Class Iiiii_ql Book ^4— CoipghtN" COPYRIGHT DEPOSIT CENTRAL STATION EXPERIENCES A series of narratives on the trials and tribulations of a steam eng^ineer while learning; to run an electric station FROM I e c ) o 3 ■) 1 } J , 3 , NEW YORK THE POWER PUBLISHING CO. WORLD BUILDING I90I ^/(f THE LI9«ARV OF CONGRESS, Two Copies Receivep WAY. 31 1901 CoPYRtCrtT ENTRY CLASS O/XXc. N». I COPY B. Copyright, J 90 1, by The Power Publishing Co, Tfif// « « «< c c CONTENTS, A Defective Arc Lamp i Excessive Drop in Three- Wire Circuits 9 Careless Paralleling of Dynamos 15 A "Dead" Dynamo and Hot Field Coils 23 A "Breaking" Arc Circuit — Simple Ground Detector 31 Another Case of "Dead" Dynamo — Low Voltage 38 Careless Motormen — An Equalizer Trouble 42 A Sparking Motor — Motor Wiring 47 Some Railway Kinks 53 Reading a Recording Wattmeter 59 Braking a Car with Its Motor (i^ Enlarging a Running Station — The Motor Balancer 74 A Simple Trouble, with Annoying Results 81 Transformers on Three-Wire Secondaries 87 A Long Circuit from Ordinary Generators — Two-Phase Motors on Single-Phase Generators 93 Increasing the Output of an Alternator — Wiping Out Inductive Drop 100 A DEFECTIVE ARC LAMP. The water-works plant of the town of Millville had been aug- mented by an electric lighting plant, comprising a 50-light Brush arc dynamo and two 500-light incandescent machines, with the necessary circuits and appurtenances. The engineer, who was a bright fellow, and had studied as much as his limited opportun- ities would allow, was without practical experience in the opera- tion of electrical machinery, and was correspondingly nervous over his new responsibilities. "You see," he confided to Jones, who installed the. plant, ''I never actually run one of these blamed things, though I've been over to the Watertown station a good deal, and watched 'em running." i "Don't you worry a mite," said Jones; "I'll be through here every few weeks, and I'll always stop off to see how you're get- ting on," which he did faithfully. The plant was duly started up by Jones, who remained a week to get the engineer fairly started, and things went swimmingly until one night when the "trimmer," who looked out for the arc lamp circuits, came rushing in and exclaimed: "The lamps are all upside down; turn her around quick!" The engineer stared. "Upside down? I haven't touched 'em. Turn who around — what—" "They're burning backwards, man; can't you see?" "No, I can't see. What are you talking about?" The trimmer had had considerable experience, and explained to the engineer that the current was going through the arc lamps in the wrong direction, making the bottom carbon positive and the top one negative. Central Station Experiences. "What's the odds, so long as they burn ? Might as well let her rip until morning," said the engineer. *^Good Lord, man; you'll burn up all my carbon holders. Can't, you change your plugs on the board?" The engineer felt shaky, but he didn't wish to appear too green, so he sauntered over to the switchboard, followed by the trimmer. "Yes," he said, with assumed composure, "I s'pose I might." The board was a simple affair, consisting of two plugs at the ends of flexible cords leading from the circuit lightning arresters, and two sockets connected with the terminals of the dynamo, as shown by the diagram in Fig. i. This arrangement, Jones had explained, was better than connecting the plugs to the dynamo and the sockets to the circuit, because if the plugs should be hanging free at any time when the dynamo was running, their touching each other could not hurt the dynamo. If they were the dynamo connections, touching them together would short- circuit, and might damage, the machine. "All you've got to do," suggested the trimmer, who wouldn't have tried to do it for the whole plant, "is to reverse them plugs. A Defective Arc Lamp. That'll make the positive side negative and the negative side positive." The engineer pretended to ignore the trimmer's friendly advice, as though it were unnecessary, but he heeded it. Without stop- ping the engine he closed the field switch on the dynamo, "kill- ing" the field, as Jones had shown him should be done when it was desired to open the circuit for any reason. Then he took out the switchboard plugs and reversed them in the holes, went "The lamps are all upside down back to the dynamo and opened the field switch. The pilot lamp over the dynamo did not light up and the engineer felt a shiver of apprehension pass up his spine. "What have you done now?" asked the trimmer, ready to lay all the blame for any possible mishap