^^ N^^x. ^ %^^^^^ ^h. ' -H -^w . ^ ^ K " ,V^^ .V^'" . ^ -;^ ^ .^ -:^ '^^ N .V «
.
.,^/^ % ". VJ^\]^^- '\^'
"^:
:^; O^ -c.
.0) o
Ki^ V
■^oo^
oo^
s ^ - /
THE LIFE AND DIARY OF
JOHN FLOYD
Governor of Virginia, an Apostle of Secession,
AND THE Father of the Oregon Country
BY
CHARLES H. AMBLER, Ph. D.
Author of
Sectionalism in Virginia, 1776 to 1861,
Thomas Ritchie: a Study in Virginia Politics, etc.
rxso
Copyright 1918
Charles H. Ambler, Ph. D.
APR 17 1919
RICHMOND.
KICHMOND PRESS, INC., PRINTERS
1918
©CI.A52511)9
Bebicateb
TO
My Friends, the Late Doctor George Ben Johnston
AND His Niece, Ann Mason Lee, of
Richmond, Virginia
-yi »». . 1H .^
CONTENTS
I. A Child of the Frontier 9
II. A Spokesman of the Frontier 33
III. The Oregon Country 52
IV. President Maker and Governor 76
V. An Apostle of Discontent 94
VI. John Floyd's Diary 123
PREFACE
This brief biography of John Floyd, one of Virginia's
unique characters of the first half of the last century, was
made possible by the acquisition of his papers by the
Library of Congress and by an opportunity to use his long
forgotten diary. His defense of the interests of the fron-
tier, his fight for the Oregon country, his uncompromising
stand for the state sovereignty theory of government, his
bitter hostility to the administration of Andrew Jackson,
and his part in the formation of the Whig party entitle him
to a place among the statesmen and politicians of his day.
To his contemporaries he was a visionary, known and ridi-
culed as "Old Oregon." Now, he is honored as the "Father
of the Oregon Country," his celebrated report of 1821 on
our rights and interests in the Columbia Valley bearing the
same relation to the occupation and settlement of that
part of the United States as does Richard Hakluyt*s famous
Discourse on Western Planting to the founding of the
English colonies in America.
Mr. Floyd's "Diary," published herewith, covers the
period from March, 1831 to February, 1834, and is repro-
duced in full, excepting only the daily comments of its
author upon the weather and other commonplace subjects.
The parts here given cast some new light upon the purposes
and methods of the opposition to Jackson and upon the
social life and happenings of Washington in the Jacksonian
period. It is hoped that the lapse of time and the demands
for a more scientific study of the past will be sufficient rea-
sons for the publication of this source in the unexpurgated
form in which it here appears. In bringing to light this
Diary, neither the editor nor the publisher vouches for the
truthfulness or justice of any of the references made by
Mr. Floyd to Jackson and his friends. Very few changes
have been made in the spelHng, the punctuation, the capi-
tahzation, and the paragraphing of the original document.
Mr. Floyd's "Diary" was first brought to my attention
by Mr. J. M. Battin, a former student in my classes in
Randolph-Macon College. Mr. Battin first used the
"Diary" in writing a short biography of John Floyd. His
paper was published in the John P. Branch Historical
Papers of Randolph- Macon College, June, IQ13.
In the preparation of these pages I have received helpful
assistance from the late Dr. George Ben Johnston, of Rich-
mond, Virginia, and from his niece, Ann Mason Lee, also
of Richmond. They are direct descendants from Floyd
and own his "Diary," together with other interesting and
useful source materials relating to the Floyd, Johnston, and
Preston families of Virginia. Acknowledgements are also
due the authorities of the Library of Congress and the State
Library of Virginia.
CHARLES H. AMBLER.
Randolph- Macon College,
Ashland, Va.
September 1, 1917.
LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
I. A CHIDD OF THE FRONTIER.
ALWAYS true to the interests of the
frontier and a zealous defender of the
state sovereignty theory of government,
John Floyd was, through it all, true to
his heritage and early environment. He
was, in fact, a child of the frontier, his ancestors
being, for generations, leaders in those pioneer
movements that carried settlement first into the
tidewater section of the New World, thence in turn
into the Piedmont, the Valley separating the Alle-
ghany and the Blue Ridge mountains, and finally
into the great West beyond. He first saw the light
of day near Louisville, Kentucky, on April 24,
1783, twelve days after his father, Colonel John
Floyd, had fallen a victim to the savage foe.
Reared in this frontier environment he early
learned to judge merit by individual standards. It
was from the ^^association,'' the embryo state of
the frontier, that he received his first lessons in the
inalienable right of a rational and social people im-
bued with the highest and most extensive ideas of
liberty to make all the laws and regulations neces-
sary for the common good and to alter and abolish
those laws when they failed to accomplish the ends
for which they were made. Thus to understand
this man, it will be necessary to know something of
the life and the times of his forebears.
Two brothers, Nathaniel and Walter, seem to
have been the first of the Floyds in this country.
10 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
They landed at Jamestown in their own vessel, the
Nova, a short time after the first settlement there
and seem to have been engaged for several years in
trading with the mother country. Their father,
John Floyd, a veteran of that thrilling conflict in
which the Spanish Armada had gone down to de-
feat, was a man of means and of social position.
He probably helped to equip his sons for their ad-
ventures in the new world. He was knighted at the
hands of Queen Elizabeth, and later became a writer
of some note and a lecturer in the Society of Jesus.
Wlien tobacco culture and negro slavery were
introduced into the colony of Virginia, the life of a
planter there became both attractive and profitable.
Following the impulse of the times, Walter Floyd
patented four hundred acres of land in Martin's
Hundred, and five years later, in 1637, Nathaniel
became the owner and proprietor of eight hundred
fifty acres in Isle of Wight County. These two
pioneers in the conquest of the Tidewater thus be-
came the progenitors of the many families which
bore their name in that section.^
It was not until near the middle of the eigh-
teenth century and until after two generations of
their ancestors had passed away that we hear any-
thing more of the Floyds in Virginia. About that
time a feeling of unrest and dissatisfaction, fol-
lowed later by political revolutions and readjust-
ments, was abroad in the world. It had extended
even to the tobacco growers of Virginia, who, de-
spite the comparative newness of their lands, now
fell victims of that wanderlust which carried the
Floyds forth, at intervals more or less regular, in
A CHILD OF THE FRONTIER 11
search of new homes. William, John, and Charles
Floyd answered the call and set out on a surveying
expedition which carried them along the James to
the Blue Ridge Mountains. Already that pictur-
esque frontiersman, Alexander Spotswood, had led
the way and had founded a settlement in the Pied-
mont. Numerous other surveys had been made in
the country so that there was nothing very remark-
able in the journey of the Floyds to the Blue Ridge,
Its significance is in the fact that they were on the
move. Soon after their return John cast his lot
with the North and was lost to his family. Charles
went to the South and became the progenitor of a
long line of descendants, among whom was General
John Floyd, a famous Indian fighter and a repre-
sentative from Georgia in Congress. William, the
grandfather of the subject of this sketch and the
ancestor of the Virginia-Kentucky branch of the
Floyd family, returned to the uplands of his native
state, finding a home in Amherst County which was
then on the very outskirts of the slaveholding so-
ciety.
William Floyd had received the rudiments of a
substantial education and, as a surveyor, early rose
to prominence on the frontier. He became the
owner of a large tract of land which he himself pat-
ented and was, during a large part of his life, both
county surveyor and captain of the county militia.
Shortly after his arrival in Amherst County he
married Abadiah, the beautiful daughter of Robert
Davis, a large landholder on the upper James, who
had married a half-breed Indian girl. There is a
family tradition of uncertain origin that traces the
12 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
ancestry of this girl to the great Indian chieftain
Opechancanough. However that may be, the de-
scendants of William Floyd and his wife, Abadiah,
have never ceased to be prond of the Indian blood
that courses through their veins and to hold in
highest esteem the memory of their maternal ances-
tor.
William Floyd and his wife, Abadiah, had
twelve children: Sarah, who married Wyatt Powell
and became the ancestor of a noted line of descend-
ants, in the succeeding generations in Virginia;
Elizabeth, who married Charles Tuley whom she
later accompanied to Kentucky, whence her children
spread to all parts of the great Northwest; John,
the father of the subject of this biography; Charles,
who played a prominent part in the Revolutionary
War, aided George Rogers Clark, and gave a son
for the Lewis and Clark Expedition; Robert and
Isham, who lost their lives in encounters with the
Indians while fighting under the command of
George Rogers Clark; Nathaniel, who saw gallant
service under Jackson at New Orleans; Jemimah
and Abadiah, whose husbands were killed in Indian
massacres ; and three other girls, who are known to
the family only as Mrs. Pryor, Mrs. Drake, and
Mrs. Alexander.
Because they were, in many respects, typical of
the other families that carried settlement and civil-
ization into the frontier, it should be noted, in this
connection, that the sons and daughters of Wil-
liam Floyd came from a home of refinement and
even of wealth. Their ancestors represented the
best in the culture and taste of two races and were
A CHILD OF THE FRONTIER 13
numbered among the landholding aristocrats who
lived in almost regal splendor on the banks of the
upper James, and who were only one generation
and a few score miles removed from the aristo-
crats of the Tidewater. They were thus able to
extend to the Valley and to the country beyond a
modified, yet discernible, form of the plantation
life. Thus amid all the privations and hardships
of the frontier, they never forgot or abandoned the
distinctive traits of the Virginia gentleman, in emu-
lation of whom they became leaders among their
fellows upon the battlefields and in the political
arenas of the frontier.
John, the eldest son of Abadiah and William
Floyd, was born in Amherst County, Virginia, in
1751. At the age of eighteen he married a Miss
Burfoot who died twelve months after their mar-
riage. Disconsolate he now sought new friends
and new fortunes in the land beyond the mountains.
About 1770 he went to Botetourt County and found
employment first as a teacher and later as a clerk in
the land-office of Colonel William Preston, sur-
veyor of Fincastle County. When not thus em-
ployed he rode as a deputy sheriff with Daniel
Trigg, both being employed by Colonel William
Christian, high sheriff of Botetourt County.
Shortly thereafter, the officers and soldiers, who
had land claims in the West for services rendered
in the French and Indian War, made application to
Colonel Preston to have their lands located and
surveyed. Accordingly a party of surveyors was
sent into the trans- Alleghany country. Floyd's
services in the land office and in the bailiwick had
14 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
"~^een such that Colonel Preston selected him as one
of the party and commissioned him a captain. In
the spring of 1774 he set out for the **Dark and
Bloody Land'' with his companions: James Doug-
las, Isaac Hite, Alexander Spotswood Dandridge,
Thomas Hanson (who kept a journal), James
Knox, Frederick McCra, and Mordicai Batson.
Notwithstanding the fact that the relations be-
tween the white man and the savage had become
alarming, that the inhabitants of what is now
southwestern Virginia were abandoning their out-
posts and retreating to the more thickly settled
communities, and that the newspapers of the East
were demanding war for the protection of the
frontier, the band of surveyors pressed on to the
task before them. On the long and tedious joui-v
ney down the Kanawha and the Ohio, Floyd,
though yet a young man, seems to have been the
moving spirit among his companions. After they
had passed the Falls of the Kanawha, on April 14,
1774, it was he who provided the canoe that carried
most of the party beyond the '^burning spring" and
into the midst of the hostile red men who were now^
jealously watching the Ohio; it was he who sur-
veyed the lands for Colonel George Washington on
the Kanawha and for Patrick Henry and others on
the Ohio; and it was he who provisioned his com-
panions by the aid of his trusty rifle and inspired
them to press on in the face of the dangers which
seemed to surround them on all sides.
By the middle of May, 1774, Floyd and those of
his companions who had not turned back for fear of
the Indians were in the ^* Kentucky country.'' A
A CHILD OF THE FRONTIER 15
few days later a canoe driven by two Indians and
flying a red flag came down the Ohio. The Indians
bore passes from the commandant at Fort Pitt and
had come to warn the hunters and trappers that a
war was on between the whites and the Shawnees.
The news which they bore of the frightful massa-
cres which had already taken place caused some of
the party to turn back, but '*Mr. Floyd and the
rest of the surveyors were determined to do the
business they came on if not repulsed by a greater
force than themselves/' Accordingly they pressed
vigorously to the work of surveying on the Ohio
River and on the waters of Bear Grass and Elk
Horn Creeks. Among the tracts surveyed by Floyd,
to say nothing of those surveyed by Hancock Tay-
lor and others already in the field, were six for
Patrick Henry comprising seven thousand four
hundred acres, five for Colonel William Christian
aggregating eight thousand acres, two for Alexan-
der Spotswood Dandridge, making three thousand
acres, a tract of one thousand acres for Colonel
William Preston, and one of one thousand acres for
himself.
Meanwhile the Indians continued to press down
in ever greater numbers, and Colonel Preston be-
gan to have concern for the safety of his survey-
ors. Accordingly he secured, through the aid of
Captain William Russell, the services of two sea-
soned woodsmen, Daniel Boone and Michael
Stoner, to go as runners through Kentucky and
warn the surveyors and the outlying settlers of the
impending perils. Before they reached the Ken-
tucky country the Indians had already penetrated
16 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
to the very midst of the surveyors and murdered
James Hamilton and James Cowan, pioneer set-
tlers. Coming upon the scene of this barbarity,
James Douglas and others of Floyd's companions
fled by way of the Ohio and Mississippi Eivers to
New Orleans. Deserted by his companions and of-
ficially apprised of the impending danger, Floyd
could hold out no longer. He at once set out by the
most direct routes for the settlements in the Val-
ley of Virginia, where he arrived after a journey
of sixteen days, which led ^^ through mountains
almost inaccessible and ways unknown." It is
probable that he followed, for a part of the distance
at least, the route taken by Christopher Gist in
1751.
Upon his arrival in the Clinch Valley, Floyd
found his countrymen busy and even enthusiastic
in their preparations for Dunmore's War. AH
realized that the long series of mutual grievances
and outrages between the frontiersmen of Pennsyl-
vania and Virginia on the one side, and the savages
of the Ohio Valley on the other, had reached a
crisis pregnant with weal or woe. In his inability
to restrain his subjects upon the frontier, who ** ac-
quire no attachment to place and who ever imagine
the lands further off are still better than those
upon which they are already settled," Lord Dun-
more had issued a circular letter calling out the
militia of the western counties for a part in the
impending conflict. Dunmore himself was on his
way to Fort Pitt and had sent word to Colonel An-
drew Lewis **to raise a respectable body in your
quarter [southwestern Virginia], and join me
A CHILD OF THE FRONTIER 17
either at the mouth of the Great Kanawha or
Wheeling, or such other point on the Ohio as may
be most convenient/' The summons had also
reached the county lieutenants and the local mili-
tary officials, among whom great rivalry prevailed
in the contest then on for excellence in raising and
equipping companies of soldiers.
Although the main army had already assembled
at Camp Union on the Big Levels of the Greenbriar
River and was about ready to march under the
command of the gallant Lewises, Floyd began to
raise a company of his own, hoping to join his fel-
low soldiers before they reached the common en-
emy. The best soldiers had already enlisted, and
Floyd did not, therefore, wish his friend Preston
^Ho take too much notice '^ of the news that might
reach him of the efforts and means being used to get
others. He was certain that all could be explained
when they met and that all differences between
rival commanders could then be adjusted. He suc-
ceeded in raising one of the best companies that
ever went out of the Valley to meet any foe.
Hoping to return by way of Kentucky and to
finish his surveys Floyd set out with his command
late in September, following the line of march of
the main army. We next hear of him from Point
Pleasant six days after the decisive battle which
took place there on October 10, 1774, between the
Indians commanded by Cornstalk and the whites
commanded by Colonel Andrew Lewis and his
brother Charles. He had arrived on the night of
the battle but too late to take part in it. While yet
twelve or fifteen miles from the scene of action.
18 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
messengers brought reports of the conflict which
waged just ahead, and of the uncertainty of the out-
come. Inspired by the prayers of those who fought
and of those who sought to aid them he hastened
onward covering the whole distance in a single
afternoon, but, when he arrived, the defeated en-
emy had fled never again to threaten the whites on
the Ohio in such formidable numbers.
When the troops were ready for march from the
mouth of the Kanawha, the season was too far ad-
vanced and the contest with the Indian was too un-
certain to permit Floyd to return by way of Ken-
tucky, as he had planned. April 21, 1775, found
him in PowelPs Valley, twelve miles from Cumber-
land Gap, ready to reenter the Kentucky country
by that popular route. It mattered not that the red
man, in defence of his hunting-grounds, persisted
in carrying war and massacre into the very midst
of the settlements that were being made there. The
lands they sought to defend were the only diet that
satisfied the appetites of the pioneers. Already the
contest for Kentucky had passed into a chaotic
scramble for the best and the next best lands, and
it was thus necessary for Floyd to be on the scene
of action to protect the interests of those whom he
represented.^ Several independent companies were
making surveys there, and Eichard Henderson and
his associates from the Watauga Valley had pur-
chased the Indian title to several million acres in
central Kentucky. Floyd saw plainly that the set-
tlements were ruining the hunting-grounds of the
**Tawas and the Kickapoos'' and dreaded the con-
sequences, but he too had the land hunger and
A CHILD OF THE FRONTIER 19
pressed onward. This time he marched at the
head of a band of thirty-two tried frontiersmen
who were resolved to **foree their way into the
country'' and to maintain their ground in the face
of the savage foe and in defiance of their white
competitors.
Floyd and his party seem to have made a first
stop near Stamford in what is now Lincoln County,
Kentucky. Joining with Henderson and others, his
supposed rivals, he lent a hand to the efforts then
on foot to establish law and order in the frontier.
Thus he was able to play an important part in the
organization of the first Anglo-American govern-
ment on the west side of the Alleghanies. A move-
ment was on to create a fourteenth colony to be
called Transylvania which was to be provided with
*^a plan of government by popular representa-
tion.'' To this end a representative assembly com-
posed of delegates from the towns or settlements of
Boonesborough, 'Harrodsburg, Boiling Spring, and
St. Asaph was summoned to meet at Boones-
borough on May 23, 1775, to agree upon a form of
government and enact such laws and regulations
as were required to meet the immediate needs of
the proposed colony. Floyd was sent as a delegate
from the St. Asaph settlement.
After listening to a speech from Richard Hen-
derson, the father of the proposed new colony, in
which might come from the proposed scheme, andX
** solid consequence" of their deliberations to '*the
peace and harmony of thousands," to the blessings
which he called attention to the importance andX
to their right, surrounded as they were by dangers
20 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
which threatened their destruction, to make all
laws for the regulation of their conduct ** without
giving offence to Great Britain, or any of the Amer-
ican colonies/' the delegates provided for courts
of justice. Floyd became a member of the first
court that met under their authorization. The dele-
gates also provided for the organization of a mili-
tia, for the preservation of game, and for a system
of fees. They adjourned after four days, and the
proposed colony of Transylvania ceased to be
heard of; but their efforts marked the initial step
of the process by which Kentucky later entered
the Union.
Floyd's work and appearance on this occasion
were described, sixty-five years later by John
Morehead in a famous address as follows :
Alternately a surveyor, a legislator, and a soldier, his dis-
tinguished qualities rendered him at once an ornament and a
benefactor of the infant settlements. No individual among
the early pioneers was more intelligent or better informed;
more displayed on all occasions that called for it, had a bolder
or more undaunted courage. His person was singularly attrac-
tive. With complexion unusually dark, his eyes and hair were
deep black and his tall spare figure was dignified by the ac-
complishments of a well bred Virginia gentleman. Connecting
himself with the Transylvania Company he became their prin-
cipal surveyor and was chosen a delegate from the town of
St. Asaph .... to make laws for the infant colony.s
Following his initial experience as a legislator
Floyd continued to make surveys of land until late
in the summer of 1776. The letters which he wrote
meanwhile to Colonel Preston tell the story of the
occupation of the Kentucky country. They tell of
A CHILD OF THE FRONTIER 21
the hundreds who were pouring into the new land
by way of the Ohio River and the Cumberland Gap,
of the log cabins which were being erected both by
those who came as permanent settlers and those
who sought adventure, of the failure of the Vir-
ginia convention to take proper steps for the pro-
tection of the frontiers and the regulation of land
sales, of the pernicious activity of ^^Jack Jones'^
(Gabriel Jones) at the head of the Harrodsburg
^* banditti," of the Bryans and other Tories on the
Elk Horn, and of the numerous contests between
rival land claimants.* Because of the unusual and
thrilling narrative contained therein his letter of
July 21, 1776, to Colonel Preston is here given in
full as follows :
My Dear Sir, The situation of our country is much altered
since I wrote you last. The Indians seem determined to break
up our settlement; and I really doubt, unless it is possible to
give us some assistance, that the greater part of the people
may fall a prey to them. They have, I am satisfied, killed
several whom, at this time, I know not how to mention. Many
are missing, who some time ago went out about their business,
of whom we can hear nothing. Fresh sign of Indians is seen
almost every day. I think I mentioned to you before some dam-
age they had done at Lee's town. On the seventh of this
month they killed one Cooper on Licking Creek, and on the
fourteenth a man whose name I know not, at your salt spring
on the same creek.
