26th Congress, \si Session. [ SENATE. ] [ 428 ] IIEPORT FROM THE SECRETARY OF WAR, In compliance with a resolution of the Senate relative to the application of a mineral solution to the preservation of timber^ called " Kyani- April 9, 1840. Ordered to be printed. April 10, 1840. Referred to tlie Committee on Naval Affairs. April 21, 1840. Committee discliarged, and 200 additional copies ordered to be printed. War Department, April 9, 1840. Sir: I have the honor to submit the reports of the chiefs of the Engi- neer and Topocrrapliical Bureaus, furnishing the information called for by a resolution of the Senate, dated the 20th ultimo, relative to the application of a mineral solution to the preservation of timber, called "Kyanizing." Verv respectfully, your most obedient servant, J. R. POINSETT. Hon. R. M. Johnson, President of tJte Senate. Bureau of Topographical Engineers, Washington^ April 3, 1840. Sir : In reference to the resolution of the Senate of the 20th instant, I have the honor to submit the following report : Kyanizing is the name for a process of saturating timber with a solution of corrosive sublimate. The name is derived from the inventor (J. H. Kyan, Esq., of Enorland), who, having ascertained, by a great variety of experimentis, ''that albumen was the primary cause of the putrefaction and isiibseqnpn*^3" of the decomposition of vegetable matter," and aware of the affinity between albumen and corrosive sublimate, he concluded that, by sat- urating timber with the corrosive sublimate, its combination with the albu- men v/ould prevent its fermentation and decomposition, and consequently their destructive effects upon the timber. The object of the process is, therefore, to combine a well-established anti-destructive material with that which is considered the principal cause of the destruction of timber, and Blair & Rives, printers. [ 428 ] 2 thus to modify the character of the latter by the formation of a new and comparatively indestructible compound. Mr. Kyan justly deserves the credit of the invention in its useful appli- cation, and which, it would seem, has generally been conceded to him by the name of the process, although the use of corrosive sublimate, as a pre- ventive of dry-roc, was suggested in the form of a wash by Sir Humphrey Davy ; and Chapman, " on the preservation of timber,'' as stated in Thompson's Chemistry, says, " corrosive sublimate may be advantageously used in the proportion of one ounce to one gallon of water, to be applied hot." The mode of operation is, to construct a trough, or tank, in which the timber intended to be prepared is placed, and secured in position, when the trough, or tank, is sufficiently filled with the solution to cover the timber thorouglily. The cost of preparing the timber depends upon the following elements ; first, the construction ot the tank ; 2d, the cost of the corrosive sublimate ; ^^d, the proportion of the mixture and quantity absorbed ; and 4th, the labor of attending the process. The cost of the tank would be to be divided upon the whole quantity of timber prepared, and would, of course, lessen the expense of preparing the timber in proportion to the quantity. The cost of the corrosive sublimate is about per pound ; the proportion to water is variously stated at one pound to five gallons of water, one pound to seven gallons, and one pound to fifteen gallons : this last is considered as the weakest admissible solution. The quantity absorbed must depend upon the kind of timber. The more albuminous matter it contains, the more of the solution will have to be ab- sorbed to produce the desired change of that matter. The labor in attend- ing upon the process is not great. In an experiment made in the navy yard at Boston, in 1838, the labor was estimated at about one-ninth of the whole expense ; the proportions of the mixture, one pound of corrosive sublimate to seven gallons of water ; and the cost of preparing the limber, exclusive of the cost of the tanks, at about twelve cents the cubic foot. I have un- derstood that some interesting experiments were made by Colonel Totten, of the corps of engineers, when stationed at Fort Adams, which will, no doubt, be noticed in his report under the resolution. Kyan says, that a load of pine timber (fifty cubic feet) will cost, to pre- serve it, twenty shillings sterling — about ten cents per cubic foot ; and that this quantity would require about one pound of corrosive sublimate. In the United Service Journal, the quantity is stated at from one to one and a half pounds the load. In an article in the Journal of the Franklin Insti- tute, from the Earl of Manvers, the proportion of one pound to ten gallons of water is given. Mr. G. M. Totten, civil engineer, in an estimate of the cost (Army and Navy Chronicle, for 1837, page 341), at one pound to five gallons of water. or. according to others, at one pound to ten gallons, assumes, that a cubic foot of oak timber will absorb three pints of the liquid ; and he states the price of the corrosive sublimate at eighty-six cents the pound, the cost of the liquid, at six and a haU cents per cubic foot, that of