UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS LIBRARY AT URBANA-CHAMPAIGN ILLINOIS HISTORICAL SURVEY Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2012 with funding from University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign http://www.archive.org/details/moundbuildersofiOOthro Mound Builders of Illinois THROOP |MHM The Great Monks' Mound (also called the Cahokia MounW)°L5 I] M?4 FJ feet high, occupies a base 1,080 feet long and 710 feet wide, and covers approximately 17 acres of ground. The tumulus contains over 1,500,- 000 cubic yards of earth. "Monks' Mound is the greatest aboriginal tumulus in the United States and is more than treble the size of any other similar structure of the same area. It is the most striking figure of the Cahokia Group, which was originally the central feature of several hundred mounds within a radius of six miles. Nothing like a systematic exploration, or study, of this rich archaeological field has yet been made, and the Aboriginal paintings and carvings on cliffs and in caves occur in all countries of the earth. "Over there" they developed into heiro- glyphics and finally the alphabet. "Over here" they never developed beyond the symbolic stage. Mr. Wm. McAdams in his "Records of Ancient Races," 1887, page 21, says in speaking of the above illustrated paintings: "Some three or four miles above the city (Alton), high up beneath the over- hanging cliff, which forms a sort of cave shelter, on the smooth face of a thick ledge of rock, is a series of paintings, twelve in number. (They are now, in 1928, utterly destroyed.) They are painted or rather stained in the rock with a reddish-brown pigment that seems to defy the tooth of time. * * * It may be said, however, that their posi- jnd (also called the Cahokia Mound) W1YV4 e 1.080 feet long and 710 feet wide, and covers of ground. The tumulus contains over 1,500,- 3fk0/j, and his reports arc utv hi - hamlicapp y Lick of funds to make and thorough as he would liked to have mil awaken to the importance of placing till hands, and then many things of tre- mce will no doubt he unfolded. cliffs and in caves occur in they developed into heim- lere" they never developed Aboriginal paintings and can intries oi the earth. "Ovei a I. \ phi. - and finally the alphabet, beyond the symbolic stage. Mr Wm. McAdams in his "Records of Ancient Races," 18X7 page 21, savs in speaking of the above illustrated paintings: "Bona three or four miles above the city (Alton), high up beneath the over hanging cliff, which forms a sort of cave shelter, on the smooth tact of a thick ledge of rock, is a series of paintings, twelve in number (They are now. in 1928, utterly destroyed.) They are painted oi rather stained in the rock with a reddish-hn.u „ pigment that seems t, defy the tooth of time. * * * It may be said, however, that their posi | tion is so sheltered that they remain almost perfectly dry. We made Sketches of them thirty years ago (1857) : and on a recent visit could see that they had changed but little, although their appearance de- notes great age. They doubtless have been there for centuries. "These pictographs are situated on the cliff more than a hundred feet above the river. A protruding ledge, which is easily reached from a hollow in the bluff, leads to the cavernous place in the rock: and while one is safe from rains or storms, he has a splendid view, not only of the Mississippi, whiifh flows, a mile in width, in majesty below, but of the cultivated bottom lands on the opposite shore, and beyond, the turbid waters of the Missouri, — one of the most magnificent scenes of this romantic locality." Mound Builders of Illinois DESCRIPTIVE OF CERTAIN MOUNDS AND VILLAGE SITES IN THE AMERICAN BOTTOMS AND ALONG THE KASKASKIA AND ILLINOIS RIVERS BY ADDISON J. THROOP CALL PRINTING COMPANY EAST ST. LOUIS, ILLINOIS 1928 Copyright 1928 ADDISON J. THROOP PREFACE THE most interesting study for mankind is man. So long as life remains, to the student is unfolded new knowl- edge, new interests. To delve, in imagination, into the long- ago, into the crude beginnings, finding there, perhaps, evi- dences of superior culture along other lines than our own, certainly is fascinating mental exercise. Go back as far as earth's gaseous beginnings with the geologist ; go with the archaeologist back to mankind's rudest beginnings ; contemplate reverently the tremendous complex- ities and wonders of mankind to-day ; visualize with Christian faith the future development of man, when civilization will have embodied the divine Hope that lies within mankind's very soul, and we are but brought to a faint realization of the infinite love of an Infinite Father, whose Purposes, deeply rooted in aeons gone by, are unfolding by laws that are im- mutable. At odd times, and by using spare moments, we have writ- ten the matter, gathered the illustrative material, and set the type for this little book. We dedicate it to a better understanding of the Red People, on whose lands we now live, and whose village and burial sites are now teeming with the life of American farms, towns and cities. We are grateful to many individuals for the encourage- ment to proceed with this work, and especially to the Rev. Albert Muntsch, S. J., of the St. Louis University, for his kindly interest ; to Col. Sam. N. Hunter of the East St. Louis Daily Journal ; Mr. P. B. Corr, of the Northwest Territory Exposition. We are also grateful to Mr. H. M. Braun who furnished so many of the illustrations used in this little work ; and to Dr. Don F. Dickson, who has assisted us by sending in photographs of his work at Lewiston. The photo engravers, the printers, the pressmen of our shop, the Call Printing Co., too, have all seemed to take special interest in working on "The Mound Builders of Illinois." INDEX $ Mound Builders of Illinois .y.<. 13 Abundance of Flint Hoes in "Bottoms"....^. 15 Relics of Bone 15 Relics of Seashell 16 Pottery of the American Bottoms 17 Relics of Wood, Skin and Basketry Missing 22 Burial Customs 23 Can We Reconstruct Life by Study of Burials? 24 Stone Graves 25 Jackson County 28 Near Roots, Randolph County 31 Stone Burials Near Fults, Monroe County 34 St. Clair and Madison Counties 36 Rattlesnake Mound, St. Clair County 38 John B. Rolle Village Site, St. Clair County 40 Site at French Village, St. Clair County 42 "Dickson's Mound Builders," near Lewiston, Fulton County 47 The Original Americans 56 Virginia Indians, in 1584, Were Clean, Thrifty 56 Character Qualities of Known Red Men 58 Prof. Moorehead Pays Tribute to Red Race 59 Ohio-Illinois Indians Were Brave 60 Unscrupulous Traders Curse to Indians 61 Chiefs Logan, Cornstalk and Tecumseh Were Great Men 61 Too Much Emphasis Placed on Battle-Cruelty 63 Government Made Treaties; Upheld Trespassers 63 Many "Frontiersmen" Were Dissolute Fellows 64 Indians Lived Comfortably in Cabins 65 Destroyer Williamson Meets Real Indian Fighters 66 Logan, Great Orator; Tecumseh, Great War Chief 66 Prof. Moorehead Displays Ancient War Flag 67 Agriculture of the Red Men 68 Hariot, 1587, Describes Crops Cultivated 68 Beverly Gives Evidence of Long Cultivation of Maize 70 Marquette and Others Add Interesting Testimony 71 Modern Corn-Crib of Indian Origin 72 DeSoto's Chroniclers Tell of Abundant Indian Crops 73 America's Debt to the Red Men 74 Did Thousands Leave American Bottoms Suddenly? 76 Injun Stuff (a Poem) 78 LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS Cahokia Mound, from Photo Taken in 1904 Insert Cliff Carvings from near Alton Insert Peterson's and McAdams Map of the Cahokia Mounds Insert Flint Tools in St. Clair County Cache..... 17 Notched Hoes Found in East St. Louis 18 Flint Spades Found near East St. Louis 19 Flared Spades from Three Neighboring Counties. 20 Flared Spades or Hoes from the American Bottoms 21 Various Types of Notched Hoes 22 Interesting Find near Centreville Station, St. Clair County 25 Cahokia Arrowheads. 26 Persimmon Mound 27 Pipe, Human Figure, from Jersey County 29 Bowl, Human Head, from Blythesville, Arkansas 30 Pipe, Frog Figure, from near Centreville, St. Clair County 33 Ceremonial Sceptre from Mound near Cahokia 37 Effigy Pottery of the American Bottoms 41 Dickson's Mound Builders, Horizontal View 49 Dickson's Mound Builders, "Bird's Eye" View 50 Pottery from Dickson's Mound - - - 51 Pipes, etc., from Dickson's Mound 52 Collection of Arrowheads, etc., from Dickson's Mound 54 Effigy Pot and Concretions Found in Mound and Grave 55 Vessels from Offermann's Mound, Monroe County 57 Dickson's Unfinished New Work 75 Our Relic Cabinet - - 79 Mound Builders of Illinois MOUND BUILDERS OF ILLINOIS ILLINOIS has, without doubt, the most abundant supply of natural essentials for the development and support of mankind of any area of its extent in the world. Its fertile prairies, its verdant woodlands, its beautiful lakes, its numerous streams and its sections of rock-bound hills, made it a veritable paradise for the development and support of the prehistoric people who thrived there. Mod- ern man has cultivated its fertile prairies, harnessed its beau- tiful streams, delved into its rock-bound hills, bound them all together with magic bands of steel and concrete, for the swift distribution of the abundant production of the essentials so necessary for our comfort and wellbeing. Prehistoric man found ample supply for his simple needs and tribal organizations without delving into the refractory depths, as does our luxury-loving man with his complicated civilization, to-day. Food, shelter and protective raiment were all of prehistoric man's personal needs. Tribal organiza- tion was necessary for his continual battle against the inroads of ravenous beasts and greedy human rivals. The American Bottoms, the alluvial bottomlands border- ing the Mississippi River, from Alton to Chester and below, as well as the bordering hills on both sides of the Father of Waters, show abundant proof that in this district was prehis- toric man's greatest development north of the Rio Grande. At East St. Louis the great Cahokia group of more than eighty tremendous mounds, containing as they do millions of cubic yards of dirt, clearly indicate that here was the center of a numerous and age-old prehistoric human habitation. These people, as evidenced by a wealth of relics, traded far and wide, from the Eastern Alleghenies to the Rockies of the West, from the frozen North to the Gulf of Mexico. 