o . * » V \*> ^oV^ ^•\/ V^V V*/ V^V V^'/ %*^>'....^ ■*> .vta*. -\/ /Jfe'v ^.. O K*^ ^0* yr«V %*t^- ^ °o.*^t** cp v : ^ 9 V ^/^-v v*^ 3 > . *< 4? <* a* 0* »fe 1? * 4 ^ V # W a «r \/ °o *^^"^ V r o ♦ *' ^ .^ V >^^:^^. .* v ^i^";-. ^ a*' •*>§«•.' ^ ,^ v .^^o^ ^* ^ ^ W rt" . o » o . *K-> &*** **** -Mr V^ .^K£. %/ «£ v** %■ *0^ *o. *^rr* a ^ < tf ^O*i^ o \/ C *^ 4> ^ ■ >„« ... A^ *% *^tVV* A <\ -o . » % ■^d* :• °o ^/i^-\. c°*.^% ^s^ks% VVi* A 7 • A V -% /.^°o /\^*\ cP*.^^>* o ^\C^/V /.« ;< *^o^ »>» A * .•y\ ;-^.- r /\ -p^A -.^.- /\*' < o,. ' 'i.^r-*.*^ 'q. *^^ , \o' "Oo A, ^ « „ A° *o, *'7CT» A ■4* . ^ .*« ^ i-. X^ ■a* .♦•^ ?/.^%.'.f y\ -* . •• "^O ^, *'TVi* A - - - ^v ^, • » « » ^V <^ ' Bureau of Mines Information Circular/1984 Manganese Availability— Market Economy Countries A Minerals Availability Program Appraisal By Joseph S. Coffman and Cesar M. Palencia UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR Information Circular 8978 Manganese Availability—Market Economy Countries A Minerals Availability Program Appraisal By Joseph S. Coffman and Cesar M. Palencia UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR William P. Clark, Secretary BUREAU OF MINES Robert C. Horton, Director As the Nation's principal conservation agency, the Department of the Interior has responsibility for most of our nationally owned public lands and natural resources. This includes fostering the wisest use of our land and water re- sources, protecting our fish and wildlife, preserving the environmental and cultural values of our national parks and historical places, and providing for the enjoyment of life through outdoor recreation. The Department assesses our energy and mineral resources and works to assure that their development is in the best interests of all our people. The Department also has a major re- sponsibility for American Indian reservation communities and for people who live in Island Territories under U.S. administration. Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data: Coffman, Joseph S Manganese availability— market economy countries. (Information circular / United States Department of the Interior, Bureau of Mines ; 8978) Bibliography: 25 Supt. of Docs, no.: I 28.27:8978. 1. Manganese industry. 2. Manganese mines and mining. I. Palencia, Cesar M. II. United States. Bureau of Mines. III. Title. IV. Series: Information circular (United States. Bureau of Mines) ; 8978. JQN2&5.U4 [HD9539.M32] 622s [333.8'5] 84-600014 For sale by the Superintendent of Documents, U.S. Government Printing Office Washington, D.C. 20402 PREFACE The purpose of the Bureau of Mines Minerals Availability Program (MAP) is to assess the worldwide availability of nonfuel minerals. The program identifies, collects, compiles, and evaluates information on active, developed, and explored mines and deposits, and on mineral processing plants worldwide. Objectives are to classify domestic and foreign resources, to identify by cost evaluation resources that are reserves, and to prepare analyses of mineral availabilities. This report is part of a continuing series of Minerals Availability Program reports that analyze the availability of minerals from domestic and foreign sources and the factors that affect availability Analyses of other minerals are currently in progress. Questions about the Minerals Availability Program should be addressed to the Chief, Division of Minerals Availability Bureau of Mines. 2401 E St., NW., Washington, DC 20241 _J CONTENTS Page Preface iii Abstract 1 Introduction 2 Commodity overview 2 Industrial applications Production 3 Ore and concentrates - 3 Manganese ferroalloys Geology 4 Resources 5 Country* manganese resource summary 8 Australia 8 Brazil 9 Serra do Navio Mine 9 Azul, Buriturama. and Sereno Deposits (Carajas Mineral Province^ 9 Santana Mine 9 Urucum Mine 10 Other mines 10 Gabon 10 Ghana 11 India 11 Maharashtra-Madhya Pradesh area 11 Balaghat Mine 12 Kandri Mine 12 Mansar Mine 12 Tirodi Mine 12 Ukwa Mine 12 Keonjhar District 12 Karnataka (Mysore) area 13 Other mines 13 Page Country manganese resource summary — Con. Mexico 13 South Africa 13 Resources 13 Operations 14 Kalahari Field 14 Black Rock area 15 Mamatwan Mine 15 Middleplaats Mine 15 Wessels Mine 15 Postmasburg Field 16 Ferroalloy smelters 16 United States 16 Upper Volta 17 Alternate sources of supply 17 Sea nodules 17 Stockpile 17 Engineering and economic analyses 18 Mining 18 Beneficiation 18 Transportation 19 Smelting 20 Production cost summary 21 Availability of market economy country manganese 23 Potential total manganese production 23 Potential annual manganese production 24 Conclusions 24 References 25 Appendix. — Mines and deposits investigated but not evaluated for this study 26 ILLUSTRATIONS 1. Joint U.S. Geological Survey-Bureau of Mines resource classification system 5 2. Relationship of demonstrated and identified resources included in this study 5 3. Demonstrated ore resources evaluated in this study, by country 5 4. Location of market economy country manganese mines and deposits 7 5. Manganese ore resources of South Africa, by grade 14 6. U.S. ferromanganese production and imports and manganese ore imports, 1970-81 16 7. Market economy country manganese production costs 21 8. Relationship of cost elements through manganese ore and concentrate production 22 9. Relationship of cost elements through ferromanganese production 22 10. Cost and total availability of world manganese 23 11. Cost and annual availability of world manganese 24 TABLES 1. Market economy country manganese ore and concentrate production, 1976-82 3 2. Market economy country manganese ferroalloy production, 1976-81 4 3. Reserve-resource classification categories by organization 6 4. Market economy country manganese mine and deposit data 6 5. Estimated South African manganese resources, total and used in this study 14 6. Manganese land transportation distances and modes 19 7. Estimated manganese ore and concentrate ocean shipping rates 20 8. Annual manganese ferroalloy capacities and ore requirements of major ore importing and exporting countries 2 1 9. Manganese ore and ferromanganese transportation costs, comparing smelting in South Africa and in the United States 22 10. Manganese ore and ferromanganese transportation costs, comparing smelting in France and in the United States 22 VI UNIT OF MEASURE ABBREVIATIONS USED IN THIS REPORT Btu British thermal unit m meter ft 3 cubic foot mm millimeter kg kilogram |xm micrometer kg/m 3 kilogram per cubic meter pet percent km kilometer ton metric ton unless lb pound otherwise noted MANGANESE AVAJ LABILITY— MARKET ECONOMY COUNTRIES A Minerals Availability Program Appraisal By Joseph S. Coffman 1 and Cesar M. Palencia 3 ABSTRACT To determine the availability of manganese for metallurgical purposes from selected world resources, the Bureau of Mines evaluated the potential production of contained manganese in concentrates based on the demonstrated resources of 23 foreign and 8 domestic mines and deposits in 9 market economy countries. All but 2 of the 23 foreign deposits are operating mines; none of the domestic deposits are in operation. The demonstrated resources of the mines and deposits used in this study represent an in situ ore resource of approximately 2.2 billion tons, 3 containing 780 million tons of manganese with a total recoverable production potential of 514 million tons of contained manganese in concentrates. The analyses of mines and deposits in this study indicate that about 213 million tons of the contained manganese (41 pet) is potentially available at a January 1981 constant dollar long-run total cost of up to $1.50 per long ton unit (22.4 lb, or 10.15 kg contained Mn), approximately 428 million tons (83 pet) is potentially available at a cost of about $1.75 or less, and 491 million tons (95 pet) is available at less than $3.30. The remaining 23 million tons, which is potentially available at much higher costs (about $8 to $35 per unit), represents the U.S. deposits. On an annual basis, with a cost range of up to $1.75 per long ton unit, the availability from currently operating mines would last at least 80 years based on 1980 world production data. Total manganese production costs are estimated to comprise mining — 8 pet, beneficiation — 3 pet, transportation — 26 pet, and smelting — 63 pet. Metallurgist - Mining engineer. Minerals Availability Field Office. Bureau of Mines. Denver, CO. ' L'nless otherwise noted, "tons" refer to metric tons. INTRODUCTION Manganese is a vital element in an industrial society; virtually all steels must contain some manganese to improve malleability. No other metal can be substituted for this purpose. Over 90 pet of all manganese produced is used in the ferrous and nonferrous metallurgical indus- tries for improving metal strength and workability qualities. The remaining amount is used in the battery and chemical industries. The United States is highly dependent on imports for its supply of manganese and has no resource that could economically offset an interruption of foreign supply. In 1981, the United States imported approximately 265,000 tons of manganese ores and concentrates and 620,000 tons of ferromanganese, which represented an apparent 99-pct import dependence (17, p. 96)." The purpose of this report is to evaluate selected domestic and market economy country resources of manganese for metallurgical application. Individual mine and deposit evaluations were performed on the basis of tonnage, grade, and cost of production. In 1982, about 11.6 million tons of manganese ore was produced in 21 market economy countries. Production in the nine countries used in this study accounted for more than 98 pet of this total. Since a high percentage of all manganese produced is used in the metallurgical indus- try, this study includes only resources suitable principally for metallurgical use. In this study, final engineering and economic evalua- tions were performed on 31 mines and deposits. This includes eight U.S. deposits analyzed in a recent report on the availability of U.S. manganese (10). A total of 52 deposits were investigated; however, 21 were excluded from the final analysis because their demonstrated tonnages were negligible or the product was used in the battery and/or chemical industries. Deposits investigated but not included in the final analysis are shown in the appendix. The procedure for conducting this study was to identify and define demonstrated manganese resources and the engineering and economic parameters that would affect production from these selected deposits. Capital investment and operating costs for the mining and beneficiation methods were estimated, and a cost analysis for each deposit was performed. Allowances were made for mine and mill recoveries of manganese from each deposit, and results are reported on the basis of U.S. dollars per long ton unit (22.4 lb or 10.15 kg) of recoverable manganese contained in the concentrates. Estimated production costs are in constant January 1981 dollars and include all required costs to deliver the material to existing ferromanganese smelting areas, according to assumed delivery patterns. The long-run operating costs were estimated to cover mining and processing of the entire demonstrated resource of each mine and deposit. Estimated ferromanganese smelting costs are presented to assess their relative effect on total production costs. Total resources evaluated amount to about 2.2 billion tons of in situ material with about 779 million tons of contained manganese. From this, about 514 million tons of manganese (metal content) is recoverable after all mine and mill recoveries have been applied. This addresses greater than 98 pet of all known demonstrated resources at current mining grades. All resources are estimated as of January 1, 1980. U.S. ferromanganese production has been declining in recent years. The current annual capacity available for production is 250,000 to 350,000 tons, much of which is shut down. COMMODITY OVERVIEW Manganese is the 12th most abundant element in the Earth's crust, and thus manganiferous occurrences are relatively widespread. It is a relatively low-value com- modity of abundant supply and is used in larger quantities than other ferroalloy materials. Manganese occurs in the form of numerous mineral assemblages of varying constituents or mixtures of one or more minerals. The most important economic minerals include bixbyite, braunite, cryptomelane, hausmannite, jacobsite, pyrolusite, rhodochrosite, romanechite (psi- lomelane), and wad. With the exception of rhodochrosite, which is a carbonate, all these minerals are oxides or mixed oxides and silicates. The physical and chemical properties of manganese enhance its strategic value in that other elements can rarely substitute satisfactorily for the use of manganese on a cost-effective basis. No workable substitutes have been found for the metallurgical uses of manganese; only in chemical uses may substitutions be made. Manganese metal oxidizes readily and as metal by itself has no practical use. 4 Italicized numbers in parentheses refer to items in the list of references preceding the appendix. In ancient times, oxides of manganese were used as colorizers and decolorizers for ceramics and glass; elemental manganese was first isolated in 1774. Man- ganese additions to steel began with experiments in 1839 which demonstrated that manganese increased the mal- leability of steel. Large-scale usage of manganese for steel alloying began in 1856 with the addition of spiegeleisen (a low-grade ferromanganese) to the bessemer steel process. In 1888, high-alloy, wear-resistant steels were developed. The invention of the wet galvanic electric cell led to the development of the dry cell battery in 1886, which currently represents one of the largest nonmetallurgical uses of manganese. Oxides of manganese combine easily with a wide range of organic and inorganic acids which are utilized in the chemical industry (3, pp. 653-654). Nearly all manganese resources are located at relatively great distances from the major consuming centers in the United States, Europe, and Japan. A certain amount of manganese concentrate production is processed into ferroalloys or used in direct blast furnace application in countries where it is produced, although the majority is shipped to the major consuming centers. International trade in manganese concentrate is restricted to a relatively small number of users, principal- ly consuming steel mills and intermediate ferroman- ganese producers. Some manganese producers have sales contracts with steel mills which may hold an equity investment in the mine itself. A relatively small amount of manganese concentrate production is sold on the spot market. INDUSTRIAL APPLICATIONS The metallurgical uses of manganese involve the application of raw ore in various forms and its use in the manufacture of manganese ferroalloys. The ores are utilized as a smelting aid in the blast furnace and in the manufacture of manganese ferroalloys; the ferroalloys are usually added to the ladle in steelmaking. The use of manganese in the production or manufac- ture of steel begins with additions of manganiferous materials to the blast furnace charge as an enhancement to smelting. This can be in virtually any form or grade, such as ore, sinter, slag, scrap, manganiferous iron ore, etc. In some areas, iron ores are manganiferous to the extent that little or no additional manganese ore is needed in the process. The principal value is in the manganese acting as a sulfur scavenger and as an enhancement to smelting in that it increases refractory lining life. A certain amount of the blast furnace manganese is passed on to the steel furnaces, where it reduces slag viscosity. It is estimated that in terms of total manganese metal (content^ consumed from all sources — that is, manganese ores and lower grade manganiferous iron ores — about 45 pet is used in the blast furnace {9, p. 29). It is estimated that about one-half of this is from manganese ores that contain less than 35 pet manganese. The remainder would be from low-grade manganiferous iron ores and ferrugi- nous manganese ores that are not primarily mined for manganese. The value of manganese as an alloying agent is its property for improving various qualities of iron and steel. It enhances the toughness, hardening properties under working conditions, hardness, and overall strength of steels. Virtually all steels contain certain amounts of manganese (0.5 to 1.5 pet.) The wear-resistant alloys (Hadfield steels) contain about 10 to 14 pet manganese. PRODUCTION ORE AND CONCENTRATES Market economy country annual manganese ore and concentrate production in 1982 is estimated to be approximately 11.6 million tons. Production data for 1976—82 are shown in table 1. The centrally planned economy countries historically produced approximately 45 pet of the world's manganese ore; however, these countries as a bloc have become net ore importers in recent years. It has been estimated that the U.S.S.R. requires much more manganese per unit of crude steel than does the United States, presumably because of lower grade ores, lower manganese recoveries, and the use of high-sulfur coke (9, p. 4). The grades of the ores and concentrates shown in table 1 vary between considerable limits, and since data Table 1.