DUKE UNIVERSITY LIBRARY Treasure %oom msm REMARKS ON THE PROCrtD14«5JGs OF THE CommffCtonet0 For putting in Execution The A C T paft laft Seflions, For Eftablifhing of a Land-Bank. LONDON, Printed, and Sold by the Bookfellers of Lonion and Weflm'mfier. \6<)6. ZZ ^ . , - 'r, . L^ J bad Induftry imagiaable.Andkisplain to any intelligent Man, how the extra- ordinary Intereft of Money has been like a Gangreen to many Eftates, and has reduced them to a very mean con- ci.ion; and the difficulty of mortga- ging Land is now to great, that be- iides the Legal Profits, ( if the Summ to be borrowed be confiderable ) the Len- der muil have a Prelent made him, be- fore he will condefcend to look at the Title. This was a melancholly pro- fpedl to Men of good Underftanding, and good Eftates, and therefore it needs not remain a Myftery to fo many, why the Parliament fhould be io fond of a Land Bank, as to refufe this Fund to the Bznko^ England^ and give it to them, Imce the former is the moft beneficial thing to the Landed-man that ever was projected, and the other profitable on- ly to a few Traders, who no doubt will confederate and unite their ftrength to Gppofe any Contrivance which is like^ ly to advance the Intereft of the Land- ed^ ed-man, and to leflcn their own ^ for had the Land-Bank fucceeded, it's evi- dent that the Intereft of Money mud in a htte time have been reduced to ^ /. per Cent, and Land confequently have rifenin purchafe proportionable to the fall of Money, which the monied and trading Men could not endure to chink of, much lefs to have it brought about j for what could be more ungrateful than the thoughts of conFuming dou- ble the time in their Trade, to accumu- late chat Wealth, which v^henpurcha- fed, will acquire but the fame Eirate of Inheritance, as what is gotten in half the time, at the rate as Land and Money goes at prefenc : For now ic's every days experience, that a few years fuccefs in Trade, renders Monied-raeii Maftersoffomuch Wealth, as enables them to purchale the moil confidera- ble Eftates in the Kingdom 5 fo that at this rate in fome few years, the Tra- ders will invade the antienc Gentry, and take away their Tlace and Ha* - . . L4J ^' tion. Thele^and fuch like Confiderati- onSjWere the caufe why theLand^Bank met with fo Httle Encouragement, I and lb ftrong oppohtion, for when the ■ Gentlemen of the Houfe of Commons i would by no means be induced to lay afide a Proportion, fo apparently advantagious to all Landed-aien in the ; Kingdom, then an Exchequer-Bank. wasinventedj either to hinder the o- ther, or at leaft to protrad time, and \ therefore the Projedors of it did not ! deiift from preffing that forward, 'till it was twice call out by a divifion of the Houle , and notwithflanding they w"ere firft beaten from their Out-works, yec they had a relerve ftill, hoping that if a Bill paffed in favour of a Land- Bank, to gee a mill-ftone to be tyed about its Neck that would not ; iail oF finking it, by providing that j the Exchequer might iffue out their ' Bills immediately for 150000 /. and I for the reft if the Bank did not raile it. I And tho' this was readily confented to by the Houfe of Commons, that his Majefty might have all Relerves for raifing the Money, yet the confequence of this proved to be a dividing theln- tereft as well as the Money, and made thofe who were lb fond ol a Bank un- der the Exchequer management, to be very little concerned whether the other had fuccefs or not ; and then they who law further into the Mill- ftone than others, gave it out in a mo dilli whifper, that the Bank would ne- ver come to any thing, which difcou- raged hundreds from fubrcribing,which no doubt was the intent of the Par- ties. Another difficulty was the re- quiring (o vaft aSummas 1282000/. before they could be a Corporation ; for if thefubfcribing 500000/. would have done, they would not have been obliged to ask nigh fo large a Premium as they did, which(by the way) was not fo extravagant as their Enemies repre- fented it to be, conhdering thefcarcity of Money at that time,when mofl; Men A xi valu- valued a raill'd Grown as if it had been \i an ancient Medal of one of their Ance- ftors j neither did they themfelves (whatever they pretended, ) think it fo, fince they were of Opinion, that had it been complyed with, the Money could not have been raifed ; but it is an eafie matter to find a ftick to beat a Dog. All Scruples,tho' never lo dark