George Washington Flowers Memorial Collection DUKE UNIVERSITY LIBRARY ESTABLISHED BY THE FAMILY OF COLONEL FLOWERS Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2014 https://archive.org/details/essayonnaturalhiOOnott AN ESSAY ON THE NATURAl HISTORY OF MAlll, VIEWED IN CONNECTION WITH NEGEO SLAYERY: DELIVERED BEFORE THE SOUTHERN RIGHTS ASSOCIATION, 14TH DECEMBER, 1850. BY JOSIAH C. NOTT, M. D. DADZ, THOMPSO.V & CO. PRIKTKRS. 185L AN ESSAY. When we reflect on the remarkable advance made in other departments of science, and the many curious histori- cal discoveries brought to light by antiquarian researches, even in the last ten years, it is not to be wondered at, that the Natural History of Man — one of the most interesting and important of all subjects — should at last take up the line of march, and assume its proper rank. Heretofore it has been confined very much to theologians and naturalists, and kept from the vulgar gaze, for the very obvious reason that it was supposed to involve questions of no less magni- tude than the authenticity of the Bible, and the stability of the Christian Religion. A more wholesome spirit of inves- tigation now, however, is beginning to prevail. The more enhghtened feel assured that there can be no discrepancies between the Scriptures, properly interpreted, and the well- established truths of science ; that the words and works of the Almighty cannot contradict each other, and that any ap- parent discordance must arise solely from false interpreta- tions. However unsettled and wavering opinions may have been respecting many points in the Natural History of Man, the curious facts which experience has been forcing upon ns year after year, in this country particularly, as to the deep- rooted intellectual and physical differences seen around us, in the White, Red, and Black Races, are too obvious and too important in their bearings, to be longer overlooked ; and are now forcing themselves upon the attention of states- men, and making their way into legislative halls. These investigations are assuming a peculiar interest in our coun- try, from their connection with certain absorbing political questions now deeply agitating the American people, and shaking the very existence of our Government to its founda- tions; and knowing that I have been engaged in the study 4 of the Natural History of Mankind, I have been requested to prepare and lay before yon in a condensed form, an abstract of those facts and deductions, which have a practical bearing on the great issues now pending between the North and South. I have complied with this request, because I do not think that any man, who is called upon in a time like this, when the Republic is in danger, has a right to withhold any infor- mation which might contribute in the remotest degree to- wards enlightening the public mind. "I have the more readi- ly consented, because 1 have long been convinced, that the views I have been promulgating for the last ten years, con- tained the only appeal, which could be made Avith any possi- ble chance of success, to our Northern brethren. They have been told again and again, that the Constitution guar- anteed to the South her slaves ; that this institution could not be eradicated without bringing desolation upon the South, and ruin to the North ; that the negroes themselves were happier here than tliey could be under any other circumstan- ces ; that all experiments to improve the condition of this race by emancipation, had failed ; that we did not ask to in- terfere with the rights, or institutions, of the North, but only asked to be allowed to manage our own affairs, in our own way : but to these, and kindred arguments, our Northern brethren have turned a deaf ear, and have continued to heap injury and insult upon us. They have treated Slavery as an abstract question — as a thing above all Law and Consti- tution — to be decided upon broad principles of justice ac- cording to the dictates of that highei* law, conscience. I, therefore, as a last appeal, attempted to satisfy them, that they were guided by a mistaken and false philanthropy; that the same God who had permitted Slavery to exist by His Word, had stamped the Negro Race with permanent in- ferioriiy, and that all attempts to elevate it above its" proper ^ grade, must eventuate in failure. But ignorance and fanati- >^ 'i eism will not hearken to reason. The signs of the times eannot be mistaken. There is a great convulsion before us, the end of which God alone can see, and it is time that we should arouse from our lethargy, and prepare for the crisis. Let us take counsel together, without passion and without prejudice, and determine what we shall do to be