F HX00030074 RECAP KAIIJ"/ CSQ Columbia ©tttoergftp ^./ College of -pfjpsiictans anfc burgeons' library MEDICAL v . JUEISPRTJDENCE OF INSANITY OR FORENSIC PSYCHIATRY. BY S. V. OLEYEJSTGER, M. D., Attending Physician Adexian Brothers' Hospital, Consulting Physician Michael Reese Hospital, Chicago; Associate Editor of the Alienist Tnd Neurologist. Formerly Medical Superintendent op the Illinois Eastern Hospital for the Insane, Pathologist of the County Insane Asylum, Chicago ; Professor of Anatomy, Art In- stitute, Chicago ; Lecturer on Physics, Chicago College of Pharmacy; Author of Compar- ative Physiology and Psychology, Spinal Concussion, etc. With an Exhaustive Presentation op the Judicial Decisions upon the Subject. BY F. H. BOWLBY, Counselor at Law, of the Publishers' Editorial Staff. VOLUME I. 1898 THE LAWYERS' CO-OPERATIVE PUBLISHING COMPANY ROCHESTER, NEW YORK. Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2010 with funding from Open Knowledge Commons http://www.archive.org/details/medicaljurisprud01clev TABLE OF CONTENTS. VOLUME I. CHAPTER I. INTRODUCTION. Medical jurisprudence of insanity. Work of Dr. Isaac Ray. Changes in judicial views. Specialism in medical j urisprudence 1-4 CHAPTER II. DEFINITIONS. Difficulties of definition. Definitions of insanity. Legal definitions of insanity. Tests of insanity. Delusion test. Right and wrong test. Rule that there is no test... 5-2C CHAPTER III. CLASSIFICATION. Classifications of various authors. Medico-legal working classification 27-30 CHAPTER IV. SYMPTOMS. Asylum observations of symptoms. Conduct of patients. Premedita- tion. Design. Business ability. Superstitions concerning insanity. Excitement. Depression. Insane actions. Disappearances. Con- sciousness. Memory derangements. Delusions. Hallucinations. Illusions. Physical conditions. Insane odor. Insane manner. Insane appearance. Insane ear. Menstruation 31-61 CHAPTER V. DIAGNOSIS. Diagnosis in general. Lucid intervals. Concealed insanity. Feigned insanity. Cases of feigned insanity 62-79 CHAPTER VI. CRIMINAL CASES. Crime in general. Criminal anthropology. Insanity as a defense. In- sanity after verdict or judgment. Homicidal insanity. Sexual crimes. Larceny or kleptomania. Arson. Forgery. Assaults. False accusations. False confessions. Malicious mischief. Motive in crime. Instigation to crime. Hypnotism. Evidence of insanity. Insane as witnesses. Medical evidence. Hypothetical case. Re- sponsibility. : 80-123 v V) TABLE OF CONTENTS. CHAPTER VII. LEGAL ADJUDICATIONS IN CRIMINAL CASES. I. General insanity. --- 125-164 § 1. What insanity affects criminal responsibility. § 2. Infant or wild beast test. § 3. Delusion test. § 4. Abstract right and wrong test. § 5. Test of right and wrong as to particular act. § 6. Test of knowledge of the nature of the act. § 7. Combina- tion of the above tests. § 8. Cases denying the existence of a test. § 8a. The case of State v. Jones. § 9. Time of application of tests. § 10. Insanity as affecting the degree of crime. II. Partial insanity . . 164-177 § 1. Definitions. § 2. Test of criminal responsibility. § 3. De- lusions — definition and nature. § 4. Delusions — effect on crimi- nal responsibility. § 5. Moral insanity defined. §6. The rule that moral mania is not a defense. § 7. The contrary rule. § 8. Kleptomania. § 9. Erotomania. III. Temporary and recurrent insanity 177-178 IV. Existence of insanity — how determined . 178-180 V. Proof necessary to establish insanity.. 180-192 § 1. Generally. § 2. Previous and subsequent insanity. § 3. Nature of the crime, g 4. Motives. § 5. Acts and conduct. § 6. Personal characteristics. § 7. Exciting causes of insanity. § 8. Hereditary insanity. £ 9. Judicial determination of insanity. VI. Insanity at and after trial 192-201 § 1. Effect. § 2. Question, when and how raised. § 3. Deter- mination as to submission of issues. § 4. Questions for deter- mination. §5. How determined. §6. Effect and conclusiveness of the determination. §7. Insanity after verdict. §8. Effect of recovery. VII. Incapacity of female which -will affect rape 201-203 CHAPTER VIII. CIVIL CASES. Civil rights. Imbecility. Crazy. Unsound mind. Delusion. Moral insanity. Partial insanity. Lunatics. Mental enfeeblement. Political rights. Impeachment. Torts. Defamation. False accusations and confessions. Punitive damages. Contracts. Promissory notes. Partnerships. Patents. Conveyances. Rati- fication. Life insurance. Suicide. Conservation. Evidence. Habeas corpus. Personal injury. Subjective symptoms. Tes- tamentary capacity. Degrees of capacity. Unnatural disposition of property. Old age. In insanity generally. Lucid intervals. Physical disabilities. Delusions and strange beliefs. Prejudices against relatives. Undue influence 204-237 TABLE OF CONTENTS. Vll CHAPTER IX. LEGAL ADJUDICATIONS IN CIVIL CASES. I. General considerations 238-242 § 1. Rules applicable to civil cases. § 2. Lucid intervals. II. Contracts 242-250 § 1. What mental incapacity affects. § 2. Tests. § 3. Effect of partial insanity. § 4. Mental incapacity combined with fraud. III. Conveyances 250-260 § 1. What mental incapacity affects. § 2. Tests. § 3. Time of application of tests. § 4. Effect of partial insanity. § 5. Mental incapacity combined with fraud. IV. Proofs to establish insanity with relation to contracts and conveyances. 260-273 § 1. Measure and weight. § 2. Sufficiency, how determined. § 3. Previous and subsequent insanity. § 4. Nature of the act. §5. Previous intentions. §6. Acts and conduct. §7. Conduct of others. § 8. Age; weakness; disease. § 9. Adjudications of unsoundness. V. Wills... 273-375 §1. What insanity affects — generally. §2. Age; weakness; disease. § 3. Failure of memory. § 4. Eccentricity. § 5. Capacity as compared with the character of the act. § 6. Delusion test. § 7. Test of capacity for criminal responsibility. § 8. Test of capacity to contract. § 9. Test of capacity to transact ordinary business. § 10. Test of capacity to understand the transaction. § 11. Com- bined test; capacity to understand claims to bounty. § 12. Test of capacity to collect, hold, and consider the facts. § 13. Time of application of tests. § 14. Partial insanity defined. § 15. What partial insanity affects testamentary capacity. § 16. Insane de- lusions defined. § 17. Effect on testamentary capacity. § 18. What delusions destroy capacity. § 19. Delusions as to the person affected. §20. Speculative beliefs. §21. Moral insanity. §22. Incapacity in connection with undue influence or fraud. § 23. Testamentary capacity — how determined. § 24. Submission of the issue. § 25. Proof to establish — generally. § 26. Previous and subsequent insanity. § 27. Testimony of attesting witnesses and others present. § 28. Preparation of the will. § 29. Rationality. § 30. Equality and justice. § 31. Conformity to previous inten- tions. § 32. Subsequent recognition. § 33. Capacity to transact business. § 34. Acts and conduct. § 35. Suicide. § 36. Change of character or disposition. § 37. Advanced age and attendant defects. § 38. Physical condition. § 39. Hereditary insanity. § 40. Proof as to partial insanity, and delusion. § 41. Proof of undue influence or fraud and incapacity. § 42. Proof of knowl- edge, capacity, and intent. § 43. Unexecuted and nuncupative wills. § 44. Proof of lucid intervals. § 45. Revocation of wills. Vlli TABLE OF CONTENTS. VI. Gifts - 375-379 § 1. later vivos. §2. Of a testamentary character. VII. Partnership; what insanity warrants dissolution 379-380 VIII. Agency... — 381 IX. Public office .. 382 X. Marriage 382-391 § 1. "What incapacity affects. § 2. Tests. § 3. The question, how determined. § 4. Proof to establish capacity or incapacity. XI. Divorce.. 391-397 § 1. Insanity as a ground for. § 2. Insanity as affecting adultery. § 3. Insanity as affecting desertion. § 4. Insanity as affecting cruelty. § 5. Insanity as affecting the action. XII. Settlement or domicil 397-398 XIII. Statute of limitations. _ - 398-401 XIV. Judgments 401-402 XV. Bankruptcy 402 XVI. Insurance 403-413 § 1. Insanity as a breach of warranty. § 2. Homicide by insane act. § 3. Insanity as affecting suicide. § 4. Test of consciousness and intent. § 5. Test of capacity to understand moral character of the act. § 6. Test of responsibility for criminal acts. § 7. Suicide under conditions against self-destruction, sane or insane. § 8. Suicide as affecting accident insurance. § 9. Insanity as affecting mutual insurance. § 10. Existence of insanity, how determined. § 11. Proof as to insanity. XVII. Guardianship 418-443 § 1. Inquisitions — nature. § 2. What incapacity warrants. § 3. Age; disease; weakness. § 4. Tests. § 5. The question, by whom determined. § 6. Proof necessary to establish. § 7. In- quisition as evidence — as to subsequent acts. § 8. Effect of in- quisition on over-reached acts. § 9. Effect of inquisition with respect to parties. § 10. Evidence to rebut inquisition. § 11. When superseded. XVIII. Right to restrain 443-447 § 1. General rules as to confinement. § 2. Discharge from con- finement. CHAPTER X. EVIDENCE OF INSANITY. I. Presumption and burden of proof 449-464 § 1. Presumption of sanity. § 2. Burden of proof of insanity — generally. § 3. Burden of proof in criminal cases. § 4. Burden of proof in will cases. TABLE OF CONTENTS. IX II. Measure of proof 464-477 § 1. Conflicting character of the criminal cases. § 2. Beyond a reasonable doubt. §3. Preponderance of proof. § 4. Reasonable doubt of insanity. § 5. Measure of proof in civil cases. III. Presumption op continuance 477-489 § 1. Habitual insanity. § 2. Temporary insanity. § 3. Habitual and temporary insanity distinguished. § 4. Presumption of con- tinuance of a lucid interval. IV. Competency and admissibility 489-535 § 1. Previous and subsequent condition of mind. § 2. .The act itself. § 3. Former wills and deeds. § 4. Declarations and ad- missions of the party. § 5. Declarations and admissions of olher interested persons. § 6. Letters and private writings. § 7. Acts and conduct. § 8. Surrounding circumstances. § 9. Relationship between the parties interested. § 10. Physical and mental con- dition. § 11. Hereditary insanity. § 12. Reputation and hearsay. § 13. Adjudications and certificates of lunacy. V. Expert and opinion evidence. 536-600 § 1. Admissibility of opinions of experts — generally. § 2. Opin- ions founded on examination. § 3. Opinions based upon the evidence. §4. Opinions upon hypothetical questions. § 5. Qual- ification of experts. § 6. Scope of opinion of experts. § 7. Cross- examination of experts. § 8. General rules as to nonexpert opinions. § 9. Exceptions to the general rule. § 10. Who may give. § 11. The acquaintance necessary. § 12. Knowledge which will warrant an opinion. § 13. Facts which may be shown as a basis for an opinion, § 14. Scope of opinions of nonexperts. § 15. Opinions covering the question at issue. § 16. Time to which opinion evidence relates. § 17. Weight— expert opinion. § 18. Weight — nonexpert opinions. VI. Attesting witnesses — 601-605 VII. Books - -- 605-606 CHAPTER XL WITNESSES AND JURORS. I. Competency op witnesses 607-615 II. Competency op jurors 615-616 TABLE OF CONTENTS. VOLUME II. CHAPTER XII. ALCOHOLISM. The first effect of alcoholic liquors. Long-continued and excessive use of alcoholic liquor. Post-alcoholic conditions. Alcoholic epilepsy. Local statistics of alcoholism. The causes of drunk- enness. Delirium tremens, or mania a potu. Alcoholic trance. Dipsomania. Oinomania. Alcoholic paretic dementia. Chronic alcoholic insanity. Alcoholic dementia. Cases of alcoholism and alcoholic insanity 617-659 CHAPTER XIII. LEGAL CONSEQUENCES OF ALCOHOLISM. Definitions of drunkenness. The rule that drunkenness is no excuse for crime. Drunkenness as an aggravation of an offense. Mitigat- ing circumstances. Delirium tremens, or mania a potu. Insanity from habitual drunkenness. Reduction of the degree of crime. Confessions. False accusations. Absence of reasonable motive. The legal consequences of drunkenness in civil cases. Testa- mentary capacity in relation to the effect of liquor. The super- visory and controlling laws. Retreats for habitual drunkards... 660-681 CHAPTER XIY. THE DECISIONS OF THE COURT AS TO ALCOHOLISM. I. Alcoholism as affecting criminal law 682-718 § 1. Intoxication as an excuse for crime. § 2. "When intoxication may be shown generally. § 3. Larceny, burglary, etc. § 4. Homicide, § 5. Intoxication as affecting deliberation and pre- meditation. § 6. Assaults. § 7. Attempt to commit suicide. § 8. Involuntary drunkenness. §9. Wilful drunkenness; insane tend- encies. § 10. Insanity induced by alcoholism. § 11. Intoxica- tion under the Texas statute. § 12. Intoxication of the person injured. II. Alcoholism as affecting contracts 719-729 § 1. What intoxication affects generally. § 2. Intoxication com- bined with fraud or undue influence. § 3. Discharge of employee for intoxication. TABLE OF CONTENTS. XI III. Alcoholism as affecting conveyances 729-733 IV. Alcoholism as affecting wills 788-740 V. ALCOIIOLISM AS AFFECTING GIFTS - 740-741 VI. Alcoholism as affecting marriage 741-743 VII. Alcoholism as affecting divorce 743-755 §1. Drunkenness as a ground for. §2. Drunkenness as affecting cruel and inhuman treatment. § 3. Drunkenness as affecting desertion. VIII. Alcoholism as affecting offices and places of trust.. 755-757 IX. Alcoholism as affecting the statute of limitations... 757-758 X. Alcoholism as affecting insurance 758-763 XI. Guardianship and restraint of alcoholics 763-768 § 1. What drunkenness warrants. § 2. Inquisition of habitual drunkenness as evidence. XII. Alcoholism as affecting negligence _ 76S-776 XIII. Proof of intoxication... 776-795 § 1. Presumptions and burden of proof. § 2. Measure of proof. § 3. Proof of the fact of intoxication. § 4. General character and habits. § 5. Previous and subsequent intoxication. § 6. Acts, conduct, and declarations. § 7. Admissions and confessions. § 8. Opinions as to intoxication. XIV. Intoxication as affecting witnesses 795-797 CHAPTER XV. MOKPHINISM AND OTHER ADDICTIONS. Absinthe drinking. Darnel seeds as an adulterant of liquors. The cocaine habit and insanity. The opium or morphine habit. In- sanity from opium using. Other injurious drugs. 798-804 CHAPTER XVI. LEGAL ADJUDICATIONS AS TO MORPHINISM. 805-S08 CHAPTER XVII. HEAD INJURIES. Concussion of the brain. Compression of the brain. Traumatic in- sanity. Traumatic epilepsy and the insanity of epilepsy. Mania from traumatism. Traumatic imbecility. Traumatic idiocy. Cerebral syphilis and syphilitic insanity complications. Trau- matic paretic dementia. Alcoholism and alcoholic insanity com- plications. Traumatic dementia. Cases of head injury. Prog- nosis of traumatic insanity 809-840 Xll TABLE OF CONTENTS. CHAPTER XVIII. DEGENERACY. Cerebral neurasthenia. Casque neurasthenique. Obsessions of inde- cision. Obsessions of fear. Obsession propensities. Onomato- mania. Kleptomania. Pyromania. Dipsomania. Suicidal im- pulses. Homicidal impulses. Erotic or indecent propensities. Destructive propensities. The impulse to throw one's self from a height. Aboulic obsessions. Obsessions in general. Phrenas- thenia. Paranoia. Verrucktheit. Megalomania. Persecutory cases. Ambitious cases. Litigious cases. The mystics. Folie d . deux. Idiocy. Genetous or congenital idiocy. Microcephalic idiocy. Eclampsic idiocy. Epileptic idiocy. Hydrocephalic idiocy. Paralytic idiocy. Cretinism. Traumatic idiocy. In- flammatory idiocy. Idiocy by deprivation. Syphilitic idiocy. Idiot savants. Causes of idiocy. Imbecility. Moral imbecility. Cases of degeneracy. . - 841-901 CHAPTER XIX. AGE. Senility. Senile insanity. Senile dementia. Cases of senility or senile dementia. The climacteric. Climacteric insanity. Puberty. Masturbatory insanity. Hebephrenia 902-943 CHAPTER XX. VESANIAS. Vesanise. Delirium. Mania. Hypochondria. Hypochondriasis. Hypochondriacal melancholia. Melancholia. Melancholia agitata. Melancholia attonita. Post febrile insanity. Primary dementia. Stuporous insanity. Conf usional insanity. Moral insanity. Emo- tional insanity. Transitory frenzy. Cases of alleged transitory frenzy 944-978 CHAPTER XXI. CHILDBIRTH. Mental states during pregnancy. Puerperal convulsions. Puerperal insanity. Lactational insanity 979-987 CHAPTER XXII. PERIODICITY. Periodical or recurrent insanity. Periodical mania. Periodical melancholia. Katatonia. Circular insanity. Period of depres- sion. Melancholia. Melancholia cum stupore. The physical symptoms. Period of excitement. Kleptomania. Dipsomania. Eroticism. Maniacal excitement with incoherence. Mania with ideas of exaltation. Physical symptoms. Lucid interval. For- ensic medicine. Cases of periodical insanity 988-1019 TABLE OF CONTENTS. Mil CHAPTER XXIII. HYSTERIA. Mental hysteria. Lyssaphobia. Temporary hysterical insanity. Hysterical insanity.. 1020-1033 CHAPTER XXIV. EPILEPSY. Major epilepsy. Minor epilepsy. Mental epilepsy. Epileptic in- sanity; paroxysmal mental disturbances; epileptic mania. Inter- paroxysmal mental state. Cases of epilepsy and epileptic in- sanity 1034-1064 CHAPTER XXV. LEGAL ADJUDICATIONS AS TO EPILEPSY. _ 1065-1070 CHAPTER XXVI. PHTHISIS. Tuberculosis. Phthisical insanity. Suspiciousness 1071-1074 CHAPTER XXVII. RHEUMATISM AND GOUT. Rheumatic insanity. Gouty insanity 1075 CHAPTER XXVIII. DESTRUCTIVE BRAIN DISEASES. Aphasia. Amnesia. Amnesic aphasia. Ataxic aphasia. Para- phasia. Monophasia. Agraphia. Alexia. Amimia. Apraxia. Aphonia. Softening of the brain. Dementia from coarse brain disease. Atheromatous insanity. Delirium grave. Syphilis. Cerebral syphilis. Syphilitic dementia. Syphilitic paretic dementia. Paretic dementia. Terminal dementia. Cases of paretic dementia 1076-1 103 CHAPTER XXIX. ETIOLOGY. Causes of insanity. Proportion per cent to the admission. Moral causes. Physical causes. Diseases. Poisons. Predisposition. Idiosyncrasy. Civilization. Emotionalism. Sexes. Ages. Seasons. Marriages. Professions. Heredity : — immediate, mediate, simple, cumulative, double, direct, collateral, ho- mochronous, anticipatory, similar or homologous, dissimilar or transformed, progressive, regressive.. 1104-1123 TABLE OF CONTENTS. CHAPTER XXX. PROGNOSIS. 1124-1127 CHAPTER XXXI. PATHOLOGY. Perverted circulation. Toxaemias. Auto-toxsemias. Brain deform- ities. Brain degradation 1128-1165 CHAPTER XXXII. TREATMENT. Malpractice. Lavage. Gavage. Evacuants. Hypnotics. Stim- ulants. Tonic treatment. Hydrotherapy. Moral influences. Diversion. Hygiene. Hypnotic suggestion. Employment. Restraint or nonrestraint. Classification. Admissions. Dis- charges. Correspondence. Visitors. Supervision. Attendants. Maintenance 1166-1256 APPENDIX. SCIENTIFIC BOOKS AND TREATISES AS EVIDENCE. I. Exact sciences 1257 §1. General rule as to admissibility. §2. Tables of expectancy of life. § 3. Almanacs. II. Inexact sciences ... 1266 § 1. General rule as to admissibility. § 2. Reasons for the rule. §3. The contrary rule. §4. Opinions founded on books. §5. Use of, on examination. § 6. Use of, to sustain or discredit experts. § 7. Use of, on cross-examination. § 8. Use of, in argument. III. Law _ 1281 IV. Miscellaneous matters 1284 CASES CITED. Aber v. Clark, Den, 10 N. J. L. 258, 18 Am. Dec. 417. 431, 438, 439 Abraham v. Wilkins, 17 Ark. 292 274, 280, 286, 559, 601 Accident Ins. Co. v. Crandall, 120 U. S. 527, 30 L. ed. 740-404 Achey «. Stephens, 8 Ind. 411 241, 261, 451, 478 Adams v. State, 34 Tex. Crim. Rep. 470__. 578 Adamson v. Smith, 2 Mill Const. 269, 12 Am. Dec. 665.. 400 Addingtou v. Wilson, 5 Ind. 137, 61 Am. Dec. 81.306, 330, 333 Adkins v. Columbia L. Ins. Co. 70 Mo. 27, 35 Am. Rep. 410 411 Adler v. State, 35 Ark. 517, 37 Am. Rep. 48 ..193, 199 iEtna L. Ins. Co. v. Davey, 123U. S. 739, 31 L. ed. 315. .. 759, 760, 761, 807 v. Deming, 123 Ind. 384.761, 762 v Hanna, 81 Tex. 487 762 Aikin v. Weckerly, 19 Mich. 482.. 279 291 344, 460, 461, 462,' 476,' 477 Aiman v. Stout, 42 Pa. 114 243, 251, 269, 586 Alcock v. Royal Exch. Assur. Corp. 13 Q. B. 292.... 789 Aldrich v. Bailey, 132 N. Y. 85.. 253, 260 Alexanders. Alexander, 5 Ala. 517-311 Alexander's Will, 27 N. J. Eq. 463-346 Alger v. Lowell, 3 Allen, 402 769, 770, 771, 775 Allcard v. Skinner (1887) L. R. 36 Ch. Div. 181... 235 Alleman v. Stepp, 52 Iowa, 626... 613 Allen v. Allen, 31 Mo. 479 752 v. Griffin, 69 Wis. 529 459 v. Public Administrator, 1 Bradf. 378 316, 459 «. State, 60 Ala. 19 610, 614 Allis®. Moore, 2 Allen, 306 400 Allison v. Allison, 7 Dana, 91.374, 604 v. Allison, 46 111. 