'-^x. . - ,,^^ "^. \' ..*> ' -a ^ .•■^ ■ V, v "^/. > '^.f. '^^, "./ *<=■ •^ AV *-, " ''f vf-i \)vr * <" y ^-^-S^ ft o. >- V .0' y .^9^ 0°^^ *^^- ^o°<. n" x^ '° '/, ^• -:%*'^"\:^ ^^^ A.' "^ I a <> ^ \ ^nNr*^ ^,,^^ *^»;= %<^^^ V*o.o' ^v ...o r '^ -^1-* ^0°,. f .'/•^■■•-- ■%.'-' : • 0' :% \V
%^^ ^^ ^.m
^ -v
O.
■:*-^. (- •-
cP-
^-^^x
■f
.^
V
^A
1722 DO^ ER DATES 1922
A Bicentennial History of Dover, New Jersey
Published in Connection with
DOVER'S TWO HUNDREDTH ANNIVERSARY
CELEBRATION
Under the Direction of
THE DOVER FIRE DEPARTMENT
AUGUST 9, 10, 11, 19::
CHARLES D. PLATT. Author and Publisher
DOVER. Nb:\V JERSEY
Copyright 7
CHARLES D. PL ATT
1922
Printed by
THE JERSEYMAN, INC
Moiristown, New Jersey
©C1A692850
DEC 26 '22
^9 V
\
PREFACE
In 1914 my "Dover History" was published, containing personal
reminiscences of Dover people, with other historical matter relating to
the period 1722 to 1869. In the summer of 1921 I began to compile a
chronological review of facts contained in the Dover History, collated
with other facts from various sources, endeavoring to suggest the rela-
tion of Dover to the State of New Jersey, to the United States, as his-
torically developed, and to European history, thinking that such an
arrangement would be useful for the interpretation of our local history
in view of our approaching bicentennial year.
In October. 1921, although no formal committee had been appointed
as yet to consider the advisability of any public recognition of that anni-
versary, I conferred with our local editors, Harry R. Gill of The
Advance, and William G. Hummel of The Index and they heartily sup-
ported me in bringing before the public a series of articles entitled
"Dover Dates," published in the latter part of 1921 and the early part
of 1922.
It was our intention to publish this historical information later in
pamphlet form, and I am greatly indebted to my two friends, the editors,
for their co-operation in preparing to carry out this plan. Among other
readers of the newspaper articles, the Firemen of Dover became inter-
ested and determined to have a bicentennial celebration. With their cus-
tomary enthusiasm and energy they organized committees and made
arrangements to do honor to their Home Town, inviting me to join them
as an honorary member of their committee.
In time, it was thought best, with the co-operation of the Firemen,
to print "Dover Dates" as a bicentennial book. The Jerseyman of
Morristown made an offer acceptable to all concerned, to print this
book and promote its sale. This offer was accepted by the Firemen's
Committee. Our thanks are due to The Jerseyman for the generous
and able way in which they have helped us carry out the plan and publish
this book.
I am inde1)ted to Frederic A. Canfield, deeply versed in local lore,
for his kindness in making a few corrections and adding some items of
interest relating to the early chronology of Dover.
In undertaking this work of local historian I have been led further
than I anticipated. Not myself a native of Dover, I have gained much
of my knowledge from others who have resided here longer than I.
In this connection my thanks are due to the many persons who have,
first and last, contrilnited articles based upon their special knowledge,
making this book a symposium illustrating many phases of our modern
community and its environs.
"Dover Dates" is a supplement of "Dover History" and contains
much new and up-to-date material relating to the period 1869 to 1922,
especially 1922. The mlinicipal departments of the present day are
represented, also the military organizations of recent years, and the
larger industrial concerns of Dover and vicinity.
CHARLES D. PLATT, Editor.
DEDICATION
How dedicate these Dover Dates?
Who has this labor o' love inspired ?
Who but our Dover? Tete-a-tetes
With her have slumberiiisf srenius fired.
^& &^
The kindly old folks who recall
The scenes of youth, the happy days
That here they spent; who tell me all
That charmed them once, the old-time ways.
The business man of many cares,
Whose bosom swells with local pride
As he surveys his shops, his wares.
And waits the turn of Fortune's tide.
The younger folks — the girls and boys,
Now in succession apostolic ;
Grasping life's sweet but fleeting joys.
They conjugate the verb "to frolic."
The sober housewife, who presides
O'er hearth and home with patience rare
To raise her hopefuls; who provides
For endless wants with constant care.
The teachers, who inform the mind
And guide young hearts through realms of knowledge;
Who train crude youth to arts refined.
Prepare for life — perchance for college.
The City Fathers — may this lore
Of Dover Dates and Dover's story
Endear the Dover loved of yore
And clear her path to future glory !
CONTENTS
PART I.
EARLY CHRONOLOGY OF NEW JERSEY AND DOVER
Preliminary Dates.
The Dutch Rule, 1609-1665. 55 years.
The English Proprietary Rule, 1664-1702. 38 years.
East and West New Jersey.
William Penn and the Quakers.
The English Colonial Governors, 1702-1776. 74 years.
The Capitals of East New Jersey, i665-,i776. 11 1 y^'ars.
PART II.
LOCATION. ENVIRONMENT
Two Old Roads, Townships.
Ferromont. 1713 —
The Quakers of Randolph.
Poem : Richard Brotherton.
The Friends' Meeting House.
The Old Presbyterian Church at Rockaway.
The Old Methodist Church at Millbrook. Alonzo B. Searing.
Poem: Old Millbrook. Theodore F. Mott.
On Poetry.
The Iron Era : Poetic. Crane Hill
A Dover to Mine Hill Ramble.
Poem : The Life at Mine Hill.
From My Porch. Poem. 1919.
Twenty-fifth Anniversary of the P. O. S. & L. C, 1921. Poem.
Scenes from Hurdtown. Lefevre, Artist.
Dover and the Greater New York.
Dover and Pennsylvania.
PART III.
MUNICIPAL AND CIVIC.
The Mayors of Dover, 1869-1922.
The Manual of Dover, 1922.
The Police Force.
The Police Court.
Justice of the Peace, Constables.
The District Court.
The Dover Fire Department.
The Dover Water Department. George F. Steffany.
Poem : Hygeia.
The Dover Board of Health.
The Dover General Hospital. N. Eleanor Hulsart.
The Woman's Auxiliary of the Hospital. Mrs. Fletcher Fritts.
American Red Cross: West Morris Chapter. History Committee.
Poem : Woman's Work in the Red Cross. Minerva Freeman.
The First Decade of the Woman's Club. Minerva Freeman.
Poem : The Rhyme of the Woman's Club. Minerva Freeman.
Hurd Park. P. C. Buck.
Dover Post Office Facts. Charlotte S. Hurd.
The Dover Free Public Library. Martha A. Burnett.
Poem : What Dover Wants for Christmas.
EDUCATIONAL.
From Supt. Thurber's Report of Morris County Schools, 1876.
Reminiscences of Dover Schools, 1876-1881. Edward M. Young.
Thirty Years' Grovv^th and Progress of the Dover Schools, 1890-
ig22 J. Howard Hulsart, County Superintendent.
The Dover Schools in 1922.
Rosv/ell S. Bowlby, Supt. of Dover Schools, 1920—
Presidents of the Board ofEducation, 1910-1922.
Song: Dover High.
Prize Essay : What the Flag Means to Me.
Ruth Meyer, class of 1922.
PART IV.
OTHER INSTITUTIONS.
The National Union Bank, 1872. J. B. Tonking.
The Dover Trust Company, 1902. E. W. Rosevear.
Waste Not, Want Not: poem.
'The Newspapers of Dover
Dover Real Estate.
THE CHURCHES.
'Sunday School, 1816.
The First Presbyterian Church, 1835.
Grace Methodist Episcopal Church, 1838.
The First Methodist Episcopal Church, 1838.
St. ]^;Iary's Roman Catholic Church, 1845.
The Free Methodist Church, 187 1.
St. John's Episcopal Church, 1849.
The Chrystal Street Chapel, 1879.
The Swedish Trinity Lutheran Church, 1889.
The Swedish Baptist Church, 1889.
The First Baptist Church, 1893.
The Swedish Bethlehem Church, 1894.
The Salvation Army, 1900.
The Church of the Sacred Heart, 1903.
The First Church of Christ Scientist, 1908.
The Jewish Orthodox Congregation.
Mt. Zion Baptist Church.
The Gaines A. M. E. Mission.
International Bible Students.
The Christian Alliance.
Mine Hill.
The Mine Hill Presbyterian Church, 1874.
CEMETERIES.
The Old Morris Street Burying Ground.
The Dover Cemetery Association, Orchard Street, 1854.
The Locust Hill Cemetery Association, 1867.
The Friends' Meeting House and Cemetery Association, Rand
olph (1748) 1898.
The Mt. Sinai Cemetery Association, 1899.
PART V.
Hymn for Independence Day.
The Grand Army of the Republic.
The Spanish-American War.
The Boys' Brigade.
The Dover Home Defense League.
The Dover Home Guards.
The Dover Guard.
Battery D.
The American Legion in Dover.
PART VI.
INDUSTRIALS. CLOTHING.
The Silk Mills of Dover, 1881—
The Swiss Knitting Mill, 1890.
The Brotherhood Overall Factory, 1890.
Paul Guenther, Inc., 1897.
The .Sussex Overall Factory, 1918.
Cook's Laundry Inc., 1894.
The Progress ofAgriculture
PUBLIC SERVICE
New Jersey Gas and Electric Company.
New Jersey Power and Light Company, 1915
More Poetry: Reminiscences
New York Telephone Company, 11880.
Highways of Speech : Poem.
Crystal Ice Company, 1922.
Ulster Iron Works Inc., (1745) I903-
Warren Surnburger.
Miller Rofif.
George R. Flartey.
C. H. Benedict, Jr.
Edward W. Larsen.
Stewart Kahler.
George R. Flartey.
Fred W. Batten.
[ames O. Cooper.
B. S. Woodman
F. J. L. Doyle.
Otto A. Marquard.
8
EXPLOSIVES.
The Hercules Powder Company, 1871. S. B. Moore.
Picatinny Arsenal, 1880. Howard S. Deck.
The Atlas Powder Company, 1883.
Naval Ammunition Depot, Lake Denmark, 1891.
IRON
Dover Boiler Works, 1874. W. E, Goldsworthy.
McKiernan-Terry Drill Company, 1895.
Downs-Slater Iron Foundry Company, 191 1.
Lackawanna Frog and Switch Shop, 1912 C. B, French^
Richard Mine.
Replogle Inc., 1919.
North Jersey Steel Company, 1920. H, M. Roche.
Developing North Jersey Iron Ores. E. C. Kreutzberg.
PART VII.
TRANSPORTATION.
The Morris Canal, 183 1.
Early Days of theMorris and Essex Railroad, 1848 —
The Lackawanna Railroad in Dover. Charles E. Mill.
The Central R. R. of New Jersey, 1880.
The Morris County Traction Company, 1889.
PART VIII.
ODDS AND ENDS.
An Old Account Book of 1821-30.
A Dover Fourth of July in 1823.
Three Odes of 1823.
The Loan Exhibition of 1879.
The School Pageant of 1920.
PART IX.
LOCAL HISTORICAL POEMS.
John Jackson, 1722 —
A Song of Iron
The Mine Hill Blacksmith
Forge and Song
When Greatgrandmother was a Girl, i84(
Log Cabins
Ovens
Uncle Byram 1 792-1888.
A Race
Father Byram's Christmas, 1866.
Ford's Pond
William Young, 1802-1875.
Tave. 1842-1902.
Rapid Transit
The Town Clerk, 1922.
The Firemen, 1922.
The Song of Dover.
INTRODUCTORY
Blest is the man who can relate
The story of his native State.
In view of our approaching bicentennial year, I have tried to
constrvict a chronological summary of leading events and picturesque
incidents in the history of Dover. We may as well start with the
date when Columbus discovered America and a few other dates which
affected our historic destiny. While some of these dates may seem
far-fetched they furnish historical perspective and indicate great
dramatic forces upon which the future of Dover was depending.
Whether we should be a dependency of Spain, Holland, France. Great
Britain, or Sweden, whether we should be governed under a feudal
patroon system, by an absolute monarchy claiming the divine right
to rule, or conducted to an earthly Utopia by Puritan or Quaker or John
Locke's Model of Government, or whether the principles of Magna
Charta should mold a new form of government for the new world,
remained to be seen.
Our public library contains many books which will enable the
inquiring student to follow up these scanty hints more thoroughly and
trace the relation of our town history to the development of the state
and nation and the world at large — a study which is full of interest.
Preliminary
1492 — Columbus discovers America, October 12.
1497 — John and Sebastian Cabot explore the North Atlantic Coast
and claim North America for Henry VII of England.
1564 — French at Florida, destroyed by the Spanish in 1565.
1567 — The French destroy the Spanish settlement in Florida.
1584-90 — Raleigh's ill-fated colonies in North Carolina.
1588— The Spanish Armada attacks England and is destroyed.
Holland thus becomes independent and becomes a sea power
with trade and colonies in America.
England, freed from Spanish interference, can use the southern
route by the Azores to Virginia.
The future of the United .States (to be) and Canada depends
upon the supremacy of the seas, whether it shall be held by
Spain, France, Holland, or England.
1607 — Jamestown, Virginia, is founded by the London Company.
Captain John Smith, Pocahontas and John Rolfe.
1609 — Henry Hudson, in the employ of the Dutch East India Com-
pany, discovers the Fludson River and views New Jersey, which
the Dutch claim and rule until 1664.
1664 — The English assert their claim and rule New Jersey by Pro-
prietary Government until 1702.
1702 — New Jersey a Royal Province until 1776.
1776 — The United States of America assert their independence.
1926 — One hundredth and fiftieth anniversary of Declaration of Inde-
pendence. One hundredth anniversary of the incorporation of
Dover Village.
10
THE DUTCH RULE
1609 — Henry Hudson, in his ship The Half Moon, explores the Hudson
River, Manhattan Island, and the Jersey shore. Hence the
Dutch claimed the territory which he explored. As he was an
Englishman the English claimed it, basing their claim also upon
the earlier discoveries of the Cabots.
1 61 3 — The Dutch founded a trading post at Manhattan, called New
Amsterdam. The surrounding country was called New
Netherland.
1614 — They built a redoubt at Jersey City Point.
1620 — The Pilgrims landed at Plymouth, Massachusetts. Capt. John
Smith had previously explored and chartered the coast and
named the country NEW ENGLAND. The Plymouth Com-
pany ruled here.
1638 — to 1640 — English colonies were founded at New Haven and
vicinity. From these colonies many went across Long Island
Sound and settled on Long Island, at Huntington and else-
where. The New England settlements are intimately related to
the early English settlements in New Jersey.
1643 — The Dutch have trouble with the Indians of New Jersey and
massacre some of them. Fear of the Indians keeps the white
men, for some years, from settling in New Jersey far from
the coast.
1 65 1 — The Dutch begin to take up land in New Jersey under a patroon
system of large landed proprietors, like the old feudal barons of
Europe. A large tract is taken up by Cornelius Van Werk-
hoven, extending from the Raritan to the Passaic and beyond.
Gustavus Adolphus, king of Sweden, has schemes for founding
a New Sweden, with settlements on Delaware Bay and in New
Jersey.
1655 — The Dutch bring New Sweden under their rule.
1655 — The Indians retaliate for the massacre of their people in 1643.
They massacre Dutch colonists at Pavonia, Hoboken, and Staten
Island. Fear checks further settlement for a time.
1660 — Bergen was founded, the first permanent settlement in New
Jersey. The first school in New Jersey was probably estab-
lished here in 1662, taught by Engelbert Steenhuysen.
1664 — The Dutch remained in possession of New Netherland (and in
control of New Jersey) until 1664. They left their mark upon
the population, the land titles, and names and customs of a great
part of the low lands of New Jersey and their posterity have
been honored and influential in the later history of the State,
penetrating farther into the interior.
If their rule had continued, our Dover might have had another
name, such as Stuyvesant, in honor of the redoubtable Peter,
and Blackwell street might have been Goedenhuyzen avenue, or
some such name.
A good story might be written in the manner of Washington
Irving, on our present possibilities, in such a case.
II
THE ENGLISH PROPRIETARY RULE
1660 — Charles II was restored to the English throne, May 29. He
wished to bring the whole Atlantic Coast of North America into
immediate dependence on the English Crown.
The Royal African Company — slave traders — was chartered,
with James, Duke of York, brother of king Charles, as its presi-
dent.
1664 — He obtained from the king a grant of Maine, the islands of New
England. Long Island, and the land from the Connecticut River
to Delaware I^.ay, including land previously granted to Connecti-
cut and including New Netherland. "A very cool proceeding
and a clear case of usurpation."
The Duke of York sent Col. Richard Nicolls with four ships-of-
war and a Commission to act as deputy-governor within this
tract. Asserting the earlier claim of the English to Manhattan
and New Netherland, Nicolls called upon the Dutch to surrender
their possessions and their rule. They did so. Many of the
settlers were glad to have a change of government, hence made
no resistance.
1664 — June 23. The Duke of York conveyed New Jersey to Lord
Berkeley and Sir George Carteret, the latter from the Isle of
Jersey north of France, called in Latin "Insula Caesarea," after
Julius Caesar, the "farthest North" explorer of his day. Carte-
ret applied the name "Nova Caesarea" or New Jersey to his new
possessions. Thus the name of the Roman Caesar has descended
upon our State.
1664 — Elizabeth Town was founded by English settlers from Long
Island and Connecticut. The Dutch had denied them any share
in the government and had refused their request to settle in
New Jersey. Four weeks after the surrender of the Dutch these
English families made their petition to Gov. Nicolls, who
promptly "consented unto the proposals." The settlers obtained
liberal "concessions" of local self-government, far in advance of
the age.
1665 — Philip Carteret was appointed governor of West New Jersey
and made the seat of government at Elizabeth Town, which was
named after the Lady Elizabeth, wife of Sir George Carteret.
1666 — Newark was founded by English settlers from New Haven and
vicinity. In 1676 a school was established, taught by Mr. Catlin.
1667 — Quakers were settled at Shrewsbury.
t668 — The first Meeting House was built at Newark.
1668 — The First General Assembly was held at Elizabeth Town.
1668 — Rev. Jeremiah Peck, first pastor of the Presbyterian Church in
Elizabeth Town, also taught school. He lived and preached in
Newark the previous year and may have taught school there.
One of New Jersey's first "schoolmasters."
1672 — There was an insurrection of the Puritan settlers against Gov.
Philip Carteret, feeling that he was encroaching on their rights
as "free-born Englishmen." The antagonism and conflict
12
between the independent yeoi'ianry of England and the exactions
and assumptions of royalty as represented by Charles II and his
Cavalier partisans were perpetuated on this side of the Atlantic.
1673 — The English and Dutch are at war. The Dutch regain New
Netherland. When peace is made New Netherland is restored
to the English. Col. Edmund Andros was appointed governor
of New York, claiming also jurisdiction over New Jersey.
EAST AND WEST NEW JERSEY
1674 — Sir George Carteret and Lord Berkeley divided New Jersey by
a line running from Little Egg Harbor to the Delaware Water
Gap.
Berkeley sold his part. West New Jersey, to John Fenwicke and
Edward" Byllinge, Quakers, for one thousand pounds, with the
right of government, March 18.
Byllinge sold to William Penn, Gawen Lawrie, Nicholas Lucas,
Quakers. They sold to others, forming a company of Proprie-
tors in Common, with concessions from the Crown. The
Quakers were at this time trying to escape from unhappy condi-
tions in Great Britain. The New World offered the inducements
of freedom and prosperity. They settled chiefly in West New
Jersey, along the Delaware, and at Shrewsbury, and along the
Rahway River. Shrewsbury became the seat of a Quaker gov-
ernment and many Quakers of the better class took up their
residence there. They had iron works there.
1674 — June 29, the Duke of York received a new patent for the whole
territory restored by treaty with the Dutch, February 9.
July 29, the Duke of York reconveys East New Jersey to Sir-
George Carteret, who now becomes sole proprietor, having
sole power, under the king, to settle and dispose of the country.
This arrangement appeared to revoke some concessions of 1665.
1674 — In November, Gov. Philip Carteret returned, after two years
absence, to his home in Elizabeth Town, with a new commission
as Governor of New Jersey. The liberal concessions of 1665,
which had attracted the best class of settlers from New England
and Long Island, were remodeled, depriving the people of all
original jurisdiction, and giving the governor control of the
Legislature.
1676 — July first, a quintipartite deed was executed between Sir George
Carteret, William Penn, Gawen Lawrie, Nicholas Lucas, and
Edward Byllinge, by which East New Jersey was confirmed to
Sir George Carteret, and the partition line between East New
Jersey and West New Jersey was described. See Smith's His-
tory of New Jersey.
1676 — The Assembly met twice : At Elizabeth in April ; at Woodbridge
in October.
1677 — to 1679, the Assembly met annually in October in Elizabeth.
There was a conflict of authority between two masters, Gov.
Andros of New York, and Gov. Carteret of New Jersey.
13
16/8 — August, Andros returned from a trip to England, with full
mstructions from the Duke of York to claim jurisdiction over
all New Jersey.
One matter in dispute was the collection of customs duties from
ships. Andros demands that all ships shall clear in New York
and pay duties thf^re, before landing in New Jersey.
1679 — Gov. Carteret declares that all vessels that will trade to East
New Jersey shall be free. The Assembly declares that ships may
clear directly, by way of Sandy Hook, at His Majesty's Custom
House, which is at the Governor's House in Elizabeth Town.
The dispute became serious. Finally Andros sent men who haled
Gov. Carteret from his bed at night and took him, unclad, in a
canoe, to New York, having treated him with personal violence
to the detriment of his health.
Carteret was tried in New York for exercising jurisdiction.
Jury's verdict, "Not guilty."
The Deputies of New Jersey answered the demands of Andros
by claiming their rights as free-born Englishmen under Magna
Charta, as against any King's Letters Patents granted to the
Duke of York. An appeal was made to the Home Government
in England.
Gov. Carteret, on his return to Elizabeth, stretched his authority
to the utmost. The Deputies re-asserted their original rights
under the concessions of 1665. Carteret dissolved the Assem-
bly. These continued disputes caused some to withdraw from
the settlement. But the colonists were forming more and more
clearly their convictions as to their rights and the constitutional
principles of self-rule.
1680 — Sir George Carteret died. A new administration of East New
Jersey became necessary. His widow was made executrix of
his estate, becoming the Lady Proprietrix of the Province.
1681 — John Ogden of Elizabeth Town died, a man worthy to rank
with the Pilgrim Fathers, the acknowledged pioneer of the
town, a pillar of church and State.
1682 — Lady Carteret and trustees sold East New Jersey to the highest
bidder, viz.. William Penn and eleven others, twelve proprietors,
mostly Quakers, for three thousand four hundred pounds.
These twelve proprietors took partners, making twenty-four
proprietors, called the London Company. Some of them were
Scotch.
1682 — March 14. A fresh grant was made by the Duke of York to
these twenty- four proprietors. "One proprietor was thus ex-
changed for twenty-four, and the Cavalier for the Quaker rule."
1682 — Robert Barclay, a Quaker proprietor in favor with William Penn,
was made Governor of New Jersey for life, with the privilege
of ruling by deputy. He appointed Thomas Rudyard, one of
the proprietors, as his deputy. Rudyard took up his residence in
Elizabeth Town, November 13, 1682.
14
Former Governor Philip Carteret died December, 1682.
The long contest of the Carteret regime with the people was
at an end. Rudyard brought with him kind and conciliatory
letters to the planters, as the colonists were called. "He was a
man of amiable instincts and courteous demeanor, representing
not the lordly Cavalier, but a trading association of Quakers,
plain, unassuming men, who had themselves suffered much
from the Crown."
1682 — The four original counties of New Jersey, laid out in 1682,
were Bergen, Essex, Middlesex and Monmouth.
1683 — July. And yet something went wrong, for Gov. Barclay ap-
pointed Gawen Lawrie (Lowrie), one of the proprietors, his
deputy for East New Jersey in place of Rudyard.
There was still dispute about land titles. The proprietors
advised Gov. Lawrie "to use all means of gentleness and tender-
ness with the people, not standing much upon small matters. '^
He did so.
1683 — Charles H recognized the title of the twenty-four proprietors.
1684 — The ''killing time" in Scotland caused many to flee to New
Jersey. 1
1684 — August I. A Board of Commissioners, known as The Board of
Proprietors, was established to act with the deputy-governor
and Assembly in settling disputes and establishing titles to land.
This board was empowered to establish a new town to be called
"Perth" in honor of the Earl of Perth, one of the new Quaker
proprietors. Lord High Chancellor of Scotland.
This town was known as Perth Amboy and became the seat of
government of the Province when the General Assembly of the
people met here in 1686.
1685 — The Assembly met for the last time at Elizabeth Town, which
then ceased to be the seat of government. Perth Amboy was
more removed from the traditions of the Carteret regime and
nearer to the Quaker population of Shrewsbury and the Rahway
valley.
1686 — The Assembly met at Perth Amboy, the new seat of government.
Records of warrants and surveys from 1673 to 1738 are still
kept there. The Board of Proprietors still meet there.
The English Proprietary Rule from 1660 to 1686 was an experi-
ment in government by a land company formed to "plant" the new
country over the sea. The problem of giving and taking title to land
in a newly discovered continent, inhabited by natives of a dififerent
race and of a different stage of development, was the great problem
of the time, solved by no scheme of absolute moral justice.
There was no one then living who could foresee the future or com-
prehend all that was involved in the transactions of the day. and the
monarchial feudal system of Europe's past was inadequate to the new
situation and the ideas and spirit of the new age. Some confusion
inevitably resulted from the strange circumstances as well as from the
IS
conflicts of nationalities and the varying standards and moral principles
of the many individuals concerned. But New Jersey claims that, for
the ideas prevalent at the time, her title to the new land was acquired
by just bargain and payment, and not by conquest and robbery.