11 MOUND BUILDERS OF ILLINOIS TO visualize the ancient life of a people by their relics of stone, bone, shell and clay, may be impossible, but long acquaintance and much study of their burial places and their camp sites should enable one, to some extent, to arrive at fairly accurate general conclusions. It would be open to argument to try to establish the origin of these peoples. It is generally maintained by writers and scientists that the prehistoric Americans, from the Arctic Circle to Cape Horn, were Red Men. Therein the New World differs from the Old World in its ethnology, because over there are found the Caucasian, the Malay, the Negro, the Yellow races. • The beginnings of races being too remote for the writer, we will accept the hypothesis that the prehistoric residents of Illinois were Red Men, pre-dating the advent of the horse, which animal changed the habits especially of the Plains In- dians from sedentary, industrious, agricultural people, to roving, predatory creatures, such as our histories tell us about. It is not only interesting, but we believe proper, to note briefly the radical differences of the prehistoric peoples of the two hemispheres. The Western peoples never learned, until the advent of the white conquerors, to put tools on their handles. They split withes, and bound with rawhide and fibre the handles on their tools. Here they never invented a pot- tery wheel, or other ordinary uses of the wheel. They did not develop the metals or metallurgy. Nowhere has the prehis- toric American evidenced the art of smelting metals. They used the iron (hematite) and copper just as they were found, chipping, pounding, grinding them into ornaments, tools, arms and charms as were wanted. The use of galena, quantities of which are found on campsites, caches and in burials, is en- tirely problematical, with the evidence tending to show that it was prepared for use as paint. Certain findings in the mounds near East St. Louis would lead one to believe that they had a method of heating or chemicalizing it for the making of their white paint. The prehistoric peoples never — in the American Bot- toms — conceived the idea of expressing thoughts by inscribed heiroglyphics or letters. Such fixing of thought was done by MOUND BUILDERS OF ILLINOIS 15 imagery in artistic effigy pottery and stone. Occasionally carvings on stone, in caves and sheltered cliffs, indicate the rudiments of such ideas, but the meaning of the carvings is clear only to the ancient individuals who so laboriously made them. The relics of flint, stone and bone are the only "reference books" the student has from which to draw conclusions. The Mound Builders, who have left their great earthen monuments so numerously and magnificently in the American Bottoms, were an industrious people, and their works, their artifacts, their camp sites, together with the situations of the mounds and sites, make an interesting study. ABUNDANCE OF FLINT HOES IN BOTTOMS. Flint was procured from exposed ledges of limestone, locally; from quarries in the Ohio "Flint Ridge ;" in the nearby Ozarks; from the Tennessee and Kentucky mountains, and was their universal material for the making of knives, arrow and spearheads, adzes, chisels, digging and scraping tools. The flint hoes, finely chipped and of varying size, and the great numbers that have been found in the American Bot- toms, cause one to come to the conclusion that the Mound Builders were a people given to agriculture. In fact the "gen- tlemen" Spaniards who accompanied DeSoto found them so, and have described their fields and crops. They were the first white men to come in contact with the Mississippi River Indians, and say that from one village, in what is now Arkan- sas, they procured corn enough to last their 600 men and 200 horses for three months. They tell us that besides tobacco, the natives raised popcorn, yellow, white and red corn, pump- kins, melons, beans, potatoes, yams and many other vege- tables and fruits now common and useful to us. RELICS OF BONE. Much use was made of bone, especially of the deer and bear. Knives were made from the bones of deer which are still very hard, ivory-like and durable. Long, slender, very 16 MOUND BUILDERS OF ILLINOIS sharp implements are found, as well as shorter, even tiny needle-like implements. One is forced to the conclusion that such were used as needles in the making of clothing, mocca- sins and the like. Others were used, no doubt, as engravers' tools, in the marking of pottery and possibly wood. Some collectors believe the smaller needles were used for tattooing, as so many primitive people mark their bodies for ornamentation, identification or in following out some pe- culiar "religious" purpose. Bone relics are scarce, because when found at all they are quite fragile and brittle, and the amateur collector crushes them or passes them on, not realizing their ethnological value in his collection. It is difficult to save them, but they should be saved, for they add a whole chapter in the unwritten his- torical value of one's collection. A solution of white gelatin, procurable at almost any drug store, will preserve them, seem- ing to feed the chalky bones until one can handle them with- out danger of their crumbling. The bones should be dry when dipped in the solution. These old bone needles cause one to visualize the matron or maid, carefully perforating for the insertion of the sinew or fibre threads, the finely tanned doeskin she used for her babe's dainty clothing, or for her wedding finery, or in mak- ing for her Man a "brave" and beautiful garment which would cause him to appear well in council or to protect him on the hunt or warpath. RELICS OF SEASHELL. One is always interested to find in Illinois anything made of seashell. Hundreds of long miles from seacoast as we are, yet we find seashells in the burials and on the plowed camp sites. River mussels were made use of as hand-hoes, by per- forating a thumb-hole in the thickest part of the shell. Others were evidently used as spoons. Also they valued them as or- naments, and shells are found highly polished, with perfor- ated borders and engraved with what appears to be highly complicated artistic figures of human beings, birds, animals or geometrical designs. MOUND BUILDERS OF ILLINOIS POTTERY OF THE AMERICAN BOTTOMS. 17 Pottery offers the student the best means of visualizing these departed peoples, and the American Bottoms furnish FLINT TOOLS IN ST. CLAIR COUNTY CACHE Caches of flint tools and pro- jectile points have been numerous in St. Clair county, and are food for thought. Without horses or like methods of overland transpor- tation, it became necessary, when the need for moving arose, to hide the heavy, bulky utensils of the field and village. Mr. H. M. Braun of East St. Louis came into possession of such a cache found in the spring of 1897 by Michael Pflugmacher, three miles southwest of Belleville, in Stookey township, St. Clair County. Be- sides the spade here illustrated, which was 15% inches long, very thin and finely chipped, were found four fine flared flint hoes, three polished flint chisels, a turtleback blade, a six-inch blade, a celt and a cupped stone. Whether this cache represented the labor of one man or more, does not matter, but it is interesting to note the two types of hoes in th3 same cache. 