r*' 1557.73 Gr-16 c. 3 '/m « STATE OF ILLINOIS DEPARTMENT OF REGISTRATION AND EDUCATION A. M. SHELTON, Director DIVISION OF THE STATE GEOLOGICAL SURVEY M. M. LEIGHTON. Chief REPORT OF INVESTIGATIONS—NO. 16 THE OIL AND GAS RESOURCES OF THE AVA-CAMPBELL HILL AREA BY TOWNER B. ROOT ILLINOIS STATE LIBRARY PRINTED BY AUTHORITY OF THE STATE OF ILLINOIS URBANA, ILLINOIS 1928 STATE OF ILLINOIS DEPARTMENT OF REGISTRATION AND EDUCATION A. M. SHELTON, Director DIVISION OF THE STATE GEOLOGICAL SURVEY M. M. LEIGHTON. Chief REPORT OF INVESTIGATIONS—NO. 16 THE OIL AND GAS RESOURCES OF THE AVA-CAMPBELL HILL AREA BY TOWNER B. ROOT PRINTED BY AUTHORITY OF THE STATE OF ILLINOIS URBANA, ILLINOIS 1928 ILLINOIS STATE LIBRARY STATE OF ILLINOIS DEPARTMENT OF REGISTRATION AND EDUCATION A. M. SHELTON, Director DIVISION OF THE STATE GEOLOGICAL SURVEY M. M. LEIGHTON. Chief Committee of the Board of Natural Resources and Conservation A. M. Shelton, Chairman Director of Registration and Education Charles M. Thompson Representing the President of the Uni¬ versity of Illinois Epson S. Bastin Geologist Jeffersons Printing & Stationery Co. Springfield, Illinois 1928 c -J CONTENTS Introduction. Previous work and acknowledgments. Location and general description . General structural relations . Geology . Stratigraphy . Chester beds . Pottsville beds . Higher Pennsylvanian beds . Structural geology ... Sources of information . Structure . Faults . Oil and gas . Producing areas . Lange pool . Rickenburg pool . Combs-Carter pool . Carter pool . Combs pool . Ditch pool . Downen pool . Geberding pool . Morris pool . Smaller producing areas . Exploration outside the producing area. Gas and oil showings . Dry holes . Untested strata in the main Campbell Hill Anticline Shallow testing of other structures. Levan anticline . Minor structures ... Page 5 5 6 7 7 7 7 9 10 10 10 11 12 13 13 13 16 16 17 17 18 19 20 21 22 22 22 23 24 25 25 26 3 ILLUSTRATIONS Figure Page 1 Index map showing the area of this report. 6 2 Cross-section along the axis of the Campbell Hill anticline (PI. Ill line A-B) . 14 3 Cross-section through Geberding-Lange pools (PI. Ill line E-F). 18 4 Cross-section through Modglin-Ditch and Carter pools (PI. Ill line C-D) 20 Plate Pocket I Columnar section for the Ava-Campbell Hill area. II Structure map of the Campbell Hill area showing the elevation of the Ava shale and the Herrin (No. 6) coal. Ill Structure map of the Campbell Hill gas fields showing the elevation of the Menard limestone. 4 OIL AND GAS RESOURCES OF THE AVA-CAMPBELL HILL AREA By Towner B. Root INTRODUCTION The Ava-Campbell Hill district of southwestern Illinois has been producing natural gas for more than ten years. Drilling during and be¬ fore 1916 had shown the presence of both oil and gas, and the gas from one well on the Froemling property was piped for use in the house of the land owner. Nevertheless, systematic and extensive develop¬ ment was not begun until the Mid Egypt Oil and Gas Company started operations in the region in February, 1918. Gas was first marketed in October, 1921, and since then has been produced at a rate of about 450,000 to 500,000 cubic feet per day. The oil production has been less im¬ portant; the estimate of total production up to midsummer, 1925, was from 20,000 to 25,000 barrels. The production of both gas and oil has declined recently, and drilling in the last few years has developed pro¬ gressively smaller wells. PREVIOUS WORK AND ACKNOWLEDGMENTS In 1912 Mr. E. W. Shaw and Dr. T. E. Savage reported on the Mur- physboro quadrangle in folio No. 185 of the United States Geological Survey. In 1914 Mr. H. A. Wheeler published a map of Illinois, showing an area of gas production in the Ava region, in Volume 48 of the Trans¬ actions of the American Institute of Mining Engineers. In 1917 Mr. Stuart St. Clair published a short report on the “Oil possibilities of the Ava area” in Bulletin 35 of the Illinois State Geological Survey. In 1919 Dr. J. Marvin Weller mapped the geology of the Campbell Hill quad¬ rangle for this Survey, but this has not been published. Grateful ac¬ knowledgment is given for the material obtained from these sources. The cooperation of the Mid Egypt Oil and Gas Company and of the Willis Coal and Mining Company in making available important data is gratefully acknowledged. Thanks are especially due to Dr. U. S. Grant of Northwestern University, geologist for the Mid Egypt Oil and Gas Company, and to Mr. A. L. Pratt, head driller, and Mr. Fred A. Krewer, engineer of the Willis Coal and Mining Company. 