Duke University Libraries Speech of Hon. Conf Pam #627 DTTDbb7flflA (i-u:-: f7- -■ .->-/-^'^ SPEECH OF HON. GUSTAYUS A. HENRY, OF TENNESSEE, In the Senate of the Confederate Slates, November 29, 18G4. The qnoBtion being on the joint resolution introduced by him in the Senate, defining the position of the Confederate States, and declaring the determination of the Congress and the I>eople thereof to prosecnto the war till their indspcndenco is acknowledged- Mr. Henry said : Mr. President, I rise to address the Senate on the momentous questions inolved in the resolutions which have just been reported to the Senate, with more than ordinary sensibility. The field pre- sented for discussion is so wide, that I fear, were I to occupy it fully, I might consume more of the valuable time of the Senate than would bo appropriate; and yet, if 1 attempt to contract my remarks into too narrow a limit, I will rob the resolutions of much of their interest, and render the discussion of them stale and unprofitable. I will, therefore, be obliged to the Senate for its charitable indulgence while I give my views, in my own way, on all the topics I may see proper to discuss ; promising the Senate to strike the golden medium, if I can, which lies between the extremes of undue expansion on the one hand and of contraction on the other. • Sir, I feel it will be good for us to- day, and a useful occupation of our time, to recur to first principles, and to examine well the ground on which wo stand, that the judgment of mankind, which we invoke on our conduct, may be properly en- lightened before it is pronounced. e. -^nUJ In 1776, the American Rerolution dawneil upon the world, and the people of the thirteen colonies, then British gubjects the common anceetors of the parties to the present conflict of arras, in Congress as»embled, proclajmed to the world the Declaration of American In- dependence, in which thepe great political truths, never before an- Dcunced with such solemnity, w. re submitted to the candid judgment of .mankind — among others, that all men *' are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rijzhts; that among these, are life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness ; thar, to secure these rights, governments are instited among men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed ; that, whenever an} form of gov- ernment becomes destructive of these ends, it is the right of the peo- ple to alter or abolish it, and to institute a new government, laying its foundation on such principles, and organizing its powers in such form, as to them shall seem most likely to effect their safety and hap- piness." To establish these great principles, and in earnest of their sincerity, the Adamses and the Hancocks of Massachusetts "pledged their lives, their fortunes and their sacred honor." On this declaration the peo- ple of Massachusetts and New York, Virginia and South Carolina, in- deed, the whole North and the whole South, united in the revolu- tionary struggle, and, hnnd in hiind, fought and bled in its defence, and finally achieved their independence, in despite of the power of England, then the mistress of the world. This was the language of stern men, not hastily adopted ; of unconquerable patriots, who had counted all the cost, and who had deliberately staked life, liberty and property on the great issue — the independence of their country. On these principles our fathers, more than eighty years ago, though comparatively few in numbers, grappled with the power of Great Britain, and, after seven years of war, in which their country was desolated, and their cities occupied, possessed and sacked by the en- emy, finally triumphed. On these same principles we have staked our all, in the war in which we are engaged with the United States; and though our country may be despoiled and ravaged, our cities given to the flames, and nothing bo left but the " blackness of ashes" to mark vthere they stood, we, too, will finally triumph and achieve our independence. Mr. President, are not these principles as potent now, and as full of magic, as when they were uttered in Independence Hall, in Phila- delphia, air id a silence as deep and solemn as that of the grave ? The spell they threw over the hearts of men is felt by us now, and we are bound by it still. This was true political doctrine when England was trying to rivet chains upon Massachusetts' and New York, Virginia and South Carolina. It is true now. We stand where our fathers stood and in defence of the same rights. The United States occupy the ground of George the Third, and are re enacting his despotism, obliterating the brightest pages of their own hi.story, and tearing down with their own hands the monuments that were erected by their '^ • <^ • •^ *•! ancestors, and cemented with their b'ood ; and such will everywhere be the verdict of enlightened public opinion upon their conduct. Mr. President, we are struggling in this war for the right of stlf- government. These few words cover the whole ground, and elucidate the insue we have joined with our