^^H w ^^M m PRINCETON, N. J. /^ /^ v.,.„, ,.rs( i .V^*-//'... Number. % mixr €^atnta mx 3t "^unl's ^pblU^. A PRACTICAL AND EXEGETICAL ON THE EPISTLE OF ST. PAUL TO THE PHILIPPIANS: IN WHICH ARE EXHIBITED THE RESULTS OF THE MOST LEARNED THEOLOGICAL CRITICISMS, FROM THE AGE OF THE EARLY FATHERS DOWN TO THE PRESENT TIME. EDITED BY THE LATE REV. HENRY NEWLAND, M.A., VICAR OF ST. MARY-CHUECH, DEVON, AND CHAPLAIN TO THE BISHOP OF EXETER ; ' Erudite Lector, iii hoc libro si aliquid tibi supervacaneuin ^isum fuerit, id minus eruditis relinque." J. H. AND Jas. PARKER. i860. PIIINTKU BY MKSRllS. PAUKKR, CORNMARKKT, OXFOUD. TO THE MEMORY OF HENRY NEWLAND, PRIEST OF THE ENGLISH CHURCH, IS GRATEFULLY DEDICATED, IN REMEMBRANCE OF A HAPPY FRIENDSHIP, BY HIS AFFECTIONATE BROTHER IN CHRIST, THE AUTHOR. AUTHOR'S PREFACE. The practical and exegetical Commentary on the Epistle of St. Paul to the Ephesians, lately published, was intended, as the title denotes, to be the first link of a new Catena on St. Paul's Epistles. The Com- mentary on the Epistle to the Philippians, now pub- lished, was written before the Commentary on the Ephesians ; both were submitted to my late dear and valued friend the Eev. H. Newland; the whole of both passed under his hand, and it was by his advice, and under his editorship, that the Commentary on the Ephesians was published fu-st. His lamented, and to me, as well as to others, irreparable loss, renders it necessary for me to speak in my own person, and to announce myself as the author of the works which I was but too happy to see introduced to the public under the authority of his honoured name. His character and writings have long been well known and appreciated, and will only cease to be so when unswerving rectitude of purpose and valour for the truth are no longer considered qualities to be admired in an author. When I say that he was a sound and honest theologian, one who never sacri- ficed even the smallest principle to " content the INTRODUCTORY OBSERVATION'S ON ST. PAUL'S EPISTLE TO TEE PEILIPPIAN8. Philippi was a city of Macedonia, on the borders of Thrace, and not far from the coast. It was originally called Dates, and in still earlier times was known as Cre- nides, from the springs of water which abounded in the hill on which the city was built. Philip of Macedon forti- fied it, and called it after his own name, and in his hands it became an important military post. In after times the city acquired a world-wide reputation from the victory gained in its immediate neighbourhood by Anthony and Octavius over Brutus and Cassius, the murderers of Julius Coesar. Mention is made of it in Acts xvi. 12, where it is called " the chief (or first) city of that part of Macedonia, [the word ' first ' referring either to its posi- tion relative to one crossing the Strymon, or to its mili- tary and mercantile importance,^ and a colony." St. PauL was the first to preach the Gospel there, having crossed over to Europe in obedience to a heavenly vision ^ ; and so successful were his labours, that many of the inha- bitants believed. It was here, . as St. Chrysostom remarks, that the seller of purple was converted, a woman of rare piety and earnestness ; it was here that the keeper of the prison believed. Here St. Paid was scourged with St. Silas. Here the magistrates requested them to de- part, and were afraid of them. Here the preaching of the Gospel had a most glorious commencement. It may be truly said that this city shewed great readiness for the faith, inasmuch as the very jailor (a class of persons not usually susceptible of religious impressions) at once, upon seeing one miracle, ran to the Apostles, and received Bap- tism with aU his house. Even the magistrates who scourged » Acts xvi. 9, 10. b INTRODUCTORY OBSERVATIONS ON them seem to have done this rather from a sudden impulse than malice, as may be concluded both from their sending at once to let them go, and their afterwards being afraid, when they learnt that they were Romans. This Epistle arose out of the follo-«dng circumstances. The Philippians, hearing of St. Paul's imprisonment at Rome, sent Epaphroditus, their Bishop, (according to St. Pacian, Theodoret, Baronius, and others,) to carry him money, and make enquiries about his state, which was causing them much anxiety. While with the Apostle he fell sick, almost to death ; but having at length recovered, St. Paul lost no time in sending him back to his diocese with a letter to his flock, in which, while praising them for their Kberality and aflec- tionate care, he exhorts them to stand fast in the faith, and not be troubled about his bonds ; and, above all, that they should be of one mind, shewing that unanimity comes of humility. No doubt Epaphroditus would have told him of certain painful dissensions which, it appears, existed among some private members of the Church, and also of the danger which was imminent to the whole body from the insidious advances of false teachers ; and so wc find, as might have been expected, special reference made to each of these, accompanied by earnest cautions and ex- hortations. The Philippians seem to have been very much attached to St. Paul personally ; and he, in turn, bears them many and high testimonies, shewing them special honour, calling them his ' crown,' and saying that they had suffered much for the Gospel. It may be truly said that no Epistle is so full of tenderness and fatherly affection as this, and it is the highest proof of the virtue and excellence of the Philip- pian converts that they gave no occasion to their teacher to speak sharply to them, but only in the way of exhorta- tion and encouragement. Respecting the authorship of this Epistle there has hap- pily been but little difference of opinion, and it has been all but universally ascribed to St. Paul. It is satisfactory to know that it is quoted largely by the early Fathers. Some modern German critics (who, for obvious reasons, are in- ST. Paul's epistle to the philippians. xi terested in undermining the authority of certain passages in this Epistle) have found difficulties in believing that St. Paul was its author. No one, however, can read their criticisms (esj)ecially those of Schrader and Baur) without concluding, with Dean Alford, that they deserve to take rank with Abp. Whately's " Historic Doubts Eespecting Napoleon Buonaparte." Various dates have been assigned to this Epistle ; but there seems sufficient internal evidence to shew that it was written from Rome towards the conclusion of St. Paul's first imprisonment, that is to say, the end of a.d. 62 or beginning of 63. The grounds which Conybeare and Howson give for fixing the date appear to be satisfactory and conclusive. They say : — " I. It was written during an imprisonment at Rome, be- cause (A) the Prsetorium was at Rome^ ; (B) so was the Emperor's household <= ; (C) he expects the immediate de- cision of his cause '^j which could only have been given at Rome. " 11. It was written during ihe, first imprisonment at Rome, because (A) the mention of the Prsetorium agrees with the fact that during his first imprisonment he was in the custody of the Praetorian Prefect ; (B) his sitiiation described^ agrees with his situation in the first two years of his imprison- ment ^. " III. It was written towards the conclusion of this first imprisonment, because (A) he expects the immediate deci- sion of his cause ; (B) enough time had elapsed for the Philippians to hear of his imprisonment, send Epaphroditus to him, hear of Epaphroditus' arrival and sickness, and send back word to Rome of their distress s. lY. It was written after Colossians and Philemon ; both for the preceding reason, and because St. Luke was no longer at Rome, as he was when those were written ; otherwise he would have saluted a Church in which he had laboured, and would have cared in earnest for their concerns ^." » c. i. 13. <= c. iv. 22. ^ c. i. 19, ii. 27, and possibly ii. 23. ' c. i. 12—14. ' Acts xxviii. 30, 31. s c. ii. 26. ^ c. ii. 20. Xii INTRODUCTORY OBSERVATIONS, &C. This Epistle, so suggestive of comforting thought to every devout Christian, becomes doubly precious when we view it as St. Paul's parting address to the Church as a body. The Second Epistle to St. Timothy is of later date, though written under similar circumstances, and shews the feelings of the Apostle in the prospect of death which was now close at hand ; but that Epistle, though it is now the property of all the Church, was written to an individual, and so far differs from the present one wherein the Apostle pours out his soul towards all believers. This Epistle has not always received full justice from commentators. It has been thought to be deficient in in- terest, and to afford little scope for exegetical labours. It is diflficult to say how such an opinion could ever have got abroad. It is true that this particular portion of St. Paul's writings may not have the depth of others of his Epistles, as, for example, that to the Ephesians, but it has at least a beauty all its own. There is a rich tone of colouring about it which the light of the Eternal Day, even then breaking through the bars of the Apostle's prison-house, alone could give. COMMENTARY ON ST. PAUL'S EPISTLE TO THE PIIILIPPIAKS. SUMMARY OF CHAPTER I. Having given thanks to God for the constancy of the Philippians in the faith, and having shewn his exceeding earnestness for their salvation, the Apostle proceeds to explain that his imprisonment at Rome has turned out for the furtherance of the Gospel ; and then, having expressed a good hope of his speedy restoration to them, he exhorts them to a course of life conformable to the doc- trine of Christ. This chapter may be divided into five chief parts : — ■ (1.) The epigraphe, or inscription, containing the names of the writer and of those to whom it is written : ver. 1 . (2.) The salutation : ver. 2. (3.) Thanksgiving for the faith of the Philippians, and a prayer for their perseverance : ver. 3 — 11. (4.) An account of the spread of the faith at Pome, and how his bonds have greatly assisted it: ver. 12 — 26. (5.) Exhortation to a life worthy of the Gospel : ver. 27 — 30. CHAP. I. Yer. 1. Paul and Timotheus, St. Timothy is associated with St. Paul, as joining in his salutation to the Christians at Philippi, to whom he must have been well known, having accompanied the Apostle in both his journeys to that city. See Acts xvi., xx. It is not to be supposed, however, that he had any share in the composition of the present Epistle, any more than ' all the brethren' whom St. Paul joins with himself in his salutation to the B COMMENTARY ON [cHAP. T. Galatians, chap. i. 2. That this Epistle was the work of St. Paul alone appears from verse 3, where he proceeds in the first person singidar ; but it is quite possible that Timothy may have written it at his dictation. So Zanchius. Caietan says, "He was unwilling to keep the salutation of Timothy for the end of the Epistle with the rest, but gave him a pre- eminence, that the Philippians might the better understand how highly he valued him." Haymo thinks that the name of St. Timothy was added to give greater weight and au- thority to the Epistle, according to our Lord's words, " In the mouth of two or three witnesses every word shall be established'*." Menochius has something similar ; but pro- bably this mode of interpretation is more ingenious than true ; for the simplest reason appears to be that St. Paul associated the name of Timothy with his own for the sake of humility ; intending thereby to shew that he did not despise him, as inferior to himself in spiritual gifts, but that he honoured him as a brother. A most illustrious example for Christ's ministers to follow. the servants of Jesus Christ St. Paul does not here insist upon his rank as teacher, as at 1 Cor. i. 1, but claims for himself another and a higher title, (see Matt. xx. 2C, 27,) calling himself a ' servant,' and not an * apostle ;' " for great truly is this rank, and the sum of all good things, to be a servant of Christ, and not merely to be called so*^." In one sense, indeed, all faithful Chris- tians are the ' servants' of Christ ; but SS. Paul and Timothy were so in a higher degree, having been called to serve Him publicly in preaching the Gospel. Compare James i. 1 ; 2 Pet. i. 1 . It is well known that the bishops of Rome sub- scribe themselves " Servant of the Servants of God," fol- lowing the example of St. Gregory, who was the first to adopt this style. It is probable that St. Paul docs not prefix his title of * Apostle' to this Epistle lest he should seem to have received as a matter of right, and not of liberality, the contribu- » Miitt. xviii. 16. '• S. Chrysos., in loc. VER. 1.] ST. Paul's epistle to the philippians. 3 tions whicli the Philippians had sent by the hand of Epa- phroditus. Another reason for the omission of this title may be found in the fact that this is the least official of all the Epistles. " The Philippians did not dovibt that he was an Apostle and teacher of the Gentiles, and therefore in writing to them it was not needful that he should style himself Apostle^" Caietan accounts for the omission on the ground that as St. Paul wished to join Timothy with himself as a colleague, he used a title which would suit them both. See remarks on Eph. i. 1. to all the saints * AH,' see also vers. 4, 7, 8, &c. ; he repeats the word to shew that he loves them all alike, and to excite in them a corresponding love one for the other. In the term ' saints' are included " all who have been sanctified in Baptism, and continue in that sanctification '^." " Sanctos vocat fideles, quorum congregatio sancta est, licet non singuli sancti, id est, a peccatis mundi ®." The sense of a^LOi in the New Testament is nearly equivalent to modern ' Christians ;' but it would be an anachronism so to trans- late it, since in the time of St. Paul the word ' Christian' was only used as a term of reproach. The objection to translating it ' saints' is that the idea now conveyed by that term is quite different from the meaning of ol a<^ioi as used by St. Paul \ Compare Eph. i. 1, and iii. 8. in Christ Jesus which are at Philippi, The use of the word * in' is to be observed ; implying that the baptized are actually part of Christ, as living members of His Body. See remarks on Eph. v. 30. He calls them ' saints in Christ Jesus' to distinguish them from the Jews, who would be likely to claim this title exclusively for themselves. See Exod. xix. 6; Deut. vii. 6. with the bishops and deacons : St. Chrysostom thinks that this Epistle was written only to the clergy of Philippi, and reads avveTnaKoirots as one <= Haymo. ^ Ibid. * Estius. ' Conybeare and Howson, Life and Epistles of St. Paul, vol. ii. p. 26, note. 4 COMMENTARY ON [cHAP. I. ^vord — coepiscopis, ' fellow-bishops.' This reading, however, cannot be maintained. St. Ambrose" distinctly asserts that the Epistle was written to the people at large, but, curiously enough, makes the words 'bishops and deacons' refer to those at Eome, who joined with St. Paul in his salutation to the Church at Philippi. He accounts for the plural (bishops) being used, by supposing that bishops flocked together to Eome from all parts during the imprisonment of St. Paul, for the purpose of performing kind offices. This, however, is simply an assumption, resting on no known foundation ; not to mention that the solitary condition which the Apostle complains of, chap. ii. 20, would be inconsistent with the presence of numerous provincial 'bishops' and 'deacons* at Rome. Theodoret also says that the Epistle was addressed to the laity as well as the clergy of Philippi ; a conclusion which, in the absence of other evidence, might safely be arrived at from its structui'e ; " for the praises, exhortations, consolations, doctrine, and precepts which are read in it are common to all people alike. Moreover, the liberality of the Philippians towards St. Paul was not merely on the part of the clergy, but of the whole Church •*." It was quite na- tural that, having previously mentioned * all the saints,' he should then make a separate notice of the 'bishops' and ' deacons ;' for it is by no means uncommon, even among ourselves, that the chief person should be mentioned last. A learned writer (Hammond') supposes that under the general term Philippians must be included more than the inhabitants of that single city, and that the word refers either to all the Christians throughout Macedonia, or at least to all that were mider that metropolis ; for that Philippi was such, he says, is the distinct alffirmation of St. Luke ^. Hence it appears that there might have been at Philippi more bishops than one ; indeed, a§ many as were in all Macedonia, at least in the cities under that metropolis. For more on this subject, see Thorndikc, " Of the Laws of the Church," 8 In loc. h Estius. ' Parapbnise, fol, ed., p. G3G. (Loudon, 1675.) '' Acts xvi. 12. VER. 1, 2.] ST. Paul's epistle to the philippians. 5 c. xvii. 10. The objection to this interpretation is that St. Chrysostom, Theodoret, and St. Jerome all affirm that ' bishops' in this place must signify ' presbyters' or priests ; and that Thessalonica, and not Philippi, was at that time the metropolis of Macedonia. St. Chrysostom, in loc, en- quires, " Were there several bishoj)s of one city ? Certainly not ; but he (St. Paul) called the presbyters so. For then they still interchanged the titles, and the bishop was called a deacon." It is common enough in the Greek Fathers to find the bishops called presbyters, and vice versa. And this, says Theodoret, is manifest in this place, because he here adds * deacons' to the * bishops,' making no mention of their presbyters. Assuming, then, (as there is good reason for doing,) that Epaphroditus, who was now at Rome with St. Paul, was the Bishop of the Church at Philippi, it was natural that in sending a letter by his hands he should address it, not to the Bishop, but to the presbyters (priests) and deacons. * Deacons' in this place must be understood in the same sense as in the Epistle to St, Timothy, i. e. the ministers of the altar, next to the presbyters. See Acts vi. It is im- portant to observe that there is no authority for the intro- duction of the article before 'bishops and deacons,' the Greek being avv i7rLaK6'7roi<; Kal htaKovois, ' with presbyters and deacons,' where the absence of the article seems to dis- tinguish the true Church, having threefold orders, from Gnostics, or any unepiscopal sectarians, such as St. Ignatius hints at when he says, % which kind of confession is called avTOfioXoyrja-is. This also is a part of prayer, and ought to go with it, as appears when the Apostle doth 'thank God always' for the Churches in his prayer q." 4. This verse is evidently parenthetical, since St. Paul evj(apt(n6l for the Koivcovla, verse 5. Always in every prayer of mine for you all See Ps. xxxiv. 1. For observations on the duty of per- petual thanksgiving, see Commentary on the Ephesians, pp. 28, 78, 300, 330, 394, 395. ' In every prayer.' Here we have the overflowings of a full heart. Surely it is the sign of great affection that in all his prayers he mingled petitions for them. ' For you all.' Compare ver. 8, " How I long after you all." " Omnes complectitur suo afiectu, respiciens saniorem par- tem, nam indubie erant in eo coetu etiam improbi, hypocritee et similes, sed eorum non ofiensus numero totam Ecclesiam piorum titulo complectitur''." making request Tr]v herjo-iv TToiovfievos. It is to be observed that Beijais is used tivice in this verse. It means petition. Prayer gene- rally (including confession, petition, oblation, intercession, and thanksgiving) is TrpoaevxV} which Polus renders ' preces ad bona impetranda,' while he translates Berjats ' deprecatio arcendis malis qua) metuimus,' for, as he remarks, this last word is derived airo rov Beov9, ' from fear.' See observations on chap. iv. 6, and compare Eph. vi. 18. with joy, i. e. with spiritual joy, derived from the comforting ac- counts which he received of their state. This is the sum and substance of the whole Epistle. It is natural that in a com- <) Bp. Aiiclrewes, Sermon vi., "On Propavixtion to Prayer." ' Aretius. rOMMEXTAKY ON [cHAP. 1. position like this, where love predominates, there should be a constant mention of 'joy/ See ch. i. 18 ; ii. 2, 19, 28 ; for love and joy are both fruits of the same Spirit. It will be the easier for us to understand why St. Paul makes special mention of 'joy' in this place, when we find from 2 Cor. ii. 4 that it is quite possible for a pastor's recol- lection of his flock to be one of grief. 5. For your fellowship in the Gospel €771 rrj Koivcovia vfxcov els to evayyeXiov, ' for your commu- nication U7ito the preaching ;' or, ' with reference to your liberality towards the Gospel ;' i. e. for the share you have had in promoting the preaching of the Gospel ; els to evayye- Xiov meaning " in usum Evangclii." This verse contains the reason why St. Paul gives thanks for the Philippians. They had zealously entered into his Apostolical labours, and had become sharers in them, specially by contributing largely of their worldly substance. While others proved faithless, and deserted him in the hour of peril ^ they remained stcdfast, and " although absent, took part in his tribulations, both sending men to him and ministering to him according to their ability, and leaving out nothing by any means ^" In chap. iv. 15 — 18 he thanks the Philippians for the pecuniary assistance he had received of them. KoLvcovia occurs in this sense Ileb. xiii. 16. St. Ambrose, Aquinas, Caietan, and others explain this verse differently. According to their interpretation, the Apostle's meaning is, 'I rejoice and give thanks to God that ye have been made partakers of the Gospel of Christ ; that is to say, by believing and shewing your faith by j'our works ; and that ye have been stedfastly pursuing the same course from the day in which ye began to believe until now." For this use of the word * fellowship ' see 1 Cor. i. 9, and Gal. ii. 9. There can be no doubt, however, that the former interpretation (which has the authority of St. Chrysostom) is the best, being more in accordance with the Greek and the general bearing of the Apostle's language, " 2 Tim. i. 15; iv. 10, IG. « S. Chrysos.. in loc. VER. 5, 6. J ST. Paul's epistle to the philippians. 