TREATISE Concerning the S TAT E of Departed SOULS Before, and At, and After the RESURRECTION. Written originally in Latin by the late Rev. Dr. Thomas Burnet, Mafter of the Charter-Ronfe, Author of the Theory of the Earth, Tranflated into EngliJI} by Mr. DENNIS. LONDON: Printed for John Hooke, at the Flower'dc-Lucc y over-againft SuDunflari 's-Church in Fkst-Strect. M.DCCXXX. Juft publijhedy 'Trice 4 s. tfranjlated from ihe Latin of Dr. Burnet, late Mafier of the Charter-Houfe. The FAITH and DUTIES of Christians. A Treatife in eight Chapters j giving an Ac- count of, I. The Foundation of Natural and Instituted Religion. II. The Authority and Ulcful- nefs of the Jew'ijb Religion. III. The Chriftian Difpenfation; the Nature and Author of it. IV. The Worfhip of God ; and its facred Rites, according to the Chriftian Law. V. Moral Rules and Precepts ac- cording to the Chriftian Law. VI. The Chriftian Articles of Faith. VII. The Secondary Articles in the Chriftian Doctrine ex» plain'd. VIII. The Chriftian Church i its Government and Difciplinc. Tranflated into EngUJb by Mr. Dennis. - i/«atf» I fay upon c Pofterity, to which his Works will certainly deft end : He flyews every where too magnanimous a Soul for that. No Man feems to me ever to have abhorred Faljhood more. I will not pretend to fay that he is without Error, no human Writer either is^ or was, or ever will be without it. The greateji of Men both may and muf err ', but if we are to judge, as in Equity we ought, of the Trofe of a Writer, by the fame Rule by which Horace judg'd of the Verfes of his Contemporaries, Ubi plura nitent in Car- mine, non ego paucis, offendar maculis, &c. Then will I venture to affirm, that if 1)r. Burnet has Errors, he has Beauties, and great Beauties, fiffcient to make an ample md a glorious Amends for them, THE THE CONTENTS. HE Introdu&ion : The Sub- ject, and the Method of hand- ling it. Page i CHAP. I. That human Felicity does not depend folely upon this Life, but that we are to expecl: a future State. 3 CHAP. If. That the human Soul is an immortal Sub- ftance, diftind from the Body, and from all Matter. 18 CHAP. III. What will be the future Condition of the Soul after the Difiblution of the Body ; or of the The CONTENTS. the Middle State of Souls in the Interval between Death and the Refurre&ion, as to the Degrees of Happinefs or Mifery ? 49 CHAP. IV. Of the State of Nature, in which departed Souls are in the Interval between Death ard the Refurredtion. Whether they are nked and feparated from all corporeal Sub- il.mce, or whether they are united to an ae- rial, or any other Body? 106 CHAP. V. Tranfition to the remaining Parts of thisWork ; and, firft, concerning the Coming of Chrift, and the Conflagration of the World. 125 CHAP. VI. Of the lalt Judgment : A View of its princi- pal Appearances ; of its Manner, End, and mcd. 144 CHAP. VII. Of the Refur re&ion of the Dead ; and in what State they will be after they are rifen, and what Sort of Bodies they will have. 1 80 CHAP. VIII. What fort of Body we are to have at the Re- furrecYion ? the lame that we have at prefent, er a different one ? 231 CHAP. The CONTENTS. xi CHAP. IX. Of the firft and laft Refurre&ion : Of the new Heavens, and the new Earth, and the Re- novation of Nature: Of the Millennian King- dom of Chrift, and the Confummation of all Things. 2$$ CHAP. X. Of Heaven and Hell. What fort of Heaven that of the Chriftians is, and how far it may be faid to be local. What Hell is j whether there is, or will be any Subterra- nean, or any other local, corporeal, and ex- ternal Hell, before the Day of Judgment, and Conflagration of the World. Of the Puniftiments of Hell ; whether they are to be looked upon as finite, infinite, or indefi- nite. 315 The Conclusion.' * 368 ERRATA ERRATA. ■pASE 1 8. 1. 12. f. it treats ; r» they treat ; p .at. 1. 19. i.Reafons .t.Rtafon ? p. 31.1.9. in the Notes, f. Confciencioufnefs, r. Confcioufneft ; ibid» 1. 15. f. »Aew, r.fmce; p. 33. 1. I. f. 3f"'«> r * jfaifM 5 P* 35* '• I, f- «* t- are ; p. 4.9. chap. iii. 1. 1. t. When, r. Whereas ; p. j-j. 1. a. f. ffor, r. as if i P« j8. 1. 17. f- tax, r. fays $ p. 60. 1. 10. i. Phrafe, r. ExpreJJion ; ibid. 1. 1 1, 12. f. them, r. »» ; p. 6 .• 1. 30. f. eacA, r. iWi ; p. 84.. 1« 3a» f- has, T' from ; p. 87. 1. 10 t. Beatitudes, r. Beatitude ; p 88. 1 aj. f. Light which, r. Light with which ; p. 98. I. 13. f has had, r. havebai; p. 1 06. chap. iv. f. the aerial, r. an aerial ; p. 1 2 1 . 1. aa. t. ObjeB, r. ObjeSs ; ibid. I. aa. f. Imprtffwn, r. Imprefficns ; p. 124. 1. 8. f. Doraf i.Goodi p. 129. 1. 14.. t. otm/ij fte, r. meant that the; p. J 36. 1. f. whom» r. it/jo; p. 193. 1. a 3. f. belongs, r. beltrng; p 19/. 1. 14* f« thereby, » therefore ; p- 197. 1. 27. f. forced, r. «ever; p. 199. 1. 22. (.follow, r. follows ; ibid. 1. 31. f. Apofiles, r. Apofile ; p. aoc>. 1. 9. f. 7m, r. /j- if; p. ajj\ chap. ix. 1. 2. f. F/r/?, r. Thefirft ; ib. I.3. f. ./4W laft, r. ^<»i »fo /<«j? ; p. 264.. 1.6. in the Notes, dele and ; p. 27?. 1. 23. f". this r. the; p. 279» 1. 1 a. i. of World, r. of the World ; p. 290. 1. 19. f. remains, r. remain ; p. 308. 1. a4.. in the Notes, r. of Chriji ; p- 313- L 1. f-^ex, r. ./fge; p. 337. 1. a9- f. Tartarum, r. Tartarus ; p. 34a. in the Notes, f. latter, f. /<>«»«• ; p. 34.4. 1. 16. f. their, r. fci/j p. 3J0. !• 2. f. fta», r. thnt ; V' 159' !• 3 1- /• JheulJ r. ra not for that we would be uncloathedj but c loathed upouj that Mortality might be J wal- lowed up of Life. In the fame Manner St. 'Paul fays to the Romans _, that all Mature, together with us^ does groan being burthen y d„ and afpiring to a certain Immortality : For r< I reckon^ fays he, that the Sufferings of l %> J 9- this pre fent Time are not worthy to be com- pared with the Glory which floall be reveal- ed in us : For the earneft Expectation of the Creature waiteth for the Manifejia- tion of the Sons of God. To be fhort, e very- Page in the Apoitolick Writings proclaims a future State and eternal Life ; at once the Foundation and Recompence of our Faith : And Chrift is laid to have brought, by his Gofpel, this Immortality to Light, that is, he explain'd it more clearly, and more effica- cioufly, than either Mofes in his Laws, or the Philofophers in their Schools. C C HAP. Lorn, vnii i8 A TREATISE concerning the CHAP. II. That the Human Soul is an immortal Sub- fiance j difiinct from the Body, and from all Matter. IT being once granted that Men are to enjoy a future Life, it neceffarily follows that the human Soul is immortal. But fome are of Opinion, that its Immortality is foreign from its Nature, and only granted to it as an Advantage by divine Favour : Others are of Opinion, that it was created immor- tal ; and that 'tis by its own Nature exempt from DhTolution. The facred Writings ma- nifeftly teftify, that 'tis immortal either one Way or the other, as we have juft now feen, when it treats of eternal Life, of the Refur- re&ion of the Dead, of the laft Judgment, of future Rewards and Punifhments, of Heaven and Hell, and other Things that re- late to them ; all which fuppofe, that the Soul exifts after the Death and DiiTolution of the Body, that it lives and enjoys both Senfe and Thought. However, I am of Opinion, that it will be worth while, in a few Words, to enquire, whether, befides the extraordina- ry Favour of God, whatever that is, the Soul is not immortal and incorruptible, by the Force and Principles of its original Na- ture, State of Departed Souls, fcV. 19 ture, though depending ftill upon God : For it greatly corroborates our Affent to this, and Belief of it, to fee what we believe have its Root and Foundation in the very Nature of Things. We can never difcern or difbover, with all our Attention, any Quality in the human Soul, befides Thought, and the Power to think. Whatever the Soul does, ei- ther within itfelf, or externally, it ads not by Touch or Impulie, but by the Force of fome Thought, whether that Thought is called Will, or Underftanding, or Appetite, or by any other Name. And like wife when it fuffers, either from itfelf, or from without, that Suffering too is a Species of Thought : So that we can find nothing at all in the Soul, befides the Power of Thinking, and its various Manners. Now if the Nature of the Soul, or the very EfTence of it, as fome are us'd to ipeak, confifts entirely inThought, 'tis efTentially Life, and is active or confci- ous of itfelf without ceafing ; nor can it any otherwife perifh than by Annihilation. For if you take away all Thought from it, or the Power to think, you deprive it of its very EfTence, which is the fame Thing with annihilating or deftroying the Soul. We own that this is in the Power of God ; nor is that the Qiieftion at prefent : But we de- ny that its Life, or its Power to think, can poffibly perifh, the EfTence of the Soul re- maining j which from this Conftitution of G 3 the 2 .4 TREATISE concerning the the Soul, if you admit of it, in my Opinion, truly and neceffarily follows. They who after this Manner conftitute the Nature of the human Soul, by that very Thing render it immortal, and inceflantly active or confcious of itfelf, unlefs 'tis re- duced to nothing. But they who, befides this Force of thinking, and this vital Ener- gy, if we may be allowed to borrow that Word, attribute to the Soul Extenlion and Dimension, and lay this as a Foundation an- tecedent to all Thought, they are to confi- der by what Means they are able to prove the future Life of the Soul. I fay the fu- ture Life, not the fimple Duration ; for 'tis one Thing limply to endure, or to laft, like a Stock or a Scone ; and another Thing to live and to enjoy Senfe and Thought ; which is what all Men underftand when they hear the Name of Immortality, and of the Life hereafter. But if once an extended Subftance is placed in the room of a Soul, in which Life or Thought are not neceffarily included, it will depend upon external Caufes, or upon divine Favour, whether it mail want or en- joy Life and Thought. But I am unwil- ling to quarrel with any one who is for pre- ferving Immortality for us at any Rate, whe- ther he derive it from Nature, or from di- vine Favour. But now to make a farther Progrefs in my Argument : They who endeavour to perfuade us out of Immortality, than which nothing State of Departed Souls, &c. zi nothing can be dearer to our Thoughts, will have the Soul to be not only an extended Subftance, but really and truly Corporeal in every Reipeft, and fo, like Body, capable of being duTolved. Thefe Reaibners I look upon as profefsM Enemies to Human Na- ture. But even towards Enemies there are certain Rights and Decencies that ought to be obferved. Let us, therefore, lay aiide all paflionate Reproaches and injurious Lan- guage, and argue the Matter candidly and calmly with them. We will, if you pleafe, for the fake of fhortening the Caufe, take it for granted, by common Confent, that there is lbmething incorporeal in the Nature of Things ; or if you are unwilling to take any Thing for granted, that is not extorted from you by the Force of Reafons, we will, in the rirft Place, prove that God is not a Body, or is not cor- poreal. And, after we have laid this Foun- dation, we will proceed to examine the Na- ture of the Soul, which is the Point in Quef- tion. Though itmay juftly be reckon'd among thofe Abfurdities which require no Proof^ that the corporeal World created itfelf, with- out the Hand of an Artift, without any pre- ceedingDefign, or Thought, or Counfel ; and though it be no lefs abfurd, that that High Wifdom and Sovereign Power, which mine forth fo brightly in the Workmanmip and Government of Nature, fhould be innate or G 3 implanted zz ^TREATISE concerning the implanted in blind and grofs Matter ; yet fo oddly are the Minds of fome Men turned, that whatever does not ftrike the outward Senfes, or fill the Imagination ; or, that I may fpeak more plainly, whatever is not corporeal, all that they efteem as nothing. Well then, let us briefly examine the Thing: If God is corporeal, he mull either be the whole corporeal World, all the univerfal Mafs of Matter ; or fome certain Portion, fome Species, or fome lingular Kind of it. If you affirm the latter, you fay nothing ; becaufe no kind of Matter is unalterable. All Matter, indeed, as to its Subftance, is one and the fame ; but as to its Modes and Qualities, it alters continually : That which is hard to Day, to Morrow grows fofter, or is melted ; and that which is thin and fubtle to Day, grows hard, and thickens to Morrow, and is depriv'd of its Motion. For Motion paifes without ceafing from fome Parts of Matter to others ; as like wile the other Qualities of Matter by the Media- tion of Motion ; and nothing remains under the fame Form perpetually. Therefore your God would be like 'Proteus; or rather, by the various Mutations of Matter, would often die and revive. Befides, as he is not univer- fal Matter, he cannot be omniprefent ; nor only that, but he would be broken afunder ? and his Subftance would have Chafms in feveral Places, by the Interpofition of other Bodies ; for if your God is the thin and flui4 State of Departed Souls, i*fc. 23 fluid Portion of Matter, by the Interpofi- tion of hard Bodies there would be a Solu- tion of his Continuity : If you make him of the hard and grofs Part of Matter, he would be often and varioufly torn from himfelf by the Fluid that would run between his di- vided Parts. So that by this Means you will have not One, but Numberlefs Gods ; Nor would it at laft be an entire God, but ib ma- ny broken Limbs and miftiapen Pieces of a God. Laftly, you include your God in fingle Particles of Matter ; or Part of him in one, and Part of him in another : Chufe which Way you will, the Choice will be down right Stupidity, which it is not worth while to take any farther Notice of. You fee how wretchedly God is made up of fbme particular Matter, be it what it will that you chufe : Nor is it lefs abfurd, or lefs impoflible, to exalt the univerfal Mafs of Matter into a God and a divine Nature. If you imagine that all the vaft Structure of this vilible World, and all Bodies whatever, celeftial, terreftrial, animated, unanimated, Stocks, Stones, Metals, and whatever is viler and more fordid than thefe ; if you imagine all thefe to be God, in this your Folly fur- pafles the Folly of the grofleft Heathens in the World ; for they believed that the Deity which they adored was very different from the Marble or Wood, or whatever Statue they had confecrated to him. They believ'd, indeed, that the God inhabited, after fome C 4. Man- 24 A TREATISE concerning the Manner, the Statue which they had erected to him ; but they diftinguifrYd the Inhabitant from the Houfe, and the Sword from the Scabbard : But you confound both the one and the other. Befides, according to your Opinion, we daily eat and drink the God that we worfhip, nay, we tread him under our Feet. And whatever Matter fufFers when 'tis violently tofs'd or driven, when 'tis cut, burnt, ground, or tormented any other Way, God fufFers in that : For you fay that Matter is God ) and, fince 'tis di- vine, it cannot be infenfible. Nothing can be more foreign from all Reafon than this : But ftill you are preifed with an Abfurdity of a blacker Dye. You not only make God iufFer, but, what I hardly dare to pronounce, you make him impious, you make him vil- lainous : For if the Univerfe is God, he muft be all its Parts, whether they are ani- mated or unanimated, bafe or noble, pure or impure, nay, the molt profligate, and moft accurs'd either of Men or Devils. But we ought with a religious Care, to abftain from thefe unutterable Things. Thesf, and other Things of this Nature, unworthy the Majefty of the fupreme Dei- ty, are infeparable from your Hypothefis, which depreffes the Nature of God, and con- founds it with Matter. Nor, on the other Side, do you lels contend againft Reaibn, when you are for exalting Matter, in fpite of its Unwillingnefs and its Reludancy, into a divine State of Departed Souls, <&VJ 2 5 divine Nature, and clpathing it with Per- fections, of which it is moft incapable. Let us, if you pleafe, recoiled: what all Men underftand by the Word God : They cer- tainly all underftand a Nature that is infi- nitely perfect. But is there any Man alive who can perfuade himfelf and others, that all Perfections are inherent in Matter, that they all ipring from that Root, that they all flow from that Fountain ? In the firft Place, the Mafs of Matter has in itfelf neither Force nor Action ; nor could it receive either from abroad, if there were nothing more excellent than itfelf: And then, after it had received it from fbmething elfe, it could not poffibly exercife it, unlefs by the Divifion of itfelf into various Parts, and the local Motion of thofe Parts. But neither does Divifibility, nor local Motion, agree with infinite Perfec- tion. Secondly, if the Mafs of Matter con- tains and includes in itfelf neither Force nor Action, much lefs does it contain and in- clude in itfelf Cogitation ; and leaft of all, Cogitations infinitely perfect, infinite Wif- dom, Power, and Goodnefs ; befides other Perfections, in which the Sovereign Power incomparably out-fhines all Nature. But you will fay, perhaps, (that I may not be in the leaft indulgent to my own Caufe,) that Cogitation, indeed, is not ma- nifeftly included and contained in the Con- ception of Matter, or of the Mafs of Bodies, but that, perhaps, 'tis fecretly or remotely contain'd, 2 6 A TREATISE concerning the contain'd, beyond our Capacity and Ken of Soul. To this I anfwer, that among all the Ideas of the human Soul, there is none which is either more prefent, or of which it has a clearer View, than the Idea of Mat- ter, or of an extended Subftance. We moft evidently conceive all its Dimenfions ; be- fides its Divisibility, Mobility, Figures, Por- tions, and Proportions. And the Sciences which treat of thefe Proprieties of Matter, are of all the moft evident, and the moft demonftrable. And when we can find no Connexion between Cogitation and any of thefe Proprieties of Matter, or any other Propriety of it, that falls within the Com- pafs of human Underftanding, it feems to be a groundlefs Sulpicion, and without the leaft Appearance of Truth, that this moft excel- lent Propriety, or Perfection of Matter, ac- cording to your Imagination, fhould be con- tain'd in the fame Idea, and yet fhould not fhine out in it ; and that we fhould not, with our utmoft Effort of Mind, be able to come at it there, or to derive it from thence. I say this moft excellent'Propriety of Mat- ter ; for the other Proprieties which I enume- rated are of lmall Moment, of little Dignity, if they are compared with Thought, and all the Perfections which flow from Thought ; thefe conftitute the divine Nature, and all that is noble and eminent in human Nature : The others have neither Life, nor Senfe, nor any Thing of the Force and Virtue of the great- eft State of Departed Souls, $sfc 27 eft of Beings. Thus that Idea which ap- pear 'd to us, of all Ideas, the moft entire and the moft accomplifh'd, viz. the Idea of Matter, or of corporeal Nature, is cut fhort by one Half, and that the more noble Half: God has concealed from us, to our great Dis- advantage, if not to our great Wrong, that which was moft noble and moft worthy to be known in the Nature and Notion of Bo- dies, by impofing this defective, and there- fore fallacious, Idea on us. But this is a Ca- lumny that has been invented againft God, and againft Men : Whatever is proper to Matter is included in its Idea ; and whate- ver is foreign to it, and of another Kind, as Thought, and the Power of thinking, that neither is, nor ought to be included in it, unlels you would include any Thing in any Thing, and entirely confound the Diftinclion of Things. But that we may proceed in our Argu- ment : The divine and corporeal Nature are fo far from agreeing, that they are repug- nant to each other, and contradictory. One is infinitely perfect, the other manifeftly and variouily imperfect, in itfelf enervate and impotent, and every Way obnoxious to fuf- fer from external Force : One of them al- way the lame, the other liable to perpetual Mutations : One of them fimple and uni- form ; the other, by various Modifications diverfify'd, and by Compolitions numberlefs. By which 'tis abundantly manifeft,, that there is 2 8 r A TREATISE concerning the is fo far from being any Connexion, Affini- ty, or Similitude, between divine and cor- poreal Nature, that there is an apparent Re- pugnancy, and that confequently God is in- corporeal. Now this Foundation being laid down, that I may come the nearer to what I pro- pofed, I alTert, in the. fecond Place, that be- sides God, there may be fomething incorpo- real in the Nature of Things. This, with- out Delay or Contention, is manifeftly de- duc'd from the Premifes ; for fince God is incorporeal, 'tis plain from thence that an incorporeal Nature implies no Contradic- tion, or that 'tis a poffible Nature. Now, to produce a poffible Thing, can never be impoffible : And when the fame God that is incorporeal is likewife omnipotent, 'tis in his Power really and actually to produce whatever is not impoffible. Thirdly, and laftly, we affirm, that the human Soul is of an