FRANKLIN INSTITUTE LIBRARY PHILADELPHIA Oass.(3..X C- Book Accession . . . <^ .0 article d. ine library shall be divided into two classes; the first com- prising such works, as from their rarity, value, or extent, should not be lent out, except when required by Committees for the use of the Institute, or by Members who have obtained the sanction of the Committee at a regular meeting ; to this class shall be added all unbound periodicals, and such text- books as ought necessarily to be found in a library of reference. The second class shall include those books intended for circulation among the Members. Article 6. The Actuary shall have authority to loan to Members of the Institute any work belonging to the second class, subject to the following regulations : — Section 1. Every person, on borrowing a book, shall sign a conditional bond, or obligation, for the sum of fifty dollars, as security for his due observance of the rules of the Library, and for the value of such books as may be injured or lost by him. Section 2. No individual shall be permitted to have more than two books out at one time, without a written permission, signed by at least two Mem- bers of the Library Committee, nor shall a book be kept out more than two weeks ; but if no one has applied for it, the former borrower may renew the loan : should any person have applied for it, the latter shall have the pre- ference. Section 3. A fine of ten cents per week shall be exacted for the detention of every book beyond the limited time ; and if a book be not returned within three months, it shall be deemed lost, and the borrower shall, in addition to his fines, forfeit its value. Section 4. Should any book be returned injured, the borrower shall pay for the injury, or replace the book, as the Library Committee may direct; and if one or more books, belonging to a set or sets, be lost, the borrower shall ay the full value of the set or sets, and may take the remaining volumes. / Article 7. Any person removing from the Hall, without permission from the proper authorities, any book, newspaper, or other property in charge pf the Library Committee, shall be reported to the Committee, who may inflict any fine not exceeding Twenty-five Dollars. Article 8. No Member, whose annual contribution for the current year shall be unpaid, or who is in arrears for fines, shall be entitled to the privi- leges of the Library or Reading Room. Article 9. If any Member shall refuse or neglect to comply with the fore- going rules, it shall be the duty of the Actuary to report him to the Commit- tee on the Library. / Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2015 https://archive.org/details/philosophyofmanuOOurea THE PHILOSOPHY OF MANUFACTURES: OR, AN EXPOSITION OF THE SCIENTIFIC, MORAL, AND COMMERCIAL ECONOMY OF THE FACTORY SYSTEM OF #reat Srttam* By ANDREW URE, m.d, f.r.s, M.G.S., M.A.S. Lon., M. Acad. N.S. Philad., S. Pharm. Soc. North Germany, &c. &c. &c. LONDON : CHARLES KNIGHT, LUDGATE- STREET. MDCCCXXXV. COA/'S TS MS U? IS3S LONDON : Printed by William Clowes and Sons, Stamford Street. CONTENTS. Fage Preface . vii BOOK THE FIRST. General Principles of Manufactures, Chapter I. General View of Manufacturing Industry .... I Chapter II. Arrangement and Connexion of Manufactures . . .55 Chapter III. Topography and Statistics of the Factory System . . .67 BOOK THE SECOND. Scientific Economy of the Factory System. Chapter I. Examination of the Textile Fibres, — Cotton, Wool, Flax, and Silk . 81 Chapter II. Nature, &c of a Cotton Factory . . . . . ,105 Chapter III. Worsted Manufacture — General Observations on Wool . . 124 Chapter IV. Nature and Operations of a Woollen-Factory. — Of the Short Wool or Cloth Manufacture 160 Chapter V. Nature and Operations of a Flax-Factory .... 207 a 3 <£~0 o vi CONTENTS. Page Chapter VI. Nature and Operations of a Silk-Factory .... 229 BOOK THE THIRD. Moral Economy of the Factory System. Chapter I. Condition of our Factory Operatives, as to Personal Comforts, compared to that of other Labouring Classes; or the Quantity and Quality of their Work considered, relatively to the means of Enjoyment which it can procure. — History of the Discon- tents, Prejudices, and Legislation on this subject . . . 277 Chapter II. Health of Factory Inmates 374 Chapter III. State of Knowledge and Religion in the Factories . . . 404 BOOK THE FOURTH. Commercial Economy of the Factory System • . . 430 Note A 467 „ B . . . . 470 C 471 9 f D 472 Appendix — Relative Ages, Sexes, and Wages of Factory Work- people ......... 473 General Statistical Table of the Textile Manufactures, subject to the Factories Regulation Act . . . . . 48 1 ggp- In the wages-column of table, page 373, the figures have been printed with horizontal lines, as vulgar fractions, instead of oblique lines, as shillings and pence. It should read lis., 10s., 5*. 8d., 4*. 5tf., 4s., 3s. 6d., 2s. 6d. Errata. — Page 291, line 7, for "Of" read "On." „ 383, line 7, for " wires " read " wings." PREFACE. The present is distinguished from every preceding age by an universal ardour of enterprise in arts and manufactures. Nations convinced at length that war is always a losing game, have converted their swords and muskets into factory implements, and now con- tend with each other in the bloodless but still formid- able strife of trade. They no longer send troops to fight on distant fields, but fabrics to drive before them those of their old adversaries in arms, and to take pos- session of a foreign mart. To impair the resources of a rival at home, by underselling his wares abroad, is the new belligerent system, in pursuance of which every nerve and sinew of the people are put upon the strain. Great Britain may certainly continue to uphold her envied supremacy, sustained by her coal, iron, capital, and skill, if, acting on the Baconian axiom, " Know- ledge is Power," she shall diligently promote moral and professional culture among all ranks of her pro- ductive population. Were the principles of the manu- factures exactly analyzed, and expounded in a simple manner, they would diffuse a steady light to conduct the masters, managers, and operatives, in the straight viii PREFACE . paths of improvements and prevent them from pursuing such dangerous phantoms as flit along in the monthly patent - lists. Each department of our useful arts stands in need of a guide-book to facilitate its study, to indicate its imperfections, and to suggest the most probable means of correcting them. It is known that the manufactures of France have derived great advan- tage from the illustrated systems of instruction pub- lished under the auspices of its government and patri- otic societies. The present volume, introductory to a series of works in more ample detail, is submitted to the public as a specimen of the manner in which the author con- ceives technological subjects should be discussed. Having been employed in a public seminary for a quarter of a century, in expounding to practical men, as well as to youth, the applications of mechanical and chemical science to the arts, he felt it his duty, on being solicited from time to time by his pupils, now spread over the kingdom as proprietors and managers of factories, to prepare for publication a systematic account of their principles and processes. With this view he resolved to make afresh such a survey of some of the great manufacturing establishments, to which he had liberal access, as might qualify him to dis- charge the task in a creditable manner. This tour of verification would have been executed at a much earlier date, so as to have enabled him, ere now, to have redeemed his pledges both publicly and pri- PREFACE. ix vately given, but for an interruption of unexpected magnitude. The Right Honourable the Lords of the Com- mittee of the Privy Council for Trade and Plantations requested him, about three years ago, to undertake a series of experiments on the refining of sugar, in order to ascertain the relation of the drawbacks on exporta- tion of refined loaves to the duties paid upon the raw article. Under an impression that these researches might be set sufficiently in train, in the space of two or three months, to lead to the desired information in the hands of experienced operatives, he undertook their ar- rangement; but encountered so many difficulties from the delicacy of the material operated upon, and other circumstances stated in his official report printed by order of the House of Commons, that he did not get en- tirely extricated from them till nearly two years were ex- pired, nor till he had suffered considerably from anxiety of mind and bodily fatigue. Being advised by his me- dical friends to try the effects of travelling, with light intellectual exercise, he left London in the latter end of last summer, and spent several months in wandering through the factory districts of Lancashire, Cheshire, Derbyshire, &c, with the happiest results to his health ; having everywhere experienced the utmost kindness and liberality from the mill-proprietors. Neither they^ nor the great mechanical engineers who construct their buildings and machinery, use any mystery or reserve towards a visiter actuated by legitimate feelings and X PREFACE. principles; but, on the contrary, most readily show and explain the curiously-productive inventions which surround them. The few individuals who betray jealousy of intelli- gent inspection are usually vain persons, who, having purloined a few hints from ingenious neighbours, work upon them in secret, shut out every stranger from their mill, get consequently insulated and excluded in return, and thus, receiving no external illumination, become progressively adumbrated ; till, after a few years of exclusive operation, they find themselves undersold in the market, and deprived of their oldest or best cus- tomers by the inferiority of their goods. Were it not invidious, the author could point out several examples of clever people, having thus outmanoeuvred them- selves, in trying to steal a march upon their friends in the dark. Mystifiers of this stamp are guilty of the silly blunder of estimating their own intrinsic re- sources above those of all the world beside. It is, however, not more for the advantage of the kingdom, than for that of every individual manufacturer in it, to receive light from all quarters, and to cause it by reflection to irradiate the sphere around him. In tracing the progression of the British system of industry, according to which every process pecu- liarly nice, and therefore liable to injury from the ignorance and waywardness of workmen, is withdrawn from handicraft control, and placed under the guid- ance of self-acting machinery, the author has made it PREFACE. xi his business to study the descriptions of most of the patents of that nature obtained in Great Britain, France, and America, during the last twenty years, — a task in which he has been assisted by Messrs. Newton and Berry, of Chancery-lane, gentlemen de- servedly esteemed for the soundness of the specifica- tions which they professionally prepare for patentees. To James Cook, Esq., of Mincing-lane, he is in- debted for the extensive assortment of samples of raw cotton, wool, flax, and silk, which have formed the principal subjects of his microscopic researches upon textile fibres, as also for much valuable information on the statistics of trade. Nor ought he to leave unacknowledged the polite readiness of S. M. Phillipps, Esq., Under Secretary of State, and of Mr. Porter, of the Board of Trade, to aid his formation of a census of the factory population, and his inquiries into the commerce of the kingdom. In delivering this general Treatise on Manufacturing Industry into the hands of the public, the author is not unconscious of defects, both in its matter and arrangement ; for most of which, however, an apology may be found, in the vague and contradictory opinions entertained by experienced manufacturers on many departments of their business. Those of his readers who have most deeply considered the difficulties of his undertaking will not be the least indulgent. The body of facts distributed throughout the volume have been most carefully verified, and will, it is pre- xii PREFACE. sumed, bear the strictest scrutiny, though a desire to keep the volume at such a price as would bring its purchase within the reach of working-men has pre- cluded the multiplication of notes of reference to authorities. The main portion of these, indeed, would have been to the reports of Parliamentary Commit- tees ; many great folios of which have been diligently consulted in quest of authentic information — though sometimes to little purpose — in consequence of the judgments of even honest men being strangely per- verted by passion, prejudice, and self-interest. The engravings at pages 48, 49, 120, 162, 271, 273, afford specimens of the original drawings of machines made under the author's eye, for illustrating modern manufactures ; the complete series of which, when pub- lished in his forthcoming works on the cotton trade, dyeing, calico-printing, &c, will, it is hoped, constitute an interesting gallery of practical science. London^ June 1835. # PHILOSOPHY OF MANUFACTURES. BOOK THE FIRST. GENERAL PRINCIPLES OF MANUFACTURES. CHAPTER I. General View of Manufacturing Industry. Manufacture is a word, which, in the vicissitude of language, has come to signify the reverse of its intrinsic meaning, for it now denotes every extensive product of art, which is made by machinery, with little or no aid of the human hand ; so that the most perfect manu- facture is that which dispenses entirely with manual labour. The philosophy of manufactures is therefore an exposition of the general principles, on which pro- ductive industry should be conducted by self-acting machines. The end of a manufacture is to modify the texture, form, or composition of natural objects by me- chanical or chemical forces, acting either separately, combined, or in succession. Hence the automatic arts subservient to general commerce may be distinguished into Mechanical and Chemical, according as they mo- dify the external form or the internal constitution of their subject matter. An indefinite variety of objects may be subjected to each system of action, but they VOL. I. B 2 GENERAL VIEW OF may be all conveniently classified into animal, vege- table, and mineral. A mechanical manufacture being commonly occu- pied with one substance, which it conducts through metamorphoses in regular succession, may be made nearly automatic ; whereas a chemical manufacture depends on the play of delicate affinities between two or more substances, which it has to subject to heat and mixture under circumstances somewhat uncertain, and must therefore remain, to a corresponding extent, a manual operation. The best example of pure chemis- try on self-acting principles which I have seen, was in a manufacture of sulphuric acid, where the sulphur being kindled and properly set in train with the nitre, atmospheric air, and water, carried on the process through a labyrinth of compartments, and supplied the requisite heat of concentration, till it brought forth a finished commercial product. The finest model of an automatic manufacture of mixed chemistry is the five- coloured calico machine, which continuously, and spon- taneously, so to speak, prints beautiful webs of cloth with admirable precision and speed. It is in a cotton mill, however, that the perfection of automatic industry is to be seen ; it is there that the elemental powers have been made to animate millions of complex organs, infusing into forms of wood, iron, and brass an intelli- gent agency. And as the philosophy of the fine arts, poetry, painting, and music may be best studied in their individual master-pieces, so may the philosophy of manufactures in this its noblest creation. There are four distinct classes of textile fibres, cot- ton, wool, tlax, and silk, which constitute the subjects of four, or, more correctly speaking, five distinct classes MANUFACTURING INDUSTRY. of factories ; first, the cotton factories ; second, the wool- len ; third, the worsted ; fourth, the flax, hempen, or linen ; and fifth, the silk. These five factories have each peculiarities proceeding from the peculiarities of its raw material and of its fabrics ; but they all possess certain family features, for they all employ torsion to convert the loose slender fibres of vegetable or animal origin into firm coherent threads, and, with the excep- tion of silk, they all employ extension also to attenuate and equalize these threads, technically styled yarn. Even one kind of silk which occurs in entangled tufts, called floss, is spun like cotton, by the simultaneous action of stretching and twisting. The above-named five orders of factories are, through- out this kingdom, set in motion by steam-engines or water-wheels ; they all give employment to multitudes of children or adolescents ; and they have therefore been subjected to certain legislative provisions, defined in the Factories Regulation Act, passed by Parliament on the 29th August, 1833. It is probable that 614,200 work-people are con- stantly engaged within the factories of the United Kingdom: of which number 561,900 belong to Eng- land and Wales ; 46,825 to Scotland ; and 5,475 to Ire- land.