5 6 AVA-CAMPBELL HILL AREA The field work was done during the summers of 1924 and 1925, and the writer was assisted by Mr. William E. Powers, Mr. John T. McCor- mack, and Mr. Joseph H. Markley, Jr. LOCATION AND GENERAL DESCRIPTION The Ava-Campbell Hill district is located in southwestern Illinois and includes the northwest corner of Jackson County, the southwest corner of Perry County, and an adjacent strip of Randolph County (fig. 1). All but one of the producing wells of the district are located Fig. 1. Index map showing the location of the area discussed in this report and other oil fields in central and southwestern Illinois. in Bradley Township, (T. 7 S., R. 4 W.) in the northwest corner of Jackson County. The district is naturally divided into two contrasting physiographic units: (1) a more or less rough and broken highland to the south and west; (2) relatively level lowlands to the north and east. The boundary between the two is indefinite except at the northeastern edge of the Campbell Hill anticline where it is marked by an abrupt change in topo¬ graphy. The highland is underlain by the older rocks of early Pennsyl¬ vanian (Pottsville) and late Mississippian (Chester) age, principally ILLINOIS STATE GEOLOICAL SURVEY Urbana, Illinois Revised Copy- Report of Investigations No. 16 "Oil and Gas Resources of the Ava-Campbell Hill Area" In the first distribution of this report, serious errors appeared in the table on page 8, in the discussion of the Lange well on page 24, and in the generalized columnar section shown on Plate I. Revised copies are being prepared to cover all of the first distribution and will be mailed within a few days. In order that the old copies may be with¬ drawn from reference to avoid confusion in the future, request is urgently made that upon receipt of the new copy, the old be returned to this Survey under cover of the self-addressed stamped envelope which will be enclosed with the new copy. The author of the report does not share in the responsibility for the errors referred to above. M. M. Leighton, Chief June 1, 1928. OIL AND GAS RESOURCES 7 sandstones in this area, which resist erosion and produce the rough topo¬ graphy. The lowlands are underlain by the softer beds of later Pennsyl¬ vanian age (Carbondale and McLeansboro), which consist largely of shale with some sandstone, limestone, and coal beds. GENERAL STRUCTURAL RELATIONS The principal structural feature of the region is the Campbell Hill anticline, an asymmetrical fold dipping more steeply to the north, which is elongated in a general southwest direction. The highland of the area is directly due to the physiographic effect of the Campbell Hill anticline. The areas northwest and southeast of the anticlinal ridge show somewhat less markedly the physiographic effect of the underlying structural basins and small subsidiary anticlines locally show up as ridges, as for example at Wine Hill, and in secs. 10 and 16, T. 8 S., R. 3 W., (Levan Township) Jackson County. GEOLOGY Stratigraphy The columnar section (PI. 1) shows the character of the rock forma¬ tions which occur in the Campbell Hill area as determined from examina¬ tions of well records and outcrops. The best known of these beds are as follows: (1) The Chester series of formations of the upper Mississippian, (2) the Pottsville series of the lower Pennsylvanian, and (3) the Car¬ bondale and McLeansboro coal-bearing beds of upper Pennsylvanian. Data on the beds underlying the Chester were obtained from one well only, for no others in the area have penetrated these lower strata. Below the Chester the rocks are predominately limestone. (See the columnar section and the table of data for a general description of these beds.) CHESTER BEDS The Chester beds, from which the gas and oil of the region are de¬ rived, consist of sandstones, shales, and limestones, and show this se¬ quence of beds repeated several times. The sandstones are typically the lowest beds in each group and commonly lie on an eroded limestone surface. As shown in the columnar section, the Chester series in this region consists of 16 formations. All of these may be recognized more or less clearly in those well logs of the area which are detailed and accurate. Production is limited to two of these formations: (a) the Cypress sand¬ stone, fifth from the base, the more important producer; and (b) the Tar Springs sandstone, ninth from the base, which is productive only locallv. AVA-CAMPBELL HILL AREA w, o ■ 4—' 1 O £ • *— o in t— r— CV O 4—* C/) cv » ' < 4—* O m O m CJ r -1 Cv «n - fc£ oT“ o in — CM J) hs m lo o <5j Cv o CJ u VO o ct VO ct Cv o CO T ~ l in CM O fc/: bp >-> s m m CM C .c o k. 4 —* CT, a w ^S 5 CJ rN, w a 0 +j Cfi ct u o c n r- <—• c 2 r - 1 o 4 —* CJ CJ .O u CJ ct CO o C /3 > J. CJ C ffi n U E ■i c K. \> .2 - 4—1 cj f — 1 c u o (o > 5 a w OIL AXD GAS RESOURCES 