A TREATISE ON STEEL: COMPRISING ITS THEORY, METALLURGY, PRtfERTITWS,, PRACTICAL WORKING, AND USE. BY M. II. C. LANDRIN, nJR., CIVIT ENGINEER. TRANSLATED FRO'M TIlE FRENCII, WITII NOTES, 13Y A. A. FESQUET, CIIEMIST AND ENGINEER. WiTII AN APPENDIX ON THE BESSEMER AND TIIE MARTIN PROCESSES FOR MANUFACTURING STEEL, F1R1OM'111E REPORT OF ABRAM S. TIEWITT, UNITED STATES COMMISSIONER TO TIlE UNIVERSAL EXPOSITION, PARIS, 1867. PHILADELPHIA: lI E NR Y CAR E Y BA I R D, INDUSTRIAL PUBLISIIER, 406 Walnut Street. LONDON: TRUBNER & CO., 60 Paternoster Row. 1668. Entered according to Act of Congress, in the year 1868, by HENRY CAREY BAIRD, in the Clerk's Office of the District Court of the United States for tl:e Eastern District of the State of Pennsylvania. PIIILADEITPITA: COLLINS, PRINTER, *05 JAYNE STREET. TRANSLATOR'S PREFACE. NOT many years agto, when the uses of steel were confined to the manufacture of tools, cutting instruments, etc., there were few qualities of steel; and cast steel, tilted steel, and some German steels especially employed for the manufacture of files, scythes, etc., were the only compounds of iron and carbon known under the name of steel. The enormous progress made recently in iron metallurgy and in metallic constructions, has prompted the employment in large quantities of new kinds of steel, endowed with properties of resistance and flexibility hitherto unknown and unsuspected, and at a cheapness of cost which has allowed their use for rails, large pieces of machinery, railroad tires, plates for boilers, ships, bridges, etc. iv TRANSLATOR'S PREFACE. These improvements are due to the energy of some inventors, and to their complete knowledge of the nature and composition of the metal with which they were working. The scientific principles by which their efforts were directed were the same, the methods to arrive at the result were different. These new steels, whose properties were so different from those hitherto known, made many persons inquire if they were really steels, or some particular kinds of iron. This depends on definitions: we shall call them steels, if we continue to consider asIron, the fibrous or granular metal known under that name, combined with a trace of carbon (all commercial irons contain carbon), and which cannot be hardened by the hardening process. Steel, the combination of iron with an average of one per cent. of carbon, which call be hardened and melted. Piq iron, the combination of iron with three TRANSLATOR'S PREFACE. V to five per cent. of carbon, which can be melted, and possesses scarcely any malleability. A very small change in the proportion of carbon will affect the properties of steel, which will be exemplified in the course of this work. Nevertheless, Mr. Lanclrill takes cast steel as a type, because of all known steels its properties and composition are the most constant. Beginning with a history of steel, the Author next examines the various fuels employed in metallurgy, the substances which in the ore and the fuel are capable of influencing the qualities of iron and steel, the different ores in use, and then passes to the theory of the formation of steel, with citations from a work on steel by Reaumur, published in 1722. This ancient work may be read with advantage even at the present day, as pointing to the futility of certain secrets and mixtures for making steel, by which many persons are yet deceived. The theory of the formation of steel is followed by a method of quantitative analysis for 1* Vi TRANSLATOR'S PREFACE. iron, steel, or pig metal, by the metallurgy of natural, puddled, cast steel, and ~Wootz steel, special attention being given to the manufacture of pots for casting, and by the new processes known under the names of Chenot, Bessemer, Uchatius, etc. After examining certain mixtures of steel with other metals, Mr. Landrin, Jr., fully explains the various operations by which steel is welded, hardened, and tempered; and finally describes some of the uses to which steel is applied, such as the manufacture of files, steel wire, steel plates, needles, and saws. Within a small compass, Mr. Landrin gives anl insight into the whole question of the manufacture of steel. Formerly, the steel manufacturer had only to buy some wellknown mark of iron, cement and cast it; but the present state of steel industry, where the pig iron is sometimes run directly from the blast furnace into the converter, requires a knowledge of the ores and fuels employed for producing the raw metal. TRANSLATOR'S PREFACE. vii To extend the knowledge of a metal so necessary as steel, has been the aim of the Author, and we hope our readers will find this book useful to them. In order to convey an idea of the present state of steel industry, we have added some extracts from the valuable report made by Mr. Abram S. Hewitt, U. S. Commissioner to the Universal Exposition at Paris, 1867. PHILADELPHIA, August 1, 1868. CONTENTS. The figures refer to the numbers of the paragraphs. INTRODUCTION. HISTORY OF STEEL. Discovery of Steel................ 1 Metallurgy in ZEthalia......... 