THIRTIETH CONGRESS— SECOND SESSION. Ex. Doc. No. 47. * " f CJ_ HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES. MILITARY CONTRIBUTIONS IN MEXICO. MESSAGE PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES, TRANSMITTING Reports from the Secretaries of War and JVavy, in answer to a resolution of the House of the 20th December last, relative to the money and property received at the various Mexican ports during the late war, 4'c. January 31, 1849. Referred to the Select Committee on the subject of military contributions in Mexico, and ordered to be printed. To the House of Representatives of the United States: I communicate, herewith, reports from the Secretary of War and the Secretary of the Navy, together with accompanying documents, in answer to a resolution of the House of Representatives of De- cember 20, 1848, requesting the President " to communicate to the House he amount of moneys and property received during the late war witli the republic of Mexico, at the different ports of entry, or in any other way within her limits, and in what manner the same has been expended or appropriated." JAMES K. POLK. Washington, January 29 j 1849. 2 .Ex. Doc. No. 47. War Department, Washington^ January 27, 1849. Sir: The accompanying statements contain all the information in this department relative to " the amount of moneys and property received during the late war with Mexico, at the different ports of entry, or in any other way within her limits, and in what manner the same has been expended or appropriated." Besides moneys derived from contributions, levied under military authority, officers of the army have been required to report to the department all moneys and property received by them from muni- cipal and other public authorities or corporation^ in Mexico, as salaries or compensation for any service whatever, or as gratuities or presents, or from any citizen or public authority, for the per- formance of any service in any way connected with their official duties; and all sums so reported have been embraced in the follow- ing statements, except one or two small accounts yet too imperfect to be cfrried on the books. By far the largest amount of contribution money has been levied upon the external commerce of the enemy in the form of import, export and tonnage duties. The aggregate from this source is $3,434,664 67, while from all others tht amount is but $553,054 65. The sum of $163,572 79 has been derived from captured money, and sales of captured property, belonging to Mexico. From the assessments imposed upon the several States of the Mexican republic, and the special contribution levied upon the city of Mexico, there has accrued the sum of $225,648 96. A considerable amount has been derived from municipal and State revenues, seized on the occupation of such cities and States, and confiscated to military purposes. The whole amount from these sources could not be applied to our service, but only such balances as remained after sufficient suras had been unavoidably applied to the support of the city authorities, and to other indis- pensable objects. It would have "Tseen a more correct mode of stating the account, in. such cases, to have carried the balances only into the aggregate of military contributions, but it has been deemed the most satisfactory course to report the gross amounts which passed through the hands of our officers, where the accounts have been rendered in a sufficiently complete form, and to state, in a dis- tinct shape, the deductions to which they were unavoidably sub- jected before being applicable to military purposes. These appear under the head of city and civil expenses. The sums derived from these revenues, with some other items, are placed under the head of miscellaneous collections, and amount to $163,054 65, The aggregate collected amounts to $3,987,719 32, exclusive of the sums collected after the date of the ratification of the treaty, and paid over to the Mexican government, in pursuance of the third article thereof. The deductions from this gross amount is as follows: The contingent expenses of collection, so far as supported by vouchers, amounting to $72,869 56. Ex. Doc. No. 47. . 3 Drawback allowed to sutlers on goods sold to officers and soldiers, sailors and marines, for their own individual use and con- sumption, amounting to $44,289 22. The disbursements for civil and city expenses, brought into the statements of contribution money, for reason's above stated, amount- ing to $16,247 25. Deducting from the gross receipts the aggregate of the above three items, ($133,406 03,) there remains a nett revenue of $3,854, - 313 29, of which $25,565 23 is still due the Mexican government ior collections at Matamoras, subsequent to the 30th of iMay, 1848, and the balance is applicable to military purposes. Of this nett revenue there was paid over to disbursing officers of this and other departments, and into the treasury, the sum of $3,712,797 70. So much of this sum as w^as paid over to army officers, $3,293,- 721 05, has been mingled with their other public funds, and per- haps, in almost every case, the amounts have been disbursed in the public service. The accounts of these officers, except a few on very distant stations, have been rendered to the accounting officers of the treasury, and are in the process of settlement. In my last annual report^ submitted to Congress at the commencement of the session, it was recommended that the laws regulating the settle- ment of accounts be extended to the suras received from this source by disbursing officers, and that their accounts for disburse- ments be settled at the treasury. The balances in the hands of collecting and receiving officers amount to $141,515 59. It will be perceived that of this the sum of $124,919 16 is covered by claims for expenditures, &c., not ad- mitted for want of vouchers, or for other reasons stated in the proper place, leaving balances unclaimed by them, and not paid over, to the amount of $16,596 43, in their hands. Neither the claims of the officers engaged in the collection, nor those of the disbursing officers, have been finally settled, because there is no authority in the department to allow such parts thereof as are deemed just and equitable. Such as are stated in the ac- counts herewith presented, must not be regarded as claims which have received the approval of the department. The accounts are all considered open, and will remain so until Congress shall con- fer authority on some one to adjust them. For information in regard to the property taken from the enemy in Mexico, I respectfully refer you to the accompanying communi- cations from the quartermaster general and the head of the ord- nance bureau. Very respectfully, your obedient servant, , W. L. MARCY, Secretary of War. To the President. 4 . Ex. Doc, No. 47. Quartermaster General's Ofeice, Washington City, January 26, 1849. Sir: In obedience to your order dated the 24th instant, requiring a statement of the property received by the officers of the Quarter- masters department, during the late war with Mexico, within the limits of that republic, and the manner in which the same has been disposed of, I have the honor to report, that, from accounts re- ceived and examined at this office, it appears that the following of- ficers received and sold or caused to be sold the property set oppo- site their^names, and for the amounts stated, viz: Captain Montgomery, clothing, 3d quarter fiscal year 1847 $6 75 Caplain R. Allen, tobacco and segars, 4th quarter fis- cal year 1847 6,031 12 Lieutenant James Lea, segars, mules and carriage, 4th quarter fiscal year 1847 3,941 13 Captain R. Allen, tobacco and segars, 2d quarter fis- cal year 1848 15,310 00 Captain McKissack, segars, 3d quarter 1848 1,437 50 Colonel J. Bankhead, tobacco and segars, 3d quarter 1848 92,004 5^0 Captain R. Allen, lumber, 4th quarter 1848 83 50 Major G. T. Howard, animals, 3d quarter 1848 699 97 Captain F. Britten, segars, 3d quarter 1848 400 00 Total $119,914 47 There is no means of ascertaining the quantity of property c tured and sold. The money received for the property was applied to the public service in the field, but without legislation cannot be noticed at the treasury. I have the honor to be, your obedient servant, TH. S. JESUP, Q. M. General. To the honorable Wm, L. Marcy, Secretary of War, Washington City. • Ordnance Office, Washington, January 26, 1849. Sib: In answer to your call of 24th instant, for a report of all property received by officers of the ordnance department in Mexico, during the late war, except such as was purchased and paid for by them, I have the honor to state that the only evidence atForded by the files of this office is as follows: A letter from Major H. K. Craig, of the 14th May, 1846, says, that there was captured in the actions of 8th and 9th of that month (Palo Alto and Resaca,) 8 bronze guns, 9, 6 and 4 pounders, on Ex. Doc. No. 47. 