■'" f ,'-*• r- \^ "^ .%'-^ v«:^ -.., ■■■; '.f ' ^ ** ' * - * ■^- .. * . *. '*.' ••, ^ •■» ,5. - %■ • -«»-^ s — fe;;."'uK''.v-.' /• r- -^ ^ij Sij ^ ■y^^^^y T R E A TfYlE Concerning Religious AfFedions, In Three Parts; Part I. Concerning the Nature of the AffeBions^ and their Importance in Religion, Part II. Shewing what are no certain Signs that reli- gious Affe^ions arc gracious^ or that they are not. Part III. Shewing what are diftinguijhing Signs of truly gracious and i?oly Affe5fions, By Jonathan Kdwards^ a. ivi. And Paftor of the /^r/? Church in Northampton, Levit. ix. ult. and x. i, 2. ^W there came a Fire out from before the Lordy upon the Altar', njjhich ivhen all the Peotie fanjo, they Jheuted and fell on their Faces, And Nadab a.nd Abihu offered f range Fire before the Lord, fwhich he commanded them not : And there 'were chofen ; of the Multitude that were roufed and affected by his Preaching, and at one Time or other appeared mightily engaged, full of Admiration of Chrift, and elevated with Joy, but few were true Difciples, that Hood the Shock of the great Trials that came after- wards, and endured to the End: Many were like the flony Ground, or thorny Ground; and but few, comparatively, like thegood Ground: Of the whole Heap that was gathered, great Part was Chaff, that the Wind afterv^ards drove away; and the Heap of Wheat that was left, was comparatively fmall ; as appears abundantly, by the Hillory of the New Teftament,. So it was in that great Out-pouring of the Spirit that was in the ApolHe's Days ; as appears by Matth. 24, 10, II, 12, 13. Gal, 3, I. and 4, 11, 15. Phil. 2, 21, and 3, 18,. 19. And the two Epillles of xht Corinthians,, and many other Parts •f the nev/ Teliameut. And fo it was in the great Reformation front Popery. The F R E F A C E. Vh Popery.' It appears plainly to have been in the vifible Church of God, in Times of great reviving of Religion, from Time to Time, as it is with the Fruit Trees in the Spring ; there are a Multitude of Blofibms; all v/hich appear fair and beautiful, and there is a promi- {ing Appearance of young Fruits ; but many of them are butof Ihort Continuance, they ibon fail off, and never come to Maturity. Not that it is to be fuppofed, that it will always be fo : For tho* there never will, in this World, be an entire Purity ; cither in particular Saints, in a perfed Freedom from Mixtures of Corruption; or in the Church of God, without any Mixture of Hypocrites with Saints, and counterfeit Religion, and falfe Appearances of Grace, with true Religion and real Holinefs : Yet, 'tis evident, that there will come a Time of much greater Purity in the Church of God, than has been in Ages pall ; it is plain by thofe Texts of Scriptures, Ijii. lii. i. Szei.^l. 6, 7, 9. Joel 3, 17. Zech. 14, 21. ffaX 69, 32, 35, 36. J/ai. 35, 8, 10. C/pa/>. 4, 3, 4. EzeL 20, 38. Fjizl. 37, 9, 10, II, 29. And one great Reafon of it will be, th?,t at that Time, God will give much greater Light to his People, £0 diiHnguifh between true Religion and its Counterfeits ; Mai. iii. 3. y^n(^ he jhallfit as a. Rejiner and Purifier of Silver', and he jh all purify the Sons of Levi, and purge them as Gold and Sil'ver \ that they may offer to the Lord an Offer- ing in Right eoufiefs. With Verfe 18, which is a Continuation of the Prophecy of the fame happy Times; then Jhall ye return, and difcern betiveen the Righteous and the Wichd^ hetnjoeen him that fer-vcth God, and him that ferret h him not. 'Tis by the Mixture of coijntcrfeit Religion with true, not difcern *d ,^nd dillinguifhed, that the Devil has had his greateft Advantage .againft the Caufe and Kingdom of Chrift, all along, hitherto. 'Tis plainly by this Means, principally, that he has prevail'd againil all Revivings of Religion, that ever have been, fmce the firll founding of theChrilHan Church. By this, he hurt the Caufe of Chriftianity, in, and after the apoftolic Age, much more than by all the Perfecu- tions of both Jevus and Heathens : The Apoftles in all their Epiilles, ihew themfelves much more concerned at the former A4ifchief, than the latter. By this, Satan prevail'd againft the Reformation, begun by Luther, Zuinglius, Sec, to put a Stop to its Progrefs, and brin? it into Difgr^ce ; ten Times more than by all thofe bloody, cruel, ana before unheard of Perfecutions of the Church of Rome. By this principally, has he prevailed againft Revivals of Religion, that have been in our Nation fmce the Reformation. By this he prevail'd againft Ne^-England, to quench the Love, and fpoil the Joy of her Efpoufals, about an hundred Years ago. And I think, I have had Opportunity enough to fee plainly, that by this, the Devil has pre- vail'd againft the late great Revival of Religion in Ne^vo-Englands fo happy and promifmg in its Beginning : Here moft evidently has 'been the main Advantage Satan has had againft us j b^ this he has foil'd IV The P R E F A C E. foird us ; 'tis by this Means that the Daughter of Zion in this Land, now lies on tlie Ground, in fuch piteous Circumftances, as we now behold her; with her Garments rent, her Face disfigur'd, her Naked- nefs expos'd, her Limbs broken, and weltering in the Blood of her own Wounds, and in no wife able to arife; and this, fo quickly after her late great Joys and Hope: Lam. i, 17. Zion fpreadeth forth her Hands, and there is none to comfort her : The Lord hath commanded co7i^ cerning Jacob, that his Ad-verfaries Jhall he round about him : Jerufalem is as a menjiruous Woman a7nong them. I have obferv'd the Devil prevail the fame Way, againfl two great Revivings of Religion in this Coun- try.— Satan goes en with Mankind, as he began witli them: He pre- vail'd againit our iirlt Parents, and call: 'em out of Paradife, andfud- denly brought all their Happinefs and Glory to an End, by appearing to be a Friend to their happy Paradifaic State, and pretending to advance it to higher Degrees. So the fame cunning Serpent, that beguiled E've thro' his Subtilty, by perverting us from the Simplicity that is in Chrift, hath fuddenly prevail'd to deprive us of that fair Profpeft, we had a little while ago, of ^ Kind of paradifaic State of the Church of God in Neivr-England* After Religion has revived in the Church of God, and Enemies appear, People that are engaged to defend its Caufe, are commonly moft expofed, where they are lead fenfible of Danger. While they tTQ wholy iutent upon the Oppofition that appears openly before 'em, to make Head againll that, and do negle6l carefully to look all round 'em, the Devil comes behind 'em, and gives a fatal Stab unfeen; and has Opportunity to give a more home Stroke, and wound the deeper, becaufe he llrikes at his Leifure, and according to his Pleafure, being obllrud:ed by no Guard or Refiftance. Andfolt is likely ever to be in the Church, whenever Religion revives remarkably, 'till we have learned v/ell to diftinguifh between true and falfe Religion, between faving AfFedions and Experiences, and thofe manifold fair Shews, and glittering Appearances, by which they are counterfeited ; the Confequences of which, when they are not diilinguiflied, are often inexpreffibly dreadful. By this Means, the Devil gratifies himfelf, by bringing it to pafs, that That Ihould be offered to God, by Multitudes, under a Notion of a pleafing accept- able Sacrifice to him, that is indeed above all Things abominable to him. By this Means, he deceives great Multitudes about the State of their Souls ; making them think they are fomething, when they are nothing ; and fo eternally undoes them : And not only fo, but eftabiilhes many in a ftrong Confidence of their eminent Holinefs, who are in God's Sight fome of the vilefl of Hypocrites. By this Means he many Ways damps and wounds Religion in the Hearts of the Saints, obfcures and deforms it by corrupt Mixtures, caufes their reli-r gious AfFed\ions wofuUy to degenerate, and fometimes for a confide- r^ble Time, to be like the Manna, that bred worms and flank ; and dreadfully The PREFACE. v dreadfully cnfnares and confounds the Minds of others of the Sdnts» and brings 'em into great Difficulties and Temptations, and entangles 'em in a Wildernefs, out of which they can by no Means extricate themfelves. By this Means, Satan mightily encourages the Hearts of open Enemies of Religion, and flrengthens their Hands, and fills them with Weapons, and. makes llrong their FortrefTes ; when at the fame Time, Religion and the Church of God lieexpofed to '«m, as a City without Walls. By this Means, he brings it to pafs, that Men work Wickednefs under a Notion of doing God Service, and fo fin with- out Reftraint, yea with earneil Forwardnefs and Zeal, and with all their Might. By this Means, he brings in, even the Friends of Reli- gion, infenfibly to themfelves, x6 do the Work of Enemies, by deftroy- ing Religion in a far more effeftual Manner, than open Enemies can do, under a Notion of advancing it. By this Means, the Devil fcatters the Flock of Chrift, and fets 'em one againft: another, and that with great Heat of Spirit, under a Notion of Zeal for God; and Religion by Degrees degenerates into vain Jangling ; and during the Strife, Satan leads both Parties far out of the right Way, driving each to great Extremes, one on the Right Hand, and the other on the Left, according as he finds they are moll inclined, or moft eafily moved and fway'd, 'till the right Path in the Middle, is almoft wholly neg- ledled. And in the midll of this Confulion, the Devil has great Opportunity to advance his own Intercft, and make it Urong in Ways innumerable, and get the Government of all into his own Hands, and work his own Will. And b,y what is feen of the terrible Confe- quences of this counterfeit Religion, when not diftinguilhed from true Religion, God's People in general have their Minds unhinged and unfettled in Things of Religion, and know not v/herc to fet their Foot, or what to think or do; and many are brought into Doubts, whether there be any Thing at all in Religion ; and Herefy, and Infidelity and Atheifm greatly prevail. Therefore, it greatly concerns us to ufe our utmofl Endeavours, clearly to difcern, and have it well fettled and eftabliflied, wherein, true Religion does confill. 'Till this be done, it may be expeded that great Revivings of Religion will be but of fhort Continuance : 'Till this be done, there is but little Good to be expe6led, of all our warm Debates, in Converfation and from the Prefs, not knowing clearly and difiindly, what we ought to contend for. My Defign is to contribute my Mite, and to ufe my beft (however feeble) Endeavours to this End, in the enfuing Treatife : Wherein it mull be noted, that my Defign is fomewhat diverfe from the Defign of what I have formerly publilhed, which was to ihcv/the dijii?iguijhing Marks of a Work of the Spirit of God, including both his common, and faving Operations ; but what I aim at now, is. to Ihew the Nature and Signs of the gracious Operations of God's Spirit, by which they are to be dillinguilhed from all Things whatfoever, that the Minds of Men vl 7he P R E F A C E. Men are the Subje6ls of, which arc not of a faving Nature. If I have Tfucceeded in this my Aim, in any tolerable Mcafure, I hope it will tend to promote the Intereft of Religion. And whether I have fuc- ceeded to bring any Light to this Subjedl, or no, and however my Attempt may be reproach'd, in thcfc captious, cenforious Times, I hope in the Mercy of a gracious and righteous God, for the Accep- tance of the Sincerity of my Endeavours, and hope alfo, for the Candor and Prayers of the true Followers of the meek and charitable Lamb of God. ™ PART 1 ^^^S iM ^ ^ -"^ ■ ^ .^ :t K *^^V^^ ^M ^^® ^M ^^^^i^iUv^^l^^f!^ Il^^ms^^w^ 1 ^m S ^P ^^^M PART I. Concerning the Nature of the AfFedions, and their Importance in Religion, I PETER i. 8. Whom having not Jeen^ ye love : In whom^ though now ye fee htm not^ yet believing^ ye rejoice with Joy un/peakabity and full of Gtory^ 0 N thefe Words, the Apoflle repre- W. fents the State of the Minds of the Chriftians he wrote to, under the Per- fecutions they were then the Subjeds of. Thefe Perfecutions are what he has Refpe6l to, in the two preceeding Verfes, when he fpeaks of the T^rial of their Faith ^ and of their being in Heavinefs through ma- Tiifold temptations. Such Trials are of threefold Benefit to true Religion : Hereby the Truth of it is manifefted, and it appears to be indeed true Religion: They, above all other Things, have a Tendency to diftinguifh between true Religion and falfe, and to caufe the Difference between them evidently to appear. Hence they are called by the 2 ^be Nature and Importance Part I. the Name of Trials^ in the Verfc nextly prececding the Text, and in innumerable other Places: They try the Faith and Religion of Profeflbrs, of what Sort it is, as apparent Gold is tried in the Fire, and manifefted, whether it be true Gold or no. And the F^ith of true Chriflians being thus tried and proved to be true, is found to Praife^ and Honour^ and Glory ; as in that pre- ceeding Verfc. And then, Thefe Trials are of further Benefit to true K eiigion ; they not only manifeft xh^ Truth of it, but they make it's genuine Beauty and Amiabknefs re- markably to appear. True Virtue never appears fo lovely, as when it is mod oppreiTed: And the divine Excellency of re^l Chriftianity, is never exhibited with fuch Advantage, as when under the greateft Trials: Then it is that true Faith appears much more precious than Gold-, and upon this Account, is found to Praife^ ' and Honour^ and Glory, And again, Another Benefit that fuch Trials are of to true Religion, is, that they purify and increafe it. They not only manifeft it to be true, but alfo tend to refine it, and deliver it from thofe Mixtures of that which is falfe, which incumber and impede it; that rothing may be left but that which is true. They tend to caufe the Amiablenefs of true Religion to appear to the beft Advantage, as v;as before obferved-, and not only fo, but they tend to increafe it's Beauty, by eilabliihing and confirming it, and making it more lively apd vigorous, and purifying it from thofe Things that obfcured it's Luftrc and Glory. As Gold that is tried in the Fire, is purged from it's Alloy, and all Remainders of Drofs, and comes forth more folid and beautiful-, fo true Faith being tried as Gold is tried in the Fire, becomes more precious; and thus alfo is found unto Pnilfe^ and Honour^ and Glory, The Apoftle feems to have Reipe6l to each of thefe Benefits, that Perfc- cutions are of to true Religion, in the Verfe preceeding the Text. ' • And PAr^T I. of religious Jlffe5fic?7s, j And in the Text, the Apoftle obferves how true Religion operated in the ChrifVians he wrote to, under their PerfecudoRs, whereby thefe Benefits of Perfecu- tion appeared in them; or what manner of Operation of true Religion, in them, it v/as, vJnereby their Reli- gion, under Perfecutior^, was manifeiLed to be true Religion, and eminently appeared in the genuine Beauty and Amiablcnefs of true Rciigion, and alio appeared to be increafed and purified^ and fo was like to be found unto Praife^ and Hcncur^ and Glory^ at the Appearing of Jefus Chrift. And there were two Kinds of Opera- tion, or Exercife of true Religion in them, under their Sufferings, that the Apoftle takes Notice of in the Text, wherein thefe Benefits appeared. 1. Love to Ckrift\ Whom having not feen^ ye love. The World was ready to wonder, what irrange Prin- ciple it was, that infiuenc'd them to expofe themfeives to fo great Sufi^erings, to forfake the Things that were feen, and renounce all that was dear and pleafant, which was the Objedl of Sene: They feem'd to the Men of the World about them, as thoiicrh they were befide themfeives, and to zCz as tho' they hated .them- feives; there v/as nothing in their View, that could induce them thus to fufier, and fupport them under, and carry them, thro' fuch Trials. But altho' there was nothing that was feen, nothing that the Vv^orld faw, or that the Chriftians themfeives ever faw with their bodily Eyes, that thus infiuenced and fupported 'em ; yet they had a fupernaturai Principle of Love to fomething unfeen\ they loved Jefus Chriii; for they faw him fpiritually, v/hom the World faw nor, and v/hom thev themfeives had never feen with bodilv Eves. 2. Joy in Chrijl, Tho' their outward SulTerings v/ere very grievous, yet their inv/ard fp'ritual Joys v/ere greater tlian their Sufferings, and thefe fupported them, and enabled them to fuffer with Chearfulnefs. There 4 The Nature of Part I. There are two Things which the ApoAle takes Notice of in the Text concerning this Joy. i. The Manner in which it rifes, the Way in which Chrift, tho' unfeen, is the Foundation of it, viz. By Faith ^ which is the Evidence of Things notfeen-, Inwhom^ though now ye fee him not^ yet believing, ye rejoice — . 2. The Nature of this Joy ; unfpeakable^ and full of Glory, Unfpeakable in the Kind of itj very different from worldly Joys, and carnal Delights; of a vaftly more pure, fublime and heavenly Nature, being fomcthing fupernatural, and truly divine, and fo ineffably excellent; the Sublimity and exquifite Sv/eetnefs of which, there were no Words to fet forth. Unfpeakable alfo in Degree-^ it pleafmg God to give 'em this holy Joy, with a liberal H^and, and in larcre Meafure, in their State of Perfecution. Their Joy was full of Glory : Altho' the Joy was un- fpeakable, and no Words were fufficient to defcribe it; yetfomething might be faid of it, and no Words more fit to reprefent it's Excellency, than thefe, that it was full of Glory -, or. as it is in the Original, glorified Joy, In rejoicing with this Joy, their Minds were filled, as it were, with a glorious Brightnefs, and their Natures exalted and perfected : It was a moft worthy, noble Re- joicing, that did not corrupt and debafe the Mind, as many carnal Joys do -, but did greatly beautify and dig- nify it: It was a Prelibation of the Joy of Heaven, that railed their Minds to a Degree of heavenly Blefiednefs : It fili'd their Minds with the Light of God's Glory, and made 'em themfelves to fliine with fome Communi- cation of that Glory. Hence the Propofition or Dodrine, that I would raife from thefe Words is this, DOCT. True Religion, in great Part, conjijis in holy Affections, We fee that the Apoftle, in obferving and remarking the Operations and Exercifes of Religion, in the Chri- Itians he wjote to, wherein their Religion appeared to be Part I. the AffeBions. 