Some Moral Demonstrations of the World-War PRESIDENT HENRY CHURCHILL KING Some Moral Demonstrations of the World- War A Baccalaureate Sermon Delivered at Oberlin College June 16, 1918 By President Henry Churchill King Press of the News Printing Co. Oberlin, Ohio SOME MORAL DEMONSTRATIONS ; OF THE WORLD-WAR I wish to speak of some of those inexorable lessons, which God seems intending to teach the whole human race in this war — lessons to be burned into the very consciousness of the men of this generation. I. The Critical Significance of the Times. And first of all, it is hardly possi- ble to exaggerate the critical signifi- cance of the times in which we are living. We are all far more likely to dream through this crisis, and to wake up too late to its true meaning. If Mr. Wells could say early in the war, — " This is the end and the be- ginning of an age. This is something far greater than the French Revolu- tion . . . and we live in it — that statement is ten-fold more true now than when he wrote it. For practi- cally the whole world is now engulfed in this struggle, and there is not a single people whose interests will not be vitally affected by the final set- tlement after the war. The greatness of the crisis is to be —3— seen not only in the fact that on the western front more millions of men are involved than have ever been seen on any single field of war, and in a battle on which, as Lloyd George says, "The fate of liberty through- out the world may depend; " but also in the fact that in this war the Allies confront — it is to be soberly said — probably the most threatening challenge that has ever teen Drought to Christian civilization — a threat so dire, so insiduous, so penetrating, that the very possibility of the sur- vival of democratic and Christian ideals is involved. Kipling states the case with incisive insight when he says of the German, He thought out the hell he wished to create; he built it up seriously and scientifically with his best hands and brains; he breathed into it his own spirit that it might grow with his needs; and at the hour that he judged best he let it loose on the world that till then had believed there were limits beyond which men born of women might not sin. . . . Therefore all mankind are against Germany. Therefore all mankind must be against her till she learns that no race can make its way or break its way outside the borders of humanity. —4— So great is the crisis in which the world is now involved. And the critical significance of our times is to be seen, not less, in the greatness of the opportunity now of- fered to the moral forces. When President Wilson laid before Con- gress January 8, 1918, the fourteen points of his " program of the world's peace," he was definitely attempting as a practical statesman to apply Christian principles to international relations; and he thereby, with the prestige of his far-reaching influence, gave such an opportunity to the forces which are working for the bet- terment of the world as they have never had before. For if a settlement can be reached after the war in the line of this program of President Wilson's, it will mean a great new era in human history. It will mean that gains will have been made, which would be in some true sense commen- surate with the immeasurable sacri- fices for which this war has called. The fathers and mothers of the al- lied nations cannot be, and ought not to be, satisfied with less. For if there are not to be great construct- ive gains included in the final war settlement, even a decisive military victory over the Central Powers would still be a virtual defeat of the highest aims of the Allies. No greater question, therefore, confronts forward-looking men and women in this hour than the question, whether the educational, moral, and religious forces of the race are to rise to the greatness of the present opportunity; or whether they are to leave after- the-war forecasts and planning and settlements to labor and socialist groups, on the one hand, or to the reactionary forces which want no true democracy, on the other. The greatness of the present crisis is, therefore, to be seen in the immen- sity of the opportunity opened to the moral forces of the world. The very fact that a war so terri- ble and so desolating was allowed to occur at all, also suggests the great- ness of the present crisis. What does it mean? This probably: Under the providence of God the war was to make unmistakably plain Ger- many's selfish and unscrupulous pur- poses of world-domination, before she had quite throttled Christian civili- zation. We are able to see now, how menacing was the danger which threatened the ideals of the race be- —6— fore the war. The fact was, that Germany was on the high road to a peaceful accomplishment of her con- scienceless purposes. Through her persistent and insidious propaganda, through her unscrupulous policy of " peaceful penetration," through her despicable spy system, and through her treacherous and damnable pol- icy of double citizenship, Germany was securing at a rapid pace a dom- ination, illustrated even in Prance and Italy, which can now be seen to have been most threatening. For all the highest interests of civ- ilization, it is well that she elect- ed to fight. Her greed over-reached itself; and she therein revealed her purpose of