i llil llil !!aiill!i!iiii^"'- mi niliiiiii.i UiiilillniiuUliiiiil.iiiiliillilliilil il^^^^l^^ ^^x^"^ PRIIS Dy Mr. Sanr rCETON, N. J. adelphia, Pa. _ . Presented luel Agne\N of Phi Division^Vl^ II Sec/ion ' T cD O Number M , \ BR 157 .F74 1845 Free Church of Scotland. Lectures on foreign churche^ LECTURES FOREIGN CHURCHES, LECTURES ON FOREIGN CHURCHES. DELIVERED IN EDINBURGH AND GLASGOW, MAY 1845, IN CONNECTION WITH THE OBJECTS OF THE COMMITTEE OF THE FREE CHURCH OF SCOTLAND ON THE STATE OF CHRISTIAN CHURCHES ON THE CONTINENT AND IN THE EAST. FIRST SERIES. EDINBURGH : W. P. KENNEDY, ST ANDREW STREET, GLASGOW : D. BRYCE. BELFAST : W. m'COMB. LONDON : HAMILTON, ADAMS & CO., AND JAMES NISBET & CO. MDCCCXLV. EDINBURGH : PRINTED BY JOHN GREIG, LAWNMAKKBT. Hi CONTENTS. .^^^ I. iNTRODUCTORr— " Tlie Relations in which the Churches of Christ ought to stand to each other — Principles of Union, and Mutual Duties." By Robert S. Candlish, D.D., Minister of Free St George's, Edinburgh, . . 3 II. The Independent Eastern Churches. By John . Wilson, D. D., F. R. S., of the Free Church of Scotland's Mission at Bombay, . . . . .41 III. The Ancient History of the Waldensian Church. By Rev. Thomas M'Crie, Professor of Theology to the Synod of Original Seceders, .... 165 IV. On the Present Condition and Future Prospects of the Waldensian Church. By the Rev. Robert W. Stewart, A.M., late of Erskine, . . .205 V. Religious History of Holland and Belgium since the Reformation. By William K. Tweedie, Mi- nister of Free Tolbooth Church, Edinburgh, . . 269 VI. Past and Present State of Evangelical Religion in Switzerland, especially Geneva. By Pa- trick M'Farlan, D.D., Minister of the Free West Church, Greenock, ..... 325 VII. The Past and Present State of Evangelical Re- LiGloN in France. By J. G. Lorimer, Minister of Free St David's, Glasgow, .... 383 LECTURE I. Introductory—" The Relations in which the Churches OF Christ ought to stand to each other — Principles OF Union, and Mutual Duties." BY ROBERT S. CANDLISH, D.D. SnNISTEB OF FEEE ST GEOKGE'S, EDINBUBGH. The subject more immediately brought before us, in connection with the proposed Course of Lectures, is not so much the general question of union among Christians, as one particular portion or department of that question, bearing upon the relations which ought to subsist among the different branches of the cliurch of Christ, in differ- ent parts of the world. The geographical divisions of the Church, according to continents and countries, form a totally distinct field of contemplation, from its polemi- cal distractions, according to names and parties ; and the inquiry into the nature of the correspondence which the Christians of various lands ought to have with one another, is not to be confounded with that which relates to the healing of breaches among Christians dwelling together in the same territory, — though, alas ! not dwelling together in unity. It is true, indeed, that in the present state of Christendom, these two subjects of inquiry run very much into one another, and cannot be 4 INTRODUCTORY LECTURE. kept altogether separate ; since the causes of diversity which affect Christian society in one place, operate, more or less, over the whole world ; and the mutual duties and terms of reciprocal fellowship among churches sepa- rated by seas and mountains, can scarcely be adjusted without facing the difficulties, and in part at least, and practically, settling not a few of the points of controversy, involved in any attempt to harmonise those, whom, with- out such physical barriers, minute articles of creed, and too often mere punctilios of form, rend even more widely asunder. Still, it is desirable to distinguish between the two topics ; and for this, among other reasons," that while the one, namely, that which would deal with the church as geographically subdivided, may be considered with far greater calmness and clearness than the other, since it does not so violently raise the din and dust of per- sonal and party strife, — the principles of good sense and Christian love naturally and necessarily unfolded in the discussion and right disposal of it, may, by an indirect but most happy influence, tell with good effect on what will be found to be very much mixed up with it, and what constitutes the great and urgent Christian problem of the day ; the determination, that is, of the sense and man- ner in which, split as she is into sections and fragments, by innumerable peculiarities of thought and feehng, brought out in the exercise of that right of private judg- ment and free scriptural inquiry which is her just privi- lege and boast (let no man take her crown), — the Pro- testant Evangelical Church of the living God, is yet, in every land and over all the earth, to recognise herself, and be recognised by the world, as one. Let us look, then, at Christianity in its first introduc- tion to mankind, by its Divine Founder and his inspired MUTUAL RELATIONS OF CHURCHES. O followers. It is to possess and occupy the world. It is to penetrate into all nations, and come into contact with every creature ; and its doctrines and ordinances are to be everywhere preached and administered. How is it to be fitted for this end ? In the first place, it is to be altogether divested of the local and territorial character which belonged to the pre- ceding dispensation, as well as of the cumbrous mass of ritual and ceremonial observances to which the Jewish church was bound. There is to be no holy city or venerable temple on earth, to which the tribes of the Lord must go up ; there is to be no priestly order or transmitted virtue of priestly consecration ; nor is any set of minute and rigid regulations, as to the worship and service of God, to be enforced by statute, or pre- scribed as the condition of acceptance. Under the Old Testament economy, " the people were to dwell alone ;" and accessions from other nations could be made by proselytism, only on the terms of exact conformity to a strict, specified, and unalterable routine ; implying a con- nection of locality with one favoured spot, and a concur- rence in one precise and peremptory directory. The gospel threw matters much more open as to all that concerns the place, the agents, and the manner of wor- ship ; religion ceased to be local, personal, and ceremo- nial ; the truth to be received was most exactly and carefully defined ; but, evidently of set purpose, no rules were given for settling in detail the questions of, where ? and how? or the localities and methods of divine service ; pains were taken to have men's minds duly informed, and men's hearts made right with God ; but, as to the rest, latitude was allowed for carrying out, in practice, the general principles of evangelical faith and love. 6 INTRODUCTORY LECTURE. But farther, secondly, as to rule or government, one thing, at least, is plain, that under the new economy, no universal empire or monarchy was established ; certainly not in the beginning of the Christian dispensation, was any such universal subjection to one authority contemplated, or any provision made for it. On the contrary, the temple service, and the whole priestly hierarchy connected with it, being for ever set aside, the model or platform of the Christian discipline and administration, was undeniably the usage of the synagogues ; and beyond all question, that system savoured far more of the principle of repub- lican self-regulation ; each society with its own officers, exercisino- a laroe discretion in the reo-ulation of its own services and the manao-ement of its own affairs ; than of any general and uniform submission to one order or to one head. It would appear, indeed, that in cities and populous neighbourhoods, there was more of a community of the pastors and elders of different congregations, as well as of the concrresations themselves, than the ancient cus- tom of the synagogue, or, perhaps, the modern rule of in- dependency based upon it, exemplifies and reahses ; and there are reasons for believinoj that local ties contributed to consolidate the believing inhabitants of a town, a pro- vince, and a country, into one compact body, and that this formed a part of the original apostolic plan. Still, whether on a smaller or a larger scale, the principle which developed itself in the early church, and which is, at least by implication and in embryo, contained in the New Testament, is substantially that of self-government ; fitted to give the church the aspect of a number of free and separate commonwealths, rather than that of one single, vast, and gigantic empire. It must be added, however, in the third place, to com- MUTUAL RELATIONS OF CHURCHES. / plete this view of Christianity, as it started on its earthly career, that it evidently pointed not only to a close and frequent interchange of good offices among these spiri- tual commonwealths or republics, but to the exercise of much mutual deference, in the way of constantly con- sulting one another, referring difficult points of doc- trine and duty for grave deliberation and advice, and renderino- cheerful and unconstrained respect to the voice of counsel or admonition that might issue from meetings, or convocations, of venerable fathers and el- ders, possessing the general confidence of God's people, and giving evidence of being directed by his good Spirit. The apostolic journeys, so manifold, and often so perilous, — the messages sent by trustworthy ambassadors from church to church, conveying substantial proofs of brotherly losre, — and the case or cases of conscience, sent up from the provinces, and submitted to the apostles and bre- thren at Jerusalem, the most influential general council to which appeal could then be made ; all these precedents, without pressing them too far, or regarding them as binding in the letter, make out, at least, the general principle of a sort of federal union of kindness and con- sultation, among the independent Christian communities of diff"erent cities and countries throughout the world. Now, let primitive Christianity, wdth a constitution thus elastic, yet cohering, be viewed as making way among the nations. Congregations spring up in the larger towns ; and as these multiply, and spread their branches into the surrounding neighbourhoods, they form themselves into societies, under their pastors and elders, consulting and acting together, in consistories, or colleges, or pres- byteries, or synods. Gradually and insensibly, territorial boundaries, or the arrangements of civil governments, 8 INTRODUCTORY LECTURE. mould into shape and form the larger sections into which these smaller bodies combine ; union, not isolation, being the law and tendency of the gospel ; and Christian com- mmiities are found to become provincial and national. Considerable diversities, it is not improbable, may be allowed to prevail, even within these united brotherhoods; and between one of them and another, still greater dis- similarity may exist. The general rule of decency and order, and the precept of mutual forbearance and ten- derness towards weaker brethren, being observed in all, and rites and ceremonies of human appointment, with whatsoever, in the discipline and worship of the church, has not warrant of the word of God, being repudiated and disowned, there will still be room for shades of pecu- liarity, occasioned by climate, customs, or circumstances. Instead of the dead flat level of insipid and enforced uniformity, not a little variety of undulating surface and tints of diverse colours may gratify the liberty -loving eye. But no inconvenience need arise from this, nor any breach of real unity. The discarding of all forms, ceremonies and observances, and indeed, all works of every kind, from having any place at all, or any thing whatever to do, in the sinner's justification before God, and the unanimous consent to receive that great boon, as the free gift of God, dispensed through the righteous- ness and blood of his own Son, and appropriated by that faith which his own Spirit works in the heart, — the loyalty and allegiance exclusively rendered to the divine word, apart from all authority and tradition of man, — the di- rect access to God assured to every behever in Jesus, without the intervention of any priesthood, — the liberty of adoption which the sacraments only outwardly, but the Holy Ghost inwardly seals, — and the glowing love, not MUTUAL RELATIONS OF CHURCHES. U of a doubtful and contingent, but of a present and full reconciliation, — all these elements of harmony may pre- serve unbroken, amid many differences of detail, the peace of congregations and communities ; and when to all this, we add the influence of these lesser or larger bodies on one another, through a reciprocity of cordial and kindly attention, and the weight of well-timed and well-considered decisions, given forth, on critical ques- tions, from quarters universally deemed, at least in a moral sense, authoritative, — as from arbiters or umpires or assemblies, generally called and trusted, — we may form to ourselves the conception of the universal Christian church, minutely subdivided, as is the surface of this ter- raqueous globe, and in its minutest subdivisions, free and self-regulating ; yet presenting, as a whole, the aspect of one great republic of letters and religion, with common counsels and a common spirit, and capable of many a combined effort, for mutual comfort, improvement and defence, as well as for reclaiming the waste places of the earth and invading the territories still unsubdued. This, however, it may be said, is a fair theory : but alas ! it is nothing more. True. But what then ? Is it wonderful that the apostolic model should fail to be realised, when it was to be carried into practice by men full of prejudices and passions at the best, and in too many cases, by Christians but half- enhghtened, if not, even in the earliest age, by hypocrites and formalists ? Or is it the less on that account to be held up now, in these latter days, as the mould and measure of Christian effort and aspiration, if by any means the Spirit may yet be given, for having it executed on some considerable scale and exhibited to a wondering world, ere the end come ? And, that it is, in itself, no impracticable scheme, or 10 INTRODUCTORY LECTURE. Utopian dream, may be gathered, not only from the brief sunshine of that Pentecostal time, when the multitude of them that believed were of one mind and of one heart, and great grace was upon them all ; but from the very device of the adversary himself. He, at least, is no visionary ; he deals with no speculative and theoretical schemes ; but he shrewdly avails himself of hints that may be acted on, and turns them to practical account. And, it might almost seem, as if the plan and machinery of this noble enterprise having fallen into his hands, Antichrist had set himself to work it out. Taking ad- vantage of the tendency in all the portions of the church to associate and run together, and adroitly substituting a poHtical and priestly, for a doctrinal bond and basis of union, (for it is easier to make men one, in the spirit of party or the panic of superstition, than in the harmony of free thought and warm affection,) he was able to turn the Christian ministry, throughout all nations, into a trained and disciplined police, and to give, on his own terms, to his minion, the Roman Pontiff, that throne of the world, which the Lord himself had refused. The boasted unity of Popery, with its wide-spread ramifica- tions and organization, throughout all lands, is the mimic rival and distorted caricature, of that all-pervading sym- pathy, breathing submission to one another, and the submission of all to Christ, which overflowing the inter- sected field of Christianity, should have presented to the eyes of men, the one unbroken tide of divine and brother- ly love, filling up all inequalities, and covering all land- marks, and making the whole, as it were, one broad and placid ocean, reflecting in its bosom the wondrous unity of Father, Son, and Holy Ghost, the one living and everlasting God. MUTUAL RELATIONS OF CHURCHES. 11 Still farther, that we may judge of the truth and reahty of the representation which we have given, let us look at the era of the R-eformation. Then, light simultaneously broke in on thechurches of all various lands ; and without any common plan or preconcerted scheme, without dic- tating to one another or owning any common master, guided by the word, and the Spirit sought in prayer ac- cordincr to the word, cono-reo-ations and communities, with their bishops, pastors and elders, reformed themselves from popery. In different countries they acted, to a great extent, independently of one another, and their different circumstances, as well as the peculiarities of national and individual character, very considerably mo- dified their plans and proceedings ; so that shades of di- versity marked their several creeds and constitutions. Yet, after all, and on the whole, how marvellously near did they come to one another. The harmony of the Protestant confessions, in all essential particulars, has defied the skill and learning of Rome's ablest advocates, to effect any serious breach. How close, also, and how intimate was the intercourse and correspondence of the reformers of difterent lands, both personally and by letters ; how frankly did the churches mutually afford to one another asylums of refuge for their persecuted sons ; and how unhesitatingly were ministers, on visits or in exile, invited to officiate, as they were ever willing to do, in communities constituted, in many things, very differently from their own. Thus, John Knox served a cure in the Episcopal Church of England, preaching, whether in surplice or gown, is not recorded ; and not a few of the victims of the Marian persecution, confessors of the true faith, and fugitives from the fires of Smith- field, were hailed and welcomed as honoured servants of 12 INTRODUCTORY LECTURE. Christ, and officiated as pastors of congregations in Switzerland and Holland, till the accession of Elizabeth restored them, with some taint, perhaps, of presbytery and puritanism, to their own country, and their church, which they would gladly have seen brought nearer to the foreign pattern than prince or prelate would allow. England was not then quite so jealous of Geneva as she is now ; nor were her sleeves of lawn so fearful of con- tact with the homely presbyterian cloak. We might refer to the Zurich letters, recently pubhshed by the Parker Society, as full of illustrations of the community of mind and heart that prevailed among the reformers of all the different sections of Christendom ; the very table of contents, is in this view, instructive,* and when we come to read the letters themselves, we find them breathing a spirit of intense affection on both sides, and especially, a spirit of deference, and anxiety to be coun- selled, on the side of the Anglican bishops and divines, certainly very unlike the tone and manner in which now- a-days some of them are apt to speak of those Christian churches and Christian ministers, who unhappily want the mysterious virtue resident in Episcopal government, apostolic succession, and baptismal regeneration. * Thus, Bishop Jewel writes to Peter Martyr, Henry Bullinger, Rodolph Gualter, Josiah Simler, and others ; Bishop Cox, also. Bishops Sandys, Parkhurst, Horn and Grindal, are correspondents of the same parties ; and of the spirit in which all this epistolary intercourse is carried on, let the honest-hearted burst of affectionate enthusiasm to which Jewel gives vent, be taken as a specimen: — " O Zurich, Zurich," he exclaims to Peter Martyr, " how much oftener do I now think of thee, than ever I thought of England when I was at Zurich !" O for such times again, and such cordial brotherhood between the dignitiiries of Episcopacy and the prea- byters of those more simple communions, with which, once at least, Episcopacy did not refuse to fraternise. MUTUAL RELATIONS OF CHURCHES. 13 Several subordinate causes contributed to form such habits of intercourse and familiar intimacy among the re- formers and the reformed churches, in all various coun- tries. Besides the fierce persecutions, which, breaking out in these countries successively, forced the protestants to flee from city to city, and from land to land, we might refer to the custom of close correspondence among learned men on the revival of letters, and perhaps, also, to the uni- versal knowledge and use of the Latin tongue. The press did not, indeed, then, as now, teem with its innumerable progeny of ephemeral journals, which flying all abroad, as on the wings of the wind, waft the idlest gossip and the faintest rumour of the hour to the remotest chmes and most secluded retreats ; nor was the giant power of steam evoked to bring distant isles and continents together. Still, at that remarkable era, " men did run to and fro, and knowledge was increased ;" a commonwealth of li- terature, with an acknowledged free-masonry of learned dialog-ue and somewhat stately epistolary eloquence among the initiated scholars of the day, filled all Europe; the colleges exchanged professors and students ; educated men understood one another, sought to see one another face to face, visited one another, and wrote to one another. It was an age of stir and bustle, at any rate ; and when, after the invention of printing and the awakening of the slumbering intellect and spirit of the times, the religious excitement came, kindled and controlled by the master minds of that age of master minds, the train was pre- viously laid, and all was ready for the freest circulation of the flame, fed, as it was, with earth's purest and brightest fuel, and fanned by the breath of heaven. Is the cycle again run out ? Has that old era come up again ? Does our own day witness a fulfilment of Daniel's 14 INTRODUCTORY LECTURE. prophecy, even more striking, both physically and intel- lectually, than that of the Reformation period ? " Many shall run to and fro, and knowledo-e shall be increased." Trade, commerce, gambling speculation, exhaustless and endless production of wealth, dizzy calculation of mer- cantile chances, incessant hurry of locomotion, a pres- sure, at the higrhest, on all men's energies — what fever of the over- wrought brain and pulse may these not occasion and account for ? Then, we have the opening up of new worlds, in far Australia, and in the Chinese seas, and our jBery vessels ploughing the Indian and Atlantic Oceans, and all Europe and America chequered with those iron ways, along which men rush with the speed of wind. We have the waking up, also, of the general mind, from a cold ague fit, to alertness and life ; and all things betoken on earnest time, and earnest doings. Nor are there wanting indications of a process going on fitted to make men of high thought and deep feeling recognise, over all the earth, their brotherhood again. Events and circum- stances are brino-inr>- such men more and more tog-ether. They who have toiled, and testified, and suffered for Christ in difi'erent lands, are seeing one another in the flesh, and learning to know one another. Visits are in- terchanged; and foreign accents are not so strange as they were in social circles, and even in ecclesiastical as- semblies, and the customary house of prayer. Is the analogy we have indicated altogether fanciful ? Nay, does not that Reformation era, with its disniptions and reconstructions — its rending asunder of many ties — its stormy outbreak of truth in the very heart of Popery — its healino; ag-ain of the wound inflicted on the beast, — its confrontincr of the combatants to one another, with that strange breaking of their ranks, ere the combat was well MUTUAL RELATIONS OF CHURCHES. 15 bejvun — almost seem as the shadow of what is now to be exhibited — the rehearsal of what is now to be enacted, on this time-trodden stage, ere the curtain drop which is to close all ? If so — if in any measure this may be re- garded as a true interpretation of past and present ap- pearances — may we not seek, if it please God, under hap- pier auspices, to realise the state of things, as regards the fellowship of the churches, which partially existed among our reforming fathers ; and the rather, as they have left some beacons for our warning. Into the causes which arrested and disturbed the free circulation of the pure and vital blood through all the veins of the body ecclesiastical, animated surely, for a time at least, by one soul, through the indwelling of the Spirit of Christ, it would be impossible to enter at large ; they will be found to be to a great extent identical with the causes of the check given to the advancing progress of the Reformation — a fact, or phenomenon in history, at least as remarkable as its rise. The marvellous growth of that living form of Christianity soon came to a stand ; the reforming church ceased to expand herself; the quick- ening Spirit seemed to be straitened or withdrawn ; and the firm strength and fresh beauty of her nervous frame, gave place to the pallor of exhaustion in the countenance, and in the limbs, the palsy of premature decrepitude and decay. Angry passions tearing her own bosom, and the wretched wars, and still more wretched politics, of the princes of this world, who would be by turns her tyrants or her patrons, contributed to this sad result ; and for long years, the Protestant church in Christendom, as a whole, may be said to have dragged on a protracted existence, with fitful impulses of partial and occasional revivals ; but, alas ! without that uniform and general " growing 16 INTRODUCTORY LECTURE. up into Him who is the head, in all things," whereby " the body maketh increase of itself, unto the edifying of itself in love." The religious wars, also, on the Continent, the revolutionary struggles in England, the persecutions of the Vaudois in Piedmont, and the Covenanters in Scotland, together with the internal factions which dis- •tracted and weakened the various national churches, and the tendency of the reaction from that eager tension of spirit, which had been keeping men's minds on the stretch, to degenerate into the languor of barren and antinomian orthodoxy, or to seek relief in novelties and errors — all these influences must be taken into our cal- culation, if we would trace the origin and stealthy ad- vances of that sleep of death, which fell, as a withering bhght, on the whole Protestant church; and in which even Popery partly shared. Then came the days of isolation, when churches severed by a ridge of hills, or an arm of the sea, knew little of one another, and cared to know still less. Nor was this surprising. For, could it be expected that they would be very anxious to in- quire of one another, how it fared with Christ's cause and men's souls, when they never seriously made such inquiries within themselves ? And when, at last, a bet- ter day began to dawn, as the eighteenth century drew towards its close, and the present was darkly ushered in, amid the storm of war, yet with gleams of better hope, — the faithful men in each community found enough to do at home ; and some time, besides, must naturally elapse, before the long habit of selfish indifference could be broken, and the beating of the warm Catholic heart of Cliristianity be felt once more. But, now, the hour is fully come, and the longing is generally felt, for the current of evangeUcal sympathy MUTUAL RELATIONS OF CHURCHES. 17 to circulate again, and the grace and strength of evan- gehcal union, — not artificial, forced, and fettered, — but free, elastic, and unconfined, — to be manifested at last for the conviction of an unbelieving world. How all- important, in such a crisis, that all the several sections of the Protestant commonwealth, instead of churlishly questioning, or with faint hesitation, barely admitting, one another's Christianity, should have arms and hearts open to embrace as brethren ! How sad, if any church, however apostolic, shall isolate herself, in these days, from the great Protestant brotherhood, and under what- ever pretence of a via media, between Romanism and Dissent, shall insult the spiritual descendants of Luther and Calvin, by coolly classing them in the same cate- gory, under some nicely- turned antithesis, with the fol- lowers of the Man of Sin.* What pity if the Church of Cranmer and Jewel, enamoured of a soul-destroying error, making baptism the new birth, and besotted with * For instance, an article in the "English Review," on the " Eng- lish Church on the Continent," making all hope of good depend, as usual, on Anglican Episcopacy, thus skilfully balances its censures and concessions : — " Both the Romanist and the Protestant com- munions are in these countries in a state of ferment, the former unable to resist the progress of more enlightened views of Chris- tianity, even within its own pale ; the latter equally unable to avert the licentious rationalism that has been bred in its bosom." Of course, Anglican example is to put all right, both parties being, as it would seem, about equally wrong. Or, if some charity is to be extended to them, it is with the same impartiality, giving no preference to either. " The Christian communions of the Con- tinent, however much they may be defiled by Romish errors, or however imperfectly constituted, in the absence of an apostolically derived ministry," — their faults about equal, and their chances equal too, — " are not to be held by us as beyond the pale of the Christian world." Most gracious admission ! And this is not a Tractarian journal, but one rather of a moderate tone. B 18 INTRODUCTORY LECTURE. the fond notion of a transmitted priesthood, going far to make void the sole priesthood of Christ, — shall seem to frown on the entire mass and body of reformed Christen- dom, which, from the beginning, with the single excep- tion of herself and her American daughter, has chosen, as scriptural, a simpler ritual and less ambiguous faith, and the privilege of being taught and governed by pres- byters alone. What avails the shallow pretence of the rationalism of these churches, already fast disappearing before the reviving enthusiasm of a reviving age ? Has she forgot the cold fit of latitudinarianism and infidelity, which the passing knell of death in her high places may even now remind her, is scarcely yet over ? And is she really to stand aloof, as, amid the multitude of those who worship Jesus, the sole authentic depository of the grace of Heaven, prepared to swallow up all her once-owned and much-loved sister churches, but to give the hand of fellowship to none ? If so, shall not the voice go forth, for this and other signs of sympathy with Antichrist, Come out of her my people ; or at least raise a more energetic protest within, — aye, though England's St Bartholomew be enacted once more, and a stern mother cast forth her thousands from her bosom, to find a home in every Christian heart, and be free to recognise a brother in the kindling eye of every Christian face ? All honour, however, we must add, be to the men, such as Hartley, Bickersteth, Gillies, and the many other friends of the Continent, among the clergy and people of the English Church, who were the first to awaken among Christians at home, an interest in reli- gion abroad, and who have proved themselves the uni- form and liberal supporters of all the missionary plans of our brethren in foreign lands. Would that they were MUTUAL RELATIONS OF CHURCHES. 19 able to stem the tide of Anglican intolerance, which threatens to sweep all reason and charity away ! Would that they, and many besides, held themselves more free and ready, for combined cordial and decided action, with the calumniated Protestants over all the world, against the fast mustering ranks of Oxford and of Rome ! But, passing from this painful theme, let us ask, — What practical measures may be taken for manifesting and maturing the union, which is so desirable, and turning it to good account ? And, here, the first expe- dient which naturally suggests itself, is that of conference and consultation among the churches. On this point, the general principles laid down at the outset may partly guide us ; and we may profit also, by the experience of the reformers. Two things, especially, seem clear, first, that we are not ripe for the calhng of anything like a general legislative or authoritative council ; and secondly, that, for any scheme of co-operation, to insist on minute agreement on all the articles of any creed, would be an insuperable ban ier, at the very outset, to all hearty cor- respondence or communion. In regard to the first point, we may observe, that even in particular countries, few would anticipate good, at pre- sent, from national conventions of the Christians at large, to settle the affairs of the nation's Christianity ; nor, how- ever precious the result of their deliberations, would a re- petition of either the Synod of Dort or the Westminster Assembly precisely meet the present exigency. And on a larger scale, any such attempt would be disastrous. But nothing could be more practicable, nothing more safe or becoming, than the meeting together, from time to time, of brethren, representing the various Protestant churches, at convenient seasons and places, for prayer 20 INTRODUCTORY LECTURE. and conference on all that relates to their common Christianity. Let such convocations, stated or occa- sional, be arranged to be held, now in one great city and now in another, and let the facilities of travel be regarded as taking away all excuse from any society neglecting to send its members ; and when these convocations are constituted, let them have no power or authority over particular churches, nor any right to interfere, beyond giving advice when asked ; but let the time be spent in Christian fellowship, and devout exercises of soul before God ; let missionary intelligence, and information re- garding the Lord's work, be interchanged ; let the pro- gress of error be watched and marked ; and let plans be canvassed, and suggestions made, for promoting the in- creased efficiency of the means of grace, and obtaining an increased effusion of the Spirit of God. Controversies need not be agitated, since there would be no competent tribunal to settle them ; questions of discipline and go- vernment need not come up, since there would be no court of final appeal to dispose of them : all may be occupied in brotherly conversation on the spiritual reali- ties of the divine word, and the spiritual interests of the divine kingdom. The second matter referred to is more difficult; the adjustment of such a test or criterion of genuine Chris- tianity, as may exclude the avowed holders of error, and yet be comprehensive enough to embrace all who love the truth. For this end, it is allowed on all hands, that whatever may be the general harmony of the Protestant confessions, no one of them could in fairness be adopted, as it stands, for all. Two methods are suggested for (retting over this difficulty. The first would seek, by a selection out of existing confessions or the compilation MUTUAL RELATIONS OF CHURCHES. 21 of some new form of agreement, to frame a few short and simple articles in which all may concur, embodying the essentials of the gospel, and nothing more. Now, we acknowledge that we look with considerable dread to this plan being carried out, both because it is so difficult as to involve endless delays and deliberations, — meeting the views of this body, and obviating the scruples of that, and bandying to and fro indefinite proposals ; and still more, because it seems to be fraught with danger to the soundness and good faith of the churches, in their adherence to their present formularies. It is a hazardous thino- to set about drawinoj the line between essentials and non-essentials in religion, and selecting out of a creed, which is compact and consistent as a whole, what por- tions are to be deemed indispensable, and as such, de- tached from the rest, on which a slur may be thus ima- gined to be cast. We fully admit, indeed, the propriety of Christians substantially drawing this distinction, for the recognition of one another's Christianity, and the regulation of their mutual intercourse. But the risk is when they begin also to do this, in forming their own opinions, and determining their own conduct ; for a door is thus opened to much subtle casuistry and refinement, and a sophistical tampering with conscience, as to the harmlessness of ignorance and error, upon minor points. Now, in this view, it is not safe for any man to count any point a minor one, on which Scripture may be found to give any deliverance at all, if he use such an idea as an apology for either not inquiring, or not making up his mind, in regard to it. For, not to speak of the relaxed conscientiousness and impaired moral tone that may be thus engendered, we really know too little of the mutual relations and influences of the truths of God, as they 22 INTRODUCTORY LECTURE. stand in his word, all harmonizing and meeting together, or of their mutual bearings, as they balance one another in the believing mind, to be able to assure ourselves, that an error, even in non-fundamentals, may not, to us at least, be pernicious and fatal ; and it were to be re- gretted, if the adoption of a vaguer and more general profession, in the adjustment of the fellowship of the churches, should seem at all to warrant a loose and latitudinarian interpretation, even of the details, of their particular creeds. But, besides, we have another fear. All experience sliews, that the omission, or disparage- ment, or doubtful interpretation, of a single clause in a well-weighed doctrinal statement, may be held to cover far greater laxity than was ever contemplated. It is by no means the same thing for a Christian man, or a Christian church, to abandon a doctrine previ- ously held, as it is never to have known it ; the abandon- ment of it necessarily involving more than the mere ab- sence of it would have done. Hence, as has been often remarked, degenerate Calvinism, is not so spiritual and evangelical as reviving Arminian Methodism. We are apprehensive, therefore, that such a general form as may be devised, would come to be practically construed even more liberally than might be intended, and would fail to exclude parties, whose presence might damp all zeal and mar all concord.* * We have seen an attempt of this kind made by an American divine, evidently in the most excellent spirit, which, however, as we humbly think, only serves to shew the difficulty of the experi- ment, without holding out much apparent prospect of success. It is contained in a little work, with the title of Fraternal Appeal, by Dr Schmucker, Theological Professor in the Lutheran Church, published in 1839. The specimen of a united Protestant confession, in twelve articles, is given, each article being framed in words MUTUAL RELATIONS OF CHURCHES. liJ For such reasons as these, we prefer a mode of adjust- ment, which, leavino- the confessions of all the several churches untouched, would provide rather a negative than a positive criterion ; uniting all who protest against certain errors, and whose very protest shews their willing- ness to combine in advocating the opposite truths. And if it be objected that this mere denial is too cold a cement of union, and that something more positive is needed, let it be considered, in the first place, that the end proposed being not authoritative decision, but friendly consulta- tion, it is enough if we have the warrant of opposition to common foes for securing that we are really friends ; and, secondly^ that the range of antagonist eri'ors is such, as to afford sufficient security that the condemnation of them, as in a circle, all around, must proceed upon an admission of the enclosed and central truth. It is with extreme diffidence that we pi'esume to ex- press this opinion, which may seem to be at variance with that of a very high authority on this subject. We refer to the distinguished historian of the Reformation, who, in a recent address, thus eloquently pleads the cause of Christian brotherhood, and, not only so, but suggests practical measures for promoting it : — " The principle of union — of catholicity, was one of the essential features of Scripture and of the Reformed Church. Whatever others say, to this let us adhere. " Further, this unity of the Church in heaven must one selected out of the Reformed formularies, half a sentence often from one, and the other half from another, ingeniously put to- gether, and on the whole sound ; yet bald and meagre, if not am- biguous, presenting a sort of tessellated work, or artificial joining together of " disjecta membra" which would scarcely convey a fair impression of the real creed of any of the combined bodies. 24 INTRODUCTORY LECTURE. day be manifested on earth. ' There shall be one fold and one shepherd.' Precious promise ! Yes, all these barriers shall fall, all these party colours shall be effaced, and Christ alone be King of his people. But how shall that glorious time arrive ? Some would hasten it by cabinet orders duly sealed and registered in the bureaux of the civil administration. Others would bring it on by introducing- into the Reformed Church the hierarchical abuses and magical operations which she has rejected. Others, in fine, aim at it by latitudinarianism. Let us reject all these human expedients, and await this union from God and not from man. " Nevertheless we have also something to do. On the one hand, in waiting for the Lord, we must be truly what we are. Were a man to be created by the union of a soul and a body, would not the first thing necessary be, that the soul were truly a soul and the body truly a body ? Could we think it a good preparation for the union, to deform at once both the soul and the body ? But on the other hand, let us above all cleave to the grand doctrines which we hold in common. " You know the proposal which was made with that view at Saint Gall, in the General Assembly of Swiss Pastors.* It was made only some weeks ago, and yet * " The proceedings at St Gall were as follows : — " The general conference of the pastors of the Reformed Church of Switzerland took place at St Gall, on the 13th and 14th of August. One hundred and sixty professors and pastors assembled in the grand council-chamber of the ancient palace of Prince- Abbe. The first day was devoted to the important question of the Con- fessions of Faith, designated by the last conference; and Mr Scherer, a pastor of the canton of St Gall, began by reading a paper which he had been charged to draAv up. M. Merle D'Aubigne, the only representative of French Switzerland present at the conference. MUTUAL RELATIONS OF CHURCHES. 25 letters on the subject have ah-eady reached me from various quarters. In particular, I have received from developed and explained his motive in bringing forward the follow- ing resolutions (in Genevan), which he then laid on the table : — "The Swiss Pastoral Society, assembled at St Grail, one of the principal seats of apostolic or missionary labours in the west, ac- knowledges and resolves, — " ' First, That it is highly desirable for all evangelical Chris- tians, Reformed and Lutheran, Presbyterians and Episcopalians, and generally, all who believe in the fundamental truths of the gospel, to unite for the purpose of making an open confession of their common faith, in opposition to the unity, purely material, of the Romish Church, and thus proclaim their own true and spiritual unity. " ' Secondly, It resolves to put itself in communication with some of the pastoral conferences recently formed in Germany, particu- larly with that of Berlin, which has very lately occupied itself on the same question, and this may eventually lead to a similar union with the pastoral conferences of other coixntries, namely, France, Great Britain, Holland, and America, and to the re-establishment of an oecumenical Confession of the Christian faith. " ' Thirdly, It appoints a commission, authorised to fix the basis of an Evangelical Confession of the nineteenth century, and which shall contain the truths embodied in all existing Protestant Con- fessions, and arranged in a form adapted to the wants of the pre- sent age. This commission should likewise be authorised to take the necessary steps to obtain the end pointed out in the preceding articles.' " The author of this proposal, whilst making it, reminded his hearers, that at the period of the Refoi'mation, Calvin and his friends in Geneva opposed themselves energetically to the tendency the Swiss evinced of looking only to their local churches, and strove to direct their attention to the church at large. He further added, that one of the wants of the present times was, the unity of a true Catholicity, and that, however remote Ave were from this desirable end, it was now quite time to take the first steps towards it. " These resolutions having been seconded by Professor Kir- choffer of Schaffhouse, and approved of by Mr Schiess senior, one of the pastors of the canton of St Gall, and likewise by the licen- tiate in theology, Mr Scheuker, was carried by a considerable ma- jority, and sent, recommended, to the Committee of Conference." 26 INTRODUCTORY LECTURE. Scotland this interestino; communication : — ' Our Pro- vincial Synod having met on the very day when this good news arrived, unanimously resolved to overture the General Assembly to countenance the proposal of Saint Gall.' Surely we are moving towards a grand union. Let us then cast flir from us our disputes, our injuries, our nicknames, our false accusations, and our grievous personalities. Let us not give way to a passionate, blind, sour, and bitter spirit, which would kindle again among us the polemics of the sixteenth century. Let us rather with one heart exclaim, — ' Come quickly. Lord Jesus.' " — The Last Days, hy J. H. Merle B'Aubigne, D.J). Not in antagonism to this proposal, but in furtherance of it, we venture to call attention to the method indicated in our own church, in a plan submitted to the Commis- sion of Assembly, towards the end of the year 1842. On that occasion, a report was given in relative to the contemplated commemoration of the Westminster As- sembly ; embracing, however, a scheme for a more ex- tended union among the friends of evangelical truth throughout the world. In introducing the report, the Convener, among other things, remarked : — " A desire after more unity was rapidly extending in the Christian church. Communications on the subject, of a very de- lightful kind, had recently appeared from ministers and members of several evano-ehcal denominations, includinor a very admirable one from that eminent and godly Inde- pendent minister, Mr James of Birmingham. The unity desired was founded neither on popish uniformity, nor on latitudinarian compromise, but on an agreement on essential points. It had struck the committee that, on this occasion, somethinor mioht be done to follow out these breathings after unity at home and abroad ; and in pur- MUTUAL iti^i^ATIOXS OF CHURCHES. 27 suance of this view, the committee begged to lay on the table the following interim report." The report it- self went very generally into the subject, and was far from doing justice to it ; but as to the matter now on hand, we still think that some of its hints might be use- ful. In particular, we crave attention to the basis of union, and the kind of fellowship among the churches and evangelical societies in Christendom, which it indi- cated. We give below some extracts from it ;* sim- ply observing, for the present, that the outline might easily be filled up and rendered more precise and de- * " Besides the commemoration of this event (the Westmin- ster Assembly) by the several churches which hold the Westmin- ster standards, separately and by communion with one another, the committee are of opinion that advantage should be taken of this opportunity for attempting a joint or united meeting of Christians of different denominations, on a still larger scale, and in a wider and more catholic spirit. That in Presbyterian communities, as in Scotland, Ireland, and America, and among the Presbyterians in England, there should be solemn meetings, at which communi- cations by deputations, or otherwise, may mutually be interchanged, is highly desirable and important. But, in addition, there is every reason to believe, especially from recent movements, that a propo- sal for a more general convocation of evangelical churches would be hailed with great satisfaction, and would be productive of much good ; while it might be so arranged and conducted, on the princi- ple of a united testimony against prevailing heresies and corrup- tions, of various kinds, as to have an appropriate harmony with the Westminster Assembly itself, which, while it aimed at unity and uniformity, had for one of its leading objects the fencing of the true Protestant Church, on every side, against anti-Christian errors. " Following out this idea, it is suggested that a plan for the constitution of such a meeting might be framed, which would be suflBciently precise to exclude heresy and disorder, and yet suffi- ciently wide and catholic to admit of all who hold the Head, which is Christ, joining in the consultations, as well as in any measures which might be adopted for the advancement of the principles of the Reformation and the extension of the kingdom of Christ, Three points require, in this view, to be considered : — the parties 28 INTRODUCTORY LECTURE. finite ; the errors condemned might be more accurately specified ; and the whole might be so adjusted, as to who are to meet — the terms of the meeting — and the objects to be sought. " I. The parties who are to convene. " 1. These should, as far as possible, be individuals duly named and commissioned by the respective bodies in whose name they are to sit. " 2. The bodies so naming commissioners might be either the supreme assemblies of those churches which have such assemblies ; or, in the case of churches not having supreme assemblies, any asso- ciation, society, congregational union, or general conference, which is understood virtually to be the bond of union and the centre of action among any number of evangelical Christians. " 3. By correspondence among the churches, and by the appoint- ment of committees, this preliminary point, as to the bodies which are to send commissioners, and as to the number to be sent by each, might be arranged and settled. " II. The terms of meeting. " 1. Great difficulty might be felt in framing anything like a general creed or confession of faith, in which all the commission- ers should concur. There are obvious objections to the statement of essential truth in terms more wide and comprehensive than the several churches have adopted in their respective standards ; and there is manifest danger of schism or of latitudinarianism in such an attempt. " 2. But in entire accordance with the spirit of Protestantism, as well as with the exigency of the times, it is conceived that such a body of commissioners from various evangelical denominations, might harmoniously and effectively meet and concur in a statement of errors renounced and opposed, rather than of truths held. And the errors which would require to be specified are of such a nature, that the mere denial of them would be a sufficient guarantee for substantial soundness of faith. " 3. These errors are chiefly of three kinds ; and the terms might be stated in the form of a protest against Socinianism or Ra- tionalism, Popery, and what is called Tractarianism. The protest would thus embody a denial and renunciation, " (I.) Of socinian and rationalist principles, as these aifect — 1. The inspiration and interpretation of Holy Scripture ; 2. The doctrine of the Trinity ; 3. The person of Christ ; 4. The doctrine MUTUAL RELATIONS OF CHURCHES. 29 make it plain, that while all Evangelical Christians, — Presbyterian, Episcopalian, Independent, Baptist and Psedo- Baptist, Calvinist, Lutheran, Methodist, — might concur in the terms and test of unity, and meet for con- ference of the frankest kind, none else could honestly intrude themselves, to disturb the general harmony. On the whole, we cannot but think, that, at least for a commencement, this mode of procedure is safer and of the atonement ; 5. The personality and work of the Holy Ghost. " (2.) Of popish principles, as these affect— 1. The supreme and exclusive authority of Scripture ; 2. The doctrines of the mass, transubstantiation, purgatory, &c. ; 3. The power of the priest- hood, auricular confession, supremacy over civil rulers, &c, " (3.) Of tractarian or semi-popish principles, as these affect — 1. The doctrine of justification by works ; 2. The doctrine of regene- ration in baptism ; 3. The doctrine of the sacraments, ex opere operato ; 4. The apostolical succession and the catholicity of the Church, &c. " III, The objects to be sought by such a meeting. "1. The exchange of mutual and brotherly aflFection among vari- ous bodies of Protestants might be expected to strengthen and en- courage the several churches in the good work of the Lord. " 2. AVhile the meeting would, of course, be strictly precluded from all authoritative interference in the affairs of any of the bo- dies represented in it, and while controversial discussion on mat- ters on which' they differ must necessarily be avoided, a free inter- change of advice and consultation might be encouraged : and by prayer and the searching of the Word of God together, light might be expected to be cast on the principles of our common faith, and the duty and prospects of the church at large in the present criti- cal state of the world. "3. The various missionary operations of the several bodies or churches would furnish an interesting theme. " 4. The spectacle might be exhibited of Protestant unity, as distinguished from Popish uniformity and latitudinarian com- promise. " 5. Out of such a meeting, besides its being a pleasing oppor- tunity of brotherly fellowship in the Lord, more mature plans for future fellowship and co-operation might arise." 30 INTRODUCTORY LECTURE. more speedily practicable, as well as less apt to raise con- scientious scruples and difficulties, than that wliicli im- plies the framing, at the outset, of a general Protestant creed. Let this ulterior object by all means be kept in view, and let the consultations of the brethren have a reference to its ultimate accomplishment. But, mean- while, as it is far easier, and will take less time, to specify errors which we agree in condemning, than to compile any compendious, and yet correct, summary of our com- mon faith, — what should hinder arrano-ements being in- stantly made for holding a succession of yearly or half- yearly meetings, in London, Paris, Geneva, Berhn, and other places, to be attended by brethren of different lands and denominations, concurring in a protest against Popish and Socinian errors, and to be conducted on such general principles, and with such objects in view, as might tend to bring about, under God, at no distant date, some- thing like that harmony of faith, and unity of action, of which some hope seemed to be held out, at the first promulgation of the Gospel, and again, at the blessed awakening of the Reformation era ? But we must draw this lecture to a close, and in doing so, we would urge another practical duty, connected with the keeping up of a good understanding among the churches ; and that duty consists in a right observation of the signs of the times and the nature of the present crisis, and a disposition to extend sympathy and aid, wherever the enemy seems to be most pressing, and the line of defence most feeble and most apt to break. We might take a review, here, of the Continent of Europe, with those adjoining regions in Africa and Asia, which along with it, make up the platform of the apocalyptic earth, destined, it would seem, to be the scene of the MUTUAL RELATIONS OF CHURCHES. 