far/y QuoTcL~Tion Of- Ve rg j j . EARLY QUOTATION OF VERGIL BY DORA AILEEN LOUGEE A. B. Bates College, 1917 THESIS Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of MASTER OF ARTS IN CLASSICS IN THE GRADUATE SCHOOL OF THE UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS 1921 Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2016 https://archive.org/details/earlyquotationofOOIoug -*V TABLE OE CONTENTS I Jibl iography - i, II Introduction 5. Ill List of Quotations 12. IV ose of Quotations among poets and prose writers - - 63 . V List of variant readings found in the quotations - - 74 . VI Significance of variant readings 81 . VII List of quotations from the M i n 0 r Poems — — 85 VIII Discussion of the quotations from the Minor Poems- - 86 IX Table giving number of quotations --------- 87 X Conclusion: Popularity of Vergil’s work ------ 89 This thesis was prepared under the direc- tion of Dr. A* S. Pease, Professor of Classics, whose ever ready interest and helpful criticisms have been a constant source of inspiration and encouragement. BIBLIOGRAPHY 1 . Caesius Bassus . Kell, G ram m at ic i L a t i n i , 6, 305 ff., Leipzig, 1864. Calpurnius, Baehrens , Po.et.ae Lat ini Mino res . 3,65 ff ., Leipzig , 1879. Schenkl . Calp urnii et Nemesiani Bucolica, Leipzig , 1885. Columella, Schneider, Scriptorum Re i Rusticae. Tomus Secundus, Leipzig, 1794. Germanicus, Baehrens, Poet ae La t ini Minores, 1,200 f f . , Le ip z ig , 1978. ( Mueller, Ho rati Fla cc i , C ar mi n a, Leipzig, 1874. Horace( Hirschf elder , Hor a t i us PI acc us . Berlin, 1882. ( Keller et Holder, Hor at i Place i Ope ra . Le ip zig , 1899 . HJyginus, Bunte , Hyp; ini Ast r onomi ca . Leipzig, 1875. Funaioli, Gram mat i cae R oman a e Fragmen t a .Leipzig. 1907. • Justin us, Ieep , Trogi P pause i hi st or iarum Phil ippi car um , ep it om a Le ip zig , 1859 . .. Juvenal. Friedlander, D. Ittni i - Iuve n alls , Leipzig, 1895. Gehlen, De I uvenale Vergilii I mitator s, Gottingen ,1886. Lucan. Hosius, M, Annae i Lucan i Belli. Civil is . Libr i Lecex n , )( Leipzig, 1913. M Zingerle, Zu Spa t er en Late i nischen Dicht e rn Be itgage , Innshruclc, 1873. Christoni. Be Vergil io Luca n i in dedcr ip t ionibus auc tare . Rtv ista di St or ia Ant ic a . 3, 29 ff., 1898. Caspari. De rati, one guae int er Ye re; ilium et Luc anum lnterc edat .Leipzig, 1908. Manilius. Housman , M. Ma nil ii Astronomic a , London, 1903,1912,1916. Van Wageningep ,M . M anil i i As tr onomica , Leipzig, 1915. Martial. Friedlander, M. Va leri i Ma rtial is Sp igrammat on t Le ipz ig , 1 886. Ovid. Ehwald , P. Ovid i us Naso , Leipzig, 1902. Ellis, P. Qvidi Na son i s lb i s . Oxford, 1881. h ii Zingerle, Ovid ius und se in Verha ltnis. gar den Vor gangern r Innsbruck, 1869. Palaemon. Keil, Gramm at ic i Lat ini , 5, 334 ff . , Leipzig, 1864. Persius. A. Pers Ii Flacc i , D. Iunii l uvenal is , Sulpic iag 3a.t_u.ra® , Berlin, 1916 • - ■ * 2 Petronius. B ue ch e 1 e r , Petronii Arbitri Satirarum Reliquiae , Berlin, 1862, Buecheler — Heraeus , Petronii Satura g. Berlin, 1912. Phaedrus. Schwabe, Ph ae d ri F abul»r mft A esopiar um Libri Y, Brunswick, 1806, Hall, The Fables of P haedru s , New York, 1902. Pliny the ULder. Sillig, C, Plini Secu n di Nat uralis Histo riae Lib ri XXX YII f Hamb&fg r 1851-1858. Bet lef sen , C«,_Plini Secund l Natur alis Hi st or iae Lihri XXXYII, Berlin, 1866-18837 " May h off, C» Plini SecUndi Naturalis Lihri XXXYII , Leipzig, 1870. Pliny the Younger. He il , Cj_Pl ini__ Caec il i Sec-undi Ep istulft-rnm Novem .Bpistularurn ad Traiamimj^ Panegyric us , Leipzig, 1868. Mueller, C ^P 1 j& j _C ae cj 1 i Secu ndi Enis t .lar/ura ,_No v em^_^ 1 s t ul ar i um_ad_g_r a i anu m L ib e y P&negyr icus, Leipzig, 1S03 , " Probus. , He il , Grammati ci Latini , 4, 4 ff. Eeipzig, 1864 . Heil, Mi_Valeri Probi_in Verg ili i Bucplica_et H®OHKica_Comment ar ius, Halle, 1848. . ThiloJHagen, Appendix Serviana, 3 t 3,l>321ff., Leipzig, 1902. Propertius. Baehrens , Elegiarum Libr i Y, Leipzig, 1880. Reisch, Proper z^tudien^Wiejosif _St udien . 9, 121ff . , 1887. Roth stein, Das Yer halt nis von_Pr ojpor und_Ve rg.il , Hermes , 24, 1 ff . , 1889. Quintilian. Halm, M._F abi Quintil ian! Instituti onis Orator iae tikri_XII , Leipzig , 1 86 S*- 1869. * B o nn e 1 1 , M^_Fabr i_ Qui nt i liani Institutionis Or a.*. o r i ae lil'by.l. XII , Leipzig, 1869. Seneca the Elder. Kiessling^L^^nnai i_Senneca^0ratarum et Hh© t orum S ententlae Divisiones Co lores, Leipzig, 1872, " ~ 3 . « Muller, L. Annae_i__Seneca 0 _Orat orum et Phator urn , Leipzig, 1887. Seneca the Younger, Haase, L. Anna ei Senecae Oper a. Leipzig , 1865 . , H e n s e , L. Annaei Se necae Opera, Quae Supgnaunt , Leipzig, 1898. • Peiper y Richter , Ben eea e Tra go edlae r Le ip z ig , 1902. * W i r t h , Le Vi rgil i apud S en ecam Philos opbua Usu Freiburg, 1900. ' Silius Italics. Le Maire, Cains Siliua Italicus Pu nlcorum , L ibri X II , Paris, 1823. Statius, Mueller, j\_Papini Stati Tbebais e t _Ach i 1 1 e i s jL e i p zig, 1870. Vollmer, Sil varum Libr i, Leipzig, 1898. Klotz, P, Papi ni S tati A chil lei s. Leipz i g , 1902. Le i p s e r , De P . P api nid St atii V erg ilii et Ovi di i Imitatd re . Strassburg, 1881. Helm, De P, Papi nio Statio Thebaid e, Berlin, 1892. Michler , De P, P apinio Statio M. Annae i Lucani Im itator e , Breslau, 1 9 14 . Sulpicia, Buecheler, A. Pgrsii Flacci. D. Iu nii Iuvonalis , Sulpiciae Saturae f Berlin, 1910. Tacitus. Kritz, P . C orneli i Taciti Ag ric o la, Berlin. 1874. Furneaux, The A n nals of T acitu s. Oxford, 1884. Peterson, Tac i t i_L_ialog.us__de _0r at or .ibus, Oxford, 1893. Sudeqian , Cornelii Taciti Li alogus de O ratoribu s, Leipzig, 1914. Tibullus. Le Goldbery, Albii Ti bulli Omnia Oper a, Paris, 1826 . Hiller, Al bii Tibu lli Elehiae . Leipzig, 1883. Valerius Flaccus. Schenkl , C. Va leri Fl acci Se tini Balbi Argonaut icon L ibri Oct o , Leipz ig , 1859 . Hr arner , C. Val eri F lacci Ar gonaut icon Lib ri_ Oct o, Leipzig, 1913, Schenkl, Gramm at ic or urn Batavorum in C . Valeri i Flacci Argonautica Coniecturad in e dT t~ae' 7 W i bn e r S t udl e n .5 , "139' : ff . ,1883, < < - l c c l ( c < ... . t 4 • Man it ins , Vor'bilder u nd Nachahmer des Val er ius Flaccus_ , Philo l. ,48 . 249 ff., 18 89 V Stroll , Studie n zu Valeriu s Fla ccus hesonders iSher dessen V er hal't nis zu Ver gil, Mun i ch , 1905. • Ve r r ius Flaccus . Dac erius, Sex. Pompei Fes ti et Mar. Verrii Fl acci de Ve rh orum Sign if icat i one , Am s t e r data , - 1700. Fun a i o 1 i , O r amir, at ic ae Rom an a e Fra gm ent a, 1,511 ff . , Leipzig, 1907. . Caspar i, De r at ione q uae inter Ve r gil i am et Luc an -urn in ter cedat , Leipzig, 1908. . Chr i s t on i , De Vergilio Luca ni in descri pt ionihus gras tore , R4 vista d i Storia Antica, 3 , 29 ff . , 1898, De ip s e r , De P. Papini o Statiso Ver gilii et Ovidi i Imita tor p 9 Strasbourg ,189 2 . Gehlen, De._ Iuvenale Vergilii Imltatore. Got t inge n , 1 8 8 6 . Helm, De P . Papinii S tatii ffhe haide , Berlin, 189 2. Man it ius , Vor'bilder und H achah B tter des Valerius Flaccus Philol . 48 , 249 ff , , 1889. ' ~ ' Mi chi sr , De P. P apin io Stati o M. Annaei Luca ni Imita to re , Breslau, 1914. Re isch , Proper z-S tu dien . Wiener S tudien. 9, 121 ff., 1887. Rothstein , Das_VerhSl tni.s_von Pr o p er z und_Ver gi 1 ^Herme s_, 24, 1 ff . . 1889. S ch enkl , Gr am mat icor um Ba tavorum in C. Valeri i Fl acci Argo - n au t i.c a_c o n ie c t urae Ifoed itae , Wiene r _S t ud i_e n ,139 f f . , 1883. S t r oh , Studien z u Va lerius Fl accu s tesonders uher d essen Verhalt n is zu Vergil , Mun i ch , 1905. V/ i r th , De Vergi lii ap ud S enecam Phi los oph u m Us u , Fr 4 ihur g , 1900. lingerie, 0 vidius _und_sein_Verhaltn is _zu den Vo rgangern, Innsbruck 1869. " ~ ~ Zingerle, Z u Spatere n Lateinischen Dichtern Beitrage. Innsbruck 1873. ~ ' ‘ “ 5 EARLY QUOTATION OF VERGIL Tlie field of Vergilian imitation and r em ini a^-aaoe ex- tends over so many centuries that I have confined myself in this discussion to a single phase of the subject, -- Early quotation of Vergil, a comprehensive subject, but here limited in its ap- plication to the quotations found in the works of Vergil's con- temporaries and of the Latin authors of the first century after Christ , Quotation, as I shall understand it, is not mere iTTu.t-.vii ion 01 reminiscence ; but, in the case of pro3s writers, an actual citation of a word or words, a phrase, a lino, or several linos. In the pcots, the line between reminiscence and quotation can be less easily drawn; but, in this discussion , I shall assume that a Vergilian quotation in the poets consists of tnc use of the same words in essentially the same metrical posi- tion in which they occur in Vergil, with allowance for changes of case, tense, mood, and number, where the meter is not affected. -jy this restriction, I have somewhat narrowed the range of my subject and have discarded various instances of so-callsd quota- tions enumerated by other collectors. I realize, of course, that this work would be more nearly uniform if I myself had examined the authors treated and had made my own list of Vergilian quotations found in their works; buo the short time available for collecting my material has oblig- ed me to employ the collections of various editors and the authors Special works on vergilian influence. Consequently, there cannot 6 fail to "be various inequalities in this work depending upon the editions and compilations of different men who, doubtless, have performed their work with various degrees of accuracy. I do not, therefore, claim that, in the portion of the field covered, I have succeeded in noting every quotation from Vergil; “but I have done my work according to the definition of the subject already set forth, and with such accuracy as the materials at my disposal have permitted. The authors examined are those listed in Sc hang’ s G-es - „ " ch ichte der romischen Litteratur in Muller's Handbuch in the two volumes (VII, II, lj VIII 11,2.) containing the authors contemporary with Vergil and those writing during the first century after Christ. I have reviewed the works of each of these in the order in which they are treated by Schanz, save that I have omitted Livy because the greater portion of his history was written before Vergil's poems In the bibliography are included only those authors who quote from Vergil, and I have listed twice special studies on Ver - gil's inf luence once under the name of the ancient imitator and once under that of the modern scholar. Vergil occupies a unique place in the world of Homan literature, for no other Latin author has achieved the degree of lasting popularity accorded to him both in his own and in succeeding generations. Of course, like all men of genius, he had his enemies as we learn from Donatus ' life of