61, 92 Am. Dec. 237. 321, 323 Allison v. Taylor, 6 Dana, 87, 32 Am. Dec. 68 401 Allison's Case, 35 N. Y. S. R. 363. 377 Allore v. Jewell, 94 U. S. 506, 24 L. ed. 260 _.:_258, 259, 399 Alstons. Boyd, 6 Humph. 5U4... 246 v. Jones, 17 Barb. 276 339 American Bible Soc. v. Price, 115 111. 623 296, 301, 304, 311, 329, 559 American L. Ins. Co. v. Isett, 74 Pa. 176.. 408,409 American Seaman's Friend Soc. v. Hopper, 33 N. Y. t>19._ 278. 282, 295, 301 Ames's Case, 51 Iowa, 596.351, 505, 543 Anderdon v. Burrows, 4 Car. & T. 210 443 Anderson v. Cranmer, 11 W. Va. 562 255, 263, 451, 454, 479, 481, 561 v. Irwin, 101 111. 411 462 v. State, 43 Conn. 514, 21 Am. Rep. 669 90, 126, 163, 164, 172 v. State, 42 Ga. 9 130, 171, 470, 551 v. State, 25 Neb. 550 126, 131. 135 Andress v. Weller, 3 N. J. Eq. 604 274, 286, 288, 488, 734, 737, 77S, 779 Andrews's Case, 33 N. J. Eq. 514. 592 Angell v. Probate Court, 11 R. I. 187 419 Anonymous, 17 Abb. N. C. 231.. 749 21 Am. Jurist. 7 664 2 Kay & J. 441.. 380, 381 4 Pick. 32 ...3S4, 386, 389 Anthony v. Hutchins, 10 R. I. 165 251, 257 Appleby v. Brock, 76 Mo. 314.5S4, 563 Arbery v. Ashe, 1 Hagg. Eccl. Rep. 214 341 Argo v. Coffin, 142 111. 368 269, 449, 453 Armor v. State, 63 Ala. 176... 695, 794 Armour's Estate, 154 Pa. 517 307 Armstrong v. Farrar, 8 Mo. 627. . 503, 505 v. Short, 1 Hawks. 11.. 430, 451 v. State, 27 Fla. 366. ...471, 474 XV XVI CASES CITED. Armstrong v. State,30 Fla. 170, 17 L. R. A. 484 181, 457, 471, 477, 479, 557, 561, 596 v. Timmons, 3 Harr. (Del.) 342..449, 477, 478, 608, 612 Arnold v. Hickman, 6 Munf. 15.. 720 v. Richmond Iron Works, 1 Gray, 434 209 v. Townsend, 14 Phila. 216 439 Arnold's Case (1724) 16 How. St. Tr. 695, Harg. St. Tr. 322 13, 128, 134. 139 Case. 14 Hun, 525 584, 589 Asbury v. Fair, 111 N. C. 251 263, 399, 400 Ash's Case, Freem. Ch. 259_ 446 Asbcraft v. De Armond, 44 Iowa, 229 491,493, 494. 528 Aszman v. State, 123 Ind. 347, 8 L. R.A. 331. -.27,180, 682, 684, 688, 689, 693, 699, 701 Atkins v. Sanger, 1 Pick. 192 504 Atkinson, Ex parte, Jac. Ch. 333.. 425 v. Medford, 46 Me. 510 384 Attorney General v. Parnther, 3 Bro. Ch.441.___67, 242, 370, 371, 372, 453, 479, 526 Atwood v. Smith, 11 Ala. 894 427 Aubert v. Aubert, 6 La. Ann. 104 242, 275, 284, 525 Aurantz v. Anderson, 3 Pittsb. 310 241, 261, 478, 480, 481, 483 Aurora «. Hillman, 90 111. 61 771, 775, 795 Austen v. Graham, 29 Eng. L. & Eq. 38 315, 329 Avery v. Avery, 33 Kan. 1, 52 Am. Rep. 523 394 Ayres v. Ayres, 43 K J. Eq. 565. . 355, 805, 1072 v. State (Tex. Crim. App.) 26 S. W. 396 698, 705 Ayrey v. Hill, 2 Add. Eccl. Rep. 206 733 B. Baccigalupo v. Com. 33 Gratt. 807, 36 Am. Rep. 795... 456, 467 Bachmeyer v. Mut. Reserve Fund L. Ins. Asso. 82 Wis. 255, 87 Wis. 328 412, 413, 415, 417, 477 Bagshaw v. Parker, 10 Beav. 532 379 Bailev v. State, 26 Ind. 422... 682, 709 Bailey's Case, 7 Jur. N. S.712.... 347 Baker 0. Baker, 82 Ind. 146..391, 393 Baker v. Baker, L. R. 5 Prob. Div. 142, 49 L. J. Prob. N. S. 49, 42 L. T. N. S. 332, 28 Week. Rep. 630, Aff'd in L. R. 6 Prob. Div. 12, 49 L. J. Prob. N. S. 83 396 0. Cartw right, IOC. B. K S. 124 383 0. Lewis, 4 Rawle, 356 330 Baldrick v. Garvey, 66 Iowa, 16.. 270 Baldwin v. Dunton, 40 111. 181... 244, 245, 248 v. Parker, 99 Mass. 792, 96 Am. Dec. 697 308 v. State, 12 Mo. 223 173. 467, 558, 589 v. State, 15 Tex. App. 275.. 202 Baldwin's Appeal, 44 Conn. 37... 605 Estate, 13 Wash. 666 462 Ball®. Com. (Ky.) 18 Cent. L. J. 438, 16 Chicago Leg. News, 289 466 v. Mannin, 3 Bli$rh, U. S. 1, lDow&C.880.251,252, 254 Ballantine 0. Proudfoot, 62 Wis. 216 289, 296, 302 Ballard v. State, 19 Neb. 610 457, 543, 685 Ballew v. Clark, 2 Ired. L. 23 449. 454, 478, 480 Balston v. Turpin, 129 U. S. 663, 32 L. ed. 747, 25 Fed. Rep. 7 732 Baltimore & O. R. Co. v. Boteler, 38 Md. 568 770, 775, 785 v. Henthorne, 73 Fed. Rep. 634 786 «. State, Chambers, 81 Md. 371 770 Banker v. Banker, 63 N. Y. 409, 388, 435, 437 Banks v. Goodfellow (1870) L. R. 5 Q. B. 549... 157, 158, 224 v. Goodfellow, 22 L. T. N. S. 820 289, 293, 294, 296, 297, 298, 309, 343, 344, 461 Bannatyne 0. Bannatyne, 14 Eng. L. & Eq. 581, 16 Jur. 864 242, 372, 436, 439 Bannister v. Jackson, 45 N. J. Eq. 702 488,734, 737 Barber v. Barber (Conn.) 14 Law Rep. 375 744, 808 Barber's Appeal, 63 Conn. 393, 22 L. R. A. 90 457, 458, 462, 476, 477, 543, 552 Barbo v. Rider, 67 Wis. 598 429 Barker v. Comins, 110 Mass. 477.. 290, 334, 460, 461, 495, 512 CASES CITED. XV11 Barker v. Northern P. R. Co. 65 Fed. Rep. 460. 243 v. Pope, 91 N. C. 165.. 529, 559 v. Savage, 1 Sweeny, 288... 785, 796 Barker's Case, 2 Johns. Ch. 232.. 422, 423. 424 Barnes v. Barnes, 66 Me. 286 284, 460, 461 Barney v. Dimmitt, 1 Wright (Ohio) 44 725 Barnhardt ». Smith, 86 N. C. 473 273, 286 Barnsley, Ex parte, 3 Atk. 168 9, 12, 419 Barrett v. Buxton, 2 Aik. (Vt.) 167, 16 Am. Dec. 691 719, 726, 737 Barry v. Butlin, 2 Moore, P. C. C. 482 326, 739, 740 v. Butlin, 1 Curt. Eccl. Rep. 637.. .365,368, 461 Bartee v. Thompson, 8Baxt. 508.. 459 Bartholemew t>. People, 104 111. 605, 44 Am. Rep. 97 (1882) 665, 688, 691, 692, 707 Bartholick's Case, 1 Connoly, 373_ 342 Batchelder v. Batchelder, 14 N. H. 380 743, 748 Bates v. Ball, 72 111. 108 721 v. Bates, 27 Iowa, 110, 1 Am. Rep. 260 498, 500 Baughman v. Bauguuian, 32 Kan. 538 ..384, 386, 567 Baumgarden v. Langles, 35 La. Ann. 441. 261 Bawden v. Bawden, 2 Swab. & T. 417. 3 L. J. Mat. N. S. 94, 8 Jur. N. S. 157, 6 L. T. N. S. 27, 10 Week. Rep. 292.... 396 Baxter v. Abbott, 7 Gray, 71 321, 459 461, 517, 527, 537, 547, 603 v. Baxter, 76 Hun, 98 273 v. Portsmouth, 5 Barn. & C. 170, 2 Car. & P. 178. .. 429, 441 Beall v. Cunningham, 1 B. Mon. 399.... 505 Bean v. Bean, 11 Lane. Bar. 138. . 743 Beasley v. State, 50 Ala. 149, 20 Am. Rep. 292 ..:. 130, 170, 171, 178, 183, 495, 682, 685, 709 Beaubien v. Cicotte, 8 Mich. 9.452, 461 v. Cicotte, 12 Mich. 459 288, 289, 315, 496, 506, 514, 517, 560, 562, 576, 580, 591, 596, 598 Beaumont's Case. 1 Whart. 52, 99 Am. Dec. 33 421, 424 Beavan v. McDonell, 26 Eng. L. & Eq. 540 491, 586 Beazley v. Denson, 40 Tex. 416... 461 Beck v. State. 76 Ga. 452 450, 455. 467, 503, 682, 685, 686, 6»5, 709, 713, 782 Behrens v. McKenzie, 23 Iowa, 333, 92 Am. Dec. 428.. 245 Belcher v. Belcher, 10 Yerg. 121 .. 730, 741 Bellv. Bennett, 73 Ga. 784. ..384, 387 v. Buckmaster, 1 Harr. (Del.) 460, note ...451, 459 v. Lee. 28 Grant, Ch. 439... 302 v. McMaster, 29 Hun, 272.. 579 v. Rinner, 16 Ohio St. 45.. 608, 613 Beller v. Jones, 22 Ark. 92 244, 558, 569, 584 Bellingham'sCase, 1 Collinson, Lu- nacy, 636 23, 131, 132, 133, 134, 139, 140, 168, 178, 182, 465, 467 Bennett v. Bennett, 50 N. J. Eq. 439 288 v. Hibbert, 88 Iowa, 154.344, 345 v. State (Wis.) 4 Crim. L. Mag. 378 165 v. State, 57 Wis. 67, 46 Am. Rep. 26.. 174, 540, 541, 585 v. State, Mart. & Y. 133... 683 v. Vade, 2 Atk. 324.. 241 Benoist v. Murrin, 58 Mo. 307... 256, 285, 294, 295. 460, 463 Bensell v. Chancellor, 5 Whart. 371, 34 Am. Dec. 531.. 503 Bergin v. State, 31 Ohio St. 111.. 456 Berkley v. Cannon, 4 Rich. L. 136, 719, 723 Bernhardt v. State, 82 Wis. 23 699 Berrien's Will, 35 N. Y. S. R. 255-324 Will. 34 N. Y. S. R. 332.297, 336 Berry v. Hall, 105 N. C. 154.. 259, 264 v. Hamilton, 10 B. Mon. 129-357 v. State, 10 Ga. 512 558 Berryman v. Berryman, 59 Mich. 605 746, 749 Best v. Best, 11 Ky. L. Rep. 215.. 738 Bever v. Spangler, 93 Iowa, 576. . 319, 343, 478, 487, 494, 501, 544, 545, 553, 555, 591, 503 Beverley «. Walden,20 Gratt. 147. 266 Beverly's Case, 4 Coke, 125a 241, 251, 684 Beville v. Jones, 74 Tex. 148.. 251, 258 Bey's Succession, 40 La. Ann. 773, 24L.R. A.577 324,327,340,371, 489 2a xvm CASES CITED. Beyley ®. Alexander, East's Notes, Cas. 79, Morley's India Digest, 352 Bice*. Hall, 120 111. 597 603, Bickel ®. Bennet, Com., 15 W. N. C. 515. Bicknell Case, 3 Add. Eccl. Rep. 231 Bigelow ». Berkshire L. Ins. Co. 93 U. S. 284, 23 L. ed. 918- Billinghurst ®. Vicars, 1 Phillim. Eccl. Rep. 193.364,365, Billings ®. State, 54 Ark. 588 Bird ®. Bird, 2 Hagg. Eccl. Rep. 142... 368, Birdsall's Case, Ray Med. Jur. 465- Case, 2 Connoly, 433 Birdsong ®. Birdsong, 2 Head, 289 247, 726, Birdzell v. Birdzell, 33 Kan. 434, 52 Am. Rep. 539 Bishop ®. Hendrick, 42 N. Y. S. R. 296 Bitner®. Bitner, 65 Pa. 347 512, 537, 538, Bittleson ®. Clark, 2 Lee, Eccl. Rep. 229 274, Bixler ®. Gilleland, 4 Pa. 156 Blachford ®. Christian, 1 Knapp, 73 254, Black v. Ellis, 3 Hill, L. 68 488, 778, Black's Estate, 132 Pa. 134 Blackburn ®. State, 23 Ohio St. 148 131, 132, 134, Black Hawk Co. ®. Springer, 58 Iowa, 417 426, Blackmore's Case, 1 DeG. J. & S. Blackstone ®. Standard L. & Acci. Ins. Co. 74 Mich. 592, 3L. R. A. 486.-9, 405, 408, 409, 413, 415, 418, Blagg ®. Hunter, 15 Ark. 246 Blair Case, 16 Daly, 540 277, Blake ®. Garwood, 42 N. J. Eq. 276 v. Rourke, 74 Iowa, 519 478, 483, 588, 594, ®. State, 121 Ind. 438, 16 Am. St. Rep. 408. .173, Blakeley o. Blakeley, 33 N. J. Eq. 508 253 Blakely's Will" 48 Wis." "2~9~4_~-116,' 205. 289, 293, 300, 336, Will, 48 Wis. 298 Blaker's Case, 27 N.Y. Week. Dig. 486 Blakey v. Blakey, 33 Ala. 611.331, Blanchard v. Nestle, 3 Denio, 37- 279, 410 604 446 373 -411 736 583 952 ■669 342 728 395 273 547 952 768 258 779 768 174 444 442 493 740 381 595 175 256 338 342 534 505 280 Blaney®. Blaney, 126 Mass. 205.. 743, 746 Bledsoe ®. Bledsoe (Ky.) 1 S. W. 10 330, 332, 333 Bleecker ®. Lynch, 1 Bradf. 458.. 275, 277, 349 Blewitt ®. Blewitt, 4 Hagg. Eccl. Rep. 410 J 370 Blimm®. Com. 7 Bush. 320.. 682, 686, 693, 694, 695, 708, 709 Bliss ®. Connecticut & P. R. R. Co. 24 Vt. 424 400, 719, 757 Blocher ®. Hostetter, 2 Grant, Cas. 288 560 Blood's Will, 62 Vt. 359. .511, 512, 561 Bloodworth ®. State, 6 Baxt. 621, 32 Am. Rep. 546 202 Blough ». Parry, 144 Ind. 463, 43 N. E. 560 275, 459, 463 Boardman ®. Woodman, 47 N. H. 120... 24, 158, 159, 297, 306, 321, 536, 549, 564, 602 Bogardus ®. Clark, 4 Paige, 623 433 Boggess ®. Boggess, 127 Mo. 305.. 250, 253, 268, 503, 750 Boiling®. State, 54 Ark. 588 127, 170, 175, 455, 502, 510, 571, 581 Bomgardner ®. Andrews, 55 Iowa, 638 55 9 Bonard's Will. 16* Abb. ~Pr.~ "if." S: 128 303, 304 Bond v. Bond, 7 Allen, 1 208, 244, 256, 257 ®. State, 23 Ohio St. 349... 466, 467 Bonds v. State, 1 Mart. & Y. 143, 17 Am. Dec. 795 Bonfanti ®. State, 2 Minn. 123 Bonner®. Matthews, Cited by Shel- ford on Lunacy, 327 ». Northwestern Mut. Relief Asso. 90 Wis. 144 ...268,407, 576 Blundell, 19 Ves. Jr. 494... 315, 321, 322, 323, 338, 499, 508 Boren ®. State, 32 Tex. Crim. Rep. 637. 129, 164, 180, 466 Borlase v. Borlase, 4 Notes of Cases, 106.. 373 Borradale v. Hunter, 5 Man. & G. 639 406 Bost®. Bost, 87 N. C.477... 288, 289, 521. 559, 582 Boswell ®. Com. 20 Gratt. 860.... 465, 467, 470, 683, 685, 709 v. State, 63 Ala. 307, 35 Am. Rep. 20 169, 170, 171, 175, 466 Boorman Bootle ®. 200 456 366 CASES CITED. MX Boughton v. Kniclit. L. R. 3 Prob. & Div. 64, 28 L. T. N. S. 562. 42 L. J. Prob. N. S. 41... 187, 274, 279, 282, 283, 295, 300, 486, 495, 514 Bovard v. State, 30 Miss. 600 ]65, 166. 169, 172 v. Wallace, 4 Serg. & R. 499 . 505 Bowrien v. Achor, 95 Ga. "243.49V, 561 v. People, 12 Hun, 85.. 493, 712 Bowie v. Bowie, 3 Md. Ch. 51 750 Bowler's Case, 1 Collinson, Lun- acy, 673 131, 139, 178, 179, 1069 Bowling®. Bowling, 8 Ala. 538.. 557, 561 Bowman v. Van Baum, 17 Phila. 633, 14 W. N. C. 185.. 253, 435, 436, 441, 535 Boyce v. Phoenix Mut. L. Ins. Co. 14 Can. S. C. 723 760 v. Smith, 9 Gratt. 704 256 Boyd v. Boyd, 66 Pa. 283 367 v. Eby, 8 Watts, 66. 505 Boyer v. Berryman, 123 Ind. 451.. 401 Boyer's Estate, 166 Pa. 630 314 Boylan v. Meeker, 15 N. J. Eq. 310 344, 498, 501, 511 v. Meeker, 28 N. J. L. 274.. 331, 332, 333. 451, 478, 481 Brace v. Black, 125 111. 33. 297, 303, 311, 499, 568 Bradbury, Ex parte, 3 Jur. 1108, 4 , Dea, 202... 435, 437 Bradford v. Abend, 89 111. 78, 31 Am. Rep. 67 395 Bradley v. Second Ave. R. Co. 8 Daly, 289 772, 773 «. State, 31 Ind. 492 173 191, 458, 472, 527, 682, 709 Brady v. McBride, 39 N. J. Eq. 495 433, 436 Bramhall v. United States, 6 Ct. CI. 238 401 Bramlette v. State, 21 Tex. App. 611, 57 Am. Rep. 622.. 705 Brand v. Brand, 39 How. Pr. 193 559, 561, 602 v. Schenectady & T. R. Co. 8 Barb. 368 772, 773 Breasted v. Farmers' Loan & T. C0.8N.Y. 299, 59 Am. Dec. 482. .405, 410 Breed v. Pratt, 18 Pick. 115.. 367, 432 Breedlove v. Bundy, 96 Ind. 319.. 609 Bressy v. Gross (Ky.) 7 S. W. 150. 376 Brewer v. Ferguson, 11 Humph. 565 506 Brick v. Brick, 66 N. Y. 144 341 Bricker v. Lightner, 40 Pa. 199... 569, 614 Brfghamfl. Brigham, 12 Mass. 504 128 Brindle v. Mcllvaine, 10 Serg. & R. 282 ...785, 796 Brinkley®. State, 58 Ga. 296.. 130, 528 Briukman v. Rueggesick, 71 Mo. 553 227, 284, 528 Brinton's Estate, 13 Phila. 234 296 Brittan v. Mull, 99 N. C. 483.. . 401 Broaddus v. Broaddus, 10 Bush. 299 330 331, 333 Broadstreet v. Broadstreet, 7 Mass. 474 392 Brock v. Luckett, 4 How. (Miss.) 459 344, 604 Brogden v. Brown, 2 Add. Eocl. Rep. 441.. 307, 366, 371, 950 Brooke v. Berry, 2 Gill, 83... 259, 276 Brooks v. Barrett, 7 Pick. 94 346, 459, 461, 476, 477 Brooks's Estate, 54 Cal. 471. _ 559, 568 Brookshaw v. Hopkins, Lofft. 243.444 Broome v. Ellis, 2 Lee, Eccl. Rep. 528 324 Brotherton v. People, 75 N. Y. 159 450, 456, 457, 472, 473 Broughton v. Knieht, L. R. 3 Prob. & Div. 64 361 Brounckera. Brouncker,2Phillim. Eccl. Rep. 57 274 Brown v. Brown, 38 Ark. 324 743, 745, 751, 764 v. Brown, 39 Mich. 792 454 v. Bruce, 19 U. C. Q. B. 35 311, 452 v. Com. 14 Bush. 398... 179, 470, 474, 542, 560, 569, 573 ©. Com. 78 Pa. 122 133, 173, 175, 456, 466, 486 v. Mitchell, 87 Tex. 140, dicta, 75 Tex. 9... 287, 496, 537, 559, 584 v. Mitchell, 88 Tex. 350, 36 L. R. A. 64 284, 497, 501, 586, 587 v. Moore, 6 Yerg. 272 505 v. Riargin, 94 111. 560... 276, 284, 292, 310, 340, 485, 595 v. State, 4 Tex. App. 275.. 683, 698, 701 v. Torrey, 24 Barb. 583 318, 341, 355, 459 v. Ward, 53 Md. 376, 36 Am. Rep. 422 288. 451, 459, 520 v. Westbrook, 27 Ga. 102.. 383, 387, 392 Brown's Case, 1 Abb. Pr. 112.... 763 Case, 45 Mich. 326 421 "Will, 38 Minn. 112. ...500, 501 XX CASES CITED. Browne v. Molliston, 3 Whart. 129.577 Brownfield v. Brownfield, 43 111. 147 517 Browning v. Budd, 6 Moore, P. C. 430 461, 476 v. Reane, 2 Phillim. Eccl. Rep. 69 382, 383, 384, 385, 389, 391, 435, 455 Brush's Case. 61 Hun, 193 441 Brunt v. Brunt, L. R. 3 Prob. & Div. 37 373 Bryant v. Jackson, 6 Humph. 199 207, 494 Brydges v. Kins:, 1 Hagg. Eccl. Rep. 256 365 Buckey v. Buckey, 38 VV. Va. 168 251, 253, 254, 255, 262, 271, 451, 454, 500 Buckhannon v. Com. 86 Kv. 110. . 682, 684, 698, 714 Buckland t>. Charlemont, 3 Pick. 173 --- 397 Buckley's Case, 16 N'. Y. S. R. 983-341 Buckman's Will, 64 Vt. 313 496 Bulger v. Ross, 98 Ala. 267 274, 288, 291, 333 Bullt\ Wheeler, 6 Dem. 123 299 Bull's Case, 2 N. Y. Supp. 52 317 Case, 14 Daly, 510 567 Bunce v. Gallagher, 5 Blatchf. 489 381 Bunch v. Hurst, 5 Desauss. Eq. 273, 5 Am.Dec.551.259, 266 Bundy v. McKnight, 48 Ind. 502. . 274, 500, 596 Burger r. Hill, 1 Bradf. 360 364 Burgess v. Pollock, 53 Iowa, 273, ' 36 Am. Rep. 21S 256 Burgo v. State, 26 Xeb. 639 125. 130, 172, 173 Burkhard v. State, 18 Tex. App. 599 126, 131, 489, 717 Burkhart v. Gladish, 123 Ind. 338 9, 282, 288, 291,294, 298, 361. 517, 522, 561, 567, 577 Burley v. McGough, 115 111. 11... 592 Burnell v. Taylor, 9 Ves. Jr. 381 _ 615 Burnham v. Kidwell, 113 111. 425. 251 v. Mitchell, 34 Wis. 117.... 241, 398, 399, 531, 534, 559, 567, 571 Burns®. Burns, 13 Fla. 369 744 v. Elba, 32 Wis. 605.771. 775, 779 v. O'Rourke, 5 Robt. 649... 720 Burr v. Duvall, 8 Mod. 59 331 Burr's Case, 3 Barb. Ch. 208 442 17 Barb. 9 421, 423, 442 Burritt t\ Silliman, 16 Barb. 198. . 739 Burroughs v. Richman, 13 N. J. L. 233, 23 Am. Dec. 717.. 721, 724, 783, 793 Burrows v. Burrows, 1 Hagg. Eccl. Rep. 109 347 Burrows's Case, 1 Lewin, C. C. 75 684, 709, 713 Burt v. Burt, 168 Mass. 204 743, 744, 808 v. Quisenberry, 132 III. 385. 251, 253, 269, 271 Burton v. Eyden, L. R. 8 Q. B 295-414 v. Scott, 3 Rand (Va.) 399_. 317, 452. 453, 459, 479, 481, 505, 597 v. State, 33 Tex. Crim. Rep. 138 180 Bush v. Breinisc, 113 Pa. 310, 57 Am. Rep. 469 719, 720 v. Lisle, 89 Ky. 393 ....526, 808 Bush's Will, 5 N. Y. Supp. 23.. .. 319 Butler v. Benson. 1 Barb. 526 604 ■o. Mulinhill, 1 Bligh. 137. . 727 v. St. Louis Ins. Co. 45 Iowa, 93_-532, 533, 567, 580 v. State, 97 Ind. 378 616 Butlin v. Barry, 1 Curt. Eccl. Rep. 614. ..366, 368 Button v. Hudson River R. Co. 18 N. Y. 248 773 v. McCauley, 38 Barb. 413. 790 Buys v. Buys, 99 Mich. 354 575 C. C v. C , 28 Eng. L. & Eq. 603 751 Cadwallader t. West, 48 Mo. 483. 250, 259 Cady's Case. 36 Hun. 122. 756 Cain v. Warford, 33 Md. 23 244 Caldwell v. Anderson, 104 Pa. 199 228, 366 v. State, 41 Tex. 86 616 Calhoun v. Jones, 2 Redf. 34 302 Call s. Byram, 39 Ind. 499 600 Calloway v. Witherspoon, 5 Ired. Eq. 128 ...724, 725 Calumet Electric Street R. Co. v. Mabie, 66 111. App. 235-400 Camp v. Camp, 18 Tex. 528 750, 751, 754 v. Shaw, 52 111. Aop. 241. „ 488 Campbell v. Campbell, 130 111. 466, 6L. R. A. 167 280,281, 286, 309 n. Carnahan (Ark.) 13 S. W. 1098 336 v. Hill, 23 U. C. C. P. 473.. 256. 262, 264 v. Ketcham, 1 Bibb. 406. .. 724, 728 v. Kuhn, 45 Mich. 513, 40 Am. Rep. 479.. 207 CASKS CITED. XXI Campbell v. Spencer, 2 Binn. 129. 724 v. State, 10 Tex. App. 560.. 558 v. State, 23 Ala. 44.608, 609, 612 Canfield v. Fairbanks, 63 Barb. 462 267, 522 Cannady v. Lynch, 27 Minn. 435.. 583, 607, 608, 609, 611, 615, 796 Cannon v. Smalley, L. R. 10 Prob. Div. 96.. 384. 391, 455 Card's Will, 28 N. Y. S. R. 528, 55 Hun, 607, mem 346 Carew v. Johnson, 2 Sch. & Lof. 208 9 Carl v. Gabel, 120 Mo. 283 460 Carlin v. Baird, 11 Ky. L. Rep. 932 356, 806 Carmichael's Case, 36 Ala. 514 ... 427, 511, 519, 538, 569 Carpenter «. Bailey, 94 Cal. 406.. 543, 572 v. Calvert, 83 111. 62.284, 285, 332, 460, 462, 520, 594, 599 v. Carpenter, 8 Bush. 283.. 253, 477, 482, 485 v. Carpenter, Milw. 159 462 v. Com. 92 Ky. 452.682, 705, 714 v. Dame, 10 Ind. 125 609, 610, 613 v. Hatch, 64 N. H. 573 492, 495, 557 Carpenter's Case, 79 Cal. 382 309, 347, 559 Estate, 94 Cal. 406.297, 299, 348 Carr v. State, 96 Ga. 284.131, 450, 455, 466, 470, 471, 489 Carrico v. Neal, 1 Dana, 163..339, 364 Carroll v. Norton, 3 Bradf. 291 ... 277. 349 Carter v. Dixon, 69 Ga. 82.... 299, 520 v. State, 56 Ga. 463.... 466, 551 v. State, 12 Tex. 500, 62 Am. Dec. 539 .131, 183, 450, 683, 684, 707, 710 v. State, 87 Ala. 113... .682, 703 Carter's Estate, 11 Pa. Co. Ct. 140. 313 Cartwright p. Cartwright,l Phillim. Eccl. Rep. 90...67, 242, 371, 430, 459, 479, 481 v. Cartwright, 1 Phillim. Eccl. Rep. 578 275 v. State, 8 Lea, 377.698, 699, 700 Casat v. State, 40 Ark. 511 455, 466, 682, 696, 713 Casey v. People, 31 Hun, 158, 2 N. Y. Crim. Rep. 187.168, 172 Cassedy v. Stockbridge, 21 Vt. 391-773 Castner v. Sliker, 33 N. J. L. 95.. 792 Castors Davis, 120 Ind. 231.. 390, 482 Cathcart v. Sugenheimer, 18 S. C. 123.. ... 531 Cauffman v. Long, 82 Pa. 72 312 Caulkins v. Fry, 35 Conn. 170.720, 722 Cavaness v. State, 43 Ark. 331 682, 709, 713, 788 Cavender v. Waddingham, 5 Mo. App. 457. 515, 720, 723 Cawthorn v. Haynes, 24 Mo. 236.. 502 Central R. &Bkg. Co. v. Phinazee, 93 Ga. 488 770 Chaffee v. United States, 85 U. S. 18 Wall. 517, 21 L. ed. 908 472 Charm's Will, 32 Wis. 557 306 Chambers v. Queen's Proctor, 2 Curt. Eccl. Rep. 415... 319, 324, 326, 347 Chancellor v. Donnell, 95 Ala. 342 453 Chandler v. Barrett, 21 La. Ann. 58, 99 Am. Dec. 701... 283,317, 327, 341, 344, 361, 449. 536, 538, 584, 594 v. Ferris, l" Harr. (Del.) 454 286, 459 Chaney v. Bryan, 16 Lea, 63.-293, 301 Chapman v. Erie R. Co. 55 N. Y. 579 790 v. Republican L. Ins. Co. 6 Biss. 238 411, 412 Charles v. State, 13 Tex. App. 658-698 Charter Oak Ins. Co. v. Rodel, 95 U. S. 232, 24 L. ed. 433 415, 560, 599 v. Rodel, 95 U. S. 285. 24 L. ed. 433 405, 408, 409 Chase v. Lincoln, 3 Mass. 237 321 «. People, 40 111. 352.. .471, 473 v. Winans, 59 Mel. 475 557, 562, 589, 599 Chatham v. State, 92 Ala. 47 682, 688, 689, 695 Chattin's Case, 16 N. J. Eq. 496.. 424 Cheatham v. Hatcher, 30 Gratt. 56, 32 Am. Rep. 650 322, 323, 324, 590, 603 Chess v. Chess, 1 Penr. & W. 32, 21 Am. Dec. 350 498 Chevalier v. Whatlev, 12 La. Ann. 651 249 Chicago C. R. Co. v. Lewis, 5 111. App. 242 772 Chicago W. D. R. Co. v. Mills, 91 111.39 449, 453 Checkering ». Brooks, 61 Vt. 554.. 558, 576, 585, 587 Children's Aid Soc. v. Loveridge, 70 N. Y. 387 ..308, 351, 360 Choice v. State, 31 Ga. 424. ..131, 132, 171, 182, 493, 528, 536, 541, 558, 590, 594, 682, 684. 685,. 709, 712, 792 XX11 CASES CITED. Chrisman v. Chrisman, 16 Or. 127, 18 Pac. 6 276, 186, 288, 289, 309, 316, 318, 350, 459, 461, 462, 463, 476 -. 493 v. State, 54 Ark. 283 682 Christie's Case, 5 Paige, 242.