HEBREW POLITICS IN THE TIMES OF SARGON AND SENNACHERIB: AN INQUIRY INTO THE HISTORICAL MEANING AND PURPOSE OF THE PROPHECIES OF ISAIAH, WITH SOME NOTICE OF THEIR BEARINGS ON THE SOCIAL AND POLITICAL LIFE OF ENGLAND. BY EDWARD STRACHEY. LONDON: LONGMAN. BROWN, GREEN, AND LONGMANS. 1853. Their orators thou then extoll'st, as those The top of eloquence ; statists indeed, And lovers of their country, as may seem ; But herein to our Prophets far beneath, As men divinely taught, and better teaching The solid rules of civil government In their majestic, unaffected style, Than all the oratory of Greece and Eome. In them is plainest taught, and easiest learnt, What makes a nation happy, and keeps it so, What ruins kingdoms, and lays cities flat ; These only with our Law best form a king. Paradise Regained, iv. 553. London : Spottiswoodes and Shaw, Ncfr-street-Square. PREFACE. The winged bulls and alabaster bas-reliefs now brought from the palaces of Sargon and Sennacherib, and their Annals now in course of decipherment, have already thrown a new light on the Hebrew historians and pro- phets of the same period. Although the interpretation of the inscriptions must be farther confirmed, as well as carried out, before we can estimate our gain as to new facts, we already find that the old facts have begun to seem more real. For if the additional rays of light are still few, and the field of vision not much extended, yet there is just that extension which gives the roundness and solidity of actual life to what had hitherto some- what of the flatness of a mere picture, unless we could fill out the unaided Jewish accounts by an effort of the imagination. Who does not know the sense of defect, when he has only one account of great historical events? Who has not felt it, in particular, as to the Hebrew his- tory, hitherto left — except for a few fragments — with- out that kind of confirmation which even very opposite accounts give to each other ? However sure we might have been, that there was no essential misrepresentation in the Philippics of the Hebrew Demosthenes, when he denounced the imperial conquerors who ' trod down A 2 PREFACE. men as the mire of the streets, removed the bounds of the nations, found as a nest their riches, and gathered all the earth as one gathers eggs:' — yet we are not the less glad to read the Assyrians' own accounts of the way in which father and son did, year by year, and from country to country, receive tribute from the kings who submitted, and conquer and punish by captivity or death those who resisted ; carrying off their gods, their chief men, their treasures of gold and silver, their horses and cattle, nay, the whole inhabitants, men and women ; and giving up the cities to pillage, and then restoring them under new vassals : so that of each em- peror, and of each year of his reign, we may say in Colonel Rawlinson's words, ' his annals contain the usual amount of burning and plundering, sweeping off the old population, and planting fresh colonies in their place.' We knew from Isaiah that all this must have been so ; but the mind is not the less pleased to have independent evidence that it was so : — to find its infer- ences realised in facts. The antiquarian is not, however, the chief interest of these times of Sargon and Sennacherib. Our latest historians of Greece and Rome are showing us, as in a mirror, the very lineaments of our own age. They tell us of soldiers who followed their leaders to certain death, in obedience to the orders of those who sent them, ex- pecting every man to do his duty : and of citizens whose political vices and even passions, as well as virtues, and the causes of their national decay, no less than their national growth, are all found within the circle of con- stitutional government, with its juries and its parlia- ments, its administrations headed by the highborn, the PREFACE. V rich, and the respectable, and its opposition led by speakers who used the most unlicensed violence of words, without a thought of overstepping the forms of the constitution by act, and whom the people half de- spised as plebeian, while they supported them as the necessary check on the aristocratic men whom they pre- ferred to have in office. Again they show us, how con- stitutional freedom of thought and action in politics degenerated into individual selfishness or self-will, so that each man held it his right, or, if he was a fanatic, his duty, to enforce his own private view or interest, without regard to the good of the commonwealth : and how, when this vice had become incurable, the most enlightened patriots agreed with the most timid or selfish lovers of order, that nothing was left for the state but simple military despotism ; nothing in religion, but an organised superstition without faith : — which despot- ism and superstition would do nothing, indeed, towards restoring the life of the nation, but would make its in- evitable death more gradual, and less convulsive, than if they continued to try successive forms of anarchy under the pretence of regaining liberty : and they show us how the civil skill of an Augustus built up this ne- cessary system of state-craft, for which the sword of his predecessor had cleared the ground. These things, and much more, they tell us, and we know how to make the application. But when it is made, it announces an in- evitable law of national decay and death, which is to take effect upon us too, as well as upon Greece or Rome ; rather than a moral warning, with direction how we may escape our threatened destiny : and it is this latter that we feel we want, and of which we will not abandon the A 3 VI PREFACE. hope that it may be still found. We know that in our personal experience the moral laws of spirit do control and modify the laws of nature, and in the end pro- duce a result which, though apparently in accordance with the latter, is really the complete triumph of the for- mer : — that the body grows old and dies, but that the man himself may all the while have been growing up towards the maturity of an imperishable life. And we apply the analogy to our country. We observe that all nations that have hitherto perished, have perished, partly at least, of disease originating in political vices : and we conclude, that if immortality is no more pos- sible to a nation than to anything else on earth, it must be possible that its decay should be that of simple and healthy old age ; that it should be altogether honourable and honoured, in that old age, by the young nations that spring from it ; and that it should leave to them the inheritance of a wholly noble character and spirit, and not merely that mixture of vices and virtues, of wisdom and error, which has come down to it from its great predecessors. This, then, is the important matter to us : whether the law of disease, which, as distinguished from that of age, is so plainly at work in England, as well as in every other nation of Europe, can be still arrested ; and in particular, whether there is truth in that half-forgotten faith of our statesmen in former days, that the political history of the Hebrews does contain indications of the remedy, as well as the disease, though the latter only is described in the books of Greece and Rome : whether, for instance, Milton, who was no mean statesman in a day when men had to show what was really in them, PREFACE. Vll and who had no lack of knowledge as to what the ancients could teach us of politics, was right when he asserted of the Jewish books, that In them is plainest, taught, and easiest learnt, What makes a nation happy, and keeps it so. To get an answer to this question for myself; to as- certain whether an English squire could find in the Bible any political instruction which might avail him at union boards and county elections, and in his relations with the parson and the magistrate, the farmer and the peasant ; was my purpose when I began the study of the writings of Isaiah many years since : and the hope of serving some one desirous of such information, might have seemed to me excuse enough for thus attempting to show what I had learnt of the internal politics of Judea, and of their relation to those of modern England. But, meanwhile, there are gathering signs, that the times of Isaiah, and the principles which he enunciated, are finding, and may find more and more, their counter- part, and their application, in our foreign relations too. It may not be only Hebrew politics, but Hebrew poli- tics in their connection with Sargon and Sennacherib, that we want to study. We may know already what the prophet meant by his protests against 'the new moons and sabbaths, and the making many prayers ; ' and against the ' land full of silver and gold, where men join house to house, and field to field, and grind the faces of the poor, and right not the fatherless, and jus- tify the wicked for reward, and are prudent in their own sight, but regard not the work of the Lord, nor the operation of His hands.' We may know, too, or hope to know, something of the contrary state of things, A 4 VU1 PREFACE. when righteous and just rulers and princes show how 1 a man can be a covert from the tempest ; ' and how he can ' devise liberal things for the poor and needy, and fill the land with knowledge and understanding, and break every yoke.' But our country has, within the last four years, become almost as isolated, though not as weak, as Judea, in the midst of military despotisms. Our old notions of law and liberty, in religion and in government, are shocked by acts and maxims which re- mind us of the Assyrian's boast, that ' By the grace of my god Assarac I have done it,' or, ' By the strength of my hand, and by my wisdom, for I am prudent.' And while the political moralist now, as in Isaiah's day, recognises a needful discipline for each nation in these things, and asks himself what cause his own country can show why she should wholly escape it, he thinks — we all think at times — of the possibility of a contest in which not our mere lives, or even the life of our nation, but the life — all that deserves the name of life — of the world itself, will be at stake : nor is the faith wanting among us that, in such a contest, God will have work for ' his Englishmen,' as Milton calls us. Men's various tempers, and the changeable events of the day, may variously incline, or disincline, them to be- lieve that the contest will be one with fleets and armies : but no one doubts that — in the one sense or the other — a war of principles is at hand, or rather begun already. And, if so, it is worth our while to inquire what we may learn of those principles in a book which professes to set them forth in direct form, and with a practical, and for us illustrative, application to the political events of the writer's own time. If the principles of Isaiah PREFACE. IX are the true ones, his demonstration of them will not be the less clear and instructive, because his diagram is the simple constitution, and the little state, of Judea, and we are interested in the commonwealth of Eng- land, with its complicated organisation and mighty power. The reader must not, however, suppose that I have employed the writings of Isaiah to set forth and en- force some system of dogmas, political or theological, of my own. I have applied myself to the prophet, simply to learn from him whatever I might find he had to teach an English citizen : I have taken the book as it stands: and, while availing myself of the stores of thought and learning which the commentators of vari- ous schools have provided, I have, to the best of my ability, handled the book itself by the method of the Niebuhrs and the Grotes, and treated it as they — with thorough freedom and thorough reverence — treat the classical books. Wherever the method led, I have followed : and I now offer the sketch-map of my route to any one who may intend to take the same road for himself, and be willing to accept such help as it can give. If he finds its use real, he will, I trust, pardon some repetitions of statement which, if not inevitable to my plan, I have not had the skill to avoid. The special, but important, question, as to the genuine- ness of parts of the book ; which has been debated on theological and speculative grounds during the last sixty years, but on which each school still refuses to accept the conclusion of the other ; I have ventured to examine by the same — the positive — method. With what result, the reader will judge. X PREFACE. I have given, in their proper places, the latest readings of the Cuneiform Inscriptions according to Colonel Itawlinson and Dr. Hincks ; and have shown their bearings upon the Jewish accounts, as well as upon the notices in the classical writers, and in Berosus and the other Oriental annalists of whom a few fragments have come down to us : — so far as relates to the times I have treated of. But I have been careful to distinguish our main standing-ground ; which is independent of the Inscriptions, and will hold firm though the present interpretations of these should hereafter be set aside in part, or altogether. Of this, however, the best authorities have the least expectation ; and, in addition to what others have published on the subject, Mr. Norris, of the Asiatic Society, permits me to give, with the weight of his name, the following note, in which he states the case more lucidly, I think, than has yet been done : — " I believe the general tenour of the reading of As- syrian monuments is quite correct, about as correct as would be the reading of a Latin historical document by an intelligent Italian, who knew no more of Latin than what he might have learned through a general study of antiquities, and a comparison with the roots and forms of his own tongue : and it must be remembered that the monuments we have from Assyria are couched in the very plainest and simplest language. The reading of foreign names too is, I believe, accurate : of native names we have less certainty, as it appears to have been the practice of the writers rather to indicate a name than to spell it : — to designate their monarchs rather as the favourites of this or that particular god or goddess, than PREFACE. XI as having vulgar names, to be written with common letters. Hezekiah, Menahem, Jehu, &c. I believe to be quite sure, and there is reason to suppose that other foreign names are equally ascertained : but monograms of gods are much less manageable, though even here we have now and then collateral aids which render pro- babilities all but certainties." Such collateral aids are found in the coincidence of the Hebrew, and fragmentary Greek, accounts — con- firmed in one case by a local name — with those state- ments of the Inscriptions which, being written in the ordinary manner, have been deciphered by the ordinary methods. Thus, within the pile of ruins which bore the name of Sarghun as late as the Arab conquest, were found inscriptions which state, among other things, that the builder was king of Assyria and Babylon, and swept away Samaria, and reduced Tyre and Ashdod ; and the annals of his successor relate, that he invaded Judea in order to compel Hezekiah to pay his accustomed tribute, and defeated the kings of Egypt and Meroe, who came to help their Jewish ally : — with various details of names and facts, corresponding with those of the Hebrew his- tory. And, if it be admitted that these names and facts can be so far deciphered, the conclusion is inevit- able, that these two Assyrian kings, under whatever monograms their own names are concealed, were the Sargon and Sennacherib of Isaiah. CONTENTS. CHAPTER I. The Greek Orator. — The Hebrew Prophet. — The modern Preacher. — — Schools of the Prophets. — The Book of Isaiah — its Arrange- ment — its Unity. — Hypothetical and positive Criticism. — Niebuhr's Canons -_..-_ Page 1 CHAP. II. The Book of Isaiah — its Title. — Date of Chapter i. — Prophetic Ima- gination. — Hebrew Oratory rhythmical. — Parallels in other Nations. — Contents of Chapter i. — Times of Uzziah and Jotham Forms and Spirit. — National Brotherhood. — Political Ideals - - 14 CHAP. III. Isaiah ii., hi., iv. Hebrew Genius imaginative rather than logical. Preterite and Future Tenses in Hebrew. — The last Days. — Contrast of the ideal and actual State of the Nation. — Foreign Influences. Private Idolatry. — Political Materialism. — National Decay. — Laws of God's Government of the World. — Good and evil of Commerce. — Hebrew Matrons. — Female Luxury — its Punishment. — The Branch of the Lord. — The restored though humbled Nation - - 32 CHAP. IV. Isaiah v. Coming Woes. — Fusing Power of Imagination. — Hebrew Idyll. — Ancient Fertility of Judea — present Barrenness. — The Vineyard of the Lord of hosts. — Selfishness in an Aristocracy. — Rights and Duties of Landowners. — Property a Trust — Hebrew and English Laws of Entail. — Word and Work of the Lord. — God a Constitutional Ruler. — Abuse of Words by worldly Men. — Thu- cydides. — Fulfilment of Isaiah's Threats to his Cotemporaries — and to all Ages since. — Grotius on Prophecy - - - 49 CONTENTS. CHAP. V. Isaiah vi. The Prophet's Commission. — The Temple — its Scenes. — The Vision. — Insight into the Life of Things. — Prophecy rational and intelligible. — God the real and actual King. — Plural of Majesty. — Holiness of God — His Justice. — Calvinism - - Page 67 CHAP. VI. Isaiah vii. The Accession of Ahaz. — Political State of King and People. — ' The Lord said.' — Topography of Jerusalem. — The Virgin con- ceiving.— The Incarnation an universal Idea — how realised. — Loss of Hebrew Independence. — Isaiah not a Magician - 84 CHAP. VII. Isaiah viii. — ix. 7. The Symbolical Family. — Ancient and modern Habits of Public Men. — Siloah and Euphrates. — The Panic of Judah, and its Remedy. — Galilee of the Gentiles. — The National Gloom. — The Great Light. — The Messiah. — Gradual Development of the Prophet's Anticipations - - - - - -100 CHAP. VIII. Isaiah ix. 8. — xii. Epic Unity. — Obstinate Energy of the Hebrew Race. Lawlessness of the Ten Tribes. — Legalism of Judah. — The King of Assyria. — Gods in the Image of Men. — The Scourge of Nations, and its Wielder. — Ancient Roads. — The King of the Stock of Jesse. — The Golden Age. — Fusion of Conflicting Elements in a Nation. — Consequences of the Revolt of Ephraim. — Deportation of Jews in Isaiah's Time. — The Universal Church — its Relation to the World. — The Water of Salvation - - - - - 111 CHAP. IX. Isaiah xiii., xiv. Genuineness of the Prophecies on Babylon. — Scep- tical Criticism — its Origin and Progress — not Positive or Construc- tive. — Orthodox Criticism. — Results of the Controversy. — Tra- ditional Comments confounded with the Text. — Hebrew Historical Notices of Babylon — Assyrian Notices. — Babylon sacked in Isaiah's Time by Persians, and perhaps by Medes. — Babylon a Diagram or Ideograph. — Arguments from Style. — Suspense better than hasty Decision. — Final Overthrow of the Empire of Force - - 140 CHAP. X. Isaiah xiv. 28. Philistia. — Origin of the Philistines — their Extermi- nation commanded by Moses Law of Conquests and Exterminations. CONTENTS. XV — British Conquest of India. — Evil not Eternal. — Philistia's Re- lations with Judah — with Assyria. — Sargon and Sennacherib in Philistia -.._-. page 163 CHAP. XI. Isaiah xv., xvi. Moab — probably reduced by Shalmaneser. — History of Moab — Picture of its Overthrow. — Tribute of Lambs due to Judah. — Friendship with Judah advised. — Modern Distinction between the animal and spiritual Life. — Corporate Unity of a State - 174 CHAP. XII. Isaiah xvii., xviii. Damascus, Ephraim, and Ethiopia. — Probable Date and Unity of this Prophecy. — The Rush of Nations. — The general Panic. — Worldly Alliances. — God's Deliverance. — Notion of this Prophecy being a Myth — not well founded - - - 183 CHAP. XIII. Isaiah xix. Egyptian Dynasties in the Time of Isaiah — Cotemporary or Successive. — Historical Notices from various Sources. — Anarchy. — Invasion of Sargon. — Sack of Thebes. — Treaty between Egypt and Assyria. — Multitude of Gods and of Castes unfavourable to Political Unity. — Exclusive Wisdom Qf Priesthood. — The City of Destruction. — Alexander and Ptolemy. — Temple of Onias. — Septuagint. — Philo. — Church of Alexandria. — Bacon on Prophecy - - 189 CHAP. XIV. Isaiah xx. Sargon, Shalmaneser, Tartan. — The Siege of Ashdod. — Shebna's Policy of Alliances. — Isaiah's Symbolical Protest against it — he walks naked and barefoot. — Isaiah's Policy probably more Ex- pedient— certainly more befitting Israel's Place in Universal History 196 CHAP. XV. Isaiah xxi. A Vision in a Dream or Trance. — Bible Meaning of In- spiration. — Divination. — Ancient Oracles. — Special Powers of Na- tions and Individuals. — One Greece, one Shakspeare. — Discernment of Political Effects in their Causes less possible now than formerly. — — ' The Desert of the Sea.' — The Prophet a Watchman. — The Tribes of Arabia — subjected by Assyria - 202 CHAP. XVI. Isaiah xxii. Political Parties at Jerusalem. — Shebna and the Majority. — Eliakim and the Minority. — Isaiah's Attack on Shebna. — Prepara- XVI CONTENTS. tions for the Siege. — Topography of Jerusalem. — Site of Sion. — Spirit of the People and King. — Fall of Shebna. — Sufferings of Modern Nations from Invasion. — Moral and Religious Results. — Prussia. — Switzerland. ... - Page 211 CHAP. XVII. Isaiah xxiii. The Phenicians — Historical Notices — Their Trade — — Carriers of Philosophy and Politics — Relations with Israel. — The Tyrian Hercules — their Religion Political, not Natural. — Siege of the Island-Tyre by Shalmaneser — by Nebuchadnezzar — by Alex- ander — present State. — Authorship of the Prophecy. — The Dis- penser of Crowns. — The Queen of Cities dishonoured. — Tyre for- gotten Seventy Years — shall sing as an Harlot - - 227 CHAP. XVIII. Isaiah xxiv. — xxvii. Utter Desolation of Judah — actually caused by the Assyrian Armies. — National Covenant, broken by Ahaz — he shuts the Temple. — God's Counsels of Old. — Moab put for Assyria. — Pa- tience in National Calamities. — The Wife divorced, and taken back. — The Silver Trumpet sounded. — Expansion of Isaiah's Views - 239 CHAP. XIX. Isaiah xxviii. — xxxv. The Political, Moral, and Religious State and Prospects of Judah. — Ariel, the Lion of God. — Worldly State-Craft. True Insight. — The Embassy to Egypt. — Persecution of the Pro- phets Dumb Idols and the Unseen Teacher. — The Holy Solemnities. Talmudical Account of Festal Processions. — The Stroke of Doom on Sennacherib. — The Real Deliverer. — Social Influence of Women. The Siege raised. — Edom put for Assyria. — Return of the ran- somed Captives -------- 248 CHAP. XX. Isaiah xxxvi., xxxvii. Historical Events of Sennacherib's Invasion and Retreat — his Letter — how answered. — Unconscious Genius in the Narrative. — Rab-Shakeh's Theology. — Isaiah's Inspiration. — ' The Incarnate Wrath of God.' — Zion's Defiance. — The 'Sign' of the Spontaneous Crops. — The Destroying Angel. — Sethos delivered by Vulcan. — Value of Sennacherib's Annals, if established — their Altered Tone after this Year. — German War of Freedom. — History teaches a Belief in Providence. — Niebuhr. — Grote - - - 271 CHAP. XXI. Isaiah xxxviii. The Sickness of Hezekiah. — Importance of his Life to his Nation. — his Desire of Recovery not purely Selfish. — Fear of CONTENTS. Xvii Death in Old Times. — Christ's Resurrection. — The Sign of the Sha- dow on the Sun-Dial. — Two Accounts — the Cotemporary One not Miraculous. — Bible to be treated like other Books. — Not so treated by Sceptics. — The Hymn of Hezekiah - Page 285 CHAP. XXII. Isaiah xxix. : The Embassy from Babylon. — Chronicle of Eusebius. — Berosus. — Sennacherib's Annals. — Books of Kings and Chronicles. — Value of the Latter. — The Sin of Hezekiah. — Trusting God in Po- litics. — Modern History. — Niebuhr and Naples. — Colletta. — Reve- rence for Great Men. — Nations and Rulers re-act on each other. — Hezekiah's Reception of the Embassy. — Isaiah's Denunciation. — c Apres moi le Deluge.' — Prosperity of England. — Religious Temper of our Statesmen. — Mr. Gladstone - 2.95 CHAP. XXIII. Isaiah xl — lxvi.: Question of the Genuineness of the last Chapters of Isaiah. — Pseudo-Isaian Hypothesis. — The Name of Cyrus. — Coresh, and the Lord's Servant. — Modern Explanations. — Moller's Interpretation. — Doubts and Certainties. — The Positive Method. — Coherence of earlier and later Prophecies. — The earlier not fulfilled as Isaiah had expected. — Enlargement of his Views. — Finite and In- finite Ideals. — ■ Facts for Induction as to the Nature of Prophecy. — Note on Strauss, and the Application of Positive Criticism to Chris- tianity ._--..- sio CHAP. XXIV. The Vision of the Captivity and Deliverance. — The Transitory and the Permanent. — God in Nature, and in Human Society. — The Power- less Gods of the Nations. — The Jewish Institution of the Redeemer. — Its Effect on the more enlightened Jews. — The Deliverer, King, and Teacher. — The Work of Isaiah and Hezekiah. — Its Success and its Failure. — Jewish Idea of the Messiah. — Its Relation to their Poli- tical Life. — Atonement a Human Fact. — A rational Idea. — Union of Half-Truths. — The Messiah of the Gospel. — The Prophets and the Apostles. — Isaiah's Science of Politics — His Death — His Triumph - - - - - - -332 Appendix _„__--_ 253 HEBREW POLITICS, CHAPTER I. THE GREEK ORATOR. — THE HEBREW PROPHET. THE MODERN PREACHER. SCHOOLS OF THE PROPHETS. THE BOOK OF ISAIAH. ITS ARRANGE- MENT— ITS UNITY. HYPOTHETICAL AND POSITIVE CRITICISM. NIE- BUHR's CANONS. The Spartan king told Xerxes that he was no match for the Greeks, ' because they, though free, had a master — the law — over them, which they feared more than the Persians did his despotic will.' And the Athenian orator, looking back on the great struggle after a generation or two had passed, gave his countrymen the same explanation of their fathers' success * against the barbarian myriads of the king of Asia : ' he pointed out how ' they had done such noble and wonderful deeds, because they were already organised into a free commonwealth in which the good were honoured, and the bad restrained, by law ; because they knew *and held that it should be left to brute beasts to control each other by mutual violence, such as oriental kings and subjects lived by, but that it became men to define rights by law, to persuade to its maintenance or expan- sion by rational and instructive speech, and in their conduct to follow the guidance of both these, — the law their king, and speech their teacher.' The orator enunciated an eternal truth. Had it been less than eternal, it could not be still keeping its ground, and still sustaining the life of every nation which holds to it, or B 2 HEBREW POLITICS. indeed, although we (not to judge of others) hold never so im- perfectly to it: for though we are ready enough to thank God that we English are not as other men, we might more reason- ably reflect how often we are all on the verge of doing what lies in us to disturb the perfect play of those two forces, of entire obedience to tlie law and absolute right of discussion, according as either may check some private opinion or class interest ; and how seldom we remember that one step beyond that verge lies the region of mutual violence with the cor- relates of despotism and insurrection in which its vitality consists. But this truth, this universal law of human society, has not only outlasted the polities of Greece, but was not first discovered there, as the Athenians supposed ; nor was the ex- ercise of this master right and power of words ' so originally and peculiarly the possession of Greeks alone among all living creatures, that' (as their panegyrist goes on to say) 'if any other people did acquire it from them, this only extended the name of Grecian to distinctions of mind as well as race, so that they were called by it who shared their education rather than those who had their blood.' Another people had been set, many centuries earlier, to work out some of the same, with some very different, problems of human society, and under not wholly dissimilar conditions, internal and external : and while the Hebrew as well as the Greek could have pointed to various other proofs that his was a commonwealth, or constitutionally organised body-politic, as distinguished from the inorganic despotisms of Assyria or Persia, the one fixed on the same marks as the other did, as the characteristic ones: the 'Nomos and Logos ' of the Greek were anticipated by their true counterparts the ' Law and the Prophets ' of the Hebrew. Isaiah, no less than Demosthenes, might have said that it was the office of the political speaker and adviser, l to see events in their beginnings, to discern their purport and tendencies from the first, and to forewarn his countrymen accordingly ; to con- fine within the narrowest bounds those political vices of habitual procrastination, supineness, ignorance, and love of strife, which are inevitable in all states ; and to dispose men's minds instead to enlightened concord and unanimity, and to the zealous dis- charge of their social duties : ' and he too might have added, INSTITUTIONS FOR NATIONAL CULTURE. 3 ' All these things have I done, and no creature can say that I have ever left any of them undone ; I do not shrink from your scrutiny, be it never so strict.' * But there were differences as well as resemblances between the orator and the prophet, and we must look for further illustrations elsewhere. If we were to describe a nation, in the political constitution of which was found an incorporated and endowed body of men, with the business of caring for all those interests of the nation which did not fall under the heads of trade, agriculture, war, or domestic and feudal (that is, patriarchal) government ; who practised the more difficult branches of medicine, law, and statesmanship ; who bestowed a religious consecration on all states of national, family, and personal life — delivering the crown and sceptre to the sovereign in trust from the King of kings, joining the hands of man and wife in the name of God, and enrolling, as a citizen, the babe who has just before been received into the congregation ; who claimed the right, and acknowledged the duty, of educating every member of the na- tion to apprehend his privileges and obligations, not only as a citizen, but as a man, and of teaching him that his greatest dignity and happiness, and his truest and deepest communion with his fellow-men and with God, belong to him as a man, and will be his in proportion as this, his proper humanity, is renewed in him ; and who rescued one day in each week from worldly employments, devoting it to public worship and holy rest, and thus providing the opportunity and means for keeping up that consecration of the nation, and for carrying on that education of the people : — if we were to draw such a pic- ture, it would suit equally the old constitutions of England and the other nations of Christendom, and that of the Jewish nation, whence their model was, no doubt, derived. And though decay and growth have conspired to efface many of the original characteristics of the 'Church of England,' and to provide other means for the execution of many of its old functions, it is * Demosthenes, de Corona, c. 73. This, and the preceding passages from Herodotus (vii. 104.), Lysias (ii. 17 — 20.), and Isocrates (iv. 53 — 56.), are pointed out as characteristic of the political life of Greece, by Mr. Grote: History, vii. 498., ix. 11G. B 2 4 HEBREW POLITICS. still not only the best, but a thoroughly effective illustration of the analogous ' estate of the realm' of Israel. It is an obscure, though interesting, inquiry what was the rightful (we know what was the corrupt) practice of the Hebrew people, and their ministers the Levites, as to the local worship of the Lord God. The practice among the patriarchs, and in the early commonwealth, of setting up an altar on every spot which had been hallowed by some mani- festation of God's power or favour ; the organisation of the synagogues, all over the country, in later times ; the character of the nation so religious in spirit and not merely in forms ; the story of Elijah building the altar on Mount Carmel ; are among the indications of what in itself seems so probable, that during the middle ages of the nation there may have been modes of local worship of the true God in accordance with the design with which Moses had scattered the Levites among the people, and which were not comprehended in those repeated denuncia- tions of the worship of ' the High Places ' which occur through- out the histories of the kings. Be this as it may, the ecclesi- astical law of the Israelites at least appointed the Levites to perform the sacrifices and other services of the tabernacle or temple ; to assist in, and give a religious sanction to, all the main proceedings of the nation and its kings; to instruct the people in the law, — for which end they had the tithes allotted to them, that they might reside in every part of the country when their turn was past for attending at the temple; to keep the genealogies and other records of the state ; and to administer what we should now call its sanitary code. And out of this spiritualty, or order of clergy, grew the institution and order of Prophets, or preachers, educated in colleges or schools of the Prophets. Such colleges existed at Eamah, Bethel, Jericho, Gil- gal, and Jerusalem; there was a president or 'father,' in which office we find Samuel and Elisha : and his disciples and asso- ciates, who bore the names of ' sons of the prophets,' lived with him in a common habitation, and shared a common table. We arc told that they c prophesied with the psaltery, tabret, pipe} and harp : ' their writings show them to have been students, nay masters, of poetry, rhetoric, and philosophy, as well as of music ; and they were historians, though only brief abstracts NATIONAL EDUCATION OF THE HEBREWS. 5 of their historical works survive : practical, no less than specu- lative and literary, politicians, they habitually show themselves educated to the use of the mental and moral powers which were required for advising their kings, at home and in foreign affairs ; and — ■ what belonged to a still higher training — for advising and directing the people how to resist those kings when the latter set the constitution deliberately at nought, and yet not fall into the same guilt themselves. There seems no reason for supposing that kings and princes were not, when they pleased, educated in these schools, as well as the prophets. It was eminently a national education ; in the Psalms, Pro- phets, and other Scriptures of the Old (nay, of the New) Tes- tament, we see its results, extending through the whole life of the nation for 1500 years : in the Pentateuch we see how its foundations were laid by the great Hebrew legislator, in further- ance of his design, that all nations should have cause to say, f Surely this great nation is a wise and understanding people ; ' and in the historical notices, brief as they are, of these schools of the prophets, we have just the fact of an adequate working instrument, to connect the design and the results. But though regular education was not less, neither was it more, important in the Hebrew than in other nations. The prophet Amos says, ' I was no prophet, neither was I a prophet's son ; but I was an herdman, and a gatherer of sycamore fruit : and the Lord took me as I followed the flock, and the Lord said unto me, Go, prophesy unto my people Israel.' And no doubt this was not the only instance in a body, of whom one of the characteristic features was that they should not belong exclusively to any one tribe, or rank, or profession, and that each should « speak as he was moved by the Holy Ghost.' Yet here as elsewhere the settled institutions of the country will have exercised their due influence in forming the character even of those individuals who did not come into immediate contact with them. The prophets were the preachers, not the predicters, the forth- speakers of God's eternal plan and methods of governing man, not foretellers of particular events, of and to their nation : this was what our Lord and his apostles understood by the name, and so has it always been understood in modern times of earnest- ness and zeal, such as our Reformation or Civil War, when men u 3 G HEBREW POLITICS. interpreted the Bible by experience gained in the council- chamber, the battle-field, or the prison, rather than by collation of commentators.* And while we may pursue our illustration by comparing the schools of the prophets with the monasteries and colleges which have hitherto sent out most, if not all, the great prophets of Christendom, as well as the multitude of ordinary teachers, we shall find a real and instructive resem- blance between these and the Hebrew prophets. The sermons and other discourses, of a Latimer at Paul's Cross, of a Luther at the Diet of Worins, or a Knox before the Popish queen and nobles ; the field-preachings of a Wesley or Whitfield, and, within narrower limits, the orations of a Burke in defence of justice, laws, institutions ; — these, taken with the lives and acts, and, where need was, the deaths of the men, are the true counterparts of what Isaiah and the rest of the Hebrew pro- phets said, did, or suffered. But facts — facts in their detail, and in their original and living coherence, are our best teachers. We shall best learn what the prophets were to the Jews, and what they are to us, by a methodical examination of what the greatest of them said and did, during a chief crisis of his country's history. The meaning of facts came to light in the collision of the Assyrian empire with the Hebrew commonwealth, as they did when Xerxes invaded Greece, or Napoleon overran Europe : and if we will take the book of Isaiah, and follow its guidance, Ave may expect to see its facts in their own proper light. This, there- fore, I propose to do. The reader will find the English text, for reference, at the end of the volume. As our familiarity with this Book of Isaiah increases, we find that the careful literary composition and elaborate finish of the single prophecies, noticeable as it is, is less so than that with which these are again fused into larger, but not less organic members, and these again into one perfect * Matt. iii. 1—12., xi. 9—14.; Luke, i. 17. 76, 77.; Rom. xii. 6.; 1 Cor. xi. 4.; xiv. 6., &c. Milton hopes (in his Speech for the Liberty of Unlicensed Printing), that England is on the eve of becoming 'a nation of prophets :' and Jeremy Taylor entitles his book on the like subject, A Dis- course of the Liberty of Prophesying, without any intimation that he is using the word in an unusual sense. GERMAN AND ENGLISH CRITICAL METHODS. 7 ■whole. And the most simple and probable explanation of this arrangement, if there be no insurmountable obstacle to its acceptance, is plainly to attribute it to Isaiah himself. If it can be shown that this explanation, of the prophet's own arrangement of the book in its present form, is absolutely incom- patible with the undoubted nature of its contents, we must give it up, and refer the compilation to such later date as the exigen- cies of the case require ; but we must not overlook that the latter is on the face of it the hypothetical and speculative, and the former the historical and positive criticism. For the arrangement of t lie book, with its general and particular titles and its historical notices, together with all that these assert (till contradicted) as to the authorship, have come down to us from time immemorial by exactly the same means as the text itself, of which they must therefore be taken to be an integral and original part, until the contrary is proved ; and the one no less than the other must be protected by that canon of criticism, that no conjecture, however ingenious, must disturb the in- tegrity of the text however obscure, until the actual reading has been shown to be hopelessly corrupt. We cannot altogether dispense with supposition and conjecture as helps to the eluci- dation of such parts of this book as, by reason of their antiquity, must now remain without any more certain explanation; nor need we doubt that conjectural criticism often throws a real, though a flickering, light on objects which are but dimly dis- cernible in the distance of ages, if only the torch be kindled by a mind thoroughly imbued with the spirit of the writer com- mented on, and held in steady, that is judicious, hands. The studious and meditative genius of the German eminently quali- fies him for these speculative inquiries and explanations ; but while the Englishman avails himself of them, with the frank acknowledgment that he could never have originated them himself, he must not scruple to test and modify them by the practical common sense which is his birthright, and which, if a more modest, is not a less useful gift than the other. Nor must we forget that Niebuhr, the greatest of the German critics of this kind, himself pointed out the true method of testing his own and all other such conclusions. He constantly endea- vours to verify his hardy conjectures by reference to corre- B 4 8 FIEBREW POLITICS. sponding facts of other times and countries, and thus to ascer- tain that he is not dreaming, but discovering and applying the real laws of history ; and his method is not the less the true one, though grave English scholars may sometimes think his particular conclusions those of the advocate rather than the judge. To exhaust the evidence and the arguments on every side of a question is the German's proper calling: and I believe that the help of the German commentators is indispensable to our thorough understanding of the Prophecies of Isaiah ; yet that they will be most serviceable to him who can best check speculation with not literal but matter-of-fact criticism; who can abstain from doubting historical facts because cotemporary records relate them in ways not easy of verbal reconciliation, or in phrases not the most obvious or likely if tried by the standard of his own mind ; and who is content to account for all such minor difficulties and discrepancies in the same way as he must the like ones which he finds in the books of his own day, and which the still living authors cannot, or do not, explain. Com- mentators often darken the text with the mists of their own undue speculativeness ; and by returning to a more practical method of investigation, by studying the book as it is, and not as ingenious theorists say it must have been, we shall often secure a firm pathway through difficulties that conjecture has hopelessly perplexed. The arrangement of the Book of Isaiah's Prophecies, as it has come down to us, is mainly chronological, yet sometimes with reference to the subjects rather than to the dates of the several pieces which form it. A like method is observable in St. Matthew's Gospel, in which the miracles, parables, and discourses of our Lord are collected into groups without strict regard to the order of time ; and the Pentateuch, the Book of Psalms, and the Bible itself as a whole, show that the appro- priateness of such composite arrangement has been recognised by the Jewish and the Christian Church. And we have a modern instance of the kind, with an exposition of its import- ance, in Mr. Wordsworth's avowedly deliberate arrangement of his poems into a whole. The particular arguments will be found in their several places : the general conclusion I deduce from them is, that THE BOOK OF ISAIAH. 