world-domination, and her true character as an enemy of all mankind. That domination the hu- man race is now forever to make im- possible. So great is the present crisis. The critical significance of the times is also revealed in the length and the unexampled extent and in- tensity of this war. The war has several times seemed near its end. Why has not the end come? Why instead has it gone on to involve the world? Under the —7— government of a righteous God what does this mean? In the first place, we may well believe that the war was not to be allowed to end, until the real nature and character of Pan- Germanism, now so completely in the saddle in the Central Powers, — the whole German purpose and ideal, — were fully laid dare, as they could not be in a few months' struggle. For that revealing, the whole story of the terrible desolation of Serbia, Bel- gium, Armenia, Russia, Russian- Armenia, and Roumania was neces- sary — written out in characters so plain that no man could fail to see them. The absolute cynicism of Ger- many's aims could not be made clear until this blackest page of her Rus- sian record was written. Twenty-five years ago, in spite of factors in her life which men could not approve, and partly misled by the German propaganda itself, thousands of men of all nations were giving Germany an admiration and an affec- tion even beyond her real desert. Men were ready to recognize in her the educational and scientific and mu- sical leader of the world. Is It a good thing for her that in this war and in the long preparation for it, —8— she has put her admirers and lovers to shame, and has done all that the most fiendish ingenuity could devise to drive out of their hearts every last bit of admiration and love? Well may one, whose lines show that he has both known and loved his Ger- many and must hope that she will return to sanity and her own best, write in Punch of "A Lost Land," A childhood land of mountain ways, Where earthy gnomes and forest fays, Kind foolish giants, gentle bears, Sport with the peasant as he fares Affrighted through the forest glades, And lead sweet wistful little maids Lost in the woods, forlorn, alone, To princely lovers and a throne. Dear haunted land of gorge and glen, Ah me! the dreams, the dreams of men! A learned land of wise old books And men with meditative looks, Who move in quaint red-gabled towns And sit in gravely-folded gowns, Divining in deep-laden speech The world's supreme arcana — each A homely god to listening Youth -9- i Eager to tear the veil of Truth; Mild votaries of book and pen — Alas, the dreams, the dreams of men! A music land, whose life is wrought In movements of melodious thought; In symphony, great wave on wave — Or fugue, elusive, swift and grave; A singing land, whose lyric rimee Float on the air like village chimes; Music and verse — the deepest part Of a whole nation's thinking heart! O land of Now, oh land of Then! Dear God! the dreams, the dreams of men! Slave nation in a land of hate, Where are the things that made you great? Child-hearted once — oh, deep de- filed, Dare you look now upon a child? Your lore — a hideous mask wherein Self-worship hides its monstrous sin: — Music and verse, divinely wed — How can these live where love is dead? O depths beneath sweet human ken, —10— God help the dreams, the dreams of men! All this required the revelation of the whole of this frightful war. Nor, under the providence of God, was the great war to be allowed to end until America could come in with unified conscience, with full realization of the meaning of the crisis, and with all her powers; as having now and forever after a rec- ognized organic share and responsi- bility in the world-life. Her tradi- tional policy of isolation was to be finally shattered, and a world-life more truly unified and Christian made possible. Nor was the war to be allowed to end until all the liberal powers and forces of the Allies were driven into a genuine cooperation; though it was to take the full weight of the great German offensive on the west to in- sure one Commander-in-Chief for the allied forces. The Allies have paid an enormous price again and again for their independent action. The world's crisis is now too great to permit anything but the closest co- operation among all the forces of righteousness and justice in the —11— earth. And we may thank God that this has now become plain. And we may be sure that another of the providential reasons for the length, extent, and intensity of this war is to be found in the fact that the Allies were to be driven to 'puri- fying their own aims; to purging out of their ambitions all merely selfish ends and all democratic inconsisten- cies. The Russian autocracy was to cease; imperialistic aims to be aban- doned; unwarranted Italian ambitions to be reduced; and the same fiery in- dignation to be manifested against racial and social wrongs within their own borders, as against such wrongs among other belligerents. As surely as the Allies are no believers in a tribal God, so surely must they cleanse their own hearts, and make sure that their aims are the just alms of a righteous God. We may be sure, too, that under the providence of God this war was allowed to engulf the world, in order that the great moral issues involved might be made clear to all men, and a significant