'l^ College of 3$f^v^icmm anli burgeons ilibrarp Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2010 with funding from Open Knowledge Commons http://www.archive.org/details/physiologicalillOObuch PHYSIOLOGICAL ILLUSTRATIONS ORGAN OF HEARING. PHYSIOLOGICAL ILLUSTRATIONS OF THE ORGAN OF HEARING, MORE PARTICULARLY OF THE SECRETION OF CERUMEN, AND ITS EFFECTS IN RENDERING AUDITOR V PERCEPTION ACCURATE AND ACUTE ; WITH FURTHER REMARKS ON THE TREATMENT OF DIMINUTION OF HEARING, ARISING FROM IMPERFECT SECRETION, &C. BEING A SEQUEL TO THE GUIDE, AND TO THE ILLUSTRATIONS OF ACOUSTIC SURGERY. By THOMAS BUCHANAN, C. M. MEMBER OF THE UNIVERSITY OF GLASGOW ; MEMBER OF THE WERNERIAN NATURAL HISTORY SOCIETY OF EDINBURGH ; HONORARY AND CORRESPONDING MEMBER OF THE MEDICO»CHIRURGICAL SOCIETY OF THE UNIVERSITY OF GLASGOW ; MEMBER OF THE ROYAL MEDICAL SOCIETY, AND CORRESPONDING MEMBER OF THE PHRENOLOGICAL SOCIETY, EDINBURGH, &C. AUTHOR OF THE GUIDE, AND OF THE ILLUSTRATIONS OF ACOUSTIC SURGERY, AND SURGEON TO THE HULL DISPENSARY FOR DISEASES OF THE EYE AND EAR. LONDON : PUBLISHED BY LOXGMAN, REES, ORME, BROWN AND GREEN. 1828.
-
burgh Philosophical Journal, January, 182L
47
circle in the meatus, and at the same time promote the
secretion of healthy cerumen.
After repeated trials I composed a preparation which I
have termed Unguentum Auriculares^* and which has
been of more temporary benefit to patients with diminu-
tion of hearing', arising from imperfect secretion accom-
panied with Hirsutus Tubulus, than any medicine which
I have used.
The first person on whom I tried this new preparation
was aa old soldier, who had been almost deaf several
years. He had been stationed in the island of
St. Domingo, in the year 1795, when after being re-
viewed, he laid himself down on the damp grass, and
caught a severe cold, which was followed by almost total
deafness. Being an excellent soldier, every effort was
made by various medical gentlemen to restore his hear-
ing, but in vain. He was afterwards discharged, and
at the time when he applied to me, subsisted on a small
pension and the product of his labour as a shoemaker.
The following statement of his case is taken from the
Journal. " Hull^ 25th Jaly^ 1826. Richard Potter, aged
seventy years, has been under treatment upwards of two
weeks ; has had the injection applied, and taken decoc-
* For the Formula of which, see Appendix,
48
tion without receiving much benefit. Applied this day the
Unguentum Auricular es^ and gave the nervine draught.
Patient heard distinctly when spoken to in a low tone of
voice, within . fifteen minutes after the ointment was
applied and the medicine taken."
•
Several patients aflfected with the same complaint
were treated in a similar manner, and the restoration of
their hearing was eflfected as speedily as in the above
case.
From these fortunate circumstances I was induced to
send to Mr. J — n, mentioned in page 43, in order to try
the powers of this excellent preparation on him. He
arrived in town when I was visiting some patients, and
one of my pupils, who was in attendance, spoke to him,
and although the young gentleman shouted as loud as
he could, he could scarcely make himself heard by
the patient. As soon as I arrived, Mr. J. was taken
into the surgery, and while my eldest pupil supported
his head in the most favourable position, I extracted the
greater part of the strong hairs from the meatus, and
then applied the ointment with a camel-hair pencil,
so as to form an artificial tubular circle.
The effect was so instantaneous and satisfactory, that
I called the pupil into the room who had spoken to him
49
on his arrival, in order to witness the resuH of the appli-
cation, and who expressed as much astonishment as the
patient did of satisfaction. I then took Mr. J. into
the apartment appropriated to the Dispensary, where
upwards of a dozen patients were seated, all of whom
viewed the case with unfeigned satisfaction ; for in him,
they beheld a pledge of their future restoration. *
In order to melt the ointment so that it may be applied
with a small brush as described, and at the same time
the preparation may lose as little as possible of its stimu-
lating qualities, I generally heat a small plate, and place
a little of the ointment on it, immediately previous to
application. This ointment should be prepared, if pos-
sible, just before application, otherwise, its effects are
much diminished ; and if exposed to the atmosphere for
any length of time, it becomes quite inert, owing- to the
volatile particles being easily dissipated.
I have thus shewn, that if a patient affected with
diminution of hearing arising from imperfect secretion,
fSecretio Imperfecta] were to take the draught men-
tioned,j' and a preparation containing- the properties of
* Oue of these patients was upwards of fifty years of age, and during tlie last
twenty years had great diminution of hearing ; on the application of the
Unguenta, (No. 1. and No. 2. mixed) so as to form the tubular circle, the patient
could hear distinctly in the space of ten minutes after the operation,
t For the Formula of which, see Appendix.
H
50
healthy cerumen were to be applied in the manner
described, so as to form a tubular circle, the hearing-
would be restored ; but the patient would be unable to
hear for a few minutes after the operation, until the
stimulus of the medical preparation had excited the
nervous fasciculi, in, and around the tube, so as to excite
the action of the membrana tympani, in order that it
might accommodate itself to the pulsations, and thence
transmit the undulatory vibrations to the sentient parts of
the organ.
The absorption of the resilient pulsations of sound,
will be speedily effected by means of the medicated
tubular circle, and consequently, accurate vibrations of
the membrana tympani take place. But if, instead of
the medicated preparation, healthy cerumen, recently
extracted, were to be applied to the dry tube, the patient
would be more quickly restored to his hearing, than by
any imitation, however accurately prepared ; and the
hearing would continue as long as the stimulus of the
application existed.
The objection to this mode of treatment would be, the
difficulty of procuring a sufficient quantity of healthy
cerumen recently extracted. And likewise the danger
there might be of communicating to the patient, any
disease with which the person might be affected, from
51
whom the cerumen was extracted, or, at least convey
some peculiarity of diathesis to contaminate, or perhaps
destroy the healthy secreting power of the ceruminous
glands.
Even the simple act of washing the meatus with an
injection of tepid water, will cause a partial, but tem-
porary restoration of hearing ; provided no more fluid
remain in the tube, than that which is necessary to lubri-
cate the meatus. The tepid water stimulating the ceru-
minous glands partially, and dissolving the cerumen that
may be in, or which may be squeezed out of the ducts,
by the action of elongating the auricle during the opera-
tion of cleaning the meatus, may cause partial excretion,
and this excretion forming an aqua-ceruminous tubular
circle, is the cause of the temporari/ improvement of
hearing, sometimes observable after the operation of
syringing the meatus has been performed.
But if the medicated, or pyrolignous injection,* were
used, it would be still more powerful than that of
tepid water, and if continued, and assisted by medicine,
effect healthy action in the parts, so as to produce secre-
tion and excretion, improve, and ultimately restore the
ceruminous tubular circle.
* For the Formula of which, see Illustrations of Acoustic Surgery, page 103.
h2
52
As all glutinous aromatic substances are more or less
volatile, according- to the greater or lesser quantity of
odoriferous particles contained in them, and the degree of
heat to which they may be exposed ; so it will be found,
that the cerumen when volatilized and thrown off by the
heat of the parts in the healthy subject, serves likewise
another useful purpose, as well as those mentioned, and
which will be explained when we recollect the situation
and structure of the membrana tympani, as has been
already described.*
The existence of the membrana tympani, is so essential
to the arrangement of the healthy organ, that when
destroyed either by disease or accident, no contrivance
hitherto invented, has been able to preserve the tym-
panum effectually from the baneful effects of a moist,
cold atmosphere, when the parts have been long exposed
to its influence. •]■
* For a description of the membrana tympani in the human subject, see page 8
of this work.
f The destruction of the membrana tympani, may be effected by the process of
ulceration, the introduction of foreign bodies, or ruptured, sometimes, but rarely,
by the concussion or intensity of atmospheric undulations, produced by the firing
of cannon ; but in all cases, the destruction or even partial loss of this membrane,
is productive of consequences fatal to perfect hearing. I have frequently seen
patients who have heard remarkably acute, in whom the membrana tympani of
one ear was destroyed, but it was only by means of the healthy ear, that this acuteness
qfhearinff was effected.
53
Inflammation and ulceration, are the frequent eon-
sequences of exposure to cold moist winds ; and if the
indication of cure be not clearly understood, and means
adapted to prevent the progress of disease in its incipient
stage, irremediable destruction of the parts will, perhaps,
ultimately follow, accompanied with Inhahilitas, the
most hopeless and deplorable of all diseases that affect
this organ *
The destruction of the membrana tympani has, how-
ever, been mentioned by authors as trivial, and in no
way affecting or diminishing the hearing ; but on the
contrary, that those persons in whom the membrane
was destroyed, had notwithstanding, retained their
perfect hearing.
Sir Everard Home, in his " Additional remarks '^ on
Sir Astley Cooper's paper, " On the effects which take
place from the destruction of the membrana tympani,^'-]-
asserts, " that in cases in which the membrana tympani
has been destroyed, the air is capable of acting with
sufficient force on the stapes^ to communicate vibrations
to it, and to produce on the internal organ, the necessary
effect for perfect hearings is completely ascertained by
* See the Synoptical Table of Diseases of the Human Ear, in the Guide, and in
the Illustrations of Acoustic Surgery.
t See Philosophical Transactions, 1800.
54
Mr. Cooper's observations/'* If this statement of
Sir Everard's were correct, there would be little use for
the membrana tympani, and its beautiful muscular struc-
ture, by which it accommodates itself to the great variety
of sound. But unfortunately for the accuracy of Sir
Everard's " additional remarks,'^ Sir Astley, in his state-
ment of the case, allows that in Mr. P. there " was a slight
degree of deafness ;^^ and afterwards adds, "Ae in-
formed me, that in a voyage to the East Indies, while
others, when ships were hailed at sea, could catch words
with accuracy, his organ of hearing received only an
indistinct impression"^ and that in Mr. A.'s case, the
" defect of hearing in the diseased organ was somewhat
greater "
That the power of the undulations of sound may
be increased by the speaker, so as to cause the person to
hear the words spoken to him, even when the membrana
tympani is destroyed, I have no doubt. I have tried it
myself, and succeeded. But could the person to whom
I spoke, be said to have perfect hearing, because I
raised the tone of my voice when speaking to him, and
by that means the pulsations of sound became strength-
* Some additional remarks to the foregoing, on the mode of hearing in cases
where the membrana tympani has been destroyed. By Everard Home, Esq.
Philosophical Transactions, 1800.
f An excellent criterion of the perfection, or degree of diminution of hearing in
the individual, is found in the distance at which perception of sound takes place.
55
ened, and their impulse excited the almost dormant
qualities of the sentient parts of the organ, so that
perception of sound took place. Surely, if the hearing
be diminished, it cannot be perfect.
From my own observations on those who have lost
the membrana tympani, I am inclined to believe that
part* of the statement, in Sir Astley's history of the above
cases, where he mentions the apparent diminution of
hearing in his patients, in preference to the remarks of
Sir Everard ; especially, when I have always found, that
the destruction of the membrane, or even when only
partially injured, was sooner or later, followed by
great diminution of hearing, terminating generally in
deafness.
The sole intent of Sir Astley's paper, was to reconcile
patients, in whom permanent obstruction of the eusta-
chian tube had taken place, to the operation of puncturing
the membrana tympani, in order to restore the hearing,
when there existed no other cause of obstruction to
auditory perception. But the operation is only the lesser
* I mention this part, because in several other parts of that excellent paper, the
assertions of the worthy Baronet disagree with my own observations ; especially,
where he mentions " an accumulation of the natural secretion, or wax," taking place
in the meatus of an individual, whose membrana tympani had been destroyed,
and in whom the destructive process of ulceration had formerly existed several years
prior to his statement of the case ; but of which I shall notice in its proper place.
36
evil, and must on that account, be depreciated, if there
remain any other mode of treatment by which the hear-
ing can be restored *
Every circumstance connected with the welfare of this
membrane, must therefore be invaluable, inasmuch, as its
loss sooner or later, exposes the tympanum and internal
parts of the ear, to be annoyed by every passing blast and
hurricane.
And althouofh this membrane should neither be
destroyed by disease nor accident, yet if it be constantly
exposed to the action of an arid, cold atmosphere, and
the ceruminous glands become destitute of their secreting
power, or nearly so, the membrane becomes shrunk
and colapsed, diaphanous and shining, sometimes trans-
parent as if divested of vitality, and diminution of
hearing, generally followed by deafness, is the result of
a continued want of this secretion.
The plentiful secretion of healthy cerumen, is therefore
of the utmost consequence towards preserving this mem-
brane ; and hence the use of the odoriferous volatilizing
particles ; for when the tubular circle is well formed
* For an account of this operation, see Surgical Remarks on the Operation of
Puncturing the Membrana Tympani, in the Guide to Acoustic Surgery, Chap. II.
page 32.
57
and complete, the volatilized odoriferous particles of
cerumen, which are thrown off by the heat of the parts,
lubricate the external surface of the membrana tympani,
and promote circulation in the membrane, by stimulating-
it to that healthy tension, consistent with elasticity and
vitality, so as to render it efficient to transmit the most
delicate vibrations.
