THE PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT THE PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT BY GEORGE MEUDELL LONDON GEORGE ROUTLEDGE & SONS, LTD. BROADWAY HOUSE: 68-74 CARTER LANE, E.G. Printed in Great Britain by The Botuering Press, Plymouth. CONTENTS CHAP. FACE I. EARLY EXPERIENCES . . .1 II. LAND BOOM AND LAND BOOMERS . I I III. POLITICS, LEAGUES, ASSOCIATIONS, CLUBS. THE KYABRAM MOVEMENT . . 34 IV. BANKS AND BANKERS . . .54 V. MINES AND MINING. STOCK EXCHANGE. OIL QUEST . . . .8l VI. FORTUNES MISSED . . .130 VII. TRAVELS A TABLOID OF TRAVEL . 145 VIII. PEOPLE I HAVE KNOCKED ABOUT WITH . 190 IX. AUSTRALIAN PEOPLE . . . 227 X. EARLY EXPERIENCES. HOTELS, CAFES, DINNERS, ENTERTAINMENTS . . 273 FOREWORD MY travels in forty countries covering over 400,000 miles by land and sea, on over 400 steamships, and through about 600 hotels, allow me to claim I have travelled further than most Australians. Of course, postmen, commercial travellers, sea-captains and rail- way guards have an opportunity of breaking my record for distance. During my travels I have met lots of people who have been everywhere, have seen little, and remembered less. I have not been able to find a better country than my own Australia. The old controversy as to which is the finest harbour city in the world can only be truthfully settled in favour of Sydney, with Rio Janeiro half a length away second, and Naples a bad third. Among the " also rans " are Hobart, Auckland, Queenstown, Quebec, Nagaski, San Francisco, and Hong-Kong, precisely in that order. Before going abroad to view the world I saw my native land fairly extensively and knew something of the South Sea Islands and of glorious New Zealand. There is no such picturesque country elsewhere as New Zealand, although we have in Australia magnificent scenery of a quality unknown to the European. In fact the traveller does not need to go outside Aus- tralasia for sightseeing, or to see the best, get the best or do the best this planet affords. vii FOREWORD All these years of travel over the Seven Seas have fixed firmly in my soul and mind the belief that my native land, Australia, is the best country and the Australians are the best people on the globe. The finest people of all the nations are the French, and unlike most other peoples the French as a nation love their homeland, passionately and devotedly. The English, the Scotch, the Londoners (who are a curious sect of the British people standing apart), Germans, Italians, Swiss and all those other races from the cold north of Europe have no obsessing love of country. The Irish have mostly left Ireland, but they were forced out. For freedom, for food, for work, for money, they leave their homes as soon as they can. And most of those countries are good places to get away from. The Australian is pure-bred, of one race, and that (excepting the French) the best race of them all the miscalled Anglo-Saxon. The latest figures are not available, but those of the 1921 census give the birth places of the inhabitants of Australia as 86 per cent born in Australasia, 10 per cent born in the United Kingdom, and only 4 per cent born in foreign coun- tries. Ours is, perhaps, the purest breed of people living. The strain was a good one too, because only the strong and healthy men and women were able to travel from Europe hither, and speaking generally, the Government immigrants in later years were examined and selected. So the Australian is well and cleanly bred from a good stock, and endowed with viii FOREWORD excellent bone and blood. Given these requisites of pure blood and strong bone, it is only necessary to use plenty of wholesome food in a fine climate to produce, physically and mentally, healthy men and women. The Australian is a superior being physically. Other nations do not produce such a high proportion of able-bodied men and women as the Australian nation, because Australians are essentially livers out of doors. If our men are in every respect the finest males living, what can be said of our women ? My travels in 450 cities in every region of the globe enable me to judge, and without reserve I can declare the Australian woman is the healthiest, sanest and most beautiful in the wide world. The women of Norway and Sweden are perhaps physically stronger, those of Odessa perhaps in the mass prettier, maybe Grafton Street, Dublin, or Princes Street, Edinburgh, or Hyde Park or the Bois de Boulogne may offer a few picked specimens of the highest form of womanhood ; yet in the mass our Australian girls and women easily bear the palm as the best and most capable women of all the nations, fit comrades and helpmates of the very best men. Our Australian boys and girls are better educated than those of other nations ; and speaking broadly our school system is in its infancy, in a state of flux, from which is being evolved a more complete and advanced educational environment and atmosphere. In the matter of education we have been hampered ix CHAPTER I EARLY EXPERIENCES MY father, William Meudell , by descent related to the Hertford family of Seymours , was a highly educated man from Edinburgh who, with William Grant, a crony of his, came to Australia in search of health and gold. At Geelong, Henry Miller who had just helped to es- tablish the Bank of Victoria was on the wharf looking for a couple of " pommies " to work on his farm at Bacchus Marsh. He asked the two white-faced, white- handed young men whether they wanted work. They used the Scottish equivalent of " My oath, Mister." " All right," said Miller, " I want you to take a load of palings by bullock team to Bacchus Marsh." They had no recollection of ever having seen a bullock in their lives, and it took them three weeks to learn bullock driving and swearing, and as well how to travel to Bacchus Marsh. Every morning was devoted to chasing bullocks all over the landscape and then yoking them up. When they reached Bacchus Marsh they were a mass of callosities corns, warts, bunions and blisters all over their hands, arms and feet. " Money " Miller said to my dad, " How would you like to join the Bank of Victoria, Meudell ? " ' That's my profession," said my father, and he took the billet in the Bendigo branch at five pound a week, and slept alongside the gold for eight years. Not very long before he died " Money " Miller, Chair- man of the Bank of Victoria, sent for my father, then the General Manager, to visit him at " Findon " Kew. He found the old man sitting at a green baize card table playing with twenty-five new golden sovereigns, PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT red hot from the mint, delicious to the touch and sight, better than aspirin for a headache and an excellent cure for that universal complaint, tightness of the chest. Old " Money " Miller asked my father to prepare all the requisite papers to make applications to the Supreme Court to wind up the Bank of Victoria and distribute the assets among the shareholders. The old chap was in his dotage, but what a lovely dotage to be in, to just do nothing but sit all day playing with new yellow " Jimmy Goblins," to absorb their glitter and harken to their click and clink. Isn't it a delightful way to spend a long life gathering money, piling it up, seeing it grow without spending more than keeps one alive, and then to pass on to another existence conscious of having made heavy footprints on the sands of time, and indulging one's ruling passion to the utmost right up to the door of death ? It's a curious case of putrefaction of the soul. EARLY CAREER My father took me into the Bank of Victoria and I learned all I could about the craft in several positions, from " pig-boy " to teller. I learned shorthand to get into head office as secretary to the Inspector, E. G. Harrison, who sent me to Horsham during the wheat season. It was a horrible place full of banks, and inns, poor food, bad drink, too many card- players and betting men, and as rude and crude as a Californian mining camp. So I applied for a billet in the Sandhurst Savings Bank shortly after George E. Emery, the very capable General Manager of the State Savings Bank, joined the service at Castlemaine. Had I stayed in the bank I would have been a senior officer to-day. Eager for personal freedom and better pay, I became a public accountant and was doing well when the late B. J. Fink found me EARLY EXPERIENCES out and offered me the job of assistant manager of the Mercantile Finance Guarantee and Trustee Company, the pivot and headquarters of the land and finance boom then starting on its meteoric career. J. M. Bruce, Stanley Bruce's father, O. Fenwick and J. H. Dodgshun were the directors ; B. J. Fink was Chairman ; J. Me. A. Howden, manager ; and Andrew Lyell, the best accountant Melbourne ever had, was inspector. I learned high finance all right and lost twenty thousand pounds buying the blessed or cursed shares of the Company. EARLY LIFE ILLNESS The greatest mistake I have made in my life was to believe three doctors that I was dying and ought to give up work. Brought up by my parents on homoeo- pathy I never was able to understand why people had any faith in medicine. Doctors prescribe medicine of which they know nothing to cure diseases in a body of which they know less. Materia medico, and the British Pharmacopoeia should be suppressed by force. Doctors know very little and what they know they use blindly on their patients. They cannot cure cancer, consumption, baldness, or rheumatoid arthritis, to name only a few universal diseases. The few diseases they can cure are mostly mental, diseases of the nerves created by the mind, by thinking and by fear. I was doing a big business on the Melbourne Stock Exchange which was always growing. Working too hard my system ran down and I spat blood. So I consulted a doctor, a member of the British Medical Associa- tion, who said I was ill and must stop work. The second B.M.A. man, looking like a coffin-lifter's helper with a belly-ache, shook his head and asked me whether I had made my will. This put the wind up me, so I stopped work, downed tools and went to London. The first B.M.A. chap said, " You have PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT only three months to live, make your will and go home to Melbourne." That was nineteen years ago. The next B.M.A. member was a big pot, a Royal physician, who also condemned me to death as being in the last stage of tuberculosis. I swore at him gently. I went away for a long sea trip to Burma, Malaya and East Indies on my way home. Fear, fright, funk, those three most deadly and damnable curses and ills that afflict humanity, caused me to give my splendid Stock Exchange business away and thereby ruined myself. However, my mate and I went to Bendigo, lived in the open air at Kangaroo Flat, and I swallowed beaten up eggs and milk to the extent of three quarts a day. I slept like a night watchman, avoided exercise, a thing that kills more people than it saves, and in twelve months I gained three stone weight. After that my diet was crayfish, onions and stout. The hole in my lung filled up, what with I don't know, and all that happened twenty-one years ago. What funny folks doctors are, and what a zany I was to believe their doleful maunderings ! Now I believe that all diseases are mental in origin. A change in the mental outlook is therefore a health force. In a year I gained three stone weight and entirely renewed the vitality which had led to my undoing. Don't need doctors nor their beastly physic, and have only had one illness since, an attack of shingles, which a doctor friend told my wife would take three weeks to disappear. My friend, James Moore Hickson, the celebrated faith healer, attended and cured me, and I went back to the office the next day. Abolish fear from the world and you will abolish disease. Never to be born would be best for mortal man, but hardly one man in 100,000 has this luck. It is really fiddle-faddle and of no interest to any- body but myself, yet some unlucky mortal suffering EARLY EXPERIENCES from tuberculosis or consumption may make use of my experience in curing myself of the white plague. For the first forty years of life I worked too hard and used up my vitality too quickly. Ever since passing that milestone I have drifted and let things rip and I am much happier. When doing splendidly on the Stock Exchange I caught consumption and a silly ass of a doctor said, " Give it up, shut your office ; make your will ; go away. Your spit is malignant." It might have been, so I gave my seat and my fine business away and went travelling with my mate. EARLY EXPERIENCE I am glad to admit I have spent a very happy life crammed full of varied experiences. David Mickle, an exceptionally intellectual man, a Victorian Post Office Inspector, induced me to make a complete study of Herbert Spencer's philosophy to gain a groundwork of First Principles. Years after, Alfred Deakin, a friend of Mickle's, who also helped to fashion my reading curriculum, told me he had found Herbert Spencer's philosophy impracticable, and with that I agreed. The only man who could frame a workable system of philosophy would be a lawyer who had been a land shark and who had been a com- pany promoter and had gone insolvent. Deakin gave me much good literary advice and persuaded me to study Ralph Waldo Emerson to get a knowledge of the canons of conduct. So there you are, Herbert Spencer for character building and Ralph Waldo Emerson for framing one's conduct ; copious libations of Herbert Spencer and long banquets with Emerson. And in addition to being thankful for a happy life, love of travel, a product of atavism, derived from Viking ancestors who as soldiers and sailors were moss-troopers, bandits, buccaneers and pirates, nour- ished my desire to see the world. So I have seen the PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT two finest sights on earth : the Taj Mahal fane in India, and Carbine winning the Melbourne Cup in 1890, carrying 10 stone 5 Ib. over two miles. EARLY DAYS BANK OF VICTORIA The best thing ever done by me was to write an essay at the age of fifteen creating that blessed and priceless device, " Australia for the Australians." The most blessed gift by atavism to me was the sense of humour bequeathed through Scottish ancestors who were descended from Vikings. Up to my great grandfather's time they were generally soldiers and sailors. My grandfather and father were Scotch bankers, and the precious endowment of humour which had lain dormant and unused for untold generations seems to have been imbued with life amongst bank ledgers, overdrafts, bills payable, and unpayable, and Head Office circulars, the funniest of all human documents. Like Bernard Shaw, my way of joking is to tell the truth. It is the funniest joke in the world. The day I joined the Bank of Victoria in knickerbockers (listen to that first hiss of egotism) the staff assembled to receive me into the craft, and twenty underpaid and overworked bank clerks in- ducted me to their guild in the strong room. Not one of them got over 150 a year, the ruling wage. The chairman, still alive and always laughing, wound up his advice to be a good honest banker like my father, with this warning, " If you ever feel a desire to go wrong, don't prig petty cash or enter threepenny letters as sixpennies, collar 10,000, and be sure to burn the bally books." Years afterwards the secretary of the Bankers' Association, when he heard me tell that story said solemnly, " George, if you ever want to be head of the Melbourne Savings Bank drop funny stories and try and look like Archibald Currie," a dour, sour, Scotch sea-captain and then the chairman EARLY EXPERIENCES of the Savings Bank, who looked as though he never had laughed in his life, yet left a lot of money he did not know how to spend. Most rich men look wise and hold their tongues and their money. You cannot, young man, practise the divine gift of humour and get rich. This world dislikes people who laugh, unless they do it for a living like Harry Lauder or Charlie Chaplin. Henry Ford has never laughed and John D. Rockfeller has never smiled, yet regard their possessions ! Hugo Stinnes, the great German financier, and Jimmy Tyson, the successful keeper of sheep and cattle, died from the same obstruction of their risible organs. If the general managers of the twelve banks that burst in 1891 and 1893 had kept paid clowns to make fun of the valuations of city and suburban land, made by the old-established auctioneers and valuators of Melbourne in the land boom days, their banks would never have closed their doors. Every bank should keep a laughing department where absurd valuations and ridiculous securities could be laughed off the premises. EARLY EXPERIENCES As a schoolboy I cut my right eye with a knife and lost the sight. For a long time I lived under the over- hanging fear that the good eye would fail through sympathy, so I consulted several leading oculists in London and Edinburgh, and one each in Weisbaden, Homburg, Paris, Berlin, Vienna and Venice. All except one advised the excision of the wounded optic. Dr. George Anderson Crichett of Harley Street, London, told me to stick to the invalid eye and for thirty-five years I enjoyed his friendship. Instead of getting stale magazines in Sir George's waiting- room, sherry, port and biscuits were provided, and patients invited by printed notice to help themselves. I think the sherry was '56 and the port a '48, both PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT excellent wines having the effect of clearing one's vision. Resting against a magnificent cloisonne" vase in the centre of the mahogany table was another fine specimen of the printer's art simply mentioning that " patients are politely requested to pay fees by cash." Sir George had specially made waistcoats with roomy pockets. In the port side pocket he put silver coins, and in the starboard one he slipped the sovereigns. Five pound Bank of England notes drifted into his hip pockets. At the end of a busy day Dr. Crichett had a decided list to starboard slightly canting towards his stern. He was a wonderful oculist and a charming man. As a young and enterprising tuft-hunter, I desired to see some of the great people of England, so voyaged to Cambridge to call on Professor Sydney Howard Vines, a cousin of my father's. He was an eminent botanist and appeared to be stuffed with the same sort of cotton wool they use to preserve dead mammals. Vine's friends were the sons of Charles Darwin, and his close cobber was Frank Darwin. Calling at King's College, Vine's man told me he was up an oak tree with Dr. Darwin inspecting a new aphis discovered that day, so I strolled down and introduced myself to my professor cousin up the tree. He asked me to go back to his rooms and wait. It was about 12.30 and I was hungry, also young. The factotum told me there were three chops, a pound of cheese, and a gallon of table ale for lunch with a sufficiency of bread. Half a crown proved a big enough bribe, so the unjust steward cooked the chops which I ate and I left the cheese and bread for Mr. Vines who arrived for lunch at 1.30. Luckily Frank Darwin had gone home, and my cousin for one time more was a martyr to science while I was well fed and happy. MERCANTILE FINANCE COMPANY When the late B. J. Fink cajoled me into joining the Mercantile Finance Guarantee Trustees and Agency Company as Assistant Manager, upon the specious plea that he would train me in la haute finance ', John McAlister Howden was the Manager, and I filled the vacancy made when Andrew Lyell, a leading Scotch accountant, left the company. Fink's high finance was pure grotesquerie, something to be laughed at. His idea of high finance was to ask high commissions. Although Howden was a pawky, shrewd man he was controlled by Machiavelli Fink whose knowledge of sound finance was primary with an Asiatic tendency. Well I remember one day after short and sharp negotiations Fink had signed a contract to buy C. J. and T. Ham's old estate agency business for a vast quantity of paper scrip. Cornelius Job Ham had been lying awake thinking it out, and next morning came to the office to plead with B. J. Fink to cancel the contract and let him off". BJ. was hard-hearted and granitic until C.J. wept scalding tears on the new office carpet. Then he went away and brought back Robert Reid, the soft-goods-man of Flinders Lane, who bluffed and blustered and demanded the return of the contract of sale which was legally returned. B. J. Fink was messianic in his conceit and made paper millions with the same ease as a schoolboy builds Meccano bridges, and the millions fell to pieces as simply. SAVINGS BANK I often wonder what would have happened if I had stuck to the Savings Bank, of which I was a senior officer when I resigned to become a public accountant. I was close up to Mr. George E. Emery, the present able General Manager, to whom the successful PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT expansion of the State Savings Bank of Victoria is almost entirely due. To Emery, more than to anybody else falls the credit for placing the Savings Bank at the top of the list as the biggest and best national savings bank in the world. During my extensive travels in foreign countries I have used my expert banking and savings banking experience to observe and criticize the savings banks of other countries, and the Australian system of keeping and protecting the savings of the poor and thrifty excels all others. It has only one weakness. The Savings Bank should have a department for lending small sums of money to small borrowers, on enlightened and improved pawnshop lines. Why should a man have to pay 60 per cent for loan money simply because he is poor ? On the whole it was a splendid thing for me, that being a rolling stone I left the bank to lead a merry life. 10 CHAPTER II LAND BOOM AND LAND BOOMERS THIS interview with the " Daily Graphic " of London, in 1895, gives a clear idea of " The Causes of the Crisis of 1893." " For practical purposes," Mr. Meudell explained to a " Daily Graphic " representative who called on him at 28, Swithin's Lane, " three causes may be assigned for the recent financial collapse. First, there was the fall in prices of wheat, wool, and other staple products of the colony. Wheat, which in 1873 sold at 5*. a bushel in Melbourne is to-day only 35., and greasy wool which in 1873 averaged 20 a bale, say is. id. a pound, is now only 12 a bale, or 7\d. to %d. a pound. The demonetization of silver and appreciation of gold Mr. Meudell holds mainly responsible for this fall in prices, for he is an ardent bimetallist, and in Melbourne is an active teacher of the doctrine. Then," said Mr. Meudell, " another and more direct cause was the land boom of 18878 encouraged by the excessive influx of British capital into Australia in the form of Govern- ment and municipal loans, bank deposits, and moneys sent by assurance companies for investment on a 5 per cent basis. Money was thrown at our heads too rapidly to be absorbed safely, and in order to make a profit funds which carried interest bank advances were made far too freely and without suffi- cient inquiry. Under the Torren's system of registra- tion, title deeds of landed property are more easily dealt with than here, and banks freely lent on a mere deposit of documents, taking a lien on the estate. 