1 PRINCETON, N. J. j I Division Si'C/ian ....: Shelf... ^>J.\ Ntimlwr .... Ai'f^^H^- / A ^ ttORM SOLITARI^ on, ESSAYS UPON SOIME REMARKABLE NAMES AND TITLES OF THE OLY SPIEIT dccunRiNG in ? THE OIB AND NEW TESTAMENTSj AND DECIARATITE OF HIS ESSENTIAL DIVINITX AND GHACIOCS OFFICES IN THE SALVATION OF MEN : TO WHICH IS ANNEXED A BRIEF ACCOUNT OF THE HERESIES, UELATIVE TO THE DOCTRINE OF THE HOLY SPIRIT, WHICH HAVE BEEN PUBLISHED SINCE THE CHRISTIAN ^RA, IN TWO VOLUMES. Whosoever speaketh against the Holt Ghost * ** ***=■'*■**** 03' Matth. xii. 3?.. VOL. II. ECOND AJIERICAN FROM THE THIRD LONDON EDITION. HARTFORD: T'UBLISHED BY SILAS ANDRU? K. liy E. Hosfvrd, Printers^Albanti. PREFACE. T. HE former volume ©f essays, which chiefly related to the divinity of Christ, was composed in hours of retreat from the business of the world : the present, which treats of the divinity of the Holy Spirit, has been written in full retirement from the world itself. It was therefore supposed, that the title of Hora Solitariee might not be improper for both. However trite and common the apology, it can very truly be said, that this part of the work was attempted and now appears at ihe instance of a learned and most valuable friend, whose wishes •with the author, on the best of accounts, ought to have the force of commands, and whose worth and eminence it might seem vain to mention upon this occasion, as it would be thought superflu- ous (did he take the liberty to name him) upon any. The two volumes, beyond the particular subject of each, concur in one common design to shew ; that the doctrine of a Trinity of iter sons in one and the same Jehovah is essential to the very being of the Christian religion ,- and, that the firactical use or exfierience of this truth, including and combining all the other principles of the faith, is the proper constituent of the Christian life. If the essays tend to confirm a doctrine so important, or to induce an imprevement so desirable, the author may be credited in professing to have no other purpose in their puhiication. The author's distance from the press has increased the imper- fections of his papers, which the candid and intelligent reader will have the goodness to correct or excuse : and he ventures hum- bly to solicit every reader, who is duly sensible of the consequence of divine truth, that prayer may be made for the blessing of grace, without which no human endeavours can be successful, and that all the praise, if the least good ensue, be rendered to HIM, " from whom all holy desires, all good counsels, and all just works, do proceed," ADDRESS TO THE PUBLIC* THE knowledge of God is the most important subject that can engage; ;he attention of man. " This is eternal life to know the only true God and Jesus Christ whom he hath sejit." Every attempt to assist in searching- the Scripture and of becoming better acquainted with the character and perfections of Jehovah, Father, Son and Holy Ghost, deserves the approbation and encouragement of every faithful Christian. Tlie Hon.E Sohtahi^ or Hours of Retirement, are eminently en- titled to Christian pati'onage. The author, with great piety, application, and a large share of scriptural criticism, hath explained, and by sound reasoning established this funda- mental article of the gospel. That Jehovah our Lord is one God, revealed to us under the distinct names and personal properties of Father, Son and Holt Spihit. The doctrine of tlie Trinity, so essential to the faith and comfort of the Christian, and the peculiar offices and operations which distinguish the per- sons of the ineffable Godhead, has not received an illustration more satisfac- tory and purely scriptural, since the days of Jltluinasius, than what these papers contain. The author, it is said, was a Layman, attached to the British arjuy in the revolutionary American war. The parts were written at different times, some of them in the camp, and published at different times and places. His motives, for he sought no profit, he courted no applause, must have been pure and disinterested. Published in detached portions, and issuing from presses, in all cases, not correct, many errors in the text, but especially in his valuable notes, nbounded. The Philadelphia edition published by different printers in 1801, is liable to tlie same censure. It v/as printed from the second London edition. This edition is printed from the tliird London edition, of 1804, revised and corrected by the author himself, which is allowed to be peculiarly ac- curate. The proof-sheets have been revised by gentlemen who are pledges that the learned notes have suffered no injury. THE PUBLISHER. * The absence of the Publisher from the Press 7vhen the frst vohme -was printed, occasioned the omission of the Address to the Public and Recommen- dutions of tlie luork from being i7itroduced in the front of that volume, the usual place allotted for them. He hopes that by prefixing them to the second volume, every object intended by them shall be accomplished tvifhont any real di'^ad- ".•antttpe RECOMMENDATIONS. 'po MR. TORRiT, SIR, I am highly pleased with j-our intention of offering to the Christian public an American, from the third London edition of those interesting volumes en- titled Hon^ SoLiTAuiiE. This work, from its first publication, lias been highly esteemed by every real believer who has become acquainted with it The subject itself is of great importance and sublimity ; and, whilst the friend of Jesus Christ delights to trace the real divinity of the Son and the Holy Spirit in the light of divine Revelation, he will here find arguments an4 view s calculated to strengthen his faith, and draw forth the affections of his iieart, towards the triune god, in holy adoration and praise. SAMUEL BLATCHFORD, D. D Pastor of the United Congregations of hansingbvrgh and Waterfurd. Lansingburgh, June 16, 1814. I concur in tiie above recommendation. WILLIAM NEBLL, D. D. ]^Cistor of the First Presbyterian Church, Albany. Albany, June 19, 1814. I also concur in the above I'ecommendations. JOHN M'DONALD, Pastor of the Presbyterian Church, Chapel-street, Albavy, Sin — Your design to re-publish the volumes entitled the " Honjj Sou- TAHi.E," cannot fiill to gratify the friends of evangelical truth. There are it'x works of human composition in which the divinity of the Son of God with the infinite sufficiency of his sacrifice for tlie remission of sin ; also, the divinity of the Holy Spirit, with his agency in the sanctification of the soul, arc more clearly stated and ably defended : And what adds to the excel- lence of this Treatise, thetie great doctrines of our religion are very happily applied for solving the doubts and enlivening the hopes of those who are ex- ercised to Godliness. I have i-ead the work with great pleasure, and can cheerfully recommend it to all who love the truth as it is in Jesus, and ivould grow up to the measure of the stature of his