A Is " VINDICATION *’ OF THE CHURCH OF SCOTLAND’S INDIA MISSIONS BEING THE SUBSTANCE OF AN ADDRESS, DELIVERED BEFORE THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF THE CHURCH, ON WEDNESDAY, MAY 24, 1837. BY THE REV. ALEXANDER DUFF, D.D., THE assembly’s FIRST MISSIONARY TO INDIA. . rUBLTSHET) AT THE SPECIAL REQUEST OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY. Tenth Thousand. EDINBURGH : PRINTED AND PUBLISHED BY .JOHN JOHNSTONE, 2, HUNTER SQUARE, AND SOLD BY J. NISKET AND CO., LONDON. MDCCCXXXVII. PREFACE. I. Thk following Address, being published at the special request of the General Assembly, now appears as nearly as possible in the form in which it was originally delivered. Under two or three heads only, have a few additional sentences been inserted, in order to render the meaning less liable to misapprehension. II. In the course of a single Address, on a subject so vast and all- comprehensive, it was not possible, ever and anon, to step aside, for the purpose of pointing out all the exceptions from a general rule — or all the modifications, real or conceivable, of 2, general principle. On this account, it was my original intention to append to the Address a series of annotations, partly illustrative and partly confirmatory. But the length, to which I now find the Address, when printed, has extended, seems to forbid the realization of this intention. I must, therefore, throw myself on the candour and indulgence of the Christian reader. Conscious as I am of cherishing no desire, save that of promoting God’s glory, by the conversion of lost souls : — and entertaining, as I do, a brotherly affection towards all that love the Lord Jesus in spirit and in truth : — I shall be rejoiced to receive the friendly remarks or suggestions of any minister or member of any congregation of professing Christians in this land, relative to any of the topics introduced into the present Address. Any communication, directed to the care of the Publisher, will be sure to reach me. > III. People in this country, are ever apt to conceive of India, as if it were a mere Asiatic province of limited territorial extent, like some section of the Island of Great Britain. It is necessary, therefore, con- stantly to remind them that, in extent, India more resembles Europe than Britain : — and how much moi'e than any mere section of the latter ? Consequently, though the Brahmanical system, as elsewhere remarked, “ may be said to preserve, through the wide extent of its baneful domination, a sort of universal identity in fundamental prin- ciples, yet in tlie practical development of these principles, it may ex- hibit modifications that are endlessly or even capriciously diversified. So that what may be strictly and literally true of the mental habitudes, the social and religious practices, of the people of one city or province, iv PREFACE. may require some qualification when predicated of the inhabitants of another.” From oveilooking this essential circumstance, the state- ments of Missionaries situated in different parts of India, have some- times been pronounced, erroneous, exaggerated, distorted, or, even contradictory. Whereas the truth may be, that each may all the while be conveying a scrupulously exact Report of his own individual findings, and local experience. Would it be reasonable, for instance, on the part of a Hindu, to call in question the accuracy of any part of an account of the state of Christianity and Christian society in Edinburgh ; — on the ground of its difiering considerably from the report given to him by one man from Copenhagen ; another, from Lisbon ; and another, from Cape Matapan, in Greece ? And yet, this, in principle, is but the counterpart of the mode in which a native of Britain is sometimes led to set aside, the apparently conflicting reports of individuals, that happen to have been located, in different and distant parts of the widely scattered provinces of India. Besides, it ought to be borne in mind, that different individuals may see the same objects with different eyes. From this cause also, the reports of different observers may considerably vary, and yet one and all of them may be honest, conscientious men. Look, for instance, at the reports of different individuals relative to the practical difficulties to be encountered in attempting to evangelize such a country as India.. While some have represented them as absolutely insuperable, have not others been disposed to run into the opposite extreme of unduly lessening their real magni- tude ? And yet who can doubt that the advocates of both extremes have often been honourable men, though both must be allowed to be equally wide of the truth ? If one man, from a certain peculiarity of mind, may see things, as through a telescope, unduly magnified ; while another man, from some other peculiarity of mind, may see the same things, as through an inverted telescope, unduly diminished ; — will not the report (d the latter be as unaccordant with the reality as that of the former To imagine a mole-hill to be a mountain is no doubt a great mis- take. But to imagine a mountain to be merely a mole-hill is surely a mistake equally great. To see things less than the reality seems just as deceptive as to see them larger than the reality. Difficulties undulv magnified may scare the timorous, but will never daunt the courage of the brave. Difficulties, unduly dimi- nished, may allure the timid and leave them floundering amid unex- pected shoals and quicksands — while the brave may be deceived by the appearance of imaginary triumphs. The grand thing is, as in all other cases, to endeavour to avoid either extreme. On a subject of this nature, however, no two men can scarcely be found so .similarly circumstanced, in respect to mental powers, habits of reflection, and opportunities of observation, as to form precisely the same cstiiiaate. It is not possible, therefore, to fix any standard to which all opi vvlons can be brought for admeasurement. PREFACE. V IV. It did not fall in with the object of the following address specially to advert to the important cause of female education in the Presidency of Bengal. The author, however, may here be per- mitted to transcribe a few brief notices, written some time ago, at the request of a friend, and published in the Appendix to an adr mirable sermon of the Hon. and Bev. Baptist Noel, preached in behalf of the Society in London for promoting Female Education in China, India, and the East. , 1. While the education of males, more or less diverse in character and limited in extent, prevails pretty generally among the better classes throughout Eastern India, the education of females, from the operation of various causes, is not only almost universally ne- glected, but neglected designedly and systematically, as in itself not less mean and disreputable, than repugnant to the immemorial usages, social and religious, of the people. 2. In such an unpropitious state of things, immediate, rapid, wide-spread success in any scheme of female education, liowever skilfully devised, or vigorously prosecuted, is not to be anticipated. From the unnatural constitution of Hindu society, the education of females, in a national point of view, cannot possibly precede, cannot even be contemporaneous, with the education of males. The educa- tion of the former, on any great national scale, must, from the very nature of their position, which those only who have been in India can at all adequately, comprehend, follow in the w'ake of the en- lightened education of the latter. In a word, a generation of educated males, i. e,, educated after the European model, must be the pre- cursor of a generation of educated females. 