N V \ \ (£, > THE WORLD CONFERENCE FOR THE CONSIDERATION OF QUESTIONS TOUCHING FAITH AND ORDER 1 NORTH AMERICAN PREPARATORY CONFERENCE ^GARDEN CITY, LONG ISLAND, NEW YORK, U. S. A. JANUARY 4-6, 1916 Report of Progress BY THE SECRETARY Opening Address BY THE RT. REV. C. P. ANDERSON, D.D. "iva irdvres £v (3<7t, Kad&s 9 ] mission on the World Conference is seeking uniformity. There is nothing in the statements of the Episcopal Commission to justify this assumption. 11. The question of orders naturally looms largest, as most of the writers are clergymen. Many Anglicans declare that unity can be reached only through the Historic Episcopate, while very many members of non-Episcopal bodies declare that the Episcopate will never be accepted. Orders are obviously a question for the World Conference. 12. There is little evidence of general comprehension, and some evidence of distinct lack of comprehension, of the difference in the conceptions of unity by those who believe Christ to be God made man, and by those who merely reverence Him as the perfect man. 13. There is little agreement as to the nature and functions of a creed. 14. We have, as yet, hardly touched the laity, men or women. 15. It must be remembered that thousands of letters have not been preserved which expressed a warm interest, but did not indicate any specific attitude of the writer on the question. 16. There is little profound realization of the necessity for prayer. The Commissions and Committees outside of the United States do not yet quite understand that they are partners with us, ex¬ pected to volunteer suggestions as to the further conduct of the movement. Their attitude is too much that of waiting till they see what we have to propose. Without their active assistance we may make serious mistakes, and we cannot secure that widespread interest in the movement, and prayer for its guidance, which are necessary for any progress. One of the objects of this North Ameri¬ can Conference is to make definite suggestions which Commissions in other countries can use as a basis for their thought, and which, while specific enough to call out definite criticism, shall make it clear that we desire such criticism and are not proposing a plan to be accepted or rejected as a whole. Doubtless this Conference in formulating such suggestions will bear in mind the fact that we still lack the cooperation of Communions, embracing the [ 20 ] greater number of Christians in the world, whose cooperation is essential, if we are so to lift up Christ befoi’e the world that He may draw all men unto Him and establish His reign of peace and righteousness and love. To the prosecution of the great enterprise in which we are engaged we must devote, with enthusiastic heroism, all our powers. Each of us, unconsciously perhaps, has been thinking of it first of all in its bearing upon his own Communion, with little recognition that it is world-wide and absolutely vital and fundamental. And so we have had but little faith. Our eyes have been turned downward to the barriers we have inherited and have strengthened against our brethren, rather than to the vision of a world at one in its Redeemer. The contemplation of that vision will, by God’s grace, fill us wdth the faith which will remove the mountains in our path and show us that, if we are to be God’s instruments in the opportunity He has given us to bring His w^orld to Him, all that we are, all that we have, is far too little for the task. We have undertaken to bring Christians to that mutual com¬ prehension and appreciation which is the necessary preliminary to directly reconstructive work, for we believe with Dean Turkevich, that to understand is to love, and love is unity. We are not to deal wdth mere questions of ecclesiastical diplomacy, of ignoring or compounding theological differences, of superficial agreement or amiable indifference with regard to the questions which have kept in separate and often hostile camps the armies which God intends for the conquest of the world. Our task will not be fulfilled by any human concordat. We must prepare the way so that the Holy Spirit may restore that unity which will enable all who are mem¬ bers of Christ to receive together the Bread of Life. Ours is the opportunity to lead Christians to put first things first, and to manifest to the world the true Faith which is the unity of the Christian with the Lord of Life, and of all Christians with each other in and through Him. Every epoch in the history of Christianity has been crucial, but now has come in these latter days to us a new and greater opportunity and responsibility, for Christianity can no longer endure apparently divided against [ 21 ] itself. The Old World is being swept by horrors the most dreadful in the history of man. The New is drifting in aimless self-com¬ placency,—perhaps to be involved in this frightful war, perhaps, and more probably, to inherit the supremacy in the things of this world which will hide from our eyes for generations to come the things which are eternal. We have been preaching or hearing Christmas