31 last outbreak of the antichristian power, and of its signal and final fall. The revival of Popery, and in particular, of Popery's surest and subtlest agency, the secret, stanch and deadly order of the Jesuits, is the most wonderful event, — the greatest fact — of our day. Why, it seems but as yesterday, when Popish as well as Protestant governments united to put down that pernicious system ; and, suppressed by a stern Papal bull, the remnant of the scattered followers of Loyola scarcely found a precarious refuge in the retreats of Poland, and under the wing of the Russian Czar. The struggles in which the Galhcan church proved and abused her liberties, under the reign of Louis XV, seemed to manifest the effete and worn out im potency of the once formidable power of Home ; and when, but a few years after, the infidel hurricane swept away the whole clergy of France, and Napoleon stript the Pope of his tiara, and held him, a poor prisoner, at his mercy, — the tide of feeling turned, and sympathy was enlisted on the side of what was now the weaker and persecuted party ; till, pity being akin to love, the de- vout refugees driven from their altars, and the poor old man insulted at Avignon, became the objects of a compla- cency and admiration, which easily extended itself to the whole system that was identified with such illustrious sufferers. But the era of Rome's deepest humiliation was the beginning of her triumph ; and as if Satan here too mimicked the ordinance of God, he made her weak- ness to be her strength. A brief space saw Jesuitism revived ; unprecedented treasures cast into the coffers of the Vatican ; fresh zeal imparted to the propaganda ; old lethargic priests replaced by the sons of young Rome ; abuses checked ; discipline restored ; and everywhere signs and symptoms of new life and heat. All this went 32 INTRODUCTORY LECTURE. on quietly ; Protestants being unobservant and oflp their guard ; insomuch that Protestant statesmen were begin- ning to beheve that the once gigantic and implacable tyranny of Rome had become mild as a little child, — its roar as gentle as any sucking dove's, and its fair form one that might be fondled and caressed as a tame and petted lamb, — and even Christian divines were apt to give chari- table credit to the profession of a meek and tolerant spi- rit, which adversity seemed to have taught, and, against the more sagacious views of the older interpreters, were inclined to read the prophetic record as announcing not a Popish, but an infidel, Antichrist, to be chiefly dreaded at the laht. All the while, securely, silently, stealthily, that Church, with her Jesuit staff, was winding and working her serpent way, till, almost within these few last days, she ominously starts forth to view, with a footing already won in the very heart of infidel France, — a wily hand insinuated into the foreign relations and domestic policy of Britain, — a plot laid for convulsing Switzerland to its centre, — and from Eastern China to remote Western America, throughout the South Sea Isles, and along the Mediterranean coasts, a secret, but firm, grasp laid on all educational, political, and social influences, by which general opinion is to be moulded, and the mass of men to be ruled. And, now, backed as she is with enormous resources, courted by too many of the Potentates of Christendom, and skilfully adapting herself to the pro- gress, as well as to the exigencies, of this overwrought age, she seems about to wield an empire over the human mind, as effectual as she ever did in the darkest gloom of ignorance ; — an empire, too, which, as it is now allied to enlightenment and civihzation of the highest pitch, may be regarded as, on that very account, so much the MUTUAL RELATIONS OF CHURCHES. 33 more proud, and it might seem also, so much the more secure. But " when the enemy cometh in hke a flood, the Spirit of the Lord hfteth up a standard against him." Never, perhaps, was this text more signally fulfilled than now ; whether we regard the revival on the side of truth as chiefly preceding that on the side of error, or following in its wake, or partly both ; at all events, the simultane- ous infusion of spiritual life, from above and from be- neath, into the antagonist ranks, in this great contest, must be obvious to all competent observers. It is like the resuming of hostilities after a doubtful and precarious truce. The armies have been encamped in their trenches, upon a kind of tacit understanding that the war was suspended : their armour has been allowed to rust, and sloth has enfeebled the combatants : mutual civilities, also, have been interchanged, and it has become a point of honour to be chivalrously complaisant to a brave foe : private friendships have been formed ; and not only the fierceness of personal animosity, but even the sense of weighty public causes of difference, has given way to the influence of reciprocal familiarity and acquaintance- ship. But, suddenly, the trumpet sounds ; the armistice is at an end ; the crisis is come. Both armies awake as from a slumber ; new animation pervades their ranks ; the tents of idleness and dissipation are broken up ; and the lines of battle are promptly formed. Meanwhile, the effect of the respite is felt on bt)th sides ; some, in either host, have imbibed leanings towards the other, and are really in heart devoted to the interests they are called formally to oppose ; and not a few have begun to think that the quarrel might have been avoided from the be- ginning, and are asking if, at least, it may not be conipro- 34 INTRODUCTORY LECTURE. mised now ? But, alas ! it soon proves to be an irrecon- cilable feud ; and, with some wrong assortment of in- dividuals, which must be left over for extrication till the day of reckoning, the troops are found eager and alert to take up their respective stations ; and that, not as on parade or in review, but in earnest and warlike array. Thus as Popery has been reviving in spirit, and mus- tering her forces, so also Protestantism may now be seen, especially on the Continent of Europe, awaking as a giant refreshed, shaking herself from the dust, freeing herself Irom the " canker of a calm world and a long peace," and nerving, as well as purging, herself for the impending strife. French frivolity, German mysticism, English materialism, and Scottish ideahsm, — all these and other forms of infidelity are passing away, as unsuited to the gathering storm ; in which nothing of holiday and cour- tier make, or of idle academic subtlety, will live ; no- thing, in short, but what is strong and stern ; scriptural or antiscriptural ; whether it be desperate atheism, or bigoted and intolerant Popery, or warm and spiritual Christianity. Hence, the Protestant church, weary of i-ationalism, under every form, is becoming instinct with energy. Even on the principles of common policy, some- thing may be expected to come out of this awakening : and if we recognise in it, as every devout student of the Bible nmst, ihe immediate interposition of the Spirit of God, opposing Satan, the spirit of Antichrist, — what enthusiasm of courage may not this thought inspire into our ranks, and what bright hopes of victory, after a deadly and desperate struggle, may it not entwine, around the banner which our God has given us ? On many accounts, therefore; in the view, — 1. of the original plan and purpose of Christiav^ity ; 2. of the mar- MUTUAL RELATIONS OF CHURCHES. 35 ring of that plan through the antichristian perversion of it ; 3. of the ghmpse given at the E/eformation of a better state of things ; 4. of the present singularly fa- vourable aspect of affairs, when compared, in this respect, with the past ; as well as, 5. of their critical character, when scanned in reference to the future ;* — we urge the * The substance of the following note has been communicated by an intelligent student, who has just returned from the Conti- nent, and whose fresh impressions, the result of observation and conversation in different countries and among different classes of men, may be regarded as giving a vivid picture of what is going on, and of what is looked for, on both sides, in this gathering conflict. Popish Movements. 1. It is matter of general remark in Germany, that Popery has revived its energies during the last ten years. The Rationalist party even, who may be said to have their head-quarters in Leip- sic and Dresden, have been awakened thereby into a sense of the danger that threatens them, and are now quite zealous in defend- ing the Reformation, on high religious and theological grounds. The place where popery may be best studied in Germany is Co- logne. And here it has become quite notorious that the churches are much better attended, that the clergy are far more laborious, and that, as the expression of this newly-infused life, societies of all various kinds, charitable, educational, religious, among all classes of the citizens, are instituted; generally, it is believed, under the secret influence of the Jesviit party. Two circumstances may partially account for this revived energy, — 1. The imprisonment of the Archbishop by the late king, for not sanctioning mixed mar- riages — a " blunder," similar to that of Napoleon, in his treatment of the Pope, and occasioning a similar reaction in favour of the seemingly ill-used and oppressed ; — and 2. The steps taken to com- plete the Cathedral, which is countenanced by Protestants as well as Catholics, but which has been made the centre and nucleus of Catholic societies all over Germany. In the Rhine provinces, it is said, the popish feeling is such, as to indicate a leaning to France, in the event of any rupture, which might be attended with serious results. "Z. In Bavaria the present King has now openly given his coun- 36 INTBODUCTORY LECTURE. duty of correspondence and common effort among the tenance to the encouragement of Jesuitism, and great fears are en- tertained that much of the education of the country may fall into their hands. The book of Muhler, late professor in Munich, on the Protestant and Roman Catholic Theology, has been the oc- casion of great controversy, in which the leading theologians of Germany have taken part. (It has been translated into English.) Among a large section of the Roman Catholic Bavarian clergy, there exists a strong feeling of opposition to these attempts on the part of the King, but, so far as I know, no positive steps have as yet been taken. One circumstance which, though it has practi- cally tended much to keep alive Protestant feeling in Bavaria, in- dicates the power and spirit of Popery, is the law, that all Protes- tant soldiers be compelled to kneel on the streets at the passing of the Host. This law, notwithstanding every remonstrance, is still continued. The Queen of Bavaria is a very decided Protestant ; as is also the Crown-Princess. 2. In Switzerland the proceedings of the Jesuits have been more public and appreciable. All along they have had an immense educational establishment at Freihurg, with some hundred teach- ers, and attended by the sons of noble fiimilies from all parts of the Continent, as well as by great crowds of young men intending to enter their order. Of late years this establishment has been re-in- forced, and has secretly been exerting its influence among all the Cantons. In several of them this question respecting the Jesuits, is the great element of political difference. In Liiccrn, by a deci- sion of the Council, afterwards ratified by the Canton, the whole education of the Canton seems about to be committed to them ; seven additional Jesuit masters being already introduced into that Canton. In other Cantons the question has been mooted"; and at present, the one great question in Switzerland is — the duty of the Confederacy in connection with these movements. 4. In Italy, the order has had new privileges conferred on it by the present Pope. Jesuitical institutions and seminaries are ris- ing up on all hands. No class of priests is held in greater honour? and great care is taken, that all those who are admitted be men of approved ability and zeal. The order is immensely rich, and is daily obtaining new grants of lands or money, or the like. On the great feast-days, it very frequently is the case that members of this order alone preach in the chief churches. They are the most po- MUTUAL RELATIONS OF CHURCHES. 3t churches; pressing for an immediate discharge of the duty, pular and favourite confessors also, and are most resorted to by the devout. Thus these two great engines, Preaching, on high days, and the Confessional, are chiefly wielded by them. In Rome their churches are the most frequented of all. The general theological and even literary education in the University and Colleges, has almost entirely fallen into their hands. It is the universal opinion of Protestants in Rome, that thei/ are the means employed to carry out the different schemes of the Church. Protestant Movements. 1. During the last ten or fifteen years, great advances have been making towards orthodoxy among the theologians. A better prac- tical spirit in the Church may be dated from the discussions called forth by the Reformation Jubilee, (the third centenary). 2. This is especially remarkable in the Missionarii Spirit, whicli is daily becoming more prominent. The society of Basle has now branches in the various large towns. Many professors give separate courses on the history of missions. Great activity is also shewn in connection with the Bible Society, circulation of tracts in Catho- lic countries, and the like. 3. For some time back the great body of the evangelical clergy have, by means of PASTORAL CONFERENCES, been striving to create and direct a spirit of Christian organized activity and prac- tical efficiency in the Church. Great steps have been taken in connection with the improvement of their ecclesiastical constitu- tion — with the duty of union among all bodies of true Christians — with the establishment and final settlement of a purer creed, by stricter adherence to their symbolical books. Meetings in churches for prayer, and in connection with missions, are frequent. The churches of the Rationalists are comparatively deserted, and espe- cially in Berlin, Westphalia, Wittemberg, &c. there is a vast accession to the body of faithful preachers. A great spirit of in- quiry is abroad as to the state of foreign Evangelical churches, and a general desire is expressed for closer Christian fellowship with them. The greatest result and proof of this tendency to organi- sation and activity in the church, is in the case of the Gustavus- Adolphus Society for the assistance of poop congregations in Catho- lic countries, especially Bavaria and Austria. It too has its branches all over Protestant Germany. The King of Prussia is patron. 4. Rongl's Movement. — His letters have been translated into 38 INTRODUCTORY LECTUHE. seeing that the time is short ; and as to the mode and manner of discharging it, saying, in all sincerity, " si quid novisti rectius istis Candidus imperii ; si non, his utere mecum." several languages, and are read with equal avidity by Protestants and Catholics alike. Independent congregations have now been formed in Breslau, Dresden, Leipsic, Berlin, Magdeburg, &c. The Bishop of Mayence has published a pastoral letter, strongly op- posed to what has taken place ; and, it is stated, that Ronge has been already denounced in Rome. Some suspense of judgment, in regard to this work, may be necessary, until we know how far it is deeply evangelical, or is simply an honest recoil from the fla- gi'ant impostures of Rome, and the holy coat of Treves. Mean- while, the critical position of the man entitles him to our prayers ; and we cannot but admire his lion-like and Luther-like port, his fearless defiance of wrong, and that trumpet sound which has star- tled Popish Germany to its centre. I iind that I have omitted to state ; that in Hungary much greater religious freedom exists than at any former period ; and that the position of Austria seems a medium one between two extremes. In Hanover, great excitement has been created by one of the bishops reviving an old Jesuit catechism. In regard to France, we may refer, for an exposition of the pro- gress of Popery and Jesuitism, to a remarkable article, in the pre- sent number of the North British Review, written, evidently, by no religious alarmist, but by a calm observer ; while, as to the re- viving influence of Evangelical Protestantism, every day brings us new testimonies from godly ministers, and missionary societies, that the fields are white unto the harvest. LECTURE 11. 'HE INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. BY JOHN WILSON, D.D., F.R.S. OF THE FREE CHDBCH OF SCOTLAND'S MISSION AT BOMBAY. LECTURE II. THE INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. Associations connected with the History and Prospects OF the East— Prevailing Ignorance of the State of Christianity in the East— The Greek Church— The Armenian Church— The Syrian Church— The Nestor- lAN Church— The Coptic Church— The Abyssinian Church — The General Claims of the Eastern Churches — How Help may be immediately extended to them by Scotland. The East is associated with all that is interesting in the past history, and glorious in the future prospects, of the world. It was in a twofold sense the cradle of the human race, for there our first parents were created, and their descendants lived in the times which preceded the flood ; and there the ark rested^ and the preserved family of man again grew and multiplied, and spread abroad over the face of the earth. It was there, that, in utter forgetfulness of God's judgments and impious neglect of God's revelations, those forms of idolatry, su- perstition, and delusion, were generated and matured, which have changed the glory of God into a lie, and which have injured, and are now injuring, unnumbered millions of immortal souls to their eternal destruction. It was there, that, amid the general apostasy of our race, the D 42 INDEPEIS^DENT EASTERN CHURCHES. people sprung from faithful Abraham sojourned, as the chosen recipients of the divine favour, and the deposita- ries of divine truth, to whom pertained the adoption, and the glory and the covenants, and the giving of the law, and the service of God, and the promises ; and with whom, insignificant though they might be in the eyes of the world, were connected the destinies of the mightiest nations of antiquity in their most important relations. There, the Son of God from heaven was made flesh, and revealed as the only- begotten of the Father full of grace and truth, and taught, and suffered, and died, to accom- plish the redemption of his people. There, he appeared after his resurrection ; and gave the commandment that repentance and remission of sins should be preached in his name among all nations, beginning at Jerusalem. The East witnessed the first and most conspicuous triumphs of Christianity, when its divine Author, seated on the horse of spotless purity, with warlike bow, and imperial crown, went forth conquering and to conquer.* The light of the Gospel, under the neglect of those who were highly favoured by its cheering rays, first began to wax dim on its golden candlesticks, which, in the righteous judgment of God, were removed from many of its dis- tricts. Within its borders, the " mystery of iniquity" first began to work ; and it has participated largely in the great apostasy. It forms the half of that great E-oman empire, in which Antichrist, the wicked one, has been revealed. It was among its fair, and beautiful, and fertile regions, that the hosts of Islam, the locust armies from the smoke of the bottomless pit, under its ano-el Apollyon, with their scorpion tails, and lion teeth, * Rev. vi. 2. INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. 43 and dreadful panoply, received their power to hurt men five months,* or one hundred and fifty years, — a com- mission which they actually executed from the year that Muhammad commenced his imposture till the Khalifs, consolidating their power at Baghdad, ceased to extend their conquests. It was over the same localities, that, in later times, the four angels which were bound in the great river Euphrates — the four Turkman Sultanats — were loosed and prepared for an hour, and a day, and a month, and a year — about three hundred and ninety-one years, — to slay the third part of men, and out of whose mouths issued fire, and smoke, and brimstone, for the accomplishment of this destruction, f which they effected from the time that they began to assail Christendom, till the day when they were compelled to restrain their movements in the east of Europe. Over its regions of Assyria, and Egypt, and Pathros, and Cush, and Elara, and Shinar.t are scattered in laro;e numbers the Jews, who shall yet " remember" the Lord " in far countries," and " live with their children and turn again," before they are brought into the land of Gilead and Lebanon. |1 It contains Jerusalem, " the city of the great King," trodden down of the Gentiles till the times of the Gen- tiles shall be fulfilled. Though the rest of the men, or professed Christians, which have not been killed by the plagues with which it has already been visited, have not yet repented of the works of their hands, and though it may experience the raging of those storms in heaven above, and those convulsions in the earth below, which are to issue in the calm and quiet of the millennial day, it will participate even in greater and richer grace than * Rev. ix. 1-11. t Rev. ix. 13-20. i Isaiah xi. 12. !| Zech. x. 9-10. 44 INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. it has yet experienced. That Lord who of old, for the destruction of Samaria and Jerusalem, so revealed his presence, and displayed his power and his glory, that the prophetical announcement was fulfilled, " Behold the Lord cometh out of his place, and will come down, and tread upon the high places of the earth ; and the mountains shall be molten under him, and the valleys shall be cleft before the fire, and as the waters that are poured down a steep place,"* shall, in the latter days, for the salvation of Israel and of Judah, go forth in his majesty and might, and fight against the nations that oppose them, as when he fought in the day of battle, with his presence and power again so manifested, that his " feet shall stand in that day upon the Mount of Olives, which is before Jerusalem on the east, and the Mount of Ohves shall cleave in the midst thereof toward the east, and toward the west."f Though upon the heights of Israel, the confederate armies of the Lord's adversaries shall "ascend and come like a storm," the fury of the Lord God shall come up in his face, and he will magnify and sanctify himself, and will be known in the eyes of many nations, and will make his holy name known in the midst of his people Israel, and will not let them pollute his holy name any more, neither will he hide his face from them any more, for he will pour out his Spirit upon the house of Israel.J The Lord will remember his land, and have mercy upon his people ; and they shall divide it among them, accommodating all their tribes, and share it as an inheritance with the strangers sojourning with them. || The blessing resting upon them shall be extended to the neighbouring nations ; and " Israel shall * Micah i. 3-4. t Zech. xiv. 4. X Ezek. xxvii. xxviii. y Ezek. xlvii. 21, 22. INDEPEJ^DENT EASTERN CHURCHES. 45 be the third with Egypt and Assyria, even a blessing in the midst of the land.""*^ Though the Mosaic economy and law shall not be restored, — for " in those days, saith the Lord, they shall say no more. The ark of the cove- nant of the Lord ; neither shall it come to mind, neither shall they remember it, neither shall they visit it, neither shall that be done any more, — at that time they shall call Jerusalem the throne of the Lord ; and all the na- tions shall be gathered unto it, to the name of the Lord to Jerusalem." t God's providential care of his land and his ancient people will be gratefully acknowledged ; and in the salvation wrought in their behalf, the converted Gentile nations, to whom the conversion of the Jews will be as life from the dead, will greatly rejoice. Their kings shall be the nursing fathers, and their queens the nursing mothers, of Zion. And while spiritual privi- leges are dispensed alike throughout the world, — for, " from the rising of the sun even unto the going down of the same, God's name shall be great among the Gen- tiles, and in every place incense shall be offered unto his name and a pure offering," J — the birthplace of Chris- tianity will be its great metropolis, the central spot, or focus, where the rays of light from all God's providen- tial dispensations toward the nations of the earth, and especially the seed of Abraham his friend, will converge together, to the most effulgent display of his sovereignty, and truth, and faithfulness, and grace. It will scarcely be contended, that the regard which we the people of the Lord, in these western parts of the world, and especially in the highly-favoured land of Scotland, have paid to these regions of the East, has * Isaiah xix. 21. f Jer. iii. 16-17. + Mai. i. 11. 46 INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. comported with these their high claims to our attention. With those within their herders who have borne the Christian name, we have scarcely formed the least ac- quaintance. We have been contented to remain igno- rant of their principles and practice ; of their doctrines, and rites and ceremonies ; of their temptations, and trials, and contendings ; of their errors, and corruptions and retrogressions. We have extended to them neither our sympathy, nor our prayers, nor our exertions. We have neither marked their alienation from the truth, nor recalled their attention to its solemn testimony. We have conveyed to them neither instruction, nor warning, nor entreaty, nor expostulation. We have mourned more over the desolations of the natural, than over those of the spiritual, Zion. Our past neglect has been com- plete, and, I will add, criminal ; and our consciousness and confession of it should strongly urge us to present consideration and immediate amendment. I trust that it is in some degree an acknowledgment of this duty which has brought us together on this occasion ; and I pray that God may vouchsafe to us his blessing, while we refer to the circumstances of the oriental churches. The survey which we can take of them from this place, must be very limited ; but if it in any degree arouse attention, or satisfy inquiry, or lead to further investiga- tion, it will not be without its use. I devote the pre- sent lecture to the Independent Eastern Churches — the Greek, Armenian, Syrian, Nestorian, Coptic, and Abyssinian. On another occasion, — should it occur in providence before I leave this country, — I shall advert to the Papal Eastern Chiuxhes — the Maronite, Greek- Catholic, Armenian- Catholic, Syrian- Catholic or Chal- dean, Coptic- CathoHc, and Indian-Catholic Churches. INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. 47 I. THE GREEK CHURCH. This Church is to be associated, not so much with the nation of Greece properly so called, as with the language of Greece, — so extensively diffused in Asia, and even in part of Africa, by the conquests of Alexander the Great, that it was the most widely-spoken in the days of our Lord, and selected by the Spirit as the most suitable for the inspired writings of the new covenant, — and, especially, with those countries which were comprehended in the Byzantine dominions, or Eastern Roman Empire. It denominates itself t] 7iadoXr/crj xal a'lroGro'ktTiYi sxxXscita Tj dmroXizri, the Catholic and Apostolic Oriental Church. In Turkey in Asia it has four ancient Pa- triarchates, those of Constantinople, Antioch, Jerusalem, and Alexandria. In the north of Syria, and particu- larly about Aleppo and Antioch, it includes a majority of those who bear the Christian name. In the Pashalik of Damascus it claims, of 78,262 — the total Christian population — 42,160 souls. In the district of Lebanon, its followers are outnumbered by the Maronites ; but to the south it again asserts its predominance. It forms the largest Christian sect in the whole of Syria and the Holy Land, numbering there a population of 345,000 souls, while the other Christian bodies embrace only about 260,000 souls. In Egypt it has two or three thousand members. It is in possession of all the con- vents in Arabia Petrfea, including that of Mount Sinai. In all the districts of Asia Minor, except in that part of it which is sometimes known by the name of the Lesser Armenia, it has more followers than any other church. It is the established relioion of the kingdom of 48 INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. Greece, where its affairs are managed by an independent Synod ; and it is predominant there, as well as among that portion of the population of the Greek islands which acknowledges the faith of Jesus. At Constantinople, it has as many followers as those of the Armenian and Roman Churches united together. It is almost the ex- clusive Christian Church in the different provinces of Turkey in Europe, such as Romania, Macedonia, Al- bania, Bulgaria, Servia, and Bosnia. North of the Danube, it occupies Wallachia and Moldavia. In Hun- gary even, it has a population of 2,283,505 souls. It is the established religion of Russia, which, like Greece, has an independent Synod for the ordering of its own affairs ; and, except in the provinces lately conquered from Tar- tary and Persia, and in part of Poland, it extends its discipline and instruction to the whole population of that great empire, to the exclusion of a very small portion of it almost secretly practising dissent. A few villages in Mesopotamia, speaking the Syriac language, also belong to the Greek communion. With the relations in which the ancient Eastern Church, of which the Greek Church professes to be the genuine representative, stood to the Western, or Latin, Church, ecclesiastical history makes us acquainted. The first great dispute which occurred between them, ori- ginated in the second century, about the observance of a sacred season consecrated by human authority, that of Easter. Those v/hich followed had principally a re- ference to the comparative dignity of the Bishops of the old Rome and the new Rome, or Byzantium, to which Constantino removed the seat of Empire. In the second general council, the Bishop of Constantinople was al- lowed to sit next to the alleged successor of St Peter ; THE GREEK CHURCH. 49 and by the twenty-eighth canon of the Synod of Chalcedon, he was permitted to enjoy an equal rank. These concessions were sufficiently humiliating to the aspiring Pope ; but the Emperors of the East, jealous for the honours of their own capital, prevented their with- drawment. The flame of resentment, which appeared stifled for a time, broke out with increased fury in the eighth century. The Emperor Flavins Leo, the Isaurian, convinced by the arguments of Besor the Syrian, that the use of images in the Christian churches was unlawful and idolatrous, violently opposed the views of the Roman Pontiff on the subject, as did his two immediate suc- cessors. Gregory the Second retaliated by the persecu- tion of those who remonstrated against image worship, — ' the Iconoclasts as they were called, — by stirring up po- litical rebellion in Italy and the neighbouring territories, and l)y seeking to appropriate important portions of them to himself. The Emperor, in punishment of his arro- gance, removed Calabria, Sicily, Illyricum, and Greece, from his spiritual jurisdiction, and placed them under that of the Bishop of Constantinople. The disturbances which thus originated continued to rage for years both in the state and in the church ; and though the Emperor Flavins Leo Constantinus VI.* and his mother Irene restored the use of images, the division between the eastern and western churches, almost insensibly begun, became distinct and confirmed. Photius, and Michael Cerularius, accused the Romish See of various irregula- rities ; and the attempts made by Michael Paleologus, in the thirteenth century, to promote a reunion, even though seconded by the council of Florence, were in vain. * Born in 771, and died in 797. E 50 INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. The Eastern and Western Churches have remained divided. Rome aims at satisfying her ambition by the subversion, or conversion, of the Eastern Church, which she denounces as schismatic, and not by union and incor- poration. Of the actual tenets of the Greek Church, we have now a favourable opportunity of forming a correct opinion, by consulting its own Symbolic Books, which for the first time were collated and pubhshed in the original Greek, and with a Latin translation, about two years ago * They con- sist of several documents. The first of them is the confes- sion of Gennadius, both in the form of a dialogue and a distinct creed, presented by request to the Sultan Mu- hammad in the fifteenth century, by Gennadius the pa- triarch of Constantinople. Between this and the second document, is interposed the condemned evangelical con- fession of Cyrillus Lucaris, a native of Crete, educated at Venice, who ultimately became patriarch of Constanti- nople, which he published in 1629, and for which, and his embracement and support of the general views of the churches of the Beformation, through a conspiracy of the Pope's emissaries, the clergy of the Greek church, and the Turkish authorities, he was cruelly murdered, by drowning or strangulation, on the 26th of June 1638. The second document is the catechetical " Confession of the Orthodox Faith of the CathoHc and Apostolic Church of Christ, composed by Peter Mogilas, metropolitan of Kioff," and bearing the confirmation and authority, dated 11th March 1643, of the four oriental patriarchs, and the other ecclesiastical dignitaries and office-bearers of the Greek church. The third contains " The Shield of * Libri Symbolici EcclesijE Orientalis, nunc priraum in unuin corpus collegit, Emestus Julius Kiramel. Jense, 1843. THE GREEK CHURCH. 51 Orthodoxy, composed by the local Synod met at Jerusa- lem under the patriarch Dositheus, composed against the heretical Calvinists," &c. This document, which ob- tained the subscription of three of the patriarchs, twenty- one bishops, and twenty-three other ecclesiastics, includ- ing the Russian legates, after reviewing and condemning tlie writings of Cyrillus, and anathematizing him on their account, sets forth the eighteen special decrees of the Synod, dated March 1672, with the resolution of certain questions to which some of them incidentally gave rise. A perusal of all these authorities warrants the assertion, that the errors of the Greek Church are nearly as great and detrimental as those of the Church of Kome, and compel us, making all charitable allowance for those within its pale who practically disavow them, to view it as within the dominions of Antichrist. Of this you will be all sorrowfully convinced by an analysis of the pro- ceedings of the Synod now mentioned. Its first decree embraces the articles of the Nicene Creed, with this difference, on which the Greek Church and all the Oriental Churches lay great stress, — that the Holy Spirit, while consubstantial with the Father and the Son, proceeds only from the Father. In the second, we find it asserted that sacred scripture is to be received "according to the tradition and interpretation of the CathoHc Church," which is declared to have " an authority not less than that of sacred scripture," being guided by the unerring wisdom of the Holy Ghost. The third ascribes the election of men to the divine foresight of their good works, and represents the supporters of a * For an able refutation of the views of the Greek Church, see the Acta et Scripta Theologorum Wirtembergensium, referred to in a subsequent note. 52 INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. sovereign election, as blasphemously disparaging good works, and not even viewing them as the consequence of election, or a necessary part of salvation. The fourth, as if insinuatino; that Calvinists charo;e God with heinor the active origin of sin, properly ascribes it to men and devils acting in disobedience to the divine will. The fifth maintains the holiness and justice of God in all his dispensations, which though overruling evil for good, never extend to it moral approbation. The sixth no- tices the fall, and the depravity which originated with it, declaring, however, that *' many of the patriarchs and prophets, and innumerable others, both under the shadow [of the law] and the verity [of grace], as the divine fore- runner, and especially the eternal Virgin Mary, the Mother of the divine Word," were not naturally tempted to impiety, blasphemy, and other sins specified. The seventh sets forth the conception and birth of Christ with- out injury to the virginity of Mary, and his ascension and future judgment of the quick and dead. The eighth, while it admits that " Jesus Christ is the only Mediator and ransom of all," expressly declares that, " for present- ing our requests and petitions to him, we reckon the saints to be intercessors, and above all the immaculate Mother of the divine Word, and likewise the holy angels, whom we know to be our guardians, and the apostles, pro- phets, martyrs, and whomsoever of his faithful servants he hath glorified, amongst whom we number the bishops and priests, as if surrounding God's altar, and the other just men remarkable for their virtues." The ninth sets forth that no one is saved without faith, but that faith justifies, because " it works by love, that is by the obser- vance of the divine commandments." The tenth, while professedly acknowledging Christ to be the Head of the THE GREEK CHURCH. 53 church, declares that he governs it by " the ministry of the holy fathers," and condemns the tenet of the Cal- vinists, that priests can be ordained by priests, holding that a bishop superior to a priest, " the successor of the apostles, communicates, by the imposition of hands and the invocation of the Spirit, the power which he has re- ceived, by uninterrupted succession, of binding and loos- ing, and is the living image of God upon earth, and by the fullest participation of the energy of the perfect Spirit, the fountain of all the sacraments of the church, by which we arrive at salvation." The eleventh sets forth that the catholic church is instructed by the Holy Spirit, ** not directly," but '' by the holy fathers and overseers of the catholic church." The twelfth reckons those only to be members of the catholic church who receive the faith of Christ both as declared by himself and the apostles and by " the holy oecumenical synods,"* and de- port themselves in a becoming manner. The thirteenth intimates, that " that faith, which, as a hand, lays hold of the righteousness of Christ," is not that by which man is justified, but that which, by the good works to which it leads, becomes itself efficacious for our salvation, f The * The seven first general Councils. t A very lucid view of the evangelical doctrine of justification by faith, had been given to Jeremiah the patriarch of Constantino- ple by the "NYirtemberg divines in the year 1577, in the course of the correspondence which they maintained with him on the sub- ject of the Augsburg confession. '• When we say," say they, " that we are justified before God only by faith in Christ, we wish thus to express ourselves, that by faith only we so apprehend Christ our Saviour, that on account of liis most perfect merit, we obtain the remission of our sins and eternal life, and that we reckon faith in Christ the hand by which we receive those things ivhich Christ our Redeemer has imrchased for us.'" They then show clearly how good works are the fruit of faith and part of salvation. — Acta et 54 INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. fourteenth maintains the undepraved freedom of the will, and the natural ability of man to choose good or evil. The fifteenth enumerates and describes the seven sacra- ments of the church, namely, Baptism, Confirmation or Chrism, Ordination, the bloodless Sacrifice of the real body and blood of Christ, Matrimony, Confession Peni- tence and Remission, and Extreme Unction, intimating that they are not naked signs of the promises, but ne- cessarily convey grace to those who partake of them. The sixteenth declares that baptism is absolutely necessary to salvation, even in the case of infants ; that it destroys original sin ; and is infallibly accompanied by regenera- tion, and even ultimate salvation.* The seventeenth maintains that in the Eucharist, to be administered only by a duly consecrated priest, the bread and wine, though their accidents remain, are transubstantiated into the real body and blood of Christ, and are to be worshipped and adored with supreme honour, and viewed as a pro- pitiation and sacrifice both for the living and the dead. The eighteenth maintains that the souls of the departed are either in a state of rest or suff'ering ; that those (be- longing to the church) who have been removed from the Scripta Theologorum "Wirtembergensium, et Patriarcha; Constan- tinopolitani D. Hieremia;. Witebergaj, 1684, p. 165. This is a work which should be in the possession of all missionaries having to do with the Greek Church. It sets forth its tenets, as propounded by the church authorities at Constantinople, and refutes its errors in a very calm and dignified, but earnest, manner, the whole dis- cussion being in Greek, with a Latin translation, by the celebrated Crusius. Many parts of it might be advantageously reprinted, and circulated in the form of tracts. * These and similar views of baptism, too, are expressed in the form of the administration of the rite used in the Greek Church. Vide Codic. Liturg, Eccles. Univers. Josephi Aloysii Asseman i lib. ii. Romse, 1749. THE GREEK CHURCH. 55 world with their penitence incomplete, or with a lack of its fruits, or the prayers, watchings, and charities deno- minated " satisfactions" by the church, are in a state of exclusion from perfect bliss, from which, however, they may be relieved by the prayers and alms of the priests presented in behalf of their relatives, and by the perform- ance of masses. Here almost all the fatal errors as- sociated with Antichiist are most distinctly propounded and defended. The questions appended to the decrees, in a similar manner certify the apostasy of the Greek Church. That in which it is asked, should Holy Scripture be commonly or indiscriminately read by all Christians, is answered in the negative. In reply to another, the perspicuity of the scriptures is disparaged. In the response given to that which refers to the Canon of Scripture, it is stated, that not only the books which were received by the council of Laodicea, are to be acknowledged as inspired, but also the Wisdom of Solomon, the Book of Judith, of Tobit, the History of the Dragon, the History of Susanna, the Maccabees, and the Wisdom of Sirach. When the honours to be given to saints and their images are made the subjects of inquiry, it is declared that the Virgin Mary is to be worshipped by hyperdulia ; and the saints and angels by direct didia, referring both to their relation to God and their own sanctity ; and the pictures, and relics of the saints, and holy places and articles, such as crosses, and sacramental vases, by indirect dulia ; while latria is to be exclusively reserved for the Divine Spirit. This doctrine is set forth by the invention of distinctions not re- cognised in the Holy Scriptures, and not to be seen in the nature of things ; and it is reduced to practice in direct violation of the express commandments of God, 56 indepi;ndent eastern churches. and by extending the presence, knowledge, power, and offices, and sacredness of God's creatures far beyond their endowments. The other symboHcal books of the Greek church are quite in accordance with that which we have now briefly analysed. The catechetical confession of Mogilas, which contains the fullest exposition of its doctrines, sets forth, along with a mixture of truth, most of the fatal errors to which w^e have alluded, even more in detail than the decrees of the Synod of Jerusalem. We may extract from it some additional information respecting tenets and observances. It places the traditions of the church on a level with the written word of God, and requires it to be interpreted through the medium of these traditions. It speaks of angels, not merely as spirits ministering accord- ing to the direct will of God, but as the guardians of cities, kingdoms, countries, monasteries, and churches, and as both presenting our prayers to God, and interced- ing in our behalf.* It speaks of the Virgin Mary as the " mother of God.""]" It represents the devil as put to flight, and the perniciousness of poison as averted by the sign of the cross ; and enjoins us to make this sign when we eat and drink, when we sit down or stand up, when we speak or walk, and on all occasions by night and by day, and gives minute directions as to the way in which it is to be made.^ When alluding to the ascension of Christ, it sets forth that his humanity is present in the Eucharist, and to be venerated and adored as the Saviour himself. § While it denies that the dead can be delivered from their deprivations, by purgatorial fires or punishments after death, it represents them as receiving * Quest. 19. t Quest. 40, 43. X Quest. 50, 51, i Quest 5.6. THE GREEK CHURCH. 57 in the less glorious mansions of the heavenly regions, — for the Greek Church recognises noplace intermediate between heaven and hell, — the benefits which they need, from the prayers and masses of the church* It repre- sents the presidents of the church, as vicariously its heads for Christ, and requires subjection to them as such as- sembled in general council.! It enumerates nine pre- cepts of the church, which are to be observed. The first enjoins attendance on matins, liturgies (the sa- crament of the mass so denominated), vespers, on the Lord's Day, and the appointed festivals. The second appoints four annual fasts, two of forty days each, preced- ing Christmas and Easter, one from the week after Pente- cost to the festivals of Peter and Paul, and another from the first to the fifteenth of August, the day of the As- sumption of the Virgin, and two weekly fasts on Wednes- days and Fridays ; and forbids fasting on the Lord's Day, except on the "great sabbath," during which he remained in the sepulchre, and some other special days. The third precept enjoins respect to ecclesiastical per- sonages, who receive our confessions and minister to us in holy things. The fourth recommends a quarterly, and in the case of the more devout, a monthly confession, and enjoins at least an annual confession, of sins to the priests, urging the sick especially to wash away their stains by confession and a participation of the sacred supper. The fifth interdicts the reading heretical books and association with the ungodly. The sixth enjoins prayer for ecclesiastical, civil, and military authorities, for the living and dead members of the church, and for the conversion of heretics and schismatics. The eighth * Quest. 65, 66, 67, 68, f Quest. 85, 86. 58 INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. forbids sacrilege. And the ninth forbids the celebration of marriage in forbidden vestments, and attendance on forbidden amusements * The confession expounds at length the doctrine of the " seven sacraments." It de- clares that they are nol only signs and seals of the doc- trine of Christ, but present remedies for overcoming the infirmities of sin. Baptism, which destroys original sin, and effects regeneration, is to be practised by a threefold immersion in water, and always by priests, except in cases of urgent necessity. Chrism or confirmation — by oil, balsam, and other unguents, consecrated by the highest ecclesiastic, and symbolic and communicative of the unc- tion and gifts of the Holy Spirit, — 'to be applied to the different members of the body, is immediately to follow baptism. The sacrament of the Eucharist is said to be more excellent than any other of the sacraments, nay than all of them united together, and to conduce more tlian they do to the attainment of salvation. A duly con- secrated priest is necessary to its dispensation. The bread used must be fermented, and a little water must be added to the wine, to represent that which flowed from the Saviour's side. These materials must be viewed as changed into the real body and blood of Christ by the words of consecration; and the sacrament must be con- sidered a commemoration, a propitiation, and a protection and defence against the assaults of the devil. In ordina- tion, by which the succession of power to the priestly office in the church is continued, regard must be had to the probity, and knowledge of candidates, and the soundness and completeness of the members of their body. The minor orders of reader, singer, candle-lighter, and sub- * Quest. 87-95. THE GREEK CHURCH. §9 deacon are recognised, and reference is made to the Directories, in which their duties, and those of other ecclesiastical office-bearers, are described."^ The neces- sity and efficacy of auricular confession and clerical absolution are emphatically declared ; and meritorious prayers, alms, fastings, pilgrimages to holy places, and religious genuflexions, are sometimes to be added to them, that they may restore the effects of baptism and afford grounds for confidence and peace. Marriage, except as being denominated a sacrament, is rightly treated of in the confession. The Euchelaion, corresponding with extreme unction, is to be given to the sick as well as to the dying, is sometimes attended with the healing of the body as well as the soul, and fails not to be accom- panied with the remission of sins in the case of those who are penitent. All these explanations and statements are given in the confession under the head of Faith. Under that of Hope, there is given a tolerably good, though not an entirely approveable, exposition of the Lord's Prayer and of the beatitudes contained in the sermon on the Mount. Under that of Charity, the last of the treatise, in which our duty both to God and man is con- sidered, both truth and error are sadly intermingled. Almsgiving is there set forth as an expiation, and the antiscriptural distinction of mortal and venial sins is re- cognised. Under the first commandment, the worship of saints and angels is vindicated by the identical arguments * In tte works in which the ministry is more particularly- treated of, it is stated, that the secular clergy are allowed to marry once ; but that those who do so are debarred from the episcopacy, an oflBce which is reserved for individuals of the regular or monastic clergy, who, on account of their vows and self-restraints, are sup- posed to be holier than those who have retained and used their Christian liberty. 60 IXDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. current in the Church of Home. Under the second commandment, which is separated from the first as by Protestants and the Jews, the worship of images (pic- tures of the saints only are used in the Greek Church) and of holy objects is vindicated in a similar manner, and particularly by the authority of the seventh general • council. In connexion with the fourth commandment, the sacred days appointed by the church are brought to notice. It will be seen from these brief, but distinct references, that the Greek Church has departed far indeed from the simplicity and truth which are in Christ Jesus. It agrees with the Church of Rome in most matters of the greatest moment. It has the essential characteristic of Antichrist, inasmuch as it places the priests on earth, and the saints and angels in heaven, intermediate be- tween the soul and the Saviour, and allows the merits of the Son of God to be dispensed by the minister, and purchased by the prayers, and penances, and services of the worshipper. Though it administers the initiatory rite of Christianity, without many of the impious and absurd concomitant ceremonies which have been added to it by • the Romish Church, it forms the same judgment of its spiritual efficacy. Though it administers the Eucharist in both kinds to the laity, it holds forth the doctrine of absolute transubstantiation, and renewed propitiation. Within its pale it cherishes, in its worship of saints, angels, and their representations, and sacred things, that very implied polytheism and idolatry for which Romanism is so very abhorrent to the Christian mind. Though it disclaims works of supererogation, and does not profess to dispense indulgences, it makes the services of the living available for the dead. Its superiority to Rome in any THE GREEK CHURCH. 61 respect principally arises from its inability or unwilling- ness to follow out its principles to their legitimate length. Practically, however, it is not so consolidated and fear- ful in its power as that tyrannical institution. It does not pretend to have an infallible earthly head. Though it makes the general councils the interpreters of Christian doctrine, and disparages the Scriptures, both by adding to their contents and questioning their intelligibility, it does not always systematically oppose their circulation and perusal. Its symbolical books, though they have had a general, have not yet had a universal, ratification ; and, in Russia in particular, other compendiums of Christian doctrine, written generally in an evangelical strain, have been composed and published with high recommenda- tions. Of these the most remarkable is the Summary of Christian Divinity by Platon, late Metropolitan of Mos- cow, wdiich has been translated from the Slavonian into English by Dr Pinkerton,* and the doctrines of which, according to the testimony of that zealous agent of the Bible Society, in his valuable work on " Ptussia," pub- lished a few years ago,t and the no less interesting " Biblical Researches" in the same country,J of his former associate Dr Henderson, are received by a large portion of the Russian clergy of all orders, including the instructors of candidates for the holy ministry. Compared with the doctrines and sacraments of the Greek church, to which our notices have hitherto prin- * The Present State of the Greek Church in Russia, or a Sum- mary of Christian Doctrine by Platon, late Metropolitan of Mos- cow. Translated from the Slavonian. With a preliminary Memoir on the Ecclesiastical Establishment in Russia ; and an Appendix , containing an account of the origin and different sects of Russian Dissenters. t London, 1833. X London, 1826. 62 INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. cipally referred, its usual forms of worship are only of secondary importance, but not altogether to be overlooked. Its voluminous liturgical works, I have only partially examined. The following account of them from the pen of a gentleman long resident at Constantinople, I believe to be correct. " Dr King judiciously remarks, that by liturgy, the office of the Eucharist only was described, nor has it at present a different meaning in the Greek church, the four liturgies of which are those of St James, St Basil, St Chrysostom, and those of the pre-sanctified mys- teries. " The first of these is asserted to be spurious by Smith, and therefore obsolete. The liturgies of St Basil and St Chrysostom are essentially the same ; but the former being the longer, is used only on certain days, while the latter is considered as the ordinary communion service. That of the pre-sanctified is appropriated for Wednesdays and Fridays in Lent, or the great fast. " The service of the Greek church, like that of Kome at present, and that of all other churches before the Reformation, is principally choral. Their canons and antiphonies are hymns, or portions of Scripture, set to music, first recited by the minister, and then chanted by the choir, but without musical instruments, which are not admitted in accompaniment. The ectinea corresponds with our litany, but is never so called by the Greeks. They have several in every service. In consequence of a great variety of these and other forms, their books of offices are numerous and bulky. *• The Menseon contains the hymns and services for every festival, as it occurs in the calendar, and is divided into twelve volumes folio, each volume comprising the THE GREEK CHURCH. 63 service of a month. The Octoechos, is so called from eight tones or voices, v^^hich are fixed to particular hymns, and which serve as a rule for singing the rest. It is divided into two volumes folio. " The Synnaxar, or biographical history of the saints, comprehends four volumes folio, of which an appropriate portion is read on every saint's day. To these must be added the psalter and hours, the common service, the four gospels, the two triodes, the book of prayer, the ritual, and (which is very necessary in such a complex mass of liturgical forms) the regulation, wherein are con- tained directions how they are to be used. " Of the Menologion it is sufficient to remark, that it nearly resembles idolatry ; they admit pictures into their churches, not merely as ornamental, but as indispensable ill the ceremonial of their religion. They are usually attached to the screen which secretes the chancel, and from thence receives the name of iconostas. In the ar- guments advanced by Greek theologists in defence of this preference of painting to sculpture, there appears to be little solidity. They consider themselves as secure under the authority of St John Damascenus. In the emblematical and mystical properties, attributed to cleri- cal vestments, the Greek church rivals the barbarism of the monkish ages.