5 old carriages drawn by mules, 8 sets mule harness, 450 muskets, 24 carbines, 18 lances, 5 pistols, 135,000 musket cartridges, 5,000 flints, a few rounds of field ammunition, and a few armorer's and smith's tools. On the 23d January, 1847, he sent copies of the invoices of ord- nance stores taken at Monterey, September 24, 1846, consisting of 33 guns and howitzers, bronze and iron of various calibres, mostly small, mounted and dismounted, 250 muskets, 112 carbines, 43 lances, 1,469, 12 and 18 pounder balls, 247 boxes of artillery am- munition, 352 rounds of ammunition, 350 grenades, 261 boxes mus- ket cartridges, 128 boxes powder, 680 pds. and 6 arobas of slow match, 70 quintals and 400 pds. of lead in balls, and 101 quintals in bars, 10 dozen signal rockets, 60,000 musket cartridges, 2,117 cannon cartridges, 713 canister shot, 112 loaded shells, 2,870 prim- ing tubes, 15 port-fires, and a quantity of tools, materials, and in- complete parts of arms and implements. A letter from Captain Huger addressed to me, 30th March, 1847, after the capture of Vera Cruz, says that there was received on the ground where the enemy stacked their arms, some 3,600 muskets, 180 escopettes, 96 carbines, and 250 non-comm'gsioned officers' swords. In the forts and bastions of the town, 61 bronze cannon, 24, 18, 16, 12, 9, 6 and 4 pounders, and 2 stone mortars, and 12 others not in position; making a total of 73 pieces of bronze ar- tillery. Of iron cannon, 42 to 9 pounders, and mortars 13 and 10 inch, mounted, 52. Old and unserviceable, not mounted, 136, new guns of large calibres, not mounted, 6, making a total of 194 pieces of iron arliUery; and in the castle 130 pieces bronze an. I iron, either mounted or for which they have carriages, and some old and useless not mounted. The letter further says, that the Mexican au- thorities can give, or will give no returns, and what there was could only be found by hunting round. On the 5th of April he writes, " I will, by the next opportunity, be able to send you returns of the captured ordnance; I have al- ready told you the main items. I find in the castle an immense quantity of projectiles and aramunitiy)n, 44,871 solid shot, 18,211 empty shells, 3,716 filled shells, and 434 canister shot. There are 11,356 cartridges filled in line7ihags. The powder in town (18 bar- rels) and castle only amounts to about 300 barrels. A large quan- tity of filled cartridges and shells are also distributed about the town." The official return here promised never came to hand. On the 27th of September, 1847, Captain Huger sent me a return of the ordnance and ordnance stores captured at the various places in the valley of Mexico, including the city. This return embraced 57 bronze mounted howitzers, mortars and cannon, and 16 mounted iron cannon, 16 wall pieces, 5,600 shot, 900 shells' and 1,700 canis- ter of the various calibres, 210 barrels and 17 bags of powder, 4,000 cartridges for siege and garrison cannon, 3,000 rounds of ammuni- tion for field artillery, 6 tons of slow-match, 1,000 port-fires, 15,000 primers for cannon, 5,000 cartridges bags, 1,500,000 musket cartridges, 1,000,000 flints, and 56 barrels of unserviceable powder. The foregoing comprises all the information in this office as to 6 Ex. Doc. No. 47. ordnance stores obtained in Mexico, by capture or otherwise, except wiiat was sent to ordnance officers from the United States; and the files of this office are deficient in enabling me to answer your fur- ther call for a report of how the property was di>3posed of. We know by Lieutenant P. V. Hagner's accounts that he sold in Mexico, after peace had taken place, captured ordnance stores to the amount of $6,847 75; and by an account of Major Bell we know that when the American array were about to leave the valley of Mexico, he sold ordnance stores to various individuals on their own account, to the amount of $15,959 33, and to agents of the Mexican government to the amount of $87,655 93, but what por- tion of the same were captured stores is not shown. The papers accompanying this account also show a large quantity of captured stores delivered up to the Mexican goverament, in pursuance of the treaty of peace. Captain Kendrick, of the 2d artillery, acting ordnance officer, sold at Puebla, about the same time, ordnance stores to the amount of $31,320 54; and Captain Williamson, at Vera Cruz, to individ- uals to the amount of $365, and to an agent of the Mexican gov- ernment to the amount of $21,845; but neither of their accounts "shows what portion of the same were captured stores. In 9^11 instances the sales were public sales, and in pursuance of the orders of the generals in command, and the proceeds duly ac- counted for. A large quantity of the small arms and ammunition were from time to time broken, and the materials used, so far as they were of any value, in the repair and re-manufacture of arti- cles for the use of the American army. Seventy-three of the cap- tured bronze guns, howitzers and mortars, of various calibres, are reported to have been sent to the United States. I am, sir, very respectfully, your obedient servant, G. TALCOTT, Col. ordnance. Hon. W. L. MjiRCY, Secretary of War. Ex. Doc. No. 47. 7 A. ■ Statement of military contributions collected at Vera Cruz by Capt. Francis M. Dimond, and the disposition made thereof. Amount collected under the order of Major General Scott, of March 28, 1847 Anaount collected under the order from the War Depart- ment of April 3, 1847 Gross collections. From vchich deduct — Expenses of collection, per statement F. City expenses do. . ...G. Drawback to suttlers if.do H. Total deductions. .. Leaving net revenue. Which has been disposed of as follows: Paid over to — Lieutenant B. R. Johnson, asst. cora'ry subsistence. Captain S. M. Pluramer do do Captain M. R. Patrick do do Total to subsistence department Paid over to — Captain A. R. Hetzel, assistant quarterrnaster. Major H. Smith do do. . .. Captain E. G. Elliott do do Captain Thomas Jordan Total to quartermaster's department. Paid over to — Major V. E. Piollet, paymaster. Major R. B. Reynolds. . . .do. . . . Major D. Randall do. . . . Major J. Y. Dashiell do: . . . Major A. D. Stetiart do. ... Major C. Andrews do. . .. Major John C. Bergh. . ..do. . . . Total to pay department. Paid over to— , Officers of the Navy Department. Officer of the State Department. . Total to officers of other departraents. Total paid over Balance to be accounted for Against this balance of $77,.535 79, Capt. Dimond claims credits as follows: For salary as collector under the order from the War De- partment, April 3, 1847 $287,186 58 1,986,753 44 47,050 21 8 ,726 76 16,215 41 91,064 82 25,000 00 130,869 20 40,847 45 37,343 70 34,072 94 534.520 08 28,949 CO 105,975 93 187,569 67 150,228 01 586,405 84 95,838 71 6,645 50 68,949 00 100 CO .616 66 $2,273,940 02 72,022 38 2,201,917 64 $246,934 02 646,786 17 1,161,612 66 69.049 00 2,124,381 85 77,535 79 8 Ex. Doc. No. 47. A — Continued. For commissions on collections under the order of Major General Scott of March 23, 1847 ■ $18,862 03 255 94 3,197 05 2,396 04 12,479 29 624 06 9.149 02 16,724 05 $71,304 6,231 military expenses, to be settled through the treasury... city expenses . ...... (vouchers not produced) .... expenses of collection do paid over to Lieut. B. R. Johnson do refunded do expenses of collection (to be explained) .... char "es ....do Amount suspended 11 Balance acknowledged 6,232 37 72 From which deduct errors .jj . . . Balance, according to Capt. Dimond's account 65 Balance, as reported above 77,535 70 — - — . — .■ ■ — — RECAPITULATION. Net revenue Total paid over Balance, as set forth above Total. $2,124,381 85 77,535 79 ,201,917 64 2j201,917 64 Ex. Doc. No. 47. 9 B. Statement of military contributions collected at Tampico, and the disposition made thereof^ by Colonel William Gates. Collections made under the order from the War Depart- ment, ef April 3, 1847 , From which deduct — Expenses of collection, per statement I. Drawback to sutlers do K . Total deductions. Leaving net revenue Which has been disposed of as follows: Paid over to — Captain E. B. Babbitt, assistant quartermaster Total to quartermaster's department Paid over to — Major J. Y. Dashiell, paymaster. Major R. A. Forsyth do..., Total to pay department. Paid over to — ■Captain F. N. Mioton, ass't com. of subsistence. Total to commissary department Paid over to — Captain James Boyd recruiting service. Lieutena.it W. H. Harrison do Lieutenant F. McHenry ..do. ... .. Captain J. R. West do Captain F. 0. Wyse do Total to recruitinjT service. Paid over to — Lieutenant Andrew Daly, ordnance. Total to ordnance service . Paid over to — D. Perkins. . ..mail agent D. P. Wells do Total for mail service Paid over to — Officers of the Navy Department Paid into the treasury of the United States Total paid over. Balance to be accounted for. $8,727 78 27.392 59 160,486 92 85,296 00 48,000 00 24,500 00 864 00 200 00 179 00 650 00 200 00 1,300 00 560 02 2.180 00 $728,976 52 36,120 37 692,856 15 160,486 92 133,296 00 24,500 00 2,093 00 1 ,300 00 2,740 02 3,658 35 346,369 30 674,443 59 18,412 56 10 Ex. Doc. No. 47. B — Continued. The above balance of $18,412 56 is in the hands of the fol- lowing officers : Colonel L. G. DeRussy Who claims for his services Lieutenant Colonel S. J. Marks. Who claims for his services Captain C. E. Carr Who claims for his services Lieutenant V. H. Lindenberger . Who claims for hi? services . , Lieutenant F. B. Nimmocks .... Who claims for his services Major J. Y. Dashiell Who claims for his services Captain E. B. Babbitt Who claims for his services Major R. A. Forsyth Who claims credit to the same amount, viz : For his services For payment to Lieut. Lindenberger.. .no voucher.. For payment to D. P. Wells do For contingent expenses do For duties refunded , do , For drawback to sutlers do , For loss on false coin do , Balance in the hands of Major Dashiell $412 09 'iJ446*00 1,404 30 *'776'oo' 437 50 766*62 1,123 43 121659 22 1,250 00 18 67 200 00 2,684 06 3.117 26 4,400 00 389 23 18,412 56 $412 09 1,446 00 1,404 30 770 00 437 50 760 00 1,123 43. 12,059 22 2 18,412 56 RECAPITULATION. Net revenue $692,856 15 Total paid over , $674,443 59 18,412 56 Balance, as set forth above , Total 692 856 15 Ex. Doc. No. 47. 