MA S TER NEGA TIVE NO. 92-80497-21 MICROFILMED 1992 COLUMBIA UiMVERSITY LIBRARIES/NEW YORK as part of the "Foundations of Western Civilization Preservation Project" Funded by the NATIONAL ENDOWMENT FOR THE HUMANITIES Reproductions may not be made without permission from Columbia University Library COPYRIGHT STATEMENT The cop)'nght law of the United States - Title 17, United States Code - concerns the making of photocopies or oth( reproductions of copyrighted material... Columbia University Library^ reserves the rieht to reftise ti accept a copy order if, in its judgement, fulfillment of the would involve violation of the copyright law. AUTHOR: DECKMAN, ALICE ANNA TITLE: STUDY OF THE IMPER SONAL PASSIVE OF... PLACE* PHILADELPHIA DA TE : 1920 Master Negative if COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY LIBRARIES PRESERVATION DEPARTMENT lV-_W>_iH-^-M.\ nTRLIOCRAFHIC MICROFORM TARGET Original Material as Filmed - Existing Bibliographic Record :i:D:NYCG92 B9950 CC:9J.24 BLT;;am CF' : pjEu..! MND:: (J :!. G G40 04 1 G :::)(:} G :l.GG 1 ••■\ t ir.: ..;;. ••••I- -J .1. .u.. I... :; enq PDi! 1920/ OR:i POL:; 219015 HHO^ I c^!r^IC PA223'5- 1 b.D4 DecKniai) ,, A J., i c«^ A study of the DCF;; I NT;; RTYP;;a CSC: c: G K^ C : F^'EPs ST:p MOD ;; BIO;; CPJ; :G DM RR;; 1 M personal F-RMs BMRn F I C ;; FBI :D COL : MS s EL s 1 ATCl' CONsb I L C ; EHL 5 ADsG2 UD : 02- I I ,1 GEM s 11-92 11-92 BBE : passive of the v en turn est type-- I hi! mi cr of arm "J Restrictions on Use: 260 3 GO 302 650 lj:)g 1 c; I J y A 1. i c. e A n i i ;^i e t: K fii a < f . P \) i 1 -^ d B 1 D I ■) i H ., 1"^ /^) „ , ^ I r: 1 9 2 - •^j.ii. \..t ! c:24 c:ni . ■f I -^ e s i <- ( F-- 1 1 „ D » ) •- 1. 1 n i v e i" s i t y o f D :i. b 1. 1 o u !'•• a f:^ h y j p . 7 .. L. a t i } "1 1. B n q 1. 1 ?^ cj t^ « RLIN 02 -11 --92 T' B r ) n f;;; y 1. v a i-) i a ., 1 9 2 « TECMNICAL MICROFORM DATA REDUCTION RATIO: FILM SIZE: 3_lil__l IMAGE PLAC'MENT: lA JIA ID IID DATE FILMED:„_ 1_^QlI INITIALS FILMED BY: kESEARCIi PUBLICATIONS. INC VVOODBRIDGE. CT \ \ VAX,^ ' f CX'^A n Association for Information and Image Management 1100 Wayne Avenue, Suite 1100 Silver Spring, Maryland 20910 301/587-8202 Centimeter 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 n 12 13 liiiiliiiiliiiiliiiiliiiiliiiiliiiiliiiil LIT iiiiliinliinliniliiiiliiiiliiiiliiiiliiiiliiiiliiiiliiiil IT I Inches iiiiiii 1.0 I.I 1.25 I I I I I I IT I I I I I I 1 I 1 2 3 u 15.0 2.8 2.5 1^ i 3.2 2.2 l^ 3A l^ 1. 10 2.0 I^ i^ u UCu 1.8 1.4 1.6 n 1 I 5 liiii 14 Lm 15 mm MflNUFflCTURED TO flllM STfiNDFIRDS BY fiPPLIED IMRGE. INC. :*-'^, UNIVERSITY OF PENNSYLVANIA A STUDY OF THE IMPERSONAL PASSIVE OF THE VENTUM EST TYPE BY ALICE ANNA DECKMAN A THESIS PRESENTED TO THE FACULTY OF THE GRADUATE SCHOOL IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY Philadelphia, Pa. 1920 UNIVERSITY OF PENNSYLVANIA A STUDY OF THE IMPERSONAL PASSIVE OF THE VENTUM EST TYPE BY ALICE ANNA DECKMAN A THESIS PRESENTED TO THE FACULTY OF THE GRADUATE SCHOOL IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY Philadelphia, Pa. 1920 Grateful acknowledgment and sincere thanks are tendered to Professors John C. Rolfe, Walton B. McDaniel, George D. Hadz- sits, Harry B. Van Deventer and Edward H. Heffner of the Latin Department of the University of Pennsylvania, and to Professor Roland G. Kent of the Department of Indo-European Philology and Sanskrit of the same University, for their helpful suggestions and criticism in the preparation of this thesis. PREFACE The following dissertation on "Impersonals of the Ventum Est type" was suggested by Professor Kent's review of Profes- sor H. E. Burton's Latin Grammar in the Classical Weekly 5. 162. Professor Kent says, "In §346 ventum est is rendered by 'some one came', but it means also, and more often, 'they (he, we) came.' " This remark has led to this study, the aim of which has been to investigate the use of the impersonal passive of the type ven- tum est, and to discover whether or not impersonals of this class have a definite agent or doer of the action logically implied in the context. The material for this thesis has been gathered from those au- thors of the republican period of whom we have works or por- tions of works preserved substantially entire: Plautus, Terence, Cato, Varro, Caesar and the other works found in the Corpus Caesarianum, Lucretius, Catullus, Sallust and Nepos. Examples (about nine hundred in number) found in Cicero and classified on page 40 have not been discussed, since they add nothing new to the investigation. The works of other authors of this time, as Livius Androni- cus, Naevius, Ennius, Lucilius, Pacuvius, etc., have not been used, because they are in a fragmentary condition and the prop- er context for such study is usually lacking. A. A. D. CONTENTS Bibliography 7 I. Definition and Classification of Impersonal Verbs 9 II. Divisions of the Ventum Est Type 14 Hi. Impersonals with Agent Unexpressed 15 1 . First Singular Definite 2. Second Singular Definite 18 3. Third Singular Definite 19 4. First Plural Definite 23 5. Second Plural Definite 25 6. Third Plural Definite 26 7. Second Singular Indefinite 33 8. Third Singular Indefinite 34 9. Third Plural Indefinite 35 IV. Impersonals with Agent Unexpressed but Defin- itely Known 37 I. Third Singular 37 II. Third Plural 37 V. Impersonals with Expressed Agent 38 VI. Summary and Conclusion 40 Appendices: I. Excursus on Caesar 43 II. Doubtful Readings 46 III. Remarks on relinquitur, etc 47 Indices: I. Index Locorum 48 II. Index Verborum 54 BIBLIOGRAPHY In addition to the various editions and translations of the Lat- in authors, the following works have been consulted : Allen, J. H. and J. B. Greenough, New Latin Grammar, New York, 1903. Bennett, C. E., Latin Grammar, Boston, revision of 1908. Bennett, C. E., Syntax of Early Latin, The Verb, Vol. I, Boston, 1910. Draeger, A., Historische Syntax der lateinischen Sprache, Leipzig, 1874. Ernout, A., Recherches sur Vemploi du pas sif latin, in Memoires de la societe de linguistique, 15.290 ff. Gildersleeve, B. L., Latin Grammar (revised by G. Lodge), third edition, New York, 1905. Hale, W. G. and C. D. Buck, Latin Grammar, Boston, 1903. Kiihner, R., Ausfuhrliche Grammatik der lateinischen Sprache, Vol. II, part I (second edition, revised by C. Stegman), Hannover, 1912. Lane, G. M., Latin Grammar for Schools and Colleges (revised by M. H. Mor- gan), New York 1903. Madvig, I. N., Latin Grammar, Oxford, 1849. Meusel, H., Lexicon Caesarianum, Vol. I, Berlin, 1887; Vol. II, Berlin, 1893. Roby, H. J., Latin Grammar for Schools, London, 1880. Zumpt, C. G., Grammar of the Latin Language, New York, 1846. CHAPTER I DEFINITION AND CLASSIFICATION OF IMPERSONAL VERBS This chapter deals with the definition and classification of the impersonals as given by grammarians. They all seem to have the same opinion with little or no variations. Zumpt §225 thus defines an impersonal verb: "The term im- personal verbs strictly applies only to those of which no other but the third person