BV 600 .B865 1923 Brunner, Edmund de Schweinitz, 1889- Testea methods in town and country churches Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2019 with funding from Princeton Theological Seminary Library https://archive.org/details/testedmethodsint00brun_0 TESTED METHODS IN TOWN AND COUNTRY CHURCHES The Committee on Social and Religious Sur¬ veys, which is responsible for this publication, was organized in January, 1921. The Commit¬ tee conducts and publishes studies and surveys and promotes conferences for their considera¬ tion. Its aim is to combine the scientific method with the religious motive. It cooperates with other social and religious agencies, but is itself an independent organization. The Committee is composed of: John R. Mott, Chairman; Ernest D. Burton, Secretary; Raymond B. Fosdick, Treasurer; James L. Bar¬ ton and IV. H. P. Faunce. Galen M. Fisher is Executive Secretary. The offices are at 370 Seventh Avenue, New York City. TESTED METHODS IN TOWN AND COUNTRY CHURCHES A.' / \> BY OF PR/^ OCT 17 1923 EDMUND deS. BRUNN^R^,, |C4[ With a Foreword by HONORABLE GIFFORD PINCHOT GOVERNOR OF PENNSYLVANIA NEW YORK GEORGE H. DORAN COMPANY COPYRIGHT, 1923, BY GEORGE H. DORAN COMPANY TESTED METHODS IN TOWN AND COUNTRY CHURCHES. I PRINTED IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA FOREWORD By Honorable Gifford Pinchot GOVERNOR OF PENNSYLVANIA In 1909 it was my privilege to serve as a member of the Country Life Commission set up by President Roosevelt. At that time if somebody had prophesied that only four¬ teen years later a volume would be published giving, as this one does, not the theory of a successful ministry in the country church but actual concrete methods employed in forty country churches which had won conspicuous success through the use of these methods, I should probably have thought the prophecy entirely too optimistic. I remember a phrase in the recommendations made by President Roosevelt’s Commission which bears very specifi¬ cally upon the subject of this volume : “The country church of the future is to be held responsible for the great ideals of community life as well as of personal character.” Just because the Commission felt that the country church was not serving, as in the earlier periods of our history, to pro¬ mote the social and religious well-being of the country, it stressed the social obligations of the rural church. The present volume shows that country churches succeed by living up to principles which the report recommended. They have been the servants, not only to their constituents, but to whole communities. They have been social centers in the best sense and at the same time have remained true to their distinctive evangelistic purpose. In a word, they have demonstrated that the church which fully represents Jesus Christ ministers to all sides of community life, and must supply the motive for many of its purely social activities. As one, who, in company with Mr. Charles O. Gill, has vi FOREWORD had practical experience in the work of making rural re¬ ligious surveys, I have followed with profound interest and satisfaction the studies of the church in rural America which have been completed by the Committee on Social and Religious Surveys. It seems eminently fitting that the careful investigation made by Dr. Brunner and his col¬ leagues, as published in the twelve volumes of the Com¬ mittee’s Town and Country Series, should be followed by this study of the country church at its best. It shows how others have met and overcome the very difficulties which the average rural church is facing. I can imagine no better inspiration for the rural pastor than the reading of this book and its companion volume, “Churches of Distinction in Town and Country”—and only those who are familiar with the difficult problems which the country pastor faces can realize his need of inspiration. INTRODUCTION The Committee on Social and Religious Surveys conducted during the year 1922 an investigation of the most successful town and country churches of Protestant persuasion that it could find anywhere in the United States. The study was undertaken in order that the experience of these churches might be available to all other churches similarly placed. For the purposes of this study no attempt was made to arrive inductively at a scientific definition of what consti¬ tutes a “successful” church. The test of a church’s “suc¬ cess” most generally accepted by the denominational boards consulted in the preliminaries of the study is the service, spiritual and material, which it renders to the community of which it is a part and the measure of support which in turn it receives from the community. This test was accepted as the basis of the present investigation. Two books have resulted from the investigation; a volume made up of stories of certain of the individual churches, which has been published under the title of “Churches of Distinction in Town and Country,” and this one, which describes the methods employed by those churches. The present volume is intended for use in theological seminaries, in graduate summer schools for the training of town and country ministers, by classes in leadership-training within congregations, and above all by individual town or country