Research Division Report #7 Minorities and Women in e b £* ,b *~»«« the Arts: 1970 55** January 1978 A Study by Data Use and Access Laboratories, October 1977 Research Division Report #7 Minorities and Women in IHriS ,tewm * the Arts: 1970 January 1978 A Study by Data Use and Access Laboratories. October 1977 Minorities and Women in the Arts: 1970 Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2012 with funding from Boston Library Consortium Member Libraries http://archive.org/details/minoritieswomeniOOdata PREFACE This report is the second in a series that analyzes in considerable detail the data from the last national census. Some of the data being used has not been published before, except in the form of computer data tapes known as the Public Use Sample. In this report the participation of women and minorities in artist occupations in 1970 is com- pared with their overall participation in the labor force. Likewise, their earnings in each artist occupation in 1969 are compared with earnings for their counterparts in the same artist occupation. Also, patterns of residence and migration are discussed. Because the number of persons employed in artist occupations is small relative to total U.S. employment, only extremely large or specialized surveys can provide information on employed artists nationwide. The decennial census provides sufficiently accurate and detailed occupational information and has been used in this study. Furthermore, census data is part of an ongoing process so that valid statistical comparisons can be made of changes over time. The 1970 Census information used in this study can be compared with data from the 1980 Census when they become available and will show changes that occur in this decade. The tabulation and analysis of the 1970 Census data for this study was performed for the Research Division by Data Use and Access Laboratories. This report was written by Diane Ellis under the general direction of Jack Beresford. Much of the data appearing in this publication was taken from three sets of tabular material prepared earlier by Data Use and Access Laboratories — "Rank of Artists in Specific Artistic Occupations," "Interstate and Interregional Migra- tion of Artists Based on the Printed Results of the 1970 Census," and "Tabulations of Artists and Persons in Compara- tive Occupations in the United States: 1970." Copies of these materials can be examined at the Library of the Arts Endowment or borrowed through inter-library loan. To do so, contact Mrs. Chris Morrison, Librarian, National Endow- ment for the Arts, Washington, D.C. 20506; phone: (202) 634-7640. Research Division National Endowment for the Arts November 1977 TABLE OF CONTENTS Page INTRODUCTION 1 MINORITIES IN THE ARTS 3 Population Size 3 Earnings 8 Residence and Migration 10 WOMEN IN THE ARTS 12 Population Size 12 Earnings 13 Residence and Migration 15 APPENDIX 17 11 TABLES AND FIGURES Table 1. Table 2. Table 3. Table 4. Minority Composition of Artist Occupations, U.S., 1970 Percentage Distribution of Minority Artists by Occupation, U.S., 1970 Percentage Comparison of Earnings of Minority and Non-Minority Artists in Each Artist Occupation, U.S., 1969 Percentage Comparison of Earnings of Established Men and Women Artists in Each Artist Occupation, U.S., 1969 Page 5 6 15 Figure 1 Figure 2 Figure 3 Proportions of Minorities in Artist Labor Force Compared with Proportions in Total Labor Force, U.S., 1970 4 Median Incomes Among Established Artists by