9 chapter vi. is the account of Isaiah's consecration to the pro- phetic office, and its date the earliest in the book; that the three preceding discourses (chapters i., ii. — iv., v.) are placed first, in order to set forth the state of the nation at the time Isaiah began to prophesy, and the consequent fitness of the severe terms of the commission given him ; and that the rest of the book preserves the chronological order, with possibly such modifications as might serve to bring together similar prophecies, such as the series of 'burdens' on the neighbouring nations; and probably also in certain cases (chapters vii. — xii., xvii. xviii., xxviii. — xxxv., xl. — Ixvi.) with some revision and fusion of dis- courses originally distinct, so that they are now successive paragraphs in a continuous writing. The supposed insurmount- able obstacles to the acceptance of the historical assertion involved in the book itself, that it owes its present form to Isaiah's own hand, are the account of the ' Sign' of the shadow going back on the dial, and the doubt — which, indeed, the most eminent German critics say is not a doubt, but a final decision in the negative, — whether certain portions of the book were written by Isaiah at all. These will be best considered as they occur ; only I will here observe, that in examining the latter question, the student must be on his guard against the fallacy contained in an argument sometimes employed as to the arrange- ment of the book, and which supposes it to be a collection like those which are popularly called the ' Psalms of David,' and the ' Proverbs of Solomon,' though it is admitted that only a portion of each can be ascribed to its nominal author. The fallacy is in assuming that there is no difference between a real title, and a popular name, of a book. In the Hebrew the respective titles are, ' Isaiah,' ' Psalms,' ' Proverbs,' with no names attached to the two last ; and both of these contain special titles expressly attributing various portions to other authoi*s, while the whole book of Isaiah is almost as expressly attributed to him. Let the reader test the reality of this historical evidence (without prejudice to the internal counter- evidence we may come to by-and-by) by asking himself how we could strengthen it, even now we know the attack it has to stand. On the other hand, let me entreat him to keep his eyes open to the actual arrangement of the book,, as we follow 10 HEBREW POLITICS. its detail. If we find indications that tlie whole, looked at as a whole, is more like the growth of an individual mind than a collection of writings of men who lived in times far apart from each other; if we can, as we proceed, trace the manner and method in which the prophet's views opened out, as he came in contact with, and sought for the deepest springs of, the circumstances and events of his own times; then the proportion and relation of particular parts to each other and to the whole will become an important element of the question, and those of which the genuineness is disputed will be seen in a light, and with advantages, not available to us if we merely analyse each separately. The fact of such a vital coherence and inter- dependence will, I believe, become more and more apparent as we go on ; we shall find a harmony resulting not from mere me- chanical compilation, but from the presence of a one informing and enlivening spirit, and our reason no less than our religious feeling will resist the dismemberment of any part of the per- fectly organised whole. And if so, we shall (as can hardly be too often repeated) escape from the hypothetical to the positive and the historical. But the hypothetical criticism has its own rebound ; and the very commentators who are least sensitive to the weight of evi- dence in favour of the facts we have, are most ingenious in making out more and more historical dates and details of what they say must have been the events of Isaiah's time, and alluded to by him in his prophecies. Such criticism is valuable, in as far as it is a real induction ; and an unhoped for, and most inte- resting verification of it is now in progress by the help of the Cuneiform Inscriptions, which are already found to mention several facts which the Bible historians had passed in silence, but which are precisely those which the student of the pro- phets knew to be wanted, and which he had to assume in any attempt to form a distinct picture of the times. But the limit of real induction is soon reached ; and it has grown the fashion to expatiate beyond it till the commentator becomes unable to distinguish between facts and fancy. Each sees the error in his neighbour ; but we shall perhaps best guard against it in ourselves if we consider that we possess no such power of dis- covering more than a mere outline of the facts on which anv ALLUSIONS TO LOST FACTS. 11 such book, even written by a still living author, is founded : no two men, even though fellow-countrymen and cotemporaries, look at the same facts in exactly the same light, nor does either draw exactly the same inferences as the other would ; and espe- cially, perhaps, is this the case in writings in which the imagina- tion of the poet or orator has a large part, because it is one of the prerogatives of the imagination not to be tied down to literal facts, but to modify, while it employs, these instruments of illustrating universal ideas or laws. It might have, seemed the easiest thing possible to supply the facts assumed in most of Wordsworth's poems, by a simple enough use of the ' higher criticism ; ' but the actual statement of those facts in his lately published Life shows that they were quite different from what any criticism could have suspected.* We must admit of the Hebrew, what Niebuhr asserts of the Greek and Latin, litera- ture, — that though we may be able to see that some facts were present to the writer's mind, it is often no more possible to re- piece them into an historical statement than it is to restore the statues or columns to which we know must have once belonged those marble fragments which we see everywhere built into the walls in modern Rome. We must be content with him to define the true interpretation of an ancient book as ' an expression of its meaning as it was understood, if not by its cotempo- raries, yet by those who lived shortly after, when the passing al- lusions of the moment were lost.'] Nor is it merely lapse of * He presents, as though he had himself witnessed, various occurrences related to him by his sister ; he also says of the Evening Walk, — " The plan of it has not been confined to a particular walk, or an individual place ; a proof (of which T was unconscious at the time) of my unwillingness to submit the poetic spirit to the chains of fact and real circumstance. The country is idealised rather than described in any one of its local aspects." — Memoirs, vol. i. p. 68. Southey supplies us with another illustration : — " In one point I thought him (Sir George Beaumont) too much of an artist ; none of his pictures represented the scene from which he took them ; he took the features, and disposed them in the way which pleased him best. You shall see a little piece of his .... which perfectly illustrates this : the subject, is this very house, and scarcely any one object in the pic- ture resembles the reality. His wish was to give the character, the spirit of the scene " — Life and Correspondence, vol. vi. p. 216. f Letter to a Student of Philology, translated in the Educational Magazine for January, 1840, and since then in his Life and Letters. ]2 HEBREW POLITICS. time which prevents our now recovering all the detail of the facts present to the eyes or minds of Isaiah, or the other prophets. Jeremiah's statement (chap, xxxvi. 2. 4.), that in the fourth year of Jehoiakim he wrote in a book all the words that he had spoken during a period of about twenty years : the fact that the short book of Micah is a summary of his dis- courses delivered during three reigns, as we learn from its title : the existence of like titles and inscriptions throughout the Pro- phetical Books : the explanatory narratives in some of them, and the manner in which these are introduced : the exact rhythmical structure, and elaborate finish of the composition, both of thoughts and language : all show that the writings of the pro- phets, as wre now have them, are not verbal reports of their dis- courses set down before, or at the moment of, delivery, but careful literary compositions, in which these national preachers, at their leisure, and with the deliberate judgment and ability which the books themselves exhibit, put on record what was of permanent interest to their countrymen, and to ail coming ages and peoples. And in doing this they would certainly (like men in the same circumstances now) obliterate, or suffer to become indistinct, references to events which were of absorbing interest at the moment of speaking, but which had given place to others at the time of writing, perhaps many years afterwards, though the eternal and universal truths which those particular events had best illustrated then, continued as important, and as worthy of proclamation as ever.* Nor need we lament that we cannot restore these marks which the prophets have not themselves thought it necessary to retain. They are not only not neces- sary for a right understanding of our authors, but would have been a real hindrance : for they would have inevitably over- laid those universal truths, those clear enunciations of the laws of God's government of the world, which they teach us to see in all history, and especially in our own, and in which — and not in picking out stray historical facts — the real interest of the He- brew prophets for us consists. But if some commentators are * See Ewald, Die Propheten, i. 42. There is a translation of the first two Bcctiona of the Introduction (to which I thus refer) in Kitto's Journal of Sacred Literature, for January, 1853. Let me here acknowledge my many and great obligations to this profound religious philosopher. IMPORTANCE OF SUCH ALLUSION'S. 13 tluis mistaken in their anxiety to invent what they cannot find, others go into the other extreme of indifference to those links between the prophet and his own times which do actually re- main, and are so important in enabling ns to feel that he was a real flesh and blood man : the middle, matter-of-fact course of taking just what we really have given us, is the best, alike for historical and for philosophical and theological purposes. 14 HEBREW POLITICS. CHAPTER II. THE BOOK OF ISAIAH. — ITS TITLE. — DATE OF CHAPTER I. — PROPHETIC IMAGINATION. HEBREW ORATORY RHYTHMICAL. PARALLELS IN OTHER NATIONS. CONTENTS OF CHAPTER I. TIMES OF CZZIAH AND JOTHAM. FORMS AND SPIRIT. NATIONAL BROTHERHOOD. — POLITICAL IDEALS. The book begins with its title : — « The vision of Isaiah, which he saw concerning Judah and Jerusalem in the days of Uzziah, Jotham, Ahaz, and Hezekiah, kings of Judah.' This is at once the title of the whole book, and the title of the chapter of which it forms the first verse : so as to indi- cate that the chapter is an introduction to the book, and a summary of its contents. If we compare it with the similar titles to the books of Amos and Micah, we may see from that comparison that there is no need for the conjecture of Vitringa, adopted by so many of his successors, that it, at first, ended with the word 'Jerusalem,' and belonged only to the single prophecy contained in the first chapter, and that some compiler of the book added the rest of the sentence to make a title for the whole. That the expression, ' concerning Judah and Jeru- salem,' should be thus prefixed to prophecies which relate to Ephraim, Egypt, Assyria, and other neighbouring nations, will not appear a difficulty (if it ever did so), when we bear in mind that the language of the Hebrew, and above all, of the Hebrew prophet, regards the life and force rather than the formal accuracy of its expressions. The highest kind of ac- curacy indeed, that which distinguishes and asserts the real diiferences and relations of things, it has; but it is careless of, or rather unacquainted with, that classical precision of word and inference which all European discourse is more or less imbued with. For the destiny of all these nations did in truth ' concern' Judah and Jerusalem, and only for this reason became the object of Isaiah's consideration. 'Whatever he ISAIAH I. 1. : DATE OF FIRST CHAPTER. 15 utters against the heathen nations, he says it all fur the sake of Judah.' * But while this first prophecy, or discourse, forms a suitable summary and introduction to the whole book, and its actual place is thus sufficiently accounted foi", there seems no reason for doubting that it was delivered on some special occasion. Its date therefore comes in question, and this must be decided according as we take verses 7, 8. to describe the actual state of the country when the words were uttered, or as prophetic of what it would shortly become. If the latter, we could not hesitate to refer it to the earliest period of Isaiah's ministry — the reign of Jotham, — which every other part of the discourse suits perfectly. If the former, it must have been delivered in the reign of Ahaz, before he shut up the temple ; or during the Assyrian invasion in the time of Hezckiah : and the earlier date would be prefer- able, as less opposed to the position in which we find the pro- phecy, though it is not, as some commentators suppose, fixed by the mention of idolatry in verses 29, 30, 31., for we see from chapters xxx. 22., xxxi. 7., that this still co-existed with the worship of the true God, in the reign of Hezekiah, as it had in those of his predecessors. The doubt cannot be decided by the mere grammatical construction of the sentence as it could be in English, since the Hebrew prophets habitually use the liberty which their language permits, of speaking of future events in the present or even past tense. Thus the description of the invading army in chap. v. 26., is in the -past tense in the Hebrew; 'but this,' says Roscnmuller, 'is no reason for doubt- ing that Isaiah is speaking of the future ; for in prophecy the past or present tense is used instead of the future, in order that future events may be contemplated as if present, and may the more strongly stir the mind of the hearer, when they arc set be- fore his eyes by the very form of the discourse.' But the question is, whether, in this particular place, the expressions are those of the poet and prophet picturing the scene as it rises in vision before his imagination, or whether there be something so matter- of-fact in them that they must be taken to describe the horrors of actual invasion, visible at the very time to the bodily eyes of Isaiah and his hearers. There are learned authorities on each side, and they have been marshalled in a special treatise by * Kiinclii in Gesenius. ]6 HEBEEW POLITICS. Caspar?, who decides in favour of the earlier date. If I could perceive the supposed difference between this and the ordinary prophetic style, I should (unless that difference made it impossi- ble) still be decided by the external fact — the actual position of the discourse — to adopt the same conclusion. But while 1 recognise the thoroughly life-like character of the picture, I cannot see that it is more life-like than many which no one denies Isaiah to have drawn in imagination ; nor (if I must argue the a priori point too) can I admit that Isaiah could have been a master of his art, if his imaginative creations could be thus positively distinguished from statements of fact. I shall have occasion to return to this subject of prophecy, considered as a real and intelligible product of the intellectual faculties : here I will observe that I believe the present is only the first instance — and we shall reach the last, but in the last chapter — of that want of thorough apprehension of the phenomenon of prophecy, which is at the bottom of many serious critical errors of the most opposite kinds. The subject is indeed becoming clearer every day ; and the most sceptical commentators have abandoned the notion that no prophecy can be rationally ex- plained except as a description after the event. And if I sit in judgment on much more learned men than myself, when I thus say that the present difficulty exists only in their own minds, it is not without being well aware that but for them I could never have acquired any insight into the subject which I may now be turning against them. Though we do not adopt Vitringa's date (in the reign of Ahaz), we must still agree with him that this discourse is fitly placed here as being the most general in its argument and application, as well as remarkable for its finished and elegant structure, apparently modelled after that great vision of the nation's destinies, the Song of Moses. And, perhaps, this finished and elegant structure may be taken with some pro- priety as itself an indication of the early date of the compo- sition. It is the attribute of youth, and especially of youthful genius, to embody its newly-budding thoughts and feelings in ideals of microcosmic beauty and completeness : but by-and-bye the growing and expanding mind finds these ideals of its own creation too narrow to express the whole truth of things, and YOUTHFUL IDEALS: HEBREW VERSE. 17 abandons them for the larger, though severally less complete, forms, which the various realities of the actual world supply, and then seeks to find in these a new and better ideal, large as the world itself; — an ideal which is revealed to, rather than created by, the human mind ; and the source of which, if we will go so far back, we must look for in that which the Athe- nian philosophers called the eternal truth and beauty of the divine mind, and Hebrew sages the things of the kingdom of God. That the marks of such a first youthful ideal are here conclusively present I do not venture to assert positively, but rather leave the point to the feeling and judgment of the reader; but certainly this short chapter may be taken as a very com- plete summary and specimen of the chief characteristics — moral, political, religious, poetical — of the whole book ; and we may find in it the germs of almost all the great principles which Isaiah announced and applied to practice during the whole period that he exercised the prophetic office. Bishop Lowth has the honour of discovering that the pro- phets wrote in the same e verse, measure, or rhythm,' as the Hebrew poets properly so called ; and we could hardly have a better illustration of the fact than in the chapter before us. The rhythm of thoughts and images which in Hebrew poetry takes the place of the rhythm of syllables and sounds, and enables it alone to be translated into other languages, may here be studied in its several forms: — line answering to line, and word to word ; each bringing out the depth and force of the other, sometimes by variation, sometimes by opposition, some- times by accumulation, of the corresponding or contrasted thoughts ; no thought so like the other as to occasion same- ness, nor so unlike as to make a discord ; no formal adherence to any one rule of parallelism, but a free movement in which the poet's inward sense of beauty and order supersedes all formal rules ; and a blending and fusing of the several parts into a harmony which, with its variety in unity, produces a fulness not attainable in any other way. Thus in the first paragraph : — Hear, O heavens, and give ear, 0 earth ; For the Lord hath spoken. C 18 HEBREW POLITICS. I have nourished and brought up children, And they have rebelled against me. The ox knoweth his owner, And the ass his master's crib : But Israel doth not know, My people doth not consider. In the first line 'heavens' is set against 'earth,' and both united in rhythmical opposition to « the Lord,' the inanimate creation to the living God; while 'hear' and 'give ear' in like manner correspond with each other and with 'spoken.' Then the next six lines are intertwined in a noticeable manner ; for not only is there the double correspondence and double con- trast of the four last lines among themselves, but the two pre- ceding ones (which also balance each other) indirectly involve and anticipate the images of the four that follow : — ' I ' and ' me' corresponding and contrasting with 'owner' and 'mas- ter,' 'nourisher' with 'crib,' and 'brought up' again with 'owner,' and 'children' with 'ox' and 'ass;' and the rebel- lion of the former with the obedience of the latter : and the thoughts are again repeated with a variation and summed up in the two last lines. And, finally, those two lines, with that taste and judgment with -which every true poet (and none more than Isaiah) keeps down his imagination, and subordinates the parts of his diction to the whole, turn back the mind from images to realities, bringing before it the very people of Israel and their sin. Verses 18, 19, 20. supply us with another instance of very beautiful rhythmical construction: — Come, now, and let us reason together, saith the Lord : Though your sins be as scarlet, they shall be white as snow ; Though they be red like crimson, they shall be as wool : If ye be willing and obedient, Ye shall feed on the good of the land ; But if ye refuse and rebel, The sword shall feed on you : For the mouth of the Lord hath spoken it. First the single introductory line ; then two, corresponding as to the lines (yet with the artistic variation in the relative posi- RYTHMICAL ORATORY OF THE HEBREWS. 19 tions of 'white' and the answering 'red'), but with the parts of each line contrasting between themselves ; then four lines, in which the balance is between the alternate lines, with a con- trast of word for word in the first and third, and a play and contrast of words and images (which call up, as in a back ground, the whole picture both of rural plenty and foreign in- vasion) in the second and fourth lines ; and then the single line brings the period to a full close, while it answers to its first line. How elaborately these lines must have been constructed ! What a delicately cultivated and refined sense of beauty in the least as well as the greatest matters of the poet's art do they evince ! And in this, as in every part of the rhythmic art dis- played by Isaiah, there is a soul of poetry inhabiting and ex- pressing itself through this beautiful form. Yet we must repeat, that the prophet — that Isaiah — is not a poet, but a preacher or orator ; his aim is not to de- light, but to teach and persuade men : he is not content that his hearers should unconsciously receive into their hearts the seeds of truth and goodness in the form of beauty, there to take root and grow up, night and day, one knows not how ; but he labours to impart these by direct indoctrination in all its moral methods of reproof, warning, consolation, and instruc- tion. There may be no exaggeration in the assertion that Isaiah possessed poetic genius of the highest order, and had cultivated it with the utmost care ; but it is his servant not his master, and he, the patriot and the man of God, habitually employs it for the purposes of his own proper vocation. Ewald carries out this distinction by printing his translation as prose, observing that, though there is no doubt that the form of the original is as strictly rhythmical as in the poetical books, there are traces in the Hebrew text of these, and none in that of the prophets, that they were originally written verse-wise ; and that the half-poetical style of the Arabs is always written as prose. There is, however, a composite style in Arabic, as in Persian and Sanskrit, in which prose and verse are interchanged at the writer's discretion, in the form in which Lowth prints Chapter vi., and which seems to me to supply a nearer parallel. But if we consider that the Hebrew language retained to the last its primitive simplicity of construction, and never acquired c 2 20 HEBREW POLITICS. those complex developments of grammar which have fitted the classical and modern tongues for elaborate prose composition ; and that for this reason, as well as because Hebrew verse was a rhythm of sense rather than of sound, the main distinction be- tween it and prose must always have been in the tone of thought; — we shall find a truer illustration in the rhythmical oratory of the Greeks at a period when their political culture, indeed, was at a much less advanced stage than that of the Jews in the time of Isaiah, but that of the two languages, as instruments of thought, apparently not so unequal. ' We must recollect,' says Mr. Grote, of this early rhythmical discourse, ' that this was not only the whole poetry, but the whole literature of the age : . . . . and writing, if beginning to be employed as an aid to a few superior men, was at any rate generally unused, and found no reading public. The voice was the only communicant, and the ear the only recipient, of all those ideas and feelings which produc- tive minds in the community found themselves impelled to pour out ; both voice and ear being accustomed to a musical recitation or chant, apparently something between song and speech, with simple rhythm, and a still simpler occasional accompaniment from the primitive four-stringed harp.' And again, — ( Kallinus .... employed the elegiac metre for exhortations of warlike patriotism ; and the more ample remains which we possess of Tyrtteus are sermons in the same strain, preaching to the Spar- tans bravery against the foe, and unanimity as well as obedience to the law at home. They are patriotic effusions, called forth by the circumstances of the time, and sung by single voice, with accompaniment of the flute, to those in whose bosoms the flame of courage was to be kindled. For though what we peruse is verse, we are still in the tide of real and present life, and we must suppose ourselves rather listening to an orator addressing the citizens, when danger or dissension is actually impending.' * The modern Italian improvisatore, too, can utter verse extempore ; and such was the rhythm ofGrattan's first speech in the English House of Commons, that we are told (in Lord Holland's Me- moirs) that ' Mr. Pitt beat time to the artificial but harmonious cadence of his periods.' Even in the actual utterance of their * History of Greece, vol. iv. pp. 100. 110. PARALLELS IN OTHER NATIONS. 21 discourses the Hebrew prophets must have come very near the rhythmical form of their written works : and with whatever mix- ture of simple or even rude prose we suppose them to have spoken, we see that they afterwards recorded the substance of their discourses in literary compositions, which for their careful editing may be better compared with Burke's pamphlets, than with his merely reported speeches; while their eminently poetical thoughts and imagery, as well as diction, may remind us of the free blank verse in which Shakspeare idealises spoken discourse, as contrasted with the more restricted move- ment of Milton or Spenser. And, therefore, as in all trans- lations something of the original must be given up for the sake of what we keep, I incline to think that the rhythmical printing of Lowth and the Paragraph Bible may better represent the original to an English reader than that adopted by Ewald.* Let us turn to the matter of the prophecy. The heavens and earth are constant to the constitution and laws imposed on them by their Creator, and to them does God appeal against a nation who have ceased to believe in any moral * The following passage is to the purpose, whether it supports me or no : " My pamphlet .... was composed as for an oration before an assembly, and flowed straight from my heart, and hence it must be read like a speech. Any one who should read it to himself, or aloud, without modulating his voice, in a uniform tone, like a treatise that is merely concerned with ideas, would probably be as much puzzled with it as the ordinary reader is with Greek orations .... particularly those in Thucydides, before he has learnt to read with the ear Most of our authors do not in the least know and consider, that the old prose writers wrote as if they were speaking to an audience ; whilst among us, prose is invariably written for the eye alone, at least only for the ear in the case of an easy nar- rative. This is why my style is found so strange and unusual, and hence punctuation is so difficult to me, for I ought to have many more signs in order to indicate my exact intentions. In fact, with all that the writer com- poses as if he were speaking, the character of the movement, and the time, ought to be marked, as in music, for the ordinary reader." — Niebuhrs Life and Letters, vol. i. I suspect this is the key to the music of our authorised English Bible and Prayer Book. It also throws light on the elaborate Ma- soretic accentuation, which has undertaken to mark the tone not only of words, but of propositions, and so to preserve 'the sense of the thought, the internal life of the sentence,' in a dead language. See Ewalds Hebrew Grammar, trans, by Nicholson, § 180. fF. c 3 22 HEBREW POLITICS. order or government of the world* : the dullest animals show an attachment to their owner's person, and a recognition of his manner of caring for them, though he keeps them only for his own profit ; but this people disregard and set at nought their filial relation to the Lord, though he has chosen them out from all mankind to be his own children, bestowed on them the peculiar care and love of a father, and by a long education qualified them to understand as well as to enjoy the blessings of this adoption. They have made themselves like those beasts of burden, loading themselves with their iniquities ; so degene- rated are they from their true birthright, that they seem to be evil in their very stock and breed, like the Canaanites and other accursed races f ; — They have forsaken the Lord, They have despised the Holy One of Israel, They are gone away backward. * Lowth here quotes Psalm I. 3, 4., Micah, vi. 1, 2., Deut. xxxii. 1., and Deut xxx 19.; and Gesenius Virgil's 'Esto nunc sol testis, et haec mihi Terra vocanti,1 &c. — 2En. xii. 176. To which may be added the appeal of Prometheus, — 'il S?os alOrjp, Kol TaxvTTepoi wool, iroTan&v re Tr?J7cu, irovTicjov re Kv/xdraiv avripiQfiov ye\acr/u.a, Tra/.tfj.rjTop re yrj, Ka\ rhv irav6irTr]y kvk.\ov tj'Aiou KaAcS. JEsch. Prom. Vinct. 88. And Hamlet's — ' O all ye host of heaven, O earth ! ' All are founded on the same intuitive feeling of the mind, that the works and powers of outward nature are an abiding witness for a settled constitution and order in the universe, however overlooked or defied. So Wordsworth, in his Ode to Duty, — ' Thou dost preserve the stars from wrong, And the most ancient heavens through thee are fresh and strong.' Contrast, too, the pantheistic confusion in the language of the classical parallels, with the clear distinction between the world and its Maker, which is so clear to the Jew, that he does not so much assert as assume it as an axiom impossible to doubt. f Ethnology, while it adds daily to its proofs of the descent of mankind from a single stock, also shows clearly the existence of degenerate races which have long lost even the capacity for the nobler human qualities, re- ligious, political, and intellectual. Whether it be lost beyond redemption is a problem which, in each case, has to be solved by Christianity. No other power even attempts the task. See further, on chapter xiv. 28. ISAIAH I. 2 — 8. : POLICY OF UZZIAH. 23 Therefore punishment comes upon the sinful nation, and punishment severe and repeated enough to rouse it from its ob- stinate rebellion : as it is become thoroughly diseased at heart, it shall suffer outwardly in proportion to its inward insensi- bility ; as there is no soundness, and no desire for soundness within, so shall it sink under the repeated strokes of a foreign invasion which adds fresh wounds to sores already festering, while it longs in vain for a deliverer and a healer. The vision of that woe rises before the prophet's eyes, and he sees all the national fruits of the long and vigorous reigns of Uzziah and Jotham swept away. Uzziah had effectually humbled that old and troublesome enemy of Judah, the Philistines, dismantling their fortified cities, and establishing his own garrisons in their territory : on the opposite side he had reduced the Ammonites to their proper condition of tributaries, from which they had never lost any oj^portunity of revolting since David conquered them : he had recovered the port of Elath on the Red Sea, rebuilt it, and thus, after an interval of about eighty years, restored to Judah an important share in the commerce of the world : and he had strongly fortified Jerusalem, and organised a well armed and disciplined militia, ' that went out to war by bands,' that so the people might not be taken from the cultiva- tion of the land, and other peaceful occupations, except in re- gular turns. And while by these means 'his name spread abroad, even to the entering in of Egypt, for he strengthened himself exceedingly,' he was no less active in availing himself of the profound peace he had secured abroad to encourage com- merce and agriculture at home ; he himself setting an example in the latter which his nobles were not slow to follow : ' he built towers ' for the protection of his flocks ' in the desert ' or commons where they pastured, 'and digged many wells; for he had much cattle, both in the low country and in the plains ; husbandmen also, and vinedressers in the mountains and in Carmel ; for he loved husbandry : ' the reopening of the port of Elath would not merely have enabled his merchant-ships to supply Judah and Jerusalem with the luxuries of Africa and India, but would have made Judaea the direct natural highway of much of the traffic between those countries and Europe, which the Phoenicians carried on by help of trade-caravans, c 4 24 HEBREW POLITICS. and which would previously have taken a different route; and while trade and agriculture thus filled the land with wealth, Egypt supplied them with horses and chariots : and what the reign of Uzziah had begun, that of Jotham, at the end of half a century, was still carrying on. And now the prophet be- holds all overthrown, the cities burned, the cultivated fields and the pastures laid waste, and the whole land devoured, plundered, and ' turned upside down, as is the way in foreign invasions'*, while the inhabitants look on, unable to resist, and Jerusalem itself, the only remaining hope, is threatened with siege. Then, by one of those transitions and combinations with which the imagination can throw a gleam of light and beauty over the darkest and most terrific picture, and yet at the same time even heighten its truth and force, the wasted fields seem to the prophet like the vineyards and cucumber gardens at the end of the fruit season, when they are indeed stripped and trampled, and desolate-looking, yet only because the crops have been gathered in for the benefit of the husbandman : and the sole surviving capital stands there apparently abandoned by its divine watcher and keeper, like the temporary shed which sheltered the keeper of the vineyard or garden as long as its fruits could tempt the jackal and the fox, and was then left as useless, — yet, inasmuch as it is ' like a besieged city,' it is garrisoned as well as beleagured, and hope remains within, though desolation is without. And then the thoughts and images of selfish prosperity and general calamity, of national sins and divine judgments, but of a small remnant saved through and out of all, assume another form, and recall the ancient fate of those cities which were destroyed because the Lord could not find ten righteous men therein : — Except the Lord of hosts had left unto us a small remnant We should have been as Sodom, we should have been like unto Gomorrah. * Grotius quotes — " Impius haec tarn culta novalia miles habebit? Barbaras lias segetes ?" — Virg. Ec. i. 71, 72. " England is become the residence of foreigners and the property of strangers : at the present time there is no Englishman either earl, bishop, or abbot: strangers all, they prey upon the riches and vitals of England; nor is there any hope of a termination of this misery."— William of Malmsbury, ii. 13. ISAIAH I. 9. : THE LORD OP HOSTS. 25 The Lord of hosts, or of armies, is a favourite expression of the Hebrew writers, and especially of Isaiah, Jeremiah, Ze- chariah, and Malachi, by which they recognise Him as the universal governor of heaven and earth, ' who has ordained and constituted the services of men and angels in a wonderful order : ' — ' His state Is kingly ; thousands at his bidding speed And post o'er land and ocean without rest ; They also serve who only stand and wait : ' — and who employs His kingly and almighty power to rule the nations in righteousness, and, as now, both to punish and to save His chosen people. Nor need we be deterred by gram- marians from discovering a like depth and beauty of meaning in the phrase just before — e the Daughter of Zion,' or doubt that to the mind of the prophet and his thoughtful hearers it called up the idea of the nation having been brought up by, set apart for, and by formal covenant united to, the Lord ; called His bride ; and appointed to show forth, in the constitution, and order, and duties, of national society and political life, a new and wider manifestation of those laws of God's relation with, and government of, man, of which marriage was the first type: while the name of Zion would remind them of a city founded upon a rock, and that could not be moved — set upon a hill, and that could not be hid. The sin of Sodom is said (Ezekiel, xvi. 49.) to have been pride, fulness of bread, abundance of idleness, and contempt of the poor and needy ; their land was one of peculiar fertility, and they had given themselves up to a mere life of nature, till they wallowed in all the worst sins that break out from such a life. National institutions are the proper jneans of preserving a people from, or raising them out of naturalism ; but the prophet protests that his countx-ymen were sunk in it, notwith- standing their national polity, and their strict maintenance of its forms. Though the blasted and submerged site of the cities of old was a perpetual witness to the Jews of God's wrath against this sensualism — a witness abiding from generation to o-eneration in the very midst of them — yet they were as reck- less of God's meaning in this thing as the Italians always seem 26 HEBREW TOLITICS. to have been regarding the like destruction of Herculaneura and Pompeii. The prophet kindling at the thought of his own comparison, and feeling how just a one it is, calls on those men — rulers and people — who, though professing to administer and obey the law of the Lord, were in heart no better than the men of Sodom and Gomorrah, to hear what the law of the Lord is in spirit and in truth. They still maintain all the external forms of religion according to the established ecclesiastical ritual, but no inward faith quickens them. This has ever been the great abuse of religious forms in all nations and times. Forms there must be ; they are a real, vital, part of religion, as the body is a real part of the man : but when they lose their life they become as worthless and corrupt as a dead body. To preserve this life is the difficult task : it must be fed direct from heaven through a channel which can only be kept open as long, and as far, as man consents that his spirit should be raised above the routine of nature and the world. And this elevation is so irksome to our nature, it is so much pleasanter that morality and religion should go on, like digestion, by the unconscious working of a mechanical organisation, that men are alwaj's yielding to the delusion that the thing can be accomplished, — from the African or the Buddhist, who multiply their prayers by help of a rotary calibash or drum, to the priest of Rome, who 'makes God' with robings, and genuflexions, and unintelligible utterances, and the elevation of a wafer, or the Protestant divine with his ' Letter of Scripture,' and his Articles which are to fasten truth, like an idol, ' with nails so that it shall not be moved,' and to establish a ' doctrine and discipline from which he will not endure any varying or departing in the least degree.' Therefore Isaiah protests in God's name that the Law is not in the forms but in the meaning of them : sacrifices of bullocks and goats are worthless if they arc not the symbols of an actual though inward sacrifice of that fleshly will which is separating the worshipper from God's spiritual presence : the multitudes who throng the courts of the temple, and think they are keeping the command to 'appear before the Lord,' though their hearts are far away, are but treading that command under their feet (as the Hebrew word ISAIAH I. 10—27. : NATIONAL BROTHERHOOD. 