18 MOUND BUILDERS OF ILLINOIS the largest variety of any section of our great Middle West. Remember, no wheel was used in the making of prehis- toric Indian pottery. It was many times painted and pol- ished, but not glazed after the modern or European manner. Some pottery makers were very skillful and artistic. Some of the ware is almost as hard as china, and yet we doubt that NOTCHED HOES FOUND IN EAST ST. LOUIS In the spring of 1912, workmen who were excavating a trench at Fifteenth Street and Illinois Avenue, in East St. Louis, unearthed the cache of notched hoes shown herewith. Mr. H. M. Braun, in whose collection they were, has grace ously presented us with the cut. Notched hoes are peculiarly the pro- ducts of a race of people who inhabited the American Bottoms, and we believe their "home" was here at East St. Louis, because of the great numbers formerly found here. At the National Stock Yards, over twenty-five years ago, in taking away a huge mound, were found great numbers, and many caches have been found here. The "spread" of these old implements of agriculture, to our knowledge, extends somewhat up the Ohio River, and into Tennessee and Kentucky, as well as south- eastern Missouri, and in Arkansas. Thou- sands of notched hoes are preserved in the collections of Dr. H. M. Whelpley, de- ceased, of St. Louis, and of Mr. E. W Payne of Springfield, this state. Other thousands are in eastern collections ; many have been sent to museums and collectors abroad. MOUND BUILDERS OF ILLINOIS 19 it was burned as our own finished pottery. From the fact that so much of it contains a large proportion of pounded shell, it seems to us that it was made cold, similar to our concrete or plaster mixtures, then sun-dried, after which it may have been buried in hot wood ashes or coals to "cure" it. Handles, in some instances at least, were placed on the FLINT SPADES FOUND NEAR EAST ST. LOUIS Flint spades like the one here illustrated have been found in great numbers in the American Bottoms, especially in the area now occupied by East St. Louis and its environs, as well as among the mounds of the great Cahokia Mounds State Park Group. This specimen was found in this neigh- borhood and was in the collection of Mr. H. M. Braun. It is a very fine specimen, fifteen inches in length, of artistically chipped flint, very thin; has a glassy polish at the bit from being used in the dirt as a garden or field tool. It is supposed that handles were bound onto such spades by using an ell-shaped tree branch and raw- hide. Experiments show that thus hafted it becomes a serviceable garden tool, with which corn, beans, melons, tobacco, gourds or other garden truck could be suc- cessfully cultivated. 20 MOUND BUILDERS OF ILLINOIS vessels by boring holes in the sides of the partly cured vessel, then placing on the handles, forcing them through the holes and smoothing each side so that, unless one breaks a handle from the pot, it seems to be molded in its place. The pots are made melon or squash-shaped, in animal de- signs, and ducks, owls, eagles, bears, deer, frogs, fish, human faces and figures are depicted in pottery. Seashells were imitated almost perfectly, just as they would cut a shell to FLARED SPADES FROM THREE NEIGHBORING COUNTIES The flared spades or hoes are interesting, and seem to cover a wide range of territory. They are made of various kinds and colors of flint. The four specimens here illustrated, read- ing from the top down are as follows : found by Miss Tebow, on the KeifTer farm, near Casey- ville, just east of East St. Louis; near Collinsville, Madi- son county; near Posey, Clinton county; near Edwardsville, in Madison county. They were in the collection of Mr. H. M. Brann, to whom we are indebt- ed for the cur. If a certain tribe or nation of Red Men made only flared spades, they either migrated over a great territory, or they were a very numerous people occupying it. They are found, we believe, in parts of Ohio, Indiana, Kentucky, Tennessee, Arkansas, Missouri and South- ern Illinois. MOUND BUILDERS OF ILLINOIS 21 make it a useful vessel. Bowls and saucers and occasionally plates are found. Colored pottery sherds, usually red, are found frequently on plowed camp sites, where they lie exposed to rains, snows, freezes and hot sunshine, still appearing fresh, and the col- FLARED SPADES OR HOES FROM THE AMERICAN BOTTOMS These five specimens from Mr. H. M. Braun's collection, were all found in the Ameri- can Bottoms. Reading from the top, as on page 16, they were found as follows: Will Pow- ell, between Canteen Creek and the Collinsville Road, in Madi- son county; on August Adele farm near Cahokia; just west of Caseyville, St. Clair county; near Edwardsville ; a half mile west of Imbs Station, St. Clair County. This group of flared spades show a great variance in shape and material. Inasmuch as each modern tribe of Indians has some indi- vidual characteristic in his man- ufacture of arrows, bows, etc., so, we believe, the ancient tribes had certain individual or tribal characteristics in the mak- ing of their arrow and spear points, axes, spades and hoes. 22 MOUND BUILDERS OF ILLINOIS oring matter so soft that it adheres to one's lingers. In size the vessels vary from about a gill to several gal- lons in capacity. In thickness they run from thick cardboard to about half an inch. RELICS OF WOOD, SKIN AND BASKETRY MISSING. Of the utensils of gourd and wood, relics are very rare. These, like the skin, basketry and feather work, have disin- tegrated with the ravages of the years. In the mounds and burials no appreciable relics of such material have been found. A few bits of woven fabric were found during the summer of 1927 by Mr. Ben Woesthaus, in a burial on the bluffs east of East St. Louis. The fabric was lying beneath the knee of the burial, the bones of which, from the neck down showed pos- itive evidences of quite thorough burning. Mr. Woesthaus managed to save a piece possibly two square inches in dimen- sion, carefully mounting it on a card, under glass. In very dry caves, relics of gourd, wood, basketry, fibre and cloth have been found and saved. VARIOUS TYPES OF NOTCHED HOES A collection such as Mr. Braim had furnishes many instances which cause one to think. Beautiful notched hoes are found over a somewhat restricted territory. True, they, like the flared spades, are found on the Ohio River and its tributaries; but East St. Louis, we believe, was the "home" of the notched hoe. The center piece above, a beautiful piece, was found just south of Eads Bridge, near the river; the lefthand hoe was found near Collinsville; the righthand hoe, near Lebanon. MOUND BUILDERS OP ILLINOIS 23 BURIAL CUSTOMS IT is difficult for us, accustomed as we are to the telephone, newspaper, mail service, radio, steam, electric and gaso- line transportation, to imagine conditions lacking all of these things. We hardly understand the Scottish Clans of many decades ago, their enmities, their differing customs and dialects, oc- curring in glens or valleys, separated by mountainous hills, yet apart, "as the crow flies," but a few miles. This con- dition existed, but, of course, at a time before modern means of thought transference and rapid transit eradicated the ig- norance of one people as regards another, and which give us — or should give us — understanding and a feeling of kin- ship to our fellow men. One must visualize the ancient peoples of Illinois in much the same manner as the ancient Scots. The tribes or villages on the Illinois River, no doubt, differed materially in customs from the tribes or villages on the Kaskaskia or other rivers. Not having books and letters, knowledge necessarily was transmitted by example and word of mouth. Therefore the learned of a tribe must have been after the manner of the Siouan or other modern Indian "Medicine Men." While these men were taught by their predecessors, each one, with- out doubt, interpolated into his ceremonies, his prayers, his magic, personal idiosyncracies and "discoveries" of his own, and his teachings would impress his tribe differently, and cause a variance in tribal customs of living and of burial even of those of the same "nation." This individualism would explain the differences found in similar shaped mounds. It is impossible to choose a pyra- midal, sugar loaf, oblongated, oval, truncated pyramid, effigy, high or low mound and say that "this shape contains certain burials, this shape without burials," and that another shape is strictly for "temple" purposes. It seems that each tribe or nation built mounds with some generally accepted kindred purpose. Practically all of the 24 MOUND BUILDERS OF ILLINOIS mounds contain unmistakable evidences of careful building, sometimes apparently for religious uses. It has been our privilege to witness much excavating of mounds and ancient graves, and we have been moved to deep- est reverence at the evidence of the painstaking labor in their construction. CAN WE RECONSTRUCT LIFE BY STUDY OF BURIALS? If one were to attempt to describe America as it is to-day, just how would we come at the subject? Especially would it be difficult to describe it to one who was totally unacquainted with modern America. If all we had to picture America in 1928 were our burial places, would it be possible to literally reconstruct the life of to-day ? Verily, one would find these burials as diverse in custom as are the lives of the members of our various denom- inations. However, without the modern "conveniences" which cause unnumbered complications of living and differing conditions, life would of necessity be more simple. Life in ancient times was filled, no doubt, with desires for love, for power, for ease in living, for solution of the sun's rising, for the answer to the shining of the moon, for the an- swer to what seems the inherent belief or hope of all man- kind — of Life itself — whether or not it continues after dissolu- tion. The philosophy of the ancient Indians is known to us only as we find it expressed in their mounds, graves and the poor relics