HX641 57032 RC963 .F54 Periodic physical ex RECAP Columbia ®nitiem'tp mtljeOEitpoflimgork College of 3^l)v^\tiani anb ^urseon£( iCttirarp Periodic Physical Examination of Employes: Its Economic and Social Value Address delivered before The National Association of Manufacturers May 26, 1915 By Eugene Lyman Fisk, M. D. Director of Hygiene LIFE EXTENSION INSTITUTE, Inc. 25 WEST 45th STREET NEW YORK Issued by the Life Extension Institute Incorporated To prolong life and mal^e it more livable NBW YORK, N. Y. 2B W. 45TH ST. HON. WM. H. TAFT, Chairman, Hoard nf Directing ELMER E. RITTENHOUSE, I'rr^idi'nt GEN. W. C. GORGAS, Covsiilta nt , Sa ii itat ion PROF. IRVING FISHER, Chairman, Ilytiicnc Reffrenre Board EUGENE L. FISK, M.D., Director of Hygiene HAROLD A. LEY, y ire- President and Treasurer JAMES D. LENNEHAN, Srrrilitry Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2010 with funding from Open Knowledge Commons http://www.archive.org/details/periodicphysicalOOfisk Periodic Physical Examination of Employes, its Economic and Social Value. Address delivered before the National Association of Manufacturers May 26th, 1915, Why should a turtle live longer than a man ? What does the turtle contribute to the biological progress of the universe that he should be granted three times the span of human life? Is it not a little galling to human pride when we reflect that man, supposedly at the center of the universe, bending most of its mighty forces to his will, is yet unable to distance the tortoise in the race for longevity? It is all very well to say that the life of the turtle is flat, stale and unprofitable. After all, he lives long and apparently comfortably and happily — barring such accidents as getting into our soup. Man, on the contrary, lives a brief existence, hampered, nagged and handicapped by countless miseries and disabilities, that not only shorten his existence but embitter it, causing him as a rule to break down prematurely, and })re- venting him from achieving what mind and body are capable of achieving when working in harmony with Nature's laws. Man has defied the forces of Nature, and harnessed many of them in his service, but concomitantly he has broken many of the laws of Nature, creating an artificial environment, pro- tective in some respects, menacing in others. The Cjuestion that confronts us is tiiis : Is it inevitable that the higher and more complex life of man should be shorter than the lower life of the turtle? So far as science can reveal, there seems to be no princi]ile of either life or death. There are many good and bad reasons why men die, but no un(k'rl\ing necessary reason why they must die. The brilliant Carrel, now working in the very jaws of death, has kci)t tissue cells alive outside the body for the past three years. These cells are multiplying and growing, apparently unchanged by time, to all appearances immortal so long as they are i)eriodically washed of poison and nourished in a proper medium. Wash man of his poisons at intervals, and nourish him. and win- should he not live on so long as there is energy in the universe to supply his needs. Notwithstanding what I have said about the turtle, I would not waste one moment of time in pleading for a mere extension of human existence, if there were not sound scientific evidence to prove that such extension can most easily be attained by improving the quality and the total value of existence. There is even something ignoble in hanging on to the coat-tails of Old Father Time just to sneak a few more years of life. Tolstoi is right in advising us not to fear death, which under present conditions like sleej), must come to all. It is, rather, a wasted and deformed life that we should fear and that we should seek to escape, not by leaving it, but by mending and moulding it. Man has made some progress in escaping death, and in hammering down the death rate as the following figures show : Death Rate Year per 1,000 living Geneva 1551-1600 39.7 Geneva 1891-1900 17.6 Berlin 1721-1730 40.6 Berlin -. 1 905-1910 15.5 London 1 800-1810 29 London 3905-1910 14 Paris 1809-1816 30.5 Paris 1905-1910 17.5 Sweden 1751-1760 27.4 Sweden 1912 14.2 U. S. Reg. Area 1880 19.8 U. S. Reg. Area 1913 14.1 While the average duration of human life has been greatly extended during the past century, there has been no material addition to the span of human life. It is true that in certain countries such as Sweden, England and Wales, Prussia and Denmark there has been a gain in vitality at every age period of life during the past quarter century, but in this country, so far as we can determine from our exceedingly unsatisfactory registration records, there has been not only a failure to lengthen the span of life but a positive loss in vitality at middle life and later, notwithstanding the fall in the general death rate. This conquering of death, in the earlier age periods of life is due to man's success in meeting the massive frontal attacks of such enemies as diphtheria, tuberculosis, typhoid fever and diseases of infancy. The elimination of such plagues as "Black Death," yellow fever, smallpox, has also left its impress on the general death rate. But we have been less successful