If time and space permitted, much interesting discussion of this
question of land titles acquired, under the Crown of England, through
purchase from the original inhabitants, might be quoted from sources
such as the opinion of Chief Justice Marshall, or a monograph by Adrian
Lyon, present registrar of the proprietors, or a series of articles by the
late Chancellor Magie.
But through all the bickering and dickering of the times, it is to be
noted that an honest efifort was being made to establish a new social
system upon a foundation of law rather than by conquest of arms
and superior force.
1684 — Gov. Lawrie wrote home glowing accounts of the new country.
Others were writing enthusiastic letters to the old country about
the charms of New Jersey. "It is not strange, Biancroft,
"that many Scottish Presbyterians of virtue, education, and cour-
age, blending a love of liberty with religious enthusiasm, came to
East New Jersey in such numbers as to give to the rising common-
wealth a character which a century and a half has not effaced."
Lawrie continue to reside in Elizabethtown, notwithstanding
instructions from the Proprietors, directing him to make Perth
Amboy his capital.
After four years of Quaker rule and great expense in bringing
over colonists the Proprietors were disappointed in results. Law-
rie, like Rudyard, was thought to be too intent on his personal
interests in taking up the best lands for himself. Settlers holding
lands by Indian title had not surrendered title to the new Pro-
prietors and were slow in paying the land rental demanded. A
new deputy must be appointed, but not a Quaker, this time. The
Presbyterians are gaining the ascendancy. To please them Lord
Neill Campbell is appointed in 1686.
1685 — Here we must turn back the hand of time to note that on the
death of Charles 11, his brother, the Duke of York, became
James II of England.
1687 — Lord Neill Campbell relinquished his post as governor of East
New Jersey and left Captain Andrew Hamilton in charge of the
government.
James the Second, formerly Duke of York, soon took occasion to
settle old scores with New Jersey. He made a decree,
1688 — Ap. 7, that the two Jerseys and New York be united with New
England under the rule of Andros * * * the whole to be known
as "New England."
The East New Jersey Proprietors were compelled to give up their
right of jurisdiction.
Andros appointed Capt. Francis Nicholson Lieutenant Governor
of New Jersey, and he took up his residence at Elizabethtown,
i6
by which it appears that it was still regarded as the capital of the
Province. (3ctoI:)er 15. 1688.
The people seem to have been pleased again at a change in the
government, having had enough of the Proprietary rule of the
Quakers.
1688 — New Jersey, as part of New England, is now a Royal Province,
ruled by a governor appointed by the Crown.
1689 — Tames II was deposed. William of Orange was made king of
England. The reign of William and Mary.
William Penn had been very friendly with the Duke of York who
became James 11. The Quakers of New Jersey remained loyal to
James II, hence called "Iacol;ites." The antagonism of political
parties in the Old World had its counterpart of the New World.
The Orange Mountains and the towns called Orange must have
taken their names from William of Orange.
l6c)o — The Quaker Proprietors re-asserted their right to rule, which
they were compelled to surrender to James II in 1688.
l6go — Gov. Hamilton left the country. Although retained in office by
Andros. under James II, on the accession of William of Orange,
he ceased to be regarded as governor. ?Te was really nothing
more than President of the Board of Proprietors, acting as deputy
governor,
i5go — Robert Barclay, for the last eight years of his life nominal gov-
ernor of East Jersey, died October 3, 1690.
Hamilton arrived in England and laid before his fellow-proprie-
tors the state of affairs in New Jersey.
i5g2 — Complications followed. Finally Hamilton was appointed gov-
ernor in 1692, and was so received by the people.
i5g2 — Bv an Act of the Assembly the bounds of townships were defined.
Elizabethtown took in Union county, parts of Somerset, Hun-
terdon, Morris, Warren and Sussex counties, including Morris-
town, Stanhope, Schooley's IMountain, and Newton. It almost
included Dover — but there was no Dover then.
There were disputes about land titles. Some settlers claimed title
bv purchase from Indians. The Proprietors did not admit such
titles. The king and his Council reserved the decision of the
Board of Proprietors in a test case and confirmed the Indian titles
acquired under Gov. Nicolls.
The people of the Province then wished to be rid of the Proprie-
tary rule and come under the direct rule of the king, William of
Orange. Petitions were sent to the king.
;i6q8 — Finally Gov. Hamilton was superseded by Jeremiah Basse, in
April. More complications followed.
The people of New Jersey formulated their complaints in peti-
tions to the Crown.
jyo2 — Finally, April 17, 1702, the twenty- four Proprietors surrendered
the right of government to Queen Anne, who succeeded to the
throne of England on the death of William of Orange, 1702.
17
She re-united the two provinces of West and East New Jersey
in one province and made her cousin, Edward Hyde, Lord
Cornbury, governor of the combined province of New York and
New Jersey. And so New Jersey remained a Royal Province
until the Declaration of Independence, 1776. The combined
colonies were called "New England."
1703 — In May, 1703, on the arrival of the royal commission, the Pro-
prietary Government of East New Jersey was brought to a per-
petual end.
Under the Dutch the English settlers had been denied all share
in the government. The first concessions of the Duke of York
granted them freedom of conscience, political freedom, and a
legislature of which the popular branch was chosen directly by
the people. To this legislature was committed the making of
laws and the laying of taxes, thus establishing early in New Jersey
the principle of no taxation without representation. We have
seen that in 1674 there was a recall of these rights.
Much of the discontent and trouble of these times was caused
by the quit-rent system of the British Colonies, which became a
contributory cause of the American Revolution. By that revo-
lution all feudal restraints upon the land were abolished and the
right of absolute ownership in the soil was established — a signifi-
cant aspect of our law of real property. (See Bond's Quit-Rent
System in the American Colonies.)
From 1702 to 1776 New Jersey was ruled by colonial Governors
appointed by the Crown. In this period Dover began its career.
THE ENGLISH COLONIAL GOVERNORS
1702-1708 — Lord Cornbury, governor of New England, including New
York and New Jersey, His rule was not satisfactory to the peo-
ple and in 1708 he was recalled. The royal governor, and others
before, showed too great a tendency to exploit the Province for
their personal benefit rather than to promote the real interests of
the people.
John Lovelace, the next governor, died soon.
1710 — Ingoldsby was governor until 1710. Then came Gov. Hunter.
1 7 14 — Queen Anne died. George I became king.
1720 — Gov. William Burnet was appointed. He removed to Boston,
1727.
1722 — Dover, under Gov. Burnet and George I, was founded by John
Jackson, who set up an iron forge here. Jackson's Forge.
1727 — George I died. George II became king.
1 727- 1 73 1 — John Montgomery was governor.
1 73 1 -1 736 — William Cosby was governor. At his death John Ander-
son was governor for two weeks. Then John Hamilton for two
years.
1738 — Lewis Morris was appointed governor of New Jersey, separate
from New York. He died 1746.
i8
1739 — Morris County was set off from Hunterdon County, and named
after the new governor. Jackson's Forge, up to this time, had
been in Hunterdon County.
1746 — John Hamilton, President of His Majestie's Council, became
governor. He died soon.
John Reading, President of the Council, acted as governor until
"1747-
1746 — Princeton College chartered at Elizabeth. Rev. Jonathan Dickin-
son of that town was its first president. It was removed to
Newark and then to Princeton.
1747 — Jonathan Belcher, former governor of Massachusetts and of New
Hampshire, was appointed governor. He came from Boston,
published his commission, August 10, at Perth Amboy. the capi-
tal, met the Legislature at Burlington, soon became a resident of
Burlington. He was a New England Puritan and did not like
the Quaker ways which prevailed at Burlington. He had to
drive with his coach and four, twenty miles to Philadelphia to
attend a church of his liking on Sunday. In 1750. September
26, while attending a commencement of the College of New Jer-
sey at Newark, he had a stroke of paralysis. Wishing a change
of air, he removed his residence to Elizabethtown in September,
1751. His goods (and the smallpox) were brought by sloops,
from Burlington. He occupied a house in Jersey Street, later
the home of Dr. Charles Davis, grandfather of the author of
"Dover Dates."
Elizabethtown thus became again the "seat of government," it
seems, from 1751 until 1757, when the governor died, overcome
by his infirmities and the excitement of the French and Indian
War. He was one of the most notable of the colonial governors
of New Jersey.
The government devolved for a time upon Lieutenant-Governor
Pownall, governor of Massachusetts, who shortly prevailed upon
John Reading, President of the Council, to act as governor — as
usual.
1758 — Francis Bernard became governor. Bernardsville bears his name.
1760 — Thomas Boone became governor. Boon-ton bears his name.
Josiah Hardy was the next governor.
1760 — George II died. George III became King.
^7^3 — William Franklin, son of Benjamin Franklin, became governor.
He was the last royal governor. The Revolutionary War changed
everything. Henceforth Jerseymen would have to settle their own
troubles in their own way.
We have now traced the English proprietary government of New
Jersey to its close in 1703, and given a brief review of the English
Colonial Governors to 1776.
We have seen that Dover was founded in 1722 in the reign of
George the First of England ; that Wm. Burnet was then governor of
New England, which then included New York and New Jersey; that
19
the capital of this greater New England was New York City ; and that
Dover, for the first fourteen years of its existence, was in Hunterdon
County. Dover was not born with a silver spoon in its mouth, but with
a hammer in its hand.
1 710 — to 1 719. Colonel Robert Hunter, governor of New York. He
was a Scotchman, a friend of Steele, Addison, Swift and the
literati of that day. He was appointed by Addison, who was
then Under-Secretary of State. He rejoiced in the title of Cap-
tain General, Governor-in-Chief of the provinces of New York
and New Jersey and territories thereunto belonging, and Vice-
Admiral and Chancellor of the same. Of him John Fiske says:
"He was the ablest and best of the English governors since
Richard Nicolls."
1713-14 — Hunterdon County was set off and named in honor of this
popular .rrovernor, who had acquired large lands there.
In Fiske's "Dutch and Quaker Colonies of America" will be
found graphic sketches of the colonial governors.
1719 — Trenton took its name from William Trent, who built mills on the
Delaware.
1720 — to 1728 — Gov. William Burnet, a god-son of William of Orange,
who stood sponsor for him and gave him his name. He was
said to be "a man of gay and condescending disposition, the
delight of men of sense and learning, and the admired friend of
the ladies." Dover began its career under his political star.
1728 — The Lenni Lenape Indians moved west, but several thousand
of them remained in Pennsylvania until a few years later,
SUNDAY SCHOOL
1747 — As early as 1747 a Sunday School was established at Ephrata,
Pa., by Ludwig Hacker, a German Seventh-day Baptist. This
was 35 years before the one instituted in England by Robert
Raikes.
1786 — A Sunday School was established in Virginia.
1809 — Rev. Mr. Steele, Presbyterian, opened a Sunday School in Pitts-
burgh, Pa., in the Court House.
1812 — A Sunday School was opened in Hackettstown, in the Presby-
terian Church.
181 5 — A Sunday School was established by Rev. Burr Baldwin in the
Old Academy, Newark.
1816 — Rev. Barnabas King, of Rockaway, organized a Sunday School
in Dover.
Springfield, Madison and Woodbridge followed.
See Mellick's Story of an Old Farm.
THE INDIANS
The Lenni Lenape Indians, totemic tribes of the Turtle, the Turkey,
and the Wolf, occupied parts of New Jersey. They were eventually
subjugated by the Iroquis Indians of New York State and degraded from
20
being independent warriors to the status of "women." In 1755, during
the French and Indian War, Sir Wm. Johnson restored them to their
fighting status as "men" again.
The Indians in their day, enjoyed our picturesque streams and
glens and wooded hills. Doubtless Indian Falls was a favorite haunt of
theirs and they must have known and used the pleasant water of the
spring in Hurd Park. Lake Hopatcong was a resort to which they
flocked with delight. They marked out the early trails through forest
and over hill and dale, of which the Minisink path was the most notable.
It led from the sea at Shrewsbury Inlet and crossed the Raritan river
two or three miles above its mouth, passing through the eastern and
northern part of New Jersey to IMinisink Island in the Delav/are river.
No doubt it had something to do with establishing the early communica-
tion between Shrewsbury and Dover to which the Quaker element in
our history bears witness. Many Indian arrow heads have been found
in our fields. The Indians knew the black stone or heavy stone, as
they called the ore of Succasunna.
(From "Historic Trenton" by Louise Hewitt. 1916. The Smith
Press, Trenton, N. J.)
1680 — Mahlon Stacy arrived.
1685 — Trenton called Ye Falles of Ye De La Ware.
1714 — Wm. Trent l>ought property.
1 719 — Court held at Trenton.
1724 — Wm. Trent came to Ye Falles of Ye De La Ware.
1724 — Trenton became seat of Supreme Court.
1726 — First Presbyterian Church built.
1734 — Postal service established.
1738 — First Stage Wagon — two trips a week to New Brunswick
1739 — Friends Mortgage House built.
1740 — Royal Giarter from George II.
1^750 — First steel mill in United States erected and owned by Benj.
Yard.
(Compare with Gov. Belcher's Report to Parliament.)
1750 — The Trenton Library established.
(Above data relating to our State Capital are inserted for
comparison with Dover Dates.)
EARLY RETURNS
1698 — In 1698 Jeremiah Basse was made governor of New Jersey, under
William and Mary. Many deeds are recorded as of "Basse's
Book of Surveys."
1713 — Among such deeds is one made out. May 19th, 1713. to Joseph
Latham, for 527 acres in what is nov/ Mine Hill, and recorded
in Basse's Book of Surveys, page 80, the survey being made by
John Reading, General Surveyor, by virtue of an order from
Daniel Leeds, one of the surveyors general of the western divi-
sion of the province of New Jersey surveys.
1710-1715 — The Proprietors of West New Jersey, owners in common,
21
allotted themselves as individual holderf large tracts of land
called "returns," which were surveyed, legated, and recorded on
the books.
Wm. Penn and Joseph Kirkbride took up returns as far as Dover
and Rockaway. Titles were derived from locations on the East
New Jersey right after the dividing line was settled in 1676. The
Latham deed appears to be classed under the "Western division
of the province." Locations or returns were mostly on streams
and meadow land, as at Mill Brook, Dover and Rockaway.
As late as 1693 much of our present Morris County (then part
of Hunterdon County) was included in the bounds of Elizabeth-
town. These bounds were more definitely fixed by the Assembly
in 1693, having been first described in 1664.
1 713 — William Schooley, of Schooley's Mountain, bought about 600
acres near Dover, including Mill Brook, which was named, no
doubt, from the grist mill set up on the stream — the first one in
these parts. A flourishing settlement sprang up at Mill Brook,
with various industrial activities, before Dover had become more
than a hamlet. At Mill Brook were to be found, in due time,
besides the grist mill, a fulling mill, a rope walk, a hat factory, an
oil mill, a Quaker shoemaker, a blacksmith, a sawmill, probably,
a forge, and (if we include the neighborhood known as
"Randolph") a school, a church, farming, a store, a butcher.
A cooperage was also established at Mill Brook, carried on
by David Tuttle and commemorated by Theodore F. Mott
in a poem entitled "The Deserted Cottage." But this brings
us to the nineteenth century. It was to the blacksmith in
Mill Brook that Gen. Winds traded in his "Soard" for two-
and-six-pence in 1782.
John Reading took up the Dickerson Mine tract on West Jersey
right.
171 5 — Wm. Penn took up a return, including the Munson farm, later
the residence of Leonard Elliott, just inside of Dover limits.
1 716 — John Reading sold the Dickerson Mine tract to Joseph Kirkbride.
Before that everybody came and helped themselves to the ore,
shoveling it from the open cut. The streams, the waterfalls, the
easily available ore. the woodland furnishing coal (charcoal),
made this an attractive investment.
And now these extended "preliminaries" are bringing us to the
birth of Dover.
THE FOUNDING OF DOVER
1722 — May 31. nine years after Joseph Latham acquired title to his tract
of 527 acres in Mine Hill, he sold it to John Jackson, "son of
James Jackson of Flushing in Queens county on Nashaw Island,
yeoman." The original deed was in the possession of Mr. James
H. Neighbour in 1914 and is shown in full of the text in Dover
History, pages 453-4. With the property therein described was
conveyed in some way or title was assumed to a forge site on
22
Jackson's Brook where Singleton's silk mill stands to-day, above
iiurd Park. Here Jackson set up the second iron forge in the
county in 1722, building himself a log cabin and becoming the
first known settler, The Founder of Dover. From this date we
count two hundred years to 1922.
The extensive woodland on his 527 acres doubtless was pur-
chased to keep him in wood from which charcoal could be made
for use in his forge fire. His house was probably near his
forge — possibly near that good spring of water in Hurd Park,
there being no city reservoir at that date, you understand. This
country was then a wilderness. Remember that Blackwell street
was not then in existence. Bridle paths were the routes of travel.
In picturing the landscape leave out the Morris canal and the
Pine Terrace Inn. Let our local artist paint the scene with two
log cabins near the spring and the great forge-hammer wheel in
the background.
From that day Dover has "forged ahead." "Forge ahead !" might
well be her slogan.
Much of the preceding history is summarized from Hatfield's His-
tory of Elizabeth and other sources. The history of the tide-water
settlements, such as Elizabeth, Newark and Perth Amboy leads up to
the history of Dover and gives us Dover's historical perspective. At
first settlements were made at tide-water for ease of access by ships, that
persons and supplies might reach these towns when waterways were the
only ways of travel, and for security from the Indians, provoked by the
Dutch. Later relations with the Indians were more peaceful, and lands
were obtained from them by purchase, under the Nicoll's patent. The
first purchasers of large tracts would sell to others. This caused trouble
with the Quaker Proprietors who gave independent title, as proprietors,
to lands previously acquired through Indian purchase, and tried to col-
lect rents from settlers who acquired lands under the first proprietors,
as referred to elsewhere.
The family names that are found in the early history of Elizabeth
and Newark and the Quaker settlements of the Perth Amboy region are
found later at frequent intervals among the inland towns, reaching
Dover in due time. Hence Dover history may be regarded as beginning
in these tide-water settlements and in these preliminary facts and dates
that have been given.
The following names occur in the early history of Elizabeth. How
many of them do you recognize as appearing later in the history of
Dover and vicinity? They came chiefly from Long Island and Con-
necticut. The same names may be found in Connecticut to this day,
for some members of the family remained there.
NAMES:— Andrews, Bailey, Baker, Beach, Benedict, Blackwell,
Burnet, Bryant, Brant. Berry, Bonnell, Blanchard, Qark. Cramer, Crane,
Curtis. Dickinson, Egbert, Freeman, Harris, Headley, Johnson, Jones,
Kerr, Lambert, Lyon, Marsh, Meeker, Megie, Mellin, More, Ogden,
Osborne, Parker, Pierson, Price, Runyon, Searing, Shotwell, Thomp-
23
son, Tucker, Tuttle, White, Whitehead, Watson, Wines or Winds,
Wood, Woodruff, Young, Carter, Gray, Skillman, Morse, Haynes, Peck,
Spinning, Ross, Lawrence, Morris, Wilson, Barber and others.
Among the founders of Newark we find such names as : Bruen,
Camfield, Kitchell, Baldwin, Day, Albers, Tomkins, Crane, Lyon,
Browne, Freeman, Treat, Pennington, Davis, Riggs, Curtis, Burwell,
Denison, Wheeler, Bond, Ward, Blachley, Plum, Lawrence, Harrison,
Pierson, Johnson, Catlin, Rose, Swaine, Ball, Morris, Tichenor.
THE CAPITALS OF EAST NEW JERSEY FROM 1665 TO 1790
The following memorandum was made out from scattered refer-
ences in Hatfield's History of Elizabeth. No complete statement like
this is found in any of the books on New Jersey.
Elizabeth Town
Perth Amboy
Elizabeth Town
New York
Perth Amboy
Elizabeth Town
Trenton
1665— 1686
1686 — 1702
1688
Gov. Philip Carteret resided there.
Perth Amboy 1738 — 1747
Ehzabeth Town 175 1 — 1757
Elizabeth Town 1783 — 1790
Lieut.-Gov. Nicholson was appointed
by Gov. Andros of New York to rule
East Jersey. He resided in Elizabeth.
1703 — 1738 When New Jersey was part of New
England. East and West Jersey
united.
1722 — Dover founded.
Gov. Belcher, coming from Boston,
stopped here to present his commission.
Gov. Belcher resided there, in house
on Jersey street, now owned by War-
ren R. Dix, Esq.
After the death of Gov. Belcher.
The home of the War Governor, Wm.
Livingston; but he did not dare live
there, for fear of attack by British.
Had to wander, like David, in hiding.
Gov. Livingston returned to his home,
Liberty Hall, in 1783.
He died July 25, 1790.
November 25, made capital by Act of
Legislature.
1758— 1776
1776— 1783
1790
Gov. Lewis Morris had his home near Trenton. After the Revo-
lution New Jersey tried to have the Capital of the United States located
at Trenton. To please the Southern States it was located nearer them.
Burlington was the Capital of West New Jersey, 1677. After the
establishment of Perth Amboy as the Capital of East New Jersey it
was arranged that Legislature should meet in alternate years at Perth
Amboy and Burlington.
24
T^Iellick's "Story of an Old Farm" tells much about the guberna-
torial tradition and splendor of Perth Amboy.
Shrewsbury was, in early times, a sort of Quaker capital and resi-
dential center of the wealthy and influential members of the Quaker sect.
1722 — Ore from the Dickerson ]\Iine was brought down to the forge in.
saddle bags. The blooms were bent into the shape of a letter U
to fit over the back of a horse or mule and were so transported'
to Elizabethtown port, to be shipped by water.
1730 — Iron works were established at Rockaway.
1740 — General European War. England against Spain and France.
America becomes a sea power, aiding England.
1741 — A petition was presented to Governor Morris, asking that the
duties imposed on iron by the British government be removed.
This is a hint of the financial difficulties that gathered like a cloud
over the head of our pioneer iron master, John Jackson, now about
forty years old.
1744 — Henry Brotherton, the grandfather of Richard, bought 125 acres
of the Kirkbride estate, and in 1753 his brother, James Brother-
ton, bought 200 or 300 acres on Mine Hill, of the same estate.
Henry Brotherton was born in 1724.
1745 — May 30. Joseph Shotwell bought from the Proprietors, 91 acres
of land (beginning at a house with lower part of brick, on West
Blackwell street, beyond the viaduct), taking in the main
business part of present-day Dover.
The Shotwells are an extensive Quaker family.
Soon iron works, together with a forge, were in operation on the-
Rockaway river. About this period of time we meet with refer-
ences to the "Quaker Iron Works."
1748 — There was a Quaker meeting conducted at Lamson's farm, south
of Dover, before the present Quaker Church building was put up.
On the map of 1832 Morris street is indicated as "The Road to-
Lamson's Farm."
1748 — 1750 — There was a great advance in the iron trade.
1749 — Middle Forge was set up at Picatinny by Jonathan Osborn.
1750 — An Act of the English Parliament forbade the colonists to set up-
rolling mills or to manufacture iron into articles of use. They
must ship it to England in the bloom. The English manufac-
turers would produce the articles of commerce made from iron
and then send these back to the colonists to be sold for a price
that would cover all expense of such double and distant trans-
portation. To this the colonists objected. Whatever manufac-
turing they did had to be done in secret and the iron business
received a great setback, if not a complete quietus.
Gov. Belcher reported to Encdand that there was only one iron
mill in New Jersey (one at Trenton), and that diligent search
revealed no others.
25
1734 — 'to 1750 was the period of "The Great Awakening" — George
Whitefield and Jonathan Edwards were friends of Gov. Belcher
and were entertained at his house in EHzabeth.
John Jackson was compelled to sell out at sherifif's sale in 1753,
and his farm and woodland, the ^2"] acres, was bought by Harts-
horne Fitz Randolph, a well-to-do Quaker of Monmouth county,
for about five hundred pounds. It seems to have been a case of
getting back an equivalent for moneys advanced as loans or other-
wise, as was the case later, when Blackwell and jMcFarlan took
over the property of Canfield & Losey.
THE NAME
John Jackson is said to have gone to West Virginia, where the
town of Jackson was named for him. an honor which did not
fall to the lot of Dover. Dover is thought to have gained its
name from Moses Hurd, the first associate of Jackson in Dover,
who is said to have come from Dover, New Hampshire. But
there seems to be some uncertainty about it. The town once had
the name of "Old Tye," which remains unaccounted for.
1753 — When Jackson left Dover (1753?) we do not know that this place
was known by that name. Nor do we know the exact date of
the name Old Tye and its continuance in use. But the name
"Dover" is found in an old account book, in a reference to "the
Dover Store," January 13, 179S. See Dover History, page 477.
The name "Old Tye," as applied to Dover, has puzzled antiquar-
ians. Its origin is a subject of conjecture. Let us again consult
the oracle of Morris county history, Rev. Joseph Tuttle.
1776 — In 1776, Gen. Winds (then Lieut-Colonel) and many men from
this part of New Jersey were at Ticonderoga, New York. Among
them was one Joseph Tuttle, who kept a diar}^ in Vv'hich he con-
stantly refers to Ticonderoga as "Tie." October 11, 1776, he
writes, "Col. Winds made application to go home, but no suc-
cess by reason of the senior ofiicers devilish lies told to the Gen'l;
the old Col. is shamefully alnised and belied." Nov. 5th and 6th
he notes that Col. Winds got an order to "be oft" and left Ticon-
deroga with 105 men of our Battalion, some say with scandal,
but Col. Winds says with honor. On the basis of such memo-
randa we may venture a guess. Some old soldier, returning
from this expedition, may have referred to his experiences so
frequently or in such a way as to gain the nickname "Old Tye,"
and if he lived here, as Gen. Winds did, the name may have
passed over to this locality. Perhaps both names, Old Tye and
Dover, were synchronous for a while, and Dover "won out"
after 1790.