tanks, labor, and liquid ai eight cents ; but he does not appear to have made any allowance for labor in attending to the process, or other contingency. * Corrosive sublimate is soluble in water at the rate of five parts by weight, to one hundred parts by weight, of water at 60° of Fahrenheit, or efght 3 [ 428 3 ounces per gallon ; and fifty parts in one hundred, at a temperature of 212^ of Fahrenheit, or five pounds per gallon. From which it will be observed, that the strength of the mixture depends upon the temperature of the water used, and no doubt also upon its softness. I have, myself, made no experiments on this matter. The remarks which occasioned the resolution are in the last annual report from this of- fice, in which the use of Kyanized timber is recommended for the harbor improvements on the lakes, and with the object of giving to those improve- ments a character of greater permanency than can be obtained to an equal degree in any other way, at so small an expense. In case these improve- ments should be continued, the preparing of the timber will open a field for the most interesting experiments, and upon a large scale. Of the main point involved, namely, that Kyanizing timber really in- creases its durabihty, there is, I believe, now no doubt. Upon this single point, therefore, there need be no experiment. It is, I think, sufficiently established, as may be ascertained, in addition to the authorities already referred to, from Professor Farrady's lecture of 1834, a pamphlet by Mer- cator, of the same year, Doctor Burbeck's lecture, a report from a committee of the board of admiralty in 1835, a report, in 1838, from a commission in Holland of experiments made in the dock yards of that kingdom. All these clearly show that the effects of Kyanizing are, the prevention of dry rot ; a more perfect and more certain seasoning of timber ; defence against the depredation of insects ; and that it can be applied to all kinds of tim- ber. These are, certainly, correct results, if the authorities named are de- serving of confidence, of which they undoubtedly are, in my opinion ; and therefore justify me in resting upon the single fact, that the process of Ky- anizmg is a certain mode of increasing the durabihty of timber. The points which do not seem to be sufficiently determined, and upon which it would be extremely desirable to make a series of experiments, are i 1st, The proper strength of the solution for different kinds of timber ; 2d. The time required for it to penetrate different thicknesses of different kinds of timber ; 3d. The quantity absorbed by different kinds of timber, and the period of cutting best adapted to receive it. In making these experiments, many interesting facts will be suggested to a carelul observer, adding much to the value of the general results, proba- bly the partial mineralization which the timber undergoes in the process, may render it also less liable to combustion. In the report which occasioned the inquiry of the Senate, allusion is made to a process of mineralizing^ timber by the sulphates of iron and cop- per, as an invention of Doctor Edward Earle, of Philadelphia. I submit certain. papers on the subject which Doctor Earle has left with me. Very respectfully, sir, your obedient servant, J. J. ABERT, Colonel Top. Engineers. Hon. J. R. Poinsett, Secretary of War. [ 428 ] 4 PRESERVATION OF TIMBER. Hall of the Franklin Institute, Philadelphia^ December 12, 1839. The committee on science and the arts, constituted by the Franklin Institute of the State of Pennsylvania for the promotion of the Mechanic arts, to whom was referred for examination Dr. Edward Earle's method of preserving timber, report. [The " report" being long, and a considerable portion of it, although a necessary part of the whole, being irrelevant to the main purpose ; an ab- stract of it may suffice to show the proceedings of the committee, and the conclusions to which their investigations, experiments, and reasonings, have conducted them as to the nature and qualities of the means employed, and the probable advantages and value of the process. Composed of many of the most distinguished m.embers of the Institute — such as President A. D. Bache, Messrs. Booth, Peale, Merrick, Frazer, and others, the above committee may be considered as constituting, in matters of science, the highest tribunal in our country ; and the sanction of its approbation must go far to establish the character of those inventions and improvements on which it is conferred. Having adverted to the form of the " process" — the materials used and the mode of applying them — together v/itli the different kinds of decay to which timber is liable, and which they agree with others in attributing to the gaseous, albuminous, and glutinous substances inherent in it ; they give a short history of the attempts which have been made, in different countries, to prevent or cure this costly evil. They then proceed to detail their own experiments made to determine the relative efTects produced on the putre- factive constituents of timber, by the sulphates of iron and copper, and by corrosive sublimate, which