Xi
^/)^/?A
/>7^
Columbia 2Bnit)er^ft|)
CoUegc of ^fjpsiiciansi anti burgeons;
Hiiirarp
IN-KNEE: ITS RELATION TO RICKETS,
LONDON :
PRINTED BY WEST, NEWMAN AND CO.
HATTON GARDEN, E.C.
MEDICAL AND SURGICAL ASPECTS
IN-KNEE (GENU-VALGUM):
ITS RELATION TO
RICKETS,
ITS
PREVENTION AND ITS TREATMENT WITH AND WITHOUT
SUEGIGAL OPEEATION.
BY
W. J. LITTLE, M. p., F.R.G.P.,
LATE SENIOR PHYSICIAN TO AND LECTUKER ON MEDICINE AT THE LONDON HOSPITAL ;
VISITING PHYSICIAN TO THE INFANT OKPHAN ASYLUM AT -VVANSTEAD,
THE EAELSWOOD ASYLUM FOE IDIOTS ;
FOUNDEK OF THE KOYAL OETHOPaiDIC HOSPITAL ; ETC.
ASSISTED BY
E. MUIEHEAD LITTLE, M.E.C.S.
Illustrated by upwards of Fifty Figures and Diagrams.
D. APPLETON & CO., NEW YOEK,
1882.
3i
r «*'■■';
>4^\
:S.'^
.■v\'
V^^
ID
Ui
s
\i
TO
PROFESSOE GROSS, M.D., D.C.L.,
ETC., ETC.,
FATHER OF SURGEEY
IN
AMEEICA,
AN ENLIGHTENED AND HONOURABLE EXAMPLE OF ALL THAT
IS NOBLE IN OUR PROFESSION,
AND TO HIS
MEDICAL AND SURGICAL BRETHREN,
IN
GRATEFUL ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF THEIR CORDIAL RECEPTION
OF HIM WHEN ON A VISIT TO THE UNITED STATES
IN 1878,
THIS BOOK IS INSCRIBED
BY THE AUTHOR.
Digitized by the Internet Arciiive
in 2010 with funding from
Open Knowledge Commons
http://www.archive.org/details/medicalsurgicalaOOIitt
CONTENTS.
Aberration of form, no, without alteration of structure
Accident may cause the distortion . . .
Accommodative changes ....•••
Activity, intellectual, of parent, in excess, a cause .
,, cerebro-spinal, ,, ,, 5? • •
Adolescents, tall, often become affected with atonic in-knee
Adults, curable in, without operation . . . .
Aitken, Dr., on undue hairiness in rickets
Animal food, aversion to, often observed in atonic distortions
Annandale, osteotomy by
Antiseptic system, Lister's, available in osteotomy .
Arms, the, disproportionately long in rickets . . . .
Arthritis deformans and rheumatic in-knee . . . .
Asphyxia neonatorum, in-knee from
Atalectasis and in-knee . . ...
Atonic disorders, increase of, through civilisation
„ in-knee may co- exist with atonic in-ankle and atonic
spinal curvature
,, in-ankle may precede in-knee and scoliosis .
,, in-knee, diagnosis from rickets . .
,, ,, may return on re -application of exciting causes
,, „ occurs mainly at the two most rapid periods of
growth
,, ,, occurs more readily in tall infants .
Atony of fibrous tissues a stage of rickets ? _ .
,, ,, structures, cause of other disorders
Atrophy of external condyle, see deficiency of .
B.
PAGE
88
8
11
69
69
19
30
. 107
75
148, 152
. 152
81
59
95
10
69
70
70
26, 70
78
75, 88
88
41
15
19
Baker, H. F
Beaded ribs in rickets . . . . •
Belly very protuberant, in rickety cases
Billroth on redressement force . . . •
,, ,, statistics of osteotomy
,, ,, supra-condylar osteotomy
Bloodless method, Esmarch's, useful in osteotomy
Bone, simple division recommended .
,, removal of portion undesirable _
,, ,, „ length impaired
„ bent, lengthened by simple division
33
80, 85
81
130
142
149
154
160
160
160
160
Vlll
CONTENTS.
Bones, Macewen on cutting the comparatively soft, of adole-
scents
., once ebiii-uateil after rickets do not again soften from
that disease
may they soften from scorbutus ?
most rapid growth in lower limbs during the earliest
months of life
primitive malformation of, eiToneous . . . .
curvature of, may take place after subsidence of rickety
disease
„ from gravity
,, ,, scorbutus ?
,, ,, phthisis'?
,, ,, atony and paralysis .
wasting of, Mikulicz on .
,, in paralytic in-knee
density of, increased in rickets
Bouvier on iu-knee, as the first stage of rickets
Bow-legged knee curvature ....
Brain, excess of stimulating amusements and pursuits favours
distortion
Breast-milk, absence of ....... .
Broca, views on rickets ........
Brown, Dr. Buckminster, on mechanical treatment
Burdach
143
79
16,83
150
18
79
93
57
57
57
31
18
68
37
89
133
16
Cartilages thickened by undue pressure
,, thinned by diminished pressure
,, C. Reyher on .
CerelDro-spinal system, influence on in-knee
Changes, the mechanical, similar in all forms
Chest flattened and narrowed in rickets
Clavicles arched upwards and forwards in rickets
Compression of limbs, undue, evils of
Condyle, internal enlarged, not a primary cause
,, ,, ,, pathognomonic
,, the normal length of
,, prominent ....
external, deficiency of primary cause . . 19,
,, ,, )) a more common marked con-
dition
„ ,, slight deficiency occasions appreciable dis-
distortion
Confinement, long, hurtful
Congenital in-knee ....
Constitutional conditions in distortion
Creases in rickety thighs .
Crossed-legs distortion
,, j)osition aids cure .
CruveiUiier, J
Curvature of bones from paralysis
muscular contraction
rickets
58
58
59
65
61
81
81
114
4
66
22, 25
25
58, 65
19
153
151
2
21
106
1
133
43
95
66
96
CONTENTS.