— Market economy country manganese ore and concentrate production, 1976-82 (Thousand tons) Oc Manganese, pet 1976 1977 1978 1979 1980 1981 37-53 2.154 1,389 1.241 1,723 2,019 1,448 Bolivia 28-54 12 9 1 11 1 1 B-az 38-50 1,696 1,515 1.916 2,258 2,281 2,042 Z* e 32-36 24 18 24 25 28 25 Egypt 28- 44---- GSbori 50-53 2.216 1.850 1.710 2,299 2,146 1,487 Ghana 30-50 312 292 316 272 252 225 Qreace 48-50 8 10 7 5 5 5 India 10-54 1.834 1.865 1,619 1,755 1,645 1,526 ndonai a 47-56 10 6 5 6 5 3 33- 40 40 30 20 Hay 30 4 9 10 10 9 9 Japan 24-28 142 126 104 89 80 87 Korea 23-40 1 1 1 - - - MexiCO 27- 453 487 523 493 447 578 Morocco 50-53 117 114 126 136 132 110 P* pp-nes 35-45 11 21 4 4 3 3 Sour* Afnca 30-48- 5451 5.047 4.345 5,182 5,694 5,038 Thatend 46-50 50 77 73 35 54 11 Turkey 27-46 17 19 68 42 42 15 tinted Stale 12-13 233 196 283 218 158 159 fenuafU 40-44 35 23 21 11 Yugoslavia 30- 19 25 27 30 30 31 Za.re 30-57 182 38 - - 16 31 Totl NAp 15.025 13.181 12,454 14.624 15.047 12.834 -rated NAp Not applicable - Negligible ' Mmor amounts (less than 500 tons) were also produced by Pakistan. Peru, and Sudan 2 Ferruginous manganese ore and manganiferous iron ore Source Reference 19 Converted from short tons by the factor: short tons x 907 ■ metric tons. 1982° 1,132 1,300 24 1,512 132 5 1,466 4 9 82 509 94 3 5,215 8 5 29 31 4 11,564 Table 2. — Market economy country manganese ferroalloy production, 1976-81 (Thousand tons) 1976 1977 1978 1979 1980 Country FeMn SiMn FeMn SiMn FeMn SiMn FeMn SiMn FeMn Argentina 24 (5 36 6 25 10 37 16 35 Australia 50 15 71 24 95 - 86 20 86 Austria 8 - 7 - 7 - 9 - 8 Belgium 84 - 55 - 87 - 90 - 85 Brazil 99 63 129 75 118 106 133 128 141 Canada 80-60-70-41 - 86 Chile 8 2 5 - 5 - 5 - 5 France 365 12 358 21 390 19 440 13 470 Germany, Federal Republic .... 280 - 225 - 225 - 223 - 225 India 176 - 193 10 220 3 189 5 162 Italy 78 42 75 40 90 43 89 54 83 Japan 632 373 527 334 455 303 603 299 569 Korea, Republic 29 - 36 •- 47-53 - 54 Mexico 54 17 100 27 107 34 123 31 125 Norway 348 169 244 127 273 133 337 184 296 Peru - - - - 1 - 1-1 Portugal 55 2 55 5 78 15 75 15 74 South Africa 350 22 310 22 330 22 560 45 500 Spain 133 91 141 63 134 109 148 119 120 Sweden - 7 Thailand 2 - 1 - 1 - 1 Turkey - - 1 - 1 - 1-1 United Kingdom 122 - 69 - 69 - 137 - 52 United States 438 117 303 109 248 129 288 150 171 Venezuela - - - - - - 1 1 2 Yugoslavia - - 54 9 36 28 45 29 44 Zimbabwe - - - - - - 3 - 3 Total 3,437 964 3,055 872 3,112 954 3,718 1,109 3,397 8 Estimated. - Negligible. Source: Reference 18. Converted from short tons by the factor: short tons x 0.907 = metric tons. 1981 s SiMn FeMn SiMn 15 34 14 19 85 19 - 8 - — 90 - 134 128 122 - 109 - - 5 - 21 315 9 - 233 - 5 209 9 45 81 54 310 570 283 - 64 - 31 125 30 168 224 1 73 198 17 18 60 450 50 123 92 63 - 1 91 - 171 175 157 2 2 2 28 54 29 - 2 - 1,149 3,221 1,057 are not available on the amounts produced at specific grades, it is difficult to determine the average manganese content. It is estimated that average annual production of about 13.7 million tons from 1976 to 1982 would contain an annual average of 5.0 to 6.0 million tons of manganese (5.3 million tons in 1981). The weighted average grade of the ores and concentrates produced from the mines and deposits in this study is about 44 pet contained man- ganese. The United States is almost totally dependent on imports for its supply of manganese. Production of ore is limited to manganiferous iron ore. The average grade of all ore produced in the United States in 1980 and 1981 was about 12 to 13 pet manganese. This ore was used in various ceramic applications, such as brick coloring, and for direct additions to the blast furnace. Ore imports by country vary considerably from year to year; in 1981 and 1982 South Africa was the largest supplier of metallurgic- al ore. MANGANESE FERROALLOYS Ferromanganese and silicomanganese account for nearly all the manganese ferroally production. Market economy country production of manganese ferroalloys from 1976 through 1981 is shown in table 2. As can be seen in the table, production of ferroalloys has increased in the ore-producing countries of Australia, Brazil, India, Mexico, and South Africa. The other ore-producing countries of Gabon and Ghana as yet have no smelting facilities. The largest consistent U.S. sources of ferromanganese are South Africa and France. GEOLOGY Manganese deposits are classified into four geological types: hydrothermal, residual, metamorphic, and sedimentary (15, pp. 10-14). Hydrothermal manganese deposits are normally made up of carbonates and oxides of manganese minerals along with other hydrothermal minerals such as barite, fluorite, and sulphides. Examples of hydrothermal vein-type and replacement deposits include the rhodochrosite ore at Butte and Phillipsburg, MT. Residual deposits are formed near the surface by weathering processes. Large deposits of economic sig- nificance include the Serra do Navio Deposits in Brazil, Moanda in Gabon, Nsuta in Ghana, and several occur- rences in Australia and India. Metamorphic occurrences are generally in the form of low-grade silicates and rarely if ever have any economic value. Sedimentary manganese deposits contain the largest portion of world economic manganese. These deposits are subdivided into several subclasses as shown below: 1. Volcanogenic deposits are those in which the manganese can be related directly or indirectly to volcanic sources. The Nsuta Mine in Ghana is considered to be in this class. 2. Nonvolcanogenic sedimentary deposits include those where the manganese is not related to any volcanic source. The more important manganese deposits of this type include Groote Eylandt in Australia, the Morro do Urucum area in Brazil, and the Maharashtra-Madhya Pradesh area in India. 3. Metasedimentary manganese deposits associated with iron formations are identified in Brazil and South Africa. The iron formation units are entensive and cover relatively great distances: however, the associated man- ganese beds within these formations vary in thickness and continuitv. 4. Ocean floor nodules cover vast areas in the Pacific, Atlantic, and Indian Oceans. The nodules are found at all depths of the ocean, but higher grades are usually found within the deeper basins at great distances from land areas. RESOURCES Resources are defined according to the mineral resource-reserve classification system developed jointly by the U.S. Geological Survey and the U.S. Bureau of Mines (21). This classification is shown diagramatically in figure 1. The position of the resources included for this study is shown by the crosshatched areas. The selection of 23 foreign and 8 domestic mines and deposits for this study includes over 98 pet of the known demonstrated resources at current mining grades for . m :-:* :■ EWCt - v :;■.-;«. -E?,-.--. : ,-..,....,. ■ onae '•;■■: 1 Speculate i : *.;■«: V///77 1 + + 1 w - - : i vi - . - BDOMM E : Z/77/P, bOM sue- - grade '-•a'c o ! Figure 1.— Joint U.S. Geological Survey-Bureau of Mines resource classification system. TotoI Identified = 994 million tons Figure 2.— Relationship of demonstrated and Identified resources Included In this study (in situ contained man- ganese). market economy countries. In terms of contained man- ganese, deposits evaluated in this study contain 780 million tons of demonstrated (measured plus indicated) and 994 million tons of identified (measured plus indicated plus inferred) resources (fig. 2). The demonstra- ted resources evaluated in this study by country are illustrated in figure 3. Manganese resource estimate compilations have been made by several organizations. Correlation of these compilations with each other and this study in many cases is quite difficult, if not impossible, because of the different classification criteria used. A summary of world manganese resources was made by the U.S. Geological Survey in 1973 (5). A later world estimate was made in 1979 as a combined effort by the U.S. Geological Survey and the U.S. Bureau of Mines (4). The South Africa Minerals Bureau also presented an estimate of world resources in 1979 (6). The most recent comprehensive study (1981) was completed by the National Materials Advisory Board (15). Ghana 9 million tons India 1 1 million tons Upper Volta 9 million tons Mexico 8 million tons United States 39million tons Total = 780 million tons Figure 3. — Demonstrated ore resources evaluated in this study, by country (in situ contained manganese). Table 3.— Reserve-resource classification categories by organization Organization Reserves and/or resource classifications U.S. Geological Survey (1973) Bureau of Mines-Geological Survey (1979). South Africa Minerals Bureau (1979). National Materials Advisory Board (1981). Minerals Availability Study (1980). Reserves and conditional and hypothetical resources. Reserves and other (resources). Reserves and resources. Measured, indicated, and inferred reserves and submarginal and hypothetical resources. Demonstrated and Identified resources resources (measured plus (measured plus indicated) indicated plus inferred) Source: References 4-6 and 15. A summary of the manganese resource classification used by these different organizations is shown in table 3. The table illustrates a difficulty in correlating manganese resource estimates because there are no established standards for the categorization of in situ manganese ore resources. Resources are reported in terms of ore, product, contained manganese in ore or product, or a mixture of any of these. In addition, classification includes reserves, resources, measured, indicated, inferred, other, condition- al, hypothetical, etc., all assessing the same material and from essentially the same sources of data. Table 4 contains the total demonstrated and iden- tified resources of mines and deposits in market economy countries as interpreted from published and other available sources. The resources analyzed for this study are identified by footnote 5. The demonstrated resources Table 4. — Market economy country manganese mine and deposit data Owner and/or Map Deposit Annual output capacity as of Type of Average in situ grade, pet Mn Resources, 4 million tons Country and mine Demonstrated Identified or deposit operator index 1 status 2 1981, thousand operation 3 In situ Contained In situ Contained tons material manganese material manganese Australia: Groote Eylandt Broken Hill Proprietary Co. 20 Prd 2,500 OP 41 308 5 126 490 201 Brazil: Azul-Buhtirama-Sereno . Companhia Vale do Rio Doce (CVRD). 11 Expl NA NA 42 65 5 27 65 27 Santana Compania Pavulista de Ferro Ligas. 12 Prd 120 UG 46 5 5 2 30 1.4 Serra do Navio Industria Comercio e Minerios S.A. (ICOMI). 10 Prd 1,200 OP 39 23 59 23 9 Urucum CVRD .NAp 12 NAp Prd NAp 250 UG NAp 45 NAp 72 5 32 102 46 Total Brazil 1,570 165 70 220 96 Gabon: Moanda Cie. Miniere de I'Ogooue (Comilog). 15 Prd 2,300 OP 44 400 5 176 467 205 Ghana: Nsuta Ghana National Manganese Corp. 17 Prd 300 OP 31 30 5 9 30 9 India: Maharashtra-Madhya Manganese Ore India, 18 Prd 320 OP/UG 46 10 5 5 20 9 Pradesh area Ltd. (includes Balaghat, Kandri, Munsar, Tirodi, Ukwa). Karnataka (Mysore): Bisgod . Mysore Minerals Ltd. 17 Prd 45 OP 44 2 5 1 2 1 Keonjhar District . Various owners . NAp 19 NAp Prd NAp 300 OP NAp 40 NAp 12 5 5 20 8 Total India 665 24 5 11 42 18 Mexico: Tetzintla-Molango. Compani Minera Autlan. 9 Prd 550 OP/UG 28 30 5 8 230 69 South Africa: Black Rock area Associated 16 Prd 2,000 UG 44 132 5 58 132 58 (includes Gloria, Manganese Mines Nchwaning, of South Africa Ltd. Nchwaning West) (AMMOSAL). Southern Farms . ..do 16 Ppd NAp NAp 33 10 3 10 3 Other AMMOSAL 6 - 7 . . . . ..do 16 Expl NAp NAp 36-40 7 3 7 3 Do" . ..do 16 Expl NAp NAp 30-40 12 4 12 4 Do 67 . ..do 16 Expl NAp NAp 38-40 377 147 509 199 Do 67 . ..do 16 Expl NAp NAp 30-38 402 137 1,913 650 Do 6 ' 7 . ..do 16 Expl NAp NAp 20-30 126 32 1,400 350 Mamatwan South African Manganese Amcor, Ltd. (SAMANCOR). 16 Prd 2,200 OP 38 433 6 165 433 165 Middleplaats . ..do 16 Prd 1,000 UG 38 40 5 15 40 15 Wessels . ..do 16 Prd 1,125 UG 44 208 5 92 208 92 Lohathla . ..do 16 Prd 520 OP 33 5 5 2 5 2 Other SAMANCOR 67 ..do 16 Expl NAp NAp 36-40 11 4 11 4 Do 6 - 7 . ..do 16 Expl NAp NAp 36-40 19 7 19 7 Do 67 . ..do 16 Expl NAp NAp 30-38 614 209 2,992 1,017 Do 6 - 7 . ..do 16 Expl NAp NAp 20-30 200 50 2,163 541 Do 6 7 . ..do 16 Expl NAp NAp 30-38 179 61 852 290 Other companies 6 South African Iron and Steel Industrial Corp. Ltd. (ISCOR). 16 Expl NAp NAp 20-30 i04 26 1,159 290 Do 6 . Minerts 16 Expl NAp NAp 44 20 9 20 9 Do 6 . ..do 16 Expl NAp NAp 30-38 51 17 244 83 Do 6 . ..do 16 Expl NAp NAp 20-30 62 16 693 173 See footnotes at end of table. Table 4. — Market economy country manganese mine and deposit data — Continued Country and mine or deposit Owner and or operator Map index' Deposit status-' South Amca — Con Other companies 6 — Con " do 5 ^. : Do 6 Do 6 Do 6 Total South Afnca Armco Bronne do Texas. Gulf .do NAp 16 16 16 16 . . NAp Expl Expl Expl Expl NAp Identified . Resources, 4 million tons Annual output Averaqe capacity as of Type of in Sltu gr s ade Demonstrated 1981. thousand operation 3 pet Mn In situ Contained In situ Contained ,ons material manganese material manganese NAp NAp NAp NAp 6.845 United States Hardshell Maggie Sunnyside Maple Mountam- Hovey Mountain North Aroostook Distnct (Dudley and Getot Hill) Cuyuna North Range (southwest portion) Butte distnct (Emma Mine). Three Kids fl Anzona Manganese Corp Standard Metals Inc Various owners Various owners ( 8 ) Total United States Upper Voita Tambao Grand total The Anaconda Co. Income Investment Inc. NAp Societe Miniere de Tambao NAp 2 1 6 NAp 13 Expl Expl Expl Expl Expl Expl Expl Expl NAp Expl NAp NAp NAp NAp NAp NAp NAp NAp NAp NAp NAp NAp NAp NAp 30-38 20-30 30-38 20-30 NAp NAp NAp NAp 15.0 8.8 NAp NAp 10.5 8.9 51 40 9 7 17 241 10 446 3 42 2 77 3,119 1,089 13,628 NAp 95 NAp NAp 14,730 NAp 78 NAp 180 NAp 132 NAp NAp NAp 54 NAp Nap 6 8 25 260 63 49 1 7 5 1 5 1 5 3 5 23 6 8 40 260 63 5 4 140 9 1 5 1 15 419 39 533 16 29 4,511 1,537 15,671 82 112 14 19 4.182 4 23 11 9 2 48 16 4,844 NAp Not applicable ' Refer to figure 4 2 Status of deposit: Prd — operating. Expl — explored. Ppd — past producer 3 Type of operation: UG — underground. OP — open pit * Rounded to nearest 1 million tons 5 Resources used m this study. 