11 c. Statement of military contributions collected at Matamoras by Col- onel William Davenport^ and the disposition made thereof. Amount collected under the order from the War Depart- ment, of April 3, 1847 From which deduct — Expenses of collection, " L' Drawback to sutlers, " M".. Total deductions. Net revenue — of which, however, there is yet due the Mex- ican governnaent, oh account of collections subsequent to the 3'Oth May, 1848, the sum of $25,565 23 Which has been disposed of as follows: Paid over to Major N. Anderson, assistant quartermas- ter Paid over to Captain E. A. Ogden, assistant quarter- master ^ Total to quartermaster's department. Paid over to Major R. A. Forsyth, paymaster. Majors. S Stacy, paymaster ... Major D. Hunter, paymaster. . . . Total to pay department... . Total paid over Balance to be accounted for. The above balance of $11,668 15, is in the hands of the followins officers: Major D. Hunter Who claims for his services Major N. Anderson Who claims for his services Captain M. S. Pitcher Who claims for his services Lieutenant Charles Van Alen . . . . Who claims for his services Lieutenant Hiram Russell Who claims for his services Lieutenant Robert A. Bouton.... Who claims for his servicas Lieutenant Thomas J. B. Weld. . . Who claims for his services Lieutenant E. E. McLean....... Who claims for his services Colonel William Davenport Who claims for his services Errors in his favor Total $7,225 94 651 22 31.291 06 1,415 95 66,213 19 12,761 78 224.954 83 4,379 83 '1,354' 87* 13 46 26 85 19 17 62 27 360 00 300 00 5,151 70 11.688 15 $356,182 12 7.877 16 348,304 96 32,707 01 303,929 80 336.636 81 11,668 15 4,379 83 1,354 87 13 46 26 85 19 17 62 27 360 00 300 00 5,080 82 70 88 11,668 15 12 Ex. Doc. No. 47. C — Continued. RECAPITULATION. Net revenne Total paid over Balance as set forth above Total. $336,636 81 11,688 15 $348 ,304 96 348.304 96 Ex. Doc. No. 47. 13 D. Statement of military contributions collected in California by sundry officersj and the disposition made thereof. Lieutenant Colonel H. S. Burton, at La Paz Captain Jos. L. Folsom San Francisco. Colonel R . B . Mason Monterey Captain W. G. Marcy do Lieutenanx J. W. Davidson ...San Pedro Captain F.J. Lippett Santa Barbara. Captain W; E. Shannon San Diego D Allen Perry La Paz Talbott H. Green Monterey Lieutenant Canfield San Diego Gross amount collected. From ■which deduct expenses of collection, per statement N Net revenue , Which has been disposed of as follows: Expended in support of the gofernment of California, per statement O . , Paid over for military purposes to- Major J. A. Hardie Captain Jos. L. Folsom, assistant commissary Major W. Rich, paymaster Captain W. G. Marcy, assistant commissary Lieutenant W. H. Warner, topographical engineers, Total to disbursing officers. In the hands of — Captain Jos. L. Folsom , Lieutenant H. S. Carnes , Lieutenant J. W. Davidson Lieutenant H. Magee Lieutenant Colonel H. S. Burton Total to other officers. Total amount paid over $10,000 00 5,000 00 3,500 00 21,186 48 200 00 18,168 17 1,320 95 5,048 57 3?2 76 388 05 $2,535 35 40,718 42 18,123 01 4,411 01 6,058 65 1,601 30 217 73 724 27 1,017 04 159 23 75,566 01 3,342 52 72,223 49 $7,088 51 39,886 48 25,248 50 72,223 49 RECAPITULATION. Net revenue Total amount paid over. $72,223 49 72,223 49 14 Ex. Doc. No. 47. E. Statement of moneys collected in Mexico^ at various places, and from various sources, and the disposition made thereof. FROM INTERNAL TAXES, MUNICIPAL REVENUES, AND MISCELLANEOUS SOURCES. By whom collected and whereat. Amounts. Anderson, Lieutenant W. C, Eagle Pass. Bankhead, Colonel James, Orizaba Bee, Lieutenant H. P., Laredo Brannan, Lieutenant J. M., Vera Cruz ... Brooks, Lieutenant, Vera Cruz. , , . Chapman, Captain W. W., Mataraoras... Childs, General Thomas, Puebla Collier, Lieutenant B. W., Parras Curtis,' Colonel S. R., Saltillo Donaldson, Captain J. L., Saltillo Dowsing, Lieutenant E., Mazapil Gait, Captain P. H., Mexico Gates, Colonel William, Tampico Hamilton, Major F., Camargo Reynosa Mier Not stated Harper, Captain K., Parras Kane,' Captain E. K., Monclova Keeling, Lieutenant R. H., Parras McDonald, Lieutenant B. F., Puebla. . . Paine, Colonel R. T., Saltillo Pattridge, Major J. C , Monterey Pharr, Lieutenant W. W., Eagle Pass. Plummer, Captain S. M., Vera Cruz .. Randall, Major D., Mexico Reynolds, Captain A. W., Monterey... Ricketts, Lieutenant James B., Saltillo Scott, Major General W., Mexico Sibley, Captain E. S., Monterey Camargo Smith, Captain J. P., Ceralvo Smith, General P. F., Mexico Stille, W. G., Camargo Tibbatts, Colonel J. W., Monterey. Warren, Colonel B. W., Saltillo ... Washington, Major J. M., Saltillo.. Wilson, Colonel H., Vera Cruz.... Winder, Captain J. H., Vera Cruz . Wool, General J, E., Saltillo Sabinos China $2,697 51 39 50 797 72 1,615 76 13,631 28 446 60 122 00 498 87 100 00 $5,714 41 9,955 50 1 ,067 05 5,H6 84 5,981 17 21,849 61 2,980 55 80 57 149 12 13,801 02 380 66 929 00 4,989 98 5,150 49 3 00 2,998 84 621 74 78 50 1,638 86 1,995 84 250 16 750 00 13,500 00 7,640 33 858 50 18,650 40 14,077 88 446 64 2,600 00 107 00 763 32 884 60 7,516 43 1,360 00 8,224 00 720 87 163.832 90 Ex. Doc. No. 47. 15 E — Continued. CAPTURED PROPERTY. By whom collected and whereat. Amounts. Bankhead, Colonel James, Orizaba Cbiids, Colonel Thomas, Puebla Gordon, Lieutenant C. P., Chihuahua Howard, Major G. T., Sahillo McGowan, Captain S., Mexico McKissack, Capts^in William D., Santa Cruz. Scott, Major General W., Cerro Gordo Mexico ........... $11,791 19 49,569 44 $92,005 00 i,bOO 00 3,985 31 764 85 2,419 50 1 ,437 50 61,360 63 163,572 79 STATE ASSESSMENTS, &c. Scott, Major General W., Mexico Randall, Major D., Mexico Twiggs, General D. E., Vera Cruz Trcd&ury of the United States, credited in the payment of the first instalment of $3 ,000 ,000 $159,000 00 14,000 00 11,936 68 49,712 28 225,054 65 RECAPITULATION OF REVENUE. From municipal revenues and miscellaneous sources. assessmencs captures $163,832 90 225,6-18 96 163,572 79 553,054 65 16 Ex. Doc. No. 47. E — Continued. From which deduct expenses of collection, (paid by,) per statement P : Anderson, Lieutenant W. C. Bee, Lieutenant H. P...... Brannan, Lieutenant J. M.. Chapman, Captain W. W.. Childs, Colonel Thomas Curtis, Colonel S. R Donaldson, Captain J. L. . . Gait, Captain P. H Harper, Captain K Howard, Major G. F . Kane, Captam E. K Keeling, Lieutenant R. H.. Pharr, Lieutenant W. W. . . Reynolds, Captain A. W... Sibley, Captain E. S Tibbatts, Colonel J. W Warren, Colonel B. W Washington, Major J. M... Total expenses of collection And civil expenses, (paid by,) per statement Chapman, Captain W. W, Childs, Colonel Thomas... Donaldson, Captain J. L.. Gates, Colonel W Keeling, Lieutenant R. H. Tibbatts, Colonel J. W... Warren, Colonel B. W.... Washington, Major J. M.. Wool, (jieneral John E.... Total civil expenses. Total deductions. . . . Net revenue. Which has been disposed of as follows Paid over to — Allen, Captain R Bergh, Major John C Blair, Lieutenant W Brice, Major B. W Britton, Captain F Cross, Major O Cunningham, Major Gordon, Lieutenant C. P Hunter, Major D Irwin, Captain J. R Jordan, Captain Thomas Kirby, Major E Lawson, Dr. Thomas McDonald, Lieutenant B. F McKinstry, Captain J McKissack, Captain W. D .., Pattridge, Major J. C Randall, Major D Reynolds, Major R. B , Satierlee, Dr. R. S. . , , $J63 80 229 57 140 35 1,703 72 344 80 50 1,123 41 17 05 41 00 64 88 163 75 107 (fl 19 25 149 96 843 26 181 90 8 00 920 90 3,079 63 149 75 1,525 46 1,650 70 131 63 513 32 120 00 300 00 50 00 8,794 19 13 10 2,377 00 9,525 70 9,596 50 82,444 50 2,000 00 3,985 31 15,959 44 2,419 50 22,010 45 100,000 00 J 20 00 78 50 500 00 1,437 50 22.099 13 30.100 00 1,967 70 300 00 1,523 11 7 ,520 49 14 ,043 60 $539 ,011 05 Ex. Doc. No. 47. E — Continued. 17 Paid over to — Sparks, Major W. A Stacy, Major S. S Treasury of the United States Van Dorn, Lieutenant E Wilder, Major G. H Total paid over to disbanding officers. Scott, Major General W. Anaoiint disbursed by him, for which he has rendered special account to the War Department... Total applied to the military service. Balance to be accounted for. The above balance of $33,899 09 is in the hands of ihe following officers, viz : $1,010 18 4,900 46 49,712 28 61] 95 14,918 73 113,219 84 Anderson, Lieut. W. C Who claims for his services Do contingent expenses Bankhead, Colonel James Who claims credit for his services Bee, Lieut. H. P .... Who claims for his services* Do contingent expenses Balance unclaimed , Bills receivable Not collected Brannan, Lieut. J. M ,• , Who claims credits for services ". , Do payments to officers Do military expenses , Chapman, Captain W. W Who claims credits for services Do contingent expenses Balance unclaimed Chiids, Colonel Thomas Who claims credits for services Do military expenses Coombs, Lieut. Joseph Who claims credit for services De Russy, Lieut. L. G Who clamis credit for services Donaldson , Captain J L Who claims credit for services Balance unclaimed ; Dowsing, Lieut E Balance acknowledged Gates. Colonel Willianr. Who claims credit for services Harper, Captain K Balance acknowledged Howard, Major P. T Balance acknowledged . , Niramocks, Lieut. L. B , \V ho claims credit for services Pliimraer. Captain S. M Who claims credit for services ; Reynolds, Captain A. W Who claims credit for services Balance unc]a.imed 1 1 . . 1 1 1 . • « , , i . , , i « 1 1 , , . i > i f • , , . , , r22 50 699 94 '893*49' 3,006 29 's*163'45 591 67 1,743 30 375 00 '360*66' *879"93 380 66 2',964*28" ""'42*57' 45 22 75 00 750 00 1.200 87 $386,892 12 118,219 84 605,111 96 $33,899 09 166 60, 555 92 699 94 229 98' 60 00 603 51 3,006 29 736 45 867 CO 6,500 00 4§0 m 90 00 51 67 139 24 1,604 06 375 00 300 00 225 18 654 75 380 66 2,964 28 42 57 45.22 75 00 750 00 149 96 1:050 91 18 Ex. Doc. No. 47. E — Continued. Sibley, Captain E. S «. Who claims credit for services Do .' contingent expenses. Balance unclaimed Smith, Captain J. P Who claims for his services Tibbatts, Colonel J. W Who claims credit for civil expenses. ...... Warren, Colonel B. W Who claims credit for military expenses. . . . Washington, Major J. M , Who claims qredit for contingent expenses. . Wilson , Colonel H , . „ Who claims credit for services. Winder, Captain J. H Who claims credit for expenditures Balance acknowledged Wool, General John E Who claims credit for military expenses. . . , Balance as reported above. $624 97 50 00 "45*66' 151 43 '547*56" 1 ,360 00 '8*224*66' 122 00 33,899 09 $245 15 371 82 8 00 50 00 45 00 I5l 43 547 50 1,360 00 3,373 70 4,450 30 122 00 33.899 09 RECAPITULATION. Net revenue . , . . ^ Total applied to military service. Balance as set forth above $505,111 96 33,899 09 $539,011 05 539,011 05 Ex. Doc. No. 47. 