3. Must we then, it may be asked, in the meanwhile sit still, and desist from the attempt to achieve anything in the department of female education ? No, by no means. Though great things cannot, at this moment, be undertaken, still something may be done, and tve are never to “ despise the day of small things.” Already have British example, British intercourse, and British philanthropy, ])artially broken downf in many places, the three thou- sand years’ accumulated force of native prejudice ; and female schools, for elementary e> Bengali, 35 Hindui, . 4,171 33 Hindustani, (or Urdu,) . 3,384 33 Uriya, 834 53 Persian, 1,454 53 Arabic, 36 33 Sanskrit, 16 33 This enumeration is altogether exclusive of the many valuable English publications that constantly issue from the Serampore press ; as well as of those sold at different private establishments in Calcutta. Can any proof appear more decisive of the growing taste of the natives for the English language ? From the School-Book Society’s De- pository, there issue in the two learned languages of India only 52 works ! — Arabic, 36 ; and Sanskrit, (believed to be the very language of the gods,) 16 ! — While, in the 24 English language, there is a sale of 31,649 ! — Who, after this, can pretend to doubt the accuracy of the averment respecting the rapidly increasing demand among the natives of Eastern India for the English language, and that im- proved literature and science of which it is the key ? My second statement is, that the British Government in India not only encourages the native taste for English education, but also provides to a large extent the means of obtaining it. When I last addressed this House, I specially adverted to Lord W. Bentinck’s resolution to supersede the Persian, in the political department of the public service, and ulti- mately in every other, by the substitution of English. I adverted, at the same time, to several striking facts, illus- trative of the effect of this resolution in stimulating num- bers of the higher classes of natives to the study of the English language. Little did I know that, at the very time of my addressing this House, there was, midway on its pas- sage from India to England, an edict which more than confirmed all that had ever been advanced on the subject — an edict that promises to constitute a new era in the his- tory of India. Up to the 7th March 1835, the great object of the Go- vernment schemes of education had been, to initiate the natives into a knowledge of their own literature, science, and relig'ion, through the medium of their own learned languages. By the Government enactment* of that date, this object was totally changed. It was therein decreed by the Governor-General in Council, that “ the great object of the British Government ought to be the promotion of European literature and science among the natives of In- dia ; and that all the funds appropriated for the purposes of education, would be best employed on English education alone.” This enactment has already been followed up with such rapid effect by the Committee of Public Instruction, that, within the last two years, the Government English Institu- tions in the Presidency of Bengal have been more than doubled. The number of purely Government Institutions is now heentg-seoen ; and the revenue for their sujtport exceeds £25,000 per annum. All of these, except four • See tile nature and tendency of this cimctiiient expounded at l.iruc in a |.j.iiiplilet just published hy the author, eiititkd, “ New i'.ra of tlie i'ji ,lisli J.an^uaji'e and Eiislisli Literature in India.” Printed and jiublislied by J. Johnstone, Edinburgh ; and sold by J. Ni.sbet, Bcineis Sliert, Loudon. Mahammaclan and Sanskrit Colleges, are devoted to Eng- lish education — and the funds, at present appropriated to these four, will gradually become available for the purposes of instruction in English literature and science. Some of the first established of the English seminaries, such as the Hindu Colleges of Calcutta and Delhi, have already risen to the status of Collegiate Institutions. And all the rest have been carefully planted in large central towns, with the express design of raising them, by degrees, into Colleges, with a Principal, and Professors of English composition and literature, of mathematics and natural philosophy, &c., in each. From these central institutions, as from so many radiating points, it is also intended that branch-schools shall gradually emanate — so as ultimately to pervade, with elementary instruction, every disti'ict anti village in the land. As an exemplification at once of the growing demand for English, and of the liberal manner in which Govern- ment is prepared to meet it, I shall here refer to what took place about a twelvemonth ago, in the town of Hugh, about 30 miles north of Calcutta. On the authority of the Government functionary, al- ready named, I have to state that, when, last year, the new English seminary was opened in that town, English stu- tlents flocked to it in such numbers, as to render the or- ganization of them into classes a matter of difficulty, — and tliat there are now, about 1,400 native boys, learning English onJg; about 200, learning Arabic and Persian only; and up- wards of a hundred, who are learning both English and Arabic or Persian. To this it is expressly added, that “ notwithstanding this unprecedented concourse, the ap- plications for English instruction are still extremely numer- ous ; and there seems to be no limit to the number of scholars, except the number of masters whom the (Govern ment) Education Committee is able to provide.” In another place, the same competent authority positively declares, that, “in the numerous (English) seminaries under the Education Committee, there is no want of scholars — and that the difficulty is to provide masters enough to teach the numbers who are anxious to receive instruction.” 3r/, My thud statement is, that, in order still farther to extend and perpetuate the thirst for English litei'ature and science, the Government Committee in Calcutta have recently determined to provitle the more advanced of their 2 (> English institutions with libraries of books in every depart- ment of knowledge. o This determination to provide the different institutions with libraries of English books is a truly noble one, and worthy of all commendation. In regard, however, to the jyructlcal execution of this grand design, a sense of duty compels me to make a few passing strictures. I had lately occasion, in another place, to refer to the same subject, and shall here simply' repeat what was then advanced. Had the libraries, ordered from England about a year ago, and now in all probability landed in Calcutta, “ consisted of the choicest standard works in English literatui’e and science, — so far all well. However much a Christian might regret the absence of all publications that unfold the ennob- ling doctrines and morals of Christianity, he would find some consolation in the circumstance that true literature and science had been substituted instead of a literature and science abounding with demonstrable errors. He would have to complain of an act of omission, and not of commission. But it is with