J ■ V- V l^ \ v .0 $ % -1 J W ^ V y ./> V>^ ■ V ^U # * "<£ ■^ v* % / «5 -n*. \ \ / <£. '% %* .■y ■>* %, o, ' ^ ^ -J ^ v ^ N •V y
A HISTORY
DELAWARE STATE SOCIETY
CINCINNATI.
i745-i«22.
/E, MRS. CAMPBELL D. EMORY, (nEE TJLTON,) WASHINGTON, 0. C.
PAPERS OF THE HISTORICAL SOCIETY OF DELAWARE.
XIII.
A HISTORY
OF THE
DELAWARE STATE SOCIETY
OF THE
CINCINNATI
FROM ITS ORGANIZATION TO THE PRESENT TIME.
TO WHICH IS APPENDED
A BRIEF ACCOUNT OF THE DELAWARE REGIMENTS
IN THE WAR OF THE REVOLUTION.
PERSONAL MEMOIRS OF OFFICERS, ROLLS OF SAME, ORATION
BEFORE THE DELAWARE CINCINNATI ON THE
DEATH OF WASHINGTON, ETC.
BY
HENRY HOBART BELLAS, LL.B.,
CAPTAIN U. S. ARMY,
MEMBER PENNSYLVANIA HISTORICAL SOCIETY; HONORARY MEMBER NEW HAMPSHIRE
HISTORICAL SOCIETY, ETC.
THE HISTORICAL SOCIETY OF DELAWARE,
WILMINGTON.
I8 95 .
**
y±
■':
7
PREFACE.
The following paper on the Delaware State Society of
the Cincinnati was read by request before the Delaware
Historical Society in Wilmington, Delaware, on December
17, 1894 (the Hon. Charles B. Lore, Chief-Justice of the
State and President of the Historical Society, presiding);
and, by resolution, was afterwards directed to be printed for
the information of the members and others.
The author, while acknowledging the uniform courtesy
and valuable assistance which he has received from officers
and members of the Society of the Cincinnati, has been
greatly impeded in his work by the meagre sources of in-
formation on the subject; finding at the commencement of
his labors not only no record whatever of the Delaware
Cincinnati, but that very few in the State were aware even
of its prior existence. All the data in the following pages,
therefore, have been ascertained only by patient and con-
tinued research in all parts of the Union.
While deeply gratified with the result accomplished, — viz.,
the subsequent and speedy revival of the Delaware Society
of the Cincinnati, — the author cannot but be aware that
both imperfections and errors still exist in this brief history ;
therefore he must ask the indulgence of the reader, as well
as the favor of an early notification of the proper correc-
tions.
H. H. Bellas.
Germantown, Philadelphia,
May 13, 1895.
CONTENTS.
PAGE
Preface 3
History of the Delaware State Society of the Cincinnati . 7
History of the Delaware Regiments in the Revolution . . 40
Personal and Military Records of Original Members of the
Delaware Cincinnati 53
Roll of Officers of Colonel John Haslet's Regiment, Dela-
ware State Troops (1776) 72
Roll of Officers of Colonel David Hall's Regiment, Dela-
ware Line (1777) 75
Roll of Officers of Colonel David Hall's Regiment, Dela-
ware Line (1780) 78
Roll of Officers of Colonel Henry Neill's Regiment, Dela-
ware Line (1780) 80
Roll of Officers of Colonel Samuel Patterson's Battalion,
Delaware Militia (1776) 81
Roll of Officers of Captain Allen McLane's Partisan Com-
pany, Delaware Troops 82
Roll of Officers of Veteran Corps of Delaware ( 1802-18 12) . 8^
Oration on the Death of Washington, pronounced by Captain
Edward Roche before the Delaware Cincinnati, February
22, 1800 84
Reorganization of the Delaware State Society of the Cin-
cinnati, February 22, 1895 104
Charter of the Delaware State Society of the Cincinnati . 109
A HISTORY
OF THE
DELAWARE STATE SOCIETY OF THE CINCINNATI.
On the sixteenth day of November,
1782, the veteran Delaware battalion
of the Continental Line, under Cap-
tain William McKennan, — who in the
closing days of the Revolutionary
War had relieved its brave but dis-
abled commander, Major Robert
Kirkwood, the successor of Hall,
Pope, and Vaughan, — in obedience
to orders previously received to hold
itself in readiness to march home from the southward
in the Carolinas, started on its last long and wearisome
journey of over seven hundred miles. Leaving its head-
quarters on the Ashley River, where it then lay encamped,
and taking up its march via Camden, Salisbury, and Peters-
burg, it crossed the James River at Carter's Ferry, pushed
NOTE. — The above illustration of the Cincinnati insignia is from a photo-
graph of the eagle presented by General Lafayette to Surgeon James Tilton,
the first President of the Delaware Society, and which is now in the posses-
sion of his eldest representative, Colonel M'Lane Tilton, U. S. Marine Corps.
7
8 HISTORY OF THE DELAWARE STATE
on through Maryland, and in exactly two months after
the date of its departure from the main Southern army
(January 17, 1783), it finally arrived — and with what feel-
ings can be only imagined, not described — at Christiana
Creek, near New Castle, in its native State.
Here the battalion rendezvoused until October of the
same year, when it was permanently disbanded; Captain
McKennan, then in command, being appointed to settle
and adjust the accounts of the officers and men of the bat-
talion with the United States Auditor, as also
" to issue both certificates for past services as well as land warrants to the
individuals claiming, or their attorneys for them, which duty he performed
to the general satisfaction." *
Ramsey, in his " History of the United States," f says, —
" This Delaware regiment was reckoned the most efficient in the Conti-
nental army. It went into active service soon after the commencement of
the contest with Great Britain and served through the whole of it. Courting
danger wherever it was to be encountered, frequently forming part of a vic-
torious army, but oftener the companions of their countrymen in the gloom
of disaster, the Delawares fought at Brooklyn, at Trenton and at Princeton,
at Brandy wine and at Germantown, at Guilford and at Eutaw, until at length,
reduced to a handful of brave men, they concluded their services with the
war in the glorious termination of the Southern campaign. . . ."
Gates and Greene, Lee, Williams, and De Kalb had all
borne testimony, as eye-witnesses, to the heroism of the
Delaware line.
* See Governor Caleb P. Bennett's "History of the Delaware Regiment,"
Perm. Mag. of Hist, and Biog., Vol. IX., No. 4 (1885) ; also " Niles' Reg-
ister," September 2, 1843.
f Vol. I., p. 209.
1 752-1 Si;
I POSSESSION OF OtSCEHOAVT, JOHN
; /.<:
SOCIETY OF THE CINCINNATI. 9
It was impossible that its memory should be easily-
forgotten, or that the ties formed in its long and arduous
service should be readily sundered. Accordingly, when
the moment for separation arrived, steps were taken for
the formation of a branch of the Society of the Cincin-
nati in accordance with the recommendation made by the
General Society, instituted at Newburg, on the banks of
the Hudson, May 13, 1783, and as had been already
done by many of the remaining thirteen States.
The object of the institution of the Cincinnati, formed
by the officers of the American army at the close of the
Revolution, and, in the words of the original Institution, —
" to perpetuate as well the remembrance of this vast event, as the mutual
friendships which have been formed under the pressure of a common
danger and in many instances cemented by the blood of the parties;" —
as well as the steps which led to its formation, are so
well known and have been so often told, as to require
here no repetition.
It suffices merely to state that, following the example
already set by the officers in other States, and preceding
the final disbandment of the Del vare line at New Cas-
tle, its officers, with other r at Wilmington, and on
the fourth day of July, ^63, formed a State Society,
or, to use the quaint, old style of the period and the
original title of the State, the " Delaware State Society
of the Cincinnati."* An organization was effected, officers
elected, and in the month following the disbandment of
* Original records of the Society. See also Scharf's " Hist. Delaware,"
Vol. I., p. 266.
IO HISTORY OF THE DELAWARE STATE
the battalion under the command of Captain McKennan,
at New Castle, a circular letter was addressed to the
General and other State Societies, notifying them of the
preceding facts as well as addressing them on the then
condition of the Union.
This letter is not only interesting but valuable as being
among the first recorded authoritative acts of the Society,
and for this reason is cited in full with its accompanying
letter of transmittal to the Connecticut State Society.*
"Delaware State, November 6th, 1783.
" Sir :
" Enclosed with this, I transmit you a letter from the Delaware State
Society of the Cincinnati and have to request you to lay it before your
Society at their next meeting.
" I am, Sir, with respect,
"Your Most Hum. Servant,
W. McKennan, Secretary.
" The Secretary of Connecticut State Society of the Cincinnati."
" Delaware State, November 6th, 1783.
" Gentlemen :
"Agreeably to those rules of the Cincinnati, which enjoin an annual
correspondence of the State Societies, the Delaware State Society have now
the pleasure to address you.
* Proceedings of General Society of the Cincinnati, 1784; also Minutes
of N. Y. State Society for February 3, and of Conn. State Society for
December 17, 1784, before which latter Society the circular letter (having
been previously acknowledged on March 30) was then read at this first
meeting of the Connecticut Society. The original letter is now in the
archives of the Connecticut Historical Society at Hartford, with which
body the records of the Connecticut Cincinnati were deposited, after its
so-called dissolution in 1804, by the Secretary, Lieutenant John Mix, "for
safe keeping."