19 -« s tiO -« 1^ 52 bjj o —; s- ^ ^ 2 o j: 3 be cs •5 M o "-« ; m « p o -o orT S-S o u-2 c S 2.S S § O c o ,r " ■^"2-3 0- J3^ o J2 S CO S-2 I -^ •^ MfO .» S 11 £.11 ill. ?a N 2 .eu 1-1 .-c p^ (NOT CL, oQ « fl S o s o « u u s OS M M o fc« e^ ^ 7~ a ^ •— = o o ►^ o o ■ (A/ •— P ' " °^ i a. o ■; cS Sf.i-1 «5 S o.s Qq 20 Ex. Doc. No. 47. OOOfO OOOOOOtOO OiOOOOOOOOO \n f^ 'Ci oi i«rj«inomiO'»m t^ -^ m m "c ir^ 1-- t>i r- C»ii ITS S3 o IJH >^^ o o p. t« ^ ti o o g (U 01 -tJ SI. S..A d c3 3 a M ^ p s s ^ »] ""^ m m tn CO rt ^ fl3 cj ci 53 ^ X 73 « « > '> "> -3 "> (f:">-' '" u •— •- t. t- >.^ ■'S ^' 5 = ^, . J 4^ s > » - 03 m t>. aj 'iii !=- -- ^ sj — , .. — CO ^ c3 ^'S C J£ 13 C '/-' O »■; ~ >•- CO O) cc ^ . ^ c_ f- 5 o O O Jsi ^ -= ,5 5^ ;-3 Is ; 7 g tr. ; \-e.B ■^ S2 5 _ = s- C — Ol m CO S — t^ ._ s s ° P o S o -^ o o .'^ Ji a. o." ^ l^-g-g-^ M i/i a) o 2 ^ 3 5 .* Si :; — o m^ t> t>^ oiccJ C/3Cy;COiy)C/J''lM73^C^- c;53«c3eioirtrai.O ^''■'ftSi.i.S " S^.2 ^fo 2 ■5 '>^ '?'F F ^ "^ F *"F CO 00 03 CO CO CG cc cci cc fi( c/; cc M ?i "> "1 ^- '^ .2-5 3 !- o o o >~ tn a! -o tn , Cl 0) > V £ o ci '■if ID E HH ' ri-i • •- sj i- rj . ;0 o^ _• O «J. • O O- 1-5 1-5 CK 1-5 2 N-- S fe »5 >-J H >■ u si tf CO CO CO CO CO r'. CO ir;t>-t^t^l>.i-»y-— I '(n '" o m — 5 Q K o iWmI 2^ « -r > > > K- C^l > > o _ 1.. -T~ o *J " I- 03 CS .£«.2 i :5 :3 « 3 . to O o . 23 Ex. Doc. No. 47. C ffl © O s '^ J bo corf CO c qs I "1 be o o c O n3 in ., o si ¥ CO o '^ I—. ^^ o CO o •S^^^ S § ° S be S « C c - ^ »i aj o ♦; = ■£ " ■^ . ^^ S 2=^ t_ vj j; C o :^ t— . t_ . . i- -J ^ oOoo-^Sgc oOoS'5?^-g Ci=c = = fei> .-> •— ._ ._ ^ •— I' c/) rt o ■- m en fccS E-S o o o o •- OJ O) CL» o o cj oj ■> ■>■> ^' :-- S~ b ai (B aj be ^ '^ *^ *-■ c ^ ri 5 aJ o o li aJ S jT £ g g 5 g g c 5. 01 o . , ij - - =-■ c o a cr o a; ^ c o S be be . 0< • O £ in O 41 - ^ 11 ?A be— o _ «So Krf^ -(O CJ CO •2 S c _, .- g c S Oi P o o •55 bc g S c3 eS I- d is' o . , li a ci o r- bcr-j; 0, oj c a ^La >, bcm •> .£ •> •> ■>->^-z ^ s •> •> e-> -3 ■> -^ ;a ■> ^; 1- !- X 1- 1, •r si &, a, ; _« 0) o (DO*© CO CG Q cc c/} o .- C '^ en «i c !- t- o o (C e ■" Ji; ^ *^!^ 2 i_; u - ""^ « 6-M .o « > > to cits. 2 =- k2 br^ o Si >> C3 s s s . fc s c^ i-;w Ex. Doc. No. 47. 23 ^' . ;>, = o o "-St— ,- PO . "= -S ^ >i'o -a -^ — ■3 ^ :i •- cs ■I ^^4-5 g - g ^• 5fo-5_ ^ S S ■S cs^ ^o ^ s • o -^ o ^ ^ o. s - '-JI-J *J ^ o d ..a ^ «=" _ _Q ^ CO " « ' o — o-^ ro O a o 2 si '^ S a ^ •- m o ■-= '-' O -5 .s M.3 -a -a o to in a c o- CL^ a _ *j *-> - a I cj OS J o >, 7i w , >^ 3 o -TT3-3 ^ « I a " 1 \ S c 3 *-> — "5 3 ^ to TS j£ --jl-! M 3 L— -v^ '■'^ , ^^ C3 o -^ - o t? « s=" j3 2 £ ^ -; Ot3 ♦^ ^ o "'^ *^ a a to -^ a c -a * O -, ■" C *J *J cN ^ S 6 ^ «'=^ S £ S S -^ '- a a, o ai ~ o o g o o o -c ■ ■ -. 0) o u >- c- a ■" > m '/I a3 •2.5 .S ^ -^ "^ -^ "^ " ■ o ".> F F F '^ F F r/i CO CO :/! en :« .V) m m CD m wi :/) =^ o 3 5 5 a M CC CL| en OJ *s W 73 CO aT W K ■^ o sj *j •- rt o: c. a r3 '> > Q-S -3 toccoivDccxiMmascQcncoa} _i) o _a o a o t> '> ■> '>'> '> '>"> u •— u •— i^ u i^ 0) a> a> o ^ Q) 0) OT C» OO OO CC 02 tn ?^^. 'a 2 : o ::^ ^ 52 i» -a ;; ^ r •r o • a c • ^ I .a cd tn c5 g>S .!^1i^ a a D 0) :o : •11 ^C\^ a ' 3 _ ® — v '-'?^c-)CH? « .2 i: 5 53 !»(Z! I 5-::: S ■" I O 13 «^ ^ S. 00 '-' -o a;. : ■3 ^ ^ tc o. ^'' be '- •— °- cs _ be :S eirs _^ d S 5-5 2 'i ^ ^ ^ o'-so^o-S-^ ;-= s i^-BrS; — CO '-5 CO o ■^ ^Mhi^q S " m Irom ] 1st to up to mes 0' o - P 43-13 £ o keeper er from -keeper en (Ja " 1 " O O) in a. CO *-' ^ 5 , o ^ = OJ £ 43 5 JC %- w ri Qi W ^ ^g = = -H bcS C be a-5 (S 3 O : be 1 a i'E 2 o 3 ^ . ;g ^w ^ ^ _. ' e§ S^-3 "^ 2 O «3 i 43 1. c- O- ° 43 ficg -o c ^ !- W Ot2 S i 43 S SS ^ »e. 5 be c '5 iB ^ ™ ^ • -^ c o -^ • > Ch O -3 «-, 1-5 1-5 . o ■^ to bo Ex. Doc. No. 47. ^5 loooinoooioiooo 5< r- ^ r-i > > L^ u ^ o ® o - ^ c gj CS >< p " ^ ■" ^ ^ "^^ ^"-^ -^ -^ J <- J '^ OJ "t: 3 t-O _-fO o c ^ -5 o > p i ^ •' - S 2 £4^^^ Ot ^ <^ C^ fc_- c ,o ?:icfii^{c/)OW"^C0C/l(y]''^ en W Cfl y; t/) O'O^cS ■'T! -rf^ til m -n tii t/i m -r ui v: 'Ji ir. m ,r. VI ■^grojiu c/)C/?(y:c/;cn[« ) o u o o_o u o U.2.-' ^ o o • '>'>'>>'>>'>'> >'>'>'S'> . t- t- 1- — U W •— 1- ^ '— t- i- 1-, JC»COM!Z)COMCC'M(ZiCZ3(/3C»C/3 — ^ ^7 in <1> J- (« o a o o o '— sJ-5 ?: U O o a. c-S »3 » £" S ^ o s +j Q-" . «i pmS so. N^ o . e«5 M .-<« (N< cocococoeofocococofoc^cococo cococ-; 26, Ex. Doc. No. 47. lO o in fo Tf CO CO ca (NOOOOOOO 05000 000 a c! o o bo S - ^■57 « „ m S QJ o " - Sf 2 -< —1 o» '-< £ fcB m C O £ ."^ „ O aJ o _o u o .c c ,7^0 = i- u i. ^ — 0^ Qj D 03 qi U L. ' S ^ !> S-s ^ o ^ o — ■^ S = ° -5 ti c ^ o bn o So 1- -Q . . m "Z; 3 .S S2 .71 O . o ^ ci^ = blO'-^ ^ ffi^^ ^«1-gK Sfr.(^ S>;ohS i-iWw oj «*i CO CO ro CO 00 CO o c -p C) ^ o fio W t» n S3 > o »o in m •12 J= si SO C3 %^ m3^ en 0) Sc-;sibco ■ r o c r- -3**Ph Ex. Doc. No. 47. 27 t^'^t-ooocoot'OooooiooooooooiooQcr^o C»9l^COOCOOOOOO<:^OOOOWOOC;OOOOCNC'-iOOO tic s Tt< o o o o ^ „ O O O O 2 o (_ _ ^ -O, -a ns -g fC fO CO l^ ,.-^ s • . • tc =p ^ '. ' . r^ a,' ^ • • • "c '5 — -^" —' , : c o o o o « '^ 'O '^ ^3 "3 ^ S ^ ro M ro ro I '2- "~ c^ I • ! S2 O-S ^.° O OOP "O c en -^"S '3 -a _ O -TV OJ - - - Kl . Q. ti;^ ; • ; j3 re lO cj* — ' — '-^ — c-l ' CO 00 — cc t^ '» oj ^sl' (M r-H ™ Cl» — (N » QJ w J"=Sik2 5 o hr? ^^ t£ .;:.«;>, g 5 t-i — M t^ ^ ~ I i i. I I ^J , ta<0 '^ ^ 'S en cS r— C -> (US : 01 ci. ^^ CO XJ I s i CO u ja o O C O (N t^ O »o m lo '^ CO lo ■2 u • Jo ^ " Si r> 2^ - ^ " > > ^ o o 5 3' 53 3 -a c:^c:j= !/2 tZ! ;0 C< " Ct ' a) J3 £■3 p w O a! J5 ed s a> C/J 3^' 28 Ex. Doc. No. 47. S3 .s o O o o s-B fcc£J (J3 cS ■> s>> O = ^ S c S £ 2 5Q JS O CO 5^ "^ Ji. o . O re S S o ms !^ •5 X ^^ *J ^ OJ o *- m ^ Jii ■- = ■*- eS C ^ ~ j3 P. CO (C ») c "" "O o3 cs jj J ■- C u (N ■«*' .-I eo 5 ci o o. o g" O O t. — w « « a> .1 .1 .1 o S -I J^£M a) -" ri ° K 03 c» fii ;> ■> "■> a"> jj'pcnV o ■> o (/} !/J VD CC O 03 00 03 ci Ch3 .— 0-1 Z^ ~ S Q VH '^ '^^^ • • • (ft -0 w s 11 p &< n J3 Ofc ~ .:::; (S OM Ex. Doc. No. 47. 29 o c xn o c !- ^ /-, "O -^ ''^ -S^ ^■>-> S.2.2 £ S o g si: G. O te — O o tt) o "F"^ &-> g G O " = 2 a ■?:.-■ o ^- Ji S ai s o K a: M so -.s ei "^ 3 ooooocc 1^^ o o c « S 5 j3 , 0-0.0.0.0. .- z. . .-.S.S.S.S* A ^ ^vimtntnt^sory) in m /: m »! aT » »■ I > > > S c i (u - qj a; ^ > -a ' =^ as 00 ■fc- *=* ft rK <{ < 0) CS r3 (J ja o fc^' K , c/; w o ^^^|||«§ ._ • r ■ S ® Ci 03 ^' • >-Hl-,&H>-5l-sO>-5 o s " « ffi! 0-5 p.Sii ' • 1- TO i^ »-) 1-. -5 CO ro n ro CO 30 Ex. Doc. No. 47. © e o c o o o o o o o o O O O CO >o o vn lo in O) ^- o 3 E o O COOiOOO _>s -£ £ u -^ 13'".^ 2 o =« £ 2 c « O !=- CI. 03 VI o ^ ^ ^ ' ' rt j*»i ^ c^ ^ 1 t^ w www ) .= 03 « o Ol o ) 6r o J2 o o a w w 1:= § § ^ •'-■ . tr fee br S I • CO > > © O 03 QJ 2 2 «3 :2e 'L- w S o ci •- «= c *- -r .c r^ W 03 C W • S C 03 ur • jji.a) -^ - - fee == , ^ jd ii oj .2 tj] " "5 (N «N U p pq to w tJ. ei re «.o oS OS w ^n W f^ (U C3 QJ»» 03 03 C3 a > > > (S > > So" 3 J3 •- £ S £ 03 ^ J^ ^ a^ •£ rt "o www ^i ^ oj O J? ^^ t. o "> B..S.5— a m tn ^ tfl '^ 45 o ci © to OOOOifJOOC^^Ch^iO coooo>rtc!x>oinooe< 2 J5 o- > > = a.ti 2 gj^ fee si c en CO ^ ^ b« 0) ^ c3 (/( u •? .ii - ^ c^ *=•= ° 5 > jj -.S a o = is — o o o o o I- -, ^ C QJ -^ O "o o o t; - £°^ o g ^ £-§ O -■ y-j D-— , -i;^ t; i!-^ C O O O o 3 -o -a -a OJ Q o ^ « — § - .5 5 o o -Fv, •" -Q fcE 3 in g 5 (/I w O (t '^ o C .2 ^ ^ ^ O i. - C i. • ,-3 ^ tc S r „ o cc cfl k5 GO hJ ^ S tj ^ U -= ^ -3 » O o C-^ ^ C - X to - a; t) o ^, r"7 o " to c -i = 2 ^ " o ^ -K -H S (v; O cj —• !^ ; o? n Jd > E o i« u !S p — t. ''> — c .-< g »-, fe .-, PQ -H °~£ = o 3"— c^ • C P en s m S >- - > C CO iris *j o "5 ■^ « 0) C :- O M §^ s s a >^ C t- ^ _C3 : ed ^, (U cs . — — - '^ ^1 .^ ? • ■^ Of . a* o S^ ^ - -^ f^ O ^■5 c^ O ^ £ "= S ? -l^'S ^■ =- o S i-r^o aJ ^■S 2 c -^'^ *" Si o " ai OJ c * 5 2 oj t<:<- : ^ C (S — ; 6C, be cs o o S S — iJ^ ^ ~ .- o c 3 w c/5 , ^ CD aj CI m ) cj o o o o 5 5 'n B-T.-S **.5 c 03 sj.; 1. m r^ ^ '" u si '"' en 2 w w w w w oj CJ O ■ o o o o o N O O 4i H > 'O > t> > > VJ M OJ Qi "D GJ

CO CO 00 03 C» OC W2 05 Oj . f^ 2^ J A Ex. Doc. No. 47. 33 o o o o c w ^ ^ o o 0500 o o 00000500COOO OOOOOlOOOOOO iC5tS005iftOOOOOOT:< t>. r-1 C5 ' - rl i-< QC' Ci ^ C- c< o o o o o >o o o o lo lO wi r» »o CN ^ ,-, ^ ,-, M> o /-- S " I* ^ ixj -" o .-Q ^§ 3 el o O « ^ '-' §5 §■£ o . s c £ CO L^ • ^'— « o fc/; 3 J=! S 0] ifs, "* G ro C -, • ^ . _2 ; .O j_ . o si M 11 OJ — t: « O 3 = ^. S <5 > c > > a o O u o =J O O „ c &- i— ^ rv yj * u-i -ji TiT c _= C C c •- ^ 'Ji :/i -Ji V} "O vj ^ 1 c; oj cj o o:" » u "IJ " i S ".2 O Cl'-<'-i?J.-<-^'T<6tH X( OvtZJC/. •72 CC tn 03 o o -5 ;^ _ ^ " 3 c 73 in w- ^ p ^ ^ § <" 53 3 3-=-= « (/3 Ptl P^ .-I T-l 73 O n m O T1 r^ O >i O (U n - g^ 3 R^ o 2-s ° « ^ tj zr en o 3 « o - c ~ ill 1^ 3 o 5 3 ■" gM c Q o —. O ^ CO — • ^ s S^ O w ^"2 g.," 3 J S o 73 c o 6 O C 1- Cj _K( -_ © „ .■ ~ V ^ cS JB ^ O .3 O 4-> 3 73 o CC S 3 O n ■"■ CJ CI c 03 73 S '> ■> C CO _ l-J OOM l-s O '^— 0.y,o— :3cj JJ I-: &4 '^ (i, ^ !< '-C 03 . ® . . . . H fe H,'Q O ta O Q cc 5 sen :g' "3 3-1 £ ,S ■5 3 - S S H, ^ cs O '-J 1-3 CO 34 Ex. Doc. No. 47. M «^ re CO C5 05 32 Oi 1-- t^ t^ t- 1 CO Q •- •- ^ . s '^ CS.5 o •- u . ^ c 5f ,o i ojO -C f^ -^ £ o £ 03 r- ■ a> '5 1) S ■— . i-' .5^ a 3 "2 :^ :p :-S c %. : ^= '-a c c ~ ; av X ^ < E C C ! o ■- o <« ti "1 _^ . -- o t o o • O "33 a ' (/3- ; u O i i "•2 a • o >- ! '^ £ S J £ -^ '• . o O o oqO ro . .= ;_ - O |_ j c c "t: i-=2 w o . .^ ^ . ~ =! _, CO ^ a> c S S ! -— ? Q o u : OJ - s '~ Q : v2-5 o X » , • a i-~ OCX 5 _2 o ; "c >. o c ■><« s • ci cS *5 rt >« SS ; 5;»>>> ~ -- „ to ' ^ VI ^ tfi . ci > « - « ?? ;^ -3 S =-g £ . — ^ '^ w r' K !- u 5 -; o ei Cp !^ — o j3 O ^ * rt 5i tJ o m 73 ^'' « 2 — -C O " ?> fl ■" 7)'2 > O »3 C C cr tfj. « ■;; =^ -J O N a> o CO 02 CQ K -^ fcC-j ^•s s:£ 9 !:, C — « y L ^ si 5i^ C;, fa t5 ?- — Q cs i; ~ •::; 'i' .fa ai'-5 ■^^^ • - fa>-5l-3> Oi « n '^'' P fi; 6C^ -5 P5^ Ofa = Ch..o 1 .fs rorococOco co co eoeoco ro co coro Ex. Doc. No. 47. 35 „ „ -H ifi )00(NOiftSiOr-.OOOOSCOO (N ■>* C<5 r-< 5^ -^ *1.J 1^ ^-^ ^— ' —.' ^-^ — '— »—' ^_J « — CO o -^ «— C «S 5J O ?