* During my journey from India to this country in the year 1843, particularly in the Turkish empire, I had ^ many opportunities of observing the actual state of the Greek church, on whose tenets and ritual I need not farther enlarge. Of the observations which I then made of it, I shall now give such a brief summary as is * Dallaway'a Constantinople, p. 375. 64 IXDEPEXDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. expected of me. It is my heartfelt desire to speak with the utmost kindness towards the individuals and classes of men to whom I may refer, but at the same time with a due reo-ard to the interests of truth and righteousness and the purity of the Church of Christ. Amono- the few adherents of the Greek church whom I met in Egypt, I found one family of which the head appear- ed to entertain views of divine truth essentially evangelical, to cultivate personal godliness, and to take a warm in- terest in the advancement of the kingdom of the Redeemer upon earth. He lives on the shores of the Red Sea, from which he has never been absent. His vernacular tongue is Arabic ; but he has a tolerable acquaintance with Eng- lish, which he has turned to some account in the perusal of one or two of our best books on practical rehgion. Attention to the tenets and observances of different de- nominations of Christians, and the history of the church, he said, has taught him charity. He possessed a copy of the Scriptures in Arabic, with the contents of which he appeared tolerably familiar ; and he gratefully re- ceived from me a few of the Arabic publications of the Church Missionary press at Malta, and recommended his friends to make application for a supply, which they readily did. He took a great interest in the Arabic translation of the abridgement of Dr Keith's admirable work on Prophecy, and of the General Assembly's Letter to the Jews. He intimated his readiness to send one of his ^'oung relatives to Bombay for education in our mis- sionary seminary on my return to India. He gave me and my fellow-travellers such introductory letters as he thouoht would facilitate our movements and inquiries. It would have been joy to my heart to have met with manv such persons in the course of my peregrinations. THE GREEK CHURCH. 65 From the inmates of St Catherine's Monastery at Mount Sinai, who, including both the regular clergy and their lay-assistants, are twenty-three in number, my fellow- travellers and myself received much kindness. Like all the other recluses of the Greek church, the monks be- long to the order of St Basil, the rules of which they rigidly observe. Their seclusion they do not seem to have improved for the cultivation of deep and rational devo- tion, for pursuits of study, or for evangelistic effort, in which, — if their perpetual vows through which they de- prive themselves of their Christian liberty could be over- looked, — some apology might be found for their situation. Some of them confessed to me that, in the multiplicity of their public authorised services, they could dispense alto- gether with private prayer, and the perusal of the Scrip- tures. It was painful indeed to witness the manner in which they conduct divine worship in the church of the convent, dedicated to the " Metamorphosis," or Transfi- guration. The lengthy Greek service, they read and chanted with the greatest irreverence and altogether un- intelligible rapidity. Their ceremonious genuflexions and prostrations, and invocations, before the pictures of the saints, the large cross on the screen which separates the altar from the nave, and at the feet of their own superior, bore but too certain evidence of their practice of idolatry under the very shadow of that mountain, from which God himself spake the words, " Thou shalt not make unto thee any graven image, or any likeness of any thing that is in heaven above, or that is in the earth beneath, or that is in the waters under the earth." When they shewed us their library, in which we found a considerable number of works in the Arabic and Syriac, as well as Greek, languages, both printed and in manuscript, they 66 INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. could give us no general account of its contents, and ac- knowledged that, excepting its ecclesiastical service-books, it was to them merely useless lumber. The copies of the Scriptures too, which had been presented to them by Dr Joseph Wolff, during his first visit to the convent, for their individual use, had been added to the common stock, and were quite neglected. Only one or two of them appeared to be able to converse in Arabic with the surrounding- children of the desert, the religious instruction of whom, they confessed, they entirely neglected. No greater proof of the want of pastoral care of themselves, or rather of their predecessors, can be found than the fact, that they have allowed the body of the Jeheliyah, or moun- taineers, who are entirely dependent upon them as their menial servants, and who are the descendants of Christian slaves said to have been sent to the convent by the Em- peror Justinian, to become Musalmans. I did not hear of a single Arab to whom they have access having been instructed by any of them in the faith of Christ. Except in as far as they practise hospitality to travellers who visit the grand and terrific scenery and hallowed locali- ties among which they dwell, they seem never to aim at usefulness among their fellow-creatures. Their merits in the matter to which I allude, all are most ready to ad- mit who have participated in their kindness. It is in acknowledgment, however, of something else than this service, that their convent has for ages met with favour from the members of the Greek church. Their whole establishment, and especially their church, are viewed as so sacred throughout its bounds, that offerings to them are considered as especially meritorious, and have been accumulated within them by all classes of the people, and particularly by the Greek and Russian Emperors. THE GREEK CHURCH. 67 The Greek monks of the Holy Land with whom we came into contact at Bethlehem, Jerusalem, Mar Saba, Nazareth, and other places, we found to correspond very- much in character, attainments, and occupation with those of Mount Sinai. The great Christian pilgrimage con- ducted under their direction at the time of Easter, which we witnessed as far as our feelings could permit us, ap- pears to be calculated to produce anything but hallowed associations and holy impressions on the multitudes, from all parts of the Levant, who seek its blessings. A simi- lar remark may be extended to the pilgrimage of the Latins, and other denominations of Christians. The Greeks, it must be remembered, however, are peculiarly culpable in the confusion and revelry which they gene- rate, and imposture which they practise. It is under their auspices, that the miracle of the holy fire from heaven, as it is alleged, is annually exhibited to the people. We were so shocked by what we witnessed of the preparations for this lying wonder at the church of the Holy Sepulchre, that after having handed in our letters of introduction to the metropolitan, we found ourselves compelled to withdraw from the scene. The whole transaction, I was informed by those who had witnessed it, surpasses even the usual description of its presumption and impiety given by travellers and ob- servers. Of these let the following, which is the latest which I have seen, be taken as a specimen. " The miraculous Greek fire," says Mr Caiman,* " which takes place on the Saturday of the Greek Easter week, serves in the hands of the Greek and Armenian priests, the same purpose that the keys of Peter do in * A highly respectable Jewish convert residing at Jeursalera, and well known to many in this country. 68 INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. the hands of his skilful successors, the Popes ; it unlocks every coffer and purse of the pilgrims, and renders them at the disposal of the inventors and perpetrators of this lying wonder. " To notice all that was passing within the church of the Holy Sepulchre during the space of more than twenty-four hours, would be next to impossible ; because it was one continuation of shameless madness and riot- ing, which would have been a disgrace to Greenwich and Smithfield fairs. Only suppose for a moment, the mighty edifice crowded to excess with fanatic pilgrims of all the Eastern churches, who, instead of lifting pure hands to God, without wrath and quarrelling, are led by the petty jealousies about the precedency which they should main- tain in the order of their processions, into tumults and fighting, which can only be quelled by the scourge and whip of the followers of the false prophet. Suppose further, these thousands of devotees running from one extreme to the other, from the extreme of savage irrita- tion to that of savage enjoyment, of mutual revellings and feastings ; like Israel of old, who, when they made the golden calf, were eating, and drinking, and rising up to play. Suppose troops of men, stripped half naked to facilitate their actions, running, trotting, jumping, gallop- ing to and fro, the breadth and length of the church ; walking on their hands with their feet aloft in the air ; mounting on one another's shoulders, some in a riding and some in a standing position, and by the slightest push are all sent down to the ground in one confused heap, which made one fear for their safety. Suppose further, many of the pilgrims dressed in fur-caps, Hke the Pohsh Jews, whom they feigned to represent, and whom the mob met with all manner of contempt and insult, hurry- THE GREEK CHURCH. by ina them through the church as criminals who had been just condemned, amid loud execrations and shouts of lauo-hter, which indicated that Israel is still a derision amongst these heathens, by whom they are still counted as sheep for the slaughter. All these, and similar pro- ceedings, marked the introduction of this holy miraculous fire ; and when questioned about the propriety of such conduct within a Christian place of worship, and with the name of religion, the priests will tell you, that they once tried to get quit of these absurdities, and the holy fire was withdrawn in consequence of it ! " About two o'clock on Saturday afternoon, the pre- parations for the appearance of the miraculous fire com- menced. The multitude who had been heretofore in a state of frenzy and madness, became a little more quiet; but it proved a quiet that precedes a thunderstorm. Bishops and priests in their full canonicals, then issued forth from their respective quarters, with flags and banners, cruci- fixes and crosses, lighted candles and smoking censors, to join or rather to lead a procession, which moved thrice round the church, invoking every picture, altar, and relic, in their way, to aid them in obtaining the mi- raculous fire. The procession then returned to the place from whence it started, and two grey-headed bishops, the one of the Greek, the other of the Armenian church, were hurled by the soldiers through the crowd, into the apartment which communicates with that of the Holy Sepulchre, where they locked themselves in ; there the marvellous fire was to make its first appearance, and from thence issue through the small circular windows and the door, for the use of the multitude. The eyes of all men, women, and children, were now directed towards the Holy Sepulchre with an anxious suspense, awaiting the issue of their expectation. 70 INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. " The mixed multitude, each in his or her own lan- ^age, were pouring forth their clamorous prayers to the Vircrin and the saints, to intercede for them on behalf of the object for which they were assembled; and the same were tenfold increased by the fanatic gestures and the waving of the garments by the priests of the re- spective communions who were interested in the holy fire, and who were watching by the above mentioned door and circular windows, with torches in their hands, ready to receive the virgin flame of the heavenly fire, and convey it to their flocks. In about twenty minutes from the time the bishops locked themselves in the apart- ment of the Holy Sepulchre, the miraculous fire made its appearance through the door and the two small win- dows, as expected. The priests were the first who lighted their torches, and they set out on a gallop in th& direction of their lay brethren ; but some of these errand- less and profitless messengers had the misfortune to be knocked down by the crowd, and had their firebrands wrested out of their hands ; but some were more fortunate, and safely reached their destination, around whom the people flocked like be«s, to have their candles lighted. Others however were not satisfied at having the holy fire second hand, but rushed furiously towards the Holy Sepulchre, regardless of their own safety, and that of those who obstructed their way ; though it has frequently happened that persons have been trampled to death on such occasions. Those who were in the galleries let down their candles by cords, and drew them up when they had succeeded in their purpose. In a few minutes thousands of flames were ascending, the smoke and the heat of which rendered the church like the bottomless pit. To satisfy themselves, as well as to convince the THE GREEK CHURCH. 71 Latins, (who grudge so profitable as well as so effectual a piece of machinery being in the hands of the schis- matical Greeks and Armenians, and one which augments the power of the priests and the revenue of the convents, and who therefore exclaim against the miraculous fire), the pilgrims, women as well as men, shamefully expose their bare bosoms to the action of the flame of their lighted candles, to make their adversaries believe the miraculous fire differs from an ordinary one, in being perfectly harmless. The two bishops, who a little while before locked themselves in the apartment of the Holy Sepulchre, now sallied forth out of it. When the whole multitude had their candles lighted, the bishops were caught by the crowd, lifted upon their shoulder, and carried to their chapels amidst loud and triumphant ac- clamations. They soon, however, reappeared, at the head of a similar procession as the one before, as a pre- tended thank-offering to the Almighty for the miracu- lous fire vouchsafed, thus daring to make God a partaker in their lie. An express messenger was immediately sent off to Bethlehem, the birthplace of Christ, to inform the brethren there, and to invite them also to offer up their tribute of thanks for the transcendant glory of the day. Thus closed the lying wonders of the holy week of Easter."* This whole fraud, and these riotous Saturnaha, — I should rather say downright Satanalia, — approved as they are by the body^of the Greek ecclesiastics at Jeru- salem, are such as ought entirely to exclude those who have the control and management of them from Protest- ant approbation and ecclesiastical intercommunion. That * Herschell's Visit to my Fatherland in 1843, pp. 173-180. 72 IXDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. the very highest of the Greek clergy at Jerusalem are answerable for the fraud is evident, not only from their tolerance of it, but from the direct statements which they give when interrogated on the subject. The Greek metropolitan even was not ashamed to lurite to Joseph Wolff as follows : — " The holy fire was known in the time of the Greek emperors ; it was then seen in the holy sepulchre, and also in the time that the Crusaders were in possession of the place. Many of the Latin historians mention it. From the time of the invasion of the Turks till now, the holy fire is seen both by behevers and unbelievers."* The long continuance of an evil practice does not hallow it in the sight of God. In connexion with the Greek pilgrimage to Jerusa- lem, I may mention that the ecclesiastics at the Holy City are in the habit of furnishing the pilgrims with most impious and delusive certificates of the pardon and absolution of their sins, on account of the alleged merit of the journey which they undertake. I was glad to learn, during my journey through Syria, that the services of the Greek church are there generally conducted through the medium of a language vernacular to the people of the country, — the Arabic. f The secu- lar priests, though they read with notable rapidity, were not so faulty in this respect as the monks. They sel- dom, except on extraordinary occasions, preach to the people, and hence the great ignorance of multitudes bear- ing the Christian name. The disuse of preaching is not confined to Syria. It is general throughout the whole * Wolff's Journal. f In Greece, on the coasts of Asia Minor, and in Turkey in Europe, the service is performed in ancient Greek. In Russia, the medium adapted for it is the Sclavonic. THE GREEK CHURCH. 73 bounds of the Greek church. Respecting Greece itself, this statement is made in the Report of the American Board of Commissioners for Foreign Missions for 1841 : — " What the country needs above all things is, an edu- cated, pious priesthood, which shall preach the gospel in the churches from Sabbath to Sabbath. This necessity is beginning to be felt especially at Athens, where the demoralizing influences are greater than elsewhere. It is true two or three preachers were appointed two or three years ago for the kingdom, and these have occa- sionally preached a sermon in different parts ; but ex- cepting these, and the reg-ular preaching of Dr King at Athens, probably not a sermon was preached in the Greek language during that period until the last spring. Then four young men, who had gone through the regu- lar course of classical and theological study, were di- rected to preach m the churches in Athens." In this neglect of religious instruction through the most impres- sive mode of its communication, the distribution of copies of the Scriptures, and Christian publications, among the members of the Greek church in the East who are able to peruse them, becomes a duty of even more than ordi- nary importance. With a sense of this duty, the Ame- rican missionaries, the principal protestant ministers ex- pressly appointed to seek the revival of evangelical reli- gion in the regions to which I now refer, are deeply im- pressed. It is a happy circumstance that some of the Greek ecclesiastics themselves are not indisposed to encourage the circulation of the word of eternal life. Procopius, the second in authority amongst them at Jerusalem, proved for a considerable time a warm friend and useful agent of the Bible Society. Isa Petrus, too, at that place, is well known to the readers of missionary 74i INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. journals as a friend of the same institution. Wherever I went in Syria, I found the laity of the Greek church anxious to obtain copies of the Bible, and not unwilling to receive publications pregnant with the statements of evangelical truth. Having taken with me a large sup- ply, I was able to make a pretty extensive distribution throughout the country, except at the places at which the missionaries usually labour. At the town of Has- beiya, near the farthest source of the Jordan, I was en- craojed for some hours in meetino- the demands which were made upon my stores. Among the Arabic books which I distributed were several copies of a Life of Lu- ther, and other Protestant publications. When the Greek priests saw them in the hands of the people, they became quite infuriated, and sent an agent to beg me to order their restoration. I told the people that, as a friend of rehgious liberty, peaceable discussion, and prayerful inquiry, I left the matter entirely in their own hands. They declared that they would keep what they had received at all hazards ; and they heard the threats of the agents of the priests without being moved. Mr Smith, my fellow-traveller from Bombay, who took a deep interest in the 'affair, and who strenuously de- fended the rights of the people, remarked to me that more would afterwards be heard of this matter, — an an* ticipation which has been most remarkably fulfilled. Before we left Hasbeiya, a Druse of considerable intel- ligence told us, when we were quietly seated with him on the roof of his house, that a considerable number of persons in the town had for some time been anxious to declare themselves Protestants ; and that, if we could promise them protection from England, a hundred fami- lies, he was sure, would immediately join our commu- THE GREEK CHURCH. 75 nion. The effects of the ministrations of the excellent missionaries at Beirut, who had occasionally visited the town, and at one time maintained a school for the in- struction of its youth, had thus begun to appear. Some months after our visit, a considerable number of persons actually declared themselves Protestants, and one hun- dred and twenty of them were formed into a religious community by the Rev. Eli Smith, who hastened to visit them from Beirut. Connected with this transac- tion, I solicit your attention to the following extract of a letter from my excellent friend and for some time fel- low-traveller, the Bev. William Graham, missionary of the Irish Presbyterian Church at Damascus. On the 17th of May last, he says, " one hundred and fifty of the Greek church have become Protestants. They wrote a petition to the British Consul in Damascus, pray- ing to be taken under the protection of England, and vowing before God and man that, rather than return to the superstitions of their ancestors, they would suffer to be chopped like tobacco. This protection the Consul could not give, as the Protestant religion is not recog- nised nor tolerated legally in the Turkish empire. The Greek Patriarch [of Antioch], who has his residence in Damascus, was furious, and threatened to force them to return to the Church. The Turkish authorities also took the alarm. They held their secret councils, and dis- cussed what was to be done. Some did not think much of the matter ; others were clear for compelling the people to return, and several saw in it the design of Eng- land to gain a party in the country, that she might have some plea for taking forcible possession of it. In this state of matters, the affair was by common agreement referred to Constantinople." The English, Prussian, 76 INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. and, I believe, French authorities, much to their credit, recommended that these Christians should not be perse- cuted for their opinions ; and the government of the Sul- tan granted them permission to return to Hasbeiya, with the promise of protection, on condition that they should pay the usual taxes, and conduct themselves in a peace- able manner. The Greek priests were greatly incensed at this result ; and, under the instigation of Russia, it is alleged, they induced the adherents of the Greek church to make a show of leaving Hasbeiya on the re- turn of the Protestant party, that the Turkish govern- ment might have the case again thrown upon its consi- deration, as Hasbeiya could not contain the members of both churches ! The last tidings which I have received of this affair are contained in a letter of Mr Graham, dated January 1845 : " You may be interested," he says, " to hear more about the Protestants of Hasbeiya. They have been excommunicated by the Greek patri- arch, or his priests, in the strictest form, and all inter- course with them interdicted. Their teacher has been stoned, and fifteen families driven from their houses. They are thrown for support on the American mission- aries. Notwithstanding these evils, and even greater, which may yet arise, I think it probable that the prin- ciple of the toleration and recognition of Protestantism will be established. It is interesting to know, that the children of these poor people are committing to memory the Shorter Catechism." This movement, I have no hesitation in saying, is the most important which in our day has taken place in the Holy Land. Fervent should be our prayers that it may be overruled for the esta- bUshment of the liberties of Protestantism in that most important locality, on the same footing that those of the THE GREEK CHURCH. 77 Greek, Latin, and other churches have been secured. Our country has a perfect right to interfere in the case, both on the grounds of humanity and rehgious affi- nity, and the implied engagements connected with the ejection, in behalf of the Sultan, by the European powers, of Muhammed Ah.^ * " England having, in conjunction with other Christian powers, succeeded in restoring Syria to the Sultan, she is entitled to ex- pect that the Sultan, in return for such assistance, should secure his Christian subjects from oppression." — Lord Falmerston to Chekib Effendi, June 15, 1841. " On the 4th instant, I had an in- terview at Pera with the Internuncio and Monsieur de Titow, to concert the measures to be adopted with regard to Syria. Mr Wood and Monsieur Laurin were present. It was agreed to ad- vise the Porte. . . . 3. To issue positive orders to all Otto- man functionaries in Syria, to abstain from offering any impedi- ment whatever to the free exercise by Christians of the rites of their religion." — British Ambassador at Constantinople to Lord Palmerston, June 8, 1841. It would be strange indeed if England were to seek protection for all classes of Christians in Syria except Protestants. The interests of Protestantism in the Turkish em- pire, when connected with the first principles of toleration, will not, I am certain, be compromised by Sir Stratford Canning, Her Majesty's present able representative at Constantinople. The de- cided stand which he lately made for the prevention of the execu- tion of penitent Christian apostates returning from the profession of Muhammadism, — in which he was happily supported by the re- presentatives of Prussia andFrance, — experienced complete success ; and called forth the official declaration from the Sultan, the most remarkable ever heard from his lips, that " neither should Chris- tianity be insulted in his dominions, nor should Christians be in any way persecuted for their religion." To secure complete tolera- tion in Turkey, this declaration should be held as embracing Pro- testants, and extended to converts from Muhammadism, as well as to those who may have been born within the pale of the Christian church. Connected with this latter matter, the Free Church of Scotland lately addressed Her Majesty's Minister for Foreign Affairs. Lord Aberdeen has admitted its importance. His Prus- sian Majesty, who is deeply alive to the interests of Christianity in the East, it is understood, will keep it steadily in view. 78 INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. At Beirut, I had the pleasure of seeing a few members of the Greek church, united with others, in attendance upon the ministrations of the American missionaries, to whose able, zealous, and efficient labours, I have pleasure in bearing my humble testimony. At Smyrna, where the Greeks are a numerous, spirited, and influential people, I had the pleasure of findino- the cause of general education prospering in their schools and seminaries, which, in company with a gentleman of con- siderable literary attainments, I had an opportunity of visiting and examining. The attempt is there made, with encouraging success, to revive a knowledge of the an- cient Greek literature, and to associate it with the study of modern philosophy. One of the professors of the Lyceum, I found with a translation of Dugald Stewart's Philosophy of the Human Mind before him when he was instructing his class. When I asked if he had any can- didates for the sacred ministry students of the Scotch metaphysics, he said, smiling. This study is not for the priests of Smyrna. It was with extreme sorrow, that I found the scriptures, except in the form of most meagre extracts, banished from the Greek institutions there. Giving vent to this feeling, it was said to me by one of the teachers, " Why, we are afraid that as the style of the New Testament is not classical, it may defeat our attempts to revive the pure Hellenic Greek!" On my mentioning this circumstance to Mr Temple, the veteran American missionary, he said, " The Greeks now, as of old, seek after wisdom, but it is not that wis- dom which is from above." The Greeks at Smyrna have a press of their own, at which both a newspaper and magazine are printed ; but in a set of its publications which I ordered and i-eceived, I do not find many bear- THE GREEK CHURCH. 79 ing directly on the subject of religion. Some excellent works, however, have issued from the press of the Ame- rican Mission. In modern Greek, Armenian, and Ar- meno-Turkish, works to the extent of 50,000,000 pages have been there printed. The Greeks at Constantinople, as far as I could learn, though advancing in general and social improvement, are not yet becoming alive to the supreme importance of regulating their faith by a personal acquaintance with the word of truth. Religion with them, as with the Smyrniotes, occupies but a small share in their system of educationx The Bible, in modern Greek, however, has been circulated among them to some extent, through the agency of the British and Foreign Bible Society, and the American Mission. The translation used was made by Ilarion, the ex-bishop of Bulgaria, who is described as the " most learned and most indefatagible of the Greek hierarchy,"* and, I believe, that, as a literary work, it has received the highest recommendations. Little if any thing is being done toward the enlightenment of the members of the Greek church in the different provinces of Turkey in Europe ; but I heard from our American friends, that they have some intention of directing their attention to Bulgaria, where education and instruction are much needed by its simple and neglected population. On both sides of the Danube, there are other large and interesting districts which have powerful claims on evan- gelical benevolence. As the result of all my observation and inquiry re- specting the Greek church, I would say, that at present it seems a very difficult matter to impregnate it with evangelical truth and influence ; and that its circum- * Macfarlane's Constantinople, p. 400. 80 INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. stances are less encouraging than those of the other Oriental churches. So Httle has been done, and is now doing for it, however, compared with its magnitude, that we have little reason to restrict ourselves in our exertions in its behalf, either by its apathy or its opposition. The Protestant church should not overlook that access to it which at present it has in the Turkish empire, for it is very questionable whether, if political power were in the hands of the Greek church itself, it would tolerate decided efforts for reviving throughout its bounds the purity and power of Primitive Christianity. Its con- duct in the affair of the Protestants of Hasbeiya, whose case we have been called to notice, is characterized both by intolerance and persecution. II. THE ARMENIAN CHURCH. The Armenian Church is next in importance to the Greek charch in the East. It derives its name from the country of Armenia, of which Mount Ararat may be reckoned the centre. The greater Armenia comprehends the country lying west of the Caspian Sea, south of tlie Caucasian range, north of a line drawn from the north- east corner of the Mediterranean to the north-west corner of the Caspian, and east of Asia Minor. The lesser Armenia comprehends the eastern part of Asia Minor. The members of the Armenian church, intermingled throughout with the followers of the false prophet, inhabit the whole extent of this country, except the portions of Georgia in which the members of the Greek church abound, and the hilly districts around Uramiah, inhabited by the Nestorians and Kurds. They are scattered, however, also, over the whole of Asia Minor ; and are THE ARMENIAN CHURCH. 81 numerous at Constantinople. In Syria they number several thousands, and in Egypt a few hundred souls. In Persia a good many of the descendants of 80,000 fa- milies, carried captive by Shah Abbas, still reside. Some of them are to be found in the countries east of Persia as far as Kabul, and in India, particularly at Bombay and Calcutta. A few of them as merchants have proceeded eastward as far as Batavia. Individual families are esta- bhshed at Venice, Trieste, Vienna, and other towns of Europe. I have seen various estimates of their num- bers, from ten to two millions. Mr Lucas Balthazar, the intelligent editor of an Armenian newspaper, entitled '' The Dawn of iVrarat," published at Smyrna, stated to me that he calculates them at five millions, of whom he supposes two millions are to be found in the Russian provinces of Erivan, Karabagh, and Tiflis, recently con- quered from Persia ; two millions in the Turkish domi- nions ; and one million in Persia, and India, and other remote countries. I find by reference to the statistics of Russia, that he has over-estivnated the Armenian sub- jects of that empire by one-half. Turkey may have a million mid a lidlf of Armenians under its sway, and Persia and other distant lands half a miUion. Altogether, then, we may have about two millions and a half of Ar- menians in the different countries of their dispersion. In the valuable Researches of Smith and Dwight in Armenia, they are estimated at two millions. Armenia is connected with the ancient history of Assyria, Media, and Persia, and particularly with the dynasties of Arsaces and Sasan. The notices which can be collected of the early conveyance of the Gospel to its different regions and the surrounding territories are remarkably interesting, as they make us acquainted with G 82 INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. the first triumphs of Christianity over the rehgion of Zoroaster, who is said to have been born within its borders — as they certify to us that Armenia was the first country converted as such to our holy faith — and as they make us acquainted with the stedfastness of the early professors of the tmth, tried by seasons of fierce and long-continued persecution. The greatest instrument of its early evangelization was Gregory the Enlightener, the son of Anax, a Parthian prince. He was instructed in the doctrines of Christianity at Cesarea; in Cappadocia, and ordained a bishop by Leontius of that city, who signed the decrees of the Council of Nice. He was one of the most distinguished men of the eastern world. Tiridates the Great, and a large portion of the Armenian people, received baptism at his hands so early as the year 302 of our era. He was devoted, heart and soul, to his work — which he advanced by most enlightened educational measures, as well as by the public proclama- tion of the Gospel.* It is supposed that the monophysite doctrines were propagated in Armenia by Samuel, the disciple of Barsumas, who, about A.D. 460, introduced the doc- trines of Eutyches into Syria. A synod of ten bishops, assembled at Thevin in the year 536 by Nerses the patriarch of Ardaghar, condemned the decision of the Council of Chalcedon, recognising the two natures of Christ ; and from this time may be dated the separation * See History of Vartan, and the battle of the Armenians by Elisajus, translated by Professor Neumann of Munich, and Avdall's History of Armenia; The notices of the early propagation and persecutions of Christianity in Armenia and the adjoining terri- rories, I have endeavoured to collect in a sermon, entitled the Doc- trine of Jehovah addressed to the Parsis. THE ARMENIAN CHURCH. U6 of the Armenian from the Greek Church * In the pro- ceedmgs of the Jerusalem Synod of the Greek Church, of which we have ah^eady given the substance, the Armenians, as well as the other independent eastern churches, are represented as agreeing with the Greek Church, except in so far as their own " special heresy" is concerned. The statement made respecting this matter is substantially correct. The heads of the Armenian Church, recognised from ancient times, are the patriarchs of Echmiadzin and Ardaghar in the Greater, and of Sis in Cilicia, in the Lesser, Armenia. Each of these dignitaries, and parti- cularly the chief of thei See first mentioned, receives the additional title of Catholicos. To them are to be added the titular patriarch of Constantinople, recognised by the Turkish Government as the head of its Armenian subjects, and the titular patriarch of Jerusalem. Below them are the bishops of towns and districts — who like themselves must be selected from the monkish orders, — who, as in the E/omish and Greek Churches, are deno- minated the regular clergy, and supposed to be possessed of peculiar sanctity ; the secular or parish clergy ; and the four minor orders of porters, readers, exorcists, and candle-holders. The monkish clergy are denominated Vartabads or Doctors, and it is their peculiar office to teach and preach-^duties, however, seldom discharged by them, even when they are elevated to the grade of bishop. No lay-monks are recognised. The parochial clergy, who. are the most numerous, must all be married, and have at least one child before they are appointed to * Conciliationis Ecclesise Armense cum Romana ex-ipsis Arme- norum Patrum et Doctorum Testimoniis, auctore Clemente Gralano. Roma;, 16S0. Vol. i. p. 86 et seq. Fabricii Lux Evangelii, p. 644. 84 IXDEPEXDEXT EASTEJlN CHURCHES. office ; and, what is well worthy of notice, they are chosen for ordination by the members of the respective congre- gations. The most objectionable arrangements connected \\^ith the Armenian ministry, consist in their maintenance of confession, both formal and extemporaneous, and subsequent absolution.^ They do not pretend to dis- pense indulgences, but they foster the principles of self- righteousness, by prescribing meritorious *' satisfactions," by fastings, prayers, almsgivings, pilgrimages, and masses. Of the views of the Armenians respecting the nature and person of Christ, which formed the occasion of their separation from the Greek Church, the following ex- tracts from one of the letters of the Rev. Eli Smith, present us with a statement quite in accordance with the result of my own inquiries. " One of the Vartabads here [TJchkeliseh], introduced of his own accord the monophysitrsm of his church, by declaring that it re- ceives only the first three, of the general councils. Nestorius, he said, held to a perfect separation qf the divinity and humanity of Christ, and Eutyches taught that his humanity is absorbed in his divinity. The Armenians, agreeing wnth neither, believe that the two natures are united in one, and anathematize all who hold to a different, creed. In this he spoke advisedly, for it is well known that Eutyches is acknowledged by neither of the three monophysite sects — the' Armenian, the Jacobite Syrian, and the Coptic, including the * It would appear that the form of absolution in the Armenian • .Church has been changed from " God remits thy sins," to *'I ab- solve thee from thy sins." Galanus thus writes, " Vera forma" Sacramenti Poenitentia^ seu ExomologensiSj non est absolutio ilia (ab Armeilis olim Presbyteris usurpata,et a Yartanopropugnata): Deus remittit pcccata tna :■ sed hac alia (qiia nunc communiter ipsi utuntur) ; Ego absolvo te a peccatis." Vol. iii. p. 617. ■ THE ARMENIAN CHURCH. 85 Abyssinian, to which his controversy gave birth — and that his alleored doo-ma of a confusion in the natures of Christ is the reason of his rejection, though, perhaps, a candid investigation will hardly find him chargeable with such an opinion.* Another inteUigent ecclesiastic had told us, that not only does his nation hold to one nature, but also to one will, in Christ — thus making the Armenians partake in the monothelite as well as the monophysite heresy. f The same priest, after declar- ing that Christ is perfect God and perfect man, and being asked, also, if the Divine nature was so united to the human as to suffer with it on the cross, replied that it is impossible for the Divinity to suffer ; but in ex- pressing this opinion, he seemed to contradict the for- mularies of his church in which the prayer occurs, * Holy God, and holy strong, and holy immortal, who was crucijled for us, have mercy upon us ;' and with its belief that the Divinity of Christ cleaved to his body even in the grave, so as to render it incorruptible." Like the Greeks, the Armenians hold that the Spirit proceeds from the Father only. Practically, however, they dwell so little on their peculiar opinions respecting the Trinity, that Mr Smith finds himself warranted to say, that " missionaries may convert the whole nation to the truth as it is in Jesus, without feeling themselves once called upon to agitate the questions which, in the times of the first councils, rent the Church asunder." + * Assem. Bib. Orient, vol. 2, intro. dissert. Mosheim Eccles. Hist. vol. i. I Compare Assem. Bibl. Orient, vol. iii. p. 607. + Smith and Dwight's Researches in Armenia, pp. 419-421. — Connected with the matters here adverted to, the following accu- rate statement by Cotovicus, (Kootwyk) is worthy of notice. It is 86 INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. The following extract of replies given by an Armenian bishop at Basrah to Dr Wolff, throws light on their ecclesiastical position and tenets. " What relation have the Armenians to the Coptic and Syrian Churches? Ans. The Armenians have the same faith and tenets as they have. Q. What persons are by them considered as heretics ? Ans. Macedonius, Nestorius, Arius, and Pope Leo. Q. On what authority does the Armenian belief rest ? Ans. The Bible and the three first Coun- cils — 1. Nicea ; 2. Constantinople ; 3. Ephesus. Every other Council is anathematized by the Armenian Church.'* The views entertained by the Armenian church of the sacraments are much akin to those of the Greek church. It holds that they are seven in number, namely, baptism, confirmation, extreme unction, the communion, marriage, ordination, and penance. The four first of these are administered together, generally when the child is only eight days old. Baptism, according to the rules of the Armenian church, should be administered by a threefold effusion of water by the hand of the priest, followed by a three- well that it is in Latin. " In Christo in primis (uti ot Jacobitse) unam tantum naturam, unam voluntatem, unamque operationem constituunt ; aiuntque Ilumanitatem abysso Divinitatis esse infu- s;un, atque ita ex Divinitate et came unum quid factum. Asse- runt etiam corpus Christi subtile, et agile fuisse, non corruptibile,, neque accidentibus subjectum. Credunt quidem Virginem Mariam Deum peperisse; negant tanaen earn camera ex ea sumpsisse; sed coeleste corpus et spirituale e coelis secum attulisse, atque subtilL- tate sua et agilitate Virginis viscera penetrasse, eorpusque ejus tanquam per canalem pertransisse, atque ita demum statuto a na- tura tempore editum fuisse : Hinc vero incorruptam eam tam ante quam post partum mansisso volent." Itin. Hierosol. p. 207. Aut- v^rpicB, 1619. THE ARMENIAN CHURCH. 87 fold immersion, emblematic of* the Saviour's three days abode in the grave. The present mode of its administra- tion corresponds with the direction of the ritual. " We were assured by more than one intelligent ecclesiastic," says Mr Smith, " that it is by pouring upon the head of the child sitting in the font, a handful of water in the name of the Father, another in the name of the Son, and a third in the name of the Holy Ghost, and then plung- ing the body three times, to signify that Christ was in the grave three days. That entire immersion, and the triple repetition, are not considered essential, however, is proved by the fact, tliat the baptism of even heretical sects, who only sprinkle once, is considered valid, and persons thus baptized are not required, as among the Greeks, to submit to the ordinance again, on entering the Armenian church."* A small colony of Armenians at Kabul applied to the chaplains attached to the British troops for the administration of the ordinance to their children. Three drops of the holy oil are put into the water of baptism before its use, as obsei-ved by an Ar- menian bishop to Dr WolfF.f Baptism, the Armenians view as destructive of original sin, and productive both of regeneration and adoption, and communicative of for- giveness. They pray for the literal descent of the Holy Spirit into the holy oil, which they mix with the water and into the water itself, so that it may receive what they, in common with the Greek church, call " the bene- diction of the Jordan." In the act of baptism, they commemorate " the mother of God and eternal Virgin Mary, St John the Baptist, and all the saints, along with the Lord." Thei» baptismal service, which is given at * Smith and Dwight's Researches, p. 305. t WolflTs Journal, vol. iL p. 347. OO INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. length by Joseph Aloysius Assemanus, bears painful testimony to the degeneracy of their faith."^ As I have myself witnessed, in the chapel of the nativity at Bethlehem, they administer mass, or the communion, in a very ceremonious and pompous manner, with the priests arrayed in gorgeous robes, the waving of incense- pots, washing of hands, bowings, prostrations, and saluta- tions. They believe in the doctrine of absolute tran- substantiation ; and they worship the consecrated ele- ments as the real body and blood of Christ. The effi- cacy which they attach to the mass may be learned from the following extract from one of their prayers : — " May this be for justification, propitiation and remission of sins, to all who draw near. Through it grant love, stability, and desired peace to the whole world ; to the holy church, and all orthodox bishops, priests, and deacons ; to kings, the world, princes, and people ; to travellers and seamen ; to those who are bound, in danger and in trouble, and to those who are fisfhtinor with barbarians. Throuo-h it also grant to the air mildness, to the fields fertility, and to them who are afflicted with diverse diseases, speedy relief. Through it give rest to all who are already asleep in Christ, first parents, patriarchs, prophets, apostles, martyrs, bishops, elders, deacons, and all the members of the holy church. With them also visit us, we pray thee, thou beneficent God."f The Armenians commu- nicate by having a piece of the bread dipped in the wine. Confirmation is always administered by the Armenians at the time of baptism. It is generally denominated by * Codex Liturg. Eccles. Univers. Lib. sec. p. 194, et seq. t Armenian missal, called Khorhiirtadedr. Smith and Dwight*s Researches, p. 288. THE ARMENIAN CHURCH. 89 them 3Ieirun, from the sacred oil whidi is used on the occasion of its administration.* This oil is applied to the forehead, and the eyes, ears, nose, mouth, hands, heart, back, and feet, by the parish priest and not by the bishop. t Extreme unction, as we have already hinted, is also administered at the time of baptism. The uncertainty of life is urged as the reason of this early administration. By some it is supposed that the rule has fallen pretty generally into disuse in the Arme- nian church. Marriage may take place among the Armenians, ac- cording to their ecclesiastical rules, when the girl is ten and the boy fourteen years of age. Betrothments are frequently effected when the parties are of a much more tender age. The seclusion of females is to a great ex- tent practised among them in their fatherland ; but in foreign countries they catch the spirit of an advanced civilization, and restore woman to that position in society which she is fitted and designed to occupy by Him who gave her as a help meet to man. The ordination of priests among the Armenians is conducted by the bishops, and of the bishops by the catholicos. They speak, however, of only two distinctive orders of the clergy properly so called, those of the priest and deacon. J Their principal prerequisites to ordination are the simple ability to read, and assent to the orthodox * " Meirun is the holy oil which is used at confirmation, ordina- tion, and A^arious other ceremonies, and is one of the principal su- perstitions of the Armenians. Its sanctity is commonly believed to be miraculously attested by its being made to boil by the mere ceremony of consecration." Smith and Dwight's Researches, p. 299. t Smith and D wight, p. 305. X Smith and D wight, pp. 234, 330. 90 INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. creed.* Should there be a revival of literature among them, we may receive from them very interesting de- tails connected with the history of the Christian church in the eastern parts of the world. In the convent at Echmiadzin, they have a very large library, principally of manuscripts of very great antiquity. * The following are the replies of an Armenian bishop to the queries of Dr Wolff on the subject of the ordination of priests. " If an Armenian desires to become priest, what ceremonies, or forms, must he pass through ? " Bishop. — They examine him, whether he is a legitimate child ; then whether he is clever and honest, and whether he can read ; then they consult with the congregation, and then the young man is required to confess whether he has always been a moral man or not. " How is he made priest ? "Bishop. — He is dressed in church cloth, thenhe kneels down near the church gate. The bishop prays over him, and gives him the key to open the door, saying. Thou must be ready to open the church. Then the candidate goes upon his knees in the church, and then he gives him a thing to sweep the church, saying, Thou must keep clean the church. Then the bishop prays over him, and then he goes some steps farther into the church, and a prayer-book is given to him, and the bishop prays again over him. Then the gos- pel is given to the candidate, then he advances a step farther in the church, and then a bottle of wine is given into his hands, and then he is Dpir, that is sub-deacon. Then they put on him a cloth over the shoulder, and give him a vessel with perfumery, then he makes one step farther, and a Testament is given him, and he becomes head-deacon, i. e. Sarkawak ; when he becomes Sarkawak,he is no longer allowed to marry. After he is Sarkawak he kneels down and ascends three steps of the altar ; the bishop prays and gives him the Testament and the priest's dress, and a cup ; and after this the bishop anoints his forehead and both his hands ; he then stands withboth his hands folded together, whilst another priest performs mass, and then the bishop bows over him ; when the service is over he reads four chapters of the Testament, and must remain forty days in a room near the church, and is neither allowed to see his wife nor family. At the end of this time he celebrates mass, and thus he is Kahanah, f riest." Wolff's Journal, ii. p. 356. THE ARMENIAN CHUKCH. 91 The Armenian ritual appoints nine distinct seasons for daily worship, and contains the services for them, viz. " midnight, the hour of Christ's resurrection ; the dawn of day, when he appeared to the two Marys at the sepulchre ; sunrise, when he appeared to his dis- ciples ; tliree o'clock (reckoning from sunrise), when he was nailed to the cross; six o'clock, when the darkness over all the earth commenced ; nine o'clock, when he gave up the ghost; evening, when he was taken from the cross and buried ; after the latter, when he de- scended to hades to deliver the spirits in prison ; and on going to bed. But never, except perhaps in the case of some ascetics, are religious services performed so often. All but the ninth are usually said at twice, viz. at ma- tins and vespers, which are performed daily in every place that has a priest ; the former commencing at the dawn of day, and embracing the first six services, and the latter commencing about an hour before sunset, and embracing the seventh and eighth. On the Sabbath, and on some of the principal holidays, instead of one, there are frequently two assemblies in the morning. '"*''' Mass is as distinct from these services as the communion service in the Church of England is distinct from morn- ing prayer. It is generally performed daily. The Psalms of David, hymns, and anthems, occupy half of the services ; but, being in prose, they are not sung but chanted. Most of the lessons are taken from the Bible ; but a considerable number belong to the Apocrypha, and books of extravagant legends. The prayers are offered up in behalf of the dead, as well as of the living and they are presented" with the invocation of the Virgin Mary, John the Baptist, Sai^ Stephen, and Sarp Gre- * Smith and Dwight's Researches, p. 105. 92 INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. gorius Lusavoricli (St Gregory the Eiiliglitener), and other saints, as well as of Him who is the only mediator between God and man. The mode of conducting divine worship among them is often very unlike what is to be expected, when that God, who is a Spirit, is to be wor- shipped in spirit and in truth. The prayers and read- ings are in the ancient Armenian language, which is little, if at all, understood by the common people ; and they are generally read both rapidly and indistinctly, " In the enclosure before the altar," says one who has more frequently witnessed their devotions than myself, " will be two or three priests, surrounded by a crowd of boys from eight to twelve years old, performing prayers ; some swinging a smoking censor, others, taper in hand, reading first from one book and then from another, and all changing places and positions according to rule. The monotonous, inarticulate sing-song of the youthful offi- ciators, with voices often discordant, and stretched to their highest pitch, will grate upon your ear You will be surrounded by a barefooted congregation, [this is no matter of reproach, for the shoes are taken off for the same reason that our own hats are,] uttering re- sponses without order, and frequently prostrating them- selves and kissing the o-round, with a siojn of the cross at every fall and rise Why so large a portion of the service has been suffered to pass into the hands of boys is exceedingly strange. They fill the four ecclesiastical grades below the sub-deacon, to which are attached the duties of clerks, or more commonly are substitutes for their occupants, having themselves no rank at all in the church. Of the first 158 pages of the Jamakirk, con- taining the whole of the midnight service, with all its variations for feasts and other special occasions, more THE ARMENIAN CHURCH. 93 than 130, consisting of psalms, hymns, &c. are read or chanted by them under the direction of the priests. . . . Of the remaining pages, some half a dozen belong to the deacons, if there are any, and the remainder, consisting simply of prayers and lessons from the gospels, are read by the priests. All the service, with few other excep- tions than the lessons, and that the priest in the middle of every prayer of any length turns round to wave a cross before the people, and say, ' Peace be to all, let us wor- ship God,' is performed with the back to the congrega- tion If a boy makes a mistake he is reproved, or even chastised, on the spot, though a prayer be inter- rupted for the purpose. The people, too, are constantly coming and going, or moving about, and often engaged in conversation."* This gross irreverence, it is but jus- tice to say, is matter of regret with many of the intelli- gent Armenians with whom I have come in contact. The Sabbath, the Armenians regard with greater strict- ness, as far as rest is concerned, than most of the other bodies of eastern Christians ; and few of the people alto- gether neglect attendance at church. This bespeaks on their part some becoming reverence for the divine insti- tution. It would doubtless tend to its better sanctifica- tion, were they to curtail the numerous feast and fast days which they have devised of their own hearts. It is to be lamented that they too often substitute their at- tendance at church for family and private prayer. To the worship of saints and angels by the Armenians I have already alluded. The material cross on which the Saviour died, tliey view as a real, though silent, inter- . cesser. In imitation of it, they make artificial crosses * Smith and Dwight, pp. 139-141. 