SOCIETY OF THE CINCINNATI. II
" The success with which the Society is likely to be established in every
State, affords us a sensible pleasure. The attack, or rather the compliment
paid us by the learned Cassius, we hope, will have no other effect than
to excite us to laudable ambition, to engage our attention to maxims of
prudence and to contribute in establishing us in those republican principles
of virtue, honor, and honesty which we hope will ever be the more dis-
tinguishing badges of the Cincinnati.
" The union of the States affords an ample field for discussion, but we
are confined to the compass of a letter. We know, that the misfortunes
and destruction of confederacies flow not from usurpation, but from discord
and disunion ; and that it is the advice of our best politicians, at this
critical juncture, to brace the bonds of our Union. That bond, which we
think most immediately to be regarded, is the peace establishment, as
pointed out in General Washington's letter. The ablest civilians assure
us, the confederation is not defective in this respect, and we consider our
political union as very deeply interested in the support of this measure.
" The Delaware State has complied with the requisitions of Congress,
for paying the interest, and gradually sinking the principal of the public
debt; and when the other States shall have agreed to this righteous
measure, we hope, public credit will be restored, and that nothing will be
wanting to make the whole community happy.
" The officers of this State Society, chosen on the 4th of July last, are
" Doctor James Tilton, President.
"Major John Patten, Vice-President.
" Captn. William McKennan, Secretary.
"Lieutt. Edward Roche, Treasurer.
" " Stephen McWilliam, Ass't Treasurer.
"By order of the Society,
12
HISTORY OF THE DELAWARE STATE
The complete Roll of the Society at this time bore the
names of thirty-seven (37) officers of the Delaware and
Pennsylvania lines and Continental staff, or their repre-
sentatives. They are recorded as follows (the signatures
being given as written) :
Dollars.
Name.
Rank.
75-
{David) D. Hall,
Colonel.
60.
{Joseph) J. Vaughan,
Lieut-Col.
50.
John Patten,
Major.
40.
Robert Kirkwood,
Maj. by Brv't
40.
James Moore,
« «
40.
John Learmonth,
<( «
40.
Peter Jaquett,
Captain.
40.
Wm. McKennan,
u
40.
George Purvis,
William Adams,
«
Son of Captain Nathan Adams, who was k.
40.
Harry Duff,
Captain.
30.
{John Vance) John V. Hyatt,
Lieutenant.
30.
James Campbell,
tt
30.
{Caleb Prew) Caleb P. Bennett,
tt
30.
Joseph Hosman,
«
3°-
Charles Kidd,
tt
30.
Edward Roche,
tt
30-
Thomas Anderson,
tt
—
«
Joseph Haslet,
Eldest son of Colonel John
Haslet, who was k.
30.
Stephen McWilliam,
Lieutenant.
30.
John Piatt,
it
60.
{Reuben) R. Gilder,
Surgeon.
SOCIETY OF THE CINCINNATI.
13
Dollars.
Name.
Rank.
90.
James Tilton,
Hosp'l Surg'n.
60.
Chas. Pope,
late Lt.-Col.
40.
Allen McLane,
Captain.
60.
George Monro,
Surg'n 6 V. R.
30.
{Joseph) Josh. Driskill,
Lieutenant.
60.
James Jones,
Surg'n 4 P. R.
90.
Henry Latimer,
Hosp'l Surg'n.
40.
Enoch Anderson,
late Captain.
40.
Joseph Anderson,
Maj.byBrev't.
William Anderson,
Ensign.
30.
David Kirkpatrick,
Capt. Lieut.
30.
Nathaniel Twining,
late Lieuten't.
9O.
Ebenezer Augustus
Smith, Hosp'l Surg'n.
40. {Daniel Jenifer) Daniel J. Adams,
late Major.
40.
Nathaniel Mitchell,
Major.*
Many other names of surviving officers of the Delaware
line are missing from the above roll, some by reason of lack
of eligibility, from not
having served the requi-
site time, and a number
probably not approving
of the institution of the
Order, as was also the case in other States. Such, for in-
* This list is from original parchment roll of the Delaware State Society.
On a list in the possession of the General Society, dated 1788, there are
slight variations in one or two of the names, as is also the case in memoran-
dum made by the Hon. Hamilton Fish, President-General, in the Records of
the New York State Society, and in list copied (in 1846) by the then secre-
tary of the Pennsylvania Society, and in possession of the latter to-day.
14
HISTORY OF THE DELAWARE STATE
'flme/Uu
01O
i^ZHT^Z^svcZICk.
stance, are the names of Lieutenant Edward Armstrong,
Lieutenant - Colonel
Gunning Bedford, Cap-
tain John Corse, Lieu-
tenant Daniel Powell
Cox, Captain Henry-
Darby, Major Thomas
Macdonough, Ensign
Benjamin McLane,
Captain Paul Queen-
ault, Lieutenant Elijah
Skillington, Lieutenant
John Vaughan, Captain
John Willson, and
others.*
At a meeting of the
Society held a few
months later (February, 1784), the minutes, as well as the
daily papers of the time,f in addition to recording "the
election of the following gentlemen as officers of the Dela-
ware State Society of the Cincinnati for the present year"
(the list being the same as already given in the circular
letter), add the additional information that
" Dr. Tilton and Major James Moore were also appointed
delegates to attend the first General Meeting of the Cincin-
* See Heitman's " List of Officers of Delaware Line at close of Revolu-
tionary War," p. 472; also Scharf's "Hist. Delaware," Vol. L, and White-
ley's "Hist. Delaware Revolutionary Soldiers," 1875.
fSee Freeman's "Journal and N. A. Intelligencer," Phila., Pa., March 3,
1784.
1 730-1 797.
1 PORTRAIT IN POSSESSION OF FAMILY.
SOCIETY OF THE CINCINNATI. 1 5
nati at Philadelphia, on Tuesday, May 4, of the same
year." At this meeting these delegates voted, with the
others present, for the adoption of the proposed "Amended"
Institution of the Society, but which was never finally rati-
fied by all the States, and resulted in the original Institu-
tion of 1783 remaining in force to the present day. Dr.
Tilton represented Delaware on the committee appointed at
this meeting to make the revision proposed.
On the second day of the meeting (May 5), the mem-
bers of the several States having been requested by General
Washington, the President-General, to declare the ideas
which prevailed in their States in regard to the Institution
(it having been, as is well known, the subject of fierce at-
tack by its opponents since its foundation the previous
year), we find it stated in the proceedings that " Doctor
Tilton for Delaware informed the Society that the principal,
and indeed the only, enemies of the Cincinnati were among
the class of people denominated Tories." *
The circular letter already alluded to of the Delaware
State Society of the Cincinnati, dated November 6, 1783,
was also presented at this meeting by General Knox, the
former Secretary-General, and read by the Secretary pro
tem.\
The next meeting of the Society was held at Wilming-
ton on July 4, 1785, at which the same officers as of the
preceding year were re-elected. The additional record of
the proceedings is as follows : " The Order of Cincinnati
* Winthrop Sargent's "Journal of Cincinnati General Meeting, 1784."
"Penn. Hist. Soc'y Pub.," Vol. VI., p. 80.
f Proceedings of General Society of the Cincinnati, 1784.
1 6 HISTORY OF THE DELAWARE STATE
being convened at this place (the 4th July, 1785), the
anniversary of the Independence of America, a dinner was
prepared for them at Captain O'Flinn's tavern,* and a num-
ber of the steady friends of the American Revolution
being invited to dine on the occasion, the day was spent
with the utmost festivity and good order. At the dinner-
time the following toasts, enlivened by the firing of
cannon from the beautiful eminence of this borough, were
drank :
1. May the anniversary of this day forever rejoice the sons of America.
2. The United States of America.
3. His most Christian Majesty.
4. The United Netherlands.
5. The Delaware State.
6. General Washington.
7. May Congress be vested with full and efficient powers to complete the
happiness of America.
8. May the principles of Republican freedom universally flourish.
9. The glorious memory of those heroes who fell in vindication of the
American Revolution.
10. Immortality to the Sons of Cincinnati.
11. May the virtues of the illustrious farmer be as well grounded as his
ploughshare.
* This tavern, named at different periods the "Sign of the Ship," the
"Happy Retreat," and still later the "Lafayette," stood at the southeast cor-
ner of Market and Third Streets till 1835. Patrick O'Flinn, who had been a
captain of militia during the Revolution, was the proprietor of the place when
known as the " Happy Retreat" from 1789 till his death in 1818, and in such
latter capacity had entertained at different times, when passing through Wil-
mington, Washington, Jefferson, John Adams and wife, Louis Philippe, Aaron
Burr, Commodore Perry, and other distinguished guests. As seen, it was a
favorite meeting-place of the Delaware Society of the Cincinnati.
SOCIETY OF THE CINCINNATI. 1 7
12. May the sons and daughters of Columbia join to transmit to latest ages
this day's birthright.
13. Success to the trade and commerce of Wilmington." *
In 1786 the Society met at New Castle, the final rendez-
vous and the place of disbandment of the Delaware line.
The record is as follows: "New Castle, July 4, 1786, the
Society of the Cincinnati of the State of Delaware met at
this place and elected the following gentlemen officers for
the current year :
" President, Doctor James Tilton.
" Vice-President, Major John Patten.
" Secretary, Captain William McKennan.
" Treasurer, Captain Edward Roche.
" Assistant Treasurer, Major James Moore.
" Doctor James Tilton, Major James Moore, Major Na-
thaniel Mitchell, Major Daniel Jenifer Adams and Captain
William McKennan were elected delegates to the General
Meeting of the Society at Philadelphia, on May 7, 1787."
