9MMJ>»M»Jt»iB33AM3ajm3X3'i33 Jt Jl JS^AA'MA'J.^":)' -9 if \ ? MID I E HIGHER LIFE \ 3! i; ;• 1 PRmCETON, N. J. % '^'*' BX 7233 .B76 H5 1883 \ , Brown, James Baldwin, 1820- ■ll 1884. 5/,.//......" The higher life: its .^reality, experience , „and — THE HIGHER LIFE BY THE SAME AUTHOR. THE DOCTRINE OF ANNIHILATION IN THE LIGHT OF THE GOSPEL OF LOVE. Five Discourses. Fourth Edition. Crown 8vo, cloth, price Q.s. 6d. " From nothing that we have seen or heard of Mr. Baldwin Brown's have we received such an impression of intellectual and moral power as from the second, third, and fourth of these discourses." — Nonconformist. " The special object of Mr. Baldwin Brown's lectures is to confute a school which preaches in one form or another that Christ offered immortality only to those who believed in Him and obtained new life in Him, and that for all others is reserved the fate of an annihi- lation which is as much due to the operation of natural laws as is the annihilation of the lower animals. "^Spectator. London : Kegan P.\ul, Trench, & Co., i. Paternoster Sq. THE HIGHER LIFE ITS REALITY, EXPERIENCE, AND DESTINY BY / JAMES BALDWIN ^BROWN, B.A. MINISTER OF BRIXTON INDEPENDENT CHURCH AUTHOR OF 'the HOME LIFE' 'FIRST PRINCIPLES OF ECCLESIASTICAL TRITH ' Nor must we, as some advise us, being but men, think only of tlie things of men, being transient, of transient things; but as far as in us lies we must live the immortal life '—Aristotle For our citizenship is in the heavens' — Paul SIXTH EDITION LONDON KEGAN PAUL, TRENCH, & CO., i, Paternoster Square 1887 \The rights of translation and of reproduction are reserved?^ TO MY DEAR DAUGHTER MY LOVING AND DEVOTED HELPER IN MY MINISTRY I INSCRIBE THIS BOOK ON THE HIGHER LIFE J. B. B. X PREFACE. I SEND FORTH this book on The Higher Life, in the hope that it may help some, especially among the young, to hold fast their faith in the great facts and truths, which alone seem to me to make this life of ours worth living at all. The elder Mill, as we learn from the autobiography of his distinguished son, re- jected " all that is called religious belief." It does not surprise one to learn further, that " he thought human life a poor thing at best, after the freshness of youth and of unsatisfied curiosity had gone by." I fear that there is a large class of cultivated men and women among us who are falling into the same unbelief, and into the sadness which is its inevitable fruit. If what I have written should afford any help to such against this pressure of the times, the labour which it has cost will be amply repaid. The sermons, as will be seen, do not form any- thing like a consecutive argument. Each has a com- pleteness of its own, and a definite theme ; yet they viii Preface. form a course of connected thought on the subject of The Higher Life, its reaUty, its experience, and its destiny. In the earher chapters I have glanced at some of the recent speculations of science, in which solutions have been offered of the mysterious problems of Creation, which theologians, as a rule, have fiercely assailed. It seems to me that if we consider them patiently, and let development " have its perfect work," they may open to us a larger vision of the way of God in the creation and the government of His world. The chapters which follow deal mainly with the higher Christian experience, and the spirit which Christianity seeks to quicken and to nourish in men. God forbid that the Church should ever be unmindful of the larre blessing- which intellectual culture and political activity bring in their train. There are periods in which this side of human de- velopment needs to be vigorously pushed forward. But in these days it seems well able to care for itself; while the side of man's nature and activity to which the Cross appeals, is in danger of being slighted, and thrust out of the field. But none the less is it the salt of the world's life in all ages, and will be, while the world endures. In treat- ing of this portion of my subject, I have dropped for the most part, all reference to current controver- sies ; while in the closing chapters I have brought Pi^eface. ix back the thread of my thoughts, to the questions which are in such eager debate among us, once more. Each sermon, as I have said, has a certain com- pleteness of its own ; and, as a book Hke this is mostly read in sections, I have not been over studi- ous to avoid the presentation of central ideas again and again, from different points of view, and often with the same illustrations from Scripture. I have used in quotation the authorized version, except where my argument rendered a more accurate translation needful ; and throughout the book I have kept steadily in view, the difficulties, burdens, and needs of those who are hardly pressed by the battle, or sharply exercised by the discipline, of life. J. Baldwin Brown. Kent Villa, Brixton Hill: March, 1874. CONTENTS. FAGB I. WHAT IS MAN? i " What is ManV Ps. viii. 4. II. THE UNIVERSAL TRAVAIL 25 " We know that the whole Creation groaneth and travaileth in pain together until now. " Rom. viii. 22. III. THE ATHEISTIC LIFE 49 " Having no hope, and without God in the world." Eph. ii. 12. IV. THE MEANING OF REDEMPTION .... 