1 1 PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT Australia is undoubtedly over-banked, but in new countries capital is scarce and all are borrowers. Yes, we might have been over-banked, but it must be remembered that it was the splendid banking facilities which developed the wheat, wool, mining, and other industries. Money," continued Mr. Meudell, " was so plentiful that everyone thought land values were bound to rise enormously. It's an old story this ' land boom ' after all, and those who want to under- stand how it can be worked cannot do better than read Marian Crawford's * Don Orsino,' which describes the land and building crash in Rome a few years back. The immediate cause of the collapse," con- tinued Mr. Meudell, in his clear and concise style was withdrawal of deposits from the building societies which have done valuable work in the past, but on a totally unsound basis and taking money on deposit for short terms and lending for long terms, so that when a sudden rush of withdrawals came funds could not be called in to meet the demand. A similar movement followed against the banks, which were in somewhat similar financial position and well, the result everybody knows only too well. Certainly I think the reorganization schemes adopted by the banks were the best possible under the circumstances. Liquidation of assets was impossible. It might have taken fifty years to wind up some of those concerns." The total losses of the people of Victoria in securities and property during the liquidation period amounted to 200,000,000. That much was visible, and could be reckoned. How much unseen property, chiefly personal, was wiped out it is impossible to estimate. And foreign loans and deposit receipts were the stimulus that led to over-building and over- buying. There were thousands of empty offices and thousands of vacant blocks of land. Every day the newspapers reported sales of city properties at i 500 to 12 LAND BOOM AND LAND BOOMERS ,2000 a foot, the rentals of which worked out at 2 and 3 per cent. After all, the interest test or the yield test is the only one to apply to values of land or buildings. The other day 2500 a foot was paid for a Melbourne city building which shows 4 per cent net return by rentals. The new owner cannot raise the rent, because there are nearly 4000 offices in old and new buildings vacant in Melbourne to-day. When I was assistant manager of the Mercantile Finance and Guarantee Company, I wrote a good many prospectuses of companies at the behest of B. J. Fink. The most splendid specimen of the art of imagining the basis of a prospectus ever perpetrated in Australia was my draft of the Australian Assets Purchase Com- pany, capital, j5, 500,000, to take over and liquidate the landed properties in houses, cottages, farms, sub- urban subdivisions, city lots, blank broad acres held by the late G. W. Taylor of Prahran, one of the most notorious land boomers. It was a rare farrago of high-priced rubbish, and every title or option had been mortgaged to a bank, a building society, or to a life assurance company. Our company held a bundle of equities of redemption. G. W. Taylor went up to London before the scheme materialized and the Board of Directors, all well-known men of the time, let the Australian Assets Purchase Company slither to oblivion. Saw Taylor in Cornhill, London, in 1895 an< ^ had a hearty laugh when he unfolded a scheme for securing emigrants in the United Kingdom to send in here to settle on orchards and bee farms in the suburbs of Melbourne, especially on the Glen Iris line ! G. W. Taylor was once Mayor of Prahran, a council celebrated in those days as a graduation college for land boomers, a most amusing type of speculators, who were nothing, knew nothing, and had nothing. The land boom and banking collapse was born in '3 PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT 1886 when the Service-Gillies Government brought in a bill to borrow 20,000,000 for alleged reproductive public works, that blessed trilogy of words which always spells disaster in Australia. It ended on Sunday, 3Oth April, 1893, when two ignorant and weak politicians, the late J. B. Patterson, the then Premier of Victoria, and G. D. Carter, the Treasurer, lost their heads and issued a Government Gazette declaring as bank holidays, Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thurs- day and Friday, ist to ^th May, 1893. This silly, senseless, stupid action forced upon Patterson by Carter, an extremely self-conscious and withal ignorant man, caused the banking edifice to topple and crash. The National Bank shut down next day, the Colonial, Victoria, Queensland National, Commercial of Sydney and City of Melbourne broke in that order. There was no need for the Commercial of Sydney to shut, but Thomas Dibbs, the General Manager, closed as a matter of expediency to strengthen his bank's position. On Friday, 2ist April, 1893, there was a " run " in Sydney on the Bank of New South Wales, Commercial Banking Company, City Bank of Sydney and Govern- ment Savings Bank of N.S.W. Sir George Dibbs, premier of New South Wales, unlike the weakling politicians of Victoria, Patterson and Carter, wisely visited the Savings Bank and guaranteed the deposits on behalf of the Government of New South Wales and the " run " and the panic were stopped. Yet such an important event is not included in the official Year Book chronological table from 1788 forward. Such was the policy of hush and secrecy. The easiest marks as borrowers were the building societies and the land and estate agents, and they had a right royal time asking for and getting advances. In those halcyon days nobody was ever refused a loan by a bank manager. So the banks opened agencies in Scotland, Ireland and England, and borrowed millions 14 LAND BOOM AND LAND BOOMERS on deposit receipts for eighteen months and lent them out in Victoria for thirty years, and a great deal of the money for eternity. It wasn't a mad or pessimistic or despondent thing to do. It was one calling for laughter, for merriment, for jocosity. Why should the good-humoured borrower explain to the dismal bank manager, irritated and worried by Head Office letters and circulars censuring him for not lending money fast enough, that though he had paid i a foot for land at Coburg or Glen Iris or Mentone that it was not in his own opinion worth the 10 a foot of his own valuation. Bankers love bills to discount and the land boomers had heaps, piles, bundles of bills in tin boxes and blue and yellow carpet bags. If a suburban estate was turned over and sold five or six times at a paper profit, that meant five or six sets of bills owing on one property, enough to fill twelve baskets full. Nobody dared to laugh at these insane transactions, nobody was brave enough to say, " All this business is frenzied, delusive and pure buffoonery. There must be a smash." And there was. Prices of houses and lands jumped higher and higher, day by day, nay, hour by hour, and more and more people were drawn into the maelstrom, into a true Walpurgis ride to sudden wealth. In 1888 there were exactly 1,000,000 people in Victoria mostly under twenty-one years of age, and five years later, after at least 1 00,000,000 had been poured in molten gold down Moloch's throat, there were only 133,266 more inhabitants, chiefly babies. Rateable property in cities, towns and boroughs went up by leaps and bounds from 53 to 86 million pounds sterling in five years, while the rateable property of shire councils jumped from 71 to 108 million pounds in the five years 1886-1890. It was all so dashed funny, because there was no solid foundation for all this paper wealth. Production did not increase part passu, PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT nor overseas trade, nor exports, nor shipping, except that imports increased literally horribly. During 1886 and 1 8 90 in Victoria railways costing 8 ,000,000 and 486 new churches and chapels were built. To me it was all so ridiculous and amusing, and the best of the joke was that none of the leaders of the people in Press, Parliament, Church, or on the platform, ever uttered a single word of warning about the coming debacle, the terrible catastrophe so close at hand which brought ruin to tens of thousands of decent people and nearly smashed Victoria. Bank assets rose from 41,000,000 in 1886 to 63,000,000 in 1891. Deposits grew from 3 1 ,000,000 in 1 8 8 6 to 40,000,000 in 1891. After that they fell away and did not reach 40,000,000 until 1907, or twenty-eight years later. I am writing of what I know because I went through that critical period on the inside in a finance company and in a property company as an executive officer, and when the panic stopped I was a member of the Stock Exchange. One of the prime causes of the collapse of the land boom was the lax management of the Melbourne building societies, which were as plentiful as fleas. Owning his own home was a craze in those parlous and perilous days of land sharks and building society bounders. In September, 1889, tne "Building Societies Gazette " published what it named " An imposing array of figures." And so it was. Fifty-six societies had shareholders' capital for 3,270,773, earning 7 to 1 6 per cent with paper reserve funds of S 1 7>9%7- They took deposits from the fool public to the extent of 5,353,730, bearing 4 to 7 per cent interest. Bank overdrafts, the basis of the whole deplorable business, totalled 314,856, and there was very little actual cash in the tills or tellers' boxes. That their fellow-citizens thoroughly believed in home comforts and manly independence, they bor- 16 LAND BOOM AND LAND BOOMERS rowed upon the undoubted security of houses and land the magnificent sum of 8,482,944. It was a gem in the middle of the paean of joy, the io triumphs ! of this journal of the building societies then rotten with corruption, and drunk with false valuations, slithering blindly to oblivion by liquidation ! They are indeed noble institutions ! They enable citizens to become the proud possessors of that great blessing a home of their own, and they are an impregnable bulwark against anarchy, revolutions and strikes. Why, because their assets amounted to 20,000,000, soon to vanish into thin air ! And the house and land valuations of those days were jocular and mirth inspiring. Met a man in Elizabeth Street in 1891 who was manager of a soap and candle company. He said, " Bought that two-story building in Flinders Lane this morning for 37,000, and just sold it for 56,000." While I stood and laughed merrily his face fell and became with gloom overspread. ' That works out at 1000 a foot and you sold it at about 1500. How cynical," I guffawed. That gambler ultimately made a composition of 68,293 with his creditors and promised them one penny in the pound, which he never paid. His father and uncle " competed," as it was jokingly called in those unreal days of the Barmacides, for a total sum of 381,779, at a penny in the pound. All three eventually died wealthy. The utter absurdity of the financial situation in those bank-boom days never struck any of the frowning, dismal general managers. The boom began with the banks who inflated land values all over Australia, though chiefly in Victoria. Between 1886 and 1891 the Service Gillies Ministries floated 16,000,000 of loans in London, and these two Premiers did more harm financially to Victoria than all the other Premiers since responsible government added together. Neither '7 PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT Service nor Gillies ever laughed or joked. They were too superior and became the political heroes of the moneyed classes. About the same time the Commercial Bank of Australia under Henry Gyles Turner and John McCutcheon began an inglorious career of aggrandisement. They started out to show the hypochondriacs who managed the National, the Victoria, the Australasia, the Union, the London, the English and Scottish banks how to create business and open branches. To supply new capital for these objects the Commercial Bank appointed agents to receive deposits in all the big cities of the United Kingdom and chiefly in Scotland. Their interest rates for fixed deposits were most alluring 3 per cent for three months, 4 per cent for six months, and 5 per cent for one year. The result was that an avalanche of money was poured into the London office of the Commercial Bank which carried interest from the date of deposit and consequently had to be lent out on this side quickly. The bank here implored its customers to take overdrafts, to discount bills, or to lend money to their country clients, to borrow it quickly and to lend it how they pleased. Flinders Lane doubled its travelling staff, and with the cheap 7 per cent money the warehousemen over-imported goods extensively and backed country storekeepers without limit. Fortunately I was writing regularly on banking and public: statistics and got to recognize signs of financial weaknesses, so I rented a box in the Safe Deposit and when the last bank had failed, and the forty-seventh building society had gone into liquida- tion, I had saved nearly one thousand sovereigns. They came in very handy and satisfied once and for all any desire one may have had to become a miser. To-day the same cycle of financial prodigality is being run by the people of Australia. These huge empty 18 LAND BOOM AND LAND BOOMERS buildings, those new unwanted railways, these superb private homes and public hotels are being built with the savings of the community, with the deposits of the savings banks, the life assurance societies, the trustees companies and the banks. The monstrous public debt of over 1,200,000,000, owing by 6,000,000 people, mostly babies, is a finger-post pointing to trouble, disaster and suffering. City and suburban values are inflated, and all the vacant land within twenty miles of the Melbourne G.P.O. has been sold at prices that discount its value for twenty-five years. ALEXANDRA THEATRE Here is one example out of hundreds of mad loan and building contracts I saw put through during the insane land boom. A clever old Frenchman, Jules Joubert, away back in the era 18601890 acted as a promoter of exhibitions in the cities of Australia and New Zealand with varying success. Tiring of travel- ling Joubert concluded he would build a good theatre in Melbourne, a city then as now without a really modern theatre. He came to the Mercantile Finance Company to be financed, being friendly with B. J. Fink, the Chairman. Fink's only anxiety was to earn high-sounding commissions for the company, and he would charge 20 to 25 per cent for putting through a 10 per cent loan if it were big enough in size. Joubert induced him to back his theatre building enterprise, and thus the Alexandra Theatre was born. When nearly finished things began to look a delicate shade of dark blue in high finance, according to Fink, and the Alexandra Theatre contract was suddenly broken. Being assistant manager of the Mercantile Finance Company and having learned an awful lot about theatres from a coign of vantage outside the stage doors of several, I was given control of the " Alick " Theatre, now called Her Majesty's. Our only trouble '9 PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT was to find money for the gas bill of fifty pounds a week. Dan Barry, an entrepreneur or actor manager of those times found the gas money and rented the theatre at one peppercorn a week, which he never paid, being so small and so useless. Barry put on blood-curdling, heart-jerking melodrama at 3^., 6d. and is. for gallery, dress circle and stalls. I did my share by getting 100,000 tickets on tick from a printer and employing a corps of unemployed to distribute them in the suburbs. At night these propagandists were given free supper and beer to act as claquers in the very best French style. We ran the show for three weeks and the only people who were really disappointed with the financial results were the gas company board of directors. I came to the conclusion that to conduct a theatrical business at a profit calls for the services of large quantities of money. The Alexandra Theatre was built on a building lease granted by the owner, George Porter. It was afterwards bought and completed by J. C. Williamson. Never forget asking George Porter to join me in a sherry and bitters at the Athenaeum Club once and he called for a pint bottle of French Hock which cost me i os. Another costly aperitif to remember was when, just before dinner at the Athenaeum Club, I asked Sir Edmund Barton to have a sherry and he ordered a bottle of Romance Conti Still Burgundy, then the dearest and finest wine of its kind, but not a drink to be taken in sips. It cost me IQS. 6d. for that " shout." Fortunately there was very little booming of farming or grazing lands, and the following list of the lords of Victorian soil in 1894 is worth reproducing. Since then most of these big estates have been cut up. Chirnsides owned in acres ... ... 279,946 Robertson's 207,097 Russell's 202,197 20 LAND BOOM AND LAND BOOMERS Sir W. J. Clarke owned in acres ... 177,952 Moffat's ... 176,874 Wilson's ... 175,872 Austin's ... 175,854 Armytage's ... 125,425 Manifold's ... 119,572 Ware's ... 105,104 Laidlaw's ... 103,852 E. Crossley ... 80,500 J. Winter ... 80,400 J. Bell ... 73,102 Staughton's ... 60,309 J. L. Currie ... 66,102 J. McPherson ... 62,194 W. & A. Armstrong ... 52,241 Simmons Bros. ... 54,622 W. McCulloch ... 55,663 Gumming Bros. ... 50,011 The late Sir M. H. Davies and I were living at the Athenaeum Club when the land banks and building societies were crumbling down. At breakfast time M. H. took his seat looking blithe and debonair, spic and span, smiling withal sombre at heart. Hidden behind the " Argus " he would whisper, " How dreadful ; another bank closed its doors. Tut, tut, very sad." Or, " Did you see the Lath and Plaster Building on Sand Society has stopped payment ? Shocking, isn't it ? Waiter, a little more buttered toast, very hot and very buttery." The poor chap had been up all night at the death of one of these flimsy, cranky, pseudo banks, or unsound building societies, which went down and out like wheat before a harvester. That breaking up of the small land jobbing companies lasted about a month with a daily killing. And M. H. Davies became invisible. Then the big banks and companies began to sway sideways and topple over. They were based on sand and false valuations, and the finance companies especially were C 21 PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT corrupt and rotten at the heart. And from stupidity, mistaken for stoicism, the public did not commit suicide or shoot or maim or punish any of the guilty financiers. Forty-seven of these rotten building societies fell out with a dull silent thud, just like Abaddon, the destroying angel, into the bottomless pit of bankruptcy. Nowadays the State Savings Bank has taken the place of the building society system, which was good in theory and badly managed in practice. Some of the biggest societies were the City of Melbourne, deposits 342,469, Federal, deposits 523,689, Melbourne, deposits 456,363, Victorian Permanent, 682,576, Premier 540,000. Building societies' snares were usually paid to 5 and stood on 'Change from 6 to i o, being a favourite popular investment. They all touted and advertised for deposits. One old squatter, Tommy Robertson, from the Campaspe, took a trip down to town and went up and down the street peering into the tables of interest rates allowed for fixed deposits which were exhibited in the windows of the building societies. He made a list of six societies which allowed 7 per cent on twelve months deposit receipts, and deposited 5000 in each, 30,000 in all, which he ultimately lost altogether. The Premier Building Society was the first to smash, and the tale of corruption and mismanagement earned for the secretary, James Mirams, a short term in gaol. Of the making of many tables of figures there is no end, and much study of them is a weariness of the flesh. On 3ist December, 1889, tne zenith or apex of the land boom, there were sixty-seven building societies doing business in Victoria with various objects. There were permanent investment, mutual, terminat- ing and benefit building societies. Capital, investing shares, terminating shares, reserve funds and un- divided profits amounted to 4,365,786, while these 22 LAND BOOM AND LAND BOOMERS institutions held 5,578,359 of public deposits. What with overdrafts and mortgages, the building societies were custodians of the public money to the extent of over 11,227,207. Where are those millions now ? Certainly the societies had lent 10,000,000 to people to buy homes. One society, the Premier, the first to close its doors, had paid up capital of 268,618. On this it raised a crazy super- structure. Deposits were 652,702, and it owed on mortgages of freeholds 715,993. Total liabilities on account of capital and liabilities were 1,682,687. The Secretary, the late James Mirams, failed for 338,000. Amongst the hundreds of prospectuses I have written during forty years' connection with companies mining, industrial and financial three please me most because of their audacity. The first is the prospectus of the Mercantile Investment Trust, capital 2,500,000, in 500,000 shares of 5, Directors, B. J. Fink, J. M. Bruce and J. M. Howden. The object of the Trust was to pool investments so that the investor would not have all his eggs in one box, that is he would buy one hundred shares in each of five stocks, instead of 500 shares in one stock. We never launched this company because I had skedaddled to another financial group. The prospectus is dated June, 1888. Then in London in June, 1889, I drew up the prospectus of the Guarantee Society of Aus- tralasia, capital 1,000,000, its object being to guarantee the punctual repayment of the principal and interest of mortgage loans made by British companies in Australasia. It died still-born, no flowers and private interment. The land boom was due to over-borrowing and over-speculation, and it was engineered by bands of marauders who conceived schemes of such gross dishonesty that the fortunes of multitudes of honest people were endangered. The wages of the bread-winners and the workers were 23 PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT sapped by traitors. The leaders of the boom were mostly extremely pious men and almost invariably they were teetotallers. To-day they would be called " wowsers." Like all extremists in conduct and ideals the chief land boomers were narrow, illiterate and uneducated. Mankind has always been a flock of sheep. Those with little money blindly follow those with much. Therefore the business of finance is largely in the hands of men of wealth. As R. L. Stevenson wrote of the missionaries, " Their faculty of humour is very small," and so with the land boomers while filching money from the public they put into active practice their principles of Puritanism and hatred of all pleasure and its votaries. The three best hotels in Melbourne, at the instance of James Munro, James Mirams and J. W. Hunt surrendered their licences, and the Grand, the Victoria and the Federal Hotel became coffee palaces. From 1887 to 1890 there was a systematic writing up of land and house property throughout Australia, though chiefly in Melbourne. In 1892 there were 418 insolvencies in Melbourne of which 77 were declared by firms. Total liabilities were 7,800,000, and assets 3,975,000. There were 248 compositions within two years nearly all made with banks and land specu- lators. The devil's brigade of lawyers figured largely, and some families contributed three or more composi- tions. One notable family of five brothers each made a " compote " for insignificant payments from one halfpenny to one shilling in the i. Twenty-six finance companies with total capitals of 10,000,000, of which 5,200,000 was paid up, went bung owing 12,000,000 on deposits and debentures. No wonder every individual in the community suffered directly and indirectly. Huge losses were made by the fire and life insurance companies and the State Savings Bank on their mortgages, and by mutual consent they LAND BOOM AND LAND BOOMERS were all hushed up. And individual instances of fraud and forgery were kept quiet, so as not to upset the public and lose its confidence. Plato called the world a City of Pigs, and Melbourne during its boom years could have been so described justly. Besides excessive Government borrowings out in London between 1886 and 1890, another catastrophe hit Australia and nearly toppled her over the precipice into a financial abyss. The land boom was encouraged by the exces- sive influx of British capital into Australia in the form of Government and municipal loans, bank deposits, and money sent by Scotch life assurance companies for investment at 5 per cent. Money was thrown at the Australian banks too rapidly to be absorbed safely, and in order to make a profit on funds that carried interest, bank advances were made far too freely and without sufficient inquiry. Money was so plentiful that everyone thought land values were bound to rise enormously, and so the future was discounted to an alarming extent. Liquid capital became fixed, confidence was lost, and steady with- drawal of deposits became a universal panic. ~The first speculator to buy suburban land cheaply by the acre and sell it by the foot was C. H. James, a grocer in North Melbourne. James made a good deal of money at first and if he had only tackled subdivisional land on the foreshore of Hobson's Bay, or in Toorak, Malvern and Caulfield, instead of selling pocket- handkerchief allotments in the Fairfield Ivanhoe districts, he would have made ten times what he did. C. H. James lost most of his money in the Dominion Bank, whose fine office building, still one of the best in the city, now belongs to the Royal Insurance Co., 414, Collins Street. Frank Stuart, of Lincoln, Stuart and Co., drapers, was one of the first into the arena of the land boom. He was an intellectual of excep- PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT tional clarity of thought and good judgment and landed a fortune. When the boom reached zenith Stuart, against his better judgment, was induced to go into it again and lost much, but not all, of his previous profits. G. W. Taylor, a land agent, once Mayor of Prahran, was another pioneer boomer. He was a weak, excitable man with unbounded confidence in himself, and he managed to impress bank managers and building society secretaries to the extent of about 5,500,000 worth of land and houses. Sir Matthew Henry Davies, a solicitor, once Speaker of the Legisla- tive Assembly, was a leader of investors all through the boom and made two million pounds profit on paper. He was an able man of singularly fine presence and charming manners. Davies founded the Mercan- tile Bank with a capital of 400,000 which smashed badly at the finish. There was a prosecution of the directors for issuing a false balance sheet, quite an ordinary custom at that time. Very few balance sheets of banks or companies interested in landed securities were honest during the boom period. Sir Bryan O'Loghlen refused to allow the directors to be tried by a judge, although Mr. I. A. Isaacs, his Solicitor-General, now a Federal High Court Judge, recommended the matter should be proved. Sir Matthew Henry Davies was ably defended by Mr. Theodore Fink of the firm of Fink, Best and Phillips, then a rising lawyer. The Davies group was deeply interested in the Australian Deposit and Mortgage Bank, the English and Australian Mortgage Bank, the Freehold Investment and Banking Company, the Victorian Mortgage and Deposit Bank, Henry Arnold and Company, the Gascoigne Investment Company, and the General Land and Savings Com- pany and numerous building and land societies not listed on the Stock Exchange. Far and away the ablest of all the land boomers was Benjamin Josman 26 LAND BOOM AND LAND BOOMERS Fink, M.L.A. for Maryborough, who before the boom began was practically king of the furniture trade of Melbourne. Fink began work as a boy in Maurice