Vergil; but he could afford to overlook the adverse criticism of a Haevitis, a Maevius , or a Carvilius Pictor amid the general es- teem in which he was held not only by literary men of ability but by the whole Homan people who, we learn in Tacitus' Dialo gu e de 8 . This enthusiastic' zeal was not felt by the prose writers only, hut Tibullus, Propertius, and Ovid eagerly studied Vergil*s style. * Ovid was twenty-four years old when Vergil died and had seen the poet hut once, yet he had conceived the greatest admiration for him and his works and consciously studied him as a model of perfection, so that it is not surprising in so great and original a poet to find as many as three hundred and forty-four Vergilian quotations . In the case of these early writers, so nearly contem- poraneous with Vergil, it is interesting to note that this imita- tion could not have come about through the influence of the schools, for Vergil was not introduced there until a few years before his death. ** And, even then, before we can see the direct effect of such study we must allow time for the pupils to have grown up and to have produced works of their own. Vergil early came to be regarded as a vast storehouse of wisdom which needed explanation and, hence, we have the learned com- mentaries of Donatus and Servius, and the .Saturnalia of Macrobius, He was a model for poets and orators, and his philosophic views and sage maxims endeared him to the philosopher. Ho was the source- book of the grammarians, who quoted him with such profuseness that Comparetti remarks that even if all the MSS, of Vergil were lost we could still reconstruct practically all of his major works from the quotations of the later Latin authors. Perhaps, at first, this seemi an /extravagant and impossible statement, but when we look at the evi- Comparetti, (tr Tjy Benecke)' Vergil in the Middle aye. , 12. Saniya, HJ^tory^g Classica l Schol arship . 1, i S 6 . 9 dence of a single century and reflect that the great grammarians ana Vergilian commentators wrote in the centuries following, we can bet- ter appreciate the probability of the statement. Phrases from the Ec log ue s are incorporated in the pastor- als of Calpurnius and Nemesianus, while Lucan, Statius, Valerius Flaccus, and Silius Italicus drew from him so abundantly that their works have almost the effect of centos, Statius deeply revered his master as we see from these verses : . . . nec tu divinam Aeneida t'enta Sed longe sequere et vestigia semuer adora (Theb. 12, 816) and more fully in the fourth book of Silv ae (4, 4, 55) . . . Haronique sedens in margine tempi i Sumo fenimum et rnagni tumulis adcanto Magistri. Pliny (Epist, 3, 7, 8 ) throws some very interesting light on Silius Italicus’s esteem for Vergil whom he imitated in an almost slavish manner. Pliny tells us that Silius treated the busts of Vergil with especial veneration and that he kept his birthday far more scrupulously than he did his own, principally at Naples, where he used to approach the poet’s monument as tho it were a temple, Vergil also had a high place in the regard of Seneca, the philosopher, who quotes much more frequently from his poems than from any other author and dignifies him by the epithets, "nostc r Vergil ius , ” ”vir dtsertissimus , ” "Maximus v*tes.” 10 That Vergil was considered the "best handbook for orators we learn from Quintilian (l, 3, 4) who recommends the study of Ver- gil and Homer to all aspiring orators. Moreover, he lays down this maxim for the orator in the very words of Vergil, Geo rg. 2, 272, "adeo in teneris consusssere multurn est.", and Tiberius Claudius Donatus, an ancient Edward ITorden, of the fourth century, wrote a commentary on the Aen e id in which lie recommended Vergil to his son as a great orator. Vergil was also regarded as an authority on everyday matters. Manilius in his As tr onom ica finds occasion to draw from him frequently and Pliny in his Hat ural.Hi story in many places re- produces him in indirect form. Columella’s book De Re Rust i ca quotes the Geor gies at great length, and in his tenth book on gardening, which he wrote in verse, he rather successfully imitated the style of the Georgies. Doubtless he hoped that this book might be considered worthy of finding a place with the four Geor gies, for Vergil had admitted that he had left a portion of the field for other writers to cov- er. * Of course these are but a very few of the authors who quote Vergil, but to continue farther would be to go beyond the lim- its of my subject. We are not to assume, however, that Vergilian quotation ceases with these authors. On the contrary Vergil’s po- pul a r ity increased in the next few centuries, flourished in the Middle Ages, and persists even to-day. 11 In the list of quotations immediately following, an asterisk indicates the quotation of a complete line, the sym- bol (I) the "beginning , (M) the middle, and (F) the end of a line. Interrupted quotations are indicated "by the symbols (I) (M) where the beginning and middle of a line are quoted, (M) (F) for the middle and the end, and (l)(F) for the begin- ning and end. The authors are arranged chronologically by the date of their death, in order that we may readily see what portions of Vergil’s works were most popular at different per- iods within the century. - ■ . “ „ ' t 12 1» 1 Pro'b. 7, 15 Z, 1,76 (F) Mart . 13 , 99 , 1 . I , * quint. 2,4,86 1,81 (F) Quint . 10 , 1 , 12, 1.5 * Pro'b • ult._syll. IV, 236 Z» 1,6-10 * Sen. ben ef, . 4,6,4. 1.6 *(Sen. e p i s t . ,73,10. 7 (I) ( 1.7 (F) Prob, ult . syll . IV, 234 K. 1,9-10 * Sen. epist . 73,11, 1,11 (F) (Quint. 1, 4, 28. ,12 ( 1,15 (M) Pro'b . norn . ex c . IV , 209 Z, Quint .1,6,2. 1,22 * ( 23 (l)( Colum, 3, 9, 4, 1,22 * Quint. 5,11,30. 1,33 (F) Hor. ars . 330. 1.42 (I)( 43 (I) ( Quint. 9,3,53. 44 * ( 1.43 (F) Sil. 12, 332. 1.58 * Prob, ult. s£ll.IV,225 Z. 1.59 * (Prob . 5, 13 Z. 60 * ( 1, 59 * Prob, inst. Art. IV, 149 Z, 1.68 (I) Prob. gath .IV.16 Z, 1.69 (I) Prob. ult. syll . IV. 261 Z. 1.70 (I) Prbb . ult.syll. IV f 230 Z. 1,73 * Sen, epi st . 101,4. 1,73 ( I) Prob . inst .ar t . IV. 183 Z. 2, 1 (F) Mart .8,63,1. 2, 2 (I) Juv. 2,6,47. 2, 6 ( I) (Prob .ult.3ftll.IV , 229 (Hor .c arm. 4, 10,1. z. 2, 6 w Prob .ult . syll . IV, 250 z. 2, 6 * Prob. 6, 25 Z. 2, 7 (I) Prob. ult .syll. IV, 232 z. 2,11 * Prob .ult . syll . IV , 260 z. 2,14 (I) Prob.ult.syll.IV ,250 z. 2,22 (I) 0v.me._t, 13, 829. 2,22 * Prob . cath, IV, 7 Z. 2,23 24 * (Prob. 7, 19 Z. (I)( 2,25 26 (F) (I) Sen. aat. 1,17, 5, 2,26 (I) Sen. nat.*. 5,1, 1. 2,28 w Man i 1 . 5, 125, 2,29 w Tib, 4, 1, 84. 2,45 (I) Prob. Inst .art . IV, 154Z. 2,45- 48 *Pr ob . 5, 17 Z. 2,47 (I) Man i 1 . 5, 257, 2,52 (F) Ov.ars.am. 2,267, 2,52 (I) Calp. 2, 82. 2,56 (I) Calp. 2, 61. 2,60 (I) Prop. 3 , 22, 1. 13 2,65 (F) Ov. ar s . am . 1,749. 4, 1 * Prob. 7, 16 E. 2,65 (I) Pr ob . I V , 258 E. 4, 1 (I) Sil. 14, 467. 2,66 * Quint. 8, 6, 21. 4, 8 (I) Prob. ult , syll , 250 K. 2,69 (I) (Quint. 9, 3, 28; 4.49 * Fest. 17, 5^8 D, (Juv. 3, 9, 102. 4,49 (M) Mart • 6 , 3 , 2 . 3, 6 * Prob. ult . syl 1 . IT , 264 E. 4,57 0?) Tib. 2, 3, 11. 3, 8 (F) ProT3.ult.syll.IV r 250 E. 4,61 * Prob .ult. syll . I V , 259 E. 3,8-9 * Quint. 9, 3, 59. 4, 62 (F) ( Quint • 9 , 3, 8. 63* ( 3,12 (F) ProT3.ult.syll.IV.328 E. 3,17 * (Quint. 9, 2, 13. D » 18 (I)( 5, 2 ♦ Prob.ult.syll.lv, 241 E. 3,21 * Quint. 9, 2, 13. 5, 5 * Prob.ult.syll.IV. 2S.3 E. 3,25 ( I) Quint . 11,3,176. 5, 6 ( I) Prob .ult . syll . IV. 248 E. 3,32 * Prob. inst .art . IV , 186 K. 5,32 (F) Mart . 1,43,3; Juv. 11 ,*! 52. 3,33 ( I) Prob. ult. syll. IV, 332 E* 5,39 (F)Colum. 10, 22. 3,42 * Prob. 9, 1 K. 5,39 (I) Prob .ult . syll , IV , 227 E, 3,49 (i)Prob. 89 ,28 E. 5,45 (I) Prob .ult . syll , I V , 233 K. 3,60 (l)Ger, 1; Calp. 4, 82. 5,46 (I) Pr ob .ult ..syll. IV, 233 K. 3 , 60- 51 * Prob , 6, 28 E. 5,50 (I) Prob, ult. syll. IV, 250 E, 3,64 * Prob.ult.syll.lv, 260 E. 5,64 (M) (St at, sil. 4, 6, 36: (Theb. 5, 751. 3,69 (F) Quint. 1,6, 2. 5,85 (I) Prob.ult.syll.IV, 23 8 E. 3,95 (F) Pr ob . inst .art , IV , 129 ult . syll . IV. 325 E. 5,88 * Fest, 14, 332 D. 3 , 100 ( I) Prob .ult . syll . IV , 256 K. 3,102 (F) Quint. 8, 6, 73. 6, 1 * Prob. 7, 17 IC. 3,104 -105 * Quint . 8 , 6 , 52 . 6, 5 (F) Quint. 8, 2,9. 3,106 (F) Prob.nom.exc, 213 E. 6 , 6 0?) Hor • carm, saec . 76. 107 (I) 6,13 (I) Fast,. 14, 338 D. < < < 14 6, 12 (F) Pro'b .ult . s.yll • IV p 226 E. 7,21 (I)Prob. ult. syll. IV, 231 E. 6,21 (I) Pr ob . cat.h. IV , 18 E. 7,33 (I) Prob. lit .syll. IV, 260 E. 6,32 (M) Pr ob , 18, 24 K. 7,42 (F) ?$st. 1, 19 D. 6,33 (I) Prob. 11, 14 K. 7,46 * Fast. 1, 35 D. 5,38 (M) (F) 0v.iP3t.ll , 516. 7,47 (F) (Prob. ult . syll. IV, 262 E. 6,41 * Prob. 21, 27 II. 7,48 (?) ( 6 ,43 (?) Luc . 9 , 611. 7,49 (F) Man i 1 . 4 , 758 . 6,43 (i) Pro'b. 22, 12 K, 7,54 * Colum. 7, 10, 8, 6,43 (F) S t a t . all . 1 , 3 , 70. 7,61 (I) Prob. 24, 15 E. 6 ,47 (I) Prob .ult . syll . IV , 219 E, 5 6,51 Ov. hal, 3; Pet r on, 126 , 14 i 6,52 (I*) Sil. 13, 332. 0 v . are . am. 3 , 427 . 8,10 (M) (F) (Ov.aii 1 , 15 , 15 (Mart. 5, 30, 1, 6,54 (F) Ov, am, 3, 5, 17. 8,13 * Quint. 10, 1, 92. 6,61 ♦ Prob. 22, 23 E. 8,18 (F) Val.Fl. 3, 22. 6,52 (F) (Prob . nom.exc . IV . 205 8,28 (F) Quint. 9, 3, 6. 6 ,63 ( I) ( Quint , 1, 5, 35. 8,32 (F) Prob. 81,13 II. 6,70 (M) Sil. 12, 413. 8,43 (M) Tib, 3, 4, 74. 6,74 (I) Prob. 23, 7 K, 8,44 (I) Prob. ult. syll. IV t 22£ E, 6,74- 75* Prob, 23, 18 K. 8,47 8,69 (I) (F) Tib, 3, 4, 65-66. Ov. her. 6. 89. 6,74- 75* (Prob. 10,26 E. 0,69 * Prob. ult. .syll, IV, 231 E. 76 (I) ( 8,70 (?) Petr on. 134, 12. 6,78 ♦ Prob. 23, 27 E. 8,83 * Prob, ult .syll. IV ,230 E. 6 , 82 83 (I) (Pro'b . 24, 9. (M) ( 8,87 (I) Prob. ult. syll. IV, 254 E. 8,105 * Prob. 94,25 E. 7, 1 (I) Prob . ult . syll . IV , 247 K. 7, 8 (© Pr ob • inst • art • IV , 149 II. < < t { c ( ( 15 9,1* Prob. 6 , 11 K. 9, 2 (F) Pro~b. ult.sy ll.lv, 223 K. 9, 2 (I) Prol3.ult. snl l. IV, 229 K. 9, 5 (I) Prols.u lt.syll . IV, 252 II. 9, 7-10 * Quint. 8 . 6 . 46. 9.10 (LI) Pr o~b . 74, IK. 9.11 (I) Pro~b. 31 ltiSzll.lv, 238 K. 9.14 (I) Pro~b.u lt.s y 11. IV. 25 2 K, 9,14-15 *Pro~b.S, 6 K. 9.15 (I) ProT 3 .ult. 3 yll. IV, 254 K. 9,24 ) M) Fest. 1, 16 D. 9,28 (F) Mart, 8 , 56, 7 . 9.39 (I) Pr o~b , ult . sy l 1 . 1 V , 236 K. 9.40 (F) (Pro~b. nom.ex c. Iv, 231 K. 41 (I)( 9,43 (F) Stat.Iheb. 12,729. 9.45 (F) Quint. 9, 4, 54. 9.46 (I) Pro~b.u lt .syll. IV, 229 K. 9, 49 (I) Pro~b .ult.syll .lv. 247 K, 9,53 (F) (Prol3. ult.sy ll. IV, 261 K. 54 (I) ( 9,56 * Pro~b. ult. syll. IV, 237 II. 9,58 * Prol3. ult.sy ll.IV.228 K. 10, 4-5 * Sen.nat. 3, 26, 5. 10.10 XI) ProT3. ult.syll . IV, 231 K. 10.11 * Quint. 9, 3, 18. 10.12 * Pro~b.ultiSyll. 258 K. 10,23 * Pr o~b • ult.syl l.IV,26Q K. 10,33 (M) Qv.he r , 7, 162. 10,35 (I) Pro~b. ult .syll. IV ,247 K, 10,37 ( I) (Pro~b .ultj.syll. IV, 250 Kj (IV, 251 K. 10.50 (M) Quint. 10, 1, 56. 10.51 (F) (Til). 2, 1, 53; ( Calp . 