lEx IGtbriB SEYMOUR DURST H'hen you leave, please leave this book Because ii has been said "Ever thing comes t' him who waits 8:xcept a loaned book." Avery Architectural and Fine Arts Library Gift of Seymour B. Durst Old York Library Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2013 http://archive.org/details/lectureonhistoryOOtyse LECTURE ON THE HISTORY OF STATEN ISLAND; DELIVERED BEFORE BY RAYMOND M, TYSEN, ESQ. TUESDAY APRII. 12tli, 1842. PUBLISHED BY REaUEST OF THE DIRECTORS. STATEN ISLAND: P. L. HAGADORN, PRINTER. 1843. 4 to mo than to Bketcb, as well as I am able, the principal occurrences upon our Island bince its diflcovr'ry. Three hundred arjil lifiy years u;;o, this con- tinent was ii)l)al)il<(), as you will know, by a numerous ra( (! who bad never seen a while aiun. They weredividi'd into nations or tribes, under the government of their chiefs, men who obtain- ed their rank and power by fi-ats in war; and their laws and histories were handed down by tradition. The people who possessed this por- tion of the country, were the Lei»ni-Lenapc, af- terwards called the Delawares, a warlike and powerful nation, who lived many years before, in the Werit ; but allured hither by the accounts of these dcli(;htful regions, they attacked the Al- ligcwi who dwelled here, and having overcome them in a great battle, expelled them from tho country, and established themselves between the Potomac atid Hudson rivers. There were several branches of the Delaware nation, one of which occupied Staten Island. Manhattan Island, nnd the lantl on tho east side of the Hudson. (I) This was the Mahiccan or Manhattan tri!>c. ('J) It was distinguished as the niost fierce and war- like member of the Delaware family; ani in- deed that portion of It which dwelh-ri upon this Island appear to have conquered and held parts of the surrounding country, for the land upon which Elizabe'.h-Town now stands, was pur- chased of their chiefs. (3) While they lived the careless, and apparently happy lives of savages, spending most of their time in warring with tljoir neigtibors, and sub- sisting chiefly upon the fruits of the chase, or the spontaneous [iroductions of the earth, some of tl)e.Ti who were fishing upon the coast, observ- ed a strange sight; and a number were soon gathered together, to gaze at a remarkable ob- ject, such as had never before been seen, float- ing upon the water, and nearing the land. Va- rious were the conjectures as to its nature; some supposing it an immense fish, others a large house. As its appearance wsr4 alarming, run- ners were immediately sent off in every direc- tion with the new's, and these shores are soon covered with a multitude of warrior?. As it continues to approach, they imagine that it must he a house or canoe, containing the Manitto or Supreme Being, who was come to make them a visit. The chiefs are assembled, the conjurers and wise men are consulted, and a sacrifice is pre- pared to appease the Manilfo. As it comes near the^ see that it is filled with beings of a different colo\>Tfrom themselves, dressed in a strange man- ner ; and one who is clothed in red, they HUp- posc to be the Manitto. But now the hout*f stops ; and a smaller canoe leaver it, containing the red man, and some others. When these reach the shore, they greatly admire the dress of the Manitto, but ihey wonder why he should have a white skin. He now approaches, en- ters the circle they have formed, and salutes them in a friendly manner; and wiien ihey have re- turned his salute, one of his servants brings for- ward a large gourd or vessel, pours from it a li- quid into a smaller one, and gives it to the Ma- nitto, who drinks it. lie then has the cup filled again, and hands it to the nearest chief, who takes it, smells it, and passes it to the next, who does the same; and so it goes round the circle, none having the courage to taste it. At length a great warrior addresses the assembly ; tells them that it was given ihem to drink, that to re- turn it untouched might offend the Manitto, and cause their destruction; and that as it is better for one man to die, than for a whole na- tiofj to be destroyed, he himself will drink it. — Then, like Curtius, he dcvotes'himself for his country, bids them adieu, and swallows the draught. All eyes are now upon him; he stag- gers and falls; but while they are lamenting his death, they discover that he breaihes, and after a little