agriculture, or where new in dustries as dairying, beet-growing or fruit culture have been added, or where there have been radical changes in the methods of these industries. MATERIALS RELATING TO CIVIC LIFE Objects, pictures and drawings illustrating public utilities such as ferries, bridges, drainage and sewer ing, water supplies, fire protection, lighting, street transportation, parking, military defense, jails, etc., are very instructive for good citizenship and hence very worthy of preservation. MISCELLANEOUS PRINTED MATERIALS In another class of things to collect come the printed materials. Especially worthy are all publications of 2. The first seven volumes are especially good for this purpose and can be obtained from the Secretary of the Michigan Historical Cotmnission at $1 per volume. They can be supplied gratis, including transportation, to libraries in educational institutions and Ranges containing 500 volumes. Temporary loans can be made to the smaller libraries. 24 HINTS FOR PRACTICAL WORK the local press, — newspapers, periodicals and journals, public ordinances, reports of local clubs and organiza tions, books or pamphlets written by local talent, and clippings about the community issued from the out side press. INDIAN RELICS Interest is usually easy to arouse in archaeological and ethnological remains. Scarcely a county in Mich igan is without some evidence of Indian occupation. Indian trails can still be traced in the newer counties. In some cotmties rock carvings can be found. The sites of Indian villages, planting grounds, battles and graves can be identified in many. The romance sur rounding the Indian is a very live culture bed in which to nourish interest in locating these sites accurately. There are probably in the State many unidentified mounds and deposits of Indian tools and weapons. Such interest might readily develop iiito concerted action, not to open the mounds — ^which should be left to the scientifically equipped archaeologist — ^but to identify and preserve them and have them accurately located by township and range on the atlas sheets of the United States Geological Survey. MARKING HISTORIC SITES AND CELEBRATING ANNIVERSARIES The appropriate marking of historic sites is another activity in which local interest may easily be aroused. There is no one thing that contributes more directly HINTS FOR PRACTICAL WORK 25 to historic consciousness in a community than the bestowal of honors upon the old landmarks. Besides Indian sites some counties afford sites of furtrading stations, of important military events during the French and British occupation, and of many events important to the locality and to the State since that time. Every village and city should appropriately mark the site of its first school, church and similar important public institutions. A simple white stone bearing an appropriate inscription is often adequate. For the same reason, every community should prize the opportunity to focus public attention and stir anew the popular interest in local history afforded by the recurrence of anniversaries of the significant events that have taken place at these sites. ALLIES OF THE HISTORICAL SOCIETY: THE SCHOOL; STORY-TELLING AND THEME-WRITING School children especially will be interested in the story of the Indian and in the collecting of Indian relics of the neighborhood. The romance of early Michigan in all of its phases will make a strong appeal if vividly presented. Fortunate is the child whose teacher is a skillful story-teller and loves to tell stories to children. For such work the innocence and fearsomeness of the aboriginal tribes, the heroic strug gles of the early missionaries, the exploits of the voy- ageur and the fur-trader, the glamour of the military post and the mystery of wild nature in the back ground form a maze of material. The life of the early 26 HINTS FOR PRACTICAL WORK American settlers is little less romantic. The volumes of the Michigan Pioneer and Historical Collections abound with this material from cover to cover, to be had almost for the asking. If the teacher is not specially skillful in telling the story, let her read to the class for example from pages 399-408 in volume 28 "Reminiscences of pioneer life in Oakland County" or the story of "The Dying Pirate" found in pp. 524-526, the same volume. It will be the very exceptional class that does not ask for more, and it will be the exceptional child that does not carry home to parents some accoimt of that story as well as interest in the volumes from which it was read or told. Teachers can thus be strong factors in developing that interest in the community life which leads to the organizing of the local historical society. In the upper grades teachers can use these materials for EngUsh exercises; to write up correctly an inter view with a pioneer would be a very practical exercise, and from a number of interviews there could be woven a tolerable historical sketch. Not only would this correlation of the English and History work develop skill in English and stimulate the spirit of historical inquiry but it would lay the basis of an intelligent patriotism which would be a source of strength for the historical society later. HINTS FOR PRACTICAL WORK 27 GROUP PRIDE IN THE STUDY OF FOREIGN ELEMENTS OF THE POPULATION A subject of much local interest in some com munities is the foreign bom population, in the study of which there may be utilized a certain group pride which is often no small impulse to historical interest. There are many important