singular is used,and which do not admit a personal subject (I, thou, he), the subject being a proposition, an infinitive, or a neuter noun understood." Madvig §165 writes: "Those verbs are called impersonal which are used only in the third person singular, and have usual- ly no reference to a subject in the nominative." Allen and Greenough consider this a definition of impersonal verbs: "Many verbs from their meaning, appear only in the third person singular, the infinitive, and the gerund. These are called Impersonal Verbs, as having no personal subject." Roby §575 says, "Certain verbs in the third singular, where the fact of the action, state, or feeling is the prominent point and the doer is left indefinite, are called impersonals." Gildersleeve §208 says, " Impersonal verbs are verbs in which the agent is regularly implied in the action, the subject in the predicate, so that the person is not expressed." Lane §1034 expresses his idea of an impersonal thus: "Some verbs have no subject at all in the third person singular; these are called Impersonal.'' Roby seems to have been the only one who emphasized the fact, that an impersonal expression is used when the writer wish- es to make the act prominent and the actor secondary. This idea is very clearly brought out by a French scholar, A. Ernout in his '^ Recherches sur Vemploi du passif latin,'' in M. S. L, 15.292. In distinguishing between itur and it, eunt, Ernout says that the action is stressed in the former, the actor being obvious and left to inference, while the latter {it, eunt) gives equal promi- nence to the act and to the actor. Grammarians have classified these impersonal verbs under four headings. 9 lO A Study of the Impersonal (i) The first group contains all those verbs which express the operations of nature and the time of day; as, lucet, pluit, ton- at J vesperascit. This class of verbs is ranked as impersonal, al- though in the ultimate logical analysis, sky, earth or heaven per- sonified is understood as the subject: cf. Cic. N. D. 2.25.65, also Ar. Nub. 1279-1281. KOLieiTzi vuv ■ludTepa vo;jL(l^et<; Katv6v del t6v A (a usiv uSwp Ik^^'Zoi* , ri t6v yJXiov eXKitv KdcTcoOev TauT6 to08' uBtop iraXiv. and II. 12. 25, 26. U£ 5 apa LBuq (Juvs/lq, o . Plaut. M. G. 1 1 73 praeceptumst = praecepi; cf. volo 11 70. Plaut. Most. 314 imperatum est = imperavi; cf. volo. Plaut. Most 401 curabitur = curabo, answering the command in- tus cave muttire quemquam siveris. Plaut. Pers. 17 vivitur = vivo, answering quid agitur? which is equivalent to quid agis; cf. ut vales, ut queo I7^ Plaut. Pers. 246 taciturn erit, celabitur = tacebo, celabo, cf. tu hoc taceto. Plaut. Pers. 320 credetur = credam; cf. commodabo. 15 i6 A Study of the Impersonal Plaut. Poen. 913 dictumst = dixi, being in answer to the com- mand liaec cur a clanculum ut sint dicta. Plaut. Pseud. 273 amatur, egetur = amo, egeo, answering quid agitur^ Calidore? Plaut. Pseud. 457 statur = sto, answering quid agitur which is equivalent to quid agis. Plaut. Pseud. 687 philosophatum est = philosophatus sum; cf. diu loquor. Plaut. Rud. 776 curatumst = curavi, being an answer to the com- mand cura. Plaut. Stich. 467 sustentatumst = sustentavi, answering valuistin usque? Plaut. Stich. 509 credetur = credam; cf. experior, Plaut. Stich. 586 susientatumst = sustentavi, answering valuistin bene? Pl^ut. Trin. 578 ibitur = ibo, answering the command abi hue ad meam sororem ad Calliclem 577. Plaut. Trin. 720 sisti potest = sistere possum; cf. agam, constrin^ gamy accomodem, iubeam. Plaut. True. 667 ibitur = ibo, answering qui non extemplo < in- tro>ieris. Ter. Ad. 210 actum esse = egisse ; cf. conveniam, faxo 209. Ter. Ad. 561 factum = feci, answering produxe aibas. Ter. Ad. 631 cessatum est = cessavi; cf. exorassem, ducerem 630. Ter. Ad. g^Sfactumst = feci, answering tu illas abi et traduce Q17, Ter. Eun. 271 statur = sto; cf. quid agitur, an equivalent to quid agis. Ter. Eun. 851 factum = feci, answering aufugistin? Ter. Eun. 1066 dictumst = dixi, strengthening the threat si te in platea offendero 1064. Ter. Heaut. 862 inceptumst = incepi; cf . mi. Ter. Hec. 452 factum = feci, answering dixtin dudum illam dix- isse se expectare filium? Ter. Hec. 457 creditur = credo, being an answer to bene factum te advenisse, etc. Ter. Hec. 843 visumst = vidi, answering vide 841. Ter. Hec. 846 factum = feci, confirming te dixisse . . . Bacchidem anulum suom habere 845, 846. Ter. Phorm. 402 did potest = dicere possum; cf. mihi 401. Cato de Agr. 118 scriptum est = scripsi (the writer). A Study of the Impersonal 17 Varro L. L. 5. 109 perventum est = perveni; cf. dicam 105. Varro L. L. 5. 171 dictum est = dixi; cf. video 164. Varro L. L. 8. 21 dictum — dixi; cf. omitto 8. 19. Varro L. L. 8.21 visum est = vidi; cf. dico 22. Varro L. L. 9. 92 responsum est = respondi; cf. dixi, Varro L. L. 9. 107 dictum est = dixi (the writer). Varro L. L. 10.51 decurritur = decurro; cf. dicere. Plaut. Cure. 7 14 factum est = fecisti, answering his own question promistin te omne argentum redditurum 709-710. Plaut. Poen. 756 postulatumst = postulavisti, answering the re- mark valeant apud te quos volo 755. Plaut. Pseud. 501 dictumst = dixisti; cf. mussitabas. The ques- tion non a me scibas pistrinum in mundo tibi 500, answered by scibam, is immediately followed by quin dictumst mihi? which is answered in 502. Plaut. Pseud. 516 praedicitur = praedicis; cf. te 515. This ques- tion is asked as an answer to facito ut memineris 515. Plaut. Trin. 138 curatum = curavisti; cf. inconciliastin 136, ex- turbasti 137. Plaut. True. 369 ambulatumst = ambulavisti; cf. soles 368. Ter. Eun. 416 dictum = dixisti; cf. iugularas 417. Ter. Eun. 902 commissum erit = commiseris, answering, nonfac- iam, Pythias, 18 CHAPTER III 3. THE ACTOR DEFINITE IN THE THIRD PERSON SINGULAR This group includes all those verbs having a definite actor log- ically implied in the third person singular; as, Plaut. Pseud. 11 13 imperatumst. Harpax, after speaking of the general worthless- ness of slaves when their master is absent, adds, "ego, ut mi im- peratumst, etsi abest, hie adesse erum arbitror. I, as commanded me, although he is away, think he is here . " The sense of the passage requires a definite subject for the active verb implied in imperatumst, as is shown by erum. Plaut. Aul. 527 itur = it-, cf. ipsus 530. Plaut. Bacch. 43 emeritum sit = emeruerit; cf. haec. Plaut. Bacch. 447 itur = it; cf. magister 448. Plaut. Cure. 336 responsumst = respondit; cf. respondit 333, ab illo 336. Plaut. Men. 650 factum = fecit; cf . homo, Menaechmus. Plaut. Men. ^0% factumst = fecit; cf. hoc, hominem. Plaut. M. G. 590 actum est = egit; cf. mulier 591. Plaut. M. G. 1085 responsumst — respondit; cf. hie 1083. Plaut. M. G. 12,32 factum est = fecit; cf. mulierem 1330, also huic miserae. Plaut M. G. 1403 ventumst = venit; cf. uxorem 1402. Plaut. Most. 260 dictum = dixit; cf. Scaphae. Plaut. Most. 958 desitum est potarier = desiit potare; cf. eius 957. Plaut. Pseud. 74 scriptum est = scripsit; cf. ea 62. Plaut. Pseud. 