It may be added here that this is the only time that we
find the full number of delegates required, representing the
State Society at the General Meetings.
At this meeting, Delaware had the honor of having one
of its delegates — Dr. James Tilton — appointed on a com-
mittee of three, " to prepare rules and regulations for con-
ducting the business of the General Meeting." These
rules, reported by the committee a couple of days later,
were unanimously agreed to by the General Society.f It
* See, also, Penna. Packet, Phila., July 8, 1785, Penna. Journal and
Weekly Adv'fr, and Penna. Evening Herald, Phila., July 9, 1785.
f Proceedings of General Society of the Cincinnati, 1787.
1 8 HISTORY OF THE DELAWARE STATE
was also at this meeting that the committee appointed " to
fix and report the quota of each State Society according to
its membership, to operate as a rule for all apportionments
which it may be necessary to make in the course of this
meeting," reported the rule for Delaware to be in the pro-
portion of 15 to 1000 parts; the ratio varying from 172, as
a maximum for Virginia, to 11, as a minimum for Georgia.*
The record continues : " The day was afterwards spent
in festivity with a number of gentlemen of the town and
country, when the following toasts were drank :
1. The United States.
2. The Delaware State.
3. General Washington.
4. The President of this State.
5. May this anniversary be ever marked with joy, as its birth was with
glory.
6. The allies of America in the time of her glorious trouble.
7. The memory of our brethren who fell in the struggle.
8. May the supporters of the Independence of America be ever united
in the basis of republican principles.
9. Encouragement and success to the agriculture, manufactories, and
commerce of America.
10. May liberality of sentiment, benevolence, charity, and good-will to
all mankind ever pervade the minds of Americans and influence
their conduct.
11. Those ladies who have ever countenanced and encouraged the authors
and supporters of American Independence.
12. May the liberties of America be propagated to the latest generations.
13. The memory of Cincinnatus; may his sons ever perpetuate his spirit
with his name."j-
* Proceedings of General Society of the Cincinnati, 1787.
f See, also, Penna. Packet, Phila., July 7, and Penna. Evening Herald,
Phila., July 8, 1786.
SOCIETY OF THE CINCINNATI. 1 9
We find no record of any State meeting in 1787, though
probably one was held as usual on the national anniversary
and the same officers continued in office, but in the follow-
ing year (1788) the Society met again at Wilmington,
which, indeed, with few exceptions, seems now to have
been the principal meeting-place of the Society during the
entire remainder of its existence.
Of this last-mentioned meeting it is stated : " The State
Society of the Cincinnati met at this place (Wilmington) on
the 4th inst, and chose the following gentlemen officers of
the Society for the current year :
"President, Doctor James Tilton.
" Vice-Preside?it, Major John Patten.
" Secretary, Captain William McKennan.
" Treasurer, Captain Edward Roche.
"Assistant Treasurer, Doctor George Monro.
" A sermon by the Rev. Doctor Wharton and an oration
by Doctor George Monro were delivered in the forenoon,
both very suitable to the occasion. The Society and citi-
zens of the place spent the afternoon in festive joy, and
drank the following toasts :
1. The wisdom that directed and the sword that obtained the indepen-
dence of America.
2. The new Constitution.
3. The ten States that have adopted the new Constitution.
4. May the three remaining States soon follow the noble example first set
by Delaware.
5. The agriculture of America.
6. May the wings of commerce be soon clipped by the growing manu-
factures of America.
7. Success to science and seminaries of learning.
20 HISTORY OF THE DELAWARE STATE
8. May the liberality of the French monarch in his commercial regula-
tions be copied by the British king.
9. The friends of freedom and patrons of liberty throughout the world.
10. Farmer Washington, may he, like a second Cincinnatus, be called from
the plough to rule a great people.
11. The memory of all those who fell during the American Revolution.
12. The Delaware State.
13. May our utmost hopes and wishes be exceeded in the blessings of the
new Constitution."*
The only delegate representing Delaware at an extra
General Meeting of the Society held at Philadelphia on
May 5, of this year, appears to have been Major James
Moore, though " credentials appointing delegates from
Delaware, namely : Major John Patten, Major James
Moore, and Captain William McKennan, one of whom
was to be a representation," were filed with the Secretary
at the meeting and probably explains the solitary repre-
sentation. The following return of members of the
different State Societies was likewise produced and filed
at this meeting :
yfi 5jC 5jC 5jC ?|C ?(C
" Cincinnati of Delaware .... Total, 27,"
******
thus showing a loss already of over a quarter of the
number of members on the original roll of the Society.f
For the year 1789, the records are again silent, but the
same officers retained their positions in the Society for
that year, as we still find them holding over and re-elected
once more in 1790.
* See, also, in Penna. Packet, Phila., July 12, letter from Wilmington, Del.,
dated July 9, 1788.
f Proceedings of General Society of the Cincinnati, 1788.
SOCIETY OF THE CINCINNATI. 21
In that year, under date of July 5, it is stated: "On
Monday, the 5th instant, the Society of Cincinnati for the
State of Delaware met at the house of Captain O'Flinn,
in this borough, to celebrate the anniversary of Indepen-
dence, and at eleven o'clock marched in procession to the
Academy, where divine service was performed by the Rev.
Lawrence Girelius ; after which a very ingenious and well-
adapted discourse was delivered by the president of the
Society to a large and brilliant audience; at the conclu-
sion of which a Federal salute of thirteen cannon was
given under the direction of Captain Hugh Montgomery.
Then the Society returned to Captain O'Flinn's and par-
took of a collation which was provided and drank the
following toasts, with a salute to each, viz. :
1. The President of the United States.
2. The Senate and House of Representatives.
3. The Vice-President.
4. The King and National Assembly of France.
5. The fair patriots of America.
6. The Society of the Cincinnati.
7. The Delaware State.
8. Agriculture.
9. Peace and free trade with all the world.
10. Manufacture.
11. May virtue and merit ever be the best claims to distinction and regard.
12. May the citizens of America ever pay due respect to religion, morality,
and equal laws.
13. Success to population and industry.
" To which were added the following toasts by the rev-
erend clergy then present :
22 HISTORY OF THE DELAWARE STATE
May America be an asylum to all the distressed people of Europe.
Patriotism without party and religion without hypocrisy.
May the Americans ever be valiant in war and subservient to their laws in
peace." *
At the third triennial meeting of the General Society in
Philadelphia, May 4, 1790, Major John Patten appears to
have been the only representative from Delaware, probably
under the same rule as adopted for the General Meeting
of the Society in 1788^
Three delegates were, however, elected at the annual
meeting of 1790, to represent the Delaware Society at an
extra General Meeting of the Cincinnati held in Philadel-
phia, May 2, 1 79 1, viz.: Doctor James Tilton, Major John
Patten, and Captain William McKennan, the President, Vice-
President, and Secretary respectively, of the Society. This
meeting was called for the purpose of urging the States
to send full representations at the next triennial meeting
of the General Society to be held in Philadelphia on the
first Monday of May (the 6th), 1793, for the final adoption
of the alterations proposed in the Institution of the Cincin-
nati as well as to recommend the expediency of the State
Societies obtaining acts of incorporation to secure their
funds for the charitable objects for which originally de-
signed. Two of the delegates from Delaware, Major Patten
and Captain McKennan, were appointed by the chair
(General Knox) on the Committee to examine the cre-
dentials of the delegates from the several States at this
* See, also, in Federal Gazette, Phila., July 14, letter from Wilmington, Del.,
dated July 10, 1790.
f Proceedings of General Society of the Cincinnati, 1790.
i 746-1800.
" DESCENDANT, H3N LEONARD EUiENE WALES, WILMINGTON,
SOCIETY OF THE CINCINNATI. 23
meeting.* It was the last one at which the Delaware
State Society was represented, no record appearing here-
after of any delegates accredited to that State being
present at the General Meetings of the Cincinnati.
The minutes of the Society for 1793 are as follows:
"Wilmington, July 4, 1793.
" The State Society of the Cincinnati met in this borough
on the 4th instant. At 12 o'clock a brilliant assembly
convened at the College, and the occasion being solemnized
with prayers by the Rev. Mr. Clarkson, Captain McKen-
nan, agreeably to appointment, pronounced an oration most
acceptable to the citizens.
"The Society and many respectable citizens then pro-
ceeded to Mr. Brinton's tavernf and dined together in a
manner expressive of heartfelt joy and satisfaction at
another return of our national birthday. After dinner
the following toasts were drank :
1. The day that gave birth to a nation and set the example of freedom
and independence to the world.
2. The United States — may they enjoy the blessings of peace, union, and
freedom to the latest ages.
3. The President of the United States — may long life, health, happiness,
and the confidence of his country reward his eminent services.
4. The Vice-President and the Congress of the United States— may wis-
dom mark their councils and integrity their conduct.
5. The memory of those heroes and patriots who fell in the cause of
independence.
* Proceedings of General Society of the Cincinnati, 1791.
f This tavern, known as " The Indian King," stood at the southeast corner
of Market and Fourth Streets, and, under the proprietorship of David Brinton,
was long a noted inn.
24 HISTORY OF THE DELAWARE STATE
6. The friends of freedom and lovers of independence in all parts of the
world.
7. The French nation — may it soon enjoy the blessings of peace and a
free Constitution.
8. Confusion to the counsels of despots, and may tyranny be banished
the earth.