-438, 611 Christmas v. Mitchell, 3 Ired. Eq. 535 421, 434, 438 Christy v. Clarke, 45 Barb. 529.. _ 382, 388 Churchill v. Scott, 65 Mich. 485.. 260 Cilley v. Cilley, 34 Me. 162. ..323, 460, 461, 577, 601 'Clapp v. Fullerton, 34 N. Y. 190, 90 Am. Dec. 681... 301, 565, 566, 5S8 S 600 Clark *. Caldwell, 6 Watts, 139 435 v. Davis, 1 Redf. 249... 277, 292, 329, 350 v. Ellis, 9 Or. 128 288, 292, 316, 3*17, 333, 481, 483 v. Fisher, 1 Paige, 171, 19 Am. Dec. 402 288, 289, 308, 330, 478, 481 v. Malpas, 31 Beav. 80 250, 454 v. Morrison, 25 Pa. 455 505 v. Periam, 2 Atk. 337 509 v. Robinson, 88 111. 498.... 382 i). Sawyer, 3 Sandf.Ch. 351. 598 v. State, 12 Ohio St. 483, 40 Am. Dec. 481 131, 132, 174, 555, 558, 583 v. State, 8 Tex. App. 350. . 125, 132, 135, 162, 178, 450, 467 v. State, 8 Humph. 671.... 683 v. Trail, 1 Met, (Ky.)35... 172, 176, 398, 399, 400, 430, 432 Clark's Case, 1 City Hall Rec. 176, 1 Wheeler dim. Cas. 218, note 125, 130, 178 Case, 40 Hun, 233 498 Clarke v. Dunham, 4 Denio, 262.. 401 v Lear, Cited in 1 Phillim. Eccl. Rep. 119 362 v. Sawyer, 3 Sandf. Ch. 351, Reversed in 2 N. Y. 498 284, 353, 375, 484, 485, 536 Clarkson v. Hanway, 2 P. Wms. 203 259, 260 Clary v. Clary, 2 Ired. L. 78 558, 559, 569 Clearwater v. Kimler, 43 111. 272 265, 377 Clearwater's Case, 17 N. Y. S. R. 794 351 Cleghorn ». New York C. & H. R. R. Co. 56 N. Y. 44, 15 Am. Rep. 375. 786 Clement v. Mattison. 3 Rich. L. 93 382 Clement's Case, Shelford, Lunacy, 92 425 Clements v. McGinn (Cal.) 33 Pac. 920. ._ .9, 309, 459, 475, 476, 507, 607, 609, 611 Cleveland®. State, 86 Ala. 1 695 Clifton v. Clifton, 43 N. J. Eq. 315 290 v. Clifton, 47 N. J. Eq. 227 288, 289, 560, 562, 597, 599 v. Davis, 1 Pars. Sel. Eq. Cas. 31 719, 730 Clineo. Lindsey, 110 Ind. 337... 310, 598 v. State, 43 Ohio St, 332. .. 683, 687, 688, 706 Cline's Will, 24 Or. 175 300, 341 Clinton v. Estes, 20 Ark. 216 491, 1067 Clore v. State, 26 Tex. App. 624. . 683, 698, 716 Clough v. Levy, People, 71 Cal. 618 573 Cluck «. State, 40 Ind. 263 125, 682, 700 Clutch v. Clutch, 1 N. J. Eq. 474. 754 Coates v. State, 50 Ark. 330 466 Cochran v. Amsden, 104 Ind. 282 424, 441, 442 Cochran's Will, 1 T. B. Mon. 246, 15 Am. Dec. 116. .483, 780 Cockell v. Taylor, 15 Beav. 115... 250 Cockeram v. Cockeram, 17 111. App. 604 498 Cockraft ». Rawles, 4 Notes of Cases, 237 368 Cockrill v. Cox, 65 Tex. 676 284, 559, 584 Cocks v. Purday, 2 Car. & K. 270. 606 Coffee v. State, 3 Yerg. 283, 24 Am. Dec. 570 472 Coffey*. Home L. Ins. Co. 44 How. Pr. 481.-.. 416 Coff man's Will, 12 Iowa, 491. ... 459 Coghlan «. Coghlan, Cited in 1 Phillim. 120..324, 325, 336 Coghlan's Case, Cited in 19 Ves. Jr. 508 371 Cohn v. Cohn, 85 Cal. 108 394 Coit®. Patchen, 77 N. Y. 533..-. 299, 300, 343 Colbath v. State, 4 Tex. App. 76. . 683, 698 Colby v. Jackson, 12 N. H. 526.. 444 Cole v. Cole. 5 Sneed, 57, 70 Am. Dec. 275 382, 383, 384, 385, 387 CASKS OITKD. XX 111 Cole v. Robins, Bull. N. P. 112... 719, 720 Cole's Trial, 7 Abb. Pr. N. S. 321 . . 127, 133, 172, 185, 187, 191, 513, 519 Will, 49 Wis. 179 361, 452, 459, 463, 464, 476 Colee v. State, 75 Ind. 513.... 182, 560. 573, 576. 599. 682 Coleman v. Com. 25 Gratt. 865. 18 Am. Rep. 711 607, 612 ■o. Frazer, 3 Bush. 300 248 v. Robertson, 17 Ala. 84... 283, 284, 330, 331 Coleman's Case, 111 N. Y. 220. .. 309, 601 Colgate's Estate, 5 W. N. C. 170.. 312 Colhoun v. Jones, 2 Redf. 34 335 Collier v. Simpson, 5 Car. & P. 74 606 Collins v. Brazill, 63 Iowa, 432... 276 333 v. Osborn, 34 N. J. Eq.51ll 332 v. Townley, 21 N. J. Eq. 353 349 Collins's Case, 18N. J.Eq. 253..I 422, 423, 424, 427 Colvin v. Warford, 20 Md. 357... 492, 501, 506, 530, 603 Colvin's Estate, 3 Md. Ch. 278 ... 424 Combs's Appeal, 105 Pa. 155.. 312, 342 Com. v. Bakeman, 131 Mass. 577, 41 Am. Rep. 248 718 v. Baker, 11 Phila. 631 683, (394, 698, 712 v. Baranski, 36 Pittsb. L. J. 363 200 v. Bezek, 168 Pa. 603 134, 456, 465, 466, 467 v. Braley, 1 Mass. 103... 93, 192 v. Brayman, 136 Mass. 438. 514, 536, 546, 565 i). Buccieri, 153 Pa. 535 183, 184, 189, 190, 200, 523, 524, 550, 571, 573, 616, 1057, 1058, 1065, 1066, 1067, 1069 v. Cleary, 148 Pa. 26. ..128, 187, 188, 524, 683, 698 v. Cleary, 135 Pa. 64, 8 L. R. A. 301. 782 v. Cloonen, 151 Pa. 605 782 v. Coughlin, 123 Mass. 437. 661 «. Crozier, 1 Brewst. (Pa.) 349 ....699, 709, 711 v Curry, 150 Mass. 509 789 ». Dougherty, 1 Browne (Pa.) Appx. xviii 683 v. Eddy, 7 Gray, 583 456, 457. 466, 469 «. Fairbanks, 2 Allen, 511.. 564 Com. Farkin.2 Pa. L. J. 475.. 127. 128, 180, 184, L83 Farkin, 3 Pa. L. J. 480 450, 456, 467 Freetb, 5 Pa. L. J. 445.. 131. 166, 169, 173, 175 French. Thacher, Crim. Cas. 163 ....674, 711 Freth, 3 Phila. 105. 17:; Fritch, 6 Pa. Co. Ct. 164. 177 Gerade, 145 Pa. 289 468, 469, 472, 558, 569 Gilbert, 165 Mass. 45 682, 6S6, 708 Haggerty, 4 Clark (Pa.) 187 605 Hart, 2 Brewst. (Pa.) 546 666, 683, 686. 687, 698. 777, 780 Haskell, Phila. Leg. Int. (Dec. 4, 1868) 174 Haskell, 2 Brewst. 491... 149 Hawkins, 3 Gray, 463 702 Heath, 11 Gray, 303 450, 458, 467, 469, 472 Howe, 9 Gray, 110. ..673, 791 Hughes, 133 Mass. 496. . . 273, 782 Jones, 1 Leigh. 598 133, 175, 683 Kirkbride. 7 Phila. 8 446 Knepley (1850) Pa. 148 Lynch, 3 Pittsb. 205 470 Lynch, 3 Pittsb. 412 450, 456, 467 McAnany, 3 Brewst. (Pa.) 292 720 McCaulley, 16 Phila. 502 135, 165, 467 McKie, lGrav.61,61 Am. Dec. 410-... 458, 472 McNamee, 112 Mass. 285 764, 765 Malone, 114 Mass. 295 682, 703 Meredith, 17 Phila. 90, 14 W. N. C. 188 128, 129, 165, 167, 187. 188, 423, 424. 425, 426 Moore, 2 Pittsb. 502 131 Mosler, 4 Pa. 256 166 Mosler, 4 Pa. 264 99, 128, 148, 169, 172, 175, 176, 183. 495 Moss, 6 Kulp, 31 ....456, 528 Perrier, 3 Phila. 229.. 683, 698 Piatt, 11 Phila. 421 134, 174, 698, 701, 710 Porueroy, 117 Muss. 143. . 490, 493, 494, 510 Reeves, 140 Pa. 258.-423. 425 XXIV CASES CITED. Com. x. Reynolds, Cited in 10 Al- len, 64.. 607, 609, 613 v. Rich, 14 Gray, 335. ..549, 583 v. Rogers. 7 Met. 500, 41 Am. Dec. 458. 15,99,117,126,131,132, 138, 146, 149, 169, 172, 466, 467, 469, 536, 540, 545, 585 v. Say res, 12 Phil a. 553 131, 132, 166, 450, 456, 467 v. Slack, 90 Mich. 448 783 v. Smith, 15 Phila. Leg. Int. 33 128 v. Spink, 137 Pa. 255 446 v. Spink, 27 W. N. C. 37. .. 430, 531 v. Werling. 164 Pa. 559 126, 133, 165, 176, 450, 456. 465, 466, 788 v. Whitney, 11 Cush. 477... 808 v. Wilson, 1 Gray, 339 520, 564, 606 v. Winnemore, 1 Brewst. (Pa.) 356 130, 166, 169, 174, 196, 456. 470, 478, 527, 1057, 1065 v. Woodley, 166 Pa. 463.... 450, 466 Commonwealth Title Ins. & T. Co. v. Gray, 150 Pa. 255. .. 570, 584, 600 Comstock v. Hadlyme Eccl. Soc. 8 Conn. 254, 20 Am. Dec. 100..283, 460, 461, 463, 464, 498, 499 Comstock's Case, 26 N. Y. S. R. 292 337 Conant v. Jackson, 16 Vt. 335.726, 777 Concord v. Rumney, 45 N. H. 423 384 Conely v. McDonald, 40 Mich. 150 318, 346. 492, 493, 512, 552 Conley v. Com. 98 Ky. 125. 682. 685. 688 v. Nailor, 118 U. S. 127, 30 L. ed. 112 259 Connecticut. Mut. L. Ins. Co. v. Aikens, 150 U. S. 468, 37 L. ed. 1148 408 v. Groom, 86 Pa. 96, 27 Am. Rep. 689 408 v. Lathrop, 111 U. S. 612, 28 L. ed. 536. 560 Connelly «. Fisher, 3 Tenn. Ch. 382 248 Conner v. Stanley, 67 Cal. 315.. .. 580 Connor's Case, 110 Cal. 408 757 Will, 7 N. Y. Supp. 855 ... 354 Conover's Case, 28 N. J. Eq. 330. . 420, 423 Continental L. Ins. Co. v. Del- peuch, 82 Pa. 225 418 Converse «. Converse, 21 Vt. 168, 52 Am. Dec. 58 284, 285, 289 Convey's Will, 52 Iowa, 197 276,286, 287 Conway v. State, 118 Ind. 482 126, 130, 174 v. Vizzard, 122 Ind. 266 277, 286, 330, 331, 336 Cook v. Cook, 53 Barb. 180 393,438, 478 v. Territory, 3 Wyo. 110... 695, 700 Cook's Case, 25 K Y. S. R. 64 438 Estate, 16 Phila. 322.. .323, 333 41 Phila. Leg. Int. 6 323 Estates. Clay worth, 18 Ves. Jr. 12..719,724, 725, 729, 731 *. Turner, 15 Sim. 611 531 Coon v. Cook, 6 Ind. 268 419 Coop's Will. 24 N. Y. S. R. 417. . 357 Cooper v. Massachusetts Mut. L. Ins. Co. 102 Mass. 227, 3 Am. Rep. 451 407 Cope's Case, 19 Phila. 569, 7 Co. Ct. 406_ -.423, 425, 426, 427 Copeland v. Copeland, 32 Ala. 512-463 Corbit v. Smith, 7 Iowa, 60, 71 Am. Dec. 431 251, 257, 477, 478, 482, 484 Cordrey v. Cordrey, 1 Houst. (Del.) 269 286,288, 289, 451 Cornelius v. Cornelius, 7 Jones, L. 593 286, 320 Cornwell v. Riker, 2 Dem. 354 274, 275. 287, 349, 544 v. State, Mart. & Y. 147 ... 683, 709 Cory v. Cory, 1 Ves. Jr. 19.. 722 Cory T s Case, N. H 150 Coryell v. Stone, 62 Ind. 307 505, 506, 537, 584 Cottell v. State, 12 Ohio C. C. 467, 5 Ohio Dec. 472 163, 166, 456, 466 Cotterell v. Dutton, 4 Taunt. 826.. 400 Cotton v. Ulmer, 45 Ala. 378, 6 Am. Rep. 703.293, 297, 459 Couch v. Eastham, 29 W. Va. 784 331 333 v. Gentry, 113 Mo. 248 '. 288,290, 291 Coughlin v. Poulson, 2 MacArth. 308 527 Coursey v. Coursey, 60 111. 186... 754 Covenhaven's Case, 1 N. J. Eq. 27-438 Cowan v. Cowan. 139 Mass. 377.. 396 Cowee v. Cornell, 75 N. Y. 91, 31 Am. Rep. 428 249, 451 CASES CITED. XXV Cowles v. Merchant, 140 Mass. 377-504 Cox v. Cox, 4 Sneed. 87 459 Coylev. Com. 104 Pa. 117... 536, 538, 451, 585 v. Com. 100 Pa. 573, 45 Am. Rep. 397.. ...175, 186, 450, 456. 466, 468 Craddock v. Cabiness, 1 Swan, 474 258, 259 Cragg v. Holme, Cited in 18 Ves. Jr. 14 723 Craia: v. Felaud, 4 T. B. Mori. 232-440 Cram v. Cram, 33 Vt. 15. .558, 559, 584 Cramer v. Burlinston, 42 Iowa, 315.... "..771, 775. 778, 781 v. Crumbaugh, 3 Md. 491.. 335, 366. 460. 462 Crandal v. Accident Ins. Co. 27 Fed. Rep. 40.... - 413 Crane v. Conklin, 1 N. J. Eq. 346, 22 Am. Dec. 519_ .724. 725,726, 731 Crank v. Frith, 2 Moody & R. 262, 9 Car. &P. 197 602 Cranmer, Ex parte, 12 Ves. Jr. 445 421,422, 423 Cravens v. Faulconer, 28 Mo. 21.. 460, 463 Crawford v. Hoeft, 58 Mich. 1.259, 519 v. Thompson. 161 111. 161.. 402 Creagh v. Blord, 2 Jones & L. 509, 8Ir. Eq. 434 242 253, 266, 532, 533 Creely v. Ostrander, 3 Bradf. 107 276, 350 Crew v. St. Louis, K. & N. W. R. Co. 20 Fed. Rep. 87... 781 v. State (Tex. Crim. App.) 23 S. W. 14 683, 707 Crews v. State, 34 Tex. Crim. Rep. 533 179 Crichton v. Crichton, 73 Wis. 59 750, 753 Crippen v. Culver, 13 Barb. 428.. 401 Crocker v. Chase, 57 Vt. 413 499, 500, 520, 521 Crockett ». Davis, 81 Md. 134 356, 538, 591 Croft v. Day, 1 Curt. Eccl. Rep. 782 365 Crolins v. Stark," 7"Lai)s"3li".".27^ 280 v. Stark, 64 Barb. 112 592 Croppe. Cropp, 88 Va. 753 454 Crosby v. People, 137 111.3^5 682, 688, 706 Cross®. State, 55 Wis. 261 698, 703, 704, 705 Cross's Case, 2 Ch. Sent. 283 611 Crosswell v. People, 13 Mich. 427. 202 ■D. People, 13 Mich. 426.201. 202 Crow v. Meyersieck, 88 Mo. 411.. 401 Crowe v. Peters, 63 Mo. 429. 557, 580 Crowell v. Kirk, 3 Dev, L 855 600 Crowninshield v. Crowninshield, 2 Gray, 524 227, 320, 460, 461 Crowthers v. Rowlandson, 27 Cal, 376.. 263. 399 Cruise v. Christopher, 5 Dana, 181 249, 250, 725 Crum®. Thornley, 47 111. 192.... 375, 377, 388, 516 Crump v. Morgan, 3 Ired. Eq. 91, 40 Am. Dec. 447 382 Cubbagett. Cubbage, 1 Harr. (Del.) 461, note. ...478, 481 Culver v. Haslam, 7 Barb. 314 559, 561, 597 Cummings v. Henry, 10 Ind. 109 709 722 723 Cundy v. Le Cocq. 53 L. J. M. c! N. S. 125. 660 Cuneov. Bessoni, 63 lnd. 524. .428, 595 Cunningham v State, 56 Miss. 269, 21 Am. Rep. 360 130, 169, 171, 172, 179, 458, 465, 472, 473 Currie «. Child, 3 Campb. 283 615 v. Currie, 24 Can. S. C. 712. 464 Curry v. Bratney, 29 lnd. 195 496 ». Com. 2 Bush, 67 682 v. Curry, 1 Wilson, Super. Ct. (Ind.) 236 391 Curtis v. Brownell, 42 Mich. 165 26S, 270 v. Hall, 4KJ.L 361.. 725, 783 Cuthbertson's Appeal. 97 Pa. 163.. 366 Cutler a. Zollinger, 117 Mo. 92 165, 251, 253, 256, 257, 263 D. Dacey v. People, 116 111. 555 176. 471, 474 Dale's Appeal, 57 Conn. 127... .. 318, 346, 492, 494, 503, 504, 505 Daly v. John Hancock Mut. L. Ins. Co. (Ind.) 8 Ins. L. J. 319 .. 759 Dammaree's Case, 15 How. St. Tr. 522 684 Danforth v. State, 75 Ga. 614, 58 Am. Rep. 480 194, 450, 455, 466 Daniel v. Daniel, 39 Pa. 191 280, 288, 582, 584 Darby v. Hayford, 56 Me. 246 251, 253, 254 Darley v. Darley, 3 Bradf. 481. .. 368 XXVI CASES CITED. Darling v. Bennet, 8 Mass. 129. .. 421, 425, 427 Darnell v. Rowland, 30 Ind. 342.. 247, 271 Daviess. Cooper, 5Myl. &C. 276. 250 v. Grindley, Shelford, Lun- acy, 266 253 Davis v. Calvert, 5 Gill. & J. 269, 25 Am. Deo. 282 283, 315, 380. 331, 492, 505 v. Culver, 13 How. Pr. 68.. 277 v. Lane, 10 N. H. 156 381 v. Latta, 93 Iowa, 811.-318, 319 v. Merrill, 47 X. H. 20S._.. 444 t. Oregon & C. R. Co. 8 Or. 172. 770 v. Phillips, 85 Mich. 198___ 243, 244 a. State, 35 Ind. 496, 9 Am. Rep. 760 543, 555 v. State, 38 Md. 15 (Oi fl. State, 25 Ohio St. 369__. 7t#i v. Tarver, 65 Ala. 98 568 ®. United States, 165 U. S. 373, 41 L. ed.750 134, 173, 551, 585 v. United Slates, 160 U. S. 469, 40L.ed.499 450. 456, 457. 458, 472, 473 Davren v. White, 42 X. J. £q. 569 251, 253 Dawson v. Dawson, 23 Mo. App. 169 744, 808 v. State, 16 Ind. 428,79 Am. Dec. 439.682, 688, 782, 787 Day v. Seeley, 17 Vt. 542 253, 258. 272, 453 De Alberts v. State, 34 Tex. Crim. Rep. 508 710, 712, 716 Dean v. American Mut. L. Ins. Co. 4 Allen, 96 407 v. Dean, 27 Yt. 746 452, 459 «. Fuller, 40 Pa. 474 602 Deans v. Wilmington & W. R. Co. 107 N. C. 686 776 Dearmond v. Dearmond, 12 Ind. 455 449, 451 Deas v. Wandell, 3 Thomp. & C. 128 335 De Gogorza v. Knickerbocker L. Ins. Co. 65 N. Y. 232.. 411 De Haven's Appeal, 75 Pa. 337. .. 312 Deitz's Case, 41 X. J. Eq. 284 331, 333 Dejarnette v. Com. 75 Ya. 867 163, 166, 171, 176, 179, 467, 469. 550, 554 Delafield v. Parish, 25 N. Y. 9 280, 374, 449. 451, 453, 461, 462, 476 v. Weckerlv, 19 Mich.4S2_. 291 Delaney v. Selina, 34 Kan. 534 281 28 9 Delaware, L. & W. R. Co. v. Roalefs, 70 Fed. Rep. 22 224 De Lesdernier v. De Lesdernier, 45 La. Ann. 1364 745 Delgado v. State, 34 Tex. Crim. Rep. 157 714, 716 Demelt v. Leonard, 19 How. Pr. 140 401, 435, 438 Demelt's Case, 27 Hun, 480 438 Den v. Yancleve, 5 N. J. L. 589 . 461, 496, 501 Den, ex dem. Merritt, v. JohDson,5 X. J. L. 454 275 Denaber v. Clark, 10 N. J. L. 258, 18 Am. Dec. 417 430 Denison's Appeal, 29 Conn. 399_. 326, 501 Denman v. St. Paul & D. R. Co. 26 Minn. 357 774 Dennett v. Dennett 44 N. H. 531, 84 Am. Dec. 97. ...208, 243. 244, 247, 253, 315 Dennis Elliott, 60 Tex. 337 401 Denning v. Butcher, 91 Iowa, 425 495, 559, 570, 571, 576, 581, 588 Dennis v. Dennis, 68 Conn. 186, 34 L. R. A. 449 747 v. Union Mut. L. Ins. Co. 84 Cal. 570 411 v. Weekes, 46 Ga. 514 362, 500, 505, 526 1). Weekes, 51 Ga. 24 559 Dennv v. Denny, 8 Allen, 311 ... 396 'v. Pinney, 60 Vt. 524.-452, 461 Denson v. Beaz"lev, 34 Tex. 191... 129, 282 Denton t. Franklin, 9 B. Mon. 28. 351 Derby's Case. 1 W. N. C. 212.312, 313 Deshon v. Merchants' Bank, 8 Bosw. 461 585 DesMoinesXat. Bankw.Chisholm, 71 Iowa, 675..208, 243, 251 Devin «. Scott, 34 Ind. 67.... 764, 767 Dew v. Clark. 1 Add. Eccl. Rep. 279 (1826), 3 Add. Eccl. Rep. 79... 14, 129, 156, 158, 282, 293, 295, 301, 345, 459 v. Clark, 5 Russ. Ch. 163. .. 301 Dewey v. Allgire, 37 Neb. 6 251, 256. 273, 532 Dewitt t. Barlev, 9 X. Y. 371.... 600 v. Barly, 17 N. Y. 340, 13 Barb. 550 559. 560, 580 Dexter v. Hall, 82 U. S. 15 Wall. 9, 21 L. ed. 73 478, 482, 541, 542, 545, 586 CASES CITED. xxvu Dey's Case. 9 N. J. Eq. 181.. 419, 446 Dickeu v. Johnston, 7 Ga. 484 253, 453, 477, 478. 480, 557, 561, 575 Dickerson v. Davis, 111 Ind. 433. 401 Dickie ». Carter, 42 111. 37G . 493 v. Van Vleck, 5 Redf. 284.. 326 Dickinson v Barher, 9 Mass. 225, 6 Am. Dec. 58.. 263, 494, 538 v. Buskie. 59 Wis. 136 797 v. Dickinson, 61 Pa. 401 561, 573, 602 Dickson v. Waldron, 135 Ind. 507, 24 L. R. A. 483.... 609, 613 Dietrich v. Dietrich, 4 Watts, 167, note 505 Dietrick v. Dietrick, 5 Serg. & R. 207 521 Dillard v. Dillard, 2 Strobh. L. 89. 505 Dimes v. Dimes, 10 Moore P. C. 422 371 Dimick v. Downs, 82 111. 570.784, 792 Dimond's Estate, 3 Pa. Dist. R. 554 .493, 737, 738 Dinges v. Branson, 14 W. Va. 100 376, 498, 499, 502 District of Columbia v. Armes, 107 U. S. 519, 27 L. ed. 618 607, 608. 609, 613 Ditchburn «. Fearn, 6 Jur. 201 298, 300, 303 Ditchett v. Spuyten Duyvil & P. M. R. Co. 5 Hun, 165.. 770, 775 Dodds v. Wilson, 3 Brev. 389 243 v. Wilson, 1 Tread. 448 243 Dodge v. Meech, 1 Hagg. Eccl. Rep. 612 338, 496 Doe «. Roe, 1 Edm. Sel. Cas. 344. 384 Doe, Bainbrigge, v. Bainorigge, 4 Cox, C. C. 454 541 Griggs, v. Shana, 4 Term. Rep. 306 400 Guest, v. Beeson, 2 Houst. (Del.) 246 253, 258, 262, 449, 451, 453, 524 Mather, v. Whitefoot, 8 Car. & P. 270 528 Sutton, v. Reagan, 5 Blackf. 217. 33 Am. Dec. 466.. 262 Dominick v. Dominick, 10 N. Y. S. R. 32 373 v. Dominick, 20 Abb. N. C. 286 438, 506, 532 Donegal's Case, 2 Ves. Sr. 4U7, Ves. Sr. Supp. 369.... 9, 419, 422 Donelson v. Posey, 13 Ala. 752... 704. 730 Doran v. McConlogue, 150 Pa. 98 272, 561, 573 Dorchester o. Dorchester, 18 N.Y. S. R. 402... 269 v. Dorchester, ii N. Y. Supp. 23H. I.Yv.-r.ed in 121 N. Y. 156 451. 453, 175 Dormay r. Borradaile, 10 Beav. 335. 407 v. Borradaile, 5 C. B. 380, 11 Jur. 231 406 Dornick v. Reichenback, 10 Serg. & It 84 ....". 230 Dorsey v. Sheppard, 12 Gill. & J. 192 370 v. Warfield, 7 Md. 65. ..561, 584 Dotto v. Felzer. 9 Pa. 88 505 Doty v. Hubbard, 55 Vt. 278.-255, 437 Doughty v. Doughty, 7 N. J. Eq. 643 244, 593, 509 V. Doughty, 7 N. J. Eq. 227. 727 Douglass y.Douglass,31 Iowa, 421. 393 Douglass's Estate. 162 Pa. 567. .. 314 Dove v. State, 3 Heisk. 348 456, 472, 555, 558 Downer's Case, 1 Eccl. & Aclm. 106, 26 Eng. L. & Eq. 600 373 Doyle's Estate, 7 Pa. Co. Ct. 657 276, 289, 313, 353 Draper v. Kirkbride, Com. 3 Brewst. 393. ..430, 443, 446 Draper's Estate, 26 W. N. C. 218. 438 Drayton, Ex parte, 1 Desauss. Eq. 144 441 Drew v. Nunn, 40 L. T. N. S. 676. 381 Drinkhouses Estate, 14Phila.291. 296 Drummond v. Hopper, 4 Harr. (Del.) 327 ..719, 732 Ducker v. Whitson, 112 N. C. 44. 503, 568 Dufaur v. Professional L. Assur. Co. 25 Beav. 599, 4 Jur. N. S. 841, 27 L. J. Ch. 817 406 Duffield v. Morris, 2 Harr. (Del.) 375 - 346 v. Robeson, 2 Harr. (Del.) 375 9, 10,241, 275, 279, 280, 344, 371, 449. 459, 477, 487, 737, 780 Duggan v. McBreen, 78 Iowa, 591. 311 Dulaney v. Green, 4 Harr. (Del.) 285 730 Dumond v. Kiff, 7 Lans. 465 353 Dun v. Amo, 14 Wis. 107 731 Duncombe v. Richards, 46 Mich. 166 259, 377, 378 Dunham's Appeal, 27 Conn. 192 . 288. 298, 520, 552, 559 Case, 15 N. Y. S. K. 292 .... 337 Dunn v. Dunn, 62 Cal. 176 743 v. Dunn, 114 Cal. 210 401 XXV111 CASES CITED. Dunn v. People, 109 111. 635..174, 176 Dunnage v. White, 1 Swanst. 137. 247, 248 Durant v. Ashmore, 2 Rich. L. 184. 502 Durham v. Durham, L. R. 10 Prob. & Div. 80 384 v. Smith, 120 Ind. 463 281, 310, 598 Durling v. Loveland, 2 Curt. Eccl. Rep. 225 369, 739 Durnell v. Corfield, 8 Jur. 915.366, 369 Duvale v. Duvale (N. J.) 34 Atl. 888 395 Dyce Sombre v. Solaroli (1856) 1 Deane, 110 226 Dyce Sombre's Case, 13 Jur. 857, 1 Macn. & G. 116.. 442, 443 Dye v. Young, 55 Iowa. 433 505 Dyer v. Dyer, 87 Ind. 13.. 492 Dvre's Estate, 12 Phila. 156 276, 285, 315, 430 Dyson's Case, 1 Lewin, C. C. 64.. 197 E. Eaglehardt v. State, 88 Ala. 100.. 682, 703 Ealing Grove, The, 2 Hagg. Adm. 15 729 Ean v. Snyder, 46 Barb. 230 280, 342, 449, 453 Earle v. Norfolk & N. B. Hosiery Co. 36 N. J. Eq. 188.. 253 Eastabrook ». Union Mut. L. Ins. Co. 54 Me. 224, 89 Am. Dec. 743 405 Eastis v. Montgomery. 95 Ala. 486 277, 288, 317, 459 Eastwood v. People, 3 Park. Crim. Rep. 25 696, 792 Eaton v. Eaton, 37 N. J. L. 108, 18 Am. Rep. 716 253 Eckart v. Fiowry, 43 Pa. 46.. 518, 569 Eddey's Appeal, 109 Pa. 406.. 312, 342 Eddy's Case, 32 N. J. Eq. 701.... 351 Edge «. Edge, 33 N. J.Eq. 211.... 737 Edson v. Munsill, 10 Allen, 557. .. 531 Edwards v. Davenport, 4 McCrary, 24, 20 Fed. Rep. 756. .. 241 v. Davenport, 20 Fed. Rep. 756 244 Egan v. Dry Dock, E. B. & B. R. Co. 12App. Div. 556. .. 606 Egbert v. Egbert, 78 Pa. 326 321, 451, 459, 525, 601 Egeers v. Eggers, 57 Ind. 461 294. 295, 549, 596 Ekin v. McCracken, 11 Phila. 534 242, 256, 267, 278, 293, 344 Elcessor v. Elcessor, 146 Pa. 359. . 261, 377, 559, 573, 575, 584, 600 Elder*. State (Ga.) 26 S. E. 80.... 180 Elkinton v. Brick, 44 N. J. Eq. 154, 1 L. R. A. 161.... 317, 451, 459, 488, 779 Ellars v. Mossbarger, 9 111. App. 122 263 Elliott v. Grimes, 13 B. Mon. 257. 452 v. Wei by, 13 Mo. App. 19.. 452, 460, 461, 463, 487 Elliott's Will, 2 J. J. Marsh, 340.. 276 Ellis v. Bowman, 17 L. T. 11 390 v. Ellis, 133 Mass. 469 564 v. Mathews, 19 Tex. 390, 70 Am. Dec. 353 247, 249 v. Secor, 31 Mich. 185, 18 Am. Rep. 178 378 v. State, 33 Tex. Crim. Rep. 86 528,558, 561 «. White, 61 Iowa, 644 395 Elmer v. Kechle. 1 Redf. 472 756 Eloi v. Eloi, 36 La. Ann. 563 428, 561, 598 Elston e. Jasper, 45 Tex. 409 482 Elzey v. Elzey, 1 Houst. (Del.) 308 383, 390, 742, 743 Emerick v. Emerick, 83 Iowa, 411, 13 L. R. A. 757 421 Emery v. Hoyt, 46 111.258 246. 261, 434, 478, 480 Ernes v. Ernes, 1 Grant, Ch. 325.. 