enemies. All others are minor considerations and are merged in it. The contest about our domestic in^titutionti, the li^ht of the States to legalize, destroy or perpetuate thein, as' an attribute of their sovereignty, are all embraced under the general idea, and purel.y an American one, the right of the people to s.'lf-government ; for whatever may be the dogmas of legit'macy and of despotism, under which man, in all ages, has groaned, and been doomed to drink the cup of slavery, w ho/4 that governments have no rigli»tul authority over men. except by the consent of the governed. Sir. I deKire to disabuse the public mind of one fatal error into which our enemies have fallen, and which, to some extent, is participated ia by a few of the people of the South This is no "rebellion ;" but such a war as independent sovereignties wage against each other. These States were all equals. Virginia was as free as New York, and in all pcilitical respects her equal and her peer. Equals cannot rebel the one against the other. If they disagree, and rcHort to arms .•^s the arbitrator, it is war, such as writers on the law^ of nations recognize among independent nations. The people of the old thirteen colonies were Briti'sh subjects, acknowledged to be so, and dependent on the Crown. When they threw off British authority they were in rebellion against England. Not so with us in this war. We V ere the subjects of no power, but were ourselves sovereigns, equal* in all respects with our enemies; and they who call us rebels con- found all legal distinctions, and show, to say the least of it, *hat they have not investigated the subject. Here, no one State was dependent upon another, or upon all of them together. The States^ after the i^ar with England, received the acknowledgment of their indepen- lienoe as States, not as one consolidated nation. They wee recognized ly England in the treaty of peace, ns States ; by the name of Geor- gia, Virginia, New York, arid so on, the whole thirteen being called by name. Undet the old confederation they had stood for thirteen years as equals, and voted as equals, each State being enti- tled to one vote. Jn 1787, when they formed the Constitution of the Lnited States, they met as equal sovereignties. They did not afterwards sink their separate State sovereignty,- abolish tlifir State governments, and have one legislature, as in the case of England, Ireland, and Scotland. No, sir. They maintained their State 80verei;'nty, in opposition to centralism, ai« beii.g the great «nemy of liberty in free States, which would swallow them in the whirlpool of consolidation, but for the spirit of local Belf-go?ern« rcents, always the life-blood of freedom. The States never surrendered their independent sovereignty, and when the Constitution was on its passage through the convention that formed it, they unanimously rejected a proposition to dele> gate to the General Government the power to coerce a Stale. The proposition wae distinctly made and unanimously rejected ! This historical fact takes from the United States the last pretence of a constitutional right to coerce, by military power, a State, or any number of them, if they see proper to throw off the government of the United States, and institute a new government, which would be more likely to effect their safety and happiness. Even Alexander Ilamil- tcn, who was supposed to be the advocate of unlimited power in the government, declared that a proposition to coerce such a State as New York or Virginia, with such a population as they would have in fifty years, was the maddest project that could be devised. Mr. Mad- ison declared that it would be to confer despotic power on the Gov- ernment, and that it would convert our free institutions into a des- potifm. While the States exercised military power to establish their independence, and delegated to Ccngress the power to declare war, thev did not intend to organize a government with a view to the sub- jugation of the sovereign States which created it. On the contrary, they unanimously refused to delegate such despotic power to the government. Nor is this, sir, a civil war. That is, a war between the people of the same State, such as prevailed in England between the houses of York and Lancaster, when contending factions rent the vitals of the State. This is no such war. It stands on the broad ground of a war etween sovereign and independent States, precisely such as has often prevailed between France and England. Mr. President, it is a source of pure and Christian consolation to the people of the South, that they did not rush blindly into this war. No, air; we flew to arms only after wc had exhausted every means of peace and reconciliation. Never did a people more earnestly implore and sup- plicate their rulers to beware how they drove them to the necessity of defending their rights by an appeal to arms. We implored thorn by the ties of a common kindred, and in the name of a common God, to abstain from the injuries and insults they were habitually inflicting upon us,- and from the usurpation of powers not delegated