incorporeal Nature, or that 'tis a Subftance incorporeal. I could here before this Propofition infert another, more general, and, as it were, intermediate, 'viz,, that 'tis not only poffible there mould be, but that there really and actually are, exifting in the Univerfe , incorporeal Subftances, befides God ; and then could have added, that fuch in its Kind is the hu- man Soul. But we will, if you pleafe, in this Chapter comprehend them both. Firft then, I aifert, that in the vail Compals of the State of Departed Souls, iffc. 29 the Univerfe, there are other incorporeal Subftances befides God. For nothing from the Thing itfelf, as has been made to appear, hinders the Sovereign and All-powerful Be- ing from creating thefe incorporeal Natures when he created the Univerfe, and without them the Workmanihip of it had been in a Manner imperfect, and maimed in its no- bleft Part. If any one mould build a mag- nificent Houfe ; and when he came to adorn and furnifh it, fhould fupply it with no coftly Furniture, but only with earthen or wooden Ware, or Utenfils of fome more ignoble Matter, to the Neglect of every fumptuous, every gallant Ornament ; you would be apt to fay, that Man, or that Mafter, was ei- ther dilbrder'd in his Underftanding, or ex- haufted by his Expence, or very miferably covetous. So if the Creator of all Things in compleating and adorning his Work, had omitted the moft excellent Ornaments, incor- poreal Natures, one would have been apt and ready to fay, that he had been either by Envy or Impotence deprived of the Will, or of the Ability to finifh and accomplifh his Work. How great and how frightful a Chafm had there been ? how vaft a Vacuity in the Nature of Things, if there had been nothing between the higheft and the loweft Nature, between God and Matter ? In that immenfe Interval, there is Room for num- berlefs Orders of Beings, and Beings of the nobleft Kind ; which, if God had either not created, jo A T R E AT I S E concerning the created, or had afterwards fupprefs^d, he had been neither mindful of his own Majefty, nor the Dignity of his Undertaking. Laft- ly, in the Nature of Things there are very many Phxnomenas, which can neither juftly be referred to Matter, nor immediately to God: Thefe Appearances require interme- diate Natures, and fecondary Caufes from God, fuperior to the utmoft Power of Mat- ter: But there is here no room to dwell any longer upon thefe. The Way being thus prepar'd, and, as it were, leveled, we come at length to the very Conclufion in which the Argument termi- nates, viz. that among thefe incorporeal Subftances the human Soul has a Place, or that 'tis one of their Number. The whole Point in Debate, it is plain, turns upon this, viz. to what Clafs and Order of Things, corporeal or incorporeal, the human Soul be- longs ? * But fince the EfTences of Things in a great meafure lie hid from us, and we have hardly * That this may more clearly and diftinctly appear, let us diligently examine, and, as it were, look into our- 1 s, that we may fee what we are. and what Value \ o 't to fet on ourfelves. Every Man is confcious of . nfelf and his own Exigence. If any one fhall happen to doubt of this, be mult be convinced by that very Doubt, nnd confefs that he txifts But what fort of Beings we are, who doubt, who will, who will not, who rejoice, who grieve, and who think, a thoufand different Ways; here, I fay, lies the great Queftion, what we are who acl, and who futfer thefe Things. In the firft Place, State of Departed Souls, is?c. 3 1 hardly any other Way to difcover the Diffe- rences between them, than by their Proprie- ties and their Effe&s, it will not be foreign to our Purpofe to compare, in the firft Place, the Qualities and Effects of each Nature, the corporeal and the incorporeal, or of our Souls and our Bodies; that. we may learn from thence, whether they are different, or are one and the fame ; and if they are diffe- rent, in what Manner they differ or are op- pos'd to each other. We Place, I perceive that I am a Being diftincTt from all o- ther Beings. Nor does any other feel the Grief or the Pain that 1 do, nor I what another feels ; and fo for Pleafure, and the reft of the Affections. Befides, I un- derstand either more or lefs than others ; and as every one has the Freedom of his own Will, I have that of mine. I am lick, am in Health, I hunger, I fleep, for my felf only; and laftly, I live, or I die formyfelf alone, Byreafun ofthisConcienfcioufnefscf Actions and Paf- fions proper and peculiar to me, and incommunicable to anyThing elfe, I call myfelf a certain Individual, di- vided and diftinct from every other Being; diftinct from God, as I am an imperfect Being, obnoxious to the Errors, both of my Underftanding and Will; diftinct: likewiie from every ether Being, when they neither per- ceive my Thoughts, nor Senfations, nor have 1 any Senfe of theirs. In the mean while, thofe Actions or Paffions, of which I alone am confeious, muft neceffa- rily belong to fome Subftance, as the Properties and Faculties of that Subftance: To God they cannot be- long, as we have fhewn above, and will be ftill more clear below; they muft belong then to fome created Subftance, corporeal or incorporeal. These Things being premis'd, you fee very clearly that the whole Point in Debate turns upon this, viz. to what Clafs of created Beings, corporeal or incorporeal, the human Soul belongs ? A TREATISE concerning the We have feen above, that Thought is not included in the Idea of corporeal Nature, or that on the other Side, any of the Pro- prieties of Body are included in Thought ; and therefore the Author of Nature has de- ceived us both Ways, if Thought belongs to Matter ; and therefore unlefs we pretend to understand beyond the Reach of our Facul- ties, or befide them, or againft them, no Motive or Handle can fpring from our Ideas that may occafion our uniting and confound- ing Thought with corporeal Nature. But you will fay, perhaps, that wefome- times learn thofe Things by Experience, which we could never have dedue'd from our Ideas alone. If we Ihould grant it, yet never has it been found by any Experience, that the Mind either acts or fuffers after the Man- ner of Matter ; or that Matter either acts or fuffers the fame Way that the Mind does, that is, by the Power and Force of its own Thought. We all know very well, that Matter either acts or fuffers by Motion, Touch, or Impulfe ; but never has it yet been made to appear, that the Mind either acts or fuffers by Touch, or by Impulfe, or by any of the Motions which they excite. For Example ; when I move by a voluntary Mo- tion either my Tongue or my Finger, or any other Part of my Body, I am confeious of no Impulfe, or any Manner of Stref what- ever made by my Mind upon that Part of the Body. There is, indeed, a Motion of the Spirits, State of Departed Souls, isfc: ?j Spirits, or of the thinner Juice, from which the Motion of that Part of the Body ulti- mately proceeds : But we are now inquiring into the rirft Original or Caufe of that Mo- tion of the Spirits in the Brain, as far as it lies in our Power, and after the Manner by which it proceeds immediately from the Mind, or from the Action of the Mind. But I affirm, that I am confcious of no Ac- tion of my Mind in the producing or effect- ing this Motion, but Volition, or the Com- mand of my Will. But that this Action, or Command of my Will, is perfbrm'd by Touch or Impulfe, or has its EfFeft by thofe, I am able to difcover by no Conicioufnefs, nor rind by any Experience. And as for the Paflions of the Mind, oc- cafion'd by the Body, and by corporeal OIj- jec~isj theie Objects as far as they are in the Soul, have no Refemblance or Relation to Local Motion, or to thofe Motions of the Body by which they are excited. For Example : The Heart is contracted in Grief and Sadnefs, and dilated in Mirth and Joy : But no Man can imagine that this Contrac- tion, or this Dilatation, can be in the Soul it- felf, as if the Soul of Man were mufcular, composed of Fibres and Tendons. For the Senfeof Grief, of which we are confcious, and which we clearly perceive, reprefents neither Local Motion to us, nor any Thing that is moveable, but is a lingular Idea, ha- D ving 34 'A TREATISE concerning the ving no Refemblance to any other, and leaft of all to Local Motion. And, laftly, in external Scnfations, in the Perception of Tafte, Smells and Sounds, that which we moft immediately feel, gives us no Image, either of Matter or Motion. And when we fee external Objects by Images painted in the Eye, thofe Images can never be carried with an equal Motion, and in the fame entire Figure to the Seat of the Soul in the Brain, or in whatever Part or Region the Soul has its Seat and Perception is per- form'd ; nor can they more^ when they are in c l)ifbrder and Con f upon ^ reprefent the Object {by their own Force) diftinBly to the Soul. But we ought leaft of all to fufc peel, that thefe Images, or Remnants of Images, are the very Thoughts themfelves that arife from them in the Soul. And the fame Account is to be given of thofe little Images, which we may call Memorial Marks, which are very imperfect, and therefore un- equal to their original Types. Laftly, if there are befides any other Thoughts, that may be rcferr'd to this Clals, you will find upon inquiring into them, that they include nothing extended, or figured, or corpo- real. Thus far have we treated of the firft Ope- ration of the human Soul, which is call'd iimple Apprehenfion, whether it be a pure and abftracled Idea, or join'd together with Motion in fome Part of the Body. But there State of Departed Souls, teV. 35 there is in us, befides Ideas or fimple Ap- prehenfions, fuperior and nobler Principles, or Faculties of the Soul, as Judgment, Reafon, and a Chain of Reafons linkM to one another ; and, laftly, there is a fovereign Principle that prefides over all thefe, and therefore is juftly call'd by the Greeks, To yye/ucovixov, c£ to otule^ovcriov. This lb vereign Principle has Dominion and Empire as well over the Operations of the Soul, as over the Motions of the Body : And all thefe are to be feparately weigh'd, when we fearch into the Nature of the Soul. Let us proceed then, if you pleafe, to a feparate Examination of each of them. The Ope- rations of the Soul then, as we faid above, following each other in due Order, are divi- ded into fimple Perceptions, into Judgments, into Ratiocinations, and, if you pleaie, into Methods, or into a Series of Thoughts that are marfhall'd in exad: Order ; for Method comprehends and diipofes of feveral Ratio- cinations. Ratiocination is employ 'd in the Connexion of feveral Judgments, Judgment in comparing and comprehending feveral Ideas, or feveral Senfations. Thus if you proceed in Order, the Ideas are the firft Ele- ments of Knowledge, and, as it were, the Letters of the Alphabet of which Words are compos'd, and of Words Sentences and Periods, and Difcourfe of Sentences : And thus the Scale of Thoughts anfwers, in fome Meafure, to the feveral Parts of Speech. D 2 We 36 A TREATISE concerning the We have laid enough concerning the Ideas. The Judgments and Ratiocinations follow, in which the Mind contemplates the Relations, Proportions, and mutual Regards of the Ideas ; for we ought to take notice of this, that the Ideas, confider'd feparately, are incapable of offering any Truth to us, and that they neither conclude, nor affirm, or deny any Thing. This is another Ac- tion, another Faculty of the Soul, which by contemplating the Proportions, Regards, and Refpects, that there is between thefe Ideas, (I here take Ideas in the largeft Senfe,) affirm or deny fomething concerning them, and confequently concerning the Things which they reprefent, as they accord or differ, im- ply or exclude, agree or are oppos'd to each other, and this according to their different Meafure and Degrees. Now fancy, if you pleafe, that the Ideas themfelves are corpo- real Motions ; what are thefe Relations be- tween the Ideas, thefe Concatenations and Dependencies ? But, laftly,what is this Judge, this Ruler of the Ideas, that examines as well the Ideas themfelves, as the Relations they have to each other ? compares them, weighs them, determines and reconciles them? and by comparing them, forms various Pro- pofitions, and Concatenations of Propor- tions? Lastly, do you believe that this Progreis that you make in thinking, from fimple Per- ception to Judgment, from Judgment to Ratio- State of Departed Souls, &c. 3 7 Ratiocination, and from thence to a well- order 'd Scries and Context of Arguments ? do you believe, I fay, that this Progrefs is made by the Impulfe of one Part of the Soul on another, or by any Succeffion of Motions, according to the Laws of Matter and Local Motion ? Molt certainly you do not believe it: Turn your Eyes inward, con- fult yourfelf, interrogate your Soul, that is Mafter and confcious of itfelf; ask it, if thefe Operations are nothing but corporeal Mutations, but Touches, Impulies, or Darn- ings againft other of corpufcularian Particles 3 and that they are produc'd one from the o- ther, according to the Laws of Local Mo- tion. Your Soul, unlefs it lies againft the Truth and itfclf, and is induftrious to de- prefs itfelf into an inferior Order of Things, which God did not ordain for it, but which yet it deferves, by reafon of the Wrong and Injuftice which it does to itfelf ; 1 fay, un- lefs it does that, it will ingenuouily confcfs, that it finds nothing at all of that in itfelf, nor is able to gather from any Indication, that thefe Operations are perform'd in it af- ter a corporeal Manner, by virtue of its own or of any other Body ; but that by a Power peculiar to itfelf, and according to the Laws of a thinking Nature, from the Contempla- tion of its Ideas, and the Relation between thofe Ideas, new Contemplations more com- pounded arife, as it were, fo many new Births, or new Conceptions, after them. D 3 To 3 8 A T R E AT I S E concerning the To confirm this Teftimony which the Soul gives concerning itfelf, provided it be frank and ingenuous, let us recollect a little what has been laid above : That Truth or Falihood, properly calPd fo, does not con- fin in the bare Ideas taken feparately from each other, but in the right Difpofition of fevcral Ideas among one another to their different Kinds, and their feveral Relations; for fo Proportions and Judgments are form'd in the Mind, from which Ratiocination is afterwards wrought ; and from them both, Difcourfe of whatever Nature, Oration, or DifTertation. From what has been faid, we form two Obfervations: The firftis, that the greateft Force of Mind that can poilibly be conceiv'd, is feen in its contemplating, dif- tinguifhing, determining the Relations that Things have to one another, or the Ideas of Things. As Argumentation turns upon thefe, or makes its Progrefs from one to an- other, according to their mutual Connexions or Relations, the whole Series, and Pro- grefs, and Concatenation of Thoughts de- pends intirely upon thefe. The Ideas of Things that fall under the Imagination, be- ing feparately taken from thefe, are like fo much Sand without Lime: The Things which cement them, are the forefaid Rela- tions perce'rod by the c Onderftandiug only. I fay, perceiv'd by the Underftanding only ; for the fecond Obfervation that we make is this, that the Relations of Things of this Nature State of Departed Souls, isfc, 29 Nature have no Images of themfelves in the Brain, no Marks in the Imagination; nor can they be reprefented by any corporeal Image, when they are without Parts, with- out Shape, and without Extenfion. How- ever, exprefs Subject, or the Words which we annex to our Idea, Termini Sub/ecJi, may be in ibme Meafure reprefented ; as for Ex- ample, a Triangle, or Quadrangle, or Ibme- -^ thing of that Nature. But the Companion or Proportion between thefe Termini j or the Parts of either of them, or between any other Things whatever j this is Ratiocina- tion refulting from divers Things compared with each other, which can be reprefented by no Lines, and which no Colours can paint. We may apply to this what the Pro- phet laid concerning the divine Nature ; To whom will ye liken Almighty God 2 or what ifa. x. 18. Likencfs will ye compare to him ? What Si- militude of his Likenefs, or what Effigies of abftract ed Proportions can you poffibly con- ceive could be drawn in the Brain, or in any other material Subitance whatever? Thus the Realbns of Truth and Falfhood, of Bafenefs and Worthinefs, of Pofiibility and Impoffibility, and of thole univerfal Notions which arife from the comparing feveral Things together • I fay, theie, and Ideas of this Nature, have not the leaft Trace or Fold, the leaft Shadow, or Form, or Figure, in the narrow or lmalleft Fibres of the Brain. But fo much for this Argument. D 4 Hitherto 40 ^ TREATISE concerning the Hitherto we have follow'd one only Thread of Difcourfe, viz. the gradual Pro- gress that the human Soul makes in its Ope- rations y in which, from fimple Perception it proceeds to Judgments and Arguments ; and from thence to a Series and Syitem of Thoughts in the Arts and Sciences, ranked in the molt, beautiful and the exa&eft Order, and to a long Range and Sequel of Propor- tions, as well for Contemplation as Practice, and the Government of human Affairs. How juitly are thcie Virtues and this Force admir'd in the human Soul, by which 'tis diftinguiih'd from the Machine of its Body, and from all material Subftance ? Let us now return to that other no lefs admirable Principle or Faculty which we mentioned above, by which the Soul is iikewife diC- tinguihYd from the Machine of its Body, and by which it vindicates its Empire over all the Motions of the other : This Principle we have call'd To dvre^yaiov ; the Latins call it Liber um Arbitrium, or the voluntary and fpontaneous Force of the Mind. In the firft Place, by the Force of this Principle we govern the Body, and command the Spirits which Way we pleafe, to move this or that, or any Part of it : By this Principle we re~ fift the- Propenfions of the Body, we con- troul its Appetites, and its Affections, and its external and internal Senfes, as often as 'tis our Pleafure. But State of Departed Souls, &c. 4 1 But, for God's fake, what ftrange kind of Thing is this that refills the Body, if we are nothing but Body? When a River runs either this Way, or that Way, can it by its own Force put a Stop to its Stream, and turn it a contrary Way. No Matter whatever ads againft itfelf, no Machine is confcious of its own Motions, or from that Confciouf- nefs a Corrector and Reformer of its Errors. If it err, as 'tis not confcious of it, it con- tinues to err, till the Hand of the Artift or Mafter being applied to it, 'tis brought into Order, and reftor'd to its right State. No Part of Matter, and no Machine, can imitate this reflexive Principle, if I may have Leave to ufe the Expreffion. This Force, that is a Reformer of itfelf, and that repents of itfelf, tranfcends all the Force, the Nerves and the Springs of thofe corpo- real Engines that appear to move of them- felves : And as it is lingular and peculiar to an intellectual Nature, fo 'tis in that Nature what is greateft and moft divine. I not only admire that perpetual Motion in the Mind of Man, by which it is rais'd above all Matter ; but there is fomething yet more fublime, which lords it over the Mind itfelf, as well as over the Body, that with fove- . reign Authority exacts an Account of ' all the Motions of each, and, as it were, an- other I, and a fupream Judge, firi&ly re- views the A&ions of both one and the other, 4* A TREATISE concerning the other, and corrects or confirms them at Plea- sure. * Now as to what relates to our Thoughts, and to the feveral Motions of our Minds, what we chiefly find by Experience is this, that the Mind, according to that Liberty and Domi- nion with which it was at firft created, applies itfelf to profecute whatever Thought it plea- fes, dwells on it a longer or a fhorterTime, de- ferts it, and turns itfelf to another, according to its lbvereign Pleafure. Befides, we are to obferve, that this avre^tov, in exercifing its lbvereign Power, either on the Body, or on the Soul, fometimes takes the Advice of Reafbn, and follows that for its Guide ; and fometimes, and that but too often, it takes a contrary Courfe, and then it loofes all Com- mand of itfelf, and often runs headlong up- on its own Deftruction. But when it calls in Reafon to its Afliftance, and choofes her for a Companion, then fhe is like the Deity, and *Tell me, I befeech yon, what is the Difference between Sleeping and Waking? When we dream, ibme Thoughts follow others fortuitoufly, according as the Phantoms offer themfelves, without the Government or Command of the Mind, whether they are aptly or abfurdly join'd. But when we areawake, there is fome- thing in us that corrects thcfe Thoughts, guides them, commands them, (lops them, and turns them which Way lbevcr it plcafes; and rejecting the abfurd, connects and compotes the red into a rational Scries. What is that fuperior Principle that prefides over all thefe Motions of the Body, and all thefe Thoughts of the Mind, and go- verns them at its Pleafure? This fuperior Principle, I call the high, the fovereign, and imperatorial Mind. State of Departed Souls, ©V. 43 and calls to a fevere Examination all the Errors of the Soul, the Errors of the Will, and thofe of the Senfes ; the Errors of the Imagination, and thole of the Paffions; nay, and the Errors even of Reafon itfelf. In this the divine Force of the Soul fhines out with the greater!: Glory. Indeed, in every Action, in every Paffion of the Soul, let it be ever ib weak, let it be ever fo abjecl:, as in Sen- fation, or in any Affection or Appetite, there is fbmething fuperior to all corporeal Force ; I mean that confcious, perceiving, and com- prehending Quality, which is every where prefent ; for which Matter can be never fuf- flcient, nor any Thing compofed of Matter. But when we afccnd by the forementioned Steps to the fupream Perfection of our Na- tures, then we are immcnfely diftant from Earth, and from earthly Things ; then we are rais'd to the very Heaven of Heavens, ten thoufand Degrees higher than any orga- nical or mechanical Engine could ever have the Force to carry us *. Lastly, * But let us proceed: In a thinking Nature two Things are join'd, which can never concur in a corpo- real Nature; for Example, Action, and the Unity of A£Hon. Our. Conception of Thought includes in it Ac- tion, and that the moft united Action : But Matter is either void of Action, as the more hard, ponderous, un- wieldy Bodies are ; or 'tis void of Unity, as fluid and vo- latile Matter, which confifts of numerous Particles, which are carried this Way and that Way, without Connexion pr Unity. 