and nice, mull belaid hold of, and all the weak Sophiftry they were Maftersof, muft now be furbiflhed up to attack the Land- Bank ; but that imprudent and unreafonable demand ( as it was call- ed ) was not lb bold as welcome to fome, who were glad of that or any o- ther occafiontodeny the Land-Bank } and had their Demands been but a fifth part of what they were, it's likely they would have been thought unreafonable, for every Mole-hill feemed a Mountain, and they were lookt upon as fuch as intended to raile a Rebellion rather than Money : And it was ibmething ftrange, to fee fuch an indifferency to thofe Ithofe who endeavoured to bring in fiicK a Mafs of Wealth •, but it could not be the Money that was difliked, but the Method of raifmg it 5 for the grand Debate was. Whether thefe Chimera's and Idols of Fancy ^ called E — Bils mud do it or nocjvvhich at laft being refolved in the affirmative, 5ow if this be a Crime, it is not the firft thatParhaments have been guilty of in that nature, having ferved the Church of England the fame fauce be- fore, which all People muft allow was byLaweftablifli'd, and was as much the Church oi England as the otlier is the ^ank of England, taking the word Tk in its utmoft latitude. Neither can it be denyed, but that the Church of England has been as ferviceable to the Govern- ment as the Bank, and is much better calculated for Co being, than this or any any other Bank can poffibly be.' And in truth, the Bank hath been ra ther ferviceable to the Subje^s than the|a Government, for ifym refled on thet Proceedings of the Bank for this laft fix I Months, we muft take the People to be in their minority,and to have chofenthe Bank for their Guardians. It is well known, that the defire of living above our Fortunes, has been an Epidemical Diftemper to the People of this King- dom, and elpecially to the Gentry : Now the cure of this Difeafe is totally owing to the Bank, for their Pious and Paternal Care ought never to be forgot- ten, in diligently enquiring into Mens circumftancesjwhen they came for their Money, Vi^.What Family they had? what Children ? what fervants ? and what other Neceflary Expences they were obliged to fupport, and fupplyed them not according to their own extravagant demands, but with what was conveni- ent for the Neceflaries, not for the Lux- ury 1 ity of Life. Mow to do any thing a- jainft the intereft of thefe our Spiritual ind Temporal Bencfaftors, mull argue the higheft ingratitude. But the Bank may be contented to run the fame Fate with the Church, linceitwas as much the Intent of the Legiflators to have but one Faith as one Bank. - But here it will be faid by the Dire- aors of the Bank, that although the Confequence of the Toleration will be fctting up as many Churches as there are different Opinions amongft Man- kind, yet the Dire6torsofthe Church of England put all other Churches under Contribution, and receive Tithes from all, like the City Council, who muft be fee'd though you make ule of others. To this may be laid, that the Church have a Legal Right to Tithes, and can force People to pay them, which the Bank ( to their Grief) have not, to force People to depofite their Money -, but if the pay- ments PJfflSSSIllSgSffl^^ mentsofTirhes had been as voluntarJ as putting Money into the Bank, it hac been no more unlawful to eftablidi a Toleration than it is now. But here perhaps they will Objedt, that if the Church were really as iU^ ufed as the Bank, yet that is an Ag-I gravadon of the Grime rather than an * Excufe, which is very true; but I de- ny that either have been fo ill ufed, or the publick Faith broke to either,- for nothing paffes in an AdofParli- nient, but what is given by exprefi' words, or fomething neceffarily im- ' plyed. I fuppofe the Bank does not pretend that another Bank is exclu- ded by exprefs words ; and it is the moft unreafonable thing in Nature to make the particle The fuch a Mon- ger, as to carry in its belly, all the Calli in the Kingdom, and to be oeitruaive to all future Corporations and Bodies Politick. But I dare be bold to affirm, that if the Parliament had had fufpeifled this' Particle to have im- ported but the loth. part of what is by Tome fuggefted, they would have fent loo Miles for a word rather than have ufed it ; and therefore ic can be no Crime, in foro Conjcimtie, to fet up another Bank, • And the' the DiredtorsoftheBank of Enoland were not blameable, tor ufing all