Qass. Book. .15 3 s ^e.7/i^^^v^^ GOD'S WAY OF LEADING THE BLIND. DISCOURSE OOMMEMOEATIVE OF THE DEATH P ABRAHAM LINCOLN, / GOD'S WAY OF LEADING THE BLIND, A I3ISCOUKSE GOMMEMOEATIVE OF THE DEATH O F ABRAHAM LIi\GOLN, DELIVERED BY REV. HENRY E. BUTLER IN THE CONGREGATIONAL CHURCH, K eese vi I le, 1\. Y., APRIL 23, 1865. ^nrltngton : FREE PRESS BOOK AND JOB PRINTING OFFICE. 1865. w... 5>^ .^OfCONGfif^ Keeseville, N. Y., April 24th, 1865. Rev. H. ¥,. Butler, Dear Sir : We, llie undersigned, for ourselves, and on behalf of mail}' otiiers who listened to the eloquent and christian discourse, delivered by you in the Congregational Church in this village on the last Sabbath, in commemoration of the death of the late lamented President of the United States, respectfully request a copy of the same for publication. Kespectfully yours, SILAS ARNOLD, WILLIS MOULD, N. KIXGSLAND, W. C. WATSOX, Jr. J. R. ROMEYN, Keeseville, N. Y., April 26th, 1865. Gentlemen : — Your request affords me grateful evidence of the kind sympathj' of my congregation with their pastor. If the interests of Truth and Christian Freedom, with which our late Chief Magistrate was identified, can bo advanced by so humble an efibrt, the accompanying discourse is at your disposal. A^ery truly yours, II. E. BUTLER. Messrs. Silas Arnold, N. Kingslaxd, and others DISCOURSE. Js\i.\ii M.ir. IC. — And 1 will bring ihe blind hij a ivay tliut Ihey knew not ,• / will lead them in paths that they have not known ; I will make dark- ness liijht before them, and crooked things straight. These things will T do nnio them and notforsdke them. There are times in human history Avheu we re- alize how full of meaning are the words we use in daily speech. In ordinary life they seem the product of a breath, the common coin which passes with car- rent stamp at all the marts of trade. The word, wdiich is the body, seems to have capacity unfilled. The thought, which is its soul, is only a germ, into wdiich new life being thrpwn, the growth is manifest. But when the thought receives impulse from the feeling ; when emotion with overflowing stream crowds upon its barriers in speech, and the heart is filled to its ut- most with the great tidal wave that comes surging in- land from the wide deep ocean of human passion, 'tis then the infant goes forth to do a strong man's labor, 'tis then that ordinary sounds born upon the lips are intensified with meaning, and the great depths of feel- ing, broken up, refuse to be contained within the bounds of articulate expression. At such a time, a tear writes volumes as it trickles down from the im- 6 passioned eye ; a low deep sigh, a broken wail of sorrow moves multitudes to pity; a warm, close grasp of the hand writes love and sympathy on every cham- ber and gallery of the heart, and the deep full breath tells of heroic resolution, such as conquers armies and saves nations from destruction. Four years ago, a word came trembling over the magnetic wire. Unconscious of the woe it was to bring to millions of before happy hearts, it came, a spectre sad and terrible, and sat beside the hearthfire where the children play, and where the parents find their sweetest joy, and where the loved ones meet to share their home of sympathy. It was but the echo of a single gun, taking life in word ; but there was no hamlet so obscure, or street so busy that it did not grimly stalk through, tossing gaunt arms of desolation, and in dim shadow then retreating as if a nearer view might bring forth horrors not yet ripe for the gaze. We had read in olden story how discord sometimes rent nations in twain ; how brothers of common blood and language had sometimes sheathed their weapons in each other's bodies, and traitors sometimes strove to overturn established governments, till on the ruined wall they could erect their own impious building. — Perchance we who are younger had listened to some aged grandparent, as with youthfui fire still kindled by warm feeling in his heroic heart, he had told us of the early struggle to establish here a home of liberty, a land of free hearts and brave hands. We had read, too, in the inspired Book, how brother should deliver up the brother unto death, how father should be ar- rayed against the son, and son against the father. But all these were in the past. On other national life the demon of destruction might fasten his fang, on ours it were incredible : to other households the sword might be given to separate, to ours some guardian angel would be sent for sure defence. And thus it was that at the first, civil war meant little more than a dress par- ade with burnished arms unused to cut through bone and sinew, a pleasant excursion for home-bred youths to sunnier climes, and in a few short months a happy welcome to homes of loyalty and love amid the proud rejoicings of admiring throngs. We did not know then that civil war meant blood and carnage, fire and deso- lation. We did not know that it meant weeds of mourning in every street and by-way of the broad Republic — a vacant