world-decision reached, by which the whole world, rather than any small section of it, might profit. It was to be made forever —12— clear to the whole race that moral obligations are binding upon nations as well as upon individuals; that men must choose between the ideal of a true brotherhood of self-respecting and mutually-respecting nations on the one hand, and domination by an unscrupulous autocracy on the other, — an autocracy already planning for another war more terrible than this. For it has come to be clear that the war in which we are now engaged is no ordinary war of a mere clash of selfish interests of certain nations. All mankind are to be forced to choose between democracy and au- tocracy. They are to be driven to see that there is no such thing as divine rights of kings or aristocra- cies; that there are by right no priv- ileged classes through inheritance or enactment; that nobody is good enough for such domination as Ger- many seeks, and if he were good enough he would not want the domi- nation. This war, thus, men are coming to see, is an inevitable collis- ion between two absolutely contra- dictory systems, between two irrecon- cilable ideals. And the war must be finally so settled, that such a world- —13— engulfing crime as this shall not be possible again. God has intended, thus, that this generation should not repeat the fail- ure of the French Revolution, should not stop short of great constructive results, in mere negative overturn- ing. We are not to be allowed to evade, this time, the demands of a radical democracy. We are not to be allowed to heal lightly the hurt of the peoples. In fact, as Mr. Wells says, a league of nations has become "a plain necessity": It becomes more and more plain- ly a choice between the League of Free Nations and famished men looting in search of non-existent food amidst the burning ruins of our world. Now in such a war and facing a crisis like this, we may be sure that no small motives will avail to keep our nerve unshaken, our morale firm to the end — into that last quarter of an hour of which the French Pre- mier has spoken. Petty self-interest will not suffice. Hate and revenge will come far short. Rather, if in this struggle we are to endure to the end, we shall need all the undergird- ing of the deepest moral convictions —14— and of the firmest religious faith. For if a thinking man is to be a fighting man, he needs a great cause for which to fight, and such a cause, purified and glorified, the Allies have today. II. The Plasticity of the Present World Forces. Now in this crisis in the world's history, there is also being daily demonstrated before the eyes of men the plasticity of the present world forces — a plasticity that cannot long continue, and of which every advan- tage must be taken now by the forces of righteousness, if the largest re- sults are to come out of this war. As William Harbutt Dawson writes, "We are living at a time when days and weeks have the fulness and signifi- cance of years and decades." If we are blind to this, we shall sacrifice great gains for the race otherwise easily possible. My chief fear as to the outcome of this war is, that when peace comes, whether soon or late, it will come suddenly; and we shall all be so war-weary, so sick and disgusted with the whole strife and its conse- quences, so anxious to get back to —15— any kind of a patched-up peace, that we shall nervelessly let slip out of our hands perhaps the greatest sin- gle opportunity that the race has ever had for a great forward step. We may not forget that there are many forces even within the allied nations that are thoroughly reactionary, that desire no true democracy, and that want to see unjust privileges perpet- uated. Their desires will be fulfilled, unless men and women of moral con- victions and ideals are determined now, not later, by and through the war and not simply after it, to mold these plastic forces for great gains for the race. There is such a thing as winning a war and losing all its best possible fruits. As I have else- where quoted Brailsford as saying: The hope of the world is in our grasp. At the settlement of this war we may realize it. If that mo- ment escapes us, we and our chil- dren may expiate our cowardice and our indecision in an epoch which will turn to revolution as a mild alternative to war. III. The World's Need of Christian Comfort. Once more there is being brought home to the consciousness of men the heavy load of human sorrow and —16— the world's unspeakable need of Christian comfort. It is Christian- ity's greatest opportunity. For no religion can speak so deeply to the suffering souls of men. The earth has never known so many anguish- torn hearts. We have only begun to understand it here in America; but we, too, are to be baptized into the spirit of sacrifice, and to drink the cup of suffering. If we are to come through it at all with sanity and faith and hope and love, we shall need all the great motives of the Christian faith. Thousands of men at the front, and thousands of those who love them at home, are facing once again, as no academic problem but as a mat- ter of life and death, the question of immortality. Are those, who are sac- rificing their lives for the emancipa- tion of men, to have no personal share in the new age that is to come? Does death end