Aron's furniture shop in Elizabeth Street, known as Wallach Brothers. B.J. played the piano divinely and his job was to produce music from ten pound German pianos to sell them to suburbanites for forty to fifty pounds. Fink sold pianos as other men sell crayfish and peanuts, quickly and easily. When the boom opened he was interested in the five leading furniture shops of Melbourne and was worth 250,000, solidly and unencumbered. He was making twenty thousand pounds a year, and why he went into the land boom cesspit is not understandable. B. J. Fink was a subtle, astute man of business of more than ordinary capacity, as sagacious as he was audacious, a man of vivid imagination and of restless energy in carrying out his schemes. He should have stopped outside the boom vortex and when the smash came he might have gathered in four or five million pounds' worth of goods and properties. Instead he com- pounded with his creditors for 1,520,175, having assets worth 500,900, and paying a dividend of one halfpenny in the pound. Of all the financiers I have met in Australia or abroad, B. J. Fink was easily the cleverest of them all. He had no equal in Australia in la haute finance. Unfortunately for me he lured me from an accountancy practice, where I was making 750 a year, to become assistant manager of the Mercantile Finance Guarantee Agency Com- pany, Mr. J. McA. Howden being the manager. Fink carried a black bag in which were mining scrip, bank shares, Crown grants, bond warrants, pro- missory notes, debentures, bank deposit receipts, mortgages, an olla podrida of saleable things. He would say, " Here you are, George, take this title round to the Savings Bank and get them to prepare 27 PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT a mortgage for ten thousand pounds, and I will call in to-morrow and sign it." Or " Here are a thousand National Bank, George, get Billy Jones, the share broker, to sell them and send me a cheque to-morrow morning." J. McA. Howden, manager, of the Mercantile Finance Company, was an extremely able man, who did not keep his head when values started to rise sky-high. At one time Howden held a million pounds' worth of saleable scrip and property. He was son-in-law of the best accountant Melbourne ever had, Andrew Lyell, a shrewd Scotchman of much common sense and fine business acumen. Thomas Bent, an ex-Speaker and ex-Premier of Victoria, was another celebrity who made a lot of money dealing in land. As secretary to many meetings where big deals were discussed amongst the big city financiers I saw a good deal of Tom Bent, and I never heard him suggest any sharp practice or propose anything dis- honest. J. M. Bruce, the Prime Minister's father, was one of my directors, and he too was a man of utmost integrity and of unblemished character. A lot of rich Flinders Lane people followed Bruce, Fenwick and Dodgshun into shares of the Mercantile Finance and " dropped their bundle." Other notable land boomers were William Bruce, the cricketer ; Bob Beeston, share broker ; H. T. Clarton, G. C. Clauscen, C. W. Derham, Alfred Dunn, H. H. Drysdale, Raynes, W. Dickson, Senior, A. F. Dean, P. H. Engel, Theodore Fink, A. J. Fuller, F. Gillman, William Greenlaw, J. M. Gillespie, A. Goldberg, A. H. and W. H. George, J. Harris, M. Herman, H. H. Hayter, J. A., Theo. and J. H. Kitchen, S. G. King, Stephen King, R. H. Lemon, E. W. Lightfoot, W. A. Mclntosh, A. D. Michie, R. Neave, F. M. Palmer, Richard Shann, W. R. Skene, W. L. Smith, A. Stewart, W. G. Sprigg, C. F. Taylor, John Turner, 28 LAND BOOM AND LAND BOOMERS Joseph Woolf, Whittingham Brothers, George Withers and many others. It is curious to note how many solicitors were drawn into the land boom. The fortunes they first won were Cadmean victories which ultimately ruined them. The only man who made money out of the land boom bought and sold for cash, and those who bought on credit either made com- positions with their creditors or went insolvent. To everyone else the boom was a volcanic calamity. Man is chiefly a two-legged bird with feathers to be plucked, and the general public is largely com- posed of people who itch to be plucked by clever schemers. One of the most powerful factors in creating Victoria's land boom was the ring of fifty-six building societies operating in Melbourne. They acted like self-raising flour, blew themselves up quickly and subsided when fully baked into flat lumps or total loss. The directors and secretaries of the building societies in Melbourne in 188691 were in a class by themselves. All of them were earnest temperance workers, and therefore abjured alcohol, wore black broadcloth clothes, the customary suits of solemn black, drank too much water and over-ate themselves and had too large families. Mostly both directors and secretaries were elders of kirks, members of chapels, bethels and churches, knew nothing, were nothing and lost nothing. Their ignorance of the ordinary rules of lending money miscalled finance was colossal. The big idea in those unlettered days was that every citizen should own his own home and buy it on building society tables, most of which were actuarial swindles. It was a mistaken policy then as it is more so to-day for each struggling citizen to try to own his own small uncomfortable little house. All the inhabitants of the other great cities in the world then, as now, lived in comfortable, commodious flats, 29 tenements or apartment houses, well built, well warmed, easy to get at and easy to leave. In 1888 this deponent found himself assistant manager of the ill-fated Mercantile Finance and Guarantee Company, whose 3 shares were selling at 8. The chairman, B. J. Fink, suggested buying some shares to make my position more stable. So through his broker I bought two thousand shares at 8 and fell in. Within nine months the last of my shares were sold at 25^., and the frying pan becoming too hot for me I jumped into the fire when another financial group offered me 1200 a year to rearrange the affairs of a leading land and property company, the Australian Property Company. After ten hours' audit, the balance sheet showed me the Company would be insolvent if much money was not raised quickly. Within seven days the directors got bona fide conservative valuations of their properties from leading Melbourne valuators show- ing a marketable value of about a million pounds. Next day the P. & O. s.s. " Oceania " took me to London, en route to Edinburgh to float 400,000 of debentures, in a frame of mind closely resembling something blithe, buoyant and debonair. In Edin- burgh I called on David Beath, a Flinders Lane soft-goods-man, who held a big parcel of shares in the company and after excellent family prayers and a meagre breakfast at his home, we assailed the hardest- headed Edinburgh firm of Scotch accountants ever born in Aberdeen and got them interested in my request of 400,000 in cash. I took my letters of instructions and valuations to an extremely powerful firm of Scotch Stock Brokers in London who agreed to float the Home and Colonial Assets and Debentures Corporation and issue debentures for 400,000 secured on Melbourne land and buildings valued at 1,000,000. They were called city properties, the 30 LAND BOOM AND LAND BOOMERS best known of them being the building at the corner of Flinders Lane and Elizabeth Street, once called Australian Building and previously the English and Scottish Bank. Most reluctantly one had to agree to cut four stories off the top of the fifteen-story building, plans of which I carried in a golf bag. Also we excised a safe deposit that had been ordered and built by Milner and Company. In three days I had secured underwriting letters for 400,000 of debentures and in three weeks the company was registered ! (This seems an appropriate place to emit another hiss of egotism, loud and prolonged.) Fancy being able with divine aid to extract 400,000 in cash from a Scotch group of financiers in so short a time, without a hem or a haw, or even a dinna ken ! It was a veritable financial battle of Bannockburn, won by a green inexperienced youth of Scotch descent, with a grossly enlarged fund of Australian cheek, or would audacity be a less harsh euphemism ? When I got home the directors neither thanked me nor paid me any commission, although I had saved them, all leading public men, from utter financial ruin ! So I re- signed. One curious consequence of the terrible wiping out of millions of pounds' worth of assets was that the heads of the banks and the directors directly responsible for misjudging the financial position did not suffer and were not punished. Not a single general manager was dismissed, as they all should have been, and both the ignorant and the dishonest directors were allowed to remain on the directorates. The sufferers by the damnable cataclysm, damnable because avoidable, were the middle class people of the community, the thrifty, the saving, the respectable. They were ruined by the thousand because their deposited money was raped from them under one-sided banking reconstruction schemes sanctioned by too complaisant judges, and their homes and properties were torn 3' PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT from them by blundering liquidators. The settle- ment of the land boom took place in an inferno of dishonesty and ruthlessness. Those who had com- piled the biggest schedules of positive debts and negative assets got off scot free and in hundreds of instances were able to ensure future freedom from monetary worry by concealing assets of all sorts from their creditors. A complete list of the alleged honour- able men who made shameful insolvencies would startle their descendants and amuse the rest of the community. In the financial history of all times there never has been such a disgraceful financial failure as the Australian land boom or one on such a grand scale. The total losses by institutions and individuals approached 200,000,000 sterling, or nearly half the country's wealth. One of the worst compositions with creditors was made by the general manager of the Colonial Bank of Australasia, who failed for 113,789 with assets of a nominal value and offered to pay 6d. in the pound. Very seldom were these purely im- aginary dividends paid by the insolvents in that dishonest period known as the land boom. This man's judgment of property values must have been warped and false, so there is small wonder his bank failed when its advances were based on wrong valuations. In the thick of the mad, insane banking boom I never could properly orient my mind to under- stand the psychology of the banking leaders who were the lenders of money to the gambling speculators most responsible for the foolish unwarranted inflation of land values. The only man with whom I used to discuss seriously the absurd chopping and changing of city and suburban land allotments was my father who protested to his directors of the Bank of Victoria against loans to the champion land boomers like B. J. Fink, G. W. Taylor, Thomas Bent and W. L. 3* LAND BOOM AND LAND BOOMERS Baillieu. Old " Money " Miller, unfortunately for the Bank of Victoria, was in his dotage and off the Board or it would never have collapsed. My father's reward for prophesying the downfall of his bank was removal to London from the general managership. When the smash came every bank manager showed himself to be a tin man painted to look like iron. 33 CHAPTER III POLITICS, LEAGUES, ASSOCIATIONS, CLUBS. THE KYABRAM MOVEMENT OF all the seven political leagues I have helped to establish, the most interesting was what was called the Kyabram movement for Parliamentary reform and State retrenchment. A public meeting was held at Kyabram, a small country village in the Goulburn Valley, Victoria, on I3th November, 1901, and it took the agitators five months to get going. Directly I thought their circulars had taken effect amongst country shire councils and public bodies, I asked George W. S. Dean, then the cleverest election secretary in Victoria, to help me to divert the move- ment to Melbourne. Samuel Lancaster was Chairman of the Kyabram Committee, and B. Goddard and C. H. Wilson were joint hon. secretaries. For months I had been writing in " The Age " suggesting a reduction of State members of Parliament because Federation ought to have meant less state spending. Mr. A. J. Peacock was Premier of Victoria, and Dean and I knowing him, knew he would be too feeble to stand up against a country demand for reform and retrenchment. So we got the Kyabram leaders to consent to explain their policy at a public meeting in Melbourne. Dean and I ran the show and Henry Butler of Sargood and Company, soft-goods-men, found the thousand pounds. The meeting on the 1 7th April, 1902, was a brilliant success. We formed the National Citizens' Reform League and in seven days enrolled two thousand members. Within six months we had established 214 branches. Our 34 POLITICS, LEAGUES, CLUBS programme demanded a reduction of the members of the Legislative Assembly from 95 to 46 ; of the Council from 36 to 23, and of the Ministers from 10 to 5. The Peacock Ministry was displaced by the Irvine Cabinet Irvine, Shiels, Murray, Bent, McKenzie, Taverner, Cameron, MacLeod and Kirton. At a General Election on the nth October, 1902, Mr. W. H. Irvine, backed by the National Citizens' Reform League, swept the country, winning 64 seats, the Opposition holding 18 and the Labour Party 13. It was a ding-dong go and two dozen " old hat " politicians were wiped out for ever. If George Dean and I had not annexed the Kyabram agitators and their pet agitation, nothing would have been done and there would still have been 95 M.L.A. I suffered seriously in health, made large numbers of enemies, and lost half my Stock Exchange clients. However, I carried out an item of public service so nothing matters. Previous to Kyabram I founded the Young Victorian Patriotic League, and there we secured two thousand members in three weeks. The league fought one election for economy and lay down and died. After Kyabram I started the People's Liberal Party which perished from lack of funds. No political association can ever succeed and become permanent without plenty of money. Enthusiasm is a poor vote-catcher, and mere patriotism is valueless, but a strong banking account can win seats every time. The gravest and most serious of these political com- mittees was the Constitutional Association, and there I was the youngest member of a body which controlled the existing, but dying, Conservative Party in politics. My colleagues were R. Murray Smith, Robert Harper, Walter Madden, Edward Langton, F. T. Derham, W. F. Walker and M. R. McCrae, now of Dalgety's in Sydney. For a few years I sparkled as an official of the Australian Natives Association and 35 PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT originated half a dozen suburban branches. I had plenty of fun making inflammatory speeches about the decadent British Empire, the glorious destiny of Australia, and the superiority of the native-born Australian. Between whiles I was the instigator of public meetings to advocate occupying New Guinea and the New Hebrides, to oppose French convictism in New Caledonia, to prevent the A.M.P. Society opening an office in London, and to support Aus- tralian Federation. That section of my life was always amusing and sometimes exciting. Never forget one political meeting I had called in the Town Hall, Collingwood, to expound Kyabramic economy. Of course the audience wouldn't give me a hearing till John Hancock, M.L.A., a genial, kindly soul said, " Give the little bloke a chance for five minutes. He won't do anybody any harm." You could have heard a pin drop and a few apt allusions to the grandeur and merits of every Australian in the Collingwood electorate won me a host of transient friends who cheered me to the echo when I sat down. We used to fight about nothing at the A.N.A. meetings and I am sorry I gave up close connection with it because it is the only public body worthy of my support. When the late George Dean and I conspired to get the Kyabram economy movement into our hands, Mr. William Irvine was Premier of Victoria and Messrs. William Shiels and Thomas Bent were Ministers. As the first step towards public economy the National Citizens' Reform League, of which I was a founder, made the first plank in its platform, the reduction of members from 95 to 46 for the Legislative Assembly. At the General Election the Irvine Cabinet won 64 seats and was able to reduce the assembly to 65 members at which it now stands. Shiels and Bent offered to help me to win a seat and like a fool I declined. My election with the support of the POLITICS, LEAGUES, CLUBS Government and the National Citizens' Reform League was a certainty. My subsequent political life was bound in shallows and miseries, and I lost both my health and my business by mixing in politics as a nonentity instead of as a sitting politician. Of the making of many political leagues there is no end, and much politics is a weariness of the flesh. Here are some of the many political bodies and societies I have helped to direct, and of several of them I was prime mover. National Liberal Association in Bendigo in 1880, Young Australian Liberals in 1885, Constitu- tional Association, People's Liberal Party, National Citizens' Reform League (Kyabram), Young Vic- torian Patriotic League, Financial Reform League, Bimetallic League, Legion of Relief, and Middle Class Party. Ten scrap-books containing thousands of my speeches and articles representing forty years of public work are my only monument. I have never had a vote of thanks, a banquet, or a bouquet, though I hope some day to become a J.P. ! Before the days when political parties were organ- ized and subsidized, I stood for Parliament in a country pocket borough called Grenville, a decayed mining district near Ballarat, and made a decent showing at the poll. Encouraged by the falsity of that voting I tried single-handed to win the seat and failed badly. It was not the fault of the electors for they didn't understand me nor my highfalutin about the rights of man, the need for good public finance, the evil of too much borrowing by the Government, and woman's right to vote. I talked above their heads and they voted for the local candidate every time. It served me right to the extent of three hundred pounds per election spent in a fortnight each time. My excellent platform work began to pall on the three audiences a day, so I hired a grey horse and buggy, with a gramophone and operator and sent him to D 37 PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT every one of the thirty decayed hamlets in the electorate to deliver my speech. As he interspersed the speech with comic songs and humorous recitations the children loved it and followed him in hundreds like the Pied Piper of Hamelin. But as William Trenwith, the greatest of all the Labour tribunes of that epoch said to me, " Meudell, they don't understand you and they'll wooden you." And woodened I was. Before starting for Grenville I called on David Syme of the " Age," the greatest of all the political leaders of his time, and he promised me the powerful support of his influential newspaper. My speeches were reported, but the desirable leading article describing my wonder- ful sagacity, extraordinary intellect, and god-like personality, was never written, and I fell like Lucifer, Belial, Apollyon and other chaps of that sort into the bottomless pit of obscurity. Even since my last political defeat I've been laughing heartily whenever I think what a lot of fun I could have bought with the three hundred pounds I spent on election expenses. Like everybody else alive I am steeped, soaked, pickled in vanity, yet not so badly conceited as to avoid admitting I made one grave mistake in an active life. I descended into politics and became besmirched in business. By taking a leading part in the Kyabram movement for public economy I made armies of enemies and lost battalions of clients. No man can become a successful politician and prosper in business. The money I spent trying to get into Parliament, and the time I wasted outside my office would have been far better spent seeing the dream city of Samarkand or taking a trip to Kashmir or the West Indies, or even to Bali, in Dutch East Indies, the island of the most beautiful women. Very few politicians are educated as men, or trained for law- making. No man should be permitted to stay in Parliament after the age of sixty. Old men are the 38 POLITICS, LEAGUES, CLUBS main cause of Britain's decadence, and one recalls the present leading English statesmen when one wants a hearty laugh. Newspapers made gods of tin men painted to look like iron, such as Asquith, Lloyd George, Churchill, Amery, Balfour, Chamberlain, Baldwin, all slaves of tradition shackled by ritual and convention. And what a mess they made of the war, the army, the navy, the peace and Great Britain's trading supremacy ! HE FINDS LITTLE RIGHT Mr. H. G. Wells delivers the negative side of his gospel in what he calls " an outbreak of auto-obituary," which occurs in the last chapter of his book, " A Year of Prophesying." " I am against the clothes we wear and the food we eat, the houses we live in, the schools we have, our amusements, our money, our ways of trading, our ways of making our compromises and agreements and laws, our articles of political associa- tion, the British Empire, the American constitution. I think most of the clothes ugly and dirty, most of the food bad, the houses wretched, the schools starved and feeble, the amusements dull, the monetary methods silly, our ways of trading base and wasteful, our methods of production piecemeal and wasteful, our political arrangements solemnly idiotic. Most of my activities have been to get my soul and some- thing of my body out of the customs, outlook, bore- doms, and contaminations of the current phase of life." On the positive side Mr. Wells makes this contribution to the housing question : " Plans have been made that show beyond dispute that the whole population of industrial London could be rehoused in fine and handsome apartment buildings, with night and day lifts, roof gardens, and nearly all the light, air and conveniences to be found in a Kensington flat, at hardly greater cost than would be needed to 39 PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT choke all the ways out of London with a corresponding spread of Wheatley hovels, and so great an amount of space could be saved by so doing, that half the area of London could be made into a playground and garden." The familiar objective of Mr. Wells's hopes is, of course, a confederation of all mankind to keep one peace through the world. I do not think that the League of Nations at Geneva is ever likely to develop into an effective World Confederation. It is much more likely to develop into a serious obstacle to such a confederation. The sooner now that it is scrapped and broken up the better for mankind. When the United States rebelled and threw the German soldiers of the English kings out of the colonies in order to get control of as much of the land of North America as possible, the custom of transport- ing convicts from England to America was stopped for ever. One thousand convicts a year had been shipped to the Southern States for about a hundred years. It was one form of getting rid of political agitators, ne'er-do-well sons of aristocratic families, and pickpockets who stole pennies and purloined bread or meat from shop doors. All the rest of the malefactors were hung. There were three times as many convicts sent to America as to Australia. When the colonies were taken over from them, the English authorities sent Captain Cook to find a place far enough away to make a safe prison for poachers, sturdy beggars, pick purses, shop lifters, republicans, Communists and reformers. The rest of the real wrong-doers Bill Sikes, Jonathan Wild, Jack Shep- pard, Dick Turpin and suchlike were hung at Tyburn, near Maida Vale, London, or at the cross- roads, or in the Tower of London, or at Newgate Street off Holborn, just outside the Old Bailey prison. Captain Cook conferred a benefit on this old world 40 never before or since equalled by finding this good Australian continent, superior to all other countries in its varied climate, soil and fertility, the perfect nidus for a better race of people. Brutal, low-class English officers came with shiploads of these petty prigs and food thieves and created a penal system which dehumanized them. Of the early military Governors of the Australian colonies one cannot write too bitterly. It has become a rooted custom of historians to praise and idolize these early governors and treat them as able administrators and clever executants. The truth is the contrary. Of hundreds of governors sent from London to Australasia, perhaps ten or a dozen were decent civil servants who tried to do their best. All the rest were brainless duffers or worse. Of the nine governors-general since 1901 there may have been one who stood above the ruck. The rest were quite ordinary little men who earnestly strove to ape the manners and methods of royalty and create a mimic court composed of rich but quite ordinary women-folk. One governor-general, Lord Hopetoun, who has been praised to the skies and above them, resigned in a huff because the Govern- ment questioned his bill for the entertaining of the present King and Queen. Very shortly after he died leaving a cold million pounds of dross ! Both governors and government houses and the whole paraphernalia of pompous snobbery which they stand for, ought to be wiped out. What use are they in a community where nearly every one works, and some day the others will be made to work by