* Fully five-tenths of them are under twenty-one years of age, and three tenths of these young persons are females. It must be remembered, however, that besides these 614,200 inmates of factories, a vast population * The above numbers for Scotland and Ireland are taken from Mr. Leonard Horner's excellent Report as Factory Inspector; the number for England is computed on the recognized datum that it is twelve times greater for the cotton trade than that of Scotland. For the last official details see the Appendix. B 2 4 GENERAL VIEW OF derives a livelihood from the manufactures of cotton, wool, flax, and silk, such as the hand-weavers, the calico-printers and dyers, the frame-work knitters, the lace-maters, lace-runners, muslin-sewers, &c. &c. It appears from the Parliamentary Returns of 1831, that in Great Britain, out of a total population of 16,539,318 persons, there are of Agricultural Labourers and Labour- ing Occupiers 1,055,982, and of Manufacturing Labourers 404,317 Whence there are 1000 agricultural to 383 strictly manufacturing labourers. Persons employed in retail trade, or in handicraft, as masters or work- men 1,159,867 Total adult persons employed in arts and trades 1,564,184, being about fifty per cent, more than those engaged in agri- culture. The capitalists, bankers, professional and other educated men amount to 214,390 Labourers non-agricultural to .618,712 If we include in the agricultural de- partment, the occupiers employin g labourers (few of whom, however, work), we shall have to add 187,075 to the above number 1,055,057 The total sum of Agriculturists is 1,243,057, being only 80 per cent, of the adult males employed in manu- factures, arts, and trades. MANUFACTURING INDUSTRY. 5 When we take into account the vastly greater propor- tion of young persons constantly occupied with factory labour, than of those occupied with agricultural labour, we shall then be led to conclude that at least double the amount of personal industry is engaged in the arts, manufactures, and trade, to what is engaged in agricul- ture. Considerably upwards of one-tenth of the popu- lation of this island is actually employed in manu- factures ; and probably little more than one-fifteenth in agriculture. This conclusion ought to lead our legis- lative landlords to treat the manufacturing interests with greater respect than they have usually been accus- tomed to do. If we consider, moreover, how much greater a mass of productive industry a male adult is equivalent to, in power-driven manufactures, than in agriculture, the balance in favour of the former will be greatly enhanced. France, which has for upwards of a century and a half tried every scheme of public premium to become a great manufacturing country, has a much less proportion than one employed in trade for two employed in agri- culture. M. Charles Dupin, indeed, has been led by his researches into the comparative industry of France and of the United Kingdom, to conclude that the agricultural produce of our country amounted in value to 240 millions sterling, and that of his own to 180 millions sterling, being the ratio of three to two; and that our manufacturing power is inferior to that of France in the proportion of sixty-three to seventy- two ; or as seven to eight. There can be no doubt that his agricultural estimate underrates France, as much as his manufacturing estimate underrates Great Britain. 6 GENERAL VIEW OF This island is pre-eminent among civilized nations for the prodigious development of its factory wealth, and has been therefore long viewed with a jealous ad- miration by foreign powers. This very pre-eminence, however, has been contemplated in a very different light by many influential members of our own community, and has been even denounced by them as the certain origin of innumerable evils to the people, and of revo- lutionary convulsions to the state. If the affairs of the kingdom be wisely administered, I believe such allega- tions and fears will prove to be groundless, and to pro- ceed more from the envy of one ancient and powerful order of the commonwealth, towards another sud- denly grown into political importance than from the nature of thing's. In the recent discussions concerning our factories, no circumstance is so deserving of remark, as the gross ignorance evinced by our leading legislators and econo- mists, gentlemen well informed in other respects, rela- tive to the nature of those stupendous manufactures which have so long provided the rulers of the kingdom with the resources of war, and a great body of the people with comfortable subsistence ; which have, in fact, made this island the arbiter of many nations, and the benefactor of the globe itself.* Till this ignorance be dispelled, no sound legislation need be expected on manufacturing subjects. To effect this purpose is a principal, but not the sole aim of the present volume, * Even the eminent statesman lately selected by his Sovereign to wield the destinies of this commercial empire — Sir Robert Peel, who derives his family consequence from the cotton trade, seems to be but little conversant with its nature and condition. — See Dr. Carbutt's observations on the subject, next page. MANUFACTURING INDUSTRY. 7 for it is intended also to convey specific information to the classes directly concerned in the manufactures, as well as general knowledge to the community at large, and particularly to young persons about to make the choice of a profession. The blessings which physico-mechanical science has bestowed on society, and the means it has still in store for ameliorating the lot of mankind, have been too little dwelt upon ; while, on the other hand, it has been accused of lending itself to the rich capitalists as an instrument for harassing the poor, and of exacting, from the opera- tive an accelerated rate of work. It has been said, for example, that the steam-engine now drives the power- looms with such velocity as to urge on their attendant weavers at the same rapid pace ; but that the hand- weaver, not being subjected to this restless agent, can throw his shuttle and move his treddles at his conveni- ence. There is, however, this difference in the two cases, that in the factory, every member of the loom is so ad- justed, that the driving force leaves the attendant nearly nothing at all to do, certainly no muscular fatigue to sustain, while it procures for him good, unfailing wages, besides a healthy workshop gratis : whereas the non- factory weaver, having everything to execute by mus- cular exertion, finds the labour irksome, makes in con- sequence innumerable short pauses, separately of little account, but great when added together ; earns there- fore proportionally low wages, while he loses his health by poor diet and the dampness of his hovel. Dr. Car- butt of Manchester says, turned out at the instigation, as they told us at the time, of the delegates of the union. They said they had no fault to find with their wages, their work, or their masters, but the union obliged them to turn out. The same week three delegates from the spinners' union waited upon us at our mill, and dictated certain advances in wages, and other regulations, to which, if we would not adhere, they said neither our own spin- ners nor any other shoujd work for us again ! Of course we declined, believing our wages to be ample, and our regulations such as were necessary for the proper conducting of the establishment. The conse- quences were, they set watches on every avenue to the mill, night and day, to prevent any fresh hands coming into the mill, an object which they effectually attained, by intimidating some, and promising support to others (whom I got into the mill in a caravan), if they would leave their work. Under these circum- 284 RELATIVE COMFORTS OF stances I could not work the mill, and advertised it for sale, without any applications, and I also tried in vain to let it. At the end of twenty-three weeks the hands requested to be taken into the mill again on the terms that they had left it; declaring, as they had done at first, that the union alone had forced them to turn out. The names of the delegates that waited on me were, Jonathan Hodgins, Thomas Foster, and Peter Madox, secretary to the union. " What advance of wages did they require? — Ans. It was considerable, but I don't remember the exact sum ; and the regulations required were, that the men should not be fined for bad work, or for not con- forming to the regulations of the mill ! u Have you ever had turn-outs before ? — Ans. Yes, two; in a former turn-out of the spinners, we were waited on by a man named Doherty, and Jonathan Hodgins, two leaders of the union, who, after examining our wage book and the machinery on which the men worked, stated that the wages were fair, and the machinery good ; and they ordered them to their work again." The increase of the silk trade at Manchester is partly owing to its migration from Macclesfield, which is much depopulated in consequence of the restrictions placed on labour by the unions. Norwich has suffered the same evil. All silk-weavers work by hand ; and earn from 12s. to 20s. per week, according to their skill and diligence. Mr. Brocklehurst, being desirous to make gros-de-Naples at Macclesfield, put out 400 or 500 warps, which would have given employment to many more persons; but the weavers would not bring in the webs without an advance on the prices agreed FACTORY OPERATIVES. 285 on, and in fact laid such obstructions in the way, that he was obliged to restrict his business, and produced no goods of consequence in that line, because the men would not work at the Manchester prices. In 1833 about 6,000Z. were paid weekly in silk-weavers' wages. Mr. William Harter, in his evidence on the silk trade, says, " I have seen a great many turn-outs, and have invariably found that the result was the lowering of the wages of the operative ; that was the result in my own case. In the spring of the year, when the looms were full of goods, the weavers thought they could do what they pleased under such circumstances, and struck for higher wages ; but after remaining out of work for three or four months they came to terms. I had meanwhile got hands from the cotton trade */' " I was not aware," says a Factory Commissioner f, " until I was engaged in the investigation at Glasgow ,, that the operatives there have so completely organized their association, as not only to prescribe the wages to be paid to the members of the association, but to all other persons, from whatever quarter they may come ; that further, no male worker not entered with them is allowed to work at all, without their consent, and the concurrence of the association, and never without making a payment to them at the beginning, and con- tinuing a weekly payment at the same rate as their own afterwards ; that females, however able, are not allowed to become spinners, or to be engaged as such ; and that it is hardly in the power of a piecer, that is of * Factory Commission. — Second Rep. of Central Board, D. 2, p. 38. t James Stuart, Esq., Author of an excellent Tour in the United States.— First Report, A. 1, 126. 286 RELATIVE COMFORTS OF an assistant to a spinner, to learn 1 the business of a spinner, unless he is related to a spinner who will bring him forward ; that, in short, the object of the Glasgow Association is to make their company a close corpora- tion, accessible only to those whom they choose to admit, and not only to prevent all others from becoming spinners by their regulations, but by a system of inti- midation, which they successfully carry into execution absolutely by physical force." " The mill-owners in Glasgow," says Mr. Graham, ** did not attempt to bring down the wages of labour, except when they were higher than in Lancashire, but to get the management of their works into their own hands. Nor did they combine with one another to effect their purpose, as their men had done. The labourer not only says — 6 1 will not work for you, un- less for such a price,' but he says — c I will not let any other person do it, however willing ; ' and he sets a w T atch upon the streets, that prevents us from get- ting men in, and will abuse anybody that comes, in the most shocking manner, even to taking their lives, if it were necessary. The consequence is, that we have, once or twice, ourselves attempted to stand out against our men, but we have been obliged to take them in. The practice is illegal, but the law is per- fectly inefficient; we never can get a conviction. Within a week before I left Glasgow, they beat a per- son, and he came back to the work frightened and alarmed, and he w 7 as obliged to go out. Some years ago there were several people almost destroyed, by vitriol being thrown upon them by combined men*." * Wm, Graham, Esq., in Committee's Report on Manufactures, p. 335. FACTORY OPERATIVES. 287 When asked, by the Committee, how it happens that he cannot reduce the price of his spinning as low as his neighbours, Mr. Graham answers, " That the combination of spinners in Glasgow will not allow it, and that he cannot admit a new hand into his mill unless he has joined the combination." What a mortifying predicament, for a most respect- able manufacturer to be obliged, by the vindictive spirit of united workmen, to pay from 35s. to 40s. of weekly wages for the same labour which they freely give his neighbour mill-owners for 21s. or 25s. ! It was no wonder that a temper so dictatorial and conspiracies leading to such violence, excited the deepest interest in the public mind, and roused the legislature to enact new laws corresponding to the novelty of the crimes. The conspirators, aware of the horror which they had inspired in every well-principled mind, betook themselves to a bold line of defence. They disavowed the outrages, on the one hand, and denounced their own occupation on the other, as irk- some in the highest degree, destructive of all comfort, ruinous to health, and the cause of premature decay of all the faculties of body and mind. During a disastrous turn-out in Manchester, in 1818, when fifteen thousand of the factory people refused employment for several months, paraded the streets, besieged such cotton-mills as continued to work in defiance of their commands, and threatened to destroy their industrious inmates, the Committee of the Spinners' Union issued the following pro- clamation, — the fountain-head of the torrents of calumny since so profusely discharged on our factory system : — 288 RELATIVE COMFORTS OF " We believe there is no species of labour so fraught with the want of natural comforts as that the spinners have to contend with ; deprived of fresh air, and sub- jected to long confinement in the impure atmosphere of crowded rooms, continually inhaling the particles of metallic or vegetable dust, his physical powers become debilitated, his animal strength dwindles away, and few survive the meridian of life, and the grave is often the welcome asylum of his woes. His children! but let us draw a veil over the scene ! our streets ex- hibit their cadaverous and decrepit forms, and any attempt to describe them would be impossible. Let it not be understood that we attach blame to our employers, as applied to these calamities ; they are perhaps inseparable from the very nature of the employment, and our masters may lament, but cannot redress them." We shall presently prove that this picture is dis- torted in every respect, and as to the children in par- ticular, there are no trades in which young persons are engaged in numbers, such as sewing, pin-making, or coal-mining, nearly so salubrious, or so comfortable as a cotton-mill. But let us, meanwhile, pursue for a little the rising tide of defamation. In consequence of these turmoils and complaints, Sir Robert Peel's bill for regulating the hours of labour in factories was passed in 1818 : but a similar spirit of discontent continuing to manifest itself, a second bill was passed in 1825, and a third in 1831 — the last under the direction of Sir J. C. Hobhouse. A general meeting of the mill-owners and other inhabit- ants of Manchester took place soon after the passing of the last bill, at which resolutions were made for FACTORY OPERATIVES. 289 enforcing the execution of its provisions, under a com- mittee of superintendence. This bill was soon found to be ineffectual towards protecting children from being worked over-hours under greedy operatives and needy parents : for it held out mutual temptations to collusion and perjury with respect to the ages of the children employed by the spinner to mend his broken yarns, and sweep up the stray fibres of cotton from the floor. As the masters paid the spinners the full allowance of wages for these piecers and scavengers, as they are called, he had a strong motive to prohibit their being worked too long, or beyond their strength, for in all such cases he would suffer loss, by the bad quality of his yarn, and the waste of his cotton. Every manufacturer is well acquainted with the eagerness of his spinners to earn the highest possible wages by quick work and prolonged hours, and knows that if he stops his mill half an hour sooner than his neighbours, he will certainly lose his most skilful hands. Owners become thus a check on each other, relative both to the time of labour and amount of remuneration. The spinners, being obviously respon- sible for the quality of the yarn, must of course have the selection and hiring of their juvenile assistants ; yet if they introduce those who are too young, un- skilful, or feeble, they would expose themselves to the censure of the overlookers of the rooms, as well as the manager and master of the factory. Hence the ten- dency of the spinners to overwork children relative to their years, is controlled, directly, by the observa- tion of superintendents, and, indirectly, by inspection of the quality of the work, which, if at all defective, occasions deduction of wages, or even the imposition vol. i. o 290 RELATIVE COMFORTS OF of a fine. Nearly the whole of the children of four- teen years of age, and under, who are employed in cotton-mills, belong to the mule-spinning department, and are, in forty-nine cases out of fifty, the immediate servants and dependents, often the offspring or near relations of the spinner, being hired and dismissed at his option. In fact, mule-spinning could not go on with any degree of prosperity if the assistants were independent of the operative. He is therefore their sole patron and master, and as such is naturally courted by poor parents, solicitous to get their children profitably employed. We may judge, from these un- doubted facts, of the absurdity and injustice of the clamour so industriously propagated against the pro- prietors of mills for cruelty to children under their charge. The slightest inquiry on the spot, the most superficial ocular inspection, would have satisfied any candid mind, that the owners, from regard to pecuniary interest, as well as to humanity and reputa- tion, always set their faces against every species of oppression within their premises. Nothing shows in a clearer point of view the credulity of mankind in general, and of the people of these islands in particular, than the ready faith which was given to the tales of cruelty exercised by proprietors of cotton-mills towards young children. The system of calumny somewhat resembles that brought by the Pagans against the primitive Christians, of enticing children into their meetings in order to murder and devour them. The sentimental fever thus excited by the craft of the Operatives' Union was inflamed into a delirious paroxysm by the partial, distorted,, and fictitious evidence conjured up before the Committee FACTORY OPERATIVES. 