70 ' ' / have called you friends. " John xv. 1 5. V. THE PAIN OF PROGRESS 92 ^^ Thy heart shall fear and be enlarged." Is. Ix. 5. VL THE LORD IS MY LIGHT AND MY SALVATION . 114 '■'■ The Lord is 7ny light and 7ny salvation, whom shall I fear? The Lord is the strength of my life, of whom shall / be afraid ? " Ps. xxvii. I. VII, GOD'S GREAT WORLD ... . . 131 " ILe brought me forth also into a large place." 2. Sam. xxii. 20. xii Contents. PAGE VIII. THE PILGRIMS 150 ' ' For they that say such things, declare plainly that they seek a country.'''' Heb. xi. 14. IX. THE NOBLE ARMY OF MARTYRS . . .169 " And ye beca?}ie followers of us, and of the Lord, having received the word in much affliction, with joy of the Holy Ghost.'''' I. Thes. i. 6. X. THE TWO SORROWS 185 ^^ For it is better, if the will of God be so, that ye suffer for well doing t/ian for evil doing." i Pet. iii. 17. XL THE SACRED DARKNESS 205 ' ' Who is among you that feareth the Lord, that obeyeth the voice of His servant, that walketh in darkness, and hath no light ? Let him trust in the name af the Lord, and stay upon his God." Is. 1. 10. XII. THE SACRED JOY 227 '■^ As the sufferings of Christ aboicnd in us, so our consolation also aboundeth by Christ.''^ 2 Cor. i. 5. XIII. THE GARDEN BY THE CROSS . . . .248 '■'■Now in the place where He was crucified there was a ." John xix. 41. XIV. OH, THAT I HAD WINGS LIKE A DOVE . . 266 " Oh, that L had zvings like a dove! for then would L fly away and be at rest." Ps. Iv. 6. XV. FAINT, YET PURSUING 288 ^^ Faint, yet pursuing them." Judg. viii. 4. Contents. Xlll XVI. THE VICTORY OF LIFE PAGE ^' I am He that liveih and was dead ; and, behold, I am alive for ever mover Rev. i. 18. XVII. THE KEYS OF HELL AND OF DEATH . .321 " /ivien : and have the keys of hell and of death.'''' Rev. i. 18. XVIIL THE RESURRECTION OF MAN . . . .338 " But nozu is Chnst risen f-om the dead, and become the first- fruits of them that slept. For siitce by man came death, by man came also the resurrection of the dead." i Cor. xv. 20, 21. XIX. THE DESTINY OF THE CREATURE . . .364 " The creature itself also shall be delivered f-om the bondage of co7'iiiption into the glorious liberty of the children of^God." Rom. viii. 21, XX. THE DESTINY OF MAN 387 '* What is man that Thou art mindful of him ? and tlie Ton of man that Thou visiles t him\?" Ps. viii. 4. •I )i iB83 \ THE HIGHER LIFE, I. WHAT IS MAN? The Scripture sets man before us as a beinyf whom his Maker cares to redeem at quite infinite cost. This affords to us the one true measure of the quahty of our nature, and assigns its place in the scale of the Creation : it is Heaven's own answer to the fundamental question of philosophy, What is man ? The Bible, happily for us, is not a book of definitions. It offers little that can be regarded as a scientific elucidation of the dark problems of Being, human or Divine. I ts concern is supremely with man "in relation;" as bound in duty to the Creation around him, to his fellow men and to God. The chief part of it is history, and it is the history of Redemption. From the first act of the Divine drama in the hour of man's transgression, to the vision of the purified and perfected Creation which is unveiled in the Apocalypse, it treats of the world as the theatre of Redemption, and of man as a being born to be redeemed. The Higher Life. Whatever man may be in his interior structure end constitution, by whatever stages of development he may have attained to his present goodly stature and power, thus much is clear about him to the loving students of Scripture ; he is a being whose redemption, whose salvation from the pit into v/hich moral evil steadily settles and buries itself from the light, is held on high to be worth the agony anc bloody sweat, the cross and passion, the precious death and burial, the glorious resurrection and as- cension, of his Redeemer, Christ. This is the central thought of this series of dis- courses on the higher life, and the travail through which it is born. Some of them are more sp^:ula- tive ; some of them are directly practical in tone ; but I seek to develope through the whole of them the ground of my belief, that the redemption which is by Christ Jesus is the one key to all that man is and to all that man endures. I hold that the existence of such a world as this, and such a creature as man has come to be through sin, would be a burning stain on the government of the righteous Ruler of the universe, but for the end to which it is working through Redemption ; while in the light which the