IX
Curvature of bones from statical inilueuce
,, ,, ,, innutrition, atrophy
,, of knee outwards
Curves, successive, in scoliosis .
,, ,, rickety limbs .
,, explanation of production
Cyanosis, and in-knee
,, Mikulicz on, as a cause of in-knee
101
12
99
100
lO'J
10, 61
61
D.
Debility, cause of in-knee ......
Deficiency of external condyle . .. . ...
Density of bones increased in rickets
Diet, a too watery, a cause of atonic in-knee
Digestion, weak, often a co-existent atonic ati'ection
Disease, any of knee, may cause the distortion
Distortions, rare amongst oriental and tropical races
Disuse, persistent, influence of .
E.
Eburnation of bones froixi rickets
,, density of bones increased in
,, none in " mollities ossium"
Elasticity of structure
Enamel on teeth, want of in rickets .
Epiphysis of tibia and fibula in rickets
Esmarch, bloodless method in osteotomy
Exercise during treatment
Extremities, the lower, most visibly affected in rickets
„ ,, development of them in rickets more or
less arrested
2, 9
19
57
66
75
2
73
20
57
57
89
145
85
84
140
123
81
82
F.
Fascia lata, its action in bracing the knee .... 53
Fatigue as an exciting cause ....... 53
Femoral diaphysis, changes of, in in-knee .... 53
,, ,, Linhart on ....... 41
„ „ Mikulicz on ...... 55
,, ,, Macewen on 41
,, ,, increased growth ..... 136
,, epiphysis, changes of, Mikulicz on .... 56
Femur, natural adduction of, not a primary cause ... 4
,, and tibia, form of, may aid other causes ... 49
Fevers during convalescence cause of in-knee . . . . 2, 9
Flat-foot, co-existence with in-knee ...... 7
Food, animal, aversion to, often shown by atonic subjects . 75
Foods, unsuitable articles for infants . . . . .67
Foot, inversion or eversion of, in in-knee .... 99, 116
G.
Gap, between external condyle and tibia .... 27. 131
,, modes of filling up ...... 29, 13o, 155
,, nature can fill up even in the adult ..... 30
h
X C0NTKNT8.
PAGE
Gait in iu-kiiee .......... 7
Gentle means, explanation of action 132
Genu-varuna .......... 13
Genu- valgum (see in-knee).
„ not confined to rickets 2, 143
Genu-valgns talipes, spui'ious, with in-knee .... 7
Genu-varus talipes, ,, ,, ,,.... 7
Genu, extrorsuni cui'vatum ....... 12
Gravity, influence of . . . . 2, 8, 15, 36, 49, 65, 78, 188
Gross, Professor ......... 147
Gx'owth, two fast periods of ..... . 16, 19
,, explanation of rapidity at particular periods . 16, 87
,, inordinate rapidity of, cause of distortion . . 10, 75
,, rapid after severe illness, need of rest and good feeding 75
,, does osteotomy impair it ? ...... 158
Guerin, Jules, experiments on large subcutaneous division in
animals useful to men 19, 31, 33, 90
H.
Hand-feeding of infants a cause of atonic in-knee
Hairiness, undue in rickets .....
Hamstring division .......
Harrison .........
Head disposed to be relatively enlarged in rickets
,, may be one-fourth the length of the body in rickets
Height, inordinate cause of distortions
Hips and knees sometimes contracted at birth .
Holden, exaggerated opinion as to normal length of external
condyle
Horse exercise
Hueter, C.
„ pathology ....
,, treatment of in-knee by flexion
Hutchinson, on rachitis ....
Hygiene, neglect of, favours production of in-knee
66
107
127
9
81
81
3
35
22
133
7, 29
40
113
131
68
I.
Infancy, earliest period of, growth most rapid
,, rate of growth during .
In-ankle, with in-knee
In-knee, adiilt, cured without operation
,, definition of .
,, varieties of .
,, from fatigue
,, infantile
,, idiopathic
,, adolescent
,, rachitic
,, statical
,, congenital
,, accommodative
,, paralytic
,, spasm ....
,, atonic ....
16
16
7
30
1
2
18
8, 12
25
8
2, 7, 10
2
2, 5, 8
10
2, 92
2, 10, 95
8, 15, 19
CONTENTS.
XI
In-knee, strumous
,, rheumatic
,, from inordinate stoutness
„ „ „ growth
,, disappearance on bending
,, fevers from debiHty, after
,, never a normal condition
,, influenced by normal anatomic conditions
,, frequency of
,, traumatic
,, from partial luxation of epiphysis
,, with scoliosis, miscalled "lateral curvature
„ outward rotation of leg in
,, with flat-foot
,, ,, ankylosis
,, from carrying heavy weights
,, in cyanosis and atelectasis
,, from excessive use . .
,, morbid anatomy .
,, pathology
,, prevention of
,, from curvature of tibia
,, non-i'achitic, Dr. Shaffer on
,, hereditary influence in
,, cure of, by deposit of bone and cartilage
Intellectual activity of parent in excess a cause
of spine
PAGE
3, 101
3
3
2, 9, 15
5, 56
2,9
3
3, 19
7
8, 62
8
9
6
9
101
10
10
10
14, 44
14
109, 139
20
32
70
51
69
Jenner, Sir W., on the rickety skull .
Johnson, Dr. .......
Joints, less well-knit in some families and races
,, constant fixation to be avoided
104
69
72
135
K.
Knee, mechanically altered relations in
,, hyper-extension of .
Knee joint, opening of, for in-knee
Knock-knee, symptoms of .
21
56
149
77
Langenbeek
Legs, disproportionately short in rickets .
Leg bones, curvature of, augments apparent in-knee
Ligament, internal lateral of knee, elongation of
,, external ,, ,, shortening of
,, ,, Linhart on .
Limb, the soundest, provided only with a maximum
Linhart, morbid anatomy .....
,, on instrumental treatment .
Lister, his antiseptic method available in osteotomy
Little, Louis Stromeyer .....
Locomotion, excess of, a cause ....