The volatilized secretion which protects the membrane
from the action of cold and dry winds, preserves it
likewise from the baneful effects of a cold moist atmos-
phere, frequently more prejudicial than that of extreme
drought. The moisture or vitiated secretion, produced
in the meatus by the admission of the atmosphere, when
unprotected by the ceruminous tubular circle, causes the
membrana tympani to relax, become thickened and
callous, vibrating only to the impulse of very strong- puL
sations. For it may be remarked, that the membrane,
when in a relaxed state, cannot vibrate so easily as when
it is tense and stimulated.*
Sir Everard Home, in his excellent paper formerly
mentioned, ascribes accuracy of hearing entirely to the
muscular structure of the membrana tympani ; without
assigning any properties to the cerumen, either in stimu-
lating the membrane, modifying or absorbing the
resilient pulsations of sound.
* The stripgs cf a violin, when damp and relaxed, furnish a fine illustratioji of
this ajciom,
I
58
He seems to have had no idea of the properties of
cerumen in rendering auditory perception accurate^ by
means of the absorption of resilient pulsations. " The
knowledge of a muscular structure in the membrana
tympani," says that celebrated author, "enables us
to explain many phenomena in hearing, which have
not hitherto been accounted for in a satisfactory manner.
It is principally by means of this muscle, that accurate
perceptions of sound are communicated to the internal
organ,* and that the membrana tympani is enabled to
vary the state of its tension, so as to receive them in the
quick succession in which they are conveyed to it." j*
The muscular structure of the membrana tympani, is
well adapted to communicate grave or acute vibrations
to the sentient parts of the organ, but it is only by means
of the ceruminous tubular circle^ that accuracy of these
vibrations can take place. J
* The fallacy of this theory is easily proved by the following circumstances,
■which occur so frequently, that they may be put to the test by any practitioner.
When the meatus is divested of cerumen, resilience, or confused, inaccurate audi-
tory perception takes place; even although no defect of the membrana tympani
exists, yet as soon as the secretion of healthy cerumen is restored, so as to form the
ceruminous tubular circle; or, if only an artificial one be formed, accurate percep-
tion oj" sound takes place, unless the tympanum, labyrinth, or sentient parts of the
organ be injured.
f Croonian Lecture, on the Structure and Uses of the Membrana Tympani of
the Ear.. By Evcrard Home, Esq. F.R.S. Anno 1800.— Philosophical Trans. Vol. 90.
% See pages 6, 17, 19, and 30 of this work.
59
M. Du Verney, as has been already noticed, ascribed
to the membrane, the power of accommodating- it-
self to grave and acute sounds ; but afterwards adds,
" I confess it is hard to conceive how this is performed,
they are mechanical motions which are imperceptible,
the nature and causes of which are difficult to explain.*
M. Savart affirms •]• " that it is not necessary to suppose,
as has been done, the existence of a particular me-
chanism, intended to act on the membrane of the
tympanum, and make it vibrate in unison with the bodies
which affect it ; but, that it is always so conditioned, as
to be readily influenced by any number of vibrations /^+
That it is always so, I deny ;|1 or how is it, that when a
person is intensely thinking on any subject, another
person may approach him, and even speak in his ordi-
nary tone of voice, and not be heard. The will is there-
fore always necessary, to enable a person to discriminate
between the various tones of pulsations, which may
* Treatise on the Organ of Hearing. f Ann. de Chim. Vol. XXVI.
J Although these authors ascribe no qualities to the cerumen, whereby it may
contribute towards exciting healthy action, so as to produce tension of the fibres
of the membrana tympani, yet, without its protecting influence, to guard and defend
the meatus, and also to modify the undulations of sound, before they approach
to the membrane, as well as its stimulating properties, the membrana tympani
would soon become callous, or painfully acute by the stimulus of these undalalions ;
and even then, fail in transmitting accurate vibratory sensation, unless the resilient
pulsations be absorbed by the ceruminous tubular circle.
II As an analogical proof, see Plates V., VI., and VII.
i2
60
affect the membrana tympani, in order to form accurate
perception of hearing. I grant that a person may be
roused from abstraction of thought, but even then, he
cannot distinguish the tones and various inflections of
sound, until he make an effort for the purpose ; which
is done so quickly, as to catch the pulsations from the
vibrating body, before it becomes quiescent-
That the mil is necessary, may be also inferred from
the number and functions of the nerves which supply the
parts.* The chorda tympani stretches across, and is con-
nected with the membrana tympani and ossicula auditus.
The meatus is also plentifully supplied with branches from
the fifth, portio dura, the second, and sometimes the first
vertebral nerves. The portio dura, from its connection
with the membrana tympani by means of its branch the
chorda, tympani, must have considerable influence in as-
* Mr. Bell, in an admirable paper read before the Royal Society, says, " A pure
or simple nerve has the influence propagated along with it in one direction only,
and not backwards and forwards; it has no reflected operation or power retro-
gade; it does not both act /rom and to the senioxmra,"— Philosophical Transactions,
Part II. page 163, 1826.
This beautiful and simple theory of the nervous system, is greatly in
favour of the muscular structure of the membrana tympani. For if a branch of
the great moter nerve be distributed in the membrane, it ought, agreeable to the
functions of moter nerves, to furnish the membrana tympani with a power to
produce tension, and tension is generally understood to be accomplished by the
contraction of fibres, a property or quality inherent in the muscvilar fibre, under
the influence of a particular nerve.
61
sisting to promote the healthy tension of the membrane, So
as to dispose it to transmit acute vibrations from sonorous
bodies.
And as all undulatory motion, whether of aerial or
denser mediums, is preceded by more or less of a slight
oscilliation, but so quickly followed by the pulsation of
sound, as to be scarcely perceptible ; so this avant
courier of the pulsation affecting the extreme branches
of the nervous fasciculi distributed on the face and lateral
parts of the head,* conveys the approach, followed
almost instantaneously by the pulsation itself, -j-
I say almost instantaneously, because however short the
space may be, still it exists as a portion of time. In the
same manner, the rays of the sun when travelling to
this earth, a distance of upwards of ninety-six millions of
miles, perform the journey in seven or eight minutes,
which is so rapid, that it is deemed instantaneous ; and
yet we know, that seven or eight minutes is a space
accounted sometimes too long, especially when occupied
* And hence may partially be accounted the quick turn of the head, when
sounds are heard indistinctly.
f The connection formed between the portio dura and the fifth, by means of the
junction of a branch of the latter nerve and the chorda tympani, will account for
this seeming retrogade influence. The impression being carried towards the senso-
rium by branches of the fifth, or sentient nerve, until the junction with the portio
dura, or moter, which immediately acts, so as to promote the necessary degree of
tension in the fibres of the membrana tympani..
62
by painful sensations. The small muscles in the tym-
panum, in like manner, act instantaneously, so as to pro-
duce general tension of the membrana tympani ; which
is rendered still more efficient by the action of the fibres
of • the membrane, under the controul of the minute
fasciculi of the chorda tympani or semi-moter and semi-
sentient nerve. The membrana tympani, is also stimu-
lated by the halitus of the ceruminous tubular circle, and
by these means it accommodates itself agreeable to the
will, or desire of the auditor, to the variety of pulsa-
tions produced by the vibration of sonorous bodies,
whether grave or acute.
It has been remarked by one of our most elegant
writers, " that if the stroke be strong, the organ of
hearing- suffers a considerable degree of tension. If
the stroke be repeated soon after, the repetition
causes an expectation of another stroke. And it
must be observed that expectation itself causes a ten-
sion. This is apparent in many animals, who, when
they prepare for hearing any sound, rouse themselves,
and prick up their ears ; so that here the effect
of the sound is considerably augmented by a new
auxiliary, the expectation.'^^ By the term expectation,
it may be presumed the author meant the will of the
auditor ; which is communicated by the branches of
* Burke on the Sublime and Beautiful, Part TV. Sect. 11.
63
the portio dura, distributed in the substance of the mem-
brana tympani * so as to excite tension in the fibres, in
order that it may accommodate itself to the various in-
flections of sound ; and by this means be rendered capable
of transmitting- the most delicate vibrations.
But this beautiful arrangement of the structure of the
membrana tympani, assisted by the machinery of the
ossicula and distinct muscles, under the controul and
influence of Ihe minute fasciculi of the chorda tympani,
is however, unavailable in rendering auditory perception
accurate^ if the ceruminous tubular circle be destroyed.
In cases of induration and relaxation of the mem-
brana tympani, it has been proposed to apply a strong-
solution of nitras argenti to the membrane, by means
of a camel hair pencil ; but very bad effects of this
application are already on record. I have lately seen
several cases treated in this manner, and the effects
were destruction of the sensibility of the parts, and of the
ceruminous glands. Can that which destroys vitality,
* The membrana tympani of the Balaena Mysticetus, furnishes a beautiful
illustration of the distribution of reticulated nervous fasciculi, formed by branches
of the Portio Dura. The large branches ramify on the white membranous sub-
stance under the cuticle, and the minute ones terminate near the inner surface
of the membrane, which renders it susceptible to the slightest undulatory piilsa-
sations, and possessed also of power to accommodate itself agreeable to the wij/^
of the animal.
64
enter into the circulation of the parts, and promote
heahhy action ?
In parts possessing great depth of muscular substance,
the application of caustics may sometimes be admissible ;
but to a substance so thin and extended as the membrana
tympani, and of such vital importance to the organ, the
consequences resulting from the application of strong
caustic lotions, must be fatal to the healthy action of the
parts. The injection of pyrolignous acid, as mentioned
in the Illustrations of Acoustic Surgery, is a preparation,
that when assisted by the necessary medicines, will answer
every useful purpose in changing the morbid into healthy
action, and stimulating so as to produce the necessary
degree of tension, consistent with the vitality of the mem-,
brane and adjacent parts,
When a person is exposed to boisterous weather, the
volatilization of the cerumen takes place slowly, some-
times only partially, and hence one reason why persons
travelling in bad weather have to speak louder to each
other in order to be heard, than when they are within
a room of moderate temperature.*
The halitus of volatilized cerumen, is therefore of the
Vitmost consequence, to preserve the membrana tympani
* Change of position, as well as the state of the atmosphere, will tend to prevent
the pulsations of sound from being so distinctly heard, as when delivered in ai^
^pa^rtment. Sec Appendix. •
65
from the effects of moisture or drought, produced by
the state of the atmosphere, and also in stimulating* and
promoting the healthy tension of the fibres of the mem-
brane, and keeping it moist, so that the delicate pulsations
and inflections of sound, may be transmitted to the in-
ternal parts of the ear, more acutely than could otherwise
have been done if the membrane were dry,* as will be
shown by the following experiment.
I procured a tin instrument similar in shape to that of
an ear trumpet, but considerably larger, consisting of
four pieces, which fitted neatly into each other. By this
means I was enabled to apply a piece of bladder across
the caliber of the tube, at the distance of three, six, or
nine inches from the aural or small aperture, according
to circumstances. The piece of bladder was intended to
represent the membrana tympani, and was fixed neatly
at about six inches from the small aperture.
I then placed my watch on the table, at a little
distance from me, and applied the instrument to my ear ;
when I could hear the watch beating considerably louder
than without the aid of the instrument. I removed the
piece of dry bladder, and applied in its place another
piece moistened in water. On applying the trumpet to
* All parts of the human system, when in a healthy state, are more or less
moist according to their desiguatiun, and perspirability.
K
66
my ear, the beating of the watch became more audible
and distinct than when the dry bladder was applied,
at the same time the tones of the pulsations were con-
siderably softened.
In addition to the uses already mentioned, the cerumen
may be considered as a regulator to modify the quantum
of electric fluid, which may enter the meatus along with
the condensed pulsations of sound.*
In order to ascertain the effect which cerumen has on
the electric fluid, I smeared the point of my finger with
this secretion, taken recently from the ear of a boy of
acute hearing, and then applied my finger to the prime
conductor of a small electrical apparatus, and felt a slight
sensation of the presence of the fluid, but perceived no
sparks. On applying one of my other fingers on which
there was no cerumen, I received several sharp pene-
trating sparks emitting noise and light, as usual in such
instances. My eldest pupil tried the same experiment
with the same result.
I continued to repeat the experiment several times,
with my finger covered with cerumen, and once or twice
* The atmosphere sometimes abounds so much with electric fluid, particularly
in fine warm weather, that it has been supposed, by Mr, Murray, to be the means
by which the aerial spider (Aranea Obstetrix) projects its filaments into the air.
For an account of this interesting' and ingenious theory, see Experimenta,i
Jtesearches in Natural History. By John Murray, F.S.A., &c. Glasgow, 1826.
67
saw ahd felt a few weak sparks ; but when my finger
was deprived of the ceruminous coating-, and apphed to
the instrument in that state, I received always a number
of strong penetrating sparks, accompanied with crackling-
noise, and light.
It Would appear from these experiments, that the
cerumen protected the internal parts of the organ, from
the electric fluid that may be concentrated by the con-
densation of the pulsations of sound ; that is to say,
divested the pulsations of their intensity, and, perhaps,
some other properties ; changing, or modifying* them, so
that they may be assimulated to the galvanic fluid, so
remarkably predominate, and assimulating to the ner-
vous fibre, rendering it thereby more efficient and con-
* Mr. Sturgeon, of Woolwich, has, by a number of ingenious experiments on
Electric Discharge, ascertained that the quantity of aqueous fluid regulates the
intensity of the shock. " I have," says that gentleman, " frequently discharged a
jar through my own body, without any other inconvenience than a burning sensa-
tion at the extremities of the fingers, and have ignited gunpowder in the same
circuit. So modified is the electtic discharge, by being transmitted through aqueous
conductors, that the effect of an intense charge oj" the most powerful battery may be
reduced to almost any degree. I have discharged eight feet of charged surface
(eight feet of lining, and eight of coating) through my own body, without feeling
the least shock. But the burning sensation was very severe." Philosophical
Magazine, Vol. LXVlI. Page 445.