6 "Other" refers to resources that are not delineated by location, thickness, specific grade, ' Manganese grade ranges averaged as follows for contained manganese, in pet: Range Average Range Average depth, etc, or that are below current mining grade 36-^0 38 30-^0 35 38-M) 39 8 Property not under ownership ; Less than 500.000 tons contain 30-38 20-30 ed manga 34 25 nese. T A 1 •? s \_v ^V\ /-^ Figure 4. — Location of market economy country manganese mines and deposits; index numbers refer to table 4. used in this study are based on estimates of quantities existing in the foreign mines and deposits at or above current mining grades shown for the producing mines in table 4; the U.S. deposits contain about 12 to 13 pet manganese. The resource locations are shown in figure 4. The resources used in this study compared to total published resources listed in table 4 are shown below (in million tons of contained manganese): Resources evaluated in this study Total resources (table 4) lonstrate d Identified 780 994 1,537 4,844 In the total demonstrated resources (contained man- ganese) there is a difference of about 757 million tons (1,537 minus 780), which is accounted for by the difference in classification of materials in South Africa. This results from the inclusion of resources in the total quantity that are below the current mining grade or that cannot be defined as to location, dimensions, depth, ore thickness, etc. The resources used for South Africa are an adaptation of data published by Taljaardt (16) in which the resources are identified by ore types, grade, and various company ownership. The ore types include the Wessels, which is of higher grade with a relatively high iron content, and the Mamatwan, which is lower grade with a low iron content. In the Wessels category 340 million tons of plus 40-pct-Mn material were analyzed in this study, or about 83 pet of the Taljaardt estimate of 409 million tons. In the Mamatwan category 4/3 million tons of 38- to 40-pct-Mn material were used in this study, or about 3.6 pet of the Taljaardt total estimate of 13.2 billion tons in grades of 20 to 40 pet Mn. Taljaardt estimated a total of 982 million tons of Mamatwan-type ore at 38 to 40 pet Mn, of which only the 473 million tons used could be identified as to location, thickness, depth, etc. Even with the varied interpretations of resource data by different organizations, land-based manganese re- sources of the market economy countries are vast in comparison with future requirements. In fact, only seven major operations, Serra do Navio in Brazil, Groote Eylandt in Australia, Moanda in Gabon, and the Black Rock area (three mines), Wessels, Middleplaats, and Mamatwan Mines in South Africa, after allowing for mine and mill recoveries, could supply the market economy estimated demand for at least 80 years based on 1976-81 average production. The grade ranges and resource quantities estimated by Taljaardt for the Wessels and Mamatwan ore types follow: Ore type and Estimated resource grade, pet Mn quantity, million tons Wessels: + 44 330 40 to 44 30 36 to 40 18 30 to 40 31 Total 409 Mamatwan: 38 to 40 982 30 to 38 6,286 20 to 30 5,938 Total 13,206 COUNTRY MANGANESE RESOURCE SUMMARY AUSTRALIA The principal manganese deposit in Australia is the Groote Eylandt, owned by Broken Hill Proprietary Co. Ltd. and operated by a subsidiary, Groote Eylandt Mining Co. Ltd. The mine has been in operation since 1966. A number of smaller deposits not included in this study are located in Western Australia, Queensland, New South Wales, Victoria, and South Australia. The Groote Eylandt Deposit occurs as a relatively flat tabular stratum deposited over an irregular basement rock. Sandy clay and laterized conglomerates which vary in thickness and lateral extent overlie the ore body. The ore in turn lies on consolidated sands and clays with claystones and mudstones; the principal ore minerals are pyrolusite, cryptomelane, and psilomelane (12). It is estimated that there was approximately 308 million tons of demonstrated material remaining as of January 1980, containing an average of 41 pet man- ganese. There is possibly another 110 million tons in other areas of the deposit that have only been minimally explored (12). The deposit is mined by open pit methods and is worked in a series of separate quarries for grade control. The mine has a capacity of about 5 million tons of ore per year and can produce about 2.5 million tons of product. It is estimated that to mine the total resource the cumulative waste-to-ore ratio will be about 2.5 to 1. The maximum haulage distance to the concentrator is about 20 km. The concentrator consists of four sections: crushing, feed preparation by washing and screening, scrubbing and dewatering, and heavy-media separation. The concentra- tor produces products of varying grades in both lump and fine sizes. The concentrate grades vary from a little over 41 pet to about 52 pet. A high-silica lump product is also produced that is used in the production of silicoman- ganese. The concentrate is hauled about 16 km to a storage area near the port where the various grades are reclaimed, blended, and shiploaded by conveyor. The high-carbon ferromanganese capacity of Austra- lia is about 115,000 tons per year. This is produced in three Bell Bay (Tasmania) plants operated by Tasmanian Electro Metallurgical Co. Proprietary Ltd. An additional 25,000 tons per year of silicomanganese can be produced as a byproduct of the high-carbon process. Estimated ore requirements would be about 360,000 to 370,000 tons, or about 15 pet of the mine output capacity. The largest export markets are Japan and Asia, which have in the past consumed about 40 pet of the production. The remainder is shipped to Europe and the United States. There are no known plans for increasing smelting capacity in Australia. Smelting capacity required to utilize all the Groote Eylandt output would be approx- imately 1 million tons per year. BRAZIL The principal manganese resources of Brazil occur in the Serra do Navio Mine of Amapa, the Urucum and Santa Mines of Bahia, and the Azul, Buriturama, and Sereno Deposits in the Carajas Mineral Province of Para. Numerous other manganese deposits occur in the States of Minas Gerais, Bahia, Goias, and Espirito Santos, but because of their small size, they were not included in this study. Data on production from separate areas are apparent- ly not reported on a common base and thus are difficult to interpret. In 1979, total ore production was reported as approximately 2,260,000 tons, from which about 1,700,000 tons of concentrates and pellets was shipped. Of this quantity, 1,189,800 tons was shipped from the Serra do Navio Mine. The remaining production was from numerous mines in the States of Minas Gerais (about 400,000 tons), Bahia, Mato Grosso, Goias, and Espirito Santo. Serra Do Navio Mine The Serra do Navio Mine is located in the Amapa Territory and is the largest producer of manganese concentrates in Brazil. The mine is owned and operated by Industria Comercio e Minerios S.A. (ICOMI), which is a joint venture between Cia. Auxiliar de Empresas Miner- acao (Caemi), a Brazilian company, and Bethlehem Steel. Initial development began in 1952 and production in 1957. A pellet plant for upgrading previously discarded fines to about 54 pet manganese was put on stream in 1973. The deposit is part of the Precambrian Guyana Shield, consisting of a metasedimentary sequence of gneisses, amphibolites, schists, and quartzites. These sedimentary units alternate in a relatively cyclic pattern and are subdivided into three distinct facies: quartzose, biotitic, and graphitic. The major ore minerals are cryptomelane and pyrolusite. Minor manganiferous minerals include hausmannite, lithiophorite, and manga- nite. These deposits are classified as residual lateritic concentrations. The mining area contains about 20 ore bodies distributed along a belt about 12 km long up to 70 m wide. Typically the ore bodies are fairly dense and compact but show stages of variations from dense to porous friable material. Mining operations are rotated to some extent on a seasonal basis. During the rainy season (January through June), activities are concentrated on mining; stripping receives major emphasis during the dry season. The ore is concentrated at the mine by crushing, screening, and washing. The minus 1.2-mm material is stockpiled for use in pelletizing feed, and the plus 1.2- to minus 8-mm material is either shipped as sinter feed or used as pellet plant feed as conditions warrant. The pellet plant is located at the port of Santana, about 200 km from the mine. Here the processes include cyclones, screens, heavy media, and spirals, followed by reduction roasting, magnetic separation, and pelletizing. The pellets contain about 54 pet manganese. The remaining in situ demonstrated resources are estimated at approximately 23 million tons including stockpiled fines (7, p. 11), which would last about 8 to 10 years at a 2.5-million-ton-per-year mine capacity. Another 6 to 7 years of pellet production is possible from the fines stockpile at a product capacity of 200,000 tons per year. All the concentrates are shipped by rail to Santana, where they are loaded on ships for export. The approximate 1.2 million tons of concentrates available annually in the Serra do Navio Mine should be more economically shipped to the United States than to other areas. In recent years, though, only about 10 pet has been shipped to the United States. The majority is shipped to Europe. In 1980, about 64 pet was shipped to Europe, 11 pet to Japan, 6 pet to the United States, 17 pet to Brazilian ports, and the remainder to other South American ports. In 1981, the export destinations were Europe — 70 pet, Japan — 15 pet, United States — 13 pet, and 2 pet to other South American countries, with none shipped to Brazilian ports. Azul, Buriturama, and Sereno Deposits (Carajar Mineral Province) The Azul Deposits in the Carajas area of Para State lie between the north and south limbs of a synclinorium composed of Precambrian sediments, iron formations, and volcanic rocks. The manganese deposits lie above manganiferous pelitic shales that uncomformably overlie the Precambrian sediments. The in situ ore was derived from weathering of two shale protore beds with grades ranging from 14 to 36 pet manganese and an intervening layer grading about 2 to 4 pet manganese. The Buriturama deposits, consisting of nine separate ore bodies, appear to be the product of weathering and are an enrichment of a manganese carbonate-silicate protore. The Sereno Deposits are genetically similar to the Buriturama deposits, but are much smaller and more scattered. Resources for the separate areas follow (7): Deposits Azul Buriturama . . Sereno Quantity, million tons 65 11 2.8 Grade, pet Mn 42 39 30 Exploitation of these deposits is not expected until a 900-km railroad from the coastal city of Sao Luis to the Carajas Iron District is completed. This railroad is presently under construction and is projected to initiate the development of some 18 billion tons of iron ore in the area (14, pp. 16-18). It is estimated that to develop the manganese in this area world require an investment of about $40 million, including the construction of a 30-km railroad and other infrastructure. Mining capacity is assumed at about 1 million tons per year. For this study, only the Azul Deposit containing 65 million tons was used. It was assumed that mining would be by open pit methods, that milling would consist of crushing and screening, and that 50 pet of the concen- trates would be consumed in Brazil; the remaining 50 pet would be shipped to Europe and the United States. Santana Mine The Santana Mine is located in a remote area of Mato Grosso near the Bolivian border and is owned by Cia. 10 Paulista de Ferro-Ligas, which also owns the smelters through which the material is processed. The manganese bed at the Santana Mine, probably the lower bed of the Morro do Urucum Formation, can be traced over a distance of 650 m along an outcrop. The manganese bed dips 15° to the east and ranges in thickness from 2.5 to 4.0 m, with most of the manganese oxides concentrated in the lower part of the bed. The major ore mineral, cryptomelane, occurs as thin irregular layers and roughly stratified layers of nodules in a matrix of coarse sand and clay derived from weathered arkose. The Santana Mine has produced both hematite float and manganese ore for several years. The ore is mined by underground room-and-pillar methods from adits, and current capacity is 120,000 tons per year. Output from the Santana Mine is converted to ferromanganese in two company-owned electric smelting plants in the Corumba area and in smelters in other locations. Demonstrated resources of the Santana Mine are estimated at 5 million tons. Nearby properties have reported a total of about 30 million tons of resources, which reportedly could be increased by some 30 + million tons by more detailed exploration (7, p. 16). At this time, there are too few data available to adequately delineate these other deposits for inclusion at the demonstrated level for this study. Urucum Mine The Urucum Mine is located in Mato Grosso in the same area as the Santana Mine. The manganese occurs in a mesalike mountain of sedimentary rock series. The deposit was first mined in 1912 and had intermittent periods of production through 1972. In 1976, mining was restarted by Companhia Vale do Rio Doce (CVRD). Three manganese beds with thickness ranging up to 6 m occur in this area. The manganese oxide beds are almost all intercalated between clastic beds in an iron formation. Average analysis of the manganese oxide lenses in the Urucum area is about 46 pet manganese. The principal mineral is cryptomelane. The ore is mined by room-and-pillar methods. The mine is developed and mined through parallel adits driven along the strike. The ore is broken and removed prior to breaking and removal of the waste to prevent dilution. Rooms are turned off from the adits at right angles every 15 m. Stope pillars are 4 by 4 by 4 m wide, and the rooms are 60 m long. With the present equipment and mine development, the mine has a maximum annual capacity of 260,000 tons and contains an estimated resource of 72 million tons (7, p. 14). The ore is beneficiated by simple crushing and screening. The ore from this mine can be shipped either 1,500 to 1,700 km by rail to Rio de Janeiro or Sao Paulo for domestic use, or 2,700 km by barge (seasonal) to Nueva Palmira, Uruguay, for export. The ore contains 3 to 4 pet alkalies that must be diluted by blending. For the economic evaluation in this study it is assumed that 50 pet is transported by barge through Paraguay for export. The remainder is transported by rail for domestic use. Other Mines Aside from the more important manganese deposits discussed above, Brazil has numerous smaller mines which supply domestic requirements. These small de- posits are scattered through the States of Minas Gerais, Bahia, Goias, and others. The estimated resources from individual States follow (7, p. 29): Quantity, Grade, Area million tons pet Mn Minas Gerais 5.5 31 6 35 5 30 Bahia 15 38 Goias 10 33 With the development of the Urucum and Azul areas, Brazil could maintain current production levels after the depletion of the Serra do Navio resources, although at higher costs mainly because of the longer transportation distances. Brazil's current annual smelting capacity is 140,000 tons of ferromanganese and 180,000 tons of silicoman- ganese, which requires a feed of about 560,000 tons of ore and concentrates at full capacity. Part of this is supplied by a number of small mines that have relatively insignificant resources. The remainder is supplied by the mines in the Urucum area. Brazil has projected a progressive increase in its manganese ore, ferromanganese, and steel production. Because of vast iron ore resources, the near-future expansion of the steel industry is more probable than the expansion of the manganese industry. Future develop- ments in the manganese industry will probably depend on the domestic iron industry, such as development of the Carajas iron ore area. Increases in mine production will be restricted by high transportation costs, since the major resources are located in remote areas. GABON The Moanda Mine in Gabon is owned and operated by Comilog, a company jointly owned by U.S. Steel, Bureau de Recherches Geologiques et Minieres (BRGM), Imetal S.A., other French interests, and the Gabon Government. The manganese occurs in five deposits within the Francevillian Series, and the principal ore minerals are pyrolusite, manganite, and cryptomelane. The ore is mined at the Bangombe Deposit by open pit methods and is excavated in a series of rectangular trenches running from 610 to 915 m in a north-south direction. Each trench measures 20 m wide and is worked from east to west by walking draglines. Ore from the mine is trucked to the crusher station, where it is reduced to 6 mm size. The crushed material is then fed to cleaning drums, where water is introduced countercurrently. The washed material is then classified through vibrating screens to different product sizes with fines upgraded in a heavy-media separation circuit. The minus 6-mm mate- rial is currently being stockpiled as waste; about 10 million tons had been stockpiled as of 1979 {15, p. 177). With current annual mine production capacity of 4 million tons (about 2.3 million tons of product) and a demonstrated resource of 400 million tons (6, p. 40; 15, p. 178), the deposit will sustain a mine life of at least 100 years. Annual mine production rate in 1982 was about 3.5 million tons of ore. The mine product is transported 78 km by aerial ropeway and 485 km by rail to Pointe Noire in The Republic of Congo for export. 