gospel of God's love and mercy casts upon the world, life, with all its pain, becomes a holy and blessed culture, binding man to God in a fellowship of in- terest and spirit, which is destined to furnish the highest developments of being through eternity. I can see no light about man, about his capacities, his experiences, and the possibilities of his life, except What is Man f when I regard him as a being born to be redeemed. I can see no Hght about Hfe, its broken promises, its poor fulfilments, its frustrated hopes, its ideal always far up in the height, except when I regard it as a redeeming process, which earth commences in pain and travail, but which heaven will complete in glorious joy. This is why I believe the Bible. It is a light shining for me in a dark place ; it lights up man, it lights up life, it lights up God. And the light seems to be of heaven. All thingrs within and all things around, when I look at them in the lieht of the love of God which is in Christ Jesus our Lord, rcoolve themselves into an order, which, obscure as is much of its method, and sad as is much of its aspect, I joyfully recognise as Divine. It commends itself as "of God" to the purest and justest judgment which I can frame of Divine things ; while it lays the basis of an intelligent hope for myself and for the world which justifies patience and sanctifies pain. There- fore, I believe. Rob me of this faith, give me such a world to live in as some of our wise ones are doing their best to make for us, and the only question of supreme interest would be, which is the quickest and the easiest way out of it into the everlasting night ? There are certain views as to the nature of man, as to his place in the Creation, and the way in which it becomes him to look at his life, which are kept very prominently before the eye of the intellectual world in our day by able thinkers, who state them with great force, and with an earnestness of con- The Higher Life. viction and contention, for which there seems to be little room in the pale of their narrow and cold phi- losophy. The grounds on which we base our view of man, of his relations and his destiny, are to them simply non-existent, or at least non-apparent, and not capable of being made to appear. God, Revela- tion, Redemption, to them belong to the world of dreams. Man is to their apprehension the last and completest product of that organising principle or force which somehow — that is all that they can say about it at present — has introduced itself into the inorganic matter of the world, and behold it lives ! it becomes plastic at once to the inward pressure of the vital principle, and reveals a capacity for the assumption of an inconceivable variety of organic forms. These shape themselves, we are instructed, under the stress of constant pressure, collision, and struggle for exist- ence ; in which the strongest, or rather the fittest, the best adapted to the external conditions prevailing around, survives and perpetuates itself. Thus there rises in the Creation an ascending series of specific forms, order rising out of and resting upon order, each more complex in structure and manifold in function than that on which it rests, until passing through countless stashes of evolution, the series emerges and completes itself in man. Man, according to this view of Nature, is simply the most complex, the most capable, and the most largely developed of the creatures. But all the hu- man faculties and qualities, judgments, emotions, What is Alan f passions and volitions, are held to be but the highest functions of kindred qualities and capacities which are found in the lower stages of Creation. This school can find no sufficient evidence of a breach of continuity in the chain of evolution, from the lowest organism which manifests vital functions — some are bolder yet, and include the inorganic — to the genius that created Hamlet, or read the secret order of the stars. Reason and will, the distinctive human endow- ments in the popular judgment of all ages, are, in this scheme, but the highest function of that finest form of matter which enters into the composition of the human structure ; '' ohne PJwsphor, kein Gedanke^' without phosphorus, no thought : volition being equally the evolution of that battery of material ele- ments in man's bodily organisation, on which the unseen currents are ever playing ; motion having its key in the chemical constituents of his nature ; all that he is, all that he does, all that he can become, being as surely settled by the arrangements of the particles of his frame and their relation to the currents of force around him, as are settled, on the same basis and with the same certainty, the track of a storm or the path of a star. For such a being, if this be the true account of man's nature, Redemption can have no meaning, for there is absolutely nothing to