1 Class _iLiLl^ Book . V ^ ^- ( iM i< J^. l^ 7 }xi^^^^^^:^< yfu^^^yf^ /^/^. y.Y'f/^ THE CHURCH AND THE SLAYE POWER. A SERMON PREACHED BEFORE THE STUDENTS OF THE METHODIST BIBLICAL INSTITUTE. CONCORD, N. H„ FEHRFARY '23, 18G0. By rev. S. M. vail, D. D. PUBLISHED BY THE STUDENTS. CONCORD: FOGG, HADLEY & CO., PRINTP^RS. 1860. Entered according- to an Act of Conjrress, in the year ISOO, by Charles E I itti ■- in behalf of the publishers, in the Clerk's office of the " '''^' District Court of IS'ew Hampshire. 4 THE CHURCH AND THE SLAVE POWER. SERMON PEEACHED BEFORE THE STUDENTS OF THE METHODIST BIBLICAL INSTITUTE. CONCORD, N. H., FEBRUARY 23, 1860. ':< ""' ^av. By REY. SrM.^AIL PUBLISHED BY THE STUDENTS, CONCORD: FOGa, HADLEY & CO., PRINTERS, 1860. ■i n Concord, N. H., Ft'5. IWi, 1860. Rev. S. M. Vail, d. d., Reverend and dear Sir .-—By a vote of the students of the Methodist Gen- eral Biblical Institute, we, the undersigned, are appointed a committee to respectfully solicit the publication of your sermon, delivered before the stu- dents on the 23d inst. We sincerely hope you will grant om- request, as we believe the truth will be thereby promoted. Your affectionate Pupils, CHABLES E. LITTLE, EDWIN WARRINEB, E. S. CHEESEIVIAN. Dear Brethren -.—Your polite note informing me that " by a vote of the students of the Methodist General Biblical Institute, you were appointed a committee to respectfully solicit the publication of my sermon delivered before the students, on the 23d inst.," has been received and duly considered. The sermon was not prepared with a \'ieAv to publication, but as you judge its publication would subserve the cause of truth I do not feel at liberty to withliold it. Your affectionate Teacher and Brother, STEPHEN M. VAIL. Rev. Charles E. Little, ~i Rev. Edwin Warhinkr, > Committee. Rev. E. S. Cheeskman, j SERMOisr Text : JRommis, 13 : 1—10, Let every soul be subject unto the higher pow- ers. For there is no power but of God : The powers that be are ordained of God. ^Vhosoever therefore resisteth the power, resisteth the ordinance of God, and they that resist shall receive to themselves damnation. For ru- lers are not a terror to good Avorks, but to the evil. Wilt thou then not be afraid of the power ? do that which is good, and thou shalt have praise of the same. For he is the minister of God to thee for good. But if thou do that which is evil be afraid ; for he beareth not the sword in vain, for he IS the minister of God, a revenger to execute wrath upon him that doeth evil. Wherefore, ye must needs be subject not only for wrath, but also for conscience' sake. For this cause pay ye tribute also, for they are God's ministers attendmg continually upon this very thing. Render therefore to all their dues ; tribute to whom tribute is due ; custom to whom custom ; fear to whom fear ; honor to whom honor. Owe no man anything but to love one another ; for he that loveth another hath fulfilled the law. For this thou shalt not commit adultery ; thou shalt not kill ; thou shalt not steal ; thou shalt not bear false witness ; thou shalt not covet ; and if there be any other commandment, it is briefly comprehended in this saying, namely, thou shalt love thy neighbor as thyself. Acts, 4 : 18-20. And they, [the Jewish council or Sanhedrim,] called them [the apostles] and commanded them not to speak at all nor teach in the name of Jesus. But Peter and John answered and said unto them, whether it be right m the sight of God, to hearken imto you more than unto God, judge ye. For we can not but speak the thmgs which we have seen and heard. It has seemed to me not inappropriate on tliis occasion to direct the minds of the young men of this Institution, to a subject in- volved in the Scriptures just read, which if properly understood and acted upon, will render your ministry a blessing both to the present and future generations, and which if not understood and not acted upon, will render your ministry of doubtful utility. It is of the highest importance that a Christian minister entertain right opinions, and then that he be a man of so much courage and faith that he shall bravely carry them out. It IS only a few months ago, that one of our Superintendents, Rev. Bp. Janes, while holding the Arkansas Conference at Bon- ham, Fannin County, Texas, was interrupted on the holy Sabbath 4 THE CHURCH AND in the midst of the religious services, usual on such occasions, by a body of armed men, who commanded the Bishop and