saved. The lessons of Jamaica and Hayti are before us. 5 In all I have written horctofuic about the Races, I have attempted as iniicli as possible to confine myself to the sci- entific view of the subject, hoping that the facts once made out would i^radually find their practical application through others ; but the crisis is hastening with a rapidity that no one could have dreamed of at the opening of the Mexican war, and I now proj)ose to pass over the intricacies of sci- ence — all the difficulties of antiquarian research — and to lay before you a few results of investigation, which are very gen- erally admitted amongst men of science, and which are am- ply sufficient for our present purpose. For obvious reasons, I would gladly have avoided colli- , sions with sects whose religious opinions are entitled to re- spect, but the very nature of the subject forbid it ; for when I took what I believe to be the only true and tenable ground, that the White, Red and Black Races are not descended from one pair, I came at once in contact with the very ground-work of their faith. Nothing had occurred for cen- turies to throw doubt, in the minds of Christians, over what seemed to be the teachings of Holy Writ, touching the ^inity of the human family, and it never occurred to them that any other construction could be put upon its language. W^ithout stopping to inquire what new lights recent scientific re- searches had developed, or what was the character of these investigators, bulls were at once thundered against me : I ' was called an mfidel — an enemy to religion, morality, law, &c. All this disturbed my equanimity but little, for I felt that I was right ; that the facts developing were of incalcu- lable importance in determining the future destiny of Races, and I was convinced that truths so clear, if held up boldly to the public eye, must, after a time, be received — and I was willing to abide my time with patience."* I now have the satisfaction of seeing that the doctrine of Diversity of Races is taking hold upon the public mind even faster than I had hoped. Apart from the clergy, the naturalists every where are endorsing the opinions for which I am contending. Prof, Agassiz, the greatest naturalist living, is now delivering a course of public lectures in Boston in support of Diversity of Races. I)rs. Morton and Pickering, the leading writers on this subject in America, are openly taking the same side, to say nothing of a large number of others not so well known to fame. The Christian Examiner, a very able periodical 6 in Boston, has been publishing some of the leading papers of M. Agassiz. The Democratic and Whig Reviews, publish- ed in New York ; the Southern Quarterly, in Charleston ; the Commercial Review, in New Orleans, and a host of other pe- riodicals and journals, are publishing articles freely on this . side. ]\Iany learned divines, in this country, and in Europe, regard this as an open question ; and all who have paid any attention to the subject admit, at least, that the White and Black Races were as distinct 3000 years ago as they now are : and I hazard the assertion, that no subject of equal magnitude, and which had such a load of prejudice to carry, ever made such rapid progress as this has in the last five years. The Bible was clearly intended, not as a book of science, but to teach mankind their duties towards each other, and towards their Maker ; and the inspiration which guided the human beings who wrote it, though full, for all purposes in- tended, stopped very far short of Omniscience, It certainly will not be questioned that these writers gave no evidence whatever, of any scientific or geographical knowledge be- yond that of their profane cotemporaries. They regarded the earth as an extended plain, and spoke of its " sides and ends ;" they knew nothing of its extent beyond that border- ing on the Mediterranean Sea; they knew nothing of South- ern Africa, Northern and Eastern Asia, the greater part of Europe, the whole of America, Australia, * the next i>oint of inquiry is, whether there are any known climatic, or other physical agencies, that can transform one type into another, as the White man into the Negro, Mon- gol, or Indian ? This idea, though very generally received at one time, is now abandoned by all modern naturalists, from Pritchard down to the Rev. Dr. Bachman. A new hypothesis sprung up from the ruins of the old one, equally untenable, but which is still held on to by a few who are determined not to yield to any proof. This party tell us that when the Almighty created man, he planted in him a certain organic law which predisposed him, under certain unknown infiuences, to change type, and run