9 for in other places also he calls assistance of the kind rendered by the Philippians * fellowship.' See Rom. xii. 13, xv. 26 ; 2 Cor. viii. 4, and ix. 13; Gal. vi. 6. from the first day until now ; i. e. from the time of their conversion to the time when he wrote the Epistle. Their religion had stood the test of time. We gather from this verse that giving assistance to those who are ministering in Christ's Name and by His authority, (of whatever kind this assistance may be, as prayers, money, sympathy, &c.), is actiially ' a fellowship of the Gospel,' and entitles the givers to the highest rewards. It was the ap- preciation of this that caused the early Christians, " as many as were possessors of lands or houses," to sell them, and to bring the " prices of the things that were sold" and "lay them down at the Apostles' feet "." And surely it is a sweet and comforting thought for those who have not been called in the course of God's providence to teach and preach in His Name, that by making His priests partakers of their worldly substance they are becoming fellow-heirs with them in their reward. See Matt. x. 41. " He that receiveth a prophet in the name of a prophet shall receive a prophet's reward ; and he that receiveth a righteous man in the name of a righteous man, shall receive a righteous man's reward." St. Gregory, commenting on this passage, remarks, with great beauty and force : — " Qui recipit prophetam in nomine prophetse mercedem prophetae accipiet. In quibus verbis notandum est quia non ait mercedem de prophetd, sed mer- cedem propheta" 6. In this verse the Apostle incidentally teaches a lesson of humility. He does not say, ' Being confident that as ye have begun, so ye will finish,' but, "that He which hath begun a ^ood work in jou will perform it," plainly shewing that the 'good work' of which he is speaking is wrought from beginning to end by God working in us. See chap. ii. 13, and Eph. ii. 8, 9. St. Paul affirms this, not out of any » Acts iv. 34, 35. c 10 ' COMMENTARY ON [CHAP. 1, opinion of the election of all the Pliilippians to eternal life, or of the certainty of their perseverance to the end'^, but he speaks from a judgment of charity, which in doubtful matters ever inclines to the more favourable slde^, conjecturing-, as Theophylact says, from what was past, what they would be for ih.e future. Eeing confident ireTTOLdd)';, ' persuasum habens,' see Eph. iii. 12. " IIocc fiducia nervus est gratiarum actionis ^" of this very thing, viz., that God will not forsake His work. that lie which hath begun a good work in you OTt 6 ivap^d/xevos iv v/jlIv epyov uyaOoi/. The repetition of the preposition eV makes this expression very emphatic. It is as if he had said, ' He who hath inbegun a good work in you' — for the work is wholly inward and spiritual. See 2 Cor. vi. 16. ' A good work ;' i. e. the preaching of the Gospel among them, and their consequent conversion. will perform it einreXicrec, ' absolvet,' * ad finem perducet,' so that by daily growing in grace, ye may at length attain to everlast- insr life. This verse teaches us that the smallest indications of grace are to be lovingly cherished, since God will not desert His work. As Bengel truly says, " Initium est pignus consummationis." ^Vnd yet because it is Ilis work it must not be thought that our co-operation is excluded. God's indwelling and inworking arc not indiscriminate, but belong to those who make a right use of the grace vouchsafed to them. This verse tells strongly against the Semipelagians, who thouglit tliat the bi'f/innlnf/ of good actions was to be ascribed to man's free-will, while the comjjletion of them belonged to Divine grace. * See chap, ii, 12, IG; iv. 1. >' 1 Cor. xiii. 7. ' Bengel. VER. 6.] ST. Paul's epistle to the philippians. 11 It must not, however, be inferred from tliis place that grace is indefectible, and that all Avho have once been made partakers of the Di\ane Nature will necessarily attain to everlasting glorj^ ; but this passage contains, for the com- fort of all believers, the confident assurance of the Apostle, (abundantly confirmed by other parts of Holy Scripture,) that God, Who is the Author of grace in the soul, will con- tinue that grace to the end, in the case of those who are desirous of retaining it. There is no promise, however, here or elsewhere, that the operations of that grace will not be suspended, and finally withdrawn, from those who neglect or misuse them. The distinction between justifying grace and the gift of perseverance must be carefully marked, or sad consequences will ensue ; for many heretics have rashly con- cluded that God always grants perseverance to those who have once been made partakers of spiritual life. But to suppose that God continues His grace irrespective of the way in which it is used, would be to say that He deals ■v\^th us as with logs and stones. See Commentary on Ephesians, p. 31. St. Augustine says % " Being sanctified, the faithful make progress in holiness and become more holy ; not without the aid of the grace of God, but by His sanctifying their ad- vancement Who sanctified their beginning." And the Coun- cil of Trent declares '\ " Deus enim, nisi ipsi homines illius gratise defuerint, sicut coepit opus bonum, ita perficiet oper- ans velle et perficere." until the day of Jesus Christ : i. e. The day of judgment ; or, as it is called, " the times of restitution of all things <=," Bengel says, " Diem Christi potius quam suam mortem sibi pro meta proponebant credcntes." The meaning of the Apostle is. The Holy Spirit of God will not desert you even in death, but will continue with you up to that day when time shall be swallowed up in eternity. For rjjxepa in the sense o^ judgment, see 1 Cor. iv. 3, iiiro avdpco- TTLVTjs t)[jLepa> Sess. vi. c. 13. " Acts iii. 21. 12 ' COMMENTARY ON [cHAP. I. prosper up to the judgment of Christ, in -which, of course, it must stand and be approved, since God will not condemn His own work. The wicked will not stand. "Therefore the ungodly shall not be able to stand in the judgment"^." Bp. Andrewcs remarks ^ "The da^^ of the Lord" (equiva- lent to " day of Jesus Christ" used here) ; " the prophet calls it dies Domini, as it were opposing it to dies servi, to our days here. As if he said. These are your days, and you use them, indeed, as if they were your own. You pour out yourselves into all riot, and know no other pouring out but that. . . . These are your days. But know this, when yours are done God hath His day too, and His day wall come at last, and it will come terribly when it comes." There is something very grand in the expression, ' day of Christ.' It is true that all days are His ; yet there is one day of such overwhelming interest and importance, that in a special sense it is His above all others. In another place St. Paul calls it 'that day' ^ (though he had prcA-iously men- tioned no particular day), plainly indicating where all his thoughts were fixed, and how they were centred in the glory that should then be revealed. 7. Even as it is meet KadoDs ia-Ti BUaiov, ' Par est enim.' See Acts iv. 19. " Piorum est semper de bene coeptis optime sperare s." He here gives the reason why he speaks of the Philippians in terms of such affectionate regard. Wetstein certainly docs not go far enough when he explains this place, " justum est vos omncs et singulos a me amari, quia oranes communi consensu contulistis ad inopiam moam sublcvandam." for mc to think this of you all, The word 'think' {^povelv) may very propcrl}- be viewed as a kind of qualification of the ' being confident' {Treiroidws) in verse 6 ; shewing that though he believed them to be sincere Christians, yet, as he could not read their hearts, it i. G. ' Scriu. xi., " Of tliu Scndinfr of the Holy Ghost. ' -1 Tim. iv. 8. k lleimuiiicrius. VEIL 6, 7.] ST. Paul's epistle to the philippians. 13 was out of liis power to pronounce a positive judgment upon their state. because I have you in my heart ; q. d. 'I bear you in my mind, or recollection, as a beloved object.' See 2 Cor. iii. 2, " Ye are our epistle, written in our hearts." And again, vii. 3, " Ye are in our hearts to die and live with you." It is to be observed that the sen- tence might be rendered 'because you hold me in your hearts.' This would be quite in accordance with the Greek text, and would give a very good sense, though probably the usual rendering is more consistent with the general scope of the Apostle's meaning. inasmuch as both in my bonds, "Yincula non constringunt amorem'".'* and in the defence i. e. ' My defence.' He means either his public speeches when brought before the Roman magistrates, or his private conferences with those who came to him. See Acts xxviii. 17, 30. The word * defence' is well used, since he was com- pelled to plead his cause as a prisoner. and confirmation of the Gospel, St. Paul defended his doctrine by words, and confirmed it by deeds. See ver. 17. There can be little doubt that he is here alluding to his bonds, for in the truest sense they were a ' confii'mation' of his preaching. If he had shrimk from imprisonment, or borne it impatiently, endeavouring to procure his release by any of those unworthy means that were then so common, he might have been thought to be a deceiver ; but now, by patiently submitting to bonds and affliction, he shewed that he was suffering for no human cause, but for God, Who would reward his sufferings with a croAvn. No one surelj^ would have chosen of his own free will to come into collision with such an emperor as Nero^ 14 co:M:\rENTATiY ON [chap. I. unless he bad looked to another and a greater King. But while accejjting this interpretation, (sanctioned as it is by the most venerable names,) it must be observed that the structure of the Greek seems rather to point to another : fie/3aicoa€i tov evayyeXiov are the Apostle's words, there being no article before ^e^atcoa-ei, and the meaning would be the general work of settling tlie Gospel by organizing the Church. Now the Church at Philippi had been fully or- ganized, as is shewn by the opening address to the priests and deacons. See observations on verse 1. The sense of the passage will then be this, ' It is but fair that I should think this of yon, because ye retain me in your affections, being all of 3'ou severally {iravras, not airavTa^,) my helpers, (1) in mv imprisonment, (2) in my public trial, (3) in Church work generally.^ yc are all partakers of my grace. The pronoun 'my' being highly emphatic; and the 'grace' being that referred to in verse 29, otl vfiiv ix"-- picrdr], K.T.X. involving belief in Christ, and suffering for His sake. For this use of the personal pronovm see 1 Cor. iii. 10; Eph. iii. 8. This sentence is sometimes translated * partakers with me of grace,' but wrongh^, since this would require avyKoivoivovs fjiOi x^ipcro?. It is evident that the Apostle here applies the term 'grace' to his sufferings; for indeed it is a great ' grace,' a distinguished mark of God's favour and love, to be permitted to suffer for the cause of Christ. This is brought out very forciblj'- in the last two verses of this chapter. Although no persecution of the Church at Philijipi is recorded in the Acts of the Apo- stles, yet it is only natural to suppose that the violence of unbelievers soon spread from St. Paul to those who were converted by him. It has been thought by some that the %«/3ts here referred to was the Apostolic office (see Rom. xii. 3), of which the Philippians became avyKoivoivoi, by assisting in, and rejoic- ing at, the preaching of the Gospel. There is another reading of ^apa9 ('joy'), for xfipt-'t'os, 'partakers of my joy,' but tlie commonly received one gives the deepest sense. VER. 7, 8.] ST. Paul's epistle to the philippians. 15 8. For God is my record, The Apostle having declared that he has the Philippian Christians ' in his heart/ now calls God to witness to the truth of what he has said. And this he does, not from any fear that his sincerity would be called in question, but because God alone searches the heart, and would therefore know the depth of his affection. Compare Rom. i. 9 ; 2 Cor. i. 23 ; 1 Thess. ii. 5, 10. See also Gen. xxxi. 50 ; Job xvi. 19. The word 'for' (yap), with which the sentence is intro- duced, must be noticed. It means ' yea,' and is used by way of preface to the explanation of verse 4, which follows. how greatly " I am unable in words to represent unto you my longing ; wherefore I leave it to God, whose range is in the heart, to know this '." I long after iiTLTroOoi ; this word denotes great ardour of affection. It occurs again, chap. ii. 26. See also Ps. xlii. 1 (LXX), ov rpoTTov eTTiTTodel rj e\a(fi09 eVl ras TTTfjas tmv vSdrcov, ovTWi eTTiTTodei T) ^jrvx^r] /xov irpos ere 6 ©eos. It may, therefore, be taken to mean " desiderium quod non patitur dilationem aliquam." you all * All' is emphatic, shewing the expansiveness of the Apo- stle's love, and is added in case the less advanced Christians among them should think themselves excluded. And then, lest it should be thought that his fervent longing towards them was merely the effect of the contributions which they had sent by the hand of Epaphroditus, he hastens to say in the bowels of Jesus Christ. The word a7r\dyxa ('viscera,' 'bowels'), denotes the 'in- ward parts,' especially the heart, lungs, liver, &c., and then comes to mean metaphorically (like our 'heart') the affec- tions, especially pity. In this place it means ' omnis affectus.' ' St, Chrysostom. 16 COMMENTARY OX [cHAP. 1. Sec 2 Cor. vi. 12 ; Eph. iv. 32 ; Col. iii. 12 ; PliHcm. 7, 12, 20 ; 1 John iii. 17. The words ' of Jesus Christ' very much intensify the force of the expression. It is as if he had said, ' with that won- drous depth of love wherewith Christ loves you and all Christians.' AVetstein says, " Eo affectu qui in ipso Christo fuit erga nos omnes," and Gagneius, " Ainicitia quae est in Christo." Bengel admirably remarks here, " In Paulo non Paulus A'ivit, scd Jesus Christus ; quare Paulus non in Pauli sed in Jesu Christi movctur visceribus." He has here very happily expressed the meaning of the Apo'stlc ; for all real love among Christians is but a fragment of the great love where- with Christ loves us, and which lives and yearns in all who are in union with Him. For reconciling this adjuration of St. Paul with our Lord's command, " Swear not at all," see St. Augustine, de Mendacio, XV. : " It is also written, * But I say unto you. Swear not at all.' But the Apostle himself has used oaths in his Epi- stles i. And so he shews how that is to be taken which is said, ' I say unto you. Swear not at all ;' that is, lest by swearing one come to a facility in swearing, from facility to a custom, and so from a custom there be a downfal into pcrjuiy. And therefore he is not found to have sworn except in writing, when there is more wary forethought, and no precipitate tongue withal. And this indeed came of evil, as it is said, ' Whatever is more than these is of evil •^ ;' not, however, from evil of his own, but from the evil of infir- mit}' Mdiich was in them, in whom he even in this waj' endea- voured to work faith. For that he used an oath in speaking, while not in writing, I know not that any Scripture has related concerning him. And yet the Lord says, ' Swear not at all ;' for He hath not granted license thereof to persons writing. Ilowbeit, because to pronounce Paul guilty of violating the commandment, especially in Epistles written and sent forth for the spiritual life and salvation of the nations, were an impiety, we must imderstand the word that J Rom. ix. 1 ; I'hil. i. 8; Uiil. i. :iU. ^ Matt. v. 3J, 37. VER. 8, 9.] ST. Paul's epistle to the philippians. 17 is set down, ' at all/ to be set down for this purpose, that as much as in thee lies, thou affect not, love not, nor as though it were for a good thing, with any delight desire, an oath." For further remarks on this subject, see Trench's " Expo- sition of the Sermon on the Mount," 2nd ed., pp. 217—222. 9. From verse 3 he has been declaring that he prays for them ; he now proceeds to shew what is the special subject of his prayers. And this I pray, that your love i. e. towards God and man. See whither those desires which are according to 'the bowels of Jesus Christ' tend! The Apostle does not pray on behalf of the Philippians for riches, or power, or praise, or anything that is usually esteemed among men, but for ' love ;' the ' more excellent way,' which he points out to the Corinthians in 1 Ep. xiii. may abound yet more and more " Ignis in Apostolo nunquam dicit, sufficit '." By the use of the expression, 'yet more,' he recognises the existence of love among the Philippians ; but his prayer is that it may increase and develope itself. And this with good reason, for " Love," says St. Chrysostom, " is a good of which there is no satiety ; see how, when loved, he would be loved still more of them ; for he who thus loves the object of his love will stay at no point of love, for it is impossible there should be a measure of so noble a thing, whence Paul desires that the debt of love should always be owing, in that he says, * Owe no man anything, but to love one another.' The measure of love is ifi stop nowhere." With the expression " more and more," compare Eph. iii. 20, "exceeding abundantly above all/' &c., and see remarks there. in knowledge and in all judgment ; iv iirtyvcoaeL koX irdcrrj alaO^aet. The word yvMcrts having been perverted by those called jvcoo-tlkoI (Gnostics) to an ' Beiigel. D 18 COMMENTARY ON [ciL\P. I. evil sense, {\lr€vS(ovv/xos yvwais, 1 Tim. vi. 20,) St. Paxil pre- fers to use eTTLjvcoais lor true knowledge. It is here (and in other parts of his writings) equivalent to the Aristotelian (f)p6i"T]a-is, and perhaps the Platonic ao^La, being that prac- tical wisdom which enables us to apply the best means, morally and intellectually, to compass a virtuous end. Aiadr}- <7Ls is moral sense, the intuitive perception of right and wrong. St. Paul here praj's that the Philippians may be guided, both in their deliberations and intuitions, by the great ruling principle of love. 10. That ye may approve This is the fruit of (Triyvcoais and alia6r}(ri9, that ye "may be able to comprehend with all saints what is the breadth, and length, and depth, and height ; and to know the love of Christ, which passcth knowledge, that ye might be filled with all the fulness of God °\" This word {BoKifid^eLv) is properly used of metals which are tested in the fire, so that their quality may be ascertained. See Prov. viii. 10 (LXX) ; x^-ii. 3. It occurs in this sense in 1 Pet. i. 7, "xpvaiov hui irvpos 8oKiiJ,a^o/j.evov. It then comes to mean ' to examine, prove, or try,' ' probare.' (See Luke xiv. 19 ; Rom. xii. 2 ; 2 Cor. viii. 8, xiii. 5 ; Gal. vi. 4 ; Eph. V. 10,) and then * to discriminate,' Luke xii. 56 ; Rom. ii. 18 ; 1 Cor. iii. 13. Bengel renders it here, "explorare et amplecti." things that are excellent ; ra BiaepovTa, ' ut probetis quje sunt utilia.' Sedulius says * altiora mysteria.' " !Non modo prae mulis bona, scd in bonis optima, quorum prrestantiam non nisi provectiores ceruunt. Sane in rebus externis eligimus accurate, cur minus in spiritualibus ? Theologia comparativa magni est "." " Pertinet ad rectum mentis judicium in ac- tiouibus probare, id est eligere meliora "." The object of the Apostle is evidently to guard them against receiving false doctrine under the specious pretence of love. Aretius says, " Siay€vi- crdaL, and then the meaning will be, *so that my bonds have become manifest in Christ ;' i.e. they have become generally known (since God wills not that His faithful witnesses should lie concealed *) not merely as a matter of notoriety, but of notoriety in Christ; as being in connexion with Christ's cause, and as being endured for His sake, and not for any faidt of my ovm. This probably is the better sense, and is more in harmony ^^dth the Greek. Bengel says, "Paulus cum aliis captivis traditus par eis visus erat ; deinde innotuit aliam esse Paidi causam, et sic invaluit Evangelium," St. Anselm says, " TJt manifestum fieret quod propter Christimi vinctus sim, non propter dcbita aut scelera ; sicque per vin- cula mea Christi nomen ubique clarescit." There is a force about the word 'manifest' {(ftavepovs) which must not be overlooked in its practical application to our own case. The Cross which Christians bear is a fiap- Tvpiov to the world, because it is a testimony to the doctrine of Christ, and is, as it were, a sealing of the truth of the Gospel. "Nam cum homines vident sanctos non propter cruccm abjicere confessionem, cogitant eos certis niti fun- damentis"." in all the palace, The Proctorium. It seems most probable that this was the barrack of the Praetorian Guards attached to the palace of Nero ''. Estius says, " The Apostle calls the palace of Ca)sar Prcetorium, [iv o\(o tm TrpanwpLw) using a Latin word, be- ' (Japneius. " Ilenimingius. " Comp. iv. 22. VEK. 13.] ST. Paul's epistle to the philippians. 23 cause it was commonly so called, even by the Greeks. And so also in Matthew, Mark, and John, we read of the pra- torium of Pilate ; and in Luke of the prcetorium of Herod." "When the blessed Apostle came to E-ome, bound for the Name of Christ, and when he had been committed to prison in the palace of the Emperor, and had begun to teach, to heal the sick, and to work many miracles, many believed ; to such an extent, indeed, that as St. Jerome says, he made the palace of the persecutor Nero a Church of the Redeemer y." and in all other places ; KaX Tot Estius. VER. 20.] ST. Paul's epistle to the philippiaks. 