And hence may be accounted the effect which the ceruminous tubular circle
has in regulating the intensity of the gaseous fluid, contained in the condensed
pulsations of sound, especially when they proceed from large bodies that have the
effect of causing violent concussion of the atmosphere.
k2
68
genial to auditory sensation, than if the fluid had been
admitted in its concentrated state.
The cornea of the human eye is protected from the
continued stimuli of rays of light and reflecting bodies,
by the frequent action of the palpabrse washing the
lachrymal fluid over its glassy surface; and by this
means, its beautiful pellucid substance is preserved in
all its transparent lustre.
The auditory perception in the organ of hearing is
also so frequently exercised, that without some provision
to allay irritation, it would soon become callous, except
to the impulse of strong pulsations of sound.
It is, therefore, necessary to protect the internal parts
of the ear from the effects of the condensation of the pul-
sations of sound ; and for this purpose, the above modifi-
cation takes place by means of the cerumen, in order to
preserve that delicate perception necessary to the
accurate and acute ear.
In a paper which I wrote on the Comparative Anatomy
of the Ear of the Squalus Canus, part of which appeared
in the Edinburgh Philosophical Journal, January, 1826.
In the Physiological department of that paper, after
describing the arrangement of the nerves of the organ,
69
and the nervous circle formed, so as to receive and
communicate the slightest vibration, I mentioned,
" We may therefore presume from these circum-
stances, that the sensation of hearing- is perfected by the
existence of the electric fluid, modified according to the
nature of the parts which it may enter, which in its
tangible state displays the course and rapidity of vibra-
tory motion. And that auditory sensation cannot
exist, unless when the vibrations affect, and fill up the
chasm so as to connect the extremities of the fasciculi
forming the nervous circle; and hence may be the reason
why the whole of the auditory apparatus and nerves
assume a circular figure."
" And this is farther confirmed, when we observe,
that it is only the extremities of nerves that are endued
with the particular sensation for which they are
destined."*
* The reason why I insert this theory as a, quotation from the above paper, is,
that it was written in the latter end of 1825; and that excellent paper by Mr. C. Bell,
on " The nervous circle which connects the voluntary muscles with the Brain" was
read before the Royal Society, in January, 1826. My paper was read to several of
my friends, particularly the Rev. Mr. Colquhoun and Mr. Goodwill, two gentlemen
of whose discrimination, as well as general information, I entertain the highest
opinion. The whole of my paper was designed to have been published in the
Edinburgh Philosophical Journal, but owing to several circumstances, only one
section was printed.
I am preparing to publish a work on the Comparative Anatomy of the Organs
of Vision and Hearing, illustrated with drawings of the most remarkable specimens
of these organs in my possession.
70
The existence of the ceruminous tubular circle in its
most perfect form, is also an excellent criterion of the
state of the organ. For if the meatus, tympanum,
or labyrinth be diseased, no healthy secretion of
cerumen takes place, in the external tube of the ear
affected.
1 am well aware, that Sir Astley Cooper, in his history
of the case formerly mentioned, appears to have a con-
trary opinion when he says, "The slight degree of
deafness of which Mr. P. complained, was always greatly
increased by his catching cold." So far the worthy
Baronet is correct ; but when he adds, " an eflfect which
seems to have arisen from the meatus being closed by
an accumulation of the natural secretion of the ear^^^
I am very much disposed to question the accuracy
of the statement, and more especially when I read the
following continuation : " For it frequently happened
to him, after he had been some time deaf from cold, that
a large piece of hardened wax, during a fit of coughing,
was forced from the ear by the air rushing from the
mouth through the eustachian tube." Now, according
to this account of Sir Astley's, it must either be taken for
granted, that the hardened wax was the cause of the
cold, for he adds that the cold was "an effect which
seems to have arisen from the meatus being closed by
an accumulation of the natural secretion of the ear."
71
Or else, that the cold caused " an accumulation of the
natural secretion of the ear," in corroboration of which,
he adds, " for it frequently happened to him after he had
been some time deaf from cold, that a large piece of
hardened wax during a fit of coughing- was forced from
the ear, by the air rushing from the mouth through the
eustachian tube." That is to say, that the cold produced
an extraordinary secretion of cerumen, so much so, as to
block up the meatus until the "fit of coughing forced it
from the ear,'^
According to the observations which I have made on
the natural consequences of cold, when affecting the ear,
it acts always so as to suppress the secretion of the ceru-
minous glands,* and therefore, no accumulation of
cerumen can take place from that cause. I have,
indeed, often observed in those who have had the mem-
brana tympani injured or destroyed, and who in general
bad purulent discharge from the meatus at the time, that
when patients of this description caught cold, an accumu-
lation of this purulent, or semi-purulent matter took
place, became condensed, and frequently caused greater
diminution of hearing than that which formerly existed.
* I am happy to find, that the most celebrated authors who have written on this
subject, are of the same opinion, particularly M. Du Verney, who, in his Treatise,
when describing the effects of cold on this organ, adds, "For cold thickening this
wax and rendering it more viscious, causes it to obstruct and stop up the excretory
ducts of the glands, as it may be observed in other neighbouring glandular parts,"
72
If the consequences of cold were to be an increase of the
" natural secretion" of the meatus, then, the indication of
cure in diminution of hearing, arising* from a deficiency of
cerumen, would be to expose the patient so as to produce a
cold. Now this mode of treatment, however plausibly
it may be deduced from the statement of the case
mentioned, would be absurd, to term it no worse. It
should therefore be laid down as a rule in all cases,
that cold diminishes the secretion of cerumen ; and also,
that when the ceruminous tubular circle is perfect, no
disease exists in the membrana tympani, or tympanum.
In all instruments usually applied to the ear for the
purpose of condensing and thereby increasing the strength
of the pulsations of sound, it may be remarked, that if
the diameter of the caliber of the part of the instrument
placed in the concha be diminished, the power of the
instrument is augmented.*
A similar process takes place in the meatus, when the
cerumen is secreted so as to form the tubular circle, which
in the healthy subject, is from one-twentieth to nearly a
quarter of a line in thickness, so that the cerumen causes a
* This holds good only to a certain extent, for if the diameter be diminished
so as to form a capillary aperture, the pulsations become so condensed as to pro-
duce a hissing noise by the strong current of pulsations striking upon the mem-
brana tympani in a continued stream, so that the undulatory motion of the
pulsations are lost, and the membrane prevented from vibrating freely.
73
considerable diminution of the caliber of the contracting-
meatus * and at the same time the auditory power of
the tube is augmented, and produces an effect on the
membrana tympani, in proportion as the length of the
meatus, and the size and position of the auricle and
concha, is to the diameter of the caliber of the tubular
circle. •]•
Hence the great danger to the sentient parts of the
organ, or even the membrana tympani, from the use of
an ear trumpet. For when the pulsations of sound enter
the large recipient or external orifice of an ear trumpet,
which is sometimes five or six inches in diameter, and
are propelled inwards, the sides of the tube prevent dis-
persion, and as the instrument contracts in caliber, so the
pulsations are gradually condensed, and produce an
effect on various parts of the organ, in proportion as the
length of the tube and its diameter at the mouth, is to
the small or aural aperture.
* The auditory tube, as formerly mentioned, is of a conical and partially wind-
ing figure, the diameter of the interior parts near the depressional curve, in the
well formed meatus, being in proportion to that of the expansion of the osseous
aperture, at its junction with the cartilaginous part of the meatus, as two and a
half is to three and a half in the length of four. — See Appendix, Table I.
t The degree of susceptibility in the Portio Mollis, (and perhaps that of the
whole nervous system of the individual,) must also be taken into account in
forming a proportional estimate of the effects produced from the relative figure
of the parts.
L
74
Although an auricle were twenty-three or twenty-five
lines in length, yet from its angle of attachment it would
scarcely occupy one-third of that space in breadth, con-
sequently, the recipient orifice of an ear-trumpet, if six
inches in diameter, would be capable of retaining and
conveying to the membrana tympani upwards of ten
times the quantum of pulsations of sound, that a mode-
rate sized auricle could possibly retain ; and which in its
condensed state must ultimately injure and destroy the
percipient qualities of the sentient parts of the organ.
The caliber of the meatus in the well formed ear, is
generally in proportion to the size of the auricle, and
depth and size of the concha, but when the tube is either
too large,* or too small, f the hearing is diminished in
proportion to the departure from the healthy standard.
In the Appendix is a table J taken from the measurement
of one hundred living individuals, and which may serve
as a criterion to judge how far the size of the parts may
assist in regulating the diagnosis of any attempt to effect
a lasting cure in cases of diminution of hearing.
The consequences arising from the disease M. Permi-
nutus, II is sometimes more easily remedied than that of
* M. Peramplus. f M. Perminutus. % Table IV. see Appendix.
II I have met with several cases of diminution of hearing in elderly persons,
particularly females, arising from the auricles being bound down on the head ; and
the cartilaginous parts of the auricle being pressed forwards by the bandage,
75
M. Peramplus^ especially if the diminution of the caliber
of the meatus be occasioned by tumidity of the integu-
ments. When the caliber of the meatus is contracted
from the above cause, it may be considerably enlarged
by introducing elastic tubes or short bougies made of
catgut into the meatus, and afterwards slightly moistened
with tepid water.
The tube or bougie swelling by means of the moisture,
causes pressure, and consequently absorption of the parts
takes place, which enlarges the meatus in a slow
gradual manner. Considerable tact will be necessary to
prevent absorption of the ceruminous glands, or ulcera-
tion of the parts, which occurs invariably if the pressure
be so great as to cause pain and head-ache.
On the first appearance of these disagreeable symp-
toms, the tube or bougie must be withdrawn, and the
case treated according to the directions mentioned in
Injlammatio Supurata.^
The secretion of the cerumen, is considerably affected
by the size of the tube, especially if it be much above that
of the usual standard, where the atmosphere is admitted
gradually contract the horizontal diameter, and ultimately block up or close the
meatus. This species of diminution of hearing may be termed Impedimentnm
Pressures Senilis,
* For a particular account of the mode of treatment, see Illustrations of Acoustic
Surgery.
l2
76
in so large a volume, that the cold prevents the formation
of the halitus, or even the secretion of the cerumen, and
the membrana tympani being- partially unprotected, soon
loses its delicate tone. The ceruminous glands become
at first inflammed, afterwards enlarged, followed some-
times by ulceration, but more frequently they are par-
tially shrivelled, the tube becomes therefore gradually
dry, and the integuments callous * Great diminution of
hearing in the adult, and deafness in the aged, is the
consequence of this species of malformation.
In a case of M. Peramplus which came under my
care, (patient seventy years of age,) where the tube was
completely dry, and measured seven lines and a half in the
longitudinal diameter, attended with considerable dimi-
nution of hearing ; I applied a thick coating of artificial
cerumen, so as to diminish the caliber of the meatus, and
form a tubular circle. About fifteen minutes afterwards,
the patient could hear when addressed in an ordinary
tone of voice.
The mechanical properties of the application, forming
an extremely thick tubular circle, and thereby diminish-
* Several cases of M, Peramplus came under my care, -where the caliber of the
meatxis measured from six to eight lines in diameter. The inside of the meatus was
completely destitute of the ceruminous tubular circle, being dry and shrivelled ;
and even the mouths of the ducts of the ceruminous glands could not be dis-
covered. The diminution of hearing was of course very great.
77
ing* the caliber of the meatus, assisted by the stimulating
qualities of the preparation, and the pulsations of sound
beino- condensed and transmitted to the membrana
tympani with nearly equal power to that of the well
formed meatus, succeeded in restoring the hearing of the
patient.
But the restoration of hearing lasted no longer than
the continuance of the form and existence of the medical
properties of the artificial tubular circle, which was
renewed for several times with the same result.*
Several very important criteria are to be found in the
shape and size of the auricle, especially in the angle
which it forms with the cranium, and also in the size and
depth of the concha, which may assist to determine the
prognosis in cases of diminution of hearing when the
symptoms are obscure.
As the figure and aspect of the auricle have consider-
able effect in augmenting or diminishing the strength or
condensation of undulatory pulsations, so they afford also
excellent diagnostic symptoms to guide the practitioner
in his mode of treatment of the particular species of
disease which may affect the hearing of the patient, and
* The meatus might also be contracted by means of a small tube smeared over
with cerumen, and fashioned so as to fit neatly into the tube.
78
may, agreeable to Table IV., be reduced to the follow-
ing axioms, viz.
Axiom I. — If the concha be large and deep, the upper
part of the helix rather overhanging, the scapha not pro-
truding, the lobe inclining diagonally forwards, and the
angle of attachment* from twenty-five to forty-five
degrees ; the auricle is then formed to retain, concentrate,
and convey into the meatus, the necessary quantum of
undulatory pulsations requisite to excite acute auditory
perception. J-
Axiom II. — If the concha be small and shallow, and
the angle of attachment of the auricle be nearly forty
degrees ; this angle, formed by the auricle and cranium,
compensates for the deficiency of that important cavity,
by the quantum of pulsations which the auricle, by its
position,, conducts into the meatus.
Axiom III. — If the angle of attachment be small, and
the concha large and deep, the capacity of this cavity,
compensates for the deficiency of the angle of attach-
ment.
