''■'>Bi>?^^i'^Mm^ D'/<; ' L I B PI A- R Y 11- Tilt". Theological Seminary. PRINCETON, N. J. BL 80 .A74 1853 Cas Arnold, John Muehleisen, She 1817-1881. I r. True and false religion Boc L 0/2. /%^ ^ a^^i^ 4C^x ^^^ «^^ ^^-tT- ««>^»^^*. TU^./a- /^^3 ^Vr TRUE AND FALSE RELIGION: A COMPENDIOUS, SCRIPTURAL AND CONSECUTIVE VIEW OF THE ORIGIN, DEVELOPMENT, AND CHARACTER OF DIFFERENT SYSTEMS OF BELIEF. EEV. DR. J. MUEHLEISEN ARNOLD, CHAPLAIN OP ST. MARY's HOSPITAL, PADDINGTON ; FELLOW OP THE ROYAL ASIATIC SOCIET? OP GBEAT BRITAIN AND IRELAND; CORRESPOK DI SG MEMBER OF THE EGYPTIAN LITERARY ASSOCIATION; AND MEMBER OP THE GERMAN ORIENTAL SOCIETY. Si tameii in eo erraverim et amice de errore monear, seu publice ieu privatim, aures praebebo : in hoc unum intentus, ut hi aliique labores mei cedant ad triumphum verifatis et fidei Evangelicse, ultimumqne fineni omtiium actionum nostrarum gloriam solius et uniiis veri Dei, Patris-, Filii et Spiritus Sancti. REPUBLISHED IN ONE VOLUME. LONDOx\ : J. H. JACKSON, 21, PATERNOSTER ROW SEELEYS, FLEET STREET AND HANOVER STREET. 1853. I^rrfare. The Author of the following pages contemplates pub- lishing a series of smaller works upon some of the most important subjects connected with the East. He could not, however, seriously think of carrying out his favourite plan without a number of grave but desultory inquiries presenting themselves to his mind, which seemed to require some preliminary consider- ation. Hence the appearance of the present work, which comprises a few general reflections upon the History of Genuine and Spurious Religion. The object of the present work being of a purely practical nature and tendency, the Author has brought its contents before a Christian public in a less scien- tific and philosophical form than he could otherwise have wished to do. His design has been to write VI PREFACE. for the immediate benefit of those who have not sufficient means, powers, opportunity, time, or inclina- tion, to obtain direct information from the various sources which are scattered abroad upon a vast field of scientific research. It is scarcely necessary to state that part of the subject which constitutes the theme of the present work, is beset with singular dangers and difficulties. The student of Eastern systems of Mythology is, at all times, encompassed with a series of disadvantages of the first magnitude. The character of foreign languages, the sometimes arbitrary theories of other- wise able and zealous men on what has been rendered accessible by translations from those languages; the circumstance, that notions which have been errone- ously formed from want of more explicit information, are sometimes propagated from one authority to an- other ; the fact that, however much has been done in the department of Oriental research, much remains yet to be achieved, to bring it beyond the state of infancy ; the fact, moreover, that those very authori- ties which we find in the East, and on which we must chiefly depend, are strange compounds of facts and fictions, mixtures of historic events and poetic \ PREFACE. Vll coruscations, — all these and many other circumstances are highly unfavourable to the acquisition of a sound view of spurious systems of Religion. The advantages under which the Author has at- tempted to give a general view of the leading systems of ancient and modern Paganism have been neither small nor few in number. He has enjoyed access for a considerable time to English, Continental, Classical, and Oriental resources. He was enabled, by a length- ened and laborious sojourn in divers countries of Africa and the East, to acquire to some extent a knowledge of several Oriental languages ; to examine the most magnificent, and at the same time the most important, classical remains of Pagan antiquity ; to ascertain the peculiar views and feelings of Heathen and Mohammedan nations, from personal observation ; to trace the actual working of the human mind, under the various phases of religious error, and to study spurious systems of belief, as they are practically ex- pounded in the general character, and exemplified in the moral complexion, of whole nations and commu- nities. The Author feels greatly indebted to the valuable labours of several eminent writers, As it was, how- VIU PREFACE. ever, foreign to his plan to crowd the pages of this' work with critical annotations and detailed references to an endless variety of authorities, they have never been acknowledged. Nor would it, under any circum- stances, be in his power to determine, in numerous instances, what has been derived from others, having omitted to identify his authorities at a period when he gathered his information for mere practical purposes, without the remotest view of himself writing upon the subject. For the satisfaction, however, of such per- sons as may feel desirous of obtaining further infor- mation respecting the numerous sources to which the Author is indebted for part of his materials, an imperfect catalogue has been added to the second volume of the work. There being nothing more detrimental and less favourable to scientific inquiries than a systematical spirit, or a mind stereotyped by a set of prejudices and preconceived theories, pains have been taken to acquire and preserve that kind of mental type which can be changed, enlarged, or contracted, as may be found expedient on the acquisition of additional light and more accurate information. New discoveries suggest, or may suggest, fresh theories ; new wine requires new PREFACE. IX bottles, and new facts demand, or may demand, new systems. It was by acting on