r Cornell University Law Library. THE GIFT OF 0a,et.2^..../^?...Z.fA.^.- 9181 CORNELL UNIVERSITY LIBRARY 3 1924 066 074 695 (flnrupU ICam irlynnl ICtbraty '^^y. Cornell University Library The original of this book is in the Cornell University Library. There are no known copyright restrictions in the United States on the use of the text. http://www.archive.org/details/cu31924066074695 TAYLOR'S ANALYZED CITATIONS of the NEW YORK SUPREME COURT REPORTS Subscription, $10.00 for the First Edition Renewals, $5.00 per Year Cumulative Supplements in February, July and November Copyrighted 1919 by Zachary P. Taylor, Rochester, N.^Y. ZACHARY P. [TAYLOR, Rochester, N. Y. m^oji PREFACE IMPORTANT FEATURES OF THIS EDITION First — ^The analysis of all Citations is made up from the opinion of the court, and not from the syllabus of the case, thus covering all points in the citations of the court. ■ Second — ^The history of each case is recorded wherever cited in the New York court of Appeals, and in the Supreme Court of the courts of record of New York State. Third — ^These analyzed citations, giving at a glance the point cited in each case, avoid the necessity of looking at the syllabus or else- where, and will economize the time of the bench and bar. Fourth — Bound volume editions bring these citations down from 1847 to July I, 1919, which are continued with November, February and July Cumulative Supplements. Fifth — They show the determination of each case in the court of last resort, if the case has gone up on appeal, either aa afhrmed, re- versed, modified, distinguished, etc., and subsequent, citations of the case in all the courts of record in this State. Sixth — ^This and succeeding issues are sold with the express agreement that the subscriber will destroy previous issues. Zachary p. Taylor Rochester, N. Y. ABBREVIATIONS Ab. Abbott's Decisions. A. C. N. Y. Annotated Cases. A. D. Appellate Division. Am. D. American Decisions. A. R. American Reports. A. S. American State Reports. H. A. Howard's Appeal. K. Keyes' Reports. N. C. Abbott's New Cases. S. N. Selden's Notes. S. T. Silvernail's Supreme Court Repons. Tr. Transcript Appeals. U. S. United States. B. Barbour. H. Hun. L. Lansing. M. Miscellaneous. N. Y. N. Y. Court of Appeals. S. N. Y. Supplement. S. A. Silvernail's Appeals. T. C. Tompson and Cook. M. Miscellaneous Reports, N. Y, Supreme Court Reports — Barbour Vol, 1 560 dower 44 372 565 estate title a 2 NY 355 584oorpn bowers riAD 649 24 H 418 19 M K5K el4NY 37fl 136 NY 411 not rescind 106M 356 592 estover 68LRA 649n 599 f'd repreeen 67 415 10 H 221 statute frauds 27 H 120 ITC 260 610 estoppel 24 57 41 97 49 88 627 usurious 55 NY 623 635 construction 28 326 39 44 98AD. 452 39 US 737 32 NY 707 33 NY 281 sp. performance 25 NY lag 636 statutory 158 AD 7HH 144 S 472 VOL. I 9 husband title 116 NY 693 I I tax costs 16 693 594 1 9 taxpayer el6 34 18 NY 20 bond 16 NY 24 domain case 2 96 NY indemnity 74M 29 power ot 21 H 448 237 116 512 30 pers knowl. 82 H 359 lOS AD 687 3 1 atfidavit 17 .AC 318n 34 mandamus 47 45 27 NY 385 36 revival INY 44 undue inil. 26 NY 219 12 48 valid judgt, 1 L 192 53bill particular 87 NY 276 58 trust power 4L 37 H 65 nuisance r4NY 5 affidavit 16 intention 180AD 167S 70 recsiver 68 AD 238 22 126 555 478 347 951 17 71 serv protest 3M . 230 service 50 M 277 risk service 198NY 135 72 new matter 62 75 priority dl title e 10 power sale 12 16 25 H creditor lien 29 H 32 H e42 H 46 H 64 NY 105 NY subrogation 61 H ?Fesumption 4H 79 H 18 M crops 23H no reform 648 398 250 119 195 411 255 47 598 654 401 497 480 278 485 133 122 861 UOAD . reinstated 99M 295 163 S 674 construction 180AD 403 167S 831 89 inchoate ISAD 304 308 legatee rent 16 H remedy 25 H title 130 NY 220 commissions IH 78 3TC 81 225 considerat n 179 362 416 520 94 legacy 37 H 86 US vesting 78 M 23fi 138S 157 time not essence 78 M 239 138S 159 1 02 construction 255 176 a INY e2 a7 10 30 ejectment IH 4TC 483 132 224 601 334 560 147 I 1 4 money in ct. 3 412 rescission 10 376 602 297 442 289 187 11 600 3H 6TC 10 NY 59 M joinder 165 NY award 48 48H 137 receiver r 1 NY 330 146 set aside 84 M 631 I 55error evid'ce 6 462 463 7 688 charge 55 . 613 157 damages 39 CP 204 1 58 per. demand 1 Ni e6 e24 e31 227 parties 20 H 37 NY 3Tr 36 NY residence 16AG 448 666 192 184 240 337 681 164n 230 admissions 37 67 1 L 3L 2H 3H 19 H 4 TO 8 NY 21 NY 141 NY 165 NY will trustee 123 NY foreign executor 41 48 158 S 543 title legacy 95 M 45 235 weight of ev 3 370 639 172 263 483 250 159 259 108 322 74 684 279 249 68 25 46 4 6 6 8 17 7L a3NY conclusive 8 471 666 426 456 392 502 435 238 satisfaction 6H 670 land source 170 NY 602 execution' 135S 218 243 land 5LRA liable 283n 321 499 511 288 consid. proof 26 469 1 65 money equ 26 M 779 I 68 conclusion 70 249 28 47 4H 25 H evidence 49 NY costs e31H notice 6 TO 1 87 jurisdiction 26 486 2 1 assignment 4 242 184 166 179 379 612 2 1 7 law remedy 248 jurisdiction do 48 261 271 re-hearing 2 546 usury personal 344 6 26 elTr 6 NY 33 NY 36 NY merger 25 H 133 638 262 352 34 149 487 280 surplus d60 d3L e4H transfer condtnl. 26 NY 72 286 damages 410 616 337 67 H injunction 60 H 3 I 6 injunction — H 642 e 86 NY 126 50 US 29 3 1 8 adultery m3 230 31 333 61 NY 403 325 arbitration 1 690 estoppel 4 621 6 NY 207 60 NY 448 non-perfmance 12 370 do 12 376 14 81 27 77 impeachment 20 412 419 488 waiver parol 20 ' 491 493 20 515 41 H 579 330 evidence 4 TC 684 340 hab. corpus 4 34 jurisdiction ev. 57 AD 149 161 34 H 466 355 vol. paymt. 29 93 d 12 NY 312 362 opening sal 2 TC 679 379 4 11 H 61 H e31 NY title 79 NY 303 e 44 H threats 17 H 2 TO q 17 NY 26 NY 493 redemption 126 32 443 226 179 180 equitable lien 4M 352 e 48 NY 123 delivery 119 AD 612 304 29n 30n 349 12 428 transcript 63 474 430 ahmony 61 AD 98 186AD 816 174S 775 432 usurious 33 4Ab 80 72 436 committee 17 13 125AD 466 jurisdiction 43 AD 233 27 H 481 37 H 309 1 31 III 343 Stat, findings 33 M discretion 192NY 67M fl47S right to jury 192NY 44 L "lunatic ILEA 270n 390 stay 57 404 392 incompt. ev 46 23 NY priority IIH subrogation 51 H equity 18 M SOUS 163 89 305 480 132 179 d4NY 6 NY 224 442 659 296 receiver 12 H 148 3,1 1 complete discharge 63M 367 4TC 176 50 315 sp. 15 prfmanc 601 332 399 jurisdiction 11 110 bond mortgage 18 48 dower 23 132 47 H 290 purchase money 53 H 238 reservation 11 NY 321 judgment lien 26 NY 72 127 NY 624 eq. assignees 5LEA 292n 407 reservation 19 488 408 opinions a 6 NY 268 7 321 324 330 9 NY 375 383 q 9 NY 394 presumption 10 15 447 damages 10 H 263 449 jurisdiction 43 M 662 77M 156 1.36 S 897 lis pendens 103M 426 454 lien fund 39 235 81 US 84 88 US 440 47 1 rescission r4 96,471 89 H 68 2 TC 620 e 30 NY 671 682 5 1 I redemption 4 126 injunction 25 H 82 H 82 H merger 12 74 NY 5 1 9 notice e9 29 H 77 NY 271 283 284 639 412 390 656 296 opimens 526 7 2TC 33 H presumption 10 18 al3M 63M 71 M 130 S attestation ell 17 37 . devise class 27 signature 49 69 AD 17 M memorandum 328 408 234 16 438 469 172 632 1067 126 108 340 483 190 elH e3TC 6 NY 22NY 29NY 39 NY probate 1 29 AD 348 687 340 462 346 160 10 57 NY 486 lien d4 19 H 30 H 675 130 417 686 495 trustee 17 484 611 86 641 125 10 14 90 US eq. conversion 17 166 18 83 part performnce 29 H 600 costs error 41 500 dower 3 10 32 53 52 AD 21 H 22 H 32 H 43 M 93 US 26 NY 48NY relief d 152 NY assent 60 646 321 401 630 38 99 382 32 222 316 127 46 123 110 179 hand writing 136AD 794 proof will ICP NS 375 witness mark 73 M 165 attestations 132S 483 542growing trees 2 618 36 417 67 246 157 AD 533 do 142 S 857 chat, mortgage d8 110 m20 38 43 H 64 142 NY 677 personalty 46 286 statute frauds 18 340 representation 48 H levy 11 NY redemption 39 liable do 142 S real estate e 157 AD in writing 157 AD 552 affidavit 5 amendment 17 22 45 4H 144 605 608 857 528 533 579 427 139 196 344 643 oonstruotioxi 41 NY 161 648 sp. prf manca s 10 NY 374 a 10 NY 397 25 NY 199 SN 28 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; t. followed; r. reversed; m. modified c. criticised; 1, limited: e. explained; o. overruled; s. same case: do, dissenting opinion ; . dismissed; n, note; parallel case; q, questiuiicd Vol. 2 N, Y. Supreme Court Reports — Barbour VOL. 2. 9 parol evidence 44 196 282 costs 23 H 86 fd intent 60 H 266 16 prin. debtor! e2g 530 44 346 security 7 NY 174 9 NY 499 24 NY 171 e 47 NY 236 76 NY 278 assume mort'ge 5LRA 276d 20 parties 11 168 4 AD 196 197 43 H 624 69 H 423 6 NY 84 30 NY 444 e 30 NY 446 e 76 NY 132 86 NY 436 144 NY 239 eetoppel 64 H 623 25 oonstrnrtion 3L 72 77 H 602 28 security 44 146 47 225 227 89 NY 592 re-purch option 87 NY 684 37 trueteee 10 86 d27 notice 8L equity 79 H 205 71 NY 655 204 261 51 guaranty a 2 NY 225 6 298 56 usurious 14 140 t8 usury proof LRA 466n 59 alimony 20 M 646 63 power aale S 20 47 H 368 I87NY 407 11 M 224 rescission tl legacy 64H 399 166 83 legacy c 19 M 202 ademption S4 NY 206 distinction 141 S 925 construction 80 M 202 85 legacy 96 M 207 161 S 62 90 injunction q21. 