27 implies) : oblations which express no sincere thankfulness are vain : incense with which no prayer of the heart ascends is an abomination : sabbaths and feasts do but mock God when they are kept by men who are grinding the faces of the poor Avith unremitted and unrewarded work : the great yearly assemblies are worse than idle types of national brotherhood in the midst of universal and habitual oppression and misery. And such a national worship and obedience to the law as this, will obtain nothing from the Lord in the day of calamity : men may lift up their hands in prayer, but in vain, while those hands have been so long and deeply stained with blood ; they must wash them thoroughly (still alluding to the ecclesiastical ritual), by ceasing to do evil, and learning to do well; they must Seek justice, relieve the oppressed, Right the fatherless, plead for the widow. If they will so reform, and return to true obedience to their King and their God, He will himself wash them thoroughly from all their iniquity, though it be more deeply ingrained than the power of man can reach. The word which our Bible translates reason, means also ylead or argue in a court of justice, as it does in Job, xxiii. 7., and Micah, vi. 2. The con- text shows that both ideas must be included; for while the whole tone of this prophecy is judicial, arraigning the unjust and iniquitous rulei's of the Jewish nation before the judgment- seat of their invisible King, the reformation, which is the end of judgment, is never lost sight of, the fatherly character of the Judge is always present, and He reasons with the culprit, and is willing to be reasoned with. For He remembers His covenant, and is not a God of mere power and wrath, nay, not even of mere unbending law, but a living Lord of righteousness and love, resolved indeed to maintain absolutely and without in- fringement His own holiness, and justice, and truth, yet desiring that the most disobedient should still depart from his sin, and return and live again under His holy constitution and govern- ment, and enjoy the blessings of so doing, loving God, and knowing that God loves him : therefore, in the midst of all these threatenings, God appeals to the people themselves whe- ther He is not reasonable in His conduct towards them. Thus 28 HEBREW POLITICS. the word is at once expressive of the deepest truth and meaning, and in accordance with the actual practice of the Hebrew in- stitutions, which preserved much of their patriarchal character, as all Eastern nations do to this day, even when most corrupt. ' The faithful city is become a harlot' : — Jerusalem, the daughter of Zion, the wife of the Holy One of Israel, has broken the bond of her covenant with Him, has set at nought the divine constitution and order in which He originally placed, and has continued to sustain, her : and, as the outward consequence and sign of this spiritual defection, has actually fallen to the worship of other Gods. Throughout this prophecy Isaiah dwells chiefly on the sins of the princes and rulers of the nation, and only incidentally on those of the people ; and ac- cordingly, he now dilates on the characteristic vices of the former, which are the fruits of their national unfaithfulness. Social and political morality have vanished along with religious faith ; thieves and murderers are found instead of virtuous citizens* ; the nobles and men in authority are the first to break the laws they should enforce; the administration of justice is so corrupt that the judges take bribes, connive at the robbers whose booty they share, and permit the rich man to pervert the law for the oppression of the fatherless and the widow, who have no patrons to demand, and no money to buy, justice: and thus the aristocracy, setting aside all belief that they hold their wealth and power in trust from God, for the benefit of the people under them, do but employ these as irresistible engines for breaking down all rights that can oppose them in their pursuit of luxmy and vice. Therefore will the mighty Lord of the nation put forth his strength, and purge out these iniqui- ties, destroying those who have defied and renounced Him, and by means of this severe discipline restoring the nation to its former and true character of a people faithful to God, and dealing uprightly with each other. ' Zion shall be redeemed,' through this execution of judgment, and her restored and re- formed children shall dwell within her walls in righteousness. ' Converts' is a cognate word to that in chapter x. 21. It may be asked, At what former period of Jewish history * The word 'lodging' is suggested by the image of a populous city; ' silver' by its wealth ; ' wine' by its luxury. POLITICAL IDEALS. 29 did the nation deserve that character for faith and righteous- ness which Isaiah ascribes to it ' at the beginning ? ' and at what subsequent time was it restored to the condition which he pro- mises 'afterwards?' I must reply, — not by pointing back to the days of Moses or Samuel, or David, or Solomon, nor forward to those of Hezekiah, Josiah, or the Maccabees ; for it could be shown that the men who lived at each of those times were ready to cry out against their special corruption, — but by refer- ence to that universal habit of men's minds to suppose a past and hope for a future, realisation in actual life, of their ideals of human perfection. Few men, in any time or country, have that power of metaphysical abstraction which can enable them to contemplate ideals as such ; and even they, when they de- scend to practical life, and the practical instruction of the men around them, find it necessary to translate their ideas into the popular language. The oppressed Saxon prayed for the re- storation, by his Norman tyrant, of the laws of Edward, though it would have been difficult for him to prove the personal merits of that king as a legislator or ruler ; the Long Par- liament based all its demands on the ancient rights of the Commons ; the French and English Republicans of the last century referred to an original social contract ; and in our own day the Church of the first centuries and the chivalry of the middle ages, supply to considerable classes a local habitation and name for their ideals of life, though it would not be easily shown that there ever was an adequate historical realisation of any one of them. We all feel indeed that there is a fact no less than a truth recognised in such language, both as to the past and the future. There is a continual progress in the world, and every step of it is gained by the triumph of some good over some evil, and consequently by some realisation in fact of what, till it had so triumphed, could only assert itself in idea. Thus the new is always the restoration of the old, and the old the promise of the new, and the whole ideal of time is in light, though the particular moment as it passes is marked by shadow. It will become increasingly apparent as we go on, how important an element of the prophetic character and office this belief and promise of the realisation of a perfect commonwealth was, and in what relation it stands to the search or longing for such a 30 HEBREW POLITICS. society by the philosophers and philanthropists of other nations and times. But to return to the detail of the text before us. In the judgments and the restoration which the prophet foretells, he declares that the people shall learn the worthlessness of the idols which they have been worshipping under the oak trees, and in the sacred groves. The worship of the ' high places ' seems to have been partly an adoption of the actual idolatry of the neighbouring nations, and partly (2 Chron. xxxiii. 17.) a remains of that local worship of the true God, which in some of its forms at least (for the obscurity of the subject has been already noticed) seems to have become irregular and blameable when one central sanctuary had been established for the whole people : experience proved that neither pure faith and wor- ship, nor national unity, could be preserved but by the para- mount— perhaps the sole — recognition of that sanctuary as the one house and altar of God ; and when they fell away from this, their religion became a religion of nature and not of faith, of isolated individuals and not of a church. That this false worship was going on in Judrea during the reigns of Uzziah and Jotham> at the same time with the temple services, appears from 2 Kings, xv. 3, 4., compared with 2 Chron. xxvii. 2.* In that day the prophet foretells that these men who have been flourishing in their sin, like the oaks, and living in pleasures like those of a well- watered garden, shall find that their idols have no power to save them from a destruction which shall make them ' as an oak whose leaf fadeth, and as a garden that hath no water,' — images which will be the more forcible if we remember that in a southern climate, trees fade rather from excessive heat than from seasonable cold, and a garden without water is a mere de- sert of sand. Then shall the strong, the mighty, and the unjust ruler become tow, and his idols, the work of his hands, a spark; they shall both burn together, and no man shall quench them. In verse 29, is an instance of what seemed to Lowth's classical taste a corrupt reading : ' They shall be ashamed of the oaks which ye have desired.' But this variation of the persons of * For allusions to the subject at other times, see Deut. xvi. 21., 1 Kings, xiv. 23., 2 Kings, xvi. 4., 2 Chron. xxviii. 4., Ezekiel, vi. 13. LANGUAGE A KEY TO NATIONAL CHARACTER. 31 the verb is not unusual in Hebrew, and certainly no cor- ruption. Nay if we look at Psalm xci., which is very artisti- cally constructed, we shall see reason to think that what jars so harshly on a classically trained ear was a beauty to the Hebrew poets. I dwell the more upon these peculiarities of idiom and composition, because I believe that we cannot understand the higher and deeper meaning of Isaiah, any more than we can of Shakspeare, iinless our minds are emancipated from servile ad- herence to classical rules. Each language and literature has its own laws, and these are derived from and connected with a dis- tinctive national mind, which expresses itself in its own way through the great writers of each nation : and thus language be- comes a key to national character. 32 HEBREW POLITICS. CHAPTER III. ISAIAH, II. III. IV. HEBREW GENIUS IMAGINATIVE RATHER THAN LOGICAL. PRETERITE AND FUTURE TENSES IN HEBREW. THE LAST DATS. CON- TRAST OF THE IDEAL AND ACTUAL STATE OF THE NATION. FOREIGN INFLUENCES. PRIVATE IDOLATRY. POLITICAL MATERIALISM. — NATIONAL DECAY. — LAWS OF GOd's GOVERNMENT OF THE WORLD. — GOOD AND EVIL OF COMMERCE. HEBREW MATRONS. FEMALE LUXURY ITS PUNISH- MENT. THE BRANCH OF THE LORD. THE RESTORED THOUGH HUMBLED NATION. The next discourse, consisting of chapters ii. iii. iv., is en- titled, ' The Word that Isaiah the son of Amos saw concerning Judah and Jerusalem.' The propriety of applying the phrase * saw'* to * the Word'' is apparent, if we refer ourselves to the mental process which takes place in meditating upon any important truth, especially while the vividness of the first dis- covery lasts ; and still more is it obvious, as we read the dis- course itself, and look for ourselves at its various pictures of military power, maritime commerce, wealth, luxury, pride, sel- fishness, and irreligion. No arguments need be added to prove that the prophecy de- picts the state of society in the period between the latter end of the reign of Uzziah, and the beginning of that of Ahaz. The opening paragraph — a passage of aphoristic complete- ness and beauty, and here serving as a text to the subsequent discourse — is found also, with a few verbal alterations, in Isaiah's cotemporary, Micah (chap. iv. 1 — 3.). Conjecture has variously attributed it to each of these prophets, and to some older one, copied by both : the last seems the most probable supposition. If we keep the verbs in the tenses which they have in the Hebrew, the passage will stand thus : — And it hath come to pass in the last days, That the mountain of the Loud's house shall be established at the head of the mountains, ISAIAH II. 1 — 4.: HEBREW PAST AND FUTURE 33 And exalted above the hills ; And all nations have flowed unto it. And many peoples have gone and said, Come ye, and we will go up to the mountain of the Lord, To the house of the God of Jacob; And He will teach us of his ways, and we will walk in his paths : For out of Zion shall go forth the law, And the word of the Lord from Jerusalem. And he hath judged between the nations, And hath arbitrated for many peoples : And they have beat their swords into ploughshares, And their spears into pruninghooks : Nation shall not lift up sword against nation, Neither shall they learn war any more. This — at first sight and to our notions — singular use of the tenses is thoroughly discussed by the grammarians ; yet in their translations even Gesenius and Ewald obliterate all traces of it, usually substituting the present for both past and future. If the German idiom peremptorily requires this, Professor Alexan- der has shown, in his notes on the latter chapters of Isaiah, that no such entire sacrifice is demanded by the English ; but that very frequently an adherence to the original distinction of tenses gives a beauty as well as force to the passage, which leaves little doubt that we shall one day see it naturalized to a great extent in our English Bibles. The explanation of the Hebrew usage, in as far as this is the place for considering it, is clearly that the structure of such a passage as that before us is imaginative, not logical — a picture, not a statement. The speaker completely projects himself into ' the last days ; ' he is there, he finds them come ; he looks about him to see what is actually in process, and sees that the mountain of the Lord's house is about to be — still in process of being — established at the head of the mountains ; he looks again, and the nations have already arrived at the place prepared for them, yet so freshly that they are still calling one another on ; and as they come up they find that the King they seek is already there, and has effected some of his arbitrations and decisions before they arrive for their turn. So thoroughly does this imaginativeness pervade the language not only of the prophets but of the historians, so habitually has D 34 HEBREW POLITICS. the imaginative and not (as with us) the logical faculty dictated the laws of Hebrew grammar, that the form • and it hath come to pass' in the first line, 'refers always to a future event;' while that of * shall be' in the second, is usually equivalent to the iysvsro of historical narration.* There seems indeed a spe- cial idiom as to this verb: and the subject is still more clearly explained in the general rule ' that in continued narrations of the past, only the first verb stands in the preterite, the others being in the future form ; and on the contrary, in continued descriptions of the future, the first verb is in the future, while the rest are in the preterite form. Thus in Genesis i. 1.: — In the beginning God created (pret) the heavens and the earth: And God will sag (fut.) 'Let there he light, and there will be (fut.) light : And God trill see, 8fc. And just the reverse in Isaiah vii. 17. ff. : — Jehovah trill bring (fut.) upon thee a?id upon thy people, dags such as have not come since, §c. And it hath (pret.) happened on that dag . . . And they have (pret.) corned 'f In both these examples the speaker evidently places himself in the midst of the events themselves, describing the past creation as it would have been seen by that eye that ' was there or ever the earth was, while as yet He had not made the land nor the fields 't, and picturing the future as Ahaz would realise it after it had become the past. Nor is it only in the Hebrew language and its grammar, that this characteristic appeal's : it pervades the whole genius of the nation, the structure and growth of their laws and institutions, and the acts and habits of their legislators and statesmen, as well as the writings of their poets and historians : they are ' of imagination all compact;' a very 'nation of prophets;' the future is their goal, and their appointed rest, to which they press forward as travellers through the mere actual and present. It may be difficult for an Englishman, or German, in our nine- teenth century, to realise this state and habit of mind ; but it is a difficulty somewhat analogous to that which we find in realising the state of mind which produced the Greek mytho- * Gesenius, Lexicon, word H*Pt. ■j" Gesenius, Grammar, § 48 b. English edition of Bagster, 1852. } Proverbs, viii. 22—30. The whole passage bears on this point in a noticeable manner. ANCIENT AND MODERN HABITS OF MIND. 35 logy *, and which also, in another way, was so highly imaginative, that in the present stage of the human race, and the now pre- dominating development of the reasoning faculties, we have no corresponding inward experience. Yet the faculty of imagina- tion still exists in us ; and if we carefully study its character and workings in our own minds, and in the writings of the poets of our own, and of other times ; if we meditate upon the distinctive features of the Hebrew mind, literature, language, and institutions, in their action and reaction upon each other, and as they correspond with, or differ from those of other na- tions ; if we consider that there is a growth (with its consequent losses as well as gains) of the human race, no less than of its several families and individual men f ; if, lastly, we believe that * " But how can we arrive at an idea of its (the Mythus) real nature and import ? Such an idea cannot be attained a priori, as we have it only from experience; neither is it immediately, and of itself, intelligible, being utterly unknown as a product of our times. It is a purely historical idea ; an idea, moreover, by which a creation of very remote times is to be conceived. It cannot possibly be arrived at otherwise than historically. But how is its historical perception possible, the mythus itself being the only source of the idea of the mythus, and appearing, too, in a form different from its contents ? In the statement of an historical fact the form and the contents correspond ; an acquaintance with the language forms the bridge which leads from one to the other. But here they lie further apart, and the path must first be sought, is itself a problem. In other words, mythi must be interpreted, must be explained, ere we can attain a knowledge of their contents. This must be done in a thousand individual instances ere we shall be able to seize the essence of the mythus as a generic idea. And then the question still remains, whether we can express the knowledge thus attained by an idea such as passes current amongst us, or by a simple combination of such ideas ; whether we do not find something compounded, according to our notions, of multifarious, widely separated, and heterogeneous materials, the union of which is based on a mode of thinking entirely different from ours." Miillers Scientific Mythology, translated by Leitch, p. 6. •f" Mythology has supplied us with one instance, Language furnishes another. "It may be observed as a general fact," says Dr. Pritchard, "that Lan- guages appear to have become more permanent as we come down towards later times. During the last ten, or perhaps the last fifteen centuries, they have undergone few alterations except through the effect of conquest, or the intermixture of nations. The Bretons .... are still easily intelligible to the natives of Wales. . . . The Scots who emigrated from the north of Ire- land to Argvleshire can still converse with the natives of Ireland. Languages, by intermixture of nations, become disintegrated; they lose part D 2 36 HEBKEW POLITICS. these characteristics of the Hebrew mind were providentially so heightened, adapted, and directed by the influence of political institutions, and local and historical circumstances, as that men chosen out of this nation might, without any violent, arbitrary, or in any way monstrous, subversion of their human nature and faculties, be made the fit instruments of God's revelation of Himself to men : — then we shall perhaps find that there is a rational and intelligible idea of prophecy attainable by us; and that in proportion as we realise it, it will make clear the dark and difficult places in the prophetical Scriptures, and deliver us from the fear of having to choose between interpretations fairly obnoxious to the charge of introducing the doctrines of superstition, and even magic, into religion, and those of a sceptical criticism, which is often as regardless of historical and literal fact as of true philosophy and Christian faith. Isaiah then, ' rapt into future times,' sees the throne of the Lord of Israel established in sovereignty over all the nations of the earth, and they becoming willing subjects to Him, and friendly fellow citizens to each other. The nations attain to true liberty, for they come to submit themselves to the righteous laws and institutions, and to the wise and gracious word and direction, of that King whose service is perfect freedom ; and to true brotherhood, for they leave their old enmities and conflicts, and make the same Lord is their judge, and umpire, and reconciler. And all this, not by some newly invented device of the nations, of their grammatical modifications. ... In the mean time no new forms of human speech are produced : no new varieties of inflection expressive of the modification of ideas by changes in the endings or the initial syllables of words are ever attempted ; particles and auxiliaries are inserted to supply the want of obsolete inflections. Formations of language and the develop- ment of grammatical systems have long ceased. As in geology, we now only witness the disintegration of what the first ages produced. How different was the habit of the human mind with regard to language in the age when the Sanskrit, the Greek, the Latin, and the Msso- Gothic, idioms were de- veloped from one common original!" — Researches into the Physical Hist, of Mankind, ii. 221, 222. The whole paragraph is most interesting, as show- ing man's original powers of language-making, and their gradual cessation. The practice of sacrifice by all the nations of antiquity, with its aban- donment by those of Christendom, as also by the Mahometans, is another of the changes in hind, and not merely in degree, of a large part of the human race. In such facts as these, the student of a constructive historical phi- isaiah ir. 5 — 9.: true and false philanthropy. 37 some new result of their own civilisation, but by the carrying out of the old original purpose and plan of God, that His chosen people of the Jews should be the ministers of these good things, and that in them should all nations of the earth be blessed, — that 'out of Zion should go forth the law, and the word of the Lord from Jerusalem.' This is the vocation of the Hebrew people. This, says the prophet, is the key to all our duties as a nation, this is the master-light to guide us to right action : — ' O house of Israel, come ye, and let us walk in the light of the Lord.' The appeal is in vain. The house of Israel is, indeed, willing enough for, and is already practising, a universal brotherhood of nations, but quite of another fashion from this. They have filled themselves to repletion with the idolatries and divinations of the Syrians, Chaldasans, and Philistines ; and on every side have joined themselves to the heathens by marriages, political alliances, commercial intercourse, and adoption of religious rites. Juventutem studiis externis degenerare, was the complaint of the Romans who were still faithful to the ancient discipline, in the time of Nero * ; and even in our own Christian times, and among Christian nations, these are great causes of na- tional deterioration : and Moses and the prophets are proved by the result to have judged rightly, that nothing but the strict exclusion of such foreign influences could preserve the moral, political, and religious nationality of their country. I would urge the thoughtful consideration of these verses (2 — 9.) on any one who is perplexed by the confident assertion of writers who prefer vague declamation to close investigation and reasoning, that the Hebrew prophets were actuated by a bitter hatred of foreigners. He will, I think, discover (from this and such like study) that they were possessed by views and hopes of a phi- lanthropy which even our own times have not been able to ex- tend : they yearned for fellowship with all men, under the only conditions in which fellowship is possible : they longed for an universal communion of virtue, humanity, and goodness, and losophy patiently seeks the key to many a difficulty in Jewish as well as other ancient history, which the merely destructive critic gets rid of by a re- ference to the standard of his own times and country. * Tacit. Ann. xiv. 20. quoted by Vitringa. d 3 38 HEBREW POLITICS. could not be content to have a general licence of vice, brutality, and wickedness instead; and they advocated what they saw, and what all history has proved, to be the only way of avoiding the one and securing the other. For the like reasons Moses had forbidden, and Isaiah here proceeds (no doubt with a reference to the law of Moses) to censure, the accumulation of wealth, and the multiplying horses and chariots. The nation had come to the state from which Moses would have kept it back if possible : it was rich, luxu- rious, and put its trust in the physical force of its standing army, and meanwhile had forgotten its divine King, and the covenant between them. And therefore the land had become ( full of idols.' It has been noticed that these were doubtless worshipped in many groves and high places during the reigns of Uzziah and Jotham, though these kings formally upheld the national worship of the true God ; but we may (with Vitringa) especially refer this passage to the Teraphim, the Penates or Lares 'which they made each one for himself to worship,' and to divine with, in their own houses ; — a species of idolatry which from the earliest times is found among those who yet professed the worship of the Lord. The whole ecclesiastical scheme of the Hebrew polity tended to elevate the members of the nation out of a selfish state, and bring them to a consciousness of the dignity and virtue of being ' members one of another;' Avhile the effect of this private superstition, which had filled the land with idols, must have been the exact contrary. So many gods, so many centres of social attraction and repulsion. A state of things in which every man has his own god in his own house, is mere naturalism, Shammanism, or Fetish-worship, and engenders the horde-life, into which family or patriarchal life sinks, if not comprehended in and upheld by national institutions, and espe- cially a national worship. The bond of political society in Greece, or in Home, was the national recognition of Apollo or Pallas, Jupiter or Mars. And if faith was thus potent as long as it remained sincere, though its objects were imaginary, not less was it necessary to the people whose God was the Lord. But since they have forsaken Him, in the office to which He had appointed them among the nations, the prophet declares that the Loud too hath forsaken them, and will not forgive them. ISAIAH II. 10—22.: DAYS OF JUDGMENT 39 The Lord hath forsaken them as their father and friend, but He comes to call them to account as their judge. Men of every rank, high and low, have been humbling themselves every- where before their idols ; they shall now be compelled to bow down before the Lord, for all their haughtiness. The day of the Lord of Hosts is at hand; — that crisis or ' day of judg- ment,' in which He who upholds and directs the universe and its inhabitants by righteous laws and administration, executes on the impenitent breakers of those laws the sentence which He has pronounced against them. The Flood, the destruction of Sodom, the invasion of Judaea in the reigns of Ahaz and Heze- kiah, the taking of Jerusalem by Nebuchadnezzar or by Titus, and the like national crises in ancient and in modern history, are all ' Days of the Lord,' in which He comes to judge the earth; and partial anticipations of the last judgment of the world. Their wealth and rank shall not save them: though they tower above their fellows, as the cedars of Lebanon and the oaks of Basan (of which they build their palaces) tower above the common shrubs ; though they stand like their native mountains, and like the fortifications which they have added to those mountains in defiance of all invaders ; though they are prepared to resist the storms of fortune like the great merchant ships by which they have amassed their wealth, and though their dissolute idol- worship sanctions all the sensual luxury of their life * ; yet all shall be brought down to the dust. They shall vainly seek to escape, as unarmed peasants or women fly into the nearest cave or hole when they hear the hoofs of some plundering tribe of Edom or Ishmael from the desert : but the judgment of the Lord shall reach them, as the earthquake (then, as now, not uncommon in Judaea) would bring down the rock on him who sought refuge in it. And as such fugitives carry in their hands their most precious goods, but are glad in their extremity to abandon these to the moles and bats of the caves, that they may more freely use their hands in clambering * This seems the best explanation of ' images of desire.' Compare chap- ters i. 29., xliv. 9. with Genesis, iii. 6. ; Levit. xxvi. 1.; Numb, xxxiii. 52. The phrase ' ships of Tarshish' (Tartessus in Spain), applied to merchant- ships which could only have traded in the south, is exactly like our usage of ' China cups,' ' Japan trays,' &c. d 4 40 HEBREW POLITICS. into the safest recesses, so the idolatrous nation shall be obliged to abandon its false gods. Such is man, when his trust is in idols, and when the Lord is not upholding, but opposing, him. The prophet now proceeds to tell, in literal and detailed lan- guage, of the national calamities he has just before described metaphorically ; and to declare the worthlessness of man's po- litical devices to stay the ruin. At the time Isaiah spoke, the nation, and its capital city and seat of government, might seem to the worldly-wise too firmly established to fear the wrath, or need the help, of a God, whom they had forgotten as a dream among the realities of life. The fortified frontiers and the standing army might not have been tested for some time, but doubtless they were as invincible as in the days of the great Uzziah ; and Judah's power was not merely in its army, but still more in its civilisation, in its system of laws, its reli- gious and political culture, its statesmen versed in affairs, its feudal aristocracy, its ranks and dignities, its manufacturing skill and industry, and its eloquent oratory. How could such a state be in any danger? So argued the shrewd man of the world in Isaiah's day, just as he still does in our own. He could not see that the soldiers were a set of machines incapable of standing against an invasion of men full of fierce life; that the law was so administered as to be an engine of oppression instead of justice; that the prophets, the teachers of the people, em- ployed their gifts and opportunities of teaching — just as the orators and advocates did theirs — to prove good to be evil and evil good, to justify prosperous wickedness, and to undermine all faith in moral and political righteousness. But Isaiah foresees that a slight irregularity in the working of this vast machinery of imposture will throw the whole into confusion. It may hold together for the life of the present king (though even his ma- tured state-craft had no doubt done more than it could hope to do again), but the life and death of rulers are among the events which God retains in His own power ; and when the weak and worthless boy Ahaz sits on the throne of his fathers — when God gives a child to be their prince and a babe to rule over them, it will be seen what their boasted order of society is worth.* The sovereign authority having fallen into powerless * "Fire and slaughter raged on all sides. The country [Normandy during ISAIAH III. 1 — 15.: ETERNAL LAWS OF JUSTICE. 41 hands, there will be nothing to restrain the strong man from exercising his pleasure against his weaker neighbour, and espe- cially nothing to restrain the refuse of society from rising against the refined classes. Foreign invasion shall take advantage of this internal disorder, and the heads of tribes and families, the centres of Jewish political life, being killed, or carried into cap- tivity, there will be a general dissolution of society ; and when, under the sense of this calamity a man shall try and restore order and unity by calling on his elder brother — on whom de- volve the rights and duties of the absent father — to take up his position as that father's l'epresentative, and to become a ' healer ' of the ' ruin,' then will he refuse with the selfishness of despair, declaring that the ruin is too great to be repaired, and that he himself is too much sunk under it even to make the attempt.* How the men who heard these words of Isaiah experienced their truth a few years after, we learn from 2 Chron. xxviii., xxix. 6 — 9. Again were these judgments executed on arepetition of the offences in the reign of Manasseh ; and again far more heavily in the days of Jeremiah, whose Prophecy and Lamentations de- scribe the famine ; the loss of all who could have given aid by vision, counsel, or the sword ; the imbecility of the king, who dared not rule according to the dictates of his own conscience or judgment, but himself avowed that 'the king was not he who could do anything against ' the people about him ; the tyranny of the great men during these calamities ; and the general de- pravity and dissolution of all moral and political order. If we compare the prophecy and history of the one period with those of the other, and both with like periods in the history of other nations (as, for instance, before the French or English Revolu- tions), we shall see clearly how the prophets announced the eternal and immutable laws of God's government of the world, to be again and again brought into operation, and accomplished, In the events of successive ages. the minority of William the Conqueror], formerly most flourishing, was now- torn with intestine broils, and divided at the pleasure of the plunderers ; so that it was justly entitled to proclaim, ' Woe to the land whose sovereign is a child.'" — William of Malmsbur i/, iii. * Compare the corresponding state of the kingdom of Samaria, at the period ; Isaiah, ix. 17 — 20. ; Hosea, vii. 1 — 7. 42 HEBREW POLITICS. The prophet will not for a moment lose sight of the moral character of these national calamities ; each fresh prediction of them is followed by the declaration that they are ' the fruit of their doings,' ' the reward of their hands : ' — Jerusalem is ruined, and Judah is fallen, Because their tongue and their doings are against the Lord, To provoke the eyes of His glory ; The show of their countenance is against them ; And they declare their sin as Sodom, they hide it not. The selfish aristocracy have abandoned all their proper — patriarchal and paternal — duties to their people, for the one business of wringing from them the means of unbounded luxury. This was a consequence of the commercial spirit entirely ab- sorbing the aristocratic or patriarchal element which ought to have limited and purified it. Commerce is perhaps one of the most dangerous, as well as one of the most important, of na- tional developments. Its good is as real as its evil; it is, in many obvious respects, a far better source and occasion for national and international activity than its only substitute, war : but the thoughtful student of history and politics does not need to be told that even war has sometimes proved more humanising than commerce; and still less, that the latter as certainly as the former turns to mere corruption and political degeneracy, if it be not duly balanced by other elements of national life.* And if modern philosophy is right in considering that each of the nations of antiquity was fitted to exhibit the separate working of one or two of the more elementary laws of politics, but not to afford a field for those vast and complicated * "The philosophical thinkers on politics," says Mr. Grote, "conceived (and to a great degree justly, as I shall show hereafter), that the conditions of security in the ancient world imposed upon the citizens generally the abso- lute necessity of keeping up a military spirit and willingness to brave at all times personal hardship and discomfort; so that increase of wealth, on ac- count of the habits of self-indulgence which it commonly introduces, was regarded by them with more or less of disfavour." — History of Greece, iii. 151. And again : — " There was a considerable body of ancient sentiment, and that, toe, among high-minded and intelligent men, which regarded gold and silver as a cause of mischief and corruption, and of which the stanza of Horace (Od. in. iii. 49.) is an echo — ' Aurum irrepcrtum,' &c." — Ibid. ix. 320. ISAIAH III. 16 — 26.: LUXURY OF THE HEBREW LADIES. 43 problems which modern societies have to solve, then was Moses right in making laws to discourage the money-making spirit and practice of which the results would be such as Isaiah here denounces ; results quite preclusive of the effectual development of that idea which it was the very end of the existence of the Hebrew polity to develope. Connected with the grasping, money-loving spirit of the great and rich men, is that of pampered luxury in the women. The nobleman has substituted mere greedy blood-sucking with the forms of law for a kind paternal care and guidance of his dependants ; and the lady has turned that feminine delicacy and gentleness which she should have employed in refining and humanising the relations of domestic life, and thence spreading its influence throughout society, into haughty exclusiveness and a love of dress and luxury, gradually degenerating to sensuality and licentiousness. It always seems to me that Isaiah marks the fact of the social importance of the Hebrew Avomen (which we otherwise know to have been so much more like that of the Roman than the Greek matron), and his own mournful though indignant sense of what high dignity and duty they had abandoned, in the prominence which he gives to the subject, by the elaborate de- scription of the luxury of the daughters of Zion. How graphic he is ! We see before us the Jewish ladies, ' walking and mincing as they go,' with haughtily tossed head, and wanton eyes, and hear the tinkling of the mimic fetters of gold with which their ankles are encircled : they wear the fine white linen of Egypt, and their long robes are rich with embroidery ; the turban shows its wearer's taste, or the open network the beauty of her hair; the large veil, the ancient dress of the modest Hebrew woman of every rank, is now adjusted in the bold fashion of the day, or superseded by the lighter mantilla of lace or gauze thrown so gracefully over the head and shoulders; each fair face glistens with ear-drops and nose-jewels ; from the chains about each slender neck hang the ornamental crescent, the amulet with its magical characters graven on the gem, the little mirror, or the scent-box ; or we notice another capricious fashion, where a purse is fastened to the broad girdle of silk embroidered with gold, and the mirror is carried in a hand 44 HEBREW POLITICS. loaded with bracelets and rings. We turn to look again, and the squalid filth and disease of poverty and the prison are before us : — Instead of perfume there is stench ; And instead of a girdle, a rent ; And instead of well-set hair, baldness ; And instead of a stomacher, a girding of sackcloth ; And branding instead of beauty. The prophet seems to answer (in verse 25.) the incredulous question, How can this ever be ; what danger is there of its befalling us ? As though he had said, You are living in utter wordliness and selfishness, in the neglect of all relationships, and you shall feel what it is to be stripped of them all, by your husbands, fathers, sons, and brothers falling in battle; — that you may know what you are out of the order in which God has placed you, and which you have renounced. When your fore- heads are scarred by the slave-master's brand, when your rich apparel has but insured its stripping by your ruthless captors, and when the sun beats on your heads, and you sink with hunger, thirst, weariness, and degradation, while driven naked and like herds of cattle in the train of the conquerors who have laid waste your homes, — then you shall know that it is the Lord who ' hath smitten the crown of the head of the daughters of Zion, and discovered their shame.' Then he turns abruptly from the daughters, to the Daughter, of Zion, gathering them together in their proper representative, the licentious and rebellious nation, the faithless bride of the Holy One of Israel. He employs no arguments to prove the connection between the selfish luxury of the women and the decay of public virtue : their consciences cannot deny that their sin is both a cause and an effect of the national unrighteousness, and to their conscience he appeals direct, by simply announcing the impending judgment : — Thy men shall fall by the sword, And thy mighty in the war : — * and the gates of Jerusalem, the places of resort for business * See further as to the treatment of captives in war, on Isaiah, xx. ISAIAH IV. 1. : THE WIDOWED MATRON. 