their Intereft to hinder the Aftlrom paiting, yet when ( notwich- ftanding all the oppofition that could be rande ) the Ad paffed, and the King's Affairs, and the Affairs of all Europe, in a great meafure depending upon the Succefs of it, then, I fay, to appear fo vigoroully againft it, and to ftrain fo hard, as to bankrupt themfelves, rather than the Land- Bank fhould rife, favoured rankly oi Malice and Self-intereff. Neither can the Diredors of the Bank of England be taken by any intelligent Man, to be fuch Patriots as they would have the World fuppofe them to b; -, but ■ ^ P- T I will detain you no longer in the Porch, but proceed to the Objeai- ons made againft the Gentlemen that propofed and profeciued the Land- Bank. _ fir/?, That they undertook the raif- ing 2564000 /. at 7 /. per Cent. per. petual Intereft, redeemable by Parlia- ment. Secondly, That contrary to their firft Prqpolals, they infilled upon an Extra- vagant Premium of 500000 /. Thirdly, That they were not able to raifetjie Mone'y upon the Premium they delired, nor could give any Se- curity to do it. ^ Fourthly, That they mined theCre-' dit of the Bank of England. I propofe to znCwer thefe Objeai- ons, and then to fliew, Firji, That the Bank of England, through their Covetoufnefs and want of Tlnderftanding, min'd their own Credit. Secondly, If thisTuRd had been of. ven II ven either to the Bank of England^ oi the Exckquer alone, it could not have been fo eafily railed as by a Land- Bank. f Thirdly, That there is no v/ay to teftore Paper-Credit but by a New Bank* The Firft Objeaion is, Ti?at they undertook the raifing of 2564000 1.'^^ */ 1. per Cent; perpetual Intereft. To this I Jnj\)?er, l^hat neither the Gentlemen concerned in the Land- Bank, or any Perlon, or Body or^Per- fons in England^ did, or could under- take fo great a Summ ; but when Me- thods were propofcd in the Hou'e of Commons for raifing this Money, they offered their Opinions, that it might be raik^d by a Land-Bank, and that 7 /. per Cent, was fjfficient \Lv- couragemenc, as the Tre.^fury and Courtiers thought it m>^z be bcft railed by an Exchequer-Bank, ando- thers by different Methods -, and if they were miftaken, ( as 1 (hall endeavour B Z . CQ I to fhew they were not ) k is what the Treafury werein their Exchequer bank, and what any one elfe in probabiUty would have been^confidering the diffe- rent circumftances of the Kingdom v^/hen the Propofals were made, and when the Money was to be raifed. Second Obje(51:ion. That they inft/ied upon an extravagant ^nm'ium of -^oooooh To this I Jnfiver^ They were obliged to it. 1 . By the Difcouragement and Ob- ftruaions they met with in theHoufe of Commons in the paffing their ©///. 2. The Condition of the King- dom in relation to Money and Cre- dit vvas very different when the Pro- pofals were made, and w^hen the Mo- ney was to be raifed, and therefore they were obhged to enlarge their Demands. F'lrft^ The Difficulties they met with in paffing their Bill were thefe, Ftrft. The Members of the Bank of Englmd were excluded from fubfcrib- m\ Se. Secondly, They were not to be la- corporated upon a lels Summ than liSzJoo '. by which Diicourage- ment not one in ten would fubicnbe 'till they were aflfured of being a Cor- poration, efteemingthat Priviledgeto be half their bargain, and fearing the Subfcriptions might not amount to that Summ; whereas if the Subfcribers had been qualified to be a Corporation up- on the fubfcvibing 500000 /. that Summ had been lubfcribed in thrCe days,by the CommiflTioners themfelves, and the Members oi Exeter Exchan^^e ; and if they had been once entituled to a Corporation, there could b.e no doubt but the whole Money would be fub- iciibed afterwards, fince it would be then a greater Encouragement to come in at Var than upon 20 fer Ce«t. Pre- mium before. . Thirdly, When they offered a Claufe to their Aa,to naturalize fuch aswould fubfcribe 500 /. and had reafonable Affurance from the Forreigners upon B 3 the I tlie Exchange, that luch encourage- ment would bring in 400000 /. that daufe being thrown out, the flock of the Bank of England advanced, and their Wagerers upon the Ex- change offered odds againft the Suc- cefs of the Land-Bank. Fourthly^ Their Bill was delayed To long by the oppofition it found, that they could not get their Commiffion paffed before the ^th. of May^ by which means it was left in the power of the Treafury to refufe or take the fourth