360 94 ooDsideretieii a 8 ilY 83 10 316 246 delivery 14 legacy 47 386 gift e mortis 66 AD 6Q6 5 H , 470 stara decisie f28 H 263 339 373 1 04 statutory 607 16 436 corp'n not liable ILRA 327n nuisance 41 332 19 M 494 authority 67M 45 t ISrecitls.proof 6 611 r 622 411 426 d9 428 10 463 e 10 476 presumption 36 639 deed evidence 38 73 50 641 affidavit demand 5 NY 368 10 NY 332 destruction 59 NY 284 negligence proof 5 NY 622 1 20 covenant a 2 NY 86 a 418 I 30 intention 13 126 construction 19 601 135 rescission 6 322 11 662 40 NY 404 parol evidence 16 NY 343 equity action 65M 50] 1 49 character alNY e25AD do68H e4NY f 142 NY 630 403 472 496 601 1 53 illegal 13 428 jurisdiction 31 H 168 judgment 34 M 681 incompetency 100 S 46 114 AD 464 finding 51 M 641 accounting 37 CP 273 claim VB. lunatic 19A0 79, 83n 1 56 title 2 341 666 amendment 6 . 131 compet. jurisdn. 9AD 6 7 7Tr 76 38M 17 39 NY 306 310 64 NY 607 17 6 NY 461 165 eq owner rl NY 62 18 88 41 . 146 143 neglig. servant 29 424 26 NY 346 fact queation 80 NY 619 f 157 S 92.i can recover f 175 AD 39 f 161 S 481 I 80 surrender 65M 660 release 19 138 44 641 64 433 7 H 161 617 33 H 672 f40H 432 do 40 H 437 e 4 SS 585 18 M 449 54M 230 a 30 NY 463 1 82 seduction loss services r4NY 38 5 665 8 326 9 526 31 278 50 106 d 6 H 578 do 6 H 681 1 90 improper ev r2NY 165 3 615 10 333 13 44 200 will executr 13 26 16 146 39 381 39 NY 169 subscription e 141 ^Y 167 85 M' 65S 148 S 105U single act 76M 170 136 S 933 206 possession II 600 defense 26 107 41 69 208 imp .promise 12 478 d 20 391 39 H 73 86 H 330 i 161 S 36j 2 1 juBtificntion 39 M 12 57 US 4 84 NY 60 2 1 4 corporation 12 677 2 1 6 new trial a 1 NY 399 16 391 impressions do 57 362 Bl3H 251 13H 252 2Tr 8 86 US 128 36 NY 279 43 NY 34 power court 32 NY 138 appmt. guardiai' 18AC S4ii 229 trusle s3NY 9 12 NY 376 689 315 construction 27 440 60 174 d7AD 441 2 TC 190 36 NY 166 92 NY 201 47 M 4b 1 charge on land 16 AD 444 accumulation 66 AD 666 child living 23 H 228 legacy 70 H 277 258 eq. set-off 19 200 3SS 72 87 NY 515 41,K,A 859n 264 use occupa. e20M 116 26 M 770 270 waiver a 10 NY .466 20 618 damages 66 644 SN 141 d 61 NY 166 28 2 jurisdiction 57 415 e2H 26 4 TC 296 e 4TC 290 new trial author e20NY 647 6 do 20 NY 66(0 new trial f 20NY 551 28 NY 417 79 NY 60 294 subscription 10 268 273 stockholders 17 676 23 H 344 e 26 H' 582 e 47 H 146 26 NY 145 d 88 NY 416 good faith 28 H 133 do 28 H 136 300 privity se 165 40 217 covenant 6L 199 10 H 417 seisin 124 NY 221 307 execution 7 NY 199 94 NY 47 309 limitation a 10 NY 96 s9 395 21 594 26 217 10 NY 103 sSN 220 notice 5211 100 53 M 554 3 1 6waiver notce 6 657 9 308 17 405 18 168 20 487 27 161 abrogation 33 643 61 258 54 214 27 AD 681 66 AD 391 IL 6TC 66 US 13 NY 267 600 471 306 320 lie facto oflice rs 7 72 14 286 321 27 526 36 648 86 386 IL 344 3 1, 13 14 H 615 42 H 387 69 H 2U7 70 H 5 3 K 449' 3Tr £>1 4 Ab 24 8 NY 84 89 57 NY 402 86 NY 306 91 NY 635 validity f 91 M 508 326 ord. care d 13 490 20 252 presumption 28 601 insurers 42 260 44 666 10 NY 437 do 46 NY 28a proof bailor 71M 194 128S 422 330 quantity 2 655 5 573 6 131 one parcel do 163 NY 69 61 34 I waiver' 10 376 10 NY 442 344 authority 2 119 conformity 9 411 11 190 2H 601 6TC 39 e 2 NY 72 61 NY 66 62NY 362 jud'l notice 126S 993 compliance 141AD 609 348 authority e 40 H 280 352 pers propty 14 249 eqtiity 107 NY 192 356 discharge 3 20 8 36 nonsuit 46 AD 147 8 NY 74 177 NY practice 131AD 656 38 H • 406 vesting wife 108 NY 628 379 perfrmance d32 74 pro rata 34 663 28 H 226 26 NY 492 38 1 construction 15 61 e 11 NY 306 385 nill execute 13 26 22 671 38 160 39 NY 159 publn. will 17 AC 394n £ 165AD f 150S 104 764 397 mandamus 126 129 49 264 d 29 AD 251 42 H 103 71 H 464 28 M 744 d 34 M 328 8 NY 330 420 exp moral 10 13 20 63 H 11 M 26 NY e26NY e91NY dispute d2L revival 3L 290 I promise oblign 488 369 154 67] 370 611 616 400 considn 52 126 368 joinder 16 executor 33 631 532 dl2H 163 6 NY 173 28 NY 233 373 discontinue 10 M 305 49 NY 127 377 restoration 427 robbery 61 H 675 objn. laches 1 Ab 423 432 costs dam f 8 H 281 282 allegation d 60 H 640 69 H 466 467 436 attachment 3 229 439 Val. Gonsid 87 AD 10 jurisdiction 31 NY 98 injunction 55 M 37 444 receiver 41 AD 209 12 H 119 31 H 388 446 receiver 39 102 6 Tr 327 39 NY 200 trustee 6 AD 77 15 H 39 450 right bail e 60 484 457 principal 40 291 trust objection 86 AD 424 vested legacy 16 H 452 86 US 174 475 securities 30 H 518 payment e 43 NY 163 rescission 484 security a 5 NY 171 s 5 520 623 d 11 160 14 239 488 preeumption 8 251 allege payment 29 442 493 new consid r 11 271 29 608 authority 16 H 494 joinder 29 51& 31 NY 566 513 CO. officer 7 34 certiorari 24 608 60» 42 20& habeas corpus 49 IS remedy ' 7 37 520 sale a 2 NY 168 construction do 4 NY 86 90 525 spl damage 52 AD 16S 52M 287 534 cond. limit- ation 13 136 power sale e 64 NY 362 538 chat mtge 52 371 545 merger 26 H 487 usury assigment 1 Tr 262 e 6 NY 362 36 NY 14» 549 notice 12 64 9H 649 93 US 44» 12 NY 28» 554 warrant 171 H 464 559 holders val consideration 6 44S 24 666 31 1B2 49 H' 1& 566 understood 216 NY 336 577 injunction 34 607 67 166 37 H 60 ordinance void 1 124AD 84T 52M 223 584 set-off 39 H 21» 586 presumptioa 10 216 69 AD 516 conclusive 17 420 36 B4 63 AI) 160 59 AD 621 33 H 41» 73 H 284 ABBKEVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; c, criticised ; 1, limited ; e, explained ; o, overruled ; s, same case ; do, dipel nting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, questioned N. Y. Supreme Court Reports-Barbour Vols. 2, 3 4Tr 94 US 37 NY 101 NY 135 NY 144 NY impeachment 171 NY pleadine 29 AD 07 H 42 NY rectifying 4LRA 6S 346 74 594 136 688 201 297 390 S04n 598 set of? soin 18 AO 272n 599 partition J5 I H >53H ITC 4TC f 214NY 687 S@I 326 126 127 348 fi02 concluBive 20 NY 152 foreign executor 125 NY 403 SOSsp. prfmanoe a8 SO 57 e 103 AD 76 NY 154 NY oonsideratton IH 4TC jiu'isdiotion 93 NY 627 333 566 469 370 239 249 33n 343 456 24 584 270 466 140 157 - 87 apportioBable 32 468 39 H 274 rent wheat 9 NY 613 license a 69NY 18 46 19 H oontract dSO dS7 2K 1 Ab 69 NY estoppel 3H 5TC construction 6 H 38338 conversion el42 S liable do 142 S real estate e 157 AD in writing 137 AD growing timber 157 AD 533 625 tenancy 4-;. authority 53 bona fide 22 H 24 NY 630 sp damage 318 270 349 286 52 306 246 325 162 165 270 301 534 854 857 528 533 17 NY 639 Indians e 52M e52M e52M 148 S dovureign do 121AD 121 AD distribution do 121AD do 121AD Indian law d 121 AD 85 M. authority c 64M powers q 155 AD 205 424 425 619 24u 315 314 316 317 334 125 618 776 643 amendment 131 6 interest 17 41 46 _H 5TC 2 NY 8 NY 11 NY VOL.3 9 draff 1 2 draft 7 enforcement 14 14 H 40 H lONY joinder 29ADr esLRA indorser 21 merger 68Lr 98 M 162 S 237 continue 176AD 665 73 warranty r 2 NY 43 s 10 288 632 374 484 320 321 11 21* e 7 NY 222 561n 534 541 567D 1 7 lack seal 64 NY 156 execution defect 94 NY nonsiut 177 NY practice 13 IAD dismissal 166S 47 38 656 84- revers error 376 20 13 comity 23 8 NY felony e23NY 99 NY 3 I referee 3 exception 28 42 advice costs 39 6Tr 84 NY NY 37 H acquisence 3K ITr 3Ab restrictions 8 NY 37 damages e2L 40 assignees e24H 53 H 4Tr set-off 6 NY 79 presumption 39 44 Ik 597 4 Ab 92 _ . attachment 34 222 notice 4 NY 525 00 explanation 6 465 consideration 16 261 8 NY 213 authority 17 600 parol evidence 46 70 sale void 312 930 lien 270 53M 461,462 misjoinder 123AD i Jinder 39 CP 139 AD injunction 155 AD 123 S 206 203 ■^T6 423 1015 liabilities f ILRANS 262 eq. lien 19 H 30 H 68 US 81 US 88 US 121n 1 62 authority 29 H 618 42 H 276 1 7 1 conclusive 26 21 70 US 19 title 78 NY 1 75 affidavit f5 679 258 17 181 77 NY 149 42 I 1 trustee 6 24 412 616 3 S S 400 421 assignment 24 NY 383 256 non-suit 223 36 NY - 25 fact question 125 61 NY 483 burden proof ;80 103 NY 46 27 , ,, I I Ofact question I 136 12 476 ' 243 44 H 334 437 inference 65 66 42 AD 374 666 prospct damage 34 H 88 206 I 1 9 meas dam. 143 8 425 weight evidence 77 15 31 417 586 22 84 440 447 267 prior lien 196adm'n bar 31 355 47 118 201 authority 48 146 9 NY 240 20 NY 441 203 replevin b7 115 7 NY 655 28 187 sSN 46 209 confliderat'n IS 342 27 84 2 f 5 parol ev. 21 404 28 c29 15 H 75 H 21 NY 22 NY value 354 59 NY waiver 32 141 NY 20AC 20AC trustee 43 vendor's i;07 NY 275 burden prf 611 430 ) discontinuance 7 AD 79 AD IH 17 H 77 H 76 NY 3TC d2SS 222 objection 1 28 2 mtges. 