5 be true and of the right Kind, when it had it's greateft Trial of what Sort it was, being tried by Perfecution as Gold is tried in the Fire, and when their Religion not only proved true, but was moft pure, and clcanfed from it's Drofs and Mixtures of that which was not true, and when Religion appeared in them moft in it's genuine Excellency and native Beauty, and was found to Praife, and Honour, and Glory; he fingles out the religious Affedlions of hove and Joy^ that were then in exercife in them : Thefe are the Exercifes of Religion he takes Notice of, wherein their Religion did thus appear true and pure, and in it's proper Glory. Here I would, I. Shew what is intended by the AffeEiions, II. Obferve fome Things which make it evident, that i great Part of true Religion lies in the AfFedions. I. It may be enquired, what the AiFedlions of the Mind are? I anfwer. The AfFe61;ions are no other, than the more vigorous and fenfible Exercifes of the Inclination and Will of the Soul. God has endued the Soul with two Faculties : One i^ thaf by which it is capable of Perception and Specula- tion, or by which it difcerns and views and judges of Things •, which is called the Underftanding. The other Faculty is that by which the Soul don't meerly perceive and view Things, but is fbme Way inclin'd with refpedl to the Things it views or confiders; either is inclined to ^em^ or is difmclined, and averfe from 'em-y or is the Faculty by which the Soul don't behold Things, as an indifferent unaffe6led Spedlator, but either as liking or difliking, pleas'd or difpleas'd, approving or rejeding. This Faculty is called by various Names : It is fometimes called the Inclination: And, as it has refpedt to the Adions that are determined and governed by it, is cal- led the TVill: And the Mind, with regard to the exer- cifes of this_Faculty, is often called the Heart, The 6 _ The Nature of Part I. The Exercifes of this Faculty are of two Sorts ; either thofe by which the Soul is carried out towards the Things that are in viev/, in approving of them, being pleafed with them, and inclined to them; or thofe in which the Soul oppofcs the Things that are in view, in difapproving them, and in being ciifpleafed v/ith them, averfe from them, and rejecting tliem. And as the Excrcifes of the Inclination and Will of the Soul are various in theit Kinds^ fo they are much more various in their Degrees. There are fome Exerci- fes of Pleafednefs or Difpieafednefs, Inclination or Dif- inclination, wherein the Soul is carried but a little beyond a State of perfect Indifference. And there arc other Degrees above this, v/herein the Approbation or DiHike, Pleafednefs or Averdon, are ftronger; wherein we may rife higher and higher, ^till the Soul comes to acft vigoroufly and fenfibly, and the Actings of the Soul are with that Si:rength, that (thro' the Laws of the Union which the Creator has fix'd between Soul and Body) the Motion of the Blood and animal Spirits begins to be fenfibly alter'd ; whence oftentimes arifes fome bodily Senfation, efpecially about the Heart and Vitals, that are the Fountain of the Fluids of the Body : From whence it comes to pafs, that the Mind, with regard to the Exercifes of this Faculty, perhaps in all Nations and Ages, is called the Heart, And it is to be jioted, that they are thefe more vigorous and fenfible Exercifes of this Faculty, that arc called the Affe^ions, The IVill^ and the AffeElions of the Soul,, are not two Faculties •, the Affections are not elfentially diilind; from the Will, nor do they differ from the meer Adings of the Will and Inclination of the Soul, but only in the Livelinefs and Senfiblenefs of Exercife. It mull be confeffed, that Language is here fomewhat imperfeft, and the Meaning of Words in a confiderable Mcafure loofe and unfixed, and not precifely limited by Cuftom, which governs the Ufe of L anguage. In fome Sgnfe, the Affedion of the SquI differs nothing at all from ,Part L fbe JffeSfiom. 7 [from the Will and Inclination, and the \Vill never 1% in any Excrcife any further than it is affe^ed \ it is not moved out of a State of perfe(5l Indifference, any other- wife than as it is affe5fed one Way or other, and ads nothing any further. But yet there are many Adings of the Will and Inclination, that are not fo commonly called Affe5liens: In every Thing we do, wherein we ad voluntaiily, there is an Exercife of the Will and Incli- nation, 'tis our Inclination that governs us in our Ac- tions : But all the Adings of the Inclination and Will, \ in all our common Adions of Life, are not ordinarily called Affe6>ions. Yet, what are commonly called Af- fedions are not elTenti ally different from them, but only in the Degree and Manner of Exercife. In every Ad of the Will whatfoever, the Soul either likes or diliikes> is either inclined or difinclined to what is in view; Thefe are not effentially different from thofe Affedions of Love and Hatred: That Liking or Inclination of the Soul to a Thing, if it be in a high Degree, and be vigo- rous and lively, is the very fame Thing with the Affec- tion of Love: And that Difliking and Difmclining, if in a great Degree, is the very fame with Hatred, In every Ad of the Will for^ or towards fomething not prefent, the Soul is in fome Degree inclined to that Thing; and that Inclination, if in a confiderable Degree, is the very fame with the Affedion of Dejire. And in every Degree of the Ad of the Will, wherein the Soul approves of fomething prefent, there is a Degree of Pleafednfefs > and that Pleafednefs, if it be in a confi- derable Degree, is the very fame with the Affedion of Joy or Delight, And if the Will difapproves of what is prefent, the Soul is in fome Degree difpleafed, and if that Difpieafednefs be great, 'tis the very fame with the Affedion of Grief or Sorrow. Such feems to be our Nature, and fuch the Laws of the Union of Soul and Body, that there never is in any Cafe whatfoever, any lively and vigorous Exercife of tie Will or IncUoatiori of the Soul, without Ibmc Effed upon % 8 Tie Nature of Part I. upon the Body, in fome Alteration of the Motion of it's Fluids, and efpecially of the animal Spirits. And on the other Hand, from the fame Laws of the Union of Soul and Body, the Conilitution of the Body, an the Motion of it's Fluids, may promote the Exercife o: the Affections. But yet, it is not the Body, but the Mind only, that is the proper Seat of the Affedtions. The Body of Man is no more capable of being really the Subje6t of Love or Hatred, Joy or Sorrow, Fear or Hope, than the Body of a Tree, or than the fame Body of Man is capable of thinking and underftanding. As 'tis the Soul only that has Ideas, io 'tis the Soul only that is pleafed or difpleafed with it's Ideas. As 'tis the Soul only that thinks, fo 'tis the Soul only that loves or hates, rejoices or is grieved at what it thinks of. Nor are thefe Motions of the animal Spirits, and Fluids of the Body, any Thing properly belonging to the Nature of the Affediions-, tho' they always accompany them, in' the prefent State ; but are only Efteds or Concomitants of the AfFe6tions, that are entirely diftindl from the Affections themfelves, and no Way eifential to them ; fo that an unbodied Spirit may be as capable of Love and Hatred, Joy or Sorrow, Hope or Fear, or othef Affedtions, as one that is united to a Body. The Affe^ions and Faffions are frequently Ipoken of as the fame; and yet, in the more common Ufe of Speech, there is in fome Reipedt a Difference; and Affe5iion is a Word, that in it's ordinary Signification, feems to be fomething more extenfive than PaJJion-, being ufed for all vigorous lively Actings of the Will or Incli- 1 nation ; but PafTion for thofe that are more fudden, and whofe Effects on the animal Spirits are more violent, and the Mmd more overpower'd, and lefs in its own Command. As all the Exercifes of the Inclination and Will, are cither in approving and liking, or difapproving and rejecting; fo the AffeCtions are of two Sorts; they are thofe by v/hlch the Soul is carried out to what is in view, cleaving the jiffeBions, g cleaving to it, or feeking it •, or thofe by which it is averfe from it, and oppofes it. Of the former Sort are Love^ Beftre^ Hope^ Joy^ Gratitude^ Complacence, Of the latter Kind, are Hatred^ Fear^ Anger ^ Griefs and fuchlikej which it is needlefs Inow to iland particularly to define. And there are fome AfFe6tions wherein there is a Compofition of each of the aforementioned Kinds of Adings of the Will ; as in the Affedion of Pity^ there is fomething of the former Kind, towards the Perfon fufFering, and fomething of the Latter, towards what he fuffers. And fo in Zeal, there is in it high Approba- tion of fome Perfon or Thing, together with vigorous Oppofition to what is conceived to be contrary to it. There are other mixt AffeClions that might be alfo mention' d, but I haften to the lid. Thing propofed, "Which was to obferve fome Things that render it evident, that true Religion, in great Part, confifts in the Affedions. And here, What has been faid of the Nature of the Affec- tions, makes this evident, and may be fufficient, with- out adding any Thing further, to put this Matter out of Doubt : For v/ho will deny, that true Religion con- fifts, in a great Meafure, in vigorous and lively Adlings of the Inclination and Will ot the Soul, or the fervent Exercifes of the Heart. That Religion which God requires, and will accept, don't confiil in weak, dull and lifelefs Wouldings, rai- fmg us but a little above a State of Indifference: God, in his Word, greatly infills upon it, that we be in good Earneft, fervent in Spirit, and our Hearts vigoroufly engaged in Religion: Rom. xii. ii. Be ye fervent in Spirit, fervijig the Lord, Deut. x. 12. And now Ifrael, What doth the Lord thy God require of thee, hut to fear the Lord thy God, to walk in all his Ways, and to lov^ hint, and to ferve the Lord thy God, with all thy Heart, and with all thy Soul? And Chap. vi. 4, 5. Hear, O B Ifraeli lo The Nature of Part T, Ifrael-, the Lord our God is one Lord-, and thou jhalt love the Lord thy God^ with all thy Hearty and with all thy Souly and with all thy Might. 'Tis fuch a fervent, vi- gorous Engagednefs of the Heart in Religion, that isr th^ Fruit of a real Circumcifion of the Heart, or tru^; Regeneration.;, and that has the Promifes of Life ; Deut.' XXX. 6. And the Lord thy God will circumcife thine Hearty mid the Heart of thy Seed^ to love the Lord thy God^ with all thy Hearty and zvith all thy Sotily that thou may eft live. \ If we ben't in good earned in Religion, and our Wills and Inclinations ben't ftrongly exercifed, we arc, Nothing. The Things of Religion are fo great, that there can be no Suitablenefs in the Exercifes of our Hearts to their Nature and Importance, unlefs they be lively and powerful. In nothing, is Vigour in the Actings of our Inclinations fo requifite, as in Religion-, and in nothing; is Lukewarmnefs fo odious. True Reli- gion is evermore a powerful Thing v and the Powerlar it appears, in the firll Place, in the inward Exercifes of it in the Heart, where is the principal and original Seat of it. Hence true Religion is called the Power of God- Unefsy in Diflin^tion from the external Appearances oi it, th^ix 3.1'c the Fo7'm of ky 2 Tim. iii, 5. Having a Form ef Godlinefy but denying the Power of it. The Spirit of God, in thofe that have found and folid Religion, is a Spirit of powerful holy Affe6lion-, and therefore, God- is faid to have given them the Spirit of Power^ and of LovSy and of a found Mind^ 2 Tim. i. 7. And fuch, when they receive the Spirit of God, in his fan6lifying. and faving Influences, are faid to be baptized with the Holy GhofVy and imth Fire \ by reafon of the Power and Fervour of thofe Exercifes the Spirit of God excites in their Hearts, whereby tlieir Hearts, when Grace is im exerciie,. may be faid to hum- within them , as is faid of 1 the Difciples, Luke xxiv. 32. The Bufmefs of Religion is, from Time to Time;, compared to thofe Exercifes, wherein Men are wont to Hiave their Hearts and Strength greatly exercifed and engaged^ Part I, the Affedlionu 1 1 engaged; fuch as Running, Wreflling or Agonizing for a great Prize or Crown, and Fighting with Itrong Ene- nemies that feek our Lives, and Warring as thofe that by Violence take a City or Kingdom. And tho' true Grace has various Degrees, and there are fome that are but Babes in Chrift, in whom the Ex- ercife of the Inclination and Will towards divine and heavenly Things, is comparatively weak ; yet every one that has the Power of Godlinefs in his Heart, has his Inclinations and Heart exercifed towards God and divine Things, withfuch Strength and Vigour, that thefe holy Exercifes do prevail in him above all carnal or natural Affedlions, and are effedlual to overcome them: For every true Difciple of Chrift, loves him above Father or Mother^ Wife and Children^ Brethren and Sifters^ Houfes and Lands \ yea^ than his own Life. From hence it fol- lows, that wherever true Religion is, there are vigorous Exercifes of the Inclination and Will, towards divine Objeds : But by what was faid before, the vigorous, lively and fenfible Exercifes of the Will, are no other than the AfTedions of the Soul. 2. The Author of the human Nature has not only given Affections to Men, but has made 'em very much the Spring of Men's A6tions. As the AfFedions'do no^ only ncceifarily belong to the human Nature, but are a very great Part of it-, fo (inafmuch as by Regeneration, Perfons are renewed in the whole Man, and fandified throughout) holy Affe6lions do not only neceffarily be- long to true Religion, but are a very great Part of •ihat. And as true Religion is of a pradical Nature;^ and God hath fo conftituted the human Nature, that the Aifedions are very much the Spring of Men's Ac- tions, this alfo fhews, that true Religion muft confift very much in the Affedions. Such is Man's Nature, that he is very unadive, any otherwifc than he is influenc'd by fome Affedion, either Lfive or Hatred^ Ikfire^ Hope^ Fear or fome other. B 2 Thefe 12 'Religion conjijls much Part I. Thcfc Affe6lio,ns we fee to be the Springs that fet Men a going, in all the Affairs of Life, and engage them in all their Purfuits : Thefe are the Things that put Men forv/ard, and carry 'em along, in all their wordly Bufi- nefs •, and efpecially are Men excited and animated by thefe, in all Affairs, wherein they are earneflly engaged, and which they purfue with Vigour. We fee the World of Mankind to be exceeding bufy and adlive-, and the Affedions of Men are the Springs of the Motion: Take away ail Love and Hatred^ all Hope and Fear^ all din- ger. Zeal and affedionate Defire^ and the World would be, in a great Meafure, motionlefs and dead; there would be no fach Thing as Adivity amongft Mankind, or any earneft Purfuit whatfoever. 'Tis Affedlion that engaftes the covetous Man, and him that is greedy of worldly Profits, in his Purfuits •, and it is by the Affec- tions, that the ambitious Man is put forward in his Purfuit of w^orldly Glory •, and 'tis the Affediions alfo that aduate the voluptuous Man, in his Purfuit of pkafure and fcnfual Delights : The World continues, from Age to Age, in a continual Commotion and Agi- tation, m a Purfuit of thefe Things; but take away all Affeftion, and the Spring of all this Motion would be p-one, and the Motion itfelf would ceafe. And as in worldly Things, worldly Affc6tions are very much the Spring of Men's Motion and Adion; fo in religious Matters, the ^'^pring of their A6lions are very much relio-ious AfTedions: He that has do6lrinal Knowledge and Speculation only, wiihout Affedion, never is enga- ged in the Bufmefs of Religion. ^.^, Nothing 15 more man^fefl /« Fa^^ than that the Things of Religion take hold of Men's Souls no fur- ther than th.^y affe^ them. There are Multitudes that often hear the Word of God, and therein hear of thofe Thino-s that are infinitely great and important, and that moil nearly concern them, and all that is heard feems to be wholly ineffectual upon them, and to make no Alte- ration Part I. in holy Affedllom, ij ration in their Difpofition or Behaviour ; and the Reafon is, they are not affedted v/ith what they hear. There are many that often hear of the glorious Perfedions of God, his almighty Power, and boundlefs Wifdom, his infinite Majefty, and that Holinefs of God, by which he is of purer Eyes than to behold Evil, and cannot look on Iniquity, and the Heavens are not pure in his Sight, and of God's infinite Goodnefs and Mercy, and hear of the great Works of God's Wifdom, Power and Good- nefs, wherein there appear the admirable Mapifeftations of thefe Perfections ; they hear particularly of the un- Ipeakable Love of God and Chrlft, and of the greac Things that Chriil has done and fufferVl, and of the great Things of another World, of eternal Mifery, in bearing the Fiercenefs and Wrath of almighty God, and of endlefs BleiTednefs and Glory in the Prefence of God, and the Enjoyment of his dear Love; they alio hear the perernptory Commands of God, and his gra- cious Counfels and Warnings, and the fweet Invitations of the Gofpel; I fay, they often hear thefe Things, and yet remain as they v/ere before, with no fenfible Alterar tion on them, either in Heart or Pradlice, becaufe they are not affedted with v/hat they hear -, and ever will be fo 'till they are affeded. I am bold to ^ffert, that there never was any confiderable Change wrought in the Mind or Converfation of any one Perfon, by any Thin.o- of a religious Nature, that ever he read, heard or faw, that had not his Afredlions mov'd. Never was a natural Man engaged earneflly to feek his Salvation: Never were any fuch brought to cry after Wifdom, and lift up their Voice for Underftanding, and to wreflle with God in Prayer for Mercy-, and never was one humbled, and brought to the Foot of God, from any Thing that ever he heard or imagined of his own Unworthinefs and De- fervings of God's Difpleafure ^ nor v/as ever one induced • to fly for Refuge unto Chrift, while his Heart remained unaffe6led. Nor was there ever a Saint aw^akened out of a cold, lifelcfs Frame, or recovered, from a declining State 14 Religion conjifts much Part I. State in Religion, and brought hack from a lamentable Departure from God, without having his Heart affec- ted. And in a Word, there never was any Thing con- fiderable brought to pafs in the Heart or Life of any Man living, by the Things of Religion, that had not his Heart deeply affedled bv thofe Things. 