fulness. ALEXANDER PROUDFIT, D. D. Pastor of the First Presbyterian Church, Salem, JV*. Y. Salem, August 13th, 1814. Sin — I rejoice to heai- that you are about to print that valuable work, termed Hors Somtaui*. Its republication, at present, is peculiarly sea- sonable, when many are exerting themselves to subvert the Christian's faith in the doctrine of tjie Trinity. In this precious work, the learned and pious author proves from the sacred volume, that tlie Redeemer and Sanctifier of dinners, arc pod equ;il with the Father. I know of no publication cmittecl SECOMMENDATIONS. vii from the press for a length of time, that is better calculated to confirm the wavering, strengthen the weak, and comfort the afflicted believer ; and therefore recommend it to the people of my charge, as worthy of a place in their libraries. JAMES MAIRS, A. M. JUinistef of the Associate Itefonned Congregation of Galiuay and Charlton, Gal-way, 2^th August, 1814. Having perused " Hor.s Scutari^:," I do most cordially approbate the \rork, as exhibitmg tlie highest marks of ingenuiu^, learning, and piety ; and I do most cheerfully recommend it to the careful and candid perusal of all classes of people, ars eminently calculated to establish in the public mind, the Deity of the Second Person in the Trinity. JOEL BYINGTON, Minister of the Gospel of Christ, Hahron, JV. I' Sir— Understanding that you are about to publish an edition of the HoHiE Solitabia:, I most cheerfully reoommend it to the serious perusal of all who have a relish for evangelical truth. R. PROUDFIT, JkEnister of tfie Associate Seformed Chwxh, £roailalbin. September 26th, 1814. The HoH.ffi SoLiTABi^ have been so long known as a work of superior me- rit, and so justly recommended by names of such respectability, that my approbation can be of little avail. A publication exhibiting so much evan- gelical doctrine and pious sentiment, has a powerful claim upon the patro- nage of the Christian public. GILBERT M'MASTER, Minister of the Gospel of Christ, in Gabtx^. 'September 8fA, 1814, CONTENTS. LORD, or Jehovah Alehim, or God Adonai Most High Holy Spirit Eternal Spirit Comforter Spirit of Life Water of Life Spirit of Truth Spirit of Grace Spirit of Adoption Spirit of Faith Law Voice Spirit of Wisdom, 8cc. Spirit of Counsel Spirit of Might Spirit of Knowledge Spirit of Fear of Jehovah Guide Teacher Power Spirit of Promise Love Understanding Oil of Gladness Conclusion NAMES, TITLES, AND ATTRIBUTES, OF THE HOLY SPIRIT, REVEAIED IN THE TWO TESTAMENTS, LORD, OR JEHOVAH. A HE import of this glorious name has been considered in the former volume, in which it was shewn, that the Almighty called himself by this title to explain, to our understandings, his neces- sary, independent, self-existent Being, and to impress us with the idea of his own immutability and eternity, and of the derivation of all other existence from him. This name of course cannot be- long to a creature^ is never applied to any, but is claimed distinct- ly from all other names and attributes by the great Author and Creator of all things. It is the purpose of this Essay to prove, that the incommuni- cable name Jehovah belongs to the Holy Spirit: And such testimonies will be brought for this end, as (it is hoped) may confirm every believer, and do something to silence the mouth of the gainsayer ; because they will be testimonies from Him who cannot lie — from Him, who cannot te mistaken himself, and who is too good and gracious, in the remotest degree to deceive us. We shall see, as we go along, what a glory this sublime truth throws upon ail the other doctrines of the gospel, and in what per- fect agreement it proceeds with the analogy of faith revealed in the Old and New Testaments, and (it may be ndded) revealed in every real Christian's soul for his comfort and salvation. To those who neither knonv the scri/itures nor the fiower of God, it is not pi'esumed, that any evidence upon this subject, from those scriptures can be satisfactory ; since, as our Lord assures us, that, rejecting these, they nvouldnot (or could not) believe though one arose from the dead. The Spirit Jehovah himself must af- VOL, II. B 10 LORD, OR JEHOVAH. ford an elenc/ms, or energy, to his own testimony; or, could they cease to be declarcdinfidcis, they would only become mere specu- latists, and consequently notional, not real believers. But to those, whose understandings are ojiened to understand the scri/iturea (Luke xxiv. 45.) and from whose hearts the stone is in some mea- sure removed (Ezek. xxxvi. 26) ; it is hoped, that the evidences of this great ti'uth will not only be convincing and undeniable, but (what seems, to the author, of more moment) edifying and esta- blishing in their most holy faith. Merely to inform the judgment, is but half the object: The desire is, that, with a clear and sound comprehension of the truths the heart may be warmed with the love of it, and the soul built up thereon by a happy and divine ex- perience. The Spirit, of whom we are treating, is alone able to effect this : Reader, look up to him for his blessing, that thou mayest be led in a right way to a right end ; which is, by the pow- er of grace, to the glory of Jehovah, and thine own salvation. Our first design is to prove, that the Holy Spirit is Jehovah ; and our next, that, being Jehovah,* He is able to accomplish all that is said of Him, and all that is necessary for xis to life etei'nal. It will be granted by all but professed Atheists, and no Chris- tian therefore can deny it, " That there is but one Jehovah." We are slandered, consequently, when, upon our professing to be- lieve, that the Father is Jehovah, the Son Jehovah, and the Spirit Jehovah, it is said of us that we talk oi three Gods ; for the very name Jehovah (if our adversaries would but understand it) en- tirely precludes that notion. A simple, infinite, perfect essence must necessarily be indivisible : Nor do wcjin our idea, presume to make divisions in the Deity, but to believe only those distinC' tions of persons, hypostases, or subsistences in him, of which He himself hath been pleased tc^ive a revelation, and by which reve- lation alone we can know any thing of the matter. We are not wise above what is -written s nor would we be too proud or self- sufficient to follow the written wisdom of God. In another case, v/hen our philosophers speak of the light, or fire, or substance of the material sun ; they would deem it an insult, if they were ac- cused of maintaining, that there were several suns ; because of those distinctions, which they perceived in his nature. And, by * One cannot help wishing" with Forster, tliat the Hebrew name Jehovah were preserveil ui all translations of the Bible, gitotl hcec nttributa [i. e. Do minus et Deus,] neqnc esseiitiavi iUxinam, neque nominis propriam signijica- tionem exprimant ,■ "bccaiisctlicse titles of Lord and God can neither express the divine essence, nor give the proper signiiicutiou of hW names." LORD, OR JEHOVAH. 