salts they find to act in a similar manner and equally — and are considered as the materials most powerful in their pres- ervative agency; and, also, their experimeiits to ascertain the introduction of the sulphates, by the proposed process," into the body of different kinds of wood. In the course of the experiments made for these several purposes, they satisfy themselves of the following results, most affecting the subject, which we give in the language of the " report"] : " 1st. That if these salts — the sulphates of n*on and copper — penetrate the wood throughlj^, according to the process adopted by Dr. Earle, we have an economical substitute for the mercurial compound — the corrosive sublimate ; "2d. That the solutions are carried through the pores of the wood^ is conclusively shown by the experiments (detailed) on pieces taken from the interior of large pieces of timber which had been boiled with the solutions. The pieces were further split in half and the experiments made on the inner surface ; "3d. Tiiat heated solutions of various salts, such as corrosive sublimate and the sulphates of iron and copper, operate by expelling the gaseous mat- ter, and rendering the albumen and gelatine inert in all the parts of the wood which they penetrate ; " 4th. That they (the sulphates) penetrate different woods in different degrees ; ash being more thoroughly impregnated ; he/nlock nearly the samej hickory less so ; and oaf: still less ; 5 [ 428 J " 5th. That the sulphates of iron and copper produce the precipitation ■of albumen equally well with the perchloride of mercury [corrosive subli- mate)^ and that of gluten in a nearly equal degree ; and that they are therefore to be considered as an excellent arid economical substitute for that compound ; " 6th. That therefore the penetration of wood, by these salts {the sul- phates of iron and copper) renders it less subject to decay and the attacks of insects ; " 7th. That although theory and experiment thus go to show the dimin- ished destructibihty of the wood, experiments on a hirge scale should be instituted in order to ascertain the correctness of these views of the com- mittee, without which they are of little value ; but that the subject is one of sufficient importance, and the probability of success sufficiently strong, to warrant the performance of such experiments with great care, and with less regard to the primary expense; " 8th. That lime penetrates wood in a similar manner" — but the opinion of the committee as to the effect of lime on the wood being less favorable, their experiments and retisonings are not thought important to be commu- nicated. To the report of the Franklin Institute it may not be unavailing to add that numerous other testimonials, consisting as well of facts as of the opin- ions of scientific and practical individuals, might be adduced by the patentee in favor of his " process and especially that the " committee on public highways" — after having used it to some extent in paving with blocks, during the summer and autumn of 1839, — have made a " report" on it to the councils consonant to that of the institute ; presenting it in the most favorable manner to the attention of the councils v/henever they shall con- sider it expedient to proceed further in the employment of wooden pave- ments, &c. The process is conducted by means of boilers and wooden tanks, which, in size and cost, may be accommodated to timber of any dimensions and quantity, whether it be to prepare posts for fencing, or the largest ship- timber ; and is capable of reducing it, in a few hours, from a perfectly green to a perfectly seasoned state. The efficiency of this method, it is believed, will prove equal, at least, to any that ever has been tried ; while the facility with which it may be practised, and the trifling expense attending it, give it powerful claims to general acceptance. The materials employed being inexhaustible too, and not liable to fluctuation in price, can never occasion an augmentation of the cost. Communications to the patentee, may be directed to the care of J no. C. Montgomery, Esq., President of the Little Schuylkill and Susquehannah Railroad Company, or to Wm. Rawle, Esq., Counsellor at Law, Phila- delphia. EDW. EARLE. Philadelphia, January 14, 1840. Philadelphia, October 4, 1839. Respected Friend — In compliance with thy request that we should communicate to thee the result of any experience we may have had in the 6 employment of wooden vessels in our copperas and blue vitriol works, we may briefly state that about two and a half years ago we had a number of large crystallizing vats made of seasoned white pine-planks into which the hot solution of sulphate of iron is drawn from the 2:enerators. The first effect observed was a shrinking of the wood and consequent leaking, to obviate which the crystallizers were successively buried, nearly to the top, in a moist clay soil. Several of those which have been thus buried have,, from time to time, been taken up and examined, and we have found no in- dications of decay, the texture of the wood appearing generally quite firm and sound, except in places