found on camp or village sites. The work of their hands that have resisted unknown ages of time, the manner of bur- ial, food bowls, stone tools and projectile points and knives, remain to tell us their mute story of the life of a primitive peo- ple that developed and became great along the simplest pos- sible lines. It is impossible to delve into all the many thousands of graves and mounds and to explore the innumerable ancient camp sites. It would be impossible to tell a comprehensible story of the total findings even were one able to do so. How- ever, as we believe that if one could describe any one typical MOUND BUILDERS OF ILLINOIS 25 American individual he would be telling a great deal of mod- ern America, so we here describe a few typical Indian burials, in the hope that our findings may shed a little light on the cus- toms of the ancient pre-Columbian Red Men of Illinois. INTERESTING MOUND FIND, NEAR CENTREVILLE STATION, ST. CLAIR COUNTY These relics were taken from a low mound at the foot of the bluffs east-southeast of East St. Louis, near Centreville Station, and are now in the collection of Mr. Wm. E. Herrington of this city. Numbers 1, 2, 3 and 4 are wonderful specimens of unfinished pipes, clearly showing that the shaping of the objects from the rough stone thus far was accomplished by a pecking process. Numbers 3 and 4 are partly drilled, and all are of very hard, refractory, grainless stone. Number 5 is a spade, rather thick, well chipped, with polished bit, made of pinkish flint, length nine and three-fourths inches. Number 6 is a beautifully polished celt of mottled granite. Numbers 7 and 8 are pottery sherds of thin ware, nicely finished, unornamented. Number 9 is a "bone needle sharpener," of white sharp sandstone. On the dark card, lower center, are some arrowheads, a very fine spearhead, a good knife blade. Near the mound are to be found abundant evidences of a large prehistoric settlement. Immediately north is a bubbling creek of clear water, and to the west lay the southerly end of old Pittsburg Lake, formerly a fine body of water, extending west- erly five miles or more into East St. Louis corporate limits. 26 MOUND BUILDERS OF ILLINOIS At the Cahokia group have been found tens of thousands of arrowheads, similar to the ahove, generally, in shape. Collectors as a rule name them "Cahokia points." Invariably of beautiful craftsmanship, some are marvel- ously chipped to knifelike fineness of edge. The materials used indicate some- what the tremendous range covered by those Cahokia warriors. Obsidian, calcedony and quart/, from the western Rockies, copper from the Lake Superior region; clear crystal, dark, bluish veined hint from Ohio, Tennessee and Ken- tucky; pure white flint from the Ozarks; red flints from lower down in the Arkansas hills. Other jewel-like materials one would like to believe came from old Mexico. MOUND BUILDERS OF ILLINOIS STONE GRAVES STONE GRAVES are found, to personal knowledge, from above Alton to Gorham. We have read that they are found quite generally throughout the South (especially in Georgia) and up the Ohio River and its tributaries, They have been found, to our knowledge, occasionally in Iowa on the Skunk River. These stone graves, like the mounds, while similar in general, has each one its individuality. They are found on the limestone bluffs, and in country miles away from ex- posed limestone. As it would be, to our minds, impossible to state even briefly the many differing ways of building stone cists or graves which we have found, we will not attempt a general description. It will be better to content ourselves with a few observations than to be lost in the maze of min- ute descriptions of the many which we have seen and explored. And so we will merely tell about a few of them, in dif- ferent parts of the territory up and down the Mississippi River from East St. Louis. ^'\;.. Persimmon Mound -aem^ MonK/9 Mound. N 28 MOUND BUILDERS OF ILLINOIS JACKSON COUNTY IN SEPTEMBER, 1924, on the invitation of Mr. J. Dan Will of Roots, Randolph County, we accompanied him on an exploration trip in Jackson County. On the Mississippi River Bluffs, a few miles west of Murphysboro, there is an extensive ancient Indian cemetery of stone graves, situated on a high ridge between the bot- toms and a fair-sized creek which comes through the bluffs from the east at this point. Much work had already been done by various persons in times past. Many great slabs or "cap stones" were scattered about, showing that a great many "resting places" had been disturbed. The side walls of many explored graves could be seen, evidently of graves which had been built very close to the original surface. After digging into several of these, we finally came upon an undisturbed cap stone about two feet below the surface. After carefully uncovering the entire box or vault, we lifted the cap stone, finding the cist to be approximately seven feet long by twenty inches wide. The side walls were made by setting, edgewise, slabs of limestone about two to three inches thick. These stones had been broken into about the same sizes, but showed no evidences of having been trimmed with tools. Trenching all about the walls, we carefully withdrew one side and began taking away the sandy clay. At the head of the burial we found a great chunk of red "paint stone," which we judged to weigh about ten pounds. Beneath this was a tent-like structure of very thin limestone slabs, which had been built over the face and head of the burial. On removing the dirt from the entire body, we dis- covered that all the bones below the skull were charred from burning, bits of charcoal being associated therewith. The body was flexed, arms at side, lying on its back, the general direction of the ridge. No artifacts or projectile points were discovered, but the evident care of the burial, the protecting stone "tepee" over the head, capped as it was by MOUND BUILDERS OF ILLINOIS 29 an unusual quantity of "paint rock," led us to believe it an "important" burial. The good contour of the skull, the rest- ful attitude, the careful construction of the cist of heavy, well chosen stones, which must have been carried several hundred yards, together with the evidences of thorough burning, caused queer thoughts to course through our minds. As if we were eye-witnesses to the solemn ceremonies which must have attended the burial of this ancient Red Man, the im- Wm. McAdams found quite a number of these "sphinx-like images." The frog pipe, on page 33, and the ab ove pipe in human form we reproduce with his description, from his "Records of Ancient Races," 1887. He says: "The face of this figure is a fine, expressive one, and the head is sur- mounted with a covering as though of some fabric, not very unlike some of the head-dresses shown in the sculptures exhumed by Layard from the ruins of Assyria. It is a sort of cap of folds, the end of the fold form- ing a crest or knob at the top. * * * It is considerably larger than the frog-image described above ; is of the same red stone, and was taken from a mound on Piasa Creek, a few miles from Alton. * * * Like the preced- ing image (the frog, page 33), it is highly polished, and as a work of art has certainly no small degree of merit.'' 10 MOUND BUILDERS OF ILLINOIS pression came of the Reason which prompted them. The Man himself had gone to the Spiritland. The fleshly remains, carefully laid to rest in a solid, protecting stone grave, were consumed by the fire and given to the god of the Air, while the bones were given to the god of the Earth, being carefully covered by the great stone, to lie throughout untold ages, until the cavity of the cist became entirely filled by the filtering in of the surrounding clay. Their sacred symbols of Life seemed to us to be exemplified as fourfold — the Spirit to the Spiritual realm ; the flesh to the Air; the blood to the Waters ; the bones to the Earth. Our observations made, this burial was carefully re- placed, to lie undisturbed, perhaps, until the poor bones of this Red Man are indeed absorbed into Mother Earth. This is a remarkable life-sized effigy vase, found near Blythesville, Mississippi County, Arkansas, from a burial site that was being washed away by river. Mr. H. M. Braun, East St. Louis, had it in his collection some years ago, and says that while not at all common, Mr. Clarence B. Moore, Philadelphia Academy of Sciences, has described dozens of them in his book on his Arkansas archaeological work. The perforations in the ears were no doubt for the suspension of ornaments. Perforated fresh- water pearls have been found associated with burials, in great quantities. The protuberance at the forehead is also perforated, possibly for the fas- tening of feathers, which held a religious significance to the Indians, or some other form of distinguishing ornament. MOUND BUILDERS OF ILLINOIS 31 NEAR ROOTS, RANDOLPH COUNTY MR. WILL is an ardent student of archaeology, and by his continued interest and observations since early boy- hood, he has amassed a wonderful collection of the relics of prehistoric Indians, as well as a knowledge of the burial places and village sites of the American Bottoms and bluff lands, especially in the territory from the mouth of the Kas- kaskia River, up that