44 ^TREATISE concerning the Lastly, that I may wind up all this together, there is fomething within us that may be called an univerfal Percipient, or an univerfal confcious Principle, that runs through all the Operations of the Soul, and is difFufed through all its Actions and Paffions. Now I would fain know of you what this is : Is it fome Limb, fome Part or Particle of the Body ? It is one and the fame Thing that difcerns external Objects, that judges and reafons, that wills, refoives, underftands ; laftly, that receives all Im- preffions, and exerts or accompanies all Ac- tions. There is a Neceffity that this uni- verfal Perceiver mould be very fimple, and of an Unity inexpreffible, that it may be capable of receiving fb many Impreflions without Confufion, and of contemplating with one View fo many Reafons and Relations of Things. No Part or Portion of Matter feems to me to be capable of fb much Unity and Simplicity. Whatever is receiv'd, is receiv'd according to the Meafure of the Receiver ; and where there are feveral Parts or Particles in the Receiver, the Impreflion mult be confufed or diftra&ed. If the whole Impreflion falls upon the fame Point, there will be Confufion; if upon feveral, there will be Diffraction. In Matter there can be no one Part, that can perceive the Whole, or that can be confcious of the whole Impref. . fion, and the whole Object : But as in the perceiving external Obje&s, fo in the com- paring State of Departed Souls, fcfr. 45 paring and diftinguifhing them, there mull be fomething one, that comprehends the Reafons of them, and handles, or divides, or connects them, like lb many Threads ; and either lengthens them, or breaks them off, and in various Manners winds and works them together. And in all thefe Variations and Operations, befides the proper Force which is in each of the lingular Operations, there is a certain common Force which runs through them all, and is, as it were, the Soul of the Soul. And this univerfal Per- ceiver, or univerfal Confcious, mull not be only fomething one, but lomething moil perfectly one, and of the greateft Simplicity ; of fo great Unity and Simplicity, as was faid before, that can never be conceiv'd to be in any extended Subftance, divifible and compofed of Parts that are diftant from each other. Having thus difcu-fs'd thefe Things with ]; vid Su a r - all poffible Brevity, it appears clear to me, « X x X .%." on every Side, that our Souls are of a dif- <, * , 3»o*. ferent Nature from our Bodies, and luperior to all corporeal Force whatfoever. And this appears evident, whether we contemplate the Ideas of both Natures, or the Motions and Operations of the Soul, or that univer- fal Confeious, which is infeparable from the meaneft of them. Many other Argument?, and thofe unanfwerable ones, are us'd by learn'd Men to prove the Diftinction be- tween the Soul and the Body, and any par- ticular 46 A TREATISE concerning the ticular Part of the Body. Certainly, the Soul of every Man is ibmething permanent, and is, during Life, the fame numerical Be- ing. But no Part of the Body is, during Life, the fame numerical Thing ; but one Part flies fenlibly off, and a new one fuc- ceeds unconicious and ignorant of the Things which the other knew or a£ted. But there is no Occafion to dwell longer here upon this, when the Chriftian Inftitution hath in- ftru&ed us clearly and fully in the Do&rine of the Immortality of the Soul, and the Diftin&ion between that and the Body, as well in Creation, as in Death. Speaking of the Creation of Man, the facred Text diftin- guifhes between his Soul and his Body, when Gen. ii. 7. it tells us, that God form'd his Body of Earth, and then infus'd his Soul into it. Nor does it lefs upon the Death of a Man, when the compounded Being is diflblv'd, fend each Part of him feparately to its proper Origi- Eccl.xii.7. na l- Then /ball the 'Dujl return to Earth j as it was,, and the Sprit to God who gave Mat.x. 28. it. And Chrift has taught us, that we jhould not fear them who kill the Body, but are not able to kill the Soul : And he him- felf, being about to expire, recommended his Lukexxiii. Soul into the Hand of God, while his Body * 6 - hung upon the Crofs. Mat. xxii. Besides, Chrift has affirm'd, that the Souls 2 '- of Abraham, and of the Patriarchs are ftill alive, (or, at leaft, that they were at that Time.) And gives to pious, or penitent Souls, State of Departed Souls, fcV. 47 Souls, after they have put off their mortal Luke *v"- Body, a Seat in Paradife or in Abraham's "' Bofom ; but fent the Souls of wicked Men ^kexxiii. to Hell, or to Gehenna. Mofes and Elias appeared in the Transfiguration of Chrilt, /ohnxi.45; many Ages after they had departed this mor- tal Life. Chrift likewife call'd back depart- Mat.ix.2/. ed Souls to their Bodies, as often as it was his Pleafure, and refum'd his own Body af- ter it had been three Days buried, and as- cended into Heaven full of Life, and fur- rounded with Glory. Thus has Chrift tef- tify'd, by what he faid, by what he did, by what he fuffer'd, and every Way, that the Souls of Men are diftinguifh'd from their Bodies, and live after the others die. That the Dead are faid to fall afleep in the facred Writings,* is no folid Objection to the Immortality of the Soul ; for neither does the Soul perifh in Sleep, nor ceafe from all Kind of Adion ; but the Senfes being bound up, is not affected with the ex- ternal World ; which may very well be the Cafe in the State of Death, or in the fe- farate State, as it is wont to be call'd, when we live to God, and to the intellectual World, till we wake again in the Refurre&ion, and reluming * It appears clearly in the facred Writings, that the Dead enjoy a fort of Lire peculiar to them, or that the middle State between the Death and the Rcfurre&ion of the Body, is a State of Life, whatever that Lite is, 1 Tbef. v. 10. 4? A TREATISE concerning the refuming a vifible and corporeal Shape, re- new our Commerce with the external World, Rom.xiv. Chrift calling us back to it, who is Lord of 9 * the Living, and of the Dead. But we fhall have Occafion to treat of this Matter below. That we may finifh this Part of our Difcourfe, we are to obferve, that every Man oblerves the Diftinction between the Soul and the Body with Eafe, or with Diffi- culty, according to his Genius and hisExtent of Capacity. If any one could doubt, which, perhaps, fome People may, of the Exiftence of their own Bodies, and of all external Things ; that very Man, notwithstanding this, would be certain of the Exiftence of his own Soul. Which fufficiently difcovers the Body and the Soul to be two different Things, and that there is no fuch Thing as a neceffary Connexion between them. This doubting Man, I fay, would be cer- tain ftill of the Exiftence of his own Soul, from his very Incertitude and his Doubting ; for any fort of certain Operation, let it be what it will, neceffarily demonftrates the Exiftence of the Thing whofe Action or Operation it is. Nor can the moft obftinate Sceptick ever arrive at that Degree of Stu- pidity, as to deny or doubt of their own Exif- tence. Let them take away Motion from the Nature of Things, let them take away Hea- ven, and the Stars of Heaven, and all the fur- rounding Objects that ftrike our Senfes, nay, their State of Departed Souls, &ci 49 their own Bodies, if it be pofllble ; this thinking doubting Thing, which denies the Exiftence of all the reft, will ftili itlelf re- main ; nor can it confound itfelf with thofe of whofe Exiftence it doubts. Laftly, the Soul which after this Manner is diftinguifh- ed from its own, and from every other Bo- dy, is to be accounted an incorporeal Sub- ftance, as we faid at firft : Nor will it be duTolvedat the Diflblution of the Body, nor periih when that perifhes ; but, polTeiling the Life that is proper to it, it remains fur- viving and immortal, capable of enjoying eternal Felicity, or feeling everlafting Mi- fery. CHAP. III. What will be the future Condition of the Soul after the c Dijfolution of the Body ; or of the Middle State of Souls in the Interval between Tleath and the Re fur ~ reclion, as to the degrees of Happinefs orMifery. WHEN we have already proved, as well by Arguments drawn from Reaibn and Nature, as by the moft evi- dent Do&rines and Teftimonies of facred Authors, that human Souls furvive the Ex- tinction of their Bodies ; we are next to en- E quire* 5 o ^TREATISE concerning the quire, what Kind of Life they are like to enjoy, or in what State they fubfift after they are feparated from their Bodies. The Queftion that naturally offers itfelf firft, is, whether, after they are feparated from this Body, they are to inform another, of what kind ibever it is ? or whether they are to remain naked, disjoined, and abftra&ed from all Matter, even to the Refurre&ion ? The Solution of this Queftion would lead us di- rectly into the Knowledge of the future State of the Soul : But when there is another more general, and lefs obfcure, which in- quires into the Degrees of Happineis or Mifery before the Day of Judgment, I am inclin'd, firlt, to examine by Way of Intro- duction, the Opinions of certain Moderns, who carry the Souls of Men, juft after Death, immediately after they have left their Bodies, either direclly up to Heaven, to the Height of Glory and the beatifick Vifion ; or thruft them down into the Torments of Hell and unfpeakable Mifery. Either of which appears to me in its kind to be carried to too great an Extremity. There are feveral of the Proteftant Di- vines who will allow of no middle State of Souls, through anApprehenfion of Purgatory. Thus when we would avoid one bad Extream, fuch is the Folly of Mankind, we often run into another as vicious, and as blameable. 'Tis fumciently known, that the Papiftical - Purgatory is a human Invention,, adapted to the State of Departed Souls, Zsrc. 5 1 the Capacity of the People, and the Advan- tage of the Priefts ; nor will we, through Apprehenfion of this Fantom, defert the Do&rine of the Ancients concerning the im« perfect and unfiniuYd Happinefs or Mifery of human Souls before the Day of Judg- ment. But, as for what relates to the Mi- fery and Punifliments of the wicked, we mail at prefent pal's it by : It will be fufficient to mew at prefent, that the Opinion of thofe who tranilate the Souls of the departed Righ- teous to the Kingdom of Heaven, and that fupreme Glory, which is call'd the beatifick Vifion, before the Refurreclion of the Dead^ and the Coming of Chriff, is neither agree- able to the facred Writings, nor to the primi^ tive Faith of Chriftians. They who promife themfelves, or others, that they mail enjoy the beatifick Vifion immediately after their Deaths, ought in Reafbn to fhew us fome Promife in Scrip- ture that may fuftain fo great a Hope : For in thefe and the like Matters, which flow not immediately from the Nature of Things, but from the Will and the Appointment of God, a Hope that is founded on no divine Promife, is a temerarious Hope. Tell me then the facred, the infpir'd Authors, who are the Sureties and the Guarantees of fo great a Hope, and of fo fudden and fo vaft a Felicity. In thofe Paffages of the facred Writings, which allure us that we fhall one Day fee God, we are by no Means taught Ez that 52 A TREATISE concerning the that this mall be immediately after any one's Mat.v. 8. Death. We are rather told, on the contrary, l^"-" 8 - that this mail not be till Chrift {hall appear, nor fhall it be made manifeft to the Sons of Rom.viil' God > unlcfs in the Refurreftion. 19,2.3. Besides, according to the fame facred Col.111.4. Oracles, and the Apoftolical Writings^ the Saints are not to obtain their Glory and their lolemn Reward before the Coming of Chrift, and the Refurrection of the Dead. St/Peter Ep.v. 4. promiles a Crown of Glory to the faithful Shepherds of Chrift,when the Prince of Shep- herds fhall appear : Nor can I believe that the People will receive their Reward before their Pallor. St. 5P^«/, who in the Chriftian ^ m - Wt Warfare is fecond to none, tells us, that he is not to receive his Crown till the Day of the Coming of the Lord, the rightful Judge ; and that he is perfuaded that he fhall then at laft receive from God the Soul which he has committed to him, together with eternal zTim.i. Tife. / am perfuaded, fays he, that he I2 - is able to keep what I have committed un- to him againfl that ^Day : As if he was of Opinion, that the Time that interven'd be- tween the Day of Death, and that great Day, was to be efteem'd as nothing, being filent and inglorious; which that Holy A- poftle would never have thought, if, in the mean while, he had been confcious to himfelf, that in that Interval of Time we were to enjoy the Fulnefs of Glory, and the beatifick Vifion. Laftly, when he prays to God State of Departed Souls, isfc. 53 God to have Mercy on any one, when he promifes Joys, or threatens Revenge and Torments, the Apoftle to that Day is wont 2 Tim.i. to refer them all. And yet, if human Souls ,s - _. immediately after their Departure were ei- 7,8,9,1«. ther to be plung'd in unlpeakableTorments, or exalted to the Height of Glory, he ought to have referred both the Happinefs and the Mifery only to the Hour of Death* We are moreover to obferve, that where- as the Apoftle, like to one who is about to lie down, and to take his Reft, depofited his Soul into the Hands of God, to be kept by him to that great Day ; fo in the Style of the facred Writings, the Dead are laid to fleep, or to fall ajleepj and to waken at laft ' Cor.xv. on the Day of Judgment, and of the Refur- ']•* io ' rection. I know very well that thefe Things « Their, iv. are not to be underftood in altogether a li- I? ' 14 " teral Senfe, much lefs are they to be under- ftood fo grofly, as if the Soul after Death were void of Life and of Action ) for never can all the Power of thinking be driven from the Mind of Man ; yet, neverthelels, this Manner of fpeaking can never be ap- plicable to the Condition of thoie who are in PolTeilion of the beatifick Vifion, which both in Divinity and in Philofophy is ef- teem'd the molt Perfect Operation of the Soul, and for that Reafbn can never be com- pared to a Sleep, or a Dream, in which the Actions of the Soul are ib very far from Perfection. E 5 Both 54 A T R E AT I S E concerning the Both thefe Difcourfes of St. Taul to the Corinthians and Thejfalonians, concerning the Hope and State of the Dead, are cer- tainly worthy to be well confidered. He exhorts the Theffalouians not to grieve im- moderately, like Men that are without Hope, for thofe that are Dead, or that fleep in Jefus. But what Argument does he make life of to comfort them, and to repel their immoderate Grief ? Is it from this, that the Souls of the Righteous, as icon as ever they are freed from their Bodies, enter into Hea- ven, and partake of celeftial Glory ? This, indeed, had been the greateft Coniblation ima- ginable, and a moft prefent and effectual Remedy. But 'tis not from this Confidera- tion, nor from the Dead's immediate PofTef- lion of Happinefs, that he derives the Com- fort which he gives to the Living, and the Fomentation that he ufes to alfwage their Grief; but from the certain Hope of a blifsful Refurrc&ion, and of a future Return with Chrift in the glorious Day of his Coming. / I Thefr. \v. would not have you to be ignorant \, Brethren, ?*' ' 4 ' ' concerning them which are ajleepj that you forrow not even as others that have no Hope : For, if we believe that Jefus died and rofe again, even fo them which fleep in Jefus, will God bring with him. « Wherefore comfort one another with thefe Words. _. ~ . Moreover St. Taul, in another Difcourfe 30,51. :i. to the IfOrmthianSj Chap, xv. teems tq argue State of Departed Souls, i$c. 55 argue in fuch a Manner, as if our whole Hope depended on the Refurreclion, that the Life to come would not be worth look- ing after, unworthy the Labours that we undergo, and the Dangers that we pais through in ex peeling it, unlefs we were one Time to rife from the Grave. But now, if at the End of this prefent Life we are im- mediately tranfported to that bcatifick Glory, we mail then be happy, nay, unfpeakably happy, though no Refurre&ion mould fol- low. That divine Condition of the Soul would be the umpleft Reward for the rnofr. heroick Virtue, fince to dwell for ever in that celeftial Light would be fupream Feli- city. And yet the fame Apoftle, after the fame Manner, in the eighth Chapter to the Romans j comparing the Sufferings of this v. 18. 13. prefent Life, with the Glory that we fhall enjoy hereafter, takes no Notice of this im- mediate beatifick Vifion, but regards the Time of the Refurrection only, as if before the Arrival of that Day, the Saints would have no Reward ; for I reckon that the Suf- ferings of this prefent Time are not worthy to be compard with the Glory which (hall be revealed in us. But when is this Glory to be reveal'd in us ? Is it to be immediate- ly after Death ? No ; but when we wait for the Adoption, to wit, the Redemption of the Body, that is, at the Refurrection. And in the fecond Epiftle to the Corinthians j he— Wm E 4 fays 5 6 A TREATISE concerning the fays after the fame Manner • That our light Affliction; which is but for a Moment^ worketh for us a far more exceeding and eternal JVeight of Glory. For we know y i Their, v. that this Tabernacle being dijfolv^d: Well, »i what follows ? That we fhall ftrait afcend up to Heaven to the Enjoyment of the beatifick Vifion: No, I find nothing like it. Well then, what follows ? We have a Building of God, a Houfe not made with Hands eternal in the Heavens^ to wit, the celeftial Body, with which we fhall then be cloathed. You fee, therefore, that in the Chriitian Do&rine all Su?" Things are referr'd to this : Nor will it be Aa.iii.ip,eafy to find that there is any Retribution a °The(T. i. befides Peace and Reft, and Comfort of j. Mind, promis'd in the Gofpel, before either Apoc. xx. t | ie £ r fl. or t h e fecond Refurre&ion. I pass over, for the fake of Brevity, Tit. H. i2, other Paffages which relate to the Point in Coioff. iii. Queftion, which yet I earneftly advife you 3,4.. to weigh diligently. Let us now only 1 John iii. hearken to the Voice from Heaven, Blejfed Apoc. -xiv.are the 'Dead who die in the Lord. But s 3- why bleffed ? Is it becaufe they are imme- diately to enjoy the beatifick Vifion? I find nothing at all like this in the Prophet : What then do we find in him? For they %Cor.v.f. re f from their Labours ', and their Works i ? e , 18.' follow them j which at length will have their 1 Cor. 1.7. Reward. This is the eftabliftVd Order of Things ; this ? and no other, is the Beatitude that STATE of Departed Souls, ifc. 57 that we are to expect. We affert then, ac- cording to the Decrees of the Chriltian Re- ligion, that the Felicity of departed Saints will arife, either from the Hope of future Glory, or from Reft and internal Joy, till that happy Day fhall fhine forth, in which Chrift will raife them from the Dead, make them like to the Angels in Glory, and con- formable to himfelf. What we read further in the facred Story of the Dead recall'd to Life, and of the Seats and Receptacles ;of departed Souls, anfwers to this Explication. For can any one believe that Chrift tore Lazarus from the beatirick Viiion, and fore'd him to come back into this miferable Life ; or that Abra- ham's Bofom, into which we read that the other Lazarus was translated, was the fame Place with the Kingdom of Heaven, and the beatifick Vifion of God ; or that the Souls that cry from under the Altar, or that the Faithful, in their imperfect. State, , can bear the Splendor of celeftial Light, Heb. xi. ' and dwell in eternal Glory? If upon thefe 39. 