4. The holy Scriptures do every where place Reli- gion very much in the Affe6lions j fuch as Fear, Hope,, Love, Hatred, Dcfire, Joy, Sorrov/, Gratitude, Com- panion and Zeal. The Scriptures place much of Religion in godly Fear% infomuch that 'tis often fpoken of as the Chara6ter of thofe that are truly religious Perfons, that they tremble at God's Word^ that they fear before him^ that their Flefh trembles for Fear of him^ and that they are afraid of his Judgments^ that his Excellency makes them afraidy and his Dread falls upon them-, and the like: And a Compellation commonly given the Saints in Scripture, is, . Fearers of Gody or they that fear the Lord, And becaufe the Fear of God is a great Part of true Godli- nefs, hence triie Godlinefs in general, is very commonly called by the Name of the Fear of God-, as every one knows, that knows any Thing of the Bible. So Hope in God and in the Promifes of his Word, is often fpoken of in the Scripture, as a very confiderable Part of true Religion. 'Tis mentioned as one of the three great Things of which Religion confifts, i Cor. xiii. 13. Hope in the Lord is alfo frequently men- tioned as the Chara6ler of the Saints : Pfal. cxlvi. 5. Happy is he that hath the God of Jacob for his Help^ whofe Hope is in the Lord his God, Jer. xvii. 7. Bleffed is the Man that trufieth in the Lord^ whofe Hope the Lord is, Pfal. xxxi. 24. Be of good Courage^ and he fhall Jirengt hen your Hearty all ye that Hope in the Lord. And the like in many other Places. Religious Fear and Hope are, once and ^gain, joined together, as jointly conilituting the Charader of the true Saints. Pfal. xxxiii. 18, rART I. tn holy Affecliom. J J 1 8. Behold the Eye of the Lord is upon them that Fear .him^ upon them that Hope in his Mercy, Pfal. cxlvii. ii. ne Lord taketh Pleaftire in them that Fear him^ in thofi that Hope in his Mercy. .Hope is fo great a Part of true Religion, that .the Apoftle fays "jue are faved by Hope^ Rom. viii. 24, And this, is fpoken of as the Hel- met of the Chriftian Soldier, i Thef. y. 8. And for an Helmet^ the Hope of Salvation^ and the fure and lledfaft Anchor of the Soul, which preferves it from being call av/ay by the Storms of tliis evil World, Heb. vi, 19. Which Hope we have^ as xin Anchor of the Soul^ both Jure and fiedfafi^ and which enter eth into that within tht Veil. 'Tls fpoken of as a -great Fruit and Benefit which true Saints receive by Chriil's Refurredtion ; i Pet. i. 3. Bleffed be the God and Father of our Lcrdjefus Chrift,^ which according to his abundant Mercy ^ hath begotten us .again unto a lively Hope^ hy the Refurre^ion of Jejm Chrifi from the Dead. The Scriptures place Religion very much in the Af- fediion of Love^^ m Love to God, and the Lord Jefus Chrift, and Love to the People of God, and to Man- kind. The Texts in which this is manifeft, both in the Old Teftament, and NeWj are innumerable. But of this more afterwards. The contrary Affe6biQn of Hatred alfo, as having Sin for its Objed:, is fpoken of in Scripture, as no inconfi- i*mm0nmmmam0mmaum PART P A R T IL . Shewing what are no certain Signs that religious AffeSiions are truly gracious^ or that they are not. F any one, on the Reading of what has been juft now faid, is ready to acquit himfelf, and fay, " I am not " one of thofe who have no religious " AfFedions; I am often greatly moved " withtheConfiderationof the Things " of Religion:*' Let him not content himfelf with this, that he has religious AfFe6lions. For (as was obferved before) as we ought not to reje6t and condemn all AfFe(5lions, as tho' true Religion did not r,t all confift in Affedion-, fo on the other Hand, we ought not to approve of all, as tho' every one that was religioufly affected, had true Grace, and was therein the Subjed: of the faving Influences of the Spirit of God-, and that therefore the right Way is to diftinguilh among religious Affedions, between one fort and another. Therefore let us now endeavour to do this : And in order to it, I wcKild do two Things. D2 1. 1 44 What are no Signs Part. II. I. I would mention fome Things, which are no Signs one Way or the other, either that Affedions are fuch as true Religion ccnfiits in, or that they are otherv/ife ; that we may be guarded againft judging of AfFedions by falfe Signs. IT. I would obferve fome Things, wherein thofc Affe6lions which are fpiritual and gracious, differ from thofe which are not fo, and may be dillinguifhed and known. FIRST, I would take Notice of fome Things, which are no Signs that Affedions are gracious, or that they are not. I. 'Tis no Sign one Way or the other, that religious Affedions arc very great, or raifed very high. Some are ready to condemn all high Affedions: If Perfons appear to have their religious AfFedions rais'd to an extraordinary Pitch, they are prejudiced againft them, and determine -thafthey are Delufions, without further Enquiry. But if it be, as has been proved, that true Religion lies very much in religious Affedlions ; then it follows, that if there be a great deal of true Religion, there will be great religious AfFedions; if true Religion in the Hearts of Men, be raifed to a great Height, divine and holy Affedions will be raifed to a great Height. Love is an Affeclion; but will any Chriftian fay. Men ought not to love God and Jefus Chrifl in a high Degree ? And will any fay, we ought not to have a very great Hatred of Sin, and a very deep Sbrrov/ for it ? Or that we ought not to exercife a high Degree of Gratitude to God, for the Mercies we receive of him, and the great Things he has done for the Salvation of fallen Men ? Or that we fhould not have very great and flrong Defires after God and Holinefs ? Is there any who v/ill profefs, that his Affedions in Religion are great enough; and will Part IL to diftinguijh JffeBions' 45 will fay, " I have no Caufe to be humbled, that I am *' no more affecled v/ith the Things of Religion than I *' am, I have no Reafon to be afhamed, that I have no " greater Exercifes of Love to God, and Sorrow for *' Sin, and Gratitude for the Mercies which I have *' received ?" V/ho is there that will go and blefs God, that he is affe6led enough with what he has read and heard, of the wonderful Love of God to Worms and Rebels, in giving his only begotten Son to die for them, and of thedving Love of Chrift; and will pray that he may not be affedled with them in any higher Degree, becaufe high AfFe6lions are improper, and very unlovely in Chriftians, being enthufiaftical, and ruinous to tru^ Religion ? Our Text plainly fpeaks of great and high AfFe£lions., when it fpeaks of rejoicing voith Joy iinfpeakahle and, full of Glory: Here the molt fuperlative ExprelTions are ufed, which Language will afford. And the Scriptures often require us to exercife very high Affedlions: Thus in the firft and great Commandment of the Law, there is an Accum.ulation of Expreffions, as tho* Words v>^ere wanting to exprefs the Degree, in which we ought to love God; ^hou fhalt love the Lord thy Gcdy with all thy Hearty with all thy Soul^ with all thy Mind^ and witb' all thy Strength, So the Saints are called upon to exer-^ cife high Degrees of Joy : i^^'^w, fays. Chrift to his Difciples, and be epcceeding glad^ Matth. v. 12. So it is faid, Pfal. Ixviii. 3. Let ihe Righteous be glad}, let them rejoice before God -^ yea^ let them exceedingly rejoice. So In the fame Book of Ffam.s, the Saints are often called Vi^OTitofhoutforJoy, and in Luke v'u 2^^ to leap for Joy. So they are abundantly called upon to exercife high Degrees of Gratitude for Mercies, to Fraife God with all their Hearts^ with Hearts lifted up in th§ Ways cf the Lord^ and their Souls magnifying the Lord-, finging his Praifes^ talking of his wondrous Works^ declaring hi§ Ppin^s^ &c, hr4 ^6 What are no Signs Part. II, And we find the molt eminent Saints in Scripture, often profefiing high Affections. Thus the Pfalmift fpeaks of his Love, as if it were unfpeakahle-, Pfalm cxix. 97. O how love I thy Law! So he expreifes a great Degree of Hatred of Sin*, Pfalm cxxxix. 21, 22. Do I not hate them^ O Lord^ that hate thee? And am I ■ not grieved with them that rife up againfi thee ? I hat,e them with perfect Hatred. He alfo expreffes a high Degree of Sorrow for Sin: He fpeaks of his Sins going cv£r his Head^ as an heavy 'Burden^ that was too heavy for him •, and of his roaring all the Day^ and his lAoiflure^ s being turned into the Drought of Summer^ and his Bones being as it were broken with Sorrow. So he often expreffes great Degrees of Spiritual Defires, in a Multitude of the ftrongeft ExprelTions which can be conceived of; fuch as his. Longing., his SouVs thirfting as a dry and thirfty Land where no Water is .^ his pantiyig., his Flefh and Heart crying out., his SouVs breaking for the Longing it hathy &c. He expreffes the Exercifes of great and extrem.e Grief for the Sins of others, Pfal. cxix. 136. Rivers of Water run down mine Eyes., becaufe they keep not thy Law. And Verfe 53. Horror hath taken hold upon me, becaufe of the Wicked that forfake thy Law. He expreffes high Exercifes of Joy, Pfal. xxi. 1. The King fh all joy in thy Strength', and in thy Salvation, how greatly fhall hs rejoice! Pfal. Ixxii. 23. My Lips fi) all greatly rejoice^ when I Jing unto thee. Pfal. Ixxiii. 3,-^^ — 7. Becaufe thy loving Kindnefs is better than Life, r/iy Lips fhall praife thee. Thus will I blefs thee^ while Hive: I will lift up my Hands in thy Na^ne : My Soul fhall be fatisfied as with Marrow and Fatnefs., and my Mouth fhall praife thee with joyful Lips : When I remember thee upon my Bed, and meditate on thee in the J^ight Watches-, becaufe thou hafi been my Helpy therefore in the Shadow of thy Wings will I rejoice. The Apoflle Paul expreffes high Exercifes of Affec- tion. Thus, he expreffes the Exercifes of Pity and Concern for others Good, even to Anguifh of 'Heart-, a great-i fervent.^ and abundant Love^ and earneji and long-. ing Part. IL to diflinguij}^ Affections. 47 pg Befires^ and exceeding Joy ; and fpeaks of the Eml- tation and 'Triumphs of his Soul, and his earnefi Expec^ tation and Hop£^ and his abundant Tears^ and the Tra- ro ails of his Soul^ in Pity, Grief, earneft Defires, godly Jealoufy, and fervent Zeal, in many Places that have been cited already, and which therefore I need not repeat. John the Baptift expreiTed great Joy^ John iii. 39. Thofe blefled Wonieyi that anointed the Body of Jefus, are reprefented as in a very high Exercife of religious AfFedion, on occafion of Chrifl's Refurredtion ; Matth. xxvi.ii. 8. And they departed from the Sepulchre^ .with Fear and great Joy» 'Tis often foretold of the Church of God, ia her future happy Seafons here on Earth,, that they Hiall ex- .ceedingiy rejoice; Pfal. Ixxxix. 15, 16. They Jhall walky O Lord^ in the Light of thy Countenance: In thy Name Jh all they rejoice fill the Day^ and in thy Right e oufnefs fh all they he exalted. Zech. ix. 9. Rejcice greatly^ O Daugh- ter of Zion ; Jhout^ O Daughter of Jerufalem \ Behold thy King cometh^ &c. The fame is reprefented in innu- merable other Plac€s. And becaufe high Degrees of Joy are the proper and genuine Fruits of the Gofpel of Chrifl, therefore the Angel calls this Gofpel, good Ti- dings of great Joy., that fhould he to all People, The Saints and Angels in Heaven, that have Reli- gion in it's higheft Perfection, are exceedingly affected with what they behold and contemplate, of God's Per- fedions and Works. They are. all as a pure heavenly Flame of Fire, ii) their I^ove, and in the Greatnefs and Strength of their Joy and Gratitude : ■ Their Praifes are reprefented, as the Voice of many Waters, and as the Voice of a great Thunder i Now the only Reafon why their Affedions are fo much higher than the holy Affec- tions of Saints oi^ Earthy is, they fee the Things they are affe6led by, more according to their Truth, and have their Affedions more conformed to the Nature of Things. And therefore, if religious Affe6lion& in Men here belp\^^-^e,,but of the fame Nature and Kind with their's. 4? Whai are no Signs Part II. their's, the higher they are, and the nearer they are to t heir's in Degree, the better-, becaufe therein they will be fo much the more conformed to Truth, as their's are. From thefe Things it certainly appears, that religious Affedions being in a very high Degree, is no Evidence that they are not fuch as have the Nature of true Reli- gion. Therefore they do greatly err, who condemn Perfons as Enthufiafts, merely becaufe their AfFedions are very high. And on the other Hand, 'Tis no Evidence that reli- gious Affe6i:ions are of a fpiritual and gracious Nature, becaufe they are great. "Tis very manifeft by the holy Scripture, our fure and infallible Rule to judge of Things of this Nature, that there are religious Affedi- ons which are very high, that are not fpiritual and fav- ing. The Apoftle Paul fpcaks of AfFedions in the GalatianSy which had been exceedingly elevated, and which yet he manifeftly fpeaks of, as fearing that they were vain, and had come to nothing. Gal. 4. 15. JVhere is the Blejfednefs you fpake of? For I bear you Record^ that if it had been poffible^ you would have plucked out -your cwn Eyes^ and have given them to me. And in the 1 1 th Verfe he tells them, He was afraid of them^ left he had heft owed on them Labour in vain. So the Children of Ifrael were greatly afFe6ted with God's Mercy to them, when they had feen how wonderfully he wrought for them at the Red Sea, where they fang God^s Praife ; tho' they foon forgot his Works. So they were greatly affecSled again at Mount Sinai, when they faw the marvelous Manifeftations God made of himfelf there*, andfeemed mightily engaged in their Minds, and with great For- wardness made Anfwer, when God propofed his holy Covenant to them, faying. All that the Lord hath fpoken will we do, and be obedient. But how foon was there an End to all this mighty Forwardnefs and Engagednefs of AfFedion ? How quickly were they turned afide after other Gods, rejoicing andfhouting around their golden Calf? So great Multitudes who were affeited with the Miracle . Part. II. to difiinguijh Jffe.5lions. 49 Miracle of raifing Lazarus from the Dead, were ele- vated to a high Degree, and made a mighty ado, when Jefus prefentiy after enter'd 'mK.o J erufalemy exceedingly magnifying Chrift, as tho' the Ground were not good enough for the Afs he rode to tread upon; and therefore cut down Branches of Palm-trees, and ftrewed them in the Way -, yea, pull'd off their Garments, and fpread them in the Way, and cried with loud Voices, Hofanna to the Son of David, hlejjed is he that co\neth in the Name of the Lord y Hofanna in the Highefi\ fo as to make the whole City ring again, and put all into an Uproar. We learn by the Evangelift John^ that the Reafon why the People made this ado, was becaufe they were affedied with the Miracle of raifing Lazarus: John xii. 18. Here was a vaft Multitude crying Hofanna on this Occafion, fo that it gave Occafion to the i^harifees to fay. Behold the World is gone after hiniy John xii. 19. but Chrift had at that Time but few true Difciples. And how quickly was this ado at an End ? All of this Nature is quell'd and dead, when this Jefus ftands bound, with a mock Robe and a Grown of Thorns, to be derided, fpit upon, fcourg'd, condemn'd and executed. Indeed there was a great and loud Out-cry concerning him, among the Multitude then, as well as before; but of a very differ- ent Kind: 'Tis not then, Hofanna^ Hofanna^ but Crucify^ Crucify. And it is the concurring Voice of all orthodox Divines, that there may be religious A ffedlions, v/hich are raifed to a very high Degree, and yet there be nothing of true Religion.f II. 'Tis no Sign that Affedtions have the Nature of true Religion, or that they have not, that they have great Effects on the Body. All Affedions whatfoever, have in fome Refpe6b or Degree, an EfFed on the Body. As was oblerved be- fore, t Mt» Stoddard obfer'ves. That commcn Affcdilons are fQrmtimx ftmnger than facing* Guide to Chrift. p. 21. ' 50 What are no Signs Part II. fore ; fuch is our Nature, and fuch are the Laws of Union of Soul and Body, that the Mind can have no; lively or vigorous Exercife, without fome EfFe6t upon; the Body. So fubjed is the Body to the Mind, and fo: much do its Fluids, efpecially the animal Spirits, attend, the Motions and Excrcifes of the Mind, that there can't be fo much as an intenfe Thought, without an Effedt upon them. Yea, *tis queftionablt, whether an embori died Soul ever fo much as thinks one Thought, or has ;any Exercife ac all, but that there is fome correfponding Motion or Alteration of Motion, in fome Degree, of the Pluids, in fome Part of the Body. But univerfal Experience fhcvv's, that the Exercife of the Aftedions, have in a fpecial Manner a Tendency, to fome fenfible Effed: upon the Body. And if this be fo, that all Affections have fome Eife6t on the Body, we may then well fuppoie, the greater thofe Affe6tions be, ,and the more vigorous their Exercife (other Circiimftance$i being equal) the greater will be the Effed on the Body. Hence it is not to be wondered at^ that very great and ilrong Excrcifes of the Affedions, fhould have great Effeds on the Body. And therefore, feeing there are very great Affe6lions, both common and Ipiritualj ^ence it is not to be wondered at, that great Effeds on ithe Body, fhould arife from both thefe Kinds of Affec- tions. And confequently thefe Effeds are no Signs, that the Affedions they arife from, are of one Kind or the other.