11 13 imperatumst = imperavit; cf. erum. Plaut. Trin. 138 mandatum = mandavit; cf. qui 137. Plaut. Trin. 308 actumst = egit; cf. animus 306. Plaut. Trin. 600 imperatumst = imperavit; cf. ibit 598. Ter. Ad. 279 reddetur = reddet; cf. reddet 280. Ter. Ad. 474 ignotumst, tacitumst, creditumst = ignovit, tacuit, credidit; cf. matrem 471. Ter. Ad. 508 defunctum sit = defunctus sit; oi.fratrem 510. Ter. Heaut. 200 mansum = mansit; cf. erat 201. 19 20 A Study of the Impersonal Ter. Heaut. 568 factum = fecit. Syrus confirms the statement of Chremes. Ter. Heaut. 628 factum est = fecit, confirmation of sustulisti, Ter. Phorm. 135 persuasumst = persuasit; cf. Phormio 122. Ter. Phorm. 283 ventumst = venit; cf. potuit. Ter. Phorm. 778 siletur = silet, Ter. Phorm. 1006 factumst = /ea7; cf. c^wxi/ 1005. Cato de Agr. 144. 3 conductum erit = conduxerit; cf. redemptoris, Cato de Agr. 144. 3 locatum erit = locaverit; cf. domino. Varro L. L. 6. 72 ^o/e^/ agi = /?^/e5/ agere; cf. -25 (the person to whom the daughter is promised). Varro L. L. 6. 94 itur = it; cf. classicus 92. Varro R. R. 2. 2. 6 adnumeratum est = adnumeravit; cf. dominum. Varro R. R. 2. 4. 20 bucinatum est = bucinavit; cf. subulcus, Varro R. R. 3. 8. i. dictum est — dixit; cf. i4xiw5 7. 11. (Caes.) B. Afr. 4. 3 mandatum erat = mandaverat; cf. L. Plancus 4. I. (Caes.) B. Afr. 6. 6 discedebatur = discedebat; cf. Caesar 5. (Caes.) B. Afr. 19. 4 decertatum est = decertavit; cf. Labienus. (Caes.) B. Afr. 31. 2 accederetur = accederet; cf. /?05/e5. (Caes.) B. Afr. 50 i perveniretur = perveniret; cf. Caesari. (Caes.) B. Afr. 82. 3 pugnari = pugnare; cf. Cae- 5are. (Caes.) B. Afr. 88. 7 em/ imperatum = imperaverat; cf. Cae5ar 86. I and 86. 3. (Caes.) B. Alex. i. 5 succurri posset = succurrere posset; cf. Cae- sar 4. (Caes.) B. Alex. 9. 2 occursum est = occurrit; cf. Caesar 8. i. (Caes.) B. Alex. 14. i ventum est = z;ewi/; cf. uterque. (Caes.) B. Alex. 75. 3 confiigitur = confiigit; cf. Caesar i. Caes. B. C. I. 5. 3. decurrittir, discessum est = decurrit, discessit, cf. senatus. Caes. B. C. I. 5. 4. decernitur = decernit; cf. senatus, Caes. B. C. I. 6. 6.feratur = /era/; cf. senatus 5. Caes. B. C. 1.24.5 disceptetur = disceptet; cf. Caesar, se cum Pompeio. Caes. B.C. I. 26. 5 waw posse agi = non posse agere; cf. Lt^a. Caes. B. C. I. 37. 3 imperatum erat = imperaverat; cf. Caesar 36. 4. Caes. B. C. i. 71. i confligeretur = confligeret; cf. exercitum. A Study of the Impersonal 21 Caes. B. C. I. 80. 5 pugnatur = pugnat; cf. equitatus 80. 4. Caes. B. C. I. 84. 2 venitur = z;ewi/; cf. Afranius. Caes. B. C. I. 85. 12 dictum esset = dixisset; cf. Caesar i. Caes. B. C. 2. 22. 5 imperatum est = imperavit; cf. Caesar 6. Caes. B. C. 2. 25. 7 imperatum est = imperavit; cf. Cwrzo 6. Caes. B. C. 3. 33. i ventum esset = venisset; cf. Scipio. Caes. B. C. 3. 72. 4 esse/ offensum = offendisset; cf. posse dimicare; cf. Caesar. •Caes. B. C. 3. 93. 3 imperatum erat = imperaverat; cf. Pompei. Caes. B. G. 2. 11. 6 imperatum erat = imperaverat; cf. Caesar 2. Caes. B. G. 3. 14. i waceri />osse = < Caesarem> nocere posse; cf. Caesar. Caes. B. G. 3. 23. 2 ventum erat = venerat; cf. Crassus i. Caes. B. G. 3. 26. 2 imperatum erat = imperaverat; cf. Crassus, Caes. B. G. 4. 8. i i^tswm es/ = i^i^^/; cf. Caesar. Caes. B. G. 4. II. I constitutum erat = constituerat; cf. Caesar. Caes. B. G. 4. 28. i ventum est = z;ewi7; cf. Caesar. Caes. B. G. 4. 31. 3 navigari posset = navigare posset; cf. e/ea/. Caes. B. G. 5. 3. 3 cognitum est = cognovit; cf. aZ/er. Caes. B. G. 5. 7. 9. imperatum erat = imperaverat; cf. Caesar 6. Caes. B. G. 5. 8. 5. accesum sit = accesserit; cf . tpse 2. Caes. B. G. 5. 45. 5 cognoscitur = cognoscit; cf. Caesarem. Caes. B. G. 5. 47. 3 imperatum erat = imperaverat; cf . Caesar 46. i. Caes. B. G. 5. 48. 7 praeceptum erat = praeceperat; cf. Caesar i. Caes. B. G. 6. 30. i imperatum est = imperaverat; cf. Caesar 29. I. Caes. B. G. 6. 34. 7 noceretur = noceret; cf. Caesar 8. Caes. B. G. 6. 43. 4 ventum est = venit; (supply res). Caes. B. G. 7. 36. 7 z;ewm posset= venire posset] d. Vercingetorix 2. Caes. B. G. 7. 61. i ventum esset = venisset; cf. i/>se 60. 4 (Caes.) B. G. 8. 27. 5 praeceptum erat= praeceperat; cf. Fabius 3. (Caes.) B. H. 27. 6 ventum esset = venisset; cf. Caesar 3. (Caes.) B. H. 35. i ventum esset = venisset; cf. Caesar. Catullus 39. 2 ventum est = i^ewi/; cf. Egnatius. Catullus 39. 5 lugetur = /wge/; cf . wa/er. Sail. Cat. 45. 2 praeceptum erat = praeceperat; cf. Cieera i. Sail. Cat. 50. 5 ventum est = < consul> venit; cf. a consule. Sail. Cat. 55. 5 praeceptum erat = praeceperat; cf. cowsw^ i. Sail. Jug. 13. 8 consuleretur = consuleret; cf. senatu. 22 A Study of the Impersonal Sail. Jug. 25. I consider etur = consuleret; cf. in senatu 24. i. Sail. Jug. 29. 6 imperatum erat = imperaverat; cf. Calpurnius 4. Sail. Jug. 52. 3 praeceptum fuerat = praeceperat; cf. Metello 2, Sail. Jug. 53. I imperahatur = imperahat; cf. Rutilius 52. 5. Sail. Jug. 62. 7 iussum erat = iusserat; cf. iw&e/ 6. Sail. Jug. 75. 7 ventum — venit; cf. proficiscitur 6. Sail Jug. 91. I ventum est = venit; cf. distrihueraty curabat. Sail. Jug. 108. 2 caveri nequivisse = cavere nequi' visse; cf. Bocchus. Sail. Jug. 109. 3 praeceptum fuerat = praeceperat; cf. 5w//a I. Nep. 6. I. 2 factum est = fecit; cf. consecutus sit, Nep. 14. 8. 3 pugnatum erat = pugnaverat; cf. posuit. Nep. 15. 8. I reditum est = rediit; cf. i//e permisit. Nep. 18. 8. 4 posset perveniri = posset pervenire; cf. Antigonus, Nep. 18. 9. 5 imperatum erat — imperaverat; cf. mittity praecepit 3. Nep. 19. 4. I perventum est = pervenit; cf. valeret, portaretur. CHAPTER III 4. THE ACTOR DEFINITE IN THE FIRST PERSON PLURAL Under this heading are placed all those verbs which have an implied definite actor in the first person plural. There are two varieties of this class, the Real and the Editorial. I. Real. The Real first plural refers to definite persons, as Ter. Phorm. 135 factumst, ventumst, vincimur. Vincimur is a real first person plural active and has for its subject, Geta, who is speaking, and his master. In the same line, Terence uses factumst and ventumst, tw^o impersonals which have for the subject of their equivalent actives fecimus and venimus, the same subject as vincimur, Geta says, "factumst, ventumst, vincimur. We did , we came, we were conquered, or we did , we went < to court >, we lost < our case >." Vincimur cleaLV- ly shows that factumst and ventumst are equivalent to actives with an implied subject in the real first person plural. Plaut. Cure. 646 ventum est = venimus; cf. ea me spectatum tu- lerat per Dionysia 644. Plaut. Stich. 774 saltatum est = saltavimus; cf. aheamus. Plaut. True. 9 ventumst = venimus; cf. agamus. Ter. Ad. 302 emergi potest = emergere possumus; cf. mihi, erae- que filiaeque erili. Ter. And. iigfletur = flemus; cf. venimus 128. Ter. Heaut. 275 ventum est = venimus; cf. hie, ego 277. Ter. Heaut. 281 interventum est = intervenimus; cf. hie, ego 277. Ter. Heaut. 743 eatur = eamus; cf. sequere hac. Ter. Phorm. 