* The angle of attachment is found by applying a quadrant to the parts of the
head immediately in contact with, and in front of the auricle.
t In the female auricle, when well formed, the parts are in general more elegant
than in the male, and the length greater in proportion to the breadth. In the
79
Axiom IV. — But if the concha be small and shallow,
and the angle of attachment under fifteen degrees, the
hearing' is rarely, if ever acute, especially in middle aged
persons.*
Axiom V. — And if to these imperfections, the meatus
be small and circular, it adds considerably to the
defective formation of the external, or recipient parts of
the organ. •]•
Axiom VI. — And if to any of these imperfections of
the auricle, the meatus be large and circular, and the
diameter six, seven, or eight lines, the person is gene-
rally affected with diminution of hearing, which is in-
creased with age.
From these axioms may be deduced the propriety of
paying attention to the head dress of children, as well
as to those of aged persons ; in order that the auricle may
become strengthened so as to retain its shape and
position in the angle of attachment most favourable to
receive the pulsations of sound.
above axiom, it is taken for granted, that the ceruminous tubular circle is perfect,
the intermediate and internal parts of the organ well formed, healthy, and
possessed of the necessary susceptibility requisite to acute perception of sounds.
* See Table IV.
t See page seventy-two of this work, and particularly the note appended to that
passage.
80
If the angle of attachment of the auricle of a child be
small, it can easily be increased by applying* a pad and
bandage, and continuing the same until the auricle
assume a permanent position agreeable to the angle of
attachment required *
Females of all ages ought to be particularly careful
in the form of their head-dress, so that it may not inter-
fere with, or bind the auricle flat to the head, as the con-
tinuance of this kind of pressure, will, sooner or later,
cause the cartilage of the auricle to contract the horizontal
diameter of the meatus, and ultimately block it up. ■]•
That the angle of attachment of the auricle to the
cranium, has a very great effect in diminishing or aug-
menting the strength of the undulatory pulsations of
sound, even when the ceruminous tubular circle is fully
formed, may be illustrated by the following case.
* This can be more readily accomplished with the male child than with the
female, by means of the hat usually worn; and which ought always to be placed on
the child's head, so as to cause the upper part of the auricle to overhang the concha.
Nurses ought to be careful never to place the auricles within the hat, because
this manner of wearing it, will ultimately tend to flatten the auricle, and decrease
the angle of attachment.
t The obstruction caused by means of the cartilage of the auricle blocking up
the meatus, forms, as has been already mentioned, the species Impedimentum
Pressure Senilis. This species of obstruction is never found but in aged persons,
and more frequently in female than in male patients,
81
" Mr. E — e, aged thirty-nine years, returning- home
late in the evening, fell on the handle of a pump,
which being square and made of iron, the edge of it
cut into the auricle and almost severed the greatest
part of it from his head. Considerable hemorrhage
took place, but, with the assistance of his family, he
succeeded in stopping it, and went immediately to bed.
I was called in next morning-, and found the meatus
blocked up with coagulated blood, which was removed
with difficulty, on account of the Pili Auricularis being
involved in the coagulum.
The auricle was divided through the integuments and
cartilage, and the detached portion connected by a small
slip of the helix, rather more than the breadth of a line. I
washed the parts with tepid milk and water, brought
the edges of the wound together, and passed one suture
through the integuments, near the inferior part of the
scapha, and another rather below the upper part of the
concha. And, in order to keep the parts in apposition,
particularly the cartilage, I applied a suture through the
integuments on the back of the auricle, next to the
cranium, equi-distant from the sutures on the other side
of the auricle, and strengthened the parts with slips of
adhesive plaster. I then formed a pad, and placed it so
as to retain the auricle at an angle of nearly forty-five
degrees from the cranium, and secured the whole in the
M
82
manner described in the 'Illustrations of Acoustic
Surgery/* The patient did not complain of much pain,
and as he was of temperate habits, and confined himself to
his room ; the parts were healed by the first intention in
a few days. The cicatrice could scarcely be discovered,
except on minute inspection. But the most satisfactory
part in the history of the case was, that the patient could
afterwards hear better with this ear than the other,
which forms an angie of attachment of about ten degrees
with the cranium. "I*
This case illustrates the great importance of the angle
formed by the auricle with the cranium, in rendering-
the hearing acute. But the following history of a case
so hopeless as to have discouraged several eminent
Physicians as well as Surgeons from attempting a cure,
is still more conclusive than the above, in showing the
effect of the angle formed by the auricle and cranium.
A country gentleman about fifty-seven years of age,
applied to me under the following circumstances.
" Has had great diminution of hearing in the left, and
almost deaf of the right ear, upwards of twenty years ;
* For a description of the Auricular Pad and Bandage, see Illustrations of
Acoustic Surgery, chap. IV. page 29, and plate V.
■\- When he informed me of his accession of acuteness of hearing, I proposed to
cut off the flat auricle, or at least make an incision, and endeavour to heal it so as
to form a corresponding angle with the other ; but to this he would not
consent.
83
and at present can scarcely hear a word spoken, unless
the person speaking shout very loud. Meatus dry and
large. Concha very shallow. Auricle forming an angle
of sixteen degrees with the lateral parts of the cranium.*
Has had advice, and been under the care of several
medical gentlemen, without experiencing any ameliora-
tion of his complaint. A practitioner under whose care
he had once placed himself, poured into the meatus of
the right ear a fluid, the nature of which he (the patient)
did not know ; but it caused such intolerable pain as
almost to distract him; and this ear has always been
worse than the other, since that period. ''-j*
On the formation of the artificial tubular circle, the
hearing was considerably improved in his left ear ; but
as he lived upwards of seventy miles from Hull, and
business requiring his immediate return, I resolved to try
some other mode, in addition to the application of the
artificial tubular circle.
From the very small angle of attachment of both
auricles, being only sixteen degrees, I was led to believe
that by applying a pad so as to extend the natural angle
* The size and dimensions of the auricle and meatus of this patient, are given
in Table IV. No. 13.
t Taken from the notes of the case.
84
of the auricles to forty-five degrees, the hearing might be
considerably improved.
I made tvro temporary pads, and the patient vs^earing-
glasses, I was thereby easily furnished with the means
by which the pads could be secured in the position re-
quired. I fastened a pad to the end of each of the
handles of his glasses, and in the space of five minutes
after they were adjusted, he could hear me speaking to
him in an ordinary tone of voice.
It may be remarked, that whenever the horizontal
diameter of the caliber of the meatus exceeds three
lines, diminution of hearing invariably takes place ;
unless there be peculiar advantages in the size of the
auricle, its angle of attachment, capacity, or depth of
the concha.
In Table IV. there are only six persons in the hundred,
whose meatus measures three lines horizontally ; and of
that number only one has acute hearing, viz. No. 62.
But this extraordinary circumstance in No. 62, is chiefly
owing to the individual being strong and muscular, and
of active habits, the auricle rather above the usual size,
the concha very deep, and the cranium very large.
No. 76. has the meatus large, but as the auricle is of a
tolerable size, the greater part of it at an angle of
thirty degrees, and the lobe at an angle of fifty-two
85
degrees, and no unhealthy symptoms in the nervous
system, the hearing is therefore good.
If the angle of attachment be under twenty degrees,
the hearing will be diminished, unless compensated by a
large and deep concha ; because a sufficient quantum
of the pulsations of sound cannot be conveyed to the
membrana tympani, so as to form acute vibration of that
membrane, if the auricle be small, and attached to the
cranium in that position. As the angle of attachment
exceeds twenty degrees, and approaches towards forty-
five degrees, so the hearing becomes more and more
acute, according to its grade of approximation.
If the angle of attachment be forty degrees, the
hearing is always acute ; unless the meatus be very
large, and the concha extremely small and shallow, or
the intermediate, or internal parts of the ear injured.
The angle of forty-five degrees, appears to be the
best at which the auricle can be placed, so as to receive,
retain and convey the greatest quantum of the pulsations
of sound to the membrana tympani.
In several parts of the concha, but particularly around
and in the entrance of the meatus, are numerous small
ducts, visible to the naked eye. These are the ducts of
the sabaceous glands. The secretion is limpid and
tasteless, and very plentiful in some individuals. I have
86
taken out of the concha of a healthy person, upwards of
one-fifteenth part of a dram.*
There is a remarkable case related by Dr. Barnes, of
a vicarious menstruation which took place repeatedly
from the ear of a lady, of a liquid which had neither
taste nor smell.* The history of this case agrees so
exactly with my own observations on the secretion of
the sabaceous glands in the auricle, that I have no doubt
the discharge mentioned might be emitted from the
ducts of these glands, in the entrance of the meatus and
concha.
In the case mentioned, it is stated that the discharge
" was colourless, and had neither taste nor smell. The
ear was dry in the interval." Now as the remarks by
Dr. Barnes, on this extraordinary case, are so appropriate
and valuable, it is therefore to be regretted, that he has
not given a more explicit and minute account of the
state of the concha, but particularly of the meatus,
especially when it was the seat of disease, according to
his account in the above paper.
* The measurement of the auricle of this individual, is given in Table IV.
No. 29. And I may add that he is of remarkable temperate habits and healthy
constitution ; but rather inclined to corpulency.
* " Case of Vicarious Menstruation, -with, singular discharge from the ear, with
remarks. By Thomas Barnes, M.D. Physician to the Fever Hospital and Public
Dispensary, Carlisle, &c. Communicated by Benjamin Bell, Esq. Edinburgh."
Edinburgh Journal of Medical Science, October, 182C.
87
In a note by the learned Editor of the above Journal,
forming- a very elaborate critique on Dr. Barnes' paper,
a case is given as an illustration of the discharge in ques-
tion, and vi^hich was laid before the public by Dr. Russel,
in his inaugural dissertation De Otorrhoea. After re-
lating the preliminary history of the case, (of a girl,) the
Editor mentions, that " of a sudden an eruption, to vrhich
she had never been subject, broke out about, but not in
the ear, with a copious discharge (this we saw many
times a day) from the meatus, of a pellucid colourless,
nodorous fluid, but so acrid that it excited pustules and
scabs over all the parts of the cheek and neck upon
which it flowed.'^
From this description, it may at once be recognized
as Injiammatio Suppurata, induced by bathing (as
the history of the case relates,) in the sea at New-
haven. I have had several cases of the above
species of inflammation of the meatus under my care ;
but the discharge in my patients, was in general slightly
tinged, and this partial discolouration proceeded from
the patients having been several days, sometimes weeks
or months affected with this complaint, before their ap-
plication to me for relief. Whereas in the case mentioned
in the note, the learned Editor having the patient already
under his superintendence, prior to the appearance of the
discharge, was by that means enabled to see the very
beginning of the primary stage of the disease.
88
The use of the secretion of the sabaceous glands may
be partially inferred by analogy. As bodies when dry
and hot, have more or less the power of attracting the
electric fluid, especially when they are pointed and
projecting ; so there might be some danger of the
auricle, (by means of its figure and position,) attracting
the gaseous fluid, if the parts, when evolving caloric,
continued in a dry state.
The secretion of the sabaceous glands, which is limpid
and tasteless, may, when the individual is heated by
active exertion, tend to prevent the electric fluid becom-
ing prejudicial to the hearing ; or at least modifying its
influence, or lessening the attraction of the heated and
projecting auricle, and of course the accumulation of that
fluid in a concentrated state.*
By all the accounts which I have seen of those persons
who have suffered by the fatal effects of the electric fluid,
* In a very ingenious paper by Mr. Sturg'eon, of Woolwich; on the Ignition of
Gunpowder by the Electric Discharge, and which has been mentioned in another
part of this work, it appears, that when the conductor which was made of twine,
and well soaked in water when used, ignition did not take place so readily as when
the twine was but partially moistened.
These experiments are valuable, inasmuch, as the arrangements by which the
results were obtained, are greatly facilitated by Mr. Sturgeon's communication ;
but particularly that part which relates to the modification of the intensity of the
discharge which takes place by means of the conductors being moistened with
water. See Journal of Science, Vol. XXII. Page 200, and Phil. Mag. Vol. LXVII.
These experiments were also tried by Mr. Leuthwaite, of Rotherhithe, and are
recorded in the same Journal, Vol. XI. Page 393.
89
the individuals have been of a dry temperament, not
given to perspiration, at least the skin has been dry at
the time the accident happened, and from their situation
in respect to the surrounding space, become a point of
attraction to the concentrated fluid.
When man is heated by active exertion, the perspira-
tion is more abundant on the forehead than on any other
projecting part of the frame, and this may be the more
necessary, in order to relieve the parts, and at the same
time shield the source of vital, intellectual and physical
power, and render it repulsive to the electric fluid,
whether diffused or condensed in the surrounding
atmosphere.
I have thus given a brief account of the physiology of
the recipient parts of the organ of hearing, and endea-
voured to impress on the mind of the practitioner, the
importance of the shape and size of the auricle, and the
angle formed by its attachment to the cranium; and
also, the figure, size and position of the meatus, but
more particularly that of the ceruminous tubular circle,
in rendering the hearing accurate and acute.
•
The cerumen is so absolutely necessary in preserving-
accurate vibrations in the membrana tympani, and con-
sequently acute sensation, that without this peculiar
90
secretion, all the beautiful arrangement of structure in
this membrane and machinery of the ossicula, and
even the sentient qualities and percipient powers of the
portio mollis itself, would soon become alike insensible
to the shrill, sweet, or harsh pulsations of sound, their
modifications or inflexions, whether proceeding from the
cultivated tones of the human voice, or the more rugged
species of animated nature.*
From these views of the subject, we are led to admire
the beautiful simplicity of the various contrivances
adapted to render every part of the organ efficient, and,
in none more than in the secretion of cerumen, in
which is displayed the greatest design united with
mechanical arrangement : and, should the economy of
this organ appear to the philosophical mind, so com-
prehensive and grand, as to soar with sublimity above
all human inventions ; let it be remembered, that even
when arrayed in all the pride of symmetry and ex-
quisite organization, it conveys only a faint idea of
Infinite Wisdom.