4°- PaiTages we confult the Fathers, they will make quite other Anfwers. Laftly, when Chrift carried with him the Soul of the Thief into Paradife, he carried him not up to the Heaven of Heavens, the Seat of beatifick Vifion; for he afcended not thither himfelf, during the three Days of his Death \ nor do antient Authors, either Jews or Chrif- tians, 58 ^TREATISE concerning the tians* give that Interpretation to the Word Taradife. If we weigh all this with impartial Minds, and readily follow where the Light of the i'acred Wriings leads us ; if we turn not afide from this Path for any Caufe what- ever, nor take one Step beyond it, why then we muft fay, or rather repeat, Blejfed are the'Dead who die in the Lord y even at prefent blefTed, becaufe they enjoy Peace, and Reft, and Comfort ; and will be here- after tranfcendantly bleft, when, upon the fecond Coming of Chrift having put on their glorify 'd Bodies, they mail enjoy the ravifh- ing Sight of God in an inexpreffible Man- ner. Phil i ^ -^ OR * s lt an y ^ ^ 0bj e &i° n t0 tn i s our aCcr!v.3. Opinion, that St. 'Paul has, That if he dy'd, he jhould be prefent with Chrift and, as it were, at home with the Lord : For whatever Prefence you can fuppofe that the Apoftle means here, whether the vifible and corpo- real one, or the fpiritual and internal one, neither of them will at all weaken our Caufe. If the Apoftle means the corporeal Prefence, he means it from the Time of the Refurrec- rion, the Interval of Reft between Death and that being accounted as nothing : For Souls being feparated from their Bodies, and from * The Jews fuppofe the Happinefs of the Dead to be imperfect till the Day of Judgment. Vid. Pocock. No>- mfc. c. vi. p. 17$. State of Departed Souls, fcV. y^ from all Matter, cannot, during that State, have any corporeal or external Prefence with. Chrift : This is, from the very Nature of the Thing, impoffible. If, therefore, the Apoftle means this corporeal Prefence, the Time of Separation, or, that I may ufe his own Term, of Obdormition, is reckoned by him as nothing. But by reafon of the Cer- tainty of the Thing, and the infenfible De- lay, he joins the Refurrection immediately together with Death. And I am the lefs a- verfe to this Explication, when I obferve the Apoftle's Opinion, in feveral Places of his Epiftles, of the Approaching and fudden Coming of Chrift. Befides, in the firft Verfe of this Chapter to the Corinthians, he has join'd the Time of throwing off the terreftrial Body, with that of putting on the celeftial. one, making no Account of the Interval of Time between them : For we knoWj faith 2 Cor.v. r. he, that if our earthly Houfe of this Taber- Heb.ix.22, nacle were dijfolvedj we have a Building of God, an Houfe not made with Hands j eternal in the Heavens : Where he imme- diately joins the Diffolution of this mortal Body with the Alfumption of the other, though more than fifteen Centuries have paf- fed fince the Death of St. Taul, and he has not yet received his celeftial Body. But the imperceptible Time, in which no Alte- ration either happens, or can poffibly happen to the Matter depending, is to be looked on as nothing, Befide, the Apoftle has faid in that Chapter 6o A TREATISE concerning the — ver.4. Chapter to the Corinthians, that he would not be uncloathedy but cloathed upon, that is, that he would not be divefted of his pre- fent Body ; but here to the 'Philippians, he fays, that he dejires to depart, or to be dif- mifled from h:s Body. But this latter Say- ing is ib to be moderated and expounded, that it may not be repugnant or contradic- tory to the former. And if the Apoftle Eph.ii.6. uies this Phrafe, to be with the Lord, in the fame Senfe in thefe PafTages, that he has ufed i Theff. w. them in others ; and fo we (hall be always Evh.w.io.frffevt with the Lord, we muft necelfarily conclude, that the fame Time, and the fame State of the Refurre&ion is to be underftood in both*. Laftly, we muft obferve from the Nature of the Thing, that Chrift has already afcended above the higheft Heavens, cloathed with his glorious Body ; and that the Saints cannot poflibly afcend thither, or inhabit there, till they have likewife put on their celeftial Bodies ; which being grant- ed to none before the Refurrection, unlefs to thofe who are rapt up to Heaven like Enoch j neither the Reafon of the Thing, nor eftablifh'd Order, nor divine Difpenfa- tion, will allow us to expound thefe Say- ings of the Apoftle, as meant of the local and corporeal Prefence. There- * 'lis certain that when Chrift was about to afcend into H.aven, he did not promife his Difciples that he would receive them to himlelt before his Return to the Earth. State of Departed Souls, Isfc. 61 Therefore if you had rather undcrftand here the fpiritual and internal Preience of Chrift, I am not againft it. The Saints even in this Life are in this Manner prefent with Chrift, and will be prefent with him in the Life to come after feveral Manners : By all which, according to this Interpretation, the Souls of the Righteous may be faid to be prefent with Chrift after his Death. Firft, they may be faid to be with Chrift, as they will be under the Guardianfhip and Protec- tion of Chrift ; for Chrift being now about to expire, recommended his Soul into the Hands of his Father, that is, into the Cut- Luc.xxiil tody and Protection of his Father. But when + * Chrift by dying had conquered Death, and . fo was become the Lord both of Life, and of Death, St. Stephen expiring, depofited his Soul into the Hands of Chrift, who dy- ing, cry'd out, Lord Jefus receive my Spl- A€tMlf$. rit. After the lame Manner the Soul of St. Paul would be with Chrift, depofited with him, and in his Protection to the Day of the Refurrection. Again, the Souls of the Saints are faid to be with Chrift af- ter his Death, by Reafon of the internal Confolation and Joy which they receive from Chrift : For fince Chrift came into theWorld and became victorious over Death, I make no doubt but he has made a great Acceilion to the Comfort and the Felicity of thole who are dead in him, as well from the Influx of divine Virtue, as from the molt certain Hope, and, 6z J TREATISE concerning the and, as it were, the ravifhing Profpect ef a glorious Refurrc&ion : And, therefore, *in the Interval between Death and the Refur- reclion, 'tis rightly faid, that Chrift is with us, and that wc are living, and prefent with him. Laftly, in this Manner of fpeaking, there is a Regard to be had to the Oppofi- tion, as is evident from both the PafTages to the 'Plrilippians and Corinthians, To be with Chrift, and to be in this World, are each oppofed to the other : When we go out of the World, we are not extinguifhed, we are not abolimed, we arc not reduced to no- thing. Where are we then ? We are with God, we are with Chrift ; we live to God, Luc.xx.38. we are prefent with Chrift, who will bring £°J ■/"• us back to the Stage of the World, full of Life and Spirit. We have no Reafon to wonder then that St. Taul fhould fay, T>eath is gain to me : We ought rather to wonder that fo great an Apoftle fhould fay fo very little. He who aCor.xi. in this Life had gone through fb many Ca- lamities and Difquiets, fo many Fatigues, and fo many Dangers \ who had endured Hunger, and Thirft, and Cold, and Naked- nefs, and Stripes, and Beatings, Imprifon- ments, and Stoning, and Shipwreck ; all Kinds of Evils, all Kinds of Hardfhips both by Sea and by Land ; that he fhould pro- nounce Death more defirable than this pre- fent Life, is not at all to be wondered at : If Death were nothing but Reft, and a Truce from State of Departed Souls, &c. 6$ from the Evils and Calamities of this pre- fent World, it would ftill be preferable to Life. Let us then, that are fuch little and wretched Creatures, learn from hence to think more modeftly of ourfelves, and the Rewards which we merit, and not to promife ourfelves and others the Enjoyment of the beatifick Vifion, as foon as ever our Eyes are ihut ; when the great Apoftle of the Gen- tiles, who, if ever any Man deferved highly of the Chriftian Religion, certainly it was he, feems to promife himfelf nothing fo great and fo deferable. Let us be contented in that middle World, if I may have leave to call it fo, with far lefs Enjoyments; yet, let us not think it a fmall Thing, that the Soul being confcious to itfelf of its Immortality, and breathing forth nothing but Love di- vine, mould acquiefce in God and itfelf, ha- ving at the fame Time a joyful and lively Hope of the Coming of Chrift, and the Glory which it is to partake with him. Lastly, that I may add this Reflection to the reft, they feem to me to weaken the Force of the Chriftian Do&rine concerning the Reiurrection, and to render the Refur- re&ion itfelf, as it were, of no Significance, who allow that Sou Is enjoy the beatirick Vifion, and a State of Glory immediately after De?;th : For what Occafion have Souls for a Body that are already eftabliihed, and have their Dwel- ling in the Refulgency of Light divine ? You /will fay, perhaps, that the Body may par- ticipate 6 4 A TREATISE concerning the ticipateof the Glory and the Reward, as it was formerly a Partaker of the Calamities which the Soul endured in this Life, or of the good Works which it wrought. You trifle with me : The Soul of every Man is the Man ; N«? lthe Foundation of the World ; yet have they an hereditary and indefeaiible Right to it ; and, therefore, they may be faid, by an eafy Anticipation, to poifefs it al- ready. We are all of us in hafte to take PofTeflion of our Inheritance, and we are carried by a natural Impetuolity to the En- joyment of that Glory and that Felicity which we fo impatiently defire. Many of the firft Chriftians believ'd that the Corning of Chrift was even then approaching, as 'tis moft evident to me from the Apoftolical Epiftles, and from the ancient Fathers ; and thofe firft Chriftians, ftrengthen'd and ani- mated by that Belief, bore Perfecution and painful Deaths, with the more undaunted Spirit. But the Courfe of Years having naturally detected this Error, let us not, I befeech you, fall into another; nor appear endeavouring to pull down the unwilling Heavens to us, and ftepping over the Order o9 the Promotion of the Juft, as Iren£us *pcpreiTes it, feem rather to invade thofe ^ lb,v - * F 2 Heavens J 62 ^TREATISE concerning the Heavens, than to receive them as our In- heritance. At length the Evening of the World is come, Chrift is at hand, and even at our Doors ; we, therefore, want no Con- folation but this : Behold 1 come quickly, and bring my Reward along with me, that I may render to every one according to his Works. Amen j even fo, Lord Jefus, come. O *Deathj where is thy Sting ? O Grave, where is thy Victory ? Thus far we are inftrucled by the facred Writings concerning the State of the Dead. Befides, in Matters of Controverfy, to en- quire into the Belief of primaeval and un- corrupted Antiquity, us'd to be of no incon- fiderable Weight with moft People : For, though we attribute Infallibility to no Mor- tals in any Age whatever, the Apoftles alone excepted, neither to the firft Ages of ChriC. tianity, nor to the Middle, nor to the Mo- dern j yet, when as yet the Chriltian Re- ligion was neither degenerated into Artifice, nor grown up to Empire, Chriftians with more Simplicity and Sincerity follow'd the naked Truth. It will, therefore, be worth our while, briefly to enquire what was the Opinion of the ancient Chriftians concerning the immediate Beatitude of the Saints ; or concerning the State in which they who de- part this Life are, before the Time of the Refurre&ion. The nearer that Rivers are to their Foun- tains, the more pure and unfoil'd are the^ wont State of Departed Souls, &c. 69 wont to be ; and the nearer the Chriftian Fa- thers come to the Apoftles, or the Apofto- lick Times, the more appro v'd and more un- exceptionable Witneifes of orthodox Faith are they efleem'd to be. And, therefore, thouph I make no doubt but that the Greek Fathers, generally ipeaking, were of our Side in the preient Caufe, it will be fuffi- cient in this Chaprer to enquire into the three rTrft Ages of the Church, in which, if I am not miftaken, you will find neither Greek nor Latiiij unlefs the Hereticks, and, per- haps, St. Cyprian only, who transferred the Souls of the Dead, as fbon as ever they had left their Bodies, to the Enjoyment of the beatifick Villon, and the Poifeilion of celef- tial Glory ; I mean, after the fame Man- ner, that in thefe latter Ages it has been decreed by the RomijJj Church. That this was the Opinion of numerous Hereticks in the firft Ages of the Church, who at the fame Time deny'd the Refur- rection of the Body, is apparent from Juf- tin Martyr j IrenaitSj Tertullian, and ieve- ral others. J u ft in Martyr has thefe Words in the Dialogue with Tryphon : " Never M " believe that thofe can be Christians who u deny the Refurrection of the Body, and " affirm that their Souls, as foon as ever cc they die, are carried up into Heaven. " Obferve how thefe two are join'd together /fry J u ft* n -> as if there were fome Relation between them 3 at leaft, the fame Hereticks F 3 • who 7o A TREATISE concerning the who deny'd the Refurre&ion of the Body, transferred their Souls to the Heaven of Heavens, as foon as ever they had left their Bodies. There is a PalTage in Irenaus which gives Light to this of St. J-ujlin : for the former, in the thirty firft Chapter of his fifth Book, attributes at once both Errors to the Hereticks of that Age. " But be- a caufe, fays he? fbme of thofe who are be- / State of Departed Souls, isfc. 7$ And he proves this by the Authority of St. Taulj the 'great Inftrudtor of the Gen- tiles ■, in the nth Chapter to the Hebrews j and adds, " You fee, therefore, that Abra- " ham Hill waits, expecting- to obtain " Perfection : Ifaac and Jacob exped the " fame Thing, and all the awful Society of " the Prophets expects us, that, together " with us, they may receive complete Fe- « licity." Towards the End of the third Century, Vifiorinus the Martyr and Laft ant tus liv'd, who were both Maintainers of our Caufe. The Words of Lafiantius, in the feventh Book of his Inftitutions are known : " Nor let any one believe that the Souls of Sed.xxi. " the Dead lhall immediately be brought to " Judgment : For all of them are detained a in one common Cuftody, till the Time il ihall come when the Sovereign Judge of " the World lhall examine all their Merits ; " then they whofe Righteouiheis fhall be u approved of, ihall receive the Reward of a iC blifsfui Immortality. " In like Manner ViEiorinus, upon Revel, vi. 9. concern- ing the Souls that are under the Altar, af- ter he had obferved t/hat the external Altar, not the internal, thit is Heaven, was "to be underftoodThere, there 'tis his Opinion, that the Souls mull attend till the Coming of the Laft Day, the Day of the Diftribution of Rewards and Punifhments. " But be- C J caufe, fays be,, in that laft Time the Saints " will u cc 76 A TREATISE concerning the will find a perpetual Recompence, and the Wicked perpetual Damnation, therefore u they are commanded to Wait ; and for IC their bodily Comfort, they have received, cc fays he j white Garments, that is, the " Gift of the Holy Choir." Besides, when ieveral of the moffc an- tient Fathers, if not, indeed, all of them, were of Opinion that the Souls of Men, af- ter their Deaths, defcended to Hades, they declared by that, that it was their Opinion, that they were not immediately to be car- ried up to the Heaven of Heavens, and to the Enjoyment of fupreme Glory : For though Hades, with relation to feparate Souls, as well the Juft as Unjuft, is of a large Signification, yet none of them ever faid that any of the Souls that defcended thither, enjoy'd the beatifick Vifion there. Since then the antient Fathers placed all the Souls that had left their Bodies there, they by that exclude them a)l, as long as they re- main there, from the Felicity of that glori- ous Vifion. We have now done with Jvf- thtj Irenausj and 'Tertullian, having fhewn that from the Defccnt of Chrift to Hades, they proved that all the Souls of Men muft defcend thither, Jince the Ttifcipkj fay they, is not above his Mafter. And from this ve- ry Argument reverted, Macarins, Bifnop of Gelaf.Cy- Jerufalem, explaining the Incarnation of zin - a - . Chrift to aPhilofopher in the Nicene Coun-fc i C °?c.^'. C 'cil 3 ftiews, that he defcended to Hades, that^ he State of Departed Souls, $?fc. 77 he might be in all Things like unto us. As we were all of us carried after Tieath to Hades, he accepted of this Condition _, and voluntarily zveut to the fame Place. From whence he fays, that he made the fame Re- furre&ion from Death that we did. And he afterwards adds to this, and the other Things that are mentioned in the fame Chapter, viz. This is the apoftolical and unblameable Faith of the Church. And what Euftathius the Patriarch of Antioch, fays in Theodoretj up- on that Paffage of the Pialmift, Thou wilt In Dia j - u not leave my Soul in Hades, has a Relation to this, where he calls Hades the Place that was the Receptacle of human Souls, and where he proves that the Soul of Chrilr. was truly a human Soul, becaufe that, as well in this Life, as in the other, it underwent the common Fate of Humanity : But the Soul^^ll of befits had a Tryal of both States : For ad Phot. he was in the 7 lace of human Souls, a?id being without Flejh lived and exijledj, his rati'.nal ("'Part) Soulj being like to the Souls of Men. Laftly, in the old Fragment con- cerning the Caiife of all Things, whether the Author of it be Cuius, or lome other very antient Chriftian, 'tis more than once afferted, that the Souls both of the Righteous and of the Wicked are retained in Hades. Thus he begins : And this is the 'Dfcourfe concern- ing the Angels ; but of Hades j in which the Spirits of the Juft and Unjuft are detain V, it is necejfary to /peak. And thus he after- wards 78 ^TREATISE concerning the wards diftinguifhes their feveral Manfions : Thejufljindeedj are now detain' din Hades _, but not in the fame Tlace where the iJnjujl are ; for there is one Entrance to this 'Placej of which the Gate, SCc. where he places An- gels as fo many Guards, who feparate the Souls as they enter, and either fend or conduct them feverally to the Seat they deferve, to the Region that is fitting for them, to the Place that is due to them. Laftly, he affirms, that they remain there till the Time of the Refurrection. This is the ^Difcourfe concerning Hades ^ in which the Souls of Men are retained till the Time preordained by Godj who when that comes j will raife them up all together. Thus have we thefe Authors,who lived be- fore the End of the third Century, as Wit- nefTes of the primitive Doctrine of the Church concerning the Souls in Hades : To which we may add two Cafarean Bifhops, I believe of a later, but of a very uncertain Age : I mean Andrew, and Arathas, who from the Commentaries of Andrew upon the Revela- tions, colleded thofe which he purloin'd himfelf. And thus they both of them write. 'Death is the Separation of the Soul and the Body ; but Hades is the Country to us in- vifible, that flies from our Enquiry > and hides it fe If from our Knowledge, and that receives our Souls as foon as they depart from our Bodies. Laftly, the forementioned \^ Bilhops, concerning the Souls that cry from under State cf Departed Souls, isfc. 79 under the Altar in the fixth Chapter of the Revelations j confirm the fame Things, and are utterly and entirely averfe to the Ro- mifo Opinion concerning the beatifick Vi- fion, as appears by the following PaiTage. "*Tis for this Re a fin that the Saints are feen to dejire with Impatience the Con/urn- mation of the World, becaufe they are com- manded to wait till then, and to bear the Delay till the "Death of all their Brethren, that they may not., according to the divine Apoflle, be made perfect before them. In the mean Time the white Garments, which they have on j intimate the Splendor of thofe Virtues, which in them fljine fo ilhtf- trwujly y with which being furrounded^ though they have not as yet obtained the 'Per- formance of the Promifes,yet the very Hope of that Happinefs j which they view with afpiritual Eye, caufes them juftly to rejoice-, especially fince, in the mean Timej they are freed from the Defilement of Matter, and in the Bofom of 'Abraham, free from allDiftur- bance, take their p leafing and their lafting Rep oft : For many of the Saints are of Opi- nion, that every one who in his Life -time has endeavoured with all his Power to im- prove himfelf in Virtue, foall find after Death a Place that is worthy of his Ac- tions ; from whence they may make a certain Conjetlure at the Glory that is prepared /or them. And thus much concerning Hades, according to what the moll: antient Authors have So A TREATISE concerning the have faid of it, which they agreed to be the common Receptacle of departed Souls, even till the Refurre&ion. Lastly, to confirm the Truth of every Thing that has been faid, 'tis worth our while to coniider with what Modeftv, with what Moderation, the blelTed Martyr Poly- carpe, Clemens RomanuSj and Ignatius, have fpoke of the Refidence and the State of the Saints, from the Time of their Death to the Time of their Refurrection. They af- fert not, that they are immediately received into the higheif. Heaven, to the Enjoyment in Epift. of tne beatifick Villon ; but, fays Polycarpe y fua ad Phil. ^- ro7r ov civtoTs o^eiKofjLivov^ to a Place appoint- ed for them, their own Place that is due to them j, or that is proper for them y or *■ m rw ayiov roirov, into a holy Station 3 as Cle- mens Rom anus faid of St. 