Lordosis, not always from rickets
Luxation of patella, partial or complete
. 19,3
. 19, 3
of strength
147
81
90
i, 136
i, 136
39
37
39
123
140
141
69
84
60
XII
rONTKNTS.
M.
Macewen ........
Miilfonnatiou, primitive, of bones theory erroneous
Manipulations, mode of doin^^ ....
Mayer, H
Mechanical appliances .....
,, ,, unsuitable ones
,, treatment, relapses after
^ilikulicz ........
,, on wasting of bones ....
,, ,, cliaufjes in ligaments
,, ,, increased growth of femoral diaphysis
Microscopical conditions .....
Mikromele .......
Milk, fresh or unfresh, important difference between
" Mollifies ossium," nut rickets ....
,, ,, is incurable
^forbid anatomj', obliqiiity of articular surfacos
,, ,, Sandifort ....
„ „ Mayer
,, ,, Mikulicz ....
,, ,, Linhart .....
Muscles, structural shortening of . . .
Muscular contraction of secondary importance .
7, 20
effects
PAGE
20
wo
115
3B, 45
IIG
122
139
35
57
59
13G
21
82
C7
89
89
35
43
46
89
11
95
60
N.
Natural cure by deposit of new bone and cartilage ... 29
Nervous system, disorder of, in in-knee ..... 66
Nodes at the extremities of the long bones in rickets . . 89
Nutrition of tissues, insufficient in atonic in-knee ... 65
,, full, necessary during convalescence from acute
diseases 75
O.
Osteo-pliyt
c fcn-mations in in-knee ....
4
i, 59
., Mikulicz on ...
.
59
,,
,, Sandifort on ...
44
Osteotome
Macewen's ......
.
153
Osteotomy
Annandale ......
148
152
Barwell .......
152
Macewen on ..... .
45, 141
154
relapses after ......
142
Macewen, successes in .
143
necessity after puberty in severest cases .
143
chisel, introduction of, in ...
143
the complement to instruments
145
W. Adams on .
147
Barker on ......
148
Barton Rhea on .... .
147
Grosse, Professor on ....
147
Langenbeck on .....
147
L. Stromcyer Little on .
147
Ogston on
.
152
CONTENTS.
Xlll
Osteotomy, Reeves on . . .
Rupra-condylar, Bilrotli on
,, ,, Macewen's mode of perfovmin
effect of Macewen'fi method
subcutaneous, first performed
unnecessary, often been done
simultaneously in both le.sfs
unnecessary and undesirable in young children
Out-ankle, with in-knee
Out-knee (genu-varum)
,, accommodative .
Over-rapid growth
Over-work and over-use
U<)
149, 155
155
. 149
. 151
. 151
. 144
7
12, 74
74
15
37
P.
Pancoast, Dr. ........
Paralysis, infantile, a cause of in-knee
Patella, luxation of, partial or complete
,, ossification of ..... .
,, wearing away from undue pressure
,, Mikulicz on .
Periods, the two fast growing, of life a cause of distortions
Phokomelie ........
Phthisis, bones wasted in .
Position, extended .
Pressure, undue, thickening of cartilages from .
,, absence of, thinning of cartilages from
Prevention of in-knee ......
Progress, rate of, with mechanical treatment
Puberty, rapid growth about .....
R.
60,
15
147
10
97, 145
101
59
59
19, 75
82
58
133
58
59
109
124, 135
16
Races, oriental, joints less well-knit than in robust Europeans
Rachitic disease exclusively limited to early childhood 18, 34
Redressement force ........
Rest, a means of preventing distortions in chilhood after severe
illness
Reyher, C, on the changes in unused cartilage
Rheumatic in-knee and arthritis deformans
,, extreme in-knee ....
Rickets, a more or less general and specific disease
,, restricted growth during
,, period of its occurrence
,, discussion at the Pathological Society .
,, not a recurrent disease
., Guerin on ..... .
,, intra-uterine .....
,, increased thickness of bones in
,, eburnation ......
,, shortening ......
,, artificial production of .
,, occurs only at the first fast growing period of life
,, nodes at the ends of the long bones, in
,, curving in of lower third of femur
72
78, 89
129
75
59
59, 97
64
80
19
18
18
78
34
35, 82
57
57
80
83
88
89
55
XIV
CONTENTS.
PAGE
Rickets, many foi-ms, formerly described ..... 101
,, ■ dependence should be placed on more than one sign in 105
,, creases in limbs, how produced ..... lOG
,, undue hairiness in ....... 107
,, coustitutioual treatment ...... Ill
,, mechanical and operative treatment .... 113
Rickety subjects more or less stunted .... 19, 81
,, in-knee, diagnosis from atonic .... 20, 71, 88
,, head 81
Rokitausky 43
Rotation outwards of tibia as a cause ..... 52
S.
Sandifort, morbid anatomy
Scarlet-fever, weakness and convalescence as a cause
" Schlottern," or " wobbling" of knee
Schwartz .........
Scissor-leg distortion .......
Scoliosis, analogy of, with atonic in-knee and in-ankle
,, often co-exists at puberty with atonic in-knee
Spasm, infantile, cause of in-knee
Standing, excess of, as a cause .
Statical influence, C. Hueter on
Stoutness, undue, cause of in-knee
Shaffer, Dr. N. M., on rachitic form .
,, ,, ,, value of gentle means of cure
Stromeyer, Ernst
,, Louis .....
Synovitis, in-knee from ....
Subluxation of tibia with in-knee
T.
Tailor's occupation favourable to cm-e
Teeth, condition of, in rickets
Thomas, Dr., observations on fresh and unfresh milk
Tibia often most affected in so-called in-knee
Toes, the, turning in or out in in-knee
Tone, deficiency of, a pathological state
Town, life of, compared with country, as cause
Treatment .......
Trunk, the, relatively long in rickets
31,43
9, 75
27, 42
16
1
99
70
2, 10
69, 74
51
3
32
131
15
15
11,63
101
. 13S
85, 106
67
20
99
40
68
108
86
Vegetables, green, and animal food, aversion to of atonic subjects 75
A^ertebrte comparatively little affected in congenital rickets . 83
Violent method of cure 129
Volkmauu . . . . . . . . . ■ . 7, 18
Von Aramon on congenital in-knee ...... 35
W.