9 Because of the erosional unconformity at the base of the Pennsyl¬ vanian series, one or more of the upper formations of the Chester series is usually missing. The three upper formations, the Clore, Degonia, and Kinkaid, outcrop in the valleys along the southern and western edges of the area described. The total thickness of the Chester series is more than 1000 feet. At Sugar Hill, in secs. 4, 8, and 9, T. 7 S., R. 3 W. (Ora Township), it is 1,268 feet thick. POTTSVILLE BEDS The Pottsville beds outcrop over a larger part of the area than do the Chester formations, and consist largely of massive sandstone beds alternating with shales, shaly sandstones, and local beds of coal. The beds are not uniform in character, but range from cross-bedded and rip¬ ple marked sandstones to shales which vary widely in both composition and thickness. In places the shaly layers thin out and disappear so that locally two or three of the sandstones may form an apparent strati¬ graphic unit, as for example, at Sugar Hill. The sandstones are more abundant toward the south and east, thinning out among the increas¬ ingly shaly beds towards the north and west. None of the Pottsville beds is productive of oil or gas in this region. A shale bed which is fairly persistent and extensive occurs in the upper part of the Pottsville and for the sake of convenience is called the Ava Shale. It can be identified in many outcrops and well records. Throughout the greater part of the area the Ava shale has been used as the key horizon for the contour map which shows the structure of the Pennsylvanian beds (PI. II). Although the Ava shale is irregular in thickness and locally is missing in both outcrops and well logs, it was found to be the best horizon to use over so large an area. The maximum thickness of the Pottsville is difficult to measure because the top of the Pottsville is arbitrarily taken as the base of the Murphysboro (No. 2) coal, and the coal has been removed by erosion in most of the places where wells have been drilled through to the Chester. Also the unconformity immediately above the Chester brings the basal Pottsville sandstone in many places in contact with very similar upper Chester sandstones, so that from a well log it is difficult to locate the contact. In certain wells in the eastern part of the area the Pottsville is not less than 400 feet thick but it is thinner in most other sections, par¬ ticularly at the western edge of the area where at Wine Hill its thick¬ ness is estimated at 175 feet. 10 AVA-CAMPBELL HILL AREA HIGHER PENNSYLVANIAN BEDS The higher Pennsylvanian • beds, of the age usually described as Carbondale and McLeansboro, are more uniform in character than the Pottsville. Shale is the dominant rock. There are some irregular sand¬ stone beds, notably one slightly above the basal coal that has been named the Yergennes sandstone, 1 and another immediately below the Herrin (No. 6) coal at the top of the Carbondale. In addition to the shales and sandstones there are several important coal seams with associated thin limestone layers. None of these upper Pennsylvanian beds is pro¬ ductive of oil or gas in this area. The Carbondale immediately overlies the Pottsville and includes the group of beds which occurs between the base of the Murphysboro (No. 2) coal and the top of the Herrin (No. 6) coal. A third important coal, the Harrisburg (No. 5), occurs a short distance below the top of the Car¬ bondale group. The thickness of the Carbondale is about 275 feet in the Gallagher well, sec. 17, T. 6 S., R. 4 W., Perry County, just north of the area, where the best data on the thickness were available. The Herrin (No. 6) coal at the top of the Carbondale is about the highest recognizable bed which is persistent in the structurally low por¬ tions of the area. Therefore, it has been used as a key horizon for struc¬ ture contours in the north parts of the area where data on the Ava shale are lacking. Intervals between the two Pennsylvanian key horizons were determined as follows: SW. corner sec. 4, T. 7 S., R. 4 W. (Bradley Township) 314 feet; NW. p; sec. 31, T. 6 S., R. 2 W. (Duquoin Town¬ ship) 335 feet; NE. Rf sec. 32, T. 6 S., R. 4 W. (Southwestern Township), 393 feet. Although the variation in this interval is considerable over dis¬ tances of a few miles, the local variation appears to be generally slight, so that the structure of the Herrin (No. 6) coal may be given the same consideration as that of the Ava shale. The greatest measured thickness of McLeansboro strata, or the Pennsylvanian strata above the Herrin (No. 6) coal, in this area, is 9 7V 2 feet, recorded in the log of a well two miles north of Willisville. Structural Geology SOURCES OF INFORMATION Outcrops in the northeastern plains part of the area are rare because of a covering of glacial and alluvial debris. In the highland area to the south and west outcrops are more abundant, although locally there is i Shaw, E W„ and Savage, T. E., U. S. Geol. Survey Geol. Atlas, No. 1S5, Murphys- boro-Herrm folio, p. 7, 1912. OIL AND GAS RESOURCE'S . 