sermons about peace to men of good will. God is giving us the opportunity so to surrender ourselves to Him during these four days that we may be filled with Christ’s good Will and do our part to manifest to the world the Prince of Peace. But the world will not listen unless our message is vital, and only in the unity of the one Body of Christ is perfect life. Until we present to the world the glory of the visible unity of the Church which is that Body, the good news of the coming of the Prince of Peace will never be so heard as to establish His Kingdom. A distracted Europe, a self-complacent America, and a divided Christendom which can speak only with uncertain voice — the unceasing thought of these must set the tone of our discussions and bring us again and again to our knees. If we wait here upon God in utter submission to His Will, He will guide us into His truth and will give us abundant grace and strength. So only shall we be able during this coming year to devote all our united strength of heart and mind and soul to the healing of those wounds in the Body of Christ which now impair His perfect work, and He, no longer obscured by us and our differences, will be so lifted up before the world that He will draw all men unto Him. Respectfully submitted, Robert H. Gardiner Secretary of the Advisory Committee of the Commis¬ sions on a World Conference on Faith and Order [ 22 ] INTRODUCTORY ADDRESS AT THE GARDEN CITY CONFERENCE Delivered by the Rt. Rev. Charles P. Anderson, D.D., LL.D. BISHOP OF CHICAGO, MODERATOR AT THE FIRST SESSION Brethren and Friends: I ESTEEM it an honor and privilege to be presented to you as the Moderator of the first session of this Preparatory Con¬ ference. Perhaps it will be proper for me, on the threshold of our deliberations, to try to indicate the character and purpose of this meeting and of the World Conference for which it would make preparation. My thoughts group themselves under two heads — letter and spirit. The spirit of this meeting should be and must be the spirit of hope and faith and expectancy. This on the one hand. On the other hand we have to be governed by certain spe¬ cific instructions which accompanied our appointment as repre¬ sentatives of the Churches under whose authority we act. We are to open our hearts and minds to each other and to the guid¬ ing influence of the Holy Spirit, as agents of those bodies from whom we have received a limited and well-defined commission. We have come here to confer about a World Conference on Faith and Order. We are here to consider how the arrangements for that conference can be advanced. This meeting is not a Con¬ ference on Faith and Order, but a consultation on ways and means of bringing about a Conference on Faith and Order. The confer¬ ence which we are here to promote is to be a World Conference. It is to be world-wide in its scope. It is not to be an American gathering, nor a European gathering, nor a gathering confined to any geographical limits. It aims to encompass representatives of practically every nation and race and people and language in the world. It is not only a world-wide conference, but a Church¬ wide conference also. It aims to embrace all those forms of organ¬ ized Christianity which have at their centre allegiance to Jesus Christ as the Saviour of the world. It is not to be, if its plans carrv, a pan-Protestant conference, nor a pan-Catholic conference. [ 23 ] It is to be pan-Christian. It is neither sectional nor sectarian nor partial nor partisan in its conception. It seeks to be truly repre¬ sentative of all Christendom, thoroughly ecumenical in its reach, but without authority to legislate or to bind participating bodies. It is a conference wherein no compromise nor embarrassment can overtake any member, but which is nevertheless inspired by the holy hope that it will prove to be a step toward the realization and manifestation of corporate unity amongst all who profess and call themselves Christians. It is unnecessary to say that such a conference, unique in the world’s history, sublime in its purpose, requires on the part of its promoters abundant charity, wide sympathy, a capacity for dis¬ covering spiritual wealth in unexpected quarters, an open mind that seeks only the truth, a heart that loves the whole brother¬ hood, a freedom from inherited pride and prejudice, and the cul¬ tivation of a catholic and cosmopolitan temper. On first thought the bigness of the plan seems to make it im¬ practical, if not impossible. On second thought, however, it is its very bigness which seems to make it possible and practicable. Its wide scope lifts it above local difficulties. It lifts it above the spirit of the age into the spirit of the ages. There is scarcely a nation in the world to-day wherein a national conference for the same purpose could take place. Political complications, educational controversies, social inequalities between established and unestab¬ lished Churches,—these and conditions such as these make na¬ tional conferences on Faith and Order quite impracticable. But a World Conference