> s ?i " M I. M ^ « ^ CO C-3 " s o = o ? 2 ^ c S.= ^ c. ." -^ — " I - ~ IJ ... s 2 > O -T o ? _ = y « — i; CD s:^i.ct>^i--«M :z^_^:-- o >-,^ ^ m S £ rt tf 2 _Du o— a— -••!--= o -.aPH~sii(N— .— ■— .cw .2 - c^Hm iJ > > > cfy > :^ « -- « rt ;S CO CO M 03 02 Km o, i: *w a. «< M !«i-^ i^ . o -s . a o O C O J3 <" ^ "3 fee !- 1) a a} ra TO s- QJ OJ t„ ■5 >> T § i oi 00 ^ '-3 •rr Tn (/' ~ CO m t>> ■"T cj .J )^ O > j-i c « J- o ^ § fc£=S =: a; >. n — 1- h o J2 , aj ^— QJ -tv, P,> O >-3 >T3C<>C !- ». I- i- (u ca oj c^ oj OT c» 00 -^ a; S t^ S " ^ S fc'r -g c 1. c: S's;^ o .E o ^ ^ > • • • 3 ^ 'i Ji • • ._ ._, c la 'a r^ I-? eopococororonnrocofo Ex. Doc. No. 47. 3/ 1^ ifs o in lO o oi owooomoiooooteoooo) ooo>oor^ocviooooiooio-< CO "^ n c\ '-1 1- "-i Tj" — . i?< oi -^ cr> co ^ » 3 ' 3 5 = ■" O r- -Sfo s; rt " ® >• ti o J2 — '^ *^ .- "S 2 "^ cy ^ © « j>; ^ -C J« O I!j -^ I CO o .„ S p « = 2 o a,_g o ^'^ « »s , in IS * m ■" "> 5 "5 j3 u — > lU fcf Oi «3 Sr; ♦-> ^ _"i JO "S 3 t» ^ ^ CO s_ < i- *i d S ^ — '■"■ O n,'- jH (U 1> 03 ^ © C 2 i. o © A 5 « b OHOOO I I I M oo 3 J 3 03 S V a> 3 J2 ^ CO _ >, (K Q O C^ a o -3 ca ci-— ^ w <;; — . C 3 - ^ £- ^ (U C u t£ ta 3 13 CO M «3 i- ;^ -^ O O O S3 en - U C 2 73 > 4-3 ■^-3 =-§ 2 - g >^ C o! 3 01 S •— D C f • o 3 • • =i S --o _ -E 5 3 2 ^ ■ - f:i a, S S S fcn 2:5 _ ^ o . KM S8 Ex. Doc. No. 47. 0) 3 C a- o O 1 o o o c o in O »rt ll oo o o o o* o t^ t ■g c c ooo OS « o * (N 1 5 1 o o i£5 " 05 c cc T^ ^ • ! < i o . . (M CO O O o 1 oooinoiftir: looooooooin 1 ♦^ ■ e* . -O --O CO CO o c in s o .ir5C30iOOiOiOt» 1 '^ o c -f rr -H c^ — ( M »- lO 00 ■^co ff* • 1^ >, • , ^ o t- c^ ^ (X n 5 "^ es a. M 1 ^ 1 » 00 33 ■-5 -3 *j ■^ 2 c c c OS e c a 1— a o 5 o :• > 0. M oi CD ■— _o «i TS 1 ift ifi D C = i a c o >,1n _- -a „ o ' - 13 ri — ' j^ = -S t^ i( £ <: C S 25 (T) C c 5 c o a 'i vl: i s t^ M S 3 (U « 'a S2. !- t ►^ oo "-c : 1 J " o (C i" 3 Ilf c s J3 O 12 1 0) o ^ JO 3 ■51 O o c- "Si i 1 r: O S =^ £ ID o s o • - s "o.S coo _4) (U u P ? t" _5 'o > CO 3 o i "i 'V, s c a J/ c E a m d '> e. Ho 1-1 rt „ » g J ■"■^ = «- en .= 7} 5 "-c S _- S s " cc 1 tn "E. = s "i^ - ci 9 c 2 o q o "o 2 a c 1 c/" g « !. .£ oj S aj 't s 3 : "■ Z c 0. e "a (E ■H=^"c: « = JS -2 ""-£ O X OO 03 X Oi- fri P^ a. TS "cS c- S o "f. i. s c o _£ J_ c/i C "o H S ■J- ►-5 o 5 U ^"4o 0. o ■^ 'i« t>i — ' — ' (a ^ >v S3 ^ C I— • o o 00 "" ' cS 'TT* « CO Ex. Doc. No. 47. 3iJ _ _)00~000O0OO00SO0O oooocoooooooooooco o o o o o m o o o o IT* ^ CT) c c 2 "ia^iJ^j ^§fa| a; -= o ,_^ ^ « j^' ;s ^ -< ^ ?^ fcri rt.S < O o o£Ssc=-w*js-s o o P <" M c at—- c o = ° S £ 2 •-: - o o i> 9 J! en (L> o o rrr =. c-c-E-'r:ro is ? 2 > =^ a 3 "3 c- ^ i- r; ^ .:: •— r. cj-J tr -ji y? ■Jt jj sJ- ci d i/i s: u /! •-■! tn a a T. > > > > > X C -" M CQ — o "Z^Z >, >, C- c, ^ . '> 2^ ^' rt _g -^^ «" coin 7\ S'^'^'-' "* ^J-"' '■fi 71 c/3 -y) n K cj ^-3 si V} ■/) yj r/) C) il C) .•) CJ > > > > ID 01 <■< -/3 c/i en cc !» ^3) «J •-. - _C « r^ M _ cj '- o fa r- '■* ^1 5 % C ^ "O o a-. CIO :r -J «— [ is ^ - OJ O <= 2 = b" = § F- "^ o - « o - ^ ; en c •_ — tf.— - C" *^ '■E^ I c ^^ = 5 i o I. J= OJ T, '~ - V . r C! qj J_ t: 5- c c - - ,-" '•« tr II E '•" !o ■" o VI *j S OS jn w^cn to to y- ■«•" _ns ■y3 CO -^ C/i cc o ; fa =5 >-^ w C ! -.0 -- o . v_; ^ aj •— - S ^ "^ "• § -i •J J: «s -o oS 61 5 -o - ;i -cq 2 -. 2 c X t. o z Siccocooooooooccococccxrooojcfsacoccoci 40 Ex. Doc. No. 47, a a o V ^ - 5 ii = =5 3 i« o 'i 2 CO ^ i- S m ^ O o "■' '"^ 03 _ 03 00 PQ ^ : : : : : 53-= : : : : : CO'-'^ ^ — " IN 3 s ci o —5 c a) , ^ ja o C eS 0) = 5^2 fa- S :2 >>- 5 2 5 o c P^ c" o 5 c .5 '^ "^ fl o 5 c— o oi _5 • - o ^ 2 en Qo w — -c si > c3 > > 1. D &- cc Cd en c/2 D Oi O ?~ CC CZ3 , t^ >^ >-, >5 -c 'S-a — -o o c o '^ ^ u ^ ^-CTi-a Oi m (U O O C C- CL c c- C^ «« P"^ i>A P'5 ^ if. -3p. g * «s rt =* s ^ o o o £^ — :? '^ o. >~ f o 1^ "o 9 j2 w Jf; ■■'-' , — — ^ ^ CO ^ CO : c c O _ •;; ? ^j CO o -^ y) i J3 c -J- 21. en tJ-TS .on &— ., ■ '- a-j<( s; _ S ' s 5 tic 1- :- n ' o ^ = o o o l-^TTrS o o c> a; o oi 6t^ CCC s g S o c = o _2 -^ „ «l CO o - — Of. C J= CO •- o ^^-£§ '^. O g ^ ^ ^ ' "oft O Q O o p O o o o 2 O y U 'S O ^ >, a, ^ ■=- r/i (/; X tf^ ^ « 8j rt 73 rt Cj Cj M 75 trt « IK Vi O O 1. OJ O 0) ■J o u c o o ■?■>■>■>■>■> ^ u l> u ^ s. ffl 0) CJ CJ O) IJ 03 tZJ «3 CO M CO S -3 IS 5 - ?'^ c _o o rt s . . . TV M 7) 30 7) ci .* d es c3 Cfl 7) 7) f/I 7) d D o ^ CJ O O o o o i) o o o o .5 5J - - c 0) — 'i. ^o'H^ S S = O O ^ s^- g "^-5 : o CO eJ *j — ■sss^ 2J o :- r •- 'O .- •- .= ^ S >,2- — ° o si = ■= . -i -c -a "35 "« P ! *j t. D ? r o o ^ ^ c in « IN ">'> ^'><^ - o . ^ O fv" S2 '" ■- t-l tin ~S tr-"* — "^ ~ — P^ O - r- -^ ^1 r^ _ i-J ^ I 3 •>: C23 "2 - O 0.5-. •iS.t.S .«JO^ • K^ '^•<£'u--Rb>. -5 [F 6 ^ 5:3 CO ra Q to a3 a5 r- -C 5 :5 53 r: £.5 (N — ° Jr oj Qi >- ^ -, (>> a !XiC/2^ tcccoccc^ j*^c^ro^ rcTOncor^c^coc^corcc^ 42 Ex. Doc. No. 47. CO o> o 3 C o t^^ tC— tn 5 « m ?:; :3 bC so C ^ •- i" o ci <^ - _0 — . <>< m o o « " S o « o^ • CO , r 'O u •' 0) u '■^ CO ,-, m 1, rt « --.5 — ^ s ~ -Q = E ~" i~ -O O 5„- - - - — — ^ ■- O o ^ irS 2 tr. rf r! !_ tr = * !2 • S 5 t 5 '=^13 '^ K So e: e: 2 _ -7 ^ s .contort — cj s rS "-^ ^/i _ " -3 ° « ^ cj-;:: ai w c« ^ ; eS ci c3 2 « •- C ■_ o g « mPi .2 2.2 =' ):! w w — ^ u S o bi,-s =^ : ■- ■" C ^ i- SJ O .t t. 4j OT -j S « S — _x — •~ 03 O -e i •- 1- " c o ;^ S o o S-S £ph « 2 2 <" = !r! &. -So 2.= 5W g • . bl.o Ex. Doc. No. 47. 43 coiomoooo e>* oos c^ ^ —I « o>n>n»nceoooooooiooomoio e»3 ;o .-(CJ'-^'-iW-^-^ ;2-=Es >/i ■ — ■ > cc < <1 « ■p ^ c <= : .« si Ji O O O O '^ g c5J -j: i i ;:; ' "" .' JW ~ Js! ■- oj i) Si "o ti: "S ^ m i> CD s a 5^ IT; ^W ij O t, M O-Ol S; g £Ti:£i y, r4=ii ^ fee Jl ^ ^ .-, = OJ o pap ties m F d ea ties J2 « O OJ 3 > — -s « ?^-"— ? •- O o CI. a o == o aj rf o M !- 3 ci o £. ti: cj-3 -ic*.^ -° - -o £. o J= en tl cr &^ -3 — 1 (N -H (N e>» — T- C^ ^|c< — M -1 1-^ (N C-J (N (N = < V CJ . ^^^ :^ es'o _"««•-'" ■s ^ *' c -£ c ■^ S ? t^ ^-3 j3 £5 - S ^ c I^ c o o a^ i_ <=J '-'. o i/. :t '■" *" o = ^ S s- '2 ^ ^ '^ iJ '^ o '-' "^ 2 .i .i ^ 5 ■>'>■>■>"> &.'> £'>■>'> _ rt .-S CS rt — 7! tn ui « as 5 C O o >>>>• O Gi — ^ "i^ ■ r- S Js'S ::-= ^^ o '=-' ^ 3 — I _ pL, ij O 0-1 ^ C K- 1-5 t-; •^ * . ■ ■ t* Ex. Doc. No. 47, 53 a c o o o o o o o o o o c o o Oi Cj O^ Ci J: o -' CO €&^ < ^T ^S >-. m OS OS o J. i-ri ■- »: •s & CO crj "^ c« ■7 ;-» i Si ♦^ a. i=-oj .> CO • '« ^ to 3 n= <^ — T ^< « o - 2 ^ r- "CO i*^ ^"^ H ^ 'T. t- S O eg ccJ: ° S =J — •- o m c o 0) oi r. •— o a, 5 "J -Is- i« •— > > ■2J ® 5.^' tw Ci* en en ci ^ oi oj "^ tn rf eft (» t^ o .00 tn en g a. 5J J3 O tn w ^ a> Qj £■ c > * > > > > — • 1-1 ' o o ' cr. as •<* M — ' -^ rr !-- (N £ : Z' ■ ^ s — "^ .o fo 2 >< J^co c o O C 03 _ _^ •.-> _c: TS '5J — ^ ►, fc _'- b: C s- '^ = 2 2 o « aj M to .„ • i/j aj M ~ ^ fit a a a y> ^ « CO O O O OJ S13 o o t- r- - /I *^ SS c^ lyj -< — — 1 Oh c O. •- ri pq © pq I— I Hs U ^ 02 o S ^ 03 o o o o crj c^ ro n •^s •IT ^ ^^. :S : ■^ - '^ O — I '" o ~ '©.5'S I 'S C js a; ^ o o o 3 : ^ ; -T • s '"^ -? o — j: ^— ' ,«=5 £ o i s St 7i " fcr ii = ^ '— o n s- s s ^ en yi 73 c/3 ^ t CO©©© .— .— -rt.:d.-_ _ 5i ^ "> > -n '? > "> '> > ©OM©©©©© M vj — M 32 CO M X © O -— - © ,1- .i © o =- = ^ o-Sa -a -o © = 05 OJ 52 tC cn V! J) ' = © © © llts ^ © © © --J M V3 73 >> I O >> 9 o ■ -t; a"- ^ - C- ■^:^«,-- . 00 — © CO • — ^ :±: .^ ^ = • 3 , I - S Z • 5 S 05^0 i: « o P s S a ^ „ *" 1. !r ._ S B . ^ 3 ^ o P o ■^ v. © r; — --i: 2 c. I i; !- . ,.=00 - ! a j; © ] ^__. i ^ 5- =-■=■>,.§•>. 1 1- : .= -S ~' -^ .s -S 7; Cft -5 "3 CO (« r: oS ~ «3 ci 83 02 03 yj w yj y; o3 .-S .-* K -/) y; - © © C © © O O _ .- o ._ , © © © © © en M CQ en uQ 'r~v^ © t>^ © © • *© ' • © © ^ - Pc— r^ = J — r2 ^ >-5O::ii-}i-nEe=;i-50H>-5>-5>-5 Jl bis O o .— - \^ ' 22 f= — ■-= _ T5>;0;Ci2C;0000'H— c«^ 1-1 C^ CJ C^ r<» CC C^. CO rorcrocorocopscoro^^cnfom 46 Ex. Doc. No. 47. o O o o : ; c ^ SCO . • . . 5- • ^ . C3 • c< ■" • "* in 10 1ft in (M j • 'O • * . • m lO <» J2 • >oint^t^t--0> : rt S a S c . 1 TS y; '=5 *" •g p 5 <" £ c c a u ft J ci - S 1 CO IE c ^ ^ i/i — 1 " (/3 ^^3 gj Q. i:; I- X c _c r? .^ tJ : Oi oi Oj C) ^ " aM^cQi^ci 1 '-3 • :' I =* ■ « &. !■ s • * o * * T! ' "^ "2 : ■? • -Jz:: S^ s • ; o C 5 I i: •- i '2 i ; !- iC 'J, 2 H >3^"3--5(^'| c — • '5 '5 ,c d "o 1 ::J H, ^ ^ CO 5 1-5 I-- 6 Is 1 ^ ,^ _ ,H — — . — . — « _„ Z. -T 1 £« 1 0) oro«roMrcr?co CO CO C<5 ?T m n CO CO CO 00 s 1 >> 5 «— 4 P^ Ij o i! 1 ii a a , Ex. Doc. No. 47. 47 CO O en «n 4f, l-H -C "3 O-T s g 01 rT o in Q 3 o Ui a ti a 3 o O s s « tH <-" CO 48 Ix. Doc. No. 47. *T3 5>J fc>JQ =3 »^ f^ C s > >> O V z> e O ^ ^ 1 ^ js U^ .-e;^ 2Q T O o o c o ~' o o o o o 00 H \ -w 1 1 1 1 o — o o ro oo ooo 1 o c; O 1 ^ o ( oooc--^ oo oooloc G 1 c .-c !r~ o -^ in o , ' " .a • :« T3 '. cr S I ID . S • M ^ J o ti X -: ^ 3 _£ q : rt i§ • 2 ° ' \ MM 2s • ~ fM " If. • i« : o^ : 'IS ^ o '^^ cS ^i rt 1 1 "oi C o c" o " o S-« : bj. tj: - 'o •a, -^ I— , o C £ c » ... i) — o a; C tx}!: r; SS •_ r^ C O tr. c£ m-;.2 ^ o oj J3 -g o a ■ o^ — £ c o i 0! ■r aj o O r. 3} od ^ a J3 -5 a; 1^ a oi S = -si 1 c 1- I. y^ QJ O O cj ft a o ^ re --s c o o o a. B. CO « n S3 • Sot: o O o O OJ S J.i S ■J- 1 C o o . t S 2 ® l " „ 3 ~ "- &£ O » tn (^ •- en M ^ « M 5 2,33 OJ ._^ -J) Ui = ■>> C O s a; ;/ •Ji -J in £ EC '5 .5 a 5 »5 a s c •-; ^— 33 w c/: a o o o u o o o a o »j . ■>■> ci I- ^ \ ieS "rt ; 3 J3 'A . '^ 'rt s N . a. i> '^ , 0. S o o -3 C 53.2 St T p i S > "3 . CCS c f5 > ft ll G o «. K,oS - r' ° o . ^ GO •-3 CO ^ ifi I'-. in lO vo o o in iT. in in m m in o m .—1 1—) ri ^ r-i rfl M .— 1 r-i 'I r-i F-i r^ —1 CO 5 X a i., &. c o M _3 1 i ^ ^ U) C, ' a •^ ►^ -^ c» Ex. Doc. No. 47, 49 O H < H Oi < w £t: PiJ HH 50 Ex. Doc. No. 47. o s o 13 ■V ^ o o J-. 05 50 r^ O 'O C* lO tfs « in . CVjiO O — ' CO CO —l to O CO ® ho to .23 g o . ^ s ^ . CO u o ^ '5 V J3 5 ^ 1- (U o ^ = • S .s o o o o o„ > -a Ts 13 -o - kZ; o o o o SK-§^ 03 o '^ U o c ! 13 -a j3 "^ -o a «3 .5*0 o o o o c 13 ""O 13 TS 13 N 13 13 -3 GO 13 •^ in in h- CO 00 Oi ~ — • est ^ 0< oooc ooOooo ^3l3-;;i-0 1313l3'ai3'T3 =" s = c -c S c ^ c^ . Sj T3 . » . :p=h i^ o ^ o . B "5 c « S « 3 oj g oi 3 • OJ Sm ut» O ■T3 "O "O 13 rg -o 13 13 O O C O O O O O w s S ^ P Ex. Doc. No. 47. 