9. A union of all free countries to save Poland from the rapacious bands
of all spoilers.
10. May equal liberty, equal rights, and a government of laws long be the
boast of America.
11. May America receive into her bosom and cherish the oppressed from
all parts of the world.
12. Success to the agriculture, manufactures, and commerce of America.
13. The arts and sciences, and all who love and promote them.
14. Neutrality to America, the best means to promote her happiness and
prosperity.
15- All our friends and brothers who are doing homage to liberty in cele-
bration of the epoch of our independence." *
In 1795 the Society met once more at New Castle :
" Wilmington, July 8 (1795).
" The State Society of the Cincinnati met at New Castle
on Saturday, the 4th instant, and chose the following offi-
cers for the current year:
"President, Major John Patten.
" Vice-President, Major Peter Jaquett.
" Secretary, Captain William McKennan.
" Treasurer, Captain Edward Roche.
" Assistant Treasurer, Doctor George Monro.
"The Society then adjourned to dinner, and after dinner
drank the following toasts :
* See, also, General Advertiser, Phila., Pa., July 9, 1793.
SOCIETY OF THE CINCINNATI. 25
1. This Day — may the remembrance of it and the glorious effects pro-
duced by it never be obliterated from the minds of America.
2. The United States — may the people thereof be ever mindful of
this political truth, That an incessant attention to the administra-
tion of government can alone give permanency to freedom.
3. The State of Delaware — may the honest industry of its citizens
be equalled by the virtuous patriotism of her representatives.
4. The President and Congress of the United States — may they
with true wisdom and unshaken fortitude remain uninfluenced,
unbiassed, and unawed by any foreign nation whatever.
5. The People of France — may the storm which has threatened them
with destruction speedily subside, and the sacred rights of liberty
and property be established among them on a solid foundation.
6. The United Provinces — may they avail themselves of the present
opportunity afforded them by the prowess of the French arms to
establish a free and happy government.
7. The memory of the heroic citizens of Delaware who fell in defence
of American Independence.
8. Arts and Sciences — may the citizens of all free governments remem-
ber that Information is the nurse of Freedom and Improvement.
9. Peace and Commerce — a general commercial intercourse with every
nation on earth upon honorable principles and reciprocal interests.
10. May the triumph of Freedom be the harbinger of Peace to the nations
of Europe.
11. May all free governments rightly comprehend their mutual as well as
individual interests.
12. The American Fair — may their importance be enhanced from a just
sense of liberty and equality.
13. Civilization, instead of extirpation, to our Indian brethren.
14. May America, in forming new political engagements, never sacrifice
her honor by injustice to her old friends.
15. May the Temple of Freedom be established on the ruin of thrones,
and all the nations enter its gates."
But the political excitement of the times required a still
stronger and more positive expression of opinion by the
26 HISTORY OF THE DELAWARE STATE
participants of the occasion, and the following "volun-
teers," we find, were added :
" By Doctor Tilton — No treaty with Britain, but in lieu thereof a non-im-
portation agreement.
By Doctor Alexander — The people of Great Britain, may they shortly
experience a revolution in the administration of their government.
By Major Bush — The ten patriotic senators who refused to ratify the
British treaty.
By James McCullough — The Congress of 1776, who gave birth to this Day.
By Major Jaquett, Vice-President — John Jay, may he enjoy the benefits
of a Purgatory."*
On July 4, 1797, it is stated, "the Delaware State Society
of the Cincinnati assembled and partook of a dinner pro-
vided for the purpose, after which a number of toasts were
drank ;" (similar, no doubt, in character to the above).f
The last regular election of officers and stated meeting
of the Society found recorded is in 1799, and reads as
follows :
"Wilmington, July 4, 1799.
" The Society of the Cincinnati for the State of Delaware
met at this place and elected the following officers for the
current year :
"President, Major John Patten.
" Vice-President, Major Peter Jaquett.
" Secretary, Captain Edward Roche.
" Treasurer, Doctor George Monro.
" Assistant Treasurer, Captain Caleb P. Bennett."!
* See, also, Independent Gazetteer, Phila., Pa., July II, and N. Y. Journal,
N. Y., July 15, 1795.
f See, also, Independent Gazetteer, Phila., Pa., July II, 1797.
% See, also, Federal Gazette and Phila. Evening Post, Phila., Pa., July 8,
1799.
SOCIETY OF THE CINCINNATI. 27
The only entry for the following year (1800) records
that " Captain Edward Roche, secretary of the Delaware
State Society of the Cincinnati, prepared and delivered a
funeral oration on the death of General George Washing-
ton ; prepared at the
request of the Society, [^lrt/{$^(JpZ) £,y
and pronounced in the
Second Presbyterian
Church in Wilmington on the twenty-second day of
February, 1800. Judge Bedford and Major Cass were
masters of the procession and ceremony."*
The Society, however, still kept up its membership. We
find twenty (20) names yet on the roll in 1 801, as follows :
Colonel Joseph Vaughan.
Major Robert Kirkwood.
Major James Moore.
Major Daniel Jenifer Adams.
Major Peter Jaquett
Doctor James Tilton.
Doctor George Monro.
Captain Henry Duff.
Captain Allen McLane.
Captain Thomas Kean.
* For oration and full account of this interesting ceremony, see Appendix
K ; also, " Reminiscences of Wilmington," by Miss E. Montgomery, pp.
297-98. The procession formed in the Town Hall, on Market Street (the
previous arrangements having been made in the old Academy, see note, p.
35), and moved down to Second Street, up French Street, and thence to the
stone meeting-house, known as the Second Presbyterian Church, at the cor-
ner of Walnut and Fifth Streets, where the ceremonies were held. The
Judge Bedford named above was Gunning Bedford, Junior, the Major Cass
28 HISTORY OF THE DELAWARE STATE
Captain Caleb P. Bennett.
Surgeon Reuben Gilder.
Lieutenant John Piatt.
Lieutenant John Vance Hyatt.
Lieutenant Joseph Hosman.
Lieutenant Stephen McWilliam.
Lieutenant Charles Kidd.
Lieutenant Joseph Driskill.
J. Mayo.
John Jones.*
The following year, however, we find one of its most
prominent members, Colonel Allen McLane, petitions the
Pennsylvania Society, at its annual meeting at Francis'
was Major Jonathan Cass, of the Third U. S. Infantry, stationed at the time
at, and in command of, the old U. S. Arsenal near Wilmington.
The above-mentioned oration, in the possession of the author, is endorsed
on the title-page in the handwriting of Captain Roche, as follows :
"To
Miss Betsy Donaldson,
as a Memorial of her
Polite and Patriotic attentions
on the 22d February, 1800,
in Honor of the Memory of
George Washington.
By order of the Society of the Cincinnati
of the State of Delaware.
Edwd. Roche, Sec'y."
A copy of this oration is now in the collection of the New York Histor-
ical Society. See " Bulletin, Phila. Library Co., Phila., Pa.," 1851, p. 51.
The autograph of Captain Roche, under his portrait in silhouette (opposite
page 85), is a facsimile of that in the above dedication.
* Records of Delaware Society of Cincinnati. See, also, Scharf 's " Hist.
Delaware," Vol. I., p. 266.
SOCIETY OF THE CINCINNATI. 29
Hall in Philadelphia, July 5, 1802, to be admitted to mem-
bership in that Society, by reason of the Delaware Society,
of which he was a former member, having ceased to exist.
The wording of his petition is plaintive. He states that
" In the commencement of the struggle for the Independence of America,
he resided with his family in one of the three lower counties then annex'd to
Pennsylvania, now denominated the State of Delaware, and that after the
contest he returned with his family to said State, the better to enable him to
support them, and that at that time it was more convenient for him to meet
the Society then assembled in said State, and that he did subscribe his name,
paid his dues, received his diploma and has since conformed to the rules of
said Society, as fully appears by the enclosed paper. But that he has to
lament a great falling off in said Society owing to death and desertion, so
that it is no more ; and therefore requests he might be permitted to assemble
with his companions in arms, the members of the Society of Pennsylvania,
and be considered as a member of the same from this time."
To this is appended the certificate of the Secretary of
the Delaware Society, as follows :
" I do hereby certify to whom it may concern that Major Allen McLane
is a member of the Society of the Cincinnati in the State of Delaware : That
he has subscribed and paid one month's pay thereto, and has generally con-
formed to the Rules and orders thereof.
" In witness whereof I have hereunto set my hand and seal this thirtieth
day of June in the year of our Lord one thousand eight hundred and two."*
[Seal.]
* Archives of Penna. State Society of the Cincinnati.
30 HISTORY OF THE DELAWARE STATE
The applicant was accordingly admitted to the Penn-
sylvania Society with the proviso that his month's pay be
transferred at the same time. The Treasurer's account in
the latter Society accordingly has the following entry:
" 1802. August 5. To cash from A. McLane, being
his dividend from
" The Delaware Society . . $43.50."*
The exact date when the Delaware Society was dis-
solved, or, to speak more correctly, " when, on the informa-
tion of some of its members, a portion of the members
of the Delaware State Society of the Cincinnati had voted
to dissolve that Society and distributed its funds/'f is not
easily settled. No date is given in the report by the Com-
mittee in 181 1 appointed "to ascertain the present situation
of the several State Societies of the Cincinnati," it simply
calls attention to " the inconsiderate act of a portion of
the members of one or more State Societies in dissolving-
their official connection as members of the Cincinnati and
in distributing those funds which had long ceased to be
individual property, or liable to any but their original
appropriation."!