in guarding against influences, agencies and infections which may be compared to submarine attacks, or to sapping and mining operations that reveal no enemy until an explosion occurs. Under this class of agencies we include faulty living habits which tend to disturb the functions of the body and impair the efficiency of our organs, ultimately causing them to break down ; also chronic infections, which pass unnoticed often for years until announced by illness and physical failure. HUMAN LIFE A STRUGGLE WITH GERM LIFE. Life is one long struggle with micro-organisms. Sanitation, quarantine and the annihilation of pest carriers such as the mosquito and rat, protect us from some of these enemies, but others lodge in our tooth sockets, our tonsils, our middle ears, the nasal cavities, etc., and from such favorable bases of sup- plies stream out and attack our joints, our gall bladders, our appendices, our stomachs, hearts, kidneys and other vulner- able points. A sound bodily condition protects against all such menaces, as the normal human body has a war machine that gets quickly and successfully into motion against these minute enemies. But few individuals are always in a state of perfect health. Most men have, at least at intervals, their points of least resistance, and few are aware of these weak si)ols until a successful attack reveals their presence. THE HUMAN MACHINE. ]\Ian has often been compared to a macliine. This may not be true of man as a whole, but his body is certainly built on mechanical principles. The motions of his limbs are con- trolled by a perfect system of levers, and he even has shock absorbers. The heart is a pump with valves constructed on ordinary mechanical principles. The blood vessels are elastic tubes that contract or dilate under the control of nerve centers that respond, like push buttons, to certain stimuli. The entire telegraphic and telephonic system of this country is not more complex, and is certainly less efihcient, than the sensory and motor nervous system linking the brain to the body and gov- erning its functions. jMillions upon millions of cells — muscle, nerve, brain, kid- ney, liver, heart, are all busily at work, each with a definite function to perform. Few people who buy a manufactured product stop to think of how it is made; how seldom their imaginations are stimulated to go back of the shop in which the article is sold and visualize the army of toilers who bring the article into being. How few have any knowledge what- ever of the marvellous machinery that often seems to be alive and purposeful in the complexity and precision of its move- ments. To the manufacturer, the integrity and precision and the smooth working of this machinery is the first rule of preserva- tion in his business. Before a manufacturer can engage in business, he must plan and build his machines and then he must test them. After they are established and in good work- ing order, doe's he then sit back and take their products until they break down? Such a course would be looked upon as insane. No well managed plant but has its system of inspec- tion. But what about the men who guide and supervise these machines, who sell their products and who keep the wheels of business moving? Is there some good kind fairy that watches for the first signs of faulty heart pump, of an impaired poison separator (the kidneys), of poles and wires down in the telegraph and telephone system (nerves), of hardening in. those normally elastic tubes (arteries), and countless other indications of over-stoking, rust and clinkers in this marvel- lously complex human machine ? In most estabhshments this task is certainly left to the fairies, for there is no human agency that covers it. Wel- fare work and emergency medical relief for employes is pro- vided in most of the important industrial establishments, and many of them require a physical examination before employ- ment. A regular, systematic periodic physical examination of the entire body, such as is applied to ordinary machinery, is, however, practically non-existent, except in the establish- ments taking the service of the Life Extension Institute. * PREVENTION vs. CURE. Immediate relief for injury or illness is a matter of com- mon humanity, but the prevention of illness and accident is a matter of business economy, as well as humanity. This is well recognized in regard to accidents by the widespread use of safety devices. But the almost infinite capacity of the human machine for going wrong seems not to be recognized, and the remedy is usually applied only after physical deterioration and impairment has resulted in frank illness, or in accident that is essentially caused by illness. Long before the heart breaks down, or the kidneys lose their function, or the arteries become seriously affected, there is a period of slow change which often affects the efficiency of the individual and increases the liability to accident. These early signs of trouble are readily revealed by thorough health examinations, affording the o])portunity not only to prevent disease, and accident due to an improperly working body, but to improve the general * I am informed by Mr. Royal S. Meeker, United