51 CM -H O O O O o O © O 41 t/i Ui uj tn i; o «5 ?i o 1^ to C F^ n3 '^ "3 "^ ^ ^ •^ ns-Tsrs 'W-OTJ •~Z'n':xi-0 'O'B'C T3 -3 ' O O O O O o o o o o o ■3 'W^'O -^-3 o o o o o n3 'O -3 ts-c "3 T3 ^ "^ ^ o o o o o o o •73 ^ ^ ^3 "^ ■D "O ;ooo ooooo ; ra -3 r-; .-..Q^.^,^ o o o o tfjvnioio oooo ifsiorfjio oooooo T-o iC m lO O O O o o o " CO C«5 CO CO ,^: CO 52 Ex. Doc. No. 47. o o o o o o oocoooooo o o o o o o "a t; -O t: -3 ^3 "TS rs ~S r^ "is -a rs ns "V "WtS '73 -O "O TS "O -o -c fe .e '• . (n C > VI ; .-^ 3 s) " s * oy^ , CZ! M c O; CO CO en • f/i (A • en o = ^ o ;j3 o o<^ £0 oo oa;cC! oMco ocncc S = 2 S = o S c £ cap^ 3 « M 02 t/3 0(Z! CO ocaco a o O «s O O O O O o o o o o o ooooooooo o o o o o o TS '73 T3 "13 "C 'C •:3 TJ T3 "O T3 'O 'S '73 ts '^ '^ "O 'T3 -C 13 -3 i^ TS -r; "U '73 -O TS TJ C5 .ii o c o o c O C O Q O O •-0 -O rs '73 "13 "^ I lO >» >«5 in lo ^ — -< -H — .-( >o lo in >o o lO in lo lO "^ — ' ^' "* ::; !r? ^o •« > I ,1 .-, rl ,4 r-l C5 CO fiy e*5 CQ M f-l r-1 rl ri »1 rH M T~ rt CO SO M OT M « rl « « il .q Ex. Doc. No. 47. «J C- M — CL O -S « O •;: m o o "" o c —" o — ® a -c ID ^ s3 3 ?3 K 3 M CO o 02 VD w c o o o o o o o O » o o « CO C • — ^ c o o ^ ri -CT3 ;=^ .• >o • "■^ ,rt & M "3 fa E r- C OS >-< I. ii ^ bo* <= . o " a3 i- tffl -^ ^^ jj^ 2. o ts .5 ^^ «^ ^"5-2 = ^ 13 . T3 . -g . ^ OJ O O 3 O JS fa fa fa fa O o o o o o o o o o o o o 13 TS "O -3 -a -O -O -3 -C r3 -^ -3 -3 -3 -3 I"'*'*— <-^— < —•'-IQOIO 54 Ex. i)oc. No. 47. a a •f-t •♦-> c o O O ^ z o o o o o "^13 '^ "^ "O T3 ^ - o o o O O 00 lO lO »o o o o o c o rQ rQ r^ ^ 'rye S 2 o c !-§ H H I o c o o o o Ex. Doc. No. 47. 55 '^ •«» ~^ o S 00 o w o ^ "= S^ CO O I § "3 hb CO 00 « W (N O O ■^ ■— O t^ CI CO <-< s -Our in 05 00 o CO o ^ . • -O . I £ § S ^J ^ . u ^ w. ^ •= _2 ^ >,'-5 ° .S * c;oo-<3-• 00 PC CO TQ 56 Ex. Doc. No. 47. >> >«) E^ 8 o 8 8 : '^ ^ o (n M C' « to • o 43 6 j: QJ m Ej .en o. L, ; 3 . . to : ^ 0. . O 3 • a ; in \< 1 2 : c o O > • a ^0 • s Si 4) s- : £ P 2 E ^ S • CO • C , c S32 {/ a • c c a o c ■5 • 2 ; > - 1 ° .'ft, , : E ! . 4) J3 -0 -0 C C "a o S H ■ £ ; p ; 4 • • :^ s CO 43 C <-> £ c : « : : t5 ?- .4) . 41 r^ ^j £ . c t c s: I s : • Si o Ph i 6 1 Oh — o o ? o , £ a. c Q Si C • c ; J2 : S • c I V . B . U r •S'S ej g 5 tf c £ c 4 • "* s I ' S 1 S £ • 4 • E • c 11 0.- «3 I a '. , -a . a : • <" '. B . . '— c O !- •5 5 (,., -- a. £ 4 C a : 1 I.H r a- a> ■- • .s = 4) s 5 • 4 C y !M f &» Vi V • in t « » , c: w • • s ^ c K ^ K =--5 ''■' ^ a ^ « ^05 «j K S-n "^^ 2 "■ _= — -ji .^ :/ *i « — ' fcr to V -2 tr tn "^ Q. L 0, cS 4 ¥i 4 S a, a 4 5 a- CO r- 4) 4 sj 4) = !» C c. , «■ 4 ..-04 §'>^ ■> '* F •> E '5 C'5 2-s->-5 > c •> s ? J- h u Si s. s- • - fc- J- , 0. c OJ 4> 4 4) >- 4) 4 'Vi (D c-"!/: cc K ! t» CO K C/3 PhCC^CA P, cc -o . 'o8 > 1 > ^ P< ei « S O 1 i J E .E ^^£ -r ^ a3 a t ^ ft ^ 00 £ — !^ ^ "■ J o pi &: 4^ Kr r • .- OIj s- 'b ti cJ a. e. (U o CO C ^ «. Q oc Ex. Doc. No. 47. 57 o o o o o o ;o o . O'S 0) -^ oQ <^ « » c o 3 . 0) « i ^ C g ■r 3 J3 c e a -^ u^ Q. en -0 c b3 ^^ J2 c '1^ _w :-^^ tIJ c ^ s 01 £•> ] o S K « CO — CO JS S _ Ci . .. _ S S '^ 5j n p I. o _ ■5 " o"« 2^ £ JE _ 3 cot— .^ .•! — ^ :^ r-» ^ = 5 = _ „ O O 5 I, p ~ 1- i, --^ ?^ '^ '^ !> Jri — O ° t: ^ "c == "S O C Q .- -Q§S 1> 73 _ 0) 'O tn o a Oj © O C — /— ^ w ^r^ uj \j Qj ^ >^ 1^ y.i\_j m ID u be S3 CJ -^ "__ rf tr.S IB io w on" '^ o CO X *; CO ^1 fife! 3 if' oi — .5 . ^ g^fiH "5^ 0 .o o o o oo — a. t>. 00 oc o o O o lOOO o\ r- o c •O T t-^ ai^ C>4 • c o s- • • c ti j: • o '. s> r^ is s « • • lO " • o . c in o c " • • a& ^ • s . c u • . • I 1 ■^ • or , : : 1 1 ■^ ! o £ '•m ► • r^ > "t. 0. K X 1 • JZ o o J3 £ «s £-a ■% > 1.3 , a. : gS fi. p!^ • a 'y ■ -'T^i • -3 (» a^^7 • 'o c IJ d c O" . o ^ : £i • O • u S 1 f :^ J2 b c c • CD.S . J2 1- •5 > 3 . O : s o g 3) It u ** l» s, ° 5 > s •j=o J. 12° ! £ — -'^ • g CO in • »2~ • tl * «- ! ,£ ~ ^ • ~" 2 • $ o £ : sc: c ifli «. • > 2 • a -o C c £ c G £ c i. : 2^'^ lil £^ « . a. • . 3 i S o * : s -S E-S i o si o c 3 O J3 £ C • O c c • -= J= c : « 1^ = . 3 3 1/ aj « 2 -S 3 = o -= :| • o 3 If £ o c • o J I a. . a . > (U ti ^ cn >• ^ — 3 -r • ■« O 3 S = I _: • o La CO . •"i .S ^ c c : 2 I " C 3 s. : 3 3 '^ S " = .•-— _3 .S'" "S £ 2 ^ _g ^ -^ 3 t_ tl ^ "T '— a. _o o c « SJii: • a • t • e (3 • S • *" S i- ♦^ £ 2 c B ' 6 : b 1^ != "' i-^: 2 O-C 83 , -c c . o o 3 3.C1.0 j= o ■5 -c . V _3 .3 CJ c 3 10 V 09 V CO - » • to a r^ a 55: J: ^ CO ^7) CO (O I'* tn c a 2.S a C CL ^ o a 3 OJ (U 0. — , 0) o a> D m a 2 « o o w 2 '^ ^ Q. 5 ® Ol Qi OJ u c .2 ^ _c £'S O c/ c C tJ O.C aj .E: o y £■> CJ X ■>■>■> > a W L. !- Sm 1- ^ w I- t. !_ 1. 1. 1- >- 1- i^ I. •_ u t. c 0) a a C. q:i q. (D o a. oj '/5 c» l-H ' 4- r2 ^ > (U c ■ tL 'eS S ^ ^ ^ a E . £ p. ^ £ a _t 3 • 5:§" = s £ . b^ • £ o o H r 1— ~" a c c t (2 s c ,< aS C c < "£ c, £ a c. «: a c "c m cj C tea, a: ^ a 'i & a. 1 a < ft 6 • 0' w a ^ ^ — ^ ^ , , „_ f-4 -^ *— I-H — 1 — cn a> C3- c- a> as CC CO CO IX a> CO ffr ) coe? )S > ?■ "o' « « 0^ mno- C^ C-« Ol CS IN CN I c< <^< W <^ ! £ -= i t^ o 7^ a eS '(-1 c ^ &. S. ' o ■< t^ > 1 . Ex. Doc. No, 47. 59 CO § a-. CO o vn CO 0* CO o o o o s o g CO o 00 o o o o o o m o o o o o s CO = in in o in CO so 00 in o in o o m o c §2 1^ ^ o ♦* g , ji In Q O S •;:! • V • «~ ,o s 9 <« * m 0) "3 O ^s a) o ,^ o « ^ 2 > — ' > > j3 > ' _ 'n o c j2 in o s ^ s s ^_ " J— t/j -. « ^ m vT '^ © > w > f^ Sm 'm ^ WCQ CO M CO CQ >> c ._ — E ^ t, -^ *'' .SI ^ — e 2 S c I" " c o o .5 o _, -r S tn SB " 2i .£ o -a o 5 « O c in *^ 5 fcD S.S si r. -5 " « S 2 5 35_Ci > j- ^ ■? K .5 a "i Eiq !>-, t>-> Q C OS .^ « 'A M ^ -n '^ o W a << <; 33 »-5 «*! W ^w 03 * 2_g (N oi in C^ to rrj 'cu _D J= n >-. JZI rt (/^ ifi pa o Q eq Uh >H W <5 i-s c pi .^ sS i< c o 05 C6 1 60 Ex. Doc. No. 47. W <— 1 "«* PO O Co n •^ C-! O O O:) t^ O 03 :6^ o — O '^ O 05 O xO CO O »— C> lO 00 O — M r^ CO — 00 CO p» ic a -M — OJ — 15 i)l5 Q :^ QJQ ■^H^ tcj, 3 O O a> 03 Ex., Doc. No. 47. 61 K — Continued. RECAPITULATION Paid by Major J. Y. Dashiell ^M!^ l^ Captain E. B. Babbitt • 5,281 00 Major R. A. Forsyth .15 ,973 37 Total drawback 27,392 59 62 Ex. Doc. No. 47. o I S o ■ -C) ^ S oo s ^ K- to iO. tE s- o •— ■" o Ol o •o o — (N c COS c Sag a I fed o o S o ^^■- twin «■— >,2.ti'a 2^-2 -I ill S = i3 - a' -is: o . ^ ^'o « = g ^.S--S S i£ S o = i xi^.^-u .;; S.£=5 -> o O o cS "S aj -J •- 0 1^ a o o o CO o ■« O 05 p >; £ J cj . £ S S Cj - — a -5 i-J 1-^ S O Ph o P5 o a CO P5 CI CVJ a. H Ex. Doc No. 47. 63 M c o o o o o T o o o o ac in OC O O O O CJ £ o 2 2 2 § S S?- " § a t„2 = ° "w 2 «i 2'^ -si r- o E 2 o "> -StD bc.S = 5 ti 5 - CJ ^ -' O O ^ ;j U O o c-' = en 5 oj c .2 — o -^ i' 00 = ai — E u ^ g = = § i £■=■5 ^Es 13 ^ '—i (DUO > > > "^ - ^ _ — VI •-" .E «3 • > c > ' " 'i" 3 r CO frl < 55 O W M OQ 3 2 CO 00 C/2 -^ M CC »- f^ _. _ CJ >-Q .so g^.; ■= O^'- •^ *^ cJ < O " o c: (u a. o o r: ■- c o i; o H ^ , ^ • • c c J (o -= • „~'0 • • SJ ^<: = - • >, • — 'E 3- a c > -^ == 5 "^1 — -^ 5 r-\ ^ u _j --• J j= .- ^ n £ c c C ''I 3fc c c c s .- «^ 2 = ~ c (D 2" Ml OCi J. W. Gurnier Josiiih Parrott, J Vance, Simon Do and Philip Chipman. 0; I. c t c 9. c J. W. Gartiier Wm. Peck and Jonat William Richey, J McNealy, William Presson, and Corne „ „ „ _ (j^ -^ 64 Ex. Doc. No. 47. a o O Ex. Doc. No. 47. 65 r- t-- 3C o Tf CO o re 00 •T O lO fcfl a 3 Pm a. -a in o fct-=! s c o 8J ,^ '^ b J3 J3 >-. « ^ f^ Lxd -^ = «^ ^' ^" ^ _• •%-a3,"5 0-T3 2 g ^ 2, © ^ 2 .2 '^ -2 ' == o o o /_ o . o •M ' '• S3 c • Ut • o . . o • a : CO a 1-2 ! ; rrt ! o ! ; •2 • o . Vl . o s • PS • a : s • • 'S • d :s : S o r<« I J3 • o . 3 o • 3 • • P. • o m e: 0) Oj • (S • o3 s> • 3 • c • a • o 0) • o . > • > • s a> ' a • CJ > o •"o • o • a ..2 ■ o :.2 ,^ o a > o S 1 o S ° I en 02 O ::: o a o O *j a o ■2.2 00 -r-i a c. — ' I < ca ^ CO O **i-3 ' "^ ■" ^.a o « ; ^ O ^ O Si Ui CD O cnos 2-—. "^ ^ .2 '> 'o '> S ■> 5 © g (U ci O M C-O a : © o "^ 3 » © a o cd £ o § ° tc.2 — « CO O u o g.2 : c > - >^ 3 : tJtn . v> w tn © 2 :-, P ^ pq £ o o p:?::^ •^ ^ « -S S 5 Ot-J o u 66 Ex. Doc. No. 47. 'T3 a ■*-> a o O = M 2 2 ti = « at -^ 0) ^ o Ex. Doc, No 47. 67 3J r-l ?= CO TS -^ '^ o , s> s ><; "*»^ o •**i CO "t2 l— < c* w ^ s s l>5 s o to > ■53 & 4; i^ "e s »» .S Co ^ ->o V^ '< • • .h O N o • • • ^ ^ O >-" 00 ■* lO i-i ^^ t» =~-2 3 ttj c rt S o S jS ^ S :j o S >-_§ a csvo *J3 5J C oi s s S si 2 ;■«'« yi CO ti ^ <" 5 <- p. B to aj _ _ g .i = .s 2 .2 .H = .ii 2 .2 S .s .3 :_ ii i^ u u I. Si :-.i> o a< cj no o o ajo CO CO m CO 33 CO CO COCO o > £ a .-3 ^ <« So .S u i3 "o -= « O &) W Oi >^0 W O Ex. Doc No. 47. 69 ac oo 00 03 00 00 00 c rt fcK c.5 = "E 5 ?5 a g n ;; g §< ir o- ti B" 2 S „ ..': ^"-^ ^o 5 \J2^M^ c o .&?« c c ~ SS cS * .-.-.5 o v.- w w ™ _ 'C 13 ^ '^ "^ > fi, > £ > j^ O .2 y P5 ^'^ O K •S ^ O 2 o > pq ■= ^ « 70 Ex, Doc. No. 47. ■«# N « 00 ir.. Qoooooiftioinx't-- io»nin>ftooxocoooooo>o n3 V P 8 O <^ 'Z "3 '5 go 3 .S ^ •«? a. ^ 11 ^- = S- " ID c as t_ - g S o SJ] P-^ g cs o c 2"= as 00 » ® « S i C CO M ' 111 ci: 3 o E « s ^ ^22 fccbcS tJ.S .S C3 ; W © © S ^ i> © ! CO OC 02 OJ GO 50 CQ M ce s B o ;= ,i -^ * -C S -C 1^ n : o 0.2 rt OD 1-1 (N CO CO rc ro M Ex. Doc. No. 47. 71 o 2 ooooooooooooooooo ococmiomocioooooooo o»orf;lSlmmtc>lftl0^^ooocooooooc ^ ,- r~ — rt— . ^ . n ■Z-^ °^ Z.O U, OJ O ^ o :? _, o so = "5 >- * = ?r ?, a> « * ^ CS c .S — "X! .-.ii'a .— C (u cc > o •-^ G c (BO £ £ £?^ >Q i.^ 5^»^> s _ J ~ J3 '.^ c Jj; 6 ;r| -'i o o o • - ^ 3i > = c • - o 6- d ocgjogacc^ggr^cjl. o • - a s — — ■ Cl O (U = o o n ftO — '-OJi-iO'D'.-iCOin moi IM CO ^3 s o D fe C CO c. a o «3 i; «s f- g rt ^ N X 5 I, <«-3 J2 J3 -^ rH t-H to "a- o o s.Sis "O ei o o o .ii X! J2 fcrj fctS 03 C m "^ '-C 03 = ^ • 6C ••- ^ a " S 5 fcfj" " ?^§ ^ J,; <* • OO • ^ • 'S" : 43 ' O ' OS . S : . o I 'f- '. .'* . ^ 00 . o . •■* , a •>* . « • u, • ^ . 0) . CO X> • ' a : &q o , b •I? : S I'i : 55 m «-> S S cS II! '-'•3 si 3^ Ex, Doc. No. 47. 73 O > I fe N ^ • * :; sJ >~> >, s« aS s- = '^ ►_ .t> O C3 , _- !