1, 93. 10.67 (F) Prol3. cath .IV, 12 K. 10.68 (F) Manil. 3, 480. 10.69 (I) Prob. ult . s yll . I V , 257K. 10,72-73* Quint. 9, 3, 44. t t < 16 CrEQRGICS. 1, 1 (M) Colum. 10, 3. 1, 1 (F) (ProTa. inat.a rt. I Y. 79 K, 2 (DC 1,1-4 * Prob . 26, 5 10. 1 , 5 (F) (Pr ob » 26, 10 10. 6 * ( 7 (I)( 1,6 * Prob. ult .sy ll, 17,236 10. 1, 6 (F) Prob. ult , syl l. IV, 237 K. 1,28 (F) Ov.gm. 1,1, 2S: fas t , 4 , 15, 1,28 * Prob. 30. IS K, 1,30 (F) (Prob. 30, 22 30. 31 * ( 1,30 (I) Pr oil . ult . syll. IV, 227 10. 1,32-35 * Prob, 31, 4 10. 1,35 (I) Prob «ult . syll. IV, 226 10. 1,36- 39 * Prob. 31, 26 10. 1, 7 (I) Prob.cath .17, 12 10. i , ^ n (F ) 4, S' ^7 1,43 (l) Colum. 11,2,2. 1, 7 (F) (Prob. 26, 18 X. S * ( 1,43 * (Quint. 4, 2, 2. 44 (I)( 1, 9 * Prob. 26, 31 10, 1 ,45 (F) Man i 1 , 4, 380. 1,10 * Prob. 27, 15 X. 1 ,47- •48 * Prob. 32, 14 X. 1,11 (F) Prob. 27, 27 X. 1,48 (F) PI in. hat . 18, 181 1,11 (I) St at . Theb. 4, 480. 1,51- 53 * Colum. 1, 4, 4; 1,12 (F)(Prob. 28. 1 K. Plip.. Hat. 18, 2 13 * ( 14 (I)( 1,52 (F) Ov.met.7, 58; Stat.Sil. 2,2,41; 1,14 (F) (Prob. 28, 17 10. s il . 3, 5, 89. 15 * ( 1,53- '57 * (Sen . spi s t . 87, 20 1,16- 17* (Prob . 22, 5 10. 58 (I) ( 18 (D( 1,53 * Colum. 5, 5, 7, 1,18 (F) (Prob . 29, 16 10. IS (I) ( 1,53 (I) Colum. 8, 17, 7, 1,19 (F)(Prob. 29, 22 X. 1,54 * (Quint. 9, 3, 39. 20 * ( 55 (DC 1,20 * Prob. 30, 3 10. 1,55 (I) Prob. ult .syll. IV f 1 ,21 (I) Prop. 3, 13, 41, 1,56 (I) (Prob, 33, 3 10. 57-59* ( ( * 17 1,60-62 * (ProTj , 33, 27 2. 63 (I) ( 1.63 (M) ProTj • 79, 5 2 1.64 (I) Mart. 1,107, 8, 1 ,67-68 * ProTj. 34, 12 2. 1 , 69-70 *ProTj. 33, 12. 1 ,73-76 * ProTj, 34, 24 2. 1,77-78 * Colum, 2, 14, 3. 1,78 (F) Ov. am. 2, 5, 31. 1 ,78 (F) ProTj, 34, 30 2. 1,86-87 *( Quint. 9, 3, 96. 88 (I) ( 29 (I) ( 91 (I) ( 1,93 (M) Mart. 4, 19, 9. 1,100 (I) ProTj. IV, 124 2. PI in . nat . 17,13. 1 , 102 (F) (Pr oT> . 35, 3 2. 103 * ( 1,106 (I) Prols . ult , syll . iv . 247 2. 1,110 (F) Manil. 2, 87. 1,114 * ProTj . 34, 21. 1,114 (F) Juv. 1, 157. 1, 115 (I) ProTj. ult .sy ll. IV. 252 2. 1,120 (I) Pr olj . 35, 9 2. 1, 121 (M) TiTj. 1, 4, 23. 1.122 (F) Manil. 1, 51 1.123 (F) Manil. 1, 79 1, 124 * ProTj. 35, 11. 1,125 (F) Ov.met.. 11,33; Manil. 1, 877. “ -s 1,125 (F) (Ssn. epist. 90, 37. 126-128 *( 1,134 * ProTj. u lt .syll . IV, 250 2. 1,137 (F) Sen. nat. 7, 25, 3. 1.137 (I) ProTj. ul t A S2ll_..IV,263 2. 1.138 * ProTj. 35, 14 2. 1.139 * (Sen. ep ist . 90, 11. 140 (DC 1,139 (M)(Sen. vita^Tjeata 14, 3 140 (F) ( 1,144 Sen. epist, 90, 9. 1 , 148 (F) (ProTj, 36, 3 2, 149 * ( 1,154 (l)(Plin. nat. 22 , 106. 1,158 * Sen. Tae n ef . 7, 5, 2. 1,160 * ProTj, 81. 12. 1,163 * ProTj. 36, 10 2. 1,176-177 * Sen. epi st. 124, 1. 1,181 (F) Quint. 8, 3, 20. 1,183 (M) Quint, 9, 3, 6. 1,187 (I) ProTj. ult .s yll . IV r 243 2. 1,195-196 * Colum, 2, 10,11. 1,197-200 * Colum. 2 ,9 , 12; 3. 10 , 18 , 1,198 * ProTj. ul t. s yll. IV, 22 6 2. 1,201 (F) ProTj. 36, 18 2. 1,204 (F) (Colum. 11 1 31 . 205-207 *( 18 1,305 (I) Pro*. 36 19 K. 1,208 * Prob. oat h. IV, 3 ICj Prob. 36, 29 K. 1.211 * Prob.ult, syll.IV, 254 K. 1.212 (F) Prob, ITT, T*f"~ 1,214 * Colum. 2, 8, 3, 1,215-216 * Sen. epi st .86,16. 1,217 (M) ( F) Man i 1 . 2 , 494 . 1,217-218 * Prob. 37, 2 K. 1,219-221 * Colum. 2,8, 1. 1,219 (F) Prob. oath. IV, 14 K. 1,221-222 * (Prob . 37, 13 K. 223(FX 1,222 * Prob. 17, 13 K. 1,225-226 * Prob. 37, 28 K. 1,227 (I) Prolj.iiit^syll.IV, 250 K. 1,227-229 * Prob . 38, 1 K. 1,233-239 * Prob. 38, 18 K. 1,233 (I) Prob. 40, 15 K. 1,237 (F) Sil. 4, 792 1,242 (I) Test. 17, 538 D. 1,244-246 * Prob. 40, 5 K* 1.245 (¥) Ov. met. 2, 172. 1.246 * Prolj.u lt.syll . IV T 231 K. 1,247-251 * Proo. 39, 27 K. 1,250 (M) (jb 1 ) Man i 1 . 2, 796. 1,250-251 * Sen. epi st . 122,2. 1,268 (I) ( Colum. 2, 22, 1. 269-272 *( 1,273- -275 * Colum. 7, 1, 3, 1,281 (p) 0 V. met . 1 , 1 55 * Prob. 43, 17. 1,295 (M) Quint. 8, 2, 10. 1,303 (3?) Prop. 3, 24, 15, 1,309 (P) Luc. 1, 229. 1,312 Prob.ult . syll . IV ,249 1,313 (P) Sen. mat . 4, 4, 2. 1,322 (P) Sil. 12, 619. 1,324 (P) Luc . 2 , 290 j St at, Theb . 9, 30. 1,335 (P) Manil. 2, 102. 1,336- •337* Sen. epist . 88, 12* Prob. 43, 20 K. 1,357 (I) Quint. 8, 3, 4?. 1,351 (M) Val , FI. 3, 144. 1,362 (P) (Sen. nat. 7.28.1. 363- 364 *( 1,367 * Sen. nat , 1, 14, 2 1,367 (p) Sen. nat . 7, 20, 1. 1,377 00 Prob, 9, 22 E. 1,378* Prob. 44, 5 K. 1,380 (F) (Sen. nat . 1, 6, 1 381 (I) ( 1,383 (F) (Prob. 44 , 11 Z 384 * ( 1,388 * Quint. 5, 9, 15 1,392 * Sen, nat . 7, 28 1,397 (I) Prob . inst . art . IV . 130 ttL 19 1,399 (I) Prob. 44, 15 K. 1,409 * ProT5.ulti8.xll. IV, 249 X. 1,415 (I) Prot.ult.ayll, >17,34 7 X 1,422 (M) Quint. 5, 9, 15. 1,424-426 * Sen. eni st . 83,16. 1,427-429 * Sen.auas, 3, 5. 1,429 * Pr o'b . ult, syll. I V , 249 X. 1,430 (?) Ov.met,. 1,484; Stat.Theb. 2. 231. 1,431 (?) Quint. 5, 9, 15. 1 ,432- -433 * Sen, suas . 3, 5. 1,433 (?) Manil 4, 506. 1 ,437 * P r p b . ult. syll . I V , 2 5 8 Prob. 44, 25 X, Ki 1,440 (?) Manil 1, 182. 1,450 (M) (F) Manil, 1,178. 1,457 * Prob .ult iSyli. IV, 240 X 1,463 (P) (Manil. 2, 134-135. 454(1) ( 1,464 465 c?) ( (M) Ov. met. 15, 794. 1,469 (?) Ov. met . 2, 872 1 ,492 * Prob. 45, 5X, 1 ,495 Stat . Theb . 3, 582. 1,506 (a) Manil. 5, 461. 1 ,509 (P Prob.ult.syll.IV f 260 x. 1,512- 514 * Quint. 8, 3, 78. 2, 1 (F) Ov. met. 7, 580; Luc. 4, 521. 2, 1 (I) Colum. 3, 1, 1; Colum. 10, 433; Pr ob .u lt , sy ll . IV, 260 X. 2, 2 (I) Prob . 45, 11 X. 2, 5 * Pro~b.ult.s yll .lv, 257 X. 2, 9 (M) Manil . 2, 150. 2 , } 0 ( F) ( C o lum . 3 , 1 , 1 . 11 (I)( 2,16 (F) Pr o'b . 26,26 X; Pr o'b , 45, 16 X. 2,18 * Pr o'b . 45,23 X. 2,32 * (ProT5.ultiByll.lv, 249 X. 33 (II 2,37 (F) (Pro~b .46 , 1 X. 38 * ( 2,40 (DProT5.ult. 8yl l. 17,322 K. 2,45-46 * Sen, benef . 7, 1, 1. 2,46 (I) Pr o’b . ult .syll . IV . 254 X . 2,49 (pProTu ult.syll .IV, 252 K. 2.53 * Prob . ult . s yll . IV T 254 X. 2,58 * Sen, enist . 86,15, # 2.54 (F)ProTu ftWM^ «4S f ll K . 2,56 (P)ProT5. /L^ J 4^jl^ 46,15 X. 2.67 (pProT5.ult.syll.IV,227 X, ; 26, 28 X. 2.68 (F)Pr o'b. ult. syl l. IV, '261 X 2.69 * ProTD.ult i sxll,IV,228 X. 2,74 (H) Quint. 1, 5, 35. 20 . 2.83 ( I) Proh .ult . syl l . IV, 220 Kj ult . syll IV, 250 K. 2.84 ( F) Proh. 46, 20 K. 2,86 (I) Proh. oa th, IV, 22 K; 2.86 * " 47, 3 K. 2.87 (I) Pro*. 47, 7 K, 2,89 * Proh. ul t .syl l. IV, 227 K; 2, 8S-S0* 47 , 13 K. 2,91 * Proh. 47, 19 IC. 2,93 (F) ProT3.cath.IV, 19 IC. 2,95 (F) ( Sen , nat , 1,11, 2. 96 * ( '2,95 (I) Pr oh , 47, 22 IC. 2,9 3 * Proh. 47, 24 IC. 2,104 (F) (Colum. 3, 2, 89. 1 05-106 ( 2,109 * Colum. 7, 2, 2. 2.115 * Proh. 48, 3 IC. 2.116 (M) Pr oh . 48, 6 IC. 2,119 (I) Proh. 48, 7 IC. 2, 120-121 * Proh. 48,10 K, 2,124 (I) Proh. ult. sy ll f IV,260 IC. 2,126 * (Proh. 48, 16. IC. 127 (I) ( 2,128 (F) Luc. 4, 637. 2,132 * Proh.ultiS^ll . IV, 249 IC. 2,137-139 * Proh. 48,23. 2,140 (F) Sil. 17,133: 6,232; Val . FI. 1,221. 2,145 (F) Sil. 10, 430. 2,146-147 * Proh. 43,29 IC. 2,148 * Pr Ah . ult . syll t IV r 23 8 IC. 2,152 * Proh. 48, 32 K, 2,153 (M)Manil, 1, 330 2.158 * Proh. 49, 6 IC. 2.159 (F) ( Sen, hene f . 4, 5, 2; 150 * ( 2,159 (I) Proh. ult. syll . IV, 229 IC. 2,159-130 * Proh. . 49. 10 IC. 2,167-168 * (Proh. 49, 15 IC. 169 (I) 2,137 (I) Proh, IV, 228 K. 2,137 (F) Juv. 3, 169. 2,158 Proh .u lt . s yll . IV , 260 K. 2,169 (F) (Quint. 9, 3, 24. 170 * ( 2.175 (F) (Colum. 10, 435 173 (I) (F) 2.176 * Proh. 49, 21 IC. 2.177 * Proh. ult^BEll^IV, 233 IC. 2,180 (M) (F) Manil. 2, 229. 2,180 * Proh. IV, 257 IC. 2,185 (M) Val. FI. 6, 711. 2,192-193 * Proh. 49, 26 IC. 2,197-198 * Proh. 49, 31 IC. 2,204 * Colum, 2, 2, 4 t t 21 2,204 (F) Colum. 5 , 4 , 2 . 2,204 (I) Prob .ult . syll . IV, 233 Sil. 8, 39 2. 2,209 (I) Manil. 2, 778. 2,211 (F) Manil. 4,524. 2,221 (F) 0 y . her . 5 , 47. 2,224 * (Hyg. 536 F. 225 (1)1 2,224-225 * Prob . 50, 19 K. 2,238-240 * Co lum . 3, 1. 9. 2,241 (F) Prol 3 .noraj. 0 sc. IV, 211 K, 2,243 (I) Pro-b.ultj.szll. IV, 224 K. 2,246-247 * Hyg. 529 F. 2,250 * Colum. 2, 2, 18. 2,259 (I) Ivl anil 2, 433. 2,272 (F) Quint. 1,3,13. 2,278 (I) Prol3. ult.syl l. 2,288 (I) Manil. 3, 203. 2.291 (F) (Mart . 292 (I) ( 2.292 2.293 2.297 2 . 298 2,301 2,338 2,342 2,348 * Colum. 3, 15, 4, 2,350 (F) ) Colum. 3, 15, 4. 351-354 *) 2,365 * Prol3.ultj.szllj.lv, 252 K. 2 , 330-384*Prob . 50, 27 Z, 2,385-389 * Prob. 51, 20 K. 2,392 * Colum. 3, 21, 4. 2, 3 9 5 ( I)Prob. ult. s yll . iv, 245 K. 2,410 ( I) Prob. ult j.sz.11. IV, 239 K, 2,412 (F) (Colum. 1, 3, 9. 413.(1) ( 2,420 ( I)?rob. ul t . syll. IV, 254 K, 2.437 * Prob . 52. 16 II. 2.438 (I) Plih. nat. 14, 128. 2,438 (F)Prol3.ult.syll,IV,261 K, OV. 2,442 ( F) / am. 1, 12, 13; 3, 7 , 15; Mart , 7 , 19 , 1 . 2,457 (F); Val . FI. 1, 337. 2,459 (F) Tib , 3, 37. 2,464 (F) Prob. 52, 22 K. 2,476 (F) Stat.Theb. 4, 263. 2,478 * Prob. 52, 25 II. 2,481-48 2 * Prob. 53, 7 S, IV, 260 K. 1,3, ,11; 1,6,1. (F) Manil. 2, 794. (I) Prob .ul t , syllJ V, 352 II. (I) Pr ob . ult . syll . IV , 246 K. * Colum. 3,12, J Quint . 9 ,3 , 21 . 2 ,483*Prob . ult . syll . IV. 252 II, 2,483-484 * Prob. 53, 12 K. 2,484 (F) Luc. 2, 557; Stat.T heb . 2, 669. -,48® C I) Pr^ol) . IV (I) Prob.ultj.szll. IV, 235 E. (M) Prob. ult. syll . IV. 233 E, (F) Luc. 4.54; Stat.Theb. 10,145: Sil . 5, 1,241; Sil. 2,239; 7 » 476; 11,461. ( 22 2,490 (I) Prop. 1, 12, 15. 2 , 50S*Pr ob . 53, 21 X. 2.512 (I) Man 11 . 4, 171. 2.513 (F) Ov. met . 5, 341, 2,519 (F) Pro!) , 54, 1 X. 2,523 (F) Or, met. 0, 211. 2,529 (F) Man 11. 4, 27. 2,541 * Quint. 9, 3, 20. 2,541-542 * Quint. 8, 6, 45. 3, 1 Colum. 10, 3; Pro!) . ul t . 8yll.IV, 222 X; IV, 23 3 X, 3 , l-2*Prob. 54 , 5 X. 3 , 4 (F) (ProTj. 54, 23 X. 5 * ( 3,6 * Pr ob . 54, 29 X; Pas a , VI , 260 X. 3, 8 (F) (Plin . op ist. 5,8,3. 3,9 * ( 3,10-12 * Pro 1). 55, 12 X, 3, 12(H) (F) (Pro b.55, 25 X. 3 , 15 (I) ( Sil.7, 456 3,19-20 * Pr ob . 56, 1 X. 3,25 * Prob . 56, 22 X. 3,27 * Prob. 56 , 27 X. 3,30 * (Pr ob . 57, 1 X. 32 *( 3,34-35 * Prol). 57 , 13 X. 3,37-38 * Pro*. 57, 25 X. 3,37 (I) Stat . si l . 2, 6, 69. 3,40 * (Prob. 58, 14 X. 41 Cl) ( 3,42 (F) (Colum. 10, 68; Pr ob .u lt . syll. IV . 236 X. 3.42 * ProT3.ult.syll.lv, 24 7 X. 3.43 (F) ( Prob. 58, 17 X. 44 * ( 3.44 (M) Val. FI. 2, 391. 3,46-48 * Prob . 5® T 27 X. 3,49-50 (Prob. 33,24 X. 51 (I)( 3,53 (F) Ov. me t . 2, 854. 3, 53 (M) Prol) .ult . syll . IV , 255 X. 3,59 Or) Stat. Acla. 1, 60. 3,60- • si * Prob . 59, 11 X. 3,54 (I) Prol). oath. IV, 24 X. 3,66-68 * Sen, op ist . 108,24, 3.66 * (Son. brev^vitae 9,2; 67 ( I) ( Sen, epis t . 108,26. 3.67 (F) Man i 1 . 4, 156; Sen. epis t . 108.29. 3,73 * Prob. ult. syll . IV, 250 X. 3,75-80 * (Sen. epist . 95, 68. 31 (I) ( 83 (F) ( 84-85 * ( 3,76 (M) Sil. 16, 443. 3,79 (F) Quint. 0, 2, 15. 3.81 (I) Sen. ep i st . 95,71 3.82 (I) Prob. 59,16 X. 3,33 (F) (Quint. 8 , 2, 15. 34 (I) ( < c. r ( t < r c < i t ; ( < l ♦ t t * t t < < 23 3.84 (I) Luc. 1, 145; Stat.TheL. 1,130. 3.85 (F) Sil. 6, 232. 3,89 * Pro!) .ult . syll . I V , 327 2. 3 ,89-91* Pro!) . 59 7 21 2. 3,92-94 *Pro!>. SO, 3 2. 3,94 (I) Pro!) . ult^syll. IV, 229 2. 