35 how entirely I am freed from shame ? For if the fear of death had cut short his boldness, death would have been worthy of shame ; but if death at its approach casts no terror on me, no shame is here ; but whether I live, through life I will not be ashamed, for I still preach the Gospel ; or whether I die, through death I will not be ashamed, for death hath not disgraced me, since I still exhibit the same boldness. Do not, when I mention my bonds, think shame of the matter ; so manifold good hath it caused to me, that it hath given confidence to others. For that we should be bound for Christ is no shame ; but for fear of bonds to betray aught that is Christ's, this is shame. When there is no such thing, bonds are even a cause of boldness \" as always, i. e. from the time when I became an Apostle of Christ. " Ex prseteritis sumens fiduciam futurorum ^." SO now also i. e. now that I am in prison. Christ shall be magnified /jbeyaXwOijo-erai, : for this word see Luke i. 46, 58 ; Acts X. 46, xix. 17. His humility prevents him from saying ' I shall magnify,' &c., but he says, ' Christ shall be magnified.' Whichever way his imprisonment turns out^ he says it will be well. " If I endure torments, they who hear of it will say, * That Grod is great for Whose Name His servants fear not to die 1.'" in my body, The word ' body' is here highly emphatic. Christ was to be glorified not by his soul or spirit only, (as some would have it,) but actually in his ' body.' His life or death in the body would be a glorifying of Christ. Such is the result of the Incarnation. (Compare Rom. viii. 11, "But if the Spirit of him that raised up Jesus from the dead dwell ' St. Chi-ysostom, in loc. '' Caietan. ' Hnymo. 36 COMMENTARY ON [cHAP. I, in you, He that raised up Christ from the dead shall also quicken your mortal bodies by His Spirit that dwelleth in you." See also chap. iii. 21, and the remarks made there.) It is worthy of notice that the carnal are not said to glory in the ' body/ {kv tc3 a-co/uLart,,) but in the ' flesh,' {ev rfj aapKi^) : a most important distinction. The martyrs are said ho^d^eiv tov Qeov by their death. See John xxi. 19. whether it be by life, or by death. Compare Rom. xiv. 8 ; i. e. " whether my adversaries com- pass my death, then Christ shall be magnified in my bod}' by the constancy "with which I suffer it ; or whether I shall escape from their malice, Christ shall be magnified in the same body, which He has so often delivered from their snares '^." In the occurrence, therefore, of either Ufe or death the Apostle would not be ashamed ; the one bringing active service for Christ in the world ; the other, union with Him in heaven. Sedulius well remarks " that St. Paul here triumphs over his enemies, because they are not able to harm him. For if they kill him he will be crowned with martyrdom ; if they keep him alive, he will by preaching Christ procure more abundant fruit." It is not probable that St. Paul had any supernatural means of knowing what the issue of his imprisonment would be. Bengel well says, " Paulus ipse nesciebat quo evasurum asset ; neque cnim Apostoli erant omniscii, sed potius in rebus ad sese pertinentibus per fidem et patientiam exercebantur." 21. For to me to live is Christ, He here supplies a reason for what he had said in ver. 19, shewing that he is fully prepared for any turn of fortune." " Let matters fall out as they will," he would say, " one object is immovably fixed before me, viz. Christ. All my life, the powers of my soul and body, are His ; / live Christ; my present and my future life are alike in Him." (See John i. 4.) What. St. Paul intends to convey is, " If I live it is to act Christ ; that is to say, to do what Christ did "' Oal. vi. 13. " Gagnaeus. VER. 20, 21.] ST. Paul's epistle to the philippians. 37 in suffering and teaching in order to bring men to salvation, and this is (as Caietan calls it) life to me." " For the sake of this life he delivers up his mortal body that he may receive it again for eternity ; and in this way he counts it gain to die for Christ".'' In Col. iii. 4, Christ is called "our life." Caietan remarks, "As those who are given to the pleasure of hunting say that this pursuit is life to them, and as those who are addicted to the luxuries of the table say that meat and drink is life to them, and so in the same way of others ; thus St. Paul says that Christ is life to him, because he has consecrated all his desires and all his pursuits to Christ." and to die is gain. Because death to a good man is the day-break of eternal brightness; 'janua vitae,' as St. Bernard calls it, a valley of Achor, a door of hopeP to give entrance into paradise. " Accounting it," says St. Cyprian "3, " the greatest gain to be no longer holden of the claims of this life ; no more ex- posed to all sins and vices of the flesh ; redeemed from poig- nant tribulations, and delivered from the poisoned jaws of the devil, to pass at the call of Christ into the joy of ever- lasting salvation." Haymo explains the verse thus : " If I shall die under punishment, it is the greatest gain to me, and Christ will be more and more preached. Or, it is gain to me simply to die, because if I die, I shall receive the greatest gain, that is, eternal life." See, then, the wonderful effect of divine grace ! " He who accounted it great gain to him to slay Christ in His disci- ples, now holds Christ to be his life, and death gain "■." How fully it may be permitted to the faithful to realize the truth that 'to die is gain,' is shewn by the glorious death of the Venerable Bede, attesting to all that even the valley of the shadow of death may smile like the green pas- tures, and be tranquil as the waters of comfort, to one who descends into it sustained by the staff, and defended by the rod of the Good Shepherd, Whose guidance he has followed ° St. Ambrose. '' Hosea ii. 15. '» Dc Mort., 4. ' St. Greg., Moral., xi. 16. 38 COMMENTARY ON [cHAP. I. all his life through. His death is thus described by the author of Jiistorum Semita, who quotes probably from St. Cuthbert's Life of the Saint : " About the hour of none he said to Cuthbertj * I have a few trifles in a box, run and fetch them, and call the brethren of the monastery that I may distribute these among them.' When they were come he gave each of them a little memorial of his love, and be- sought them all to be mindful of his soul in their prayers, and especially when they offered the adorable sacrifice. The brethren wept abundantly ; but he comforted them and said, ' The time of my freedom is at hand. I long to be dis- solved and be with Christ ; for my soul desires to see Christ my King in His glory.' " The following beautiful passage from St. Ignatius, Ep. ad Rom., is quoted by Wordsworth in his Greek Testament : " Suffer me to be the food of wild beasts, that I may attain unto God. I do not command you as Peter and Paul did ; they were Apostles, I am condemned. They were freemen, I am only a slave. Suffer me to die. Pardon me in this ; I know what is best for me. Now I begin to be a disciple. Let nothing that is seen or unseen envy me the joy of being Christ's. Fire and the Cross, the assaidts of wild beasts, lacerations, distractions, and dispersions of my bones, the crushing of my joints, the grinding of my whole body — welcome, welcome to them all — so that I may gain Him ! I covet not kingdoms of earth. I long to die into Christ Jems, rather than to be king of the world. Him I seek Who died for me ; Him I long for Who rose again for me. Now my birth is near. Forgive me, brethren ; do not hinder me from being born ; do not desire that I should die — I who desire to be God's. Allow me to emerge into the pure light ; when I shall arrive there I shall be a man of God. Suffer me to be an imitator of the Passion of my God." St. Chrysostom uses this verse as ground for consolation on the death of friends. " Let us," he says, " lament for them, let us assist them according to our power, let us think of some assistance for them, small though it be, yet still able to help them. How, and in what way ? By praying our- VER. 21, 22.] ST. Paul's epistle to the philippians. 39 selves for them, by entreating others to make prayers for them, by continually giving to the poor on their behalf. This deed hath some consolation ; for hear the words of God Himself when He says, ' I will defend this city for Mine own sake, and for My servant David's sake.' If the remem- brance only of a just man has so great power, how, when deeds are done for one, will it not have power ? Not in vain did the Apostles order that remembrance should be made of the dead in the dreadful mysteries. They know that great gain resulteth to them, and great assistance ; for when the whole people stands with uplifted hands, a priestly assem- bly, and that awful Sacrifice lies displayed, how shall we not prevail with God by our entreaties for them ?" There is another reading here of ')(^pr}(XT6v for XpiaTos, — * to me life is good, though death is gain ;' but this is a very inferior reading ; for the whole force of the passage is to con- trast the Apostle's death with his life ; q. d. Christ shall be glorified in me whether I live or die. If I live, it is Christ to me ; i. e. I become by sufiering more and more like Christ. If I die, it is gain to me, for then I depart to Christ. 22. But if I live The Apostle here begins to treat of the first member of the alternative ; the second is in ch. ii. 17. Lest any one should think that reproach is cast upon life, lest any one should say, if we gain no advantage here, wherefore do we not make away with ourselves ? He answers, By no means. It is open to us to profit even here ; if we live not this, but another life ^ El, ' if, ' in this verse does not imply doubt ; the meaning is, since to live in the flesh, &c. in the flesh, i. e. in this p^ishable body. Compare Gal. ii. 20. " Li- mitat ; nam etiam morientes vivvmt ^." this i. e. life in the body. It seems best to connect rovro in this verse with to ^rjv, and to construe 'this life in the flesh.' ' St. Chrysostom, in loc. ' Bengel. 40 COMMENTARY OS [cHAP. I. There is no reason that this should not be done, and it is preferable to making rovro redundant, as some do. The full meaning will then be, " If then this life in the flesh is KapTTos epyov, worth the trouble, which it assuredly is if it makes me like Christ, Kal, then, I cannot tell which I shall choose." He would naturally prefer to die, and be with Christ ; still, if his li\dng glorified God, and was Christ to himself, he would consent to it. is the fruit of my labour : " For the edification of others "." " Mihi maximus labo- rum atque operum meorum fructus est ^ :" i. e. the occasion of my bringing forth much fruit by Avinning souls to Christ. Compare Rom. i. 13. The expression Kapirbs epyov would appear to be a Latinism opera pretium, and to signify * worth my labour,' ' worth doing,' or, as we should say, * a desirable thing.' Observe here the total want of selfishness displaj'-ed by the Apostle. Another person would be discouraged if he did not receive some fruit from his toils, more especially when they had been very irksome and severe ; but not so St. Paul ; with him toil and fruit were identical. Cicero well says, " Ego mihi fructum amicitise propono ipsam amicitiam, qua nihil est uberius." yet what I shall choose I wot not. KoX Tt alprjcrofjbai : for the meaning of koX in this place see above. He had declared death to be gain, yet life is needful, not indeed for himself, but for his spiritual chil- dren. As Fulgentius says, he had " mortem in desiderio, vitam in patientia." * what,' i. e. of these two things ; either that by dying I may be with Christ ; or living, may bring forth fruit for the Church. St. Paul professes himself unable to choose. On both sides were weighty reasons, " To remove to the assembly of the saints was for the good of the Apostle, but, on the other hand, he sees that the Churches stand in need of his helpy." " St'dnlina. * Wetstein. ^ Aretins. VER. 22, 23.] ST. Paul's epistle to the phtlippians. 41 How great must have been his love for souls, that he could postpone his own happiness to the welfare of his converts ! It is only by considering what his life was, its toils, anxieties and distresses, (see 2 Cor. xi. 23, and follow- ing,) the fightings from without and the fears within, that we shall be able at all to estimate the nature of the sacrifice which he made in choosing life for the sake of his spiritual children. We may, perhaps, think it wonderful that he should doubt, even for a moment, what to choose ; but we must not forget that, after all, his choice was Christ ; for he chose life, that he might be the means of winning more souls. Compare Rom. ix. 3, " For I could wish that myself were accursed from Christ for my brethren, my kinsmen according to the flesh." St. Chrysostom says % ' The blessed Paul placing before himself the alternative of living upon earth, and departing and being with Christ, decides for the former." 23. For I am in a strait betwixt two, (Tvve-)(pfiaL e/c roiv hvo, * coarctor ex his duobus ;' (com- pare 2 Sam. xxiv. 14 ;) i. e. I am perplexed, held in, kept back from decision by the two, (the article being highly em- phatic,) viz. TO ^rjv and to airodavelv, for it is about these two that he has already been speaking. The meaning is, I am drawn in two different directions ; on the one hand by the desire of being with Christ, on the other, by the love of the brethren. For o-vvixpfiai in this sense, see Luke xii. 60 ; Acts xviii. 5. See also St. Augustine, De doctr. Christ., lib. iii. c. 3. It is just possible that the use of this word may have been suggested to the Apostle by the circum- stance of his being at this time a prisoner, and bound to two soldiers. Compare Acts xii. 6. having a desire to depart, Tr]v eTriOvficav e^cov eh rb avaXvaaL ; literally, ' having my desire towards,' rrjv eiriOvfilav e^f^v being much stronger than the simple eiriOvficov. In order to make the English * In Gal. i. 4. G 42 COMMENTARY OX [CHAP. I. Tersion correct, the reading should be eTTtdvfiCav e-)(o)v rou, hence the delicacy of the sense is lost. The Apostle here gives the reason for his being ' in a strait ;' he does not, how- ever, sa)', * to die/ but ' to depart,' dvakvaai, Vulg. ' dissolvi,' the idea probably being that of unharnessing the spirit, as opposed to eiTLixeveLv iv rfj aapKi, ' to remain in the trammels of the flesh.' The plain word 'die' is very seldom used of Christians. As the heathen used scrupulously to avoid it, so St. Paul (a classical scholar) seems to prefer using an- other word whenever he can. ' Depart, decease, sleep, rest, cease,' &c., are the words which find most favour with him. Bp, Andrewes remarks beautifully on 1 Cor. xv. 20 : " Christ is risen from the dead, the firstfruits not of the dead, but of them that sleep. You see His rising hath wrought a change." "We should never forget, therefore, the important bearing which the word ' depart,' and kindred terms, should have upon Christian doctrine, since they teach that the change involved in death is but of place, not of company. * What do I here ?' i. e. in the -world, was a favourite sajang of St. Augustine's holy mother. Camerinus ordered in his will that the following line should be inscribed on his tomb : — " Vita mihi mors est; mors mihi vita nova est." The ' strait ' in which St. Paul felt himself may be illus- trated by the words of Pontius, the deacon and biographer of St. Cyprian, who, speaking of his martyrdom, says, " What shall I here do ? between joy at his passion and grief at bereavement my mind is divided, and two sorts of feelings oppress a breast too straitened for them. Shall I grieve that I was not his companion ? but his triumph is to be celebrated. Shall I celebrate his triximph ? but I am in grief that I am not his companion. To you, however, the truth is to be avowed, and simply, as you know it, that it was in my purpose to be so. In his glory I exult much and more than much, and yet I grieve more that I remain behind." and to be with Christ, This must be connected closely with 'to depart,' since VER. 23.] ST. Paul's epistle to the philippians. 43 death by itself is not a thing to be desired or chosen, but only in so far as it unites vis to Christ. The faithful in this life are 'in Christ/ and Christ is in them% but only those who are actually present in glory can be said to be ' with Christ ^' St. Chrj^sostom '^ shews that St. Paul's longing to depart is our example, and represents him as saying, " ' I have tasted of the grace, and I cannot contain myself in the delay. I have the first-fruits of the Spirit, and I press on towards the whole. I have ascended to the third heaven ; I have seen that glory which is unutterable; I have be- held the shining palaces ; I have learnt what joys I am deprived of while I linger here, and therefore do I groan.* For suppose any one had conducted thee into princely halls, and shewn thee the gold glittering everywhere on the walls, and all the rest of the glorious show ; if from thence he had led thee back afterward to a poor man's hut, and promised that in a short time he would bring thee back to those palaces, and would there give thee a perpetual mansion : tell me, wouldest thou not indeed languish with desire, and feel impatient, even at these few days ? Thus, then, think of heaven and of earth, and groan with Paul, not because of death, but because of the present life !" which is far better : ttoWm fxaXXov Kpelcraov, the comparative is doubled, by a common Hebraism, to shew the exceeding earnestness of the Apostle. Compare Mark vii. 36, and 2 Cor. vii. 13. St. Ambrose ^ mentions three reasons why the faithful Chris- tian should desire to be ' dissolved,' or ' depart,' because there are three chains which bind us down to earth : (1) the pains arid suffering of the body ; (2) lusts and sinful af- fections ; (3) the eager pursuit of worldly objects. Death breaks these chains, and so sets us free. As might be ex- pected, this is a very favourite passage with the Fathers for consolation on the death of friends. TertuUian says % " He ^ 2Cor. xiii.Sj Eph. iu.l7; IJohn iv. 13. •> 2 Cor. V. 8. "^ On the Statues, v. 5. '' De Bono Mortis. *■ De Patientia, ix. 44 COMMENTARY OX [cHAP. I. that goetli before us is not to be mourned, but altogether to be longed for ; and even this longing must be tempered with patience. For why shouldest thou not bear with moderation that he hath departed whom thou shalt presently follow? But impatience in such a matter augureth ill for our hope, and is a double dealing with our faith. Besides, we injure Christ, when, as each is called away by Him, we bear it impatiently, as though they were to be pitied. How ' much better' does the Apostle shew the desire of the Christian to be ! "Wherefore, if we impatiently mourn for others who have obtained this desire, we are unwilling to obtain it ourselves." St. Chrj'sostomf makes vise of this passage against sor- cerers and those who professed to have dealings with the inhabitants of the other world ; shewing that disembodied spirits are not allowed to roam about at pleasure. " It is evident," he says, " that after their departure hence our souls are led away into some place, having no more power of themselves to come buck again, but awaiting that dread- ful Day.' 24. This verse contains the reason why St. Paul chose life ; viz. that by his continued presence among his spiritual children he might further their faith. Nevertheless to abide iu the flesh i. e. in this mortal body, as above, v. 22. is more needful for you. a-va'^/Katorepov 8c v/xas ; the English Version misses the delicate sense contained in these words, which is, *my re- maining in the flesh is the more needful of the two alter- natives because of you ;' i. e. for your sake ; and it is to be observed that the Apostle does not say to ' remain in the flesh' is less good, or less desirable ; but, as if it were nei- ther good nor desirable iu itself, ho says, 'more needful because of you.' ' Ilom xxviii. 3, in Matt. VER. 24, 25,] ST. Paul's epistle to the philippians. 45 So Seneca, " Vitee suae adjici nihil desiderat sua causa, sed eorum quibus utilis est s." Speaking of the intensity of St. Paul's loving self-denial, St. Chrj^sostom says *", ' Let one fast and deny himself, and be a martyr, and be burnt to death ; but let another delay his martyrdom for his neighbour's edification; and let him not only delay it, but let him even depart without martyrdom ; who will be the more approved after his removal hence ? AVe need not have many words, nor a long circumlocution, for the blessed Paul is at hand, giving his judgment and saying, ' to depart and be with Christ is better, nevertheless to abide in the flesh is more needful for you ;' even to his removal unto Christ did he prefer his neighbour's edification. For this is in the highest sense ' to be with Christ,' even to be doing His will ; but nothing is so much His will, as that which is for one's neighbour's good." What an admirable example does the Apostle here set for Christ's ministers to follow ! Instead of seeking bene- fices and honours, to choose the lowest room ; to deny themselves worldly honour and glory, for the edification of their flock ! St. Chrysostom well describes the love that a minister should have for his people ; " Oh ! that I could always be with you. Yea rather, am I always with you ; though not by bodily presence, yet by the power of love. For I have no other life but you, and the care of your salva- tion. As the husbandman hath no other anxiety but about his seeds and his harvests, and the pilot about the waves and the harbours, so the preacher is anxious with respect to his auditors and their progress, even as I am at this present time. Wherefore I bear you all upon my mind, not only here, but also at home. For if the multitude be great, and the measure of my heart be narrow, yet love is wide, and ye are not straitened in us '." 25. The Apostle here begins to treat of his grace in bonds, and the defence and confirmation of the Gospel, relatively to the Philippians. g Ep. 98. '• Horn. Ixxvii. 6, in Matt. ' On the Statue?, ix. 1. 