'Paul, y T ws oLttyiX- KcLyi) Ttf %oajj,a, xco rev ea ocyion T07rov t7ropevSrn 9 fo he left the World and went to a facred Art.li. Place. He afterwards calls that %Mpca> htre- £&>j', the Place of the Righteous, in the fame Epiflle. But that Paifage principally de- ferves our Confideration, where he fays, that all from Adam to this Day, who have died perfected in Charity and Virtue, reft in the Regions of the Good, as in their proper Re- politories, * They were not receiv'd up into Heaven or Glory* but into a Place that was due to them, fays Clemens, ,j Ejp. c. v. Le Clerc quotes him on Matt. xvii. 18. State of Departed Souls, &c 81 pofitories, ^till on the Coming of Chrift at the Day of the Refurreclion, they fhall be brought forth into open Light. All the Ages of the World, from Adam even unto this 'Day, are faffed away : But they who have been made perfefl in Love, have by the Grace of God, obtain d a P Hace among the Righteous ; and fhall be made manifefi in the Judgment of the Kingdom of Chrift. For it is written, Enter into thy Chambers ifa.xxvi.io; for a little Space, till my Anger and Indig- nation fhall pais away : And I will remem- ber the good Day, and will raife you up out of your Graves. All thefe Things agree exactly with the Opinion I am contending for : And the fame PlaGe that Juft'tn calls %£>pctv htreCwv, the 'Place of the Righteous, Clemens terms, %u>pov x,p&TiovcLxAticriv y a LuexvU Comfort only, and not a fupreme Glory j which *;-. G in 82 A TREATISE concerning the in other Places of Scripture is call'd Repofe and Relaxation, and is compared to a plea- ling Slumber. Behold here the Style of the holy Spirit, and of the apoitolick Writers ! Behold, on the other Side, the Style of the Romiffj Church 1 that tells us that the Souls of Saints, after they leave the Body, are im- mediately taken up into Heaven, and there clearly lee God, as he is in Trinity and in Unity ! Good God ! from whence have they taken this Doctrine ? from what Book of the facred Scriptures ? or from what Re- mains of the primitive Church ? When Chriil was about to die, he faid to his Dif- ciples, / qo to prepare a *Place for you ; John xiv. * j -l t + / / en/ r J T I* and if 1 go to prepare a Flace for you., I will return, and take you to myfelf that where I am, there ye may alfo be. You fee, therefore, that this glorious Place, this Place prepared for them by Chrift, is not to be po£ felled before the Coming of Chrift ; and that then, at laft, according to his Prayer to the John xvii. Father, the Saints mall dwell together with J£ xvii Chrift, and mail behold his Glory. I [hall be fatisfy'dj O Lord_, when I awake ., with the Sight of thy Countenance. Besides, it is agreeable neither to Scrip- ture, nor to the Light of Nature, either to exact extreme Puniihments, or to expect fu- preme Rewards, before the Matter is brought to Judgment, and the Merits of the Caufe are known. But the Scripture makes Men- tion of no Judgment before the End of the World. State of Departed Souls, tsrc. 83 World. That is the T>ay in which God ' A &- xvii. will judge the fVorld by Chrift. Then atfc^.a laft, Every one's Work fjjall be tried. Then, »?- 14« l f< Every one ^9 all receive according to what * Cor ' v * he has done in the Body. Then, The Thrones Apoc.xx. will be placed, then the Books will be operid, ' '• l2 ' I3 ' and every Man will be judged according to his Works. Then the Juft will be feparated from the Unjuft, the Sheep from the Goats ; thofe being placed on the Right, and thefe on the Left, and both of them receive their Sentence. All this we have been taught by the Mouth of Chrift himfelf : But when the , r!j *# *+• ... Glory, that they fpeak of only as an incon- ,s, a j. fiderable Over- weight ; and what St. JPe- 2 Co y ]V - ter calls a Crown of Glory, that will never V cr. 1.'" wither, never decay, of that they are pleas 'd ,Pct - v -f to make not the greateft or the principal Part, but a little Addition of Glory. Laftly, Chrift himfelf teaches us, that the Redemp- tion of the Saints will not draw near, and is not to be expected before the End of the Luke xvi. World : Nor does he promife any Retribu- 2S - tion before the Refurre&ion of the Juft. So ' '*' great is the Diftance in this Matter, between the Dodhine of the Gofpel, and the Decrees of the Romiih Church. Thus, what the Apoftles, what the bleiTed Martyrs, what the antient Fathers of the Church, all of G 4r them gg A TREATISE concerning the them accounted the greateft Promife of the Gofpel, the very Foundation of the Chrif- tian Faith, and the chief Anchor of our Hope, that, by their Decrees, becomes only a Thing not utterly vain, unufeful, and fu- perfluous. What Occafion is there for more ? Chrift purchafed this Return of Life for us, this Renovation of Hope, at no lefs a Price than tf . ' ' ' that of his own ineftimable Blood, and con- a Tim. i. firm'd it by his own Refurrection. And i Pet. i. 3. whatever does not rile again, he accounts as & . 2I \ loft in that facred Difcourfe, as afterwards 39, &c. St. c Paul did in his Difcourfe to the Corin- thians, upon the fame Argument. This is the Myftery full of Wonder, the Work of divine Virtue, our Victory and our Triumph by his Death derived to us: This is the Ne- Phil.iii 10. plus -ultra of our Perfection, towards which we all ftrenuoufly tend, to which we all afpire. Nor can the moil ambitious of our Defires foar to a greater Height, nor wifh for a farther Progreis. Then we fhall be like to the blelTed Angels, cloathed with that glorious Light which they are cloathed, and perpetually beholding the fame God, which they perpetually behold. From what we have hitherto faid, it ap- pears to me to be manifeft, as well from the iacred Writings, as from the Teftimonies of the molt antient Fathers, that the Beatitude of the Saints depends folely or chiefly upon the Refurrection ; and that that Height of Per- STaTe of Departed Souls, &c. 89 Perfection, that Height of Felicity, and of Glory, which is commonly known by the Name of the beatifick Vifion, is not imparted to human Souls before the Day of Judg- ment, and the Coming of our Lord. But yet if this Caufe were to be determined by the Number of Witnefles, it would be eafy to add to thefe Fathers of the firft Ages, thofe of the Fourth, and afterwards thofe of lower Centuries. But the Force of the fa- cred Writings which alone is fufficient, would be but obfcur'd and hid by too great an At- tendance. And therefore I fhall feparate- ly, by Way of Appendix, mark feveral of the more manifeft PafTages relating to the fame Argument, from the Authors of the following Age, which every one may either confult or omit, according to his Leifure or to his Inclination. AT

ay foould come of Refurreclion and Recommence. St. Chryfoftome thought fo highly of the Refurreclion, that without that he entertain- ed but a mean Opinion of the Immortality of the Soul, and reckons all the Advantages that the Saints poiTeffed before that, but as a very inconfiderable Part of their Recom- pence and Felicity. Be pleafed to confult him upon the fifteenth Chapter of the firft Epiftle to the Corinthians, where upon thefe Words of St. Paul, If our Hope was only in this Life, we were of all Men the moft miferable, he fays thus : What is it that the Apoftle fays ? Why, tinlefs the Body rifts again, have we only Hope in this Life, not- withftanding that the Soul remains, and re- mains immortal? And thus he anfwers him- felf : Though the Soul remains, and were yet a thoufand Times, if it were poffible, more immortal than it is ; yet never could it without the Body receive thofe ineffable Advantages : And, therefore, the Soul be- fore the Body rifes, can neither be punijhed nor rewarded : For all Things will be laid open State of Departed Souls, ifc. 91 open before the Tribunal of Chrift, that every one may receive in his Body the Re- commence of the Things "which he did in his Body ^ "whether they are good, or whether they are evil. And therefore, fays the Apoftle, if in this Life only we had Hope in Chrift, we were of all Men the moft miferable. For utile Js the Body rifes again, the Soul remains without its Recommence, and without that fupreme Felicity which is enjoy 'd above in the Heavens. And thus St. Chryfoftome exprefTes his Opinion clearly, and by Examples and Si- militudes confirms it in other Places, viz. upon that Saying of the Apoftle to the He- brews, Chap. xi. 40. Thefe have not re- ceived their Reward, that without us they might not be made perfect» The Words of St. Chryfoftome are as follow : JVhat ! have not they received their Reward, but are ftill kept in Expectation ? What ! have not they yet received their Reward, who died as they did, in fo much Tribulation, in fb much Affliction ? Have fo many Ages faf- fed fine 'e they conquered, and have they yet not triumphed ? And do you impatiently brook Delay s, though your Contention is not over ? ^Do you confider of what vaft Impor- tance it is, that Abraham and St. Paul have not yet received their Reward, but wait till you [hall be made perfect , that they may receive it together with you ? He afterwards proceeds in working up the fame Argument, and S>z A TREATISE concerning the and declares, that Abel the Protomartyr, and Noah the Preacher of Righteoufnefs, both to the Antediluvian World and ours, will not be crown M before we are : For he has appoint- ed one and the fame Time for all to receive their Crowns. Till that Time, he fometimes names for Seats to the Souls of the Righteous, lepd irpoSrupcty the holy Gate,, but oftener the Bolbm of Abraham. See at your Leifure his twenty- fourth Homily upon the fir ft Epiftle to the Corinthians, and the fortieth Homily upon Genefis ; where he fays, that it is the principal Ambition, and the only Wifh of all the Righteous, from the Times of Abra- ham to the End of the World, that in his Bofom they may find Reft to their Souls. But by the Bofom of Abraham, as you know very well, is not meant fupreme Glory, or the Felicity that the Angels en- joy in Heaven. Laftly, all thefe Things are confirmed in St. Qhryfoftomeh nrft Ser- mon concerning the Refurrection ; where he refers all our Hope, and all the Retribution which we expect, to the Day of the Coming of our Lord : Nor does he give us the leaft Ground to believe, that before that Day we fhall find any Reward, except that which arifes in this Life, from our very Contention for Victory, and from the exer- cifing ourfelves in Virtue, and in Chriltian Conftancy, by which the Soul acquires more Fortitude, and, that I may ufe his own Expreffion, a more philofbphical Temper : For State of Departed Souls, istc. 93 For as Wre filers, fays he, by contending for Vicfory become more nervous ■_, and more ro~ buft y fo from our Contention in Virtue _, we {hall reap this great Reward % that our Souls will become more firm and philofophi- cal, even before the Heavens are open'd to us, before the Coming of the Son of God, and before we receive the Recommence which we contend for. These Paflages have we quoted from St. Chryfoftome, concerning the State and Felicity of the Saints before the Refurrec- tion. But you will fay, perhaps, that fome- times the fame Father fpoke more freely and more fublimely of this intermediate Fe- licity. That, indeed, may very well be ; for Orators, fbmetimes, when they come to conclude, are apt to grow fbmething warm, nor fcrupuloufly weigh in the Balance every Word that proceeds from them ; and when they are endeavouring to give Ornament to popular Harangues, or to funeral Orations, there are feveral Reafbns which in their Conclufion may incite them to exaggerate the Felicity of thofe who are dead in the Lord, but not one that may incline them to diminifh it, except their Conicioufnefs of the Truth alone. This Method might be of great Advantage to comfort, and exalt, and raife up the Soul againft the Influence and Power of Death, efpecially the Death of Martyrdom. To fpeak warmly and freely of the Happinefs that the Saints are to enjoy im- mediately 94 -A- TREATISE concerning the mediately after their Deaths, would be of great Ufe in exciting Mens Affections, and confirming their Piety : But it could be fer- viceable to no Defign, nor to any View or Ufe whatfoever, to reprefent it more cold- ly or more lightly than is convenient. And, therefore, in order to difcover the Truth, and the real Opinion of every Author who has writ upon this Subject, one Place alone, that confines this Felicity within the Bounds that we have prefcrib'd to it, is of more Va- lidity than many of thofe which with Pallion exalt it, and more highly extol it. It has six. Sen. beenjuftly obferved by others, That every IVord of a Treacher is not to be wider flood by the Reader with the fame Rigour ■, with which it at firfl entered into the Ear of the Hearer : For Terfons while they declaim, deliver^ and inculcate fever al Things hyper- bolically, as the Tlace, the Time^ or the Audience give Occafion, or as they are tranfported by the Force of their < PaJfions y or inflamed by the Currency of their 'Dif- courfe. This is molt prudently, and moll judicioufly obferved, and ought certainly to be of chief Confideration in the prefent Argument. Let us not wonder then if facred Orators mov'd, either bv their Affection for the Dead, or a Defign of comforting and foothing the Living, have ufed a fofter and lefs rigo- rous Style, and have talked of an immediate PoiieiTion of Heaven, ahd of feeing God as he State of Departed Souls, isfc. 95 he is. The Word Heaven taken in a lar- ger Senfe may lignify any happy Condition of Souls, after their Departure from their Bodies ; which yet is more ufually by the Fathers called Taradifej or Abraham s Bo- fom> and which fignifies an intermediate State of Beatitude, and inferior to the Celef- tial. By Taradife, fays St. Aaftin, is gene- Epift. rr , rally meant a c Place where the Inhabitants ^?9 cn ' live happily. And that too is the general c . 34. ' ' Notion or Signification of Heaven. The Saints, indeed, enjoy a fort of internal Hea- ven immediately after their Deaths j but without their Bodies cannot enjoy the ex- ternal one. Then the Sight of God, or of Chrift, or the divine Pretence, of which Chryfoftome fomewhere makes Mention, can be no other than intelle&ual before the Refur- reclion. The Soul, indeed, in that teparate State will be nearer to God than it is in this Prifon of the Body, and will feel his Influ- ence more intimately within itfelf, and more preterit and efficacious, than if it was before him, and in his very Sight. But by thete, or the like, to underftand fupreme Felicity, or the moft gloriousVifion of God, is to make this Father moft apparently contradid him- felf. In reading Authors, whether facred or others, this has been wont to be obterved as a Rule, to interpret Things that are cloudy by thote that are clear, and Things that are vulgarly and popularly fpoke, by thote that are more exad and tevere \ and the 95 A TREATISE concerning the the Obfervation of this Rule will, in a good Meafure, keep us from erring. Laftly, that we have truly explained the Words and the Senfe of St. Chryfoflome, may be concluded from hence, that the other Interpreters, and the Grecian Fathers, who were the greateft Followers of Chryfoftome, as Theodoret, Oe- comenius, Theophylactj and Euthymius^ efpoufed the fame Opinion * that we do. Theodoret explains his Opinion in the fame Place that St. Chryfoftome had done it before him, viz. upon the laft Verfesof the eleventh Chapter to the Hebrews, where he aflerts, that none of the Righteous are fooner re- warded than others, or enjoy their Crown of Glory fooner, but that all will at once in the Refurre&ion be declared Victors by God together. And upon thefe Words of the Apoftle, And thefe all having obtained a good Report through Faith j, received not the Tromifi, God having provided fome better Thing for us, that they without us fbould not be made perfect, he fays thus : Were their Conflicts for Victory then fo great and fo many^ and they have not yet received their Crowns ? For God expects till the Conflicts and Contentions of all are over, that all who have obtain' d the Victo- ry, may be together declared Conquerors by him* *See more Fathers of this Opinion in Not. Cortbolt. Jujiitt. xliv. Col. i, & 2. State of Departed Souls, iffc. 97 him, and be rewarded together, Nor does OEcumenius underftand in any other Senie that Saying of the Apoftle, and that Account of thofe antient Heroes who were fo renown- ed for their Faith. They^ fays the Apoftle, fit down without their Recommence > expec- iug our Miniftration, or Coming. For fo Theophylatl upon the Place ; All thofe that are accounted Saints ^ though they have a Teftimony that they were p leafing to God by their Faith, have not yet obtain 3 d that ce- kftial Felicity which they were promifed. And upon the following Verfe, he adds fe- veral other Things of the fame kind, which he has almoft Word for Word tranfcrib'd from St. Chryfoftome. Laftly, this Author maintains the fame Opinion, in what he fays upon the twenty-third Chapter of St. Luke, where he explains the Saying of Chrift to the Thief, To Day foalt thou be with me in Paradife : For when he had before di£. tinguifhed Paradife from Heaven, and had by that means reconciled the Evangelift with St. 'Paul, in the PafTage quoted above, he adds ; The Thief therefore, though he ob- tain d Paradife, obtain d not the Kingdo?n of Heaven ; but he will be let into that too with all thofe others that are enumerated by St. Paul : In the mean while he has Pojfef fion of Paradife, the Kingdom of Spiritual Reft. The Explication of the fame PafTage by Euthymius, is exaclly of a Piece with this, as appears by the following Quotation H from 98 A T R E AT I S E concerning the from him : Chrift, knowing the Intention of the Thief promifed him what appeared moft deferable to him : For theThief was acquainted with Paradife by the Mofaick ^Doctrine ; and Chrift promifed that he [hould be with him in c Paradife J as an Earneft^ that he ftoould be one 'Day with him in his Kingdom, where he foould enjoy eternal and inexpref fible Happinefs ; where he jhould enjoy fitch Things as neither Eye has feetij, nor Ear has heard j nor has it enter'd into the Heart of Man to conceive : For none of the Juft, as yet j has had the Performance of the Promifes^ as the great Apoftle of the Gen- tiles has taught us : For Chrift by granting him what he did,, gave him AJfurance that in the Time of the univerfal Re furred ion, he would grant him a Place in his Kingdom. But fb much for St. Chryfoftome, and his Grecian Difciples and Followers. Among the Latin Fathers, who are like- wife of the fame Century, (viz,. Fourth,) you may confult, if you pleafe, about the State of the Dead, St. Hilary, St. Ambrofe, and St. Auftin. St. Hilary > in his Com- mentaries on the Pfalms, has often touched upon this Subject, and upon that Paffage of Pfalm cxxxviii. If I defend into the lower Parts of the Earth, thou art there '_, he tells us, that there is a Law univerfal and inviolable, for the Souls of Men to defcend to Hades ', and he adds, that for this Reafon Chrift did it, "becaufe by it he fulfilled the whole State of Departed Souls, is?c. 99 whole Courfe and Order of human Nature. He had taught us the fame before upon Pfalm liii. where he fays again, that Souls are retained in Hades, until the Day of Judgment. And, upon Tf. ii. and c Pf. cxx. upon thefe Words, The Lord (hall guard thy Going in, and thy Coming out, he fays thus, That the fVord Guard has no relation to that Time or Age ; but that 'tis an Expecta- tion of future Happinefs, when the Souls of the faithful, departing from their Bodies to the Entrance of that heavenly Kingdom _, (hall there be detain d in the Cufiody of the Lord j and configtfd to the Bofom of Abra- ham. This is the Doctrine of St. Hilary ^ con- cerning the State of the Dead. He who has a Mind to know what St. Ambrofe fays, may read his tenth, eleventh, and twelfth Chapters of his Treat ife of the Advantage of Death. In the tenth Chapter he acknow- ledges the Repofitory and Receptacle of Souls till the Day of Judgment : For the 'Day of Recompence is expected by all, the Day on which the Conquered §o all bhifi, and the Conquerors receive the c Palm and Crown of their Victory. And in the eleventh Chap- ter, fhewing the Gladnefs of thole Souls in its feveral Degrees before the Refurredion ; Fourthly j fays he, they rejoice „ becaufe they begin to tmderftand the Meaning of the Re- pofe that they take^ and to fore fee their fu- ture Glory 3 and charm' d with that Cou- H 2 folation, ioo A TREATISE concerning the folation, they take their Reft in their Re- ceptacles with great Tranquillity; furround- ed by Guards of Angels. Laftly, the fame Author in Book ii. Chap. ii. of his ^Difcourfe of Cain and Abel, appears to me to go a great deal too far upon this Subject ; for he gives a fort of a Hint that the Souls of the Dead are, till the Day of Judgment, uncertain of their future Condition : For though at the End of this Life, fays he, the Soul is re leafed from the Body ; yet 'tis ftill in Sufpence as to the Event of the future Judgment, Thus far fays St. Ambrofe. St. Austin comes after him, and though he fometimes, through Caution andModefty, declines the Difficulty, or rather the Envy, of deciding the Queftion \ yet, generally fpeaking, he detains the Souls of all the Righteous, at leaf!, if you except the Mar- tyrs, on this Side Heaven, and on this Side Glory, in iecret peaceable Receptacles, un- til the Refurrection, and the Day of Judg- ment, as will manifeftly appear to you by the following Paffages, if you confult them, and compare them at Leifure. Exfof. of *Pfal. xxxvi. io. upon thefe Words, adhuc 'Pufillum, Enchirid. ad Laurent, c. 118. Gen. ad Liter am, 1. xii. c. 3 5. 