3,103 (I) JuV. 3, 249. 3,113-115* Pro!) . SO, 15 2. 3,115 * ProL . nor n. exc . IV, 211 2, 3,122 * Pro!). SO, 11 2. 3, 135-135* Quint. 8, S, 8. 3,143 Pro!), ult.syll , I V , 254 2 . 3.146- 149 (Son. on is t . 58. 2. 150 (I) ( 3.146- 148 * Pro!). 61, 7 2. 3.150 (P) (Pro!) . ult.syll . IV, 245 E 151 (I) ( 3.151 (F) Pro!), SI, 21 2. 3,171 (F) Sil, 4, 258, 3,184 (P) Pr o!) .nom^exc', IV, 211 2; uJJU&Zll^IV, 241 2. 3, 186(F) Pro!), ult. syl l. IV, 241 2; Sil. 16, 356. 3.201 (I) Pro!), ult.syll . IV, 248 2. 3.202 * Pro!). 61, 26 2. 3,204 (P) Sil. 3, 337. 3,212 (I) Pro!). ult.sy lI.IV f 252 2. 3,242 (P) Manil . 1, 236. 3,243 (P) Quint. 1, 5, 28. 3,258 (F)' Stat. Sil . 5. 1. 56. 3,260 (F) (Sen. e^ist .' 108, 34. 261 (I) ( 3,264 (I) Pro!:, 34, 14 2. 3,266-273 * Colum. 6,27,5. 3 , 2G7 (P) (Pro!) . S2, 8 . 268 * ( 3,271 (P) Manil. 1, 881. 3,282 (P) Pro!) . 62, 3 2. 3, 234 (P) Sen. enis t . 108,24. 3,304 (P) Pro!). S2,23 2. 3.312 * Pro 1). 52, 25 2. 3.313 * Colum 7, S, 3. 3,324-327 *( Colum. 329 *( 7, 3, 23. 3,325 (M) Pro!) .u lt . syll , IV, 246 2. 3,332-334 * Colum. 7, 3, 23. 3,336 * (Colum, 3, 7, 24. 337 (I)( 3,338 (*)' Pro!). 68, 8 2, 3,339-340 * Pro!). 64,19 2. 3,340 (M) Pro!). 63, 14 2. 3.344 (F) (Quint , 9, 3, 51 345 ( I) ( 3.345 * ProL. S3, 16 2. 3.346 * Quint. 9, 3, 20. 3,348 (I) Sil. 2, 31 , ■ 24 3,364 (F) Quint. 8,6,40. 3,483 (F) Ov. her. 11, 27. 3,381 (F) Quint. 8,6, 66. 3,484 (I) Pro*. ult .syll. IV. 247 K. 3,382 (F) Pro*. 63,21 Z. 3,499 (F) (Pro*.ult t syll . IV, 249 Z. (Colum. 7, 3, 10. 500 (I)( 3,384 * 385 (I)( 3,514 (I) Pro*. ult. syll. IV, 253 K. 3,386 ♦Pro*. ult. syll. IV. 239 Z. 3,516 (F) Sil. 10,246; 10,2?6» 3,387- >389 * (Colum 7 , 3 , 1 . 3,529 (F) Manil. 2, 851. 390 (I) ( 3,532 (I) Pro*. 82, 17 K. 3,391 (I) (Pro*. 63, 1 II. (I) 392 (F) ( 3,556 Pro*. ult . syll . Iv.251 K. 393 * ( 3,399 (F) Ov. met. 10,125. i 4, 1, ♦(Pro*. 64, 24 Z. 3,406 (I) Pro*. ult. syll. IV. 256 K. 2, (I)( 3,408 (F) Pro*. 63,26 K. 3 ,414-417 * ( Colum. 7,4,6. 418 (I) ( 3,415 (I) Pro*. 63,27 K; Sil. 1, 412. 3,420 (F) (Colum. 7, 4, 6. 421 * ( 422 (I) ( 3,435 (I) Pro* . nit . syll . IV, 251 Z, 3,435-436 * Quint. 9, 3, 21. 3,439 (F) Stat. The*. 1,565. 3.441 (F) (Colum. 7, 5, 5. 442 * ( 443 (I)'( 3.442 (I) Pro*. ult. syl l. IV. 221 Z, 3.443 ( F) ( Colum. 7, 3, 10. 444 * ( 3,453-454 * Colum. 7,5,10. 3,459-460 * Colum 7,5, 10. 4, 2 (M) Pro* . ult . s.vll . IV, 225 K. 4, ,9-12 ♦ Colum. 9. 4, 1. 4 j , 10 (F) (Fest • 14 , 343 D, 11 (I) ( 4, ,10 (F) Pro*. 64 , 29 K. 4, • 11 (F) Pro* . 64 , 30 K. 4, • 14 (F) Pro*. 64 , 31 Z. 4, ,15 * Pro*. 65 , 5 Z. 4, ,20- 24 ♦ Colum. 9 » 5, 4. 4, ,27- 29 ♦ Colum. 9 , 5 , 5. 4, 30 (F) (Pro*. 65 ,11 K. 31 (I) ( 4 ,36 (I) Pro*. ult . syll. IV 4 ,44 (I) Manil • 5, 150. 4 ,53 (F) Manil . 4, 223. 4 ,59 (I) Quint. 8, 6, 18. £5 4,63 * Colum. 9,8,13; Prob. 65, 14 K. 4,70-72 * Colum. 9, 9. 4. 4,76 (M) Val . FI. 2, 539. 4.86 (I) Prob. ult.syll .IV 261 K. 4.87 (I) Hor, cam . 1,28,3. 4,87 * Colum, 9,9, 5. 4,90 * Colum. 9,10,6: 4,90 (i)Sen. apod , 3, 4.94 * Colum. 9,11,2. 4.95 * (Colum. 9, 10, 2. 91 * 93 (I), 92 (F) 4,96-97 * Colum. 9,10,2. 4.99 (F) Ov. met . 4, 461; 4.99 * me t . 4,578. Colum. 9, 3, 2. 4,110-111 Prob. 67,23 K. 4,111 (F) Ov.faat. 1, 415. 4,119 (F) Prop. 5, 5, 61; Ov. met . 15, 708; Mast. 12,31,3. 4,125 (I) Proh. ult.syll .IV, 236 K; Iv, 252 K. 4,129 (I) (F) Sil. 1,237. 4,132 (I) Sen. ke&eJL, 1,7,1. 4,138 (I) Prob. ult.syll . IV, 220 K. 4,147 (F) ( Colum. 10,2,3. 148 (F) ( 4,149 (I) Val. FI. 8, 74. 4,152 * Colum. 9, 2, 4. 4,146 (*) Fest. 12, 272 D. 4,168 (I) Colum. 9,15, 1. 4,168 (F) Colum. 9,15,2 4,172 (I) Manil. 3,436. 4,173 (F) Stat. sil. 3, 1, 130. 4,176 Or) Ov. met . 5, 416; Stat. sil. 1,5,61. 4,185 (i) Prob.ult^syll, IV, 246 Z. 4,209 (M) Stat. |il. 2,1, 137. 4,210 211 (*) (Prob. 66, 1 K. (D( 4,211 (F) Prob. 66, 4 K. 4,212 213 (F).(Sen. filavu 1, 4, 2; dMfifti&i. 114, 23. 4,223 (F) Calp. 2,10; 7, 57. 4,227 (F) Stat. Ach . 1 , 2 . 4, 235(F) Luc. 3, 630; Stat. ThsJSL* 5,402; 9,279. 4,246 247 (F) * (Prob. 68, 1 K. ( 4,257 (M) Sil. 2,221. 4,260 (F) Prob.ult tsyll. IV, 249 K. 4,279 (I) Prob .jolt . syll. IV , 235 Z. 4,286 (F) Sil. 8 , 48 . 4,287 * Prob. 66, 7. 4,310 (I) Prob. cath. IV , 26 K, 4,312 * Prob.ult.syll, IV, 247 K. 4,317 * Prob. 66, 13 K. 4,318 * Prob.ult.8yll.lv, 230 K t 26 4,341 (F)(Prob.9, 26 X. 342 *( 4,358 (I)‘ Prob. ult. syll t Iv ? 236 X. 4,371 (F) (Prob. 68, 9 X. 372 (I) ( 4,380 (F) Ov.met. 7, 246, 4,382 * Prob. 21,25 X. 4,387 ♦ Prob. ult.syll .IY, 256X: Prob. 66,29. 4,390 * (Pro*. 62, 1 X. 391 (I)( 4,398 (I)’ Prob. ult.syll . 17 f 255 X. 4,401 (M) Sil. 3, 6?L 4,408 (F) Pro)?. Inst .art . 17,82 X. 4,414 (F) 7al. FI, 1, 300. 4,420 (I) Prob. ult.syll . 17,262 X. 4,426 (F) Manil . 1, 514. 4,429 * (Prob . 67, 7 X. 430 (I)( 4,437 * ProT3. ult.syl l.I7. 223 X. 4,445 (I) Quint. 9,3,15. 4,449 (F) Sib., 2,3,21.. 4.462 * Prob. 67,10 X. 4.463 *Prob. ult. syll . 17 . 225 X. 4,467 *Prob. ult.gyll .IY ,263 XJ 34 X; Prob. 67. 16 X. 4,471 (F) Manil. 2, 9^11. 4,475 (F) Ov. her. 14, 125. 4,480 (M) Porb. ult.8yll .I7 T 247 X. 4,486 4,508 4,515 4,520 4,535 4,551 4,566 * Pr oh. ult. ayll . 17.262 K, (I)Proh. ult.e y ll . 17, £30 X. (F) 7al. FI. 6, 726 (F) Prob, , 67, , 19 X. (F)' Prob, . 67, , 21 X. (F)' Sil. 13, 431. (I)' Prob, ,ult , , syll.X ; < A E N E I D 1, 1 (I) Per. sat . 1,96; Sen.ep.iit. 113, -25; Quint. 9, 3, 52. 1, 1 (F) Proto ,cath. IV, 41 K; Quint. 1, 25, 27. 1, 1 * Quint. 11, 3, 36, 1, 2 3 * (Hyg. 531 F. (I) ( 1. 2 (I) Pr oft . ult . ay 11 . I V , 259 K; Quint. 1, 5, 18. 1, 2 3 (F) (Quint. 11, 3, 37. (I) ( 1, 3 (M) Pr oto . ul t . syll . I V , 264 Kj Quint. 9, 3, 52; Quint. 11, 3, 34. 1, 3 w Sil. 7, 474. 1, 5 (I) Quint. 9, 3, 52. 1. 6 (I) Proto .ult . syll . IV . 253 K. 1, ? (F) Luc, 3, 90; 3, 99; 3,298 Q.uint. 11.3,38; St at. sil. 4,4, 14; JLll* 5 ,2,168; Sil. 1,309; 1, 608; 3,182; 3 , 509 ; 17 , 353. 1,10 (I) Proto. ult .syll. IV f 253 K. 1,15 * Proto. 10, 17 K. 1,16 (F) Proto .ult . syll . IV .23 OK; IV, 259 K, 1,17 (M) Val . FI. 4, 346. 1,19 ♦ Pr oto .ul t , syll . IV . 244 K. 1,19 20 * ( (IX Quint, 9, 3, 14. 1,19 (F) Stat.sil. 5, 3, 111. 27 . ,25 26 (I) (Stat.Thel3.5, 645-646. (DC > ,27 (I) Sil. 7. 465. ,28 (I) (p) Val.Fl. 2, 573. o CO (F) ProTa. Cath.IV, 28 K. co to ♦ Quint. 8, 5, 11. co co (F) Sil. 1 , 28. . ,25 (I) Ov, aet.l, 132; Val.Fl. 1, 760 • ,36 (F) Ov.met . 7, 842. ,37 (F) ProTa . ins t , art . IV, 145 K, ,38 (I) ProTa .ult .syll. IV, 251 K, ,41 (I) Quint. 1, 5, 18. ,42 (F) Ov.metjL 6, 696; M/tPPl Stat.TSefr 7, 150; Sil. 12, 628. ,43 (F) Ov, net. ll,433;trist 1, 4, 5 ; t r i s t . 4, 4, ex P. 2, 3, 27. .♦ 57; 1,43 ( I) ProTa .ul t . syll . IV, 253 K. 1,46 (i)Yal. FI. 3, 326. 1.46 (F) (Ov.met.3 ,265^266. 47 (I) ( 1.47 (I) Sil. 12, 693. 1.48 (F) Quint. 9, 2, 10. 1,53 -54* Sen.nat .6.18.14. 1.53 (F) Val.Fl. 1, 667. 1.54 (M) Val.Fl. 1, 602. 1 * 5 5 6 SSn * nat * 6 » 18 » 1 • 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 t < t < ♦ 28 1,58 * Pro~b.ult.syll. IV, 255 X. 1,58 (F) Pro*. 15, 26 X. 1,58 (I) Pro*. 19, 7 X. 1,60 (M) Val. FI. 2, 117, 1,61 (I) Val. FI. 1, 509. 1,62 (M) Val, FI. 1, 592. 1,62 (F) Sil. 15, 75. 1,65 (I) Pro* , ult . syll . IV, 229 Xj 4,232 X, 1,65 (F) Quint. 0, 6, 29. 1 , 67 (F) Quint. 9, 3, 17. 1,71 (I) Pro* . uit x s.yll . IV ,232. 1,73 (F) Pro*, oath. IV, 38 X. 1,78 (I) Quint. 11, 3, 176. 1 , 81 82 83 (F) (Quint. 8, 4, IS. * ( (I)( 1,82 (f) Juv, 4, 10, 218. 1,84 (F) Stat.The*^ 1, 228. 1,85 86 1 * (Sen.nat. 5, 16, 2. (I)( 1,87 Qv.met . 11, 495. 1,90 (F) Sil. 1, 135. 1.93 (F) (Ov. met. 9, 175; (met. 5, 639; (trist. 1,11,21; (Val. FI. 1, 80: ( Val • FI. 4, 473: (Stat.The*. 1, 497: (The*. 10,336; (sil.. 3, 4, 99. 1.94 (M) T i* , 3, 3, 26. , 94— 95 * (Sen. epist. 67, 8. 96 (I) ( , 94 (M) ( Sil . 9, 159; (Mart. 1, 103, 6. ,95 (I) Pro*. ult . s.yll . IV, 233 X. (I) Pro*.ult.syll.IV,229 X. ,100 (M) Sil. 3,474. ,101 (I) Sil. 4,542. ,102 (I) Sil. 4, 649. ,102 (F) Sil. 7 , 573 ; 10,205, ,103 00 Luc. 1, 416. ,109 * Quint. 8, 2, 14. ,113 (I) (M) Qv.met. 14, 241. ,114 (I) 9 Pro* .ult . syll , IV, 234 IV, 259 X. Kj ,114 (F) Val. FI. 8, 373. ,120 * Pro*. ins t. art . IV, Si X, ,122 (M) Pro* .oath. IV, 10 X, ,126 (I) Pro* .ult . syll . IV, 261 X. ,127 (F) Qv.met. 5, 487. ,129 (F) Sil. 1, 25 1; 12,530. ,132 ♦ Pro* . ins t .art . IV. 145 X. ,135 * Quint. 9, 2, 54. ,136 * Pro*. inst .art. IV f 149 i X ,137 (I) Just. 2, 13, 7. ,142 (F) Ov.met. 11. 432. ,146 (F) Qv.met.. 12, 94. ,148 (I) Pro*. ult. syll. IV. 248 X, 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 ml 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 < < ( l < t ( ( t < « ( * « < 29 1 , 149 (F) Prob.cath. IV, 21 K; 1,211 (F) Prob.inst.art.IV, 125 £ nom, exc. IV, 208 K. 1,211 (I) Prob . ins t .art , IV . 127 K. 1,150 (?) Ov.metj. 15, 471, 1,214 (?) Qv.met. 3, 438. 1,150 (M) St at, Theb , 5, 695. 1,217 (?) Sil. 10, 402. 1,151- 153 * Quint . 12 , 1 , 27 , m 1,218 (I) Luc. 6, 419; Val. FI. 7, 1,153 (?) Val , ?1. 4, 358. 211 ; 192 ; St at iS.il.. 2,2,125. 1,158 (?) Ov. met . 14, 77, 1,220 (?) Prob. inst.art. IV, 64 £. 1,162 (?) (Quint . 8 , 6 , 68 . 1,223 (I) Manil. 1, 914; Val. FI. 163 (X) ( 1, 350. 1,166 (a) Stat. sJJL. 2, 2, 16. 1,224 (?) Ov. , et . 2 , 179 : Manil. 1, 536. 1,167 (?) 0 v . met . 5 , 317. 1,225 (?) Val. FI. 2, 88; 1,177 (I) Quint . 8 , 6 , 23 , 1,227 (F) 0 v • unij.affij. 25 9 ; 1,178 (I) Prob . app . IV , 195 K, Luc. 1, 272; 3, 52; 3, 161; Val. FI. 5, 281; 1,183 (I) Prob ,ult , 8yll . IV, 227 K. Stat .sil. 2 , 1 , 71; sil. 5, 1, 77: 1,190 (F) (Prob .nom. exc , IV , 208 K. Theb. 2, 333; ( Theb. 8. 606; 12 , 514; 1 , 191 * ( Sil. 4.92; 5, 370; 8, 152; 11, 287; 15, 19; 13 ,263. 1 , 194 (F) Pr ob . c ath. I V , 36 K. 1,232 (?) Stat. Theb. 3, 153. 1,197 (F) Val .FI . 1, 29S . 1 ,242 (M) (?) Val. ?1. 5, 552. 1,198 ♦ Prob.ult.syll.IV, 231 T T 1,245- -246 * Sen.nat. 3, 1, 1. 1,201 (?) Sil. 14. 514. 1,245 (M) Val. FI. 3, 588. 1,203 (?) (Sen. e^sit .78,15: (Val. FI. 1, 249; 1,253 (I) Prob .cath. Iv , 16 E. (Stat. Theb. 1, 473. 1,259 w Ov. met, 7, 580. 1,204 (I) Jus t • 3 , 4 , 11 . 1,261 (I) Val. FI. 4, 578. 1,204 (?) (Luc . 5 , 557; (Val, FI. 1, 217; 1 ,262 * Prob. ult . syll. iv . 250 K. (Stat, Theb . 8, 37, 1,265 (?) Val. FI. 6, 115. 1,207 (M) (?) (Luc. 5, 324; - zCStat. Theb . 1 , 691 9 1,279 (F) Prob.inst.art.IV. 83 K. 1,209 (I) Stat .sil. 5, 1, 160. 1,279 (?) (Prob. 19, 15, K. 280 * ( ( ( t t c t r i < < ( t i c c < < ♦ * 30 1,279 (I) Sulp.sat. 34. 1,282 (F) Calp . 4, 8. 1,282 * Mart. 14, 124, 1. 1,286 (I) Just. 15, 4, 14. 1,238 (F) Mart. 6, 3, 1. 1,289 (F) Just, 24, 6, 1. 1,291 (M) (F) Hor. ep&s-t . 2. 1 .93. 1,310 (F) Ov. met. 9, 211. 1.312 (F) Proh.ins t .art .IV, 125E 1.313 (M) Sil. 8, 372. 1,318 (F) Ov.zg.et. 2, 440. 1,321 (I) Val.Fl. 7, 217. 1,324 (I) Manil • 5, 329. 1,327 * ( Sen. epist . II 5, 5, 328 (I) ( 1,330 * Sen. epi st . 115, 5. 1,333 (F) Val . FI. 2, 603. 1,335 (F) {Dv. mot . 1, 194; met. 8, 559; met . 3.3 , 949; quint. 11, 3, 70. 