time he ribes, declares he was never so liappy before, and wishes to repeat the experi- ment. Curious to experience his sensations, they join in his request, and a general intoxica- tion ensues. The placil was ever afterwards called by the Indians Mannahattinink — tho place of intoxication. (4) This is the traditionary account of the visit of the Europeans to these shores, and of the first introduction among the Indians of their deadli- est cneniy, the destroyer alcohol. The scene just described is supposed by some to have oc- curred upon the shores of Slaten Island or Long Island in 1521, when they say John de Verrazano, a Florentine in the service of the King of France, discovered and vjsited this port. This conjec- ture arose from a description in his narrative of his voyage, which closely applies to the narrows and bay. He says " after proceeding one hun- dred leagues, we found a very pleasant situation among some steep hills, through which a very large river, deep at its mouth, forced its way in- to the sea; from the sea to the eastuaray of the river any ship heavily laden might pass with the help of the tide, which rises eight feet. But as we were riding at anchor in a good berth we would not venture up without a knowledge of 5. the mouth ; therefore wo took the boat and en- tering the river, we found the country on its banks well peopled, the inhabitants not differing much from the others, being dressed out with the feathers of birds of various colours. They came towards us with evident delight, raising loud shouts of admiration, and showing us vvhere we could most securely land with our boat. We passed up this river about half a league, when we found it formed a beautiful lake, three leagues in circuit, upon which they were rowing thirty or more of their small boats, from one shore to the other, tilled with multitudes who came to see us. All of a sudden, as is wont to happen to nuviga- tors a violent contrary wind blew in from the sea, and forced us to return to our ship, greatly regretting to leave this region, which seemed so commodious and delightful." Others, particu- larly the Dutch writers, have contended that Hudson was the first who discovered the river which bears his name. Nor ^have the claims to that honor been confined to these two. It has been imagined that the Northmen who sailed to the Northern part of America, in the middle of the eleventh century, pushed their discoveries at least as fir as this Island, and that these regions were included in iheir famous Vinlnnd; while it is asserted, with some probability, that the Span- iards at least saw the river, and named it "the River of the Mountains." Henry Hudson, however is generally consid- ered to have been the fir:-': European whu visited these shores. He sailed from Holland, in t!ie employment of the East India Company, in 1601^, and on the 3d of September of that year, entered this harbour, and anchored within the Santly Hook. As he explored the neighborhood, he was delighted with the pleasant aspect of the country ; with its noble trees, its fine scenery, and its fragrant air ; and " the land" he says " is the finest for cultivation, that I ever in my life set foot upon." Having been kindly treated by the Indians except on one occasion, when his boat was attacked by the fierce Mahiccans, and in the flight, one man shot with an arrow, and killed, and having proceeded up the North Riv- er nearly as far as Albany, he returned to Hol- land with the news of his discovery. To Hudson our Island owes the name it yet retains. Its Indian name was Aquehonga — Manacknong ; (5) which signifies in English, the place of bad woods. This is properly th. signification of the latter part of the term, Man- acknong ; the former has no necessary connex- ion with it ; it means— i[l i BB ri iHt J i|i M yi|wrrr v mIiim Ii . li mit . i. I -|i h. 