river to Evansville, and the country toward the Mississippi. On our return from Jackson County, we explored for a day in a very interesting burial place near Mr. Will's home. His father had done extensive work here in years gone by and it was some little time ere we made any discoveries. Finally, however, beneath a disturbed site, we discov- ered two very interesting burials. The first one, about four feet down, was a carefully-made cist, which, when the great cap rock had been removed, we found to be about four feet nine inches long by only about eleven inches wide. On the outside of the cist, at fairly regular intervals, we found peculiar naturally-shaped pieces of "lime-drip/' which forma- tion occurs in the fine sand-like clay of the neighborhood. The shapes resembled the pottery-effigy squatting fat woman, which figure is found depicted in pottery vessels throughout the American Bottoms and further south near the great river. This resemblance was vague, somewhat after the fancied image of the ''man in the moon" or faces in the clouds or rocks, as children see them. (See page 55.) The skeleton, apparently that of a youth, was lying on its back, extended full length. The side walls fitted quite snugly against the skull and the body was either crowded into the cist after the flesh had been removed, or the pressure of the settling earth pushed the sides in very evenly before the cavity was finally filled by the sifting action of the fine clay throughout the ages. No artifacts or stone relics were found. The second burial was peculiar. Bent at the waist, it lay on its back. At its head to the left, we found a crude 32 MOUND BUILDERS OF ILLINOIS bottle-shaped pot of about three pints capacity. The legs bent straight down from the hips. At about the waist line, on the right, we found a well-made pot of about a quart capacity, with an animal head on the rim. Later when Mr. Will carefully took out the dirt with which it was filled, he discovered a polished mussel shell "spoon" very nicely in- cised, and also a small handled pot of about a half pint capacity. It is peculiar how the apparently solid earth fills all cavities of these carefully made stone cists, filling even the skulls, whose only openings into the brain cavity are at the entrance of the spinal cord or the tiny nerve channels of the eye and ear sockets. At this place Mr. Will, some years prior to our visit, re- moved a very large cap stone, beneath which was an exceed- ingly well-made cist about fourteen inches in length by about six inches wide. The bones were disintegrated with the ex- ception of particles of very thin skull, which were encased in one-half of a broken pot, placed over the tiny head by the loving hands which interred it so long ago. One small handled pot, about one-fourth pint capacity, was found, and it was found bottom up. Whether it was placed in this man- ner at the time of interment is a question. One can imagine that its being upside down was to indicate that the immature life, in thus leaving its loving parents, had left unfilled the hopes they held for it. Then again it may have been placed on the top of a little thickly blanketed and be-feathered fig- ure, and as the ages ate the fabrics and skins, and the earth filtered through the interstices, its foundation crumbled and the tiny pot rolled over and became covered over in its fallen position. This burial site, situated about half way up the steeply sloping hill, on a shelf-like park, overlooks an ideal camp site at the foot of the hill, where the hamlet of Roots now stands, and on the bluff above it are ample evidences of village occu- pancy. A sugar-loaf mound about twenty feet in diameter by ten or twelve feet high, "overlooks" the burial site. This mound was explored some years ago by Mr. Will and his MOUND BUILDERS OF ILLINOIS 33 father, who found at about the base line a great "wheel" made of a conglomeration in which pounded shell seemed to predominate, which was so hard it was very difficult to _vbreak. Evidently, as the Indians knew nothing of wheels two Mound Builders' platform pipes. Lower front is a most unique relic — a tiny dagger and sheath, cut from the teeth of a grizzly bear. How the scabbard was hollowed out to receive the beau- tifully shaped dagger of the hard bear tooth, with primitive stone tools, is indeed a puzzle. MOUND BUILDERS OF ILLINOIS 53 the unusual number of flint arrow points and bone chipping tools found lying with it. Another individual has been uncovered who was no doubt laid away in the full vigor of warriorhood. No finely- ornamented blanket, no gorgeous featherwork, none of the choice tidbits of basketed food, nothing of the carefully en- graved and painted ax-handle or bow, with its accompany- ing quiver, were found. Father Time has claimed all of those untold hundreds of years agone. But lying at his waist line, embedded in its protecting sheath of clay, lies a very beautiful polished green granite celt. This seems to us to clearly show that the celts were ungrooved axes, and were without doubt firmly bound to handles by rawhide, which dries and shrinks to almost metallic firmness. So much has been said, so much has been written, so much more could and will be written about Dr. Dickson's work by those better qualified to do so than the writer, that it seems to us futile to attempt a fuller description here. DICKSON'S Mound Builders seem to us to show distinct relations to the Cahokia people. Their arrow points are predominatingly triangular in form, well made, of material from widely separated sources. They used no stone in their burials, but the pottery, the attitudes of the bodies in their extended, restful positions, are very similar to those of the people who inhabited the American Bottoms, and who buiit the great mounds there. Indications of social diseases are not found in the bones of Dickson's Mound Builders, nor are they found in the bones of other ancient pre-Columbian peoples. Here no man is surrounded by female skeletons. The family groups are pure — one man, one woman and their off- spring. Diseased bones are occasionally found, but seem clearly to be results of infections from wounds, or other malforma- tions. 54 MOUND BUILDERS OF ILLINOIS These people were so intensely tribal in their lives that they have shown their desire to remain so in death. Their relics indicate various degrees of culture. In the upper or later portion of Dickson's mound was found pottery of very fine workmanship and texture, superior ornamenta- tion and shapes. The lower or earlier levels contain un- marked pottery, though of fine shape and finish. The flint chippings show a fine degree of craftsmanship. The material indicates a wide range, though the pure white flint was generally used. ♦fitful ifr*n*t«ii«'W»» r»*Tf*t*tirm»t»*» tr»*tT'?m m ?r?r*iu nil ; ii ?» <» This picture shows a collection of arrowheads, implements, vessels and r.nimal bones found in Dickson's Mound. The arrowheads are typical of the Cahokia group culture, as indeed are the vessels. The bones are from buffalo, elk, deer, antelope, wild-cat, wolf, etc. The shells are from the sea and from the nearby rivers. Flint knife blades, bone awls, perforated discoidal beads are shown. The large flints, lower right, are spades, not so fine as are found at the Cahokia grop. MOUND BUILDERS OF ILLINOIS 55 Some implements were found, large and strong, made of the radius of deer, also very fine, needle-like bone implements were present which may have been used in the making of clothing, etc., or possibly in tattooing. The bones of the deer, grizzly and smaller bear, elk, ante- lope, buffalo, turtle, fish, fowl, wild cat and wolf are found. A sacrum with a perfect Cahokia Mound arrowhead, deeply imbedded in it, was an interesting discovery. These people procured shells from the seacoast, hundreds of miles distant, to make their beads and which they also used in their entirety as ornaments or sacred vessels. One of the finest pieces of workmanship was found that we have ever seen. It is made from the teeth of a grizzly bear. One portion of the tooth is hollowed out, at a cost of who knows how much painstaking labor, to receive a little dagger which has been cut from a grizzly tooth of the same size. This will puzzle the craftsmen of today with their chilled steel drills and engravers' tools. How it was accom- plished with the stone tools of those ancient people will re- main a mystery. The effigy pot came from Hickman County, Ky., and like effigies have been found in the American Bottoms. The small concretions came from the base line of a mound in the Cahokia group; the larger concre- tions came from outside of stone cist near Roots. (See text, page 31.) 