45 or for pleasure, which now resound with the cheerful hum of prosperous throngs, shall echo with the voice of the bereaved, the destitute, or the captive, filling the air (as the manner of eastern nations was and is) with their wailings ; and She, the widowed and childless City, shall sit upon the ground, as mourners used to sit, and as she was represented 800 years afterwards (and may still be seen), on the medals of her con- querors, Vespasian and Titus. And in that day, when the youth of the land are everywhere cut off, Seven women shall take hold of one man, saying, We will eat our own bread, And wear our own apparel ; Only let us be called by thy name, — Take thou away our reproach.* The Jewess, like the ancient Roman, or modern English, woman, was called by her husband's name ; and she prized the honour of wedlock, and dreaded the reproach of childlessness, at least as much as either of these ; but we must contrast the dignified expression of these feelings by Sarah, Hannah, and Elizabeth, nay, even that of the jealous and petulant Rachel, with the exhibition which the Prophet now contemplates in his mind's eye, in order to see the picture of social disorganisation which he sees. If a harem of wives and concubines was still a part of the king's state in Isaiah's time, though I know no rea- son for thinking it was, it is quite improbable that polygamy was the common custom of the nation, or that they had not long passed out of the half-civilised condition and habits for which Moses had jn'ovided, in his laws for the protection of the female slaves whom a man might take at the same time for his wives : but now Isaiah says that these women, whose luxury and pride he has just described, will abandon even the natural reserve of their sex, and not only force themselves several upon one man, but declare that they will be content to share with each other a legalised concubinage, in which they will not claim the con- * Grotius quotes Lucan (Pharsal. ii. 342.) : — ' ... da tantuni uomen inane Connubii ; liceat tuniulo scripsisse, Catonls Marcia.' 46 HEBREW POLITICS. cubine's ancient right of bread and apparel, which the old law (Exod, xxi. 10.) had, in express terms, secured to her. It need not be supposed that Isaiah anticipated the literal fulfilment of his words ; we shall probably understand him better by taking this as an instance of that poetic or rhetorical hyperbole, which he so delights to use for the more forcible expression of his moral and political teaching. The mystery which some commentators have seen in the numbers seven and one in this passage, and which is even said to have occasioned the separation of this portion of the prophecy into a distinct chapter, perhaps makes worth while the obvious remark, that it is nothing more than the wide-spread idiom of modern as well as ancient languages, by which a definite or round number is put for an indefinite. Seven is thus generally used by the Hebrews for any consider- able number, as it was among the Egyptians and Persians, and is still said to be in the East. The Moguls are said to employ nine in like manner. So in English we put five, or ten, for any small, and a hundred for a large, number, in conversation ; though the genius of our language forbids such idioms in graver discourse. In that day shall the brancli of the Lord be beautiful and glorious, And the fruit of the earth shall be excellent and comely, For them that are escaped of Israel. Some commentators refer these Avords ' branch of the Lord,' and 'fruit of the earth,' merely to the restored and reformed nation, but there seems greater propriety in the ex- planation of those who see in ' the branch of the Lord' an allusion to more than this. I think that if we only contrasted the passage with such declarations as, — 'I will restore thy judges as at the first, And thy counsellors as at the beginning : Afterwards thou shalt be called, The city of righteousness, the faithful city : Zion shall be redeemed with judgment, And her converts with righteousness' (chap, i., 26., 27.) ; or, ' The remnant that is escaped of the house of Judah, Shall again take root downward, And bear fruit upward' (chap, xxxvii. 31.) ; — ISAIAH IV. 2 — 6. : MASTER-THOUGHT OF ALL PROPHECY. 47 we might perhaps suspect some allusion to a personal deliverer and ruler in the one, which is wanting in the others : and we might find a probable explanation of this image of the branch, by comparing it with Isaiah's subsequent, — ' There shall come forth a Rod out of the stem of Jesse, And a Branch shall grow out of his roots,' &c. (chap. xi. 1.) ; — with Jeremiah's — ' Behold the days come, saith the Lord, That I will raise unto David a righteous Branch, And a king shall reign and prosper, And shall execute justice and judgment, &c.' (chap, xxiii. 5.); — and with Zechariah's- — ' Behold the man whose name is the Branch : And he shall grow up out of his place, And he shall huild the temple of the Lord, And he shall bear the glory,' &c. (chap. vi. 12.) But we have a fuller, more philosophical light, to aid this verbal criticism. We find traces in all the earlier records of the Hebrew faith and history, of the expectation of an incarnate representative of the invisible Lord God of Israel; we see how it gradually becomes to Isaiah (as I hope the following pages will help to show at large), and to his cotemporaries and successors, the master-thought and light of their faith and teaching, to which they hold fast, though their individual anti- cipations of the manner of its fulfilment are again and again baffled, when the event shows that a Hezekiah, or Zerubbabel, or son of Josedech, is not the Branch ; and, lastly, we know when and how this expectation of Israel for themselves and mankind has been fulfilled in God's manner. And thus (if I may use the correct, though perhaps pedantic, phrase), we can explain the particular fact by the universal law, and recognise in the words before us an early dawning, in or to the mind of Isaiah himself, of the great idea of all prophecy. Then follows the description of the restored and the reformed, though humbled and diminished, nation. It is a common ob- servation, verified alike in great national calamities and in ordinary pauperism, that misery of itself tends to make men 48 HEBREW POLITICS. more vicious ; and accordingly it is not a mere judgment and execution on the bloody men and sensual women of Jerusalem that Isaiah foretells, but a moral purification of the nation, wrought by the Lord, and by his spirit, through these means. Their sin had alike infected their family and their political life ; but now a new and holy spirit shall be revived in every house- hold, and in the 'assemblies' of the citizens whether meeting at the temple worship or the preaching of a prophet*, at the eccle- siastical feasts or national fairs, at the tribunals of the king or the judges sitting in the gate, or on other occasions when they seem to have had a real (though according to modern European notions, irregular) voice in the legislation and government. God himself will bring about this restoration, showing Himself to be the present Lord of the nation, as He was when He led their fathers, — the 'tribes of Israel' and the 'congregation of the Lord,' — by the pillar of cloud and of fire ; and He will pro- tect and defend ' the glory, 'f — this glorious restoration of his Name which He has effected — as a tent shelters the traveller from the sun or the storm, or as the same pillar of cloud or fire defended the hosts of Israel from the pursuing enemy or the burning noonday heat : — And the Lord will create upon every dwelling-place of Mount Zion, And upon her assemblies, A cloud and smoke by day, And the shining of a flaming fire by night : For upon all the glory shall be a defence. And there shall be a tabernacle for a shadow in the day-time from the heat, And for a place of refuge, and for a covert from storm and from rain. * They seem to have preached regularly on Sabbaths and New-moons : — 2 Kings, iv. 23. f ' For I, saith the Lord, will be unto her a wall of fire round about, and will be the glory in the midst of her.'— Zechariah ii. 5. ISAIAH V. : HEBREW IDYLL, 49 CHAPTER IV. ISAIAH V. COMING WOES. — FUSING POWER OF IMAGINATION. — HEBREW IDYLL. ANCIENT FERTILITY OF JUD^A PRESENT BARRENNESS. THE VINEYARD OF THE LORD OF HOSTS. SELFISHNESS IN AN ARISTOCRACY. RIGHTS AND DUTIES OF LANDOWNERS. PROPERTY A TRUST. HEBREW AND ENGLISH LAWS OF ENTAIL. WORD AND WORK OF THE LORD. GOD A CONSTITUTIONAL RULER. — ABUSE OF WORDS BY WORLDLY MEN. THU- CYDIDES. FULFILMENT OF ISAIAH's THREATS TO HIS COTEMPORARIES AND TO ALL AGES SINCE. — GROTIUS ON PROPHECY. The contents of this discourse show it to belong to the same period as the two preceding ones ; but perhaps we may see some indications that it properly follows them, as being of rather a later date. The gloom of the approaching calamities is deeper, and in addition to the previous pictures of the effects of foreign invasion, we have now a description of the invaders themselves, and of their coming, hardly less explicit than when the prophet speaks of them by name to king Ahaz, in chapter vii. verse 18. The last prophecy began with an apologue of ' the Last Days ;' this opens with a like poetical picture of the former and the present times of Israel. Isaiah seems for a moment to think of Zion as in the days of her first love, when she still called the Lord 'her Beloved;' and in her name he begins to speak: — and then, in the rapid transitions which succeed, we have one of the instances, almost as frequent in Isaiah as in Shakspeare or Milton, of that true poet's imagination, which does not merely collect and arrange a succession of beautiful thoughts, but fuses them into one homogeneous whole, though they may be so diverse that less skilful hands could hardly bring them together. The Hebrew Pastoral or Idyll, as we see in the Canticles, chooses the imagery of the vineyard rather than that of the sheepfold. The Jewish poets embody their ideal of a happy life, in the sitting under their own vine and under their own fig- E 50 HEBREW POLITICS. tree ; and this ' Song of the Beloved touching his vineyard,' gives a lively picture of what a vineyard was.* * Apertos Bacchus amat colles ;' and this vineyard is on (literally in, i. c. on the side of ), a hill, of which the Hebrew expresses the fertility by calling it 'a horn the son of oil.' Oil may here be used metaphorically for fertility, or the vineyards of Palestine may have been planted with olive trees, which would at once support the vines and supply a fruit of their own ; and if there were any other trace in the Scriptures of the belief that the olive increased the fruitfulness of the vine when they grew to- gether, we might suppose an allusion to it here. Lowth and other commentators illustrate the word horn by instances of the same and like metaphors in other languages. We call a pro- montory a cape or head, and the Turks a nose ; a ridge in Latin is dorsum ; Brundusium, which, according to Strabo, signifies a stag's head in the ancient language of the country, is described by Lucan as stretching out a tongue and horns into the Adriatic, Solinus says that the south of Italy divides into two horns, and Cambden that ' Cornwall is called by the inhabitants, in the British tongue, Kernaxv, as lessening by degrees like a horn, running out into promontories like so many horns.' So Statius has Cornu Parnassi, and the Swiss have such names as Buchhorn, Sckrechkorn, for mountains. And so Demetrius told Philip, that 'the hill Ithome (with its citadel of Messene) and the Acro- corinthus, were the two horns of the Peloponnesus, which he who held was master of the bull.'f Lowth farther observes, with his wonted taste, that ' Whoever has considered the descriptions given of Mount Tabor, and the views of it which are to be seen in books of travels ; its regular conic form rising singly in a plain to a great height from a base small in proportion; its beauty and fertility to the very top, will have a good idea of "a horn the son of oil." ' The land of Israel was once a fertile as well as a mountainous country : Moses calls it ' the mountain of thine (God's) inheritance'! and ' that goodly mountain'; § and * " Schulz states that lie supped under n, vine whose stem was about a (not and a half in diameter, iis height about thirty feet, while its branches ami branchlets, which had to be supported, formed a tent of upwards of thirty feet square." — Kitto's Bill. Cyclop., art. Vine. f Polyb. vii. 11. ((noted in (1 rote's History of Greece^ x. 309. I Exod.xv. 17. § Deul. iii. 25. FERTILITY OF JODJSA. 51 afterwards describes it as * a good land, a land of brooks of water, of fountains and depths that spring out of valleys and hills ; a land of wheat, and barley, and vines, and fig trees, and pome- granates ; a land of oil olive, and honey ; a land wherein thou slialt eat bread without scarceness, thou shalt not lack any thing in it ; aland whose stones are iron, and out of whose hills thou may est dig brass : . . . a land which the Lord thy God careth for : the eyes of the Lord thy God are always upon it, from the be- ginning of the year even unto the end of the year.' * The eyes of the Lord have ceased to be upon it ; the curse has been as truly fulfilled as once the blessing ; and the traveller now finds the mountains returned to their natural barrenness, though still bearing traces of long - abandoned cultivation. The way in which the change has been effected, is thus lucidly explained : — ' Judaea, the southern part of Palestine, is a country full of hills and valleys, conformably to the Scriptural intimations. The hills are generally separated from one another by valleys and torrents, and are for the most part of moderate height, uneven, and seldom of any regular figure. The rock of which they are composed is easily converted into soil ; which, being arrested by terraces when washed down by the rains, renders the hills cultivable in a series of long narrow gardens, formed by these terraces, from the base upwards. Thus, the hills were cultivated in former times most abundantly ; and were enriched and beautified with the olive, the fig-tree, and the vine ; and thus the limited cultivation which now subsists is still carried on. But when the inhabitants were rooted out and cul- tivation abandoned, the terraces fell to decay, and the soil which had collected on them was washed down into the valleys, leav- ing only the arid rock, naked and desolate. This is the general character : but in some parts the hills are beautifully wooded ; and in others, the application of the ancient mode of cultivation — under which the valleys are covered with corn, while the ter- raced hills are clothed with fig-trees, olive-trees, or vines — sug- gests to the traveller how rich this country once was and still might be, and how beautiful was the aspect which it offered. All these characteristics of desolation apply with peculiar force * Deut.viii. 7—9., xi. 12. e 2 52 HEBREW POLITICS. to that portion of Judaea which formed the inheritance of Ben- jamin. Its most favourably situated mountains are wholly un- cultivated ; and perhaps in no other country is such a mass of rock exhibited, without an atom of soil.'* I believe that, in a poetical allegory there is always more or less of allusion to the details of that which is allegorised; but it is only allusion, — to be realised by the imagination, rather than by the understanding, of the reader, as well as of the poet. The several images are parts of a picture, which must be con- templated as a picture, and its meaning is to enter into the mind through the imagination. Still, a matter-of-fact commentator, like Vitringa, deeply imbued with the spirit of his author, will sometimes greatly help his reader's imagination, even by his un- imaginative remarks : and I think this is the case in his explana- tion of the details of this description of the vineyard. — A vine- yard consists of vines planted for the sake of their fruit : the Hebrew nation with its tribes, its families, and its persons, was such a vineyard, appointed to bring forth the fruits of personal and social religion and virtue, — holiness, righteousness, and love to God and man : this nation was established in a land flowing with milk and honey, endowed with all natural advantages, all circumstances which could favour inward life by outward pros- perity; and the grace and favour of the Loud, and the influences of His Spirit, always symbolised by oil, were continually caus- ing it to be fruitful : ' And he fenced it,' — the arm of the Lord of hosts, employing kings and heroes, was its defence against all enemies; its institutions were fitted to preserve in- ternal order, and to prevent the admixture of evil from without, with the chosen and separated nation ; and its territory was marked out and protected by natural boundaries in a noticeable manner : ' And gathered out the stones,' — the heathen nations, and the stocks and stones they worshipped : ' And planted it with the choicest vine,' — a nation of the noble stock of the patri- archs, and chosen and cultivated by the Lord of the vineyard, with especial care, for his own use : ' And built a tower in it,' — namely, Jerusalem — for the protection and superintendence of the vineyard, as well as to be its farm-house, so to speak: ' And also made a wine-press therein,' — where the wine-press seems to * Kitto's Physical Geography of I lie Holy Land, pp. 32, 33. ISAIAH V. 1 7. : THE VINEYARD. 53 point to the same idea as the sending the servants to receive the fruit in our Lord's modification of this parable : lawgivers, kings, and judges, the temple with its priesthood and ordinances, and the schools of the prophets, were the appointed means for press- ing out and receiving the wine — the spiritual virtues and graces of the vineyard.* And the end is, that He looked that it should bring forth grapes, And it brought forth wild grapes. The master of the vineyard appeals to the inhabitant of Jeru- salem, as to an impartial stranger, to judge what more could have been done for the vineyard ; and to approve his decision as to what shall be done, when the stock of the choicest vinef has turned out to produce nothing but wild, or crab-grapes, after all the culture bestowed on it: it is worthy of nothing but to be laid waste, and this is what he will do to it. And then (by one of those transitions and fusions of the parts of the imagery into a perfect whole), after the utterance of what an earthly master of a vineyard might do, follows, * I will also command the clouds that they rain no rain upon it ;' — which reminds us that it is the Lord of hosts who is speaking, and that His vineyard is the House of Israel. The men of Judah, who were the plants of His choice and delight, have brought Him the fruits of their mere sinful nature, instead of those of His election and grace : 'He looked for judgment, but behold oppression ; for righteousness, but behold aery : ' and the inhabitant of Jerusalem, who had been appealed to, as an impartial judge between the vineyard and its master, hears the still voice of his own ieason * Grotius, following Jerome, explains the wine-press by the altar with its blood of sacrifices. f " Yet I had planted thee a noble vine, wholly a right seed : how then art thou turned into the degenerate plant of a strange vine unto me ? " Jere- miah ii. 21. Lysias, in the place quoted above (page 2.), attributes the ' noTcle and wonderful deeds ' of the Athenians to their noble stock as well as to their political wisdom : — Kcd yap toikoI (pifres Ka\t2s /coi yvovres of^oia. «•. t. a. He just before explains this noble birth to be their autochthony, which had enabled their political existence to be a just one from the very firsi:, instead of being founded, in the ordinary way, on the violent expulsion of a previous race. The same idea is recognised by the Hebrews in their habitunl claim to their land as the land of their father Abraham. How far this was, or was not, the ground of their right, I shall notice hereafter. e 3 51 HEBEEW POLITICS. and conscience pronouncing to him, as it did to the pharisee who listened to the same parable 800 years afterwards, ' Thou art the man.' Selfishness, or the making self the centre to which all things are to tend, is the great sin in all ages and peoples. As soon as national institutions have awakened the sense of personality and the feeling of self-respect, the evil desire of accumulating wealth for that self begins to arise. And in no form is it more hateful than in connection with the possession of land. Men desire, by an almost universal instinct, to possesss property in land, with its healthy occupations and interests, so varied and multiplied by the living powers of nature ; and this kind of property, while it offers more enjoyment than any other, brings a claim for more, and more obvious, duties than any other, by bringing a man into more complete personal relation- ships with his neighbours than is possible in the crowd of cities, and the whirl of city trades. And therefore the prophet pro- nounces his first, and, as it were, a special woe, on the selfish landowner. lie who can join house to house, and lay field to field, when he knows, and long has known, face to face, the very man, wife, and child whom he has dispossessed, and can drive out by his own simple act his fellow-men to be desolate in their poverty, in order that he may be alone in his riches, may expect a punishment proportioned to his crime. Such men were the nobles of Judah and Israel throughout the land ; and the pro- phet heard, ringing in his ears, the declaration of the Lord and King of the land, that the great and fair palaces should become as desolate as the peasants' and yeomen's cottages which had made place for them : — the lordly vineyard of ten acres shall yield but eight gallons of wine, and the corn-field shall give back but a tenth part of the seed sown in it. "We have all seen, in the present day, how this eternal law of politics has been executed in Ireland by the famine, with its inevitable accompaniments the Poor Law and the Encumbered Estates Act : and though the course of social changes is so noise- less in England that it attracts less attention; yet those who do look into the reasons why this or that estate passes from an old to a new owner, can usually Bee plainly enough that those reasons are moral ones — that when a man ha;? to sell the home of his Isaiah v. 8 — 10. : duties of landowners. 55 fathers, it is almost invariably because he and they had ceased to acknowledge that they held it on the tenure of social duties. All property whatever is, doubtless, a trust ; but the principle always has been, and always must be, more clearly illustrated in landed, than in any other property ; and this, not less by the efforts of selfish men to deny, than of good men to assert it. If we suppose the history of England to be the gazette of its battles, we may be content to explain our feudal institutions in the middle ages as arrangements for providing the kings with soldiers : but, looking a little deeper, we see that they were a complex organisation of patriarchal government ; in which, if the tenure of the landowner's occasional military service to the king was the more palpable, it was not more real, nor more im- portant as an element of national life and progress, than the daily and hourly performance of his, and his wife's, and chil- dren's, personal and social duties to their vassals. In as far as the feudal spirit was true to itself, it taught the English lord to hold that it was the mark, not of the Christian gentleman but of the usurer and the alien, to have a merely selfish right in property which he could call his own : and when, in a later age, the gentleman borrowed the usurer's money, and then pleaded his family's inalienable right to its land in bar of repayment, we were happily drawing towards a stage of our history in which the law was strong enough to assert its majesty against even the statute-makers of the time being, and to teach them that they had duties to,jLisurers and aliens, as well as to a vassal yeomanry.* Then the judge upon the bench showed himself more than a * I refer, of course, to the subtle legal construction by which the judges, in Edward I V.'s reign, gave the first deadly blow to the famous statute De Donis, 13 Edw. 1. c 1. This was a law by which the barons thought effectually to prevent any future alieuation of their estates from their respective families. But after throwing out hints in the long interval, as to what could be done, the judges under Edward IV. decided that an 'estate- tail ' could be effectually converted into a ' fee-simple,' by the fiction of ' common recovery.' The king may have sanctioned or connived at this decision, with a view to break the power of traitor-barons the easier ; but when we remember the growing spirit of independence in the educated elass, and the increased importance of trade, there seems little doubt that the judges were conscious of the higher motive of compelling even nobles to pay their debts and leave oil' trampling on the middle classes. £ 4 56 HEBREW POLITICS. match, in the cause of justice, for the baron in parliament: and now, when our ways of effecting our ends are become very dif- ferent, though the ends themselves — of truth or of selfishness — are still the same, the latest developments of the science of political economy are bringing out the same results in the form suited to this age. For they are proving, beyond refutation, that while an old and civilised State like ours, has the deepest interest — probably that of its very existence — in the mainte- nance of each individual's absolute legal property in his estate, it has an equally deep interest in his using his property in the way most beneficial to the community ; and a public and inde- feasible right, limited only by considerations of practical expe- diency, to enforce that user by any necessary means.* It may be thought strange to doubt the existence of a ' natural right ' of property ; but I believe that, if we look quietly to the bottom of the matter, we shall see that the ordinary assertion of such a rio-ht is partly a misapplication of abstract reason to a subject which lies altogether within the region of positive institutions, historical experience, and the calculations of expediency ; and partly a selfish animal instinct, which reveals its true nature by its rage and fear at any alarm of losing its material possessions, and by the resolution which it then shows to defend these by all that physical force of police and soldiers, for the organisation of which alone society seems to it to exist. ' Right, in its most proper sense, is the creature of law and statute, and only in the technical language of the courts has it any substantial and independent sense. In morals, right is a word without meaning, except as the correlative of duty.' f It is hard to say how a nation, which is to preserve its own orderly existence, can remain without some laws or institutions * See especially the chapters on landed property in Mr. J. Stuart Mill's Principles of Political Economy. f Coleridge's Lay Sermons, p. 66. edit. 1 852. — I have purposely adopted, as to the 'natural right' of property, Coleridge's argument, and almost his words, as to Jacobinism, which all agree is the assertion of man's ' natural right' to power. It is instructive to be reminded how ultra-conservatism and ultra-liberalism agree in appealing to ' natural rights ' instead of to the positive laws of an historical constitution, — to the petty individual reason, instead of to the universal reason, which, because it is universal, can only manifest itself in successive historical developments. LAWS OF ENTAIL. 57 for encouraging, or at least permitting, the disposition of its members to found families, to be maintained by hereditary posses- sions in land. Yet, if this disposition be not kept within bounds, those who are influenced by it will * join house to house, and field to field, till there be no place ; ' till the race of small landholders, yeomen, and partly independent tenants, is swallowed up by a few rich despots. To prevent this evil among the Jews, Moses directed as equal a division of the land as possible in the first instance, among the whole 600,000 families who originally formed the nation ; and provided against the permanent alienation of any estate, by giving a right of repurchase to the seller and his relations, and of repossession without purchase at the Jubilee.* The story of Naboth f illustrates the effect of these laws in forming an order of sturdy independent yeomen ; but it must also be taken as an instance of the habitual breach of the same laws by the rich and powerful J as they in like manner disobeyed that respecting the liberation of slaves at the Jubilee.§ In England, Avhere the Norman conquest had accumulated all the land in the hands of a few nobles, the like result of check- ing this accumulation has been effected by laws, in their form exactly opposite to those of Moses ; — by the permission to cut off old entails, and the prohibition to make new ones, ex- cept for one generation ; and by allowing land to be bought and sold like other commodities. The Hebrew constitution provided by law for the preservation of the old families, while our constitution at the same time that it gives them the means of sustaining themselves with even the most ordinary internal virtue and energy, permits them, if they become effete and worthless, to give way to new and more vigorous houses, which have raised themselves out of the ranks below ; and thus new blood is continually infused into the old organisation of the state. I do not indeed say, nor think, that our existing means are as effectual as they might be for the latter purpose ; but the law has very much less, and the private arrangements of fathers and sons very much more, to do with the alienation or retention of family estates than is supposed by most of the common argu- * Levit. xxv. 8 — 11., 23—28. f ] Kings, xxi. 1—24. J Compare Micah, ii. 2. ; Nehcm. v. 1 — 13. ; 2 Cbron. xxxvi. 21. § Jcr. xxxiv. 8 — 16. 58 HEBREW POLITICS. ments for or against ' laws of primogeniture ' in England. Some remedies, too, are as bad as the disease ; and we must be cau- tious how we try to direct English free-will by Continental re- strictions. But how imperfectly we realise the ideal of the con- stitution; how deeply liable we are to the denunciations of the Hebrew prophet ; and in what degree this national sin, with its practical bad consequences, might be checked by legislation, as well as preached against by the Church ; these points must be left for the reader's consideration. I would also direct his attention to the progress of the world as shown in the comparison of these opposite means, in ancient Israel and modern England, for effecting the same end, and for providing that clement of the political constitution of each which the Jews marked by the name of ' tribe,' and we usually call ' feudal,' or ' aristocratic,' but which is properly the ele- ment of family life as distinguished from the several other elements — industrious, intellectual, moral, religious, which have all their appropriate political forms of expression, and which together unite in one constitution or body-politic. Be- fore the times of the Christian Church, with its assertion of a spiritual constitution and order, which at once demanded the highest personal responsibility and permitted the fullest personal liberty, to its members, it was not possible for a State to allow its existence to depend so greatly on the free-will of its citizens as it now can ; nor to leave the provisions for such a main element of its organisation as (for instance) the breaking up of old families and the formation of new ones, with all the hazards consequent on both, to be regulated by the will, and according to the personal character, of the individual agents. Men grasp wealth that they may expend it in luxury ; and at last in the most sensual forms of luxury, — drinking and revelling. Such is the state of the rich men Isaiah sees around him. As in another age, the old Roman, who touched nothing, least of all ardent drinks, till the ninth hour of the day *, was succeeded by the race who could boast with Horace, — * " They always ate but once a day, and that was In die evening." — De- Bcription of the Golden Age in King Alfred's Boethius, S. Turner's Hist, of England, ii. 86. ISAIAH V. 11, 12.: WORD AND WORK OF COD. 59 ' Est qui nec veteris pocula Massiei, Nee partem solido demere de die Spernit ;' so the land of Israel has fallen from the blest state in which its princes ' ate not in the morning, but in clue season, for strength and not for drunkenness ; ' * and we see men ' That put far away the evil day, And cause the seat of violence to come near ; That lie upon beds of ivory, • And stretch themselves upon their couches, And eat the lambs out of the flock, And the calves out of the midst of the stall ; That chant to the sound of the viol, And invent to themselves instruments of music, like David ; That drink wine in bowls, And anoint themselves with the choicest ointments : But are not grieved with the affliction of Joseph.' f And thus embruted, they have lost all sense of there being any divine order and government of the world, for have they not even obliterated the natural distinctions of healthy appetite, and of night and day ? They cannot retain any glimmering of that which God had revealed to their nation, above all other nations, and was still telling them by the mouth of His pro- phets,— that the whole world, social no less than natural, the heavens as well as the earth, had been created according to the designs conceived in the eternal mind of God himself, of which mind the declaration and explanation is called his ( Word,' the actual realisation of the design his ' Work,' and the various processes by which He is effecting that realisation the ' Operation of his hands,' while the ultimate end of the whole is named the ' Glory of God.' J They have no knowledge either of the Word or -the Work of the Lord: they lack that which alone could save them, which alone has upheld any nation, in any age or clime, and which alone can uphold us now here in England. Their feasting and * Eccles. x. 17. f Amos, vi. 3 — 6. where the prophet is speaking of the same Jewish nobles. j Compare Psalms, xxxiii. 4., xcii. 4, 5., cxi. 2 — 8., lxiv. i), 10., xxviii. 5., Ixxvii. 12, 13, 14. 60 HEBREW POLITICS. drunkenness is about to be succeeded by thirst and famine ; by an indefinite, hopeless, desolation of the whole land, dark and deep as death and the grave ; so that hell, with its insatiable maw, shall be the only banqueter, and its food the hopes and life as well as the bodies of men. The nation has forgotten God, the Lord living and reigning among them ; they are sunk into selfish, carnal ease, trusting in their riches and glory, and in the apparent stability of their civil and ecclesiastical institutions. Therefore the Lord sum- mons this carnal glory, and the men who trust in it, to judg- ment, to try what there is in it, whether it has anything by which it can stand without His help ; and then they will see by the judgment and its execution (which will be according to truth and righteousness), that all their glorious endowments were given them by God as witnesses of Himself, and means whereby to attain to the knowledge of Him, but that apart from Him they have no worth. This judgment came upon the men whom Isaiah addressed, in the reign of Ahaz, soon after the delivery of the warning ; but in order fully to understand it, we must (as in the case of all the other prophecies) look at it in the light of the Gospel. Then was the selfish and carnal nation brought to its final and most awful trial, righteously condemned, and its sentence carried into execution by that Man whom God had appointed. And then, while all flesh, not except- ing those institutions which God had himself ordained, but which men had turned into a lie, was utterly humbled, did God exalt Himself and His Son, and sanctify His holy Name, setting it up in the world, and causing it to triumph over all opposition. In the present day our consciences are so insensible, that we can hardly realise any practical belief in the reality of judgments from God upon our nation. One reason of this seems to be, that such vague recognition as remains to us of a Divine King invisibly reigning over the nation, is rather the acknowledgment of a despotic than a constitutional lord ; one who from time to time puts forth his power to prevent or punish flagrant crimes, but not one who is steadily governing us by fixed laws, and administering settled institutions. For though we may slavishly dread an arbitrary will, we can never feel for it that salutary fear which is the beginning of wisdom ; and unless we believe ISAIAH V. 16, 17.: GOD A CONSTITUTIONAL RULER. 61 that God's judgments are righteous — that they are a part of the steady administration of a polity — as well as good in their effects, it will be impossible for us to keep long from superstition, or its opposite, scepticism. And, therefore, we should take heed to this repeated assertion, that God is ex- alted in executing justice, and sanctified in righteousness. The sanctifying God is the recognising and worshipping Him as holy and separate from all other gods, and the renouncing and denying all others as false gods. This shall be the end of the Lord's judgments : and the prophet contemplates the judgment and the reformation with a chastened contentment, while he pictures the once richly cultivated fields as become a pasture for lambs ; and the lands of the selfish nobles, after being desolated by the Assyrian invader, as now restored to a humble peace by the presence of the wandering shepherds, those friendly strangers, Rechabites or Kenites, who still appeared from time to time in the plains of Palestine with their flocks, as Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob had themselves done in old times, when they too were strangers (the same word) in the land of the Canaanites. There is no need to decide whether we are to give a literal or an allegorical meaning to this verse, for the one image into which the two are fused is the only adecpaate counterpart to the event : the lands wasted by the inroads and invasions which followed the delivery of this prophecy were no doubt pastured by flocks that were owned by others than the former landlords ; and the rule of Uzziah, Jotham, Ahaz, and their rich and selfish nobles, was succeeded by that of the lamblike Hezekiah. * He in the first year of his reign, in the first month, opened the doors of the house of the Lord, and repaired them. And he brought in the priests and the Levites, and gathered them together into the east street, and said unto them, Hear me, ye Levites, sanctify now yourselves, and sanctify the house of the Lord God of your fathers, and carry forth the filthiness out of the holy place. For our fathers have trespassed, and done that which was evil in the eyes of the Lord our God, and have forsaken him, and have turned away their faces from the habitation of the Loud, and turned their backs. Also they have shut up the doors of the porch, and put out the lamps, and have not burned in- cense nor offered burnt offerings in the holy place unto the God 62 HEBREW POLITICS. of Israel. Wherefore the wrath of the Lord was upon Judah and Jerusalem, and he hath delivered them to trouble, to astonish- ment, and to hissing, as ye sec with your eyes. For, lo, our fathers have fallen by the sword, and our sons and daughters and our wives are in captivity for this. Now it is in mine heart to make a covenant with the Lord God of Israel, that his fierce wrath may turn away from us.' * Nor must we forget that other and greater fulfilment of the words when Paul, the apostle of Jesus Christ, said, ' The foolishness of God is wiser than men; and the weakness of God is stronger than men. For ye see your calling, brethren, how that not many wise men after the flesh, not many mighty, not many noble, are called : but God hath chosen the foolish things of the world to confound the wise ; and God hath chosen the weak things of the world to confound the things which are mighty ; and base things of the world, and things which are despised, hath God chosen, yea, and things which are not, to bring to nought things that are : that no flesh should glory in his presence. But of him are ye in Christ Jesus, who of God is made unto us wis- dom, and righteousness, and sanctification, and redemption : that, according as it is written, he that glorieth, let him glory in the Lord.'f The sensual reveller simply disregards God's constitution and government of society ; but the shrewd man of the world, and the intellectual sceptic, sneeringly deny its reality. ' Wise in their own eyes, and prudent in their own sight,' do they not see clearly that selfishness is at bottom the one real motive-power of society ? priests or prophets may preach about good and evil, light and darkness, right and wrong, as though these words represented realities essentially contrary ; but do not they know that these are but words, useful instru- ments by which wise men govern fools, but to which they arc themselves no slaves? shall the astute and able men who have been transreting public affairs, or their own business, with such perfect success for so long past, who have carried on the whole social and political mechanism during the prosperous reigns of Uzziah and Jotham, be threatened with this 'counsel and * 2 Cbron. xxix. 3—10. f 1 Corinthians, i. 25 — 31. ISAIAn V. 18 — 23. : ABUSE OF WORDS. 63 work of the Lord?' Strong at once in their religions for- malism, and their pride of worldly craft, they reply, ' Let Him make speed, and hasten His work, that we may see it; and let the counsel of the Holy One of Israel draw nigh and come, that, we may know it ! ' — In the act and habit of thus rejecting the guidance of the Lord, they have harnessed themselves to their sin as to a waggon, and they shall draw the load of their choice till they find whether it be the woe that the prophet declares it to be. Vitringa quotes the famous description by Thucydides, of the like confusion between virtues and vices, and their very names, the consequence of the Greek civil wars : Kal rrjv slcoOvlav d%Lw- uiv t6>v ovo/Jbdruiv sis to, epya dvTijWa^av rfj hi/carncrst,' roXfxa pusv ydp uXoytaros, dvSpla (piXsracpos svopbiaOrj' p.sWrjais Ss 7rpop,t]$7Js, 8si\ia evirpsiri'is' ic. t. X.