46 COMMENTARY ON [ciIAP. I. And having this confidence, i. e. that my continued life in the flesh is needful for your spiritual welfare. I know that I shall abide and continue with you all Not that he had any absolute or certain source of know- ledge ; but he sj^oke from reasonable conjecture. Sedidius, however, saj^s, " Spiritu prophetico promittit." for your furtherance and joy of faith ; i.e. that I may promote your spiritual interests J, and fill you with that hol}^ joy which results from a living faith. It is to be observed, that advance in the faith is inseparable from joy. The more we are penetrated with faith the more we rejoice*^, and gloom and moroseness are pretty certain signs that vital religion is absent. ' Fui'therance and joy ' are a hendiadys for 'joyful advance.' This verse proves that the Epistle was written during St. Paul's first imjDrisonment, as he was put to death in his second. Ben gel says, " Non dubium est quin Paulus ex priore captivitate in ilia climata redierit." The use of the expressions ' abide ' and ' continue ' would seem to point out that the Apostle anticijDated a lengthened sojourn among the PhiHppians, on his release from prison. There is a remarkable passage in Seneca, Epist. 104, which illustrates this verse. " Indulgendum est enim honestis af- fectibus, et interdum, etiamsi premimt causae, spiritus in honorera suorum vel cum tormcnto revocandus, et in ipso ore rctinendus est : cum bono viro vivendum sit, non quam- diu juvat, sed quamdiu oportct. Ille qui non uxorem non amicum tanti putat ut diutius in vita commoretur, qui per- sevcrat mori, delicatus est. Hoc quoque imperet sibi ani- mus, ubi utilitas suorum exigit ; ncc tantum si vult mori, sed si coepit, intermittat, et suis se commodet. Ingentis animi est alicna causa ad vitam reverti ; quod magni viri sajpe fccerunt." J Rom. i. 11. ^ Kom. v. 1—5. VER. 25, 26.] ST. Paul's epistle to the philippians. 47 26. That your rejoicing may be more abundant To Ka6)^r)/iia vfiMv, somewhat stronger than 'rejoicing.' It is probably equivalent here to a-'yaWiajxa, exultatio, or perhaps gratulatio, or gloriatio, i.e. boasting, in a good sense. Estius says the meaning of the passage is, " Ut cum liberatus et vobis restitutus fuero, possitis affatim de me Apostolo vestro gloriari, yobisque gratulari, sed hoc in Christo Jesu." Others, however, understand it to mean, That I may the more abundantly boast myself of you in Christ Jesus, when I have returned to you, and seen how much you have ad- vanced in Christian doctrine and discipline during my ab- sence. The former meaning is probably the correct one ; being more in harmony with the general tone of the Apo- stle's character and his language throughout this Epistle, which is to ignore self. The difference between Kav'x^rjfia and Kav'^rjuLs must not be overlooked, Kav^nfia being the thing boasted of, the object of boasting ; Kavj^i^cns the act of boasting '. This difference (a very important one) is often lost sight of by translators, e.g. Kripv^ixa"^ is the thing preached, not 'preaching,' as translated in the English version ; this woidd be Krjpv^is. The 'foolishness of preaching,' then, does not mean a bad sermon, but a subject which seems un philosophical. And so in this place to Kav^nijua v[jlS)v means that the reason you have for boasting may abound through my restoration to 3'^ou. See also 1 Cor. v. 6, ov koXov to Kau^rjfia v/xcov, 'the reasons you give for glorjdng are not good.' in Christ Jesus for me St. Paul never even for a moment separates himself from Christ. He is the Central Figure in all his thoughts. See Commentary on the Ephesians, pp. 127, 141. by my coming to you again. i. e. that from my unexpected return to you, you may be able to see how great is the care which God has for His people, ' Rom. iii. 27. " 1 Cor. i. 21. 48 COMMENTARY ON [CHAP. I. 27. Only rrom an intense desire of receiving good fruits from among the Pliilippians, he passes on to exhortation, calling upon them to shew themselves such as he believes them to be. As if he had said, Dismiss all your anxiety on my behalf; this is the one thing that I have to ask of you in the prospect of my speedy return, viz. that your life be answerable to the holiness of your profession. let your conversation be JJoXcreveaOe, ' play the citizen.' There is great force and beauty in this word as used here, because iroXirevixa was applied to the imperfect citizenship (municipium) of the Romans. See chap. iii. 20 ; compare also Acts xxiii. 1. As if he had said, "Play the citizen of heaven, though j^our heavenly citizenship is as yet necessarily imperfect "." At the last day we shall be made 'full citizens' [Quirites, koXoI Kayadol) of the celestial Jerusalem. as becometh the gospel of Christ : See Commentary on the Ephesians, pp. 216, 217. " To walk worthily in the Gospel is to believe in Christ and to teach Him according to the precepts of the Gospel ; to live according to His commands, to trust in His promises, and to do all things according to His will °." that whether I come and see you, or else be absent. Shewing that he did not feel certain how his imprison- ment would end. See above, verse 25. I may hear of your affairs, This is explained by what immediately follows, where he tells them what he desires to see when present among them, and to hear of when absent, viz. : — that ye stand fast in one spirit, "Ecce societas gratiae spiritualisP." In using the word " Heb. xiii. 14. " Haymo. p Caietan. VER. 27.] ST. PAULAS EPISTLE TO THE PHILIPPIANS. 49 'stand,' the Apostle borrows a figure from wrestlers and others wlio contended in tlie Grecian games. See remarks in Commentary on Eph. vi. 11, 13^ 14. He here exhorts the Philippians to unity. As the Spirit is one, he would say, so must they who are under His blessed influence be one also. See Acts iv. 32, and Commentary on Ephesians iv. 3. Zanchius remarks, " He well shews that perseverance is not of our own strength or merit, but is the free gift of the Holy Ghost." It is not necessary, how- ever, to restrict the meaning of * one Spirit ' to the Holy Ghost. It may also mean that identity of thought and feel- ing which should ever exist among Christians. with one mind Mia 'yjrvxV) " quasi vobis omnibus una tantum esset anima charitatis 5." Aristotle calls a friend dXkos avros. See remarks on chap. ii. 20, and compare 1 Cor. i. 10. striving together avvaOXovvres, a very emphatic word. He still preserves the metaphor taken from wrestling. "Ecce societas ad confirmationem Evangelii '^■." 'Striving,' not amongst each other, or against each other ; but helping one another, and me also, in spreading the common faith. for the faith Ty iricrreL, i. e. virep rrjs irlcrrews. See Jude 3, " that ye should earnestly contend for the faith." It may also be rendered per fidem', being that by means of which the con- flict is to be carried on. of the gospel ; i. e. " which faith rests on the Gospel as its foundation, and consequently upon the unconquered strength of Christ ^" This shews that it is not for trifles that Christians have to contend, but for the Truth of the living God. 1 Corn, a Lap. ■■ Caietau. ' Beza. H 50 COMMENTARY ON [cHAP. I. 28. And in nothing terrified by your adversaries : Compare with this verse Ps. iii. 6, " I will not be afraid for ten thousands of the people : that have set themselves against me round about." ' Terrified,' irrvpo/xevoi, " is a word properly used of horses V' and thence transferred to men. The figui-e is taken from gladiators, who with a fierce assault and sarage gestures rush upon their antagonists in order to terrify them. " Ecce societas ad defensionem Evangclii "." The Apostle would say. Let not persecutions excited by wicked men disturb or terrify you. There is no real cause for alarm ; since the affliction which they endeavour to bring upon you will cast them down to hell, but will be the means of exalt- ing you to heaven. Comj)are 1 John v. 4 : " This is the victory that overcometh the world, even our faith." which is to them an evident token of perdition, " Quod vos terrent et affligunt perditionis illis causa est, vobis salutis, et hoc Dei gratia''." The English Version 'evident token' seems hardly to express the force of the original eVSe/^t?. From the way in which the verb ivBel^at is used elsewhere (see 2 Tim. iv. 14, ' AXe^avhpos 6 xaXfcem iroXkd yuoi KaKa eueSel^aTo), it is plain that the word ' token' inadequately translates its substantive evBet^cs. It must be taken, therefore, not so much for a token, as a cause, q. d., the malice of the Gentiles is the cause of their destruction, and at the same time the cause of your salvation. For that affliction is not only a token, but also a cause of salvation, appears from 2 Cor. iv. 17. If the English Version ' token ' is accepted, evhei^is will be a shewing by signs or tokens, as oj)posed to airohei^Ls, logical proof; and then the meaning will be, ' the opposition of your adversaries is a proof of their being lost, and of your being saved by a salvation which comes of God, because you suffer as Christ did.' and that of God. Since this freedom from terror is not to be acquired by ' BcHgel. " Ciiietan. ^ Gafrneius. VER. 28, 29.] ST. Paul's epistle to the philippians. 51 our own natural powers it is well said to be ' of God,' " Who wills that His Own children should be crowned when proved, as Job is permitted to be tempted y." Zanchius says, " There is therefore no reason why the stronger should wax insolent, or the weaker become fearful, since they are able to seek and obtain from God fortitude and perseverance." And Hemmingius, " The Apostle as- cribes the victory to God as its Author for two reasons ; viz. that the faithful should not faint in their minds if anything is to be suffered for the Gospel, and may not become insolent and be puffed up, as if they could effect anything through their own excellence." The word 'terrified,' used in this verse by the Apostle, is suggestive of a very solemn line of thought, as shewing the nature of the devices of the adversary with whom we have to contend. In the first instance he endeavours to overcome our constancy by bringing to bear upon us all pleasurable things, thereby enticing us to gratify our appe- tites to the full ; but at last, when these have failed, he brings all painful things. He first knocks at the door of desire, and when he finds that closed against him, at the door of /ear. It was so with our blessed Lord, as will be seen by comparing the temptation of the wilderness with the temptation of the garden. See especially the words " for a season ^ ;" implying that there was another and a fiercer temptation still to come. 29. For unto you it is given in the behalf of Christ, not only to believe on Him, but also to suffer for His sake; St. Paul here ascribes the very highest position to suf- ferings endured for the sake of Christ, a position even above faith itself, and the power of working miracles, and as conferring such an honour as the most exalted angel in heaven is not permitted to enjoy : — " Non solum ut fidei y Sedulius. ^ Luke iv. 13. 52 ' COMMENTARY ON [cHAP, I. meritum, scd etiam martyrii meritum prsemium liabeatis, duiu vos tentari Deus patitur ut vincatis'*." We learn hence (1), That to suffer for Christ's sake is grace and favour, (" it is given," i-x^aptadr),) and that if the grace be used aright it merits the highest rewards. (2) That they who infer from these words that faith is so exclusively the gift of God, that men are merely the passive recipients of it, have just as much reason for jjronoimcing that we can possibly be considered to have suffered for the name of Christ without the concurrence of our own wills; the expression * given ' being applied equally to both. St. Augustine in a passage of singular beauty '' shews how persecution and suffering helped to propagate the Faith. " Let the Jews," he says, " rage madly, and be filled with jealousy; Stephen be stoned, Saul keep the raiment of them who stone him, Saul, one day to be the Apostle Paul. Let Stephen be killed, the Church of Jerusalem dispersed in con- fusion ; out of it go forth burning brands, and sj)read them- selves and spread their flame. For in the Church of Jeru- salem, as it were, burning brands were set on fire by the Holy Sj)irit, when they had all one soul and one heart to God- ward. "\V~hen Stephen was stoned that pile suffered per- secution : the brands were dispersed, and the world was set on fire. . . . Let the nations hear, let the nations believe, let the nations multiply, let the Lord's empurpled spouse spring forth from the blood of martyrs." Speaking of suffering for the sake of Christ, St. Chr}^- sostom says that it is a gift " far more wonderful than rais- ing the dead or working miracles, as there I am a debtor to Christ, but here I have Christ as my debtor," "Your cruelty is our glory," said the primitive martyrs. " I had rather be a martyr than a monarch," said St. Ignatius. "It is to my loss if you defraud me of anj^thing in my sufferings," said another holy martyr. And St. Augustine testifies that Crispina rejoiced aloud when she was ap- prehended, when she was brought to trial, when she was condemned, and when she was led away to execution. ■ Scduliua, ^ Horn. Ixvi. 6, in Nov. Test. VER. 29, 30.] ST. PAULAS EPISTLE TO THE PHILIPPIANS. 53 And this, surely, when rightly considered, should be the ground of the deepest and holiest Christian joy, viz. that God thinks us worthy to suffer anything for the love of Him who suffered everything for love of us. In the case of St. Paul persecution followed close upon persecution, — there were tumults, fightings, scourgings, stonings'', — the devil only relaxed his efforts for a moment to gain strength for a new assault, and yet these things only excited in him a deeper rejoicing. And so with the other Apostles : suffer- ing was the groundwork of their most fervent joy ; the ut- most malice of their enemies was their source of triumph. It was in the inner prison, with their feet fast in the stocks, that SS. Paul and Silas sang hymns of victory "^ ; and when St. Peter and the rest were dismissed by the council, their backs having been torn by rods, they rejoiced, not indeed because God had vouchsafed to them the power of working miracles, but because " they were counted worthy to suffer shame for His Name ^." 30. Having the same conflict St. Paul uses the word aywv ('conflict') in describing the sufferings of Christians to shew that he who suffers aright ever strives manfully lest he be overcome by an impatient spirit. St. Cyprian ^, speaking of the fortitude of the martyrs, and the glorious strife between the tortures and the tortured, continues : — '' The crowd of by-standers witnessed wondering the heavenly conflict, the conflict of God, the spiritual con- flict, the battle of Christ ; that His servants stood with voice unfettered, with minds unbroken, with courage given of God, of secular weapons indeed naked, but armed and trustful in the armour of faith. The tortured stood more resolute than the torturers, and the racked and mangled limbs vanquished the grappling-hooks that racked and mangled them. Long though it raged, the oft-renewed blow could not vanquish a faith invincible, although the closure of their bowels was <= 2 Cor. xi. 23—28. ^ Acts xvi. 25. « Acts V. 41. ' Ep. X. 1. 54 ' COMMENTARY ON [cHAP. I. torn open, and now in God's servants not limbs, but wounds, were tortured. There flowed blood, that might extinguish the blazes of persecution, quench the flames and fires of hell by its glorious gore. Oh ! what a spectacle was that to the Lord, how sublime, how great, how acceptable to the eyes of God, the fealty and devotion of His soldiery ! " which ye saw in me, and now hear to be in me. He proposes himself as a pattern to them (as it were a speculum fortitudinis) of the way in which they should with- stand all adversaries, so that they should not be crushed beneath the weight of the cross, nor cast aside their pro- fession through the bitterness of affliction. He reminds them of the sufferings endured by himself, of which they had been eye-witnesses (see Acts xvi.), there being special stress on the words ' in me,' i.e. ' in me not terrified or cast down,' as a proof of what may be borne by one sustained by the grace of God. " Let it not therefore be thought un- worthy in you to suffer those things wherein you behold us glorying ^." It appears from this verse that verse 29 must be paren- thetical, and explanatory of ' to you of salvation, and that of God,' since the Greek is top avrbv d'ywva e')(ovTes, and not exovai (dative), which it would be if this verse w^ere con- nected with vfjbiv in ver. 29. We gather from this passage, that after the departure of St. Paul the Philippian Christians were exposed to persecution, although no account of it is given ill Holy Scripture. K Sedulius. VER. 1.] ST, Paul's epistle to the philippians. 55 SUMMARY OF CHAPTEE II. With many arguments and much fervour, St. Paul exhorts the Philippians to unity, humility, and perseverance. He promises that he will send Timothy and Epaphroditus, whom he separately commends to them. The chief parts of this chapter are two : — (1.) Hortatory, in which he encourages the Philippians to the practice of virtues worthy of the Christian calling, and takes occasion to dwell specially on the humiliation and exaltation of Christ, ver 1. to 18. (2.) Commendatory, in which he specially commends St. Timothy and Epaphroditus to their love : ver. 19 to 30. CHAP. II. Yer. 1. See with what aniazing earnestness the Apostle here entreats tlie Philippians, with love surpassing even that of the fondest parent ! Estius has not done more than jus- tice to this exhortation, when he calls it " oratio vehemens ac mira pathetica." Another writer, speaking of the ex- quisite tenderness of this verse, says, " Persuasion itself could not speak more persuasively." Nor shall we wonder at the exceeding earnestness of the Apostle's language when we consider the importance of the matters he is about to introduce, viz., four great points of the Christian life, which, he proceeds severally to unfold. St. Chrj^sostom remarks upon the affectionate fervour of the Apostle's language, and goes on to say, " We indeed remind men of our carnal claims ; for example, if a father were to say to his son, ' If thou hast any reverence for thy father, if any remembrance of my care in nourishing thee, if any affection towards me, if any memory of my kindness, be not at enmity with thy brother. This is what I ask in return for all those things.' But Paul does not so ; for he calls to our remembrance no carnal, but all of them spiritual benefits.^' 56 ' COMMENTARY ON [cHAP. II. If there be therefore It Is to be observed that the use of the word ' if in such a construction as this implies a strong and earnest affir- mation. any consolation in Christ, q. d. If you are willing to afford to mc, who am bound for the sake of Christ, any such consolation as it becomes one Christian to offer to another. The words * in Christ' are added to shew that it is spiritual consolation which he asks at their hands, and that he is not actuated by mercenary motives. It may also mean, if you feel in yourselves any consolation arising from a sense of God's love and jowx for- giveness through Christ ; but the former Is the best inter- pretation. It may well be thought that there is a notion of entreaty included In the word ' consolation' {irapaKkr^ais) in this place, irapaKoXeiv meaning 'to entreat,' see ]\Iatt. xviii. 32, and the sense would then be, * if you can be entreated in Christ.' *' Si exhortatio nomine Chrlsti instituta locum apud vos ha- bere potest V See also 2 Cor. v. 20: virep Xpia-rov ovv TrpecrlBevoixev ois rov Qeov irapaKaKovvTOS Bt' r][xS)v. if any comfort of love, irapafxvOiov a'ydiTTjs, i. e. comfort furnished by love ; ' of love' being the subjective genitive. The primary meaning oi irapafivdtov is an 'address' or 'exhortation' — alloquium, and then by an easy transition it comes to mean that parti- cular form of address whereby we comfort the afflicted (the word Is so used John xi. 19, 1 Thess. ii. 11, and v. 14), and so it has been well translated here, locutio super cor ; for to speak to the heart Is to speak those things by which the heart may be cheered and refreshed. The meaning of the Apostle Is plain, viz. if you are willing to shew your love by consoling mc. " There is," says Caietan, " among those who suffer in fellowship for Christ a mutual consolation also in Christ." For if God so loved the world as to give His Only ' Koscniuiiller. v VER. 1.] ST. Paul's epistle to the philippians. 57 Son, and the eternally Begotten was willing to die for His enemies, surely Christians are bound by the closest ties to love one another, and to abound in mutual consolation. Though the above is most probably the Apostle's meaning, it is pos- sible that Trapa/jbvOcov ayaTrijs may be nearly the same as the preceding words, q. d. ' if ye can be persuaded by love,' which should ever be the highest and most forcible per- suasion to a Christian"^. if any fellowship of the Spirit, el Tis KOivwvCa irvevjjLaTos, literally * if there be any fellow- ship of spirit,' (the word ' the' before * spirit' in the English Version being gratuitous,) i. e. of human sjTupathy and kindly affection between us. See chap. i. 27. But this interpreta- tion n«ed not of course exclude the higher sense, ' if there be any fellowship between us and the Holy Sjnrit,' in union with Whom alone all true fellowship consists. For if they were of old called 'Pagani' who were accustomed to drink from the same fountain, how much more intimate is the connexion of those who drink of the same Spirit ? See 1 Cor. xii. 4. Gagneius paraphrases these words thus: " Si mecum aliquam Spiritus Sancti communicationem accepistis." if any bowels and mercies, (TirXa'^'yya koL olKTipfMoL In Col. iii. 12 we meet with aiT\dpov€lT€, which if correct would be much more simple than the commonly received (^poveladoy. Our Blessed Lord was pleased to set Himself before His disciples as their pattern s : " Take My yoke upon you, and learn of Me ; for I am meek and lowly in heart : and ye shall find rest unto your souls." St. Paul now does the same, and in exhorting the Philippians to humility brings •■ De Off., (quoting probably from a well-known passage in Plato). * " Ilia sancta qusedani cura est, qua quisque proximi studiis perinde atque suis studet. Ha'c profana tenie- ritas Gft, qua quis nunc aliena Uiunera invadit, nunc alios calmnniandi studio observat. De hac recte dicitur — Tijs TToXvTTpay/jLoavi'-qs ovSii/ x^P^^'i'^pov &K- \o." — Hemniingius, in lac. f Ej). xi. 1. e Matt. xi. 29. 