94 INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. for consecration by water, wine, and the holy oil ; and to these crosses they direct their adorations, believing that Christ becomes inseparably united to them. They worship the pictures of Christ, setting forth that the Re- deemer himself is inherent in them ; and give inferior ho- nour and reverence to the images of the saints and angels. The Armenian bishop of Cairo, when shewing us his church, seemed to be ashamed of their practice in these respects. '' We have here," he said, " only a very few pictures, and these only for purposes of commemoration. But the fewer the better." I have alluded to the standard of literary attainment among the Armenian clergy. The state of education among the people of Armenia proper, is in general ex- ceedingly low, the schools being extremely few in num- ber, and limited in the instruction which they communi- cate. Among some of the exterior parts in which Ar- menians are to be found, as we may afterwards have occasion to notice, education is advancing in a very en- couraging manner. There are Armenian presses at Echmiadzin, Constantinople, Smyrna, Moscow, Astra- khan, and Tiflis; and they may be made the means of extensively diffusing useful and divine knowledge within their community. Many important works in the Ar- menian lan^uao-e, which obtain an extensive circulation, are published at the Catholic convent of St Lazarus near Venice ; but it becomes the Armenians to be on their o-uard ao-ainst their beino- ensnared by them to the em- bracement of the tenets and practices of Rome. Without enlarging these details, it will be seen that the Armenian church has departed far indeed, in many respects, from the doctrine and discipline of Christ. It delights my heart, however, to say, that its ministers THE ARMENIAN CHURCH. 95 and people are not so hopelessly involved In error as at first sight appears. They are not overborne by human authority, either that of their present ecclesiastics, or of the ancient fathers and councils of the church ; and much as they defer to tradition, they allow that, in mat- ters of faith and practice, the ultimate appeal must be made to the Holy Scriptures. Their ecclesiastical ser- vices are tolerated by some of them more from ignorance than approval of their contents. There is a pretty ge- neral persuasion amongst the more intelligent members of their community, that the primitive days of Chris- tianity were distinguished for gi-eater simplicity in the forms of worship and church-government than the pre- sent. They are not unmindful altogether of the sted- fastness of their forefathers under the direful persecu- tion of the Zoroastrians ; and they are not ignorant of the fact, that love to the Saviour was the grand instru- ment of their support under the tribulation which they were called to endure. They cordially hate Popery, from the insidious inroads which it has striven to make in their own body ; and they are better pleased with their disagreement than with their accordance with Rome.'^ Scattered though they be over a surface of * Galanus, the Roman missionary, gives the following summary of the " errors of the Armenians" in the time of Bartholoma3us, also an emissary of Rome, who died in the year 1333. " 1. They assert that there is only one nature in Christ, according to the heresy of Dioscorus. 2. That the Holy Spirit proceeds not from the Son, ac- cording to the error of the Greets. 3. That the souls of the saints do not enter the kingdom of heaven, and of sinners into hell, before the final judgment; but that they all waitthatjudgment inthemiddle of the firmament. 4. That there is no place of purgatory, or of hell. 5. That the Romish Church has not obtained the primacy 96 INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. country immensely large, when compared with their numbers, they cherish no small share of commendable fraternal and patriotic feeling. They are, compared with others in the East, to a great extent free from bigotry. If they have not yet received the doctrines of the Reformation, it can scarcely be said that they have rejected them, like the Koman and Greek churches, for it is only lately that the attempt has been made to press them on their acceptance. Some of the prayers which are most popular in their body, are well nigh evangehcal over other churches. 6. They detest Pope Leo, and the Council of Chalcedon. 7. They do not observe the Dominical festivals, according to the order observed by the Romish Church, especially the nativity of our Lord. 8. They do not observe the fasts accord- ing to the ecclesiastical canons. 9. They have not all the seven sacraments of the church, omitting confirmation and extreme unc- tion, and being ignorant of the essence of the other sacraments. 10. They do not pour water into the cup, when they celebrate the divine sacrifice of the mass. 11." They assert that the Eucharist is not to be dispensed to the people, unless under both kinds ; and therefore they distribute the body of Christ first tinged with his sacred blood in the cup. 12. They celebrate it in cups made of wood or clay. 13. Any priest may absolve the penitent from any sin, without any reservation, even without any case of necessity. 14. They are subject to two patriarchs, each of whom claims the patriarchy of the whole of Armenia to himself. 15. The parochials and bishops are constituted by hereditary right, through the vio- l^ice of their kindred. 16. They buy and sell the sacraments of the Church for a price. 17. They make a divorce without a cause between man and wife for the sake of money, contrary to the command of the gospels and the sacred canons. 18. They do not con- coct (conficiunt) the oil of chrism, and of the sick. 19. They give the holy communion to children before the use of reason." Con- di. Eccles. Armen. cum Rom. vol. i.p. 515. Some of these charges against, the Armenians are without foundation ; and for some of the grounds of their differing from Rome they have a scriptural warrant. THE ARMENIAN CHURCH. 9? throuo-hout.* Many of them, in the different countries of their dispersion, exercise a great influence over the * The following occurs in a prayer-book, in the modern Arme- nian, composed by Petrus, Wartabed of Tiflis. The translation is by Dr Wolff. " Jesus Christ, my Lord, thou hast suffered for us sinners, who have been worthy of condemnation on account of our sins ; and thou hast freely saved us without our merits ; thanks be to thee. O Jesus, thou art sweet indeed, and the light of ray eyes. Thy sufferings have been very bitter and grievous indeed which thou sufferedst with thy great condescension, and this for our sake. O how deeply do I feel that we have so heavily sinned that thou hadst to suffer for it. For we are nothing, we soon, very soon pass away ; and thou hast voluntarily suflFered for thy own good plea- sure. I feel in myself nothing but sickness and sins ; and for our sakes thou wert nailed on the cross ; therefore, O Jesus Christ my Lord, as thou didst suffer all these great sufferings, I humbly be- seech thee, that thou mayest inspire in me faith and an experimen- tal knowledge of thy sufferings. This will be sufficient, and I de- sire nothing else in this world, only that I may acquire faith in thee, and love toward thee ; and by which faith and love, thou mayest burn within my heart and in my soul. And grant to ena- ble me always to think in my mind of those things which thou, O Lord, sufferedst ; for if I have acquired such a faith in thee and love toward thee, then the wicked one will never be able to hurt me, nor consume me. Nor shall I ever be afraid of him, relying on, and supported by thy cross, so mighty and so powerful to destroy him. Thou art our Wartabed, our master in truth ; and thou art the light of our heart. Thou art he that healeth our wounds, and thou takest away all our sores, and thou drivest away all our fears, and thou art the giver of tears, tears unto repentance ; and thou enrichest us with thy loving-kindness. Lord, I am undone without thee. I am a dry tree, which giveth no fruit. O Jesus, good Jesus, I humbly beseech thee to hear me for the sake of thy sufferings." AVolff's Journal, vol. ii. p. 357. A prayer of Nerses Clajensis of the twelfth century is a great favourite with the Armenians. An edition of it was some time ago printed at the monastery of St Lazarus in no fewer than twenty-four languages, embracing even the Chinese. It is divided into twenty-four sections, corresponding with the hours of the day. It contains many supplications, strictly evangelical, addressed to the H b'u INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. Muhammadans, and Jews, and heathen, among whom they dwell, and exercise their calling as merchants, Fathei* and Son, and jn-esented in the name of the Saviour, -^rhose sole mediator ship ^ however, it does not recognise, as it contains a direct reference in the conclusion to " the intercession of the holy mother of God, and John the Baptist, and the first martyr St Ste- phen, and St Gregory our ilhmiinator, and the holy Apostles, Doctors, Martyrs, Patriarchs, Hermits, Virgins, and all thy saints in heaven and earth." Should this lecture ever come into the hands of any Armenian, an admirer of this prayei', I would direct his attention to the fol- owing substance of a simple convei'sation which a friend and myself on one occasion had with a priest who approved of that invocation of the saints and angels which it exemplifies, " Protestants. — You seem, friend, to l>e very unwell. What is the matter with you ? " Priest. — I fear that I am suffering from a consumption. I have tried a change of climate without effect, and now death seems to stare me in the face. '• Prot. — Your circumstances are very solemn. "What do yon do in the prospect of death and judgments '' Priest. — I ask the saints and angels to recommend me to the Saviour's mercy, •' Prot. — Where are the saints ? " Priest. — They are in heaven. " Prot. — But suppose them to he a great deal nearer to you than heaven. Suppose them to be on the other side of this plain of Bal- bek, seated on the summits of Momit Lebanon. Do you think that they could hear you, if you were to cry to them from this place ? Do you think that they could lend an ear to hundreds and thou- sands of Christians calling upon them at Damascus, Jerusalem, Constantinople, and ten thousand other places throughout the world, at the same time ? Do you think that they could separately represent the interests of all appealing to them to the Saviour ? " Priest. — I do not see how they could ; but you have destroyed my peace, and taken away my hope. " Prot. — Only that they may rest upon a sure foundation. Christ the Saviour is everywhere present, and he knows the thoughts of all, and, as God, can receive the prayers of all. He is the " only uiediator between God and man." THE ARMENIAN" CHURCH. 99 bankers, shopkeepers, and agents ; and the revival of evangehcal rehgion among them would have a powerful influence in the conversion of the eastern nations to the faith of Jesus. This opinion is quite in accordance with that of the great Fabricius,^ and of every friend of the propagation of our holy faith who has particularly con - sidered their circumstances. " Next to the Jews," says Dr Claudius Buchanan, " the Armenians will form the most generally useful body of Christian missionaries. They are to be found in every principal city of Asia ; " Priest. — But will it not be the height of presumption for me a miserable sinner, to call upon his name ? " Prot. — You have a divine warrant expressly to pray in his name. ' "Whatsoever ye shall ask the Father in my name, he will give it you. Hitherto have ye asked nothing in my name : ask, and ye shall receive, that your joy may be full.' how little do men knoAv of the grace of Christ, when they refuse to trust him, or to come into his presence without the favour of their fellow-creatures. Be content with him : ' We have an advocate with the Father, even Jesus Christ the righteous.' " *"Armenii longe lateque per Asiam commerciorum causa corn- meant, qui possent Religionis Christiante propagationem promovere egregie, si illius successus a^que quam ex mercatura lucrum cordi illis esset." Lux Evangelii, p, 651. (1731.) Before this time we find the traveller Cotovicus (Kootwyk) thus writing of the Arme- nians: — " Armenii peromnem fere orientem latissime sparsi, Syria?, iitriusque Armenise, Mesopotamia, Persidis, Caramenia', necnon Egypti urbes passim inhabitant. Homines sunt acerrimo ingenio pra3diti, mercaturts in primis dediti, atque omnium artium mecha- nicarum peritissimi, ca;terisque in rebus vel maxim e industrii, erga exteros supra modum humani, et benigni; sed et Mahommeteis omnibus grati, acceptiores saltern cieteris Orientis Christicolis ; quamobrem plurimis apud barbaros gaudent immunitatibus, et pri- vilegiis. Grjecis vero in primis inlensi, maxirao jam dudum inter ntranique gentem vigente odio, Latinis auteni studiosiores, quod hos pariter a Graicis odio haberi noverint." Itiner. Hieros. p. 206 Antwerp. 1691. 100 INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. they are the general merchants of the East, and are in a state of constant motion from Canton to Constantinople. Their general character is that of wealthy, industrious, and enterprising people."* The Rev. Henry Martyn, Dr "Wolff, and other missionary travellers, have spoken strongly of the great hopefulness of their circumstan- ces, compared with those of some of the other eastern churches. Though little has hitherto been done for the revival of evangelical religion among the Armenians, they have not altogether been neglected. Nor has their own agency been quite overlooked in the great work of the enlightenment of the eastern world. The friends of the Bible and Missionary Societies in this country are fami- liar with the name of Mr Johannes Lassar, a member of their community, and a native of China, under whose guidance Dr Marshman in the first instance engaged in the study of the Chinese, and with whose assistance he rendered the Scriptures into that most difficult lan- guage. Mr Arratun, a man of piety and devotedness, is at present, as he has been for years, a most useful agent of the Baptist Missionary Society at Calcutta. Mr Johannes Avdall, an Armenian of the same place, is distinguished for his learning, and most zealous for the diffusion of knowledge throughout his nation. He is well acquainted with many eastern languages, and the whole range of Armenian authorship. He is the author of a translation into English of Father Chamich's His- tory of Armenia, and of several minor pieces. Mesrop of Julfah, when in India, translated Bishop Heber's Palestine, into his native tongue. The late Mr Aganur found a place among the literati of Bombay, and his two * Christian Researches, p. 242. THE ARME^^IA^^ CHUIICH. 101 sons occupy a most respectable position in that city. Their friendship is highly valued by the members of our own mission there. To one of them, Mr Aviett, who has taken a great interest in my discussions with the Parsis, I have been indebted for a translation of that part of the work of Esnik, an Armenian writer of the tifth century, which refers to the tenets of the ancient Zoroastrians.^ During my own residence in Bombay, five Armenians, who had been attending for some time the ministrations of our mission there, were brought under serious impressions ; and, deeply alive to the errors of the Armenian church which we have already noticed, and afraid, lest continuing with it they should participate in its sins, they voluntarily asked from us, and received, admission into the communion of the Presby- terian church, being desirous, as they said, to avail themselves of its services, at least till an effectual reform should appear among their countrymen. Several Ar- menian youths have been educated in our institution ; and one of them, a young man of promising piety re- turned to Julfah, near Isfahan, his native place, on my leavincT India. o The first Protestant Mission which seriously directed its attention to the spiritual amelioration of the Ar- menians, was that of the Basle Evangelical Society, established in the Russian province of Georgia in the year 1824. That mission, though, in the first instance, it had particularly in view the conversion of the Muham- madans, did much, and with encouraging success, for the Armenians. Of its proceedings among them, the following is an interesting, and affecting, and instructive * Appendix to " The Parsi Religion, as contained in the Zand- avasta," &c. 102 IXDEPENDEXT EASTERN CHURCHES. summary, extracted from a retrospect of the Mission drawn up at my request by my excellent friend the Eev. Mr Pfander, one of the missionaries, now in India. Its great interest will form an excuse for its introduc- tion to your notice. " The population of these provinces consists of Muhammadans and Armenians ; the Muhammadans, who speak a dialect of the Turkish language, form about two-thirds, and the Armenians one- third, of the whole population. To labour among the former, and occasionally to go over to Persia to distribute the word of God and to preach the unsearchable riches of Christ to the benighted and deluded Persians, was the principal object of the mission. But as soon as the missionaries got more acquainted with the moral state of the Armenians, and found them, in the towns as well as in vil- lages, suuIl deeply into such a state of ignorance, that they had lost sight altogether of the grand and practical doctrines of the Grospel, and believed Christianity to consist merely in a few exter- nal rites, as fasting, making the cross, praying to the saints, and giving homage to their pictures, «S£c., the missionaries could no longer resist the impression, that it was their duty to attempt an amelioration of their deplorable state, by providing them with the means of getting better acquainted with the glorious and saving doctrines of the Gospel, as well as with their practical bearings. In this view, they were confirmed by the Armenians themselves* manv of whom, including several of the clergy, entreated them not to overlook them altogether, but as Christian brethren to sympathise with their low religious state, and great lack of Chris- tian knowledge, into which they had sunk by the oppression they suffered for several centuries from the Muhammadans, their former masters. They desired the missionaries to establish schools, not only for the Musalmans, but particularly for the instruction of their children. These circumstances induced the missionaries to lay the subject before their friends at home, together with a state, ineut of the necessity of erecting schools for the Armenians, as well ns of providing them with the necessary school-books, and with a number of scriptural tracts and religious books. This plan being approved by the home society, some of them devoted their time and strength to this work, and the others to labour amongst the Mu- hammadans. " It must be remarked that the Armenians, in the course of time, liave so much deviated from the old language, into which their pious and learned ancestors more than a thousand years ago translated THE ARMENIAN CHURCH. 103 tlie whole Bible, in which all their numerous religious and literary books have been written, and church serA^ice is still now performed, that it is now only understood by those who learn and study it ; and the common people, though they sometimes can read the gospel in the old language and hear it read in their churches every day, do not understand it. Before therefore the missionaries could do any thing, it was necessary, that the vernacular language should be- well studied, and its orthography and grammar fixed, that the New Testament and useful tracts and school-books might be translated into it. But here the missionaries had to struggle with greater dif- ficulties than they anticipated. The priests and the learned they found, with a few exceptions, greatly prejudiced against the idea of translating the Holy Gospel into such an unholy language as they believed their vernacular one to be, and viewed the attempt as an injurious innovation ; and the language itself was divided into so many dialects, that it was very diflicult to find out, which was the more common and the most proper for being reduced to writing, and introduced as the standard of good vernacular lan- guage. But through the Lord's gracious help, and merciful assist- ance, the missionaries were enabled to overcome all these difficul- ties, and succeeded in the course of some years, in translating, with the assistance of some able and pious Armenians, the New Testa- ment, the Psalms, a number of evangelical tracts, and some religious books into this language, and to prepare and print the necessary school-books. The greatest part of these books have been printed at their own press at Shustri. About a thousand copies of the New Testament, which only latelj^ left the press, together with about 40,000 tracts and school-books, have been distributed by them in the vernacular language amongst the Armenians in Georgia, and in the adjacent provinces of Persia and Turkey. Though the prejudice was at first very great against books in the vulgar tongue, yet it was soon overcome, and the people felt happily surprised to find that they could understand what they read, or was read to them, and began to value the great gain, and to anticipate the bless- ings which this innovation would, in time, bestovv upon their nation. The New Testament was eagerly sought for, and bought in most instances, and the tracts Avere, where bigoted and ignorant priests did not oppose, gladly received. Besides this, a number of schools in several towns and villages were established, and some young Armenians educated for schoolmasters. " The intercourse they had with them, when travelling among the Miihammadans preaching the gospel, has been in several instances the means of bringing their Armenian brethren to Christ, A re- markable instance of this kind was the conversion of a respectable 104 INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. Armenian merchant at Bakur. When two of the missionaries visited this town in 1828, the first time, he no sooner heard of their arrival and the object for which thev came, than he visited them, and ex- pressed his joy and his readiness to introduce them to his Muham- madan friends. As he was fond of religious conversation with the Muhammadans, he desired the missionaries to teach him, how to speak with them about Christ, and to instruct him how to an- swer their objections. This they gladly did, but when they began to speak with him also about the salvation of his own soul, he said, he wanted now only to know how to convert the Musalmans ; about his own soul they might leave him at peace. Yet as they were much interested in him, they felt it the more their duty to shew him the necessity, above all, of first seeking his own salvation and the kingdom of heaven. In this state they left him ; but a few weeks after, when they returned to the town, they were happily sur- prised at finding them (juite altered, and so anxious about his own salvation, that the whole desire of his heart was now to know how to become a partaker of all the merits and righteousness of Christ» and how to make sure his share in it. lie now sat down with them for some hours every day to read the gospel and have it explained to him, and to mark out all the passages regarding our redemption through Christ. After two years, when they saw him again, they found him truly converted to the Lord, full of grace and unction, overflowing with love to his Saviour, and with a warm desire to glorify Him, and to bring by a holy walk and conversation Arme- nians and Muhammadans to the saving knowledge of Christ. They could not help marvelling at the work of grace, which was visible in him, and gave him gladly the right hand of brotherly fellowship in Christ. And till now he continues to walk worthy of the gospel of Christ, and to be a light and blessing to those around him. Like hira in other places several Armenians have been brought to a concern about their own souls, when they heard and saw the mis- sionaries inviting the Muhammadans around them to come and partake of the salvation of Christ ? Others, again, became in- terested about the truth by reading the tracts and the New Testa- ment printed and distributed by the missionaries, or by the in- struction they had received in their schools. In short, the attention of a great body of the Armenians of Georgia has been by these means turned to the gospel ; a concern about religion and a spirit of inquiry, quite unknown before, has been raised up, and religion has become again a subject of common conversation, whereas in former times religious conversation was believed to belong only to the learned and priests. Many begin now to see, that their church, as well as they themselves, in their life and practice, have gone far THE ARMENIAN CHURCH. 105 astray from the gospel. In one town of Georgia, called Schamochy or Shamachy, a body of from twenty to fifty Armenians, have for several years met together on the Lord's day for reading the gospel and prayer. They and others, though they did not separate from their church, yet renounced her errors and testify openly against them, standing by the evangelical principle, that in matters of re- ligion only what can be proved and established by the gospel is to be believed and regarded as binding, and nothing^more. Several of these awakened Armenians, in the town mentioned and at other places, are truly converted to the Lord, and dear and faithful Christians ; some of them have already gloriously entered into the joy of their Lord. " It will be expected, that the great enemy of God would not re- main an inactive looker on at this glorious work, which begun among the Armenians with so promising an aspect ; and so it was. Though many of the Armenian priests, and even some of the higher clergy, expressed their satisfaction to the missionaries, and encouraged them to go on in their endeavours for the good of their nation, yet no sooner the fruit of their labours began to spring up, than the priesthood, fearing the light which was spreading, would at last rflake it no longer possible for them, to hide their ignorance and to conceal their evil doings ; and that they would ultimately lose their influence and gain, which is founded on the ignorance of people and the errors of their church, became violent enemies of the missionaries, and used all their influence to persuade the people, not to read the books of the missionaries, nor send their children to their schools. The Patriarch of the Armenians who resides at Etschmiajin, went even so far, as to send about his emis- saries against them, and to excommunicate those who kept a friendly intercourse with them, or sent their children to their schools. Two deacons who came to the missionaries to be instructed in theology, and who were by their means truly converted to the Lord, and greatly assisted them in their work, were taken away from them^ by force, on the ground of being the inmates of an Armenian mo- nastery, and because they refused to return when the superior or- dered them back. One of them died in faith on the road, and the other was, as there is every reason to believe, poisoned in the mo- nastery, because they could not make him renounce his evangelical principles. " In the first instance, this opposition having made some impres- sion, frightened many, and interrupted for a little while the schools and labours of the missionaries ; but the people soon recovered from their terror, and the missionaries could go on as before. But when the Armenian clergy found so many of their nation in favour of 106 INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. missionaries and evangelical principles, and felt that their power TiTould not be strong enough to prevent the progress of the gospel and to stop the labour of the missionaries, they applied for aid to the Russian Government. With a view to obtain it, they brought many false accusations against the missionaries before government, alleging that their real object was not the conversion of the Mu.ham- madans, biit to destroy the peace of their church, and to entice the Armenians over to the Lutheran confession, adding that they had already turned a great number of their flocks to the Lutherans ; and begged government to protect their church against such un- lawful inroads. As it was never the object of the missionaries to create dissensions and separations in the Armenian church, nor to bring her members over to the Lutheran, but merely to bring, through the blessing from on high, a new life into the dead body of the Armenian church, and consequently they actualbf dissuaded the converted Armenians from leaving their church, telling them, that according to their opinion, they should remain in her, as long as they were not expelled ; therefore it was not difficult for the missionaries to prove the falsehood of those accusations, and to point out the real sources of them. Yet the Patriarch, joined by the members of the Synod, which is the highest ecclesiastical body in the Armenian church, continued to use all possible means to set the minds of those persons of influence against the missionaries, and to create suspicions of the sincerity of their object, and the usefulness of their labours. For some time their endeavours were in vain, as the minister of the interior at Petorsburgh, under whose protection and inspection the missionaries stood, felt convinced of their sincerity, and was in favour of their labours ; but when the Armenian clergy found the views of the present Governor General of Georgia unfavourable to Protestant missionary labour, they easily succeeded in inducing him to use all his influence, that their labours might be stopped altogether. This he did, and though several of those of high influence at the court at Petersburg!! used their endeavours to overrule these evil machinations, yet at last the Governor succeeded in bringing the greater part of His Ma- jesty's privy counsellors over to his views. Consequently, an or- der was passed, and brought before the Emperor, and signed by him and sent to the missionaries, September 1835, which prohibited them from every kind of missionary labour. It appeared from thi6 order, that it was not so much on account of the accusations of the Patriarch of the Armenians, the falsehood of which must have been well known to government, that their labours were prohibited, but more because the Russian clergy declared, or were induced to THE ARMENIAX CHURCH. 107 declare, that they wished to send their own missionaries to Georgia, and that therefore, there would be no need any longer for foreign ones, and secondly, that the government suspected, that as foreign- ers the missionaries might spread political principles opposed to those held by themselves. The missionaries thought it their duty, as a last attempt to preserve their labour, to send into the govern- ment at Petersburgh once more, a full and free representation of their labours, and of the principles on which they had acted, beg- ging the minister of the Interior to lay it before His Majesty the Emperor ; but as this was' not done, and they said that, at least for the present, no alteration of the order could be expected, they aban- doned their promising sphere of labour, adoring the mysterious ways of an all-wise Providence, which allowed the enemy to triumph over them, and apparently to destroy, what they have been build- ing up during a ten years' period of labour. " Though it may appear to the human, and unenlightened eye, as if their labour has been in vain, yet they are sure that it was not. That the Lord has blessed their endeavours, is clear from the statements mentioned above, and there is no doubt that a lasting blessing will flow from them. To give to a Christian nation the word of God in a language which the people can understand, to pro- vide it with a number of religious books, which lead the mind to take a practical and right view of the doctrines of the gospel, and instrumentally to kindle the fire of a new spiritual life in Christ in a number of individuals of that nation, however small this num- ber may be, and to excite in many others an interest to know and understand the truth, is, there can be no doubt, to originate a better and a new era for such a nation. Although the missionaries have now left their friends and brethren among the Armenians of Geor- gia to themselves, yet they feel assured that the Lord will carry on the work he has begun amongst them, and will make true, what one of their greatest enemies among the higher orders of the Arme- nian clergy uttered, who, when he was in Schamochy, whither he was gone to preach, and set the people against the missionaries, but finding that nobody would hear him, said in the anger of his perverted zeal : ' I see the Germans have kindled such a fire as will never be extinguished again.' The leaven is cast into the mass, and will in its time leaven it through. That the Lord is in our days preparing the Armenian Church, which he, for wise pur- poses, has kept for so many centuries in the midst of the Muham- madan nations, for a better religious state, this observation cannot escape any one, who is acquainted with the present state of the Armenians." 108 INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. Before the breaking up of the German mission in Georgia, that province, as well as the other provinces under Russia and Turkey, in which the Armenians re- side, was visited by the Rev. Messrs Smith and Dwiglit, who prosecuted their exertions among them with great judgment in behalf of the American Board of Commis- sioners for Foreign Missions. Permanent missionary stations have been formed, in consequence of their in- quiries, by the body they represented, at Trebizond and Erzerum, in the Turkish dominions, where the good work of evangelical reformation is proceeding. The American missions in Syria, Asia Minor, and Constantinople, as they bear upon the Armenioins, I shall briefly notice in connexion with my journey from India to this country. When at Cairo, I visited the Armenian bishop, along with Mr Walne the English Consul ; and was received by him with great kindness. He informed me that the Armenians in Egypt, now members of the Armenian church, to the exclusion of those who have become Papists, amount only to about 600 souls. He represented them as generally educated men, holding the most respectable situations, and dwelt much on the virtues of their head, Boghos Yusep, the prime minister and faithful servant of Muhammad Ali the Pasha, who was lately removed from this sublunary scene, regretting much that, owing to his absence in Alexandria, I should not have the pleasure of making his acquaintance. The bishop appeared one of the most intelligent orientals whom I have met, a most lively and cheerful person, and a professed foe of bigotry. " The differences among Christians," he remarked, " would be much lessened, if the Bible were viewed as the supreme authority. I myself am much of a Protestant." When he was shewino^ us his church and directing^ attention to THE ARMENIAN CHURCH. 109 its pictures and other pieces of furniture, and when I remarked that we had neither images nor altars in Scot- land ; and that we administered the Lord's Supper seated in a social form around a table, he added, " So did Christ and his apostles."* He lamented his ignorance of the original languages of Scripture. I presented him with a copy of the New Testament in the modern Armenian language, and with a couple of tracts, all printed in Cal- cutta. The language of the former, he commended for its intelligibility. He shewed us his library, containing a few scores of volumes, from the Armenian presses at Echmiadzin, Venice, and Constantinople, and told us that he regularly received the Armenian newspaper en- titled " The Dawn of Ararat," published at Smyrna, of which he had a few numbers beside him. In reply to my inquiries about the history of the Armenians in Egypt, he stated that, about 700 years ago, no fewer than 20,000 were introduced into the country as slaves, and that about a century later they were joined by considerable numbers of their countrymen. The descendants of these persons were gradually amalgamated with the Copts and Moslims. From the assumption of power by Muhammad Ali, the * The Armenian church at Cairo is small, but a most respectable erection, and fitted up in a tasteful manner. Like the other eccle- siastical edifices of the people to whom it belongs, it is destitute of forms or chairs, but carpets and cushions are spread on the floor for the accommodation of the worshippers, when they may wish to seat themselves according to the custom of the Orientals. Several ex- cellent chandeliers are suspended from the roof. It is well lighted from without, and is free from the gloom which characterizes most buildings, public and private, at Cairo. A candle is always kept burning near the altar, as a symbol of the illumination of the Holy Spirit, a sign not appointed for use by the New Testament, and which I have heard objected to by some Armenians them- selves. iiU IXD£PENDE^'T EASTERN CHURCHES. present Armenians date their immigration. A few of them, in the first instance, came as travelUng merchants ; and about twenty-five years ago they began to be joined by members of their famihes. At one time they were more numerous than they are at present, reckoning them- selves about 2000. They have two churches in Cairo, one at Marminah near Old Cairo, and one at Alexandria. Besides themselves there is a small body of Koman Ca- tholic Armenians in Egypt. The bishop introduced me to some of his clerical friends when I was with him ; and in return for my visit, he waited upon me at my lodg- ings, bringing Vv^ith him a letter which he wished me to carry to one of his young relatives at Constantinople, whom he asked me to take to Scotland for his educa- tion. Besides making the acquaintance of the bishop, I had the pleasure of meeting with Hekykian Bey, the most proficient of all the Egyptians sent by Muhammad Ali to Europe for their education. His shrewd master has marked his sense of his attainments by raising him to the rank of a noble, which he well deserves. He is a person of great ability ; but his views of religion have been considerably affected by his residence in France. The Armenians resident at Jerusalem, exclusive of the ecclesiastics, I found to be few in number. Having been recommended to the patriarch by the bishop of Cairo, I visited that dignitary at the Armenian convent, which is said to be the richest at Jerusalem, and which, judging from its appearance and extent, I should cer- tainly say is the greatest establishment of the kind in the holy city, — a striking memorial of the devotion of the Armenians to Jerusalem as a place of pilgrimage, their liberality of contribution, and their influence, even though destitute of political power, with the Muhammadan go- THE ARMENIAN CHURCH. Ill vernment, in the acquisition of property and privileges. The patriarch received me and my companions with great kindness ; but though we remained with him for a con- siderable time, our conversation with him was rather H- mited, owing to the circuitous manner in which it was con- ducted. Arabic not being understood by his interpreter, we had to get our questions translated into Turkish, and from Turkish into Armenian, and vice versa, before we could get an answer to our inquiries. He appeared to be treated with the highest honour by those M'ho ap= proached him, and was addressed in terms similar to those bestowed on majesty in the West. He declared his friendliness to missionary efforts for the conversion of the Jews. He invited us to take up our abode with him durino- our residence in Jerusalem : but we were unable to accept his invitation. His secretary shewed us all his buildings ; and when he pointed out the hall in v/hich the monks take their meals together, he directed our attention to a large liturgical volume from which passages are usual- ly read when they are engaged in eating. That intelligent priest seemed to regard the ruins of the " city of the Great King," which he shewed to us from the summits of the convent, with an interest and enthusiasm, exceed- ing any thing we had witnessed among either the Greek or Latin monks. We were sorry to observe the Ar- menian pilgrims in the gorgeous church of St James, and especially the women, doing reverence, by kissing, to all its distinct apartments and accessible objects, and pros- trating themselves before its altars and pictures. JMany of them had come from the most distant places that they might enjoy these imaginary privileges, and engage in these foolish and sinful ceremonies. The appearance of the church is much calculated to impose upon their senses. 112 INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. Its walls are covered with cloth of rich embroidery ; and the pnlpits, altars, and other fixtures are set with tortoise- shell and mother-of-pearl. Ancient tradition is appealed to, to add to its sacredness. It is alleged that it, or a small adjoining convent, contains the stone with which the sepulchre of our Lord was closed. Beside the large con- vent and church now noticed, the Armenians have a small nunnery in its neighbourhood called Ez-zeituni, and an- other convent outside the city, but also on Mount Zion, which they allege to be the house of Caiaphas, and where with all gravity they point out the spot where Peter de- nied his master, and the cock crew, and where was the prison of our Lord ! They have a chapel, or oratory, too, in the church of the Holy Sepulchre. It is sad in- deed to think that they publicly participate with the Greeks in the fraud of the holy fire. Their priests al- lege that they view the fire as not really miraculous, but merely emblematical of the descent of the Holy Spirit. They do not, however, undeceive their people as to the actual nature of the transaction. For a few years, indeed, they stood aloof from the Greek imposition ; but, owing •to the clamour of the people, they scrupled not again to give it their direct countenance. The two excellent Ame- rican missionaries at Jerusalem, Messrs Whiting and Lanneau, embrace every opportunity presented to them of aiding the circulation of the evangelical books and tracts preparedin the Armenian language by their breth- ren at Smyrna and Constantinople. The late Rev. Levi Parsons, the first Protestant missionary who entered Jerusalem,* with a view to permanent residence, was cor- dially received by the Armenians to whom he addressed * On the 17th January 1821. THE ARMENIAN CHURCH. 113 himself ; and the missionaries to this day acknowledge the comparative kindness of the sons of Haik to whom they have access. During my travels from Jerusalem to Beirut I was accompanied by several Armenians from Diarbeker. Not one of them was able to read. It appears that their countrymen in the quarter from which they come are very generally in a state of ignorance. At Damascus, I found the number of resident Armenians to be 190. The total number under the whole of that large pashalik, is under 3000. The American Mission at Beirut, which was first esta- bhshed in the year 1823, had its first fruits, as far as the assumption of an evangelical profession is concerned, among the Armenians. An Armenian archbishop, and a bishop, and a priest, appeared to profit much by the in- structions of Mr Goodell, while prosecuting his study of the Armeno-Turkish at Sidon. I am uncertain of the degree of satisfaction which they continued to give to the mission. Only few of their nation are within the in- fluence of the mission at Beirut. The Armenians at Smyrna have been frequently brought to notice by European travellers, who have given very contradictory accounts of the state of their com- munity. Letters which I had brought with me from India gave me ready access to them ; and I was much pleased to find their circumstances highly encouraging as far as the progress of education and social improve- ment, if not of religious inquiry, are concerned. Their numbers amount to about 4500 souls ; and ample provi- sion seems to be made for their general instruction. In the Mesrobian School, — in which the Armenian, ancient and modern Greek, Turkish, Italian, French, and English 114 INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. languages, as well as Arithmetic, Geography, and Ma- thematics, are taught, — there are 300 boys prosecuting their studies. The Sarkisian female school, — in which the Armenian and French lancruao;es and the different kinds of female work are taught, — is attended by about 200 girls. An extensive hospital has been founded for the sick of the community. An educational society has been formed for the diffusion of a simple, moral, and economical education, in the different villages of Asia Minor in which Armenians reside. Two presses are constantly employed. At one of these a weekly news- paper, entitled " The Dawn of Ararat," is pubhshed. This periodical, which is read in various countries of the world, is edited by Mr Lucas Balthazar, a devoted philanthropist, and a true friend of his kindred according to the flesh. The American Mission, through its press, too, is multiplying excellent Christian works to the fullest extent of its means, for distribution in various parts of the Turkish empire ; and the Rev. Mr Adger, and the Rev. Mr Rio'ss, zealous and able aQjents, are devoted to the work of the Lord among the Armenians. Mr Lewis, the excellent English chaplain, embraces opportunities also of doing them good. The American Mission at Constantinople, which was founded in 1831 by Mr Goodell, whom we have already noticed in connexion with the mission in Syria, has from its very commencement proved a great blessing to the numerous and influential Armenians of that great city. It has been the means, by the schools which it has in- stituted, the books which it has prepared and distributed, and the oral announcement of the Gospel in public and private, of exciting much serious inquiry, and producing salutary religious impressions among not a few Armenians. THE ARMENIAN CHURCH. 115 Of the success which it has experienced, and of its pre- sent wants, I think it my duty to take special notice, by laying before you the substance of two important letters which I have received from the missionaries since I had the pleasure of making their personal acquaintance. " You have been amongst us," says the Rev. H. G. 0. Dwight, "and have had some opportunity of judging from personal observation, of the extent and importance of the work of reform that is going on in the Armenian cliurch. That this work is the effect of the special opera- tions of the Holy Spirit, we have, what appears to us, the most satisfactory evidence. One circumstance in re- gard to it, is full of interest and promise, and that is, that, not only at the metropolis, but throughout the in- terior of the country also, wherever Armenians are found, there is also found a preparation of mind to re- nounce old errors, and to receive the truth in its sim- plicity and power. This is evidenced by the fact, that wherever missionaries have gone preaching the gospel, they have found among the Armenians an open ear, and in every place where continued efforts have been made, souls have been converted unto God ; and even in many places where no missionary's voice had been heard, by- means of the printed word, souls have been awakened, and some, we have every reason to believe, truly con- verted. I could relate many instances, in which in- dividuals far in the interior of the country have had their minds opened through means of a tract or book from our press, that fell into their hands ; and in some of these cases the awakening has extended from one to another, until a large number have been enlightened. In Nico- media, for example, a tract (the Dairyman's Daughter) and the New Testament v/ere left by a passing mission- 116 INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. ary in the hands of an Armenian. A priest got hold of the books, and was led by the perusal of them to the conclusion that he never had known what true religion is. He began to open his mind to a brother priest in the same church. And they soon became thoroughly convinced of the truth of evangelical religion, and we hope truly regenerated by the Spirit of God. As a natural consequence, they laboured for the salvation of the people of their charge, and now there are a number of praying souls in Nicomedia, and they sometimes meet for prayer, amidst scoffs and threats, to the number of sixty or seventy souls. A similar work has been car- ried on at Aderbazar by very similar means. Indeed, wherever our books have gone we have reason to be- lieve that some souls have been awakened. All this shews to us that the set time of the Lord to favour the Armenian people, has come. Similar labours have been performed among the Greeks, for a much longer period of time; but hitherto without any such result. We seem to be called upon by the special providence of God towards the Armenians, to arise and possess the whole land ; and yet, with all these encouraging prospects, we find ourselves greatly straitened for want of the re- quisite means for prosecuting the work. We are par- ticularly embarrassed in the printing department ; and it is with the hope that you may be able to induce some of the good people of Scotland to come forward and aid us in this time of our pressing need, that I proceed to lay before you a few statements in reference to this portion of our labours here."* * " We have already published between thirty and forty differ- ent books and tracts in the Armenian and Armeno- Turkish lan- guages; all of which, with the exception of three or four school THE ARMENIAN CHURCH. 11? " You will be glad," says the Rev. H. A. Homes, *' of a word or two about the Armenians. The work is makino' o-radual progress, and in a manner that we can definitely see it. We hear of new cases of awakening in different parts of the city, even if a long time passes before we can see the individuals themselves. There has been a new and interesting developement in the interest taken by the female portion of this community, from whom, owing to the Asiatic prejudices of society, books, are decidedly religious and evangelical works. Among these are the whole Old and New Testaments in Armeno-Turkish, and the New Testament and book of Psalms in modern Armenian ; and the whole Old Testament is now in the process of translation into the Armenian language. Twelve of our books are now out of print ; and we have no means of reprinting them, and at the present rate of printing and distribution, our shelves must ere long be emptied, and we know not how they can be replenished. Besides the Old Testament already alluded to, the following works are in a state of preparation for the press, or are actually prepared, and yet we have no means of printing them. 1. An abridgement of D'Aubigne's History of the Reformation. 2. A Book of Prayer. 3. A Reference Testament. 4. An original Essay on the Character and Office of the Holy Spirit. 5. A Text of Scripture and Medita- tion for every day in the year. 6. Wayland's Moral Science. 7. Two or three Sermons. 8. Gallaudet on Natural Theology. 9. Abbot's Young Christian. 10. A volume of short Narrative Tracts. 11. On Reading the Sacred Scriptures. 12. Lives of the Prophets. The first seven of these are in the modern Armenian language, and the last five in the Armeno-Turkish. I may also state, that we published for four years, a monthly magazine in Armenian, which proved to be very useful, though we have been compelled to suspend it from want of funds. * * * I would state in closing this communication, that the number of Armenian and Armeno-Turkish books distributed last year from Constanti- nople alone, was nearly 12,000 copies ; and it must be remembered that there are also four other missionary stations of our Board in Turkey, from which our books are also distributed. Many of these books are sold, and in fact the comparative amount of gratuitous distribution is becoming less every year. 118 INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. we have been much separated.* In two or three casep, numbers have come on purpose to hear the gospel preached, and arrangements have been made at their own request to have regular preaching to them in two different places, and this in addition to the places already established for preaching to men. Our schoolf is fill- ing up with pious young men, who will, we hope, here- after be a blessing to their nation. An evangelical priest was lately cast into prison by the patriarch, on the charge of having preached infidelity in the interior, and was called upon to sign a paper retracting all his errors. He declared that he aimed to preach nothing but the truth as it is in Jesus, and that they might cut off his head as the Musalmans had lately cut off the head of an Armenian, but that it would be useless to ask him to sign a paper, no more to preach what he believed to be true. We praise God that he was enabled to witness a good testimony, and as the reward thereof so soon to receive his liberty. We know of a dozen towns in Asia Minor where are to be found pious Armenians ; and in many of these places they meet for the study of * In the clixirches of the Armenians, as in the Jewish synagogues, the females are uniformly k ept apart from the males, being generally crowded into a small receding gallery, or orchestra, separated by lattice-work from the body of the building. •j- This is a boarding-school, principally for Armenian youth, at Babek, a small village on the European side of the Bosphorus. It is under the assiduous superintendence of one of the missionaries, the Rev, Mr Hamlin, formerly assistant to the celebrated Dr Pay- son. I had the pleasure of attending an examination of it during my visit to Constantinople, and witnessing the progress of the pu- pils both in sacred and secular knowledge. The relative of the Armenian Bishop of Cairo, whom he wished me to take to this country, is attending this school, where every attention is paid to his improvement. THE ARMENIAN CHURCH. 119 the scriptures, which they take as their only rule of faith and practice. This is the Lord's doing and it is mar- vellous in our eyes." Those who seriously reflect on the degraded state of the Armenian church, will be most readily disposed to appreciate this great work of divine grace, and to seek to forward it by their contributions and their prayers. When I was with the American missionaries at Con- stantinople, I promised to endeavour to procure in this country the means of printing a translation into the Ar- menian language of the Assembly's Shorter Catechism with the Scripture proofs, and of the excellent pamphlet on the Culture of the Mind of the late eminent physi- cian and universal philanthropist Dr Abercrombie, pro- vided they would kindly effect a translation of these small but important works. Both of them, I am happy to say, have been lately published, the latter at the sole expense of the author of the English original, who ap- peared to take the greatest interest in the work of the Christian enlightenment of the Armenians, when it was brouorlit to his notice. I wish that we could ofive exten- sive assistance to our American brethren in their opera- tions connected with the press, and that they could tell the Armenians that many Christians beside those of the yeni-dunid, or new world, feel a deep and growing inte- rest in their spiritual welfare. Ill, THE SYRIAN CHURCH. The great body of the members of this church is now found in Mesopotamia, particularly in the neighbour- hood of Mousul and Mardm, where their hio-hest eccle- fiiastical functionary, the " patriarch of Antioch" as he 120 INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. is denominated, at present resides.