'De Civ. T)ei y 1. xii. c. 9. Retract. 1. i. c. 14. Confejf. l.ix. c. 3. 'Tis hardly worth while to call for more particular Witnefles from that or the follow- ing Centuries : But there are befides, two v . general State of Departed Souls, izfc, 101 general Heads, from which Arguments may be brought that may comprehend feveral Fa- thers, and feveral Witneffes. One of thefe is from the confenting Opinions of the pri- mitive Fathers, who take it for granted, that the State of all the Dead whatfoever, is bnt imperfectly happy before the RefurrecHon. The other is from the Ufe and Practice of the Church, in their Prayers and Offerings for the Dead. As for what relates to their Opinions, there are two that are chiefly to be confidered : The one is, that the Saints iTiall return in the Millennium, and reign together with Chrift upon Earth. The other teaches us, that the very Saints themfelves are to be purged in the lalt Fire, and mult be re- new'd and purified, together with the World, before they are called up to Heaven, and the Sight of their Maker. Each of thefe Opi- nions had great and numerous Champions in the firft Ages of the Church, as will plain- ly appear below in the Sixth and the Ninth Chapters. But each of thefe Opinions fup- pofes, that the Saints are not yet in PoiTef- fion of fupreme Felicity, of celeflial Glory, or the beatifick Virion of God ; and that they neither are, nor can be prepared for that En- joyment without the forefaid Purgation. And whether thefe Doctrines are true, or are falfe, they acquaint us, however, with the Opi- nions and Sentiments of both thefe ClaiTes of Fathers, (whofe Number is not final 1,) concerning the State of the Dead, and how H 3 far, iGi -A TREATISE concerning the far, with relation to the Point in Queftion, their Belief and their Opinions are conlbnant to our own. The other Head, which carries with it the Confent of many, is, the Cuftom and Prac- tice of the Church in their Liturgies, and thofe facred Rites that regard the Dead. Thefe Liturgies contain either Thankfgi- vings for the Dead, and Commemorations of them ; with either of which we have nothing to do here, or Offerings and Supplications for them. And this fufficiently fhews, that in their Opinion, the Souls for which thefe Rites were performed were not yet arrived at fupreme Glory, and the moil bleffed Vi- fion of God ; but thefe Rites were perform- ed for the Souls of the moft holy, and moft illuftrious Perfons ; for the Souls of the Patriarchs, the Prophets, the Apoftles, the Evangelifts, the Martyrs, and all the other Lights of the Church ; as may be feen in both the antient Liturgies, however doubt- ful, interlin'd, or corrupt, and in the Con- futations of Clement , in St. Cyprian, in 'D'zo- nyfius whom they call the Areopagite, and in Epiphanius. Whether this Practice is lawful and laudable, or other wife, it feems to be found- ed in this, that the Ancients believed that the Souls of all the Dead, of what Order foever, excepting the Soul of Chrift himfelf, were detained in Hades till the Refurrection of the Body ; and that they who were not yet made perfect State of Departed Souls, isfc. ioj perfect might receive fbme Advantage from the Offerings and Prayers of the Church : I fay Prayers; for that, befides their Of- ferings, Supplications were alio ufed, appears to me, both from the forefaid Liturgies and Authors, and others, to be certain and irre- fragable. Thus, for Example, in the Li- turgy which is called St. James's, Prayers are put up to God, that he would grant Light and Reft to all the Dead who are orthodox Believers, from Abel even to this Day. Remember, O Lord Godj the ortho- dox Souls j even of all Flefij thofe whom we remember ^ and thofe whom we do not^ from Abel the juft, unto this very T)ay : And do thou make them to reft in the 7 lace of the Livings in thy Kingdom, in the 'De- lights of Taradifej in the Bofoms of our holy Fathers Abraham, and Ifaac, and Jacob, &c. The fame is apparent from other Liturgies, as well the Greek, as the Latin, as you may fee in thofe who have made it their Bufinefs to colled them, and examine them. They pray for prefent Re- pole to the Dead, and future Light and Glory. And in all their Offices relating to the Dead, they always look with a ftedfaft Eye upon the Refurredion. Laftly, no- thing is to be found, as far as I know, in the Practice of the antient Church, that does not anfwer to this our Hypothefis of the State of the Dead and Hades, where all the Souls that are feparated from their H 4 Bodies 104 A TREATISE concerning the Bodies wait the Coming of Chrift, and the Sound of the laft Trumpet. So much for the Teftimonies of the Fa- thers, either taken feparately, or in a Body together. But perhaps you will lay, that all this, or at leaft a great Part of it, is to no Purpofe; fince the Papifts (whofe princi- pal fecular Intereft it concerns, that the Saints mould enjoy Heaven, and Glory, and the Virion of God before the Refurre&ion) confefs, that the Fathers are generally of the fame Opinion with us, and that from them they exped neither Ailiftance nor Pa- tronage in a Caufe which 3 fay they, de- pends entirely upon the Authority and De- termination of the Church. * But does not this Determination come fomething too late, fince we had it not till the Council of Flo- rence^ that is, till the fifteenth Century ? in which Council it was decreed, that the Souls of the Saints, when they leave their Bodies, fbould, in a little Time, be receivd into Heaven, and fyonld fee God, as he is in Trinity and in % Vnity. In the mean Time, we * Thus many, and thus celebrated are the antient Fa- thers, as TertulUan, Irenaus^ Origen, St. Chr^foflome, Theodoret, OEcumenius, Theophylafi, St.Ambrofe, Cle- mens Romanus, St. Bernard, who do not afTent to that Opinion, which at length has been determined by the Council oi Florence, after a great Debate, viz. that the Souls of the Juft enjoy the Vifion of God before the Day of Judgment, but are of a contrary Belief. Stapled Def. Auiiorit. Ecclef. l.i. c.a, State of Departed Souls, &c. 105 we can hardly bear it, when we reflect that fo many Fathers, who were fuch illuftrjous Rulers, and fuch mining Lights of the Church, mould be pretended to have been in an Error for fourteen Centuries together, and that Truth mould be difcovcr'd fo late at laft at Florence, and, as the Hiftory of that Synod relates, extorted with Co Violence, or fo much Fraud, from the Gre , whom yet we behold, either ill r relaps'd. Let them conilder this,, 2 concerned in it: But as for thofe that reform'd, this RomiJJj Authority of Popes or Synods is of no Validity with us : We are left entirely at Liberty, fairly and im- partially to examine the Thing, to confider its Force and its Weaknels, and diligently to weigh its natural Tendency ; to fee how the facred Scripture dire&s us, how the Reafon of the Thing itfelf, and how the un- corrupted Age of the Church ; and not to have only before our Eyes what was done lately, or determin'd at Florence againft the united Voice of them all. This Article of the State of the Dead, highly defer ves to be throughly examined, that it may appear what it is that our Adverfaries and we con- tend for : For upon this Foundation depends the whole Superftru&ure of Romifi Reli- gion, and RomijJj Pomp, with regard to their Saints, with regard to the Canoniza- tion, as fome are pleas'd to exprefs them- felves, to the Invocation and the Adoration of io6 4 TREATISE concerning the of them ' y nor only with regard to the Saints themfelves, but to their Images and their Relicts. Upon this depend all their Pil- grimages, their meritorious Vows, the Maffes of their Saints, and that new, but moft lu- cretive Invocation of Purgatory. Since, therefore, fo great a Provilion, fo great a Weight of Superftition depends entirely upon this Article, fo great a Superftrudture upon this Foundation, or upon this Corner Stone, it moft highly concerns us to make no rafh Conceffion in a Caufe of fo vaft Importance, and not to indulge too pious, but too ill-grounded Affections. CHAP. IV. Of the State of Nature , in which departed Souls are in the Interval between "Death and the Refurrectton ; whether they are naked and feparated from all corporeal Subjiancej or whether they are united to the aerial j or any other Body. Vid. Dall. i d A F c n i2. HP HE firfl Queftion being difpatch'd l p. 18 1, 8cc JL concerning the Quality of an inter- Gcrard de mec ii a te State, as to Felicity or Mifery, or Tom. 8. concerning the moral Condition of Souls be- p 4.9. 8c f the ReiurrecYion, there follows another, de ftatu A- J . * nimarum and a much more aimcult one, concerning feparata- ^^ natU ral State. That Souls furvive, turn, p. ,. * 403. live, State of Departed Souls, isfc. 107 live, and think after Death, or upon the Dif- folution of the Body, has been provM in what went before. But what the Apoftle faid of his Exftafy, whether it was in the Body, or out of the Body^ I know not, fays he, God knows y that I may be allow'd to repeat here ; whether the Soul, having thrown off this Body, puts on a new one, or remains naked, and without a Body, un- til the Time of the Refurredion of the Dead, / know not , God knows: At leaft I reckon this among thofe Obfcurities, which neither clearly appear by the Light of Na- ture, nor by any divine Revelation. Since there is no Room here for Experi- ments, we muft derive our Knowledge, ei- ther from the Nature of the Thing itlelf, thole Seeds of Knowledge with which we came into the World, or from the facred Writings. The Philosophers are the prin- cipal Evidences and Interpreters of the for- mer, and the Chriftian Fathers of the latter. But after we have confulted all thefe, you will hardly find any Thing upon this Sub- ject that is evident or conclufive, where one may fix one's Foot. As for the Light of Reafon, and the Nature of Things, very little Ailiftance is to be expected from them in the determining this Queftion. For fince the Union of the Soul with this terreftrial Body, or any other Body whatever, does not, as far as is known to us, arife from any natural Neceflity, or any neceifary Con- nexion jc8 .4 TREATISE concerning the nexion between thefe two Natures, but en- tirely from the Will of God, and his divine Decree ; when this Body comes to be di£- folv'd, it will depend upon the fame divine Will, or, which is the fame Thing, upon Laws of Nature unknown to us, whether the Soul fhall be fubje&ed to a new Union, or remain feparated from all Matter : For fb it poffibly may remain, fince 'tis a Sub- ftance, or a Thing capable of fubfifting by itfelf. If upon this Subject you confult the Phi- lofophers, they, for the moll part, are fi- lent. The Platonicks, indeed, or at leaft fome of the Platonicks, allert, that the Soul, immediately after its Departure from this Life, and the Body, will be fubje&ed to an aerial Body ; and that from thence it will proceed to an aetherial one, after it has fuf- ficiently improv'd itfelf in Wifdom and Vir-r tue, by a retrograde Order, from that by which it fell down by Degrees into this loweft Station. I cannot fee that there is any Thing of Abfurdity in this Opinion ; but Evidence and Proof are wanting. For how does it appear that we, laft of all, at our Birth threw off this aerial Body ? or that there ought to be the fame Order and the fame Degrees of the Afcent and Defcent? or that, laltly, no State intervenes of Silence and Separation from all Bodies ? Since there are innumera- ble Worlds in the immenfe Compafs of the Univerfe ? State of Departed Souls, &c 109 Univerfe, there may be many Orders, Modes, and Variations in the Revolutions of Souls, according to the manifold Wifdom of God ; and what Order of Afcent or Defcent God has prefcrib'd to us, belongs to his fecret Difpenfation, which is hid from us in this Life. But perhaps you may believe that it may be poflible to prove, from the Ghofts and Apparitions of the Dead, that human Souls, when they throw off this Body, immediate- ly aflume another, by means of which they lometimes fhew themfelves vifible and con- fpicuous in a human Shape. I muft confeis, that it never was evident yet to me, nor could I be convinc'd that the * Souls of the Dead ever yet appear'd, or will appear be- fore the Day of Judgment. Genii^ perhaps, or ^Dtemons, may have the Power of con- densing the Air, or their proper Vehicles, and forming them into human or brutal Shapes, and may perhaps exercife that Power lometimes, efpecially among barbarous Na- tions, or Nations that are half barbarous j but * See the Words of St.ChryfoJiome, Homily xix. on Matth. and Homily the laft, concerning Lazarus. Mal- donatus upon St. Luke, Chap. xvi. towards the End, quotes Tertullian, De Amma, againft the Apparitions of the Dead; butlfuppofe he is miflaken, becaul'e he quotes not the Chapter. He quotes likewife Aihanafin^ or the Author, whoever he be, of the Treatife to Antiochus, ir. xi. and xiii. IJiodor. Lib. viii. Etymol. c. ix. and Theo- phylatt on Matthevj viii. 1 1 o A T R EAT I S E concerning the but I believe that this is rarely done among us ' y and that among a thou land Tales of iuch Apparitions we hardly find one true. Thefe, however, by the vulgar are fwallow^d, and the Remembrance of a future Life is renew'd, and their Faith is ftrengthen'd. But the Monks are they who have imported the greateft Cargo of Fables on this Subject, by their own Inventions, or .their imaginary Vifions, in order to introduce and confirm the Belief of Purgatory. But let us now, if you pleafe, fuppofe that the Souls of the Dead have aerial Bodies, and have an animal Life. Here many Queftions will occur, many Doubts to be clear'd up : Firft of all, what Region of the Air would you have thefe new Comers inhabit ? the fuperior or the inferior one ? If you place them below the Clouds, youthen expole them to all the piercing Extreams of Seaibns, and all the Intemperature of the Skies, fince they always live in the open Air, defended by no Roofs, by no Houfes of any kind whatfoever. When it rains, when it fnows, when it hails, when it thun- ders, they ftill lie expos'd in the open Air ; and thefe Meteors muft of Neceffity, not only rudely infult their tender Bodies, but Itrike and tranfpierce them through and through ; and the Fury of tempeftuous Winds muft drive and tranfport them, like fo many Clouds, into new Habitations. But if you place thefe Souls of the Dead, as well State of Departed Souls, &c. 1 1 1 well the Evil as the Good, above the Clouds and the Atmofphere of the Earth, you car- ry them from Hades, into Regions ierene and lucid, of which the impure and wicked Souls are moft unworthy, . and for which they are moft improper: Nor would you, I believe, have thefe Separated from the reft, the Goats from the Sheep before the Day of Judg- ment. But fo much for the Seats and Sta- tions of the Dead. The fecond Query is concerning the Po- lity of the Dead : For if they have Bodies, and lead an animal Life, 'tis neceffary that there fhould be fome Polity, fome Govern- ment among them. Would you then, have them live all in the fame Republick pro- mifcuouily ? or would you have them fe- parated and diftributed, as they were here on Earth into feveral Nations, both by their Names and their Manners diftinguim/d ? As for Example ; Would you have the French dwell all together, and feparately from the reft ? Would you thus have the Spaniards^ the Italians, the Germans ^ the Britons, and all the reft of the Nations upon the Face of the Earth, have their own Seats in the Air, each of them feparated from the reft ? Would you have each of them likewife have their ancient Government, their own Lan- guage, their own Religion, and Cuftoms ? Thefe are the Queftions that are to be de- termin'd, and explain'd to the Inquirers. But flrft of all it will be difficult to fix and prefer ve ii2 4 TREATISE concerning the preferve in a fluid Element, the Bounds of the feveral Empires ; in an Element where there can be neither Ditches, nor Rivers, nor any Fortifications : Nor will the Difficul- ty be lefs in appointing their Kings ; for which of the old ones, the firft or the lalt, will they reftore to the Throne? or what royal Pedigree will they prefer to the reft? or, rejecting all antient Titles, fhall they give the Crown to the worthier!? I can eafily fee that Contentions will arife from hence, and Parties, and Factions, and Wars ; but what Manner of righting, or what Weapons they will ufe in the Air, I do not yet underftand : The Dead certainly can die no more; nor do I know whether they can be wounded. Some little Queries like wife arile concern» ing the Difcourfe and Language of the Dead. Many have invented Dialogues of the Dead ; but what Language the Dead make ufe of, I am yet to learn. You will fay their Mother, or their native Language, the fame that they us'd here on Earth, as the Grecians fpeak Greeks the Latins La- tin, and fb for the reft of the Nations : But Times, and People, and Languages, from Age to Age are chang'd. Our modem Romans are very little skilled in the Lan- guage of the antient Latins, nor do the vulgar Italians underftand any Latinity whatever: How fhall thefe People hold Difcourfe with their Romulus, or their Numa. The Languages of the Celt a and the Scy- thians State of Departed Souls, &c. 1 1 thians, are no more remember'd by thole who inhabit the fame Seats in the North and the Weft, that they did. Laitly, what is to be done by us the Inhabitants of this Ifland, who have had fb many Languages and lb many Originals ? Shall we fpeak fVeljh in our aerial Bodies, or Saxon, or Norman, or as we do at this Day, a Mix- ture and Compound of them all ? If the Life to come were to be regulated at this Rate, I am afraid there would be a Confu- fion of Tongues more grievous than that of Babel. We come into the World, in which we are now, Infants, where by Degrees we learn the Ufe of Speech, inftructed by our Mo- thers and our Nurfes ; but in the aerial World I prefume there is no Infancy. They who are Infants when they go out of this, when they enter into that, are mature at once, without any Diftinclion of Age. They do not come out from the Womb of their Mo- ther, and gradually, like our little ones, grow up to Youth and Manhood ; but as • foon as they have a Tafte of aetherial Air, grow, reafonable and polite at once, with- out any Apprenticefhip in learning. Thefe Things I fpeak, not that I mean them, but according to the forefiid Hypothec's : Nor do I fee how the Dead can retain their old Languages, or fwallow down a new at one Draught. But fo much for their Dil- courfe. I But ii4 A TREATISE concerning the But a greater Difficulty ftill remains ; and that concerns their Religion: For thefe aerial Men muft of Neceflity have among them divine Worfhip, and fome Inftitu- tion and Form of. Religion. Is every one then to embrace the fame Religion which he profefs'd upon Earth, and his own particu- lar Sect of it ? Are the Jews to follow the Law of Mofes, the Mahometans that of Mahomet i the Heathens to worfhip their own Gods, and the Chriftians Chrift? Would you have the Papifts have their Pope as they have here below? and the reformed have the Scripture as the Rule of their Faith ? But what do I talk of the Scripture, when I have no Notion of aerial Books orWritings? If Men write in vain in Water, much more will they do fo in Air. No Religion can, in that Station, retain its Canon or its writ- ten Law, nor its particular facred Rites, nor its external OEconomy. Befides, if all the Souls of the Dead, from the World's Origi- nal to this very Day, live together in the Air, the Jews will find their Prophets there, and the Chriftians their Apoftles. The Jews being better inform'd of the true Me£- fiah, from the oraculous Interpretation of the Prophets themfelves,will immediately be- come Chriftians. Thefe in like manner, will, from the Mouths of the Apoftles them- felves, receive the infallible Decifion of all the Controverfies which are now depending between the Reform'd and the Romans. The State of Departed Souls, &c 115 The Confequence of this will be, both the Converfion of the Jews^ and the Union of the Chriftians. O happy Seats! O thrice more happy, thofe who are dead, than thofe who areyet living! Laftly, when the reft of human Kind lhall be clearly inftru&ed in the Nature of the true God, and the Myi- tery of