^ Great Effeds on the Body certainly are no fure Evi- dences that Affedions are fpiritual; for we fee that fuch Effeds oftentimes arife from great Affedions about temporal Things, and when Religion is no Way con- cerned in them. And if great Affedions about fecular Things, that are purely n;itural, may have thefe Ef- feds, I know not by what Rule we fhould determine, that high Affedions about religious Things, which arife ■ m like Manner from Nature, can't have the like Effed. Nor Part II. to diJiinguiJJ: j^ffedfions* 51 Nor on the other FT and, do I know of any Rnle any have to determine, that gracious and holy Affedions, when raifed as high as any natural AfFe6lions, and have equally ftrong and vigorous Exercifes, can't have a great Eifc6t on the Body. No fuch Rule can be drawn from Reafon: I know of no Reafon, why a being affedied with a View of God's Glory ihould not caufe the Body to faint, as well as a beiiig affecled with a View of Sdomonh Glory. And no fuch Rule has as yet been produced from the Scripture : None has ever been found in all the late Controverfies which have been about Things of this Nature. There is a great Power in fpi- ritual Affedions; v/e read of the Power which v/orketh in Chriftians, * and of the Spirit of God being in them, as the Spirit of Power, -j- and of theeffeduai working of his Power in them; J yea of the working of God's mighty Power in them, i) But Man's Nature is weak: Flefh and Blood are reprefented in Scripture as exceeding weak; and particularly with Refpe^l to it's Unfitncis for great fpiritual and heavenly Operations and Exer- cifes, Mntth, xxvi. 41. i Cor. xv. 43, & 50. The Text- v/e are upon fpeaks of }>>' unfpeakahle, and full of Glory. And- who that confiders what Man's Nature is, and what the Nature of the Affections are, can reafon- ably doubt, but that fuch unutterable and glorious Joys may be too great and mighty for weak Dull and Afhes, fo as to be coniiderably overbearing to it ? It is evident by the Scripture, that true divine Difcoveries, or Ideas of God's Glory, when given in a great Degree, have a Tendency, by affedling the Mind, to overbear the Body-, becaufe the Scripture teaches us often, that if thefe Ideas or Views fnould be given to fuch a Degree,, as they are given in Heaven, the v/eak Frame of the Body could not fubfiil under it, and that no Man can, in that Manner, fee God and live. The Knowledge which the Saints have of God's Beauty and Glory in this World, and thofe holy Aftedions that arife from it, * JEph. iii. 7. \ 2 Tim. i. 7. % Ibid. y. 7. Ibid. v. 19. I! Epl^. i. 19- 52 What are no Signs Part. II. it, arc of the fame Nature and Kind with what the Saints are the Siibje6ts of in Heaven, difFering only in Degree and Circumilances : What God gives them here, is a Forctalle of heavenly Happinefs, and an Earneft of their future Inheritance. And who fhall limit God in his giving this Earned, or fay he fhall give fo much of the Inheritance, fuch a Part of the future Reward, as an Earneft of the Whole, and xio more ? And feeing God has caught us in his Word, that the whole Reward is fuch, that it would at once deflroy the Body, is it not too bold a Thing for us, fo to fet Bounds to the fove^ reign God, as to fay, that in giving the Earneft of this JK^eward in this World, he iliall never give fo much of it^ asintheleaft todiminifh the Strength of the Body,, ^Nhtn God has no where thus limited himfelf ? The Pfalmifc fpcaking of vehem^ent religious Affec- tions he had, fpeaks of an Effed; in his Flefh or Body, befides what was in his Soul, exprefly diflinguifhing one from the other, once ancj again, Pfal. Ixxxiv. 2,. My Soul longethy yea even fainteth for the Courts of the Lord., my Heart and my Flelh crieth out for the living God. Here is a plain Diftindion between thie Heart and the Flefh, as being each affeded. So Pfal. Ixiii. i . My Soul thirjleth for thee., my Flefh longeth for thee^ in a dry and thirjly Land., where no Water is. Here alfo is an evident defigned Diflindion between the Soul and the . Flefh. The Prophet Hahakkuk fpeaks of his Body^s being over-born, by a Senfe of the Majefly of God, Hab. iii. 16. JVhen I heard^ my Belly trembled^ my Lips quivered Gt the Voice^ Rottennefs entered into my Bones., and I trembled in my f elf So the Pfalmifl fpeaks exprefly of his Flefh trembling, Pfal. cxix. 120. My Fl/fh tremhleth for Fear ef thee. That fuch Ideas of God's Glory, as ar,e fometimes given in this V/orld, have a Tendency to overbear the Body, is evident, bccaufe the Scripture gives us an Account, that tliis has fometimes actually been the Ef fed Part IL io dijlinguijh Affections. 53 feci of thofe external Manifeftations God has made of ;himfelf, to feme of the Saints, which were made to that End, viz. to give them an Idea of God's Majefly and Glory. Such Inilances we have in the Prophet Daniel^ and the Apoille John, Daniel giving an Account of aa external Reprefcntation cf the Glory of Chrifb, fays, Dan. X. 8. And there remained no Strength in me^ for my Ccmelinefs 'was turned into Corruption^ and I retained no Strength, And the Apoflle John giving an Account of a like Manifeilation made to him, fays, Rev. i. 17. And when I faw him^ I fell at his Feet as dead. 'Tis in vain to fay here, thefe were only external Manifeftations or Symbols of the Glory of Chrift, which thefe Saints beheld : For though it be true, that they were outward Reprefentations of Chrift's Glory, which they beheld with their bodily Eyes; yet the End and Ufe of thelc external Symbols or Reprefentations, was to give to thefe Prophets an Idea of the Thing reprefented, and that was the true divine Glory and Majefty ofChrift, which is his fpiritual Glory ; they were made XM^ of only as Sigpiiications of this fpiritual Glory, and thus un- doubtedly they received them, and improved them, and were afFe6led by them. According to the End, for which God intended thefe outward Signs, they recei- ved by them a great and lively Apprehenfion of the real Glory and Majeily of God's Nature, which they were Signs of; and thus were greatly affected, their Souls fw allowed up, and their Bodies overborn. And I think, they are very bold and daring, who will iay God cannot, or fhall not give the like clear .and affedingr Ideas and Apprehenfions of the fame real Glory and Majefly of his Nature, to none of his Saints, without the Intervention of any fuch external Shadows of it. Before I leave this Head, I would farther obferve, that 'tis plain the Scripture often makes Ufe of bodily Effects, to exprefs the Strength of holy and fpiritual Affc6lion *, 54 What are no Stgjts Part. II; Affections*, fuch 2iS trembling ^^ groaning ^-\ heing fick^\ irying out^^ panting^W zwd. fainting.^ Now if it be fup- pofed, that thele are only figurative Expreflions, to reprefent the Degree of AfreClion; yet I hope all will allow, that they are fit and fuitable Figures to reprefent the high Degree of thofe fpiritual Affedlions, which the Spirit of God makes Ufe of them to reprefent. Which I don't fee how they would be, if thofe fpiritual Affections, let them be in never fo high a Degree, have no Tendency to any fuch Things ♦, but that on the con- trary, they are the proper Effedls, and fad Tokens of ^ faife Affections, and the Delufion of the Devil. I can't think, God would commonly make Ufe of Things which are very alien from fpiritual AffeCt ions, and arc fhrewd Marks of the Hand of Satan, and fmell ftrong of the bottomlefs Pit, as beautiful Figures, to repre- ^ fent the high Degree of holy and heavenly AffeCtions. III. 'Tis no Sign that AffeCtions are truly gracious ; Affections, or that they are not, that they caufe thofe who have themi, to be fluent, fervent and abundant, in talking of the Things of Religion. There are many Perfons, who if they fee this in others, are greatly prejudiced againft them--^ Their being fo full of Talk, is with them, a fufficient Ground to con- demn them, as Pharifees, and oftentatious Hypocrites.' On the other Hand, there are many, who if they fee this EffeCt in any, are very ignorantly and imprudently forward, at once to determine that they are the true Children of God, and are under the faving Influences I of his Spirit, and fpeak of it as a great Evidence of a new Creature : They fay fucb an one's Mouth is now epen^d: He ufed to he Jlow to fpeak ^ hut now he is full and free: He is free now to open his Heart, and tell his Experiences^ and declare the Praifes of God\ it . cornes from *' Pfal. cxix. 1 20. Ezra ix. 4. Ifa. Ixvi. 2, 5. Hab. iii. 16. fRom. viii. 26. X Cant. ii. 5. and v. 8. § Pfal. Ixxxiv. 2. i|Pfal xxxviii. : 10. and xlii. i. ani cxix, 131. ^ Pral. Ixxxiv. z. and cxk. 81. ^ART. 11. to di/iinguijh Jfe£lions. 55 ro'fn him^ as free as Water from a Fountain^ and the ike. And efpecially are they captivated into a confident ind undoubted Perfwafion that they are favingly wrought apon, if they are not only free and abundant, but very lifedionate and earneft in their Talk. But this is the Fruit of but little Judgment, a fcanty iind ihort Experience i as Events do abundantly ihew ; find is a Miftake Perfons often can run into, through .heir truiling to their ovv^n Wifdom and Difcerning, and Tiaking their own Notions their Rule, inflead of the [holy Scripture. Tho' the Scripture be full of Rules, aoth how we ftiould judge of our own State, and alfo low we fhould be condu6led in our Opinion of others -, |ret we have no where any Rule, by which to judge our- elves or others to be in a good Eftate, froni any fuch Effedl: For this is but the Religion of the Mouth and af the Tongue, and what is in the Scripture reprefented by the Leaves of a Tree, which tho' the Tree ought not to be without them, yet are no where given as an Evidence of the Goodnefs of the Tree. That Perfons are difpofed to be abundant in talking of Things of Religion, may be from a good Caufe, and it may be from a bad one. It may be becaufe their Hearts are very full of holy Affe6lions; for out of tH, Ahundafrie of the Hearty the Mouth fpeaketb : And it may be becaufe Perfons Hearts are very full of religious Affedion which is not holy ; for flill out of the Abun- dance of the Heart the Mouth fpeaketh. It is very much the Nature of the AfFedlions, of whatever Kind they be, and whatever Obje6ls they are exercifed about, if they are ftrong, to difpofe Perfons to be very much in fpeaking of that which they are affefted with -, and not only to fpeak much, but. to fpeak very earneftly and fervently. And therefore Perfons talking abundantly and very fervently about the Things of Religion, can be an Evidence of no more than this, that they are very much affe6led with the Things of Religion ^ but this njay be, (as ha? been already ihcwn) and there be no Grace. 56 What are no Signs Part II Grace. That which Men are greatly affeded with, while the high AfFcclion lails, they will be earneiUy engaged about, and will be likely to fhew that Earneflnefs in their Talk and Behaviour j as the greater Part of the Jews^ in all Judea d^nd Galilee ^ did for a while, about John the Baptift's Preaching and Baptifm, when they were willing for a Seafon to rejoice in h's Light: A, mighty ado was made all over the Land, and among allJ Sorts of Perfons, about this great E^rophet and his Mi-j.- niftry. And fo the Multitude in like Manner, often-i manifefled a great Earneftnels, and mighty Engagednefs of Spirit, in every Thing that was external, about Chrifl and his Preaching and Miracles, being aftonijloed at his Do^rine^ anon with Joy receiving the Word^ fol- lowing him, Ibmetimes Night and Day, leaving Meat, Drink and Sleep to hear him-, once following him into the Wildernefs, failing three Days going, to hear him?;^ fometimes crying him up to the Clouds, faying, Never\ Man j-pake like this Man \ being fervent and earnefl in; what they faid. But what did thefe Things come to, in ^ the greater Part of them ? A Perfon may be over-full of Talk, of his own Ex-»^ periences; commonly falling upon it everywhere, and, in all Companies ; and when it is fo, it is rather a dark Sign than a good One. As a Tree that is over-full of Leaves, feldom bears much Fruit: And as a Cloud, tho' to Appearance very pregnant and full of Water, if it brings with it over much Wind, feldom affords much Rain to the dry and thirfty Earth: Which very Thing the holy Spirit is pleafed feveral Times to make Ufe of, to reprefent a great Shew of Religion with the = Mouth, without anfwerable Fruit in the Life: Prov. XXV. 14. Who fo hoafteth himfelf of a falfe Gift^ is like Clouds and Wind without Rain, And the Apoflle Jude^'\ fpcaking of fome in the primitive 1 imes, that crept in unawares among the Saints, and having a great Shew of Religion, were for a While not fufpedbed, l^hefe are Clouds (lays he) without Watcr^ carried ^oHt of Winds, Jude Part II. to dilimgui(h Jffe5lions. 56 I Jude V. 4 aiid 12. And the Apoftle Peter^ fpeaking of i the fame, lays, 2 Pet. ii. ij. Thefe are Clouds without t Water y carried with a Tempeft. Falfe Affections, if they are equally ftrong, are much more forward to declare themfelvcs, than true. Becaufc I 'tis the Nature of falfe Religion, to affedl Shew and jObfervation; as it was with the Pharifees.* j IV. 'Tis no Sign that Affe£tions are gracious, or that ithey are otherwife, that Perfons did not make 'em I themfelves, or excite them of their of their own Con- : trivance, and by their own Strength. i There are many in thefe Days, that condemn all Affec- itions which are excited in a Way that the Subjedts of iof thqm can give no Account of, as not feeming to i be the Fruit of any of their own Endeavours, or the natural Confequence of the Faculties and Principles of human Nature, in fuch Circumftances, and under fuch ; Means ; but to be from the Influence of fome extrinfick and * That famous experimental Divine Mr. Shephard, lays, " A ** Pharifee's Trumpet fhall be heard to the Town's End ; when Sim- ** plicity walks thro' the Town unfeen. Hence a Man will fometimes *^ covertly commend himfelf (and myfelf ever comes in) and tells you ** a long Story of Converfion : And an hundred to one if fome Lie " or other flip not out with it. Why the fecret meaning is, / pray *' admire me. Hence complain of Wants and Weakneffes ; pray " think ivhat a broken-hearted Chrifiian I am.'*^ Parab. of the ten Virgins, Parti. Page 179, 180. And holy Mr. Flanjel fays thus, " O Reader, if thy Heart were " right with God, and thou didllnot cheat thyfelfwith a vain Pro- ** fefTion, thou woui'fl have frequent Bufmefs with God, v/hich thou ** would'ft be loth thy deareft Friend, or the Wife of thy Bofom, ** fnould be privy to. Non efi Religio, ubi omnia patent. Religion ** doth not lie open to all, to the Eyes of Men. Obferved Duties *' maintain our Credit ; but fecret Duties maintain our Life. It was ** the faying of a Heatheii, about his fecret Correfpondency with his " Friend, What need the World he acquainted ivifh it ? Thou and I ** are Theatre e?2ough to each other. There are cnclofed Pleafures in " Religion, which none but renewed fpiritual Souls do feelingly " underftand." //« Ws Tcuch-Hone of Sincerity, Chap. JI. Sed» 2. E 5? What are no Signs Part IL and fnpernatural Power upon their Minds. How greatly has the Dodrinc of the inward Experience or fenfiblc Perceiving of the immediate Power and Operation of the Spirit of God, been reproach'd and ridicul'd by many of late. They fay the Manner of the Spirit of God, is to co-operate in a Client, fecret and undifcern- able Way, with the Ufe of Means, and our own Endea- vours •, fo that there is no diftinguifliing by Senfe, be- tween the Influences of the Spirit of God, and the , natural Operations of the Faculties of our own Minds. And it is true, that for any to expedl to receive the faving Influences of the Spirit of God, while they neg- le6t a diligent Improvement of the appointed Means of Grace, is unreafonable Prefumption. And to expedt that the Spirit of God will favingly operate upon their Minds, without the Spirits making life of Means, as fubfervicnt to the Effedl, is enthufiailical. 'Tis alfo undoubtedly true, that the Spirit of God is very variovis in the Manner and Circumftances of his Operations, and that fometimes he operates in a Way more fecret and gradual, and from fmaller Beginnings, than at others. But if there be indeed a Power, entirely difl'erent from; and bcivond our Power, or the Power of all Means and; Inilruments, and above the Power of Nature, which is} requifice in order to the Produ6tion of laving Grace in the Heart, according to the general ProfefTion of thc; Counrry : Then certainly, it is in no wife unreafonable, to fuppofe, that this Effe6t lliould very -frequently be produced after fuch a Manner, as to make it very mani- ■ fed, apparent, and fenfible that it is fo. If Grace bei indeed ov/ing to the powerful and efficacious Operation i of an cx'criniick Agent, or divine Efficient out of our-| felves, v/hy is it unreafonable to fuppofe, it ffiould feem to be f ; to them who are the Subje^ls of it? Is it a f' range Hiins^. that it fhould feem to be as it is ? When Grace in the Heart, indeed is not produced by our Strenp:th. ncr is the Effect of the natural Power of our own Part II. to dijlinguijh Affediions. 