his confer- ence consisting of about twenty members, to cease their work as ministers of the Gospel in connection with the Methodist Episcopal Church, in the county of Fannin, " henceforth and forever." That in the event of their failing to comply, they might expect to be visited with such pains and penalties as an outraged Southern com- munity might see fit to inflict. It is not to be forgotten, that a few years ago several of our worthy ministers were called to sufi"er even unto blood, in Missouri and Kansas, for no other offence than that they belonged to the Methodist Episcopal Church, which is and ever has been an Anti- Slavery Church. The pious and youthful Kelley was dragged from the preacher's stand and hurried through cold and storm to a distant place to die of violence and exposure. The Rev. Mr. Sellers had molten tar poured upon his head and shoulders, filling his eyes and ears. Rev. Father Holland, was shot dead at the same time, for mUdly remonstrating against this violence. The Rev. Daniel Worth, a pious and excellent Presbyterian minister of North Carolina, writes from Queensboro jaU, under date of Dec. 26th, 1859: "I have been three days incarcerated in this jail on charge of a breach of the criminal law of this State in preaching, and selling incendiary books, Helper's Impending Crisis, &c." In Kentucky, Rev. Wm. Kendrick, and Rev. Geo. Candee, were recently seized by a mob, and prevented from filling their Sabbath appointments, one of which was the preaching the funeral sermon of a brother minister's daughter. They then had their hair and beards shaved, and their heads and faces covered with tar. Rev. John G. Fee, Rev. J. A. R. Rodgers, Rev. J. F. Boughton, and Rev. J. S. Davis, and some members of their churches have been driven out of the State. Verily the days of martyrdom have not yet passed, and we have to discuss the old question anew, " What is our duty when the government forhids us to preach ?" It is true that the recent events above related, showing the deadly hostility of the slave power have grown out of the fact, that that power fears the preaching of Anti- Slavery doctrines. THE SLAVE POWEE. 5 The truth is, when the faithful preacher opens his mouth and de- nounces any darling sin, Satan is very much concerned to have his mouth closed by some means, and if it cannot be done by mild means, it must be by violence. There is a portion of our people, both of the North and the South, who declare that the government is supreme over all its subjects, and that any preaching contrary to the will of the govern- ment is contrary to the general good, and therefore contrary to the law of Grod. Vox Pojjuli Vox Dei. " The voice of the people is the voice of Grod," say they, " being expressed in legislative enact- ments." When in 1856 a distinguished United States Senator in discuss- ing the fugitive slave law, so called, ventured to remind his brother Senators, that there was a " Higher Law," thanhuman constitutions, a pious horror ran through the souls of aU the upholders of sla- very, both North and South. " There is a higher law than human constitutions or human enactments." A very simple sentence and very full of truth as I think. And yet even many professedly Chi'istian men, not politicians and lawyers only, but even ministers, united in the denunciation of the horribly, monstrously treasonable phrase. " There is a higher Law." And what is there more implied in this simple phrase than is implied in the declaration of Peter and John to the Jewish Sanhedrim? " Whether it be right for us to obey you rather than God, judge ye." In this connection we may be pardoned, we trust in alluding to another phrase of the same honorable Senator, which escaped from his lips it would seem, by the purest accident, while speaking to an assembly of his fellow citizens. " There is" said he "an irrepressi- ble conflict, between opposing and enduring forces, and it means that the United States must and will, sooner or later become either entirely a slaveholding nation, or entirely a free labor nation." Horror of horrors, again ! The whole of pro-slavery conservatism — conserva- tism ! I should say, propagandism — is seized with a sudden cata- lepsy. The whole Northern atmosphere is full of Sharp's rifles and Colt's revolvers. " Tliere is an irrepressible conflict." And again we ask is there any thing more implied in this phrase, than is implied in the words of the Apocalyptist Seer, " There was u-ar in