'i i U ' l l .IIIH I i I U in l li i u lii iii i n y for lu r huMjiry ciiildri'i). FuriiJiiatcly, lln; n« xt • lay iifhT lliis mTurrrrtcc, tlioy were gladilcnrd hy IIh; hi^hi «ifa sliip vvliii h brou^jhl llu'iii relief. (8) This was the whip of llie co:iii»'my, whirl), at: I have |i»'fore ft iled, arrived here lit lG2'.i. R.ipel- ju Huuii atlt rwards reuiuvcd to the Wal Cocht, and becnme fmiiou!' as the fatljer of the first \\ Iiile child horn in the New Nolheihndri 1 ('.)) No further atteiiipl was made, for j't.iiic liino, (ocoloiiize SiaU'ri Island. In it was pur- chased from Ilje Indians l»y Miihaol Pauw.one of Ihe Patroofis (10) lie owned also the Imtl on the West si io t)f (lie h.iy, and o|i|ioHite the foil, where Jersey City no.v s'anils, and culled Ihe whole P.ivonia.t Dul he apjiears from some rau:?c Io have nenlccteil his lands, and they at length hecaiiie the properly of the company. — Thif? Island was llien yranted to David Pieter- BZ'-n Du Vrie.H, one of the Patromis vvlio liad come over some years he fore wiih Godyn, V;:ii ReUfeselner, and olhcrJ*. De Vries arrived lieru from Holland, hringinj^ a niitnlter of coli^nistr in lGo8, aJul in January of the nexl year, he cmii- meneed Iiis seltlejicnt. Dul his colony u;rt with a iiielanehnly fate, causi'd by liie short sighted policy pursued with respect to the na- tives. De Vries himself treated them wi>n the sli^^litest provocation, he punished them \vi;h ;;r«'at cruelly, and upon swver.d occasions caused llicui to bo destroyed with savage barbar- ity; which severity never fuilcd to be retorted l.y them upon the Dutch. This was the case with regard lo the colony of De V rics. Some pnrsons from a vessel which had stopped here f.)r wood ^nd water, had commiiled a petty thet'l, which was laid to the charge of the Raritan Indians, a tribe wlio lived near Aral oy, and a troop of one hundred men was sent to jiunish them. — These coniaiiUed violent exce.Taies, killing witli- oqt mercy ; and the only residi of the expedition was to excite a thirst for revenge, which was af- terwanls fully gratified. Upon the first oppor- tunity, the Uaritans invaded the Island, altack- ed the coionist.s and ojunlered ihem lo a man ; at the same litiie telling some friendly Indians thai the whiles should now have cause to Sght Ihem, having before assailed them unjustly. This occurred in the latter pari of 16-11, and about the same time, a person named Malyn ar- rived here from Holland, and claimed the Island, under an alleged grant from the West India Company. (12) Dc Vries at first disputed hia right, but, after the murder of his people, hcaban- doned hid design to plant a colony here, and Malyn obtained possession, and made some im- provements. He maintained his claim until near the end of the Dutch government, when he 8ur- rendi red it lo the Company. (13) The Inilians, however, were always ready to renew ihcir claims to the Island, and re-sell it, as often as ihey could find piirchasr rs ; and. accordingly, it was sold by tiiem again in 1G51, to Auguslin Herman, (I I) and again io 1Cj7 to the Baron Van Capel- lan. (15) The Sachems who made this sale weie called Warrincr, Aguepos, and Mingua, and the |)rice paid was) ax f»»llows : 10 shirts, 30 pair of stockings, 10 guns, 30 bars of lead, 30 pounds of powilpr, I'J coufs, 2 pieces of dufTell, 30 kettles, 50 h.ii:hets, 23 hoes, and a number of knives and awKs. (IG ) Uul the Dutch never tucceedrd in securing the frieixlship of the Indians. Prudence, if no brtd r moliu! should have inducer! them, at first, to act mildly towards (hose whose lands they were usurping, and experii-nce should have taught ihem that if i.s beltcrto be loved than fear- ed by our ncighl'ours. But ihey abandoned this principle, and their ill-judged measures [iro- duced in tlie minds of the savages an exaspera-^ lion, of which llicy often felt the cfTects; and as Sialen Island was easy of access, and its white inhabitants too few lo make much resistance, it was again made the K'cnt: of vengeance. In IGjj about five huniircd warriors, in sixty four canoes, landeil at New Amsterdam, and com- mrncid hostilities. Having iHade great havoc there, killing the inhabitants, burning houses, and destroying cattle, they at last made a des- cent upon this Island where they massacred six- ty seven persons, which must have embraced nearly the whole white population. (17.) Ac- cording lo tradition there were two or three houses at Olil Town, where all were murdered, except a little girl, w ho ran into the woods, but having been decoyed back to the house by an Indian diessed in her father's clolhcs, was pre- served, and carried away unharmed. We hear nothing more of Stalen Island dur- ing the Dutch government, except that all pri- vate claims to it were extinguished, and that it became again the property of the Company. In 1GG4, the English conquered the province and took the most efTeclual means to encourage emi- galion, by granting lo any person the lands he