lifts the whole subject above those national and artificial barriers that men erect between themselves ; it lifts it above the realm of racial types and local phases; it lifts it above the incidents and accidents and tragedies of history into the clearer vision of the universality of Christ and the unity of His Body, the Church. Multitudinous difficulties automatically disappear as saints and scholars of many lands and Churches meet to contemplate a world Saviour, saving a whole world, through a world Church. It is of the utmost importance that the world character of the plan be kept in mind in such a local meeting as this. We repre- [ 24 ] sent but one of many countries, and that one only in part. We represent only a portion of the Christian world geographically and ecclesiastically. It is of the essence of the proposed conference that opportunity for participation not only in the conference, but in the previous arrangements for it, shall be pressed home to every part of Christendom. For this reason scrupulous care should be exercised that a local gathering of this sort should not unwittingly create a prejudicial atmosphere into which all other Christians might hesitate to come. How often it has happened, dear brethren, that you and I have been invited to take part in some movement, toward which our sympathies inclined, but in which we could not conscientiously join because certain premises and presuppositions had unconsciously been built into the foundations. These diffi¬ culties would not have existed if those who were invited to join in the movement had also been asked to join in laying the founda¬ tions. So it is with this movement which we are trying to launch. Speaking for myself only, I am prepared to admit without any mock humility, that, living as we do in more or less isolation in our divided Christendom, I have probably acquired certain stereo¬ typed habits of mind which make me incapable of reproducing the mental habits and attitudes of many who are better Christians than I am. Consequently I confess incompetence for laying the foundations on which others are to be asked to build. All those who are to be invited to take part in the conference should also be invited to take part in the steps leading toward it. The Churches of Sweden and Norway and Denmark and Russia and Germany and England and Scotland and other lands; the missionary Churches of Asia and Africa in their close contact with the non-Christian world; the Roman Catholic Church, which knows no national boundaries but which has such wide international power and in¬ fluence; the ancient Churches of Asia Minor, whose conservatism in the face of long-continued persecutions may enable them to teach the world a great deal about the primitive contents of Chris¬ tianity,— all these should have the privilege somehow of getting in on the ground floor. Our task, therefore, as a sectional confer¬ ence, is to do those things which we ought to do to further the conference, and to leave undone those things which we ought not [ 25 ] to do lest we encroach on the domain of others. So long as there is a ray of hope, the ecumenical character of the conference should be steadfastly maintained. The point of contact in the proposed conference is belief in Jesus Christ as God and Saviour. No other point of contact is considered essential to the conference. No previous recognition, on the part of any Church, of the claims or tenets of any other Church, can be demanded, under the terms of the conference, as a preliminary basis of negotiation. Each body comes into the con¬ ference on the basis of its own estimate of itself, without the aban¬ donment of any distinctive belief or differentiating principle. For the purpose of the conference and as members of the conference, all come in on the same level — the same lofty level of belief in Jesus Christ. Everything else is subject-matter for conference. The object of the conference is the study and discussion in the spirit of love and forbearance, in personal eye-to-eye contact, of the things in which Christians differ as well as the things in which they are of one mind. Personal contact between representatives of unlike groups is regarded as a fundamental element in the solu¬ tion and removal of difficulties. The hope of the conference is that personal contact, mutual counsel, interchange of ideas, and united prayer will prove to be a step toward unity. The belief of those who are promoting the conference is that the time is ripening for it, that world conditions demand it, and that providential circumstances are compelling Christ’s followers to draw together into compact unity and solidarity. As we look out upon the world to-day we see it engaged in a war of indescribable destructiveness. Nation is fighting against nation, Christian against Christian, Catholic against Catholic, Protestant against Protestant, culture against culture. It is a situ¬ ation to make men and angels weep. Men are seriously asking whether Christianity has failed. We answer, No. Christianity has not failed, but our civilization is