59 own Faculties, or any Means or Inftruments, but is properly the Workmanlhip and Produdlion of the Spirit of the Almighty, is it a ftrange and unaccountable Thing, that it fhould feem to them who are Subjedts of it agreeable to Truths and not right contrary to Truth; fo that if Perfons tell of Effedls that they are confcious to in their own Minds, that feems to them not to be from the natural Power or Operation of their Minds, but from the fupernatural Power of fome other Agent, it fhould at once be looked upon as a fure Evidence, of their being under a Delufion, becaufe Things feem to them to be as they are? For this is the Objedlion which is made: 'Tis look'd upon as a clear Evidence that the Apprehcnfions and Affedlions that many Perfons have, are not really from fuch a Caufe, becaufe they feem to them to be from that Caufe : They declare that what they are confcious of feems to them evidently not to be from themfelves, but from the mighty Power of the Spi- rit of God; and others from hence condemn them, and determine what they experience is not from the Spirit of God, but from themfelves, or from the Devil. Thus unreafonably are Multitudes treated at this Day, by their Neighbours. If it be indeed fo, as the Scripture abundantly teaches, that Grace in the Soul is fo the EfFe6l of God's Power, that it is fitly compared to thofe Eftedls, which are fartheft from being owing to any Strength in the Subjedt, fuch as a Generation^ or a being begotten^ and Refurre^iion^ or a being rvjed from the Dead^ and Creaticr.^ or a being I brought out cf nothing into Beings and that it is an EiTe(5c I wherein the mighty Power of God is greatly glorified, I and the exceeding Greatnefs of his Power is manifefted*,* i then what Account can be given of it, that the Almighty, in fo great a Work of his Power, fliould fo carefully hide his Power, that the Subjects of it fliould be able to difcern nothing of it ? Or what Reafon or Revelatioii E 2 have *' Eph. i. 17, 18, 19, 2Q, 6o What are no SIgni Part. If. have any to determine that he does ib? If we may judgcr by the Scripture, this is not agreeable to God's Manner,^ in his Operations and Difpenfations^ but on the con- 1 trary, 'tis God's Manner, in the great Works of his»3 Power and Mercy, which he works for his People, tav order Things fo, as to make his Hand vifiblc, and his-j Power ccnlpicuous, and Men's Dependance on hini- moft evident, that no Flefh fhould glory in his Prefence,* that God alone miglit be exalted,f and that the Excel--, lency of the Power might be of God and not of Man, J and that Chrift's Power might be manifefled in our Weaknefs,§ and none might fay, mine own Hand hath faved me. II So it was in moft of thofe temporal Salva- tions which God wrought for Ifrael of old, which were Types of the Salvation of God's People from tlieirfpi- ritual Enemies. So it was in the Redemption of Ifraely fiom their Egyptian Bondage -^ he redeem'd them with a ftrong Hand, and an outflretched Arm ; and that his Power might be the more confpicuous, he fuffer'd Ifrael lirft to be brought into the moft helplefs and forlorn Circumftances. So it was in the great Redemption by Gideon-^ God would have his Army diminifhcd to a Handful, and they withoutany other Arms than Trum- . pets, and Lamps, and earthen Pitchers. So it was in the Deliverance of Ifrael from Goliath^ by a Stripling, with a Sling and a Scone. So it was in that great Work of God, his calling the Gentiles^ and converting the heathen Worlds after Chrift's Afcenfion-, affer that the "World by Wlfdom knew not God, and all ^he Endea- vours of Philofophers had proved in vain, for many Ages, to reform the World, and it was by every Things become abundantly evident that the World was utterly , helplefs, by any Thing elfe, but the mighty Power of God. And fo it was in moft of che Converfions of particular Perfons. we have an Account of in the Hiftory * I Cor, i. 27, 28, 29. t Ifai. ii. 1 1, 17. X z Cor. iv. 7. % Cor. xii. 9. jl Judg. vii. 2. Part IL to dijiinguijh Affecilom, -61 Hiflory of the New Teflament: They were not wrought on in that filent, fecret, gradual and infenfible Manner, which is now infifted on-, biitv/ith thofemanifefl: Eviden- ces of a fnpernatural Power, wonderfully and fuddenly caufing a great Change, which in tl^efe Days are looked upon as certain Signs of Delufion and Enthufiaim, The Apoftle, in Eph. i. 18, 19, fpeaks of God's en- lightninor.the Minds of Chriftians, and fo brino-ing; them to believe in Chrifr, to the End, \\\2iX. xht^ might know xkx^ exceeding Greatnefs of his Power to them who believe. The Words are, 1'he Eyes of your Underftanding being enlightned^ that ye may know what is the Hope of his Callings and what the Riches of the Glory of his Inheri- tance in the Saints^ and what is the exceeding Greatnefs of his Power to us-ward^ who believe^ according to the Work- ing of his mighty Power ^ &c. Now when the Apoftle fpeaks of their being thus the rubjefts of his Power, in their enlightning and effedual Calluig, to the End .that they might know what his mighty Power was to them who believe, he can mean nothing eife, than that ihey might know by Experience, But if the Saint know this Power by Experience, then they feel it, and difcerxi it, and are confcious of it^ as fenhbly diftinguiftiable -from the natural Operations of their own Minds which is not agreeable to a Notion of God's operating fo fecretly, and undifcernably, that it can't be known that they are the Subjedts of the Influence of any extrinfick Power at all, any .otherwife than as they may argue it from Scripture AfTertions-, which is a different Thing from knowing it by Experience. So that it is very unreafonable and unfcriptural, to determine that Affections are not from the gracious Ope-- rations of God's Spirit, becaufe they are fenfibly norfrora the Perfons themfeives^ that are the Subjeds of them. On the other Hand, it is no Evidence that Affeftions are gracious, that they are not purpolely produced by thofe who are the Subjeds of them, or that they arife in their Minds in a Manner they f an't account for. There 62 TPbat are no Signs Part. H, There arc fomc who make this an Argument in their own Favour, when fpeaking of what they have expe- rienced, they fay, "• I am fure I did not make it my- " felf : It was a Fruit ot no Contrivance or Endeavour " of mine-, it came when 1 thought nothing of it; if I *' might have the World for it, I can't make it again *' when 1 pleafe." And hence they determine, that what they have experienced, muft "be from the mighty In- fluence of the Spirit of God, and is of a faving Nature; but very ignorantly, and without Grounds. What they have been the Subje6ls of, may indeed, not be from themfelves diredlly, but may be from the Operation of an invifible Agent, fome Spirit befides their own : But it does not thence follow, that it was from the Spirit of God. There are other Spirits who have Influence o the Minds of Men, befides the Holy Ghofl. We an direded not to believe every Spirit, but to try the Spi rits, whether they be of God. There are many falfi Spirits, exceeding bufy with Men, who often transform' themfelves into Angels of Light, and do in many won derful Ways, with great Subtilty and Power, mimic the Operations of the Spirit of God. And there a many of Satan's Operations, which are very dillin- guifliable from the voluntary Exercifes of Men's ow Minds. They are fo, in thofe dreadful and horrid Sug geflions, and blafphemous Injections with which he fol-l lows many Perfons ; and in vain and fruitlefs Frightii, and Terrors, which he is the Author of. And the: Power of Safan may be as immediate, and as evident ia- falfe Comforts and Joys, as in Terrors and horrid Sug- geflions ; and oftentimes is fo in Fad. 'Tis not in Men's Power to put themfelves into fuch Raptures, as the: jinabaptifts in Germany^ and many other raving Enthu- fiafts like them, have been the Subje6ts of. And befides, it is to be confidered, that Perfons may have thofe Imprcfiions on their Minds, which may not be of their own producing, nor from an evil Spirit, but from the Spirit of God, and yet not be from any faving, Part. IL to difitnguijfj Jfedilom. 63 faving, but a common Influence of the Spirit of God: And the Subjedls of fuch ImprelTions, may be of the Number of thofe we read of, Heb. vi. 4, 5. T!hat are once enlightened^ and tafie of the heavenly Gift^ and are made Partakers of the Holy Ghoft^ and tafie the good Word of God^ and the Pozver of the World to come ; and yet may be wholly unacquainted with thofe better Things that accompany Salvation^ fpokenof ver, 9. And where neither a good nor evil Spirit have any immediate Hand, Perfons, efpecially fuch as are of a weak and vapoury Habit of Body, and the Brain weak, and eafily fufceptive of Impreflions, may have ll. an^e Apprehenfions and Imaginations, and ftrong AiTe6lions attending them, unaccountably arifmg, which are not voluntarily produced by themfelves. We lee that fuch Perfons are liable to fuch ImprefTions, about temporal Things ; and there is equal Reafon, why they Ihould about fpiritual Things, hsz Perfon who is alleep, has Dreams, that he is not the voluntary Author of; fo may fuch Perfons, in like Manner, be the Subjeds of invo- luntary ImprefTions, when they are awake. V. *Tis no Sign that religious Affeftlons are truly holy and fpiritual, or that they are not, that they come with Texts of Scripture, remarkably brought to the Mind. 'Tis no Sisrn that AfFedions are not gracious, that they are occafioned by Scriptures fo commg to Mind ; provided it be the Scripture itfelf, or the Truth which the Scripture fo brought contains and teaches, that is the Foundation of the Affedlion, and not merely or mainly the fydden and unufual Manner of its coming to the Mind. But on the other Hand, neither is it any Sign that Affedlions are gracious, that they arife on Occafion of Scriptures brought fuddenly and wonderfully to the Mind ; whether thofe Affections be Fear, or Plope, Joy, or Sorrow, or any other. Some feem to look upon this, a good Evidence that their Afiedtions are faving ^ efpecially if the Affedlions excited are Hope or Joy, or 64 What are no Signs Part II. or any other which are plcafing and delightful. They will mention it as an Evidence that all is right^ that their Experience came with tbi Word^ and will fay, " There were fuch and fuch fweet Promifes " brought to my Mind: They came fuddenly, as if '• they were fpoke to me : I had no Hand in bringmg " fuch a Text to my own Mind: I was not thinking of " any Thing leading to it-, it came all at once, fo that *' I was furprifed. I had not thought of it a long Time *' before; I did not know at firft that it was Scripture ; *' I did not remember that ever 1 had read it." And it may be, they will add, " One Scripture came flowing in " after another, and.fo Texts all over the Bible, the '' moll fweet and pleafant, and the moft apt and fuita- " ble, which could be devifed ; and filled me full as *' I could hold: I could not but ftand and admire: *' The Tears flow'd; I was full of Joy, and could not *' doubt any longer." And thus, they think they have undoubted Evidence, that their i\ ffedtions muft be from God, and of the right Kind, and their State good: But without any Manner of Grounds. How come they by any fuch Rule, as that if any AfFedlions or Experiences arife with Promifes, and comfortable Texts of Scrip- ture, unnaccountably brought to Mind, without their Recollection, or if a great Number of fweet Texts fol- low one another in a Chain, that this is a certain Evidence their Experiences are faving ? Where is any fuch Rule to be found in the Bible, the great and only fure Direc- tory in Things of this Nature? What deceives many of the lefs underilanding and confiderate Sort of People, in this Matter, feems to be this; That the Scripture is the Word of God, and has nothing in it which is wrong, but is pure and perfe6t : And therefore, thofe Experiences which come from the Scripture muft be right. But then it Ihould be confi- dered, Affedions may arife on occafion of the Scripture, and not properly come from the Scripture, as the ge- nuine Fruit of the Scripture, and by a right Ufe of it; but ^Part. II. to diftinguijl: j^ffeBiom, 65 but from an Abufe of it. All that can be argued from the Purity and Perfection of the Word of God, with Refped to Experiences, is this, that thofe Experiences which are agreeable to the Word of God, arc right, and can't be otherwife-, and not that thofe Atfedtions mufl be right, which ari.e on Occafion of the Word of God coming to the iVJind. What Evidence is there that the Devil can't bring Texts of Scripture to the Mind, and mifapply them^ to deceive Ferfons ? There feems to be nothing in this which exceeds the Power of Satan. 'Tis no Work of fnch mighty Power, to bring Sounds or Letters to Per- fons Minds, that we have any Reafon to fuppofe nothing fhort of Ominipotence can be fufficient for it. li Satan has Power to bring any Words or Sounds at all to Perfons Minds, he may have Power to bring Words contained in the Bible, There is no higher Sort of Power required in Men, to make the Sounds which cxprefs the Words of a Text of Scripture, than to m.ake the Sounds which exprefs the Words of an idle Story or Song. And fo the fame Power in Satan^y^mch. is fufficient to renew one of thofe Kinds of Sounds in the Mind, is fufficient to renew the other: The different Signification, which depends wholly on Cuftom, alters Aot the Cafe, as to Ability to make or revive the Sounds or Letters. Gr will any fuppofe, that Texts of Scripture are fuch fjcred Things, that the Devil durft not abufe them, nor touch them ? In this alfo they are miftaken. He who was bold enough to lay hold on Chrift himfelf, and carry him hither and thither, into the Wildernefs, and into an high Moun- tain, and to a Pinnacle of the Temple, is not afraid to touch the Scripture, and abufe that for his own Purpo- fes : As he fhev/d at the fame Time that he was fo bold with Chrift, he then brought one Scripture and another, to deceive and tempt hixm. And if Satan did prefume, and was permitted, to put Chrift himfelf in Mind of Texts of Scripture to tempt Him^ what Reafon have we to determine, that he dare not, or wiUfriot be per- mitted I 66 What are no Signs Part. II, mitted, to put wicked Men In Mind of Texts of Scrip- ture, to tempt and deceive them? And if Satan may thus abufe one Text of Scripture, fo he may another. It's being a very excellent Place of Scripture, a comfort* able and precious Promife, alters not the Cafe, as to his Courage or Ability. And if he can bring one com- fortable Text to the Mind, fohe may a Thoufand; and' may choofe out fuch Scriptures as tend moft to ferve hisPurpofe; and may heap up Scripture Promifes, ten- ding, according to the perverfe Application he makes o£] them, wonderfully to remove the rifmg Doubts, and t confirm the falfc Joy and Confidence of a poor deluded Sinner. We know the Devil's Inflruments, corrupt and here- tical Teachers, can and do pervert the Scripture, to their own and others Damnation; ^Pet,m.l6. We fee they have the free Ufe of Scripture, in every Part of it : There is no Text fo precious and facred, but they are permitted to abufe it, to the eternal Ruin of Multitudes of Souls: And there are no Weapons they make Ufe of with which they do more Execution. And there is no Manner of Reafon to determine, that the Devil is not permitted thus to ufe the Scripture, as well as his Inflru ments. For when the latter do it, they do it as his Inftrumcnts and Servants, and through his Inftigation and Influence : And doubtlefs he does the fame he infti- gates others to do : The Devil's Servants do but follow their Mafler, and do the fame Work that he does himlclf. And as the Devil can abufe the Scripture, to deceiv and dcftroy Men, fo may Men's own Folly and Corrupt tions, as well. The Sin which is in Men, adts like it's Father. Men's own Hearts are deceitful like the Devil, and ufe the fame Means to deceive. So that 'tis evident, that Perfons may have high Af- fedtions of Hope and Joy, arifmg on Occafion of Texts of Scripture, yea precious Promifes of Scripture coming fuddenly an4*remarkably to their Minds, as though they were Part II. to dijlinguipo AffeBiom* 67 were fpoke to them, yea a great Multitude of fuch Texts, foliowing one another in a wonderful Manner, and yet all this be no Argument that thefe AfFe6lions arc divine, or that they are any other than the Effedts of Satan's Delufions. And I would further obfervc, that Perfons may have raifcd and joyful Affedlions, which may come with the Word of God, and not only fo, but from the Word, and thofe Affe(5tions not be from Satan^ nor yet pro- perly from the Corruptions of their own Hearts, but from fome Influence of the Spirit of God with the Word, and yet have nothing of the Nature of true and faving Religion in them. Thus the flony Ground Hearers had great Joy from the Word ; yea, which is reprefented as ■arifmg from the Word, as Growth from a Seed ; and their Affections had, in their Appearance, a very great and exa6l Refemblance with thofe reprefented by the Growth on the good Ground, the Difference not appearing, till it was difcovered by the Conlequences, in a Time of Trial: And yet there was no faving Reli- gion in thefe Affedlions.* VI. 'Tis no Evidence that religious Affections arc faving, or that they are otherwife, that there is an Ap- pearance of Love in them. There are no profefTing Chriftians who pretend, that this is an Argument againft the Truth and faving Nature of religious Affections. But on the other Hand, there are fome who fuppofe, it is a good Evidence that Affections are from the fanCtifying and faving Influences of the Holy Ghofl. Their Argument is, that Satan cannot love\ this AfleCtion being direCtly contrary to the ^ Devil * Mr. Stoddardy in his Guide to Chrijfj fpeaks of it as a common Things for Perfons while in a natural Condition, and before they have ever truly accepted of Chrijly to have Scripture Profnijh come to them, WiX.)