251 Emigu Diehl, 76 Pa. 359 615 English v Porter, 109 111. 105 252 v. Porter, 109 111. 285 205. 251, 427, 451, 453, 475 Enright v. Atlanta, 78 Ga. 288. ... 788 Equitable L. Assur. Soc. v. Pater- soa, 41 Ga. 338, 5 Am. Rep. 535 405, 763, 807 Errickson v. Fields. 30 N. J. Eq. 634 325 Erwin v. State, 10 Tex. App. 700.. 23, 131, 710, 711, 715 Eskridge v. State, 25 Ala. 30 791 Eslava v. Lepretre, 21 Ala. 504, 56 Am. Dec. 266 419 Esterbrook v. Gardner, 2 Dem. 543-338 Estes v. State, 55 Ga. 30.. 682, 690, 697 Ethridge v. Bennett, 9 Houst. (Del.) 295 278, 286, 449, 559, 584, 600 Etter v. Armstrong, 46 Ind. 197. . 274 Euchenberg v. Schneider, Com. 59 Pa. 328 419, 424, 425 Evans v. Arnold, 52 Ga. 169. .171, 309, 321, 322, 326, 330, 460 v. Heitich, 20 U. S. 7 Wheat. 453, 5L. ed. 496. 608 ». Kniuht, 1 Add. Eccl. Rep. 229 329, 337, 950, 951 CASES CITKD. XXIX Evans v. Thomas, 2 Hagg. Eccl. Rep. 433 241, 320 Eveis, Ex parte, 29 Tex. App. 539 683, 716, 717 v. State, 31 Tex. Crim. Rep. 318, 18 L. R. A. 421 131, 683, 713, 716, 717 Exum v. Canty, 34 Miss. 532 2(14, 265, 336 Eysaman Case. 113 N. Y. 62, 3 L. R. A. 599 568 P. Fahnestock v. State, 23 Ind. 231... 785 Fain v. Com. 78 Ky. 183, 39 Am. Rep. 213 523, 552 Fairchild v. Baseomb. 35 Vt. 398. . 493, 512, 521, 543, 544, 518, 549, 585, 587, 613 Fane v. Devonshire, 6 Bro. P. C. 137 272 Farmer v. Parmer, 129 Mo. 307." 285 Farnham v. Brooks, 9 Pick. 212.. 244, 247 Farnham's Case (1895) 2 Ch. 799.. 402 Farnsworth's Will, 62 Wis. 474.. 289, 339 Farrell v. Brennan, 32 Mo. 328, 82 Am. Dec. 137 557, 587 Farrer v. State, 2 Ohio St. 54 173, 176, 185, 466, 469, 470 Farris v. Com. (Ky.) 1 S. W. 729.. 173 Fauldera. Silk, 3 Campb. 126 429, 531 Faulkner v. Territory, 6 N. M. 464 456,472, 473 Fay v. Burditt, 81 Ind. 435, 42 Am. Rep. 142..246, 451, 453, 479 Fayette ». Chesterville, 77 Me. 28, 52 Am. Rep. 741... 397, 548, 549, 557, 585 Fee®. Taylor, 83 Ky. 259. 463 Fennell v. Tate. 1 Cromp. M. & R. 584 ..607, 611 Fenton v. Holloway, 1 Starkie, 126-719 Fenton's Case (Iowa) 66 N. W. 99_ 571 Fentress v. Fentress, 7 Heisk, 428-420 Ferguson v. Borrett, 1 Fost. & F. 613 264 Ferrars, Ex parte, Mosely, 332 442 Ferrell v. State, 43 Tex. 502 666, 683, 686, 688, 708 Ferrer's Case, 19 How. St. Tr. 943, 947 139, 181 Ferris v. People, 35 N. Y. 125 186 Field v. Shorb, 99 Cal. 661 378 Field Case, 3 Curt. Eccl. Rep. 754-367 Fielder v. Collier, 13 Ga. 496 557 Finn's Will, 1 Misc. 280 Firby v. State, 3 Baxt. 358. First Nat. Bank v. Win-bach, 106 Pa. 37, 12 W. N. C. 150 263, 509, 542, 561, 574, 575. 570. 59 1 , Fiscus v. Turner, 125 Ind. 46.423, Fishburnev. Ferguson, 84 Va. 87.. 250, 454, 479, Fisher v. People, 23 111. 283 132. 176, 449, v. State, 64 Ind. 435 682, 709, v. State, 30 Tex. App. 502.. 574. 687, Fitzgerald v. Shelton, 95 N. C. 519 v. Weston, 52 Wis. 354... . 771, 773, Fitzgerald's Case, 30 N. J. Eq. 59. Fitzpatrick v. Com. 81 Kv. 357... 126, 127, "134, 175. Flanagan v. People, 52 N. Y. 467, 11 Am. Rep. 731 135, 171, Flanders v. Davis, 19 N. H. 139.. Flanigan v. Peopie. 86 N. Y. 554, 40 Am. Rep. 556.. _ 683, Flansburgh's Will, 82 Hun, 49... 286. 461, Fleming v. State, 5 Humph. 564. . 782, Flint's Case. Shelford on Lunacy, 91 Flood v. Martin, People, 15 Misc. 335 195 v. Pragoff, 79 Ky. 607 Florey v. Florey, 24 Ala. 241 296, 517, 557, 569, Floyd v. Floyd, 3 Strobh. L. 44, 49 Am. Dec. 626 Fluck v. Rea, 51 N. J. Eq. 233 .. Fogarty v. State, 80 Ga. 450 Fonville v. State, 91 Ala. 39 682, 693, 710, 777, 780, Foot i). Stanton, 1 Deane & S. Eccl. Rep. 19 355, v. Tewksbury, 2 Vt. 97 Forbes v. Edinburgh L. Assur. Co. 10 Shaw & D. Sc. Sess. Cas. 451.. Forbing v. Weber, 99 Ind. 588 Ford v. Ford. 7 Humph. 92 283, 317, 373, 459, 462, «. State, 71 Ala. 385, 5 Crim. L. Mag. 32... 466, 470, 482. 562, 569, 682, v. State. 73 Miss. 734, 35 L. R. A. 117 457, 472 479 : v. Umatilla County, 15 Or, 313 505 424 559 474 713 717 -495 783 428 188 172 321 685 470 795 423 792 463 570 308 736 171 781 1068 720 760 373 492 693 484 XXX CASES CITED. Format! v. Forman, 53 N. Y. S. R. 639 391 v. Smith, 7 Lans. 443 288, 289, 595 Forman's Will, 54 Barb. (N. Y.) 27, 1 Tucker, 205 71, 280, 281, 2s2, 295, 306, 307, 364, 373, 374, 461 Forney v. Fen-ell, 4 W. Va. 729.. 505 Forushill v. Murray, 1 Bland, Ch. 479 3«2 Fossa. Hildreth, 10 Allen. 76 788 Foster v. Brooks, 6 Ga. 290.. .528, 557 v. Dickerson, 64 Vt. 233. .. 320, 508, 513, 518, 537, 540, 548, 551, §55, 559, 501, 573, 576, 577, 578, 579. 588, 600, 601 v. Jones, 23 Ga. 168 401 v. Means, 1 Speer, Eq. 569, 42 Am. Dec 332 383, 385, 386, 388 Foster's Estate, 142 Pa. 62 312 Fountain v. Brown, 38 Ala. 72 326, 496, 511, 525. 559, 568 Fouts v. State, 4 G. Greene, 500__ 168, 169, 174 Fow's Estate, 147 Pa. 264 314, 352 Fowler v. Mutual L. Ins. Co. 4 Lans. 202 ..410, 418 Fowlis v. Davidson, 6 Notes of Cases, 461.... 293, 301, 316, 478, 486, 488 Fox v. Evans, 3 Yeates, 506 603 v. Pennsylvania Mut. L. Ins. Co. (Pa.) 4 Bigelow.Life & Acci. Ins. Rep. 458 .. 759 v. Territory, 2 Wash. Terr. 297... 796 Francis v. Wilkinson, 147 111. 370 251, 252, 255, 285 Francke v. His Wife, 29 La. Ann. 302 422, 428, 429, 594 Frank v. Mainwaring, 2 Beav. 115 435. 438 Franke v. Shipley, 22 Or. 104 290 Franklin v. Franklin, 53 Kan. 143 „ 394 Franks v. Jones, 39 Kan. 236 722 Frary v. Gusha, 59 Vt. 257 516, 520, 538 Fraser v. Jennison, 42 Mich. 206. _ 294, 349, 499, 502, 507, 508, 527, 530, 543, 546, 592, 606 Frazer v. Frazer, 2 Del. Ch. 260. . 242, 253, 330, 336, 339, 453, 478 Frear v. Williams, 7 Baxt. 550. .. 460, 462 Freed v. Brown, 55 Ind. 310 244 Freeman v. Dwiggins, 2 Jones Eq. 162 725 v. Easley, 117111. 317 227, 274, 285 v. Freeman, 19 Ont. Rep. 141 369 v. People, 4 Denio, 9, 47 Am. Dec. 216 92.93, 133, 135, 148, 1«5, 192. 193, 196. 197, 198, 589 v. Staats, 8 N. J. Eq. 814. . 729 French v. French, 8 Ohio, 214, 31 Am. Rep. 441 719 v. State, 85 Wis. 400, 21 L. R. A. 402 197 v. State, 93 Wis. 325 193, 198, 498, 509. 554, 789 Frere v. Peacock, 1 Rob. 442 306 v. Peacocke, 3 Curt. Eccl. Rep. 664 358 Frey v. Germania L. Ins. Co. 56 Mich. 29 411 Fricke's Case, N. Y. Daily Reg. Feb. 6, 1886 (Abb. Dig. 1886, p. 377). 348 Frieke's Case, 47 N. Y. S. R. 10.. 297, 342 Friery v. People, 54 Barb. 319 683, 689, 697 Frith's Case, 22 How. St. Tr. 307 192 196 537 Fiizzel v. Reed. 77 Ga. 724..'.... ^.559 Frost v. Wheeler, 43 N. J. Eq. 573 286, 344, 806 Frost's Case, 22 How. St. Tr. 472. 684 Frowert's Case. 2 W. N. C. 588.. 312 Fry v. Fry, L. R. 15 Prob. Div. 25, Aff'd in L. R. 15 Prob. Div. 50. 427 Fulleck v. Allinson, 3 Hagg. Eccl. Rep. 527 298, 300, 324, 344, 370 Fuller v. Fuller, 17 Cal. 605 608 v. Fuller, 83 Ky. 345 605 Fullerton v. Gilbert, People, 115 111. 59. 446 Fulwilder v. Ingels, 87 Ind. 414.. 243, 484, 598 Furniss v. Mutual L. Ins. Co. 14 Jones &S. 467 759 Furstfl. State, 31 Neb. 403 131, 458, 472 Futriel v. Futriel, 5 Jones, Eq. 61. 727 G. Gahagan v. Boston & L. R. Co. 1 Allen, 187, 79 Am. Dec. 724.. 785, 793 Gainsville v. Caldwell, 81 Ga. 76.. 608, 612, 615 CASES CITED. X.XX1 Gaitan v. State, 11 Tex. App. 544 702 Gaither v. Gaither, 20 Ga. 709 287 Oalpm v. Wilson, 40 Iowa, 90 247 Gamble v. Gamble, 39 Barb. 373.. 330, 333 Gantjwere's Estate, 14 Fa. 417, 53 Am. Dec. 554 383, 435 Gannon's Will (C. P.) 3 Misc. 329 164, 292, 296 Gardiner v. Gardiner, 34 N.Y. 155. 341 v. People, 6 Park. Crim. Rep. 155 580 Gardner v. Gardner. 22 Wend. 526, 34 Am. Dec. 340 , 487, 488, 734, 735, 737, 741, 778, 779, 780 v. Lambock, 47 Ga. 133 282. 293, 294, 310 Garner®. State, 28 Fla. 113 682, 685, 688, 697, 698, 699, 701 . 703, 708, 709 Garnettfl. Garnett, 114 Mass. 379, 19 Am. Rep. 369_.-396, 397 Garrison v. Blanton, 48 Tex. 299.. 281, 286, 323, 557, 584 v. Garrison, 15 N. J. Eq. 266 323, 561, 584, 604 Gartside v. Isherwood, 1 Bro. C. C. 590.. ...243, 247, 250 Gass v. Gass, 3 Humph. 278 303, 304, 309, 341, 459, 462, 475, 605 v. Mason, 4 Sneed, 497 258 Gates v. Cornett, 72 Mich. 435... 250, 454 v. Meredith, 7 Ind. 440.719, 786 Gatley's Estate, 4 Pa. Dist. R. 52 314, 355 Gay v. Union Mut. L. Ins. Co. 9 Blatch. 142__ ..407,408, 409 Gebhart v. Shindle, 15 Serg. & R. 235 608 Gee v. Ward. 5 Week. Rep. 579.. 503 Gehhardt v. Shindle, 15 Serg. & R. 235 796 Gehrkea. State. 13 Tex. 568 581 Genz c. State. 58 N. J. L. 482.... 557 Gerrish v. Nason, 22 Me. 438, 39 Am. Dec. 589 460, 461 Gibbons v. Dunn, 46 Mich. 146... 454, 475 Gibson v. Gibson, 9 Yere. 329 537, 538, 5577 559, 573, 601 v. Gibson, 24 Mo. 227 499, 502, 790 v. Jeyes, 6 Ves. Jr. 266 423 . Miller, 48 Neb. 156 251, 256, 557 Haydock v. Haydock, 34 N. J. Eq. 570, 38 Am. Rep. 385.. 250, 452 Hayes v. Burkham, 67 Ind. 359.. 505 v. Huff stater, 65 Barb. 530. 722 v. West, 37 Ind. 21... 502 Haynes v. Swann, 6 Heisk. 560. .. 447, 478, 486 3a XXXIV CASES CITED. Hays v. Com. (Ky.) 33 S. W. 1104 130, 133 Hayward v. Hayward, 1 Swab. & T. 81 394 Hazlitt's Will, 35 Pitts. L. J. 503. 367 Hazzard's Estate, 7 Pa. Co. Ct. 56. 312 Healey v. New York, 3 Hun, 708, 6 Thomp. & C. 92.770, 775 Heard v. Sack, 81 Mo. 610.. 401 Hebert v. Winn, 24 La. Ann. 385.. 333, 733, 734, 778 Heenan's Estate, 15 Pbila. 545 485 Hegney». Head, 126 Mo. 619 464 Heister v. Lyncb, 1 Yates, 108 ... 452 Helad v. Tbing, 45 Me. 392 552 Helmbold v. Kirkbride, Com. 11 Pbila. 427.. ..446, 447, 452 475 593 Helmbold's Case, 12 Pbila. 424..' 442 Hemingway v. Coleman, 49 Conn. 390, 44 Am. Dec. 243.. 243 Hempbill v. Holford, 88 Micb. 293 265 Henderson v. Hays, 2 Watts, 148. 724 v. McGregor, 30 Wis. 78. . 259, 423 Hendrix v. Money, 1 Bush, 306.. 263, 524, 593 Henrizi i\ Kebr, 90 Wis. 344 255 Henry v. Brothers, 48 Pa. 70 535 v. Fine, 23 Ark. 417 515 v. Hall, 106 Ala. 84 452 v. Ritenour, 31 Ind. 136 720, 721 v. State, 33 Ga. 441... 682 Henry's Will, 18 Misc. 149.. .276, 288, 289, 295, 296 Henslie v. State, 3 Heisk. 202.177, 691 Herbert v. Berrier, 81 Ind. 1 449. 451, 460 Hernandez v. State, 32 Tex. Crim. Rep. 271 690, 705 Herster v. Herster, 122 Pa. 239... 307, 312, 363, 498, 500 Hewlett v. Wood, 55 N. Y. 634- . 564, 566 Hey ward v. Hazard, 1 Bay, 335. . 321 Hiatt v. Mutual L. Ins. Co. 2 Dill. 572, nole 408, 616 Hickman v. Hickman, 1 Wash. 257 .- 392 v. State, 38 Tex. 190 567 Hicks v. Marshall, 8 Hun, 327.. . . 435, 440 Hiett v. Shull, 36 W. Va. 561 8, 245, 449, 453, 598, 607 Higgins v. Carlton, 28 Md. 115, 92 Am. Dec. 666 276, 283, 323, 331, 449, 451, 452, 459, 462, 478, 481, 579, 581 Higbt v. Wilson. 1 U. S. 1 Dall. 94, 1 L. ed. 51 733 Hiler v. State, 4 Blackf. 552 471 Hill v. Day, 34 N. J. Eq. 150 244, 381, 430 v. Hill, 27 K J. Eq. 214.. 392 393 v. Horton, 4 Dem. 90 1 763 v. McLaurin, 28 Miss. 288.. 245 v. Nash, 41 Me. 585, 66 Am. Dec. 266 309, 311, 332 v. State, 64 Ga. 463... 170 v. State, 42 Neb. 503 698, 709, 710 Hill's Case, 31 N. J. Eq. 203.423, 426 Hills v. Mills, 1 Salk. 36 219 Hincbmau v. Richie, Brightly, 143 445 Hirsch v. Trainer, 3 Abb. N. C. 274 255, 438 Hite v. Com. 14 Ky. L. Rep. 308.. 573 v. Sims, 94 Ind. 333 125, 303, 472 Hix®. Whittemore, 4 Met. 545... 483 Hoag's Case, 7 Paige, 312.. 766 Hoard v. State, 15 Lea, 318 188, 457, 466, 609, 714 Hoban v. Campau, 52 Mich. 346-- 285, 307, 319, a5& Hoblyn's Case, 29 L. T. 305.. 419, 427 Hoby v. Hoby, 1 Hagg. Eccl. Rep. 146 227, 279, 346, 370, 372, 952 Hodgdon v. Crosby, 1 Wash. Terr. 578 272, 462 Hodge v. State, 26 Fla. 11 471, 473, 474 Hodges v. Scott, 118 Mass. 530. .. 509- Hoeffner v. Grand Lodge G. O. of H. 41 Mo. App. 359.. . 414 Heerth v. Zahle, 92 Ky. 202 310, 323, 333 Hoffman v. Overbey, 137 U. S. 465, 34 L. ed. 754 499 Hoge v. Fisher, 1 Pet. C. C. 163. . 451, 454, 462, 479, 481 Holbrook v. Gay, 6 Cusb. 215 615 Holcomb v. Holcomb, 95 N. Y. 316 564,566, 600 «. Holcomb, 28 Conn. 177.. 607, 608, 609, 612 v. State, 41 Tex. 125 558 Holden v. Meadows, 31 Wis. 284.. 289. 291 Holdone ®. Ancient Order of United Workmen, 159 111. 619, 31 L. R. A. 6.". 404 Holland v. Barnes, 53 Ala. 83, 25 Am. Rep. 595 726 v. Holland, 4 Legal Gaz. 372 744, 752, 808 CASES CITED. XXXV Holland v. Zollner, 102 Cal. 633 583 Hollinger v. Syms, 37 N. J. Eq. 221 297 Holloway v. Galloway. 51 111. 159 292, 318. 451, 460, 462, 464 Holmes v. Oregon & C. R. Co. 5 Fed. Rep. 523 772 v. State, 11 Tex. App. 233.. 718 Holmes's Case. 4 Russ. 182. 421 Holsenbake v. State, 45 Ga. 43.450, 467 Holterhoff v. Mutual Ben. L. Ins. Co. 3 Am. L. Rec.272,4 Bigelow Life & Acci. Ins. Rep. 395 758, 760, 761, 762, 763 Holyland's Case, 11 Ves. Jr. 10... 441, 443 Honesty v. Com. 81 Va. 283. 777 Hooper's Estate, 174 Pa. 373 482 Hoover v. State. 48 Neb. 184 561 Hoover's Case, 8 Mackey, 495 339 Hoppe's Estate, 7W.N.C. 523.. 277 Hopper's Case, 5 Paige, 491 401 Hopps v. People (1863) 31 111. 385, 83 Am. Dec. 231 25, 176, 457. 471, 529 Hopson v. Boyd, 6 B. Mon. 296.. 434, 435, 436, 438, 439 Hopt v. Utah, 104 U. S. 631, 26 L. ed. 873.. 698 Horaho. Knox, 87 N. C. 490 459, 537, 584, 587 Horbach v. Denniston, 3 Pittsb. 49. 289 Horn v. Anglo-Australian & Univ. Family L. Ins. Co. 7 Jur. N. S. 673... 405 v. Anglo- Australian & Univ. Family L. Ins. Co. 30 L. J. Ch. 511, 4 L. T. N. S. 142, 9 Week. Rep. 359 405 v. Pullman, 10 Hun, 471 ... 504 v. Pullman, 72 N. Y. 269. . 277, 287, 349 Home •». Home, 9 Ired. L. 99 286, 338 Horner v. Marshall, 5 Munf. 466. . 207, 402 Hornish v. People, 142 111. 620, 18 L. R. A. 237.. 125, 130, 132, 173, 178, 180, 473, 474 Horton v. Equitable L. Assur. Soc. (N. Y.) 2 Bigelow Life & Acci. Ins. Rep. 108. . 760, 763 Hoskins v. Hoskins (Ky.) 7 S. W. 546... 346, 351 Hotchkiss v. Fortson, 7 Yerg. 67.. 725 Houston v. State, 26 Tex. App. 657 716, 717 Houston & T. C. R. Co. v. Reason, 61 Tex. 613 770 v. Sympkins, 54 Tex. 615, 38 Am. Hep. 632 ... 769, 775 •». Waller, 56 Tex. 331 771 Hovey v. Chase, 52 Me. 304. 88 Am. Dec. 514 244, 251, 252, 253, 436, 534, 535, 544, 591 v. Harmon, 49 Me. 269 442 v. Hobson, 55 Me. 256 251, 253. 497 Howard v. Braithwaite, 1 Ves. & B. 202 323 v. Coke, 7B. Mon. 655 278, 284, 310, 567 Howard's Will, 5 T. B. Mon. 199, 17 Am. Dec. 60.... 323, 328, 341, 354, 604 Howe®. Howe, 99 Mass. 88 267, 378, 451, 475, 500. 510 v. State, 11 Neb. 537, 38 Am. Rep. 375.. 169 Howell v. Howell, 47 Ga. 492 499 v. Taylor, 11 Hun, 214 566 v. Taylor, 50 N. J. Eq. 428 273, 288 Hoyt 0. Adee, 3 Lans. 173 438, 439, 531, 610 Hoyt's Case, 20 Abb. N. C. 162... 764 Hubbard v. Hoag, 60 Iowa, 756.. 264 v. Hubbard, 7 Or. 42... 288, 462 v. Mason City, 60 Iowa, 400 778, 781, 784, 785 Hubbard's Will, 6 J. J. Marsh. 59 733 Hubbell v. Bissell, 2 Allen. 196... 563 Hudson v. Hudson, 9 L. T. N. S. 579, 12 Week. Rep. 216, 3 Swab. & T. 314, 33 L. J. Prob. N. S. 5, 9 Jur. N. S. 1302 749 Huff v. Huff , 41 Ga. 696 322 Hughes v. Hughes, 31 Ala. 519, Overruling Roberts v. Trawick, 13 Ala. 68... 330, 331, 497, 530, 603 v. Hughes, 2 Munf. 209.375, 430 v. Hughes, 19 Ala. 308 752 v. Jones, 116 N. Y. 67, 5 L. R. A. 632.431, 432, 435, 439 Hull v. Louth, 109 Ind. 315, 58 Am. Rep. 405.454. 523, 610 Hume v. Burton, 1 Ridgew. P. C. 204 434, 531 v. Taylor, 63 111. 43 82 Humphrey's Will, 26 N. J. Eq. 513.. -- 334 Humphreys v. State, 45 Ga. 190.. 131, 132, 168, 170, 449, 455, 467 XXXVI CASES CITED. Hunslet v. Densberry Union, note, 2 Jur. N. S. 1207. 398 Hunt v. Hunt, 3 B. Mon. 575 504, 505, 557, 559, 561, 577 v. Hunt, 13 N. J. Eq. 161.. 270, 430 v. Moore, 2 Pa. 105 247 v. State, 33 Tex. Crim. Rep. 252 478, 480 Hunter v. Atkins, 3 Myl. & K. 113 376 . v. Edney, L. R. 10 Prob. & Div.93-.384. 385, 388, 391 Huntingdon & B. T. R. & Coal Co. v. Decker, 84 Pa. 419, 82 Pa. 119. 770 Huntington's Trial. 447... 172 Hutchins v. Ford, 82 Me. 363 549 Hutchinson v. Brown, Clarke, Ch. 408 725 v. Sandt, 4 Rawle, 234, 26 Am. Dec. 127.435, 441, 535 v. Tindall, 3 N. J. Eq. 357. 728, 731, 733, 741 Hutton v. Waterloo L. Assur. Co. 1 Fost. &F. 735 760 Hutts v. Hutts. 62 Ind. 214 519 Hyatt v. Lunnin, 1 Dem. 14 364 Hver v. Little, 20 N. J. Eq. 443.. 258, 557, 584 Illinois C. R. Co. v. Cragin, 71 111. 177 ...772, 776, 783 v. Hutchinson, 47 111. 408.. 774 Imhof v. Witmer, 31 Pa. 243.-435, 742 Ingalls o. State, 4S Wis. 647.. 6S7, 691 Ingoldsby v. Ineoldsby, 20 Grant, Ch. 131 278, 289, 298 Ingram v. Wyatt. 1 Hagg. Eccl. Rep. 384.. 368 Irish v. Smith, 8 Serg. & R. 573, 11 Am. Dec. 648 317, 343, 496, 507, 511, 522, 526, 530 Irvin v. Deschampo, 11 W. N. C. 365 325, 345 Irwin v. West, 81 Pa. 157 433 Jacklin v. National Life Asso. of Hartford, 75 Hun, 595. 403 lackson v. Hardin, 83 Mo. 175 288, 328, 352, 356, 360, 449, 451, 462, 463 v. Jackson, 37 Hun, 306.420, 423 Jackson v. Jackson, 39 N. Y. 153. 357 v. King, 4 Cow. 207, 15 Am. Dec. 354 9. 247, 252, 449, 453 v. Kniffen, 2 Johns. 31 500 v. Moore, 14 La. Ann. 209. 370 v. Yan Duzen, 5 Johns. 144, 4 Am. Dec. 330 449, 451, 453 Jackson Caldwell, v. Kine, 4 Cow. 207, 15 Am. Dec. 354.. 478 Yan Dusen, v. Yan Dusen, 5 Johns. 144, 4 Am. Dec. 330 478, 481 Jacobs v. Com. 121 Pa. 586. ..127, 524 v. National Ins. Co. 85 N. Y. 317, 39 Am. Rep. 660.. 412 v. Richards, 18 Beav. 300.. 435 Jacox v. Jacox, 40 Mich. 473, 29 Am. Rep. 547 250, 267, 270, 452 James v. James, 58 K H. 266 755 «. Langdon, 7 B. Mon. 193. 260, 266, 294 v. Stonebanks, 1 1ST. J.L. 227. 610 James's Case, 35 X. J. Eq. 58 423 Jamison n. Jamison, 3 Houst. (Del.) 108 276, 277, 279, 286, 320, 451, 459, 475 559, 561, 573, 590, 594, 599 v. People, 145 111. 357 178, 180. 450, 458, 471, 473 558, 561, 568, 577, 580 Jane v. Com. 2 Met. (Ky.) 30 470 Jarrett v. Jarrett, 11 W. Ya. 584.. 253, 254, 255, 262, 263, 266, 271, 451, 454, 479, 481, 590, 599 Jauncey v. Thorne, 2 Barb. Ch. 40 604 J. B.'s Case, 1 Myl. & C. 538.419, 423 Jeffries v. State, 9 Tex. App. 598. 683, 704 Jenckes v. Smithfieid, Court of Probate, 2 R. I. 255.433, 486 Jenisch's Case, 3 Abb. N. C. 200.. 1065 Jenkins v. Jenkins, 2 Dana, 103, 26 Am. Dec. 437 9, 382, 383, 386 v. Morris, L. R. 14 Ch. Div. 674 208. 247, 263 v. State, 93 Ga. 1 682, 687, 691, 693 v. Tobin, 31 Ark. 306 310, 363, 463 Jenkins's Will. 43 Wis. 610 323 Jenners v. Howard, 6 Blackf. 240. 719, 785 Jerry v. Townshend, 9 Md. 145.. 257, 263, 491 John Hancock Mut. L. Ins. Co. e. Daly, 65 Ind. 6. 762 CASES CITED. XXX vu John Hancock Mut L. Ins. Co. w.Moore, 34 Mich. 41... 404, 417; 418 Johnsw. Fntchey, 39 Md. 259.720, 781 Johnson v. Armstrong,97 Ala. 731. 517 v. Blane, 6 Notes of Cas" Ecc]. 442 _ 336 v. Chad well, 8 Humph. 145* 248 v. Culver, 116 Ind. 278.499, 509 v. Johnson, 10 Ind. 387, v. Johnson, 35 Phila. Lee' Int. 70 _7. v. Kincade, 2 Ired. Eq. 470* 382, 380, 430, v. Medlicott. Cited in 3 P. Wins. 130 729, v. Moore, 1 Lilt. 372... v. Phifer, 6 Neb. 401... 244" 25*1, 720," v. Pomeroy, 31 Ohio St. 247 v. Rockwell, 12 Ind. 76 ». State, 1 Tex. App. 146 v. State, 10 Tex. App. 571 467, 539, Johnson's Case, 57 Cal. 529 Estate, 57 Cal. 529 "" Johnston v. Brown, 2 Shaw & D. Sc. Sess. Cas. 437 Jones v. Com. 75 Pa. 403.164 683 v. Com. 30 Pittsb. L. J. 423- v. Consolidated Invest. As- surance Co. 26 Beav. 256- v. Evans, 7 Dana, 96... 254, v. Goodrich, 5 Moore, P c' 16 ». Harris, 3 Rich. L. 14 v. Hughes, 15 Abb. N. 6" 141 256, 257, 306, v. Jones, 1 Cox, Ch. Cas. 184 •o. Jones, 43 N. Y. S. R. 434 250, 253, 451, 461 ». Lloyd, L. R. 18 Eq. 265 ' «. McLellan, 76 Me. 49 498 v. People (Colo.) 47 Pac. 275 v. People, 23 Colo. 276.528, v. Perkins, 5 B. Mon. 222 J 249, 400, 599. 728 ■o. Roberts, 37 Mo. App. 163 460, 463, 498, 499 v. State, 13 Ala. 153.... 193, 194, 200 v. Slate, 29 Ga. 594.... 693 702 v. Thompson, 5 Del. Ch. 374 243, 247, 248, 249, 250, m 253, 259, 378 v. White, 1 Strange, 68 532 Jones's Appeal, 11 W. N. C. 258.. 256 Case, 2 Ohio Dec. 409... 7 Estate, 2 Ohio Dec. 409 " 481 Will, 2 Ohio Dec. 409.. 374 375 743 431 731 301 730 401 732 490 540 684 767 742 698 •780 -406 262 323 340 437 -611 462 379 499 191 541 Julke v. Adam, 1 Redf. 454 598, 734," 737" 778 Juzau v. Toulmin, 9 Ala. 662, 44 Am. Dec. 448.243, 247, 249 K. Kachline v. Clark, 4 Whart. 316 r ,. „ 497, 499" 500 Ivaehn v. Com. 84 Kv. 354 466 Kahl e. Schober, 35 N. J. Eq. 461. 487 733 Kahn's Case, 1 Connoly, 510 ' 302 24 N. Y. S. R. 409 """ 343 Karew v. Continental Ins. Co. 57 Wis. 56, 46 Am. Rep. 17-416 Kastell v. Hill man, 53 N. J. Eq 49 357 Kates's Estate, 16 W. N. C. 100 362 Kearney v. People, 11 Colo. 258 174 v. State, 68 Miss. 233 ^ . , 130. 184, 555 Keating s Appeal, 19 Pitts. L. J •N- S. 282.. 338, 452 Appeal, 36 Pitts. L. J. 283. 313 Keehle v. Cummins, 5 Hayw. 43 248 Keeler v. Keeler, 20 N. Y. S. R _ . , 439. .459; 476 Keeler s Case, 3 N. Y. Supp. 629. m 300, 303 Will, 12 N. Y. S. R. 148 „ 295, 296, 301, 304 Keels v. Mutual Reserve Fund L. Asso. 29 Fed. Rep. 198 412 Keenan v. Com. 44 Pa. 55, 84 Am. Dec. 414 683, 701 Keeton v. Com. 92 Kv. 522 „ . , , ' 688, 692" 693 Keithley v. Keithley. 