part of their Subfcriptions in clipc Money, which was a particular hardfhip upon a great number of People, who avoided putting in their dipt Money upon other Funds, in hopes of fubfcribing ic, and making their firfi: payments with it in this Bank 5 and reafonably hoped fince they paid to the recompence, to have their dipt Money made good to them as well as to others. And I believe it has been every ones ones Obfervation, that feveral Gentle- men of the Bank o^ England^ and others, Oppofers of the Land-Bank, would often infult over them upon their Sue- cefs in the Houfe of Commons,' and ask them what was become of their Bank, tho' now they call them' Jacobiiies, and threaten to impeach them, for not doing what they them- lelves rendered impoifible for them to do. The fecond Reafon I gave, was^ the different Circumftances of the Kingdom when the Propofals were made, and when the Money was to be railed : As, 1. Guineas were taken at^o5. and it was not known whether the Parli- ament would bring them down or no.^ 2. Paper-Credit was good, aadche Bank of England and the Goldlmiths paid tlieir Bills puridually, whereas at the time this Money wasto'be rail- ed, both refuled. ■X. Tallies were equal, or better :i than tlian Money, whereas afterwards they were 20, ^o, and 40 per Cent. Difcount, by which means People could make a much greater advantage oF their Mo- ney, and therefore would notfubrcribe it upon the fame terms as they thought before reafonable. 4. It was hoped at firft not above 60 per Cent, would be called in, where- as afterwards by the Univerfal Fall of Credit, and want of Money, no one thought of paying lefs than the whole Summe fubicribed. 5. There was an actual want of Money in Specie in the Kingdom, leven Millions in and out of the Ex- chequer being rendered ufelefs, by which means the Commiffioners faw it impoffible to get the Money fub- fcribed, and paid in Specie, and there- ^ fore defigned to take Tallies, good Goldrmiths Bills, and Bank Bills, and dipt Money by weight at a high rate for Subfcriptions, and fo asked' 300000 /. Pra^mium, believing it^ Would — .^r.»— «»^Me,«^_. would colt them full as much to Dif- count the feveral Species aforefaid for Money, which they propos'd to pay to the King. ItistobeObfervedhere, (i.) It the 7 00000 /. defired had been granted to the Land-Bank, their bargain had not been fo great as the Bank of Eti' ^land's ; for the Bank of Bg/.W having 'tooooo /. per Ann. for izooooo /. they gave but \t years purchafe fot their Fundi befides, they had allow- ed them 4000 l.ptrAmu for their Char- ges : Whereas, if 300000 /. had been dedufted out of this Fund, the remain- der had been 1x64000 /. which di- vided by 179000, the Intereft they were to receive makes near i ; years purchafe ; and I believe the fcarcenefs and goodnefs of Money confidcred, When the Bank of Engkni was raifed, and when the Land-Bank vvas to be raifed, any one but themfelves will believe that the latter deferved at leaft equal Encouragement J and its pro- • - bable _^^^ t' p bable the Parliament would have gi-' venir, ifthey hadforfeen the Difficul- ties that have fince happened. 2. That the Comiffioners did not' ask the 300.000 /. out of the Salt- Fund, but upon the Exchequer in ge- neral, which could not be paid them but by the Confent of the Parliament,^ 5.nd fb they left themfelves to the Par- liament whether they deferved ic or I no. ^Jll^d '.'-ri 5. At the time.^t1ie"y asllced 'thofe Tallies on the Exchequer in general, ^ i it would have coil 40 /. per Cm. to dilcount them, which reduced their Denaaods. to lefs than 200000 1 4. If xheir Ternqis had been com- ply edwich, the greateft part of the Subrcriptions would have been made i^ ;Clipt;^oney arid Pkte, which wouifi.Iiave been coiped to encfeale our Speqes of Maoe^y, and it's rj>ro. bable would lavp the' Nation' next year near as mucKin the recompence for cljpt Money, and Encouragement ' for bringing in the Plate as the Summ dencianded. 5. The Exchequer has not borrow- ed any Money (6 cheap fince. The Third Objection. Jhat they were not able to raife the Money upon the ^?re^ mmn they askd^ nor could they giVe any Security to do it. This Objection juftifies them in asking the Premium refuled ; for it is very unjuft to tax them for asking too much, and yet to confels it was not enough to induce people to fub- fcribe the Money. However, I offei: thefe Reafons that it would be fub- fcribed. 