25 First Furnaces of the He- First alloy of iron and bronze 26 brews.............................. 2 Roman metallurgists............ 27 The Chinese........................ 3 The Moors of Spain............. 28 The Greeks, Homer............. 4 Ancient Bilbilis.................. 29 Scarcity of Steel.................. 5 Germany............................ 30 Bronze............................. 6 Ores employed then.............. 31 J~thalia............................. 7 Use of fluxes....................... 32 The Chalybes....................... 8 Blowing machines................ 33 Furnaces............................ 9 Pig iron unknown to Agricola 34 Fuel in Use......................... 10 Determination of the time of Knowledge of Pit Coal......... 11 its use........................... 35 Knowledge of Pig Iron......... 12 First blast furnace............... 36 Iron and Steel in Egypt and Blast furnaces in France....... 37 Arabia............................ 13 Fluss ofen in India............... 38 First Iron Bedstead.............. 14 Cast iron employed in England 39 Corporation of Blacksmiths... 15 Eastern countries the birthOres Known at that Time...... 16 place of steel.................... 40 Progress of Iron and Steel.... 17 First cementation of iron...... 41 Invention of the Hammer and Sheffield cutlery.................. 42 Anvil............................. 18 Introduction of cast steel in Invention of the bellows...... 19 England......................... 43 Manufactures in Palestine..... 20 Puddled steel invented in CaGreek colonies.................... 21 rinthia............................ 44 Discovery of metals.............. 22 Progress of steel works in Iron coins.................... 23 France........................... 45 The Phoenicians............. 24 PRELIMINARY OBSERVATIONS. I. hIEAT. II. OXYGEN. Expansion......................... 46 Its affinity for iron............... 50 Fusion...... 47 Metallic sponge (Chenot's)..... 51 Colorations by heat.............. 48 Protoxide of iron (Ferrous oxUnit of heat........................ 49 ide)..................... 5......... 52 X CONTENTS. Peroxide of iron (ferric oxide) 53 1 Swedish irons..................... 90 Affinity for carbon............... 54 Analysis of pig metal........... 91 Reactions of carbon and oxy- ~ 4. Hydrated oxide of iron.. 92 gen................................. 55 Brown hbematite.................. 93 Working of the blast furnace.. 56 Varieties of this ore............. 94 Oxidation of steel................. 57 VIII. FUELS. III. SULPHUR. Definition.......................... 95 Its action upon steel............ 58 Their importance in metalProcess for removing sulphur lurgy.............................. 96 from ores......................., 59 Carbon.97 How to avoid it in fuels........ 60 Varieties of fuels................. 98 Action of rain and air.......... 61 Constituent principles........... 99 Carbon and hydrogen........... 100 IV. PHOSPrORUS. Ashes of mineral fuels.......... 101 Its action upon steel............. 62 Ashes of vegetable fuels...... 102 It combines with sulphur.. 63 1 I'Wood................. 103'Lignine.............................. 104 V. WATER. Calorific power.................... 105 Woods divided into two classes 106 Its importance in metallurgy 64 Comparative value............... 107 Its yield in oxygen............... 65 ~ 2. Charcoal.................. 108 Steam................................ 66 Object of carbonization... 109 Its action on sulphur............ 67 Age of the wood to be felled.. 110 Its action on silicon.............. 68 Proper time for felling......... 111 Decrepitation..................... 69 Methods of carbonization...... 112 Its hygrometric state............ 70 Carbonization'in heaps........ 113 Comparison of the products... 114 VI. LIME. Conduct of the operation...... 115 Its action as an oxide........... 71 Red charcoal....................... 116 Its action as a metal............ 72 Rapidity of the carbonization 117 Calorific value of charcoals.... 118 VII. IRON ORES. Composition of charcoal.......1. 19 Importance of their know- Density and weight.............. 120 ledge.............................. 73 Yield in alkalies.................. 12 Their definition.................... 74 ~ 3. Pit coal........................ 122 Their varieties..................... 75 Various kinds of coal........... 123 How to distinguish them....... 76 Certain kinds of coals natural~ 1. Carbonate of iron......... 77 ly distilled....................... 124 Lithoid iron........................ 78 Comparative composition...... 125 Spathic iron........................ 79' Calorific power.................... 126 Analyses............................. 80 Weights............................. 127 Superoxidation.................... 81 Yield in sulphur.................. ]28 ~ 2. Oligist iron................... 824 ~ 4. Coke................... 129 Its varieties........................ 83 C1 oals good for carbonization.. 130 Analyses............................ 84 Processes of carbonization..... 131 Red haematite..................... 85 Comparative products in Its transformation into red weights..............1........ 