11 In addition to the ore treatment plant, a concentra- tion plant was installed to treat about 100,000 tons per year of washed ore sized to plus 6 mm minus 20 mm for use in dry cell batteries. The advantages of this mine are the high degree of mechanization and the abundant reserves of high-grade ore. along with significant quantities of battery-grade ore. One limiting factor is the relatively long distance to transport the concentrates to smelter installations. Gabon has no smelting facilities. The Trans-Gabon railway (560 km>. which would serve the Moanda area, is scheduled for completion in 1987. With this railroad the mine capacity could be increased to at least 4 million tons per year of product. GHANA The manganese ore deposits of the Nsuta Mine are located about 62 km from the port of Takoradi and are owned by Ghana National Manganese Corp. The deposits occur on five hills and can be traced almost continuously for about 4 km. The hills are elevated 60 to 90 m above the surrounding area and are interconnected by saddles. The principal ore bodies that have been mined in the past are sedimentary lenses rich in battery-grade man- ganese oxides from Recent or Tertiary laterizations and oxide enrichment of gondites. The major manganese mineral in the remaining resources is rhodochrosite. The mine has operated for over 60 years and has been one of the major suppliers of battery-grade oxide ore, but the reserves of this type of ore are nearly mined out. The evaluation in this study was based on approximately 30 million tons of carbonate ore underlying the oxides (6, p. 76 In recent years, the carbonate ore has been mined and processed for the manufacture of electrolytic manganese dioxide in plants in Japan and Ireland. Production in 1982 was about 22,000 tons of oxide ore and 138,000 tons of carbonate ore. The carbonate ore is processed by crushing, washing, screening, and hand sorting. At the Nsuta Mine, the Ghana National Manganese Corp. has completed a nodulizing plant which will convert the carbonate ore to oxide by roasting. The plant was completed in 1982 but has not been commissioned because of the lack of electric power. As of 1982, a 2-year plant feed supply had been stockpiled, with production anticipated in 1984. From this plant, it is expected that 300,000 tons of manganese oxide nodules from 450,000 tons of carbonate ore will be produced annually (23). The nodules will be transported about 62 km by rail to the port of Takoradi for export. This is a relatively short distance; however, the railway system experiences frequent breakdowns. The beneficiation costs for this resource are relatively high in that the ore must be nodulized; however, this beneficiation increases the grade from about 31 to about 44 pet manganese. For this study it it estimated that about 80 pet of the concentrates will be destined for Europe and the remaining 20 pet will be sent to Japan. INDIA Manganese ore mining in India is characterized by many small mine operators mining and sorting ores by hand methods. With over 300 individual mines in various stages of selective hand mining, it is difficult if not impossible to interpret resource data. In addition, no systematic geological mapping or drilling program has been done on the majority of the existing deposits. In general, resources are outlined in the immediate vicinity of the mine areas, based on ore exposures. All other data are estimated on the basis of geologic inference. As a result, most information indicated a great difference (4 to 10 times) between indicated and inferred resources. Estimates of inferred resources generally include wide areas and are not deposit specific. Mining and processing of the manganese ores is generally done by hand because labor is cheap and production of individual mines is not large enough for the use of mechanical methods. India has an annual smelting capacity of about 307,000 tons of high-carbon ferromanganese and about 43,000 tons of silicomanganese. This includes the 72,000- ton-per-year plant under construction at Tumsar. Total ore requirements to feed the smelting capacity of India would be about 810,000 tons. This is approximately 50 pet of the ore production of India, and thus it is assumed that about 50 pet of the ores are exported. Much of the production of high-grade manganese ore in India has been designated for use within the country in recent years. The only ore exported is that containing less than 46 pet manganese. The future capability of produc- tion cannot be predicted with any certainty because of the lack of a definitive resource base. Manganese production in India has remained relatively constant since the early 1950's without any significant changes in the known reserves. Without systematic exploration or mechanized mining methods in the manganese industry, it is unlikely that significant increases in production could or will occur. Because of extremely labor-intensive mining and processing methods, estimated to produce about 0.1 ton per worker-shift, the costs associated with these mines are much higher than those experienced in the mechanized mines in all the other countries studied. In view of the vast number of small mining operations and limited demonstrated resources in India, it was not considered feasible within the scope of this study to attempt an evaluation that would include a major number of these operations. It is felt that the coverage included represents the current mining and processing practices in the manganese mining industry of India. This evaluation includes mines from three areas, the Maharashtra- Madhya Pradesh area of central India (five mines), the Keonjhar District in Orissa, and the Bisgod Mine in Karnataka.The mines in central India are operated by Manganese Ore India, Ltd. Most of the ores are relatively high grade and can be blended with lower grade, low-phosphorus ores of Orissa. Most of the ore in Karnataka is exported because of the high iron content and the lack of nearby smelting facilities (22, pp. 32-33). Maharashtra-Madhya Pradesh Area It is reported that this area produces about 75 pet of all high-grade ore in India (22, p. 34). Demonstrated resources for the area are estimated at 10 million tons. Generally, the mines described represent the main operation in a particular area. Ore is also supplied by numerous individually operated workings. 12 It is assumed that about 50 pet of this ore is smelted domestically, and the remainder is shipped to the ports of Visakhapatnam and Bombay for export to Japan and Europe. Balaghat Mine The Balaghat Mine is mainly an underground operation and extends over a strike length of 3.7 km. The ore comes from two types of deposits, lode or reef type, and detrital or float-type deposits. The ore consists of a mixture of several manganese oxides, with braunite being the principal mineral. The mine operates on six levels, some of which have been developed to a strike length of 2.7 km, and produces about 114,000 tons annually. The ore is sorted and cleaned by hand and separated into different sizes and grades. The reject fines and tailings are relatively high grade. It is planned to build a beneficiation and an agglomerating plant to process this waste material. A ferromanganese plant also has been contemplated for the area. Kandri Mine The Kandri Mine is situated near the village of Kandri. The ore body occurs in a horseshoe-shaped synclinal exposure and has barren zone between its two limbs. The ore zone ranges in thickness from 1.5 to 3.9 m near the bottom of the syncline. Over the exposed length of 230 m of the syncline, the ore-bearing horizon attains a maximum thickness of 22.5 m. The ore was originally mined by opencast methods. Now, all mining operations are underground through an inclined ?haft. Overhead, flat back, and cut-and-fill stoping methods are used to mine 30,000 tons annually. Mining is performed mostly by manual labor, but in recent years some mechanization has been introduced. Manual sorting and sizing are done at the mine, and the product is shipped to the Tumsar, Kahhua, and Kelsar ferromanganese plants. Mansar Mine The Mansar Deposit has an indicated strike length of 2.8 km. The ore body crops out on the surface as a band running almost northwest-southeast in an isoclinically folded and plunging formation with very high dips. The ore is both hard and soft. The hard ore consists mainly of braunite granules cemented by psilomelane. Quartz is the main gangue mineral, and the ore contains high phosphorus and silica. On the average, the run-of- mine, unsorted ore represents 70 pet of the total thickness of the ore zone, and the balance is waste consisting of manganiferous quartzite. The marketable ore comprises roughly 30 pet of the ore body. Mining is conducted by open pit and underground cut-and-fill methods. The combined annual production is 45,000 tons. Tirodi Mine All deposits in the Tirodi area are characterized by intensely folded, overturned, isoclinal, and recumbent folds. These deposits are exposed continuously over a distance of about 10 km. The main potential zone has a thickness of 2 to 3 m along a total strike length of 425 m. The manganese ore is very hard, compact, fine to coarse grained, and usually enclosed in schist. The deposit consists of a primary bedded manganese sequence with braunite as the principal mineral. The ore is generally high in phosphorus (above 0.2 pet), whereas the silica content is fairly low. The Tirodi Deposit has been mined since 1901 using the open pit method. The bulk of the mining extraction is carried out manually, and even jackhammers and compressed air are rarely used. Underground cut-and-fill methods are being adopted in deeper sections of the deposit, consisting of levels 2.1 by 2.1 m in size driven laterally. The present combined annual production capac- ity for the mine area is estimated at about 90,000 tons. Ore from the mine is broken by hand into about 10-cm lumps and processed by hand sorting. Mechanical washing is adopted during the rainly season using washing drums. This washing technique upgrades the ore by about 3 pet. Ukwa Mine Mining in the Ukwa area was started in 1906; continuous operation probably began in 1938 when a 29-km ropeway was installed. The Ukwa deposit extends over a strike length of about 5.5 km. In general, the thickness of the ore bed for the major portion of the strike length is 3.0 to 3.5 m. The greater part of the ore is in the form of psilomelane and braunite. The ore is fairly high in manganese, with phosphorus content varying from 0.07 to 0.1 pet. Annual ore production is about 39,000 tons. All mining is done by" manual labor, including hauling. Upgrading is accomplished by hard sorting and jigging of the ore on the mine floor. The concentrate is transported by aerial tramway 29 km to the railhead at Balaghat and is shipped to Tumsar or Komptee for smelting or to Bombay for export. Keonjhar District The Keonjhar District in Orissa State contains about 200 open pit operations that are mined by a few major operators and a large number of individual miners. The principal rock types in the Keonjhar District include quartzites, banded hematite, metavolcanics, high- ly folded shales of an iron ore series, and gently folded sandstone, phyllites, and shales. The manganese ore, together with associated iron ore, occurs as lenses, pockets, reefs, and veins in the shale, jasper, and quartzite formations. The most abundant mineral is psilomelane with some manganite. The Keonjhar ores are characterized by low phosphor- us and high iron content. The grade varies from deposit to deposit, but most of the ores are in the lower grade ranges. Only about 10 to 15 pet of the ores are suitable for ferromanganese production without blending {22, p. 32). All mining operations are by open pit methods using manual labor. Current ore production from four major stratigraphic zones with the district is estimated at about 300,000 tons per year. The practice of removing the high-grade ore results in the loss of large tonnages of low- and medium-grade ores, which often become contamin- ated with waste materials. For this study, the resources of the Keonjhar District were estimated at 12 million tons. It is assumed that 50 pet of the concentrates are exported through Visakhapatnam to Japan and Europe. Rail shipping distances are nearly the same for both export and domestic use. 13 Karnataka (Mysore) Area The manganese deposits at the Bisgod Mine in Karnataka. owned by Mysore Minerals Ltd., are strati- form in nature and enclosed in laterite. The major mineral is psilomelane. with pyrolusite occurring in lesser amounts. The current mining method is opencast, and a large segment of the work is done by manual labor. Current production is estimated at 142 to 180 tons per day. as in other parts of India, part of the production is supplied from individual workings in the mine area. Most of the ore is high in iron and low in manganese, and about 75 pet of the product is exported. The exported concen- trates are transported 140 km by small trucks to Beligondi, where they are loaded onto barges and then transloaded to ships. The remainder is shipped by rail to domestic plants in the area. Other Mines It is estimated that over 300 separate mines are being worked, of which about 290 are privately owned. Because of their small size, most of these mines were not included in this study. Total reserves for the larger of the mines not included have been reported as approximately 13 million tons, measured plus indicated, and approximately 52 million tons inferred {14). MEXICO Nearly all of Mexico's total output of manganese ore comes from the Tetzintla Mine located in the Molango district of the State of Hidalgo about 140 km southwest of Tampico and owned by Compania Minera Autlan, S.A. de C.V. Mineralization occurs over an area measuring 50 by 20 km at the base of the Chipoco Formation, although the manganese-bearing horizon may not occur throughout the entire area. At the Tetzintla Mine, the manganese- bearing section is about 7 m thick and averages about 28 pet manganese. The ores are hard, compact, finely stratified man- ganiferous limestone. There are two types of manganese deposits in the Molango district. The most important is the fine-grained carbonate ore that is composed mainly of rhodochrosite. kutnahorite, and manganocalcite. The second type is rich oxide ore derived from the carbonate ores by oxidation and supergene enrichment. The oxide product from the Nonoalco Mine in the district is a source