* There is no doubt that a corresponding degree of symmetrical proportion
in the tympanum, mastoid cells, eustachian tube, and labyrinth, as well as in the
susceptibility of the organization of the portio mollis, is also requisite to form an
acute ear ; but as the limits of this Treatise do not include these parts of the organ,
the discussion of their individual and peculiar qualities shall be reserved as a
subject for a future publication.
APPENDIX,
CONTAINING
VARIOUS TABLES AND FORMULAE,
WITH
PHYSIOLOGICAL
AND
ANATOMICAL REMARKS
ON THE
OF THE
ORGAN OF HEARING
IN SEVERAL ANIMALS.
PROEM.
It is generally allowed that comparative anatomy illustrates
the physiology of the human body better than the most elabo-
rate definition, especially if there be a variety of figure and
position in the parts to be investigated. I have, therefore, added
an Appendix, containing such Tables and Remarks as may tend
to elucidate the various theories introduced into this publication.
It may, perhaps, be necessary to premise, that in the following
Tables of the dimensions of the meatus, the superior line extends
from the superior part of the external orifice to the membrana tym-
paui, and the inferior line begins at the inferior part of the ex-
ternal orifice, and terminates in the interior, or tympanal extremity
of the tube.
The depressional curve commences nearly opposite to the con-
nexion of the superior line vnth the membrana tympani, at an
angle formed in the tube, and which is more conspicuous in some
individuals than in others ; and includes all that part of the meatus
between this angle and the membrana tympani.
The longitudinal and horizontal diameters of the caliber of the
auditory tube in preparations, as well as in those of the living human
subject, are designated agreeable to the erect position of man; and,
in specimens of comparative anatomy, they are given in conformity
to the natural position of the animal.
TABLE L
DIMENSIONS OF THE
MEATUS AUDITORIUS EXTERNUS
OF THE
JHumatt ^uf)iutf
(CfflEFLY OF THE OSSEOUS CALIBER,)
TAKEN FROM PREPARATIONS IN THE POSSESSION
OF THE AUTHOR.
TABLE I.
Number or
character
of the
Description.
Length of the Meatus.
Diameter of the Caliber.
Preparation.
• Sup. line. 1 Inf. line. loep. Cun-e.
Long. Horiz.
Prep. 1
Preparation, a longitudinal section
of the left tube ; male adult.
Do, with the integuments of the
right tube injected and dried ; male
adult.
10
8 1
10
_i_40_
10
_3_4Jl_
10
10
P. 2.
_6j_o_
10
8 1
10
tVA
A very fine specimen of the parts,
the longitudinal diameter measures
large: depressional curve more acute-
ly marked than usual. Oss.
_i_3_0_
10
10
_3_0_0_
10
AVo
P. 29.
Diameter at
the Dep. C.
100
C. 1.
Craniae of two male Esquimaux,
dug up on the West Coast of
Davis' Straits. Oss.
4 3
10
t¥A
C. 2.
4 2
10
tVVo
C.3.
Cranium of Booth, executed at
York, for murder. Oss.
6 3
10
3_7
Too^o'
C.4.
Two male Craniae, of which I
tVoV
3
10
C.5.
dissection. Oss.
tVVo
3 0_7
10
P. 16.
Female, preparation dried.
5
10
t¥A
Z.
Male Cranium. Oss.
6.S-8.-_5
10
3 6
10
y.
Adult male Cranium. Oss.
4_7
10
S.fi_4.-Ji
10
X.
Adult male Cranium. Oss.
10
3J.i)l5
10
Preparation with the integuments,
injected and dried.
tVoV
Too'o"
Male, ten years of age.
tVoV
iU^
Female, six years of age.
10
To'0'0"
22.
Female, one year old.
1'"0 0"'ff
AAAl?
10
21.
Male, sixteen years of age.
tfo^
300
10
Male, two and a half years of age
integuments dried.
To'0'0
2 0-1
1
17.
Subject six years of age.
3 0.3
TTT'oo^
940
10
18.
Subject five years of age.
3 3
10
S.A7.-&
1 0^00^
The above measurements are taken on a scale of 1000 parts to an inch.
95
In the plate given by Soemmering',* of the caliber of
the meatus, neither the depressional curve nor the recli-
nation of the membrana tympani is vrell defined. There
are certainly great varieties in the size and figure of the
caliber ; but I have often observed, that all those indi-
viduals in whom the angle described by the beginning
of the depressional curve, was slightly marked, the
hearing was never so acute as when it was formed of a
strong angular figure, particularly if the ceruminous
tubular circle were imperfect. In Plate I. I have given
a sketch of a longitudinal section of the caliber of the
meatus, with the membrana tympani attached to the mal-
leus, a preparation distinguished for its symmetry and
beauty ; and in Plate II. a sketch of a longitudinal section
of the meatus of an extremely well formed ear, with the
parts adjoining-.
Soenamering, in his beautiful plates of this organ, has
delineated three divisions of the meatus, without ascrib-
ing any use to these divisions of the tube , j*
Dr. Kirby, the learned editor of Monroe's Anatomy
of the Human Bones, has added a supplement to his last
* Samuelis Thomas Soemmerring, Icones, Organi Auditus Humani. Francofurti
ad Moneum, 1807.
Y " Curvatura eius prima seu major."
" Curvatura secunda, sive minor."
" Curvatura tertia, minima." Tabula Quarta.
96
edition of that work, containing a description of the
structure of the internal ear, where he describes the
meatus " to run inwards in a curved direction, first rising
coronad and glabeliad, and then turning hasilad. *
Saunders, in his treatise, describes the meatus as
winding. " It is first turned upwards, then downwards,
and is again slightly bent near its termination." •]•
Neither of these authors assign any reason why the
hearing can be assisted by this irregular form of the
caliber of the tube.
In another part of this work, I have ventured to form
a theory on the utility of the depressional curve, to
which, I beg leave to refer the reader.
* Anatomy of the Human Bones and Nerv€s, page 287. Edinburgh, 1820.
t Treatise on the Anatomy of the Human Ear, by J, C. Saunders,
page 3. ■ London, 1806,
TABLE 11.
DIMENSIONS OF THE
MEATUS AUDITORIUS EXTERNUS
IN
(CHIEFLY OF THE OSSEOUS CALIBER,)
TAKEN FROM PREPARATIONS IN THE POSSESSION
OF THE AUTHOR.
TABLE II.
Number or
character
of the
Description.
Length of the Meatus.
Diameter of the Caliber.
Preparation.
Sup. line. 1 Inf. line. loep. Curve.
Long. Horiz.
P. s.
Preparation (in spirits of wine)
of part of the meatus of a young-
whale (Balaena Mysticetus.) The
tube is surrounded by a semi-car-
tilaginous substance, from three to
four lines in thickness. Measure-
ment taken at about three inches
from the merabrana tympani.
J.J.J.i5
I U
1 2 4.5
10
p. s.
A.
In a dissection of a foetus of the
B. Mysticetus (subject 13 inches
3 lines long) I was unable to ascer-
tain the orifice of the meatus, or
even the tube itself, after a very
careful dissection.
Prep, of the external orifice of
the meatus of the B. Mysticetus,
subject forty-tliree feet in length :
aperture in the quiescent state,
colapsed, and forming a long oval.
D.
A.
Hi-t'
A.
Section of the meatus of the
Sea Unicorn, or Narwal, (Mono-
don Monoceros.)
Section of the meatus of the M.
Monoceros, at tlie expansion near
the membrana tympani.
Section of the meatus of the M.
Monoceros, about half an inch
above the m.embrana tympani.
160.5
1000
1 fi o-s
10
D.
B.
10
tVo^o
D.
B.
10
ToVo-
116
D.
Prep, of the right ear of the Sea
Horse, or Walrus, (TrichecusRos-
marus.) The organ is finely se-
cured from violence by the Mastoid
Process, a huge massive body of
solid bone, upwards of an inch in
thickness.
ItVVo
•'^T'oo'o'
tVA
1000
1000
Meatus of the Dog-Pish (Squa-
lus Canus) subject three feet in
length. The tube is retained in
its acute angular position by strong
tendinous fibres, so remarkably fine
and pellucid, as scarcely to be dis-
tinguished amid the transparent
gelatinous substance, by which the
meatus is surrounded. Measure-
ments taken a few hours after the
animal was killed.
2 OJIii)
10
To'T) o"
At the orifice.
P. S.
1 4-3
1000
tWo"
Inside of the Cuticle.
_A2._
1000
_J.9._
10
C.
Green Monkey (Simla Sabaea)
The meatus is formed chiefly of
cartilage, so that the osseous part
of the tube has a similar appear-
ance to that of the human foetus.
Oss.
nu
_2_1_0
10
D. P.
Elephant (Elaphas Maxiraas.)
This specimen has received con-
siderable damage in the cellular
substance of the cranium, so that
there is the greatest probability
that the osseous tube of the meatus
is not complete. Oss.
•
1 -J? 3 .5
■■■10
r-oVo
The above measurements are taken on a scale of 1000 parts to an inch.
TABLE II. CONTINUED.
Number or
character
Description.
Length of the Meatus.
Diameter of the Caliber.
Preparution.
Sup. hne. Inf. line. Dep. Curve.
Long. j Horiz.
D. P.
Prep, of a Seal (Plioca Vitu-
lina.) Section of the meatus lon-
gitudinally.
72 1
10
1 110
■■■1000
_4-3_Q_
10
1 I f>
10
_2_7_S
10
Cran.
Cranium of a Seal, (P.Vitulina,)
integuments dried.
1 i .5
10
1 4 S
10
128
Prep, of a Seal, (P. Vitulina,)
integuments more full than the
above.
10
1 1 .5
10
121
Prep, of the ear of a Seal, (P.
Cristata.) Oss.
3 .5
10 0..
_4_8_1_
1 u
External orifice of the meatus
of a living Seal (P. Vitulina) ob-
long figure.
1 ■ ,5
10
2_ surrounded, so
as to prevent aerial circulation in the tube, and render
the vibrations of the membrana tympani imperfect ; in
the same manner that obesity in the human subject,
causes a considerable diminution of hearing, if the
eustachian tube be obstructed by pressure from the
swollen glands and increased muscular substance.
Hence, one reason why whales, when very fat, are more
easily approached and captured than those of less bulk.
In the Balsena Mysticetus, the caliber of the meatus
forms the four thousand three hundred and sixtieth part
of the whole length of the animal, allowing it to be
forty-five feet.
103
The meatus auditorius externus in most animals
conducts the pulsations of sound to the membrana tym-
pani, and are thence transmitted by that membrane to
the sentient parts of the organ, in order that perception
of sound may take place : but in the Balsena Mysticetus,
the pulsations of sound are conducted by the eustachian
tube into the tympanum, and proceed through this cavity
to the membrana tympani ; at the same time, the meatus
performs the office of the eustachian tube by facilitating
the vibratory action of the membrane ; and hence the
cause of the external convexity of the membrana tym-
pani in the whale, the reverse of that which is seen in
most animals.
MEATUS
MONODON MONOCEROS.
The meatus of the Narwal (Monodon MonocerosJ
is situated similar to that of the B. Mystieetus ; but
considerably larger in caliber than that of the whale.
I am at present unable to determine the exact size
of the external orifice of the meatus, having no speci-
mens of that aperture in my collection ; * but if it may be
allowed to judge by analogy, it should be rather smaller
than that of the seal.
The tube of the meatus is chiefly formed of strong
ligamentous substance, varying from half a line, to one
line in thickness ; except a small circular portion of
peculiarly hard osseous substance, (a continuance of the
parietes of the tympanum,) whence the membrana
tympani derives its origin, and which measures in
diameter from -j4/-5_ to ^YoV P^i"ts of an inch.-j-
* I have however, upwards of twenty specimens of various parts, and also several
preparations of the organ in situ.
t The -whole of the osseous part of the organ is composed of extremely dense
particles, similar to that of the petrous portion in the human ear.
P
106
The greater part of this hard petrous substance
describes a novel kind of circular arch, rising and bending
inwards to the central line of the meatus, then curling
downwards and rather outwards and upwards, somewhat
similar to the spiral lines frequently seen carved on
wooden work in old churches. This peculiar curvature
of the osseous portion of the auditory tube, may serve the
same purpose as the depressional curve in other animals.
To the edge of this curved process of the bone, the
tendinous portion of the tube is attached, and which
necessarily causes the tendinous portion to assume a
trumpet-like appearance. The caliber of the tendinous
tube, contracts rapidly to jV^V pa^i*ts of an inch, and
afterwards in the space of ten lines from its attachment
to the osseous portion of the tube, enlarges gradually to
T^o^i parts of an inch. The whole of the auditory tube
is lined with a reflection of the cuticle.
It ought to be remarked, that as the membrana tym-
pani of the narwal is concave externally, and its attach-
ment to the malleus deviates considerably from that of
the while, or even terrestrial animals ; so, the use of the
meatus in the narwal, must therefore necessarily vary,
in proportion to the deviation in size and figure of its
membrana tympani, from that of the B. Mysticetus.
MEATUS AUDITORIUS EXTERNUS
SQUALUS CANUS.
The orifice of the meatus auditorius exteraus in this
species of the shark, opens on the coronal surface of the
head, is small, but capable of admitting a bristle. After
passing through the cuticle, the caliber of the meatus
enlarges to above twice the size of the external opening,
and runs forwards and downwards, and rather inwards,
until it forms an acute angle by turning backwards,
downwards, and rather outwards, when it reaches an
aperture in the cranium, through which it passes into
the vestibule.