132 chalk............................. 86 Comparative products in volIts yield............................. 87 umes.............................. 33 Presence of manganese......... 88 Calorific value..................... 131 ~ 3. Magnetic iron.............. 89 Weights............................. 135 CONTENTS. xs Object in carbonizing............ 136 Its qualities........................ 139 Natural carbonization.......... 137 Its value............................. 140 ~ 5. Anthracite................... 138 1 Its use............................... 141 PART FIRST. STEEL AND ITS THEORY. Definition........................... 142 Unity in the theory.............. 181 Iron................................... 143 Proportion of carbon............ 182 Carbon.................... 144 Theory of alloys.................. 145 THEORY OF IREAU JIUR. Carbides of iron.................. 146 Extracts from R6aumur's Analyses of steel................. 147 work.............................. 183 Electricity................. 148 Case hardening.................... 184 Solution..............1........... ]49 Conversion of iron into steel.. 185 Saturation......................... 150 Cementing substances.......... 186 Definite proportions............. 151 Nature of these substances... 187 Reactions in the blast furnace 152 Mode of operation............... 188 Formation of pig metal......... 153 Trials with mixtures............ 189 Unity in steel..................... 154 Explaining how the experiCarbon and iron.................. 155 ments succeeded............... 190 Manganese......................... 156 Trial with lime.................... 191 Carbides of manganese......... 157 Trial with plaster of Paris..... 192 Action of manganese............ 158 Sand...................... 1.......... 193 Mushet's steel..................... 159 Change of texture............... 194 Silicon.............................. 160 Trial with clay.................... 195 Alloy made by Berzelius....... 161 Trial with leached ashes........ 196 Composition of steel............. 162 Trial with glass................... 197 Clouet's steel...................... 163 The metal cleansed.............. 198 Magnesium........................ 164 Necessity of cementing subAluminium........................ 165 stances.......................... 199 Various alloys..................... 166 Uselessness of secrets........... 200 Chemical alloys................... 167 Trial with fatty matters........ 201 Experiment........................ 168 Trial with certain salts......... 202 Beginning of cementation..... 169 Trial with soap.................... 203 Steely iron.......................... 170 Trial with charcoal.............. 204 Cemented iron..................... 171 Conclusions........................ 205 Blistered steel..................... 172 Researches......................... 206 Is this a true steel?.............. 173 Alkalies.............................. 207 Fusion................................ 174 Borax........................ 208 Remedies..................... 175 Steel not remaining such...... 209 Cast steel............................ 176 Common salt....................... 210 Steel made in blast furnaces.. 177 Spirits of salts............... 211 Inferences........................... 178 Mineral substances............... 212 Manufactures of steel in the Salts and charcoal............... 213 Alps.............................. 179 Best composition (at RdauProduction of steel in the mur's epoch)................... 214 Pyrenees........................ 180 Charcoals........................ 215 Xii CONTENTS. QUANTITATIVE ANALYSIS. Composition of steel............ 216 2. Estimation of sulphur and Combined and uncombined phosphorus....................... 223 carbon........................... 217 3. Estimation of graphitic carOther metals alloyed............ 218 bon, silica, lime, etc......... 224 Pulverizing......................... 219 Search for chrome and alumina 225 Separation into three por- Search and estimation of mantions............................... 220 ganese............,............... 226 1. Estimation of carbon........ 221 Precipitation of the lime........ 227 Search for nitrogen.............. 222 Search for magnesium........... 228 PART SECOND. METALLURGY OF STEEL. Substances for making steel... 229 1 Pig metal employed.............. 255 Classification of the processes 230 Working............................ 256 Division of this section......... 231 Products, consumption, labor 257 I. NATURAL STEEL. IV. STEEL OF CEMENTATION. Furnaces............................ 232 Definition........................... 258 Catalan Forge..................... 233 Cementation at the ordinary Dimensions........................ 234 temperature..................... 259 Production of steel or iron.... 235 Ignorance on this subject...... 260 Position of the tuyere........... 236 Cementation in general......... 261 Projection of the tuyere........ 237 Furnace............................. 262 Slope of the tuyere.............. 238 Dimensions......................... 263 Ores employed..................... 