135 factumst, ventumst = fecimus, venimus; cf. vin- cimur. Ter. Phorm. 640 pervenirier potuit = pervenire potuimus; cf. vo- lumus 641. Ter. Phorm. 773 possiet discedi = possimus discedere; cf. gesseri- mus 772. Varro R. R. i. 44. 3 dicetur = dicemus; cf. Licinius 3 and Agrius, Varro R. R. 2. 2. 6 agitur = agimus; cf. emptor, ille. 23 24 A Study of the Impersonal Caes. B. C. 2. 31. 4 credi = < nos> credere; cf. haheamus 5. Caes. B. G. i. 44. 8 concedi oporteret = concedere opor- teret; cf. nos. Lucr. 6. 32 occurri = < w(?5 > occurrere; cf . tendtmus 26, possemus 28. Sail. Jug. 31. 26 vindicatum = vindicaverimus; cf. vivamus. 2. Editorial. In this group have been placed those impersonals denoting what the writer thinks, knows, or says. To avoid mentioning himself exclusively, he uses an "editorial plural." This some- times means himself, as in Sail. Jug. 33. 2 diximus, which is equivalent to dixi and clearly means the writer (Sallust) only. Or the author may include others besides himself in this first plural, as in Varro L. L. 9. 54 dicimus which has for subject we grammarians or we people. Again, to vary his construction, he may substitute an impersonal, having for its equivalent active a subject in the first plural editorial, as in Sail. Jug. 96. i dictum est. That dictum est is a first plural editorial, is proved by Jug. 33. 2, 34. I, 37. 3, 38. 6, where diximus is used in the same sense. By careful comparison with the active plurals in the same para- graph, it has been felt that the six examples of Varro which fol- low, should be classed as first plural rather than first singular. The fourteen examples of Caesar which are cited, are also felt to be plurals rather than singulars because Caesar uses the first plural active much more frequently than first singular active. Evidence for this is given in Appendix i. Varro L. L. 5. 74 dictum est = diximus; cf. dicimus, videamus 5- 75. Varro L. L. 9. 54 dicitur = dicimus; cf. dicimus. Varro L. L. 9. 76 transiretur = transiremus, cf. dicimus. Varro L. L. 9. 82 perventum est = pervenimus; cf. dicimus 83. Varro L. L. 9. 98 responderi potest = respondere possumus; cf. dicamus 97. (Caes.) B. Alex. 4. i; Caes. B. C. i. 39. i, i. 48. 3, i. 56. 2, 2. 34. 1,3. 6. 2, 3. 15. I, 3. 39. I, 3. 62. I ; B. G. 4. 28. I demon- stratum est = demons travimiis. Caes. B. G. i. 16. 2, i. 49. 3, 3. 20. i, 4. 35. i dictum est = diximus, Caes. B. G. 6. 11. i perventum est = pervenimus. Sail. Jug. 96. I dictum est = diximus; cf. diximus 33. 2, 34. i, 37. 3, 38. 6. CHAFIER III 5- THE ACTOR DEFINITE IN THE SECOND PERSON PLURAL This class includes all verbs of the ventum est type, which have a definite actor logically implied in the second plural, as Plant. Bacch. 757 erit accubitum. In 753 Chrysalus says, *'Mnesiloche et tu Pistoclere, iam facite in biclinio cum amica sua uterque accubitum eatis." Then in 757 instead of repeat- ing the second plural he uses the impersonal erit accubitum which is equivalent to accubueritis as is shown not only by accubitum eatis in 755, but by exsurgatis 758. Plant. Bacch. 757 accubitum erit = accubueritis; cf. accubitum eatis 755. Plant. M. G. 737 desisti = desistere; cf. istis. Varro R. R. 2. 11. i praedictum est = praedixistis; cf. adieceritis, Caes. B. C. 2. 38. 3 auditum erat = audiveratis; supply, "you, my readers." 25 CHAPTER III 6. THE ACTOR DEFINITE IN THE THIRD PERSON PLURAL In this group are placed all those verbs (of the ventum est type) which have a definite actor logically implied in the third plural, as Plaut. Pseud. 453 itur. Pseudolus hears Callipho and Simo talking about him. He knows that punishment awaits him, so he says to himself in 453-4, ''itur ad te, Pseudole. Orationem tibi para advorsum senem. They are making towards you, Pseudolus; prepare your speech to meet the old fellow." Then advancing to meet them he says aloud in 455-6 "erum saluto pri- mum, ut aequomst, postea si quid superfit vicinos impertio. First, as is proper, I salute my master, and after that if anything is left I bestow it upon his neighbors." Itur is equivalent to eunt, which has for its implied subject Callipho and Simo. Plaut. Cas. 813 exitur - exeunt; cf. prodeant 806. Plaut. M. G. 1091 factumst = fecerunt; cf. legerunt 1090. Plaut. Poen. 835 bibitur, esiur = bibunt, edunt; cf. omnia genera 834. Plaut. Pseud. 453 itur = eunt, which has for its implied subject Callipho and Simo. Ter. And. 251 itur = eunt; cf. alunt 250. Ter. Heaut. 44 curritur = currunt: cf . scribunt, parcunt 43. Ter. Phorm. loio ventumst = venerunt; cf. fiunt. Varro L. L. 8. 39 transitum = {verba) transisse; cf. verbis. Varro R. R. 2. 6. 3 solet caveri = solent cavere; cf. emptores implied in emptionibus. (Caes.) B. Afr. 26. 3 subventum foret = subvenissent; cf. Alienum, Rabirium Postumum. (Caes.) B. Afr. 61. i dimicaretur = dimicarent; cf. exercitus in* structi. (Caes.) B. Alex. 2. 3 pugnaretur = pugnarent; cf. habebant. (Caes.) B. Alex. 2. 5 visum est = viderunt; cf. movebant. (Caes.) B. Alex. 15. 7 discessum est = discesserunt; cf. occur- rerevt 6. 26 A Study of the Impersonal 27 (Caes.) B. Alex. 16. 5 decer latum est = decertaverunt; cf. con- tender ent, viderent 3. (Caes.) B. Alex. 25. 5 ventum esset = venissent; cf. proficiscun- iur 2,- (Caes.) B. Alex. 29. 3 certaretur — certarent; cf. milites equitesque nostros. (Caes.) B. Alex. 31. i pugnabatur = pugnabant; cf. milites. (Caes.) B. Alex. 31. 2 ventum est = venerunt; cf. cohortis i. (Caes.) B. Alex. 40. i concurritur, pugnatur = concurrunt, pug- nant; cf. signo . . . ab utroque dato, (Caes.) B. Alex. 46. 3 concurritur = concurrunt; cf. ad duces. (Caes.) B. Alex. 53. i concurritur = concurrunt; cf. Berones com- plurisque evocatos. (Caes.) B. Alex. 60. 5 confligitur = confligunt; cf. legiones. (Caes.) B. Alex. 63. 3 pugnetur = pugnent; cf. cohortibus, and numero equitum et reliquorum auxiliorum i. Caes. B. C. i. 4. i resistitur = resistunt; cf. consulis, ScipioniSj Catonis. Caes. B. C. I. 26. 4 discedatur = discedant; cf. Caesar 2, Pom- peius I . Caes. B. C. i. 26. 4 discessum sit = discesserint; cf. Caesar 2, Pompeius i . Caes. B. C. i. 41. 3 dimicaretur = dimicarent; cf. Caesar ^ A f ra- mus. Caes. B. C. i. 43. 5 contenditur = contendunt; cf. Afraniani, nos- tri. Caes. B. C. i. 45. 6 pugnabatur = pugnabant; cf. constiterant, sustinebant. Caes. B. C. i. 46. i pugnatum esset — pugnavissent; cf. nostri. Caes. B. C. i. 46. 3 pugnatum est = pugnaverunt; cf. nostri; Afranianis 5. Caes. B. C. i. 47. 4 pugnatum est = pugnaverunt; cf. illi. Caes. B. C. i. 58. 2 ventum erat = venerant; cf. confugiebant. Caes. B. C. I. 67. i posse veniri = posse venire; d. cense- bant. Caes. B. C. i. 67. 2 posse exiri — posse exire; cf. sumebant. Caes. B. C. i. 69. 4 conclamatur = conclamant; cf. exeunt^ con- tendunt. Caes. B. C. i. 79. 4 adpropinquatum esset = adpropinquavissent; cf. iuberent. 28 A Study of the Impersonal A Study of the Impersonal 29 Caes. B. C. I. 80. i pugnatur, proceditur = pugnanty procedunt; cf. subsistunt. Caes. B. C. i. 86. 