heaven. Michael and his angels fought against the dragon, and the dragon fought and his angels, and prevailed not." And the conflict 6 THE CHURCH A^D will be irrcjyressihle, until the Angel of the covenant shall descend from heaven with a great chain in his hand and lay hold of that old Serpent, which is the Devil and bind him a thousand years. We live in stirring times, when Satan rages because his time is short, and when the saints too must fight with new courage and su- perior skill. New questions are almost every day evolved in Philosophy, in Theology and in Morals. Satan becomes an angel of light, and uses all his arts to prop up his falling kingdom. I wish in this discourse to stir up in the hearts of my young breth- ren some of those sentiments and feelings which will better fit us for the work of the Gospel, and to indicate to you some of those obligations resting upon us as citizens, and as ministers of the Lord Jesus. The Apostle says in the first verse of the text, " Thejjowers that he are ordained of God." Hence it has been inferred by some, that all governments of whatever kind, bad as well as good, are established by God and meet with his approval. But this is an entire misconception of the meaning of the Apostle. Let every soul he subject unto the higher poioers, i. e., to such higher powers as do not exalt themselves above the Divine power. Every power that contravenes the Divine power is unlawful, and is not to be regarded. Thus Moses and Aaron resisted the power of Pharaoh when it became tyrannical, and demanded of Pharaoh that he should let the people go. So also Daniel resisted the pow- er of the King of Babylon and refused to cease to pray unto the God of heaven. So the Apostles refused to obey the Jewish Sanhedrim and continued to preach as the text declares. Any power, in a word, which makes it necessary for a subject, in any way or manner to violate a single moral principle, or in any way to violate the golden rule, as ye ivoidd tJiat atjtcrs should do unto you, do ye even so unto them ; or the royal law — thou shalt love thy neighbor as thyself, is a wicked usurpation and tyranny, and is not to be obeyed. Tliat the Apostle could not mean that we are to be subject to any power which lords it over the Divine law is clear from the 9th verse of the text, "'for this thort shalt not commit adul- tery, 2%)u shalt not kill. Thou shalt not steal, Thoxi shalt not hear false vntness. Thou shalt not covet, and if there he any other com- mandment it is briefly comprehended in this saying, Thou shalt love he neighbor as thyself ." THE SLAVE POWER. 7 Our position is simply this therefore, that any power which as- sumes to violate or to cause its subjects to violate this royal law of God is not a " higher power" in the sense of the Apostle ; other- wise, the Apostle would contradict himself for he commands us to obey Grod at the same time that we are to be subject to the higher powers. It is necessary therefore that the higher powers be in subjection to the Divine law. And it further follows that any law, so called, enacted by men, which is in conflict with God's law or the Holy Scriptures, is no law, and is not to be regarded as law. To call such statutes, laws, is a misnomer and an absurdity, and it is time our legislators understood it. We are Christians and not infidels or heathen, and hence must be governed by the law of Christ. We ask attention to the phrase in the last part of the text — " The powers that be are ordained of God." " Here," says the slave power " all your notions about the higher law of God are put to flight." Here God himself says by his holy Apostle that all gov- ernments are divinely ordained, and of course can do nothing wrong." Even the cruel government of Nero is here directly sanc- tioned, and it is emphatically declared, that to resist Nero is to resist the ordinance of God. Never mind if Nero does take Chris- tian men, and Christian women, and sew them up in the skins of wild beasts, throw them into the amphitheater and then let loose upon them fierce Roman dogs, to amuse a heathen audience. These fierce creatures tear the flesh of these innocent victims from off their bones, — piece-meal, till death ends the struggle. Never mind, it is all right — it is an ordinance of Nero, one of the powers ordained of God. When this form of amusement becomes stale, Nero makes another decree. He commands his officers to take Christian men, and Christian women, and cover their bodies