law. Every Chief Justice is capable of signing Crown grants and leases, and sub-editing Government Gazettes, and if need be of deciding constitutional questions by a mere yea or nay. The seven governors cost the country about 100,000 a year, which when saved would support six good brass bands in the six capitals. PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT India and England are the two countries where the caste system flourishes luxuriantly, and where the people in the various classes or castes dislike or hate those not in theirs, mildly and virulently. To the pernicious caste system is due the two distinguishing features of life in England and India, snobbery and poverty 50 per cent snobs and 50 per cent paupers. Human nature not being changed for better or worse since man was first created we shall never entirely free ourselves from the yoke of the snob, yet we may try here to palliate it. Great Britain's cardinal weakness is her poverty. It is a striking paradox that the richest country in the world is also the poorest. Sir Henry Campbell Bannerman once told the House of Commons that one-fourth of the population of the United Kingdom was never sure of to-morrow's food. It has been reckoned that there are ten million people in Great Britain on the brink of starvation, not sure of the next meal. In no other country in the world is food so scarce and so scanty. In India, China and Japan there is no such lack of food as in the Old Country. In England and especially in London the poor are always on view : gaunt, meagre and ravenous, crawling furtively along every street north and south, east and west, licking their lips before bakers' windows. To an Australian this constant contact with the spectre, famine, this eternal brushing against the foodless and hungry and famished, stalking after skins and pips and stalks, prowling round dark corners to prospect bins and refuse boxes, is awful and pitiful ! Great Britain does not grow enough food to feed her people. She prefers to import it, and nearly three-fourths of the food consumed comes from abroad : salted, frozen and fusty. The land is there, the soil is fertile, the labour is abundant, and Britain could, if she chose, grow all her own food as easily as France and 42 POLITICS, LEAGUES, CLUBS Germany. No, she prefers to send her coal, cotton and iron to foreigners and depend on them for what she eats. Her peril of being easily starved out, either in war or peace, could be made to vanish under ten years of scientific protection. Meanwhile the few grow richer while the many starve ! The Coal Strike proved beyond question there is not more than ten days' food supply in Great Britain. The mere thought is appalling. Ten days' food for those who can buy, and no food at all for the ten million starvers, should a blockade ever occur ! And the ten millions have full minds with their empty bellies and nourish rebellious thoughts. The War and the Coal Strike allowed the flocculent human matter to rise to the surface, and the dregs and the scum floated about the streets of the towns and cities evil, hollow and desperate. What would happen during a ten days' siege ? Poverty is the primary cause of labour unrest everywhere. The cant cry of the present day is, " There is unrest everywhere," and the compelling cause is poverty. The magazines, the books, the press, all teem with statements of the unrest and discontent now raging through the world. The upheaval of the discontents proceeds apace. Everywhere in the old countries has arisen the cry for more wages, shorter hours, and cheaper food, and this clamant demand comes from one class only, the working class, or more properly, the workers' class. For, barring the idle rich, we are all working men and women nowadays. The present time is the reign of ideas, and these ideas are seething bacteria-like in the minds of the workers. The history of humanity is the history of revivals, mainly religious. The present-day revival is political, not religious, in character, marked, however, by the same enthusiasm, the same ferocity and fanaticism as every revival that has gone before. The wage-earners have at last learnt the value of unity, of co-operation, of 43 PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT alliance. All along they have known what they wanted ; to-day for the first time they know how to get it. SNAKE VALLEY ELECTION In Australia we have 7 parliaments, 7 governors, 62 ministers, 647 Members of Parliament, and the total cost of parliamentary government is 1,150,000. About 150 new laws and several hundred minor enactments are passed every year. About 4000 candidates for Parliament stand for election, so that politics in Australia is a lucrative industry. It is also a cruel tax on a population of 6,000,000, half of whom are under 21 and have no votes. It is an expensive game like golf, motoring and card-playing. Usually the man with the most money wins. Having been a defeated candidate several times I know the cost of an election and much about its humours. I was the first candidate in Australia to use the phono- graph during an election, and a bucolic constituency threw me down with a thud. At a decayed, rotten borough with 30 names on the roll my paid secretary organized a committee of 13 to collect votes and see them polled. The campaign lasted 10 days and the publican sent in a bill for refreshments, chiefly beer, for 13. There were 4 votes cast in my favour. I paid the bill without demur. Six months later the hotel-keeper sent me the same account again, so I returned him his receipt enclosed in a letter much hotter than the hobs of hell. ASSOCIATED BIMETALLIC LEAGUE The founding of the Bimetallic League was another sportive effort of mine carried out after years of study of the question of the demonetization of silver, started by Bismarck to hurt France. It was mere filibustering by old Bismarck, the leading pirate of universal history. He destroyed silver as a medium for paying 44 POLITICS, LEAGUES, CLUBS debts and harmed every debtor nation in the world, including my beloved native land Australia. Mr. Francis A. Keating of Messrs. Gibbs, Bright and Company, and now of Anthony Gibbs and Sons, London, encouraged me in my bimetallic career. Keating was a specially able and highly educated man, and what he said about bimetallism I believed. We formed a Bimetallic League and got Moreton Frewen, the famous English political economist, to address a public meeting in Melbourne, and for a year I wrote and speechified about bimetallism and dazed and hypnotized my audiences. It was splendid fun for me, because I used bimetallism as talking practice against the day when as Treasurer of Victoria I would deliver my first budget without notes and despite the help of the permanent Treasury officers. At the elections I tackled in order to enter Parliament, I was splendidly beaten by a grocer, a school-teacher, a shearer and a fruiterer ! No undertaker ever opposed me, or his unpopularity amongst really live voters would have helped me to " wooden " him. I have a genius for working dead horses on a big scale first, brown coal, next, hydro-electricity, then, petroleum, and finally, oil-shale. Have stuck tenaciously to each in turn without earning a shekel. The most disappointing of my fighting campaigns for recognition by investors was of course that for oil. The most interesting was my struggle to raise money in London to work brown coal in Victoria, totalling forty thousand million tons, for all it is worth, not alone for electricity, but for gas, briquettes, ammonia and other by-products, all saleable at a profit. We made briquettes at Yallourn, then Morwell, in 1892, and sold them in Melbourne for i a ton, and if the blessed banks had not made such asses of 45 themselves by closing their doors, the Gippsland Coal Company would have been making briquettes all these years while sitting behind a reserve fund of 1,000,000. Then I met the active antagonism of the coal importers who are also the shipping ring. They have always fought against brown coal enthusiasts and decried brown coal and briquettes. The toll levied yearly by the Newcastle, New South Wales, coal companies on every Australian industry has had a choking effect, and still the throat of industry is garrotted by them and can only be freed from the coal Thugs by a successful national briquette manu- facture. There is only one good story arising out of the creation of the electrical enterprise at Morwell, Yallourn. It was late one night towards Christmas when the Enabling Bill was before the House of Assembly. The Premier, W. A. Watt, rushed in to A. A. Billson, the Minister of Railways, and said excitedly, " W.L. says that Bill must be put through to-night." W.L. being W. L. Baillieu, M.L.C., who has pulled the strings of the marionettes com- posing every State Ministry for twenty-five years. It was just laughable because no explanation was given about the Bill or its objects ; members never knew any details of costs or expenses, and a raw, un- considered scheme compiled by two foreigners, Thomas Tait, Chief Railway Commissioner of Victoria, and C. H. Mertz, an Anglo-German electrician of Durham, England, was passed in one night simply because W. L. Baillieu said so ! The original estimate was 2,250,000, and so far the scheme has cost over 10,000,000, and will be capitalized at 15,000,000 before it turns the corner and begins to pay ! Which confirms my life view that most public men know nothing of finance or business, and their reputations as great personages is mostly poppy-cock woven by the newspapers. 46 POLITICS, LEAGUES, CLUBS CLUBS Out of four hundred members of the Athenaeum Club of Melbourne, when I was elected in July, 1889, only seven are alive to-day. It was a really first-class club, well managed, comfortable, and, excepting at the French Club, there was no better dinner in Melbourne. The Athenaeum Club was founded by James Hay who was a front ranker as a comprador, his equals being Archibald Menzies and W. C. Wilson of Scott's Hotel who were Hay's friends and contemporaries. The French Club was founded by Dr. James George Beaney, a leading surgeon, fifty years ago, and his two pals, the Denis Brothers, then leading Melbourne jewellers. Beaney wore diamonds all over his clothes wherever there was a peg to hang them on. His dinners were rare and recherche, precious as the apple of the eye, and like his diamonds of the first water. Nobody knew how to order a dinner in Melbourne in those days until Lacaton, at the Maison Doree, and Halasy and Denat, at the Cafe Anglais next to the old " Argus " office, taught the land boomers which was the right end of the asparagus to nibble, and that poulet en casserole was the summit of deliciousness. At the Australian Club founded by my father-in-law, John George Dougharty, M.L.C., and his bosom friend, Sir James MacBain, M.L.C., when I was a member, the dinners ordered from the chef carte blanche, given by Charlie Gates, the solicitor, of Taylor, Buck- land and Gates, were too ethereal almost to eat. Yet were they duly eaten. I remember that Charlie Gates had thirty-six pairs of boots in his bedroom. What a remarkable man ! As a young man I liked belonging to clubs and had a mania for founding leagues or associations. That was before my illusions were changed into delusions. There is one basic club law which ought 47 PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT to be taught the novice and impressed on every clubman at his initiation, just as certain canons of conduct were sunk in my memory, when I became a neophyte in the best religion of them all, Freemasonry. That primary rule is that what happens in a club must never be referred to outside. That club law is not kept in Melbourne, where I have belonged to about a dozen clubs. It is a practice with ignorant club members to carry home talks about their fellow- members to their wives, and next day, whether the story relates to drink, gambling or conduct, every woman in the suburbs knows all about it. The Melbourne Club is the most exclusive, and the Australian the best in Melbourne, though the Athen- aeum is comfortable, and the Commercial Travellers' Club superior in its building and appointments. The Royal Automobile Club is merely a mistake, for motorists should be united only in business and not in social union. Many of the Melbourne clubs are simply drinking dives. San Francisco has some fine modern clubs, and so has Los Angeles. The Pacific Union Club on Nobs Hill in San Francisco is one of the finest clubs out of the 1 50 I have been attached to throughout the globe. The Family Club, the Bohemian, and the Olympic in San Francisco have no imitators in Australia, nor have the Australians created a club like the Athletic Club in Los Angeles, or the Bath Club in London, where swimming baths are a feature of the club. Excepting the Royal Automobile Club on the site of the old War Office in Pall Mall, London, there was no modern club-house last time I was there. The Londoner prefers a dingy, dark, dull house for his club, which he describes as a branch of his home, and so it usually is and very like his house. Since the old St. George's Club in Hanover Square, I have been made honorary member of a large number of London clubs, in clubland and in the 48 POLITICS, LEAGUES, CLUBS city. The best dinner was to be had at the Constitu- tional, the best luncheon at the City Liberal, the best afternoon tea at the Authors' Club, while the Savage Club wins the palm for the best talkers and the oldest whisky. The most grandiose club in the world is the Jockey Club I attended in Buenos Ayres in the Argen- tine. It is a palace of magnificence de haul en has. The Author's Club at 2, Whitehall Court, London, founded in 1891 by Sir Walter Besant, elected me a member because of my high authorial attainments as a contributor of quips, cranks, and wanton wiles to the Sydney " Bulletin " for forty years. The Monday night dinners were featured in imitation of the cele- brated Savage Club Saturday dinners. It is an excellent and amusing method for giving the obscure a glimpse of the mighty under the dynamic pressure of fairly well-cooked food aided by only middling brands of fermented and spirituous liquors. In this way one saw and heard Sir Oliver Lodge, Dr. Parkin, Professor Arminius Vambery, His Excellency, Lord Lee Ching Fong, Sir William Ramsay and Mr. Henniker Heaton of Sydney. The Author's Club was an icy sort of cave where one trod on one's own tiptoes and suppressed both smile and laughter. There was nothing really to laugh at, except the atmosphere, and I used to sit reading London " Punch " and rumbling with laughter internally. Not at " Punch's " wit, which to an overseas humorist looks as though it would make a new sort of concrete pavement, heavy, strong and lasting. " Punch " is completely English, typical of the race that for a thousand years has braved the battle and the squeeze for trade and for lending money. The English no longer is a nation of shopkeepers. It can't keep shop, but, oh my, it knows how to lend money, and inci- dentally how to annex large areas of land, chiefly jungle and forest belonging to other people. The 49 PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT late Charles Garvice was chairman of the committee, and the most notable of the authors was Poulteney Bigelow, with whom I travelled once in the East Indies, Hall Caine, Andrew Carnegie (whose mono- graph on " Steel and how to make money out of it " has never been published), Francis Gribble, Rider Haggard, Anthony Hope, Cutcliffe Hyne, Morley Roberts, Franklin Lieber, the author of a very heavy, well-bound telegraphic code, and myself. No travel book worth while that touches upon London life would be perfect without a reference to the famous Savage Club, the tryst of London's clever men-authors, artists, play-actors and intelligentsia as a caste above the bourgeoisie who swarm in the world's metropolis and make it so dashed respectable and humdrum. The middle-class people of Britain, taking themselves and their caste so very seriously, are never vulgar nor outre. They may be droll, comic, farcical, laughable, at the same time they respect the conventions, pay their rates and taxes, half fill the churches, and all of them honour the King. Often have I been a guest of Savage Club members, and the best story one can tell without breaking club law was told me by E. J. Odell, a Savage Club celebrity, bon vivant, bon viveur et bon raconteur. One night about eleven he went into the bar and to his horror saw Phil May holding a whisky and polly in each hand laughing merrily at nothing. " Time to go home, Phil." ' With pleasure, Odell," so they left suddenly and slumped into the ancient growler Phil May hired by the year to take him anywhere day and night. At Phil's house in St. John's Wood he made Odell comfortable in the spare bedroom, taking care to leave a syphon of soda, a one-twelfth of a dozen of Dan Crawford, and a box of matches alongside the bed. Then Phil May slipped out back into the four-wheeler and headed for the Savage Club. Odell got tired of POLITICS, LEAGUES, CLUBS being asleep so he aroused himself and left the house with the idea of going back to the Savage for a dock and a doris. Being penniless he walked from St. John's Wood down the Maida Vale Road to the Adelphi Terrace and arrived at the club at about one a.m. Odell told me he had to laugh heartily because in the same bar entertaining the same members with the same japes was Phil May sticking tightly to a whisky and polly in each fist ! What a precious story. I have had many delicious sprees in clubs in all corners of the earth and without telling tales out of school, a thing I detest, one particular night at the Family Club in San Francisco was the wittiest I have ever attended. Had a bonzer all-night revel at a club in Quebec, Canada, with Frank Carrell, a news- paper proprietor, and felt the joy of seeing a member ejected who said to me laughingly, " You come from Australia, don't you, where the English send all their criminals ? " " Yes," I said, " that was a bad habit of the early English who sent Walter Raleigh and Captain Cook round the globe looking for suitable prisons for their criminal relatives and so made use of Canada, the Southern States of America, and Australia." Then they fired the poor devil down the stairs quite rudely and unjustly. ASSOCIATIONS The very best service I ever rendered to my fellow- labourers in the vineyard of the Lord was when I inaugurated the movement to get better pay for bank clerks. Being born in a bank and knowing how badly my father was paid by the Bank of Victoria, who gave him eight hundred pounds a year as general manager, I made a solemn vow to agitate for better pay and more humane conditions for bank clerks. I tried several times to get into Parliament where I would have agitated for a Royal Commission on the subject. My fellow-conspirator was the late Melville Calder who was allowed a salary of five pounds a week after thirty years in the Bank of Victoria. Mel. and I frequently discussed the formation of a bank clerks' association, but we never could get any of our pals to join our revolution. They were all afraid and said so. By the head of a leading bank I was warned not to have anything to do with the agitation openly. I mentioned my project to a friend who took the risk, got a few insurgents together, and launched the Bank Officials' Association. They ignored me alto- gether instead of giving me the secretaryship. Of course higher salaries were bound to come, yet some- body had to begin asking for them, and to Mel. Calder and myself is due the honour of beginning this excellent reform which led to the proper treatment of bank employe's, better pay, better housing and better pensions. A.N.A. In my callow days as in my mature, when I lived on ideals and illusions, I was intensely patriotic and too fond of writing and lecturing. I was an ardent missioner for the Australian Natives' Association. Never missed a meeting of the Melbourne No. i Branch, read papers, started debates, helped to open six suburban branches, and to organize meetings on national problems like the New Hebrides, New Cale- donia, New Guinea, Federation of Australia and so on and so forth. Being a Savings Bank officer with excellent prospects in the service I avoided politics, until I found most of the men I was associated with in the A.N.A. were working towards Parliament through the A.N.A. Jeff. Connelly, an extremely brilliant young solicitor in Bendigo, was a mate of mine in the Young Australian Liberal Association, and I found out his chief idea in boosting the A.N.A. was 52 POLITICS, LEAGUES, CLUBS to use it to get into Parliament. That he would have got there and been Premier of Victoria was a certainty. The two Barretts, Sunderland and Field, passed into politics through the A.N.A. ; and so did George Turner, J. L. Purves, Dave Hennessy (afterwards Lord Mayor of Melbourne), Dr. T. P. Mclnerney, W. A. Watt, G. H. Wise, J. Hume Cook and Arthur Robinson. Particularly did Alick Peacock carry the A.N.A. banner all day and sleep in it all night, and it has paid him well. After a field night with my mentor, Alfred Deakin, at an A.N.A. meeting, I consulted him regarding the wrong use of this patriotic and friendly society for political ends. When I said I would resign, Deakin advised me to stick to it. However, I dropped out and the A.N.A. has fallen from grace as a national society and has become a safe sick and burial association. Our politics would have been superior if the A.N.A. had retained its leadership of the Australian born. But it has been badly officered and now it is a feeble shadow of what it might have been, a great national brotherhood, and has become a good benefit society in these latter days when all friendly societies are tottering to extinction. 53 CHAPTER IV BANKS AND BANKERS AMONGST my collection of Meudelliana is one essay I read before the Bankers' Institute of Australia, of which I was an associate, entitled " Is the Bank of England Safe ? " which brought me much ignominy and many snubs. My argument then was that the bank did not hold enough gold and the result of its efforts to attract gold by raising the bank rate of interest did harm to the trade and commerce of London and Britain. I was merely forty years before my time. The war proved that credit was the thing and gold only fustian. The war was run on paper, and the political economists, when I lay at the breast of enlightenment, told the world that gold was in- dispensable, therefore the Bank of England was safe and I was wrong and deserved being kicked. Now I repeat that the control of the money market and the power to raise the rate of interest arbitrarily is brigand- age, pillage, and buccaneering, which causes immense loss every year to the merchants, traders and business people of the Empire. The Bank of England should be cut adrift and told it was unworthy to be a national bank, because it wilfully uses its control of the dis- count and interest rate to harm the whole business community. The raising and lowering of the bank rate in London is the chief financial scandal of the greatest wrong-doing to the world's trade and com- merce that is perpetrated by the seemingly honest men who are directors of the Bank of England. My first experience of a bank was acquired as a baby born in Sandhurst. My father was gold buyer 54 BANKS AND BANKERS and accountant in the Bank of Victoria during the first gold rush. In eight years he personally bought over one million ounces of gold, and no man outside the Royal Mint ever did that in history. Gold was everywhere : on and just under the surface in flakes, as dust, in cubes, in lumps, as small specimens attached to quartz, like sparrow-hail and duck shot, in alluvial form in every creek and river, shaped in big nuggets or little ones, all over the land. Gold could be washed or picked or dollied or sluiced in every creek in Bendigo. Then when the first diggers swept the banks, basin and valley of the Bendigo Creek, clean and goldless for ten miles in length by two miles wide, they cleansed all the tributary creeks of the perilous stuff and there was no aftermath or gleaning. When the diggers began not to see the gold they started digging down from the grass to twelve feet in the pipeclay where more and more gold was won for little effort. I have seen two holes at Long Gully twelve feet deep from which my father bought 1200 worth of twenty-two carat gold from four men who had worked exactly four hours each. My first remembrance of seeing gold was when my father one rainy day filled his red bandana handker- chief with a mass of clay taken from the peak of a white pipeclay pyramid. We were on our way to the Presbyterian Church at White Hills on that particular Sunday and it would have been heterodox to wash off the 18 ounces, worth, 72 on the Sabbath. In Golden Gully, near Golden Square, where gold was first discovered in 1851, and in Long Gully and California Gully, I have been shown holes (not shafts) which yielded in solid gold two thousand pounds' worth in a day ! The dirt was easily mined with pick and shovel, and directly a claim was gutted it was abandoned. Those early gold seekers took care to leave very little gold behind ! The diggers led a 55 PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT dirty, rough, uncomfortable life because of the want of water for drinking and washing. They worked in a lovely grass-lined forest free from snow and wild beasts, in a climate perfect except in summer and in a country lacking only good society, just as hell lacks water and good society. The Bank of Victoria, Bendigo, bought vast quantities of gold, both quartz and alluvial, all of the