11 much unconsolidated surficial material. Levels were run with a planetable and a telescopic alidade to outcrops which could he used for determining structural conditions, and to wells, mines, and borings for which data are available. The structural data obtained from a study of outcrops have been supplemented wherever possible by data from well logs and mines. As shown on the structure map, data on the Ava shale were avail¬ able for the greater part of the area. In the low area to the north, test borings for coal provided useful data for determining the structure. Oil and gas tests are numerous along the crest of the anticline and provide data both on the shallow Pennsylvanian beds and on the deeper Chester beds. STRUCTURE The principal structural feature of the Ava-Campbell Hill district is an elongate, irregular, asymmetrical anticline. The location, extent, and character of the folds are shown on Plate II by structure contours on Pennsylvanian beds. From the southwest portion of the area mapped to the east line of Bradley Township the axis of the Campbell Hill anticline trends about N. 55° E.; there the trend changes to nearly due east. The highest part of the anticline is located along the axis in secs. 12, 13, and 14, Bradley Township. The crest of the fold slopes gently from this high area to the southwest, and near the edge of the area mapped it rises again almost to the altitude of the highest part of the anticline, as the general struc¬ ture map (PI. II) shows. The plunge of the fold to the east is more marked, particularly eastward from the vicinity of sec. 4, Ora Township. The north and west slopes of the arch are notably steeper than the south slopes. The local dips on the northwest flank are commonly 5° to 8°; but the maximum sustained dip is less than 3^4°. On the southeast flank local dips are usually less than 5° and the steepest sustained dip is slightly over 1°. On both flanks, however, irregularities and reversals of dips occur and locally higher angles of dip are found. On the north and northwest of the Campbell Hill anticline gentle dips in a northerly direction are prevalent. Eastward dipping strata on the west side of the area form a basin. West of this basin there is a local uplift of some prominence known as the Wine Hill dome. Only one structure contour completely encloses this dome on the map, but the dips on three sides are fairly pronounced. A fault, trending nearly parallel to the strike of the beds, probably lies a short distance southwest of the highest part of this uplift. South of the Campbell Hill anticline the dips are rather irregular and generally are low. 12 AVA-CAMPBELL HILL AREA The Levan anticline is located in the southeast part of the area mapped, in Levan Township. This structure is elongated in a north- south direction and is situated just west of a zone of pronounced east¬ ward dip which occurs along most of the east side of the area. The Levan anticline dips more steeply to the east, instead of to the north¬ west as does the Campbell Hill anticline. The territory between the Levan anticline and the larger Campbell Hill anticline to the north is structurally higher than that either east or west of it, thus forming a saddle. Other less important structural features, several of which are de¬ scribed below, as well as the details of their character and location, are shown on the structural geology map (PI. II). FAULTS A southeast-northwest fault probably crosses the Wine Hill dome as mentioned above. The fault is nowhere visible, but it is strongly sug¬ gested by local changes in key-bed elevations and by abrupt changes in stratigraphy. A zone of faulting is clearly seen in outcrops north of the east end of the main arch, especially in sec. 4, Bradley Township. One fault in secs. 2 and 11, Bradley Township, which can be seen in two places, has a vertical displacement of about 10 feet and two smaller faults, one on either side of the large fault at the northwestern exposure, have smaller displacements. The faults are roughly parallel and trend N. 40 3 W., with the downthrow sides to the northeast. One of the faults of this zone probably extends northwest, for it is indicated by abrupt changes in key-bed elevations in the area southwest of the one-contour elevation in secs. 32 and 33, Southwestern Township. The extension