JUL . ..>.. AJN EXPOSITION OF TIIK PRINCIPLES OF THE ROMAN CATHOLIC RELIGION WITH REMARKS ON ITS INFLUENCE IN THE UNZTSD STATES. -7. BY PHILALETHES. ^^QF- HARTFORD: TRINTED FOR THE AUTHOK. 1830. PRINCIPLES iW THE ROMAN CATHOLIC RELIGION WHAT will be the condition of our country, an hundred years hence ? This momentous question will receive very dif- ferent answers, according to the moral views and feelings of those to whom it is addressed. While some are dreaming of an uninterrupted course of national prosperity, and are constantly descanting on the future greatness and glory of our country, as if her destiny were certainly known ; others behold in the rapid inroads of vice, and error, and infidelity ; and in the open and shameless manner in which the laws of God are trampled under foot among us, fearful symptoms of approaching dissolution. What will be the final issue of these things, none can tell but the Almighty. That vain pol- iticians, who utter confident predictions of the future, know nothing about it, is as certain as the inspired declaration that *' man is of yesterday, and knows nothing." This only we learn from the Bible, that " at what instant God shall speak concerning a nation, and concerning a kingdom, to build and to plant it, if it do evil in his sight, and obey not his voice, then he will repent of the good wherewith he said he would benefit them." I shall not attempt to enumerate all the dan- gers whicrt threaten us. We need but open our eyes, and our ears, to see the bold profanation of the Sabbath, and to hear the scoffs of infidels ; we have in our Southern States an immense mass of slaves, who are nniltiplying with alarm- ing rapidity : our population is increasing at the rate of a thousand a day, and the current of emigration, which sets so strongly to the West, is rapidly bearing away this vast tide of immortal souls, beyond the light of the Bible, the Sanc- tuary, and the glorious gospel, into the valley of the shadow of death. All these things aflTord real grounds of apprehen- sion, but as they have already been ably discussed, I shall not dwell upon them, but proceed to call your attention to an- other source of danger, which, though unknown to the mass of our churches, or little feared by them, is nevertheless of great magnitude; I mean the spread of the Roman Catholic reliffion in our countrv. Some will doubtless consider the discussion of this subject as uiichiistiau, others as uiineccft- sary. The true character of the doctrines of the Romish Church, is httle understood among us. Many good people are not aware how radically they differ from the pure word of God, and the precepts of our Saviour, and his Apostles. They have been accustomed to look upon Catholic errors, as trivial, and in no way interfering with the salvation of the soul. By such I shall be charged with narrow-minded illib- erality, and they may be even ready to join with the Holy Mother Church, in the cry of persecution. Let us not be de- ceived, dear brethren, by this mistaken liberality, which can see no difference between persecution, and argument ; and which is afraid that the truth should be told, lest it should offend. I shall utter no slanders against the Catholic Church ; I shall make no assertions which I shall not endeavor to prove ; if I persecute, it will be by exhibiting the nature and tendency of their sentiments, and if they cannot bear investi- gation, it is no fault of mine. There are others, who though somewhat acquainted with the errors of the Church of Rome, do not believe it possible that they should prevail to any extent in this enlightened community. They are not aware of the spiritual dark- ness which envolopes many sections of our land, nor of the consummate skill, with which this cunningly devised religion, is adapted to the inclinations of depraved men. I shall attempt to shew, L That the Spirit of the Catholic religion is in DIRECT OPPOSITION TO THAT OF THE BiBLE, AND HIGHLY INJURIOUS IN ITS EFFECTS. II. That there is great reason to apprehend an EXTENSIVE prevalence OF THIS RELIGION IN OUR OWN country. III. The means of combatting this error, and the DUTY OF the church IN THIS RESPECT. Let it be remembered however, that my arguments, are addressed, not to Catholics, but to the Protestant Churches of ike United States, and that I shall assume as the grounds of my reasonings, the principles which are universally admitted among them. I. The Spirit of the Catholic religion, is in direct opposition to that of the Bible, and highly injuri- ous in its effects. This will appear from the following facts. 1. The Church of Rome denies that the Word of God is the ONLY Tide of faith and practice^ conwiamlins^ vs fn rereirp. the itnUiiancts and trudifio/is of I he Chunk, uilk chiUl'likc obedi- ence^ and teaching that the scrij/tures are not ahne stifficient to instrnct us in our duty towards God. As these j)rin('i|)los tiro openly acknowlcMlged by Catholics, it may seem supcrHuoiis to athhicc testimony to sliew that such is their behef. The tbllowini^- quotations iVom Catholic works of acknowledged authority in this country, will be sufli- <'ient. Question. '• Are wc bound to obey the commandments of the Church 9" Answer. *' Yes : because Christ has said to the pastors ol* the church" (and Catholics admit no church but the Church of Rome.) ' He that heareth you, heareth me,' and, * he that despises you, despises me.' [CathoHc Catechism, Chap. 5.] " The rules and ordinances of the Holy Church, are not to be counted amongst tiie doctrines and co'>iima.ndments of men; because they proceed not from mere human author- ity, but from that which Christ has established in his church, (meaning the Catholic Church,) " whose pastors he has com- manded us to obey EVEN AS HIMSELF." ^Note on Matt. 15 : 9, in the translation of the IS eic-Tcstament approved by the Rt. Rev. John Dubois, Catholic Bishop of New- York, and circulated in this country.'] " The unwritten traditions of the Apostles, are no less to be received than their Epistles." [Do. Note on II Thess. 