the Meffiah, inftrucrcd by Men di- vinely infpirM, they rejecting their Errors will forthwith be converted to the Chriftian Faith and Worfhip. Behold now the glo nous Kingdom of Chrift, a Kingdom not upon Earth, nor in Heaven, but among the Dead in the Air. But all this very little a- grees with the Chriftian Difpcnfation, as 'tis in the iacred Writings explain'd ; and, in- deed, is foreign to common Belief and Senfe: For who can believe that Adam and Eve_, or the firft Men of all their Pofterity, Sons and Daughters, live together in the Clouds, or the Air; and have liv'd there together for feveral thoufand Years ? Do they ftill keep to their Families, and to their antient Relations ? Are they fenfible of what is done upon Earth, and eipecially among their own Countrymen, and moft of all among their own Relations ? But I am weary of asking lo many Queftions, and of being thus inqui- 1 litive, in an Affair that is {6 uncertain, and indeed incredible. If you form Queries upon other Heads, the Anfwerer will be no lefs at a ftand. For my Part, the more I reflect upon this in my Mind, the lefs can I find I z that 1 1 5 A TREATISE concerning the that there can be any poflible Way. of efta- blifhing a Commcnweaith among the Dead, that is to fay, an external, corporeal, animal, and vifible State. Hitherto we have' had Recourfe to Reafon alone, and to Arguments fetch'd from the Nature of the Thing: But we ought, befides, to confult the Holy Scripture, if that by chance mould have any Thing to offer to us concerning the Bodies of the Dead brie the RefurreCtion. But quite contra- ry, there arc many Things in the facred Writings, which, according to my Appre- hension, are by no means fivourable to aerial Bodies in the intermediate State. Firft, be- caufe the facred Writings mention only two Sorts of animated Bodies, related to human Souls, the Terreitrial and the Ccleftial ; that which we have at this Time, and that which we are to have at the Refurreclion of the Dead. In the fifteenth Chapter of the firft Epiille to the Corinthians, the Apoftle St. IPaul handles this Matter a little more dif- fufely ; and after he had diftincUy mention'd two Sorts of Bodies, and only two, belong- ing to the human Soul, he adds, And as v. 45. we have bom the Image of the Earthly, we fljall likewife bear the Image of the Hea- venly, making not the lean: Mention of any, intermediate Body, which he feems more plainly to exclude in the fifth Chapter of V. 1. the fecond Epiftle to the Corinthians i in. thefe Words: For we know that if our State of Departed Souls, &c. 1 17 our earthly Houfe of this Tabernacle wer& dijfolv'd, we have a Building of God; an Houfe not made with Hands, eternal in the Heavens. You fee here that no corporeal State comes between the terreftrial and cclef- tiai Body; but in the Veries which follow, he calls that State which perhaps may inter- vene, a State of Nakcdneis : The Words are theie, For in this we groan earneftly, defi- Vcr. 2, 3. ring to be c loathed * upon with our Houfe, which is from Heaven. If fo be that being c loathed j we (ball not be found naked', for if we are cloathed with any Body, we fhall not be found in a State of Separation, upon the Coming of Chrift to raife up the Dead: For the naked Soul, or the naked Mind, fig- niries the fame with the naked Soul or the na- ked Mind, in a State of Separation from all Body whatever. And to be cloathed upon, can be applied to no one, unlels to one who is already cloathed. Secondly, the Fate of every Man, ac- cording to the Style and Account of the fa- cred Scripture, depends entirely upon our Acfions'in this Life ; for in that to come there will be no Change, either of Manners, or of the Portion of Happineis, or Mifery, which we have merited from thole Actions. Whether the Tree falls to the South or the North, in the Tlace where it fell, there if I 3 mujl * Concerning the Word Cloathed upon, or Sufer'radui, fee the Explication of Cretins, p. 315-. n8 ^TREATISE concerning the C.xi.vcr.3. fnufi lie j lays Eccleflaftes ; which Saying is generally refer f'd to the Death of Man, and his unchangeable Condition afterwards. And Mat. xxv. f tne y are WO nt to interpret the Shutting Luc. xiii. of the Gate in the Parables of Chrift: But 25-. St. 'Paul tells us that more plainly in the ycr. 10. fecond Epiftle to the Corinthians^ and the fifth Chapter \ For we muft all appear be- fore the Judgment Seat of Chrift, that eve- ry one may receive the Things done in his Body, according to that he hath done, whe- ther it be good, or whether it be evil : Which Words feem to determine and fix the future Condition of Men, from the A&ions which they have done, or ought to have done, during this prefent Life. But if another Life intervenes before the Day of Judgment, and a Life of that Nature, that it is as capable of good or of evil A&ions, of Virtue or Vice, as is the prefent Life, \ than which it is of much greater Length and Duration ; I fee no Manner of Reafon, why the whole Weight of Eternity, and of the future Lot and Condition of Men fhould depend upon this prefent Life, which is fb ihort, fo furrounded with Troubles, and to numberlefs Temptations liable, that other of much greater Moment being entirely neg- lected and eiteem'd as nothing. Thirdly, and laftly, According to a com- mon Expreilion in the Holy Scripture, Death is callM a Sleep, and thole. that die are faid to fall ajleep' 7 which fcems to hint to me, that State of Departed Souls, &c. 1 19 that the State of Death is a State of Quiet, of Silence, and of Inaction, or Celfation from Action, that is, with regard to the external World : So that in a State of Death we have no more Commerce with the external World, than we have in a State of Sleep. Befides, we are faid to rouze ourfeives, or to be awake upon the Refurrection : But why ? becauie that changing our Condition, and lhaking off Sleep, we rile again into Light and into the vifible World. But you will fay, perhaps, that thatPhrafe in the facred Scripture, by which Death is liken'd to Sleep, and by which thofe that die are faid to fall afleep, is only an Euphe- nifmy, or a figurative favourable Expreffion, and regards the Body only, which when dead appears to take pleafing Reft, like one that is overwhelmed with Sleep. Be it lb : But then the Expreflion will be fuller and ftronger, if with the Body you comprehend the Mind, which refts from its ufual Ac- tions, as it does in a State of Sleep ; nor is it {truck by external Objeds. Therefore, the Senles are not only bound and fhut up, as they are in Sleep, but we are fnatch'd, as it were in an Extaiy, from the Body and the corporeal World. And when the Thea- tre of the vifible World opens itfelf again to us, we are aptly and juftly laid to (hake off Sleep, and to wake. But if, upon the Soul's Departure from this Body, we imme- diately put on another more active and more I ± lively j 120 A TREATISE concerning the lively; and the Souls of the Dead arefport- ing in the Fields of the Air, extremely awake and chcaiful ; I fee no Reafon why the Dead fhould be faid to fleep till the Refurrecticn,and upon that to awake, unlefs you refer all that to the Body, which leems ibmewhat hard to me. But we are here to obferve, that when Inaction, or a Ceflation from Action, is at- tributed to the Souls of the Dead, we are not to underftand a total or an univerlal Inac- tion, as well internal as external, but external Inadion only ; becaufe they have no Opera- tion, or Action, which regards the corporeal World, nor are they affected by that any Man- ner of Way whatioever. But frill they have Life and the Faculty of thinking remain- ing : For ib I underitand the Words of Chrift, when, to prove the Immortality of the Soul, he fays, that God calls himfclf the God of Abraham, of 1 [fa tfr, and of Jacob. But he is not the God of the IDeadj, but of the Living, for they all live unto him. By the Dead here Chrift underftands thole who are void of all Life whatioever ; and in this Senfe he denies that thefe Patriarchs are dead. For they live, fays he, unto God y that is, if I underftand the Thing rightly, though they do not live with Regard to Men, and the reft of the \ inble World, yet with Re- gard to God, in the invifible World, accord- ing to their intellecluai Faculties, they enjoy both Life and Vigour. Let 37.3 STaTe of Departed Souls, izfc» in Let it fuffice to obferve all this from the facred Writings, in order to diicover the State and Kind of Life, whether corporeal, or incorporeal, we are to have immediately after Death ; and that for this End, that we may be able to judge, whether we iliall be- hold this Sun, thefe Stars, and this agreeable Light j or whether, before the Refurrection of the Dead, we mall enjoy the vilibleWorld in any Manner whatever : For, according to our Philofophy, uniels the Soul is united to fome particular Body, to fome particular Portion of Matter, apart and feparately from all others, to which it is vitally, and after a peculiar Manner united, it can have no Senle or Perception of the external World, or of any corporeal Appearance, or of any Part or Motion of Matter. This, perhaps, may to fome appear a Paradox, who believe that it may very well be, and, indeed, that it actually is, that the Soul difcerns all ex- ternal Object, and the Motions of the cor- poreal World, though, 'tis united to no par- ticular Body, nor to any one Portion of Mat- ter, rather than to another : And though it be altogether naked, yet, according to the Place or Region in which 'tis prefent, it may receive Impreffion from the furrounding World, and from adjacent Bodies, in as equal a Manner, as if it had a Body peculiar to it- felf. But I would fain know how this can be, unlefs we fuppofe the Soul to be impe- netrable : For all the Action that Bodies have 12 2 A T R E AT I S E concerning the have is by Motion, Contact, and Impulfe ; and wherever there is no Refiftance, there can be no Preffure or Impulfe. Befides, the Motions of Bodies produce not Senfations, or Thoughts, or Reflections, in us by their own Power, (for at that Rate the Effeft would be more noble than the Caufe,) nor can they by their own Power act upon an incorporeal Nature : But that is brought about by a Law eftabliihed by the Author of Nature, between thefe Souls, and thefe particular Bodies \ by Virtue of which Law, they fympathize each with the other, act upon each other, and from each other fuffer ; and this we call a vital Conjunction or TJnion : So that Union is one Thing, and naked Prefence another Thing*. And unlels you can fuppofe that naked Souls, or Souls that are feparated from their Bodies, fympathize with the whole Ma- chine of the Univerie, or with all Bodies of every Kind, they can receive Senfations or feniible Impreffions from none. Lastly, that I may draw this Matter to a Conclufion, Pleafure and Pain, which are nrft-rate Senfations, and of the greateft Importance, cannot arife in the Soul with- out a Body that is peculiar to it, or that is vitally to it united : For thefe are Affections which happen to the Soul, by Reafon of fome * 1 could fee though my Eyes were (hut, if the naked Prefence, or' the Nearnefs of the Object Were fuff to excite Senfations in the Soul. State 0/ Departed Souls, isfc. 123 fome Good or fome Evil that happens to the Body, as 'tis its own Body. If you ftrike with a Staff an adjacent Wall, I behold the Motion of the Staff, and I hear the Sound of the Stroke or the Blow j but I am fenfible of no Pain from it : But if with the fame Staff, and the fame Force, you ftrike againft my Body, or that Portion of Matter which I call my Body, I immediately feel Pain from it ', for a new Senfation arifes very dif- ferent from Seeing or Hearing, which we nominate Pain. In the fame Manner, if in my Prefence, with a Sword or an Axe you lop off a Branch of a Tree, no Pain is felt by me from it ; but if with the fame Sword,. or the fame Axe, you cut my Arm afunder, I feel infupportable Grief and Pain, I am more affected with the Prick pf a Needle upon my own Finger, than with the Blow of a Cannon Ball upon any other Body whatever. After the fame Manner we may account for corporeal Plcaiure : But we have here faid enough to fhew that our Senfa- tions do not arife from any Kind of Body, nor from every Prefence of the Soul ; but that, befides local Prefence, another State is required, a State of Union, or of Sympathy, to affect us with the Motions of Matter. But enough of this.* Now * That I may have done with this Subject, tho> Dead Jeem to aaei \o i;:,ow nothing of the Affairs or tho£e "vyhQ 124 A TREATISE concerning the Now thefe Enquiries have we made, and thefe Determinations have we come to, con- cerning the Souls of the Dead, according to the Light which we have received, ei- ther from the Nature of Things, or from the facred Oracles : By which it appears, firft, that the Soul furvives the Body ; fe- condly, that the Souls of the Dead will be happy after Death, and the Souls of the Wicked unhappy : But, thirdly, that be- fore the Pay of Judgment, the former will not be fupremely happy, nor the latter ex- tremely miferable. Laitly, that ^tis more pro- who live in this. World, nor to meddle with the Con- cerns of their Families, nor to be perplexed with their Cares : They reft from their Labours. Nor can I eafily conceive, that an old Beldam, for Example, who never knew how to write or read, nor to make the Mark of any one Letter in the Alphabet, that much lefs knew howto paint or to engrave exactly ; I fay, I cannot eafily conceive, that this old Beldam fhould be able to appear before us in her own Shape, and with all the Lines of her Face, and Lineaments of her Body, like one of fuch an Age, and with thofe Wrinkles that are the Effects of it ; and all this to the greateft Exacmcfs : Nor to ap- pear only in her own Shape, but in her ufual Garments and her external Drefs : And all this fo compleatly, fo exactly, that neither Jpclles himfelf, nor Phidias, no Art of the Painter, no Art of the Sculptor, was ever able to equal the Art of this old Beldam. We are amaz'd at the Hearing of thefe Things, as Things beyond the common Belief of Men : But as the Power and Facul- ties of the Soul, after 'tis fet free from this Body, and cloathed with a thinner, are altogether unknown to us, I mud own that all that I have faid, how r ever it may have a Tendency to perfuade, yet does not come up to the Force of a Demon ftration . State of Departed Souls, isfc. 125 probable, that until the Refurrection the Souls will remain in a feparate State, than that they will be veiled in any Body. Yet, after all, my Opinion is, that this is to be numbered amongft Things obfeure,or Things not exprefly reveal'd.* Thus far have we gone, let us now proceed to the reft. * Awex»0«H to abftain, with regard to fome Things, is no lefs the Duty of a Chriftian, than of a Philofopher. If within this grofs Body, which we carry about with us, there is fome internal Vehicle, with which theSoul being inverted takes its Flight in the Article of Death, I have nothing to fay againft it; but we are bound tophi- lofophize according to Allegations folidly proved. CHAP. V. Tranfition to the remaining 7 arts of this Work ; and, fi'ft, concerning the Coming of Chrifty and the Conflagration of the World. HITHERTO we have been among the filent Dead : Now we muft return into the World's pompous Theatre, where a new Face of Things entertains us, where new Th3 1 {hall all the Tribes of the Earth mourn ; and they fiall fee the Son of Man coming in the Clcuds of Heaven with 'Power and great Glory. And he flail feud his Angels with a great Sound of a Trumpet _, and they fiall gather together his E left from the four IV inks, from one Eirtl of Heaven to the 0- ther. XXIV. '12 8 A T R EAT I S E concerning the Mar.xxvi. I N thefe, and other refembling PafTages, we are inftru&cd by the Mouth of Chiift himfelf in his future Return to the Earth ; which after him the Angels, and after them the Apoftlcs again and again proclaimed. At the fame Time, I am not ignorant that thefe Sayings of Chrift, concerning his fu- ture Coming, are fo reftrained by fome, and have their Meaning fo maimed, as if nothing was meant by them, but the DeitrucHon of Jerufalem ; though during the Time that Jerufalem Was deftroy'd, Chrift remained above in the Heavens ; nor during that Time did he ever come, or ever fo much as ap- pear, unlefs improperly, as far as the Works and the Judgments of God are taken for God himfelf. Betides, the external Splendor, the Glory of the Father, the Concomi- tancy of Angels painted in thofe Defcrip- tions, denote his perfonal Coming, and can never be adjufted to any figurative Meaning. Laftly, the univerfal Judgment, and the End of the World are connected together with this Coming of Chrift, in the foremen- tioned PafFages. The Preparation for Judg- ment is manifeftly defcrib'd in the foreiaid Paflage, Matt. xix. 28. as you will find by comparing it with Rev. xx. 4, 11, 12. You will likewife find the judicial Reward or Punifhment of every one according to his Merits, if you compare Matt. xvi. 27, 2*8. with Rom. ii. 5, 6„ &c. And in the twenty-fifth Chapter of the lame Evangeliir- ver\ State of Departed Souls, iffc. 1 29 *ver. 31, 32, &c. both the Preparation for Judgment, and the judicial Sentences, are connected together with this Coming of Ch rift : When the Son of Man fo all come in his Glo- ry > and all the holy Angels with him^ then Jhall he Jit on the Throne of his Glo- ry. And before him jhall be gathered all Nations y and he jhall feparate them one from another j as a Shepherd divideth his Sheep from the Goats, cXc. As thefe PafTages clearly denote the uni- versal Judgment, and that at the Coming of Chrift ; fb that Judgment as perfpicuoufiy means the contemporary End of the World, co-incides with the fame. Some have been bold enough to affert, that in the twenty- fourth Chapter of St. Matthew, and other parallel Places, nothing is laid concerning the End of the World, or the utmoft Con- fummation of Ages : But that all thofe Say- ings, though ever fo great, yet folidly re- gard the Deftru&ion of Jerufalem only. A bold Affirmation, and very ill ground- ed, in my Opinion. What ? becaufe in one or two Places, where a certain Coming of Chrift is mention'd, ibme View is had to the Deftru&ion of Jerufalem, therefore where- ever in the Gofpel Mention is made of his Coming, though fuperlatively glorious, and attended with a thoufand Marks that can ne- ver in the leaft regard Jerufalem, but muft be referred to Nature, and the World about to perifh together; fhall we dare to reftrain and to wreft thefe PafTages to the Deftruc- K tion 130 A TREATISE concerning the lion of one People, and of one City only? This feems to me to be highly rain, that I may lay no worfe of it. But the Qiieftion is now concerning this Chapter of St. Matthew, in which the fore- faid Interpreters fay, that nothing is found that regards the End of the World, or that ought to be extended beyond the Deftru&ion of J 'erufalem ; which, if I am not miltaken, may two Ways be confuted. Firft, ibveral Things are aflerted and related in this Chap- ter, of which we have no Account in the Hiftory of the Deftruction of J erufalem. Se- condly, the Things that are related in the facred Writings, when the ultimate Coming of Chrift in the End of the World is de- fcrib'd, agree and anfwer exactly to what is faid in this Chapter ; and therefore both ought to be underftood as meant of the fame Coming. s „ e- . As to the firft of thefe, 'tis laid. ver. 14. fcxsjxivij. This Go/pel of the Kingdom pall be preach- ed through all the World, for a Witnefs un- to all Nations, and then /hall the End come, Thefe Things are not yet come to pals, much lefs were they come to pals be- fore the Deftruclion of Jerufalem. But further, thefe Perfons would have only Ju- dea underftood by through all the Worlds and by all Nations only the various Tribes and Provinces of the Jews y which, though it is fbmething ftrain'd, yet, if there were no farther Objection, I fhould not dwell upon this alone. But, fecondly, the wonderful Appearances both in Earth and in Heaven, and State of Departed Souls, foV. 13! and the glorious Appearance of Chrift in the Clouds above all, which are faid to pre- cede the Confummation of Things, which is here marked and foretold, did neither pre- cede nor accompany the Deftruction of Je- rufalem. Thefe Prophecies are thus related by St. Matthew : Immediately after the Ver.29. Tribulation ofthofe 'Days, ftoall the Sun be darkened j and the Moon jhall not give her Light s and the Stars ft) all fall from Hea- ven, and the 'Powers of the Heavens jhall be ftaken. And then ft all appear the Sign Ver.§3 of the Son of Man in Heaven : And then ftjall all the Tribes of the Earth mourn , and they jhall fee the Son of Man coming in the Clouds of Heaven, with Power and great Glory. But upon the Deftruction of yeru- falem, Chrift nowhere appeared in the Clouds of Heaven, nor did the Sun loie its Splendor, or the Moon its Light, nor were the Powers of the Heavens fhaken. A Comet, indeed, did appear with its Tail re- fembling a Sword, or a Faulchionj as ufual : But the reft of the Portents which Jofephus ?