85 Mo. 217 243 v. Stafford, 126 111. 507 284, 285, 322. 460, 507, _ 559, 568, 582, 587 Kelch v. State, 55 Ohio St. 146. . 456 Kellogg v. Cochran, 87 Cal. 192 12 L. R. A. 104....273| 430, 443, 447 Kelly v. Com. 1 Grant. Cas. 484 683, 700 v. McGuire, 15 Ark. 555 . 245, 248, 559, 600, 601 v. Mutual L. Ins. Co. 75 Fed. Rep. 657. 411, 412 v. State, 31 Tex. Crim. Rep. 216 683, 711, 716 v. State, 3 Smedes &M. 518 _ 683, 688, 693 Kelly's Case, 6 Prac. Rep. (Can.) 220 422 Kemble v. Church, 3 Hagg. Eccl. Rep. 273 604 XXXV111 CASES CITED. Kempf v. Kempf,34Mo. 211. .746, 749 Kempscy v. McGinniss, 21 Mich. 123 281,308,316, 462, 540, 541, 542, 545, 550, 552, 584, 587, 595 Kempson v. Ashbee, L. R. 10 Ch. Cas. 15... 258 Kendall v. May, 10 Allen, 59 609, 610, 611 Kennedy v. Marrast, 46 Ala. 161.. 253, 475 v. Uniacke, State, 48 La. Ann. 1230 444 Kenney v. People, 27 How. Pr. 202 683, 700 Kenny v. People, 86 N. Y. 554, 40 Am. Rep. 556... 683 e. People, 31 N. Y. 330.... 696 Kenton's Case, 5 Binn. 613 419 Kenworthy v. Williams, 5 Ind. 375 464, 478, 481, 493, 516, 557, 602 Keough v. Foreman, 33 La. Ann. 1434_ 722, 728 Kern «. Kern, 51 N. J. Eq. 574... 384, 385, 388, 389, 390, 430 Kerney's Estate, 148 Pa. 218 353 Kerr v. Com. 2 Bush. 67, 24 L. R. A. 555 698 ». Lunsford, 31 W. Va. 659, 2L. R. A. 668 ....275, 284, 286, 289, 290, 292, 349, 492, 496, 518, 531, 533, 541, 543, 544, 545, 568, 584, 587, 597, 599 Kettletas ». Gardner, 1 Paige, 488. 757 Kevil v. Kevil, 2 Bush. 614 331 Key v. Holloway, 7 Baxt. 576 364, 369, 460, 734 Keyes v. Keyes, 22 N. H. 553 382 39^ Keys v. Norris, 6 Rich. Eq. 388-1 430 Kidder v. Stevens, 60 Cal. 414.... 529 Kiedaisch's Will, 2 Connoly, 438. 288, 356, 594 Kiehne v. Wessell, 53 Mo. App. 667 431 Kilburn v. Mullen, 22 Iowa, 498.. 608 Kilgore v. Cross, 1 Fed. Rep. 578. 243, 245, 248, 558, 559, 584 Killian v. Badgett, 27 Ark. 166... 451 Kimball v. Cuddy, 117 111. 213 ... 251, 253, 276, 353. 453, 455 Kimberlv's Appeal, 68 Conn. 428, 37 L. R. A. 261 855 King v. Bryant, 2 Hayw. (N. C.) 393 726 v. Cummins, 60 Vt. 502 271 v. Davis, 60 Vt. 502 246 v. Farley, 1 Hagg. Eocl. Rep. 502 338, 952 King v. King, Cited in L. R. 2 Prob. &Div. 125 396 v. Robinson. 33 Me. 114, 54 Am. Dec. 614 401 v. State, 9 Tex. App. 515 .. 126, 172, 176, 456, 467 v. State, 91 Tenn. 617 450,456, 472 v. State, 90 Ala. 612 68y, 702 v. Tuth, 1 Wheeler, Crim. Cas. 52, note 128 Kingsbury -y.Whitaker. 32 La. Ann. 1055, 36 Am. Rep. 278. 242, 275, 286, 294, 297, 324, 327, 371, 489 Kingsley ». Blanchard, 66 Barb. 317 344, 357, 461 Kinleside «. Harrison, 2 Phillim. Eccl. Rep. 449 281, 308. 338, 353, 485, 598 Kinloch's Trial. 25 How. St. Tr. 891, 997..129, 165, 187, 456 Kinlock «. Palmer, 1 Mill, Const. 215 452, 459, 478, 481 Kinne v. Johnson, 60 Barb. 69 288, 289, 307, 324, 326 V. Kinne, 9 Conn. 102. 21 Am. Dec. 732 277, 278, 286, 311, 316, 317, 344, 562, 599 Kirby v. Carr, 3 Young & C. 135. 380 Kirkwood v. Gordon, 7 Rich. L. 474, 62 Am. Dec. 418 .. 275, 283, 284, 289, 333, 594 Kise v. Heath, 33 N. J. Eq. 239 ._ 350 Klein's Case, Ray Med. Jur. (5th ed.)§42 135, 467 Kline v. Kline, 50 Mich. 438 748 Klock's Case, 49 Hun, 450 566 Klohs v. Klohs, 61 Pa. 245.. .431, 435, 719, 766, 778 Knapp v. Reilly, 3 Dem. 427.. 274, 356 Knauss's Appeal, 114 Pa. 10 312 Knecht «. Mutual L. Ins. Co. 90 Pa. 118 760 Knickerbocker L. Ins. Co. v. Foley, 105 U. S. 350, 26 L. ed. 1055, 11 Fed. Rep. 766, note ..598, 758 e. Peters, 42 Md. 414, 7 Chi- cago Leg. News, 421 404, 408, 411, 416 Knight v. Young, 2 Ves. & B. 184. 181 Knights Templar & Mason's L. Indem. Co. v. Berry, 4 U. S. App. 353, 50 Fed. Rep. 511 415 Knox v. Haug, 48 Minn. 58 273 v. Knox, 30 S. C. 377..:..- 535 v. Knox, 95 Ala. 495 ... . 288, 290, 330, 331, 459, 492 OASES CITED. XXXIX Knox's Appeal, 26 Conn. 20 460 Koegel v. Egner, 54 N. J. Eq. 028 735,778, 779 Koenig v. Globe Mut. L. Ins. Co. 10 Hun, 558 538, 584 Koile v. Ellis, 16 Ind. 301 264, 49L Koons v. Benscoter, 2 Kulp, 451.. 430 Kramer v, Weinert, 81 Ala. 414.. 274, 278, 288, 290, 352, 492 Krielfl. Com. 5 Bush. 362 99, 172, 173, 466, 467, 469, 470, 690, 694, 695 Kroenung v. Goahri, 112 Mo. 641. 260 LaBau v. Vanderbilt, 3 Redf. 382. 304, 305. 333, 334, 353 502 Lackey v. Lackey, 8 B. Mon. 107_. Lacy v. State, 30 Tex. App. 119.. Lady Campbell, The, 2 Hagg, Adm. 5 Laing v. Bruce, 1 Dunlop, B. & M 59 261,270 v. Laing, 21 N. J. Eq. 248.. 751 Lake v. People, 1 Park Crim. Rep 495.. 450, 456, 498, 509 536, 542, 544, 545, 551 Lamb v. Lamb, 105 Ind. 456 228, 278, 330 Lamberts v. Cooper, 29 Gratt. 61. L'Amoreaux v. Crosby, 2 Paige 422..431, 432, 435, 766 Lamprey v. Nudd, 29 N. H. 299.. Lancaster v. State, 2 Lea, 575.699 Lancaster Co. Nat. Bank v. Moore 78 Pa. 407, 21 Am. Rep 24 430 Landis ». Landis, 1 Grant. Cas 248 452, 459, 478 481, 502 Lanergan v. People, 50 Barb. 266. 683, 693 v. People, 6 Park. Crim Rep. 209 683, 687 Lang's Estate, 65 Cal. 19 336, 344, 373, 499, 720 Langdon v. People, 133 111. 382... 192, 450, 471, 477, 480 482, 484, 487 Langley's Case, Cited in Shelford Lunacy, 90... Laning v. New York C. R. Co. 49 N. Y. 521, 10 Am. Rep 417 776 Lansing v. Russell, 13 Barb. 521.. Laros v. Com. 84 Pa. 200 162 183, 200, 495 505 423 186 729 374 755 563 518 323 767 401 704 528 526 713 696 765 506 422 790 378 527 Latham v. Udell, 38 Mich. 238... 308 Lathrop v. Borden, 5 Hun, 660... 802 Latta's Case, 43 Kan. 533 .. 447 Lavette v. Sage, 29 Conn. 577... 260, 725 Lawless v. State, 4 Lea, 179 472 Lawrence v. Lawrence, 4 N. Y. Week. Dig. 299... 277, 288, 350, 565 v. Steel, 66 N. C. 584 289, 290, 329 v. Willis, 75 N. C. 471. 251, 259 Lawrence's Case, 28 N.J.Eq. 331. 4^9 Lawton v. Sun Mut. Ins. Co. 2 Cush. 5)0 682 Layman's Will, 40 Minn. 371.. 461, 462 Leach v. Marsh. 47 Me. 548, 74 Am. Dec. 503 401 v. Prebster, 39 Ind. 492 559 Leache v. State, 22 Tex. App. 279, 58 Am. Rep. 638.. 125, 126, 134, 175, 176, 456, 466, 467, 478, 482, 483, 536, 540, 544, 553, 555 Leaf v. Coles, 1 DeG. M. & G. 175 379, 380 Leake v. Linton, 6 La. Ann. 262.. 750 Le Breton v. Fletcher, 2 Hagg. Eccl. Rep. 558 323, 604 Leckey v. Cunningham, 56 Pa. 370. .430, 486, 766, 767, 768 Lee v. Lee, 4 McCord L. 183, 17 Am. Dec. 722 278, 279, 306, 315, 316, 333, 452, 459, 478, 481 v. Lee, 3 Wash. 236 750, 752 v. Scudder, 31 N. J, Eq. 634 298 v. Ware, 1 Hill. L. 313 720 Lee's Case, 46 N. J. Eq. 193 288, 289, 290, 487, 737, 780 Leech v. Leech, 5 Clark (Pa.) 86.. 274, 278, 288, 301. 306, 737 v. Leech, 5 Pa. L. J. 86 345 Leeper v. Taylor, 47 Ala. 221 . .277, 280 Legeyt v. O'Brien, Milw. Eccl. Rep. 325 382, 741, 842 Legg v. Myer, 5 Redf. 320.... 280, 459 Leggate v. Clark, 111 Mass. 308. . 273, 532 Leggett v. State, 21 Tex. App. 384-712 Leighton v. Orr, 44 Iowa, 691.... 268 Lemann v. Bonsall. 1 Add. Eccl. Rep. 389 950 Lemon v. Jenkins, 48 Ga. 313 256, 266, 284, 345, 375 Lenhard v. Lenhard, 59 Wis. 60.. 267 Lennig's Estate, 4 Pa. Dist. R. 94 353, 575, 584 Leonard v. Leonard, 14 Pick. 280 431, 767 Leonard's Case, 95 Mich. 295.... 420 xl CASES CITED. Lester v. State, 32 Ark. 727. 791 Levett's Case, Cro. Car. 538 117 Levi's Estate, 140 Pa. 179.. 738 Levy v. Lindo, 3 Meriv. 85 347 Lewis v. Arbuckle, 85 Iowa, 335, 16 L. R. A. 677.- 268 x. Baird, 3 McLean, 56 721 x. EHgle Ins. Co. 10 Gray, 508 613 v. Jones, 50 Barb. 645 435, 767, 768 x. Lewis, 44 Minn. 124, 9 L. R. A. 505 384, 386 v. Lewis, 6 Sera:. & R. 496. 309 x. Mason, 109 Mass. 169 506, 511, 533, 548 x. Pead, 1 Ves. Jr. 19 249, 271, 451 Lewis's Case.331Sr. J. Eq. 219.328, 348 Case, 51 Wis. 101 1068 Will, 51 Wis. 101.291, 323, 355 Lev's Case, 1 Lewin, C. C. 144.193, 197 Case, 1 Lewin, C. C. 239.. 472 Liddington's Will, 20 K T. S. R. 610 339 Life Asso. of Amer. x. Walker, 57 Ga. 533 405, 410 Lisktfoot v. Heron, 3 Younge & C. Exch. 586 723 Lillibridge"s Estate, 133 Pa. 211.. 312, 318, 319 Lilly v. People, 141 111. 75. 471 v. People, 14S 111. 467 125, 176, 458. 471, 472, 474 e. Waggoner, 27 111. 395.260, 486 Lin x. Lindhardt, 127 Mo. 271 ... 454 Lincoln v. Norton, 36 Vt. 679 400 Lindsey v. Lindsey, 50 111. 79, 99 Am. Dec. 4S9.. 251 Lindslev's Case. 43 X. J. Eq. 9.. 423 Case, 44 N. J. Eq. 564 422 Linton's Appeal, 104 Pa. 228.-354, 368 Case, 29 W. N. C. 550 534 Litchfield's Appeal, 28 Conn. 127, 73 Am. Dec. 662 402 Little v. Little, 13 Gray, 264.. 397, 433 Little Rock & Ft. S. R. Co. x. Parkhurst, 36 Ark. 371 774 Livingston v. Kiersted, 10 Johns. 362 608, 613 Livingston's Appeal, 63 Conn. 68 462, 463 Lloyd x. Lloyd, 66 111. 87 391 Lockridge v. Lockridge, 3 Dana, 28, 28 Am. Dec. 52 750 Lockwood's Will, 2 Connolly, 118 336 Lodge x. Lodge, 2 Houst. (Del.) 419.. 277, 286, 316, 350, 449, 459, 536, 600 Loeffner v. State, 10 Ohio St. 598 134, 450. 456, 465, 466, 467 Loeser's Estate, 3 Pa. Dist. R. 817 314 Estate, 35 W. N. C. 43 312 Loewenstine's Estate, 2 Misc. 323 358 Loewer v. Sedalia, 77 Mo. 431 778 Loftus v. Maloney, 89 Va. 576... 720, 721, 728 Logan x. McGinnis, 12 Pa. 27 601 Long v. Long, 9 Md. 348 — 258 x. Long, 4 Ir. Ch. 106 449 v. State, 38 Ga. 491 194 Longheal x. B. F. Coombs Com- mission Co. 2 Mo. App. Rep. 1017 719 LoDgmate v. Ledger, 2 Giff. 157. . 250 Look x. Dean, 108 Mass. 116, 11 Am. Rep. 323 444 Looney v. State, 10 Tex. App. 520, 38 Am. Rep. 646 177 Lopez v. State, 30 Tex. App. 487. 615 Lord x. Beard, 79 N. C. 5 550, 613 Lott x. Sweet, 33 Mich. 308 444 Lovatt x. Tribe, 3 Fost. & F. 9... 536, 588, 594 Love x. Johnston, 12 Ired. L. 355. 496 Lovegood v. State, 31 Tex. Crim. Rep. 491 190, 466, 1066 Lowder x. Lowder, 58 Ind. 538 277, 288, 291, 309, 497 Lowe®. Joliffe, 1 W. Bl. 365. .323, 604 x. Williamson, 2 N. J. Eq. 82 288, 562, 599 Loyd?). State, 45 Ga. 57 131, 171 Loza x. State, 1 Tex. App. 488, 28 Am. Rep. 416 691 Lozear x. Shields, 23 1ST. J. Eq. 509 244, 247 Lucas x. Parsons, 23 Ga. 267 432 x. Parsons, 24 Ga. 640, 71 Am. Dec. 147 293, 294, 296, 297, 310 x. Parsons, 27 Ga. 595 333 Ludlow v. Landgrove, 42 Vt. 137 398 Ludwick». Com." 18 _ Pa!Yra7_764, 766 Lyddy's Case, 17 N. T. S. R. 2... 592 Estate, 24 K Y. S. R. 607 S34, 591 Will, 5 N. Y. Supp. 636.-. 319 Lyle x. State, 31 Tex. Crim. Rep. 103 710, 716 Lynch®. Com. 77 Pa. 205 127, 466, 467, 470 x. Doran, 95 Mich. 395.561, 575 v. New York, 47 Hun, 524. 770, 771, 772 Lvnch's Case, 5 Paige, 120 763 Lynn x. Home, L. R. 6 Eq. 655-. 379 Lyon x. Home (1868) L. R. 6 Eq. 655, 682... 235, 268 x. Yan Riper, 36 N. J. Eq. 337 259, 350 CASES CITED. Xll Lyons v. New York C. & II. R. R. Co. 39 Hun. 886 789 Lyster v. Lyster, 111 Mass. 327... 743, 755 Lytlea. State, 31 Ohio St. 196 787 M. Mabie's Case, 5 Misc. 179 288, 291 McAdam v. Walker, 1 Dow, P.'C. 148.. 263, 272, 383, 388, 527 McAllister v. Slate, 17 Ala. 434, 52 Am. Dec. 180 132, 489, 537, 539, 589, 593, 594 v. Territory, 1 Wash. Terr. 360 189, 458 McBee v. McBee, 22 Or. 329 747 McCammon v. Cunningham, 108 Ind. 545.9, 204, 419, 420, 423 McCann v. People, 3 Park. Crim. Rep. 272.. ...541, 551 McCann's Case, 2 Pa. Dist. R. 181. 284 McCarthy's Case, 55 Hun, 7. 566, 585, 598, 603 McCarty v. Com. 14 Ky. L. Rep. 285 541, 713 v. Com. 86 Kv. 110 682 «. Kearnan, 86 111. 291 475 «. State, 4 Tex. Arjp. 461... 697, 698, 794 McClackey v. State, 5 Tex. App. 320 537, 558,576, 600 McClain v. Davis, 77 Ind. 419 402 McClary v. Stull, 44 Neb. 175 296, 297, 305 McCleary v. Barcalow, 6 Ohio C. C. 481 .389, 742 McClintock v. Curd, 32 Mo. 411, 4L. R. A. 738 286, 550 McClure v. Mutual L. Ins. Co. 55 N. Y. 651 418 McConnell v. Wildes. 153 Mass. 487 496, 565 McCook v. State, 91 Ga. 740.. 682, 708 McCoon v. Allen, 45 N. J. Eq. 708 288, 289, 451, 459 McCormick».Demary,10Neb.515. 728 v. Malin, 5 Blackf. 509 727 McCracken v. Markesan, 76 Wis. 499 ; 775, 786 McCraine v. Clarke, 2 Murph. 317. 505 McCreightc. Aiken, RiceL.56.438, 531 McCue's Case, 17 N. J. Week. 501 303 McCulloch v. Campbell, 49 Ark. 367 277, 288, 289, 291, 327, 459 McCullough v. Expressman's Mut. Ben. Asso. 133 Pa. 142, 7 L. R. A. 210. 414 McCullough's Will, 35 Pitts. L. J. 169, Adirmed in Heating's Appeal, 36 Pitts. D. J. 283 286, 292, 316, 864, 545, .",77, 733 McCurry v. Hooper, 12 Ala. 823, 46 Am. Dec. 280 347, 434. 557 McCutchon v. Pigue, 4 Heisk. 565 608 McDaniel v. Crosby, 19 Ark. 533. 311,366, 600 v. McCoy, 68 Mich. 340.. 266 McDaniel's Will, 2 J. J. Marsh, 331 327. 355, 598 McDiarmid v. McDiarmid, 3 Bligh, N. S. 374 259 McDonald v. Chicago, M. & St. P. R. Co. 75 Wis. 121 768 v. McDonald, 16 Grant, Ch. 37-- - 247 v. McDonald, 14 Grant, Ch. 546 241 McDonald's Estate, 130 Pa. 480... 340 McDougal v. State, 88 Ind. 24 179 v. State (Ind.) 4 Crim. L. Mag. 509 456, 457 McDougald 0. McLean, Doe, Winst. L. pt. 1. p. 120. 567, 584 McDowell v. Preston, 26 Ga. 528.. 614, 807 Mace a. Reed, 89 Wis. 440 795 McElroy v. McElroy, 5 Ala. 81... 227, 279, 283, 311 McElroy's Case, 6 Watts & S. 451 423, 426, 428 McElwee v. Ferguson, 43 Md. 479 346, 347, 738 McFaddin v. Vincent, 21 Tex. 47. 259 McFarland's Trial, 8 Abb. Pr. N. S. 57. 172 Trial, 8 Abb. Pr. N. S. 69.. 132 McGill v. McGill, 19 Fla. 341.744, 746 McGinley v. United States L. Ins. Co. 77 N. Y. 495 759 McGinnis v. Com. 102 Pa. 66.683, 698 v. Com., McGinnis, 74 Pa. 245 430, 767 v. Kempsev, 27 Mich. 363. . 462, 477, 517, 518, 536, 555. 584 McGonegal v. McGinnis, Com. 3 Pitts. L. J. 445.... 764, 766 v. McGonegal, 46 Mich. 66.. 748 McHugh v. Fitzgerald, 103 Mich. 21 ....288, 291, 537, 554. 584, 588 Mclntire v. Worthiugton, 68 Md. 203 374 Mclntyre v. Kingsley, 1 Ch. Cham- bers, 281 428 XiU CASES CITED. Mclntyree. People, 3SI11. 514-R82, 666, 686, 699. 702 Mack v. Handy, 39 La. Ann. 491. 744, 750 McKay v. McKay, 18 B. Mon. 8— 749 McKee*. Ingalls. 5 111. 30 6S2 v. People, 36 N. Y. 113 513 Mackenzie v. Handasyde, 2 Hagg. Eccl. Rep. 211,.. 364 v. State, 26 Ark. 334. _. 449, 455, 456, 466 McKillop v. Duluth Street R. Co. 53 Minn. 532.... 792 McKim's Estate. 27 W. N. C. 110. 313 Estate, 9 Pa. Co. Ct. 209. . . 289 Macklin's Case. 3 Cooper, 257.129, 282 McKnight v. Wright, 12 Rich. L. 232 366 McLane v. Elder (Tex. Civ. App.) 23 S W 758 528 McLaughlin's Will! 2 Redf'oOiL" 734 McLean v. State, 16 Ala. 672 489, 498, 501, 509, 580 McLeary v. Norment, 84 N. C. 235 557 McLeod v. State, 31 Tex. Crim. Rep. 331..191, 546, 571, 711 McMaster v. Scriven, 85 Wis. 162. 291, 328. 354, 369 McMastersfl. Blair, 29 Pa. 298... 290,357,459, 482 McMechan v. McMechan, 17 W. Va. 683, 41 Am. Rep. 682.. 274, 327, 461, 501, 521, 541, 543, 545, 585 McMeekin t. McMeekin, 2 Bush, 79 ..323, 330 McNaghten's Case, 1 Car. & K. 130,note 541 Case. 10 Clark & F. 200.19, 22, 23, 89, 131, 134, 142, 151, 169, 170, 449, 450, 467, 540, 583, 591 McNamara's Case, Arkley, 521 201 McNinch v. Charles, 2 Rich. L. 229 369, 507 Maconnehey «. State, 5 Ohio St. 77 ..... 710, 711 McPherson's Appeal (Pa.) 11 Atl. 205 734 Macpherson's Case.l Connoly, 223. 338 McQuirk i: State, 84 Ala. 435 201 McRaee. Malloy. 93 N. C. 154... 557 McSorley v. McSorley, 2 Bradf. 188 ..274, 364, 739 McSparran v. Neeley, 91 Pa. 117.. 722 McTasrgart v. Thompson, 14 Pa. 149 274, 280, 282, 322. 498, 509 McVickar v. McTickar, 46 N. J. Eq. 490.. 743, 750, 754, 755 Maddox ». Maddox, 114 Mo. 35, 35 Am. St. Rep. 735... 283 522 v. SimmoDS, 31 Ga. 512.243! 250 Magahay v. Magahay, 35 Mich. 210 745 Magee ». McNeil, 41 Miss. 17, 99 Am. Dec. 354 495 Maguire v. Middlesex R. Co. 115 Mass. 239 770 Mahone v. Mahone, 19 Cal. 627, 81 Am. Dec. 91. 745 Mahoney's Will, 58 Hun, 608, 34 K Y. S. R. 183 319, 336 Mairs v. Freeman, 3 Redf. 181.292, 327 Mallory v. Travelers Ins. Co. 47 N. Y. 52, 7 Am. Rep. 410 403 Malone v. State, 49 Ga. 210 688 Maloney v. Dewey, 127 111. 395... 401 Malta, The, 2 Haee. Adm. 158... 729 Manby«. Bewick, 3 Kay & J. 342.. 400 Manhattan L. Ins. Co. v. Brough- ton, 109 U. S. 121, 27 L. ed. 878. ..129, 204, 282, 408 Manley v. Staples, 65 Vt. 370 298,479, 487 Mann v. Betterly, 21 Yt. 326- .243, 250 Mansfield B.Mansfield, 13 Mass. 412 397 v. Watson, 2 Iowa, 111 719, 720, 721, 724, 730 Marceau v. Travelers' Ins. Co. 101 Cal. 338 132, 171, 241, 404, 414, 416, 508, 535 Markiea. Markle, 4 Johns. Ch. 168. 426 Marks v. Bryant, 4 Hen. & M. 91. 352 Marler v. State, 67 Ala. 55, 42 Am. Rep. 95 199, 535, 615 Marmon v. Marmon, 47 Iowa, 121 251, 258 Marquette, H. & O. R. Co. x. Hand- ford, 39 Mich. 537 773 Marsh v. Marsh, 28 L. J. Prob. N. S. 13, 1 Swab. & T. 312, 5 Jur. N. S. 46 752 v. Tyrrell, 2 Hasg. Eccl. Rep. 84 281, 388, 952 Marshall v. State, 59 Ga. 154.. 682, 697 Marshall's Case, 1 Lewin C. C. 76 702, 703 Martin v. Baker (Mo.) 36 S. W. 369 249, 250 v. Baker, 135 Mo. 495 523 v. Johnston, 1 Fost. & F. 122 516, 532, 536. 549 v. Martin, 8 Week. Rep. 367 395 v. Mitchell, 28 Ga. 282 331 v. Perkins. 56 Miss. 204 461, 462, 559. 600, 604 v. Thayer, 37 W. Va. 38. .. 3, 7, 278, 289, 292, 299, 320, 325, 352 CASES CITED. xliii Martin c.Wotton, 1 Lee, Eccl. Rep. 130 370, 952 Martin'sCase, Shelf ord, Lunacy, 407 129 Martin's (Jobnathan) Case, York Minster Arson Case 18 Martinez v. Moll, 40 Fed. Rep. 724 202 Marx v. McGlynn, 4 Redf. 457, Affirmed 88 N. Y. 357. . 498, 502, 500, 507 Mason v. Dunbar, 43 Mich. 410, 38 Am. Rep. 201 249 v. Libbey, 2 Abb. N. C. 137 00s v. Mason, 131 Pa. 101 743 v. Mason, 1 Edw. Ch. 278.. 749, 752, 753 Mason's Case, 1 Barb. 430.... 423, 424 Case, 3 Edw. Ch. 380 421 Case, 00 Hun, 40 -.422, 425, 441. 522, 530. 543, 555, 584 Massengale v. State, 24 Tex. App. 181. 185, 450. 457, 407 Matchin v. Matchin, Pa. 332, 47 Am. Dec. 400. 393 Matthiessen & W. Ref . Co. v. Mc- Mahon, 38 N. J. L. 530. 245, 381 Maupin v. Woals, 1 Duv. 223 323 Maverick «.Reynolds,2Bradf. 300. 275 Maxwell v. Lord Montague, Cited in 3 Atk. 540 433 v. Pittenger, 3 N. J. L. 150. 723 v. State, 89 Ala. 150.... 400, 470 May v. Bradlee, 127 Mass. 414 499, 501, 505, 587 Maynard v. Vinton, 59 Mich. 139, 00 Am. Rep. 270 595 Mayo v. Jones, 78 N. C. 402 300, 307, 459 Meacham v. New York State Mut. Ben. Asso. 120 N. Y. 237. 403, 415, 417, 758, 759, 762 v. State Mut. Ben. Asso. 27 N. Y. Wk. Die. 423... 409 Mead v. Coombs, 26 N. J. Eq. 173. 731 Means «. Means, 5 Strobh. L. 167. 320 327 Mears v. Mears, 15 Ohio St. 90...! 463 Meathe v. Meathe, 83 Mich. 150.. 747 Meeker v. Meeker, 75 111. 260 274, 284, 285, 309, 334, 520 v. Meeker, 74 Iowa, 352 284, 288, 289, 510, 544, 582,594, 595 Melanefy v. Morrison, 152 Mass. 473 504, 603 Melendy v. Spaulding, 54 Vt. 517. 549 Memphis & C. R. Co. v. Womack, 84 Ala. 149 709 Mendilon v. State, 18 Tex. App. 462 456, 561, 583 Menkins v. Lichtner, 18 111. 282.. 449, 453, 477, 478, 488, 719, 780 Mercer v. Kelso, 4 Gratt. 106.. 278, 344 v. Stale. 17 Ga. 146.082, 685, 797 Merriman's Will, 42 N. Y. S. R. 019, Affirmed 136 N. V. 58.... ..344, 352 Merrill v. Rolston, 5 Redf. 220... 293. 300, 349 ». Rush, 33 N. J. Eq. 537.. 352 Merritt v. Cotton States L. Ins. Co. 55 Ga. 103 410, 410 Messenger v. Bliss, 35 Ohio St. 587 430 Meyer v. King, 72 Miss. 1 769 v. Pacific R. Co. 40 Mo. 151. 770 v. People, 156 III. 126. .176, 192 Meyers v. Com. 82 Pa. 141 465.466, 468 MicLigan C. R. Co. v. Gilbert, 46 Mich. 176 776 Michigan Mut. L. Ins. Co. v. Nau- gle, 130 Ind. 79 408 Middleborough v. Rochester, 12 Mass. 363 384, 398 Middleditch v. Williams, 45 N. J. Eq. 726, 4 L. R. A. 738 286, 295, 297, 304, 309 Middleton v. Sherburne, 4 Younge & C. 358 363 Mifflin v. Smedley, 3 Del. Co. Rep. 143 372 Mill's Appeal, 44 Conn. 484 517 Miller v. Craig, 36 111. 109.. -.243, 251 v. Finley, 26 Mich. 249, 12 Am. Rep. 300 720, 722 v. Mutual Ben. L. Ins. Co. 31 Iowa, 218, 7 Am. Rep.122 763 v. Oestrich, 157 Pa. 264.... 345,356, 800 v. Rutledge, 83 Va. 863.... 251, 253, 449 n. St. Louis Hospital Asso. 73 Mo. 242 336 v. White, 5 Redf. 320 348, 374, 459, 470 Mills v. Slook, 9 W. N. C. 379 ... 534 Milne v. Bartlett, 3 Jur. 358 380 Milner v. Turner, 4 T. B. Mon. 244. 247 Milton v. Hunter, 13 Bush. 103. .. 463,503, 505 Minor®. Thomas, 12 B. Mon. 106.. 343 Miskey's Appeal, 107 Pa. 011 .... 430,726. 767 Missouri P. R. Co. v. Brazzill, 72 Tex. 233.-244, 261,479, 530 «. Evans, 71 Tex. 362, 1 L. R. A. 446 768, 773 Mitchell v. Kingman, 5 Pick. 431. 709 xliv CASES CITED. Mitchell v. Thomas. 6 Moore, P. C. 137. 12 .Tur. 967, 5 Notes of Cases. 600 364, 365 Mix v. McCoy, 22 Mo. App. 488- _ 683, 784 Moett v. People, 85 N.Y. 373.. 129, 131, 132, 457, 472 Moffit v. Witherspoon, 10 Ired. L. 185 -- 244 Mohler v. Shank, 93 Iowa, 273, 34 L. P. A. 161.— 395 Monahan's Case, 9 Ir. Eq. 253 422, 1068 Monroe Co. v. Budlong, 51 Barb. 493 439 Montag v. People. 141 111. 75.. 449, 457, 458, 471, 473. 474, 686 Montague «. Allen, 78 Va. 592, 49 Am. Rep. 384 275, 277, 350, 590 Montgomery v. Com. 88 Ky. 509. . 173, 181, 489, 547, 555 Moody v. Bibb, 50 Ala. 248 419 Moon v. State, 68 Ga. 687 688 Mooney v. Olson, 22 Kan. 69 498, 499, 500 v. State, 33 Ala. 419 682, 704 Moore v. Allen, 5 lad. 521. 