2 : 14.] " If we would have the whole rule of faith and practice, we must not be content with those scriptures which Timothy knew from his infancy, viz^ the Old Testament, nor yet icith the New Testament, without taking along with it, the traditions of the Apostles, and the inter- pretation of the Church, to which the Ajwstles delivered both the t)Ook ami the true meaning of it.^'' [^Do. Note on 11 Timothy 3 : 16, 17.] Shell, a writer often quoted by Catholics, says, *' When the whole canon of scripture was fully cojnpleted, there was no mention made even of the least care taken by the Apostles to divulge it in other languages, wherein it might be read to the nations then converted ; which is a man- ifest sign that they thought all christians were sufficiently provided for, only by what they heard by word of mouth, anil by the traditions of the church." [Section 24, 7.] That we may safely rely upon the traditions of the church, the church must be infallible ; accordingly 2. The Church of Rome claims infallibility. Question. " Can the Church err in what she teaches T- Answer. " No: she cannot err in matters of faith.'" Q. " Why so"^'' A. '• Because Chiist has promised, that • the gates of hell shall not prevail against his church ; that the Holy Ghost shall teach her all truth ; and He himself will abide with her forever.' "* " That Christ may assist them, (the Apostles and th ir successors,) effectually in the execution of their com- mission, he promises to be with them ; (not for three or four hundred years only,) but all days even lo the consumma- lion of the world. How then could the Catholic Church ever go astray ; having always with her pastors, as is here prom- ised Christ himself, who is the ivay, the truth and the life,'' [^Catholic version, Note on MatlL 28: 18.] Sheil says " you see, therefore," (addressing himself to a Protestant) " by clear Scripture that the church cannot err," and in other pla- ces he speaks of the church as an infallible interpreter of the Scriptures, as we shall presently shew. Indeed the doctrine of infallibility, is interwoven with the very constitution of the papal church, and is so universally admitted, that it would he useless to spend words to prove it. We will merely no- tice the singular fact, that this attribute of infallibility, does not exist in any single individual in the Roman Church, not even the Pope, (as is now generally admitted,) but in the uni- ted voice of the fallible members which compose it. As far as I can learn the decisions and decrees of her councils, as those of Nice, Trent rink ye all of it. Notes. *' He does not say, this is the figure of my body, but this is my body : neither does he say, in this, or with this, is my body, but absolutely, This is my body : which plainly implies transubstantiation. Drink ye all of it. This was spoken to the twelve Apostles, who were the all then present. But it no ways follows from these words spoken to the Apos- tles, that all the faithful are here commanded to drink of the chalice." Our readers will recollect that Catholics deny the cup to the laitv. ^i lU hov the note on Matth. 28 : 18, see above. Luke 1 : 48, Henceforth all generations shall call me bles- sed. Note. *' These words are a prediction of that honour which the church in all ages should pay to the Blessed Virgin.'* What that honour is which Catholics pay to her, shall here- after be shewn. Luke 16 : 9. Make to yourselves friends of the mammon of unrighteousness, that when you fail, they may receive you into everlasting dwellings. Note. ** By this we see that the poor servants of God, whom we have relieved by our alms, may hereafter, by their intercessions,, bring our souls to heaven." Luke 17 : 10. We are unprofitable servants ; we have done that which we ought to do. Note. Because our service is of no profit to our master; and he justly claims it as our bounden duty. But though we are unprofitable to him, our serving him is not unprofita- ble to ourselves ; foi- he is pleased to give hy his grace a value to our good tvorks, which in consequence of his promise, entitles them to an eternal reward.