On the same day they took out of a canoe in sight of this
place. Miss Bessie Callaway, her sister Frances, and a daughter
of Daniel Boone — the last two about thirteen or fourteen years
old, and the other grown. The affair happened late in the
afternoon. They left their canoes on the opposite side of the
river from us, which prevented our getting over for some time
to pursue them. We could not that night follow more than
22 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
five miles. Next morning by daylight, we were on their track;
but they had entirely prevented our following them by walking
some distance apart through the thickest cane they could find.
We observed their course and on which side they had left their
sign, and travelled upwards of thirty miles. We then supposed
they would be less cautious In travelling, and making a turn
in order to cross their trace, we had gone but a few miles, when
we found their tracks in a buffalo path — pursued and over-
took them in going about ten miles, just as they were kindling
a fire to cook. Our study had been how to get the prisoners
without giving the Indians time to murder them after they
discovered us. We saw each other nearly at the same time.
Four of us fired, and all rushed on them, by which they were
prevented from carrying anything away except one shot gun
without ammunition. Mr. Boone and myself had each a pretty
fair shot, as they began to move off. I am well convinced I
shot one through, the body. The one he shot dropped his gun —
mine had none. The place was covered with thick cane, and
being so much elated on recovering the three poor little heart-
broken girls, we were prevented from making any further
search. We sent the Indians off almost naked — some without
their moccasins, and none of them with so much as a knife or
tomahawk. After the girls came to themselves sufficiently to
speak, they told us there were only five Indians — four Shawnese
and one Cherokee. They could speak good English, and said
they should then go to the Shawnese towns. The war club
we got was like those I have seen of that nation. Several
words of their language, which the girls retained, were known
to be Shawnese. They also told them that the Cherokees had
killed or driven all the people from Watauga and thereabouts,
and that fourteen Cherokees were then on the Kentucky wait-
ing to do mischief. If the war becomes general, of which there
is the greatest appearance, our situation is truly alarming.
We are about finishing a large fort, and intend to keep pos-
session of this place as long as possible. They are, I under-
stand, doing the same at Harrodsburg, and also at Elkhorn, at
the Royal spring. The settlement on Licking creek, known
by the name of Hinkston's, has been broken up; nineteen of the
settlers are now here on their way in — Hinkston among the
A CHILD OF THE FRONTIER 23
rest. They all seem deaf to any thing we can do to dissuade
theni. Ten at least of our people, are going to join them, which
will leave us with less than thirty men at this fort. I think
more than three hundred men have left the country since I
came out, and not one has arrived, except a few cabiners down
the Ohio.
I want to return as much as any person can do; but if I
leave the country now, there is scarcely one single man who
will not follow the example. When I think of the deplorable
condition a few helpless families are likely to be in, I conclude
to sell my life as dearly as I can in their defence, rather than
make an ignoble escape.
I am afraid it is in vain to sue for any relief from Vir-
ginia; yet the convention urged the settlement of this country,
and why should not the extreme parts of Fincastle be as justly
entitled to protection as any other part of th,e country? If
an expedition were carried on against these nations who are at
open war with the people in general, we might be in a good
measure relieved, by drawing them off to defend their towns.
If any thing under Heaven can be done for us, I know of no
person who would more willingly engage in forwarding us as-
sistance than yourself. I do, at the request and in behalf of all
the distressed women and children and other inhabitants of
this place, implore the aid of every leading man who may have
it in his power to give us relief. I am, etc.s
Shortly after this letter was written the Ken-
tucky country was aroused by the information that
the united colonies had declared their independence
of the mother country. The frontiersmen had
eagerly awaited such a turn in events and now
abandoned their outposts and hastened to take a
part in the efforts being put forth to make that dec-
laration effective. Floyd was the first to join their
ranks. By the most direct route possible he came
to Williamsburg, where, after presenting the griev-
ances of the pioneers, he offered his services to his
24 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
country. Dr. Thomas Walker, Edmund Pendleton,
Colonel William Preston, and two or three others
had already purchased a vessel which they planned
to fit out as a privateer. Now that a suitable com-
mander in the person of Floyd was at hand, their
plan was quickly carried out, and the Phoenix put
to sea headed for the West Indies. A few days
after leaving port it overtook and captured a rich
prize. To the commander's great surprise the car-
go contained a wedding costume for a lady. Thus
at one and the same stroke he had won his for-
tune and a suitable present for his bride to be. Miss
Jane Buchanan, a beautiful girl of the mountains
of Virginia. A happy man he hastened homeward
but was overtaken by a British man-of-war just as
he was entering the Chesapeake Bay, was captured,
and carried a prisoner to England, where he was
retained for almost a year.
Prison bars have rarely prevailed against those
types of manliness and worth possessed by John
Floyd. They now won for him the regard of his
fellow prisoners and, what was more important to
him, the heart of the jailor's daughter. The old
romantic story of a betrayal of trust was again rcr
peated; the jailor's daughter had freed her lover.
After an affectionate farewell, at which it is
said his companions shed tears, Floyd hastened to.
Dover. There he found a clergyman who assisted
him by a sort of underground railway in his efforts
to reach France. It was the vintage time when he
landed upon those friendly shores, and the people
there supplied him with grapes and bread until he
reached Paris. After recovering from an attack of
A CHILD OF THE FRONTIER 25
the smallpox he made ready for his return to
America, but not before he had purchased a pair of
brilliant shoe buckles for his bride to be and a beau-
tiful scarlet coat for himself. With the assistance
of Doctor Franklin, our representative in France,
he was soon able to secure passage on a westward
bound vessel which, after a tempestuous voyage of
many days, landed him in Virginia in the autumn
of 1778.
During the time of Floyd ^s absence no intelli-
gence of the Phoenix or her crew had reached
America, and the inference was that all had gone
down at sea. A year, the conventional mourning
time in the colonial days, had passed, and Colonel
Robert Sayers, an officer in the Revolutionary
army and a man of means had addressed Miss
Buchanan and been accepted by her. A family tra-
dition has it that they were just returning from a
walk in the garden, when the arrival of Captain
Floyd in Smithfield was announced. Joy reigned
everywhere, except possibly in the heart of Colonel
Sayers. Be that as it may, Jane Buchanan became
the bride of John Floyd and went to live with him
in the home of his father on John's Creek.
Considering the stirring times it is strange that
Floyd was content to remain inactive, even if his
wife did prefer that sort of life, for so long a time
as one year, the period of his residence with his
father. But service in the regular army was un-
attractive, and conditions upon the frontier were
anything but certain and desirable. In the latter
quarter 'Mack'' (Gabriel) Jones and Floyd's fu-
ture friend, George Rogers Clark, had defeated the
26 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
purposes of Floyd's former associates in the
Transylvania Company and had succeeded in ex-
tending the jurisdiction of Virginia over the Ken-
tucky country. Now word came that Clark, the
*^ Hannibal of the West/' was planning an expedi-
tion into the country north of the Ohio with a view
to conquering it and annexing it to Virginia.
Floyd's real interests were in the West, but the
short period of his absence had so transformed con-
ditions there as to raise doubts regarding his future
course towards it. His former associates were dis-
credited, and their land claims were in litigation in
one of the most spectacular cases ever heard in Wil-
liamsburg. Indeed, it is not improbable that
Floyd's sojourn in eastern Virginia was determined
somewhat by the pending land litigations. At any
rate he appeared as a witness and betrayed a warm
feeling for Henderson and others of the Transyl-
vania Company. His testimony may have aided
them in securing from Virginia a grant of several
thousand acres in Kentucky, as compensation for
their initial service in opening up the wilderness to
settlement.^
Clark's successes in the Northwest convinced
Floyd that the new order of things on the frontier
was permanent and unchangeable. Sympathy for
the former order of things naturally vanished, and in
October, 1779, he with his brothers, Robert, Charles
and Isham, and his sisters, Jemima and Abadiah,
with their husbands set out in the popular hegira for
the Kentucky country. They did not halt before
reaching the Falls of the Ohio, where their leader
had already preempted some of the choicest lands.
A CHILD OF THE FRONTIER 27
Here they erected a cabin at a point near the present
crossing of Third and Main Streets of Louisville,
Kentucky. This was only a temporary shelter for
the women and children, to be occupied while the
men of the company built larger cabins and stock-
ades on Bear Grass Creek a few miles distance at
a place later known as Floyd's Station.
After their families had been settled and made
secure, Floyd and his brothers found many oppor-
tunities to serve their community and country.
Every interest centered in the contest with the red
men of the forest. Clark's victories of the previous
year had aroused them to a determined resistance
to the further encroachments of the white man. Evi-
dences of British aid to the Indians were every-
where and served only to intensify the determination
of the white man. Under the circumstances no fa-
ther or husband could rest secure until the last In-
dian was driven from the Ohio Valley.
Already George Rogers Clark had inaugurated
a war of extermination, and Robert, Charles, and
Isham Floyd and their brothers-in-law had joined
him. In the long and bloody contest which followed
in this phase of ^*the winning of the West" danger
and even death crouched in every path and behind
every tree, and the Floyd brothers, except Charles,
fell victims to the savage foe. Their lives were of-
fered as sacrifices on the altar of their country that
that country might have a greater destiny.
Killing Indians was not the only service that a
patriotic frontiersman could render his community
which stood in need of laws and administration. To
these ends John Floyd, the eldest and the most ex-
28 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
perienced of the Floyd brothers, directed his chief
energies. By an act of 1780 the General Assembly
of Virginia constituted him one of a board of seven
trustees with authority to lay out and establish the
town of Louisville, which^ under their direction,
soon sprang into importance as one of the chief trad-
ing centers on the Ohio. About the same time Floyd
joined John Howard, Robert Todd, Judge Samuel
McDowell, and others in a movement to secure the
enactment of laws to conserve the peace and dignity
of their community. It was Floyd who induced John
Brown, an able lawyer of Rockbridge County, Vir-
ginia, who later became a power in the West, to cast
his lot with the people of Kentucky. His patriotic
and disinterested efforts were soon rewarded by a
commission from the Governor of Virginia making
him colonel of the militia of Jefferson County, a
position which he held with honor to the time of his
death.^
As the commander of a frontier militia Colonel
Floyd's life was one continuous round of thrilling
adventure with the red men. He planned much for
others but never hesitated himself to meet the foe.
When on his way to Louis^alle, he one day encoun-
tered a huge Indian whom he slew in single combat
and whose ornaments of silver he confiscated and
later converted into table spoons. Shortly there-
after two hundred Indians attempted to break up
Squire Boone's settlement near Shelbyville. Upon
hearing of their designs Colonel Floyd raised a com-
pany of twenty-seven men and hastened to the res-
cue. As a precaution his followers were divided
into two parties, each of which proceeded with great
A CHILD OF THE FRONTIER 29
care; but this did not prevent those under his im-
mediate command from falling into an ambuscade
and being killed, except Floyd and one or two others.
After the battle the bodies of the dead, white and red
men alike, were placed in a common grave, near the
place of the encounter, which was on a branch of
the Salt River, known to this day as ^* Floyd's
Branch of Salt River. ''^
Finding that they could not drive the frontiers-
men from their outpost on the Ohio, even with the
aid of the savage foe, the British resorted to bri-
bery. The conditions seemed opportune for suc-
cess by this method. It was a time when the ties of
patriotism sat lightly upon many; the frontier was
in constant danger and fear of attacks by the In-
dians with little hope of aid from Virginia ; and dis-
satisfaction among the settlers and the local militia
was the order of the day. Accordingly Governor
Hamilton offered Clark and Floyd each any amount
of land they might desire on the west bank of the
Ohio and an English title, if they would give up the
Ohio Valley. The offers were made separately and
secretly, and for some time neither knew that he
carried a common secret. When at length they un-
burdened their hearts to each other, each resolved to
remain loyal to the country of their nativity in whose
future greatness they had unbounded confidence.®
At length peace was made with the mother coun-
try, and the signs pointed to better times on the
frontier. In anticipation of the changed order Col-
onel Floyd invited a number of his friends in the
East to share with him the freedom and the oppor-
tunities of the frontier. The responses were numer-
30 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
ous, but reluctant to depart from the scenes of their
savage vigils the red men lingered and long remain-
ed a menace to both life and property.
The determination of the Indian to made the
white man pay dearly for his possession on the
Ohio finally cost Floyd his life. On April 12, 1783,
when he and his brother, Charles, were riding home
from a place on Salt Eiver, they were fired upon by
the Indians from ambush. On this day Floyd wore
his scarlet coat purchased in France. He was thus
a tempting mark for the Indian. At the first shot
he reeled and would have fallen to the ground, had
not his brother supported him to a place of safety.
His last hours were spent in expressions of unmit-
igated sorrow for his young wife and her unborn
child and for his two small sons. He saw for them
the common lot of the widows and orphans of the
frontier for whom he had done so much. Before
death came, on the following morning, he knew that
the end was at hand and requested that his remains
be laid to rest in a grave on an eminence overlook-
ing Floyd's Station, where they now repose.
Besides the sub.iect of this sketch Colonel Floyd
left two sons: William and George Rogers Clark.
The former was delicate and died before becom-
ing of age, but the latter followed in the footsteps of
his father in the ways of the frontiersman. He was
born in Kentucky, in 1781, and received the rudi-
ments of an education in the school near his home.
In 1807 he received a commission in the federal
army. Later he fought in the Indian wars and was
several times promoted for gallantry. He was a col-
onel under General William Henry Harrison and
A CHILD OF THE FRONTIER 31
had a command in the battle of Tippecanoe. When
this engagement began he, with others of his com-
mand, was asleep in his tent and was awakened only
by the war-whoop of the savages. Without stopping
to dress he rushed into the midst of the fight and
slew several Indians with his own hand. Upon his
return to Louisville his neighbors greeted him as
the warrior who had * * clothed himself with honor. ' '
He thought himself slighted in the official reports of
the battle and withdrew from the service. Little is
known of his later life. He died near Woodville,
Kentucky, June, 1823, and was buried near his fa-
ther.
The subject of this biography, the child of the
frontier, was the unborn infant for whom Colonel
Floyd manifested concern on his death-bed. He was
named John for his father. He learned to read and
write at his mother 's knee and in the log schoolhouse
that stood near the grave of his father. When he
was thirteen, John Brown, then a Senator from Ken-
tucky, placed him in Dickinson College at Carlisle,
Pennsylvania. Here he remained until financial
troubles necessitated his return to Kentucky. But
fortune soon took a favorable turn, his dissipated
step-father. Captain Alexander Breckenridge, dying
in 1801, young Floyd was again permitted to resume
his college course. A severe illness kept him from
carrying out his plans for graduation.
In May, 1804, young Floyd married Letitia Pres-
ton, a daughter of Colonel William Preston, his fa-
ther's friend and adviser, and soon thereafter en-
tered the University of Pennsylvania for a course
in medicine. Already he had read medicine with his
32 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
friend, Dr. Ferguson, of Louisville, and he was thus
able to graduate at the end of two years. Mean-
while, he had become an honorary member of the
Philadelphia Medical Society and a member of the
Philadelphia Medical Lyceum. His graduating dis-
sertation was entitled **An Enquiry into the Medical
Properties of the Magnolia Tripetala and Magnolia
Acuminata*' and was dedicated to his friends: Doc-
tors Ferguson, Benjamin Rush, Benjamin Smith
Burton, and James Woodhouse. After graduation
he first settled at Lexington, Virginia, but soon re-
moved to Christiansburg, where he entered actively
upon the practice of his profession and soon acquir-
ed a wide and favorable reputation as a physician.
.j^
II. A SPOKESMAN OF THE FRONTIER.
OUR second war with Grreat Britain marked
the beginning of a new era in the history
of the United States. Prior to that time we
had been in a position of semi-depen-
dence upon Europe, looking to the east-
ward to determine whether the acts of princes
bore weal or woe. Henceforth all was changed.
The American frontiersmen had made a war in be-
half of free trade and sailor's rights and carried it
to a successful conclusion though not without its un-
certainties and blunders. Now the whole country,
under their leadership, faced about and entered
upon the exercise of a new born nationality con-
ceived in hatred of the mother country and in the
hopes of our own future greatness. For a time chief
interest centered in the West, in the Indian wars,
our relations with Spain, and our efforts to acquire
and settle new territory. As a spokesman of these
interests, if for nothing else, Floyd deserves a place
in history.
That the war sentiment in Virginia, which helped
to bring about these changes, arose in her western
counties and only gradually extended to the lowlands
is now rarely disputed. That it took form among
Floyd's neighbors, whom he had for years com-
manded as a major of militia, was hardly a mere
coincidence. Be that as it may, it was the eighth
regiment of the Virginia militia, in mass meeting as-
sembled at Lexington, that first expressed the de-
sire of the state **to buckle on the armor of the
nation" and to meet the foe, if need be, in the wilds
of Canada or on the shores of the Atlantic. From
84 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
the same quarter went forth those militant petitions
which, through the skillful presentation of Thomas
Eitchie in the Richmond Enquirer, made it possi-
ble for Virginia to abandon the peace policy of her
beloved Jefferson and join in a war of national vin-
dication.
Floyd was among the first to answer the call to
arms. Tarrying only long enough to remove his
wife and family to a new home on an old estate near
the present site of the Virginia Polytechnic Insti-
tute, where they would be nearer friends, he entered
the regular army as a surgeon with the rank of
major. In this capacity he continued to serve his
country until 1814, when he was elected to the Gren-
eral Assembly.
Before entering the General Assembly, Floyd
again changed his residence, this time to the * * Thorn
Spring'' on a large plantation in Montgomery
County. Here he continued to practice his profes-
sion for a number of years, making for himself a
warm place in the hearts of the country folk who
knew him then and ever afterwards as ^* Doctor
Floyd."
In the General Assembly Floyd's record was that
of a good nationalist. With New England in almost
open rebellion and with a foreign invader at the
door, it was no time for contention regarding the
nature of the federal government or over schemes
for territorial expansion. Accordingly he joined the
majority in support of a resolution providing for a
joint committee of the two houses of the General
Assembly instructed to confer with the federal au-
thorities regarding plans of defence for Virginia.
A SPOKESMAN OF THE FRONTIER 35
The counter proposition to authorize the governor
to ** communicate " with the ** Government of the
United States/' he opposed.^^
Probably in condemnation of New England's op-
position to the war bnt certainly not in support of
the state sovereignty theory of government, he fa-
vored, also, a bill authorizing the state of Virginia
to raise troops and place them at the order of the
federal government, **as well for the further and
more vigorous prosecution of the war, as for the de-
fence of this commonwealth.''^^ Moreover, he join-
ed in the support of a resolution condemning tne
terms of peace proposed by the British commission-
ers at Ghent, as ** arrogant" and * insulting" on the
part of Great Britain and as *^ subversive of the
rights and sovereignty of the United States." Nor
would he stand for the opposition tactics of the'Fed-
cralist leader, Charles Fenton Mercer, who tried to
call into question the ^^sovereignty of the United
States ' ' and to give a milder tone to the resolutions
censuring the British commissioners.^^ Considering
both his own future course and that of Virginia it
may be of interest to note that he now acted with
a majority in the General Assembly.
In 1817 Floyd was elected to Congress from the
famous Abingdon district which he continued to
represent by successive reelections for twelve years.
In the short period between his services as a state
legislator and the beginning of his congressional
career the nationalistic tendencies of the federal
government had become truly alarming. Conscious
of our growing power and greatness and forgetful
of the teachings of the fathers a younger generation
86 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
had boarded the national ship of state, leaving the
smaller craft, in which Jefferson and Madison had
ridden into power, to rot in the neglected harbors
of the sovereign states. Under the spell of the new
era Congress had enacted a protective tariff law,
recbartered the Bank of the United States, and made
appropriations to works of internal improvement.