* In this part of the world, their population probably amounts to about 150,000 souls. In the pashalik of Aleppo, and chiefly in that city and in Antioch, they number probably about 2000 souls. In Damascus they have only a few faniihes. There are very few, if any, of them to be found in Leba- non ; and in the southern parts of the Holy Land, in- cluding Jerusalem, where they have a bishop and a mo- nastic establishment, they probably do not exceed a hun- dred or two. t In the provinces of ^Malabar and Tra- vankur in India, their numbers, by the persecutions and frauds of the Roman Catholics, have been considerably reduced. Those who remain independent of Rome, in a letter to their brethren of Mesopotamia, stated their numbers a few years ago at 11,972 families, having forty-five churches and a half. In the government cen- sus of Travankur of 1836, they are given at 118,382 souls, the Romo- Syrians being, in addition to this num- ber, 56,184 souls. * The patriarchs profess to trace their ecclesiastical descent from Peter the Apostle, " patriarch of Antioch." Besides their own name, they now take that of Ignatius, from that of the " third patriarch of Antioch." Dr Wolff gives a list of the patriarchs from the Syrian archives in the second volume of his Journal. This missionary met the Syrian patriarch at Damascus, at which place he was on a visit, in 1834. One of the bishops, on that occa- sion, said of the patriarch, " This is our Pope !" The patriarch replied, " AVe must not say we are of Paul or Apollos." ■f Robinson and Smith (Biblical Researches, vol. iii. p. 461) say, " The number of the Jacobites (Syrians) in Syria is very small. A few families in Damascus and in Nebk,the village of Sudud [Zedad of Scripture], and a part of the village of Kuryetein, a small com- munity in Hums, with a few scattered individuals in two or three neighbouring villages, a similar community in Hamah, g-nd pro- bably a smaller one in Aleppo, constitute nearly or quite the amount of the sect." THE SYRIAN CHURCH. 121 The Syrian Christians call themselves Jacobites. When interroo"ated as to the reason of their appropria- tion of this denomination, they generally allege that they are the descendants of Jacob or Israel ; that they are the descendants of the earhest converts of the apostle James, and that they are the adherents of the monk Bardai,* Jacob Baradseus or Baradat, who died bishop of Orfa (Edessa) in Mesopotamia in the year 558, and who, during his active career, was so successful in reunit- ing the monophysite sects throughout the whole of the east. The Syrian Christians use the Syriac language in their church services, even though with most of them it has become obsolete. They communicate very little instruc- tion, and offer up almost no prayers, through the me- dium of Arabic, or any other language that may be ver- nacular to them in the parts of the world in which they sojourn. The church authorities to which they look may be ascertained from the following passage which occurs in their liturgy for the mass : — " Again, we remember those of the saints who excelled in holiness, died, and were comforted ; and who preserved, handed down, and taught us an apostolical and spotless faith. We openly acknowledge the three holy, pure, and Catholic Councils of Nice, Constantinople, and Ephesus, in which were our fathers, holy, exalted, and God-fearing Malpans. We remember holy James, the head of the Metrans,t * This is the Arabic form of the name. In Syriac, it is Fasselita. " Bardai appelhitus est quod ei araictus erat, e segminibus Alba- radai sen dorsualium qiite jumentis insterni solent consutis." — Eutych. torn, ii, p. 147, in Renaudot. Liturg. Orient. Collect, torn. ii. p. 342. f Metran literally means metropolitan. Among the eastern churches, however, it is used as synonymous with bishop. 122 INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. and the first in Jerusalem, an apostle and martyr : Ig- natius, Clemens, Dionysius * Athanasius, Julius, Basil, Gregory, Dioscorus, Timothy, Philoxenus, Antonius, Evanius, and particularly our father Cyril, who was a lofty and true wall, and the professor who openly ac- knowledged the manhood of the Son of God. We re- member our Patriarch Severus,"f the crown of the Sy- rians, a skilful orator, a pillar and doctor of all the holy churches of God, and our holy father St James (Jacob Baradseus), the precursor of the true faith : holy Eph- raim our master, St James,J St Barsumas, the head of the mourners, St Simeon the Stylite, the chosen St Abeia, and those who, either before or after them, left, handed down, or taught us a right and pure faith. May their prayers be our wall. Lord have mercy upon us !"§ This passage, which is pregnant with meaning to the student of ecclesiastical history, puts an end to the many conjectures which have been formed respecting the creed of the Syrian church. It is to be observed that it makes no mention of Eutyches himself, who is alleged to have maintained that " the divine nature of Christ had absorbed the human, and that consequently in him there was but one nature, viz. the divine ;" while * Dionysius the Great, bishop of Alexandria in the third cen- tury. t Of Antioch. * Of Nisibin ? The Syrians have so many persons of this name, that it is diflBcult to identify the person here referred to. § MS. translation of the Syrian Mass-Book in the possession of the Rev. .1. C. Thompson of Qiiilon. This document, translated, I believe, directly from the Syriac, I find to be fuller than the Ordo Cotmnunis Liturgioe secundum ritum Syrorum Jacobitarum, in the Liturgiarum Orientalium Collectio of Renaudot. This author, however, gives in a note (torn. ii. p. 103) a longer list of Syrian doctors than that set forth in this commemoration. THE SYRIAN CHURCH. 123 it mentions with reverence some of the principal sup- porters of the alhed sect of monophysites, who taught that " the divine and human nature of Christ were so united as to form only one nature ; yet without any chano-e, confusion, or mixture of the two natures." The name of Barsumas, the famous Nestorian, too, finds a place. Before its impregnation with monophysitism, the Syrian church was doubtless much under the influence of the followers of the ill-used and much misrepresented Nestorius, as well as extended by them, in the exercise of their most commendable missionary zeal, to India and other distant countries. The ministers of the Sy- rian church whom I have met in the east have generally expressed themselves in a manner not very inconsistent with orthodoxy. The union of the natures of Christ is so complete, they have said, that there is unity in these natures. The Godhead and manhood of Christ, however, being unchanged, there is still duality. To our expla- nation, — the unity is that of oneness of person, while the two nature sare still distinct, — they generally, in the end, have not objected. Except perhaps in the case of Euty- ches, with whom the Syrians indignantly disclaim all connection, the Christian church was divided by little more than a logomachy respecting the nature of Christ in the fifth century. The liturgical works of the Syrian church, as far as I have been able to inspect them, appear to present a con- siderable amount of evangelical doctrine and supplication addressed directly to the Saviour. They are far, however, from being free from the most dangerous errors. In fact, we can see in them most of the falsities which we have pointed out in connexion with the Armenian church, such as the worship of the saints, particularly " Holy 124 IXDEPENDENT EASTERX CHURCHES. Mary, the Mother of God," and John the Baptist, the constant intercessors with the Saviour in behalf of those who call upon their names, and who make odoriferous incense ascend to their delectification, and the first of whom is addressed in the most blasphemous language ;* the doctrine of baptismal regeneration ;t the transub- stantiation of the elements of bread and wine used in the Lord's Supper into the real body and blood of Christ, and the presenting them as a real sacrifice to God, both for * Let the following suffice as an example : — "0 beautiful virgin, the mother of our Saviour Jesus Christ, who by his saving mani- festation removed from us the darkness of sin and the error of de- struction, what tongue is sufficient to speak thy exaltation ? We know that thou art the spring of life, the fountain of salvation, the blessed ground and ladder that leadeth to heaven. Therefore, thou fleshly chariot, in which the Lord of angels dwelt, blessed art thou : thou the burning bush in which the ark of the highest was seen, blessed art thou : We marvel at thee : O thou who art full of goodness, pray with us now to thy Son, who sprang from thee, that in his grace and mercy, he may blot out our sins and trans- gressions, and make us and our dead fit for the house in Jerusalem, and for Abraham's bosom." Syrian Mass Liturgy. t In the second book of the Codex LiturgicusEcclesia? Universae of Joseph Aloysius Assemanus, there are given three forms of baptism according to the ritual of the Syrians. In each of these the literal descent of the Holy Spirit into the waters of baptism is invoked ; and the Holy Spirit is represented as regenerating the soul by the waters of baptism. According to these forms, the face of the child is to be turned toward the East in the Bapistry, and a triple affu- sion of water to be made with the left hand of the priest at the pronunciation of the name of each of the persons of the Trinity. The rubricks directing the celebration of the rite superadd, parti- cularly in connection with the anointing of the body, a concomitant of baptism in the Syrian Church, various other unscriptural cere- monies to which the greatest importance is attached. Tom. ii. p'p. 211, et seq. The rite of confirmation follows that of Baptism and Chrism, after the expiry of seven days. Tom. Hi. p. 191. THE SYRIAN CHURCH. 125 the dead and living who profess the true faith ;* prayers for the dead, that they may be delivered from depriva- tions and chastisements rendered necessary by their im- perfections and sins ; and the exaltation of the priest to the work of Christ himself in forgiving sins and dispens- ing judgment. Connected with this latter subject, the following strano;e exhortation occurs in the mass- book : — " God has given to men two dominions ; one to the king, the other to the priest. God has given the chief place on earth to the king, and the sure dominion over the living in the judgment to the priest. The Lord has not given power to the king to take the censer ; the priest has no power to use the sword against the king. The king is the ruler to rule in civil affairs ; the priest is the ruler to sanctify souls. The king has only power to kill the body ; but the priest has power by his curses to de- stroy both soul and body. The prayer of him who is cursed is not received upon earth, and his supplications y/ill not be accepted before God. He who is cursed has no right to enter into the church to receive the body and blood of the Son of God. He who is cursed is like a vine branch which being smitten by hail, and stripped of its beauty, is only fit to be consumed. He who is cursed is like an ear of corn blasted by a hot wind, which lies stript of its splendour amidst the standing corn. He who is cursed is like the day which the Lord cursed, and which cannot be reckoned amongst the number of the days of the year. He who is cursed is hke a dried river that is the sport of rivers and seas." This undue ex- * The Syrians use leavened bread in dispensing the Lord's Sup- per. The priest alone drinks of the cup ; but he dips the cake, with the cross and sections corrresponding with the twelve apostles imprinted upon it, in the wine, before handing it to the people. 126 INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. altation of God's minister seems to be common to Anti- christ in all the forms which he assumes. The Syrians, like the Armenians, have a superstitious belief in the power of the material cross, and in the sign of the cross. The fasts of the Syrians are numerous and rigid. One of the deacons at Kuselli said to Dr Wolff, " Our fast-days are to many a Syrian too strict; for seven months in the year we are neither allowed to eat meat, nor fish, nor eggs ; we can eat nothing else but herbs. But the Catholics allow to eat meat, to use oil, to eat fishes, and with this many Syrians are pleased and turn Catholics." On this Dr Wolff observes, " It is indeed sorrowful to consider that on the one side the Syrians believe to con- quer and gain heaven by eating nothing but herbs and sour crout, and on the other hand, that the Catholics are so cunning to get soldiers by giving to the Syrians Italian macaroni and roast beef."* Rome knows well how to bind and loose burdens upon the shoulders of the ignorant, to suit her own purposes. The monastic institu- tion is of high repute among the Syrians as among all the orientals, who associate with it pre-eminent personal sanctity. The first branch of the Syrian Church which was brought under the notice of our countrymen in later times, is that which is found among the mountains of Malayalim in India. It was visited by the devoted and ardent-minded Dr Claudius Buchanan in the year 1806, who published a striking, but in some particulars an inaccurate, account of it in his interesting Christian Ke- searches. His attractive narrative induced the Church * Wolff's Journal, vol. iii. p. 2U. THE SYRIAN CHURCH. 127 of England Missionary Society to direct its attention to the people of whom it treats, and to form amongst them an extensive mission, occupying two or three stations, which has now for many years enjoyed the services of able and pious agents. The establishment of a college at Kottayam, for the instruction of candidates for the ministry in the Syrian church, and which, through the kind offices of Major- General Monro, the Resident of Travankur, now an influential elder of our own church, received a large endowment in land from the Rani of that country, formed a part of the plan of the missionaries. At first it was thought practicable to conduct their opera- tions, so as to preserve the integrity and authority of the Syrian church ; but experience has shewn the necessity of receiving parties disposed to leave its community for the enjoyment of a purer docti"ine and discipline, into the English Church. The excellent missionaries of the London Missionary Society at Quilon have likewise to some extent sought the good of the Syrians. Dr Wolff, in the course of his journeys, distributed many copies of the Scriptures among the Syrians of Me- sopotamia. I am not aware that any regular provision has yet been made for reviving amongst them the power of evangelical religion by any of the British or American churches, though I believe something has been in con- templation in their behalf. Their own necessities, their great poverty and depression, their position in the very centre of the empire of Muhammadism, and the jeo- pardy in which they stand from the agents of Rome, should attract for them, without delay, our prayerful and practical beneficence. 128 INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. IV. THE NESTORIAN CHURCH. As far as^ original conversion to Christianity is con- cerned, this church is closely allied to that which we have now noticed. It is evidently a branch of the Sy- rian church, as is proved by its traditions and ecclesias- tical language, which is the ancient Syriac, and by the language vernacular among its members, which is a dia- lect formed from this ancient Syriac, but somewhat in- termixed with Persian, Kurdish, and Turkish. Its lo- cality is the mountains of Kurdistan and the valley of Uramiah, intermediate between Persia and Turkey, and between the 36'^ and 39" of north latitude, and 43*^ and 46'^ of east longitude. The number of its adherents has been estimated by the American missionaries at about 140,000 souls, of whom fifty thousand are resident, in a state of independence, in the mountainous district of Tiari, sixty thousand in the other mountainous districts, and from about thirty to forty thousand in the province of Uramiah.* Dr Wolff estimates them at a quarter of a million. The designation Nestorian, as applied to a branch of the Church of Christ, is derived from Nestorius, a Sy- rian, bishop of Constantinople, who has been branded as a heretic, but who was probably sounder in the faith and more disting-uished for piety than his assailants and persecutors. In refusing to give to the Virgin the epi- thet of ©soroxoj, or " Mother of God," he did not act * See a Residence of Eiglit Years in Persia among the Nestorian Christians, with Notices of the Muhammadans. By the Rev. Justin Perkins. Andover, 1813. This is a work well worthy of republi- cation in this country. THE NESTORIAN CHURCH. 129 otherwise than we ourselves should do at the present day. The charge that was brought against him at the third general council of Ephesus, a. d. 431, by which his tenets were condemned, that he taught that Christ has two distinct persons as well as two natures, he him- self denied to the very last, as is proved by his letters, published by Joseph Simeon Assemanus.* The harsh treatment which he received from Cyril and his other opponents, who hurled their anathemas against him, and succeeded in effecting his banishment, awakened much sympathy in his behalf throughout the whole bounds of the Syrian church, and his ardour and abilities procured for him many followers. John, patriarch of Antioch, befriended his cause ; but Barsumas was its greatest champion, and contributed perhaps more than Nestorius himself to give form to the doctrines which bore his name, and which fell short of the scripture doctrine of the union of the divine and human natures of Christ, only as they represent it as merely a union of will and affection. From the famous school of Nisibin, which Barsumas founded on his being appointed bishop of that See, there went forth the zealous missionaries who pro- pagated Christianity in Persia, Arabia, Tartary, China, India, and other distant countries. The doctrines ot Barsumas were dominant in the east till the monophy- site controversy arose, and divided the Syrian church. While the Byzantine emperors persecuted the Nesto- * Biblioth. Oriental. Clement. Vatican, torn. iii. p. 192. &c. In one of his letters to Cyril, he says, " I approve that you preach a distinction of natures, in respect to the divinity and humanity, and a conjunction of them in one person." To another bishop, he says, " Of the two natures, there is one authority, one virtue, one power, and one person, according to one dignity." K 130 INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. rians, they persuaded Firuz the Zoroastrian king of Persia, to give them a refuge. They were so numerous and influential at the close of the fifth century, that they appointed one of their number to the archbishopric of Seleucia, on its becoming vacant, who became the acknowledged head of the Christians of Persia, and of the Nestorians in the different countries of their Chris- tian enterprize.* The Kurdistan Christians, of whom we are now treating, are the remains of these Christians, exclusive of those connected with Armenia, and those who have from time to time been brought within the pale of the Church of Rome. They themselves, it is to be borne in mind, dislike being called Nestorians, as the following extract from the journal of the Rev. Justin Perkins sufficiently shews : — *' In conversation, Mar Jo- hannan objected to my calling him and his people Nes- torians. I asked him what I should call them, and he answered Chaldeans. I inquired whether the Catholic Nestorians are not called Chaldeans. He acknowledged * Asseman (Biblioth. Orient, vol. iv.) gives very interesting de- tails connected with the extension of the Nestorians. Of these the Rev. Eli Smith gives the following precis. " Besides occupy- ing, almost to the exclusion of all other Christians, the region which forms the modem kingdom of Persia ; they were, on the one side, numerous in Mesopotamia and Arabia, had their metropolitans in Syria and Cyprus, and a bishop even in the island of Socotra, at the mouth of the Red Sea ; and on the other, the Syrian Christians of Malabar were Nestorians, and received their bishops from Seleu- cia. [This was in the first instance. They afterwards received them from the Jacobite patriarch of Antioch.] Nestorian churches existed in Transoxiana as far as Kashgar ; in the distant regions of Mongolia, the great Khan of the Tartars held the r?.nk of Pres- byter in the Nestorian Church ; and, if we may credit a monument subsequently discovered by papal priests, Nestorian missionaries planted churches in the heart of Northern China." Smith and Dwight's Researches, pp. 364, 365. THE NESTORIAN CHURCH. 131 that they are, but added, ' Shall a few CathoHc converts from our people arrogate to themselves the name of the whole nation ? And must we surrender up our name to them ? Nestorius we do indeed respect, as one of our bishops ; but our nation are under no particular obliga- tion to be called by his name, and no reason exists why we should cease to be called Chaldeans.' '"^ The people usually call themselves Syriani (Syrians), and less often Nazrani (Nazarenes). A great deal of most valuable information is given concerning the Nestorians in the second and third vo- lumes of the Journal of Dr Joseph Wolff, who was the first in late times to brino- them to the notice of British o and American Christians. He had several interviews with some of their members, and he received interesting notices of them from Major Monteith of the Madras Army, whom he met at Tabriz, where he had been for some time residing. " The great body of Nestorian christians," says this officer, " quitted the Greek and Koman empire under the reign of Justinian, and sought protection from Nausherwan, king of Persia.f who as- signed them a residence at Oromea, Maroga, Salmas, and Bashgela. They formed four congregations, headed by four bishops, of whom Mar Shimaun was the princi- pal, whose family has ever since maintained the sove- reignty over these tribes. They originally amounted to fifty thousand families, and at one time exerted a very great influence in the empire of Persia. t At different * Residence, p. 105. t At present the Nestorian patriarch resides at Diz, a village in the Hakari district. J I have represented them above, on the authority of Asse- man, as first obtaining protection from Firuz, who preceded 132 INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. times they have experienced a very severe persecutioD, and under the Muhammadan government have been driven from their original residences into their present impregnable abode in the mountains of Curdistan. From what observations I was able to make, the worship of the Nestorian Christians approaches the nearest to the original purity of Christianity of any church in the world. They are totally free from the idolatry of the Popish churches ; neither images, saints, nor relics, are admitted to their worship. They even regard the apostles, though inspired, as not being objects of adora- tion.""^ The Rev. Messrs Smith and Dwight, who visited them in their exploratory tour, though they do not go so far in praise of them as this gentleman, still present a favourable view of them, as contrasted with the other oriental Christians ; and so does Dr Grant, in his work, which is so well known both in this country and America. Mr Perkins, the father of the American mission sent to their aid, and who has had better opportu- nities of knowing their circumstances than any other Nausherwan about a century. It was in the reign of Firuz that they most needed protection, as the persecution of the Nesto- rians was then most violent. It probably became a matter of po- licy with him and his successors to grant them countenance, Re- naudot thus writes of them, on the authority of Cedrenes : " Sunt autem illi Syrorum veterum Christianorum reliquiae, qui post damnatum in Ephesino Synodo Nestorium, pulsi legibns Romanis, et quodammodo proscripti, in Mesopotamiam se receperunt, quse a Persarum regibus sa^pius armis occupata, tutum exulibus asylum prtebuit : pra>sertim cum Cosroes, quern vulgo Nuschiruanum vo- cant, illis faveret impensius ; adeo ut ecclesiam Edessenam ipsis attribuerit ex qua ab Heraclio dejecti sunt : reliquos etiam Chris- tianos ad eorum hseresin amplectandam cogerent, quantum in illo erat." — Dissertatio de Nestorian. Liturg. p 2. * Wolff's Journal, vol. iii. pp. 193, 194, THE NESTORIAN CHURCH. 133 individual, gives a most encouraging view of their tenets and observances. " The rehgious behef and practices of the Nestorians," he says, " are much more simple and scriptural than those of other oriental Christians. They have the deepest abhorrence of all image-worship, auri- cular confession, the doctrine of purgatory, and many other corrupt dogmas and practices of the Papal, Greek, and Armenian churches ; while they cherish the highest reverence for the holy scriptures, and, in theory at least, exalt them far above all human traditions. Their doc- trinal tenets, so far as I have learned them, are in ge- neral quite clearly expressed and correct. On the mo- mentous subject of the Divinity of Christ, in relation to which the charge of heresy is so violently thrown upon them by the papal and other oriental sects, their belief is orthodox and scriptural. The Nestorians are very charitable towards other sects of nominal Christians, libe- ral in their views and feehngs, and strongly desirous of improvement. The patriarch has repeatedly written to us expressing his joy and satisfaction at our being among his people, his gratitude for our efforts for their benefit, and his earnest prayers for our prosperity. And such has been the language, and, apparently, the feelings of all classes of his people. The four bishops of Uramiah and several of the most intelligent priests, are in our em- ploy as assistants in our missionary labours. They are engaged in the instruction and superintendence of schools and sabbath schools ; they preach the gospel, engage in translation, and render other important assistance. And the patriarch and his brothers have often pledged to us the same co-operation, whenever we should be enabled to extend our labours into the mountains. Indeed, the Nestorians may, with great propriety, be denominated 134 INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. the Protestants of Asia.' ^'^ To this I must myself add, however, that if the Nestorian hturgies, translated by Renaudotjt be now in use among the Nestorians, they view the Lord's Supper as more that a commemorative and confirmative ordinance, as the presenting of a sacri- ficial off'erina: to God, the bread and wine becoming; the real body of Christ- The Nestorians have nine ecclesiastical orders among their clergy ; but two or three of them are at present little more than nominal. They are those of sub-deacon, reader, deacon, priest, archdeacon, bishop, metropolitan, catholicos, and patriarch. All below bishop are permitted at any time to marry, according to their pleasure. The word Bishop does not occur in the Syriac Testament, Kashisha, elder, being employed where it is used in the English translation ; but Episcopa, transferred from the Greek, is the ecclesiastical title in common use. The wish of the people is generally understood and consulted in the appointment of a bishop ; but his consecration de- pends on the patriarch. A candidate for the office, according to a strange custom, must abstain from the use of animal food except fish, eggs, and the productions of the dairy ; and his mother must observe the same ab- stinence while she nurses him at the breast. The patri- arch officially has only spiritual power, but, in point of fact, he exercises a great deal of secular influence among his people. Mr Perkins, whose favourable account of the Nestor- ians I have just quoted, says, " The Nestorians are still * Perkins's Residence, pp. 20, 21. t Liturg. Orient. Coll. p. 566, et seq. torn. ii. The liturgies of the Nestorians are in the ancient Syriac, and understood only by the priests. TKE NESTORIAN CHURCH. 135 to a painful extent under the influence of human, and many childish traditions. They attach great importance to their periodical /asi^, which are about as numerous as in the other eastern churches, often to the neglect of in- tegrity and purity of heart, and even of external mo- rality. As a people, they are deeply degraded in morals. The vice of lying is almost universal among both eccle- siastics and people. Intemperance is very prevalent. The Sabbath is, to a great extent, regarded as a holiday. And profaneness and some other vices are very common. Indeed, the mass of this people seem literally to have a name to live while they are dead."* It is on account of this degradation, and the want of that vigorous evange- lical teaching and spiritual life in which it originates, that they have need of our help, so that the things which re- main may be strengthened. It is much to the credit of the American Board of Commissioners for Foreign Missions, that it has founded a mission among this interesting people, with a branch i-n the district of Uramiah subject to Persia, and another among the independent mountaineers. By the transla- tion of the Scriptures into the vulgar tongue, the com- position of tracts, the institution of schools, and the preaching of the gospel, in all which endeavours it has enjoyed the co-operation of the native clergy, it has done much toward their spiritual improvement. The incur- sions of the Kurds into the hill districts, attended by the cruel massacre of some 4000 Nestorians, has done much to impede the good work which has been going on. Jesuit, and other Boman Catholic influence, and the evil suggestions of Bussian agents, I am grieved to in- timate, have procured an order from the Persian go- * Residence among the Nestorians, pp. 21, 22. 136 INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. vernment requiring the missionaries to leave Uramiah . They have gone to the court of the Shah to endeavour to procure its reversal ; and that God may grant them success must be our most fervent prayer. It will be sad indeed if our hopes of the revival of evangelical re- ligion, among the small remnant who for centuries have been so signally preserved from the wiles of the Pope and the sword of the false prophet, be disappointed, and the glorious light which appeared to be about to gild the mountains of Kurdistan, and to spread over the adjoin- ing regions, be extinguished. May the Lord himself disappoint our fears, and put a song of praise into our hearts. The churches which we have now noticed belong to Asia. Those which remain for our consideration have their seat in Africa. V. THE COPTIC CHURCH. The Coptic Church is the Church of Egypt, emphatically so called, t It is supposed that the population attached to it amounts to from between a hundred and fifty to two hundred thousand souls. t About ten thousand of * The Arabic word Kuht, or Kibt, or as it is most generally pro- nounced in Egypt, Guht or Gibt, corresponding with our " Coptic," is easily recognised as formed from Aiywros, the ancient Greek name of Egypt, though some will have it, that it is derived from Kupt (Coptos), a town in Upper Egypt, to which many of the Christians retired during the persecution under several of the Roman emperors. Renaudot (in his Dissert, de Ling. Copt.) states satisfactory reasons for not deriving the name from the city of Koptus. f " The Patriarch informed me that he calculated the number of Copts at about 150,000. This is too low an estimate." Dr Bow- ring's Report on Egypt and Candia, p. 8. THE COPTIC CHURCH. 13? these reside in Cairo. In Upper Egypt they form a considerable portion of the village population ; and they are numerous in the district called the Faium, the Pi- thom of scripture. When I had an interview with their visible head, — the patriarch of Alexandria as he is called, though resident at Cairo, — he reckoned the number of churches belonging to them at 500, but from other sources, I was given to understand that they amount only to about 150. Their regular convents are reduced to se- ven ; two, those of St Anthony and St Paul, in the eastern desert near the Red Sea ; four, including that of St Ma- carius, in the Natron valley ; and one at Jebel Koskam in Upper Egypt. Besides these they have a number of secondary monasteries, into which, the priests being se- culars, women are admitted as well as men.* From among the monks residing at one or other of these con- vents, the patriarch or Batrak, as he is denominated, is taken to occupy what is called the " chair of St Mark," the apostle of Egypt. The mode of his appointment is somewhat singular. *' The bishops and principal priests when a patriarch is to be elected," says Mr Lane, " ap- ply to the superior of the convent above mentioned (St Anthony), who names about eight or nine monks whom he considers qualified for the high office of head of the church : the names of these persons are written each upon a separate slip of paper, which pieces of paper are then rolled into the form of little balls, and put into a * For an account of the Coptic convents, see Wilkinson's Mo- dern Egypt and Thebes, vol. i. p. 386, &c. Their libraries were care- fully examined, in 1842, by the Rev. Dr Tattam, who was permitted to purchase and bring to this country the most valuable of their MSS. Among them, it is hoped, will be found some curious and interesting documents. 138 INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. drawer : a priest draws one without looking ; and the person whose name is thus drawn is invested as pa- triarch. Formerly, a young child was employed to draw the lot, being supposed to be more under the direction of Heaven."* I am not altogether certain of the absolute accuracy of this account ; but a statement to the effect of what follows, I received from the present Coptic pa- triarch himself. It is not from the bishops, but the monks, that the patriarch is selected. When the choice or lot falls upon any particular individual, the magnates of the church apply to the Pasha for a mihtary detach- ment, in company with which a deputation repairs to the monastery, to demand the person of him who is indicated. In a spirit of becoming modesty he says, nolo episcopari. The sight of the soldiers, however, speedily removes his scruples, and he humbly agrees to accompany them to the capital, where he is anointed to office, without having been constituted a bishop. Below the Patriarch, are the Bishops titular and real, the Presbyters, who administer the mass to the people, but never preach, the Archdeacons, Deacons, Sub-Deacons, Lectors, Can- tors, and Exorcists, who are mere boyish assistants of church ceremonies. The Copts do not seem to lay so much stress as the Roman Catholics and their imitators on apostolical succession, so far as the idea of the transfusion of grace, and communicating the power of transfusing grace, from man to man, is concerned. The sanctifying virtue, they think, principally rests in the meirun, or holy oil of unction, which they suppose preserves the properties imparted to it by the blessing of the apostle Mark, as a new stock is always added to the old before it is ex- * Lane's Mod. Egypt, p. 341. THE COPTIC CHURCH. 139 hausted.*' In the Arabic history of the Coptic church, written by Taki-ed-Din-el-Makrizi, which is beheved to contain the approved annals of the Coptic church, and a copy of which I lately procured, it is said, that there were no bishops in Egypt till the time of the patriarch Deme- trius, whose name occurs as the eleventh in the Coptic list.f Jerome informs us that the presbyters of Alexan- dria were accustomed to ordain their bishop. With the early history of the church in Egypt, the Roman and Byzantine fathers make us sufficiently ac- quainted. The Egyptian Christians embraced the mono- physite doctrines probably prior to those of Syria. It was through the influence of Dioscorus, the patriarch of Alexandria, that Eutyches escaped condemnation at the council assembled at Ephesus a. d. 449, by the Emperor Theodosius; and it was against Dioscorus, as well as Eutyches, that the fourth General Council, that of Chalce- don, called by Marcian in a. d. 457, declared when it set forth^its belief, "that in Christ there are two distinct natures united in one person, and that without any change, mixture, or confusion." Though Dioscorus was ordered into banishment, he met with much sympathy and approbation in Egypt, where the partisans of his views ultimately proved more numerous and powerful than the Melchites, so called from their support of the Greek emperor, the patron of the council. Upon the * " The Copts pretend to have the head and body of St Mark, in the monastery which bears his name at Alexandria ; but Leo Afri- canus affirms that they were secretly carried away by the Venetians to their city. Sir Gardiner Wilkinson (Modem Egypt and Thebes, vol. i. p. 167.) waggishly remarks, that " from the known habits and natural history of relics, this might not present any difficulty to their being still there '." f Makrizi, section 65. 140 INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. death of the Emperor Marcian, they murdered Proterius whom he had appointed successor to Dioscorus, and sub- stituted in his place Timotheus ^lurius, whose senti- ments were congenial with those of the banished patriarch ; and though occasionally they were obliged to submit to a Melchite patriarch on the occurrence of a vacancy, and were sadly distressed, they at length got matters settled according to their own wishes. The majority of the Christians of Egypt declared themselves "Jacobites," nearly as soon as Jacob Baradseus gave form to his sect. Makrizi, the Arabic historian, whose name I have already mentioned, thus writes respecting the conquest of Egypt by the Musalmans. " Know that the whole of Egypt at the entrance of the Muhammadans was filled with Christians, who divided themselves into two parties, respectively distinguished by race and faith. One party consisted of the men who held the govern- ment, and who were all of the soldiery of the lord of Constantinople, the Greek emperor. Their rites and doctrines were those of the Melchites. The Greeks exceeded the number of 300,000. All the inhabitants of Egypt, who were called Copts, formed the other part. Their race was a mixed one, as amongst them Abyssini- ans, Nubians, Israelites, and others, could easily be dis- cerned, all adherent to the Jacobite doctrine. Some of them were imperial scribes, merchants, and shopkeepers ; some bishops, and others presbyters, and such as per- tain to this order; and some husbandmen, labourers, and servants. It was the effect of discord which pre- vented them from forming marriages between them- selves and the Melchites who held the government, and that it happened that they murdered one another. THE COPTIC CHURCH. 141 Their number was about two millions."* In hatred to the Greeks, as this writer proceeds to inform us, the Copts willingly became subject to the Musalmans under A'mru ben Elas, the invader of the country a. d. 638, and even assisted him in overcoming the Greeks, which he finally did by the capture of Alexandria in 640. The tribute exacted of the Copts was two golden dinars for every person above sixteen years of age, with the exception of old men, women, and monks. At first they seemed greatly to relish their exchange of masters, even paying this price, rejoicing in the vengeance which their hate led them to view as executed in their own be- half. Fearful has been the retribution with which the pro- vidence of God ha s visited the Copts, since they placed themselves under the power of the Musalmans. De- gradation and persecution have been their lot during the centuries which have intervened between that time and the present. Hence the great reduction of their numbers, in a country remarkable for its tendency to an increase of population, and the depression under which they have so long laboured. Their history, so far as it is interesting, is little else than a narrative of suffering — of suffering so great, and in general so httle deserved, that Makrizi, himself a Musalman, cannot record its details without writing as if his sympathy were wholly on their side.f * Numb. 314-3T7. t Renaudot in his Ilistory of the Patriarchs of Alexandria, and also in the first volume of his Collection of the Oriental Liturgies, frequently refers to Makrizi. The original Arabic of Makrizi, in so far as the Copts are concerned, was published at Sulzbach in 1828, with a Latin translation by Wetzer. 142 INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. When I put the question to the Coptic patriarch, *' What are the principal ecclesiastical authorities of the Coptic church after the Bible ?" he answered, *' The Say- ings of the Fathers, the Liturgy of Basileus, the Liturgy of Gregorius, the Liturgy of Cyrillus, and the Apostolic Constitutions." The liturgies here mentioned as used in the churches, are in the Coptic language, which is not now spoken by a single native of Egypt. A translation of them is given by Renaudot in his Collection. They are merely communion offices, containing some prayers, which may be suitably addressed to the throne of grace, but bearing unequivocal evidence that the Copts, with all the other oriental Christians, believe that the bread and wine in the Lord's Supper are changed into the real body and blood of Christ, and presented by the priest as an oblation to God. A large fragment of the apos- tolical constitutions in the Ethiopic translation by Mr Pell Piatt, was pubHshed in 1834 by the Oriental Translation Fund. A complete copy in Arabic, which I procured, I have brought with mo to this country. Though it contains a good portion of unobjectionable matter, it contains also much that is erroneous and injurious. The false assumption of the name of the twelve apostles, and that of Paul the apostle of the Gentiles, stamps the commencement of it at least with decided imposture. The Copts, like the other sects whom we have men- tioned, have seven sacraments, namely. Baptism, which they generally administer to boys at the age of forty days, and to girls at the age of eighty days — unless they should previously be seized with dangerous illness, di'^ping the body three times in water, to which the sacred oil has been added, and over which the si^n of the cross has been THE COPTIC CHURCH. 143 made ;* the Eucharist, which we have just noticed ; Conjlrmation, which is effected with meirun, or the holy oil, immediately after baptism ; Confession^ which is followed by absolution, and sometimes by the prescrip- tion of penance ; Ordination, Matrimony, and Extreme Unction, which is administered with prayer to the healthy after the commission of great sins, as well as to the sick and dying. Connected with these sacraments, they hold the erroneous sentiments which we condemn in the Roman and Greek churches. The Copts, I may here mention, practise the rite of circumcision, but, as the patriarch told me, more as a civil than a religious custom. This they do privately, without any fixed age for its performance. Their religious fasts are numerous and severe. The patriarch exhibits himself as the great exemplar of religious austerity. It is said that he is awaked from his sleep every quarter of an hour during the night, that he may call on the name of God. During my visit to Cairo, I once attended public wor- ship at the Coptic church. It commenced as soon as it was light on the Lord's-day morning ; and it was well attended both by young and old, who, on account of the smallness of the church — the largest, however, belonging to the Copts of the place — were much crowded together, to their great discomfort, increased by the want of ven- tilation, and the burning of numerous candles. The construction of the church much resembled a Jewish synagogue. It was divided into four compartments. The heikel, or chancel, forms the chief compartment at the eastern end ; and it is separated from the rest of the church by wooden panel-work. Before it is suspended a * The Coptic form of baptism is given by J. A. Asseraan, in his Codex Liturgicus, lib. ii. p. 150, et seq. 144 INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. curtain with a large cross worked upon it, having a door in the centre as an entrance. The compartment adjoin- ing to this, separated by a fence of lattice-work from the other parts of the church, was occupied by the officiating priests and their assistants, by the patriarch who was sitting on an antique seat called the chair of St Mark, and by the more respectable portions of the congregation. Into this compartment we were allowed to enter. The inferior members of the congTegation occupied the next apartment ; and the most remote was appropriated to the women, who were nearly completely screened from our view by another partition of lattice- work. I observed no images ; but a few glaring pictures were here and there suspended from the walls. The worshipper, on entering the church, laid aside his shoes, but agreeably to the universal custom of the eastern churches, kept on his turban.* His first act of devotion was that of pros- trating himself before the chancel immediately in front of the suspended cross, kissing the hem of the curtain, and then before the patriarch, who extended to him his blessing on his rising, and lastly before some of the pic- tures of the saints. The entrance of great numbers aftei- the service had begun, who went through these ceremo- nies, added much to the confusion, which was now and * The text, " Every man praying or prophesying having his head covered, dishonoureth his head," the Orientals, perhaps not without reason, interpret as if to be rendered, " Everyman pray- ing or prophesying having his head enit'rappecZ [like a woman's] dis- honoureth his head." We have found that the converts in India even strongly object to lay aside their turbans during public -wor- ship, alleging that decency requires them to wear them. The Jews, it is well known, preserve their head-dress in their synagogues. " But if any man seem to be contentious, we have no such custom, neither the churches of God." THE COPTIC CHURCH. 145 then increased by the tmkhng of bells and cymbals, and some of the priests moving up and down and waving censers with incense rising from them, and making de- mands on the patriarch for a new supply of combustibles when their stock was exhausted. Many of the older men were leaning on crutches, about four or five feet high, during most of the time of the service, evidently obtain- inor some relief from the use of them, in the lack of all pews, during the three or four lengthened hours of their meeting. They were frequently talking to one another and exchanging jokes. Some of the priests were hunting after the boys, who were seeking their amusement, evi- dently anxious to improve their behaviour in our presence. Their prayers were almost all in the dead Coptic, and, of course, were perfectly unintelligible by the people, who seemed to take little interest in them, though, led by others, they gave the responses. The reading of the gospels and epistles was in Arabic ; but it was performed in a most irreverent and unimpressive manner by mere boys, who seemed to be highly amused with their occu- pation. The bread and wine used in the Lord's Sup- per were particularly inspected by the patriarch and priests before their consecration. The bread was in the form of small round cakes, with the figure of the cross, I believe, stamped upon them ; and the wine was contained in a small glass vessel. The bread was dipped in the wine before it was given to the people, only a small portion of whom partook of it ; and the priests alone drunk of the cup. The patriarch concluded the service by reading some exhortations in Arabic, and pronouncing benedic- tions. Except in so far as his part of the business was con- cerned, the whole seemed rather a mockery of sacred things, than the worship of the omnipresent and omni- L 146 INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. scient God. I trust that, in making this unvarnished statement, I speak to your deep commiseration of those- who, hke yourselves, bear the Christian name, but who treat it with such palpable dishonour. The state of the Coptic and other Eastern churches in Egypt — we must be grateful in the view of their de- gradation and destitution — has not been altogether over- looked by evangelical protestants. The Rev. Joseph Jowett, the representative of the Church Missionary Society in the Mediterranean, the Rev. Pliny Fisk of America, and Dr Joseph Wolff, during their visits to the country within the last twenty-five years, noted their peculiar circumstances, and commended them in their published journals to the benevolence of those who are able to extend to them relief.* Five Lutheran mi- nisters, who had been all destined for Abyssinia at the close of 1825, were brought into connection with Egypt; a.nd two of them, Messrs Lieder and Kruse, were even- tually settled at Cairo, which, since that time, they have made the head- quarters of their mission, and where they have faithfully and diligently laboured to diffuse Chris- tian education among the Copts, to promote among them the circulation of the Scriptures and religious books and tracts, and, by conversation and exhortation, to revive among them the spirit of true godliness. The acquaint- ance of Mr Lieder I had the pleasure of making during , my late visit to Egypt, Mr Kruse being then absent ; and I was glad to be informed by him, as well as to learn - from my own personal observation, that matters during his residence in the country have begun much to im- prove. By his kind and judicious conduct, as well as by * Jowett's Researches in the Mediterranean. Wolft's Journal, Memoir of Pliny Fisk. THE COPTIC CHURCH. 147 tlie visible benefits conferred on the Coptic community through the educational efforts of the mission, he has completely gained the regard and esteem of the Coptic patriarch, and many of the clergy, and great numbers of the people, and thus opened up a great, and what I trust will prove an effectual, door of usefulness. He has under his charge an elementary school, taught on the Lan- casterian system, containing about a hundred boys, and a seminary containing about twenty-five youths receiving a higher education, and which, when 1 saw him, he was about to re-organize, with reduced numbers, however, as a theological school, from which the patriarch had promised to select candidates for the Coptic church. Mrs Lieder, whose literary attainments and application in the work of oriental teaching are so well known, had a female school under her charge, with an average attendance of about 120 pupils, and taught by a Syrian lady, Oni Suhman. A spirit of serious inquiry had begun to ap- pear among a few of the Copts, but no decided move- ment had occurred. The embracement of evangelical views by any number of individuals would probably lead either to their abandonment of the Coptic church, or to their expulsion from its pale. Their consciences would undoubtedly shrink from the practice of the worship of saints, and their pictures, and the adoration of the mass, and other idolatrous and antichristian usages ; and toler- ation would scarcely be extended to them in their dis- sent. This matter, however, is for the present hid with God. Let his true followers publish the truths of his salvation, and trust in that protection which he will ex- tend to believers, and in his ultimately overruling that opposition with which they may be assailed to his own glory and their eternal good. The apprehension of in- 148 INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. conveniences, trials, and changes, has too long deterred us from our duty. A revival of evangelical religion among the Copts would undoubtedly render them a blessing in the midst of the land of Egypt. In the minds of the Musalman population, however much they may be despised as Christians, they are associated with claims to a higher antiquity as a race inhabiting the country, than that of those who are now their masters, whether Turks or Arabs. Muhammad Ali, the present ruler of Egypt, clearly dis- cerns the use to which they may be turned, connected with the state ; and he has given to large numbers of them employment in the public service. Dr Bowring, in his official report addressed to Lord Palmerston, pre- sented to both Houses of Parhament in 1840, justly says, " The influence of the Copts is undoubtedly an in- creasing influence, and they will probably occupy no small part of the field in the future history of Egypt. Theirs have been centuries of cruel sufferings, persecu- tions, and humiliations. In the eyes of the Turks, they have always been the Pariahs of the Egyptian people ; yet they are an amiable, pacific, and intelligent race, whose worst vices have grown out of their seeking shel- ter from wrong and robbery. A certain sympathy, per- haps the result of common suff'erings, exists between the Copts and the Arabs. They are the surveyors, the scribes, the arithmeticians, the measurers, the clerks ; in a word, the learned men of the land. They are to the counting-house and the pen, what the fellah is to the field and the plough. . . In the manufactories of the Pasha, many of the Copts are employed as hand- loom weavers. . . A great many of them are em- THE ABYSSINIAN CHURCH. 149 ployed ill public-offices."* They are nearly ten times more numerous than the Turks in Egypt, who are reck- oned at 20,000; and, except in so far as the army is con- cerned, from which they are excluded, they are begin- ning to occupy the situations formerly held by Turks. An evangelical reformation amongst them would in- crease as well as sanctify their influence. VI. THE ABYSSINIAN CHURCH. The adherents of this church occupy the whole of the country marked in our maps as Abyssinia, with the ex- ception of its outer parts on all sides, which are now occupied by Heathen and Muhammadan tribes, which, till lately, were fast contracting its limits. Beyond the bounds of Habesh, on both sides of the river Gochob, it appears, from credible reports communicated to Sir Wilham Harris during his late embassy to the country, ^* there exist in various quarters, isolated communities professing the Christianity of ^Ethiopia, who for a long period of years have successfully held their position among the mountain fastnesses in the very heart of the now Pagan and Muhammadan country." Of these I would here glean a few notices, as the most important and interesting accessions to the geography of Christen- dom which have been made in our day. For the sake of precision, I give them in the words of Major Harris himself. " One of the most remarkable of these seats is in the lake Zuai." Its five islands " are covered with lofty trees, and contain upwards of three thousand Chris- tian houses." " In Gurague the population are almost ex- clusively Christian. Twelve isolated churches, previous- * Bowring's Report on Egypt, pp. 8, 9. 150 INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. ly imlieard of, were discovered a few years since on tlie conquest of Yeya, by Sdhela Selassie [king of Shoa in Abyssinia]; and between Garro and Metcha, where forest commences in the south of Shoa, is a small tract peopled by Christians, who reside entirely in caves among the mountains, as a measure of security against the heathen, by whom they are compassed in on every side." " Eight days' journey from Aimellele, on the frontier of Gurague, is Cambat, a small mountainous province, lying due east of Zingero. With exception of a few Mu- liammadan rovers, this independent state is inhabited solely by Christians." " Wollamo is another Christian pi-ovince under an independent sovereign, lying below Cambat, to the south-eastward of Zinorero." *' Eio;ht days' journey beyond Zingero is the country of Mager, the king of which, by name Degaio, is represented to be a very powerful monarch. Korchdsi, which is famous for the great river Wabi, is peopled by Christians, as is Sidama also, and both are surrounded on all sides by the heathen." " But of all the isolated remnants of the ancient ^thiopic empire to the south of Abyssinia, Susa would appear to be the most important and the most powerful. This kingdom is situated beyond Caffa, and extends to the head of the Gitche, which rises in Chara- Nara, and is one of the principal sources of the Gochob. The language spoken is quite distinct from that of the Galla, from the Amharic, and from the ancient Giz or ^thiopic. It possesses a written character." These mtimations are not less delightful than startling from their entire novelty. They would appear to rest upon good authority. " Making due allowance," says Major Harris, " for the superstition and geographical ignorance of the various natives from whom the foregoing particu- THE ABYSSINIAN CHURCH. 