Race/Ethnicity , U.S., 1969 8 Male - Female Composition of the Artist Occupations, U.S., 1970 12 in APPENDIX TABLES Page Table A. Persons 16 Years Old and Over in Artist Labor Force and Labor Reserve, By Oc- cupation and Race/Ethnicity, U.S., 1970 18 Table B. Median Incomes by Occupation and Race/Eth- nicity for Artists Age 30 and Over Who Worked 40 Weeks or More in 1969 and Were in the Same Occupation in 1965 and 1970, U.S., 1970 , 19 Table C. State Residence of Employed Black Artists, U.S., 1970 20 Table D. State Residence of Employed Spanish-American Artists, U.S., 1970 % 21 Table E. Persons 16 Years Old and Over in Artist Force and Labor Reserve, by Occupation and Sex, U.S., 1970 22 Table F. Median Incomes by Occupation and Sex for Artists Age 30 and Over Who Worked 40 Weeks or More in 1969 and Were in the Same Occupa- tion in 1965 and 1970, U.S., 1970 23 Table G. State Residence of Employed Women Artists, U.S., 1970 24 IV INTRODUCTION The 1970 U.S. Census provides data on artists who are women and artists who have minority racial or ethnic backgrounds. This data shows: there were lower propor- tions of minorities and women in artist occupations than in the total labor force in 1970; income levels for estab- lished minority artists were below the levels for estab- lished non-minority artists; and income for established women artists was less than half the income of established men artists. The following discussion of population size is based on artists who were 16 years of age and over in the experienced labor force or labor reserve in 1970. Thus, artists working in 1970, as well as those who last worked in an artist oc- cupation are included. However, in the discussion of the place of residence of artists only artists working in 1970 make up the data base. The term "minority" in this report is used to describe persons from four major ethnic or racial groups: black, Spanish-American^, American Indian, and Asian* American. The race of all persons reported in the census is determined by self-identif ication. Data on population size and earnings are from the 1970 Census Public Use Sample. Tables for this analysis were prepared by DUALabs from extracts of these samples. Descriptions of sample sizes, weighting, and sampling error are found in the DUALabs report. ^ Data on residence are from printed * For description and use of this data file, see U.S. Bureau of the Census, Public Use Samples of the 1970 Census: Description and Technical Documentation (Washington, D.C.: GPO, 1972). Included in the category, Spanish-American, are persons with Spanish surnames, of Spanish countries of origin, and with Spanish mother tongues. 3 Data Use and Access Laboratories, "Tabulations of Artists and Persons in Comparative Occupations in the United States: 1970" (prepared for the National Endowment for the Arts, January 1977), Tables 1-12. _i_ results of the 1970 Census recompiled by DUALabs to provide breakdowns on the locations of minority artists in specific occupations. ^ Data on migration are also from printed results of the 1970 Census. 5 4 See U.S. Bureau of the Census, Census of Population 1970, Detailed Characteristics , Series PC(1)-D, Final Re- ports 1 through 52; and Data Use and Access Laboratories, "Rank of States and Standard Metropolitan Statistical Areas by Number of Artists in Specific Artistic Occupations" (prepared for the National Endowment for the Arts, January 1977). 