seat at every hearthfire, a man- gled corpse laid low at every threshold — a heroic heart going to its Maker amid the iron tramp of the war horse, the roar of cannon and the fierce cry of armed combatants. We thought when that brave man, heroic Ellsworth, was murdered in the streets of Alex- andria, that the foul demon let loose upon us had done his full Avork. We thought when tidings came of a discomfited army fleeing from the battle field, choking the streets with the rush of fugitives which so short a lime before witnessed the gay advance, that we knew fully what the words meant, and no dark spirit from the deep abodes could cast more awful meaning into words we now were forced to hear. But the word was not yet filled. It needed more brave hearts hushed to 8 (ice I) stillness, more widows' tears wrung from eyes long watching for returning husbands, an*l reaching out their hand in night dreams only to be mocked at wakinii", or with still more bitter mockery opening the house door to receive at last a broken body, or a blood- less corpse. It needed the wail of orphaned children, asking in childish wonder for the father who had tossed them on his knee and promised new joy Avhen he should come back from the wars. It needed sterner resolution in the patriot hearts at liome, stronger en- deavor to uphold the national honor. It needed too the wan, pale faces which flit before us, skeleton-like, in the southern darkness; starved by exquisite cruel- ty; perished by inhuman neglect; buried, if at all, by hands almost as dead as theirs who had passed the suffering, or tossed aside with pitiless unconcern by dead hearts, yet cumbering God's earth in living bodies. It needed defeat, again and again, more widows and more orphans, more bereaved parents and sorrowing sisters; and in it all we were taught what meaning might be thrown into a single word, Avhen God's Almighty Hand was busy filling up its history. But one day, not long ago, the bells rang out a merry peal, and then we heard a new word — Victory. The nation went wild with great delight. Joy took h)Ose rein : and while some lone hearts wept to think of those who never should come back to them, others wept that soon in joy they should welcome returning loved ones, and others shouted in gay exuberance of delight. At last we had sounded the depths, and 9 knew that in the end civil war meant victory and peace. The bells might ring, for they were ringing life and death — life to a regenerated nation — death to all rebellion. No wonder peace seemed a word most beautiful. The grey streaks of the morning light had come from over the eastern mountain — now we could discern the sun's disc not fully risen, but surely the sun in all his beauty. Soon the broad circum- ference should stand forth in beams of glory, and the world should see a spectacle such as it had never seen — a re-united nation, not bound together by bonds of brass and iron, but by that stronger chain, forged in Heaven, common love, common respect for what is good and true. Were we blind'/ By a way that we knew not of, a wise guide had been leading us. Had the word which became real to us lour years ago yet deeper meaning ? A week ago another word came trembling over the magnetic wire. It sped throughout the villages, it lingered in the cities — a sound of awful omen — a word which Americans will henceforth shudder to re- peat, just as in other times there were some names so full of evil, direful import,that king nor peasant would dare to speak them. It seemed as if the lightnings of heaven, chained by man to do his bidding, strove to assert their natural freedom and spurned so terrible a messiige, almost conscious of the woe such news would bring to a million happy homes. It almost seemed as if having carried the first tidings far over the land, 2 10 they too were paralyzed and for a little while could not be roused to tell the full details of the monstrous crime. For they must tell that the great national heart was wounded in the person of its chief, and the life blood oozing from the brow of that noble sufferer was crimsoning a broad land and draping every heart with the sadness of a funeral train. They must tell that be- neath the clear, pure sky of heaven, was wrought a deed so fearful, so malignant, that Baal, Ashtaroth and Lucifer, princes of the lowest depths of darkness, might strike hands with a mortal man in horrid glee at its consummation; that a miscreant yet breathed God's air and walked God's earth, .whose heart could calmly plan and whose hand could coolly execute a peerless crime in christian history. Poor human nature ! Is it then, Christ Divine, so low a depth of sin from which Thou didst leave Thy pure abode to save us ? Is it then possible, Holy God, so fearful a downward growth shall be permitted when Thy restraining hand is taken off? Is it then, Spirit Wise, a soul un- heeding Thy kind pleading, refusing Thy beseechings, that rivals demons while he yet walks in the sem- blance of a man ? Pity us, great Savior, restrain us