291 of the House of Commons on factory employment, of which Mr. Sadler was the mover and chairman. It commenced its sittings on the 12th April, 1832, and did not terminate them till the 7th of August follow- ing, when it published a mass of defamation against the cotton- mills, spread over upwards of 600 folio pages. Of this notable report, Mr. Tufnell, a most able and candid observer, makes the following remarks in his Factory Commission Report to the Secretary of State :— (e The selection of witnesses to be examined before that body was most extraordinary. Of the eighty- nine who gave evidence, only three came directly from Manchester, though it is the largest manufac- turing town in the kingdom, and being almost w T holly devoted to the cotton-trade, which is as yet the only business subjected to a factory bill, some important information respecting the experience of former fac- tory bills, and the probable effects of the change it was proposed to make, might reasonably be expected from it. Of these three witnesses not one w T as a me- dical man, a manufacturer, or a clergyman. The first was a dresser of yarn, and is now one of the delegates sent by the Lancashire workmen to London to forward the passing of the Ten-Hour Factory Bill, and w 7 hose colleague is a man named Doherty, who (it is right that the character of the leaders in this business should be known) originally came to Man- chester with a forged character, and was subsequently imprisoned for two years for a gross assault upon a woman ; the second is the keeper of a small tavern in the purlieus of the town, and the third is an atheist. " The first being in London I could not re-examine, o2 292 RELATIVE COMFORTS OF but he refused to corroborate his former evidence be- fore the Central Board of Commissioners when re- quested to do so by them ; to the second, I sent a summons and he refused to attend ; the third did attend, and the following is the commencement of his examination : — Have you any objection to take an oath ? Ans. I would rather not. I have no objection to kiss the dirty book. Truth is what I swear by, and wherever I meet her I embrace her. "'Do you believe in a God? Ans. Can you tell me what God is ? God is incomprehensible. I am a moral character. When I was in London I lived in Mr. Carlile's shop, Fleet Street. I acted in the capacity of a servant to Mr. Carlile and the Rev. Robert Taylor.' "Considerable part of this man's evidence, which fills nine folio pages of the Committee's (Mr. Sadler's) Report, refers to charges thirty and forty years old ; but every specific accusation which he or his two compeers had made against the cotton-mills, I as- certained, from witnesses of the utmost respectability, to be absolutely false From this specimen we may judge of the nature of Mr. Sadler's evidence against the textile factories. Yet so violent was the prejudice raised by its means, as well as by the Chairman's rhetorical expositions, and those of his parliamentary partisans, that an influen- tial newspaper, responsive to popular feeling, ex- pressed itself on the subject in the following strong terms on the 28th May, 1833:— * Supplementary Report of the Central Board of Factory Commis- sioners, page 209. FACTORY OPERATIVES. 2S3 " The state of these infants is really, in our eyes, the blackest guilt with which England stands chargeable at the present moment; and we are convinced that the reformed House of Commons will remove it with- out delay, whatever these Commissioners (on factory employment) may report, whatever new device the hard-hearted manufacturers may have recourse to, and however Ministers may countenance other schemes of procrastination, as they have countenanced this scheme of a commission." In the same paper appeared an extract from a protest presented to the gentlemen of the Government Factory Commission on their arrival at Leeds. " You appear," says this modest docu- ment, " to be quite ignorant of the subject of inquiry, which to its due examination demands habits, talents, and experience far different from those requisite for mere legal investigations/' &c. &c. &c. In thus revil- ing the characters and capacities of the Commissioners (who were not all lawyers) Mr. Sadler was singularly out of his reckoning. Their examinations and reports are as remarkable for sagacity and candour, as All are for the opposite qualities. So gloomily meanwhile did the phantoms of factory cruelty haunt the public mind, that the same talented journal published, on the 18th June, the following remarkable animad- versions : — " The Government and the Commissioners are now on the right way, and we hope will arrive at the end of their journey, with the same humane dis- positions, and entitled to the same grateful applause, as at the commencement. It w T as high time that something should be done, after the publication of the late report from Mr. Sadler s committee, if not for 294 RELATIVE COMFORTS OF the sake of humanity and religion, if not to check barbarous oppression, or to protect helpless infancy, at least to rescue our moral character from disgrace, and our manufacturing system from abhorrence among other nations. We remember a period, when, actuated by a feeling of horror at the atrocities of the slave-trade, some of the more enthusiastic friends of its abolition, in order to terminate the evil, abstained from the use of sugar produced by slave-labour, and if we may credit the sincerity of one of the speakers in the principality of Darmstadt on a late occasion, the people of Germany might, from the strong repre- sentations of our English white slavery, almost be led to discontinue the use of English manufactures. In a debate which arose in the states of Darmstadt, on a bill for punishing cruelty to animals, Baron Gugern, well known for some political tracts, took occasion to describe the manufacturing system of Eng- land, as more cruel than any thing from which it was proposed to protect the inferior creation in Germany. His picture is not overcharged as limited to our fac- tory population, though he is wrong in applying its features indiscriminately to our whole population. He seems to imagine that England is one huge factory; that all our children and youths are employed in spinning cotton or weaving calicoes for German con- sumption, and that there is a perfect contrast, result- ing from this labour, between an English and a German village. Now r we need not remind our own countrymen, though we may apprise M. Gugern and our German customers, that although a large body of children in our manufacturing towns are subject to the toils and restraints w r hich he so feelingly describes, FACTORY OPERATIVES. 295 the blight has not spread over the whole land ; and that our villages are often as happy as those of any nation which wears our broad-cloths or our calicoes." When Lord Ashley's ten hours' bill came on for discussion in the House of Commons, on July 5, 1833, the Chancellor of the Exchequer, Lord Althorp, said, " that on looking into the provisions of the bill, he could not but feel apprehensive, that if it were passed in its present form, it would have a most in- jurious effect upon the manufacturing interests of the country. He need not say, that if the effect of legis- lative interference were to increase the power of foreigners to compete with us, so far from being a benefit to the poor people, whom it was sought to protect, any measure of this kind would be one of the greatest injuries which could be inflicted on the manu- facturing population. He said so, because he need only draw their attention to the state of the manufac- turing districts to show, that if any measure had the effect of diminishing the demand for our goods, the result would be to throw the whole population of these districts out of work, and in consequence to pro- duce the most miserable effects. He was not one to say that nothing ought to be done in this case, as, from the general excitement and feeling throughout the country, Parliament must interfere, and protect unfortunate children from suffering under such cruel oppression and being treated with undue severity. But when the measure of the noble lord, taking the ages of the parties into consideration, went to fix on the short period of ten hours, he thought he shortened the period too much, as regarded adults, more par- ticularly as all the arguments urged in the house 296 RELATIVE COMFORTS OF referred to children of nine, ten, and eleven years old, and did not apply to adults, who had an option to work or not as they thought proper. The house had the opinion of the Factory Commissioners, that the protection heretofore afforded to children was by no means satisfactory; let the house then limit them- selves to this subject, without applying themselves to parties for whom their interference was unnecessary, as they could choose for themselves. With this view, should the house agree with him, he would wish to refer the subject to a select committee, and he should suggest, that children, before the fourteenth year of their age, should not be allowed to work more than eight hours a day." u The great object urged by Lord Ashley," added the Chancellor of the Exchequer, se and one which every man would willingly give his aid to, was to give chil- dren the benefit of education, which it was impossible they could enjoy, while compelled to continual labour throughout every day, and he therefore thought that care should be taken that the children should have this advantage during the intervals which occurred in their labour ; and that inspections of the mills should take place in order to secure the operation of these provisions of the new bill" Lord Ashley said, " he had no objection that chil- dren under thirteen years of age should work no more than eight hours ; neither had he the slightest objec- tion to the system of compulsory education mentioned, for it was a deep source of regret to him that there should be so many thousands in this country deprived of this blessing. It was becoming in Lord Althorp, as a minister of the crown, thus to come forward, and if FACTORY OPERATIVES. 297 he chose to go farther, he should find in him a zealous supporter ; and should the noble lord extend his bounty in this way, not merely to factory children, but to all who were destitute, he would not only be the best benefactor to this country, but the most glorious minister that ever existed." A celebrated Irish member exclaimed, " Then why not legislate at once ? On one side was the number of children slaughtered in a year ; on the other the pos- sibility of the loss of the sale of a certain portion of calico. The protection ought to last till twenty-one, at all events to eighteen assigning as a reason in law, that the Lord Chancellor took especial care of all under twenty-one years, and that the House of Com* mons was bound to act as universal chancellor. In the House of Commons, July 18th, Lord Althorp moved an amendment on Lord Ashley's bill, to the effect that protection should be given by the bill only to those who could not protect themselves, and that adults should be left to their own discretion ; — a motion w T hich was carried by 238 votes against 93, or with a majority of 145. It will certainly appear surprising to every dispas- sionate mind, that ninety-three members of the British House of Commons could be found capable of voting that any class of grown-up artisans should not be suf- fered to labour more than ten hours a day — an inter- ference with the freedom of the subject which no other legislature in Christendom would have countenanced for a moment. The Gloucestershire manufacturers justly characterized the proposal as "worthy of the darkest ages, when governments took on themselves to control, direct, and punish all handicrafts, trades, and o3 298 RELATIVE COMFORTS OF callings for any diversity in their operations. " This, says Mr. Tufnell, is not strongly enough expressed. We shall now detail a few more particulars concern- ing t he origin of this torrent of falsehood and defama- tion which lately overflowed the country, and had nearly converted its most productive fields of industry into sloughs of despond. We have seen that the union of operative spinners had, at an early date, denounced their own occupa- tions as being irksome, severe, and unwholesome in an unparalleled degree. Their object in making this misrepresentation was obviously to interest the com- munity in their favour at the period of their lawless strike in the year 1818. Subsequently to this crisis, some individuals of their governing committee made the notable discovery, that if the quantity of yarn an- nually spun could by any means be reduced, its scarcity in the market would raise its price, and con- sequently raise the rate of their wages. They accord- ingly suggested the shortening of the time of labour to ten hours, as the grand remedy for low wages and hard work ; though at this time they were receiving at least three times more wages than hand-loom weavers for the same number of hours' employment, and therefore had very little reason to complain of their lot. In fact; it was their high wages which enabled them to maintain a stipendiary committee in affluence, and to pamper themselves into nervous ail- ments by a diet too rich and exciting for their in-door occupations. Had they plainly promulgated their views and claims, they well knew that no attention would have been paid to them, but they artfully intro- duced the tales of cruelty and oppression to children, FACTORY OPERATIVES. 299 as resulting from their own protracted labour, and succeeded by this stratagem to gain many well mean- ing proselytes to their cause. The clamour for the ten-hour bill, and the subsidiary lamentation for the children, were confined among the operatives, almost exclusively to the mule-spinners. We have here a remarkable proof of the power of passion to stultify the human understanding. Since the said spinners are the sole employers of the younger children in cotton- mills, who are often their own offspring, and entirely at their disposal to hire or to turn away, they were the only persons capable of abusing them, the sole arbiters of their fate^ and therefore amenable to the parents and the public for their good treatment. The mill- owner,, in fact, could never interfere but beneficially for the children, to protect them against the occasional caprice of these friends to humanity, who alone could exercise tyranny over their dependents. We may judge from these particulars of the effrontery of the Spinner's Union, and of the credulity of their partisans in and out of parliament. If cruelty of any kind existed at any time, the operatives were the only cul- prits, and ought to have been prosecuted for it, or at least for practising gross imposition on the public to serve their own sinister ends. After receiving so much unmerited sympathy from well-meaning philanthro- pists, their impudence knew no bounds. Within a week after the factory commissioners arrived at Man- chester, the Operatives' Union dramatized the miseries of the children in a public procession. They collected about 4000 of the youngest, mustered them in tawdry array, and paraded them through the streets, heading the motley throng by themselves or their agents, bran- 300 RELATIVE COMFORTS OF dishing straps and bludgeons as emblems of their masters tyranny, but really the instruments of their own wickedness, if punishment were ever inflicted by them with such weapons in their moments of ill- humour. If it be a maxim of equity in every state that false accusation should recoil on the heads of its authors, what punishment ought to be awarded to those who, after committing unknown severities upon their depen- dent children, should magnify the extent of the evil a thousand-fold, and lay all this load of exaggerated crime on persons not only entirely innocent and uncon- scious of its existence, but avowed enemies to its com- mission in any degree. The following short extract of evidence given on oath by respectable witnesses will confirm the pre- ceding statement. " Who is it that beats the chil- dren? — The spinner." " Not the master ? — No; the masters have nothing to do with the children — they don't employ them." " Do you (a spinner) pay and employ your own piecers ? — Yes ; it is the general rule in Manchester; but our master is very strict over us, that we don't employ them under age." u Are the children ever beaten ? — Sometimes they get beat, but not severely; for sometimes they make the stuff to waste, and then correction is needful ; but that is un- known to the master — he does not allow beating at all*. 