where there have been fissures into which the saturated solution penetrating has, by its crystallization, forced apart the fibres of the wood. We have no doubt that the impregnation of wood with the solution of copperas tends to its preservation, possibly in a high degree, but the facts above recited are all that have come under our notice* We formerly employed wooden vessels for the sulphate of copper, but find- ing that the wood was softened by the strong acid solution, we have substi- tuted lead ; we should, however, observe that that effect would not be pro- duced by a dilute solution, such as that thou usest ; on the contrary, we think it quite probable that in such proportion it may increase the efficiency of copperas in preserving the wood. Respectfully, CARTER (fe SCATTERGOOD, Manvfaciiiring Chemists. Dr. E. Earle. Extract from the minutes of the committee on public highways^ Philadel- phia, August 13, 1839. " JResolved, That this committee, having tried the process of Dr. Earle, are satisfied, from the effect of chemical tests on the split blocks and other evidence before them, that he has fully succeeded in impregnating the wood with the salts of iron and copper." WM. STEVENSON, Secretary. The above "resolution," in connexion with the fact that, under the au- thority of the said committee, several portions of the streets of Philadelphia have already been paved with blocks of wood prepared according to this process, and that the same work is still proceeding in other parts of the city, is strongly expressive of their confidence in the effect of it ; and the letter of Messrs. Carter .ne- rience. I am, sir, very respectfully, your obedient servant, .TOS. G. TOTTEN, Colonel, and Chief Engineer. Hon. J. R. Poinsett, iSecreiary of War, Washington, March 27, 1840. Sir : The following information, relative to Kyanizing timber to prevent the dry-rot, is, at your request, herewith communicated to the department. I 428 ] 16 As it was necessary to Kyanize all the timber used in repairing Port Niagara when operations commenced, the proper steps were taken for put- tinir into practice Kyan's method. This required nothing more than a water-tight vessel, without any iron on ils inside, and a quantity of corrosive subhmate. The subUmate was dissolved in hot , water, the timber to be saturated placed in the vessel, and the solution poured therein. It was left iu this state a certain number of days, depending on the size of the tim- ber. The solution was then pumped out, and the timber taken from the tank and placed under cover to dry. The vessels used by me in my operations were, first, a tank, made of four and a half inch Canadian pine plank, thirty feet long, eight wide, and five and a half deep ; and, secondly, a cistern of a capacity about one third that of the tank. The plank were tongued and grooved, and secured to- gether by one-inch iron bolts. In most cases, it would be well to calk the vessels on the inside; but, as mine did not leak on being filled with water, no precaution of this kind with them seemed necessary. The cor- rosive sublimate was dissolved in hot water and poured into the cistern, and, after a sufficient quantity had been used, water was added, until the strength of the solution indicated a proportion of one pound of corrosive subliuiate to fifteen gallons of water. The tank, in the meantime, was filled with timber, well fastened down with, cleats, Avith sufficient space be- tween the different sticks to allow a free circulation of water around them ; the solution was then pumped from the cistern into the tank, and, after having been left therein the requisite nrirnberof days, was pumped back into the cistern : the timber was then taken out and placed under shelter to dry ; and this completed the whole operation. The same solution can be used any number of times, provided care be taken to add, occasionally, a sufficient quantity of corrosive sublimate to keep it at its proper degree of strength. The timber saturated by me, amounting altogetlier to between three and four thousand cubic feet, is mostly of a large size, the different sticks varying between eight and twenty four feet in length, and twelve and eighteen inches in breadth, and has cost a little over twelve cents a cubic foot. This, however, should not be taken as the average cost ; for, beside the large size of the timber saturated, the circumstances under which the operation has thus far been conducted have been by no means flivorable. The tank was not completed until nearly the 1st of November ; so that most of the timber prepared has been Kyanized durinof the winter months — the season of the year, of all others, least favorable for such an operation. Wj^ij so, a few words will explain. When the weather was cold, the time re- quired for loading and unloading the tank was much longer than when moderate, and hence the cost vv^as greater. Besides, the moisture in the timber during the severe vveather being frozen, the moment a stick was placed in the solution it became enveloped in a thick crust of ice. This, if not removed, would have prevented the corrosive sublimate from having