all? And to this cry of the human heart for the immortal life, we shall have no sufficient an- swer except as we speak out of that atmosphere of the eternal which is the very air of Christ. And as certainly as men need the assurance of immortality, they need —17— even more the sure sense of living relation to a living God — a God who has vitally to do with his children, who lives and works and loves and suffers in them, and is the infinite Father ever at hand and never a God afar off. Will the Christian church greatly meet this deepest need of men? Nor can men be satisfied today, as they fight to preserve the very foun- dations of civilization, without the assurance of the increasing coming of the kingdom of God on earth. Millions of men in all the belligerent armies are fighting with the vivid hope and the grim determination that a war like this shall not occur again; that their children shall be spared the facing of such an inferno. They are determined that the great result of the war shall be the bring- ing on of a new epoch for the race, a new civilization of brotherly men. Is the church of Christ mightily to back this determination? Surely those who name themselves after the name of Christ cannot fail to put up to God the prayer They who shall give for Thee Lover and son, Show them Thy world set free, Thy battles done! —18— Lord God we lift to Thee A world in pain, Look down and let it be Made whole again! IV. A Growing Sense of the In- tangible Values. In close harmony with these con- victions of the Christian faith, is the growing sense of the intangible val- ues which this world-war is steadily disclosing. It should mean much to all believers in the ideal that more millions of men than ever before have come to see that force and ma- chinery and organization and wealth and science, even, are not enough; that a man or a nation may have all these and still have no life worth living. For something like three- fourths of the population of the world are now knit up in some fashion with the cause of the Allies, — not for ter- ritorial gains, not for commercial ag- grandisement, not for purposes of political domination, but because they have come to see as never before that all possible material gains without essential liberty do but furnish forth a barren life. It has become finally clear to them that no material gains can ever make good the heritage of free men: freedom of worship, free- —19— dom of thought, freedom of investi- gation; political, economic, social freedom; the emancipation of all the powers of men. They have awak- ened, thus, to the meaning of the in- tangible values; they have caught the vision of the things that though they be not seen are yet eternal — the everlasting values of faith, of hope, of love. Does it mean nothing to you that this war, in spite of all its evils, has brought this growing sense of intangible values? V. Unparallelled Cooperation of the Forces of Righteousness. I am no panegyrist of war, and I am bearing in mind its fearful train of evil; but one may rejoice never- theless that, under the pressure of a war like this, the peoples who are really seeking a free society of self- respecting and mutually-respecting nations, are being driven also to such far-reaching cooperation and companionship in high aims as the world has never before seen. The resources of money, of food, of ship- ping, of man-power of three-fourths of the world are pooled to establish the great aims of the Allies. What a marvelous thing it is, that we may sit here surrounded by the flags of —20— twenty-one allies! Something like a unified Council of all these peoples has been made possible — an actual and potent internationalism, a super- nationalism, indeed, that holds the one great promise for the world's fu- ture peace and progress. Coopera- tion on such a scale and for such ends may well send a thrill through any man who can think. For here is already actualized a kind of parlia- ment of man, a great world unity of the free nations, who seek the tri- umph of freedom, of justice and of peace for all the peoples of the entire world. If cooperation like this for great unselfish aims may be secured in time of war, surely we need not be without hope of the establishment of a permanent league of the nations after the war. For without such a league the very existence of civiliza- tion will be jeopardized. VI. New Faith in Common Men. In speaking to you a year ago, I asked you then to think of the new faith that had arisen in common men. The year that has intervened has only strengthened and deepened that faith. Common men of all the nations have proved themselves capable of —21— an endurance we had hardly thought possible to human flesh, and of a he- roism unsurpassed in the history of the world. Wells counts this one of the characteristic things of this war: It is the peculiarity of this war — it is the most reassuring evi- dence that a great increase in gen- eral ability and critical ability has been going on throughout the last century — that no isolated great personages have emerged. Never has there been so much abil- ity, invention, inspiration, leader- ship; but the very abundance of good qualities has prevented our focusing upon those of any one in- dividual. ... It is not that the war has failed to produce heroes so much as that it has produced