463 v. Com. 13 Ky. L. Rep. 738 — 466 v. Com. 92 Ky. 630... .450, 455, 466, 489 v. Connecticut Mut. L. Ins. Co. lFlipp. 363._..405, 408,409,410, 416 v. Hershey, 90 Pa. 196 438 v. McDonald, 68 Md. 321.. 311 v. Moore, 62 Mo. 192 259, 377, 571, 596 v. Moore, 41 Mo. App. 176. 748 v. Moore, 2 Bradf. 265.-337, 495 x. Speir, SO Ala. 129... 492, 569 v. State, 68 Ga. 687 693 Moore's Estate. 68 Cal. 281 382 Mordaunt v. Moncrieffe, 43 L. J. Mat. N. S. 49, 30 L. T. N. S. 649, 22 Week. Rep. 12, L. R. 2 H. L. (Sc.)374 396 D. Mordaunt, L. R. 2 Prob. & Div. 129, 18 Week. Rep. 845 396 Morgan v. Boys, Cited in 7 Ad. & El. 337. 508 Morgan's Case, 7 Paige, 236.-419, 421 Morris*. Clay, 8 Jones, L. 216... 719 v. Morton, 14 Ky. L. Rep. 360 333,477, 497 v. Nixon, 7 Humph. 579. .. 730 «. State, 84 Ala. 405. 702 v. Stokes, 21 Ga. 552 280 Morrison v. Maciline, 24 Scotch Sess. Cas. 626 553 v. McLeod, 2 Dev. & B. Eq. 221 727 t>. Smith, 3 Bradf. 209.. 367, 478 v. State. 84 Ala. 405.... 682. 693 Morse v. Crawford, 17 Vt. 499, 44 Am. Dec. 349 557, 558 v. Scott, 4Dem. 507.... 297, 301, 329, 343, 478 Morton v. Morton (N. J.) 7 Cent, 134 249. 250, 258 Moss v. Tribe, 3 Fost. & F. 297. .. 721 Mosser v. Mosser. 32 Ala. 551.299, 3: J .l Motley v. Head, 43 Vt. 633.... 38 1, 433 Mott v. Mott, 49 N. J. Eq. 192. .. 258 Mountain v. Bennet, 1 Cox, Eq. 356 280, 308, 461 Mowry v. Home L. Ins. Co. 9R. I. 346 762 v. Silber, 2 Bradf . 133 364. 367, 454 Moyer «. Swygart, 125 111. 267 311 Mudway v. Croft, 3 Curt. Eccl. Rep. 671 8, 279 Muir v. Miller, 72 Iowa, 585 362 Mull v. Carr, 5 Ind. App. 491.570, 580 Muller v. St. Louis Hosp. Asso. 5 Mo. App. 390 496, 500, 501, 502 Mullinsfl. Cottrell, 41 Miss. 291.. 279, 295, 299, 304, 358, 449, 459, 475, 47S. 479, 517, 518, 530 Mulloy v. Ingalls, 4 Neb. 115.244, 251 Munday v. Taylor, 7 Bush, 491... 335 Murdv's Appeal, 23 W. N. C. 124. 367 Murfett v. Smith, L. R. 1 Prob. Div. 116. 297 Murley v. Templeman, Cited in Shelford, Lunacy, 495. 611 Murphree v. Senn. 107 Ala. 424_. 459, 482, 507, 516, 561 Murphy v. Com. 92 Ky. 485 181, 182, 184, 528 v. People, 90 111. 59. ...764, 795 Murray v. Carlin, 67 111. 286 727 Murry v. Hennessey, 48 Neb. 608. 460 Musick».Fisher,16Ky.L.Rep. 277 379 Musselman v. Cravens, 47 Ind. 1. 431 Mutual Ben. L. Ins. Co. v. Daviess, 87 Ky. 541 407 Mutual L. Ins. Co. t>.Hunt,79 N.T. 541 437 v. Lubrie, 71 Fed. Rep. 843, 38 U. S. App. 37 410 v. Terry, 82 U. S. 15 Wall. 580, 21 L. ed. 236 405, 408, 409 v. Wiswell, 56 Kan. 756. 35 L. R. A. 258- -405, 432, 482 CASES CITED. xlv Myatt v. Walker, 44 111. 485 260, 261, 311, 475 Myers v. Hauger, 98 Mo. 433.. 285, 307 v. Knabe, 51 Kau. 720 529 Mynn v. Robinson, 2 Hagg. Eccl. Rep. 169.. 496 Myrickfl. Myrick, 67 Ga. 771 747 N. Nace v. Boyer, 30 Pa. 99 243, 247 Nagle v. Baylor, 3 Dru. & W. 60 720, 725 Nailing v. Nailing, 2 Sneed, 630.. 334 Nailor v. Nailor, 4 Dana, 339 419 NaphVs Estate, 134 Pa. 492.. 313, 325 Estate, 134 Pa. 494 350 Estate, 46 Phila. Leg. Int. 57 275 Nash v. Hunt, lie Mass. 237..".. 496, 547, 565 Nave v. Newlin, State, 69 Ind. 108 557 558 Neanes v. State, 143 Ind. 299 . 533 Needham v. Ide, 5 Pick. 510.. 561, 600 Negroes Jerry v. Townshend, 9 Md. 145 539. 541, 585 Neill v. Morley. 9 Ves. Jr. 478 441 Neilson v. Lafflin, 50 N. Y. S. R. 277 731 Nelson's Case, 39 Minn. 204 587 Nevillsp. Nevills, 6 Grant, Ch. 636. 266 Nevling®. Com. 98 Pa. 322. ..126, 127, 130, 134, 164, 173, 180, 450, 456, 699, 710, 793 Newberry *. State, 32 Tex. Crim. Rep. 145 466 Newcomb ». Newcomb, 16 Ky. L. Rep. 376 289, 811, 562 v. Newcomb, 96 Ky. 120... 495 ■v. Newcomb, 13 Bush, 544, 26 Am. Rep. 222 392 v. State, 37 Miss. 383 126, 131, 450 Newell v. Fisher, 1 Smedes & M. 431, 49 Am. Dec. 66... 719 v. Smith, 23 Ga. 170 401 Newhard v. Yundt, 132 Pa. 324.. 451, 464, 475, 559, 599, 600 New Home L. Asso. v. Hagler, 29 111. App. 437.. 408, 409, 415 Newhouse ©.Godwin, 17 Barb. 236. 280 v. Yundt, 13i Pa. 324 310 Newlin's Estate, 7 Pa. Co. Ct. 648 312, 313 New Phoenix, The, 1 Hagg. Adm. 198 729 Newton v. Carbery, 5 Cranch, C. C. 626.304, 340, 345, 577 Newton v. Central Vermont R. Co. 80 Hun, 491 770, 775 v. Mutual Ben. Life Ins. Co. 15 Hun, 595, Affirmed 76 N. Y.426 408, 404, 409, 534 New York L. Ins. Co. v. La Boi- teaiix (Ohio) 5 Bigelow, Life & Acci. Ins. Rep. 437 761, 763 Nexsen v. Nexsen, 2 Keyes, 232.. 599, 600 Nichol v. Thomas, 53 Ind. 42 435, 491, 531 Nicholas v. Kershner, 20 W. Va. 251.. 275, 284, 286, 289, 292, 334, 349, 461, 590, 597 Nichols v. Binns, 1 Swab. & T. 239 296, 315, 371, 479 v. Nichols, 31 Vt. 331, 73 Am. Dec. 352 392 v. State, 8 Ohio St. 435 690, 697, 705 Nichols & S. Co. v. Hardman, 62 Mo. App. 153 245 Nimick v. Mutual Ben. L. Ins. Co. 3 Brewst. 502 407 Noel®. Karper, 53 Pa. 97 430, 515, 725, 767, 779, 783 v. Modern Woodmen of America, 61 111. App. 597. 401, 414 Nonnemacher v. Nonnemacher, 159 Pa. 634 388 Norfleet v. State, 4 Smeed, 345 698, 701 Norman v. Georgia Loan & T. Co. 92 Ga. 295 242, 246, 484 Norman's Case, 72 Iowa, 84 543, 544, 559, 580 Norris®. Seed, 3 Exch. 782 536 v. Sheppard, 20 Pa. 475 338, 345, 501 v. State, 16 Ala. 776. ...558, 569 North Brunswick Twp. Bd. of Health v. Lederer, 52 N. J. Eq. 675 449 Northern P. R. Co. v. Craft, 69 Fed. Rep. 124 770, 771, 775 Northwestern Mut. L. Ins. Co. v. Hazelett, 105 Ind. 212, 55 Am. Rep. 192 762 v. Muskegon Nat. Bank, 122 U. S.501,30L. ed. 1100 758, 759, 762, 790, 794 Northwestern R. Co. v. Craft, 69 Fed. Rep. 124 784 Norton v. Chapin, Com. 19 Phila. 551 447 xlvi CASES CITED. Norton e.New York Hospital, Peo- ple, 3 Abb. N. C. 229.. 609, 611, 612, 613 v. Paxton, 110 Mo. 456 285, 460, 461 *. Relly, 2 Eden, 286 259 Norwood v. Marrow. 4 Dev. & B. L. 442 ..-498. 499, 500, 501 Nottid.se v. Prince, 2 Giff. 246. .. 376 Nu*sear v. Arnold, 13 Serg. & R. 323 -.505, 517 Nyce v. Kirk bride, Com. 2 Brewst. 400 - 443 O. Obear v. Gray, 73 Ga. 455 423, 429, 493, 560, 582, 584 O'Brien *. Dwyer, 45 N. J. Eq. 689 276, 288, 289, 290 v. People, 36 N. Y. 276, 48 Barb. 274 132. 473, 564, 701, 710 Ockendon v. Barnes, 43 Iowa, 615 241, 531 O'Connell v. People, 87 N. Y. 377, 41 Am. Rep. 379, Af- firming 62 How. Pr. 436. -450, 457, 458, 472, 474 O'Connor v. Madison, 98 Mich. 183 350, 460. 463, 561, 569. 573, 574 v. Rempt, 29 N. J. Eq. 156- 731 Odd Fellows Mut. L. Ins. Co. v. Robkopp, 94 Pa. 59, 9 Ins. L. J. 787 .—761, 783 Odell v. Buck, 21 Wend. 142.-251, 252 Odom v. Riddick, 104 N. C. 515, 7L. R. A. 118 449, 451 O'Donnell v. Roilisrer, 76 Ala. 222, 52 Am. Rep. 322. -.451, 459, 478, 481, 483, 485 Ogden's Case, 2 N. Y. Supp. 345. 342 Ogilvy v. Gregory, 4 "Week. Rep. 221 380, 381 Ogletree *. State, 28 Ala. 993-..- 472 O'Grady v. State, 36 Neb. 320.... 683, 688, 709 O'Hagan v. Dillon, 10 Jones & S. 456 772, 775 O'Herrin *. State, 14 Ind. 420 _ 682, 689, 693 O'Keefe v. Chicago, R. I. & P. R. CO. 32~Iowa, 467 774 Oliver p. Berry, 53 Me. 206, 87 Me. 547 398 *. Puliam, 24 Fed. Rep. 127. 400 O'Neil v. Murray, 4 Bradf. 311... 733 O'Neill v. Nolan, 50 N. Y. S. R. 641 723 Orr *. Pennington (Ya.) 24 S. E. 928 249 Ortwein z. Com. 76 Pa. 414, 18 Am. Rep. 420.176, 467, 470 Osborn v. State (Tex. Crim. App.) 26 S. W. 625 683, 686 Osterbout v. Shoemaker, 3 Hill, 513 438, 531 Otto *. Doty, 61 Iowa, 23 304 Outlaw*. State, 35 Tex. 481 683 Overall v. Bland, 11 Ky. L. Rep. 371 363, 582, 584 *. State, 15 Lea, 672 478, 485, 486 Overton v. Overton, 18 B. Mon. 61 308 3^3 Owing's Case, 1 Bland, Ch. 290.! 424 Case, 1 Bland, Ch. 370, 17 Am. Dec. 311 8, 19, 164, 260, 294 P. Paine *. Aldricb, 133 N. Y. 544.. 566 v. Roberts, 82 N. C. 451... 284, 286 Palmer *. Parkburst, 1 Ch. Cas. 112 435 Palmer's Estate, 24 W. N. C. 105. 312 Estate, 5 W. N. C. 542 592 Panaud v. Jones, 1 Cal. 488.. 451, 459 Pancoast *. Graham, 15 N. J. Eq. 294 324, 325. 327, 337 Pannell *. Com. 86 Pa. 260 460, 465, 550, 578, 596 Parish v. Parish, 42 Barb. 274.274, 1067 Park *. Barron, 20 Ga. 702 383 Parker v. Davis, 8 Jones, L. 460 _. 430, 431 v. Marco, 76 Fed. Rep. 510 241, 254, 255 *. Parker, 2 Lee Eccl. Rep. 383 382, 383, 389 *. Parker, 52 111. App. 333. 791, 792 Parker's Case (1812) 1 Collinson, Lunacy, 477.. 130, 139, 467 Parkhurst v. Horsford, 21 Fed. Rep. 829 260, 559 Parnell v. Parnell, 2 Phillim. Eccl. ' Rep. 158, 2 Hagg. Con- sist. Rep. 169 396 Parramore r. Taylor, 11 Gratt. 220 35 7 Parris *. Cobb, o Rich. Eq. 450 . 376 Parsons v. Parsons, 66 Iowa, 754. 500, 579, 583 *. State, 81 Ala. 577, 60 Am. Rep. 193 126, 131, 135, 165, 168, 173, 174, 179. 466, 470 Partello v. Hoi ton, 79 Mich. 372.. 425 CASES CITED. xlvii Patterson v. People, 46 Barb. 625. 127, 563 v. State, 86 Ga. 70... 586 v. State, 66 Ind. 185 783 Patterson's Case, 4 How. Pr. 34.. 431, 432, 435, 767, 768 Will, 36 N. Y. S. R. 813... 354 Patton v. Patton, 5 J. J. Marsh, 389 345 Pavey v. Wintrode, 87 Ind. 379.. 493 Payn's Case, 8 How. Pr. 220, 224. 419, 429 Payne v. Banks, 32 Miss. 292.451, 459 v. State, 5 Tex. App. 35... 683 Peabody v. Kendall, 145 111. 519.. 251, 252, 253 Peacock v. Evans, 16 Ves. Jr. 512. 250 Peake v. Van Lewven,59 Iowa,764. 272 Pearce v. Chamberlain, 2 Ves. Sr. 33.. 380 Pearman v. Pearman, 1 Swab. & T. 601, 29 L. J. Prob. N. S. 54, 8 Week. Rep. 274 751 Pearson's Case, 2 Lewin, C. C. 75. 684 Peases. Burrowes, 86 Me. 153... 612, 613, 614 Peaslee v. Robbins, 3 Met. 164.263, 491 Peasley v. Safety Deposit Life Ins. Co. 15 Hun, 227 404 Peck v. Cary, 27 N. Y. 9, 84 Am. Dec. 220. 736, 737, 738 Peck's Case, 42 N. Y. S. R. 898.. 738 Pedler v. Paige, 1 Moody & R. 258. 602 Peebles?). Case, 2 Bradf . 226 604 Peeples v. Stevens, 8 Rich. L. 198, 64 Am. Dec. 750.. .504, 505 Peery v. Peery, 94 Tenn. 328.498, 500 Peiffera.Weishaupt, 13 Daly, 161. 414 Pelamourges v. Clark, 9 Iowa, 1.. 280, 347, 557, 560, 561, 583 Pendlay v. Eaton, 130 111. 69 320, 462, 464 Pendleton's Case, 1 Connelly, 480. 328, 440 Penninerton v. Stanton, 125 Mo. 658 253 «. Thompson, 5 Del. Ch. 328.. 434 Pennypacker v. Pennypacker (Pa.) 7 Cent. Rep. 532... 449, 453 Pennsylvania v. McFall, 1 Addi- son (Pa.) 255 664, 702 Pennsylvania R. Co. v. Books, 57 Pa 339 770 Pensyl's Case," 157 Pa" 465V." 313", 325 People v. Ah Ying, 42 Cal. 18.193, 194 v. Augsbury, 97 N. Y. 501. 543, 555 v. Barber, 115 N. Y. 475... 184, 536, 540. 553 t>. Batting, 49 How. Pr. 392 683, 698 People v. Bawden, 90 Cal. 195 455,466 v. Belencia, 21 Cal. 544 688, 698, 699, 701, 702 v. Bell, 49 Cal. 485.455, 466, 777 v. Bemmerly, 98 Cal. 299.. 455, 466 v. Best, 39 Cal. 690 163 v. Blake, 65 Cal. 275 682,692, 785 v. Borgetto, 99 Mich. 336... 562, 569, 574, 580 v. Bumberger, 45 Cal. 650.. 180 v. Calton, 5 Utah, 451 131, 456, 690 v. Carnel, 2 Edm. Sel. Cas. 200 128 v. Carpenter, 102 N. Y. 245, 38 Hun, 490. 172, 616 v. Casey, 2N. Y. Crim. Rep. 7, Reversed 2 N. Y. Crim. Rep. 194 131, 450, 456, 472 v. Cassiano, 30 Hun, 388... 693 v. Cavanaugh, 62 How. Pr. 187.. 683 v. Clendenin, 91 Cal. 35 162, 172, 181, 490 v. Coffman, 24 Cal. 230.134, 466 v. Coleman, 1 N. Y. Crim. Rep. 1. 131, 172, 450, 456, 472 v. Conroy, 33 Hun. 119 164 v. Conroy, 97 N. Y. 67 566 v. Conrov, 2 N. Y. Crim. Rep? 247 698 v. Cummins, 47 Mich. 334.. 133, 691, 713, 715 v. Degraff, 1 Wheeler, Crim. Cas. 203 180 v. Dillon, 8 Utah, 92 450, 456, 466, 694 v. Divine, 1 Edm. Sel. Cas. 596 127, 172 v. Durfee, 62 Mich. 487. 127, 175 v. Eastwood, 14 N. Y. 562.. 667, 688, 693, 793 v. Eubanks, 86 Cal. 295.... 781 v. Farrell, 31 Cal. 576 193, 195, 197, 199, 200, 489 v. Ferris, 55 Cal. 588 682, 685, 690, 710 v. Fine, 77 Cal. 147 573 v. Finley, 38 Mich. 482 127, 174, 175, 472, 558, 591, 593, 6b2 D. Fish, 125 N. Y. 136 564, 689, 694, 695 v. Fisher, 23 111. 293 458 v. Foy, 138 N. Y. 664 127 v. Francis, 38 Cal. 183.. 482, 484 xlviii CASES CITED. People x. Fuller, 2 Park. Crim. Rep. 16... _.6S3, 701 x. Garbutt, 17 Mich. 9, 97 Am. Dec. 162 450, 458, 466, 471, 472, 491, 527, 682, 685, 709 x. Haley, 48 Mich. 495 688 x. Hamilton, 62 Cal. 377, Overruling People v. Wreden, 59 Cal. 392. .. 469 x. Hammill, 2 Park. Crim. Rep. 223__672, 683, 693, 697 x. Harper, 1 Edm. Sel. Cas. 180... 608 x. Harris, 29 Cal. 678 687, 688, 693 x. Hawkins, 109 N. Y. 408. 501, 502, 552 x. Hobson, 17 Cal. 424. .131, 164 x. Hoin, 62 Cal. 120, 45 Am. Rep. 651 172 x. Holmes (Mich.) 69 N. W. 501 178, 180, 552, 553 x. Hurley, 8 Cal. 390... 126, 127 0. Hurtado, 63 Cal 288 163, 165, 514, 530 v. Irvine, Lincoln, Neb., Crim. Court, 1892 977 x. Jones, 63 Cal. 168 787 x. Jones, 2 Edm. Sel. Cas. 88 683, 697 x. Kemmler, 119 N. T. 580. 538. 590, 703 x. Kernaghan, 72 Cal. 609. . 171 x. King, 27 Cal. 507, 87 Am. Dec. 95 693, 698 x. Kirby, 2 Park. Crim. Rep. 28.. 450 x. Kleim, 1 Edm. Sel. Cas. 13... 135, 148, 172 v. Kloss(Cal.) 47 Pac. 459.. 180 x. Kloss, 115 Cal. 567 685, 693, 788, 1067 «. Lake, 12 N. Y. 358, Aff'g lPark. Crim. Rep. 495. 530, 542, 555, 590, 591 «. Lake, 2 Park. Crim. Rep. 215 8, 183, 185, 514, 590 x. Lane, 100 Cal. 379 694 x. Lane, 101 Cal. 513. ..513, 573 x. Langton, 67 Cal. 427.701, 702 x. Lavelle, 71 Cal. 351 572 x. Lee Fook, 85 Cal. 300... 194, 195, 489 x. Leonardi, 143 N. Y. 360. 688, 699 x. Lewis, 36 Cal. 531... 682, 695 v. McCann, 3 Park. Crim. Rep. 272 465, 794 v. McCann, 16 N. Y. 58, 69 Am. Dec. 642 471, 472 People v. McCarthy (Cal.) 46 Pac. 1073 180 x. McCarthy, 115 Cal. 255.. 455, 573, 583 x. McDonell, 47 Cal. 134... 131, 171, 455, 466, 467 x. McElvaine, 121 N. Y. 250. 546 x. McNulty, 93 Cal. 427 449,455, 466 x. March, 6 Cal. 543 181 x. Marseiler, 70 Cal. 98 690 x. Messersmith, 57 Cal. 575. 466 x. Messersmith, 61 Cal. 246. 184, 469 x. Miles, 143 N. Y. 383 .... 513 x. Mills, 98 N. Y. 176.... 1. 171, 695, 701, 712 x. Moice, 15 Cal. 329 198 x. Monteith, 73 Cal. 7 792 X. Montgomery, 13 Abb. Pr. N. S. 207 125, 132, 171, 172, 189, 190, 478, 479, 529, 594, 1067 x. Mortimer, 48 Mich. 37. 127, 175 x. Myers, 20 Cal. 518. 455.466, 470 x. Nichol, 34 Cal. 211 682, 687, 688, 698, 701, 707 x. O'Connell, 62 How. Pr. 436 125, 131, 450, 456, 683, 710 x. Odell, IDak. 189 682, 686, 688, 704 x. Osmond, 138 N. Y. 80... 189, 520, 552, 567 x. Packenham, 115 N. Y. 200, 566, 793 x. Parker, 67 Mich. 222 692 x. Phelon, 93 Cal. Ill 692 x. Pico, 62 Cal. 50 132, 133, 180, 200, 528 v. Pine, 2 Barb. 566 133, 168, 169, 17S, 191, 450, 456.467, 683 x. Porter, 2 Park. Crim. Rep. 14... ...683, 690 x. Rbinelander, 2 K Y. Crim. Rep. 335 196 x. Robinson, 1 Park. Crim. Rep. 649, Affirmed 2 Park. Crim. Rep. 285.. 450, 456, 683, 685 x. Robinson, 2 Park. Crim. Rep. 235 683, 688, 696, 707, 711 x. Rogers. 18 N-. Y. 9, 72 Am. Dec. 484 683, 685, 689, 702, 710 x. Sadie McMullen, Oyer and Terminer, Buffalo, N. Y. 1891 1057 CASES CITED. xlix People v. Sanford, 43 Cal. 29 557, 558, 568 v. Schmitt, 106 Cal. 48.. 168. 182, 199, 455, 484, 530, 573 v. Slack, 90 Mich. 448 186 v. Smiler, 125 N. Y. 717... 544 v. Smith, 31 Cal. 466 528 v. Smith, 57 Cal. 130 480 i>. Sprague, 2 Park. Crim. Rep. 43 99, 172, 185 v. Sutton, 73 Cal. 243 -555 v. Taylor, 138 N. Y. 398... 166,169, 170 ®. Thurston, 2 Park. Crim. Rep. 49..542, 544, 586, 591 v. Travers, 88 Cal. 233 449, 455, 466, 710, 713 v. Tripler, 1 Wheeler, Crim. Cas. 48 181 v. Vincent, 95 Cal. 425 701 v. Walker, 38 Mich. 158.688, 691 v. Walter, 1 Idaho, 386--.. 134, 179, 450, 455, 466 v. Waltz, 50 How. Pr. 204. 130, 167, 171, 172, 178 v. Ward, 105 Cal. 335 171, 455, 466, 469, 533 v. Webster, 59 Hun, 398... 179, 552, 596 v. Whedon, 2 N. Y. Crim. Rep. 318. 489 v. Willey, 2 Park. Crim. Rep. 19 683 1). Williams, 43 Cal. 344.... 682, 685, 698, 701, 703 v. Wilson, 49 Cal. 13. -.466, 469 v. Wilson, 55 Mich. 506 ... 682, 684 «. Word, 126 N. Y. 249_... 509, 519, 524 v. Worthinffton, 105 Cal. 166 523 v. Wreden, 59 Cal. 392, 12 Am. Rep. 682, Overruled by People v. Hamilton, 62 Cal. 377 466, 469, 558, 794 v. Young, 102 Cal. 411 688 People, Clough, v. Levy, 71 Cal. 618 180 Peresse's Case, 1 Malloy, 219 427 Perkins v. Perkins, 39 N. H. 163.. 449, 459, 460, 604 v. Scott, 23 Iowa, 237.. 258, 259 Perkins's Case, 2 Johns. Ch. 124.. 534 Perrine's Case, 41 N. J. Eq. 409.. 421, 422, 425 Perry v. Pearson, 135 111. 218.. 242, 244 v. State, 87 Ala. 30 181 Peters v. Peters, 101 Mich. 291... 263 Pettitt v. Pettitt, 4 Humph. 191 .. 346 Petrie v. Petrie, 25 N. Y. S. R. 309 56«, 598. 599, 602 Pettes v. Bingham, 10 N. II. 515.. 451, 459 Pettigrew v. State, 12 Tex. App. 225 187 Pflueger v. State, 46 Neb. 493 192,570, 583 Phadenhauer v. German ia L. Ins. Co. 7 Heisk. 567, 19 Am. Rep. 623 408, 410 Phebea. Prince Walk (Miss.) 131.. 608 Phelan v. Gardner, 43 Cal. 306... 719, 778 Phelps v. Com. 17 Kv. L. Rep. 706 18*2, 450, 455, 466, 547, 557, 558 v. Hartwell, 1 Mass. 71 460,461, 503 Philadelphia Trust & S. D. Co. v. Drinkhouse, 17 Phila. 23 289,291,292, 295, 296, 298, 452, 459, 475, 492, 493, 734 Phillips v. Chater, 1 Dem. 533.274, 301 v. Louisiana Equit. L. Ins. Co. 26 La. Ann. 404, 21 Am. Rep. 549 405, 408, 409, 416 v. Moore, 11 Mo. 600 719 v. Phillips, 81 Ky. 329 289 Physio-Med. Col. v. Wilkinson, 108 Ind. 314.. 251, 478, 487 Pickerell v. Morss, 97 111. 220.. 243, 454 Pickett v. Sutter, 5 Cal. 412... 720, 721 Pidcock v. Potter, 68 Pa. 348, 8 Am. Rep. 181.. 291, 294, 288, 289, 290, 492, 528, 600 Pierce v. Pierce, 38 Mich. 412 340, 509, 734, 739, 779, 793 v. State, 53 Ga. 365.... 787, 792 v. Travelers' L. Ins. Co. 34 Wis. 389 407, 411 Pigg«. State, 43 Tex. 108. .. .536, 537 Pigman v. State, 14 Ohio, 555, 45 Am. Dec. 558 683, 686,687, 698 Pike v. Pike, 104 Ala. 642 265, 266, 370, 454, 477, 478, 480,481, 488 Pile v. Pile, 94 Ky. 308 391, 394 Pilling v. Pilling, 45 Barb. 86.... 325 Pinney's Will, 27 Minn. 280 494, 507, 509, 531, 557, 559, 561, 582 Pinocvi's Case, 5 City Hall Rec. 123 181 Piper v. Hoard, 107 N. Y. 67.. 399, 400 Pirtle v. State, 9 Humph. 663 683, 698, 701 Pistorius v. Com. 84 Pa. 158 163 4a 1 CASES CITED. Pitt v. Smith, 3 Campb. 33.. 719, 720, 730 Pittard v. Foster, 12 111. App. 132 286, 287, 430. 431, 433, 542, 557, 559, 573 Plake v. State, 121 Ind. 433, 16 Am. St, Rep. 408- -178, 471 Plimley v. Plimley, 35 N. J. Eq. 18 . 755 Pockett o. Sutter, 5 Cal. 412 682 Polin v. State, 14 Neb. 540 558, 568 Polk v. State, 19 Ind. 170, 81 Am. Dec. 382 471, 474 Pollock t. Horn, 13 Wash. 626.-- 401 Poole v. Richardson, 3 Mass. 330, 565, 600 Porritta. Porritt, 16 Mich. 140.-- 743 Porter v. Campbell, 2 Baxt. 81... 341 v. Porter, 3 Humph. 586. .. 399 v. Throop, 47 Mich. 313— 582, 584 Portsmouth v. Portsmouth, 1 Ha^er. Eccl. Rep. 355. . 386, 430 Potter v. Jones, 20 Or. 239, 12 L. R. A. 161 295, 297, 300 9. McAlpine. 3 Dem. 108— 297, 300, 340, 451, 459 9. Woodruff, 92 Mich. 8— 272. 1067 Potts v. House, 6 Ga. 324, 50 Am. Dec. 329 275,276, 278, 280, 284, 293, 331, 335, 343, 460, 463, 464, 537, 538, 559, 561, 573, 601 Powell 9. Powell, 27 Miss. 783 — 384, 389 9. Powell, 18 Kan. 371, 26 Am. Rep. 774 382, 386, 387, 391, 394 v, Powell, 27 Miss. 783 451 9. State, 25 Ala. 21 572, 581, 583, 588 9. State, 37 Tex. 348 126 Power 9. Power, 11 Jur. N. S. 800, 4 Swab. & T. 173, 34 L. J. Prob. N. S. 137, 13 Week. Rep. 1113 750 Powers 9. Powers, 20 Neb. 529. .. 751, 753, 754 Prather v. McClelland, 76 Tex. 574 281, 284, 289, 291. 295, 296, 309, 310, 326, 327, 505, 543 9. Naylor, 1 B. Mon. 244... 245, 246, 268, 534 Pratte v. Coffman, 33 Mo. 76 498, 499, 502 Prendergast's Case 99, 866 Prentice v. Achorn, 2 Paige, 30 719 Prentis 9. Bates, 88 Mich. 567, Affirmed 93 Mich. 234, 17 L. R. A. 494 277, 282, 284, 341, 345, 351, 354, 358, 459, 460, 461, 476, 511, 525, 527, 540, 544, 545, 552, 553, 555, 561, 573, 574, 578, 584 Prescott's Case, N. H 150 Prewettt\ Coop wood, 30 Miss. 369. 259 Price 9. Berrington, 2 Beav. 286. . 438 9. Philadelphia W. & B. R. Co. 84 Md. 506, 36 L. R. A. 213 ...769, 774 9. Price, 1 DeG. M. & G. 308. . 259 9. Richmond & D. R Co .38 S. C. 199 541, 553, 557, 568, 580 Prine 9. Prine, 36 Fla. 676, 34 L. R. A. 87 383, 741 Prinsep v. Sombre, 10 Moore, P. C. 232.-295, 330, 430, 486, 591 Probst's Will, 2 Lane. L. Rev. 97. 279 Pugh 9. State, 2 Tex. App. 539— 683, 704 Puryear 9. Reese, 6 Coldw. 21 293, 297, 459, 478, 482, 536, 538, 557, 559, 601 Q- Queen 9. Crouch, 1 Cox, C. C. 94. 606 9. Goode, 7 Ad. & El. 536_. 197 v. Ryan, 2 Cox, C. C. 15— 201, 202 9. Whitehead, L. R. 1 C. C. 33 609 Quteenberry 9. Quisenberry, 14 B. Mon. 481... 340, 502 R. Rafferty 9. People, 66 111. 118 682, 689, 693 Raean 9. Raean, 33 Ga. 106 288 Rafston 9. Turpon, 129 U. S. 663, 32 L. ed. 747.-269, 271, 375 Rambler 9. Tryon, 7 Serg. & R. 90, 10 Am. Dec. 444 500, 557, 559, 570, 580 Ramsdall's Case, 20 N. Y. S. R. 466, 51 Hun, 636 329 Ramsdell v. Viele, 6 Dem. 244 321 Rankin 9. Rankin, 61 Mo. 295 340, 496, 592 Rannells v. Gerner, 80 Mo. 475. .. 431, 535 CASES CITED. Rapplee's Case, 66 Hun, 5/58 355, 564, 1068 Rarick v. Ulmer, 144 Ind. 25 560 Kathbun v. Rathbun, 40 How. Pr. 328... 