5 See U.S. Bureau of the Census, Census of Population 1970, Detailed Characteristics , Final Report PC(1)-D1, U.S. Summary, Table 293, "Detailed Occupations of the Experienced Civilian Labor Force, by Sex, for Regions"; U.S. Bureau of the Census, Census of Population 1970, Subject Reports , Final Report PC (2) -7A, Occupational Characteristics, Table 34, "Residence in 1965 for the Experienced Civilian Labor Force by Occupation, Race, Spanish Origin, and Sex, 1970" and Tables 35 to 37 "Region of Residence in 1965 for Persons in the Experienced Civilian Labor Force, who moved between Regions, by Oc- cupation and Sex: 1970"; and Data Use and Access Labora- tories, "Interstate and Inter-regional Migration of Artists Based on the Printed Results of the 1970 Census" (prepared for the National Endowment for the Arts, August 1976). •2- MINORITIES IN THE ARTS POPULATION SIZE In 1970 there were about 68,000 persons of minority racial and ethnic backgrounds who had occupations as actors, archi- tects, authors, dancers, designers, musicians, composers, painters, sculptors, photographers, radio and television announcers, university teachers of art, music, or drama, and other types of artists and entertainers. Appendix Table A breaks this figure down by occupation and ethnic background. Minority artists made up about 9% of all artists in the 1970 labor force. This figure is low when compared with the proportion of minorities in the total labor force, which was about 15% in 1970. It is similar to minority participation levels among all professional, technical, and kindred workers in the 1970 labor force. Of the four minority groups studied, black artists were the only minorities who were found in a considerably lower pro- portion than their proportion in the total labor force. Artists of Spanish heritage, as well as American Indian and Asian-American artists, were represented in nearly identical proportions as their proportions in the total labor force. These relationships are illustrated in Figure 1. In specific artist occupations, some fields had a sizeable proportion of minorities in 1970, while other fields had very few such persons. Dance had the highest participation levels — nearly 20% of the U.S. dancers in the labor force were minorities. The writing field had the lowest proportion of minorities. Only 4% of all authors in the labor force were minorities. (Examination of related writing occupations also showed low levels of minority participation: 5% for editors/reporters and 6% for public relations and publicity writers . ) The percentage of minorities in the labor force of each artist occupation is shown in Table 1. -3- Figure 1 Proportions of Minorities in Artist Labor Force, Compared with Proportions in Total Labor Force, U.S., . 1970 3.8% Spanish 3.6% Black * T T 1.8% Other* 3.7% Spanish 1.6% Other* ARTIST** LABOR FORCE TOTAL LABOR FORCE * Includes American Indians, Asian-Americans, Eskimos, Aleuts, and others identified as non-black, non-white, and non-Spanish. **Actors, architects, authors, dancers, designers, musicians, composers, painters, sculptors, photographers, radio and television announcers, and university teachers of art, music, or drama. -4- Table 1 Minority Composition of Artist Occupations, U.S., 1970 Occupation Dancers Actors Musicians/Composers Photographers Designers Architects Painters/Sculptors Radio/TV Announcers University Teachers of Art, Music, Drama Authors Other Artists/Entertainers (not elsewhere classified) All Artist Occupations All Spanish- Minorities Black American Other* 19.5% 7.8% 6.8% 