11 a very small share of candor, those, who charge the Christians ■with Tritheism, for holding the doctrinp of the Trinity, might have saved themselves from committing a violent injustice ; be- cause, though we maintain, that " each person by himself is Je- vohah," yet we also declare, that there are not three Lords, but one Lord, according to what is written in Deut. vi. 4. Hear, O Israel, Jehovah our Alehim is one Jehovah, — Nor doth it strike our reason with more repugnance to assert this concerning a spi- ritual essence, of which we can know nothing but what is reveal- ed, when God himself hath revealed this doctrine to us ; than it can the reason of a philosopher to conceive light and heal in a ma- terial substance, without aflFecting the imity of that substance, •when he knows this only by his senses, which in some respects are acknowledged to be fallacious. In the one case, there is the testimony of God, who surely knows the mode of his own being, and who is himself pure and perfect reason ; but in the other, wc have only the evidence of sense, which not only is not reason, but very often is contrary to it. Yet were we to assert the existence of three sefiarate suns, because we could find as many properties in our one sun ; we should have enough to laugh at us for our notion, and especially among those who are so unfair (not to say ■worse) as to accuse us of believing in three separate Gods, because ■we assert three divine hypostases, or persons, to be in the Godhead, and this upon the authority of God himself. Who then act the most rationally ; they^ who, confessing God to be incomprehensible^ yet presume to define his infinite nature according to their own low and limited notions ; or we, who, acknowledging that his being f«- finitely transcends all human investigation, receive with humble submission that testimony, which he bath given us of himself ? We never pretend, that God's existence is a subject of human reason : Nor have we so little reason as to attempt the measure of all in- finitude by a finite rule. The presumption of infidelity^ which af- fects to believe nothing beyond its own puny comprehension, and yet blames those who cannot believe it upon a point confessedly incomfirehensible ; is at once too daring to be safe, and too igno- rant to be trusted, in a matter of such importance. God's own wisdom and truth, in this respect, are only sufficient to satisfy us : But, if they were not, we certainly could not be satisfied with the cogitations of poor mortals, who know not even the mode of their own being, nor how themselves think, nor indeed the essence of ^ny one material substance about them. le LORD, OR JEHOVAH. THE SPIRIT IS JEHOVAH. Jeremiah xxxi, 33, 34. This shall be the Covenant^ saith Jcho' ■vah — they shall teach no more every inan his neighbour — saying, Kjiow Jehovah ; for they shall all know 7ne-— saith Jehovah. John xvi. 13. When He, the Spirit of Truth is come, he ivill guide you into all truth. This is the accomplishment of the promise, that Jehovah the Spirit guides into all truth, and makes himself known to his peo- ple. An obvious distinction is here made between the teaching of God and of man : And as obvious a fact it appears, that the Spirit guiding, in one text, is Jehovah promised to be known in the other. Deut. vi. 16. with Matth. iv. 7. Thou shalt not tempt Jehovah thy Alehim. Acts. v. 9. How is it that you have agreed to tempt the Spirit nf the Lord ? Ananias and Sapphira for this temptation were judicially seized by immediate death, which proved upon fact, that they had not lied unto men, but unto God, and that to tempt the Spirit, is no other than to tempt Jehovah himself, which could not be unless the Spirit were Jehovah.* Acts xxviii. 25. Well spake the Holy Ghost by Esaias the Pro^ phet. Sec. But we read in Luke i. 68, 70. that it was the Lord God [Jehovah Alehim] of Israel, who spake by the mouth of his holy Prophets, which have been si?ice the world began. See Micah iii. 8. It follows, then, that the Holy Ghost is the Lord God of Israel. 1 Sam. xvi. 13. The Spirit of Jehovah came upon David from that day forward. But in the 18th verse, it is said expressly, that Jehovah was with him. Deut. xxxii. 12. Jehovah alone [nia entirely alone] did lead him [Jacob, a collective name for his people.] But in Isaiah Ixiii. 11, 12. We read that it was the Holy Spirit, that led them by the right hand of Moses, with his glorious arm. The Holy Spirit, therefore, is Jehovah. Isaiah vi. 9. Jehovah Sabaoth said, go and tell this people. Hear ye indeed, but understand not ; and see ye indeed, but perceive not, &c. But the Apostle says, * See an excellent Note upon tliis argiunent in Jones's Catholic Doctrine of a Trinitij. p. 41. 3d. edit. LORD, OR JEHOVAH 13 Acts xxviii. 25. ffcll s/iake the Holy Ghost by Emian the Pro- fihet unto our fathers^ saying^ Go unto this fieople^ and say ^ Hear- ing ye shall hear, and shall not understand^ &c. Therefore, The Holy Ghost is Jehovah Sabaoth.* Numbers xii. G. If there be a Prophet among you, I Jehovah will make myself known unto him in a vision, &c. 2 Pet. i. 21. For the profihecy coine not in old time by the will of man ; but holy men of God spake as they were moved by the Holy Ghost. The Holy Ghost, therefore, niust be Jehovah. The name Jehovah in the Old Testament is rendered by Kvpioi in the New, and into the English by Lord, which certainly doth not convey the sense of the original word. It is, however, as- well as to the Father and the Son, applied to the Holy Spirit ; though not very modestly or carefully denied by the opposers of his divinity. Thus, 2 Cor. iii. 17, IS. Por the Lord is the Spirit — eve7i as by the Lord the Spirit ; for so it should have been translated ; as indeed it is so translated in the margin of our larger Bibles. Col. ii. 9. In him [Christ"] dwclleth all the fulness of the God- head bodily. Isaiah xi. 2. ^nd the Spirit Jehovah shall rest upon him, 8cc. Matt. xii. 18. I will put my Spirit upon him, Sec. The Spirit, therefore, is the yji/wes* of the Godhead, not sepa- rate from (for that is impossible, the Godhead being one) the other divine persons, but in unity with them, participating the un- divided essence. Isaiah Ixiii. 10. The Israelites of old re/5f//frf and vexed his Holy Spirit. But in Numb. xiv. 11. They are said to have provoked Jehovah, and in Psalm Ixxviii. 56. to have tempted and provoked the most High God. The Holy Spirit is, therefore, Jehovah and the Most High God. Psalm xxxiii. 