Meanwhile John Marshall had practically destroyed
the former rights of the ^^ sovereign states" by his
liberal interpretation of the * ^federal compact.*'
Despite his liberal tendencies of the war period,
tradition, education, and inclination made it impossi-
ble for Floyd to acquiesce in the nationalistic ten-
dencies of the federal government. He, too, had
been a war-hawk, both favoring and supporting our
second struggle for independence, and now shared
with others a feeling of confidence in his country's
future, but, in his theories of government, he re-
mained true to the fathers of 1789. Like many of
them, he saw our only escape from the dangers of
absolutism at the one extreme of government and
of anarchy at the other, in adhering closely to the
constitution which they had made. With equal care
he would, therefore, have guarded the rights both of
the states and of the federal government by confin-
ing the latter strictly to the exercise of its delegated
powers. According to his interpretation the recent
acts of Congress were therefore unconstitutional.
Floyd was not alone in this particularistic reac-
tion of Virginia, if indeed he could be called a leader.
Although he had done much to make it necessary
Jefferson had already launched a crusade against
the federal Supreme Court and the heresies of na-
A SPOKESMAN OF THE FRONTIER 37
tionalism ; Judge Spencer Roane was an able second ;
Thomas Ritchie, through the Richmond Enquirer,
was calling the country back to original principles ;
and, after a humiliating defeat at the hands of his
former constituents, John Randolph had recovered
his seat in Congress, where he now became the pop-
ular apostle of discontent and of strict construction
of the federal constitution.
Floyd entered Congress at a critical time in the
history of Virginia. Her older statesmen were pass-
ing from the stage of activity, and new and inexpe-
rienced leaders were taking their places. The for-
mer had led when Virginia stood in the ascendency
of the states of the Union; the latter were now called
upon to preserve that ascendency at a time when she
was in a political minority and in a period of econo-
mic uncertainty. A comparison of the fifteenth, the
one to which Floyd was first elected, with the Con-
gresses immediately preceding, shows a great
change in the personnel of Virginians representa^
tives. John Tyler, P. P. Barbour, and others later
prominent among the strict construction politicians
were now just entering national politics. By James
Buchanan, just entering upon his own congressional
career, and by others at the North, these young
leaders from the South were spoken of as the ** radi-
cal party. ''^^ Thus, from the beginning they were
marked men; but the ability of his rivals, to say
nothing of the needs of his state, made it necessary
for Floyd to work for distinction. If he surpassed
his fellow representatives from Virginia in any par-
ticular, it was probably in his vision of the future
and importance of the American frontier.
38 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
Soon Clay^s proposition for sending a minister
to Bnenos Ayres came before the House, and Floyd
joined its author in a demand amounting to recogni-
tion for the new born republic of Argentina and in
an attack upon John Quincy Adams, the secretary
of state, who hesitated to offend Spain so long as
the negotiations for the purchase of Florida re-
mained undetermined. Swayed by the prejudices of
a frontiersman and ignorant of the requirements of
diplomacy, Floyd had been aroused by the * ^ sublime
and wonderful'* spectacle of a ** brave people, dis-
daining the shackles of a foreign despot" in an ef-
fort to erect their government upon a free basis.
Transformed by the influence of a new and pure
climate, *^ where the productions, the scenery, the
physical conformity of the country, and even the
very sky and stars of heaven are so different that
nothing of the Spaniard is left but the name, and
that no more,'' he relied upon the purifying effects
of revolution to fit Argentina for a place in the sis-
terhood of nations. It was in vain that her settlers
and explorers had given the names of Spain to her
hills, valleys, rivers, and mountains. The wrack
and the torture of the inquisition had wrought havoc
mth all these precautions, and Argentina and other
South American countries were free. Moreover,
Floyd was happy to believe that the liberties of a
republic could be enjoyed by a Spaniard, or by any
people capable of fighting for them. Especially was
this true in America, where every man was a general
capable of ** wiles and stratagems, quick advance,
attack, and flight, ' ' guarantees of success in any en-
A SPOKESMAN OF THE FRONTIER 39
counter with the slow and expensive formalities of
European warfare.
This effort in behalf of Clay's measure, also,
overflowed with the characteristic contempt of the
American frontiersman for Spain. From the proud
conqueror of the Incas and the Montezumas he now
saw in her ruler only an improvident and bankrupt
gamester. Bloated with pride inherited through a
long line of ancestors the ruling king was incapable
of imitating the magnanimous conduct of George
III. in acknowledging the independence of his col-
onies; yet, despite his proud boast that ^Hhe sun
never sets upon his domains,'' the king of Spain
was impotent at home and despised abroad. Plainly
his was not a power to be taken seriously, certainly
not one to thwart the extension of justice to an inde-
pendent and free people.
Both from our own example and from the writ-
ings of Vattel, Henry Clay had defended the right
of the Spanish colonies to rebel, but Floyd carried
this right to its logical conclusions: independence
and recognition. Moreover, he was certain that it
would be a ^' black and sorrowful day for this re-
public," when the opinions of Europe were held over
our deliberations ^4ike a lash of scorpions." He
did not, however, share the boldness of his leader,
who already had aspirations for the presidency, in
urging recognition for Argentina for political rea
sons and was sorry that the efforts to intimidate
those who advocated the measure from *^ honest con-
viction" had led gentlemen to mention the presi-
dency in connection with the matter.
With a vision which penetrated the conditions
40 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
under which the Monroe Doctrine was later pro-
claimed, Floyd also attempted to show that onr
proposed course towards Argentina was a matter
of indifference to some of the European nations,
particularly to Great Britain. Since some of the
nations of Europe were then making efforts, **not
loud, but deep and dangerous/' to exclude her from
American markets, he felt confident that Great
Britain would welcome our intervention in South
America. Thus he relied upon another continental
system, more dangerous to Britain than the colos-
sal power of Napoleon had ever been, to break down
the decaying fibers of the Holy Alliance. Under
the circumstances we had nothing to fear. If war
with Europe should follow our acts, England could
be relied upon to aid us, *^even with arms.'' Thus
she would win the eternal gratitude of a grateful
people and serve her own commercial purposes.
Alarmed at the hereditary land mania of the
Russian monarchs who had carried their conquests
across the continent of Asia and well down the
Pacific coast of North America, he considered the
Czar a formidable factor in South American affairs.
No doubt the prominence of the Czar had been en-
hanced somewhat by the part Avhich he had taken
in the formation and maintenance of the Holy Al-
liance, but Floyd now saw in his designs only a bar-
rier to our ambitions for some day reaching the Pa-
cific coast. But Russian territorial ambitions in
America were not sufficient cause of war. Before
them came always her designs upon Constantinople
in an effort to reach an ice free harbor on the Medi-
terranean. She was not then to be feared.
A SPOKESMAN OF THE FRONTIER 41
Floyd therefore nrged the recognition of Argen-
tina, not only as a matter of justice but also as a mat-
ter of self-interest, but some of his colleagues failed
to see wherein recognition would be to our best in-
terest. Because Chili had already sold wheat in the
West Indies cheaper than the United States could
pell it in the same market, Mr. Smith, of Maryland,
the merchant prince and ^ ^crooked'' politician, op-
posed all measures intended to accelerate the growth
and importance of the South American countries.
Even the capable Mr. Lowndes of South Carolina
was discouraged because of the fact that the British
trade advantages with those countries exceeded ours
in the proportion of one to seventy. But Floyd saw
that great advantages must accrue to us from a free
and direct trade with the countries of South
America, a veritable granary of luxuries and the
precious metals.
This proposed recognition meant more to Floyd
even than trade advantages and justice; it was
another step in the disenthrallment of America. It
would afford relief from that political plexus which
had made it impossible for one European nation to
move, even in matters relating to America, without
creating a corresponding movement in each of the
others. He was tired of negotiating the things which
related exclusively to America in London, Paris, and
Madrid.^*
While Congress was debating the subject of our
relations with Spanish America, General Jackson, in
an attack upon the Seminoles, invaded the Spanish
territory of Florida and put to death, in a most sum-
mary manner, Arbuthnot and Ambrister, British
42 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
subjects charged with aiding and abetting the In-
dians in their attacks upon the United States. It is
true that he bore instructions from the president
and Mr. Calhoun, the secretary of war, which, in the
absence of other instructions and in the light of our
previous policies in dealing with the Indians, might
have justified his course. However that may be, his
acts alarmed the president and his cabinet, aroused
British and Spanish war talk, and placed Jackson
prominently before the country as the object of
praise and criticism. Under the circumstances the
president could not well disavow Jackson ^s conduct,
and the magnanimous Adams adroitly placed the
blame upon the impotency of Spain to preserve law
and order within her own territory.
Except as a subject of diplomatic negotiation
elackson's conduct in Florida would have passed sim-
ply as the ill-advised act of a rash and daring gen-
eral, but the politicians would not have it that way.
Somehow the rival candidates for the presidency,
Clay, Crawford, Adams, and even others, now rec-
ognized in him their most formidable opponent.
Led by the Richmond Enquirer, the press of the
country attacked him under the heading ^^ Arbuthnot
and Ambrister,"^^ thus precipitating the great Sem-
inole debate in the Congress of 1818-1819, during
which Jackson loomed large as the most talked of
and probably the most popular man in the whole
country. As every other possible error of the Sem-
inole campaign had been officially explained, the
House Committee on Military Affairs attempted to
censure Jackson for the execution of Arbuthnot
and Ambrister. At once a minority of the same
A SPOKESMAN OF THE FRONTIER 43
committee reported a resolution extending to him
the thanks of the comitry for his services in termin-
ating the Seminole campaign, and the debate was
staged.
To one whose ancestors had fallen victims to the
savage foe and whose childhood visions were filled
with pictures of the scalping-knife and the toma-
hawk this occasion presented a rare opportunity for
a word upon the frontier and for a defence of him
who stood as its best impersonation. To Floyd it
mattered not that more than half of Virginia's rep-
resentation in Congress followed the cue of the En-
quirer. Their course was actuated largely by poli-
tics and diplomacy; he spoke for those forces mak-
ing for national expansion and for the rights and
safety of the frontier. He therefore justified Jack-
son upon every score.
In view of the semi-independent condition of the
Indian tribes and of the fact that our government
had only treaty relations with them, some argued
that Congress alone could have authorized the war
with the Seminoles and that Jackson had exceeded
his authority, whatever may have been the wishes
and intentions of the president in the matter. In an-
swer to these contentions Floyd reviewed the his-
tory of previous administrations to show the origin
of Indian wars. Whatever the causes he found that
defensive measures had usually thrown the initial
step for the United States upon her president, who
had without exception been sustained in his course
by Congress. At least that was the procedure in the
wars of 1789, 1791, and 1793. Nor was the war with
the Seminoles any exception. Granting that the
44 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
I3resident was in a measure responsible for it, had
not Congress come to his rescue with liberal appro-
priations and supplies to maintain it? Jackson had
therefore acted in keeping with established prece-
dents and had not exceeded his authority.
To the other point of this contention Floyd re-
plied by denying the sovereignty of the Indian tribes.
Their espousal of the British cause in the American
Revolution had forfeited all such rights, a fact at-
tested by our refusal to treat with them as separate
nations in the peace negotiations of 1783. Her later
resumption of diplomatic relations with them and
the fact that they made war upon the United States
without becoming traitors mattered not. Treaties
made with them were only ceremonies indulged as a
means of conciliating favor, and treason was a
meaningless term to a savage. Besides the question
of their alleged sovereignty had been definitely set-
tled at Ghent. Both Clay and Adams had then op-
posed the desires of the British for a sovereign In-
dian state between the United States and Canada.
Moreover, Floyd justified Jackson's acts in Flor-
ida. With definite instructions from the secretary
of war to conduct the fight with the Seminoles **in
the manner he [Jackson] might think best'* he had
indeed entered the territory of a neutral power in
pursuit of a common enemy and tried in vain to pro-
ceed with the good will and permission of the local
authorities. When all hope of cooperation had
passed, then it was that he attacked the Indian towns
and discovered that their war-poles were decorated
with the scalps of his fellow countrymen and that
their wigwams were stored with stolen plunder.
A SPOKESMAN OF THE FRONTIER 46
Signs pointed to St. Marks, a Spanish town, as tlie
place whence the Indians received their anununi-
tions, guns, and instructions and where they sold
their plunder. With the case thus clearly establish-
ed against the Spaniards, it was no time for fine-
spun distinctions regarding the sovereign rights of
the nation to which they owed allegiance. An ex-
perienced Indian fighter had found his prey and
would give no quarter either to the inhabitants of
St. Marks and later, for a similar reason, to those
of Pensacola. Their nationality was a question of
trivial importance; they were made captives; and
Floyd was certain that the spirit of the law of na-
tions would justify Jackson in his treatment of them.
For Arbuthnot and Ambrister, Floyd could not
feign the ^^ sickly sorrow^' of time-serving editors
and interested politicians. To him they were simply
** British agents,'' for more than a generation the
authors of the horrors and cruelties of our Indian
wars. They were of those the mere mention of
whose name created **a sudden start of horror in
the widowed mother of a family on the frontier, as
it tears open the sluices of her grief, which time had
smoothed but could not destroy.'' They were in a
class with Simon Grirty and Alexander McKee and
would have been considered undeserving of clemency
in any age. Their activities in Florida brought to
Floyd's recollection those early days on the frontier,
when helpless females had been butchered while
kneeling and begging for mercy and toothless in-
fants had been snatched from their mother 's breasts
and thrown upon the ground to die. Satisfaction
and retaliation therefore demanded their death, and
46 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
Floyd was not particular in his choice of an execu-
tioner. It was just as well to leave the patriotic ser-
vice to a general with his army as to a frontiersman
with his rifle.
In the course of this debate Clay reviewed the
conditions that had given Greece an Alexander,
Rome a Caesar, England a Cromwell, and France a
Napoleon and closed with the warning that the
United States should beware of her military des-
pots. In view of his subsequent attitude towards
both Jackson and Clay, Floyd's answer to the above
argument is the most interesting feature of his
speech on this occasion. He was unable to trace the
fall of free governments to the usurpations of mili-
tary despots. On the other hand he traced them
directly to the legislative halls and thence to the
^* hollow, treacherous eloquence of some ambitious,
proud, and aspiring demagogue'' who either needed
the help of a military leader or Avas willing to do
his bidding. In proof of this position he called at-
tention to the fact that Caesar had retired to the dis-
tance, ^* whilst the two great factions preyed upon
the liberties of Rome." Also, he insisted that the
French Revolution was the product of insincere or-
ators; that Cromwell had been the leader of a fac-
tion; and that the French orators, in legislative as-
semblies, had aided and abetted the Napoleonic usur-
pations.
The Seminole debate ended in a vote of confi-
dence in Jackson, thus sending him upon another
phase of his triumphant conquest of popular favor.
The date of the vote marked the beginning of a new
regime in American politics. Henceforth Jackson
A SPOKESMAN OF THE FRONTIER 47
was the coming man, and it was to be well with those
who had been friendly to him and bad for those who
had not. Thus far Floyd was in the favored class ;
the influence of environment had placed him there.
Meanwhile Missouri had applied to Congress for
admission to statehood, and a heated debate had fol-
lowed over the various proposals for the retention
and the exclusion of negro slavery within her pro-
posed boundaries. Again Floyd was not in accord
with a majority of Virginia's representatives in
Congress, who desired the retention of negro sla-
very in Missouri at any price. Thus while they
debated, he remained quiet. His silence was prob-
ably due to the influences of his early environment,
to the interests of his constituents, and to his per-
sonal convictions. The fact remains that he was one
of the four representatives from Virginia and the
only one from a district west of the Blue Ridge,
who voted for the Missouri Compromise in its final
form.^^ Judging from his subsequent utterances he
seems to have preferred immediate statehood for
Missouri to an extension of the slaveholding ter-
ritory of the Union, though there is little evidence
to show that he opposed the latter on general prin-
ciples.
At the subsequent session of Congress, that for
1820-1821, Floyd felt called upon to defend the sov-
ereignty of the state of Missouri. Under the enab-
ling act of 1820, out of which the compromise of
that date had grown, she had made a constitution
which required her legislature to enact a law **to
prevent free negroes and mulattoes from coming to,
or settling in-' Missouri under any pretext whatso-
48 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
ever. Since some of the northern states accorded
such persons all the rights and privileges of citizens,
the anti-slavery forces in Congress demanded that
the ^ * free negro clause ' ' be expunged from the con-
stitution of Missouri, threatening, notwithstanding
the enabling act, to keep her from the Union in case
their desires were not complied with. The points
thus raised involved the rights of the people of Mis-
souri under the enabling act, also their power over
their own local institutions.
Floyd regarded the demands upon the ^^sover-
eign State of Missouri," in this connection, as op-
posed to the nature and intent of the federal con-
stitution and as dangerous in practice. As the rep-
resentative of an old state, he was unwilling to dic-
tate to a new one in the exercise of its sovereign
power, because, under such precedents, he did not
know how soon Congress might desire to encroach
upon the reserved rights of the former. Already
he had seen an alarming tendency among legislators
to find justification for their acts of centralization
and federal usurpation in the law and history of
England and in their desire to convince the crowned
heads of Europe of the self-sufficiency and national-
ity of the United States of America. Then followed
an exposition of his conception of the nature of the
federal govermnent. Said he :
If gentlemen would only expunge from their memories the
progress of European liberty and institutions, they would find
in America a number of states, or separate, independent, and
distinct nations, confederated for common safety, and mutual
protection, taught wisdom by the eternal feuds of Spain, Eng-
land, Prance, and Germany, now consolidated into large empires.
A SPOKESMAN OF THE FRONTIER 49
These states before the confederation could make war and peace,
raise armies, or build a navy, coin money, pass bankrupt laws,
naturalize foreigners, or regulate commerce . . . Informed by
Europe they knew jealousies would arise, and constant strife
render armies in every nation necessary to their defence, which
would endanger their liberties and homes.
These states then, in their sovereign and independent char-
acters, were willing to enter into a compact, by which the power
of making war and peace, and regulating commerce, possessed
alike by all, should be transferred to a congress of the states,
to be exercised with uniformity, for their mutual benefit; thus
avoiding the evils of "superanuated and enslaved" Europe.
These two were the only powers ever intended to be granted by
the states. All other powers conferred by the compact are nec-
essary to carry these two into execution. 17
This rather circumscribed but defensible exposi-
tion of the nature of the federal government was fol-
lowed by the presentation of the point in question.
Floyd argued that the enabling act of Congress had
given the people of Missouri the necessary power to
create a *^ sovereign state'' which they and they
alone could destroy. After the state had been formed
Congress had no other power than that of admitting
it or excluding it from the Union. In case of its re-
fusal to admit Missouri, she became at once a ^*for-
eign state'' or a ^^ state out of the Union." In any
event she was not to be dictated to regarding her
sovereign rights, if she would preserve them. As
Congress would not tolerate the presence of a rival
state west of the Mississippi, there was only one
other course open to it: the immediate recognition
of Missouri as a state in the Union under her duly
authorized and legal constitution. Delay and ulti-
mate refusal would make necessary a war to force
her return to her former territorial status.
50 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
The question of Missouri's sovereign rights
under her constitution came up again, when the two
houses of Congress met in joint session to canvass
the returns of the presidential election of 1820. She
had finally yielded the point of her original consti-
tution regarding the proposed exclusion of free ne-
groes and mulattoes but had not yet made the nec-
essary changes in that document to have it conform
with the requirements of the majority in Congress.
Nevertheless, she claimed to be a state in the Union
entitled to a vote in the electoral college. On the
other hand there were those who denied her this
right arguing that she was not a state and that she
could not be until Congress had approved the final
draft of her constitution.
In his speeches on the proposed amendment of
Missouri's constitution under the enabling act Floyd
had already answered the points raised by those
who would have excluded her from the electoral col-
lege. Accordingly he now introduced the following
resolution: ^^That Missouri is one of the states of
the Union, and her vote for president and vice-presi-
dent ought to be received and counted. ''^^ The de-
bate which followed precipitated one of the liveliest
*^ scenes'' ever witnessed on such an occasion.