highest quality. Smelting was carried on almost continuously in the bank smelting house right under my bedroom window. For years I saw gold in every shape, size and condition, from nugget to ingot, and so much and so often, as to become familiar with it, without feeling the slightest contempt for the stuff man loves the most of all inorganic things. When very young, one became accustomed to the arrival at all hours of the bank's gold buyers, both officers and agents laden with the precious stuff. The gold escort by coach to Melbourne was just before my advent, and the less picturesque escort in a railway carriage full of armed police and clerks was the mode of transport. It is a simple boast to say I have seen more gold weighed for one escort than the whole of the last generation of young Australians have seen in their lives. Gold made Victoria, Victoria made Australia, and Australian gold made the present British Empire. Without Aus- tralia's gold from 1852 to 1872, London could not have become the open gold market of the world, and her shipping and foreign trade would not have been on the vast and overwhelming scale made possible by the possession of gold for paying foreign debts and drafts. Banking and shipping have made Britain great, but without gold her banking and shipping could not have expanded so enormously or so quickly. Truly her merchants and manufacturers, thanks to the invention of steam, were ready to capture the world's commerce and markets, and Australian gold 56 BANKS AND BANKERS largely helped Britain to conquer them. Gold mining has been allowed to perish in Australia, and the world's output is declining gradually. It needs no second sight or gift of prophecy to foresee the revival of gold mining, because the nations must have gold to pay their debts to one another, and until a better standard than gold is found and universally adopted, the world must get gold whatever it costs to win ! Nowadays in South Africa and Australasia ten penny-weights of gold per ton does not pay to produce. Without hesitation I predict the mines will soon be satisfied with ten grains to the ton rather than not mine for gold. The period of paper money and inflation will very soon fade out into an epoch of repudiation and cancellation of paper currency and paper bonds, and the people of the earth will go back to the use of gold as the basis of exchange and currency. Gold and human nature are two unchangeable things. Without gold and enough of it this civilization will decay and die, and as it is an imperfect framework for humanity it will not matter if it does disappear. My father was frequently moved from one branch to another chiefly where the gold lay thickest. The banks made huge profits buying gold at 2 IQS. an ounce and selling it in London at 4 ! One rest from the never-ending gold buying my father had when he was sent to Warrnambool to recover a mass of doubtful debts due by the squatters who originally took up land at los. to ^i an acre and ran a few ill- bred sheep on stations that were neither cleared nor fenced. Warrnambool was the market town for the squatters within a radius of a hundred miles. They were mostly Scotch and Irish peasants or shepherds and very few of them were educated. There was precious little blue blood and very few aristocrats in the Western District in those days, though there were plenty of kindly, hospitable and respectable farmers 57 PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT and graziers, and none of them were very rich. In- crease of population made many of these people wealthy in course of time, and land valued by the banks then at 30*. and 2 an acre is worth 15 to 20 to-day. A lot of nonsense has been written about the hardships of these pioneer squatters, the majority of whom led pleasant, easy lives free from anxiety and hard work. As a class they were narrow, uncultured, and not public spirited. To return again to the bank collapse in Melbourne during the height of The Terror of 1893. Let me recapitulate the position after the crisis. Twelve banks of issue suspended with total liabilities of 103,315,214, including deposits for 81,331,223 ; 47 building societies, over 100 land banks, property and investment companies and innumerable land syndicates, at a guess 500, were dragged down to the dust after the Walpurgis night dance of over- borrowing, over-lending, and over-valuation. The destruction and ruin of thousands of hard-working, respectable people was horrific. The Dark Age of Victoria lasted for ten years, and the havoc and wreckage was not cleared away for thirty ! Yet nobody was punished for causing the cataclysm and destroying hundreds of homes. Not a single land valuer was sent to gaol. Only one unworthy bank or building society manager " did time," whilst most of them made dishonest compositions with their creditors, hid house and shop property away in their wives' names and generally began again with light hearts their occupations of fleecing the public on the Stock Exchange or in the real estate market. The only bright spot in Victorian industry all through that insane banking and land boom was the fact that eighty-four gold and silver mines remained on the dividend list and kept thousands of poverty-stricken people in bread and butter, but no circuses. Our 58 women were more heroic than the men and went out to work in thousands to keep the poor old ruined people in the mansions and cottages in food. There was no panic leading up to the gigantic failure. The extinction of the banks was due to a quiet weeping away of deposits, a silent, secret system of drawing a cheque for your current account or fixed deposit and paying it into the Union or the Australasia or the New South Wales. There were no frantic runs on the banks, and no frenzy was shown openly by depositors. It was first come, first paid, and the bank liquid assets and coin simply faded away. It was a good thing there were no Treasury or Com- monwealth Bank Notes in those days to bolster up rotten institutions, because every bank that broke completely ought to have done so. Indeed some of them should not have been allowed to re-open. Some of the defunct banks simply annexed their customers' deposits and wrote off 90 per cent of their over- drafts " Convey," the wise call it steal ? foh ! a fico for the phrase ! The humour of it. Nobody was punished and everybody suffered except the men who engineered the financial downfall of an innocent public. The ruin was almost universal and the Australians, specially the women, took their losses and misfortunes smiling, and kept on working. Nobody was killed or hurt and only a very few of the perpetrators of the ruin committed suicide. The leading valuators of those days should have gone to prison. On Friday, 2ist April, 1893, there was a "run" in Sydney on the bank of New South Wales, Com- mercial Banking Company of Sydney, City Bank of Sydney, and Government Savings Bank. Sir George Dibbs, Premier of New South Wales, visited the Savings Bank and guaranteed the deposits, yet such an important event is not included in the 59 PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT official chronological table from 1788 forward. Such was the policy of hush and secrecy. In Melbourne the National Bank of Australasia closed its doors on Saturday, 3Oth April, 1893. The chief debtors of the bank were B. J. Fink, Chaffey Brothers of Mildura, Sydney land companies, and the Midland Railway of West Australia. The National Bank paid out 650,006 worth of coin in four weeks preceding its collapse. Finally the Commercial Banking Company of Sydney, Australian Joint Stock Bank and City Bank of Sydney stopped and re- constructed. In Queensland in May, 1893, the Queensland National Bank, the Royal Bank of Queensland, and the Bank of North Queensland shut up shop. Undoubtedly one prime cause of the Victorian banks tangling up their affairs was an alteration of the banking law on the advice of a Royal Commission on banking in 1887, permitting any bank, however chartered, to advance money directly on mortgage instead of by collateral security. In Sydney, Sir George Dibbs, Premier, did the wisest thing possible by issuing a Gazette on Monday, 1 5th May, 1893, declaring bank notes then in circula- tion to be legal tender. It is worthy of noting that on 3 ist March, 1893, all the notes of all the banks in all the Colonies (a word I hate intensely) only amounted to 4,818,766. Nowadays note circulation verges close to 55,000,000, and is the main cause of high prices in Australia and the high cost of living. A wise Commonwealth bank governor would call up or sell on the open market all the 27,000,000 of Commonwealth and State stock, treasury bills, deben- tures, and fixed deposits he holds, and recall that much of the note circulation. It was terribly bad and dangerous financing to issue notes by way of loan to these impecunious and badly managed State treasuries. With how little wisdom are our public 60 BANKS AND BANKERS finances and banking functions managed ? The newspaper press is largely responsible for these very ordinary men who have been Governors of the Commonwealth Bank, Prime Ministers and Premiers, and bank general managers losing their heads from adulation and the universal process of lick-spittling. Most of the heads of banks and alleged able leaders of finance and capitalists I have met or heard about are a pretty poor lot of ordinary men and very few of them are educated or intellectual. There was absolutely no need for the Commercial of Sydney to close, but Thomas Dibbs, the general manager closed as a matter of expediency to get the chance to strengthen his bank's position. Years previously Dibbs told my father he could close all his branches, keep Head Office open, and pay 10 per cent dividend out of the bank's station properties. The City of Melbourne Bank only had 1,000,000 on deposit in Melbourne the day it shut up, and 3,750,000 on fixed deposit in Scotland. It was latterly a badly managed concern with a Board of elderly directors. Old men who want to sleep in the afternoon and do not watch the general manager and the overdraft lists sharply are a menace. There were plenty of amusing incidents during the enforced bank holiday decided by the late G. D. Carter, then unfortunately Treasurer of Victoria. Carter was a whisky merchant who was quite untrained in finance though he sustained his ignorance with a colossal conceit of himself. I went into the Bank of Austra- lasia the day it defied the Government holiday pro- clamation to shake hands with John Sawers, the superintendent, who was an old friend of my father's in the early days of Victorian banking. While standing there I noticed Mars Buckley, the draper, come in with two of his shopwalkers dressed in customary suits of solemn black each carrying two large leather 61 PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT trunks. Mars drew 10,000 in sovereigns, filled the bags and toddled across to the Safe Deposit. Whatever might happen to the Bank of Australasia, " old Tapes and Ribbons " was determined to be safe. I didn't blame Buckley, because I had lodged 1000 in gold in the Safe Deposit nearly two years before the debacle. Some dreadfully irregular things were done during the boom and winked at by those who knew better. One signature to the transfer of a city property was forged, but whether the forger knew it was wrong it was impossible to discover. BANKS 1893 In 1893 Australian banks had 79,000,000 on deposit, 54,000,000 in Australia and 25,000,000 in London. These banks did not close : Bank of Australasia, Bank of New South Wales, Union Bank, Royal Bank, Bank of New Zealand, all of which ignored the moratorium or holidays gazetted by the Government of Victoria. There were twenty-six land, finance and mortgage companies with nominal capital 10,000,000 : paid up 5,200,000 and debentures issued for 12,000,000. This is the list of banks which stopped payment, reconstructed and re-opened : Suspended. Federal Bank of Australia ... Mercantile Bank of Australia Commercial of Australia ... ... 5th April, 1893. National cf Australasia ... ... ist May, English, Scottish & Australian ... 1 3th April, Australian Joint Stock ... ... 2ist April, London Chartered ... ... 26th April, Colonial ... ... ... 6th May, Bank of Victoria ... ... i oth May, Queensland National ... ... 1 5th May, Commercial Banking Co. of Sydney ... 1 6th May, City of Melbourne ... ... lyth May, Standard Bank ... ... ... 28th April, 62 BANKS AND BANKERS The City of Melbourne and Standard Bank were too hopelessly rotten to re-open, so they stayed shut. The Federal and Mercantile banks went bung much sooner. FEDERAL BANK The downfall of the Federal Bank was the most disgraceful climacteric of the disastrous banking and land boom of 1886 to 1893. The head and front of the whole offending was the late James Munro, the champion of the teetotal party of the period. Munro used this position and his building society business to push his politics, and used his politics to push railways through suburban lands he and his clan, clique or ring, had bought beforehand. So the Clan Munro founded the Federal Bank with the help of J. B. Watson, the tri-millionaire gold miner of Bendigo. The Federal was a bank of issue, a savings bank and a building society. J. B. Watson had 10,000 shares at the start, and the other chief shareholders were : James Munro ... ... 4363 shares. William McLean, Ironmonger ... 4000 W. McLean & Jenner ... ... 1000 John Robb, Railway Contractor ... 8310 A. T.Robb . ... 3350 Whittingham Bros., Graziers ... 4100 " Table Talk," a fearless Society paper, published the following facts : "James Munro, his sons, sons-in-law, and his clan of non-drinking, church-going friends borrowed all the capital of the Federal Bank, 500,000, and nearly all its deposits. Donald Munro had nine overdrafts amounting to 161,237. Donald paid 6d. in the i." " Mr. G. Munro, a third son, owed 8000. The Hon. James Munro himself owed 30,141 and on 63 PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT account of his station (per Crellin) 38,702. The other directors had the following overdrafts : {. John Robb ... ... ... 21,000 John Whittingham ... ... 7,000 Whittingham Bros. ... ... 18,000 William McLean ... ... 55,297 Davies and W. McLean ... ... 7,000 Mrs. McLean ... ... ... 231 Kew Land Company (McLean) ... 4,764 The "Table Talk" account continued : " The list of the overdrafts in the Melbourne office, representing Mr. Munro's introductions, includes the following accounts, which we publish, without expressing any opinion as to their value as assets. The public, however, are entitled to know some particulars, and any man of business may judge which of the debts will be available for collection at 20J. in the 1." I Australian Alliance Investment Company ... 7,105 W. L. Baillieu, trust account ... ... 2,580 E. L. Baillieu ... ... ... 1,867 J. G. Baillieu ... ... ... 5,084 * W. L. Baillieu ... ... ... 28,034 R. F. Baillieu ... ... ... 945 R. L. Balding ... ... ... 5,188 Crellin (James Munro's station property) ... 38,702 Davies and McLean ... ... ... 7,000 A. G. Hall ... ... ... 4,067 A. G. Hall ... ... ... 1,337 A. G. Hall ... ... ... 15,000 Heart of Preston Estate Co. (Baillieu) ... 13,700 Henry George, Limited ... ... 10,300 64 BANKS AND BANKERS Kew Land Company (McLean) ... 4,764 J. A. Kitchen ... ... ... 7,000 Latham and Ashton ... ... ... 17,172 Latham and Baillieu ... ... ... 10,484 Munro and Baillieu, special account ... 20,734 Munro and Baillieu, lease account ... 7,600 Munro and Baillieu ... ... ... 70,209 Alexander Munro and Company ... 28,526 Donald Munro ... ... ... 26,161 Hon. James Munro ... ... ... 30,141 G. M. Munro ... ... ... 8,000 William McLean ... ... ... 55,297 Mrs. McLean ... ... ... 231 Queen Investment Land Company ... 31,837 John Robb ... ... ... 21,000 W P roperty Company ... ... 20, 150 Whittingham Brothers ... ... 18,000 John Whittingham ... ... ... 7,000 Total 565,215 Hon. James Munro formed a company called the Real Estate Mortgage and Deposit Bank to take over his own land speculations like the Chatsworth Estate, the Strathfieldsaye Station, the Narbethong Estate, the station in the Northern Territory and Kimberley, W.A., the La Rose Estate and other freehold pro- perties on which the ascertained loss was 608,500. The report of the liquidators of the Real Estate Bank showed that over 1,000,000 had been lost under James Munro's management. He actually had himself appointed Agent-General for Victoria in London. His estate was sequestrated : liabilities, 94,066 ; assets, 43,960. These were only remnants of his widespread foolish speculations, and the amount he got from banks and institutions must have been colossal. The following list is taken from " Table Talk" of 9th June, 1893, edited by a singularly 65 PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT clever man, Maurice Brodsky, who married the sister of B. J. and Theodore Fink. For his fearlessness Brodsky had to retreat to London, and so did Benjamin Josman Fink who was threatened with assassination. When B. J. Fink died in London he left 250,000, chiefly made up of feathers from his nest, called Fink's Building, corner of Elizabeth and Flinders Street, Melbourne. By the way, three valuable corners of Melbourne had, it is alleged, faulty titles, and it is alleged all three were acquired by adverse possession, that is, by fencing them in and paying the rates for sixteen years, hoping the dead owner would never return. Fink's Building was one, the State Savings Bank, corner of Collins and Spencer Streets was another, and the Liverpool Buildings, corner of William and Bourke Streets was another of these vacant and unclaimed lots. The late Nathaniel Levi, an old bill-poster, owned this latter block, recently sold it to the British Imperial Oil Company and renamed Shell Corner, but playfully known to the wits on the village green as Blood Suckers Building. At one point of the smash period the " Argus " gave data relating to sixty-seven private compositions under Section 151 of the tenth part of the Insolvency Act. The defaulters were mostly barristers and solicitors with liabilities 3,800,982, assets 1,023,830 and deficiency 2,777,152. Under forty-seven arrangements only 65,821 was paid on the total liabilities of 2,280,807 ' Half of the " compotes " offered to pay from one farthing to threepence in the pound, most of them never paid a bean, a pepper- corn, or a mustard seed ! The " Argus " estimated the total liabilities at 4,500,000 to 5,000,000. My list of 248 " compotes " runs up to 15,000,000, and even then it was only part of the story ! The favourite offer to pay was one penny in the pound ! And even in those far-off times I have heard men 66 BANKS AND BANKERS thanking God for " our strong Supreme Court Bench." Pooh ! These liquidators never got any- where near the precincts of the Supreme Court. The insolvencies were all smothered in bank parlours and lawyers' offices ; smothered, stifled, strangled and buried with extreme unction. THE CYCLOPAEDIA OF VICTORIA The Honourable William Lawrence Baillieu, repre- senting the Northern Province in the Legislative Assembly of Victoria, is a member of the well-known firm of W. L. Baillieu and Company, auctioneers and estate agents, 375, Collins Street, Melbourne. He was born in Queenscliff, Victoria, in the year 1859, and is the second son of the late Mr. J. G. Baillieu, one of the early pioneers of Queenscliff. He was educated in Queenscliff, and in 1874, at the age of fourteen, entered the service of the Bank of Victoria, Queenscliff, and was engaged in banking pursuits till the year 1885. In that year he started business as auctioneer, etc., in conjunction with Mr. Donald Munro, under the style of Munro and Baillieu. This firm was carried on with considerable success till 1892, when Mr. Baillieu withdrew from the partnership and started operations on his own account. In 1897 Mr. A. S. Baillieu was admitted as a partner, and in 1899 Mr. H. Scott was admitted, the firm having carried on business since under the style of Baillieu, Allard and Company. Mr. W. L. Baillieu is a director of the " Herald " Company and the Carlton United Breweries Company. In 1891 he was elected to a seat in the Legislative Council, in which he represents the Northern Province. He married in 1887, Bertha, a daughter of Edward Latham, the well-known brewer, and has a family of six children. His wife is dead. 67 PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT BANK MANAGERS IN BOOM The four bank managers who did the most harm during the banking boom were Henry Gyles Turner and John McCutcheon of the Commercial Bank of Australia, Alfred Priestly of the Federal Bank, and Colin Longmuir of the City of Melbourne Bank, all deceased. They were an amusing quartette who com- peted keenly and stupidly for banking business. They bid against one another for deposits in England, Ireland and Scotland, and when they got them in millions, enacted a harlequinade and scattered overdrafts, loans, and discounts right and left on the just and the unjust alike. The quality of the security was not strained, and credit dropped like the gentle rain from heaven upon the tag-rag and bobtail men of straw who were conducting a feverish land boom among themselves based upon false, faked, and untrue valuations. Having an overdraft of 40,000 against security for 60,000 worth of mushroom land, banks and building societies' shares, I contracted a fell funk and went and sold everything I had and gave it to the poor banker. Would you believe it, he up- braided me, told me I was hurting him with his board by paying off my advance, and implored to begin all over again to any extent I cared to name ! Like those other over-rated and highly-extolled bank managers, he had been led away by the paper pros- perity born of foreign deposits and foreign loans. Like them he banished care and caution and became daft. The Australian Deposit and Mortgage Bank was rather a superior sort of small bank which made advances on land and houses. When it failed J. M. Davies, a sound business lawyer, drafted a scheme of reconstruction and arrangements with its depositors under which the bank re-opened and went on with its 68 BANKS AND BANKERS business. Soon after the Commercial Bank of Aus- tralia collapsed and J. M. Davies practically copied the A.D. and M. Bank scheme with which the depositors and shareholders of the Commercial were shackled. It was one-sided and unjust, especially to those who were compelled to take shares for deposits. It took the Commercial Bank thirty years to pull round. Its ordinary shares for many years were despised till a strong group of Australian brokers in London began to buy up the ordinary shares now worth about 325. and cut a great fortune out of them. During the entire period of convalescence the Com- mercial Bank has been just as carefully managed, as it was disgracefully managed during the boom period. These men did not practise pococurantism or the art of keeping cool and not worrying. They were feather-weight financiers and their actions brought the whole financial structure of Victoria to disaster. WILLIAM MEUDELL Dr. Black was the founder of the Bank of Victoria, and the Hon. Henry Miller the first chairman of the bank. " Money " Miller made a protege of my father simply because he could rely on him. The old man was as straight as a gun barrel, and although he was genial and popular he had plenty of moral courage and could say " No " quite easily, an attribute most of us haven't got, but which is essential in the make- up of a good bank manager. Twice my governor saved the Bank of Victoria from smashing. It had only .250,000 paid up and a moderate expansion of the advances meant trouble, if they threatened to become fixed or frozen instead of being liquid. One day about 1867 the old man got a hurry call to go to the Head Office and meet Mr. Miller and Mr. John Matheson, the general manager. He was ordered to Warrnambool by the first boat, in those faraway F 69 PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT days the s.s. " Edina." With six balls of quicksilver at home, yclept children, it couldn't be done. When the governor got to Warrnambool he found a sticky mess. A firm of live stock auctioneers, Macgregor and Co., had got the squatters and farmers of the Warrnambool district to go in for dealing in sheep and cattle and to buy and sell on bills. Everybody would endorse anybody's bills, and especially Mac- gregor's who had won the hearts of the three local bank managers by discounting bills endorsed with full recourse by men then struggling to improve Western District sheep stations which to-day are enormously profitable to their grandsons. My father found overdrafts and bills discounted for over 80,000, or one-third of the capital of the Bank of Victoria in a comatose condition, unpaid inactive accounts, growing instead of shrinking. My father got into the collar, fixed his haims on tightly, nailed up his swingle-trees, girded up his loins and started to pull his clients and his bank out of the mire. It was a hard unpleasant task, but by nursing the good men and getting rid of the bad, he recovered the bad debts. The new managers of the other two local banks did fine team work with him, and they all got out of the bog, thanks of course to the rich land they held as security. As a kiddy I used to go with my father to squatter's homes to hold the ponies while the old man talked finance and clips and crops, just as though he was a partner of these young men, mostly Scotch, who loved and trusted him. The proof is that my father personally administered six deceased estates totalling 750,000, without losing one penny of principal or interest, and if he had cared he could