The Committee's report was unanimously adopted by
the General Society, and the Secretary-General was in-
structed " to forward a draft of the circular letter which the
Committee had submitted with its report, to the Presidents
* See " Records of Penna. State Society of the Cincinnati," 1891, pp.
60, 61.
f See Report of Col. Elias Boudinot, Chairman of Committee, Proceed-
ings of General Society of the Cincinnati, Aug. 9, 181 1.
\ Ibid.
*ZSZ£-
1746-1829.
POSSESSION OF FA
SOCIETY OF THE CINCINNATI. 3 1
of the respective State Societies, or to such member thereof
as would cause it to be laid before said Society."
The circular for Delaware, although that State Society had
dissolved, was duly authenticated by the President-General
and Secretary-General, " by unanimous order in General
Meeting, and sent to the care of one of its former most
influential original members" {query, Allen McLane?),
urging " as the best corrective, despite its dissolution and the
distribution of its funds, the immediate renewal of that
endeared intercourse," and earnestly recommending to that
State Society to send delegates to a special meeting
appointed for the following year (thus clearly showing the
so-called dissolution of the Delaware Society was never
accepted by the General body). In consequence, however,
of the decease or dispersion of the Delaware members, the
foregoing recommendation of the General Society was found
impossible of execution.*
At a meeting of the Standing Committee of the New
York State Society of the Cincinnati on August 2, 1804,
a letter was read from Edward Roach (Roche f), late
Secretary of the Delaware State Society, stating that " that
Society had been dissolved long since and the funds been
divided among its members. "f This letter is lost from the
archives of the New York Society, as is also the circular
* See Report of Col. Elias Boudinot, Chairman of Committee, Proceed-
ings of General Society of the Cincinnati, Aug. 9, 181 1 ; also, "Precedents
and Ordinances of General Society of the Cincinnati, 1783-1885," by A. B.
Gardiner, LL.D., pp. 10, II.
f " Hist. Society of the Cincinnati," by Hon. Hamilton Fish, 1884, p. 47.
Also, " Records of N. Y. State Society of the Cincinnati."
32 HISTORY OF THE DELAWARE STATE
letter of the Delaware Society of November 6, 1783
(before cited), which was read before the New York Society
on February 3, 1784, and a Committee appointed, consist-
ing of Brigadier- General Philip Van Cortlandt, Lieutenant-
Colonel Edward Antill, and Lieutenant-Colonel Richard
Piatt, to draft an answer. This Committee reported their
reply to the Standing Committee on February 9, 1784, when
it was adopted, signed by the President of the New York
Society and forwarded to the Delaware Society, but as
these letters were not recorded in the New York Society's
minutes, their full context cannot be now ascertained.*
In a memorandum presented to the Massachusetts
Society of the Cincinnati, in June, 18 12, we find it stated
that " the Society was dissolved in Delaware by a formal
vote in July, 1802, and the funds were resumed in due pro-
portions by those who had furnished them."f
Mr. Lloyd P. Smith, late librarian of the Philadelphia Li-
brary Company, in his "Bulletin" of 1885, states: "The Dela-
ware Society was dissolved about the year 1804, the more
attached of the members carrying their share of the funds
into the Pennsylvania Society. The archives are lost (?)."|
Per contra, Scharf, in his very complete and recent " His-
tory of Delaware," says "the Society of the Cincinnati in
Delaware continued in Wilmington for over half a century,
and then ceased to exist,"§ while the exact date has been
* " Records of N. Y. State Society of the Cincinnati."
f " Hist, of N. C. State Society of Cincinnati," by E. G. Daves, 1894, p.
14. Also, " Records of Mass. State Society of Cincinnati."
\ " Bulletin Phila. Library Co., Phila., Pa.," 1851, p. 51.
\ Scharf 's " Hist. Delaware," Vol. I., p. 266.
SOCIETY OF THE CINCINNATI. 33
recently fixed, by a most excellent authority in another of
the State Societies of the Cincinnati, as being as late as
1828.*
On July 4, 1 82 1, Mr. John R. Latimer, eldest son of
Dr. Henry Latimer, an original member of the Delaware
Society, was admitted a member of the Pennsylvania So-
ciety. The Treasurer's account has the following entry :
" 1822. June 24. By cash rec'd from
"J. R. Latimer . . 0i2O."t
These two preceding-named admissions (Colonel Allen
McLane and John R. Latimer, by descent), with that of
Major James Moore, afterwards Assistant Treasurer of the
Pennsylvania Society (1798- 1800) J appear to be the only
cases where the Delaware Society was afterwards repre-
sented in another State Society.
A long lapse of time now ensues, in which no reference
is made to the Delaware Society by the General Society
in its triennial proceedings, other than to repeatedly deplore
the fact of the non-existence of this with other extinct or
dormant State Societies. Finally, a committee having been
* Richard M. McSherry, Esq., Treasurer of Maryland State Society of the
Cincinnati.
f " Records of Penna. State Society of the Cincinnati," 1891, p. 66.
\ Ibid., p. 77. See, also, Winthrop Sargent's "Journal General Meeting
of Cincinnati Society, 17S4."
34 HISTORY OF THE DELAWARE STATE
appointed by the General Society to examine documents,
etc., it reports as follows, at the meeting of the General
Society in Boston, Mass., May 27, 1857 :
" Of the Delaware papers no trace has yet been discov-
ered."*
Just three years after this report, however, the original
roll of the Delaware Society, containing the names of all
the members, with their respective ranks, the amount paid
in by each, together with the total fund of the Society (a
little over fifteen hundred dollars), was discovered — on the
authority of Hon. Hamilton Fish — in Philadelphia by a
fortunate accident, and preserved from destruction by John
R. Latimer, the son of one of the original members, and
then President of the Pennsylvania Society.f
We think, also, it has been already shown that a con-
siderable portion of the records of the Society still exist ;
the foregoing proceedings of each meeting having been
given in full in order to show the patriotic spirit that
animated the members throughout the existence of the
Society. Possibly, too, the formation of the " Patriotic
Society"| in Wilmington and New Castle, in 1792, by
* Proceedings of General Society of the Cincinnati, 1857.
I Memorandum of Hon. Hamilton Fish, President-General of the Cincin-
nati, dated May 2, 1S60, and on file in archives of the N. Y. State Society.
% The Constitution of " The Patriotic Society of the County of New Castle,
in the State of Delaware" (and which is in the possession of the writer),
declares " the Public Good to be its sole object," and, among its other prin-
ciples, announced, that " it is both our right and our duty, as well as that of
every other freeman, to regard with attention and discuss with freedom the
conduct of the public servants in every department of Government;" and
that " it is therefore the duty of every good citizen and shall be the constant
SOCIETY OF THE CINCINNATI.
35
officers and soldiers of the Revolution, had a great deal to
do with the gradual extinction of the Cincinnati in Dela-
ware, by reason of being a more popular organization
than the latter. Dr. James Tilton was likewise (in 1797)
President of
the former,
Dr. George
Monro Sec-
retary, and
Alexander Harvey Treasurer. The Society at one time
numbered over fifty members, and met in the old Wilming-
ton Academy, long since vanished.*
endeavor of this Society, not only to remove prejudices, to conciliate the
affections, to inform the understanding, and to promote the happiness of all
our fellow-citizens, but to detect and publish to the world every violation of
our Constitutions or instance of maladministration." The Society consisted
of a General Meeting of the Associators within the County and of Meetings
of the Associators in every " hundred" in the County, the former Meeting
being held quarterly, the latter at their discretion. James McCullough was
President, and John Bird, Secretary of this political organization (for such it
eventually became) in the year 1794.
* The old Wilmington Acad-
emy stood on the south side of
the King's Road, or Market
Street, between Eighth and Ninth
Streets, and was a two-story stone
edifice, similar in appearance to
the old Rodney House, yet stand-
ing, in Wilmington, at Tenth and
Broome Streets. It is stated in
the early records that a lot which
had been the property of Peter
Stalcopp was purchased by Jonathan Daws and afterwards given by him
WILMINGTON ACADEMY.
Founded 1772-73.
36 HISTORY OF THE DELAWARE STATE
Many of the original members of the Society of the
Cincinnati, however, were still regarded with affectionate
esteem by the mass of the citizens, and were honored later
in their lives with the highest office within the people's
to build the Academy, which was erected in 1772-3. The lot extended to
King's Street, in the rear, the building itself standing back from the road
with a high wall in front and with large gates. Some of the old trees of the
former grove were left standing. The ordinary English branches, with the
Greek and Latin languages, were taught by a body of able instructors.
The first trustees of the Grammar School, or the " Academy," as it was
popularly known, were the owners of names well known and prominent in
the affairs of both Delaware and Pennsylvania, viz. : Rev. Lawrence Girelius,
Rev. Philip Reading, Richard McWilliam, George Read, Thomas Duff,
Esq., James Lea, Joseph Staplers, John Jones, Theodore Maurice, Jonas
Stidham, Nicholas Way, George Evans, Joseph Shallcross, Vincent Gilpin,
and Jonathan Daws, all of New Castle County; also, the celebrated Rev.
William Smith, D.D., first Provost of the College and Academy of Philadel-
phia, Rev. Richard Peters, of Christ Church, and Rev. Jacob Duche, of St.
Peter's Church (likewise of Philadelphia), Thomas Mifflin, Joseph Pember-
ton, Myers Fisher, Thomas Gilpin, and Benjamin Wyncoop, all of the same
city.