5 ' No master would wish to have any wayward children to work within the walls of his factory, who do not mind their business without beating, and he thereore usually fines or turns away any spinners who are known to maltreat their assistants. Hence, ill-usage * Supplementary Factory Commission Report, p, 193. FACTORY OPERATIVES. 301 of any kind is a very rare occurrence. I have visited many factories, both in Manchester and in the sur- rounding districts, during a period of several months, entering the spinning rooms, unexpectedly, and often alone, at different times of the day, and I never saw a single instance of corporal chastisement inflicted on a child, nor indeed did I ever see children in ill-humour- They seemed to be always cheerful and alert, taking pleasure in the light play of their muscles, — enjoying the mobility natural to their age. The scene of indus- try, so far from exciting sad emotions in my mind, was always exhilarating. It was delightful to observe the nimbleness with which they pieced the broken ends, as the mule-carriage began to recede from the fixed roller beam, and to see them at leisure, after a few seconds' exercise of their tiny fingers, to amuse them- selves in any attitude they chose, till the stretch and winding-on w r ere once more completed. The work of these lively elves seemed to resemble a sport, in which habit gave them a pleasing dexterity. Conscious of their skill, they were delighted to show it off to any stranger. As to exhaustion by the day's work, they evinced no trace of it on emerging from the mill in the evening; for they immediately began to skip about any neighbouring play-ground, and to commence their little amusements with the same alacrity as boys issuing from a school. It is moreover my firm con- viction, that if children are not ill-used by bad parents or guardians, but receive in food and raiment the full benefit of what they earn, they would thrive better when employed in our modern factories, than if left at home in apartments too often ill-aired, damp, and cold. 302 RELATIVE COMFORTS OF The most curious circumstance in the whole con- troversy was the different grounds on which the ten* hour bill was advocated by the leaders of the philan- thropic crusade, and by the operatives themselves in the factory districts. In London, and the agricultural counties, the Spinners' Union succeeded perfectly in mystifying their dupes by romantic representations of ivhile slavery, and of the hecatombs of infants sacri- ficed annually on the calico- crowned altar of Mammon ; but they durst not utter such barefaced falsehoods in Lancashire, because they knew in the first place that they would become laughing-stocks to the other classes of w r ork-people, and in the next, that they would be immediately charged by the superior ranks with either secret cruelty or dow T nright imposture. They would have been told by one and all, u if the children are ill- used, you alone are the criminals." In fact, not a single witness who appeared before Mr. Tufnell to give evidence in favour of the ten-hour bill (and he made it a rule never to turn away any of its advocates, but to summon many of them who would not otherwise have come forward), not one of them, of whatever trade or station he might have been, supported it out of sympathy for the children. That motives of huma- nity had not the smallest concern in the business, is a fact made out by the clearest demonstration which human testimony can give. We select one or two from a multitude of proofs. "What is the motive with the operatives in general for advocating the ten- hour bill ? — They imagine their wages will not be pulled down ; that there will be so much less yarn in the market ; that the price will rise ; and that will FACTORY OPERATIVES. 303 cause their wages to rise. That I am certain is their general opinion. " Do you think, if they were assured that such a rise of wages would not take place, they would still advo- cate it ? — No ; they would never advocate it. " Has a desire to lessen the labour of young chil- dren no influence in making them advocate it ? — Not in the least. Can you explain why the operatives make this outcry about the cruelty of employing too young chil- dren in mills, when in every case of such employment it appears that they are themselves to blame ? — As far as I am able to judge, they think that, if the hours of labour were reduced, their income would be the same as at present; that is the notion among our men; many of the spinners with whom I have spoke on it, have told me that. (c Then you think that a desire to decrease the labour of children is not the real reason for advocating the ten-hour bill ? — No ; I never met one that had that feeling about the children ; they all say it would be pleasant to work ten hours, and have the same wages. " Do you think, that if they thought their wages would be reduced one-sixth (for two hours out of twelve) they would advocate the ten-hour bill ? — No ; not if they were reduced one shilling." Nothing can place the folly of the attacks lately made upon the factory system in a stronger light than these documents, which might be multiplied, if neces- sary. The operatives, blinded by envy, and misled by phantoms of gain, need, in fact, defence against their self-defamation. I am certain that the general accu- sation of cruelty is groundless in respect even to this 304 RELATIVE COMFORTS OF class of individuals. They dare not be cruel, from fear of the just resentment of the very masters whom they falsely charge with cruelty. That particular instances of ill-usage to children do occur sometimes in factories, as in families and schools, is undoubtedly true; and they will happen wherever the depraved nature of man is not renovated by the Christian spirit ; but they are exceedingly rare. It would be a gross exaggeration to say they equal in amount, one-tenth of the hardships which children have to endure in pin- manufactories and many agricultural employments. Since factory labour does not, as we shall fully prove, essentially impair the comfort of those engaged in it, more than other worse paid avocations, we may ask, why should the workmen wish to clog it with legislative restrictions? It is because they reckon, and with justice, that a law compelling their master to turn away all persons under eighteen years of age after ten hours' work will compel him in fact to stop the mill. But as he will then produce a sixth less yarn, he must of necessity raise its price, or cease to spin any more. Now the work-people having usually found that a rise of prices caused a rise of wages in the natural circumstances of increased demand in the market, they therefore concluded that a rise of prices made by the factitious agency of an act of parliament, in- dependently of any increased demand for goods, would have a similar effect on their wages. Here their poli- tical economy was grievously at fault. They com- mitted the egregious blunder of confounding a rise resulting from increased demand or competition of purchasers, with a rise resulting from increased diffi- culty or cost of production. Whereas the two cases FACTORY OPERATIVES. 305 are totally dissimilar : increased consumption would accompany the former condition, and diminished con- sumption the latter. It would be foolish to devote more time to the refutation of so glaring an absurdity, as that ten hours' work can, in the present state of the worlds earn the same wages as twelve hours', the profit on the produce being necessarily reduced in a still greater ratio than that of twelve to ten, on account of the sunk capital being the same as before. It is certain, then, that the reason which was so pro- minently put before the public in favour of the ten- hour Bill is altogether groundless — that children in cotton-mills are not injured by their labours, and are not in general overworked. The notion of their being so, is wholly repudiated in the greatest manufacturing district of England. How else can we explain the fact, that persons of the utmost respectability in pri- vate life are in the habit of sending their children to work the usual hours in well-regulated cotton-mills ? Mr. Rowbotham, for example, the superintendent of nearly 400 workmen in Mr. Birley's mills, a man of equal respectability with any London shopkeeper, has brought up all his children in cotton-factories, and three out of four of them in that department which is usually considered the most unhealthy of all — the card-room. Are we to suppose that Mr. Row- botham, and hundreds such as he, are so devoid of parental affection as to wish to deform their children, and to subject them to all the miseries described in Mr. Sadler's factory committee ; or are they so unob- servant, as not to have discovered, if such a discovery can be made, that from eleven to twelve hours' labour in a cotton-mill injures their children ? One of two 306 RELATIVE COMFORTS OF things must be true ; either the tales of the hardships of the factory children are unfounded, or the Lanca- shire people are utterly devoid of understanding, humanity, and parental tenderness. If those persons who are best acquainted with, and constantly reside in the factory districts, do not rest their advocacy for the ten-hour Bill on the plea of humanity, and if by their conduct they show that they disbelieve this plea, what evidence can outweigh or even balance this argument ? It neutralizes, nay, annihilates all other evidence of any kind, that sophistry can adduce. Were it contra- dicted by all the physicians of London, the physicians must be wrong ; if ret urns of sick societies or mortality tables say otherwise, they must be false — all the testi- mony that can be raked together from other sources cannot overlay this evidence, without leading to the absurd conclusion, that the whole population of the said districts are void of sense and feeling *, It seems established by a body of incontestable evi- dence, that the wages of our factory work-people, if prudently spent, would enable them to live in a com- fortable manner, and decidedly better than formerly, in consequence of the relative diminution in the price of food, fuel, lodgings, and clothing. But the manu- facturers fear that, from the lower rate of wages, and the less expensive style of living among the work- people on the Continent, and in the United States, their foreign rivals may, ere long, be able to bring for- ward many descriptions of cotton goods more cheaply than they can continue to do, if competition advances in the same ratio as it has done for several years. The average of the wages paid to all the persons employed * Mr. Tufnell's Factory Commission Report. FACTORY OPERATIVES. 307 in Messrs. Lees's mills at Gorton amounts to 12s. weekly per head,, young and old ; and as the establish- ment includes 711 persons from nine years of age and upwards, the wealth diffused by this factory in its neighbourhood must be very considerable. The aver- age of the men's wages in Mr. Ashlon's mills at Hyde is 21s. per week, while that of the people not in factory employment is only 14s. The following table of the wages paid in forty-three of the principal mills in Manchester gives irresistible proof to the present proposition. TABLE Of the Number of Persons of various Ages, distinguishing Males and Females, employed in forty-three Cotton-Mills, in Manchester, the average clear weekly earnings of each age and sex, the per centage which each age and sex bears to the whole number employed, and the per centage of the total of such age relatively to the gross total employed. AGES. Number of Males. Average clear wages per week. Per centage of Numbers. Number of Females. Average clear wages per week. Per centage of Numbers. Number of each age. Per centage of each age. s. d. s. d. From 9 to 10 498 2 9f 2| 290 2 11* 11 788 4-58 10 12 819 3 8 4f 538 3 9f 31 1357 7-87 12 14 1021 5 0± 5| 761 4 m 4f 1782 10-34 14 16 853 6 5i 4| 797 6 4| 4i 1650 9*57 16 18 708 8 2i 4£ 1068 8 Of 6i 1776 10-30 18 21 758 10 4 4| 1582 8 11 9t 2340 13-58 21 & upwards. 3632 22 5f 21 3910 9 m 22f 7542 43-76 8289 8946 17235 308 RELATIVE COMFORTS OF FACTORY OPERATIVES. 309 Of all the common prejudices that exist with regard to factory labour, there is none more unfounded than that, which ascribes to it excessive tedium and irksome- ness above other occupations, owing to its being carried on in conjunction with the iC unceasing motion of the steam-engine." In an establishment for spinning or weaving cotton, all the hard work is performed by the steam-engine, which leaves for the attendant no hard labour at all, and literally nothing to do in general ; but at intervals to perform some delicate operation, such as joining the threads that break, taking the cops off the spindles, &c. And it is so far from being true that the work in a factory is incessant, because the motion of the steam-engine is incessant, that the fact is, that the labour is not incessant on that very ac- count, because it is performed in conjunction with the steam-engine. Of all manufacturing employments, those are by far the most irksome and incessant in which steam-engines are not employed, as in lace- running and stocking-weaving ; and the way to prevent an employment from being incessant, is to introduce a steam-engine into it. These remarks certainly apply more especially to the labour of children in factories. Three-fourths of the children so employed are en- gaged in piecing at the mules. " When the carriages of these have receded a foot and a half or two feet from the rollers," says Mr. Tufnell, (( nothing is to be done, not even attention is required from either spinner or piecer *." Both f of them stand idle for a * Supplementary Report of Factory Commissioners, p. 205. f The view of mule-spinning inserted at page 211 of Mr. Baines's statistical history of the cotton manufacture, shows how incompetent a general artist is to delineate a system of machinery. He has given pic- 310 RELATIVE COMFORTS OF time, and in fine spinning particularly, for three-quar- ters of a minute, or more. Consequently, if a child remains at this business twelve hours daily, he has nine hours of inaction. And though he attends two mules, he has still six hours of non-exertion. Spinners sometimes dedicate these intervals to the perusal of torial effect, regardless of truth and propriety. In the first place, he has located the mules in the attic story, and has illuminated them with sky-light windows, in order to show off the cast-iron framing of a factory-roof. Now, mule-spinning requires horizontal light, and is never carried on in the garrets of modern mills. These are re- served for preparation, winding, warping, doubling, web-dressing, &c. Secondly, the piecers are there figured joining the broken threads, when they are five feet distant from the roving ends, and would therefore need to have arms at least six feet long for the purpose. The moment a thread breaks, the one end curls about the drawing- roller at the fixed beam, and the other round the top of the spindle in the carriage ; so that in the position of the carriage in that pic- ture, there would be an interval of about five feet between the broken ends. Thirdly, the adult spinner is exhibited as busy with the copping-wire of the mule before him, where he has no business to be ; for its carriage is in the act of coming out upon the automatic principle ; while he ought to be then standing close by the headstock of the opposite mule, ready to return its carriage by the operation of the one hand and to guide the faller-rod by the other, in winding the yarn of the finished stretch upon the spindles. In fact, the whole train of operations has been curiously travestied in that engraving. Mule-spinning as there shown off, would be the incessant slavery which Mr. Sadler's partisans described it to be, like the labour of the DanaideB, never ending r or suspending. Whereas the spinner has nothing to do, while the carriage is slowly drawing and spinning the thread ; and the piecers have nothing to do, either during the coming out or going in of the carriage, but they should seize the moment of its proximity to the roller-beam to mend the broken ends, and missing this period, they must remain idle till the comple- tion of another act of stretching and winding on. Were the young persons seen in such positions at such times, they would get a sharp rebuke from the spinner, or more probably be dismissed by him for egregious stupidity. See our view of Mule-spinning, p. 308. FACTORY OPERATIVES. 311 books. The scavengers, who in Mr. Sadler's report have been described as being " constantly in a state of grief, always in terror, and every moment they have to spare stretched all their length upon the floor in a state of perspiration may be observed in cotton-fac- tories idle for four minutes at a time, or moving about in a sportive mood, utterly unconscious of the tragical scenes in which they were dramatized. Occupations which are assisted by steam-engines require for the most part a higher, or at least a steadier species of labour, than those which are not ; the exer- cise of the mind being then partially substituted for that of the muscles, constituting skilled labour, which is always paid more highly than unskilled. On this principle we can readily account for the comparatively high wages which the inmates of a factory, whether children or adults, obtain. Batting cotton by hand for fine spinning seems by far the hardest work in a factory ; it is performed wholly by women, without any assistance from the steam-engine, and is somewhat similar in effort to threshing corn; yet it does not bring those who are engaged in it more than 6s. 6d. weekly, while close by is the stretching-frame, which remunerates its tenters or superintendents, women, and even children fourteen years old, with double wages for far lighter labour. In power-loom weaving also, the wages are good, and the muscular effort is trifling, as those who tend it frequently exercise themselves .by fol- lowing the movement of the lay, and leaning on it with their arms. It is reckoned a very healthy mill-occu- pation, as is shown by the appearance of the females * Report of Mr. Sadler's Factory Committee, p. 325. 