2(i
Mr. Canfield has shown me a map published in 1777, from sur-
veys made in 1769. On this map we find "BEMEN'S" where
Dover should be. "Beman's" is referred to in a letter of 1790
written by Jacob Losey.
1756 — 63 — French and Indian War.
1756 — The sheriflf's sale and the advent of Hartshorne Fitz Randolph
mark the end of the first period of Dover's history. Close upon
this followed the advent of another notable man, General Winds
(or Wines), who came to East Dover from Southold, Long
Island, in 1756. He bought a farm of 275 acres from Thomas
and Richard Penn. situated where the Delaware, Lackawanna
and Western carshops used to be. He was a dominant char-
acter in the county, as has been so well shown by Rev. Joseph
F. Tuttle, D.D., in a biographical sketch of this "hero of Morris
county."
1757 — Following General Winds came his brother-in-law, Josiah Bea-
man, who purchased, in 1757, the forge and dwelling of John
Jackson, situated in Dover. We conclude that by this time Jack-
son had left or did leave Dover. Beaman also bought from
Shotwell 107 acres in Dover, mostly north of the river. We find
in Dover History, page 475, that Josiah Beaman acquired the
"plantation" known as the Baker Homestead at Mt. Pleasant
at some time subsequent to 1774 and sold it to Jeremiah Baker
in 1792, when he sold his iron works in Dover to Canfield &
Losey.
1758 — The "Old Quaker Church" bearing this date is a well-known
landmark. It stands facing "The Great Road," as mentioned in
the deed of land, and occupies a commanding site with a magni-
ficent view. The Quakers could not foresee the coming of the
canal and the railroad, but they located along the great thorough-
fare of their day, and chose the finest upland of this region for
their farms and their rural community of Randolph.
Continuing the memoranda of these early settlers which have
been so carefully gathered by Dr. Tuttle and published in his
"Centennial Collections of Morris County," we observe that the
Quaker community on the hills south of Dover kept growing.
Henry and Richard Brotherton, two brothers, and Richard Dell,
married daughters of William Schooley, of Schooley's Mountain.
Dell removed from Schooley's Mountain in 1759, to a tract of
land which he purchased from the heirs of Wm. Penn. His
son, Thomas Dell, bought land of the Kirkbride heirs in 1786.
Daniel Carrell settled at Center Grove in 1739, on lot No. 7,
Kirkbride Division.
1761 — There is a note to the eflfect that one Joseph Prudden sold land
in Dover to Josiah Beaman in 1761.
THE FRENCH AND INDIAN WAR
1754-63 — Turning back our historical searchlight, we must note that the
French and Indian War was going on from 1754 to 1763. Men
from this vicinity enlisted and went north to aid in the conquest
of Canada. Gen. Winds was one who was called upon to serve
in the field. To quote from Ashley's United States History,
"The French and Indian War decided the fate of the French
empire on the continent of North America." John Fiske believed
that "the triumph of Wolfe marks the greatest turning point as
yet discernible in modern history." Gen. Winds had a hand in
deciding this turning point, and other men from Dover were with
him. This is not the only "turning point" in world history in
which the men of Dover have had a hand.
1763 — The Peace of Paris gave England control of North America
east of the Mississippi, except Florida.
1765 — Following the French and Indian War the British Parliament,
under George III, passed the Stamp Act to recover the costs of
the war, in part at least, from the colonies. Stamps were required
on law papers, etc. The colonists resented this Act, Law papers
must be made out on stamped paper sold for the purpose. The
Sons of Liberty adopted the motto, "Liberty, Property, and no
Stamps." Patrick Henry stirred the people by his resolutions.
There was great excitement.
1765 — Gen. Winds, then Justice of the Peace, refused to use the
stamped paper in making out his legal documents and maintained
his independence by using birch bark.
This local incident of Dover was a prelude to the Boston Tea
Party of 1773, and points to the next great event in Dover history
as associated with the destiny of the nation, for the Colonies
became the United States of America as a result of the Declara-
tion of Independence in 1776.
1768 — John Jackson's brother, Joseph, is said to have bought part of
John's forge in 1768, selling it. next year, to his son Stephen
Jackson of "Mendom," who afterwards became owner of the
fine mill property at Rockaway, with large tracts of valuable
lands. He once had the honor of entertaining Gen. Washington
at his house. He was a man of great energy and died in 1812.
Rev. Joseph F. Tuttle thinks that Rockaway may have been
settled in 1725 — 30 by the building of a small forge.
1772 — The American colonies have great sea power. Help make Eng-
land an empire.
Richard Faesch bought up the Richard mine (named after him)
which was afterwards operated by the Dover Company of Can-
field & Losey, and by Blackwell & McFarlan, and sold by the
latter to the Thomas Iron Company in 1856. Mines and forges
are the backbone of Dover history. Further details can be found
in Munsell's History of Morris County and in the State Geo-
28
J 776 — 1783, and New Jersey was no longer under a royal governor.
The Revolutionary War occupied the attention of Dover folks
from 1776 to 1783 and Morris County was particularly con-
cerned in the struggle because of the Winter Camps of Washing-
ton and the American army at Morristown. and because of the
demand for iron products in carrying on the battle for freedom.
Dr. Tuttle has been the intimate historian of the experiences of
Morris County people during the Revolution. The "Ballads of
New Jersey in the Revolution," based chiefly upon his local
sketches, further illustrates the times.
1779 — Jonathan Dickerson. in partnership with Minard Le Fevre, began
to buy out the Kirkbride interest in the Succasunna mine.
1790 — The following postoffices were established in New Jersey: Eliza-
beth, Newark. Princeton, Trenton, East Bridgeton (Rahway).
1 79 1 — Only six post offices in New Jersey.
1792 — The rage for building canals and turnpikes broke out. Reached
Dover later.
1793 — These postoffices were added : Amboy, Bridgeton, Morristown,
Rockaway (which then served for Dover), Woodbury, Woods-
town.
1792 — Canfield & Losey bought from Josiah Beaman the iron works in
Dover, situated on the Rockaway river. They built the dam. a
rolling mill, a slitting mill, a nail factory and also a dwelling
house for Mr. Losey. who lived in Dover and conducted the
business. In his house was a store and the first knov/n post office,
of which he was the postmaster, as testified by Mrs. Livermore.
Jacob Losey was her great uncle. This is the first mention of a
"Dover store." Israel Canfield acquired title to extensive min-
ing tracts outside of Dover in northern New Jersey. Mr. Losey's
garden was notable. He was the first to cultivate the tomato in
Dover. His hospitality famous.
1794 — 99 — In an old account book of Baker & Ludlow, at Mt. Pleasant,
are found the names of 173 persons living in Dover and vicinity,
trading at the store or named as members of the family of per-
sor.s having accounts there. Business had to be conducted in
English money, pounds, shillings and pence, even at that date.
The English colonial government had discouraged the circulation
of money and the habit of trading l)y barter had long been estab-
lished in the colonies. Also credit would be given by transfers
on the accounts of persons trading at the one store, in a manner
to supply, in a way, the use of bank checks. The entries in the
old books throw much light upon the habits and doings and
method of living of that day, as well as providing the nearest sub-
stitute for a census of the po]nilation with lists of family names.
It is said that Dover was at this time (end of the eighteenth cen-
tury) full of infidelity and wickedness. (Munsell). Followers
of Tom Paine disseminated his sentiments. Standards were low.
This was not limited to Dover, for at that time, after the Revolu-
29
tionary War, French infidelity was rife in our States. The "Age
of Reason" affected this country as well as Europe. Dr. Dwight,
president of Yale College at that time, preached a series of ser-
mons on the evidences and claims of Christianity and did much
to stem the tide.
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY
By this time we see that Dover is an industrial town, and that
its prosperity is largely dependent on the mines by which it is sur- ji
rounded and the manufacture of the iron which they supply. In look- |
ing to the future, in planning to establish or to carry on a community,
present-day methods of efficiency would demand a study of those ele-
ments which belond to any well-developed community, and would
doubtless recognize as such elements —
1. Industry, or the means of making a living.
This involves the rendering of some service to the world of
which we are a part.
2. Communication with the outside world, by letter, by travel.
Hence roads.
3. Transportation : The means of carrying our products to dis-
tant places and of bringing back the products that we need.
Hence, more and better roads, canals, railroads — anything
that will carry — even airplanes.
4. A medium of exchange. Barter, or exchange of products, is
the foundation of trade; but a monetary and banking system
may facilitate business.
5. Family life, involving marriage and the home.
The industrial foundation of life is only a foundation on
which to rear the edifice, humanity.
6. Education, or the training of the young, demands a place in
the complete community.
Hence schools, teachers, books, a public library.
7. Furthermore, Religion is a part of life. Hence churches.
8. Entertainment and social life refuse to be overlooked. Hence,
places of recreation, outdoors and indoors.
9. Government and all departments of public welfare must be
provided for. Hence, municipal organization, public officers.
10. Protection of life and property call for a police force and a
fire department, to fight crime and fire.
11. Various public works are devised — water, gas, electricity.
Some of these affairs are conducted as private enterprises,
but they all enter into the history of a town.
12. A Court and a legal profession will administer the law.
13. Physicians will watch over life and health.
14. ?vlany kinds of private business, and of arts, trades, and
sciences will find a place.
15. In carrying on all these activities personal character is devel-
oped ; men and women make their mark on the common life of
their fellov/ citizens. Biography becomes a great part of his-
tory.
30
When looking forward we may build ideals for each of these inter-
ests. In looking back through Dover history we may search for the
answer that Dover has given to all these demands of human life. When
we discover that answer we have the history of Dover.
To make that history complete is more than we can attempt in the
time and space available, but some contribution to such a history may be
outlined. History is not a mere mathematical statement of facts and
dates. Behind the dates lie countless episodes of comedy and tragedy,
and a ceaseless struggle between the forces of good and evil. There is
a constant wrestling to achieve destiny, a story of varying success and
failure. The dates are merely the frame of the map, marked off to
show latitude and longitude.
COMMERCE
We have traced the vicissitudes of the iron business of Dover from
1750 to 1792, showing how John Jackson was sold out in 1753. and how
others took up the work. We have also alluded to family history, to
world events, and the Revolutionary War as it was related to Dover and
this locality. The prosperity of Dover does not depend upon its own
industry alone. We cannot consume all our own iron. Our industries
must find outside markets. And such markets are affected by tariff
laws, embargoes, wars, peaceful industries of other places, finance,
thrift and enterprise the world over.
The water in the guage of a steam boiler pulsates with an up and
down movement (when the guage is in working order), that reveals the
level of the unseen water in the boiler ; and Dover, with its industries in
iron, becomes a guage of world conditions, indicated by its smoke
stacks.
For example, in 1783, after peace was declared with England,
British ships thronged our harbors, bringing British goods. United
States commerce suffered. In 1793, the United States, as a neutral
nation had a great opportunity for trade at sea when England was at war
with the French Republic, No doubt Canfield and Losey. of Dover,
profited by this. From 1789 to 1807 there was an unparalleled growth
of American shipping and trade. Dover iron, doubtless, had a share in
this prosperity. In 1803, the United States was the great carrier of
the world's goods by sea. In 1805 Jefferson's Embargo stopped the
commercial prosperity of the United States. In 1810, when the embargo
was lifted, the foreign commerce of the United States became very great,
during the Napoleonic war. In the War of 1812-14, the blockade of
the United States coast caused great distress.
An extended essay might be written on this theme — The Prosperity
of Dover as affected by world conditions during the past two centuries.
See Kraft & Moriss's "Sea Power in American History."
31
TURNPIKES
1804 — The Union Turnpike was made from Morristown to Sparta,
1806 — The Washington Turnpike from Morristown to PhilHpsburg.
181 1 — The Newark and Morris Turnpike from South Orange to Mor-
ristown. These turnpikes had a great influence in developing the
resources of the country.
1812 — A branch of Union Turnpike from Dover to Ledgewood.
CIRCUIT-PREACHERS
1 801 — Methodist preachers tried to make an appointment to preach in
Dover, but were driven out by threats of a riot.
Early in this century circuit preaching was in vogue among
Quakers, Presbyterians and Methodists. People were engaged in
the struggle for a livelihood. Preachers had scattered parishes.
Meetings were held in barns and schoolhouses for want of a
regular church building, and at infrequent intervals. Phebe
Baker, at the age of ninety-nine, testified that the people attended
church in the old stone barn on the Chester road, and came gladly
to hear Mr. Sherman when the children brought word from
school that there would be preaching next Sunday.
1807 — Rev. Barnabas King was settled at Rockaway Presbyterian
Church, having for his parish Dover, Berkshire Valley, and
Sparta. Previous to this the church at Rockaway, although organ-
ized and partly finished, had services from time to time. People
from Dover would ride or walk to Rockaway to attend church or
religious meetings, the children walking barefoot to save their
shoes. Barnabas King was pastor for more than fifty years. Then
came Rev. Joseph F. Tuttle, D.D., author of the Centennial Col-
lections of Morris County.
1810 — Dover had ten to fifteen dwellings.
1812 — The War of 1812 grew out of embargoes on sea traffic. In
Dover By ram Pruden was probably the last veteran of that war.
1 816 — Rev. Barnabas King organized a Sunday school in Dover. Prayer
meetings were also held here. Although I have never seen a
prayer meeting mentioned in a school history, I take the liberty
of recording the fact that prayer meetings have long been held in
Dover, but they are not so largely attended as some other meet-
ings.
1816 — December. Petition of Iron Masters of Morris County sent to
Congress.
1817 — Blackwell & McFarlan of New York City took over the prop-
erty of Canfield & Losey in Dover, to settle accounts due. It
is said that there were scarcely twelve dwellings in Dover at that
time. The iron business had been depressed after the War of
1812.
1820 — There was a post office in McFarlan's office. Jacob Losey was
postmaster.
Fourth census of the United States,
32
In the nineteenth century historical events of vast proportions crowd
the stage of our national history, events intimately related to the develop-
ment of Dover and following each other in rapid succession so that one is
tempted to expand these brief "Dover Dates" into a bulky volume. But
this cannot lie. And it is needless. The work has already been done. Our
method stands revealed. Once get thoroughly interested in the history
of your home town, in its vital features, its larger interests, and the his-
tory of the State and the Nation — even of the world — takes on new
meaning. Looking out through the windows of these local facts and
dates, one feels more keenly the succession of remoter events through
their parallelism with our own story.
They say that hard times in Europe are driving some people to
study more earnestly than they ever did in their school days to find
out what has happened lately, why it happened, what it means, what is
going to happen next and what they are going to do about it. In such
a "preparedness" effort we cannot afford to be behindhand. A good
drive in United States history, with all its world-wide bearings, makes
a good setting-up exercise for us all. We need to find out what the
United States stands for, in world history, what the nations think we
stand for, what we ought to stand for. Our book mart is flooded with
books of real value and of fascinating interest on these themes. Ask
our free public library. And our new county library, when it comes.
Our educational institutions, in school and college, are presenting
such subjects with renewed emphasis and enthusiasm to those who are
still within scholastic halls. We need a generation trained and informed
as never before in statesmanship, for home and foreign service. The
liberty known within our borders for nearly a century and a half may
indeed have done something to "enlighten the world," and we may yet — •
to speak modestly — trim the lights so as to cast a brighter ray across
the waves.
1823 — A Fourth of July celebration was held on Morris street, a sort of
basket picnic in the woods, with speeches appropriate to the day,
and three odes expressive of the patriotic sentiment of that time
were sung. This we learn from an old program of the occasion,
1824 — The Morris Canal and Banking Company incorporated, Decem-
ber 31, 1824.
1825 — The Morris Canal was being dug through Dover, as noted in an
old letter. Completed to Newark in 1831. Fully completed 1836.
(Leased to Lehigh Valley R. R. 1871.)
Black well & McFarlan had a map made of Dover, showing all
shops and buildings belonging to the Dover Iron Works, and the
streets of Dover, as laid out by them in order to effect the sale
of building lots. The map was made by Van Winkle. See
Dover History, page 459. A real estate boom!
1826 — Black well & McFarlan had the village of Dover incorporated.
1827 — Town lots in Dover are sold. See McFarlan's Descriptions, page
460, Dover History, and advertisement, page 467, calling atten-
tion to the advantages of Dover from its location on the canal.
33
the turnpikes that pass through it, the Lehigh coal brought by
the canal, communication with the New York market, and that
"near lOO Forge fires is in operation within a few miles of the
village."
1828 — Wm. Ford's advertisement of this date shows his Blacksmithing
Business is in operation. He had a shop at Ford's Pond, and his
residence was near it, as usual in early times.
Zenas Pruden. the wheelwright, had his shop on the corner of
Dickerson and Morris streets, adjoining his residence.
Other items of the time can be gleaned from old advertisements
and scattered remarks of those who contributed to the Dover
History. A chapter might be written on the early stores of
Dover and vicinity, such as the Hoagland store at the site of the
Central Railroad Station, the Moses Hurd store on Morris street,
the Old Stone Store next to the National Union Bank, Felix
Hinchman's General Store, where Turner's is to-day, the Losey
Store and others. Consult the index of Dover History and the
list of additional references given with Dover Dates. The history
of commerce in Dover would require a volume.
From "The Jerseyman" of August 20th, 1828:
MEETING OF THE WATERS
A number of the inhabitants of Dover and its vicinity friendly to
the Morris Canal assembled on the i8th inst., at 4 o'clock P. M., to
witness the meeting of waters of Lake Hopatcong with those of the
Rockaway River. As soon as they were seen to mingle the following
toasts were drank, each being succeeded by the firing of cannon and
hearty cheers :
1st (toast). The memory of Jonathan Dickerson — who forty years
ago predicted that within one century there would be a canal formed
from the Delaware to the Passaic, supplied with water from Lake
Hopatcong.
Note : — The other toasts were not copied. — F. A. C.
1829 — Complaints about the educational shortcomings of the time led to
an Act of Legislature to establish schools and introduce much-
needed reforms. Too many of the haphazard teachers of ,the
country schools were addicted to intoxicating beverages, with sad
results in the schoolroom. A drunken teacher has been known
to "wale" a boy until the iron ferrule of his cane was embedded
in the flesh of the boy's back, as I have heard from one who saw
it. (The first law providing for public schools was in 1693.)
1829 — The Stone Academy on Dickerson street, opposite the old frame
building also known as "The Academy," was erected by Henry
McFarlan, Sr., for use as a school and partly for religious meet-
ings. The McFarlans took an active interest in the welfare of
the community. Under their regime we find constant traces of a
head and heart planning for the good of the people in their home
life as well as for the community as a whole. They were pioneers
34
in "communitv planning." For instance, not liking the shabby
appearance of 'the houses, Mr. McFarlan laid in a supply of paint
which he distributed to the inhabitants for the purpose of using
it on their houses, thus improving the appearance of the village..
Maple trees were set out along the street — the first trace of a
"Shade Tree Commission" — except that Jacob Losey set out a
row of willows where East Blackwell street is now. The last
one has just been cut down, near The Advance office.
1830 — The death of Henry McFarlan, Sr., occurred suddenly. He was
succeeded by his son Henry, who conducted the business until
1869. assisted by Mr. Guy M. Hinchman as superintendent.^ Mr.
McFarlan and Mr. Hinchman. on opposite sides of the main vil-
lage street, carried on a friendly rivalry in cultivating beautiful
gardens. An interest was taken in actually beautifying this town
of smoky iron mills and developing the spirit of love for the
"home town." The older inhabitants bear witness to this in their
reminiscences.
183 1 — The Morris Canal was completed to Newark. The first canal
boat. The Dover of Dover, made its maiden trip under the com-
mand of Captain Byram Pruden. The people gathered at the
Canal Basin and gave them a great "send-off." The Freight
House on the Basin became a busy center of new prosperity for
the town — it is now a neglected ruin. The railroad has changed
all that.
1832 — Mr. Thomas B. Segur came to Dover to be cashier of the Dover
Bank, which was established by Phelps, Dodge & Co., of New
York. He resided in the building since known as the Stone Hotel,
and the bank was in the same building. Barter was now assisted
by banking, another step in the progress of the village. Thomas
B. Segur left three sons: Elisha B., Anson, and Warren. The
latter was cashier of the Union Bank of Dover, which stood where
the Trust Company now is.
1834 — Dover has a bank, two academies, a Sunday school, thirty dwell-
ings, iron works, blacksmithing establishment, canal, the Alansion
House Hotel, new streets ; things are picking up. building lots
on the main streets are being taken up (see Dover History, pages
460-462), and the place begins to look more attractive. Business
and population begin to come to Dover instead of going to Ran-
dolph, Mill Brook, Mt. Pleasant, Mine Hill — owing to the canal,
and the McFarlans, and some other "town-builders." Next we
need a church of our own. What is a town without a church?
Why, they started a church the first thing in Newark ! Before
they started the town !
1835 — A]:)ril 23. The First Presbyterian Church of Dover was organ-
ized, under the Presbytery of Newark, with a membership of
seven men and thirteen women. Services were held in the Stone
Academy until 1842.
1836 — Dover population about 300. Sunday school has 150 scholars
35
and 28 teachers.
1837 — Business depression affected the country.
1838 — The First Methodist Episcopal Church was organized and a build-
ing dedicated in December. The Methodist Church at Mill Brook
was erected at the same time.
1839 — Rev. Burtis C. Megie became the stated supply of the Presby-
terian Church at a salary of $500, with donation visits.
1839 — We hear of a Dover Lyceum or literary society, at which poems
were read — a new departure for the iron town.
A poem by Dr. Jacob Lundy Brotherton, a Quaker, of Randolph,
celebrates the beauties and advantages of Dover.
Dover in 1839 had less than 400 population. The houses were
on the low land. The hills were covered with forests. A stage
coach arrived from Newark three times a week. There was a
stage to Morristown. No busses or street cars were known then
in New York City, the city limit of which was at Tenth street.
The First Presbyterian Church of Dover had 37 members.
The Sons of Temperance (S.of T.) was founded by Mr. Segur.
A library for them constitutes Dover's first public library. Dover
becomes the banner temperance town of New Jersey, and this
was one of the considerations that influenced Wm. Young (1847)
to leave Brooklyn with his family and set up his bake shop on
Dickerson street, corner of Sussex. It is worth while to have a
reputation as a banner temperance town if it induces a man like
Wm. Young to become a mem])er of the community. He became
a school trustee and a "leading citizen."
DOVER'S INVENTIVE GENIUS
1840 — Joshua H. Butterworth made patent locks in 1846. He was a
Scotchman and was headman for McFarlan. He invented rivet
machines. Fle owned the corner since known as the Baker
corner, at Blackwell and Warren streets, southeast. Here he
had his dwelling. About where Hummer's real estate office
now (1922) is, he had a little shop where he made clocks,
repaired watches and tinkered in his spare time and when the
iron works were inactive. His lot, bought in 1840. comprised
11,000 square feet.
Mr. Butterworth invented a shuttle for a sewing machine and
is said to have been the father of modern bank combination
locks. Mr. Canfield has two specimens of such locks made by
Butterworth, requiring five or six keys to operate them.
1842 — Presbyterian Church dedicated its first building.
1844 — There was great social unrest. The present State Constitution
was adopted, and needed reforms were made in regard to impris-
onment for debt and bankruptcy and the legal status of married
women.
36
1840-48 — Market day was an institution at Dover, wagons coming in
from the country with produce, and people gathering around them
to buy from the producer direct. — D. H., p. 384.
1846-47 — The Mexican War. Oregon acquired in 1846. California
ceded to the United States at the close of the Mexican War.
These acquisitions of territory, together with the acquisition of
Florida and Jefferson's purchase of the Louisiana territory, called
for a great migration to take up the new land — one reason why
more people did not come to Dover.
In "The Daily Advertiser" of Newark, 26 February, 1848, is a
letter describing the first temperance meeting held in Dover in 1833,
February 12, at which Rev. Dr. Tuttle gave an address. About that
time one store sold $2,000 worth of ardent spirits in one year.
"The Jerseyman" of March 2nd, 1848, quotes from "The Newark
Daily Advertiser" thus :
Dover, in 1833 had 133 families, 753 inhabitants.
1839 " 128 " 961
1845 " 210 " 1,201
(These figures differ from statements given in Dover History,
pages 417, 450, 478.)*
Monday, July 31, 1848, the Morris & Essex Railroad was formally
opened to Dover.
* In 1840 the school trustees of Dover reported 136 children
between the ages of five and sixteen. In 1853 there were 275 enrolled.
1848 — The Morris & Essex Railroad comes to Dover. The first train
offers a free ride to Morristown. A big time and a public dinner.
More facilities for transportation and business. Here is where
Dover forges ahead of Mill Brook.
1849 — Gold discovered in California. John W. Hurd and Sandy Young
go to California. (Hurd, the donor of Hurd Park, later.)
1849 — St. John's Episcopal Church is established under the charge of
Rev. Charles W. Rankin, of Morristown. Henry McFarlan was
appointed lay reader. He donated the property on which the
church stands, and was a liberal supporter of it. Their first
meetings were held in the upper room of the Stone Academy.
1850 — Dover claims 700 population. The names of many citizens may
be found on page 384, D. H. A railroad station is established
nearly opposite Wm. Young's bake shop and not far from Wm,
Ford's residence. Probably Wm. Ford found it necessary to
remove his machine shop to Sussex street on the lot that was
later occupied by the Morris County Machine Shop. He removed
his residence also. The railroad needed his Dickerson street
property.
The Quakers are advocating the Abolition of Slavery and past-
ing Whittier's poems into their scrapbooks at Randolph.