\a great deal of Refrejhing', which they take as Tokens ef Cod's Lorue^ and hope that God has accepted them ; and fo are confident ®f their good Eilate. Page 8, 9. ImpreiTion ^^;//zi? 1735. ^ 68 Wha^ are m Signs Part II, Devil, whofe very Nature Is Enmity and Malice. And it is true, that nothing is more excellent, heavenly and divine than a Spirit of true Chriflian Love to God and Men: 'Tis more excellent than X;^^Wf^^^, or Propbecyy or Miracles, or /peaking with the Tongue of Men and Angels. 'Tis the Chief of the Graces of God's Spirit, and the Life, Efience and Sum of all true Religion; and that by which we are moft conformed to Heaven, and moll contrary to Hell and the Devil. But yet it is ill arguing from hence, that there are no Counterfeits of it. It may be obferved, that the more excellent any Thing is, the more will be the Counterfeits of it. Thus there are many mare Counterfeits of Silver and Gold, than of Iron and Copper: Txicre are many falfe Diamonds and Rubies, but who goes about to counter- feit common Stones ? Tho' the more excellent Things are, the more difficult it is to make any Thing that fhall be like them, in their effential Nature and internal jj Virtue; yet the more manifold will the Counterfeits be, and the more will Art and Subtilty be exercifed and difplayed, in an exad Imitation of the Outward Appear- ance. Thus there is the greateft Danger of being cheated in buying of Medicines that are mofl excellent and fovereign, tho' it be mofl difficult to imitate them, with any Thing of the like Value and Virtue, and their Counterfeits are good for nothing when we have them. So it is with Chriflian Vertues and Graces ; the Subtilty of Satan, and Men's deceitful Hearts, are wont chiefly to be exercifed in counterfeiting thofe that are in higheft Repute. So there are perhaps no Graces that have more Counterfeits than Love and Humility; thefe being Vertues wherein the Beauty of a true Chriflian does efpecially appear. • But with Refpe6l to Love ; it is plain by the Scripture, that Perfons may have a Kind of religious Love, and yet have no faving Grace. Chrifl fpeaks of many pro- feffing Chriflians that have fuch Love, whofe Love will not continue, and fo fhall fail of Salvation, Matth. xxiv, 12 Part. II. to dijlhguijlj JffeBions, 6^ [2, 13. And hecaufe Iniq^uity Jloall abound^ the Love of many Jhall wax cold. But he that jhall endure unto the End^ the fame Jhall be faved. Which latter Words plainly ihew, that thofc fpoken of before, whofe Love fhould not endure to the End^ but wax cold^ fhonld not be faved. Ferfons may feem to have Love to God and Chrifl, yea to have very ftrong and violent Affedlions of this Nature, and yet have no Grace. For this was evidently the Cafe with many gracelefs JewSy fuch as cried Jefus up fo high, following him Day and Night, v/ithout Meat, Drink or Sleep ; fuch as faid^L^r^^, I will follow thee whitherfoever thou goeji^ and cried, Hcfannn^ to the. Son of David.-f The Apofyi feems to intimate, that there were many in his Days, who had a counterfeit Love to Chrifl, in Eph. vi. 24. Grace be with all them that love the Lord^ Jefus Chriji in Sincerity. The lafl Word, in the Origi- nal, Cigm^Gs in Incorruption-f which fhews that the Apo- flle was fcnfible that there were many who had a Kind of Love to Chrill, v/hofe Love was not pure and fpiritual. So alfo Chriftian Love to the People of God may be counterfeited. 'Tis evident by the Scripture, that there may be itrong Affe6tions of this Kind, without favino- Grace; as there were in the Galatians towards the Apoftle Pam\ when they were ready to pluck out their Eyes and give them to him; altho' the Apoftle exprefles his Fear that their Affedtions were come to nothing, and that he hid bellowed upon them Labour in vain, Gal.iv. 1 1, 15 VII. Perfons having rehgiousAffeftions of many Kinds accompanying one another, is not fufficient to determine whether they have any gracious AfFedions or no. Tho^ t Agreeable to this, Mr. Stoc/i/ard oUerveSy in his Gui^e to Chrifi, That Ibme Sinners >^^z;f Pangs of Jfe^icn, and gi'~je an Account that they find a Spirit of Lo^oe to God, and of their aiming at the Glory of God ^ ha-jing that 'which has a great Refe?nblance of fanjing Grace, and that fometi?nes their canmon Affe^ions are Jf ranger than Jawing. And fup- pofcs that fometimes natural Men may have fuch n^nolsnt Pangs of falfe Affedion to Gcd, that they may think themfihes 'luilling to be damned. Page 21, and 65, 70 What are no Signs Part IL Though falfe Religion is wont to be maimed and monilrous, and nor to have that Entirenefs and Symme- try of Parts, which is to be feen in true Religion ; yet there may be a great Variety of falfe Affedions together, that may refemble gracious Affedlions. 'Tis evident, that there are Counterfeits of all Kinds of gracious Affedions -, as of Love to God^ and Love to the Brethren^ as has been jufl: now obferved; fo of god- ly Sorrow for Sin^ as in Pharaoh^ Saul^ and Ahab, and the Children of Ifrael m the Wildernefs-, Exod. ix. 27. I Sam, xxiv. 16, 17. and xxvi. 21. i Kings xxi. 27. Numb. xtv. 39, 40. and of th€ Fear of God^ as in the Samaritans^ loho feared the Lord., and fermd their own Gods at the fame Time; 2 Kings xvii 32*33. andthofe Enemies of God we read of Pfal. Ixvi. 3. who through the Greatnefs of God's Power., fubmit themfelves to him^ or,* as it is in the Hebrew, lie unto him., i. e. yield a counterfeit Reverence and Submiflion-, fo of a gracious Gratitude., as in the Children of Ifrael^ who fang God's Praife at the red Sea, Pfal. cvi. 12. 'a,nd Na a man the Syrian^ after his miraculous Cure of his Leprofy, 2 Kings V. 15, &c. So of fpiritual Joy., as in the flony-ground Hearers Matth. xiii. 20. and particularly many of John the Bap4 tiflh Hearers, John v. '^^, So of Zeal, as in Jehu., 2 Kings X. 1 6. and in Paul before his Converfion, Gal, i. 14. Phil. ill. 6, and the unbelieving Jews, J^s xxu. ^,_, Rom, X. 2. So gracelefs Perfons may have earneft reli-'' gious De/ires, which may be like Balaam's Defires, , which he exprelTes under an extraordinary View that he had of the happy State of God's People, as diftinguillied from all the reft of the World, Numb, xxiii. 9, 10.. They may alfo have a ftrong Hope of etei-nal Life, as ; the Pharifees had. And as Men, while in a State of Nature, are capable of a Refemblance of all Kinds of religious Affedlions, ' fo nothing hinders but that they may have many of tliem together. And what appears in Fad does abundantly evince Part IL to dijlitiguijl: AffeBkm, yi evince that it is very often fo indeed. It feems commonly to be {o^ that when falfe Affe6tion£ are raifed high, there are many falfe Affedtions attend each other. The Multitude that attended Chriil into Jerufalem^ after that great Miracle of raifing Lazarus^ feem to be moved with many religious Affedlions at once, and all in a high Degree, They feem to be filled with Admiration^ and there was a Shew of an high Affedion of Love^ and alfo of a great Degree of Reverence^ in their laying their Garments on the Ground, for Chrift to tread upon-, and alfo of great G'ratitude to him, for the great and good Works he had wrought, praifing him with loud Voices for his Salvation*, and earneft Defires of the Coming of God's Kingdom, which they fuppofe J ejus was now about to f^t up, and lliewed great Ho'pes and raifed Expectations of it, expe5fing it "joould immediately appear •, and hence were filled with Joy^ by v/hich they were fo animated in their Acclamations, as to make the whole City ring with the Noife of them ; and appear'd great in their Zeal and forwardnefs to attend Jefus, and afTill him without further Delay, now in the Time of the great Feafl of the Pajfover^ to fet up his Kingdom. And it is ealy from Nature, and the Nature of the Af- fections, to give an Account why, when one Affe6tion is raifed very high, that it fhould excite others ; efpecially if the Affedlion which is raifed hig;h, be that of counter- teit Love^ as it was in the Multitude who cried Hofanna, This will naturally draw many other Afi^eclions after it. For, as was obferved before. Love is the Chief of the Afi'edions, and as it were the Fountain of them. Let us fuppofe a Perfon who has been for fome Time in ■ great Exercife and Terror thro' Fear of Hell, and his Heart weaken'd with Diilrefs and dreadful Apprehen- Rons, and upon the Brink of Defpair, and is all at once deliver'd, by being firmly made to believe, thro' fomc Delufion of Satan^ that God has pardon'd him, and accepts him as the Cbje6l of his dear Love, and pro- miies him ecernai Life: as fuppofe through fom^ifion, or 72 TVhat are no Signs Part IL or flrong Idea or Imagination, fuddenly excited in him, of a Perlbn with a beautiful Countenance, fmihng on him, and with Arms open, and with Blood dropping down, which the Perfon conceives to be Chrift, without any other Enlightning of the Underflanding, to give a View of the fpiritual divine Excellency of Chrift and his Fulnefs, and of the Way of Salvation reveal'd in the Gofpel; or perhaps by Ibme Voice or Words coming as if they were fpoke to him, fuch as thofe. Son he of good Cheer, thy Sins he forgiven thee ; or. Fear noi^ it is the Fathers good Fleafure to ^ive you the Kingdom -, which he takes to be immdiately ipoken by God to him, tho* there was no preceding Acceptance of Chrifl, or cloiing of the Heart with him : I fay, if we fhould fuppofe fuch a Cafe, what various Paffions would naturally croud at once, or one after another, into fuch a Perfon's Mind? It is eafy to be accounted for, from meer Principles of Nature, that a Perfon's Heart, on fuch an Occafion, Ihould be raifed up to the Skies with Tranfports of Joy, and be fill'd with fervent Affeflion, to that imaginary God or Redeemer, who he fuppofes has thus refcued him from the Jaws of fuch dreadful Deftrudion, that his Soul was fo amazed with the Fears of, and has received him with fuch Endearment, as a peculiar Favourite; and that now he ihould be hll'd v/ith Admiration and Gratitude, and his Mouth lliould be open'd, and be full of Talk about what jie has experienc'd -, and that, for a while, he ihould think and fpeak of fcarce any Thing elfe, and ihould feem to magnify that God who has done fo much for him, and call upon others to rejoice with him, and appear with a chearful Countenance, and talk with a loud Voice : and however before his Deliverance, he was full of Quarrellings againft the Juilice of God, that now it ihould be cafy for him to fubmit to God, and ov/n his Unworthinefs, and cry out againft himfelf, and appear to be very humble before God, and lie at his Feet as tame as a Lamb ; and that he fhould now confefs his UnworthinefSj and cry out, fFhy me? Why me? (like Saul^ Part. If; to iii/ii?2gmp JfeBiom. 73 Mke SauU who when Samuel told him that God had ap- pointed him to be King, makes anfwer,yfw? not I a Benja- mite, of the fmalleft of the 1'ribesof Ilrael, andmy Family the leafl of all the Families of the Tribe of Benjamin ? Where- fore then fpeakefl thou fo to me? Much in the Language of David^ the true Saint, 2 Sam. vii. 18. Who am ly and what is my Father'' s Houfe^ that thou hafi brought me hitherto!) Nor is it to be wonder'd at, that^now hefhould delight- to be with them who acknowledg'e and applaud his happy Circumftances, and ihould love and efteem atll fuch as admire him and \ hat he has experienc'd, and have violent Zeal againft all fuch as would make nothing <5f fuch Things, and be difpofed openly to feparate, ahd as it were to proclaim War with all who be not of his Party ; and Ihould now glory in his Sufferings, and be very much for condemning and cenfuring ail who Ifeem to doubt, or make any Difficulty of thele Things j and while the Warmth of his Affedions laft, Ihould be mighty forward to take Pains, and deny himfelf, to promote the Intereft of the Party who he imagines favour fuch Things, and feem earneflly defirous to encreafc the Number of them, as the Pharifees compafTed Sea and Land to make one Frofelyte,* And fo I might go on, and mention many other Things, Vs^hich will natu- rally arife in fuch Circumftances. He mufl have but ilightly confider'd human Nature, who thinks fuch Things as thefe can't arife in th's Manner, without any fUpernaturat Interpofition of divine Power. As from true divine Love flow all chriflian Affedlions, fo from a counterfeit Love in like Manner, naturally flow other falle Affcdlions. In both Cafes Love is the Fountain, and the other Affedions are the Streams, The * *' Aflbciating with go.dly Men don't prove that a Man has Grace : " Ahithcphel.yN2i^ David's Companion. Sorrows for the Afflidions "of the Church,^ and ^Defires for the Converfion of SouJs, don't "prove it. Thefe Things may be found in carnal Men, and fo cau " be no Evidences of Grace," Stoddard V Natxn cf fa Working, wiien it does convince Men, ** is by enlightening natural Confcience. The Spirit does not work '" by giving a Teftimouy, but by aililting natural Confcience to do ** its Work. Natural Confcience is the Inilrument in the Hand of ** Hand of God, toaccufe, condemn, terrify, and to urge toDutv. ** The Spirit of God leads Men into the Confideration of "their Oan- '** ger, and makes them to be aifecled therewith ; Prov. xx. 27. The * ' Spirit of Man is the CanAle of the Lordy fearching all the in-ojard " Farts of the Belly:' Stoddard'j Guide to Chrif, p. 44. § " The famous Mr. /'fr/^/wj diflinguiihes between thofe Sf^rrcr.vs ** that come through Connjiciions of Qmfcience, and jnelancholic Pa/Jions *^ ti •/'"■ S 2 What are no Signs Part II. And fome fpeak of a great Sight they have of their Wicked nefs, who really when the Matter comes to be well examined into and thoroughly weighed, are found to have little or no Conviflions of Confcience. They tell of a dreadful liard Heart, and how their Heart lies like a Stone-, wlicn truly they have none of thofc Things in their Minds or Thoughts, wherein the Hardnefs of Men's Hearts does really confifl. They tell of a dread- ful Load and Sink of Sin, a Heap of black and loath- fome Filthinefs within them ; when, if the Matter be carefully enquired into, they have not in View any Thing wherein the Corruption of Nature does truly confift, nor have they any Thought of any particular Thing wherein their Hearts are fmfuUy defective, or fall fnort of what ought to be in them, or any Exercife$ at all of Corruption in tjiem. And many think alfo they have great Convidions of their actual Sins, who truly have none. They tell how their Sins are fet in Order before them, they fee them ftand encompafling them round in a Row, with a dreadful frightful Appea? xance; when really they have not fo much as one of the Sins they have been guilty of in the Courfe of their Lives, coming into View, that they are affeded with the Agr gravations of. And if Perfons have had great Terrors, which really have been from the awakening and convincing Influences of the Spirit of God, it don't thence follow that their| Terrors muft needs ifTue in true Comfort. The unmor^*, tified Corruption of the Heart may quench the Spirit of God (after he has been ftriving) by leading Men to prefumptuous, and felf-exalting Hopes and Joys, as v/ell as otherwife. 'Tis not every "Woman who is really in Travail, that brings forth a real Child -, but it may be a monftrous Produ6lion, without any Thing of the Form or Properties of human Nature belonging to it. Pharaoh's ' ■ - ■ . ■ ■- 't ** rijing only fro7n mere Imaginations, Jirongly cenccinjed in the Brain; ^■^■■Kvhich he fays, tifually come on a Judden, like Lightning into a HoufeJ** Vol. I. of his Works, p. 385. j?ART. II. to Jiftingtd/Jj Jj-edfions. 83 11 PharaoJfs chief Baker, after he had lain in the Dungeon With Jofeph^ had a Vifion that raifed his Hopes, and he as hfted up out , of the Dungeon, as well as the chief urler ; but it v/as to be hanged. But if Comforts and Joys do not only come after great Terrors and Awakenings, but there be an Appea- irance of fuch preparatory Convidions and Humiliations, and brought about very diftin6lly, by fuch Steps, and in fuch a Method, as has frequently been obfervable in true Converts; this is no certain Sign that the Light ^nd Comforts which follow are true and faving. And for thcfe follovv^ino; Reafons, Firfi^ As the Devil can counterfeit all the faving Operations and Graces of the Spirit of God, fo he can counterfeit thofe Operations that are preparatory to Grace. If Satan can counterfeit thofe EiTeds of God's Spirit, which are fpecial, divine and fanclifying; fo that 11 there jQiall be a very great Refemblance, in all that can ■ be obferved by others ; much more eafily m.ay he imitate thofe Works of God's Spirit v/hich are common, and v/hich Men, v/hile they are yet his own Children, are the Subje6ls of. Thefe Works are in no wife fo much above him as the other. There are no Works of God that are fo high and divine, and above the Powers of Nature, and cut of the Re?.ch of the Pov/er of all Creatures, as thofe Works of his Spirit, whereby he forms the Creature in his ov/n Ima2;e, and makes it to be a Partaker of the divine Nature. But if the Devil can be the Author of fuch Refemblances of thefe as have been fpoken of, v/ithout doubt he m^ay of thofe that are of an infinitely inferior Kind. And it is abundantly evident in Fail, that there are falfe Humiliations, and falfe Submifiions, as well as falfe Comforts.* How far v^as * The venerable 5 Wng, and yet the Perfon that is the Subject of the^m, never be converted, but fall fhort of Salvation at laft/ There is no necefiary Connection in the Nature of Things, between anv Thing that a natural Man may experience, while in a State of Nature, and the faving Grace of God's Spirit. And if there be no Connexion in the Nature of Things, then there can be no known and certain Connexion at all, unlefs it be by divine Kevelation. But there is no revealed certain Conne6tion between a State of Salvation and any Thing that a natu- "^ ral Man can be the Subjed of, before he believes in Chrifl. God has revealed no certain Connection be- tween Salvation, and any Qualifications in Men, but onlv Grace and its Fruits. And therefore we don't find any legal Convidicns, or Comforts following thofe" legal 86 What are no Signs Part. Iu legal Con virions, in any certain Method or Order, ever once mention'd in the Scripture, as certain Signs of Grace, or Things peculiar to the Saints; akho* wc do find gracious Operations and Effeds themfclves, fa mention'd, Thoulands of Times. Which fhould be enough with Chriflians, who are willing to have the Word of God, rather than their own Philofophy, and Experiences and Conjtftures, as their fufhcient and fure Guide in Things of this Nature. Fourthly, Experience does greatly confirm, thatPer- fons feeming to have Convidlions and Comforts following. one another in fuch a Method and Order, as is frequently obfervable in true Converts, is no certain Sign of Grace.