79 11 21 AD 103M 98 169S 627 authority 468 81 AD 20 M 308 37 M 650 185 18 281 235 235 306 f 17 illegality 26 36 62 banking 3 NY lien el5NY e 37 NY 398 400 eq. redemption 636 682 649 576 43 AD 68 AD 84 AD 48 H 30 M 31 M 33 M 36 H e94NY 134 NY 608 131 311 230 233 40 623 244 69 474 2 NY 42 statutes a 2 NY SAD 4H 6TC d 113 US SONY do 117 NY 48 nuisance 4LRA 18AC 174n 182n notice 31 AD 633 levy 26 AD 437 311 18 169 2S6 209 519 18 583 57 127 NY 624 1 44 jurisdiction 2H 14 H 28 H 4TC 211n 50 discretion 10 83 87 NY 317 reformation 4 Ab. 28 NY 313 sp. performance 66M 447 equity relief 26 417 230 295 296 404 602 216 407 34 293 compound int. 66 NY 623 94 US 441 estoppel 28 49 334 152 339 454 684 567 646 95 468 125n 126n 30 lien 415 5 532 11 162 14 486 subrogation 6SLRA 529n 68LRA S37n merger 68LKA 567n 3 1 9 presumptio n 52 AD. 112 judgment lien 18 H 466 36 H 481 chose in action 332 mandamus d 12 463 20 297 49 507 449 119 243 154 357 266 748 191 judicial notice 111 US 710 712 power 10 H 437 284 rescission 3H 6TC e4Tr e37NY 288 meas. r4NY 8 authority 42 gains 229 b2 attachment 436 232 ct chambers 123 S 56 award s4 87 119 NY 555 253 441 482 . 49 award 33 NY 1 5 1 notice 12 1 57 nuisance 29 41 63 30 AD 4L 37 H 48 H 67 H 6Tr. 97 US 37 NY 63 NY SONY 172 NY 27 609 d21 waiver 53 injunction 6H jury trial 2TC undertaking 64 NY affirm relief 109 AD 294 332 255 68 52 40 359 58 192 669 684 584 582 14 parties plaintiff 350 494 161 564 330 891 236 adultery e 27 H ?99 243 suspension 60 AD cond fee 105 NY 249 duty elS 254 nuisance e9 65 H 9 NY illegality IS NY 98 3Ab 302 no p sumption 95 M 602 297 17 249 dam. 338 425 634 578 180 56 304 allegation 8 219 88 H 20 49 NY 260 305 mtge. Iren 26 162 27 505 71 H 17 NY p20NY prospective 49 60 323 39 warranty 13 H eOTr 39 NY 165 NY implied 72 M 130 S 680 2S1 653 136 224 126 407 133 341 strict com plianoe 6 610 7 46 10 475 16 350 26 336 340 26 363 27 97 33 191 54 386 26 H 306 76 H 89 4 NY 380 385 5 NY 514 construction 133 NY 176 347 damages a 4 NY 110 45 421 9H 22 mortgagee 65 226 353 contract 48 M 147 prf. 577 611 119 296 147 63 ■ 87 AD 91 AD 5L 7L 71 H 10 NY 17 NY 57 NY 159 NY limitation 30 178 32 431 equitable title 36432 460 35idemurrer 46131 333 181 86 146 665 566 59 235 X19 543 296 437 477 370 360 burden r4NY 6 non-suit 46 AD 147 occupation ev. 52 H 339 cond. precedent 127 NY 250 369 recovery 65 301 SH 41fi 372 revers error 1 M 498 15 M 174 374burden proof 23 587 590 alteration d31 66 authority 41 e42AD 104 634 467 160 380 conversion 44 488 burden proof 16313 1 4 security 10 H 37 M 46 NY contract e39H bailee 476 567 289 610 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed- . reversed- m mod!fi.H • • ^- ^ '^ c. criticised; 1. limited: e. explained; o. overruled; s.' same case! do.'diIL^^t7n1 opTnion ;'^*'pl-allel tre'^qfiu^^iSSS Vols. 3, 4 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Barbour 17 AC 224d 22Sn, 227n warranty 106M: 174S 463 692 385 vestiBB 19 26 22 H dSNY 99 NY wills 116AD survivora 55 H executory devise 85 NY 90 388 delivery do^ tice d 44 471 6Tr 313 39NY 36 39 1 2 mortgages 602 117 429 314 613 811 131 11 certiorari 32 6 NY Illation 76 NY covenant 22 AD 404 fraud 8 618 order discretion 560 134 326 680 629 13 resale 22 H presumption 92 H 114 NY burden proof U4NY alter note 3LRA condition 146 S 184 411 496 287 136 731 397 46 NY pleading 71 NY 459 turnpike ufie highway 15 3B7 339 640 604 605 eo dl6 2'2 93 339 367 H e7Tr 14 NY 31 NY 39 NY jectment 20 constitutional 37 416 damages 4 NY 204 516 60 412 34 470 averment 7 conclusive f 59 f 5L allegation f 5H stare decisis f23H 475 sherifT a 2 NY 19 H e9NY IS 542 193 544 263 277 t '640 new trial 44 553 voidable 136S 21 554 petition 2 NY 10 23 relation e66 92 H SN 373 108 600 221 91 67 576 basis Judgt. IS 321 notice 41 47 S3 emblements 3LRA 169 167 124 625 slander 7 12 262 216 584 authority 633 126 617 603 481 allegations a 2 NY 118 12 437 power sale 6 NY ?66 492 replevin r 4 NY %3 496 sheriff 9 NY 4 1 legacy rSNY 37 26 H 52 US practice 129S witness examine ISS 498 191 490 205 74M ' *provided' ' 1'61 AD 4 \ 9 waiver 6 partners 24 NY reference 172 NY 424 rule dam 564 148 278 14 22 36 139 US el6NY 35 NY 46 NY e 155 NY indemnity 121 AD meas. damage 123 165 626 589 37 209 496 273 568 450 369 174 3 1 2 conversion a 1 NY 537 518 judt. eredr 71 H 574 13 M 492 spL^roperty^^^ surplus 94 NY 616 523 indorsement 19 NY 319 68 US 242 529 payt notice do 2Tr S«NY 589 title n IS 20 140AD 3H 37 H 39 H STC 27 M constructioc 16 grantee 34 118 NY 127 NY 599 request f 86AD 509 (1 86 AD 510 d 26 H 253 prepond. proof 66 H 373 114 NY 64 pr'sume innocen. 180 NY 00 603 pleading a 4 NY 374 152 S 884 title pleading 4LRA 685n 600 497 406 297 305 626 264. 627 726 62e 44 393 652 notice 46 e4H assignee e fi4NY 224 79 NY 43 634surety 6 413 d 24 547 75NY _ 429 consideration 13 368 369 15 321 measure damage 8 426 643 prior lien 4H 338 99 NY 204 127 NY 627 647 excessive verdict 12 499 47 201 insane liable 65 H 477 23 M 170 143 NY 448 VOL. 4. 9 injunction a 16 NY e4 el6 demurrer 36 assessors 43 eq. powers 50 48 H 14 NY 40 NY 172 NY certiorari 23 57 construction elL 182 NY I lib'l const'n M 61 16 18 H 61 NY 534 petition e23 subrogation 6H 48 H 64 NY 70 NY 68LRA 178 316 33 600 642 427 299 402 557 534d decree redempt d 429 discharge 9 6L 17 H do 3 NY BONY 118 NY waiver 9 documents ev^ 40 466 11 H 287 45 1 cotenanf* 498 IE 227 597 286 eoi b7 13 s27 tender 60 82 H 18 M ruling 22 H 11 H H 61 H do 31 NY e42NY do 42NY 538 land 6LRA 82 641 443 226 97 105 liable 2810 543 new trial 4 331 payment 16 6 1 2 ravers error 169 44 73 84 452 187 402 616 belief 13 429 430 16 36 AD 24 H e38H 41 H 12 NY parties 20 36 AD 88 H fraud 40 616 618 jurisdiction 260 36 118 417 266 168 384 36 416 174 180 122AD 684 548 circumstan- tial evidence P 3 663 'exception ABBREVIATIONS : criticised; I, limited; 621 prospective 17 161 68 164 q 12 NY 210 213 215 705 464 18 398 60 644 190 459 639 167 48 302 303 e7 7 60 trespass a 6 NY 64 vested rights 4 10 15 2M do2M delegation 16 d61 86 NY 378 380 466 494 301 244 230 5 11 18 115 487 49 32 143 33 NY 646 St. limitations 6 NY 117 9 NY 93 acknowl edgmcnt 19A0 19AC 1 80 title 8 11 19 30 adv. possession 420n 432q 407 500 487 337 1 7 certiorari 23 ^ 378 equity powers 36 63 H 172 NY 20 election 28 10 M 3SA intent 54 H 28 will 45 revocation 60 M 75M 135S 141 S 60 273 48 465 494 406 202 80 devisee 40 el4NY 34 NY residue 63 H 79 NY 96 NY misnomer 3M broad construction 80 M 20i bequest good 146 S 1007 85 M 282 89 bequests 446 281 4.35 51S 715 621 386 587 356 360 510 479 3LRA 95 relief 89 H 40 NY 3 I commitment ■ "" •" 150 217 466 70 608 return e7Tr f lOM e38NY interest 17 16AC 60 NY d67»AD 16 H 34 H 42 NY jurisdiction 22 M 36 election a 6 NY 12 6 NY parol evidence 36 95 66 356 5L 226 spec prfmance 6L 317 cross action 62 H 537 670 112 147n 58 396 I 1 3 interpleader 17 128 131 dower 66 remedies 25 NY 37 estoppel 11 63 22 H f 161 AD 147 S 192 dower r4NY e33H 166AD 250 560 37 395 817 1065 9S 79 247 258 224 1 25 surplus 23H 428 l27corp powers IS 435 12 NY 573 1 3 I orig. promise 15 ' 23 62 H 2 1 7 bcparation 32 204 cruelty 55 33 134 3K 368 ITr 103 120 NY 493 allegationf 99AD 284 30 H 676 bar 82 H 184 condonation 4Ab 36 37 222 wife agent d21 321 c21 331 30 67 ratification 9 NY 41 207 225 alienation 442 668 125 206 117 394 660 207 414 384 466 47n -. 111 title 3d person 71 NY 38 defense 19 481 cond precedent 13 2M e81NY 300 118 346 476 607 387 , affirmed; i, distinguished; f, followed; i , explained; o, overruled; s, sam e case; do. 47 notice 3H 6 TO assignees 22 H attorney's lien 18 NY 369 51 authority 3L 14 H e39H 11 NY e 48 NY 56 damages 12 428 313 72 H 3SA el2NY 21 NY e 116 NY Stat, frauds SLRA 253 < ?t0 227 nominal ^<'" damages loS S 180 509 4 468 427 271 620 139 ejectment a 2 NY 459 1 46 prfmance 20 AD 199 IK 535 4 Ab 204 1 5 1 allegations 138 333 66 2L deceit 6M 46 NY do 46 NY statute 186 NY 1 59 vesting 17 redemption 18 NY 86 M 149 S 356 473 474 415 162 350 570 \ 68 payment -_J8 252 425 386 15 180 182 361 d 21 368 359 Inew promise e 22 15 1 228 jurisdiction 9 partition IH 4TC 71 M 521 691 127 287 232 trustee 20 381 opinion evidence 9 NY 376 250 award s 5 NY 489 492 s 7 442 256 opinions 10 12 13 16 17 29 44 48 H e9NY 29 NY damages e 121 NY objection 20 remedy 45 H rent action 51 M 261 opinions 493 383 117 105 563 21 123 401 186 36 43 417 6S 611 reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, questioned N, Y. Supreme Court Reports— Barbour Vols- 4. 5 493.32 105 21 123 375 64 175 S64 360 43fi 41 B25AD review t6AC 442 207 11 2!i6n waive objections 18AC 42aii 10 16 29 44 9 NY damaeea 39 42NY 90 H 664 324 new trial 130 NY 360 44 640 139 NT! 43fi impeachment Bpecial damage 37 AD 33 4Ab. 379 1 H 150 39 NY 142132 H 344 66 82 S9 H 229 e 64 H 211 declarations fact question | 30 244 332uaury defense 60 4L SH 22 H 62 H 5TC 25 M 25 NY 35 NY profits 11 371 84 AD 523 I roof damages 52 M 287 11 30 32 6NY 49 NY e89NY 130 NY 4K 3 Ab 265 pleading 13 103 amendment 10 NY 370 fraud answer 20 473 s 9 NY admissions iS 11 46 H 4; 11 allegation proof d 29 1 K 592 13 H 4Ab. 88shN conclusive 23 -N Y 354 sp Y 20 M recovery 130 AD »8 627 286 287 354 643 279 699 214 294 78 262 141 546 191 430n 539 36 692 burden propoots 73M 323 TOM 1J« I32S 710 137S 150 burden proof 136S 1116 130 S 1007 407 foreclosure 9 estate ri4!l 384 72 521 582 32 H 3SH no waiver f 144S f 159 AD 460 murder a 2 NY 413 630 24 154 17 H 38 H 51 H 79 NY a4NY tparate ;i 22 63 11 H e6NY 346 usury defns 241 159 168 171 406 666 206 34 107 AD 227 v^.riance ISfiAD 181 173S 867 274 assumpsit 30 223 224 agency IL 16!) parol eviden ce 25 H 144 construction 35 H 310 3 Ab. 440 101 DS 395 2Y9 intent 5 103 as 537 relief 57 2XX 4L 244 separable trust 103 AD 355 perfrmce 223 45 144 36 1 conversion 36 400 55 193 8 M 262 ,1 . 