37
1856 — "The era lollowing the close of the War of 1812 until the open-
ing of the Civil War was one of stupendous activity. Interrupted
only by the financial depressions of 1817 and 1837, and slightly
retarded by the Mexican War, the progress of New Jersey was
beyond the wildest dreams of the enthusiast, Alexander Ham-
ilton. Jersey City, Newark and Paterson were growing great.
The public school system was established, reforms instituted in
the care of the defective, delinquent and dependent classes of
society, railroads and ferries built, banks established, post offices
opened and newspapers printed." — Legislative Manual of New
Jersey.
1861 — The Civil War. How the boys and girls of Mr. Hall's School
in Dover made and raised a school flag is told in D. H., page 387.
The Memorial Day services conducted every year in Dover under
the auspices of the Grand Army of the Republic bear witness to
the part that Dover took in that great struggle for the preserva-
tion of the Union and the Abolition of Slavery.
1869 — After the Civil War, business being dull, Mr. McFarlan closed up
the affairs of the Iron Works and suspended operations. Little
of consequence was done with these works until Mr. McFarlan
sold them in 1880 to The Dover Iron Company, organized by
Judge Francis S. Lathrop. This company repaired buildings,
made improvements, and revived the enterprise which means so
much for the prosperity of Dover. The High Bridge branch of
the Central Railroad of New Jersey was extended from Port
Oram to Dover and Rockaway in June, 1881, causing an increased
demand for labor. It is the Longwood Valley R. R. from Ger-
man Valley to Wharton.
1869 — A Town Charter was obtained for Dover, April i. See "Charter
of Dover" with by-laws and ordinances. George Richards,
Mayor.
1873 — The panic that followed the Civil War aflfected Dover.
Dover Fire Department organized.
38
"PUTTING DOVER ON THE MAP"
When did Dover first "get on the map ?"
In my "Ballads of New Jersey in the Revolution," there are two
old maps of the seventeenth century. One was made from a MS. map
of R. Eskine, F. R. S., used by the army in 1778-80. As shown by the
note below this map, Dover was not on it. Hibernia, Mt. Hope, Mt.
Pleasant Forge, Longwood Forge, "Backshire" Forge, Franklin Forge
and Benson's Forge were shown, but not Rockaway or Dover, although
iron works existed at both places previous to that date.
On the other old map, made when Philadelphia was the national
capital, previous to 1800. Rockaway and "Percipany" are shown, but not
Dover, It would be interesting to find a copy of the first map on which
Dover appears. Some of the things that have "put Dover on the map"
are referred to in the following rhymes, entitled "The Dover Primer."
There was once a "New England Primer," you know, that was quite
famous. It contained the following rhyme —
Z — "Zacche-us he, did climb a tree
His Lord to see."
1722— THE DOVER PRIMER— 1922
Of blessed memory is he
Who knows his Dover A, B, C.
A — Stands for AGE, and our DOVER, we hear,
Has really arrived at her two-hundredth year.
A— THE ADVANCE, whose two Editors seek
To give you the news of the town twice a week,
B— Is for BEMAN, who followed the lead
Of JACKSON in trying by iron to succeed,
B— Is for BLACKWELL, our Dover "Main Street,"
Where the great congregation of people doth meet.
B — Is for BIRCH and his Boiler workshop,
Where Stacks, too. are made, to go over the top.
C— Stands for CANFIELD, who built dam and mill.
With LOSEY as partner, to run things at will,
C— Is for CANFIELD and LOSEY ; 'bout then
"Old Tye" grew to DOVER, but who knows just when?
C — Stands for CHURCHES, and Dover has some;
If you want to hear more, to the Meeting House Come.
C — Is for CENTRAL, a branch that comes down
From High Brideje to gather up freight from our town.
D— Stands for DOVER ; D. D., DOVER DATES ;
Dover's found on the map of the United States.
D— Is for DRILL WORKS, whose trade, it appears,
Extends to the nations of two hemispheres.
E— Is EAST DOVER; a hero lived there.
Renowned for his voice, heard in battle or prayer.
E— Is EAST DOVER, and there they make FROGS—
The kind that were never long-tailed PoUiwogs,
F— Is for FIREMEN, who at the alarm
39
Fight the flames, risking danger to save folks from harm,
F — Stands for FORGE, and a Forge, it is said.
Was the cradle of Dover — we still "Forge Ahead !"
G — Stands for GEORGE ; George the First was our king
When Jackson's trip-hammer first made anvil ring.
G— Is for GUENTHER, whose Athletic Field
O'er lovers of sport fascination doth wield.
H— Is for HOSKINS, elected to steer
Our town through her great bi-centennial year.
H— Is for HOSPITAL, please lend a hand;
A place we all visit when Doctors command.
H— Is for KURD— and HURD PARK, near the spot
Where the Hurds of oldtime had their first building lot.
I — Stands for IRON, the magnetic kind.
That long from our neighboring hills has been mined.
I — Is the INDEX, in which may be found
News items from Dover and sections all 'round.
J — Stands for JACKSON, who first built a forge
On the brook that comes down from our picturesque gorge.
K— Stands for KATTERMAN'S Swiss Knitting Mill,
Where garments are made that will just fill the bill.
E — LACKAWANNA, whose many trains roll
Through Dover with passengers, milk, freight and coal.
L — Is for Lx\UNDRY, and Cook knows the way
To save you the trouble of Blue Washing Day.
L— Is for LIBRARY ; Dover is proud
To have one, sufficiently — not too — high-browed,
L — Is for LOSEY, first postmaster, he;
Far-famed as a host for his chef's cookery.
M — Means McFARLAN, a name that long stood
For progress, prosperity, thrift, "making good."
M— Is for MORRIS CANAL, in its day,
The hope of our village ; now railroads hold sway.
N — Stands for NEIGHBORS, and we have a few;
Millbrook, Wharton, Mine Hill, Mt. Fern fair to view.
O — Is for OVENS, and we make them here;
The RICHARDSON STOVE WORKS promulgate good cheer.
P— PICATINNY is not far away,
Where Dover folks work, and get very good pay.
Q — Is for QUAKER; the Quakers bore sway
Over all of New Jersey in WILLIAM PENN'S DAY.
R — Is for RANDOLPH, the township we're near,
Named after the Quaker Fitz Randolph, 'tis clear.
R— Is for ROLLING MILL; that's where we make
The toughest iron rivets, that bend, but don't break
S — Is for SILK, and we have quite a trade.
For Singleton spins silk where iron was made.
40
S— Is SILK STOCKINGS, that famed ONYX BRAND
That Guenther produces — the best in the land.
T— Is for TEMPERANCE; Dover's the town
That once had State Temperance Banner renown.
T— Is for TEACHERS, who do their full share
Each new generation for life to prepare.
U — Is for US; here we are; look us over
And see if you don't want to settle in Dover.
V_Is for VARIOUS City Departments :
Board of Health. Firemen. Streets, all in separate compartments.
W — Stands for our first President,
Who counted each forge, on munitions intent.
W— WATER WORKS ; Steffany told
How Water's provided for young and for old.
X — Always stands for some factor UNKNOWN,
Like the Future, that's hid till we make it our own.
Y — Stands for YOUNG, a shrewd Scot who once came
To Dover and helped us maintain our good name.
Y — Is for YOUTH ; may our Young People be
The Jewels of Dover, delightful to see.
Z — Is the end, and it may stand for ZEAL,
Which keeps towns from getting run down at the heel.
& — Now I must stop ; but I wish I could view
The DOVER of two-thousand-two-twenty-two.
P. S. — And many more rhymes may be made on this plan —
Bi-centennial notes that two centuries span.
To Conclude :
B— BENEDICTION : May God's Blessing crown
The DOVER that you and I call our Home Town!
PART II
Location and Environment
43
TWO OLD ROADS
In Book of Roads A at the County Clerks Office, Morristown, on
page 213, we find this record: ROADS IN MENDUM.
ROAD near BEEMAN'S FORGE in Mendham. Beginning at
the northwest corner of the schoolhouse near Israel Canfield's forge
that was formerly Josiah Beemans thence running (we abbreviate)
i) N 36 degrees, W 5 chanes 39 links
2) N 66
W 8
21
3) N 51
W 6
38
4) S 81
W14
64
5) N 76
W I
35
6) N 62
W 2
66
7) (no
figures)
8) (no
figures)
9) N 88
W 3
89
10) (no
figures)
II) N 62
W 3
50
12) N 22
West
to the middle of the bridge
ledeing over a smale streme nere Josiah hurds one chane and being a
three Rood Road. Dated "Mendham Town Ship, August 11, 1792.
Here we find a clear reference to Dover under the name of
"Beeman's Forge" in 1792, with the fact that it had now become Israel
Canfield's forge. The name "Dover" apparently came into use soon
after, instead of continuing the practice of using the owner's name.
Otherwise the place might have been known as "Canfields Forge,''
and then by some other name.
At the bottom of the same page we find a description of a "Road
near Beeman's Forge in Pequanack a three rod road, beginning at the
end of a bridge in Pequanack, crossing the Rockaway River by Josiah
Beeman's dwelling house." Dated August 11, 1792.
The second road mentioned above is described as follows :
i) N 8 degrees W 3 chaines 39 links
2) N 39
W 2
65
3) N 27
W 5
33
4) N 60
E 5
37
5) N 55
E 4
35
6) N 53
E 6
7) N 84
E 2
63
8) S 85
E 10
57
First Road.-
—Where was
that schoolhouse?
As the road
was on the south side of the river (being in Mendham), the school-
house was south of the river. A schoolhouse at the foot of Morris
street would give us a good start, from its northwest corner. McFarlan
located a school here later. Was there a school there from earlier
times — 1792 or sooner?
44
The map of 1825, Dover History, shows a roacl running from the
foot of Morris street northwest, on a diagonal hne, to the canal, then
being made. The canal lock made it necessary for any road headed
in this direction to be changed and brought over the Rockaway below
the lock, as shown in this map, where Sussex street is indicated as a
new street. But observe the direction of this diagonal road. Old
roads of that; time were not laid out in straight lines, crossing others
at right angles. They followed old Indian trails, in conformity with
the lay of the land and the winding of streams, aiming at the easiest
ford or crossing of streams. Such v/as this road, coming from Frank-
lin around the point of the mountain, keeping to the base of the moun-
tain south of it to avoid the river north of it, then spreading much
further than its present limits and making swampy ground.
This diagonal road, coming to the northern end of what is
now Warren street, led, on the north, to a bridge over the river, and
continued northward, in Pequanack township, to what is now Pequan-
nock street. The remains of a stone foundation for a bridge are still
shown at that place of crossing. And the river was once fordable
there. The road north of the bridge, in Pequanack, is the second
road mentioned on page 213 in Road Book A.
From the southern end of this bridge a road ran along the river
and south of it, westward, as described, to the ''smale streme nere
Josiah hurds." The canal "stole this roadway" as John W. Hurd
said, making a new road necessary, south of the canal, as we now have
it. But the cuts through rock and the grading down to lower lines came
later. Mr. Magie tells of the road running north of Jacob Losey's
house before Blackwell street was opened.
"Josiah Kurd's dwelling." — The Josiah Hurd of 1792 lived
where John W. Hurd lived when he gave the land for Hurd Park.
This property has recently been bought by M. Friedman, who now
lives there. There was another Josiah Hurd (junior) who lived on
the Phillips tract, west of the Pine Terrace Inn. That house was
removed a few years ago.
Dr. Magie says that an Indian village was located where the first
Hurd dwelling stands, doubtless taking advantage of the noted spring
of water in Hurd Park, and' the good fishing in brook and river.
Blackwell street was not made until about 1825- 1832, to supply
the place of the road that was crowded out by the canal.
The Second Road. — This was near Beeman's Forge in Pequannock
(north of the river), crossing the river by Josiah Beeman's dwelling
house. His house was a long, low dwelling north of the river. Just
north of the river and east of the road stood the Hoagland House.
The site of it was between the present municipal building and the
station of the Central Railroad. Perhaps the northwest corner of
municipal building impinges on the site. But I leave it for some
surveyor to plot the course of this second road.
45
TOWNSHIPS
Let us now elucidate the subject of townships, referred to above
as Mendham and Pequannock. In 1921 reports were rendered by
Frederick A. Canfield, representinj^^ Randolph Township ; James B.
Tonking, for Dover ; and John Yetter, for Rockaway Township ;
together with Theodore Ayres, neutral, from Morris ; Edward Howell,
civil engineer ; and Lawrence Day, counsel. This commission was
appointed to clear up vmcertainties existing in regard to boundaries
of Rockaway and Randolph townships and the town of Dover. The
original reports are in the Clerk's Office, Morristown, with maps and
full description, furnishing the following data.
Until 1739 Hunterdon County extended on the north to the Rock-
away River, Dover being in Hunterdon, which was taken from Burl-
ington in 1714. In 1739 Morris was taken from Hunterdon.
1740 Morris County consisted of three townships — Morris, Hanover
and Pequannock, to which Roxbury was added later in 1740.
1749 Mendham was formed from Hanover, Morris and Roxbury.
It included Dover's location, south of the river.
1804 Jefferson was formed from Roxbury and Pequannock.
1805 Randolph was formed from Mendham, and named in honor of
Hartshorne Fitz Randolph, who made his last will March 31,
1806. Randolph took in also parts of Dover north of the river.
183 1 Dover town (incorporated as a village in 1826) was formed in
Randolph township.
1869 Dover was incorporated, containing iioo acres, in Randolph.
1 87 1 Dover limits were enlarged.
1896 Dover was separated from Randolph township.
Note on Josiah Beeman's dwelling. This dwelling (1792) is
referred to as a landmark for the second road above. It was north
of the river. Another reference states that ''the beginning corner of
Schooley's Forge was about one chain from Josiah Beeman's house."
Where was Schooley's Forge? In 1768 Robert Schooley conveyed to
Joseph Jackson and his son Stephen of Mendham, Bloomer, one-
fourth of a property known as Schooley's Forge.
Did Robert Schooley acquire the forge property of John Jackson,
who was sold out in 1753 by sheriff? It was then in Mendham. I
find this statement about Schooley's Forge — "This was at Dover
(named so later) back of the house recently (1876) built by Alpheus
Beemer, on the south side of the road to Succasunna."
The Alpheus Beemer house referred to stood on or near the
site of the Pine Terrace Inn of later years.
It looks as if Beeman first resided in John Jackson's dwelling,
within one chain of Jackson's forge ; then Beeman sold the property
to Robert Schooley, who sold one fourth right in it in 1768. And
that Beeman afterwards removed his dwelling place to the north
side of the river, where his other forge and most of his land was,
this dwelling being in Pequannock near the bridge over the river,
as stated in the road book for 1792.
46
ENVIRONMENT
To give a complete account of Dover's environment would be a
long story. One would have to do justice to the scenery and the inhabi-
tants of Mt. Freedom. Center Grove, Randolph. Mt. Fern, Crane Town,
Millbrook, Union. Franklin. Shongum, Mt. Tabor. Denville. Rockaway,
Hibernia, Mt. Hope, Mt. Pleasant, Bowlbyville, Richard Mine, Thomas
Mine, Mine Hill, Kenvil. Succasunna, Ferromont, Berkshire Valley,
Wharton, Luxemburg, Hopatcong — perhaps Stanhope and Netcong and
a few others. Here is a good opportunity for historians of the future,
or for our school classes in composition to distinguish themselves. We
have touched on a few of these inviting topics in prose and verse.
FERROMONT, 1713
At Ferromont, Mine Hill, may be seen the old mansion of Governor
Mahlon Dickerson. Across the road from the house is the shaft of the
famous Dickerson Mine, which figured so conspicuously in the early
history of this region. The mine is now closed. At first the ore was
obtained from the open cut, to supply the forges near by, 171 3 — .
In the Dover Public Library fuller information may be found about
Governor Dickerson, whose career is summarized as follows :
Born, Hanover, N. J., April 17, 1770.
Graduated at Princeton College, 1789.
Admitted to the bar of New Jersey, 1793.
Commissioner of Bankruptcy, 1802.
Adjutant-General of Pennsylvania, 1805- 1808.
Removed to Morris County, N. J., 1810.
Member of New Jersey Assembly, 1812.
Justice of New Jersey Supreme Court, 1813.
Governor of New Jersey, i8i5--i8i7.
United States Senator, 1817-1833.
Declined appointment as IVIinister to Russia, 1834.
Secretary of the Navy, 1831-1838.
Judge of U. S. District Court for New Jersey.
Died at Succasunna, October 5, 1853.
Here, too, is the home of Frederick A. Canfield, with his notable
collection of New Jersey minerals and historical data.
THE FRIENDS' MEETING HOUSE IN RANDOLPH
The annual meeting of the trustees of the Friends' Meeting House
and Cemetery Association of Randolph Township was held at the meet-
ing house, near Dover, on Tuesday afternoon, June 2, 1914, at 3:30
o'clock. The present trustees of the association are Eugene A. Carrell,
of Morristown, who is also the president; Elias B. Mott, of Rockaway;
M. Wheeler Corwin, of Kenvil; Henry Alwood, of Succasunna; Charles
Brotherton, of Dover; William H. Baker, of Dover, who is treasurer;
and Fred Hance, of East Orange, who wias elected trustee and secretary
to fill the vacancy caused by the death of his father, Edward S. Hance,
47
who capably filled these offices of the association from its organization
on October 22, 1898, when it was formed for the purpose of preserving
the historic old building and to keep the cemetery grounds in order. The
following new members were admitted at this meeting : — Fred Hance,
of East Orange ; Dr. A. L. L. Baker and Airs. Ellen B. Baker, of Dover;
Mrs. Phoebe J. Corwin; Mrs. Laura C. Alwood, and Charlotte H.
Meeker, of Succasunna. and E. Bertram Mott, of Rockaway.
The following brief history, compiled by the late James W. Brother-
ton, will perhaps prove of interest to the public.
As early as 1740 several families of Friends, most of them from
Woodbridge Township, settled in Randolph (then Mendham) Township,
and meetings were held at their homes. Among these early settlers
were William Schooley, James Brotherton, Robert Schooley, Jacob
Laing, and Hartshorne Fitz Randolph, with their families.
In 1740 meetings for worship were being held on first days at the
home of William Schooley, a log house about three-quarters of a mile
east of the present meeting house.
On 8th Mo., 15th. 1758, one acre of land, the site of this house,
was deeded by Robert Schooley for four pounds of the current money
of the Province of New Jersey, to Jacob Laing and James Brotherton.
trustees, who are to hold the land in trust as a place to bury the dead of
the people called Quakers, "then residing in the vicinity, but members
of the monthly meeting at Woodbridge, N. J."
In 1758 the sum of seventy-three pounds was raised and the present
structure v/as built and a regular meeting was established, subordinate
to the Woodbridge Monthly Meeting. For many years meetings were
held regularly on the first and fifth days of the week at 11 A. M. In
pleasant weather the meeting house was on first days well filled both
above and below, people driving in or coming on horseback several miles
to attend. Richard Dell and others ministered acceptably to their spir-
itual needs.
During the years from 1820 to 1830 or thereabouts, many valued
members of this meeting, with their families, migrated to Western New
York State and settled there. This so depleted the home meeting that
it began rapidly to decline. Mid-week meetings were dropped and in
1864 meetings for worship, except by appointment, were discontinued
altogether.
About the year 1870. John Hance. Isaac Alwood Vail, and others
whose ancestors and relatives were buried in the graveyard, contributed
money to build a stone wall to enclose the grounds. The wall was relaid
and completed in 1880-1 by Isaac Alward. and an iron fence constructed
across the front by subscriptions raised by John Alwood Vail and John
Hance. A row of sheds at the rear of the meeting house formerly shel-
tered the horses in unpleasant weather, but this fell into decay and was
not rebuilt. By the will of Edward Dell $500 was left in trust, the
interest to be used in caring for the graveyard.
The year 1897 found the building and grounds sadly neglected.
James W. Brotherton and Rachel B. Vail, the only surviving meml^ers
48
residing.': in the vicinity, requested of the Rahway and Plainfield (form-
erly \\'oodbridge) Monthly Meeting, that the property belonging to the
Randolph Meeting be deeded to them, promising to provide for the care
and oversight thereof, that the property should be kept in suitable con-
dition for the purposes for which it was intended. On loth Mo., 14th,
1897, the trustees of Rahway and Plainfield Monthly Meeting deeded
the Randolph Meeting property for $1 to James W. Brotherton and
Rachel B. Vail under the above agreement.
On the 6th Mo., 28th, 1898, there convened a number of those
whose ancestors of years ago or relatives of more recent date had been
laid at rest in the old burying grounds. These interested persons, tak-
ing the necessary legal steps, formed themselves into an association to
"be known as The Friends' Meeting House and Cemetery Association of
Randolph Township. On October 22, 1898, James W. Brotherton and
Rachel B. Vail deeded the property for $1 to the aforesaid association,
which association agrees to carry out the promises made by them.
The members of the Friends' Meeting House and Cemetery Asso-
ciation of Randolph Township at this time were : President, James W.
Brotherton. Dover, N. J. ; secretary, Edward S. Hance, Wharton, N. J. ;
treasurer. William H. Baker, Dover, N. J. ; Eugene A. Carrell, Morris-
town, N. J.; Henry Alward, Succasunna, N. J.; Elias B. Mott, Rock-
away, N. J.— From "The Index," June 12, 1914.
THE QUAKERS
When John Jackson sold out his Dover property in 1753, it is said
that he went to the w'estern part of Virginia and started something there.
You will find a town named "Jackson" in Jackson County on the map of
West Virginia. He must have been then over fifty years old. His
property was sold in two portions. The forge and the land on which
his dwelling stood in Dover went to Josiah Beman, "Bloomer." A
bloomer was one who made rough blooms of iron at such a forge as
Jackson's. A bloom of iron is the rough ball or lump of iron obtained
by roasting the ore on a charcoal fire in the forge oven.
The extended farm lands which Jackson had acquired in 1722. situ-
ated now in Mine Hill, adjacent to Jackson's brook, were sold to a
Quaker named Hartshorne Fitz Randolph, who afterwards added to this
property until he had an estate of about 1,000 acres.
At this point, therefore, the history forks — one fork leading to the
continuance of the iron works in Dover and the other fork leading to
the Quakers of ]\Iine Hill, Randolph and Millbrook,
William Penn was one who early located large "returns" of land in
this region, taking up with the Kirkbrides some thousands of acres.
Leonard Elliott's house, once known as the Munson Homestead, was
in the Penn Return of 1715 (Dover History, page 473). Thus we see
that Dover touched the hem of William Penn's garment, so to speak.
The Richard Brotherton farm, it is said, was bought from William
Penn and has stayed in the family ever since. Richard Brotherton mar-
ried Mary Wilson, a great-great-granddaughter of the Robert and Ann
49
Wilson who came over from Yorkshire, England, 1683, in the same ship
with William Penn. In 1681-82, Lady Elizabeth Carteret sold the
Province of East Jersey to an Association of twelve persons, mostly of
the Society of Friends, among them being William Penn.
William Penn's object in taking up so much land appears^ have
been to provide a place of refuge for the Quakers who were persecuted
in the Old Country. He gathered them together and led them out of the
land of persecution into the wilderness of Pennsylvania and New Jersey
— a regular exodus into a new Promised Land. Randolph and Mill-
brook, then, were parts of this Promised Land in the New World.
Perhaps the f>fesent inhabitants have forgotten that fact. Some of the
country schools in the vicinity of Dover might get up excellent historical
programs based upon their interesting past and it would be a good lesson
in American history. Morris County is full of historical interest.
A volume might be written about the Quaker settlement, and much
about these Quakers may be found scattered through the pages of
Dover History. They were strong for the Abolition of Slavery. From
1800 on the Quakers were agitating in a peaceful way for the emancipa-
tion of the slaves, and felt it their duty to assist runaway slaves in their
escape to Canada. The "Underground Railway," as it was called, had
one station at Randolph.
Let me conclude this article with a brief sketch of Richard Brother-
ton, a typical saint of the Quaker faith. Although following the butcher's
trade, not now regarded as a suitable setting for a moving picture hero,
he ennobled his calling. The poet George Herbert says, in one of his
religious poems :
"Who sweeps a room as for Thy laws Makes that and the action fine."
It was in this spirit that Richard Brotherton followed his humble
calling and became a lighthouse on the hills of Morris County. In the
same spirit other men of those early days followed the necessary callings
of village baker, blacksmith, preacher, carpenter, farmer, wagon-maker,
ironmaster, and many of them — not all — shine as stars in the spiritual
firmament of these iron-bearing hills. In our Dover History studies we
are trying to "follow the gleam of that light."
RICHARD BROTHERTON
The story of Dover would not be complete
Without "Dicky Brotherton," "honest man" he.
The Quaker of Randolph, who sold the folks meat
And won wide renown for unfeigned piety.
With wagon well stored he would ride far and wide
O'er these rough roads and hills to each customer's door
Have a chat, leave a "roast" — Morris County beef — I'd
Like to meet him to-day on his rounds, as he bore
Choice viands to Dover, Mine Hill and Millbrook.
The widow and orphan he never forsook ;
But gladdened the desolate when he drew near
With kind words and solid, substantial "good cheer."
50
"A dear, good old man," well belov'd ; true respect
He won in his day — he was surely "elect."
Just a butcher, of course, but he made his trade fine
By the honest, kind-hearted and neighborly grace
That illumined his deeds and his speech and his face.
In the quaint Quaker meetings out there on the hill
He presided for years — just a slim "two or three"
Attended, at last — everything was so still !
The men sat on one side and lest they should see
The women, a board fence was let down between,
Long silence — more silence — no music — no hymn —
No remarks — meditation — no tableau — no scene!
Just plain Dicky Brotherton sitting up there
With his plain Quaker coat and his Quaker broad brim,
Till at last this brief word breathes upon the still air —
"We must do the right!" — a tap-tap on the floor
With his patriarch staff and the meeting is o'er.