At the acute angle of the meatus, the inferior and
posterior portion of the tube is carried almost horizontally
forwards, until it arrives near the superior and anterior
portion, where it contracts to an extremely small aper-
ture, situated on the outer edge of the duplicate of the
posterior and inferior portion of the tube. This small
aperture or capillary duct, makes a small semi-circular
turn outwards, downwards, and backwards over the edge
of the reflected portion, and then enlarges in proportion
to the cavity above.
p2
108
The posterior part of the tube being also reflected
backwards, and closely united, and in contact with the
horizontal parts immediately above, while the anterior
portion by means of the angle formed, becomes the infe-
rior, and enlarges along with the other parts of the tube
to the size mentioned ; and in this manner, a valvular
membrane is formed by a duplicate of the posterior parts
of the tube, and, which I have termed the Membrana
Vestibuli.
The meatus, in its descent from this valvular mem-
brane towards the vestibule, forms an oblong globular
expansion, and then contracting into a small aperture,
arrives at the foramen in the cartilaginous cranium, to
the edges of which it is firmly attached, and passing-
do wnwards, joins the great sac of the vestibuli. The
parietes of the tube immediately below this globular
expansion, is strong and muscular, and forms a sphincter
of considerable power.*
The tube of the meatus is secured in its position by
numerous tendinous fibres, which ramify in all direc-
* It must at the same time be allowed that, if the scalpel be used freely, these
adhesions may be cut and the tube forcibly extended as if it were merely a duct ;
but the above description is given, agreeable to the appearance of the parts in situ,
and the result of nearly one hundred dissections of the organ of hearing in this
species, (S. Canus) in its most perfect and healthy state.
By means of the proximity of this place (Hull) to the sea, I could sometimes
procure any number of the heads of these animals, at comparatively little ex-
pense, so that there vi'ere no obstacles to prevent the dissection at such times as
were most convenient.
109
tions; and are extremely minute in size, but of great
strength, and nearly transparent.
The auditory tubes,* by means of the angular figure
which they describe in their descent to the vestibule,
occupy a considerable portion of the large depression
situated in the coronal and posterior parts of the cranium.
The remaining space is filled with transparent gelatinous
substance, the tendinous fibres, and two muscles, one of
which is attached to each tube.
These muscles take their origin from the edge of the
cavity or depression in the cranium, and above the anterior
margin of the foramen labyrinthi, and run obliquely in-
w'ards, forwards and downwards, and are inserted in the
angle of the reflected portion, which forms the membrana
vestibuli. The muscles are of a beautiful white colour,
and easily seen when the skin is carefully dissected back-
wards, from about half an inch anterior to the orifice.
Dr. Weber, in his delineations of the ears of fishes,
describes similar muscles in the Rai(B Miralaii, and also
in the JR. Torpedinis, but does not mention their ex-
istence in the S. Canus ; it may, therefore be pre-
sumed, that this is the first time these muscles have
been demonstrated in the dog fish.j*
* Termed by Dr. Weber, Sinus Auditorlus Externus.
t De Aure et Auditu Hominis et Animalium. Pars I. De Aure Animalium
no
I am fully aware of the formidable and respectable
list of authors who maintain that there is no external
meatus in the shark. Cuvier and Scarpa, who have
rendered themselves illustrious in the annals of phi-
losophy, for scientific investigation, as well as Bell and
Macartney, deny the existence of the auditory tube in
the Squalus.*
On the other side of the question, our no less cele-
brated countrymen, Monroe and Hunter, have both
laid claim to the merit of discovering the external
opening of the meatus. But neither the one nor the
other mention the existence of the valvular membrana
Aquatilium. Auctore Ernesto Henrica Webero. Phil, et Med. Doct. in Universitate
Lit. Lips. Prof. Anat. Comp. Extraord. Lipsiae, 1820.
* " To these authorities we may add that of Scarpa, who asserts in the most
positive manner, that there is no opening of the ear in the flat or round cartila*
ginous fishes ; he supposes that the foramina which Dr. Monroe discovered, were
the openings of some of the ducts containing gelatine which are found in this
situation ; he even treats Dr. Monroe's account with derision, and considers it absurd
to suppose that there should be a communication between the external element,
and the immediate seat of the sense of hearing. Scarpa, in denying an external
opening, admits the existence of a conduit from the integuments into the vestibu-
lum, or sac, containing the amylaceous substance. In this Cuvier agrees with him,
and we add, we have frequently and carefully dissected the organ of hearing in
the Ray and Shark genera, but have never been able to discover the opening men-
tioned by Monroe and Hunter. What we have observed agrees almost exactly
with the description given by Scarpa." Rees' C yclopasdia.^Fish. — Organ of
hearing. Supposed to be written by Macartney and Lawrence.
" We may conclude then, that fishes have no external opening like terrestrial
B."— J5«i/V Anatomy, Vol, III. page 133, London 1823.
Ill
vestibuli, or that of the muscle, or the structure of the
tube itself, by means of which, the surrounding element
is separated from the contents of the great sac. The
muscular structure of the tube of the meatus, will pre-
vent the admission of the surrounding fluid, independent
of the action of the muscle ; and this may perhaps be
one reason why I have found such great diversity in the
size of the membrana vestibuli, and capillary duct.
Dr. Weber in his Treatise (already mentioned) on
the Ears of Cartilaginous Fishes, gives a sketch of the
muscles of the external meatus, or as he terms it, " Sinus
auditorius externus of the Raiae ;" but does not men-
tion their existence in the S. Canus. Perhaps he might
not have had any opportunity of dissecting this species
of the Squalus.
I am of opinion, that the species of shark which
Lawrence and Macartney have dissected and described,
was not the S. Canus, but some other species of the
Squalus ; because, I have frequently had the heads of
very large sharks brought to me for dissection, and have
often failed in distinguishing the auditory tube, or its
muscle, particularly if the animals were old. But I have
always found the meatus auditorius externus, (the sinus
auditorius externus of Weber) and its attendant muscle in
the young dog fish.
112
In a paper on the Ear of the Squalus Canus, which was
read at a meeting of the Wernerian Natural History
Society of Edinburgh, on the 19th November, 1825. I
have thus described the meatus : " The tube is formed
of tough, elastic, membranous substance, and runs out-
ward or laterad, forwards or antiniad, and downwards
or basilad, a few lines more or less, according to the
size of the animal, until it reaches within a short space
of a membrane stretched across the tube, where it en-
larges to nearly twice the size of the other parts of the
tube/' " This membrane may with propriety be termed
the Memhrana Vestihiili.'^ " The tube then describes
an angle by running downwards, backwards, and a little
outwards, until it reaches the Foramen Oblongatum^
to the edge of which it is attached in some subjects more
closely than in others."*
This description was chiefly taken from notes of a
dissection of the external parts of the organ, in a subject
in which the capillary ducts were, by some means or
other, obliterated, and which led to the mistake of the
tube being described as impervious ; whereas the meatus
in the young animal is only rendered impervious by
means of the muscle and structure of the parts forming
the capillary duct, situated on the edge of the valvular
membrane, under the will and controul of the animal.
* The first part of this paper was published in the Edinburgh Philosophical
Journal, January, 1826.
113
If a description of the Ear of the whale were to be
given, as inchiding* an accurate account of the organ of
hearing in all the mammalia that swim in the northern
seas ; the description might possibly be correct in regard
to the whale,* but would certainly be egregiously
wrong, if it were to be applied to the narw al, and yet,
the situation of the meatus is similar in both : but the
membrana tympani of the whale is convex externally,
while that of the narwal is extremely concave. And if
an account of the Ear of the squalus canus in the young
animal were to be given, as forming a correct descrip-
tion of the whole of the shark genera, it would, in the
same manner, be found to deviate considerably from the
other species of that ferocious family.
The very small diameter of the caliber of the meatus
in the S. Canus, may perhaps be urged as an argument
in favour of the non-existence of the auditory tube in
this animal ; but if it be allowed that the balsena mysti-
cetus has a meatus, or auditory tube, the diameter of
♦ I say possibly, because, there has as yet been no correct account given of the
organ of hearing in this singularly formed animal. The Rev. Mr. Scoresby has
gone so far as to deny the existence of an external orifice to the auditory tube in
the whale, and none of the Journals which I have seen, have contradicted
the absurd and ridiculous assertion. At the same time, while stating this fact,
I by no means wish to detract from Mr. Scoresby, the merit due to him as an able
and intelligent navigator ; but, when he attempts to excel as a comparative
anatomist and naturalist, he certainly commits more errors than one,
Q
114
which is -VW parts of an inch, and the animal forty-five
feet in length ; the diameter of the caliber of the meatus
forms then about the four thousand three hundred and
sixtieth part of its whole length.
Whereas, in the S. Ganus, where the diameter of the
external orifice of the meatus in the cuticle, is only -y^^-o
parts of an inch, and allowing the animal to be three
feet in length, it forms then the two thousand four hun-
dredth part of its length, and the other parts of the tube
which measure -|^ parts of an inch, about an eight
hundred and seventy eighth part of the length of the
shark. So that, by this calculation, even the contracted
orifice of the auditory tube in the S. Canus, is above
twice the proportionate size of that in the B. Mysticetus ;
and the other parts of the tube are nearly five times its
proportionate size. Besides, it does not necessarily fol-
low, because the S. Canus has an external meatus, or
auditory tube, that the pulsations of sound must enter by
that aperture. The physiological account which I have
given of the membrana tympani and meatus of the
B. Mysticetus in this work, will I trust, place this theory
in a proper light, especially when its truth can be easily
proved by dissection.
TABLE III.
SIZE OF THE
MEMBRANA TYMPANI
IN
^eb^ral ^nimal^,
TAKEN FROM PREPARATIONS IN THE POSSESSION
OF THE AUTHOR.
TABLE III.
Number or
character
of the
Preparation.
Description.
Greatest
Diameter.
Least
Diameter.
300
Preparation of the right Ear of the Balsena Mysticetus. : remark-
able fine specimen Length of the membrana tympani, from its
origin to its attachment to the body of the malleus, measurement
in a line with the Valvular Process.
Diameter of its muscular coat, taken so as to intersect the com-
mencement of the process.
Lines.
Lines
20A
Lines
19rV
Do. do. minor concavity •.••••. ^
Length of the convexity of the membrana tympani, with l jg^
the cuticle entire 3 *
Breadth of ditto 9
367
D.
Prep, of the Ear of the B. Mysticetus, in situ, connected with the
cranium) subject young, but of four feet bone.
Length of the muscular coat of the membrana tympani from
its origin, to its attachment as above.
Breadth of ditto.
The prep having been kept several years in a dry state, the con-
cavities have become contracted, and therefore, their depth cannot
be so well ascertained as those of No. 300.
Prep, of the membrana tympani of the B. Mysticetus. Subject
middle sized.
Length of the muscular coat.
Breadth of ditto.
The concavities are considerably shrunk, but larger than those of
No. 307.
Lines
18rV
Lines
14-'-
306
20 lines
1 8 ''ne»
D.
Prep, of the membrana tympani of the Narwal, or Sea Unicorn,
(Monodon Monoceros.)
Height of the internal convexity to the insertion 7420 inch
into the malleus i 1 '"*-"•
Breadth of the muscular coat of the membrane at \ _^_h__ jjjch
its insertion into the malleus jiooo
10
1000
100
Prep, of the Ear of the Monkey, (Simla Sabaea ) Membrana
tympani.
T'oTTo"
HU
Prep, of the Ear of the Horse, (Equus Cabulus.) Membrana
tympani.
366
10
tVoV
410
Prep, of the Ear of the Ass, (Equus Asinus.) Membrana tympani.
f^^^
1000
116
Prep, of the right Ear of the Walrus, or Sea Horse, (Trichecus
Rosmarus.) Membrana tympani.
iU^'
4 3
10
133
Prep, of the left Ear of the Seal, (P. Vitulina,)oBe of the finest
specimens in the collection. Membrana tympani.
Tlie right Ear was presented to Dr. Barclay in 1817, and is, I
believe, in his museum, bequeathed to the Royal College of Sur-
geons in Edinburgh. The peculiar beauty of tlie Tympano-Coch-
lear Membrane exceedsthatofany prep.of theear which I haveseen.
Prep, of the right Ear of the Seal, (P. Cristata,) which exhibits
the best specimen of the muscles of the tympanum in this collec-
tion. Membrana tympani.
The left Ear was presented to Dr. Barclay in 1817, and is, I believe,
in his museum, bequeathed to the Royal College of Surgeons in
Edinburgh.
10
4 a n
1000
123
yoo o'
_4JL8_
10
The above measurements are taken on a scale of 1000 parts to an inch.
TABLE III, CONTINUED.
Number or
rharacler
ol'tlie
Preparalion.
Description.
Greatest
Diameter.
Least
Diameter.
95
Prep, of tlie Ear of the Common Hog (Sus Scrofa.) Merabrana
tympiiui.
3.AA--1
I u
287
10
169
Prep, of the Ear of the Hare, (Lepus Tiraidus.) The membrana
tympani is formed, as if two circles were joined ; the largest com.
mences at the extremity of the rim, and continued to the whole of
the manubrium of the malleus.
The lesser circle is attached to the tympanal extremity of the
superior line of the meatus and to the greater circle.
tVVo
10
_L.Q_o,
10
183
Prep, of the Ear of the Fox, (Canis Vulpes.) Membrana tympani.
There are several preparations of the Ear of this animal in the
collection, which measure nearly alike.
3.9.9.-_Q
10
10
90
Prep, of the Ear of the Calf of the Bull, (Bos Taurus.) Membrana
tympani.
5 9
10
3 s o.q
T"o"o"o"
161
Prep, of the Ear of the Cat, (Felis Catus.) Membrana tympani
10
2 4 0-0
10
R.
Prep, of the Ear of the Swan, (Anas Cygnus Mansuetus.) Mem-
brana tympani.