312 RELATIVE COMFORTS OF engaged in it, in every well-regulated establishment in England and Scotland. (See the engraving at the end of the volume.) The more refined the labour in factories is, it be- comes generally the lighter and the pleasanter. Thus the fine spinning is the least laborious in Manchester, owing to the slowness with which the machinery moves in forming fine threads. The mule for No. 30 or No. 40, makes in general three stretches in a minute ; but the mule for higher numbers makes only one stretch in the same time. During at least three-fourths of this minute, the four, five, or more piecers, who attend the pair of mules of 460 spindles each, have absolutely nothing to do, but are seen in an easy attitude, till the carriage begins to start for a new stretch, when they proceed immediately to mend the threads, which break, or are purposely broken on account of some unsightly knot. The pieceing is soon over, as the carriage does not stop an instant, at the frame, but forthwith resumes its spin- ning routine, and when it has again come out somewhat less than two feet, it places the rollers and roving beyond the reach of the hands of the piecers, and gives them another interval of repose. There is so little scavenger work required in fine spinning, on ac- count of the small quantity of waste from the long- stapled cotton, that it is usually performed by one of the piecers. From the same cause there is hardly any dust to be seen in the air of the rooms. The fine-spinning mills at Manchester, w T hich have been so grossly disparaged by the partisans of the ten- hours' Bill, are, in fact, the triumph of art and the glory of England. In the beauty, delicacy, and in- genuity of the machines, they have no parallel among FACTORY OPERATIVES. 313 the works of man ; nor in the orderly arrangement, and the value of the products. When 350 hanks are spun, containing only one pound of cotton, they form an almost incredible length of thread, extending 294,000 yards, or 167 miles, and enhancing the price of the material from 3s. 8d. to twenty-five guineas. This department of English industry is quite un- rivalled,, and notwithstanding the most indefatigable efforts of our ingenious neighbours in France, it still lays every foreign weaver of fine muslin and lace under contribution. It is in spinning the lower numbers, as 40s., and in weaving, that our manufacturers some time ago were most fearful of being hard-pressed by foreign compe- tition. Switzerland has for the last seven years, not only supplied herself, but her neighbours, to a con- siderable extent with that mean quality which may be reckoned the staple of cotton yarns. It appears that the time of working cotton-mills in Manchester is less, by about one hour daily, than that in any other part of the world, where the cotton manufacture is carried on to any extent ; and if the time be further abridged, it would probably prove most injurious to our commerce. Whether foreigners have or have not machinery equal to our own, forms but one part of the question of foreign competition. As the sale of our goods depends in a great measure on the lowness of their prices, the raising of these would cause a serious decrease of con- sumption — a decrease always much greater than the increased ratio of price. The more remote the market, the more necessary is it to keep the price low, to guard against contingencies, as the goods may otherwise be undersold by the product of the rudest machinery vol. i. p 314 RELATIVE COMFORTS OF cheaply worked. A Madras tanty, or weaver, would live a whole year on a fortnight's wages of a power- loom weaver at Hyde. From the evidence of Messrs. Greg, Birley, Hoole, Kirkman Finlay, Mr. Kempton, and many other most eminent and well-informed manufacturers, it appears that the profits in our cotton trade are much narrowed of late years by foreign competition, and are derived, in no small degree, from the abundance of capital and the low rate of interest for money in this country. The profits which attended our early monopoly of cotton- spinning have long since ceased, in consequence of the supply from all quarters being greater than the demand. At present, not a single mill in Manchester w T orks by night, and only one in its immediate neigh- bourhood ; and in that one, thirty-six persons only work at night, out of the 380 who are employed during the day. Whether the British cotton-trade is likely to main- tain that progressive development which the well- being of our factory population would require, depends on the question, whether the lower wages and longer hours which prevail in foreign factories may not, in course of time, compensate for their inferiority in ma- chinery and manipulation. That this compensation has already taken place to a certain extent, and may eventually to a much greater, is maintained by many of our manufacturers for foreign markets. Mr. Cowell, however, by a most elaborate analysis of cotton-spin- ning, endeavours to prove in his supplementary report, that the wages in England are virtually lower to the capitalist, though higher to the operative, than on the continent of Europe, in consequence of the amount of FACTORY OPERATIVES. 315 work turned out daily by every machine being more than equivalent to the higher price of labour upon it. If his analysis of the labour,, cost, and product of our cotton-mills could be fairly compared with a like analysis of the continental mills, we should have good data for deciding the controversy. But the latter datum is by no means given in a satisfactory manner. Whatever admiration may be justly excited by the fertility of a Manchester mill, should never make us forget the impediments thrown in the way of its pros- perity, by the discontent, intemperance, and strikes of the hands employed to conduct it. From these evils, by which more mischief may be done to our trade in a month of critical competition, than can be repaired in a year, and by which such serious drawbacks exist to the well-being of our manufactures, the foreign cotton-mills, being under the special protection of their respective governments, are entirely exempt. " Speaking generally," says Mr. Ashworth, m from my experience of cotton-spinning on the Continent, derived from an examination of twelve mills in France and Switzerland, in comparison with the wages paid at our mill, taking into view quantity, quality, and time of work, the wages of the operative spinner were generally fifty per cent, lower than our own in money, and the wages of women and children were generally thirty per cent, lower. This answer is to apply to all numbers of yarns. Money wages are here calculated by converting the currency of the one country into that of the other by a bill of exchange." Mr. Edwin Rose, the foreman of Messrs. Sharp and Roberts' great engineering establishment at Man- p2 316 RELATIVE COMFORTS OF Chester, who resided several years among the best cotton factories of France and Switzerland, says, 11 that a man there is satisfied with a deal worse clothing, and is more contented at his work than here. The French appeared a very comfortable set of people; they did not get beastly drunk as working men are inclined to do here. Mr. Roberts uses French screws in his manufactory, finding them even at double price cheaper than English ones, owing to their good shape and exact cut; their spiral is more regular, their thread more even, they taper, which is of great con- sequence, for thus they get tighter in the wood all the way they go. Ours are knocked off so cheap as to be little better than nails*." To illustrate the effect which an improvement in machinery produces upon the income and comforts of the operatives, let us take an instance from the spin- ning department, and it will hold good mutatis mutan- dis in every other. The spinner is the leading and most important operative in cotton-working. He is the one for whom every preliminary process (called "the preparation/' consisting of batting, carding, roving, &c.) is per- formed. So much weight of prepared cotton is de- livered to him, and he has to return by a certain time in lieu of it a given weight of twist or yarn of a certain degree of fineness, and he is paid so much per pound for all that he so returns. If his work is de- fective in quality, the penalty falls on him ; if less in quantity than the minimum fixed for a given time, he * Factory Commission Report, Part I., D. L, p. 123. FACTORY OPERATIVES. 317 is dismissed and an abler operative procured. The productive power of his spinning-machine is accu- rately measured, and the rate of pay for work done with it decreases with (though not as) the increase of its productive power. Since these machines are in a state of continual improvement, what effect is thereby produced upon the spinners' earnings ? The answer to this question will explain the most important cause of the discrepancies exhibited in the column headed " Average net earnings of each individual calculated for sixty-nine hours," and will show whether the ground on which the operatives affirm their wages are continually falling is sound or unsound*. The mule-jenny is a system of spindles — (see wood- cut, page 308.) A spinner manages two of them at the same time. He stands between them ; as one is always advancing while the other is retreating, he turns round from one to the other at regular intervals. The one which is advancing draws out the cotton-roving from the range of bobbins at the back, and moves slowly towards the spinner, spinning the thread the while. The greater the number of spindles, the greater is the number of threads, and the higher the productive power of the machine. Mules vary in the number of spindles they bear, from 250 to 1000 each ; or for the pair of mules, from 500 to 2000. The spinner has from one to ten juvenile assistants, according to the magnitude of his spinning-machine, whom he engages and pays himself without reference to his master, the mill-proprietor. The number of spindles measures the productive power of the machine, and the masters and men agree upon a scale of prices for labour vary- * See my Treatise on the Cotton Manufacture. \ 318 RELATIVE COMFORTS OF ing according to that number. These scales are printed and accessible to all parties. The following is the one at present in force in Manchester : — The first line will explain all the others. It de- notes that a spinner, spinning yarn of the fineness of eighty hanks to the pound, on a mule the productive power of which is represented by 336 spindles, is to be paid at the rate of A\d. the pound of cotton-yarn; that if he spins on a mule bearing 396 spindles and upwards, at the rate of 4d. per pound, and so on ; the rate of pay for work done diminishing as the pro- ductive power of the machine increases, though not exactly in the same proportion. No. signifies 66 num- ber of hanks of yarn to the pound." The figures 336, 348, 396 signify mules carrying respectively those numbers of spindles, and consequently yielding by each effort (technically called the " stretch") 336* 348, or 396 threads of a given length. FACTORY OPERATIVES. 319 The Manchester List of Prices for Spinning upon Mules of the follow- ing sizes, as agreed to by Masters and Men, 5th March, 1831, and in force in June, 1833. Spindles 336 and under. Spindles 348 to 384. Spindles 396 and above. s. d. s. s. d> No. 80 0 4 i 0 4i 0 4 85 0 4f 0 0 90 0 5 i 0 5 0 5 95 0 6 0 0 5£ 100 0 0 0 6 i 105 0 ft* 0 7 0 110 0 8 0 0 115 0 9 0 8j 0 120 0 10 0 9| 0 9 i 125 0 0 11 0 10f 130 1 °i- 1 0 0 m 135 1 H 1 H 1 140 1 3 1 1 2 145 1 4 i 1 3 i 1 150 i 1 5 I 4 i 155 1 1 1 160 1 8 1 1 7 165 1 10 1 9 i 1 8f 170 2 0 1 1 175 2 2J 2 4 2 Of 180 2 5 2 4 2 3 185 2 8 2 7 2 6 190 2 11 2 10 2 195 3 2* 3 ^* 3 0i 200 3 6 3 3 4 205 3 10 3 9 3 8 210 4 2 4 1 4 0 215 4 7 4 h 4 220 5 0 4 10 4 9 225 5 6 5 4 5 3 230 6 0 5 10 5 9 235 6 n 6 5 6 4 240 7 3 7 0 6 11 245 8 7 9 7 8 250 8 10 8 6 8 5 If this table be considered, it will be seen that the ratio of the diminution in the payment for work done 320 RELATIVE COMFORTS OF is less than that of the increase of the productive power of the machine. Hence, the improved machine enables the operative to earn more money in a given time than the imperfect machine. The predominant fear among many operatives is, that improvements in machinery would gradually " drive their wages down to nothing." How unfounded this fear is a little in- vestigation of the above list of prices will show. It is there seen that a spinner spinning yarn of the fineness of eighty hanks to the lb. on a machine of the pro- ductive power represented by 336, is paid at the rate of A\d. for every eighty hanks (=1 lb.) that he turns off, while if he spins on one of the superior power of 396, he is paid only at the rate of Ad. for the same quantity. But the second machine turns off thirty-three pounds of yarn in the same time that the other is employed in turning off only twenty- eight lbs. The ratio of inferior production is there- fore as twenty-eight to thirty-three. But twenty-eight lbs. at A\d. the lb. give 126 pence (10s. 6d.) as the earnings made on the first machine during the time in which the operative is enabled to earn on the second 132 L* pencil Is.), Thus the operative gains 6d. 9 and the master by this more expensive machine Is. A\d. It appears that mules for coarse spinning carrying 500 spindles are already introduced with success, and that mules carrying 600 spindles are on the eve of being mounted. By this increase, the productive power of the machine will be augmented one-fifth. When this event happens, the spinner will not be paid at the same rate for work done as he was before ; but as that rate will not be diminished in the ratio of one- fifth, the improvement will augment his money earn- FACTORY OPERATIVES. 321 ings for any given number of hours' work. The whole benefit arising from the improvement is divided be- tween the master and the operative. Both the profits of the one, and the earnings of the other are simul- taneously increased by it. The foregoing statement requires a certain modi- fication. Though it is manifest that improvements in: machinery of the character just described augment the earnings of the operative, as well as the profits of the capitalist, yet those who dispute the former con- clusion will say that a particular case is selected to illustrate the position, and that an important element is omitted in stating it, that the spinner has to pay something for additional juvenile aid out of his addi- tional sixpence. This deduction deserves to be con- sidered and allowed for. The effect of improvements in machinery, not merely in superseding the necessity for the employment of the same quantity of adult labour as before, in order to produce a given result, but in substituting one description of human labour for another — the less skilled for the more skilled, juvenile for adult, female for male — causes a fresh dis- turbance in the rate of wages. It is said to lower the rate of earnings of adults by displacing a portion of them, and thus rendering their number superabundant as compared with the demand for their labour. It certainly augments the demand for the labour of children, and increases the rate of their wages. If any check were given to the cotton manufacture, nay, if its continual expansion shall not prove suffi- ciently great to re-absorb those adults whom it is con- tinually casting out, then the improvements in ma- chinery might be said to have a tendency to *' lower p3 322 RELATIVE COMFORTS OF wages but hitherto these improvements have ma- terially benefited the operatives, not only by enabling a greater number of persons to enjoy the advantage of the enormous rate of earnings attainable in this im- portant branch of human industry than would other- wise have been the case, but they have enabled " an operative" (speaking in general) to earn a greater sum of money at the end of the week than he would have earned had the condition of the machinery re- mained stationary. Could we suppose that machinery were suddenly to reach a degree of perfection which dispensed alto- gether with adult labour, while no greater number of adolescents and children than are at present employed would be required for turning off the quantity of work now executed, it is clear that the adults would be forced to compete with children in the labour-market, and that their earnings would be regulated by those of children. Fortunately for the state of society in the cotton districts of Great Britain, the improvements in ma- chinery are gradual, or at any rate brought very gradually into general use. Hence the fall in the price of the manufactured article is gradual, and the extension in the demand for it, arising from the de- crease of price, bringing it continually within the range of the means of greater numbers of consumers, is like- wise gradual, and keeps up the demand for adult labour, and thus counteracts the effect