1.341 (F) (Prob. eath .IV. 10 K. 342 (I) ( 1.342 (F) Sen. epist . 89, 17. 1.343 (F) Ov. met. 5, 129. 1,350 (F) Pro'b.apii. IV, 196 Z. 1,365 (I) Quint. 1, 5, 43. 1,369 * Quint. 9, 2, 7. 1,372 (I) Proh.ult. syl 1 . I V , 219 229 II. 1,382 w Manil. 1 , 62. 1,386 w Val. FI. 7, 8 . 1,397 (F) Ov. a&l*. 4 1 616; Sil. 1, 589. 1,399 ( F) Quint. 9, 3, 75. 1,403 (F) Sil, 7, 469; 15, 23. 1,407 (I) Pro'b.ult . svll . IV, 250 1 ,417 (I) Proh.cath, IV, 29 K. 1,418 (I) Ov.met . 2 , 158. 1,432, 433 (F) (Sen. epist. 84 . 3. * ( 1,433 * Fe st. 12, 272 D. 1 , 443(F) Val.Fl. 6 , 650; Stat. ffhefr. 5, 445, ■e* r — i (M)- Val.Fl. 1 , 27. 1 ,443- 449 * ProTa, 9, 29 K. 1,451 (F) Ov. trist . 3, 5, 43, 1,458 * Sen. epist. 104 f 32* 1, 461 462 (I) (Val.Fl. 1. 723-724 (U) ( 1,438 (F) Ov. met. 12, 73. 1,477 (I) Quint. 7, 9, 7. 1,481 ( F) Ov. ars. am, l r 535: met. 5, 475 ;met , 10,723; her. 10, 15. 1 ,483 * Proh .ult . syll . IV f 23 e K, 1,485 w Ov. mot. 10, 402. 1 ,495 (I) Val. FI. 5, 96. K: 31 1 ,499 (I) Prob.ult.Bvll. IV, 259 X; 1,507 -608 * Prob.§, 8 X. IV, 253 X. 1,617 (I) Quint. 11, 3, 175. 1,501 (f) Ov. met. 3, 182;trist. 1, 2, 49; Val. FI. 1,317. 1,627 (F) Val. FI. 1, 797. 1 ,503 (I )(F) Val • FI. 8, 448. 1,631 (I) (Val. FI. 2, 649-550 632 (1)00 1,511 (F) (ProT3.nom.exc. IV. 210 II. 512 (I) ( 1 , 632 (F) Sil. 7, 90. 1,514 (F) Val. FI. 7, 344. 1,638 (F) Val. FI. 2, 341; 4, 750. 1,520 (F) Stat , sil .5 , 5 , 49 . 1,639 (I) Ov. Met. 3, 158. 1,529 (I) (F) Val. FI. 3, S9S. 1,643 (a) Prob. inst. art. IV, 74X 1,532 (I) ProT). ult . syll . IV. 220 X. Val. FI. 2, 2. 1,535 * Prob .ult . sjrll . IV, 359 X. 1,644 (F) Pr 0 T 3 .inst.art.lv, ai X. 1,545 (F) Val. FI. IV, 752. 1,649 (F) ProTs.cath.IV, 30 X. 1,559 (F) Sil. 16,644. 1,650 (I) Prob .nom. exc . IV , 213 X. 1,561 (M) S tat , Ach. 1 , 95 . 1,653 (I) Proh. alt. syll. IV ,223 X ( 1,563 (H) Val. FI, 2, 33. 1,655 (F) Ov.me t . 13, 704. 1,566 (F) Val. FI. 6, 739; 1,661 (F) Sil. 2, 56. Sil. 2, 353. 1,663, (M) (F) Val. FI. 7.171. 1,569 (I) Prot), ult. syll. IV, 252 X. 1,669 (I) Prob .ult^syll.IV, 260X. 1,569 (F) Sil. 1, 70. 1,631 (I) Prob. ult . syll. IV, 254 X, 1,574 (M) Val. FI. 4, 296. 1,689 (I) Prob ,cath. IV, 36 X. 1,578 (I) ProTp. ult. syll, IV, 251 X. 1,691 (F) Sil. 6, 97. 1,538 (F) Stat. Theb. 5, 267. 1,701 (F) Val. FI. 1, 254. 1,589 (I) ProTp.ult.syll.IV, 226 K. 1,730 (M) Val, 1, 210. 1,593 (M) Prob . inst .art • IV . 145 X-: IV, 146 X. 1,730 (I) oil, 1, 88. 1,594 (I) Val. FI. 3, 492. 1,736 (F) Sil. 7, 750. 1,595 (F) Prob .ult .syll . IV, 254 X. 1,742 (F) Quint, 1, 10,10. 1,597 (F) Val. FI. 5, 278. 1 , 748 (F) Ov. met . 12, 159. < *• t 32 2, 1 (I) Quint, 1, 5,43. 2, 8 (M)OV.Past. 2, 635; Stat .IBheb . 10 , 1 , 2,9 (F) Val. FI. 3, 33. 2, 10 (M) Luc. 1, 21. 2, 12 * (Plin. epist.6, 20.1. 1 2-13 (X) 2,14 (M) Ov. t r ist .. 4,10,27. ? , 15 (F) Val. FI. 2, 53. 2,15 (P) (Quint. 8, 6, 34. 16 (I)( 2,20 * Prob . ul t . syll . IV f 230 E. 2,25 (l)Prob.ult.syil,IV,242 E. 2,27 (M) St at . Theb. 1, 616. 2,29 (P) Qv.her . 1, 35. 2,29 * Quint. 9, 2, 37. 2,34 (F) Val.Pl. 8, 174. 2,35 (I) Prob.ult .syll. IV, 227 E. 2,39 * Prob .non . exc . IV f 208 K. 2,39 (M) Stat. Theb, 5. 147. 2,40 (I) Sen. cont. 7, 5, 9, 2,40 (P) Val.Pl, 5, 342. 2,42 (M) Luc. 1, 8. 2,44 (F) Potron . sat .39 .3 . 2,48 (F) (Prob.inst.art. IVJ145 E. 49 (I)( " e/ Cdtr> • 4, tx < 2,49 (F) Calp.12, 2. 2,51 Prob*ja£fiUJLXSL. IV, 207 K. 2,57 (F) Stat. Theb. 12, 677; Stl. 1, 450 ; 16,72. 2,61 (F) Sen. vita beata 8. 3 . 2,61 (F) Val . FI. 6, 756. 2,52 (F) Luc. 4, 165. 2 , S9 (I) Prob.ult. syll . IV. 227 IV, 256 E. 2,69 70 ffil Val. FI. 3,304. 2,69 70 * (Quint. 9, 2, 9. (I)( 2,71 72 (F) ( (I) ( Prob.inst.art.IV. 149 2,74 (F) Ov. me t . 13, 31; met. 5, 85; Stat. sil.5, 2, 17. 2,77 (M) Phaed. 3, 27. 2,81 (P) Ov.raet,. 15, 497; 5 , 25 6 ; 9 , 8 J 7, 694; ars am. 2, 449; Fast, 3,661; ex. P. 2 , 9 , 3 . 2,87 (I) Prob , ins t . art . IV, 83 E 2 t 94 (F) Just. 35, 2, 1, 2,97 CM) Just. 17, 1, 15. 2,98 (F) Val. PI. 3, 602-603. 2,99 (P) Prob .noin, exc . IV , 208 E 2,101(1) Sil. 6, 110. 2,104(1) Quint. 9, 3, 11. 2 , 108 ( 1 ) Prob.ult . syll . IV, 249 K, 2,113 (F) Ov. rae t . 1, 269. t, c ( ( ( < l * 4 ( l c t ( ( t ( ( t < ( < < ( t c < t ( < t 33 2,114 (F) Ov. met. 13, 677; 15, 631. 2,122 (F) Stat. ! Ac h . 1 , 493. 2,123 (F) Ov. met . 6, 542* 2 ,123 (a) Yal. FI. 4, 144. 2,125 (F) Manil. 5, 348. 2 , 130 (F) Hor. sht . 2, 1, 23. 2,132 (I) Hor. sat . 1, 5, 20. 2,132 (F) Ov. met . 13, 454. 2,132 (I) Luc, 1,233; Stat. sil. 3, 1, 55, 2,137 w Yal. FI. 5, 551. 2,141 (I) Hor. op is t . 1 , 7 , 94, 2,143 (?) (ProTDult.syll.lv. 23510. 144 (I) ( 2,147 (F) Stat. Ach. 1, 79. 2,154 (I) Prob .ult . svll . Iv . 223 K. 2 , 157 (I) Luc. 10, 194;State. sil 2, 1, 82. 2 , 158 (?) Ov. met, 11, 184. 2 181 (F) Val. FI. 2, 501. 2,197 (I) Prob Jult . syll . IY . 222 K 2,198 (?) Ov. me t . 12, 37; 13, 182; Sen. Troafa . 708; Luc, 9, 32; Stat. Ach. 1, 34; Sil. 3, 229; 11,586. 2,202 (F) Ov. met. 15.114; her . 7, 113. 2 ,204(1) Pr oh . ult . syll.IV.257 K 2,209 (F) Ov. met. 14, 459. 2,237 (?) Ov. her. 6, 45. 2.241 * Prob.ult_..B2rll.IV,231 K, 2.242 * Prob.ult .s yll .IV,247 K. 2,242 (E) Val . PI. 1, G76; 7, 3 82; Stat . The b . 8, 56; 10, 652; 11 ,339; 12 , 553; Sil. 7, 49; 13,73. 2,248 * (Proh . norn . exc , IY , 210 K, 249(1) ( 2,255 (F) Yal. FI. 2, 288; Stat. Theb. 2, 50, 2,257 (I) (M) Yal. FI. 6, 205. 2,262 (I) Quint, 8, 3, 84. 2.264 (F) Prob.ul t.syll . 17,244 K. 2.265 (F) Just. 43, 4, 8. 2,268 (I) Hor. carm . 1, 37,4. 2,268-269* Quint. 8, 6, GO. 2,274 ) F) (Pr oh . i ns t , art . IY 1 246 £ 2,274 (M) Prob.ult .syll , IV ,253 K. 2.277 (F) Ov, met . 14, 201; Yal. FI. 3, 286. 2.278 (I) Stat. That. 3, 364. 2,297 (?) Man i 1 . 4, 243. 2,302 (I) Ov. . 13, 111. 2, 307 (I) (Quint. 8, 6, 10. 30S * ( 2,309 (M) Luc. 1, 524; Stat. Thefo . 6 , 838. 2, 311(F) (Quint. 8, 6, 25. 312(1) ( c I 34 2,313 (F) Luc. 1, 237. 2.322 (I) Pro~b.ul t.s yll. IF , 350 K. 2.323 (I) X M) Val. FI. 1, 240. 2.332 * Pro~b.u lt.s yll. IT, 363 K, 2.333 (F) Stat .Theb.10, 774; 9, 542. 2,337 (F) Ov. he r. 6, 45 . 2,350 (I) Yal. FI. 4, 47. 2.354 (*) Ssn.nat , 6, 2, 2. 2.355 (F) (Quint. 8, 3, 72; 356 (I)(G, 3, 73. 2,435-435 * Quint. 9, 3', 35. 2,442 XF) (Pron . ins t . art . IY, 96 K. 443 (I) ( 2.456 (F) (Pro!) . inat . art . IV. 127 K, 457 (I) ( 2,459 (F) St at .fEeb*, 11, 100. 2.457 (M) Yal, FI. 3, 72. 2,459 (M) Yal. FI. 1, 709. 2,471 (Iff) Sil. 8, 498. 2,476 (I) Prob . ult . svll . IV T 225 Z. m2, 477 (I) Prol).^lt A syll.jY,224 E. 2,3 50 (P) Sil , 9 , 45 . 2,490 (p) Ov.raei. 4, 141; 2,369 (p) Ov. am. 2, 9, 41; met. 10, 726; tr ist . 1, 11, 23. Luc . 6 , 565; Prob, IY, 96 E; Stat.Theb. 12,27; Sil. 11, 331. 2,376 CD Yal. FI. 1, 722. 2,493 (p; Ov. axi. 1, 6, 49. 2,391 392 (P) (Stat.a4i.9. 107-133. (M) ( 2,494 (I) Sen. apis t. 37, 10. 2,397 (M) (F) Manil, 1 , 716. 2,497 (p) Prob. ult.syll . I y , 2 64 2,406 (p) Yal. FI, 2, 469, 2,498 (p) Ov. hal. 81. 2,407 (I) Yal. FI. 5,549; 2,493 Cm) Yal. FI. 3, 85. 2,374. 2,504 (p) Ov, met. 7, 156. 2,407 (M) S t a t . Theb . 1 , 505, 2,506 (i) Prob. ult. sill. IY,247 2,407 2,414 (M) (®) (F) Sil. 2, 210. Pr o~b . inat . art . IY . 54 K; 2,512 514 (I) (Mart. 3, 51, 6. (P) ( ult.syll. IY?221 Z. 2,514 (I) Prob .app. Iy f 196 14, 2,415 (P) Ov.met . 6 . 310; grist . 1, 2, 25, 2,518 (F) Sil. 2, 312. 2,428 (I) Sen.cpist. 98, 4, 2,532 (P) Ov. met . 2, 310. 2,430 (I) Pro~b.ult.syll. IY, 225 K. 2,540 541 (Quint. 5, 11, 14. t ( ( 35 2, 553(F) Sen. sueb, 4, 4. 2,554 ( I) Prob . in at . ar t . 17 „ 124 X; n ora . exc .17,210 X. 2,55? (F) Man i 1 . 4, 64. 2,5 60 (I) Prob.ult . syll . IV f 238 X. 2,560 (F) 7al.Fl. 1, 712. 2,564 (F) Prob. app . 17. 1S6 X. 2,336 (F) Sil. 16, 123. 2,590 ( F) (Prob . 14, 11, X. 591 * ( 2,693 (I) Prob. ult . sy 1 1. 17,338 X. 2,699 (I) Prol3. ult .syll. 17,250 X. 2,699 (F) Stat. Theb. 1, 295. 2,703 * Prob. 14, 14 X. 2,595 2,597 (F) (F) 7al. FI. 6, 444. Prot.ult.syll. 17,248 *rr , 2,704 (F) 7a 1. FI. 7, 203; Stat.Achi. 1, 539. 17, 251 X. 2,707 (I) Prob.ult. syll. 17,252 ~K. 2,603 . 509 (F) (I) (7al.Fl. 4, 659-660. ( 2,716 ( 8) Ilian i 1.3, 65 8. 2,519 w Ov .me t . 6, 240. 2,717 (F) Ov. her. 3, 67. 2,624 (I) Pro~b.ult.syll. 17,223 X. 2, 724(F) Sen. lud . 1, 2. 2,634 2,634 * (I) Prob. ult ..syll. 17,224 I Prob. ult . syll .17,246 *. * X. 2,725 2,725 (F) (I) Prob .ult . syll , 17,243 X. Prob. ult. svll. Iv. 254 X: 7al . FI. 4, 198. 2 , 638 w Stat . sil. 2, 6, 46. 2,726- 729 ♦Sen. opis t . 56, 12. 2,645 (F) Sen. rem. 5 , 1 , 1 , 2,729 (X) Sen. epis t . 56, 13. 2,547 (F) Mart. 2, 110, 3. 2,735 (X) Sil. 1, 512. 2 , 65 3 (X) Ov. met. 7, 172. 2,737 (F) 7a 1 » FI. 2, 43. 2,661 (F) Ov.rnet. 1, 562; Sil. 11, 187. 2,738 (X) Prob . inst . art . 17 1 146 X. 2,662 (I) 7al. FI. 2, 147. 2,755 (F) 7al . FI. 2, 40. 2,664 (I) Prob.ult . syll . 17,222 X. 2,758 (I) Ov. met. 9, 202; Luc. 9, 742; 2,566 (r) Prob .utl . syll . Iv , 254 K. Stat . Theb . 12, 430. 2,670 (F) Hor. sat . 2, 8, 34. 2, 772 (X) 7al . FI. 2, 206, 2 ,576 (X) 7 a 1 . FI. 7, 452. 2,774 (M) Ov.raet. 7. 631. 2 , 683 (I) Prob. nom.exc. Iv ,215 X • 2,774 2,777 (i) (M) Prob.ult . syll. 17, 259 X. 7al.Fl, 2, 48. 36 2.779 (F) Mait • 14, 175 . 2.780 (M) Val. FI. 2, 375. 2,7 81 (I) Prob.ultiS.yll, IV, 262 K. 2,7 85 (I) Prob.ultiSyll.IV,247 E. 2,781. (F) Ov, fast. 5, 375. 3, 3 (I) Prob . ul t . syll. IV, K. 3, 7 (F) Ov. met . 1. 307. 3,14 (I) Stat. The b. 5, 53. 3,16 (F) OV. fast. 3, 469; Val. FI, 1, 275, 3,22 (I) Prob .ul t « s.yll . IV, 343 E. 3,29 (F) (quint. 8, 3, 70. 30 * ( 3,44 (F) Prob.insJbj 5 .art.lv,! 85 E. 3,52 (M) Just. 14, 6, 5. 3,55-56 *( Quint. 9, 3, 25. 57 (I) ( 3,55 (M) Prob.ult .8yll .183 E. 3,57 (F) Ov. met . 10 , 56. 3,57 (F) (Quint. 9, 2, 10. 58 (I)( 3.71 (I) Problult.s yll .IV, 255X. 3.72 (F) Sen. ©joist .170 ,’ 1, 1. 3,77 * Sen. nat. 6, 26, 3. 3,81 (F) Tib, 3, 4, 23; Yal. FI. 1, 278. 3,83 (I) Prob .ult.syll. IY.338 E. 3,35 (F) Luc. 1, 345, 3,91 (I) Prob.ult.syll.lv, 257 E. 3,94 (F) Sll. 2, 173; 14,290. 3,125(1) Prob . cat h. IV . 31 K, 3,127(1) Prob, ul t . s yll . IV, 231 E, 3, 128(1) (F) Sil.ll, 438. 3, 141(F) Stat. Sll . 3, 1, 54; Mart. 4, 66, 13. 3,142 *Prob. ul t. syll . IV ,225 E, 3,145 ( F) Prob . ult. syll . IV, 246 K. 3,147 ( I) Prob. ult. syll . IV, 221 E; IV, 256 E; IY, 227 E. 3,152 ( F) Prop • 1, 3, 31; 0 v . e.x _ JP 3 , 3 , 5 . 3. 175 (F) Ov. me t . 9, 173. 3,183 (I) Prob. ult . s yll. IV . 233 Z. 3,193 (F) Quint. 12, praef. 4. 3,199 (F) Ov. met . 6, 696; 8, 399. 3.201 (M) Yal. FI. 8, 175 . 3.202 (?) Ov. rem. am. 577, 3,202 * Prob. cath. IY, 25 E. 3,207 (I) Ov. fast. 3, 585. 3.210 (F) Man i 1 . 5, 646. 3.211 (I) Prob.ultiSy.il. IV, 25 8 E. 3.212 (I) Prob . ul t ._syll . I V, 257 K. 3,214 ( F) ( Yal . FI. 7, 333--3S4. 215 (I)( 3,225 * Prob. ult.s yll.IV, 255 E. 3,234-235 *Quint. S, 3, 64. 37 3,236 (I) Pr ot . cath. IV , 21 K. 3,335 * Prot. 26, 30,11. 3,238 (I) Pr ot . ul t . s.yll . I V , 252 T T - - # 3,33 8 (F) Ov. fast. 3,621. 