* And he then goes on to observe, that there are principles of truth in man's heart which are the foundations of all right, justice, and virtue — principles not only true in themselves, but i good ' and e sweet ' in their effects : that the revelation of Jehovah, His cove- nant with Abraham and his descendants, His laws and promises of temporal and eternal life to all who should obey them, were especially the 'light' of the Jews; and were 'good' and ' sweet,' because the source of all consolations in every struggle with evil, and the bond by which their political society was held together: that the wicked were not satisfied with practically renouncing this light, with its excellent fruits, but denied them by argu- ments, and perversion of the proper meaning of words : and that while this was a national sin in the days of Isaiah, the Jews filled up the measure of their iniquity in the time of Christ, when they rejected the Light of life as darkness, and evil, and bitter, making the light that was in them to be darkness. Lastly, among the men whom Isaiah denounces as the cor- rupters and destroyers of the society of which they are the * "The received value of names imposed for significationof things, was changed into arbitrary : for inconsiderate boldness was counted true-hearted manliness; provident deliberation, a handsome fear: modesty, the cloak ol cowardice ; to be wise in everything, to be lazy in everything," &c. — Ilohhcss Translation, iii. 82. 64 HEBREW POLITICS. leaders, are the unjust lawyers and judges : he mentions as characteristic of them, that they are heroes at drinking, by which, perhaps, we are to understand, not that their heads and senses were overcome with wine like the drunkards spoken of above; but that the effect on their hearts and consciences was such as to harden them in their criminal perversion of the law. Perhaps the passage might be illustrated by instances of the professional character of hard-drinking but strong-headed judges of other times. The prophet then goes on, Therefore, as the fire devoureth the stubble, And the flame consumeth the chaif, So their root shall be as rottenness, And their blossom shall go up as dust : Because they have cast away the law of the Lord of hosts, And despised the word of the Holy One of Israel. The ' law ' of the Lord was given by Moses, and embodied in institutions and a code; the 'word' was that exposition of the meaning and life of these which the prophets were from time to time declaring in the ears of the people. The nation had cast away this law, and despised this word. And when all heart and morality are thus gone from a nation, its roots below ground are rotten ; and its flourishing appearance is ready to turn to dust, like the apples which the traveller still gathers on the shore of the sea of Sodom. There is no substance in such a people, nothing which can stand calamity of any kind. Already, when the prophet speaks, the Lord has smitten them in his anger. Whether the earthquake which happened in the reign of Uzziah had actually filled the streets of Jerusalem with dead bodies, or whether Isaiah only makes it the image or instance of wider-spread national judgments, we cannot pro- nounce historically ; but in either case, the past and present is but a foretaste of heavier woes impending : the Lord has made the hills of their national prosperity to tremble, and per- sonal suffering has begun : but ' for all this His anger is not turned away, but His hand is stretched out still.' He is about to bring foreign armies as the instruments of His judgment : the vision of the worst of human calamities — the invasion of a rich, civilised, luxurious nation by overwhelming hordes of ISAIAH V. 26 — 30. GROTIUS ON PROPHECY. 65 barbarians — rises before the prophet ; he speaks of thern as pre- sent, and his words strike a kind of terror into the heart of him who reads them now, while he thinks of their fearful import then. The men and women who heard Isaiah speak these words in the court of the temple, in the highway of the Ful- ler's Field, or in some other crowded thoroughfare ; who lived to see fathers and husbands, and sons and brothers, killed in the several invasions which soon followed, or mothers, wives, and daughters driven like herds of cattle to a sale and slavery- worse than death ; and whose wealth and sources of wealth were utterly wasted by these and like inroads into their populous and highly cultivated little country ; could not have thought the prophet's language too strong for the events, though it seems so to many commentators of the last, or even the present century. Yet we must not forget that in an imaginative and unphilo- sophic age, more of the idea of prophecy has been preserved by several such commentators seeking its fulfilment in several distant events, than could have been the case if they had agreed to restrict it (as Grotius* and others have too dryly done) to the mere contemporaneous history. It is such a picture of ' the life of things,' that it is equally the description of the same judgment of God, in whatever age or to whatever nation occurring. In successive ages it told the Jew of the Assyrian, the Babylonian, the Greek, and the Roman ; to the subject of the Roman empire it spoke no less clearly of the Goth and the Vandal ; the British monk must have recalled it in the days when Gildas recorded the invasion of the Saxon ; the degene- * Nothing, indeed, can be sounder than the principle which Grotius lays down on this subject. He says, " In the prophecies, I have made it a main object to refer the particulars to the corresponding historical events : the reader will judge with what success. In this way certain passages which the old commentators refer to Christ and the times of the Gospel, I have re- ferred to events nearer the prophet's own times, yet as involving a type of those other Gospel times. I have done this because I saw it to be the only way of preserving that coherence of words and things which in the rest of the prophetical books is so admirable ; and, indeed, these passages do reveal to us Christians the counsel of God, who has shadoAved forth to us the Messiah, and the benefits given us through Him, not by lvords only, but also by events." — Prcefat. ad Annotut. ad Vet. Tcstamentum. F 66 HEBREW POLITICS. rate Saxon learnt its truth from the Dane and the Norman ; and the Spaniard from the Mahometan ; the Byzantine from Timour ' the incarnate wrath of God;' the Continental peoples from the revolutionary armies and Napoleon.' There is no land or nation where this terrible prophecy has not been fulfilled : may God give us Englishmen grace to take heed betimes, lest we need to be roused from our too thoughtless and selfish indiffer- ence, and find that these words, read, but scarcely listened to in our churches, have an awful practical meaning to us ! And He hath lifted up an ensign to the nations from far, And hath hissed unto tliem from the end of the earth : And, behold, they will come right speedily. None hath fainted nor stumbled among tliem ; None shall slumber nor sleep ; Neither is the girdle of their loins loosed, Nor the latchet of their shoes broken : Whose arrows are sharpened, And all their bows bent; Their horses' hoofs are counted like flint And their wheels like a whirlwind : Their roar is like that of a lioness, They shall roar like young lions : Yea, they shall roar, and lay hold of the prey, And shall carry it away safe, and none shall deliver it. And in that day they shall roar against them like the roaring of the sea : And if one look unto the land, behold darkness and sorrow, And the light is darkened in the heavens thereof. From the days of Isaiah this prophecy was fulfilled to the Jews again and again, till their cup was full, in the time of the Romans. Such are the judgments with which God visits a nation which forsakes Him, and obstinately refuses to return, 'Bead,' says Vitringa, * Psalm, lxix. 22— 28. and cix. 5— 20. and tremble.' the prophet's commission. 67 CHAPTER V. ISAIAH VI. THE PROPHET'S COMMISSION. — THE TEMPLE ITS SCENES. THE VISION. INSIGHT INTO THE LIFE OF THINGS. PROPHECY RATIONAL AND INTELLIGIBLE. GOD THE REAL AND ACTUAL KING. PLURAL OF MAJESTY. HOLINESS OF GOD HIS JUSTICE. — CALVINISM. The expression ' In the year that King Uzziah died I saw,' implies that Isaiah wrote this account of his vision some time after it occurred ; and both this and the like phrase in chapter xiv. 28. suggest the thought that the prophet himself revised and arranged the book of his prophecies. Whether these ex- pressions refer to dates before or after the death of the kings mentioned in them, has been much disputed : in chapter xiv. the context will allow of either interpretation, nor in that of the passage before us can Ave assert that either is incongruous. Yet it seems reasonable to think with Gesenius, that if the meaning were after, the phrase would rather have been * In the first year of Jotham (or Hezekiah) ; ' and if we suppose with him and other commentators, among whom Jarchi rests on the authority of the Gemara, that the chapter before us is the record of Isaiah's original calling and consecration to the pro- phetic office, then it must be referred to Uzziah's lifetime, as the only prophecy which can correspond with the words of the inscription ( which he saw in the days of Uzziah.'* There is certainly a great resemblance to the parallel accounts of the calling of Jeremiah and Ezekiel at the beginning of their prophecies -f : and though this cannot be said to be conclu- sive against the supposition that Isaiah may have begun to to preach, before this vision gave the formal ratification of his appointment to the office for which the whole style of this as of his other writings shows him to have been lonq; educating ; and though it would be no disparagement of the authority of that ratification to consider that it recognised * Ch. i. 1. t Jer- i- 5 Ezek. i. ii. f 2 68 HEBREW TOLITICS. views of God's character, and of the state and prospects of the Jewish nation, which had already become familiar to the in- spired seer, while it confirmed and sanctioned them in a solemn and formal decree ; yet, perhaps, the actual manner and words of the commission which Isaiah now receives, rather indicate that it was the root and source of those prophecies which stand before it in the book, and in which there is an expansion, in various forms, of its fundamental ideas, than that it was a con- densed summary of truths already fully developed in his mind and in these discourses. ' Once for all,' says Ewald, ' must he who was to be a prophet, have become absolutely certain of the true relation of the world and Jehovah, — must have beheld, as in a distinct form, the sublime and holy character of Jehovah, and felt that he Avas directed by Him alone : once for all must he have recognised the divine power of truth against the whole world, and himself as living and moving in it alone : once for all must he have entered, with the effectual energy and act of his whole inner being, into the counsels of God, and found himself for ever bound by them, and endowed by these bonds with true power and freedom : — this was the first condition, and the true beginning of all the work of the prophet, the holy consecration and the inner call, without which none became a true prophet ; and only he who had thus first turned his eyes within, and there found clearness and strength of sight, could afterwards look clearly and firmly into the world without, and there do his work as a prophet. Therefore, on the nature and strength of this be- ginning depended the whole subsequent life and work of a pro- phet : where the true and vigorous beginning of the work was wanting, all subsequent endeavours were weak and defective, empty, and unfruitful ; while in the true prophets that beginning never ceased to be operative, and the memory of it bloomed without fading in later years. If such a prophet undertook to record his more important prophecies in writing, he put at the head of them, and with a just consciousness of its sig- nificance, a description of that holy moment — often of a time long gone by — when he had first known Jehovah in His true majesty, and felt that he was called, sanctified, and endowed with strength by Him.' * * Ewald, Die Prophctcv, i. 20. Isaiah vi. 1. : Solomon's temple. 09 We shall then account, as has been already said, for the posi- tion of the earlier prophecies, by considering that they give a com- plete picture of the state of the nation at the time that Isaiah received his commission and entered on his office, and so supply us with the preliminary information necessary to the adequate comprehension of these. For the times of Jotham were but the continuation and counterpart of those of Uzziah, as to their selfishness, luxury, and worldliness, only that these were more and more rapidly preparing their own punishment by eating away the military and otherwise energetic spirit which had animated the people under Uzziah. The scene of this Vision is the Temple ; and its features will have been the same, whether we suppose them to have risen before Isaiah's imagination while he was absent from the spot, in the solitude of his chamber, or his house-top, or assume (as I myself prefer to do) that he was actually praying in the temple at the time. Though it is unlikely that any of the successors to what was but a small remnant, of Solomon's kingdom, perfectly restored the temple after it was deprived of its original splendour by Shishak in the reign of llehoboam, yet we see the worthier princes from time to time repairing the structure where it had been suffered to fall into decay, and replacing, as far as they could, the treasures and the costly decorations of which it was repeatedly despoiled to buy off foreign invaders ; and probably there was no period in which the restoration would be more complete than in the reign of Uzziah, who, in his power, wealth, and magnificence, came nearer than any other to Solomon. And there will be much more of fact than of fancy in the picture, if, for the clearer understanding of the scene of this vision, wo figure to ourselves the youthful prophet in his rough hair or woollen garment (possibly not unlike that of the Capuchin friar as we now see him in the streets or churches of Home) going up to the temple to worship ; — and if we look with him at the temple, as, at the end of 300 years from its building, it must have presented itself to his eyes, with its ample courts and colonnades, its porch with high spire-like front, and its Holy House, and Holy of Holies, well-proportioned, and of the most elaborate workmanship, though rather massive than f 3 70 HEBREW POLITICS. large, according to our notions. As he crossed the variegated pavement of the ' great court of the congregation,' and stopped — for we have no reason to suppose him a Levite — at the entrance to the inner or ' priests' court,' on each hand would rise one of the tall pillars which Solomon set up, in token that the king- dom was constituted by the Lord, and would be upheld by His might*, and which, once of' bright brass,' but now mellowed into bronze, had their scpuare capitals richly wreathed with molten lilies, chain-work, and pomegranates ; before him, resting on the back of the twelve oxen, and cast, like them, in brass, would appear the ' molten sea,' a basin of thirty cubits in circumference, and containing two or three thousand baths of water, its brim wrought 'like the brim of a cup, with flowers of lilies,' and under these a double row of ornamental knobs; while on each side stood five smaller lavers, the bases of which rested on wheels, and were most elaborately ornamented with oxen, lions, cherubims, and palm-trees, engraved upon them ; and beyond these again he would see the great brazen altar of burnt offer- ing, with its never-extinguished fire ; and overhead the roof of thick cedar beams resting on rows of columns. These were the courts of the palace of the divine King of Israel f, for the reception of his subjects and his ministers. The house itself again consisted of two parts, the outer of which, the holy place, was accessible to those priests who were in immediate attendance on their unseen Sovereign, while the inner, or holiest place, was the very presence-chamber of the Monarch who ' dwelt between the cherubims,' which spread their golden wings over the ark containing the covenant He had vouchsafed to enter into with His people, and itself forming ' the mercy- seat,' where was ' the place of His throne and the place of the soles of His feet.' In the position which I have, following the requirements of the narrative in the chapter before us, supposed * Can there be much doubt tliat tins was the meaning of Jachin and Boaz (2 Chron. iii. 17.)? As Solomon had the belp of Tyrian architects, it is in- teresting to compare the mention o^the two pillars which Herodotus saw in the temple of Hercules, at 'Lyre. — Herodotus, ii. 44. f Compare the description of Solomon's own house, which, besides its inner porch, had another, where he sat to judge the people, 1 Kings, vii. 7. The arrangement of the Temple is plainly that of a palace. THE UNSEEN KING OF ISRAEL. 71 Isaiah to be placed, he would see through the open folding -doors of cypress, carved ' with cherubims, and palm-trees, and open flowers,' and ' covered with gold upon the carved work,' into the holy place, which he could not enter; and the light of the golden lamps on either side would show him the cedar panelling of the walls, carved with knobs and open flowers, with cherubims and palm-trees, festooned with chain-work, and richly gilt ; the mosaics of precious stones ; the cypress floor ; the altar of incense ; the table with the shewbread ; the cen- sers, tongs, and other furniture of ' pure and perfect gold ;' and before the doorway at the further end, and not concealed by the open leaves of the olive-wood doors (carved and gilded like the others), would be distinguishable the folds of the vail ' of blue, and purple, and crimson, and fine linen,' embroidered with cherubims. In the East the closed vail, or purdah, declares the presence and secures the privacy of the monarch, into which no man may intrude and live ; and in the temple at Jerusalem it was the symbol of the awful presence and unapproachable majesty of the King, the Lord of hosts. The pious and thoughtful Jew, taught to connect the presence of his God with this actual dwelling-place in the midst of His own chosen nation, was thereby educated to realise the unity and the personality of God in a way that could not then have been otherwise possible. And thus he was not the less, but the better, enabled to feel and know that ' heaven and the heaven of heavens could not contain' the Lord, how much less then this house! That the fact was so, we see from the whole tenor of Solomon's prayer at the dedication of the temple, when, in the midst of the pomp and splendour of the assembled nation, the king, raised on a brazen scaffold near the altar, ' kneeled down upon his knees before all the congregation of Israel, and spread forth his hands to heaven,' and in the name of his people renewed the national covenant with the Lord God of Israel, and received His ratifi- cation of it in the ' cloud that filled the house of the Lord.' Other recognitions of that covenant occur to the mind as it transports itself into the past : we may picture to ourselves the triumphal return of the Jewish army from the field of Berachah, when ' they returned, every man of Judah and Jerusalem, and Jchosaphat in the forefront of them, to go again r 4 72 HEBREW POLITICS. to Jerusalem with joy ; ' ' and they came to Jerusalem with psalteries, and harps, and trumpets, into the house of the Lord,' to celebrate with praise and thanksgiving their victory over the far stronger forces of a general gathering of the Moabites, Ammonites, and other shepherd nations, whose in- vasions have been in all ages so terrible to a civilised country — a victory which even the neighbouring kings recognised as the work of the Lord, whose covenant with Israel both king and people had so earnestly pleaded before the battle : or we may see before us another time when the temple courts were again filled with armed men, not the splendid retinue of a peaceful monarch, nor the troops of one just returned from the war, but veteran soldiers, loyal nobles, and patriotic Levitcs, secretly assembled from distant parts of the country, and resolved at all hazards to restore the constitution subverted by the usurping murdress Athaliah, and to maintain the rights of the little child of seven years old who ( stood in the midst of them at his pillar, as the manner was,' while ' they put upon him the crown and gave him the testimony, and made him king, and Jehoiada and his sons anointed him, and said, God save the king,' and then renewed for themselves, the people, and the king, the covenant which had thus once more been upheld in the person of the only remaining, only unmurdered, son of the line of David. And then, recalled by our text to ' the year in which king Uzziah died,' we think of the scene which these same courts had wit- nessed shortly before, not of the ratification, but of the breach of the national covenant, when Uzziah, the man of his age, the very representative of the worldly spirit, the religious formalism, and the material energy and prosperity of the nation, had ('be- cause he was strong, and his heart was lifted up to his destruc- tion') intruded himself into the sanctuary to burn incense, and the bold remonstrance and resistance of the priests had been supported and enforced by his being suddenly ' smitten of the Lord' with leprosy. For the meaning of Uzziah's act is plain : the co-ordinate offices of priest and king, and their exercise by separate persons, is a standing witness for the majesty of a present, though invisible, Lord, greater than both, and actually directing both, according to one divine law. Wherefore this spiritual independence is felt and understood to COLLISIONS OF CHURCH AND STATE. 73 be according to reason by every nation which realises its rela- tion to its divine Head ; but owing to the fallibility of all human agents, it produces so many apparent anomalies and real incon- veniences in practice, and often interferes so greatly with the smooth working of the state-machine, that it seems a thing which it would be well to get rid of, whenever that relation is forgotten in the absorbing care for the material prosperity of the people. Nor can we doubt what Isaiah himself thought of all these things, for the depths of his more than poet's and patriot's aspirations are still open for every one that will to read. Perhaps on this occasion, as certainly on many others, Isaiah had been joining in the public daily sacrifice and worship, and had afterwards brought his own free-willing offering — a bullock or a lamb without blemish. Such an offering, the symbol of his dedication of himself to God's service, would be the natural ex- pression of his earnest desire for some token that it was at last permitted him to enter on the actual functions of that prophetic office for which he had been so long preparing ; and that this vision was the answer to such heartfelt prayerful desire — itself an inspiration from on high — we may well believe. The notion that it is a poetic fiction by which Isaiah re- presents, as in an allegory, the commencement of his career as a prophet, is plainly a mere expedient of writers who cannot conceive, or believe in, any fact which transcends their indi- vidual experience. Thus the critics of the last century supposed the gods and goddesses in Homer to be an ingenious 'ma- chinery for the conduct of the piece,' exactly like that of the sylphs and gnomes in the ' Rape of the Lock,' and with no more reality to the poet's own mind ; and the rational philo- sophers and serious Christians fancied themselves required to quibble away the admonitions of Socrates to his disciples, to adhere to the actual worship of Apollo, or Eros, or Esculapius, before either the wisdom or the virtue of the sage could be safely or consistently approved: but in the present day, we are beginning again to understand the force of St. Paul's words when he told the Athenians that their poets and philosophers had, in their ignorant way, been trying to feel after and to find a divine Lord, of whose presence they were daily conscious, and whose 74 HEBEEW TOLITICS. offspring they believed themselves to he. Isaiah might pro- bably have said, as St. Paul did on a like occasion, ' Whether I was in the body or out of the body, I cannot tell,' but he would undoubtedly have confirmed the plain meaning of his words, that the vision was a reality and a fact ; nor does he, in using those words, adopt a language essentially different from that which has been employed by wise and good men — neither fanatics nor impostors — in all countries and ages down to this we live in, to describe like inward experiences. Thus Words- worth, who, like every other great teacher, is at once the ex- pounder of truths for all times, and the thorough man of his own, after describing his other endowments as a poet, speaks of ' Another gift, Of aspect more sublime ; that blessed mood In which the burden and the mystery, In which the heavy and the weary weight Of all this unintelligible world, Is lightened : — that serene and blessed mood, In which the affections gently lead us on, Until the breath of this corporeal frame, And even the motion of our human blood Almost suspended, we are laid asleep In body, and become a living soul : While with an eye made quiet by the power Of harmony, and the deep power of joy, We see into the life of things.' Let us thoughtfully bring before ourselves the youthful Hebrew seer, with his vigorous and cultivated imagination, his piety and faith towards God, and his longing to enter on the service of his country in that ministry to which he had de- dicated himself: let us consider the long mental discipline, the conflicts of soul, the hope and despair, the watching, the fasting, and the prayer, which alone could have formed such a man as the prophet Isaiah actually comes before us in each page of his writings: let us think of the 'burden and the mystery' which must have oppressed his spirit when he looked on the wealth nnd prosperity around him, and thought how glorious his country might be, yet how plainly it was going forward to the ruin which his study of past history and of the Avnrnings by INSIGHT INTO THE LIFE OF THINGS. 75 Moses, and his successors the prophets, told him was now ready- to fall on this corrupt and sense-bound generation : let us enter into his heart's desire to save them, if it were yet possible, by recalling them to the knowledge of their invisible Lord and King, Avhose holy covenant and service they had forsaken ; and then into the sickness and despair which would replace that hope, when he thought of the men whom he had just seen assisting at the sacrifices with * hands full of blood,' ' the show of their countenances witnessing against them,' while the very stones of the pavement seemed ready to cry out, in God's name, ' Tread my courts no more : ' let us remember how he felt and knew that he too was bound by the same evil nature and circumstances as these his countrymen ; how he must have been overwhelmed with the sense of what a work he was proposing to engage in, and how utterly beyond his or any human strength it was; and how sustained, while overwhelmed, by the still deeper sense that there Avas a Power sufficient even for these things: — and then we shall find in the above- quoted calm and rational description of the experience of an Englishman of the nineteenth century, an explanation and illustration of the greater part at least of what not only may, but must, have been the mental and bodily state of the Hebrew prophet, when he 'saw the Lord sitting on a throne.' The partly psychical, partly physical phenomena involved in this class of questions, may have to wait another generation before their turn arrives for that scientific investigation and solution which in every depart- ment of fact and thought is superseding the inaccurate theo- retical scepticism of the last century : we need an exact analysis of that intensified and exalted condition of the human mind which has given us language in one age, mythology in another, prophecy in another, and which still yields philosophy and poetry at least to us moderns ; and of that life of the body which must be the seat of hearing, sight, and our other senses ; which seems to assert an independent existence for itself and for the soul in dreams*; and which may be able in other modes to * " Reasoning operations may be conducted in sleep. Mathematicians have, in their slumbers, solved problems which posed them when awake. The great mathematician, Condillac, was sometimes enabled in his sleep to bring to a satisfactory conclusion speculations which, in the day, were incomplete. 76 IIEBREW POLITICS. act without the help of those material organs which remain to the corpse on the dissecting-table, but give it no sensations. Yet if we must be content with the faith that our children will have a light not given to us in these things, we shall, I think, find that here, as in so much else, we may — if we will only clearly state to our own minds the question which we know we cannot completely answer — get a kind and degree of knowledge well worth having. For we shall perceive that we are under no necessity to resort to rabbinical or curasi-rabbinical figments in support of the reality of Isaiah's vision, nor to neological devices for getting rid of it : wTe shall be at least in a position to see that there is nothing monstrous in the fact, nor irrational in the belief, of a vision such as the prophet here describes ; and that we have not here one of those prodigies which super- stition delights in, and true no less than false philosophy recoils from, but an event solemn and wonderful indeed, yet having a more matter of fact reality, and a higher interest, to him who seeks to have a reason for his faith than to any other man. But while we thus recognise the prophet's mental state to have been a calm, rational, orderly, human state, we must remember that our Christian faith — nay, our reason, when illumined by faith — forbids us to conceive of this vision as a mere projection of that mental state, and of the seer as be- holding only what his own imagination had first created. Every- thing shows how thoroughly Isaiah was prepared to become the recipient of a communication from on high, but we are not therefore to be content to think that after all there was no actual communication, but only the supposition of it, which would do as well. Get a real personal knowledge of the mes- senger (and you must get this, not from commentators and Cabanis tells us that Franklin so often formed correct and highly important conceptions of persons and political events in his sleep, as to have been inclined to view his dreams with superstitious reverence, while the real fact was, says Cabanis, that the philosopher's acute and sagacious intellect was operating even in his sleep. . . . Cases arc on record of judges who, in their sleep, have delivered decisions of the weightiest kind ; and of poets who, in that state, have composed verses of great power and beauty, though they were by no means exempt from a certain degree of mystical indistinctness." — Sleep and Dreams, by J. A. Symonds, ftl.D. pp. 54. G2 , where the reader will find much more, illustrative of the point we are considering. OBJECTIVE REALITY OF REVELATION. 77 critics, but from hearty study of his own words), and then you will be better able to understand the message — the revelation — which God has employed that man to take to his brethren : for though God can and does speak through instruments uncon- scious of his designs, — a Caesar or a Napoleon, a whirlwind or an earthquake, — yet when He would lead us into the know- ledge of Himself, and of His wisdom and love towards us, He speaks only through men whom He has first qualified them- selves to understand and appreciate the good tidings they bear. But our reason will indeed have become folly, if we deduce from the complete qualifications of the messenger, that he has no message ; from the perfect adaptation of the means to the end, that there is no end. If we will be rational, no less than if we will be Christian, we must steadily recognise the reality — the objective, independent reality — of that communication which Isaiah was thus qualified to become the recipient of. How this could be, hoio God reveals his mind and will to men, how the poetic or other human faculty gives form and expres- sion to truths not imagined nor discovered, but communicated from on high, — this can never be explained: an explanation is a contradiction in terms, an assertion that the Infinite is de- finable, that the Superhuman is subject to the laws, and ex- pressible in terms, of the human. Let the understanding attempt to comprehend the Divine, and that which it has in its grasp inevitably proves not to be the thing inquired for. We must, and well may, be content to know that God has revealed Himself to man, and thankful that man is capable of receiving and benefiting by, though not of defining, that revelation. The throng of formal worshippers would have left the temple ; the voices of the choirs of singers ' clothed in white linen,' and chanting in alternate parts ' O give thanks unto the Loim, for He is good, For His mercy endureth for ever,' or some other appointed psalm, would have died into silence ; and if other devout Israelites were praying apart, if the white- robed priest wras silently presenting their prayers in the fragrant cloud of incense which rose from the golden altar in the holy place, the stillness and solemnity of the scene would be thereby 78 HEBREW POLITICS. heightened rather than disturbed. Then the vail of the temple was withdrawn, and the holy of holies discovered to the pro- phet's eyes ; and he saw the Lord sitting as a king upon his throne, actually governing and judging. His train, the symbol of dignity and glory, filled the holy place ; while around Him hovered the attendant seraphim, spirits of purity, zeal, and love, chanting in alternate choirs the holiness of their Lord: the threshold vibrated with the sound, and the ' white cloud ' of the divine presence, as if descending to mingle itself with the ascending incense of prayer, filled the house. The eternal archetypes of the Hebrew's symbolic worship were revealed to Isaiah; and as the centre of them all his eyes saw the King, the Lord of Hosts, of whom the actual rulers from David to Uzziah had been but the temporary and subordinate viceroys. In that presence, even the spirits of fire, which consumes all impurities Avhile none can mix with it, cover their faces and their feet, conscious that they are not pure in God's sight, but justly chargeable with imperfection : and much more does Isaiah shrink from the aspiring thoughts he had hitherto entertained of his fitness to be the preacher of that God to his countrymen, — he a man of unclean lips, sharing the uncleanness of the people among whom he dwells. In utter self-abasement he realises the exceeding sinfulness of sin, and the utter separation it makes between man and the holy God. Whether we take this chapter to be the first in actual date or no, it is the key to the whole Book ; and the announcement which it makes of the Holiness of the Lord is the key to the chapter. This vision in the temple was to Isaiah what that of the burning bush was to Moses. That God has made a cove- nant with the nation, a true 'original social contract' between king and people, and of the people among themselves ; that each member of the nation is personally responsible for the breach of that covenant ; that the holiness and righteousness of God make it absolutely certain that He will enforce it, at whatever cost to the guilty parties ; yet that the same righteousness causes Him to hold the contract binding on Himself as well as them ; and that therefore He has provided a way of reconcilia- tion between them and Himself through the sacrifice of that which separates them ; — this was what was revealed to Moses, and ISAIAH VI. 1- — 7. : HOLINESS OF GOD. 79 became the ground-work of the whole Hebrew polity. And now that a long course of worldly growth and progress had almost ob- literated this, the old fundamental faith of the nation, the same revelation is renewed to Isaiah when he is to be sent forth as the restorer of what Moses originally established. Every nation arrives from time to time at some crisis, when it must either lose all that it has hitherto gained, and so depart from its place among the nations, or else must shake off the evil, and with renewed strength go forward in its appointed course. And such a crisis had the Jewish nation come to in the time of Isaiah. He was to be God's main though not only instrument for carrying her through the struggle ; he is, therefore, first made to know his own utter insufficiency, and then to realise the sufficiency which comes from God alone. He was a circumcised Jew, a member of the holy, separated, covenanted nation, accustomed to seek purification from the stains of conduct in the rites of the law, and able to understand how those rites were morally efficacious when God accepted the sacrifice of the selfish will by the man of contrite heart. But now the exceeding sinfulness of sin it- self, of his nature not of his acts, was discovered to him ; and he needed the fire from the altar to be applied to his own lips, and not to the bullock or the goat he might have brought for sacrifice, and by God's own ministry, and not by the earthly priest : and this was done as a sacramental and effi- cacious pledge that he had now received that inmost purification which is the baptism of the Holy Ghost and of fire.* 'Fire,' says Vitringa, ' is something pure, burning, purifying ; it lays hold of, penetrates, and, as it were, converts into its own sub- stance whatever is susceptible of its action, thus hallowing the gifts laid on the altar. All these are the attributes of the Holy Ghost, whose office it is to purge and illuminate man, to excite him to the love of God, to affect him with zeal for His glory, to arouse him from sloth to fervour, to inflame him with courage and constancy, with energy and devotion of all his powers to the cause of God, and to enable him to make supplications to God according to His will. And in this place fire signifies the spirit of prophecy, which spirit, like fire, sanctifies men in a peculiar * Compare St. Paul's conversion, Acts, ix. 80 HEBREW POLITICS. manner to this great work, kindles, inflames, makes them glow with zeal ; and, what is true in itself and specially applicable here, converts them into seraphs.'- God desired a willing mes- senger; therefore Pie does not command Isaiah to take on him the office, but gives him opportunity to do so if he be willing. And the prophet, now filled with the Holy Ghost, and feeling that in that power he is made holy, immediately pro- poses himself as ready to accept the commission. It has been, and is still discussed, whether, in the words ' Who will go for us ? ' as in the like use of the plural pronoun in other places in the Old Testament, there is a reference to the Trinity ; or wdiether the phrase is ' merely the plural of majesty,' or some other idiom. There is something opposed to all our present habits of thought and criticism in the notion that a word of this kind can be made to prove a dogma ; yet to the mind which recognises a deeper meaning in words than the merely grammatical, the latter explanation will seem a very poor sub- stitute for the old dogmatic interpretation. It would be better to ask what is the origin of the ' plural of majesty.' Majesty, or grcatemess, is the attribute of the personal head of a body, not that of a solitary individual. /is the word of mere will, good or evil ; ice, that of counsel, fellowship, and co-operation ; and the plural of the latter expresses a higher unity than the singu- lar of the former. There is a higher unity in the marriage of man and wife than in the single half-existence of either sepa- rately, and in the Godhead which is the object of the Christian's faith than in the solitary Being whom the Mahometan or the Unitarian worships. ' The first cause,' &nys Aristotle, ' is the last in discovery.' When it is at last revealed, we can look back and trace its workings in forms where it could not have been recognised at the time. And thus we, by the fulness of the light of the Gospel, can see in the language which combines the plural Elohim with the singular Jehovah, the preludings of that revelation of the Trinity in Unity, which the spirit of man was not yet educated to receive in its spiritual meaning, and the formal announcement of which could, therefore, have only con- firmed and perpetuated his natural pronencss to polytheism. The prophet is ' sent,' has a commission. This seems to be primarily and properly implied in the Hebrew words which we ISAIAH, VI. 8 — 10.: CALVINISM. 81 translate ' prophet ' and 'prophesy.' The Jew understood him to be * one who spoke not his own words, but those of another,' as Philo says ; one who was sent from God as His ambassador and interpreter : — as is evident from the (on this point) classical passage, Exodus, vii. 1., where God says to Moses, I make thee a god to Pharaoh : and Aaron thy brother shall he thy prophet. The verb, too, is always used in the passive voice, in the Hebrew, to imply the same idea.