upon someone else. But the engineer kept his head; although he didn't know what was wrong, he did know that he had done nothing to cause any Central Station Experiences. serious trouble. So he determined to simply start up all over again, just as he had at lighting-up time. ''Nothing," he replied to the trimmer, ''but I think I'll shut down and take a look at her." Accordingly he shut down the engine, took out the switch- board plugs and gave them to the trimmer to hold in proper po- sition for insertion, so as to avoid getting the polarity mixed up again, and pretended to examine the dynamo for a moment. "I think she'll go now," he said, without changing a single adjustment, but being careful to see that everything was in its usual condition for starting. Then he started the engine, went to the board and taking the plugs from the trimmer put them, one at a time, in the sockets. When the second plug went home the pilot lamp struck its arc with a clack and a hiss that gave the engineer's mind mighty relief. "Thought that would fetch her," he said carelessly, and he immediately rose several points in the trimmer's estimation. The lamps were now all right, except one that the trimmer brought in burned up the next morning, and matters went along smoothly up to Jones' next visit. The engineer related the whole occurrence to Jones. "You opened the field switch while the plugs were in and got no light?" he asked. "Yes." "And you stopped the engine and started up with the plugs out, putting them in after the machine was up to speed?" "Yes." "Burn up any lamps?" "One." "Ah! Let me see it." "It's gone to the factory for repairs." A Defective Arc Lamp. "Well, it doesn't matter. Give me a piece of chalk." This was furnished and Jones drew a rough diagram on the floor, like Fig. 2. "Suppose D is your dynamo and the crosses represent arc lamps in the circuit. The big cross means a faulty lamp in which the clutch was sticky and the cut-out defective." "The one that burned up?" "Yes. If you had it here you would no doubt find that there was trouble with both the clutch and the cut-out. The chances are that someone neglected to connect the cut-out, or it has be- come disconnected since the lamp was sent out." "What did that have to do with the dynamo not 'picking up?' " "Well, you know what the cut-out in a lamp is for, don't you ?" •TH- I-
60
494
437
392
347
310
275
224
173
140
108
88
68
55
43
2 \ 19
659
590 £
22
468
414
370
328
294
260
212
164
133
103
84
65
62
40
38
20
626
560 i
96
445
393
312
279
247
200
156
127
98
79
60
50
38
40
10
.21
596
628 1
72
423
375
335
297
265
235
190
148
120
93
75
58
42
669
510 4
152
404
358
320
283
254
225
183
142
115
89
72
56
44
fHS
480
432
!82
342
303
270
240
215
190
155
120
98
75
60
48
27
463
415
68
330
292
260
230
209
187
160
115
72
59
46
66
68^-15
3
28
447
400 :
154
318
282
252
223
199
177
144
110
90
70
57
44
?.
432
387
142
307
272
243
215
192
170
138
107
87
67
54
42
L30
417
374 S
130
296
262
236
208
186
165
134
103
84
65
r38
329
295 5
60
234
207
185
164
147
130
106
82
06
61
76
80 20
84
*2
313
280 -2
18
222
196
176
156
139
123
100
78
63
49
5
42
92
264 5
36
210
187
167
148
132
117
95
74
44
284
255 5
•26
202
179
160
140
127
112
91
71
46
272
243 :
15
193
170
153
135
120
107
87
67
....
(-56
223
200
77
159
140
126
110
99
88
72
65
....
58
216
193
70
153
136
120
107
96
85
....
'i
^
208
187
65
148
130
117
104
93
82
62
202
180
60
143
127
113
100
90
80
64
195
175
55
139
123
110
87
77
....
72
174
156 1
38
123
109
98
87
77
68
10
74
76
80
169
164
156
151 1
147
140
34
30
24
120
117
111
106
103
98
95
92
88
84
82
78
. ..
Wire
Nos.
2
2&3
r
3&4
4
4&5
5
5&6
6
6&8
8 '
8&10
10 10
&12
12
2 &14
14
Safe
Current
130
1 1
10
,.
92
77
77
65
65
46
46
32
32
23
23
16
16
The engineer thanked him, and they started back to the station.
"Why did you say awhile ago that I'd need all sorts of wiring
soon?" asked the engineer.
"Because you will. The town has about decided to put in an
alternator and to lease the old water-power and mill site up the
river so's to furnish light and power to the shops and factories
out at the west end, and you're going to do a lot of wiring calcu-
lations."
A Sparking Motor — Motor Wiring. 51
"But I don't know how exactly."
"You can learn."
Reaching the station the engineer took out Jones' wiring table
and spread it on the desk.
"Why are there several numbers of amperes for each size of
motor?" he asked.
"Because different motors show different efficiencies, and there-
fore require different amounts of current."
"That's so. According to the table this motor will need Nos. 6
and 8 wire, just as you guessed."