Wasting of bones in phthisis
Watery diet, cause of atonic distortions
Weber, the brothers ....
58
66, 110
38
CONTENTS.
XV
Weights, undue carrying of
Will, influence of
" Wobbling " of knee .
X-knee ....
PAGE
79
20
27, 42, 132
1
LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS.
FIG.
1. Peculiar crossed-leg deformity ...... 1
2. Moderate knock- or in-knee (non-rachitic) .... 4
3. Severe neglected knock- or in-knee (non-rachitic) . . 5
4. Rachitic in-kuees ......... 6
5. Atonic in-knee ......... 9
6. Double outward curvature of lower extremities ... 13
7. Rachitic in-knee and curvature of one leg .... 20
8. Drawing of average femur, with a femur probably rickety . 23
9. Drawing to show the amount required to rectify the greater
length of internal condyle ...... 23
10. Views of the corresponding leg bones ..... 24
11. Moderate atonic in-knee, to show the prominence of internal
condyle .......... 25
12. Natural contour of limbs in atonic in-knee .... 26
13. Morbid anatomy, view of in-knee, from Sandifort . . 44
14. The same, placed by us in the proper relation to exhibit the
same gap, shown in diagram a ..... 44
15. Extreme atonic in-knee, from Mayer ..... 45
16. View of a case called genu- valgum, from Mayer, in which
the principal disorder consisted of abduction and curvature
of the tibia ......... 46
17. The left limb from the same patient after osteotomy, which
had been doubtless more severely affected with iu-knee,
as shown by the obhquity of the articular surfaces . . 46
18. View of out-knee curvature (genu- varum), from Mikulicz . 50
19. ,, the normal relation of femur and tibia ... 50
20. ,, considerable in-knee distortion (genu-valgum) . 50
21. ,, the bones of a considerable in-knee when placed in
their normal relation, to show the manner in which
nature then fills up the gap before alluded to . . . 51
22. Anatomical representation of the relation of the thigh and
leg during over-fatigue and the carrying of heavy weights,
for which we are indebted to Mr. Alexander Shaw . . 53
23. Contains three views from Mikulicz, showing the progressive
increase of the diaphysial portion of the internal and
lower part of the femur, and slightly of the epiphysis . 55
24. Genu-valgoid distortion of knee disease .... 62
25. Complete ankylosis of knee with genu-valgoid deformity . 63
26. Genu-valgoid distortion, taken from the living strumous
patient .......... 63
27. Extreme destruction of the external condyle, &c., from
chronic rheumatism •••.... 64
28. Front view of slight atonic in-knee ..... 71
29. In-knee with hyper-extension on one side, out-knee of the
other, from Macewen ....... 74
30. Extreme in-knee, with local and general rachitis . . 81
XVI CONTENTS.
Flli. FAliK
31. Extreiue rachitic arrested ilevelnpmrnt, wilh in-kuees and
curvatures, from Bouvier ...... 82
3'2, 33. Tyjncal distortion of the epiphysis of tibia and til)ula . 84
34. Lt)rd()sis, from atonic rehixation ? ..... 85
35. Shght paralytic f«;• excellence.
It is desired in this section to draw fully the attention
of surgeons to the fact that genu-valgum is an alteration in
the form and relation of parts of the knee joint which is apt
to accompany several, indeed the majority, of disordered
states to which the knee joint is liable, either in their early
or in their later stages.
We lay it down as an axiom that in any disorder or
disease of the knee structures, active or passive, through
which either the relations of parts or the equilibrating
forces are disturbed, the condition or distortion termed
genu-valgum to a greater or less extent will arise unless
interfered with by art.
Hence it may be said that there are almost as many
clinical varieties of genu-valgum as there are knee affections,
and further that the distortion may arise even in a perfectly
healthy knee, when owing to disorder in one limb the sound
one is over-laden and over-worked.
In-knee may exist at birth ; it may originate in the one-
year-old fast-growing infant from the want of mother's
milk, from improper and from too watery a diet, without
rachitis ; it may depend upon unequivocal rachitis, upon
infantile paralysis and spasm. It arises (without rachitis)
less frequently in the later years of childhood, when the
child has been debilitated by measles, hooping-cough, or
VARIETIES. 3
scarlet fever, and has been permitted during convalescence
to resort too soon to standing or prolonged exertion. On
the approach of puberty in both sexes during another fast-
growing period, say from the twelfth to the sixteenth year,
or later, liability to the distortion again sets in. At any
period before adult age the occurrence of white swelling
(strumous synovitis) is apt to present, besides contraction
of the joint in the flexed position, manifest inward inclina-
tion of the knee with corresponding eversion of the leg
(genu contractum et valgoideum) . With advancing years the
rheumatic knee, especially in subjects who were regarded as
strumous in their youth, besides becoming contracted in the
flexed position, is apt to assume a distinctly valgoid direction,
with marked pain in the neighbourhood of the internal lateral
ligament and internal condyle, especially when attempts to
use the limb are made, and the tendency to distortion is not
checked by art.
The author has seen several cases of considerable genu-
valgum in tall, robust adolescents, and adults affected with
undue stoutness (polysarcia), inordinate height and weight
having apparently contributed to the distortion.
This frequent liability to the complaint under so many
conditions does not spring, as often asserted, from the
natural form and relation of the component parts of the
limb, and especially of the articulating surfaces of the knee
joint, for in the normal state, a well-knit knee, the active
and passive structures, the moving and resisting powers,
are so well balanced that the most perfect symmetry and a
large reserve of capability for use beyond the average use
exists.
It can no more be admitted of genu-valgum than of
congenital club-foot, as has been stated by some surgeons,
that every child born into the world has a certain degree
of, or a certain tendency to, both those affections. All that
can be admitted is that when disorder or disease of the
IN-KNEE DISTORTION.
knee or foot takes place and distortion ensues, the form of
the distortion will 1)e determined in a certain direction,
rather than in other directions, by the natural anatomical
relations and functions.