any action whatever upon the wood ; and therefore it became necessary, in order to avoid delaying the work, to incur the expense of melting the ice thus formed around the different sticks, and of preventing the solution after- ward from freezing. The timber, after it has been prepared, is found to be a liitle darker in its appearance. iSess: Jti Cmuj. S.Doc. 426 DIAGRAPH ^r?i OP AFFARATTTS MINERALIZING TLMBER E. Ernie, Fatentee FhiLad^ 1839. W.J.Sktw So.Vwsh- 1 Sas. 26 Cong. S.Voc. 428 W.J.Storue, So.Wa.sh. 17 [428] The very short time the process of Kyanizing at Fort Niagara has been in operation renders it impossible to decide definitively either on its efficacy or cost. From an article in the first volume of the Transactions of the Royal Engineers, considerable information on the subject can be obtained, and from this the following remarks were taken. Professor Faraday states, in a lecture of his on the subject, that, in his opinion, the efficacy of the process consists in a chemical combination being formed between the albuminous principle of the wood, which is first liable to decay, and the corrosive sublimate ; and Dr. Birkbeck says it produces the same change in vegetable substances that tanning does in animal. They both express the opinion that there can be no doubt of the entire success of the experiments. From a number of trials mentioned in the same article, it would seem that the preparation of timber in this manner has the effect of slightly re- ducing its specific gravity, and making it stifFer, but at the same time more brittle. To ascertain whether the timber has been sufficiently saturated. Professor Faraday recommends the application of the hydro sulphuret of ammonia, which turns black when it touches mercury. By this means, its presence was discovered in a cube of elm, to the depth of from one-fifth to one-fourth of an inch, and, by voltaic action, from three-fourths to one inch. Its action was less perceptible at the same depths in a cube of oak, and still less so in one of fir — the turpentine in the last preventing, probably, the penetration of the solution. He likewise says, the success of the method is rendered the more certain from the tendency of the solution to distribute itself (though at first satu- rating but to a small depth) equally through all the pores of the wood ; and, even if it did not strike entirely through the heart of it, by forming a chem- ical combination with its albuminous principle to the depth of an inch, it would necessarily retard for a long time the action of the dry rot. This will readily be admitted, when it is considered that the mere charring a stick will make it last much longer. The following extract is taken from a letter of Colonel Harding, of the royal engineers, to Colonel Sir John May, K. C. B., of the royal carriage department : " Placed in contact with, and under the flooring of, the old Cadet Hall, which is much affected by dry rot, prepared v/ith Kyan's patent — 1 piece of oak of 24 inches, 3 by 3, 1 piece of ash of 24 inches, 3 by 3, 1 piece of elm of 24 inches, 3 by 3, 3 pieces of memel fir of 23 inches, 4 by 2, 3 pieces American fir of 23 inches, 4 by 2, 1 piece white rope of 5 inches, 1 piece white rope of 2J inches, 1 piece white rope ofl^ inches, 1 piece tent line or cord, 4 pieces canvass, with duplicates of exactly similar materials unprepared. " We found all the cordage and canvass that were unprepared had be- come more or less rotten, except a piece of canvass ; but no material altera- tion in the wood, except in one piece of memel and one of American un- 2 [428 J IS prepared, which, with its fellow piece, prepared, was taken up, as it ap- peared they had both become injured by the dry rot." The others were left under the floor. When examined, they had been in this position eighteen months. " We then had the following pulled up out of the ground, into which they had been driven 15 inches, and the tops exposed to the south sun and to the drip, (fee, under the eaves of a building, prepared with Kyan's patent : 1 piece of oak, 24 inches, 3 by 3, I piece of ash, 24 inches, 3 by 3, I piece of elm, 24 inches, 3 by 3, 1 piece memel fir, 23 inches, 4 by 2, 1 piece American fir, 23 inches, 4 by 2, and exactly similar pieces of the same unprepared. "This trial appeared to have had more effect on the wood than the pre- ceding one at the Cadet Hall the unprepared elm being very defective, while the prepared remained perfectly sound. At the expiration of three years from the time they were first put down, another examination was made by Colonel Harding. He stales, on the wood placed under the flooring of Cadet Hall no material effect was pro- duced, but the cordage and canvass unprepared had become rotten, while that prepared still remained sound. As for the others, driven into the ground under the eaves of the building, with their tops exposed to the sun, the prepared were in a perfectly sound state, but, of that unprepared, a por- tion was much decayed, and all more or less aflfected. In the article from which these facts are taken it is also mentioned, that a vessel, the timber of which was