Amidst the repeated disorder which followed both
Floyd and John Randolph were so persistent in
their interruptions as to necessitate an adjournment
of the joint session. They each voted against the
compromise whereby the presidential vote was
counted as so many with the vote of Missouri and
A SPOKESMAN OF THE FRONTIER 51
SO many without it/^ John Qiiincy x\dams later de-
scribed their action as an effort to bring Missouri
into the Union ^*by storm/ '*°
In the other important debate of this session,
that occasioned by the successful effort to reduce the
official and numerical strength of the army, Floyd
favored retrenchment but seems to have had no part
with those who would have humiliated and injured
Jackson by relieving him of his command. As has
been seen he had no fears of a military despot, but
his faith in the valor and patriotism of the frontiers-
man was an abiding one. In all matters of defence
he was, therefore, willing to place chief reliance
upon the state militias. Some thought them inad-
equate for the defence of the frontier, but Floyd
knew that standing armies were equally inadequate
for that purpose. Memory carried him at once to
the days of his childhood in the **dark and bloody
land,'' where the pioneer had protected himself and
the federal army, where mothers and daughters had
constituted a part of the home guard, and where
the laborer, with his rifle at his side, had played an
important part in the winning of an empire.
III. THE OREGON COUNTRY
WHEN John Floyd entered Congress, in
1817, our claims to the territory along
the Columbia River were disputed.
Captain Gray of Boston had probably
discovered the mouth of that river in
1792 ; later Lewis and Clark had certainly explored
the country through which it flowed; and, in 1811,
John Jacob Astor had planted a trading post, Asto-
ria, near its mouth. Meanwhile our chief rival, Great
Britain, had done little or nothing to make good her
claims to the country. Notwithstanding her inactiv-
ity a British sloop-of-war, the Raccoon, captured As-
toria in 1812, hauled down the American flag, and
placed in its stead the Union Jack. Peace had been
followed, however, by a notification of our intention
to reoccupy the country and by a consequent series
of diplomatic negotiations resulting in a treaty of
joint occupation of 1818. Under this arrangement
the territory in dispute was opened for a period of
ten years to the citizens of both countries without
prejudice to the rights of either on the subject of ul-
timate ownership.
Meanwhile the people at home knew little of the
country in dispute and probably cared less. Indeed
there was little available information about it. Some
had read the interesting Diary of Patrick Gass, and,
in 1811, Nicholas Biddle had published the Journals
of Lems and Clark. But, as late as 1817, the Colum-
bia Valley was known to William Cullen Bryant only
as
THE OREGON COUNTRY 53
The continuous woods
Wbere rolls the Oregon and hears no sound
Save his own dashings.
It was left to John Floyd, a young Virginian,
himself a child of the frontier, to bring our claims
to the Columbia Valley prominently before the
American people. **To him,'' said Professor E. G.
Bourne, ** unquestionably belongs the credit of first
proposing in Congress the actual occupation of the
Columbia Kiver country by the United States G-ov-
ernment, of promoting its settlement, and of organ-
izing it as a territory with the name Oregon.'"^
Scholars now generally agree in crediting Floyd
with this initiative, dismissing the rival claims made
for Hall J. Kelley, the Massachusetts schoolmaster,
and for others as without foundation.^^
Floyd's interests in the Columbia River country
are not difficult to determine. George Rogers Clark
was the boyhood idol for whom he had later named
a son ; his first cousin, Charles Floyd, was a member
of the Lewis and Clark Expedition, holding the rank
of sergeant and losing his life in the early months
of its history ; and the friendship of William Clark,
a member of the Lewis and Clark Expedition, was
an '^ honor" which Floyd had enjoyed *^from his ear-
liest youth." Moreover, in the early winter of 1820-
1821 he lodged, while in Washington, at Brown's Ho-
tel where he met Thomas H. Benton who was then
the author of a series of articles for the St. Louis
Enquirer regarding our claims to the Columbia Val-
ley and our interests there." At this hotel he, also,
met Ramsey Crooks of New York and Russell Farn-
54 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
ham of Massachusetts, both of whom had been en-
gaged in the Astoria enterprise. Of their influence
upon Floyd, Benton later wrote: ^* Their conversa-
tions, rich in information upon a new and interest-
ing country, was eagerly devoured by the [his] ar-
dent spirit.''^* As it had already provoked ad-
verse criticism our treaty of joint occupation with
Great Britain was doubtless a subject of conversa-
tion among these friends, and it is not at all improb-
able that they then and there resolved to change it
for a more aggressive policy.
At all events, on December 20, 1820, Floyd
brought the question of our rights in the Columbia
country, for the first time, to the attention of Con-
gress. By a resolution, he asked that a committee
be appointed to ''inquire into the situation of the
settlements upon the Pacific Ocean and the expe-
diency of occupying the Columbia River. ''^^ The
resolution carried, and the proposed committee was
appointed with Floyd, chairman, and Metcalf of
Kentucky, and Swearingen of Virginia, members.
The boldness and vision of the report which this
committee later made is best understood in the light
of the popular conception then prevalent regarding
the frontier and the far West.
At this time, 1820, the frontier was a wedgelike
area, the apex of which rested near the junction of
the Kansas and Missouri Eivers. The flanks of this
advance army of civilization widened gradually to
the eastward, that to the south passing near New
Orleans and that to the north passing near Detroit.
Within the waterways were the highways controlling
the distribution of population. At opportune times
THE OREGON COUNTRY 55
areas of white settlement had made rapid strides to
the westward, but now a further advance seemed
almost impossible. In the first place there were few
who desired it. In the second place the areas already
preempted for settlement seemed sufficient for all
time. Besides, the outlet to the far West seemed
now closed, because the Missouri, the door of exit,
had taken an abrupt turn to the northward to an
inhospitable climate and to the home of the most
warlike of the savage foes. Nature and expediency
had thus seemingly placed a limit to the frontier.
Moreover, the country beyond the Missouri, and
between it and the *' Stony Mountain,^' was then
thought to be a great desert. Geographers had de-
scribed it as such and had furnished their proof.
Were not the sections nearest the mountains without
rainfall? Then, too. Major Stephen B. Long, after
a trip through the country in 1819-1820, had describ-
ed it as a barren waste incapable of supporting an
agricultural population. Also, the newspapers of
the day described the country just east of the Eock-
ies, as a land ^^ covered with sand, gravel, and peb-
bles" and as utterly destitute of timber, and they
expressed the belief that the Creator had fixed the
bend in the Missouri as the point beyond which the
white man was never to go.
Nevertheless, on January 21, 1821, Floyd pre- ,
sented his report, to-day justly considered famous.
It was accompanied by a bill authorizing our occu-
pation of the Columbia River. In both the handi-
work of his friends, Benton, Crooks, and Farnham,
is evident. They certainly supplied the details re-
garding the climate, the fertility of the soil, the ex-
56 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
periences of the Astorians, the nature of the over-
land routes, and, more important than all else, the
plans and suggestions for the development of the
fur trade with the East and with China. In its ex-
pressions and in the embodiment of the ideas and im-
pulses that were to shape the progress of events
this pioneer report ^^ bears the same relation to Ore-
gon that Richard Hakluyt's famous Discourse on
Western Planting bears to the foundation of the
English colonies in America/'"^ No other apology
is therefore needed for a further presentation of its
contents.
Floyd based our claims to the Columbia country
almost wholly upon our rights under the Louisiana
Purchase and gently hinted to the European nations
that ^nhere is no longer territory to be obtained by
settlement and discovery' ' in the New World. Spain
had not yet relinquished her claims to the territory
north of the forty-second degree of north latitude.
The Treaty of 1819 for the purchase of Florida re-
mained unratified, but Floyd did not hesitate to re-
strict Spanish possessions to the northern boundary
of Mexico. Thus by a strange elasticity the Louis-
iana Territory was made to embrace another em-
pire. If, however, doubt remained regarding the
validity of our title, he would have removed it by
asserting our rights accruing from the discoveries
and explorations of Hendricks, in 1785-1786, from
the Lewis and Clark Expedition, in 1804-1807, and
from the Astoria settlement made in 1811.
Thus satisfied with our rights on the Columbia,
Floyd urged its immediate occupation, that the citi-
zens of the United States might have a free and full
THE OREGON COUNTRY 57
opportunity to participate in the fur trade. Follow-
ing an able presentation of the value of that trade
to the early German tribes, to the Tartars, and to
the French he traced the rise of the British Hudson
Bay Company and the Northwestern Company,
showing how their agents had carried Indian sup-
plies from Montreal to the Rocky Mountains and
later to the Pacific coast. Returning with their furs
they had followed routes more than three thousand
miles long, paddling their birch canoes through in-
numerable rivers across more than sixty lakes and
over a hundred and thirty portages varying in width
from a few yards to thirteen miles. Despite these
obstructions and consequent delays these two com-
panies had exported annually from Quebec alone, to
say nothing of their exports from New York, Phil-
adelphia, and the mouth of the Columbia, furs val-
ued at more than a million dollars. Floyd insisted
that such a source of income could not be neglected
by the United States, because, valuable as the fur
trade was, its routes were soon to become the high-
ways of emigrants going to the far West and of
trade to China.
The practicability of occupation was not even
questioned; its necessity was imperative. Did not
the British Northwest Fur Company then occupy
posts in the Louisiana Territory east of the Rocky
Mountains? Our occupation of the Pacific North-
west was not therefore to be delayed. To make it
effective all that was needed was a small guard at
the mouth of the Columbia and another at **the most
northeastern point of the Missouri River,'* thus
** confining the foreigners to their own territory."
58 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
It was urged that these outposts could be maintained
with comparative ease by the United States. Instead
of passing the great lengths and obstructions of the
Canadian rivers, as the British were forced to do in
reaching the far West, our citizens could reach that
region by way of ^*a smooth and deep river [the
Missouri] running through a boundless extent of
the most fertile soil on the continent, containing
within its limits all those valuable furs which have
greatly enriched others, a certain, safe, and easy
navigation, with a portage two hundred miles unit-
ing it with another river [the Columbia] equally
smooth, deep and certain running to the great west-
ern ocean.'' Furthermore several passageways
leading from the Missouri to the Columbia had
already been discovered in the Rocky Mountains.
Responsible initiative was, therefore, all that re-
mained to make our occupation of the Columbia
Valley a certainty. Men with their wives and fami-
lies stood ready to follow such leadership, and it
could rely, moreover, upon the Chinese to supply a
laboring population.
The Columbia country was desirable, also, for
its natural resources other than furs. From the
ocean to the head of tide, a distance of two hundred
miles, it was heavily timbered with a variety of
woods '^well calculated for ship-building and every,
species of cabinet and carpenter's work." Then
came another belt of inferior but desirable timber
two hundred miles in width. This was followed to
the eastward by the plain country which produced
grass of the finest quality and horses surpassing in
perfection those of Andalusia and even Virginia.
THE OREGON COUNTRY 59
Besides, the Pacific coast waters abounded in fish of
numerous varieties, and Floyd saw the possibility
of making a port at the mouth of the Columbia the
center of the whale fishing industry of the world.
To strengthen the courage and faith of those who
believed Oregon a forbidding wilderness beyond
the reach of civilization and settlement, this report
called attention to the magic power, dauntless cour-
age, and clear vision with which Russia had extend-
ed her territory across the continent of Asia, even
to the western coast of North America and to the
islands of the Pacific, making it possible for her sub-
jects to journey in open boats from Kamchatka
to Japan in their own territory. If Russia could
carry cannon through ^ immense oceans, round Cape
Horn'' and drive sledges loaded with articles of
trade across the continent of Asia ^ through seas of
ice, and storms of snow so terrible as to obscure an
object beyond the distance of a few paces, in an
effort to build up her commerce with China and Ja-
pan and to extend her own territory, thus laying
tribute upon the four quarters of the globe and win-
ning for herself a ** proud security" among the na-
tions of Europe, Floyd was ** persuaded that, with
a little care and small expense/' the United States
could lay the foundations of a power in the Colum-
bia Valley that would eventually be necessary to
complete her national development and serve her
best commercial and industrial interests.
Although nothing beyond the presentation of this
report was accomplished at this time, the subject
being not even discussed in Congress, Floyd had
struck a telling blow in our fight for the Columbia
60 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
country. Of Ms efforts on this occasion Benton
said : ^ ' Public attention was awakened, and the geo-
graphical, historical, and statistical facts set forth
. . . made a lodgment in the public mind which
promised eventual favorable consideration '^^^ Others
did not think so favorably of Floyd and his pro-
posals. For instance, John Quincy Adams saw in
him only a ^^ flaunting'^ canvasser and a politician
seeking to win prestige and patronage, particularly
the latter, by a vigorous opposition to the party in
power. In this connection his support of W. H.
Crawford in preference to Adams for the presidency
should be taken into consideration. Moreover,
Adams questioned Floyd's honesty in urging the
occupation of the Columbia Valley, insisting that
he was actuated by a desire to provide a retreat for
a defaulting relative and possibly for himself. ^^ Of
the report itself Adams' ** Memoirs" has this amus-
ing comment :
The president gave me yesterday [January 17, 1821,] a
paper to read which this man [Floyd] has prepared as chairman
of a committee, being a report urging an immediate settlement
and territorial establishment at the mouth of the Columbia river,
and a total change of our system of intercourse and trade with
the Indians. Floyd had put it into the President's hands with
the request that he should suggest any alternative that he might
think desirable. I returned the paper this morning to the Presi-
dent who asked me what I thought of it. I told him I could
recommend no alternative. The paper was a tissue of errors in
facts and abortive reasoning, of individual reflections and rude
invectives. There was nothing could purify it but the fire.«9
Notwithstanding this opposition from those high
in power Floyd was undismayed. On December 10,
THE OREGON COUNTRY 61
1821, he reintroduced his resolutions of the pre-
vious year but with important modifications. It
was now proposed to inquire into the ''expediency
of occupying the Columbia Biver and the territory
of the United States adjacent thereto. Ignoring
completely Mr. Calhoun, the secretary of war, who,
like Adams and probably for similar reasons, was
thought to be unfriendly to his proposals, Floyd
one week later presented an additional resolution
asking that the secretary of the navy be instructed
to furnish the House with an estimate of the expen-
ses of a survey of the harbors of the United States
upon the Pacific Ocean and of exporting artillery
to the mouth of the Columbia Eiver.^^ One month
later, January 18, 1822, these resolutions were fol-
lowed by a bill authorizing and requiring the presi-
dent to occupy "the territory of the United States'*
on the waters of the Columbia River, to extinguish
the Indian titles thereto, and to make land grants
to prospective settlers. What is probably even more
important this bill provided that "When the popu-
lation of the settlements amounted to 2000 souls, all
that portion of the Unites States north of the 42d
parallel of latitude and west of the Rocky Moun-
tains is to be constituted a territory of the United
States, under the name of the Territory of Ore-
gon.""
Thus Floyd had taken a bold stand. In neither
of the above mentioned resolutions nor in the bill
did he express the slightest doubt about our sover-
eign rights of ownership in the Columbia Valley
which was now boldly spoken of as the "territory
of the United States.'' The skillful wording
62 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
employed was probably intended to force the presi-
dent and his cabinet officially to recognize Floyd's
contentions regarding our rights in the Columbia
Valley, now generally spoken of as the Oregon coun-
try. The resolutions showed that Floyd's plans for
furthering our interests on the Pacific had advanced,
in one year, from that of a commercial outpost to
that of a nascent state in the Union. Moreover, they
contain the first formal proposal whereby the terri-
tory in question was called Oregon.^^
Every possible effort was made to secure a fa-
vorable consideration for Floyd's propositions.
Thinking that it might contain important informa-
tion regarding the Louisiana Territory which, Floyd
maintained, included Oregon, he next called upon
the president to cause to be laid before the House all
the correspondence relating to the Treaty of Ghent,
which it *^ might not be improper to disclose. "^^ In
this request it is not at all improbable that Floyd
desired to damage the political ambitions of John
Quincy Adams by making it appear that he had
neglected the interests of the West in the negotia-
tions of 1814. Be that as it may, the desired infor-
mation was forthcoming, but it failed either to
arouse interest in the Oregon bill or to incriminate
Adams. Accordingly the whole matter was again
passed by with little consideration.
Meanwhile a rare opportunity for placing the
Oregon question before the people presented itself.
Aroused and alarmed at the growing power of Rus-
sia, which was then said to be making claims of
ownership to the Pacific northwest south of the Co-
lumbia River, and distrustful of Adams, the secre-
THE OREGON COUNTRY 63
tary of state and the guardian of our interests there,
Floyd next secured the adoption of a resohition call-
ing upon the president to communicate to the House
** whether any foreign government had made claim
to any part of the territory of the United States
upon the coast of the Pacific Ocean, north of the 42°
of latitude, and to what extent ; whether any regula-
tions have been made by foreign powers affecting
the trade on that coast ; and how it affects the inter-
ests of this Republic; and whether communications
have been made to this government, by foreign pow-
ers touching the contemplated occupation of the Co-
lumbia River.^* Again his resolution brought the
desired information which was, however, considered
'to be of too confidential a nature for use in the
open House. Accordingly the Oregon question was
allowed to take its course in the rounds of diplo-
macy, thus defeating another attempt to popularize
it.
Two years later, in 1824, the United States con-
cluded with Russia a treaty in which the latter gov-
ernment renounced any and all claims to territory
on the Pacific coast south of 54° and 40'. Neverthe-
less Floyd did not cease his attacks upon Adams.
For some time, it seems, that he searched in vain to
expose him because of his alleged neglect of our in-
terests on the Pacific coast. But **sufiicient unto
the day is the evil thereof, '^ especially when that day
falls in a presidential campaign in the United States
of America. Probably through the author himself,
who was then a member of Congress and had been
one of our commissioners at Ghent, in 1814, word
64 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
came to Floyd of a letter written by Jonathan Rus-
sell to James Monroe on December 15, 1814. This
letter was said to contain proof positive of Adams'
neglect of and opposition to the interests of the West
in the negotiations ending our second war with
Great Britain. Floyd determined to have that let-
ter. It would serve two purposes: that of making
Adams unpopular in the West and that of arousing
popular interest in Oregon. A resolution of inquiry
placed the letter at his command,^^ but it, too, fail-
ed to produce the desired sensation. Instead the
anti-Crawford press attacked the * ^ electioneering
tactics'' embodied in the Oregon movement with
such persistency as to call from Floyd a defence of
his conduct. In a letter to the Richmond Enquirer-
of August 27, 1822, he refuted the charges made
against him but refused to give the source of his in-
formation regarding the Russell letter.^®
The provocation thus extended Adams called for
more than one of his customary confidences to the
pages of his diary. In a brief letter to the National
Intelligencer for August 31, 1822, he accused Rus-
sell of aiding and abetting the attacks which Floyd
was making upon him. But one must go to Adams '
Memoirs to learn what he really thought of the inci-
dent and of Floyd. The whole affair was a part of
an alleged plot to injure him ^\ith the western peo-
ple and thus to prevent his election to the presi-
dency. Back of it all Adams saw Henry Clay
working **like a mole" to discredit him in the West.
He was certain that the influence of the press alone
had defeated their diabolical attempts. Strange as
it may seem, his opinion of Floyd had experienced
THE OREGON COUNTRY 65
a complete change. From a ^^ flaunting canvasser^'
and an abettor of fugitives he had, in the short pe-
riod of eighteen months, become ^^a man having in
the main honest intentions.'' His usefulness was
still impaired, however, by a fondness for gigantic
projects formed out of crude and half digested in-
formation, by a disposition to suspect dishonesty
and corruption in others than himself, and by the
delusions of an * * obfuscated ' ' intellect and a violent
passion."
In making the Oregon country a subject of diplo-
matic negotiations and in connecting it with the
name of a prominent candidate for the presidency,
Floyd had rendered impossible a further delay in
the official consideration of the subject. According-
ly Monroe, in his annual message of December, 1822,
suggested that the time had come for serious con-
sideration of our rights and interests on the Pacific
coast. Following this suggestion Floyd reintro-
duced his bill of January, 1822, which was promptly
referred to the Committee of the Whole. The de-
bate which followed was one of the most animated
and illuminating of the session.
As the first speech ever made in Congress on Ore-
gon, Floyd's is especially interesting and instruc-
tive. Unlike his other efforts it showed the results
of painstaking investigation on his own part. In a
graphic presentation of the operation of those demo-
cratic ideas and practices which had carried the
pioneer from the Atlantic to the Pacific, often in de-
fiance of law and always at a rate to astound those
who opposed, he assured his hearers that it was the
^*ball of empire" rolling to the westward, which
66 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
had made his alleged ^^fancifnP' measures and
**bold*' projects a reality. Then he showed how
the King of England had tried in vain to limit set-
tlements to within one hundred miles of the Atlantic
coast ; how Sevier had been outlawed for leading his
fellow countrymen into Tennessee, only later to be
esteemed a gentleman of honor and integrity fit
for any trust; and how Boone, in defiance of the
wishes of government, had found a safe and beauti-
ful retreat in the Ozark Hills, there to die a patriot
and a benefactor. Thus it was and always would be
with authority '* whether Kepublican, Imperial or
Eoyal.'' Authority could never hope to take unto
itself the ^^ exclusive privilege of thinking for the
people, of checking the progress of population in one
direction, and of fixing bounds to it in another, be-
yond which they the people are not permitted to
pass.'' They might be held in check temporarily by
military and other restrictions, but these in turn
would be crushed by succeeding revolutions of the
ball of empire as it moved to the westward.