good Lord, make us to heed, kind Spirit, and change human nature to Thy perfect likeness. Thus we learned in the moment of our joy when the end seemed nigh, that to those words, civil war, whose meaning has by God's providence been unfold- ed daily during the past few years, a deadlier element might be added — the assassination of our nation's chief, 11 the attempted murder of those whose counsel gave the nation wisdom. So have we learned how human hate and fierce malignity in these latter days can rival that of ages long ago. It was not merely that our Execu- tive died in office; such had been the case before. Not merely that a man had been murdered who was dear to us; such happens often in this world of sin. But the whole transaction combines refined cruelty with pagan barbarism, cunning invention with desperate resolution, cool hatred with the sneaking meanness of a coward. We feel that it is no wonder a paralysis seemed to deaden every heart, and make men speech- less with the tide of great emotion, soon to burst forth in united cry for merited justice on the abettors and executors of a deed so terrible. And who was he thus stricken ? The Nation's Head — the Power ordained of God, since God by Pro- vidence had placed him in the honored position, to whom a willing people had made themselves subject for their good. To raise the red hand of murder against the private citizen is to dare the vengeance of Jeho- vah, to mar His image in whose likeness man was made. To pierce the Ruler's breast is to stab the national heart, to destroy the sacredness of social bonds, insult the majesty of law, to invoke the demon anar- chy, a crime of double dye, in that by declaration of Holy Writ : "Whosoever resisteth the power, resisteth the ordinance of God." And who was he thus stricken? The Nation's Guide. We do not claim unerring judgment of the past. We only take the history, and in it see God's 12 hand writing lessons for our instruction, where men who live and speak are the letters, Avhere the daily and yearly events are the syllables and sentences. In this no one can but see, whatever may have been his own personal desires, that Divine Power raised up and brought forward this man whom we now mourn, to be our leader through the Red Sea of great trouble, through the wilderness of weary tribulation. For this God fitted him by early training. For this He gave that temperament and disposition which drew forth from the people a confidence in him who went before, and caused the nation once and again to trust his leadership. Had he been more rash, more impe- tuous, mistakes would have occurred more often, and the lurking fear lest sometimes a fatal step should be hastily taken would have withdrawn that growing confidence which felt so much secure as long as he was at the helm. Had he been less ardent the eager- ness of the follower would have oftener outstripped the leader, and watchful enterprise rebuked the tardi- ness of delay. As it was, we see in reading what now is history, how Divine wisdom gave us at the right time the man best fitted for the carrying on of His purpose, whatever tbat purpose may have been, as we believe to the uniting of our nation. He was a patriot. It is not the means used, the words employed that make a true loyalist ; and this has been a fault in public opinion during these last years — the assertion that loyalty consists only in allegiance to any one set of opinions. It is the pur- 13 pose straightforward and earnest to seek in every du- teous way the country's good. The single object be- fore the patriot's eye is the honor, glory, in a word, the well-being of his country. Single acts may fail of furthering this end, because to none of us is given an omniscient eye. And so we cannot doubt, before him always stood the Union and well-being of his country. To join again the separated parts and make a nation strong and righteous was the object of his effort. Union as he declared was first, whatever stood in its path must be put aside. It might be that blood alone could thoroughly cement the bond. It might be that an institution subversive of humani- ty's best interests must be uprooted ; but the patriot saw the end, kept close to that, and would use the means which Providence should place within his power. And who was he thus stricken ? A philanthropic lover of humanity. To love mankind not for the sake of the benefit they may be to us, not for our own se- curity or improvement, to do them good and seek their happiness is both noble and rare. For this a kind heart and generous purpose are required. To drop a penny into the beggar's open hand, because his cry is troublesome, is selfishness. To aid the suf- fering merely because the sight of woe distresses re- fined taste, is deserving of no praise. To do both from hearty love for human good, is to be like the blessed Master. And as we stand beside his grave, there's none but feels that within that breast now stilled. 