66 COMMENTARY OX [cHAP. II. forward the example of his Divine Master, as well in the precept which he had given concerning the preservation of humility towards all, as in preferring a neighbour's good to private advantage^. St. Paul might have cited himself, if he had desired to do so, for in chap. i. 24 we have a remark- able instance of his self-denying humility', — an example, too, which the Philippians would be sure to appreciate, — but he was content to set before them as a pattern no less a Person than Christ Himself, (see Rom. xv. 2, 3 ; 2 Cor. ^^ii. 9 ; and Eph. V. 2,) for " Nothing," says St. Chrysostom, " will rouse a soul to the performance of good works so much as learning that in this it is likened to God. What encouragement is equal to this?" This verse, then, teaches us that we should daily strive to express Christ to the world ; not merely as a picture does a man, in outward lineaments, but as a child does his father, in affections and actions. For as Moses was commanded by God, when about to build the taber- nacle, " See that thou make all things according to the pattern shewed to thee in the mount J," so Christians ought ahvays to set before themselves as their pattern Christ cru- cified on Calvary. This verse also may be used to refute the heresy of Nes- torius, who assigned to Christ a double Person and Nature ; for the expression * let this mind' relates to His Humanity, while what follows, about * the form of God,' belongs to His Divinity. And yet the former is assigned by St. Paul to One and the self-same Person as the latter. St. Augustine'' shews that true himiilitj^ was taught by Christ, and not by the wisest heathens. He says, " This is the water of confession of sin, this is the water of humilia- tion of heart, this is the water of a life leading unto sal- vation, abasing itself, presuming nothing of itself, attri- buting nothing proudly to its own power. This water is not in any of the books of the Gentiles ; not in the books of the Epicura3ans, not of the Stoics, not of the Manichacans, not of the Platonists. Even Avhere the best precepts of ^ Estius, in loc. ' See also Commentary on Epliosians, p. 183. J Hcb. viii. 5. ^ In Ps. xxxii. Exp. 2, VER. 5, 6.] ST. Paul's epistle to the philippians, 67 morals and discipline are found, yet is not found that hu- mility. The way of that humility flows from another source ; it comes from Christ. This way is from Him, Who when He was high, came lowly." 6. St. Chrysostom remarks that this one verse overthrows some of the most pernicious heresies that had arisen up to his time against the Nature and Person of our Lord, viz. those of Arius, Paul of Samosata, Marcellus of Gralatia, Sa- bellius, Marcion, Valentinus, Manes, Apollinarius, Photinus, Sophronius and others. " Rouse yourselves, then," he says, *' to behold so great a spectacle, so many armies falling by one stroke, lest the pleasure of such a sight shoidd escape you. For if when chariots contend in the horse-race there is nothing so pleasing as when one of them dashes together and overthrows whole chariots with their drivers, and after throwing down many with the charioteers that stood thereon, drives by alone towards the goal, and the end of the course, and amid the applause and clamour which rises on all sides to heaven, with coursers winged as it were by that joy and that applause, sweeps over the whole ground ; will not the pleasure be much greater here, when by the grace of God we overthrow at once and in a body the combinations and devilish machinations of all these heresies together with their charioteers ? " "Who, being in the form of God, 2 Cor. iv. 4 ; Col. i. 15 ; Heb. i. 3. iv rfj fiop^ equiva- lent to iv rfj ovcTLa koX rfj ^vaei. Strictly speaking, fiop(f)ij signifies what may be termed the externals of the Godhead — the blessedness, the majesty, the glory, the adoration of others (sc. angels), since the word in composition, such as IxeTafjiop^wa-is, signifies rather change of appreciable con- dition than change of essential nature. Polus says, " Mopcprj, forma, designat essentiam et naturam, et proprietates naturae ; idemque est quod ovaia et ^vcns nisi quod ouala nudam es- sentiam denotat, cui (^vais addit proprietates essentiales et naturales, quales in Deo justitia, potentia, &c. ; eisque fiopcfir) addit accidentia naturam rei consequentia, et quibus quasi 68 COMMENTARY ON [CIIAP, IT. lineamentis ovaia et (jivcns confirraantur et depinguntur, iit, in hominc, esse facie in coolum conversa, &c. ; in Deo autem (in quo nulla sunt accidentia) immensa ejus gloria, ma- jestas, &c. Mop(f>r] ergo denotat essentiam Dei non nudam sed suis vestitani qualitatibus, et proj^rietatibus esseutialibus, glorid, majestate," &c. Strigelius ' says, ** Mop(f)r) significat essentiam et proprietates naturce." This is a subject of very- great difficulty. For further information see St. Atlianasius against the Arians, Disc. 3, c. 23 ; also Bull, " Primitive Tradition of the Catholic Church," p. 302 and following, Oxford Edition. Mop(pT] ©eov, as opposed to /Ltop^T) SovXov, might with great propriety be rendered the condition of God and the condition of a slave™. It is to be observed that Christ's Divinity is here most strongly asserted, and that antecedent to His humiliation, as the terminus a quo, the term of elevation from which His humiliation takes its rise, from which it derives great in- crease. Heretics have endeavom'ed to find in these words a proof that the Son is not equal to the Father. It would be wearisome and unprofitable to follow them through their reasonings ; sufiice it, therefore, to say that fjLop(f>r}, which the English Version renders ' form,' undoubtedly means 'forma qua) dat esse rei.' Hence, 'the form of God' is the Nature of God — His Divinity, i. e. God Himself, as by the form of man is signified the nature of man". All the Fathers who wrote against the Arians are unanimous on this point, arguing rightly that Christ was really and truly God before He took the form of a servant. Cornelius a Lapide, in answer to the question, " Dices cur clare non dixit Apostolus, * Qui cum esset Deus ? ' " replies. ' viro/xvriiiiaTa in libros N. T. ■" Bp. I'earsoii snys, " IJy the word 'form' is ciTtiiinly muU'rstood ifie true cundiliiin of a servant, ;ind by tlie likc- iiess is infallilily meant tin- real nature of man ; nor dotli t\\c fashion, in which He was found destroy, but rather as- sert the trutli of His liumanity. And, therefore, as sure as Christ was really and essentially man, of the same na- ture with us, in whose similitude He was made, so certainly was He also really and e sentially (Jod, of the same nature and boinj; with Him in Whose Form He ilid subsist." " Haymo says, " In forma Dei, id est in luciualitate Paternaj Divin- iuitis consubstantialis et cou3qualia omnibus Hli." VER. 6.] ST. Paul's epistle to the philippians. 69 " Id dixit, et amplius dixit ; per formam enim significat glo- riam et majestateni Dei, eanique opponit formse, id est, in- firmitati et vilitati humanse." St. Chrysostom, writing against those heretics who wished to limit the meaning of 'being in the form of God' to suit their own unworthy conceptions of the Nature of Christ, happily contrasts the expression 'form of God' with 'the form of a servant,' which follows. " Tell me/' he says, " the form of a servant, is it the energy of a servant, or the nature of a servant ? Thou wilt say, truly the nature of a servant. Thus, too, the ' form of God' is the Nature of God, and therefore not an energy." Gagneius says, " Qui cum in forma Dei esset, id est, in eadem cum Patre sub- stantia. Formam enim hoc loco, et Groecum verbum fxopcfirjv, interpretatur Chrysostomus formam substantialem." It is very important to notice the use of the word vTrdp- X^V) ' heing,' and not lyevSfMevos, in this sentence. Its occur- rence here may be compared with Exod. iii. 14 : " And God said unto Moses, I am That I am : and He said. Thus shalt thou say unto the children of Israel, I am hath sent me unto you." thought it not robbery to be equal with God : ' Robbery,' dpTrayfios, means the act of seizing or snatch- ing ; not so much snatching from another as snatching for oneself °. The meaning then is that our Lord thought it not robbery to assert that He was equal to God, as when He said P, " I and My Father are one ;" whereas, on the other hand, if the blessed Forerunner, instead of saying, * I am not the Christ ^,' had affirmed, ' I am the Christ,' He would have been guilty of the ' robbery' contemplated by the Apo- stle, an offence actually perpetrated by Simon Magus, when he blasphemously dared to assert, " I am the Son of God ; I am the Paraclete." The eternal pre-existence of the Only Begotten is most o " Rapina est," says Havmo, " quando quilibet homo alieuam rem per vio- lentiam sibi usiirpat, quae illi non competit." p John X. 30 ; see also John v. 18. ^ John i. 20. 70 COMMENTARY ON [chap. II. clearly set forth in these words ; for that of which a man has become the possessor through fraud and violence he dares not lay aside even for an instant, lest he should lose it altogether. The Son of God, however, feared not to descend from His right, for He thought not Deity a matter of acquisition. He was not afraid that anj^ would strip Him of that Nature, or that right, therefore He laid it aside, being confident that He should take it up again. 'To be equal with God;' to elvac laa &€uj. Tertullian translates the expression pariai'i. ' With God,' i. e. the Father, declaring the equality of Person ^. It is obvious that the word ' God ' is here used in a dif- ferent sense from ' being in the form of God ;' for there * God' signifies absolutely the Essence common to the Three Persons of the ever-adorable Trinity, whereas in this place it refers to the Fii^st Person, God the Father. Primasius paraphrases this verse as follows : — " Non ra- puit quod hubebat, id est, equalitatem Patris, quam natu- raliter habebat, non rapuit." Justin Martyr, in his Epistle to Diognetus, gives a striking testimony to the Eternal Godhead of our Lord : " The Al- mighty and all-creating and invisible God hath Himself from heaven established the Truth, and the holy and incom- prehensible Word amongst men ; and hath fixed It in their hearts, not, as one might suppose, by sending unto men a minister, either angel, or prince, or any one of those who order things on earth, or any one of those to whom hath been entrusted the administration of things in heaven ; but the very Framer and Ci^eator of the universe Himself, by Whom He founded the heavens, by Whom He shut in the sea within its proper bounds. Whose mysteries all the ele- ments do faithfully observe, from Whom the sun hath re- ceived to observe the due measures of the course of the day, Whom the moon obeys when He bids her shine by night. ' " The very memorable words of a celebrated ancient Synod of tlie tbird century ailbrd an excellent comment here : 'Ep tjj tKKKrjcrla, rfj iirh Thf ovpa- vhi' -Kacni Xpiarhs irfiriffrfVTai Qehs, Ke- fwaas tavTuf airb rod (Jvat laa @«f." — Concil. Antioch. (Wordsworth, Greek Test.) VER. 6, 7.] ST. Paul's epistle to the philippians. 71 Whom the stars obey as they follow the course of the moon, by Whom all things have been arranged, and determined, and placed in due subjection, the heavens and all that is in the heavens, the earth and all that is in the earth, the sea and all that is in the sea, fire, air, and the abyss ; all that is in the heights above, all that is in the depths beneath, and all that is in the region that lies between. This One sent He luito them. Was it then, as any one of men might sup- pose, for despotic sway, and fear, and terror ? In no wise, but rather in clemency and meekness ; even as a King sending His Son, a King He sent Him ; as God He sent Him; as unto men He sent Him; as willing to save He sent Him.^' 7. But made Himself of no reputation, 'EavTov eKevoxre : ' Semet ipsum exinanivit:' literally, * emptied Himself.' " Humiliavit, et quasi contraxit et mi- noravit ^ ; " i. e. from a Master became servant ; from God, man ; from Creator, creature. " Non tantum aliunde nihil fapuit, verum etiam quod habuit abdicavit*." He Who had all riches voluntarily led the life of a poor man ". Un- fortunately the English Version, ' made Himself of no repu- tation,' loses much of this meaning. Haymo describes this act of our Blessed Lord, whereby He emptied Himself, as "quando res magna et incompre- hensibilis in parva formula comprehenditur," and proceeds to say, that if an artist were to represent on a small scale, in a picture, birds and beasts and fishes, and the difierent objects of nature, it would give some idea of the humi- liation of the Son of God, Who being everywhere by His Godhead, though not discerned by sense, deigned to become visible in the small form of man, and so emptied, and as it were contracted Himself. No doubt allusion is intended in this verse to Dan. ix. 26. Bp. Pearson, justly complains of our translation of this passage^. We have two copulative conjunctions, neither of ■'* Haymo. ' Wetstein. " Matt. viii. 20 ; see also 2 Cor. viii. 9. " Art. ii. 72 ' COMMENTARY ON [cHAP. II. which is in the original text, and three distinct propositions, without any dependence of one upon the other, whereas all the words together are but an expression of Christ's ex- inanition, with an explication shewing wherein it consists. As might be expected, this astounding act of humiliation, whereby the eternal Son, remaining full ^, carried Himself among men as empty, is a theme on which the Fathers de- light to dwell, as what loving, reverent soul will not ? St. Je- rome, in particidar, was so devoted to the contemplation of this strange humility of his Master, that he spent many years of his life near the spot where the manger stood. It will be well to quote a few passages from their writings ; no easy task, however, when we remember how allusions to this wondrous mystery run through nearly ever}" page. " Emptied Himself," says St. Augustine y, " not that that "Wisdom was changed, seeing that It is altogether unchange- able, but because in so humble a guise He ysdlled to be made known unto men." Again ^, he uses the humiliation of our Lord to exhort teacliers to mildness and gentleness with their pupils ; specially with those who are dull of under- standing, and when it becomes wearisome to dwell so long on first principles : " Let us meditate on what we have received from Him who has shewed us an example that we may follow His steps. For however much our articulate speech may differ from the vividness of our perception, much more does mortal flesh differ from equality with God." The same Father * makes Elisha restoring the dead child a tj-pe of our Lord's humiliation. Bj'- the ' staff' sent by the hand of the servant he understands the Law. " If," he says, " there had been a Law given which could give life, the boy might have been raised to life by the staff; but seeing that the Scripture hath concluded all under sin, he still lies dead. But why hath it concluded all under sin ? That the promise by the faith of Jesus Christ might be given to them that believe. Let, then, Elisha come, who sent the staff by the servant to prove that he was dead ; let him come himself, » .Tobn i. 11. v i)e Fill, et Symb., 18. ' De Catcchizaiulis Uuilibus, 15. " Serin. Ixxxvi. 6, in Nov. Test. VER. 7. J ST. TAUl's epistle TO THE PHILIPPIANS. 73 come in his own person, himself enter into the woman's house, go up to the child, find him dead, conform himself to the members of the dead child, himself not dead but living. For this he did ; he laid his face upon his face, his eyes upon his eyes, his hands upon his hands, his feet upon his feet ; he straitened, he contracted himself ; being great, he made himself little. He contracted himself; so to say, he lessened himself." St. Gregory'' also uses Elisha as a type of Christ. He says : " He, (Elisha,) when he sent his servant with a staff never a whit restored life to the dead child ; but upon coming in his own person, and spreading himself upon the dead body, and contracting himself to its limbs, and walking to and fro, and breathing seven times into the mouth of the dead body, he forthwith quickened it to the light of new life through the ministering of compassion. For God, the Creator of mankind, as it were grieved for His dead son, when He beheld us with compassion killed by the sting of iniquity. And whereas He put forth the terror of the Law by Moses, He as it were sent the rod by the servant. But the servant could not raise the dead body with the staff, because, as Paul bears witness, ' the Law made nothing per- fect.' But when He came in His own Person, and spread Himself in humility upon the dead body, He contracted Himself to match the limbs of the dead body to Himself. He ' walks to and fro ' also, in that He calls Judrea nigh at hand, and the Gentiles afar off. He breathes upon the dead body seven times, in that by the publishing of the Divine Gift He bestows the Spirit of seven-fold grace upon those that lie prostrate in the death of sin. And afterwards it is raised up alive, in that the child, whom the rod of ter- ror could not raise up, has been brought back to life by the Spirit of Love." The same illustration occurs in St. Augustine, in Ps. Ixxi. 19. St. Augustine ^ says : " If He had avoided poverty, we should not have been rid of poverty.'^ ^ Moral, ix. G3. <= Serni. cxix. in Nov. Test. 74 COMMENTARY ON [cHAP. II. Again '^ : "'Emplicd Himself;' not by losing what He was, but by taking to Him -what He was not." Again •=: "In tbut sort emptjdng Himself tbat He ap- peared less here than He remained with the Father ; for in truth the form of a servant was taken, not the form of God forsaken ; this was assumed, not that consumed. In regard of this lie saith, 'The Father is greater than I;' but in regard of that, ' I and the Father are one.' " St. Gregory f, after speaking of the evils of pride, saj's, " To this end the Only-begotten Son of God took on Him the form of our infirmity ; for this the Invisible apjseared not only visible, but even despised ; for this He endured the jests of contumeh^, the reproaches of derisions, and the tor- ments of sufferings, that God in His humility might teach man not to be proud. How great, then, is the virtue of humility, since for the sole purpose of truly teaching it He Who above estimation is great became little, even to suf- fering ? For since the pride of the devil caused the origin of our fall, the humility of God M'as found out as the instru- ment of our redemption. For our enemy who was created great among all things, wished to appear exalted above all things. But our Redeemer, remaining great above all things, deigned to become little among all things." St. Augustine s : "So great, trul}^, is the benefit of man's lowliness, that even God's loftiness was pleased to enforce it by His own pattern ; because proud man should be for ever lost, had not a lowly God found him. For the Son of Man came to seek and save that which was lost. Lost by following the pride of the deceiver, let him follow the lowliness of the lledeemer, being found." St. Bernard'' has the following, the delicate beauty of which would be lost in a translation : — " In Christo agno- scitur longitude brcvis, latitude angusta, altitude subdita, profunditas plana, lux non lucens, Yerbum iufans, aqua sitiens, panis esuriens. Videas, si attendas, potentiam rcgi, sapientiam instrui, virtutcm sustentari, Deum denique lac- •^ Iluin. xvii. IG, in .Toh. ' Honi. Ixxviii. 1, in Jnli. Moral, xxxiv. 51. ^ lloni. Iv. 7, in .Toh. '' Scrni. ii. Super IMissus est. VER. 7.] ST. Paul's epistle to the philippians. 75 tantem, sed angelos reficientem ; vagientem, sed miseros consolantem. Videas, si attendas, tristari laetitiam, pavere fiduciam, salutem pati, vitam mori, fortitudinem infirmari ; sed est hsec tristitia Itetificans, pavor confortans, mors vivi- ficans." and took upon Him the form of a servant, i. e. He took man's nature upon Him in truth ; for the words fJ'Opcfir] SovXov signify the true nature of ma», and not a shadowy resemblance. It is to be remembered that our Lord was predicted by the Prophets under the name of * servant,' (see Isa. xlii. 1 ; Ezek. xxxiv. 23 ; Zech. iii. 8) ; and constantly in the Psalms, especially Ps. xxii., where, together with Isa. liii., our Lord is fully described under this character. The words ' took upon Him ' indicate that this was a voluntary act on our Lord's part, and that He was under no constraint. And not only did He take upon Him the ' form of a servant,' but He also performed a servant's work, (see John xiii. 1 — 17,) washing not the hands, but the feet of the disciples, even of the traitor. If anything can enhance His surpassing lowliness, surely it is this, that He disdained not even to wash the feet of him whose hands He already saw in the act of wickedness. Bp. Andre wes ' well says, " The shame of being put out of the number of free-born men He despised, even the shame of being in forma servi." and was made in the likeness of men : iv o/jboicofiari avOpooircov yevo/xevos. " Id est, similis homi- nibus factus. Similitudinem accipe, non accidentalem, non apparentem et phantasticam ; sed substantialem, qua omnes homines dicuntur esse similes specie, seu natura humana''." It must be observed, however, that the ' likeness ' was of nature, not of sin. " Made," says Caietan, " non ex humano semine, sed divina efficientia." The word yevo/nevos translated ' made' in this place is especially to be observed ; it is literally ' Serm. iii. on the Passion. '' Corn, a Lap. 76 ' COMMEMARY ON [cHAP. II. 