of manganese dioxide used for the production of dry cell batteries. About 40,000 tons per year of battery-grade ore are produced. The Tetzintla Mine started production as an open pit mine in 1969. and in 1978 an underground room-and- pillar operation was developed in the Tetzintla ore body. The open pit mine has a capacity of 1,500 tons per day, while the underground operation has a capacity of 1,900 tons per day Demonstrated resources of the district are estimated at 30 million tons 15. p. 93). This includes 15 million tons proven at the Tetzintla Mine. The concession area contains an additional estimated 200 million tons of similar material, which for this study is considered to be inferred. The concession area includes the Tetzintla Mine and the Naopa. Acoxcatlan. and Comextetzintla Deposits The Naopa Deposit is in the planning stages for an open pit mine. Normally the ore is crushed in three stages to minus 1.25 cm and fed into a rotary kiln at Otongo, where the carbonates are converted to oxides and nodules are formed. When excessive silica and alumina dilution is present, the ore is first upgraded to 27.5 pet manganese by heavy-media separation. The nodules contain 39 to 40 pet manganese (I). Mexico has a smelting capacity of about 150,000 tons of ferromanganese and 50,000 tons of silicomanganese. The mine has a capacity to produce about 550,000 tons of nodules. Because of the low grade of the nodules, they must be blended with high-grade imported ore. It is estimated that about 75 pet of the output is exported. Marketing involves transporting the nodules about 230 km by truck to Tampico, from where they are shipped to domestic ferromanganese plants at Vera Cruz and exported to Japan, France, and the United States. Within Hidalgo State, small amounts of manganese ore are mined at Pachuca. Minor amounts are also mined in the States of San Luis Potosi (Charcas), Chihuahua (San Buenaventura), and Zacatecas (Villa de Cos). SOUTH AFRICA Resources The manganese resources of South Africa are consi- dered vast, although there are differences in the resource interpretations of the available data. The resources occur mainly in two separate fields, the Kalahari and Postmas- burg. Nearly all the resources are in the Kalahari Field. Probably the most complete assessment of the resources was estimated by Taljaardt (16) at over 13.6 billion tons of material through the inferred category, grading from 20 to over 44 pet manganese aggregated by company ownership and different grade range categories. Only deposits near the existing mines are fairly well investi- gated by exploration drilling. Further exploration will undoubtedly reclassify some of the material from inferred to demonstrated resources. In this study, these resources are allocated to the operating mines as shown in table 5. The majority of the resources in South Africa are in grade categories lower than most of those currently being mined through the market economy countries. According to the data shown in table 5, the current mining grades (plus 38 pet Mn) account for 1,396 million tons, or about 10 pet of the total resource shown in the table. Of this total, 818 million tons is considered in this study. Based on current capacities (table 4), it will probably be 70 to 80 years before any development is needed on the lower grade type of ore. The relationship of the ores by grade is shown in figure 5. Of the total resource of 13,628 million tons, 409 million tons (about 3 pet) is of the high-grade, high-iron Wessels type, and nearly all the remainder is low-grade, low-iron Mamatwan type. Resources in the Postmasburg Field account for less than 1 pet of the total. Of the current total production capacity, Wessels type accounts for 47 pet, Mamatwan type accounts for 45 pet, and the remaining 8 pet is from the Postmasburg Field. The criterion used in the allocation of resources in South Africa for this study was the limitation of grades to those currently being mined. This limits the Wessels grades to plus 44 pet and 40 to 44 pet manganese, and the Mamatwan grades to 38 to 40 pet manganese. Lower grade ores are apparently produced by all operations, but 14 Table 5. — Estimated South African manganese resources, total and used in this study (Million tons) KEY Resources used in this study Resources Type and grade, pet Mn Company Total Jsed in this quantity 1 study Mine KALAHARI FIELD Wessels: Plus 44 SAMANCOR. 184 P 184 Wessels . . do 6 I 6 Wessels AMMOSAL . . 120 E 120 Black Rock 2 . Minerts 20 E ( 3 ) NAp. 40 to 44 SAMANCOR. 18 P 18 Wessels AMMOSAL . . 12E 12 Black Rock 2 . 36 to 40" SAMANCOR. 11 P ( 5 ) NAp. AMMOSAL . . 7 E ( 5 ) NAp. 30 to 40" SAMANCOR. 19 P ( 5 ) NAp. AMMOSAL . . 12 E ( 5 ) NAp. Total NAp 409 340 NAp. Mamatwan: 38 to 40 SAMANCOR. 348 P 348 ( 6 ). . . do 125 I 125 ( 6 ). AMMOSAL . . 509 E ( 3 ) NAp. 30 to 38 SAMANCOR. 614 P ( 5 ) NAp. . . do . 2,378 I ( 5 ) NAp. AMMOSAL . . . 1,913 E ( 5 ) NAp. ISCOR 852 E ( 5 ) NAp. Minerts 244 E ( 5 ) NAp. Armco Bronne 241 E ( 5 ) NAp. Texas Gulf . . 42 E ( 5 ) NAp. 20 to 30 SAMANCOR. 200 P ( 5 ) NAp. . . do . 1,963 1 ( 5 ) NAp. AMMOSAL . . . 1 ,400 E ( 5 ) NAp. ISCOR . 1,159 E ( 5 ) NAp. Minerts 693 E ( 5 ) NAp. Armco Bronne 446 E ( 5 ) NAp. Texas Gulf . . 77 E ( 5 ) NAp. Total NAp NAp . 13,204 473 NAp. Total Kalahari . 13,613 813 NAp Field POSTMASBURG FIELD Postmasburg SAMANCOR. 5 5 Lohatla. AMMOSAL . . 10 ( 7 ) Southern NAp Farms. Total Postmasburg 15 5 NAp. Field NAp Grand total . 13,628 818 NAp. NAp Not applicable. 1 E = estimated; I = inferred; P = proven. 2 Gloria, Nchwaning, Nchwaning West Mines. 3 Not delineated as to location, depth of ore, dimensions, etc. 4 Grades of 36 to 44 pet manganese contain 60 pet manganese plus iron. Grades of 30 to 40 pet manganese contain 5 to 10 pet iron. 5 Below current mining grades. 6 Total 473 million tons; allocated to the Mamatwan Mine (433 million tons) and the Middleplaats Mine (40 million tons). 7 Bishop, Gloucester, Paling Mines, shut down. Source: Adapted from reference 16. this is considered a result of grade fluctuation within the ore body and is not part of a lower grade resource category. Additionally, the grade ranges below those used in this study (30 to 38 pet and 20 to 30 pet manganese) are too broad to attempt economic analysis on specific grades. In addition to these Northern Cape deposits, a relatively small tonnage occurs in a number of small deposits in the Gopane area (Transvaal), which is mined for the chemical-grade ore for use in uranium purifica- tion (3). Because of its small size and the nonmetallurgical use of the ore, this area was not included in the study. Undoubtedly, South Africa will be a major supplier of manganese for many years. Because of the lateral continuity of the ore beds in and around the major mines, a high degree of mechanization is possible. Totol Mamatwan type 38-40 pet Mn -982 million tons — Used in this study- 473 million tons Total Wessels type - 409 million tons Used in this study- 340 million tons Postmasburg Field -15 million tons Used in this study- 5 million tons Figure 5. — Manganese ore resources of South Africa by grade. The potential for increasing production in South Africa is favorable. In the major mines, significant increases could apparently be accomplished in a short time by adding more production shifts (6, p. 113). For this study, it is assumed that 65 pet of the ores and concentrates produced in South Africa are exported through Port Elizabeth (an average rail distance of about 1,250 km), and the remaining 35 pet is used in the ferromanganese smelters in Transvaal (an average rail distance of about 900 km). Operations All operations in the Kalahari and Postmasburg Fields are controlled by two companies, The Associated Manganese Mines of South Africa Ltd. (AMMOSAL), which operates the Black Rock area mines, and South African Manganese Amcor, Ltd. (SAMANCOR), which operates the Mamatwan, Middleplaats, Wessels, and Lohathla Mines. Kalahari Field The Kalahari Field contains a relatively continuous belt of manganese ore that extends about 40 km in a north-south direction. This field contains nearly all the significant manganese ore resources of South Africa. The ore in this field is laterally consistent and can be mined by mechanized methods. There are two separate grade classifications within the Kalahari Field — the higher grade, high-iron Wessels type in the northern part of the field and the lower grade, 15 low-iron Mamatwan type in the southern part of the field. The largest resources are of the Mamatwan type. Mamatwan-type ore contains calcareous impurities which somewhat restrict its use in electric furnace manganese ferroalloy production and is generally blended with high-grade ores such as the Wessels type. Black Rock Area The Black Rock area is in the northern part of the Kalahari Field and currently includes three mines owned and operated as a unit by AMMOSAL, the Gloria, Nchwaning. and Nchwaning West. Total annual output from the three mines is about 2 million tons. Resources are estimated at 132 million tons in the plus 44 and 40 to 44 pet Wessels-type ore. These mines are located on adjacent farms and are operated at varying rates depending on ore contract specifications. Grades vary between the mines, and certain sections are mined as the need arises to maintain an overall consistent grade product. The broad structure of the ore-bearing banded iron formation in this area is a north-trending asymmetrical anticline planed off by faulting. The strike length of the ore body is about 10 km. Two persistent ore bodies are developed, each of which is approximately 6 m thick with consistent thickness and grade down dip. The area being mined at Nchwaning is the bottom ore body of the eastern limb of the anticline. The depth of the cover ranges from 150 to 900 m. The major ore minerals are braunite, bixbyite. and cryptomelane, with calcium and magnesium carbonates. The main ore bodies at the Gloria and Nchwaning West are also on the eastern limb of the anticline. The ore horizons here range in thickness from 5 to 40 m and dip from 0° to 30°. Mining in the Black Rock area is underground, using basically a room-and-pillar method; selective mining is used in some areas of the mine to produce higher grades. The ore body is accessed by one vertical and one inclined shaft to a depth of 400 m. The waste is sorted from the ore manually before it is crushed, screened, and washed. Some final sorting to various grades and specifications is done by visual identification. Four different grades of manganese concen- trates are produced. Mamatvcan Mine The Mamatwan Mine is located at the "outhern limit of the Kalahari Manganese Field and is owned and operated by SAMANCOR. The manganese deposit varies in thickness from the suboutcropping to an average of 45 m. At the base, the ore is siliceous and ferruginized with a banded appearance. The manganese ore is normally overlain by banded ironstone, which thickens to 15 m within the lease area. Except for occasional fissures, the manganese ore body is not affected by faulting and folding. The ore body consists of approximately 48 pet braunite, 14 pet manganite, 22 pet calcite, 5 pet magnesite, 6 pet hematite, and other minor minerals. The resources used for the study are estimated at 433 million tons. This includes only the grades of 38 to 40 pet manganese, and roughly coincides with the strike length of 4 km explored by 300 drill holes on the Mamatwan and Goold properties (16, p. 8); one stated reserve is over 200 years' production <15, p. 193). Mining is proceeding to the north along the strike of the ore zone and is performed by conventional open pit mining methods utilizing drilling machines, large power shovels, front-end loaders, and dump trucks. Current annual capacity is about 2.2 million tons. Currently, the manganese ore being mined is about 40 m thick and is covered by about 50 m of overburden, including about 7 m of sand. The sand is removed by a bucket- wheel excavator, and the hard rock overburden (limestone and banded ironstone) is blasted and removed in three benches. The ore is also excavated in a series of three benches. In 1981, an in-pit crusher and conveyor system were installed so that the crushed ore can now be transported about 2.2 km to the secondary crushers and wet-screening plant by conveyor. The conveyor system was designed for twice the capacity of the in-pit crusher for the possibility of increasing capacity by adding another crusher. At the secondary crusher and screening plant, the ore is crushed to minus 75 mm and wet-screened into plus 25-mm, minus 25- plus 6-mm, and minus 6-mm sizes. The minus 6-mm fines must be sintered before being used as ferromanganese smelter feed. Middleplaats Mine The Middleplaats Mine was ( purchased from the Anglo American Corp, by SAMANCOR in March 1982. At the Middleplaats, the ore horizon lies at a vertical depth of 300 to 500 m below the surface. The deposit is stratabound and dips 10° to the northwest. The ore is generally hard and competent and normally occurs as a mixture of manganese silicates and oxides. The thickness ranges from 8 to 14 m. The principal gangue minerals are calcium and magnesium carbonates. Demonstrated resources for this mine are estimated at 40 million tons in the Mamatwan-grade category of 38 to 40 pet manganese. The mine has a capacity of about 1.2 million tons per year. The mine is developed by shaft and service ramp. The shaft is 489 m deep, and the ramp is 2,500 m long with a slope of 10° to 12°. The main level is on the footwall at a depth of 400 m. The shaft is equipped with a Koepe hoist and is used for ore production and downcast ventilation, whereas the ramp is used for the transport of personnel and equipment. Mining is by room-and-pillar, where an initial 4-m cut is made on the hanging wall, followed by benching of the lower section. The ore is crushed to minus 150 mm underground before hoisting. The concentrator consists of secondary crushing, wet screening, and cycloning. The ore is crushed to minus 75 mm and screened into products of minus 75 plus 6 mm and minus 6 plus 2 mm. The minus 2-mm fraction is further processed by cyclones into plus and minus 150-nm fractions. The plus 150-u.m product is stockpiled as a potential product, and the minus 150-jim size is consi- dered waste. Wessels Mine Wessels ore occurs at a depth of about 300 m in the northern part of the Kalahari Field. On the average, the material contains 44 pet manganese, with braunite, bixbyite, and cryptomelane as the major minerals. Demonstrated resources are estimated at 208 million tons. The mine began production in 1973 and was designed to replace the production of Wessels-type ore from the Hotazel Mine, which was nearing depletion. Access 16 initially was by a vertical shaft to a depth of 395 m and an incline of about 1,200 m. A second incline was driven in 1980 and is currently being used for ore haulage to the surface through a cable conveyor belt system. Current mine capacity is about 1.5 million tons per year. Mining is by conventional room-and-pillar methods, although limited selective mining is done for grade control. This is because of a vertical gradient in the manganese content with the upper approximate 0.6 m of ore being of lower grade. Here the upper section is excavated first and stockpiled separately, and then the lower approximate 4.5-m section is mined. The mine is not adaptable to such large-scale equipment as the Middle- plaats Mine, since the ore horizon is thinner (about 5 m) and there are a number of small-scale faults and changes in dip. Crushing is done underground with satellite primary crushers located at the main haulageway intersections and a secondary crusher located at the belt loading station. The satellite crushers reduce the ore to minus 125 mm; this product is further reduced to minus 63 mm for transport to the surface. The surface plant is a secondary crushing and wet-screening plant that produces product sizes of plus 32, minus 32 plus 6, and minus 6 plus 1 mm. The rock smelted in South Africa is blended with Mamatwan-type ore for use in company ferromanganese plants. Postmasburg Field The ore in the Postmasburg Field occurs as a broken series of remnants lying about 1,800 m stratigraphically below the Kalahari Field and is divided into eastern and western belts. The eastern belt contains higher grade siliceous ores occurring in tectonic siliceous breccias along or close to their contact with a dolomite. The western belt contains lower grade ferruginous ores. These manganese deposits are marked by intricate shapes and inconsistent sizes. The only mine operating in the Postmasburg Field is the Lohathla Mine owned by SAMANCOR. Until recent- ly, three other mines, Bishop, Gloucester, and Paling, owned by AMMOSAL, were producing a total of about 300,000 tons per year. These mines are now shut down, and there is little likelihood they will reopen because of the high cost of mining (labor intensive), low reserves (about 10 million tons), and low-grade product (28 to 33 pet manganese). At the Lohathla Mine, one of the main resources of manganese is siliceous detrital ore. The detrital ore has been formed at the foot of the elevated ground owing to erosion. Resources are estimated at 5 million tons; however, the manganese ore bodies are so irregularly shaped that resource estimations are very difficult. Run-of-mine ore is transported by 17-ton trucks to the processing plant located adjacent to the mine. Waste materials in the run-of-mine ores are hand sorted on sorting belts before the ore is crushed, washed, and screened. The processing plant produces up to six different grades of contained manganese in concentrates. Ferroalloy Smelters South Africa has four ferromanganese smelting plants with an annual ferromanganese capacity of 563,000 tons and a silicomanganese capacity of 122,000 tons. These plants are shown below (6, p. 117; 11, p. 157): Smelter Annual capacity, thousand tons Location FeMn SiMn Witbank Cato Ridge 393 10 100 60 563 52 70 NAp NAp 122 50 km south of Johannesburg. 