with tar and pitch, and bind them to a stake — the chin firmly resting upon its apex, and then he commands them to kindle a fire around them whose flames shall leap up and spread over their quivering flesh, and a heathen audience shouts and exults in this new inven- tion and refinement of cruelty. Nevertheless it is all right — it is an ordinance of the powers that be — of the Emperor Nero. Strange as it may appear, this very doctrine of Devils has come down to our times, and is acted upon every day in this so called Christian Republic of the United States of America. The argu- 8 THE CHURCH AND » ment is " The slave power of slave States is one of the powers that be. The slave power therefore is divinely ordained, and he that resists this power, resists the ordinance of God." Many of the Doctors of the Church bow down to this syllogism. Instead of making the church stand erect, the monitor and guide of the State, she becomes the poor subservient tool of the State. " The fowers that 2/ e" they say "■ are ordained of God," and the church is commanded to submit to whatever the State commands." If this doctrine be true and without limitation how could the Apos- tles Peter and John stand up before the Jewish Council, and say, " Wliether it be right in the sight of God to hearken unto you more than unto God judge ye." How could the Apostle Paul dare to stand in the presence of Felix and thunder forth the doctrine of God, on righteousness, temperance, and judgment till Felix trembled ? The minister of God must be independent. The pulpit must be unshackled, or it cannot fulfill its legitimate functions. It must be free to denounce sin, in high places and in low places — in Gov- enors, in Judges, in Senators, in Legislators, and even in wicked laws, which may find their way to the statute books. No earthly power can stand between God and his servant, who is divinely commissioned to declare his will. It is the business of the Chris- tian minister to preach the gospel— to preach the whole gospel, though earth and hell resist him. The powers that be are ordained of God, then, not to be the min- isters of evil, but to be the ministers of good ; not to muzzle the mouth of God's servant, but to protect him in his heaven-appoint- ed work. Civil government is good. Judges dispensing equal justice between man and man, sit in the place of God, and are to be held in all honor, when confining themselves to their legitimate sphere. Rulers are to be a terror to evil workers, and not to those that do good. " He is the minister of God to thee for good, but if thou do that which is evil, be afraid, for he beareth not the sword in vain. For he is the minister of God, a revenger to exe- cute wrath upon him that doeth evil. Wherefore the Christian must needs be subject, not only for [fear of the] wrath [of the mag- istrate,] but for the sake of a good conscience." For this cause the Christian must " pay tribute." THE SLAVE POWEE. 9 The crime of embezzling the tribute and taxes, at the time of writing this epistle prevailed over the whole Roman Empire. The more striking in this respect was the contrast of the Christians, who although enemies of the heathen, yet manifested such integrity in regard to the tribute that TurtuUian affirms, " What the Romans lost by Christians in the way of their Temple dues, was compensa- ted by their conscientiousness in paying the taxes."* " But yet," cries the advocate of the lower law of man, " Is it not the doc- trine of the Apostle that 'he that resists the power, resists the or- dinance of G-od ?' " Did not the Christians do wi'ong who refused to pay for the support of idol worship ? Was not Nero's power legitimate ? We answer it was, when it commanded things lawful and according to Grod's word. It was not lawful and was not to be obeyed, when it commanded anything contrary to God's revealed will. The powers that be inb dsov TSTuy/nipoi lial are arranged under God, subject to the divine will, and not elevated above it. They are ever under God's direction and control, whether the power be a Monarchy or a Republic — a limited or an absolute Monarchy, an Aristocracy or an Oligarchy, it matters not, so long as it fulfills its legitimate functions, and confines itself to its own province, and gauges its enactments continually by the holy will of Jehovah, as expressed in his Holy Word, it is right, and it is to be obeyed, otherwise it is wrong and not to be obeyed, for obedience thereto involves disobedience