In 1803 the Academy was incorporated as a College, and the following
distinguished body of trustees from Delaware and Philadelphia, Pa., ap-
pointed: Right Rev. William White, D.D., Rev. William Smith, D.D.,
Myers Fisher, John Dickinson, Thomas Duff, Joseph Tattnall, Jacob Broome,
Gunning Bedford, James A. Bayard, Csesar Rodney, Daniel Rodney, Thomas
Read, David Hall, Nicholas Ridgely, James Wilson, James Lea, Dr. Henry
Latimer, Dr. George Monro, Dr. Ebenezer Augustus Smith, Joseph Tilton,
Joseph Gilpin, Robert Hamilton, William Halliwell, James Sykes, William
Warner, Outerbridge Horsey, Andrew Barrett, William McKee, and George
Kennard ; men representing all sects of religion and all shades of political
feeling.
It was in this old historic building (virtually the Town Hall) in which
portions of conflicting armies had in succession been quartered during the
Revolution, and which had been at different times converted into a barrack
SOCIETY OF THE CINCINNATI. 37
gift, — that of governor of the State. Such were Colonel
David Hall, Major Nathaniel Mitchell, and Captain Caleb
Prew Bennett (the
last surviving officer ^2^^fezS?Z^ ^
of the Delaware line) ; SL___g^__J^ S^—Z H^
also Joseph Haslet,
the son of Colonel John Haslet, who fell at Princeton.
Dr. Tilton
was after-
wards ap-
pointed by
President Madison Surgeon-General of the U. S. Army in
the War of 1812; and Colonel Allen McLane, besides
holding several important public offices in the State of
Delaware, became Treasurer-General of the Cincinnati in
1825, and so remained until his decease, in 1829; while
Major William Popham, in 1844, became President of the
New York Society, and afterwards President-General.
John R. Latimer, son of Surgeon Henry Latimer, became
likewise President of the Pennsylvania Society. Major
and a hospital, that all the noted gatherings during the latter part of the
preceding century took place. All the arrangements for the procession of
the Cincinnati on February 22, 1800 (before alluded to), were here concerted,
and here the Society repeatedly assembled on its anniversary meetings until
its final dissolution. For over fifty years the old building stood a landmark
in the centre of Wilmington, until, neglected and sadly in need of repair, it
was abandoned to baser uses and finally demolished. (See " Reminiscences
of Wilmington," by Miss E. Montgomery, pp. 293-98.)
The above drawing of the Academy is from the only one known, in the
possession of Mr. Amos C. Brinton, one of Wilmington's " oldest inhabitants,"
and was copied through his kind permission by the author.
38 HISTORY OF THE DELAWARE STATE
Joseph Anderson, appointed by Washington a judge of the
United States Courts, served afterwards as United States
Senator from Tennessee and as Comptroller of the National
Treasury. The gallant Major Robert Kirkwood, a soldier
to the last, fell in St. Clair's defeat on the Miami, November
4, 1 79 1. Captain Edward Roche, the last Secretary of the
Society, was a Justice of the Peace in Wilmington for
nearly thirty years, and was also one of the last survivors
(dying in 1821), with Major Peter Jaquett, who died in the
year 1835, and Governor Bennett, the final officer of the
Delaware line, as stated, who deceased in 1836.*
And so ends the history of the comparatively brief
existence of the old Delaware State Society of the Cincin-
nati. Who and where, we may well inquire, are the
worthy descendants of the brave Delaware line regiment or
its contemporaries, to revive it ? Many yet survive to this
day, within our call, in this or adjacent States, faithfully
preserving, we find, the golden eagles of insignia, together
with the portraits and diplomas of membership in the
Society, of their heroic ancestors ; while the names and
deeds of Haslet, Hall, Patten, Pope, and Tilton ; of Kirk-
wood, Jaquett, and McLane ; of the Read, Rodney, and
Rudolphf families (each of which latter named furnished
three or four members equally distinguished for gallantry
* See Record of personal and military services of original members of
Delaware State Society of the Cincinnati, Appendix B.
f The Ru-
* dolphs alone
furnished two
members —
SOCIETY OF THE CINCINNATI. 39
in the war for American Independence) are still not only-
household words throughout the State, but have been also
repeated by their worthy representatives in each successive
war in our country as well as in positions of honor in civil
life, to the present day.
And while we trust this earnest appeal for the speedy-
resuscitation of the Society of the Delaware Cincinnati may
not be in vain, let us also hope that its members may in the
future, in their reunited brotherhood, and with a patriotic
pride in the past history of their gallant little State, cherish
the spirit as well of this most honorable of all American in-
stitutions, of which the immortal Washington himself was
its first head, and so continued until the hour of his death.
In the words of the motto of the Order, Esto perpetua.
John and Michael — as officers to Lee's Partisan Legion, and who were dis-
tinguished not only all through the Southern campaign of 1780-82 (see Ap-
pendix A, p. 40), but the latter named of the two being also brevetted by
#&&^L&,£
Congress for special gallantry at the storming of Paulus Hook (now Jersey
City), in New Jersey. (Resolution of U. S. Congress, September 24, 1779.)
After the war he was appointed Major and Commandant of the Squadron of
Cavalry, United States Legion, also Adjutant and Inspector-General U. S. Army.
A third representative, Jacob, was a captain of Pennsylvania partisan
troops, and was taken prisoner in the battle of Brandywine ; while still an-
other, his brother John, captured at the beginning of the Revolution, at Fort
Washington, in November, 1776, afterwards served throughout the war as
an officer of the Pennsylvania line.
See Pa. Archives, Second Series, Vols. X., XIV., and XV. Also, John-
ston's " Hist. Cecil Co., Md."
40 HISTORY OF THE DELAWARE STATE
APPENDIX A.
A Brief Account of the Delaware Regiments in the
Revolution.
The following brief narration of the history of the two
Delaware regiments in the Revolutionary War has been
mainly taken from the original journal of Sergeant-Major
William Seymour, of the Delaware line, now in the posses-
sion of, and republished by, the Historical Society of Penn-
sylvania,* as well as from the personal recollections of Gov-
ernor Caleb Prew Bennett, an officer in the same regiment,
published by the same Society.f Reference has also been
freely made to the " Annals of Delaware" in the " Dela-
ware Register," Vol. II. (1839), ano ^ to tne Hon. William
G. Whiteley's address on the " Revolutionary Soldiers of
Delaware," read before the Delaware Historical Society
some twenty years since, and afterwards, by request, before
the two houses of the Delaware Legislature. By reason of
the lapse of time and the comparative rarity of all these
named publications, as well as of the possible necessity for
frequent reference to the subject, the author has thought it
well to append a resume of the services of these troops, led
by the officers so repeatedly mentioned in the foregoing
pages.
* Pa. Mag. Hist, and Biog., Vol. VII., Nos. 3 and 4 (1883).
f Ibid., Vol. IX., No. 4 (1885) and " Niles' Register," Sept. 2, -1843.
*^ ^^ ^T '^ J ^ 7y
1758-1:
ENOANT, CALVIN SMITH BENNETT, NATCHEZ, MISS.
SOCIETY OF THE CINCINNATI. 4 1
Several errors, however, in regard to both names and
dates have been found, by comparison with the original
records, to exist in the last-named paper. These — but only
where absolutely certain of being right — the author has
ventured to correct, aware of the fact that similar inaccura-
cies may possibly be found in the future, by others having
additional data at hand, in these pages.
The entire population of Delaware at the commencement
of the Revolution was only about 37,000, and the number
of troops the State could furnish could not necessarily be
very large ; yet, by the second year of the war, it supplied
and sent to the front three organizations, viz. : Colonels
Haslet and Hall's regiments and Colonel Patterson's bat-
talion, besides a partisan company under the command of
Captain Allen McLane. Colonel Henry Neill had also, in
the latter part of the war, a regiment called the Second
Delaware battalion, but it does not appear to have been in
any action.*
Haslet's regiment,f composed of State troops in Con-
tinental service, — that is, troops organized under the
* A writer in the Freeman's Journal, of Philadelphia, October 8, 1783,
states that Delaware furnished double its quota of troops in proportion to
population, as compared to Pennsylvania and other larger States. The Dela-
ware soldiers, including Continentals and militia, enlisted and in service,
from 1775 to 1783, were as follows:
1776.
• 754
1780 .
• 556
1777 •
• 1299
1781 .
• 89
1778.
• 349
1782 .
164
1779.
• 317
1783.
Total .
• 235
• 3763
f See Appendix C, p. 72.
42 HISTORY OF THE DELAWARE STATE
Colonial laws and furnished by the Delaware State upon
the call of Congress, who appointed their field officers, —
remained in service only until after the battle of Princeton,
January 3, 1777.
Hall's regiment* was the only strictly " Continental" one
furnished by Delaware that saw active service. It was
organized under a law of the Continental Congress, and
this is the regiment always referred to when mention is
made during the war of the " Delaware Regiment."
Patterson's battalionf was a part of the " Flying Camp,"
as it was called, — a body of men called out by Congress in
the fall of 1776 from New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Delaware,
and Maryland, to protect the Middle Colonies and to serve
until December 1, 1776. Being undisciplined militia, their
record was not satisfactory, and they returned to their
homes at the expiration of their brief term of service, hav-
ing had but one slight skirmish with the enemy.