'born,' of course not S)v or vTrdpxfov. The continual dis- tinction between elvai, and '■^eveadat in St. John i. sliould be carefully noticed in connection with this passage. The plural, 'of men,' (dvOpcoTrcov,) is used to express the nature of man, as in Heb. ii. 16 d'yyeXcov iirCkajji^dveTai is used to express angelical nature. Hooker^ says, " That which deceived him (Nestorius) was want of heed to the first be- ginning of tliat admirable combination of God with man. The Wor^ dwelt in us. The Evangelist useth the plural number, men for manhood, us for the nature whereof we consist ;" and then he goes on to refer to Heb. ii. 16. St. Chrysostom enquires, " What means this which he says, ' Being made in the likeness of men?' He had many things belonging to us, and many He had not ; for instance. He was not born of wedlock. He did no sin. These things had He which no man has. He was not what He seemed only, but He was God also ; He seemed to be a man, but He was not like the mass of men, though He were like them in flesh. He means, then, that He was not a mere man. Wherefore he says, ' in the likeness of men.' For we in- deed are soul and body, but He was God, and soul and body ; wherefore he says, ' in the likeness.' For lest M'hen you hear tliat He emptied Himself, you should think that some change, and degeneracy, and loss is here ; he says, whilst He remained what He was. He took that which He was not, and being made flesh He remained God, in that He was the Word." This interpretation is materially strength- ened by Rom. viii. 3, where it is said, " God sending His Own Son in the likeness of sinful flesh,'" since there was in Him no 'sinful flesh,' but only the 'likeness of sinful flesh.' For some excellent remarks on the relative meanings of eiKwv, ojjLoiwcns, and ofiotcofMa, see Trench, " Synonj'ms of the New Testament," p. 56 and following. 8. And being found in fashion as a man, It is to be observed that fjiopcftr) and ofjLoico/jLa, ver. 7, and ' Kcd. I'ul. V. 52. VER. 7, 8.] ST. Paul's epistle to the philippians. 77 ax^l^a in this verse, are not synonyms, though they are words of kincLred meaning. The force of ayy^yua may be gathered from Aristotle"', a material quality. Aristotle makes it nearly synonymous with yi,op<\>^]. Of course the Apostle does not do so, but uses o-;^^/xa only in the Aristotelian sense. The Deity can have no axnt^^^' Bengel translates these words respectively by forma, similitudoy and habitus, and explains them as follows: "'Forma' dicit quiddam absolu- tum ; 'similitude' dicit relationem ad alia ejusdem condi- tionis ; 'habitus' refertur ad aspectum et sensum.' ' Being found,' evpeOels. Eupla/ceaOaL is often = Hengel. ' Estius. " In Ps. ex 7. '' John i. 14. VER. 9.] ST. Paul's epistle to the philippians. 81 which is above every name : See above, to 6vo[xa, — the Name, the article being em- phatic, — the Name of God Himself; and this very Name, which He bore in His humiliation, is now the highest and most glorious of all names. His own words from glory are, "I am Jesus Whom thou persecutest^" The expression ' name ' includes, of course, all the dignity and worship be- longing to it. See Commentary on Ephesians, p. 331. St. Athanasius '^ says, " For as He was ever worshipped as being the Word, and existing in the Form of God, so being what He ever was, though become Man and called Jesus, He still has, as before, the whole creation under foot, and bending their knees to Him in this Name, and con- fessing that the Word's becoming flesh, and undergoing death in flesh, hath not happened against the glory of His Godhead, but " to the Glory of God the Father." For it is the Father's glory that man, made and then lost, should be found again ; and, when the prey of death, that he should be made alive, and should become God's temple. For whereas the powers in heaven, both angels and archangels, were ever worshipping the Lord, as they are now worshipping Him in the Name of Jesus, this is our grace and high exalta- tion, that even when He became Man, the Son of God is worshipped, and the heavenly powers are not startled at seeing all of us, who are of one body with Him, introduced into their realms. And this had not been, unless He who existed in the form of God had taken on Him a servant's form, and had humbled Himself, permitting His Body to reach unto death." St. Bernard ^ speaks thus : " Jesus is honey in the mouth, in the ear a honied strain, exultation in the heart ; yea, and a balm no less. Doth any sorrow ? Let Jesus come into his heart, and from its fulness the mouth will speak. Lo ! let the light of that Name but gleam, the clouds are scattered, and the sky is bright. Does any sin and meditate destruction in despair ? Let him invoke the Name of Life ; he breathes again and lives. When hath ever hardness of heart, which ' Acts ix. 5. '' Against Arians, Disc. i. c. xi. * Serm. xv. 6, in Cant. M 82 ' COMMENTARY ON [CHAP. II. SO often broods upon the Christian, or slothful indolence, or irksome weariness, resisted the presence of this health- ful Xame? What dried-up fount of tears has not gushed forth afresh, and still more plentifully, by invoking Jesus ? What like this checks the rage of anger, soothes the swelling of pride, heals the wound of envy, piits out the flame of lust, slakes the thirst of avarice, and allays all itching lust of shame ? When I name Jesus, I set before me One Who is meek and lowly of heart, kind, temperate, chaste, pitiful, the Pattern of all that is virtuous and holy ; yea, Who is also God Almighty; Who heals me by .His example, and strengthens me by His help. All this I hear when I hear 'Jesus.' I take examples from Him as Man, help from the Mighty One ; those as healthful aromatics ; this as that which draws out their hidden strength ; and so I make up a confection, such as no physician's art can equal. This, my soul, is thy electuary, laid up in the vessel of the Name of Jesus ; and truly it is wholesome, and there is no sickness of thine which it cannot cure." In such language as this have holy men spoken of the most sacred Name, but words would be altogether wanting to describe the wondrous beauty of the Church's Litany of the Holy Name of Jesus. There He is invoked by every term of grace and mercy by which He has ever been pleased to make Himself known to His people. So also in the fol- lowing h}Tnn, (dear to every Catholic heart,) with what exquisite simplicity is the sweetness of the Holy Name set forth : — " Jesu, Who dost true joys impart. Sweet is Thy memory : More sweet than honey to the heart. To know and feel Thee nigh. There's nothing sweet in sweetest sound. In hearing nothing heard, In sweetest thouglit nought sweet is found As Jesus, God and Lord. Of penitents sole hope and stay ; To wandering sinners kind ; To those tliat seek Thou art the way. But what to those tliat find ? VER. 9, 10.] ST. Paul's ei'istle to the philippians. 83 Sweetness of heart, and living Fount, Of souls the light and fire. All joys we know dost Thou surmount, And all that we desire. No tongue of man hath power to tell. No written words can prove. But he who loveth knoweth well What Jesus 'tis to love. Thee would I seek upon my hed. In chamber of my breast. In private and in public led, By anxious love possessed. I seek the tomb, wherein Thou art. With Mary in the morn. Not with the eye, but with the heart. And sorrow's plaint forlorn. There with my tears bedew Thy tomb. And fill with sighs the place ; There fall before Thee in the gloom, And Thy loved feet embrace. There with love's tender offices, I to Thy feet would flee. Nor shall my sighs and sorrows cease. Till I am filled with Thee. Jesu, great King adorable. Of all Thy saints admired, Tlie sweetness which no words can tell. All and alone desired." 10. That at the Name of Jesus every knee should bow, * That' denotes the intent of our Blessed Lord's exaltation ; q. d. so that all recognising in that Man, Who is called Jesus, the Son of God, and the true and eternal God, may submit themselves to Him, and adore Him as Lord of all, ' bowing the knee' being expressive of the deepest veneration. It appears from this text, therefore, that the Humanity of Christ is to be adored with the same degree of worship as His Di^dnity. See Commentary on Ephesians, p. 95. It must not be forgotten that the Greek is iv to3 6v6fj,aTi, 84 COMMENTARY ON [cHAP. II. ' in the name/ and the bowing the knee in the Name of Jesus signifies that all prayer, to be acceptable, must be oflFered in His Name and through Him. See John xvi. 23 ; Acts iv. 12. Of course the Human Name is given, because He intercedes for us not only as God, but as Man. It has always been the custom of the faithful to shew a sign of worship to the sacred Name, whenever they pro- nounced it themselves, or heard it pronounced by others. This practice of adoration is so old that it is hard to fix upon the time when it commenced, and w^e shall be safe in re- ferring it to the age of the Apostles. The Council of Lyons in the thirteenth century formally sanctioned it ; and in the following age two councils granted special privileges to those who observed the sign of adoration. The English Church also ^ has enjoined upon her children the solemn observance of this sign, as follows : " Likewise, when in time of Divine Service the Lord Jesus shall be mentioned, due and lowly reverence shall be done by all persons present, as it hath been accustomed." For remarks on St. P&ul's and St. Augustine's deep re- verence and love for our Lord's Name^ see Commentary on the Ephesians, p. 143. The following extract from Bp. Andre wes ^ is well wor- thy of attention : " God, though He have so exalted It, ('. e. the Name of Jesus,) yet reckons it not exalted, unless ive do our parts also, unless our exaltation come too. At which words comes in our duty, the part that concerns us. Thus, to esteem it super omne nomen, above all; and in sign we do so, to declare as much. And therein He leaves us not to ourselves, but prescribes the very manner of our declaration, how He will have it, namely these two ways ; the knee to bow to it, the tongue to confess it. Now these are outward acts both. So tlicn, fii'st we are to set down this for a ground, that the exalting of the soul within is not enough. More is required by Ilim, more to be performed by us. He will not have the inward parts onl}-, and it skills not for the outward members, though we favour our knees, ' Canon xviii. b Serm. ix. on the Resurrection. VER. 10.] ST. Paul's epistle to the philippl^ns. 85 and lock up our lips. No, mental devotion will not serve, He will have botli corporal and vocal to express it by. Our body is to ajfford her part to His glory ; and the parts of our body, and namely, these two, the knee and the tongue. Not only the upper parts, the tongue in our head, but even the nether also, the knee in our leg. The words be plain, I see not how we can avoid them." of things in heaven, i. e. angels and celestial powers. For remarks on the different orders of angels see Commentary on Ephesians, pp. 93, 94. and things in earth, i. e. men still living. and things under the earth ; i. e. either the souls of the departed, who are in Hades ; or devils, and lost spirits; for even in the nethermost hell that dread Name is acknowledged and adored''. It is well known that the Jews were accustomed to describe all creation under the terms heaven, and earth, and the parts under the earth, with all things contained in them ^ ; and the New Testament writers adopted the same idea^. Compare with this verse Rom. xiv. 9 ; Eph. i. 21; 1 Pet. iii. 22. St. Chrysostom ' makes use of this passage to shew that there is no room for saving repentance after death. " If unbelievers," he says, "are after death to be saved on their believing, no man shall ever perish. For all will then re- pent and adore. And in proof that this is true, hear Paid saying, ' Every tongue shall confess, and every knee shall bow, of things in heaven, and things in earth, and things under the earth.' And, ^the last enemy that shall be de- stroyed is death.' But there is no advantage in that sub- mission, for it comes not of a rightly disposed choice, but of the necessity of things, as one may say, thenceforth taking place." '' James ii 19 ' Exod. XX. 4; Deut. iv. 17, 18; Ps. xcvi. 11 ; Ezek. xxxviii. 20. '' Actsiv. 24; Rev. v. 13. 1 Horn, xxxvi. 3, in Matt. 86 COMMENTARY OX [cHAP. II. 11. This universal confession (relating most probably to the day of judgment) is partly spontaneous, and partly wrung from unwilling lips ; for as they who pierced our Lord will be obliged to look on Him, so also vnU the devils to confess Him, and the damned to acknowledge the justice of their doom. And that every tongue should confess The use of the word i^ofioXoyjja-eTai in this place should be compared with Rom. xiv. 11, yeypaTrrac yap' Zm iyo), \eyei Kvptos' on ifiol Kafx-^ei irdv yovv, koX irdaa yXaxraa €^ofio\oyrj(reTai tm Oeoy' whence it appears that the same honour is to be paid to Christ as to God, because He is God. The expression 'every' seems decisively to point to the day of judgment, since many now deny Him. These words are evidently quoted from Isa. xlv. 23. that Jesus Christ is Lord, No longer as He appeared on earth in " the form of a ser- vant"^," but surrounded with every attribute of majesty, the Lord of the quick and dead, the Origin and Source of all life, the Object of adoration to men and angels. to the glory of God the Father. els So^av, literally * unto the glory ; ' i. e. His dignity and the recognition of it redounding to the Father's glory, the advancement of which is the great object of our Lord's work, (see 1 Cor. xv. 24 — 28,) and should be the aU-absorbing thought of His followers. See Commentary on Ephesians, p. 76. Observe, then, that this confession of the Lordship of Christy so far from diminishing the lustre of the Father's attributes, is glory to Him. " Seest thou," says St. Chry- sostom, " how wherever the Son is glorified, the Father is also glorified ? Thus, too, when the Son is dishonoured, the Father is dishonoured also. If this be so with us, where the difference is great between fathers and sons, much more in respect of God, where there is no difference, doth honour '" Verse 7. VER. 11, 12.] ST. Paul's epistle to the philippians. 87 and dishonour pass on to Him. If tlie world be subjected to tbe Son, this is glory to the Father." Bp. Bull'i says, "The Father gave Christ His judicial power, because, for the salvation of mankind, He vouchsafed to become the Son of man, that is, Man ; and, although He was God, to take upon Himself human life, and expose it to death for man's salvation. Wherefore by that so great hu- miliation of Himself, by which He was willing to become man, and die for men. He merited this great exaltation to judicial power, in order that He, who was the Saviour of all, might be the Judge of all." He then goes on to paraphrase the Apostle's language from verse 6 to 11, and gives an excellent summary of the whole. " The Apostle exhorts the faithful to humble mindedness, by an ai'gument drawn from the example of Christ, Who being in the form of God, (that is, being God,) and so equal to God the Father in respect of His Nature, yet did not arrogate to Himself that equality with God, did not carry Himself as God, did not make a show of it openly, being alien from ostentation and pomp ; but of His own accord lowered and humbled Him- self, taking on Him the form of a servant, and being made man, &c. ; and therefore to Him has been given by His Father a Name which is above every name, &c. ; exactly as it is said in the passage of John° that the authority of judging is given to the Son, because He is the Son of Man." 12. The Apostle having referred to the example of obe- dience shewn by Christ, now returns to exhortation. Wherefore, my beloved, ware ; i. e. as a consequence of this pattern set before you by Christ. as ye have always obeyed, i. e. from the day of your conversion. See chap. i. 5, " For your fellowship in the Gospel from the first day until now." He praises them for the steady obedience which they had " Primitive Tradition of the Catholic Church, vi. 19. " Chap. v. 27. COMMENTARY ON [CHAP. II. uniformly shewn ; and a very high commendation this is. It is worthy of observation that he does not set other people before them as an example, but cites their own case as a pattern of this virtue. After * obeyed' must be under- stood either ' the Gospel p,' or ' Word^.' not as in my presence only, The word 'as' in this sentence is emphatic, q. d. ye did not obey as merely regarding my presence among you, when your obedience was shewn under my very eye, but &c. but now much more in my absence, And this indeed was their highest praise. "V^Hien St. Paul's bodily presence was removed from among them, and the ex- citement attending the first preaching of the Word had died away, and persecution began to arise, they still remained stedfast. They continued to be in the Apostle's absence what they had been in his presence. work out your own salvation 'Work out/ Karepjd^ecrde ; not merely 'work,' but 'work out,' implying a continuous and persevering w'ork, to be ac- complished only Avith much care and earnestness. For a similar use of the word see Rom. vii. 18. This word must bo carefully distinguished from ivepjetVi which is God's action, and by Him inspired into man, (see next verse). KaTepya^eadat is a word used of artificers ; see Ex. xxxv. 33, LXX. ; Demosth. Aphob. i. p. 816, iX.e(f)avra koI crlSrjpov wv Kareipyd^ovTO. The word ivepyeta is used by Aristotle to denote actual action as opposed to Svvafiis or e^ts, potentiality or power of acting, riiilosophically speaking, therefore, in the Deity there is no mere hvvafxts or e^is, because He is always in action {avve')(co9 ivepyel). But, besides this, the word ivep- ryelv has another signification ; it is ev ipyeiv, to work anything in another. Thus God ivepyel, works by His own power, or, as we might say, eneryy, and He also iv epyel, Avoi'ks b}^ the same power in man ; and tlms God, p 2 Thcss. i. 8. 12 Thcss. iii. It. VER. 12.] ST. Paul's epistle to the philippians. 89 inspiring man with His own power, enables him also evepjeiv, (in the first sense,) to energise, and act, and use those capa- cities before given him by God, (Who really has them in Himself and gives them to man) ; and man, when so ener- gising, Karepyd^erat, carves or chisels out, as a workman does, his own salvation ^. Aristotle would tell us that a man, having by nature Bvva- fjiLS, works {ivepyel) by the sole operation of his own will. The Pelagian, admitting that the Svvafiis comes originally from God, still maintains, with the heathen philosopher, that man ivepyel, works with this hvvafits, by the sole operation of his own will. While the Churchman believes with the Pelagian that God gives to man huvafiis, the power of working (one grace), but, besides this, he is aware that God must grant him a second grace, the working upon his will, which may incite him to use the first grace, and so Karepyetv a-coTrjpiav, to work out by imparted energy his means of grace ; for acorr]- pia does not mean final salvation, but, as it were, the rough material of salvation which we have to work out for our- selves. Hence the expressions in our collects, " Who workest in us both to will and to do of Thy good plea- sure," " special grace preventing us to put into our minds good desires," together with " enabling us to bring the same to good efiect," " stirring up our wills," " the spirit to do and to think such things as be rightful," &c. For more on the subject of ivepyeia see Commentary on the Ephesians, p. 88. ' Your own ; ' the work cannot be done by proxy. These words give us a view of the individual self-denial and zeal required in the Christian life. Compare Ps. xlix. 7, " But no man may deliver his brother : nor make agreement unto God for him." with fear and trembling. See Ps. ii. 11, " Serve the Lord in fear: and rejoice unto Him with reverence." See also 1 Pet. i. 17. "■ For a distinction between the way I the devil ' energizes/ see Comnaentary in which God eVe/jyei and that in which | on Ephesians, p. 113. 90 COMMENTARY ON [cHAP. IT. ' With fear/ ^lera (f)6/3ov ; i. e. the fear of failure. 'And trembling/ koX rp6/j,ov; i.e. an eager anxiety to please God. For a similar combination of words see 1 Cor. ii. 3 ; 2 Cor. vii. 15 ; Eph. \'i. 5 ; see Commentary on this last place. The two expressions when taken together obviously indicate a high state of anxiety and self- distrust, as opposed to carnal security. Hemmingius well describes the condition here indicated by the Apostle as " sollicitus tremor," and goes on to say of it, " with which doubt is not nourished, but by means of which the neglect of God, the false way of worshipping God, carnal secui'ity, idleness, and pride are excluded." St. PavJ earnestly exhorts the Philippians to maintain this state of mind, since it is impossible for one who lives de- void of fear to i*each a high point of Christian excellence. If anxiety and fear are necessary elements in worldly suc- cess, how much more so in spiritual, where the contest lies not with objects that may be discerned by sense, but with " principalities and powers, and the rulers of the darkness of this world ^" St. Chrysostom says, " I desire to know who ever learnt his letters without fear ? who ever became a proficient in any art without fear ? But if, when the devil does not lie in the way, where indolence is the only obstacle, so much of fear is necessary merely in order that we may master that indolence which is natural to us ; where there is so fierce a war, so great hindrances, how can we by any possibility be saved without fear?" How deeply the Apostle himself was sensible of this salu- tary fear will be seen from 1 Cor. ix. 27, where he says, " I keep under my body, and bring it into subjection : lest that by any means, when I have preached to others, I myself should be a castaway." The ' fear' which the Apostle here speaks of must be care- fully distinguished from the slavish fear vfYdch attaches itself to sin. The former fear " is the beginning of wisdom," it " is clean and ondureth for ever ; " the latter " hath torment," and, therefore, finds no place in those who are " made per- » Eph. vi. 12. VER. 12.] ST. Paul's epistle to the philippians. 