pastors at work in their fields. Both form and content of the volume have been adapted so far as possible to meet the wishes of officials of home mission boards who have had these purposes in mind. TYPES OF COMMUNITIES STUDIED To make sure that the investigation would cover the great¬ est possible number of churches differently placed in respect • • vii INTRODUCTION • • • vm to environment, the Committee on Social and Religious Surveys, aided by the findings of its previous studies and by the advice of rural sociologists specially consulted, drew up a list of town and country communities of twenty differ¬ ent types. It was believed that among these types every area in the United States would be represented. The com¬ munities, arranged in accordance with the plan of regional distribution used in other surveys by this Committee, follow: Northern Colonial Area 1. A Scotch-Irish community, general farming back¬ ground, preferably an open country church. 2. A German community, probably in Pennsylania, gen¬ eral farming and open country or small village church, one of the liturgical group. 3. New England communities, villages, illustrating: a—A denominational community church in com¬ mand of the field by comity agreement, b—A federated church, c—An interdenominational or union church. 4. New York village or town of 1,500 to 5,000 population with developing industrial interest, some foreign element but farm connections still existing. Middle West and Prairie 5. Village in wheat belt where there is migrant labor affected by church, preferably in Kansas or Ne¬ braska. 6. County seat, Middle West, several denominations rep¬ resented, having program of community coopera¬ tion, preferably a town with considerable retired farmer element. 7. Same social and economic background as “6” above, but in which one church is forging ahead regardless of competition. Northwest 8. Scandinavian community, dairy or grain region in Minnesota or North Dakota, preferably a church with a developed educational program and an ad¬ vanced economic program. INTRODUCTION IX •5o uh 9. Good average open country community in cotton belt. >. Cotton mill town. 1. Southern mountain community with or without any industrial development but in which outside aid has affected progress, especially along educational, other cultural or health lines. 12. Negro community in cotton section, either village or open country. Southwest or Pacific 13. Mexican community with Protestant church, either a small industrial or a farming community or a com¬ bination of both. 14. Indian community in Southwest, illustrating transition from nomadic tribal to settled agricultural life. 15. Community in irrigated country, trucking or small fruit, large influx of foreign seasonal labor affected by adequate church program. 16. Lumber or mining town with foreign element. Range 17. Town in cattle-raising or dry-farming district in which church is doing significant larger parish work. General 18. Czechoslovak community in the Middle West or in Texas, general farming background, open country or small village church. 19. Rural industrial village, preferably with polyglot for¬ eign population. 20. Community, industrial or farming, with large perma¬ nent element of later (southern European) immi¬ gration in which English-speaking church is doing significant work in reaching foreign born. No churches were discovered for a few of these types. More than one church was selected in each of the more im¬ portant of these groups. Denominational leaders, state and national, and state leaders in agriculture and education, were then asked to X INTRODUCTION name, in communities of the various kinds, churches doin£ successful work. Investigation was also made of the files of the Interchurch World Movement surveys and of religious periodicals. From this study and inquiry resulted a list of nearly 700 churches. After preliminary investigation half of these churches were eliminated. The Committee sent to representatives of each of the others a statement as to the nature of the investigation; a request for permission to have one or more of its workers study the church in case the committee should so elect; and a questionnaire. Responses were received from more than 90 per cent, of the ministers and other leaders addressed. On the basis of these replies the Committee selected forty churches. In making the choice, there was an attempt to include a wide range of denominations and of types of work. If two churches illustrated a given situation equally well, preference was given to the church of the denomination having the fewer representatives on the list. No effort was made to specialize in village churches rather than in town churches, or in country churches in preference to town and village churches. The Committee endeavored, instead, to choose successful churches which, taken together, would represent every kind of community. METHOD OF INVESTIGATION Each of the churches selected was subjected to careful investigation by competent field workers during a period lasting from eight days to a month, in the spring, summer or fall of 1922. In every instance the churches studied gave full coopera¬ tion. Pastors, church officers, and members were untiring in their efforts to obtain all