100 km northeast of Johannesburg. New Castle About midway between Johannesburg and Durban. Total NA — Not applicable. Each of these smelters is located a considerable distance from the manganese mines (Meyerton — 750 km, Witbank— 900 km, Cato Ridge— 1,450 km, and New Castle — 1,000 km). The average distance from the mines to the various smelters is estimated to be 800 to 900 km. The average rail distance for exporting the ferroman- ganese is 1,450 km, while the rail distance for transport- ing the concentrates to Port Elizabeth for export is about 1,250 km. UNITED STATES Certain manganese resources of the United States were evaluated in a previous study (10). Eight deposits were evaluated and estimated to contain nearly 422 million tons of material containing an average of about 10 pet manganese. As shown in table 4, these deposits contain very low grades not approaching the grades of manganese ore in the 23 foreign mines and deposits evaluated for this study. Recent significant factors in the U.S. manganese industry are a decrease in production of ferromanganese and a corresponding increase in imports. In addition, nearly all U.S. manganese ferroalloy plants have been acquired by foreign companies, some of which are current ore producers. Trends in U.S. imports of manganese ore and ferromanganese production for 1970 to 1981 are shown in figure 6. As indicated in figure 6, there has been a marked decrease in ore imports and ferromanganese production in these years and an increase in ferroman- ./ A \ / \ y'Q-e imports V \ V FeMmmpofts-toTol FeMn production 1970 1971 1972 1973 1974 1975 1976 1977 1978 1979 1980 1981 Figure 6. — U.S. ferromanganese production and imports ana mangenese ore imports, 1970 to 1981. 17 ganese imports. Of significance also is the increase in ferromanganese imports from non-ore-producing coun- tries. On the other hand, in 1973—78, when comparative data are available, ferromanganese imports of non-ore- producing countries other than the United States re- mained relatively stable (9. p. 491. Apparently the United States has absorbed much of the new ferromanganese production from the ore-producing countries. Although nearly all ferromanganese smelters are shut down, the U.S. annual smelting capacity (either producing or shut down on a care and maintenance basis) is estimated to range between 250.000 and 350,000 tons for high-carbon ferromanganese and was estimated at approximately 250,000 tons for silicomanganese as of January 1983. The range of the high-carbon capacity is because of the uncertainty as to whether or not the plants shut down on care and maintenance would reopen with improvement of market conditions. UPPER VOLTA The Tambo manganese deposit is located in a relatively remote region of Upper Volta. It occurs in two adjacent hills about 150 m apart and lies about 100 m above the general level of the surrounding terrain. The manganese occurs in three separate structures which are of a slightly different average manganese content, classified as first, second, and main manganese oxide zones. The main oxide zone is the highest grade material and contains material of up to 55 pet manganese (13). The Tambao oxides are variable in character. They can be layered or bedded, solid or massive, concretionary or cavernous, rubbly or friable. Generally, the central parts of the ore bodies are of the massive, black-grade oxide type, but towards the margins of the ore zones these pass into a slabby softer ore containing thin beds of argillaceous matter and kaolins. Resources are estimated at 16 million tons containing about 54 pet manganese (20, p. 202). Development of this deposit would require the construction of about a 350-km railroad and a total rail haulage distance of about 1,500 km. High development and concentrate transportation costs, in addition to problems between the Ivory Coast and Upper Volta Governments regarding the railroad transport system and terms for the use of the port, have inhibited the development of this deposit. ALTERNATE SOURCES OF SUPPLY Probably the only long-term manganese supply that could be exploited by the United States at some future time is contained in sea nodules. The National Defense Stockpile could be used for a short-term supply. Steelmak- ing slags have also been mentioned as an alternative source, but there is no commercial developed technology for the recovery of the manganese contained in slags. SEA NODULES The technology necessary for mining and processing sea nodules has been under research and development for over 10 years. The major problems associated with mining are those connected with the raising of the manganese nodules from the seabed to a surface vessel. A number of processes for the extraction of the metals from the nodules have been examined including chemical, electrochemical, and pyrometallurgical. The most applicable process has not yet been established. Manganese nodules are widespread on the sea floor, particularly in the deeper sections. The composition of these nodules ranges from 1.8 pet to nearly 34 pet manganese. In nearly all cases, the manganese is associated with appreciable amounts of other valuable metals including cobalt, nickel, copper, and molybdenum. Although manganese comprises the major metallic consti- tuent, cobalt, nickel, and copper constitute the primary metals of economic importance. In the most promising area of the Pacific Ocean southwest of the Hawaiian Islands between latitude N 8""30 and N 10W, and between longitude W 131° and W 150". the average concentration of nodules is estimated at 9.76 kg m grading 25 pet manganese, 1.28 pet nickel, 1.16 pet copper, and 0.23 pet cobalt. Within the area, the total quantity of potentially recoverable metals is estimated, using 20-pct mining efficiency, at — Million tons 500.0 23.6 20.0 4.2 Manganese Nickel Copper Cobalt STOCKPILE The National Defense Stockpile is a Government inventory system to meet essential military defense and civilian requirements in an emergency situation. It is not designed to control market prices or remedy short-term supply disruptions. A 1978 study (20) indicated that private inventories normally hold an estimated 10-month consumption supply, and the National Defense Stockpile carries an estimated 17-month inventory at normal U.S. consump- tion rates. At yearend 1981, private inventories carried about 940,000 tons of all types of manganese ore, and the Government stockpile contained about 2.5 million tons of stockpile-grade metallurgical ore and about 870,000 tons of non-stockpile-grade metallurgical ore (19, 1981, pp. 573-575). Based on the 1981 consumption rate of about 1 million tons, these inventories, not including the non- stockpile-grade ore, would last about 3 years. 18 ENGINEERING AND ECONOMIC ANALYSES To determine the potential availability of manganese, engineering analyses of individual deposits were per- formed to determine the capital investment and operating cost per ton of marketable product produced. When available, actual data were used in the analysis. For any missing cost data, the computerized cost estimating system (CES), developed by the Bureau of Mines, was used to analyze the engineering parameters of the deposit. To standardize the evaluation, a 1981 U.S. dollar base was used in all cost analyses. Foreign costs were updated to the base year by applying cost indexes. Translation to U.S. dollars was made by applying the U.S. exchange rate to the appropriate country. All costs are assumed to represent the average costs for exploitation of the entire demonstrated resource and thus will not represent current costs. Mine capital investments were estimated for acquisi- tion, exploration mine development, and infrastructure. Included in the mine capital expenditures were the costs for mobile equipment, plant machinery, the engineering and construction management fee, and infrastructure facilities. Mill capital investments include all mill and beneficiation equipment and machinery, and also the engineering and construction management fee. Working capital was calculated as equal to 60 days of operating and administrative costs. Costs for environmental factors were not considered in the analyses. Total operating cost was computed as the total of direct and indirect costs of production. Direct operating cost includes operation and maintenance labor and supplies, supervision, payroll overhead, and utilities. Indirect operating costs include technical and clerical labor, administrative costs, maintenance of facilities, and research. Transportation costs were estimated for individual mine outputs. These estimates were based on interpreta- tions of costs of the various modes and distances of transport and an assumption of what appeared to be the most probable destinations of the concentrates consider- ing existing smelting areas. An important cost factor in mining and milling of manganese ore is for support of the facilities in remote areas where the mines are located. Virtually all the mines are located in remote areas, most of them extremely remote. Support facilities include such things as housing, employee training, medical facilities, schools, recreation, power, access transportation, etc. Even in South Africa where the mining areas were populated before mining commenced, there are no facilities to support an industrial operation such as mining, so these must be provided. In other areas such as Serra do Navio, Brazil, Groote Eylandt, Australia, and Moanda, Gabon, the operations are extremely remote and all services must be provided. These areas would also experience problems in the supply of materials and a very high personnel turnover. MINING Terrestrial manganese deposits are mined by either open pit or underground methods. The physical character of the ore body and maximum economic return influence the selection of the specific mining system for any deposit. Although surface mining is generally economically more advantageous than underground mining, underground operations are used when overburden stripping has reached the economic limit and where deposits are deep seated. The continuous character of the ore horizons in the major manganese resource areas permits highly mecha- nized operations in both open pit and underground mines. Room and pillar is the most widely used underground method. Of the mechanized operating mines evaluated in this study, eight are open pit and seven are underground. The Molango-Tetzintla Mine in Mexico has separate open pit and underground operations. In terms of both production capacity and demonstrated resource, the open pit mines account for about 60 pet of the total quantities. The mining operations in India are virtually all labor-intensive hand operations. In some cases a minor amount of mechanization is used, such as a bulldozer or shovel for removing overburden. In India, mining always begins with the excavation of ore on the outcrop; if the horizon is continuous and excessive overburden is encountered, mining is shifted to underground. In terms of both production and resources, the mechanized mines evaluated in this study account for nearly all of the total quantities. Mining costs estimated in this study range from about $6 to $14 per ton of ore in the mechanized operations. Costs for the mechanized underground mining operations are estimated to range between $10 and $14 per ton. Open pit operating costs are estimated to range from $6 to $9 per ton. In the nonmechanized operations such as in India, where productivity may be as low at 0.1 ton per worker-shift, mining costs are estimated to reach $20 to $25 per ton. All underground mines, except the Middleplaats Mine in South Africa, are mining higher grade ore (plus 44 pet manganese). The higher costs for the underground mines are compensated for in part by the high grade of ore, by the high degree of mechanization (Middleplaats), and by the ore characteristics as to being able to fit into the smelting complex, such as blending for special constituents, physical characteristics, etc. BENEFICIATION All manganese ores must be crushed and screened, and if the ore contains appreciable quantities of low-grade or barren clayey material, then washing is practiced. The adaptability of a particular beneficiation process depends upon the mineralogical character of the ore and the economics of the operation. In general, crushing, screen- ing, and washing may upgrade the product by only 1 to 3 pet manganese. Washing can improve the product more if there is a significant content of lower grade clayey material, such as in the Groote Eylandt Mine in Australia. In most cases, however, the fines removed by washing contain relatively high values of manganese (approximately 20 to 30 pet manganese), and thus the recoveries are relatively low. Recoveries estimated for the operations in this study range from about 60 to 75 pet. Long-term recoveries are difficult to assess, however, because some of the material discarded at one time may be sold as low-grade blast furnace feed later, depending on demand. 