133 AD 574 waiver 85 H - 501 liuel constrctn 52M 61 waive objectoin 52 .\1 63 369 orig. consdn 472 484 sheritl 3 TC 212 e 4 TO 623 assessment 4 TC 657-8 487 guai'anty 466 468 177 4 1 6 decree a 6 NY 16 e56 AD legal services 34 H 269 commissions 3H accountiai: iS M 42 419 oonotructn 4 estoppel s u 93 AD 7L 43 40 5U0 131 87 cund precedent 3'J 285 sup'l. bill 15 H 131 f 20 H 264 29 H 446 295 usurpation 6 486 authority 38 H 405 constitutional 12 NY 213 vesting 108 NY 528 injunclion 55 M 1? 467 526 403 274 6fiB 17 H23n 605 34 13 304 delivery 9 ej.ecution 16 588 acceptance e43NY 212 consideration 52 NY 143 3 I 4 lottery e29H 94 NV 3 I 7 discretion 80 AD 366 382 pro rata 17 131 contract 82 NY 542 320 jurisdiction d 12 5611393 undue inti. d 20 2S0I17 244 245 24 410'33 68 12 authority 32 35 3TC 6TC 3Tr. 16 M 19 M 2LKA 36 NY title 42 ratihcatiou 24 AD 14 M ■ I disaiTirmance 3 M 305 132 S 4 376 defect of partierj' 29 : d51 2- security 12 H 61 26 M 6; usury 37 .il 4: inadequacy 41 NY 3i uicquality 13 IAD 71 3H repugnancy 16 NY e64 NY 1J4 S j-ewainder .9 M • conclusive 135 NY adv possession 37 249 39 H 264 5 TC 527 438 evidence 93 284 911 134 336 61 AD inference 11 M 4,1 M 33 NY e69NY 193 d24H el4M restriction du 118 AD 491 pledge 20 redemption 30 43 52 sale 67 41 M title 59 H 54 NY 390 231 177 46b 371 339 48 292 23 493 burden pr'f 7li.M 400 495 estoppel 26 23 29 30 35 36 3K 3Tr 3Ab 13 NV 62 NY boundary ILUA 611 49 575 628 435 437 439 428 591 610 256 208 316 72 523n 10 467 419 54 1 jurisdiction 24 419 36 H 418 discontinuance 95 NY 244 546 alienation 10 601 602 husband trustee 28 360 d S9 606 extinguished do 59 608 cr. bill lien 38 AD 125 husband wife 4L 167 gift to wife IK 30 2 Ab. 494 559 ordr. rights 5LH,A 2s0n 562 nuisance 16 568 96 AD 132 564 conversion 188 possession e 10 H 543 do 10 H 644 82 73 621 509 311 442 limitations 2L1<,A 83 li: 444 warrant renewal 20 38 41 H 170S 166 42 43 693 504 domicile 12 33 H 50 H doSOH 90H .->4M "resident" 63 mhabitant 26 M 67 NY judgt. u. t.. 77 NY intent 120 NY direct verdict ISM 218 -, NY 75 blander 60 NY 264 524 disaffirm- ance recovery 449 evidence 15 36>- d 17 n allege statute 251 injit rV 226 ilM 453 '>ers. 14 noie void I7H lllei^alit> 4 rc 457 parol ev. 42 5L 4 NY conclusive 93 AD 4H 351 226 76 237 SI 643 581 462 476 234 206 52 142 386 tunc 517 d20 trust funds 50 92 AD 15 H 64 H 23 M 37 M 112 US 40 NY compound int 45 191 i92 84 NY 187 construction 63 410 authority 27 H ,460 riduciary 4Lfi.A 219n 850 contract 4 MY 360 571 impeachmt 198 41 iraud H enforcible 193 NY 315 35 209 531 partnership 3 LIIA llSii 3ii2 trespass 34 J.03 N V uy^ier beds 2 H 181 NY pers, properly 66il 193 43 Jl . 13 . Cfiiversiou 47H 368 jarceny 194 NY 77 113 65 171 117 VOL. 5. 483 4 393 6 219 529 468 95 9 corporations s 3 NY 19 230 237 408 21 NY discharge 39 process Jew 20 AD enforcement 2H delegation 15 NY power to borrow 15 NY 219 divisible 4LRA 593 damages *91 600 trust rSNY 43 H SN 20 2 H 32 H 3TC e 103 US 12 NY 316 438 695 489 147 59 36 530 payment 15 174 175 ISO 15 176 joint debtors 43 69 Hi 38 H 1 evocation 16 limitations 141 US parties »2NY admissions 293 536 u.iO 383 6 1 4 assumpsit d 1 2 376 iioii-perfmance 14 35 60 3L opinions 46 H 5Tr. 9 NY 38 NY 1 18 NY waiver 46 72 H 25 M 29 M 60 NY deduction 17 M abrogation 81 604 148 524 61 308 375 73 438 240 174 487 399 448 360' 3761 181 T oJo e.\.ecutur 614 205 594 191 156ii 38 lex loci e91NY 43 certiorari 9 27 NY jurisdiction 15 discretion 33 22 AD 9M 15 M 73 NY 126 NY parties 135 NY deed e 9 H 144 office duration 74 H 175 5 1 trust 519 520 521 133 542 310 461 347 175 251 13 441 183 449 e33 title 39 du 66 4TC 29 NY o85NY 137 NY St. frauds 27H agent authority 2L11-V 14711 63 presumption 5l 16 6J 94 9J St frauds d 52 -192 97 US UL8 17 630 218 344 340 612 434 124 12o 73 nmsance c6 319 17 445 4^ 11 359 a2 M ■17 f 92 M 28 f 155 S 97U '■ r. use streets 37 409 ■vrongfu] f 93 M 2 1 155 S 96lj 9 (election 055 a.ssumpHit 66 355 57 NV 675 i9 cunstruction a 5 NY 40S 44 NY 21 lOSolTsei ■ 1 9 255 d 11 484 24 H 346 35 M 458 90 NY 206 restitution 41 H 446 108 eviden do 301 B 14 548 assign! . pHVl i\i 34 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note. «. criticised ; 1. limited ' £, explained ; o, overruled ; i. eame case ; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, questioner] Vols. 5, 6 N. T. Supreme Court Reports — Baroour 1 1 constructn. 16 436 29 240 320 450 29 149 41 291 43 H 75 H IM I 1 7 bigamy 2H 29 H 4TC 86 NY e92NY do 101 NY el03 N Y l22impUed promise a 3 NY dlO 11 13 15 d43 48 3H 6TC 3 NY Beduetion 50 105, 221 1 30 usiiry defense persnl. 638 362 439 630 622 144 351 172 326 490 150 228 312 486 227 607 445 605 329 547 567 317 26 40 43 47 2Tr. 6 NY 24 NY 36 NY 40 NY 78 NY 94 NY waiver 4K 3Ab 139 trust 44 H 2TC 28M 240 202 725 203 lewdness 13 AD 70 86 H 74 prove intent 136AD 307 204 intent proof o7M 306 2 1 stockiiolder 43 165 23 H 344 e 47 H 147 e 11 NY 163 do 132 NY 258 stoclc pledged 20 H 337 findings 8 eontrib neg. 11 13 17 21 22 26 27 1 Ab 18NY e 29NY 34 NY charge en or IK 2Ab. 426 116 15 98 341 583 602 228 214 252 331 14 572 381 limitations eSL 59 6H 348 27 H 341 note 'payment 214 293 592 44 25 201 347 9 36 IAD 18 H 71 NY use infant f 178AD 8 I 47 security 13 H 661 parol evidence 17 H 393 16 NY 343 1 56 wife witness vs. liusband 613 517 368 26 30 44 construction ■45 q47 18 H 40 H 44 NY 2 1 4 marriage a 4 NY 230 45 535 presumption c 7 Tr. 314 c 38 NY 300 2 1 8 Corp. power, a 3 NY 430 26 170 14 NY 376 225 weight of ev 339 waiver 10 369 10 NY 90 NY estover 68LRA *2NY s8 11 powers 20 H 283 review 12 13 14 19 22 26 35 45 65 28 H 39 H 46 H 571 81 384 119 229 345 665 279 119 261 589 33 393 11 376 442 698 649n 40 AD 10 H 80 H 16AC devisee 13 set-off 81 H 233 38 210 142n 136 418 360 aclcBowlmt 44 131 132 364 parol con- tract r6NY 12 14 estoppel 41 375 pleading 55M 379 entry o20 incidental 217 NY 279 686 641 279 286 conclusive 22 66: joinder 6 NY 8( eQNY 605 206 424 249 576 309 I 6 I perfrmance 337 422 440 594 s6 19 20 2H I 66 bond r4NY el8 111 US 173 92 20 1 69 unconstitl. 30 81 AD 4 NY 12 NY do 18 NY 601 391 585 601 70 I 85 insolvent b'k r 3 NY 47fl 193 297 malice 41 discovery 14H 16 H 26 H i7iVl incrimination 30CP 43n special damage 88M 271 151S 817 247 385 attachment 79 H 149 393 St. limitatn 393 S47 360 622 297 421 778 66 bonting. liable 24 NY 292 prior eqmues 52 NY 146 68LBA 629n subrogation 68LUA 534l 4 1 4 recovery a 3 NY 88 42 H 114 424 advancemt 61 299 301 SH 4BH 09 US 21 NY 68 NY 72 NY e 163 NY do 177 NY do 193 NY 116 474 148 213 286 , 6 141 17!) 420 12 H sale 22 H 573 jurisdiction 14 252 499 411 486 injunction 5L 143 NY mtention 9H 43 H fraud 11 H 491 217 282 281 transfer -:i; 267 438 trust 30 exemptions e6H 14 NY e35NY 528 426 47 367 dower interest d41 accruing c9AD. do 9 AD e22AD 6L d7L 4H e64H Stat, limitation 12E 43o 169 3B2 305 discharge a 4 NY 603 U 106 3 1 2 charge on realty 26 366 legacies e 131 NY 460 319 14 . 26 'i 40 NY 54 NY 102 NY rescission 90 trust powr L 238 L 252, H 30B 4 M H 50 NY I 216' 324 devise 16 H dower int. 72 H 697 241 404 415 499 316 567 74 H 78 H 61 NY 62 NY 130 NY 398 evidence 296 307 503 556 14 12 40 H discharge 14 39 43 6H 14 M 70 NY sureties 15 24 14 H relief 26 31 81 NY d91NY 124 NY assumpsit 33 objections 47 e67 3TC 34 NY admissions 181 NY 5 AD .561 17 H 164 '38 H '79 NY 213 264 L.J 239 614 465 348 686 551 321 547 562 88 360 362 188 116 80 492 263 503 346 347 626 382 263 ISO 10 466 419 33 57 NY e87NY 98 AD income e31 NY 446 dower 3LliA 499 326 158 268 28 497 11 21 84 AD 147 NY 490 notice dS dl2 dlS 50 demand 2TC rlNY 197 436 60i 289 686 250 332 48 122 413 50 1 cond preced 14 682 23 631 31 94 38 106 108 117 14 AD 122 21 H 540 30 H 267 40 NY 188 guaranty 18 AC 326r. AzTn 5 1 6 cond-pr'^ied. 36 M 384 520 relief r 6 NY 171 U 163 666 575 arrest 17 d62NY 580 surety a3NY 183 280 VOL. 6 446 60 1 consideratn a 10 NY 479 45 613 sSN 110 executor contrct 48 335 603 enforcemnt. 5LRA 169 607 jurisdiction 449 handwriting 10 378 proof execution 90 H 524 85 NY 674 455 parol ev. 9 210 13 100 15 251 3 L 200 83 H 402 42 NY 320 46 1 indorser 53 26 H 89 US 465 judicial 4H 469 bar 13 37 H 77 NY services 65 70 AD 10 H 24 M 28 NY limitations e20H 92 H e31 M relief 16 83H 369 48 593 686 160 598 168 t . 