ACTIONS ■yv) e-T OF THE Board of Managers of The Missionary Society The General Missionary Committee AND The General Conference IN REGARD TO SELF-SUPPORTING MISSIONS IN CHILI Published by order of the Board September, 1897 Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2018 with funding from Columbia University Libraries https://archive.org/details/actionsofboardofOOunse Communication of the Board of Managers to the General Missionary Committee, 1897. THE MISSION IN CHILL—ORIGIN OF THE WORK. In tlie year 1877 William Taylor, who had been prosecuting an evangelistic work in India from November, 1871, to June, 1875, and who had returned to England and the United States to secure and send out preachers to take cliarge of the young churches which had been organized, and who had remained in this country, traveling extensively, preaching and selling his books, and selecting preachers for the India work, was attracted to the religious condition of South America. On October 16 he set sail from New York for the west coast, by way of Panama, landing at Callao, Peru. It was his purpose to ascertain the condition of the people, the need of religious teachers, the number of the English-speaking race, and the possibilities of organizing work on the same principle which he had pursued in South India. It was not, however, his purpose to engage in evangelistic labors, but to secure the co¬ operation of English and American residents in such work, to be developed by preachers whom he should send out. He soon found that the cooperation of foreign residents could in most cases be more readily secured in founding schools, or school and church work combined, than churches alone. At Coquimbo, Chili, he formed a Committee of the principal English residents, who engaged to make ready a place for worship and to raise funds for the support of a pastor. At Valparaiso, Chili, he formed a similar Committee among merchants, who agreed to raise funds among shippers and captains to support a chaplain to seamen in the Bay. At various other points in Chili and Peru he made arrangements for schools and for school and church work •combined. In April, 1878, after an absence of six and one half months, he returned to the United States, and on July 1 of that year sent ■out a party of nine preachers and teachers. Protestant Missions had been begun thirty years before by the American and Foreign Christian Union, which was formerly 3 4 the Foreign Evangelical Society. In 1873 that work had passed under the care of the American Presbyterian Board of Foreign Missions, and has been supported by that Board ever since. At only one of the places occupied by that Board did Mr. Taylor try to start work, and that was among seamen. He did not purpose to interfere Avith Avork already begun, but to try to reach those Avho were Avholly neglected. In 1879 all the Mission stations Avere bright Avith promise, and Chili Avas prosperous, but war broke out between that country and Peru, and lasted for five years. The work on the four Northern stations Avas entirely broken up, but in the meanwhile Avork had been begun at Santi¬ ago, the capital. The first property bought for the Mission Avas in January, 1883. In 1884 William Taylor was elected Lay Delegate by the South India Conference to the General Conference of 1884, and to fulfill that function left South America, and Avas at the General Conference elected Missionary Bishop for Africa, arid withdrew attention from South America. This led to the establishment of the Transit and Building Fund Society. The names given in the article of incorporation are that the names of the Trustees, Directors, or Managers for the first year of its existence are: William Taylor, Asbury Lowrey, An¬ derson FoAvler, Richard Grant, and Chauncey Shaffer. In the first seven years the amount contributed to South America was $70,720.62. During the same period Anderson FoAvler alone gave for Santiago College $48,600, making a total spent by the Tran¬ sit and Building Fund Society in the period of $119,320.62. In 1885 I. H. La Fetra, one of the original missionaries, was made general agent for Bishop Taylor’s work on the west coast of South America. Amid various vicissitudes the Avork, both educational and evangelical, has progressed, and has been Ausited by Bishop William L. Harris, in 1881, Avho there ordained eight men who had previously been elected to orders by A'arious Con¬ ferences. He found Chili at war with Peru, and suffering under the effects of the conflict. In 1887 Dr. and Mrs. Asbury LoAvrey visited the field. At that time, OAving to the existence of cholera, the ports were closed to vessels coming from the north. Dr. and Mrs. Lowrey, and a party of seven missionaries Avho accompanied them, journeyed to Chili by the way of England and the Straits of Magellan. In 1889 Bishop Walden made an episcopal tour of South America, and visited Santiago and Concepcion. The General Conference of 1884 had altered the Discipline so as to authorize the organization, outside the bounds of Conferences, of Missions, and for their attachment to one of the home Conferences as an outlying presiding elder’s district. After the visit of Bishop Walden this provision was applied, and Cincinnati Conference, at its session in September, 1890, admitted the churches of this Mis¬ sion, and organized the Chili District of the ('onference. Tn 1893 Bishop Newman visited the Mission officially, accom¬ panied by Mrs. Newman and Mrs. Moses, of Washington. The History of the Chili Mission of the Methodist Episcopal CJmrch, published in Santiago, represents him as having made a ‘‘ some¬ what thorough inspection of the work,” and as having conversed extensively vvith the missionaries. The attempt to form the en¬ tire work in South America into one Annual Conference by Bishop Newman, at the Annual Meeting of the Methodist Episcopal Mis¬ sion in the Argentine Republic, at Buenos Ayres, on July 1, 1893, resulted in the organization of the South America Conference. There were, however, present only the members of the Argentine Mission. The foregoing sketch of the rise and progress of the Missions in Chili is necessary to make clear to those not familiar with it the action hereinafter set forth of the successive General Com¬ mittees, and of the Board of Managers and the present state of the case. Chronological Extracts from Official Records. The Board of Managers of the Missionary Society, at its regu¬ lar meeting on September 21, 1897, passed the following resolu¬ tion ; On motion of J. M. Buckley, a Special Committee of three persons was ordered to draw up a statement as to the relation of the Mission in Chili to the property in Chili, and setting forth the relation of the Methodist Episcopal Church to evangelistic work in Chili; to have the report ready for consideration at our next meeting ; and that the report, when completed, be printed and sent to each mem¬ ber of the Board. I.—Report of Committee. The Committee appointed under the preceding resolution con¬ sisted of J. M. Buckley, James F. Rusling, and Anderson Fowler, and in the discharge of the duty imposed on them re¬ spectfully present the following report : 6 II.— Action of General Conference of 1888. The General Conference, in 1888, passed the following resolu¬ tions: (Journal, page 440, report 16.) The Committee on Missions, to whom was referred memorials concerning Bishoy) Taylor’s Self-supporting Mission work, respectfull}' reports as follows : Whereas, The plan of Self-supporting Mission work, which has been in¬ augurated in South America and Africa by Bishop Taylor, has elicited much enthusiasm in the Church, and deserves an opportunity for full development under the fostering care of the whole Church ; and, Whereas, It is not desirable to bring this experiment into competition with the established methods of missionary administration which have long existed in the Church, and inasmuch as there is no reason for antagonism between the two methods, if both are conducted under the same authorities; and, Wh reas, The Missionary Board and the General Missionary Committee are the only agencies through which the General Conference administers its Missions ; and. Whereas, The agencies are sufficiently broad and flexible in their scope and purpose to embrace all departments and methods of missionary work; and, Whereas, The principle of self-supporting has long been recognized and culti¬ vated in the regular Missions of the Church; therefore. Resolved, 1. That we direct that all property acquired in the prosecution of the Self-supporting Mission plan be held by and for the Methodist Episcopal Church. 2. That the Missionary Board appoint a Standing Committee on Self-support¬ ing Missions, who shall have the oversight of the Missions on the self-supporting plan. 3. That missionaries employed and churches organized on the self-supporting plan shall be entitled to the same rights and be amenable to the Discipline of the Church the same as missionaries and churches in other fields. 4. That Missionary Bishops in charge of Self-supporting Missions be instructed to report annually to the Missionary Board the condition of all Self-supporting* Missions, including the number of missionaries, the number of stations, and the number of communicants in each station, and a financial exhibit of all the re¬ ceipts and expenditures. 5. That the Argentine Republic, Uruguay, the southern province of Brazil, Paraguay, and Chili may during the next four years, by a vote of two thirds of the members present and voting, and with the .approval of the Bishop having the jurisdiction, be organized into an Annual Conference, to be called the South America Conference. 6. That the General Missionary Committee be requested to organize the Portu¬ guese stations in Northern Brazil into a Mission. III.— Action of General Conference of 1892. The General Conference of 1892 passed an enabling act to prepare tlie way for uniting the Mission in Chili with all the work of the Methodist Episcopal Church in South America in one Conference. IV.