of the fault was not seen in the field but its supposed course is shown on the map by broken red line (Plate II). Where visible, the downthrow side of this fault is to the southwest. Its trend is parallel to the structure contours in the south central part of sec. 32. Faults have been observed in other parts of the area. In general the trend of the faults is northwest to west-northwest, nearly at right angles to the axis of the arch. The known faults are closely related to the topography and correspond in position to certain indentations of the topographic contour lines. Similar indentations of the topographic contour lines, where faults could not be directly observed, may likewise be related to faults or they may represent the dying-out of faults in cross folds. It seems possible that most or all of these offsets in the regularity of the topographic outline of the arch along the north flank in the north¬ west part of Ora Township may have been caused by undetected fault- OIL AND GAS RESOURCES 13 in g. It is probable that in the area as a whole faulting has taken place to a far greater extent than can be observed from present outcrops. None of the known faults has a great displacement, in so far as determinable. The only one of considerable displacement is just east of the center of sec. 4, Bradley Township, where the northeast side rises about 60 feet. OIL AND GAS Although oil and gas both are produced in the area, the gas pro¬ duction has been of greater commercial importance thus far, and as yet there is no expectation that oil production will increase in importance to any marked degree. None of the wells obtained large production, probably because of the irregularity and thinness of most of the Chester sands. The discovery of larger production appears to depend on the pos¬ sible presence of deeper and more favorable productive sands. This is discussed on a later page. The producing areas as shown in Plate II are on the high part of the main Campbell Hill anticline. The relation of the producing areas to the structure of the Menard limestone of the Chester series, as well as of the oil to gas producing areas, is shown on Plate III. Marketable oil and gas have come from only two of the Chester for¬ mations in the Campbell Hill area; the Tar Springs and the Cypress sandstones. The larger part of the gas production, and the oil produc¬ tion in two of the three oil pools, is from the Cypress sandstone. As the map shows (PI. Ill), the productive areas are small in extent and are not all located on the highest points of the local domes along the Campbell Hill anticline. The relations between the geologic condi¬ tions and the accumulation of oil and gas in this area are further shown by the several detailed cross-sections. Producing Areas LANGE POOL The Lange pool, as is shown on Plate III, has the largest producing area, and extends over the highest portion of the Chester structure shown on the map. Eight of the twenty-seven producing wells in the area are located in this pool. The gas production is obtained from the lower sandstone member of the Cypress, here 33 feet thick and 900 feet below the surface at the crest of the structure. This bed is usually permeable and porous; there¬ fore accumulation of gas on the highest part of the structure, as found here, is to be expected. This relation is shown by the cross-sections 14 AVA-CAMI’REF.L HTf.E AREA 600 500 400 300 200 100 Sea level 100 200 300 400 500 Illinois State Geological Survey A Ste. Genevieve-, Limestone Shale EZD Sandstone GIRed Rock Fig. 2. Cross-section along axis of lation to oil and gas accumulation. mu. i 1 1 ut i H i iumu.iu.iui ii n uh i hujih i - i m nilj i iuimuMi i .wmu . ii ni lll T iyi OIL AND GAS RESOURCES 15 ?glShaly limestone EE3 Sandy shale Sandy limestone gH Sandy limestone with shale B (PI. Ill) showing the structure and sand conditions and their re 16 AVA-CAMPBELL HILL AREA (figs. 2 and 3). The producing area of the Lange pool is outlined by wells which found water in the lower Cypress sand. A test on this part of the structure has been drilled through the Thebes sandstone to a total depth of 2530 feet and found nothing below the Chester except a show of oil in the top of the Thebes sand, gee rey i g g4 sec. 9, Ora Township. To the east of them, in the NW. corner sec. 8, Vergennes Township, (see PI. II) another dry hole was drilled into the base of the Chester, probably well into the Aux Vases sandstone. It is located on what is apparently the eastward continuation of the main Campbell Hill anticline, here reduced to a low arch of little or no surface expression. To the southwest of the producing area, holes have been drilled along the more favorable