6. JBy the word of Jehovah were the Heavens made, and all the Host of them by the Spirit [nn] of his mouth. But it is said, Prov, xvi. 4. Jehovah made all things for himself, &c. And that Acts xvii. 24. God lyiade the world, and all things therein. * See some valuable Notes from the fathers upon this argument, in that excellent volume of Sermons upon tlie Divinity of the Holy Spirit, by the late Mr. John HuiTion : printed 1734. And also an answer to some objec- tions in Sloss's Sermons upon the Trinity : Serm. xvi. See .ilso Witsii Srerc in Is yu U LORD, OR JEHOVAH. The Spirit, therefore, as well as the Son, is both Jehovah and God. ^ Romans xv. 9, The Apostle ascribes the mighty signs and wonders, wrought in confirmation of the Gospel, to the fiower of the spirit of God. But the Psalmist says, in Psalm cxxxvi.thatit is Jehovah, the Alehim, the Lord of Lords, odiis existendi, the scripture has not endeavoured to explain, because man could not possibly conceive that wot/f'. nor is it necessary for him ; and theretbi-e all disputation upon these points is impertinent, and proceeds from the affectation of being iiisi-: above -zvho: is ivritten. * We would use the word person in the sense of the Aug.sh\irgh Confes- sion, which says, JVo?n!?i iser and a modester part. It would teach us to be con ent with;n iliosc; bounds which God has assigned to us, 2 Cor. x. 5. casting dottm imuginattons and every high thing that exalteth itself against tlie knoiuledge of God, u?id brm&i/ig into captivity every thought to the obedience of Christ." Lord Lyti.lc:on's Obs- on the conversion of St. Paul. * Cceli mystcrium dacsat me JDeu? ipse, 7wn homo qui scipnum ignoravit.— Ambr Epist. 31. no ALLIUM, OR GOD. to know. Of course, we arc not to seek for descriptions of the Deity out of the linoits of this testimony, beyond which we are sure only of finding nothing certain, but most entirely wf/Zim those boundaries, where we can hear nothing but the truth. If even Pythagoras could say, « Without light nothing is to be uttered concerning God." Where tlien shall we find this light, but in his •word? Till this /zos^M/cCum be admitted, a man has nothing but his own chimerical fancy to support him, which will not only dif- fer from the ten thousand d.fFerent opinions of ten thousand dif- ferent men, but also quarrel with itself times without number in the course of his life. But when this ground and pillar of the truth is once erected in the heart, the man does not measure it by his own whims and conceptions taken from other things ; but he makes this the standard and rule whereby to measure t/iem. And, after some experience of the justness of this measure in its ex- ercise upon natural and raoral subjects, in which it never was yet detected, by all human wit and malice, of one mistake ; he has an increasing encouragement to trust it, I)y the grace and light of the Holy Spirit its author, in the determination of those purely spiritual topics, to which no rule, taken from or existing in mate- rial object?:, can possibly be applied. The rule, tlien, by which we are to be guided, in these high and momentous enquiries, is no other than the mind, rule, or law of God, speaking and revealing itself, so far as it is right or neces- sary for us to know, in the lioly scriptures. These were given by his inspiration, and are profitable for doctrine, for reproof [con- viction] for correction \_i7rix,vo^B-eao-n;, restoration to rectitude,] for instrttction in righteousiiess ; that the men of God may be per- feet [wanting nothing] thoroughly furnished unto all good ivorks, 2 Tim. iii. 16. The prophecy came not in old lime, or at any time, by the will of 7nan ; for man could have foretold nothing by him- self, and bad men especially, in different ages of the world, would never have combined to compose such a system of pure and pious doctrines ;* but holy 7nen oj God spake as they mere moved by the Holy Ghost. 2 Pet. i.21. We can call for no greater witness in this cause than God himself ; and we owe both to it and our own souls too much, to think of calling for less. God hath revealed his nature under the name of Jehovah, by • "If the scriptures were delivered by men ; then either by 5'oo'^rnen or by bad : If by lioly men, then Uiey would speak tlie truth, and not lie; if by bad men, then they would never have set down such strict rules of doctrine to live bv, as must condemn themselves." Sec Dr. IVcston's Sermons on the Divine Esse?ice, 8cc. Serm. iii: ALEHIM, OR GOD. 31 which he declares himself to be the sole independent essence, the necessary existence, in whom and by whom alone all othei' be- ings, corporeal or spiritual, exist and subsist. This title expres- ses his incommunicable, self-existent, infinite, and everlasting na- ture. He ever ivas, eyer w, and ever will be. This is all we can comprehend of his essence, when we have added every idea of perfection and glory, which are revealed concerning this essence, and which can fill our minds. He is then beyond all idea the EVERLASTING SAME. If we were /aire creatures, this unchangeable perfection of the Most High would be an unfailing source of joy to our souls : But^ being imfierfect^ fallen^ and sinful creatures, all this purity of our Creator is directly opposed to us. We have now no complacency in it, naturally ; and cannot have, while we continue in our natu- ral state ; for it is repugnant to our lusts and passions, which are all corrupted by sin. God is not only opposite to the sinner; but the sinner feels a diametrical opposition to him, and all that be- longs to him. Hence, the world, in all ages, hath been averse to the revealed Will of God, and to the true disciples of God, who have spoken of tliat Will and walked in it. That no natural man can savor the things of God, is a proposition, which since the fall ever was true, and which will be true to the end of the world. From this opposi- tion nothing could justly have been expected by the creature but absolute destruction and misery, a taste of which every man feels "within him ; had not the benignity of his Creator graciously in- clined both to procure the means of deliverance, and to publish them to him. His Creator did publish these means ; and they are happily in force to this day. In the discovery of so much goodness and mercy iri himself for his ruined creature ; he was pleased to represent himself under a varJe^!