—Formation of South America Conference. Against the judgment, wishes, and expectations of the Transit and Building Fund Society the whole of South America, includ¬ ing Chili, was formed into a Conference, known as the South America Conference, July 1, 1893, by Bishop J. P. Newman. V. —Action of Board, September 19, 1893. At the meeting of the Board of Managers, September 19, 1893, the Committee on South America and Mexico reported from their minutes of September 8, stating that Bishop Newman had made a report to the Committee concerning the work in Chili, and after giving certain facts, the Committee recommended the appoint¬ ment of a Committee to confer with Anderson Fowler, Richard Grant, and Asbury Lowrey, of the Transit and Building Fund Committee, with reference to a transfer of the evangelistic work of that Committee to the Board of Managers, and ordered that the said Committee should report to the October meeting. The Committee, as finally constituted, consisted of Sandford Hunt, E. L. Dobbins, and John S. McLean. At the meeting of October 17 this Committee reported as fol¬ lows : Your Committee, appointed to confer with the representatives of the Transit and Building Fund Society of Self-supporting Missions in South America, repre¬ sented by Anderson Fowler, Richard G-rant, and Asbury Lowrey, would respect¬ fully report that we met the representatives named, and spent an afternoon iu free consultation in regard to the matters submitted for consideration. The representa tives of the Transit and Building Fund Societj^ state that they have no evangelistic work which can be turned over to the Missionary Society separate from their schools, and that the school property, which constitutes the larger proportion of the property in Chili, was purchased and is still held by the original purchasers for the Transit and Building Fund Society of Self-supporting Missions. Without entering into details at length, it was very evident to your Committee that the only way that the Missionary Society can obtain possession of said property in South America is by actual purchase from those parties who hold the same. The question of purchase of property for the Missionary Society is one which the General Committee must determine and provide for by appropriation. We therefore recommend the further consideration of the subject to the General Committee. On motion, the report was adopted. VI. — Action of General Committee of 1893. The “ Order of the Day,” namely, consideration of the work in Chili, was taken up. 8 The following jjreamble and resolutions, presented by Bishop Fowler, were, on motion, adopted : It is known to this Committee that there has existed for some years an incor¬ poration known as the Transit and Building Fund Society of Self-supporting Missions. The nature and work of this Society is defined in the following statement taken from its charter, namely, The particular business and objects of the said Society are to provide the ways and means, and to manage, appropriate, and supply the same as follows, namely: 1. To provide a suitable outfit for missionary preachers and teachers. 2. To pay their passage to foreign countries. 3. To pay the traveling expenses of pioneer evangelists in those countries. 4. To build or purchase dwelling-houses, schoolhouses, and houses of worship for the use of the missionaries. 5. Also to translate the sacred Scriptures and suitable religious and literary publications into foreign languages, and to print and publish the same. 6. The funds of this Society shall not be used to paj' salaries of agents at home nor of preachers or teachers in foreign countries. Under these provisions of the charter educational and evangelistic work has been carried forward in Chili, and a property amounting to about $200,000 in gold has been accumulated. At present forty-three ministers and teachers from the United States are at work in this field. This Society, represented by Messrs. Anderson Fowler and Richard Grant, now presents the following proposition, namely, “ We offer to transfer all the Mis¬ sion work and Mission property belonging to the above-named Society in Chili to the Missionary Society of the Methodist Episcopal Church, free from debt, upon these conditions, that Chili be set apart exclusively for Self-supporting Mission work, and that the Mission work in Chili be carried on and conducted on the plan of self-support, as heretofore.” Now, therefore, the General Missionary Committee, so far as it has authority, and subject to the authority of the General Conference, accepts for itself the above proposition, and recommends the Missionary Board to accept in like man¬ ner the proposition, and to enter upon and prosecute the work on the conditions hereinbefore set forth. We also appropriate $25,000 contingent upon its being given specially for this work, said money to be administered by the Board. On motion of Bishop Foss, it was resolved that Bishops Fowler and Newman, J. M. Buckley, S. F. Upham, and E. L. Dobbins be appointed a Committee to express to Mr. Anderson Fowler and Mr. Richard Grant our appreciation of the great work estab¬ lished and successfully carried on in Chili, and our hearty thanks for the proposition made by them and now adopted by the Com¬ mittee. VII. —Action of the Board of Managers, December 19, 1893. At the meeting of December 19, 1893, the Joint Committee on Self-supporting Missions and Finance, appointed at the last meet- 9 ing as a Special Committee on the Transference of the Property of the Bishop Taylor Transit and Building Fund Society to this Missionary Society, presented its report, as follows : The action of the late General Committee on tiie offer of Messrs. Anderson Fowler and Richard Grant, representing the Transit and Building Fund Society of Self-supporting Missions, with reference to the work in Chili, was laid before this Committee. The snbjeet was serionsl}’’ considered and debated, and your Committee beg leave to report as follows: Wherecis, The following paper was addressed to the Board of Bishops by Anderson Fowler and Richard Grant, representing the Transit and Building- Fund Society of Self-supporting Missions, namely: 7b the Board of Bishops of the Methodist Episcopal Church : We, the undersigned Committee of the Transit and Building Fund Society (incorporated under the laws of the Slate of New York), offer to you, as repre¬ senting the Methodist Episcopal Church, to transfer all the Mission work and Mission property belonging to the above Society in Chili, upon the condition that Chili be set apart exclusively for Self-supporting Mission work, and that the Mission work in Chili be carried on and conducted on the plan of self-support, as heretofore, and upon which the Transit and Building Fund Society is incor¬ porated. (Signed) Anderson Fowler, Richard Grant. P. S .—It is estimated b}^ Rev. Ira H. LaFetra, superintendent of the work in Chili, that at least $20,000 in gold will be required annually to make the work a great success. And Whereas, The following paper was presented by Bishop Fowler to the General Missionar}' Committee and adopted by said Committee: It is known to this Committee that there has existed for some years an incor¬ poration known as tlie Transit and Building Fund Society of Self-supporting Missions. The nature and work of this Society is defined in the following statement taken from its charter, namely: The particular business and objects of the said Society are to provide the ways and means, and to manage, appropriate, and apply the same as follows, namely: (1) To provide a suitable outfit for missionary preachers and teachers. (2) To pay their passage to foreign countries. (3) To pay the traveling expenses of pioneer evangelists in those countries. (4) To build or purchase dwelling- houses, schoolhouses, and houses of worship for tlie use of the missionaries. (5) Also to translate the sacred Scriptures and suitable religious and literar}'- publications into foreign languages, and to print and publish the same. (6) The funds of this society shall not be used to pay salaries of agents at home, nor of preachers or teachers in foreign countries. Under these provisions of the charter educational and evangelistic work has been carried forward in Chili, and a property amounting to about $200,000 in gold has been accumulated. At present forty-eight ministers and teachers from the United States are at work in this field. 10 This Society, represented by Messrs. Anderson Fowler and Richard Grant, now present llie following proposition, namely, ‘‘ We offer to transfer all the Mission work and Mission property belonging to tlie above-named Society in Chili to the Missionary Society of the Methodist Episcopal Church, free from debt, upon these conditions, that Chili be set apart for Self-supporting Mission work, and that the Mission work in Chili be carried on and conducted on the plan of self-support, as heretofore.” Now, therefore, the General Missionary Committee, so far as it has authority, and subject to the authority of the General Conference, accepts for itself the above proposition, and recommends the Missionaiy Board to accept in like manner the proposition, and to enter upon and prosecute this work on the conditions hereinbefore set forth. We also appropriate $25,000 contingent upon its being given specifically for this work, said money to be administered bj' the Board. In view of these facts, and of the action of the General Missionary Committee, your Committee recommends to the Board of Managers of the Missionary Society to adopt the propositions herein contained, and recommends the Board to instruct its legal counsel to prepare the necessary documents for transfer of the property to the Missionary Society. On motion, the report was adopted by a rising vote. VIII.