parts of the anticline in the SE. 34 sec. 16 (see PI. Ill), the NW. 34 SW. 34 sec. 15, and NW. corner SE. 34> SW. corner NE. 34, and SW. corner SE. 34 SE. 34 sec. 20 of Bradley Township. Several of these penetrate the Yankeetown sand, and the one at the crest of the arch in NW. corner SE. 34 sec. 20 goes into Aux Vases sand. All of them are dry, and they serve to delimit the Chester production towards the southwest, for the arch flattens out in that direction beyond them. Within this area only two wells have been drilled into the pro¬ ductive sand horizons south of the main anticline and both of these are dry holes. One of them tested the highest part of the Levan anticline in NE. 34 SW. 34 sec. 10, Levan Township (see PI. II). The other is located in the SW. corner NW. 34 NW. 34 sec. 24, Bradley Township, at the 24 AVA-CAMPBELL HILL AREA southeastern border of the Campbell Hill anticline, where the structural slope flattens out into the saddle mentioned on page 12. Both holes were drilled through the base of the Chester beds and into the Ste. Genevieve limestone below. North of the Campbell Hill anticline two wells have been drilled into the Cypress formation and both were dry holes. One of these lies in the NE. 34 NE. 34 sec. 32, Southwestern Township, on the lower north flank of the anticline. The other is nearly three miles to the north, in sec. 17 of Southwestern Township, and is in an area which is structurally nearly flat. Other dry holes are shown on Plates II and III, but most of them test only the Pennsylvanian or upper Chester rocks and have not penetrated the oil- and gas-bearing beds of the lower Chester. UNTESTED STRATA IN THE MAIN CAMPBELL HILL ANTICLINE 2 Recent development in the more favorable local domes along the highest part of the Campbell Hill anticline has resulted in thorough test¬ ing of the more shallow zones. Each of the suitable localities has been tested to the Yankeetown sand, and a well was drilled to test lower for¬ mations in the Lange pool in the NW. 34 SE. 34 NE. Ya sec. 15, Bradley Township, which reached a total depth of 25,30 feet, the greatest depth attained by any well in the area or nearby. This deep well passed through the recognized Chester and Lower Mississippian series and entered a thick shale sequence at 2020 feet, the correlation of which is uncertain. This shale occupies the normal place in the stratigraphic section of the Kinderhook-Chattanooga formations, but it more closely resembles the Maquoketa shale in lithology. If this is the Maquoketa shale, the Silurian and Devonian formations have been removed by pre-Mississippian erosion in this area, as they were in Mon¬ roe County on the Waterloo and Valmeyer anticlines. Immediately be¬ neath the shale, at a depth of 2410 feet, the drill entered a very cherty limestone, in which the well ended at a depth of 2530 feet. The very cherty character of this limestone is typical of the Devonian limestone underlying the Chattanooga shale, whereas the Kimmswick limestone beneath the Maquoketa formation has very little chert. It seems likely, therefore, that the normal stratigraphic sequence prevails here. 2 The study of the Lange well was made by other members of the Survey staff who also collaborated in preparing the statement regarding the testing of deeper strata in the main Campbell Hill anticline. The author of this report did not have opportunity to study the well cutting samples from the well or to compile the generalized columnar section below the Chester series shown on Plate I.—Editoi"’s note. OIL AND GAS RESOURCES 25 Assuming this to be true, the possibilities of the Kimmswick-Plattin (“Trenton”) limestone have not been determined. The top of the Kimms- wick probably lies about 1000 feet beneath the base of the Kinderhook- Chattanooga shale. If this shale is the Maquoketa, the St. Peter sandstone would be reached at a depth of some 600 feet beneath this shale. The St. Peter sandstone is of interest to oil men at the present time for it is similar in character to and is the approximate stratigraphic equivalent of the Wil¬ cox sand of Oklahoma. Further, the generally open texture of this sand¬ stone gives promise of good possibility of the proper conditions of per¬ meability for satisfactory oil or gas production. The overlying lime¬ stone may be assumed to have contained abundant source material for forming petroleum and gas. In view of the above considerations it is believed that drilling to test the St. Peter sandstone is desirable. If the structure is to be tested thoroughly, two deep wells will be necessary. One of these should be located in the NW. 34 NW. 34 sec. 14, Bradley Township, near or within the highest structure contour