in the Con- stitution, which foreshadowed the establishment of an absolute tyranny over these States. They were deaf to our appeals. In vain did we invoke a peace congress to step in between us and them, and, like the daysman, lay its hand upon the ono and the other, and command the peace. The Hon. John Tyler, from Virginia, who had " sounded all the depths and shoals of honor," and who had been President of the whole United States in their purer and better days — the venerable Ju('ge Iluffin, of North Carolina, who had for so many years presided witti such dignity and intelligence in the Supreme Court of that i State, and had shed such lustre on American jurisprudence ; as re- | markable for the purity of his character^as for the power and clearness I pf his logic — the pure-ciinded and gifted Judge Caruthers, of Ten- | nessc, wl o had held nearly everj post of honor in his native State, and^vNtio is now her Chief Magistrate elect; and many others of equal j patriotipm, made tlieir pilgrimage to Washington to stay the coming strife before the first blow was struck — toiled in vain to bring about an honorable adjustment, and were at last forced to go home in despair of the Republic, and to tell their people that all hope of saving it was gone ! It was not until all these efforts were made and provetl to be una- vailing; not until the last star of hope that blazed on the political horizon had gone down in blood, and Lincoln had made his proclama- tion for seventy-five thousand men to subjugate these States, that the people began to prepare for war. When that dreadful alterhative, war or subjugation, was presented to them, the masses everywhere, as if by instinct, before the politicians were ready for it, or had fully made up their minds what they would do, had detected the lUrking purposes of the tyrant, sounded the tocsin and were panting for the conflict. The politicians, who, in ordinary cases, lead the people, were led, in this great greund-swell of popular indignation, by them. It was more emphatically a movement of the people than any I have ever observed since I have been in public life. It is emphatically tht people's war. Mr. President, we have now maintained this unequal contest for nearly four years, and invoke the judgment of the world whether or not we have established our capacity for self-government, and our ability to resist the power of the enemy to subjugate us. \V e have a Government regularly organized under a written con- stitution, with Executive, Legislative and Judicial departments ; all the functions of a constitutional government .in full and successtul operation. If the Governments of Europe have not seen fit to recognize us as a free and independent Power and welcome us into the family of na- tions, it is their fault, not ours. The United States were recognized by France in less than two years after their decjaration of independence; and the United States, in a much shorter period than that for which we have niaiatained our sep- arate nationality, recognized the South American Republics and the Republic of Mexico, after they asserted their independence of the G(A'ernment3 which they respectively overthrew. We need hut look to the present and the past, to settle the question of our ability to resist the power of the enemy. Less than four years ago we were without an army and navy. Our enemy took possession of both, and turned them against us. The wealth of the country was at the North ; and the pernicious system of legislation pursued so long and so persistinglj to our prejudice and to the aggrandizement of the North, had concentrated there nearly all the public works and manufacturing power of the whole country. We had neither heavy ordnance nor small arms ; manufactured neither powder nor ball ; not even percussion caps. But see the progress we have made, and how we have developed our resources. We are now making more than ten thousand pounds of powder per day at^one of our milU. Our army is well equipped with all the implements of warfare. We are able to iepp an nrmy of four hundred thousand soldiers in the field. TVt hnre met the enemy in a hun^ired baiiles, and have baflled and defeated his armies in conflicts without number on the land, and our little navy has nearly driven his commerce from the seas. We have struck the world with astonishment at the power we hive exhibited, while th'' giize of all Europe is fixed in admiration of the gallantry of our soldiers. If we connider our small and meagre resourc'S at the be- ginning, and the material strength we wield now, we are ourselves antonished at the progress we have made in the art of war and the • science of government. The most potent . ower on earth has gtineJ no decided a wr'-tro-union with them ? No, sir ; never! There* is a great gulf that rolls between us. It is a gulf of blood, without a shore and without a bottom, and is as impassable as that which separates Dives from Lazarus The mute objects of nature; our desecrated churches and altars; our sweet valleys drenched in blood and charrad by fire, forbid it. The dead