— Action of the Board of Managers, January, 1894. At the meeting on January 16, 1894, on motion of Sandford Hunt, the rules were suspended in order to take up and consider the matter of the Self-supporting Mission work in Chili. On motion of Sandford Hunt, the action taken a month ago adopting the recommendation of the Committee on Self-support¬ ing Missions was reconsidered. E. L. Fancher then offered the followinsf as a substitute for the action taken at the last meeting: The action of the Board of Managers of the Missionary Society, at its last meeting, in December, 1893, relative to the Self-supporting Missions in Chili, is hereby reconsidered, and in place lliereof the following is substituted: 1. There are difficulties attending the proiiosed transfer of title to the Mission¬ ary Society, such as stamp tax and transfer tax, and as a foreign corporation it could not hold the title longer than a few years under the laws of Chili. 2. It is therefore proposed that the present beneficiaries authorize the trii.stees now holding the legal title to transfer the beneficial use to the Missionary Society. Also that Richard Grant and Anderson Fowler become the trustees to hold the title for the Missionary Society; thej' to deliver to its Treasurer a dec¬ laration of such trust, and their agreement to execute at any time such powers of attorney or other papers as will authorize transfers of title to the property, or any part thereof, on request of said Board of Managers. 3. It is understood that said property is to be freed from all mortgage or other debts by the present holders of title. 4. The general treasury of the Missionary Society is not to be charged with any payment for or on account of the said Missions. 11 5. AYhenever the |25,000 contingent appropriation made by the General Mis¬ sionary Committee shall be contributed for the maintenance of the Missions, or any part thereof, tlie Board of Managers will assume the oversight thereof, and continue them as Self-supporting Missions, so far as said special contributions re» ceived will enable the Board to do so; subject, however, to any further action of the General Missionary Committee or of the General Conference. Sandford Hunt moved that tlie original report and the substi¬ tute be referred to the Committee on Self-supporting Missions and Finance, as a Joint Committee, for careful consideration, to report at the next meeting. * On motion of C. S. Harrower, this motion was laid on the table. Bishop E. G. Andrews, Vice-President, took the chair. Bishop Foss moved that the paper offered by Judge Fancher be accepted as a substitute for the last clause of the report adopted at the last meeting, namely, and “ I’ecommend to the Board to instruct its legal counsel to prepare the necessary docu¬ ments for transfer of the property to the Missionary Society.” Bishop Foss resumed the chair. E. L. Dobbins moved to strike out the fifth item from the sub¬ stitute, and it was so ordered. M. D’C. Crawford moved to strike out the fourth item, but the motion did not prevail. Yeas, 10; nays, 20. The substitute as amended, by the omission of the fifth item, was then accepted and adopted, and the report made at the last meeting, as amended, was then adopted. Sandford Hunt moved that the paper as adopted be referred to the Committee on Finance and Self-supporting Missions, with Judge Fancher, for careful revision of the language, and it was so ordered. Anderson Fowler moved that the Corresponding Secretaries be requested to immediately issue a call upon the Church for the contribution of 125,000, conditionally appropriated by the Gen¬ eral Committee for the Self-supporting Missions in Chili. C. C. Corbin moved to amend so that the appeal shall be issued as soon as the representatives of the Ti-ansit and Building Fund Society declare their acceptance of the report as adopted to-day, and it was so ordered. The motion as thus amended was then adopted. IX. —Action of Board of Managers, February, 1894. At the meeting on February 20, 1894, the Joint Committee on Self-supporting Missions and Finance reported from its minutes of January 16, 1894 : 12 'J’he Board at its last meeting referred its action then taken in regard to the Self-supporting Missions in Chili, modifying the action taken at the previous meeting of the Board to this Committee to revise its phraseology. Your Committee reports the following as embodying the action of the Board at the December meeting, as modified by its action at the January meeting: Whereas, Anderson Fowler and Richard Grant, representing the Transit and Building Fund Society, presented to the Board of Bishops an offer to transfer all the Mission work and Mission property belonging to said Society in Chili to the Missionary Society of the Methodist Episcopal Church, free from debt, on the conditions that Chili be set^part exclusively for self-supporting work, and that the Mission work in Chili be carried on and conducted on the plan of self-sup¬ port, as heretofore; and. Whereas, The General Missionary Committee, so far as it had authorit}', and subject to the authority of the General Conference, accepted for itself saidproposi- ti< ri, and recommended the Missionary Board to accept tlie same, and to enter upon and prosecute this work on the conditions named, and appropriated $25,000 contingent upon its being given especially for tliis work, said money to be administered by the Board. Therefore, the Board of Managers of the Missionary Society of the Methodist Episcopal Church accepts said proposition on the conditions named, so far as it has authority, and subject to the authority of tlie General Conference. Section 1. In view of the difficulties attending transfer of title to the Society, Sec. 2. It is proposed that the present beneficiaries authorize the Trustees now holding the legal title to transfer the beneficial use to the Missionary Society ; also that Richard Grant and Anderson Fowler become the Trustees to hold the title for the Missionary Society, they to deliver to its Treasurer a declaration of such trust, and their agreement to execute at an}' time such power of attorney or other papers as will authorize the transfer of title to the property, or any part thereof, on the request of the Board of Managers. Sec. 3. It is understood that sucli property is to be freed from all mortgage or other debts by said holders of title. Sec. 4. And that the General Treasury of the Missionary Society is not to be cliarged with any payment for or on account of the said Missions. Bishop Foss moved that the Board approve of this report as a correct embodiment of its action, and the motion prevailed. Richard Grant moved that R. B. Kelly, Attorney of the Build¬ ing and Transit Fund Society, be heard by the Board as repre¬ senting said Society in regard to the transfer of the property and work in Chili. Bishop Walden moved to suspend the “ Order of Business ” in order to allow this motion to be passed, and it was so ordered, and the motion of Richard Grant was adopted. R. B. Kelly then addressed the Board and presented a paper representing the views and wishes of the Building and Transit Fund Society. Bishop Foss moved to reconsider the fourth item of the sub¬ stitute, namely, “ And that the General Treasury of the Mis- 13 sionary Society is not to be charged with any payment for or on account of the said Missions,” as adopted at tlie last meeting, and to refer the same with the paper just submitted to the Joint Committee on Self-supporting Missions and Finance. The motion was divided, and the first clause, providing for the reconsideration of the fourth item, was adopted. Bishop Andrews moved to substitute for item fourth, as adopted at the last meeting, the following : Whenever the $25,000 contingent appropriation made by the General Mis¬ sionary Committee, or any part thereof, or any other or furtlier sums shall be contributed for the maintenance of the Missions in Chili, the same shall be set apart and tised solely and exclusively for such purpose, and the Board of Managers will assume the oversight of such Missions and continue them as Self- supporting Missions, so far as this Board has authority (and so far as contributions sliall be made expressly therefor), and subject to any further action of the General Conference. Bishop Foss moved that this substitute, the paper presented by Mr. Kelly, and the whole matter connected therewith be referred to the Joint Committee on Self-supporting Missions and Finance. Richard Grant stated that he agreed to the substitute of Bishop Andrews, whereupon Bishop Foss withdrew his motion. The substitute was then adopted. Bishop Walden moved that the report as amended be adopted, and it was adopted by a rising vote, as follows: Whereas, Anderson Fowler and Richard Grant, representing the Transit and Building Fund Society, presented to the Board of Bishops an offer to transfer all the Mission work and Mission property belonging to said Society in Chili to the Missionary Society of the Methodist Episcopal Church, free from debt, upon the condition that Chili be set apart exclusively for Self-sui^porting Mission work, and that the Mission work in Chili be carried on and conducted on the plan of self- support, as heretofore. And, Whereas, The General Missionary Committee, so far as it had authority, and subject to the authority of the General Conference, accepted for itself said proposition, and recommended the Missiouar}- Board to accept the same, and to enter upon and prosecute this work on the conditions named, and appropriated $25,000 contingent upon its being given specially for this work, said money to be administered by the Board; Therefore, the Board of Managers of the Missionary Societ}' of the Methodist Episcopal Church accepts said proposition on the conditions named, so far as it had authority, and subject to the authority of the General Conference: Section 1. In view of the difficulties attending transfer of title to the Society. Sec. 2. It is proposed that the present beneficiaries authorize the Trustees now holding the legal title to transfer the beneficial use to the Missionary So¬ ciety; also that Richard Grant and Anderson Fowler become the Trustees to hold the title for the Missionary Society, they to deliver to its Treasurer a declaration of trust, and their agreement to execute at anj^ time such power of attorney or 14 other papers as will authorize the transfer of title to the property or any part thereof, on the request of the Board of Managers. Sec. 3. It is understood that such property is free from all mortgage or other debts, by said holders of title. Sec. 4. Whenever the $25,000 contingent appropriation made by the Gen¬ eral Missionary Committee, or any part thereof, or any other or further sums shall be contributed for the maintenance of the Missions in Chili, the same shall be set apart and used solely and exclusively for such purpose, and the Board of Managers will assume the oversight of such Missions and continue them as Self-supporting Missions, so far as this Botird has authority (and so far as con¬ tributions shall be made expressly therefor), and subject to any further action of the General Conference. X.