States Commissioner of Labor Statistics, that it is contemplated to establish a central agency in that Department for the systematic collection of informa- tion regarding welfare work among employes, to supply the demands upon the Department of Lal)or for information of this character. It would seem desirable for employers, who are making provision for the physical examination or care of their employes, to submit a precise statement to the Department in order that those who are interested may have a reliable source of information on this subject. The Institute will he pleased at all times to receive information of this character. average condition of the individual, raise him to a higher level of physical fitness, and increase his capacity for living hap- pily, contentedly and efficiently. All these factors have an economic as well as a social and humanitarian value. An employee who is sound and healthy, who is doing work to which he is physically adapted, is less irrital:>le, suspicious and intractable than an employee who is physically below par and easily stimulated into unreasoning discontent. The value of the system of periodic examination is no longer a matter of theory. In one life insurance company (Postal Life), a trial of this system over a period of five years resulted in a reduction in mortality of about 50 per cent, among those taking the examination, and a saving of $13 for every dollar expended. The experience of such corporations as the National Har- vester Co., Sears, Roebuck and Co., the National Cash Reg- ister Co. and the Chicago and Northwestern R. R. Co. and others, where examinations of applicants for employment are carried on, show the need of inspecting the human body that is called upon to do work. The Chicago and Northwestern report that 12 per cent, of the men examined were found unfit for the form of employment sought. In Sears, Roelnick, through their system of entrance exami- nation and medical inspection and examination of special groups, the death rate among those sufifering from tuberculosis was reduced from 11 to 1 per cent., and the percentage of tuberculous employes from 4.G per cent, to .8 of 1 per cent. TITE TOTAL VALUE OF THE HEALTH SURVEY. In all establishments of which I have knowledge, the effort seems to be to give the employee work adapted to his physical capacities. The mere weeding out of tuberculous employes or others who are a menace to their fellows, by reason of com- municable disease, is a minor feature of the work. It is, of course, greatly in the interests of the tuberculous employee that he be located and aft'orded an opportunity for seeking treatment, rather than that he continue at work until his malady has perha])s Ijccome incuraljlc. The chief vakie of the system of complete health surveys, supplemented by education in personal hygiene lies in its total effect on the force, and in its power to raise the general level of fitness, well-being and efficiency. These are the broad general purposes that actuate such men as Ex-President Taft, Surgeon General Gorgas, Professor Irving Fisher, Dr. Alexander Graham Bell and other eminent scientific men and publicists who have joined in the work of the Life Extension Institute without compensation or other reward than the satisfaction of seeing these benefits extended to the largest possible number of people. The privilege of periodic physical inspection has already been extended to a vast body of insurance policyholders through arrangements made by certain life insurance companies with the Institute. The latest company to take this service, the Germania Life of New York, tried this experiment first in New York City, and the opportunities for improving the condition of policy- holders was so manifest that the system was quickly extended to their policyholders throughout the country. No life insurance company has any relation with the Insti- tute other than that of patron. The interest of the life insur- ance company is similar to that of the employer. By reducing the number of death claims, the company is reimbursed for its expenditure for the Institute's service. The employer bene- fits by a reduced sickness rate and accident rate among his employes, and an increase in their mental and physical effi- ciency. GOOD WORK AND GOOD BUSINESS. To measure these benefits to the employer accurately will take years of experience, but it must be evident that an influ- ence that will produce a 50 per cent, saving in mortality and return $13 for every $1 expended in life insurance will at least produce a 10 per cent, improvement in the physical and mental efficiency of empl()}'es. There arc oilier c\i)cricnlial data that sujijiort those views, such as the known inllucntx' of alcoht)! in impairing mental and muscular efficiency, the power to memorize, the power to perform a simple act such as typewriting, typesetting, etc., conditions that are paralleled by functional disturbances and diseased conditions revealed by the examinations. Assuming the tigure to be conservative, it follows that the application of the system to a group of employes earning $100,000,000 per annum would increase their productivity 10 per cent., and result in a gain in