pain and sorrow^ I have to ob- serve, that while the libraries in question contain some of the very best books in the English language, they also contain some of the most useless, and some too of the very worst. There are, for the younger pupils, several excellent works : — but why ransack the dust-covered book- shop of some antiquated librarian for copies of Cinderella, Puss in Boots, Jack the Giant-Killer, Tom Thumb, Little lied Riding Hood, the Devil on two Sticks, &c. ? Could this age of “ the inarch of intellect ” provide no better food for the newly-awakening minds of Hindu youth ? But all these, you will say, are simply trash and trumpery : — that is all; — as they may be said to be comparatively harmless. Well, for adults, many most admirable wmrks are provided. But there is a strange medley. If, for instance, under the general designation of “ History and Biography,” there are copies of the Bible ; placed side by side are copies of Sale’s translation of the Koran. If, under the head of “ Poetry,” there ai'e copies of Miltons works, in 6 vols. ; there are also copies of the entire w'orks of Byron, in 17 vols. If, under the head of “ Metaphysics and Moral Philo- sophy,’’ there are copies of Bacons Essays ; there arc also copies of Hume's Essays, in which the very foundations of Christianity are sapped and undermined. But why need I emimerale more ? Enough has been advanced to entitle 27 me to ask, Why this strange intermixture of light and darkness, truth and error ? Why supply the newly eman- cipated intellects of Indian youth with poison simultane- ously with wholesome food ? As if India had not already enough of wild and fantastic absurdities in the speculations of its Pantheistic metaphysicians, or enough of prurient licentiousness in the revolting legends embodied in the Ramayan, and Maha Bharat, and other Sanskrit legends, that outrage decency and common sense ; — why inundate, from the West, its rising institutions with the anti-Christian sophisms and crudities of Hume and Bentham, or the moral pestilence of Fielding and Byron ? And w'hy send forth all these productions, good, bad, and indifferent, in the name and by the authority of the British Governor-General of India — as if all were alike precious — and all alike bore the high stamp of his approbation ?” '* ■ith, My fourth statement is. That a thorough English education, apart from religious instruction altogether, is entirely subversive of Hinduism. The rationale of this I formerly explained at length, and shall not, on that account, again revert to it. The litera- ture and science of the Hindus being incorporated with their religion, if you destroy the former, which abounds with palpable errors, by the introduction of the true litera- ture and science of Europe, the foundations of the latter must be overthrown. Should this appear to any one, merely in the light of a plausible theory, let him ponder well the following unsuspicious testimonies from natives themselves, and say if they are not absolutely decisive of the question. The once Brahman, but now Christian editor of the Inquirer newspaper, who himself received his English edu- cation at the Government Hindu College, where no religion is taught, thus strongly testifies : — “ The Hindu College, under the patronage of Government, has^ as indeed it must have, destroged many a native’s belief in Hinduism. How could a boy continue to worship the sun, when he understood that this luminary was not a dcvatah, (a divi- hut a mass of inanimate matter? How could he be- lieve in the injunctions of such Shasters as taught him lessons contrary to the principles inculcated by his lecturer in natural philosophy ? The consequence was, that the Sec ail Aildfcss, recently delivered in lilxcter Hull, London, at the anniversary cl the Cliurch ot Scotlajurs Forei^ijii Missions. castle of Hinduism was battered down. Xn Missioiiari/ ci'f^r taufjht us (meaning himself, the editor,) to forsake the reli- r/iou of our fathers ; it was Government that did us this ser~ Vice. Again, the native editor of the Reformer, another English newspaper, and the organ of the educated Hindus in Cal- cutta, contrasting the results of ordinary missionary labour with those realised by the Hindu College, thus emphatically asks “ Has it (the college) not been the fountain of a new race of men amongst us ? Have oil the efforts of the Mis- sionaries given a tithe of that shock to the superstitions of the people tvhich has been given hg the Hindu College 9 This at once shews that the means they pursue to overturn the ancient reign of Idolatry is not calculated to insure suc- cess, and ought to be abandoned for another which pro- mises better success.” Whatever share prejudice, ignorance, or dislike, might have in leading the native editor to form so low an esti- mate of the fruit of onlinary missiomirg exertion, must not scepticism itself concede, that his testimony is conclusive as to the efficient power of a thorough English education in overturning the supei’stitions and idolatries of India ? 5th, Here I might pause, — satisfied w'ith having called the attention of the Christian public of this land to the all- important subjects now summarily detailed, at so early a stage of the progi’ess of events, that shall one day terminate in a mighty crisis in the history of India, — but it may be well, briefly to sum up the four preceding state- ments. There is now, more especially in Eastern India, a yearly increasing demand for English education ; and there is a strong disposition, on the part of the British Government, to encourage this demand, as well as largely to provide the means of supplying it, by the establishing of numerous English institutions, and the founding of English libraries. But a thorough English education must, everywhere, prove destructive of the systems of Hinduism. Hence, as the Go- vernment schemes of education systematically exclude re- ligion, the necessary effect of their operation must be, eveiy- where to subvert the idolatries and superstitions of the people, and then cast them adrift on the w'ide ocean of infidelity. It is worse than idle to evade this conclusion, by mei'el^’ pointing to the present limited results of such a system. Why are these results, at present, so limited ? Simply because the sphere of operation of those plans, that inevitably lead to them, is as yetsocontracted. Anditis justbecausethissphere is as yet so circumscribed; it is just because the processes of change ar« as yet only coming into action, at the am- iiienceinent n transition siaiQ', it is just because, on that very account, it is, as yet, quite possible, through God’s blessing, to overtake a movement that will be ever progres- sive in a sphere ever widening ; — that I feel so intensely anxious to rouse and direct the attention of British Chris- tians to the present extraordinary state of things in India. The Hindu College of Calcutta, from having reached maturity, has already given a tremendous shock to the systems of Hinduism. And, as “ like causes will, in similar circumstances, produce like effects,” are we not constrained to admit that the other institutions, similar to the Hindu College of Calcutta, planted in various central stations throughout India, will, in the course of tinie, produce iden- tical results ? I say, “in the course of time,” with emphasis, because I would not be the author, or the victim, of Utopian visions. The vast importance of the subject