this simple principle, that a Baconian spirit emancipated the intellect of Europe from the bondage of being guided by deep- rooted prejudice and the authority of antiquated systems. Whilst it is pleasant to agree at all times with people who are looked upon as authorities in the various paths of Literature, and who, indeed, have a just claim upon our regard and veneration, there may be circumstances in which it must be our motto : — "Amicus Socrates, amicus Plato, amicus Aristoteles, sed magis amica Veritas." When, therefore, the author has deemed it neces- sary to deviate occasionally from the mode in which part of the subject has been hitherto represented in this country, it was neither ignorance, nor vanity, nor wantonness, which induced him to differ from vene- rable Authors to whom he feels otherwise deeply indebted. It is hoped that the very brief account respecting the grand and marvellous Jubilee, which was cele- brated in the brilliant orbits of our planetary system at the time of our Saviour's advent, will tend to extol the mystery of godliness, that God was manifested in the X PREFACE. flesh when the fulness of lime was come ! Such is the result of astronomical calculations which have been recently made by some of the most eminent men of our age, and which has, as far as we know, never before been brought before the British public. When Uranus, the remotest of all the planets, had completed the fiftieth of his revolutions around the sun, each of which being a complete Theocratical year of the plane- tary system, the multitude of the Heavenly host sounded the evangelical silver trumpets of a universal Jubilee on the fields of Bethlehem Ephratah, "praising God, and saying, Glory to God in the highest, and on earth ])eace, good-will toivards men.'' In perfect harmony with the original design of the work, the Author has taken pains to preserve the style of the argument free, as much as possible, from the appearance of controversial elements. These may well grace the pages of a more scientific perform- ance ; but they are, unquestionably, stumbling-blocks in works of a more simple and popular nature. There w^ere, however, some few occasions in w^hich the interests of divine truth demanded a peremptory exposm'e of certain pernicious notions, by which the poor victims of a spurious and infidel Philosophy have PREFACE. XI recently attempted to impeach the originaUty of revealed Religion. It was our object to expose, briefly though it might be, certain plausible arguments, by which it was made to appear as if some of the pecu- liarities of our blessed Religion were plagiarized from the Mythological systems of the ancient Egyptians, Persians, and Phoenicians. Again, some palpable errors, into which honest and intelligent writers were, from unavoidable causes, at times betrayed, have been invariably rectified, it is hoped, in the tone and spirit of Christian authorship. " Homines sumus omnes et erroribus obnoxii." If, however, in spite of the general frailty of all human efforts, the following work contribute another mite towards a sounder and more comprehensive view of the actual and real History of True and Counterfeit Religion, which is still desirable to the comparative analysis of an important chapter of the history of our race ; if it tend, under God's bless- ing, to bring the deplorable character, the melancholy position, and the just claims of the Pagan world, in a new form and with more emphasis, before the Chris- tian public ; if by any means the cause of Christianiza- tio7i and Civilization, of science and humanity, be advanced : in short, if in any measure glory result XU PREFACE. " to God in the hi(/hest, and on earth peace and (jood- will towards men,'' the arduous labour of thought, and the toil of study and research bestowed upon the sub- ject, will be considered abundantly rewarded. " In magnis voluisse sat est." Finally, the Author embraces the opportunity of this his first appearance upon the field of literary enter- prise, to express his very cordial thanks to a numerous circle of generous friends, for the kind manner in which they came forward to encourage him in his arduous undertaking, by offering to subscribe for the work. And he would fail in his duty were he to omit express- ing his deep sense of obhgation to some of the Right Reverend Prelates of our Chm'ch, and others distin- guished by their position, learning, and piety, for the encouragement, the kind advice, and the valuable assistance with which they countenanced both the composition and the eventual publication of this work. Little Hampton, Oct. 23, 1849. CnHtnits nf tjit .first itDhiniL CHAPTER I. JBcftnition, antJ iSrcIiminavi) l^emavlig upon tlje Subject of Mfltgton. Page 1—25. Difficulty of defiiiiug Religion — Definition from etymology — Definition upon the professedly liberal principle of eclecticism — The only safe and legitimate method of defining Religion — Religion gradually deve- loped— Its practical nature — Religion is one as God is one — Human nature neither needs nor admits of various kinds of Religion — Analogy between genuine and spurious Religion — An important feature in which true and false Religion coincide — The most giievous errors in Religion are perversions of most vital truths — Instances drawn from the chronology and other branches of Pagan systems — To every inquiry as to his nature, Jehovah replies, " I am that I am ; In the name of the Father, of the Son, and the Holy Ghost" — Fellowship with the eternal Father, through the blessed Son, by the Holy Spirit. CHAPTER II. Historical JBcbtlopmcnt of Sivcligion in tf;f