19 Heavy-media separation can be used where there is a significant quantity of silica and alumina gangue in the ore and in some cases for upgrading chemical- and battery-grade ore. This process is currently in use at the Groote Eylandt Mine, the Molango-Tetzintla Mine in Mexico where silica gangue is encountered, and the Serra do Navio operations in Brazil in conjunction with reduction roasting and magnetic separation. Pelletizing of manganese fines (about minus 1.5 mm) in conjunction with heavy-media separation and spiraling is done by Serra do Navio Mines of Brazil. The final process is a reducing roast to convert hematitic gangue to magnetite. The magnetic fraction is removed, and the remainder of the material is pelletized. The nodulizing process is normally used in upgrading manganese carbonate ores. The process involves calcining the crushed ore in a rotary kiln to liberate carbon dioxide and to form nodules. Carbon dioxide is first liberated; then further heating softens the ore and forms sized nodules of about 25 mm. At the Molango Mine in Mexico the ore is nodulized and the Nsuta Mine of Ghana installed a nodulizing plant to upgrade the carbonate ores from 31 to about 44 pet manganese 23 I. In all processes, a certain amount of fines are produced which may or may not be further upgraded or shipped direct as sinter feed. All fines (generally minus 6 mm' must be sintered, and this is done at the smelter installation. Recoveries of manganese in the processing operations are generally relatively low. ranging from about 60 to 75 pet. The losses are the result of the fine material generated by the process not being adaptable to further processing. This may be the result either of dilution with clayey gangue or of fineness of the material produced in crushing and screening (generally less than 150 u.m>. The weighted average grade of all concentrates produced from the mines in this study is about 44 pet manganese. Beneficiation costs for crushing, screening, and washing are relatively standard, about SI to $2 per ton of feed. Where the ore is processed by simple crushing and screening, the costs would be in the lower part of this range. Washing would increase the costs by a relatively small amount. The higher range of the costs would be experienced in operations where other methods were used, such as heavy-media. Even heavy-media costs are not very significant, because generally only a small part of the feed passes through the heavy-media process. Of more importance in the beneficiation costs is the treatment of fines produced in the process. These fines are generally in the range of minus 5 to 6 mm plus 150 u.m and must be sintered before being adaptable to the production of ferromanganese. It is estimated that the amount of fines produced in the operations evaluated in this study ranges from about 25 to 50 pet. The costs of sintering these fines are estimated to range between about $12 and $16 per ton. These costs are prorated to the mill costs on an individual basis, depending on the amount of fines estimated for each operation. Nodulizing is done at two operations — Molango, Mexico, and Nsuta, Ghana; the incurred costs are mainly in fuel consumption. Assuming a heating requirement of 3.5 to 4.0 million Btu per ton and 1,000 Btu per cubic foot of gas, the fuel requirement wuld be about 3,500 to 4,000 ft 3 per ton of product. The advantage of this process is that the manganese content of the carbonate ore can be increased by 12 to 15 pet with little recovery loss. TRANSPORTATlbN Transportation is by far the most significant cost element in the production of manganese concentrates since nearly all the ore must be transported long distances to smelters. Even land transportation distances to smelters within the ore-producing countries are not significantly different from the distances required for export. Since there is virtually no possibility of develop- ment of manganese resources nearer to the major market areas, transportation will continue to be the major cost factor. A comparison of land transportation distances for export and in-country use is shown in table 6. Costs for land transportation by truck can vary greatly depending on road conditions and the type of haulage equipment used. For this study, data indicated that costs range from about $0.06 to $0.20 per ton- kilometer. Truck transportation costs are relatively insignificant in total world manganese production, howev- Table 6. — Manganese land transportation distances and modes Exported Domestic use: Country and mine Percent Distance (km) exported and mode Destination Distance (km) and mode 1 6 — true* NAp i do Navw 200— rail JfUCUfT 30 — truck . ... 2 700 — barge Sereno 930— I Gabon Moanda 76 — ropeway 485— rail Ghana Nsuta 60 — rail India Central Baiagha- msar 450 — rail TVodt. Ukwa Kamataka BisgodMine 140— truck 350— rail Mexico Tetzintla 230— truck South Ainca Kalahan F« - 1 .250— rail Postmasburg Field 1.1 50 Upper Votta: Tambao 1 500— rail' Milner Bay , NAp Santana Corumba ■, Nueva Palmira. Uruguay } Sao Luis Railhead -. Pomte Noire. Congo J Takoradi Visakhapatnam and Bombay Beligondi Visakhapatnam and Bombay Tampico Port Elizabeth do Abidjam. Ivory Coast 75 100 50 50 100 100 50 70 50 50 65 65 100 16 — truck. 30— truck. NAp 1.50C— rail 930— rail NAp NAp 50— rail 50— truck 400— rail 230— truck 900— rail. 800— rail NAp \~z Not app catte 'Proposed explored depOBitl 20 Table 7. — Estimated manganese ore and concentrate ocean shipping rates (Dollars per ton) Destination Originating country United and port States Europe Japan Australia: Milner Bay 30 30 12 Brazil: Santana 12 16 26 Rio de Janeiro 18 22 30 India: Visakhapatnam 36 30 18 Bombay 32 26 22 Mexico: Tampico 10 17 24 Gabon: Pointe Noire, Congo 28 28 34 Ghana: Takoradi 23 21 28 South Africa: Port Elizabeth 30 30 32 Upper Volta: Ivory Coast 23 21 28 er, since they are involved in only a small number of mines. Rail haulage involves long distances in nearly all manganese operations. A number of factors can influence the costs of rail haulage, such as size of the cars, condition and availability of the track, use of multiple units (unit trains), or Government policies such as special taxes, tariffs, or rebates. For this study, rail haulage rates are estimated to range between about $0,020 and $0,035 per ton-kilometer. Ocean transportation is generally the highest cost element in the transportation of manganese concentrates to main market areas. Estimated ocean shipping rates from loading ports to the various use areas are shown in table 7. Cost data for ocean transportation are generally very difficult to obtain and can be unrepresentative when applied to specific cases. This is because rates can vary drastically, depending on the availability of ships. Also, different ports have different loading facilities that can affect costs. In addition, destinations of the concentrates can be extremely variable, generally on an annual basis, depending on contracts between buyers and sellers. Other variables in ocean shipping costs include the capacity of the ships, or whether or not the ships are under term contract or are owned by either the buyer or the producer. In some cases, prices for shipping are negotiated for each load. SMELTING Smelting of manganese ore for the production of ferromanganese is carried out in either a blast furnace or a submerged arc electric furnace. Blast furnace smelting can utilize iron blast furnaces converted to ferromanganese smelting. When this is the case, the primary use of the smelter is to supply the steel complex in which it is located. Excess production could be sold on the open market. An exception is the Boulogne blast furnace smelter in France, which was constructed for the purpose of supplying ferromanganese to the open market. The majority of ferromanganese sold on the open market, however, is produced in electric smelters. Any new smelters built will undoubtedly be electric furnaces. Electric furnaces can be used for producing all forms of manganese ferroalloy and other ferroalloys as well, whereas the blast furnace can only produce high-carbon ferromanganese. Recoveries in the electric furnace are higher when the slags, which may contain 30 to 35 pet manganese, are used to produce silicomanganese which may be used as is or can be used to produce medium- and low-carbon ferromanganese. The production of silicoman- ganese in the electric furnace process from these slags is mandatory, if the manganese in the slags is to be recovered. The slag is upgraded by the addition of manganese ore and resmelted to produce the silicoman- ganese. It is estimated that manganese recoveries to final products in the electric furnace would be about 95 pet and in the blast furnace about 80 to 85 pet (9, p. 63). If the slag in the electric furnace process were not used for silicomanganese production, electric furnace recoveries would be about the same as those for the blast furnace. A variable type and quality of manganese ores and concentrates is used in ferroalloy smelting, depending on the availability of specific types of ores and the desired quality and type of ferroalloy produced. For this reason, complex blending of the ores for ferromanganese smelter feed is done at all smelters. The blending will nearly always include ores from four or five different sources. Blending is not entirely contingent upon manganese content but may be used to control the quantity of other constituents such as iron, silica, phosphorus, alumina, alkalies, and manganese and calcium oxides. In South Africa, a mixture of the high-grade, high-iron Wessels ore is blended with the relatively low grade, low-iron Mamatwan ore to obtain a higher manganese-to-iron ratio (15, p. 19). The nodules produced from the Molango ore in Mexico must also be blended with a higher grade ore to produce a market-grade ferromanganese, and the ores in the Urucum area in Brazil must be blended to dilute the high alkali content. It is estimated that the ore-producing countries have the manganese ferroalloy production capacity to utilize about 26 pet of their ore production capacities estimated in this study, based on an average usage of about 2.2 tons of ore per ton of ferromanganese and 1.4 tons of ore per ton of silicomanganese produced. Ferroalloy production capa- cities of the major ore importing and exporting countries are shown in table 8. The only recent development in the construction of new ferroalloy smelters is the 72,000-ton-per-year plant at Tumsar, India, which was built to utilize the ores of the Madhya Pradesh-Maharashtra area in central India. In view of the 11.6 million tons of manganese ore production in 1982, there is a substantial overcapacity in smelters at the present time. Assuming 25 pet of the ore (approximately 35 pet manganese) is used as blast furnace feed, and about 500,000 tons is used for the battery and chemical industry, the effective ore production designated for ferromanganese smelter feed would be about 9.1 million tons, or about 76 pet of the smelting capacity. Using the factors of 2.2 and 1.4 tons of concentrate per ton of ferromanganese and silicomanganese, respectively, about 8.5 million tons of concentrate would be used in 1982. This would leave a concentrate surplus of about 400,000 tons, even though only about 76 pet of the smelting capacity was being used. The smelting overcapacity has caused a shutdown of a number of smelters in trie ore-importing countries. As an example, the United States had only 1 ferromanganese smelter operating as of January 1983 out of 11 available. 21 Table 8. — Annual manganese ferroalloy capacities and ore requirements of major ore Importing and exporting countries (Tons) Ferromanganese Silicomanganese Capacity Ore requirement Capacity Ore requirement Total ore requirement ORE-IMPORTING COUNTRIES OR AREAS Canada Western Europe Japan United States Total Austrai a Brazil India Mexico South Afnca Total Grant total Assumed maximum 90 000 1.908.000 727.000 '350.000 198.000 4.198.000 1.542.000 770.000 50.000 427.000 575.000 240.000 3.049.000 6.709.000 1.292.000 70,000 598,000 805,000 336,000 1,809,000 268,000 4,796,000 2,347,000 1,106,000 8,517,000 ORE-EXPORTING COUNTRIES 1 1 5.000 140.000 307,000 150.000 563.000 253.000 308.000 675.000 330.000 1.239.000 25,000 180,000 56,000 50,000 122,000 1.275.000 2.805.000 433.000 4.324.000 9,513,000 1,725,000 35,000 252,000 78,000 70,000 171,000 606,000 2,415,000 288,000 560,000 753,000 400,000 1,410,000 3,411,000 1 1 ,928,000 It is possible that in the event of future increases in ferromanganese demand, the ore-producing countries will attempt to expand their existing smelting facilities to meet the demand. A smelter operating cost is assumed for the deposits evaluated in this study to illustrate the effect of the cost components of mining, beneficiation, transportation, and smelting on the total production costs. For this purpose, it is assumed that average operating cost for a smelter would be about $117 per ton of concentrate in all countries except South Africa and India. In South Africa, smelting costs are assumed to be about 8 pet lower, or about $108 per ton of concentrate. This is because the main smelting installation iMeyertom is relatively modern and efficient. In India, because of the lower degree of mechanization, smelting costs are assumed at $135 per ton of concentrate. In Western Europe and Japan, labor costs are generally lower than in the United States, but it is assumed that this is compensated for by higher power costs. In Brazil, the smelters in the Corumba area have low powers costs; however, these plants are relatively remote, and supplies and the ferromanganese product must be transported relatively great distances. In addition, most of the plants in Brazil are small and therefore would not have cost economies of scale. The concentrates in Mexico (about 39 pet manganese) must be blended with imported high-grade concentrate to make a marketable alloy, and in Australia high labor rates could compensate for the low power rates. 200 500 RECOVERABLE MANGANESE, m.ll.on tons Figure 7.— Market economy country manganese production costs. PRODUCTION COST SUMMARY Comparative operating costs to produce manganese ore and concentrates and ferromanganese are illustrated in figure 7. All costs are direct operating costs in terms of dollars per long ton unit of contained manganese in ore and therefore represent the effect of manganese grade on the cost elements. Additionally, the costs are based on mining and beneficiation of the entire resource and do not include taxes, insurance, brokerage fees, warehousing, etc., or profit or rate of return on investments. Transporta- tion and smelting costs that are assigned to particular mines and deposits are based on assumed delivery patterns to areas of smelting. As shown in figure 7, estimated mine operating costs range from about $0.20 to $0.34 per unit, and beneficia- tion costs range from about $0.05 to $0.45 per unit. The major variance in the milling costs represents nodulizing and the amount of sintering required. Transportation costs show the largest variance of all costs — from about $0.30 to $1 per unit. These costs are dependent on the geographic location of the mines and the modes of transportation to market areas. The relationships of the cost elements through concentrate production and delivery to the smelting areas and through smelting are shown in figures 8 and 9, respectively. As previously stated, U.S. dependence on ferroman- 22 Figure 8. — Relationship of cost elements through manganese ore and concentrate production. Beneficiation 3 pet Figure 9. — Relationship of cost elements through ferroman- ganese production. ganese from non-U. S. sources has increased in recent years. The increased imports have been not only from ore-producing countries but also from countries that import the ore, smelt it, and ship the ferromanganese to the United States. On a per unit of contained Mn basis, there appears to be more of a transportation cost advantage to shipping the ore to the United States for smelting rather than importing the ferromanganese. Table 9. — Manganese ore and ferromanganese transportation costs, comparing smelting in South Africa and in the United States (U.S. dollars) Smelting in Smelting in the South Africa United States Per ton Per unit Per ton Per unit product contained Mn product contained Mn Mine to smelter (ore) 16.00 0.36 NAp NAp Smelter to port (ore) NAp NAp 25.00 0.57 Smelter to port (ferromanganese) 34.80 .47 NAp NAp Shipment from South Africa to U.S. market: NAp NAp 30.00 .68 Ore 36.00 .49 NAp NAp Ferromanganese Total NAp " 1 .32 NAp 1 .25 NAp Not applicable. Using South Africa (the largest ferromanganese supplier to the United States) as an example, and a similar type of ore (estimated 44 pet manganese) and ferromanganese at 74 pet manganese, table 9 shows transportation costs for shipping ore versus ferroman- ganese to the United States. The shipping distance for transporting the ore to South Africa smelters was assumed at 800 km; distance for shipping the ore to Port Elizabeth for export was assumed at 1,250 km. To ship the ferromanganese to ports for export, a distance of 1,450 km was assumed. Costs of $0,020 and $0,024 per ton-kilometer were assumed for ore and ferromanganese rail transportation, respectively. If 51 -pet- manganese Gabon ore were used as a comparison, the difference would be greater since the comparable transportation cost would be about $48 per ton of concentrates from the mine, or about $0.94 per unit of manganese ($48/51 units of manganese per ton). Thus the transportation cost advantage of smelting Gabon ore in the United States instead of importing ferromanganese smelted in South Africa from South African ore would be about $1.32 minus $0.94, or about $0.38 per unit. Table 10 shows comparison of transportation costs involved in ferromanganese smelting in France (the second largest U.S. supplier of ferromanganese) and the United States. For this example, Gabon concentrates (51 pet manganese) are used. The locations of the plants in this example are Boulogne in France and Marietta, Ohio. As near as can be determined, the ocean shipping rates between the port of origin (Pointe Noire, Congo) and either Boulogne, France, or New Orleans are similar at an estimated $28 per ton. Since Boulogne is a seaport, costs for delivery to the smelter are less than the barging costs from New Orleans to Marietta as shown in table 10. This difference is more than offset by the ferromanganese transportation costs from France to the United States. Table 10. — Manganese ore and ferromanganese transportation costs, comparing smelting in France and in the United States (U.S. dollars per long ton unit) Smelting in France Smelting in United States Ore: Transportation to France 0.55 Delivery to smelter location .02 Ferromanganese: Transportation to the United States .37 Delivery to market areas .16 Total 1.10 NAp Not applicable. 