151 iars have been collected, the fullest credit may be ac- corded, — minute cross-examinations of individuals, who oould have held no previous communication with each other, having corroborated every point." " It is im- portant," he adds, " to know that the Gochob, in its upper course, is occupied by so powerful a Christian people, whose sovereign exercises over the destinies of the surrounding Gentiles, an influence which, if properly directed, could be made to check the rapid spread of Islamism, instead of fostering the traffic in human beings."* Where is the enterprising Christian traveller who will personally visit these remote localities in the interior of Africa ; and where is the missionary of the cross who will descant to their inhabitants on the love and grace of Him whose name they bear, till, moved by his own Spirit, they in very deed lay hold of His I'iojhteousness, and be born again in the imag-e of His own holiness ? The earliest authentic notices which we have of the conversion of -Ethiopia to Christianity, are connected with a visit made to the country about the year 327 of our era, by Meropius, a merchant of Tyre, and his ne- phews Frumentius and ^desius. When, after exploring the country, and having set sail on their return, they were forced by a disaster at sea to re-enter one of its ports, the uncle was murdered, and the youths sent into captivity. They were carried to court, where one of them, Frumentius, was appointed to the office of se- cretary. The sovereign, before his death; gave them their liberty ; but the queen-regent prevailed on them to remain in the country during the minority of her son. They embraced the opportunities presented to them of * Harris's Highlands of Ethiopia, vol. iii, pp. 74-83. 152 INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. commendino; the religjion of Jesus to those around them; and they were blessed in their labours. When they did leave the country on the king becoming of age, Fruraen- tius communicated to Athanasius, the patriarch of Alex- andria, the success which he experienced ; and by this father he was ordained a bishop to the Ethiopians, among whom he afterwards experienced such success, that the king and the great body of the people embraced the Christian faith.* It was at Axum that this sovereign resided, as appears from a letter of Constantius the em- peror, — who wished to bring him within the pale of Arianism, — quoted by Athanasius, clearly shews. t Fru- mentius is commemorated by the Abyssinians till the present time. He occupies a place in their calendar of saints, under the name of Salama. To other notices of the early history of the Abyssinian Church I cannot here advert. J The connection which it formed with Egypt through Athanasius has remained to this day ; its Abuna, or chief ecclesiastic, being still appohited by the patriarch of the Coptic Church, of which it reckons itself a branch, and which it imitates both in doctrine and discipline, — far outstripping it, how- ever, in the multiplicity of its absurd legends, vain and superstitious ceremonies, and its idolatrous worship of * Socrates, lib. i. cap. 19. Sozomen, lib. ii, cap 24. Theodori- tus, lib. i. cap. 23. The country mentioned in these passages as the scene of the labours of Frumentius is called " India." I for- merly thought that it referred to Hindustan (Second Exposure of Hinduism, p. 145) ; but I am now convinced from the mention of Axum (which is in Abyssinia) in the letter of Constantius re- ferred to below, that " India," was indefinitely used as correspon- dent with ^Ethiopia. t Athanasii Apologet. ad Imp. Constant. I For the most important of these see Geddes's Church History of JSthiopia. THE ABYSSINIAN CHURCH. 153 saints and ano-els. How far it has strained its inventive o faculties in the exercise of will-worship, appears from its crivino- Pontius Pilate and his wife Procla a place in the calendar of its saints, under the 19th of June, — the for- mer, because he washed his hands before condemning our Lord, and the latter, because she said, Meddle not with that just person. The clergy are remarkable for their ignorance, and no check seems to exist as to the assumption of the ministerial office. '* The .ordination of priests," says Mr Gobat, " is easily performed. It is sufficient for a man to know the letters of his alphabet, with a few prayers, and to give two pieces of salt to the interpreter of the Abuna or Coptic bishop, after which he receives the imposition of hands, without examination or exhortation ; and this is the reason why those who are better instructed would be ashamed to be made priests. There are exceptions ; but I am speaking of the generality."* The religious instruction of the peo- ple is not to be expected in these circumstances ; and its twelve thousand clergy are nothing but " twelve thousand clerical drones."t Public worship, as conducted by them, seems neither designed to honour God nor benefit man. " Capering and beating the ground with their feet, the priests stretch out their crutches toward each other with frantic gesticulations, whilst the clash of the timbrel, the sound of the drum, and the howling of hai"sh voices, com- plete a most strange form of devotion. The lessons are taken partly from the Scriptures, partly from the mi- racles of the Holy Virgin and of Tekla Haimanot,J the * Gobat's Abyssinia, p. 349. f Harris's /Ethiopia, vol. iii. p. 131. J Tekla Haimanot is the favourite saint of Abyssinia. " Tekla Haymanot lived in the seventh century and was the apostle around Shoa. Tekla Haymanot means Planter of the Faith ,• his original 154 IXDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. life of St George, and other foolish and fabulous works ; but all are in the ancient JEthiopic tongue, which to the congregation is a dead letter."* The books found in the country beside the Scriptures are 108 in number. Co- pies of all of them have been taken to Germany by my friend Dr Roth, the naturalist of the British embassy, and deposited in the Protestant College of Erlangen. They consist principally of legendary lives of the saints, monks, and other personages ; of abridgments of scrip- ture history, sadly corrupted by absurd traditions and ex- travagant inventions; of collections of hymns and prayers, some of which are intended to fiighten evil spirits ; and of ecclesiastical canons and summaries of doctrine. Taking them as a whole, they are more fitted to mislead than to edify, to nurse superstition, than to beget a right faith and cherish a right devotion. A few of them, perhaps, are worthy of examination, as contributing in some de- gree to throw light on the religious history of Ethiopia.! Many of the customs of the Abyssinians, — such as the practice of circumcision on the eighth day, abstinence from the unclean animals, the observance of the last day of the week as a day of rest (in addition to the Lord's name was Fesahat Ziun, i. e. Juy of Zion. He was bom in Shoa. He replaced the royal family upon the throne, and was zealous in converting the Galas to Christianity. He even made such an impression on the Devil by preaching, that he (the Devil) deter- mined to become a monk for forty years The same Tekla Ilaymanot stood forty years upon one place praying, until he broke his leg. There are twenty-four elders around the throne of God with censers in their hands, serving God, and Tekla Haymanot is the twenty-fifth. He had six wings like angels." "Wolff's Journal, vol. v. p. 350. This is a fair specimen of the legends of Abysssinia. * Harris's /Ethiopia, vol. iii. pp. 13S, 137. t See a catalogue of these works in the appendix to the third volume of the Highlands of Ethiopia, by Sir AVilliam Harris, THE ABYSSINIAN CHURCH. 155 day), religious purifications, the wearing of a ribband of blue as a symbol of their faith, the construction of their churches in the form of synagogues, the performance of worship with the musical instruments mentioned in the Psalms, abstinence from the sinew that shrank and from blood, the practice of confession on the day of the atonement, and the offering of a kind of atoning sacrifice called Boza, — have evidently had a Jewish origin ; and there consequently can be little doubt, that the nation was considerably affected by Jewish manners and cus- toms before its conversion to Christianity. I think it proba- ble that the Jews, in some numbers, extended themselves from Egypt and Yemen to the country before the Chris- tian era. It is a matter of certainty, that many Jews repaired to it both after the destruction of Jerusalem by Titus, and on the persecution raised by Adrian. Many of their descendants, estimated by Dr Wolff at 200,000, are still in Abyssinia, known by the name of Felashas. Heathen proximity and intercommunion, however, have told more on the church there than Judaism. I have already mentioned, that the Abyssinian Church is a branch of the Coptic. It is not necessary for me, then, particularly to advert to its constitution and creed. It may be proper to mention, however, that, for the last sixty years, religious controversy has raged within it, and that certain differences of opinion respecting the birth and unctions of the Saviour, — of which we have not yet received consistent and intelligent accounts, — have divided it into three parties most inimical to one another, and who will no longer partake of the commu- nion together.* * Compare Gobat pp. 342, 343, with Major Harris, vol. iii. pp. 18 -191. 156 INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. All the Abyssinians whom I have met in India, Egypt, and Syria, seemed to deal with religion as a matter of great seriousness and importance ; and I ob- served that the most outwardly devout pilgrims visiting Jerusalem are from Ethiopia. Nothing but religious feelings of some kind or other, indeed, could make the Abyssinians submit to the numerous fasts and penances enjoined by their ecclesiastical standards, and prescribed to them by the priests, and in which they suppose the essence of religion consists. Depraved and degraded though they almost all are, from their imperfect know- ledge of that holy fiith which they nominally profess, and the superstitious practices to which, acting almost on the license of Pagans, they have devoted themselves, there is still something connected with them calculated to act on our sympathy as Christians. " We may still congratulate them," says Mr Gobat, " for the little they have preserved of Christianity, for it is, after all, to this that the Christian traveller is oblioed to attribute all those traces in the character of the Abyssinians which, in many respects, render them superior to all the nations of Africa. Indeed, it is a great advantage for Abyssinia to have had till now none but Christian governors. This is acknowledged even by the Musalmans of that country. It is in this religion itself that the seed is to be found for the regeneration of the people of Abyssinia." '• Abyssinia as she now is," says Sir William Harris, " presents the most singular compound of vanity, meek- ness, and ferocity — of devotion, superstition, and igno- rance. But, compared with the other nations of Africa, she unquestionably holds a high station. She is supe- rior in arts and in agriculture, — in laws, religion, and social condition, to all the benighted children of the sun. THE ABYSSINIAN CHURCH. 157 The small portion of good work which does exist may be justly ascribed to the remains of the wreck of Christi- anity, which, although stranded on a rocky shore, and buffeted by the storms of ages, is not yet overwhelmed. There is, perhaps, no portion of the whole conti- nent to which European civilization might be applied with better ultimate results ; and although now dwindled into an ordinary kingdom [with several chiefs], Habesh, under proper government and proper influence, might promote the amelioration of all the surrounding people, while she resumed her original position as the first of African monarchies." Is there no hope of the speedy amelioration of this most interesting country ? The attention of the Church of England Missionary Society has been directed to it for several years. In 1820, the Rev. Mr Jowett, the agent of that institution, purchased, on account of the British and Foreign Bible Society, an entire version of the Bible into the Amharic, the principal vernacular language of Abyssinia, which had been executed at Cairo by a native of the country. It has been printed for distribution. Messrs Gobat and Kugler entered Abyssinia at the close of 1836. The latter was cut off by a melancholy accident ; but the former, after a missionary journey in the country of three years, says, " The word of God, as contained in the four Gospels, and some copies of the epistles, has been distributed in every quarter of the country. The religious conversations which I had at Gondar have been reported in every province. The most instructed persons have begun, in consequence of these means, at least to doubt the truth of some of those errors which they had always considered truth itself; and some young people appear to feel the drawing of 158 INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. the Father, who will lead them to Jesus, that they may receive eternal life." Mr Gobat, accompanied by Mr Isenberg, a second time visited the northern provinces. Dr Wolff also made a journey to the northern parts of the country, where he found Mr Gobat so unwell that he was obliged humanely to accompany him to the coast. Mr Isenberg returned to this country, where he pre- pared some elementary works in the Amharic and Galla languages. Mr Krapf, another missionary, whose inte- resting journal has lately been pubhshed, proceeded to Slioa, the southern province of the country, where he seemed to be acquiring a salutary influence, and where he was joined by two other labourers. I fear that, for the present, they have left the country ; but I trust that it is only to return to it with greater advantages than those hitherto enjoyed. The seed which these excellent men have already sown, may yet spring up and bear an abundant harvest. From other providential occurrences more nearly connected with ourselves, we have hopes of a blessing for at least some parts of Abyssinia. Wlien Dr Wolff visited the country, he and Mr Isen- bercr encourao-ed an influential native to set out for India with his two promising sons, in ordei* to procure for them a superior education. On their reaching Aden, they wrote to the Bombay Government informing, it, that they had obtained letters for me, and that they intended to place themselves under my care. On their arrival in India, I was prepared to receive them into my family, and to appoint the youth to study in our mis- sion institution. The father staid a year with me, watching diligently over his sons; and he then re- turned to Abyssinia, leaving his sons under my care. They remained four years and eight months under my THE ABYSSINIAN CHURCH. 159 roof, (luring which time they profited much by the in- structions received in my family, and by their attend- ance at our institution, all the members of the mission showing the deepest anxiety to advance their improve- ment. They distinguished themselves even among the Hindu pupils, with whom there is no lack of talent ; and, what is of far more importance, they shewed the most pleasing and satisfactory signs of personal piety, being constrained by their religious feelings to sit down with our native church at the Lord's table. On my leaving India for this country, they accompanied me to Aden, from which they proceeded to Abyssinia. I have had no tidings of them since they entered that country ; but this may be accounted for by the difficulty of com- munication. If spared, they will, through divine grace, prove lights in the midst of the surrounding darkness ; and, full as they are of Christian zeal, they will seek the instruction of their countrymen. They repeatedly ex- pressed the wish to me to return to India, if their friends Avould permit them, to complete their studies for the lioly ministry, and to devote themselves to the work of a missionary among their kindred according to the flesh. They have the pledge from me and others that they will not be overlooked ; and if no tidings of them be soon received, a special native messenger will be despatched from Aden to inquire about their fate. May they be preserved, and made a rich blessing to multitudes in ^Ethiopia, which, in all its extent, will yet stretch out its hands unto God. I cannot at present extend these notices of the Independent Eastern Churches, though I have in my possession abundant materials for a much fuller descrip- 160 INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. tion of them. I trust, however, that it has not alto- gether been in vain, that you have this day been called to advert to their past history, and present condition, and the benevolent efforts which are now being made in their behalf. When you contrast their constitu- tion, as formed through the ministry of apostles, evange- lists, confessors, and martyrs, — the splendour of their glory in the morn of their existence, when the beams of the Sun of Righteousness, unobscured by the clouds of error and superstition, directly conveyed to them life and heal- ing, and when the Spirit of God himself rested on their members, with all the effulgence of his enlightening, purifying, and beautifying grace, — and their first love, and works, and charity, and service, and faith, and patience, amidst all the opposition whick they experienced from the Prince of the power of the air, and his ministers on earth arrayed in all tbe untarnished and unbroken pano- ply of a matured and dominant paganism, and the dis- appointed worldHness of a perverted Judaism — with their present darkness, desolation, and ruin, you must be well nigh lost in wonder and astonishment, and tempted to leave them as they are to the fearful judgments of that God whose righteous indignation they have done so much to provoke, and long-suffering patience to exhaust. When, however, you bear in mind that some of them form a remnant wonderfully preserved for ages, though so often assailed by the sword of the false prophet, and the heathen chief, and the frauds of the man of sin — whose efforts to secure their allegiance have been despe- rate and unceasing — you may come to the conclusion that God may yet have rich grace in store for them, and errant them speedily a day of merciful visitation, intro- duced, though it may be, by fearful chastisements and INDEPENDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. IGl changes. If we view some of them as the alhes, or even the subjects, of Babylon, we should still say to their mem- bers, in the name of God, '' Come out of her, my people, that ye be mot partakers of her sins, and that ye receive not her plagues : for her sins have reached unto heaven, and God hath remembered her iniquities." If we view the lands in which they are found as the field of the warld's battle, we should also remember that they are the destined scene of the world's deliverance. If no state on earth neglects its frontier, without injury, Chris- tendom should look to its interests where they come in contact with the dominions of the Heathen and Muham- madan powers ; and, if our own country at present be the most highly-favoured on earth, we should remember that its influence should be felt where protection, re- covery, and advance, are most imperiously needed. If we esteem it a privilege and a duty to labour and pray for the conversion of the Jews to the faith of that Jesus whom their fathers crucified, we should not overlook those depressed communities bearing the Christian name, in which are to be found the descendants of that rem- nant according to the election of grace, which, in the days of the apostles, saw in Jesus of Nazareth that Sa- viour of whom Moses and the prophets did write. We should remember that it is as clearly revealed, that it is through God's mercy to the Gentiles that the Jews are to obtain mercy ,^ as that the receiving of the Jews is to be to the Gentiles as life from the dead ; and that the neglected Eastern Christians are, by their idolatries and superstitions, at present stumblingblocks in the way of the Jews, while, if evangelical truth were again re- stored to them by the blessing of God upon our exertions, * Rom. xi. .31. 162 INDEPENDEXT EASTERN CHURCHES. the Jews mio-ht be provoked by them to jealousy and emulation, to their being saved. We have seen that o-reat doors of usefulness are opening up among these Christians : and it becomes us, with others, to enter in, and labour for their enlightenment and reformation. In the view of their claims and necessities, I thank God for the formation of the Committee of the Free Church for holding correspondence with, and promoting the interests of, the Foreign Churches, which has given me this op- portimity of making this first appeal in their behalf in Scotland. In concluding, I beg to observe, that our present con- tributions to the Eastern Churches may be easily em- ployed for their benefit. Members of the Armenian and ^Ethiopian churches belonging to Persia and Abys- sinia, as well as India, have already been educated at our Mission Institution at Bombay ; and I know of others willing to repair thither if the promise of assistance in supporting themselves could be held out to them. A fund, then, for the thorough education at Bombay — our great commercial emporium for Arabia, Persia, and the shores of Africa — of members of the Eastern Churches destined to return, surcharged with Christian truth, to the lands of their nativity, would, through God's grace, accomplish an amount of good not easily to be over-estimated. When, as we expect it will ere long be the case, a mission will be formed by us at Aden for the numerous Jews of Yemen, it may prove a valuable auxiliary in procuring Christian pupils for us from Africa, and eventually, by its o-reater proximity to that continent, supersede the Indian missionaries in the charge of them. In the joint Presbyterian mission to the Jews of Damascus^ Mr LVDEPEXDENT EASTERN CHURCHES. 163 Graham regularly preaches every Lord's day m Arabic, a language which he acquired with unexampled rapidity, to as many members of the various churches of that place as he can assemble together ; and aid should be given to him in defraying the expenses incurred in this department of his work, and in the circulation of such tracts and books calculated for edification as can be pro- cured. Mr Allan, in subordination to his work among the Jews of Constantinople, may aid our American breth- ren there, when occasion demands, in their labours among the Armenians and Greeks, particularly by the distribu- tion of books. Our American friends in Syria, Asia Minor, Constantinople, and other parts of Turkey, have not, as we have seen, the means of meeting the demands which are made upon them through the press ; and we may much forward the cause which we have in view by as- sisting them in their printing operations. If the libe- rality of the public encourage the enterprise, direct mis- sions to some of the Eastern churches may be founded by ourselves and other evangelical denominations in Scot- land. Let us be prepared to act in earnestness, prayer- fulness, and devotedness, and the Lord will graciously use our instrumentality to the promotion of his own glory .^ * Contributions for any of the objects here indicated, -will be thankfully received by the Committee of the Free Church on Foreign Churches, and by the author of this Lecture. LECTURE III. The Ancient History of the Waldensian Church. BY REV. THOMAS M'CRIE, PROFESSOR OF THEOLOGY TO TUE SYNOD OF OillGlNAL SECEDEKS. "Where was your Church before Luther?" is a ques- tion that has been often put to Protestants by their Komish adversaries, and always with an air of trium- phant confidence, as if it admitted of no reply, and decided the whole controversy. It would not be diffi- cult to show, that the question, viewed as an objection against the truth of the Protestant religion, is founded upon mere fallacy and gratuitous assumption. It as- sumes not only that Christ has promised that there shall always be in the world a visible Church, but that this Church must be so visible as to be seen by all, and that it must be confined to a particular locality. But although we have every reason to believe that our Lord has always had a visible Church on earth, in which the faithful have been nourished and preserved, it does not follow that it was at all times equally visible. On the contrary, the same Word which holds out the prospect of a perpetual visibility to the Church, warrants us to expect that, during a long and dreary N 165 LECTURE III. interval, the Anticliristian interest would maintain a visible ascendancy; while the true Church, under the emblem of the Two Witnesses in the Revelation, would be reduced within very narrow limits, and driven to preach the gospel in a state of great distress and de- pression : so that the Church may have existed under a visible form, though, like the sun in the heavens, it may have been often and long involved in obscurity, though it may have been hidden from the observation of the world, and though the ecclesiastical historian may search in vain or to little purpose for the records of its organic existence. In like manner, although Christ has given a promise of perpetuity to his Church, it does not follow that this promise is to be allocated to any particular Church, far less, as our opponents have the simplicity to believe, and the presumption to maintain, that this promise was made to the Church of Rome. The great question certainly is, not where our Church was, but where our religion was, before the Reformation? Where did true Christianity exist, the spirit and power of a living faith? To this question we reply, that true Christianity, though buried for ages, to a great extent, under the rubbish of Popery, was never extinct. It lived in the Word of God, " which liveth and abideth for ever;" in those sacred records, which, in spite of the efforts of Rome to suppress or supplant them. Provi- dence has preserved entire and unpolluted. And it lived in the hearts of the faithful who were raised up from time to time, to protest against her' apostacy, and who, though nominally within the pale of the Romish Church, liad not received the mark of the beast, neither wor- sliipped his im^ge. The summons, " Come out of her, my people," clearly intimates that before the Reforma- HISTORY OF THE WALDENSIAN CHURCH. 167 tion, which may be viewed as its response, Christ had a people within mystical Babylon, whom he owned a? his people, and who were as distinct from her as the captive Jews were from ancient Babylon. We may go farther, however, and reply that we find our Church before Luther, not in the Roman, but in the Catholic Church, or in those branches of the Church universal which adhered to the truth of the Gospel. We do not seek our pedigree in the Church of Rome, which, from her very constitution, is a schismatical Church, and which we view as, beyond all question, the Antichrist of Scripture, and consequently no church of Christ at all. She may pretend to be the mistress of other Churches, but in virtue of this very claim to ascendancy, she forfeits her catholicity. If she will be the Roman, she cannot be the Catholic Church. Still she is only a particular Church — a mere piece of the Church — fixed down and stereotyped within the locality of her seven mountains — the Roman Church, bearing, in the very name that she boasts of, the certificate of her schism. The Catholic Church is composed of all the churches of Christ, combined into a whole, not under the name or authority of any particular church, but under the name and authority of Christ, the Head of them all, and embracing " all that in every place call upon the name of Jesus Christ our Lord, both theirs and ours." Now that such Churches did exist during the dark- est ages before the Reformation, vre have no reason to doubt. It is not necessary that we should be able to trace their existence, far less their uninterrupted succession. Our faith in this matter is founded, not on the testimony of man, but on the sure promises of Jehovah. In tracing the descent of these Churches from the Apostles, we are guided, through the intricate 168 LECTURE III. and sometimes almost impenetrable course of their history, not by the names of Popish bishops, little known and long forgotten, if indeed they ever existed except in the imagination of their monkish chroniclers, but by the clear, sparkling, living stream of evangelical truth, leading up to the sacred fountain. And in identifying ourselves with these churches, we are not actuated by the vain ambition of " tacking ourselves on" to antiquity, as if we considered it necessary to establish such a link of connection, in order to prove our descent from the Apostolic Church ; for the true link is not corporeal, but spiritual, or, as one of the fathers expresses it, '• Where the Church is, there is the Spirit, and where the Spirit is, there is the Church." Our object simply is to show that, even during the darkest ages of the world, "God has not left himself witliout witness," and to illustrate the sub- stantial unity in the faith which has at all times distinguished the followers of the Lamb. On this point we are not left to mere conjecture. We have the testimony of unimpeachable history — a testimony which recent investigations have rendered clearer, fuller, and more explicit, than ever it was before, that during the darkest ages, there were, not individuals merely within the pale of the Romish Church, but whole Churches living in a state of separation from her, and retaining the ancient faith of the gospel — Churches which can be traced back to the days of primitive Christianit}'-, and some of which continued to exist down to the time of the Reformation — true branches and living representatives of the Catholic Church of Christ. We might have referred, as an illustration, to the Syrian Churches, which have been proved by the researches of Dr Claudius Buchanan, confirmed by HISTORY OF THE WALDENSIAN CHURCH. 1G9 subsequent inquiries, to have preserved, foi; many cen- turies, their independence and their primitive puritj. But we confine ourselves at present to the Christians of the Alps, who, under the general names of Waldenses and Albigenses, can be proved to have retained from the earliest ages the character of true Churches of Christ. It may not be out of place, before proceeding fur- ther, to advert a little to the evidence which we possess of the antiquity of the Christian Churches on both sides of the Alps, who were, in more than one respect, closely connected together. The difficulties necessarily attendant on all such inquiries, and which have crea- ted much confusion among Protestant as well as Popish writers, have been greatly enhanced by a circumstance which deserves more consideration than has hitherto been given to it. We refer to the variety of names which have been given to the early Christians, in- vented by their enemies, and too easily adopted and freely applied to them by their professed friends. We say invented by their enemies, for we have evidence to show that they were rejected as calumnies and by- names by those to whom they were originally ap- plied. It has been the uniform policy of Rome, to vilify and defame every party or Church which has dared to question her supremacy. In order to up- hold her claim to catholicity, or universality, it be- comes an essential point with her, that there should be no other Church on earth to dispute the palm with her. The existence of another, an independent Church, is fatal to the pretensions of Popery. Other Churches may have brothers or sisters: — Rome is a mother- church, and will own none but sons or daughters. Other Churches may quarrel with their neighbours. 170 LECTURE III. and, like graham and Lot, " separate themselves" to the right or left : — Rome must annihilate others, or be herself annihilated. Her motto is, Aict Cesar, aut nihil.'' To this cause, which furnishes a key for the explanation of all her persecutions in the past, as well as her proselyting zeal in the present time, we must trace the policy, cunning as it was contemptible, of in- venting nicknames, and a multitude of various dresses for those who opposed her pretensions. These appella- tives were derived from various sources — sometimes from the names of individuals who happened to distin- guish themselves for their piety, or success in gaining converts, sometimes from the places where the Christ- ians chiefly flourished, at other times from the most trifling peculiarities, such as the cut of their clothes, or the shape of their sandals. Thus, on the Italian side of the Alps, we meet with some of them called Beren- garians, from the famous Berenger of Tours, Cathari, which corresponds with our term of Puritans, Beghards, Paulicians, Paterins, Subalpines, and Vaudois. On the French side, we have them denominated Albigenses, from Albi, a town in the south of France, where they abounded for some time; Waldenses, from Peter Waldo of Lyons, whose followers again have been styled Lyon- ists, poor men of Lyons ; Sabatati, from a kind of sandal called zahata, which some of them wore ; with a variety of other names too tedious to mention, and the very number of which shows the prevalence of their opinions.* The obvious design, however, of this pyebald nomen- * Usher, de Christ. Eccl. Success, and Statu, p. 108. Mosh- eim, cent. xii. We do not recite here the much more oppro- brious epithets, founded on the pretended crimes ascribed to them, and applied to them, not only by their vulgar persecut- ors, but by learned historians. Perrin Hist, des Vaudois, p. 10. HISTORY OF THE WALDENSIAN CHURCH. 171 clature, was to affix to these confessors of Christ the character of obscure and paltry schismatics, following divisive courses from the true Catholic Church, and ranging themselves under the banner of some here- siarch, instead of that of the Pope, the sole representa- tive of Christ on earth. The device succeeded, at the time, to admiration. All true Catholics shunned the detested names of the heretics, with more horror than ever true Churchman disavowed the name of Puritan or Methodist. The good men, again, to whom they were applied, when summoned before the inquisitorial courts of that age, found themselves placed in the try- ing dilemma, of either disowning the degrading soubri- quet, and thus appearing to renounce their peculiar profession, or of acknowledging it, and thus confessing themselves schismatics. In either case advantage was taken of them by the wily inquisitors of Eome, as we learn from the bitter taunts and complaints contained in their writings, and the records of their courts. " Are you a Waldensian 1 are you a Subalpine f would their inquisitors demand. If they refused the name, and begged to explain that they were Christians, and ac- knowledged none as their master but One in heaven, — " See the obstinacy of these heretics," it was said; " they will never give you a direct answer !" If, again, they owned the designation, — " Ah, the schismatics !" was the exclamation of their inveterate foes ; " they prefer the name of Waldensians and Subalpines to that of Christians!" But these multifarious titles have been productive of more lasting mischief. They have tended to involve the history of these Christians in al- most inextricable confusion, and rendered the study of it any thing but inviting to the general reader. What is still more to be deplored, they have led to disputes 172 LECTURE III. among even Protestant writers, who, misled by the similarity, or perplexed by the number of these wretch- ed nicknames, instead of searching together for the veins of evangelic truth, under whatever kind of strata it might be found, have unhappily quarrelled with each other, and spent their time in idle controversies as to the respective origin of the Waldenses and Albigenses, and the precise differences between the Paulicians and the Paterins.* The advantage which such disputes afford to our Romish adversaries, it is needless to show; and it must increase our regret to know, that they are whol- ly uncalled for. What need we care for the names by which their enemies stigmatized them, when the fact stands out unquestioned, that with the exception of some diversities of sentiment and practice of an inferior kind, which can easily be accounted for from diffe- rences of locality, they all agreed in protesting against the supremacy of the Pope, and the characteristic errors of Popery, and in holding the main distinctive tenets of the Protestant creed ? Another grand device of the enemy, which has suc- ceeded in creating confusion and contention in regard * We might refer particularly to the unhappy turn given to this controversy by Mr Maitland, in his " Tracts and Docu- ments" regarding the ancient Albigenses and Waldenses, in which he attempts, not in the very best spirit, and certainly without any great success, to overthrow the evidence of Mr Faber, in his " Sacred Calendar of Prophecy." The later work of Mr Faber on the Ancient Vallenses and Albigenses, is one of the most complete answers to all the charges which have been brought against the antiquity and theological purity of these chiirches. Considering the tone in Avhich he has been treated by Mr Maitland, we are not surprised that Mr Faber should not have referred, by name, to an opponent to whose boastfully paraded testimonies his work is a more than suffi- cient reply. HISTORY OF THE WALDENSIAN CHURCH. 173 to these churches, was to charge them with the most odious heresies and the most revolting crimes. The Albigenses, in particular, as certain of these Christians were called, have been confidently accused of being Ma- nicheans, a class of heretics who appeared in the early ages of Christianity, and who held, among other things, that the visible universe, or the whole of matter, was the creation of the devil. This charge, which has also been brought against the Paulicians, who emigrated to the south of France, and who are represented as the an- cestors of the Albigenses, has been most satisfactorily disposed of ; and it has been evinced, by a large induc- tion of facts, chiefly drawn from the writings of their accusers, that the only heresies of which they were guilty, were the blessed truths of the gospel which we profess, and that, as in the case of the primitive Chris- tians, against whom the same kind of odious calumnies were raised, the only crime of which they stand con- victed, was that of leading blameless and holy lives. "^ Indeed, when we consider the character of the tribunals before which they were tried ; when we know that they made it a rule to receive the testimony of the most aban- doned characters against them, while they paid no re- gard to the disclaimers of the accused ; when we reflect, moreover, how easy it was for them to put a forced con- struction on the harmless language and the sound sen- timents of a simple and unlettered people, which would amount to a charge of heresy, and how much it was for their interest to show that these separatists were as much opposed to the faith of the gospel as they were to the authority of Rome ; we cease to wonder at the sentences of these monkish courts, and are only amazed * See Faber's Vallenses and Albigenses, pp. 68-270. Peyran's Hist. Defence of the Waldenses or Vaudois, pp. 15, 147. 174 LECTUEE III. at the amount of saving truth which, it appears, even from the testimonies of their antagonists, was held by the much calumniated Churches. Were it in our power to examine the records of these inquisitorial dens, instead of the reports carefully prepared for the eye of the public by interested agents, we have no doubt that evidence still more satisfactory would be found to show that, after the manner which they called heresy, these Christians in the middle ages worshipped in spirit and in truth the God of their fathers. Even as it is, the cloud of unmerited scandal having been blown away, we behold the interesting spectacle of Churches whose antiquity stretches back into the age of the apostles. The Christians in the south of France, during the twelfth century, are seen to be only the re- mote descendants and representatives of Churches which are known to have existed in Armenia under the name of the Paulicians, in the middle of the seventh century, or about the year 650; while those on the Italian side of the Alps, at the same period, can be shown to be merely the gleanings of a harvest of Churches, which remained in a state of independence of Kome and her corruptions from time immemorial, until mowed down by the relentless scythe of persecution.* The Vaudois or Waldenses of Piedmont, to whom it is time to direct our more special attention, are not less interesting a people when viewed as the last relics and representatives of these ancient churches, than they are for their history as a separate church. Dwelling amidst the lofty recesses of the Cottian Alps, in those beautiful and sequestered valleys which are formed by * See Allix's Remarks on the Ancient Churches of Piedmont, p. 10.9, &c. HISTORY OF THE WALDEXSIAN CHURCH. 175 the mountain torrents, this ancient Church has asserted from the earliest ages her independence of Rome, and preserved, in the face of the most relentless and un- wearied persecution, the primitive simplicity of the gospel. The Creator seems to have constructed these retreats for what he designed them to be, — the asylum of a persecuted flock. The scenery presents a striking combination of all that is grand and beautiful in na- ture. Alps piled upon Alps in majestic confusion — tremendous crags intersected by raging torrents — steep gullies, accessible only by a single gorge — appear as if purposely thro'C\'n as a rampart around this little sanctuary of truth ; while the valleys beneath, care- fully cultivated, are so many storehouses in which nature has collected her most luxurious fruits. In this abode, which may be regarded as the hollow of the Almighty's hand, the descendants of this Church reside, down to the present day. Placed between Italy and France, they bear no resemblance to the natives of either country, in manners, language, or re- ligion. " Dwelling alone in the midst of the people," they still retain all the peculiarities of an ancient race ; and in surveying them, one feels, as on inspecting an antique building, curious to know something of their past history. In addition to the confusion arising from that va- riety of names already noticed, it so happens, that by what we can only regard as an unlucky coincidence in the sound and spelling of the words, the Vaudois of Piedmont, who were sometimes termed Waldenses, which some consider a corruption of Vallenses, and sometimes Leonists, from Leo of Ravenna, have been confounded with the followers of Peter Waldo of Lyons, who were also called Waldenses and Lyonists, or Poor 176 LECTURE III. Men of Lyons. It is easy to see how these names should have led to confused and apparently contradic- tory statements in regard to the origin of the Vaudois. But from whatever source they may have derived the name of Waldenses, and whatever other name may have been applied to them, it is beyond all doubt that they existed, as a distinct church and people, many ages before the appearance of Waldo. This person was a rich merchant of Lyons, who came into notice about the middle of the twelfth century, and distinguished himself by his piety, by his translation of the Scrip- tures, and his success in gaining converts to the faith. But anxious as the Romish writers are to identify the persecuted Yaudois of the Alps with the name of Waldo, and thus make them no older than the twelfth century, we have happily sufficient evidence, not only from their own records, but from the writings of their opponents, to show the contrary. It seems but fair, in estimating the antiquity of any people, that we should take into account, as a very material testimony, their own records and traditions. The ancient histories of this people were destroyed by the rage of their enemies, who sought thus to exterminate the memory as well as the whole race of these so-called heretics. But among their manuscripts, which were preserved by Sir Samuel Morland, and deposited in the University of Cam- bridge, there is a catechism bearing the date of 1587, in which the question is put, " How long is it since the pure doctrine has been preached in the valleys ?" and the answer is, " About 500 years, as near as can be gathered from any histories, but according to the opinion of the inhabitants, from father to son, time out of mind." The most venerable of these documents, called the Noble Lesson, which is a simple exposition HISTORY OF THE WALDENSIAN CHURCH. 177 of the Cliristian doctrine in verse, not only bears evi- dence of its own antiquity in its dialect, but contains its precise date, 1100, and speaks of the term Vaudois as even at that period applied to them in contempt. It commences thus : — Brethren, give ear to a noble lesson, — One thousand and one hundred years are completed Since it was written, that we are in the last times. And then, after describing the Christian, it adds, Such a one is termed a Vaudois; And they seek occasion, by lies and deceit, To deprive him of the fruits of his toil. " As for us," said the venerable Peyran to Dr Gilly, " we have been called heretics, and Arians, and Mani- cheans, and Cathari ; but we are, like yourselves, a Church built up in Christ. We have adhered to the pure tenets of the apostolic age, and the Roman Catho- lics have separated from us. Ours is the apostolic suc- cession, from which the Eoman hierarchy has depart- ed."* " Neither," says the brave Henry Arnaud, " has their church ever been reformed ; whence arises its title, Evangelic. The Vaudois are, in fact, descended from those refugees from Italy, who, after St Paul had there preached the gospel, abandoned their beautiful country, and fled, like the woman mentioned in the Apocalypse, to these wild mountains, where they have to this day handed down the gospel from father to son, in the same purity and simplicity as it was preached by St Paul."t « Gilly's Narrative, p. 79. + Blair's Hist, of the Waldenses, i. 7. 178 LECTURE III. Listen to the testimony of their enemies, and you will find that it entirely coincides with their own tra- ditions, and by doing so, furnishes a confirmation of their truth, which has all the weight of the deposition of an adverse witness who voluntarily comes forward to support the declaration of the pannel at the bar. One, for example, tells us, that '" the ancient Yaudois would admit no other name than that of Apostolicals, as they maintain that they are the successors of the apostles and the primitive church." A second declares, that " their origin cannot be found out with certainty, and that in the ninth and tenth centuries they were not a new sect." A third testifies with much bitterness, that " always, and in every age, the valley of Angrogna had been filled with heretics." A fourth makes the same remark regarding Toulouse; while another, who was both an apostate and an inquisitor,* and has written bitterly against them, confesses, that " this sect is the most ancient of all, some supposing that it existed from the days of Pope Sylvester, while others trace its origin from the times of the apostles."t Besides all this, we can account for the prevalence of • Reinerius Sacco, who flourished during the earlier part of the fifteenth century. + Peyran's Hist. Defence of the Vaudois, p. 25-29; Mor- land's Hist, of the Evang. Churches of Piedmont, p. 10-29 ; Gilly's Researches, 78 ; Faber's Vallenses, &c. The two last of these writers have accused Dr M'Crie of denying the anti- quity of the Waldenses, or confounding them with the Albi- genses, in his History of the Reformation in Italy. It is hard- ly necessary to observe, what Mr Faber seems willing to allow, (Vallenses, Preface), that this is an entire mistake, arising from their not attending to the fact, that Dr M'Crie speaks simply of these churches, under whatever name they might go, as alike "the hereditary witnesses for the truth against the corruptions of Rome." (Italy, p. 4, 2d ed. ) HISTORY OF THE WALDENSIAN CHURCH. 179 evangelical sentiments among the Vaudois, and can trace their history in the soundness of their creed and the purity of their lives. The labours of Claude, bishop of Turin, the diocese within which the Valleys were included, in the year 823, eiFected a reformation in the district to such an extent, and in such a spirit, that he deserves to be classed with the most eminent of our reformers. He declared war against all the pre- vailing corruptions of the church, particularly against images, the use as well as worship of which he con- demned. He ordered all the images, and even the crosses, to be cast out of the church, and devoted to the flames. He treated relics with the utmost contempt, and severely inveighed against superstitious pilgrimages to the tombs of the saints. In short, he published com- mentaries on several of the books of Scripture, from which it appears, that he held the leading doctrines of the gospel, and condemned the corruptions of Kome. The Vaudois gratefully acknowledge their obligations to the zealous services of Claude, and to these, among other causes, we may ascribe the Scriptural knowledge, and freedom from superstition, which have ever distin- guished this primitive people. The distinguishing tenets which they held clearly in- dicate their derivation. All agreed in regarding the Church of Rome as the Babylon of the Apocalypse, in denying the corporeal presence in the Eucharist, reject- ing the sacraments of confirmation, confession, and mar- riage, and in charging with idolatry the exposure of images in the churches. The bells which summoned the people to the adoration of these emblems, they called the trumpets of demons. And if the body of Christ, said they, had been as large as one of our moun- tains, it must have been devoured long ago, by the num- 180 LECTURE III. berswhom tliey pretend to have eaten of it."^ But they were no less distinguished for that purity and piety of life, which is the best commentaiy on a sound religious creed. Their adversaries, unable to deny so conspicu- ous a feature, could only account for it by having re- course to the ordinary shift of all such characters, and ascribing it to hypocrisy. " All other sects," says the inquisitor formerly refer- red to, " render themselves odious, by reason of their blasphemies against God himself, but, on the contrary, the Waldenses have great appearances of piety, inas- much as they live justly in the sight of men. They believe well, as concerning God, in all things, and hold all the articles of the creed. There is only one thing against them, and that is, they hate and blaspheme the Church of Rome, and hereby they easily gain credit and belief among the people, "t Another feature illustrative of the Christian charac- ter of this ancient colony, and accounting for the rapid promulgation of their opinions, was their missionary spirit. Like the Church at Jerusalem, when scattered abroad by a great persecution, they went everywhere preaching the gospel. The following curious account, given by a contemporary historian, discovers the mode in which they sometimes improved their opportunities for enlightening their neighbours, and shows that the * Sismondi, Hist, of the Crusades, p. 7. -|- The same testimony to their strict purity is borne by Thu- anus, one of the most candid of Romish historians, who records with high praise the self-devoted act of a Waldensian young woman, who, on being pursued by the soldiers of La Trinita, threw herself headlong from a tremendous precipice into the gulf below, that " by a generous death she might escape the lust of her barbarous pursuers." HISTORY OF THE WALDENSIAN CHURCH. 181 colporteurs of France follow no modern trade.* " The heretics cunningly devise how they may insinuate them- selves into the familiarity of the noble and the great. They exhibit for sale to the lords and ladies, rings, and robes, and other wares which are likely to be accept- able. When they have sold them, if asked whether they have any more goods for sale, one of these travel- ling pedlars will answer : I have jewels far more pre- cious than these, which I will readily give you, if you will secure me against being betrayed to the priests. The security being pledged, the heretic then proceeds to say : I possess a brilliant gem from God himself, for, through it, man comes to the knowledge of God : and I have another which casts out so ruddy a heat, that it forthwith kindles the love of God in the heart of the owner. In like manner proceeds he to speak of all his other metaphorical gems. Then he recites a chapter from Scripture, or from some part of our Lord's dis- courses. — After this the heretic draws a comparison be- tween the Roman Church and the ancient Pharisees: — and then puts the question. Judge ye, which faith is the more perfect, that of our community, or that of the Church of Rome, and when you have honestly judged, choose that which you deem the best."t Animated by such a spirit as this, we need not be surprised to learn, that these Christians of the Alps should have penetrated, not only into Italy and France, but into Germany, « Mr Faber applies this account to the P'rench Waldenses, and maintains that the Vaudois never displayed the migratory and missionary spirit of the Albigenses ; but the truth is, the Christians known under these names always showed this spirit, until compressed by the force of persecution within the narrow limits of the valleys. Peyran, Nouvelles Lettres, pp. 48—56. t Reiner, do Kaeret. Faber, p. 73. 182 LECTURE III. Bohemia, Spain, and even England. Wlierever they went, they carried the light of the gospel with them, and feeble as that light was, it pierced through the thick darkness which it could not dispel, with a pure and steady radiance. Thus, literally " set upon a hill," the Waldenses have verified their ancient device, that of a lighted candle, surrounded by seven stars, and bearing the motto. Lux lucet in teneb7'is, " The light shineth in darkness." And thus may this Church be viewed as the living link between the primitive and the protestant Church, — the archway between the apostles and the reformers. But there is another mark by which we may trace the history of this ancient Church — a mark, alas ! too well descriptive of a Church of Christ — the same by which their cruel persecutors were wont to track the poor fugitives to their retreats in the mountains — the mark of blood. The fury of persecution fell first on tliose that have been termed Albigenses, who occupied the province of Languedoc, in France ; and as we view these Christians as forming part of the same Church, under another name, with that of the Vaudois, who were merely the grape-gleanings of the vintage, we may ad- vert a little to the suiferings they underwent. In the year 1208, the vengeance of the Court of Rome was di- rected against this unhappy people, under pretext of waging war against their sovereign, Raymond, Count of Toulouse. The Pope issued a Bull, in which he ordered that this prince should be anathematized in all the churches. " As we must not observe faith," said his holiness, " with those who keep not faith towards God, or who are separated from the communion of the faithful, we discharge, by apostolic authority, all those who believe themselves bound to this Count by any HISTORY OF THE WALDENSIAN CHURCH. 183 oath of alliance or fidelity ; we permit every catholic man to pursue his person, to occupy and retain his ter- ritories, especially for the purpose of exterminating heresy."