facts which school children may gather that can be formed into readable sketches of permanent worth; for instance, the date when immigration began, the causes of emigration from the old country, why Michigan was chosen, who the leaders were and something about their qualities, the character of the immigrants, experiences during the journey, experiences in the new homes, relations with the native Americans and contributions to the general welfare. CLUBS AND SOCIETIES AS CENTERS OF HISTORICAL INTEREST Usually in a community there is early formed some club or organization based upon personal or social relationships, like the Daughters of the American Revolution, the Ladies' Literary Club under whatever name known, the G. A. R., etc. These bodies can serve as centers of interest in local history, and where that interest has been organized they have proven to be its warmest promoters. THE PUBLIC LIBRARY AND THE LOCAL MUSEUM The public library is a very natural ally of the in cipient historical society. It has a large opportunity 28 HINTS FOR PRACTICAL WORK to stimulate popular interest in local, state and na tional history by calling attention to books of history. Every Michigan public library, at least all that are located at county seats, should have on reserved shelves in the reading room and easily accessible at least the important works bearing upon the history of Michigan and the Old Northwest. Besides furnishing historical books of reference, the Library could well set apart one room to receive and display such local collections as might be obtained either by gift or loan from local collectors. The local museum is coming to be recognized as a very legiti mate extension of local library work, a relation very thoughtfully expressed by Dr. G. Browne Goode in the American Historical Association Papers III, 266, where he says, "The museum cultivates the powers of ob servation, and the casual visitor even makes discover ies for himself, and, vinder the guidance of the labels, forms his own impressions. In the library one studies the impressions of others. The library is most useful to the educated; the museum to educated and un educated alike, to the masses as well as to the few, and is a powerful stimulant to intellectual activity in either class. The influence of a museum upon a com munity is not as deep as that of the library, but ex tends to a much larger number of people." In view of the popular interest in a museum and of its real value to the masses the local library might well devote a part of the library funds to gathering and maintaining such a collection, feeling assured that HINTS FOR PRACTICAL WORK 29 what the people are interested in they will consent to pay taxes to maintain. The interest of prominent families is readily enlisted by getting them to deposit loans in the museum, which in turn stimulates the interest of others. A good local collection is an important educational supplement to the schools when visited by the pupils in charge of their teachers and intelligently presented to them. Popular lectures based on the exhibits, delivered by suitable local talent, will prove always a means of stimulating interest. It is small argument against the local mu seum that it is miscellaneous and comparatively insignificant for the student of history beside books; the same argument necessarily applies to all local institutions. Indeed the local collection should be kept typically local in character, its purpose being to exemplify the fauna, flora, geology, archeology, furni ture, utensils, books, weapons, dress, ornaments, etc., of the community. Much of this material will be lost to the community unless the private collections are solicited and placed thus in safe keeping. There should be, undoubtedly, discrimination exercised as to the articles accepted for such a public display, and on the other hand rare objects needing fireproof housing, also objects of state-wide importance, should be sent to the state Museum in charge of the Historical Com mission. In cities the public library should be able to afford sufficient funds to make the museum artistically at- 30 HINTS FOR PRACTICAL WORK tractive. Proper space, light, cleanliness and restful colors are essential to the effectiveness of a museum. Objects should be properly classified and arranged according to their relationships, each with an appro priate setting. Modem cases of steel and glass, with glass shelving, should be used where possible. Printed or typewritten labels should be placed on each object, giving its name, donor and history. When the col lection has grown to some size visitors appreciate having a printed pamphlet containing brief accounts of the different objects, classified and referred to by number so that they can find at once objects in which they are most interested. A museum so equipped may serve for study, research and technical instruction as well as for culture and amusement. The spirit thus developed would work directly towards the support of a live historical society. METHODS OF PRESERVING CLIPPINGS AND MANUSCRIPTS To the smaller libraries and to individual collectors a word might be useful about the preservation of printed and manuscript materials. For newspaper clippings and fugitive sheets some variety of the scrap- book method is common, but the scrapbook is not the best to start with. Envelopes should be used, pre ferably manila, size 3 by 5 inches; the clipping if large should be folded carefully, placed in the envelope without sealing, and the envelope should