as shown on Plate III, and the other either in the structurally high area of the Rickenburg pool in the NE. 34 sec. H (see PI. Ill) or in the struc¬ turally high area in the NE. 34 NW. 34 sec. 12, Bradley Township. Because of the faulting to the west of this second location, which should serve to interrupt the circulation of fluids through any porous rock bed, it seems possible that the latter location is to be preferred to the one in sec. 11. SHALLOW TESTING OL OTHER STRUCTURES Levan Anticline The Levan anticline is the most pronounced structure outside of the strongly folded Campbell Hill anticline. As Plate II shows, the highest point of this structure is located in sec. 10, Levan Township, and is marked by a two-contour closure. This structure has been tested through the Chester by only one well which found no showings of oil or gas. According to the best available information this well does not condemn the Levan anticline any more than one of the dry holes drilled on the Campbell Hill anticline condemns that structure, for the presence of properly permeable sand bodies, as well as favorable structural feat¬ ures, is necessary for oil and gas production. The records available do not show whether this well on the top of the Levan anticline found any water in either the Tar Springs or Cypress sands, although it is known that in a well drilled in sec. 16 in which the Tar Springs sand was only 10 feet lower structurally, salt water was found. The Cypress sand, however, was not reported to have contained water in this latter well. 26 AVA-CAMPBELL HILL AREA In case the dry hole in sec. 10 failed to find water in either the Tar Springs or Cypress sands, then only the location and not the structure is condemned. Minor Structures Other structures possibly favorable for oil and gas accumulation which might be worth testing through the Chester will be described, in so far as possible in their order of merit, although there is little choice between them. None of them is strongly folded, and in even the most favorable the uncertainty of getting production is high because of the very irregular and unpredictable occurrence of the oil and gas in the Chester beds. Consequently a structure should not be condemned on the basis of only one dry hole. On the eastern extension of the main anticline there is a spot in the NW. %. sec. 11, Ora Township, where a test might be made. The anticline is narrow here, and the topography indicates a local bulge on it which the structural data were not complete enough to show. The nearest oil tests are two wells a mile and a half to the west-northwest along the southern boundary of sec. 4. Both of these go through the base of the Chester; one found only a small show of oil in the lower Yankeetown, the other was dry. A dry hole is also located about three miles to the east in the northwest corner of sec. 8, Vergennes Township, referred to before as having gone into the Aux Vases sandstone with negative results. A single additional hole should suffice to test the possibilities of the struc¬ ture, and it should be located on the crest of the ridge at or near its highest point, in the NE. ^4 NW. sec. H- The Tar Springs sand should be encountered at a depth of from 700 to 750 feet; the Cypress at from 880 to 930 feet; and the Yankeetown at from 1140 to 1190 feet. The area which appears to have the next best possibilities for testing is the Wine Hill dome in sec. 5 of Wine Hill Township. This structure was described on page 11 as a one-contour dome, and reference was made to the fault along its southwest flank. The possibility of a detri¬ mental effect on possible oil and gas accumulation as a result of this faulting seems negligible, for in the Rickenburg, Combs, and Carter pools nearby, faulting apparently has had little effect either in the ac¬ cumulation or dispersion of the oil and gas. No deep wells are known near the Wine Hill structure except one about four miles northwest, in sec. 23 of Bremen Township, in which some gas was encountered but was drowned out by salt water. The horizon which showed the gas has not been determined but it is known that it is in the Chester series. A single test well on the Wine Hill dome might be enough to test it and should be located on the highest part of the hill, either in the area shown on the topographic map as inclosed by the 620-foot contour or slightly OIL Ai\ T D GAS RESOURCES 27 north of it. The Tar Springs sand should be encountered at a depth of about 400 feet; the Cypress sand at about 650 feet; and the Yankeetown sand at about 750 feet. Another place for a test is shown on Plate III as a broad one- contour closure in the E. ^ sec. 32 and the W. ^4 sec. 