the information desired, and con¬ tributed in the aggregate many days of valuable time. SIGNIFICANCE OF MATERIAL The significant thing is that what is here presented is not theory but the actual practice of churches that are successful. INTRODUCTION xi From the experience of these churches, it is believed, the country church of America has much to learn. This volume is submitted with a word of caution. It is a composite account of forty churches, and therefore contains a multiplicity of suggestive detail. No one church can do all the things of which it tells. Few can do any one thing in exactly the way here indicated. An outstanding tendency of the churches investigated was found to be adaptation of program to need, or method to situation. Their practice must likewise be adapted to varying local conditions. WHAT OF THE CHURCHES? For a still better understanding of the methods of work described in this book, an analysis of the situation of these churches as it existed at the time of the survey will be found valuable. These churches are not situated in unusual, above-the-average communities which have now ordered their religious life so that but one church serves all elements of the population. Furthermore, most of these churches be¬ gan their development when at just an average level of effi¬ ciency and success, while many began at a level considerably below the average. The success they have won has come because of the consecration of their leaders, because of the methods they have developed and because they have applied those methods with unceasing effort. They have traveled no easy road to distinction. DISTRIBUTION OF CHURCHES Six of them are town churches, twenty-two are in villages, and twelve are in the open country. Of the villages, seven have less than 500 population. Some of the churches have from eight to thirteen different denominational bodies repre¬ sented in their present membership. Four of the organizations studied are federated churches made up of what were formerly separate congregations differing in denomination. One is an undenominational community church. Ten of the churches are the only ones in their communities, either because of federation or of the INTRODUCTION • • xn withdrawal of some other denomination by agreement, or because they alone survived. Two more share their fields with only very small churches of the Holy Roller type. The church at Parma shows excellently how wide an appeal a church may have. It successfully reaches all. In its active membership are former members of sixteen different denom¬ inations, including such diverse groups as Methodists, Lu¬ therans, Congregationalists, Roman Catholics, Nazarenes and Latter Day Saints. EXTENT OF PARISH Virtually all of these churches include people from both village and country. Even those in the larger towns draw considerably from the countryside and have broken down such barriers as often exist between town and country. Grace Church at Spencer, Iowa, draws 20 per cent, of its 900 members from rural areas surrounding the town. The open country membership exceeds that of the village or town in eight of the thirty-two churches located in non¬ industrial towns or villages. In ten others the proportion ranges from one-third to 90 per cent. In most other in¬ stances from one-sixth to one-fourth of the membership is drawn from the surrounding countryside. In the entire group of churches, less than half the members live within a mile of the church building. A fifth live from two to five miles from the church and nearly a fifth live more than five miles away. This long-range influence is not accidental. The churches accept full responsibility for the care of the communities in which they are. They not only care for members at the outer edge of their parishes, but systemati¬ cally cover, with their evangelistic and social programs, the whole territory for which they are responsible. Seven out of every ten of these churches have extended their parish boundaries until they are coterminus, or nearly so, with the boundaries of the community. In a few in¬ stances the parishes extend beyond the community bound¬ aries. The parish boundaries of only a fifth are markedly smaller than those of the communities, and in each of these cases the church is either reaching only one neighborhood INTRODUCTION xm in the community or is meeting exceptionally strong compe¬ tition. This is an unusually good record. The Interchurch World Movement surveys found that the church was rare indeed whose parish boundaries included the whole com¬ munity. MEMBERSHIP Whatever their past, most of these churches are now larger and stronger than the average. Only nine have fewer than ioo members, and in most cases they are the churches in very small communities or in communities in which there is a considerable proportion of Roman Catholic population. Nearly half the churches fall within the next membership group of between ioo and 200. This group also has the most extended activities. Six more churches have between 200 and 300 members and a final six range from 349 to nearly 1,100. Three of the last six are in county seats that have populations of from 2,590 to nearly 5,000. These three, however, share the field in each instance with half a dozen or