must plead my apology for repeating liere, what 1 have asserted elsewhere, vifc., that I do “ not anticipate sudden, instantaneous, uni- versal changes. But I do look forward, with confidence, to a qrecd idtimate revolution in the social and religious struc- ture of Hindu society, — I do regard the Government enactment, already referred to, as laying the foundation of a train of causes which may, for a while, operate so insen- sibly as to pass unnoticed by careless or casual observers, but not the less surely, as regards the great and momentous issue. Like the laws which silently, but with resistless power, regulate the movements of the material universe, the present educationary operations, which are of the na- ture and force of moral laws, will proceed onwards till they terminate in effecting a decisive change in the national mind of India.” But, let it never be forgotten, that, as the Government schemes of education uniformly exclude religious instruc- tion, this may only be a change from a stagnant superstition to a rampant infidelity. What then is to be done ? Are the Christians of Great Britain to stand idly aloof, and view the onward march of the spirit of innovation in the East, as unconcerned and indifferent spectators. Forbid it, gracious Heaven ! What 30 then is to be done ?\ Why, if we are faithful to our trust, and wise in time, we may. through the blessing of God, be honoured in converting the education plans of the Indian Government into auxiliaries, that may lend their aid in pre- paring the way for the spread of the everlasting Gospel ! Wherever a Government Seminary is founded, which shall have the effect of demolishing idolatry and supersti- tion, and thereby clearing away a huge mass of rubbish ; there, let us be prepared to plant a Christian institution, that shall, through the blessing of Heaven, be the in- strument of rearing the beauteous superstructure of Chris- tianity on the ruins of all false philosophy and false reli- gion. Wherever a Government library is established, that shall have the effect of creating an insatiable thirst for knowledge; there, let us be forward in establishing our depositories of Bibles and other religious publications, that may satui'ate the expanding minds of Indian youth, with the life-giving principles of eternal truth. And who can tell whether, in this way, by “ redeeming the time” — by s&\zmgX\ie present golden opportunitg — we may not be privileged to behold, all the Government schemes of educational improvement in India, overruled by a gracious superintending Providence, for the ultimate introduction of Messiah’s reign ? VI. From having formerly said so much on the power of useful knowledge in destroying the systems of Hinduism, it has been strangely concluded by some, that our object has been to reform the natives of India, by means of “knowledge without religion.” Need I say that no conclusion could possibly be more un- founded? It is, indeed, most true that, for reasons which have more than satisfied many of the wisest and most devoted Chris- tians in this land, I have, with uniform and persevering earnestness, advocated the universal diffusion of sound knowledge in India. Not contented with seeing such knowledge ooze out in scanty drippings, I have toiled and laboured, in conjunction with others, to pour it out in copious streams that may, one day, cover the whole land with the swelling tide of reason and intelligence. This, however, happens to be only one-half ol any state- ment that I have ever, anywhere, made on the subject. And what right has any one, in reason or in justice, 31 to fasten on one-half a statement, and deal with that half, as if it were the whole ? Strongly and sincerely as I have pled for the diffusion of sound general knowledge in India; — have I not, on every occasion, insisted as strongly on the cotemporaneous diffu- sion of religious tridh ? Have I not even laboured to de- monstrate that, for the best interests of man in time and eternity, the former should ever be. based on the latter — per- vaded with the spirit of it throughout — and made to termi- nate in its exaltation and supremacy? Have I not ever con- tended for the holy and inseparable alliance of both ? — for the reciprocal inter-blendingoftheir different, thoughnotun- congenial, influences? And if one or other must have the precedency, either as respects priority of time or dignity of position, in the mighty work of regenerating a corrupt world ; — in the name of all that is reverend and just, let that be selected for the honour, which, by inherent supe- riority and excellence of nature, is pre-eminently entitled to it. Without “ useful knowledge ” man might not live so comfortably in time ; without “ divine knowledge ” eternity must be lost. How then, could the Missionaries of the Church of Scotland — the Missionaries of a Church, first loosened from Popery by the Wisharts and Hamiltons, sub- sequently established by the Knoxes and Melvilles, and on- wards perpetuated by the Rutherfords and Halyburtons ; — how could we dare to sacrifice, at the shrine of a spurious liberality, that highest and sublimest knowledge, whose ennobling truths many of these worthies so heroically died to testify ? — Or, if we dared thus to act the part of degene- rate childr^, how could we abide the piercing glance of rebuke which they would cast upon us, if recalled from the realms of day, to witness our treacherous cowardice ? .\nd how might we not feel, even now, as if their very ashes would speak out of the tomb, and their blood from under the altar cry out against us ! Such, indeed, and so strong, are my own convictions of the vast importance of useful knowledge in the great work of reforming India, that — were this Venerable House to for- bid the diffusion of it in connection with its own Mission — I for one, would feel myself, however reluctantly, constrain- ed at once to relinquish the honourable position which it has been pleased to assign to me. But such, and so over- whelming, are n>y convictions of the immeasurably supe- 32 rior importance, of that higher knowledge, which unseals the fountain of Immanuel’s love, that, — sooner than con- sent wilfully to withhold it for an hour from the famish- ing millions of India, or of any other land, in deference to the noxious theories of certain propagandists of the present day, — I would lay down my head upon the block, or com^ mit this body to the flames ! I feel assured, however, that, so far as this House is con- cerned, it will never fall into either of these extremes. Notwithstanding the charges of religious bigotry that have been so profusely heaped upon it, this House, like its noble reforming ancestry, has been, is now, and, I trust, ever will be, the consistent, the enlightened advocate of all really useful knowledge throughout the wide domain of families, schools, and colleges, whether in this, or in other lands. And, notwithstanding the charges of secular convergency that have been as abundantly levelled at it, this House, like its noble reforming ancestry, has been, is now, and, I trust, ever will be, the intrepid, the unbending advocate of a thorough Bible instruction, as an essential ingredient in all sound education, w'hether on the banks of the Forth, or on the banks of the Ganges. Yea, may I not be permitted with emphasis to add, that, sooner than consent to surrender this vital principle, which is one of the main pillars in the palladium of the Protestantism of these realms, this House is prepared, as in times of old, to submit to dissolution by the strong arm of violence? — and its members, like their Fathers of the Covenant, prepared once more to betake themselves to the dens and caves of the earth — to wander by the lonely shore or over the desert heath, — to climb the mountain-steep for refuge, or secretly assemble to worship in “ some deep deli by rocks o’ercanopied ? ” Let it, then, ever be our distinguishing glory to arbitrate between the advocates of untenable extremes. Let us, on the one hand, disowm the bigotry of an unwise pietism, by resolving to patronise to the utmost, as in times past, the cause of sound literature and science — lest, by our negli- gence, in this respect, we help to revive the fatal dogma of the dark ages, that what is philosophical!