Nor was the lawlessness and boldness of those
who carried empire to the westward a cause of alarm
to Floyd. Their acts were simply proofs of the
ability of the people to *^ preserve their own interest
long before government can be prevailed upon to re-
linquish to them their privilege of acting. ' ' He was
certain, therefore, that our republic would never
bind its citizens to a sterile soil simply to please the
notions of those in authority. Mandates to the con-
trary, such as ^^ would have kept Boone's Lick a
wilderness," would be made only to be defied.^^
As the occupation was inevitable Floyd urged
THE OREGON COUNTRY 67
that it be immediate. By such a course he would
have opened a mine of riches to our shipping inter-
ests and to the western country surpassing the hopes
of avarice itself. Laboring under great disadvan-
tages, had not the American fur traders on the upper
Mississippi and Missouri cleared almost four hun-
dred thousand dollars annually? Give our citizens
access to Oregon and encourage the whaling indus-
tries of the Pacific, and he was certain that our trade
would, in a short time, rival that of the British and
become the basis of a commerce with China more
than sufficient to balance our purchases from that
country. Besides, this new field of commerce would
become a training school for sailors, whence could
be drawn ** hardy sons of the sea," who, like those in
our second war with Great Britain, would **shed a
blaze of glory over the arms of the nation'' and
teach **the British lion to crouch to the banners of
the republic.'' To those who argued that the pro-
posed settlement would, in time, become a free and
independent state and thus drain the United States
of her population and wealth, Floyd replied with the
wise suggestion that our security would be better
conserved by the presence of a neighbor upon the
Pacific coast, who spoke our language and adhered
to our manners and customs, than by the presence
of a Eussian state with all its ** disgusting notions
of monarchy. ' '
Floyd was ably seconded in most of his argu-
ments by Francis Baylies^^ of Massachusetts, who
spoke chiefly for the whale fishing industries of New
Bedford and Nantucket. Unlike most of the repre-
sentatives of the New England States, Baylies was
68 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
pleased with the idea of multiplying and extending
the states of the Union as a certain means of pre-
serving it. Thus a variety of interests could be de-
pended upon to neutralize each other, cementing the
whole. In the following prophetic utterance he even
urged the extension of our territory and population
to the Pacific:
As we reach the Rocky Mountains we should be unwise did
we not pass that narrow space which separates the mountains
from the ocean, to secure advantages far greater than the exist-
ing advantages of all the country between the Mississippi and
the mountains. Gentlemen are talking of natural boundaries.
Sir, our natural boundary is the Pacific Ocean. The swelling
tide of our population must and will roll on until that mighty
ocean interposes its waters and limits our territorial empire.
Then with two oceans washing our shores, the commercial wealth
of the world is ours, and imagination can hardly conceive the
greatness, the grandeur, and the power that await us.*o
Those who opposed the bill were equally zealous
and were doubtless as patriotic as either Floyd or
Baylies. Tucker of Virginia did not think the prop-
osition visionary but rather too practical. With the
deserted farms of his own state being abandoned to
grow up in briars and pines, he thought it time to
call a halt upon the westward movement of popula-
tion and capital. Tracy of New York pictured the
* imaginary Eden" on the Columbia as an inhospita-
ble wilderness, and Wood of the same state opposed
occupation because of the indifference on the subject.
Numerous others opposed, urging mainly the inac-
cessibility of the Oregon country.
On January 27, 1823, the vote was taken on
THE OREGON COUNTRY 69
Floyd 's bill. It stood : ayes 61, noes 100, an analy-
sis of the vote showing the representatives of the
manufacturing and frontier sections in the majority
and those from the commercial and small farming
sections in the minority.*^ Public indifference had
probably done most to defeat the measure, but its
friends had no reason to despair even on that ac-
count. In less than one month after their defeat,
Little of Maryland presented a memorial from
eighty farmers and merchants within his district
praying Congress to pass the Oregon Bill.
At the following session of Congress, that for
1823-1824, Floyd again introduced a bill providing
for the occupation of the Columbia River, but the
progress of diplomatic negotiations with both Great
Britain and Russia regarding our interests there
rendered discussion inexpedient at that time. He
was unwilling, however, completely to bury Oregon
in the labyrinth of diplomacy. Accordingly he se-
cured the adoption of a resolution requesting the
president to cause to be laid before the House an es-
timate of the expenses for transporting two hundred
troops from Council Bluffs to the mouth of the Co-
lumbia.''^ Later he addressed a letter to Calhoun,
the secretary of war, asking for the president 's opin-
ion upon the proposed occupation of Oregon from a
military point of view. The official replies to these
inquiries showed such occupation wholly practicable
and estimated the expense at about $44,000. They
also carried a tone of official approval.*^
Thus slowly Floyd was winning his way into ex-
ecutive favor. Our difficulties with Russia satis-
factorily adjusted. President Monroe suggested to
70 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
the next session of Congress, that for 1824-1825, that
it take the necessary steps to establish a military
post at the mouth of the Columbia River. Such a
post was now desired as a resort for our ships of
war, a point of strategy in dealing with the Indians,
and a base of commercial intercourse between the
East and the West. Accordingly Floyd again re-
introduced his bill for the occupation of the Oregon
country.
Under these changed conditions the time seemed
ripe for results, and Floyd made a master effort in
behalf of his pet measure. His opponents continued
to talk of the inaccessibility of Oregon, of the insu-
perable difficulties in maintaining a local govern-
ment there, and of the folly of establishing settle-
ments that could not be protected and defended in
time of war. They were reminded, however, of the
achievements of the application of steam to naviga-
tion bringing Oregon closer to the East than Wheel-
ing and Pittsburg had been in 1810, of the success of
the frontiersmen of Missouri and elsewhere in solv-
ing, for themselves and in their own way, the prob-
lems of local self-government, and of the experiences
of the ^*Dark and Bloody Land,'' where the settlers,
alone and unaided save b^^ the use of their rifles, had
defended themselves and the Union against the
designs of foreign enemies. Floyd was certain that
the interests of the citizens of the United States
upon the Pacific coast ^Svould be identified with the
interests of the people of the whole Atlantic coast
in a stronger degree'' than had been the interests of
the people of Vermont and Louisiana at an earlier
date. He therefore urged an outpost on the Pacific
THE OREGON COUNTRY 71
as a center, whence the United States in time would
rule the Pacific and probably achieve the victories
in India for which Napoleon had longed in vain.
To prove further the urgent necessity of occupa-
tion he then produced a wonderful array of facts
concerning the geography and topography of Ore-
gon and of our commercial interests there. He,
also, predicted the rise of a city at the mouth of the
Columbia, that would become a world mart for the
precious goods of Asia and of a vast inland empire.
He saw, in fact, a modern Tyre in America. Thence
the Unites States would supply Canton with flour,
cotton, and tobacco, thus completing a commercial
circuit of the globe.
To those who still questioned the practicability
of maintaining a settlement in Oregon, Floyd con-
ceded the impossibility of finding there the wealth
and splendor then found in the salons and drawing
rooms of Washington, that ** magnificent counter-
feit of European royalty ;*' neither would they find
what was ver3^ common in Washington, namely : * * a
heartless intercourse, an aping etiquette of misera-
ble pretenders to the monthly fashions just from
Europe. '^ But he assured them that they could find
there salmon sufficient to subsist fift}^ thousand men
annually ; potatoes grew wild along the banks of the
Columbia; and gooseberries were found in abund-
ance with strawberries, raspberries, onions and
peas. Moreover, wheat and all kinds of grains could
be had cheaply in a few days from Mexico; hogs,
sheep, and cattle could be procured in abundance
and in a short time from California and the Sand-
wich Islands ; . and enterprising citizens had re-
72 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
duced the difficulties of the trans -continental route
to a minimum.
Floyd closed his argument with this characteris-
tically imaginative and instructive statement:
"I . . . appeal to the House to consider well our interests in
the Western Ocean, on our western coast, and the trade to China
and India; and the ease with which it can be brought down the
Missouri. What is this commerce? Thousands of years have
passed by, and, year after year, all the nations of the earth have,
each year, sought the rich commerce of that country; all have
enjoyed the riches of the East. That trade was sought by King
Solomon, by Tyre, Sidon; this wealth found its way to Egypt,
and at last to Rome, to France, Portugal, Spain, Holland, Eng-
land, and finally to this Republic. How vast and incomparably
rich must be that country and commerce, which has never ceased,
one day, from the highest point of Jewish splendor to the in-
stant that I am speaking, to supply the whole globe with all the
busy imagination of man can desire for his ease, comfort, and
enjoyment! Whilst we have so fair an opportunity offered to
participate so largely in all this wealth and enjoyment, if not
to govern and direct the whole, can it be possible that doubt,
or mere points of speculation, will weigh with the House and.
cause us to lose forever the brightest prospect ever presented to
the eyes of a nation ?"44
On this occasion no set speeches were made in op-
position to Floyd's arguments, those who did not
agree with him contenting themselves with the sug-
gestion that our occupation of Oregon, at that time,
would be a violation of the spirit of the treaty of
joint occupation with Great Britain under which our
citizens had access to the country. Nevertheless the
bill passed the House by a vote of 115 to 57, crown-
ing with partial success the ability and efforts of
one man. From the House the bill went to the Sen-
ate, where it was championed by Benton of Mis-
THE OREGON COUNTRY 73
souri and James Barbour of Virginia; but their
efforts could not prevail to command for it even
a respectful hearing, and thus the question of our
occupation of Oregon ceased again to be agitated for
a brief period.
Meanwhile the question of our rights and inter-
ests on the Pacific had again entered the rounds of
diplomacy. After some delay the treaty of joint
occupation was renewed for another term of ten
years but not without protests. Floyd's distrust
of Adams together with the demands of the diplo-
mats had served, however, to prevent a discussion
of the Oregon question in Congress, but now, that
the former of these barriers was removed, popular
interest in Oregon began to revive. As a result
three companies of adventurers, one in Massachus-
etts, one in Ohio, and another in Louisiana, were
formed with a view to colonizing the country. The
time thus seemed opportune for another effort, and
Floyd revived and reintroduced his bill providing
for our occupation of the Columbia Valley.
Like a school of hungry trout after a new bait,
a number of the newer members of the House at-
tacked the measure resolved to defeat it. Most prom-
inent among them was James K. Polk of Tennessee,
who later entered the presidency as the champion
to our claims to ^^ fifty-four forty." With Bates of
Missouri, Mitchell of Tennessee, Drayton of South
Carolina, Ingersoll of Connecticut, and others, most-
ly young men, Polk argued against any use of the
Oregon country that might drain the East of specie
and offend Great Britain. He thus spoke for a gen-
eration in greater accord with the mother eountrv.
74 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
To one of Floyd's traditions and prejudices his ar-
guments were deplorable. Besides marking a back-
ward step they rendered necessary the temporary
abandonment of our rights and interests on the Pa-
cific.
Though the outlook seemed hopeless Floyd
fought to the last. His opponent's alarm, lest their
specie should some day take wings and fly to the
West, he traced to the ^^ ignorant days of British
commerce,'' the days of the Mercantilists, when
England had actually prohibited the exportation of
gold and had suifered untold consequences. Nor was
he willing to take seriously our treaty obligations
with Great Britain. He predicted that the British
would soon repeat in Oregon the scenes of Ken-
tucky, where the ^* British trader" and the *^ Brit-
ish agent" had induced the Indians to murder our
citizens on their own territory, to drive them from
the fur producing regions, and to deter them from
returning. Regardless of their treaties, were they
not then increasing their establishments upon the
Columbia? Under the circumstances he thought it
imperative that Congress take some steps to pre-
vent the murder of our citizens and to command re-
spect for the ** sovereignty and rights of the Con-
federacy,"*^ but the House would take no action.
In a few days after this effort Floyd voluntar-
ily ended his congressional career, but his work had
not been in vain. He had succeeded abundantly in
filling the minds of the American people with a sort
of romantic interest in the lands upon the Pacific
and in kindling in them a patriotic resistance to
British aggressions in that quarter. These forces
THE OREGON COUNTRY 75
later combined to win the prize for which he had
labored. Following the lines thus marked out the
American fur traders carried their activities across
the Rocky Mountains to the Pacific coast. Through
the knowledge which they brought back of the supe-
rior tribes of Indians who dwelt there and longed
to know of the white man's God, Jason Lee of the
Methodist Mission Board answered the call for the
gospel and, in so doing, paved the way for the col-
onization of the Columbia Valley. This movement
gave a new interest to the Oregon country, and, in
1838, Senator Ljewis F. Linn again took the matter
up in Congress, where Floyd had left it ten years
before. At the later period the movement for oc-
cupation was carried to a successful conclusion.
Whatever credit may belong to Linn and others,
John Floyd remains, nevertheless, the father of the
Oregon country. ^^He, more than any one of his
day, was the unwearied prophet of the commercial
future of the Pacific Northwest."*^ Far greater
honor and credit should therefore be accorded him
in the future than he has received in the past. His
famous report on Oregon has been reprinted ; some
of his speeches should be preserved; and he him-
self should have some lasting and fitting memorial.
IV. PRESIDENT MAKER AND GOVERNOR
THOUGH concerned in a proposed national
vaccine institution for the eradication of
small- pox,*^ in the alleged rights of the free
negroes in the District of Columbia,*®
and in the prompt payment of the
public debt, Floyd's minor activities and in-
terests centered in national politics. To the
great surprise and alarm of the politicians
of the rival factions he was, in 1824, made
chairman of a select committee appointed to con-
sider the '^Address of Ninian Edwards,''*^
which made charges of malfeasance in office against
William Henry Crawford, then a prominent candi-
date for the presidency. The composition of the
committee together with Floyd's known friendship
for Crawford's candidacy were thought to render
impossible an impartial investigation.^*' But the
politicians had set their hearts upon a political scan-
dal and were determined to have no whitewash in-
stead. Accordingly some of them joined in a move-
ment to remove Floyd from the committee, but the
*^ caucus politicians" remained loyal to Crawford
and defeated every effort to depose Floyd.
Then followed a period of anxiety during which
the country waited for the results of the investiga-
tion, the suspense being increased by one of John
Eandolph's antics. Deserting the committee of in-
vestigation of which he was a member, he left in a
flurry for Europe, leaving behind for publication in
the Richmond Enquirer a letter in which he attacked
Edwards, the president, and his fellow investiga-
tors." Meanwhile rumor had it that Floyd was
PRESIDENT MAKER AND GOVERNOR 77
trying to dismiss the charges against Crawford as
^ * frivolous and malicious, ' ' and suspicion and uncer-
tainty increased.^^
But the fears of the politicians were ill founded.
The Committee of Investigation finally acquitted
Crawford of all charges of wrong doing, and most
persons were satisfied that the evidence and circum-
stances showed a deep laid and infamous plot to
discredit an honest, though at times careless, pub-
lic servant; and Floyd received only praise for the
thoroughness and fairness with which it was ex-
posed. Thus he triumphed over his critics, vindi-
cated his choice for the presidency, and terminated
one of the most embarrassing and painful incidents
of Monroe's administration.
Among other questions having a direct bearing
upon the presidential succession, but of later date
than the above, the proposed Panama Congress of
1826 was important. Both Adams and Clay, his sec-
retary of state, favored the project and thought that
the United States should be represented in it. Al-
though he doubtless had an eye to the presi-
dency, Floyd's opposition to their plans was not
entirely political. He, too, favored an ^'American
policy'' but desired no counterpoise to the Holy Al-
liance.
Such a course meant defiance to Europe and
war. Moreover, he did not care to participate in
any arrangements which might result in Hayti
sending a negro minister to Washington, in the lib-
eration of the slaves of Cuba and Porto Rico, and
in subjecting the southern states to the possible at-
78 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
tacks and the subtle influences of a neighboring free
negro population.^^
It was about this time, probably earlier, that
Floyd and other southern leaders of his type had
their first definite understanding regarding the
presidential election of 1828. Up to that time they
had been determined to defeat Adams for a reelec-
tion but could not agree upon a candidate to op-
pose him. Jackson was considered impossible, but
their favorite, Calhoun, could not command a popu-
lar following. After his unsuccessful contest of
1824-1825 they had expected Jackson's star to set
in peaceful oblivion, but the developments of a pe-
riod of anxious waiting convinced them that he had
come into the political arena to stay. As the inno-
cent victim of the famous ^^ corrupt bargain" by
which Clay was alleged to have placed Adams in the
presidency, Jackson had constantly grown in popu-
lar favor. The leaders had, therefore, no other
choice between him and certain defeat. They flat-
tered themselves, however, that Jackson in the
White House could easily be relegated into the
background of his own administration and that the
affairs of government could thus be carried on as
of old. Accordingly, Martin Van Buren, speaking
for the North, and Littleton Waller Tazewell, one
of Floyd 's intimate friends, speaking for the South,
concluded a working alliance between the ** plan-
ters'' of the latter section and the ^' plain republi-
cans" of the former by which Andrew Jackson was
to be made president.^*
Confident of success and probabl^^ of prefer-
ment under the leadership of the ''Old Hero" who
PRESIDENT MAKER AND GOVERNOR 79
was thought to have at least one foot in the grave,
Floyd was active on the political battle line. At
times his ardor seems to have dulled his judgment.
This was certainly true when he gave to the Demo-
cratic Central Committee, for publication, a state-
ment of a private conversation with Clay, in 1824,
in which the latter, in response to Floyd's efforts
to dissuade him from supporting a man of Adam's
unpopularity for the presidency, was alleged to have
said: ^*Give us [Adams and Clay] the patronage
of the federal government, and we will make our-
selves popular.'' Despite the methods used to se-
cure it, Floyd considered Jackson's election a tri-
umph for true democracy. Accustomed, as he was
to the old methods of caucus politics, he doubtless
considered himself partly responsible for the vic-
|Qj.y 55
Belying upon Jackson's supposed intention to
select his advisers from the ** talented and distin-
guished men of the Confederacy" and probably
expecting for himself a call to the new cabinet, Floyd,
in January, 1829; declined a reelection to Con-
gress. Considering his future course his printed
letter to his constituents announcing his purpose to
retire is as amusing as it is interesting and instruc-
tive. The letter is here given in full :
Feli.ow Citizens — I have been your representative in Con-
gress, and I feel proud of having been so distinguished by
my fellow citizens. This favor has been the more grateful to
me, and is cherished in every recollection, when I reflect
in this long period, you have conferred that office upon me
without opposition.
I know you have had something to pardon and forgive
80 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
in your representative, because I, in common with mankind,
am liable to err. Whatever my errors may have been, they
were, however, unintentional; as I am not conscious of ever
having done anything other than the constitution of our coun-
try, your honor, and your interest required at my hand. That
portion of the sovereign power of Virginia, which you con-
fided to me, is returned to you uninjured and undiminished.
Though, in the course of the great conflict, which has event-
uated in another great political revolution, the constitution
may have received some deep wounds, it has not been by the
hand of your representative.
I have the fullest hope, and the strongest belief, that
a wise, cautious, circumspect, and temperate course will be
pursued by General Jackson whom we all contributed our
best wishes and our best efforts to place in the presidential
chair of the Confederacy; and that he will aid in healing
those wounds, and calming the troubled fears of all.
Whilst this war in the political world was going on, in
which, as we conceived, nothing less than the great princi-
ples of liberty and the rights of the sovereign states were
concerned, I should have deemed myself unworthy the flat-
tering kindness and confidence, with which you have on all
occasions honored me, had I in this hour of danger and diffi-
culty, of responsibility and trial, quitted the post v/hich you
assigned me. Now it is otherwise. General Jackson will, on
the fourth day of March next, commence his duties as Presi-
dent of the United States with a clear sky and a calm sea.
To pay the public debt, to lop off all the branches of useless
expenditure, to revive our sinking commerce and heal the
bleeding wounds in the Constitution, inflicted by ambition,
avarice, and a spirit of monopoly, will constitute an ample
field, in which he may win laurels no less green than those
won on the plains of New Orleans; and crown himself with
more true glory in the love and admiration of millions of free-
men, than all the conquerors of earth ever possessed. Such,
fellow citizens, is the condition of our country which justifies
me in saying to you that I am not a candidate to represent our
district in the next Congress.