0.55 .16 NAp .07 .78 23 AVAILABILITY OF MARKET ECONOMY COUNTRY MANGANESE This study analyzed potential manganese production based upon the demonstrated resources of 31 manganese mines and deposits in 9 market economy countries (including the United States); of these resources, an in situ amount of about 2.2 billion tons was represented and provided a total production potential of approximately 514 million tons of contained manganese in concentrates. The economic evaluations of each deposit were performed using discounted cash flow rate of return (DCFROR) techniques. All economic evaluations were performed using the computerized Supply Analysis Model (SAM) (2). This evaluation determines the cost of the manganese that equates the present value of revenues over the life of the mine to the present value of all costs of production, including a prespecified rate of return on investment. This determined value is equivalent to the long-run total cost of production for the deposit under a set of assumptions and conditions (e.g., mine plan, design capacity produc- tion, and a market for all output) that are necessary in order to make an evaluation. This long-run total cost was determined (in January 1981 dollars) at an assumed rate of ret lrn of 15 pet over the life of the deposit. The model contains a separate tax record file for each foreign country and automatically applies and relevant tax information to each deposit under evaluation. In addition, it holds a separate file of economic indexes to permit continuous updating of all cost estimates. Using January 1981 as the initial year, a cash flow generation of individual preproduction and production years was performed. After the cash flow generation, all properties under study were analyzed and aggregated to estimate manganese availability curves. The availability of manganese from a deposit is presented in this study as a function of total cost associated with development, mining, concentration, and transportation. The evaluations are based on the utiliza- tion of the entire resource of each deposit. POTENTIAL TOTAL MANGANESE PRODUCTION (CONTAINED IN CONCENTRATE) The potential production of manganese based on the long-run total cost of each operatiop is illustrated in figure 10. At a 15-pct DCFROR, the individual deposit costs range from about $1 to $35 per long ton unit of contained manganese in concentrate. These costs are for the delivered material to ferromanganese smelting areas and are estimated to include costs that would be incurred in exploitation of the entire resource of each deposit. The curve estimates the availability of manganese that is potentially recoverable at certain costs. At up to $1.50 per long ton unit, the total potential recoverable manganese (metal > is about 213 million tons. At up to $1.75. total potential recoverable manganese would be about 428 million tons, and about 491 million tons would be available at up to about $3.25. The analyses were performed in constant January 1981 dollars. The U.S. total potential recoverable amounts to approximately 23 million tons reflected on the curve. This is because determined long-run total cost for U.S. manganese resources is about $8 per long ton unit of contained manganese, which is approximately 2V2 times greater than the highest cost for any foreign operation. This determined long-run total cost causes all U.S. potentially manganese and is not the lowest 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500 550 TOTAL RECOVERABLE MANGANESE, million metric Tons Figure 10.— Cost and total availability of world manganese; cost is in January 1981 dollars and includes a 15-pct DCFROR. recoverable manganese to fall beyond the scale of the curve. An analysis of U.S. potential manganese resources is discussed in BuMines IC 8889 (10). 24 POTENTIAL ANNUAL MANGANESE PRODUCTION Another method of illustrating manganese availabil- ity is to disaggregate the total resource availability curve and show potential production on an annual basis. Figure 11 illustrates the potential annual production of contained manganese in concentrates at various determined long- run total costs from 1981 through 2025. The curves are based on current production capacities for the producing mines and estimated design capacities for the two nonproducing operations. The annual curve does not take into account possible delays caused by environmental, legal, fiscal, financial, market, or other problems. The figure also illustrates that 75 pet, or approx- imately 5.8 million tons, of the total potential annual manganese production is available at a cost of $1.75 or less per long ton unit. These analyses indicate that present potential annual capacity can very well handle the free world market requirements through the year 2025 without any addi- tional capacity expansion, assuming no significant in- crease in demand over that of the average 1976-82 production rate. / 6 5 0<— 1981 '•N— > $0-$4.00 \ $0-$2.SO "A '\ $0-$l.75 ','■ $0- $1.50 •■-,.v ; 2006 2011 2016 2021 2026 Figure 1 1 .—Cost and annual availability of world manganese; cost is in January 1981 dollars and includes a 15-pct DCFROR. CONCLUSIONS The demonstrated in situ resources contained in the 31 mines and deposits analyzed in this study amount to approximately 2.2 billion tons in 9 market economy countries (including the United States). From this demonstrated resource, an estimated 514 million tons of manganese is recoverable. The analyses indicate (given all parameters remain constant as of the initial year, 1981) that at a long-run total cost per deposit of up to $1.75 per long ton unit, over 30 pet of this material (about 413 million tons) is potentially available. Operating mines in Australia, Brazil, Gabon, and South Africa account for approximately 98 pet of the total available at this indicated cost. Demonstrated resources of manganese are sufficient to serve well into the next century. Based on the average 1976-82 production rate of about 13.7 million tons and assuming between 5 and 6 million tons of manganese content, the demonstrated resources of the current operating mines would last about 80 years. As manganese deposits with tonnage estimates at the identified resource level, such as in Australia, Brazil, Gabon, and South Africa, are further explored, they could be upgraded to demonstrated resources, significantly increasing the fu- ture availability of manganese. On the basis of contained manganese in concentrate, nearly 80 pet of the market economy country demons- trated resource included in this study is contained in seven operating units: Groote Eylandt, Australia; Serra do Navio, Brazil; Moanda, Gabon; and the Black Rock area, Middleplaats, Wessels, and Mamatwan, South Africa. This study analyzed only the deposits containing material of current mining grade with the exception of the United States. The only foreign area where lower grade resources have been quantified is South Africa. These resources amount to approximately 5.7 billion tons containing 30 to 38 pet manganese and a further 5.1 billion tons containing 20 to 30 pet manganese. Un- doubtedly, lower grade resources may also occur in association with other known deposits as well, although apparently very little work has been done to delineate them. Thus, it appears quite definite that the long-term world supply of manganese will be from the current producing areas. The major consuming areas of the United States, Western Europe, and Japan have no resources that can impact this current supply status. The most significant cost element in the manganese ore production process is transportation. By far the majority of production is from highly mechanized opera- tions. Concentration of the ore generally involves crushing, screening, and washing, and thus these costs are relatively uniform. The long-term world situation with regard to man- ganese supply is principally one of competition between the major producing mines for markets. In that seven operating units, all in a current competitive cost position account for over 400 million tons of recoverable man- ganese, the long-range manganese supply for approx- imately the next 80 years is assured. In recent years, the manganese ferroalloy smelting capacity of the United States has decreased significantly, as is indicated by a change in the relative import quantities of ferroalloys versus ore. This has been caused in part by increases in smelting capacities in the ore-producing countries. By contrast, there has been comparatively little decline in smelter production in Western Europe, which exports ferromanganese to the United States. This is evidenced by the fact that in the period 1973-78, U.S. imports of ferromanganese increased 25 by over 200 pet. while the imports of other consuming areas (Western Europe and Japan) did not perceptibly increase. One deterrent to the smelting of manganese concen- trates in the United States is that none of the smelters is integrated with the steel companies, such as is the case in Japan, where the ferroalloy could be supplied to the steel plants at cost if necessary. As of 1983. market conditions in the market economy countries will sustain only about 76 pet of the available smelter capacity. Undoubtedly, some of the shutdown smelters will not reopen even if it is warranted by increased demand because of the inefficiency of the operations. If demand should be projected to exceed the effective smelter capacity in the future, it is expected that the ore-producing countries would attempt to increase their capacities to meet this demand. REFERENCES 1. Clavillo. M. T. Autlan. High Resources Will Feed Steel Industry's Manganese Demand. Eng. and Min. J., v. 181. No. 11, 1980. pp. 107-108. 2. Davidoff, R. L. Supplv Analysis Model (SAM): A Minerals Availability System Methodology ."BuMines IC 8820, 1980, 45 pp. 3. DeHuff. G. L. Manganese. Ch. in Minerals Facts and Problems. BuMines B 671. 1980. pp. 549-562. 4. DeHuff. G. L.. and T. S. Jones. Manganese. BuMines Mineral Commodity Profile. 1979, 19 pp. 5. Dorr. J. V.. M. D. Crittenden, and R. G. Worl. Manganese. In United States Mineral Resources. U.S. Geol. Survey Prof. Paper 820. 1973. pp. 385-^00. 6. Duke, V. W. A. (comp.). Manganese, A Mineral Commodity Review. South Africa Department of Mines, Minerals Bureau Internal Report 53. 1979, 246 pp. 7. ICOMI ilndustria Comerio de Minerios S.A.). Contribution to the Round Table on Supply and Demand of Terrestrial Manganese Ores. European Economic Council, Brussels, Dec. 4-5, 1979. 20 pp. 8. Industrial Minerals. Manganese Non-Metallic Market De- velopments. August 1980, p. 23 9. International Iron and Steel Institute. Manganese and the Iron and Steel Industry. Brussels, 1980, 77 pp. 10. Kilgore, C. C. and P. R. Thomas. Manganese Availabil- ity — Domestic. A Minerals Availability System Appraisal. BuMines IC 8889. 1982. 14 pp. 11. Metal Bulletin, Ferro Alloys, a World Survey. Metal Bulletin. Ltd.. 1979, pp. 155-157. 12. Mining Magazine. Groote Eylandt. V. 144, No. 3, 1981, pp. 216-225. 13. Tamboa Manganese Deposits, Upper Volta. V. 144. No. 6. 1981, p. 437. 14. Narayanaswami, S. The Geology and Manganese-Ore Deposits of the Manganese Belt in Madhya Pradesh and Adjoining Parts of Maharashtra. Geol. Survey of India, Bull. 22, Series A, Economic Geology, Part I, 1963, p. 60. 15. National Materials Advisory Board, National Research Council-National Academy of Sciences. Manganese Reserves and Resources of the World and Their Industrial Implications. NMAB-374, Washington, DC, 1981, 334 pp.; NTIS, PB 82- 117615. 16. Taljaardt, J. J. Major Manganese Ore Fields, Republic of South Africa. Johannesburg, November 1979 (updated November 1982), 11 pp. 17. U.S. Bureau of Mines, Mineral 'Commodity Summaries, 1983, pp. 96-97. 18. Minerals Yearbook 1976-81. Chapter on Ferroal- loys. 19. Minerals Yearbooks 1976-82. Chapter on Man- ganese. 20. U.S. Department of State Bureau of Intelligence and Research. The World Manganese Market: A Status Report. Report 920 (unclassified), Feb. 6, 1978, 10 pp. 21. U.S. Geological Survey and U.S. Bureau of Mines. Principles of a Resource Reserve Classification for Minerals. U.S. Geol. Survey Circ. 831, 1980, 5 pp. 22. Vasudeva, O. P. Status of Manganese Mining in India — Problems and Prospect. Indian Mining, 1977 Annual Review, pp. 31-36. 23. World Mining. Ghana Manganese Will Extend Life by Nodulizing Carbonate Ore Reserves. V. 31, No. 12, 1978, p. 79. 26 APPENDIX.— MINES AND DEPOSITS INVESTIGATED BUT NOT EVALUATED FOR THIS STUDY Country and mine or deposit Comments Argentina: Fallaron Negro Small resource, production of about 25,000 tons per year as byproduct of a gold-silver mine. Bolivia: Mutum Resource has not been established. India: Barbil Included in Keonjhar District. Chickla Small resource. Gumagon Do. Beldongri Do. Kuhiuga Do. Bicholim-Sirigoa Principally an iron deposit. Harbaliem Do. Morocco: Imini All chemical grade, small resource. South Africa: Annex Langdon Nearly mined out. Hotazel Do. National Do. Rand London All chemical grade, small resource. Devon Included in Black Rock area. Adams Do. Mukulu Do. Smartt Resources low grade. Paling Resources small, shut down, will not reopen. Bishop Do. Gloucester Do. H 229 84 * » 4 °* .Ho, KV ** * A *" G°*..i^>o ,/\^%\. rP*..^*o, ,^.V_^V <$ SJ£-.*°> > %•/ ■*^°' \/ '*«■- %-/ ' - '** ft « •\^HS- -^& :£§lg^ "W ' * *bv" ***** A* % --£?** .&«* V 4>°<* ^o^ *■"% •. .. <4* c ^M^^ "^ q^ " o ^MK"<» ^ «4 ^ * o « o ° ^ v „4 Q. V' i> o <£ % > > • b? <. -.-.-..* * %•%•*./ Vv-wa •\ o^-jssLi.* /.«i-^i-\ ^°,-^<>- 4/.^" %.^!>J> v*-^\^ \/^.-*> ^"'^\# °*^- •'„/... % ,* 4 ,-.^/** g *.'J^i- °o ^yJ^/%. .\>z:J^,\ «y °^. * e '^* A V *°* a9 .••VL'v *> %■ -p *\.'v& ****** P- : #*% \ »fev* "* x* \d *' .71* A ^ ,0* c«-°. **b ^ P^, - V° V*. V V .. *« •• : *i C- A. V ^ a* ■A. v ; *°, a v ,N V 1. >bv D : W / HECKMAN ^f ^ BN06RY INC ^ ^ NOV 84 ■ = "* N. MMOCS T2_ ■ . ••« ;• 0« > ^ *!^ A*" V ,/ *> ^