/ q/wames, either cha- racteristic of his engagement to save, or explanatory of the nature of his salvation. It was expedient for man's faith and comfort, that this publication should take place ; or rather, it was nece^- ^ary-i or God would not have made it. One unalterable attribute which God hath declared of himself, is his Justice. The soul that sinnethy shall surely die. In the day^ that thou eatest thereof dying, thou shalt die. Without shedding of blood (which is spilling or destroying the lifej thvrc is no remis- sion of sins- How then could this justice be satisfied? Not by the sinner's perdition ; for then there could be no exercise of mercy. Not by the sjj^nev's mere pardon: for then Cod mu-^ S3 ALEHIM, OR GOD. have been a liar, and given up that pure J4istice, which is foundcdf upon his infinite holiness and is absolutely essential to his nature. The sinner was to be saved ; and God's denunciation against sin was at the same time to be fully accomplished. Here it was, that hifinite wisdom alone could not be at a loss : Here, infinite love only cOuld not meet with despair. Life was to be forfeited to pro^ cure salvation. But the life of whom ? What created being could step forth and say, " Take my life for the lives of millions of men ; and let my perdition prove an atonement for them I" If any finite love could have uttered this tender expression ; it would have been madness or presumption for any finite being to have offered the change. No holy creatuie could have been guilty of it; be- cause the root oi /17-^sum/irion is ignorance and sin. All the An- gels in Heaven, blessed with holiness and wisdom, could not but see, that no finite sufferings could have made an atonement to the infinite justice of their Maker, and that the destruction of one crea- ture could never answer the deserved destruction of millions of creatures, — -a destruction to keep equal with the guilt, necessari- ly without intermission or end. The scripture now breaks in with lightdivine, and shews ; that He only, ivhom all the Angels luor- shifi, was to perform this astonishing task of suffering ; and that He only, who breathed into man his original life, would restore him, by a new and incorruptible birth, to the possession of that forfeited life again. The scripture marks these two pronouns He and He by various names descriptive of their distinction in point oi personality or subsistence.^ as well as of their U7idertaking or office. From the one end of the Bible to the other, it appears to be the office of the one He to atone for, reconcile, and restore; and of the i3/Aer,to effectuate, apply, and complete, all that was ne- cessary for the divine glory, and for human salvation. Thus Je- hovah was to be reconciled by Jehovah : Thus Jehovah became a Saviour, and the oJily Saviour : And thus Jeliovah is the sanctijier of those unholy creatures, who are the objects of his mercy and redemption. Here, then, Vr'e see distinct offices^ undertaken and accomplish- ed by distinct persons. We read of one person, who is called the Father, who sent his Son into the world to save sinners ; we read the prophecies concerning this Son, and their fnlfilnicnt in him and by him for the salvation of sinners ; and wc read of the Hoi]/ Spirit, sent from the Father and the Son to quicken and bless these sinners to the end,* To these three persons we also find * These and many other doctrines of divine revelation, in the delivery of "^hicU so many holy men ii» ail ag«s,unkno\vn to each other, have concurred ALEHIM, OR GOD. 53 ascribed all the powers, glories, perfections, and attributes of the Deity: we hear far/j saluted by that incommunicable name, which is above every Jiafne^ and distinctly denominated Jehovah : and we are taught, both by precept and example, to worshi/i, in consequence, all these persons under (his navic. Yet, after all, we find it written, as with a sun-beam, and most careftiJly and em- phatically delivered, as an infallible and invariable trutli, that Jeho- vah is but ONE Jehovah. Either, therefore, these three persons, each called Jehovah, are but one Jehovah ; or the revelation and v/isdom of God, respecting his own being, contradicts itself. But, as this is impossible, it will follow most irrefragably, that Jeho- vah is 07ie Jehovah in three persons, and that the three persons have a c?«^/«c? mode of subsistence in the one Jehovah, though their essence is not d/rzc/erf, but the «a772e.* It is absurd in this place to say, that we cannot comfirehend this ; because our reason is not the judge here, but God's own revelation of himself; and this truth cannot depend, for its existence, upon ourdepraved and unequal faculties. God hath revealed it^aud therefore it is true; is an argument which human wit cannot repel, and which it will be found the height of human imprudence to oppose. If he hath not revealed it, then it falls to the ground of itself; but then also fall with it, the whole gospel of God, and the whole salvation of man. There is no alternative in the case, but humble faith or ab- solute scepticism and infidelity. Now, as the word Jehovah doth not express the trinal conjunc- cion of these three divine persons in the divine essence; ariother word hath been given us, v/hich affords us a notion of this plurali^ ?!/,and yet is so applied as not to mislead us from the unity. This name is the title of our present essay. Alehim is plural, and intimates plurality : it is fi::^ quently used with verbs and nouns singular, and is sometimes applied to unity itself. Thus, in that important text ; Jehovah our Alehim is one Jehovah. As a very and concurred to one and the. same end; in humano cereuro nasci non potiie- ^■unt (says tlie excellent ]SIorn?:us) could never have spiiinsj from the head of man, but must have been, as appears even tiom dieii- internal ev.dence, communicaled from Him, who only could give just thoughts of his ov.a being', and confirm die truth of these thoug;hts by xvorida^s and signs foUoiu- ing. See much more to this effect in that great work of Mornseus. De verit. Rcl. Christ, c. 25. * The Wirtemberg confession of faith states the doctrine m the following' ■".vords; Credimiis iS conftevnir, uwuxn solum, -ven; in, cetcnmm, immcnswn cs&e Deum, omnipotentem creatorem, omnban xisibillvm^ invisibiliiim ,- et in i,. c ima PC ceieriia Divinitate tees esse per se svBSifTENTKs proprietates sen personar, F;.lrein, Filiriir, -' Spir.tujTi Sar.ctv.m. ^Li'itag. Conf.Fld. V ii, p. 142. 34 ALEHIM, OR GOD. iearnerl and exceiient author hath observed; "the very sense of ''' this passage leads us to seek for a filural interpretation ; because, « there is no need of a revelation to teach us, that Jehovah our " Alehi in is one Jehovah, which is no more than one is one."* This word, then, expressing the plurality of the divine persons, is proved to mean the conjunction of tliose persons by the use of the singular word Jehovah with it : or the two terms would con- tradict each other. For if the word Jehovah mean one essence, and the word Alehim bear a iilural interpretation ; these divine persons are in some respect that divine essence conjunctively .