644 130 322 68 497 471 276 388 31 406 474 unconstitl 17 662 47 AD 361 64 AD 286 IL 274 182AD securities 14 discharge 39 23 M 9 NY 70 NY sureties 127S trustee 70M 622 239 614 176 246 651 820 683 533 undue infl 10 508 65 366 2 TC 29d 550 insurance 16 29 52 78 AD 96 AD 3SS license IK statute 57 NY 669 393 394 393 132 452 418 frauds 227 owner in fee 63 252 556 exp 10 3L 26 NY treasurer 21 560 guest 30 72 M I2f) S bailee 36 issurer 6L 33NY ability prom 488 126 611 655 153 371 845 461 114 575 3P(i 565 deed valid 15 498 judgmenl lien 14 17 rl9 19 c 24 27 32 d47 o48 UNY 16 NY 36NY C36NY' 46NY e63NY e 153 NY elOM exemption e22AD 6H 19B olTC presumiption 4NY 6 1 3 usury 14 146 148 15 3 231 183 23 188 422 97 136 326 52 673 321 242 265 682 56 339 332 9 owners 14 641 waste 26 414 29 17 10 NY 118 67 NY 613 ,ife tenant 41 540 no right* 140S 7fl6 1 9 bona hdes 11 494 merger 17 503 creditors 12 H 410 parol evidence e 14 H 212 judgment lien 29 H 260 74 US 218 28 election 11 H 158 37 mortgaeor 5 NY 149 43 mitigation 21 32 AD 39 M 11 NY law question 8 NY 121 NY 60 notice 12 26 42 45 160 468 12 355 76 203 14 e4NY 7 NY 14 NY statutory 42 do 70 US 126 US trust power 9 4L 12 H d69H ins AD trust 179AD 166S 449 616 3 8tiel7AD "'^^gOAD 249 29 H ''28 M 10 NY 10 NY 16 NY e79NY 162 475 368 120 502 669 329 519 256 408 '41 352 223 630 609 406 592 204 323 107 lis 615 516e 618 539 542 192 31 86 1 seduction '> damages 625 280 276 105 214 217 581 dofiH f3T0 36 M ?4NY 31 NY 56 NY 666 296 222 44 407 442 insurance construction B5M 149 S 79 replevin 16 13 H 1 K 4K ratification 1 Ab 3Ab. e83NY 117 411 313 28 475 297 11 42 626 83 prob. cause 48 58 84 AD 2H 20 H 49 H 68 H 4TC 10 NY SONY 5SS 34 431 19 211 212 466 422 168 443 240 466 134 9 I assignment 37 628 39 102 6 Tr 327 covenant 49 135 NY 68 1 incomp ev 76 AD 448 64 H 137 257 39 NY I 200 554|98 consideration 578 13 delivery 14 26 24 H 46 H e79 H elll NY 43 M parol evidence 233 45 260 296 416 524 306 525 AliBliEVlATIONS : a, affirmed; d, distinguished; i, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note, oriticUed ; 1. limited ; c, explained ; o, OTcrruled ; •. tame «ue ; do, disaentiiiv opinion ; p, parallel cue ; q, qneatioocd ' N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Barbour Vol. 6 16 «4 statute frauUB 65 S19 estoppel 39 H , 3S4 contract fraud 5LRA 324n berturmance 13oAD 837 1 06 Pt. prf mance 5LRA 3260 109 discretion speoificatioD ih 13 eq assisnoieut 61 NY 268 d 71 NY 328 19 J contract 19 453 title vesting 13 other ev ne 37 H 1 K 2Ab exceptions 9 NY I 16 title 11 38 AD co-tenants 3TC 9 NY 184 65 delivery 79 H 79 H 44 M 70US f71 268 42 500 168 10 • indorser 23 d26 IH 4 TO f5Tr. f37NY 615 523 524 462 642 40436 487 eq. int. conversn 542 50 AD 142 460 634 210 213 617 308 limitation 2LRA 831n 3 1 3 nuisance 364 367 1 99 parol ev. a 2 NY 406 10 515 12 NY 470 201 authority « 2 NY 189 18 M 284 62 NY 481 620 parol evidence e 64 NY .294 tenant at will' 71 M 27B 130 S 328 133 mortagor 31 208 211 209 assessment Sulr-iNY 419 52 9 9 __ 560 579 e4NY delegation 15 ol5 31 NY ' axation iKY a4NY I 4 1 weight ot ev II 389 22 655 42 575 damages 32 NY 353 198 423 115 641 582 427 428 10 ejectment 15 369 leg. authority 18 247 50 NY 210 320 marriage 3 AD 639 70 AD 577 e 39 M 393 327 exemption o 11 NY 281 330 objections 366 custody 15 248 249 370growing crop 16 196 19 321 122 NY 489 oond. precedent 102 NY 12 373 aver, proof 16 267 mortgage lien f 1 H • 306 notice 114NY 286 231 ' aSNY )6 I 15 H i 23 M e24NY ISl NY co-servant 1 44 new matter 5 H 495 40 ■ 232 53 NY 552 taken as true. esp. superior -- 132AD 43 master neg. 492 635 175 529 220 528 r6NY a 6 NY 10 36 47 67 3TC 6Tr. 38 NY set o£F f IH 59 NY oi>tion 26 M 10 NY 168 170 378 401 525 527 383 disenetion 145 AD 687 19 H 29 H 18 M 72 NY 88 NY lo 130 S 190 273 248 399 27H 494 445 note 24 566 31 192 parting withvaJ. 41 32 indorsement ev 6NY _ 30 discretion 8 NY 77 45 1 admiBBionB 21 337 26 282 rule 26 NY 175 26 NY S42 assignment 16 298 303 vesting 392 recovery 219 NY 413 burden proof a 219 NY 414 458 parol ev 11 40 18 33 41 437 42 AD 35 11 H 646 ITC 6 e 4 Tr. 247 8 NY 218 e 406 do 8 NY 506 25 NY 52a e37NY 314 remedy 23 6&i averment 15 261 .ral evidence r,5M 595 26 43 65 9 NY 128 NY receiver 2T 29 43 m order relation 34 559 64 H 389 7 NY 1 47 tender e 16 demurrer 20 1 52 injunction 244 note as pay- ment 213 r9NY 7 63 78 AD 74 H ! K 2 Ab eSN 67 US construction 26 NY cnnd. precedent 31 NY I 65 warranty 394 32 eviction 58 88AD eSL 8 H 10 H 23 H 26 NY 46 NY 65 NY 124 NY do 124 NY 246 60 40 199 543 417 6 233 373 505 221 23:' '173 undertaking 11 M 444 I 77 commissions 18 AD 127 e56NY 31 I 79 election e 40 M 407 I 82 possession 35 167 398 relief 346lr4NY 13 606ll7 242! divisible 186|4LRA 449 404 lS6n 3231403 h. and wife 577,20 5)6 517 do 31 NY 566 386 parties 620 Sti H 404 i.uunterclaim i.,« ... \:^^2S 1037 4 1 6 criticism 12 13 17 36 1 H 28 H 32 H 37 H 80 H 3TC notice- 69 NY 234 604 149 452 37 392 605 210 484 dissolutn 575 preference do 148 AD liability do 148 AD .337 covenants 5 NY ol9 341 St. 66 10 H r4NY 34 AD 3 4 1 9 damages rfiNY 423 damages 467 conclusive 18 12 470 assignment 344 in writing. J* Ab, 253 false im- prisonment e 5 L 107 258 pleading e 10 381 258 construction e 48 NY 649 265 nav. stream public use 14 518 622 18 283 284 285 35 NY 460 injunction 97 NY use water 5LRA J ivigable fiSM 247 ,„ limitatnlprofiU 101 104 expenses |66 14 assignees d22 3K ITr. I Ab. 116 N d 117 NY creditors rights STB priorities 17NY surplus 32 ill 629 parol evidence 544 387 581 466 526 148 653 103 77 468 525 10 NY 56 NY justiticatiun 131 NY title IL trespasser 5L conclusive 1 455 466 613 jurisdictioQ 624 547 exp, clO performance do 14 guaranty 23 discharge 30 H lemaud 18 40 NY l»AC prom 488 582 631 107 188 315 116 247 412 47 560 306 149 385 415 398 557 guaranty 44 538 540 57 415 demurrer 7 L 195 averment proof 34NY 120 566 compet ev. 11 479 12 . 364 equity owner 18 576 corporation 12 51 9H 33 H 39 H 76 US 41 NY 46 NY 70 NY 98 M f 98 M 163 S f 163 S conclusive 13 76 US judgt. for'n state 66 335 incompetent ev. 45 M 318 82 1 judgment 10 295 jurisdiction 20 647 542 626 579 506 123 276 33 261 264 466 469 185 137 161 123 82 302 7BM probate 137S 404 39 NY 1139 NY 48 64 523 82 S79 142 436 98 1471 140 346 notice r6NY dl7 21 H e29H e85NY valid judgment 24 512 56 426 prosecution 12 H 369 429 law action 41 48 B7 e 98 AD 298 4Jloreign exectors 13 AD ell H 20H 326 126 277 409 481 leg. estate 13 99 trustees 14 641 presumption 79 H 82 492 mutuality 28 H 609 heir trust 8 47H lex loci. e24NY do 24 NY damages 107 NY .ransfer tax 199Ny 34 64 161 165 192 90 387 544 454 54 384 400 lis M 288 speoifv defects l.;.i S 252 competent I05M 716 583 limitations 5 e48 32 H 10 NY 110 NY authority 48 non-suit 276 318 206 467 178 344 71 265 411 268 381 n 15 d21 32 36 9 NY el4NY 54 NY 10 26 490! 29 31 349 notice i.~« ... 5LRA 286n *32 ong. debt^_^ 352 jurisdiction IBM . "* - ' 320 possession 504 serve copies 8 NY 42 34 397 335 352 438 oonveraion 546idoll9AD 260 16 AD 36:doll9AD 261 9 H 602 6 H 337 280 13 H 207 31 H 490 16 H S 50 H 576 273 non-perfmce 4 K 149 55 H 253 146 4 Ab 430 431 33 jj 282 72 NY , 520 25 NY 196 376 liquidated debt gg ny 494 514,98 NY 349 hmitations 56 M 224;72 M file executor's pwr. ] -'i t^ 596 81 H 520 QflZ 39 M 609 440 conversion ''"" ■ Ifil AD 766 12 offer do 12 20 waiver 25 M 8 NY 24 NY 507 waste 29 5H MNY S I 5 bar rll NY all NY 13 305 64 17 342 32 431 425 161 532 indemoitv 14 206 23 M 408 179 184 358 359 143 631 93 21 427 aLknowledgment 10.A.C 42 4n 589 jurisdiction r 6 NY 12 receiver 16 r36 83 US vesting 9 NY e87NY assignment 16 23 41 81 e9 AD 6H 2M e70NY 93 NY consent 20 conclusive 2LRA defense facta 45 181 632 pers. injury d 4 L 200 negligence "MI 341 637 recovery a 4 NY 326 45 615 646 damages a 4 NY 396 24 105 43 473 69 NY . 134 compliance 82 591 sp. performance 236 438 296 598 218 148 158 303 282 guarantor 1362 vesting title 147 S 537 contribution a 5 NY 205 19 warranty 24 554 balance struck 8154 607 strict com- pliance 10 47 r 19 18: jurisdiction 186,27 200 32 23 AD 32 M 8 NY d40NY 658 receipt 37 "'id cause R62 delivery 69 \D evidence efiOH demurrer 15 NY i. 23 M 'inegation 14.5 S 160 AD presumption 145 S 748' 160 AD 703 367 e 70 NY 97 135 87 226 58 264 71 292 503 598 284 4 28 736 748 703 aBBEEVIATIONS : a, affirmed; d. distinguished; f. followed; r, reversed; ni, modified; *, dismissed; n, note criticised ; 1, limited ; e, explained ; o, overruled ; s, same c^sc ; do. dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q. questioned Vol. 7 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Barbour VOL 7. 