— Action of General Committee, 1894. On motion, the consideration of appropriations for Self-sup¬ porting Missions in Chili tvas taken up. On motion of Bishop FovSS, the following resolution was adopted : Resolved, That we make a conditional appropriation of $25,000 for the purposes named and for other kindred work in the Self-supporting Missions in Chili, to be at tlie disposal of the Board, so far as special contributions may be made for these purposes. A .—In 1895 Bishop Fitzgerald visited South America and held the South America Conference in March of that year. XI.— Action of General Committee, November 19, 1895. The Committee on Chili presented the following resolution : The General Missionary Committee, finding it impracticable to administer suc¬ cessfully the work in Chili upon the plan adopted by the Transit and Building- Fund Committee, from which it was received, most respectfully requests the General Conference to consider the question of placing this work in the same relation to the Missionary Society as our other work in South America. Bishop Foss moved that the whole matter be referred to the Board of Managei’S. On motion of Sandford Hunt, the whole subject was laid on the table. XII. —Action of Board of Managers, December, 1895. The Committee on Self-supporting Missions reported from their minutes of December 16, 1895 ; The General Committee made no direct appropriation for Chili, but left the matter wholly with the Board of Managers. It is desired that the Board shall decide what amount shall be used in that Mission for the year 189G. Your Committee recommend that $1,G00 be appropriated for immediate use and until the needs of tiie work can be further considered. 15 Treasurer La Fetra, of Chili, asks the privilege of using a balance appropriated for f\irnishing to the pa}unent of rents. He sa 3 ’s he has kept everj’ expenditure within the estimates, except for moving expenses, which he could not control. Your Committee recommend that this request be granted. Adopted. A statement received from Treasurer La Fetra, of Chili, shows that at the end of 189.3 there Avere owing for— Pesos. Pesos. Balance on Concepcion Girls’ School. 11,926 50 Mortgage on Concepcion Boys’ School, for lot. 5,000 00 - 16,926 50 Rents, 1892 and 1893. 11,928 80 Sundry expenses. 1,945 99 Furniture for Santiago College. 11,291 60 Book agenc}^ and printing office, books and material on hand, over capital. 10,061 40 Passage of Mr. and Mrs. Davis. 751 20 Total . 52,905 55 The interest on this amount for 1894, as per Brother La Fetra’s statement, was. 1,132 12 Toward payment on this indebtedness. .. . 54,037 07 In January, 1895, according to his statement, the Mission Treasurer received from the Transit and Building Fund Societj". 25,306 00 Leaving unpaid. 28,731 67 And from the Missionary Societ}'' for rents, etc., for November and - ■- December, 1893. 1,115 15 Leaving unpaid. 27,616 52 Add interest for 1895, estimated. 583 48 And there remains 3 ’et to be paid. 28,200 00 Or in United States gold about. $9,400 00 Your Committee recommend the following: *• Whereas, The work in Chili was to be turned over to the Missionaiy Society free from debt; therefore, “ Resolved, That this statement of indebtedness at the close of 1893, and interest on the same, be referred to the Transit and Building Fund Committee.” Adopted. XIII.— Action of Board of Managers, January, 1896. At the meeting on January 21, 1896, the action of the Board at its December meetinor concerninor the indebtedness of the Chili work at the close of 1893 was promptly forwarded to the Tran¬ sit and Building Fund Committee. Brother Richard Grant, the Treasurer, replies that their Committee will require more evidence than this statement shows before paying any more money. A joint cablegram has been sent to Brother La Fetra, instructing him to bring the account books with him to the United States. It is desired that the Board shall decide whether any further 16 action shall be taken concerning said indebtedness at the present time. Your Committee on Self-supporting Missions recommend that action on the above be deferred until the arrival of Brother La Fetra with the books. Adapted. For action General Conference of 1896 see page 33, XIV.— Action of the Board of Managers, July, 1896. July 21, 1896. Your Committee recommend the adoption of the folloAving : Wltereax^ The General Conference, subject to whose authoriW all the agreements between the General Missionary Committee and the Board of Managers in behalf of the Mi^sioTiary Society, and Anderson Fowler and Richard Grant, in behalf of the Transit and Building Fund Society, have been made, at its recent session re¬ ferred tlie matter of the work in Chili to the Board of Managers with power; and. Whereas, This action makes it necessary for the Board to clearly define the pol¬ icy upon which it will carry on said work; therefore. Resolved, 1. That this Board purposes to carry on the work in Chili upon the plan of self-support, as originally agreed upon. 2. That as the charter of the Transit and Building Fund Society allowed the appropriation of money to provide outfits, to pay passage, to pay traveling e.v- penses of pioneer evangelists, to build or purchase dwellings, schoolhouses, and houses of worship, and to tramslate, print, and publish the Scriptures, therefore the General Missionary Committee has authority to make appropriations for any or all of these purposes as it makes any other apj)ropriations. On motion of J, B, Graw, it was ordered that this report be postponed until tlie September meeting, and that it be printed, together with an historical statement of the past actions in the matter, and each member of the Board supplied with a copy as soon as practicable. XV.— Action of the Board of jNIanagers, September, 1896. The Committee on Self-support reported as follows : September 15, 1896. The following paper was presented to the Committee by the Transit and Building Fund Society : Meeting of the Self-supporting Committee of the Transit and Building Fund Society held July 27, 1896, in Anderson Fowler’s office. Produce Exchange, New York city; Brother Grant, secretary pro tern. Present, Asbury Lowrey, D.D., Brother Fowler, Brother Grant. Brother Fowler opened the meeting by saying we were called together to con¬ sider a proposition in reference to the work in Chili, now before the General Con¬ ference, represented b)’- the Board of Managers of the Missionary Society, and to decide whether we should modify said proposition so as to enable the Missionary Board to administer the work in Chili on the same lines as they do all their other Mission work. Resolved, That we, the Board of Jfanagers of the Transit and Building Fund Society, being anxious to work in harmony with our brethren of the Missionary Society of the Methodist Episcopal Church, hereby authorize Richard Grant to accept for us a sum of not less than !|100,000, to be paid in ten annual payments. 17 with interest at not loss than 2)^ per cent per annum, for the property owned by this Transit and Building Fund Society in Cliili, being the amount which we esti¬ mate as being contributed by the donors for self-supporting work and used for the same in that country. First payment of $10,000 to be made at the next meet¬ ing of the General Committee, November, 1896. All other payments yearly at the meeting of the General Committee. (Signed), Richard Grant, Treasurer and Secretary tern. In view of this communication from the Transit and Building Fund Society, your Committee respectfully ask leave to withdraw their report made at the July meeting, and to present the following: Whereas, All negotiations between the Transit and Building Fund Society and the Board of Managers and the General Missionary Committee were made subject to the authority of the General Conference; and. Whereas, This was understood by the' members of this Board generally and by the members of the General Committee, as we believe, to implj' the authority of the General Conference to order the method in which the Mission in Chili should be carried on even to the extent of dropping the self-supporting plan if it should be deemed necessary ; and, Whereas, The General Conference delegated its power in the premises to fhe Board of Managers; and. Whereas, The representatives of the Transit and Building Fund Society have proposed to the Board of Managers, in case of our unwillingness to pledge ourselves perpetual!}' to carry on the work in accord¬ ance with said plan, either to purchase the property in Chili for $100,000, payable in ten annual installments, or to return the property to their hands; therefore. Resolved, 1. That we deem it unwuse and impracticable to pledge this Board in perpetuity to carry on the work in accordance with the plan of said Society. 