have had double that number and value of estates as sole executor. Within four years, he had pulled the business back to normal and was then sent to Bendigo to square up a heavy list of bad debts which were 70 BANKS AND BANKERS crippling the bank, mostly owing by defunct mining companies, in those days all limited and not no liability, who had a habit of stopping work and, rather than make calls, of letting the overdraft r.i.p. He recovered about ,50,000 of bad and doubtful debts, and his reward was the general managership of the Bank of Victoria at 800 a year, a house over the bank in Collins Street for my parents and six sisters. Imagine the meanness of a board of directors that paid its chief manager ,800 a year to handle 10,000,000 of assets and liabilities ! The Bank of Victoria was founded by Dr. Black and Hon. Henry Miller, better known as " Money " Miller, who learnt banking and money lending in the Union Bank, Hobart. It is said Henry used to lend money to his fellow-clerks at slightly over the current rate charged on overdrafts. For years the paid-up capital of the Bank of Victoria was only 250,000, and old " Money " held most of the shares. When the Vic. burst wide open on 9th May, 1893, the published list of shareholders showed that the Millers held only a trifling handful of shares, Edward having 380, Albert 390, Septimus 324, and William Henry 276 worth 5 each, 5 uncalled, out of a register of 120,000 shares. Sir W. J. Clarke was the biggest holder with 2058 shares. Which reminds me I had a glass of sherry with Sir W T illiam at the Athenaeum Club about an hour before he collapsed to death on a tram in Collins Street. As I was elected a member of the Athenaeum Club in July, 1889, I am well within the first dozen members still alive out of 400 in that year. A fine club, the Athenaeum, composed of real leaders in every walk of life. Although I met all the celebrated men of the day there, club law forbids me to tell any tales about them. PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT W. KNOX AND JOHN ALSOP Of all the business men with whom I have been connected during my meteoric career, William Knox was easily one of the very best. With all his mannerisms he was shrewd, just and always kindly and helpful. The Broken Hill silver pioneers were fortunate in getting him to be the driving force of the new industry. If Knox had remained in the Bank of Victoria he could not have failed to become general manager. He had plenty of tact and a deep knowledge of human nature. Another fine character amongst leading men was the late John Alsop, actuary of the Melbourne Savings Bank, with which he was connected all his life. He laid the foundations firmly and well of the present State Savings Bank system by opening suburban branches and pursuing an active advertising policy. Because I was the first Victorian to win Isaac Pitman's shorthand certificate, Alsop made me his assistant, and I have a scrap book of twenty-five pamphlets on thrift, which I wrote for him, besides hundreds of newspaper letters, and each was a brilliant coruscation of literary gems adapted from Samuel Smiles, Charles Spurgeon and Ralph Waldo Emerson, on the virtue of being thrifty, and how good it was for the young. All these authori- ties saved their pennies, let their pounds rip and died poor. This much sank into my bones and filled up lesions in my brains. Save all the money you can in early youth and middle age, and spend it on what gives you happiness. Big estates and probate duties are merely lack-lustre joys only suitable for wowsers and dullards who cannot realize the joy of living in the present, because their thoughts, conduct and actions are concentrated on what they will do in the eternity after death. Carpe diem, enjoy to-day, ought to be tattooed on the chest of every babe which sur- 7* BANKS AND BANKERS vives the critical age of twelve months. These pamphlets of mine were distributed from house to house by three returned soldiers from the Crimea and the Indian Mutiny. They pushed them under doors, put them in letter boxes, under the mats, through the keyholes, everywhere except down chim- neys, literally in millions. In five years Alsop had doubled the number of depositors' accounts and set an archaic, half-dead institution on the high road of prosperity. When I suggested I might go round the world at my own expense to find out how other savings banks were behaving, the trustees gave me nine months' leave, and I visited as many savings banks in Europe, Great Britain, the United States and Canada as time allowed. The net result was nothing. Savings banks abroad were a hundred years behind the Melbourne Savings Bank in book- keeping, advertising and service to depositors. And they are to-day. Like our Australian banking system, the Australian Savings Banks lead the world. Denial of this is difficult, because in every civilized country on the globe I have seen and observed these banks of the poor. That trip cost me 250, while my second world's tour ate up 1000. When my father was general manager of the Bank of Victoria in Melbourne, he was presented with a letter of introduction by a new chum early one Monday morning written by the young man's uncle, whose famous family had extremely large sums on fixed deposit in the London office of the bank. The youngster was a typical product of an English public school : well groomed, quite illiterate, very athletic, and enormously superior to everybody. He was affable, courteous and ignorant ; in fact, a real scion of a true British aristocrat. He said he wanted to learn banking, so my father handed him over to the paying teller who set him to work sorting 73 PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT crumpled notes. Entering the over-crowded teller's box with its piles of gold and silver and hillocks of notes, Monty loudly exclaimed, " Bai Jove, what a lot of munnay ! " That was all he uttered from ten until one o'clock, when the teller told him he might go out to lunch and be back at two. The well-groomed cadet of a noble family never came back and has never been seen in Melbourne from then till now. When the paying teller tried to balance his cash at four o'clock he found he was 2500 short in notes of assorted denominations, singles, fives and tens ! His uncle was advised by cable of the episode and his reply authorized the bank to debit his account for the missing amount. Ned Kelly was a man born out of his time with no education excepting his great knowledge of the Book of the Bush ; his leaping thought, rapid action and fertility of resource marked him as a clever fighter who in a modern war could have entered as a private and ended as a general. His father had been a convict, but not a convict of the brutal type. Rather his offences against the law were of the kind natural to a new country of few fences. The lifting of horses, and the duffing of cattle were not crimes generally execrated. In fact, they were the crimes from which many a great pastoral family in many countries have dated their beginnings. His mother naturally accepted the commercial morality of her husband and of her times. Her only crime was to protect her children from pursuit of the police, then more hated than in more settled times, and probably deserving some of the hatred. She was in gaol when her son was under sentence of death, and her last words to him are recorded to have been, " Ned would die like a Kelly." Ned Kelly's first brush with the police and his first convictions were the matter of lifting a horse. 74 BANKS AND BANKERS In his youth he knew Power, the bushranger, an inoffensive, old, bad man. When released from his first imprisonment the dislike of the " currency lad " for that which he regarded as his oppressive supervision by the police made his course rapid down the latent ways of crime. The cold murder of Sergeant Kennedy put him outside the pale ; after that he shot the traitor, Aaron Sherriff, who had been in his pay and was about to sell him to the police. Ned Kelly shot Sherriff at the door of SherrifFs house, while the police who were there to " take " the outlaw, Kelly, cowered in a back room. From that time Ned Kelly became more daring and intrepid ; he knew the value of speed to the moment ; he struck swiftly and moved swiftly to a place fifty or one hundred miles from the scene of earlier robberies, paralysing a slow-moving police force whose heart was not in the chase which had such a dangerous animal for its quarry. At the end a train-load of police sped from Melbourne to capture an outlaw gang that had no resources but those it made, and the police in the fight that ended the gang at Glenrowan even used a cannon. I met the Kelly gang only in their works and through Ted Living, my fellow-bank clerk. At one time Living was accountant at the bank of N.S.W. branch at Jerilderie, a small N.S.W. town north of the Murray River. The Kellys had already robbed three banks and had been posted missing four months until suddenly and early on a Sunday morning they appeared at Jerilderie police station. The Kelly gang rode into the police yard and bailed up the three policemen whom they locked in the cells. Then the Kellys donned the policemen's Sunday clothes. In full sight of the public they spent the day in the precincts of the gaol and Ned Kelly escorted the ser- geant's wife to the Roman Catholic church on Sunday 75 ' PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT morning and stood guard while she dusted the church before the visiting clergyman arrived. All day the gang held the police and not a townsman knew. On Sunday night they cut the few telegraph wires leading from the town, telephones and automobiles were not then invented. Tartleton, the manager, and Living, the accountant and teller of the Bank of New South Wales, had been at near-by stations spending Saturday and Sunday, and they rode to the bank early on Monday. Tartleton went upstairs for a shower bath and Living got out his cash and sorted his notes. The junior clerk had left the front door ajar. Ned Kelly walked in a little before ten and placing the muzzle of a Brown Bess rifle against Living's temple, ordered him to put up his hands, which Ted did with much zeal and rapidity. Ned said, " Gimme yer keys," and Ted replied with the swiftness of a flashlight, " All right, Mr. Kelly." By this time Steve Hart had been upstairs and collected Tartleton at the point of his rifle from under the shower. Tartleton dropped his soap, threw up his arms and said, " Won't you let me dry meself." " No bally fear," said Mr. Hart. " Come along down as y'ar." And come as he was he did in nine and one-fifth seconds by the stop watch. Mr. Ned Kelly then filled two saddle- bags from the safes and tills with notes and gold valued at j 15,000. A big heavy canvas bag took his fancy, and he was about to drag it along when Living smilingly remarked, " Them's coppers, mis- ter/' ' That be damned for a yarn," said Ned, but he drew a jack knife, used for trimming his nails and cutting tobacco, from his pocket, cut the bag and punted pennies with his boots all over the bank floor. " Come and 'av a drink," said their genial host, Mr. Edward Kelly, so they left the bank to its fate, disdaining to take title deeds and overdrafts, loans and advances, and crossed the road to the 76 BANKS AND BANKERS public house. Dan Kelly and Byrne had rounded up every man, woman and child in the village and put them in the pub. The police had been given some tucker and beer and were left in the lock up. They missed all the fun that day. Just as the gang entered the hotel corridor, Dan Kelly had drawn a bead with his gun on the publican who had suggested that Daniel was tipsy. Ned threw his brother's rifle up and the bullet was shot into the ceiling instead of through Boniface. One shearer had a concertina and another a riddle, so the bar room was cleared and everybody danced. The Messrs. Kelly generously bought drinks for all hands, most generously and frequently, and by noon both cellar and bar were empty of anything to drink. Living managed to slip out the back door over to the bank stable, got his horse and rode like Steve Donoghue, Tod Sloan and Frank Dempsey, not gracefully but very fast, towards Deniliquin to break the news. When he reached the telegraph office his favourite prad fell down dead. He bought it as a colt for five pounds. Very bravely Ted pushed on with the good work, took the first train for Melbourne, and turned up at ten o'clock precisely next morning before one Walsh, the inspector of the Bank of New South Wales in Melbourne armed with a huge red and yellow carpet bag. Walsh, without looking up said, " What's that for," and Living brazenly replied, " Want more." " More what ? " said Walsh. " Cash," hinted Ted. " Mr. Kelly took the lot on Sunday." " Oh, did he," said Walsh, and without taking breath, said, " Mr. Living, why are you absent from your branch without leave ? ' Of course the newspapers had answered that for Ted. However, old Walsh said, " Go back at once to Jerilderie by the noon train." Then he relaxed, and Ted and I spent a joyous night with the lads of the village (and some of the lassies) telling 77 PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT about the vile and rude behaviour of the Kelly gang in collaring fifteen thousand of the " best," mixed and all that it was. Ned Kelly gave Living an account of his life written in his own blood. This we tried to sell to the Melbourne newspapers, but the best offer by Sam Winter of the Melbourne " Herald " was only five pounds, so Living kept the MS. which was afterwards lost by a friend. Tartleton was so angry with Walsh's harsh reception that he resigned from the bank. By midnight on Tuesday neither Ted's halo or mine fitted nicely, but we both agreed the Kelly gang ought to have made the event a quarterly affair. When the popular Kelly gang of bushrangers were successfully dodging the Victorian police, the banks took more than ordinary care not to be stuck up. In the tiny branch at Corop where I was, we were fur- nished with ancient pistols and one hundred cartridges each with elaborate instructions how to load and fire them. Mine were all used to shoot swans in Lake Cooper, and I felt safe as a marksman because Ned Kelly was three times as big as a black swan. The north-eastern district of Victoria was the Kelly's stronghold and the Oxley branch of the Bank of Victoria was an isolated outpost in Kelly land. There was a staff of four, one being a new junior from head office, called Gaff George, who was eager to shoot a Kelly or two to get the rewards. An old gentleman named Lane, a director of the bank, senile and nervous, visited the Oxley office to inspect the strategic plans laid down for shooting and catching (preferably shooting) the desperadoes Ned and Dan Kelly, Steve Hart and Steve Byrne. Old Lane rehearsed the staff in the manoeuvres to be followed when the Kellys called, which by the way they didn't. ' You, Mr. Wallis, will stay in the manager's room and on the first alarm will aim through the door at the 78 BANKS AND BANKERS easiest object." ' You, Mr. Sutherland, the teller, will drop on your knees directly Mr. Edward Kelly enters the front door, seize the revolver provided by head office, and kill Kelly without delay ; then you will run out to the stable, mount your grey horse (for which the bank allows you twenty pounds a year fodder allowance) and ride swiftly to Oxley for the police." ' You, Mr. Williams (the ledger-keeper) when you notice Mr. Daniel Kelly pointing his rifle at you, you will instantly fall to the floor of the ledger desk and shoot him without wasting time." " And you, Mr. George, will take your weapon from the drawer and aim at Mr. Byrne or Mr. Hart, whoever may first appear. I trust you are practising marksman- ship assiduously, Mr. George, and you know it is your duty to protect the bank's property." They went through the defensive action several times, but the last time GafF George, who stuttered badly was choking inwardly. Old Lane said, " And now, Mr. George, when the Kellys enter the bank chambers, what will you be doing ? " " Well, Mr. Lane, I really think I would be still sitting on my stool making a mess of things." Poor young George was trans- ferred to Head Office for want of respect to a senior officer, and the Kellys never called. COMMERCIAL BANK When this bank failed in 1893 ^ should have stayed shut. It was in a most awfully putrid state, for out of 13,000,000 of assets only about 2,000,000 was realizable. The bank was able to reopen because under its scheme of reconstruction the Supreme Court allowed it to annex 2,000,000 worth of customers' deposits and turn them into preference shares at 4 per cent. The ordinary capital left from the wreck was only 95,619, and the lucky holders of ordinary shares were so protected by an unjust scheme of 79 PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT reconstruction that they now draw the bulk of the profits. For many years the ordinary shares hung round 4^. because no dividends could be paid till the old debts of the bank were completely cleared off. Now they are 335. and within three years four issues of these los. ordinaries have been made and nothing has been done to increase the dividends of the preference shares, whose money was taken from them by force. I was nominal plaintiff in a case brought against the directors to stop them paying dividends on ordinaries. We lost the case although Sir William Irvine, C.J., and Justice Mann, then leaders of the Bar, presented our arguments mag- nificently well. 80 CHAPTER V MINES AND MINING. STOCK EXCHANGE. OIL QUEST THIS is the proper place to tell the story of how one great gold-mining fortune was begun. Naturally I was a fine baby, and as there was no need to drink typhoid water, I throve mightily. We lived in a small bluestone bank building near the Bendigo Creek, and George Lansell, the Quartz King, started making soap and candles in Forest Street, behind the Oriental, New South Wales and Union Banks. He made a villainous smell and my mamma thought the rank compound would affect my health, so she persuaded papa to get the other bank managers to join the Bank of Victoria in buying Lansell out and tearing his soap works down. He took one thousand pounds cash and put the money into the Adventure and Advance Mine, struck it rich till he gathered two million pounds from his mining and put them for " safety first " in Government and municipal debentures. If he had made only highly scented soaps he might never have gone into quartz mining. Lansell had an overdraft in the Bank of Victoria just before he struck gold in the Garden Gully United Tribute Companies. Head Office told my father to call up the account against his wishes. He gave Lansell a fortnight's grace and gold was struck in two of the shafts during the period. Within twelve months Lansell took 200,000 of gold out of those tributes and paid off and closed his account. Six months later he showed my dad a twelve months' deposit receipt of the Union Bank for 125,000. 81 PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT J. B. Watson was another lucky digger. From the Kent Mines he won twelve tons of gold worth 4.00,000 from between the 300 and 500 levels. Altogether J. B. Watson made and left a fortune of nearly two million pounds made quickly and invested shrewdly in Melbourne city property. The sight of nine little Watson boys and girls and nine little Meudells marching like eighteen Christian soldiers hand in hand to the Rev. Dr. Nish's Scotch kirk in Bendigo must have afforded plenty of fun to the angels above. The first big cheque I ever saw when I was a bank " pig-boy " on the exchanges was for 25,000 signed by J. B. Watson for a mortgage over Billy Heffernan's Shamrock Hotel, Bendigo. The signature looked like a sketch of a hot-water radiator. Barnet Lazarus, a quartz miner who owned the two Lazarus gold mines at New Chum, did well and left 80,000. He killed himself by doing his own retort- ing and inhaling quicksilver fumes from the amalgam. Old Barnet should have allowed somebody else to do the retorting or ought to have worn a glass mask. My father was his executor and when Dan Lazarus came of age seven years later the estate was worth 1 20,000, or ,40,000 each to Sam, Abe and Dan Lazarus. For doing that Sam and Dan each gave my father 50, and Abe sent him a letter of thanks from London without any enclosure. STOCK EXCHANGE, COLLINS STREET BUILDING In 1887, j ust as tne Broken Hill boom was failing and fading away, the committee of the Stock Exchange of Melbourne allowed itself to be swayed by that arch land boomer, B. J. Fink, then a member of committee. B. J. persuaded them to buy from some obscure land syndicate the land opposite the existing Stock Exchange then housed in a tumble-down building owned by Messieurs Miller (Ted, Sep and 82 MINES, STOCK EXCHANGE, OIL Albert) and now belonging to the Commonwealth Bank. The Mercantile Exchange, a first-class news- paper and advertising concern owned by H. Byron Moore, W. H. Waddell, and J. E. Gilchrist occupied the hall in front, and the Stock Exchange sessions were held in a ramshackle, dark, stuffy room at the back. Most of the trading was done in a small vestibule, ten feet by eighteen feet, opening into Collins Street. Seats on the Exchange had sold up to 2,500 and the committee thinking the boom was first cousin to perpetual motion lost their heads, bought the land from the E.S.A.C. bank and erected a fool of a building for an Exchange which cost them 280,000 and kept the Stock Exchange dog-poor for the same time nearly as it took Moses to cross the desert with the children of Israel, about forty years. The A.M.P. Society lost a lot of money on the "mort- gage " as B. J. Fink used to call that form of security. The purchase of the land was a wrong deed and the erection of a costly, dark, dull building was a pure act of treason to the members. Later I helped to save the Stock Exchange Building Company a big sum of money. The Australian Property Company had bought the old E.S. and A. Bank at the corner of Flinders Lane and Elizabeth and pulled it down and started a fifteen-story building before they had arranged for the money to finish the job ! That was one of the maddest things done in the mad boom era by a board of the city's leading men. They tempted me with a salary of 1600 a year to take the managership of their company, and I told them money could only be raised in London to finish the Australian Building and pay off the bank overdraft. I raised 400,00 for the Australian Property Com- pany in London and got no thanks and worse still no brokerage ! A safe deposit had been ordered from Milner and Company of Manchester and a deposit 83 PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT of 1000 paid. Part of the strong room was packed and about to be shipped. Promptly I forfeited the deposit, paid Milner's another 1000, and they can- celled the contract. That action of mine saved the Stock Exchange Safe Deposit from failure and its profits kept the Building Company alive for many years. BROWN COAL Away back in the pre-smash days when banks burst wide open and overdrafts were closed with a click I became interested in brown coal, its uses and its possibilities. My handbook and vade-mecum was the parliamentary report of the Royal Coal Commission of 1891. My brother, William Grant Meudell, was the pioneer of the Morwell brown coalfields now called Yallourn. We were interested in several boring and mining companies and for many years shepherded brown coal areas in Gipps- land, so as not to be out of it when brown coal was making fortunes for everybody interested in it. I became obsessed with ideas of its potential value, and as I was making pots of money in those boomy days I spent some on a trip to Europe to see brown coal mines for myself. In Germany, Austria, Bel- gium and France I saw brown coal being mined and used raw and in briquette form. That was thirty-six years ago, and to-day the Yallourn people are pottering round on the fringe of the science of using brown coal and are still throwing money away in a tinpot shed at Fitzroy, called a research laboratory, in a futile attempt to find out what the Germans have known and been using for fifty years ! What a funny farce the history of brown coal in Victoria has been, played by oafs and officials still in their pupilage. The drill has located thirty thousand million tons of brown coal in Gippsland of varying calorific value, 84 MINES, STOCK EXCHANGE, OIL and the brown coal industry is still in the experimental stage ! Another trip I made out to London to form a company to work the big brown coal deposit on George Chirnside's Werribee Park. I formed one of the strangest syndicates ever collected in London, headed by the powerful A. E.G. Company, or General Electric Company of Berlin to put up or lay down half a million pounds to open a brown coalfield to supply electricity from Laverton to Melbourne. Directly Thomas Tait appointed C. H. Merz as consulting electrician to the railway department my syndicate declined to go ahead and the project failed. Thereby I lost what is known on 'Change as a wad of money. C. H. Merz has drawn from the Victorian Railways Department 221,000 in fees and com- missions for reports and consultations. Some of that might have been mine. ' Tidapa," as they say in Malaya, ' Why worry ? " I missed another fortune. That's all, well " Nitchevo," it doesn't matter. Altona is a much better brown coal body than Yallourn and is only ten miles from Melbourne compared with ninety to Yallourn. Ultimately Yallourn will be abandoned and Altona will be operated to supply drier brown coal and cheaper electricity at half the cost. There are splendid possi- bilities in the brown coal deposits near Adelaide, South Australia, and near Welshpool, Victoria. STOCK EXCHANGE The Broken Hill Silver Boom was just reaching its climacteric when William Knox suggested I should join the Stock Exchange and do his business and that of his most intimate friends of the Broken Hill crowd. These half-dozen big shareholders and directors formed a syndicate called the Barrier Ranges Associa- tion, and I was given most of their orders. Knox gave me 2000 to buy my Exchange seat, and I o 85 PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT had 2000 of my own to open an account with the Bank of Australasia. The first day I took 200 in commissions and at the second session I lost 50 by buying 100 Central Broken Hills instead of selling them. In three months I paid my debt to William Knox and record this action of his as by far the kindest I have experienced in life. He was an exceedingly able man despite certain idiosyncrasies and his intuitive knowledge of psychology enabled him to select as his lieutenants to handle the extensive and growing business arising from the creation of the silver mining industry, such able men of high character and sound sense as Alfred Mellor, Thomas Rollason, John Brandon, Colin Templeton, F. M. Dickenson, James Campbell, John Bristow, C. L. Hewitt, and many others who were attached to the powerful Broken Hill organization from the very outset. On two occasions I went to London with Mr. Knox and acted as his secretary in connection with his missions on behalf of the Broken Hill Proprietary and the Mount Lyell Railway Mining Company. When I joined the Stock Exchange silver mining was proceeding vigorously in Zeehan, Dundas, Whyte River and other fields on the west coast of Tasmania, where 44 companies were being worked. In 1891, 1 68 gold mining companies were operating : Bendigo ... ... ... ... 