In the causation of genu-valgum the natural greater
size of the internal condyle, the naturally adducted position
of the femur in relation to the trunk and to the tibia, the
asserted naturally less developed condition of the external
articular suface of the til)ia, the known greater physiological
range of the abduction of the tibia over adduction in some
positions of the knee, cannot be regarded as primary causes.
We equally deny the primary influence of contraction
of any muscle, e. g. the biceps femoris, in producing the
distortion, except where its origin has been spasm.
The annexed woodcut figures of tolerably severe adole-
FiG. 2.
Moderate knock-kiiee, non-rachitic.
DEGBEES. O
scent genu-valgum will convey to the uninformed reader
a better idea of the distortion than words. It consists of
undue inversion of the thighs to the extent that the knees
may touch (fig. 2) or overlap one another (fig. 3); the
Fig. 3.
Severe atonic neglected Jnwcli-'knee, arrived at the adolescent stage.
legs are more or less widely abducted as regards the thighs,
and consequently are separated. In extreme cases the
particular change of relation of the thigh and legs is so
considerable that the limb may entirely cross, sometimes
to the extent that the right foot presents where the left
should do, and rice versa. As the distortion augments, the
individual when attempting locomotion sinks from the
upright posture, so that considerable bending of knees
IN-KNEE DISTORTION.
becomes apparent. This bending of the knees diminishes
the deformity. The disappearance of the deformity on full
bending the knee is a characteristic symptom even of genu-
valgum in the severest forms. In the earUer stages excessive
extension of the knee (hyper-extension to 10 or 15 degrees)
may also be present.
It will be observed further, in fig. 4, that not only
marked abduction of the legs has taken place, but that the
Fig. 4.
Efichitic in-lniee durinfl childhood. In this drawing one foot inclines to
I'anis, the other to valr/us.
tibias are rotated outwards on their perpendicular axes.
The distortion, consisting of knee inversion, leg abduction,
and outward rotation, is greater in the left than in the
right limb. The internal condyles may be felt and seen to
be unduly prominent ; that of the left leg, which has been
passed in front of the right, is strongly marked in the
drawing. The external condyle is concealed in the charac-
teristic hollow or angle, which obtains in genu-valgum on
IN- OB OUT-ANKLE CO-EXISTING. 7
the external aspect of the knee. Observers differ as to the
state of the ankle in knock-knee, some stating it to be
affected with valgus, others that it has a tendency to varus.
It would be more exact to say that sometimes the foot '
exhibits more or less valgoid tendency, at other times a
varoid tendency. As a rule, in young children, the inner
ankle will be found to have more or less sunk, and the
point of the foot to be proportionately turned out ; in older
patients the foot, owing to the efforts of the patient to ease
the ankle when walking, may assume the reverse position.
Even young children, who are brought for consultation by
parents because "they turn their toes in," when seated,
are found on examination to have incipient knock-knee and
flat-foot (spurious valgus). The gait is in all stages unsteady
and unsightly; in advanced cases the upright attitude is
impossible, and walking is effected with bent knees ; some-
times attempts at locomotion are quite given up. The
individual is then obliged to confine himself to sedentary
pursuits ; the resulting want of exercise leaves the limbs
to the further disturbing influence of the unused thigh
muscles, which results in aggravation of the original
deformity. In-knee is not only a very frequent distortion,
but, as already stated, one which is induced by primary
causes of very dissimilar characters.
H. Mayer,* Volkmann,! C. Hueter,t and Mikulicz, §
describe two forms of the complaint : that from softening
of bones — the rachitic ; and that which arises from undue
* H. Mayer : ' Die Osteotomie ; lUustrii-te Medicinisclie Zeitung.'
July, 1852.
f Yolkmann : ' Hanclbucli tier AUgemeineu und speciellen Chinirgie,'
von Pitlia und Bilrotli, Erlangen, 1872.
I C. Hueter : ' Klinik der Gelenkki-ankheiten mit Einscliluss der
Ortliopiidie,' 1876.
§ Mikulicz : ' Arcliiv fiir Klinisclie Clnrui'gie,' von Dr. B. von
Langenbeck, vol. xxi., 1879.
8 IN-KNEE DISTORTION.
augmentation of the work which the knee joint has to
perform when bearing the weight of the trunk, and
especially when carrying heavy loads — the idiopathic, or
statical form. They mostly regard the rachitic form as
originating in childhood, and the statical that which
originates in adolescence. Volkmaun coincides with our
views, that idiopathic or statical in-knee occurs in infants
beginning to walk; and in adolescents, Volkmann says
between the ages of two and four years, and between
fourteen and seventeen. It will be seen further on, that
we have frequently met with the idiopathic or atonic form
during the first year of infant life.
Many observers have described congenital knock-knee ;
and C. Hueter, oj;. cit., p. 263, refers to " a kind of traumatic
form," caused by accidental dislocation of the epiphysis of
the tibia in early childhood.
Our experience enables us to affirm with confidence
that the distortion may originate under several other very
different predisposing conditions, all operating to add
valgoid knee, though not an equal degree of it, to the pre-
existing or co-existing disorder or contraction.
Congenital genu-valgum is rare and slight in amount,
and is commonly rachitic ; sometimes it is due to the same
cause which produces co-existent congenital varus, viz.,
convulsive muscular contraction (retraction musculaire of
Guerin). Gravity, in its ordinary sense, cannot affect the
foetus in the same manner that it influences the fast-growing
infant trying to stand and walk. The rachitic foetal limbs,
however, if not modifiable in utero by gravity, are probably
sometimes susceptible of external influences, e.g., pressure
through the uterine walls of the neighbouring maternal
organs, and the action of their own muscles.