3 , 241 (M) (F) Fest. 13, 317 D. 3,346 (I) Prot.ult. syll. IV, 225 IC. 3 , 268 (I) Profit .syll. IV. 260 3 i ' n o<\ c. 3,351 (F) Val. FI. 1 : , 676,. 3,271 * Prot ,ult . syll , IV, 226 H. 3,354 * Ver. FI. 521 F. 3,274 (F) °v. jnet_, 6, 311; 8,797. 3,354 (I) ProblUltiSyll , IV, 263 IC. 3,277 (I) Sen. ejoi.st.53, 3. 3,35 6 (M) Val. FI. 5, 276. 3 , 277 (F) Luc . 2 , 649 ; S tat . sil. 5, 1, 242. 3,367 (I) Fest. 13, 317 D. 3 , 281 (M.) Ov. trist. 3, 12, 21, 3,368 (i) Val. FI. 5, 617. 3,282 (F) ( Sen. ey ist , 104, 10. 3,36 9 (F) Manil . 1, 317. . 283 * c 3,374 (I) Ov. me t . 15, 435, 3 , 283 (F) Val . FI. 1, 438. 3,375 (M) Luc. 1, 524. 3,285 (I) Ov. met . 2, 30. 3,382 * P r o t . ul t . syll , I v , 23 SIC. 3, 235 (F) Ov.am.2 ,11 , 27 ; Luc. 8, 195. 3,3 04 *Prot, inst . art . IV f 149 IC, 3,292 293 # (F) (Prot.ult .syll. Iv.227 (I)( II. 3,385 3,389 (I) Prot. 17, 12 K. ♦Prot.inst. art, IV, 149 Z. 3,295 (I) Ov. met . 13, 99 j Fr , inst.art . 17, GO X. 4,596 (I) Ppgb.ult. syll. 17,252 X. 5 , 162 ♦(Sen. Sllfc+xSsx&xxS* ) 163(1) (Tsenef . 6, 7. 5, 1 , * (Petr on. sat. 68, 4. 5,163 (DProTa. ult. syll. 17,239 X. 2 Cl) C ' 5,165 (F)7al. FI. 1, 120. 5, 1 11) Pro's .ult . syll . 17 , 25 0 X, 5 ,165 (F) Pro*b . ins t . art . 17 , 31 X. 5, 5 (F) Ov. ars am. 2, 519. 5,169 ( I) Prolj. ins t . ar t • 17 , 80 X. 5 ,13 (I) P r o b . ul t . syll. 17,247 2 • 5,173 (FiProB , inst.art . 17,81 X. 5 , 13 (M) Quint. 3, 3, 25 . 5,182 (M) 7al . FI . 2, 25. 5 , 14 (F) 7al . FI. 7, 472 ; St at . sil 2, 2, 26. 5,184 (F)PBrTj. inst.art .17.80 X. 5,15 (F) Ov. dfis am. 2, 731. 5,207 (F) 7al . FI. 5, 28. 5,26 (I) Sil. 7, 474. 5,212 (F) Quint. 7, 9, 10 . 5,35 (M) 7al . FI. 4, 381. 5,214 (F) ProB .nom, exc. 17,209 X, 5,56 (I) 7al. FI. 5, 254. 5 , 228 (M) (F) Ov. ars am. 3,375. 5,230 (?) Stat. Theh. 1, 319. 5,235 (I) Val. PI. 1, 667. 5 , 240 (F) Quint. 9, 3, 10. 5,256 (M) Val. FI. 1, 80. 5,254- -265 * Quint. 8, 4, 25. 5,266 (F) Ov.her. 3, 31. 5,256 267 (F) (Hyg. fah. 273. (I)( 5,267 (F) Sil. 2, 432. 5,291 (F) Tib . 4, 1, 83; Oy.rnet .4,303; Manil. 1, 396; Val. FI. 3, 548. 5,295 (F) Ov.ars am. 3,557. 5,298 (F) Proh.ult.syll.IV.324 5,304 (F) Ov. ars.am. 1 , 267 ; ih. 69. 5,310 (F) Sil. 16, 447. 5,310 311 (M) (Hyg. f ah. 273; (II) ( 5.314 (?) Calp. 3, 18, 5 ,319 (F) Quint. 8,6, 69; Sil. 8, 476. 5,320 (F) PI in. epis t . 1 , 20 , 4. 5,334 (F) Ov, tr ist . 5 , 7 , 21 . 5 , 344 (I) Sen, epist . 56, 2. 5,344 (F) Stat. Theh. 6. 573. 5,357 (I) Val. PI. 6, 602. 5 ,361 (?) Ov. ars am. 2. 261. 5,363 * Sen. epis t . 92, 30. 45 . 5,368 (I) Calp . 2, 27. 5,374 (M) Ov. met . 10, 716. 5,376 (I) Val . PI. 1, 434. 5,381 (P) Ov. met. 12, 322. 5,381 (I) Proh . ins t .art . IV , 149 K. 5,381 (P) Val. PI. 4, 243. 5, 39 0 * Proh.ult.syll. IV, 244 IC. 5,396 (I) Stat.Theh., 1, 463. 5,406 * ProTa. ult.Byll .IV ,349 K. 5.409 (P) Val. FI. 6, 496. 5.410 (I) Prol3. cath .IV. 30 K. 5,426 * Quint. 8, 3, 53. 5,426 (P) Stat. Theh . 1, 413. 5,432 * Proh.ult. Byl l.IV. 257 K. 5.435 (F) Stat. Th eh . 1, 418. 5.436 (M) Man i 1 . 5, 603. 5.437 * Prola.ult .syll . IV. 262 IC. 5,455 (F) Stat. Theh . 1, 644; 5, 826; Sil. 2, 575. 5,470 (F) Ov. ne t. 12, 256. 5,480 (F) Stat. Theh, 6, 811. 5, 482(F) Val. FI. 1, 504. 5,504 (F) Prohlul t . syll . IV, 260 IC. 5,520 (M) (F) Ov. niai. 9, 219; 10 , 178 ; 14 , 127 . 5,523 (F) Stat. Theh.. 6, 944. 5,528 (F) Sen. Hat . 1, 1, 5. 1 1 / Co ip- L l ) 595 ( *) Proh . ult . syll. IV, rr wOO xu a 9, 595 (M) Val . Fl. 2, 117. 9 > 598 (I)' Pr oh • ult iS.yll.IV ,24511. 9, 60S (”) Val. Fl. 3, 122. 9, 610 ( F) Hor . sat . o , 2 , 88. 9, 612 (I)' Sen . o t i o 1 , 4 . 9, 514 (F)‘ Val. Fl. 3 , 3 4 o ; Sil. 15, 116; Mar t . 8, 48, 5. 9, 637 (F)' Mart • 9, 13, 7, 9, 641 (?)■ Sen . ftp i s t . 48, 11; 73 , 15 ; Stat. sil. 1, 4 , 48 • 9 . 642 (I)' Sen ♦ con ,15, 1, 9, 653 (i) Pr ch • ult, syll . I V ,243 X 9, 656 (I)' Val . Fl. 7, 225. 9, 659 w Stat . sil. 5, 1, 133. 9, 667 (P)' Val. Fl. 4, 254. 9, 638 (I)' Pr oh . ult .syll. IV ,235 E 9, 669 (I)' Tih. 1, J 9, 699 op Ov. ; br ist . 5 , 2 , ■ 38: m ct . 4 , 6 1 6 « 9 , ?09 (I)' Stat . Ehe h . 5, 527. 9,720 (M)' Val. PI. 1, IQ2. 9,724 (M)' Man i 1 , 2, 929. 9,742 (I)’ Proh . ult . syll . IV ,247 X. 9,744 (F) Val. FI. 3, 193. 9,752 (F)' Sil. 4, 199. 9,754 (F)' Manil. 2. 291. 9, 762 (F)' Sil. 4, 341. 9,767 * 0V. met . 13, 258. 9,770 (II) (Sil. 13, 246-247. 771 (M) ( 9.773 (I)' Prolp. inst.art . IV, 184 X, 5.773 (F) Quint. B, S, 12; Sil. 1, 411. 9,777 (I)' Proh. ult . evil . IV t 250 X. 9,798 ( F) Stat. The) b. 11, 297. 9,810 ( F) (Luc. 6, 192. 811 ( 1 )’ ( 9,314 (l) Proh . ul t « . eyll . IV. 324 E. 10,1* Quint. 1, 4, 28j 9, 4, 49. 10,2 (J)' Ov. met . 1, 167; Val. FI. 2, 313. lQ,5 (I) Proh. ult .syll . IV f 253 E. 10,18 *Pr oh. ult. syll . IV r 222 X. 10,18-19 *Proh. ult syll. IV, 222 X. 10,23 (F) Ov. met . 5, 156; her . 18. 141, 5 6 10,63 (I)' Val. FI. 8, 35. 10,265 (F) Ov. rne t . 8, 420. 10,65 (I)' Prols .ult . syll . IV f 239 K. 10,276 (I) ProT). ult. syll. IV. 251 K. 10,51 (I)' St at, Ac'h. 1, 82. 10,230 (I)' Sil. 7. 35. 10,92 (ItProT? 3Lult.syll.lv, 332 K. 10,284 * Sen. enist . 94, 28. 10,92 * Quint. 9, 2, 49. 10,291 ( F) Val. FI. 2, 453. 10,96 (F)Proh.ult .syll. IV. 231 K. 10,308 *Prol3 .ult . syll . IV, 257 K. 10,102 (F) St at « Thels , 9, 30. 1© , 318 (F) Val . FI. 3, 162." 10,116 ( I) Prol; .nom.exc. IV, 21 q IC, 10,324 (F)' Ov. met . 9, 398; 10,12? ) F)' Sil. 10, 196. 12 , 291 ; 13 , 754; Luc. 1 0,135 ; 10,123 (I) Sen. ftuas , 1, 12, Stat. TheT>. 7, 665; Sil. 2, 31S; 7,691; - 1 0 , 132 (iV Val. FI. 4 , 531; 16, 469; Mart. 2,61,1. 3, 257. 10,324 *Prol3 .ult . syll . IV, 250 IC. 10,136 (F) Prop, 3, 7, 49, 10,333 (I) Prol3.inst .art. IV f 183 IC. 10,149 (F) lianil . 3, 95. 10,359 ( DPro'b .ult .syll . IV t 249 IC. 10,151 (M) lianil. 5, 220. 10,361 (M) Ov. met.. 9, 43, 10,1?4 j(M) Hart. 14, 95, 1. 10,362 (I)' Manil . 1, 319. c- £> i — 1 o t-l (F) Luc. 1, 60 6; St at. Thoo . 3,76; 10,368 * Pro”b. app, IV, 195 IC, Sil. 14, 589. 10,381 (F) Luc. 5, 192 ; Sat^Theb . 10 , 199 (I) Pro"b.£&£3l.£ Y i 9 IC. 12,742; Mart. 1,88. 10, 205 (M)' Val . FI, 6, 564. 10,390 (I)'(wy Sil. 2, 533. 10 ,209 (I) Prol3.ult._sfr 11. IV, 224 K, 10,394 (I) Prol3.ult.syll.IV f 252 IC, 10,222 (M) Prob. in st. art. IV, 13 5 .. 10.394 *ProV.ult .sail. IV. 264 IC. 10,225 * Pro’b.ult.syll, IV, 233 K. 10.39? ( I)ProTj ,ult . syll . Iv r 23 IK. 10,239 (I) ProT3.ult.syll.IV, 225 IC 10,406 (F) Sil . 7. 366. 10 , 244 (I) Val. FI. 2, 566. 10,40? (I) Prol3.ult.svli, Iy,232Z 10,263 (I) Prol3.ult.syll. IV ,2jft4 II. 10,421 ( I)Fro‘b .ult .syll . IV, 23 6 K 10,264 (F) Luc. 2, 299; 10,443 (F)' Stat. sil. 5, 3, 216. 3, 98; Stat.PThe-b. 1 , 646 • 1q, 472 (F) Son « c on . 21, 5. t ( ( c < < c 57 10,431 ( I) Pr ob .Jul.tL, JLZl-lj IV , 263 E. 10,409 (F)Sil, 5, 526. 10 ,491*1)' Pro'b .ult . ■ syl JL.IY,231 E. 10 ,502 (M) Mart . lQ ,33 , 9. 10 ,5x0 ( I) ( F) Val . FI. 3, 522. 10 ,511 (M) Yal. FI. 4, 689 ; 3,712. 10 ,515 (F) Prob . nom. oxc . IV , 214E. lc ,523 (M) Yal. FI. 4 5 74-0 . 10 ,527 (M)' Man i 1 . 4 924. 10 ,543 (*) Ov.me t . 3, 543; 1,750 ; 14, 599. 10 ,545 (F) Pro'b. cath. IV, 17 E. 10 , 558 w Yal. FI. 1, 813. o f — ( ,586 (!!) Sil. 8, 281 * o 1 — i ,590 (I) Ov. met. 15 , 524. 10 ,598 (M) Yal. FI. 1, 749. 10 ,600 (M) Yal. FI. 1, 215. 10 ,517 w 0 v . fast . 4 ,239. o rH ,627 (I) Prob. ult .syll. IV, 244E, 10 , 630 * Prob. ult . syll . IV, 251 E. 10, ,630 t lac. ann. 4 , 74, 7. 10, ,638 (I) Sil. 17, 525. 1 0 ; ,649 ( I) Pro'b .ult . syll . IY.229E; 246 Ej 261 E, ; Sil. 17. 542. 10, ,653 (n Yal. FI. 4, 44. 10, , 569 (*)' Yal. FI. 7, 421. 10, ,670 (i)' Pro'b . ul t . syll.IY.237 E; 233 E; 242 10,671 *Pro'b . uIt«syll «IV f 261 E. 10,587 (F) Ov. met. 13, 63 q, 10,688 (F) Ov. trist . 1,2,79; Val. FI. 2, 135. 10,707 ( I) Prob . ult . syll . IV f 246 K; Val. FI. 5, 67. 10,719 (I) Pro'b. iilt. s yll . IV, 262 K, 10,725 (F) Ov. met. 10,538. 10 ,754 (M) Sil. 5, 401. 10 ,786 ( I) Pro'b . ult . axil .. I Y, 262 10 ,779 ( I) Prob . cath . IV , 12 E. 10 ,782 (f) Quint. 6 O 9 w 9 33. o H ,791 (?) Yal. FI. 2, 263. 10 ,811 (F) Manil. 3 , 1. 10 ,819 (I)' Juv, 4, 41. 10 ,230 w. (Yal. FI. 3 , 613. 831 U) f \ lo ,837 (fV Yal. FI. 1, 177. lo ,838 (F) Ov. fast T * - J 259. 10 ,843 (i)' Ov. met. lo , 719. 10 ,0 62 (M) Pro'b. ult . S-Zii .IV, 246 bat . Theb. 1 , 461. lo ,877 w Yal. FI. 5 , 207. o r-t ,892 (F)' Sil. 17, 135 « 11, 7 (I) Pro'b. u lt. syll . IV, 25 ? K, 11,14 (F) Stat. Theb . 6, S3Q. 11,27 (F) Yal. FI. 4, 151. 58 . 11.40 (F) quint. 6, 33, 11.41 (M)'(F)' Ov. met.', 1, 3 5QJ Val.Fl. 7, 258. 11,49 (I) Yal. FI. 7, 203. 11,51 (F)' Stat. sil. 5, 185. 11,53 (I) ProTa.u lt.gy ll.IY, 228 E, 11,71 (F)' Man i 1 . 5, 226. 11,85 (I)' Prol3. ult. syll. IY.237 Kj 242 K. 11.88 (I!) Luc. 8, 375 J Stat .sil*. 3, 1, 35; 4, 6, 78. 11.89 (M) Yal . FI. 2, 386; Quint. 3, 2, 33, 11.90 (F) Stat. LheL. 4, 591. 11,93 *Pro‘b.ul t.s yll.IY,231 K, 11,98 (I) Stat . sil. 3, 3, 209. 11,107 (F) Manil .3 , 6 q3. 11,112 ♦Pro’b. ult .s yll . IV.257 10. 11,118 ( iVProb . ult , Syll . IY . 263 K. 11,133 (FVstat . Theft . 2, 425. 11,135 (F) Sil. 10,529. 11,140 * Prols . ult. g yl l . IV, 221 E, 11.142 (I) Quint. 3, 6, 21. 11.143 (F)' Yal. FI. 1, 842. 11,159 (I)' Ov. met. 13, 521; Mart. 7, 2, 5. 11,166 (M) (IS) Yal. FI. 3, 296. 11,169 *Proft . ult . syll « IV, 252 E. 11,185 (F)' Ov. f ast . 2, 561; Luc. 2, 299; 3,98; Stat^Thoft.S, 81. 11,304 (a)' Luc. 3, 240. 11,214 (mV Yal. FI. 3, 631 . 11,233 •N (I)' Pro!) .ult .syll . IY, 237 11,241 (I)' Yal. FI. 1, 532. 11,254 (i)' Yal. FI. 2, 548. 11,269 (i)' Yal. FI. 2, 375. 11,272 (I)' Pro o. ult . syll. IV. 238 11,277 * ProT). ult. syll. IY, 238 E 11,283 (*) Ov. ars am. 3 r 511. 11,288- 29 0 * Sen. suas . 2, 2©. 11,290 (F) Ov. Met. 13,666 ; Sen. suas . 2, 20. 11,292 (F) Manil. 2, 626; Stat .Theft. 5. 290. 11,293 (I) Vai.Fl. 7, 270. 11,296 (IT)' Stat. Theft. 4. 804. 11,307 (F) S^&t. Theft. 5, 669, 11,315 (F)0V. met. 15, 238. 11,335 (I)' Luc. 5, 46. 11,347 (I’)' Luc. 1, 450. 11 ,357 (F) Ov. fast. 3, 283. 11,383 384 (F)‘ (Proft. ult .syll. IY, 251 * ( 11,383 384 (F) (Quint , 11, 3, 176. (I)'( 11,383 384 385 (F) (Quint . 9 , 2 . 49 . * ( (I)'( 11 ,396 (F)' Sil. 12, 501. 11,406 * Quint. 9, 3, 14. t < < 59 . 11 ,413 ay Stat. sil. 3, 3, 157. 11 ,415 * ProT3. ul t . syll ..IV, 223 E. 11 ,415 ay Sil 653 • 11 ,417 (F) Ov. met . 2, 812. 11 ,418 ay 0 v . met . 9, 61. 11 ,425 (U)(F) Val. FI. 2, 619. 11 ,441 ay Sil . 7, 55. 11 ,467 (*y Sen , fip. i s t . 58 , 4. 11 ,477 ay Pro~b.ui2b.syll . IV, 229 11 ,480 CM) Val . FI . 2, 470. 11 ,498 ay Val . FI • 2, 550. 11 ,507 (M) Val . FI . 5, 220. 11 ,508 ay Pr o~b.uit . . syll . IV. 232 11 ,526 (F) Val • FI. 5, 634. 11 ,538 * P r o ~b . ult . syll .IV, 2 61 K. 11 ,544 P ’ro~b . ult jlS.m 11. I v , 259E. 11 ,581 (F) Stat . ¥he~b . 2, 134. 11 ,589 (M) Ov. met . 6 > 448. 11 ,595 (F) Ov . ar3 am. 1, 43; am . 3,5, 21. 11,597 * Pro-b. ult.6 yll.IV.225 K. 11,300 (F)' Ov^met. 2, 37. 11,308 (I VProb.ul t.s yll.IV, 254 E. 11,617 (F) Sil . 9, 167. 