of the improvements of machinery which operate to displace it. Hence no diminution of earnings for adults has thus far arisen. In the year 1834, in two fine spinning-mills at FACTORY OPERATIVES* 323 Manchester, a spinner could produce sixteen pounds of yarn, of the fineness of two hundred hanks to the pound, from mules of the productive fertility of three hundred to three hundred and twenty-four spindles,, working them sixty-nine hours : and the quantity that he turned off in sixty-nine hours more frequently exceeded sixteen pounds than fell short of it. These very mules being in the same year replaced by others of double power, let us analyze the result. The spinner had been accustomed to produce sixteeen pounds of No. 200 yarn from mules of the said extent. From the list of prices^ it appears, that in the month of May, he was paid 3s. 6d. per pound ; which being multiplied by sixteen, gives 54s. for his gross receipts, out of which he had to pay (at the highest) 136*. for assistants. This leaves him 41s. of net earnings. But soon thereafter his mules have their productive power doubled, being re-mounted with six hundred and forty-eight spindles. He now is paid 2s. 5d. per pound, instead of 3s. 6d. — that is, two-thirds of his former wages per pound; but he turns off double weight of work in the same time, namely, thirty-two pounds, instead of sixteen. His gross receipts are therefore 2s. 5d. multiplied into thirty-two, or 77s. 4d. He now requires however five assistants to help him, to whom, averaging their cost at 5s. a-piece per week, he must pay 25s. j or, to avoid the possibility of cavil, say 27*?. Deducting this sum from his gross receipts, he will retain 50s. 4d. for his net earnings for sixty-nine hours' work, instead of 41 roved, and stretched, in an. appropriate manner, by machines differing in structure and adjustment for different qualities of goods. It must be spun into warp-yarn and weft-yarn, each of peculiar grist; and these yarns must be dressed and woven on a particular power-loom, adjusted both to the yarns and to the style of goods required. If any one member in this long train of operations proves defective, the profit in the product may be much impaired, or become altogether nugatory. The preceding processes are all mechanical, continuous, and mutually dependent. Were they partly mechanical, partly chemical, and also discon- tinuous, there would be a risk of confusion from the multiplicity of operations in one factory, and the work, as in the printing of calicoes, would in most cases be more profitably conducted by a separation of the mechanical and chemical arts into two distinct establishments. The power-loom factories now generally weave only their own yarn, spun to suit their peculiar FACTORY OPERATIVES. 331 fabric; and hence they generally command a better profit on their capital than establishments in which the same capital is expended in either the mere spin- ning of power-loom yarn,, or the weaving of what is purchased. The throstle, on which warp is usually spun, may be considered to be a complete automaton, capable, on good construction, of furnishing a very uniform yarn ; but the mule, on which weft is always spun, has been, till recently, only half automatic, and has partaken, therefore, in a certain degree, of the irregularities of hand-work, varying with the skill and steadiness of the workman. The improved self-actors of Messrs. Sharp, Roberts, and Smith, are likely to remove the above cause of irregularity in calico and fustian wefts, and therefore they place a weaving factory which works in train with them, in a condition to produce fabrics of invariable excellence. This new mechanical union of automatic spinning and weaving promises to have two admirable results. It will, in the first place, put an end, in this large department of factory labour, to the folly of trades', unions, so ruinous to the men, and so vexatious to the masters; and in the second place, it will secure, for a long period to come, the monopoly of coarse cotton fabrics to Great Britain. The continental nations must serve a severe and tedious apprenticeship under the fostering care of tranquillity and capital, before they can fabricate and manage a good system of throstles, self-actors, mules, and power-looms, like those now in vigorous exercise in Stockport. As to the United States, it may be presumed that the Southern part of the Union will prefer getting cheap goods from their great customer, 332 RELATIVE COMFORTS OP England, in exchange for their agricultural produce, to buying dearer goods from their illiberal brethren in the North-east. This combination of spinning and weaving in one establishment has lately given a fresh impulsion to our cotton trade, and is likely to render it para- mount over all competition; enabling it to furnish supplies of cheap clothing to many millions of new customers in every region of the globe. New factories will hence arise, requiring multitudes of new hands, presenting prizes in the lottery of life to the skilful and steady operatives, and enabling them to become managers or masters. On the other hand, non-factory processes of art which can be condensed into a single frame or machine moveable by hand, come within the reach of operatives in every adjacent country, and will have their profits ere long reduced to the minimum consistent with the employment of capital in it, and their wages brought down to the scale of those in the cheapest or meanest living country. The stocking trade affords a pain- ful illustration of this fact. No manufacturer in this country can afford to make stockings, unless he can get labour at as low a rate as in Germany ; because a German stockinger may easily have as good a stock- ing-frame, and work it as well, as an English frame- knitter. In the market of the world, therefore, Great Britain has here no advantage by its machinery and capital over other countries, where the materials of the fabrics can be purchased at nearly the same price. The same reasoning may be applied to the bobbin-net trade, in so far as it is carried on by hand-machines. The wages now paid for this most ingenious fabric FACTORY OPERATIVES. 333 are deplorably low, in consequence of the competition of the continental handicraftsmen, who are content to live in the poorest manner. Thus also the profit on lace made by power-machines has been reduced, for a time at least, even below its natural level, in conse- quence of the possessors of hand-machines continuing to work them, in the vain hope of redeeming their first great cost in some degree, though the wages of their labour meanwhile can hardly keep them alive. It deserves to be remarked, moreover, that hand- working is more or less discontinuous from the caprice of the operative, and never gives an average weekly or annual product at all comparable to that of a like machine equably driven by power. For this reason hand-weavers very seldom turn off in a week much more than one-half of what their loom could produce if kept continuously in action for twelve or fourteen hours a day, at the rate which the weaver in his work- ing paroxysms impels it. A gentleman in Manchester, one of the greatest warehousemen in the world, told me that 1800 weavers, whom he employed in the surrounding districts, seldom brought him in more than 2000 pieces per week, but he knew that they could fabricate 9000, if they bestowed steady labour on their looms. One young woman in his employment, not long ago, pro- duced by her own industry upon a hand-loom six pieces a week ; for each of which she received 65. 3d. This fact strongly confirms what Mr. Strutt told me concerning the discontinuous industry of handicraft people. Learning that the inhabitants of a village a few miles from Belper, occupied chiefly by stocking weavers^ was in a distressed state from the deprecia- 334 RELATIVE COMFORTS OF tion of their wages, he invited a number of the most necessitous families to participate in the better wages and steadier employment of their great spinning-mills. Accordingly they came with troops of children, and were delighted to get installed into such comfortable quarters. After a few weeks, however, their irregular habits of work began to break out, proving both to their own conviction, and that of their patrons, their unfitness for power-going punctuality. They then renounced all further endeavours at learning the new business, and returned to their listless independence. Let any curious observer pay occasional visits to the workshops of stocking or lace weavers, and he will seldom find the men to be steadily occupied with their labour, even during the hours fixed on by themselves. In hand- weaving, however, the depreciation of wages has been extraordinary. Annexed are the prices paid at different periods in Manchester for weaving a sixty reed •§- cambric, as taken in the month of March each year; the weaver paying threepence out of each shilling for winding his warp, for brushes, paste, &c. In 1795, 39s. 9d. In 1810, 15s. In 1830, 5s. 1800,25s. 1820, 8s. The following painful statements made to the Fac- tory Commissioners will show in how abject a condi- tion are our so-called independent handicraft labourers, compared with that of those much-lamented labourers who tend the power-driven machines of a factory. The former class needs all the sympathy which Mr. Sad- ler's faction so perniciously expended upon the latter. The present net weekly earnings of the cotton hands in the stocking trade are from 4s. to 7s. a week ; but those received by a far greater number are less than FACTORY OPERATIVES. 335 the lowest sum. The consequences are truly deplo- rable. The workmen are physically deteriorated, mentally depressed, and too often morally debased*. Ill-fed, ill-lodged, and ill-clothed, with care-worn and anxious countenances, they constitute a peculiar class of misery. It is supposed that the hosier's profits have decreased in at least an equal proportion with the decrease of wages. , A number of instances are adduced by Mr. Felkin as fair specimens of the situa- tion of the plain full-wrought cotton-hose workmen in March, 1833. They are taken indiscriminately from a very large population similarly employed; but all of them are sober and industrious persons. They fully justify the public appeal made at a meeting of frame-work knitters in September, 1832, "that their average earnings are not more than 6s. 6d. a week." On this sum, a man, his wife, and children, have to be maintained. Many among them are therefore ex- tremely wretched and destitute of the necessaries of life ; some have neither blanket nor sheet, and sleep in a little straw. The embroidery of bobbin-net, called lace-running, also a non-factory household work, pain- fully illustrates our position. No less than one hun- dred and fifty thousand females, chiefly of very youth- ful ages, get their livelihood from this employment in Great Britain. The work is wholly domestic ; and though requiring more skill and harder labour than any other branch of the lace business, it is the worst paid. 6( Almost the youngest of them," says Mr. Power (and they begin at the age of nine or ten), (C is able to speak with regret of a better state of earnings and a period of less necessity for constant labour. * Felkin: Factory Commission Report. 336 RELATIVE COMFORTS OF They begin early, and work late, and during this long daily period their bodies are constantly bent over the frame upon which the lace is extended, the head being usually kept within five or six inches of the frame, the edge of which presses against the lower part of the chest. One effect universally produced by this habit is short-sightedness, and often general weakness of the eyes ; with consumptive tendency, distortion of the limbs, and general debility from the confinement and the posture*." Aversion to the control and continuity of factory labour, and the pride of spurious gentility, or affecta- tion of lady-rank, are among the reasons why young women so frequently sacrifice their comfort and health to lace-embroidery at home. One girl in her exami- nation states, " I like it better than the factory, though we can t get so much. We have our liberty at home, and get our meals comfortable, such as they aref In thus exposing some of the evils incident to rustic and handicraft labour, while I desire to lead the bene- volent to devise means for their mitigation, I wish at the same time to remove that unjustifiable prejudice which hinders both of these classes from participating in the better paid and more comfortable factory em- ployments. There are many trades of great extent against which no public odium has been stirred up, which are, however, far more noxious to health and morals than a cotton-mill. Mr. Tufnell, after examin- ing several witnesses in regard to the condition of the boys and girls employed in the Worsley coal-mines, * Report by Mr. Power, on Nottingham, p. 17. f Factory Commission, Nottingham, p. 20. FACTORY OPERATIVES. 337 near Manchester, descended into them to verify the truth of the statements. "This mine," says he, If it were possible, says a great master of commer- cial economy, to make a calculation of the quantity of labour that is wasted — positively thrown away — in consequence of different provinces and countries striv- ing to produce commodities for which they have not the best facilities, the mind of men would turn with disgust from the protective system, so tenaciously clung to by the Spitalfield weavers, and so absurdly lauded by their parliamentary patrons *. The existence of a profitable foreign trade in any article is wholly incompatible with the existence of a protecting system for it. Protection implies the ne- cessity of a price beyond the average price in the market, of the world ; for were it otherwise, protection would neither be wanted nor could with decency be sought. With regard to France, eleven-fourteenths of her silk trade is for exportation, leaving only three- fourteenths for her home consumption, affording there- fore a considerable portion of reward to industry. On the protection system Great Britain must have confined her silk manufacture to her home consumption, and remained deprived of participation with France and Switzerland in the custom of the world at large. There can be no trade with foreigners in fact, but what involves some superiority in those who carry it on ; and unless a nation possesses some peculiar ad- vantage in reference to another nation, commercial * J. D. Hume,. Esq., Secretary to the Board of Trade. THE FACTORY SYSTEM. 457 interchange could not take place between them. Equa- lity would cause an equilibrium or stagnation as to export and import, that is, a destruction of all barter, so that each would be compelled to do every thing within itself, and to subsist on its own scanty range of productions. The peculiar faculties of a country can- not be duly developed under restraint of any kind, as is well shown by the French law, which prohibits the exportation of their first quality of silk. Were this law repealed, it would greatly encourage the silk growers, who enjoy uncommon facilities, and by lower- ing the price of the raw material, their silk manufac- ture would be encouraged. The same argument applies to the cotton and worsted manufactures of France. This branch of business is in great distress from the false direction given to industry by the government. Foreign manufactures may be fairly made to pay a moderate duty as the best way of providing revenue supplies to the state ; but not such a tax as the manu- facturer of the importing country can put into his pocket to reward his unprofitable industry. So applied, it becomes a legalized embezzlement of national re- sources for private and injurious ends : it is, in fact, the worst form of sinecure. Since the opening of the English ports to French silks, the looms at Lyons for weaving fancy goods have greatly increased in number ; while those for plain goods have considerably decreased, a line in which they possess no peculiar facilities over England. The best security against distress among the operatives of any country, is to apply their labour to the natural and most improved field of production. The relative situations and aptitudes of nations can be best judged vol. i. X 458 COMMERCIAL ECONOMY OF of by the emulation which exists between their opera- tives in the open, unprotected area of trade. The complicated problem of wages in two or more countries cannot be solved by the analysis of a single class of productions : there may be in it peculiarities which tend to reduce wages below the average standard, though, when applied to the whole industry of nations, there is always in the market a quantity of labour whose excess or deficiency regulates its price. In making goods for a foreign market, their price, and of course that of the labour involved in them, must fall, if the admission of the foreign articles to be returned in exchange be prohibited. Close up any channel to the export of English labour, by the prohibition of your neighbour's peculiar articles of barter, and you diminish the demand proportionally for British labour. Thus new restrictions would very soon (namely, the moment the equilibrium of trade can take place between countries) aggravate the evil and distress ; the inevitable result of prohibition. In most countries, but particularly in France and the United States, there is a great deal of misdirected labour, or a dis- turbed equilibrium of industry, which makes its level too low in one district, and too high in another. Nothing can give permanent relief on the great scale of the civilized world, but the entire suppression of the prohibitory system. A particular place possessing a monopoly may indeed gain by the prohibitory system for a time, but in the long run it would lose, and at any rate could never prosper but at the expense of the rest of the community. To repair as far as possible the ruinous condition of the French manufactures, resulting from the revoca- tion of the edict of Nantes, and at the same time to THE FACTORY SYSTEM. 