"I didn't guess; I knew."
"How could you know?"
"With No. 10 wire your drop is 16 volts, isn't it?"
"Yes."
"Well, seven or eight volts is as much as you ought to have on
a 220 or 230 volt circuit. And in order to cut your drop down
from sixteen volts to about eight, your wire must be about twice
the size it is."
-Yes, but "
"Wait. No. 7 wire is roughly twice the size of No. 10, but No.
7 wire is not generally kept in stock. As No. 7 is about half way
between No. 6 and No. 8, making half of your circuit of No. 6
and the other half of No. 8 will give practically the same result."
"I don't exactly see that."
"No. 6 wire has an area of 26,250 circular mils," referring to
his notebook, "and No. 8 has 16,510 circular mils. Now if half
of the circuit is of one size and half of the other size, the average
area throughout the circuit will be the plain average of these two
areas. What is the average or mean of 26,250 and 16,510?"
The engineer wrote: 26,250
16,510
2)42,760
21,380
"Twenty-one thousand, three hundred and eighty circular
mils," he said.
"All right. Now No. 7 wire has an area of 20,817 circular mils,
so that Nos. 6 and 8 used together give slightly less drop than
No. 7 would."
52 Central Station Experiences.
"1 see. And Nos. lo and 12 can be used instead of No. 11;
Nos. 8 and 10 instead of No. 9, and so on?"
''Exactly. Thus you get a greater number of available wire
areas or resistances without carrying any more sizes in stock."
The engineer pored over the wiring table for several minutes.
"Suppose I wanted to wire a 5-horse motor and didn't know
how many amperes it would take?" he suggested.
"Assume the middle figure, in such a case. The wiring will be
near enough for all practical purposes."
"Forty-two amperes for a iio-volt five-horse, and twenty-two
amperes for a 220-volt five-horse?" he asked.
"Yes."
"How can you use the table for some other percentage of
drop?"
"Multiply the actual amperes by the drop you want, divide by
3.6, and use the result as if it were the amperes your motor de-
manded. But I wouldn't bother with any other drop. Three and
six-tenths per cent is a good all round drop and will fit any case
within reason. Get your wiring book — but get a good one that
contains something more than kid lessons on Ohm's law — and
you will have tables for all practical drops. Be sure it includes
alternating-current wiring."
"Is that any different ?"
"Considerably. Direct current wiring tables are no earthly
good for alternating-current circuits."
SOME RAILWAY KINKS.
Since the circuit-breaker episode Mr. Harvey and the engineer
had become better acquainted, and each had discovered, as usually
befalls, that the other had "lots more sense" than he had sup-
posed. Moreover, Harvey's '"'newness" had worn off greatly, and
he had come down to an appreciation of his own limitations. If
"The old man'd raise caln."
I may be permitted to digress a little from the historical to an
advisory line, I would like to urge upon young engineers the
fact that an accurate weighing of one's own ability, coupled with
confidence and a determination to improve, results in success
ninety-nine times in a hundred.
54 Central Station Experiences.
Harvey was rapidly attaining this frame of mind ; hence he and
the engineer found mutual benefit in frequent consultations, and
appeals to Jones' superior experience were not so often neces-
sitated as they had been previously. Thus it happened that
Harvey called on the engineer one day nearly a year after the
circuit-breaker occasion, for ''consultation."
"It's mighty nigh time for that old fair ag'in," he said, "and
we'll have to do something to provide for the crowds."
"Got no extra cars?" queried the engineer.
"Oh, yes; plenty o' cars. But the feeders out there ain't
calc'lated to keep up the pressure with such heavy loads."
"We might run some temporary feeders — hang 'em up from
the cross-arms by loops from porcelain knobs," suggested the
engineer.
"Lot o' work, and the wire's bound to be more or less dam-
aged."
"Yes. Really, the feeders ought to be reinforced permanently
so's we could carry extra loads."
"The old man 'd raise Cain if I asked him to put in that much
extra wire just for the fall fair."
"Figured out what 'twould take?"
"Roughly. We've got three feeders out there now; a mile o'
No. 2, two miles o' No. oo and three miles o' No. oooo wire. The
drop with two cars, one going out and one coming in, is about
60 volts, so we'd need to put in two more sets o' feeders to handle
six cars at the same drop."
"That's so, or nearly so. You'd need two more No. 0000 feed-
ers out to the far end; a No. 0000 near the middle and a No. 00
out to the near end of the branch line. Eight miles of No. 0000
and a mile of No. 00. Whew!"
Harvey nodded gloomily.