^ ■which they are not distinctly respecting each other. In other •words, there is a distinction in the miity of the divine essence ; or an application of plural words to that essence would be an absur^ dity, with which no man will surely be hardy enough to charge the wisdom of God. Since then there exists a /z/M7*c^?7t/ 0/ /persons in the divine es- sence, we have a full answer at once to the question ; how Jeho- vah could be reconciled by Jehovah ; how Jehovah could be an atonement for sinners to Jehovah ; and how Jehovah could lead those pardoned sinners to Jehovah ? Upon any other ground than that of this plurality, these doctrines, which frame the very constitution of the gospel, would be overthrown as inexplicable and absurd. The word, in this view, necessarily implies as well as expresses a co-ycwa;:?, and, because undertaken for lost sinners, a covenant oi grace. The Son in Jehovah must have undertaken this re- demption, or he could not have been compelled. The Spirit, who promised all that was promised, voluntarily made these pi'omises, or they could not have been forced from him. Deity cannot suffer any impressions of external power ; because there is no power out of itself. If, therefore, the Son undertook this ■work, long before its fulfilment ; and the Spirit promised for ages before the accomplishment of his promises ; it will follow, that it %vas because the mind, counsel, and purpose of the three persons had determined\tbat it should be done, in the fulness of time. If tbe counsel and purpose of the three persons deter7mned this^ it will then follow to have been from an affree7nc7it or covenant ex- isting among them, in the frame of which they all concurred, and in the reciprocal parts of which they all engaged to take their re- * Sermoiis upon the Laxi- and Gospel, by the Kev. Mr. Eomaine. p. 243- t Acts iv. 28.. ALEHIM, OR GOD. 35 tiprocal share. And as all the ideas or purposes of Jehovah Ale- him must, from the necessity of his nature, be everlasting and perfietual ; this covenant could not but be, what the scripture calls it, a perpetual or cuerlasting covena72(, 3. covenant order editi all (/ii?igs and stir e, a. co\enCan any hide himself in secret places, that I shall not see him ? saith Jehovah : do not I Jill Heaven a7id earth ? saith Jehovah, The same question is asked almost in totidem Verbis, concern- ing the Spirit. Psalm cxxxix. 1 — 12. Whither shall I go from thy Sjilrit? Or whither shall I fee tijdd from thy faces ?\ And au * This name Alehim was very early abused by the Heathen, and applied to the powers ofnatui-c, to the heavenly bodies, and afterwards to stocks and to stones. They retained the sound, when they had lost the sense : and be- cause it conveyed the notion of a plurality of persons in the Godhead, it was perverted by them to signify a plurality of Gods. f This word is often used for person or persons, and their immediate pre- sence. It occiu's very reuiairkably in Dcut. iy, 37- where Moses, speaking' 36 ALEHIM, OR GOD. answer is given, in the course of tlie Psalm, to this eftecl ; " thou Jehovah Alehini, art every where ;" evidently implying the co- equal Omiiiprcsence of the Sfnrit. The question, other wise, is ab- surd, and the answer impertinent ; which no man will dare to as- sert, wiio believes the Bible to be a divine revelation. Tl e Spirit, then, is Alehim and Jehovah. Acs X. 19, 20. The Spirit said to Peter — go — / have sent them. B".t,iii verse 33, it is said, that they were /ircsfnr 6«^c/r. 211. 40 ALEHIM, OR GOD. 77ess, firoved fiim, and saw his ivorks. Comp. Ps. xcv. 8, 9. witii Exod. xvii. 7. Numb. xiv. 22. et al. But the Holy Ghost saith — your Fathers tcmfitcd tne^ he. Heb. ill. 7, &c. The Holy Ghost, therefore, is Jehovah and Alehim,* or Lord God. No creature can possibly be a proper object of ivorshi/i ; and therefore no creature can possibly have a temfile for the worship of itself. The pretence would be impious, and the service idola- trous. But believers are called in sevei-al places the temples of the Holy Ghost, and the temples of God, indiscriminately. There ]s not the least difference or distinction, or even the remotest hint of a difference or distinction made between them. 1 Cor. iii. 16. 2 Cor. vi. 16, &c. God and the Holy Ghost, therefore, are essentially one, as well us their temples ; and thus, distinctly in person^ or conjunctively in essence, are the proper object of ivorship and adoration. There would be no end to the arguments, which might be brought to prove this truth of the Spirit's divinity from his owa Bible. Indeed, as the testimony cf Jesus is the spirit of prophe- cy ; so the testimony of the Holy Spirit is the power and princi- ple of all revelation, and, consequently, as such, the very life of all the scriptures. Without Hiin, they never would have existed ; nor, without his continual agency, are they, more than any other book, a blessing in the world. It appears, then, from revelation, that the Holy Spirit is Jeho- vah and Alehim, or Lord and God ; that he is a divipe/^eriow, and not a mere unconscious instrument, or created quality ; and that, accordingly, he hath ascriptions which can belong only to a per- son in the Godhead, who sees, who knows, and who orders all things. In the course of these essays, the evidence of his divine personality w'lW he move particularly considered; and therefore we will conclude this point of the Spirit's proper divinity by an argument of a mixed nature, founded indeed, as to its datum, upon divine revelation, like all other spiritual truth ; but more combined with human reason, which some people pretend to exalt against the wisdom of God, but which " purged from its film," becomes its dutiful servant and willing advocate against the daring pretences of unreasonable men. * If it be asked, "How croi tliin plural \rortl Mehim be applied to one of tlie divine persons ?" the reader is requested to turn to the first Volume, p. ALEHIM, OR GOD. 41 God alone is the Creator of all thifigs. This is a maxim which revelation hatb fully declared, and to which the lowest degvee of reason must yield a ready assent. AU the men, who have ever lived upon the earth, were never able to produce a neiv thing upon it, or to give life where it has once been taken away. The intellect of man can only rise to a discovery, more or less, of Avhat exists; and all his power is exercised only upon the matter and forms about him, to which he can add nothing of his own, nor from which diminish aught by a reduction to nothing. This rule must hold with all ranks of being, except the Sup.reme. But we are informed, by the unerring wisdom of the Most High, that the Spirit, of whom we are treating, hath made, hath fashioned, doth give life and being, to the heavens, to the earth, and to me7i. This Spirit, therefore is not, cannot be made himself : And if he be no; made; then, consequently, he is not a passing emanation era dependent creature. But if he be not a creature, he must be of the same substance with the Godhead of the F. ther, and the Son ; and, being of the same substance, has a right to the title of «n3, or Creator, with them in the unity of that substance, as the whole three persons or Trinity have to the plural denomina- tion of D^«"ii3 and ci'j? the Creators and Makers. See Eccl. xii. 1. and Is. liv. 5. et al. Now, as whatever is not God, must ne- cessarily be a creature ; so what a creature is not. That God is. If the Spirit, therefore, be not of the same substance with the Godhead, he is unavoidably a created substarice : And if he be a created substance, then nothing ever was, or ever could be crea' ted by him. But the word of the living