}' true, may yet be allow’ed to be theologically false. And let us, on the other hand, denounce the bigotry of infidelity, or religious indifference, by resolving to uphold the paramount import- ance of the sacred oracles, in the great w'ork of Christianiz- ing and civilizing a guilty w'orld. 33 Let ns, thus hail trile literature and true science as our very best auxiliaries — whether in Scotland, or in India, or in any other quarter of the habitable globe. But, in receiv- ing these, as friendly allies, into our sacred territory, let us resolutely determine, that they shall never, never, be allow- ed to usurp the throne, and wield a tyrant’s sceptre over it. VII. It has been alleged that, in the former statement, there seemed to be something like a denial of what has been well styled by Owen and others, the “ self-evidencing power” of the Bible. If this were the proper time for a theological discussion, I think I might hold myself pledged to prove, to the satis- faction of all reasonable minds, that this is one of the most groundless of charges. 1 did indeed speak, as I must ever do, not only of the number, but of the peculiarity of those difficulties and obstacles that impede the dissemination of divine truth, in a country like India. Many of these are of such a nature, that they admit of being removed by an ordinary application of ordinary means. Are we not, therefore, bound, as creatures endowed with reason and judgment, to employ these means — looking all the while to Heaven for the blessing, which alone can insure success ? And how can the prayerful employment of such means be said, in any legitimate sense, to interfei'e with the self-evi- dencing power of the Word of God ? Look at the Saviour of mankind at the tomb of Lazarus. Could he not, by one word of his mouth, have caused the great stone to be removed from the mouth of the sepul- chre ? Beyond all doubt he could. But the removal of the stone was within reach of the power of the assembled multitude. Accordingly, did he not command them to re- move it? There was that, however, which the assembled multitude could not achieve. Neither their voice, nor the united voice of all the myriads of mankind since the time that Adam fell, could restore life unto him who lay putri- fying in the grave. The voice of the Son of God alone could have given efficacy to the command : — “ Lazarus, come forth.” — By this word of power alone could the iron fetters of the tomb have been burst asunder. So, in India. If there are any obstacles that seem, in particular cases, to interpose between the souls of men, and the direct application of any of the means of grace ; — ought we not, humbly and prayerfully, to apply ourselves to the S4 removal of these obstacles ? And if so, how can our at- tempting to remove them, be said to impugn the glorious truth, that “ the Word of God” is fraught with a self- evidencing power, and is the alone efficacious instrument in awakening and regenerating a guilty and polluted soul ? I rejoice in believing, as in publicly declaring, that “ the Word of God” has lost nought of that tremendous power by which it pierceth to “ the dividing asunder of soul and spirit, joints and marrow” — nor the sword of the spirit, aught of its keen and etherial temper — and that, when the Spirit of God powerfully worketh through the instrument- ality of “ the Word of God,” every shred of opposition must be dissipated, even though “principalities and domi- nions” should league with the powers of earth in the fruit- less effort to resist. I rejoice in believing, that, unlike many of the gorgeous, but short-lived, forms of error, divine truth — as revealed in the Bible — is still destined to shine before an astonished world, in its beauty and strength ; — that it will scatter to the winds of heaven all the doubts and fears and irresolution of man ; — that it will infuse that spirit of divine heroism, which, even in the view of excruciating- torments, can resent, with holy scorn, every wretched and cowardly compromise ; — that it will finally stalk over the grave of its opponent error — and, if required, in fulfilment of the purposes of an all-wise Providence, once more cause the blood of martyrs to become “ the seed of the Church” — and, in its glorious triumphs, run parallel with eternity. All this, and much more, I rejoice in believing, so far as concerns the capabilities of that Wox-d, which is emphati- cally termed, “ the Sword of the Spirit,” — and the possi- bilities within the range of a gracious Providence. And yet I see not how all this can abstract one “jot or tittle” from the piety, the wisdom, the propriety on our part, of attempting to imitate the Omniscient God himselt, by de- voutly endeavouring to adapt all our means, to the accom- plishment of all our ends. VIII. It has been alleged that, in the former statement, there was not a sufficiently explicit reference to the indis- pensable agency of the Holy Spirit, in the great work of evangelizing a lost world. My own impression was, and still is, that the distinct recognition of this indispensable agency did pervade the whole of the address, formerly delivered before this Assent- 35 bly. And had I, for one moment, even suspected that I had not adequately acknowledged what, with my whole heart and soul, I believe, — that is, our entire and unquali- fied dependence on the influence of the Holy Spirit, for a saving efficacy on all the means of grace — our entire and unqualified dependence on the influence of the Holy Spirit, for the rise, progress, and final consummation of true reli- gion in the soul of man, — I could not have given sleep to my eyes, nor slumber to my eyelids, till I had silenced the upbraidings of conscience by the freest, fullest, and most unreserved acknowledgments, which language would enable me to express. And now, if I only knew how to represent the strength of my own convictions on this most vital sub- ject, in terms proportionally strong, or in ternfs less liable to misapprehension than those previously employed, most cheerfully would I do it. I believe, that there is a spiritual deadness in the soul, which will yield to no power^ save the life-giving energy of the Spirit of God. I believe, that there is a depth of depravity in the soul, which can never be re- moved, except by the sanctifying influence of the Holy Spirit. I believe, that there is a thick darkness in the soul, which no mere human expedient can ever dispel — and that the omnipotence of the Divine Spirit alone, can enkindle it with the splendours of heavenly light. IX. It has been alleged that disparagement was formerly cast on “ the preaching of the Gospel” to the natives of India. So far is this allegation from being well-founded, that I ask any man, whether friend or foe, carefully to peruse the former statement, and then say, whether it be not in posi- tive contradiction to many of its most explicit passages.