* d B f l - mentions are quite of another Kind. c . ii." But, befides, thefe Signs in the Heavens are attended by others on Earth, as the Shaking of the Earth, and the Roaring of the Sea and its tumultuous Waves. For fb St. Luke : And there ftjall be Signs in the Sun, Ca P* XI * and in the Moon, and in the Stars ; and up- on the Earth T>ijirefs of Nations \, with Per- plexity j the Sea and the Waves roaring, K % Mens 132 A T R EAT I S E concerning the Mens Hearts failing them for Fear y and for looking after thofe Things which are coming on the Earth j, for the 'Powers of Heaven (hall be foaken : But what has Je- rufalem to do with the Sea, or the Raging or Roaring of its tempeftuous Waves ? Is any Thing like this related to have happen'd at that Time ? Certainly nothing ; but thefe and the reft of the Things above mentioned, relate to another and a greater Cataftrophe, the Deftru&ion of the World : And there- fore in explaining this Matter, Chrift very aptly puts them in Mind of the Times of JSfoahy and the Deluge, which was not a na- tional, but an univerfal Deftru&ion. In the mean Time, I am not ignorant that the Interpreters, of whom we have been here lpeaking, in expounding thefe Pheno- mena, have Recourfe to Metaphors, and to Allegories, and to quote PafTages from the Prophets, in which thefe or the like Ex- preffions are usM in a figurative Senfe : 'Tis granted that fome of them are ; but it ap- pears to me to be no juft Law of interpret- ing, to pretend that thofe Things which are fometimes us'd figuratively by the Prophets, fhould be always and every where under- ftood in the fame Senfe. The Style of the Goipel is a great deal more chafte, nor does it eafily deviate from the literal Senfe ; from which an Interpreter ought never to depart, unlefs the Necefiity of the Subject-Matter conftrains him ; And we haye Ihevvn in an- other •State of Departed Souls, Zffc. 133 other Place, that thefe Phenomena in tbfe T^cor.TclU Earth and the Heavens, though wonderful ' * 3, and extraordinary, will really happen to- wards the End of the World, when Nature is in its Pangs, and the Conflagration impend- ing. The Deftruction of Jenifalem was, indeed, a Type of the Deftru&ion of the World, and therefore we have lefs Reafon to wonder that they mould both be mingled in a. confus'd Relation ; for there is, in the fkcred Style, if I may fo exprefs my felf, a fort of a Communication of Idioms between the Types and the Antitypes ; and there is in the Prophets a repeated Completion of the fame Prophefy, afcending gradually to its Height. But fo much for the fecond Argument, taken from the external Signs ; the third follows it, taken from hence, that we obferve, that there is in this Prophecy another Period of Time, beiides that of the Deftruction of Jerufalem, and a Period pofterior to it ; for thus we read in St. Luke 3 Jerufalem /^^//C.xxi.24. be trodden down of the Gentiles > until the Times of the Gentiles be fulfill' d. See here another Period, different from that of Jem- falem^ and pofterior to it ; for the Defla- tion of the Jews is faid to endure to this other Period : I defire to know then what this pofterior Period is, unlefs it be that of the World ? or the Reftoration of the Jews towards the End of the World, after the Times are accorrmliftYd that are pre- K\ deftu'd 134 ^ T R E AT I S E concerning tU deftin'd for the preaching to and convert- ing the Gentiles. But the Wonders in the Earth, and the Heavens, and the glo- rious Appearance of Chrift in the Clouds, immediately follow the Mention of this pof- terior Period, and are therefore properly to be referred to that, and not to the Deftruc- tion of Jernfalem. Befidcs, when Chrift fays, that of that 'Day and Hour knoweth no Man j no, nor the Angels which are in Heaven, he feems to mean fomething more remote than that Deftruction, which when it was fcarce at the Diftance of half an Age from the Time in which our Saviour fpoke, -tis a great deal lefs probable that it ihould have efcaped the Knowledge of all the An- gels in Heaven, than if you interpofe the Series of many Ages, and underftand by it the laft Day of the expiring World. Thus far we have treated of the Remarks which are found in the very Text, If be- fides you compare this Prophecy with other Paffages of the ficred Scripture, where the laft Coming of Chrift, and the Day of Judg- ment are defcrib'd, you will eafily find by the Refemblance and the Relation which the Expreffions have to each other, that the fame Time is dclign'd by all of them, and the fame State of Things. In all of them you fee Chrift coming in the Clouds of Heaven ; in all of them you fee an Army of Angels attending him, and in all of them hear the Clangor of the laft Trumpet proclaim him. Do State of Departed Souls, iffcl 13 5 Bo you know,you who maintain the contrary Side, tell me, I befeech you, in what Pla- ces do you own that the facred Scripture fpeaks of the true, the perfonal, and the laft Coming of Chrift ? I know very well that you believe in that Coming fo much expected, and fo much defir'd by Chriftians; and according to my Opinion, Chrift fpeaks of the fame in many Places, in many the Apoftles likewife. Chrift, for Example, fpeaks of it in the Gofpel of St. Matthew xvi. 27. but you will not allow it*; in Matthew xxiv. but you will not allow it ; in Matthew xxvi. 64. but you will not al- low it; Matthew xix. 28. and xxv. 31, 32. when you either deny, or hefitate. Besides, the Apoftles, in our Opinion, often fpeak of the fame ; as for Example, 2 Thejf. i. 7, 8, &c. but you are of another Opinion : Nor the Guards of Angels, nor the revenging Fire, nor the eternal Perdition of the Ungodly, which are all of them here commemorated, have Prevalency enough to prove to you that the ultimate Coming of Chrift in the End of the World is here to be underftood. Then in the fecond Epiftle of Teter, Chap. iii. 4, 8, 9, 10, &c. we be- lieve that the Coming of our Lord, that the K 4 Day * See Dr. Hammond upon thefe and the following Places, efpecially on Matt. xxiv. 3. Not. b. 2 TbeJJ . u and upon 2 'Pet. iii. and Lishtfoot upon the fourth of St. Mark, p. 18. 136 A TREATISE concerning the Day of Judgment, and the Diflblution and Renovation of this World are clearly ihewn and exhibited to us ; neither here do you give your AlTent. Laftly, we in like Man- ner interpret the fourteenth and fifteenth Verfes of the St. Jude, and the feventh of the firft Chapter of the Revelations ^ of the judicial and vifible Coming of Chrift ; and here you likewife prevaricate ; as likewife in fundry other Places, too numerous to be mentioned here. 'Tis with Pain that we fuffer fo many facred PalTages to be torn from us; Paflages on which all our Hope was founded, of the future Coming of Chrift. Nor is their Employment either grateful to Chriftians, or advantageous to Chriftianity, who make it their Bufinefs to leflen the Weight of the Prophecies, and to confine and conftrain their Senfe, which fometimes they do without Senle of Right or Shame, in fpite of the Reluftancy, both of the Spirit and the Let- ter ; as when the Preparation for the laft Judgment is manifeftly defcrib'd, or the Con- flagration of the World, or the Glory of the Father and the Angelick Guards; or laftly, Chrift himfelf descending from Hea- ven, and confpicuous in the Clouds of Hea- ven; they who pretend to reduce thefe Rea- lities, fo illuftrioufly manifeft, to Shadows and Figures, thefe Univerfals, comprehend- ing no lefs than a World, to the DeftrucHon of one City and Nation ; thefe Perfons feern to State of Departed Souls, &c. 137 to me not only to convert a rich Vein into a fteril one, but by an Interpretation of this Nature, to do Violence both to Words and to Things ; for what can be more manifeft than that Conflagration and the End of the World defcrib'd in the foremention'd PalTa- ges of St. Taul and St. Teter ; which yet they are pleas'd to refolve into I know not what chymerical Allegories ? But what we can ftill worfe endure, and what has ftill a nearer Relation to our Argument, is, that they wreft and diftort the Defcent of Chrifi in the Clouds of Heaven, (Matth. xxiv. 30.) from the Letter and the Truth, * and pretend that there is nothing meant by it, but the Judgments of God, and Punifhments that are fent from Heaven; when yet they might have learn'd the Force of that Expreflion from the Mouth and Information of an An- gel, who tells us, that this Coming in the Clouds is both true and perlbnal ; for faid the Angel, Te Men of Galilee, why ft and ye Aa • llt gazing up into Heaven ? This fame Jefus, which is fo taken up from you into Heaven, {ball fo come in like Manner as ye have feeti him * That the Word Clouds is to be taken in a literal Senfe, you may fee fullv prov'd by Gerard. Tom. ix de extrera. Jud. p. 67, 63. This Word is taken from 2)«%. vii. 13. where the Prophet is fpeaking of the fe- cond Coming of Chrift. By the Clouds of Heaven, the Jews underftand Angels, or the Guardian Hoji of Angels, fays Pearfcn on the Crecd^ p. 322. marg. ii 3 2 A TREATISE concerning the him go into Heaven, that is, peribnally and vifibly in the Clouds. It fecm'd tome to be of the greateft Con- ference, to make thefe fhort Remarks, that no Evidence might efcape me in an Affair of fo vaft a Moment, and in fo renown'd a Caufe ; for unlefs Chrift returns from Hea- ven, we are loft, vain is our Hope, and vain our Faith, as the Apoftle fpeaks concerning the Refurre&ion. But there are, befides, in the facred Writings, numberlefs Proofs and Teftimonies of this glorious and moll wifh'd- for Coming, which is exprefs'd by various Names. 'Tis for the raoft part call'd 7rap«- trloL Prefence, and fometimes cliroy.xAv-^is Re* velation, i Cor. i. 7. 2 Thejf. i. 7. 1 Tet. i. 7, 13. and iv. 15. Luke xvii. 31. fometimes 'tis named e7r«poiv& and I/aiah fpeaks plainly, Chap. lxvi. ixviii. 2,3. 1 <)> 16. For behold the Lord will come with fclxxxih. Fire, and with his Chariot like a IVhirl- xcvii. 5. wind, to render his Anger with Fury, and his Rebuke with Flames of Fire. The fame Prophet has the fame Meaning, Chap, xxxiv. 8, 9, 10. Befides, m the Prophet 'Daniel the Antient of 'Days is defcrib'd, as fitting. upon his Tribunal, and furrounded and co- Chap, vii. ver'd with Flames : His Throne was like the 9> 10. fiery Flame j and his Wheels like burning Fire : A fiery Stream ijfuedj, and came forth from before him : Thoufand Thoujands minijierd unto him, and ten thoufand times Ten thoufand food before him ; the Judgment was fet, and the Books were open'd. Laft- Chap.iv.i. ly the Prophet Malachy fhews us the fame Face of Nature upon that Day of the Co- ming of the Lord : Behold the 'Day comet h that will burn as an Oven,, and all the 'Proud, yea, and all that do wickedly jhall be Stubble, and the Ijay that cometh foall bum them up. Hitherto State of Departed Souls, fcV. 145 Hitherto we have brought PafTages from facred Authors, as Proof's of the fu- ture burning of the World upon the Coming of Chrift : And this Conflagration, and this Coming, ought, in my Opinion, to have a Place among the cleareft Doctrines of the Chriftian Faith, if we only have Regard to the Fads themfelves. But there are, befides, feveral Circumitances, Modes, and Condi- tions of this Conflagration, worthy of our Thoughts and our Contemplation, though not equally manifeft, nor equally neceffary to be known. 'Tis certainly worth our while to endeavour to difcover the very Time of this future Burning, and to have lome Foreknowledge of it ; to be able to fet forth the Bounds and the Limits of it ; how far it will reach upwards, and how far defcend j how far it will pierce into the Bowels of the Earth, or penetrate the Regions of the Skies ; and then to enquire into the Caufes and Seeds of this univerfal Burning, as far as 'tis founded in the Nature of Things, and the Matter and Form of the Earth. Laftly, to give an Account of its Beginning, its Progrefs, and its End ; and with what Shape and Countenance the Earth will ap- pear, when the Conflagration's over. Thele and other Things relating to thefe, we have handled more at large in the foremention'd Treatife, to which the Reader is defir'd to Theory of have Recouife, who has a Mind to be fur- the Earth. ther fatisiied upon this Subject CHAP, 144 ^TREATISE concerning the CHAP. VI. Of the laji Judgment : A View of its prin- cipal Appearances y of its Manner ', End t and Ejfefi. UPON the Coming of the Lord, the Dead arife, and appear before their Judge. The Refurre&ion, indeed, in the Order of Nature precedes this ; but of Things that are tranfa&ed at the fame Time, thofe are moll commodioufly handled firft, that can be fboneft difpatched. Now as of all Things that belong to our future State, the Doctrine of the RefurrecKon is of the moft Importance, it moll: of all requires our Care and our Application ; and therefore we have refer vM the laft Place for it, of the four Things which we propos'd to treat of. In handling this Subjed we lhall firft give the Reader a View of its principal Appear- ances, as 'tis reprefented and painted by the facred Writers. Secondly, the Thing itlelf, and its facred Truth ihall be explained accord- ing to a reafonable Hypotheiis : Laftly, and the End and Effect: of this Judgment upon the Innocent and the Guilty, upon the Ac- quitted or the Condemn'd ; and thefe Things appear to me to comprehend this Matter in general, and the moft ufeful Parts of it, re- jecting State of Departed Souls, &c. 141 jccHng feveral impertinent and fophiltical Disputes, which are wont to be carried on with fb much Noife in the Schools, without Advantage to either Side, and by which the Force of the Mind, employ 'd in fuperfluous Trifles, is diflipated and confum'd. A § for what relates to the View of its principal Appearances, in the firft Place the Judge is defcrib'd by the Prophet 'Daniel 'chap.vii^ fitting on his Tribunal, and furrounded by 9> IO - his Guards, in thefe Words ', / beheld \ fays he, till the Thrones were fit, and the An- cient of Days did fitj, whofi Garment was white as Snow, and the Hair of his Head like the pure Wool; his Throne was like the fiery Flame, and his Wheels like burning Fire : A fiery Stream ijfuedj and came fortl) from before him : Thoufand Thoufands mi- nifter'd unto him, and ten thoufand times Ten thoufand flood before him ; the Judg- ment was Jet, and the Books were 0" fen 3 d. In the Revelations of St. Join, the Judge, chap, «i the Judgment, and the Judged, are reprefent- "• &c, ed together. I faw, fays the Prophet, a great white Throne, and him that fat on it, from whofe Face the Earth and the Hea- -vens fled away, and there was found no Tlace for them : And I faw the Dead, fmall and great, ft and before God, and the Books were open'd; and another Book was ofien'd, which was the Book of Life ; and theDead were judged out ofthofe Things \, L which i^2 A TREATISE concerning the which were written in the Books, according to their Works. And the Sea gave up the Dead which were in it, and Death and Hell delivered up the Dead which were in them : And they were judged every Man according to their Works. And whofoever was not found written in the Book of Life, was caft into the Lake of Fire. Thefe Things are handled more diffufely than they are by 'Daniel, but the former exa&ly a- gree with the latter, as the Revelations are wont to do. Let us now attend to the Difcourfe of Chrift concerning the Proceedings of the laft Judgment, and the Sentence that is pro- nounced both upon the Good and theWicked. Mattxxv. wh en the Son of Man {hall come in his Glo- ry j and all the holy Angels with himj then {hall he fit upontheThro7te of his Glory. And before him {hall be gathered all Nations > and he {hall feparate them one from the o- ther, as a Shepherd divideth his Sheep from the Goats : And he {hall fit the Sheep on his Right Hand j and the Goats on his Left. Then {hall the King fay unto them on his Right Handj Come, ye Bleffed of my Father, inherit the Kingdom prepared for you from Ver.41. the Beginning of the World. Then (hall he fay alfo to them on his Left Hand; De- part from me, ye Cur fed, into the Fire pre- pared for the Devil and his Angels. Thus faith Chrift in the forefaid Palfage. 'Tis Matt. xix. a( ^ ec j - m f omc ot k er Places, that the Saints and State of Departed Souls, istci 14?' and the Apoftles will fit together in Judg- * Cor.vi. ment with him. < Re*k*3 If we compare thefe and other HkePalTages 4. of the facred Writings, this will be the Re- prefentation of the laft Judgment, this its dread» ful Appearance. A large burning Throne be- ing ere&ed, Chrift fits upon it as Judge, and with him fit the holy Apoftles. Chrift is at- tended and furrounded with his Minifters and Guards, the Angels. Then the Dead are placed before the Tribunal pale and trem- bling, fummon'd by the Trumpet's Clangor,; Which Things being thus fet in Order, and Silence commanded, the Regifter is brought^ or the memorial Books, in which the Deeds$ Words, Thoughts of every one, throughout his former Life, are marked : Thefe being opened and read, every one's Caufe is deter- mined according to his Works, or conform- ably to what he did in the Body. Then alt Things being weigh'dand examin'd, the Wic- ked being placed on the Left Hand, and the Good on the Right, the Judge pronounces Sen- tence, a Sentence for the Wicked unutterably dire : 'Depart from me, ye Cur fed, into ever- lafting Fire ; but a Sentence tranfporting and beatifying for the Good : Come, ye Blejfedof my Father j foffefs the Kingdom prepared for you from the Foundations of the World. In this Idea of the future univerfal Judg- ment, there are fome Things, without doubt, theatrically fpoken, conformably to the Man- ner of a human Court of Jnltice, Things L z that 144 A TREATISE concerning the that will not happen litterally upon the Day of Judgment. In this Part of the Sub- ject, I believe, we fhall have no Adverfa- ry : In the other Part, like wife, 'tis manifeft, that feveral Things will be litterally accom- plifhed, according as they are related. Chrift will defcend from Heaven perfonally, and vilibly, attended with his Angelick Guards, upon whofe Coming the Dead will be raifed, in order to undergo fome Examination or Probation, upon which every one's Deftiny will depend. But that thefe Things will be actually done under the Command and Conduct of Chrift, the facred Scripture abundantly teftifies, Matt. xvi. 27. John v. 22, 27. AEis xvii. 31. Rom.xlv. 9. 2 Tim. vi. 8. and in numerous other Places. You fee now that in this Reprefentation of the laft Judgment, there is a Mixture of the vulgar and the fecret Hypothefis. ^Tis the Part of a wife Man to diftinguiih what, and how much belongs to each of them. The Tryal of Souls, in order to punilh or reward them, according as each of them is undefiled or wicked, is the main of the Affair, the Defign, and the End of it. Nor is it of much Significancy, whether this Tryal proceeds, after the Manner of external Judi- catures, or a human Procefs, or by any other Way ; provided 'tis effectual, and obtains the End defign'd by it. Some of the An- tients were of Opinion, that this Tryal, at the Burning of the World, was to be per- formed State of Departed Souls, iffc'. 145 formed by Fire, of which we mall lpcak immediately. However, this is manifeft, that the Style of the facred Writers, in re- prefenting this judicial Proceeding, is accom- modated to human Cuftoms and InfKtutions ; and that neither Books nor Regifters will be found in the Air, nor the Hiftory of his pall Life be recited to every Individual. That every one will deferve the Fate which he meets with, will fufficiently appear by the Teftimony of his own Conference, and that State of Mind, in which he will be actually found. But we have faid that thefe Things are in a great Meafure accommodated to human Cuftoms and Inftitutions, and particularly to the Doctrines and the religious Belief of the Heathens, who constituted Judges in the infernal World, Obfervers of JufHce and E- quity, and the Rewarders and Revengers of human Actions. Their Names and their Bufinefs, and the various Punifhments which they inflided upon flagitious Men,-*are fuffi- ciently known from the Grecian Authors. ^P/ato, above all of them, has copiouily trea- ted of this Matter in feveral Places, as in his 'Phado, and towards the End of his Gorgiasy and in his Tenth Book of a Com- tntnwealthy under the Perlbn of Herus Ar- miniusy who was come back from Hell to make the Relation. But thefe and feveral other Things, which relate to the infernal World, and to the State of the Dead, were L 5 borrowe4 j aS A TREATISE concerning the borrowed by the Grecians from the Egyp- tians^ according to * < Diodorus Siculus 7 which, he fays, was begun by Orpheus , whom afterwards feveral Grecian Poets and Theologues followed. But thefe Things by-the-by. What is more worthy of Remark, is, that fome among the Antients were of Opinion, that there was no perfonal Miniftry, no artful Pomp or Or- nament, in the Diftribution of Juftice to human Souls ; but that the Nature of Things was by divine Providence fb prepared and ordered, that it w T ould fpontaneous diftri- bute Juftice to every Soul that mould be freed from its mortal Body. And, therefore, they gave the Name of Nemejls y and fome- times of Adrafiia, to this Force of God or Nature : 'AvcL7rc£p