91 feet in love." " Fear, so to say, prepares a place for charity. But when once charity has begun to inhabit, the fear which prepared the place for it is cast out. For in pro- portion as this increases, that decreases ; and the more this comes to be within, is the fear cast out. Greater charity, less fear ; less charity, greater fear. But if no fear, there is no way for charity to come in. As we see in sewing, the thread is introduced by means of the bristle ; the bristle first enters, but except it comes out the thread does not come into its place ; so fear first occupies the mind, but the fear does not remain there, because it enters only in order to introduce charity*." The same Father", shewing the danger of prosperity if not accompanied with fear, says again, '* There is then fear in gladness. How can there be gladness, if fear ? Is not fear wont to be painful ? There will hereafter be gladness with- out fear, now gladness with fear ; for not yet is there perfect security, nor perfect gladness. If there is no gladness, we faint : if full security, we rejoice wrongly. Therefore may He both sprinkle on us gladness, and strike fear into us, that by the sweetness of gladness He may lead us to the abode of security ; by giving us fear, may cause us not to rejoice wrongly, and to mthdraw from the way^." St. Chrysostom, in loc, very beautifully shews how this ' fear and trembling,' so necessary to the Christian, may be produced and stimulated. " If," he says, " we but consider that God is everywhere present, that He heareth all things, that He seeth all things, not only whatsoever is done or said, but also all that is in the heart, and in the depth of the soul, for He is *a Discerner of the thoughts and intents of the heart ; ' if we so dispose ourselves, we shall not do, or say, or imagine, aught that is evil. For, tell me, if thou hadst to stand constantly near the person of a ruler, wouldest not » St. Aug. in 1 Joh. iv. 18. " In Ps. Ixxxvi. 16. ' " The Schoolmen have distin- guished four kinds of fear : the fear of man, by which we are led rather to do wrong than to suffer evil ; servile fear, through which we are induced to avoid sin only from the dread of hell ; and this fear, taken by itself, was, till later and laxer times, always held to be sinful : thirdly, initial fear, in which we avoid sin partly from the fear of hell, but partly also from the love of God, which is the fear of ordi- nary Christians ; and filial fear, when we are afraid to disobey God only and altogether from the love we bear Him, which is the fear of saints." — Neale, Commentary on the Fsalms, pp. 100, 101. 92 COMMENTARY OX [CHAP. II. thou stand there with fear ? And how, standing in God's presence, dost thou laugh, and throw thyself back, and not conceive fear and dread ? Let it never be that thou despisest His long-suffering, for it is to bring thee to repentance that He is long-suffering ; and when thou doest aught, never allow thyself to do it without being sensible that God is present in all things, for He is present. So then, whether eating, or preparing to sleep, or giving way to passion, or robbing another, or whatever thou art about, consider that God is standing by, and thou wilt never be led into laughter, never inflamed with rage." Gerard Vossius concludes from this text (coupled with Matt. XXV. 21, 23, 34, 35 ; Rev. vii. 14, 15 ; 2 Cor. iv. 17; Gal. vi. 8) that they do not go far enough who think the promise of reward is made to good works merely as signs of faith ; since it is plain from these passages, to which many more might easily be added, that in the matter of sal- vation our works are viewed as the indispensable cause or condition precedent, which carries with it inseparably the promise of eternal life. 13. For it is God which worketh in you iarlv 6 ivepyMV is stronger than the simple ivepyet. For the use of this word see observations on verse 12. The in- working of God, which, as St. Augustine " says, is efficacious, when rightly considered, is the foundation of true humility. The work of grace in the soul is God's work, but yet, though energetic and effective, not wrought in such an irresistible manner as that it is impossible for those in whom He is pleased to work to retard, and finally to destroy. His work. If this were so, the Apostle's exhortation in the preceding verse, 'work out your own salvation with fear and trem- bling,' could have no bearing upon Christians. But God works in us, not against us ; not by physical determination of the will, not by destroying the nature of His creature, but morally, by illumination, persuasion, and inspiration. As St. Augustine^ says, " Through thee and in thee He work- eth good." The fact, therefore, that it is ' God which * De Gratia, xvi. y In Ps. ciii. 29. VER. 12, 13.] ST. Paul's epistle to the philippians. 93 worketh/ &g., supplies us with the reason why our share of the work should be accompanied by ' fear and trembling,' since the good which we may possess is not of ourselves, but of God, Who resists the proud (the self-confident and care- less), but gives grace to the lowly. St. Augustine^ says, "If therefore God worketh in thee, by the grace of God thou workest well, not by thy strength. Therefore if thou rejoicest, fear also, lest perchance that which was given to a humble man be taken away from a proud one." And again ^ : " Thou say est, O Paul, work : thou commandest us to work : wherefore with trembling ? For it is God, he saith, which worketh in you. For this reason then with trembling, because God worketh in you. Because He gave, because what thou hast cometh not from thee, thou shalt work with fear and trembling, for if thou fearest not Him He will take away what He gave." * In you ; ' observe the force of these words. Not among you, but in you. See 2 Cor. iv. 12 ; Eph. ii. 2 ; Col. i. 29. both to will and to do St. Augustine'' says, " The will is prepared by the Lord." And again <= : " We may understand that even what we do well should be ascribed to God's grace." " Deus operatur," says Estius, " velle et perficere, per sanctas inspirationes, illuminationes, afiectiones, ostendendo bonum, ad illud alli- ciendo et trahendo, absque tamen ulla impressione quae vo- luntatem praedeterminet." St. Bernard*^ shews how God works in us these three things : " Primum, scilicet cogitare, sine nobis ; secundum, scilicet velle, nobiscum ; tertium, scilicet perficere, per nos facit." Speaking on this subject, Bp. Andrewes ^ says, " Now of ourselves, as of ourselves, we are not fit so much as to think a good thought. Not so much as to will, ' for it is God that worketh in us to will.' If not these two, (1) neither think, nor (2) will, then, not to work. No more we are ; neither to begin ; nor having begun, to go forward, and bring it to an end. Fit to none of these. Then made fit we must be ; and * In Ps. Ixvi. 5. I ' In Ps. cxix. Serm. xxv. ■ In Ps. civ. Serm. iv. 16. I ^ De Grat. et Lib. Arbitrio. '• In Ps. cxix. Serm. xi. I ^ Serm. xviii. On the Resurrection. 94 COMMENTARY ON [cHAP. II. •who to reduce us to this fitness but this God of peace that brought again Christ from the dead?" of nis good pleasure. virep rrjs ev8oKLaiTbant qiuu sunt sua, scd (^luu .losu Cliri.sti. ' Umnes,' ergo, id est, plcriquu oinues, passim omnes, plurimi." — Cornelius a Lap. Ikngel exclaims, " O quam multi sua causa pii sunt, quanquam non sunt ' hostes,' " chap. iii. 18. VER. 20, 21.] ST. Paul's epistle to the philippiaists. 107 St. Aug'ustine s says of self-seekers, " They preach, mercy and truth, and do not mercy and truth. But by preaching it they know it, for they would not preach it unless they knew it. But he that loveth God and Christ, in preaching the mercy and truth of the same doth himself seek her for Him, not for himself; that is, not in order that himself may have by this preaching temporal advantages, but in order that he may do good to His members, that is, His faithful ones, by ministering with truth of that which he knoweth, in order that he that liveth no longer for himself, may live but for Him that for all men hath died." The same Father '\ commenting on the words, "0 God, my life I have told out to Thee," continues, " If therefore thou livest, and livest not by thyself, because that thou shouldest live He hath granted ; tell out thy life, not for thyself, but for Him ; not thine own things seeking, not for thyself living, but for Him that for all men hath died. For of cer- tain reprobate men what saith the Apostle ? * For all men seek their own things, not the things which are of Christ Jesus.' If for this reason thou tellest out thy life, in order that it may profit thee, and other men it may not profit, for thyself thou tellest it out, not for God ; but if so thou tellest out thy life, in order that other men also thou mayest invite to receive life, which thou, too, hast received, thou tellest out thy life to Him from Whom thou hast received, and thou shalt have a reward more ample, because even out of that which thou hast received not migrateful thou hast shewn thyself." And again ' : " Many men seek to learn His (God's) mercy and truth in His books. And when they have learned, for themselves they live, not for Him; their own things they seek, not the things which are of Jesus Christ ; they preach mercy and truth, and do not mercy and truth." not the things which are Jesus Christ's. i. e. which tend to His honour and glory in the salvation of souls. e In Ps. Ixi. 9. " In Ps. Ivi. 14. ' Ps. Ixi. 9. 108 COMMENTARY ON [cHAP. IT. 22. But ye know the proof of him, We meet with the word Boki./j,i] Kom. v. 4 ; 2 Cor. ii. 9, viii. 2, ix. 13, and xiii. 3. ' That I am not speaking at random/ he says, ' ye yourselves know how many proofs of his faith ho has already given.' Compare 1 Cor. xvi. 10. St. Timothy had laboured among them at the first. See Acts xvi. 1 — 3, xvii. 14, xviii. 5, xix. 22. This is one of the many passages that shew the depth of St. Paul's aifection for him. that, as a son with the father, The Apostle would have written ' as a son a father, so he served me,' but changes it to * so he served with me ; ' and this he does from modesty and reverence, seeing that we are not servants one of another, but all of God, in the Gospel'. Compare Nehem. vii. 2. " Concinne loquitur, partim ut de filio, partim ut do col- lega ; sic iii. 17 se ut typum sistit, et tamen av/ii/jiifirjrds, ' ima imitatores,' non mere ' imitatores' esse jubet ™." he hath served with me The force of the word 'served' (iSovXevcre) must not be overlooked. It means ' served as a slave,' — a Roman mode of expression, the father having by Roman law the same power over a son as over a slave. in the Gospel. els TO evayyekiov, 'unto the Gospel ;' i. e. in teaching and promoting the spread of the Gospel. Younger ministers should learn from the example of St. Timothy to shew that reverence to their elder brethren, particularly the bishops, which becomes theh years and experience, while the spi- ritual rulers of the Church should remember that those who are entrusted to their charge stand to them in the relation of sons. It is forgetfulness of this hallowed bond of con- nection that is the fruitful source of so much oppression on the part of those who govern, and of disobedience in the ' Alford. " Bciigel. VER. 22 — 24.] ST. PAULAS EPISTLE TO THE PHILIPPIANS. 109 governed. No form of Church government can ever be successful where the notion oi paternity is lost sight of. St. Chrysostom ° says that "Paul's humility is shewn here, by thus associating Timothy with himself ; " and Caietan well remarks that the Apostle commends him thus highly in order that the Philippians may the better understand the greatness of the favour he has done in sending him. 23. Him therefore I hope to send presently, so soon as I shall see how it will go with me. ' i. e. how my imprisonment shall end, — coy av aTriSa), " I shall have seen, as from a point from which I am able to contemplate the things around and concerning me ; not only the issue of my trial, but also my ovni consequent move- ments." Compare Jonah iv. 5, where it is said that the pro- phet went out of the city, and took his seat in front of it, €a>s ov diTiSr] to ecrraL rf] TroXec. ' How it "will go with me,' ra Trepl e/jui — " quae circa me sunt." It is plain from these words that the Apostle was by no means certain what the result of his imprisonment would be ; and it is probable that the departure of St. Ti- mothy was delayed for the present, in consequence of his assistance being indispensable to him. St. Bernard draws a beautiful spiritual lesson from these words : " Whatsoever," he says, " relates to the body, whether good or evil, is external, and cannot touch him who is within. Wherefore the Apostle lying in filth of body and in chains, and, as far as his body was concerned, crowned with tribulation, says, I will send Timothy unto you, that ye may know the things which are around me. ' The things which are around me,^ he says, that is, in the out- ward man, in the outward clothing of the flesh, but which do not touch me myself, who am within." 24. But I trust in the Lord that I also myself shall come shortly. Compare chap. i. 25. "See how he depends in all on God°." This verse is evidently added to confirm what he " Horn. i. in 2 Cor. • St. Chrysostom. 110 COMMENTARY ON [CHAP. II. had already said in ver. 15, lest they should think that he- cause he sent Timothy he did not intend to come himself. 25. Yet I supposed it necessary i. e. for 3'our comfort^ while the journey of Timothy was delayed. to send to yon Epapliroditus, He is not mentioned elsewhere, except in chap. iv. 18. The name was a common one. Some have supposed him to be identical with Epaphras, (see Col. i. 7, iv. 12; Philem. 23,) but the grounds for such a supposition appear to be insufficient. Here follow five titles of commendation which St. Paul applies to Epaphroditus. my brother, (1.) A fellow Christian, in the sense in which all the bap- tized make up one great family, and so are brethren ; or (2.) in the still higher sense in which all who have been called to the ministry of the Church are brethren. and companion in labour, i. e. in preaching the Gospel : avvepyos means * col- league.' and fellow-soldier, avarpaTKorrjv, (see Philem. 2) ; this expresses more than avvepyov, {' colleague/) it implies a fellowship in contests and dangers for the cause of Christ, a brotherhood in arms. There are many who will work zealously enough in time of peace, but are not prepared to fght when the time of peril comes. The faithful Christian must be prepared to do both. See 2 Tim. ii. 3. but your messenger, airocrToXov. It is commonly inferred from the use of the term ' Apostle,' which is here applied to Epaphroditus, that he was Bishop of the Church at Philippi, and, as such, set over those who in the opening of the Epistle are called 'Bishops and Deacons.' This is the opinion of Theodoret, and it has been largely adopted. Hilary says of Epaphro- VER. 25, 26.] ST. Paul's epistle to the philippians. Ill ditus, "he was their apostle, made so by the Apostle ;'' i. e. he was constituted their Apostle (Bishop) by St. Paid. But, as he was also the messenger of the Church at Phi- lippi, having carried their contributions to St. Paul, it is not impossible that the word airoa-roXos may have been purposely used in this place, to express the twofold character of Epaphroditus, messenger and bishop. It is to be observed that the word airoaToXos means origi- nally * one sent.' It was translated into Hebrew by the word malach, signifying ' messenger.' This, when re-translated into Greek, became ayyeXos. Hence we see why the oriental St. John calls the Bishops by the name of ajyeXot p. and he that ministered to my wants. Kal Xeiroupjou rrjs ')(^pelas fxov. The word Xeirovpyos is applied to Epaphroditus, as if he were discharging a jJublic office, the person so called being properly a citizen who un- dertook a XeiTovpjLa. See remarks on ver. 30. This is the last, bu.t not least honourable, commendation of the services of Epaphroditus. The Philippians had sent money by his hand, in the first place to supply the needs of St. Paul him- self, and then to enable him to help the poor at Pome. This is called ^joe/a Acts ii. 45, iv. 35, vi. 3, xx. 34, xxviii. 10 ; Eph. iv. 28 ; Phil. iv. 16. 26. For he longed after you all, eimroOoiv rjv, (ISelv must be supplied here : it is found Pom. i. 11 and 2 Tim. i. 4). The expression signifies such a vehement desire as is impatient of delaj^s. His heart was among his flock at Philippi. He did not merely desire to see those of his own household, but all the Philippians, shewing how wide his afiections were. and was full of heaviness, because that ye had heard that he had been sick. It was not on account of his own svjferings that Epaphro- ditus grieved, but for the distress and anxiety which he knew the report of his dangerous sickness would cause P Rtv. i. 20. 112 COMMENTARY ON [CHAP. II. among tlie Philippians. An admirable example of devoted zeal for tlie welfare of his flock wliicli it -will be good for ministers to have constant!}' before their eyes ! St. Chrysostonii quotes this among other passages of Holy Scripture to shew that the saints had infirmities, lest they should exalt themselves above measure, or lest they should be exalted, and, as it were, deified by others. " For if," he says, " when this was the case, (i. e. when they were liable to sickness, &c.) the people accounted them to be gods,' and prepared to do sacrifice to them, sajdng the gods are come doA^Ti to us in the likeness of men^', had such infirmities not existed, to what extent of impiety might not men have pro- ceeded when they beheld their miracles ?" 27. For indeed lie was sick nigh unto death : This sickness of Epaphroditns was caused by his assiduous attendance upon St. Paul, hence the marked way in which he makes mention of it. but God had mercy on him ; i. e. by restoring him to health, no doubt in answer to the Apostle's prayers, though with his usual modesty he suppresses all mention of this. We gather from this place that, since Epaphroditus was not recovered by the gift of healing, then frequent in the Church, that gift was not exercised by those to whom it was given simplj' at their own pleasure, but in obedience to a special and Divine instinct. St. Paul here shews how recovery from sickness is a mercy j especially against those who held that life was an evil in itself. In answer to those who might object, that "if to depart and be with Christ is far better," how does the Apo- stle say that he obtained mercy, St. Chrysostom rephes, " I would rather ask why the same Apostle says that to abide in the flesh is more needful for you ? For as this was needful for him, so too for this man, who Avould hereafter depart to God with more exceeding riches, and greater bold- ness. Hereafter that woidd take place, even if it did not 'I lloiu. X. 7, ou tbo Statues. ^ Acts xiv. 11. VER. 27, 28.] ST. Paul's epistle to the philippians. 113 now, but the winning souls is at an end for those who have once departed thither. In many places, too, Paul speaks according to the common habits of his hearers, and not everywhere in accordance with his own heavenly wisdom, for he had to speak to men of the world who still feared death." It is plain that St. Paul is speaking in this place of death considered by itself. and not on him only, but on me also, lest I should have sorrow upon sorrow. The second ' sorrow' refers of course to his imprisonment, and the sufferings consequent upon it. He would doubly grieve if, as Grotius says, "ad vincula accessisserit jactura amici." This verse plainly shews that God does not require , of men the dirddeLa of the Stoics, but the (TvixirdOeia of Christians. 28. I sent him therefore the more carefully, a-TrovSaLoripois, — festinantius, — diligentius. St. Ambrose renders it sollicitius, others studiosius. The meaning is^ that the Apostle took the earliest possible opportunity of de- spatching him. that when ye see him again, * Again,' i. e. after his sickness, and on his return amongst you. ye may rejoice, as it was most natural they should. and that I may be the less sorrowful. When I hear of his safe arrival, and so become partaker of your joy. This is an unusual form of expression, and it should be observed that he •does not say ' that I should be altogether without sorrow,' but 'less sorrowful,' evidently implying that as long as he was in the flesh his soul could never be wholly free from sorrow. See Pom. ix. 1, 2 ; 2 Cor. xi. 29. Q 114 COMMENTARY ON [cHAP. II. 29. Receive him therefore in the Lord * In the Loi'd,' propter Dominum ; i. e. as an ambassador of Christ. 1 Cor. iv. 1. with all gladness ; "NVitli deep and fervent Christian joy. The Apostle may be supposed to distinguish between the gratification of simply seeing a friend, and the holy joy which would be superadded in the case of those who are brethren in the faith. This ex- pression must not be regarded so much as a command, (for they were not likely to fail in joy at the arrival of Epaph- roditus,) as a token of approval at what they would do. and hold such in reputation : See 1 Cor. xvi. 18 ; 1 Thess. v. 12 ; 1 Tim. y. 17. Not merely Epaphroditus himself, but all ministers who are like him in zeal and love, are to be esteemed for their work's sake. " All," says Haj^mo, *' who have the same faith, and persevere in good works, as he." How sadly the command of the Apostle contrasts with the practice of the present day, when people have mostly learnt to say, "ministris eorum nihil vilius !" 