prepared with Kyan's patent, returned home, after a twenty-nine-month voyage, as sound as she was the day she started. The crew enjoyed good health during the whole time, and the bilge-water did not seem affected by the corrosive sublimate. A bolt, much corroded, was examined to ascertain whether it had been injured by the mercury, but Professor Faraday could not discover the presence of any. Trials have been made by Mr. Kyd, of Calcutta, to find out whether the preparation of timber, after Kyan's method, would not prevent it from being attacked by the white ant, so destructive to timber between the tropics, and he seems to be of the opinion that it will. That the Kyanizing of timber used in the construction of works, alter- nately exposed to the action of the sun and fresh water, might be introduced with much advantage to them, can scarcely admit of doubt ; but whether it would prove beneficial for those in salt water is not quite certain, though the case of the vessel before mentioned is somewhat in its favor. The anti-dry rot company of London, Kyanize timber at the rate of 20 shillings sterling for every 50 cubic feet; but, though the cost of corrosive sublimate is greater in this country than in Great Britain, I am satisfied that timber can be prepared at a cheaper rate. 1 have the honor to be, very respectfully, your obedient servant, WILLIAM D. ERASER, Captain Engineers. Col. J. G. TOTTEN, Chief Engineer^ Washington, 19 [ 428 ] Engineer Office, Fort Ontario, Oswego, N. Y., March 29, 1840. Sir: I have the honor to acknowledge the receipt of your communica- tion of the 24th instant, enclosing a copy of a resolution of the Senate, dated March 20, and asking for such information as I may possess on the subject of Kyanizing timber, and particularly with reference to its cost. The Kyanizing process was commenced here about the first of October last, and, consequently, no opinion as to the efficacy of the preparation, in pro- tecting timber from dry rot and the worm, can yet be formed. The opera- tion has been conducted under the disadvantages incident to every untried experiment, and has not been sufficiently extended in time to give, with accuracy, the data from which to determine the expense. One tank only has yet been buill, and of the following dimensions : thir- ty feet long, sixteen feet wide, and four and a half feet deep. This tank will ordinarily contain 1,535 cubic feet of timber. The quantity of solu- tion required to immerse it, has been 4,000 gallons ; and at the rate of one pound of corrosive sublimate to fifteen gallons of water, 244.4 pounds cor- rosive must be dissolved for this purpose. According to Mr. Kyan, the abovementioned quantity of timber should imbibe 38.3 pounds corrosive sublimate ; and, consequently, on or previous to the removal of this timber from the tank, and the substitution of a fresh charge, equal to the first in quantity, 38.3 pounds corrosive sublimate should be added to the solution. This being added in the smallest quantity of water which will dissolve it, seems amply sufficient for restoring the strength of the whole. The cost of charging the tank with 1,535 cubic feet of timber, and of removing and placing it under a timber-shed when Kyanized, has been, in the case of large timber 18 x 18 inches, and from 20 to 29 feet long, $25. The price of corrosive sublimate in New York is $i 35 per pound, and fifty cents per pound additional is paid for the use of the patent. The cost of transporta- tion from New York to this place has been, during the last season, 90 cents per hundred. With these data, and excluding the cost of the tank, cistern, and crane, for moving the large timber, the Kyanizing costs at the rate of 6 cents 2-^^^ mills per cubic foot. The tank, with its cistern, cost $495 84, and the crane $79 30. The cost of the tank was considerable greater than would now be necessary. It is proposed to construct an additional one, somewhat larger than the first, and as the crane and cistern already built will serve both tanks, it is ex- pected that the one proposed can be built for about $300. The quantity of timber required in the rebuilding of the fort, is estimated at 91,812 cubic feet. Charging the cost of the two tanks, one cistern, and one crane, in the ex- pense of Kyanizing the abovementioned quantity of timber, it will increase by 9 j\ mills the cost of Kyanizing a cubic foot ; so that the expense of Ky- anizing, including the necessary machinery, and supposing this machinery to be of no value afterward, will not, in this case, exceed 7 cents and 2 mills per cubic foot. This, it will be observed, is about equal to the first cost of sawed timber at this place. Sheds, in proportion to the quantity of Kyanized timber on hand at any one time, are necessary to protect it from the weather until dried. But, as this protection costs but little more than the materials for its construction, and these can afterward be appropriated to other use, this item will not [ 428 ] appreciably increase the expense. Some of the sokition must remain on hand at the close of operations, but it is presumed that this, as well as the tanks,