=. -T Si 0) .- q ^ _ co-g CO « O it o< I^'-Eo" a « F 05 S "^ ^ " ^ f^ , -^ - £ c.-^^ .s» o oo o og -t; >o 0) ^ o - Js is^ 1-clo 1e «! a 05 <3 rtO 7, S «5 .. 0-.2 tn -, tfi r- O S dj c '^^ ® a O !- coco .2 c > ti > c: > *■ ^ O J:^ 0-2 C-cj S3 ffl^ a; .- o .H! 0.2 ..a > -= > 5 2 il -5 u -G O A Ji o o O O C !.< "^tS o.^ ^ £ ^'£ S^" .^^ O o t) as > f" ■> f a> = c^ —I (N — o 00 o Tt c .n c/5 a o S . ai cj 2 tr o a i- ci •« Se; •J ffi H^; czi !i; aj c ^55 ii^ c-5 =^ O CC o .2 o o OOhJOQ Ex. Doc. No. 47. 75 o 8 '1^ be .55<» * t- G ■■« o s e (L O = t^ .-'"-. P o = S O 3 S O » ^ o- ^ o a> b£ S " ♦^ /^ H ra « O) OJ s a 2 « -. ~ -r o .a a = ^ lO M M IN to lO «5 o .2 •"O '^ "a o o o o oo r> ;C T u CO ej 11 § VI u O tn S) ,, i- c <" sar. . "1 _. E Cm • ii — • — o : " .- to cj • O) P a> •= o S-:3 5 o o • >-S >^ '-3 £ *= t: 0) = '^ u * c > ^ — C o aj [« -^ (M CO -3 c 00 • «J : a u «j -a ,T, 5^ ® S ci o ?J o = ^ © -3 C •- .— C in O p crt U > U :w fcc,2 '3 «i — tr 0) 2^ 3 aj _ _ ^'v, .i; C 0/ ^ 5 * cr> > -c > -a c li I- o W 03 ■-< » S !? 5 >. £f I jio c .£ 5 1 1; 02 H&^ i 5S . . es «• . I ; 0) © • ^ J3 , • .S a • v> . I c ; • "^ • • ^ : i^ i • w • 5 d - CS g 00 OT "^ 00 0> g I^ o 3 a .— lU 1< '» - • .ti • > 4> HI c — Ji >G0 = S di a, PL, p^ d, pq .S a K=P S oi P I Ex. Doc. No. 47. 77 OS en S « ^ a CO u >® ■-5 5j •-> OS tn h OS *^ rt *^ M •/! » Ol (D (1> on^ r3 > s ■gs «©♦ . Fi . « .'tJ < • 03 30 • • • c * : • • "O M . I s . Id • J3 . -a . . or! c . . -0 e3 . "(N tn . J! • &4 . 3 • M ; • ■-3 . C . rt oj ■> fa ■ 0) 30 2 *-. c oi ? j^ ^ O 00 OS ^ -a cS £ S - 2 ,M c: 05 oi ■^ t- in 5 * "5 CO (» CO ^00 4) C "3 ta g * O G^r Pj 78 Ex. Doc, No 47. :3 a a o O ce p °° " en" 0-3 C» r-2 c 2 11 O) _, K tn O tfi cS " i * r-'cn ^ „ oi (U (« .2 O £•= c-S .2 K fi .2 ® cc - 2 .£ o ^ '-^ * ci !« oj 1, ~ J; ■ 2 S S a k o . 13 o ^ en --; S-* ^ s *-=^ s 2 CI. S 5 gi ffi ?J rl< riS ^ S «* ° O !--2 2 03 II 5 2"-5 o £ ^ = a •= o _ &JJ.2 "? Kr:= Ci, ^ 1- CC^ . ^ cfi «J C t/> ^ " ■■ p ° - S- o &•" " g fcr] ■« "^ S i« IS «* e^ rH §0(02 Ph 4).S .2 S OfJ — ' m o 2^ =a O 03 c CO =S5 a Ex, Doc. No. 47. 79 in • . OJ 3 O „ Mt/3 S bog Pi e o a> S;3 o 7i * S o -S ».=3 ^ - • « s >- -; " ' _C .i Kl „ E C ^ tJ § 'u § w ti $ ° ei ° o (D O =■5 0-3 -- o 2 C S «! T3 c s ,- >5 °^ '^§ t, 11 2 3 C S3 S O -S .. O o (B rii2— °- S ij « « £ s ^=^ ;i 01 !^ 1=! ^ § § iT t- <» o. o 0^ J? 4/ U S *j .— < ^ 3 cS t. O O 1- s a (U s c «^w tn » -SC3 o) 'be o JS bti 03C^ O4 ^J 2 ^ &■ 3 3 o bC-S -n o M c I. S •» rf- iJ-rs S- 2 c m ^ c a !« S jao to i=-c-3 "MH (D ::= c «j a .2 c D. <« c-"0 jn. ♦.^ c o a X a !-! <1 W -^ W •^ — ■ X/i ^ • — «^ es oo 5 !< s o o •— m g« C.3 '-' » "-I ro -H c< T-i rt O P )-l tM ofe Ex. Doc, No. 47. 81 CO c* CO ^ — r-i OT W U %, — 1-1 7-1 Si ^ 2 £ o O ID B - *J o I " I— I : s s ® .2 ' o 2 § •^ '" * c a. .■ « -w ^ - _; . -a sis = =£« * j^ b b. ■»1 ») to ~ 1. *' a - " ^ - OS T3 >1 g £ "^ Oj 3 O .2-- S^— a o ^ 5 o ^ a o en »-_ 5 I, i.c-Jtr-'— '' ■ "" y. tfl O 5J *" ■" lisle t«'^'w c s o ;= .~ S C '-1 c — o *o s >.a ^ o c5 • — >, Fr >i< ■^•■* ^ "^ 4) o = "^ 3 °* ■'^ 03 ><. ij — i5SM»-liZ3 (N Oi PL| OQ ftl W Cl| W &< s a wo - a:; § ^-6 a: — c « -2 •= oS •^ S ■ "^ § i 2 -!« ° JD — CO 0'^ £ 5 « to .O O 5 03 ^ *^^ !^ >.«« • — c en c i^ f o c ^ = " o fe fc. 2 5 1>. o >o >n o o 5 00 o o o c — rr N C»7 1-1 i-i 2 i^; be m [ y 3 03 in a. 11 . «2 1 S ^ f? S - o i. ■*' -1*1 Mtt (N « ^ , f3 lO w, 'fj S g C Oi oi€ft 03 d u 2 o S "« '^ -H o o c s j~ "1 *t^ o3 rf , _ ■— ' r 4j 4; ^ ^ >^ ® "^ *" '^'(M -a OQ » cvj !N »-i (2.00 « 9 g >^ig2l^ -^-= ?^-= 2 -=«•"= 0) a-o ■;:i D s -. -- — ■^ = "' ^^§ i-i W 1-1 '* *< lO ^ O 01 03 1^ a . :S a w| 12; ^H u PL * Ci >o m Ex. Doc. No. 47. S3 O Q r-< M O '-' — ' -= • ^ i- _r O "j- : s tOoJ ^.O 5 S "tj « c o C CO ^H C i- .%^ gr- i m S si (B &. Or o cm 5 o i.-^ 2 ?^ - '^ S, 2 •- 1. ^ C -= IC O o in o „ o o *•= ■ o o it ■- -= o ■ o .-r: o {,5 „ o fcn tfi •- '^ S CK o o 4^ 0-- c be t2 .E o" X S -§§ c o 15 a 2 o K o - ^ ^ r^ „ — TO o »> a c ^ Q " il 1.2 « to P, *=•£ O s ^ s S"® -2-=2 ^ - - 03 tl. j3 Bj « aj ti :- o s (S S M £ § ^ _ •-- ''^ *^ ■" 55 „ ID ;2 =^-- S „ tc « > o r~'T3 OC CO O 6'g -^w J3 (D 1- C o ^ o s, •%, o t>-. ?; -a S £- o o) a o "Scot— 0) as £ c — r— — 7( K 2 ^ S Ex. Doc. No 47, 83 2 : « 'S • ■* S-i • -^ o C S *= 2 S H S g . £ ^'f= 03 O >^ S = 4> .- I ^^ • ,_ C I- *^ r; »! c 0) "■ "^ s- o >• o « . © c o o i; •'; o I :z:u-S H ^ I >'3 o S 10 ^ '^ -^ in •-< >. ■^ ^ ,1 =^'^ S fi o ■g cS &._ ^' S -^ &10 _ _, _ a. o c o 5^ o 1- m S) I, J2 3 i5 PS W-hC^' =" o O) 03 - en > ^ O o ^ a s2 ii a 1) a! M :;s '^ a *^ O p tc = 0) o — in cd 4= 2 o Oi-5-a s a c O ^ w ,0 O 1- t^ -; — !-. C O £2f|-§ a to a G^ ^-^ S3 St rt p c 4) w o O ; CJ 3 cj +^ c ■> O ■> 1-1 'i i. o i< s. o ^ 09 a coPh t» cr ei -a -3"0 ,s (D (D © O C O O 3 ^ « e/3 7; J O «3 U lU , 0.-S — T3 3 m O o (U -.■3 w tzi en ' e i =- !- ) 3 O o o > S^-=J3. ' & O C (B 1 ...^ S C C Si^ o a = i-j c S 0-5 es SO = .S .2;S si's, sa -3 6C. .3 «> 3 O Si3 ccO < f^ o" I? = P OS H 3 j H t; a s ><^ • • C o ■ u ^ en a aiJS "2 c s o a «3 cS • g 2 £0 2:f 2 ?3 -n ^^ -fc^ "^ H ^■^ - -J ..^ ^ T3 t^C^'^aoo — — ■ — — 1-^ c* C4 w ^* c^ r> ':^ H fi»ooo 00 in — ** C< •-< a 00 b4 N '. • • 1-5 -5 ::i|Ji .5 CO 1^ a r3 -a c c . • a ? — : : 43.C • • oj "^ be 03 I- c 03 a ' 2 • 13 !t3 H4 S GO M a- 1 u be a 'fcc _, 03 • ^ •"a 1 < 'a. S 05 s • • • -4-; ..-» C3 •^ : : : u^ t ^ >5 a o3 '.S c . 03 c c . : :^ >,«^^ '-I b ^ !-i : '. • S.g'S 22 • • • >H ^ P J- • • • 03 e i: a^ : : ^--ll-i . . . a5=-^ 71 S . . . c3 -03 rt 5 s c c OJ "^ s-S-S.a g^.2-- . . . U S S-i . . . 03 ^ C3 . >^^ ® S !=« ■§=^ ^^-^ ■ <« ^ « "^ .2 -.2 -^ = a ® = Sr; ^ oi : 'S . = 2 .5 S 1 0) w IB S ■ aj ■ 6 1 1 ■3 • . . « • . . . Si . ci S a. • . . . 03 . . . 'O 'S -a" S t H I e r ■5 . 13 _ - C - K' . t c 1 .i i : 13 : 14 a g^-sicS^'cCoii-;^ §«< H i3^ H^ ^ '-I — ' M (M n 10 «c ■» 00 s 03 < (M (N CM C^ CN (r* C<<>i C^8 " , ffj ^' s a o< a> i^ c3 1 c« fe< ^ "^ . 1 •o o 3 kO « >£■ h. «J >o O s m ffl • c: ir o c ^ C5 u > • GO * C 3 "o o -."-J Or). ,^_> fcc Q 1 S Sp a! & s • a si c fcl o » '5 o •— • r2 si o "55 1 •73 c Oj s S o « 13 C as o a u. c o 7 as > o c o o W) o O tc s s o .'-^ -"^ ^ : c t« 4^ ;= .0) ° 3-3 >^" c -a B 0) to" ID -3 « S o . — ID . s2 : o ■" ; s !- : /=^ to 'S 1^ ^ " 3 j^ eS lO 3 -t; - cc 'c3 ^1 ': d > c*^ _c c^ a - ; o£ -- J3 -a Si o s 1 s 2 S ® 'o J= ® o © s 3 -3 o >-. S 75 rt c. 3 =■ c a S ' " > St = o 3 „ i2 c u "2 m o > ; >■. 3 a ■ c C c ! > . 0. . c c WE s = .1 ^ o ^g-? (53 > o 'ij r = w m fcl.S « 2m : c g S3 ^ = -S o c- a. ^ -r c c ® ej c S CD • C V. in C tn Ch 0.0 ; 2 fi • 1? o S-i .o c -3^cr S IS - i|4 3:h a . i- 1. t- 1^ I- i ■— 12 -£ -^ t2 g ' ."2 rs r5 r? :s rs > o. S ® H .2 ° '5 ci 1 '^ 3 -id : a 0) V is - ' a. c j 5 '5 '5 '5 '5 '5 _ o. o. a. c c ff. :« ifi cfl j ci O OJ 5 ' v (d > ~.^ b 3 ^ Oh* ■g o -^ -< O O C r-^ ^ "* 1 Q oo ' Ex. Doc. No. 47. U.J i bS_^ si £ — « s « 0) *- — J3 S £ ^ •- o S ■- —•'•■'" a* 5j oj S -^ ej m jS '75. = ■- ^ U) £ c I § - sS > O •■2 -• to t^ «2 "> s^'> S ^ 3 «•:;:— 3 c o " S - •—.So ° S " g 'O c __ Ci O 03 jj = o M £ = O C S o o S ■> ■y'S 2 Pm 02 CC CO CO o o o -o t- o = = c > > O .2 ffi »J Or® • 1^1 P S_ ;-S c *— 2 ■~ \n 15 ^ r- v^ . ^ ^ - j3 2.H So > o g s^ o . S Itfil « -m ^ « .' OS'S "S s _ Ft.* JS aJ > £ D. © (M o **J= OS ^ o o >. u o tj o 3 o ^ lU l/( c U4 H . lO o • . . t^ • csi . . B 3 . • J3 03 • "-3 ; . j: . <» CO • .w ; q o ; -G . • m t- : •■ a JS • . ^ . • u © . . L. a • © • • J3 > • i'"© © • • 1m • O ■ u o . o • c: y • • "^ © • ■ js c • tf . : s .~ as fe o _« t^ c« » oc« o Ifl a o a -^ -S -2 • ■§ '■ u ' 2 s= JioS<= = 2cs © -s 2!^ © . o ©.2 > ^ > c > . © •_ © © ©.2.2 S- %t © © CQ 00 ts .2 .2 p5 -N !N •nc^oci^'^iCJ^cr. <7>^ 3 £3 O o Ph J= J=! J- S 1. -C -^. y o O fc. s a a — • 03 — ^ in •^ (N 1- c_ m ri 5e-= = ■~ in ■ - 5 " eS »- ^ CO S S 5 o o c Jr; o >-2 si 0) tn s ■^ o o = E- '- •- o. ■" _ c.in (M o m * si ^ OS ^ s sS c^o •- on s • - -^ 05 03 C •2 9 P = d N ■- Oi =J ■' Ex. Doc. No. 47. 89 cti o d o 1= 2 -^ i — tj) nj ^ " !^_2'S •-= '— -3 ^ ^ t — . = '^ ci o ^ o _ j^ "2 c ■■3"5 ~, -S V; c ffl ^ 33 a '-s; '— tc '— ^ O o c C c »; ^ ^ O r- 3 '=-■ .2.2 *^ £ ^^ ?*. S £ s S 5 *= 'S o 'S t 'S c --i iH « -_i JJ o a a r, := ■Ji'7: ■- D ■- ~ m &i; be o tx9 g •r -P 6I-S bi p .::•:; .£: 5 C50 O O 3 S 6 w ~ S ci 0^ 2 ^- c o o •i| 2 o cj i; oj ^^ CD .^ »S ,S^ --M .S: > p^ > ^ > *« :- ^ « be i:j <; b r o o ■- > be H '/3 O OT H OS ^ A 1) & 4) en BQ Oi »-. ^ c — C 6» .__. >, %< ■^ O 5H 2 ».ti c PU g 03 ■w .2 — 'O tti I" tJ 5 i« ee -^ .2 o o « »-. 2 ■- '" .S^> o •o I i^ a o J. br = i;-^ £ « M U 90 Ex. Doc. No. 47. .s a o O P^ o <^ — o o " f^ :: .- e '*- — ' j- ^ "S c o SS -=-? 3 S S " O O -u -'J i/3 3 S t- O a OJ *j ^ © rt eS •- ;;) :-> £ii^ !» s -^X >~ c« . C w m:£ a) C • ffiaiffio o .-TS oo (.N "3 -c S " = 1-' E •- _, 1" ci - ^ o :i o S OS ' 2 * S n •" :; ^ = ■■;3 "a ^ £ s £ c o 33 S O « fl §- 2S S- C!j O >, 01 -3 .^ 03 "S- 2 5 _C- o ^ o O — S o "S " > (N g S ^^ o e3 rt 03 O eS 2 «* ^^ « ^ o ^ a 1^ *-" oi fli -G 5^ w 0.3 o "^ .2 53 ■^ -2 s"3 — Z-s"^ 3 ? o "z; aj -H ■-•-H =? c8 ;i; 33ii OJ 33 O) c: •tJ » — n; .2^ 5'.2 S CO 03.2 >— OJ — »>^ = ^ ^ 53 = -3 V) r-i m a -3 ._ 0^ a V c c: <» . i' P . 2 «3 n ft > C; |> »-j js !- ci O 4> =^ ^ p ^ a « I ^ t: -' « .2«, O) J ~3 - < M D Uj "3 P Oh a; rf) a c a S \m H o- " . >-. . * *j - o S ^ a S . a ^ |J«1 U Ex. Doc. No. 47. 91 o o s o o o o g o o o o o o o o o o •*• o o oc l^ ov o in o • o b' CJ - C£ oj = s £l JB ® c S ^ c = ^a :-£ '■•* o CO CO 03 tZ3 w'~ o ^=^ ^ tx; .- -^ 3 > a. o ® «.ti O ^- ^"^ t2 o " SB ^ o a g o s s;^ SS^ 2 o a> 3 ^ S 2 i; "^ 3 53 2.:'=^ P g g '^^ « I o a^ w I O o o O " cJ -3 .S i> cs > ;-■ ^ s^ o V a> CQ CO 03 month iiiterp St Ma c • i t: . o a 03 "' 2 ■ w e. ,« o MtDo M ^ ; b/) ^'> -. c t> S o O PW iM .£■3 o -^ m ^ « ,.0 IT 0» O" ^3 w .ft OC —5 'f-. " § p~ S '*< :^ 4^ ^ 2 2 — • ■•n M aJi '^'^ c w a = o — .,0 Ol « o * ^= ! , S . a I ,J3 . Xi , ; ^ . j2 , s . & • Ch . a • c • • • * . X • X • s : § : -. . ^ , coo ^ . 9'y: u —' i-i • cS o Si -iT t:; OS -c '^ t -5 a — ?