into what has been termed congenital or accidental varieties, which may continue to propagate and be perpetuated. An example will illustrate this more clearly to you : It is assumed, that our continent was peopled from the old world by White, Mongol, or other Races ; and it is again assumed^ that in obedience to this hidden law, at some subsequent period, these congenital or accidental varieties began to spring up ; little genuine Indians were born from the White, or Mongol parents ; and in the course of time, multiplied, overspread the whole continent, and rooted out entirely the original type. Although all this is bare assumption, without an example in history to prove it, and a strong chain of facts to refute it, yet this is (apart from the Bible) the sole ground on which the Unity of the Races reposes. All the recent advocates of Unity of Races, of any authority, from Prichard to Bach- man, agree substantially on this j^oint. Dr. Bachman, who ^ is better posted up in the natural history part of this contro- versy than his confreres, tells us that these ^^per?nanent varie- ties^^ occurred soon after the creation, and long before the dawn of history. He does not pretend that any of the new types, as the Negro, Mongol, Malay, Indians, Australians, &c., (supposing the Caucasian to be the original type) have f prung up within the last three or four thousand years. He knows enough about history, and the monuments of Egypt to krop him out of such l>lurid(M > us lliose. 11 • While it IS conceded, even by liii advucute- ui llnity of Races, that Iiistory affords no example of tlie transformation of one type of men into another, they arc compelled to con- cede on the other hand that we have numerous well-authen- ticated examples, of permanence of type under the most ojh- fosite climatic influences. Kaccs have removed from their original abodes to distant lands where they have been sub- jected to the most opposite climates, modes of life, diet, &,c., and yet have remained nnciianged in type for hundreds of years. We all know that climate produces very decided ef- fects on men and animals, but there is a limit to its influence. * We see the fair-skinned Germans, Englishmen, &:c., tanned and emaciated by Southern climates, but their children for generations continue to be born fair, and they never approxi- mate the type of Indians or other dark Races. Nor can the iiorse be changed into the ass or zebra. The Jews, whose blood has been kept purer than any other Race — who have consequently preserved better their origin- al type — v/ho are more widely scattered, and whose iiistory is best known, aftbrd the most striking illustration of the truth of my assertion. It shoukl be borne in mind, however, that this race has not escaped adulteration, and that every individual professing the Jewish religion and following their customs, is not necessarily of pure blood, and we thus have a satisfactory explanation for the varieties of faces seen amongst them ; but wherever a well-marked Jewish face is presented to us, we never for a moment think of doubting that it has been handed dovv^n in a direct line from father Abraham, who lived about three thousand five hundred years ago, and we never see the Jewish lineaments, except where we have every reason to believe tlrere is Jeicish blood. Has it ever occured to any man to call in question these facts .'^ This people have been scattering and wandering over the habitable globe since the ca])tivity of the Ten Tribes, now more than twenty-five hundred years, and yet, though fairer in the North and darker in the South than in their native land, are every where unmistakable Israelites. We see them distinctly portrayed on Egyptian monuments three thousand years ago, with the identical features they now pre- sent, through more than one hundred generations, and which they doubtless received from their venerable progenitor. The juost remarkable well-authenticated exainple of perma- 12 neiice of type on record, perhaps, is that of the White Jews of Malabar, in India, who have been Uving among the dark- skinned, small-headed Hindoos for at least fifteen hundred years, without approximating in the slightest degree the type of the native Race. This fact is now beyond controversy. Another striking example may be found in that peculiar and mysterious race, the Gypsies : they have been scattered for at least four hundred and fifty years, (nearly twenty gen- erations) through all climates, and amongst all nations ; ex- posed to want, misery and suflering, in every shape ; subject- ed, in the highest degree, to all those physical causes which are said to change Races : yet, like the Jews, retaining their pecuhar