56 MOUND BUILDERS OF ILLINOIS THE ORIGINAL AMERICANS T is not the endeavor of the writer to settle the status of the Mound Builders. The writing of this little book, as well as the printing of it, was done merely as the diversion of one interested in the study of the ancient Indians who so completely occupied our lands hereabouts that their relics are evident on almost every farm, on every river or creek bank. In answering our craving for knowledge, we are led afield, into the outdoors, and as a healthful recreation it has repaid all our efforts. In reading the expressions of those who have made the study of our Original Americans a life work, our respect for the American Indian has been increased. We find that, as a race, they have very much to command the high regard of all thoughtful persons. The white man, filled with the greed for possession nur- tured by a culture so different from that of the American Red man, came, conquered and almost exterminated the Red peo- ple, and all their works, crowding them into our waste lands, where they have lost even their ancient exalted traditions. They have been starved and neglected and abused and robbed. In more recent years, however, steps have been taken, books have been written and educational work has been done so that the remnants of the great Red Nations are adjusting themselves somewhat to the ways of the "world." VIRGINIA INDIANS, IN 1584, WERE CLEAN, THRIFTY To overcome somewhat the prevailing opinions of the helplessness and wretched shiftlessness of the Indians, we herewith reproduce excerpts from some writers and workers, some old and some modern. To our minds the "broad chasm" linking the sedentary, industrious Mound Builders to the North American Indians of our times, dates from the times of the destructive, disturbing, crushing advent of the white con- querors. It is interesting to read a statement from the ac- count of "the first voyage of Raleigh (1584) to Virginia." (Hakluyt's Voyages. London Ed., 1600, Vol. 3, p. 304) : "After they had been divers times aboard our ships, my- MOUND BUILDERS OF ILLINOIS 57 self with seven more went 20 miles into the river that runneth toward the city of Skicoak, which river they call Ocam, and the evening following we came to an island which they call Roanoke, distant from the harbor which we entered seven leagues; and at the north end thereof was a village of nine houses built of cedar and fortified round about with sharp trees to keep out their enemies, and the entrance into it made like a turnpike very artificially. When we came toward it, standing near to the water side, the wife of Granganimo, the chief's brother, came running out to meet us very cheer- fully and friendly. * * * When we came into the outer room, having five rooms in her house, she caused us to sit down by a great fire, and after took off our clothes and washed them and dried them again; some of the women plucked off our stockings, washed them, some washed our feet in warm water, and she herself took great pains to see all things ordered in the best manner she could, making great haste to dress some meat for us to eat. * * * Their ves- sels are earthen pots, very large, white and sweet ; their dishes are wooden platters of sweet timber. v, ■ \ a > ' ; . ,A~ , ' '" '\. % ) HI^H M VESSELS FROM OKFEHMAMV MOUND, MONROE COUNTY The Mound Builders may have heen materialists, or they may have had a realization of spiritual thing's heyonl what one would ordinarily suppose. The fact that food bowls and "water bottles" are found with burials leads one to the belief that material food and drink were consigned to the ground, with the individual, with a knowledge that it would be absorbed into its original elements. The effigy "bottle" here shown on the right, has a hole in the side of it that was made there, it being the supposition of some observers that the hole was for the purpose of "killing" the pot, or to more quickly release the contents. The vessel on the left is a modified form of the "fox" vessel on page 37, the "tail" or handle reminding one of the beaver. 58 MOUND BUILDERS OF ILLINOIS CHARACTER QUALITIES OF KNOWN RED MEN IT gives us great pleasure to introduce in this work a speech delivered by Prof. Warren K. Moorehead at Circleville, Ohio, October 7, 1926, beneath "Logan Elm," on the Shawano Indians and their great leaders. The occa- sion was the meeting of the Ohio History Day Association, and in spite of threatening weather, there were 3,500 people in attendance. Prof. Moorehead's speech is instructive in general, although local in application. Prof. Moorehead has done much to teach us our duty toward the remnants of the people who were once great and who had tamed the "wilder- ness" of America hundreds, perhaps thousands of years before the advent of the white man. Nor do we here desire to argue the question, "Were the Mound Builders the Forebears of the Indians Whom the White Men Found on This Continent?" We feel it reasonable to believe that the systems or development of culture of the American Indians, like the systems of government or govern- ments by different dynasties of the Old World, either built up or tore down the development of the people at various periods of time. We reprint Prof. Moorehead's speech because, as an eminent authority on the American Indian, his utterances, as reported in the Circleville (Ohio) Watchman, are informative of the real character of the Red Men so late as the beginning of the last century. The Red Man, driven from the home he and his forefathers occupied for unnumbered generations, his well ordered system of habitation destroyed, no doubt quickly descended to the status of homeless wanderers fighting always for the right to live — for a home. Mr. Chairman, Ladies and Gentlemen : I esteem it both an honor and a privilege to appear be- fore you and speak briefly upon the lives of two great char- acters, Logan and Tecumseh, and also tell you a little con- MOUND BUILDERS OF ILLINOIS 59 cerning the Shawano Indians, commonly called the Shawnees, whose villages were in this part of our State. We are assembled on a very historic spot, historic not merely because the cabin of the earliest settler, Mr. Boggs, a man who has been fittingly honored by the first monument here erected, but also because this was the center from which radiated the activities of these same Shawano Indians. I speak informally. Obviously such a setting demands a flight of oratory. Yet the great oration, the one delivered by Logan near this spot in the fall of 1774, renders any studied effort that might be attempted today extremely fu- tile and commonplace. Indeed, since it is quite obvious that no public speaker called upon to address an assemblage gath- ered together on the field of Gettysburg would do more than refer in the highest terms to Lincoln's immortal Gettysburg address, so today, ladies and gentlemen, it would be almost a sacrilege to attempt any flight of eloquence. Moreover, I am no orator, but on the contrary, merely a student of Indian history. PAYS TRIBUTE TO RED RACE The purpose of our gathering today is to pay tribute to these people of the Red race, men, women and children, and distinguished chiefs, rather than to accord a full meed of praise to our White pioneers. This is said in no disrespect. I can speak frankly upon our Indians' wrongs, for the reason that my > own ancestor, Captain John Mason, in the State of Connecticut, in the Pequot war of 1687, was active in "pun- ishing the heathen" as he called those who were merely fight- ing to preserve their firesides and their homes. Our country today, having possessed itself of all the lands owned by the Indians, beginning with the mouth of the St. John River, in New Brunswick, and extending to the Golden Gate of Cali- fornia, can well afford to accord our original inhabitants their proper place on the page of American history. The Shawano Indians probably had their origin in the South. There is abundant evidence of this. Yet I shall not weary you with a technical dissertation today, and neither shall I present a long succession of dates and circumstances. To those who are inclined to serious study, I would commend the excellent publications of the Ohio State Archaeological and Historical Society, wherein you will find set forth in ac- curate detail most of the occurrences which I may mention. Particularly, would I recommend that you read the observa- tions of those noble missionaries, Heckewelder and Zeisberger, who present for your consideration a correct picture of the 60 MOUND BUILDERS OF ILLINOIS backwoods or frontier element responsible for most of the trouble with our Indians. These two self-sacrificing and up- right men lived with the Indians for many, many years, spoke the languages, and they are competent witnesses to the scenes, and trustworthy recorders of the events which led up to the cruelties and outrages perpetrated by the frontier element upon the Shawano Indians of the Scioto and Miami valleys. The word for "town" in Shawano is Chillicothe (Cha-la- ka-tha), and there were four or five Shawano towns, one being on the site now occupied by Portsmouth, another at Old Town, three miles north of Xenia, a third at Frankfort, Ross County, and the others here in the Pickaway Plains. These towns at no time possessed more than 400 to 500 fight- ing men. OHIO-ILLINOIS INDIANS WERE BRAVE I have always maintained that, considering their infer- iority in numbers, these Indians of Ohio were the bravest and most successful warriors in the entire United States. Briefly summarized, between the years about 1750 and 1813, they took part in twenty-two actions. We depend on our own records, the Indians having no written history. If memory does not fail me — of these twenty-two actions, we ourselves admit we were defeated eleven times ; in four the honors were