1 . They Propofed they might open their Books for Private Subicriptions, not doubting within three days they might bring Hands for near the Summ toberaifed, which was not thought fit to be granted to them, it being Object- ed it would be a Difencouragement to the real Subfcriptions. 2. When they were fent for to at- tend II tend the Lords Juftices, and were ask- ed, What Security they could give of raif* ing the whole Summ ? They Ankvered, That they computed the Commifjtoners theni^ fehesy and the Members of Execcr-Ex- change, would (uhjcrwe 700000 1. that they believed they p?ould k able to bring in as much more by their hitereft and Acquaint tance^ and they thought it reafonable to [up* pofe the whole l^ngdom would fuhfcribe the reji. ^. That they thought the Nature of the thing would admit of no other Security than what they offered, fince it could not be expected that any num* ber of Perlons would enter into Re- cognizances to raile the Summ. 4. It was Iblely to their Difadvan* tage if they did not fublcribe to be a Corporation, fince by the failure they would only entitle themfelves to 7 per Cent, in the Exchequer, which no one would give 70 /. for, and therefore it is to be prefumed they would take fiich care for their own fakes, as not to to lofe 50 per Cent, of their Money ; which if they did not, it would folely redound to the advantage of the Pro- jedors of the Exchequer-Bank, who would have the Money that was fub- fcribed to circulate their own Bills. 5. When they became a Corpora- tion, ic cannot be doubted but the whole Money would be quickly fub'* fcribed, fince then the advantage of fubfcribing would be much greater, (as 1 laid before) and it was not in the power of the Commiflioners to hinder any one from fubfcribing that thought ic his Intered j but admitting the Subfcriptions would have ftopt when they were qualified to be a Cor- poration, I believe mod People arc of Opinion now, that 1 1 82x^00 /. would better ferve his Majefties occafions, than nothing, though the Arithmetick of that time was, that half was lets than none. The Fourth Objeaion is. That they rmdthe Credit of the iB^^A 0/ England ; and and here thefe worthy Patriots mak' bold with the Parliament, and fay, the^ - broke their Faith with them, in fetcin^iy ^- up another Bank. I Jnjwer^ I . There are no words in the Ad of Parliament, that direftly or iadi- redly exclude the Parliament fron- fetting up another Bank: The Ad onlj incorporates a Body of Men to fue and be fued, which if it fliould amount to a prohibitory Claufe, excludes King and Parliament ever hereafter to graait a Corporation, lince every Corpom- tion, fingle perlon, or number of per- fbnsin England-, m^ay lawfully do what thefe Gentlemen pretend to have the Monopoly of. 2. The Land-Bank was excluded fromdifconnting Bills of Exchange, lending Money upon Pawns, dealing in Bullion, C^c. and every thing elfe, but lending upon Land, and to the Government, and therefore could pof^ fibly be no difad vantage to the Bank of Englandy who-do not pretend to lend upon Land. y If ^. Iftfie other Bank had taken ef- ^cCt^ lis probable the Bank ot England nvould have had more Cafh left wich hem than before, fince it would have been the Intereft of both Banks to have agreed 5 and then without doubt they mioht have divided the Goldfnaiths proHts between them, and lo each Bank have more Depofices than the Bank of England had before. 4. If the fecting up a Land-Bank would be a Difadvantage to the Bank Oi England^ it was no injuftice toefta- bhfli them, fince the ParUament gave no Warrant to the contrary, and their bargain was great enough iiotwith- Handings and greater than they thought was iic to be granted- to the Land-Bank, who were to raifc.more than double the Summ, in lels time, when the Difficulties were greater, and the Coin better •, they had but 7 L per Cen^ excluded fronri many Advantages the Bank oS: En^mi had, and were ol> ^ ligcd' belides cu lend 5ooccoj.