In taking leave of you, as your representative. I have
PRESIDENT MAKER AND GOVERNOR 81
a request which fills me with pain, because I feel assured that
I never can convey to? you any just idea of the deep sense
of my gratitude for your indulgence and kindness to me.
Could I manifest that to you and make you sensible of the
true condition of my feelings, I should be cheered by the
memories of it in my retirement. I am, fellow citizens, ss Your
humble servant,
John Floyd.
For reasons later to be considered Floyd was
not given a place in Jackson's cabinet. Accordingly
he retired to his home in the Valley of Virginia,
there to enjoy the love and confidence of a large f am-
ly of children and a devoted wife and to retrieve his
declining fortunes. In his retirement his children
shared with him the pleasures of the chase and the
violin ; his wife became his most trusted political and
business adviser; and his neighbors again became
the recipients of his gratuitous services as a physi-
cian.
Of the many wonderful families of Virginia there
are few to be found anywhere more interesting and
important than that of John Floyd and his wife, Le-
titia. To this union were born twelve children, of
whom George, Susan, and Thomas died in infancy,
Mary at the age of six, and Coralie at the age of
eleven. Those who survived to maturity were : John
Buchanan, w^ho became Governor of Virginia and a
member of President Buchanan's cabinet; William
Preston, a distinguished physician of Wytheville,
Virginia; George Rogers Clark, secretary of the
Wisconsin Territory and later a distinguished mem-
ber of the legislature of West Virginia ; Benjamin
Rush, a celebrated lawyer of southwestern Virginia ;
Tjetty Preston who married William S. Lewis ; Eliza
82 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
Lavelette who married George Frederick Holmes,
long a professor of history and literature in the Uni-
versity of Virginia; and Nicketti Buchanan who
married John Warfield Johnston, from 1870 to 1883
a member of the United States Senate."
Through this family, celebrated for its intellect
as well as for its numbers, John Floyd's influence
survived long after he had passed from the political
stage and had much to do with shaping Virginia's
policies at critical periods. Almost without excep-
tion, his immediate descendants and their connec-
tions were persons of political influence devoted to
the state sovereignty theory of government. But for
them the history of secession in Virginia might have
been written differently. Wherever they resided
and were active, even in what is now West Virginia,
there the pro-southern and secession sentiment was
strong; there particularism, as taught by Patrick
Henry, flourished.
There are yet those in Virginia and elsewhere
who believe that Floyd's descendants and their con-
nections should have had a greater part and respon-
sibility in directing the affairs of the Southern Con-
federacy. Such persons criticise President Davis
for his failure or refusal to recognize their import-
ance and abilities. Although their favorite was vin-
dicated by the General Assembly of Virginia and the
testimonials of his soldiers, there are those who have
not forgotten that John B. Floyd was summarily re-
moved from his command after the fall of Fort Don-
aldson; that Joseph Eggleston Johnston, a member
of the famous Johnston family of Virginia, did not
receive the promotion which seemed to be due him ;
PRESIDENT MAKER AND GOVERNOR 83
and that, against the protests of his devoted sol-
diers, he too was relieved of his command following
the fall of Atlanta. The heartburnings thus kindled
are yet alive and have rendered the name of Jeffer-
son Davis odious to some confederates.
In his efforts to relieve his declining fortunes
Floyd relied largely upon the products of his past-
ure lands. Experience, environment, and study had,
in fact, made him an authority upon the subject of
grazing. The following extract from a letter by
Floyd upon that subject shows a broad grasp of the
economic forces in the development of this and
other countries :
I am inclined to believe that we might almost tell the
condition of every country and form a very accurate opinion
of its prosperity from simply ascertaining the proximity of
the grazing region to the commercial town of that country,
provided the soil of the country is adapted to grass from the
seaport to the distant frontier.
This is founded upon my knowledge in part and from
history which I think fully sustains the opinion,
I cannot now call to mind the precise period, but you rec-
ollect that English history tells us at the period referred to,
perhaps during the reign of Elizabeth, an ox sold in the
markets of London for about thirteen shillings, which ox
grazed near the city. Now their beef is fed on the Teese in
the mountains of Wales and in the Highlands of Scotland;
that small but esteemed beef called the Kyloe is principally
had there.
In France, also, grass and beef at a much later period
than that first referred to, seems to have employed many of
its inhabitants in the neighborhood of their largest towns.
Now however the principal supply of beef is obtained at a great
distance.
In our own country the same thing has taken place. The
city of New York not many years ago obtained its beef from
84 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
the neighbouring counties. At this day they procure it from
the most distant counties, and even from the State of Ohio,
Philadelphia and Baltimore thirty-five years ago, were sup-
plied from the counties lying between those cities and Car-
lisle in Penna. They now get much of their beef from Ohio,
and the western counties of Pennsylvania and Virginia.
I have mentioned this briefly to show that as the pros-
perity of the country increases cities also increase, which arises
from the fact that all the commodities produced from the soil
are more valuable in market than beef, and hence the beef re-
gion is thrown to a greater distance.
Not only is this true, but it requires much more land to
produce the same revenue where the ox is grazed, than any
product which the farmer cultivates, for example I will take
Virginia in her present condition.
The grass region in the southwest may be said to extend
from the Roanoke to Kentucky, including all the branches of
grazing. The nearest point to this city where is fed for
market, intended as proof beef, is Montgomery in that direc-
tion. In that county there are many extensive farms some
perhaps of from fifteen hundred to two thousand acres, laid
down in grass to graze the ox for market. This is the precise
point at which flour and other heavy products of the farm
cease to be of value to the producer on account of the high
price of transportation resulting from the distance to market
and the bad condition of the roads.
The farmer finding himself possessed of large tracts of
land immediately clears it off, by killing the timber; perhaps
sows upon it some grass seed, and in a few days it becomes
rich pasture. His next step is to purchase as many oxen,
from his neighbour still more distant, as will graze upon
these pastures and become fat. If he has slaves he keeps
them on his farm during the winter and feeds them the crop
of the preceding summer. For this purpose perhaps twenty
hands may be necessary where the farm contains fifteen hun-
dred acres of pasture land.
But if the farmer has such an extensive establishment
and six or eight men, which is a pretty good supply of labor,
he generally sells his cattle in October or November to some
purchaser who feeds them as before observed until he can
PRESIDENT MAKER AND GOVERNOR 85
dispose of them in the market, which will sometimes require
a whole winter's operation.
In this way you will perceive slaves are not necessary,
very few however to the feeder and still fewer to him who sells
from the pasture, and none to those who furnish the store
cattle, because they most generally raise them in the range,
as it is called, that is by turning in the forest or in the moun-
tains during the winter months.
To graze an ox well it will require from two and an half
to five acres of ground. Taking into view the quality of the
soil of the country, the age of the pasture, and the drought,
I think five acres would be about a fair average, because I
have known some thin soil whilst new to require even eight
acres for several years to sustain an ox so as to make proof
beef. This however is rarely the case.
By this process the land will be worth perhaps two dol-
lars per acre, sometimes more, but I think the increased value
of the ox, when made fat upon the grass alone, will be worth
much more. When poor, the animal is purchased, according
to his size, say at twelve dollars. If the animals are large
and well formed they will command when poor from twenty to
twenty-five dollars. The increased value when fat is not in
the same proportion, besides this stock sheep are often put
over the same ground to follow the fat cattle and become
the finest sort of mutton. The only attention in this process
is to examine daily to ascertain whether accidents have oc-
curred, to know when the stock should be removed to fresh
pasture and to give them salt every day, or every few days.
It will not be well to let them want salt longer than three
days.
In this mode of drawing a revenue from the soil you will
perceive that few slaves are necessary, and more than can be
employed in the daily routine described is a bad investment
of capital in such a country. Hence a slave is seldom pur-
chased unless his labor is wanted for some specific purpose. 58
But Floyd was not long permitted to enjoy the
pleasures of his home and estate. On January 9,
1830, less than one year after he had declined a re-
86 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
election to Congress, he was made governor of Vir-
ginia, receiving one hundred and forty votes to six-
ty-six cast for Peter V. Daniel.-'' At the time of his
election a notable body of men, in convention assem-
bled, was engaged in relaying the fundamental laws
of his state. Considering the personnel of that body,
containing, as it did, two ex-presidents of the United
States, Madison and Monroe, the venerable chief
justice of the Supreme Court, John Marshall, the
Governor of Virginia, William B. Giles, and a score
or more other members prominent in political and
judicial life, Floyd was rather conspicuous for his
absence. Considering the exigencies of the times
from the standpoint of federal relations, he was
probably already the choice of the state rights poli-
ticians for the governorship of Virginia to succeed
Giles. His desire to speak for the whole state in the
impending nullification crisis, therefore eliminated
him from participation in local politics.
From the sources at hand it is difficult to deter-
mine Floyd's position on the question of a proper
basis of representation for the several counties of
Virginia in the General Assembly, the chief subject
of discussion in the state constitutional convention
at the time of his election to the governorship. His
neighbor favored the white basis as opposed to the
mixed basis of property and persons. His silence is
probably best explained again by the fact that he
was the gubernatorial candidate of the old line pol-
iticians of the eastern countries, who favored the
mixed basis of representation and opposed reforms
generally. The readiness with which he accepted the
Constitution of 1830, as the best possible compromise
PRESIDENT MAKER AND GOVERNOR 87
of the differences between the rival sections, betrays
an unusual sympathy for the tidewater interests, be-
cause his neighbors of the Abingdon district were
now, for the most part, unwilling to compromise
their local political difference with the residents of
the eastern counties. Some were open in their ex-
pression of a desire for dismemberment of the
Commonwealth.^^
Whatever may have been Floyd's attitude to-
wrrds the all important question of representation
in the local Assembly, he was in thorough sympathy
with the interests and demands of his section on the
subject of internal improvements. Blessed, as it
was witn many navigable rivers, the Tidewater had
consistently refused to tax itself for the construction
and maintenance of roads and canals for the use of
the uplands and the sections beyond the mountains.
But Floyd thought that the future greatness of the
Commonwealth la}^ in her ability to render available
her natural resources and to bind her inhabitants
together by the ties of common interest. In his an-
nual messages to the General Assembly he, there-
fore, recommended that immediate steps be taken to
these ends. The debates then waging regarding the
comparative values of railroads and canals were of
little concern to him; action had become impera-
tive.^'
The proposed central line of communication con-
necting Richmond and the Valley by way of the
James received his first consideration. Next in im-
portance came the plans for rendering accessible the
counties of the southwest. This he thought should
be done by a railroad extending to the salt, lead,
88 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
iron, and gypsum mines of that section. Thus, in
case of war, the state could command its natural
resources and dispatch troops, very important con-
siderations to one who believed, as did Floyd, that
^^ speed is power; dispatch victory/^ Meanwhile
the proposed great highway passing through Fred-
ericksburg, Richmond and Petersburg at the head
of tide and connecting the North and the South, and
that other proposed highway passing from one end
to the other of the Valley were not to be neglected.
Like many other Virginians, Floyd ^s attitude to-
wards negro slavery, which was receiving serious
consideration at this time by his state, was determin-
ed largely by local conditions and abolitionist activ-
ities. When, in August, 1831, like a firebell in the
night, the report of a negro uprising in Southampton
County, brought to all the gruesome account of the
death struggle of helpless women and children at the
hands of their brutal and misguided slaves, thus
breaking the long and studied silence upon the sub-
ject of the relations between the whites and the
blacks, Floyd predicted that ^^This will be a very
notable day.'^ At once he prepared to meet the
crisis by sending troops and artillery to the scene
of the uprising. Though taking every precaution
for the defence of his people, he refused to impli-
cate the slave masses and placed the blame for their
conduct in Southampton County upon their misguid-
ed leaders. Through the whole excitement he never
lost sight of those slaves who had remained loyal
to their masters, even in the midst of the uprising.
The court sentences of some of those condemned to
PRESIDENT MAKER AND GOVERNOR 89
death were commuted to imprisonment or deporta-
tion, and others were set free.^"
In reply to an inquiry from Governor Hamilton
of South Carolina, Floyd wrote the following let-
ter regarding the causes of the Southampton Insur-
rection and suggested ways of dealing with the ne-
gro and slave problems :
I received your letter yesterday, and with great pleasure
will state my impressions freely.
I will notice this affair in my annual message, but shall
only give a very careless history of it, as it appears to be pub-
lic.
I am fully persuaded the spirit of insubordination which
has, and still manifests itself in Virginia, had its origin among,
and eminated from, the Yankee population, upon their lirst
arrival amongst us, but most especially the Yankee pedlars
and traders.
The course has been by no means a direct one. They
began first by making them religious; their conversations were
of that character, telling the blacks, God was no respecter of
persons; the black man was as good as the white; that all men
were born free and equal; that they can not serve two mas-
ters; that the white people rebelled against England to obtain
freedom; so have the blacks a right to do.
In the meantime, I am sure without any purpose of this
kind, the preachers, especially Northern, were very assiduous
in operating upon our population. Day and night they were
at work and religion became, and is, the fashion of the times.
Finally our females and of the most respectable were per-
suaded that it was piety to teach negroes to read and write,
to the end that they might read the Scriptures. Many of them
became tutoresses in Sunday Schools and pious distributors of
tracts from the New York Society.
At this point more active operations commenced; our
magistrates and laws became more inactive; large assemblies
of negroes were suffered to take place for religious purposes-
Then commenced the efforts of the black preachers. Often
90 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
from the pulpits these pamphlets and papers were read, fol-
lowed by the incendiary publications of Walker, Garrison and
Knapp of Boston; these too with songs and hymns of a sim-
ilar character were circulated, read and commented upon, we
resting in apathetic security until the Southampton affair.
From all that has come to my knowledge during and since
this affair, I am fully convinced that every black preacher, in
the whole country east of the Blue Ridge, was in the secret,
that the plans as published by those northern prints wer^a
adopted and acted upon by them, that their congregations, as
they were called knew nothing of this intended rebellion, ex-
cept a few leading, and intelligent men, who may have been
head men in the church. The mass were prepared by making
them aspire to an equal station by such conversations as I
have related as the first step.
I am informed that they had settled the form of govern-
ment to be that of the white people, whom they intended to
cut off to a man, with this difference that the preachers were
to be their governors, generals and judges. I feel fully justi-
fied to myself, in believing the northern incendiaries, tracts,
Sunday Schools, religion and reading and writing has accom-
plished this end.
I shall in my annual message recommend that laws be
passed to confine the slaves to the estates of their masters,
prohibit negroes from preaching, absolutely to drive from this
state all free negroes, and to substitute the surplus revenue
in our treasury annually for slaves, to work for a time upon
our railroads, etc., and then sent out of the country, prepara-
tory, or rather as the first step to emancipation. This last
point will of course be tenderly and cautiously managed, and
will be urged or delayed as your state and Georgia may be
disposed to cooperate.
In relation to the extent of this insurrection I think it
greater than will ever appear. The facts will as now consid-
ered, appear to be these: It commenced with Nat and nine
others on Sunday night, two o'clock, we date it Monday morn-
ing before day, and ceased by the dispersion of the negroes on
Tuesday morning at ten o'clock. During this time the negroes
had murdered sixty-one persons and traversed a distance of
twenty miles, and increased to about seventy men. They
PRESIDENT MAKER AND GOVERNOR 91
spared but one family and that one was so wretched as to be
in all respects upon a par with them. All died bravely indi-
cating no reluctance to lose their lives in such a cause.
I am with consideration and respect. Your obedient ser-
vant,63
John B^oyd.
Though impressed with the necessity of moving
^ tenderly and cautiously'* and with due regard to
the wishes and conditions of other slave-holding
states the alarm occasioned by the Southampton
Insurrection, in eastern Virginia, was such that
Floyd decided, in November, 1831, to recommend to
the Greneral Assembly the enactment of a law pro-
viding for the gradual abolition of negro slavery.
If such a law could not be made to apply to the whole
state, he hoped to have it apply to the counties west
of the Blue Ridge Mountains with a view to the
final enactment of such a law for the whole state. ^*
Nevertheless his annual message for that year
contained no recommendation regarding the aboli-
tion or even the gradual abolition of negro slavery.
Whether, as on former occasions, the slave-holding
states advised delay and caution or the condition of
federal relations was such as to render unwise the
injection of other and complicating subjects, Floyd
had evidently resolved not to push the matter. Yet
he did all in his power to precipitate its discussion
in the Assembly and expressed his confidence in the
ability of his young friends from the western coun-
ties: Summers, Faulkner, Preston, Campbell, and
others to manage the ^ ^ atf air most excellently. ' '
But, when the debate which he thus aided to pre-
cipitate in the House of Delegates began to be heat-
V
92 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
ed and to engender bad feelings, Floyd, with others,
became alarmed. Regarding the delegates from be-
yond the mountains as allies of the abolitionists and
as bent upon the destruction of slave property, the
delegates from the eastern counties talked of a dis-
memberment of the Commonwealth. As expressed
by Floyd, ^^a sensation had been engendered which
required great delicacy and caution in touching. ^ ' It
was allayed, and with his approval, by shifting the
question from that of gradual abolition to that of
the *^ expediency'' of legislating upon the subject at
all at that time. On this proposition the pro-slavery
party won, the vote being sixty-seven to sixty.
The uncertain condition of federal relations at
this time was doubtless a factor in defeating the an-
ti-slavery party in Virginia. Absorbed, as he was
in national affairs, Floyd was perfectly willing to
turn the whole subject of the state's proper policy
regarding negro slavery over to the solution of a
master who was at hand in the person of Thomas
R. Dew of William and Mary College, a man in
whom all Virginia reposed the greatest confidence.
In April, 1832, Floyd wrote him inviting his atten-
tion to the subjects of slavery and abolition as set
forth in the debates of the Assembly of 1831-1832.
The able defence and justification of the institution
of negro slavery which followed was accepted by
Floyd and most other Virginians of whatever sec-
tion as final. Under the changed conditions the anti-
slavery sentiments of 1832 were largely lost sight
of in a struggle to maintain the state sovereignty
theory of government.
As Floyd's ^^ Diary," published herewith, prac-
PRESIDENT MAKER AND GOVERNOR 93
tically covers the period of his term as Governor,
the reader is referred to that source for a fuller
account of his domestic policies and local activi-
ties than is here given. On February 11, 1831, he
was re-elected without opposition, this time, to a full
term of three years, thus becoming the first gov-
ernor of Virginia under her Constitution of 1830,
a distinction of which he was proud. Like his pre-
decessor he took a keen interest in the selection of
his successor, his choice falling upon the successful
candidate, Littleton Waller Tazewell. Believing
that ** great events are in the gale'' he urged Taze-
well to hasten to Richmond and prepared to lay
down his share in the power of the state as he had
lain it down for the * ^ Confederacy, ' ' ^'uninjured
and undiminished.''®^
The Richmond Whig of April 17, 1834, noted his
retirement to private life in this editorial :
Yesterday Governor Floyd left Richmond for his resi-
dence in Montgomery, carrying with him the hearty good
wishes of the great bulk of this population for his happiness
and prosperity. He was escorted out of town by all the vol-
unteer companies — Digger's Blues, Richardson's Artillery, My-
er's Cavalry, and Richardson's Riflemen. No Governor has
retired from office with a more general feeling of regard from
the citizens of Richmond.
V. AN APOSTLE OF DISCONTENT
SUFFERING from declining health and de-
spairing of the republic under the ad-
ministration of Jackson whom he had
helped to place in office, Floyd was, during
his period as governor of Virginia, an apos-
tle of a local and sectional discontent that, at times,
threatened the preservation of the Union. His griev-
ances were not, however, mainly personal and polit-
ical. He spoke for a poverty stricken and declining
section embracing a large part of tidewater and
piedmont Virginia and extending far into the same
sections of the lower Atlantic seaboard. Thence
had gone tobacco growers into Kentucky and Ten-
nessee and cotton planters into the Gulf States leav-
ing desolation and poverty behind. With others
Floyd now lamented the decline of the seaboard
planters and watched, in dismay, the lowering clouds
of obscurit}^ as they gathered over the places made
vacant by the flight of population and capital to the
westward. Alarm was, indeed, the general aspect
of the South 's ancient aristocracy, and others than
Floyd had come to believe that the days of her won-
derful civilization were numbered.