then be proper ly labeled in the upper left comer with the name and date of the paper from which the clipping was made. HINTS FOR PRACTICAL WORK 31 A brief note should be made on the body of the en velope indicating the nature of its contents. No envelope should contain more than one item. At first the envelopes should be^filed chronologically, with a division card for each week. When a sufficient number accumulate, say for a few months, it will be possible to analyze the entries for general topics. It is best not to make too many topics. Some of these can be ascertained beforehand, for example "advertise ments;" nothing more vividly reflects the evolution of a given industry or business of a locality than a chron ological Hst of advertisements for a series of years. When the topics have been ascertained the envelopes may then be filed topically, with the place of each topic indicated by an appropriate index card. The process is simple when the appropriate topics are chosen. At the end of a given time, say a year, the contents from each group may be taken out of the envelopes, properly subclassified and entered in a scrapbook; and for this purpose it is far the best to use the prepared scrapbooks, which avoids the many disadvantages of library paste. These can be bought at any well equipped book store, and consist of gummed lines per pendicular on the page to which when slightly moist ened with a small brush the clippings will readily and permanently adhere. The book when full can be properly labeled, indexed, and placed with other books on the library shelf. School children in the upper grades are found to take a very lively interest in this form of 32 HINTS FOR PRACTICAL WORK gathering materials of current interest for local, state and national history. In libraries it is desirable to have two copies of each newspaper, one for filing and one for clipping. Letters and other manuscripts which must be read on both sides may be mounted on sheets of transparent surgeon's plaster, or on architect's tracing paper. The sheets can be cut to a convenient size, preferably octavo, and when enough have accumulated they can be paged, indexed, bound, and shelved like the scrap- books. A common method of mounting manuscript is to attach the margin to suitable leaves already bound in a volume. Obviously this is not as flexible a system as the former, but may answer very well where the material is already completely gathered and classified. SUGGESTIONS TO LOCAL HISTORICAL WRITERS Often an interest in local history may be nourished and made effective by attempting to write upon some phase of the life of the community. Only the barest suggestions of course could be offered here; one of the very first would be the very subject of research which the preceding pages have sketched. In the second place the writer should seek to get some idea of the nature of historical evidence, such as might be gained from a book like Channing and Hart's "Guide to the Study and Reading of American History," of which a new edition has just been published,' or Small and 3. Ginn and Co., Boston, $2.00. HINTS FOR PRACTICAL WORK 33 Vincent's "Introduction to the Study of Society."* An extensive treatise on the subject is Langlois and Seignobos' "Introduction to the Study of History," translated from the French.^ One of the chief canons of historical writing is accur acy — accuracy in ascertaining the fact, in stating the fact or conclusion, in copying, and in every phase of the process. A statement "in print" is of course as likely to be false as a statement made orally. Distinction must be sharply drawn between original material and secondary material. For every statement upon which a conclusion is based a reference should be cited in a footnote, either at the foot of the page or at the end of the article or chapter; the citations in footnotes enable the reader not only to check his writer but to supplement the information on any given point, or to draw his own conclusion from the facts given in the original. Bias must be carefully guarded against, as the truth is the only justification of any writing. A writer is of course specially prone to bias who bases his accounts upon the books of others without ques tioning their authority. The relation of local history to the larger history of the state and nation must not be left out of view. Local history is of consequence largely because of its place in the larger field. All available maps bearing on the subject should be care fully studied. The value of an article or book is much 4." American Book Co., New York, $1.80. 5. Henry Holt and Co., New York, $2.25. 34 HINTS FOR PRACTICAL WORK enhanced when appropriately illustrated with maps, drawings, photographs, etc. It would not be of much value to suggest specific topics to treat in writing local Michigan history, since these would vary necessarily with the period, the locality and the scope of the field. It might be useful however to suggest the type of topics that it would be most profitable to treat in general. The following are offered: SUGGESTIONS FOR THE TREATMENT OF A LARGE SETTLEMENT AREA: Why the area is, or is not, a unit of settlement Stages of settlement — reasons Sources of settlers— reasons Causes of migration from the old homes Reasons of settlers for choosing this area instead of neighboring areas Routes of immigration Obstructions or facilities afforded by governmental action Description of new environment — comparison with the old Founding of first settlements Obstacles met — ^how