^:r^:/?i- nuniy at ^ Lxos. o d. per Cent. Intcreft, 5, If the eftablifliing the Land-Bank did encreafe the Demands upon the Bank of England^ it was canfed by the unreafonable oppo fition they gave ro it ^ which failing of the Effect they propoied, gave them that Dif* reputation that always attends thole that are overcome, for the World had . reafon to believe they underftood their own Intereft beft; and when they Teem- ed to wind up their whole happinefs in defeating the Land-Bank, and mifcarri- ed, it is not to be wondered if other People thought their Condition to be worfe then it was. That the Covetoufnefs and want of Underftanding of the Bank of £?g* land was the Occafion of their lofs of Credit ; To prove which I fliall fliew, 1. That they left undone thole things which they ought to do. 2, They have done thole things, which they ought not to do. ' ' ' 1 . To the firft^ They ought to have* foreleen. foreften, chat softer the 4t/;.of A% ih^ Demands upon them would be greatei^ than before, for admitting the World had as good an Opinion of their Cre- dit as ever, yet the nece/Tityof Peopld muft call upon them for Money, fot the whole Silver Species of England being flink in a day, they might be af- fured all People would want Money for their ordinary occafions ; and what- ever opinion they had of their Securi-' ty, would call for it when they had demands, and therefore they ought to have made Provifions to anlwer them. 2. They fiiould have called in as many of their Bills as they could, whereas they iflued out Bills till the j^th.o^Mayj and how many fincethe^ ftopt their payments is belt known to themielves. 5. They rhight have bought Gui- neas for Tallies and dipt Money, when Tallies were par^ and dipt Money cur- tant,and Guineas playing, between lis. .2 C and and 24 5. which Weeks or a Month. |t 4. They might have called in their 40 L per Cent, either before or immedi- ately afcer the j{tk oi May^ and not kept Money in their Pockets whicb they owed to other people, 5. When they could not pay all their Demands, they might have allow- ed the difference which their Credir tors gave to dilcount their Bills, fince it is more realbn the Debtor fliould pay it than the Creditor. 6. They might have allowed the Intereft they received, or at leaft Le- gal Intereft, v^hen they were notable to pay the Principal ..n To the laft they Object, That they (offered Tallies to any that demanded them^l winch ^as the Security they had. I Art-- fwer, r I I. It lyes upon them to prove, they ever offered any Tallies payable with- in three Months, but only fuch as it wasi worth 10 L per Cent, to difcounc. - a. If z. If they had offered fuch Tallies^ t had not been fufficient, fince their Creditors did nottruft the Exchequer, but them, and expeded their Money upon demand, as the Bank is liable by Law to pay it, or otherwife they would rather have put theit Money into the Exchequer for Tallies them- lelves, and have receiv'd the Incereft from the beginning, than let the Bank receive the Intereft of their Money till they call for it, and then give them but part of that Security which they might have had at firft, and upon fuch Funds as the Bank thought fit to fpare, whereas themfelves might have chofen their own Funds. If thefe Methods would not have fully anlwered their Creditors, atleaft it would have given them the Cha- rafters of honeft Men, and of doing all that they were able to do. "Next I am to prove the Bank of England have done thofe things which thev ousht not to do. ^ ^ C z 1. They J, They extended their Credit ije-i ,yond 1 100900 /. and by that means ^fun in debt more than they were able! to pay, whereas it is very evident the A<^ of Parliament defigned to confine i;heir Credit to j 200000 /. which theit, Fund was anfvverable for, byobhging tbem ngt to iflfue out a greater Summ ppon it i not imagining that they would pvade the Ad, by iOuing out Notes, which bound not themfelves, nor was my ways Security to thofe that accept- ed theni. For it is not to be conceiv'd fbe Parliament defigned they fhould borrow any Money, but what they could give Security for, and not under phe flieiter of an Ad of Parliament de- ceive innocent People, who do not know a Corporation is not bound, but under their Common-Seal. ?. When they had thus evaded the A(5V, and vyere afraid to be called to account by the next Parliament, to fweeten the Contrey- Gentlemen they promifed to ]^nd Monqy upon Land, to mmBmsmammaasoM ' io any one th^t offered them good Se- curity, which I hope they have nciore modefty then to iay they have per- formed, and by that means have juftly raifed the indignation of the "NobiUty, and Gentry againft them, who hoped to be eafed from the Extortion of bcri- veners and Ufurers. ^. They undertook a fooUfli Bar- gain, to return Money for Flanders ^ by which they have loft a Summ beft known to themfelves, whereas it might have done better by