303, 396 Rather v. State, 25 Tex. App. 624 717, 779 Rawdon v. Rawdon, 28 Ala. 565 382, 386, 390 Rawson's Case. .._.-_ 977 Raymond v. Vaughn, 128 111." 256 4 L. R. A. 440 ' 380 v. Vaughn, 17 111. App. 144 380 v. "Wathen, 142 Ind. 367 252, 480 Raynett v. Baluss, 54 Mich. 469.. 245 Reagan v. State, 28 Tex. App. 227 707, 717 Real v. People, 42 N. Y. 270.. 564, 787 Redden v. Baker, 86 Ind. 191.431,' 432 Reece v. Pressey, 2 Jur. N. S. 380. 367 Reed v. Harper, 25 Iowa, 87... 784 v. State, 62 Miss. 405.. 541 548. 550, 557, 558, 569J 586 Reed's Case, 2 Connoly, 403 734 Will, 2 B. Mon.*79*._._284, 285 Reel v. Reel, 1 Hawk. 248, 9 Am. Dec. 632 498, 500 Reese. Stille, 38 Pa. 138 309 Reeves. Bonwill, 5 Del. Ch. l._. 449,453 Reg. . Offord (1831) 5 Car. & P. 168.. ..18, 23, 132, 134, 140. 465 v. Pritchard, 7 Car. & P. 303 196 «. Searle, 1 Moody & R. 75 540, 591 t. Spilsbury, 7 Car. & P. 187 674, 791 v. Thomas, 7 Car. & P. 817 684, 696, 702 v. Wright, Russ. & R. C. C. 456 540 Reynolds v. Adams, 90 111. 134. 32 Am. Rep. 15.. 498, 499, 514 v. Dechaums, 24 Tex. 174, 76 Am. Dec. 101 ..720, 723 v. Reynolds, 44 Minn. 132. . 744 «. Root, 62 Barb. 250. .277, 288, 289, 290, 335, 353, 362 Rhodes v. Bates, L. R. 1 Ch. 252. 248 v. Vinson, 9 Gill. 169, 52 Am. Dec. 685.. 374 Rice v. Rice, 50 Mich. 448, 53 Mich. 432.. 233, 276, 283, 298, 331, 353, 437, 512, 533, 537, 557, 559, 561, 582, 584, 599 v. Rice, 127 Pa. 181... 498, 499, 501, 502 Rich v. Bowker, 25 Kan. 7 463 v. Cary, 27 N. Y. 9 734 Richards v. Pitts, 124 Mo. 602... 250 v. Richards, 19 111. App. 465 745, 746, 748 Richardson v. Smart, 2 Mo. App. Rep. 1107 ...375, 483 v. Strong, 13 Ired. L. 106, 55 Am. Dec. 430 722 Richmond's Appeal, 59 Conn. 226 350, 581 Ricketts v. Joliff, 62 Miss. 440 252, 253, 370, 371, 449, 453, 478, 480 Ridell v, Johnson, 26 Gratt. 152.. 461, 476 Rider v. Miller, 86 N. Y. 507.... 436, 438, 531, 535, 566 Ridgeway v. Darwin, 8 Ves. Jr. 65 420, 422 Ridley v. Lamb, 10 U. C. Q. B. 354 770 Rigg v. Wilton, 13 111. 15, 54 Am. Dec. 419 ..322, 323, 460, 475 Riggs v. American Home Ins. Soc. 35 Hun, 656.. 295, 301 v. American Tract Soc. 95 K Y. 503 296, 302, 376 Right r>. Price, 1 Dougl. 241 604 Riley v. Hartford L. & A. Ins. Co. 25 Fed. Rep. 315 412 Ripley v. Babcock, 13 Wis. 425. .. 265, 269, 481 Rippey v. Gant, 4 Ired. Eq. 443 .. 241. 243, 248, 437, 438 Ritter v. Mutual L. Ins. Co. 70 Fed. Rep. 954 405, 408 Rivara v. Ohio, 3 E. D. Smith, 364 613 Rivard v. Rivard (Mich.) 2 Det. L. N. 1003 302, 585 Roberts v. People, 19 Mich. 401. . 671, 682, 688, 689, 694, 696, 704, 705, 709 «. State, 3 Ga. 310 23, 131, 169, 174 v. Trawick, 13 Ala. 68, Over- ruled by Hughes v. Hughes, 31 Ala. 519. .. 495, 497, 505, 561, 569, 584 Robertson v. Lain, 19 Wend. 650.. 401 v. Lyon, 24 S. C. 266 423 Robeson v. Martin, 93 Ind. 420... 443 Robinett v. Ship Exeter, 2 Rob. Adm. 261 729 CASES CITED. liii Robinson v. Adams, 62 Me. 369, 16 Am. Rep. 473 298, 301, 306, 309, 310, 460, 461, 476, 492, 493, 600, 601 v. Allbee, 1 Ohio Dec. 19 .. 271 v. Dana, 16 Vt. 474. ...608, 609 v. Fitchburg & W. R. Co. 7 Gray, 92 785 v. Hutchinson, 26 Vt. 38, 60 Am. Dec. 298 498, 501 o. Robinson, 39 Vt. 267. ... 430 i). State, 113 Ind. 510. .682, 691 Roblin v. Roblin, 28 Grant. Ch. (U. C.) 439-741, 743,752, 754 Rock Island v. Vanlandochoot, 78 111. 485 773 Rodd v. Lewis, 2 Lee, Eccl. Rep. 176 429, 440 Rodgers v. Rodgers, 56 Kan. 483 . . 487 v. State (Tex. Crim. App.)28 S. W. 685 129 Rodgers's Estate, 19 W. N. C. 383 286, 289, 291, 294, 359 Rodman v. Zilley, 1 N. J. Eq. 320. 728 Rodriguiz v. State, 20 Tex. App. 542 202 Roe v. Taylor, 45 111. 485 288, 296, 559, 579 Rogers v. Diamond, 13 Ark. 475.. 311 v. People, 3 Park. Crim. Rep. 633.-683, 688, 693, 694 v. Rogers, 2 B. Mon. 324... 505 v. State, 33 Ind. 543.... 524, 767. 801, 805 «. Walker, 6 Pa. 371, 47 Am. Dec. 470.. 430, 431,478, 480 Rogers's Case, 2 Greenl. Ev. § 372. 150 Case, 5 N. J. Eq. 46 441,442 Case, 9 Abb. N. C. 141 423 Rollwagen v. Rollwagen, 5 Thomp. &C. 402 339,565, 566 Root v. Davis, 10 Mont. 228 756 Rose v. Rose, 9 Ark. 507 743 Ross v. Chester, 1 Hagg. Eccl. Rep. 227 337 v. Christman, 1 Ired. L. 209. 331 1). McQuiston, 45 Iowa, 145. 493, 496, 498, 501, 502 v. State, 62 Ala. 224.... 682, 684, 686, 703, 713 Ross's Case, 87 N. Y. 514 564, 566 Roswell v. Com. 20 Gratt. 860 698 Rothrock v. Rothrock, 22 Or. 551. 355 Rottenbure:h v. Fowl (N. J. Ch.) 26 Atl. 338 721, 724, 733 Rowland v. Sullivan, 4 Desauss. Eq. 518 331 Rowson's Estate, 4 Pa. Dist. R. 91, Affirmed in 175 Pa. 154. 312 Rubright v. W. Pa. Hospital, Com. SPittsb. 299.. 425, 443, 445 Rude v. Nass, 79 Wis. 321 660 Rulet\ Maupin, 84 Mo. 587.. 499, 501 Runkle®. Gates, 11 Ind. 95.. 276. 286 Runyan v. Price. 15 Ohio St. 1, 86 Am. Dec. 459 464, 587, 588, 589, 603 Rush v. Meeee, 36 Ind. 69.... 278, 291, 295. 296, 303, 344, 449, 477, 530, 552, 554, 558, 579, 584, 587, 590, 598 Russell v. Lefrancois, 8 Can. S. C. 335 380, 479 v. State, 53 Miss. 367... 132 457, 472, 489, 546, 548, 549 Russell's Case, 1 Barb. Ch. 38 427 Rutherford v. Morris, 77 111. 397.. 276, 284, 337, 502, 592 v. Ruff, 4 Desauss. Eq. (S. C.)350 732, 740 Rutland v. Gleaves, 1 Swan, 198.. 739, 777, 807 Ryan v. Ryan, 9 Mo. 539 748 Ryerson v. Adams, 6 N. J. Eq. 618 731, 740 Ryman «. Crawford, 86 Ind. 262.. 558, 571 S. Sabalot v. Populus, 31 La. Ann. 854... 387 Sabin v. Senate of Nat. Union, 90 Mich. 177 411 Sacramento Sav. Bank v. Spencer, 53Cal. 737 401 Sadley v. Lee, 6 Beav. 324.... 379, 380 Sagar v. Hogmire (Mich.) 2 Det. L. N. 894 561 Sage v. State, 91 Ind. 141.125, 163, 522 St. George v. Biddeford, 76 Me. 593.-8,30,241,384,385, 388 St. Leger's Appeal, 34 Conn. 434, 91 Am. Dec. 735... 286, 291 St. Louis Mut. Life Ins. Co. it. Graves, 6 Bush. 268.405, 557 Salentine v. Mutual Ben. L. Ins. Co. 24 Fed. Rep. 159.. 411 Salisbury v. Aldrich, 118 111. 199.. 330, 331 Samuel v. Marshall, 3 Leigh. 567. 731, 740 Sanchez v. People, 22 K Y. 147.. 514, 553 Sanders v. State, 18 Tex. App. 372. 467 v. State, 94 Ind. 147.... 127, 175. 180, 450, 455, 594, 682 Sanderson v. Sanderson, 52 N. J. Eq. 243 334, 349 Sands v. Potter, 59 111. App. 206. 244 v. Sands, 112 111. 225 259 liv CASES CITED. Sanford v. San ford. 62 N. Y. 553. 401 Sankevfl. Lilley, 1 Curt. Eccl. Rep. 391 326 Sapp v. Sapp, 71 Tex. 348 395 Sarbach v. Jones, 20 Kan. 499 811, 612, 613 Sasser v. Davis, 27 Tex. 656 399 Sawyers Sauer, 10 Kan. 466 779 v. State, 35 Ind. 70 173, 188, 189, 514 Saxon v. Wkittaker, 30 Ala. 237.. 478, 488 Say v. Barwick, 1 Ves. & B. 195.. 727 Sayer v. Bennett. 1 Cox, Ch. 107.. 379 Sayresw. Com. 88 Pa. 291 173, 175. 456, 466, 467, 506 Scarth v. Security Mut. L. Soc. 75 Iowa, '346 412 Schallerc. State, 14 Mo 502 683 Schapo v. Lehner, 54 Minn. 208 .. 273 Scheffer v. National L. Ins. Co. 25 Minn. 534 405 Schlencker v. State, 9 Neb. 241 ___ 558, 683, 686, 698 Schlidnecht v. Rompf, 9 Kv. L. Rep. 181...1 306 Schmidt «. Pfeil, 24 Wis. 452 784 Schneider v. Manning, 121 111. 376 252, 278, 283, 285, 297, 331, 359, 550. 586, 587 Schoellhamer v. Rometsch, 26 Or. 394 247 Schramm v. O'Connor, 98 111. 539- 720, 723 Schreiber's Case, 22 N. T. S. R. 892.. 735 Schuenke v. Pine River, 84 Wis. 669 776 Schuff v. Ransom, 79 Ind. 458 254 Schultz v. Ins. Co. 40 Ohio St. 217, 48 Am. Rep. 676 408, 412, 417, 455 Schwabe v. Clift, 2 Car. & K. 134, On appeal, 3 Man. G. & S. 437, 17 L. J. C. P. 2. 406 Schwilke's Appeal, 100 Pa. 628... 312 Scoland v. Scoland, 4 Wash. 118.. 395 Scott v. Com. 4 Met. (Ky.) 227, 83 Am. Dec. 461. .99, 175, 176 v. Paquitt, 17 Lower Can. Rep. 283 742 v. Scott, 29 L. J. Prob. N. S. 64 749 v. State, 12 Tex. App. 31.. 683, 687, 688, 706, 717 v. Wakem, 3 Fost. & F. 328, 444, 766 Scribner v. Crane, 2 Paige, 147, 21 Am. Dec. 81 321 Scruby v. Fordham, 1 Add. Eccl. Rep. 74 373, 374 Searle v. Galbraith, 73 111. 269 247 Sears®. Shafer, 1 Barb. 408.-271, 564 Sechrest v. Edwards, 4 Met. (Ky.) 163 277, 323, 604 Secor v. Secor, 1 McArth. 630 383 Seebrock v. Fedawa, 30 Neb. 424. 460 Seeley v. Price, 14 Mich. 541.. 731, 732 Seerley v. Sater, 68 Iowa, 376 243 Sefton v. Hopwood, 1 Fost. & F. 578 .289, 333 Selah v. Selah, 23 N. J. Eq. 185.. 741 Selby v. Jackson, 6 Beav. 192 265 v. Jackson, 13 L. J. Eq. N. S. 249 273 Selden v. Mvcrs, 61 U. S. 20 How. 506, 15 L. ed. 976 250 Sellars®. Sellars, 2 Heisk. 430 321, 504, 603 Sellick's Case.l City Hall Rec. 185. 465 Sentance v. Poole, 3 Car. & P. 1_. 247 Sergeson v. Seeley, 2 Atk. 412 429, 438, 531 Severin v. Zack, 55 Iowa, 28.567, 581 Sewall v. Robbins, 139 Mass. 164. 318, 603 Seymer v. Lake, 56 Wis. 651.. 770, 771 Seymour v. Delancey, 3 Cow. 445, 15 Am. Dec. 270.. .724, 728 Shackleton v. Sebree, 86 111. 616.. 730 Shader v. Railway Pass. Assur. Co. 5 Thomp. & C. 643 761, 763 Shailer v. Bumstead, 99 Mass. 112 309, 318, 494, 505, 526, 528 Shanlev's Appeal, 62 Conn. 325_. 492. 559, 568, 575 Shannahan v. Com. 8 Bush, 464, 8 Am. Rep. 465 99, 173, 668, 682, 685, 693, 695 Sharp v. Kansas City Cable R. Co. 114 Mo. 94.. 557, 577,596, 597 v. Merriman (Mich.) 2 Det. L. N. 890 597 Shaul's Case, 40 How. Pr. 205 419 Case, 40 How. Pr. 204.421, 427 Shaver v. McCarthy, 110 Pa. 339. 8, 204, 274, 286, 288, 290, 291, 309, 310, 559, 561, 574, 584 Shaw v. Dixon, 6 Bush, 644. .420, 423 v. State, 32 Tex. Crim. Rep. 155 184 v. Thackray, 23 Eng. L. & Eq. 18, 1 Smale & G. 537, 17 Jur. 1045. .723, 724 Shaw's Will, 2 Redf. 107 282, 295, 301, 302, 331, 343 Sheehan v. Kearney (Miss.) 21 So. 41, 35 L. R. A. 102.... 460,461,498, 561 CASES CITED. lv Sheldon v. Dow, 1 Dem. 503 227, 281, 317, 318 Shelley's Case 83 Shelton v. State, 34 Tex. 606 536 Sherar v. State, 30 Tex. App. 349. 716 Sherley v. Sherley, 81 Ky. 240 ... 307. 332, 349 Sherman's Petition, 17 R. I. 356. . 444,447, 590 Sherwood v. Sanderson, 19 Ves. Jr. 280. 421 Shirley v. Whitehead, 1 lred. Eq. 130 --- 378 Shirleys v. Taylor, 5 B. Mon. 99.. 437,557, 561 Shorb v. Brubaker, 94 Ind. 165... 359, 505 Shotwell's Estate, 1 Pa. Dist. R. 257 337 Shoulter v. Allen, 51 Mich. 529... 244 Shreiner ». Shreiner, 178 Pa. 57.. 296 Shropshire v. Reno, 5 J. J. Marsh. 91 339 Shropshire's Will, 5 J. J. Marsh. 15 289 Shuck v. Shuck, 7 Bush. 306 749 Shufflin v. People, 4 Hun, 16. .787, 790 Shults v. State, 37 Neb. 481 572,586, 588 Shultzfl. State, 13 Tex. 401 198 Shutt v. Shutt,71 Md. 193.743, 750, 751 Shuttlewirth's Case, 11 Jur. 41 . 446, 447 Siemon v. Wilson, 3 Edw. Ch. 36. 266 Sill v. McKnight, 7 Watts.& S. 245. 756 Silverthorn's Will, 68 Wis. 372... 372, 461, 462 Silvus v. State, 22 Ohio St. 90. .456, 466 Sim v. Russell, 90 Iowa, 656 330, 331, 516, 525 Simonton v. Bacon, 49 Miss. 582.. 243, 248, 249, 250 Sindram v. People. 88 N. Y. 196, 1 N. Y. Crim. Rep. 448. 128, 163, 169, 188, 510, 524 Singer v. Isbey, 1 Lane. L. Rev. 193 324, 326, 330 Singleton v. State, 71 Miss. 782... 183 Sinks v. Reese, 19 Ohio St. 306, 2 Am. Rep. 397.. 382 Sisson v. Conger, 1 Thomp. & C. 564 498,501, 796 Slais v. Slais, 9 Mo. App. 96 385, 388, 390 Slinger's Will, 72 Wis. 22.. ..433, 739 Sloan v. Maxwell, 3 N. J. Eq. 563 288, 459, 475, 562, 599 Smart v. Taylor, 9 Mod. 98 383 Smee v. Smee, 5 Prob. Div. 84, 28 Week. Rep. 703, 44 J. P. 220 297, 343, 461,479, 486 Smith v. Beatlv, 2 lred. Eq. 456, 40 Am. Dec. 435... 251, 258 v. Burnham, 1 Aik. (Vt.) 84. 424 v. Com. 1 Duv. 224 23, 174, 470, 474, 686, 697, 708 v. Elliott, 1 Patton & H. (Va.)307 729 v. Fenner, 1 Gall. 170 500 v. Hickenbottom, 57 Iowa, 733 420, 423, 426, 429, 518, 545, 567, 585 ». James, 72 Iowa, 515.. 311, 333 v. Knights of Father Math- ew, 36 Mo. App. 184 .. 761 v. Kramer, 5 Pa. L. J. 226.. 358 v. McClure, 146 Ind. 123... 453 v. Norfolk & S. R. Co. 114 N. C. 728, 25 L. R. A. 287.. 768, 774 v. Smith, 4 Baxt. 293 460 v. Smith, 75 Ga. 477.. 282 v. Smith, 157 Mass. 389.564, 584 v. Smith, 47 Miss. 211 382, 383, 389, 392 v. Smith, 108 N. C. 365 273 v. Smith, 33 N. J. Eq. 458. 395 v. Smith, 48 N. J. Eq. 566. 288, 289, 290, 295, 332, 451 v. Smith, 60 Wis. 329 252, 259, 362 v. State, 55 Ark. 259 127, 169, 175, 583 v. State, 4Neb. 277 472, 683, 694, 698, 781 v. State, 19 Tex. App. 95.. 125, 466, 467, 468 «. State, 19 Tex. App. 444. 135 v. State, 22 Tex. App. 316.. 125, 132, 162, 178, 450, 467, 483 v. State, 31 Tex. Crim. Rep. 14 467 v. Tebbitt, 36 L. J. Prob. N. S. 35, 15 L. T. N. S. 594 478, 479 v. Tebbitt, L. R. 1 Prob. & Div. 398, 16 L. T. N. S. 841. 157, 159, 293, 301, 316, 360, 361 v. Thomas, 1 Houst. Crim. Cas. 511 185 v. Waite, 4 Barb. 28 373, 374 v. Williamson, 8 Utah, 219. 722 Smith's Will, 52 Wis. 543, 38 Am. Rep. 756 303, 305 Smurr v. State. 88 Ind. 504... 682, 689 Sne'ling's Case, 44 N. Y. S. R. 477 350 Will, 136 N. Y. 515 286 Snook v. Watts, 11 Beav. 105.185, 439 Snow v. Benton, 28 111. 306 333, 358, 479, 489, 528 lvi CASES CITED. Snyder ». Cunningham, 13 Ky. L. Rep. 24... 595 v. Nations, 5 Blackf. 295... 608 v. Sherman, 23 Hun, 139. _. . 288, 289 v. Snyder, 142 111. 60 423 Soberanesw.Soberanes, 97Cal. 140. 377 Sombre v. Solarolii, 1 Deane & S. 110 242 v. Troup, 1 Deane & S. 22 __ 330 Somers v. Pumphrey, 24 Ind. 231. 244, 251, 252, 269, 454 Somes v. Skinner, 16 Mass. 348.. . 248 Soule Case, 22 Abb. N. C. 236... 276,288, 327 Case, 1 Connoly, 18 342 Southcombe v. Merriman, Car. & M. 286 759 Southern Tier Masonic Rel. Asso. v. Laudenbach, 5 N. Y. Supp. 901.243, 431, 432, 438 Southwestern R. Co. v. Hanker- son, 61 Ga. 114 774 Spann v. State, 47 Ga. 549 93, 200 v. State, 47 Ga. 553.. ..126, 130 Sparks v. Knights Templars' & Masons' L. Indemnity Co.l Mo.App.Rep. 334. 412 SDear v. Sweeney, 88 Wis. 545 523 Speck v. Philips, 5 Mees. & W.279. 728 Speedling v. Worth Co. 68 Iowa, 152 445, 1068 Speer v. Sewell, 4 Bush, 239 265 Spellier's Estate, 2 Pa. Dist. R.513. 354 Spence «. Spence, 4 Watts, 165 603 v. State, 15 Lea, 539 711 Spencer v. Moore, 4 Call. (Va.) 275, 349, 423 604 v. State, 69 Md. 28.134, 171, 490 Spencer's Estate, 96 Cal. 448 304, 344, 359 Spiers v. Higgons, Cited in 1 Madd. 304 723 Spittle v. Walton, L. R. 11 Eq. 420 607, 610, 611 Sponable «. Hanson, 87 Mich. 204 262, 440 Spoonemore v. Cables, 66 Mo. 579 310, 502 Spraguea. Duel, 11 Paige, 480.251, 261 v. Duel, Clarke, Ch. 90 258 Spratt «. Spratt, 76 Mich. 384. .291, 324, 325, 333, 345, 520, 521 Springfield v. State, 96 Ala. 81... 702 Springstead's Case, 55 Hun, 603, 28 N. Y. S. R. 186 333 Stackhouse v. Horton, 15 N. J. Eq. 202 294, 299, 308, 591, 593, 598 Stacy v. Portland Pub. Co. 68 Me. 279 792 Stancell v. Kenan, 33 Ga. 56.-288, 289 Standard Life & Acci. Ins. Co. v. Jones, 94 Ala. 434 761 Stannard v. Burns, 63 Vt. 244 430 Stanton v. Wetherwax, 16 Barb. 259... 9, 282, 295, 296 Staples v. Wellington, 58 Me. 453. 8, 483, 486 Starnes v. Marten, 1 Curt. Eccl. Rep. 294 322 Starrett v. Douglass, 2 Yeates, 46. 337, 734 Staser v. Hogan, 120 Ind. 207.492, 520, 529, 530, 562, 567, 577 State v. Abrams, 11 Or. 169.. 561, 718 v. Alexander, 30 S. C. 74, 14 Am. St. Rep. 879. .. 126, 132, 172, 466 v. Archer, 54 N. H. 465 564 v. Arnold, 12 Iowa, 479 194, 195, 196, 197 v. Ashlev, 45 La. Ann. 1036 695, 709 v. Atherton, 50 Iowa, 189, 32 Am. Rep. 134 201 v. Avery, 44 N. H. 392.689, 701 %. Baber, 74 Mo. 292, 41 Am. Rep. 314 544 v. Barber, 92 N. C. 820.... 695 t Bartlett, 43 N. H. 224, 80 Am. Dec. 154 162, 173, 458, 467, 469, 472 v. Bell, 29 Iowa, 316 682, 690, 692 v. Bell, 136 Mo. 120 456 v. Bowen, Houst.Crim.Rep. (Del.) 91 699, 705, 780 v. Brandon, 8 Jones, L. 463 133, 171 v. Brinyea, 5 Ala. 241 ...93, 184, 199, 200, 465, 471 v. Brooks, 4 Wash. 328.... 514, 574, 575, 561 v. Brown, 1 Houst. Crim. Cas. 539 173, 477 v. Brown, 12 Minn 538 456 v. Brown (Del.) 36 Atl. 458. 607, 611 v. Bruce, 48 Iowa, 530, 30 Am. Rep. 403 466 v. Bryant, 93 Mo. 273 515, 558, 569 v. Buckley, 72 N. C. 358... 718 v. Bullock, 13 Ala. 413.682, 685 v. Bundy, 24 S. C. 439, 58 Am. Rep. 262 125. 134, 172, 466, 683, 685 v. Carter, 98 Mo. 176 683 v. Castello, 62 Iowa, 404... 796 v. Christmas, 6 Jones, L. 471 527 CASES CITED. lvii State v. Clements, 47 La. Ann. 1088 455, 465 v. Coleman, 27 La. Ann. 691 162, 171, 449, 561, 565, 682. 684, 709 v. Coleman, 20 S. C. 441.... 183, 456, 470, 472,473, 554, 605, 606 q Coleman, 31 Ga. 424 541 v. Crawford, 11 Kan. 32. .. 457, 458, 471, 472, 473 v. Crisp, 126 Mo. 605 539. 546, 561, 569 v. Cross, 27 Mo. 332 683, 691, 695 v. Cross, 42 W. Va. 253.686, 781 v. Crow, 10 West. L. J. 501. 201 v. Cunningham, 72 N. C. 469 191, 528 v, Danbv, 1 Houst. Crim. Rep. 166.... 131, 165. 455, 456, 466 v. Davis, 109 N. C. 780, 14 L. R. A. 206 467 v. Davis, 27 S. C. 609 487 v. Davis, 9 Houst. Del.) 407 682, 685, 698, 699, 700, 710, 711 v. Dearing, 65 Mo. 530.. 683, 700 v. De Ranee, 34 La. Ann. 186, 44 Am. Rep. 426.. 456. 465 ©. De Wolf, 8 Conn. 93, 20 Am. Dec. 90 608 ». Dillahunt, 3 Harr. (Del.) 551 682. 710, 711 v. Donovan, 61 Iowa, 278.. 691 v. Donovan, 61 Iowa, 369 682, 687, 688, 706, 707 v. Douglass, 28 W. Va. 297. 467, 470 v. Draper, 1 Houst. Crim. Rep. 291 449, 450 v. Dreher (Mo.) 38 S. W. 567 180, 185 v. Duestrow, 137 Mo. 44, 38 S. W. 564.... 456, 465, 467, 785 v. Edwards, 71 Mo. 321.683, 691 v. Enrigbt,90 Iowa, 520.201, 203 v. Erb, 74 Mo. 199 125, 131, 132, 172, 558, 713 v. Felter, 25 Iowa, 67.. 99, 125, 127, 149, 174, 175, 489, 527, 537, 586, 589 v. Felter, 32 Iowa, 49 457, 458, 466, 469 v. Feltes, 51 Iowa, 495.792, 795 v. Fiske, 63 Conn. 388.. 704, 781 e Gardiner, Wright (Ohio) 392 ..125, 470 State v. Garvey, 11 Minn. 154 561, 683. 688, 706 v. Geddis, 42 Iowa, 268 126. 451, 453, 466, 475, 570 v. Gould, 40 Kan. 258 539, 542 v. Graviotte, 22 La. Ann. 587 189 v. Grear, 28 Minn. 426, 41 Am. Rep. 296 673, 791 v. Grear, 29 Minn. 221 469, 685, 704, 777, 780 v. Greer, 22 W. Va. 800.... 702 v. Gut, 13 Minn. 343... 132, 134, 169, 465, 467, 529, 697 v. Hanley, 34 Minn. 430 467 v. Hanson, 25 Or. 391.. 174, 465, 474, 502, 573, 695, 697 v. Harlow. 21 Mo. 446.. 683, 691 ». Harrigan, 9 Houst. (Del.) 369 ...449, 455, 466, 489, 682, 709, 713 v. Harris, 8 Jones, L. 136.. 193 197 v. Harrison, 36 W. Va. 729^ 18 L. R. A. 224.... 165, 166, 172, 194 v. Hart, 29 Iowa, 268 682,691,714, 788 v. Hartley, 22 Nev. 342, 28 L. R. A. 33 450 v. Hayden, 51 Vt. 296 539, 540, 558, 570, 600 v. Hayes, 16 Mo. App. 560. 131, 189, 1066 v. Hays, 22 La. Ann. 39 162, 490, 498, 509 v. Haywood, 1 Phill. L. 376 131, 134 v. Hill, 46 La. Ann. 27.777, 780 v. Hockett, 70 Iowa, 442... 125, 126, 191, 466, 469, 524, 592 v. Holloway, 8 Blackf. 45.. 608 v. Holme, 54 Mo. 153. 178 v. Home, 9 Kan. 119 682, 718 v. Hoyt, 46 Conn. 330. 47 Conn. 518, 36 Am. Rep. 89. 455, 466, 513, 527, 528, 605 v. Hundley, 46 Mo. 414 173, 178, 450, 456, 465, 466, 467, 468, 469, 595, 683, 709 v. Hurley, Houst.Crim.Rep. (Del.) 28 682, 694, 710, 780, 784 v. Hurst (Idaho) 39 Pac. 554. 570 v. Huting, 21 Mo. 464 166, 467, 470 Ivm CASES CITED. State v. Huxford, 47 Iowa, 16. .. 765, 792 v. Hyde, 29 Conn 564. .434. 531 v John, 8 Ired. L. 330, 49 Am. Dec. 396 502, 683 v. Johnson, 40 Conn. 136,41 Conn. 584 23, 174, 472, 477, 479, 682, 693, 694. 695, 698, 701, 702 v. Johnson, 91 Mo. 439 456, 465, 470 v. Jones, 64 Iowa, 356 455, 458, 466, 469, 489, 599 1). Jones, 50 N. H. 369, 9 Am. Rep. 242 25, 125, 126, 135, 136, 169, 173, 174, 179 «. Kalb, 2 Ohio Leg. News, 364 131,174, 191, 450, 590, 597 D. Kelley, 57 N. H. 549. ... 489, 490, 608 v. Klinger, 43 Mo. 127 135, 178, 450, 456, 465, 466 v. Klinger, 46 Mo. 224 540, 557, 558, 561, 571, 586 ■c. Kluseman, 53 Minn. 541 181, 499 -». Kotovsky, 74 Mo. 247... 131, 172, 173 •o. Kotovsky, 11 Mo. Aop. 584 1__ 163 v. Kring, 64 Mo. 591 506 «. Lawrence, 57 Me. 574 134, 166. 169, 450. 456, 466 v. Leuth, 5 Ohio C. C. 94- . 456, 1065 «. Levelle, 34 S. C. 120.... 172 ». Lewis, 20Nev. 333 131, 132, 167, 456, 465, 466, 468, 490 v. Lewis, 136 Mo. 84 456 v. Lowe, 93 Mo. 547 478, 480, 683, 687 v. McCants, 1 Speers, L. C. 389.. 683, 685 v. McCoy, 34 Mo. 536, 86 Am. Dec. 121.450, 456, 466 v. McDaniel, 115 N. C. 807 697. 699, 701 v. McGonigal, 5 Harr. (Del.) 510 682,710, 713 v. Mcintosh, 39 S. C. 97... 131, 132, 456, 466, 469, 470, 472 v. McNinch, 12 S. C. 89.... 797 v. Mahn, 25 Kan. 182-473, 805 v. Maier, 36 W. Va. 757 125, 181, 541. 558, 568 v. Marler, 2 Ala. 43, 36 Am. Dec. 398.. 465, 471 State v. Martin (N. J.) 3 Crim. L. Mag. 44 131, 135, 450, 456, 466. 467, 49C v. Martin, 4 N. J. L. 252, 3 Crim. L. Mag. 44 683, 684. 686, 694, 695, 710 v. Maxwell, 42 Iowa, 208— 682, 688 v. Merrick, 19 Me. 398 470 V. Mewherter, 46 Iowa, 88 125, 168, 169, 174, 175, 176, 599 v. Meyers, 46 Neb. 152 608 v. Miller, 111 Mo. 542 171 v. Morgan, 40 S. C. 345.683, 685 v. Morphv, 33 Iowa, 270, 11 Am. Rep. 122 458, 470 v. Mowry, 37 Kan. 369 131, 132, 172, 682, 687, 698 v. Mullen, 14 La. Ann. 577. 