Church Record Series, No. 2. DIVES AND LAZARUS Six Studies By WALTER C. WHITAKER Rector of Christ Ciiurch, Tuslcaloosa, Ala. ^ :B52418 W578 Tuskaloosa, Ala THE CHURCH RECORD I 898 ^ PRINCETON, N. J. ^ Division Section ...A.;...*^.... Church Record Series, No. 2. DIVES AND LAZARUS Six Studies WALTER C. WHITAKER Rector of Christ Church, Tuskaloosa, Ala. Tuskaloosa, Ala THE CHURCH RECORD 1838 CONTENTS. I. The Ground of Judgment. I Thi Key to the Parable ... - - 2 Dives not a Gross Character ... - 3 ' p:;arthly Accidents and Eternal Character - 4 Selfishness Blind to Stewardship - - - 5 II. The State ok the Dead. 7 The Continuance of Personality - - - - 8 Each Soul Goes to Its Own Place ... 9 The Intermediate State 10 III. The Nature of Eternal Punishment, - - - 12 Recognition after Death - - - - 12 Hell Internal not External - - - 14 God's Judgment Infallible - - - - 16 IV. Eternal Hope. --- 17 The Chasm between Life and Death - - - 17 "The Spirits in Piison" • - - - 20 Prol)ation Precedes Death - - - - yi y. The Continuance of Affection. - . - - 32 Dead Roots ?nd Dying Branches - - - 22 Degrees of Punishment - - • - 24 Intercessory Prayer in Paradise - - - 25 VI. Evidence and Conviction. .-....- 27 The Impotence of Miraclts - - - - 27 The Testimony of Revelation - - - • 30 DIVES AND LAZARUS, PART FIRST. The Ground Of Judgment, Tlierc; was a certain rich man, which was clothed in purple and fine linen, and fared sumptuously every day. And there was a certain lieggar named I.azarus, which was laid at his gate, full of sores, and y the story of the ten talents, impresses on us the necessity of using our advantages. It is not of great importance whether the present narrati\e be looked upon as liistorv or as parable. The saiue lessons are yielded in either case 1 he popular view, however, may tiie more convenientlv be adopted. At the outset of these studies we must hold clearlv in DiVKS AXD LAZARirs. xic'W tl;c nature of panibles. Parables are cartoons; not caricatures but pictorial sketclies. As sucli thev teach one central idea to which all details are subordinate. I>ut in parables, as in all well-executed cartoons, every minor frai^- ment has a meaninjj. the disregard of which weakens the pictm-e. and the inti'.rpretation of which must be in harmony with the central teachintr. TiiK l\.i;y TO THK I'akaiu.k. The names of the two personaf^ros of the narrative J^ive the key to the parable. Their names sinnienl ix'sult from a i)rc\ioiis refusal to hear his preachinti^? Tlie s-pirils ;;onin prison arc t'ie very souls that tlie Spirit of the Son of (rod acting through Noah, a .preacher of rii^hteousness, had in vain c.aHetl Id repentance while the Ark was a-preparing. This sarelv is a rational interpretation, and it is in thorough ac- cord with other undisputed facts. The sacred reconl tells us that Christ went into l\u-adise after his Crucilixion. Christ jioniised that he would be in Paradise with the ])enitent malefactor. W'e find no such promise of his in- tended [)resence with the impenitent. l*K()i5A'no.\ Preckdks Dkatu. Christ".-, explicit statement is tiiat men shall be judged ac- cording to the deeds done "in the flesh."' Deeds done in tile tlesh must be done in this w(udd. Wliat is done after the flesh is laid aside sliall not be the criterion of eternal existence. The opportunitv for repentance is expressly limited to this world. They who to into the unseen world unprepared for com- munion with Christ shall find no agency there to prepare them. Every opj)(>rtunity and every incenti\'e possible io (jod is gi\en and addeil in this world. Earth was the theatre of our Creation; it must be the phice of our Re- (.lemption. God himself appeals to men to say whetljcr the\- can imagine greater deterrents froni evil and inciteinents to good than are furnished in this life. *'0 inhabitants of Jerusalem and men of Judah. judge. I pray you, betwixt me and my \ineyard. What could have been dtme nu;rc to my \ineyard, that I have not done in it?"' — W'liat more, indeed, than tlie giving of his Son to die forr.s? And God announces his determination : 'T will com- mand the clouds tliat they rain no rain upon it."' Since tlie life is grotesque and lawless, let life cease, and let deso iation and death reign. Rejection en earth, (h;d"s pro^ing ground, is eternal rejection. PARI FIFTH, '[he Continuance of Affection. •'Then he said, I pray thee tlu'reforf, father, lh.it thou woulde.-t semi him to my father's liou.e; for 1 hive five hretliroii; that ht- may ti'slify unto them, lest they also come into this plac of torment." — -Sy. Lu.ke i6:2j ami 3S. Mcii luuc drawn very diverse conclusions from tlu- rich man's prayer for his brotliers. Some have :ir(rued that the prayer is iiicom[iatible with total depravity ; that it shows a residutim of love which jjfives ve for (Jod; that tinder the moving power of that love it may repent, and at tlie last be literally saved by the fire of age-long torment. Others have argued, with sadder ingenuity, that the prayer of the rich man 's the prayer of total depravity; that it no- where indicates unselfish care for others; tluit it clearly is the petition of one tha.t fears that his own miserv shall be increased by the eternal reproaches of those over whom he ])ad exercised evil influence on earth. It is overlooked by both classes, who reach sucli dift'erent conclusions from the common assumption that total dej)rav- itv is necessary to eternal loss, that th'.