11.623 (F) Sil . 4, 315. 11.624 (FV Luc. 5, 234; 7, 813; Petron. sat . 123, 241; St at . The~b . 7 , 143 ; Sil.l, 197;9,32o; 1^,117; 12 , 44-0 » 11,627 * Pro~b.ult.Byll.lv, 253 X. 11,648 * Prol3. ult.sy ll. IV, 222 E. 11,650 (V)' Val.Fl. 6, 229. 11,654 (F) Man 11. 1, 269 11,660 * Pro~b. ult.syll .lv. 231 E. 11,668 (I)' Val. FI. 6, 555, 11,569 (F)' Sil. 10, 577, 11,679 (F) Stat. She~b . 4, 166. 11,581 (F) Quint. 8, 2, lQ. 11.691 (F) Manil.. 5 , 2Q2. 11.692 (I)' Sil. 1, 381. 11,695 (F) Manil. 1,304. 11,706 CMVProt. ult .syll. 17,261 K. 11,715 (I)' Pro~b. ult .syll. IV, 346E. 11,718 -(F)'Sil. 3, 306, 11,731 (lVProT3.ult.syll.lv, 223 Kj Val. FI. 4, 649. 11,736 (F)'.Ov, am • 1, 9, 45. 11,739 (I)' Ov. met. 14, 634. 11,747 (I)' ProT3. ult. syll. IV, 256E, 11,764 ( I) Pr o~b . ult .syll . I V , 24 6E . 11,784 (F) Val. FI. 5, 212. 11,803 * Pro~b.ult.sy.il . IV, 255 E. 11,818 (F)'(Val. FI. 821-822. 819(1)' ( 11.822 ( I) Pal . V, 541 E. 11.823 (FV (Prob.ul t ,syll . IV.253IC. 824 (I)'( I < ( t < 11,855 (I) Proh ult . s.v ll . IV f 247K. 11 , 090 (D'Prolj. ult.s yll. IV,357E. 11,911 (M)'(F)' Gil. 5, 433. 12, 5 : x - ) G t at . I 1 *! 6.13 • 1 0 , 4 3 9 ; Sil.l, 168. 12.10 (F)Sil. 1, 477. 12.11 (I) Sen. henef. 6, 41,2. 12,13 ( 3?) St at. Ach. 1, 9 q2. 33 (F) Mart. 11, 78 , 91. 43 ( F) Val. FI. 1, 326. 77 (M) Ov. met. 3, 160. 34 * Sen . henef . 7 , 23, 1. 84 (•D Sil. 13, 116 • 12,94 (I)' Proh.cath. IV. 12 E. (_!) £ 100 12,1q 4 (M) Hanil. 4, 50 9. 12,115 (?) Ov. rnet . 2,85. 12,115 (DProl3. ult.sy 11. IV f 224 E. 12,113 (F) ( Sil . 4, 701. 119 ( I) ( 12,120 * Hyg . 533 F. 12,142 (F) Ov. met . 5, 251. 12,159 (I)' Prol3.cath.lv, 12 E; 128 E, 12,154 (I)' Hyg. 532 F; Val . FI. 5, 513; G, 459 . 12,165 (F)' Hanil . 3, 23. 12,167 (?)' Val. FI. S, 485. 60 12,159 (F)' Val. FI. 1, 840. 12,200 (I) Ov. mot . 5, 543; Proh T ult.sy ll . I V , 24 0 & 1 12,208 (F) Quint. 1, 6 , 2. 12,210 (I)' Proh. ult , s yll . IV.346E-. 12,213 (F)' Val. FI. 5, 284. 12,225 (I)' Hanil. : 5, 301. 12,239 (I) Val. FI. 1, 742. 12,24 7 (F) Ov. met . 6, 517; Val. FI. 1, 156 . 12,266 (F) Sil. 4, 134. 12,274 (i)’Proh. nom^exc . Iv , 213 K. 12,28 0 * Pr oh .ul_ti.sy.il . IV, 255 E, 12 ,298 ( I ) Pr oh .ul t . syll .IV ,253 rr 12 ,300 (I) Val. FI , 3, 1 68. 12 ,303 (V Pr oh jJUl t . syll .IV ,231 *rr **■ • 12 ,331 (i’v Proh • ult . syll .IV ,253 t r jX a 12 ,333 (I)' Pr oh lul t syll . iv, 245 TT « li. 9 ^ £1 C j» il , 12 ,342 (a)' Proh . Ill t . s Tr 1 1 ,. IV ,246 rr 12 ,351 (fV Val. rn If X * 5, 259. / 3 CF) M d n. 3„ (, 6 2- 9 ~ i 359 (i)': Proh • ul t .syll. iv, 247 rr 12 ,386 (F) Sil. f* o , 79. 12 ,398 (H)' Val. FI . 3, 229, 12 ,402 (3?)' Ov. met iJL 4, 49. 12 ,403 (I)' Proh . ult . syll .• IV ,247 T 7 * ■U. 12 ,421 w Proh * ult .syll ..IV , 261E. 12 ,424 (F V Val . FI. 5 , 60 2 . I 61 15; ,435 (I)' Stat * all. 5 , o *■' ] , 51. 12 ,438 (F) Hor. sat . 1 , 9, 34. 12, ,445 (i)Proh. ult . syll . lv, ,261 X 12; ,449 ( I)Pr oh . 11 t . syll . , 238Z. t 2 J ,455 (M)Manil . 5, 327 « 12, ,455 (I) Proh • ult , syll . 17,233 ! 12, ,466 (M)'7al. FI. 6, 577. 12.432 (I)' Ov. met . 3, 52. 12.433 ( FVPrdl 3 . ult.sy ll. 17.25011. 12 ,487( I)’(F)’ Til). 3, 4, 59. 12,497 (F)‘ 7a 1 , FI. 6 , 6 -, 2. 12.518 *Pr oh. ult. sy ll. 17.231 Z. 12.519 (M) Porh. inst .art.IV.82 K. 12,525 (M)' Sil. 3,445. 12,531 (F)' Sil. 2, 135. 12,566 (I)' ProT3 uit.syll .lY.254Z. 12,572 ( ITPr ol 3 . ult . syll . I7,277Z, 12,574 ( I)'Pr oh . ult. syll. 17 , 24 8 E. 12,589 (M)’Sil. 2, 234. 12,594 *Prol 3 . ult. syll. I7,25oZ. 12,616 (I)' Prols.Tilt^ssrll . I7,248Z. 12,635 (F)Manil .4,387. 12,638 (I)' quint. 9, 3, 46. 12,643 (F)' Juv. 4, 128. 1^,345 (I) Sen. cpis t . 101,13; Luc , 1 , 366; quint. 8 , 5, 6 . 12 , 649 (F) Sil . 8 , 383. 12 ,672 (I)’ Val , . FI . 2, 587; S 8.32 2 y • 12 ,5?9 . . - * 77 Prob. Pr ot> , Quint Pro!). Prcfc * Prob. Prob. Quint Prob* Prob. Aeneid 1,341 germanum fugiens longa est iniuria longae IV, 10 K. * multae 1,593 argentum Pariusve lapis circumdatur auro IV, 145 K. H w # circumdatus n 2,307 praec ipitesque trahit silvas stupet inscius alto , 8, 6, 10 * sedet " « 2,560 opstipui subiit cari genitoris imago IV, 238 K * obstipuit « M 2,564 respicio et quae sit me circum copia lustro IV, 196 K. n n n n ^circum i$e H " 3,125 bacchat amc l' ae iugis Naxum viridemque Donusam IV, 31 K. " « » Naxon " " (abc) 3,238 ergo ubi delapsae sonitum per curva dedere IV, 252 X. " « " * sonitu 3,436 praedicam et repetens itertpaque iterumque monebo » 2, 13, 8. *pra@cipiam ac « n « n 3,578 fama est Enceladi semustum fulmine corpus 10, 19 K. ” ” " semiustum ” ” (a) 4,596 infelix Dido nunc te facta impia tangunt IV, 154 K. * n-uxa mu n « - , f . . . . . , . 78 Prob. Quint Prob • Prob. Prob. Prob • Prob. Prob, Prbb . Prob. Prob. 5,266 IV, 81 Z. 5,212 . 7,9, 10. 5,720 IV, 253 Z. ^uo diversus abis iterum pete saxa Menoete * fug© H " proma petit maria et pelago decurrit aperto * c ae 1 o n n turn vero in curas animo diducitur omnis w " " " animum " H ( V b c) 6,154 IV, 222 Z. 6,202 11, 15 Z. 6,720 IV, 247 Z. 6,745 IV, 210 Z. 6,897 IV, 248 Z. sic demum lucos Stygis et regna invia vivis ” " H *Stygiae tollxuat se celeres liquidumque per aera lapsae ♦Xiquidum super aethera " sublimi9 animas iterumqu© ad tarda reverti " " " " * tartara donee longa dies profecto temporis orbe n n ” W H * a gyQ his ibi turn natum Anchises unaque Sibyllam ♦hie ubi " " " " " (M cl) 7, 98 extern! venient generi qui sanguine nostrum Iv, 233 K. M veniunt " " " " (_ X- ) 7,148 postera cum prima lustrabat lampade terras IV, 230 K. n " primo n " " (p) 7,244 munera reliquias Troia ex ardente receptas IV, 259 Z. " * Trbiae g t4si CL. ‘tl.Vf /> «• 79 8,259 hie Cacum in tenebris incendia vana vomentem Proh. IV, 254 K , n *tantum " M conversum a lumine 8,442 nunc manibus rapidis omni nunc arte magistra Sen. epist.95,33 ” n " *opus est nunc arte magistra 8,630 fecerat et viridi fetam Mavortis in antro Proh. IV, 3, 5, he is speaking about the grwat admiration which poets and Romans in general felt for Vergil, He says that Arelliue Fuscus drew freely from him, but in a more or less veiled manner, while other authors were more open in their borrowing. He mentions one Vergilian phrase "plena deo" which found great favor with Messalla, Caesar, the orators of the day, and even with Ovid in his traged- ies. In fact, the highest compliment that one could pay any man was to say of him in the words of Vergil, "et ill© erat plena deo". It is interesting to note that Seneca uses the feminine "plena" even when referring to "ille", and that this phrase must have be- come stereotyped in the form in which it is reputed to have been found in Vergil, Seneca says that Ovid made use of this Vergil- ian phrase in his tragedies in the following line, ' * * * * . ■ - 82 feror hue illuc ut plena deo. This phrase attributed to Vergil has proved a puzzle to modern scholars* * Leo * summarizes the evidence for such a passage. Seneca quite evidently cannot be referring to Eel. 3, 60, "lovis omnia plena". The more appropriate place would seem to be Aen. 6, 77-79: - at Phoebi nondum pa'fciens immanis in antro bacchatur vates magnum si pectore possit excuse ise deum for this passage has been imitated by many authors, by Ovid in particular, and "plana deo" would seem to be especially appli- cable to the Sibyl. There appears, then, to have been another version of the text containing this phrase, Norden in his commentary on the sixth book of the Aeneid ** expresses the be- lief that even though there is no present manuscript evidence for such a passage ever having existed in Vergil, there must have been a different arrangement of the text containing such a verse, and that this was very popular in the time of August us, If we should take the assumptions of these two scholars, we then should find no rea- son for impeaching the reliability of Seneca; for he is too re- putable an authority to have made so ungrounded a statement. Although Columella makes but eight variations from the Vergillian text, he seems to have been rather careless in his mode of quoting. In the case of Georgies 1, 43 where he fills in \ * Leo, De Senecae Tragoediis Observat iones Crit,cae, 166, note 8. * * Norden, P. Vergil ius Maro , Aeneis Buch. VI, Second Edition p. 145. . . * : - w - . * . - ¥■ ' - S ♦ . . 83 . a the line with such/marked variation from the Vergilian text, Schneider remarks that Ursinus suspected that these words crept in from a marginal gloss, and Gesnerus who followed him included them. This may have been the case; hut Columella proves care- less in several instances. In his quotation from Georgies 4,87 ff„, one would judge that he had quoted from memory. The fact that he quotes line 95 before 91 and then combines the beginning of 93 and the end of 92 may have been intentional; but, if we look at Georgies 4, 95-96, we note that he has made a strange have jumble of the lines such as might easily/happened if he had quot- ed from memory. Seneca the Younger in his quotations makes six varia- tions from the text, but, in general, his citations are very ac- curate. It is evident that he is familiar with Georgies 1, 139, for he once quotes it in its authorized form, and again makes a slight adaptation to his context. There is no manuscript author- ity to bear out his using "nomine " for "carmine" of Georgies 2, 95, or "Opus est" for "omni" of Aene id 8, 442, unless in the latter instance ho wished to make the line complete in itself. His variations generally can be explained on the ground. of adap- tation, as, for example, his variation of "di® genite et geniture deos" of Aene id 9, 642. As Is quite natural, Probus because of the immense number of quotations in his Vergilian commentary and his gram- * ‘ ' ' 1 * - - » ; . - ♦ , ' - . 84 matical works has more opportunity for variation than Seneca, Columella, or Quintilian, and of the sixty-three variations noted, forty-eight occur in his work. Of these forty-eight, thirty-six are unsupported hy any Vergilian manuscript author- ity. From the very character of Probus’s work, wo expect him to exercise the utmost care in quoting, for, where he is merely commenting on some Vergilian passage there would not he much oc- casion for adapting the quotation to the context. But the very fact that h© quotes Vergil so profusely, and with so many varia- that, since tions leads us to think /he was very familiar with the text, he often times may have made citations from memory, or els® that h© used a different text. We find on® very curious variation in his version of Aeneld 8, 269: hie Cacum in tenehris incendia vana vomentem where he reads hie tantum in tenehris converaum a lumin© and where the latter part of the line in no way correspondes with the text. In fact, the only place in Vergil where we find the end of a line to any extent corresponding with these words is in Georgic 4, 423: in latehris aver sum a lumin® nympha. One wonders if Prohus , s memory may not have played him false in this instance, and if he did not accidentally combine these two lines into the resulting chaos. - * • 1 , . ♦ * : . , 85 Quintilian varies from RibbeckVs text in nine instances. In one or two cases , he omits a i^o'r'd two from the Vergilian line* perhaps intentionally, and in others, where he uses "prae- cipianV for "praedicam" of Aeneid 3, 436 and "indignetur n for "indignatus " of Aeneid 8,728, he is evidently making adaptations. There are hut a very few variations in his works which ate not authorized either hy manuscript authority or on the ground of adaptation. MINOR WORKS. Cat. 3 , i » (Quint. 