Those Quakers stuck to it when slavery tried
To rule this fair land, when it fain would enthrone
Its power o'er our future : Let no man deride
The faith of the Quakers. They could not condone
This blot on our scutcheon ; they clung to this plank —
"God made man for freedom; no slave chains must clank
In this great land of ours — Do the right ! Do the right !
Heed the still voice of conscience, the true inner light!"
Out here on these hills, where God's free breezes blew,
Came Whittier's voice to a conscience refined
By the breath of God's spirit — the message rang true.
It rang through the nation at last, unconfined —
"Do the right ! Do the right ! We must do — we must do —
We must do the right !" — and the faint whisper grew
Till in bloody encounter and death-toll this land.
This fair land of freedom at last took its stand.
Led by Abraham Lincoln ! Now all men are free
Who are born 'neath our banner, from mountain to sea !
5»
DOVER'S MOTHER CHURCH
The history of religion in Dover is not complete without some
account of the Mother Church at Rockaway. Rev. Barnabas King came
from New England in 1805, according to Dr. Megie's statement. He
began preaching at Berkshire Valley. Did the name "Berkshire" come
with him from the Berkshire Hills of Connecticut? He was installed
pastor at Rockaway in 1808, and died in 1862. in the fifty-fifth year of
his pastorate, as noted on his tombstone in Rockaway. He was a gradu-
ate of Williams College, 1803, in the Berkshire Hills of Massachusetts.
Rev. Joseph S. Tuttle, D.D., in an historical sermon, speaks of him-
self as the colleague of Barnabas King from 1847 to 1862. Dr. Tuttle
afterward became president of Wabash College, Indiana; but l^efore
going West he wrote many historical articles about Morris county. To
him we are indebted for the information that George Bowlsby deeded
land in Parsippany to "the religious society of people commonly called
Presbyterians." This was in 1745. And he dates the birthday of the
old church at Rockaway on the second of March, 1758, for then the first
subscription paper was starte dthus: "We, the subscribers to do by
these mannefest It to l>e our desier to Joyn (pronounced 'ji'.ie') with
pasipaney to call and settel a minnester to have the one half of the
preachen at posipaney and the other half at rockaway and each part to
be eakwel to payen the minnester."
A second memorandum states that the "inhabitenc of rockaway
pigenhil and other places agesant" (adjacent) met and agreed upon a
"suitable place above bemans forg, below the first small brok upon that
rode up to Samuel Johnson."
Dr. Tuttle explains that the congregation was gathered from the
then sparsely settled region which included Denville. Rockaway Valley,
Horse Pound. Meriden (a school district). Mount Hope, Denmark,
Berkshire Valley. Franklin, Dover (not then known by that name, prob-
ably) and the region beyond.
This first "meting hous" was raised in 1759, and partly enclosed.
Glass, paint and floor boards were bought the next year to finish the
house. The founders were assessed to "pay a prespetering minister.'*
The building was not ceiled nor plastered. The people did not wait for
their church to be finished and "all decorated up" before they used it.
It was said to be ghastly in its incompleteness. In 1780 it was voted "to
make a Ladder to go up Galeryes and Lay Down boards on the galery
Beams and make seates to set on." And yet nothing was done until
1794. We must remember the distractions and sickness of the Revolu-
tionary War.
This building continued in use until 1832. In Rockaway they have
a pen sketch of this old building, a contemporary of our old Quaker
Church and very much like it in design. In 1831 a new building was
started, and this was dedicated in 1832. By this time there were enough
people in Dover to think it worth while to organize and form a Dover
church, instead of subscribing longer to a Rockaway church. So we
find in the records of Rev. Barnabas King that eighteen members were
52
dismissed in 1835 to form a Dover church. And we find in the Dover
records that the Dover church began its life April 23, 1835, with a mem-
bership of seven men and seventeen women, whose names are given in
Dover History, page 415.
Let us conclude this brief sketch with two short ballads, which take
us back, in spirit, to Dover's Mother Church of 17S8-1832,
I. AUNT ABIGAIL'S MEETING
Aunt Abigail Jackson was very devout.
And this is the story that comes down about
This old-fashioned saint — 'tis an anecdote quaint,
Well attested, it seems, without mythical taint.
The Rockaway folks — seventeen htty-nine —
Decided to ask all their neighbors to "Joy"" (j'^ie)
And set up a Meeting House handy for all,
Above Beman's Forge, near a brook that was small.
They called the inhabitants of Rockaway,
Pigeon Hill, Horse Pound, Meriden, Denmark, they say,
Franklin, Dover and Berkshire and further away.
To meet and consult on a place that would suit.
Where a new Meeting House would be sure to take root.
It soon was agreed, so with zeal they began
To lay the foundations and work out the plan.
So eager they were the first meetings to hold
They began with loose boards laid on beams, we are told.
But interest waned, and soon meetings were few,
Till one faithful soul started things up anew :
Aunt Abigail Jackson was so filled with zeal
That she held a grand meeting which made its appeal.
What though floors were lacking, no parson in sight,
Though side walls and ceiling were in sorry plight,
She just sat on a beam and sang hymns; she could sing
Like a bird ; but no bell was yet ready to ring
And no organ led oflf. When the neighbors inquired,
"Who all was at meeting?" Aunt Abbie said, "Three —
The Father, the Son, and the Holy Ghost — me;
That makes four ! — a good meeting as could be desired !"
More came the next time; so folks, in that day.
On the beams held their meetings in old Rockaway.
53
II. GENERAL WINDS OF ROCKAWAY
1776-7
O, have you heard the General pray,
Brave General Winds of Rockaway,
In the deacons' meetings that they hold.
Where patriots meet, both true and bold?
'Twas there I heard him, many a day,
Brave General Winds of Rockaway !
In the old, unplastered church they met;
No parson was there the text to set:
But when the General once began,
Loud waxed the voice of that valiant man.
Oh, yes, I've heard him many a day.
Brave General Winds of Rockaway!
In thunder tones he prayed the Lord
And fervently His name implored
To break the oppressor's yoke and free
This land — the home of liberty.
The people loved to hear him pray.
Brave General Winds of Rockaway !
And when at Chatham Bridge he stood
And faced the foe, they thought it good
To take a hint that the General dropped.
So they took to their heels and never stopped;
For he could fight as well as pray,
Brave General Winds of Rockaway !
The first Sunday school in Morris county was started in 181 5 by
Mrs. Joseph Jackson (Electa Beach, the Colonel's second wife), who
gathered the children together in the old red schoolhouse near the
church. Before this date she and Mrs. James Jackson had instructed the
children in their own homes.
For several years the Mother Church was racked by the music
question. Should the hymns be "lined out" or sung without such pre-
liminaries? The old-style precentor, David Beman, led the party that
stood by the old custom. Young Benjamin Jackson led the younger ele-
ment of progressives. A compromise was tried, by which one party
should have charge of the morning service and the other party have
the afternoon service. Finally, after a long "unpleasantness," the
progressives won a permanent victory in 1792, due, perhaps, to the high
repute of Benjamin Jackson as a singer. There was no Caruso in those
days, but one who could lead the singing in meeting as wonderfully as
Benjamin Jackson could do it enjoyed an equally enviable renown in
these parts.
54
THE METHODIST CHURCH AT MILLBROOK
NOTE : — In a former article we spoke of the Presbyterian Mother
Church of Dover. Since then Mr. Alonzo B. Searing has furnished me
with his excellent narrative of the Methodist Mother Church of Dover.
This was published sixteen years ago. I give it here in somewhat con-
densed form, but mostly in Mr. Searing's own words. Mr. Searing has
done a fine piece of historical work. The story of these self-reliant and
godly people who maintained the influences of the Gospel among these
picturesque, sequestered hills is worthy of record. It is a part of
Dover's moral environment. This Mother Church now desires to build
^as a favorite with Mr. Kenstler,
and I recall a concert given in the old Presbyterian Church at which he
rendered several solos to my accompaniment at the piano. Other partici-
pants at this concert were Miss Abbie Condict, a lady much admired,
both for her personal charm and her ability as a reader, and Miss Bertha
Gage, later Mrs. Dr. Flagge.
Miss Gage was accomplished both in vocal and instrumental music,
and the Dover schools, for many years, profited through the exercise of
her talents.
Dover, in those days, was visited periodically by some eminent musi-
cians who taught and gave musicales. Among them was a Prof. Watson,
an accomplished violinist, a long time friend. I believe, of Mr. Horace
Dunham, a well-known Doverite and a connoisseur in that line.
I also met a visitor at that time, Mr. A. N. Johnson, the author of
a well known text-book on harmony.
The occurrences of those years and the succeeding decades give evi-
dence that Dover has kept pace with other communities, and to-day finds
the citizens with an adequate equipment of church organs, auditoriums,
and musical talent capable of worthily using these facilities.
Three-part and four-part singing was a common occurrence in the
Dover school during those eventful years, and while there are doubtless
many residing in Dover at the present time who could testify to the
accuracy of that which is herein recorded, I recall the names of two
well-known citizens, whom Dover still delights to honor. Alderman Etta
C. Searing, and Mr. William Otto, cashier of the National Union Bank,
both of whom laid the foundation of their future usefulness, as did
many others, in those "unforgotten days."
Edward M. Young.
THIRTY YEARS' GROWTH AND PROGRESS OF THE
DOVER SCHOOLS
1892 — 1922
In September, 1891, I began my administration as Supervising
Principal of the Dover Schools. During the preceding four years there
had been three dififerent principals and the schools were in a rather
chaotic condition. The Board of Education at that time was composed
of five members: Capt. Sedgewick R. Bennett. President; Rev. Fred
Bloom, District Clerk ; and Messrs. Isaac W. Searing, Martin V. B.
Searing and Russell S. Penniman.
At the annual election the following spring there were three vacan-
cies to fill, caused by the expiration of the terms of Mr. Isaac Searing
and Mr. Penniman and by the resignation of Mr. Bloom. These three
vacancies were filled by the election of Messrs. Fred H. Beach, Edwin
138
J. Ross and Henry W. Crabbe. The Board then organized with Mr.
Beach as President and Mr. Crabbe as District Clerk. This organization
remained until the Township Law went into effect and the Board was
increased to nine members. The Board has continuously consisted of
nine members since that time with the exception of two years, during
which Dover was under city government, when four members, one
elected from each ward, constituted the City Board of Education.
When I took charge of the schools there were fourteen teachers —
ten in the old North Side Building, two on the first floor of Odd Fel-
lows Hall and two in a private house on Pequannock street. The
South Side School was then under construction. It was occupied the
following spring — April, 1892 — with Mr. Albert J. Titman as principal
teacher. The annexes were then abandoned, two additional teachers
engaged and six rooms opened in the new school. This enlarged faculty
of sixteen teachers in 1892 appears surprisingly small when compared
with the present corps of 65 day school teachers in the Dover schools.
When the schools re-opened in September, 1893, all eight rooms of
the South Side School were occupied, and two years later rented annexes
were again resorted to. The number of teachers in annexes grew until
before the opening of the East Side School in 1901 there were eight
teachers with their classes thus housed — six in the old Iron Era building
at the foot of Morris street and two in what had been a blacksmith shop
on Pequannock street. The more recent school constructions in Dover
have been the erection of the new North Side Building in 1908, with
more than double the capacity of the old North Side Building, and the
new High School in 1918.
During the school year ending in June, 1892, the statistics of enroll-
ment and attendance were as follows :
Total Enrollment 945
Average Attendance 595
Percentage of Attendance 89.8
Pupils Present Every Day 23
Tardy Marks 820
In 1901 the following growth and improvement may be noted:
Total Enrollment 1,311
Average Attendance 997
Percentage of Attendance 93.7
Pupils Present Every Day 116
Tardy Marks 400
For the year 1921-22 the statistics are as follows:
Total Enrollment 2,283
Average Attendance 1,906
Percentage of Attendance 93-3*
Pupils Present Every Day 167
Tardy Marks 908
139
* The former method of estimating percentage of attendance would
make this percentage considerably higher.
When I took charge of the Dover schools there were a number of
studies being carried on of a more advanced character than those belong-
ing to elementary grades. These, with some additional subjects, were
promptly arranged into a two-year English high school course. This
course was approved by Dr. J. M. Green, Principal of the Trenton State
Normal School, which allowed the graduates to enter that institution
without further examination.
Two years later — 1893 — an optional three-year high school course
was arranged, which included all of the shorter course with the addition
of three years of Latin. The first class to complete this advanced course
was graduated in June, 1896. At the time of its graduation this class
was composed of six girls, who were graduated with eleven others who
had completed the shorter or two-year course.
The six young women who were the first graduates from the three-
year course were Bessie Coe, America Davis, Augusta Howell, Bertha
Richards, Grace Richards and Jennie Sayre. They were not only excel-
lent students, as their choice of the advanced course would indicate, but
they were all both present and early every day during their entire Senior
Year. This is the only class that I have ever known to be absolutely
perfect in attendance as a class during an entire year.
In 1898 the high school courses were rearranged and enlarged. The
optional two-year and three-year courses were extended to those of
three years and four years. The first class taking the four-year course
was graduated in June, 1901, together with fourteen students of the
shorter or three-year course. At the time of its graduation this first
four-year high school class was composed of six students, as follows:
Robert C. Baker, Belle Champion, C. Raymond Hulsart, Raymond C.
Matthews, Marion Richards and Luella B. Sands. The three-year course
was later abandoned and for graduation from the Dover High School the
completion of a full four-year high school course was required of all
students.
Manual Training, Domestic Science, Physical Training and Modern
Health Instruction have been more recent additions to curricula of the
Dover schools. In comparison with the various curricula now offered
to its students by the Dover High School our modest two-year course of
thirty years ago appears meager indeed.
The foregoing sets forth briefly the growth and development of the
Dover schools during the past thirty years. What may we expect in the
line of educational development during the thirty years to come?
J. Howard Hulsart.
Superintendent of Schools in Morris County.
140
DOVER SCHOOLS IN 19.22
Roswell S. Bovv'lby
The schools are directed by a Board of Education of nine members
elected by the people, and administered by a staff consisting of a super-
intendent, four principals, and sixty-one teachers. There are four
schools, McFarlan street, with an enrollment of 798; Academy street,
373 ; Belmont avenue. 478 ; and Myrtle avenue. 634 ; making a total
enrollment of 2.2S3 pupils. Work as far as the Fifth and Sixth Grades
is carried on in the Academy street and Belmont avenue schools respect-
ively. All Seventh Grade work is done on the departmental plan in the
McFarlan street school. The Eighth Grade, also on the departmental
plan, and all High School classes are housed in the Myrtle avenue build-
ing. This is knov/n as the High School building and is a fine structure
of which Dover may justly be proud. It is fireproof and modern, being
splendidly adapted to meet the needs of the communit}^ as vv^ell as of the
High School. It contains chemistry and physics laboratories, manual
training shops, cooking and sewing rooms, a large gymnasium and an
attractive auditorium. Many concerts and civic meetings are held here.
Dover is one of the very few towns in the State which have half-
yearly promotions. This form of organization v/as introduced years ago
by Dr. J. Howard Hulsart. Pupils who fail in the work of any particu-
lar grade are required to repeat the work of one-half year instead of one
full year. It is possil:)le for the bright pupils to skip a half-year's work,
when they might find it extremely difficult to skip a full year's work.
Two forms of classroom procedure much stressed by educators in
recent years are the socialized recitation and the project method. These
were introduced by former superintendent W. V. Singer. They are
widely used in our schools to-day.
Nearly all of the elementary teachers are graduates of an approved
Normal School and many of the high school teachers hold college degrees.
The work of the High School is approved by the State Department and
its graduates are able to enter most colleges without entrance examina-
tions. Both boys and girls have entered some of the colleges of highest
standing, where, with few exceptions, they have done very creditable
work. Many have reached high places in business and professions.
The High School has made an excellent record in almost every
kind of activity that is found in a modern school. In debating it has
won several championships. In athletics, its best records were made in
football and baseball. It has numbered among its defeated opponents
some of the largest high schools in the State. Many excellent plays and
operettas have been presented and several ])rizes have been won in
literary competition.
Besides the day school, there are two other types of schools — eve-
ning and continuation. The former runs during the winter and its chief
feature is the work of teaching English to foreigners. The continua-
tion school was established two years ago for all boys and girls between
the ages of 14 and 16 who have regular employment. They are required
to attend school six hours each week. The enrollment is about 100.
141
Under Dr. Emma C. Clark, the medical inspection of the schools
has become very efficient. A full-time nurse is employed. Miss Lucy
D. Coe, the attendance officer, maintains a high standard of attendance,
the percentage this year being 93.35. The emphasis by Dr. Hulsart upon
punctuality and attendance created a community attitude v/hich still
persists.
One of the outstanding features of present-day school interest is
the Home and School Association movement. Several years ago, under
Mr. Singer's regime, an association was organized in each school. These
have grown in size and importance and have proved to be very helpful.
The forms of service which these associations are rendering are num-
erous. Clothing, shoes, and surgical operations for some of the unfor-
tunate ones have been provided. Playground equipment, Christmas
parties, and hot cocoa at lunch time are some of the things which are
making the modern school pleasanter and more healthful. But perhaps
the greatest benefits come from the closer relations between teachers
and parents. Visits to the schools are more frequent and parents and
teachers are helped to appreciate each other's problems and difficulties.
This tends to produce sympathetic co-operation and results in more
effective school v^-ork.
Members — Board of Education —
Emil G. Kattermann, President
William Otto, Vice-President
Coleridge H. Benedict, Secretary
William L. R. Lynd
Arthur W. Condict
Plenry Heiman
Estelle E. Totten
Lena Dott Allen
John D. B. Vreeland
Superintendent of Schools —
Roswell S. Bowlby
Officers — Home and School Associations —
Academy Street School —
Mrs. Chas. E. Powers, President
j\Irs. W'illiam Herridge, Vice-President
Mrs. Harry Mulroy, Vice-President
Mrs. Eskel Danielson, Vice-President
Mrs. Benj. Cleve, Vice-President
Mrs. John Byram, Secretary
Mrs. Arthur Longcor, Treasurer
Belmont Avenue School —
Mrs. W. A. Sellers, President
Mrs. R. Bruland, Vice-President
Mrs. Chas. ALacEall, Vice-President
Mrs. Wilson Davis, Vice-President
142
Mrs. Henry Wills, Vice-President
Mrs. Edward Jensen, Secretary
Mrs. Edward Northey, Treasurer
Central —
Mr. Harry Armitage, President
Mrs. Max Heller, Vice-President
Mrs. Lawrence K. Diffenderfer, Vice-President
Mrs. James T. Lowe, Vice-President
Miss Minerva Freeman, Vice-President
Mrs. R. F. Woodhull, Secretary
Mr. Seth H. Ely, Treasurer
McFarlan Street —
Mrs. Richard Washburn, President
Mrs. Edw. Ackerman, Hon. President
Mrs. Clarence Hance, Vice-President
Mrs. Clarence Petty, Vice-President
Mrs. R. Liftman, Vice-President
Mrs. Allen J. Hahn, Vice-President
Mrs. C. H. Williston, Vice-President
Mrs. J. H. Tillyer, Vice-President
Mrs. John Cook, Jr., Vice-President
Mrs. Walter E. Howe, Secretary
Mrs. John Drake, Treasurer
PRESIDENTS OF THE DOVER BOARD OF EDUCATION
1909 — 1922
J. Willard Farrow, M.D., 1909-1915
Coleridge H. Benedict, 1915-1917
Arthur W. Condict, M.D., 1917-1921
Emil G. Kattermann, 1921-
DOVER HIGH
Air : Sweet Genevieve
O Dover High, dear Dover High !
We come to thee from far and nigh ;
Mt. Freedom, Wharton, Mine Hill vie
To fill thy halls, dear Dover High !
O Dover High, dear Dover High!
Thy lads and lassies charm the eye ;
But when their genius burns — O my !
The sun's eclipsed by Dover High!
O Dover High, dear Dover High !
We love thee as the years go by.
And when we come to say goodbye !
We love thee more, dear Dover High !
143
ELKS' PRIZE ESSAYS
DOVER STUDENTS TELL WHAT FLAG MEANS TO THEM
To stimulate patriotism and encourage greater interest in Flag Day-
each year, Dover Lodge of Elks has awarded prizes to two D. H. S.
students in an essay contest open to all high schools, within the juris-
diction of the local lodge, including schools at Newton, Hackettstown,
Wharton, Rockaway, Roxbury Township and Franklin. All of the
essays were gathered from the three counties participating, Warren,
Sussex and Morris, and carefully inspected by competent judges, result-
ing in Miss Ruth Meyer being awarded first prize of $15, and Stewart
Hunter second prize, $10.
Members of the Elks' Committee in charge of the essay contest
were W. V. Singer, J. J. Vreeland and Andrew M. Ryan. A final
report will be made at special Flag Day services in the lodge room.
WHAT THE FLAG MEANS TO ME
By Ruth Meyer, Dover High School, Class of 1922
"Have you ever stopped to consider what the American flag really
means? Most Americans regard it merely as their flag, to be saluted,
respected and loved. But the flag is more ; to me it enfolds volumes of
history, a depth of meaning.
"The American flag is symbolic of the greatest country on earth,
of the most democratic population existing and of the most sacred prin-
ciples of mankind.
"When first the American flag was unfurled, the birth of the nation
was proclaimed ; a new nation, a land of forests and fields, undeveloped,
unprogressed, in its infancy. Since then, at each step in its progress, at
each great development, the flag became more significant. At each war,
when the flag was floated, it proclaimed that the American people were
joined into one in every battle; it meant that this country was lined up
against its enemies, behind that flag, united powerful and determined.
"The flag has always meant a great deal to the people of America,
but to the coming generation its greatest meaning was revealed during
the World War. We lived while that great historic conflict was raging.
History was being made by us, by our generation. To me, at that time,
the American flag attained its greatest glory and its meaning was por-
trayed in its fullest sense. First, just before our entrance into the war,
when international law was being ignored, when our neutrality was
being disregarded, when our ships were threatened with destruction and
the threats were being carried out by an aggressive and militaristic
nation, our flag was being disrespected, and therefore our honor as a
nation. Would America tolerate such a condition? Indeed not, but in
defense of that flag and that honor, America's name was added to those
already lined up against autocracy. Immediately, every dollar, every
industry, every conceivable resource was set to work to be utilized in
144
the great cause; every person gave willingly of his time, his money and
his energy. For it is agreed l)y everyone that either victory or defeat,
either restoration or destruction, either freedom or despotism, depended
upon whether or not America entered the war.
"While our money was rendering priceless aid to our comrades, our
army was being trained and all the machinery of war being prepared.
At the end of nearly a year, our boys were sent three thousand miles
across the ocean, to an unknown land, to horror, to suffering and to
death to defend that flag. That is what it meant to me and to every
American in the land. When our soldiers arrived and the American
flag was planted on French soil, signifying that American soldiers
were in the battlefield, it meant victory to us and our friends and
defeat to our enemies. Of course, this was not accomplished all
at once, but from the time the American flag and all that was there
to back it appeared on the scene, the tables were turned.
"With the aid and leadership of our well-equipped army, with their
unequalled perseverance and grit that all the world admired, yards were
gained, and miles, the enemy was forced back and victory was achieved.
The nations of the world looked up to our flag with prayerful thanks
for its great and human work. The flag, and all that it meant, was
proclaimed anew, more glorious, powerful, inspiring and everlasting
than ever before. For that flag, our gallant youth, the flowers of the
great garden of America, were given. For that flag, they left their
homes, their happiness and their loved ones and went to answer their
country's call, the call of the flag. And for that flag, they fought,
they suffered and they died. America will never forget the tribute paid
by this incalculable loss. It will ever remain a memory, and a glorious
one, in the hearts and minds of humanity.
"To-day, perhaps in the busy whirl of commerce, in the hustle and
rush of our daily tasks, we Americans do not think of the value of this
flag, but lest we forget, let us turn our eyes for a moment towards the
thousands and thousands of little iron crosses in the cemeteries of both
Flanders and America — mute testimony of the tribute paid for that flag.
This is the most sacred meaning of the American flag to me.
"The country behind that flag is to-day the greatest nation on this
earth — in riches, yes, but more important and by all means more worthy,
she is the moral leader of the world. That, in my mind, is America's
most commendable achievement and in that leadership lies the true basis
of her magnanimity and that of her emblem.
"All this is what the flag means to me, and in concluding, may that
flag, representative of our country, ever be loved and reverenced by
mankind, may it be a glorious monument of freedom, protection and
justice, in the eyes of all nations, all people, throughout all the ages."
PART IV
Banks, Newspapers, P^eal Estate
Churches and Cemeteries
I 147
THE NATIONAL UNION BANK, DOVERi, N. J.
By James B. Tonking
On the ninth day of March, 1871, George Richards made an
application to the U. S. Banking Department at Washington, D. C, to
open a National Bank at Dover, N. J. This was made through U. S.
Senator F. F. Frelinghuysen. After considerable correspondence,
which took up some time, the matter progressed to the point where,
on October 17. 1872, the necessary pa])ers were received from Wash-
ington to be executed for organization and, on November 21, 1872,
permission was received from the Comptroller to organize with a
capital of $150,000.
On December 19, 1872, the first meeting of the Stockholders was
held and the following Directors were elected. Columbus Beach,.
George Richards, I. B. Jollcy, Isaac W, Searing, Ephraim Lindsley,.
Jas. H. Neighbour, Hudson Hoagland, Albert R. Riggs, Alpheus Bee-
mer, Richard (Jeorge, John W. Jackson. The newly elected Directors,
then selected Columbus Beach as the first President of the National
Union Bank of Dover, N. J. On December 26, 1872, the Comptroller's;
approval of the organization was received. On December 27, 1872,.
Jay S. Treat of Newark, N. J., was elected as the first cashier.