1 3 consideration 28 6 NY objections 6 NY construction 7 NY amendment e78NY 1 8 evidence 22 22 merger 106 AD 501 30 jurisdiction 31 490 159 9H title 67 AD 35 M 4TC 39 appointment 37 377 2M 358 359 48 399 173 a 5 NY 14 publication c 16 4L e21NY jurisdiction 31 3L construction 89 NY liability 117 NY four weeks 183AD 269 171S 125 53 authority 55 184 59 parol evidnee 26 ' 448 19 H -126 void aereeent 14 H 284 21 H 70m 169 AD 714 implied trust 26 H 506 e 87 H 76 77 e 66 NY 236 performance d 157 NY 289 statute frauds 292 90 33 547 27r. 327 at will 276 328 trespasser 49 NY remedy 59 M not estate 7i M 130 S tenant 71 M 130 S 80 trespass 7 45 demurrer 14 16 IH 86 H 4TC plea bad 98M t 163 S 9 1 adv power la 8 NY '9H 312 481 634 96 639 308 115 690 382 31 51 1 57 competent witness 11 478 636 a 15 NY 182 NY 454 494 253 jurisdiction 62 7L express promise [d 3 K 17 674 678 18 , 308 cond precedent 21 65 467 r7NY 2H 4TC aSN d86NY 150 US 523 4 272 31 67 415 24 ell NY subscription 29 32 37 16 NY acceptance do 26 NY e22H 96 US 421 books evidence 17-1 NY 496 assessment eSlNY 11 Ab' d44NY e52NY 86 NY 147 S f 162 AD 180 134 97 399 428 414 388 lOO: 72- undertkg, void 338;f 87 M 620|f 150 S 4AQ 280 slander ° ,111 AD 80 U M 363 364 263 fixtures 10 458 78f 368 wav. ct. elm l&AU 123d 370 cumulative 13 104 alleeatioDS e 35 H 560 6 Tr. 143 38 NY 16;! 373 distribution f 25 456 ptnrshp property 3 H 723 6TC residue IL 35 H 133 23 587 impeachment alteration proof 9 NY 149 3 AD 365 138 NY 368 49 M 365 assignment 37 M 8I» 570 insurance r 6 NY 405 16 256 3 TC 482 e 32 NY 408 472judl notice IH 384 3H 16' 23 H 582 3 TC 609 6 TC 268 plan delivery 27 M 631 477 misdemean 472 13 d52 62M 97 US 628 155 S 775 gen. contributn. d 185AD 893 f 92 M 548 156S 259 d 171S 1086 64 judgment 47 184 185 S SN 187 70 execution e2L 317 74 opinions 10 493 • 13 • 117118 possession 14 license 45 -jond. precedeni 1.39 AD 654 ^t, limitations 124 S 212 1 07 evidsBce 30 46 e 6 H 103 104 character e 29 U 128 proper practice 76M 262 134S 887 1 1 3 replevin r 7 NY 655 28 187 sSN 46 lien possession 5M 104 1 20competentev 11 478 ajsptb 30 H 191 87NY 4Ab liability eOONY 1 69 pleading s27 27 26 H 44 H e4M 11 NY contract 94 NY 614 301 34 368 73 76 43 186 65 33 162 ol d57AD 24 H 36 H 19 NY 5LRA 500 200 307 77 141 144 240 150n 380 debt aSN 119 115 personalty 43H 53 27 1 cumulative 13 30 return 25 e20NY deposition e25 27 104 662 27S 13.' 45i 241 I 74 guardian ; weight evidence 16 41 79 H 53 572 54 624 I 78competentev II 478 6381 36 26 1 27 asseaament 640 322 1 82 attachment 37 AD 25 1 9 1 dower 13 66 use and occupatn. new discov. ev. 67 412 80 AD 30f neghgence 15 NY 381 279 ratification 12 63 48 389 stockholders 28 667 66f. 464 28 H I 40 H J 76 US : 90 us i notice 20 513 34 352 47 ,167 169 legal evidence 44 123 objections d39 94 sum. proceedings 49 H 348 lease relation 27M 726 12 24 30 53 16L 7H judicial e 19H ■t Tr. 37 NY SN 1 33 judicial r7NY 7 12 16 24 53 11 AD 4L ii6L 4Tr. II NY 37 NY SN ussessmts 16 167il H 422 619 563 291 373 196 263 346 25 517 129 142 167 250 422 653 516 162 291 263 573 346 27 void disap. 94M 440 ci 158 S 304 1 43 assessment 34 NY statute 6H e36H 3TC nous 36 155 290 frauds 664 55 666 629 parol agreement o 5 NY 465 construction 154 NY 50>> 443 100 223 14: 443 67 o69 e21NY 26 NY SONY 211 NY judgment ev. e 10 NY 45! e 61 NY 16; liability 24 9; cond. precedent 38 618 388 commissionB a 6 NY 43G 39 I indictment 44 M 93 395 injunction 78 AD 391 071)5 002 construction 69 H 278 26 NY 394 jurisdiction 31 NY quantity 74 H 99 17 407 represntatn. 2!s 47 4 I 2 authority 50 AD 649 550 employment 4M 103 4 1 6 compensatn 46 319 e 64 NY 145 void 6L 44 6fj H 219 310 notice e24NY extrinsic ev 63 54 66 AD 3H e5TC 15 M e36M indictable 147AD 1325 310 536 308 628 435 714 443 752 482 pleading 306 95 537 34 670 115 276 576 representrtn 24 652 bar 61 34 4L 466 33 M 507 16 17 2H 13 H 4TC evidence ' H 539 488 mortgagor 138 NY 494 bar 13 26 36 36 H 2Ab priority test 37 M liability 93 NY conclusive ILRA 498 tender a 6 NY 4Tr 505 161 21 04 383 173 79 581 judgment 28 H63. amendment 36 29 review 47 NY 631 585 incomp ev 71 H 535. 3TC 332 d41 M 235 175 NY 226 590 intent 27 434 441 27 443; consideration 41 H 170- 66 NY 212 absolute owner 74 H do 3 SA elOM 479b23.M life time q,o'52NY ''*"'|61 NY 672n|''163NY vesting 23 H 434|q88NY 92,37 NY 48|508 use ets. r r 21 H 3Tr. 2 AB a( tice 20 M 24 M d88NY 116NY 1 52 decree 204 joinder 16 allegations 118 AD 208 damages IB 2 .1 5 realty r 11 NY 16 31 136AD, oai 297 pasturage '''*'|11 39e division fence' 292 1 13 597 construction 42P;e25 112 'presumption 86 H 430 135 181 NY 319 ■ 309 private way 544,7 558 667 U4 221 life estate 19 waiver 29 226 bar 10 13 ■ 34 47 iniplied trust 4H conversion 601 27 182 222 117 302 158 341 293 47 NY 69 probable cause- 40 M repairs 76 NY 148 S beneficiary ( 163 AD 614 477 3 1 4 opinions 12 383 ,,,13 117 661 '°Ail4 213 ,*0le9NY 383 1=5 do 9 NY 394 749 331 damages 170S 170 26 '354 authority 427 leg power jin 24 135 is 431 award (IS r6NY ^82 J^ 44,5 construction 22 10 d20 32 2 NY H 24 H 3TC 171 36 467 468 639 101 465 170 St. limitation 16 184 667 In writing 32 141 dl43 452 interest 11 42 2H e3H 5TC 34 57 529 249 138 e496 1249 constructn 'a 6 NY construction 1 68 NY 180 partial paymeni y:< N\ 7i 457 jurisdiction I] M 454 462 larceny a 6 NY 50 466 preference 16 302 waiver 20 244 void assignment 37 628 24 37 8 AD 29 H el4NY easement 6 32 M conting. injury 364 28 364 666 207 439 246 488 226 403 285 247 618 64 e50NY 121 NY legal title 168 NY fee vesting 11 450 451 618 suspension 127 NY 599 pleading a 6 NV 8 irregularity It 34 pc.flsesslou 16 61 626 toll 11 14 428 34 671 282 1^4 60- 195 229- 478 537 74 286 25 149- 134 264 616. 633 51 AD 168 NY license 17 injunction 67 62 H d 18 M 16 NY property 48 631 affidavit 33 AD 136 40 H 243 commission 78 H 615- 640 pwr selectn 75 M 42>> 409 644 representa n 618 28 47 estoppel 441 32 289 13 NY 638 166 316 275 101 386 dam. r r const'n 652 indorsers 2LKA auth) rity f ILl 4NS distinction f 21 2 iN Y damages 182AD 169S demand 67 discharge SONY 183 528 107 S9n{ llOnid 12 il3 656 attachmentf 285 406 535 301 loreditors '564 law quest'n affidavit 4 H regularity 14 H 3rd, party 76 NY 413 492 382 182: ABBREVIATIONS: V affirmed; d. distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; ", dismissed; n, note; c, criticised; I, hmited; e, explained; o, overruled ; s, same case: do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q, questioned N. T. Supreme Court Reports — Barbour Vol. S VOL 8 9 pleading 16 sale paroel* 24 eSL 9H 10 H 42 NY do 42 NY 42 NY eatoppe) 3L erection SSH 1 8 lapse 19 16 26 a 17 17 136 deed 67 18 662 d 27 2 oharitieg 102 27 106 easement ISO 21 H i»u j° strict compliance 26 200 16NY -""'" 86 NY 403 indemnity 161 AD ( 146 S implied power 23H 37 H 187NY 23 tax rent 70 AD e 177 NY 601 r 12S 21 407 487 30 28 fr'd assien'mt a 6 NY 610 15 23 60 AD U9AD 46 H 68H 6Tr TOM 128S 134S 341 200 426 168 251 537 479 532 48 decree 26 guardian 66 2L 36 H 48 H e20M 31 M 37 M parol evidence e 8 NY 405 liable 93M 302 f_156S 938 discretion court 93 M 309 f 156 S. 942 75 sham answer 14 dlS 18 NY 322 adv. possession 396 11 17 1 02 fut product 20 e25 e41 44 17 H e 142 NY uncertainty 40 H 57 H 36 M estoppel 34 NY mortgace 65 NY 164 1 35 corp powrs 133 241 103 106108 48 277 233 reUef 15 NY 193 244 presumption 93 NY 36 mistake 5LRA 165n 239 jurisdiction 16 103 398 objectionable title 190 18 ITO elK eSAb estoppel 54ifY court power 16A0 189 16 AD 605 9 H 209 e 2K 280 e 1 Ab 25 NY 153 presumpt'n judicial "oti™ 480 3 H 476 477 6 TO 38S public highway 742 182 273 238 83 96 103 35 AD 39 AD 95 AD 7L 4H 37 H 40 M 38 NY Don-user 36 2TC 10 121 51 262 301 648 438 117 329 353 1 58 presumption 16 M 446 bail murder 47 M 97 M 162 S 256 1 69 arrest 873 304 . 7 1 recovery d 61 M 600 ,.,. indorsement 39 201NY 139 303 406 174 discretion 418 80 US 219 122 677 189 possession r 9 NY 291 308 8 260 644 adv possession ' " ■ 37 H 548 9 NY 343 a SN 206 109 467 chee. possession 11 AD 27 H 84 NY equity lien 119 AD 118 NY title lien 28 132 NY 303 92 640 251 143 103 64 205 parol ev. 16 21 e2S d45 10 M d24NY 124 fr'd transfer 154 NY 706 130 pew realty 104 18 17 34 subscription 44 H 6 NY 7i M 130 S statute power IS NY 189 divestine, 32 4(; 468 16 516 781 279 33 19 173 468 343 2 1 demurrer 12 469 2 1 3 replevin e 12 349, 350 51H 48-' e 71NY 30 levy 13H 2 1 7 complaint 20 88 H 49 NY 225burden proof a 13 346 96 US 123 corporations 21 NY 408 284 240 632 621 645 634 183 184 -B 167 268 261 649 146 28 '442n 30 33 NY 72 NY 34 NY 461 riparian rights 5H 646 188NY 79 navigable river 18 IAD 412 244 ejectment e 81 H 241 250 pleadg pay't 29 442 IH 539 e 3 H 653 4TC 115 e 6 TO 104 253 adv. poss'n 26 403 57 H 482 9 NY 343 346 62 M 228 impeachment 34 622 138 NY 42 300 irregular 16 25 3 1 2 indorsement 26 H 106 notice 26 NY 466 323 inference 121 106 256 477 285 290 272 38 seduction 50 AD damages do 24 NY 42 NY 68 NY aggravation 30 NY marriage 53 NY personal injury 15 M 628 sexual intercrse 63 H 363 327 contract r 21 NY 462 20 61 333 conversation 40 . 