to God, which under no circumstances can ever be allowed. We are to serve and obey God, whatever be the consequences. Duty is ours, consequences belong to God. We may safely leave results in the Divine hand. In no case whatever may we do evil that good may come. " The damnation of such is just," says Paul, who teach this abominable doctrine. We may do things indifferent, or leave them undone, as the eating of meat. In such case we should act upon the principle of expediency. It may be perfectly proper in itself, for me to eat meat or drink wine, but if thereby my brother is offended or stumbled, it is expe- dient that I should refrain, that I may not injure his weak con- science. But the doctrine of expediency has nothing to do in excusing us from the performance of our moral and religious duties. To do * See Turtullian Apol. C. 42, infine. 10 THE CHURCH AND right is ever the highest expediency. Right doing is a solemn duty which we owe to God, and no circumstances but those of absolute necessity can absolve us for a moment. Wrong doing is always forbidden, and no civil, no earthly power can excuse us therefrom. The great law of Grod is that we are to love him with all the heart and our neighbor as ourselves. Any law or enactment of man therefore, which interferes and prevents us from discharging this law of Grod, is in fact, a dead letter, and is no law, and is therefore not to be obeyed — we are rather to mak^ up our minds to suffer its penalty, as Daniel did when thrown into the den of lions, than to sin against Grod. The same is equally true of the second table of the law, " Thou shalt love thy neighbor as thyself." If any human enactment says, thou shalt not feed the hungry, or clothe the naked, or give shelter to the panting fugitive, that law is void. It interferes with, and is contrary to the law of Grod, and is not to be regarded. We may suffer its penalty, but we are not to obey its iniquitous commands. I would say further, we are to seek by all proper means the im- mediate overthrow and abrogation of all such iniquitous statutes. The Christian minister, as well as the Christian member of the household of faith, is also a citizen. Paul was a Roman citizen, and on more than one occasion, availed himself of this advantage, " And Paul said I am a man ivhich am a Jew of Tarsus, a citizen of no mean city." Acts, 21 : 39. And as they bound him with thongs, Paul said unto the centurion that stood by : " Is it lawful for you to scourge a man that is a Roman and uncondemned ? When the centurion heard that, he went and told the chief captain, saying, take heed what thou doest for this man is a Roman. Tlien the chief captain came and said unto him, art thou a Roman ? He said yea, and the chief captain answered, tvith a great sum obtained I this freedom ; and Paid said, but I toas free born." Acts, 22: 25 — 28. And when cited before the tribunal of Felix, he further used his right as a citizen to defend himself, and finally to appeal unto Caesar. As it was not only the riglit but the duty of Paul to vindicate himself and the Holy cause he served, as a citizen, so doul)tlcss, it is our right and duty to do the same. If wicked laws get upon the Statute books, it is the duty of the Christian citizen to seek their abrogation, and if tliey undertake to compel us to dis- obey God, we are not to regard them, but to resist them, by all THE SLAVE POWER. 11 peaceable means, and suffer their penalty if need be. So likewise if ungodly rulers bear sway, it is our duty to seek for the appoint- ment of other and better men. The duty of votiny, therefore, be- comes often an imperative Christian duty. At all times therefore, and in all places, the Christian should lift up his voice and act for the right ; avoiding violent partizau feeling as far as possible, yet never compromising or yielding the right. The principles of faith and action, above recounted, we believe have their foundation in the infallible word of God. We wish now to make a brief application of some of them to the great question of our day, and of our country, the question of American Slavery. It is in vain for us to say that we have nothing to do with it ; that it is a question which belongs to those communities in which it exists as an institution. Whether we will or not, it has a great deal to do with us, both as members of Christ's Church and of the body politic. And even though it had nothing to do with us, yet I think we have much to do with