4.9% 12.2 4.8 5.4 2.0 11.7 7.0 3.7 1.0 8.8 3.3^ 3.7 1.8 8.5 2.2 4.1 2.2 8.1 2.1 3.0 3.0 7.5 2.3-" 3.3 1.9 6.5 2.7 3.0 .8 5.0 2.9 1.0 1.1 4.4 2.1 1.7 .6 13*5 4.4 6.1 3.0 9.2% 3.6% 3.8% 1.8% ♦Includes American Indians, Asian-Americans, Eskimos, Aleuts, and others identified as non-white, non-black, and non-Spanish. Dance had high levels of participation by all minority groups. The architect and author occupations had the lowest proportions of blacks, while the occupation of university teacher of art, music, or drama had the lowest proportion of Spanish-Americans. Census data shows no American Indians with occupations as university art, music, or drama teachers. Table 2 summarizes occupations of all minority artists in 1970. The largest single group of minority artists was that of black musicians and/or composers. Also, one-third of all black artists were in the musician occupation, while blacks were found with least frequency as authors and radio/TV announcers. In contrast, Spanish-American artists were most numerous in the designer occupation, which was the largest artist occupation in terms of the total number of minority artists. -5- o c to 1 o C-H -l •H 0) CO e < < CM m fH CM CM 00 00 CO in O o CM 1 •p (0 •H -P u < •p •H U o c •H s o c o •H -P .Q •H Vj. ■P (0 ■H D 0) tr> OP in dP CM CM CO dP in CM r^ *» o 00 O iH CM CM O f-cMro^r-mi-ico in CO en CO CO CO dP o © 0f> © o CO U 0) c •H id (M •p o id n B o> q w to u x: ■P e o n *« & cu 3 id o E iH CO 0) CO s fc c E-» * +J u o a) s u CO CO \ W £ >i-H •H -p m CO \ a •P CO •p o u c CO id M M CO S < CO -p h M c •H a> tr \ H u -H 4J a) - fc •J us .G O •H -H c 4J •H > -p o < •p o 4J e to CO •H •o •H M JC H o M 3 id in ^r in o 00 in (1) rH O rH ro ** ON vo 00 VO in rH ON si rH CN •H CN rH CO ^* u KH 4J « o iH CTJ * •H (1) c to rd U rd c a Q) 1 u o a) CO C -H «0* ro CN on CN CN 00 rH o vo ON VO CO >-l •H CO * E H •> 4-> a) 0) • < rH U rH u w <45 u • rd D 1 c U-l E-l b X RJ \ * CO U s • U >i ■H -H VO r^ ^ 00 on ON r» 00 *T ^r ON in to »-* 4J c u VO vo ro on © CN a\ CN ro ro in in c o r- & -H (d •PrH rH C CN rd < 4J x: 10 4-> rH >i 3 •• U (D •H W Si to (d rH 4J \ rd in CN in ON ON El 4J C <0 < u u ro oo in rH 00 in rH 00 in CN o o s cd id c tf rH ^ to ta h h « »i * -w •H CQ rH rH CN 00 CN CN ro VO CO - T3 CM Q) TJ CO i-i c •h a) 4J (1) rd J4 -P M > ro on ro VO VO r» VO o in in ■H rH O-H rtj o c vo rH 00 O on CO in ro o r> ^ rH 4J C CU in CN o TT in on ro CN o r> ^« VO rd D u si C -P •H o r- o on on on o> rH ro CM ON CM i U TJ U C CD (0 CQ a) CD U E QJ CO c •H <-H % Jh a; CO U VM rd •H rd vw •H 4J Tj rd *0 V£> CO O E -P CO c a c rH a CO U CO rd U Q) CO rd rd 3 W (0 E tH Q> 0) c +» »H CJ) OrH c 3 O 43 C to O rd u o C u U w o S CO (A 3 rd \ a) o u ■a CO 0) to u rd >-H CD e •0 u c H » +> rj) 4J-H 4J 04 rd G a) £ o to x rd -P id C CO rd x >1-H •H ? O rd Z o +> 0) to a 4-> CO 4-> d) •H u u c CO rd £ •H 3 M to ■P 0) 0) CO a> rd M Vl W £ < r^ •• «d CO +> u u c •H Q) tr \ H 0) 0) a U -H o a) On 4J CD h u g 3 £ si u •H •H c 4J •H > +> 0) 4J u o 4J U +> c CO (0 •H o TJ •H M Si H 3 O u 3 rd 0) 3 rd s: rd C < V c O o < < < Q O 2 fr. CU OS D o *■' H CO -18- a o> iH Id Eh o c r> TJ o> 0) CQ e •0 CD fH 0) -H . H CO Id c 1 C 01 fH flJ-H « •P o © o o o o o o o o id > • iH •H CM tH in CM o CO 00 CM 00 tH a o Cuoo CD o w iH P in VO h 43 • < -P O O 9 D c •H o\ CM fH o iH o iH VO o iH r^ tH iH a\ o> u id U Eh * P * £ vy »H 3 C in r> > r- M-l u O iH O o\ c OiO 01 Eh r-i i 'O 1 u O O o O o o •H 4J oi u C T3 c •H r> ^r CM tH o> vo C 01 id -h oi iH tH iH iH < Eh ^ VO <0> id •0 iH C fH * C7>fH c U »H id id oi < id C O o < 4J 4J C u id § 00 VM S 03 C P 01 -H •H •H a\ +» CD < •P P T3 * * « * « « ^ « * « « CQ TJ oi E 03 C 0) C ^« r*- CD C •H CD CD •H £ H iH 01 id +» fH 43 -P-H < v> id p a-p P -P Os < a < Id 01 a u a l c £ CD CD *H Mh W P 3 43 id o o O o O o o o o 4h u to u !