overcome Chief checks and stimuli to further immigration Rate of increase of population at different times — reasons Chief characteristics of the immigrants Chief characteristics developed in the new community HINTS FOR PRACTICAL WORK 35 Economic development — lumbering, mining, agricul ture, grazing, dairying, fruit culture, manufacture, transportation, trade, commerce, banking, etc. Political history Military history Social progress EducationReligion Comparison with neighboring areas SUGGESTIONS FOR A SKETCH OF COUNTY HISTORY: Causes of rate of growth in population Environment Advantages Nearness to large centers of population Attraction to immigrants Markets and supply depots Accessibility Rivers navigable for large boats Streams navigable for small craft Openings and unforested areas Indian trails Resources Climate SurfaceDrainage Water power Soil Products 36 HINTS FOR PRACTICAL WORK Disadvantages Comparison with neighboring environments Disposition of the land Indian treaties Government surveys Establishment of land districts and offices Legislation affecting land sales Administration of land sales Speculation and high prices Titles and litigation Financial crises affecting the currency Improvements of harbors, rivers, roads, canals, and railroads Economic, political, social, and religious traits of settlers Interactions of city and farm with industry and trade Factors operating in foreign countries to cause emigration Manufacturing and banking institutions Amount of growth at different dates Degree of organization When surveyed and opened to settlement When organized, as compared with neighbors From what territory organized Number of townships having given number of settlers at given date Number, size, location, and importance of settlements When first settlement made Most important settlements at a given date HINTS FOR PRACTICAL WORK 37 Most important settlements in a given part of county New settlements of note made during a given time Location relative to water or forest Exceptions to usual location Pioneer tendencies displayed by locations ' ' Paper cities ' ' Population Population of county at given dates Center of population at given dates Exceptional variations of population — reasons Most populous areas — reasons Amount of increase in a given period Comparison of increases of population for different periods Industries Kinds of industries Location of heavily timbered areas Location of best farming districts Date when all timbered land taken up Proportional number of acres cultivated — location Number of bushels of different grains raised in given years Property valuations, real and personal Process of growth of population Sources of population Source of first settlers Effect of certain lines of transportation Effect of absence of certain facilities of trans portation 38 HINTS FOR PRACTICAL WORK Absence of a population element that might be expected In what ways sources are typical Location Preferences shown for different environments — reasons Location of settlers from different native sources * Chief locations of foreign bom population Proportions Predominant foreign population When foreign population became important Relative proportions of population from different states Relative proportions from other parts of same state Relationship of elements Conflicts among elements Forces tending to amalgamate elements Relative tendencies to concentration Extensions of the frontier The fiUing-in process Methods of founding settlements Individual initiative Informal partnerships Stock companies Social and religious colonies Economic types The hunter The woodland farmer The prairie farmer HINTS FOR PRACTICAL WORK 39 The lumberman The miner Urban population Proportions of these elements Summary In what ways typical of the larger area Irregularities of growth Absence of usual and important characteristics Comparison with immediately environing areas Parts in which growth was exceptionally rapid — reasons Parts in which growth was exceptionally backward —reasons Periods in which growth was most rapid — reasons Periods in which decline set in — reasons Periods of steady or irregular growth Comparative importance of county at different dates Relation of rate of growth to that of larger area Distinctive contributions to the general welfare. TYPES OF OUTLINES FOR SKETCH OF SETTLEMENT IN TOWNSHIPS A Key to early settlement of the township — recruits from transients going to other places — ^illustrated by a leading family of the township. First spot to attract settlers — description of the environment — motives of the settlers — sources of the settlers — dates of first post office, store, frame house. 40 HINTS FOR PRACTICAL WORK village plat — significance of the name — source of later settlers. An early abortive settlement in the township — causes of failure. First mills, if significant — importance of the first grist mill and saw mill in early settlement. Population of the township in the first authen,tic census — limits of the township at that date — portion of the township most densely settled ; reasons. Highways of the township influencing early settle ment — Indian trails and streams located with reference to immigration. Original topography of the township; timber land, oak openings, small prairies, marsh — corhpared with neighboring townships in attractiveness to settlers — illustrated from early censuses. Location of largest settlement — ^its essential local influences — source of the settlers — routes of immigra tion — other centers of settlement — citizenship of the township as represented by the first township officers. Early censuses. c Population at the first authentic census — distribu tion of this population — influence of topography and highways — sources of population. First settlement — importance for later settlement — importance of the tavern and of pioneer hospitality in HINTS FOR PRACTICAL WORK 41 early settlement — illustrations — influence of the lo cation of a stage station in the township — compared with the later influence of the first railroad station — illustration of the influence of a railroad in disintegrat ing an embryo village. Comparison between the order in which land was entered at the land office and the order followed by actual settlement — location of ' ' boom towns ' ' — amount of speculation compared with that in neighboring town ships. D Influence of the presence of Indians in checking im migration to an otherwise attractive spot — ^how the Indians came to be there — date at which the reserva tion was ceded to the government — effect of cession on growth of population — illustrated from censuses. Main points of settlement — general direction in which the frontier was extended. Topography of the site of a future city given in some detail. "Squatters" and their difficulties. Struggle of contending localities for the coimty seat — significance of the possession of the county in stitutions to growth of settlement. Important mills — effect of lumber supplies on settle ment. Source, amount and distribution of population at given censuses. 42 HINTS FOR PRACTICAL WORK Influence of Indian trail and oak openings on settle ment of township — ^location and source of first settlers — routes of immigration. Effect of establishment of state road on settlement. Censuses — distribution of population — centers of densest settlement as indicated by location of first schoolhouses. F Influence of a line of communication shown by the location of land entries for the first years — circum stances modifying the inference from these entries. Source of these first land purchasers — ^what pro portion became actual settlers. Original occupations of settlers — how modified by the new environment. Characteristics of a purely agricultural township — natural growth and even distribution of population- — slow formation of civic centers — influence of strong personalities — distribution of institutions — influences aside from environmental tending to produce and per petuate such a community. Censuses — source and distribution of population — limits of township at given dates — comparative dates of organization of neighboring townships. Routes of immigration to the township — typical set tlers. HINTS FOR PRACTICAL WORK 43 Influence of scenery on settlement in lake region — tendency of New Englanders to select spots reminding them of home — tendency of settlers from the same source to settle together — first settlers, date and source of population. Censuses — distribution and source of population at different times. Geological formations affecting settlement in the township — surface, soil, springs, minerals, drainage, timber, waterpower. Position with reference to lines of communication — illustration of excellent natural advantages offsetting poor communication. When organized — extent then — population — loca tion of chief centers — source of population. First settlement — influences and source of settlers. First public improvements in the township — effect on settlement. First public institutions in the township — officers as types of pioneers. H Type of densely timbered and somewhat swampy township — late settlement — first settlement centered in one place, on open land — later settlements scattered. Effect of scientific drainage on growth of township. Saw, stave, heading and cooperage mills, in early developement. Source of first settlers — influence of nearness to an earlier settled county. 44 HINTS FOR PRACTICAL WORK Type of densely forested township free from swamps and with unusual water power, but not easily ac cessible — mill sites early developed as nuclei of vil lages, especially at junctions of streams. First roads influenced by Indian trails — effect of connection with large centers outside the county. River transportation. First settlement — important settlers — other centers. Censuses — distribution and source of population at different times. J Type of township located near large settlement in neighboring county with similar environment. Influence of good communication in different parts of township. Early taverns as nuclei of villlages. Minor settlement areas. Censuses — distribution and source of population. Growth compared with that of neighboring town ships. It is most true that the value of an article or book is often vitiated by faulty organization, and experience suggests that there are many persons who would like to know some method of properly arranging their material. A knowledge of certain mechanical aids HINTS FOR PRACTICAL WORK 45 may put one in the way of using one's mental equip ment to the best advantage. Individual writers have in this matter worked out their own methods, adapt ing to their needs whatever they have found of value in the practice of other writers. The Secretary of the Commission would be glad to give what help he can to any one who feels the need of personal assistance in this part of their work. ^ , .« 4.1. .fr*'^ , V. ' .-,4 - - > »<' ,> J>i . I* J ... -¦•"' I* .- . ' . •>¦« 5 I' 1 r 1 .-¦ .' ¦'-. -"^ i*, '-«.. 'U .'¦>•' - '^ ,- i' 'V .1 Vi