33, Southwestern Township. The data are not full enough to recommend an exact loca¬ tion for drilling but a hole about in the middle of the eastern boundary of sec. 32 would test the structure. There are no deep drill-holes nearer than those along the Campbell Hill anticline three miles southeast. The Tar Springs sand should be entered at a depth of about 575 feet; the Cypress at about 850 feet; and the Yankeetown at about 975 feet. Near the SW. corner sec. 34, Bradley Township* there is another location which might repay a test. It is a two-contour closure of small area, flanked on the west by a rather steep syncline. No holes which encounter the productive sands are nearer than those along the main anticline to the north, in secs. 20 and 22, Bradley Township. The struc¬ ture could be tested by a single well located about 700 feet east and 200 feet north of the SW. corner sec. 34. The Tar Springs sand should be encountered at a depth of about 450 feet; the Cypress at about 750 feet; and the Yankeetown at about 875 feet. In secs. 33 and 34 of Ora Township the flattened northern end of the Levan anticline offers another site for testing the Chester sands. This is the least favorable of all the locations shown on Plate II, for there is no closure, and the crest of the anticline is broad and ill-defined. The test hole should be located near the line between secs. 33 and 34, about three-eighths of a mile north of their southern boundary. The nearest well which penetrates the Chester sands is the one in sec. 10 which was referred to before as a dry hole. The Tar Springs sand should be entered at a depth of about 700 feet; the Cypress at about 1025 feet; and the Yankeetown at about 1175 feet. . J200 • ItfQO 1300 1300 I TOO JOCO 900 300 r \00 'xr: —• »r«- I ; : xTvX"] -TL'XXX {>• ■ VJ x. r : jo x.x * • -• - - : I -- - 1 . X ; T- :l *. .*-4 1C x--J ::ir± j~1 Et 7 E 11 ::r :x: ... X J XI - -v— • 1 — ■l- ■■ — .. • » * ' ‘ Vi ■ ■ vnrv . ■ > 1 > » * «i xxixx rt ■l.VX/j » • ♦ * <* fa* 4 a » ■ : :-i ,.x: T x.x Zt “ X' tx Vx* 4 ■ •‘•r • » « 1 • • ; • » * * • • ‘ ♦ ♦ ' C».ocjc i*uQ'i(o;je k G^bi.eu* ; I ! {!j .o.-;;-‘.nro afjyqa(o»«i • CP a i>- a ■ li j - .•;.! Vf J « V (• o,:o»ic» J i :;y :/,}.4fOt, - ■ ‘.to:; :• ' ■*• J iifXf 7.-, 'UJ'y - j;)O.X;rur JtU/O^OU© n *r? r a-v f- Illinois State Geological Survey Report of Investigations No. 16, Plate I Formation Series System ICO :: 2M 400 700 800 900 1000 1100 1200 1300 1400 1500 1600 1800 1900 2000 2100 2700 No. 6 coal No. 6 cool McLeanaboro formation Carbondale formation PottsvtDe formation Klnkald limestone Degonla sandstone Clore formation Palestine sandstone Menard limestone Vienna 9hale Tar Spring* ■nndstone Glen Dean llmeetone Hardlnsburg sandstone Golconda limestone Cyprees sandstone Paint Creek formntlon Yankee town sandstone Renault formation Aui Vases sandstone Ste. Genevieve llmeetone St Louie llmostono Spergen llmeetone Warsaw-Keokuk llmeetone Kiadsrbook- OiftiTvooca shale iRKBSketaT) Deroeiaa Luaeetooe l Klrr-gjwlck 7) I I J ' 5 . O. S I 1 1 3100 Generalized columnar section for the Ava-Campbell Hill area I-owcr Minsisnlppian PLATE II Y 1V*T>2 ITA/ir' rioh jjI / / P —-j—*——' y / \ V \ : Vi V Illinois State Geological Survey Report of Investigations No. 16, Plate II 31 1 _ General map of the Ava-Campbell Hill area with structure contours showing the elevation of the Ava shale in black and the Herrin (No. 6) coal in red. The producing areas, areas recommended for prospecting, a nd oil tests drilled outside the producing areas are shown by appropriate symbols. t Producing (iron* Observed fault Inferred fault Contour "bowing elevation of tho Ava nhnla Contour showing approximate olovatlon of tho Ava shale Dry hole, show of oil In Yankeetown sandstone Dry hole, tested Into: Yunkootown sandstone Cypress sandstone Tar Springs sandstone Areas recommended for drilling Observed fault Inferred fault Contour showing elevation of Herrin (No. 6) coal Contour showing approximate elevation of Herrin (No. 0) coal Illinois State Geological Survey Report of Investigations No. 16, Plate III Show of gas—well abandoned Oil-producing area Show of oil—well abandoned Show of oil in Yankeetown sandstone Show of gas in other Chester formations Dry hole tested into: ; Yankeetown sandstone 2 Cypress sandstone 3 Tar Springs sandstone Fault—definite Fault—doubtful Contour—definite - Contour—doubtful R. 4 W. Structure map of the Ava-Campbell Hill gas fields with contours showing the elevation of the Menard limestone. Locations of producing areas and abandoned wells are also shown. ■V'Vjr■■j; v . - . jr~ (-r» - . . V ' - ' » ■ ' ■ \ o *■. : feBrVL -, H* - - I - ► j - . . • - • ■ ■ -■ • l> 5 - ; / : - ' r v ) ■ ■ , . * / .