* I appeal to all thofe Miniftc s in this Land, who havef had much Occafion of dealinp- with Souls, in the late extraordinary Seafon, whether there have not been many who don't prove well, that have given a fair Account of their Experiences, and have feem'd to be converted according to Rule, /. e, with Convictions and Auedlions, fucceeding diflindily and exadly, in that Order and Method, which has been ordinarily infilled on, as the Order of the Operations of the Spirit of God in Con- verfion. And as a feeming to have this Diilinfbnefs as to Steps and Method, is no certain Sign that a Perfon is converted; fo a being without it, is no Evidence that a Perfon is not converted. For tho' it might be made evident to a Dcmonilration, on Scripture Principles, that a Sinner can't be brought heartily to receive Chrift as his Saviour, who is not convinced of his Sin and Mifery, and of his own Emptincfs and Helplefnefs, and his juft defert of eternal * Mr. Stoddard^ who had much Experience of Things of thii ; Nature, long ago obferved, that converted and unconverted Men can't be certainly dillinguiflied by the Account they give of their Experience : The fame Relation of Experiences being common to both. And that 7naity Perfons hanje ginjen a fair Account of a Work cf Con- 'verflon, that have carried Affedllom. 89 Bat yet there has been fo much to be feen of the Ope- raiions ot the Spirit of God, of late, that they who have had much to do with Souls, and are not blinded w.thafeven-fold Veil of Prejudice, muflknow that the Spirit is fo exceeding various in the Manner of his operating, that in many Cafes it is impolTible to trace hun, or find out his Way, What we have principally to do with, in our Enquiries into our own State, or Dired:ions we give to others, is the Nature of the EfFe6l that God has brought to pafs in tlie Soul. As to the Steps which the Spirit of God took to bring that EfFed to pafs, we may leave them to him. We are often in Sci'ipture cxprefly drreded to try ourfelves by the Nature of the Fruits of the Spirit j but no where by tht Spirit's Method of producing them.* Many do greatly err in their Notions of a clear Work of Converfion; calling that a clear Work, where the fucceffivc Steps of Influence, and Mrthod of Experi- ence is clear: Whereas that indeed is the cleareft Work (not where the Order of doing is cleareft^ but where the fpiritual and divine Nature of the Work done^ and Effect wrought^ is moft clear. IX. * Mr. Shepard, fpeaking of the Soul's clofmg with Chrift, fays, */ As a Child cannot tell how his Soul comes into it, nor it may be *' when; but afterwards it fees and feels that Life; fo that he were " as bad as aBeall, that ihould deny an immortal Soul; fo here.'* Parable of the teri Virgins, Part II. p. ijz. ** If the Man do not know the T/me of his Converfion, or firfl: *' clofing with Chriil; the Miniiler may not draw any peremptory *' Conclufion from thence, that he is not godly." Stoddard''^ Guide toChrifl, p. 13. *' Do not think there is no Compunftion, or Senfe of Sin, wrought ** in the Soul, becaufeyou cannot fo clearly difcern and feel it; nor ** the Time of the Working, and firll Beginning of it. I have " known many that have come with their Complaints, that they ivere * * ne'ver humbled, they ne'ver felt it fo ; yet there it hath been, and ** many Times they have feen it, by the other Spedacles, and blefs'd ** God for it." Shepard^s, found Believer, p. 38. the late Impref- fiOn in Bcfiji. G 90 What are no Sigm Part 11. IX. *Tis no certain Sign that the religious AfFedlions which Ferfons have are fuch as have in them the Nature of true Religion, or that they have not, that they dif- pofe Peribns to Ipend much Time in Religion, and to be zealoufly engaged in the external Duties of Worfhip. This has, very unreafonably, of late been looked upon as an Argument againft the religious AfFc6lions which fome have had, that they fpend fo much Time in reading, praying, finging, hearing Sermons, and the like. 'Tis plain from the Scripture, that it is the Ten- dency of true Grace to caufe Perfons very much to delight in fuch religious Exercifes. True Grace had this Effed on j^nna the Prophetefs; Luke i. ^y. Shs departed not from the temple ; but ferved God with Faji- ings and Prayers^ Night and Bay, And Grace had this Etfed upon the primitive Chriftians in Jerufalem\ A6ls ii. 46, 47. And they continuing daily ^ with one Accord in the l!emple^ and breaking Bread from Houfe to Houfe^ did eat their Meat with Gladnefsy and Singlenefs of Hearty praifing God, Grace made Daniel delight in the Duty of Prayer, and folemnly to attend it three Times a Day: As it alfo did David, Pfal. Iv. 17. Evenings Mornings and at Noon^ will I pray. Grace makes the Saints delight in fmging Praifes to God. Pfal. cxxxv. 3. Sing Praifes unto his Name J for it is pleafant. And cxlvii.. i . Praif^ ye the Lord^ for it is good to fing Praifes unto our God^ for it is pleafanty and Praife is comely. It alfo caufes them to delight to hear the Word of God preached. It makes the Gofpel a joyful Sound to them ; Pfal. Ixxxix. 15. And makes the Feet of thofe who pubiifh thefe good Tidings, to be beautiful : Ifai. lii. 7. How beautiful upon the Mountains are the Feet of him that bringeth good Tidings^ &c. It makes them lo/c God's publick Wor- fhip; Pfal. xxvi. 8. Lordy I have loved the Habitation of thy Houfe^ and the Place where thine Honour dwelleth. And xxvii. 4. One Thing have I defired of the Lor d^ that will I feek after y that I may dwell in the Houfe of the Lordj all the Bays of my Life \ to behold the Beauty of the Lordy Part. II. to di^inguifh JjfeBions, 91 Lord^ and to enquire in his Temple. Pfal ?xxxiv. 1,2, &c. — How amiable are thy Tabernacles^ O Lord cf Hofts! My Soul longeth^ yea even faint eth^ for the Courts of the Lord. — Tea the Sparrow hath found an Houfe^ and the Swallow a Nefi for herfelf where fjje may lay her Toung.^ even thine Altars^ O Lord of Hofts , my King and my God, Bleffed are they that dwell in thine Houfe\ they will beftill praijing thee. Bleffed is the Man in whofe Heart are the Ways of them^ who paffing through the Valley of Baca,— go from Strength to Strength .^ every one of them in Zion appear eth before God — Verfe 10. A Day in thy Courts is better than a Thoufand. This is the Nature of true Grace. But yet, on the other Hand, Pcrfons being difpofed to abound and to be zealoufly engaged in the external Exercifes of Reli- gion, and to fpend much Time in them, is no fure Evi- dence of Grace-, becaufe fuch a Difpofition is found in many that have no Grace. So it was with the Ifraelites of old, whofe Services were abominable to God; they attended the new Moons^ and Sabbaths., and calling of AffemblieSj and fprecd forth their Hands., and made many Prayers \ Ifai. i. 12, 15. So it was with the Fhari- fees ; they made long Prayers., and fafted twice a Week. Falfe Religion miay caufe Perfons to be loud and earneft in Prayer: iiai. Iviii. 4. Te fnall not faft as ye do this Day., to caufe your Voice to be heard on high. That Reli- gion which is not fpiritual and faving, may caufe Men to delight in religious Duties and Ordinances: Ifai Iviii. 2, Tet they feek me daily., and delight to know my Ways ; as a Nation that did Righteoufnefs., and forfook not the Ordi- nance of their God They afk of me the Ordinances of Juftice^ they take delight in approaching to God. It may caufe them to take Delight in hearing the Word of God preached-, as it v/as with Ezekiel'% Hearers, Ezek. xxxiii. 31, 32. And they come unto thee as my People cometh., and they ft t before thee as my People., and they hear thy Words 1, but they will -lot do them : for with their Mmth they fhew much Love \ but their Heart go eth after their Covet oufnefs. G 2 And gi What are no Signs Fart. If, ylnd lo, thou art unto tbem^ as a very lovely Song^ of one" that hath a pleafant Voice^ and can -play well on an Injlru- ment : For they hear thy TVords^ but they do them net. So it was with IJerod, he heard John the Baptift gladly z- Mark vi. 20. So it was with others of his Hearers, for a Seafon., they rejoiced in his Light; John v. 35. So the ilony-ground Plearers heard the Word with Joy, Experience fhcws that Perfons, from falfe Religion, may be indined to be exceeding abundant in the exter- nal Exercifes of Religion-^ yea, to give themfelves up to them, and devote almoil their whole Time to them. Formerly a Sort of People were very numerous in the Rcmifh Church, called Reclufes\ who forfook the "Worlds and utterly abandon'd the Society of Mankind, and lliut themfelves up clofe, in a narrow Cell, with a Vow never to ftir out of it, nor to fee the Face of any of Mankind anymore; (unlefs that they might be vifited in Cafe of Sicknefs) to fpend all their Days in the Exer- cifes of Devotion and Converfe with God. There were , alfo in old Time, great Multitudes called Hermits- and Anchorites^ that left the World to fpend all their Days in lonefome Defarts, to give themfelves up to religious Contemplations and Exercifes of Devotion-, fome Sorts of them having no Dwellings, but the Caves and Vaults ©f the Mountains, and no Food, but the fpontaneous Productions of the Earth. 1 once lived for many Montlis, next Door to a Jewy (the Houfes adjoining one to another) and had much Opportunity daily to obfervchim-, who appeared to m.e the devoucefl Perfoa that ever I faw in my Life : great Part of his Time being fpent in Ads of Devotion, at his eaflern Window, which open'd next to mine, feeming to be mofl earneftly engaged, not only in the Day Time, but fometimes whole Nights. X. Nothing can be certainly known of the Nature of religious Aifedlions by this, that they much difpofe Perlons with their Mouths to pralfe and glo-rify God. . This tPART IL to dijlingutjh Affe5fions. 93 This indeed is impliedin what has been juft now obferved, of abounding and fpending much Time m the external Exercifes of Religion, and was alfo hjpted before ; but becaufe many feem to look upon it as a bright Evi lence of gracious A fFeftion, when Perfons appear greatly dif- pofed to praife and magnify God, to have their Mniths full of his Praifes, and affe6lionately to be cailmg on others .to praife and extol him, I thought it deferved a more particular Confideration. No Chriftian will make it an Argument again ft a Per- son, that he feems to have fuch a Dilpofition. Nor can it reafonably belook'd upon as an Evidence for a Perfun, tf thofe Things that have been already obferved and proved, "be duly confidered, 'Viz, that Perfons, without Grace, may have high AfFc6lions towards God and Chrift, and that their Affeftions, being ftrong, rnay fill their Mouths, and incline them to fpeak much, and ve y earneftly, about the Things they are affeded wiih, and that there may be Counterfeits of all Kinds of gracious Affedion. But it will appear more evidently an \ diredlly, that this is no -certain Sign of Grace, if we confider what Inftances the Scripture gives us of it in thofe that were gracelefs. We often have an Accou-nt of this, in the Multitude that were prefent when Chrift preached and wrought Miracles; Mark ii. 12. ,And immediately .he arofe^ took up his Bed^ and went forth before them all: Infomuch that they were all amazed-, and glorified God^ faying^ We never f aw it on.this Fafhion! So Matth. ix. 8. and Luke V. 26. Alfo Matth. x v. 3.1. Infomuch that the Multitude wondered^ when they faw the Dumb to fpeaky and the Maimed to be whole^ the Lame to walk, and the Blind to fee\ and they glorified the God of IfraeL So we are told, that on Gccafion of Chrift's raifmg the S'jii of the Widow of Nain, Lirlce vii. 16. 'There came a great Fear on all-, and they glorified God, faying., that a great ' Prophet is rifen up among us, and that God hath vifited his People, So we read of their glorifying Chrift, or ^caking exceeding highly of him, Luke iv. 15. And he taught 94 What are no Signs Part. II. taught in their Synagogues^ being glorified of all. And how did they praiie him with loud Voices, crying. Ho- fanna to the Son of David, U of anna in the Higheji, Blef- fed is he that coMeth in the Name of the Lordy a little before he was crucified ! And after Chrift's Afcenfion, when the Apoftles had hcal'd the impotent Man, we are told, that all Men glorified God for that which was done^ A(5ts iv. 2 1. When the Gentiles in Antioch of Fiftdiay heard from Paul and Barnabas^ that God would reje6t the 'jewSy and take the Gentiles to be his People in their Room, they were affeded with this Goodnefs of God to the G entiles y and glorified the Word of the herd: But all that did fo, were not true Believers •, but only a certain cle6l Number of them; as is intimated in the Account wc have of it-, A6ls xiii. 48. And when the Gentiles heard this^ they were glad^ and glorified the Word of the Lord\ and as many as were ordained to eternal Life^ believed. So of old, the Children of Ifrael^ at the Red Sea, fang God's Praife , but foon forgat his Works. And the Jews in Ezekiel's Time, with their Mouth fhewed much Love^ while their Heart went after their Covetoufnefs, And 'tis foretold of falfe Profellbrs, and real Enemies of Reli-^ gion, that they Ihould Ihew a Forwardnefs to glorify God; Ifa'i Ixvi. 5. Hear ye the Word of the Lord^ ye that tremble at his Word: Tour Brethren that hated yoUy that caft you out for my Nam^^s Sake^ faid^ Let the Lord he glorified. ' I IS no certain Sign, that a Perfon is gracioufly affedt/d, if in the Midftof his Hopes and Comforts, he is greatly affeded with God's unmerited Mercy to him that is fo unworthy, and fcems greatly to extol and mag- nify free Grace. Thofe that yet remain with unmorti^ fied Pride and Enmity againft God, may, when they imagine that they have received extraordinary Kindnefs from God, cry out of their bnworthinefs, and magnify God's undeferved Goodnefs to them, from no other Convidtions of their Ill-deferv ings, and from no higher Principle, than 6'ii Works. And iays, that the Spirit iv ill Jig hy and not Jing in that Brojom, 'whence corrupt Di/pojitions and Pajjioni break cut. And that though Men in J'uch Frames may feem to maintain ihe Confolation of the Spirit, and not fu/pe^ their Hypocrify, under Pretence of trujiing the Lorct s Mercy y yet thcj cannot avoid the Con-- demrHLtion of the Word. Parable of the ten Virgins, Part L p. iJ'Q. I Part II. to diflinguifh Affediions. 105 And here |[ can't but obferve, that there are certairi Doflrines often preached to the People, which need to ! be delivered With more Caution and Explanation than (they frequently are; for as they are by many underftood, 1 they tend greatly to eftabllfh this Delufion and falfe Con- fidence of Hypocrites. The Do6lrines I fpeak of are thofe of Chrifiians living hy Faith ^ not by Sight-, their giving Glory to God^ hy trujling him in the Dark\ living uponChrift^ and not upon Experiences-, not making their good Frames the Foundation of their Faith * Which are excellent and important Do(5lrines indeed, rightly under- ftood, but corrupt and deftru6tive, as many underftand them. The Scripture fpeaks of living or walking by IFairh, and not by Sight, in no other Way than thefe, mz. a being governed by a Refped to eternal Things, ithat are the Objeds of Faith, and are not feen; and not [by a Refpe6l to temporal Things, which are feen; and ;believing Things revealed that we never faw with bodily Eyes •, and alfo living by Faith in the Promife of future Things ; without yet feeing or enjoying the Things pro- mifed, or knowing the Way how they can be fulfilled* iThis will be eafily evident to any one that looks over the Scriptures which fpeak of Faith in Oppofiticn to \Sight', as 2 Cor. iv. 18, and v. 7. Heb. xi. i, 8, 13, 17, 27, 29. Rom. viii. 24. John xx. 29. But this Dodrine, as it is underftood by many, is, that Chriftians ought iirmly to believe and truft in Chrift, without fpiritual Sight or Light, and altho' they are in a dark dead Frame, and, for the prefent, have no fpiritual Experiences or Difcoveries. And it is truly the Duty of thofe who are thus in Darknefs, .to come out of Darknefs, into Light, and Dr. Jmes fpeaks of it as a Thing, by which the Peace of a wicked Man may be diftinguilhed from the Peace of a godly Man, " that " the Peace of a wicked Man continues, whether he performs the '* Duties of Piety and Righteoufnefs, or no; provided thofe Crimes " are avoided that appc^ir horrid to Nature itfelf," Cafes of Con- fcience, Lib. IIL Chap. 7, H io6 What are no Signs Part \h and believe. But that they fhould confidently believe and iruft, while they yet remain without fpiritual Light ; or Sio:ht, is an antifcriptural and abfurd Dodlrine. The Scripture is ignorant of any fuch Faith in Chrift of the Operation of God, that is not founded in a fpiritual Sight of Chrift: That believing on Chrift, which accom- panies a Title to everlafting Life, is 2i feeing the Son., and believing on hinij John vi. 40. True Faith in Chriftis never exercifed, any further than Perfons behold as in a Glafs^ the Glory of the Lord., and have the Knowledge of the Glory of God in the Face of Jefus Chrifi-, 2 Cor. xviii. and iv. 6. They into whofe Minds the Light of the glorious Gofpel of Chrift., who is the Image of God., does not fhine: i'hey believe not-, 2 Cor. iv. 4. That Faith, which is without fpiritual Light, is not the Faith of the Children of the Light, and of the Day, but the Pre- fumption of the Children of Darknefs. And therefore to prefs and urge Men to believe, without any fpiritual Light or Sight, tends greatly to help forward the Delu- fions of the Prince of Darlcnefs. Men not only can't exercife Faith without fome fpiritual Light, but they can exercife Faith only juft in fuch Proportion as they have fpiritual Light. Men will truft in God no further than they know him : And they can't be in the Exercife of Faith in him one Ace further than they have, a Sight of his Fulnefs and Faithfulncfs in Exercife. Nor can they have the Exercife of Truft in God, any further than they are in a gracious Frame. They that are in a dead carnal Frame, doubtlefs ought to truft in God; becaufe that would be the fame Thing as coming out of their bad Frame, and turning to God: But to exhort Men. confidently to truft in God, and fo hold up their Hope and Peace, tho' they are not in a gracious Frame, and continue ftill to be fo, is the fame Thing in Effe6b, as 1 to exhort them confidently to truft in God, but not witha gracious Truft: And what is that but a wicked Pre- fumption? It is juft fo impofTible fo»* Men to have a ftrong or lively truft in God, when they have no lively Exercifes Part. IL to dijllnguijlo Affedlions. 