* On the faith of this barbarous edict, the monks began to preach up crusades against the here- tics ; and, in an incredibly short period, the plains of France presented a most extraordinary spectacle. A thousand knights, the flower of Erench chivalry, are drawn up in battle array, encased in iron armour. Bishops have blessed their standards, and engaged to pray for their success. Priests have absolved them from all their sins, past and prospective, and promised them heaven for the blood which they are to shed. Each of these mailed warriors is a pilgrim, engaged, he thinks, in a holy war, on which Heaven smiles, and to feel pity for the victims of which would, in his appre- hension, be a crime to be confessed to the priest, and only to be wiped oiF by bathing in the blood of his fellow-creatures. These are the Crusaders ; and along with them are fifty thousand meaner men, — persons of the most abandoned characters, animated at once by the lust of rapine, the rage of bigotry, and the hope of heavenly pardon. At the head of this fanatical band is Simon de Montfort, a name which stands out in the annals of history, stained with every crime that can tarnish the laurels of the hero. Onwards rolls the fiery mass to the scene of its destination. The Count of Toulouse, trembling at their approach, yields to the Pope, and is only forgiven on condition of his joining in the bloody expedition. They approach the town of Beziers, where sixty thou- sand people, including women and children, are assem- * Sismondi's History of the Crusades, p. 21, 184 LECTURE III. bled, among whom are many Roman Catholics. These, when required by their bishop to betray their fellow-citizenSj nobly refuse ; and the inhabitants, animated by a common sentiment of devotion to their country, make a vigorous but unsuccessful resistance. The knights of the crusade, having asked the Pope's legate how they are to distinguish between the catho- lics and the heretics, receive the celebrated reply, "Kill them all; the Lord tvill know well who are hisT His orders are executed to the letter; not a living creature escapes ; and when the last of the sixty thou- sand are massacred, they set fire to the city, and re- duce it to one vast funereal pile ! In vain do the wretched inhabitants, filled with consternation on hearing of this horrible act, betake themselves to fortified places, hitherto deemed impreg- nable; it is only to be gathered to the slaughter. De Montfort has brought with him engines of war hitherto unknown. Among these is one which, from its form and mode of working, was named the Cat. A huge moveable wooden tower, covered with sheepskins, is moved by the soldiers within, close to the wall of the beseiged city. Its side then opens, and an im- mense beam, armed with iron hooks, is projected like the paw of the cat, which shakes the wall with re- iterated blows, and then with its claws tears out and pulls down the loosened stones. With this instrument De Montfort approaches the strongly fortified castle of Cabaret; tlie cat is pushed forward, and its terrible claws soon open a passage for the knights of the cru- sade. The priests, clad in their pontifical habits, await with undisguised eagarness the commencement of the carnage ; and the result may be told in the lan- guage of one of them who was present. " Very soon," HISTORY OF THE WALDENSIAN CHURCH. 185 says he, " they dragged out the knights of the castle. The noble Count immediately ordered them to be hang- ed; but perceiving that this would occasion delay, he commanded the rest to be massacred ; and the pilgrims (i. e. Crusaders) receiving the order with the greatest avidity, very soon massacred them all on the spot. The lady of the castle, who was an execrable heretic, was, by the Count's orders, thrown into a pit, which was filled up with stones. Afterwards our pilgrims collected the innumerable heretics that the castle contained, and burned them alive with the utmost joy T'^ The Crusaders, however, did not always proceed to immediate execution. Candour requires us to state, that, on one occasion at least, they proposed to their victims to save their lives, on the simple condition of abjuring their religion. The castle of Minerva sur- rendered after a vigorous siege; the Crusaders entered singing Te Deum, and found the men assembled in one house, and the women in another, preparing themselves, on their knees, for the fate they anticipated. An ab- bot was ordered to preach to them ; but men and wo- men unanimously refused to comply with his terms: " We will have none of your faith; we have renounced the Church of Rome." De Montford ordered an im- mense pile of wood to be erected in the square, and the people, amounting to more than a hundred and forty, were conducted to the spot. " Be converted to the Ca- tholic faith," cried the Count, " or ascend that pile." Not one complied with his demand. The fire was kin- dled, and filled the square with the conflagration. But no force was required to fulfil the other part of his al- ternative. The martyrs voluntarily plunged into the flames. * Sismondi, pp. 05, 76. 186 LECTURE III. By a series of atrocities like these, which the writers of romance require to conceal, lest the effect of their gaudy pictures of the Crusades should be spoiled, and the delicate feelings of their readers should be shocked, but which the pen of faithful history has disclosed, the plains to the north of the Alps were laid desolate. The Inquisition, following in the wake of the crusaders, completed their work; and those branches of the Alpine church, which have been called the Albigenses, were all but exterminated. Still, however, the churches in the valleys of Piedmont, and in Calabria, protected partly by the inaccessible nature of their country, partly by the cupidity of their rulers, who derived much of their re- venues from their industry, continued to flourish ; and so long as they existed, proved an eye-sore to the Pon- tiff and his clergy. In the year 1400, an attack was made on the Valley of Pragela, when the ground being covered with snow, the inhabitants were taken by sur- prise, and found themselves shut up to one retreat alone, a mountain called the Albergo. Thither they fled with their wives and children, pursued by the ruthless invaders. Mothers were seen carrying their infants, and leading their children by the hand ; but thus encumbered, many were overtaken and cruelly put to death. The inclemency of an Alpine winter night finished what the soldiers began. When the morning dawned, eighty infants were found dead in their cradles, and their mothers expiring by their side. Some blows leave a scar on a nation's heart which time cannot efface. Two hundred years after this catas- trophe, the natives of Pragela could not mention it without a shudder; and it is not forgotten even to this day. Rome needs not to renew her persecutions again : she has only to show her teeth, to prove her unchanged HISTORY OF THE WALDENSIAN CHURCH. 187 temper, and she will revive the memory of the past, and marshall against her every generous feeling that God has planted in the breast of man. Patient as the Vaudois were under unavoidable suf- fering, they were not so destitute of spirit as to suffer themselves to be cut down as Christians, when they were able to fight for themselves as men; nor could they tamely submit to see their wives and children butchered before their eyes, so long as they had brawny arms and brave hearts to defend them. In this, as in many other points, they bear a close resemblance to our own Scottish forefathers in the time of persecution. About the close of the fifteenth century, when 18,000 troops were mustered against them, under the profaned banner of the cross, they turned upon their assailants. Planting themselves in the straits of their mountain fortresses, the front ranks protected with long wooden shields, while those behind fought with slings and cross-bows, they repulsed the attack. On this occa- sion, while their fathers and brothers were engaged in the unequal conflict, the women and children, placed in the rear, were loudly imploring on their knees the assistance of Heaven, crying, " God, help us !" Their prayers, which excited the ridicule of the brutal and bigotted soldiery, seemed to have been listened to with more regard by their heavenly Protector, — a dense fog which descended on the mountains having completely confounded and dispersed their assailants.* It is extremely interesting to notice, as the Reforma- tion began to dawn on Europe, how gladly its healing beams were hailed by these watchmen and witnesses on the mountains, and how cordially, and, as it were, ♦ Perrin, 153. 188 LECTURE III. instinctively, they adjoined themselves to the Reformers. No sooner did they hear of this event, than they sent some of their pastors as deputies to wait upon and consult with the most eminent of the Reformers. In the month of October 1530, two of these deputies, George Morel and Peter Masson, visited Haller and Ecolampade at Basle, and Bucer and Capito at Stras- burg. They told them that having heard of the gifts of the Holy Spirit bestowed on the Reformers, as ap- peared by their blessed fruits, they had come to share in their illumination, and obtain instruction on some points on which they were in doubt, and others on which they modestly acknowledged and deplored their ignorance, which they ascribed partly to their own neg- ligence, and partly to the unfavourable circumstances in which they had been lately placed. " Such as we are," said they, "we are poor instructors of a little liock, which has now for four hundred years, nay, ac- cording to the general tradition of our people, from the time of the apostles, lived among cruel thorns, though not, as good men may easily conceive, without the spe- cial favour of Christ." They then gave a long account of their ecclesiastical discipline, their doctrine, worship, and customs. Thus brought into contact with the re- formers, without having had any previous concert with or knowledge of each other, it is striking to observe how closely, in all the leading points of doctrine, and even of discipline, they were found to agree together. Guid- ed by the same Word and the same Spirit, never was there a more complete illustration of what the apostle denominates " the unity of the faith and of the know- ledge of the Son of God." Their confession of faith, so far as it went, was nearly, in the eyes of our reformers, unexceptionable; and the few points on which the de- HISTORY OF THE WALDENSIAN CHURCH. 189 puties expressed doubts, referred to doctrines of an ab- struse and controversial kind, with respect to which, as held by Luther and others, they had received a garbled account. The only points of discipline on which they followed a different practice from the re- formed churches, were that, they retained something like confession, when consolation or advice was re- quired, but without superstition or tyranny — that their pastors lived for the most part unmarried — and that they had females, called sisters, who lived together under a vow of perpetual celibacy."^ On other points, there was the most wonderful agreement. Their pas- tors, or harhes as they were called, were set apart to the holy ministry by prayer, and by the imposition of the hands of their brethren, and were freely elected by the people. On being presented before them, they were to entreat the people to receive them, and to pray God for them that they might be worthy of such a charge. They had no other food or raiment than what was be- stowed on them by the free charity of the good people whom they instructed, or what they gained by the labour of their own hands, the young and able-bodied pastors being expected to Avork at some employment, though the aged were exempted from such a necessity.f Attempts have been made to show that they had • These practices do not appear to have existed among them in the earlier ages of their Church, but to have been intro- duced after the 12th century, with the view of wiping away the odious calumnies propagated against them by their po- pish enemies. Faber's Vallenses, p. 475. For the same pur- pose, they had been for some time in the habit of occasion- ally attending mass in the popish chapels, a practice which they agreed to abandon, on the recommendation of the re- formers. f Ruchat, Hist. Reform. Suisse, ii. 252. Perrin, 210. 190 LECTURE III. bishops, and the Episcopal form of government, and even of worship, among them. But never were at- tempts of this nature more unsuccessful. Such asser- tions are contradicted by the ancient constitutions of the Waldensian Church, by the testimonies of their enemies, and by their owti unvaried disclaimers. Sir Samuel Morland has observed, that such suppositions are "mere fictitious notions and chimeras," and that " none of their pastors were empowered to act in the least matter without the consent and advice of their brethren and associates in the ministry." Their form of government was, in fact, purely Presbyterian. " As to their synodical constitutions," says the same writer, *' their manuscripts tell us that the barbes, or pastors, assembled once a-year, to treat of their affairs in a gene- ral council — that this council was constantly held in the month of September, and that some hundreds of years ago, there were seen assembled together in one synod, no less than a hundred and forty barbes." The same manuscript adds, that " they had always their con- sistories, and a form of discipline among themselves, except it were in the time of persecution, and then the barbes had their consistories in secret, and did also preach to their congregations, during the winter season, in their own private houses, and in the summer time, upon the tops of mountains, as the people were there feeding their flocks.*" The Waldensian deputies having heard that a difference of practice prevailed among the reformers on this point, made it one of their questions for information, "If there ought to be degrees of dignity among the ministers of the Word of God, such as bishops, priests, and deacons V And Ecolam- * aiorland, p. 179—183. HISTORY OF THE WALDENSIAN CHURCH. 191 pade, in his answer to this inquiry, stated, that while ministers of the gospel ought to avoid those titles and degrees of dignity, which savoured of Papistical pomp and pride, he saw no harm in some of them being pre- sidents alone, while others gave themselves to the preaching of the Word ; and that some might be visi- tors, whom, if they chose, they might call bishops." But this suggestion, moderate as it was, was never adopted by the Vaudois; their ministers remained simple pastors; and even to this day, notwithstanding endeavours made to introduce something like the Epis- copal form among them, by those who had showed them much kindness, and whose wishes they had every temp- tation to gratify, they have uniformly adhered to the simplicity of their ancient Discipline.* On other points, they were found to* have the same agreement with the great body of the reformed Churches. The Commis- sioners appointed in 1506, by Louis XII. of France, to examine into the truth of the false reports which had been circulated against the Vaudois, reported to their master, " that they had visited all the parishes and temples of the places mentioned ; that they found nei- ther images, nor the smallest appearance of any orna- ments, nor of the masses and ceremonies of the Church of Rome ; that the people were not guilty either of sor- cery nor impurity, nor of any of the horrible crimes re- lated of them, but lived like honest men, without in- juring any one ; that they obsei^ved their Sabbaths » An attempt having been lately made to induce them at least to appoint one as perpetual moderator of their Synods, it was unanimously resisted. Among others who spoke against it, was a venerable elder of the Church, who said, — " What would our friends in Scotland say or think of us, if we should adopt the constant moderator ?" 192 LECTURE III. with punctuality ; that they caused their infants to be baptized according to the order of the primitive Church ; that they taught their children the articles of the Chris- tian faith, and of the ten commandments of God ; that they prayed with their eyes lifted up to heaven ; and that the Word of God was purely expounded among them." On hearing this report, Louis exclaimed with an oath, " These men are better than I and the rest of my Catholic people." We shall only add here, that the deputies having returned to the valleys, a meeting of Synod was held at Angrogna, at which, aided by the suggestions of the reformers, several practical errors into which they had fallen were corrected, and a new Con- fession of Faith was drawn up, embodying the doctrines of the Reformation, which was cordially subscribed and solemnly sworn to in September '1532. This Confes- sion having been approved of by the Reformers, the Vaudois may, from this date, be viewed as forming a branch of the great Protestant family. Vital religion was revived by this happy union ; and it may be truly said, " The wilderness and the solitary place was glad for them, and the desert did rejoice and blossom as the rose." It is often seen, however, in the history of Christ's church, that a time of spiritual awakening and religi- ous attainment is followed by a season of severe trial. In 1536, Francis I., the king of France, having con- quered Piedmont, was induced by the solicitations of the Pope to sanctify his conquest by attempting the conversion, or, failing in that, the extermination of his heretical subjects. Deaf to their humble entreaties, he swore that " he did not burn Lutherans in France to permit a reserve of them in the Alps." He commenced by employing the arm of the law. The parliament of HISTORY OF THE WALDEKSIAN CHURCH. 193 Turin commanded them, on pain of death, to dismiss their revered pastors, who had spoken to them the word of God, and receive a relay of priests to sing masses to them. The Vaudois nobly replied, " that they could by no means obey commands contrary to the laws of God, and that they would render to Cesar the things that were Cesar's, and to God the things that are God's."* Soon the sounds of war, and the shrieks of massacre, were heard on both sides of the Alps. On the one side, next to France, stood two smiling towns, Me- rindoles and Cabrieres. These were doomed to fire and sword, and a wretch, named Oppeda, was charged with the execution. The inhabitants were destroyed with- out regard to age or sex. Forty females were locked in a barn, and the straw within having been set on fire, the poor creatures, on attempting to escape, were driven back by the spears of the gallant soldiers, and miserably perished in the flames. Mothers, having their breasts cut off, were left to perish with their in- fants. But it were too shocking to dwell on these barbarities. Upwards of eight hundred perished in Cabrieres alone. On the other side of the Alps, in Calabria, where a flourishing colony of the Vaudois had long been permitted to dwell in peace by their rulers, who derived a rich revenue from their industry, the court of Rome found another bloody revenge. Here there was not even the poor pretext of war. No trumpet sounded to battle ; even the excitement of the chase was awanting; it was a human battue, for the victims were found cooped up in their hiding-places, and made no resistance. The scene [.wanted even the decent formalities of a judicial execution. It was con- * Blair, vol. ii. p. 222. 194 LECTURE III. ducted with all the coolness and deliberation of the shambles. " To tell you the truth/' says an eye-wit- ness, " I can compare it to nothing but the slaughter of so many sheep. They were all shut up in one house as in a sheep-fold. The executioner went, and bring- ing out one of them, covered his face with a napkin, led him out to a field near the house, and making him kneel down, cut his throat with a knife. Then taking off the bloody napkin, he went and brought out an- other, whom he put to death after the same manner. In this way the whole number, amounting to eighty- eight men, were butchered."* Woe to the men whose religion is thus perverted! and woe to the religion which thus perverts men, stifling the natural emotions of the breast, and turning man into a monster, more cruel to his kind than the beasts that roam in the forest ! While such scenes were transacting at their feet, on their brethren of the same blood and faith, the Vaudois of the Alps could not expect to remain unmolested. In 1560, the troops of Savoy, whose Duke had regain- ed his dominions, led on l:)y the unprincipled La Tri- nita, were commissioned by the Pope and cardinals to exterminate the inhabitants of the valleys. In vain did they try, by menace and cajolery, to induce these simple mountaineers to make submission to Rome. Reluctant to draw the sword against their native prince, they agreed at first to relinquish their abodes in the valleys, and retreat to the loftiest of their moun- tains, preferring, under the Divine protection, to en- counter the storms and snows of the Alps, rather than embrace the religion, or trust in the mercy, of their ♦ Reformation in Italy, bv Dr M'Crie, p. 305. HISTORY OF THE WALDENSIAN CHURCH. 195 enemies. Aged men, women, and children, might be seen carried by their friends, or dragging their feeble limbs to the place of safety. But even there were they followed by their blood-thirsty pursuers. Hem- med in on every side, driven to bay, and provoked be- yond endurance by the infamous La Trinita, who vio- lated every treaty, torturing and murdering all who came within his reach, the spirit of the Vaudois was roused, and by a well-sustained guerilla warfare, they repulsed the veteran troops of Savoy, and procured at length a temporary respite. During the truce that followed, an incident oc- curred which illustrates the absurd calumnies propa- gated against this harmless people, by their bigotted persecutors. It was not only alleged that the Vaudois fought with poisoned weapons, and that they used the arts of sorcery, but that nature had stamped the mark of infamy on their offspring, — that their infants were born with black throats, with four rows of teeth, and one eye in the middle of the forehead, like the cy clops. Philip VII., Duke of Savoy, having expressed a desire to see some of their children, to satisfy himself on this point by ocular inspection, twelve infants were brought down to him from the mountains, along with their mothers. On being exhibited to the Duke, he inspect- ed the babes with intense interest, and declared, that " he had never seen prettier children in his life." The subsequent history of the Vaudois presents little more than a repetition of the scenes we have attempted to describe, more or less melancholy and disastrous. In this respect it differs considerably from the history of our native country, which has its periods of sun- shine as well as storm, and which, even in the darkest of its persecutions, exhibits some redeeming traits of 196 lectuhe hi, happiness^ and even of humour. The history of the Waldenses maj be read in tears, may be heard with sighs; but it can never, by any chance, awaken a smile. Another dissimilarity must have struck you, in the wholesale character of the martyrdoms of the Alps. In Scotland we had our single martyrs, our Wisharts and Hamiltons under Popery — our Argyles and Camer- ons under Prelacy — whose individual sufferings, and specific testimonies, even in the very words they uttered, have been embalmed in our martyrologies. The Vau- dois, again, were offered up in hecatombs, and few par- ticular cases have been left on record. Their execu- tioners were whole armies; the scaffolds on which they bled, were their own snow-clad mountains; and as " there was none to bury their dead bodies," there was none to transmit their dying testimonies. How true, as well as beautiful the lines of our own Milton, whose muse was inspired by the distant report of their suffer- " Avenge, O Lord, thy slaughtered saints, whose bones Lie scattered on the Alpine mountains cold : Even them who kept thy truth so pure of old. When all our fathers worshipped stocks and stones, Forget not; in thy book record their groans. Who were thy sheep, and in their ancient fold, Slain by the bloody Piedmontese that rolled, Mother with infant down the rocks. Their moans The vales redoubled to the hills, and they To heaven. Their martyr'd blood and ashes sow O'er all the Italian fields, where still doth sway The triple tyrant; that from these may grow An hundred others, who having learnt thy way, Early may fly the Babylonian woe !" A few examples, however, of individual suffering have reached us, and one of these, which took place in HISTORY OF THE WALDENSIAN CHURCH. 197 the beginning of the seventeenth century, we may briefly notice. Bartholomew Copin was a Vaudois merchant in the valley of Lucerne, and had come in the way of his business to the fair of Aost. When at sup- per with some other merchants, one of the company began to inveigh, in the most insulting terms, against the inhabitants of the valleys. Copin, provoked at his insolence, spoke up in their defence. " What!" said the reviler, " are you a Vaudois?" He acknowledged he was. " And do you not believe that God is in the host?" " No," said Copin. " Faugh !" replied the other. " What a farce of a religion is yours !" " My religion," said Copin, " is as true as that there is a God, and as sure as death." The next day he was summoned be- fore the Bishop of Aost, who told him that he must confess his crime or suiFer for it. The honest mer- chant refused to acknowledge any fault. He had some property, he said, with a wife and children, but he would sacrifice all for a good conscience. He pled, too, that he had not violated any civil law. The bishop, however, would hear of nothing but submission. He was thrown into prison ; there he was visited by an inquisitor, who tried him first with honied speeches, but finding him obdurate, ended with curses. " Be- gone, thou cursed Lutheran," cried the enraged monk ; " thou shalt go to the devil, and when tormented by unclean spirits, thou shalt repent of thy obstinacy, in choosing to go to hell, rather than be reconciled to holy mother church." '• It is a long time now," said Copin, " since I was reconciled to the holy Church." To subdue his fortitude, his wife and son were permit- ted to see and sup with him in prison ; but he spent the time in reconciling them to their approaching loss; and having blessed his son, he took an affecting farewell 198 LECTURE III. of his wife, exhorting them to live in the fear of God. Their cries and tears, on leaving him in the prison, were enough to melt a heart of stone. But Copin with- stood the temptation. " My dearest companion," he wrote to his wife, " I received much consolation from your visit. I feel persuaded we shall never meet to- gether again. May God comfort you and bless you. Be not concerned about me ; for if it please God that I have reached the end of my days, and that I now ren- der back the soul he has lent me so long, I trust he will receive it into heaven, through his Divine mercy, for the love of his holy Son, Jesus Christ, through whose holy death and passion I believe that our sins are washed away." One morning, sometime afterwards, the body of the martyr was found strangled in prison, lest his confession and constancy should be publicly known, and thereafter it was drao-ged from the dun- geon, and committed to the flames.* At length, in the year 1655, the implacable enemies of the Vaudois gained the object after which they had been striving for centuries — the expulsion of this pri- mitive race of witnesses from the Valleys. In that fa- tal year, which bears the blackest mark, even in the dark calendar of this oppressed Church, the Duke of Savoy, under the instigation of the court of Rome, and among other reasons to make room for the Irish Pa- pists who had been banished by Cromwell for their atrocities during the rebellion, t lent himself to a scene of atrocity which has hardly its parallel in the history of civilized nations. By an order issued by Gastaldo, the legate, all of the reformed religion were * Perrin, 177-183. -}- Leger, part ii. chap. vii. HISTORY OF THE WALDENSIAN CHURCH. 199 ordered to withdraw from and abandon their native valleys, within the space of three days, under the pain of death and confiscation, unless they became Roman Catholics. The hardship of such an order, issued in the midst of winter, when the ground was covered with snow, may be easily conceived. We shall not at- tempt to describe the distress and consternation into which the poor people were throAvn, when old and young, the blind and bed-rid, the sick and dying, be- took themselves to their retreats on the mountains, and prepared for their melancholy departure. Nor shall we attempt to sketch the misery and devastation that followed, — " a story," says honest Morland, " so lined and interwoven with horrible attempts, such bloody edicts, such profound stratagems, and barbarous persecutions, — whole families miserably ruined, and the innocent blood of the saints poured out as water on the ground, — insomuch that my spirit has often waxed cold within me, and my heart even failed me, yea, my very hand has trembled, as with a fit of palsy, in the writing thereof" The barbarities inflicted by the savage soldiery, on the unfortunate people who fell into their hands, are too fearful for description. The ears of men in the nineteenth century have be- come too delicate to hear what the hands of men were found capable of perpetrating at the time to which we refer. And 1 can only darkly insinuate, that the ope- rations of the butcher on the carcase, and of the ana- tomist on the corpse, combined with those of the miner in exploding his quarry, and, I may add, the cannibal on the shores of Africa, convey a dim idea of the atro- cities committed on the living bodies of the poor Vau- dois. The cry of their oppression rung through Eu- rope, and met with a response in every Protestant 200 LECTURE III. bosom. To his eternal honour as a man, and as the ruler of a Protestant country, Oliver Cromwell pro- rested, on hearing the sad tale, that " it lay as near, to rather nearer, his heart, than if it had concerned his nearest and dearest relations in the world."* He imme- diately dispatched Sir Samuel Morland as his ambassa- dor to the courts of France and Turin, to remonstrate against the bloody policy which they were pursuing towards a people whom he regarded as his brethren in the faith; and not obscurely intimated that, if the per- secutions were not arrested, he would make common cause with the sufierers. Not content with this, he sent letters to all the Protestant states, inviting them to join in the interposition; and a collection was or- dered throughout England in behalf of the suflferers, which speedily amounted to nearly L. 40,000. Never was the voice of Old England heard in a juster and holier quarrel. It does one's heart good to see how the craven spirits of the persecutors quailed, and how they apologised and slunk back from their bloody work, be- fore the noble remonstrance of the blunt soldier of the commonwealth. Cromwell, however, died; the treaty which he procured in the favour of the Vaudois was violated; they were at last driven from their valleys, and the miserable remains of them were obliged to be- take themselves for shelter to the cantons of Switzer- land. Eor upwards of twenty years, during what may be considered the dark age of Protestantism, when the Huguenots of France, and the covenanters of Scot- land, were passing through the furnace of persecution, the ancient valleys of the Vaudois were desolate and deserted; the incense of praise and prayer no longer * Morland, 552. HISTORY OF THE WALDENSIAN CHURCH. 201 ascended ; and nothing was heard save the blasphemies of their invaders, echoed by the scream of the moun- tain eagle, as he rose scared from feeding on the bloody and bleached remains of the slaughtered saints. But Providence had determined that these valleys should be re-peopled with their ancient inhabitants. We can only advert to one of the most remarkable scenes in the annals of Protestantism, — the glori- ous return of the Vaudois to their native mountains, under the chieftainship of their noble-minded pastor, Henri Arnaud. In August 1G89, — a year remarkable for the deliverance of our own country from Popish tyranny — Arnaud, after a day spent in fasting and prayer for the Divine help, set out from Switzerland with between eight and nine hundred of his banished countrymen. Never was the hand of Providence more visible in any expedition of the same nature. Boats seemed to be kept ready waiting to convey them over rivers — battalions of armed men opened up a passage for them — the darkness of night and the light of day seemed alike to favour them — and the heavens seemed prepared either to hurl its hail and lightning in the face of their foes, or to cast a mantle of mist around the little band, to favour their escape. Day after day were they hunted from mountain to mountain, dealing destruction on their opponents ; and when at last, be- fore a tremendous host and train of artillery, their last retreat was demolished, " Retreat we must, my brave friends," exclaimed Arnaud, " though our road should lie over ravine and precipice. Better far to meet death, shattered on the rocks, than surrender our bodies to infamy and death in the hands of our ene- mies." " See," he continued, pointing to a cloud of mist which came at that moment rollinof down the val- 202 LECTURE III. ley ; " see how the hand of Jehovah is, in this hour of our extremity, outstretched to save us." It was even so. Enveloped in its sable curtain, they were enabled, by sliding and catching at projections, to descend the frightful precipice undiscovered. Next morning, when the enemy arrived at the post they had occupied, ex- pecting an easy and full revenge, they found it deserted, and saw the undaunted mountaineers high above them on another of the Alps, and far beyond their reach. Of these brave and devoted men, the present Wal- denses are the descendants. They would soon, to all human appearance, have been crushed, had not Provi- dence again stirred up the Protestant states to aid them. They found efficient friends in the persons of King William, and his pious queen, Mary, who founded a royal subsidy for their support, which in the reign of George III., was converted into a national grant. During the last century, repeated attempts have been made to expel or exterminate them, which have been providentially thwarted ; and nothing affords a clearer proof of the inextinguishable hatred borne towards them by their Popish neighbours, than the fact, that one of the basest of these attempts was discovered, when on the eve of being executed by agents of the Sardinian government, shortly after the French Revolution, al- though the Waldenses proved so strictly loyal to the king of Sardinia, that they refused to submit to the con- quering arms of Napoleon, and fought in the ranks of their ungrateful prince, until he was compelled to sur- render. But though thus saved from extinction, they have been strictly confined, since the beginning of last century, to three of their valleys. Lucerne, Perouse, and St Martin. Every means which legal tyranny and Jesuitical chicanery can devise, have been used to de- HISTORY OF THE WALDENSIAN CHURCH. '20S grade and depress them ; and at this moment they are almost as dependant on the sympathy and succour of their Protestant friends in more favoured lands, as when they were suiFering from the fire and sword of persecu- tion. Next to the miraculous preservation of the Jews, the continuance of this little Church in the very heart and centre of Popery, may be regarded as one of the most striking of the standing miracles which confirm our holy faith. Surely Divine Providence must have some great end to fulfil by the instrumentality of a Church which he has so wonderfully preserved. It is not pre- sumptuous, we trust, to conclude, that it may have been preserved as an agent for diffusing the light of the gos- pel through poor benighted Italy, and thus, by sup- porting it, we may be lending a hand to the overthrow of that system of superstition and tyranny which has there so long held its seat. Let it be hoped, that the final effort which that system is now making to regain all, and more than all, its past ascendancy, may have the blessed effect of uniting all the sections of the Pro- testant Church together, and that the descendants of those who have suffered under her dominion, may meet to hold their jubilee over her downfall, according to the promise, " Rejoice over her, thou heaven, and ye holy apostles and prophets, for God hath avenged you on her." LECTUPvE IV. On the Pkesent Condition and Future Prospects of the Waldensian Church. BY THE REV. ROBERT W. STEWART, A.M., LATE OF ERSKINE. The armorial legend of the Protestant valleys of Piemont, from time immemorial, has been " Lux lu- cet in tenebris ;"* and it contains, remarkably enough, a truthful epitome of their history. Somewhat similar in signification is the motto of Geneva, the model church of the Reformation, " Post tenebras lux,"t and yet in the use of the same words, there is sufficient diversity to establish a striking contrast between a pri- mitive and reformed church. Though poor and despis- ed by the world, the Vaudois community lays claim to the high prerogative of being called a primitive church. From father to son an unbroken tradition has been handed down among them, which the writings of their enemies have unwittingly confirmed, that the doctrines they maintain were received directly from the apostles ; and Henri Arnaud, their renowned pastor-chief, has left * " The light shineth in darkness." f " After the darkness light." 206 PRESENT CONDITION AND FUTURE PROSPECTS OF on record this testimony concerning them, which has never been denied, " neither has their church been ever reformed, whence arises its title of evangelic."* Their eventful history during past ages — their earnest " contendings for the faith once delivered to the saints" — the cruel massacres, by which they were repeatedly in danger of being entirely exterminated — and the atroci- ties, too shocking for detail, perpetrated upon them by a dissolute soldiery, goaded on by the blood-hounds of the Inquisition, have all combined to associate with their name, a vague traditionary interest, more sacred in character, though similar in kind, to that which is awakened by the names of Bruce and Wallace in read- ing the annals of our own country. Unfortunately for them, as well as for us, this interest on our part, up to the present period, has partaken more of the passive ad- miration, mingled with regret, which one is apt to in- dulge over the memory of departed excellence, than of that active sympathy, which calls into exercise imme- diate and sustained exertion on behalf of brethren still enduring persecution and distress. We have been wont to talk of the Vaudois as a valiant and religious race, who, after holding up the lamp of truth, amid the thick darkness of the middle ages, and " resisting unto blood, striving against sin," merged both their testimony and their existence in the churches of the Reformation, ra- ther than as a living church, still bearing witness to the truth, and suffering in our own times a constant and painful oppression at the hands of " the man of sin, the * •■' The Glorious Recovery," by Henri Arnaud, pref. p. 14, edit. Lon., 1827. The original work, in French, dedicated to Queen Anne, is exceedingly rare; not more than eight copies are known to be in existence, and one of these is now deposited in the library of the Free Church College, in Edinburgh. THE WALDEXSIAN CHURCH. 207 son of perdition." To this mistaken view of their his- tory, I apprehend, is to be attributed the unenviable position Scotland has, up to a very recent period, occu- pied, as the only Protestant nation in Europe which has never, in its national capacity, contributed towards the alleviation of their poverty and distress. If this be the true cause of the vague sentimentalism so long en- tertained towards the Vaudois, it has only to be pro- claimed upon the house-top, that they are living, wit- nessing, suffering still, to awaken on their behalf an active and universal sympathy. Amid the deep re- cesses of the mountain valleys, surrounded by the stupendous precipices, the dark-blue glaciers, and un- trodden snow of the everlasting Alps, there exists at this moment a Church, venerable for its anti- quity, which reaches back to apostolic times, and lovely for its simplicity and comparative purity, — a Church which, though it waxed small under the iron rod of persecution, has yet outlived the most unheard-of and revolting cruelties, and which during the dark ages, when " all the earth wondered after the beast," was the sole depository of gospel light throughout Europe — a witness prophesying in sackcloth for the truth of God. Such is the evangelic Church of the val- leys of Piemont ! — nurtured in a sterile soil — com- pressed within narrow boundaries — composed for the most part of poor unlettered peasants, — yet in it has been treasured up the " salt of the earth," wherewith in days past the kingdoms of the Reformation have been salted ; and with which also, so far as man can judge, it seems the purpose of Him " who is wonderful in counsel," that the benighted kingdoms of France and of Italy shall in due time be purified. Some modern writers have drawn a distinction be- 208 PRESENT CONDITION AND EUTURE PROSPECTS OF tween the names Waldenses and Yaudois, afFirming that the latter is the proper appellation of this moun- tain community, while the former is a Popish term of opprobrium, intended to mark them out as a sect de- riving their origin from Peter Waldo, the rich merchant of Lyons. It is certainly true, that Popish writers have called them Waldenses in this sense, against which we find them protesting in some of their public docu- ments ; but that is no sufiicient reason for the distinc- tion, as the ingenious and erudite Faber,* following Beza, satisfactorily makes out that Peter of Lyons de- rived his sirname Waldo from these very valleys, of which he was a native, while the name Yallenses (from which Waldenses has been derived) was applied to their inhabitants at least a century before his birth. Their own historian, Leger.f assures us, that the names, Val- lenses, Valdesi, and Vandois, by all of which that peopl-e are known, have been derived from the valleys they inha- bit, according as the dialect used was that of ancient or modern Italy, or of Gaul. " Those," says he, " who first called the valleys Vaux, called its inhabitants Vau- dois, meaning simply by the name Yaudois, those who dwelt in the Vaux, in the same way that others called them Valdesi or Vcddenses, having regard to the word Vol, or if you will, to the Latin and Italian words Vallis and Valle.'' At one period, the Yaudois Church extended over a considerable portion of the province of Dauphino in Prance, but it has again been reduced within its origin- al limits in the valleys of Piemont, situated between Monte Yiso and the Col de Sestriere, at the eastern * Faber's Vallcnses and Albigenses. -j- Leger Histoire Gen. des Eglises Vaudoises, p. 17, edit. Levdc,^16G9. THE WALDENSIAN CHURCH. 209 base of the Cottian Alps, extending, according to Dr Gilly's estimate, twenty-two miles north and south, and eighteen miles east and west. These valleys are gener- ally said to be three in number, viz., Val Lucerna, throuofh which flows the river Police, — Val Perosa, through which flows the river Clusone, — and Val St Marfcino, watered by the torrent Germanasca; but pro- perly speaking there are jivey the other two, Val di Rora, and Val d' Angrogna, though both smaller, being far the most celebrated during the struggles for religious freedom in which their inhabitants were engaged, dur- ing the fearful massacre of 1655. On approaching the Vaudois territory from Pinerolo and Bricherasio, the coup d'oeil is varied and most magnificent. To the right, on the top of one of the undulating hills which separate the Val Lucerna from the Val Perosa, lies the commune of Prarustino, with its white church peeping out gracefully at intervals from the forest of chesnut and walnut trees which sur- round it. This parish, which has two Protestant churches within its bounds, one at St Bartholomeo, and the other at Piocca-piatta, is now the only connecting link between the two Protestant valleys which open from the plains of Piemont; though both Leger and Sir Samuel Morland, in their histories, relate that the in- habitants of Bricherasio, St Secondo, Garciliana, and Osasco, villages situated around its base, were at one time Protestants also. To the left, over the dark moun- tain-chain which intervenes between Lucerna and the valley of the Po, Monte Viso is seen rising in pyrami- dal form, crowned with virgin snow, like a watchful sentinel keeping guard over the peaceful valleys be- neath. In the back ground, the valley rises abruptly towards the main ridge of the Alps, and the practised 210 PRESENT CONDITION AND FUTURE PROSPECTS OF eye can at once discern the altitude, by the varied hues on the mountain side, so peculiar to these Alpine re- gions, — the bright green of the meadows — the brownish tint of the fruit and forest trees — the sombre shade of the pine forests — and the cold blue tints of the rocky region that intervenes between the line where vegeta- tion ceases and perennial snow begins. The rich and luxuriant vegetation which the immediate foreground displays, relieves the scene. Every inch of ground that can be brought under cultivation, has been occupied, and every rocky eminence where the spade or plough are useless, is covered with fruit trees. The vines are planted in rows between ridges of wheat, maize, pota- toes and hemp, and hang in most graceful festoons along the rude trellis-work which supports them, while the wood-built chalets of the poor but brave peasantry, ap- pear to great advantage half hid amidst the profusion of chesnut, mulberry, and walnut trees, which clothe the hills on either side. It is impossible to view the hamlets ranged one above another, on the steep moun- tain side, without being convinced that these valleys are too densely populated, and that wretchedness and misery — notwithstanding the fertility of the soil, must be the consequence of the despotic edict which impri- sons them, on account of their religion, within a terri- tory far too strait for them. In a region where there is scarcely a vineyard or a meadow that has not been the scene of warfare and of horrible atrocity, — scarcely a precipice in that land of precipices, which has not associated with it a tale of infamy and blood, — scarcely a mountain pass in that land of mountains, that has not proved a new Ther- mopylae, nor a torrent whose waters have not been dyed with the blood of martyrs, it would be no easy matter, THE WALDENSIAN CHURCH. 211 even if this were a fitting occasion, to describe the places most celebrated in Waldensian history. The crag of Castelluzzo which frowns above the hamlet of St Mar- guerita, in the Val Lucerna, still proclaims the slaughter of the innocents who were precipitated from its summit to the plain below. Rora is celebrated to this day for the martial achievements of its hero Gianovello, as also the Balceglia in Val St Martino, for the memorable de- fence of the intrepid Arnaud and his followers ; while the Val d' Ano;rog:na is at once famed for its Barricade, behind which the Vaudois defied all the efforts of their enemies ; and for its College at the Pra del Tor, where their Barhes^ in ancient times gathered around them not only the students of the valleys, but those of Bo- hemia and Calabria also, who sought ordination at their hands. I would recommend those who desire to be- come better acquainted with these localities to consult the very interesting works of Dr Gilly of Durham,t who was the first, of late years, to revive in this country an interest in the Vaudois : and of Dr Henderson of Hiorh- bury,t whom I met in the valleys last summer, — the latter of which was published so recently as the begin- ning of the present year. There is a spot, however, in Val Perosa, which particularly fixed my attention, on account of the solemnity of the event that occurred there, and as I have not seen any notice taken of it in the records of preceding travellers, I hope I shall be ex- cused for shortly adverting to it. A few miles above * Literally Uncles. — The name anciently given to their Pas- tors. r Narrative of an Excursion to the Mountains of Piedmont, by the Rev, Wm, Stephen Gilly, M.A. London: 1824. And Waldensian Researches by the same author. London: 1831. ± The Vaudois, by E. Henderson, D.D. London; 1845. 212 PEESENT CONDITION AND FUTURE PROSPECTS OF the village of St Germano, and in the same parish, there is a place called Pinache d' Envers. It is by no means remarkable for the beauty of its scenery, — the meadows are not interspersed, as on the other side of the Clusone, with vineyards and orchards, because after mid-day the sun's rays are intercepted by the heights which tower above it; and the dark pine forest that bristles to the mountain top, adds a feature of sternness to the landscape, and sheds around an air of profound melancholy. Here during the months that elapsed ere the treaty of Pinerolo was signed, after the bloody mas- sacre of 1655, the Yaudois remnant met Sabbath after Sabbath to worship God under the open canopy of hea- ven. On one of these occasions, two of their ministers, Peter Gros and Francis Aguit, who, while prisoners at Turin, had abjured their religion under the torture of the rack, appeared before the weeping congregation to confess their sin, and to " testify their extreme sorrow for their defection, through infirmity, from the true re- ligion." How humiliating to them must have been the thought, that while they had fallen in the day of trial, many from among their unlettered flocks had kept the faith amidst sorer temptations, and had endured the martyr's death rather than " remove their integrity from them." Morland has preserved their declaration ; the last sentence of which is as follows, " We recant whatsoever we may have pronounced to the prejudice of the Evangelical truth, and promise for the future, through the grace of God, to persevere in the profes- sion of the reformed religion to the last moment of our life; and rather to suffer death and torments, than to renounce that holy doctrine which is taught in our church according to the word of God; even as we swear and promise, with our bended knees upon the THE AVALDENSIAN CHURCH. 213 eartli, and our hands lifted up to the eternal, our Al- mighty God and Father, Son, and Holy Ghost. As we desire His assistance to do this, even so help us God. Amen.""^ It may be proper here to give an outline of the con- stitution of this mountain Church. Of late I have often had the question put to me, " Is the form of Church government among the Waldenses episcopal, and do they hold the modern notions of Apostolical succes- sion f The doctrine of Apostolical succession is strong- ly held by the Vaudois Church, but in a sense very dif- ferent indeed from that which many attach to it in the southern part of this island. If "the fruits of the Spirit" manifest themselves in the labours of those who have been put in charge of the ministry, the idea of attaching weight to the question whether ordination has been transmitted to them in an unbroken line from the Apostles, appears too childish to be for a mo- ment entertained. They believe, to use the words of their confession, " That it is necessary that the Church should have ministers, known by those who are em- ployed for that purpose, to be learned, and of good life, as well to preach the word of God, as to administer the sacraments;" but they also believe that the doctrines and ordinances of the gospel are not made effectual by any virtue in him that administers them, but only through the blessing of God, and the effectual operation of his Spirit in those who by faith receive them. They claim an apostolical succession, because they now hold and teach those very doctrines, which from time im- memorial their forefathers handed down to them as the * History of the Evajigelical Churches of Piedmont, by Sir Samuel Morland. Bookii. Chap. 3. p. 279. 214 PRESENT CONDITION AND FUTURE PROSPECTS OF doctrines of the Apostles, and for the maintenance of which they bled and died. So far as I know, almost every traveller who has visited that region of late years, bears testimony that the constitution of the Evangelical Church of the val- leys is in all material points a facsimile of our own. " The constitution of the Vaudois Church," says Dr Henderson, " comes nearer to the Presbyterian than to any other form of ecclesiastical polity now in existence;" and even Dr Gilly, while labouring to prove that their ancient constitution was episcopal, records the fact, that, " their discipline is now presbyterian, very much re- sembling that of the Church of Scotland." If the episcopal form of church government ever obtained among them, it is very certain that all knowledge of the fact has now. disappeared from the valleys, a circum- stance exceedingly strange, and unlikely, when we call to remembrance with what scrupulous care they have ever guarded against all innovations, and have handed down as a precious heir-loom from father to son, the tradition above referred to. The grounds on which this assertion rests, do not appear sufficient to support it. It is maintained that the change from episcopacy to Presbytery took place about the year 1630, when the clergy who came from France and Switzerland to re- place their own pastors, who, with the exception of two, had all been cut off by the plague, introduced the form of church government to which they had been accus- tomed in their own countries. It seems very unlikely indeed, that a mere handful of strangers should have in- fluence enough to effect a change so much in opposi- tion to all the feelings and prejudices of the people; and though Leger speaks of some slight relaxation in discipline, as occurring in consequence of their arrival. THE WALDENSIAN CHURCH. 215 he never hints at any thing like an organic change, though had such taken place, he must have been cog- nizant of it. But surely the advocates of episcopacy must have entirely overlooked the fact, that one of the ancient manuscripts deposited by Sir Samuel Morland in the University of Cambridge, bearing date 1587, speaks of a church government by kirk-sessions and synods, as having already existed among them for some, hundred years.^ This is surely sufficient evidence to prove that if episcopacy had any existence amongst them at all, it must have been centuries previous to the irruption of French clergy into the valleys, in 1630. Another argument in favour of episcopacy, has been attempted to be drawn from the mention of Bishops, made in some Waldensian manuscripts. Unfortun- ately for its conclusiveness, however, the term never occurs in the singular but always in the plural num- ber, in conjunction with the term pastors, and hence, if it proves any thing at all, it proves too much for their purpose, because if episcopacy ever did exist among them, they could not have had more than a single bishop, and even he must have enjoyed a comfortable sinecure, with so small a diocese. In the second article of the ancient discipline of the Evangelical Church of Piedmont, "concerning pastors or ministers," the fol- lowing passage occurs ; " Among the powers which God hath given to his servants, as belong to their station, is ♦ " The Italian manuscript, the original whereof is to be seen with the rest in the University of Cambridge, bearing date 1587, tells us that this council (Synod) was constantly held in the month of September, and that some hundred years ago, there were seen assembled together in one Synod held at Valone del Lauso, in Val Clusone, no less than 140 Barbes. The same MS. adds that they had always their Comistoires:'' Morland's Hist, p. 183. 216 PRESENT CONDITION AND FUTURE PROSPECTS OP the election of Rulers of the 'people, and Priests in tJie offices, according to the diversity of operation, with the unity of Christ, which is proved by what the apostle says, Titus i., " I left thee in Crete that thou mightest set in order the things that are wanting, and ordain elders in every city." The words denoting Rulers and Priests, in the Waldensian dialect are " regidors,''' and " preires,'' and on the strength of these. Epis- copacy again claims ancient jurisdiction over the val- leys. On this passage Dr Henderson admirably re- marks, — " Whatever difference may have been design- ed to be expressed between " irgidors,'"' and " pre- ires," the passage alleged from Titus sanctions the ordination of none but TTpeac^vrepovs, presh^/ters or elders, so that if it had any force, as adduced in proof, it could only be regarded as descriptive of the two-fold view of the same office, viz. ruling and teach- ing. At all events the term regidor cannot be consi- dered as equivalent to bishop, inasmuch as the subjects of rule are expressly said to be the people, not the pres- byters." But, farther, we have the testimony of Kein- erus Sacco, an apostate Waldensian barbe, and after- terwards a Jacobin inquisitor, that neither prelatic titles, nor episcopal authority, were recognised among the Vaudois so far back as the 13th century. In the year 1254 he wrote a treatise against them, in which he assures us, that among other " blasphemies" uttered by them, they affirm, " that prelatic names, such as pope, bishop, and the like, are to be reprobated ; that obe- dience has to be given, not to the prelates, but to God; that no man is greater than another in the Church, "for all ye are brethren.'"''