even, and seven engagements resulted in victories for the Whites. Well may their few mixed-blood descendants now living in Kansas or Oklahoma be proud of these Ohio Red men. Had they possessed the numbers of the Iroquois, it is certain that the White settlements north of the Ohio River would have been delayed for a half century. We haven't time to go into detail, but I will briefly men- tion some of the actions in which the Shawano were present. Braddock's defeat, and Grant's action, near Pittsburg, in which nearly 1,000 English and Colonial troops were killed, wounded, or captured, and the rest of the army driven back to the frontier settlements. St. Clair's defeat in the western part of our own State, 1791, where nearly 1100 of that army were destroyed. They were in evidence against Harrison and Wayne in all those campaigns leading up to and through the war of 1812. We should realize the great disadvantages of these peo- ple when they contended with the superior civilization of the Whites. Most of the guns sold them by the traders were poor; they had no granaries, no cattle or farm produce on which to draw. Their means of communication were ex- MOUND BUILDERS OF ILLINOIS 61 ceedingly primitive, and they must of necessity have traveled long distances from village to village, and gathered their war- riors together to resist invasion. UNSCRUPULOUS TRADERS CURSE TO INDIANS Our early records are filled with stories of Indian attacks on the settlements of Kentucky, Pennsylvania and Virginia. It is quite true that the Indians were cruel, and murdered men, women and children. It is equally true that many of our frontier element deliberately attacked Indians in times of peace, regardless of tribal affiliation. This has extended down to modern times, and in the last Indian fight — let us hope there will never be another — at Wounded Knee, South Dakota, December, 1890, one hundred and ninety-two Sioux, mostly women and children, were shot down by our troops. James Smith, who wrote our best narrative of captivity, was with the Ohio Indians for a number of years prior to 1762. His description of unscrupulous traders is most inter- esting. They loaded pack horses with powder and ball, tomahawks, scalping knives, and whiskey, and did a lucrative business with the Ohio Indians. By common consent, the Ohio River was the boundary between the White and Indian countries, yet men of the type of Wetzel and Greathouse repeatedly crossed this river and killed Indians. Rewards offered by our officials for scalps resulted in many surprise attacks on the Indian encampments. An educated, New England woman, Elizabeth Dwight, went by stage and horseback into the heart of the Ohio coun- try in 1819. I would commend her volume to those of you who wish a portrait of conditions in the backwoods at that time. It is published by the Yale press. Coming from Con- necticut, where there was no frontier element, her minute description of the kind of men she met in the cabins and prim- itive inns does not tally with our pre-conceived notion of the so-called noble frontiersman. CHIEFS LOGAN, CORNSTALK AND TECUMSEH WERE GREAT MEN Let us consider for a few moments the lives of these three men — Logan, Cornstalk and Tecumseh. Logan's Indian name was Tah-gah-jute, meaning spying. He was born at Shamokin, Pennsylvania, about 1725, was a very peaceable man; removed to the Ohio country in 1770, and was seen by Heckewelder in 1772. He lived a few miles west of here on the Scioto, at the site we now call Westfall. G2 MOUND BUILDERS OF ILLINOIS He was a Cayuga Chief, and thus belonged to the Iroquois Confederacy. On the frontier the term, Mingo was employed to designate Iroquois living away from' the Mohawk Valley. Logan never became a warrior until his friends and relatives were destroyed by the Whites. Cornstalk, the celebrated Shawano Chief, born about 1720, probably near this spot. He was leader of the Indians in that great fight at Point Pleasant, October 19, 1774. Three years later he came to Point Pleasant to warn the settlers that his tribe might be forced into war, and to beg them to dis- continue raids into Ohio. He and his son were murdered while upon this peaceful mission by the very people they sought to aid. Tecumseh, properly Tikamthi or Tecumtha, according to the dialect of different bands. His name is variously inter- preted. His mother is thought to have belonged to the Pan- ther clan. "I stand in path" or "I oppose" might be a free translation of the Shawano meaning. He was born about 1768, six miles southwest from Springfield on Mad River. His father was killed in the battle of Point Pleasant. His elder brother was killed at his side in Wayne's victory, 1794. Tecumseh was one of three brothers born at the same time. This in itself was considered by the Indians miraculous, since Indian women seldom bore twins, and triplets were unknown. His other brother became Tenskwa-tawa, the celebrated Prophet, was painted by George Catlin in 1832, and died in 1837 in Kansas. He w T as a remarkable personality. Tecumseh himself was killed at the battle of the Thames, Canada, October 5, 1813. One might devote this entire afternoon to a considera- tion of the outstanding figure in Ohio Valley Indian history, Tecumseh, but it is necessary to omit not only that, but also interesting and dramatic episodes in the lives of all these men. No complete life of Tecumseh — one worthy of the name — has been written. It would require the pen of a Parkman to do justice to this great personage. Logan himself was not a Shawano, but he was associated with what the early settlers called the hostile element, which I prefer to term the patriotic element here in southern Ohio. That is, judged by our standards of national life, all that these people desired was to live in contentment here in the beautiful Pickaway Plains. Suppose a superior race should suddenly appear in this portion of our state — a race as far above us as we were above the Indians. Suppose that they should take our lands, inflict customs and manners of which we were totally unfamiliar upon us. I am quite certain that, MOUND BUILDERS OF ILLINOIS 63 notwithstanding our inferiority to the higher culture which such newcomers thrust upon us, we would resist with every resource at our command, the destruction of our homes and the loss of our lands. In the final analysis that is all these Indians did. TOO MUCH EMPHASIS PLACED ON BATTLE-CRUELTY Our early writers placed entirely too much emphasis on the cruelties practiced by Indians on White people. They say very little concerning the ruthless murder of Indian men, wo- men and children by our own ancestors. One of the greatest factors in bringing about the troubles during the period 1740 and 1812 is set forth in great detail by Helen Hunt Jackson in her famous "Century of Dishonor." Perhaps we do not realize that after White people had se- cured most of the land in Kentucky, Pennsylvania and Vir- ginia, and began to encroach on the north side of the river, that the Indians were summoned by our authorities to a great Council at Detroit in 1786. They petitioned our President to observe previous treaties and asked "prevent your surveyors and other people from coming upon our side of the river." GOVERNMENT MADE TREATIES; UPHELD TRESPASSERS The United States Government had assured the Indians they could reside on their lands so long as they behaved them- selves peacefully, and of trespassers (Whites) adds: "The Indians may punish him as they please." Notwithstanding sacred promises, the next year our Presi- dent ordered the Governor of the Northwest Territory : "You will not neglect any opportunity that may offer for extinguish- ing of Indian rights as far westward as the Mississippi." In 1792, the President of the United States utters these significant words : "Remember that no additional lands will be required of you," etc. And again, General Putnam said at Vincennes: "The United States does not mean to wrong you out of your lands." This was followed by an offer to give the Indians a great deal of money for additional lands. The Indian spokesman was wise in his day and generation. He told the Commissioners that money was of no value to the Indians; that the lands were needed for the sustenance of women and children ; that since the White settlers were poor, therefore the proposed money should be divided among them ! To this should be added the large sums of money which our Government must 64 MOUND BUILDERS OF ILLINOIS expend and pay in raising armies to fight the Indians ! All of which was quite clever and to the point. Whether these logical statements had any effect on our Commissioners I do not know. Finally the Indians declined to make further concessions, reminded the officials of their repeated promises against fur- ther invasions. General Anthony Wayne wrote the Secretary of War advocating aggressive measures against the Indians. We all know what happened. Their villages were burned ; their cornfields destroyed, and the Indians defeated in several actions. In a final treaty of 1795, two-thirds of the present State of Ohio was ceded to the United States, and we solemnly guaranteed these Indians all other Indian lands northward of the Ohio River, eastward of the Mississippi, and southward