"That's what I figured out, and I might's well ask the old man
for a pair o' gold wings as all that wire."
Suddenly the engineer jumped up and said emphatically:
"Well I'll be d d."
"That won't help the cars any," said Harvey, but he brightened
up under the influence of the engineer's jubilant countenance.
"What's struck you?"
"Booster," sententiously.
Some Railway Kinks.
55
*'You did seem to get a pretty good lift out o' that chair.
Where's any booster?"
The engineer took Harvey by the coat lapel, and leading him
out into the dynamo room, pointed dramatically towards the
dynamos and said: ''There!"
'Ts it wheels you've got, or snakes?"
The engineer laughed and went back in his den.
*'See here," he said, drawing a diagram like Fig. i and remark-
ing, 'T'm getting into Jones' habits."
VwS- -vr«v^
-^K^aAr
FIG. 2.
Harvey looked on in silence.
''All we need to do is to disconnect your three fair-ground feed-
ers from the bus-bars and put one of my 500-light dynamos in
series with all three of them, hke that."
"Goin' to leave her self-exciting?"
"Yes; why not?"
"Lemme draw a little," said Harvey, with a smile. And he
drew Fig. 2.
"I was just wondering about the current in that field circuit,"
56
Central Station Experiences.
he said. ''The current must go like the arrows for the dynamo to
work; now won't the generators force current backward through
the booster dynamo's field?"
The engineer hesitated.
'T don't think so," he said. ''You see, the
E.M.F. that forces current through the dynamo
field is furnished by its own armature."
"Yes ; but the railroad generator is furnishing
the most of the E.M.F., and the current going
out on the line must divide when it comes to the
dynamo, part'll go through the armature and be
boosted, and a little will go through the field "
"And be kicked back. No ; I don't believe any
of the feeder current will get through the field
circuit of the boosting dynamo."
"Well, well, well; what's the game?" broke
in a familiar voice, and Jones' chubby visage
seemed to fill up the entire doorway.
"You always turn up at the right minute,"
said the engineer
"Born that way," broke in Jones. "What's up ?"
The case was soon laid before him, and his usually sunny coun-
tenance clouded slightly.
"T'll be ashamed of you fellows if you don't use your brains
more. Why should you be in doubt about it ?"
"Well, we — that is — of course — " stuttered Harvey.
"Suppose," said Jones, drawing Fig. 3, "you had this condition.
What would be the joint resistance of the two coils in parallel ?"
The engineer scribbled hurriedly, with the result below:
-I
FIG. 3.
\\ 100 ^ * 100
10. t oy^ fci
lo«) tcoooC. o<|£j
"Ninety-nine thousandths of an ohm," he announced.
So))ie Railway Kinks. 57
"Then what's the drop if the current is a hundred and one
amperes ?"
'Ten volts," after scratching for a few seconds.
"Then if the left-hand coil became an armature giving one
hundred to one hundred and ten volts^ do you think the ten volts
originally at the terminals of the field coils could overcome it
and force current through backwards?"
"I never said it would," asserted the engineer; "but I wasn't
absolutely sure about it," he confessed.
"You win have to be careful, though," said Jones, "in using
that arrangement. The feeders must be disconnected until the
dynamo has picked up and reached its full field strength."
"What difference would it make?"
''Reason it out and see."
The engineer and Harvey studied Fig. 2 a few moments.
"If it was put in circuit not running," said Harvey, "the field
would be excited backwards and when the dynamo started it
would oppose the feeder current instead of helping it."
"Exactly. That is one reason why a series-wound booster is
preferable. The principal reason, however, is that the more cur-
rent there is the more voltage the booster adds, so that the E.M.F.
at the far end may be kept absolutely constant no matter what the
load is."
"There's something else I'd like to ask you," said Harvey.
"I've got a car that runs at the same speed on the last controller
notch that it does on the one next to it. Why is that?"
"What kind of a controller?"
"K2."
"Nothing seems wrong anywhere else?"
"No. The controller contacts are all right, and there ain't a
sign o' trouble anywhere."
"H'm. Which controller notch is the speed correct for?"
"Dunno."
"Then you might profitably spend a while finding out. If the
car runs at full speed on the eighth notch that notch has be-
come the same as the ninth, by some accidental contact. If the
car never gets beyond the eighth notch speed, then the ninth
notch is 'killed' by something wrong."
"What could be the trouble in each case?"