The Bank I'uilding is located at 7 and 9 West Blackwell street,.
Dover, N. J., in the heart of the business section of the town of Dover
and is conveniently located to care for the interests of a large sur-
rounding territory, including the iron mines, arsenals, furnaces, mills,
and factories, not/ only of the home town, but of adjacent towns of
Wharton, Mt. Hope, Succasunna, Kenvil, Chester and other places
having large industrial plants, probably representing, all told, a popula-
tion of 30,000 people. On January 15, 1873, this building was secured
from the Segur Banking interests and possession was given February
IS, 1873.
While the bank was authorized to start with a capital of $150,000,
the same has been changed from time to time to meet the new condi-
tions which presented themselves. On June 28th, 1892, it was voted to
make the capital stock $125000, which has obtained up to the present
time. The present capital stock has behind it $250,000 surplus, besides
about $60,000 undivided profits.
Tlie growth of the bank has been steady and, on referring to
records, we find that, April 15th, 1878, the deposits were $97,599.20
and, on May 11, 1922, $4,041,004.13.
During the year 1907 it was found that facilities for carrying
on the business were inadequate, and plans were commenced for a
complete remodeling of the inside of the bank building. In the years
1908-9, the rooms on the third floor and officer on the second floor
were renewed and brou.ght up to modern practice ; the main banking
room was made up-to-date with laminated steel vault, circular door,
safe deposit boxes and outside cover of 15-inch concrete walls around
the entire vault.
148
It can with confidence be stated that no better facihties for the
transaction of business can be afforded the people of this section of
our County and State, the bank being prepared at all time's to negoti-
ate the purchase or sale of marketable securities, such as Government,
Railroad or Municipal Bonds, to collect foreign or domestic bills,
■drafts, or letters of credit, and to transact such business for the
accommodation of the public as any well managed institution of this
character can undertake.
It is a well recognized fact that this bank from its inception has
been conservatively managed ; in fact, some of its best friends claim
for it that it is ultra conservative and, for a Banking Institution,
this is one of the best things that can be said of it, as depositors and
all people doing business with a bank are interested in having it safe-
guarded and protected to the limit. Courtesy to its clients and careful
attention to every business transaction for them is the aim of the
'directors, officers and employees.
The selection of employees of this bank is largely made from
X)over High School graduates and our local business college. Only
those of good family and with best recommendation froiu teachers and
principal are considered. These young men are carefully trained in
the work and, with proper initiative on their part, should be fitted to
fill at a later date high official positions as bankers at home and abroad,
if called.
It is with pride that the bank refers to the list of splendid, sub-
stantial men who have served on this Board of Directors and whose
services continued up to the close of their lives, except a few who, for
business reasons, decided to sever their connection, owing to removal
from this vicinity and press of their private business : Columbus
Beach, George Richards, Isaac B. Jolley, Isaac W. Searing, Ephraim
Lindsley, James H. Neighbour, Hudson Hoagland, Albert R. Riggs,
Alpheus Becmer. Richard George, Henry ^.IcFarlan, Josiah Meeker,
James W. Brotherton, John W. Jackson. John H. Pierson, Wm. H.
Lambert, Thomas Anderson, Samuel Tippett, Fred H. Beach, Leopold
C. Bierwirth, Mahlon Hoagland, Jr., Cadwallader R. Mulligan, Rus-
:sell T. Penniman. Robert Killgore, Elbert H. Baldwin, Emil M.
Lowenthal, John H. Bonsall.
The men who so ably filled the position of President of this bank
.since its organization, whose valuable services are reflected in the
success of the institution are: Columbus Beach, George Richards,
LIudson Horigland, Cadwallader R. 3.1ulligan, Thomas H. Hoagland.
The men v/ho served the bank as Cashiers, so ably and efficiently
•giving the best that was in them, are Jay S. Treat. George D. Meeker,
Elbert H. BakUvin. Charles Applegate. William Otto. The men who
are guiding the destinies of the bank at the present time and who are
doing their best for depositors, stockholders and all interested parties
are as follow^s :
Directors — Peter C. Buck, Thomas H. Hoagland, DeWitt R.
flummcr, James B. Tonking, John Mulligan, F'aul Guenther, William
F. Birch, James N. Goodale.
149
Officers — Thomas H. Hoagland, President; Peter C. Buck, Vice-
President; AVilliam Otto. Cashier; Sanford C. Gerard, Asst. Cashier.
In Conckision, it is proper to state that this bank, Hke all others,
stood by the U. S. Government in the World War, receiving subscrip-
tions for Liberty and Victory Loans, made deliveries to the proper
owners and acted as safekeepers for the owners of these bonds, all
without charge to the owners and subscribers or to the Government.
THE DOVER TRUST COMPANY
The Dover Trust Company commenced business January ist, 1902,
with a capital of $100,000, succeeding the People's National Bank,
which began business 1898 with a capital of $50,000. Mr. James H.
Simpson was its first President and was. succeeded by Mr. L W.
Searing.
Its present officers are Edward Kelly, President ; James L. Hurd,
Vice-President ; E. W. Rosevear, Secretary-Treasurer ; C. S. Clark,
Assistant Secretary-Treasurer.
The following is a list of its Directors :
John S. Dickerson E. J. Neighbour
'Max Heller Robt. F. Oram
lames L. Hurd .- t,,- -n „„..
T- -1 r^ T^ j-^ i'- W. Rosevear
Emu G. Kattermann
Edward Kelly Roy E- Lynd
Elmer King ' Reinhard Huettig
T. O. Bassett Hov/ard H. King
Its present resources are in excess of $3,000,000.
This institution has been remarkably successful in the develop-
ment of thrift and saving. It has aided in the erection of homes and
the general prosperity of Dover and vicinity. It safeguards financial
interest, provides adequate security for valuables, advises as to
investments bv its patrons and friends, furnishing information free
of cost to them. It encourages all efi:'orts for the advancement of the
general good and recomniends accounts by the young.
The chief asset of a bank clerk is honesty, courtesy, and willing-
ness to serve the public. Studiousness and a desire for greater effi-
ciency, a requisite of great value to them. The higher the education
attained the better fitted to fill whatever position may be open to them.
It is difficult to measure a bank's influence. Absolute integrity is
required. Confidence of the public must be maintained. The per-
sonnel of directors, officers and employees must be unquestioned. All
this the Dover Trust Company has, and sets the highest standard of
moral and financial integrity in all dealings with the people and public
interest.
.150
A trust company has for its depositors, individuals, firms, corpora-
tions. It can act as Executor, Administrator and Trustee under wills
or by appointment of the Court. It is under strict control and con-
stant supervision by the State Department of Banking and Insurance.
WASTE NOT, WANT NOT
*' WASTE NOT, WANT NOT"— how shall we mortals marry
These words to action in our little sphere?
How gather in the wealth they seem to carry,
How heed the voice of thrift, the summons clear?
Each man, each child may be an engineer
Of fortune, as Poor Richard taught of old ;
The banks were filled with savings in a year.
When thrifty Ben this open secret told.
"Waste not your substance," said our frugal Bennie ;
"Don't pay too much for whistles, but put by
Erom day to day a dollar or a penny
And so win independence ; do not cry
And shout aloud, 'We're freemen, free!' — the lie
Sticks in your throats when you are slaves to debt ;
For freedom must be earned, and this is why
Some folks, freeborn, have not found freedom yet.''
And so the printer's lad became our Moses,
Our prophet, leading to the Promised Land ;
While others heavenward gazed with upturned noses.
He saved his pennies, firmly took his stand
Upon this text — 'Waste not, want not"; no grand
Ideal of the Euture made him blind
To conmion sense, to dollars in the hand,
To nearby fortunes that the thrifty find.
BEN, we have canonized you lately ; many
Are making pilgrimages to your shrine ;
Your shrewd, plain preaching holds its own with an}-
Taught by rapt seer or eloquent divine.
For January 17, the birthday of Ben Franklin.
151
THE NEWSPAPERS OF DOVER
By Harry R. Gill
We have been told that "a man is known by the company he keeps,"
and in a great measure, we have come to learn that a town is judged
by the newspapers it supports.
Since 1869 Dover has not been without a newspaper, On April
ist, 1869, The Dover Enterprise came out as the town's first paper,
published by Edward L. Dickerson and Frank N. Lindsley. The
type was set in a small shop over the present Dickerson store in East
Blackwell street and the forms taken to New York for printing. The
Enterprise was a weekly and this farming-out process continued until
June I, 1870, when the paper was taken over by W. J. Bruce, a prac-
tical printer, who put in a plant and changed the name to The Dover
Mail, not a very large sheet, but surely large enough to carry the
events as they happened way back in the seventies. In those days
the advertisements were more or less in the nature of reading notices
and it is more than likely that Editor Bruce gathered his own news,
set his own type from the case, and "got out" the newspaper himself.
We are also reasonably sure that Dover's pioneer publisher had very
little trouble with the "newsies" and that he knew nothing of the
blessings of the telephone as the newspaper's greatest friend in the
gathering of news. It took a genius to publish a paper in those days —
nowadays a fat bank account is the greatest asset. In those days the
typesetting machine was only a dream — but those were the days when
the versatile printers were made. Now they are specialists, each doing
his part in the great organism that groans for lack of time in which
to do more and to do it more quickly. To '\niss the mail" in Bruce's
time perhaps gave him little concern. The coming of plate and type-
setting machines was to the newspaper office what a copious shower
is to the parched soil.
In 1870 The Iron Era, founded by Benjamin Vogt, also came
into the journalistic life of the community. As a paying newspaper
proposition The Era was perhaps the most successful until more recent
years. During the regime of the late George Richards, who was
recognized as one of the leading political factors of Northern Jersey,
The Dover Printing Company was able to pay what was considered
in those days a handsome dividend. At that time the late John S.
Gibson was its editor, and it has been conceded that Editor Gibson
was the ablest newspaper man of whom North Jersey can boast.
Editor Gibson went from The Era office to The Nezvark Commercial-
Advertiser and from that time on the career of Dover's strongest paper
became more or less checkered. In the meantime Mr. Richards passed
away in iqoo, with some of those whose political patronage was neces-
sarily withdrawn.
In 1875 The Dover Index was founded by Francis F. Hummel
and Lorenzo D. Tillyer, upon the discontinuance of The Dover Mail.
Mr. Hummel came to Dover from Mauch Chunk in 1874 as foreman
152
of The Mail, under Mr. Bruce. Both Mr. Hummel and Mr. Tillyer
are now deceased, but, like Tennyson's brook, The Index goes on for-
ever. William G. Hummel, brother of the founder, is the present
publisher.
In the earlier days of journalism, newspapers had an ambition —
for the most part political — more so than now, when profits are more
to be desired than a principle fought for. The Era was the Republican
mouthpiece and TIic Index the Democratic. So, on the assumption
that temperance or prohibition was a burning issue in the breasts of
many, a number of local enthusiasts, known then as "prohibition
cranks," formed a stock company and The Morris County Journal
blossomed forth as the noonday sun — one of the very few prohibition
papers in New Jersey. Its first editor was James S. Bradbrook, a
Free Methodist preacher, who got out its first number in 1890. The
publication office was on the top floor of the Alexander Wighton Build-
ing, now owned and occupied by James T. Lowe. Of course its
income was restricted and consequently its existence was not the
smoothest. Editors came and went. Bradbrook was succeeded by
Edward Jones, another Free Methodist preacher, who remained at
the helm the longest of any of its editors. He was a widower and
practically lived in the office, hence a little salary went a long way
with him, for he was working for the sake of principle and stuck
to the ship as long as he could. Jones was extremely bitter in his
writings, but none too strong for some of those on his board of direct-
ors. However, he finally came into disfavor and stepped out "on his
own hook," equipping a small printing plant in a residence in Sanford
street, where he continued to publish his literature in tract form and
oft'ered it for public distribution. During this period he was maintained
by a few of his friends, who still had confidence in him and the work
he was trying to accomplish. Jones was succeeded by Norton Wagner,
who came from Scranton. In a short time Wilton R. Capps. now a
resident of Newark, succeeded Wagner, but only for a brief period.
During his time, however, Mr. Capps attempted for the first time in
the history of the town to publish a daily paper. He made a noble
struggle — but he was only a pioneer. The Journal appeared as a daily
but for a few weeks. It was a money-loser as a weekly, but more
so as a daily.
Then along came Rev. David Spencer, a Baptist minister, who
had the Ledgev/ood church as his pastorate. He came from Racine,
Wis. Through his forcefulness he was able to form a stock company
of such representative business men as William H. and Andrew K.
Baker, Martin V. B. Searing, Isaac W. Searing, Charles E. Clark,
David S. Allen, Jacob J. \'reeland, Sr., Alex Kanouse and others.
The paper was reorganized as The Morris Journal and the company
known as The Morris Publishing Company. During this regime Dover
was given its nev/siest and best printed newspaper. It was all hand-
set but, although its patronage was generous, its income was not suffi-
155
cient and it went into the hands of a receiver. At the sale the paper
was taken over by George Richards and absorbed into The Iron Era.
The plant was dismantled and taken to Morristown and used for sev-
eral months by Morey Bros, in publishing The Daily Record, and later
the Morris County Standard, edited by John W. Williams. The
Standard was absorbed by the the Morris County Chronicle, and The
Standard and Chronicle, in time, were absorbed by The Jerseynian.
Editor Gill, of Tlie Advance, got out the first issue of The Daily Record
with the old Morris Journal plant, in a shop at the rear of a building
in Morris street near the yards of the Mills Wood Working Company.
He still has in his possession the first copy of Tiic Record off the press.
On March 9, 1903, The Doz'er Ach'ancc first saw the light of
day. Harry R. Gill, the present owner and publisher, conceived the
idea of a twice-a-week paper while employed as foreman of The Daily
Record in Alorristown. Before starting the paper, however, because
of limited financial means, he took in partnership with him Oron P.
Cole, who was then employed as a compositor on The Dover Index.
Together they worked diligently for months building up their already
small business, for they had made a nev/ start. Their competitors.
The Inde.v and The Iron Era, had been in existence for years. The
novelty of a semi-weekly paper seemed to meet with popular approval
and the business took on a healthy growth from its inception. Shortly
after The Advance appeared. The Inde.i' came out as a daily, the
second attempt for Dover, and it proved as disastrous as the first,,
except that its publishers had stronger backing and greater prestige
in the community than Ilie Daily Journal had when Mr. Capps
attempted it. It was a disagreement over the continuance or the dis-
continuance of The Indc.r as a daily that led to the dissolution of part-
nership betAveen Hummel and Tillyer, the latter of whom retired
from the business and built the Fair Building in East Blackwell street,
now occupied by F. A. Rinehart. Failing in this enterprise as a novelty
store, he engaged in the newspaper business at Hightstown, where
he conducted for several years The Highstown Gazette. The Inde.v
was published as a daily for about seven months.
In May, 1905, Mr. Cole sold his interest in The Advance to the
present owner, who has since operated it personally. In May, 1914,
at a chattel mortgage foreclosure sale, The Iron Era and its plant
was bought in by Harry R. Gill and absorbed into The Dover Advance.
Older residents in the town will remember the names of some
of the former editors of The Iron Era : Benjamin H. Vogt, John S.
Gibson, Frank Everett, Frank J. McDeede (now a surgeon in Pater-
son), A. E. C. Mindermann, James E. Williams and Frank E. Porter.
154
DOVER REAL ESTATE
I never intended to become a real estate agent, but I find that 1
have been accumulating material that might easily form a history of the
growth of Dover real estate. We are sometimes told that there can be
no sound vi^here there is no ear to perceive it, no music except as it is
performed and heard. R-cal estate appears to belong in the same class
of phenomena. Land becomes real estate v/hen it gets related to human
use. Real estate grows or develops as it becomes more intimately or
extensively related to the service of man. Hence its historical changes
in value as indicated by prices paid at successive periods of time, illus-
trated in the case of Dover.
The late James H. Neighbour allowed me to have access to his old
deeds, maps, and his copy of McFarlan's Descriptions of Dover real
estate from 1827 to 1849, "1 which a methodical account was given of
each lot on the principal streets, with area, date of sale and selling price
and purchaser. Much of this information may be found in "Dover
History," together with the full text of the available deed concerned
with John Jackson's real estate transactions. 1722 and 1753, briefly
noted in "Dover Dates." Mr. Neighbour told me that Silas Dell is
thought to have originated the first detailed map of this region in his
endeavors to locate bits of land yet unappropriated. He showed me Silas
Dell's map.
THE SHOTWELL RETURN
From Edward Howell, Civil Engineer, Morristown, I have obtained
the following memorandum of the Shotwell Return, which he took from
the original record at Perth Amboy.
"JOSEPH SHOTWELL. S-2-Q8. May 30, 1745. Martin Ryer-
son. Deputy Surveyor. A tract (in Morris County) at the place called
'Quaker Iron Works.' Beginning at a Hickory Sapling marked on four
sides, standing in the line of a former survey made for Joseph Latham
at the west side of a rocky hill.
"First: — i) N 44d E 30.00 2) S 46d E 3.00 3) S 44d W 29.00 4)
N 7od W 3.00 to beginning, containing 9 acres strict. Second : — Also
that tract of land lying on both sides of the Rockaway River, beginning
at a Black Oak tree standing by the south side of said Rockaway River
by a point of Rocks distant from the N E corner of the above mentioned
lot upon a S 69d E course 99c & 5^ from thence N 5id E 40, S 43d E 29,
S 13d W 133/2, N 78d W 49 to beginning, containing 91 acres and both
tracts together contain 100 acres strict."
Note that the first place was called Quaker Iron Works previous to
1745. This may mean that the Schooleys, had a forge here at an earlier
date. Was John Jackson a Quaker? William Schooley took up land
at Millbrook, 171 3. Also note that Joseph Latham had a tract within
Dover's present limits, in addition to the tract of 527 acres which he
sold to John Jackson in 1722. Possibly John Jackson acquired the land
155
for his forge and dwelling from the same Latham, but we find no
record of the deed, as is common for that time.
This Shotwell return took in the business center of Dover.
The late Frederick H. Beach gave me access to the original books,
maps, and surveys of the McFarlan estate, going back to the land pur-
chases of Israel Canfield, made with a view to mineral rights. These
documents were then kept at Morristown in the law office of John Bon-
sall, nephew of Mr. Beach. They are important records of Dover
history, and of a still wider territory.
Alexander Mott of Rockaway informed me that the entire tract
from Turner's Corner (Sussex street) eastward to the first Blackwell
street bridge over the Rockaway river (formerly known as "the wading
place") was once offered to a certain individual for $500. The man to
whom it was offered declined to sink his money in such a swamp as the
property then appeared, and said he would buy land where it was worth
something. So he bought a farm in Millbrook, which was then the flour-
ishing industrial section of this region. No doubt he made a wise choice
for his time. Real estate values are made by other considerations than
the number of acres in a tract. The canal came. The railroad came.
The trolley came. Industries came. Building lots in the rejected tract
are now sold at $5,000.
Harry L. Schwarz, who has made a lifelong study of Dover real
estate, has greatly assisted me in securing accurate data that illustrate
the changing real estate values of the past fifty years.
But before we take up these later details let us take a brief historical
survey, gathering from our "Dover Dates" certain real estate facts, for
this book goes to show how New Jersey ever became "real estate."
1497 — The Cabots claimed North America for England by discovery.
(This included Dover, of course.)
1607 — Henry Hudson claims New Jersey for the Dutch, by discovery.
1664 — England asserts her prior claim and Charles II grants New
Jersey to his brother, the Duke of York. The Duke conveys New
Jersey to Berkeley and Carteret.
1674 — Berkeley sold West Jersey to Quakers for £1,000.
1682 — Lady Carteret sold East Jersey to Wm. Penn and others for
£3,400.
1713 — Wm. Schooley took up 600 acres at Millbrook.
1722 — John Jackson bought 527 acres at Mine Hill for £5. (about $25).
1745 — The Shotwell Return includes 100 acres of Dover. No price.
1753 — Fitz Randolph bought at Sheriff's sale Jackson's 527 acres, for
£555. Values have risen.
1817 — Blackwell & McFarlan introduce a new era in village real estate,
making the map of 1825 and laying off streets and selling many
building lots.
The storv of the corners all along Blackwell street is particularly
156
significant. The four corners of Blackwell and Sussex streets may be
indicated as NW, NE, SW, SE.
1827 SW sold to Minton 2,500 sq. ft. $400. Now Killgore.
1827 SE sold to Hurd 5,000 sq. ft. $475. Mansion House.
1835 NW sold to McDavit 7,500 sq. ft. $500. Richards.
1836 NE sold to Hinchman 5,000 sq. ft. $750. Turner.
Real estate values progress by epochs marked by certain great
causes, such as transportation facilities, industries, growth of popu-
lation, cost of labor and building materials, market value of commer-
cial products (which depend on how other people are prospering in
other parts of the world). Dover's land values, therefore, were
successively affected by the changes in modes of travel, and trans-
portation from teams and stage coaches to canal (1831), D. L. & W.
Railroad (1848), Central R. R. (1880), trolley (1904). and trucks
and automobiles; and by the coming of new industries, as suggested
by the following table :
1874 Birch Boiler Works.
1 881 Singleton's Silk Mill.
1884 E. J. Ross, Silk.
1890 Kattermann, Swiss Knitting Mill.
1893 Laundry, Clark-Cook.
1894 Peters' Overall Factory.
1896 Richardson & Boynton Stove Works.
1897 Guenther's Silk Hosiery.
19CO ^IcKiernan Drill Works.
1912 Lackawanna Switch & Frog Works.
1914 Artificial Ice Hygeia — Crystal.
191 5 N. J. Power & Light Company.
19 16 l)o\A"ns & Slater's Foundry.
1918 MacFall's Factory.
Outside industries have aided the prosperity of the town, such as,
1871, Hercules Powder Company, 1880 Picatinny Arsenal, 1883
Atlas Powder Co., 1891 U. S. Navy Depot, 1907 Wharton Steel Co. —
Replogle, Inc.
The AlcFarlan lar.d lioom can be traced street by street and
corner by corner, and the later indtistries have left their impress imon
the expanding map of Dover, with new streets and new residential
tracts. To trace in detail the real estate reaction to each change in
transportation and industry would be an extended but illuminating
study.
The McFarlan regime lasted about half a century. Then it
ceased. McFarlan Park, the pride of the village, was sold and soon
all traces of the old gardens on both sides of Blackwell street gave
way to the show windows of thrifty storekeepers, the billboards of the
Baker Theatre, the Hoagland ]\Iemorial Church.
Before quoting the sales which converted McFarlan's Park into
marketable real estate, let us note that Mrs. Losey, further down the
street, sold her vegtable garden to W. H. Goodale for $1,000 in 1850,
157
and he built on it the first brick building in Dover — Goodale's Drug
Store of to-day. When Mr. Goodale asked the little son of Mrs.
Losey to tell his mother that $i,ooo was offered for her garden plot
she thought the child was "kidding" her and paid no more attention
to it — who would pay such a fabulous sum? Mr. Goodale had to
explain later that he really meant it.
And in 1872 Leopold D. Schwarz bought the Steel Furnace lot
on Sussex street for $2,500 and erected the Central Hotel from the old
bricks of the Steel Furnace, this being the second brick building in
Dover.
To secure a right of way through this Sussex street property in
1880, for the Central Railroad of New Jersey, George Richards made
a bargain v.ith Leopold Schwarz, giving him the Old Stone Store
(now Friedman's) near the National L^nion Bank, in exchange for
said right of way. Hence said store on Blackwell street was rated as
worth a fraction of $2,500 in 1880.
To resume the story of McFarlan's Park: — the portion from the
corner of Blackwell and Warren streets to the Woolworth store near
the Baker Theatre was sold to Mayor Pierson for $5,500 about 1885.
W. H. Baker bought the rest of it for $8,000. From the Baker
purchase 125 feet was sold to the Hoagland Memorial Church for
$15,000 in 1899.
Kvery street has its real estate story and of these Blackwell street
is the most startling. The Business l^Ien's Association might
well devote an evening to swapping real estate stories about
Dover's main street. Old Dickerson street, once the Fifth ave-
nue of the village, also has a tale to tell. Our new Americans
from classic Greece and Italy now delight in the mansions of
Dover's "old families."
In 191 2, the Presbyterian Church (the original name for the
Hoagland Memorial) sold its old building and lot on the south side
of Blackwell street and opposite its present edifice for $6,500.
In 191 1, Edward Jenkins and Price, the photographer, bought a
lot (50x120) from Miss Mary Rose for $15,000. In 1922 the lot
known as the "White property" (50x100), opposite the Jenkins &
Price purchase, was sold for $30,000.
It is said that the Killgore corner (25x50) which sold in 1827
(2,500 square feet) for $400, was sold in 1922 for something between
$40,000 and $50,000.
Another Blackwell street corner worth noting is that at the north-
west corner of Essex street. The late Robert F. Oram had a mort-
gage on this lot (50x100) and a small strip (18x50) in the rear, with
River street between the two lots. The mortgages were for $3,261.72
and $526.47. At public vendue in 1889 the two lots sold for $3,100.
In 1919 this property was sold for $30,000 to Pasqual Nazzaro, who
has since sold it at a profit.
The property at southeast corner of Blackwell and Warren streets,
158
opposite the Trust Company, was recently sold to Wm. S. White.
The price was said to be $75,000. The corner is occupied by a brick
building, three stories high. There are six stores on the first floor.
Lot 35 XI 05^/2. This makes a price of $6.77 a square foot.
Lehman's comer (Morris and Blackwell street), was bought in
1902-3 for $19,000 (75x100). Two years before that date it could
have been bought for $12,000. All taxes on this property, when
bought, amounted to $t66. The property was formerly occupied by-
Sovereign's Mercantile and Savings Association, and by the residence
of Sidney Breese.