Many patriotic attempts had been made to avert
the effects of these calamities. For a decade or more
agricultural societies had sought remedial aid in a
more scientific cultivation of lands; experiments
were then being made with a view to converting the
tobacco, corn, and wheat lands of Virginia into cot-
ton plantations; Edmund Ruffin was teaching the
scientific use of calcarious manures ; plans for con-
AN APOSTLE OF DISCONTENT 95
necting the eastern and western counties by means
of turnpikes and canals were on foot ; in defence of
a declining power in their legislative assemblies the
older sections of the slaveholding states had devel-
oped a well defined theory of minority rights; at
South Carolina College Doctor Cooper was teach-
ing the sons of the South the Manchester doctrines
of laissez faire; near him, at Fort Hill, South Caro-
lina, Calhoun had formulated his famous nullifica-
tion doctrines ; and meanwhile Virginia, in her reso-
lutions on federal relations, had protested, from
time to time, against the exactions of the odious tar-
iff.
Regardless of the wishes and interests of the
South, the North continued meanwhile to demand
protection for her manufacturing industries and
congressional appropriations for her projected in-
ternal improvements. More alarming still, her
power to enforce these demands increased from day
to day, as the South 's minority in Congress grew
smaller. Nor could she always rely upon the loy-
alty of her own sons removed to other sections to
guard her interests. Prosperous in their new homes
beyond the mountains, which required only good
roads and markets to make them ideal, they had
not hesitated to ally themselves with the North in
support of the American System of which Clay, him-
self a native Virginian, was the father.
Under the circumstances there seemed nothing
left to the seaboard South but the election of a
president who would cast the weight of his office
against the demands and power of the North. Thus
it was hoped to make any resort to nullification,
96 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
secession, or the Virginia doctrines of 1798 unnec-
essary. Although Jackson ^s record was not to their
liking, Floyd and others expected his official acts,
under the changed conditions, to be shaped largely
by the interests and demands of the South. Foi
these and other reasons, already referred to, they
had aided in placing him in the presidency.
Speaking of their expectations in this connec-
tion Floyd later said:
"At this moment [1828] came the direful struggle be-
tween the great parties in Congress founded upon the claim
which the majority . . . from the north of the Potomac
made to the right to lay any tax upon the importations into
the United States which was intended to act as a protection
to northern manufacturers by excluding foreign fabrics of the
same kind. Hence all the states to the south of the Potomac
became dependent upon the Northern States for a supply of
whatever thing they might want, and in this way the South
was compelled to sell its products low and buy from the North
all articles it needed from twenty-five to one hundred and
twenty-five per cent higher than from France to England . . .
At this juncture the southern party brought out Jackson."
"With the popularity which he had shown in 1824
and especially with the aid of Pennsylvania which
he had carried at that time, it was thought that **the
South could elect Jackson and by his help reduce
the odious tariff. ''^^
In this connection Floyd's support of the inter-
ests and demands of the seaboard South may need
some explanation. The interests of his former con-
stituents in the Valley had not always harmonized
with those of eastern Virginia. Besides, it can not
be forgotten that Floyd was born and reared in
AN APOSTLE OF DISCONTENT 97
Kentucky. He seems, however, to have been
true to the interests of his neighbors and was
not the tool of the slave-holding aristocracy.
Already negro slavery had gained a firm foot-hold
in the counties about his home, thus identifying their
interests with those of the slaveholding sections.
Besides, Floyd was related to and connected with
some of the oldest and most conservative families
of the old South, notably the Prestons of South
Carolina, who were then among Calhoun's most
trusted advisers.
Personal and political disappointments played,
however, a large part in Floyd's opposition to
Jackson and his administration. It seems certain
that he left Congress fully expecting to be called to
some higher place in the federal service. It is cer-
tain that he expected Mr. Calhoun, the vice-presi-
dent, his close friend, and ^^the one upon whom we
placed the highest confidence,'' to play the leading
role in the new administration; also, that such men
as Landon Cheves of South Carolina, Tazewell of
Virginia, Hugh L. White of Tennessee, and others
of the old guard would be called to the places of
highest trust.^^ Instead, of all those who had done
most, in Floyd's opinion, to secure Jackson's elec-
tion only Martin Van Buren received a cabinet port-
folio. In some mysterious way Floyd and his friends
had qualified as suitable persons for foreign mis-
sions and governors of distant territories, and a
race of ** harpies" represented by Amos Kendall,
William B. LewiS; and others of the later famous
** kitchen cabinet" had usurped the places which the
old line politicians had reserved for themselves.
98 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
Tlius Jackson had been tested and found to be like
^ ^ the apples of the Dead Sea . . fair to the eye but
all bitterness and ashes within. "^^
It was under these conditions that Floyd was
made governor of Virginia but not as an avowed an-
ti-administration candidate. Those back of his can-
didacy were too farseeing for any such a blunder.
Disappointed in their personal ambitions they still
hoped to redress the South 's economic grievances
and to allay the sectional discord in Virginia which
was then threatened with dismemberment. Accord-
ingly many Jackson men in the General Assembly,
which then elected the governor, supported Floyd's
candidacy.*^^ Though the Richmond Enquirer, sl
Jackson organ ably conducted by Thomas Ritchie,
failed to comment upon Floyd's election, there is
no reason to conclude that its attitude was in itself
a severe stricture.
Already disgusted with the personnel of the new
cabinet, Floyd was driven by the events of the year
1830 into active and open opposition to the admin-
istration. First there was the Mrs. Eaton affair in
which Jackson demanded recognition by his official
family for a woman whose reputation was such that
Mrs. Calhoun did not recognize her. Then came the
famous Webster-Hayne debate in which the bonds
uniting the North and the South were drawn to the
breaking point with eJackson maintaining the posi-
tion of a neutral. An effort to ally him with the
South, his own section, brought from him that as-
tounding but patriotic declaration: ^'Our Federal
Union, it must be preserved. ' ' Soon thereafter fol-
lowed an open breach between Jackson and Calhoun
AN APOSTLE OF DISCONTENT 99
caused by W. H. Crawford's revelation of the long
concealed fact that it was Calhoun who, as secretary
of war in 1818, had desired to censure Jackson for
his conduct in Florida in dealing with the Seminoles
and the British agents, Arbuthnot and Ambrister.
Explanations from Calhoun had sufficed only to
place him among political traitors and in no way
appeased Jackson who had probably known of Craw-
ford 's intentions for some months. The time had
come for a break. Accordingly Duff Green, Cal-
houn's friend, was deposed from the editorship of
the party organ, the Daily Telegraph, to make a
place for Jackson's friend, Francis P. Blair, who,
in December, 1830, founded a new organ, the Globe.
Meanwhile one session of Congress had passed
without any change in the tariff schedules.
Thus far the attitude of the administration was
equivalent to a declaration of war, if not upon the
South certainly upon her politicians of the old
guard. In a letter of May 4, 1830, to his ^*dear
friend," Flo3^d, John Tyler made his position clear.
He was certain that the efforts of the president, his
satellites, and his mercenaries would not break them
(the state rights party) down or cause them to yield
to a mere majority. He said:
"We should [thus] derive an immortality of infamy-
more damnable than that which attended the rascal who
fired the Temple of Ephesus. They may pronounce us
mad, if they please, but we say with Hamlet that we
yet know a "hawk from a hand saw." If I am to sink
for this, be it so in the name of all that is holy, I can not die
a political death that would be attended with fewer pangs.^o
100 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
But there is little evidence that Tyler expected
political death either for himself or his friends.
That was to be the portion of the administration
crowd. Failing to recognize Clay's superior rights,
Tyler expected Jackson to throw himself at the
head of the American System. There, he would
favor and encourage large appropriations for
roads and canals, a *' judicious tariff,'^ a distribu-
tion of the surplus revenues, an enlargement of the
pension system, removals from office for ** opinion's
sake'' and license for the wildest pretensions of the
Federal Supreme Court under the leadership of
John Marshall. As in the case of Adams and Clay,
this course was expected to result in an avalanche of
disapproval. Already discontent was abroad in the
land. Tyler had never seen ^^so much dissatisfac-
tion." His friend Troup, a senator from Georgia,
was authority for the statement that the president
could not again carry the state of Ohio.
Somewhat later, in a letter of December 27, 1830,
Floyd's own impressions and purposes were clearly
set forth, to his friend. Colonel John Williams of
Nashville, Tennessee, as follows:
As you long ago wrote me, and told me personally, nay
predicted, Jackson has thrown me overboard; he is not only
unwilling to give me employment, as he promised after I de-
clined a reelection to Congress, but has in every single in-
stance refused office to my friends, and even respectful con-
sideration to my letters of recommendation to others. Nor
does he stop here. I am at this moment enduring the whole
weight of the opposition to him, his friends, and the power
and patronage of his government to break down myself and
my friends in Virginia, and to prevent my reelection to the
office I now fill. Without having much reputation for politi-
AN APOSTLE OF DISCONTENT 101
cal matters, I have read those folks at Washington thoroughly
. . . I am not of a temper to pocket insult, neglect, or in-
jury.
I have, my dear friend, determined on my course. I can
be as silent and patient as any of my aboriginal ancestors, and
like them I feel that vengeance would be sweet, but when the
day of retribution shall come, it will be marked by the ef-
fects of the tomahawk.
You must know that notwithstanding all efforts to pre-
vent it I calculate on a reelection. Then I will begin to for-
mulate a message in which, as you know, my own principles
will be maintained. "i^i
Thus all hope of a reconciliation with Jackson
had passed, and Floyd began to prepare for a con-
test. To this end he requested his friend, Colonel
Williams, to procure affidavits from certain Metho-
dist ministers of Nashville, Tennessee, who, it was
alleged, had been asked by Jackson in the summer
of 1830 to be on the lookout for such a man for the
vice-presidency as would suit them, in case he should
decide to resign the presidency after securing a re-
election. He desired, also, to know the particulars
about a certain letter reported to have been written
by W. H. Crawford in December, 1827, to one Balch
of Nashville, in which the vote of Georgia had been
promised to Jackson on the condition that he (Jack-
son) would decline to listen to the views of John
C. Calhoun. He desired to know in particular
*^ whether Balch had shown that letter to General
Jackson, what the GenPs answer was, and what
Balch 's answer was to Mr. Crawford.*' Fortified
with this data Floyd was confident of his ability to
^* produce a state of things which will be ample ven-
geance for so much ingratitude. *'
102 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
More interesting still than this declaration of
war and active preparation for hostilities, coming,
as they did, immediately after a conversation be-
tween Floyd and Calhoun, was the willingness of
the former, even at this early date, to be on terms
of accord with Clay. All that now prevented a rec-
onciliation between them was the absence of conmion
ground *^to occupy with the freedom of former
friendship. ' ^ Floyd had no enmity toward Clay, not
even ^Hhe remotest disposition to check his future
hopes in this state, or anywhere else,'^ and he was
perfectly willing that his friends ^^ should. deal with
him as their judgment of the present and belief of
the future shall dictate. '' He also suggested that
Clay might be benefited by Calhoun's friends, since
all others in the South had for him only curses. For
himself, if he could not be Clay's friend, he was re-
solved not to be his enemy."^^ Considering the char-
acter of the combination later effected between the
followers of Cla;^ and those of Calhoun for the for-
mation of the Whig party, the above suggestions
are, to say the least, interesting.
Notwithstanding these suggestions for the for-
mation of an opposition party, the way to political
success was not clear to Floyd. His prospective al-
lies would probably expect too great a share of the
spoils and honors. Accordingly he began again to
despair of the republic. At that moment Jackson's
friends seemed supreme not only at Washington but
also in Virginia, and, in disgust, Tazewell was pre-
paring to resign his seat in the federal Senate.
Thinking that such a document might serve as a
guide and warning to future generations, Floyd now
AN APOSTLE OF DISCONTENT 103
began a diary in which he proposed to chronicle the
events of our failure at self-government.
Although Floyd * continued his diary for some
years, his despair soon turned to hope. Encouraged
by a unanimous reelection to {he governorship of
his state, then regarded as pivotal, he was, one
month later, taken into the confidence of certain
southern leaders who proposed to make Calhoun
president in 1832. Accompanied by their favorite
they had, following the adjournment of Congress,
stopped in Richmond on their way home from Wash-
ington to formulate their plans. There they enjoy-
ed a convivial period at the governor's mansion and
mingled with members of the General Assembly.
They certainly talked about Jackson's candidacy for
a reelection and about his rumored choice of Yan
Buren for the succession. The good of the country
plainly demanded their defeat, and Calhoun was
thought to be the only man who could .accomplish
that end.
Before his guests resumed their respective jmir-
neys information from Washington made it clear
that Jackson knew of the rendezvous in Richmond
and that he would give no quarter in the approach-,
ing fight. This information came to Floyd in the
form of a letter from Duif Green; the recent hap-
penings in political circles at Washington was the
pretext. As a matter of self-justification Calhoun
had published the correspondence between himself
and Jackson relevant to the Seminole affair. It was
not wholly favorable to Jackson who became indig-
nant and read Calhoun out of the Democratic party.
On the information of Judge W. T. Barry, the post-
104 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
master general in Jackson's cabinet, G-reen was in-
formed that Calhoun must henceforth be regarded
as a traitor and a nullifier. Through the same
source warning was also given that the attacks upon
Van Buren must cease."
The challenge was complete, and Floyd prepared
to put Virginia and especially Richmond in a condi-
tion for aggressive and defensive warfare. First
of all, he desired to weaken the influence of that
** profligate,'' Thomas Eitchie, the editor of the
Richmond Enquirer and the head of the Richmond
Junto, a body of politicians similar in some respects
to the Albany Regency of New York. To this end
Thomas W. Gilmer was encouraged to establish a
party organ in Richmond, devoted to the Virginia
doctrines and to the patriotic duty of keeping Cal-
houn before the country as a prominent candidate
for the presidency. In the following letter of April
16, 1831, to Calhoun, Floyd had already outlined his
plans of action :
You will perceive that Messrs. Tyler and Tazewell have
declined a public dinner; that however has made no difference
with us. Mr. Tazewell is here and has been for several days,
has been much among the members, has dined with several
messes, and has met a' most graceful reception; wherefore we
are settling down to a quiet belief that so far as Virginia is con-
cerned, all is safe, or at least so little to doubt that we do not
fear the contest.
I have received several letters from Duff Green, which have
puzzled me. He writes as though it were his opinion, and per-
haps some of our northern friends also, that it would be well
to bring you forward by the General Assembly before they ad
journ, as the vice-president with Jackson at his reelection, so as
to keep the long end of the lever in case of his death.
AN APOSTLE OF DISCONTENT 105
Of the wisdom of this scheme I doubt as Jackson in two
years may die, and moreover of his reelection I also doubt, be-
cause Virginia you may be assured, at least we feel assured, will
vote for you as president if necessary at the next election. Then
comes the difficulty with Clay and his friends; that with Jack-
son's own may throw the election into the House. How then
would it terminate? Were we now to offer you as a candidate
for the vice-presidency, would we be able with good grace to
change our front if the presidency should be deemed the proper
course next winter? Would it not seem like placing too low a
value upon the pretensions of our candidate? Besides, three
fourths of our friends look to you as the proper person to be
supported as president on the first, fit occasion. Though if nec-
essary to defeat Clay the vote can be given again to Jackson.
If Clay were out of the field, we can carry your election against
Jackson to an entire certainty.
Under all these views I really do not know which course to
take; whether to announce you a candidate for the presidency
and take the hazard of war, or wait the fate of Clay. We would
be glad to know your opinion about these things.
I have though, suggested to our friends that it would be per-
haps prudent, to keep firmly in the opposition to Clay, conciliate
his former adherents, who are now for you, and observe a quasi
war with Jackson through the summer — extend your interests,
and still weaken Jackson; let the public eye be still held upon
you until the meeting of the Assembly next fall, at which time
you will be formally presented, in the meantime our paper will
war for our principles, yet holding you forward to be supported
at the proper time. As to Van Buren he has been so disposed
of that you may consider him in this State a Caput Mortuum,
of according to the lawyers civilitur mortuum.
I have talked much with Judge Brook, the confidential
friend of Clay. He is at the head of that party, is with us,
and is anxious Clay should decline for a time. We have saved
these judges, they are our friends and will give efficient aid
by their talents, their characters and judgment.
This is my course, holding you thus before the public as a
candidate for the first office, and as we think, succeeding so
well in this state, that we are unwilling to have it supposed
106 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
anything less would be tolerated. You, however, can from
your position look through, the whole Union, and can
determine whether we are right, and make any suggestion ii
we are wrong. We think, as I have observed to you, that
Clay alone stands in the way. If you can be assured of New
England even he, I think, would not prevent your success. As
Clay will see if he does not already perceive, the consequence
of his continuing in the contest is not to benefit himself, but
to aid Jackson, as he never can be president, until another ad-
ministration has intervened. To ask the people to turn Jack-
son out and put him in would be to ask them to pronounce a
satire upon themselves. To prevail upon them to turn Jack-
son out, and put you in would be to censure Jackson and so
far by that act, to excuse Clay for his former course as to make
his future justification more easy. Can he be made to see this
course? The Fox and the Stag, when long chased by the
hounds, often lose all self-possession and lose their sagacity
entirely as to attack their pursuers at a moment when safety
would be secured by another effort.
I will not say anything about the proceedings of Pennsyl-
vania. You no doubt are already advised of all. Should they
address you, without doubt you will answer fully, fully, very
fully. Take from them the charge of nullification and dis-
union, and you are stronger than any man. I do not urge
this as being at all necessary for Virginia. Here you are safe.
The resignation of Jackson's cabinet, which now
followed as a further means of ridding the adminis-
tration of objectionable influences, made no changes
in Floyd's plans. He considered Van Buren's flight
a streak of political sagacity in which he could find
no personal consolation. Instead he saw in the de-
parture of the *^ wretched harpies" onl}^ evidences of
a ^* concerted political movement, intended by the
president and Van Bur en to effectuate some great
political object." It was possible that they desired
to make the latter vice-president and thus ^*to inflict
AN APOSTLE OF DISCONTENT 107
a punishment upon Mr. Calhoun and overthrow his
friends."
But so long as Virginia held the destiny of the
plotters in her hand Floyd felt secure. By a judic-
ious use of her power and influence he hoped to de-
feat the political aims of the administration. Ac-
cordingly he now proposed united action on the part
of the States Rights party of the South in an effort
to defeat its plans. Soon he proposed, also, to sug-
gest **to the Confederacy the name of Mr. Calhoun
of South Carolina, as a fit and proper person to fill
the presidential chair.'"*
That Calhoun knew of and approved, in general,
the movements in Virginia there can be no doubt.
In a letter of May 10, 1831, to W. C. Preston he
said :
I see that Gilmer is about to establish a new paper at
Richmond. It does seem to me that nothing could be more
propitious to the great cause for which we have been contend-
ing than the establishment of such a paper (as I doubt not
will be established) at this moment in the Capitol of the Ancient
Dominion. I have long believed that the lead of Virginia is
all important on all great constitutional struggles touching the
interests of the South; and it does seem to me that no time
could be more propitious to obtain that lead than the present.
Nothing is wanting but an energetick and able press at Rich-
mond, and I do trust that all who feel the importance of the
crisis will cooperate in its support. No one state can take
a stand on its constitutional rights, however clear her cause,
without the cheering voice of her surrounding sister states,
but with" that nothing can be more easy than to mention her
rights. Most men require to be backed by the force of publick
opinion. With these views, I do hope that this state will unite
with our friends in Virginia in sustaining Mr. Gilmer's move.
I know it is hard to get subscribers but still much may be done
108 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
and few can" do more than yourself. Let all who have a
stake in the South remember that at the next session the battle
must be fought, and that it is essential that our cause should
be vigorously sustained in the oldest, most populous, and
most exposed Southern State. I know that our friends in Vir-
ginia are looking anxiously to be sustained in this State and
generally in the South. ts
But all these well laid plans went awry. In the
first place the anti-administration organ under the
editorship of Gilmer did not materialize, and in the
second place Clay refused to listen to any overtures
for a political alliance which meant his elimination
even for a period of four years. Accordingly
Floyd's friends advised a more moderate course,
and Calhoun himself refused to become an active
candidate for the presidency so long as Clay remain-
ed in the contest *^with just strength enough to de-
feat him . . . without being able ever to elect him-
self. '"«
Discouraged and with nightmares of ^* Peggie '^
'Neil and of the towering wrecks of the federal edi-
fice haunting his memory, Floyd betook himself to
his home beyond the mountains, there to enjoy a
period of quiet and repose. He returned, however,
in time to observe the fruitless flirtations which his
friends were conducting with the Anti-Masonic
party with a view to supporting its candidate, Wil-
liam Wirt, for the presidency in place of Jackson,
but Floyd would not listen to their suggestions. He
refused absolutely to have anything to do with one
of Wirt's ** laxity in morals" and ^^ opportune" po-
litical thinking ; with one who would turn the federal
government over to ^* fanatics, knaves, and religious
bigots."