3 disputatum esset = disputavissent; cf. in utramque partem. Caes. B. C. i. 87. i veniatur = veniant; cf. dimittantur 86. 3. Caes. B. C. i. 87. 3 postulatum est = postulaverunt; cf. Petreius atque Afranius. Caes. B. C. 2. 9. 9 visum est = viderunt; cf. exstruxerunt, relique- runt. Caes. B. C. 2. 16. 2 noceri posse = nocere possent; cf. /^05/^5 i. Caes. B. C. 3. 6. i perventum esset = pervenissent; cf. milites. Caes. B. C. 3. 16. 4 discederetur = discederent; cf. Pompei, Cae- saris 5. Caes. B. C. 3. 16. 5 rediri posset = rehire possent; cf. missuros. Caes. B. C. 3. 19. 5 ventum esset = venissent; cf. /ega/i 4. Caes. B. C. 3. 26. 5 itum est = ierunt; cf. nacti^ introduxerunty aestimaverunt. Caes. B. C. 3. 37. 3 contenderetur = contenderent; cf. militibus. Caes. B. C. 3. 52. i pugnatum est = pugnaverunt; cf. Volcatius TulluSy legionis, cohortibus tribus, and Germani 2. Caes. B. C. 3. 52. i succurri posset = succurrere possent; cf. Caes. B. C. 3. 63. 2 dimicaretur, posset resisti = dimicarenty possent resistere; cf. nostri. Caes. B. C. 3. 67. 5 pugnatum est = pugnaverunt; cf. nostril illi, Caes. B. C. 3. 72. 3 dimicatum = dimicavisse; cL Pompeia^ nis I, nostrorum militum 2. Caes. B. C. 3. 80. 3 succurratur = succurrant; cf. Scipionem, Pompeium. Caes. B. C. 3. 86. i cognitum est = cognoverunt; cf. Caesar apud suos. Caes. B. C. 3. 86. 3 accessum sit = accesserint; ci.equitibus. Caes. B. C. 3. 87. 7 discessum est = discesserunt; cf. praecipiC' bant. Caes. B. C. 3. 109. i ageretur = agerent; cf. regum. Caes. B. C. 3. iii. 2 pugnatum est = pugnaverunt; cf. Achillas^ Caesar. Caes. B. C. 3. iii. 3 pugnabatur = pugnabant; cf. diductis copiis, Caes. B. C. 3. iii. 5 actum est = egerunt; cf. t//^', /jt. Caes. B. C. 3. iii. 5 agi debuit = agere debuerunt; cf. t7/i, /li. f Caes. B. C. 3. 112. 7 pugnatum esty discederetur = pugnaverunt, discederent; cf. neutri. Caes. B. G. i. 26. i pugnatum est = pugnaverunt; cf. nostras , Helvetii. Caes. B. G. i. 26. 2 pugnatum sit = pugnaverint; cf. nostras y HeU vetii. Caes. B. G. i. 26. 3 pugnatum est = pugnaverunt; cf. nostroSy Helvetii. Caes. B. G. i. 26. 4 pugnatum esset = pugnavissent; cf. nostri. Caes. B. G. i. 30. 5 mandatum esset = mandavissent; cf. sanxe^ runt. Caes. B. G. i. 43. 2 dictum erat = dixerant; cf. venerunt. Caes. B. G. i. 43. 4 ventum est = venerunt; cf. Caesar 2, Ariovis- tus 3. Caes. B. G. i. 52. 4 pugnatum est = pugnaverunt; cf. nostri. Caes. B. G. 2. 6. i sustentatum est = sustentaverunt; cf. Remorum. Caes. B. G. 2. 9. i contendebatur = contendebant; cf. neutri. Caes. B. G. 2. 10. I pugnatum est = pugnaverunt; cf. hastes y nostri. Caes. B. G. 2. 1 1. 4 ventum erat — venerant; cf. nostrorum militum, Caes. B. G. 2. 17. 2 cognitum est = cognoverunt; supply Caesar and his officers. Caes. B. G. 2. 20. i concurri = concurrere; cf. milites. Caes. B. G. 2. 32. 4 perspectum est = perspexerunt; supply Cae- sar and his officers. Caes. B. G. 2. 33. 2 intellectum est = intellexerunt; supply Caesar and his officers. Caes. B. G. 2. 33. 3 concur sum est = concur rerunt; cf. proximis castellis. Caes. B. G. 3. 5. i pugnaretur = pugnarent; cf. nostras. Caes. B. G. 3. 15. 4 pugnaretur = pugnarent; cf. nostriy perpaucae {naves hostium.) Caes. B. G. 3. 21. i pugnatum est = pugnaverunt; cf. SotiateSy nostri. Caes. B. G. 3. 22. 4 pugnatum esset — pugnavissent; cf. milites. Caes. B. G. 3. 24. 5 exspectari = exspectare; cf. omnium. Caes. B. G. 3. 24. 5 tVe/wr = tV^w/; cf. omnium. Caes. B. G. 4. 13. 5 dicebatur, dictum esset = dicebant, dixissent; cf. Germani 4. Caes. B. G. 5. 16. i dimicaretur = dimicarent; cf. nostras, illi 2. Caes. B. G. 5. 19. 3 discedi = discedere; cf. equitum 2. 30 A Study of the Impersonal Caes. B. G. 5. 25. 5 perventum = pervenisse; cf. legatis, quaestorihus. Caes. B. G. 5. 26. i ventum est = venerunt; cf. legatis, quaesto- ribus, legiones 25.5. Caes. B. G. 5. 31. i consurgitur = consurgunt; cf. comprehenduntf orant. Caes. B. G. 5. 31. 5 maneatur = maneant; cf. proficiscuntur. Caes. B. G. 5. 35. 5 pugnaretur — pugnarent; cf. committehant, Caes. B. G. 5. 44. 3 pugnaretur = pugnarent; cf. 5W05 omneSy and hostes 43. 6. Caes. B. G. 5. 50. 5 concur sari, agi = concur sare^ agere; cf. equites. Caes. B. G. 5. 56. i veniri = venire; cf. legationes, 55. 4. Caes. B. G. 5. 58. 3 visum est = viderunt; cf. equites 2. Caes. B. G. 6. 13. 7. interdictum est = inter dixerunt; cf. interdi- cunt 6. Caes. B. G. 6. 19. 3 compertum est = compererunt; cf. habent, in- terficiunt. Caes. B. G. 6. 37. 6 trepidatur = trepidant; d.ferantur, provident. Caes. B. G. 7. 2. 3 disceditur = discedunt; cf. ^wi. Caes. B. G. 7. 4. 2 concurritur = concurrunt; cf. 5«^*^ clientibus. Caes. B. G. 7. 15. 3 deliberatur = deliberant; cf. Gallis 4. Caes. B. G. 7. 16. 3 iretur = irew/; cf. nostris. Caes. B. G. 7. 24. 4 occurreretur = occurrerent; cf. /i(?5/e5 3. Caes. B. G. 7. 25. i pugnaretur = pugnarent; cf. hostibus, nobis. Caes. B. G. 7. 28. i veniretur = venirent; cf. t7/i 27. 3. Caes. B. G. 7. 35. 5 perventum = pervenisse; cf. C(?/>ia5, correptis cohortibus 4. Caes. B. G. 7. 49. i pugnari = pugnare; cf. Romanis 48. 4. Caes. B. G. 7. 50. i pugnaretur = pugnarent; cf. hostes, nostri. Caes. B. G. 7. 61. 3 tumultuari = tumultuare; cf. Caes. B. G. 7. 67. 2 pugnatur = pugnant; cf. equitatum, hostem, omnibus in partibus. Caes. B. G. 7. 70. 6 z;ewm = venire; cf. legiones 5. Caes. B. G. 7. 76. 5 pugnaretur - pugnarent; cf. those in the town, implied in ex oppido. Caes. B. G. 7. 80. 6 pugnaretur = pugnarent; cf. Germani, hostes, nostri. A Study of the Impersonal 31 Caes. B. G. 7. 84. 2 pugnatur, concurritur = pugnant, concurrunt, cf. 5W05 I. Caes. B. G. 7. 85. 4 laboratur = laborant; cf. GaZ/i, Romani. Caes. B. G. 7. 87. i pugnaretur = pugnarent; d. Brutum, Fabium cum aliis. (Caes.) B. G. 8. I. 2 resisti posse = resistere posse; cf. Gallis. (Caes.) B. G. 8. 7. 2 esse demigratum = demigra- visse; cf. Bellovacos i. (Caes.) B. G. 8. 10. 2 contendebatur = contendebant; cf. paucis. (Caes.) B. G. 8. 12. ^dimicari= < Remos> dimicare; cf. i^emi5 3. (Caes.) B. G. 8. 19. 3 pugnatur = pugnant; cf. pari contentions (Caes.) B. G. 8. 23. 5 ventum esset = venissent; cf. C. Volusenum Quadratum, centuriones 4. (Caes.) B. G. 8. 29. i dimicaretur = dimicarent; cf. nostri 28. 4, hostes 28.5. (Caes.) B. G. 8. 48. 2) contender etur = contenderent; cf. Volusenus, ille. (Caes.) B. H. 11. 2 pugnatum est = pugnaverunt; cf. miserunt. (Caes.) B. H. 13. 7 pugnatum est = pugnaverunt; cf. dubitarunt, essent facturi 6. (Caes.) B. H. 15. 5 pugnari coeptiim est = pugnare coeperunt; cf. nostris defendentibus iniecissent 6. (Caes.) B. H. 23. 8 pugnatum est = pugnaverunt; cf. inter quos, comminus. (Caes.) B. H. 33. 2 ventum esset = venissent; cf. coeperunt. Lucr. 2. 962 decursum siet = decucurrerint; d. animantes, im- plied from animantem 944, and possint 961. Lucr. 3. 598 trepidatur = trepidant; cf. cupiunt 599. Sal Sal Sal Sal Sal Sal Sal Sal Sal Sal Sal 1. Cat. 9. 4 vindicatum est = vindicaverunt; cf. curabant. 1. Cat. 51. 5 consultum est = consultaverunt; cf. maiores nostri, 1. Cat. 60. 