The following is the arrangement of the non-congenital
clinical varieties of genu-valgum we have adopted : —
a. Atonic, idiopathic, statical or uncomplicated genu-
ATONIC IN-KNEE.
valgum, not rachitic, in infants hand-fed upon improper
and too watery diet before or when beginning to walk.
h. As in older, strong-limbed children who had for one
or more years walked perfectly well until they became
affected with general debility followed by genu-valgum, as
a sequela of scarlet, gastric, and other fevers ; too early
return to the use of the limbs in such persons having
engendered weak or in-knees, sometimes accompanied with
other distortions caused by premature use of trunk and
limbs, such as scoliosis and flat-foot. See fig. 5.
Fig. 5.
Atonic or idiopathic in-knee,from debility on resuming exercise too soon after acute
illness, not racldtic. From Harrison, on ' Sinnal Diseases,' London, 1827.
c. As in adolescents, not rachitic, suffering from general
debility caused by too rapid growth, late hours, too much
10 IN-KNEE DISTORTION.
standing, and too much carrying of heavy weights, as in
pursuing particular mechanical occupations, often aggra-
vated amongst the very poor by insufficient feeding.
d. As in children congenitally weak, with congenital
heart, vascular and capillary disease (cyanosis), or lung
disease (atalectasis) ; rarely from non-congenital heart
disease.
e. From over-use of a sound knee, or from a previously
sound knee having accommodated itself to a short opposite,
or to a weak, wasted neighbour.
/. As in over-fed, over- stout, fat, heavy infants ; over-
stout and over-tall adolescents.
In addition to these varieties of genu-valgum, as
deduced from difference of origin, all, however, being alike
in the circumstance that the genu-valgum — the morbid
inward inclination of the knee — is the only knee joint
affection, there is a series of knee distortions in which
inward inclination — a genu-valgoid direction — of the joint
is an important and striking element, though not the more
important part of the disorder. They might be termed
sub-forms of genu-valgum, and those forms a to /, already
defined, in which the inward inclination of the knee con-
stitutes the whole of the deformity, might be termed true
or genuine in-knee ; and those in which the genu-valgum
is the minor part of the affection might be termed false or
si)urious in-knee. This denomination of cases would cor-
respond Avith the manner in which we speak of true or
complete (meaning bony) ankylosis, and false or spurious
(meaning fibrous) ankylosis ; or as we speak of true talipes
valgus (meaning congenital or complete) and spurious talipes
valgus (meaning rachitic talipes valgus, or flat-foot).
g. For convenience sake here we will drop the expression
sub-form, and speak of the next variety as the paralytic or
spastic one, arising from partial paralysis or spasm of the
muscles moving the knee joint. These cases, except as to
VARIETIES. 11
the disordered innervation, are closely allied to the former
varieties a to/.
h. From rachitis. It will be hereafter shown that in
this form cm^vature of the thigh and leg bones plays as
important a part in the deformity as the articular knee
structures, if not a more important part.
i. From rheumatic, strumous and traumatic knee
affections. In synovitis, whether rheumatic, strumous, or
the effect of accident, the often long-continued distention of
the joint and the impairment of joint structures immediately
due to the congestion or inflammation, are the causes of
weakness, and relaxation of the connection of the bones
with each other, upon which is apt to follow contraction in
the bent position, sub-luxation,* and a genu-valgoid form of
the joint with abduction of the tibia.
It will now be seen that each of these primary causes of
in-knee, except e, which results from "accommodation,"
which is an example of the complaint having been produced
by a cause acting outside of the affected limb, operate by
lessening the tone or strength of some or all of the active
and passive structures of the joint itself, — the muscles,
the ligaments, and the bones. The secondary or determining
causes are, as will be seen, the form and bearing of the
articular surfaces of the femur and tibia upon each other,
and the action of gravity, &c., of the weight of the head,
upper extremities and trunk upon the enfeebled and
loosened joint, modified in the case of rickets by the
peculiar form acquired by the thigh and leg bones in
severe rachitic instances of this deformity.
From this enumeration of the clinical and pathological
varieties of in-knee it will be understood why neither con-
■•' The important and miscliievous part performed bj'^ sub-luxation
of the tibia in knee joint diseases was, it is beheved, first pointed out
by the author. See lectures on " Contractions and Deformities " in the
' Lancet,' 1842 — 3 ; and also in ' Treatise on Ankylosis,' London, 1843.
12 IN- KNEE DISTORTION.
currence with the views of those recent authors who divide
the cases into two forms (the rachitic and statical), or with
C. Hueter, who adds a third form (the traumatic), nor still
less with those who see in the distortion of in-knee a
single form (that of rachitic origin), can be arrived at.
When in-knee is looked at from an etiological and con-
stitutional point of view, it will be evident that all cases,
including the rachitic ones, might equally be called statical ;
that in all, the weight of the body being attempted to be
inefficiently borne by the limb causes the passive structures
to yield beneath its influence.
The principal conclusions at which we have arrived in
this section are that there are several clinically and patho-
logically well-marked varieties of in-knee, and that of these
varieties the rachitic is not the most frequent.
OUTWARD CURVATUEE OF KNEE.
Cases of an opposite form of distortion of the knee, see
fig. 6, termed outward yielding or curvature of it (genu-
extrorsum*), are occasionally met with, mainly in rachitic
subjects. It is much less frequent than genu-valgum, or
inward inclination. The greater frequency of the latter is
apparently due to the natural inward direction of the shaft
of the femur and condyles.
The immediate or mechanical cause of outward knee
inclination has not been satisfactorily explained. It is com-
monly of rickety origin, and is combined with curvature of
the femur and tibia. When one knee is inclined inwards
and the other outwards, the latter appears as if it were the
result of accommodation. It may also occur independently
of rickets, as when one limb is shortened from paralysis,
=^ We were the first to name and describe geuu-extrorsum curvatum
at the Royal Ortboptedic Hospital in 1839.
OUTWAED KNEE DISTOETION.
13
knee disease, or accident, the other limb yielding outwards
for accommodation purposes.