- assumption on which their arguntents are reared has no probability in its favor, is supported by no analogy of nature, is not deduci- ble from anv revelation from God. Dead Roots ani> D^ ing 11k vnchks. Tiie human body does n!)t need to be tolallv diseased in DrvEs AN'D Lazakits. evcrv part and incinher thereof before death sie/.es it. Men die with but a simple vital origan diseased and with every other portion of the body perforniintj its functions perfect- Iv. Hut the fate of tliat origan u[)on whicli mortal dis- ease has seized must be the fate of all the members, how- ever healthv, in vital connection with it ; and the stricken organ and the healthv members, wliich. altogether, consti- tute the bodv, sink in the common ruin of death. And as we look upon the dead body we think, "This body is not dead because it was mortally sick, totallv depraved, in all its members. It is dead, and its healthv members are dead, only because de ith overpowered the seat of life."' And so it is with the soul that leaves the dead body. Death does not work in it a miraculous transformation of character. Death simply transfers the personal soul to a new sphere of action. The soul's new life begins exacllv where the old life ended. Its character the first instant of eternity differs inlinitesimally from its character the last instant of time, and that diBerence is but the ditYerence tliat conies in the growth of a single instant. The test question would not be, Is tlicre a spark of af- fection still living.- The test cpiestion is. Is the s[)ark of atTection growing brighter or colder.^ For almost if not quite ever)' man that ever went into eternity had some spark of good in him. But when mortal elisease has struck the soul the few remaining possibilities for good cannot long exist after the life-giving power is gone from the soul. It would be hard in this world to find a criminal so de- praved that he would not warn others to escape his own fate. Misery does not love company for its own sake. An aniinal when sick wants solitude. A human body when sick wants quietude. A soul when sick wants to be away 24 Dives AM) Lazaius. from the wliirl of biisincs> and pleasure-. Aiul so with tor- mented souls. The criminal tlial dra;j;s others down with him hv cov- fession or false accusation does so either fri)m fancievl in- jury, from hope of g)od, or from vagiu s.'ns,> of injustice that he should sufl'er while others equally L^'uilty shoulil escape. r»ul when reven^v. selfis'.iness, fancied injustice, do not urge on there is no criminal so mean as not to warn hi> loved ones or his confederates tliat lhe\' mav escape. l>ut doi's this warnin-^ chan;^-e the crinn'nal's characler.- llus it any connection whatevei* with the crime for which he is to sulVer.' Doesit ha\e any tendency to elevate his moral standartl, and to make him more thoULjhtful of prop- erty and life ? So in torment shall be found men who. wilh.out ho]")e lor themseKes. shall still desire that their kinch-ed on earth shall not come to the same place. Men ' do not become malignant devils the moment thev feel the Jiangs of suiTer- ing for a mis-sj)enl. selfish,, (jodless lil~e; P'rom the thought of the rich man in torment as si ill car- ing, to some extent, for his brothers on earth we are ieatl on to two other teachings inferred trom this. I)k<;kkks ok Pi nishmknt. The first teaching is : That in the world to come there are degrees of punishment. This teaching is elsewhere explicity made by Christ. when he speaks of some as being jiunished with few strijies ami ol hers with man\ . As men go out of this world, so thev go into the next ; to \arving degrees of happiness or of miser\ . S(,me forever Dives and Lazauus. separated from Christ were led into temptation, and sone were the leaders. And inasmuch as eternal punishment is not arbitrary, but is commensurate with character, the memory of the actively malignant will be more heavily loaded and his cons.'cjuent remorse more bitter than the memory and the remorse of him who, it may be, lived and died "not far from the kingdom of heaven." The punish- ment of Caiaphas is greater than that of Pilate. "Thou hast destroyed thyself" is God's asseveration to the lost. "Whatsoever a man soweth, that shall he also reap" is the Apostolic description and measure of any man's destruction. While the soul exists seed-time and harvest shall not fail. In eternity a man will reap just the same kind of hell that he sowed on earth, and he will reap as much of that kind of hell as is proportionate to the amount of hell he sowed on earth. The man who despite the greatest opportunities rejects the highest good shall reap the lowest hell. It is for this reason that, of angels, Satan, and, of men, Judas, stand for all time the two supreme exampleg of infinite despair. How much each man that has crossed the limit is doing of Satan's seed-sowing even he himself cannot teJl now, but when he wakes in torment his harvest of punishment will declare it infallibly. Intercessory Prayer in Paradise. The second inferential teaching fi-om the rich man's cai'e for his brothers on earth is : That if the lost can still care for us much more do the redeemed care for us. The activities of Paradise are not entirely hidden from us. The highest of earthly Christian duties shall not cease there. 