he- roism in a torrent. The great man of this war is the common man. It becomes ridiculous to pick out particular names. The acts of the small men in this war dwarf all the pretensions of the great man. Imperatively these multitudinous heroes forbid the setting up of effigies. When I was a young man I imitated Swift and posed for cynicism; I will confess that now, at fifty and greatly helped by this war, I have fallen in love with mankind. And this courage of the common man is ground, as William Allen White sees, for a great new faith in democracy: —22— That Courage — that thing which the Germans thought was their special gift from Heaven, bred of military discipline, rising out of German Kultur — we know now is the commonest heritage of men. It is the divine fire burning in the soul of us that proves the case for democracy. For at base and underneath we are all equals. In crises the rich man, the poor man, the thief, the harlot, the preacher, the teacher, the laborer, the ignorant, the wise, all go to death for something that defies death, something immortal in the human spirit. Those truck driv- ers, those mule whackers, those common soldiers, that doctor, th^se college men on the ambu- lance, are brothers tonight in the democracy of courage. Upon that democracy is the hope of the race, for it bespeaks a wider and deeper kinship of men. The passionate tribute which one of our American poets has paid to the spirit of France, is typical of this new faith in the common men of all the nations. For there has been a new birth for nations, like Serbia and Belgium and France, as well as for individuals in this great war. Von Hindenburg said sneeringly of France, " France is dying," and the poet catches up this word: —23— If France is dying, she dies as day In the splendor of noon, sun- aureoled. If France is dying, then youth is gray And steel is soft and flame is cold. France cannot die! France can- not die! If France is dying, she dies as love When a mother dreams of her child-to-be. If France is dying, then God above Died with His Son upon the Tree. France cannot die! France can- not die! If France is dying, true manhood dies, Freedom and justice, all golden things. If France is dying, then life were wise To borrow of death such im- mortal wings. France cannot die! France can- not die! VII. The Prevalence of the Sacri- ficial Spirit. And once more this war has dem- onstrated afresh and on an unexam- pled scale the capacity of men for sacrifice. The massive heroism of —24— the common men of all the nations has made this fact certain. More millions of men than ever be- fore in the history of the world have thrown themselves unflinchingly into the support of a great unselfish cause, ready for whatever sacrifice that might involve. This very spirit of sacrifice has given to them all a new sense of the great values for which they fight, and a new grip upon them. Men are seeing things in bet- ter proportion; the great values are looming up as really great, and the relative goods are forced back into their relative places. So that it is the " glory of the trenches," as Con- ningsby Dawson says, that has eman- cipated men from selfishness and from the domination of petty aims and fears: There's one person I've missed since my return to New York. I've caught glimpses of him dis- appearing around corners, but he dodges. I think he's a bit ashamed to meet me. That per- son is my old civilian self. What a full-blown egoist he used to be! How full of golden plans for his own advancement! How terrified of failure, of disease, of money losses, of death — of all the tem- porary, external, non-essential —25— things that have nothing to do with the spirit! War is in itself damnable — a profligate misuse of the accumulated brainstuff of centuries. Nevertheless, there's many a man who has no love of war, who previous to the war had cramped his soul with littleness and was chased by the bayonet of duty into the blood-stained large- ness of the trenches, who has learned to say, " Thank God for this war! " He thanks God not be- cause of the carnage, but because when the winepress of new ideals was being trodden he was born in an age when he could do his share. And some such emancipation as has come to the men at the front should come in like manner to those at home, who bear them on their hearts in love and prayer and make common cause with them. How in- evitably the home life, too, must be exalted by the sacrifices of this war is voiced by Miss Rittenhouse in her poem, " I Have no Lover on the Bat- tle-field." I have no lover on the battle-field, I do not go with sickening fear at heart, And when the crier calls the latest horror I do not start. I have no lover on the battle-field, —26— I am exempt from terror of the night, I can lie down, serene and disre- garding, Until the light. But on the battle-field had I a lover, How life would purge itself of petty pain, And what would matter all the petty losses, The petty gain? I should be one with those who suffer greatly, With pain all pain above, And I should know then, beyond peradventure, The heart of Love! But the glory of the spirit of sacri- fice is not merely that it emancipates and exalts the individual who feels it, but that it is contagious and spreads from soul to soul, and so be- comes truly redemptive for other men