.■5 4 1
10
2 3 0-.;
T03"0^
R.
Prep, of the Ear of a Turkey, (Meleagris Gallipavo.) Mem-
brana tympani.
3 3 .3 • .5
10
3 6 3
10
142
Prep, of the Ear of the Cock, (Phasianus Gallus.) Membrana
tympani.
Prep, of the Ear of a young Game Cock, (P. Gallus.) Membrana
tympani.
Prep, of the Ear ot an old Cock, (P. Gallus.) Membrana tym-
pani.
5
2 4 4-5
100
R.
10
2 0-S
10
150
1 fi 1
10
2
10
R.
Prep, of the Ear of the Partridge, (Tetrao Perdrex.) Membrana
tympani.
2 6 6.3
10
tVW
R.
Prep, of the Ear of the Fulmer, (ProcellariaGlaciales.) Mem-
brana tympani.
■> 1 4-3
10
10
R
Prep, of the Ear of the Goose, (Anas Anser.) Membrana tym-
pani.
3 n n ■ .5
10
2_5LP_-2
10 6
R.
Prep, of the Ear of the Drake, (Anas Domestica.) Membrana
tympani.
2 1 1
To "00"
10 00
R.
Prep, of the Ear of a Sparrow Hawk, (Falco Nisus.) Membrana
tympani.
The merabrana tympani is beautifully pellucid, almost trans-
parent, and in proportion to the size of the animal, more than seven
times the size of that in the human subject.
3 1 i . .5
10
1 p fi-s
1009
R.
Prep, of the Ear of the Common male Pheasant, (Phasianus
Colohicus.) Membrana tympani.
The membrana tympani in this animal is convex externally ; but
not from the effect of the pulsations of sound.
3
10 9 9
2 15-1
10
A.
Prep, of the Ear of the Common female Pheasant, (P, Colchicus.)
Membrana tympani convex externally.
2 6 2-6
10
1 6 n
10
The above measurements are taken on a scale of 1000 parts to an inch.
118
Although the membrana tyrapani be generally con-
sidered as belonging to the intermediate division of the
organ of hearing ; yet, as it forms the boundary between
the external and intermediate divisions, I have therefore
included a description of this membrane in the present
work.
In this table, the convexity of the membrana tympani
is not stated, the size of the tympanal rim is only given :
and therefore, a considerable allowance should be made
when estimating the superficial extent of this important
membrane, particularly in that of the Balsena Mysticetus
and the Monodon Monoceros.
I am engaged at present, in forming an instrument to
ascertain the degree of convexity, or concavity in the
membrana tympani of various animals.
An accurate knowledge of the extent of the concavity
of the membrana tympani in persons, or animals of acute
hearing, as well as of the size of the membrane itself,
may tend to form a criterion, to ascertain the quantum
and strength of the pulsations of sound ; and perhaps
also, the grade of susceptibility in the portio mollis,
necessary to acute auditory perception.*
* The size, form, and angle of attachment of the auricle; as well as that of the
meatus and its secretions, are also absolutely requisite to form au estimate of the
qualities of the recipient parts of the organ of hearing in man.
MEMBRANA TYMPANI
BALiENA MYSTICETUS.
The form of the membrana tympani in most animals,
is so uniform and extremely simple, being- concave
externally, and convex internally, and generally more or
less of an oval figure ; that it requires very little descrip-
tion in order to convey an accurate idea of the propor-
tionate size and figure of the membrane in various
animals, to that of the human subject.
But in the Balsena Mysticetus, the membrana tympani
is of so extraordinary a figure, and so much the reverse
in form and position to that in other animals, or even
the human subject, as to render it an object of investig-a-
tion, meriting a minute and accurate description. In
this animal, the membrana tympani is large and irre-
gular ; convex externally, and internally of a valvular
and double concave figfure.
A tolerable correct idea of the internal appearance of
the membrane may be formed, by supposing* a fold of a
very large membrane to be taken up, and the edge of
120
this fold to run in the direction of, and forming a divi-
sion of its diameter. The slender* process of the
malleus, is attached by its whole length to the edge of this
fold, or duplicate of the membrana tympani ; and which
may be termed the Processus Valvulus (or Valvular
Process). This process is kept tense by the action of the
small muscles of the tympanum, while at the same time,
this tension necessarily causes a correspondent slackness
and depression, or concavity on each side of the process ;
but which is more considerable in the one underneath the
fold (when viewed from the tympanum) than in the other.
The one depression I have termed the Major Con-
cavity, and the other the Minor Concavity.-j- The
muscular coat of these concavities forms externally two
convexities, which are covered, and united by a kind of
fibrous, cellular, membranous substance ; so that the two
convexities form only one oblong convex surface, pro-
truding considerably into the meatus, and covered by
the reflection of the cuticle. J
* There is also a remarkable deviation in the very figure of the malleus from
that of the human subject, and which shall be fully described when treating of the
intermediate division of this organ.
•f- These concavities are deep in proportion to the age of the animal.
J And in this manner one portion of the membrana tympani forms the minor
concavity, and the other the the major concavity, and the edge of the duplicate
or division between them, is termed the Valvular Process ; and these concavities
■when viewed from the meatus, or externally, are consequently of a convex figure.
121
On laying- open the meatus immediately over the
membrana tympani, the parts have a very singular
appearance. The cavity which is oblong, is filled
with the membrana tympani, that assumes, as has been
mentioned, an oblong-, convex, sharp ridged figure.
When this convex substance is inspected closely, there
appears underneath the cuticle* a profusion of nervous
fasciculi, which shine through the thin cuticle, forming
a beautiful reticulated plexus, and of which I have given
a sketch in Plate V. The sharp ridged-like process is
formed of a duplicate of the cuticle covering- the ex-
treme convexity of the membrana tympani, and ex-
tending beyond the membrane.
The main branch of the nerve runs longitudinally be-
tween the cuticle and the membranous substance, and
the beginning of the formation of this sharp ridge, and
sends ofi* numerous branches, which ramify on each side
and cover the convex membrana tympani. On tearing
off the cuticle, the numerous and extremely minute
nervous fasciculi, are seen more distinctly than when
covered ; branching in various directions and piercing the
white membranous substance that is in immediate con-
tact with the cuticle, and are afterwards lost in the
muscular substance of the membrana tympani.
* In a preparation of the meatus of this species of the whale, in my possession,
the cuticle is of a brownish slate colour.
R
122
When this nervous plexus, and also the membranous
substance are removed, the muscular portion of the
membrana tympani is seen underneath, having the ap-
pearance of an oblong convex substance, divided through
its shortest diameter, so that in reality it forms two convex
bodies. The ends of these two convexities of the
muscular portion of the membrana tympani, press so
close on one another, that it is only by introducing a
probe between them, that the depth of this division can
be ascertained. The parts which correspond internally
to this division of the muscular portion of the membrana
tympani, form the valvular process or edge of the fold.*
The extreme convexity of both these divisions are
surmounted by a sharp ridge-like process, which runs
longitudinally, and of which I have endeavoured to
give a sketch in Plate VI.
In this animal, the meatus auditorius externus is of
great length, but very small diameter, and its use is
completely reversed to that of the external meatus in the
human subject. In the Bala3na Mysticetus it serves the
same purpose as the eustachian tube in other animals ; to
admit of the vibratory action of the membrana tympani.
* In one preparation, now before me, the external division between the con-
cavities formed by the muscular coat of the membrana tympani, extends uo
deeper than about three-tenths of an inch, the remaining portions being closely
connected until they form the edge of the Valvular Process.
123
The eustachian tube (in the whale) though short, yet
performs the important office of conducting the pulsa-
tions of sound into the tympanum.* Now, as the tym-
panal extremity of the eustachian tube is situated
obliquely in the tympanum, and also directly opposite to
the valvular process of the membrana tympani ; so it may
thence be inferred, that the above figure of the mem-
brana tympani is admirably adapted to prevent the
resilience of the pulsations of sound as they strike on the
membrane ; and also cause strong vibratory action in the
membrane, and correspondent action in the ossicula
auditus to which the membrana tympani is firmly
attached.
Sir Everard Home, to whom the learned are indebted
for the best account of the muscular structure of the
membrana tympani in the human subject, has also given
a description of this membrane in the Baleena Mysticetus,
(the same species from which the above illustrations were
taken) and attached a drawing of the external, and
another of the internal appearance of this membrane.
* It would certainly add considerably to the anatomical definition of the organ
of hearing in this animal, if the situation and course of the eustachian tube were
delineated, and likewise that of the large cavity adjoining to the osseous tym-
panum, with its cavernous assemblage of carnese columnae and cordas tendinae, but
these, with other parts of the tympanum and labyrinth, are reserved for a work
which I am preparing for the press, on the Comparative Anatomy of the Organs of
Vision and Hearing.
R 2
124
But although few plates are more beautifully executed
than the engravings of his two sketches, yet at the same
time it ought to be remarked, that Sir Everard's repre-
sentation of the parts are very incorrect, as well as his
account of the figure and position of the membrana
tympani in its relation to the ossicula auditus.
In this paper of Sir Everard^s,* after stating how, and
from whom he received the preparation, the subject of
discussion, he gives a short description of the parts, and
then flatly contradicts the account given by Hunter, of
the organ of hearing in this species of the whale tribe,
and endeavours to show, that there is no connexion be-
tween the membrana tympani and the ossicula auditus.
" Having pointed out," says Sir Everard, " that there
is no direct connexion between the membrana tympani
and the ossicula auditus as in other animals, and also
shewn that Hunter^ unwilling to believe that there could
be so great a deviation from the ordinary construction
of this organ, was led into an error, which I can only
attribute to his having formed to himself too strong a
chain of analogies. "f
* An account of some peculiarities in the structure of the organ of hearing in
the Balasna Mysticetus of Linnaeus, By Everard Home, Esq. F.R.S. — Philosophical
Transactions, 1812.
t It might have been thought, that respect for the memory of Hunter, as well
for his talents as consanguinity, would have rendered Sir Everard more wary in
125
He afterwards states, " Within the cavity of the tym-
panum, close to the bony rim to which the membrana
tympani is attached, there is a membranous fold fixed at
one end to the centre of a slight protuberance on the
concave surface of the large hollow bone, and stretched
across the cavity, its loose upper edge forming a line
across the centre of the hollow of the membrana tym-
pani ; the other end passing beyond the cavity to be
attached to the short handle of the malleus, which is
situated immediately behind the membranous lining of
the tympanum."
According to this account of Sir Everard's, his mem-
branous fold has no connexion with the membrana
tympani, (indeed he expressly avows it) but merely a
triangular piece of membrane affixed by its base to the
inside of the cavity, and its apex or point, to the slender
handle of the malleus. Now, instead of its being a
seperate, unconnected membrane, it is bona fide a fold
of the muscular portion of the membrana tympani itself.
The edge of this fold, which I have termed the Valvular
committing himself on a point where that celebrated anatomist was so deeply im-
plicated; but as Sir Everard asserted his opinions on this subject, in direct
opposition to that of the first Physiologist and Anatomist which this country has
produced, for what he conceived to be the truth; so I hope the worthy Baronet will
giant me the same indulgence claimed by himself, when I endeavour to prove, that
Hunter was correct in his description, as far as he went, and that he, (Sir Everard,)
in his description of this membrane, is, to say the least, inaccurate and too hasty
in forming his conclusions.
126
Process, is attached to the whole length of the gracilis,
or slender process of the malleus ; and one portion of it
being reflected backwards and downwards, (viewing the
parts from the tympanum) forms the major concavity ;
and the other reflection of the muscular portion of the
membrana tympani forms the lesser or minor concavity.
And the parts that would necessarily hang loose, (if the
fold were to be formed artificially) are attached to the
body of the malleus ; which in this animal is nearly as
long as any of its two processes in the adult, and longer
than those of the young animal. By this means, the
largest portion of the membrana tympani immediately
under the valvular process, forms a very deep cul d' sac,
while the parts beyond it form another of considerable
less depth ; and their ends coming in contact, form ex-
ternally (as a whole) an oblong convexity which protrudes
into the meatus, similar to the sketch given in Plate VI.
The elevation, or as it is termed, the protuberance
of the osseous parieties of the tympanum, is situated in
some parts about five and a half lines, and in other parts
about three and a half lines from the extreme edge (or
' rim' of Sir Everard) of the osseous cavity of the tym-
panum. The whole of this space is rough for the
attachment of the muscular portion of the membrana
tympani, and also the membranous substance formerly
mentioned ; and occupied by the points of adhesion
127
which it forms, as well for strength as to allow the trans-
mission of vessels and nerves to the membranous
substance lying externally to, but in immediate contact
with the muscular portion of the membrana tympani,
and inside of the reflected cuticle lininof the meatus.
This membranous substance appears to be intended
to afford a bed, or protection for the nervous plexus and
vessels, in order that when contraction of the fibres of
the muscular portion of the membrana tympani takes
place,* there may be no undue pressure on the plexus,
the extremity of the minute branches of which, are lost
in the muscular portion of the membrane.
Sir Everard says, " From the mechanism des-
cribed, it is evident that the impulses made on the
membrana tympani are not immediately communicated
to the ossicula auditus as in other animals, they are only
communicated to the tympanum, and thence to the
chord stretched across its cavity.^ '-j- To this it may be
remarked, that as I have already fully explained both by
sketches and description, that the membrane described by
Sir Everard as attached to the malleus, but forming ac-
cordii^ to his account, no connexion with the mem-
* When in the act of accommodating itself to the pulsations of sound.
f Of what use is the membrana tympani to this species of the whale, if Sir
Everard be correct in his description and physiological illustration of the parts ?