the Merchants, who(e Bufinels it was, and who un- ftood it better. They alledge, they did ittolervethe Government, but I think it will be hard to fatisfie the World, that they were contented to lofe 80000 /. to fave the King 20000 /. and therefore it will be rather account- ed their Folly than Zeal. 4. Within few days before the J^th. of Majiy they gave Bills payable upon demand for dipt Money, whereas it is probable, the fame perfons would have have been contented to have taken them payable fix Months after, orelfo they need not have given them at all, 5^ By their unrealonable Oppoiiti- on they gave to the Land-Bank, they rendered the raifingoftheSumrapro- pofed ineffedual^and coniequenrly dit abled themfeives, by not receiving Co much Money as was appropriated to their own ule out of that Fund. 6. 27. Whether they did not addrels themfelves to the Treafury, to have their Bills refufed in the Cuftoms i if fb, it was a great diminution to their Credit, 7. To finifh their mine, they lent 200000 /• to the King, when they paid but 5 /. per Cent, of their Debts, and fome (ay to hinder the Land-Bank Propafals from being accepted. Here I am aware I fhall be anfwer- ed, that they did it out oi Zeal to his Majefty, and to (erve the Government ; this they think will juftifie all their ^'^iliarriages, and proteft them for adins adling againft the Rules of Juftice and Prudence, therefore it ought to be exa- mined. They have ferved the Go- vernment, I grant ic^ butit wastolervc themfeivesi a Mifer would be as good a Friend^ they have lent the Govern- ment Money, but upon as great Inte- reft as the Parliament allowed, and greater than they could get elfewhere. They have lent other Peoples Mo- ney, and not their own, and at the iame time refufe to pay tho(e to whom it belongs ; whereas if their Zeal for the Government had been as great as they pretended, they would have rail- ed Money in their private Capacities, and lb lent what was their own, or at lead given their Creditors the In- tereft they received, butinftead of that they keep part of their principal Mo- ney in their hands, and what they have already called in for they pay 6 Iper Cent, to themfelves, though they deny it to their Creditors. 1 will put them two Queftions. ^ ^ t.If 1. If a Man robs another of his Mo^ ney, and lends it to the Government will it juftifie this Robbery ? 2. Whether detaining a Mans Mo- ney fiom him,and lending it at Intereft without giving the Intereft received, be' not in foro Conjcienm as bad as taking! it from him ? I believe if the Scene were changed from Grocers-Hall to Lumhard'flreet^ we fliall all be of an Opinion. I leave with a Goldimith looo /.hd gives me his Note payable upon de- mand, I go to him jfix Months hence, and ask him for my Money, he tells me the Government was in great di- ftrefs, and he lent them my Money ; I tell him I gave him no fuch Com- miflion, but finding my felf remedilefs, I ask him to allow me the Intereft he receives, he refufes it ^ I then ask him to give me his Bond, and Legal Inte- reft, he refutes that ; I fancy if I flhould •pHllhimby the Nofe, Iflhould be ju- ftified by moft of thofe Gentlemen that ar© n^^»^^««iiiM»g^ii»«^^^^^ jjHre of another Opinion, in Ithe cale of the Bank of England. The next thing 1 have to prove, is, ^:hat if this had been given to the Ex^ ::hequer alone, or to the Bank offi/g;^ jW/, it would not have beenfoeafily raifed as by a Land-Bank. And fiift for an Exchequer-Bank, i.TheProjedors themlelves propofe 400000 /. always to lye ftill to cii:- culate their Billsj, ( whichis tobe ufed to no other purpole whatloever ) which mud be wannng upon the Sak-Fund, jtoanlwerHis Majefties Occafions, or .elle muft be railed upon another ; and fo 400000 /. inuft be railed extra- ordinary, whereas the Land-Bank ask- ed but three. 2. If the Demands upon the Exche- quer flio.uid exceed the 400000 /. which it's, likely they would, (every Body knowing their Stock ) the Ex- chequer will be broke, and theCre- tdic of the Government lunk; whereas the Land-Bank may be able to anlwer D all B all cheir Bills ; or if they fliould not, the Government will iuffer no difcredit by it. ^. If the Exchequer fiiould refufi Payment, the Credicor has no reme- dy, but upon 7 /. per Cent, which he will not value at 70 /. whereas if the Bank iliould refule Payment, he would have Remedy for his whole Money. Note^ If the Exchequer-Bank fliould have Credit, Intereft upon Land muft be at 8 or 10 per Cent. For it is not to be imagined any one will lend upon Land at the ufual Intereft, when he can have it upon demand, wdch 4 /, 1 o s. running Intereft j and therefore fuch a Bank can't be of as great Ad- vantage as a Bank that would raile the Land, and leffen the Intereft of Mo- ney 5 for an Exchequer-Bank can be of no ufe to any one, but iuch as have the management of the 400000 /. which may be made ufe of to lend his Majefty upon Funds, and to circulate the Tellers Notes, which fome lay has been a com- common pradice, fince they have C^t up the Trade ofBanking. 