* But, if the charge of disparaging the divine ordinance of “ preaching” in itself, be not only untenable, but prepos- terously unfounded — it is still objected that I appear to have “ poured contempt” on the preaching of Europeans to the natives of India, through the medium of their own lan- guage. • See second edition, ]). 2G-28, wliere there is an elaborate attempt to prove the necessity of remkrin^ the administration of the ordinance o/'“ preaching ” more adequate, e^cient, a/ul perfect, than it has ever yet heen in' India — 'as well as the necessity of multiplying the number of duly qualified lyreuchers'' a hundred, oi even a thousand-fold." C 36 Nothing that has ever issued from m}' lips, on this sub- ject, can be fairly alleged to merit the strong appellation of “ pouring contempt.” If, indeed, the adduction of evi- dence from the analogy of past history, and the known capabilities of the human mind and its external organs, to prove, what most reflecting persons would be disposed to reckon a mere truism, viz., the comparative superiority of natives over foreigners, both being alike quailed, in respect to natural and spiritual endowments, when addressing their own countrymen in their own language ; — if this be designated, however unjustly, the “ pouring of contempt ” on the foreigner’s exhibition as compared with that of the dfdg qucdijied native — I cannot help it. This is merely the statement of a plain historical fact. And the general fact being an uncontrovertible one, I must, — for the sake of truth, for the sake of India, for the sake of a benighted world, — persevere, in openly and fearlessly proclaiming it. And, if the whole “ head and front of my offending ” in this matter has been, that I have jAainlg spoken out what the consciences and experience of hundreds must pronounce to be true, whether they openly avow it or not; — may I not, for the sake of advancing the real prosperity of mis- sions throughout the world, be permitted to rejoice in the liberty of speech that has been given me ? — Cheerfully willing, to bear my own lull share of the disgrace, if dis- grace it really be, of not )n’etending to rival, far less out- rival the learned natives of India, or of any other land, either in a perfect knowledge of the peculiarities of idiom, or a perfect enunciation of (dl the peculiarities ot sound, which may characterize their varied dialects and languages ! — Cheerfully willing, to submit to the discredit, if discredit it really be, of not pretending to rival, far less out-rival, the natives of India, or of any other country, in the physical capability of withstanding tlie influence ot climate, or in a perfect acquaintance with all the manners, customs, feelings, sentiments, habits of thought, and prejudices that may dis- tinguish its varied tribes and families ! And here, I must protest against the validity ot one very common mode of impeaching the accuracy ot the general rule, as at present announced. It is based on one ot the grossest of fallacies, — even that which converts a splendid exception from a general I’ule, into a sjilcndid example of a general rule. To illustrate what I mean. ’Fliat females nve not equal to 37 men in military courage, is surely the general rule. Now, how can this be said to be disproved, by pointing to such a dazzling example as that of the celebrated Maid of Oi*- leans, whose feats of heroism outshone, in brilliancy, the entire martial prowess of France ? So, in like manner, if the general rule be, as I have represented it, that foreigners are not on a level with duly qualified natives, in the style, manner, and effect of their address, — how can this rule be said to be invalidated, by quoting one or more examples from past or present times, in which a learned foreigner may have rivalled, or even out-rivalled, a learned native? Moreover, if this be the general rule, as to the subject now under review, may 1 not ask : — Is it wise to make it the general rule to fight against it? Rather, is it not the dictate of wisdom, is it not the demand of duty, so to adjust our plans as to have the general rule on our side ? — ready to rejoice, at the same time, at the appearance of any splendid exception, which an overruling Providence may cause to be manifested, for the benefit of any tribe, or peo- ple, or nation ? And what is this but, in other words, to describe one grand leading department in the great Missionary enter- prise of this Church ? Believing the field to be “ the world,” we have gone forth on a voyage of mercy and benevolence, — and shall not reckon our task accomplished till we have circumnavigated the globe. For reasons, potent and ma- nifold, we made the metropolis of British India, the first point of disembarkation. Do you, then, wish to see the millions of India, awakened, regenerated, saved? And is it worse than chimerical to attempt to reach and reclaim all of these millions, by the direct bmuediate exertions of a mere handful of foreign agents, — labouring under countless dis- advantages ? Well, to meet the fearful exigency, and, as speedily as possible, consummate the glorious end, have we not resolved, in humble dependence on divine grace, to rear up “ a school of prophets,” or religious teachers, who shall diffuse the light and life of Christian knowledge, throughout the length and breadth of the land ? And rest we never shall, till, through the divine blessing, we behold arising, a band of native labourers, who, mightily endowed with the acquisitions of sound knowledge, and, above all, with the gifts and graces of the Holy Spirit, shall become preachers of the everlasting Gospel to the perishing mil- lions of their own countrymen, — thespiritual Reformers, — 38 aye, and I will add, — the Luthers, and the Calvins, and the Knoxes of Hindustan I * X. It has sometimes been impatiently asked, — What, after all, have you done towards the attainment of the pro- posed objects ? — And the question is usually followed up, by a significant reference to the alleged meao-reness of the ^ ® • O O Committee’s reports. I do not appear here, this day, as the advocate of the Committee. Should the occasion require it, they are far more able to defend their own proceedings, than I am. But I do feel it to be incumbent on me this day, in the spon- taneous and independent exercise of my own judgment, publicly to declare, that the expectations of many amongst us are worse than unreasonable. These, first of all, look at the numerous monthly and quarterly papers, and voluminous annual reports of the great Societies in England. And then, turning round, they ask with an air of affected surprise. Why does not your Committee furnish similar papers and reports? — Why! — iust because you loithhold the means of enabliny them to do so. * Let it not be sui)posed tliat I look for the immediate appearance of sveh a race of men in India. No. But I do look for their apix;arancc ultimately. And in order to prepare and hasten the state of things that shall ?iurse and rear sucli men, I would now, the more dilijjently, employ all tho^e ([uickeninp; means which God, in times past, has been pleased to bless. God, in mercy to India, 7nay raise up such men sooner than the most sanguine amongst us can anticipate. But, judging from the experience of past ages, I should not hesitate to say, that such men can scarcely be expected to arise during tlie present, iterhaps not even during the next, genera- tion. There must be a be'^imvt!