would cry out against it from their gory beds. The blood of my own sons, yet unavenged, cries to Heaven from the ground for vengeance The thousands who are sleeping red in their graves would awake and utter their solemn protest. Stonewall Jackson, Polk, Stuart, Rodes, Morgan, Preston Smith, and the thousands ove/ whose remains a monument to the unknown dead shall bo ruised. are speaking in tones of thunder against it; and can it be the livwg only will be dumb ? Sir, those who have died in this war are not dead to us. " E'en in their ashes live their wonted firef." They are, in the light of their example, more valuable than the living. Their spirits walk abroad, and stir the hearts of living men to do or die in the cause of liberty. We cherish their memory Weeping virgins and devoted mothers shall kneel arOund their tombs, and bed ! The people of Tennessee have felt the yoke of the oppressor. They know how gallirTg it is to the neck. They have been made to drink the cup of slavery to the dregs, and they know how bitter is che draught. They have been ground under the heel of petty tyrants, and they know what it is to have the iron enter their souls. They hate their oppressors with a concentrated hate which can expire only wifh their lives. The Jews when they were carried away into cap- tivity in Babylon, never looked more anxiously for deliverance thaa they are looking even now for the Confederate army to enter the State, and strike from their limbs their galling chains. They are now, sir, standing on tiptoe, straining their eyes to catch the first gli'mpse of the Confederaie flag as it floats out upon the wild winds free on yon- der hill, and long for its coming as the hunted hart pants for the water brook. 1 confidently predict, if our at my enters the State and maintains its position there for three months, that its numbers will be doubled. From every hill and valley pur oppressed people will come to our banner as the " leaves come when forests are rended." It is my nightly prayer that my life may be spared till I witness the deliverance 11 of my noble State and my oppressed people. Tennessee ! Ob, may I be allowed to " Raise my exultant head and see Thy hilla, thy daleg, thy people free I That glance of bliss is all I crave Between my labors and my grave!" I further predict, Mr. President, if our army goes into Kentucky and stays there three months, and gives to that people any assur- ance that we will hold it and stand by them — if they will unite their fortunes with ns, and make common cause in this great struggle for liberty — the last that ever will be made if wefail ; for if the light of liberty ia extinguished here the gloom of despotiem will be unbroken all over the world ; put out that light and where is the Promethean spark that pan that light relume — if, I say, we will g^ve the people of Kentucky an assurance that we will stand by them, and not, by com- ing ppeedily away, hand them over to the ravenous wolves who will thirst for their blood, thousands will join our army, and re-enact the scenes of the "dork an^ bloody ground," and add new lustre to this, the most memorable struggle in the annals of time, in which Ken- tucky has not as yet, as a State, participated. I do not overestimate it when I predict that fifty thousand as gallant men as ever shouldered a musket or hung a enbre to the thigh, will be added as fre^h recruits to our army from Kentucky and Tennessee. Sir, they constitute the Lest recruiting grounds now in America. The people of both States are now ripe for action, and will coEie to the rescue of our gallant army with alacrity. Mr. President, let us be united ; let us work together in this com- mon cause, no matter at what cost of bkod and treasure ; for it is worthy of the sacrifice Let not the future historian record of us : here was a nation that bij'avely spurned " villian bonds and despot sway," and never was conquered by its enemies till from itself it ftll. If there had been no division in North Carolina and Tennessee, we could have sent to the field an army of 4t)n,(IUii men. The mother and the daughter, locking their shields together, could have passed through the land conquering and to conquer. It is not too late yet. If all discord were silenced, and the peopl«s of the two States, soldiers and politicians, the men at home and the men in the a^my, could act together as one people, animated by one purpose, and emulous only to excel each other in the race of glory, this war would soon have an end ; indeed, under such a condi- tion of things it never would have had a beginning. It is kept alive by discord now. Is it not mortifying, in a struggle like this, when all hearts should be united in a common effort, that any discordant voices should be raised in carping criticism against the Government, its administration and its President? It is surely task enough lor his worn energies to watch the public enemy, without being forced to .endure the distrustful assaults of friends at home. From the bottom of my heart he has my sympathy in the midst of the great and multi- 12 plied