The lot on which Pierson's Clothing Store long stood, sold in 1872-
for $6,000 with no building on it.
In some such way a table or chart of real estate transactions could
be made out and the rise in value of each city lot recorded in chrono-
logical order. Then we should have that complete guide to Dover real
estate values which I feel myself unprepared to furnish. Besides,
my interest in the subject is purely academic.
The Trust Company, by the way, secured their corner (30x65)
for $22,500 in 1912, and have since added a lot (30x35) in the rear
for $13,500. With some incidental expenses this brings the purchase
price of their property up to $36,000 and more.
If we should add to these statistics of commercial real estate the
story of the mining properties by which Dover is surrounded — farms
and hillsides with "mineral rights" — we should have another chapter
of thrilling interest, leading up to the recent gathering up of the old
mining lands by Replogle, Inc.
There is still another side to our real estate story, and that is
the chapter that tells of the many cozy homes for working people of
whatever occupation, erected by their thrift and often, in great part,
the work of their own hands, aided perhaps by the Building and Loan
Association, founded in 1882. This is the real crux of Dover's pros-
perity — how can the man or woman of moderate means secure a com-
fortable and satisfactory home? Many interesting answers to that
question have been worked out in Dover and on al! the hills surround-
ing the town, where choice building sites become more and more
available through the increasing possession of automobiles. The air-
plane may yet lead some of our good folks to "mansions in the sky" ;
but, if you fall short of that, try the vicinity of Quaker Church or
Mt. Fern for delightful scenery at an elevation of 800 to i.ooo feet
above sea. Or West End Heights and Mine Hill. Low-lying plains
beyond these toilsome heights may be found at Kenvil. with plenty
of elbow room. Elycroft on the east is also holding out inducements.
But I am not an agent.
In addition to the above historic facts the following considera-
tions may be noted.
Real estate values in New Jersey have been notably affected by a
'rowing appreciation of landscape beauty and picturesque scenery and
lurroundings. There was a time when land was valued chiefly for
ts productivity and this always holds for farming properties.
159
But after the Civil War and especially during the last quarter
century, beauty of rural and suburban scenery has become a distinct
factor in real estate values — witness the developments at Morristown,
Summit, Short Hills, Far Hills, Peapack, Lyons Farms, Montclair
and numerous modern residential tracts. With the application of
landscape gardening and the erection of attractive villas many of the
old farms have risen in market value from $60 to $1,000 an acre.
Another potent factor in causing such values is the social charac-
ter of the community. This may become exclusive or exaggerated ;
but it cannot be denied that land rises or falls in value by the charac-
ter of those who reside on it or near it. Good neighbors are an asset
to any man who wishes to put his property on the market.
Accessibility to daily work is another consideration. In old times
it was a marked feature of our village life, as when Zenas Pruden
had his shop at one end of his garden spot and his dwelling at the
other, at the corner of Morris and Dickerson streets, N. W. With
the growth of a great population of commuters to our cities suburban
real estate has acquired new value. In a local way it may be noted
that Guenther's factory has raised land values to and beyond the
Rockaway Township line from about $150 or $200 a building lot to
$1,000. The Richardson & Boynton Stove Works has added greatly to
the real estate possibilities of the Baker tract and North Dover as
well as other parts of the town.
Architectural beauty also enters into ultimate values of residen-
tial and even business-block properties. The architectural fitness, vari-
ety, harmony and tout ensemble of a village, town, or city creates
positive market value. Well designed buildings such as public schools
and libraries, churches, banks, municipal buildings, stores and even
factories may be so treated, grouped and harmonized as a whole that
the general effect is a real asset to all property owners in such a
community or neighborhood. I have even heard the remark that if a
group of houses that may be seen at one view along a country road
were well harmonized in their color scheme instead of seeming to
"swear at" one another, the result would bring artistic blessings to
humanity if not dollars and cents to the owners. In towns and cities
a building commission may do much for the general good. Europe
learned this lesson long ago. Our Trust Company Building marks a
forward step in Dover. When the post-sewer building craze sets in,
then engage a competent architect that a new Dover may rise majestic
from the ancient foundations !
The completion of a sewerage system will be another great step
forward in the history of Dover real estate. Sanitation is a founda-
tion stone of good living and real estate value. Dover's future, in
this respect, is bound up with that whole area which includes New
York City and a circuit of fifty miles about it, for which the Russell
Sage Foundation is endeavoring to raise up competent constructive
advisors.
i6o
Any changes that our raih-oads may make in shifting their Hne
of road building will inevitably cause some shift in real estate availa-
bility. We are all watching to see which way the Lackawanna will
jump when it seeks a better line of traffic through the awkward turn at
Dover, going west. The ultimate fate of the Morris Canal is another
factor.
Dover's diversified and picturesque scenery makes possible build-
ing sites in great number, beautiful for situation and outlook — situa-
tions that would cost nuich more if nearer New York. We are here
at the gateway of the Switzerland of New Jersey. Lake Hopatcong is
eight miles west of us, and many smaller lakes and ponds dot the
landscape of the State as one fiivvers through this Schooley's-Moun-
tain peneplain of New Jersey.
CHURCHES
THE FIRST PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH
The First Presbyterian Church of Dover was organized in 1835
and held its first services in the Stone Academy erected on Dickerson
street by Henry McFarlan, Sr., to serve in part for church use. The
first building erected by the Presbyterians was located on land donated
by the executors of Henry IMcFarlan, Sr., on the south side of Black-
well street, at the west corner of Prospect street. It was dedicated
in 1842. The first building was later moved across Prospect street to
the triangle where Totten's Garage now stands.
The second building (now used as Arcanum Hall) was erected
on the site of the first and dedicated in 1872. Elder J. L. Allen left
$10,000 towards the erection of this building, and $5,000 for a parson-
age, located on Prospect street, further up the hill.
The third and present building, known as The Hoagland Memorial
Church, was erected, 1899, on land purchased from Wm. H. Baker,
opposite the former site of the old church buildings. The third build-
ing (with the land on which it stands) was donated by Hudson Hoag-
land as a memorial of his wife, Martha D. Bigelov\'.
These gifts are recorded in recognition of the generosity of the
donors.
The pastors of this church have been as follows:
Rev. James Wvckoff 1835-1838
Rev. Robert R. Kellogg 1838-
Rev. Burtis C. Magie, D.D 1839-1876
Rev. William W. Halloway, D.D 1876-1910
Rev. Peter McMillan, D.D 1910-
Previous to the organization of this church prayer meetings
had been held in Dover and a Sunday School established in 1816. A
series of special religious meetings was conducted in Dover in 1831 by
Rev. Edwin F. Hatfield, later known as the author of Hatfield's History
of Elizabeth, N. J. These meetings, apparently, were a prelude to
the organization of the church in 1835. It was "set off" from the
Rockaway Church in 1834.
i6i
GRACE METHODIST EPISCOPAL CHURCH
The first organized Methodist society in Dover was an off-spring
from Millbrook Methodist Episcopal Church. In 1838 the first Meth-
odist Episcopal church in Dover was erected on the corner of Sussex
and McFarlan streets. For fifty-two years this church stood as the
pride and honor of Methodism in Dover. In 1890 this old church
was sold to H. P. Ropier, as it had served its day and generation and
must give place to the new. It was removed to its present site on
Sussex street and turned into a dwelling house. It is still owned and
occupied by its original purchaser, H. P. Hopler.
On July 23rd, 1890, the cornerstone for the new church was laid.
On the 28th day of January, 1891, the new church, now known as Grace
Methodist Episcopal Church, was dedicated. With few minor changes,
this building has been used for the glory of God for a period of
thirty-three years, and is in good condition to-day.
The present membership is about 150. Number on roll in Sunday
School, 280; members in the Epworth League, 135; number in Ladies'
Aid, 40 ; in Sisters of Bethany, 28 ; in Boys' Club, 25 ; Girls' Club, 85.
The pastors who have served the church since 1876 are as follows:
W. H. McBride, one year; A. M. Palmer, one year; W. I. Gill, three
years ; W. H. McCormick, three years ; J. R. Daniels, three years ;
Ered Bloom, five years ; Thomas Hall, one year ; S. D. Decker, one
year; W. M. Trumbower, two years; W. J. Hampton, three years;
J. E. Machman, one year ; M. T. Gibbs, four years ; S. H. Jones, four
years; E. V. King, one year; H. P, King, one year; A. B. Eitzgerald,
five years ; Nathaniel Brooks, seven years ; William H, Hudson, present
pastor, one year.
THE EIRST METHODIST EPISCOPAL CHURCH
The First Methodist Episcopal Church, like the Grace M. E.
Church, dates its organization from the first church building erected
in Dover in 1838 on the corner of North Sussex street and McFarlan
street.
They removed from the old site and put up a stone church in 1872,
on North Essex street, corner of Blackwell street. In 1907 they
erected the present large and beautiful stone building on Blackwell
street, to which the building of 1872 becomes an annex for the use
of the Sunday School and other purposes.
The present pastor is the Rev. J. Fred. Bindenderfer, who suc-
ceeded Rev. George Whitehead, who followed Rev. Christopher Von
Glahn.
l62
ST. MARY'S R. C. CHURCH
ST. MARY'S PARISH
In the matter of church history St. Mary's has set us all an
example by publishing, in connection with its seventy-fifth anniversary,
a pamphlet containing a history of the parish, illustrated. In it are
shown pictures of the church buildings, higher dignitaries of the
church, pastors and others — 23 illustrations, such as every church
ought to have. From this pamphlet the following data are obtained.
1774 Earliest record of missions in Morris County. Baptism by
Rev. Father Schneider.
1844 Rev. I. P. Howell visited Dover, stopping with Mr. and Mrs,
William Phillips. Father Dominic Senez of Madison followed.
Mr. and Mrs. Phillips donated ground for a church.
1845 Work was begun on it. Father Senez was pastor.
1847-1867 Father John Callen. Parish School established in base-
ment of old church.
1867-1869 Rev. Bernard Quinn. First school building 1868.
1869 Rev. P. Byrne and Father Fitzsimmons,
1870 Rev. Pierce McCarthy. New cemetery acquired.
1873 Cornerstone of new stone church laid.
1878 Rev. James Hanley.
1883 Rev. John A. Sheppard.
1884 Rev. Nicholas Hens.
1885 Rev. Gerard Funke. Brick school and new rectory built.
1908 Rev. Paul T. Carew.
1914 Rev. E. J. Miskela. Sisters' Home built. '
1917 Rev. P. A. Maher.
1920 Seventy-fifth anniversary.
ST. JOHN'S EPISCOPAL CHURCH
Note: — At the time of the seventieth anniversary of St. John's
Church a history of the church was published in the local papers. It
was not possible to obtain such a history in 191 3 for the "Dover His-
tory" and I now include this history in "Dover Dates" the better to
preserve it. — Editor.
19 1 9. The Seventieth Anniversary.
On Sunday morning there was corporate communion of the parish
in thanksgiving to God for His years of care. On Sunday evening the
service was in charge of five of the former pastors, the Rev. Messrs.
Butterworth, Butler, Pickslay, McCleary, and Thomson. Special music
was rendered at both services by the choir under the direction of Miss
Mabel Banghart.
On Monday evening there was an informal reception to former
pastors and communicants in the parish house, to which the local clergy
were invited. The townspeople of Dover were invited to attend the
anniversary exercises.
1 63
PARTIAL HISTORY OF THE CHURCH
In the month of November, 1849, the Right Rev. George Washing-
ton Doane, D.D., LL.D., Bishop of New Jersey, placed the village of
Dover under the charge of the Rev. Charles W. Rankin, Rector of St.
Peter's Church of Morristown.
Henry McFarlan, Esq., of New York, had in years past manifested
his interest in the establishment of the church in Dover by designating
a commanding piece of ground as the site of a parish church and pro-
viding a large folio Bible for the use of the minister officiating in that
village.
His son, Henry McFarlan, Esq., residing in Dover and inheriting
his father's spirit, was the first to encourage the revival of the church's
work and has been foremost in every labor of love to carry it forward
to a successful end.
The above, taken from record made by Dr. Rankin, is in brief the
tale of the beginnings of the work of St. John's Church which is now
keeping its seventieth anniversary.
On the evening of the eighth of November of that year the first
service was held in an "upper chamber" of the Academy building then
located on what is now Dickerson street, where Snyder's restaurant now
is. The room could hold about a hundred people and is reported as being
well filled. So well was this enjoyed that it was then determined to begin
a weekly service, which has been continued ever since.
On November 23. the sacrament of Baptism was first administered
by the pastor. The three children of Asa M. Clark, George C, Augustus
H., and Mary E., were presented and their names are the first entered
upon the parish register.
The following January it became needful to enlarge the meeting
place and a number of repairs were made so that the room might have
"a neat and pleasant appearance." Shortly afterward a Sunday School
was organized under the superintendence of Henry McFarlan.
Because it was not possible to have the services of a clergyman in
the morning, no Communion service was held until January 12, 1852,
when the Bishop himself officiated. The service consisted of the Litany
and Holy Communion and nine communicants were reported.
Encouraged by this visit of the Bishop, the people determined to
effect a parish organization and this was done at the first Parish meet-
ing, held on February 28, 1862. At this meeting Henry and Charles
McFarlan were chosen Wardens and Asa and Henry Phillips, William
Losey, Thomas T. Lewis and Joshua Butterworth, Vestrymen.
Among the early members of the congregation were many whose
names are familiar to all who have traced the history of Dover. McFar-
lan, Blackwell, Cooke, Elliott, Richards, Munson, Tippett, Tremain,
Stickle, Mott, Jackson, Phillips, Clark, Tonkins, and Green are names
known and still to be found in our community. These communicants
came from Dover, near Dover, Succasunna, Mt. Pleasant Mine, Rock-
away. Denville, Lake Hopatcong, Mt. Hope, Mott Hollow, Mine Hill,
Long Pond, Swede's Mine, Iron Dale, Scrub Oaks and Ferromont.
164
St. John's treasures the first prayer ])Ook used at this time. This
book was used by the first rector of St. Peter's Church in Morristown,
Rev. Benjamin Holmes, and its services were marked for punctuation
and emphasis by Rt. Rev. John Croes, who was one of the first liishops
of ths American Church. It was in continuous use there from 1830 to
1849, ^^"^d when the services were begun in Dover, was presented to the
new mission by the parent church.
The Church grev/ and prospered and on October 18, 1866. work
was begun upon the present stone edifice upon the plot which Mr.
McFarlan, Sr., had promised. His son, Henry, fulfilled this promise
"by deeding the land which has become so valuable to the parish, on
December i, 1866, for the purposes of a church, rectory, and parish
"srhool. The work of building became burdensome to the little congrega-
tion, and after foundations were laid the work ceased and services v/ere
continued in the Academy. When Rev. John F. Butterworth became
rector the project was revived and under his energetic leadership the
church building was completed and was consecrated by Bishop Oden-
heimer in 1871. The total cost was $15,037.19, a large sum for those
days.
During the rectorship of Dr. Wm. M. Pickslay. the present parish
house (since enlarged) and the rectory were built. Much of this work
was superintended by Mr. Cadwallader Mulligan, who is still a member
of the Vestry.
St. John's has always evidenced a community spirit and co-operation
in movements for the benefit of the town, and for some years the school
conducted in the Academy was under its jurisdiction. Pupils are still
living vAio studied under the Rev. H. C. H. Dudley, and Piatt's Dfover
History remarks that documents from the Parish School conducted by
Rev. James A. Upjohn constitute a report on education in Dover in
i860. It may be interesting to note that the curriculum eml^raced Cate-
chism, Sunday lessons, Latin, Arithmetic, Spelling, Reading, Gram-
mar, Geography, Plistory. Astronomy, Writing, Dictation, Composition,
Declamation, Drawing, Vocal and Instrumental Music, and French,
Quite a formidable list when we know that he had only one assistant,
Miss Forgus.
During the influenza epidemic last year (1918), the Parish House
was used by the town as a hospital for those unable to secure medical
attention elsewhere.
During the years of its life St. John's has had the follov/ing clergy
•as settled pastors :
Rev. Charles W. Rankin 1849-1852
Rev. Charles S. Little 1852-1853
Rev. J. B. Berry 1853-
Rev. Nathan W. Munroe 1853-1854
Rev. Charles F. Hofifman 1855-1856
Rev. Francis D. Canfield 1856-1857
.Rev. H. C. H. Dudley 1S57-1S60
i65
Rev. Thomas W. Street 1860-1861
Rev. Thomas Margot 1861-1862
Rev. James A. Upjohn 1863-1869
Rev. John F. Butterworth 186Q-1871
Rev. Edwin E. Butler 1871-1880
Rev. David D. Bishop 1881-1883
Rev. James B. Mead 1883-1887
Rev. WilHam M. Pickslay 1887-1897
Rev. C. R. D. Crittendon". 1897-1898
Rev. C. Harvey Hartman 1898-1904
Rev. Edg-ar E. Brooks 1904-1908
Rev. James A. McCIeary 1908-1912
Rev. Robert J. Thompson 1912-1914
Rev. Waiter E. Howe 1915-
After his return from Germany, where he represented the Amer-
ican Church for a long period, Dr. Butterworth was elected Rector
Emeritus. His death occurred May, 1921.
Walter E. Howe.
THE FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH
Corner of Richards Avenue and Union Street
The first meeting which led to the organization of the First Baptist
Church of Dover was held in Bennett's Hall on Blackwell street, Feb-
ruary 2i2, 1892, under the leadership of Rev. W. H. Shawger, pastor
at Netcong, and Wm. H. Morey of Dover. The organization of the
church was completed on September 18, 1893, by request of thirty-
nine members of the Netcong Baptist Church and residents of Dover
who withdrew from Netcong, with deacons and trustees as follows :
Deacons — ^Obadiah Parker, Sr., Char.les Parker, Peter Swayze;
Trustees — James H. Rhone, Eugene Ayres, Thomas Headland, Wm.
Morey. Clerk and treasurer, Wm. Morey.
The laying of the cornerstone of the church building took place
on Sunday, P. M., December i, 1895, Rev. David Spencer, D.D., giving
the address and laying the stone. Dedication of the church edifice
took place on Sunday afternoon, April 5, 1896. Dedication sermon was
preached by Rev. D. De Wolf, superintendent of missions, of Newark.
Rev. E. O. Wilson was appointed pastor in 1921.
Pastors of the Church :
Rev. W. H. Shawger 1893-
Rev. Melvin Shelford 1902-1904
Rev. John FI. Earle 1904-1906
Rev. Robert Gordon 1906-1908
Rev. John A. Cortright 1908-1910
Rev. T. J. Winslade, Ph.D 1910-1918
Rev. F. P. Bemensderfer 1918-1920
Rev. Edwin O. Wilson 1921-
i66
CHRYSTAL STREET CHAPEL
iprom Mrs. Stephen A. Broadwell (Rachel A.) I have obtained the
following information about the Chrystal Street Chapel.
On November i6, 1879, ^^^s. Alexander Searing (Jane), residing
on the top of Chrystal street, gathered children together in her parlor
for a Sunday School. Mr. C. J. Broadwell was superintendent and
Mr. Oliver Freeman of the First Presbyterian Church of Dover, his
assistant. To meet a growing need Mrs. Searing later gave a lot and
the people erected a small, one-room house (14x14), which may still
be seen on Chrystal street, now a dwelling, but looking as if it had
-once been something else, like other discarded church buildings in
Dover. Mrs. Searing deeded this lot and building to the Grace M. E.
Church of Dover. Then it was enlarged and as Grace Church was
in need of money they sold it to the Presbyterians. The school grew.
Then the Presbyterians bought from Wellington C. Casterline the
site of the present Chapel, on the corner of Morris street and Chrystal
rstreet, and in 1892 built the edifice now known as Chrystal Street
Chapel. Mr. E. J. Ross was much interested in this. In 1908 the
Presbyterian Church sold the property to the people of the neighbor-
Tiood. represented by Wm. W. Sickles, J. D. Pedrick and Edward A.
Smith.
Union prayer meetings and a Union Sunday School are held here.
The people belong to various churches in Dover, but unite in these
neighborhood meetings. They invite leaders and singers from many
places to conduct the meetings, which are well attended and heartily
supported by the people.
SWEDISH TRINITY LUTHERAN CHURCH
From 1872 to 1874 religious services in the Swedish language
were held in the Presbyterian Church of Dover. These services were
conducted by Mr. A. B. Lilja, then a young man interested in religious
work. In 1889 the Swedish Trinity Lutheran Church was organized
and Mr. Lilja was ordained as pastor. Since that time Mr. Lilja has
Jiad other charges, as at Wilkesbarre, has been a missionary of his
people in this country, and has established thirty-three congregations
,of the Swedish church in Connecticut. New Jersey and Pennsylvania.
He has worked in New York and Philadelphia in behalf of his people
-and was instrumental in bringing many Swedes to Dover to work in
the D., L. & W. carshops when they were operated here. There are
said to have been about five hundred Swedes here then. After the
.carshops removed from Dover many of the Swedes went away to Cali-
iornia, Canada and Michigan.
Rev. A. B, Lilja, D.D., now the venerable pastor of the church
at the corner of Blackwell and Mercer streets, has been settled in
Dover since 1912. The church numbers seventy-eight members; Sun-
day School, 62. Services in Swedish in the morning; English in the
evening.
J 67
THE SWEDISH BAPTIST CHURCH, founded January i,
1889. Situated on the corner of Belmont avenue and Linn street.
Known as "The little Church 'round the corner."
Rev. Carl Wesgerdahl, of Newark, comes to conduct services.
FACTS ABOUT THE SWEDISH BETHLEHEM CHURCH
(CONGREGATIONAL)
(Organized as a Missionary Association, Dec. 6, 1890.)
The Swedish Bethlehem Church was organized May 26, 1894,
with 16 members. Present membership 66. Church building, located
at the corner of Union and River streets, was erected and dedicated
1898.
Ministers serving the Church a longer or shorter time:
O. Sjoberg O. W. Arell
G. D. Hall G. Bloom
L. Akeson A. Liljestrand
J. A. Dahlgren E. Person
F. Jertberg N. O. Lind (The present minister — Located
90 Morris street. Began his ministry in Dover, August 24, 1920.)
The Sunday School has a membership of 90. Young People's
Society 43, Ladies' Aid 23.
OTHER CHURCHES
The society of the Free Methodist Church was organized in 1871.
The stone building which they occupy on Sussex street was erected
in 1872. Rev, G, E. La Fave is the pastor.
In 1872 this congregation used the first church edifice of the
First Presbyterian Congregation, then vacant because the Presbyter-
ians had erected their second building. A picture of these two
Presbyterian buildings is shown in Dover History.
The Free Methodists completed their own stone edifice on Sussex
street, on a lot donated by Manning Searing. It was dedicated on
December 8, 1872. The cost was $5,000. The Free Methodists advo-
cated inexpensive buildings.
Rev. W. M. Parry was their preacher in 1872.
In 1865, in the little town of Perry, New York State, some Metho-
dists who believed it wrong for a member of their society to hold
slaves or uphold the institution of slavery withdrew from their former
church connection and formed the Free Methodist Church, thus regis-
tering tlieir conviction that slaves should be set free, and that Christ*
ians should live the life of spiritual freedom and holiness.
i6&
The Christian and Missionary Alliance of Dover, N. J., has held
meetings here for about eighteen years and is now using the church
edifice of the Swedish Methodist Church, 21 Hudson street.
Rev. C. Paul Gates has been the pastor of this society since 1917.
Previously services were conducted by students from the Missionary
Institute at Nyack, N. Y., a training school, undenominational and
interdenominational, founded by the late Rev. A. B. Simpson, D.D.,,
a Presbyterian minister of New York City and Canada.
The society has 350 missionaries in eighteen mission fields.
The Swedish Methodist Cliurch has ceased to hold services. The
members have, for the most part, joined the other Methodist churches
in town. The building which they once occupied on Hudson street is
now rented to the Christian Alliance, whose pastor is Rev. Paul Gates.
The Salvation Army has carried on in Dover since about 1900.
Their Captain now is Arthur Woodruff and they occupy a newly fitted-
up Chapel at 14 South Morris street, next to the playhouse. They
conduct a Sunday School numbering 150 to 175. They plan to equip
the top floor of their building as a public gymnasium. They have an
Advisory Board : Albert Sedgman, Chairman ; Eugene L. White, sec-
retary ; Edward Jenkins, treasurer ; William F. Birch, Paul Guenther,
Charles N. Polaski. William S. White, R. F. Woodhull, Emil Katter-
mann, and John Price.
The Gaines A. M. E. Mission has been holding religious services
in the Annex of the Northside School.
The Mt. Zion Baptist Church has been holding services in Youngle-
son's Hall for about four years.
There are in Dover about twenty-five disciples of Pastor Russell
of Brooklyn. They take the name of International Bible Students,
and meet for Bible study.
Adath Israel of Dover, New Jersey, Inc., is the name of the
Orthodox Hebrew Congregation that meets Friday evening and Satur-
day morning and evening in the hall over Pierson's Clothing Store, 6
West Blackwell street. Services are held in Hebrew. The society
was organized October 18, 19 17, with thirty-two charter members and
the following officers : Barney Harris, president ; Rev. Solomon
Nimoityn, vice-president; Charles Harris, treasurer; Milton Goldman,
secretary. 1
169
MINE HILL
The Mine Hill Presbyterian Church has been associated with the
First Presbyterian Church of Dover in such a way that it may be allow-
able to include a notice of it in this book of Dover and vicinity.
In the Magie history of Dover churches we learn that Welshmen
employed in the mines of Mt. Pleasant and Mine Hill used to assemble
for religious service in 1850, led by a Welsh preacher, John R. Jenkins.
Mr. Jenkins removed later to Ohio. In 1859, this Welsh congregation
united with the Dover Presbyterian Church. In 1869. twenty-eight
members of the Dover church withdrew to constitute the Welsh Presby-
terian Church of Richard Mine, and Rev. John R. Jenkins, returning
from Ohio, became their pastor.