2. That wm cannot entertain the proposition to purchase the property. B. That a Special Committee of three be appointed to confer wdth the repre¬ sentatives of the Transit and Building Fund Society, to adjust all the details necessary to a retransfer of the property, and report to this Board at its next meeting. On motion of E, L. Dobbins, the Committee was permitted to withdraw its report made at the last meeting. On motion of J. M. Buckley, the report just presented was laid on the table. On motion of J. M. Buckley, it was resolved that when we adjourn we adjourn to meet on Monday 19, at 3 p. m., to transact business connected with Self-supporting Missions. On motion of J. M. Buckley, it was ordered that a Committee of three be appointed by the Chair to confer with the representa¬ tives of the Transit and Building Fund Society to see if it be not possible to come to some agreement by which this Board can continue to carry on the work, and, if not, to perfect details for the retransfer of the property to the Transit and Building Fund Society, and report to the adjourned meeting, October 19. The Chair appointed J. M. Buckley, E. L. Dobbins, and Secre¬ tary Leonard said Special Committee. 2 18 On motion of A. K. Sanford, the report was taken from the table and referred to the Special Committee just appointed. XVI.—Action of Board of Managers (Special Meeting), October 19, 1896. October 19, 1896.—At an adjourned meeting of the Board of Managers held October 19, 1896, J. M. Buckley made a report for the majority of the Special Committee on the Self-supporting Missions in Chili, appointed at the last meeting. Secretary Leonard presented a minority report. J. M, Buckley moved that the modified proposition of the Transit and Building Fund Society be accepted, namely, that the Missionary Society purchase the property in Chili for 1100,000, to be paid in twenty annual installments of |5,000 each, with interest at 2}^ per cent, the Society to own the property free of all conditions. S. F. Upham moved that the resolutions of the minority report be substituted as follows : Resolved, 1. That we now declare our willingness to accept in perpetuity the property belonging to the Transit and Building Fund Society, pledging ourselves to carry on the school and evangelistic work on the principle of self-support to the utmost of our ability, reserving the right to make such direct appropriations from time to time for the support of the work as the exigencies of the case may require. 2. That if the Transit and Building Fund Society decline to accept the fore¬ going proposition, we will return to that organization the bond they have given us, in which they agree to deed the property to the Missionary Society upon our request, surrendering on the part of this Board all authority over the Mission property now existing in the Republic of Chili owned by the Transit and Building Fund Society. Alden Speare moved to amend by striking out all after the word “ Resolved ” and substitute tlie following : 1. That we deem it unwise and impracticable to pledge this Board in perpe¬ tuity to carry on tlie work in accordance wuth the plan of said Transit and Building Fund Society. 2. That we cannot entertain the proposition to purchase the property. 3. That a Special Committee of three be appointed to confer with the repre¬ sentatives of the Transit and Building Fund Society, to adjust all the details necessary to a retransfer of the property, and report to this Board at its next meeting. The motion to amend was lost by a vote of eight to twenty- two. S. F. Upham’s motion to substitute the resolutions of the minority report was lost by a vote of eleven to eighteen. 19 The motion of J. M. Jluckley was then adopted by a vote of twenty-one to ten. On motion of J. M. Buckley, it was ordered that the same Committee prepare a resolution to present to the General Com¬ mittee on this subject, and report the same to the Board at its regular meeting to-morrow. XVII.— Board of Ma^jagees (Regular Meeting), October 20, 1896. No action was taken upon Chili. XVIII.— Action of Board of Managers (Special Meeting), November 5, 1896. The Chairman stated that the meeting was called by the Cor¬ responding Secretaries, at the request of the Committee on Finance, to further consider the Self-supporting Missions in Chili, and for such other business as might be presented. The Minutes of the adjourned meeting of October 19 and the majority and minority reports of the Special Committee presented at that time were read for information. On motion of J. M. Buckley, the Committee on Finance were requested to state the reasons which led to their request for the calling of this special meeting. After some statements by members of the Committee, on motion of J. M. Buckley, Judge Fancher, the Counsel of the Society, was requested to state to the Board what difficulties he found in the way of carrying out the action adopted by the Board at its adjourned meeting, October 19. E. L. Fancher then addressed the Board in response to this request. II. K. Carroll moved to reconsider the action taken by the Board at its adjourned meeting, October 19. After much discussion, on motion of C. S. Ilarrower, the previous question was ordered ; and the motion to reconsider prevailed. Homer Eaton moved to substitute the minority report for the action now before us. Bishop Andrews moved to refer the whole matter to the General Missionary Committee. After much additional discussion. Bishop Foss moved the previous question, and it was ordered. 20 The motion to refer the whole inatter to the General Missionary C'omniittee was then adopted hy a vote of fifteen to thirteen. Secretary Smith asked direction from the Board in regard to the estimates from Chili. Bishop Foss moved that they he sent to the General Com¬ mittee, to be considered by that body, and it was so ordered. The Chair being requested to rule as to what was referred to the General Committee, ruled that all the reports and papers con¬ nected with this matter and all that were referred by the General Conference to this Board were referred to the General Com¬ mittee. XIX. —Action of Board of Managers, December, 1896. The General Committee at its recent session adopted the fol¬ lowing : 1. That it is our judgment that we should continue our work in Chili, that we may receive for the Church the advantages of the labor alread}' performed and the propert}^ secured. We therefore recognize Chili as a Mission field, within the bounds of the South America Conference. 2. That we recommend that the Board purchase the property for $100,000, payable in twenty annnual installments, without interest. 3. That the General Committee place at the disposal of the Board $20,000, to provide for the first payment and the needs of the Missions for the current year. Your Committee recommend: 1. That in accordance witli the recommendation of the General Missionary Committee, this Board authorize the purchase of the property in Chili for $100,000, provided the title be found correct, payment to be made in annual installments of $5,000, without interest, beginning February 1, 1897, with the distinct under¬ standing that the Board will be under no obligation to carrj^ on the work on the self-supporting plan, and distinctly disclaims any purpose to do so, but proposes to carry it on in the same way as its other Missions. Adopted. 2. That a Committee of five be appointed bv the Board to complete the transfer of the property, provided they find the title correct. Adopted. On motion of J. M. Buckley, it was ordered that E. L. Fancher, G. G. Reynolds, E. L. Dobbins, Lemuel Skidmore, and J. M. King constitute said Committee. On motion of Alden Speare, the tliird resolution was laid on the table until the Committee just appointed shall report. The resolution is as follows: 3. That this Board select three persons to serve as Trustees, in whom the title of the pi’operty shall be vested. 21 On motion of J. M. Buckley, it was ordered that Bishop An¬ drews, the Corresponding Secretaries, and the Committee on Self- supporting Missions be a Committee, with power, to distribute the $15,000 appropriated for the work in Chili. XX.— Action of Board of Managers, January 19, 1897. On motion of J. M. Buckley, it was ordered that the report of the Special Committee on the Chili property be made to the March meeting of the Board, and that the Treasurer make no payment on the property until after this report shall have been made. On motion of C. C. Corbin, it was ordered that the Recording Secretary incorporate in the notices for the March meeting a statement that the reiiort of the Committee on Property in Chili will then be considered. ^4 —In 1897 Bishop Vincent visited South America, and held the South America Conference February 9-12 of that year. On February 19, 1897, under the enabling act of the General Conference of 1896, he organized at Santiago, Chili, “The West¬ ern South America Mission Conference.” XXI. —Action of Board of Managers, March, 1897. On motion of C. C. Corbin, the order of business was sus¬ pended so as to take up the report of the Special Committee on the Chili Property. The report was then presented by E. L. Fancher, as follows : The Committee appointed at the December, 1896, meeting of the Board of Managers of the Missionary Society, to examine and report touching the title to certain Mission stations in Chili proposed to be sold h}" the Transit and Build¬ ing Blind Society to tlie Missionary Society for !