14 malice and malignity were strangers. The good he sought was to unite this people. Hence there was respect to every class, and all unite to-day in giving him credit for great honesty of heart, when with his own words he says he has no desire to triumph over anybody, but rather that the right should prevail by whatever means God chooses. Even his enemies who wickedly have striven to subvert good government, were such only because they were opposed to right ; and when they would accept a peace, he was ready, as the events of the last few weeks were showing, to proffer them the olive branch. And when all other tongues shall have done telling his human love and friendship — if such a time should ever come — that race down-trodden for long ages, but destined in God's OAvn good time and way to play a mighty part in human life and destiny, will, if true to their high privilege and duly, take up the harp of praise and join the glad acknowledgement of their indebtedness to the philanthropist, who, loving men whom God has made, whatever be their rank or color, lifted from them the degrading yoke, and left them free to develop every capacity toward the grand perfection of all good. Once again we ask, who was he thus stricken? And the answer comes from every congregation in this land which met to join his funeral train, from every home where his name is spoken with respect, from all these habiliments of woe which a nation sadly puts on as a poor expression of her grief; He was the nation's 16 friend. No stately potentate with guards and lack- eys to do him honor and drive away the approaching subject. The sad circumstances of his death prove, alas, how much he trusted the people, his brothers. From humble life he rose by the force of his own me • rit, and to the people he always seemed as one of them. The pioneer boy became the murdered Presi- dent, and through all these intervening years he nev- er was aught than a citizen among citizens, though w^earing a crown more imperial than that of Ctesar. — That single request, " Pray for me, my fellow coun- trymen," as he left his western home to enter on new^ duties at the capital, took him straightway to the Christian heart and made the ruler's name a familiar sound at many a family altar. The frequent occa- sions since, when even better tidings have been told, that he himself consulted the Divine oracles in the midst of his arduous duties, and on his bended knees sought Divine guidance and Divine pardon for his own soul, coupled with those now remarkable utteran- ces of his last public message, give us ground for Christian hope that the eternal crown of glory is won, and his name is now written among the saved. For however noble, brave and patriotic, wanting this, a humble belief in Jesus Christ for pardon and salva- tion, the loveliest natural graces will be found to lack the one good thing which counterbalances a uni- verse of worldly riches. The Christian hope is the greatest joy, the crown of earth, the glory of the skies. With ic the lowest servant in royal court shall 16 rule a, Heavenly Kingdom in which the proudest mon- arch with only earthly possessions is unworthy to be- come a servant. But we cannot in a few brief words fitly charac- terize the event which has robbed us of a President, or iti full measure portray his life and mission whose death the friends of liberty throughout the world will mourn. We are yet too blind, we are yet groping in paths we know not of. But thank God, a hand of un- erring wisdom prepares the way, and through tlie thick and murky gloom comes a voice clear as heaven's own breath, saying, " I will make darkness light be- fore them and crooked things straight." This is the ground of courage for the future. And that we may not spend this hour without some attempt to know His will more fully and to do it with more readiness, let us take this thought to our hearts as we stand be- side his grave with all the nation. It is God who thus leads the blind. Mysterious though it be, taken just when his services seemed to be most needed, when he was about to add to his other names the most glorious of all, that of the Peace Maker ; yet be assured it was Almighty wisdom that brought the event to pass, and if Almighty wisdom, then Almigh- ty love. We may never unroll the concealed lesson. Those who come after certainly shall. We may strengthen faith in His good providence from the history of the past. It is not the first vile act on record. France has more than once witnessed the like. In the sixteenth century a king sat on the throne in a 17 time of terrible confusion. Contending parties sprinkled the streets of Paris with each others' blood. The king, to give strength to his throne, allied himself with the Protestants. In three months afterward, a Dominican monk was prevailed upon to regard the murder of the king as not only lawful but meritorious. He fasted, prayed, partook of the sacraments, sought access to the monarch, and plunged the fatal knife into his body. God's providence was soon seen overruling the wrath of man, for the next king was the recognized