84 Ballarat ... ... ... ... 21 Smeaton and C res wick ... ... ... 10 Timor (Duke group of mines) ... ... 5 Miscellaneous in a dozen Victorian districts ... 36 Now South Wales and Queensland Gold Mines 1 2 1 68 If it had not been for the gold mining industry Victoria would have disrupted and gone to pot for 86 MINES, STOCK EXCHANGE, OIL twenty-five years, and when I hear imported Governors, modern Members of Parliament and Pommy visitors of more or less distinction talking disparagingly of mining, one cannot help sneering, laughing and gibing at them and all such ignorant people. Amongst the New South Wales gold companies were two in which we had " corners " Bear Hill, Hillgrove and Earl of Hopetoun. A " corner " is a most amusing and highly exciting event in a Stock Exchange. I took part in four of them, the other two being Round Hill Silver Company at Broken Hill and Duke of York Company at Meredith. A " corner " is not played like golf, or Mah Jong, or croquet, or rounders, it is not nearly as simple and stupid as these games, but vastly funnier. The plan is to form a syndicate to buy, take off the market and put in a Safe Deposit box all the scrip possible up to more than half the register. Then the market price is put up and down and sometimes over sideways to encourage the inno- cent to " spec-sell " or " bear " them. When the mug speculators (the world is full of them, for they are born at the rate of ten a minute all the time) are well and truly over-sold and the last scrip certificate has been imprisoned, the price is steadily bid up to an impossible and false value and held there. Notices to deliver scrip at once are sent to every broker who is over sold and he has to go to the syndicate, confess he has sinned, and pay whatever the syndicate chooses to exact. When Tommy Arnfield, once a butcher boy in Bendigo, cornered Duke of York shares, several brokers came to him crying to be let off, and being an ex-slaughterman, and therefore pained to see tears, Tommy compounded for merely nominal prices and the corner was gradually dissolved. There were 200,000 shares in Bear Hills and J. S. Vickery, one of the very shrewdest brokers we ever had, made up his mind the register was too large to PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT " corner." It wasn't and Vickery had to pay up, it was said 10,000, to be released from his bargains. Fitzgerald Moore, another brainy member, an engineer by profession, engineered the Round Hill " corner " and squeezed extremely able and crafty members like G. W. Staples, Tom Luxton, C. Von Arnheim and others. The Earl of Hopetoun corner was worked on a commission by an outside broker, Colonel Alfred Wilson, who afterwards distinguished himself in the Boer War. It was only a small affair. It is surprising some of the present generation of share- holders don't plan a corner just for the fun of the thing. None of them have the courage of the old gold-mining crowd, like Jimmy Taylor, M. B. Jenkins, J. R. Rippin, Arthur Sprague, Dev. Call, Dave Green way, Tommy Luxton, or J. B. Simmons. These old diehards never took the trouble to teach the young eagles to fly, so these young eagles do not live in eyries. They are content to live in hen coops and make $s. commission out of bonds and debentures. There have been no great men on the Stock Exchange since Agammemnon. The shouting that once tore open hell's concave has died down, and the din and dash of conflict for speculative stocks has passed into the limbo of oblivion. G. W. Staples was a truly great operator, full of knowledge about every stock, primed with early news from every mine of importance in Australia, and quicker than light- ning or radio in acting. Staples was a king amongst share dealers. He would quote a buying and selling price for almost any active stock, and he was a god- send and a fountain of blessings to a commission broker like myself who had a host of small clients' orders to transact. Staples took 30,000 Commodore Vanderbilts from me one night at market price i$s. and had sold them all by next evening at up to jCi. He thought nothing of buying any number of Broken 88 MINES, STOCK EXCHANGE, OIL Hills up to lOjOOO, and some of my best bargains were made with him privately because Staples was an honourable gentleman and dealt justly. He left Melbourne for the London Stock Exchange when at his zenith, and has never been replaced either as an operator or as a creator of business. Another splendid operator was Bill Clark, of Clark and Robinson, who was talented in feeling the course of the market. The broker with the best nose for a good or a bad market was Billy Jones who learnt sharebroking at Ballarat, where he failed three times. Like Clark, Jones drifted to London after he made his pile. Then there was Harry Karlbaum who joined the Melbourne Stock Exchange from Adelaide, and being possessed of high courage cut a fortune out of the timid speculators, whose name is legion. The gradual decline in prices on the Stock Exchange between end of 1889 and 1892 cast its shadow before the fiasco of 1893. Here are the figures showing the total shrinkages in each section in 1892 : L Six Banks ... ... ... 4,500,000 Banking & Financial Institutions ... 8,500,000 Melbourne & Silverton Tram Co. ... 8,500,000 Breweries ... ... ... 1,000,000 Metropolitan Gas Co. ... ... 1,000,000 Miscellaneous Companies ... ... 2,500,000 Building Societies ... ... ... 4,000,000 Davies' family group of Companies . . . 3,500,000 Broken Hill Silver Companies ... 3,000,000 36,500,000 As an illustration, Goldsborough, Mort and Com- pany ji paid shares fell to 2J., although the last dividend in 1891 was 10 per cent. Goldsboroughs 89 PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT owed 2,599,382 on debentures A and B issues. A friend of mine bought B debentures 100 paid, in quantities at 40 through me and held them for a fortune. In January, 1892, the shares of coal, brick, and coffee palace companies were unsaleable, and thereby 1,273,802 of paid-up capital was tied up and became fixed and unfruitful. Fortunately gold mining was active in Bendigo, Ballarat, Smeaton and Creswick, Timor and all over Victoria. This table ought to be recorded for sake of permanence. The following figures from a circular I posted broadcast in April, 1896, gives a faint idea of how bare land was used to make scrip as gambling counters and then boomed by bad men like myself. These leases were all " weaners " to the Mount Lyell Company, and most of them have since been absorbed by the big company and have produced payable copper ore : Shares Market Market value Company. Issued. Price. of Mine. North Mount Lyell ... 600 *45 87,000 Lyell Consols ... 100,000 12/6 62,500 Mount Lyell Extended... 600 90 45>ooo Lyell Pioneers ... 3,ooo 8/5/0 24,750 Lyell Blocks . . . 50,000 8 /- 20,000 Lyell Tharsis ... 24,000 io/- 12,000 Tasman Lyells ... 30,000 9/6 14,250 Melbourne Tramway Company shares was a stock very cleverly worked by those in control. By a successive series of " watering " the stock, that is by giving shareholders the right to apply for new shares at a price under the market price, and by increasing dividends to boost prices. Trams were put up to 8 5-f. for the i share, paid up to ics. with IQS. uncalled. It was the most brilliant sequence of attractive coups ever employed on the Stock Exchange 90 MINES, STOCK EXCHANGE, OIL of Melbourne. The business done throughout the land boom for nearly ten years in Melbourne Tram shares was literally enormous. Tens of thousands of pounds were put into the 960,000 shares that were issued from time to time out of 2,000,000 authorized. At 8 a share, Trams were once worth 7,680,000 on the market, a simply fabulous price and rotten to the core. Hundreds of people were ruined when the shares fell away to 8j., and at no time in the career of this spectacular stock were they ever worth more than i. The company was well managed by F. G. Clapp, H. A. Wilcox and W. G. Sprigg. The latter died in 1926 leaving 100,000. In 1893 in the land boom Sprigg made a composition with his creditors for 150,172 at 4^. in the i. BROKEN HILL Towards the^ close of the land boom other stocks besides those connected with land dealing suffered depreciation, mainly because holders wanted cash, therefore gold and silver mining shares were flung on the market. During the month of March, 1890, the depreciation in the values of nine leading silver mining companies was over five million pounds ! It suited me very well because I had just got home from out in London and had found splendid agents interested purely in Australian stocks on the London Stock Exchange. The pioneer of the business of selling Australian shares in London was the late F. W. Prell, a Melbourne merchant, who very cleverly used Australian scrip to pay his London obligations and made profits on his local purchase of shares. The first sharebroker to sell Australian shares of all sorts in London was myself, and when the banks broke I bought bank deposit receipts in a big way chiefly in Scotland. The winter climate in 9 1 PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT London prevented me joining the Stock Exchange there, and several offers of partnership were made to me because of my special and intimate knowledge of Australian companies. Had I stayed in London I could easily have made a fortune quickly for that reason. Three good things did I do on the Stock Exchange. I proposed that the Exchange should endeavour to secure that a proportion, if not the whole, of every Government, Metropolitan Board of Works, and all other public and municipal loans should be floated in Melbourne. My resolution was opposed in the room, the only supporter being a man of wide vision, E. Millard, an old Ballarat broker. My reason for proposing such a radical change was that I had happened to be in London when E. G. Fitzgibbon, chairman of the Melbourne Board of Works, was negotiating in Throgmorton Street. I heard a conversation between two leading bond brokers who openly and laughingly told me they were going to squeeze Fitzgibbon, who was a new chum in London and green at the loan raising game. They made him pay 4 per cent and sell the loan at 98. The money could have been got much more cheaply and with less expense for brokerage, etc., in Melbourne. The next Board loan was raised by the Melbourne Stock Exchange, and the custom of local loans was thereby established, and had grown to large dimensions. Nobody ever gave me any money or thanks or flowers for my idea. Another, the third, of my schemes beneficial to the Stock Exchange was the establish- ment of the system of arbitrage in shares between Australia and London. During one of my numerous visits to London I made arrangements with a leading firm of stock brokers to send them daily orders to sell shares in the principal Australian companies on the London Stock Exchange. The first stock we 92 MINES, STOCK EXCHANGE, OIL dealt with was Broken Hill Proprietary Company, which at that time had no London office. The object was to buy the shares here in a quiet market and cable a selling order to London at a price above Melbourne value. Gradually we enlarged the number of stocks by offering Metropolitan Gas, Melbourne and Silver- ton Trams, and occasionally a few Mount Morgan shares. The business was most profitable and we never made any loss, because we got from 5^. to los. a share above the buying price here. When Mount Lyells came on the list we did a roaring trade before the London register was opened, an action in which I was personally interested, being in London at the time. Mr. F. W. Prell, the remarkably clever Mel- bourne merchant, was in the field before me using Australian shares to settle his exchange transactions in London and New York. That is to say, he sold shares at a profit in London to meet drafts on time for goods. Another scheme of much importance to the Stock Exchange was suggested to my friend, F. T. Derham, then Postmaster-General of Victoria. In 1 889 in Berlin I noticed and made use of the " rohr- post," a system of sending letters and telegrams by pneumatic tube across the city. These tubes, now universal, were not at that time used in any other city, because I made inquiries at post offices in Paris, London and New York and elsewhere. Mr. Derham, who was a splendid business man, and then the active head of Swallow and Ariell, one of the world's greatest biscuit manufacturers, seized my suggestion, and the first pneumatic tube between the Stock Exchange building, then about to be opened, was laid to the G.P.O. in Elizabeth Street. It has been a great convenience, and has saved much time in despatching sharebroker's telegrams. For that discovery I got neither reward nor thanks. Later on F. M. Dickenson, my partner on the Stock Exchange, and I placed 93 PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT before the Post Office Department an option I had secured from the Exchange Telegraph Company of London to establish a " ticker " system of sending quotations and news by tape from the Stock Exchange all over the city. Our offer was turned down flat by the Post Office authorities and I lost a good commission. Hon. W. A. Zeal, M.L.C., an ex-railway contractor, was Postmaster-General, and being ignorant of the use and value of the tape machine for the quick distribution of news, he sneered at the idea and turned us down. Zeal bossed the Legislative Council of Victoria for many years. He was as aggressive as a bull-ant and could bite as keenly. Mr. William Knox, first secretary, then director, of the Broken Hill Proprietary Company, a life- long friend of mine, suggested I should join the Stock Exchange, and offered to pay for a seat. With his powerful influence I was elected a member on the 1 5th January, 1890, and paid 2000 for my seat. B. R. Harris, a son-in-law of Mark Moss, a well- known city moneylender, paid 2500 just afterwards and holds the belt for the record price. There are 129 seats on the Stock Exchange of Melbourne and only enough business for 29 members. Until the Exchange is reorganized the value of the seats will never reach 2500 again. The members will not employ or pay agents, touts, or runners to create orders for them, according to the custom of every Stock Exchange outside Australia, and consequently their business is small and circumscribed and the total done is contemptible. About ten big firms do 90 per cent of the business while 119 members sit round and watch them doing it. It is a purely farcical and nonsensical state of affairs. So I joined the Stock Exchange and went through several years of exciting, tense work, seeing fortunes made and lost, and men made poor by dabbling in the market. I 94 MINES, STOCK EXCHANGE, OIL discovered the first sound principle of speculation to be that success awaits the man who is not always speculating, but who watches his chance in one stock either to buy or to sell, and preferably to sell or to " bear " it. Money can be made on the Stock Exchange only in this way. Take one stock at a time. Never attempt to juggle with three or four, or thirteen or fourteen as some gamblers do so foolishly. Not once did I observe a man make money on the Stock Exchange who was interested in numerous stocks at one time. The fool who thinks he can win every time with any stock he fancies, invariably ends by losing his money and frequently by being bankrupted. The sensible gambler, and there are very few of this species, learns everything he can about one stock, gets the best expert advice about it and then acts or does not. Most people buy and sell shares on straight tips, street tips, advice from brokers holding the shares themselves, or they are influenced by newspaper information, which is generally carefully prepared for the public by those who control the company. Another sound principle to be laid down for investing, is never to buy bank shares or shares in any company liable to calls. My experience has been that most prudent investors avoided bank shares as being too risky. At the end of the land boom came a very iliad of woes, a train of disasters. In that day I cast my idols to the bats and moles. The banking crisis and collapse followed closely on the heels of the obliteration of the building societies with which Melbourne was engorged. These societies were generally managed and directed by men without any financial knowledge of monetary training, and they were the easy prey of sharp land and estate agents, jerry builders and land boomers. A building society can only succeed under the most careful management and by keeping closely to the business 95 PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT of lending money to bona fide house-holders and repelling speculators as borrowers. During the debacle an opportunity occurred of reducing the number of banks, and several of them should have been wiped out ruthlessly. A mistaken sympathy was exercised and several dangerous institutions were permitted to exist. Through avoiding dealing in bank shares and land bank scrip I got through the tumult for 2 IQJ. calls due on Real Estate Bank shares. That was all the money I lost as a share- broker after the smash. Two of my best exploits were working on the Stock Exchange for the issue of local loans, and going to London to arrange to export scrip from the Australian market to the London. There were very few other share brokers in that business then, and there were no Baillieu's, or Robinson Clark's in the game. I did very well and ought to have stuck to the buying of shares in Melbourne and selling them by cable in London the same day. I have made as much as IQJ. a share on Melbourne Trams, Mount Lyells and Silverton Trams, and occasionally did better even than that. Cabling was costly and I had a specially fine code by which I have sent as many as eighty-five words by one message at a cost of IGJ. I found one Queensland broker in London doing a roaring trade in Australian scrip. He made 100,000 in three years and foolishly started " punting " stocks on his own account and lost it all. Am still hoping to see the day when Australian borrowing in London will be restricted and when all loans, old and new, will be raised in the Commonwealth. There is a silly craze nowadays to try and build Rome, meaning Australia, in two or three years. Slow growth is sound growth. Though many hundreds of competencies have been made out of mines, and though gold mining 96 MINES, STOCK EXCHANGE, OIL is the quickest of all methods of making a fortune, most of the big fortunes of Australia have been made by corruption and chicanery. The public, meaning the small investor, gets no consideration when it comes to scuttling a mine to buy in cheaply after a drop, or in the other usual instance, where the reef is " covered up " till the persons in control have secured enough shares cheaply. An old gold miner I met years after the coup of his life told me he had covered up a rich reef successfully when a great mine was on its last legs for working capital. He did not report his find and the mine was closed down. Ten years later he got possession of the mine, uncovered the gold reef and in a short time made 50,000. Another Bendigo miner after firing a shot uncovered a quartz reef that looked like a jeweller's shop. He quickly concealed it with mullock, crawled slowly to the shaft, signalled for the cage, and with both hands on his stomach told the underground boss he had a bad attack of dysentery and must go home. There he put on his Sunday suit of broad-cloth, went to the Beehive, where the Stock Exchange met, and through his broker bought thousands of the shares in the Great Extended Hustlers which very shortly soared from is. 6d. to 7 IOJ. He invested most of his winnings in a big terrace of houses which the ribald and the under-bred brokers named Diarrhoea Terrace. He lost all his money on the Stock Exchange and died in poverty. MOUNT LYELL DEBENTURE ISSUE When the Mount Lyell mine had been fully opened up and proved it had no capital left for develop- ment, William Knox took an office in St. Swithin's Lane, London, right opposite the iron gates leading into New Court and Rothschild's Bank. There I acted as his secretary and as pro tern, secretary of the 97 PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT Mount Lyell Company. Knox's visit was to raise money either by shares or by debentures to build a railway from Strahan to Mount Lyell and to erect treatment works. The Rothschilds called in J. Hays Hammond, an American mining engineer of much tonnage and high status. Knox went confidently to the conference which lasted half an hour. He offered 50,000 Mount Lyell shares at 3 their face value, a proposal quickly turned down when somebody held up a cable from Melbourne quoting the shares the day before at 27 s. So that settled that. Hays Hammond was unfriendly towards the mine's pros- pects although he admitted that Dr. E. D. Peter's report was technically sound. He would not listen to any debenture scheme and advised further prospect- ing to find another rich pipe of ore in the mine like the one which the year before had yielded about 150,000 cash to the Mount Lyell Company. The business went fut and Knox went home ill and dis- appointed. George McCulloch and I saw him off at Victoria railway station, London, en route to Mar- seilles, and George said, " Poor old Knox ; he will never reach Melbourne alive." He did, however, and lived to make Mount Lyell a highly successful enterprise. As with Broken Hill Proprietary, the Mount Lyell mine was fortunate in having directors above suspicion and thoroughly capable secretaries in F. M. Dickenson and Alfred Mellor. The Stock Exchange as the deus ex machina in the drama of commerce has violent ups and downs. One year business will be brisk and extensive and the next year there will be nothing doing, and excepting a few of the big firms, sharebrokers are idle and workless. There are for too many members for the volume of business, not of course all active. If the Committee had bought and extinguished fifty seats when the price dropped to 250, after the bank smash MINES, STOCK EXCHANGE, OIL in 1893, seats would have been worth 5000 to-day instead of 1700. The chairmen from the first year of the reconstructed Stock Exchange have been, F. W. Howard, W. Noall, Walter Slade, Joseph Thomson, R. H. Clarke, J. McWhae, W. J. Roberts and Forster Woods. The best operators when I was a member were G. W. Staples, Dave Thomson, H. G. Evered, F. D. Call, M. B. Jenkins and myself ; who they are to-day I don't know. An operator must be quicker than lightning in saying, " Buy," " Sell " and " Yes." It is far quicker than the bidding at a wool sale. The brokers are a decent lot of men, liberal in the cause of charity, and that of good fellow- ship. Their best feature is the sacredness of their verbal agreements. A sharebroker's word is his bond and that will account for good unto him in the hell where most of them generally go. MINES Captain Charles Sturt, the Australian explorer, found Broken Hill in 1844, and Charles Rasp, the boundary rider on Mount Gipps' station, rediscovered it in 1883. A mining prospector told him it was a hill of mullock, that is of worthless stone. In thirty- five years the "Hill of Mullock," the despised Razor- back, paid in cash and share dividends 13,452,388, and in wages 13,000,000 ! In 1883 a syndicate formed in the house of the manager of Broken Hill, George McCulloch, decided to peg out the whole of the Hill of Mullock, and they finally secured seven leases. They were seven poor men : Charles Rasp, George McCulloch, George Urquhart, George A, W. Lind, Philip Charley, David James and James Poole. The original seven shares became fourteen paying los. a week in calls. In 1885 the Broken Hill Pro- prietary Company, Limited, was registered in 16,000 shares of 20 each, issued as paid up to 19. The 99 PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT directors were : George McCulloch, Bowes Kelly, D. W. Harvey Patterson, Kenneth E. Brodribb, William Jamieson, W. A. Horn, J. W. Bakewell, William R. Wilson and S. F. Hawkins. All except Harvey Patterson were poor men, while he owned Corona Station, covering 3,200,000 acres and carrying 80,000 sheep. Later on W. Knox became secretary, and Duncan McBryde and W. P. MacGregor directors. Through W. Knox I had the good fortune to be associated with most of the big holders of the Broken Hill group of mines. Never had I a better friend. BROKEN HILL THE GAME OF EUCHRE FOR A SHARE In 1884 William Jamieson bought three shares in the original syndicate which owned Broken Hill for jno, jioo and 100. One night he called on George McCulloch to pay him for the last share at 100, and found an English " new chum " named " Fairie " Cox bargaining with McCulloch for one of the original fourteen shares in the syndicate for which McCulloch was asking 200. Cox was chaffing Mac. by offering him 100. After a lot of airy persiflage Cox raised his bid to 110, and McCulloch stood pat for 200. Finally Cox offered to play Mac. euchre whether he gave him 120 or 200. Mac. agreed, and the following evening the historic game of euchre was played and won by " Fairie " Cox, afterwards a prominent racing man in London, so he bought for 120 a share that repre- sented within six years on the market 1,250,000. McCulloch got out of his loss by buying a share from one of his station hands for 90 cash, thus making 30 on his game of euchre. In 1883 the Broken Hill mine had unexpectedly disclosed silver ore of an extraordinary richness, and a group of Scotch back-blocksmen found them- 100 MINES, STOCK EXCHANGE, OIL selves enriched by magic beyond the dreams of avarice. Mile after mile on the line of lode was floated into public companies, and the shares of good mines and wild cats alike formed counters in the terrific boom in values which ensued at the Stock Exchange of Australia. In 1885 I went to the Hill of Mullock, called Broken Hill, and beheld primitive mining which startled me. Nobody knew anything about silver mining, and the directors and managers were learning their business at the expense of the mines. Without exception every mine was being mismanaged. Unsuitable machinery, ignorant miners, wrong methods, above and below ground, and an appalling want of knowledge of the value of the different ores combined to make Broken Hill present a pitiable picture. The Broken Hill South mine, with a market value of one and three-quarters of a million pounds had a shaft 80 feet deep and was being worked by a man, a boy, and a horse, with a whim and bucket. The 100,000 shares in this company were assessed by the public at 17 los. each. Wild cat mines miles north and south of the Broken Hill mines had shallow shafts, neither machinery nor water, and market values of anything from a quarter of a million upwards. Here was a chance to make money quickly, and the young speculator quickly availed himself of it. I sold the 17 los. shares persistently, and when a lull in the boom occurred covered my sales at a profit of several thousand pounds. Neither in the land boom which followed the Broken Hill boom nor in the Zeehan- Dundas, Mount Lyell, Kalgoorlie, or Chillagoe booms which came after was ever such a chance offered for easily making money out of the ignorance of the public then blindly following alleged leading men who knew absolutely nothing about silver mining. There have been booms of magnitude in H 101 PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT Australia, and there will be booms of greater magnitude again times without number. When mules have foals, or crows turn white, it is likely such a combination of enormously rich mineral deposits, stupendously ignorant mining men and a stupid investing public may be crystallized out of such fortuitous atoms. Only one Broken Hill mining squatter, George McCulloch, came solidly out of the boom, having sold a quarter of a million pounds' worth of Broken Hill shares at their highest and bought pictures of great artists who were in delicate health. Death doubles picture values, and the crossing of the Stygian ferry by celebrated painters made McCulloch's collec- tion one of the most valuable in London. The day before Vicat Cole, the famous English landscape painter, died, George McCulloch bought every one of Cole's pictures held by the art dealers and auctioneers and of course they doubled in value soon afterwards. MINING One of the closest shaves I ever had of making a shocking lot of money quickly was when William Macmurtrie, brother-in-law of William Knox, brought to my office John Godkin, the prospector, who dis- covered the Hampden Copper lode at Cloncurry, Queensland. Godkin had pegged out three leases and we went quietly to work and formed three small syndicates among three groups of the leading men of Melbourne. David Syme of the " Age " was the chief of one syndicate, Malcolm MacEacharn of the second, and Alfred Tolhurst, a sharebroker, brought his friends into the third. The three syndicates were formed and the money paid within three days. We had overlooked William Knox and the mighty Broken Hill crowd in picking our shareholders, so mark, lo ! and behold, next week a telegram was published from H. H. Schlapp in Cloncurry advising 102 MINES, STOCK EXCHANGE, OIL Knox that " much work had to be done before the extent of the lode could be known," which was obvious as everybody knew. Yet one after another of the investors " cray-fished " out of the ventures, and we had to return their money ! The Hampden mine proved to be a great copper producer, and all the best ore came out of our three blocks ! What do you know about that ? Recollect two occasions when I made a lot of money by going down mines to see for myself. Once the late A. E. Wallis of the Bank of Victoria and I went to inspect the Cordillera Mine, west of Goulbourn, New South Wales. We hired a light buggy and pair of horses and drove them hard and fast to the mine, shares in which were 7 IQJ. We arrived in time to go through the mine with the night shift and con- cluded the amount of work done and the ore in sight did not justify the price. We went back to the rough bush pub, took two beds just vacated by two miners on night shift, tied our pyjama legs and arms with string to keep out the pulex, and slept like tired policemen. Next morning we drove back to the Melbourne train and passed two buggies with the directors of the Cordillera Company Josh Cushing, Phipps Turnbull and Fitzgerald Moore who had with them G. F. H. Schuler, then chief of staff on ' The Age." Schuler had lived in Bendigo and knew his mining. The second buggy contained a distended supply of food and Heidsieck's dry mono- pole in case the horses ran out of grass and water. Directly I got back to the Stock Exchange I oversold and specked 2000 Cordillera's and bought them back under 5, not so bad for a three days' trip. Another funny episode occurred at Wood's Point, a gold field then in its second childhood. Got there one Christmas Eve, having done fifty miles in a buggy without a hood in a three-inch fall of rain all the day. PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT At dinner the room was crammed with miners in from the jungle to knock down their cheques. I had earned a bottle of " boy " and picked on Krug, a sweet wine dear to the hearts of the demi-monde of Paris, whence I had just come. The bloke alongside poured the precious fluid over his corned beef and cabbage, and turning to his mate said, " Gor blimey, Bill, the blooming termater sauce is gawn bad." The room rocked with laughter. Jim and I became friends, and I used his information to knock the stuffing out of several overvalued stocks on 'Change. At midnight I was roused from sleep to go and meet a deputation in the " dead-house " up the yard. My reception had been carefully staged. There were four stark naked men standing silent, smiling, silly, but not berserk, on their heads in the four corners, and three more nude musicians playing the fiddle, concertina and Jews' harp. My " shout " was three dozen bottles of beer at is. 6d, a piece. Then came along another huge chimera, known to the public as the Chillagoe Copper Mines and Railway Company, a venture blessed with the patron- age of some very big personages in the mining world. And lo ! Ben Adhem's name led all the rest. The public played " follow my leader " in a mad, hare- brained rush, and shares jumped from half a crown to two pounds. At top price they were sold in thousands chiefly to London by the big holders. It was sending owls to Athens with a vengeance. Oft- times the jingling guinea helps the hurt that honour feels. Is it not lawful for them to do what they will with their own ? as the Apostle of old asked. Once again I stood upon Achilles' tomb and heard Troy doubted, just as time will doubt of Rome and by that time be tired of following leading men into mining companies. I kept clear of the Chillagoe company and warned my clients so that when the 104 MINES, STOCK EXCHANGE, OIL crash came we were not bitten by the snapping of the trap. As cold water is to a thirsty soul, so is good news from a far country. Sensational reports were circulated in favour of the mine, and after London had provided the debentures and bought most of the shares the Chillagoe Mines were found to be a collec- tion of meagre surface shows. Then came a series of damaging reports, some public, some private. There was, in fact, a terrible talk about lentils. Shares toppled from 40^. to nothing, and several big fortunes were made while the losses were well spread over a large body of shareholders. The Chillagoe Com- pany's fate is merely another illustration of the maxim that investors should never buy shares in a mine where thousands of miles separate the directors and the mine manager. For a mine to be successful the directors and the manager must be in close touch. Occasionally and very rarely, as in the case of the Mount Lyell Company, the manager (Robert Sticht) was an exceptionally able man. The directors are merely administrators. Then it may be safe enough to hold shares in a mine at a distance. My records are full of details of mines which failed because the mining manager was too far away to be controlled by anybody. MOUNT LYELL My first visit to Mount Lyell Mine, near Mac- quarie Harbour, Tasmania, was in 1893, when I went across in a steamer of 125 tons in thirty-three hours to Strahan. A stormy crossing in the Irish Channel mailboat from Holyhead was my worst sea trip up to then. The beastliness of that trip to Strahan is indescribable. Of twelve small cockle shells, mere bum boats driven by a kettle full of steam, in which I made many trips to the west coast of Tasmania, six were wrecked, and that was their fore- 105 PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT ordained destiny. On a pure bred Clydesdale palfrey, with feathered legs and a capacious back, it took me ten hours to cover the thirty-one miles from Strahan to Mount Lyell. They were mere bridle paths, not roads, over which we stumbled, down " Kelly's Stone Stairs," and over a rocky torrent called " Roaring Mag." We slipped down 400 feet in one mile and clambered up 600 feet in the next. It was a ride of horror, tempered by a perpetual feast of gorgeous scenery. Bill Dixon and Jim Crotty, who found Mount Lyell in 1883, deserved every penny of their ultimate reward, for it was a hell-uv-a place to get to. F. O. Henry, the storekeeper at Strahan, who " grub staked " Bill Dixon, once quietly slipped a small blacksmith's anvil into one of the tucker bags, and Bill carried it the whole thirty-one miles, grunting all the way without knowing wherefore he should grunt. Frank Gee Duff, whom I met in New York living obscurely in 1919, introduced Mount Lyell to Bowes Kelly, William Knox and William Orr, whose Broken Hill winnings had been sadly depleted. These three paid .25,000 for 50,000 shares in a company of 150,000 after H. H. Schlapp, metallurgist of the Broken Hill Proprietary Company, had examined Mount Lyell and reported favourably. Next to Robert Sticht, the greatest metallurgist who ever came to Australia, stands H. H. Schlapp as a thoroughly experienced scientist and a gentleman. Sticht was easily primus inter pares, and to his unrivalled skill Mount Lyell's success is due. Schlapp recommended that Dr. E. D. Peters, Junior, an American expert on pyritic smelting, should be imported to report on the best way to work Mount Lyell. He came for the small fee of 1250, and his report is a mining classic. I had the luck to travel with Dr. Peters in Tasmania. He was short in stature, round in figure, grizzled in mien and a typical Bostonian in speech 1 06 MINES, STOCK EXCHANGE, OIL and conduct. Peters told O. G. Schlapp, nephew of H. H. Schlapp, and then mine manager of Mount Lyell, to put down a winze on the footwall. This unearthed fabulously rich ore worth from 1000 to 2500 ozs. of silver to the ton. One chunk of ore assayed by Ward, the Tasmanian Government analyst, gave 8765 ozs. of silver, 45 ozs. of gold and 19 per cent of copper per ton. The average value of the ore was 3 ozs. silver, 3 ozs. gold and 5 per cent copper per ton worth 3 a ton. That pipe or rich ore saved the company as it was most difficult to raise capital because of the ignorance of mining investors concern- ing such a low-grade pyritic deposit. Dr. Peters estimated there were 4,600,000 tons of ore in the Lyell mass worth 15,292,920. A similar mine, the Rammailsberg in Germany has been working for 800 years. OIL QUEST IN AUSTRALIA When I think about the speeches I heard Lord Roberts make urging the British public to gird up their loins and prepare to repel a German onslaught, it reminds me of the repeated warnings given to Australia by leading sailors and soldiers like Lord Jellicoe, Admiral Henderson, Generals Birdwood and Fitzpatrick that this country should strive to secure an oil supply of its own so as to be independent of foreign sources of petroleum products. There is bound to be war in the Pacific Ocean within the next twenty years, and when it comes Australia will be weak and helpless, an easy prey to a raider or an invader unless she has a domestic supply of petrol for her aircraft and submarines. There is not a reserve of petrol in the Commonwealth which would last more than two months. There is no reserve of fuel oil at all for the use of the Australian Navy. We have no domestic supplies of lubricants, benzol, 107 PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT or engine kerosene. Our automobile industry is like a subverted pyramid, plenty of cars, trucks and tractors and no petrol to run them with. It is farcical and would be laughable if it were not so damnably dangerous. When war in the Pacific is declared, it matters not by whom, every automobile in Australia will stop dead, because the Government would have to put an embargo on their use, and commandeer every gallon of petroleum products in the Common- wealth. The Australian Navy, its submarines and its warships could not leave their harbours, and the Australian air force would be as impotent as a cut cat. This all sounds strong, yet it is true. Australia is placidly standing on thin ice over a deep abyss because it lacks the first instrument of defence petroleum. My travels round the Pacific, from Japan to Patagonia and from Vancouver to Invercargill, enable me to laugh at the journalists and publicists, who have never been outside Australia, and who daily write and utter cautions and warnings against the Japanese and their urgent desire to take this big continent from us. To me it seems childish blatherskite. The Japanese would need one thousand vessels to transport men and enough food to effectively occupy this vast territory. They cannot ever try it, because they have not got the money, and the second solid reason why the Japanese will not for a long time to come attack Australia is that it would be a signal for the white races of the world to band together to sweep back the rising tide of colour. No white nation could afford to stand back and watch the Japanese trying to effect a landing in Australia. For their own sakes they would come to the rescue without being invited. If the Japanese occupied Australia, not a single tribe of white people would be safe from destruction. The whites of the world would come at a run to help us so as to save their own skins. The 108 MINES, STOCK EXCHANGE, OIL Japanese know better than to do as Germany did, and by defying the world call loudly for defeat. Day after day we Australians are told we must not rely on Great Britain for help if we are attacked. Lord Burnham said it and so did Lord Salisbury. The feeble Press delegation was almost as weak as the gimcrack British Parliamentary party, and both of them continually told Australia she would have to help herself in any warlike trouble, because she could not depend on the British Navy for protection. This silly bleating advice became a parrot cry with both these visiting missions, and my reply to the craven threat that Australia cannot defend herself without the aid of Britain is, " In that event what is the use of belonging to the British Empire, if Australia cannot call upon every soldier and sailor in that Empire to come and help her in time of trouble." No, there is no chance that the Japanese will ever risk a descent on Australia, for the defeat of the Spanish Armada would be a marionette show alongside the annihilation of the Japanese fleet. My dread is that some day this century the United States will want Australia as a spillway for its surplus population and as a land of exile for its negro citizens. Only 25 per cent of the people of the United States are of British descent, and the other 75 per cent are people from seventy-five different races who hate the British intensely and therefore hate the Australians. The only nation we have to fear is the American, which leads right back to this grave problem of where we are to get an independent and domestic oil supply. Without plenty of petroleum products Australia is vulnerable. With enough oil we could face the world at arms and keep our country to ourselves against all comers, whether Great Britain came in or stood out. There is no difficulty about getting oil inside Australia. It is not a question of the cost of 109 PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT getting it when our existence as a people is concerned. If petrol cost us, to make here from coal and oil shale, los. a gallon, and if fuel oil from the same substance cost us 25 a ton, we ought to have it, and we must. It is simply a question of money to build the retorts to extract crude oil from coal and distil it from oil shale and lignite, of both of which materials we have the richest, if not the largest, deposits on earth. Twenty million pounds would be a molecular sum to spend to make sure of our national safety and perpetual independence. AUSTRALIA MUST HAVE HER OWN OIL SUPPLY BEFORE ANYTHING ELSE WHATSO- EVER AT ANY COST AND QUICKLY. OIL SHALE TASMANIA If I missed a fortune over brown coal I feel sure I ought to make its substitute out of oil shale. For years I have been intrigued by the rich possibilities of treating successfully the tasmanite or kerosene shale deposits of Northern Tasmania. About 25 million tons have been proved by boring, running from 35 to 45 gallons of petroleum to the ton, averag- ing in the laboratory about 40 gallons to the ton. The sole drawback to the oil shale deposits of Tas- mania is a thin band of mudstone lying between the upper and lower seams of oil shale. This mud- stone carries only about 5 per cent of oil, yet it has to be mined and treated along with the shale, thereby increasing the cost of treatment, and pulling down the average oil contents of the shale. So far no satisfactory retort has been operated, and the con- tinuous failure of retorts working at Latrobe has cast a slight upon the prospects of the oil shale industry. It is a simple question of finding the right retort, and that must come in course of time. Then Tasmania will employ an army of miners delving unceasingly to supply the vast quantities of no MINES, STOCK EXCHANGE, OIL shale that will be wanted for the batteries of retorts working day and night, year in year out, without stopping. BROWN COALS ALTONA, MORWELL I have wasted a lot of time and money hanging on to the development of the brown coal industry of Victoria, which sooner or later must become one of the most important industries in the State. It was during one of my earliest tours through the continent of Europe forty years ago I saw brown coal being used as briquettes and as raw fuel in special locomotives drawing freight trains. I got the usual bee in my Scotch bonnet about brown coal and began a study of it and its uses directly I came home. Since then I have made three voyages to Europe to raise capital for the Altona and Laverton brown coal fields, an infinitely superior deposit to Morwell, alias Yallourn. Altona is ten miles from Melbourne, Morwell ninety, and in that factor alone lies the immeasurable superiority of Altona over Yallourn. My mistake was in not joining forces with W. L. Baillieu, who forced Morwell into the W. A. Watt government when A. A. Billson was Minister of Railways. Parlia- ment was not properly informed about the project, yet once it was started, it seemed impossible to stop it, and finally the working out of this important public work was handed over to the wrong set of men, who were provided with the wrong lot of executive officers. Primarily then as now, from first to last, Morwell (Yallourn) should have been treated as a brown coal mine demanding special scientific knowledge and skill to work. Instead it was looked upon as an electrical undertaking, and the character, quality and faults of the brown coal deposit were never properly examined. It is not Sir John Monash's fault, and he is not to blame for the disagreeable mess the in PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT chief executive officers and their inefficient administra- tive commissioners have made of Yallourn. The syndicate I formed in London to develop Altona and provide a proper electrical supply for the State investigated Morwell years before the Electricity Commission was established, and the firm of engineers who reported upon it has neither peer nor equal in London Messrs. Kincaid, Waller, Manville and Dawson. Sir Philip Dawson, M.P., is easily the leading electrical engineer in the British Empire and his verdict was in favour of Altona and against opening up Morwell, alias Yallourn. OIL QUEST On a trip to California, during my wild-goose chase after petroleum, lasting over nineteen years of fruitless search for oil in Australia, I took a secret process for distilling oil so as to yield a higher quantity of petrol, or as the Americans call it gasoline. I placed the process before eight leading oil companies in California and had the good fortune to meet their chief chemists at the various demonstrations of the process which failed to appeal to them, because it was imperfect. And when on another occasion I interviewed a dozen or more leaders of the petroleum industry to ask them to take an interest in the search for oil in Australia and provide men and money, I made numerous acquaintances who showed me much kindness and gave me plenty of information and advice, but no capital. Amongst them were the following heads, all notable men, all wealthy and influential : Captain John Barneson, of General Petroleum Corporation. W. E. White & A. P. Bell, of Associated Oil Co. B. D. Adamson, of Balfour, Guthrie & Co. F. D. Boyce, chemist, for E. L. Doheny. 112 MINES, STOCK EXCHANGE, OIL Dr. V. Bredlik, chemical engineer, Foundation Oven Co., New York. E. L. Cope, hydraulic engineer, San Francisco. E. Dobell, Union Tool Co., Los Angeles. E. J. Dyer, Union Oil Co., Los Angeles. E. B. Kimball, General Petroleum Co., San Francisco. M. V. Quigg, Independent Oil Producers' Agency, Los Angeles. H. M. Storey \ J. Lander I Standard Oil Co., of California. Dick McGraw j J. Gallagher, Shell Co., of California. A. Sclater ) and Union Oil Co. E. W. Clark ) Far and away the most interesting oil magnate I met was E. L. Doheny of Los Angeles, the lord and master of the oil industry of Mexico. He was as hard to approach as a lyre bird or a wild deer. It took me six days to get into his private office and reminded me of Mark Twain's effort to get past the janitors to see an old friend of his in a New York sky scraper. After being rebuffed by half a dozen lackeys, Mark Twain, when asked what his business was with the great man, said, " Tell him I've come to ask his hand in the bonds of holy matrimony." Mark was passed into the presence. By patience and tenacity, on the fifth day of waiting I reached Mr. Doheny who was snowed under by dividend cheques he was signing. He was a small, thin, quiet, gentle- manly little man, kindly and courteous. He heard my proposal patiently that he should embark on the quest for petroleum in Australia. My extempore speech had been prepared during the five days of waiting and utterly failed to convince this extremely sagacious suzerain of illimitable oil fields. " Mr. Meudell," he said, " in Mexico alone I have a hundred "3 PLEASANT CAREER OF A SPENDTHRIFT years work for my Pan-Mexican and other corporations are capitalized at a round forty million pounds." E. L. Doheny it was who saved the British Navy from utter destruction by supplying it with oil from his Mexican wells direct to British fuel bases. If Doheny had been unfriendly to Great Britain it is certain Admiral Tirpitz would have received Jellico, Beatty et