2. That the Bank oiEnxlanJ could not have raifed this Summ as well as the Land-Bank ^ to illuftrace which it muft be examined, which way they could have propofed to raife it, and that muft be either i . By iflfuing out Bills upon their Credit. 2. Or by opening their Books for New Subfcriptions. As to the firft : I fuppofe they will not pretend to iay, that i.Iuing out two Millions and a half of Bills more, pay- able upon demand, would enable them the better to anlwer thofe that were then out^ and it they had opened their Books for New Subfcriptions, they muft have let the New Subfcribers come in at IPary with their Original Stock, or not ; and it is not likely they would do the former, fince by the paf* fing a Bill in their Favour, their Ori- ginal 60 L being then valued at 90 I. might have been itock-jobbed to i 5 o /. And the letting New Subfcriptions D z come L42J come in upon equal terms, muft have reduced their ftock to its Original Va- lue 5 for no Man would buy it at more, if he could fubfcribe at par •, and if they had opened their Books for Subfcrip- tions, according to the Improved Va- lue, no one but would rather fubfcribe his Money to a New Fund, where he might come in upon equal terms^ than adjoyn a real value with an imaginary one, 3. But admitting they would have fo much Self-denial to accept Subfcrip- tions at par^ yet by the Money they raife they muft pay their Bills that are out already, as well as the 2564000^. w^hereas the Land-Bank are to pay no more than they receive. 4, Moft People would rather fub- fcribe to a New Bank, than one that has loll its Credit. Therefore I infer, if it could not be raifed by a Land-Bank, it could not be raifed by this Fund. The next thing I have to fliew, is, ■■■■■iHliiil^^ 'hat there is no way to reftore Pa- er-Credit but by a "New Bank. I fljaU take it for granted, that Pa- ,er will never go for Money, but vhen I can have Money for it upon iemand •, for no Man will part with •eady Money for a Note, or take a Note for Money upon any other Con- fideration, and therefore Paper can ne- ver be reftored, unlefs the Bank of Eng' land and Goldfraiths pay their Notes, or elfe another Fund is let up that can. t. The Bank of Bngland if they were difpofed to pay their Debts, can- not poOibly do It ; their Money as it became due from the Exchequer, is not enough to anlwer 5 per Cent ot their Debts, and they can never have any Credit till thev can anfwer all De- mands, which muft require greatec Summs then they have, or can pofli. bly get. a. If they had Money enough to anfwer all Demands, it is probable it would be all called from them i for Repu- Reputation is lo nice a thing, that], it's once blown upon, 'tis rarely reca vered, efpecially in a matter that fc nearly concerns us, as parting with oui Money j for it will be a hard matter to induce me to truft one, that throuoh Indifcretion or Defign has deceived me. 3. It cannot be imagined that any one will bring in Money to be depo- fited with them, for that is to pay in 100 /. and get 5 /. with a Weeks trouble when I want it again. 4. The giving them a New Fund, is enabling them to cheat more People, for by the Monies that rife upon it, they muft not only purchafe their Fund, but anfwer the Bills that are out before; and if their Creditors fhould not be fo good natur'd to flop their Demands, they muft their Pay- ments. As to the Goldfmiths reviving Credit, I fuppofe no Man experts Re- formation from them, or that any thing will make them honeft but a Catch- Pole Pole : And of the Exchequer-Credit we have had an Eflay already, which with what I have faid of it before, is fufficient, therefore I argue, that Paper Gredit can be reftored by no other means, than by a Mew Bank, and fctling a Frefli Fund of Credit. 1 i6 % '>^^ )imQ mi dL J riaz^tri^ i mm ■i HilHIHiHHIIIHIIHHIi