AN APOSTLE OF DISCONTENT 109
Again Calhoun appeared on the scene, this time
on his return to Washington. Kealizing the impos-
sibility of his own political ambitions and that the
interests of the South, so far as remedial tariff leg-
islation was concerned, depended upon the ap-
proaching session of Congress, that for 1831-1832,
he probably advised his friends in Virginia to ac-
quiesce in the reelection of Jackson who, in spite of
his faults, was now considered less objectionable
than the ^^ persistent'' Clay. At any rate Floyd's
opposition to Jackson ceased for the time, and he
turned his attention to the efforts then being made
for a rehabilitation of the sovereign states and for
a reduction of the tariff. Considering the fact that
nullification was in the air, that Virginia held a
strategic position in the crisis, and that Floyd was
in the confidence of Calhoun, his annual message of
December, 1831, to the General Assembly, was of
more than usual interest. That part bearing upon
federal relations dealt both with the nature of the
federal government and with the tariff."
In clear and forceful language Floyd reasserted
the state sovereignty theory of government, as guar-
anteed by the ^'Compact or Constitution," holding
the Federal Government to be merely the '^ Agent
of the States" entrusted only with such powers as
were originally intended to operate *^ externally"
and **upon nations foreign to those composing the
Confederacy." He called attention to the disre-
gard with which ^^an unrestrained majority" had
received the memorials and protests of some of the
^* sovereign states," justifying their acts by prece-
dent and expediency and thus melting away **the
110 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
solder of the Federal chain;'' also to the fact that it
was then ^'strongly insinuated" that the states
could not "interpose to arrest an unconstitutional
measure. ' ' Such a course, he was certain, could re-
sult only in nullifying the federal constitution and
in a complete failure in our experiment in govern-
ment.
The tariff was considered as a menace to the
South 's agricultural interests and as a violation of
the constitution. Floyd opposed any arrangement
whereby money could be drawn from one section, the
South, for the enrichment of another section, the
North. Under such a system he feared that those
who contributed least to the exports which brought
wealth to the treasury, would be tempted to urge
expedients for increasing their advantages. To his
mind the *' Compact" with its several compromises
had been entered into for the express purpose of
averting such a contingency. Otherwise, it had
been "misunderstood" and was, therefore, insuffi-
cient to accomplish the object for which it was de-
signed, the preservation of our rights and liberties.
On the other hand, if the tariff was unconstitutional,
then the federal government had usurped the rights
of the states and erected a political system "subver-
sive of that to which allegiance is due." No ar-
rangement in justification of the tariff, not even the
proposed distribution of the surplus revenue among
the several states, was therefore legal and right.
With this statement of his views before the coun-
try Floyd was willing to wait the action of Congress
and, for a time at least, to eschew politics ; but un-
foreseen events seemed to make the latter desire im-
AN APOSTLE OF DISCONTENT HI
possible. Accepting as a challenge the refusal of
the federal Senate to confirm Jackson's nomination
of Van Buren to be Minister to the Court of St.
James, his friends now put him forward as the can-
didate of the Democratic party for the vice-presi-
dency to succeed Calhoun. To Floyd's great amaze-
ment, Ritchie and the Richmond Junto fell in with
the plan, if indeed, they had not played an impor-
tent part in formulating it. As he had not yet given
up the idea of a reelection for his favorite and of
thus keeping control of the long end of the lever in
case of Jackson's death, these new arrangements
for the presidential succession did not appeal to
him.
Accordingly his attacks upon Jackson were re-
newed with increased vigor. Gilmer having failed
in his efforts to found a Calhoun organ in Richmond,
Richard K. Cralle, Calhoun's friend, was aided in es-
tablishing the Jeffersonian and Virginia Times in
Petersburg. Meanwhile active steps were taken to
prevent the election of Van Buren. To this end,
Tazewell having declined to save the day, P. P. Bar-
bour, a Virginian with a long and satisfactory pe-
riod of public service to his account, was brought
forward on a Jackson-Barbour ticket. In this way
Floyd expected to throw the choice of the vice-presi-
dent into the Senate, where, it was thought. Van
Buren 's election could be prevented.
Meanwhile, in Floyd's dealings with Jackson, a
question arose involving the rights and dignity of
the ** sovereign state" of Virginia. Bearing a let-
ter of studied official character from Floyd, Charles
J. Faulkner had appeared at the White House to
112 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
>
request Jackson's aid in securing information from
the British archives regarding the disputed bounda-
ry line between Maryland and Virginia. After re-
ceiving the ** Agent of Virginia*' with all due cere-
mony Jackson promised the desired aid and suggest-
ed that it might be necessary to send a special agent
to London to make investigations. Whereupon
Faulkner ad^dsed that, inasmuch as the establish-
ment of state boundary lines was a matter of concern
to the federal government, the expenses of such an
agent should not fall upon the states. This gave
the ^^Old Hero" an opportunity to remind the
'^ Agent of Virginia" that he too belonged to the
strict construction school of politicians, which denied
to Congress the power to appropriate money for
other than federal purposes. '^Sir," said he, **your
Senators are constantly watching my appropria-
tions. Tazewell, judging by his past course, would
be sure to condemn us, and your G-overnor, Floyd,
would be the first to blast us, if we departed from
the strict line of our duties, even if in favor of your
own State. "^^
Sarcasm was not considered in good taste in such
serious undertakings. Faulkner was therefore ask-
ed to prepare an account of his interview in a form
suitable for use by Tazewell as the basis of an at-
tack upon Jackson from the floor of the Senate. Of
the incident Floyd wrote : ^ ^ The President has in an
official conversation, with the Agent of the State of
Virginia, had no hesitation in opposing his own
resentment at the political opinions of the governor,
and the state, as well as those entertained by the sen-
ator, her representative in the Senate of the United
AN APOSTLE OF DISCONTENT 113
States/* Tazewell was urged to resent it all and
was assured of Virginia's approval of his acts.
Faulkner 's refusal to permit an account of a private
interview to be made the basis of a public attack
probably saved both Floyd and Tazewell from ridi-
cule. ^^
Other events of the year 1832 were not such as
to restore Floyd's confidence in Jackson. Instead
they led him to the conclusion that things were going
from bad to worse. N otwithstanding the fact that it
had received the support of a majority of Virginia's
representatives in Congress, the Tariff of 1832 was
mockery to the requests and needs of the South;
Jackson's attack upon the Bank of the United States
was simply a decoy; and the leaders of the South
had frequently encountered indifference and ridi-
cule. Then, too, Floyd's friend Barbour had resign-
ed his candidacy for the vice-presidency to accept
a place on the federal Supreme Bench, and the * kit-
tle magician, ' ' Van Buren, had been elevated to the
vice-presidency with Jackson as president. To cap
the climax South Carolina had nullified the tariff act
of 1832.
Though counseling prudence and moderation in
his annual message of December, 1832, Floyd was
then secretly counting the costs and horrors of war.
To his mind that ^* outrage upon our institutions,*'
that ** satire upon the revolution," and that ** con-
summation of a long expected executive usurpa-
tion," Jackson's Proclamation, in answer to the
Nullification Ordinance of South Carolina, made war
inevitable. Even before receiving information of
his choice by South Carolina for the presidency in
114 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
preference to Jackson, Floyd had, as the governor
of Virginia, prepared to sustain her sister state in
the fight upon the tariff and had given warning that
others should ^ ^beware.'' Already he had recom-
mended a better organization and equipment of the
state militia, and he then chafed under the limita-
tions placed on his power by the state constitution.^"
Whatever one may think of his attitude and
statesmanship on this occasion the following letter
of December 23, 1832, to his friend Tazewell affords
ample proof of Floyd ^s patriotism:
My Deae Sir: I have received your letter for which I thank
you, and hold the expression of your approbation of my mes-
sage [the regular annual message] and conduct, in this criti-
cal and dangerous period, far above the favor of a parasitical
confederacy. I, as you will have perceived, have been left to
choose my course, for none seem willing to develope any view,
or to contribute an effort, to resist this torrent poured upon
our liberties by the tyrant usurper, Jackson.
When I know my course has met the approbation of your-
self, who have no object in view but the good of the country,
and that it is the cheering voice of a personal friend who com-
mends, I feel a pleasing sensation flow over my heart like a
smile, which I would not exchange for all the honors and
wealth a tyrant could give.
How often I have wished you were now in the Assembly;
you could, if a member of that body, still save the republic. As
it is I fear the result of the coming conflict will leave us in
chains; and unless the tariff party in Congress do now repeal
those laws nullified by South Carolina, the blood of our citi-
zens will flow like water. Jackson pants for the sword and
will apply it freely in all cases law, politics or religion.
I have, my dear Sir, spent many many sleepless nights
since I came to be informed that Jackson had determined to
wage war upon a sovereign state, because I knew he was not a
patriot, but a tyrant who would as soon fight against his coun-
AN APOSTLE OF DISCONTENT 115
try as for it, if he in his own person was to be most distin-
guished and could rule without a check. I knew that to doubt
either his patriotism, his purity, his objects or his wisdom was
to stir up opposition, and perhaps hatred in those intended
to be protected and to be preserved.
I feel my bosom beginning to overflow, and I am afraid
of worrying your patience; for the heart like the eyes finds
relief from disburthening itself of long concealed and pent up
grief. I will restrain the inclination and say that all my here-
tofore reading in my school boy days, as well as my own obser^
vation in riper years, and we, since the revolution in France
down to that in Mexico, had ample fields for observation, con-
firm me in the full conviction that all who are prominent in
authority when those horrid brutalities of civil war begin will
surely perish. Virtue and patriotism then often cause the
death of the man who possesses them; nor do they receive
justice until after ages pronounce judgment, which is gener-
ally correct, there being no successful villain to flatter by an
opposite decision.
You will perceive by these reflections that should the
tyrant wage a civil war, I have no very strong expectation of
living through the struggle; but the crisis has arrived and we
ought to meet it like men who have not sought it, but it being
inevitable have met it with a corresponding resolution.
I have no desire but to retain the good opinion of my
friends, discharge my duty to Virginia like a good and faithful
citizen, more anxious to discharge well the duties of office
than to possess office.
Should this man bring upon us the scourge of civil war,
you will have no cause to lament the vaccillation of your
friend or call in doubt the confidence reposed. Killed and con-
quered we may be, but the honor and the patriotism of the
man, and of Virginia shall not be questioned even by malignity
itself.
With the sincerest friendship and the highest regard, I
am yours,8i
JOHN FLOYD.
116 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
Floyd ^s family shared with him these sentiments
and alarms. On January 1, 1833, his wife wrote :
\
God bless you my dear Floyd — a happy, happy New Year
to you. What will be its close? Will the alarming state ot
our country break up the enjoyments of our plentiful, peace-
ful home? Merciful Father! is there not honesty enough in
our government "To render unto Caesar the things that are
Caesar's and unto God the things that are God's? I rejoice to
see you hold out for the people. I can not be patient at the
possibility of a gallant enlightened community being sacrificed
to the passion of a "bloody, bawdy, treacherous, leacherous
villian." Oh my husband, how prophetic has your friend Col.
John Williams been as to yours and Calhoun's fate. I fear
power will crush you both. There is an universal indignation
amongst the women of the country at the President's course
"for letting the negroes loose upon us." Do you think such
a thing is possible? Ritchie I observe has got his cue from
the Albany Regency. You are to be sacrificed. Have you no
personal or political friend to aid you in these attacks? I ad-
vise you at once to discontinue your subscription to Niles
Register, upon the principle that I would not pay any man for
abusing me. Surely it has come to Ritchie's and Croswell's
to meet out the same justice. Croswell has forwarded a state-
ment of your dues to him which I will send by Nathan Hart
to you, which please discharge and stop the Albany Argus. If
money is to be given let it be to our own side. Duff Green has
lately had his arm broken for the cause; strengthen it by giv-
ing him that which has pampered Ritchie and Croswell. 82
Amidst the fears of impending disaster peaceful
currents continued meanwhile to flow and to make
for national accord. For his own part Floyd had al-
ways been willing to ^^ modify" his tone for the
common good. Thus when word came to him that
South Carolina was willing to submit her grievances
to a convention of the states and that Clay would
AN APOSTLE OF DISCONTENT 117
agree to a modification of the tariff, Floyd was will-
ing to cooperate with each. The Compromise Tariff
of 1833 had his approval, and it was partly out of re-
gard for his desires that the General Assembly of
Virginia voted to send Benjamin Watkins Leigh, as
a special commissioner, from that state, to South
Carolina, bearing requests for moderation and con-
ciliation in the nullification controversy. With these
turns the crisis passed leaving all parties in a posi-
tion to claim victory and the character of the federal
government as indefinite as it ever had been.
Under the changed conditions Floyd modified his
tone toward Jackson, but he stoutly refused to re-
turn to the Democratic fold so long as Van Buren
was one of its leaders. With many other state rights
men he now became *'a sort of Clay man,'' going so
far as to renew his friendship with him and to apol-
ogize in the pages of his diary for the abuses which
he had made of his confidences. ^^ He now proba-
bly thought it possible to attach Clay to the Cal-
houn car, hoping thereby to unite the South and the
West upon Calhoun for the presidency.
But it was no time for favorites ; principles now
amounted to more than men ; and the elimination of
both Clay and Calhoun from the list of eligibles for
the presidency had become temporarily imperative.
Accordingly Floyd set himself to the task of working
out a fighting alliance between all the factions op-
posed to the administration. To this end he encour-
aged discord within the Democratic party, while
scrupulously keeping the conflicting ambitions of his
own friends in the background. In November, 1833,
Judge Brook, Clay's confidential adviser in Vir-
118 LIFE OF JOHN FLOYD
ginia, made it clear to Floyd that Clay was not then
a candidate for the presidency, and about the same
time Calhoun's friends ceased to urge his claims to
that office. Thus was rendered possible a formidable
alliance between the heterogeneous elements oppos-
ed to the administration. The product was the
Whig party. Thus Floyd retired from office happy
in the belief that he had saved his country from a
threatened executive usurpation and that the wise
and the good would again soon shape the destinies
of the republic.
Soon after his retirement from public life Floyd
was attacked by a stroke of paralysis from which he
never recovered. He died August 16, 1837, and his
remains now repose in an unmarked grave at Sweet
Springs, Monroe County, West Virginia. His spirit
still lives, however, in that bond existing between the
Valley of Virginia and her tidewater and piedmont
sections. When our claims to Oregon became the
leading issue in the presidential election of 1844, his
memory and achievements were revived, but they
soon sank from sight in the long drawn out period of
sectional strife that followed.^*
FOOTNOTES
iRiclimond Times-Dispatch, May 2, 1909; Floyd, J. N, Bio-
graphical Genealogies of the Virginia-Kentucky Floyd Families.
2McElroy, R. M., Kentucky in the Nation's History, 2.
sMorehead, Address on the Settlement of Kentucky (pamphr
let).
Wraper (Manuscripts), 33 S291-335.
sMorehead's Address.
^Calendar Virginia State Papers, 1, 310.
''Idem, II, 47; James, George Rogers Clark Papers in Illi-
nois Historical Collection, VIII, 524.
sCollins, History of Kentucky, I, 238, 311; Marshall, His-
tory of Kentucky, I, 115.
sjohnston, Johnston, Preston, Floyd, and Bowen Families,
in manuscript,
^0 Journal, House of Delegates, 1814-1815, 13.
ii/dem, pp. 78. 141.
i2/(Zem, pp. 59, 76.
i3Moore, The Works of James Buchanan, XII, 306.
i4Benton, Alyridgement of the Debates of Congress, VI, 158-
162.
isRichmond Enquirer, December 15, 1818; Idem, May. 11,
1830.
^^ Annals of Congress. 16Cong. 1st sess., II., 1587; Riclimond
Enquirer, March 7, 1820.
^T Annals of Congress. 16Cong. 2d sess.,. p. 991. -
i8/(Zem, leCong. 2d sess. p. 1154.
-^Hdem, p. 1165.
^oMemoirs, V., p. 275.
^Wregon Historical Society, Quarterly, VI, 261.
'^ndem, 260; Shafer, History of the Pacific Northwest 129
23Tliese essays are in the Library of Congress.
24Benton, Thirty Years' View, I, 13.
^^Annals of Congress, 16Cong. 2d sess., 679; Benton, Abridg-
ment of Debates, VII, 50; Bancroft, H. H. History of Oregon,
I, 349-369.
26Bourne, E. G., Oregon Histo. So. Quarterly, VI, 265.
27Benton, Thirty Years' View, I, 13.
28This was undoubtedly a reference to the defalcation of
John Preston, one of Floyd's kinsmen. See Richmond Enquirer,
January 30, 1820.
120 FOOTNOTES
29Adams, Memoirs, V, 237.
■•iomies Weekly Register, XXI, 270.
■■ibidem, XXI, 350.
32it seems that the name Oregon was first applied by the
author of the Travels of Jonathan Carver to a fabled river some-
where in the far west. After Captain Gray's voyage, in 1792, the
names "Oregon" and "Columbia" were used interchangeably for
the river which he discovered. Later Bryant, in his Thanatopsis
popularized the word "Oregon" as the name of a river, but it
was John Floyd who first formally applied the name Oregon to
the territory along the Columbia River. See Shafer, History of
the Pacific Northwest, 47; Oregon Histo. So. Quarterly, VI, 265..
^^Annals of Congress. 17Cong. 1st sess. I, 722, 733 r Richmond
Enquirer, August 27, 1822.
34An?ioZs of Congress, 17Cong. I, 1034, 1073.
^5idem, II, 1617.
^^National Intelligencer, August 30, 1822.
^"^Memoirs, VI, 57.
^^Annals of Congress. 17Cong. 2d sess. 397.
39Francis Baylies was born at Dighton, Massachusetts, in
1783, and was elected to Congress in 1821, where he served three
terms. A former Federalist he became a strong supporter of An-
drew Jackson for the presidency and voted for Jackson in pref-
erence to Adams in 1825. Adams considered him "one of the
most talented and worthless men in New England." See Oregon
Histo. So. Quarterly, VI, 268.
ioAnnals of Congress. 17Cong. 2d sess., 682-683.
^ildem, 17Cong. 2d sess., 700.
ibidem, 18Cong. 1st sess., I, 1203; Adams, Memoirs, VI,
239.
*^Annals of Congress. 18Cong. 1st sess., I, 1G22; IMd.. U,
2345.
^^Congressional Debates. I, pt. I, 25; Benton, Abridg-
ments of Debates, VIII, 20S.
^^Idem, V, 195.
■*6Professor E. G. Bourne, Oregon Histo. So. Quarterly, VI.
275.
47Benton, Abridgment of Debates, VII, 8.
^^Idem, IX, 358.
^^Idern, VII, 40; Adams, Memoirs, VI, 297, 360, 391.
FOOTNOTES 121
soAdams, Memoirs, VI, 360.
5ildem, VI, 360.
^ndem, VI, 391.
53Beiiton, Abridgments of Debates, VII, 641, 673.
siAmbler, Thomas Ritchie, p. 108.
^'^Floyd's Diary.
ssRichmond Enquirer, February 3, 1829.
s7For a fuller account of the Floyd family see The John P.
Branch Historical Papers of Randolph-Macon College, IV, p. 78.
^»Floyd Manuscripts, Library of Congress.
^^Journal of the House of Delegates, 1829-'30.
soAmbler, Sectionalism in Virginia, p. 309, 315.
^^ Journal of the House of Delegates; Kanawha Banner,
October 1, 1830.
«2Floyd's Diary.
^^Floyd Manuscripts.
^Wloyd's Diary.
^^Tazewell Papers, now in Norfolk, Va.
^^Floyd^s Diary.
^Tldem. ' '
^^Idem.
^^House Journal, 1829-30. The house was largely Demo-
cratic, and the vote was: Floyd 140, Peter V. Daniel 66.
"J^Floyd Manuscripts, in the Library of Congress.
71 Idem.
T^Idem.
^^Floyd's Diary, April 16, 1831.
Ibidem, April 25, 26, 1831.
^^Floyd Ms.
^