should subdue, [Many then came over, and 1. nChosethis Island as their residence. It had ai- rways been a favorite spot with tlie Dutch, and vits advantages continued to attract their success- ■ ors. It was eligibly situated, and its soil was rich. Besides, it abounded with uset'ul wild an- imals — deer, raccoons, and black bears, while it was free from those of a dangerous or noxious character; and its natives w/cre quiet and inof- fensive. It received considerable accessions about the year 1666, and its white population rapidly increased. In 1G65 a shire called York- shire was created, embracing Long Island, Sla- ten Island, and probably the town of Westches- ter, and a code of laws was promulgated for its government : (18) and in 1667 the first Court of Justice was established upon this Island. It consisted of two overseers, who together with the constable, were to administer justice in all cases where the amount in controversy was not more than five pounds. Cases which involved more than that amount, were to be sent to the Court of Gravesend, (19) The English, indeed com- menced a law reform, with a sagacity worthy of our present Legislature, They sat down in council, with a wisdom that would have been ridiculed in the Dutch, gravely to deliberate whether attorneys were useful to plead in Courts, or not ; and when it was resolved that they thought not, a law was passed prohibiting them to practice in the government. As the policy of the English was to concili.ite the Indians, and satisfy, as far as practicable, their demands, those here were too cunning to ;Iose the opportunity of making another specula- tion. Accordingly in 1670, they made their ap- pearance before Governor Lovelace and his coun- cil, and claimed the Island, or pay for it. (20) When they were referred to the sale in 1657 they denied that the Dutch had completely ful- filled their part of the contiact; and they then fixed a price, at tvhich they would forever reHn- quish their claims, and abandon the Island.— Like skilful speculators, raising their price as the demand increased, they at first named a sum from which they might safely recede; and pro- posed to receive six hundred fathoms of wam- pum ; which was worth far more than they had ever before been offered. This demand was at length somewhat abated, and they consented to take four hundred fathoms of wampum, together with a number of guns, axes, kettles, and watch- coats. But here the oarallel ceases, for, on pay- ment of those articles, they faithfully performed their contract, and delivered up, not a map with the country laid out upon it, but the land itself, and they never afterwards occasioned any (rouh- le.* The ceremony of conveyance was jierform' ed by delivering to those deputed to take posset:* slon, a ^y the exertions oflhe General, most of their booty was restored. ("2^) Hut it was near the clo«ic of the war when the inhabitants of this I^ilund suflTercd mo.st from this species of arrogance. Organized bands oftories then prowled about, robbing friend and foe ; and it was no uncommon thing, during a scent of dreadful violence, for a man to distcorer that he was pillaged I'y his nearest relations. These wretches attacked the defencelcbs houses, and if they expected concealment, inflicted on the rn- raates the most horriil tortures, and even death itself. On one occasion, they seized a notorious- miser, and having in vain endeavored to discov- er his treasures, he was lied to a po.->t, surroun- ded with straw, and given I© choose between his money and his life. But the passion of avarice conquered, the flame was applied, and the rob- bers departed; and though the wrttched marv suffeieil the mo>l lion il'le agony, he yel lived to enjoy afterwards his accursed lust f>f riches, — To such a |Htch indeed had these miscreants car- ried their audacity, that on anolli^rocca.sion they dragged an enemy before the Biiiish commander, and accused him as a spy ; and when, upon in- vestigation, the man was set at liberty, determin- ed Ujjon his destruction, they again seized him, carried him across the kills, and in sight of tbe army, hanged him upon the marestlree. Each man sb-pt with arms at his side, uncertain when •he shou^d be a.ssailed - and many adopted the ex- pedient of removing their efl'ects to the upper story of their houses, where at night, having as- cended by a ladder which was drawn up after tl)em. they remained in