107 Exercifes of Grace, or feniible chriftian Experiences, as it is for them to be in the lively Exercifes of Gracej^ without the Exercifes of Grace. 'Tis true, that it is the Duty of God's People to truft in him, when in Darknefs, and tho' they remain dill in Darknefs, in that Senfe, that they ought to trull in God when the Afpeds of his Providence are dark, and look as thoug;h God had forfaken them, and did not hear their Prayers, and many Clouds gather, and many Enemies fitrround them, with a formidable Afpe6t, threatning to fwallow them up, and all Events of Providence feem to be againft them, all Circumilances feem to render the Promifes of God difncult to be fullfil'd, and God mufl be trufted out of Sight, i. e. when we can't fee which Way it is polTible for him to fuUfil his Word, every Thing but God's meer Yv^ord makes it look unlikely ; fo that if Perfons believe, they muft Hope againft Hope. Thus the ancient Patriarchs^ and Job^ and the Pfalmiil, and Jeremiah^ Daniel^ Shadrach^ Meftoech^ and Adednego^ and the Apoftle Faul^ gave Glory to God. by trufting in God in Darknefs. And Vve have many Inftances cf fuch a glorious vidorious Faith in the Eleventh of the Hehreisos. But how different a Thing is this, from trufting in God without fpiritual Sight, and being at the fam.e Time in a dead and carnal Frame! There is alfo fuch a Thing as fpiritual Light's being let into the Soul in one Way, when it is not in another; and fo there is fuch a Thino; as the Saints truftino; ia God, and alfo knowing their good Eftate, when they are deftitute of fome Kinds of Experience. As for Inftance, they may have clear Views of God's Sufficiency and Faithfulnefs, and fo confidently truft in him, and know that they are his Children; and at the fame Time, not have thofe clear and fweet Ideas of his Love, as at other Times : For it was thus with Chrift himfelf in his laft Pafilon. And they may have Views of much of God's Sovereignly, Holinefs and Allfufficiency, enabling them quietly to fubmit to him, and exercife a fweet and H 2 moft io8 Wljat are no Signs Part. II. moil encouraging Hope in God's Fulnefs, when they are not fatisfied of their own good Eftate. But how different Things are thefe, from confidently trulling in God, without Tpiritual Light or Experience! Thofe that thus infift on Perfons living by Faith, when they have no Experience, and are in very bad Frames, are alio very abfurd in their Notions of Faith, What they mean by Faith is, believing that they are in a good Eflate. Fience they count it a dreadful Sin for them to doubt of their State, whatever Frames they are in, and whatever wicked Things they do, becaufe 'tis the great and heinous Sin of Unbelief; and he is the beil Man, and puts mod Honour upon God, that main- tains his Hope of his good Eftate the moft confidently and immoveably, when he has the leaft Light or Expe- rience •, that is to fay, when he is in the word and wick- edefh Fram.e and Way ; becaufe, forfooth, that is a Sign that he is ftrong in Faith, giving Glory to God, and againfl Hope believes in Hope. But what Bible do they learn this Notion of Faith out of, that it is a Man's confidently believing that he is in a good Eftate ?* If this be Faith, the Fharifees had Faith in an eminent Degree ; fome of which, Chrift teaches, committed the upardonable Sin againft 'the Holy Ghoft, The Scripture reprefents Faith, as that by which Men are brought into a good Eftate ; and therefore it can't be the fame Thing, as believing that they are already in a good Eftate. To fuppofe * ** Men don't know that they are godly, by believing that they ** are godly. We knov/ many Things by Faith, Heb. xi. 3. By Faith ■** ^ws underjiand that the Worlds 'uuere made by the Word cf God. Faith " is the Evidence of Things notfeen; Heb.xi. I. Thus Men know " the Trinity of Perfons of the Godhead; that Jefus Chriil is the " Son of God; that he that believes in him will have eternal Life; ** the Refurret5lion of the Dead. And if God lliould tell a Saint ** that he liath Grace, he might know it by believing the Word of *' God. But it is not this Way, that godly Men do know that they ** have Grace. It is not revealed in the Word ; and the Spirit of ^* God doth not telHfy it to particular Perfons." Stoddard'^ Nature •f faving Converfion, p. 83, 84. Part II. to dijlinguljh Affe^iions. jop fuppofe that Faith confifls in Perfons believing that tlicy are in a good Eftate, is in EfFed the fame Thing, as to fuppofe that Faith confifts in a Perfon's believing that he ^as Faith, or in believing that he believes. Indeed Perfons doubting of their good Eflate, may in feveral Relpedls arife from Unbelief, k may be from Unbelief, or becaufe they have fo little Faith, that they have fo little Evidence of their good Eftate: If they had .more Experience of the A<5lings of Faith, and fo more Experience of the Fxercife of Grace, they would have <;learer Evidence that their State was good ; and fo their Poubts would be removed. And then their doubtino- of their State may be from Unbelief thus. When tho* there be^ many Things that are good Evidences of a Work of Grace in them, yet they doubt very much v^hether they are really in a State of Favour with God, becaufe it is they.^ thofe that are fo unworthy,- and have done fo much to provoke God to Anger againft them. Their Doubts in fuch a Cafe arife from Unbelief, as they arile from want of a fufficient Senfe of^ and Reliance on the infinite Riches of God's Grace, and the Sufficiency of Chrift for the Chief of Sinners. They may alio be from Unbelief, when they doubt of their State, becaufe of the Myftery of God's Dealings with them.: They are not able to reconcile fuch Difpenfations with God's Favour to them : Or when they doubt whether they have any Intereft in the Promifes, becaufe the Promifes from the Afpe6ls of Providence, appear fo unlikely to be fulfilled ; the Difficulties that are in the Way, are fo many and great. Such Doubting arifes from want of Dependance upon God's Almighty Power, and his Knowledge and "Wifdom, as infinitely above theirs. But yet, in fuch Perfons, their Unbelief, and their doubting of their State, are not the fame Thing; tho* one arifes from the other. Perfons may be greatly to blame for doubting of their State, on fuch Grounds as thefe laft mentioned; and they may be to blame, that they have no more Grace, and no more of the prefent Exercifes and Experiences of no What are no Signs Part II . of it, to be an Evidence to them of the Goodnefs of their State : Men are doubtlefs to blame for being in a dead carnal Frame; but when they are in fuch a Frame-, and have no fenfible Experience of the Ex- ercifes of Grace, but on the contrary, are very much under the Prevalence of their Lulls, and an unchri- ftian Spirit, they are not to blame for doubting of their State. 'Tis as impofiible, in the Nature of Things, that a holy and chriflian Hope, fhould be kept alive, in its Clearnefs and Strength, in fuch Cir- cumilances, as it is to keep the Light in the Room, when the Candle is put out-, or to maintain the bright Sun-fliine in the Air, when the Sun is gone down. Diflant Experiences, when darken'd by prefent prevail- ing Luft and Corruption, will never keep alive a gracious Confidence and AfTurance-, but that fickens and decays upon it, as neceflarily as a little Child by repeated Blows on the Head with the Hammer. Nor is it at all to be lamented, that Perfons doubt of their State in fuch Cir- cumftances •, but on the Contrary, 'tis defirable and every Way be!^- that they Ihould. 'Tis agreeable to that wife and merciful Conftitution of Things, which God hath eflabliflied, that it fhould be fo. For fo hath God contrived and conflituted Things, in his Difpenfations towards his own People, that when their Love decays, 2nd the Exercifes of it fail, or become weak, Fear fliould arife: for then they need it to reflrain them from Sin, and to excite them to care for the Good of their Souls, and fo to flir them up to Watchfulnefs and Diligence in Religion : But God hath fo order'd that when Love rifes, and is in vigorous Exercife, then Fear Ihould vanifh, and be driven away ; for then they need it not; having a higher and more excellent Principle in Exercife, to reflrain them from Sin, and flir them up to their Duty. There are no other Principles, which human Nature is under the Influence of, that will ever make Men confci- entious, but one of thefe two. Fear or Love: And therefore if one of thefe fhould not prevail, ^s the other dec ay 'd Fart. II. to dijltngmjh AffeSltonsl iii decay'd, God's People when fallen into dead and carnal Frames, when Love is afleep, would be lamentably expofed indeed. And therefore God has wifely ordained, that thefe two oppofite Principles of Love and Fear, fhould rife and fall, like the two oppofite Scales of a Ballance; when one rifes, the other fmks. As Light and Darknefs, necelTarily and unavoidably fucceed each other; if Light prevails, fo much does Dark' efs ceafe, and no more \ and if Light decays, fo much does Dark- nefs prevail; fo it is in the Heart of a Child of God: If divine Love decays and falls afleep, and Lull prevails, tlie Light and Joy of Hope goes out, and dark Fear and Doubting arifes; and if on the Contrary, divine Love prevails, and comes into lively Exercife, this brings in the Brightnefs "of Hope, and drives away black Lull, and Fear with it. \ ove is the Spirit of Adoption^ or the Child-like Principle; if that Sknnbers, Men fall under Fear, which is tne Spirit of Bondage, or the fervile Principles : And fo on the contrary. And if it be fo, that Love or the Spirit of Adoption, be carried to a great Height, it quite drives away all Fear, and gives full AlTurance; agreeable to that of the Apollle, I John iv. 1 8. There is nu F^ar in Love, hut perfeil Love cafis out Fear, Thefe two oppofite Principles of Lull and holy Love, bring Hope and Fear into the Hearts of God's Children, in Proportion as they prevail; that is, when left to their own natural Influence, without fome- thing adventitious, or accidental intervening; as the Difl:emper of Melancholly, dodrinal Ignorance, Preju- dices of Education, wrong Infl:ru6lion, faife Principles, peculiar Temptations, ^c. Fear is caft out by the Spirit of God, no other Way than by the prevailing' of Love: Nor is Afllirance ever maintained by his Spiiit, when Love is afleep. At fuch a Time, in vain is ali the Saint's Self-Examinations, and poring on pafl: Experiences, in order to ellablifli his Peace, and get Alfurance, For it is contrary to the Nature of Things, as God hath conftituted them, that he fliould have AlTurance at fuch a Time, They 112 What are no Sigus Part II, They therefore, do dire^lly thwart God's wife and gracious Conflitution of Things, who exhort others to be confident in their Hope, when in dead Frames ; under a Notion of living hy Faith^ and not by Sights and trufting God in the Dark^ and living upon Chrift^ and not upon Experiences-^ and warn them not to doubt of their good Eftate, left they fhould be guilty of the dreadful Sin of Unbelief. And it has a dire6t Tendency to eftablifh the moft prefumptuous Hypocrites, ^nd to prevent their ever calling their State in Queftion, how much foever Wickednels rages, and reigns in their Hearts, and prcr vails in their. Lives;' under a Notion of honouring God, by hoping againft Hope^ and confidently trufting in God^ when Things look very dark. And doubtlefs vaft has been the Mifchief, that has been done this Way. Perfons can't be faid to forfake Chrift, and live on their Experiences of the Exercifes of Grace, merely becaufe they take them and ufe them as Evidences of Grace •, for there are no other Evidences that they can or ought to take. But then may Perfons be faid to live upon their Experiences, when they make a Righteouf- nefs of them ; and inftead of keeping their Eye on God's Glory, and Chrift's Excellency, they turn their Eyes off thcfe Objecls without them, on to themfelves, to enter- tain their Minds, by viewing their own Attainments, and high Experiences, and the great Things they have met with, and are bright and beautiful in their own Eyes, and are rich and encreafed with Goods, in their own Apprehenfions, and think that God has as admiring an Efteem of them, on the fame Account, as they hav6 of themfelves: This is living on Experiences, and not on Chrift-, and is more abominable in the Sight of God, than the grofs Immoralities of thofe who make no Pre- tences to Religion. But this is a far different Thing from a mere improving Experiences as Evidences of an Intereft in a glorious Redeemer. But to return from this DigrelTion, I would mention one Thing more under the general Head that I am upon. XII. Part. IL to hifiingmP:^ Afeciiom. iij XII. Nothing can be certainly concluded concerning the Nature of religious Affedion^, that any are the Subjcds of, from this, that the outward Manifefrations of them, and the Relation JPerfons give of them, are very affecting and pleafing to the truly Godly, and fuch as greatly gain their Charity, and win their Hearts. The true Saints have not fuch a Spirit of difcerning, that they can certainly determine who are godly, and who are not. For tho' they know experimentally what true Religion is, in the internal Exerciles of it-, yet thefe are what they can neither feel or fee, in the Heart of another.* There is nothing in others, that comes within their View, but outward Manifefiations and Appear- ances; but the Scripture plainly intim.ates, th^t this Way of judging what is in Men by outward Appearances, is at belt uncertain, and liable to Deceit; i Sam. xvi. 7. ^he Lord fe^th not as Man feeth\ for Man looketh en the outward Appearance^ lut the Lord looketh on the Heart, Ifai. xi. 3. He Jhall not judge after the Sight of his Eyes^ neither reprove after the Hearing of his Ears.-\- They jcommonly are but poor Judges, and dangerous Counfel- Jors in Soul Cafes, who are qukk and peremptory in determining * *' Men may have the Knowledge of their own Converfion : The *« Knowledge that other Men have of it is uncertain ; becaufe no Man * can look into the Heart of another, and fee the Workings of Grace ' there." Stoddard's Nat. of faving Con. Chap. 15, at the Begin- ning. f Mr. Stoddard obferves, That a!l 'vijihle Signs are common to ccn- ^verted and uncon-ucrted Men-y and a Relation of Experiences among the reft. Appeal to the Learned^ P* 75* ** O how hard is it for the Eye of Man t(^ difceru betwixt Chaff" *' and Wheat! And how many upright Hearts are jiow cenfured, *' whom God vv^ill clear! How many falfe Hearts are now approved, ** whom God will condemn ! Men ordinarily have no convii>ive " Proofs^ but only probable Symptoms ; winch at moft beget but a "** conjedlural Knowledge of another's State. And they that flialj •* peremptorily judge either Way, may pofTibly wrong the Gencra- '*• tion of the Upright, or on the other Side, abfolve and jullify tlie " Wicked. And truly, confidering what hath been faid, 'tis no -** Wonder that dangerous Miftakes are fo frequently made in this ■** Matter." FU'veh Huib. fpir. Chap. 12, 114 What are no Signs Part. IL determining Perfons States, vaunting themfelves in their extraordinary Faculty of difcerning and dillinguifhing, in thefe great Affairs ; as tho' all was open and clear to them. They betray one of thefe three Things; either that they have had but little Experience, or are Perfons of a weak Judgment; or that they have a great Degree of Pride and Self-Confidence, and fo ignorant of them- felves. Wife and experienced Men will proceed with great Caution in fuch an Affair. When there are many probable Appearance3 of Piety in others, it is the Duty of the Saints to receive them cor^ dially into their Charity, and to love them and rejoice in them, as their Brethren in Chrift Jefus. But yet the bell of Men may be deceived, when the Appearances feem to them exceeding fair and bright, even fo as entirely to gain their Charity, and conquer their Hearts. It has been a common Thing in the Church of God, for fuch bright Profeffors, that are received as eminent Saints, among the Saints, to fall away and come to nothing.* And this v/e need not wonder at, if we con- der the Things that have been already obferved; what Things it has been fhewn, may appear in Men who are altogether gracelefs. Nothing hinders but that all thcfc Things * " Be not offended, if you fee great Cedars fall. Stars fall from *' Heaven, great Profeffors die and decay: Do not think they be ail '• fuch : Do not think that the Eled fliall fall. Truly, fome are fuch, " that when they fall, one would think a Man truly fandlified might "fall away, as the Arminians think. I John ii. 19. They