^ 72mv. Young men, instructed and trained in our Christian Institutions, will, of necessity, shoot very far a-hcad of their i)rcdecessors. — But the children of these educated natives will possess such paodigious advantages over their fathers, that they, in their turn, may rise to still greater eminence, — both in staldlity of character and reach of attainments. For it must be borne in mind, that there is an educatim (f habit acquired, from constant intercourse in an advanced state of society, which no mere eommwiicatiou of knmvted^e can ever bestow. For the pretent, therefore, from the infantile state of improvement in India, the judgment, and energy, and mature experience of enlightened Luropeans are indisihiiisably necessary for superintendence and control, — and tliis necessity may continue for one or more generations yet to come.' But, are we, on this account, to conclude that the necessity must continue for ever? Because, in times past, the natives of India, owing to the multiform disadvantages under which they laboured, have been inef- fective, without the watchful guidance of Ilurojieans ; are we, therefore, to conclude that they must continue to be so, in all time coming? Because, owing tothc.se disadvantages, they have been enabled to achieve little or nothing, c.ieept in the leading strings of Europeans ; arc wc, thei'tfore. to conclude that they must abide in a state of pupilage and imbecility for ever ? No. Such a conclusion were not only unwarranted, but in direct contrariety to many of the lessons of jiiist history. M'c m.iy rest assured that the very same means, which have raised the desccmlants of the ancient Britons into such itre-eminence above their savage aiicestoi's, will, if vigor- ously applied, ultimately raise the sons of India into corrcsiwnding pre-eminence above their father.s. Ours, then, be the task, — the noble task, — of beginning now, and putting into oi)cration those means that shall ultimately uplift the natives of India, to the stature of perfect men, in social, intellectual, and spiritual attainments 1 Then will they be independent of the marshdliug shill of JEuropeans. 39 Think of the doings of the respected body of Wesleyan Methodists. In numbers, fewer; in wealth, vastly inferior to the Church of Scotland ; — how much, think you, do they contribute annually to the cause ol their foreign missions — Upwards of £76,000 ! — While the Church of Scotland seems to reckon it a mighty matter to contribute £5000 ! In the City of Edinburgh, the Wesleyan body is almost unnoticed and unknown, — and yet, they raise upwards of £500 for sending the light of the Gospel to heathen lands ! — a sum nearly equal to that raised by the National Church of Scotland, in its own metropolis, for the support 01 its own mission to the regions of pagan darkness ! Notwithstanding all our recent improvement on the score of liberality, as compared with former years, I would ask, in the presence of the assembled representatives of this National Church, whether such a statement is not enough to put us all to shame ? — and whether it is not true, that, far from having unsealed, we have not as yet disturbed the very margin of the fountain-heads of Christian benevolence in this land ?* And if the people of Scotland withhold the means, how can they reasonably expect to hear of extensive labours and mighty results? The Church of England, and Wesleyan, and London, and Baptist Missionary Societies, with their princely revenues, are able to establish numei’ous stations in almost all parts of the world, and maintain hundreds of Mis- sionaries. The bare enumeration of all their stations, and missionaries, and churches, and schools, would form a document of considerable bulk. I put it, then, to the com- mon sense of all present, whether it be reasonable to expect our Committee, with their limited means, and handful of labourers, to rival these great societies in the voluminous- ness of their reports ? — and whether such expectation be not akin to the exaction of the tyranny that commanded “ brick to be made without straw?’’ Only supply your Com- mittee with the necessary means, and, through God’s bless- • J.ct not this conclusion he evaded by referring: to tlie ciTorts lately made in the cause of “ Chuich Extension” in ScoUand. 'I'hesc have been great, when compared with the total negligence of former years ; — but the neeessities of the case demand that they should be greater still 1 Have not the Methodists liad their cause of Church Extension too ? Have they not had to build all their own Churches, maintain all their own ministers, establish and support all their own schools? And yet, in aikli- lion to all this at home — the aggregate of which vastly surpasses what the jicopie of Scotland have ever yet done in the cause of Church and School Extension — the iMethodists contribute upwards of ,-€70,000 annually for the propagation of the Gosjh;! abroad 40 ing, they will be enabled amply to repay you with a re- dundancy of reports, abounding with the richest variety of interesting details. I cannot, therefore, allow the notion to be entertained for a single moment, that the Reports of your Committee, so far as the hare statement of facts is concerned, do not keep pace with the effoi’ts of your benevolence. Your Missionaries in India, fearful, perhaps to excess, of raising expectations that may never be realised, often suppi’ess many a narrative, glowing with promise, but stopping short of the announce- ment of actual fruit. And, even in their report of the ap- pearance of actual fruit, they have never been disposed to make the most of the results announced. Facts, the most important, illustrative of the operation of great principles, are often put forth in naked brevity. Facts, which might furnish the text of many a lecture, are often embodied in as many words or short sentences, as, in the hands of some, would call forth the lengthened commentary of whole pages. Besides, in o]’der rightly to estimate what has been done, people ought to be able to estimate aright the vast dispro- portion between the agency employed, and the almost overwhelming difficulties to be at first surmounted. But who that has not been in India — or, who that has been there, but has not travailed in pain for the regeneration of her children — can form an adequate estimate of the nature and number of those antagonist prejudices and supersti- tions which, in durability and magnitude, seem to rival the munitions of rocks ? To confront this terrible array in the midst of hostile millions, what was the opposing agency employed ? For nearly two years the National Church of Scotland equipped and maintained in the field only one labourer ! What a spectacle in the eye of the Christian world ! Can imagina- tion itself conceive a situation more pitiable and seeming- ly more helpless? Is it not enough to remind one of Hall’s celebrated remark respecting the lonely willow tree, that reared its drooping head, in the midst of a naked desolated common ? — That it looked like nature hanging out a signal of distress ! Think of a whole National Church sending forth, to the distance of ten thousand miles, one raw and