that, as a stupendous system of iniquity existing among men. This was Cain's argument, "Am I my brother's keeper ?" It is not to be forgotten, we have an old law written in our scriptures, " Thotc shalt love thy neighbor as thyself' And another also, " Thou shalt not suffer sin upon thy neighbor; thou shalt in any xoise rebuke him ." And further, the Savior has taught us in the parable of the Good Samaritan, that we are the neighbor of him to whom we may show mercy, whether he be in our immediate vicinity or many miles away. It would, I think be a very unchristian declaration, to say that we have nothing to do, even with the woes and sufferings and sor- rows of the poor Chinese and Hindoos, though they be on the other side of the globe. And our Christian hearts rightly dilate with gladness, when we learn that some poor orphans, through our lib- erality are snatched from heathen influences, provided with com- fortable clothing, and blessed with the best of Christian instruction, by our devoted missionaries in those distant lands. "This is Christian, this is right," say all. Is it not equally Christian and right, to care for the poor orphan, who is torn from his home and kindred, by the wicked slave trader, nearer home ? If the poor colored man be our neighbor, we doubtless have duties to him, as well as to the Hindoo or the Chinaman. We are to do 12 THE CHUECH AND what we can to relieve tlie woes of the one, as well as the woes of the other. We have much to do then, with the slave and with slavery. ^ But slavery in these days is rampant and impudent. Our fathers wisely sought to confine it within the boundaries of the old Slave States. The ordinance of 1787, in respect to the North- west Territory, and the restriction of 1820, commonly called the Missouri restriction, it has swept away. It is even legalized in all the Territories of the Union, from Mexico to the British posses- sions. It lifts its unblushing face in the Capitol of the nation. It pursues its panting fugitives along the highways of all the free States of the North. It interferes with the sacred rights of hospi- tality commanded by the Savior of sinners. It says, thou shalt not clothe the naked, and thou shalt -not feed the hungry. It has slain our brothers upon the plains of Kansas. It has burned their dwellings and driven them from their peaceful homes. It is this very hour, driving hundreds of peaceful devoted Chris- tians from their property and homes in the Southern States, for the simple reason that they believe that ive shoidd " hreak every yoke and let the oppressed go free." It has struck the cap of liberty from our coins, and it seeks everywhere to trample freedom into the dust. Slavery therefore has much to do with us, and since it has be- come rampant and aggressive, I here proclaim, in the name of the God of the oppressed it shall come to an everlasting end. We may as well come right to the point, and deal honestly with our- selves in respect to this stupendous iniquity. Some men among us, in high repute, both in the Church and in the State have pronounced it " a Christian Institution.'" But I must utter my entire dissent. It is unchristian and anti- christian. At one blow it destroys the second table of the Law. " Thou shah love thy neighhor as thyself." Slavery is not doing to others as we would have others do to us. It is on the contrary, doing to others as we would not have them do to us. No willing, wilful slaveholder can either keep the law of love, or the golden rule. What wilful slave-liolder is willing to change circumstances with his slave in one single respect ? Is he willing to become a chattel ? not he. Is he willing to submit himself and family to the tender mercies of a Negro ? not he. Is he, or could he be THE SLAVE POWER. 13 willing to work for a single week for a kind and tender hearted negro even ? not lie. Is he even willing that a negro should be upon an equality with him, whether in the church or in the State ? I answer, though I need not answer, — No ! Slavery and slavehold- ing are ever contrary to the law of love. The legal relation may exist as a matter of necessity, without sin. But in all cases where the relation is continued unnecessari- ly it must always be in so far wrong, or sinful ; as violating both the golden rule and the law of love. It is to be observed also, that slaveholding violates especially the first table of the law. " Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with cdl thy heart,