more churches. Of the other large churches, the largest is in a village of 750 inhabitants which draws heavily from the surrounding countryside; another is an open country church with 507 members; and a third is the community church in a village of 600 people. It has 349 resident members. ATTENDANCE The attendance in these churches is quite remarkable. Six of them average more than 200 at the morning service; three of these have more than 450 and one more than 800. Often people have to go early to get seats in the main audi¬ torium. For the whole group the morning attendance aver¬ ages 70 per cent, of the resident membership, and the evening attendance 52 per cent. At least one representative of 75 per cent, of the families on the rolls of these churches is in regular attendance at least one service every Sunday. In six of the churches, which make up 15 per cent, of the entire number, the average attendance at either the morn- XIV INTRODUCTION ing service or the evening service, or at both services, exceeds the resident membership. The audiences are well distributed among the various age- and sex-groups. At the morning service 39 per cent, are adult women; 31 per cent, adult men; 23 per cent, are members under twenty-one years of age, and the remainder are children. In the evening, adult men and women in equal proportion make up three-fifths of the audiences. With the exception of a few small children, young people make up the rest of the congregations. The men at the morning services in twelve of the churches equal or exceed the women in number; while in eight the proportion of young people exceeds that of any other group. In the evening the proportion of men equals or exceeds that of women in fifteen churches. In an equal number, the young people have more representatives than any of the other groups. AGE AND SEX OF MEMBERS For the purposes of this study the membership of these churches has been divided into three groups, including re¬ spectively persons under twenty-one, those between twenty- one and forty-five, and those forty-six or older. It was found that nearly a fourth of the members were under twenty- one and that exactly two-thirds were under forty-five years of age. In some cases more than a third of the mem¬ bers on the roll were under twenty-one years of age. This was owing in part to the fact that some of the churches are in communities still so young that few people have had time to grow old. Another explanation is the great attractiveness to the young people of the virile programs undertaken by these churches. The older congregations include persons of all ages and the churches minister to all of them success¬ fully. In them there are many pews in which representatives of three generations sit together. Slightly more than three- fifths of the present membership of these churches joined within the last decade. The rest of the membership is almost equally divided between those who joined between ten and twenty years ago and those who united with the church in the more distant past. INTRODUCTION xv These churches also reach both sex-groups. In the whole list there is but one “woman’s” church. In the others, male members constitute anywhere from a third to three- fifths of the total membership. OCCUPATION OF MEMBERS More than 40 per cent, of the members are gainfully em¬ ployed. Thirty-six per cent, of these are farmers who own their farms, while 12 per cent, are farm-renters, and another 12 per cent, are professional people. Thirteen per cent, are in business. Seven per cent, are farm-laborers. Of the other scattering occupations, clerks of various kinds form the predominant group. FACTS REGARDING ORGANIZATIONS In the Sunday schools there is no predominant age-group other than the adult. The proportion of the total member¬ ship varies little for the different age groupings up to twenty years. xAImost 20 per cent, more of males than of females on the church roll belong to the Sunday school. Sixty per cent, of the entire membership of these churches is enrolled in some one of the subsidiary organizations. In this respect the young people’s group makes the best showing, with 80 per cent, enrolled. The total number of males so interested is 55 per cent, and of females 63 per cent. LENGTH OF SUCCESS The average period over which these churches have been succeeding is seven years. But two entirely different types of churches figure in this average. The first type includes such churches as Stanton, Middle Octoraro and Dayton, which have behind them years of tradition. These are among the eighteen which exceed the average of seven years. For the other twenty-two, the periods of success have covered a shorter period. The average is 3.2 years. MINISTERS The ministers of these churches are not different from ministers everywhere, save that a large proportion are men XVI INTRODUCTION with college and seminary training. Twenty-five have had the advantages of both college and seminary. A dozen others are college men and the other three are seminary trained only. If they differ from other ministers in anything it is in their capacity for ceaseless work. This is the price of their success. Otherwise—in temperament, in age, in person, and in methods of leadership—they are as unlike as men