trials by which he is surrounded; trials that are with him every day and hour, and which haunt his pillow at night, driving sleep from his eye-lids while others are in calm repose. Is it fair, or generous, or patriotic, that his opponents should select the darkest hour of gloom that hangs over the country — a gloom which a united voice and effort in this capital would drive away in twenty-four hours — to assail his character and mar his plans ? As though the pilot who stands at the helm in the hour of danger did not have enough to do to watch the storm that is beating mercilessly on his vessel, to hold its head steady to the wind and shun the rocks against which it could not be driven and live, without being harrassed by the railing and the mutiny of the crew ! Thank God, those who' assail him cannot shake him in his steady march in the path of duty; nor can they shake the confidence of the country in him ! Though their words of censure may fall harmlessly at his feet, the^ are caught up by the spies who crawl about the capital and meet us in our pri- vate and public walks, and become winged messengers to the enemy, giving exaggerated accounts of whatever disaffection may prevail here, and encouragement to the enemy to persevere against us, under the hope that domestic discord may unbar the gates they have not been able to force, and weaken the fortress which has hitherto been impregnable to their assaults, and from which their columns have been hurled back in confusion, bleeding and broken. Sir, this habit of assailing the President and the administration is, in my opinion, a habit more honored in the breac|j than the observance. It does in- calculable injury,, and, though it is. not bo intended, gives aid and comfort to the enemy. It is gratifying that no such habit prevails in. the Senate. But notwithstanding all the grumblings and mutterings of disappointed malcontents elsewhere, he is firmly fixed in the hearts of the people ; aye, sir, in their heart of hearts. They put their trust in him, and lean on him while this storm of war is raging over the land as he leans on Heaven for support. May he live to bring the vessel safely into port, amid the acclama- tions of all on board and the shouts and loud huzzas of all on the shore. Doubtless he has committed errors, and made grave mistakes in his judgments of men and measures; for everybody and every thing was untried and had to be tested by experience. Did anybody ever expect any thing else ? for is he not human, and is it not human to err? Our own Washington, the purest and greatest of human beings, Avas not exempt from human frailty. • The people have given their confidence to the President of the Confederate States, because they believe he is wise, patriotic and brave ; and, so far as I know, he has done nothing to forfeit their confidence, but a great-deal to increase it. The consequence is, they who assail him do not injure him, but themselves, and. it may be, their Country. Here, sir, is the rub. The country is the chief sufferer. The shafts that are aimed at him fly wide of the mark, passing him harmlessly; but are found quivering in the heart of our bleeding country. 13 They who throw themselves in the way of a united and vigorous prosecution of this war, from any unjust suspicion of the President, or from any other cause, will repent it in sackcloth and ashes. " Who- soever falls on this rock shall be broken ; and on whomsoever it falls, he shall be ground to powder." In my opinion, we ought to give him a cordial support in all his efforts to safe the country ; not blindly, but patriotically, for the sake of the country. It were better, it seema to me, to direct our thunders against the enemy who is trying to sub- jugate us, rather than pour out our invectives on his head whom tho people have chosen as the pilot to conduct us through the storm. It shall be some consolation to me, Mr. President, wheii that storm is over, and our vessel of State is riding on tranquil seas, and " walk- ing the water like a thing of life," with our Confederate flag flying from its mast head, recognized by all nations, and honored and respect- ed in every port around the globe ; when peace and prosperity shall return to bless tlie land ; when our fields shall again smile with the rich productions of agriculture, and the white-winged birds of our commerce shall Oock to every port, carrying our great staples to other lands, and bringing back the luxuries and wealthy of other nations to pour them into our lap ; it shall be some consolation to me then, if I have not upheld the arms of the commander and stimulated the hearts of the crew in a manner commensurato with my great ambition to serve the country Jionestly and to serve it well, that I have at least done nothing to paralyze the one or the other; but, according to the best of ray poor ability, done all I could to sustain the cause, to advance our standard, to brace and strengthen, in the field or in the cabinet, all who honestly try to serve the country and to establish its inde- pendence forever. • • • • p€RmAlipe< pH8.5