405 delivery 4L 28 6 H 336 337 consignee 602 126 NY 526 20 260 340 vol bond 51 AD 9 344 contract r6NY 351 appeal 355 atty liens 26 H 607 2M 163 fact question 30 NY 216 63 NY 184 practice 63M 50 no lien attorney 3 OOP 19 358 negligence f 13 dl3 14 dl4 23 IH 3TC 14 M el3NY joinder 11 H ITr 30 NY 36 NY reservation 82 US powers 9H 80 US 495 497 601 368 372 661 379 539 601 60 692 101 79 206 497 309 213 368 contrib neg. 8 13 22 32 18 NY 436 15 497 584 659 258 384 service writ Sunday 23 M 270 44 M 498 Sunday trial e 44 NY 435 390 contrib neg. el3 496 497 601 13 596 14 368 el3 NY 50 396 draft r7NY d2TC agent 11 NY sSN 401 title IS 459 122 211 12 498 408 damages 36 577 tender 27 H 408 H 96 31 M 603 e S2 M 678 right possession 182AD 26 412 dam. entire d27 647 efi48 579 482 451 178 380 597 35 62 5H fifiH 5 2M eoSNY Northampton Tables 35 AD 55 412 right possn 169S 469 damages 186AD 594 173S 294 423 meae. dam 66 82 96 AD 524 40 NY 66 61 NY 360 427 authority IS 87 charge error 28 649 negligence 62 310 80 NY 216 436 notes r 7 NY 613 SN 5 439 revere error 13 536 pleading 15 M 415 42 M 270 bill particular 65M 656 450 taxation a 8NY 241 463 release a 6 NY 18 423 207 486 domain a 7 NY 314 493 assessment name disclose 7H 373 e 41 H S37 502 distress 16 610 14 NY 505 confirmation 13 H 485 509 in trust s 20 558 1 H 416 3 TO 602 370 5 1 4 sheriff 11 H alteration 92 H 496 proof consent 138 NY 358 assume harden 64M 227 5 1 9 set-off a 6 NY 305 527 sp prfmce. 50 333 57 566 87 AD 10 31 NX 98 144NY 678 530 declarations 30H 306 5UH 104 coi.cJusive 60M 19!» 53 5 tender 47 581 541 jurisdiction •14AD 421 6 TC 491n 71M 238 128S 437 service motion 11 M 107 547 indictment 5 9 648 defective 5H 5L variance 44H maintenanea 28 d35 SSH 98 NY 126 NY defective 69 selection 19 H divesting 100 NY aon compos men 14 490 2H 401 e4T0 599 waiver eq. lien 32 95 100 e 67 440 assumption 33 . 251 vendor's lien 207 NY 417 258 627 254 113 610 546 214 218 1698 321 560 forgery 3H e4H 33 H 35 H 6TC 3 Ab 160 NY 168 NY 293 457 246 246 310 474 442 64 13 564 revers. error 14 H 451 not error 142 S 879 consent lOOM 626 166S 959 567 title d20 49 e21NY 320 645 473 570 construction 95 13 partners IL 11 H 22 H bona 6de IL 456 35 649 461 579 marriage 45 536 register evidence 95 AD 145 73 H 604 585 parol ev. 16 454 conversion 9H 83 NY cotenanta 133S ilo 133S action lies .lo 75M 420 204 1024 1025 644 195 286 552 lunatic 13 429 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished r. criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; ; f, followed; r, 8, same case ; do, 649 588 t'd proof 96 NY 107 593 judt. oi-ed 31 394 1 1 H 285 32 NY 463 pers. security 49 NY 598 lien . 13 NY 167 597 injunction 23 378 603 proof acts «2 487 reputation 11 H evidence 26 NY chastity 153 NY 140 S prostitute 87 592 961 457 6 1 2 contract 16 H 4S0 St. limitations 34 NY 818 618 dower sur- plus IS 664 136 264 62fi S9< 408 40 428 239 S69 480 804 864 S40 226 68 23 56 41 AD 4L 11 H 21 H 23H 28H 30 H 51 H 63 NY 118 NY do4K do3Ab 26M down interest 123 S 267 630 notice dam 6 AD 60S 46 AD 414 46 H 546 73 NY 199 presume neg. 113 AD 866 animal neglig, 18AC 4flB 18AC 47S 637 pleading 12 469 53 H 380 645olaim against town 15 19 22 27 o36 18 H 25 H 40 H 75 NY e 110 NY agency do 104 AD 10 H 74 NY compromiae 35 44 440 303 646 661 66S 352 22 193 319 23S 005 664 SIS 293 662 655 revers error 12 864 restriction i 11 NY I3f reversed; m. modifled; •, dismissed- dissenting opinion; i,, parallel case; q.questfon^ Vols. 9, IC N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Barbour VOL 9 Saangnment 16 £76 divesting 16 H 468 1 7 authority d23 estoppel 27 21 M mistake 2H eSTC 610 290 SOS 4S 35 revooation 16 26 41 23H &LRA 34 NY 34 M 83 M speo, bequest 672 419 64 166 346 203 488 224 1 58 pleading 90AD 189 161 indictment 46M d47M "money" iiiaS 140 AD devise HAD do 11 AO 170 NY satisfaction 62 AD 37 H 44 H conciusire 69 H construction e92NY 164 NY S9M ademption ILRA 204n eS4M 160 unaltered int. 6LKA 346 personalty 119AD 512 failure legacy f 165 AD 278 96M 207 f 150 S 837 161 S 62 52 revocation 6LRA 346 60 jurisdiction 207 642 463 393 361 36S 391 408 220 331 166 233 538 436 66 90 AD 62 H 74NY nuisance 66 H 104 AD partnership ' 4SA 120 NY negligence 82 NY construction do72M 129S 1 76 bailee 65 possession 19 AD conversion 8M 20 M 23 M e34M 61 NY demand 48 AD 98 NY n(f defense 60 M conversion do 133AD 29 681 419 307 244 228 656 396 281 44 91 193 620 262 296 282 64 481 417 494 65 574 191 judgment 11 632 compliance d 20 638 warranty 25 604 202 subscription a 12 NY 18 24 36 H 64 church > a 11 NY 17 29 18 M decree e44 ecclesiastical e4L 64H 64 NY costs 17 law question 32 charitable 193 NY 419 418 243 105 34 660 304 347 220 663 66 uses 465 82 corpn. gift 6LRA lOSn 100 corpn. gift 6LRA 105d 1 50 agency 39 665 1 52 authority a 6 NY 92 48 62 penalty 69 AD 12 sl5 20 36 37 44 46 44 NY 9oNY 250 161 580 538 539 550 552 239 134 579 ell NY 307 e 21 NY 171 e27NY 317 e32NY 222226 credit sales 13 NY 219 260 Corp. name 11 lib 5b ^oo successor 66 70 implied repeal 2H 344 6H 27 2 TC SO 4 TC 555 construction 17H 98 NY damages 24 H 271 re vers error 29 290 presumption 43 228 4 TC 621 33 M 469 28 NY 665 44NY la:; 44 NY 322 competent ev. IK. 30 2 Ab 495 conversion 19 M 130 exceptions 22 M 106 must prove do lea Ai) 898 505 84 460 express trust 27 c29 3b d47 e87AD 33 Ny 272 291 398 657 44 308 448 131 46S e34NY 608596 susp'n pwr. alien 15 3L 4Tr 4 Ab 58US 14S 364 67 112, 114 389 law char uses 440 levy 29 NY 489 statement fraud 49 M 316 449 bar Pll desoiiption 12 606 compensation 46 319 notice 22 M 237 conclusive SNY 58 1S6 492 50 certioiari 64 nuisance bl. eaUY 33Nif 3jJMY 37 NY 44M vesting 13SS 73 AJ. 55 109 izo 131 7o 613 legacies 156 235 28H 14 M 35 M public us lti7 AD t 153 S 361 em. 4L.rtA 4bC 524 194 52L 467 629 doniaiii 7»bii 2 1 4 considerat'n 11 641 eq assignee 42 2L e6L 55 NY IIS'NY 128 NY 36 415 480 333 '355 41 competent ev. 18 533 2 1 9 adv. possesn 6 NY 15 title 40 liability 230 conversion 342 492 233 215 r 10 NY 40 e40H 31 NY 114 NY demand 19 H 34 M joinder 32 H 242 proof 169 AD 155 S 248 award 20 255 fraud e 19 29 assignment 335 405 51 493 556 629 61 333 728 670 485 178 543 278 notice lb 17 20 29 02 27 AL> 2L equity 2b a foreclosure 25 NY jurisdiction lb 10 102 2U 3Ui 23U 406 424 b40 324 323 366 coverture 287 ejectment s 12 356 15 493 tenants 28 251 subservient 3B 390 practice 36 b31 297 attorneys 37 AD allegations b2M 302 a 13 61 3L 2H 6 H 4TC repeal plied NY 30 422 im- 299 258 230 344 27 555 309 indenrur 67 39 H 3 1 5 relief 12 NY 295 75 36 3 1 7 restriction 14 625 carriers e 64 NY 302 324 jurisdiction 15 144 17 , 105 'iM 123 581 354 422 519 22 377 5l0 79 e24 28 52 IL construction 2L blH 79 11 16NY constitutional UNY 213 371 services s9 388 25 437 legacy satisfaet'n 4 a 197 74 NY 482 contract ev 32 84 AC do i26AD 72 H emancipation 115 NY 134 imphed eontraet 24 M 68 vesting 43 H 559 ineompet. ev 26 348 378 review 63 424 legal evidence 21 AD 385 63 H 102 388 application 477 parol ev. 28 326 48 96 9 NY 531 482 mtge. sale 27N Y 457 485 relief 176 AD 159 S 57 777 487 covenant 40 H 204 consideration 584 416 17 632 67 ^oste 19 H 26 H 29 H 31 M 83 M allowance 144 S 395 protest a 10 NY e49NY 378 600 325 656 48 577 1051 96 276 5LRA 37n'3S 402 acceptance 36 _ 473 408 jurisdictton 73 1U6AD e49H e3Tr 1 Ab e36NT[ 52 NY e 124 NY e 135 NY 6SLRA equity 1 K enforcement do 182AD do 170S 336 513 158 247 597 373 548 45 909 146 329 490 580h. and wife 44 368 as witaesses SO 17H 585 trust 36 59 S 4eath r roof a 7 irr 306 7 Tr 313 presumption 3611 75M 77 M 136 S 137 S 38 NY' 184 NY ejectment 64 NY 733 451 442 638 764 299 641 267 VOL.10 9 statute wills 9 643 r evoeatoD 16 672 estoppel 25 SO vol. payment 57 288 66 S03 4L 244 parol evidence 48B: intent 16 119 674 609 character ev. 18S NY 484 jury question U4 AD 430 assumption 207 NY 403 6 1 I raven error 83 NY 186 6 1 Se stoppel 25 54 26 NY 50 471 47 493 limitation e 79 AD 250 253 9H 329 e 51 H 125 500 docketing 42 593 oo-teneBt 1 L 434 51 I contract 42 c62 title risk SH 5 I 6 trust 71 AD *L 528 notice 12 assumpsit 30 qualified 18 agencv 3L 7H e7H US NY designation 11 NY el9NY 576 600 246 350 256 54 223 315 165 364 365 474 202 316 114 NY 187 189 532vol. payment rehef 57 65 4L 2Ab ONY redemption s 54M mistake lOSM 171S 288 302 244 467 391 160 62 781 535 damages r4NT 419 15' 257 373 299 271 619 levy 16 el L title 21 H improper ev. 22 H 1 K implied warran ty 37 479 165 NY 126 reversal 2 Ab 38 630 parol ev. 18 201 634 estoppel 140 AD 296 127 NY 392 26 charter 11 authority IS 18 32 property 48 38S pub. lue streets 4S0 207 246 419 148 438 141 142 618 102 204 416 610 64 21 27 41 acceptance e49H warranty 19 M 48 NY satisfaction 180 644 625 544 198 647 recovery 17 M 130 657 possession r 12 NY 664 forgery 160 NY 267 54 67 1 fraud 20 H 62 41 H 70 explicit charge 67 H 576 92 US 563 676 exemption 13 US IH 352 3 TC 597 680 legis power 15 130 24 476 e8NY489 491496 2H 4TC ITr elTr dl4NY 16 NY 27 NY 39 NY 124 NY compensation 34 603 49 121 ILRANS 128n discretion SLR A 376 comn. law remy. do 141AD 688 32 limitation 15 170 180 payment 11 NY 19S 8 SN . 