earning capacity of $10,000,000 per annum, provided the occupation were one in which the physical and mental efficiency could affect the quality and the quantity of the work turned out. This does not take into account the reduced amount of illness, death and accident, all of which have a tremendous economic and business value. Prolonged illness or death of experienced and valued employes may mean many thousands of dollars to a concern. Government has already placed a certain responsibility on the employer for the care and protection of his employes. Workmen's compensation acts are being passed by State after State, and common business prudence dictates that the em- ployer shall take every reasonable means to limit his liability. That the liability to accident among a group of employes who are examined once a year is less than the average cannot be questioned by any reasonable person. Various considerations of policy and politics have as yet prevented any official and statutory recognition of this fact, but the fact remains. Even where a compensation law calls for compulsory insurance the employer need not shrug his shoulders and say, "I am now protected by my insurance pre- miums, and there is nothing further to be done." With a reduction in the accident rate, from whatever cause, there must ultimately come about a reduction in the cost of insur- ance. Where the employer carries the risk himself, the strong- est possible reason exists for periodic physical examination, from which the two-fold benefit of increased efficiency and reduced accident loss will result. Here is a recent instance that came to my notice. The other day, in a large wood pulp plant in Canada, a man was 10 lightly hit on the head while at work, and instantly killed. It was found that he had suffered from heart disease, and that -a light shock, that would not have put a football player out •of a game, had sufficed to kill. A large indemnity was paid to the widow. How much better it would have been for the man, widow and plant, if the man had been examined and kept out of work that exposed him to accident and injury. The value of such an influence, in reducing accident lia- bility, is plainly implied in the New York Law, which allows under safety and welfare credits a reduction of from 1 to 10 per cent, for such vague conditions as "competency of man- agement," "attitude toward employes," "attitude toward acci- dent prevention," "general conditions tending to establish more cordial relations between employer and employes," etc. If such ill-defined factors can properly be given a percentage value, the direct, systematic controlling influence of periodic physical inspection, for the purpose of detecting physical weaknesses and impairments, many of which predispose to accident, can hardly be denied an equal value. When we read that 12 per cent, of applicants for employ- ment have been found defective, or that 1 to 4 per cent, of employes have been found tuberculous, it must not be thought that these even remotely express the value of the periodic -examination, and that there is no influence on the balance of the force. WHAT THESE EXAMINATIONS REVEAL. A consideration of the following analysis of the examination of employes made by the Life Extension Institute shows that practically all those examined ofl'ered some opixtrluuity for betterment. On the other hand, the number that arc found positively unfitted for any form of cniployiiiciit is very small. Yet, business prudence, as well as common humanity, renders it a(lvisal)le to locate this small percentage and to take the ])roper stejis for the protection of all concerned. 11 RESULTS OF THE EXAMINATION OF EMPLOYES OF COMMERCIAL HOUSES, BANKS, ETC. BY THE LIFE EXTENSION INSTITUTE, INC. Normal Ol^^o Imperfect — Advice needed regarding physical condi- tion or living habits .99% Not aware of impairment .81% Referred to physician for treatment .Q7% CLASSIFICATION OF IMPAIRMENTS. Moderate to Serious. Organic heart disease 6.14% Arteriosclerosis— thickened arteries 13.94% High or low blood pressure 26.81% Urinary — Albumin, sugar, casts 43.27% Individuals showing combined disturbance of circu- lation and kidneys 17.82% Nervous 1.44% Lungs — possible tuberculosis .49% Venereal .41% Minor to Moderate. Functional, Circulatory — Rapid, slow or intermittent pulse 10.51% Urinary (high and low specific gravity, crystals, in- dican, etc. ) 20.58% Digestive Organs 9.73% Constipation 20.29% Nose and throat 30.56% Ears 15.38% Decayed teeth and infected gums 26.93% Anemia 3.50% Skin 7.96% Errors in diet (pronounced) 28.54% Errors in personal hygiene 56.22% 12 Physical Defects. Faulty vision (uncorrected) 22.89^ Flat foot 3.09fo Faulty Posture 8.62fo Rupture, no truss 1.23% Overweight, important 6.10% Underweight, important 18.44% Unclassified 13.94% The above table shows the percentages that the various impairments are of the whole number of employes examined. Many employes, of course, showed several combined impair- ments. Average age 30. The life insurance experience is along similar lines, but modified by several conditions : a higher average age, the purely voluntary self selection of each individual examined, and the fact