redeem. His every act and every state is under the calm resistless rule of that law which maintains all the "sequences" of the Creation ; to make man other than he is and must The Higher Life. be, would be to break up the whole order of the world. I am very far from connecting what Is called the theory of evolution as a means of accounting for the infinite variety and yet the perfect order of the de- velopments of life, with a materialistic or atheistic philosophy. The two have unhappily been closely associated, and mainly, I think, from two causes. The first is the eagerness with which thinkers of the atheistic school have seized upon it, and sought to claim it as their own ; the second, and I think the main cause of this evil association, has been the im- provident and, indeed, insane dread of the theologians. They have to thank themselves if this attractive theory is supposed popularly to favour their oppo- nents. How much of the atheism of this age, and of every age, is generated by the antagonism and de- nunciation of the Church, is a question which, while it fills one with shame, is not unsuggestive of hope. When the Church grows less fearful, more faithful and more far-sighted, we may believe that atheism will disappear from the world. But there is no necessary, or even I venture to think, natural antipathy between evolution and a sound Christian philosophy. Conservative thinkers are beginning to acknowledge that this law of evolu- tion plays a very distinguished part in the ordering of the majestic procession of life. At the same time, the gap between man and the lower animals is, in the judgment of accomplished students of nature, yet un- bridged, and is not even in process of being bridged What is Man ? Nothing' is established which destroys the belief that man's body reveals the direct, original touch of a creative hand, I do not presume to offer a decisive judgment on a point which it needs very deep and accurate scientific knowledge even to appreciate. Whether the views which have been stated with such learning and force by Mr. Wallace are right, or those which follow the direction of Mr. Darwin's book on the " Descent of Man," I do not attempt to decide. I can only say, that, as far as I am able to judge, Mr. Darwin's case seems very far from proved. But it can hardly be denied that the course of modern scientific thought and discovery seems to be in the main following the track which Mr. Darwin has opened. It may find its limit speedily, and science may uphold the received theological ideas. But it is, at any rate, quite possible that we may have to accept it as a settled truth, that the human form has been developed, by a process of natural evolution (not natural selection, that could only have been one of the principles at work), out of the highest types of form in the animal creation, and that man began his career in this world in a condition but a very little raised above the brutes. It is not proved ; I have no idea that it can be proved ; but if it should be proved, it may open to us a new and very wonderful vision of the way of God in the creation and the ruling of the world. There is a stage In which the human embryo cannot be distinguished from the embryos of the lower orders of the Creation ; there Is a stage at The Higher Life. which, by some process which utterly evades us, it becomes distinctively human ; and there is a further stage in the development of the infant, in which the higher qualities of our nature unfold themselves in their full spiritual form, and are dealt with as the ruling powers in the house of life. It is possible that this may prove to be an image on a small scale of the travail of the Creation ; there may be a work- ing through all the stages of creature development up to the human, and a point — it has never been dis- covered as yet, nor has anything near to it — at which this creature which has shaped itself through the inward and outward pressure to the likeness of the human, becomes distinctly Man. There is really nothing to startle or to frighten us in this doctrine of a law of evolution, of which natural selection will be one of the factors, and but one, which are at work. The doctrine will accord with an intelligent Christian theory of life. It is evolution by chance medley, as It were, which seems so absolutely incredible, things chancing to settle them- selves by Internecine struggle Into this wonderful cosmos. An intelligible theory of evolution seems to demand a forecasting Intelligence behind it. We seem to be brought face to face with a far-seeing mind and a far-reaching will, when we catch the first sign of an outward and upward pressure in the primal matter of the Creation, which, through In- numerable ascending stages, was to issue forth at last in the human race. There can be no doubt that the Idea, were we What is Man f g bound to accept it, would