inexperienced labourer, to stand solitary and alone amid the boundless arid wastes of heathenism ! — and say, if it did not look 41 more like the Church hanging out a sig'ual of distress, than bravely unfurling her banners for the spiritual conquest of the nations ! At length an additional fellow-labourer did arrive. And though a third has since followed; and ere long a fourth is to leave the British shores ; — still, in point ot fact, the original ground at Calcutta, has never yet been occupied by more than two at one time! Now, when we compare the fruits already reaped by your fii’St Missionaries, with those at first reaped by others in the very same field — instead of lamenting that more has not been done, the throne of grace ought to be approached by all our churches, with the voice of praise and thanksgiv- ing to the Father of Spirits, for the favour and countenance vouchsafed towards his feeble unworthy seiwants. On the authority of Mr Townley, one of the first and ablest of the Missionaries of the London Society, I assert that, in the province of Bengal, the first agents of three great Societies —the Church of England, the London, and the Baptist — laboured in pain and weariness for seven long years, ere they were privileged to admit a single convert into the bosom of the Christian Church ! But, long before the expiry of half that period, through God’s blessing on the labours of your Missionaries, several educated natives of respectable families, and one of them a Brahman of the highest caste, were led to bend the knee at the name of Jesus — to adopt the badge of discipleship at the sacred font of baptism — to sit down with British Christians, in sweet fellowship at a communion-table, and there partake of the emblems of the Lord’s broken body and shed blood. And what though, fi'om peculiar circumstances over which we had no control, one and another of those, who received the first impulse towards Christianity from your Missionaries, may have been admitted into the communion of a branch of the Christian Church different from our own, — shall we not rejoice, if they have been rescued as brands from the burning, and their names written in the Lamb’s book of life, even though they should be unre- gistered in the Missionary Records of this chui'ch ? Yes, verily, we have rejoiced, and shall still rejoice, with exceed- ing great joy. And, in the name of this Venerable House, let me disown and denounce the worse than anti-Christian bigotry, that would rather not see immortal souls saved at all, than not see them saved as the proselytes of a sect. 42 At the time your mission was established at Calcutta, the minds of numbers of the most promising of the edu- cated natives, from the operation of the Government sys- tem of education without religion, were either turned, or rapidly turning, into the channels of infidelity. Was it nothing to have succeeded, through God’s blessing, in arresting a torrent that threatened ultimately to inundate the land with the horrors of irreligious anarchy ? — Nothing, to have x’endered the very name of Atheism a term of loathing and reproach, instead of being, as it was, the rallying watchword of a wild and reckless liberalism ? — Nothing, to have aroused hundreds to read, search, medi- tate, and inquire into the evidences and doctrines of the Christian faith ? — Nothing, to have infused a wholesome leaven into the corrupt mass that has been fermenting ever since, and will go on spreading till India become the Lord’s ? — Nothing, to have been instrumental, through God’s blessing, in leading some of the very ringleaders in this nascent conspiracy against the Lord and his Anointed, to fall down as humble penitents at the foot of the cross ? Was all this nothing ? Aftd yet not a tithe of the details connected with these happy results can ever appear in the reports of your Committee. Again, was it nothing to have succeeded, through the divine blessing, in establishing, within so very limited a pei'iod, a large Christian institution, — which, for the num- ber and respectability of its pupils, the efficiency of their intellectual discipline and moral training, and the nature and extent of their combined acquirements, literary, scien- tific, and theological, has been pronounced by impartial judges to be without a rival, from the lofty Himalaya to Cape Comorin ? — An institution, which the highest and most competent authority in the land, the Governor- General of British India, publicly declared to have produced “ unparalleled I'esults ! ” Besides its direct and immediate results in destroying, in the minds of hundreds, the combined powers of igno- rance and prejudice, idolatry and superstition, and substi- tuting the ennobling principles of true literature, science, and Christian theology instead — look at the number of problems, fraught with the most momentous bearings on the future destinies of India, which it has helped triumphantly to solve ! Was it nothing, for example, by means of the unrivalled 43 success with which God had been pleased to crown h, to have demolished the bugbear ot’alleged impracticability, as regards the attendance of respectable natives, for a series of years, on a Christian Institution — and to have confounded the so- phistical reasonings of hollow expediency, on the score ot non-interference with the religious prejudices of the na- tives ? — Nothing, to have paralysed the arm of opposition — to have satisfied scepticism itself — and to have converted the suspicions of craven cowardice into unbounded confi- dence ? — Nothing, to have given a higher tone to the sen- timents of many of the most influential British residents, on the essential constituents of sound education — to have infused a new and better spirit into some of the older sys- tems — to have generated the desire of remodelling some that were beginning to become effete ? — Nothing, to have given such an accelerative impetus to the cause ot native instruction, that scores of seminaries have already been established, that otherwise would never have seen the light of day* — and finally, to have provided many of these new seminaries, with duly qualified native teachers, that have received an intellectual, moral, and religious training in your central Institution? And if, as a learned gentleman opposite, j- and zealous friend of every Christian enterprise, lately remarked, with admirable point and truth: — If “the schoolmaster be the school — in other words, if the minds of the pupils, laith- fully reflecting their master’s image, must ever be cast in the form and mould of his opinions : — Who can estimate — who can sufficiently magnify the amount of wholesome influence which the Assembly’s Missionai\v Institution, viewed as a grand Normal Seminary for the training of teachers, is likely to exert on the future destinies of India ? Last of all, — Was it nothing, in the metropolis of such an • “ Ifow iitaneroiis,'’ i-ciiiarks Mr Trevelyan, in an address to tlic friends of Education in India, on tlie inlluencc of example, “ how mimeriAts arc the instances in u iiich visitors to the General Assembly’s celebrated Academy liave caught the .s|)irit of tlic plan, and been induced, on their return to their respective districts, to form the nucleus of similar institutions! ” Besides these, there are now, as recorded in the Committee’s Reports, several Branch-Schools in immediate connection with the Central Institution, Calcutta. 'I’he lar;jest and most a