The annexed figure exhibits a case
Fig. 6.
of considerable outward curvature of
doubtful origin. There exists obvious
curvature of all the long bones of both
lower extremities, but they are dispro-
portionately long, the reverse of the
shortened limbs of a rickety subject. The
individual had not the head and face of
rachitis, nor were other signs of former
rickets present. He had a puny chest
and lanky legs, common to the ill-fed
fast-growing atonic cases of distortion
(such as genu- valgum atonicum), and
may have followed an avocation which
had predisposed to distortion. It is well
known, for example, that jockeys are apt
to become bow-legged. As the lower
extremities are comparatively long com-
pared with the trunk, it is probable that
the over-growth and the curvature took
place during the most active period of growth, from about
the age of twelve or thirteen to sixteen or seventeen.
The disproportion is so unusually great as to suggest
the idea that it was due to excess in growth (deformity
from excess), with proportionate weakness and liability to
yield to gravity, and to any undue retention of the limbs in
a particular position.
Double outward curva-
ture of loicer extre-
mities.
PATHOLOGY AND MOEBID ANATOMY OF IN-
KNEE, AND ITS VAEIETIES.
We have already stated (pp. 2, 11) that every disordered
condition of the structures composing and surrounding the
knee joint, the integrity of which is necessary for the due
performance of its functions, may give rise more or less
completely to knock-knee.
The essential first evil consequence of disordered action
is a weakening of the naturally strong connection which
exists between the femur and tibia. If the weakening affect
the ligaments the joint is at the mercy of the muscles, the
stronger ones asserting their supremacy ; and if the indi-
vidual is able to attempt to stand or walk the influence of
gravity becomes irresistible, the joint yields to it, constituting
displacement or distortion. If the primary evil be in the
muscles it will consist of either augmented power (spasm)
or diminished power (paralysis), or a modification of that
less considered and less completely defined property known
as tone.
We have shown that from disordered, or probably rather
from insufficient nutrition of tissues, both ligaments and
muscles suffer from diminished tone and strength, and that
genu -valgum arises more often from loss of tone than from
any other single cause. Nevertheless pathologists, when
treating of this distortion and of distortions in general, ex-
cept as regards scoliosis, miscalled lateral curvature, have
seldom taken atony of fibrous and muscular structures into
account. The popular term weakness has taken its place.
RELATION TO OTHER DISEASES. 15
Atonic genu-valgum is related to several other disorders
in which weakness of fibrous structure (including muscular
weakness, short of paralysis) exists, e.g., prolapsus ani,
prolapsus uteri, ectropium senile, hernia, fiat-foot, &c.
Those complaints which depend upon muscular weakness
(atony) have more attracted the notice of pathologists than
those in which weakness of ligaments plays the more im-
portant part.* This oversight as to the important part
played by atony of fibrous structures and muscles is partly
due to the positive material tendency of pathology during
the last four or five decades. That which is apt to be reco-
vered from does not afi"ord material for the scalpel or micro-
scope (without resort to the emporte-inece, a proceeding little
to be commended and rarely employed). We do not despair
that, attention being drawn to the subject of atony of fibrous
and muscular structures, more will hereafter be known re-
specting its essential nature.
Gravity usually tells unfavourably against atonic struc-
tures; consequently in the case of atonic distortions the
ankle joint suffers most from this cause (flat-foot), next the
knee (genu-valgum), next the hip (certain waddling gait,!
when not caused by rickety change in the neck of femur),
lastly, the spinal column (scoliosis).
As an instance of imperfect gait from want of tone of
parts, we may cite the hobbledehoy movement of a fast-
growing adolescent boy, one who has "outgrown his
strength," the power of co-ordinating his muscles (apart
from a possible touch of chorea) has been outdone by the
over-rapid elongation of the bones of the lower extremities
proper to this period of life. We have occasionally been
consulted as to adolescent girls in whom, as in the above
class of boys, we could discover no distinct disease, yet the
* Consult Louis F. Stromeyer : Platt-fuss ' Beitrage zur Operativen
Orthopaedik,' Hanover, 1838. Ernst Stromeyer : ' Ueber Atonie
fibroser Gewebe,' Wurzburg, 1840.
16
IN-KNEB DISTORTION.
gait was extremelywanting in steadiness and firmness, some-
times amounting in the minds of the attendants to lame-
ness of hip. It is a question in some such cases of want of
tone in the hgaments and muscles attached to the rapidly
enlarging pelvis, analogous to the hobbledehoy gait caused by
rapid elongation of the bones of the boy's lower extremities.
We have elsewhere stated that we have known even a girl
grow six inches in a year, just before pubert3^ The case
was one of incipient scoliosis. We had periodically measured
her during the year, as an aid in determining the pro-
bability of cure.
Hitherto it has not been sufficiently noted that there are
two periods in the age of man at which growth is extra-
ordinarily rapid. The first period is from birth until the
age of nine months ; the second period is at the approach
of, or during, puberty or adolescence, say from the tenth or
twelfth to the fourteenth or sixteenth year, more or less.
We are indebted to Burdach * and Schwartz for precise
details on this interesting head. Schwartz watched a child
which grew in the
First week
H
in.
,, month
2
3 lines.!
Second ,,
1
1 line.
Third „
7 lines.
Fourth „
11 „
Fifth „
6 „
Sixth „
7 „
Seventh ,,
1
Eighth and n
mth month
H
■■' Carl F. Burdacli : 1880, ' Die Physiologie als Erfaliruugswissen-
schaft,' 3 Band, p. 236.
•j- We were led to enquire into this subject through having repeat-
edly observed how very often in the treatment of congenital varus in
infants during "the month" it became necessary to exchange the
splints used for longer ones.
GBOWTH DURING INFANCY AND ADOLESCENCE.
17
.
3 in.
.
2 „
.
2 „
.
2 „
.
1 „
.
1 „
If in
the first seven
22 inches, it will in-
so that its length increased in nine months about one-
third, say 8^ German inches.*
The average rate of growth in the infant is estimated to
be 6 to 8 German inches during the first nine months, or
from 18 or 20 inches to 24 or 26 inches. Burdach says that
growth is during the
Second year
Third
Fourth
Fifth
Sixth
Seventh
at which period there is often a stop,
years the length has increased 20 or
crease in the second seven years only 10 or 12 inches, and
attains in the male 5|- feet. The weight which at seven
years is 37 lbs. German, increases at the age of fourteen
22 or 25 lbs.