|100,000, have held two meet¬ ings. The first met at the office of E. L. Fancher on January 12, 1897, at 2 p. M., when there were present E. L. Fancher, G. 0-. Reynolds, E. L. Dobbins, and J. M. King. Also present S. L. Baldwin, Recording Secretary of the Missionary Society. The second meeting was held at the same place on March 12, 1897, when tliere were present E. L. Fancher, J. M. King, E. L. Dobbins, and Lemuel Skidmore. The Recording Secretary laid before the Committee a copy of the minutes of the Board, adopted at its last meeting, in reference to the Mission stations in Chili; also the deeds and otlier papers delivered to Secretary Leonard by Messrs. Grant and Fowler, representing the said Transit and Buildiii'g Fund Society, in January, 1894; also printed copies of the several actions of said Board of Man¬ agers in reference to the said so-called Self-supporting Missions in Chili, witlt doc¬ uments and papers printed therewith. The Committee respectfully report that they have examined the said papers; they also examined a reported statement of treaty made in 18.33 between the 22 United States and tlie Republic of Chili, showing that as to citizens of either country who died holding real estate, and lepdng heirs in the other country, such heirs, by reason of alienage, shall not be deprived of their inheritance, provided they disposed of the property within three years. The Committee also exam¬ ined the Constitution of Chili, as amended in 1888; also extracts from the Codigo Commercial and the Civil Code of that republic, and letters from Senor Gano, the Chilian Minister at Washington, D. C. The Committee, from tho papers before them, further report as follows: ]. The Transit and Building Fund Society is a corporation created under the General Laws of 1848 of the State of New York, for the purpose of carrying on Mission work on tho plan of self-support. In Chili it must be regarded as a foreign corporation for such purpose, and has not there pursued industrial or com¬ mercial business, so as to have license to occupy lands in Chili under the Codigo Commercial or the Civil Code. Nor does it appear that, as such foreign cor¬ poration, it has acquired the real property constituting the Missions in Chili by the ‘‘ express j^ermission of the Legislature in Chili, as required by Article 556 of the Civil Code of Chili, as follows; “Corporations can acquire property of all classes, by whatever title; but can¬ not hold real property that they acquire without permission of the Legislature. Without this express permission the}^ will be obliged to transfer the said real property within five years following the day on which they acquire possession of it: and if the}' do not do so, the aforesaid real property will be confiscated.” 2. Anderson Fowler and Richard Grant, in whose names the title appears to stand of record in the Conservado, are both, as the Committee is informed, cit¬ izens of the United States, and, as to Chili, are foreigners. As such, they are aliens, and cannot individually take title to real estate in Chili, nor could they, as agents of a corporation, take title, except under said codes, without authority of the President of the Republic, and in that case the charter and by-laws of the corporation must be exhibited for the approval of the President. The Constitu¬ tion of the Republic of Chili defines who are its citizens in the following terms: Ch.vpter IV.— Citizens of Chili. The following are Chilians: (1.) Those born within tho territory of Chili. (2.) Children of Chilian parents born in foreign countries, by the sole fact of becoming domiciled in Chili. The children of Chileans born in a foreign country, when the father is at the time in the service of the Republic, are Chilians, even for the ends of which the fundamental laws, or any others, require birth on Chilian territory. (3.) Foreigners who, having resided one year in the Republic, shall declare before the municipal authorities of the territory in which they reside their desire to fix their domicile in Chili, and shall ask naturalization papers. (4.) Those wlio may obtain naturalization bj' special favor of the Congress. 3. At a meeting of the Board of Managers of the Missionary Society on the 15th of September, 1896, a paper was received from said Transit and Building Fund Society, conUiining the following resolutions : Resolved, That we, the Board of Managers of the Transit and Building Fund Society, being anxious to work in harmony with our brethren of the Missionary Society of the Methodist Episcopal Church, hereby authorize Richard Grant to accept for us a sum of not less than one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000), to be paid in ten (10) annual payments, with interest at not less than than two and one half (2^) per cent per annum, for the property owned by the Transit and Building Fund Society in Chili, being the amount which we estimate as being contributed by the donors for self-supporting work, and used for the same in that country. This specifies a trust created by the donors of the fund. The Transit Society, by their own statement, is bound by the trust. It would not affect a bona fide purchaser, for a valuable consideration, without notice of the trust; but in this case express notice of the trust has been given to the Missionary Society. Its Board of Managers have already decided not to assume the trust. 4. Under the laws of Chili the Missionary Society cannot hold title to lands in that Republic without the express permission of the Legislature or of the Presi¬ dent of the Republic with the consent of the Council of State, it being a foreign corporation in Chili; nor could it establish agents there to take the title without the authority of the President of the Republic. 5. The Constitution and Charter of the Missionary Society of the Methodist Episcopal Church are in direct antagonism to the fundamental laws of Chili, con¬ tained in the Constitution of that Republic (hereafter cited), and it would be idle to suppose that the President and Council of State of that Republic would ap¬ prove of the same under Article 548 of the Civil Code. Article 548 provides: “The ordinances or by-laws of corporations that might be formed by the same shall be submitted for the approbation of the President, with consent of the Council of State; and if they have nothing contrary to pub¬ lic order, to the law, or to morals, permission shall be given.” G. 'When the Transit and Building Fund Society transferred its title to Richard Grant and Anderson Fowler, it does not appear that it held title by legislative permission, nor that such transfer was made pursuant to a previous decree of a Judge, as required by Article 557 of the Civil Code of Chili. Article 557 reads: “Real property that corporations possess, with the especial permission of the Legislature, are subject to the following rules: 1. They can* not transfer it, nor burden it with mortgage annuity, usufruct, or servitude, nor lease for more than eight years if farm lands, nor more than five years if city property, without previous decree of a Judge, with knowledge of the cause, by reason of necessitj^ or manifest utility.” 7. Article 468 of the Code of Commerce of Chili provides: “Foreign corpora¬ tions cannot establish grants in Chili without authority from the President of the Republic. Such agents, acting without such authority, are declared to be per¬ sonally liable on their contracts made as such agents, and subject to all responsi¬ bilities theretofore established, and without prejudice to any action which might also lie against the corporations.” 8. Article 546 of the Civil Code reads: “ Fonndaxions or corporations which have not been established by a law, or which have not been approved by the President of the Republic, with the consent of the Council of State, are not legal persons.” Article 547 of the Civil Code is this: “Industrial societies are not compre¬ hended in the provisions of this title ; their rights and obligations are regulated, according to their nature, by other titles of this Code and by the Code of Com¬ merce : neither do the provisions of this title extend to corporations of public right, as the nation, the treasury, municipalities, churches, religious corporations, and establishments that are supported by funds of the treasury; these corpora¬ tions and foundations are governed by laws and special regulations.” 24 0. Whether the President of the Republic of Cliili could or would give author¬ ity to agents of a foreign Protestant Missionary Society to carry on its work on lands in Chili, see the following constitutional provision : CONSTITUTION OF THE REPUBLIC OF CHILL ' Article V (lY). Chapter III.— Religion. “ The religion of the Republic of Chili is the Apostolic Roman Catholic, and the public exercise of any other is excluded.” Note —The law of July 27, 1865, which interprets this article, reads: “Article I. It is declared by Article Y (lY) of the Constitution that it is per¬ mitted to those who do not profess the Apostolic Roman Catholic religion to practice their worship within the confines of buildings of private ownership. “Article II. It is permitted to dissenters to found and sustain schools for the instruction of their own children in the doctrines of their own religion.” These fundamental provisions exclude Protestant Mission work and all public dissident worship. 10. See also letters from Senor Gano, the Chilian Minister at Y''ashington, D. C., as follows : Legacion de Chili, Washington, January 5, 1897. Mr. John Eton Wayland, 229 Broadway, New York city. Dear Sir: Referring to your esteemed favor of the 23d of last December, I beg to say that, in order to answer properly the questions you ask me regarding the acquisition of land in Chili by a corporation, I should have to know what purposes does that corporation follow or expect to follow, that is to say, whether the corporation’s purposes are simply religious, industrial, or commercial. Once I get your reply in this regard, will be most happy to satisfy your wishes. Respectfully, (Signed) Domingo Gang. Legacion de Chili, Washington, January 14, 1897. Mr. John Eton Wayland, 229 Broadway, New York city. Dear Sir: By direction of H. E., the Chilian Minister, I beg to reply to both of your esteemed favors of the 23d of last December and of the 5th inst. “Foreign corporations cannot establish agents in Chili without the consent of the President of the Republic.” Corporations and institutions of charity can onl}^ exist in Chili by virtue of a law, or by the approval of the President of the Republic, with the consent of the Council of State, and the rules or statutes of said corporations or institutions must be submitted in like manner to the approval of the President of the Republic, and must obtain the consent of the Council of State; and such ap¬ proval is only given when said statutes do not appear to be anything against