2 ventum est — venerunt; cf. cohortis, hostium exer- citus. 1. Cat. 60. 3 certatur= certant; cf. veterani, illi. ^- Jug- 53- 2 ventum est = venerunt; cf. consistunt. 1. Jug. 54. 10 subveniretur = subvenirent; cf. Romanos. 1- Jug. 58. I certatur = certant; cf . Romani 57. 4. oppidani 57. 5. 1. Jug. 60. I. certabatur = certabant; cf. t7/i, ^o^/e^ 3. 1. Jug. 74. 3 certatum — certaverunt; cf. Numidae 2. 1. Jug. 76. 5 ventum erat = venerant; cf. Romani. 1. Jug. 105. I consuleretur = consulerent; cf. Bacchus, Sullam. 32 A Study of the Impersonal Sail. Jug. 107. 7 perventum est = pervenerunt; cf. intenderant. Sail. Jug. 113. 2 veniretur — venirent; cf. Bocchus, Sullam, Jugur- thae legatum. Sail. Jug. 113. 6 dictum erat = dixerant; cf. Bacchus^ Sullam^ Jugurthae legatum 2. Sail. Jug. 113. 6 invaditur = invadunt; cf. undique, ex insidiis. Nep. 1.4.5 desperari = < praetores > desperare; cf . praetores 4. Nep. 1.4.5 ciuderi .... dimicari = < praetores > audere . . dimicare; cf . praetores 4. Nep. 4. 3. 7 iudicari = iudicare; cf. putahant. Nep. 6. 3. 5 iudicatum foret = iudicavissent; cf. iudicum. Nep. 8. 3. 3 reditum erat = redierant; cf. vellent, Nep. 14. II. I conveniretur = convenirent; cf. Datamen, Mithri- dates. Nep. 15. 3. 3 disputaretur = disputarent; cf. circulum, Nep. 16. 4. I dimicatum est = dimicaverunt; cf. gwi, undique, and praesidium 3. 3. Nep. 17. 2. I dimicari = dimicare; cf. Lacedaemoniis, Nep. 18. 4. I pugnatum esset = pugnavissent; cf. copias 3. 3, Mace- dones 3. 4. Nep. 18. 7. 3 conveniretur, deliberaretur = convenirent, deliberarent; cf. omnes 2. Nep. 18. 9. 5 auditum esse = < adversarios > audivisse; cf. adver^ sarios. Nep. 20. 3. 5 decretum sit = decreverint; cf. Syracusani implied in 53'mcw5i5. Nep. 25. 2. 4 dictum esset = dixissent; cf . haberent. CHAPTER III 7. THE ACTOR INDEFINITE OR GENERAL IN THE SECOND PERSON SINGULAR This group contains all those examples which have a subject impliedly indefinite in the second f)erson singular (i. e. you = anyone). Cato in de Agr. 5. 7, giving general directions as to farming, says, "pecori et bubus diligenter substernatur. Care- fully bed your flocks and herds." Substernatur is equivalent to substernas, having as its implied subject the indefinite you, any- body. It should be remembered that the second singular, if used indefinitely, is normally in the potential subjunctive, not in the indicative; cf. Lane 1550. Plant. Poen. 533 curratur = curras; cf. bibas, edas 534. Cato de Agr. 5. 7 substernatur = substernas; cf. conficias. Cato de Agr. 14. i iussitur = iubeas; cf. locabis. Cato de Agr. 39. 2 cessetur = cesses; cf . facias. Varro L. L. 9. 108 transitum est = transieris; cf. transieris. 33 CHAPTER III 8. THE ACTOR INDEFINITE IN THE THIRD PERSON SINGULAR In this class are placed those verbs which have a third sing- ular indefinite actor implied, as in Plaut. Trin. 65 vivitiir. Me- garonides says, "edepol proinde ut bene uiuitur, diu uiuitur. In proportion as one lives a happy life, one lives a long life." Here vivitur is equivalent to vivit and has homo (meaning any one of the race of men) for its implied subject. In negative expres- sions, usually, the indefinite is singular as Caes. B. G. 2. 17. 4 "ut instar muri hae saepes munimentum praeberent quo non modo non intrari sed ne perspici quidem posset. So that these hedges presented a fortification like a wall, through which (no one) could enter nor even penetrate with the eye." The subject of posset is felt to be singular indefinite rather than plural indefinite. Plaut. Bacch. 544 ne invideatur = ne invideat; cf. nullus 543. Plaut. M. G. 758 adpositumst = adposuit; cf. iube^ tolle 759. Plaut. Trin. 65 vivitur, vivitur = vivit, vivit. Ter. And. 501 renuntiatumst = renuntiavit. Varro L. L. 6. 72 neque agi potest = neque agere potest. Varro L. L. 8. 31 discessum est = discessit; cf. si quis putat. Caes. B. G. i. 31. 2 enuntiatum esset = enuntia- visset. Caes. B. G. 2. 17. 4 non intrari, sed ne perspici quidem posset = non intrare, sed ne perspicere quidem posset. Caes. B. G. 3. 3. 2 neque veniri = neque venire < posset. > Caes. B. G. 7. 9. 5 nuntiari posset = nuntiare pos- set. Nep. 18. 9. 4 praenuntiatum esse = praenuntiavisse, 34 CHAPTER III 9. THE ACTOR INDEFINITE IN THE THIRD PERSON PLURAL In this class are placed those verbs which have an indefinite actor logically implied in the third plural; as Plaut. Amph. 942 reventum est. Jupiter says in lines 938-42 ''nam in hominum aetate multa eveniunt huius modi; capiunt voluptates, capiunt rusum miserias; irae interveniunt, redeunt rusum in gratiam, verum irae si quae forte eveniunt huius modi inter eos, rusum si reventum in gratiam est, etc. For in the life of mortals many things of this nature happen; now they take their pleasures, again they meet with hardships. Quarrels intervene, again they (mortals) become friends. But if, by chance, any quarrels of this nature happen between them, then if they have become friends again, etc." Reventum est is equi- valent to revenerunt which has for its implied indefinite subject homines, as is shown by hominum. Plaut. Amph. 942 reventum est = revenerunt; cf. hominum 938. Plaut. Cure. 679 argentariis male credi qui aiunt = < homines > argentariis male credere qui aiunt. Credi is equivalent to credere which has for its implied subject men or people. "Those who say it is bad that < people > trust bankers," etc. Plaut. Cure. 680 credi dico = < homines > credere dico; credi is equivalent to credere, which has a third plural indefinite subject men implied. "I say it is both good and bad to trust < bankers >" is the meaning of nam et bene et male credi dico. Plaut. Most. 235 estur, hibitur = < homines > edunt, bibunt; cf. neque quisquam parsimoniam adhibei 236, showing that more than one person is doing the eating and drinking. Plaut. Rud. 271 veniri solet = < homines > venire solent. Plaut. True. 746 invidetur = < homines > invident; cf. invident. Ter. Eun. 348 conclamatumst = < homines > conclamaverunt. Ter. Heaut. 154 vivitur = < homines > vivunt. 35 36 A Study of the Impersonal Ter. Hec. 315 trepidari, cur sari = < homines > trepidare, cursare, Varro L. L. 5. 47 itur = eunt. Varro L. L. 6. 16 sacrificatur = < homines > sacrificant. Varro L. L. 6. 24 exitur — < homines > exeunt. Varro L. L. 6. 25 sacrificatur = < homines > sacrificant, Varro L. L. 6. 34 parentetur = parentent. Varro L. L. 7. 32 dubitatur = < homines > dubitant. Varro L. L. 8. 14 dicitur = dicunt. Varro L. L. 10. 80 erratur = errant, Varro R. R. i. 2. 4 posse navigari = < homines > posse navigare. Varro R. R. i. 16. 6 navigari, evehi, invehi possit = < homines > navigare, evehere, invehere possent. Varro R. R. 3. i. 2 did possit = < homines > dicere possint. Caes. B. C. i. 6^.2 conclamatumesset = conclamavis- sent, Caes. B. C. 3. 96. 4 dicebatur = dicebant, Caes. B. G. 7. 36. 2 despici poterat = despicere po- terant. (Caes.) B. G. 8. 7. 7 diceretur = < homines > dicerent. Lucr. 5. 18 wow poterat vivi = non poterant vivere; cf. mor tales 15. Sail. Cat. 2. 