leader of the Huguenots, and gave to France the memory of the White Plumed Henry of Navarre, brave and he- roic. He, too, having reigned for years with wisdom, and just beginning a scheme for pacifying the reli- gious wars of P]urope, which, if carried out, would have changed sooner the intolerant superstitions of Europe into the freedom of the Reformation, was murdered basely as w^as his predecessor. God's provi- dence again was seen, though the lesson took more years for its unfolding, and the God of nations was acknowledged. So in another country, parallel to our own in the deep sorrow it excited and the interest with which the friends of liberty everywhere regarded it. For long years a heroic people had been struggling for independence. Battled and disappointed they would never yield. Better open the dikes which shut the sea from off the land, than submit Holland and her Protestantism to a foreign yoke. But one man was the head, heart and hand. His voice guided, his arm controlled, his heart devised all for public good. His 18 people loved him with self-sacrificing devotion, equal- ling that of any nation since. They would make him king, but no other. The freedom-loving world ad- mired, loved, looked upon his life as the most import- ant to the cause of liberty of any man's wdio had lived within the century. The assassin struck a blow. — England was paralyzed, Germany put on mourning, Holland reeled and staggered, blind and faint ; and when the Prince of Orange sank to earth, it seemed as if the death of liberty was an accomplished fact. — But from above another eye was watching the event, and though it took yet more long years, the result was that Holland became free and Protestant, and Wil- liam's cruel death gave Freedom new life. So is it in every mystery of His dealing. It is a power divine that governs thus. If He thus governs then be assured the instru- ments of His will shall never be wanting. No man, or set of men, are indispensable to Him. When one is removed, having accomplished His will, the plan goes on. His purpose is not hindered, it ripens eve- ry hour. So was it in the cases noted. So was it in the early ages of the Church. The l)lood of the mar- tyrs was the seed of the Church. So is it now. Another by the harmonious working of our Constitution steps into the vacant place, to whom our duty is trans- ferred, for whom we pray unerring guidance. If He rules, then we have ground for confidence and joy. It may not suit our little plans, our seeming wisdom, but He works majestic on — Blessed be His name, 19 unmoved by aughfc from the accomplishment of His own wise plan. There is one duty in such startling providences which for a moment claims our notice. It is to con- sider fully and act Avith wisdom. The recoil from such a blow awakens passions which only the most strong and prudent will govern wisely. We have, as citizens and christians, great duties to perform, duties which, with the memory of the illustrious dead before us, render all appeal to excited passions — passions too which are among the worst of human nature, en- tirely out of place. Considerate determination is de- manded. It is " no time for angry declamation. This act may be made to embitter present divisions, may rouse the dormant passion of revolution, may sharpen the axe of the executioner." Let justice have her due, let judgment be measured to the guilty, let the majesty of law be sufficiently vindicated — but let America never forget she is the foremost christian natioii of the world. The Bible is her corner stone, a Christ- ianity of Bible-teaching her glory. America then must do a thoroughly Christ-like work. He is the model of nations as of individuals. I yield to no man in my love for the land that gave me birth, for the flag that symbolizes our best national hope. I yield to none in desire to honor the gallant dead slain on every field ; in pity for the thousand wid- owed homes and orphaned children ; in love and ad- miration for the virtues of him so lately filling a martyr's grave; or in abhorrence of all attempt to se- parate the nation Heaven hath joined. And with full 20 belief in that strong Calvinistic creed which makes justice the central attribute of God's immacuhite na tiire — an attribute that demands satisfaction tliough it cost the death of His beloved son — I yield to none in desire that justice should bo measured to all who contributed to such iniquity. But when I remember that if justice be unmixed with mercy it would make two-thirds of this people executioners of the other third, and possibly " convert ruined conspirators into martyrs," v*dien I remember the seventy times seven of the forgiving Jesus, even then not marking the limit, when I consider the interests of the future, the days when the feelings now roused in our breast shall be forever stilled, and we in some forgotten grave be mouldering into dust, while the nation great and glor- ious lives, I am not prepared to join the mad cry, "let there be no more mercy." When, too, I recall