type, habits, customs, and even peculiar language. Unlike the Jews, they have never taken part in the march of civilization, but have every where kept themselves isolated, and their blood almost pure. Like the Hindoos, (of which they are a tribe) they have much smaller heads than the He- brews, and other White Races, and their lives and charac- ters have been the result of an inferior organization, which they received from the Almighty. Intellectual activity and progression belong to the very nature of the Jewish Race; intellectual quietude and dislike belong to the Hindoo Races. The noble Magyars, who played such an important part in the recent Hungarian struggle, might be cited as another example of preservation of type. They belong to the great Tartar subdivision of the Caucasian family, and detached themselves about the year 880, A. D. (one thousand years ago) from their Asiatic connections, advjxncing into Europe under their cliief, Arphad. There are now in Hungary three millions, five hundred thousand, of this race; and we here see them still preserving their original type in one of the finest portions of Europe, where the fairest ski«s of Teuton- ic type flourish in perfection. But it does not enter into our present design to enumerate a tithe of the examples of permanence of type, with which history abounds. The point is conceded, and these are quite sufficient. You have ample evidence around you at home. The Red men of America, who Iiave had this continent to themselves for hundreds, and probably thousands, of years, preserve (with a few exceptions, which can be accounted for by immigrations, &c.) substantially one complexion, and one type, from the Arctic to Cape Horn. No influence of cli- 13 mate on tlicm is any whcie obscvvabie. And who, during* the eight or ten generations that the Whites and Blacks have been in this conntry, has ever seen a child or adult approxi- mate the Aboriginal type, or expects that such an approxi- mation ever will occur ? What may have taken place, under the special providence of God, as Dr. Bachman suggests, far back in the night of time, before the earliest dawn of his- tory, we may leave to his speculations, and those of his ami- able compeer. Dr. Smyth. Our design here, is to treat this subject in a plain, practical manner; to jnd^-e the future by what we knoit) of the past. Certainly any sensible man will concede, that we must expect, that the same laws of nature which have been operating for the last few thousand years, will continue to operate for the coming thousand, unless the existing creation is destroyed, and a new one put in its place. In plain English, we must take it for granted, that the Ne- gro will preserve for ages to come, the same physical type which we know characterized him ages ago. Dr. Bachman, who has left no stone unturned to find an argument in favor of Unity of Races, tells us, that the Negro is a ''^permanent foariety,''^ that he is " incapable of self-government," and that no causes exist which can bring a perinanent mrieiy hack to its original type : once a Negro, always a Negro, unless the Race branches off into entirely new types, which there is £o reason to expect. The point being settled, then, that the physical characterT- istics of the Races of men are widely and permanently dif- ferent, it wof ld seem to follow as a corrollary, that there are also differences or grades in their moral and intellectual fac^- ulties, since these ikcnlties are dependent on certain organir- zations. Every tree brings forth fruit in obedience to this law. The Creator, when he called these Races into being; when he stamped upon them different colors, different fornix stioijs of brain. Sec, stamped upon the Negro at the same time intellectual inferiority, which cannot be changed, until his whole organization is changed. The various species of the horse kind, the cat kind, and every genus, have faculties and instincts peculiar to each, and we never talk of changing these. The same holds in M ankind : From the remotest epoch recorded in history — from the remotest glimmering of tradition — what are generirally termed the Caucasian Races, have been the repositories of civilization, aud have been 14 steadily piisliing it on from ago to age, and from nation to nation. Tliongli there have been times when these Races have been phmged in ignorance and barbarism, 3/et it is no less certain that these well-constriicted brains were but shim- bering, and ready to rouse up at the call of civilization. Commence at Ancient Egyi)t, where we reach our first knowledge of civilization, dating back far beyond the time at which tlie Book of Genesis was written : let ns trace it on from this point around tlie Mediterranean, wliere ignor- ance and barbarism reigned, to the pillars of Hercules. Mo- ses, who Holy Writ tells us, was "learned in all the wisdom of the Egyptians," carried it to Judea, which afterwards formed a part of the great Assyrian Empire, and civilization ; follow it on through Phoenicia, Greece, Italy, Gaul, Germa- ny, Spain, Britain, . 