Adolescence extends from puberty to completion of
growth, i.e., until sixteenth to twenty-third year in the male,;
and fourteenth to twentieth in the female. Growth at the
beginning of this period proceeds rapidly, and, especially ini
cases where it had not greatly advanced, makes a fresh start.
During adolescence the growth is from 10 to 12 inches. W^
believe that in the male growth may not stop until the age
of twenty-five. It is known that ossification is not com-
pleted before thirty. It was stated at the meeting, in 1881,
of the British Association for the Advancement of Science,
that growth continues until the age of forty ; probably in
width only.
These two periods of most rapid growth are, we venture
to say, predetermined physiologically : the first to hasten
* n . , 128
* German inch = vtt?
loo
1-098 English.
•9519 EngUsh. German pound
56
51
18 IN-KNEE DISTORTION.
the infant's fitness for independent locomotion and self-help
to food, when the mother's poAver of lactation may in the
normal com'se he expected to cease, and the infant's ahso-
lutc dependence on the mother for hoth locomotion and food
shall terminate ; the second period is, we consider, allied to
sexual development, and the [ipparent necessity of then more
rapidly completing the frame of the individual of either sex
to fit it for propagation of the race, for a life of lahour, and
its defence against dangers.
Volkmann (oj). cit.) applies the term idiopathic to denote
what we have termed the atonic form of genu-valgum, and
remarks that it occurs almost without exception only be-
tween the second and fourth and between the fourteenth
and seventeenth years. He appears to attribute it to abso-
lute overloading, whilst we attribute it in infancy and early
childhood, as a rule, to relative overloading of the joint
which is relaxed from atonic causes. In adolescents it is
probable that the carrying of heavy weights, fatigue, and
long hours of work, have the principal share in its pro-
duction, favoured in fast-growing lads by insufficient diet,
and consequent weakness of tissue. Volkmann is the only
observer who, besides ourselves, as far as we have ascer-
tained, recognises the fact of atonic genu-valgum taking
place mainly at two epochs of life. We have never seen a
rachitic in-knee produced after the age of five years. Pre-
vious observers and statistical* enumerators speak of cases
of rickets originating during adolescence, and even adult
age. They have often, doubtless, included under the head
of rickets, as originating during adolescence, cases which
had commenced in early childhood, and cases of the simjAe
loeak in-knee of early infancy and adolescence, all of which
are liable to become aggravated through statical influences
during rapid growth. Simple in-knee without unequivocal
■■' See the "Discussion ou Eickets" at the Pathological Societj',
December, 1880, in the medical journals of the period.
INFLUENCE OF GROWTH. 19
signs of rickets may originate at any period between birth
and the completion of growth, but occm-s by far the most
frequently in early infancy and during the progress of
puberty and adolescence, corresponding, in fact, with the
two rapid periods of growth to which we have alluded.
Simple or weak in-knee occurs independently of the pre-
sence of signs of rickets. Eickety in-knee is accompanied
with constitutional and local signs of rickets elsewhere ;
rachitic bone curvatures, for example, rickety teeth, rickety
face and skull, restricted growth. (See rickety in-knee.)
Simple in-knee from weakness attacks tall children, and
does not lead to shortening of their stature. Rickety genu-!
valgum is met with only in individuals stunted from rickets,
i. e., shortened more or less according to the intensity of
that disease.*
As regards the proximate causes of genu-valgum and
their anatomical results, the opinions which have had more
or less temporary currency during the last forty years may
be summarised by saying that some observers, through not
having taken a comprehensive view of knock-knee, or from
not having had sufficient opportunities of studying the dis-
tortion in all its forms and stages, have singled out one fact,
often not a constant one, in the history of the complaint, to
which alone they have attributed its origin. Thus one writer
has attributed it to elongation of the internal lateral liga-
ment of the knee joint ; another to shortening of the external
lateral ligament ; another to contraction of the outer ham-
string, muscle and tendon ("retraction musculaire"), — a
great number of writers have put down enlargement of the
internal condyle of the femur as the immediate cause.
Gradually deficiency of the external condyle has obtained a
share of the etiologist's attention. Finally, it is acknow-
ledged that when the distortion has long existed, deficiency
* See also paper by the author in tlie ' Transactions of tlie Inter-
national Medical Congress,' London, 1881.
20
IN-KNEE DISTORTION.
of the external condj^le and. enlargement of the internal
condyle co-exist. In our opinion these several conditions
grow up jxiri j^assu, or successively, and appear as factors
of the deformity. The time has arrived when it may be said
that the majority of the above conditions are but conse-
quences of a common cause, — a weakening of the j&brous
structures and bones affecting the knee joint, which becomes
statically disturbed by gravity, by passive muscular action,
and may even be influenced by the will of the patient in his
efforts to eflect locomotion in the least uneasy manner when
the distortion has reached the highest stage ; and through
inability of the patient to take any exercise the members
may become surrendered to the passive adaptive shortening
of muscles, and get more or less rigidly fixed in the deformed
state.
One of our ablest surgeons, author of a ' Monograph on
Genu- valgum,' Macewen, attributes it exclusively to rickets,
and in particular to curvature of the
lower end of the femur and hyper-
trophy of the internal condyle and
adjacent part of the shaft. It may
here be remarked that curvature of
the tibia is sometimes a more promi-
nent fact in rickety genu-valgum (see
fig. 7) than femoral curvature, or
inward inclination of the knee joint
itself.
We refer knock-knee in all its
forms primarily to relative or abso-
lute weakness and relaxation of the
structures composing and surround-
ing the knee joint, the ordinary state
of perpendicularity of the whole limb being disturbed
through the weight of the head, upper extremities and
trunk being too great to be properly borne by the enfeebled
Fig. 7.
Racliitic (lemi-vahjuiit and
curvature confined to one
le