that many of these examinations were made in remote sections by less highly trained examiners. Many of the impairments above listed constitute serious physical and mental handicaps. They interfere with an alert, snappy, wideawake attention to business. They favor indif- ference, lassitude, and inaccuracy and increase the liability to accidents. Leaving out such serious matters as diseases of the heart, kidney, blood vessels, lungs, ranging from the incipi- ent to well-defined stages, there is faulty vision, mouth infec- tion, nose and throat affections, constipation, flat foot, and other so-called minor defects, all interfering with the proper working of the human machine. More than 90 per cent, of those sufificieiUly impaired lo be referred to physicians for medical ircatnient were not aware of any impairment, and were taking no slejis to correct their condition. All of which goes to show that tlie average individual is usually far below his attainable condition of health and well- being. About onc-lialf of these people showed some serious error in diet or personal hygiene, the correction of which would undonl)te(ll\- improxe their condition. 13 PLANS AND METHODS. The method of carrying on this work has been carefully studied by the Institute, and is standardized along certain lines. An examining room is equipped by the Institute in the estab- lishment, and a sufficient number of trained physicians detailed to rapidly examine the force, each doctor working a half day only in order to keep the work up to a high grade of accuracy and precision. This work as designed by the Institute is done very thor- oughly, and involves a complete health survey — eyes, ears, nose, throat, lungs, heart, blood vessels, blood pressure, urine, nervous system, physique, posture, possible deformities, rup- ture, flat-foot, consideration of family history and living habits. All these data — derived from the personal statement of the employee, the examiner's report, and the laboratory report — are considered by trained diagnosticians, and if no impairment is found, the employee is notified. If a slight impairment or error in personal hygiene — eating, drinking, working, play- ing, smoking, exercise, etc., — is found, he is directly advised, and also instructed by means of "Keep-Well" leaflets appro- priate to his case. Education in the care of the health is pro- vided Ijy monthly "Health Letters." If some impairment requiring medical attention is found, the report is sent to the family physician or to some physician designated by the employee, and he is advised and urged by the Institute and his employer to seek the necessary treatment, unless the con- dition is one that can be handled by the company's physician, if such there be. Every effort is made to protect the employee from undue alarm, if impairment is found. In all cases showing any impairment, the chief local examiner receives the report from the Home Office, and delivers them to the employes, with such suggestions as may properly be gi\en in regard to errors in hygiene, physical defects, or the necessary form of medical treatment to seek. This method guards against misunder- standing of the report, or undue alarm or indifference and neglect on the part of the employee ! A report is, of course, rendered to the employer of each case examined, and an analy- 14 sis is made of the general results, with such suggestions in regard to the sanitary conditions or the condition of the force as may be derived from the survey of the plant and the force. Every three months certain cases, which seem to require it, are checked up in regard to special conditions, such as blood pressure, urine, heart, lungs, etc., in order that the full benefit of the system may be exerted and the progress of such cases watched. The Institute is willing to arrange for one of the staff to visit the plant regularly as an emergency physician, but for this special work the employer must make private arrange- ment with the physician, as the Institute does not undertake private medical treatment. Nevertheless, such a physician would be under its general guidance and supervision with regard to the periodic examinations, and would cooperate effectively in giving them their maximum value. Where a medical department already exists, it is entirely possible for the Institute to cooperate, specializing as it does, with the assistance of the Hygiene Reference Board, in the work of the Health Survey and the application of the prin- ciples of personal hygiene. No one concern can group the forces and the scientific resources that are available to the Institute, because of its underlying altruistic purposes. If the Metropolitan Life Insurance Company, with assets of $386,- 000,000 and a splendidly equipped medical department, labora- tory and an extensive list of examiners, saw fit to pass this work over to the Institute, it must be apparent that the aver- age business concern could profitably do likewise, rather than attempt the work in an individual way. The independent, non-partisan character of the Institute enables it to command the confidence of the policyholder and the employee, and guar- antee the genuineness of the welfare