**• CM r^ in o\ iH vCM o in VH -P s VH •H •H iH in iH 00 a\ o\ in o o •H 01 *>4J o C P * fH C O c >1 id 0) CM o O vo o> I s - vo o o\ r^ CD 4J 0) a E tH iH tH iH 4J C •H ON B •H E w 5 o 00 o r» r^ CM CM CO •H < id CD fa 4-> * o <7> in * VO CM vo iH in o CM >s Eh +>fH v> o s id id Q) C id o> iH o a\ in ON 00 CO a\ 00 M U 4J C -H iH iH cH iH a o * CO o id PQ VM 01 -H « o a\ in CM o vo ^ o •H O id D43 c c •P Jh c P -P o co- Vl- •H C id 4-> (d ie S i CD •H -H < -H CD -* 43 p VH 01 fH -P P i> p (rt c « •d id &r" 01 2 g c a^oN (1) 01 01 01 id •H jj TJ id 3 ih e m u 01 u M M 4-> CQ 9 O CM 0) u 0) eu D id CD fH CD U CM U 01 u 43 a : U 01 O O CD C 01 •p c u M 9 C D Eh43 H 4* 0* a 3 id U O -H CD 1 E d) B tH 03 o 0) O id > O CD C vH +> § id O id Eh Z TJ O •P 01 01 \ 04 4J 01 01 0) ^ •H U p c 01 id z •H 3 •H 43 -P s •P cd 01 01 cd id u M 01 £ 4-i -p id •• •0 (d co •P P P c •H 0) tP ^v M U •a CD 0) a p ♦H (1) tn u 4J O CD tfc < CQ .* 3 £ X O •H •H c +> •H > *J CQ 01 P P O •P O -P c 01 01 •H •0 •H u fH CD *H 3 u O P 3 id 0) 3 id Xi id C < iH h3 43 5 o < < < Q a S (U cu « D < * Eh CO -19- Table C State Residence of Employed Black Artists, U.S., 1970 State Number Percent New York 3 r 909 21.0 California 2,417 13.0 Illinois 1,358 7.3 District of Columbia 968 5.2 Pennsylvania 951 5.1 Texas 895 4.8 Michigan 830 4.5 Ohio 690 3.7 Maryland 678 3.6 New Jersey 663 3.6 Louisiana 552 3.0 Florida 473 2.5 Virginia 427 2.3 Georgia 427 2.3 Massachusetts 354 1.9 Missouri 335 1.8 Alabama 324 1.7 North Carolina 315 1.7 Tennessee 298 1.6 Indiana 208 1.1 South Carolina 203 1.1 Connecticut 162 .9 Washington 136 .7 Mississippi 125 .7 Colorado 113 .6 Oklahoma 109 .6 Kentucky 103 .6 Minnesota 72 .4 Kansas 64 .3 Wisconsin 61 .3 Oregon 58 .3 Delaware 45 .2 Arkansas 40 .2 Arizona 34 .2 Nebraska 29 .2 Iowa 28 .2 New Mexico 28 .2 Vermont 22 .1 Nevada 22 .1 West Virginia 22 .1 Hawaii 22 .1 Rhode Island 14 .1 Alaska 6 .03 South Dakota 5 .03 Wyoming 5 .03 Utah 5 .03 New Hampshire 4 .02 Maine .00 Idaho .00 Montana .00 North Dakota .00 Source: Data Use and Access Laboratories, "Rank of States and Standard Metropolitan Statistical Areas by Number of Artists in Specific Artistic Occupations," Table la (prepared for the National Endowment for the Arts, 1977). -20- Table D State Residence of Employed Spanish- •American Artists, U.! 3., 1970 State Number Percent California 7,419 40.1 Texas 2,617 14.1 Florida 1,611 8.7 New York 1,412 7.6 Illinois 535 2.9 New Mexico 523 2.8 Arizona 406 2.2 Colorado 406 2.2 Virginia 299 1.6 Michigan 295 1.6 Maryland 293 1.6 Louisiana 215 1.2 Ohio 204 1.1 Nevada 184 1.0 Massachusetts 183 1.0 Missouri 177 1.0 New Jersey 173 .9 Connecticut 172 .9 District of Columbi a 159 .9 Georgia 148 .8 Washington 129 .7 Oklahoma 100 .5 Kansas 97 .5 Minnesota 72 .4 Tennessee 72 .4 Hawaii 61 .3 Indiana 56 .3 Wisconsin 56 .3 Oregon 51 .3 Pennsylvania 50 .3 Utah 48 .3 Alabama 47 .3 Nebraska 47 .3 North Carolina 46 .2 Rhode Island 32 .2 Kentucky 26 .1 Maine 23 .1 South Carolina 18 .1 Mississippi 11 .1 Alaska 10 .1 Montana 9 .05 Arkansas 7 .04 Idaho 7 .04 South Dakota 6 .03 Delaware 5 .03 Iowa .00 New Hampshire .00 North Dakota .00 Vermont .00 West