also. Mr. J. J. Chapman has no doubt his own brilliant son in thought, who died earlier in the war, when he writes: The young men, as of old, shine as the natural heroes of the race. Their readiness to die restores our faith in human nature. It re- minds us that the sacrificial part is what counts in the spread of truth. This much we know, and —27— we know little else, about moral- ity and religion. To count the cost and dwell upon the life and property sacrificed in heroic ac- tion is to doubt the value of truth. To what better use could these young heroes and all this amassed wealth have been put? It was for this that they existed. As for the pain involved in their engulfing, as for the agony of the experience, this is a part of the regeneration. People seem to de- sire the power of Christ, and the benevolence of Christ, without the Passion. The thing can not be done; and nothing but an age of materialism could have so softened the fiber of moralists as to lead men to think it possible. The spirit of sacrifice not only in- volves, thus, the uplift of high com- panionship in the fulfilment of great aims, but its unwonted prevalence means also that more millions of men than ever before in the history of the world have found in their own sacrificial experience the key to the understanding of the deepest message of religion, of Christianity, of Christ's own death — the mes- sage of sacrifice. Men have come to see in some half-blind fashion, that they can in a true sense do what Hinton long ago pointed out — make —28— all their pains " identify themselves in meaning and end with the suffer- ing of Christ." For when one turns all his pains into a willing sacrifice to God and to men, he makes the sac- rifice itself, as one has said, "an in- strument of joy." For love rejoices in sacrifices for love's sake. Once more, then, in this sacrificial exper- ience which is sweeping over the world, God is saying to men: "Be- loved, think it not strange concern- ing the fiery trial among you, which cometh upon you to prove you, as though a strange thing happened unto you; but inasmuch as ye are partakers of Christ's sufferings, re- joice; that at the revelation of his glory also ye may rejoice with ex- ceeding joy." One does not wonder that one of the English Chaplains was able to say that the favorite hymn of the London regiments, at the great battle of the Somme, was Watts' old Good Friday hymn: When I survey the wondrous cross On which the Prince of Glory died, My richest gain I count but loss, And pour contempt on all my pride. —29— VIII. The Promise of a New Civ- ilization. But one could not keep his faith in God and the world at all, if he be- lieved that these sacrifices were to be all in vain, and were not the prom- ise and prophecy of a better age, of a new civilization of brotherly men. With steadily increasing assurance, if I read the signs aright, men of faith and vision are forecasting a new world, a great new epoch for humanity, in which the interests of the common man shall be guarded as they have never been before in the history of the world. As another has said, " I believe that historians will look back upon this epoch as the most dynamic epoch in the world; the time when the greatest social, political, industrial, and spiritual changes of men were made." We are all to be soldiers of this great change. Out of the faith, in life and death, of one such soldier of the great change were born these lines: Ye that have faith to look with fearless eyes Beyond the tragedy of a world at strife And know that out of death and night shall rise The dawn of ampler life, 30— Rejoice whatever anguish rend the heart, That God has given you a price- less dower, To live in these great times and have your part In Freedom's crowning hour. That ye may tell your sons who see the light High in the heavens — their her- itage to take — "I saw the powers of Darkness put to flight I saw the morning break." Members of the Graduating Class: You come to the end of your college course in unexampled days of world- crisis, when the world-forces are plas- tic to men's molding as never be- fore, and when men deeply need the comfort which only a great faith can give. Face to face with such a crisis, such an opportunity, such a need, you will gird yourselves about with the new convictions and hopes which have shone through the clouds of these difficult days: the growing sense of the intangible values, the unparallelled cooperation of the forces of righteousness, the new faith in common men and nations, the wide prevalence of the sacrificial spirit — the holiest thing in man — and —31— the promise of a new civilization. Be sure, with John Oxenham: The future lies With those whose eyes Are wide to the necessities, And wider still With fervent will, To all the possibilities. Times big with fate Our wills await, If we be ripe to occupy; If we be bold To seize and hold This new-born soul of liberty. And every man Not only can, But must the great occasion seize. Never again Will he attain Such wondrous opportunities. Be strong! Be true! Claim your soul's due! Let no man rob you of the prize! The goal is near, The way is clear, Who falters now shames God, and dies. " Stir into flame the gift of God which is in thee." " Take thy part in suffering hard- ship, as a good soldier of Christ Jesus." —32—