God says positively, that the heavens and the earth, and man in particular tvere created by him : And, therefore, it will follow, upon the united assent of revelation and reason, that the Holy Spirit as Creator is of one substance or essence with the Father and the Son, and conse- quently is with them, God over all, blessed fur ever. Could it be admitted for a moment, that the Holy Ghost is not very God, nor a proper object of worship ; then the Christian Church in all ages* hath been guilty of the most profane and abominable idolatry, and the ritual of the Church of England,! among others, is contaminated with the abomination of heathen- ism, by instituting divine service to a creature. The hosts of Heaven sing Holy, Holy, Holy, for nought ; and (vvith horror be * See Lord Chancellor King' o?i the Creed, ch. vi. p. 316. I See her Litany ; her offices of Consecration of Priests, &c. and the Boxologies. VOL. ir. F 42 ALEHIM, OR GOD. it spoken) God himself hath failed in the performance of his pro- mise, that his people should be led ayid guided into all truths and that against his Church the gates of Hell should never firevail. But, if it be impossible, that God should have so left his Church, or that his faithfulness and truth should thus have failed ; it will follow, that the Holy Spirit hath been rightly th6 object of their constant adoration, and that he himself hath inspired them with his grace to render to him this tribute of their praise. The Holy Ghost then is God. But it has been before said, and it is a principle of true religion which even the wiser sort of hea- thens have assented to,* that there is but one God. It, therefore, the scriptures inform us, that there are three distinct persons, styled Father, Son and Spirit, who have distinct offices and ener- gies in the salvation of man ; and that each of these three doth claim the power and name of the one Jehovah ; it is obvious, that they are not ofie in the same resfiect as they are three^ but that there is a real distinction in their inseparable union. One they must be essentially^ for there is but one God : Three they must also be hy/iostaiical'y or personally ; or there is neither Father, Son, nor Holy Ghost, and of course the scriptures are false. The conclusion, therefore, is plain and clear, that these three persons nve one Godhead, and that the one Godhead (if it may be said) is the common substratum of the three persons, in which they mutually and inseparably coexist, " without any difference or inequality." To express this intercommunity of the divine persons, the /J/wm/ names, ascribed to the Godhead in the He- brew Bible, appear to have been revealed ; and not honoris causa, or for the sake of dignity, as some have imagined ; because God can receive no honor from mere sounds, but only from v/hat they signify ; and he has given us not the least hint that he has used the plural number for any such purpose. And if the Godhead be one only person, with what sort of propriety is the plural number Alehim so often used, when its own singular Aloah would, in that cQse, be so much the fitter term? Besides, it is a question upon his truth, that he should call himself we and us, instead of I and ME, as he frequently doth, if he were only one person or * Selden, de Diis Syris. Prol. c. 3. To the s.ime purpose, Maximus Tv- rius, a heallien, says eloquently : " Amidst all the contx'oversy, di.scord, •' and diflerences of men, you may see one rule and opinion obtaining: " Ihroui^diout the world, That God is o7ie, tlic King- and Fatlicr of all things, « with many other Gods, his children reigning' with God. 'I'his l)otli the *• Greek and Barbarian maintain ; this is asserted by nations both near and " remote ; and in this both the wise and the ignorant ai'e agreed." Ink jilura upud Grot, de rev. lid. Christ. I 1. §■ n. 16. 22- ALEHIM, OR GOD. 43 subsistence ; and it would be representing G •>d as complimenting himself, at the expence of his veracity, in the hollow language of earthly courts and princes. To render this important point still more undeniable, it may not be improper to produce some proofs from the scripture, in addition to those offered under the name Alehim in the former volume, which may evince, that what is said of the Father, is said of the Son and Holy Gfiost without reserve or limitation, and that, therefore, they are one in essence though three in person. God alone, mediately or immediately, can raise the dead. But the Father raiseth up the dead, and guickenetii them : John V. 21. So doth the Son, whom he will: Ibid. And the Spirit raised and quickened even Christ himself from the dead. 1 Pet Jii. 18. See also Rom viii. 11. Therefore each of these three must be God. But there is but one God : And, therefore, these three are one God. Col. ii. 2. The Apostle here speaks of the rnysterij of God, and of the Father, and of Christ. Now, if the God and the Fa- ther in this place are one and the same person ; it will follow upon the same ground, that God, and the Father, and Christ, are all one and the same person ; for the same copulatives unite the one and the other. The Apostle, likewise, could not have called that a mystery (to acknowledge which the Colossians were to in- crease in faith,) which would only imply that these three names meant one and the same thing ; for this would have been playing upon terms, which is a sort of folly not to be found in God's word. But if he meant the doctrine of a Trinity, and that the Father, and Christ as to his diyinity, with another person termed God, who, from other scriptures we learn, must be God the Holy Ghost, are three persons in one Godhead ; then he might justly call it a mys- tery, because it is both a divine revelation and a matter of faith, to the acknowledgment of which it would be the riches of the full assurance of understanding to obtain. And these last words areas much a mystery to the carnal mind, as the doctrine of the Trinity can be to any mind ; but, however, not the less certain and true. Haggai ii. 4, 5. I am with you, saith Jehovah Sabaoth, with the VVord which 'ma I cut ojf (or severed; with you in bringing you forth from Egypt, and my Spirit residing in the midst of yozi., (hat 44 ALEHIM, OR GOD. xj e might not fear * In this glorious promise arc mentioned the three covenanting persons, Jehovah, the Word and the Sfiirit ; and it doth not seem improbable, that the Apostle had his eye wpon this passage, when he wrote the remarkable text of the three nvitncss^s in Hea-ven, the Father^ Word, and the Holy Ghost ; 1 John V. 7. However, in that text of Haggai there are three persons, as well as in that of St. John ; and in both the three mre one. Maith. iii. 16, 17. Here we find the Father speaking, 'This is my beloved Son, &c. — to the Son the Heavens ivere opened, and ufionhim descended, hv a. visible testimony, the S/iirit like a dove. That the Father is God is allowed by all. That the Son, for