239 Charge............................... 264 Charging the furnace............ 240 Operation........................... 265 Working............................. 241 Observations on furnaces...... 266 Drawing the blooms.............. 242 Length and waste of the ope- V. CAST STEEL. ration.............................. 243 Object of casting.................. 267 Crucibles or pots.................. 268 II. RAW STEEL. Construction of pots............. 269 Pig metal employed............. 244 Choice of the materials......... 270 Furnaces............................ 245 Mixed clays........................ 271 Dimensions......................... 246 Moulds............................... 272 Staff of workmen................. 247 Drying............................... 273 Mode of operation............... 248 Annealing.......................... 274 Products and consumption..... 249 Various shapes of pots......... 275 Another method.................. 250 Stands and lids................... 276 Westphalian and Silesian pro- Labor................................. 277 cesses............................. 251 Graphite............................. 278 Products and consumption..... 252 Its composition.................... 279 Styrian process................... 253 Casting furnaces.................. 280 Dimensions........................ 281 III. PUDDLED STEEL. Sheffield furnaces................. 282 Furnace............................. 254 Charging............................ 283 CONTENTS. Xiii Fuel................................ 284 Cementation........................ 316 Operation........................... 285 New metallurgy of steel........ 317 Making the ingots............... 286 Running into large moulds.... 287 Bessemer Process. Use of manganese............... 288 Theory.............................. 318 Remarks on steel................. 289 First idea due to Mr. Martien 319 Principle of the operation...... 320 VI. WOOTZ. Apparatus........................... 321 Definition...................... 290 Fitting the converter........ 322 Ore employed...................... 291 Mode of operation............... 323 Furnace............................. 292 Analogy with natural steel.... 293 Taylor Process. Fusion.............................. 294 Analogy with the Bessemer Fusion.294 Analogy with the Bessemer Waste............................. 295 process........................... 324 Analogy with cast steel......... 296 Apparatus.......................... 325 Various processes...............297 Production regulated at will.. 326 Shape of the commercial pro- Continuous production......... 327 duct.............................. 298 Uchatizs Process. VII. NEW PROCESSES. Definition.......................... 328 Summing up of the various Pig iron employed............... 329 Granulating the metal.......... 330 processesory....................... 299....... 331 Tendency of the metallurgy of Theory steel.300 Mode of operation.............. 332 steel.............................. 300............... All processes derived from one Proportions...................... 33 principle.1301 Experiments..................... 334 principl e.......................... 301E.. Process of Mr. E. Newton.... 302 Products and consumption... 35 Process of Messrs. Crace Calvert, Fontaine.................. 303 VIII. DAMASCUS STEEL. Process of David Mushet and Damascus blades.336 S. Rodgers...................304 Price and description of scimeProcess of Messrs. Martien and tars.337 Brooman.........................305 Imitations in Europe............ 338 Process of Mr. Robert Mushet 306 How to make the pattern apProcess of Messrs. Price and pear 339 Nicholson........................ Theory of Mr. Henri, of Bou- ngival.............................. 340 Process of Mr. Manory......... 308 gival40 Process of Mr. Sterling......... 309 Influence of aluminium. 341 First idea of the Bessemer pro- IX. METALLIC TIssuEs. cess due to Mr. Martien..... 310 I.3 Definition......................... 342 Metallic alloys.................... 343 Silver steel......................... 344 Principle.......................... 311 Mechanical alloy.............. 345 A rctional idea.................... 312 Rhodium steel.................... 348 Mr. Chenot is struck by it.... 313 Platinum steel.................... 346 Disposition of the apparatus... 314 Metallic mirrors.................. 347 Enormous compression.......... 315 Chromium steel................... 349 2 X1V CONTENTS. PART THIRD. WORKING OF STEEL. Division of this section......... 350 Loss of specific gravity......... 369 Hardening in tepid water.... 370 I. REFINING BY DRAWING OR Theorem on hardening......... 371 TILTING. Limits.............................. 372 The object of this operation... 351 Cherry..red heat................... 373 Working..............................352 Pure water........................ 374 Furnace............................. 353 Degrees of hardening............ 375 Influence of a good workman 354 Temperatures for hardening... 376 Overheating........................ 377 II. WELDING. Employment of fusible alloys.. 