Meantime Pearce Rogers had conducted religious services in the
schoolhouse at Mine Hill, with a Sunday School superintended by
David Jenkins. The pastor of the Dover church often preached there.
In 1874, twenty-four members of the Dover church withdrew to consti-
tute the Presbyterian church of Mine Hill. Rev. Pearce Rogers was
regularly installed as pastor, September 22, 1874. A church edifice was
erected and, in the summer of 1879, dedicated free of debt. Mr. Rogers
continued as pastor until his death, January 8, 1893.
The Mine Hill church was under the care of Dr. Halloway of
Dover, for a time, who arranged for religious services there. Hilliard
Gage preached here for a time. Rev. Mr. Todd was pastor for a brief
time.
Then Rev. Theodore F. Chambers became the pastor, conducting
services also in Luxemburg and Berkshire Valley.
The present pastor, Rev. George McPherson Hunter, was installed,
September, 191 7. Mr. Hunter has written short stories published in
various magazines and is the author of the following books : Morning
Faces, When I Was a Boy in Scotland, and Gardens of Green.
In considering how best to secure information about our churches,
I first thought it would be well for the ministers' club, if they had one,
to take up the matter, collect data, and appoint one of their number to
write a discourse on The Function of the Church in the Development of
This Community — or any community, for that matter. But this has
not been done. If you want to hear from the clergy, attend any church
in Dover. I am doing the best I can in the circumstances, as a mere
layman. But I want something besides statistics and dates to represent
"The Function of the Church," of Religion, in the upbuilding of com-
munity life. To fill this gap my historical poem on Mine Hill Church,
in commemoration of their pastors, may do duty, although not written
for this purpose; and its concluding summary of a sermon by Mr.
Chambers may serve as the utterance of the clergy, for which I was
seeking, upon this theme.
17©
MINE HILL CHURCH
LANDMARK seen from afar, stands Mine Hill Church on the
hilltop,
Lifting its spire to the sky, a beacon light of the Gospel.
Here was a mining town, the Dickerson Mine and the Byram
Made it a busy place, the folk were numbered by hundreds.
5 Men from Cornwall and Wales came over the ocean to labor
Here in these New World mines and delve for iron in our hillsides ;
Men whose sires were skilled to garner deephidden treasure,
Iron and coal and tin — shrewd men with a lineage hidden
Far back in times when daring Phoenician seamen and traders
lo Sought for the Briton's tin to mingle with copper, so making
Weapons of bronze and utensils better than those of their fathers.
Better than wood and stone, for betterment comes with the ages.
Long ago were those days when the mystic relics of Stonehenge,
Huge, unshapen stones, were marshalled in order mysterious ;
35 Long ago were the days, when, deep in the forest, the Druids
Ruled those tribes of the dawn, whose hearts were thrilled by the
awesome
Gloom of the ancient oaks of the wood with wide-spreading
branches,
Gleam of the glittering stars of the sky, that change with the seasons
And by the still, small voice of a Spirit within them and o'er them,
20 Round about them, creative, life-giving, earth-shaping, heaven-
ruling.
From those far-away days we come to the church on the hilltop,
Landmark seen from afar, the Mine Hill Church where the pilgrim
Miner folk of these hills, strong men and women and children,
Met for worship when Dominie Rogers stood in that pulpit.
25 Godfearing men they were and here they builded their temple,
Lifting their hearts to the God of light who rules in the heavens.
Building their lives on his gospel truth, revealed by the Saviour.
Heartily they rejoiced in their new built church on the hilltop ;
Thronged was the house of God — four hundred gathered to worship,
30 Led by their pastor beloved, Pearce Rogers, son of a miner,
Miner himself, for gold, then teacher and preacher and head man
Over the Millen Mine: he knew the hearts of his people,
Knew their ways and their work, their trials, sorrows and hardships.
He was a Cornish man, but he knew the Welsh and their country,
35 Knew how to comfort his flock with solace drawn from the Scrip-
tures,
Not so learned in books as in the life of his people,
Skilled in the winning of souls, more precious to him than hid
treasure.
Who are the folk who have met in days gone by at this altar?
What are the names lof those who have rallied so long with their
children?
171
40 In this house of God to hear His word, sing His praises
Cornish names we find, and mingled with them are Welshmen —
THOMAS and JENKINS and BRAY, and CURNOW and
ENNOR and WILLIAMS,
BATH and POWELL and WHITTEMORE, TONKING.
TREDINNICK and others,
MARTIN, MILLEN and BASSETT— but who can tell all the
faithful ?
45 Music-loving, fervent, eloquent, orderly, steadfast;
Not much given to waves of excitement, but holding the standard
Ever aloft, though few were their numbers and short were their
purse-strings,
David Jenkins, a genuine Welshman and Elder beloved,
Founded the Sabbath School, the righthand man of his pastor.
50 Head of the Byram Mine was he, well versed in his calling,
Knowing the working of ore and how to deal with his workmen,
Caring most for the Kingdom of God, for treasure in heaven.
Rogers and Jenkins, they stood shoulder to shoulder as brothers,
Pillars, upholding the Church, with hearts of zealous devotion,
55 Seeking and finding the truth divine of the Holy Scriptures
As strong men who think for themselves and cherish the wisdom
Found in that grand old book, the treasure-trove of the ages.
Soon came the long, lean years, when panic reached to these hill-
tops.
Years when the mines shut down and the iron foundries of Dover
60 Ceased from their wonted toil, when plenty failed and dread hunger
Drove men forth from their homes to seek their fortune wherever
Work could be found. First the younger men, lighthanded, light-
hearted.
Had to go out and find for themselves, as their fathers before them.
Where the world had need of their young blood, vigor, and courage,
■65 Founding new homes and learning new trades, if need be, but
keeping.
Deep in their hearts the love of the old folks and cherishing ever
Memories of the faith and love that nourished their childhood.
Now, when the time drew near that many must go from this parish,
Dominie Rogers bade them assemble and hear from this pulpit
70 Words of kindly farewell and admonition and counsel.
Taking his text from Job, he preached an old-fashioned sermon.
Canst thou bind, said he, the Pleiades fast in the heavens?
Freely they wander from zone to zone like the wandering miner.
Seen in all parts of the world and shedding sweet influence — like
them
75 May you be where you go. I ask you then to look upward,
Find these stars in the sky and see them shining above you,
Just as they shine to-night — then think of father and mother.
Think of the Church on the hill and say, "God bless you and keep
yon'
I"
172
So he touched their hearts. He loved the stars and observed th3m^
80 Searching the sky with his glass, as their gleaming hosts shone in
Clearly seen from his house on this w^ind-swept, heaven-kissed
upland.
Far, 'neath the southern skies, a lad from that number, years after,.
Driving his engine up the Chilean slopes of the Andes,
Leaning far out from his engine cab, saw, shining above him,
85 Brighter than ever, that wandering cluster, the Pleiades, shining.
Cheered was his lonely heart at the sight and he greeted them gladly,
"God bless the Mine Hill Church !" he cried, as he climbed the great
mountains.
So, from hillside and glen, the young men went on their travels ;
Older men, with homesteads fixed and upspringing households,
90 Stayed and found some way to keep things going ; a remnant
Clung to the once-filled Church with ever-stedfast devotion.
So, for a score of years, Pearce Rogers preached from this pulpit.
Then his voice was stilled, his work for Mine Hill was finished.
When Pearce Rogers was called to his rest, when ended his labors,
95 Doctor Halloway then, of Dover, for a brief season.
Took us under his wing and brought us teachers and preachers.
Hither came Hilliard Gage, a stripling then, full of promise.
Bringing the word of truth as taught in the School of the Prophets.
Elders Meeker and Ross from Dover Church put their shoulders
100 To our chariot wheels — their memory lingers among us.
Parson Todd, for a time, upheld us. Then Dominie Chambers
Took his place in the line of Apostolic Succession.
When to the little flock of stedfast souls on the hilltop
Dominie Chambers became shepherd of souls, but a remnant
105 Yet remained of those who had filled the church to the doorways.
"Hold fast !" now was the word, as Doctor Halloway put it.
When he preached on the hill at their twenty-fifth anniversary.
"Hold fast that which thou hast — no crowded meetings await you.
Here is no stately dome, no splendor of rites or of riches.
no Staying power is the test of faith and devotion and valor —
Sheer, unconquerable grit that stands by its guns undefeated
When the first glad cheers give way to the shock of the combat."
Such were the words of greeting that Doctor Halloway uttered
When to these wild, rough hills his brother pastor he welcomed.
115 Here for eighteen years, with quiet courage and patience.
Dominie Chaml^ers stood at his post and preached the pure Gospel.
Preachers, like works of art, are diflferent, not a mere copy
One of the other, and so the flock may thrive by the changes
Brought about by time and Providential disposing.
120 Son of a scholarly sire, of metropolitan nurture.
Versed in the lore of the schools, in art, in science, in letters,
Delver in genealogical mines, a local historian,
173
Parliamentarian apt, in councils august presbyterial,
Weighing with critical judgment and philosophical insight
125 Arguments pro and con, and holding fast to the better,
Dominie Chambers made his mark, a man of broad culture,
Teaching by what he was, a man withal who could cherish
Friendships rooted deep, heartening, cordial, and lasting.
Not as a man of the mines, a miner to fellow miners,
130 Spake he to his flock, as did his good predecessor;
Times had changed and he wrought among a new generation.
Those who knew no birthplace beyond the billowy ocean,
Growing to manhood here, and womanhood, speaking our language.
Taught in American schools, and seeking other vocations,
135 Learning other ways than those of their fathers, the pilgrims —
These, the upspringing race, confronting new times and new notions.
Found in Dominie Chambers a leader and guide, an instructor.
Well abreast of his times, yet holding fast to the Saviour,
140 Steering by that Pole Star and never swept from his moorings
When the clear, firm faith that cheered the fathers was challenged.
Let me tell you now of a sermon that Dominie Chambers
Preached in his time : it pleased a friend and the sermon was printed.
So that we have his words: already Fve told you the story
145 Of one sermon preached in this Church— the Pleiades sermon.
Preached to men who were leaving their homes and the Church on
the hilltop.
Found in the ancient psalms, the text is now "A Church-goer" —
One who went up to the house of the Lord and worshipped with
gladness
When the tribes went up to praise the Lord in Mount Zion.
150 Climbing a hill was then a prelude to worship, a lifting
Up of the eyes to the heights, a drawing nearer to heaven,
Breathing a finer air with exhilaration of spirit.
Taking a wider view of life, rejoicing with others
In the name of the Lord, the fountain-head of thanksgiving.
155 Can we catch to-day, with all our inventions and progress —
Can we feel and value aright the perennial freshness
Of those age-old lyrics of worship sung on Mount Zion?
Human hearts were then as deeply thrilled, as responsive
To "the joy of the Lord" as now and uttered their praises
160 In as noble a song as any latter-day choral
Sung by a tuneful choir: we still repeat the old anthems.
Learning from ancient bards to join in hymning the goodness,
Loving kindness and mercies untold of God our Redeemer.
So the old tribes went up — Judah and Benjamin, joining
165 With their brethren — never so mighty, so glad, so united
As when they met in the Mount of the Lord and sought for his
blessing.
When on their waiting hearts the spirit descended, they cherished
174
Memories of such hours as life's most precious possessions.
Is there still a way for us to seek and to find Him?
170 Are there heavenly gates that we may enter and stand there
Rapt in ecstasy keen as theirs, with faith as well founded ?
Yes, we may come to His house, may enter His other-world portals.
Not forgetting our work-a-day life, the duties that bind us
Close to our fellowmen, the human ties that unite us,
175 Like the tribes of old, in brotherhood — union ennobling!
Could all nations be led to one great Mount of Assembly,
Join in anthems sweet of brotherly kindness and worship.
Lift united hearts in prayer and praise to their Maker,
180 Where were then the strife, the envy, bloodshed, and hatred
Century-old — the curse that haunts man's history ever?
Pray for a City blest and well-compacted together.
Whither the tribes go up, where thrones are set, thrones of judg-
ment.
Pray for the peace that reigns within the portals of Zion,
185 Pray for the Coming of Him whose Word of Peace is Hope's
anchor.
Then shall this world return as the wandering Dove came to Noah,
Then shall the tribes of Earth be glad indeed when the Spirit,
Gift of Pentecost, shall dwell in the hearts of God's Children.
Such was the faith that was preached from this pulpit by Dominie
Chambers,
190 Leading his folk to the Mercy Seat of God our Redeemer.
Written for the Memorial Service of January 30, 1921.
175
CEMETERIES
There are persons who remember that there was once a burying:
ground on Morris street, just about northeast of Ford's Pond. This
was done away with after the Dover Cemetery Association was organized
in 1854 under the Act of 1851. WilHam Young, the baker, of Dicker-
son street, had acquired a garden plot at the end of Orchard street.
When the Cemetery Association wished to acquire his garden plot to be
a part of the new cemetery, he relinquished it in exchange for two lots
on Orchard street.
The "first voters" of the new association were John Sandford,
Sidney Breese, Samuel Searing, Moses Hurd, Jabez Mills, Titus Berry,,
William A. Dickerson, Zenas Pruden, Jacob Segler, Aaron Doty, Byram
Pruden, Cornelius B. Gage, William Ford, Edward T. Thompson, Henry
D. Tuttle, Jabez L. Allen, James H. Neighbour.
William Young was made president.
At the present time (1922) A. Judson Coe is president, and Lyman
M. Smith is secretary -treasurer.
Locust Hill Cemetery Association was incorporated July 27, 1867,
Wm. W. Sickles has been president since 1902. Lawrence R. Hancy
is vice-president and Harry R. Gill, treasurer. The ground was form-
erly occupied in part by the Kelso family for their residence and garden.
The place was known as Kelso Hill.
One of the earliest graveyards about here was that of the Quakers
at Lampson's farm (1748) where there is now an apple orchard. The
graves, in accordance with Quaker custom, were not marked. All the
dead were laid to rest on terms of perfect equality, as far as the arrange-
ment of burial ground was concerned. A new burying ground was laid
out back of the new meeting house of 1758, about a mile west of the one
on Lampson's farm. Here, too, the graves showed no names marked on
headstones. But Mr. James Brotherton knew the name of each "by
heart." When he passed away the knowledge of names and locations
was lost.
To care for the meeting house of 1758 and the burying ground back
of it "The Friends' Meeting House and Cemetery Association of Ran-
dolph Township" was formed on 6th mo., 28th day, 1898. The Trustees
are at present: Eugene A. Carrell, president; Fred Hance, secretary;
Charles H. Brotherton, treasurer; Henry Alward, Wheeler Corwin, E.
Bertram Mott, Thomas Baker.
176
THE MT. SINAI CEMETERY ASSOCIATION
The Dover Hel^rew Society was organized in 1882 with ten mem-
bers, as follows: L. D. Schwarz, George Feder, Wm. Simon. M. Kings-
burg. S. Battlestein, D. Less and H. Heiman of Dover; A. Kaufman
of Rockaway, George Harris of Boonton, and B. Fogelson of Stanhope.
A Sundav School was organized by the Society with twenty-two
children enrolled. The average attendance was twenty, that of the
Dover children beine 98 per cent. The Societ}- was in existence until
December 14th, 1886— four years; after which most of the original
members had moved away from Dover. There are now left but two of
the original members — Wm. Simon and H. Heiman.
In 1897 the Dover Hebrew Literary Society w^s organized with ten
charter members, as follows : S. Heller. Wm. Simon. H. Rassler. C.
Polasky. J. Lowrie. L. Shreur. P. Livingston, L. Livingston, and H.
Heiman. A few months later the membership was increased to twenty.
In May of the same year the Society gave its first strawberry festival,
which netted a fine profit. In Februarv\ 1898. the Society held its first
anniversary, which netted $110.03. ^^ ^^^-Y o^ the same year a deposit
of $175 was made in the Dover bank. The treasurer's report in July
showed receipts $311.37 and disbursements $109.66. leaving a balance
of $201.71. Part of the disbursements were for aid to poor families,
amongst whom were some of other faiths.
In September, 1899. the Society bought alwut two acres of ground
for a cemetery, for which was paid $250. Over $350 more was spent
on improvements.
In May, 1898, when the United States called out our boys for
service in the army, the Society was the first to appropriate $50 to
assist the families who were in need of help.
In September, 1899. the name of the Dover Hebrew Society was
changed to the "Mt. Sinai Association." In 1904 the Association donated
$75 to the Kishinefif relief fund and also helped many families who were
in need.
The officers of the Association are: Henry Heiman, president;
Abram Schoenbrun, vice-president; William Simon, treasurer, and
Alexander Davis, secretary.
PART V
Military Organizations
178
HYMN FOR INDEPENDENCE DAY
Lo ! 'tis the morning when Liberty rose.
Claiming her birthright, m}^ Country, in thee;
Liberty, child of a world's mighty throes,
Gift of the Father, who reigns ever free.
Far, from the East, see her banner advance.
Bright with the life-blood of heroes of old,
Fair with the hopes of the day's cloudless glance,
Gleaming with light from night's lamps manifold.
Welcome, glad welcome, from ocean's wild wave !
Here plant thy banner our coasts to defend !
Welcome, glad welcome our forefathers gave ;
Blessings for aye on our children descend !
God of the nations, to Thee is our prayer;
Be Thou our helper, our guide evermore;
Grateful, we praise Thee ; O let us still share,
Share in Thy smile, as our fathers of yore.
God of the nations, we pray not alone
For the young land that our forefathers knew;
Far may Thy kingdom of mercy be known,
Wide as the sweep of Thy heaven's own blue !
y-'V"
179
MILITARY
The Colonial and early wars of our country have been fully
recorded in other books, accessible in our Public Library, such as
Stryker's ''Officers and Men of New Jersey in the Revolutionary War,"
and Munsell's History of Morris County (1882). Rev. Joseph F.
Tuttle, D.D., of Rockaway, gathered up the Morris County traditions
and local legends of the French and Indian War and the Revokition.
Upon his work, chiefly, are based the "Ballads of New Jersey in the
Revolution," which narrate many of these stories of Morris County. In
"Dover Dates" we are giving material not published before.
Alonzo B. Searing tells how, as a boy. he used to v/alk from his;
home in Millbrook to attend the military parades held then in Succa-
sunna on patriotic holidays. There he would hear the orators of the:
day and see three veterans of the War of 1812 ride in the procession,,
v/hich was lead by a venerable veteran carrying on a pole a Liberty Cap
of red, white and blue.
The three veterans of 181 2 were Byram Pruden, James Ford, and
John D. Sickles, father of our veteran fireman, Wm. W. Sickles — all o£
Dover.
General Winfield Scott, of the Mexican War, resided in Elizabeth,.
N. J., and there the author of "Dover Dates" has seen him ride out on
horseback or in a carriage drawn by a handsome pair of grays. My
grandfather was his family physician and I have dazzling recollections
of a brilliant "party" at the old mansion, which I attended when a child.
But in time the old mansion stood empty and deserted. We boys used
to climb up on the back porch roof and enter the second story windows^
roaming about the vacuous rooms, almost fearing to see the old General
appear before us. We raised terrific warwhoops to keep up our courage.
But the echoes died away in desolation. Sic transit gloria inuiidi.
His mansion is now well preserved as one of the historic land-
marks of Elizabeth.
THE GRAND ARMY OF THE REPUBLIC
July 19, 1881, the Dover veterans of the Civil War instituted the
Major Anderson Post of the Grand Army of the Republic, naming it in
honor of the loyal commander of Fort Sumter. In a few years the
name was changed to "James McDavit Post," in honor of James Mc-
Davit of Dover, who was killed, at Chancellorsville, May 3, 1863, while
binding up the wounds of his commander. Captain Thomas J. Halsey.
There were twenty-eight charter members of the Post, of whom
three now survive — George H. Wolfe. James Brannin, and A. B. Sear-
ing. The Post now numbers sixteen members, who meet in March,
June, September, and December, on the second Friday of the month,
having the following officers : E. G. Rockwell, Commander ; A. B. Sear-
ing, Adjutant; and John Burrell, Quartermaster.
T[8o
Alonzo B. Searing has long been the recognized historian of Dover's
part in the Civil War of the sixties. Many will remember his patriotic
addresses to our schools on Memorial Day occasions and the unaffected
■eloquence with which he has told of Dover's share in preserving the
Union. "The History of the Eleventh New Jersey Regiment." by
•Sergeant Thomas D. Marbaker. of Trenton, formerly a resident of
Dover, contains material furnished by Mr. Searing, relating to men of
Dover who served in that regiment.
It has long been the wish of Mr. Searing's heart that a fitting monu-
ment should be erected by Dover and Randolph Township to the soldiers
of all wars from the Revolution to the present, and this wish was
expressed by him and others on our last Memorial Day, when the statue
for the soldiers of our late war was unveiled in Hurd Park.
An extract from a poem by our fellow townsman, Uzal Newton
Crane, well expresses the sentiments that have long been cherished by
our Memorial Day Exercises in honor of the Grand Army of the
•Republic.
OUR FALLEN HEROES
Cover their dust with the brightest flowers blooming,
Affection so deep the cold world has ne'er known;
'Twill live in some hearts till Time, all-consuming.
Effaces all epitaphs graven in stone.
Children unborn shall yet rise to succeed us,
And heap up new honors where sleep the brave slain,
Who saw but decay where disunion would lead us,
But Liberty's tomb when our land lay in twain.
Deck ye their dust! the dire conflict is over,
The warriors are mute to the madness of war ;
Peace, like a halo, around them doth hover,
She beams in our skies as a bright polar star.
Strewn be their beds with floral profusion.
From Green Mountains down to the stormy Gulf -side,
They gave not their lives to giddy delusion.
Nor mighty ambition, as monarchs have died.
Theirs was the task which the right ever urges.
Incumbent on all loyal men to uphold —
Strewn be their graves from Atlantic's long surges
To far California's famed flowers and gold !
Soft be the dirge o'er the soldiers' low pillows.
Bright the banners that wave while the blossoms ye strew ;
Firm as the rocks by the storm-beaten billows
May the North and the South stand united and true !
May, 1878.
i8i
THE SPANISH-AMERICAN WAR, 1898
From a tattered copy of "The Morris Journal," of May 5. 1898, we
glean a few facts about Dover in the Spanish-American War. This
information is eked out by a little pamphlet, "Roster and Addresses of
the Second New Jersey Volunteer Infantry in the Spanish-American
War, 1898," printed at Paterson, N. J.
The Dover men belonged to Company M, having the following
officers: Captain, Edward L. Petty; First Lieutenant, John W. Roff;
Second Lieutenant, Ernest W. Goodell ; First Sergeant, Adelbert P.
McDavit ; Quartermaster Sergeant, V/arren Surnburger ; Sergeants,
Charles F. Roderer. Arthur D. Kelly. Ernest C. Dalzell, John Koerferl.
With the Dover men were a few men from Morristown and other places,
making eighty-five privates and twenty-five others — officers, corporals,
artificer, wagoner, and musicians.
The Regiment Adjutant was Captain John T. Hilton of Paterson,
N. J. The Colonel of the regiment was Edwin W. Hine of Orange,
N. J. A "Brief History" included in the Roster informs us that this
regiment was organized in Passaic, Bergen, Essex, and Morris Counties,
with headquarters at Paterson. It arrived at Sea Girt, May 2, 1898, and
was mustered into the United States service May 13, 14, and i.S, (898.
Left Sea Girt, June i. 1898, and arrived at Camp Cuba Libre, Jackson-
ville, Fla., June 3, 1898. Was assigned to the First Brigade. Second
Division, Seventh Army Corps, commanded by Major General Fitzhugh
Lee. Remained at Camp Cuba Libre until September 2, 1898.
Owing to the large number sick v/ith tyohoid fever the regiment left
Florida, September 20, T8q8. and arrived at Sea Girt. September 22,
as per orders from the War Department, to be mustered out. The regi-
ment was finally mustered out November 17. 1898.
On Monday, May second, Company M left Dover for Sea Girt.
The streets were early astir with people. Flags were flying. Photog-
raphers and amateurs were taking pictures. At the armory, soon after
eight o'clock, the men fell into line and the roll was called. Chaplain
McCormick. in behalf of William S. Collard, presented a beautiful
American flag. Three cheers were given for the flag, three for Company-
M. three for Captain Petty, three for the officers. Captain Petty then
called on Dr. David Spencer for a parting word to the Company. He
based his remarks on the name "Company M," of which he made an
acrostic. •■'
C is for Country, the whole country.
O is for Obedience.
M is for Mettle.
P is for Patriotism.
A is for American, the American continent, which takes in the United
States and Cuba, too, for right and humanity.
N Notable. You are a notable Company.
Y Yankee, which used to stand for excellence, as "A Yankee good
soldier." ,
M stands for Manhood. You comprise the manhood of Dover.
5[82
The Armory was a large biiildino^. once used as a skating rink,
occupying the ground where Birch & Basset's garage and the "Index;"
office now are, on Essex street. Here Company I\I had been accustomed
to meet and drill before the war was thought of.
The line of march from the armory was led by the Enterprise
Band, followed by Chief of Police Hagan and assistaiit IVIcElroy.
McDavitt Post G. A. R. was the escort of honor. It was a hue sight to
see the veterans of '6i with their magnificent Post flag, leading off the
*'boys of '98." Then followed the Dover Council No. 6, O. U. A. yi..
and a large concourse of citizens with Mayor Pierson in the front line.
The route taken was out Essex to Blackwell, up Blackvv^ell to Warren,
up Warren to the depot.
Farewells were soon spoken. The 9:45 train was taken. Atta^h'^d
to it were tv/o cars of the Pennsylvania Railroad on v/hich Company M
were to go through to Sea Girt. The train was in charge of Conductor
James McKay, en