459 flatter the pride of its profligate author Louis XIV., his celebrated minister Colbert established, two years after that event, an exclusive commercial system, and pushed with fresh spirit his favourite project of aggran- dizing the productive arts by royal patronage ; a policy pursued by his country ever since with extraordinary infatuation. Colbert's avowed purpose was to render France as much the mistress of the civilized world in manufacturing as he thought her to be in military glory ; and to render her independent of the inter- change of commodities with other kingdoms. On this occasion he extended the public grants of funds, honours, and immunities, to all adventurers who volunteered to advance his schemes ; and he thus forced many branches of industry into a precocious development, which w T as mistaken for sound growth, until the vicissitudes of trade caused them in succes- sion to wither and die. His was indeed the vainest of projects, for it aimed at nothing less than controlling and turning the wayward streams of industry, flowing from the wants, tastes, and caprices of millions of individuals, into a few artificial channels scooped out by the state. Conceiving that he was qualified to determine what was every man's interest better than he could himself, he framed a code of laws to regulate the processes of art in certain favourite manufactures. This presumptuous interference with private industry was not new. It had been attempted several years before, by the official publication of a book of instruc- tions on dyeing, remarkable alike for the minuteness and the absurdity of its details. Entertaining a prejudice against indigo, Colbert forbade the dyers of blue cloth to put more than a certain proportion of that drug in x2 460 COMMERCIAL ECONOMY OF their woad vats. He enacted that the dyers of black should begin their process in the grand tint, and finish it in the little tint ; permitting the dyers of the former style to have a certain number of ingredients in their possession, and those of the latter to have a smaller number; but allowing neither of ihem to have Brazil wood and some other specified articles in his dye-works. How small an amount of manufacturing prosperity the exclusive policy of Colbert has produced ; and how much agricultural, commercial/ and manufacturing wealth has been either destroyed or checked in its natural progress, is very apparent in the history of France during the century and a half which have elapsed since his time. The immense resources of the country, and active intelligence of its people, have been spell-bound by the evil genius of their grand monarque, without their being aware of their cataleptic condition. A competent judge has asserted that the whole of the bounties which have induced adventurers to enter into remote speculations, as well as the excessive duties imposed on foreign articles cheaper than their own pet productions, have been sacrifices of national wealth without almost any compensation. The French system is a vain attempt to force capital into new directions independently of the genius and capabilities of the people.* The high prices which are created by the protective system are wholly incompatible with an extended foreign trade ; for though they may be extorted by the influence of government from its dependents, for an inferior article, they cannot be obtained from foreign independent nations. A protective system necessarily * Dr. Bowring, M.P., in the Report on the Commercial Relations between Great Britain and France. THE FACTORY SYSTEM. 461 renounces the markets of the world for the home market, or if it seeks a foreign sale, it must bribe the purchaser by premiums, under the title of drawbacks on . exportation. The commerce of France, which amounted in 1787, with less than 25 millions of people, to 25 millions sterling, amounted in 1830, with 33 millions of people, to only 25J millions, not- withstanding the immense increase of population in the civilized parts of the world, and the extent of country opened by political events to commercial enterprize. The external commerce of England, in 1787, was, for 9 millions of people, only 18 millions sterling, being 7 millions less than that of France, at the same period; and in 1830 it amounted to nearly 70 millions sterling. The shipping of France is little greater at the second period than it was at the first, while that of England has been doubled with her quadrupled commerce. Comparative statements furnished by the French-Custom House to our commercial commis- sioners, Messrs. Villiers and Bowring, of the exports and imports between England and France, and France and the Netherlands, throw much light upon the man- ner in which the balance of trade is adjusted between the three countries. The official value of our imports from France in 1831, was . . . .£.3,055,616 That of the imports of France from this country was .. .. 897,179 From the above statements it will be seqn that the excess of French exports to Great Britain over her imports from it, is to a great extent paid in barter through the Netherlands. Indigo, an article exported to the value of from three to five millions of francs from the 462 COMMERCIAL ECONOMY OF Netherlands into France, is imported by the former country from England merely in transit, because being one of our colonial productions, it cannot be directly admitted by the French laws. Again, it is from the Netherlands chiefly that the clandestine introduction of British goods into France takes place to an amount far greater than is necessary to explain the apparent incongruity between the value of what France takes officially from us, and what we take from France. Thus a government suffers no less than its people from the prohibitory system. The difference of price between the foreign and the home made article might be made, very conveniently, a source of revenue, and so far diminish internal taxation ; instead of which it is given to the protected fabrics at the expense of the treasury, and causes an increasing quantity of articles to be withdrawn by contraband from the revenue. As goods are raised in price in compliance with the clamorous manufacturers, they draw a larger sum directly out of the consumers' pockets, and indirectly compel him to make up by a tax for the deficiencies thereby created in the customs. Nor does the evil stop here : for the interests which had been protected by government look to government for relief, when that pressure, which inevitably impends, comes upon them : thus the government first produces sickliness by pampering its offspring, and is then properly enough called upon to remedy the consequences. French prohibition presents an instructive history of the effects of violating the laws by which capital and labour should be governed : it is a vain struggle to attain what is unattainable ; and it rejects the natural advantages which are at the command of industry, in THE FACTORY SYSTEM. 463 pursuit of objects beyond its reach. The wines of France, for example, afford unbounded means of ex- change, but they have been sacrificed to iron and cotton goods ; articles produced at an extravagant cost, and when produced, of no value in foreign trade,, on account of the price of their production. The only article of French manufacture upon which foreign competition is allowed to act with tolerably fair play is silk : it is the least protected, and though not in so satisfactory a state as it might be, it has the best pro- spects ; though the silk trade, like every other, shares in the suffering caused by the prohibitory system, since one prohibition entails another. The foreign raw material is taxed for the benefit of the silk grower ; the manu- facturer complains of the evil, and he persuades an inconsistent legislation to prohibit the export of silk of native growth, so that each is content to be juggled in his turn, in the name of patriotism. The heavy taxes on foreign iron and foreign wood justify the French machinist in demanding and obtain- ing the exclusion of machines made abroad, and in requiring from manufacturers a monopoly price for those made by himself. But in shutting out the mechanisms of other countries, he has no choice of patterns to lay before his workmen, or for himself to improve upon. He has to begin the solution of many intricate, mechanical problems at the elementary prin- ciples, and proceeds, through a train of expensive constructions, to an equivocal conclusion, while he might at once have arrived at a certain one, by seeing the results of successful experiments already made in other countries. The French consume iron in agriculture and the 464 COMMERCIAL ECONOMY OF arts, to the amount of 160 thousand tons annually, and as they pay at least 10/. per ton more to their iron masters for it than they could get it from Eng- land, they thereby sacrifice a sum of one million six hundred thousand pounds sterling per annum to that part of their protective system ; or in 22 years of their present iron laws, they have wasted 30 millions sterling of the national wealth in direct sacrifice, and double that sum indirectly. And to what purpose ? Have their iron masters prospered, or have they improved their manufacture ? On the contrary, they require now a higher price for their iron, relative to the English price, than when they first obtained their monopoly, and the largest of their companies has become bank- rupt, while other adventurers have sustained ruinous losses.* In few of the protected articles of manufacture can France now sustain a competition with other coun- tries, nor can she hope for much improvement as long as she deprives her artisans of the discipline and know- ledge produced by that competition, which is no less valuable to the manufacturer than to the consumer. Meanwhile the fairest blossoms of her industry are devoured by the canker-worm of smuggling. It was estimated that 2,100,000 kilogrammes of goods were introduced clandestinely into France by bands of dogs, trained to the business, and called chiens frau- deurs. Tobacco, colonial produce, cotton-twist, and fabrics, are generally the objects of this illicit trade. The dogs carry from twenty to twenty-five pounds a-piece, amounting sometimes in value to from 20/. to 451. sterling. The temptation to smuggle some * Dr. Bo wring, M.P. ut supra. THE FACTORY SYSTEM. 465 articles is very great ; cotton yarn of the French num- ber, 180 for example, which may be had in England for eighteen francs a pound, fetches in France forty francs. Of late there has been a considerable contra- band, in our dyed woollen yarns, which brings as much as seventy per cent, of profit to the smuggler. It has been estimated by the French Custom-House that about one-twelfth of the contraband articles are seized ; calculating from which datum and the value of the seizures, it would appear that British manufac- tures, to the amount of 230,000/., are illicitly intro- duced by the Belgian frontiers alone. But as the goods realize a small part of their true value from the difficulties of exportation, and as one of the articles most extensively introduced, namely, cotton-twist, is protected from seizure after being deposited with the manufacturer, there is great reason to believe that the value of the contraband goods is ten times greater than the sum above stated, being probably somewhat more than tw T o millions sterling. Some data for estimating the amount of smuggling of English goods into France may be found in the facts known with regard to the smuggling of French goods into England. It appears that French silks, to the value of 350,000/., are fraudulently introduced into this country every year ; of which those seized amount to no more than 9000/., being only one thirty-ninth part, or about two and a half per cent., which repre- sents the risk run, independent of the cost of packing, freight, &c. The risk incurred in France on account of its triple cordon of custom-houses, may be safely estimated at five per cent, greater than in England ; hence, leaving out the article of cotton-twist, which is x3 466 COMMERCIAL ECONOMY OF excluded only under a certain fineness, the introduc- tion through the northern frontier of the Atlantic ports would be found to be enormous. A state of things so offensive to the national ho- nour, so ruinous to the finances, and so subversive of its morals, cannot but excite the strongest solicitude for a radical change in the system which first created and now fosters it. The prohibitions at present in force by the custom- house legislation of Great Britain are very inconsi- derable. The total amount of duties evaded by the clandestine import of French silks, brandies, &c. into this country does not exceed 800,000Z. per annum, exclusive of tobacco-cargoes occasionally smuggled from the French bonding warehouses into Ireland. The expenditure of the French treasury in premiums or bounties, and drawbacks to their manufacturers, has gone on of late years in a rapidly increasing ratio. In 1817, the whole amount so disbursed was only 3500Z. but in 1830 it had mounted to nearly 600,000Z. or one-fifth part of the whole Custom-House revenues of France ; and if the system be continued it may eventu- ally absorb all the resources of the state. In cotton-wool, where the French customs received in the year 1830 only 380,000 francs from the impor- tation, it expended in drawbacks and bounties 850,000 francs to the exporters. At this rate, had the whole cotton-wool imported been manufactured for export, it would have robbed the treasury of 8,000,000 of francs over and above the 6,000,000 paid to the Custom-House on its importation. NOTES. Note A. — p, 88. The influence of the air and other refractive media, on the appearances of minute bodies viewed through a microscope, may be very conveniently studied on particles of starch ; — those of arrow-root, for example. This, like all the varieties of fecula, consists of a transparent substance in- closed in a membranous bag of a spheroidal shape, which protects it from the solvent action of water, but which bursts by exposure to an elevated temperature, and allows the matter to show its soluble gummy nature. When a little arrow-root is dusted upon a slip of glass, and placed in the focus of a good achromatic microscope, it appears to consist of a congeries of black elliptic rings of considerable breadths, with very luminous centres (see a, Fig. 58). 00 468 NOTES. If the dust be now moistened with water, the particles will assume somewhat of their proper form of clear spheroidal lenses (or rather irregular ovoids), with darkish edges (see b) ; if it be imbued with oil of turpentine instead of water, they will be seen under the same form, but with clearer and sharper outlines, though altogether dimmer under the same light, and with black dots towards their centres (see c). In this case, the more refractive medium surrounding the particles lessens the deviation of light at their edges, and at the same time acts round them like a concave lens, so as to disperse outwardly the light which would be otherwise concentrated into their substance. If the particles be viewed after a little, when the oil has eva- porated and left a solid film, they will appear like shadowy pearls (see d). In Canada balsam, thinned with oil of turpentine, they will no longer appear as spheroidal lenses brightest in the middle, but as filmy scales with a very black dot in the centre of their convexity (see e). After a few minutes, when the balsam gets inspissated by the eva- poration of the volatile oil, the particles look as if they were concave or dished out in the middle part, with thick- ened up-turned borders, and more strongly marked with the black dots. When the balsam eventually becomes a concrete resin, they lose all distinctness of outline, most of them totally disappear, and the rest are recognizable only by gleaming spots of pearly white (see f). These interesting metamorphoses were sketched for the wood-cut in the progress of their development by Mr. Sly, an artist familiar with the details of natural history, and skilful in representing them. I had the pleasure lately of showing these phenomena to the distinguished entomologist W. Spence, Esq.,F.R.S., and several other gentlemen who can bear witness to the fidelity of my observations. They lead to the conclusion, that in order to view any spheroidal or cylindrical object with advantage in the microscope, we should plunge it in NOTES. 469 a medium of a refractive power a little, and but a little, different from its own. When the difference in this re- spect is very great, as between air and wool, for example, the interior structure of the fibres is not distinguishable, while the warty excrescences so common on certain coarse fleeces are well seen; but when that difference is very small, as between balsam and wool, the imbricated texture of the fibres is clearly developed, while the warts disappear ; because being spongy they assimilate in optical quality with the varnish. Cotton filaments, however, are of such a form and constitution as to cause little deviation in the rays of light transmitted through them, and they may therefore be viewed with more propriety in air or water than in balsam ; for this affects their edges, as it does those of starchy particles. Thin scales or parallel sections of any kind cause no deviation in the light falling per- pendicularly on their surfaces, and are therefore, as far as their outline is concerned, correctly seen in air. The following liquids furnish a good gradation of refractive densities : — Index of Refraction. Water . . .1*336 Albumen (white of egg) . 