Delaware, by an Act of the General Assembly, passed
June 21,1 780, raised a fourth regiment, and the command was
assigned to Colonel Henry Neill.| It was the second Con-
tinental regi-
ment mus-
tered into the
service of the
United States
from that
State. It was called " Continental Regiment, No. 38," was
* See Appendixes D and E, pp. 75 and 78.
f See Appendix G, p. 81.
% See Appendix F, p. 80.
SOCIETY OF THE CINCINNATI. 43
stationed in Kent County, Maryland, and served but a
limited period.*
The services of Captain Allen McLane's partisan com-
pany, whether as an independent command or afterwards as
part of Lee's Corps, are too well known to require here
detailed repetition. f
Delaware, however, says Whiteley, —
" Had great cause in the main to be proud of the conduct and heroism
of its Revolutionary soldiers. In less than a month after the Declaration of
Independence the State had eight hundred men in the field, who fought at
Brooklyn, White Plains, Trenton, and Princeton, when the regiment, reduced
to only one hundred officers and men, and its colonel killed while gallantly
leading it into action, virtually ceased to exist.
" In April, 1777, however, another regiment took its place, which fought at
Brandywine, Germantown, Monmouth, Camden, Cowpens, Guilford, Ninety
Six, and Eutaw, and this latter organization never laid down its arms, though
reduced to almost a mere handful of men, until Cornwallis surrendered at
Yorktown and Leslie evacuated Charleston.
" In fact, there was not a battle during the Revolution worthy of the name,
except those at Bunker's Hill and at Yorktown, in which one of the two
Delaware regiments did not participate with credit. And even at Yorktown,
though Hall's regiment itself, or rather what was left of it, was not present, it
being at that time with Greene in the Carolinas, yet seven hundred recruits,
raised in Delaware and Maryland for Kirkwood's and Smallwood's battalions,
were stopped on their way to join their respective commands and ordered to
join the American army before Yorktown, and thus the regiment itself may
be said to have participated there also in the siege, the decisive battle, and
conclusive victory of the war."
The first Delaware Regiment, under the brave Haslet,
in August, 1776, joined the head-quarters of the army,
* See " Life of John Neill, of Lewes, Del., and Descendants" (private
edition), 1875; a ^ so > " Remembrancer," Vol. X., part 2, London, 1780.
f See Appendix H, p. 82.
44 HISTORY OF THE DELAWARE STATE
which was then at New York, the troops marching from
Dover to New York without tents, and probably supplying
themselves with provisions along the route. The regiment
was brigaded with Smallwood's Maryland and four Penn-
sylvania regiments, Lord Sterling being in command of the
brigade. On the 27th of August, not more than five weeks
after their marching from their native State, the Dela-
wareans were in the battle of Brooklyn, or Long Island,
and behaved with the courage, the discipline, and the
steadiness of veteran soldiers.
It was stated at the time that the Delaware, with the
Maryland and Pennsylvania troops, fought as bravely as
men could possibly do. The latter became separated, by
which means the enemy obliged them to fight in small
parties. " But the Delawares, being well trained, kept and
fought in a compact body the whole time, and, when obliged
to retreat, preserved their ranks, and entered the lines in
that order; and were obliged frequently, while retreating,
to fight their way through bodies of the enemy." Caesar
Rodney, also, in a letter at the time to his brother Thomas
Rodney, speaks of
" the great honor obtained by the Delaware Battalion in the affair at Long
Island, from the unparalleled bravery they showed in view of all the Generals
and troops within the lines, who alternately praised and pitied them."
In a subsequent letter he says, —
" The Delaware and Maryland regiments stood firm to the last ; they stood
for four hours drawn up on a hill, in close array, their colors flying, the
enemy's artillery playing upon them, nor did they think of quitting their
station until an express order from the General commanded them to retreat.
. . . The standard was torn with shot in Ensign Stephen's hands."
SOCIETY OF THE CINCINNATI. 45
Lieutenants Stewart and Harvey were killed ; Major
Macdonough, who was in command, Lieutenant Anderson,
and Ensign Corse were wounded.
The next general battle in which the regiment partici-
pated was that of White Plains ; then at Trenton, on
Christmas day, 1776. The battle of Princeton followed in
ten days afterwards,
and here the brave
Colonel Haslet fell in
the first attack on the
British lines at sun-
rise. Soon after, the
regiment, greatly reduced in numbers and never reor-
ganized, was disbanded ; the majority of officers and men
having left to serve in the new Continental regiment called
for by resolve of Congress (of September 16, 1776) to
serve during the war. By reference to the following rolls,
it will be readily perceived how many officers of the
first Delaware Regiment obtained appointments in Colonel
Hall's new regiment. These officers, doubtless, also car-
ried off a great number of their men. The former were
commissioned by Congress, though their appointment, ex-
cept as to general officers, was left to the government of
the several States, which provided arms and clothing for
the men.
This second regiment became the justly celebrated
" Delaware Line." The first company to join it was Cap-
tain John Patten's ; the second was Captain Robert Kirk-
wood's, — both in the latter part of 1776. Six other
companies joined during the winter, and the regiment was
46 HISTORY OF THE DELAWARE STATE
filled to the standard of eight hundred men by the fol-
lowing spring, though there were the usual difficulties and
delays in clothing, equipping, and arming it*
It is not easy to obtain a correct or complete history of
the regiment for the years 1777-79, there being in the
State House at Dover but few original rolls, or other
returns of any kind, of the regiment; our main reliance
being on the private papers and letters of the officers and
men, and these are few and difficult to find at the present
day.
We know, however, the regiment joined Washington in
the Jerseys in the spring of 1777, and participated in the
battles of Monmouth, Brandywine, and Germantown. Its
members also shared the privations and bore the sufferings
of the dreary winter at Valley Forge, as became true
American soldiers.f
It was in the southern campaigns, however, where the
* The receipt on the opposite page, later in the same year, when Colonel
Pope was in command, owing to Colonel Hall having been seriously wounded
at the battle of Germantown, is in the handwriting of George Read, signer
of the Declaration of Independence, and is photographed directly from the
original. See, also, petition of officers of Delaware regiment to General
Assembly of the Delaware State, dated December 4, 1779, P ra y m g f° r relief
in the matter of supplies of provisions and clothing. Scharf 's " History of
Delaware," Vol. I., p. 250 ; also Whiteley's " Revolutionary Soldiers of Dela-
ware," pp. 52, 53. The original of this interesting document, with the sig-
natures of all the officers appended, together with the official action of the
two Houses of the General Assembly thereon, is now in the archives of the
Delaware State Society of the Cincinnati.
f See Caleb P. Bennett's " Narrative of the Delaware Regiment in the
Revolution," Pa. Mag. Hist, and Biog., Vol. IX. (1885).
fc w a
£ ° 2
2 f 2
5 f 1 3
H N
M 8 H
W B H ^
* > Ci
« K W »
H e * 2
« D 5 p)
r w 2 £
*> b w
£ w M
w M H
? w
kM v-^
I3W&
SOCIETY OF THE CINCINNATI. 47
regiment won its immortality. On April 13, 1780, the
Delaware and Maryland troops, then encamped around
Morristown in New Jersey, were ordered South. On
April 16, they took up their line of march, two regi-
ments from Maryland and one from Delaware, each about
five hundred strong, or some fifteen hundred men in all.
The brave Baron de Kalb was assigned as their com-
mander.
Colonel Hall did not march with his regiment, nor did
he ever join it again, having been disabled by his wounds
received at Germantown from taking the field. Lieutenant-
Colonel Pope was on furlough at the time of march (having
been also wounded at Mamaroneck), and did not go South.
Major Joseph Vaughan was therefore in command. The
regiments marched from Morristown to the head of Elk, as
it was then called (now Elkton), in Cecil County, Maryland.
This march was through Philadelphia and Wilmington, — a
distance of one hundred and eight miles. They were
veterans of three years' service, as thoroughly trained and
disciplined, as brave and good soldiers as were to be found
in the Continental Army, and if Greene had then been in
command of the Southern Department instead of Gates,
their worse than decimation at Camden would have been
avoided and the lives of many of these brave and patriotic
men saved.
From the head of Elk all the troops were taken by water
to Petersburg, in Virginia, except the park of artillery,
which proceeded by land, under escort of a detachment
from all the line. The journal of Sergeant-Major William
Seymour gives a complete and exceedingly interesting
48 HISTORY OF THE DELAWARE STATE
account of the entire campaign.* The description of the
marches, the condition of the troops, their want of provi-
sions, and their losses in battle are all fully and vividly-
related. Leaving Petersburg, the column proceeded south-
ward by the way of Hillsborough, in North Carolina (four
hundred and seventy miles from the Elk), to Buffalo Ford,
on Deep River, where General Gates took command of the
entire Southern army.
They were now approaching Camden, the scene of their
first great battle in the South, where, though the issue was
so disastrous to the American forces, the Delaware and
Maryland lines won imperishable renown. It is not the
intention here to describe in detail this, or indeed any other,
battle in which these troops were afterwards engaged, — to
do so would be foreign to the object and scope of this
paper. The battle of Camden was fought on August 16,
1780, and resulted in the overwhelming defeat of the
American troops, though the Delaware and Maryland sol-
diers covered themselves with glory in saving the remainder
of the routed army from annihilation. The former regi-
ment at the commencement of the battle was five hundred
strong ; at its close — and the fight lasted scarcely an
hour — less than two hundred officers and men remained !