682 v. Murphy, 118 Mo. 7 683, 691, 706, 707 v. Murray, 11 Or. 413.. ... 125, 126, 131, 168, 465, 561. 563, 572, 578, 788 v. Newman, 7 Ala. 69 465 v. Nixon, 32 Kan. 205 165, 172, 471, 472 e. Norwood, 115 N. C. 791. 456 v. O'Connor, 11 Nev. 416.. 704 v. O'Grady, 3 Ohio Leg. News. 137 -...195, 196, 197, 198, 456, 457, 466 v. O'Neil, 51 Kan. 651, 24 L. R. A. 555 .133, 134, 172, 186, 682, 689, 698, 710, 713 v. O'Reilly, 126 Mo. 597.683, 691 V. Pagels, 92 Mo. 300... 125, 132, 165, 172, 173, 456, 467, 469, 503, 544 v. Patten, 10 La. Ann. 299, 63 Am. Dec. 594 92 v. Patterson, 45 Vt. 308, 12 Am. Rep. 200 472 v. Paulk, 18 S. C. 514..466, 683 «. Payne, 86 N. C. B09. ... 134, 456, 467, 468 v. Peacock, 50 N. J. L. 34.. 196, 510 v. Pennyman, 68 Iowa. 216. 561 9. Pike, 49 N. H. 399, 6 Am. Rep. 533... 24, 89, 160, 162, 167, 173, 178, 564, 715, 792 v. Pitts, 58 Mo. 556 683 v. Porter, 34 Iowa, 131..503, 583 v. Potts, 100 N. C. 457 134, 170, 171, 465, 467, 488, 537, 540, 558, 569, 683, 685. 710, 711, 780 CASES CITED. lix State v. Pratt, 1 Houst. Crim. Rep. 249 131, 162, 165, 455, 466 v. Pratt, 34 Vt. 323 ....764, 765 v. Pritchett, 106 N. C. 667, 200, 490, 513 v. Ramsey, 82 Mo. 133. .683, 691 v. Reddick, 7 Kan. 143 135, 472, 477, 479, 480, 547, 555, 779 •o. Redemeier, 71 Mo. 173, 36 Am. Rep. 462 129, 131, 133. 450, 456, 467 v. Redemeier, 8 Mo. App. 1. 134 v. Reidell, 9 Houst. (Del.) 470 131, 167, 173. 449, 455, 470, 471, 593 v. Richards, 39 Conn. 591 .. 128 131 v. Riley, 100 Mo. 493...."..' 189, 683, 686, 710, 71b, 714 v. Rippy, 104 K C. 752.712, 805 v. Robinson, 20 W. Va. 713, 43 Am. Rep. 799 465, 467, 683, 685, 698, 701, 708. 709, 710 v. Ryan, 1 Jarman, Wills, 122, note 558, 583 v. Schaefer, 116 Mo. 96 183, 456, 467, 478. 479, 480 v. Schingea, 20 Wis. 75 691 v. Scoit, 4J La. Ann. 253, 36 L. R. A. 721 180, 450, 456, 467. 469 «. Scott, 1 Hawks (N. C.) 24 502, 616 D. Scott, 41 Minn. 365 171, 543, 554 v. Sewell, 3 Jones, L. 245.. 488. 780 1). Shippey, 10 Minn. 223, 88 Am. Dec. 70.. 127, 134, 188 v. Shoultz, 25 Mo. 128 127 v. Simms, 68 Mo. 305 180, 191, 527 v. Simms, 71 Mo. 538 169, 177, 854 v. Smith, 49 Conn. 376 693, 695, 702, 794 w.Smith, 53 Mo.267. 456, 467, 468 v. Sneed, 88 Mo. 138... 683, 691 v. Sopher, 70 Iowa, 494.700, 708 v. Spencer, 21 N. J. L. 196 131, 150, 205, 465, 467, 478, 479, 503 «. Stark, 1 Strobh. L. 479 178, 183, 467, 495. 683 v. Starling, 6 Jones, L. 366 450, 456, 467, 469 v. Stickley, 41 Iowa, 232... 126, 127, 175, 558, 571 State v. Strauder, 11 W. Va. 745, 27 Am. Rep 606 467, 469, 470 v. Swift, 49 Conn. 376 126 v. Swift, 57 Conn. 496 126, 133, 520, 795 ». Tarr, 28 Io=?a, 397...201, 202 v. Tatro, 50 Vt. 483 499, 683, 697 v. Thomas, Houst. Crim. Rep. (Del.) 511. ...131, 450, 455, 470, 682, 780 v. Thompson, 12Nev. 140.. 683, 686 v. Thompson, 28 Or. 296... 432 v. Thompson, 1 Wright (Ohio) 617 470,683, 686, 687 v. Till, Houst. Crim. Rep. (Del.) 233 682, 686 •o. Tilly, 3 Ired. L. 424 501 v. Toohy, 2 Rice, Dig. (S.C.) 105, 683 v. Towe, 93 Mo. 547 780 v. Townsend, 66 Iowa, 741 596, 1069 i). Trivas, 32 La. Ann. 1086, 36 Am. Rep. 293... 688, 689 v. Trout, 74 Iowa, 545.466, 469 v. Turlington, 102 Mo. 642. 131 v. Turner, Wright (Ohio) 26 532, 683 v. Underwood, 6 Ired. L. 96 796 v. Vann, 82 N. C. 631.. 467, 501 v. Vann, 84 N. C. 722... 93, 200 v. Waterman, 1 Nev. 543. .. 472 v. Welch, 21 Minn. 22 693 v. Wells, 54 Kan. 161 686 v. Welsor, 117 Mo. 570...:. 503, 510, 539 v. West, Houst. Crim. Rep. (Del.) 371 .134, 173, 174. 465, 510, 605 v. White, 14 Kan. 538 682, 688, 689, 690, 695, 706 v. White, 10 Wash. 611.... 807 v. Williamson, 106 Mo. 162 171, 466, 468, 574 v. Wilner, 40 Wis. 304 8, 478, 484 v. Wilson, 104 N. C. 868... 683, 695 v. Winsor, 5 Harr. (Del.) 512 169, 173, 174, 527, 530, 539 v. Winter, 72 Iowa, 627 558 v. Wright, 134 Mo. 404, 35 S. W. 1145. ..132, 180, 449. 465, 467, 542 v. Yarborough,39 Kan. 581. 171 v. Zorn, 22 Or. 591.131, 134, 698 lx CASES CITED. State Bank 0. McCoy, 69 Pa. 204, 8 Am. Rep. 246 722 Stauffera. Young, 39 Pa. 455 532 Stebbins v. Hart, 4Dem. 501.. 316, 346 Stedham 0. Stedham, 32 Ala. 525. 274, 805 Steed v. Colley, 1 Keen, 620.. 316, 475 Stephen 0. State, 11 Ga. 225 201 Stephenson v. Stephenson, 62 Iowa, 163 459, 602 Sternberg v. Schoolcraft, 2 Barb. 153 401 Stevens v. State (1870) 9 Am. L. Reg. N. S. 530 149 e. State, 31Ind. 485, 99 Am. Dec. 634.... 25, 99, 165, 168, 173, 174, 472, 473 «. Stevens, 127 Ind. 560 430, 440, 476 0. Vancleve, Den, ex. dem. 4 Wash. C. C. 262 284, 289, 292, 309, 320, 323, 462, 479, 481, 492, 493, 501 Stevenson v. Stevenson, 33 Pa. 469 288, 290 Steward 0. Lispenard, 26 Wend. 255..: 279, 280, 284, 337, 433 Stewart 0. Curtis, 85 Mich. 496... 265 0. Elliott, 2 Mackey, 307... 283 0. Flint, 59 Vt. 144.. ..255, 483 0. Kirkbride.Com. 2Brewst. 419 192,444, 534 0. Lispenard, 26 Wend. 256. 881 0. Redditt, 3 Md. 67 484, 499, 557, 573, 574 0. Spedden, 5 Md. 423 558, 582, 584 0. State, 58 Ga. 577 528 Stewart's Will, 39 N. Y. S. R. 801. 341 Stigers 0. Brent, 50 Md. 214, 33 Am. Rep. 317 401 Stirling®. Stirling, 64 Md. 138. _. 603 Stokes 0. Miller, 10 W. N. C. 241 314, 368, 561, 574, 584 0. ShipDen, 13 Bush, 180... 328, 497, 522 Stone 0. Damon, 12 Mass. 487 432 0. Wilbern, 83 111. 105.. 251, 252 Storer's Case, 28 Minn. 9.332, 540, 551 Storey's Will. 20 111. App. 183... . 277, 284, 29y, 305, 323, 361 Storick's Case, 64 Mich. 685 420, 424, 425 StormOut 0. Waterloo Life & Cas. Assur. Co. 1 Fost. & F. 22 406, 418, 455 Storrs0. Scougale, 48 Mich. 587.. 248 Stoutenburgh v. Hopkins, 43 N. J. Eq. 577... 276, 288, 289, 353 Stover 0. Com. 92 Va. 780.. 200 Strand 0. Chicago & W. M. R. Co. 67 Mich. 380 769 Strang 0. People, 24 Mich. 1 797 Stratford v. Stratford, 92 N. C. 297 393, 396, 397 Stratton 0. Morris, 89 Tenn. 497, 12 L. R. A. 70 275 Streeter 0. Western Union Mut. L. & A. Soc. 65 Mich. 199 411, 412, 416 Stuart 0. Machias Port, 48 Me. 477 770, 771, 775 0. State, 1 Baxt. 178 130, 131, 134, 472, 710, 711 Stubbs 0. Houston. 33 Ala. 555... 280, 285, 286, 459, 495, 511, 521, 562, 570, 576 Stuckey 0. Bellah, 41 Ala. 700 570 0. Mathes, 24 Hun, 461 383 0. State, 91 Ind. 141 570 Studstill 0. State, 7 Ga. 2 126, 127 Stuyvesant B.Wilcox, 92 Mich. 228 326 Sullivan 0. Flynn, 9 Mackey, 396. 437 Summers 0. Copeland, 125 Ind. 466 495, 496 Suppinger 0. Covenant Mut. Ben. Asso. 20 111. App. 595.. 409 Supreme Commandery K. of G. R. 0. Ainsworth, 71 Ala. 436, 46 Am. Rep. 332. . 410, 415 Surber 0. State, 99 Ind. 71 682 Sutherland 0. Hankins, 56 Ind. 343 558, 573, 574 0. Standard L. & Acci. Ins. Co. 87 Iowa, 505 762 I, Sutton 0. Morgan, 30 N. J. Eq. 629 598 0. Reagan, Doe, 5 Blackf. 217, 33 Am. Dec. 466.. 561 0. Sadler, 3 C. B. N. S. 87, 3 Jur. N. S. 1150..452, 461, 462, 476, 499, 501 0. Sutton, 5 Harr. (Del.) 459 286, 287, 308, 520, 521, 525 Swails0. White, 149 Pa. 261 492, 559, 569 Swan 0. State, 4 Humph. 136 683, 688, 698 Swayze 0. Swayze, 37 N. J. Eq. 180 453 Swenarton v. Hancock, 9 Abb, N. C. 326 288, 321 Swick 0. Home Ins. Co. 2 Dill. 160 760, 762 Symes 0. Green, 5 Jur. N. S. 742 (1859) 1 Swab. & T. 401 227, 327, 330, 362, 372, 463, 479 Symm 0. Fraser, 3 Fost. & F. 859. 766- CASES CITED. lxi T. Tacke's Case, 17 N. Y. S. R. 805.. 735 Taffe v. State, 23 Ark. 34 196 Taft®. Hosmer, 14 Mich. 309 463 Talbot v. Chamberlain, 149 Mass. 57, 3L. R. A. 254 397 Tallman's Will, 1 Pa. Adv. R. 530. 314 Tally v. Smith, 1 Coldw. 290 247,248. 249 Tatham v. Wright, 2 Russ. & M. 1 559 Tawney v. Long, 76 Pa. 106 277,288, 296 Taylor v. Atwood, 47 Conn. 498.. 248 v. Com. 109 Pa. 262.... 125, 175, 176, 558, 600 v. Creswell, 45 Md. 422 459, 462, 481, 485 v. Kelly, 31 Ala. 59, 68 Am. Dec. 150 277, 288, 350 v. Patrick, 1 Bibb. 168. .245. 720 v. Pureed, 60 Ark. 606.720, 722 v. Trich, 165 Pa. 586 292, 295, 296, 304, 305, 581, 584 v. United States, 7 App. D. C. 27.. 569, 572, 579, 1058, 1065 v. United States, 23 Wash. L. Rep. 433 188 Taylor's Case, 92 Cal. 564.... 584, 587 Estate, 16 Phila. 274... 312, 452 Will, 1 Edm. Sel. Cas. 375.. 433 Telgarden v. Lewis, 145 Ind. 98.. 459 Temple v. Temple, 1 Hen. & M. 476 324, 327, 733, 736, 737, 777, 778, 807 Tenbrook v. Lee, 5 Clark (Pa.) 37.. 276 ^88 Terrill . Meyers, 1 Hagg. Consist. Rep. 414 382, 383, 389 v. Rusk, 53 Md. 65 296, 305, 310, 481, 482, 484, 520 v. Turner, 1 Litt. 102 452 v. Union National Bank, 10 Utah, 77 250 v. Utah Title Ins. & T. Co. 10 Utah, 61 250 Tyra v. Com. 2 Met. (Ky.) 1..682, 703 Tyson v. Tyson, 37 Md. 567 283, 459, 462 U. Ulmer's Appeal (Pa.) 11 Cent. 403 314, 322 Underbill's Case, 21 Ohio L. J. 279 807 Union C. L. Ins. Co. v. Hollowell, 14Ind. App. 611 412 Union Mut. L. Ins. Co. v. Reif, 36 Ohio St. 596, 38 Am. Rep. 613 758, 759 United Brethren Mut. Aid. Soc. v. O'Hara, 120 Pa. 256... 759, 786, 793 United States v. Bowen, 4 Cranch, C. C. 604.. 684, 704 v. Clarke, 2 Cranch, C. C. 158 709, 713 v. Claypool, 14 Fed. Rep. 127 666, 684, 687 v. Cornell, 2 Mason, 91 126, 127, 684, 687 v. Drew. 5 Mason, 28, W. & S. Med. Jur. 203 665, 668, 669, 709 v. Faulkner, 35 Fed. Rep. 730 126, 128, 131, 172, 472, 473, 552 v. Forbes, Crabbs, 558 (1845) 666, 684, 687, 710 v. Guiteau, 10 Fed. Rep. 161. 450 v. Guiteau, 1 Mackey, 498, 47 Am. Rep. 247 176, 512, 550, 551, 567, 583 v. Haskell, 4 Wash. C. C. 402 616 «. Hewson, 7 Law Rep. 361. 173 v. Holmes, 1 Cliff. 98.. 166, 172, 498, 509, 512, 558, 600 v. King, 34 Fed. Rep. 360_. 167, 179, 694, 702 v. Lancaster, 7 Biss. 440 ... 199, 456, 457, 472 CASES CITED. lxiii United States v. Lawrence (1835) 4 Cranch, C. C. 514.117, 456 v. Lee, 4 Mackey, 489, 54 Am. Rep. 293 163, 183 v. McGlue, 1 Curt. C. C. 1, 2 Lawson Crim. Def. 54. ...131, 450,467, 469, 541, 665, 670, 684, 710, 713, 776 v. Meagher, 37 Fed. Rep. 875 -.688, 694, 695 v. RidL'eway, 31 Fed. Rep. 144 ..165, 169, 187 v. Roudeubush, Baldw. 514 684, 686 v. Sharp, 1 Pet. C. C. 118.. 507 v. Shults, 6 McLean, 122- . 130, 185, 186 v. Young, 25 Fed. Rep. 710 128, 134, 172, 187 Unity v. Belgrade, 76 Me. 419... . 382 Upstone v. People, 109 111. 169... 474, 558, 682, 685, 686, 689, 709, 715, 787 V. "Van Alst v. Hunter, 5 Johns. Ch. 148_ .228, 275. 277, 349, 907 Vanauken's Case, 10 N. J. Eq. 186 427 Van Auken's Case, 10 N. J. Eq. 192 422 Vance v. Com. 2 Va. Cas. 132.... 490 v. Upson, 66 Tex. 476 284, 295, 296, 309, 327, 328, 340, 461, 476, 478, 481, 482, 495, 506, 516, 522, 540, 543, 584, 588 v. Vance, 74 I nd. 370 530 Van Deusenw. Newcomer, 40 Mich. 90. .-443, 444, 509, 543, 552 v. Rowley, 8 N. Y. 358.... 375 v. Sweet, 51 N. Y. 378 253, 435, 438 Vane v. Vane, L. R. 2 Ch. Div. 124 419 Van Guysling v. Van Kuren, 35 N. Y. 70 291 Van Horn v. Keenan, 28 111. 445.. 251, 732 Van Huss v. Rainbolt, 2 Coldw. 139 561, 601 Vann v. State, 83 Ga. 44 682, 690 Van Pelt «. Van Pelt, 30 Barb. 134 331, 333, 454 Vanvalkenburg c.Vanvalkenburg, 90Ind. 434 594 Van Valkenburgh ». American Popular L. Ins. Co. 9 Hun, 583 758, 778 Van Wyck v. Brasher, 81 N. Y. 260 729 Van Zandt v. Mutual Ben. L. Ins. Co. 55 N. Y. 169, 14 Am. Rep. 215 407, 409, 411, 554 Veeder's Case, 6 Dem. 92 296, 360 Violet's Will, 1 Bibb, 617.324, 733, 735 Von Zastrow Case, 1 Casper & Liman, Med. Juris. 509. 44 W. Wachholz v. Wachholz, 75 Wis. 377 75$ Waddell v.W added, 2 Swab. & T. 584 75$ Waddington v. Busby, 45 N. J. Eq. 173... -.276, 288 Wade v. Colvert, 2 Mill. Const. 27, 12 Am. Dec. 652.-719, 730 v. Holbrook, 2 Redf. 378. - 276, 288, 289 v. State, Nix, 37 Ind. 180.. 478, 480 Wadsworth v. Sharpsteen, 8 N. Y. 388, 59 Am. Dec. 499. . 431, 432, 767 v. Sherman, 14 Barb. 169. . 431, 766, 767 Wagener v. Harriott, 20 Abb. N. C. 283 273 Wager v. Reid, 3 Thomp. & C.332. 731 Wagner v. People, 2 Keves, 684.. 129, 472 Walcott v. Allyn, Milw. Eccl. Rep. 65. -- 303 Walker v. Clav, 21 Ala. 797.. 401, 491 v. Jones", 23 Ala. 448 506. v. People, 1 N. Y. Crim. Rep. 7, 22, 26 Hun, 67, Affirmed in 88 N. Y. 81. 23, 131, 134, 172, 450, 456, 472 v. People, 88 N. Y. 86, Af- firming 1 N. Y. Crim. Rep. 7. -.125, 129, 171, 474 v. State, 102 Ind. 502 9, 166, 173, 528, 530 v. State, 46 Neb. 25 195 v. State, 85 Ala. 7 682, 704 v. State, 91 Ala. 76 696 v. State, 97 Ala. 85.... 607, 612 v. Walker, 14 Ga. 242 559 v. Walker, 34 Ala. 469 587 Wall y. Hill, 1 B. Mon. 290, 36 Am. Dec. 578 261, 430, 431, 434, 435, 438, 440 Wallace v. Manhattan Co. 2 Hall (N. Y.)495 381 lxiv CASES CITED Wallis v. Hodgeson, 2 Atk. 56 461 v. Luhring, 134 Ind. 447... 449, 477, 503 Walsh v. Consumnes Tribe, No. 14, I. O. R. M. 108 Cal. 496 414 v. People, 88 N. Y. 458-527, 1066 Walter v. People, 32 N. Y. 147— 450, 456, 473 Walther's Will, 7N. Y. Supp. 417. 334 Walton v. Northington, 5 Sneed, 282... 258, 271 v. Walton, 34 Kan. 195 744, 745, 747, 748, 764 Ward v. Chicago, St. P. M. & O. R. Co. 85 Wis. 601.... 770 v. Dulaney, 23 Miss. 410... 382, 384, 388 v. State, 19 Tex. Aop. 664. . 482, 683, "709, 712, 717 Ware v. Ware, 8 Me. 42 309, 505, 508, 529, 562, 565 Waring v. Waring, 12 Jur. 947, 6 Moore, P. C. 341 ....9, 157, 233, 293, 295, 486 Warlick v. Plonk, 103 N. C. 81... 398, 399 Warner v. New York C. R. Co. 44 N. Y. 465 786 v. State, 114 Ind. 137. 125, 166, 561 v. State, 56 N. J. L. 686.... 697 Warnock v. Campbell, 25 N. J. Eq. 485 ....731, 740 Warren v. Com. 37 Pa. 45 503, 782 v. State, 9 Tex. App. 619, 35 Am. Rep. 745 131, 489 Wartemberg v. Spiegel, 31 Mich. 402 259 Wartena v. State, 105 Ind. 445... 126 Waskam v. Waskam, 31 Miss. 154 _ 752 Waterman v. Whitney, 11 N. Y. 157, 62 Am. Dec. 71— 498, 500, 501, 502 Waters v. Barral, 2 Bush. 598 270 v. Connecticut Mut. L. Ins. Co. 2 Fed. Rep. 892 _. 7, 408, 409 ®. Cullen, 2Bradf. 354 737 v. Howlett, 3 Hagg. Eccl. Rep. 790 952 v. Taylor, 2 Ves. & B. 299.. 379 v. Waters, 35 Md. 531 464, 508, 519, 529, 557, 561, 573, 582, 584 Watson v. Anderson, 11 Ala. 43.. 263, 511, 512, 578 v. Anderson, 13 Ala. 202... 593 n. Donnelly, 28 Barb. 653. . 288, 331, 353 *. Smith, 7 Or. 448 258 Watson v. Watson, 2B. Mon. 374. 325 Watson's Case, 34 N. Y. S. R. 906. 733 Interdiction, 31 La. Ann. 757 422,428, 590 Watt v. Bookover, 35 W. Va. 323. 401 Watt's Case, 1 Curt. Eccl. Rep. 594.. 440 Watts v. Bullock, 1 Litt. (Ky.)252 277, 350 Wax's Estate, 106 Cal. 343.509, 531, 573 Waymire v. Jetmore, 22 Ohio St. 271 382 Webb v. State, 9 Tex. App. 490.. 467, 470, 540, 542, 544, 545 v. State, 5 Tex. App. 596... 135, 450, 467, 478, 479, 483, 558 Webber v. Com. 119 Pa. 223 490 v. Sullivan, 58 Iowa, 260... 274, 286, 290 Weed v. Mutual Ben. L. Ins. Co. 3 J. &S. 386 415 v. Mutual Ben. L. Ins. Co. 70 N. Y. 561 407, 416 Weeks v. New Orleans & C. R. Co. 32 La. Ann. 615.. 769 Weems v. Weems, 19 Md. 334 292, 562, 567, 569 Weil's Case, 16 N. Y. S. R. 1 336 Weir v. Fitzgerald, 2 Bradf. 42... 365, 454 Weir's Will, 9 Dana, 434.304,324, 326, 328, 329, 336, 371, 508 Weisman's Estate, 45 Phila. Leg. Int. 274 733 Welch v. Ware, 32 Mich. 77 127 Weldw. Sweeney, 85 III. 50. .321, 604 Wellman's Case, 3 Kan. Ap,». 100. 444 Welty v. Indianapolis & V R. Co. 105 Ind. 55 768 Wendell's Case, 1 Johns. Ch. 600. 419, 429 Wenz v. State, 1 Tex. App. 36 688, 689, 691 Werstler v. Custer, 46 Pa. 502.460, 451 Wertz v. Wertz, 43 Iowa, 534.391, 394 Wesley v. State, 37 Miss. 327, 75 Am. Dec. 62 169 Westcott v. Sheppard, 51 N. J. Eq. 315 277, 288, 289, 290 Westmore v. Sheffield, 56 Vt. 239 397 558 Westmoreland v. State, 45 Ga. 225. 470 Weston v. Higgins, 40 Me. 102... 478. 482, 484 Wetherbee v. Wetherbee, 38 Vt. 454 540, 553 Wetmore's Case, 6 Wash. 271 764 Wetter v. Habersham, 60 Ga. 194 294, 463 Weynine v. Wolfe, 52 Iowa, 533.. 772 CASES CITED. lxv Wheeler v. Alderson, 3Ha_._r. Eccl. Rep. 574.-241,242,282, 317, 318, G84, 734, 736. 779 v. State, 34 Ohio St. 394, 32 Am. Rep. 372.273, 531, 532 v. Wheeler, 53 Iowa, 511, 36 Am. Rep. 240.. 753 Wheeler's Case, 5 Misc. 279 288, 289, 452 Will, 56 N. Y. S. R. 709.... 349 Wheelock v. Godfrey, 100 Cal. 578 537, 547, 555, 573 Whelpleyw. Loder, 1 Dem. 368.. 365, 593 White v. Bailey, 10 Mich. 155.... 538,587, 561 v. British Empire Mut. L. Assur. Co. 19 L. T. N. S. 306, 17 Week. Rep. 26, L. R. 7 Eq. Cas. 394 406 0. Cox, 3 Hayw. (Term.; 82. 725 v. Davis, 42 N. Y. S. R. 901 720, 781 v. Driver, Phillim. Eccl. Rep. 84 341, 479, 481 v. Farley, 81 Ala. 563 276, 341, 453 v. Graves, 107 Mass. 325. 9 Am. Rep. 38 491, 494 v. Palmer, 4 Mass. 147 431 v. Small, 2 Ch. Cas. 103.... 376 v. State, 103 Ala. 72 688, 690, 695, 789, 793, 794 v. State, 32 Tex. Crim. Rep. 625 791 v. White, 1 Swab. & T. 592, 6 Jur. N. S. 28, L. T. N. S. 197 750 v. Wilson, 13 Ves. Jr.87.__ 292, 317, 479, 481 White's Will, 121 N. Y. 406 295, 298, 359 Whitenack v. Stryker, 2 N. J. Eq. 8 319, 320, 430, 451, 459, 478, 481. 492, 531, 562, 576, 734 Whitesides v. Greenlee, 2 Dev. Eq. 152 724 Whitman v. Morey, 63 N. H. 448. 495, 496, 521, 525 Whitney v. State, 8 Mo. 165. 683, 782 v. Twombley, 136 Mass. 145 225, 285, 288, 296 Wickwire's Appeal, 30 Conn. 86.. 511 Wigglesworth v. Steers, 1 Hen. & M. 70, 3 Am. Dec. 602. 719, 725 Wightman v. Wishtman, 4 Johns. Ch. 343 383, 386 Wilber«. Wilber, 129 111. 392.... 320, 451, 462 Wilcox v. Jackson, 51 Iowa, 208.. 720 v. State, 94 Term. 106 129. 131, 168, 169. 172, 175, 561, 590, 598, 683, 085 Wilder v. Weakley, 34 Ind. 181.. 244 Wiley v. Ewalt, 66 111. 26.251, 253, 741 Wilkerson®. Com. 88 Ky. 29.693, 714 Wilkinson «. Pearson, 23 Pa. 117. 489, 491, 500, 502, 558, 582, 584 Willcox v. Jackson, 51 Iowa, 208. 725 Willemin v. Dunn, 93 III. 511 251, 258, 270, 271 Willett v. Porter, 42 Ind. 250 9, 275, 294, 521, 522 Williams v. Edmunds, 75 Mich. 92 783, 785 v. Gonde, 1 Hagg. Eccl. Rep. 577 340, 372, 952 0. Goss, 43 La. Ann. 868... 744. 746, 750 v. Haid, 118 N. C. 481. .451, 452 0. Inabnet, 1 Bail. L. 343... 719 v. Lee, 47 Md. 321 346, 559, 561, 568, 580, 601, 604 v. Robinson, 42 Vt. 658, 1 Am. Rep. 359 461, 476 v. Spencer, 150 Mass. 346, 5 L. R. A. 790 600, 601 0. State, 81 Ala. 1, 60 Am. Rep. 133 682 0. State, 50 Ark. 517. ...127, 173, 175, 180, 466, 594 0. State, 7 Tex. App. 163... 131 0. State, 25 Tex. App. 76. . 683, 698, 711, 716 v. State, 12 Lea, 211 791 v. Williams, 90 Ky. 28.309, 567 Williamson v. Williams, 3 Jones Eq. 446 386 Willis 0. Com. 32 Graft, 928 163, 683, 687, 698, 708. 790 0. People, 32 N. Y. 715, 5 Park. Crim. Rep. 621.. 127, 130, 131, 132, 167, 188 0. Willis, 12 Pa. 159 430, 431, 435 Willwerth 0. Leonard, 156 Mass. 277 ..431, 432 Wilson v. Bigger, 7 Watts & S. Ill 731 0. Mitchell, 101 Pa. 495 288, 307, 312, 313, 364, 478 0. Oldham, 12 B. Mon. 55.. 243, 247, 259 Wilson's Appeal, 11 W. N. C. 333. 307 Case, Ray, Med. Juris. 465 669 Wiltshire 0. Marshall, 14 Week. Rep. 602 727 Winchomb v. Hall, 1 Ch. Rep. 40 264 5a lxvi CASES CITED. Winespear v. Accident Ins. Co. L. R. 6 Q. B. Div. 42, Aff'g 42 L. T. N S. 901 413, 1068 "Wintermute v. Wilson, 28 N. J. Eq. 437 277 Wintermute's Case, 27 N. J. Eq. 447 352 Will, 136 N. Y. 515 335 Wirebach v. First Nat. Bank, 97 Pa. 549, 39 Am. Rep. 821 249 Wise v. Foote, 81 Ky. 10 284, 310, 507, 559, 600 ». State, 34 Ga. 348 777 Wisener v. Maupin, 2 Baxt. 342-- 286, 587 Wiser v. Lockwood, 42 Vt. 720. ._ 383, 387 Witkington v. Witkington. 7 Mo. 589 .-. 321 Witkrow v. Smitkson. 37 W. Va. 757, 19 L. R. A. 762... 401 Witte v. Gilbert, 10 Neb. 539 9 Wogan o. Small, 11 Serg. & R. 131 559, 584 Wood v. Bayard, 6?. Pa. 320 401 v. Sawyer, 1 Phill. L. 251 .. 343, 498, 508, 513, 553 v. State, 34 Ark. 341, 36 Am. Re D . 13 691 v. State", 58 Miss. 741 558, 596, 600 v. Wood, 4 Brewst. 75 279, 289, 435 v. Wood, 1 Pkillim. Eccl. Rep. 357 370 Woodbury v. Obear, 7 Gray, 467. . 499, 541 v. Woodbury. 141 Mass. 330, 55 Am. Rep. 479 378 Woodcock v. Joknson, 36 MiDn. 217 498, 559, 573, 588 Woodfall's Will, 7 Pkila. 528.277, 350 Woodgate ». Taylor, 2 Swab. &T. 512, 30 L. J. Mat. N. S. 197, 5L. T. N.S. 119.- 396 Woodbull v. Wkittle, 63 Mick. 575 515, 614 Woods v. Brown, 93 Ind. 164, 47 Am. Rep. 369 401 v. Pindall, 1 Wright (Okio) 507. 729, 731 v. Tipton County Comrs. 128 Ind. 289 770 Woods's Estate, 13 Phila. 236.277, 363 Woodson ». Gordon, Peck (Tenn.) 196. 14 Am. Dec. 743.. 720 Wortkington v. Major, 94 Mick. 325.. 272 Wortbinston v. Mencer, 96 Ala. " 310, 17 L. R. A. 407... 453, 607, 610, 612 Wortky v. Wortky, 36 Ga. 45, 91 Am. Dec. 758 395 Wrav v. Wray, 19 Ala. 522 392 " v. Wray, 33 Ala. 187.. .393, 477 v. Wray, 32 Ind. 126 247, 248, 453 Wrigkt v. Doe, Tatkam, 1 Ad. & El. 3... 528 v. Doe, Tatkam, 7 Ad. & El. 313, 4 Bing. N. C. 489 508 v. Fisker, 65 Mick. 275 399,729, 757 v. Jackson, 59 Wis. 569 253, 269, 489 v. Lewis, 5 Rick. L. 212, 55 Am. Dec. 714 242, 275 v. People, 4 Neb. 407 23, 172, 176, 457, 472 v. Wrigkt, 139 Mass. 177... 246, 478, 482, 494 Wurzell v. Beckman, 52 Mick. 478. 499 Wyman v. Gould, 47 Me. 159 539, 564, 565 Wynn v. Allard, 5 Watts