4th.- From the past history of the Negroes, not a single i?faetior argument can be drawn to encourage the belief that t jithe slaves of -the United States can be colonized in Africa, or elsewhero, with a prospect of improving their condition ; .while there is ample reason to believe that it would bring i • incalculable evils upon them. 5th. That the slaves now^ in our Southern States must continue, with all their increase, to exist here as slaves, or be driven off to die of want and misery elsewhere. These are stubborn facts, which cannot be gainsaid, and whose importance to the people of the United States cannot 25 he overei*tiinated. Knowing how utterly us?(^*les;5 it is- to lioW up to iVorthern demagogues and fanatics, the Constitution, as a shield against their unceasing attacks upon our institu- tions, I have presented these facts in various shapes, again and again, hoping that if they were not Avilling to he bound by the terms of the Federal Compact — ^vere not willing to listen to the claims of justice — they would at lea^t hearken to these appeals, when sustained by the voice of humanity. Though they may view slavery as an abstract wrong, they cannot denjj w ith reason, that here, it is a practical blessing to the jNegro. And now, in conclusion, let me conjure you to ponder well- on the plain facts I have given you, and ask yourselves, what bright hope does the future hold outf Have we not arrived at a crisis in our affairs w hen it becomes us to break dowrt aU old party barriers, and to meet and take counsei together, and provide for the common danger which stands before us like the sun at noon-day. The cordon of Free ^ States around us is now completed ; our domain is but a fraction of the territory of the United States; the political and fanatical feelings of the Free States, and the prejudices of the whole civilized w orld are arrayed against us ; without having violated the laws of God, the laws of our country, or the laws of humanity, we are looked upon as an outlaw^ed and disgraced people, awaiting the execution of the sentence which is pronounced against us. The time is long passed when we were regarded as equals in the Confederacy, and the so-called Union meetings at the North are not dictated by veneration for the Constitution, by any feeling of broth- erly love, or by any desire to elevate us in the respect of mankind. We are simply tolerated, from pecuniary consid- erations. I am no politician, and did not come here to stimulate party strife; nor did I come to propose remedies for past wrongs, or for the dangers which stand before us. I would leave these to wiser and more experienced heads than mine. I came to lay before you im|X)rtant facts draw n from the phy- sical history of Races, which liave been lost sight of in the discussions on Slavery, and to draw your attention to dan- gers which are ripening, and ought to be anticipated. I came to show, that, whatever blame may attach to our an- re?tors for establishing this institution here, the perpetuaiioH 24 of s^lavery is no sin ; that we could not, as philanthropists, get clear of it if we would, and that we are entitled to the full respect of the Chnstian world. But I will say, that if any man wishes to find the strongest of all arguments for a severance of this Union, and for the formation of a Southern Confederacy, he may deduce it from the chain of facts I have detailed. We have no friends, no sympathisers, no protectors on earth ; and if the North goes on in the course she has been steadily pursuing for the last fifteen years, the South, ere long, will be compelled to protect herself, and to carve an outlet for her Negroes with the sword, from the territory which has been plundered from her. There is a higher law than the consciences of Seward and Thompson — the law of self-preservation. We now pay tribute to the sword which overhangs and threatens us ; and the time, I fear, is not far distant, when we shall need a purse and sword of our own, to protect ourselves against foreign and domestic enemies. We should not be lulled into false security by that delu- sive word. Compromise — or by hosannas sung to an unjust Government. The Constitution, itself — the Missouri line — the Tarifi!