8 siletur = < homines > silent. Sail. Jug. 5. I i/ww 65/ = < homines > ierunt. Nep. 6. 4. I perlatum esse = < homines > pertulisse, Nep. 10. 9. 5 dictum est = < homines > dixerunt, Nep. 10. 10.2 factum est = fecerunt, Nep. 25. 14. I cenatum est = cenaverunt; cf. convivae. CHAPTER IV THE AGENT NOT EXPRESSED BUT UNDERSTOOD FROM THE VERB In this group are placed those impersonals whose subjects are neither expressed nor implied in the context, yet are known be- cause the verb itself immediately calls up the person or persons upon whom this duty devolves; as CatodeAgr. 150. i interkalatum erit is equivalent to inter kalaverint. It was the duty of the pontifices to regulate the calendar. In Caes. B. C. I.I.I referretur = < consul > referret. To refer matters to the senate was the consul's business. This group has been divided into two classes: the first contains those verbs which have a singular subject implied for their active equivalent, the second class includes those verbs which have a plural subject implied. These active verbs, whether singular or plural, have their im- plied subjects in the third person. I. Third Singular. Caes. B. C. i. i. i. referretur — referret. Caes. B. C. i. 2. 2. non oportere referri — non oportere referre. Caes. B. C. i. 2. 7 refertur = < consul > refert, Caes. B. C. i. 6. 3 refertur, refertur = < consul > refert, refert. Sail. Cat. 48. 5 referatur = referat. Sail. Cat. 51. 21 animadvorteretur = < praetor > animadvorteret. Sail. Jug. 28. 3 nuntiari iubet = nuntiare iubet, II. Third Plural. Cato de Agr. 150. i interkalatum erit = < pontifices > interka- laverint. Varro L. L. 6. 13 inter calatur = < pontifices > intercalant, (Caes.) B. Afr. 40. 5 cani iussisset= iussisset canere; cf. comment on B. G. 7. 47. i below. Caes. B. C. 3. 75. 2 conclamari = < the proper officials > conclam- are. Caes. B. G. 7. 47. i cani = iussit (cornicines tubicinesque) canere. Cani in B. Afr. 40. 5 and here may mean that Caesar ordered < the instruments > to be sounded. In that case cani would not belong in this group, since there is an implied subject of the pass- ive, but would be an ordinary passive; as in B. C. 3.82. i classi- cumque apud eum cani . . . iubet. 37 CHAPTER V IMPERSONALS WITH EXPRESSED AGENT This class of verbs, which is here called "Impersonal with Expressed Agent, " includes those verbs which have their log- ical subject expressed by the ablative, or dative of agent, or otherwise. This construction is used to make the action prom- inent, while the actor is secondary, but not left to inference. Plaut. Amph. 219 utrimque exitum est; utrimque = ab utrisque and is an expressed agent. Plaut. Bacch. 295 factum a vobis. Plaut. Cas. 394 a me factum. Plaut. M. G. 561 a me factum esse. Plaut. Poen. 805 factum a vobis. Ter. Ad. 662 factum a vobis. Ter. Heaut. 158 peccatum a me est. Ter. Heaut. 249 factum a nobis est. Ter. Hec. 624 abs te est factum. Ter. Phorm. looi factumst abs te. (Caes.) B. Afr. 18. 4 ab hostibus pugnaretur nee comminus ad manus rediretur. (Caes.) B. Alex. 19. 6 pugnabatur a nobis. (Caes.) B. Alex. 39. 2 utrimque processum est; utrimque = ab utroque. (Caes.) B. Alex. 62. 3 pugnatur utrimque; utrimque = ab utroque, Caes. B. C. i. 26. i utrimque pugnabatur; utrimque = ab utrisque, Caes. B. C. i. 57. 3 pugnatum est utrimque; utrimque = ab utris* que. Caes. B. C. i. 67. i disputatur a Petreio atque Afranio. Caes. B. C. 3. 14. i erat praeceptum a Caesar e. Caes. B. C. 3. 93. i concurri a Pompeianis. Caes. B. C. 3. 93. i erat praecepttim a Caesar e. Caes. B. C. 3. 100. i factum a Libone. Caes. B. G. I. 22. 3 erat praeceptum a Caesare. Caes. B. G. I. 50. 3 utrimque pugnatum est; utrimque = ab utro^ que. Caes. B. G. 2. 33. 4 pugnatum ab hostibus est. 38 A Study of the Impersonal 39 Caes. B. G. 2. 33. 4 a viris fortibus pugnari debuit. Caes. B. G. 3. 18. 6 ab iis erat provisum. Caes. B. G. 3. 25. I a& hostibus pugnaretur. Caes. B. G. 4. 23. 2 a quibus administratum esset. Caes. B. G. 4. 26. i pugnatum est ab utrisque. Caes. B. G. 5. 6. i ab nobis dictum est. Caes. B. G. 5. 30. i a Cotta primisque ordinibus resisteretur, Caes. B. G. 5. 40. 3 a6 nostris resistitur. Caes. B. G. 7. 16. 3 a& nostris occurrebatur . Caes. B. G. 7. 47. 2 erat a Caesare praeceptum. Caes. B. G. 7. 70. I a& utrisque contenditur, Lucr. 5. 1 1 49 concessumst legibus acquis. Lucr. 6. 377 turbatur utrimque; utrimque = ab utrisque. Sal Sal Sal Sal Sal Sal • Jug. 53- 2 utrimque concurritur; utrimque = ab utrisque. . Jug. 67. 2 neque a fortissumis resisti posse. .Jug. 102. 4 a Manlio concessum. . Jug. 107. I a paucis strenuis pugnatum. . Jug. 112. 3 ab omnibus veniretur. . Jug. 114. I ab ducibus nostris pugnatum, Nep. 2. 10. 4 apud plerosque scriptum est. Nep. 2. 10. 5 legibus non concederetur. CHAPTER VI SUMMARY AND CONCLUSION Unexpressed Personals with Agent Plaut. Ter. Cato Varro Caes. Pseu- do Caes. Lucr. Cat. Sail. Nep. Cic. I. First Singular Definite 31 13 I 7 54 2. Second Singu- lar Definite. . 9 2 29 3. Third Singular Definite 17 12 2 5 37 14 2 13 6 177 4. First Plural Real 3 9 2 2 I I 87 5. First Plural Editorial S 14 I I 45 6. Second Plural Definite 2 I I 8 7. Third Plural Definite S 3 2 103 29 2 IS IS 180 8. Second Singu- lar Indefinite I 3 I 2 9. Third Singular Indefinite. . . 4 I 2 5 I 103 10. Third Plural Indefinite. . . 7 4 13 3 I I 2 4 113 II. Agent not ex- pressed but definitely un- derstood — a. Third Singular S 3 19 b. Third Plural... I I 2 I 13 Total 79 983 44 280 7 109 39 387 172 340 46 158 4 227 2 116 35 121 26 124 838 Pages of text exam- ined (reckoned ap- proximately with Teubner page as unit) 4633 Number of Teubner pages per imper- sonal verb of this tvoe 12.4 5 6.3 5 IS. 5 9.9 1.9 21 3.4 S S6.7 2 58 3-4 6 4.7 2 5.5 Impersonal with Agent Expressed 80 40 A Study of the Impersonal 41 Definite Sg. Plu. Plautus 57 10 Terence 27 12 Cato 3 I Varro 12 11 Caesar .42 122 Pseudo-Caesar 14 31 Lucretius o 3 Catullus 2 o Sallust 16 17 Nepos 6 15 Total 179 222 Indefinite Sg. Plu. 5 7 I 3 3 5 o o o o I 18 4 o 13 3 I I o 2 4 35 In examples found in the works of authors other than histo- rians (Caesar, Sallust, Nepos and Lucretius) the singular definite is used more frequently than the plural definite. In the histo- rians the plural definite is used more often. The singular indefinite is used on an average less than the plu- ral indefinite, the ratio being about i : 2. The definite meaning occurs more frequently than the indef- inite, the ratio being about 15: 2. Plautus, out of 79 examples, uses 31 which require a logically implied subject in first singular definite, because he uses dialogue requiring a first singular definite subject. This impersonal con- struction relieves the monotony of a too oft recurring first per- son definite. Terence, for the same reason, uses for the most part an im- personal requiring a logically implied subject in first and third singular definite. Cato, giving directions as to farming, makes very little use of this impersonal construction. Of the seven examples taken from his works three are equivalent to a personal