whom these words were used, is God, will appear from the se- cond Psalm and the first chapter of Heb. And that the Spirit is God, beside the proof already given, is manifest from Isaiah xi, 2. where he is expressly called the Spirit Jehovah. But there is but one God. Therefore the Father, Son, and Spirit are one God. John xiv. 23. The Father dwells in believers. Eph. iii. 17. Christ dwells in them. Rom. viii. 9. The Spirit also dwells in them. But God hath said, I will dwell in them, Sec. 2 Cor. vi. 16. * The word nnis rendered in our version, / have covenanted, is strictly, I have cut off, or severed, iind ulludes to the cutting in pieces or severing- of a clean beast before the Lord, as the instituted type, tliat Christ, the ^TfjX purifier of his people, should be so cut o^and severed, as xo be applied to then- respective use and benefit. And i.he institution of the Lord's Sup- per retains the same idea, that Christ is broken and distributed among his redeemed. The above text in tlie Pi'ophet refers to the Paschal Lamb in Exod. xii. who was sacrificed and severed, and whose blood was sprinkled upon the houses ot' the Israelites, that the vengeance of God might pass over them, and hence this Lamb was itself called the Passover, and its death the sacrifice of the LarcPs Passover ; and it was to be a memorial to them, that this _/i>5«-6o»7j Lamb (i or it was a male of the first year) was typically slain for che salvation of X\\ft first-bom among the people Israel Thus Christ our Passover was sacrificed for the first (>o^-n, wlio are called the Church of the first-bom, -whose names are luritien in Heaven ; and was the Word (here men- tioned by Haggai) ivithxvhom Jehovah -was (or as the Apostle speaks, God ■was in Christ) and whom He cut off, as t/ie first-born Lamb, -anthout spot or hleminh. to be a ransom for their deliverance from the .spu'itual Egjpt or bon- djigc ; and in tesi imony of whicli his Spirit would reside in them, that they •might not fear on account of their sins, but have everlasting consolation and good hope through grace. It IS vvortli remarking from Dr. MWji, that the Targum of Jonathan Ben Uzziel t!>e Chaldee, hatli rendered this text of Haggai ; / am with you, saith the Lord of Hosts, with the Word vy/wcA covenanted with yoti, when ye came out tf Egypt, and my Spin: which abide th in the midst of you. See Dr. Allix's Judgment of the Jewish Church, p. 358. Of tlie Targums, &c. see a clear. yet concise, accotmt in Prideaux's Connect. Part. ii. B. 8. ALEHIM, OR GOD 45 Therefore, the Father, Son and Spirit are God. Mattb. xxviii. 19. People are to be baptized in the name of the Father, Son, and Holy Ghost.* But there is only oyje Lord, as well as one faith and one bafi" tism. Eph. iv. 5. Therefore, these three are the one Lord, who is the object of this faith, and to whom his people are baptized. The following text is an invincible argument by itself ; and therefore it is not a wonder, that the adversaries of the doctrine should iittempt every means to get " well rid of it." 1 John V. 7, There are three that bear record in Heaven, the Father, the Word, and the Holy Ghost ; and these three are ONE.f 2 Cor. xiii. 14. The grace of the Lord Jesus Christ, and the love of God, and the comfminion of the Holy Ghost, be with you all, Aiyicn. But it is God who ^iveth grace. 1. Pet. v. 5. et al. Therefore Christ is God. It is the Father who loveth and bestoweth love, and he is here called God. And the communion or fcllowshifi of the Holy Ghost, must be that, by which believers have fellowship, with the Father and Son, 1 John i. 3. and which is called ye//o7£;- shift with God, in v. 6. From whence it may be inferred, that the Spirit is God ; or else the communion of the Church is with a * " This is an evident demonstration of the Spirit's Divinity ; for it can- not be believed, that to two persons, tertium quid, a third something- should be added, which might only be an operation or a quality. Noi- are \\e bap- tized in the name of any operation or grace, but in the name of God. Nor do we believe, according to the creed, in a Spirit which may not be God. And if the sin against the Holy Ghost be unpardonable; against whom bat God can such an offence be committed ?" Molenseus de uno Deo, &c. apud Thes. Sedan. Vol. i. p. 93. If the Holy Ghost m this text be nothing but a quality, there can be no reason given, why the other two names, which are coupled with it should be more : And, in that case, it was no material blun- der, which those ignorant chmxhmen made, who, instead of using the above names in Latin, baptized in nomine patria, et Jilia, et spiritusancta. iSmn. Condi, per Carranzam. p. 357. ■j- Let any unprejudiced person read the context, and he must perceive a flagrant chasm if this text be removed. It is so necessary to the Apostle's argument, that the argument is not complete without it : And it is abund- antly more likely, that these remarkable words should be left out and ob- literated in copies, made or kept by the ancient heretics, than that thev should have been foisted in by tlie orthodox, who have authorities enough beside for the doctrine expi-essed in them. If the reader would see a full investigation of this matter, let him consult the excellent Witsius, in his third E.vercit. de Sermone Dei, and the authorities cited therein. See also the Letters annexed to Sloss upon tlw Trinity. Mill ui loc. To wliicli may be added a very sensible and learned discussion in several Letters sig-ned T., ;n the Gent. Jifag-azine. iov the year 17S?. 46 ALEHIM, OR GOD. creature ; and the Apostle would bless the Church in the name of a creature, which creature he hath placed upon a line with God himself. These three persons, then, are God ; and, because the Godhead is but one, they are one God. From this unity of essence alone, can we conceive the purpose of God in denominating the Holy Spirit by various titles, which be- long to the Father and the Son, or why he is called the Spirit of the Father ; Eph. iii. 16. the Sfiirit of the Son or of Christ ; Gal. iv. 6. Phil. i. 19. the Sfnrit Jehovah or of Jehovah (which is just the same, unless it can be proved, that there is any Spirit in God, which is not himself) Is.xi. I.et al. and the Spirit Alehim ; Gen. i. 2. Being essentially one with the Father and the Son, he cannot be a different Sfiirit from them, for then there would be three Hfii- rits and three essences ; but he is essentially one and the selfsame Spirit, dividing his gifts according to his will, anci inducing faith in the souls of his people. All other people are called sensual^ not having the Spirit, wiiich is explained still further by their having no hope and being without God in the world. One argument more, instead of a multitude which might be sj-iven, shall suffice. Mai. ii. 10. Hath not 07ie God created us ? But in Eph, iii. 9. we find, that God (plainly meaning ihefath- erj created all things : In Col. i. 16 th