the public order, the laws, or tlie morals. Regarding the acquisition of property, the corporations and institutions to which I have referred can acquire them of any kind, and by any title, but cannot keep any I'eal estate they may acquire without the special consent of the Legisla¬ ture. I think that such consent could not be had for a corporation of the nature of the one to which you have referred in your letters, because in Chili there is no liberty of worship, and according to the explanation given in July, 1865, to Article Y, to-day the fourth, of the Constitution of Chili, those possessing tlie Roman Catholic religion can only perform their religious services inside a build- ing of their private property; they can also establish and maintain schools for the teaching of their children in their religion, but cannot establish Missions with the purpose of teaching publicly dissident worships. However, and in case yon might so desire it, you might address for further information the Minister of the United States before the Government of Chili. I am, sir, Yours respectfully, (Signed) M. Acletile Cients. Upon all the foregoing, the undersigned members of the Committee are of the opinion that the title to the Mission premises in Chili, offered to be sold by the Transit and Building Fund Society to the Missionary Society of the Methodist Episcopal Church, is not “ correct,” nor such as the Missionary Society can ))ur- chase with a view of prosecuting its missionary work thereon. Dated March 12, 1897. (Signed) E. L. F.vncher, Geo. G. REYxoLns, Lemuel Skidmore. On motion of J. F. Rusling, the report was accepted. On motion of J. F. Rusling, the thanks of the Board were presented to the Committee for this exhaustive report. On motion of Bishop Foss, the order of business was further suspended to consider the matter of the work in Chili. E. L. Fancher offered the following resolution : Resolved, 1. That the report of the Special Committee concerning the title to lands in the Republic of Chili be delivered to the Treasurer, to be kept on tile. 2. And forasmuch as it appears that the Missionary Society cannot hold lands in Chili without express authority of the Chilian Legislature, nor appoint agents there to act for the Society without the consent of the President of the Republic and of the Council of State, the Board of Managers of the Missionary Society decide that they cannot adopt the recommendation of the General Missionary Committee to purchase the Mission premises in Chili, which the Transit and Building Fund Society offer to sell for $100,000 to the Missionary Society. J. M. Cornell moved that the further consideration of this question be deferred until a meeting to be held one week from to-day; but the motion was lost by a vote of 17 to 17. The first item of the resolution was then adopted. The remainder of the resolution was adopted by a vote of 16 to 15. The resolution, as a whole, was then adopted. On motion of Bishop Foss, the following additional resolution was adopted : Resolved, That we have learned with great regret, through the exhaustive report of our Special Committee, that we cannot take title to property in Chili; and that we request the Committee on South America and Mexico to consider and to report to the Board, at its next regular meeting, the most economical method of administering our work in Chili until the next meeting of the General Missionary Committee. On motion of Alden Speare, it was ordered that the papers 26 relating to property in Chili, handed by Anderson Fowler and Richard Grant to this Society, be returned to them. XXII. —Actio?^ of Board of Managers, April, 1897. April 20, 1897.—At the March meeting of the Board the fol¬ lowing resolution was adopted : Resolved, That we have learned with great regret, through the exhaustive report of our Special Committee, that we cannot take title to property in Chili; and that we request the Committee on South America and Mexico to consider and report the most economical method of administering our work in Chili until the next meeting of the General Missionary Committee. Your Committee on South America and Mexico recommend to the Board that we continue the work in Chili until the next meeting of the General Missionary Committee, as heretofore, provided that satisfactory arrangements can he made with the owners of their properties for their use. lu pursuance with this recommendation, a sub-committee, con¬ sisting of Andrew Longacre and J. A. Punderford, was appointed to ascertain from Messrs. Fowler and Grant what terms can be made for the rent of their property now occupied by us, and to report at the next meeting of the Board. II. K. Carroll moved to strike out the words “ until the meeting of,” in the second line, and to substitute the words “ in accord¬ ance with the action of;” and it was so ordered. On motion of J. F. Goucher, the word “ use ” was substituted for the word “ rent,” in the eighth line. On motion of J. F. Goucher, it was ordered that the Commit¬ tee to confer with Messrs. Fowler and Grant be made a Commit¬ tee of five; and the Chair appointed J. M. King, E. L. Dobbins, and E. B. Tuttle as the additional members. The report as thus amended was then adopted as a whole. On motion of J. M. Buckley, the Secretary in charge was instructed to send out the teachers already ordered for Santiago College, without waiting for the decision of the questions now pending in regard to the use of the property. XXIII. —Action of Board of Managers, May, 1897. On motion of J. M. King, it was resolved to hear the report of the Special Committee on the Chili property at this time. The Special Committee to confer with Anderson Fowler and Richard Grant in regard to the use of the property in Chili re¬ ported as follows ; That they first propounded the question whether the purchase of the property according to the original terms was open for consideration, to which Messrs, Fowler and Grant responded distinctly in the negative. They then inquired as 27 to the terms on wliich tlie Missionary Sociot}^ might rent tlie property, to which Messrs, Fowler and Grant responded that $200,000 was a moderate estimate of the value of the property, and that with this fact in mind they would be willing to let this or any Committee appointed by the Board estimate the sum which would be a reasonable rental. Your Committee learned that Messrs. Fowler and Grant had personally put into this property the sum of $172,000. Your Committee recommend that the sum of $5,000, set aside by the General Committee for the purchase of the property, be appropriated to pay the rent from the time of the March meeting until the meeting of the General Committee—this being all the money at tlie disposal of the Board for this purpose. J. M. Buckley moved tliat the report be adopted. J. F. Goucher moved that it be recommitted, with instructions to further confer with the owners of the property and report at the next meeting the result of their conference. After discussion, on motion of Bishop Andrews, the previous question was ordered ; and the motion of J. F. Goucher was adopted. XXIV. —Action of the Board of Managers, June, 1897. Tlie report of the Special Committee on the use of the property in Cliili was presented as follow's: The Special Committee to confer with Anderson Fowler and Richard Grant respectfully report that they have agreed with them on the following: . 1. That rent be paid for the property in Chili at the rate of $700 per month from March, 1897, until different arrangements are agreed upon. 2. The Missionary Society .assumes the payment of insurance and taxes. The property to be kept in repair by the schools themselves, as under the administration of the Transit and Building Fund Society. 4. The school property at Cocpiimbo and the vacant lot at Iqulqne are not being used b)- the Missionary Society, and are therefore not included in the above proposition. J. F. Rusling offered the following substitute for the report: Whereas, After careful and pra 3 'erful effort since 1893, and with our large ex¬ perience in world-wide Missions elsewhere, we have found it impracticable to conduct the so-called Self-supporting Missions in Chili on a self-supporting basis, as those previous!}-' in charge thereof likewise did; and. Whereas, We have offered to accept said Mission, and to organize and conduct it on the same basis and in the same way as all other Missions, in the fear of God and for the best interests of tlie Mission cause, as we firmly believe; and. Whereas, The Transit and Building Fund Society, heretofore in charge thereof, and the legal custodians of said Mission and Mission property, as claimed, refuse to transfer the same to this Society', except upon such self-supporting basis, with¬ out the payment by us of the sum of $100,000, or an annual rental that will amount to about $10, 000 a year; and. Whereas, We are advised by the Counsel of this Board that under the Con¬ stitution and laws of the Republic of Chili said Transit and Building Fund Society have no valid title to said property, and can give us no such title; and, WhereoM, By tlie action of the last General Conference this Board was vested 28 with full power to consider and dispose of this Chili business, and, after a full year’s negotiation and deliberation relative to the same, the time has now come- to settle and dispose of it; therefore, Resolvtd, 1. That in view of the foregoing facts, and also of the present con¬ dition of our Missionary treasury, we regretfully decline to accept said Chili Mission on the basis or terms proposed, and hereby relinquish said Cliili Mission property to its aforesaid original owners. 2. Tliat the Counsel of the Boai’d be instructed to prepare the necessary papers to effectuate the above action, and the proper officers of the Board be- authorized to execute the same under his counsel and advice. 