* of 1842, were all compromises between the North and the South, and how have these compromises been re- spected ^ Let it be remembered, too, that the "Omnibus Bill" — which is but a mockery, under the name of Compromise — • was passed by Southern^ and not by Northern votes, as " the best bargain they could get." It is openly claimed by Mr. Clay, and his Freesoil party, that this Compromise takes away from the South every foot of conquered territory. The Legislature of Vermont has already declared Iverself against the Compromise; the Governor of Ohio is already out for repeal ; the Sewards, the Hales, the Giddings, the Phillips, the George Thompsons, are in the field, urging on their mad Schemes, and backed by all the religious sects of the North. I ask where, in the world's history, did such a volcano of fanaticism ever cease to burn, till quenched by blood ? The last safeguard of the Slave States — the right of se- cession — is now denied by the Government. One set of States claim the power to decide on the reserved rights of f^he^r States, and to enforce this decision at the mouth 25 the cannon. Does any man here believe that the South wKi jield this point without a struggle ? A deep feeling oi* distrust towards the North now pervades the whole South — and the most confiding must admit, that doubt and uncertainty enshroud the future. I may be w rong, and pray Heaven that I am, but my solemn conviction is. that events are fast ripening, which must end in blood; and under this conviction, I would say to this Association, that 1 think one of their most prominent objects should be, to urge upon the Legislature, the establishment of a Military School — a better organization of the Militia — a provision for all the munitions of war, (fee. It is an old maxim, that, the best way to maintain peace, is to be prepared for war. Yes, my friends, disguise it as you will, our situation b full of appalling dangers, and we should awake to them. Truly and eloquently has that mad fanatic, George Thomp- son, exclaimed: " A voice has spoken in the ear of this mighty nation, and " has said, ' Sleep no more ! Slavery has murdered sleep.' It is unnecessary for me to enter upon historical details. " Most, if not all, of you have been living witnesses of the " progress of the cause. Some of you have been conspicu- " ous actors in the sublime drama which is still unfolding its " scenes, deepening in interest as they advance in the stage of the civilized world. The question is up — the contest is begun — the combat " thickens — the battle becomes grand — it will be grander still — it will be the greatest and grandest ever fought on " earth, and its consequences the mosv; momentous and far- *' reaching of any that have ever followed from a war of principles since the world began. Slavery! it is the theme of every newspaper. It is tlie topic of debate in every legislative hall. It lengthens the " sittings of Congress. It allows your Senators but two " hours' rest at night. It mixes with your soil. It deter- mines your boundary lines. It is that word in every new Constitution which causes the mightiest intellects in the land to grapple with each other, in passionate and unyield- ing conflict. It is the pivot upon which every election " turns. It decides the complexion of every ticket placed \u 4 26 ^' tlifi ballot-box. It is tbe test of membersbi]) in Churches. " It is the cause of divisions in communities. It leads to ^' new combinations of political parties. It makes and un- " makes Bishops. It changes Whigs into Democrats, and both into Freesoilers. It is the interpreter of the tables ^' of stone given to Moses, and of the precepts to brotherly love uttered by Jesus. It meets the Priest on the steps of " the Altar — the Preacher on the stairs of the Pulpit — tbe " Merchant on the busy Exchange — and the New England Farmer, when a hungry, naked wanderer asks in the name ^' of it and humanity for shelter for the night. " Is it nothing, my friends, that all this has been brought, to jmss in twenty years ? Is it nothing that an obsolete ^' and buried Christianity has been exhumed, and sent forth, ^' like a refining fire, to purify this land from the curse of slavery." Yes, the evil-doers are up and at work night and day, and it is time for us of the South to arouse from our long and chilling slumber. The spirit of Liberty, the spirit of i"hi- lartthropy, the spirit of Christianity, aye, and the ghosts of the murdered Whites of St. Domingo rise up — shake their gory locks at you — and bid you, " Sleep no inoreJ''' Note. — For an extension of these views, see my ''Two Lectures on tlie Bibli. eal and Physical History of Man," and several articles in the Southern Quarterly D Date Due CALL NUMBER Vol. Date (for periodical) Copy No. 1 SEP ^2 1970 3 N916S o703''36