1 • 360 Solution of common salt . 1 '375 sal ammoniac . 1 * 382 Oil of lavender . . 1*467 turpentine . . 1*476 Canada balsam . 1 * 528 Oil of cloves . . . 1 * 535 Carburet of sulphur . 1 * 680 Mixtures of oil of turpentine and Canada balsam furnish media of refractive powers, intermediate between 1*476 and 1*528. 410 NOTES. Note B.— p. 125. For the following interesting observations I am indebted to William Ogilby, Esq., Member of the Zoological Society of London, &c, &c, &c. : — Great as are the changes which domestication has pro- duced in the form and habits of the sheep, and innumerable as are the varieties resulting from the operation of this principle, there is perhaps none of our domestic animals whose original stock has been ascertained with greater precision, or is subject to less difference of opinion. Indeed we are acquainted with only two wild species of the sheep genus, from which this useful animal could possibly derive its origin : one the Argali (Ovis Ammon), which inhabits the loftiest mountain chains of Asia and North America ; andlthe other, the Moufflon (Ovis Aries), called Musmon and Ophion by Pliny, which still abounds on the moun- tains of Asia Minor, Greece, Barbary, Corsica, and Sar- dinia, and which in the time of the Roman Republic appears to have been not less common in Spain and Por- tugal. It has been agreed on all hands, as well by ancient as by modern authors, that the latter species furnished the original stock of our domestic sheep ; and the opinion is confirmed, not only by the perfect similarity which exists in the external and internal structure of the two animals, but by the facility with which they breed together, and even by localities inhabited by the Moufflon, surrounding as they do the very cradle of human civilization. The ancients, indeed, as Columella informs us, occasionally endeavoured to improve the domestic breed by crossing it with the wild animal, and in modern times some of our English breeds have been crossed in the same manner, by means of a wild ram introduced into this country by the celebrated General Paoli. The wool of the Moufflon is very short and coarse ; the fleece, in fact, resembles that of the domestic sheep of tropical countries, being more NOTES. similar to hair than wool, but it improves rapidly by a little care and attention. In a state of nature, the wild sheep inhabits only the loftiest summits of the mountain ranges, living in flocks more or less numerous, and de- scending to the lower hills and valleys only when forced by the severity of the season. It is a bold, active, and in- telligent animal, and exhibits nothing of the helpless or stupid character often ascribed to its domestic represen- tative ; but those who have seen the half-wild flocks of Wales and other mountainous countries are well aware that their apparent stupidity and dependence are the result of circumstances, and form no part of the animal's original character. Note C— p. 253. There are some records so tortuous as to put a tolerably clear intellect at fault. The evidence published by the Committee of 1832 upon the silk trade, though replete with valuable information, is of that mazy kind, and will create a vertigo in the brains of most readers ; for autho- rities of apparently equal force are there exhibited acting upon the contested point at every angle of inclination or obliquity, and presenting to the political economist a pro- blem, not unlike the famous dynamical one of the three bodies. I fear much that some parts of my chapter upon silk, notwithstanding much pains bestowed upon equilibra- tion, will betray symptoms of the vortices out of which they have been extricated. The account given in that parliamentary report of the method used at Lyons for estimating the fineness of silk, is as curious a mystification of a plain matter as a commenta- tor could desire, and however unchallenged it might pass among the members at the time, it is calculated to ' puzzle posterity.' We read there, c The weight is taken in grammes, 24 of which constitute 1 denier; 24 deniers 472 NOTES. make 1 ounce; and 15 ounces 1 pound, poids de marc, which is the Lyons mode of selling silk. The weight of one thread of 400 ells is about 2\ grammes, when five threads are reeled together.' Now, since 1 gramme weighs 18*82715 Paris grains*, 2 f weigh 42*3 grains, which represent by the above document the weight of 400 ells of such silk thread, being nearly twenty times greater than the reality. And 18 * 8275 grains ( = 1 gramme) X 24 x 24 X 15 = 162,666*576 grains, represent by the same document 1 pound, poids de marc, being from seventeen to eighteen times more than the real number, 9216 grainsf. My experimental inquiry into the weight of the denier, by which the value of silk per 400 ells (French) is esti- mated, has led to a very simple unravelling of this arith- metical skein. An ounce poids de marc of Lyons, and an ounce troy, are identical weights ; but the former is divided into 576 parts r= 24 drams X 24 deniers = 576 deniers ; and the latter into 480 parts = 24 pennyweights X 20 grains = 480 grains. Hence the Lyons denier is to the English grain as 1 to : or as 0 ■ 8333 to T 0000, B 5 576 480' that is, 100 deniers are equivalent to 83 3 grains of our apothecaries and goldsmiths. Sixteen (not fifteen) Lyons ounces make one pound, poids de marc; 16 x 576 = 9216 French deniers, or grains. Note D.— p. 375. How any grave son of Esculapius could so masquerade his learning on the public stage of a parliamentary com- mittee, as to make a comparison between young persons working in a mill by night, and tadpoles shut up in a dusky pool, is beyond my comprehension. Did he not * Traite de Physique, par M. Biot, tome i. Supplement ; Tables Usuelles. -j- Ibidem. NOTES. 473 know that vast multitudes of children are employed in mines, where day-light never penetrates, and that they grow up into as healthy and intelligent a race of men as may be found ? The miners of Cornwall, Northumberland, Cumberland, and Leadhills, are not the abortive frogs which lack of sunshine should produce, according to this physiological sage. Excess of light is, I believe, less favourable to the due development of the human faculties, than its defect ; a circumstance verified in the experience of the crews of whalers, who lose their vigour of mind and body under the long summer days of the Arctic Circle. Had Mr. Sadler got up his medical witnesses to prove that the factory evils were a matter of moonshine , he would ave been pretty near the mark. APPENDIX. The relative numbers of the two sexes engaged in the dif- ferent manufactures form a curious subject of comparison. The following are some of these proportions: — Male. Female. Cotton factories in Lancashire and Cheshire - - - - 100 103 Cotton factories in Scotland - - 100 209 Flax factories of Leeds - - 100 147 Flax factories of Dundee and East Coast of Scotland - - - 100 280 It deserves to be considered how different the proportion of Scotland is from that of England; and how well that dif- ference confirms Sir David Barry's report on the superior 474 APPENDIX. physical condition, hardihood, and strength of the Scottish women over the English. The silk factories throughout the kingdom make little or no demand on muscular effort, and therefore employ a very small proportion of males. The wool factories, however, call frequently for exertion of bodily strength, and therefore employ a greater number of males than females. Here again the superiority of the Scottish women seems to be manifested, for a much greater proportion of them are em- ployed in the woollen manufactories of Scotland than there are of Englishwomen in those of England. Worsteds, how- ever, constitute the chief part of the woollen trade of Scot- land, and they may, to a great extent, be worked by women, whereas the clothing trade requires the labour of men. Relative to age, fully two -sixths of the English cotton- mill operatives, and more than three-sixths of the Scottish, are under twenty-one. In the cotton factories of Lancashire, the wages of the males during the period when there is the greatest number employed, — from eleven to sixteen are on the average 4s. lOf d. a-week; but in the next period of five years, from sixteen to twenty-one, the average rises to 10s. % 2\d. a- week; and of course the manufacturer will have as few at that price as he can, and certainly not for any description of work which may be done by persons working at 4s. lOfcZ. In the next period of five years, from twenty-one to twenty- six, the average weekly wages are 17s. 2^d. Here is a still stronger motive to discontinue employing males as far as it can practically be done. In the subsequent two periods the average rises still higher, to 20s. 4Jd, and to 22s. S^d. At such wages, only those men will be employed who are neces- sary to do work requiring great bodily strength, or great skill, in some art, craft, or mystery in which they are engaged, or persons employed in offices of trust and con- fidence. Again, as to the females there is no diminution of numbers between the period from eleven to sixteen, and the APPENDIX. period from sixteen to twenty-one ; and for this obvious reason the wages do not rise in the case of females to more than an average of 7s. 3^d. in throstle spinning ; and never much exceed this amount except in power weaving, where they may earn double the sum. The greater number of females is in the period of from sixteen to twenty-one ; but there is a prodigious diminution immediately after ; and none can be at a loss to tell the cause — it is the period when they marry. It is known by the returns, and the factory com- mission inquiries, that very few women work in the factories after marriage. It appears that the greatest number of the marriages of factory women take place before they reach their twenty-sixth year. They disappear about that time in the returns of the cotton mills ; but an inspection of the tables will show, that if we are to search in the registers for the names of these females, it must be in the marriage registers, and not in the registers of the dead*. Wages. The small amount of the wages of the very young children employed in factories deserves notice, but should constitute a subject of satisfaction rather than of regret, because there will be less loss to the parents in withdrawing the youngest from the factories, and sending them to school. Factory females have also in general much lower wages than males, and they have been pitied on this account, with perhaps an injudicious sympathy, since the low price of their labour here tends to make household duties their most profitable as well as agreeable occupation, and prevents them from being tempted by the mill to abandon the care of their offspring at home. Thus Providence effects its purposes with a wisdom and efficacy which should repress the short- sighted presumption of human devices. The different rates of wages paid for the same work in the different districts of the United Kingdom is a subject deserving of the most serious consideration. * Dr. Mitchell's Statistical Report, Supplement to Factory Com- mission Report, p. 38. o C/5 o « »^ . o rtXCO Ph^ S- 1 " 00 Ci CO «* tO 00 00 CO l>» 00 Ci tO tO 00 oo to -2 00 ^3 Tf O 1 1 1 J co ' 1 2 ?t 3 S CO CO 00 CO «0 lO r-H r-H CO H CO O O CO r-i CM CO IP *C «*» Htf Hi-* He "-oo i-h o m i— i eo CO O CM t>. O He O i-h to to to t& CO -2 to CO 00 (M CM O £ © CO CM r-t CM <— 1 P- 1— ! 1— I •oi* He He m o co co 1 CO tO CO to CO r-H O -2 CO He He ^ r- O CO CM H r-< CO «0 CM CM He He co o co to to tQ tO MS S3 WOOL.— Wages of Females. >4 mi* He He rW 53 o o cm (0 H 1— 1 T+* tii CM 1— 1 r-l 1— 1 r-H H-h. «5H- He »ra r-H oo i— Tt* l>» tO T}< ^ -Sin •w H"<* oW WW 53 O CM O O r-. &5 cm co oo m CM r-H r— r-H i-H mi* He h* r-H tO r-, Ci CO O CO tO tO 5 -2 § *»J He He ^ © 00 O 00 Ci 69 CM CO CO |2J 00 H* He O t>» O © is in n (d o co -2 •J H"^ H"* ^ * CO "ST Ci t>. O *j cm 21 2 ^ 2 •o,* He O Ci CM tO to to to to 1— I Q CO CO CO rH|(M H|W Ml* *8 co CO O tO CO e<5 CM O iO IP «|* eel* He CM 00 r-H ~ *>. »o oo to «o -2 CO *4 H-* «i* He He ^ iO r— 1 CO O O ^ CM CM CO CO CM H — ' — — i He col*; He TT CO tO r- < tO tv» iO t> tO tO i— i o IP CM -t- CM • *»!* r-'Ct "5fT Ml* "So O O CO to 65 Ci — « r-H "Tj* H^ H'* o to to © tO to to tO r°< -2 CM ■» Ht* mi* He 55 ci o ci 89 OS CO b>» «0 t>» He He He* He tO tO r-i Ci r-H CO Tl* tO iO ^ h*> h^* He mi* ^ — . O O r-H ^ ^ CO CO CM toi* H-* mm H'* CO © Ci Tf" CM CM CM CO -> H^ He He o % r-H O O0 r- Ci CO * CM r- CM r-H CM tO © CO TT 1 CM r-H CM CM CO | Districts. Leeds, &c. Gloucester Somerset Wilts Aberdeen Leeds Gloucester Somerset Wilts Aberdeen APPENDIX. The wool being the old staple manufacture, and that most extensively distributed in the kingdom, affords the best means of comparing rates of wages. Amount expended in support of the Poor per head for every one of the Population in the Counties of Lancaster, York (West Riding), Derby, Stafford, Leicester, Nottingham, Norfolk, Suffolk, Essex, Gloucester, Somerset, and Wilts ; being the Counties in which the Factories are situated from which Returns have been obtained, in the Years 1801, 1811, 1821, and 1831. Counties. 1801. 1811. 1821. 1831. £. d. £. s. d. £. d. £. s. d. Lancaster - - - 0 4 4 0 7 4 0* 4 8 0 4 4 York( West Riding) 0 6 7 0 10 0 0 6 9 0 5 7 Derby - - - - 0 6 9 0 10 1 0 8 0 6 7 Stafford - - - 0 6 1 0 8 5 0 7 10 0 6 5 Leicester - - - 0 12 3 0 14 8 0 14 2 0 11 6 Nottingham - - 0 6 3 0 10 9 0 7 10 0 6 5 Norfolk - - - 0 12 5 0 19 11 0 14 10 0 15 4 Suffolk - - - 0 11 4 0 19 3 0 17 9 0 18 3 Essex - - - - 0 12 1 1 4 8 0 17 7 0 17 2 Gloucester - - 0 8 8 0 11 7 c 9 1 0 8 8 Somerset - - - 0 8 10 0 12 2 0 8 7 0 8 9 Wilts - - - - 0 13 10 1 4 2 0 14 8 0 16 6 In regard to Aberdeen and the east coast of Scotland, a compulsory poor's rate is unknown ; and at Paisley and the south-west of Scotland the amount raised by a rate for the 418 APPENDIX. relief of the poor is very much lower than it is in any part of England. In respect of the wool manufacture, it will he seen that in the West Riding of Yorkshire, where the poor's rate is lower than in any of the other districts of England where wool is manufactured, the wages are the highest ; and that in Somersetshire, where the poor's rate is higher than in the West Riding of York, the wages are lower ; but they are there much higher than in the neighbouring county of Wiltshire, where the poor's rate is extremely high. The wages of Wiltshire, when contrasted with the wages of Aberdeen, where there is no compulsory relief, are in pecu- niary amount lower ; and when we take into account the great difference in the command of the necessaries of life which these wages afford in so cheap a country as the North of Scotland, we see that the condition of the Aber- deen operative is indeed much superior. A similar result is observable in the silk manufacture, for at Derby, where the poor's rate is comparatively low, the wages are the highest ; in Somersetshire, where the poor's rate is higher than in Derby, the wages are lower ; and in Norfolk, Suffolk, and Essex, where the poor's rate is ex- tremely high, the wages are far lower than in Somerset, and are indeed so low, that, but for such unquestionable evidence as these returns afford, we could scarcely have believed it possible. The contrast with Paisley, in Scot- land, where the poor's rate, as compared with any part of England, is exceedingly small, will lead to the same opinion. 479 FACTORY EDUCATION TABLE. "FNfiT AND Numbers taken from the Returns. 1 Proportion in the hundred. Read. Cannot read. Write. Cannot write. c3 m Cannot read. Write. Cannot write. Lancashire - — 11 ,393 2,344 5 ,184 8 ,553 I 83 17 38 62 Cheshire 3 O 0U9 jVJi 344 ] fi^o i j ,806' 90 A U zI7 £Q DO Yorkshire - - - - 9 087 1,616 0 ,509 | 85 1 ^ ID J8 *;9 Dl Derbyshire - - - 2 , 'IJU 314 200 I ,604 11 1 9 1 4 It) 0/ Staffordshire - - q o , 0-3 (J 71 & o _ fin 3 , DUG 1 1 ,645 83 1 7 J / fi 1 O 1 ov Leicestershire — ^ l 92 1 7 A 269 80 90 40 fiO Nottinghamshire 948 127 455 616 88 12 43 o/ Norfolk, Suffolk, 1 1 ,914 433 608 1 73Q O 1 19 26 74 Essex - - - - J Wiltshire 3 OA ^ 527 } 364 o L ,208 85 i ^ 1 o oo fi9 0,6 Somersetshire - - o L 99Q DJ 1 1 ,678 89 9fi 7/1 / 4 Devonshire 755 34 401 386 96 4 51 49 Gloucestershire - 4 ,556 379 1 ,983 2 , JDL Q9 8 40 60 Worcestershire - 21 16 5 100 77 23 Warwickshire - - 105 15 81 39 88 12 68 32 Total - - 43 ,327 7,170 21 ,488 29 ,009 86 14 43 57 SCOTLAND. Aberdeenshire - 4 ,336 305 2 ,133 2 508 93 7 46 54 Forfarshire - - - 4 879 237 2 ,425 2 691] 95 5 47 53 Perthshire 1 601 96 1 ,054 643, 94 6 62 38 Fife shire - - - - 1 558 38 862 734 97 3 57 43 Clackmannanshire 213 6 754 65 97 3 70 30 Stirlingshire — 795 23 547 27lj 97 3 66 34 Lanarkshire - - 7 815 317 4 454 3 678, 96 4 54 46 Renfrewshire — 5 664 199 3 ,165 2 698* 97 3 54 46 Ayrshire - - - - 867 2 594 275' 100 68 32 Bute 430 4 310 124 99 1 71 39 Mid Lothian - - 98 3 96 5 97 3 95 5 Total - - 28 256 1,230 15 794 13 692 96 4 53 47 480 appendix. In Scotland, in which, ever since the Reformation, edu- cation has been a subject of national interest, and where, for a long period, there has been a school establishment co- extensive with the church establishment, there is a greater proportion able to read and write. There is, however, still much room for improvement in that part of the kingdom. The returns from factories in rural districts are quite as favourable as those from the towns, which is attributable to the parochial schools. Printed by W. Clowes and Sons, Stamford Street. Date Due — - •