3. That an accounting be instituted by the Treasurer of this Board between tliis Board and said Transit and Building Fund Society, and that a report be made to this Board at an early day of the moneys received and expended by this Board on account of said Chili Mission and property during the period they Intve been under our supervision and control. 4. That a Special Committee of seven be appointed by the Chair, of whom our senior Corresponding Secretary shalfbe one and the Treasurer ofthisBoagdanother, to consider and report, at the next meeting of this Board, what steps shall be taken to organize and conduct our Mission in Chili on the same basis as our Mis¬ sions elsewhere, and what further appropriation, if any, is needed for this pur¬ pose this year, and whether onr present appropriation for Chili, with these changed conditions there, may not well be reduced. After discussion, J. M, Buckley moved to lay the substitute on the table. Pending this motion J. F. Rusling demanded a call of the house ; and a quorum not being present, the Chair declared the Board adjourned. XXV. —Board of Managers, July, 1897. Alden Speare moved that the order of business be suspended in order to take up the report on the Chili property, and it was so ordered. The motion pending at the meeting on June 15, to lay the sub¬ stitute offered by J. F. Rusling on the table, was voted upon, but did not prevail. The first resolution of the substitute being taken up, after dis¬ cussion, Bishop Andrews moved the previous question ; but the motion did not prevail, 13 voting in the affirmative and 9 in the negative. After some further discussion, James II. Taft, Vice President, took the chair. After further discussion, on motion of Alden Speare, the previous question was ordered. On motion of J. M. Buckley, the vote was taken by yeas and nays, and was as follows : Yeas.—.]. II. Taft, T. H. Burch, C. C. McCabe, C. D. Foss, 29 Oeorge Abele, Alden Speare, G. G. Reynolds, II. A. Monroe, J. F, Rusling, Lemuel Skidmore, P. A. ^\'elch—11. JVays. —J. M. Buckley, H. K. Carroll, E. L. Dobbins, J. M. King, C. R. Barnes, Archer Brown, E. G. Andrews, R. W. P. Goff, C. S. Coit, F. M. North, Richard Grant—11. 'I’he Chair declared the resolution lost. On motion of J. M. Buckley, the second resolution was laid on the table. On motion of Bishop Andrews, the rest of the document was laid on the table.. On motion of Bishop Foss, the report of the Committee was taken up.' Bishop Foss moved the following substitute for the report of the Committee: That we autliorize the Committee who presented this report to negotiate for the rent of tlie property in Chili until the next meeting of the General Missionary Committee, on the basis of a rental not exceeding $400 per month from the date of the meeting of this Board in March. 'Phe substitute tvas adopted by a vote of 9 to 7. 'Idle foregoing history shows an anomalous condition. The Transit and Building Fund Society are the owners of all the property now used by the Methodist Episcopal Church for its Mission established in Chili by the General Committee at its last session at Detroit, Mich., in November, 1896. The Board of Managers has not purchased it, nor rented it, and yet the Mis¬ sionary Society is not using it according to the principles of the Building Fund Society, nor does it vacate it. We append the best attainable financial exhibits of the Mission: Accounts of the Chili Mission for 1894 and 1895. All accounts in Chill currency, worth 36 cents gold to the dollar (peso). The Schools. 1894. Total income of six schools for the year.$137,693 84 Current expenses and native teachers. $85,521 77 Salaries of American teachers above living expenses. 23,431 39 Contributed to fund for Gospel work. 12,124 15 Spent on repairs, improvements, and lurniture. 16,616 53 -$137,693 84 1895. Total income of six schools for the y'ear.$137,650 81 Current expenses and native teachers.$87,450 83 Salaries of Americttu teachers above living expenses.... 24,339 47 Contributed to fund for Gospel work. 13,093 00 Spent on repairs, improvements, and furniture. 12,767 51 $137,650 81 30 Publishing Department. Printing office, net gain, 1894. $3,475 15 “ “ “ “ 1895. 5,639 86 Contributed to fund for Gospel work . $1,000 00 Expended on plant. 8,115 01 Book Agenc}', net gain, 1894. $',994 80 “ “ “ 1895. 1,212 59 Increase of capital in two years The Churches. Xative Ohurclies. 1894. The seven native churches cost for the year. The congregations contributed. $2,052 18 The Missionary Society paid for rent. 3,708 00 Paid from general mission funds. 13,696 60 1895. The eig7d native churches cost. The congregations contributed. $3,867 19 The Missionary Society paid for rents, moving, etc. 7,770 35 Paid from general mission funds. 15,903 08 English Churches. 1894. The three English churches cost for the year. The congregations contributed. $5,140 00 The Missionary Society paid for moving. 60 00 Paid from general mission funds. 800 00 1895. The three English churches cost for the year The congregations contributed. $8,847 63 The Missionary Society paid for moving. 266 00 Paid from general mission funds. 815 30 Miscellaneous Expenses. 1894. Insurance, rents of school buildings, tracts, stationery. printing, etc... Special contributions, sale of Bibles, etc. $2,481 55 The Missionary Society paid rents, insurance, etc....... 4,307 85 Paid from general mission funds . 1,950 30 1895. Insurance, rents of school buildings, tracts, stationery, printing, etc.. . Special contributions, sale of Bibles, etc. $1,997 32 The Missionary Society paid rents, insurance, etc. ...... 3,966 25 Paid from general mission funds.316 28 General Mission Fund. 1894. Expended on native churches.$13,696 60 “ “ English “ 800 00 “ “ miscellaneous items. 1,950 30 $9,115 01 $9,115 01 13,207 31> $3,207 39 $19,456 78 $19,456 78 $27,540 62 $27,540 62 $6,000 OO $6,000 00 $9,928 93 $9,928 93 $8,739 70 $8,739 70 $6,279 85 $6,279 85 $16,446 90 31 Received from the schools... “ “ printing office, Debt incurred. 1895. Expended on native churches. “ “ English “ . “ “ miscellaneous items. Received from the schools. “ “ printing office. Debt incurred. $12,124 15 500 00 3,822 75 $15,903 08 815 30 316 28 $13,093 00 500 00 3,441 66 $16,446 00 $17,034 66 $17,034 66 Accounts Which Shoui.d Have Eeen Paid by the Missionary Society. Improvements and furniture of schools.$29,384 04 Printing office plant. 8,115 01 Chapel and parsonage furniture and fittings. 3,667 13 Moving and transit expenses, 1804. 1,102 15 -$42,268 33 Debt incurred in two years on Gospel work. 7,264 41 Additional amount which should have been available for Gospel work. $35,003 92 Total Income from All Sources. 1894. The schools.$137,696 84 Publishing department. 33,426 20 Contributions by the churches. 8,192 18 Miscellaneous receipts. 2,481 55 The Missionary Society. 8,015 85 -$189,811 62 1895. The schools.$137,650 81 Publishing department. 67,712 16 Contributions b}^ the churches. 12,714 82 Special contribut’ns by tlie churches for benevolences, etc. 1,731 08 Miscellaneous receipts. 1,997 32 The Missionary Society... .'.. 12,002 60 -$233,808 79 Total receipts for two years $423,620 41 Expenditures on Account of Special Gifts Received for Chili Mission. (All amounts are stated in United States currency.) 1894 For outgoing of new missionaries.$1,352 98 For Rev. Harry Compton’s work. 70 00 1896 For Miss M. A. Milks’s work. 15 00 -$1,437 98 Appropriation.s. (All amounts stated in United'States currency.) 1893 For debts of 1894 and two months of 1893.$2,566 00 1894 For homecoming of W. C. Hoover. 566 15 For outgoing of G. F. Arms. 513 64 $3,645 79 32 J895 For transit of eight teacliors.$2,400 00 For rents. 1,725 00 For traveling. 220 00 For insurance. 455 00 For furnishing Girls’ ScliO'il at Concepcion. 500 00 Total.$5,300 00 Less part of appropriation Ibr transit unused. 320 73 Total regular appropriation.$4,979 27 For homecoming of James Benge. 326 87 For homecoming of Eva L. Schultz. 179 55 For outgoing of W. C. Hoover. 536 99 For moving expenses of preachers. 1,150 80 For interest. 51 02 For loss by exchange. 1,061 76 - 8.286 26 1896 For rents.$3,260 00 For traveling. 733 33 For insurance. 733 33 $4,726 66 402 23 594 05 175 00 100 00 - 5,997 94 3 897 For debts previous to 1897.$5,000 00 For salaries of men in the Spanish Gospel work.. . . 2,396 10 For insurance. 850 50 For outgoing of new missionaries. 1,950 00 For outgoing of old missionaries. 1,376 20 For homecoming of old missionaries... 500 00 For traveling expenses of presiding elders. 200 00 For traveling e.xpenses of preachers on circuits .... 200 00 For rents of chapels and parsonages. 2,527 20 For purchase of the property (in part). 5,000 00 Total.$20,000 00 The purchase of the property by the Society not having been consummated this last amount has not been used. 6,000 00 Total regular appropriation.. For homecoming of C. S. Winans. For homecoming of I. H. La Fetra For homecoming of Emilie J. Day For relief of Nettie Wilbur. Total regular appropriation, net.$15,000 00 For homecoming of Harriet M. Christopher. 229 55 For homecoming of Jennie S. Farwell. 260 40 For homecoming of T. W. La Fetra (in part). 400 00 - 15,889 95 Grand total $33,819 94 33 Action of the General Conference of 1896. (Report of Committee on Missions, No. VI.) Having cnrefully considered matters referred to it in regard to Self-supporting Missions in Chili, your Committee recommends the adoption of the following : 1. Whereas^ Messrs. Anderson Fowler and Richard Grant, representing the Transit and Building Fund Society, through the Board of Bishops offered to transfer to the Missionary Society their property in Chili, free of debt, on con¬ dition that the work should be carried on on the principle of Self-supporting Missions; and, Wlmreas^ The General Missionary Committee, in session at Minneapolis in No¬ vember, 1893, and the Board of Managers, in New York, subsequently did ac¬ cept said offer on the condition named, subject to the action of this General Conference; therefore, Resolved, That the General Conference refer this whole matter to the Board of Managers of the Missionary Society, with power. I \ i ' ’ '■ I,' • iV • mV A « 4 ^ ft 5 * ' , y i