* In another passage he describes « Reinerus Sacco in Blair's Hist, of Waldenses. Vol. i. p. 460. THE WALDENSIAN CHURCH. 217 their cliief pastor and his associates, in such a way as to leave no doubt that the ecclesiastical authority was then vested in an executive board, similarly constituted, with " The Table " of the present day. " They had a chief bishop among them, who had always two attending him, the one whereof he called his eldest, and the other his youngest son, and beside these two, he had also a third, that followed him in the quality of a deacon."* Who can fail to trace in this description, the moderator, the moderator adjunct, the secretary, and the deacon, who conjointly conduct the business of the Vaudois Church, during the intervals which elapse between the meetings of Synod 1 During my first visit to the valleys in 1842, I learn- ed that an attempt had been made in certain influen- tial quarters to alter their present form of Church go- vernment for a modified episcopacy, by introducing a bishop under the title of 2^e-r2^eiual moderator, — who should hold no cure of souls, but give his attention en- tirely to the management of the afiairs of the Church, and be the organ of official communication with the government. The overtures on this subject were very coldly received in the valleys, for the clergy and the laity were alike opposed to the plan. One of their clergy, in speaking of the matter, said to me, " even if it had found favour with the clergy, it never would have been adopted, because the elders have a majority of two to one over the clergy in our Synod, and they never would have submitted to it." Another said, " it can- not be proved that bishops ever did exist in the Vau- dois Church, and even if it could, we never would re- turn to episcopacy, as it is not suitable to our present * Rein, in Morland's Hist. p. 17u. 218 PRESENT CONDITION AND FUTURE PROSPECTS OF circumstances." The present moderator, M. Bonjour, a man well qualified by his piety and judgment for the si- tuation he holds, is decidedly opposed to any such change, though the effect of it in all probability would be to confirm him in the moderatorship for life. The following curious conversation on this subject took place between the Minister of the Interior and him in July last, on the occasion of his presenting the prospectus of business for the approaching synod : Minister, " I hear that you are about to apply to his Majesty for leave to sanction the appointment of a Protestant bishop over your Church, but I advise you not to do so, as your request will certainly be refused." Moderator, " You know that proposition was not so well received at the last meeting of synod, so you need entertain no apprehensions ; and, besides, it is altogether Catholic, and inconsistent with Protestantism." Minis- ter, " Well, I have told you this as a friend, because if you apply, I know it will not be granted. If you had a Protestant bishop, the Catholic bishops and he would be continually fighting, and the government has other things to do than to attend to their quarrels." It cannot be expected that the same number of Church courts should be maintained at present, while there are o\Aj fifteen parishes and sixteen regular pas- tors, as were found among them in the brighter days of Yaudois history, when the number of their Barbes was not less than one hundred and forty, and when the in- habitants of Yal Pragel, and a part of themarquisate of Saluzzo, belonged to their Church. It would be obvi- ously absurd for the same individuals to meet at one time as a presbytery, at another as a synod, and at a third as a general assembly, but they have retained all that was requisite, in their peculiar circumstances, to THE WALDENSIAN CHURCH. 219 prove them presbyterians, viz., the consistoire, or kirk- session, as a local court in each parish, and the synod as a court of review. The CoNSiSTOiRE is composed of the pastor, who is moderator; of the elders, who are elected by a vote of the heads of families in their respective quarters; and of a deacon, whose office it is to attend to the re- pairs of the temple, and to relieve the poor. In the Book of Discipline for the Evangelical Church of the valleys, adopted by the Synod in 1839, we are told that " the Consistoires are charged with the adminis- tration of poors' money, the election of regents or schoolmasters, the surveillance of schools, the main- tenance of good morals, and the advancement of the temporal and spiritual interests of their parishes." The qualifications requisite in the candidate for the eldership are, that he is not under twenty-nine years of age, that he does not keep a tavern, that he is able to read and write with ease, that he receives no support from the poors' fund, and that he does not stand in the relation of father, son, or brother to any one already a member of the same consistoire. The Synod is the representative assembly of the Vaudois Church, and is composed of all the pastors and ministers who are, or have been, employed in her service, — of two lay members from each parish, having only one vote between them, and of the two laymen who were members of the last Table. In ancient times this court met every year in the month of September, but now it only meets once every five years, partly on account of the smaller amount of business requiring to be transacted, but chiefly on account of the great ex- pense incurred in procuring letters patent from govern- ment, (amounting to L.oO), without which a synod is 220 PEESENT CONDITION AND FUTURE PROSPECTS OP not permitted to be held. After sermon by a Pastor, appointed at last synod for the purpose^ the moderator opens the meeting by prayer, and after the commissions of deputies have been received, the order of business proceeds as follows : — 1st, The reading of the royal patent ; 2d, The settlement of vacant parishes ; 3d, The report of the Table's proceedings since last meet- ing ; and, lastly. The election by ballot of a new com- mission. The Table are bound to send in a list of sub- jects to be brought before the synod, to the minister of the interior, for the information of government, at least a month before the meeting of that court. The Intendant of Pinerolo, with his secretary, is present, to watch all their deliberations, and to take care that nothing is enacted which may be prejudicial to his Majesty's government; but, like her Majesty's commis- sioner in the General Assembly of the Church of Scot- land, he can take no part in their proceedings. They are compelled to hold their sederunts with closed doors, and not only are strangers from other countries ex- cluded, but the population and office-bearers of the valleys also, with the exception of those who have been elected deputies. The acts passed at one synod are not adopted as the laws of the Church, until they have been confirmed by the succeeding one. The delibera- tions of the synod excite deep interest throughout the entire population ; and it is therefore part of the secre- tary's duty, within fifteen days after the rising of that court, to transmit a copy of its acts and proceedings to every parish, which the pastor is bound to read to his flock from his pulpit, and afterwards to deposit among the records of the consistoire. In addition to these two courts, there is also an exe- cutive board, called " La Table," to which allusion has THE WALDENSIAN CHURCH. 221 already been made, corresponding exactly in its func- tions with our Commission of Assembly. It is com- posed of three clergymen, the moderator, the mode- rator adjunct, and the secretary, and of two laymen, who are members of synod. According to the Book of Discipline, " the Table is charged with the execution of all the laws and regulations in force in the Vaudois Church. It has the right of inspection and surveillance over the temporal and spiritual administration of the parishes and their office-bearers. It conducts all the correspondence which affects the interests of the pa- rishes both within and without the kingdom. It settles all disputes which may be brought before it, and distributes the sums transmitted from abroad. It is also charged with the examination of schools, and of bursars, the superintendence of students, the ordination of candidates for the ministry, the inspection of the Vaudois hospitals, and the presbyterial visitation once in five years of all the parishes in the bounds."* Such is the constitution of the Vaudois Church at the present moment; but there was a time when the regular gradation of kirk-session, presbytery, and synod was found among them. The presbytery was called by them the Colloque or Class, the latter being the very name still in use in the Dutch Church ; and Leger and Morland inform us, that previous to the year 1655, there were two of these in the valleys. " Before the late horrible dispersion of these poor Protestants in the year 1655," says the latter, "there were in the said valleys, which were peopled with Waldenses, fourteen churches, which composed two classes or colloques, and these two classes one synod. The one of these was * "La Discipline de PEglise Evangelique des Vallees Vau- doises du Piedmont." 1839. Unpublished. 222 PRESENT CONDITION AND FUTURE PROSPECTS OP called ' the Colloque of Val Lucerna,' comprising the churches of San Giovanni, La Torre, Villaro, Bobio, Rorata, Angrogna, and Roccapiatta ; the other colloque, which was called ' the Colloque of Val Perosa and St Martino,' contained the other seven, viz., St Germano, Pinachia, La Cappella, Pramol, Villa-secca, Maneglia, and Prali.""^ In the Yaudois church, as in all the other Protes- tant churches of the continent, there is no class of men to be found corresponding to the probationers in our own churches. So soon as a student has finish- ed his course of study at a university, or theological academy, he is examined, and, if found qualified, at once ordained to the office of the holy ministry.f Formerly the Vaudois students were ordained at Ge- neva, or wherever they had completed their studies, but on the wise suggestion of Dr Gilly, this system has been discontinued, — the Vaudois church has resumed the ordination of its own ministers, and none can now hold office in it who have been ordained elsewhere. The ceremony of ordination takes place only once a- year in the valleys, and every candidate, before receiv- ing the imposition of hands, is obliged to sign the Con- fession of Faith. The only distinction with us, in ec- clesiastical orders, is made between a preacher and a minister; with them, however, the distinction lies be- tween the 2^^('Stor and the minister, — the former alone having the cure of souls. The election of a pastor to a vacant church is vested in the heads of families, and is conducted by ballot, after which, the Consistoire ad- dress a call to the person elected, in name of the con- * Morland's Hist. p. 4. Leger Hist. Gen. les Egh. Vaun. p. 10. t See Appendix, No. I. THE WALDENSIAN CHURCH. 223 gregation. Their choice is somewhat trammelled, how- ever, by the following regulation laid down in the Book of Discipline. All the parishes in the valleys are di- vided into two classes. The first class contains the four parishes of Maneglia, Macel, Kodoretto, and Prali, while all the rest pertain to the second class. None but young men are eligible to parishes of the first class, on account of the physical energy required for the dis- charge of the pastoral duties in those mountain regions. But a young minister cannot be elected to a vacant charge of the second class, until it has been offered in turn to each of the four pastors of the first class, according to seniority, and been refused by them. The induction of the pastor into his charge takes place upon a Sab- bath, one of his brethren officiating on the occasion, by appointment of the Table. The election and ordina- tion of elders is conducted very much after the mode observed in this country.* Besides the presbytere, or manse, with its little plot of garden ground, each pastor is paid 500 francs an- nually, from government ; — at least, the government has laid on each commune a tax of 500 francs, for the sup- port of its own minister, which is raised by the muni- cipal council along with other taxes, and paid at once into his hands without passing through the public treasury. The sums annually distributed among them from Holland, and from King William and Mary's fund in this country, (restored to them in 1827 through Dr Gilly's unwearied exertions), when added to the go- vernment allowance, produce an income varying from 1300 francs to 1500 francs, — the latter sum being about equal to L.60 sterling. When it was announced * See Appendix, No. II. 224 PRESENT CONDITION AND FUTURE PROSPECTS OF to tlie pastors (at that time tliirteen in number) that the British pension, so long withheld, amounting to L.277 annually, was about to be restored, they unani- mously resolved, with a self-denial that did them cre- dit, to appropriate only a part of it to the augmenta- tion of their own stipends, devoting the rest to the es- tablishment of a fund for widows of deceased pastors, and for the support of two suffragan-pastors to be sta- tioned in the parishes of Macel, and Rodoretto, the churches of which had been closed for upwards of 200 years, from want of funds. The latest accounts from the valleys brought the melancholy intelligence, that M. Buffa, the pastor of E,odoretto, and his whole fa- mily, had been destroyed about two months ago by an avalanche of snow, which swept away the presbytere in its impetuous course. In 1827 an arrangement was entered into between the Vaudois Table, and the three Protestant ambassa- dors* at Turin, to have a minister from the valleys, ap- pointed as chaplain to them conjointly. His stipend is paid by the ambassadors, each contributing towards it 1000 francs annually. He officiates in a chapel at- tached to the Prussian ambassador's house, and as the service is conducted in French, it is of incalculable be- nefit to the poor Vaudois servants, and others, residing in the capital, who were entirely deprived of ordinances till this admirable arrangement was effected, chiefly through the zeal of their late lamented benefactor, the Count AValdburg Truchsess, Prussian ambassador at the court of Sardinia. The present moderator, M. Bon- jour, was the first who filled the office of " pasteur-chape- lain," and on his translation to the parish of San Ger- * British, Prussian, and Dutch. THE W.ILDENSIAN CHURCH. 220 mano, the present chaplain, M. Amedee Bert, was elected by the ambassadors to succeed him. I had the pleasure of attending public worship on one occasion in the chapel, and was delighted to find a congregation of about 200 persons present. The use of a liturgy by the ancient Vaudois church rests on better evidence than that which is brought forward to establish its episcopacy. There is reference made to it in several of their ancient documents ; Mor- land has preserved a fragment of it in his history, and I have seen in the public library at Geneva a duode- cimo volume in which it is said to be preserved entire, though I had not an opportunity of examining it, as it is very carefully kept under lock and key. Until late- ly, the clergy made use of the liturgies of the Swiss churches, — each, according to his liking, officiating from the service-book of Geneva, of Lausanne, or Neu- chatel, but if a liturgy was to be retained at all, they are certainly under obligations to Dr Gilly for his sug- gestion, that a service-book of their own should be compiled from these, and adopted in all their churches. A liturgy of this sort was accordingly prepared, — it received the sanction of the synod in 1839, and is now used in every parish of the valleys. Besides prayers for public and family worship, it contains a burial service, (before unknown in the valleys,) the formularies for the ordination of pastors, and elders, and the confession of faith 1655, which the synod of 1839 has adopted, " as the truest compend, and most pure interpretation, of the fundamental doctrines of the Bible."* This liturgy, however, is not intended, and does not actually supersede, the use of extempore prayer; and so far « See Appendix, No. III. 226 PRESENT CONDITION AND FUTUEE PROSPECTS OF from being used by tlie people for the purpose of taking part in public worship by " audible responses," as in the Church of England, it is intended only for the use of the clergy, and resembles the " Directory for Public Worship," bound up with our Confession of Faith, or rather, " John Knox's Liturgy," prepared for the use of the newly reformed Scottish Church. When calling last summer, along with my friend Dr Henderson, on Madame Bert, an English lady, who, though domiciled in the valleys, still retains her early leanings towards episcopacy, the conversation turned on the use of the liturgy. She informed us, that when the cheap edition of it, published in 1842 at Lausanne, for the use of the common people, was introduced into the val- leys, they would not use it, — that for a while she brought her copy to church, and used it during the service, but at length she was glad to give it up, as they stared at her with astonishment, remarking very naively, by way of excuse, " Poor thing, she does not yet understand French sufficiently, to follow the pray- ers without a book! " The office of Eeader is still retained, and its func- tions are discharged by the schoolmaster, who, during the assembling of the congregation, reads a portion of the Bible, with Osterwald's Reflections on it. He ceases when the pastor enters the pulpit, and the ser- vice proceeds in the following order: — si^.iging, prayer from the liturgy, reading a portion of Scripture, an extempore prayer, another psalm, and a sermon, after which follows a second prayer from the liturgy, a psalm, and the apostolic benediction. The organ is not used in the churches of the valleys, more, I apprehend, from want of means, than of inclination, as it is used in all the Presbyterian Churches on the continent, and the THE WALDENSIAN CHURCH. 227 cliurcli of La Torre had one within the last 20 years. There used formerly to be only one service in each parish church on Sabbath morning, the afternoon being devoted to catechetical instruction ; but now that Sab- bath schools are being introduced, the younger and more zealous clergy have adopted a second service. The pastor is obliged to preach extempore ; he is not allowed the assistance even of notes, and the practice of reading would not be tolerated for a moment. Baptism is always administered during public wor- ship, except in cases of severe illness, and it is re- fused to the children of those who are not members of the church. Godfathers and godmothers take part in the ceremony, as well as the parents. The Lord's Supper is dispensed eight times a-year in their churches, viz. on Christmas Day, and on the preceding Sabbath; on Easter, and on the preceding Sabbath; on Whitsun- day, and on the preceding Sabbath; and on the two first Sabbaths of September. The young communicants are admitted after a long course of instruction, which they call Confirmation. The ordinance is dispensed in the same way as in the Swiss Churches. The service begins, as amongst ourselves, by reading the words of institution, from 1 Cor. xi., and fencing the tables. The minister first communicates, then the elders, after which the congregation pass before the table in single file, the men first, and afterwards the women, — they partake of the elements standing, and then return in the same order to their pews. It must be confessed, that owing to laxity of disci- pline among them, many are admitted to the Lord's table, who have no title to be there. The Consistoire, though it has the power of suspension and excommuni- cation, seems to exercise no authority in keeping back 228 PRESENT CONDITION AND FUTURE PROSPECTS OF unwortliy communicants ; and after a solemn warn- ing addressed from the pulpit to intending communi- cants, every man is left to follow the dictates of his own conscience. On this account, principally, some of the most godly persons in the valleys felt compelled to withdraw themselves from the communion of the Vau- dois Church, and to institute a separate communion of their own. This secession is chiefly confined to the pa- rish of San Giovanni, and took its origin from the con- duct of M. Mondon, the former pastor there. This man, while studying at Greneva, imbibed the Socinian doc- trines so unblushingly taught in its academy, and after- wards began to preach them to his flock. Those who dissented from his doctrines, applied to the Table to be allowed to restrict their communion to those churches whose pastors were known to be sound in the faith; and when this most reasonable request was refused, they had no alternative left them but to secede. Being joined by a young minister, called M. Gay, returning at that time to the valleys, they received the sanction of the civil authorities to form themselves into a separate as- sembly, and had the Lord's Supper dispensed among them for the first time in 1831. M. Mondon and his adherents acted towards them in a most harsh and ty- rannical manner ; but it must be remembered, that the great body of the Waldensian pastors disapproved of these proceedings. M. Bonjour, his successor in San Giovanni, is decidedly evangelical ; and the seceders, amounting in all to sixty individuals, now generally attend the other services in the Vaudois churches, though they still refuse to join in communion with them. I had the strongest assurances from the mode- rator, himself decidedly a pious man, that all the clergy at present in the service of the valleys, both hold and THE WALDENSIAN CHTJRCH. 229 preach the doctrines contained in their confession of faith. I do not mean to affirm, that the pastors are all men of deep-toned pietj, and great spiritual experience, or all equally zealous in the discharge of their duties. Some of them, especially those who have been trained of late years under the auspices of Yinet, at Lausanne, and Gaussen and Merle d'Aubigne, at Geneva, are de- cidedly so, and would be reckoned blessings and orna- ments to any Church ; and if there are others not so spiritually-minded, it is at least matter of unfeigned thankfulness, that they preach the sound doctrines laid down in their own evangelical standards. The Vaudois Church has ever been distinguished for its extreme anxiety to extend the blessing of education to all the inhabitants of the valleys. They still continue to devote much of their attention to this subject ; and by the labours of Dr Gilly, Colonel Beckwith, and other zealous friends, a considerable improvement has of late years taken place in their educational institutions. Every parish has its parochial school, and the teachers are elected conjointly by the Consistoire, and the Muni- cipal Council. Their salaries vary from 300 francs, to 600 francs, (L.25) and are paid partly by funds raised in Holland for the purpose, and partly by a tax laid on each commune by government. There are besides, 120 district schools in the valleys, which are taught in miserable hovels on the mountain sides, a small salary being allowed to each teacher, by the Consistoire of the parish in which his school is situated. The parish schools are kept open during eight or ten months of the year, the smaller ones, during three, four, or five months in winter, according as the season is more or less favourable for agricultural operations. They are examined twice a-year by the pastor, and two 230 PRESENT CONDITION AND FUTURE PROSPECTS OF elders, appointed for tlie purpose bj the Consistoire; and reading, writing, arithmetic, French and Italian Grammar, the Bible, Osterwald's Catechism, and sacred music are the ordinary branches taught in them. The patois of the country is necessarily employed in them, as the medium of communicating knowledge ; and as, in all probability, it will ever continue to be used in the chalets of the peasants, I am inclined to think, that the republication of their ancient Catechism, and of their celebrated poem, " La Nobla Le^on," for the use of schools and private families, would be attended with great advantage, as the children would thus acquire a knowledge of the elements of Divine truth, at an earlier age than they can do at present, when it is communi- cated in a foreign languige, which must first have been acquired through the medium of their own. There are five schools for girls in the valleys, to which the London Vaudois Committee give an annual grant of L.52, in addition to four others supported by private liberality. The appointment of the matrons is vested in the Table. In 1837 the foundation stone of an Institution for the higher branches of education, called Trinity Col- lege, was laid at La Torre, — funds for the purpose hav- ing been raised by Dr Gilly in England. It is now complete, and the course of study pursued there, com- prises classics, mathematics, belles lettres, geography, and history. Philosophy and theology are forbidden by government to be taught in the valleys. There were fifty students in the College in July last, and four pro- fessors, one of whom is also principal. The course of study lasts six years, after which those who are intended for the ministry remove to some foreign university to complete their education. I have but to add that Colonel Beckwith has founded a female school of a su- THE WALDENSIAN CHURCH. 231 perior order, at La Torre, for the ediacation of pastors' daughters and other young ladies, which is very ably conducted, to bring this sketch of their educational state to a close. During the days of the empire, when Napoleon was driving kings before him into banishment, and plant- ing his victorious eagle successively in every province of Italy, the Vaudois, notwithstanding their poverty and insignificance, attracted his attention, and found favour in his eyes. More loyal, honest, and industri- ous than their countrymen who inhabited the plains of Piemont, he yet found them prohibited by a barbarous edict, from acquiring land or following any profession, beyond an arbitrary boundary therein defined as the limit of their habitation. With an impartiality that did him honour, he instantly removed all restrictions, placed the Protestants on a level with their Popish fel- low-subjects, and in short introduced a new era in the history of the valleys. The clergy was the only class among the Vaudois, Avho, for a time, were sufferers by his usurpation of Italy. An annual pension from this country bestowed upon them from the time of William and Mary, was withheld by the British government from the moment that they became the subjects of France. This circumstance having been related to Napoleon, he immediately made provision for them, enrolling their names among the clergy of the empire, and allotting lands for their maintenance which yielded to each 1000 francs annually, in addition to a sum of 200 francs per annum, bestowed upon them for registrations and population returns. Bloodstained and cruel as Napo- leon's career undoubtedly was, it is an undeniable fact, that the brightest and most prosperous period of Wal- densian history was that which elapsed while he occu- 232 PRESENT CONDITION AND FUTURE PROSPECTS OP pied the throne of Italy. " Napoleon never lost sight/' says Dr Gilly^ " of the Church of the Valleys, after he had once learned to take an interest in its fate. I have the copy of an order signed by him at Moscow in 1812, by which he directed a negligent Vaudois pastor to be suspended. Strange ! that the invader of Russia, in the palace of the Czars, should be concerning himself with the affairs of a small parish in the remote wilds of Pied- mont; and that the Protestant representatives of the ' Defender of the Faith/ should forget the Waldenses at the congress of Vienna ! Tlie usurpers, Cromwell and Buonaparte, have left a better lesson behind them in regard to the Vaudois, than the advocates of legiti- macy." At the peace concluded in 1814, the throne of Sar- dinia was again restored to the house of Savoy, and with its return, all the apprehensions of the Vaudois were again called forth. It is true that a clause in the treaty of Paris, of May 31, 1814, stipulated, " That in the countries restored and ceded by the present treaty, no individual of ivhatever class or condition shall he prevented, harassed, or disturbed in his person or pro- perty, under any pretext,'' yet still the Vaudois remem- bered how it had fared with them under the old regime; and the deputation from the valleys, which proceeded to Geneva to welcome Victor Emanuel on his landing, and to declare their loyalty, besought him earnestly, that the civil rights and privileges acquired under the empire might not be disturbed. They were put off, however, with fair promises, which, from his subsequent conduct, it seems probable he never intended to be put in execution. Undoubtedly it is mainly owing to British wealth and valour that the reigning family ever were restored; and had our representatives been suffi- THE WALDENSIAN CHURCH, 233 ciently alive to Protestant interests wlien that treaty was drawn up, such stringent clauses might easily have been introduced into it, as would have for ever secured the Yaudois in the undisturbed enjoyment of the liber- ties they had previously acquired. Victor Emanuel showed by his treatment of Lord William Bentinck that he was fully aware of this oversight. "The British General naturally conceived, that he who had been instru- mental in replacing his majesty upon the throne of his ancestors, had some pretensions to be heard in favour of subjects, who professed the same religion as his own so- vereign and himself He took the earliest opportunity of urging their suit, and at Geneva, before the king could even set foot in the hereditary dominions to which the British arms had restored him, and while he was yet under the protection of a British escort. Lord William Bentinck most earnestly pleaded for the oppressed churches of the valleys. The king lis- tened to the eloquent and feeling appeal, with worse than indifference. His determination most probably was already made, for in four days afterwards, and on the morning after he had taken possession of his palace at Turin, the ungrateful monarch issued an edict, by which he dispossessed the Vaudois of all that they had enjoyed during his dethronement ; and put many vexa- tious decrees in force which had been proclaimed against them by his bigoted and intolerant predecessors.* Amongst other acts of cruelty towards the Vaudois, which signalized his restoration to the throne, the king deprived their clergy of the salary allowed them by the French government, and the English pension being still withheld, though the French domination in Italy had ♦ Gilly's Narrative, p. 92. 234: PRESENT CONDITION AND FUTURE PROSPECTS OF ceased, many of those worthy and laborious men were reduced, with their families, to a state of abject poverty. He likewise ordered the church of San Giovanni, built in his absence, to be immediately closed; and when strong remonstrance was made against such injustice, by the Pro- testant ambassadors, the church was at length allowed to be reopened, on condition that an immense wooden screen should be erected in front of it, lest the Popish inhabitants of the parish, amounting in all to forty, should be scandalized by its appearance, or their ears polluted by the sacred melodies of the seventeen hun- dred Protestants who worshipped within its walls. Can it be believed, that the same prince who acted so harsh and unnatural a part towards his loyal subjects, should have previously borne this remarkable testimony to their character, " I know I have faithful subjects in the Wal- denses, they will never dishonour their name." Some of the more enlightened Catholics are ashamed of the gross injustice thus practised on their unoffending fellow-sub- jects, and one in particular, — the Count Ferdinand dal Pozzo, — in a pamphlet written to redress the wrongs of the Vaudois, indignantly exclaims, " How then in God's name, could it happen, that without any fault or crime on their part, they should lose their rights and be reduced to their ancient state ? It may be asked, by what fatali- ty has the restoration of the King of Sardinia been followed by so dreadful a consequence, as the degrada- tion of his Protestant subjects, while no similar effect was produced by the restoration of the Bourbons to France, nor by that of the other sovereigns, in coun- tries also for a time united to France, but afterwards again dismembered 1 The fact is, that no Protestants now exist in Europe, in so low, in so degraded a condi- tion, as the Vaudois, and that they are now still more THE WALDENSIAN CHUKCH. 235 secretly harassed by some fanatics than they were before the French domination, on account of the ascend- ancy gained anew by the court of Rome, the Jesuits, and the Parti-Pretre."* In a former lecture, I doubt not earlier treatiest have been cited, which entitle this country to be heard at the court of Sardinia, on behalf of her Vaudois subjects, but even were none such in existence, is there not sufficient ground for the inter- ference of Britain, or of any of the high contracting powers, in the systematic violation by the house of Savoy, of that very treaty which restored to it the throne of its ancestors 1 From that period until the present, the Yaudois have never been altogether free from persecution; for even when exempt from acts of open hostility, they have been ground down by a system of petty oppres- sion, under the galling yoke of which, their spirit must have failed ere now, but for the advice and encouraijement of Lieutenant-Colonel Beckwith, a brave British soldier, who for nearly iivenly years has devoted his time, for- tune, and energies to their service. There is the strongest ground, however, to believe, that were it not for the all-predominating influence of Jesuitism at the coTirt of Sardinia, their sovereigns would deal kindly towards these Alpine Protestants. In 1816, for exam- ple, letters patent were issued at Turin, making procla- mation of the royal intention " to soften the rigour of the measures adopted in ancient times, towards the \'audois;" but there were those around the throne, whose aim and interest it was to prevent any such amelioration in their condition, and so, with the inti- * The Crown or the Tiara. Lond. 1842. p. 21. + Treaties between England and the Duke of Savoy, dated 20th October 1690, and 4th August 1704. I'SG PRESENT CONDITION AND FUTURE PROSPECTS OF mation of the king's benevolent intention, the matter ended. When the present sovereign ascended the throne in 1831, and for some years subsequent, the influence of the parti-pretre at court v/as understood to be less than during the previous reign, and so long as this continued to be the case, he showed considerable kindness towards his Yaudois subjects. This momen- tary calm, however, was but the prelude of a fiercer storm about to burst upon the valleys, for Rome speedily regained her influence, and it soon became evident, that the favourable leanings of the sovereign towards this persecuted race had only tended to exasperate her ire and to hasten her revenge. In 1834, M. Andre Charvaz, the Popish Bishop of Pinerolo, a cunning Savoyard, who had acquired consi- derable influence at court, while discharffino; the ofiice of tutor to the king's sons, began openly to utter threats against them, and successfully to exert his influence in getting put into execution, the rigorous, but then obso- lete edicts, hurled against their ancestors. In 1836, he published anonymously, at Turin, a book entitled "Piecherches Historiques sur la veritable origine des Vaudois, et sur le caractere de leurs doctrines pri- mitives," in which all the exploded calumnies and falsehoods of early writers are again unblushingly pro- mulged, evidently for the purpose of turning the tide of public opinion against them, and at the same time giving a fair pretext for ulterior proceedings of a harsher kind. A just estimate of this prelate's character may be formed from the fact, that while he and his party have succeeded by intrigue, in so eflectually closing the public press in Sardinia against the Vaudois, that the most trifling pamphlet cannot be printed within the kingdom without exposing the author and publisher to THE WALDENSIAN CHURCH. 237 the severest penalties, he jet has the hardihood to taunt them with cowardice, or inability to rebut his charges, because they remain silent; and when remind- ed that their silence is not voluntary, but brought about by his intrigues, he coolly tells them, that the prohibition of the press in Sardinia can form no real impediment, as they have access to the press in France, in Britain, and in Switzerland,"^ though well he knows, that by availing themselves of the press to which he thus invites them, they would fall into a snare, and ex- pose themselves to fine and imprisonment at the king's pleasure, for contravention of the law which forbids any communication on political affairs beyond the bounds of the kingdom. Is not such conduct in full keeping with the character of the Jesuits ? But even were there no such law forbidding them to communi- cate to other nations the acts of their own government. * The same author has published an address entitled " Con- siderations sur le Protestantisme," delivered in the cathedral of Pinerolo last year, on the occasion of the baptism o^ tiventy- four Vaudois. In a foot-note, at page 27, he says, " On nous assure aussi, que nos adversaires rendraient raison de leur long silence sur des ecrits qui tendent a dissiper leur erreurs, en disant a leurs Freres qu'ils n'ont pas la liberte d'ecrire. Mais ils n'ont pas oublie sans doute, qu'ils ont fait imprimer assez recemment leur nouveau Catechisme a Londres, et leur nou- velle Liturgie a Lausanne, et a Edimbourg. Ils savent aussi, qu' un de leurs Pasteurs a fait imprimer en France son His- toire des Vaudois du Piemont. Ils ont done assez bien prouve, ce nous semble, que toutes les presses de France, de Suisse, et d'Angleterre sent a leur disposition." M. Muston was actually banished the kingdom of Sardinia, because he ventured to write a history of the Vaudois Church. He is now pastor of a church in France, and it was only about three years ago, on occasion of the Crown Prince of Sardinia's marriage, that M. Bert succeeded in obtaining from his majesty an acte de grace ioT him. 238 PRESENT CONDITION AND FUTURE PROSPECTS OF — supposing them in a condition to take advantage of the bishop's very considerate suggestion, — supposing that the necessary funds were raised in Britain for printing and conveying to them their defensive writ- ings, and that the journals of France were thrown freely open for their use, — what chance, after all, I ask, have the poor Vandois either of propagating their doc- trines among their countrymen, or defending them- selves against the insidious attacks of the Jesuits, so long as there remains an Index Expurgatoriiis in Sar- dinia, — so long as the censor of the press excludes all politics from their own journals, and the government prohibits the admission of foreign newspapers, lest they should dissipate the profound darkness of that priest- ridden kingdom? I was informed in 1842, that the two Prostestant newspapers published in Paris were strictly prohibited; and that only two copies of the " Archives du Christianisme" found their way into the kingdom, one for the Prussian ambassador, and the other for Colonel Beckwith. " It took three years," says the author of a very able anonjTiious pamphlet, entitled " the Crown or the Tiara," " after the Bishop of Pinerolo had threatened to reduce the Waldenses to the miserable condition of their forefathers, in the 16th and 17th centuries, before Romish intrigue and intolerance could turn away the benevolent heart of the king of Sardinia from his un- offending subjects of the Valleys." In 1837, however, the Parti-Pretre triumphed, and the king gave his assent, and attached his signature (unwillingly it is said) to a new code of laws, which has already produced the most baneful effects, and threatens, if rigorously executed, utterly to annihilate the Vaudois. Such, no doubt, is the intention of the prelate Charvaz, and his THE WALDENSIAN CHURCH. 239 -con-fraternity, and the Vaudois need look for no mercy, except it be extorted by the vigilance of the represent- atives of the Protestant powers at the court of Turin, €0 long as the king admits to his councils, one who has sworn never to rest until he has exterminated thern. After declaring that " the Catholic religion is the only religion in the State," the civil code goes on to say, "The subjects who are not Catholics shall enjoy civil rights, conformably to the laws, regulations, and usages which concern them. The case is the same ivith the Jews'' By this new code the Vaudois are reduced to the same level with the poor Jews, who, it is well known, are subjected to the greatest indignities, and most cruel re- strictions, in almost all the kingdoms of Italy ; — while " the laws, regulations, and usages," which modify their civil rights, are none other than the intolerant and persecuting edicts of former centuries. The cruelty of these edicts will hereafter appear. It has been already stated that the Vaudois territory measures, as nearly as can be ascertained, including mountains, 22 miles north and south, and 18 miles east and west ; and within this narrow compass there is found a population amounting in July last, to 26,920 souls. Of this number, 4462 are Papists ; and strenuous efforts are being made to increase their number, by getting persons of this persuasion to purchase all sale- able lands within the bounds. It surely is a great ag- gravation of their suffering that the Vaudois cannot even call this little territory their own ; — nearly a ■fifth part of its inhabitants being Papists, while no corresponding provision has been made elsewhere for the necessities of their increasing population.* » See Appendix, No. IV. Dr Gilly has published a similar population table for 1823, in his "Narrative;" and by compar- 240 PRESENT CONDITION AND FUTURE PROSPECTS OP At present a father can make no other proyision for his sons^ when they settle in life, than by alienating a portion of his little heritage to each, thus impoverish- ing himself without enriching them. But where is this to end ? Suppose the same process once or twice re- peated, and a large proportion of the inhabitants of these valleys will then only have left them the miser- able alternative of starvation at home, or expatriation from a country endeared to them by a thousand asso- ciations. The amount of the population might not in- deed appear to be excessive were the locality one where trade and manufactures afforded ample occupation, but such is not the case in the valleys. There are only two small manufactories for cloth, and two tan-yards, and these give employment to comparatively few hands. Besides this, there is a small trade carried on in char- coal, from which the inhabitants do not derive much advantage, as it is chiefly in the hands of merchants from Turin. Many families have invested their little ca- pital in the purchase of silk worms, and endeavour to support themselves by the price obtained for the co- coons. This is an exceedingly precarious investment, however, because a change of temperature is certain de- struction to them, and it is no easy matter in a Vau- doise cottage to keep it always at the same height; while the appetite of these creatures is so voracious that more has often to be paid for the mulberry leaves ing it with the one now published, the rapid increase of their numbers, and the cruelty of their confinement will at once appear. Ifi23. Protestants, 18,600 Catholics, 1700 Total Population, 20,310 1844. „ 22,438 „ 4462 „ 26,920 Increase, „ 385S „ 2/62 "660 THE WALDENSIAN CHURCH. 241 pn which they feed than their cocoons, when gathered, will realize. The last two or three seasons have been particularly unfortunate, and, consequently, the filature at San Germano, which gave employment to a few hands, has been closed. By one of the cruel edicts above referred to, the Vau- dois are incapable of holding any situation, civil or mi- litary, throughout the kingdom; in all the learned pro- fessions, too, the door is strictly closed against them, for in the edict of 1G02, which has been again put in force since 1837, it is enacted, " that no Vaudois may practise as a physician, surgeon, apothecary, attorney, or advocate, except among his own community..'''' It will be asked, what resource then is left for the 23,000 Protestants of Piemont? Agriculture is the only occupation from which they are not debarred by statute, and the exceedingly primitive manner in which farming operations are carried on among them, abundantly proves, that even here they meet with neither protection nor encouragement. Their implements of husbandry are of the rudest kind, — a clumsy wooden plough, drawn by a yoke of oxen,- and a hoe of the same material, are the chief instruments of tillage among them, while a two-pronged branch, cut from the nearest tree, supplies the place of a pitchfork in the time of harvest. The truth is, persecution is brought to bear upon them, in their daily employments. On what possible grounds can the Sardinian govern- ment justify its procedure in imposing upon the Vau- dois a land tax, nearly double the amount of that exacted from the Papists, — the relative proportions being 20 J per cent to 13 per cent ? Had such addi- tional tax been imposed on those only who, during the days of the Empire, had acquired land beyond the 242 PRESENT CONDITION AND FUTURE PROSPECTS OP limits^ tyrannical as such a proceeding would liave been, some shadow of excuse might have been pled for it; but surely, within their own limits at least, they have a right to expect that they should be placed on a footing of equality with their neighbours. Nor is this all; — another edict compels them to observe strictly all Popish saints' days and holidays, the consequence of which is, that within their own proper territory, 23,000 Vaudois, depending for subsistence entirely upon agri- cultural pursuits, are compelled to abstain from labour, at least one, and often three days, every week, to satisfy the caprice of 5000 Papists, who, at best, can only be considered as intruders there. The utmost a Vaudois peasant can gain by his labour does not amount to more than 15 sous a day in winter, and 20 sous (lOd.) in summer. Is it not, then, excessive cruelty to deprive them^ through human inventions, which they conscientiously condemn, of a half or a third part of the time in which they might lawfully earn this miserable pittance for their families? Though the edict preventing the Vaudois from acquiring land beyond the limits, issued the very day after the fallen monarch was restored to his throne, it was never dreamt that it could be retrospectively applied to those who were already bona fide in possession of them. It is said that the late king was urged again and again by the Popish party, to deprive such of their property; but he steadily refused, declaring that had he been on the throne, they never should have acquired it, but now that they were in possession, he would not take it from them. It remained for Charles Albert, the reigning monarch, on the urgent representations of the Romish hierarchy, to give the order for perpe- trating this additional injustice; and had it been exe- THE WALDENSIAN CHURCH. 243 cuted, it would have had the effect of driving back many ruined families on the already over populated valleys. In March 1841 the edict passed, and orders w€?re given' to the judge of Pinerolo to warn those living beyond the confines, that their lands must be disposed of ; that two years would be allowed for this purpose, in cases where they did not exceed two acres, and four years in cases where they were of larger size. When the tidings of so harsh a procedure, and of the ferment produced by it in the valleys, reached this country, peti- tions from various quarters were forwarded to govern- ment, entreating its interference on their behalf with the Court of Sardinia. A communication immediately passed between the Foreign office and the Sardinian government, which, though it is said to have been by no means agreeable to his Sardinian majesty, was per- fectly successful in the accomplishment of its object. The edict has not been enforced ; intimation having been given to those concerned that they should not for the present be disturbed, hut that in case of a sale of land, the jmrchaser must he a 2oapist ! ! ! I crave spe- cial attention, however, to the manner in which this deliverance has been given, as it is a fair specimen of the " cunning craftiness" whereby these poor people are being ruined. The edict ordering the lands to be sold was duly published, and became part of the statute law of the empire ; and so it continues at this day. No edict has ever been issued to cancel it, and the permis- sion to retain the lands rests solely on the king's parole de grace. So long as his majesty's life is spared, all may go on smoothly, but the persecuting edict is part of the statute law of the empire still; the Vaudois can bring no documentary evidence to prove its repeal, and, therefore, it may at any future time be put in force 244 PRESENT CONDITION AND FUTURE PROSPECTS OP against them in course of common law. The modera- tor^ M. Bonjour, in presenting a petition for the repeal of this edict, had an interview with the king, who, it is said, received him coldly, and accused the Vaudois of having appealed to foreign powers for redress^ saying, that England had interfered between him and his Yaudois subjects; at which he was very angry, as he was an absolute monarch in his own dominions; on which the moderator assured his majesty, he was mis- taken, if he supposed the Vaudois had applied to the English government for redress ; but it was natural to suppose that some of their co-religionists from England, visiting their valleys, and becoming acquainted with the " severe measures" which he had applied to the Vaudois, should have stirred up their government to interfere. The king was pleased to receive the petition, but told M. Bonjour, he wished every individual Vau- dois to make aj^plication to him hy letter for the reten- tion of Im 'property , as a favour at his majesty's hands. Such written application, had it been made, would un- doubtedly have been used hereafter to prove that the petitioners had no legal right to these lands, but only held them during the king's pleasure. From such a snare, however, the Lord delivered them ! It is impossible to enumerate in one short lecture, all the grievances under which these Protestants are still la- bouring. In each commune there is a municipal coun- cil, consisting of a syndic, vice-syndic, and three ordin- ary members. Of these, a majority must be papists, although in some parishes there are so few of them, that it is no easy matter to find men capable of undertaking the duties of the office. To keep within the letter of the law, in a commune where the Protestant inhabi- tants are to the Papists in the proportion of 2,000 to THE WALDENSIAN CHURCH. 245 40; they are obliged to elect a majoTity of councillors from among men of the very lowest grade in society. Crucifixes, and shrines in honour of the Virgin Mary, are erected with studious attention by the wayside, at intervals of little more than half a mile, that the Vaudois may ever be reminded of the superstitions they abominate. Their worship is often interrupted on the Sabbath, by Popish processions, headed by the priests, which surround the church, chanting so loudly that the pastor's voice cannot be heard. Prayer meetings, and reunions for psalmody, have been once and again interdicted by a mandate from the secretary of state. They are forbidden by the edict of 1G02, to increase the number of their churches, and beneficed pastors, although the wants of the population demand an in- crease of both. They are forbidden by the same edict, to offer any opposition to the conversion of a protestant to the Romish faith, while a seminary of missionary priests of the order of St Maurice, and St Lazarus, has been newly established in the valleys, for the avowed purpose of making proselytes. Mixed marriages, cele- brated between Protestants and Papists, are not reck- oned valid, and the children by such, are liable to be torn from their mothers' breasts, by the priests, as ille- gitimate, and carried off to this new seminary, or to the Hospice at Pinerolo, where they are baptised according to the rites of the Romish Church. The children of Protestant parents have also been more than once carried off in a similar manner, under the pretext that they had expressed a desire to join the Romish communion, — their little popish playfelloAvs being ad- duced as evidence against them. Children so kidnap- ped, are seldom restored; — on various pretexts, the par- ents are prevented from seeing them until they have 246 PRESENT CONDITION AND FUTTTRE PROSPECTS OP readied tlie age of 12 if boys, or 10 if girls, when the law forbids them under heavy penalties, to demand the restitution of their own offspring. The Church of Rome is never at a loss for inventions, when proselytism, or the persecution of heretics is the matter in hand. If one attempt proves abortive, a se- cond is immediately made in another quarter; if one expedient fails, another is as rapidly devised more likely to succeed; and in such a country as Sardinia, where Protestants are not safe if they attempt to offer opposi- tion to the conversion of their nearest relatives, it were strano;e indeed if these were not sometimes successful. The Jesuits were no sooner foiled in their attempts to drive back the Vaudois within their ancient limits, than they adopted a plan for the extermination of heresy, which partakes at once of the wisdom of the serpent and of the baseness of the tempter. Knowing the extreme poverty of many of their victims, they appeal- ed to their basest passions, and have succeeded in in- ducing some to make shipwreck of their faith, for a handful of paltry gold. Others more ambitious, have been won by the promise of promotion in the army, or of civil employment in the State. An instance of this occurred about the beginning of last year. A Vaudois surgeon, disgusted with the restraints imposed upon him, in the exercise of his profession, on account of his religion, and ambitious of rising in it, not only embraced the Popish religion himself, but com- pelled his wife and children to embrace it also, on the understanding that he should forthwith receive a commission as surgeon in the army! I was in- formed that his wife continues in a miserable state of jnind, having been compelled, against her conscience, to conform ; but he has gained his point, having, short- THE WALDENSIAN CHURCH. 247 \j after his abjuration of Protestantism, received a commission as surgeon-major, nearly in the following terms : — " Considering the favourable reports made to us relative to R., and taking into account the resolu- tion he has manifested to return into the bosom of our holy mother, the Catholic Chiirch, appertaining to Rome, We nominate him surgeon-major, d'c. w a H ^ 5 i <: 2 Observations. * In France, . 821 „ Italy, . 31 „ Switzerland, 147 „ Holland, 24 „ England, . 1 „ Russia, . 17 „ Prussia, . 2 ,, Germany, 8 „ Portugal, . 2 „ America, 6 „ Africa, . 19 „ Asia, : . 1 „ Turkey, . 1 Total, 1080 i •IBjox sscio •eottoiUcO ^^i%B^^%^^^ii-iB^ .•li:?oi 684 1585 2380 2315 2325 2124 2407 1364 1392 1293 1676 298 792 530 793 500 i sj 1 *-puoaqv ^^2||?is3S^53g^Sgf?S; •tisuvj aUJ "I 675 1537 2264 2150 2087 2045 2356 1310 1358 1272 1552 270 733 500 769 500 1 < 1 c t O 1 t 3U 333 33^35>2^ &g'«3 lil|lli§§§§§iiii IssBllllllllill -1 .-1 r-( .M rt ^ „ ^ Hypolite Rollier. Jean Pierre Revel. Frangoise Gay. Henri Peyrot. Jean Pierre Bonjour. Pierre Monastier. Cassar Auguste Rostaing. Jean Jacques Bonjour. Jacques Vincon. Pierre Lantaret. Alexandre Rostaing. Pierre Auguste Louis Jalla. Jean Jacques Durand Canton. Daniel Buffa. Mathieu Henri Gay. Josu6 Amcdee Bert. 1 !2 Rora. Bobio. Villaro. La Torre. St Giovanni. Angrogna. Prarustino. St Germano. Pramol. Pomaretto. Villa Secca. Maneilla. Massel. Rodoretto. Prali. Turino. c "3 ii " 5 1 -;