* * To hear and not understand, to see and not perceive,' is used by Demosthenes as a proverb. It is here the expression of the sternest irony ; first as addressed to the people themselves, and then to the prophet, in reference to the effect of his preaching. As though the Lord had said, ' You are warned ; disobey the warning, and take the consequences.' It is the will in men which believes and obeys, or hardens itself and rebels. Believing and obeying, Gud blesses it with ever- increasing light and power ; but if it refuses this light and power to walk in God's way, God does not permit it to retain these for its merely worldly and selfish purposes.! We not only may, but must, reject all those notions of God's character (some- times called Calvinistic, and with which it cannot be denied that Calvin did at times discolour his noble Christian faith) which make Him out to be a Being of mere arbitrary power, or with His attributes of wisdom, righteousness, and love, all limited by a lower than human caprice. But while we refuse to hear such a doctrine of devils, though an angel from heaven should preach it to us, let us also beware not to fall into the error, equally false, and equally pernicious, of bringing God's justice and * Gesenius, Lexicon, words N33 and N'OJ, under the former of which he mentions the like usage of the Latin deponent verbs, to express the same class of notions : as, loqui, fart, vaticinari, &c. See, too, Ewald, Die Propheten, i, 6., to the like effect. f ".But when we in our viciousness grow hard, O misery on't ! the wise gods seel our eyes ; In our own filth drop our clear judgments ; make us Adore our errors ; laugh at us while we strut To our confusion." Antony and Cleopatra, iii. 11. Quoted by Mr. Trench, Notes on the Parables, p. 12., where the reader will find some instructive observations on this subject. G 82 HEBREW POLITICS. goodness down to the debased standard of worldly and sensual men, and of allowing ourselves to assume that it would be either just or merciful in God to permit men to go on inde- finitely in sin. There is nothing but the irreconcilable con- trariety between good and evil, holiness and sin, and the triumph of the former at any cost, to prevent our eventually arriving at that reign of power without justice, will without love, intellect without heart, which we may condemn in the form of ' Calvinism,' but to which we are continually tending, when we suspect it not, and are only brought back by God's judg- ment upon sinners ; — that reign in which the only God would be the devil.* And if it were anywhere necessary thus to assert God's righteousness against sin, most especially was it so in this the chosen nation of Israel. Israel had been set apart, that in him all the nations of the earth should be blessed ; and if he became reprobate, where were this promise to the world? — 'If gold rusteth, what should iron do?' Therefore the cities were to be wasted without inhabitant, and the land utterly desolate; and even after a partial recovery from this punishment, and a humble restoration of a small part of their ancient glory, the stern process should be repeated again and again : the invasion of Pekah and Rezin would be repaired only to be followed by that of Sennacherib ; the captivity of Manasseh would succeed the peaceful reign of Hezekiah ; Josiah would restore the king- dom only to be laid waste by the Egyptian and the Assyrian ; the Roman would come after the Greek, and even Hadrian after Titus. All thought of an earthly glory of the nation must give way before such a prospect. If the prophet looked forward with a patriot's hopes alone, there was nothing but humiliation and despair before him ; he could at most expect but such temporary alleviation and restoration as might enable him to do his work while he was there. No doubt — we shall come upon the proofs immediately — the prophet did not in the earlier years of his ministry take this view of the meaning of the promise with which the divine commission concludes ; but still trusted that the holy seed, the substance of the nation, * I need hardly remind the reader of Southcy's picture of what such a reign would be ; — the Curse of Kehmmi. ISAIAH VI. 11 — 13.: DESTRUCTION AND RESTORATION. 83 would spring up again, even in his own day, and Israel be re- stored to more than its pristine prosperity and power among the nations, as well as to its first and pure faith in its Lord. And when the terrible truth did at last become clear to him, he had been prepared to understand, and to declare to his own people, and to mankind, what more than adequate compensation was still behind. I have followed what seems the more probable meaning of verse 13., yet venture to observe that our Version makes a satisfactory sense, if we understand an allusion (by one of those poetical transitions which characterise Isaiah's strong imagination) to the tithes, the sacred portion of the produce of the land, and to their being duly gathered in and eaten by those to whom they pertained, and not to any wasteful con- sumption of them. Whether the concluding image of the teil (or terebinth) and the oak trees, is that of their casting their leaves, or of their being cut down, like the tree in Nebuchad- nezzar's dream, is uncertain. In either case the idea of the life subsisting under the apparent death is the same. G 2 84 HEBREW POLITICS. CHAPTER VI. ISAIAH, VII. — THE ACCESSION OF AHAZ. — POLITICAL STATE OF KING AND PEOPLE. 'THE LORD SAID.' TOPOGRAPHY OF JERUSALEM. THE VIR- GIN CONCEIVING. THE INCARNATION AN UNIVERSAL IDEA HOW REALISED. LOSS OF HEBREW INDEPENDENCE. ISAIAH NOT A MAGICIAN. The next, and following prophecies, to the end of chapter xvl., belong, with more or less clearness, to the reign of Ahaz. The ' And' with which the narrative opens here, and in chapter viii., seems among the indications that the book has been arranged as a continuous whole; perhaps we might say the same of the beginning of chapter ii. The reign of Jotham was characterised (as I have already- observed) by the same material prosperity and order, internal and external, political and religious, as that of his father Uzziah : the difference (not easily perceptible at the time) will have been that a new generation was grown up, enervated by peace and luxury, and trusting as a matter of course to old traditional routine, when they were on the eve of events to which it would be as inapplicable as that of the Austrians and Prussians, in the generation after that of Frederic the Great, was to meet the young enthusiasm of the French under Napoleon. The three narratives of these events — that before us, and those in the books of Kings and Chronicles — present those discrepancies which, however troublesome to reconcile, are just such as men accustomed to jostle with facts in police-courts or jury-boxes consider among the proofs that they are hearing a true story, and not a forgery ; but which some book-students (whose critical canons are quite other than those of the Niebuhrs, Grotes, or Arnolds) take for indications of ignorance or fraud, and throw aside accordingly. But there is little real difficulty, if we follow those commentators who combine the various accounts thus : — In the last years of Jotham's reign, Pekah king of Israel, and EVENTS ON THE ACCESSION OF AHAZ. 85 Rezin, king of Syria, made an alliance against Judah ; and the accession of the weak youth Ahaz gave them a favourable op- portunity for their purpose. A great battle annihilated the old army of Uzziah (as that of Jena did the army of Frederic) ; the invaders plundered and wasted the whole country, and car- ried off a great multitude of men, women, and children, of whom the share of the Syrians was sold into slavery at Da- mascus, while that of the Ephraimites was sent back by the intervention of the prophet Obed, who recognised, and induced his countrymen to recognise, a bond and claim of brotherhood in the common blood and faith which their national enmities had lost sight of. Up to the falling of this unexpected blow, Ahaz, and his princes and people, no doubt retained the insolent self-confidence denounced by Isaiah in the previous chapters: but now their scoffing demand, that * the Lord would hasten His work that they might see it,' had been granted ; and when they heard that the allies were preparing for a second invasion, of which the object was, not merely the reaping another year's harvest of plunder, but also the taking of Jerusalem, the depo- sition of the house of David, and the permanent subjection of the kingdom under a viceroy or tributary king, like those whom Sennacherib, in his lately deciphered annals, says he set up in Chald&a, Phoenicia, and Philistia, after conquering those coun- tries*; — then the people and their rulers were panic-struck ; ' and their hearts were moved, as the trees of the wood are moved by the wind.' We may then understand by ' Syria resteth upon Ephraim,' either 'has renewed the old alliance,' which, con- sidering the disorganised and half-barbarised state of these petty governments, was likely enough to have been only made for single campaigns ; or else ' has encamped on the territory of Ephraim,' as if preparing for a fresh march into Judaea. The scornful phrase, ' the two smoking tails of firebrands,' * One of these, Tubaal, is conjectured by Colonel Rawlinson {Outline of the Histoi'y of Assyria, p. 22.) to have been the son of the man here men- tioned. This may seem fanciful ; but if the name stands good, we have a somewhat parallel case in the way in which Merodach Baladan appears, in the same annals, to have been king and fugitive alternately. There were no doubt particular chieftains and clans more powerful and aspiring than others, in the series of barbarous irruptions which now broke from the North. g 3 86 HEBREW POLITICS. seems to imply that they had already been wasting the country, and that the prophet foresaw that their power was just extinct : and if the main calamities of Pekah and Rezin's invasion had occurred after this prophecy was delivered, the discrepancy between its promises and their fulfilment would have been so great, that it is difficult to understand how it should have been preserved as authentic, for Isaiah himself would have doubted its entirely genuine inspiration. The improbability of Ahaz having any fears till after the destruction of his army has been already mentioned. Let the reader form a distinct image, from the narratives, of the position of Jerusalem and its people at this juncture, and he will see its exact correspondence with that described in chapter i. There is a singular pathos, as well as force, in the phrase ' the house of David,' in this place. David had succeeded in uniting the ancient factions of Israel and Judah into one strong monarchy * : when it was told him that the kings of the earth were gathering themselves together against him, he felt no fear, but went forth at the head of his armies, and in the name of the Lord destroyed them ; and among other nations whom he thus reduced, were the Syrians of Damascus, whose capital he garrisoned, and made themselves tributary. And now, the house of David had not only long lost the tribes of Israel, but was trembling for its own existence, threatened by those tribes, who had already almost annihilated Judah * in a rage that reached up to heaven,' and were now returning in confederacy with this very Syria to a new attack. And the faith no less than the might of David had departed from him who sat in David's throne : Ahaz had no trust in the Lord of the nation, and therefore his heart was moved, and he called on Assyria and Assyria's gods to help him. * Then said the Lord unto Isaiah ' — not by some mira- culous communication, alien from all human experience, and of which neither the reality nor the worth is proved by say- ing that Isaiah's writings are a part of the Bible ; but by that inward and spiritual command which is daily and hourly telling each of us what is our work, and how we are to do * 2 Sam. v. 1 — 5. ISAIAH VII. 1 — 3.: TOPOGRAPHY OF JERUSALEM. 87 it. Luther, in his Commentary on Genesis, in the midst of statements which show that he had no doubts of the oc- currence of miracles either in his own or any other age, makes singular efforts to give a non-miraculous character to the expression * the Lord said ; ' explaining that it was Adam who spoke to Eve, Shem to Abraham, and so on. The great preacher of the Word felt and knew that the mightiest, divinest, presence and power of the Holy Spirit, manifested itself through properly human discourse, and not by some voice in the air. When it is taught and received for orthodox that God only revealed Himself to men in former times by certain occasional and external miracles, and that our knowledge of Him is limited to what has been written down of such communi- cations, we have reason to fear that we have too little sense that God is always actively present with us now, and to suspect that our belief is mechanical, and sceptical and superstitious at once. A Luther, or even a Cromwell, would have shrunk from dishonour- ing the Spirit of God within lum, by supposing that it was not by the same wisdom and the same power as inspired Isaiah, that he spoke and acted in the Diet of Worms, or on the field of Dunbar. Ancient topography is so often obscure, even when learned men get to the spot with their books in their hands, that perhaps it ought not to seem strange that it is yet disputed whether the ' highway of the Fuller's Field ' was on the west or the north of the city. For the former, Dr. Robinson quotes an authority of the middle ages, who speaks of a ' gate of the Fuller's Field ' in the west wall ; while he thinks, also, that no where else can the * upper pool of Gihon ' be well placed : for the latter, Mr. Wil- liams (also an investigator of the actual localities), observes that Josephus says, the ' Fuller's monument ' was on the north side of the city, where also was the traditional site of the e camp of the Assyrians,' which seems to point to Rab-shakeh's army; and he gives his own explanation of the water. I am not com- petent to judge between these learned writers, and those who have sided with each. But for reasons which I shall give when we come to Hezekiah's preparations for the expected siege of Sennacherib, the latter supposition enables me to form and to present to the reader a more coherent notion of what must g 4 88 HEBREW POLITICS. have taken place on the various occasions in which we require a picture — if only a fancy one — of the Jerusalem of that day ; and I, therefore, assume the highway of the * Fuller's Field ' to have been outside the northern gate which opened into the road to Samaria, and by which (as we see from chapter x. 28 — 32.), an army marching on Jerusalem might be expected. Isaiah, like the other prophets, taught not only by verbal discourse, but also by symbolical acts, which, especially in those times, gave a life and force to the former which it would not have had by itself. Accordingly he now takes with him his son Shear-jashub (< a remnant shall return '), who was not impro- bably born during the grief and terror of the late invasion (in which Isaiah may himself have lost other children or relations), and was thus named as a sign to the people.* He finds Ahaz, no doubt accompanied, in oriental fashion, by a throng of people, just outside the wall of the city, examining the state of the fortifications, and of the reservoirs which, fed by the brook Gihon, were situated in that quarter, and which it was now necessary to provide for the defence of, that they might neither be available to the expected besiegers, nor cut off by them from supplying the city. The fullers had their works there, for the convenience of the water, and the causeway which led to their fulling ground was a convenient place for the purposes of both Ahaz and Isaiah, just as it suited Eab-shakehf when it was his object both to reconnoitre the ground for a siege, and also to harangue the people on the walls. Hitherto we have known the prophet as a writer, and through his writings ; now he comes before us as a speaker. The pre- sent and following chapters are much more like a report of actual speeches than the first five chapters ; and the narrative and oration together give us a lively picture of how Isaiah did speak, or preach, there in Jerusalem. Isaiah tells Ahaz not to fear any further mischief from these two firebrands, now all but burnt out : each prides himself in his nation and city, and in himself as the head of these, but the Lord God laughs them to scorn, and decrees that their policy shall not stand nor come to pass, but that they themselves shall be * Compare chap. viii. 18. t Chap, xxxvi. 2. ISAJAII VII. 7 — 14. : THE VIRGIN CONCEIVING. 89 broken instead, and be no more nations. Yet to this prediction of the overthrow of the invaders of Judah, he adds, that Judah, too, shall likewise perish if it repents not : * If ye will not believe, surely ye shall not be established.' The reader will find in Dr. Alexander, and other commentators, the various attempts which have been made to clear up the obscure parallelism of verses 8 and 9., and the still greater obscurity of the date I sixty-five.' The latter cannot be proved either to agree or to disagree with history, unless we could first fix the exact year of this prediction, and also of the event to which it refers ; and as this has not yet been done, it will be more convenient to take another opportunity of considering these specific dates in He- brew prophecy. Ahaz heard in sullen and incredulous silence ; and the prophet resumes, — Ask thee a sign of the Lord thy God ; Ask it either in the depth, or in the height above. But Ahaz, who looked on the Lord not as his God, but only (like any of his heathen neighbours) as the god of Judaea, and as such inferior to the god of Assyria; and who had determined to apply to the king of Assyria, or perhaps had already applied to him, as a more trustworthy helper than the Lord, in the present strait ; declines to ask a sign, excusing himself by a canting use of the words of Moses, * Thou shall not tempt the Lord.' He refused the sign, because he knew it would con- firm the still struggling voice of his conscience ; and that voice he had resolved not to obey, since it bid him give up the As- syrian, and trust in the Lord henceforth. The question whether Isaiah could have performed a miracle if Ahaz had taken him at his word, the reader will find dis- cussed hereafter : only I would here observe that if Isaiah, or those who recorded for him the present prophecy, had been influenced by that notion of the value of miracles of which I have spoken above, and which, however orthodox it may call itself, is repudiated by Christ and his Apostles, the narrative before us would hardly have been given in its present shape, in which the promise of 'the virgin conceiving' is treated as a far higher sign than any which could be exhibited in the 90 HEBREW POLITICS. depths of earth or height of heaven. A comparison with Exod. iii. 12., and Isaiah, xxxvii. 30., throws some light upon the use of the word 'sign' in the present instance, and upon the mental state of the speaker and hearers which could recog- nise a propriety in a sign of which the force was only to be seen after the event. There may seem little difficulty in the whole passage to those who are content to ' take for granted ' that it has some good meaning, and to express this feeling in the accustomed formula that ' the words are a prophecy of Christ ; ' but he who tries to discover what the meaning really is — what ' a prophecy of Christ ' means — will find need for fur- ther examination. To believe in a person, is to trust him because we know and love him ; but to believe a narrative, an argument, or a prophecy, about him, is to understand it. And to under- stand the passage before us, we must understand what manner of man the speaker was ; what he was actually saying, and meaning ; what import his words had to those who heard him ; what import they have to us. We must, if possible, bridge over the gulf of apparently unknown depth and width which separates us from Isaiah, as he stood that day ( at the end of the conduit of the upper pool in the highway of the fuller's field.' The help which I pretend to offer the reader is slight and im- perfect enough ; nothing more than some hints of a method which I can follow out but a little way, though I believe it to be the true method, which in abler hands will lead to more im- portant results. But if we cannot solve our difficulties it is something to know precisely what they are, and to state them to ourselves clearly. The original shows, I think, what indeed is sufficiently ap- parent in the most modern and accurate versions, that, on the refusal of Ahaz to ask a sign of the Lord's faithfulness to His people, Isaiah breaks into an apostrophe — the utter- ance at once of an orator and a poet — in which the speaker is carried forward by the power of a mental impulse, which for the time controls him, rather than he it. No one who has listened to a great orator, or even read the words of an impassioned writer like Burke or Carlyle, can be wholly un- aware that the one and the other is, for the time, possessed and mastered by such a power ; — a power which heathens ECSTASY OF ORATORS. 91 have continually recognised as spiritual and divine, and which we have been too much deterred from so acknowledging, because we see it employed for bad as well as for good ends, and forget that no where in the world of nature is this mysterious mixture of good and evil absent. And this elevated, ecstatic frame of the orator, as of the poet, is still more marked among southern and eastern nations. I am told that Mazzini's denunciations of the oppressor, and predictions of his country's future social and political regeneration, are at times uttered by him with an in- conceivable fervour, rising into the tone of song rather than of mere eloquence. The reader's own observation and experience will supply him with other illustrations, sufficient to enable him to realise this characteristic of the prophet — that he was an orator, whose oratory was of the noblest kind, for manner no less than matter ; and that, consequently, as often as his love of his country and his zeal for his God raised him to the height of some great argument, his words necessarily became, and in the present instance manifestly are, the expression of thoughts and feelings which pass beyond the limits which, in a cooler mo- ment, perhaps only the moment before or after, his senses and logical faculty would have imposed upon them. The thoughts and feelings were really his, and such as the whole culture of his soul, intellectual, moral, religious, had made it possible for them to be, yet such as nothing but an occasion like the present — and we have not yet considered the whole spiritual import of that occasion — could have called into expression. Isaiah had gone down to the Fuller's Field intending in his own mind to address the king in the words which we have in verses 4 — 9, and to support this address by such symbolic emphasis as an oriental people would feel at the sight of the child Shear-jashub. And it may already have occurred to him — or, if not, he took it as the fitting course immediately afterwards — to resolve, and publicly announce his resolution, to call his next child by a name which should tell all who heard it that the riches of Da- mascus and the spoil of Samaria should be shortly taken away by the king of Assyria ; and thus to offer this second, and yet unborn son, as a new sign to the king and people, like that already given them in Shear-jashub. But his spirit was stirred by the behaviour of Ahaz, first to offer any other sign the un- 92 , HEBREW POLITICS. believing king chose, and next, still indeed to couple his warnings and promises with a reference to the unborn child, but now in language not for that age but for all times : the vision rises before him, the bounds of time and place fade away, and he says, Hear ye now, O house of David, Is it a small thing for you to weary men, But will ye weary my God also ? Therefore the Lord Himself shall give you a sign : See ! the Virgin, with child and bearing a Son, And she calls his name Immanuel. These are the words of passion and ecstasy, and as such must be read, in order to take the first step towards understanding them. The discourse then sinks to a lower level, though with a partially renewed vehemence in verse 17.; and the rest of it is in the same tone as that with which Isaiah began at first, and with the same immediate reference to passing events. If the words just quoted stood alone — that is, recorded as having been actually spoken, but existing in no real relation with any facts of other times and men, — we must either pro- nounce them simply miraculous, or else be content with what- ever was most probable of the several explanations by which the so-called rationalist critics try and reduce them to ordinary dimensions, even though it were merely that of calling them the words of eastern hyperbole and exaggeration. But the case is otherwise : history tells us that a belief in, or expectation of, an Immanuel — or incarnate God — has prevailed in all times, and among all nations ; and so strong was the vitality of this be- lief among the Greeks and Romans, that when the progress of intellect had made it impossible for them to retain it any longer in its old mythological forms, they revived it in the far more monstrous assertion of the divinity of the emperors ; and Tacitus, Suetonius, and Virgil tell us of various other shapes in which it was presenting itself in their own times of scepticism and civilisation. Brahminism and Buddhism are witnesses of the same pervading instinct of mankind ; and not less so is the reception of Christianity by every tribe of the human race, as something not foreign, but most congenial, to their religious — PACTS, NOT DOCTRINES, TIIE CHRISTIAN CREED. 93 that is, their deepest — wants and sympathies. This class of historical facts then are another set of materials, not less neces- sary to the understanding of our subject than those by which we endeavour to realise a prophet as an actual flesh and blood man, who took part in the politics and social interests of his time, just as we do now. A third class still remains, though even that will not exhaust the enquiry. We are not Jews in the time of Isaiah, Greeks or Romans in the times of Virgil or Tacitus, nor is our knowledge of life and truth derived from India or Tibet. We are Englishmen and Christians, here in the nineteenth century, and we stand on a van- tage-ground which enables us to see the relations of things, and, consequently, their meaning, in a way not otherwise possible. Reader, do you believe in Jesus Christ, who was born of the Virgin Mary ? Is that old creed the expression to and for you of a series of facts (not doctrines) at once historical, and in the inmost relation to your own spiritual and personal life and expe- rience ? If not, how can I continue to discuss our subject with you by that rational, scientific method, which to depart from is to write mere words without meaning ? For non-acquaintance with these facts in a student of the Bible is what non-acquaint- ance with the existence of the stars and planets would be in as- tronomy, or that of mountains and rivers in geology. But let us take our stand on the facts of the Gospel of Jesus Christ ; let us look for the law in the facts ; and then we shall be able to examine all past history, and especially the history of the He- brew nation, in the light of that law. It then appears that it was no fancy, but the assertion of a — or rather the — law of universal ethnology, which foretold that in the race of Abraham ' all nations of the earth should be blessed.' The Romans were called to embody and develope in their institutions the ideas of law, and of municipal and imperial government ; the Greeks to instruct mankind in free inquiry, philosophy, and art ; and every other tribe and people, which has not abandoned its duty by sinking into mere brute life, has contributed its larger or smaller waters to the great stream of human life and progress : the He- brews were appointed to set forth and realise in their polity and literature the true relation of man to God, and — what the so- called rationalist with his recognition of the 'religious senti- 94 HEBREW POLITICS. ment ' overlooks — the relation of God to man. He who has looked into his own heart, and there learnt that his religion, his faith, consists not in this religious sentiment, but in God's reve- lation and communication of Himself to him in His Son Jesus Christ, can then look around and behind him, and see that the same God did in past times reveal Himself in several and suc- cessive manifestations to and through this Hebrew nation. Their whole polity is seen to be a preparation for an universal society which is to spring out of it : their whole literature shapes itself to become a manual for that society : that fundamental idea which philosophers say lies at the root of every nation, and by which its multitude unconsciously, and its rulers and teachers with more or less perception of its presence, are age after age urged forward to their appointed goal, as by force of irresist- ible law, was in the Hebrews the idea of the coming of a Lord and King of mankind no less than of their own people. They could not have been fit for any of these ends if they had been less human, and if their polity had been less in harmony with the laws of man and the universe than the polities of the Greeks and Romans : it needed to be more in harmony, and it must have been more so in fact, for more has been able to survive, and pass into new and very diverse forms of society. But being fit for these, because the original laws and subsequent developments of their polity and literature lay in such near relation with the ultimate laws of human nature and society, they were thus also fitted — fitted by God who has created and governs the universe according to the counsel of His own will — to become the chan- nel of God's revelation of Himself to all mankind. The question whether there actually is such a revelation in the Bible is a question of fact, and must be settled by each of us for himself, just as each settles for himself on the evidence of fact, and not of argument, whether there the sun gives light and heat to his body ; but to those who have found such a revelation there, or who choose to assume it even for the pleasure of reasoning, it is plain that — Christ being the centre of the revelation — all that comes before Him will have a prophetic character. All nature, all humanity, must be prophetic, if it is progressive, and its progress the unfolding of the powers of a law inherent in it from the first : the philosophy of the Greeks, the municipalities CAUSES ANTICIPATE THEIR FINAL EFFECTS. 95 of the Romans, could be nothing to us now if they — that is, the law in them, and cause of their existing effects — had not anticipated all their present fruits ; and even the warlike am- bition, which brought the seeds of these, and many such things, into Britain or elsewhere, was a part of the same anticipatory working of the same law. And, therefore, much more is it evident, that reason and historical science require us to recog- nise the like workings in the growth of the Hebrew common- wealth and people, and in their relations to their Creator and their fellow-men. The evidence of the anticipation of a personal Messiah by the Hebrews from very early times, and of its con- tinually acquiring a more distinct and positive character, is well known to the student of the Old Testament. But the prophecy of Micah, Isaiah's contemporary, has a special bearing on the subject ; he says, — ' But thou, Bethlehem Ephratah, Though thou be little among the thousands of Judah, Yet out of thee shall he come forth unto me that is to be ruler in Israel ; Whose goings forth have been from of old, from everlasting. Therefore will he give them up Until the time that she which travaileth hath brought forth : Then the remnant of his brethren shall return unto the children of Israel, And he shall stand and feed in the strength of the Lord, In the majesty of the name of the Lord his God ; And they shall abide : For now shall he be great unto the ends of the earth.'* Even if we should assume that one of these predictions was suggested by the other (though the differences indicate at least a partial independence), or suppose both to refer to some earlier prophecy, they are not the less indications of a national belief and expectation of a mysterious birth of the Messiah. Nor can we avoid connecting them with that most ancient tradition of ' the seed of the woman ' on the one hand, and with that state of the national Jewish mind on the other, which is implied in the narratives of Matthew and Luke, who relate the incarnation * Micah, v. 2, 3, 4. 96 HEBREW TOLITICS. of Jesus Christ as an event miraculous indeed, yet not contrary or alien from the ancient faith, but as the fulfilment of its deepest anticipations. If, then, we comprehend these two sides of the case together : if we see on the one hand that Isaiah was an actual practical politician of the day in which he lived ; and on the other that it is not the dogma of a worn-out superstition, but the assertion of the newest and most accurate philosophy, — the philosophy of positive science, — to say and believe with St. Peter, that ' no prophecy of the Scripture is of any private interpretation ; for the prophecy came not in old time by the will of man; but holy men of God spake as they were moved by the Holy Ghost;'* — if we grasp these ideas at once, we shall, I think, have no insurmountable difficulty in the words of Isaiah which immediately follow, and in which he fuses into one image the birth of the Immanuel and that of his own child, and declares, in direct reference to the latter, that before he has learnt to distinguish good from evil (come to years of discretion, as we say), he shall be sharing the general prosperity — the old proverbial blessing f — of his native land, which before then shall have seen the land of her present invaders — spoken of as one, be- cause its kings were confederate — itself laid waste, after having first lost both those kings. In about three years from this time, Tiglath-Pileser overthrew the kingdom of Syria, killed Rezin, carried away the Damascenes and Syrians into Assyria and Media J : it is one of the newly opened questions whether * 2 Peter, i. 20, 21. This passage (of which the Petrine spirit at least is not questioned); that in chapter i. 10, 11, 12. of the 1st Epistle; and Peter's argument in Acts, ii. 22—36. ; offer to him who will reflect on them, an important, perhaps I might say a complete light, on prophecy, both as it appeared to the genuine Hebrew mind, and as it is in itself, accord- ing to its philosophic idea. The simple, lowly-wise, fisherman, argues that the meaning of these words of David was not exhausted in their application to himself, they were not fulfilled in him ; yet that they are not the words of hyperbole and bombast, but the utterances of a prophet, of one of those wise and good men whom God chooses from time to time to reveal his uni- versal laws and plans by ; and that therefore we must seek in history for the adequate fulfilment of them. t Deut. xxvi. 9.; Josh. v. 6. \ 2 Kings, xvi. i). ISA. VII. 17 — 25.: FINAL LOSS OF NATIONAL INDEPENDENCE. 97 Samaria was not taken at the same time* ; but at least we know that he took several cities in the north of Israel, and car- ried away the people of all the northern half of that kingdom; and that Pekah's own assassination by Hoshea, followed this devastation of his country. f Isaiah has hardly uttered the promise of deliverance and restored prosperity, when he retracts it. The abrupt beginning of verse 17. seems to mark a pause, in which the national sin of Ahaz and his people, and the fact that they had already called in, or at least resolved to call in, the aid of Assyria, come back upon the prophet ; and he goes on to foretel the beginning of calamities such as the nation had never yet known. With the exception of the temporary subjection of Rehoboam to Egypt, Judah had hitherto preserved its national independence : but from this application of Ahaz to Tiglath-Pileser was to date * its transition to a servile state, from which,' observes Dr. Alex- ander, 'it was never permanently freed, the domination of Assyria being soon succeeded by that of Egypt, and this by that of Babylon, Persia, Syria, and Rome, the last ending only in the downfal of the state, and that general dispersion which continues to this day. The revolt of Hezekiah, and even longer intervals of liberty in later times, are mere interruptions of the customary and prevailing bondage.' Ahaz intended to 'hire' the Assyrian razor for his own purposes ; but the Lord would employ the same instrument to execute His judgments ; and in the consequent desolations of the land, that prophecy of the child eating milk and honey would indeed be fulfilled, but after another manner than its terms seemed at first to imply. If they had believed and trusted in the Lord for deliverance* they should have continued to eat the fat of the land ; but now the cultivated fields should be laid waste, and their cultivators scat- tered by the sword or famine. Here and there a surviving in- habitant, who has saved a young cow and two sheep from the wreck of his property, shall feed upon the butter and milk they yield him, in an abundance which but mocks the general de- * Raw Vinson's Outline of the History of Assy?-ia, p. 15. By the last ac- counts Colonel Rawlinson still suspends his judgment as to the identity or otherwise of Tiglath-Pileser, Shalmanes^r, and Sargon. f 2 Kings, xv. 29, 30. H 98 HEBREW POLITICS. solation : for their pastures are the hill-sides, heretofore so care- fully terraced and worked by man's hand, while the well-stocked vineyards which once bore such a high price*, are turned into mere briers and thorns, where men go with arrows and with bows, to seek wild game, or to protect themselves from savage beasts or more savage men. Bees may, or may not, abound as much in Assyria as flies in Egypt ; but it does not seem a mere fancy of the commentators, who see a propriety in the fierceness and stings of the one, and the filth, buzzing, and comparative feebleness of the other. f The books of Kings and Chronicles say nothing of any intercourse, friendly or hostile, with Egypt in the reign of Ahaz ; but as an alliance with this kingdom was a part of the policy of the states- men of Hezekiah a few years later, it may have been under discussion now, or an application even may have been made to them as well as to Tiglath-Pileser. That the land of Judah was harassed, plundered, and overrun by the Assyrian armies, and the collectors of his tribute, in this and the next reigns, and not by the Egyptians, will not appear to detract from the sub- stantial accuracy of Isaiah's words, if we have once cleared our minds of the superstitious and profane notion that he was a sort of magician and soothsayer, and employed by God as such ; and can realize that he was a man of like heart and mind with * The German vineyards are valued at so much a vine, and among them the vines of Johannisburg at a ducat each, according to J. D. Michaelis : those of Lebanon were rated at a piastre each in 1811, according to Burck- hardt ; and this latter sum Henderson calculates to be a half less than the price in the text, which was probably high in proportion to the value of money. A comparison, however, with Canticles, viii. 11, 12. might lead us to suppose the reference here also to the rent rather than the price. See Gesenius and Alexander on the verse. j 'HwT€ eBvea eis rwv edvea. ttoAAo veuiv diro Ka) (cAitnaW, K.r.A. Hum. II. 0, 87. 'Hi/re fiviauv bSivaoov edvea TroAAct, a'lre Kara (»1 b> elapivij, ore re yAuyos &y^ea Sevc-i' k. r. A. lb. 461). MEN SENT FROM GOD. 99 ourselves, — truly sent from God, yet not more truly than each of us must be, if he is to do any work, not worse than useless, in the world. We may hold this belief all the more consistently for believing also that the work of the prophets, and of the other Scripture writers, was different from that of any men before or since : — 'If the whole body were an eye, where were the hearing?' h 2 100 IIEBREAV POLITICS. CHAPTER VII. ISAIAn vnr. IX. 7. THE symbolical family. ANCIENT and modern HABITS OF PUBLIC MEN. SILOAH AND EUPHRATES. THE PANIC OF JUDAH, AND ITS REMEDY. GALILEE OF THE GENTILES. THE NATIONAL GLOOM. THE GREAT LIGHT. THE MESSIAH. — GRADUAL DEVELOPMENT OF THE PROPHET'S ANTICIPATIONS. We have seen how Isaiah, during his late interview with Ahaz, was possessed by the idea of a child of his being a sign to the people of their deliverance from present invasion. In the first chapter of Hosea occurs a like instance of symbolic names given by a prophet to his children, and in Habakkuk, ii. 2. we have mention of the practice of writing a prophecy on a tablet in easily legible characters, and hanging it up in the temple, market-place, or other public resort ; from a comparison with which the most modern commentators prefer to think that Isaiah now merely inscribed ' To Maher-shalal-hash-baz,' on a metal or waxed tablet ; — though it must not be overlooked that the direction to ' tie up and seal the testimony,' in verse 16., is in favour of the older version, which understands him to have made a record of his expectation of the birth of the child, and of the significance of that birth, at some length. He wrote e with a man's pen,' or ' style,' — a phrase not unlike our ' common hand,' or ' popular style ; ' and he took as credible witnesses that the record had preceded the event, Uriah, the high priest at the time*, and Zcchariah, who was not impro- bably the father-in-law of Ahaz, and a Levite.f He calls his wife ' the prophetess,' as the wife of a king is called a queen (says Vitringa), though she does not reign, and, in some old ecclesiastical canons, the wife of a bishop a bishopess, and of a presbyter, a presbytress ; and thus claims for her a place with her husband and children \ in the holy and symbolic family, * 2 Kings, xvi. 10. f 2 Kings, xviii. 2., 2 Chron. xxix. 1. 