30. Because for the work of Christ he was nigh unto death, ' The work of Christ ;' i. e. work done for the honour and glory of Christ, but specially here visiting St. Paul in prison. All works of mercy are well called ' works of Christ,' since they are done for His sake, and He reckons them as done to Himself ^ Observe, the Apostle does not say 'for my sake,' but 'for the work of Christ ;' which shews that it was from love of God that Epaphroditus acted. " It is probable," says St. Chrysostom, " that on his arrival at the city of Rome, he found Paul in such great and urgent peril, that those who were accustomed to resort to him were unable safely to do so, but were themselves in peril by their very attendance, and that Epaphroditus, being of a noble nature, despised all » Matt. XXV. 3G. VER. 29, 30.] ST. Paul's epistle to the philippians. 115 danger, that he might go in unto him and minister unto him, and do everything which need required." not regarding his life, Tlapa^ovKevaafxevos rfj -^^vxv- " ^^t^ habita ratione vitse*." Ilapa^ovXevo/jiat properly signifies ' I take counsel contrary to my interest ;' and is a word used of those who place themselves in jeopardy. There is a reading, irapa^dXeva-dfMevos, which has found much favour ; it means, " having staked his life." Either reading gives a good sense. to supply your lack of service toward me. "Iva avaTr\ripd)v vareprifia rrjs vrpo? P'G XeLTOup' ryias ; i. e. inasmuch as you were at a distance, and so were unable to minister to my temporal necessities, Epaphroditus, acting as your messenger, supplied your place. See Philem. 1 3. " That which you were unable to fulfil, on account of the distance that intervened between you, he fulfilled in your stead"." The service {Xecrovpjia) was the contribution of money which the Philippians sent by the hand of Epaphro- ditus. The 'lack' {ucrTeprjfia) in this afiectionate 'service' was their inability through absence to minister to the Apostle themselves ; but this Epaphroditus filled up, (see 1 Cor. xvi. 17,) and in so doing risked his life. There is a catachresis in the use of the word XetTovpyia, which properly signifies the administration of a public office, (see verse 25, where Epaphroditus is called XetTovpyos,) the magistracy, for instance, or priesthood ; but it is here used to signify the private ofiices of kindness shewn towards St. Paul. As the word XeLrovpjia contains the notion of discharging a public duty, it is probable that St. Paul em- ployed it in order to check any feelings of pride that might arise among the Philippians from having exercised towards him a liberality greater than that shewn by other Churches. Photius gives the following explanation of this verse : — " Misistis quae mihi opus erant, et absentis meministis, ac vestram beneficentiam ostendistis; supererat ad hscc omnia ' Rosenmiiller. » Haymo. 116 COMMENTARY OX [CIIAP. Til. ut a vobis ad me missa recupcrarem, et hoc solum deerat : et hoc ille (Epaphioditiis) implevit qxiando vestra ad me mu- nera allaturus ad mortem usque accessit." SUMMAHY OF CHAPTER III. The Apostle cautions the Philippians to beware of the snares of false apostles, and of carnal confidence, setting himself before them as a living example of piety, which he earnestly exhorts them to imitate. The chief parts of this chapter are three : — (1.) Dissuasive, He cautions them to beware of all corrupters of true doctrine, with a special reference to Judaizing teachers : ver. 1 to 3. (2.) Demonstrative. He sets himself forward as a pattern, and by reference to his own case shews that nothing pertaining to per- fection is to be sought for out of Christ : vers. 4 to 16. (3.) Hortatory. After he has spoken of himself as one who was to be followed, he exhorts them to true piety: vers. 17 to 21. In his treatment of these three heads we find many remarkable passages, e.g. concerning the true joy of believers, circumcision (concision), Christian perfection, the Advent of Christ, the ulti- mate glorification of the body, &c. CHAP. III. Neakly the whole of this chapter is taken up with warn- ings against false teachers. Yer. 1. Finally, my bretlu'en, rb XoLTTov, "quod superest." The Apostle seems to have intended to conclude his Epistle here, as he is wont to do, b}^ the word ro Xoiirov, or Xolttov, or Tov XotTTov, as 2 Cor. xiii. 11 ; Gal. vi. 17 ; Eph. vi. 10 ; 2 Thcss. iii. 1 ; and by the word ^i^a/pere, 2 Cor. xiii. 11 ; 1 Thess. V. 10; but afterwards, when he had had a little more time for reflection, to have added what follows. His meaning is, I have already described to you in what your VEK. 1-] ST. Paul's epistle to the philipptans. 117 salvation consists, viz. in Clirist alone ; and now what re- mains but that ye rejoice in Him as in your chief good ? &c. There woidd be peculiar force in this expression if we believe that this was actually the last Epistle ever written by St. Paul. rejoice in the Lord. *E,ejoice' is the sum and substance of the Epistle. See remarks on ver. 3, and on chap. i. 4. But it is of spiritual joy that he is speaking, as indicated by the addition of * in the Lord,' ' propter Dominum,' " "Whether therefore ye eat, or drink, or whatsoever ye do, do all to the glory of God'';" or, "according to the will of the Lord," see 1 Cor. vii. 39 ; or, " Avith joy which is worthy of the Lord." Some regard the words -x^alpere iv Kvpiw merely as a form of salutation, and translate, " Dominus vobis qusevis fausta evenire jubeat." The same expression occurs chap. iv. 4. We can easily understand why the Philippians should need this exhortation to joy. There were many circum- stances likely enough to depress them. Epaphroditus their Bishop was away, and it was doubtful whether they would ever see him again. St. Paul, to whom they were fervently attached, was in prison at Pome, living in daily prospect of a painful death, so that distresses and diificulties seemed to be rising on all sides ; and, therefore, in writing to them the Apostle endeavours to revive their drooping spirits. " You no longer have," he says, ''cause for despondency. You have Epaphroditus, for whose sake you were grieved. You have Timothy ; I am myself coming to you ; the Gospel is gaining ground. What is henceforth wanting to you ? Rejoice^ !" Compare St. Paul's exhortation to the Ej^hesians, chap, iii, 13, " Wherefore I desire that ye faint not at my tribulations for you, which is your glory," and see Com- mentary, in loc. St. Chrysostom remarks that St. Paul calls the Galatians ' children y,' but the Philippians * brethren,' and assigns as V 1 Cor. X. 31. * St. Chrysostom. y Gal. iv. 19. " My little children, of whom I travail in birth again until Christ be formed in you." 118 COMMENTARY ON [CHAP. HI. a reason that when he aims to correct anything, or to shew his fondness, he calls them ' children,' but when he ad- dresses them with greater honour, ' brethren' is the title. To write the same things to you, Some suppose that the expression, ' the same things,' refers either (1) to a lost Epistle ; this opinion is supposed to derive confirnuition from a well-known passage in St. Polycarp's Epistle to the Philippians ; or, (2) to the instruction which he communicated to them by word of mouth whilst he was among- them. Either of these explanations may be true ; but, since joy is the groundwork of the wliole Epistle, it seems better to refer ' the same things' to the w^ords ' rejoice in the Lord,' which he has just used, and so w^e get a sense in accordance with the general bearing of the Epistle. Hence it wall appear that St. Paul thought it good for the spiritual advancement of the Philippians to be constantly speaking about joy ; it was a topic that could not too often be repeated ; and so St. Augustine ^ is careful to admonish preachers to continue repeating the same topic, till by the gesture and coimtenance of their heai-ers they perceive that they understand it. That this was the plan which he him- self adopted in his discourses may be gathered from the fol- lowing^: " AVe have often impressed upon you, beloved, what we do not fear to reiterate frequently ; in order that, since many of you possibly cannot read, either because they have no leisure or know not letters, at least by constantly listening they may not forget their healthful faith. Cer- tainly by repeating them we may appear troublesome to some, w^hilc, however, we may be building up others. For we are well assured that there are many of retentive memory, and careful reading in Holy Writ, who know what we are about to say ; and perhaps they w^ish us to say what they do not know. But if they are quicker, let them see that they are travelling with others not so quick ; for when two persons of different speed arc travelling in company, it is in the power of the quicker, and not of him who is more ' De Doctr. Christ. " In Ps. xci. Scrm. 2. VER. 1, 2.] ST. Paul's epistle to the philippians. 119 slow, to give or deny his company ; because if the swifter is pleased to do his utmost, the slower will not keep up with him, and so he must needs rein in his own speed, in order not to leave his fellow-traveller behind." So also St. Chrysostom, who says *", " The nature of man is slothful, and needs much reminding. The earth, when it has once received the seed, straightway gives forth its fruits and needs not a second sowing ; but with our souls it is not so, and one must be content, after having sown many times, and manifested much carefulness, to be able once to receive fruit." The same Father also says '', " Physicians often use the same remedy." It is a well-known saying of Socrates, ov fiovov del ravrd, dWd Kol irepl tcov avroiv. to me indeed is not grievous, e/tot [xkv ovK oKvrjpov — "Me quidem neutiquam piget," or, "nunquam id per desidiam aut torporem omiserim." There seems, however, to be a notion of cowardice involved in the word oKvqpov, and then the meaning will be that for him to write what he is about to write next, viz., cautions against 'dogs,' &c., does not arise from coiuardice on his part, but from regard to their safety, it being for their spi- ritual good to be thus warned and admonished by him. but for you it is safe. i. e. useful and salutary ; so that the constant repetition may have the effect of confirming you in the faith. Seneca'' well remarks, " Etiam aperta monstrare pluri- mum prodest. Interdum enim scimus, nee attendimus. Licet nil doceat admonitio, excitat tamen et continet memoriam, nee patitur elabi." 2. Beware of dogs, BkeTrere rous Kvvas, literally, ' the dogs,' the article seem- ing to point to persons who were ivell-known. The Jews were accustomed to call the Gentiles by this name ; and so our Blessed Lord, speaking according to the common practice ^ Horn, xviii. 1, iu .Job. '^ Horn. li. in Joli. '' Ep. 95. 120 COMMENTARY OX [chap. Ill, of the country, used the word^: ''It is not meet to take the children's bread, and to cast it to dogs." (Compare Deut. xxiii. 18, and Matt. vii. 6.) But now the Apostle hurls back the name, and all the odium belonging to it, to the Jews. Henceforward God's relation with them is re- versed ; they are the ' dogs,' as they have shut themselves out of the covenant, and the Gentiles are the ' children.' Compare with this verse Rev. xxii. 15. St. Chrysostom asks, " Whom does he style * dogs ' ?" and then replies, " there were at this place some of those, whom he hints at in all his Epistles, base and contemptible Jews, greedy of vile lucre and fond of power, who, desiring to draw aside many of the faithful, preached both Christianity and Judaism at the same time, corrupting the Gospel. As then they were not easily discernible, therefore he says ' beware.' " Cornelius a Lap. says such false teachers are well likened to ' dogs,' " because they bark after us, and bite like dogs." And so Caietan, " He calls the false apostles * dogs,' be- cause after the fashion of dogs they barked against Paul." beware of evil workers, Tov De Spir. Sanct. 2. c. 6. | " Uoin. vii. 22; 2 Cor. iv. 16. VER. 3, 4.] ST. PAULAS EPISTLE TO THE PHILIPPIANS. 123 and have no confidence in the flesh. To have confidence in the flesh is to rely on external ordi- nances as things which wlQ commend us to God ; particularly- such grounds of confidence as are mentioned by the Apostle in verse 5. Haymo explains this of circumcision, which no doubt is referred to primarily, though not exclusively. St. Augustine p says, " He had his eye on some who had confi- dence in the flesh ; these were they who gloried of the cir- ciuncision of the flesh." St. Chrysostom shews with what propriety St. Paul could contrast spiritual with carnal circumcision, since "if being of the Gentiles, he had condemned the circumcision, and not only the circumcision, but all those that adopted it out of place, it would have seemed that he was denying it because he wanted the high ancestry of Judaism, as being a stranger to its solemn rites, and having no part therein ;" and there- fore he immediately proceeds to shew that he has ample ground for confidence, or boasting, in the flesh, whenever he is pleased to use it. 4. Though I might also have confidence in the flesh. The expression Kal iv aapKi, 'even in the flesh,' is em- phatic ; shewing that the Apostle Jiad grounds for boasting, according to the judgment of men, if he chose to use them. See 2 Cor. xi. 18, 21. His object is to point out to the Philip plans (against Judaizing teachers), that though he possessed those very advantages which a Jew would prize most highly, yet he willingly laid them all aside for Christ's sake. His example, therefore, would be the best possible answer to those who might endeavour to bring them into bondage to legal ob- servances. If any other man thinketh that he hath whereof he might trust in the flesh, I more : " Do not imagine," saith he, " that I despise what I have P Serm. cxix. 3, in Nov. Test. 124 COMMENTARY ON [CHAP. III. not. A\Tiat great thing is it if a mean, common, ignoble man despise nobility, and then make a show of real hu- mility 1 ?" The * I ' in this verse is highly emphatic, for though some Jews may have possessed single advantages superior to St. Paul, yet none could have surpassed him in the aggregate ; and the word ' thinketh ' is probably used to shew that there was no real ground for glorying. " It was well to say * thinketh,' either inasmuch as they really had no such confidence, or as that confidence was no real confidence, for all was by necessity, and not of choice ''." Here follow seven particulars in which the Apostle might have gloried " in the flesh." 6. Circumcised the eighth day, He mentions circumcision first of all, as it was the thing above all others on which Israelites prided themselves ; and ne adds 'the eighth day' ('7TeptTo/j,r] oKraij/juepos — abstract for concrete) to shew that the rite was duly performed ac- cording to God's ordinance, and that he was a true-born Jew, and not a proselyte, having been circumcised as Isaac and his descendants wei*e. " That is," says St. Augustine % *'not a proselyte, not a stranger joined to the people of God, not circumcised at an advanced age, but of my parents born a Jew, I have the circumcision of the eighth day." of the stock of Israel, Understand * born ;' compare 2 Cor. xi. 22, " Are they Israelites ? so am I ?" As the circumcision on the eighth day shewed that he was not a proselyte, so this expression points out that he was not born of proselyte parents, and that he was not of the descendants of Ishmael and Esau who were circumcised. of the tribe of Benjamin, See Rom, xi. 1, " For I also am an Israelite, of the seed of Abraham, of the tribe of Benjamin." He adds this to •> St. Augustine, Serm. oxix. 4, in Nov. Test. ' St. Chrysostom. ' Serm. cxix. 5, iu Nov. Test. VER. 4 — 6.] ST. Paul's epistle to the philippians. 125 augment his dignity, for it was a high distinction to belong to this tribe, (the descendants of Jacob's well-beloved son,) since the first king was chosen from it, and when the rest revolted it remained loyal. In addition to which, Jerusalem was situated within its bounds. an Hebrew of the Hebrews ; Not merely a Jew, but one of pure descent, whose family had never been defiled by a forbidden marriage. Compare 2 Cor. xi. 22. Caietan says, " Non ex Samaritis, non ex admistis parentibus, sed ex parentibus Hebraeis, unde Abra- ham originem duxit." So that these words must not be considered as a mere repetition of what has gone before. as touching the law, a Pharisee ; " He is coming now to the circumstances dependent on his own will," says St, Chrysostom, " for all those things were apart from the will ; for his being circumcised was not of himself, nor that he was of the stock of Israel, nor that he was of the tribe of Benjamin." Compare Acts xxiii. 6, " I am a Pharisee, the son of a Pharisee ; " and xxvi. 5, " After the most straitest sect of our religion I lived a Pharisee." The word 'law' means as far as discipline is concerned. 6. Concerning zeal, persecuting the Church ; ' Zeal,' i. e. for the traditions of the Fathers. See Rom. X. 2. The word ^-fjXos ('zeal') is sometimes used in Scrip- ture in a good sense * and sometimes in a bad sense ". It is plain that it must be taken here in a good sense, as signi- fying the honourable emulation, with the consequent imita- tion, of that which presents itself to the mind as excellent. For more on this subject see Trench's " Synonyms of the New Testament," p. 101 and following. He mentions his * zeal,' because it would be quite possible to be a Pharisee, and yet only a cold and indifferent one. It was not so, however, with him ; for he had ' zeal,' and he * John ii. 17 ; Eom. x. 2 ; 2 Cor. ix. 2. Acts V. 17 i Rom. xiii. 13 j Gal. v. 20 ; James iii. 14. 126 ' COMMENTARY ON [CHAP. HI. shewed it by * persecuting the Church.' Compare 1 Cor. XV. 9. St. Augustine'' has the following upon this verse : "Among his merits he enumerates that he was a persecutor ; * according to zeal,' he says. What zeal ? I was not, says he, an inac- tive Jew ; whatsoever it was that seemed contrary to my law I bore impatientl}', I followed up vehemently. This was, with the Jews, nobility ; but with Christ is sought humility." touching the righteousness which is in the law, blameless. i. e. such righteousness as the Law can give to those who obey its precepts. The Apostle keeps for the last place that which was of the highest importance, viz. the exact fulfil- ment of the Law; see Acts xxiii. 1; 2 Tim. i. 3. He is careful in this place to mention ' righteousness,' " since it is possible to be adventurous, or to act thus (i. e. shew zeal, as he had done in persecuting) from ambition, and not out of zeal for the Law, as the high priests did." So St. Chry- sostom. It is plain that 'blameless' must be taken in a limited sense, as far as human observation could go, but not before Gody. He did not say absolutely 'without sin,' but 'with- out blame, ^ — Rosenmiiller explains, " Nihil unquam feci morte aut verberibus dignum," — shewing that although he sinned, yet his sins were not of such a character that any one could fairly find fault with him on the score of legal observances. Bp. Wilson interprets, "So as the Law never took hold of me." After citing the examples of Zacharias and Elisabeth % St. Augustine" goes on to say of St. Paul, " He walked in the Law without blame, and what in him was without blame, this made great matter of blame con- cerning him." It is highly interesting and instructive to notice in passing the widely difierent way in which St. Paul speaks of his state before and after his conversion. Before his conversion his Horn. cxix. 5, in Nov. Test. y 1 Tim. i. 13, 14. » Luke i. 6. ' Honi. cxix. 6, in Nov. Test. VER. 6 — 8. J ST. Paul's epistle to the philippians. 127 estimate of himself was " touching the righteousness which is in the Law blameless" ^fter, " This is a faithful saying, and worthy of all acceptation, that Christ Jesus came into the world to save sinners; of whom I am chief ^\" Just as a man that has acquired wealth may be a rich man with respect to himself, but on mixing with other people may, by comparison, appear only poor, so St. Paul, as long as he was wrapped up in himself, and did not know God truly, could never learn how great his poverty really was. 7. But what things were gain to me, those I counted loss It is well worthy of observation that althovigh ' gain' (KepSr]) in this verse is plural, ' loss' (^nj/jiia) is singular. It is as if it was but this one ' loss ' that he saw in all the 'gains' of which he has been speaking. The antithesis between the two words is very remarkable ; he depresses his former position and attainments as much as he had previously exalted them. It is also to be observed, as St. Ambrose, Augustine, and Qi^cumenius point out, that he is not speaking absolutely here of the Law, but of the ' righteousness which is in the Law.' And this is plain from verse 9, where he says, " not having mine own righte- ousness which is of the Law," &c. It was this ' righteous- ness,' which he had achieved in the Law, and not the Law itself, which he calls 'loss' and 'dung.' for Christ. i. e. ' that I might embrace Christ as my Saviour.' It would have been in vain that the Apostle abandoned the Jewish ritual unless something better had been substituted for it. St. Gregory Nazianzen, who was famous for his learning, used to rejoice like the Apostle that he had something of value that he might count 'loss' for Christ's sake. A noble ground of boasting. 8. Yea doubtless, and I count all things but loss The Apostle rises in fervour. Not merely did he count *> 1 Tim. i. 15. 128 COMMENTARY ON [cHAP. III. his Jewish birth and education and his other past-' gains' to be ' loss ;' but he reckons all possible things, including life itself, to be but ' loss.' Not only what he has already pos- sessed, or still has, but what it is possible for him in any way to acquire, all this he counts but * loss.' The use of the present tense, rjyov/xai, {' I count,') is em- phatic. As Caietan says, " I not only have counted, but at the present time continue so to count ;" i. e. after long ex- perience my conviction remains unshaken. The expression dWa /jievovvye, * yea doubtless,' veruntamen etiam, is very strong, and denotes great vehemence on the part of St. Paul ; it is a correction of any possible or actual mistake. Com- pare Luke xi. 28, pevovvye /xaKapLot, k.t.X. for the excellency of the knowledge of Christ Jesus Sid TO vTrepi'x^ov rijs yvcoaefos, instead of Std ttjv