give a grievous shock to our popular theological notions. We should have to re-read the third, as we have had to re-read the first chapter of the book of Genesis. We have come to find in the one an ideal picture of the Creation, the essential tiuth of the matter to the eye of a spirit, seeking a principle of order, of cosmos, and seeking the means of connecting that order with God. The first chapter of Genesis means more and not less to us than it meant a generation ago, before the light of science was brought fairly to bear upon it. Just so, if this new idea can be established, shall we find in the third chapter an ideal portrait of man in his spiritual and Divine relations, a revelation of the meaning of life and of the principle of moral develop- ment, to the full understanding of which he is meant to grow ; a picture painted by God's own hand to light the path of man's pilgrimage, to sustain his soul in that higher region of spiritual freedom to which he has found entrance, and to explain to him, as his Maker only could explain to him, the profoundest mysteries of his life. But there is nothing incon- sistent with the fundamental truths of Christianity in this or in any intelligent theory of the way in which man's physical system was developed out of the dust, and made capable of the reception and manifestation of that reasonable soul which relates him with a loftier sphere. Being found in form as a man, he belongs to the world of spiritual intelligence and activity ; the qualities which foreshadow reason and will, which he shares with the animal creation, lO The Higher Life. become absorbed in the superior powers ; and the spiritual facts which find a continually clearer fore- cast through the ascending types of the Creation, as the organs are growingly perfected of which a spirit alone can make full use, Reason, Will, and Moral responsibility, rule thenceforth supreme over his life. There is a kindred theory of moral development, which might fairly be called the theory of moral evolution, which resolves into an inheritance of the accumulated experience of the race as regards the utility of actions, those moral judgments and habits which we are wont to regard as the siens of the presence in man of a spiritual nature, having know- ledge of good and evil ; by the possession of which he is distinguished absolutely from the lower spheres of the Creation, and related to the spheres above him and to God. Just as we are assured by physio- logists of this school, and they have evidently much truth on their side, that the instinct of animals is but accumulated and transmitted experience, which has shaped itself into a habit of action, useful to the creature for its protection, or for the fulfilment of the functions of its life ; so we are told that in the matter of man's moral judgments and emotions, " the experiences of utility, organised and consolidated through all past generations of the human race, have been producing corresponding nervous modifications, which by continued transmissions of accumulation, have become in us certain faculties of moral intuition, active emotions responding to right and wrong conduct, which have no apparent basis in the indi- What is Man? ii vidua] experiences of utility." These moral intuitions an intelligent and conscious being comes to regard as having a sanction in the constitution of things outside him, and in the nature and will of an Almighty Being above him ; their only real sanction being their utility, their adaptation to the preserva- tion and the welfare of society. But it is acknow- ledged that at length man comes, and ought to come, to lose sight of this relation of utility, that is, of that which is regarded as the ultimate test to which the con- ceptions of " ought " and " ought not " must be referred ; and to regard duty, even when its higher sanction is denied, as having the right to claim from him the sacrifice of pleasure, utility, and even life, at need.^ Among the gravest of the objections to this system is the breach of continuity which arises when a con- ception so large, reaching to such heights and depths as duty, first appears ; just as in the theory of physical evolution, there is a break in the line some- where, when the creature first steps upon the stage of life who is endowed with the distinguishing attri- butes of man. A morality like this of the utilitarian, which has constantly to forget its origin, which has studiously to refrain from reference to that utility by ^ This is not stating the matter at all too strongly. Mr. Mill, in a noble passage, declares that if he must go to hell for refusing to worship a being whom he cannot call good, " to hell he will go." It is very difficult to extract from Mr. Mill's works any clear statement of his view of the ultimate basis of morals. It is probable that no small part of his influence on his generation is due to the fact that he seemed to claim ever and anon a higher sanction for the right than his system appeared to allow. In other words, his belief was greater than his creed. 