comparative security. — Ol!»ers obtained and kejtt at thtir houses, guards of Bri'.rsh soUiers. and in many neii^hborhoods regular patrols were established each night. But the robSiers were not so defeated, for they exten- ded their depredations into New Jersey, whence they returned loaded with booty; and marvcl'ous stories are yet told of the immense tre.nsures which they carried with them to Nova Scotia, w!)ero, at the close of the war, they, and other tories, found refuge from the vengeance oftheir countrymen. As our Island was the first position occupied by the enemy in this State, so it was tlie last de- serted; and from its situation between the con- tending armies, it was the scene of some interes- ting events. Here first landed those splendid 11 legions, which, proud in their unconquereJ val- our, went forth to battle, and here were they as- sembled, years afterwards stripped of their plu- mage, broken and conquered by the despised troops of undisciplined freemen. Here occurred ihat inter^'iew between the Engli:sh General Howe on the one hand, and Frankhn, Adams, and Rutledge on the other, when those patriots rejected with contempt all offers for submission, and refused to listen to a single proposition that Jid not contemplate the independence of their •country. (30) Here was the famous Ethan Al- ien exchanged and restored to liberty, after years of suffering in an Eiglish prison, where he re- ■ceived the treatment of the vilest culprits. (31) Here, as the last Hessian left our shore, was a salutary lesson given to tyrants, in the humilia- tion of a powerful nation before an exa?[)era- ted colony. Heaven forbid that the pride and arrogance ofthat very nation should again cause these hills to witness the marshalling of armies, and the assembling of navies, to assert and pro- tect our national rights, the freedom of the seas, and, in the language of Dallas, "the searchloss shelter of the flag." It is useful, at the close of the war of our in- dependence, to pause and reflect for a moment. Who, ignorant of history, and observing the termination ofthat mighty struggle, and the de- liberate institution by the people of a ne w form of government, could believe Uiat two centuries be- fore, the foot of civilization had never touched this soil ; that daring that time, a numerous and ancient people had melted away like the mist of the morning, or been driven into remoter wilds, as westward the star of empire took its way, and a few puny colonies had expanded into the na- tion which achieved these triumphs'? Who, then, looking forward to the present lime, would een in the possession of his Royal Highness aliove twenty years (except the liitle lime the Dutch had it) purchased by Governor Lovelace of the Indians, in the time of Sir Georf^e Carla- ret, without any pretences, till youi agents made claim of it." (3'2) But notwithstanding this the Governor himself was not satisfied that the title of New York was good, for when he obtained from the Duke a patent for a large tract of land upon the Island, being uncertain to which prov- ince it of right belonged, he obtained another pa- tent for the same land from the proprietors of East Jersey. (33.) This was about the time when New York was first divided into counties, of which this Island was one; and possession of it was afterwards kept by that province (ill the Revolution. After the independence of our country was secured, and the organization of the slate governments completed. New York, per- ceiving that the Island was of vital imfjortance, as it was necessary for the defence of her empo- rium, and the execution of her health laws, de- termined to keep possession. She claimed be- sides and exercised exclusive jurisdiction as far as low water mark on the Jersey shore. This was opposed by New Jersey, and that stale in- sisted that, by the terms of the original grant, she had jurisdiction to the middle of the nar- rows, and consequently owned Staten Island ; and when New York urged her long possession New Jersey denied the equity of the argument, and insisted that she had always protested against that possession, but that as New- York 12. was tho Btronycr province, she had never been able to contend with her.