13. \ See verse 18. of this chapter. ISAIAH, VIII. 1 — 6.: HABITS OF PUBLIC MEN. 101 who are for ' a sign in Israel.' She gave birth to a child, and his name was called, in accordance with the writing, ' Haste- plunder, Speed-spoil,' that the people might understand that before he Avas old enough to utter the words ' father ' and *■ mother,' — that is, within a short but somewhat indefinite period, such as we should express by ' in a year or two from his birth,' — the spoils of the plundered cities of Samaria and Damascus, the capitals of the nations now invading Judah, shall have been carried before the Assyrian conqueror in triumph. That the same child was also called ' Immanuel,' seems more in accordance with the text than the supposition that Immanuel was a third son, though the sense is intelligible either way. In order to realize the practical impressiveness of such sym- bolic acts and names upon Isaiah's contemporaries, we must re- member that Jerusalem was a very small town for size and population, compared with the notion we insensibly get of a capital, from our own vast London ; and also, that there was as little in the ways of thinking and living of that age and country as in the extent of the city, to effect such a separation between a public man's political and personal life as exists in England. We respect the domestic reserve of our neighbours, and we fortify ourselves in the like reserve, by our habit of learning what they are doing that concerns us, through the newspaper which we read by our own fireside. Where there were no newspapers, and where the climate encouraged an out-of-door life, the people of Jerusalem would become as familiar with that personal demeanour of Isaiah in the market-place, or elsewhere, which he made a part of his public ministry, as we are with the mental habits and political conduct of Lord John Russell or Mr. Gladstone, though the greater part of us would recognise neither of them by sight, and still fewer know anything of their personal and private life. After having uttered this prediction, and perhaps after an interval of time in which the political relations of the several states had become further developed, Isaiah proceeds to take a view of the whole Hebrew people, whom he looks on as one, notwithstanding the actual division and enmity of the two king- doms. He sees Ephraim rejoicing, and Judah trembling, at the alliance of Rezin and Pekah ; the one expecting that it will lead H 3 102 HEBREW POLITICS. to the overthrow of the feeble house of David, the other look- ing to Assyria as the only protection against that overthrow ; but both agreeing in this, that their politics are wholly worldly, and have no reference to the government and help of the Lord of hosts, the true King of the whole Hebrew people, as indeed of the other nations from whom they hope or fear so much. The visible power of armies was to them far more real than the unseen help of the Lord which the prophet believed and as- serted to be sufficient for those who would put their trust in Him and His covenant with the nation. The little brook of Siloah * might ' make glad the city of God ' with its living and never-failing stream ; but what was it in their eyes compared with the mighty river Euphrates, which, when it was swollen with the melted snows of Armenia — resembling the great king who recruited his countless armies in the like mountainous regions — yearly overflowed its banks, and covered the whole * A rock-hewn reservoir under the south-west brow of Ophel, which is itself the south-eastern of the hills which form the site of Jerusalem, still bears the name of Siloah, and waters the gardens which still occupy the place of those 'king's gardens' for the irrigation of which it may have been first made. This reservoir is supplied by a conduit tunnelled through Ophel, from a larger reservoir now called the 'Fountain of the Virgin;' and thence the tunnelling penetrates under the site of Solomon's temple, as was proved when the Arabs in an insurrection got into the city by this channel. The water, which is distinguishable by its peculiar taste and look, as well as by its intermittent flow (which Jerome mentions), has been again identified in a bath on the north-west of the temple-site ; and although more complete investigations have hitherto been prevented by Tuikish jealousy, these facts would be enough to make it more than probable that there is hidden somewhere a living spring which supplies these existing uses. Among the military advantages of Jerusalem, Strabo states that it was well supplied with water, while there was utter drought beyond the walls; and Tacitus, more precisely, that it possessed a perennial fountain with subterranean channels. And from all these things we may conclude, with Mr. Fergusson, that this was the living fountain, the 'softly flowing' waters of which 'made glad the city of God;' and that the complicated channels through which it still passes under ground, were probably among those works of military engineering which llezekiah executed (2 Chron. xxxii. 3, 4.; Eccles. xlviii. 17.). The saying ascribed to Mahomet, that ' Zemzem (in Mecca) and Siloah are the two fountains of Paradise,' is worth quoting here. See Robinson's Biblical licscurchcs, i. 493, fl". ; Ge- senius, Commentary i. 276.; Kitto's Physical Geography, p. 411, fl". ; Fer- gusson's Topography of Jerusalem, p. 69. fl'. ; and on Isaiah, xxii. below. ISAIAH, VIII. 7 — 16. : THE PANIC, AND ITS REMEDY. 103 plain with its waters ! Therefore, says Isaiah, this great river — this king of Assyria with all his hosts — shall the Lord bring upon this people and land. After breaking over Syria and Samaria, as successive dikes which hardly for a moment delay its course, it shall pass on to Judaea, filling the land with its floods, till the monarchy, and the nation it represents, shall be reduced to the near peril of a drowning man, whose neck the waters have reached : — And the stretching out of his wings shall fill The breadth of thy land, O Immanuel! — ' thy land shall be thus overflowed, O child, whom, notwith- standing, the Lord has set as a sign that He is present with us: therefore, however the deep waters may go over us, we will still trust in that Lord, and in the promise of which thou art the standing witness.' * Trusting in this Name, Isaiah defies the confederacy of Ephraitn and Syria, and the power of Assyria : their alliances, their warlike array, shall be broken ; their counsels shall prove foolish ; their resolutious and orders shall fail of execution ; — ' for God is with us.' The exact force of the original can be apprehended by the English reader, though it can only be ex- pressed — and that somewhat imperfectly — by the translation of the word ' Immanuel ' here, and its retention above. There was a general panic among the people ; ' their heart was moved as the trees of the wood are moved by the wind,' when they heard that Syria was confederate with Ephraim ; their cry was every where, ' a confederacy! has been made against us, and we must meet it by a counter alliance with As- syria ; ' and the prophet says, ' I too should have fallen under the influence of this panic, if the Lord had not laid hold of me with a strong hand, to keep me in the way of dependence on Himself, and if He had not taught me to escape the fear which possessed * " Ac si dixisset, terra nihilominus erit tua, O Immanuel." — Calvin in Alexander. f There is no difficulty from the original usually meaning a treasonable plot. Judah might reasonably apply such a term to an alliance of Israel with heathens against her, even if the feeling with which a nation must look on any alliance for its destruction, would not justify such an expression. H 4 104 HEBREW POLITICS. my countrymen, by making the Lord of hosts my fear, and my dread, by sanctifying Him Himself, as I now in His name call on you to do.' To sanctify* the Lord of hosts is in mind and in practice to recognise Him as the hohj God, the Lord who is absolute (absolutus), free from limitations which hinder every other being from carrying his will into full operation : it is to believe with the whole heart that God can and does govern all things according to the counsel of His own will, that what He determines does certainly come to pass, however probabilities and appearances may be against the belief. He who thus sanc- tifies the Lord cannot fear any other power. Therefore Isaiah goes on, — ' Sanctify the Lord, and He shall be your sanc- tuary : ' recognise Him as your holy King, and He shall be a holy King to you, raising you to share in His own absolute dominion over all the powers of the world. He is your King, and you are entitled to claim this relationship ; but if you deny it, He will not deny it also. If you renounce your rights, He will nevertheless require you to fulfil your duties. If you put your trust in Him, He will preserve you against all the power of these foreign invaders, but He will as certainly cause you to fall under their yoke, if you do not trust in Him. Your worldly statesmen dream of remedying present mischief, and securing future pros- perity, by craftily playing off against one another the barbarian, or other, nations whom they cannot hope to match by force ; but God will not allow this to you, as He perchance allows it to other peoples: He and His covenant will be a stumbling-block in your way. He has called both Ephraim and Judah to be His children, and to do His work ; and if you refuse, He will as really curse jou with blindness and weakness, as He would still bless you with strength and wisdom if you would walk in His way. The greater part of 'both the houses of Israel' will re- fuse to listen ; but I call on you, the small remnant of my faith- ful hearers and followers, to wait patiently during the present calamities, and to believe that the Lord docs but hide His face for a time, that the covenant and promise are but closed and scaled f with a more formal ratification by the delay in their fulfilment, * Compare Numbers, xx. 12.; Deut. xxxii. 51.; Isaiah, xxix. 23. f Compare Isaiah, xxix. 11.; Daniel, xii. 4. 9. Also Deut. vi. 8., xi. 18.; Trov. vi. 20,21., vii. 2, 3. ISAIAH, VIII. 17. — IX. 1. : THE NATIONAL GLOOM. 105 and that my words and acts, and my name (Salvation of the Lord), and the children (Shear-jashub, Immanuel, Maher- shalal-hash-baz),whomGod has given me, are meanwhile His signs and pledges to yon of the reality of that ratification. This people will continue their habit (from the days of Saul and earlier) of going to wizards and sorcerers, that they may raise spirits from the dead to tell them what to do in times of political difficulty like the present ; but do you reply, when they call on you to join with them, that it is not of the dead, nor of the sorcerers, who with their ventriloquism* seem to receive directions from the shrill voices of familiar spirits, that men should inquire, but of the living God, and of the prophets who declare His will in words of reason and righteousness. Let the people, let Ahaz and his counsellors, refer to God's law and covenant, and to the promises based thereon, which 1 have even now been commis- sioned to deliver : if they refuse to do so, there is no dawn of light in the darkness of their souls, nor shall they find any dawn to the night of gathering calamities. And they shall pass thi'ough the land hardly bestead and hungry: And it shall be that when they are hungry they shall fret them- selves, And shall curse their king and their God ; And they shall look upward, and they shall look unto the earth ; And behold trouble and darkness, dimness of anguish ; And they shall be driven into darkness. So completely does Isaiah identify the two kingdoms of Israel as one people, on the present occasion, that as the image of this darkness gathers itself around him, he contemplates it, not as in the land of Judah, but in the north of Israel, in that border-land and debatable ground of Galilee, which Avas politically and religiously debased by the intermixture of Canaanitish tribes with the Hebrews f ; the chief cities of which neither Solo- mon cared to retain, nor Hiram to accept J; which lay open to the first brunt of every northern invasion ; and which was actually wasted, and its inhabitants carried away, by Tiglath- * The Septuagint translates ' them that have familiar spirits' by 677a- (TTpijxvdoi. ' Peep' is pipiunt, the ' squeak and gibber' of Shakspeare. f Judges, i. 30—35. J 1 Kings, ix. 11—13. 106 HEBREW POLITICS. Pileser, shortly after the date of this prophecy, if indeed the work had not been already begun by his predecessor Pul *, as seems probable from a comparison of 2 Kings, xv. 19. 29. with 1 Chron. v. 26. v. 26,: — the reading of the Authorised Ver- sion of our text may also seem to allude to two successive invasions ; but it is a reading rejected by all the modern translators. And some of these very people ' of Asher, and Manasseh, and Zebulon,' f attended the summons of Heze- kiah a few years after, and gave a practical recognition of the unity of Israel by coming up to Jerusalem to the passover : — a fact interesting in itself, and in its reference to the passage before us, and also as raising the question whether Isaiah, or his disciples, may have taken any steps for the actual promul- gation of this prophecy in those districts, and thus by their preaching have prepared the way for its fulfilment. Considering how important, wide-spread, and active a body the prophets were, and how much evidence there is both in Hebrew history, and in their writings, of their extensive personal acquaintance with every neighbouring country and people, the supposition is not improbable: and so we pass easily from this partial fulfilment of the prophecy then, to that day when, on that same sea-coast of Tiberias, and in the city of Capernaum, was heard the voice of a greater prophet than Isaiah, preaching and saying ' Repent, for the kingdom of heaven' — a greater kingdom than that of Hezekiah — ' is at hand.' J Those commentators, who protest against our seeing any reference in this glorious vision to the times of Isaiah, lest we should disparage its fulfilment by the coming of Christ, — and their opponents, who forbid us to view it in the light of the gospel, lest we should overlook the fact that Isaiah and Hezekiah were men of flesh and blood, like ourselves, — both scern to err by a too exclusive literalncss, and preference of inferior logic for philosophic insight. Why should Hebrew history alone depart from the law of all other histories, that the earlier events must be read in the light of the later, which arc their * Wc have still to wait for the translation of the annals of these kin^s: in which, however, the name of Men ahem, king of Israel, has been read by Dr. Ilincks. | 2 Chron. xxx. 1—11. J Matt. iv. 12—25. ISAIAH, IX. 2— 5.: THE GREAT LIGHT. 107 necessary developments'? >Vhy should prophecy be honoured by making it out to be a mere verbal soothsaying ? Let me entreat the reader, — the Christian reader, — and student of the Hebrew prophets, to dread neither of these bugbears, but to see and to reflect for himself, in the firm belief that reason and faith are ever in harmony, and that neither can ever be rightly possessed to the exclusion or neglect of the other. If the English poet of the nineteenth century, whom I have already quoted, claims 'a vision and a faculty divine' for his readers as well as himself, Ave need not hesitate to recognise a like power in ourselves for the better understanding Isaiah, in these parts of his discourses, where, as here, he is so markedly carried out of himself. He sees, as we may see too, if we will only look, the thick darkness, spiritual and temporal, which was gathering over the land, and which reached its height when the nation had generally lapsed into heathenism, and Ahaz their king had shut up the temple, and substituted the worship of false gods even to the sacrifice of his own son to Moloch ; and when Ephraim had called in a heathen power to enable it to effect its fratricidal designs against Judah, and Juclah had retaliated by summoning another still stronger heathen nation, and the whole land, over which David and Solomon had once reigned glo- riously, lay wasted by the sword and tributary to the Assyrian, because abandoned by the Lord, whom they had first aban- doned. The people walk in darkness, nay, dwell in the shadow of death ! But, see, a great light breaks upon the gloom : mul- titudes, full of joy and gladness, throng the cities and the fields which just now were deserted ; we hear the shouts of the harvest- home, while they present the first-fruits to the Lord*; we see the triumphal procession going up to the temple with the spoils of victory f; we see the armour, the blood-stained cloak, and the war- chariot, gathered to be burnt, since permanent peace is established in the land : we know that they who sowed in tears have reaped in joy, and that the King has come to the rescue of His people; that the yoke of the despot, and the rod of the slave-master are broken ; and that a deliverance is effected greater even than that * Deut. xii. 11, 12., xvi. 11 — 15.; Psalm iv. 7. f Compare 1 Chron. xviii. 11.; 2 Chron. xx. 27, 28. 108 HEBREW POLITICS. ancient deliverance of Israel from their seven years' bondage, on the night when ' the Midianites and the Amalekites, and all the children of the east, lay along in the valley ' (of Jezreel, in this same Galilee of the Gentiles), ' like grasshoppers, and their camels without number, as the sand of the sea-side for multi- tude,' but ' ran, and cried, and fled,' when the three hundred raised their battle-shout, ' The sword of the Lord and of Gideon :'* and then we recall the actual debasement, under Ahaz, and ask, as his disciples must have asked Isaiah, and he must have asked himself, and his God — how this vision and its promises can be true? I do not quote the mighty words of the prophetic reply ; but its sense in modern prose, when we have somewhat unravelled the many thoughts and images which are gathered up into each word, seems to be this, — that the believing Israelites are to know that Isaiah's children, and especially the second, with whom, in more than one moment of special inspiration, he has connected the name of Immanuel, though he had formerly called him Malier-shalal-hash-baz, are signs and pledges that God has not forgotten His covenant, nor His ancient promises of a Saviour — the seed of the woman, and the seed of Abraham and David — in whom all nations should be blessed ; that this child is a witness that the Lord, the invisible King, is now actually among them, notwithstanding the iniquity of both prince and people ; and that He will ere long manifest His presence and power, by restoring the kingdom from its ruinous condition, in the person of a royal deliverer, a Mes- siah, of the line of David, f And, as Jacob conferred the birthright and blessing of his race upon the sons of Joseph by saying, ' Let my name be named on them, and the name of my fathers Abraham and Isaac' (Genesis, xlviii. 16.); or as the children of Israel in the wilderness were warned to obey the angel who went before them, because the 'name of the Lord was in him;' so the Name of God, wonderful in counsel, mighty in work, the Father of their fathers and of their children for a thousand generations, * Judges, vii. -j- To those for whom music not only ' charms the sense,' but also embodies thoughts and feelings too deep for words, Handel's ' Messiah' is no mean comment on these prophecies. ISAIAH, IX. 6, 7.: e UNTO US A CHILD IS BORN.' 109 the eternal Upholder of their race and their nation, and of its prosperity and peace, shall be named upon, shall be in, this anointed saviour. The eternal kingdom already lies about them, though they deny and reject it ; it has its foundations in the unchangeable purpose of God, and not in the good or evil dispositions of this or that king and his subjects; and there- fore, with no material hiuderance from the one, nor help from the other, of these, the zeal of God Himself will effectually carry forward the work, and spread this kingdom of righteous- ness and peace, without limit of time or place. Some com- mentators think ' mighty hero ' a more accurate translation than ' mighty God,' as the word (?x) is used in such a sense in Eze- kiel, xxxi. 11., and xxxii. 21., in the former of which places it is applied to Nebuchadnezzar : but we know that the Old Testa- ment does not scruple to l call them gods to whom the word of God came ; ' and I prefer our Authorised Translation, explaining it as I have here done. It requires a deeper insight into the relative activity of the imagination and the logical faculties in the Hebrew prophets, and into the degree of definiteness with which — in actual his- torical fact — the expectation of a Messiah presented itself to Isaiah and his contemporaries, than I possess, to authorise a po- sitive opinion how far the prophet, in uttering the words before us, was thinking of his own times and circumstances. Yet I am unable to form any distinct notion of Isaiah as a man and Israelite, and as a prophet of the Lord in contrast with those muttering wizards he denounces, without supposing that, at this period of his life and ministry, he must have connected the thought of ' the Child ' with Hezekiah, on whom the name of the mighty God had been actually named*, and who (being now a boy nine or ten years old), may already have given promise of the piety which afterwards distinguished him: — and that he would not, at this time, have considered that his prediction would be quite inadequately realized, if the youthful prince should, on his accession to the throne of David and Solomon, renew the glories of their reigns, in which peace and justice were established at home and abroad, through trust in the Lord * Hezekiah means 'the Lord will strengthen.' 110 HEBREW POLITICS. and His covenant: — reigns of which the historical facts must be studied in the light which the Book of Psalms, and such passages as 2 Chronicles, ix. 1 — 8., throw on them. I say, at this time, because we shall have occasion to inquire, what was the effect on Isaiah's mind when he did see a restoration, under Hezekiah, of such a reign of righteousness and prosperity ; and whether his expectation of the Messiah did not eventually as sume a very different form from what could have been possible to him at the time we now speak of. There is a method, through this whole book of Isaiah's prophecies, which reflects a corre- sponding progress in the prophet's own mind; and this method offers us a clue through difficulties which are otherwise impas- sable, if we will only hold it fast, and follow its guidance fairly. EPIC UNITY OF ISAIAH, VII. — XII. Ill CHAPTER VIII. ISAIAH VII. — XII. EPIC UNITY. OBSTINATE ENERGY OF THE HERBEW RACE. LAWLESSNESS OF THE TEN TRIBES. LEGALISM OF JUDAH. THE KING OF ASSYRIA. GODS IN THE IMAGE OF MEN. THE SCOURGE OF NATIONS, AND ITS WIELDER. ANCIENT ROADS. THE KING OF THE STOCK OF JESSE. THE GOLDEN AGE. FUSION OF CONFLICTING ELEMENTS IN A NATION. CONSEQUENCES OF THE REVOLT OF EPHRAIM. DE- PORTATION OF JEWS IN ISAIAH'S TIME. THE UNIVERSAL CHURCH ITS RELATION TO THE WORLD. THE WATER OF SALVATION. The strophical arrangement of Isaiah, ix. 8. to x. 4,, is sup- posed by many commentators to mark it for a distinct prophecy, delivered soon after the last ; while they see in the allusion to Samaria, as actually taken by the Assyrians (chap. x. 10.), proof that the following prophecy from x. 5. to the end of chapter xii. cannot date earlier than the sixth year of Hezekiah. But these arguments are not conclusive. There is no reason why a style of discourse in which historical narrative, political oratory, and poetical rhythm as well as imagery, are equally in place, should not embody in itself a refrain several times repeated and then dropped, just as in other instances we find it containing a song or psalm.* Nor shall we find any difficulty in explaining, by the ordinary prophetic usage of the past for the future, a reference to the taking of Samaria, not more, though not less, definite than those which were undoubtedly made before the event, even if it be premature to rely on the reading of the Khorsabad inscription, referred to above, as recording a capture of Samaria just after that of Damascus, and ten years before that which was previously known to us. On the other hand, we have the probability of a general ad- herence to chronological order in the actual arrangement of the book : the indications of an unbroken current of thought f : the unity of subject of the whole portion, chapters vii. to * Chap. xxvi. 1., xxvii. 2.; and compare the repetition in Amos, i. and ii. f As is verses 24, 25, 26, of chapter x., compared with chapter viii. 8, 9, 10.; x. 6., with viii. 1. 4.; x. 27., with ix. 3.; x. 21., with vii. 3. (Shear- jashnb); xi. 1—5., with ix. 6, 7.; and xi. 13, 14., with ix. 12. 20, 21. 112 IIEBREW POLITICS, xii. Inclusive : and, lastly, the probability, of which I believe the reader will see more evidence the longer he considers the subject, that here, as throughout the book, the author's own hand may have been at work, arranging, retouching, and fusing together the records of discourses originally distinct. These chapters form a kind of epic whole (itself a part of a still larger whole), in which the internecine enmities of the Ten Tribes among themselves, and with Judah, and the alliances with the heathen nations, by which they support these enmities, only to involve themselves in the common ruin, are traced to their first causes, and the loss of national unity and freedom shown to be the consequence of the loss of that spiritual unity and liberty which can only spring from, and be sustained by, a living faith — in king and people — in the unseen but present Lord of the nation and of each member of it : subjection to the heathenish, godless, Assyrian power, is shown to be the proper and effectual punishment of the national sin ; and a restoration, in and through the reign of a righteous prince of the line of David, is declared to be certain, because God Himself is pledged to it by a cove- nant which men's evil doings cannot cancel. The prophet stands as on a hill or tower, and sees the past and the future, the distant and the near, in one completed whole, in which all events and all wills have but subserved the almighty Master- will ; and, therefore, Ave find here an instance of the propriety of the word epic, which has with so much force been applied to the writings of the Hebrew prophets generally by Mr. Maurice.* In the second edition of the work referred to, this author has, indeed, omitted this and much more of formal comparison between the Hebrew and classical types of literature, ap- parently lest his readers should mistake a vital relation for a technical correspondence, and fall into the bondage to names which that mistake always brings us. But if we take care how we call the prophets ' epic poets,' and then fancy we understand them, we shall find a real light thrown on the subject by this word, which is farther explained by Coleridge's observation, that epic and dramatic poetry are alike founded on the relation * Moral and Metaphysical Philosophy, 1st edition. See also Educational Magazine, vol. ii. p. 22G. ISAIAH IX. 8 — 17.: OBSTINATE ENERGY OF HEBREW RACE. 113 of Providence to the human will ; but that while, in the latter, the will is exhibited as struggling with fate, in the former a pre-announced fate (or Providence) gradually adjusts and em- ploys the will and the events as the instruments for accomplish- ing its designs : — Aios Be reXslsro /SouX^.* The Jewish historian, in relating the fall of Samaria (2 Kings, xvii.) as the punishment of national sin, says, ' Yet the Lord testified against Israel, and against Judah, by all the prophets and all the seers, saying, Turn ye from your evil ways, and keep my commandments and statutes, according to the law which I commanded your fathers, and which I sent to you by my ser- vants the prophets.' And here we have one of these repeated warnings, in this ' word which the Lord sent unto Jacob,' by Isaiah. The Ten Tribes had already suffered many an infliction ; their political organisation had often been broken up by civil wars and foreign invasions, as the house of unburnt brick dis- solves into mud before the rain ; and the flower of the people had been cut down as lavishly as men cut down the cheap syca- mores : but with that stoutness of heart, that obstinate tough- ness, which, in all ages to the present, has marked this race, the men of Ephraim and Samaria seem to rise superior to every ca- limity; like Solomon (1 Kings, x. 27.) they will change the sycamores for cedars, and they will replace the bricks with hewn stones. The conversion of Damascus from an ancient enemy to an ally encourages them in their hopes ; but the Lord will confound their policy by bringing the conquerors of Damas- cus upon them. The histories mention inroads of the Philistines into Judah, though not into Israel, at this period ; but we can believe the latter did not escape, as these marauders were not likely to miss an opportunity, especially when once in movement. The * Syrians ' are either the same allies whose arms, on their becoming tributary to Tiglath-Pileser, would at once be turned against Ephraim ; or the word (Aram) may be used in a sense wide enough to include the Assyrians themselves. Tiglath- Pileser took Damascus, killed Rezin, and carried the people away captive ; and we find Ahaz going there to meet the Assy- * Literary Remains, vol. ii. pp. 159. 164. I 114 HEBREW POLITICS. rian. when it is related that he took the pattern of an altar at Damascus, and adopted the gods of Syria, ' because they helped them,' an account which can only be applicable to the gods of Tiglath-Pileser.* ' The people turneth not unto Him that smiteth them, ' and therefore they shall be smitten again and again. It will not be a mere political change of an Assyrian satrap for an Israelite king, but every rank, every household, from the highest to the lowest, shall suffer: — though youth is the season of joy, the young men shall find that it is not so, when the Lord, the source of joy, has no joy in them ; though mercy and pity are the natural right of the fatherless and widow, they shall find that God himself refuses them these : and the reason is, that all of them, man, woman, and child, are demoralised and corrupted; one may be a hypocrite, and another an open sinner, but all speak, because their heart believes, the language of that folly which is contrary to, and which denies and excludes, the knowledge of God. That in the middle of this threatening of universal calamity upon head and tail, palm-tree and rush, we should find an explanation that the 'tail' is the prophet that teacheth lies, and not the common people, as the context demands, does not require the supposition of an interpolation by a later hand, as some say. We have constant occasion to notice the Hebrew disregard of that mere logical balance of sentences which indeed soon becomes an intolerable pedantry in any other lan- guage : and here Isaiah's knowledge of what the teachers of a people ought to be, and might be, and of how great is their personal responsibility, stops him, before he can complete the explanation of the tail and the rush, and he turns it as though he had said, ' No, the common people are brutal and degraded enough, but the men who have been the cause of this debase- ment are more guilty, and more contemptible than they : they are the dregs of all.' The wickedness of the land becomes its own punishment, and burns with a fury which is indeed the wrath of God, while its fuel is the people themselves. The images of slaughter and fjrc — at once fact and symbol — suggest that of famine so despc- * 2 Kings, xvi., 2 Chron. xxviii. ISAIAH IX. 18 — 21.: ANARCHY OF THE TEN TRIBES. 115 rate that e no man shall spare his brother,' nay ' they shall eat every one the flesh of his own arm.' Ephraim and Manasseh were brethren of each other, and of Judah : and the history of the kingdom of the former is a history of tyrannies, rebellions, anarchies at home ; of wars with Judah ; and of invasions and subjugations by foreigners; and even at this time, the assassina- tion of Pekah seems to have been followed by a nine years' interregnum and anarchy, as far as we can trace and make out the lines of a picture of which the indistinctness is a token of its accurate representation of the reality.* ' The allusions of the verse,' says Dr. Alexander, care not to one exclusive period, but to a protracted series of events. The intestine strifes of Ephraim and Manasseh, although not recorded in detail, may be inferred from various incidental statements. Of their ancient rivalry we have examples in the history of Gideon (Judges, viii. 1 — 3.) and Jephthah (Judges, xii. 1 — 6.); and as to later times, it is observed by Vitringa that of all who suc- ceeded Jeroboam, the second on the throne of Israel, Pekahiah alone appears to have attained it without treachery or blood- shed. That Manasseh and Ephraim were both against Judah, may refer either to their constant enmity or to particular attacks. No sooner did one party gain the upper hand in the kingdom of the Ten Tribes, than it seems to have addressed itself to the favourite work of harassing or conquering Judah, as in the case of Pekah, who invaded it almost as soon as he had waded to the throne through the blood of Pekahiah. 'f The strophical form connects the following verses (x. 1 — 4.) with the preceding, as the exclamation with which they begin does with those that come after ; and in both are corresponding links of the subject itself. The prophet has described the sins of Ephraim in a general manner ; but on the mention of Judah, he proceeds to denounce what we know from the whole tenour of his discourses he felt to be the worst form of the guilt of his own people, with a particularity which it is perhaps not * Compare the historical accounts and dates, in 2 Kings, xv., with Hosea, vii. 7. f Alexander's Prophecies of Isaiah, chap. ix. 20. It is worth mentioning, that for critical purposes the reader must consult the unabridged American edition of this learned work, or its Glasgow reprint. i 2 116 HEBKEW POLITICS. fanciful to attribute to his thoughts being now directed home- wards. The Ten Tribes were far more ferocious and anarchical than the men of Judah : there are many indications in the latter of that national respect for law which so characterises the English, that it has been observed *, that though history attri- butes to us our share in national wickedness, our crimes have almost always been committed under colour of law, and not by open violence, — as in the series of judicial murders in the reigns of Henry VIII., Charles II., and James II. And therefore, Isaiah's mind is, perhaps, recurring to Judah, when he denounces the utmost severity of God's wrath in the day in which He, the righteous Judge, shall come to visit ' an hypo- critical nation,' whose nobles and magistrates decree, and execute, unrighteous decrees. To turn aside the needy from judgment, And to take away the right from the poor of my people, That widows may be their prey, And that they may rob the fatherless ! They are satisfied that they are safe in their heartless selfish- ness, with peace at home and protection abroad restored by their statecraft and their alliance with Assyria. But while they thus rejoice at home, ' desolation cometh from far.' To whom will they fly for help when God has abandoned them? Under whose protection will they leave their wealth, their dignities, their glory, which they have been heaping up for themselves ? Captivity or death are the only prospects before them. And yet, as though no judgments could sufficiently condemn and punish their utter wickedness, the prophet repeats, For all this His anger is not turned away, But His hand is stretched out still. Where the arguments of the learned commentators seem so nearly balanced, and no one shows such an insight into the spirit of the whole text as to claim submission to his authority, I do not presume to dogmatise : but in such a case we must assume something; and on the assumption which I have already pre- ferred, that these chapters (vii. to xii.) form one prophecy, the * By Lord Campbell. ISAIAH X. 5—12.: THE STOUT KING OF ASSYRIA. 117 scope of the portion before us will be this: — Isaiah turns from Ephraim and Judah to Assyria with an apparent abruptness which does but half conceal the real connection, or rather unity, of all the parts of his subject : quite ignoring the petty statecraft by which Ahaz and his counsellors were bringing Assyria upon themselves as well as on their enemies, the pro- phet goes at once to the heart of the matter, and shows us the Lord come to execute justice upon the nations, and the Assyrians as the rod and instrument of that justice ; and he employs the whole force of his imagination to do justice to ' the stout heart of the king of Assyria, and the glory of his high looks,' in order that he may give more emphasis to the scorn with which the Lord, and the servants of the Lord, look on his pretensions and power, and that he may bring into fuller contrast with this kingdom of the world, which Ahaz and his people make the sole object of their hopes and fears, that other kingdom which stands, and ever shall stand, in the will not of man but of God. The old Babel monarchy, which carried its traditions back to the days of Nimrod, that mighty hunter before the Lord, and was in all ages the very type of sheer, godless, arbitrary power, had, in the time of Isaiah and the generation before him, renewed its strength, and become the terror and the scourge of all the neighbouring countries ; for the Lord of hosts, the Lord of the whole earth, had sent this northern conqueror forth, and * given him a charge to take the spoil and to take the prey.' One nation after another had fallen before him ; his satraps sat in the thrones of their once inde- pendent kings ; the national gods of ancient kingdoms could not preserve their shrines nor their votaries from his hand ; Samaria might trust to her golden calves, but they were within his grasp ; and the cherubims of Jerusalem, or what other unseen images might be hidden and worshipped in her holy of holies, would soon prove equally powerless : — thus he boasted, little thinking that he was the merest tool in the hands of an un- known Master, who was exactly limiting his actions by the pur- poses for which he was being used. 'I took the cities, I gave them up to pillage, I slew the inhabitants ; ' or, ' I devastated the country, I took away the king, with his priests and his gods, his warriors and his wives, i 3 118 HEBREW POLITICS. his gold, silver, and cattle, I carried all the men and women into slavery, I brought there the people of other cities;' — such are the records which meet us every where in the newly-de- ciphered annals of these Assyrian kings, and such the subjects of the sculptures which ornamented their palaces. But the reference is also constant to the god in whose strength they have done these things, and whose worship they have thereby established every where : and it is interesting to notice the apparent one-sidedness with which Isaiah, here and elsewhere, omits all reference to this religious spirit of the conquerors, while his words are otherwise (except for the poetry) so exact a counterpart of the Assyrian phraseology. It is the one-sided- ness of the practical man, who goes straight to the single point on which all the rest really depends. The prophet who, without phrase of qualification, told the strictly religious Jews that the Avhole ritual which they were practising in exact conformity with the law, was an unbearable abomination *, would have asserted, iu equally plain terms, that the religion of Assyria was no religion. God, the living and true God, had revealed Himself to Isaiah, and to Isaiah's nation, as the Being in whose image man was created ; and in whom therefore justice, honesty, truth, kindness, and every other properly human virtue, which in man feebly struggled for existence, had its own perfect, absolute reality, without the limits or the defects of the finite. This Lord of man, the Jehovah, or I AMf, had made Himself known to Isaiah as He had to Moses, and as He does still to each of us : and when the prophet turned to look at the c gods of the nations ' he saw at once that they were something different — nay, exactly reverse, — in kind. On the one hand, God was the prototype of man ; on the other, man of God. The god of the Assyrian was made in the image of the Assyrian, was the projected form of his own character. The spirit which was embodied in that dignified human figure with its eagle's head and wings, was but the spirit of the actual Sargon or Sen- nacherib, with his wide and resistless swoop, his ravenous maw, his royal cruelty 4 And when he led out that terrible cavalry, * Isaiah, i. 11—14. T Exodus, iii. 14. \ See the majestic figures who have captives Hayed, or their eyes put out, ISATAII X. 13.: GODS IN THE IMAGE OF MEN. 119 in the ranks of which there was no ungirt warrior, no unbent bow, no horse's hoof not hard as flint, and whose shout struck panic into all who heard it *, when he went forth to conquest at their head, from that palace and city of which we have not altogether to imagine the magnificence, — we know that the winged lions, and the human-headed bulls, whom he took with him, full of fierce life, were but imperfectly represented by those which he left behind, carved in stone, at the portals of his own house, or the house of his god. We may see from the vision in chapter vi., that the distinction between the two kinds of religion — that which God reveals to man, and that which man makes for himself — is not obliterated or enfeebled, but brought out more plainly, by the fact that the cherubims at Jerusalem were, in other respects, the counterparts of these sphinx-like creatures of the neighbouring nations : we see the same human element, the same religious sentiment, the same capacity for worship, the same human methods of expressing this sentiment and capacity : the difference is between the na- tion, or the man, in whom this human element is met by a real unveiling and communication of God Himself, from above, and those in whom it is not so met, and who therefore substitute a projection of themselves for its independent existence. At the same time we must not, in our objective study of the heathen world, overlook that we Christians (like the Jews of old) do habitually combine much of this heathenish temper with the true faith which has been given us. If we look in any direction where the particular religious prejudice no longer blinds us, we can see, for instance, how much of the harsh notions which Calvin and the Puritans mixed up (as we now perceive so un- worthily) with their true worship of God, was the reflex of men's ordinary notions of justice, and of magisterial duty as well as right, in those dajrs, and which did not shock them when attributed to God, because they held them, as of course, in all their worldly dealings. So, the new form which the f doctrine of election and reprobation' took, in the religious revival of the last century, did but reflect the narrow class notions which took in their presence ; as, for instance, Sennacherib at Lachish, in Layard's Nineveh and Babylon (1S53), p. 150. Truly eagle-like men. * See page 65. , above. l 4 120 HEBREW POLITICS. for granted that a gentleman was, and would be to the end of time, a finer species of creature than a working man. And in our own day, are not the notions of a God who is pleased with lighted candles, or whose character is one of mawkish good- nature, in which the desire to spare bodily pain has superseded all regard for the distinction between crime and virtue, but varieties of the same vice ? It is instructive to see these things behind and around us, if we take heed that they teach us to look within also, — to remember that each of us has his own idol, made in his own image, which he is ever substituting for the true God, and that from God must be obtained the help for discovering and deposing that idol. To return to the Assyrian conqueror : — He does not suspect that he is the instrument in the hands of the Lord, much less desire the Lord's help or guidance ; and therefore, according to the prophet's view of things, he does not rely on any god, but simply on his own military power and political sagacity. He first boasts that he does all things by his own prudence and strength, and then dwells exultingly on the nature of his doings: valiant man that he is, he puts down one nation after another, taking pos- session of their treasuries, transplanting the inhabitants to other cities and lands, and obliterating the ancient limits of what from independent kingdoms are now but provinces in his great mili- tary empire. He has come upon nation after nation, as it dwelt in peace with all the fruits of peace, and has ' found their riches as a nest* :' he has gathered all the earth as one gathers the eggs from which he has first driven off the terrified hen-bird. But she would hover round her rifled nest, and its plunderer, with a trepidating flight and piercing cry, than which no move- ments and sounds in the brute creation express more anguish ; while these spoiled nations dare not show even such instinc- tive signs of a broken heart, but know a depth beyond that depth : — * Xcnophon says of the attempt of Epaminondas to surprise Sparta, — (\a/3ev at* rrjv ttuKiu uxnrep veuTTLau, TTavrairamu epTj/uoj' twv afivfofxeuccv. — Hellcn. vii. 5. 