12 The Higher Life. which during all its earlier stages it grew ; which has to train itself to substitute foT It some higher con- ception, more in accord with what we regard as the spiritual nature of man, had better, one would think, be referred at once to that spiritual nature whose movements it simulates so admirably, and to that God to whom it strives by natural effort to lift Its ideas. But again I say, suppose that this could be the right theory ; suppose that brutes and men through an almost endless series of stages of development, could have gradually formed those instinctive habits of action, rising at length into what looks like moral choice, which secure on the whole a course favourable to the best Interests of the race or the community, regarded on a large and, we should say, a provident scale — what then ? It is clear that the whole course of things in this world, its constitution and the cur- rents of force which act upon It, must have been so ordered as to press the action of animated beings, with great limitation of their own private pleasure, into a mould which secures in a large form, such as we might imagine only a most wise and provident Ruler could forecast, the greatest good of the whole. Thus we find a belnof who inherits all this accumu- lated experience in the form of emotions and pro- pulsions, in whom there is present too a faculty which can reflect upon it, can examine it, can see how and why certain actions secure this general good, and certain others hinder it. In this being, further, a consciousness has somehow dawned that there is a What is Man? 13 yet higher sanction for this action than utility, that the utility is of so very high and subtile a kind, that it demands a Divine foresight to forecast it ; that he is under the law as a being with the endowment of freedom to the God who made and who rules both him and the world ; a God who demands the exercise of this wise judgment which is so good for all as mat- ter of duty to Himself, while He continually educates and purifies that judgment, and draws it forth to larger and nobler ministries to the general good. What shall we say to these things, even on the poor and thin hypothesis of the evolutionists ? What, but that the creature thus trained and shaped by the obscure influences of the material sphere, was born at last, when his development so far was com- plete, into a world in which his developed nature found a response to its new-born cravings, support for its new-found convictions, the explanation and the justification of those loftier and more unselfish modes of action, to which some inward pressure had compelled it, and a home wherein its longings for the good, the true, and the unchanging might be at rest. It seems to me that on this theory of the physical and moral development of man, as clearly as on ours, the whole process presupposes, demands the existence of a world of spirit, of moral freedom, of responsibility, of knowledge of and relation to God ; a world which is ready to receive as its citizen the creature thus developed up to the pitch of its life ; unless, indeed, this marvellous vital instinct, to put it no higher, which guided development with such 14 The Higher Life. grand success through its myriad stages, ends it at last in illusion, with bitter fruit of misery and despair. As matter of fact, we find beings, who have gra- dually, whether as the result of pure evolution or otherwise, left their proneness, their front towards the dust, and who lift their heads on high, and seem to be looking beyond the world. In accord with this physical habit and gesture, we find that the idea has not only dawned upon them, but possessed them, that there is a world invisible to sense around and beyond this visible sphere, with which, rather than with the creature, their true relations and destinies are intertwined. It is a world which lays heavy demands of duty upon them, while it stimulates them to noble and fertile activity. It has inspired all the brightest, most glorious, most blessed passages in the history of the race ; it has made, as we shall see, the grandest and most heroic human spirits its pilgrims, and has sent martyrs by myriads to the rack and to the stake, that they might keep unsullied their loyalty to its King. Are we to be told as we rise to meet the messengers of this spiritual world with joy, and to listen to its Gospel, Ah ! here you are enterinor into a world of dreams ? Dreams ! Why the whole system of the uni- verse, according to these theorists, has been so shaped, or has so shaped itself, as to press develop- ment up to the type of the human. And man is moved by the same pressure — for if the supernatural be .denied,