378 Temperature....................... 355 Composition of these alloys... 379 Equilibriation of heat........... 356 Respective masses of iron and V. TEMPERING. sRteel. ~ ~ ~ Harshness of steel............... 380 s eer.................. ste of br...................... 358 Structure of iron and steel..... 381 Use of Borax...,,,..... ov358 Change by heat................... 382 Tilted steel......................... 383 III. ANNEALING.384 Tempering.......................... 384 Annealing is not tempering.... 359 Effect produced.................... 385 Difference........................... 360 Changes of color in tempering 386 Degree of temperature......... 361 They act as guides............... 387 Cooling in water............... 362 Mode of operation and preCooling in charcoal dust....... 363 cepts.............................. 388 IV. HARDENING. VI. HAMMER HARDENING. Effects from heat.................. 364 Hammering iron.................. 389 Slow cooling....................... 365 Hammer hardening steel....... 390 Rapid cooling..................... 366 Should not be done too rapidly 391 Explanation of the hardening 367 Warped or distorted pieces..... 392 Definition........................... 368 Causes of this phenomenon... 393 PART FOURTH. PROPERTIES OF STEEL AND ITS USES. Contents of this section......... 394 Differences by scratching...... 401 Substances for scratching...... 402 I. CHARACTERISTICS OF STEEL. Sound of steel..................... 403 Distinction of acids.............. 395 Fibre of steel...................... 404. Specific gravity.................... 396 Welding......................... 405 Granular texture................. 397 Forging.............................. 406 Crystalline texture.............. 398 Harshness........................... 407 Fibrous texture.................. 399 Hardness to the file.............. 408 Hardness............................ 400 Differences of texture........... 409 CONTENTS. XV How to make the trial........... 410 Trial of bastard files............ 456 Curious phenomenon............ 411 Trial of smooth files............. 457 What Diodorus and Plutarch relate............................ 412 III. STEEL WIRE. Sheffield cutlers.................. 413 Drawing wire...................... 458 Mr. Weiss, of London........... 414 Its object........................... 459 Tensile strength.................. 415 Draw plates....................... 460 Wheel tires......................... 416 What made of.................... 461 Iron tires........................... 417 The conditions they have to Puddled steel tires............... 418 fulfil................................ 462 Comparative resistance to Pointing and drawing the wear.............................. 419 wire............................. 463 Iron tires........................... 420 Effect of a coating of copper.. 464 Puddled steel tires............... 421 How many annealings.......... 465 Cast steel tires..................... 422 A slow drawing necessary...... 466 Runs performed.................. 423 Oxidation........................... 467 Horseshoes......................... 424 Annealing furnace............... 468 English manufactures........... 425 Furnace of Aigle................. 469 Trade marks....................... 426 Furnace of Mr. Fox............. 470 Swedish irons...................... 427 Working of this apparatus..... 471 Russian irons...................... 428 Its advantages..................... 472 Qualities of steel wire........... 473 II. FILES. Gauges............................... 474 Materials for files................. 429 Principle of wire drawing...... 475 Forging................... 430 Pinion and grooved wires...... 476 Hand forge......................... 431 Watch springs..................... 477 Annealing.......................... 432 Wires for musical instruments 478 Truing the blanks................. 433 Grinding........................... 434 IV. NEEDLES. Cutting.............................. 435 Choice of the wire................ 479 Cutting machines................. 436 Length.............................. 480 Hardening.......................... 437 Pointing...................... 481 Furnace................... 438 Separation......................... 482 Muffles............................... 439 Head flattening.................... 483 Why muffles are employed..... 440 Annealing........................... 484 Coating.............................. 441 Making the groove............... 485 Heating............................ 442 Stamping the heads............ 486 Colors................................ 443 Straightening...................... 487 Conditions of success............ 444 Inspection........................... 488 Number of men employed to Hardening.......................... 489 the furnace.................... 445 Tempering......................... 490 Mode of immersion.............. 446 Polishing............................ 491 Warping............................ 447 Scouring............................ 492 Straightening...................... 448 Winnowing and wiping......... 493 French files......................... 