10., quoted in Grote's History of Greece, x. 4a4. This alarm must have been as thrilling to a Greek as the danger of Jerusalem to a Jew : and it is interesting to notice the universal language of passion in remote times and peoples. It is one of the minuter evidences of our common race. ISAIAH X. 14—27.: THE SCOURGE AND ITS WIELDEB. 121 For he saith, By the strength of my hand I have clone it, And by my wisdom ; for I am prudent : And I have removed the bounds of the nations, And have robbed their treasures, And I have put down the inhabitants like a valiant man : And my hand hath found as a nest the riches of the peoples : And as one gathereth eggs that are left, Have I gathered all the earth ; And there was none that moved the wing, Or that opened the mouth, or that chirped. Shall the axe boast itself against him that heweth therewith ? Shall the saw magnify itself against him that handled) it ? As if the rod should wield him that lifteth it, As if the staff should lift up the man ! This passage, itself a specimen of the whole context, is quite a study, political and artistic : political for him who seeks the law of the rise and fall of military despotisms ; artistic, as an illustration of the working of the imagination, the ' power by which one image or feeling is made to modify many others, and by a sort of fusion to force many into one, .... and which, combining many circumstances into one moment of consciousness, tends to produce that ultimate end of all human thought and human feelings, unity, and thereby the reduction of the spirit to its Principle and Fountain, who is alone truly One.'* And the prophet and poet goes on with the same luxuriance of imagination, and the same severity of righteous faith. ' The Lord, the Lord of hosts, shall send among his fat ones leanness :' the allusion seems to be to fat herds, ' fat bulls of Bashan ;' and these, one would almost say, suggested the thought of the oaks of Bashan, if the previous mention of the axe and the saw did not seem to reverse the succession of the images which crowd in on every side. The 'glory,' the whole equipments and ammunitions, the pomp and the splendour of the warrior king, shall be burnt up, and the Light of Israel shall be the consuming fire. If the Assyrians are to be thus destroyed it is because they are mere noxious thorns and briers, only fit for burning. If their power entitles them to be rather * Coleridge's Literary Remains, vol. ii. pp. 55, 56. These lectures on the genius of Shakspeare throw much light on that of Isaiah. 122 HEBREW POLITICS. compared with lofty forest trees, and their wealth and extended dominion to the ' fruitful field,' with its vineyards, and olive- grounds, and gardens, still they shall be consumed, even as they have often wasted such scenes with fire in their marches : they shall be destroyed utterly, fsoul and body,' for they are no trees but men, and like men wasted by sickness they shall perish. And then, to gather up the whole once more in the picture of the heaven-kindled conflagration of the forest with its lofty trees and its jungles, and the fruitful fields lying all about it,— we see of all these trees, which it would have once required many and skilful enumerators to reckon, so few that a child can count and write them down, while the child himself, in the midst of the desolation, suggests new trains of thought, not foreign to the subject. If Assyria is to be reduced to such a remnant, so is the people, the two houses, of Israel. The Lord of hosts has decreed a righte- ous execution of judgment upon his guilty people through the land, and though they were as the sand of the sea in numbers, only a remnant of them shall be left. But that remnant shall return * unto their God and King : they will have learnt the lesson sent through so much suffering ; and instead of continuing to trust in Assyria, and their alliance with that worldly and faithless power, they ' shall stay upon the Lord, the Holy One of Israel, in truth.' And then Isaiah, with that feminine tender- ness which so frequently shows itself in his sternest denuncia- tions, hastens to exclaim, f Therefore, thus saith the Lord God of hosts, O my people that dwellest in Zion, be not afraid of the Assyrian ;' it is true that he shall for a time oppress you with a bondage like that which in old times you endured when you were the serfs of Pharaoh, or the tributaries of Midian ; but as the slaughter at the rock of Oreb was an effectual scourge to that scourge of Israel, and as the rods of the Egyptian task- masters were broken in the hour in which Moses stretched out his rod upon the sea, so shall it be now ; for yet a little while, and the Lord will stir up a scourge, and lift up His rod, and His indignation against His people shall cease in the destruc- tion of their, and His, enemies. The words in verse 27., which * Shear jashub are the words of the original, where there is also a piny <»n .J;islml) mid Jacob, such as Isaiah is fond of. ISAIAH X. 28 — 32. : ANCIENT ROADS. 123 our version renders by * because of the anointing,' are, lite- rally, in the face of (i. e. because of) oil, or fatness, or anointing : and it is doubtful whether the meaning be that the Lord will not suffer the anointed Israel — the race of kings and priests — to continue in bondage to the great worldly, godless, power ; or that the metaphor of the yoke suggests that of the bullock bursting it by the fatness of his neck, or rejecting it in the lusti- hood of his strength, asinDeut. xxxii. 15.; Hosea, iv. 16. x. 11. From historical parallel and poetic metaphor, Isaiah passes to a vivid description of the march of the Assyrians upon Jerusa- lem, as it ( flashed upon his inward eye,' with all the distinct- ness of sense. The rival literalists who explain this passage as a miraculous prediction, or a narrative after the event, are alike refuted by the historical accounts, from which it appears that Sennacherib did not invade Judah from the north, but from the south or south-west. For though both the traditional name of the ' camp of the Assyrians ' which still existed in the time of Josephus, and the nature of the ground which lays Jerusalem most open to an attack on the north, make it probable that this was the quarter in wThich Rabshakeh did actually, a few years later, ' shake his hand against the mount of the daughter of Zion,' he would not have brought his army round by the defile of Mich- mash. The places here mentioned, and several of which were found, still retaining their names, by Messrs. Robinson and Smith*, lay in succession between the northern frontier of Judah and Jerusalem : and the remains of a square tower and large hewn stones which they found at Jeba, opposite to Mukhmas (i. e. Michmash), and supposed to be Gibeah of Saul, and the like marks of Mukhmas itself having been once a place of strength, taken in connection with the accounts in 1 Sam. xiii., xiv., and 1 Mac. ix. 73., make it more than probable that this was the route which Isaiah might reasonably expect the invaders to take. The high road indeed no longer runs that way, and Dr. Robin- son says that the common approach to Jerusalem can never have lain through these deep and difficult ravines : but it has been pointed out to mef that while it would sufficiently vindicate the * Biblical Researches, vol. ii. p. 110. ff. f By my brother, Captain R. Strachey. I have since read the following like solution of the like difficulty : — "I do not share the doubts which have 124 HEBREW POLITICS. propriety of the picture to observe, that an Assyrian army would direct its course not by what might be the high road, but by what was the line of still unplundered towns and villages, the geographical probability is all in favour of the route de- scribed having been the actual northern highway. For the present road, which is so much more practicable, lies along the water-shed, where the ground, although better for engineering purposes, is worse for houses or cultivation from the want of water : and such roads, in which the convenient junction of extreme points is the main object, are a comparatively modern invention, though the most in accordance with our notions of a highway. But in Isaiah's time, even the main roads would be those which had been formed, stage by stage, for the communication of each town or village with the ones imme- diately before and behind it ; and these towns would, in the present case, have lain thickest in the very line in question : for while the water- shed is just to the west, and ' lower down the slope, towards the Jordan valley, all is a frightful desert,' the steep hill-sides, in which these towns were clustered, from Anathoth to Michmash, still show signs of that ' strong and fertile soil ' which (as has been explained before) only needs terracing to make the rock a garden, and which, even as it is, Dr. Robinson here found producing e fields of grain occasionally, and fig trees and olive trees every where.' Let us now return, to stand with the prophet on some watch-tower of Jerusalem, in vision, and see the enemy's troops as they enter the frontier city Aiath, or Ai, which been raised about Xenophon's accuracy, in his description of the route from Sardis to Ikonium ; though the names of several of the places which he mentions are not known to us, and their sites cannot be exactly identified. There is a great departure from the straight line of bearing. But we at the present day assign more weight to that circumstance than is suited to the days of Xenophon. Straight roads, stretching systematically over a large region of country, are not of that age : the communications were probably all originally made between one neighbouring town and another, without much reference to saving of distance, and with no reference to any promotion of traffic between distant places. "It was just about this time that King Archelaus began to 'cut straight roads' in Macedonia, — which Thucydides seems to note as a remarkable thing (ii. 100.)." Grote's Hist. of Greece, ix. 23., note. ISAIAH XI. 1 — 5. : THE KING OF THE STOCK OF JESSE. 125 Joshua had once taken from the Canaanitish king : they pass through Migron; and, meeting no resistance at Michmash, the northern key to the defile, they there leave their baggage, lest it should impede the rapid advance with which ' they pass the Pass,' and establish their quarters at Geba, which com- mands the southern exit. The inaction and stupor which had allowed this position to be mastered, is now succeeded by open panic : Raman trembles ; Gibeah of Saul — the birth-place of the king of whose feats, and the feats of his son Jonathan, in discomfiting countless hosts of Philistines in these very defiles, the old national stories told — Gibeah is fled ; Laish hears the shrieks of Gallim ; and wretched Anathoth * answers not with her echoes alone, but with a too real cry of despair, for an enemy, whom neither human pity nor fear of religion moves, is upon the city of Levites ; Madmenah is gone, and Gebim fled ; every hill-top within sight of Jerusalem is covered with those terrible horsemen from the north ; at Nob the Assyrian is seen to halt, preparatory to the assault, and ' he shakes his hand against the Mount of the daughter of Zion.' At once the vision gives place to another; the prophet recals the previous promise, with the previous image it was expressed under : — Behold, the Lord, the Lord of hosts, Doth lop the chief bough with terror ; And the high of stature are hewn down, And the haughty are humbled. And he shall cut down the thickets with iron, And Lebanon shall fall by a mighty hand. The root of the word translated ' bough ' means * adorn,' so that it is the chief or top bough, forming the ornamental head of the tree, which is alluded to. The image is now trans- ferred to the state and king of Israel, which is also to be cut down to the stump, bike the tree in Nebuchadnezzar's dream. But out of that stump, and from its living roots, shall grow up a scion — one of those slender shoots which we see springing * " The prophet plainly alludes to the name of the place (lit. the Answers) ; and with a peculiar propriety, if it had its name from its remarkable echo." — Lowth, on the verse. 126 IIEBREW POLITICS. up from, and immediately round, the stock of a truncated tree.* A king of the race of Jesse shall sit on the throne of his fathers, in accordance with the covenant made with David : — ■ ' I have made a covenant with my chosen, I have sworn unto David ray servant, Thy seed will I establish for ever, And build up thy throne unto all generations.' f The Spirit of the Lord shall not merely direct this son of David by occasional and transient impulses, but shall abide continually with him, habitually filling him with the spirit, the very life, of insight into the principles and laws of God's go- vernment of the world, and of discernment how to apply those principles to actual circumstances, so as to bring the latter into harmony with the former ; he shall receive the spirit of true statesmanship, enabling him to understand and to rule, not ideas and things, but men ; he shall have that personal know- ledge of God which is the living source of love and reverence for Him ; his delight in this knowledge and fear of God shall enable him accurately to discern the like disposition in others, so that, with an eye purged from the film of sense, he shall not fail to recognise the cause of truth and righteousness in his kingdom ; and when he has declared his righteous sentence, he will ever stand ready to execute it with prompt and strict justice. And the wolf shall make his home with the lamb, And the leopard shall lie down with the kid ; And the calf, and the young lion, and the falling together ; And a little child shall lead them. And the cow and the she-bear shall feed together ; Together shall their young ones lie down ; And the lion shall eat straw like the ox. And the sucking child shall play on the hole of the asp, And the weaned child shall put his hand on the crested adder's den. They shall not hurt nor destroy in all ray holy mountain : * " Vos modo, milites, favete nomini Scipionum, soboli impcratorum ves- trorum, vclut accisis rccrcscenti stirj>ibus." Liv. lib. xxvi. c. 41. Quoted by Vitringa. f Psalin lxxxix. 3, 4. ISAIAH XI. 6 — 10. : THE GOLDEN AGE. 127 For the earth is full of the knowledge of the Lord, As the waters cover the sea. And in that day shall a root of Jesse stand for an ensign to the peoples ; To it shall the nations seek : And his dwelling-place shall be glorious. The latter lines give the reason why this golden age, de- scribed in language which Lowth says is not equalled by the classical or the Arabic and Persian poets, shall come in the days of the righteous king. It is because his kingdom, which is the kingdom of the Lord, shall extend its influence over, and be recognised by, the whole earth. From the history of the reigns of David, Solomon, and Hezekiah, we see that when there was a righteous king in Israel, he not only governed his own people in wisdom and the fear of the Lord, promoting education and civilisation in that spirit of the ancient law and constitution which is embodied in the book of Deuteronomy, and thus establishing truth and justice, peace and happiness, religion and piety, throughout the land, but that he at the same time (as we might have expected) exercised a humanising in- fluence over the neighbouring nations, gave them glimpses at least of the superiority of the Lord God of Israel over their own idols, and disseminated among them principles of moral and political order which continued to germinate more or less effectually, notwithstanding the resistance of national vice, ignorance, and superstition. But these, and such as these, were but the shadow of good things to come : the acts of Jewish kings, like the words of Jewish prophets, were but various and partial ways of repeating, rather than of realising, the great car- dinal promise made to Abraham, or the great prophetic ideal of the Righteous King which was revealed to Isaiah and the rest of the prophets. But that better thing which God had provided for us, that they without us should not be perfect, is actually come in the coming of Jesus Christ, the Son of David. By the mani- festation of the Righteous King in His own person, the golden age has been made far more actual, and we brought into a far closer connection with it, than was possible or even conceivable in the days of Solomon or Hezekiah. Then the chosen race itself had but a dim knowledge of God, and the nations of the 128 HEBREW POLITICS. earth could but hear of Him through the testimony of the Jewish people and its kings ; but now a greater than Solomon, even the Lord himself, is come into each nation which re- ceives His gospel and His church, and abides in it as its ever- present though invisible King. True it is, that even in those kingdoms of the world which have become the kingdoms of our Lord Christ, we do not yet see all things put under His feet ; the ideal is still far from completely one with, and transcendent through and over, the actual, the heavenly over the earthly ; but by him who has an eye to see, the one may be plainly discerned every where hid under the other, capable of being developed, nay, waiting and ready to be revealed in ever new and more glorious forms. Our part is to believe this heartily, heartily to take our appointed share in the work of realisation ; and not the less so, because we learn more and more every day that we do work, how small our share, how large God's share, in the work must be ; that man's chief business is to ' Leave to Heaven The work of Heaven, and with a silent spirit Sympathise with the powers that work in silence.' I have followed our version in the use of the word ( earth ' in verse 9., though the original might equally be translated 1 laud,'' which would limit the promise of this kingdom of righteousness to Israel, as the reference to the f peoples ' and the ' nations ' in the next verse, compared with such passages as chapter ii. 2 — 4., xix. 18 — 25., is in favour of the wider sense. But the idea of the universal kingdom is certainly not so prominent here as in those and many other places, being subordinated to that of the bringing back ' the outcasts of Israel ' and the ( dispersed of Judah from the four corners of the earth ' to their own land and Lord, and of their reunion into one people as at first. " Jacob, in his prophetic statement of the fortunes of his sons, disregards the rights of primogeniture, and gives the pre- eminence to Judah and Joseph (Gen. xlix. 8 — 12., 22 — 26.), and in the family of the latter to the younger son Ephraim (Gen. xlviii. 19.). Hence, from the time of the exodus, these two were regarded as the leading tribes of Israel. Judah was ISAIAH, XI. 11 — 16.: NATIONAL REPULSIONS AND FUSIONS. 129 much more numerous than Ephralm (Numb. i. 27. 33.), took precedence during the journey in the wilderness (Numb. ii. 3., x. 14.), and received the largest portion in the promised land. But Joshua was an Ephraimite (Numb. xiii. 8.) ; and Shiloh, where the tabernacle long stood (Josh, xviii. 1., 1 Sam. iv. 3.), was probably within the limits of the same tribe. The am- bitious jealousy of the Ephraimites towards other tribes appears in their conduct to Gideon and Jephthah (Judges, viii. 1., xii. 1.). Their special jealousy of Judah showed itself in their temporary refusal to submit to David after the death of Saul, in their adherence to Absalom against his father, and in the readiness with which they joined in the revolt of Jeroboam, who was himself of the tribe of Ephraim (1 Kings, xi. 26.) This schism was, therefore, not a sudden or fortuitous occurrence, but the natural result of causes which had long been working. The mutual relation of the two kingdoms is expressed in the re- corded fact that ' there was war between Rehoboam and Je- roboam, and between Asa and Baasha, all their days' (1 Kings, xiv. 30., xv. 16.). Exceptions to the general rule, as in the case of Ahab and Jehoshaphat, were rare, and a departure from the principles and ordinary feelings of the parties. The ten tribes, which assumed the name of Israel after the division, and perhaps before it, regarded the smaller and less warlike state with a contempt which is well expressed by Jehoash in his parable of the cedar and the thistle (2 Kings, xiv. 9.), unless the feeling there displayed be rather personal than national. On the other hand, Judah justly regarded Israel as guilty not only of political revolt, but of religious apostacy (Psalm Ixxviii. 9 — 11.), and the jealousy of Ephraim towards Judah would of course be increased by the fact that Jehovah had ' forsaken the tabernacle of Shiloh ' (Psalm Ixxviii. 60.), that he ' refused the tabernacle of Joseph, and chose not the tribe of Ephraim, but chose the tribe of Judah, the Mount Zion which he loved ' (Psalm Ixxviii. 67, 68.)"* If Solomon had, like his father David, re- tained to the last his faith in the one God of Israel, and in that maxim of government which David laid down in his 'last words,' that ( he that ruleth over men must be just, ruling in * Alexander's note on verse 13. K 130 HEBREW POLITICS. the fear of God/ and if Rehoboam, Solomon's son, had followed in the same path, it is probable that they might have solved this difficult political problem of fusing into one nation various con- flicting parties and interests, of which I believe the solution has always failed or succeeded according as unity of national worship, and equal rights and justice, have or have not been established : — the centralisation of military force, whether domestic or foreign, is not a fusion, but a suppression, and (if it lasts) a destruction of the elements of national life. But Solomon forgot David's dying counsel that he should 'keep the charge of the Lord his God, to walk in his Avays, to keep his statutes, and his com- mandments, and his judgments, and his testimonies, as it was written in the law of Moses;' and his own prayer when he came to the throne, that the Lord would give him ' an under- standing heart to judge His people, to discern between good and evil,' and to follow the footsteps of ' the truth, righteous- ness, and uprightness of heart before God,' with which, and not with the arbitrary hand of the military chieftain, or the selfish- ness of the oriental despot, David had made it his aim to govern ' this God's so great people.' * The men were not equal to the * 2 Sara, xxiii. 3. ; 1 Kings, ii. 2, 3, 4., iii. 6 — 9. In referring the reader to these passages, it may not be out of place to notice an opinion that David's sub- sequent directions to Solomon ' to bring down the hoar heads of Joab and Shimei to the grave with blood,' are expressions of a revengeful malice in- consistent with a character of piety and justice. A moderately thoughtful ex- amination and comparison of the various notices of these men, and the trans- actions in which they figured, including their deaths, will make it plain that Joab, though a faithful supporter of David's throne, was a brutal soldier, with an influence over the army which made him independent, not only of the king, but of the laws ; while Shimei was a powerful chieftain of the house of Saul, and ready to proceed to any opposition to the reigning dynasty. David was unable to dismiss Joab, and, in a temper as humane as politic, he included the rebel Shimei in the general amnesty when he recovered his crown, and declared, ' There shall no man be put to death this day in Israel.' But he warned Solomon — and Solomon's mode of acting on the warning gives the fair, historical, interpretation of its precise meaning — that these two men would be his most dangerous enemies, the one of his person and house, and the other (who ' shed the blood of war in peace, and put the blood of war upon his girdle that was about his loins, and in his shoes that were on his feet ') of his endeavour to govern the nation by civil law and justice, and not by force ; and that therefore he must watch them narrowly, and if they did again break out, he must not be deterred by a misplaced reverence of pity for their age, or the hope they could not do much harm in their few remain- CONSEQUENCES OF THE REVOLT OF EPHRAIM. 131 occasion, though, by God's providence, their failure was made to illustrate the political law as clearly as their success would have done. And though the student of history feels the same regret at this permanent disruption of what should have been organic, and mutually supporting, members of a one Hebrew commonwealth, as he does at the always frustrated hopes of a national unity in ancient Greece ; yet, in the one case or the other, a deeper insight into what was possible in the then stage of the political growth and education of the human race, teaches us that the evil was the only condition on which it was practicable to secure the far greater good which was secured, and has become a part of the imperishable heritage of mankind. The experiments of Sparta, and even of Athens, and still more those of Macedon, and, above all, of Rome, show us that the problem of how to unite liberty with centralisation, could not be solved in that age. And so no doubt it was with the Hebrews ; though their worship of One God at Jerusalem gave them facilities for true national unity, known nowhere else before the times of the Gospel. It has been observed that the scriptural account of the power of Solomon resembles, almost word for word, some of the paragraphs in the great inscriptions at Nimroud. ' Solomon reigned over the kingdoms from the river [Euphrates] unto the land of the Philistines, and unto the border of Egypt : they brought him presents ... a rate year by year .... and served Solomon all the days of his life He had dominion over all the region on this side the river, from Tiphsah even unto Azzah, over all the kings on this side the river.' * And when we thus see on what a pre- ing years, from executing strict justice on them. Joab joined a conspiracy for deposing Solomon, and Shimei's reason for quitting the surveillance imposed on him, was believed by Solomon to be, and probably was, a pretext for a like course. Burke, who cultivated his love of justice, and hatred of all oppression, by the study of the Bible, and of real life and history, shows incidentally that he thus read this story of David, when (in one of his speeches on financial reform, I think) he warns his hearers that ' they must not spare the hoary head of inveterate abuse.' David did several very cruel as well as arbitrary acts : but we need not resign the use of our reason in reading the Bible, for fear men should call us superstitious. * 1 Kings, iv. 21 and 24. ; 2 Chron. ix. 24. 26. Quoted, with the above observation, by Mr. Layard, Nineveh and Babylon, p 635. k 2 132 HEBREW POLITICS. cipice Solomon stood, and what his descendants and their people might have become ; when we reflect what not only Israel, but the world would have been, if instead of a Bible we had had the annals of a race of Hebrew Sargons and Sennacheribs, and in the fulness of time aKehama — an incarnation of evil — instead of a Son of God ; we shall perceive that, if ever man spoke by the Spirit of God, or did a deed for which all posterity should call him blessed, it was that flagrant radical and revolutionist the prophet Ahijah the Shilonite, who stirred up the young sol- dier Jeroboam to plot against his master Solomon, and openly and successfully to rebel against Rehoboam. At the same time, we must not overlook that this, like the other instances of pro- phets instigating rebellion, belongs to the earlier history of the nation : the later prophets habitually recognise that highest dis- covery of constitutional politics, that, in the maturer age of a commonwealth, all reforms can, and must, be effected by a dis- cussion which, though absolutely refusing all restraint to its words, keeps steadily within the limits of the existing laws, till it can change them by the power of words alone. Of the in- creased clearness with which this momentous distinction is apprehended by our non-beneficed classes in England, we owe more than is usually acknowledged to Mr. Cobden, and his col- leagues in the Anti-Corn Law Agitation. By precept, prac- tice, and success, they have made the truth so popularly intelli- gible, that we may hope that it is as firmly established among us as the case admits of. For, in politics, as in every other region of human thought and action, it is not the mere establish- ment of maxims and traditions, however rational, but the pre- sence of a moral and religious life in the honest and earnest ap- plication of these, which upholds a constitution. The hope and promise of a reunion of the two houses of Israel, which Isaiah utters, are repeated by Ezekiel*: we cannot doubt that such a prospect must have animated the pious and the wise of the nation in each age : and the historians, in terms which show their own appreciation of events such as had not been 'from the days of the judges that judged Israel, nor in all the days of the kings of Israel, nor of the kings of Judah,' * Chapter xxxvii. 15 — 28. GREAT DEPORTATIONS OF JEWS IN ISAIAH'S TIME. 133 describe a resort of persons from all parts of the northern king- dom to keep the passover at Jerusalem in the reigns of both Hezekiah and Josiah, followed by a general visitation of the cities not only of Judah and Benjamin, but also of e Ephraim and Manasseh,' and s Simeon even unto Naphthali,' for the pur- pose of purging the land of the altars, images, and groves of the false gods.* And from these statements of almost exclusively ecclesiastical historians we may infer, with little clanger of being carried away by fancy, that there were corresponding facts in the civil condition of. society; and that in the transient gleams of peace and prosperity which Judah experienced after the fall of Samai'ia and the Ephraimite monarchy, Jerusalem, and the throne, as well as the temple there, became the recognised seat of autho- rity for such of the people of the Ten Tribes as had not been car- ried away by the Assyrians, and as preferred dwelling in towns or villages, with the habits of civilisation and of civil order, to those of mere pastoral families or tribes wandering in the desert at their own will. It was indeed but a feeble restora- tion of the times of David and Solomon, or even of the earlier commonwealth ; yet perhaps a better state of things than seems to have prevailed from the days of Ezra to those of Christ, who proclaimed the fact of a deeper ground of unity than that of descent from Jacob, and of whose meeting with the woman of Samaria we may apply, in reference to this point, His saying, that a Greater fnan Solomon was there. Ephraim and Judah shall be at one ; the Philistines and the Syrians, Edom, Moab, and Amnion, shall again become tribu- taries as they were in the best times of the monarchy : even the great nations of Egypt and Assyria shall give up their captives, — for in that day the Lord will not only dry up the Red Sea, as of old, but will extend the same power to the Euphrates, striking its deep streams into many shallow ones, and thus making a way for his people to return out of both these lands. Pathros is Thebais, or Upper Egypt ; Cusli is Ethiopia, and also Arabia Deserta, along the east coast of the Red Sea ; Elam is Elymais, adjoining — and often used to include — Persia, as * 2 Chron. xxx. 1. to xxxi. 1.; 2 Kings, xxiii. 1 — 23.; 2 Chron. xxxiv, 29. to xxxv. 18. k 3 134 HEBREW POLITICS. well as Susiana, and Media; Shinar, Babylonia; Hamath, a chief city of Syria ; and the Islands of the Sea are the isles and coasts of the Mediterranean. The Chronicles mention as a great national calamity the num- bers of captives taken by the Syrians, Ephraimites, Edomites, and Philistines, during the reign of Ahaz.* Joel speaks of the Tyrians, Zidonians, and Philistines, selling the Jews to the Greciansf, and Amos seems to allude to a similar sale to the Edomites. :}: Isaiah refers elsewhere (chap. xvi. 4.) to Jews who had fled their own country to escape domestic or foreign oppres- sion ; and in the times of Jeremiah we have like instances. § And comparing these and similar || proofs of the practice of the Jews and their enemies with that of all the other nations of antiquity, we have abundant evidence — even if we are too cautious to adopt till after farther investigation the reading^ of the Nineveh inscription, with Sennacherib's account of his having carried off the whole population which dwelled around Jerusalem — that during the reigns of Ahaz and his successor there was such a dispersion and captivity of the people as that from which Isaiah here promises the restoration. That the fulfilment of this pro- mise in the succeeding reign of Hezekiah was most inadequate, must be evident to him who sets the outward possibilities of the occasion against the unbounded magnificence of the pro- phetic ideal : yet it need not be doubted that such a fulfilment as the case did admit, would have been brought about by the king, and the relations of those of his subjects, Avho were in exile or slavery : for in the latter years his reign, when ' many brought gifts unto the Lord to Jerusalem, and pre- sents to Hezekiah king of Judah, so that he was magnified in the sight of all nations from thenceforth,' he would have been well able to demand the restoration of his people Avith effect. The reference to the Philistines may be compared with Sennacherib's statement that ( the nobles and the people of Ekron having expelled their king Iladdiya, and the Assyrian troops who garrisoned the town, attached themselves to Heze- * 2 Chron. xxviii. 5. 8. 17, 18., xxix. 9. "f Joel, iii. 6. J Amos, i. 9. § Jeremiah, xli. xlii. || As 2 Kings, xv. 29., xvii. 6. 18. T[ Rawlinson's Outline, p. 23. The translation of Dr. Ilincks, as given by Mr. Layard (Nineveh and Babylon, p. 143.), is less distinct on this point. ISAIAH XII.: THE CHURCH AND THE NATIONS. 135 kiah of Judrca, and paid their adorations to his God.'* The smiting the Euphrates into seven streams, Grotius, with his wonted clear and practical appreciation of fact and history, refers to the partial dismemberment of Assyria by the defection of the Medes and Chaldees, which, according to Herodotus, took place about the same time with Sennacherib's retreat from the invasion of Judrea and Egypt : for the reconciliation of the Greek historian with the native records, we must wait till they are more thoroughly deciphered and translated. The prophet finally concludes this prophecy,, the structure of which we have so often paused to admire in its various parts, with a hymn, after the manner of those which, in the Book of Psalms, have these two thousand years been reckoned among the most precious treasures of men, women, and children, all over the world. It is a hymn of the restored church, which Isaiah puts into her mouth * in that day.' I say the restored church, rather than the nation, because the whole matter as well as tone of the hymn — as indeed the name hymn would signify — marks that Church is the proper word here. It is as impossible to un- derstand the history and literature of ancient Israel, as it is those of modern France, Germany, or England, if we are ignorant of, or do not duly appreciate, the presence and influence of the church in each. And by the church of the Hebrews I do not here mean their national and endowed priesthood, with its pre- scribed laws and rituals for national worship and education, and which are analogous to the like institution among ourselves ; I speak of that spiritual brotherhood of which the ecclesiastical ' estate of the realm' in any nation is the proper symbol, and which embodies and expresses itself in and by that symbol in as far as it can ; but which cannot limit itself to that or any other earthly form, because it is itself heavenly, and transcends all the partial and imperfect forms of earth, even when they are at their best, and still more so when (as often happens) they have become deeply, or even hopelessly, corrupted and decayed. This brotherhood has God for its father, and for its elder brother and head the Son of God, whom the beloved Apostle beheld in vision, while ' ten thousand times ten thousand, and thousands * Rawlinson's Outline, p. 23. k 4 136 HEBREW POLITICS. of thousands,' sang — ' Thou wast slain, and hast redeemed us to God by thy blood out of every kindred, and tongue, and people, and nation ; and hast made us unto our God kings and priests ; and we shall reign on the earth.' And what St. John contemplated and declared with the eye and tongue of the old Hebrew seers, St. Paul has set forth in the language and by the methods of European philosophy ; while the life and substance of the teaching of both is contained in the last discourses of their Master and ours, who said, ' Neither pray I for these alone, but for them also which shall believe on me through their word ; that they all may be one ; as thou, Father, art in me, and I in thee, that they also may be one in us : that the world may believe that thou hast sent me.' The world and the church are the two universal opposites : not the world merely in some particularly bad sense, but in all senses, good and bad ; — the world which hates and resists the church with active enmity ; the world which hinders the church by its indifference, selfish- ness, corruption, and decay ; and also the world into which the church is in all ages infusing its own, or rather its Lord's, un- worldly, heavenly spirit ; Avhich shall be at last entirely renewed by that spirit, and shall ' believe ' that the church, and the Lord of the church, were indeed sent by the Father of all, that his Name may be glorified in and through all. This church, which Socrates and Plato hoped to find, and dwell in, after death*, but which Jesus Christ and his Apostles tell us, and we know — unless we shut our eyes to the truth — is actually * " This law of degeneracy [according to Plato] exists in the com- monwealths of the earth, just because they have not understood and steadfastly contemplated that original model, that perfect idea of a common- wealth, which is also the original model and perfect idea of a human cha- racter. It is a contradiction and absurdity then to allege the fact of this degeneracy as a proof that no such model is to be found. But after all these inquiries does the thought still linger about the mind, where is it to be found ? Plato answers (book ix. p. fin.), 'AAA1 b> oupai<

bpav km bpwvri taurbv KaroiKi'^eiv. Is it wonderful that such words should have suggested to some of the Christian fathers the recollection of those words in the Epistle to the Hebrews, which describe the hopes of the head of the covenanted people, 'E|e5exei-o y&p tV robs OepeKlovs ixov