that scene of the world renowned dramatist — a Jew cruel, unrelenting, yet completely just, demanding justice in his bond, and then look on the noble Portia confessing judgment, pleading while she yet acknow- ledges the claim, I cannot but think that every Shy lock, if he choose, shall take his pound of flesh, but shall forever miss the immortal glory of forgiveness, and the chance to make the bleeding, dead Antonio, his eternal friend. Nor so long as I remember that if justice had been meted out to you and me, if justice had let fall the blow, long, long suspended over our heads, we should ere this have been forever punished ; so long as I remember how God himself, upholding justice, 21 sent Incarnate Mercy for our salvation ; and when I turn to Calvary's cross, and from the pale, bloodless lips of Him suspended in mid-air, hear that last cry of sinless man, "Father, forgive them, for they know not what they do," — a cry which pardoned an adul- terer, took a thief to paradise, welcomed a murderer to His company, and has given grace and Heaven to many an outcast taken even from the vilest sinks on earth ; Avhen I remember that I myself, guilty in his sight, need mercy, must have mercy if I live forever, then and so long I cannot, nay, 1 dare not with up- raised hand pray God to send any man to hell, or be- lieve that his grace is insufficient to save, as he de- clares, to the very uttermost, the meanest wretch who crawls upon His footstool. Do not misunderstand my words. Conspira- tors against national and individual life must be punished. Their lives are forfeit. Treason must be made so black a crime that the very word will be ominous. Our country under God's favor must be made securely one. But there is danger lest revenge, a passion always base, should mingle with a righteous indignation. America's spirit should be that of Samuel when he hewed the guilty Agag in pieces, sad, serious, determined, God-like. Above all, let America never forget, while she is powerful and proud, while she yet wears the widowed weeds of mourning, while she is just, as just she should be, — that she is Christian, and Jesus-Christ in all His excel- lence is her exalted model. In His spirit we may drive the miscreant traders from the temple they have 22 profaned, and be the instruments of bringing such woe as He denounced on every Chief Ruler and High Priest who wickedly has compassed to defile our na- tional Jerusalem, and with him we may weep with yearning love for those misguided ones who have not known the things which were for their peace. In such a spirit America can go forward in her proud mission, secure of the result, for God is with the nation which is his servant. To high and noble des- tiny he has called her, and if she twines in every fold of her starry flag the banuer of the peace-loving Im- manuel, the Prince of Peace shall always make her His abode. The end may yet be distant. But in His favor the work of judgment shall yield to one of mer- cy. The bow of promise spans the cloud, and so sure- ly as it does we know that God is love. Courage then. Christian nation, even in this dark hour. Dark- ness is made light by Him. Onward in the glorious race for human progress. If true to God, ages hence shall find thee growing better. Add more stars to thy banner, if pure and peaceful thou canst save them all. Be the foremost to elevate and bless the race, and God will not forsake thee. Once more we turn to thee, thou illustrious dead, and lay the chaplet of our love upon thy tomb. Mid all the dangers through which thy way was past God kept thee till thy work — that which thyself an- nounced — the re-possession of the places and proper- ty seized from the Union had been done. City after city re-taken, the chief army of the enemy surrender- 23 ed. On the day when the flag of thy love was to be again raised where it had first been lowered, thou wast slain. Not for a life unfinished do we mourn, though thou wast now girding thyself for the greater victories of peace. God saw the end though we do not. An earlier death might have left the world in doubt. New measures might have been depreciated. Now by a single stroke, and that too by an oneuiy, thy deeds are passed to history, thy name becomes immortal. A friend would not have placed upon thy brow the martyr's crown. An enemy has made the cause of which thou wast the representative hallowed with thy blood. The altar fires of liberty burn anew. A world looks on their glow. Thy name shall live, thy memory shall be a nation's care. That hand which gave America a community with other nations in a murdered ruler, shall receive the execration of a world ; while round thy tomb the generations taught by thy name heroic self devotion, shall come from every land where Freedom is no strange word, and with the wreaths of an undying love crown thy grave anew, or pressing low the bended knee thank God for human freedom, rising to swear new fealty upon an altar where America's murdered president has laidhis martyred life. LB S '12 ^