of any other group could be. Had they all been of one general type, it might have been fair to conclude that men of that type possess those general qualities of leadership essential in successful church organizations. This, however, is not the case. The clue to the success of these churches does not lie in their employing a distinctive type of minister. The pastorates, however, are longer than the average. The average length of time that each of these ministers has been with his present congregation is in excess of four and one- half years, whereas the average total pastorate of the churches in the twenty-five counties studied by the Committee on Social and Religious Surveys was 3.8 years. These churches, then, have been selected as representative of a considerable number which have won more than local distinction. They have been chosen to illustrate rural re¬ ligious work in various kinds of communities and by various denominations. Growing out of average or below-average situations, and located in communities in no way especially favored, these churches have broadened their scope and in¬ fluence, have increased their memberships and attendance, have reached and held all age, sex, and occupational groups, and have developed programs that have resulted in achieve¬ ments far beyond those of the average town and country churches in America. That is why an analysis of their methods holds promise of interest and inspiration. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The field workers engaged in this study included the fol¬ lowing full-time workers of the Committee: Marjorie Pat¬ ten, Helen O. Belknap, and Elizabeth G. Wootton. Through the courtesy of the Board' of Home Missions of the Re¬ formed Church in America, John W. Myers and Ernest W. Brindle were added to the staff for four months during the summer; and through the courtesy of the Presbyterian Board of Home Missions and of the Presbyterian Synod of New York, respectively, the Rev. H. N. Morse and Dr. U. L. Mackey investigated one parish each. Elizabeth R. Hooker and Grace E. Fairley, of the staff of the Committee, assisted in assembling the data and Miss Hooker also gave invaluable service in preparing it for publication. Through their generous cooperation in this enterprise the churches studied have placed the Committee and those to whom the findings will be of service under a heavy debt of gratitude. The tabulation on the following pages gives for the churches surveyed the geographical and denominational dis¬ tribution, and the names of their ministers. Edmund deS. Brunner xvii State Community Church Pastor Arizona.Sacaton .Presbyterian Indian Mission .Dirk A. Lay, xvm ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Q A C/D CS ■s * d ■3 CO cu G u p 3 o CO 13 a. o a CO a, P +-» CO • *H G o xG -1-1 cu G G £ £ £ G 44 rt £ (U uc bo G pS g s < G xG G O CO Ox O u CO • H Q, P G O xG * UG x n a CO v, (U M CM <5 >> >» -M 44 G G G pS • *-< £ cu g ■& E CO qj O u. G PS o § 5 "G « G pS P lx 4-> o p G O G G PS -C CO G (U O > G o lx cu lx CU .O pS G O «x 4-4 PS bo CU lx bo G o G pj lx xO CO cu lx p G G £ £ 13 • *“H lx O £ -Q co G co 44 >. xQ ,_^ CO Cv 1 lx pS s xQ CO pS Q • ri • bo G • *—i -M • • CU E • • G O • ^ G lx O xG x^ G P lx cu Ox s > o G rt ’o o kxJ lx CO o pj >> PS G a cu Ox CTj -M i£ lx M C3 cu G > >■ '< • y~* PH CO U p p P Q P CO in P S PQ CO CO PS co G p) lx < pS • XX G lx o C+X • 13 u o nd PS lx o U • • • C/D pj • o xG PS 2 • rH o G • G PS • WH G pS ’G •—< G O H4 1—c l—1 H- 1 CO PS CO G PS M T3 G PS lx pS s Massachusetts ... Wilbraham.Federated, Congregational and Methodist Episcopal. W. Q. Genge ACKNOWLEDGMENTS xix G3 Ph V. -Si I o d cs> •*» >» p~i x> G 03 oS Vh Oj J> G • T—* u JLJ *o; G O CO Ui m • r—* c P= > u V C/3 o CD o, -4-> CCS Vh Gd u G o C/3 > u, CD d ffi i-H *-» r" Si « U fc ^ 4-> •S CO G ;— CD TG •tS © u 6 ^ § o «4H 4-4 t-5 CD 2 Vh ;-h C/3 Ph T3 Si £ 4S Jj *o C/3 G3 CD • »H v« c3 p< *53 Si 3 Pi a a PQ • CL> '' & a £ • • • G ^2 d CD 3 O gg O u *«« ■£ c ^2 03 co d* • f-i -_» 3 2 E W J o 43 d 4 H oj CD 42 C/3 ffi • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • *v • G • • u • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • G 03 • • • • *—« G 2 • • • • • CD • *-H a< • • • • • • • • • • • • • • *£ • CD li • a ; 'Ct W CU o • • • • • • • G «—H G -M CD • • • • • • O ctf G 2 . *n CD co ’c3 • • • « • • • • • • • • Pj CU o (J . 0 > • »-H G 2 • *—< CG Gi • • • • • 03 u * ^ O W O • • • • • bo CD T3 ; X! CD • • • V • r*H CD • CD -*-> 4-» Oh bo *—M w £ | £ 03 03 £3 G o3 1-4 03 ctf # Oh Oh aS • HH Si CD ■H-> o Oh 4-J Oh +-> • CD » , • o CD co • crH O a CO • *—1 U +G O CD CO • T—H CD • *— < ~o o '-PM CD P5 O a CO • T—« rH -G u : Pm w £ a Pm W >. G 2 CO co • rH +-» Oh Pm W -M-* "as Oh W £ +j 4-> CD • |H *o • T-H Vi CD 4-> 4-» CD • rM CD Vh Ph o3 PQ 1 4-> CD • »-M N Si 4—> CD • OS co o o T 2 o Vh 03 o »— H • iH >> dg co G 2 Gd PQ +J OJ OD U Ph +-* cu cd Si fe-H * e 2 .* 03 G U, CD O .t2 t; u o M N -a g d ° ^ O o G Si < G O £ £ | £ s CD > QJ !> S u .a o d u G o Uc u oS tc .a O w. § (J ffi • • CD • • • • • jV • G • t-M > CD M-> 4-4 T CD > O G G >> Si • »—• > CO > u Si 4-* CD Si Si CD co O aS CD G ~, * —' ■m je • ■-< r^. £ ^ £ M o .i2 U fe £ : o ^1 G J*2 o d> - i • G3 CO ^ - >• CD o 45 G £ ^ • »H G2 2 G CD X 03