Virginia .00 Wyoming .00 Source: Data Use and Access Laboratories, "Rank of States and Standard Metropolitan Statistical Areas by Number of Artists in Specific Artistic Occupations," Table la (prepared for the National Endowment for the Arts, 1977). Table E Persons 16 Years Old and Over in Artist Labor Force and Labor Reserve, by Occupation and Sex, U.S., 1970 Occupation Male Female Total Actors Architects Authors Dancers Designers Musicians/Composers Painters/Sculptors Photographers Radio/TV Announcers University Teachers of Art, Music, or Drama 20,800 13,620 34,420 Other Artists & Entertainers (not elsewhere classified) 54,160 26,073 80,233 TOTAL 493,976 236,228 730,204 Source: Data Use and Access Laboratories, "Tabulations of Artists and Persons in Comparative Occupations in the United States: 1970," Table 1 (prepared for the National Endowment for the Arts, January, 1977). 11,316 12,114 23,430 59,420 2,797 62,217 20,003 11,447 31,450 1,577 10,112 11,689 91,583 39,056 130,639 76,364 48,087 124,451 72,623 56,392 129,015 63,634 14,452 78,086 22,496 2,078 24,574 -22- Table F Median Incomes by Occupation and Sex for Artists Age 30 and Over Who Worked 40 Weeks or More in 1969 and Were in the Same Occupation in 1965 and 1970, U.S., 1970 Occupation Male Female Actors $12,780 $8,000 Architects 15,140 10,250 Authors 11,870 7,410 Dancers Designers Musicians/Composers Painters/Sculptors Photographers Radio/TV Announcers University Teachers of Art, Music, or Drama All Artist Occupations Source: Data Use and Access Laboratories, "Tabulations of Artists and Persons in Comparative Occupations in the United States: 1970," Supplemental Tables T001-T004 (prepared for the National Endowment for the Arts, January 1977, revised November 1977) . 11,500 7,000 12,480 8,420 9,110 1,960 11,130 5,670 10,180 5,150 10,990 3,510 13,420 7,900 $11,980 $5,510 -?3- Table G State Residence of Employed Women Artists, U.S., 1970 State Number Percent New York 23,205 16.9% California 19,467 14.2 Illinois 7,180 5.2 Pennsylvania 6,657 4.9 Texas 6,526 4.8 Ohio 6,123 4.5 New Jersey 4,831 3.5 Michigan 4,631 3.4 Florida 4,330 3.2 Massachusetts 4,061 3.0 Maryland 3,018 2.2 Virginia 2,753 2.0 Missouri 2,705 2.0 Connecticut 2,622 1.9 Wisconsin 2,592 1.9 Washington 2,578 1.9 Minnesota 2,484 1.8 North Carolina 2,343 1.7 Georgia 2,206 1.6 Indiana 2,199 1.6 Colorado 1,746 1.3 Tennessee 1,619 1.2 Kansas 1,488 1.1 Alabama 1,377 1.0 Oklahoma 1,352 1.0 Oregon 1,342 1.0 District of Columbia 1,302 1.0 Louisiana 1,289 .9 Arizona 1,230 .9 Kentucky 1,211 .9 Iowa 1,199 .9 South Carolina 1,046 .8 Hawaii 1,004 .7 Nebraska 837 .6 Nevada 648 .5 Utah 609 • ^ Arkansas 557 • " Rhode Island 554 • " West Virginia 543 • " Mississippi 500 • " New Mexico 493 • " Maine 444 .3 New Hampshire 321 .2 Montana 321 .2 Idaho 288 .2 Delaware 278 .2 South Dakota 248 .2 Vermont 207 .2 Alaska 155 .1 North Dakota 139 .1 Wyoming 104 .1 TOTAL 136,962 100.0% Source: Data Use and Access Laboratories, "Rank of States and Standard Metropolitan Statistical Areas by Number of Artists in Specific Artistic Occupations," Table la (prepared for the National Endowment for the Arts, January 1977). N Product and distributed by Publishing Center for Cultural Resources. 152 ^ . ._ _. Second printing. August 1979 West 42 Street. New York City 10036. Price (incl. postage): $2.50 Second printing. August 1979 Produced and distributed by Publishing Center for Cultural Resources. 152 West 42 Street. New York City 10036. Price (incl. postage): $2.50