construction having a second singular indefinite subject. One-third of the examples gathered from Varro require a sub- ject in the third plural indefinite because Varro treats of gram- mar and of affairs pertaining to agriculture and does it in gen- eral or indefinite terms. He uses this impersonal passive for the sake of variety. Caesar and Sallust write of war; consequently the greater num- ber of their impersonal verbs need subjects logically implied in 42 A Study of the Impersonal the third person singular and the third plural definite. To avoid the too frequent use of a personal subject they make use of this impersonal construction. Nepos in his "Lives" is very fond of this impersonal passive, having for its active a logically implied subject in the third plu- ral definite. The lyric poet Catullus and Lucretius in his philosophical poem make very scanty use of this impersonal passive. The comic writers Plautus and Terence, however, use it very frequent- ly. In conclusion it can be said: ( I ) . Writers of the republican period do not use the impersonal passive of the ventum est type so frequently as the imperial au- thors. The writers of the empire continued to make use of this coBiDicijoi I \i $01 jii isdi mo ip 113 IE tiiilr €HCi-§'. 1 11^ ii-G cou4;iunGC| ^o ujrg^jcG nee o^ -FJJis DsggiAG o{ ipe jisjsiM u\ |AD6 go iLGdncuiiA 5g ipG wkm\ m- ( ' ) ' NiH^^^^ ^i ^H^ i.ebnpjicgu bekioq qo uo^ nee 4:pe iuJbGi.eou^j lu couqnsiou n c^u pe ggiq: 1>^- coiJJic /Auj^GL2 j,ign4:n8 guq xglgucg* po/agagl* hsg ip aglX ^LGdnGu^:- boGUj m^G aglA gcsufA nsG oj ^pis imbGLSou^i b^ggjAG* j^pG j^fJG jXlic bo€|: c^^njing suq pncLGqns lu pi8 bpii08objJicq IS] qcpuifG* p^AiuS (OL i;8 srcqAG 3 jo§ic^j]A imb|iGq snplGC^ lu ^pc ^piiq b\n' I4Gb08 lU pi8 „n^G8^^ 18 AGLX ^OUq 0^ ^pi8 lUjbGLSGUgj b^88IAG' ^pi8 IUjbGL80U^J COU8;LncqOU* fpG po jLGdnGui: nsG o[ g bcLsouq 8nplGC|: ^pcX ixjhjcg nsG 0{ ^pG ^piiq bGi8ou 8iugn|^L guq ^pG ^paq bjnL^j qGyui^G* j^o ^AOiq ^5 \j 2^^^ ^\ ^\^^ \^\>^uowa\ APPENDIX I EXCURSUS ON CAESAR A table follows, showing how often Caesar and pseudo-Caesar make use of a first singular, a first plural, and an impersonal con- struction of verbs of saying, thinking, believing, naming, show- ing etc. FIRST PLURAL Caesar pseudo-Caesar confidamus B. C. 2.4.4 consuevimus B. G. 5.1.2 imijiiiiiii C 1 1* ' consuevitmis B. Ci. 5.1.2 1: DO (I) (I) (•) (I) CD ( » audiehamus B. Alex. 74.3 (i) demonstravimus B. Afr. 24.1, 34.1, D II 8 D ii dstrtoft.sifa.vittt^'u.s B. A.fr-. ^4- 34-1. «^^»* credit, cf. French on, German man, or a third plural may be its implied indefinite subject, as homines credunt; or it may have a word for money as its subject, for such a word is the subject of perit. The last interpretation seems the best. 47 INDEX LOCORUM CAESAR B. Afr. 4-3 mandatum erat 20 B. C. 1-5 4 decernitur 20 6.6 discedebatur 20 it 1.6.3 refertur, refertur 37 18.4 pugnaretur, redire - 11 1.6.6 feratur 20 tur 38 41 1.24.5 disceptetur 20 19.4 decertatum est 20 II 1.26. I pugnabatur 38 26.3 subventum foret 26 (1 1.26.4 discedatur, disces. ■ 31.2 accederetur 20 sum sit 27 405 cani 37 II 1.26.5 agi 20 50.1 perveniretur 20 41 1.37.3 imperatum erat 20 61. 1 dimicaretur 26 44 1.39 I demonstratum est 24 82.3 pugnari 20 44 I. 41. 3 dimicaretur 27 88.7 imperatum erat 20 41 1.43.5 contenditur 27 B. Alex. 1-5 succurri 20 II 1.45-6 pugnabatur 27 2.3 pugnaretur 26 44 I . 46 . I pugnatum esset 27 2.5 visum est 26 41 1.46.3 pugnatum est 27 4.1 demonstratum est 24 41 1.47.4 pugnatum est 27 9.2 occursum est 20 44 1.48.3 demonstratum est 24 14. 1 ventum est 20 44 1.56.2 demonstratum est 24 15 7 discessum est 26 41 1.57.3 pugnatum est 38 16.5 decertatum est 27 II 1.58.2 ventum erat 27 19.6 pugnabatur 38 II I . 67 . I veniri, disputatur27,38 255 ventum esset 27 41 I . 67 . 2 exiri, conclamatum 293 certaretur 27 esset 27 .36 31 I pugnabatur 27 II 1.69.4 conclamatur 27 31.2 ventum est 27 II 1. 71. 1 confligeretur 20 39 2 processum est 38 11 1.79 4 adpropinquatum 40.1 concurritur, pug- esset 27 natur 27 II 1.80. I pugnatur, proce- 46.3 concurritur 27 ditur 38 53- 1 concurritur 27 44 1.80.5 pugnatur 21 60.5 confligitur 27 II 1.84.2 venitur 21 62.3 pugnatur 27 II I. 85. 12 dictum esset 21 63.3 pugnetur 27 II 1.86.3 disputatum esset 28 75-3 confligitur 20 II 1.87. I veniatur 28 B.C. I.I.I referretur 37 11 1.87.3 postulatum est 28 1.2.2 referri 37 II 2.9.9 visum est 28 1.2.7 refertur 37 44 2.16.2 noceri 28 1.4. 1 resistitur 27 II 2.22.5 imperatum est 21 1-5.3 decurritur, disces- II 2.25.7 imperatum est 21 sum est 20 44 2.31.4 credi 24 48 A Study of the Impersonal 49 B.C. 2.34 I 2.38.3 3.6.1 3.6.2 3. 14. I 15 I 16.4 16.5 19 5 26.5 33.1 37.3 39 I 52.1 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 62.1 63.2 675 72.3 72.4 75-2 75-4 80.3 853 86.1 86.3 87.7 93 I demonstratum est 24 auditum erat 25 f)erventum esset 28 demonstratum est 24 praeceptum erat 38 demonstratum est 24 discederetur 28 rediri 28 ventum esset 28 itum est 28 ventum esset 21 co.^tenderetur 28 demonstratum est 24 pugnatum est, suc- curri 28 demonstratum est 24 dimicaretur, resisti 28 pugnatum est dimicatum offensum esset conclamari ventum esset succurratur dimicari cognitum est accessum sit discessum est concurri, praecep- B.G. B.C. 14 44 II II 44 44 41 14 14 93 3 96.4 3.100.1 3. 109. I 3. Ill 2 3-111 3 3. III. 5 3112. 7 I. 16. 2 1.22.3 1.26. I 1.26.2 26.3 26.4 30.5 31.2 1.43.2 1.43 4 tum erat imperatum erat dicebatur factum ageretur pugnatum est pugnabatur actum est, agi pugnatum est, dis- cederetur dictum est praeceptum erat pugnatum est pugnatum sit pugnatum est pugnatum esset mandatum esset enuntiatum esset dictum erat ventum est 28 28 21 37 21 28 21 28 28 28 38 21 36 38 28 28 28 28 29 24 38 29 29 29 29 29 34 29 29 II 41 44 41 41 41 44 l< l( It II l< << II II II II 44 44 14 41 II 44 14 14 44 44 44 44 41 II 14 14 44 44 4< 14 14 44 II II II 41 1 . 44 . 8 concedi 24 1 . 49 . 3 dictum est 24 1.50 3 pugnatum est 38 1 . 52 . 4 pugnatum est 29 2.6.1 sustentatum est 29 2.9.1 contendebatur 29 2 . 10. 1 pugnatum est 29 2 . II . 4 ventum erat 29 2 . 1 1 . 6 imperatum erat 2 1 2.17.2 cognitum est 29 2.17.4 intrari, perspici 34 2 . 20 . 1 concurri 29 2.32.4 perspectum est 29 2.33.2 intellect um est 29 2 . 33 . 3 concursum est 29 2.33.4 pugnari, pugna- tum est 38, 39 3.3.2 veniri 34 3.5.1 pugnaretur 29 3. 14. 1 noceri 21 3.15.4 pugnaretur 29 3.18.6 pro visum erat 39 3.20.1 dictum est 24 3 . 2 1 . 1 pugnatum est 29 3 . 22 . 4 pugnatum esset 29 3 . 23 . 2 ventum erat 2 1 3.24.5 exspectari, iretur. 29 3.25.1 pugnaretur 39 3.26.2 imperatum erat 21 4.8.1 visum est 2 1 4 . 1 1 . 1 constitutum erat 2 1 4.13.5 dicebatur, dictum esset 29 23 . 2 administratum es- set 39 26.1 pugnatum est 39 28 . 1 ventum est, dem- onstratum est 21, 24 31.3 navigari 2 1 35 . 1 dictum est 24 5-3.3 cognitum est 21 5.6.1 dictum est 39 5.7.9 imperatum erat 2 1 5.8.5 accessum sit 2 1 5 . 16 . 1 dimicaretur 29 5.19.3 discedi 29 5 • 25 . 5 perventum 30 5.26.1 ventum est 30 50 A Study of the Impersonal . G. 5-30.1 resisteretur 39 B. G. 8.7-7 diceretur 36