58 Central Station Experiences.
"If your car runs slow on the ninth notch, the shunt resistances
are not connected. If it runs at full speed on the eighth notch,
then the shunt resistances are thrown in at that notch instead of
the ninth. The trouble is almost certainly in the shunt resistance
circuity no matter whether the result is eighth-notch speed at both
notches, or ninth-notch speed at both. It's more likely to be dis-
connected shunt resistances than accidental contact between con-
troller fingers. Test out your shunt resistance circuits and you'll
find it."
READING A RECORDING WATTMETER.
"Harvey, do yon know anything about meters?" asked the en-
gineer, plaintively, as he watched the dignified rotation of a
Thomson recording watt-hour meter.
"Divil a bit," replied Harvey, who boasted a Celtic ancestor
and occasionally took this method of manifesting his pride
therein. "What's the trouble?"
The engineer rubbed his chin abstractedly and gazed at the
meter again.
"It seems to run all right up here," he explained, "but it don't
register anywhere near right at Briggs' store."
"How d' you know 'tain't right?"
"Weh, Briggs' bill was so derned triflin' last month and the
month before, I knew the' must be a screw loose somewhere. So
I had Jimmie take ammeter readin's for an hour yesterday, 'n'
the meter registered short."
"What kind o' load has Briggs got?"
"What's that got to do with it?"
"I dunno," responded Harvey, frankly. "Over to Durham,
where I was before I come here, they had a lot o' these on, an' I
remember Perkins told the meter man there 't the' wa'n't no use
'xpectin' a meter to talk; 't 'twa'nt intended for that kind o' load."
"What kind of a load did he mean?" asked the engineer^
anxiously.
"Dunno that," again acknowledged Harvey, "but it's evident
that the's some kind of a load the fool things ain't good for."
"It seemed to run all right before we put in that other motor,"
said the engineer.
"What other motor?"
"The little freight elevator motor."
Harvey's face lightened.
6o Central Station Experiences.
"Then that must be the kind o' load Perkins meant," he ex-
claimed.
The engineer shook his head dubiously and turned off the cur-
rent from the meter under discussion.
"Jones didn't say anything about it when he brought the first
meters here," he said.
"Probably didn't think of it. You didn't have any elevator
motors running then, did you ?"
"N— no."
" 'Spose we try the meter on the main load, with the elevator
motor tapped in between the entrance and the meter," suggested
Harvey.
"That's good," agreed the engineer, and the test was made,
Jimmie, the general utihty boy, being delegated to take ampere
readings every five minutes for an hour. The results checked
nearly enough to show that, allowing for the possible division of
Jimmie's attention between the ammeter and a blood-and-thunder
novel, the recording meter was accurate.
The engineer looked at Harvey and Harvey grinned tri-
umphantly.
"That's it," he said.
"Evidently; but what'll I do about the elevator motor?"
"Got a recording ammeter?"
"Yes; there's three on the station switchboard."
"Borrow one of 'em and put it in the elevator motor circuit for
a week and make 'em a flat rate based on what the ammeter
charts show. Put another wattmeter in and keep this one just as
it is to show Jones."
This course was pursued, after a lively interview with Briggs,
who was crusty and difBcult to convince.
Shortly thereafter the engineer related the experience to Jones.
"Now, why won't the recording meter register elevator motor
current as well as any other kind?" he asked.
"Do you know what inertia is ?" was Jones' counter-question.
"Of course."
"Well, then you know that the armature of that meter possesses
the quality called inertia, which tends to prevent any change in
speed."
"Yes, but "
Reading a Recording Wattmeter.
6i
"Hold on. You also know that the speed of the armature is
almost precisely proportionate to the power of the circuit?"
**Yes; that's why "
"Don't get excited. Now, suppose your circuit has, say, 2
horse power passing, and the motor makes, say, 10 revolutions a
minute. Then imagine that your elevator motor is thrown on and
the power changes instantaneously to 10 horse power; do you
suppose the meter armature can change its rate from 10 to 50
revolutions a minute instantaneously T'
"N — no, of course not, but "
"All right. Now imagine that the power drops immediately to
4 horse power, after that spurt up to 10. Don't you see that the
meter can't possibly shift its rate of speed rapidly enough to
register all the changes accurately?"
'*Yes^ that's clear enough, but the spurts don't last long enough
to make any great difference."
"Not a tremendous difference, perhaps, but with a motor con-
stantly starting and stopping, the difference will be fairly big.
How much discrepancy did there seem to be?"
"Not very much the first month, but simply out o' sight the
second month."
"Then your boy read the meter wrong. Let's see the record
book."
The book was found to contain the following entries: —
X
CMrwe^
db.
"^^rc
;b. 2.
CotoWr
/o
"S^ove/ywio^^f*
\o
T/yfo^o
33e