^^ Luke 23 : 43, This day shalt thou be with me in paradise. This the note says is "Limbo, the place of confinement of departed saints, which was now made a paradise by our Lord's going thither." John 20 : 19. Now when it was late that same day, being the first day of the week, and the doors were shut, Jesus came and stood in the midst. Note. " The same power which could bring Christ's whole body, entire in all its dimensions, through the doors, can, without the least question, make the same body really present in the sacrament." Verse 23. Whose sins ye shall forgive, they are forgiven them ; and whose ye shall retain, they are retained. Note. " See here the commission, stamped by the broad seal of heaven, by virtue of which the pastors of Christ's church absolve repenting sinners upon their confession. Romans 4 : 7. Blessed are they whose iniquities are for- given, and whose sins are covered. Note. ** That is, blessed are they who by doing penance have obtained pardon and remission of their sins, and also are covered, that is newly clothed with the habit of grace, don sins, and although her forms of devotion abound in idolatrous prayers to saints, and angels, and we may see with our eyes her devotees doing homage to pictures, crosses, relics, &c. I^et us then examine this matter for ourselves. that our opinion may rest not on authority alone, and we may not be abashed by bold contradiction. The history of the. Romish Church should also be studied. Her arrogant pre- tensions to be the only true church, can all be confuted, and her traditions shewn to be contrary to scripture, and unworth\- of belief; but if we are not prepared to meet her plausible and sophistical reasonings, we may be much embarrassed by them. 3. We might to make use of the information thus acquired io defend the truth. This may be done in various ways : by personal and friend- ly intercourse with Catholics themselves, as far as practicable ; by the circulation of books calculated to throw light on the subject ; many excellent treatises have been written in which the errors of popery are confuted with great force and clear- ness ; by the distribution of such tracts as already exist, and the preparation of others adapted to the wants of the commu- nity : these will be very useful if they are written in a miid» plain, and christian manner, avoiding all asperity, and seeking only to advance the truth ; but if they be written in a harsh, abusive style, they will be worse than nothing. It may be added, that every tract which clearly exhibits gospel principles, contains in itself a refutation of error, and those which display false doctrine in its true light, without reference to sects, will be read with less prejudice, and consequently with more profit. The opinion of Catholic priests with regard to tracts, may be gathered from the fact that they discourage the peru- sal of them among their people, by all the means in their power. It may be indeed the desire of Catholics that we shoidd remain silent, and many Protestants may thiid^ a controversy of this kind inexpedient : but I know not by what logic it can be proved that we ought to sit still, and see error industrious- ly propagated. We may not, it is true, be able to convert Cathohcs ; but by a clear exhibition of the truth we may prevent the spread of it, among indifferent persons, and if any man will, after being enlightened, eml3race error, his blood must be upon his own head. 4. tVe are loudly called upon to extend a more efficient and liberal patronage to the American Home Missionary, Bible and Tract Societies. The Home Missionary Society sends out pastors to break the bread of life to those who are famishing for lack of knowl- edge. The Bible Society gives the pure word of God, which enlightens the eyes, and makes wise to salvation. The Tract Society diffuses the rays of gospel light, over this benighted vegion. I will not insult your understandings by eulogising these institutions. I only ask you solemnly to enquire how much does the Lord require you to give. Are you doing your duty in this respect ? The American Sunday School Union deserves our warmest support in the efforts she is now making for the spread of Sabbath Schools in the West. If we can but establish these blessed institutions in the vale of the Mississippi, she will be safe from error. Those who have been nourished and brought up on the " pure milk of the word"' cannot easily be induced to relish the husks of popery. Blessed be God for the establish- ment of Sabbath Schools in our land ! otherwise we should soon be swept away by the floods of error. Four hundred dollars will support an Agent in the West. How many of our County and State Unions, might easily do this, and thus prove a rich blessing to thousands ? This has already been successfully undertaken by at least one County Union,* and we hope others will soon follow the example. 5. JVe slioidd he more vigilant in searching out and train- Ing iip young men for the ministry. Let pious pastors and teachers have an eye to this work. Lot not indications of youthful talents and piety, escape the notice of the watchmen of Israel. Let the instructors of youth carefully examine the texture of the minds which come under their care; and whenever they find uncommon strength, activity or enterprize, let them be consecrated to the Lord in the closet, and recom- mended to the patronage of the church. Let pious fathers and pious mothers, be willing to part with their sons when Christ calls them to follow him. Parents! who of you have children destined to receive the reward of those who turn many to righteousness, and to shine as the stars of the firma- ment forever and ever ? Methinks you cannot but rejoice and thank God when he calls you to part with them. Let those whom God has entrusted with wealth, esteem it a most delightful task to take young men by the hand and assist them in their studies, trusting to God, that he will prepare* The Hartford Countv Sabbath »School Union. 