threatened, because, though it contains many Christians, it is not corporately Christian. It is a legitimate question as to whether a united Church might not have preserved peace in the world. [ 26 ] We look out upon the Christian Church to-day and, in spite of its interior indestructible unity, we see it externally rent and torn asunder, largely disintegrated and individualistic, unable to mould the national conscience, or to influence the continental mind, or to weave itself bodily into the warp and woof of our civ¬ ilization. One does not have to deny the contribution which each Church has made to the totality of Christian experience; one does not have to deny the religious values for which each Church has stood; one does not have to deny these things in order to affirm that isolation and separation and disintegration are imperilling the power of the Church of Jesus Christ. A bleeding world and a bewildered Christendom are crying aloud, How long, O Lord, how long, until Peace be established amongst the nations and Unity be realized between the Churches ? The world-wide, Church-wide conference is an attempt at an ad¬ vance toward a world need and the fulfilment of a world prayer. In the face of world conditions to-day, in the face of religious conditions to-day, does any Christian dare or care to stand aloof from a movement so full of mutual trust and confidence, so considerate in matters of conscience, so charged with loyalty to Christ and His Church? [ 27 ] The Publications previous to this were: 1. Report and Resolution of the Protestant Episcopal Church sug¬ gesting the Conference, and Report and Resolutions of the Na¬ tional Council of the Congregational Churches of the United States looking to Reunion with the Protestant Episcopal Church. 2. Report and Resolution of the Protestant Episcopal Church sug¬ gesting the Conference. 3. Report of April 20, 1911, of the Committee on Plan and Scope of the Commission of the Protestant Episcopal Church. 12. The World Conference and the Problem of Unity. By the Rev. Francis J. Hall, D.D. 13. Letter to the Council of the Old Catholic Churches in Europe. 14. An Official Statement by the Commission of the Protestant Epis¬ copal Church. 15. Prayer and Unity. 16. Questions of Faith and Order for Consideration by the Proposed Conference. By the Rt. Rev. A. C. A. Hall, D.D., Bishop of Ver¬ mont. 17. A Bibliography of Topics related to Church Unity. By the Rev. F. J. Hall, D.D. 18. Unity or Union: Which? By the Rt. Rev. P. M. Rhinelander, D.D., Bishop of Pennsylvania. 19- The Conference Spirit. 20. The Manifestation of Unity. By the Rt. Rev. C. P. Anderson, D.D., Bishop of Chicago. 21. List of Commissions appointed up to October 22, 1915. 23. Report to the General Convention of 1913 of the Protestant Epis¬ copal Chui’ch by the Commission appointed by that Church. 24. A Fii’st Preliminaiy Conference. 25. Report of the Committee on Church Unity of the National Coun¬ cil of Congregational Churches, 1913. 26. A Woi'ld Movement for Christian Unity. By the Rev. Lefferd M. A. Haughwout. 27. Second Meeting of the Advisory Committee. Report of the Second Deputation to Great Britain. The Call for a Truce of God. 28. The Object and Method of Conference. 29. A Manual of Pi'ayer for Unity. Numbers J/.-11, inclusive, and, 22 are translations of Number 2 into Mod¬ ern Greek, Latin, Italian, Russian, Swedish, German, French, Dutch and Spanish. [ 28 ] PRAYERS The following are the Prayers which have been suggested for Pub¬ lic and Private Use. They may be obtained, printed on a card, in any quantity, on application to the Secretary, Robert H. Gardiner , Post Office Box 1153, Gardiner, Maine, U.S. A. PRAYERS FOR THE PEACE AND UNITY OF THE CHURCH O LORD Jesus Christ, Who saidst unto Thine Apostles, Peace I leave with you, My peace I give unto you; Regard not our sins, but the faith of Thy Church, and grant her that peace and unity which is agreeable to Thy will, Who livest and reignest God for ever and ever. Amen. O GOD of Peace, Who through Thy Son Jesus Christ didst set forth One Faith for the salvation of mankind; Send Thy grace and heavenly blessing upon all Christian people who are striving to draw nearer to Thee, and to each other, in the unity of the Spirit and in the bond of peace. Give us penitence for our divisions, wisdom to knoAv Thy truth, courage to do Thy will, love which shall break down the barriers of pride and prejudice, and an unswerving loyalty to Thy Holy Name. Suffer us not to shrink from any endeavor, which is in accordance with Thy will^ for the peace and unity of Thy Church. Give us boldness to seek only Thy glory and the advancement of Thy Kingdom. Unite us all in Thee as Thou, O Father, with Thy Son and the Holy Spirit, art One God, world without end. Amen. O LORD Jesus Christ, look with pity, we beseech Thee, upon Thy Church weakened and hindered by differences and divisions; bless the effort to bring together in conference all who confess the faith of Thy Holy Name, Who livest and reignest with the Father and the Holy Ghost, God, for ever and ever. Amen.