■ "^ i:; "C 3 = 5" o *^ o ■« = u s ^ "* a^ '"• O tfi '-' CO "^ 0) _. 9. !>• xg x-< ^ S- s C3 O «! O o o <1 o 5 3 u« o ■^ J2 to 3 CS U. ^ ID T3 o- S b ■a^ a o « Pd rt « o ^ *^ 2 1) H ■-> O oj ':! I- 5 !=! o ® "^ _ -^ ■" c3 a. ^ -t; 00 ^ «.■< ■^ o « . 3 a . n o . > u • (U o . l« /I . „ s . -S(N • I ' w^ : . (B C tC , • =■■=.';-= • s _^ H _« "2 M ^ a J3 C °- cS-a 5 (D !:j " M cj ri .- cc _« m j2 I' .-H ---■SI ""IS — 52 O QJ 3j "^ •^ ■.-> u -~ *j C3 I- >. 1-1 ^ ® !i i § =-^ P S o o 4j i? oj J3 rs M, 71 l-t o "^ ^ S-3 o o o S '■« « fe s o m . . .- C o ° ® ri C '-I Oi « £ o i> Jj 2 5'-ri3-<:^7 o ^£o 2- ":; -- « U en C ~ bl be —3 tfj ic r- « bBbr^'-2-? bt.^!2 s Z.B.a t.tLc=t:t. c. 53 'C 'C '« -c f;;; "C ^ -o S cS S3 T3 «:> i g S .a rf .2 -^S o ^o ■■' « - 5 P. m >-< O "'S O =n ' S-° ^ -- i, 00 W '-• r-KM •S ^" -2^ o c " — , o « :o »! O! ^ ^ '-' t—i !« aj _ cnco o o o CO o o 00 — o O i» CO " JO o ££c ;■ O I — o _. c o o p cj -=! o 2 "^^-^ CO C O > CO '> !- 13 c3 6'^ -SS S3£^ o ■ 0^ b . ? -^ * * m c-5§ !> a fl g o 5 5 S J rf (D "^ Cat? O o * '-N "^ ^ ^ cr- , ^ ^^ «3 ra - 00 0.5-0 S oc. B -> m c u. IB u o o p •- fcB ■>.2 'sxi; Q.'s ^ ^ Oi JJ 02 M Wrf CQ d<5 C1-J3 « s 2^ tn ., -r. MOO 00 ro c? CO CO 00 Ex, Doc. No, 47. 95 ^ 96 Ex. Doc. No. 47. 3 a a o O P^ o CO in to a> N 00 ^ _l cri O^ ^ 'a J^ ^ »* <©• ^ CO o 1 ^ H oo o >o cooooocoooooooooo ^ o « C (N OCOOOlOO-OOOOCOwOOX) c 3 O B O rt 00 -i iO >o lO 'S' >o t- lo 00 lo in in to io lo IN o CO s ^ : "So 1 :/) ", «= Sj '. :I3 • 'r? « 1 en 3 ■ ° a. ' ^ t^ - f^ CO ; j^ c 3 : S -^ O o ^ ^ ---S B I 03 -d o 'J t : c & '. s "5 p. E o 1 ! 2 • o s 1, . 0) ^ . o ■ i £ : :-s fe .sS Li ® s g1 a : : " ^ o O ' »">^ o s ■« rz ; . •- be _4 ■ s H f^ 1 1 :^ "^ c (i .2 'o i. J3 . .2 ' -Si Oh < 2 . • s.^ i ' . K Si o S s s o O C 3 K wo ' h - « : : ' w ■« I s 1 W-? "^ c • ' I •^ o o . ■3 s ■3 a . • 4-3 'S Vi 2 S' s E s. C C [11 ^ bi;"= -3 ■ 6 D t a i , B . 3 . . u > .1^ •'2 i -a .2 .2 • go d d 6 d c d d d d d : ^§ . : fcDa d-ss > O <3 £ ^ O *J ^'O'-s-a -j'On3-3-3-3i3'OnS'3-3 a g i^ Oh ci t2 • ^ : I '2 COiO cc OT • fri hH > rs • -a S o HI a. IS 3 — • • "o ■ • |i : S3 • 3 3.2 ^ _ „ „ t^ J^o-. a5ift035a^coco-,co(N-< — t^-ffi to s CO 1-1 ^ U C J2 o s <^ O ^ « »^ fH <; a> 00 »-^ CO ff3 ■^ ^ -^ ft oo a-) OC' i~« »-l Ix. Do€. No. '47* 97 ft< ft? s ft, o mcq S3 _4 S .- "o o cr" '-'.So > o S Wis W Kl 6) o S * His; H Cij Ex* Doc. No,. 47: P — Continued. RECAPI'TULATION. Hiisff by Major J. M. Washington Captain E. S. Sible}' Captain E. K. Kane Lieutenant W. C. Anderson Lieutenant R. H. Keeling ■Captain J. L. Donaldson Major George F. Howard Lieutenant H. R. Bee Captain Kenton Harper. . .< Captain William VV, Chapman Colonel J . W. Tibbats Captain A. W. Rej'nolds ' Lieutenant W. W. Pharr Brevet Brigadier General Thomas Childs. Colonel W . B . Warren. Colonel S. R. Curtis * Captain P. H. Gait Lieutenant J. M. Braanan Total $920 90 843 26 163 75 463 80 107 01 1,123 41 64 88 229 57 41 00 1,703 '72 181 90 149 96 19 25- 344 80 8 00 •50 17 05 140 35 15,523 11, Ex. Doc. No. 47, 99 ta o CO o CO ?^ ^ ■^ 53 S 0. O CD tp o o-^ -? O 50 -^ -H XI 7- CO r-. 1-C o ^'' 2 :-^ := ;^ . = , u c:: c3 ^^ ^^ ^ I pq i_5 Ph CO CO Ph o • .s s io^'*»-'t^cot-ot^t-'0>co a o3 .2-3 ^ -a c ^ > -i ID 05 S S'" s^ g^ 03 »rH . 3 O (D • •-S 1=^ >-3 1-5 i-i ►n ^ s S 100 Ex. Doc. No. 47. a> e -4-> a o O C^ 5 r- O g 3 O cDbfl- J3 bC ^ «3 2^ S. ^1 §2 £ 03 2 9^ o S '^ "^ 4J <1 S 2 g rt 3J r-l c- I O c = ■S rt o c"7j ~ ui: ^'y<^' ^ ?i > o 3 e ri 1 c !4 a o O > -. c a ra S3 c 3 • c ^ PC C 4 s o Eh 1 rs o >- rt o o ? =■ c o S 3 T C I— 1- p. > c a, It < < d J. J. Lo Ex, Doc No, 47 101 • St; 5 £0000=;-^jlO • o c o o • a o p cooo.nm^- n : q3 i. S 53 ^ . p.© c. c ! jy irs c^ <^' o 00 --1 m "-• °^ t: 2 3 >~ ^ "^ o ' O O w' o '" " ^ — !i^ - ^5 o ^j= ^— — — -r'^oii-i'JfioH oJojojei ,„.. no ^2 fcxS OOOOO^OJUI .EtJj.'^ O 1) dj IB OJ C © M > '? T F ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ S '^ > «-<-. 33 '^ C- OS -> -Mm S S Is - C 8j ■"■ (A O) -2 g cs to t! o c — K t-s 1-3 Pi M i-» H PQ Ti-— CO —■-. — « o ,- 13 • ; ^ C O • J3 O; Q W w G G.= I- 5 o ^ '^o u © ,<5 CO 0; a, i: 83 jT w .^ § -Ca cs i2 * c bb "^ 3 -n W -^ O •-, C1fOCOeOC»3COCo >o m lo irti o o o lO —f cvj in in o ift -gas w ^ t- o s o o •-■ o -•:f^ ^ ^ J3 J3 oooooooo ^ n fi m >.-j .1-1 >1 , .t; . - « ;:; cs p. 'o " C'w t/, s> o • &-rr 5 ■£ -^ = -C ■^ t^ i> v; o ♦-' . D 5 <= * '^ « (N (M 0< H >■ ^^ O 03 M 00 CO ro ?(? &H Ex. Doc. No. 47. « P c 03 C cS .":: -^ — ' o s^'o on .O 2 S £ c3 -C O ui ■3 " J2 -^ e> a v3 03 S- O ^ --£ -5 ^ o» -^ o rt-o ^ rf o ci I I bug rS OS M > ■ o 4J ^ m fl ^.5 S 5 I lo 'r; — » o I— -5 .5 ;i ^ '55 •- N s! i; 12 > O o eS i J;-^ -a &k, CO -Ict-ilrtr-l M ■l Is I -a -3 i^^ '^ a c o ^ '^ O O rf ^ Ct a « ^ 2 — ■^ " S o "*" """ s b£? ■- o (!• o o o "" in ifi o b ^ ; : :S JS J- ^ ^ ^ m in lO 5£i 52 cj g o o*o O ,t< " ii -^ -a o S-5 « 3 — SS CO 00 ^ p. O O — o o , -> *^ 5 O O i; • O ^ Ch "C o ^ ^:i ~ o c sii r-i o o O 1) 4) w ■ < W P^H -l £V5 , , — ^ . .^ ■ Oj 03 " I * § : • *j 4J .CO CO • • o o • 4J • * ^J ■*-> • ' 01 tn ' »^ : s •s • . o o , • s c • • 03 es • • S 2 I • S a^ S o O o O u o > e-> 2-> 2 U3 --^ • TS g bfl <>» 0» 05 CO ■^ -^ CO =a a o ^ 41 5H tU o tn ft; t- S 0)" u- O o ■" is c §"5i 2j ^•^ r u O Hi ^ OS «i 3 ™ - b,^ - oJ « -a beg b t: •— 'ri 5E o f^ o ,„ bC — en t« c |s^ c3 c c . 5 2 -« I- O.00 -00 03 t>-, ' -d oi o O C 3 ^ oj P -X3 O 7'-' r- 33 CO -„ = O .- .£,-3 13 "ts^ .« y ^^ 3 (- o • .2 -flu, s*'--'^-:^ 5 n "O •■^ « T3 = 2 • C-J o o3 * o S ® fp o Ex. Doc. No,. 47, -105 ooooooooomooiooi OCOOOOOOO(NOO(Nr-i C< 1-1 »0 00 CO lO ocor^h»»^>nh-ooooooci-Tm>-c;io-xcoot^ C»i(Nr-.>-lf-t'3'i-<'-1»-< iDfMlfi 2-5 ♦J t« j: — o 8 c, -^ '" • o J; O TS 3 _: •— £ o ®, I' t^ bf. :; m =i (« ,o C (D o « Si TS^ 2 OS §■ . . ; '.-a :«! i 'i fcr g g u " : = .5 '=^ e 2 -S : 3~ £ s).2 2 , •- CO*- "- ; j^ - (t r^ :::; .— . Oj O — S C 2 !< • oj X ce -^ o • *-> be."" "^ OS (U ^ « o .t: c * ., S SB- 4) .a (D « Q. O 5 C < ■«) a, i c. S-o S.5,-7; 3 . ^ '^ a. o c J3 '*- o o o m ^ S 3 o c o *> ^ • £Sfi y, < 106 Ex. Doc. No. 47. =3 .s o a Q o J ^ f- o *" «S ^ S OS ;i o :- • - o-a I si O =t;. _ 00 o !- I -/> • • o r - I O 1 • t:; • • m . >~> I « • ' 0) ! t " . o =^ : rs . r3 , •o ■• •2 ^r : O ! !^>, : <>' . !>i . • s • c3^ • _! : si . Ho ; •— CO ' D 1 • 1 '■ ' in ::j p. o ' j3 "C ; t- ■§-< c < " ro t-o £ O I^ -^ •5 a o s • 9 Ji S 4^ . si "5 a .3 ;i=H 5-5 o ; o • 1« :?§ I'a . >1 • c$ :^£; ;"o . o ■ ""** *"^ c*.. , izi • fi • (0 o . o . u . S JS, « *^ • Cn ;i-5 • a • o > si > k< — es -; CO C/J «*i iT i ; • a >.^Z! O !; -t- O :;(^-S a =• ^ p, aj = o a 2 ®i; CO '5 ^, 1" ° "5 ® •' ■a ffl o o ,oi: o3 ,2 .2 a: » en k. ki > 72 ^ I CGPh ^ o * !C o *j o £!:= a © > .^ « (» 02 fi OJ ■ g t>^ ^-i^ C^ -,3 ' S -— ^ o ^z ° = • 2 = M £ "^ S £> . "5 a -g ai -g O ! M l-J r- O :- '^ X '— '" n — o — .* ■^ i. -c -a S ^ 9-5, ,3 ^ y 6 rj 11' '.^^ 2 ■« o ^ o rt O > J3 a O S "o -rr £. 3 s .-i -^ . erf « J/l tfl. W W V3 M m O . i. a) m •« ; -_ "o "o S o d ti Gj' ») ^ > > > > a o o o 2c=g-- -- o beg 4) a. «. o — fcn "" «3 = ® c S - p^ tn I. •_ tj. i, «.O.D 1. d O — — ' I . . . K -; 2 I <; fe w Of I- i) c ^ c t. = u Ki S S3 O O O o i^ o o t^ 5 . « = ;^ aj = „ 1- 3 - 5 o 'S £ 2i S a -s " §_ a "^ o .2 S £ o ^'^ S ffi " e^ a; H PS ^ Ph O <; HO a (u o 3 £ 3 • T3 t;2 iS -Sojooooooooo I'd = o !!:!::;: ; .(1hH;2; ^fi MOOl'-ivOCiOOO; : l>» lO C-< lO 1" I in ■* --l rl eO rl rl a S ti W »j ^ c .- - --^ . js oD a. 0/ -o z; fe «s c oi a)—! 03"^ — 1-5 a ^ U S Q h5 CJ U |J1 5^^ 5 W 3 J' <0 ^^ t;^ ro CO § CO CO to ^ t>- C <;o '^ o -^ -T^ •« •«•. <:ii "^ ^ a « ?i- '>> c:, ^i." r,f=^ >-.. '*-^.'' 00 00 CO CO o CO <35.. o 1 00 O CO ■<3< I 05 CI Oi o o OC' IX) in to H ^ ^ CO 1 „ O 00 CO >0 "* ^ CO lO CC CO o CO Oi CO a>oo a ■;-' lO C<3 ■^ oo 4J o •rt ■■o 3> CO O -* 00 C<> lO 00 o o 1ft '"S' \o Tt Oi ■n CO OO OO Oj CC CO 00 "^ •-< OJ OJ OC lO 00 ^ »— X' O -^fO (N lO ^ CO C5 T— 1 in CO 00 s < CO IN 1ft CO oo -f l^ t^ vft ^-^ r» 1) m • ^ (M (N ■(».•> « c^ ! 5: Si, s 1 1 5> *- 1 « i~ > "i«i '^ -a R ^ 1 "i ji ^ I!* 2 ibit g g o ^ = -a s f=^ 5 C ift o m (N. lo 35 iM O ^ CO -^ O ■^ O w ^^ r-l 10 (N •* CSi t^ CO OO CO CO — . 1ft " ■^ C CO Ci cc c; 10 CN( CO CO (35 1ft m c re c) — <^^ •^ m 05 O CO > ':- = s ss >> '3 >^ B. ■ » ■^ o CI !« a c aj •-^ K o" b P, I— 1 Hi ffi 13 P- N .j= 5 OS K ^ o c -o CI rt frt a r' o 13 -s ,«!« c; 5 ►-) ^' o *' c c •to CO -s 0) r-; o rt-, a ir 3 00 >- C3 o •^ s io •o ci V. -si "*o i ^ ^ e • !V1 !•«* v. •ffi w '^ n s «3 S 2 S m- tc -^ ■^ " (N K| o ■» 1- c fe ^ 03 O ^ ^ 1i Ti 5! c ."J C C '' S t^ s 3 S - « o c 'y »i = 5 S S" S 2 114 Ex. Doc. No. 47. S 2 l^ ^ o o o ^-. (N T o o CO OC O 00 e a o o H ^ S \B • S 2 IK'S - o . .S: oi '5 a .s'P •:DTf05 — OOOtCCD CO O 00 O •^ 00 O cs ^ 5 S S ^ *-J ni 'Tt - J O c5± g ° JO * n 00 00 o CO s s o p „ O =— O OJ 7) en OD M " § s s § s ^ ^ — n : „"* S S 2 : J! (U (U 2 2 S - .2 3 ,- 3 > o « C ^ >^ , »> 01 en "O c- o « " 4) O- g 0) a> n k 2 5 S • • ofMCS a, u - ;t3 = J. <5 <; w ft ►S (i « g o H o -a !- ^ a> '^ = -?«£ §1 = S M 2 -S-^OQ ass 116 Ex. Doc. No. 47. .s a o Q H >f5 . • tc n o > <, 00 • ; ■ (N lO o , . e^ • • >Q 00 o CO • • on ^ E - vn • • "*-. to O)^ Js ^ : I r- h-" in "S — " o o o H TS • * Oi 05 I to o rs lo • oo o JO • •' eo M ^ — •^ lO is? °^ • c: o • . lo >n . o oo 00 " 1 -^ • o o ■—1 pi * "T. '^, • o •^ •^ "w 1 «; • CO «o o u - I - 1 o • * i^) (M • •-1 w 1 t^ •I- 1 l^ ^J . .^ s 3 o g Id u ■5 "* 1 Oi to o '• > 3 S c ci TS s «« :J N CO ^ o i^ K o 03 1 o «^ O 8 a S 1 S s s vi s ID s •p* m 2 ID 5E s c3 > O '-J 3 p. o o to • 9-1 ID O- n 1 ffi O.U 3 ^ s •V , P _ >, cd J-a -3 Hi '^ 1- '3 H e a a T. l«2 01 m •04 ^w s6^ < I "5 5 a o .5 o T3 . Ojl-j o o gS2 Ol -H -^ (N « Tf e* o o o o o ^ lO "O O O O O CO ts< CO c lo o o ■^ o ■^r c -^ — rt O O O OJ — IN o o o in 1-1 CO i^ o •-< lO ■>* Oi (N -- ■^ lO T-c t-i «; 'E t-'E i «5 O £ c3 ^ ^ ^ M 1-J Csi o. _ _ _ _ <0 - o & - e - M 5 = = ^ S X O !> o • s s (=-o o o " _: ^ ojfq "g T3 T3 -£;_]!» I-S O u > > o o 5 o o 2 S S S 118 Ex. Doc. No. 47. 0-3 in f-» in fo 00 -i '^ CO CO «>