Lieutenant-Colonel Vaughan and Major John Patten were
among the prisoners, and the command for the remainder
of the war devolved
mainly upon the glo-
rious Kirkwood, — he of
whom Seymour writes in panegyric that :
* See Pa. Mag. Hist, and Biog., Vol. VII. (1883).
SOCIETY OF THE CINCINNATI. 49
" His (Kirkwood's) heroick valour and uncommon and undaunted bravery
must needs be recorded in history till after years."*
At Charlotte and Hillsborough, Kirkwood afterwards
collected what remained of the regiment; and three com-
panies of light infantry being formed out of the combined
different corps, to the command of one of them — com-
posed of the remnants of the Delaware and Second Mary-
land Regiments — Captain Kirkwood was assigned.
They participated in all the battles under Greene (who
had relieved Gates) in the South from this time until the
evacuation of Charleston by the British, near the close of
the war, which was virtually ended with the surrender of
Cornwallis at Yorktown, in the fall of the preceding year.
At Guilford Court-House, Hobkirk's Hill, Eutaw Springs,
and Ninety Six this gallant band immortalized themselves.
General Greene, in his report to Congress of the battle at
Guilford, mentions in the most commendatory manner the
"old Delaware company of light infantry, under the brave Captain Kirk-
wood, whose conduct and intrepidity were peculiarly conspicuous;"
and Lee speaks of
" the company of Delaware, under Kirkwood, to whom none could be supe-
* Henry Lee, in his edition of his father's " Memoirs of the War in the
Southern Department of the United States," says, by way of comparison, in
speaking of Captain Edward Oldham, of the Fourth Maryland line, " too
much praise cannot be given him. He (Captain Oldham) was engaged in
almost every action in the South, and was uniformly distinguished for gal-
lantry and good conduct. With the exception of Kirkwood of Delaware and
Rudolph of the Legion Infantry, he was probably entitled to more credit than
any officer of his rank in Greene's army, — a distinction which must place him
high on the rolls of fame."
4
50 HISTORY OF THE DELAWARE STATE
The same praise is bestowed upon these troops in suc-
cessive engagements with the enemy. In fact, there is
scarcely a general order issued by Greene in this whole
campaign, after any of its battles, in which the Delaware
battalion is not particularly named as meriting especial
praise. In the siege and storming of the post of Ninety
Six, Colonel Henry Lee led Kirkwood's Delawares with the
troops of his own legion, and, with the intrepid Captain
John Rudolph* leading the forlorn hope in advance, was
the first to enter the fort. Though the attack failed, the
gallantry of these troops was again commented on in orders
by the commander of the American forces.
Congress, when the report of Greene of the battle of
Eutaw was received, passed a resolution of thanks in which
it was resolved, —
" That the thanks of the United States in Congress assembled be presented
to the officers and men of the Maryland and Virginia brigades and Delaware
battalion of Continental troops, for the unparalleled bravery and heroism by
them displayed in advancing to the enemy through an incessant fire and
charging them with an impetuosity and order that could not be resisted."
Their final year of service is described by Bennett suc-
cinctly as follows :
" The Pennsylvanians, Marylanders, and Delawares, under the command
of General St. Clair, after the surrender at Yorktown, proceeded South to
join the army in South Carolina under General Greene, where we arrived,
after a long and fatiguing march, the first day of January, 1782. On our
arrival we (the Delaware detachment, commanded by Captain William
McKennan), of course, took our station in Colonel William Washington's
legion, composed of the remains of his regiment of horse and the shattered
remains of the Delaware regiment, under the command of Captain Robert
* Written indifferently Rudolph and Rudwlph in the reports.
SOCIETY OF THE CINCINNATI. 5 1
Kirkwood, with Captain Peter Jaquett, Lieutenants James Campbell and
Thomas Anderson, who had been in command of the two companies of said
regiment and had remained with the Southern army since the battle of
Camden, August 1 6, 1780.
"When the officers above mentioned and the invalids, with several other
non-commissioned officers and soldiers belonging to Delaware, were relieved
by those under the command of Captain William McKennan, with Captain
Paul Queenault, Lieutenants Hyatt and Bennett, they proceeded soon after
on their route for the State of Delaware. Our forces were then concentrated
under General Greene, the army proceeded down towards Charleston, where
the British were in force (the ilite of the army was composed of the two
legions, Washington's and Lee's, with a detachment from the line of the
army under the command of Major James Hamilton, of Pennsylvania), and
took up a position on the Ashley River and was constantly kept on the alert,
never stationary ; the whole or part of the command being continually on the
lines watching the movements of the enemy.
**********
" The troops, both British and American, for the remainder of the cam-
paign were inactive, the heat of the weather and the sickly season had arrived.
The army retired from active service, and remained in that situation until it
was understood the British army was on the eve of evacuating Charleston,
the only position then held in the Southern States.
" Soon after, Captain William McKennan and his command were ordered
to proceed to the State of Delaware, there to wait for further orders."*
And, as a concluding chapter in this brief history, Ser-
geant-Major Seymour closes his journal in these words :
"On November 7th (1782), the Maryland and Pennsylvania troops were
formed into two battalions or regiments, each consisting of six hundred men,
rank and file, the eighteen months men being sent home to their respective
States. At the same time the Delaware regiment had orders to hold them-
selves in readiness to march home from the southward on the 16th of
November.
" On the same day started from head-quarters on the Ashley River for
* Pa. Mag. Hist, and Biog., Vol. IX. (1SS5).
52 HISTORY OF THE DELAWARE STATE
home, coming by way of Camden. Having arrived there November 22,
were detained thirteen days by orders from General Greene ; left on Decem-
ber 5, coming by way of Salisbury, Petersburgh, Carter's Ferry, on James
River, we arrived at Georgetown, in Maryland, January 12, 1783; left there
the same day and arrived at Christiana Bridge on the 17th, after a march of
seven hundred and twenty miles from encampment on Ashley River, which
was performed with very much difficulty, our men being so very weak after
a tedious sickness which prevailed amongst them all last summer and fall."*
No eulogy of the Delaware Line in the Revolution is
needed to be added at this day. The simple recountal of
its history and its services is sufficient, it would seem, to
perpetuate for all time the heroism, the endurance, and the
patriotism of its officers and its men.
* Pa. Mag. Hist, and Biog., Vol. VII. (1883).
I75I-I79 6 -
; PORTRAIT IN POSSESSION OF DESCEND*
CHARLES BHECK ADAMS, FEROUSON,
SOCIETY OF THE CINCINNATI. 53
APPENDIX B.
Record of Personal and Military Services of Original
Members of Delaware State Society
of the Cincinnati.
Adams, Daniel Jenifer, born at Port Tobacco, Charles
County, Maryland, 175 1 ; the son of Josias and Ann
(Jenifer) Adams. Commissioned First Lieutenant Captain
Beall's Independent Company, Maryland Militia, January
14, 1776; Brigade-Major to General Beall, of Maryland
"Flying Camp," August 27 to December 1, 1776; Major
Seventh Maryland Regiment, Continental Establishment,
April 1, 1777; resigned June 8, 1779. Served after war
as Brigadier-General of Militia and Sheriff of New Castle
County, Delaware. Elected as a delegate to the General
Meeting of the Society of the Cincinnati in 1787. Died
November, 1796, and buried in Old Swedes' Church, Wil-
mington, Delaware.*
Adams, William, son of Captain Nathan Adams, of
Colonel John Haslet's Regiment of Delaware State Troops,
* His portrait by Peale and certificate of membership in Society of the Cin-
cinnati are in possession of his great-grandson, Charles Breck Adams, Fergu-
son, St. Louis Co., Missouri. This and all the other certificates of membership
are signed by General Washington as President, and General Knox as Secre-
tary of the Society, and dated April 26, 1787.
Xp /no Cfl ijfwcfa&n^-
54 HISTORY OF THE DELAWARE STATE
in Continental Service (commissioned January 19, 1776,
and died in
service from
7 C^t^^t^ wounds March
"* 27, 1776). His
eldest son was admitted to membership in the Cincinnati
under the provision of the original Institution.
Anderson, Enoch, born at Newport, New Castle County,
Delaware. Commissioned Second Lieutenant Captain Stid-
ham's Company, Colonel Haslet's Regiment of Delaware
State Troops, in Conti- yj
nental Service, January 13, ^&
1776; wounded at battle
of Long Island, N. Y., August 27, 1776; Captain, Decem-
ber 3, 1776; transferred to Colonel Hall's Delaware
Regiment, Continental Establishment, April 5, 1777; and
retired from service, September — , 1778. Died March 4,
1820.
Anderson, Joseph, born near Philadelphia, Pennsylvania,
November 5, 1757. Studied law and at commencement of
Revolution commissioned Ensign Third New Jersey Regi-
ment, Continental Establishment, May — , 1776; Second
Lieutenant, July 19, 1776; First Lieutenant, November
29, 1776; Captain, October 26, 1777; transferred to First
New Jersey Regiment, Continental Establishment, January
1, 1 78 1 ; retained in New Jersey Battalion, Continental Es-
tablishment, April — , 1783; Regimental Paymaster from
October 26, 1777, to close of war; brevetted Major,
September 30, 1783; was also with General Sullivan in
expedition against Iroquois Indians and present at siege of
SOCIETY OF THE CINCINNATI. 55
Yorktown. After the war he began the practice of law in
Delaware, and in 1791 was appointed by President Wash-
ington, Territorial Judge of the region south of the Ohio
River, and took part as delegate from Jefferson County in
framinj
Constitu-
" on ° f (^JQ£/h^j=