128
brana tympani ; is not only part of that membrane, but
actually forms a duplicate of the whole diameter of the
central part of the muscular portion of the membrana
tympani (in the Greenland whale,) so it is therefore
unnecessary to recapitulate the description of the figure
and position of the parts. And, from its intimate con-
nexion with not only the slender process of the malleus,
but likewise with nearly the whole of the body of that
bone, (which in this animal is of great length and thick-
ness) consequently, the pulsations of sound have the most
powerful effect on the ossicula auditus, by means of their
immediate connexion with the membrana tympani.
And as the surface of the membrana tympani in the
whale, is more than double the size of that membrane in
any other animal ; so it follows, that its large double con-
cave figure will increase the power of the pulsations of
sound in more than a direct ratio of its diameter to that
of the diameter of the membrane in other animals:
because, by means of its valvular and double concave
figure, the whole strength of the pulsations of sound
which may enter the tympanum will be retained, until
the necessary vibratory action of the membrana tympani
takes place.*
* Although, the pulsations of sound pass through the tympanum in order to
arrive at the membrana tympani ; yet they can have little effect on the ossicula
auditus, (individually) as these bones are separated from the great cavity of the
tympanum, by means of a remarkable tough membrane with which it is lined.
129
When Sir Everard writes, " The membrana tympani
of the whale has the means within itself of adjustment
to different sounds, while the animal is under water."
It may be asked, of what use can this power of adjust-
ment be to the animal, if the membrana tympani have
no connexion with the ossicula auditus ; especially when
the pulsations of sound are conducted by the eustachian
tube into the tympanum. For, according' to his descrip-
tion of the parts, the membrana tympani can be of no use
to hearing, at least he does not explain satisfactorily,
in my opinion, how, or in what manner it is ac-
complished.
Sir Everard also adds : *' The long handle of the
malleus is left loose." Now in the recent subject, or
preparation, when carefully made, the extremity of the
long handle of the malleus is always found attached
to the outer edge of the osseous tympanum ; and the
groove in this process, as well as the depression in the
body of the malleus, occupied by the attachment of one
of the small muscles of the tympanum.
The long handle of the malleus is so far from being
loose in its healthy state ; that the extremity of this
process on the one side, and the process of the incus on
the other, form the central points or fulcrum, for the
motion of the ossicula auditus.
130
I have in my possession nearly twenty preparations
of the Ear of the Balsena Mysticetus, of which two are
entire and in situ (in liquid).* Two in the dried state,
with the membrana tympani entire, one of which is in
situ, and the other removed from the cranium. The
remainder are sections, cut so as to show the parts to the
most advantage, several of which are of the petrous
portion, to show^ the large and beautiful cochlea so pre-
eminently conspicuous in this animal. I have also two
preparations of the membrana tympani attached to
only a small portion of the osseous tympanum. In
all these preparations, I have found the membrana tym-
pani uniformly agreeable to the sketches and description
which I have given in this article, j*
As these remarks on the paper and drawings ot
Sir Everard Home, on the organ of hearing in the
Balsena Mysticetus, will be found correct by any person
who may choose to dissect for himself, or consult my
collection of preparations of the Ear of this animal: J
* Prepared from the cranium of a young whale presented to me, in excellent
preservation, by my late pupil Mr. B, Boulter.
f I have also six preparations of the Ear in other species of the whale,
J A celebrated Anatomist and Lecturer, (now no more) showed me, many
years ago, the tympanum of a whale that had been presented to him as the Ear of
that animal ; but of the truth of the assertion he could not be persuaded. When I
showed him one or two specimens of the organ of the Balasna Mysticetus, which I
had prepared, he allowed, that although his museum might be worth more than
131
so I may, perhaps, be allowed the liberty of hazarding
another opinion in addition to those already made
relative to the subject of discussion, namely, that the
Ear of the whale from which Sir Everard took his
sketches and description, was injured. And although
his description and beautiful drawings might be per-
fectly correct, and accurately copied from the appearance
of the preparation before him ; yet, the organ of hearing
in the Greenland whale, when healthy and in situ, varies
considerably from his account, or representation.
And also, that a full and accurate account of the
organ of hearing in most animals, cannot be given
from the dissection of one specimen ; there must be
several, in order to form sectional views of the
various parts, so as to illustrate this most intricate
organ, with its unique membrana tympani. And
I am convinced of the truth of this opinion, from
an error into which I was once led in describing the
meatus of the Squalus Canus from one preparation,
in which the capillary aperture near the valvular
membrane, was some way or other obliterated, and by
this means, the parts had not only the appearance, but
were actually such as I described.
thirty thousand pounds, yet, there was no preparation of this organ in it, which
could compare with my preparations, which he judged to be the most splendid
in Europe.
s2
132
On the suggestion of a friend, that it was possible,
a deviation from this specimen might exist, I procured at
various times, upwards of one hundred recent heads of
the dogfish, and dissected them, and found not only that
which was wanted, but also an additional muscle to
secure and counteract the accidents to which the parts
might be liable, from their very peculiar arrangement.*
But although Sir Everard, from some circumstance
or other, with which I am unacquainted, might have
been led to describe the parts inaccurately; yet his
previous discovery of the muscularity of the membrana
tympani, is sufficient of itself to compensate fully for any
errors which may be found in the above paper.-j*
* For a full account of the meatus of this animal, see Table II. and description
appended ; and also a magnified view of the parts in Plate IV.
f The great difficulty in procuring preparations of the organ of hearing of the
B. Mysticetus, renders it no easy task to give an accurate description of the
parts. Hunter mentions that he equiped several young surgeons, and sent them
to Greenland, in order to procure specimens of the Ear of the whale, but that they
ultimately failed, I have procured situations in fishing vessels for upwards of fifty
young surgeons, the whole of whom failed in procuring me any specimens of the
Ear of this animal, except my late pupil, Mr. B. Boulter, to whose attention and
perseverance, I am indebted for a cranium, which has furnished me with two
beautiful preparations of this organ.
MEMBRANA TYMPANI
MONODON MONOCEROS.
The arrangement of the machinery of the organ of
hearing in the Narwal, affords the finest illustration of
muscularity in the structure of the membrana tympani,
that is perhaps to be found in the Ear of any animal ; and
must ultimately (when fully known) claim the particular
attention of the Anatomist and Physiologist.
The membrana tympani of the Narwal is small when
compared with that of the B. Mysticetus, but consider-
ably larger than the membrana tympani in the human
subject. It is very strong and muscular; concave ex-
ternally, and convex internally, and in figure, has
somewhat the appearance of the flower of the con-
volvulus. As scarcely any description can convey so
accurate an idea of the figure and position of the parts as
a correct delineation, so I have therefore given a sketch
of the appearance of the membrane and adjacent parts,
taken within about an hour after the animal was killed.*
* See Plate VIII.
134
The external figure of the membrane is nearly
circular, the largest diameter exceeding that of the less
by only about ywo-w parts of an inch. In the note
attached to page nine of this work, its convexity is
described as greater than its diameter ; such indeed is
the appearance of the membrane in the recent state, but
the measurements specified in Table III. are taken from
the dried preparation, and must therefore be rather less
than that of the recent subject. And even in the dried
state, there is only -yo^-o parts of an inch of difference
between the height or apex of the convexity, and the
greatest diameter of the membrane.
The apex of the convexity of the membrane, forms a
strong, powerful, but small muscle, that may be termed
the Terminative Muscle of the membrana tympani, and
which measures only y^^-q- parts of an inch, at its in-
sertion to the malleus.* There is certainly a great
deviation in the figure and attachment of the membrana
tympani of the Narwal from that of all other animals
with which I am acquainted. It is connected to the
* In the preparation of the membrana tympani of the Narwal, now before me, the
Terminative Muscle, (formed by the converging and coalescing fibres of the mem-
brane) measures in length about two hundred and seventy, one thousand parts of
an inch, and at its formation is about one hundred and seventy, one thousand parts
of an inch in breadth ; and contracts gradually to fifty-five, one thousand parts of
an inch, at its insertion into the malleus. The preparation is in the dried state,
and therefore soma allowance should be made for the parts forming the concavity,
adhering, and thereby increasing the length of the Terminative Muscle,
135
ossicula by an extremely small but strong attachment,
in such a manner, as to command and regulate, in
conjunction with the muscles of the tympanum, the
motions of that bone with great precision and effect.
In most animals, the manubrium of the malleus is
attached and firmly connected to about two-thirds of the
large diameter of the membrana tympani ; but in the
Narwal, the breadth of the attachment is only about the
one-eighteenth of the surface of the convexity of the
membrane.
The malleus is of an irregular figure, and shaped some-
what like that of the B. Mysticetus, but neither so long
nor thick. The body of the bone which measures about
three times the length of its breadth, and when in situ, and
viewed from the tympanum, lies in a line with the direc-
tion of the meatus, having a broad, flat, hollow, triangular
process, that arises from about half the length of the
malleus, and which tapers gradually to a small point
that is lodged in a depression of the tympanum.
The extremity of the Terminative Muscle of the
membrane, is firmly attached to a tuberosity or process
near the interior end or foot of the malleus, when viewed
as in Plate VIII. where the half of the length of the con-
verging convexity of the membrana tympani appears
136
beyond the central line of the triangular process, the
extremity of which process, forms one point of the ful-
crum of the ossicula, or machinery of the tympanum.
The effect which this peculiarity in figure and attach-
ment of the membrana tympani, the form and position of
the ossicula, as well as the susceptibility of the beautiful
plexus of nervous fasciculi in the tympanum, may have,
in rendering the hearing of the Narwal acute, whether
the pulsations of sound be conveyed by the meatus, or
the enormous cavity formed by the eustachian tube ; and
also its adaptation to the atmosphere, but more particu-
larly to the denser medium of the ocean ; will be con-
sidered at some length in a work preparing for the press,
to which I have had occasion to allude in several parts
of this treatise.
The physiology of the organ of hearing in the Narwal,
forms a more intricate and diversified subject for dis-
cussion, than even that of the B. Mysticetus ; especially
when we consider the extreme acuteness of hearing, and
the variety of figure and position in the arrangement of
the various parts of this organ ; and must therefore give a
greater scope to physiological discrimination than that of
any animal in the Northern Ocean.*
* The above notes regard only the muscular portion (or coat) of the membrana
tympani of the Sea Unicorn.
TABLE IV.
CONTAINING THE
SIZE AND ANGLE OF ATTACHMENT
OF
THE AURICLE.
LONGITUDINAL AND HORIZONTAL DIAMETERS OF THE
CONCHA,
AND ALSO THAT OF THE MEATUS AT THE EXTERNAL
ORIFICE,
IN ONE HUNDRED LIVING INDIVIDUALS.
o
s
a
o
1
nS
O
bn
IS
d
a
'3
a
2
a
1
O
00
•n
.a
o.
a>
1
a
o
_aj
bo
2
CO
o
■2
J3
a
o
5
ns
■a
1
d
^
,£
§
60
a
I
bb
a
Cli
a
tH
■3
c
■a
Pi
p^
&5
^
C4
"bi
o-
^
g
"«
&
13
a
J3
a
■rt
O
O
fn
o
t-i
a.
3
>
o
^
»
bo
t».
1
1
S
><
c
'l4
H
So
a
f
bo
hi
1
a
o
bb
,2
1
1
1
6'
o
a
o
o
bo
.9
o
1
bi
a
*(-
(S
3
«
.2
o
1
a
-a
d
a
>.
g
a
1
1
_3
a
1
a
a
§
Z
3
T3
1
>>
1
s
.a
^■s
aj
^
a,
w
n
a
,fl
3
^
^
a
g
-"_
S
ttf
o
§
3
Cl!
3
a
ra
o
a
1
o
c
o
bo
3
o
■3
o
-a
.a
u
"3
3
'a'
he
_o
3
a
S
Sao
g
3
a
a
be
a
*E-i
bo
_a
't-
O
o
3
a
'a
Q
3
a
S
bo
.a
o
o
2
S
bo
K
fi
S
o
a
Q
Q
p
a
w
p
p
P
P
P
P
.H
-In
rH
00|-f
t—i
T-H
CO
Cl
C^
pH
pH
Cl
pH
ci"
Cl
Cl
pH
pH
cf
Cl"
H
a
H
ti
!-(((?»
wM
T-ilrei
rHl^
Hl'^
h|o»
-!«
Hw
-b
^l-p
Hu5
-h
-|«
s
3
CO
rf
'^
CO
'i*
Tj'
Tl*
rt<
CO
O
o
CO
C«
Tf
Cl
CO
^
Tt*
ri*
ri^
N
P>|(?3 r-)l(?)
r-l-f ClI-*
l-(lo«
Hlf^)
^If^)
M|i5>) col-*
HlG^
-H
He<
wl(M
Ml50 CJ5|.^
Hl(?(
<
■g
o
^«.
00
»>.
on
fN.
00
00
»>.
O
©
©
00
00
l>»
00
00
Oi
pH
©
a;
p-t
-iii^
I?:!-*
-'"l
m|-f,
-h
wIrM
GOl-*
©
00
©
©
©
00
©
©
©
©
©
rH
©
©
u, c
.o
(-*>
•-")
(^
^
^
o
©
©
©
©
©
©
©
©
©
©
©
©
°£
'CO
o
©
©
©
©
©
©
©
©
©
©
©
©
©
©
CO
©
ujf
o"^
>o
>o
»0
©
©
CO
00
©
©
>o
©
©
1-H
©
CO
©
Pi
©
»
<
CO
CO
p-l
rt*
Tt<
Tt*
■*
(M
CO
l-l
Tl^
pH
Cl
CO
pH
PH
eo
d
Cl
o 3
wi-t
r-l|l?l ISOl-j.
r-l-f
r-l-t GlH
GoH «!•+ i-