of the Great Lakes. This would give the Indians that north- western part of our State, most of Indiana and practically all of Illinois. It was carefully specified that the Indians could hunt and dwell within this territory as long as they pleased. We can dismiss the remainder of the wretched history with a statement that General Harrison was instructed by the President (1809) to extinguish Indian titles, and in 1817, what remained of this vast Indian domain was appropriated by our people. Now, ladies and gentlemen, please carefully note the fol- lowing statement: With the sole exception of the Iroquois treaty which still applies to Northern New York, our great and good Government has never observed a single treaty made between ourselves and an Indian tribe in any state of our Union. Is this a record of which one hundred percent Americans should be proud ? MANY "FRONTIERSMEN" WERE DISSOLUTE FELLOWS What manner of men were these first traders, frontiers- men and Indian fighters? Johnson, in the New York Colonial Documents, Volume 8, page 460, sheds light on their char- acters. He knew them : "Dissolute fellows, united with debtors, and persons of wandering disposition, who have been removing from Pennsylvania, Virginia, etc., for more than ten years past into Indian country, towards and on the Ohio, and had made a considerable number of settlements as early as 1765, when my deputy (Crogan) was sent to the Illinois, from whence he gave me a particular account of the uneasiness it occasioned among the Indians. Many of these emigrants are idle fellows that are too lazy to cultivate lands, and invited by the plenty of game they found, have employed them- selves in hunting, in which they interfere much more with the Indians MOUND BUILDERS OF ILLINOIS 65 than if they pursued agriculture alone, and the Indian hunters already begin to feel the scarcity this has occasioned, which greatly increases their resentment." The instinct of self-preservation is strong in all races. These Ohio Indians were beset on all sides by enemies. Then came our Peace Commissioners, from Philadelphia, then the seat of our Government, and they spoke honeyed words, pre- sented a paper, and again the chiefs affixed their totems to that document. Our Shawano could have removed from these beautiful Scioto fields to the Miami, thence to the Wa- bash, and then to the Illinois. They would have gained but a few short years, because the land grabbers would have fol- lowed them clear across the Middle West. The tide of White immigration could be stayed by armed force — by no other means. Tecumseh, Logan, Cornstalk, Black Fish, and the other chiefs, realized this. The war hatchet was thrown down and they took it up. They resisted to the nth degree. Those who tamely submit to imposition are not only held in contempt by their adversaries, but they leave no mark on the page of history. We respect them because they were real men. INDIANS LIVED COMFORTABLY IN CABINS Were our Ohio Indians always fighting? By no means. Their life here, and at other Indian settlements, was exceed- ingly pleasant. There was an abundance of game ; they lived in comfortable cabins, and raised crops. At the time Colonel Boquet marched to the Muskingum over two hundred White captives were surrendered by the Indians. Large numbers of these had to be bound because they desired to remain with the Indians. Numbers afterwards escaped and returned to the Indian life. Does anyone suppose that if they had been shamefully treated, Boquet's narrative would have made such statements ? On Muskingum River, Heckewelder and Zeisberger had built up a very successful mission. For a long time it was the only well built, well ordered, Christian town in the whole Ohio region. It was the outpost of civilization. Yet one William- son, accompanied by a large party of freebooters and fron- tiersmen from Kentucky, without justification, murdered up- wards of ninety Christian men, women and children. Not one of them was armed, and most of them were killed within the church. It was one of the most outrageous and cold- blooded murders ever perpetrated in American history. I challenge anyone to cite an incident where persons assembled at Divine worship, in a sacred church, were deliberately mur- dered by those against whom they had perpetrated no wrong. GG MOUND BUILDERS OF ILLINOIS DESTROYER WILLIAMSON MEETS REAL INDIAN FIGHTERS What was the result? Williamson, accompanied by Colonel Crawford, Dr. Knight, and a large force, marched north sometime later to attack the Indian towns near the San- dusky Plains. They were surprised by real lighting Indians, not harmless mission converts. The Indians desired above all things to seize Williamson, and be revenged for the murder of their kinsfolk. Heckewelder states the Indians ran about crying, "Where is Williamson?" He, however, secured a fast horse, and escaped from the action. Poor Colonel Crawford fell into the hands of the exasperated savages and was tor- tured to death, all of which was both cruel and wicked. I am sorry that those who love to dwell on the tortures of Craw- ford always gloss over what happened previous to the Craw- ford affair. Please read Heckewelder's narrative, as to why Crawford was killed. LOGAN, GREAT ORATOR; TECUMSEH, GREAT WAR CHIEF Let us consider finally, Logan and Tecumseh, particularly the latter. Logan's fame rests upon his great oration, and before you leave this field I trust you will read it. It is in im- perishable bronze over there, now standing in this park. Joseph Brant (The-yen-da-na-ga), the great Iroquois war-chief, visited the Ohio Valley. He knew Tecumseh. Tecumseh and Joseph Brant have much in common. Both were leaders, highly intelligent, brave and fighting men. Each was a born orator, and each knew how to play on the feelings of his followers. The martial spirit appealed to both alike. It was Brant, when asked by the King of England, "Are you fond of music?" who replied, "I like the harp, I like the organ much better, but I love the fife and drum best of all because they make my heart beat quick." It was Te- cumseh who, when asked to sit upon the platform with the officers at one of the treaties, and not wishing to place him- self in the power of White men whom he had every reason to distrust, uttered this significant epigram : "The sun is my father, the earth is my mother, on her bosom I will repose," and seated himself among his warriors. It is now one hundred and thirty years since the Shawano left this part of Ohio. It is more than one hundred years since they have resided in any numbers within the borders of our state. There are no full blood Shawanoes remaining in either Kansas or Oklahoma. We have inherited this vast do- MOUND BUILDERS OF ILLINOIS 67 main. The Indian life is all a memory, a dim tradition. Those wars of long ago are forgotten! likewise the cruelties which were practiced with equal fervor by both Reds and Whites. It is well that we have erected monuments to our military leaders and our first settlers, and it is exceedingly fitting that the most imposing one of the four here is the tribute to Logan himself. I say "four" because the great Logan Elm was the first, the real monument. Logan's speech, rather than Dunmore's treaty, renders this spot immortal. And the greatest and noblest of them all — Tecumseh — who fought men, and killed neither women nor children — does he not deserve a shaft ? I would that we knew the exact spot of his birth — where the Prophet, his brother, and himself saw the light of day. The Ohio country is our heritage — we can well afford to be gracious. Let us not omit the name of Tecumseh from our records in stone and bronze. DISPLAYS INDIANS' ANCIENT WAR FLAG In the northwestern part of our State, and also in that last engagement on the Thames, fought side by side the northern Algonquins, the Ojibwa, with our Ohio Algonquins, the Shawano. Let me present to you the original Ojibwa war flag. It is one hundred and twenty years old, and the Chiefs Me-shusk-gee-shig and Mah-in-gonce gave it to me at White Earth reservation in Minnesota in the year 1909, and it be- longs to our Museum at Andover. It is of owl and not eagle feathers, for the owl was sacred to the Ojibwa. Ne-gan-ne- bin-ace, their fighting chief, carried it. It was captured by the Sioux, enemies of the Ojibwa, held for many years, and retaken by Ne-gan-ne-bin-ace and his brave warriors. Prob- ably the only positively old and original Indian flag belong- ing to Eastern Algonquins in existence today. The Indians prized and revered it, even as we do "Old Glory," our own sacred symbol. No emblem belonging to our own Ohio In- dians remains — therefore I do not consider it inappropriate to exhibit that one carried by their allies. (Here he exhibited the feather flag.) The villages of these simple, yet heroic, Shawanoes are gone forever. Tecumseh lies in an unknown and forgotten grave. All our treaties with his band were deliberately broken by us. We cannot undo the evils of the past, but it is not too late to honor the memory of him who stood fore- most among American aborigines. Well may it be said of him: "Greater love hath no man than that he die for his country." Certainly his deeds and his character merit a dig- nified and a fitting memorial.