* This condition of tliin>»3 coiiiiriuod till the excited fcelin;;:! cauacd by the controversy, demanded that it should be Helllcd, and acconlin^ly coinmitiriioncrb were ap- pointed in 1807 for that purpose, by both states. A Communication passed between them in which U was alU-ged on the part of New Jersey that that state "would insist tl)at Staten Island was within her bounds," but an olfer was made to reliny commissioners, who, "waiting all discussion of the strict rights of either party, made such concessions as they supposed to be not only compatible with the sp')staniial interests ofeaehofthe states, but conducive to the har- mony and welfare of both : (37) New York ob- tained an acknowledgement of her right (o this Island, and to exclusive jurisdiction over a por- tion of the adjact nt waters, by conceding to New Jersey a similar jurisdiction over another portion; and thus was happily settled a vexa- tious question, which at one time threatened to *This tact I learned from the Hon. B. F. Butler who was one of the commissioners who finally set- tled the ccitrovei sy in a manner so safisfactory, that their arrangements were adopted, I believe, unan- imously, by the Lcgi.-latures of both states. disturb the harmony of the slales. Wo have now traceil down the course of events to the present time, but I should do scan- ty justice to my subject, and you would feel that tho occasion ^\crc ill-i(r.j)roved, did we fail to pay appropriate homage lo the memory of one, inti- mately connected with the prosperity of our lolvMid ; one who ma ie it his home, wjio, after a long career of public service, brought hither with him from al! good men, rei»peet for his talents, and love for his virtues, and who died here, ic- grcttcd by all as a patriot, a statesman, a philan- thropist. I need not Irll you, al Tompkinsville, that I allude lo Daniel D. Tompkins.* The character of that cninent man seems lo have re- alized the ancient adage concerning the seventh son. His father, one of the |)alriots of the llev- olution, his ancestors, the Puritans-, he inherited, and concentrated in himselfthe illoslrious quali- ties of l oth those classe s. Sustained by his abil- ities alone, he rose through the highest stations in our state, to the second office of our country, distingui-hed alike upon the judicial bench, and in the executive chair. But it was while Gov- ernor of this State, that his greatness was most conspicuous. FJected lolhat oITice for ten succes- sive years, a period which embraced the war with Great Giilain, he administered too government with the greatest success, though opposed by the bitter hostility of a violent fjciion. When tho public good called for it, he did not hesitate to adopt the boldest measures, and in no instance did the people fiil to support him; and at the darkest period of the war; when our soil was threatened with invasion, when the treasury was empty, and the credit of the government ex- hausted, liy pledging his personal responsibility, for above a million of dollars, he contributed more than any other lo those victoiies, which pieserved our slate from devastation. (38) His care, extended over all the interests of the State, and embraced all classes of persons; and no man can read his messages, without having his finer feelings kindled by a spark of his benevolence, — Agriculture, raanufactureSjand educa ion receiv- ed his support; to improve the condition of the degrailed Indians, was an object of his exertionsj and he strongly urged upon the Legislature, "the extinction from amongst us of slavery, that re- proach of a free people." An enemy to capital and corporal punishment?, he calls tbe former, "that vestige of barbarism," and of the latter he says, "no reformation can be wrought, by the *Born 21st June, 1774, in Westchester Co. He was the seventh son of Jonathan G. Tompkins. 13. agonies of a hccrated body." He deprecated party spirit, and exerted himself to appease its malignity; he was anxious to place the poor and the rich upon a perfect political equality ; and, in his last message, after congratulating the Legis- lature upon the glorious results of the war, he observes, "amidst these considerations, let not those who have achieved those great oJjccts, un- der the most adverse fortune, be forgotten. Let them not retire at once the objects of the respect and ingratitude of their country." But, ' pity 'tis 'tis true, '* the misfortunes he was so desirous to avert from others, were reserved for himself; and his retirement was embittered by the tardy justice of his country, in remunerating the sacri- fices his patriotism ha