service rendered, a matter of no mean importance — er>pecially to the employer— in mak- ing this work effective. The Institute does not advise that these examinations be made compulsory. Usually the cooperation of a majority of the employes can be obtained, if the matter is properly 15 put before them. It should be made clear that the examina- tions are part of the business policy of the concern, but that they are likewise for the material benefit of the employes ; that any well grounded or serious objection will be consid- ered, but that the total welfare of the force and of the business requires that mere prejudice should not interfere with the car- rying on of the work. POSSIBLE INFLUENCE ON NATIONAL VITALITY. It is indeed regrettable that we have not yet reached the millennium. Almost daily we have some evidence of our remoteness from that happy state. As practical men, we must take conditions as we find them, and do the best we can to improve them. The time has not yet come when an individual, a business institution or a Nation can disregard the matter of physical soundness and efficiency. I have referred to the fact that our mortality statistics indi- cate a loss in vitality and an increasing death rate at the middle age periods of life, when man should really be at his best. There has, in fact, been an increase of 40 per cent, during the past 23 years in the death rate per 10,000 in the United States Registration Area from the chronic degenerative dis- eases of middle life and old age and there are signs of the encroachment of these maladies on the earlier periods of life. This information is perhaps displeasing to a certain type of optimist, the kind of an optimist who is irritated and aggrieved when his bank notifies him that his account is overdrawn. The other type of optimist, however, the only type that is of any real value in society, the type that receives unpleasant news with a firm countenance and immediately resolves to cheer- fully anfl hopefully apply a remedy, will, I am sure, receive this particular jjiece of unpleasant news in the right spirit. The conditions, whatever they may be, that are causing this encroachment of degenerative maladies are not to be remedied by blunt-eyed optimism, but by open-eyed courage and deter- mined action. 16 It is true that I have presented this subject of health con- servation among employers as a matter primarily of i)ure business economy, as a measure that will contribute to busi- ness success. Every man wiio succeeds by energy, intelli- gence and square dealing in a business that carries "no menace to the people is a public benefactor. There is no need to apolo- gize for this work because it is '"good business." On the other hand, I am confident that there is no member of this associa- tion who would not derive a deep and wholesome satisfaction from the consciousness that the methods by which he carries on his business are exerting a powerful influence in raising the physical standard of our race. It is well to avoid the mistake that Sparta made in concen- trating on mere physical excellence, but there is no real rea- son why physical soundness and well-being should not go hand in hand v\ith moral, intellectual and spiritual growth. We hear much in these days of our lack of preparedness for military defense, of the need for armament, ships, a trained soldiery. We take it for granted that we have the raw material and that it is of the right quality. There is danger, however, in taking too much for granted when the destiny of 100 millions of people and a splendid civiliza- tion and industrial development are at stake. If there are forces in our country that make for physical decay, it is well that they should be sought for and neutralized. No Nation can carry forward the l)anner of progress, enlight- ment and human freedom, whether in war or peace, unless those who march behind it are of sound and virile stock. 17 LIFE EXTENSION INSTITUTE, Inc. Jl Work of Human Salvage ESTABLISHED by well-known leaders in the field of Race Betterment who desire to assist in reducing life-waste and to see the science of disease prevention put on as large, solid and enduring basis as curative medicine. The Institute's mission is 1. To teach you how to a'cot'c/ disease. 2. To advocate periodic health examinations that disease may be detected in time to give your doctor a chance to check or cure it. 3. To provide such examinations for you at low cost to assist in establishing this life-saving practice amongst all our people. DIRECTORS Hon. Wm. H. Taft, Chairman Henry H. Bowman Francis R. Cooley Robert W. deForest Prof. Irving Fisher Eugene Lyman Fisk E. R. L. Gould Harold A. Ley Elmer E. Rittenhouse Charles H. Sabin Frank A. VanderHp COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY LIBRARIES This book is due on the date indicated below, or at the ' expiration of a definite period after the date of borrowing, as provided by the rules of the Library or by special arrange- , ment with the Librarian in charge. | DATE BORROWED DATE DUE DATE BORROWED DATE DUE A 'R .:. i 1 1 1 • 1 C2B(l14t)M100 COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY LIBRARIES 0043076688 EC963 Fisk F54 Fb^