22 their lieaits by his j^race tor being stewards of the mysteries of the gospel. What a niultitiide of laborers might thus be sent forth into the vineyard of the Lord! (). Finally, brethren, ^^ pray ivithout ceasing-.^ ^ i would not have taken up my pen to write to you, had I not lioped to excite you to more fervency at the throne of grace. The Lord Jehovah alone holds our destinies in his hands. He has suffered this error to creep in among us. Perhaps it is to draw^ our hearts closer together, to make us feel our dependance on him, and quicken us in the performance of our duty : perhaps to make us feel more sympathy for the nations of Europe who are groaning under the papal yoke : perhaps he designs to manifest his Almighty power, by carrying on his gospel in the midst of opposition, and thus secure. the glory to himself. Let us " trust in the Lord forever ; for in the Lord Jehovah is everlasting strength." Let our missionaries in the West enjoy our liberality, and be upheld by our prayers. We ought most earnestly to pray for the outpouring of the Holy Ghost in the valley of the Mississippi. The " man of sin" is to be destroyed by " the brightness of Christ's coming." If the Lord do not interpose for the inhabitants of the West, they will be undone. I close with one reflection. How important that pure and iindefiled religion should flourish in our schools, and colleges. A vast multitude of youth is here training up, to become either the efiicient friends, or the determined enemies of Christ. With what inexpressible longings ought the church I to look upon these institutions ! How fervently ought she to pour forth her prayers in their behalf, that the Lord would visit them by his grace, and make ready a people prepared for his service! "Lift up your eyes and look on the fields, for they are white already to harvest : Pray ye therefore, the Lord of the Harvest that he w^ould send forth laborers into his vineyard." APPENDLX^ A. The following extracts from the Roman IMissal, on the one hand, and the Bible on the other, will shew in a striking light, the difierence between the Catholic, and .Scriptural way of approaching God. ROMAN MLSSAL. THE LITANY OF SAINTS. (In part.) Lord have mercy on lis. Christ have mercy on us. •Lord have mercy on us. Christ hear us. Christ graciously hear us God the father of heaven have mercy on uy God the Son, Redeemer of the Worki have mercij on us. God the Holy Ghost have, mercy on us. ITnlv Trinitv. one God. hare mercy 011 ?(S, BIBLE. WAY TO APPROACH GOD. " Father into thy hands I commend niv •Spirit." Luke, 23: 46. " Lord Jesus, receive my Spirit." Acts, -. 60. " Come u7ito me, all ye that labor and are heavy laden, and I will fi;ive von rest.'' VTatth. II : f?P i>:i Holy Mary, Holy mother of God, Holy Virgin of Virgins. St. Michael, St. Gabriel, St. Raphael, All ye holy Angels and Archangels, All ye holy Orders of blessed Spirits, St. John Baptist, St. Joseph, All ye holy Patriarchs and Prophets, St. Peter, St. Paul, St. Andrew, St. James, St. John, St. Thomas, St. James, St. Philip, St. Bartholomcic, St. Mattheio, St. Simon, St. Thaddaus, St. Matthias, St. Barnaby, St. Luke, St. Mark, - All ye holy Apostles and Evangelists, All ye holy Disciples of the Lord, All ye holy Innocents, St. Stephen, St. Lawrence, St. Vincent, St. Fabian and St. Sebastian, St. John and St. Paid, St. Cosmos and St. Damian, St. Gervais and St. Protese, All ye holy Martyrs, St. Sylvester, St. Gregory, St. Anibrosc, St. Augustin, St. Jerom, St. Martin, St. Nicholas, St. Patrick, All ye holy Bishops and Confessors, All ye holy Doctors, St. Anthony and St. Bennet, St. Bernard, St. Dominick, St. Francis, All ye holy Priests and Levites, All ye holy Monks and Hermits, St. Mary Magdalen, St. Agatha, St. Lucy, St. Agnes, St. Cecily, St. Cailiarinr. St, Anastasia, St. Bridget, All ye holy Virgins and Widows, '' Him tliat comeili to me, I will m no wise cast out." John 6 : 37. " Every man that hath heard, and hath learned of the Father cometh unto me." John 6: 45. " Seeing then that we have a great High Priest, that is passed into the hea- vens, Jesus the Son of God, let us hold fast our profession." ' For we have not an High Priest which cannot be touched with the feeling of our infirmities ; but was in all points tempted like as we are, yet without sin." ' Let us therefore come boldly unto the throne of grace, that we may obtain mercy, and find grace to help in time of need." Heb. 4: 14, 15, 16. ''But this man (Christ Jesus) because he continueth ever, hath an unchangablo priesthood. Wherefore he is able also to save unto the uttermost them that come unto God, by him, seeing he ever liveth to make intercession for them.'''' For such an High Priest became us, who is holy, harmless, undefiled, separate from sinners, and made hisjher than the hea- vens." Heb. 7: 24,25,26. '•' For Christ is not entered into the holy places made with hands, which are the figures of the true ; but into heaven itself, now to appear in the presence of God /or ws." Heb. 9: 24. " Having therefore, brethren, boldness to enter into the holiest by the blood of Jesus, And having an High Priest over the house of God; Let us draw near with a true heart in full assurance of faith, having our hearts- sprinkled from an evil conscience, and our bodies washed with pure water." Heb 10: 19,21,22. What need have wo then of the inter- cession of Saints and Angels, which is no- jwhere commanded in Scripture'