8, 3, 28. 3- 5 * ( Cir. 7, (F), Sen. Thy. 384; It uc « q , 816. 233 (F). Tib. 4, 1, 125; Calp, 2, 15. 396 (F) Stat * sil. 3 , 2 , *3 9 . Cul*. 86 (F) Calp. 4, 14, 100 (F) Ov. met, 11, 154; reia . am, 181; Sil. 14, 475. 215 (M)(F) Mart. 7, 96, 7. 405 (F) Calp. 7, 9. In the preceding list I have made note of the few quotations of the Minor Poems found in the authors studied. 1 '! . < i 86 We cannot tell at exactly how early a date Vergil's Minor Works began to be cited and some of the quotations from them which I have attributed to the poets may be fortuitous. The earliest quotation that I have noted is in Tibullus (4, 1, 125) who uses "flumine cursus", the last two words of Cir is 233. Inasmuch as Tibullus was so nearly contemporary with Vergil, it may be straining a point to say that the use of these words is an authentic case of poetic quotation, but with Ovid, who was such a thorough student of Vergil, the evidence would seem to be a little stronger, and also with Calpurniu®, Seneca, Lucan, and Statius. In Quintilian , VIII, 3, 28, we have an authentic quotation of Cat ale pt on 2, which he quotes entire with the ex- ception of the second line, and we are not surprised to find that so erudite a schoolmaster was familiar even with Vergil's Minor Poems . That the quotation of the . Mino r Works is so infrequent is not at all surprising, for they were the work of the poe1?e youth and immaturity, and very probably were not much read in the schools. In the table that follows, I have listed the absolute number of quotations from each book of Vergil found in the authors studied, and I shall attempt to draw some conclusions from this evidence with regard to the relative popularity of different por- tions of Vergil's work. -■ ■ . . . i * 1 < t ; ► “ • . ■ 1 , , % , ' — O' — 'o > — fcl v5> vS — — Qo — H — &0 ’o '(— • — lo ft I i r( — * — it* — io d § — d — £0 o d oo — a — % - r- — d :> - o N d d Q — r~ rfl vg x- —' M h cj — vS c^ :y d 7- "v w 5^ h of — — vi — — ss w H — — d rtf ro **) —9 vD *>5 ft f *o co fo Lo of — V '”— u <1 — sh £ — — o C> to o zf- M H — — r- ^0 d J o _ C3 « % <0 * lo . o H — — -o q{ o U> £T ^ W H of — ;2r i d - 22 — d c5 M — — — — Mi- — 3 <0 - — ■ CO D rt nf — W — — . 5J- — — £> w __ O K! O H R — ■ — o H — — — <0 d nf W ■H — — T* ea G o o >4 4) tJ r-J w u •d «) (0 * — i Cl 02 © © 2 ft G ,G G cd 0) © CO iH ® o m +» m -H rH p G G A G +» « pS m •H Pt P» w G H -H o 4J rl G «* G G 2 G v-t cs G Vi O flS G 6 H •H •H G {fl r-J o •ci •H G g o G o © G ft (6 +» »d •H 3 •H 4) © ft P © S G cl G o G »4 OT T* M G G G «5 G H tH G O -M rH •H •H (4 O 0) ► >* O «J 0> © Cj o m G © Ct$ EH ft W fc» *~3 o W O a CO (G Ph o o CO ft ft ft £ er* <0 O'. > "3 ,, r on t? £ s - — «n Y £ % ro Oo - • ■v-. k * " nT n? °0 C^Q 5 — 1 fr 3- <3^ <0f — JsJ ^ vS > fY * is o ^f- fi H — w M >- °K > r- c V — $Y Js; C£ > 0 *D — . ll «J> :h K fO 50 no ' • — CO o I , M | S> >* nl t In o 1= -fe — Cr- l<* o f “ — — H 1 o H & <0 lo r- «0 — S - o C* — c5 H ro fcl > ■^0 ci - ^ @ -vf) CO j W s £> k) to ^ <0i M © 0) •H M d A pl rH «n rM •rl 4-> © rH m •H •H <» d o P d P P* +» •rl Pi •H {>» 4> & & © P 4> •H <«rl Pi c •rl © o H •H d tH H •rl O P- *h d 4» •rl d Pi rH d P PM t=» o 5 CO CO S CO Pi Ei 89 . For convenience in estimating the restive popularity of the different portions of Vergil in the period covered, let us arrange the authors examined in three groups, each covering a period of approximately sixty years. In the first group of Vergil's contemporaries are Tibullus, Propertius, Horace, Verrius Flaccus , and Pompeius Trogus, There are relatively few quotations among these authors as compared with their successors, and, judging from the evidence compiled, absolutely speaking, the books of the Aenoid prove most popular in this order, Book 3, quoted ten times, Books 1 and 2, quoted eight times each, Book 6, quoted seven times, while the fourth book of the Georgies with five quotations, the fourth, seventh, eighth and ninth books of the Aeneid with four quota- tions each, and the second and eighth Eclog ues with three quo- tations each, stand next in order. Relatively speaking, the Eclogues, prove much more populaft than either the Aenoid or the il^r^icsj, but their brevity makes such a comparison seem very unfair j however, in either case, relatively or absolutely speak- ing, the Aenoid proves more popular than the G eorgies . In the second period from Ovid to Petronius, the first £.£, 9 . r g i. g. is quoted fifty-nine times, the second book forty-one times, the fourth thirty-five times, and the third thirty- three , But when we come to the Aene id . we see a marked rise in the fig- ures. The second Aeneid is quoted sixty-nine times, the first ia a close second with sisty-eight quotations, the sixth t i 1 t l t 5 i C 90 "book third, with forty-six, and the fourth Aanoid and first Georgic hold fourth place with fifty-nine quotations each. The third Aeneid is the next most popular with fifty-six quotations, the second Georgi c comes next, while tho fifth, seventh, and eighth Aeneid are more frequently quoted than the last hooks of the Georgies , Considering the number of quotations from each hook in comparison with the total num- ber of lines, the second Eclogue and first Geor gia are first, the second and first Aeneid second, the third and fourth Ae - neid and sixth Eclogue third, the sixth Aene id and second Georgic fourth, and the last two hooks of the Georgies and the first Eclogue stand before any of tho last six hooks of the Aeneid . But, in matter of relative popularity, if we take into consideration the fact that Columella quotes entirely from the .Georgie s and omit his quotations for this reason, the Aeneid proves overwhelmingly more popular than the Georgies . It he seen from the table that certain authors quote most often from particular hooks, I have already noted the cases of Maniliua and Columella who quote largely from the Georgie s , and Seneca who was particularly fond of the first Georgi c and sixth Aenei d. We note that Ovid and Lucan make more frequent use of the first and second hooks of the Aenei d than of any other portion of Vergil, and that Calpurnius , con- trary to natural expectations, quotes more often from tie Aenei d than from the Eclogues . ■ - * t < 91 . In the last period from Pliny to Juvenal, it is ob- viously unfair to include Probus or Caeaius Bassus in drawing conclusions with respect to the relative appeal of Vergi.1'3 work; for these grammarians cited a passage merely because it illustrated some point of grammar or furnished opportunity for learned comment. On these grounds I shall omit them from this discussion. In this period the first two books of the Aeneid prove most popular, whilfe the sixth takes precedence over the fourth, and the fifth and eleventh are next most frequent- ly quoted. It is interesting to note that in this period the last six books of the Aeneid are quoted absolutely more frequent" ly than either the Eclogues or the Georgies , and in relative frequency, also, the first and second Aene id hold first place, the first Eclogue comes second, the fourth and sixth Aene id next, the fifth and eighth Aeneid and second Eclogue occupy fourth place, while both in relative and absolute frequency the Georgies stand after the last six books of the Aeneid. To aid in the estimate of felative popularity, in c&ae of authors like Ovid, Manilius, Seneca the Younger, Valer- ius Fiaccus, Quintilian, Statius, and Silius Italicus who quote profusely, I have worked out the proportionate amount of quo- tation considering both the relative bulk of their works and the relative length of the different books of Vergil. Reckoned 1 ' * « , { 92 in this way, the 2cJLo_g.u0.3_ &re negligible as far as popularity is concerned, for to he proportionately popular with the Gao r- and Aeneid we should expect to find four to ten times as many quotations as we do. Considered in this light, also, any one of the first six hooks of the Aeneid is generally three to four times mors popular than any hook of the Geo r gies (save with Manilius and Seneca the Younger), for on the scale of relative hulk Manilius quotes the Georgies seven times more frequently than Ovid or Seneca, four times more often than Valerius Flac- cus, twice as often as Statius, Silius, and Quintilian. Valer - ius Flaccus quotes from ©very hook of the Aeneid twic© as fre- quently as any other author and Statius makes less frequent quotation than Silius, hut more frequent th a n Seneca or Quin- tilian. Seneca the Younger quotes from the Geor gies more often than Ovid, hut his quotation of every hook of th© Aenei d except the sixth is much less frequent than that of the other authors, while Quintili&n quotes relatively infrequently from all hooks except the sixth Aenei d. By way of summary from these figures and tables, I conclude that during the period examined the entire Aeneid is quoted absolutely more frequently than either the Georgies or Eclogues,, save only that the first Georgic stands before tne ninth, tenth, and twelfth Aenei d; while from the standpoint of relative frequency, irrespective of the relative hulk of Vergil*s work, the first and second A.eneid stand first, the - 1 ~ * , « • * « , 1 93 second Eclogue next, the fourth Aeneid and first Geo rgic third, the first and sixth Ecl ogu es . third and sixth Aeneid hold fourth place, and the first Aene id occupies the next place in order. If we reckon the whole ten Ecl ogues as a single hook, or com- pare their hulk with the Geor gies or Aeneid . the proportion seems to he much fairer and the Aen& id then holds first place, in relative and absolute frequency, the first and second Georgies the second place, while the ?:c logues then would prove equally popular with the last two Georgies . Judging, then, from the evidence of these figures, it is clear that the first, second, fourth and sixth hooks of the Aeneid were most popular among Vergil* s contemporaries and in the first century after Christ, and, while the Georgies held the next place in esteem and the Eclogues were compara- tively popular, still in this century as in succeeding gener- ations, Vergil * s main title to fan® rested upon the first half of the Aeneid,