449 Loss by the operation............ 494 How to file....................... 450 Sorting the needles.............. 495 Files employed.................... 451 Drilling of the eyes.............. 496 Color of the file................... 452 Last polishing and burnishTrial of files........................ 453 ing.................................. 497 Rejected files..................... 454 Cemented needles................ 498 Some defects in files............. 455 Gilt needles........................ 499 XV1 CONTENTS. V. STEEL PLATE. Number of revolutions of the Choice of the metal.............. 500 rolls............................... 515 Processes of drawing............ 501 Engraving plates.................. 516 Steel of cementation............ 502 Error on this subject............ 517 Slabs.................................. 503 Hammers........................... 504 VI. SAws. Steam hammers................... 505 Materials............................ 518 Rules for heating................. 506 Slabs................................. 519 Furnaces........................... 507 Punching the teeth.............. 520 Doubled slabs..................... 508 Shapes of teeth.................... 521 Construction and material of Heating............................. 522 rolls................................ 509 Hardening.......................... 523 Roughing down rolls............ 510 Blazing off.......................... 524 Train of rolls...................... 511 Straightening..................... 525 Protection of slabs............... 512 Planishing.......................... 526 Taking the oxide off plates... 513 Hammering and polishing..... 527 Hardening........................ 514 INTRODUCTION. HISTORY OF STEEL. 1. THE discovery of steel is lost in antiquity, and is mingled with that of iron; the first indications are found in Genesis. In order to write the history of the carburized metal, we should give that'of iron; but this would carry us too far beyond the limits of this small treatise. The Hebrews have confounded under the name of b;'i (barzel), the two metals, the working of which, according to Moses, had been taught to men by Tubal-Cain', whose father lived 3130 years before Christ. Job says that the metal was extracted from an arenaceous ore, probably similar to that actually employed at Samakof, in Romalia.2 We find in Deuteronomy that Og, King of Bashan, possessed an iron bedstead, which shows to what degree of perfection the art of forging had arrived.' 1 And Zillah, she also bare Tubal-Cain, an instructor of every artificer in brass and iron. (Gen. iv. 22.) 2 Job xxviii. 2. s Deuteronomy iii. 11. 3 26 TREATISE ON STEEL. 2. It is probable that, like what is now the usage in Asia and in Central Africa, the Hebrews had nothing which could be properly called a furnace; but that they made a hole in the ground, filled it pell-mell with ore and charcoal, and promoted the combustion with their breath first, and afterwards with fans made of large tree leaves. The first indications of a regular mode of working are to be found in Egypt, where the Jews, during their servitude, were obliged to work in the forges of that country.' 3. Already, at that time, steel and iron were known by the Chinese; their first chiefs had found iron mines in the territory of Leang-tcheou.2 It is likely that the knowledge of the metal came from the west of Peking, because it is there where the Celestial.empire began to be populated. 4. In Larcher's Chronology it is stated that iron was known only 1537 years before Christ, over 250 years before the Trojan war. In the age of Homer, the metallurgical working of iron and steel was much advanced and varied; the latter metal was polished, as we may infer from the epithets a0'ovL, shiny, and 7tomo, white,3 applied by the poet in his 1 But the Lord hath taken you, and brought you forth out of the iron furnace (nrI'n:r, Courbarzel), even out of Egypt. (Deuter. iv. 20.) 2 Chu-King, cap. Yu-Cong. 3 I1. iv. 485; vii. 473; xx. 372. INTRODUCTION. 27 poems, in opposition to /ixaS black, which seems to indicate ductile iron, as it comes -from the hands of the blacksmith. It was hardened, because in the Odyssey, Homer compares the noise of the inflamed branch driven into the eye of Polyphemus to that produced by a blacksmith, when dipping into cold water a saw or an axe for hardening-an operation from which is derived all the strength of iron.' 5. It is a mistake to believe that in the heroic age, bronze alone was employed in the manufacture of arms and agricultural implements; from Homer we learn that the points of darts were sometimes forged out of steel,2 and this metal was also used to make tilling instruments and weapons for shepherds.3 6. It is true that the use of bronze had preceded that of steel, as shown by Hesiod,4 and after him, by Lucretius;5 but we must not conclude with Eustathius and several other commentators, that Homer had confounded the two metals under the generic name of xax6S;. This error is very likely caused by the Grecian poet confounding all metal workers under the same I Odyss. ix. 391. The word