26 Dives and La/Jaijus. The blessed dead who prayed for us on earth still pray for us in Paradise. It would be strange if they did not, strange that the nearer they stand to Jesus Christ, and the clearer their in- sight into God's love, the less they should pray for us who they know are so easily beset with sin. Every loved one dead in the Lord, and resting from his strivings with sin, is a power that draws us closer to God; for if tlie effectual, fervent prayer of a righteous man, him- self compassed with infirmities of flesh and mind, availeth much uttered from earth, much more will his prayer avail when, with thousandfold intensity, it is uttered in the regions of the Blessed. "More things are wrought bj- prayer Than this world dreams of." They that thus constantly pray for us. as one of the very conditions of their own unfettered growth in the knowledge and love of God, may not see us here, and may not know how it fares with us, for they are still but finite beings, A passing friend mav tell them. Perchance, (who knows.'') the blessed Lord himself may tell them. They may hear from us, but we cannot in this world hear from them. The passing is all in one direction. W3 know not how far, how near, they be, in realms of space. But one thing we do know, unless God-given reason plays us false, and that is, that the love of those whom we have loved long since and lost awhile never weakens in intensity but grows more effectual for our good with the passing years. "For so the whole round earth ir. every way Biund by g")ld chiins ab^ut the feet of God." PART SIXTH. Evidence and Conviction. AVjrahani saitli unto him, They have Moses and the Prophets; let them hear them. And he said, Nay, father Al^raham: but if one went unto them from the dend, the}' will repent. And he said unto him. If the}' hear not Moses and the Prophets, neither will they be persuaded, though one rose from th.- d^ad. — S/. Liikc 16: 2g — j/. The parable of Dives and Lazarus does not have to do mere- ly with the condition of souls :ii the Intermediate State. It has to do with their condition in this world. The rich man's ])lea for his brethren still living on earth brings our thoughts back from the future, to theconditions of present life. All is over with Dives, His doom is sealed. But what about his brethren? How can living men be per- suaded? How is it possible for them to learn the truth, and learn it fo that it shall become a constant force in their lives that selfishness has hell as its inevitable end? Two answers have aWays found favor. Their correctness is indicated by their origin. The voice from the place of tor- ment cries out for a miracle, that one should rise from the dead. The voice of our spiritual father, Abraham, asserts that miracles do not convince where the ordinary testimony appealing to reason is still neglected. The Impotence of Mir.vcles. Will a miracle convince the incredulous, and turn the sinner to repentance? Will the greatest of miracles, the return from the dead, change the moral nature of living men? The Phc-irisees seemed to think that it would. "What si^n showest thou?" they asked of Him whose authoritv was ^8 Dives and Lazarus. plainly enough manifested by his moral suhlimitv. And the same question is asked by men today. "If there be a life after death." they say, "a eonscious personal existence, eternal life with tjod for the good, and everlasting [)unishment in hell for the wicked, let us have some positive proof. Let one rise lrf)m the dead and give us that testimonv of experi- enc-.' which is our only ground for belief." It is intimated in tliis demand that such a miracle will leave no loop-hole of escape from belief; and that insufficic iCy of proof and devotion to truth are the (mly obstacles to faith. Yet the experience of ages does not bear out this conten- tion. The many miracles that Moses wrought in the Egyptiatk court afitected Pharoah but for the moment; and after each one, and after all, the steadfast j urpose of his heart remained unchanged. The only beneficiaries of these miracles, the people cho.sen of G(m1, saw the water bursting from the rock, fed upon the an- gels' food that came down from he.iven, and rejoiced at going dry sliod through the waves that overwhelmed their oppress- ors; but so little were thev affected at heart by these wonder- ful works that they rebelled ag linst their leader, murmured against their God, and for generation after generation mani- fested a well-nigh ineradicable love for the lascivious idolatry of the surrounding herthen. Jesus raided one whom he lf)ved, the brother of Mary and Martha, from the dead; and tiiough one did come back from the dead the chief efitcct on the unbelieving Jews was that they sought to kill both Lazarus and Jesus. Christ himself came back from the dead; and the result de- monstrated the truth of his words in the parable as spoken by Abraham; "If they hear not Moses and the Prophets, neither Dives and Lazarus. 29 will they be jX'rsuadetl,thou