66 35 jurisdiction 35 M 767 bonds 59 NY 90 procedure f 176 AD 57 159 S relief 176 AD 159S 777 57 58 777 46 contempt 15 e exeat 6H 17 H 21 H 4L SONY construction 45 M 59 intent 69 NY 40S 380 S98 435 184 25 89 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f. c, criticised ; 1, limited ; 63 62 fact question 48 SS 67 lien costs 7L 38 8H 129 presumption 82 M 6 143 S 698 74 assumpsit a 7 NY 543 SN 35 87 easement 14 370 18 585 9 1 surety exemption 639 . i.,_.j. „ -, . --■ - followed; r, reversid; m, modified; *, dismissed: n. Bote explained; o. overruled: s.samtcase; do. dissenting opinion ; p, pajalli case; q, quesiionS M, Y. Supreme Court Reports— Barbour Vols. 10, 11 IH STC 97 notiee r7NJ( 22 notably 28 juriadictioD 21 3fi SL 17 M 147 OS 70N-X 8SN bona fids 46 362 SB7 property right S64 8S0 600 S02 422 412 237 1'4 266 57 214 S4 franehUe 37 do 20 NY 27 NY eSlNY keep 62 M 247 realty chee 10 H S24 607 427 383 620 202 usury 20 10 H 21 NY maintain 46 24 H 25 H e41 H 276 411 201 1 1 2 reyerB error 12 365 objeetions 36 401 U NY 131 bSN 63 I 1 7 Qomputins 6 AD 591 75 NY 242 1 20 damages ill 35 NY sSN adv poaaeasn 62 if 1 57 fixtures 46 65 STC 18 NY e40NY e66NY do 66 NY 254 custom 26 404 adv'se possession 41 183 e 90 AD 465 e 8 H 270 54 NY 38S 74 NY 24a existenoe deed 436 470 500 568 546 629 333 deron water 14 20 21 NY estoppel 32 NY 348 trespass 6L review 6 NY 162 NY aside verdict 121 AD aifirmance 185AD 172S 61 62 obieotioBS 42 AD 461 offioial notiett 441 320 472 66S 300 87 504 4Tr 37 NY 48 NY SN distiaetioD 48 NY 67 AD perfect 91 M 154 S 339 216 207 228 249 225 146 34 293 498 S04 title 189 447 946 190 842 258 compliance do 142AD 447 1268 972 260 Stocknolder 17 673 605 subscription 354 notiae 22 46 5i» 37 H 61 H 6L deed evidence 187NY 105 presumption 19A0 881 369 215 617 571 22 164 I 67 assign judg't 7 L 403 175 ratification rSNY status 83 AD 75 H 37 NY 4Tr sSN presumption do 121 AD 123AD 44 NY 183 estoppel 19H payment 43 NY 93 NY 139 NY satisfaction 125 AD 398 128 311 168 119 146 624 70 192 526 61 306 125 301 20 21 26 37 37 41 U N-V e 14 NY 14 NY e 16 NY e 26 NY implied promise 31 NY 438 285 warranty 25 604 18 NY 389 application 60 101 parol evidence 1 93 deliver goods 28 222 conting't interest 74 NY 153 202 declarations 30 AD 19 competent ev. 83 AD 423 141 NY 230 meas. dam, 221 162 543 468 697 608 168 109 345 350 460 145 360 use streets SONY 290 tax 10 21 certificate 63 discharge 19 H 612 abrogation 67 H examination 11 NY 161 131 303 new. d. ev. 43 209 308 authority 10 528 26 335 340 undisp. debts 24 65 jurisdiction 26 432 costs 26 heirs 34 43 H 2TC 41 M 34 NY 134 NY personalty 41 175 190 20 86 20 333 174 182 8 644 661 103 491 66 eq. eommission 666 208 246 24'< 408 605 148 247 438 668 618 104 204 266 13 16 18 37 d39 2H 29 H 4TG 6 NY dl4Y dl6NY' 27NNY mandaiaus 49 injunction 62 369 relief 62 2L11A 116 NY defense SLR A 372 revial li4M 376 mistai^e SO AD e22M 87 US 383 seal 6A1> 27 NY 54 NY joint obhsation 632 273 817ii 304 100 439 134 449 664 41 89 400 641 121 74 246 41 dower 42 legal title 2H STC estoppel ell NY trustee 16 M 436 infant e4H e6TC mutual mistake 119 AD 138 S mistake 78 M 440 insurance 20 636 IIH 112 496 removal im- provements d M AD 807 37 H 361 19 NY 240 243 e 125 NY 850 47M 406 3 SB 52 written contract 54 M 227 trade fixtures 20AC 109n 5 1 2 parol ev 7 L 373 12 NY 470 518 diversion water 19 38S 21 419 22 146 32 276 34 652 17 H 361 595 presumption I87S 764 597 wife will r 12 NY 415 608 declaration 16 . 306 presumption 137S 6 1 2 carrier raONY 13 17 42 44 S8 764 269 363 188 260 666 323 VOL. II 9 mechan lien rSNY 883 g NY 441 d 443 aN 124 1 4 guaranty SOU d 107 NY 8 guaranty r28 22 guardian 26 340 843 523 authority 249 506 1011 fact 654 a 11 NY 26 335 340 43 3L 119 NY :uardian 7 e 104 NY tatutory 72 M presumption ISIS 537 easement 446 warranty 39 6Tr e 39 NY 281 136 224 640 621 324 353 415 412 32 77 264 424 .351 621 bodily pain 49 H 462 personal injury loNY 420 mental suffering 15NY 424 626 privity STC payment 103AD 638 misjoinder 292 42 16 AD 21 AD 32 AD 28H 4M 43 M 91 M 65 NY 155 S 64 NY 447 review 44 discretion 15 U pieading 6 Tr 75 79 37 NY 641 accounting 02M 192 454 evidence 42 H notice 13 NY com law Eng 86 NY 547 relief el AD do 42 NY 65 NY 419 356 398 637 49 63 566 293 33 439 529 530 39 188 558 bona fides 22 H 218 trespass 60 11 W 213 acc't stated 134AD 199 9H 107 219 NY 512 218 stockholder a 6 NY 562 219 lien vessel 189 US 196 223 lease ferries 32 104 111 120 62 M 41 Q[29 31 32 11 H 13 H 4K 72 NY consideration 34 66 78 H note 41 AD construction 14 H 321 variance 20 353 362 646 356 341 207 149 520 625 272 124 204 207 96 AD f 171 AD 148 S guaranties t 171 AD 388 seizin 79 H 448 42U 340 29 NY recitals 47 NY 483 support 13 29 6H 8M implied prom 8EH 510 Buspn pwr. alien. 96 AD 43 M will 33 AD 402 surety 39 187 816 489 489 lobbying vs pub pohoy 34 H 66 H 66 H IK e4Ab 49 128 SSI 362 364 682 6162 64 406 hiring a 8 NY 182 378 189 110 112 607 128 679 64 1 30 626 566 limitation payment 16 dole S2H 11 NY 18 NY 797 183 16 24 28 68 9 AD 6H 71 H e23NY joinder 134S severance 76 M lability 156 AD 142 S several 85 M fl48S 70 401 446 67 IL 20 M 42 M necessaries 78 H trust estate 80 H cannot recover 80 M 379 142 S 559 302 216 537 6 606 633 446 337 248 61 639 288 95 248 341 26 grant corpn. d 12 463 title 16 111 eminent domain 58M 586 33 hldg. over 61 NY 316 35 waiver 145 S f 84 M 36 contract 8 NY 405 oral evidence 641 restraint e 35 H 426 656 construction 57 597 misjoinder e6 AD e52 AD limited f 93 M 156S 124 618 170 180 193 322 195 561 659 imorovid'n a 6 NY 444 9 H 472 663 nonsuit 46 AD 147 ol8 22 32 34 62 66 66 AD e2Tr 2Tr 69 US 88 US el4NY e36NY 36 MY 140 NY 480 374 520 637 100 543 250 52 274 55 450 293 240 634 387 573 note paymt S5 H 491 unenforceable 175 AD 279 160 S 146 576 usur. loan a 6 NY 107 do 33 NY 41 40 NY 269 582 authority slO 16 23 AD 79 NY 152 NY relief ;02 NY allowance ri M iSC.S 585 relief SLR A 626 ^464 112 489 108 141 281 332 159n 881 238 44 NY 4 I trover 36 lien 62 AD 33 NY 43 fixtures 66 20 AD e61 H 92 d41M e40NY dower 10 M realty ISM conversion 188 NY descent 162 AD 147 S 80 real party 26 640 compensation 47 NY 197 usurious excess 669 466 589 678 226 451 304 334 182 295 431 147 176 331 809 192 157 AD 143 S 91 sureties 20 oflnce vacant 77 NY 96 vo>d judgmt. d 41 S57 construction 60 386 75 NY 100 usury 31 5LRA variance 2K 3K 2Ab sSN 242 proof 102 466n 678 169 294 184 1 1 2 contrib neg AUUREVIATIONS: a, afiirmed; d, distinguished ; f, folio wed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, criticised; 1, limited; e, explained ; o, overruled ; s, same c ase ; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, q Vols. 11. 12 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Barbour SI 22 olSNY i 1 7 supt. SB audit bm STH 1 20 lien E3H 341 684 42 oor 230 148 132 £t l24rsTived 5H attestation ■ 27 M 468 34 M 443 r26iio 161 S reversal 128 I27penalty 18 161 NY 134 penalty 84 M 140 146 S 486 135 damages 22M 22 breach duty 198NT 407 1 44g;uaranty »81fy 207 26 183 statute frauds 20 489 33 213 • SN . 04 2 1 3 cdntract 17 383 38 114 86 US b79 215 new trial 67 discretion 23 H 224 serrices 3H ellH relatiyeE 6TC 412 66l 306 1 47 parol ev 16 88H sSN 1 52 priority a»NY 30 NY iSN 59 estoppel 602 144 237 aONY 29 d46 setoff 46 sSN 242 169 406 18] 276 206 237 parwership 42 H 224 4 8S £67 241 reouests 17 660 22 M 106 ciiarffe 28 185 costs 88 H 130 promissory note 66 NY 21 administrator 466 105 NY 248 oysters 43 M 254 reviTor r9NY sSN conditional r38CP 137 85 160 602 3E ITr 1 Ab 44 NY 66 NY voidable i23AU foreclosure e6H 35 H 59 H lOlNY 149 386 241 657 54 20 100 257 172 e24NY obstruction 44 user e64H 121 NY 471 parties 16 sp. 18 364 purchase 51^KA 166n 368 deceit 1? 520 prox damaines 19 40 ■M 4SS e 3L 281 387 pleading 41 a 47 680 trespass 79 H discretion SNV estrays 19A(J 566 558 disoharsa |e30H 371 600 565 430 322 409 481 jurisdiction 21 433 485 payment 2TC 603 77 490 trust 15 sl6 39 lien ' . 29 H 74 US 498 title 22 H 371n 390 center St. 34 501 519 34 633 trespasser 93 AU 263 recovery 21 H 44S 271 heir 10 H 524 293 discovery consideration 77 NY 14) 1 73 reformation 23 26S advertising IL tax sale do27H ev. of intent 40 H 46f' 166 mistake 49 H *66H o21 NY 1 9 I notice 20 273 586 451 204 2L OL 32 H '65 H 84 H ,197irY . foreclosure 51 H 20 424 5« 518 620 139 403 41 32 AD 309 iraiv. 20 24 26 NY 3 1 2 contract 102 NY 340 482 280 419 421 3 1 5 will r6NY 391 332 will con- Btruction 19 B02 41 53 42 50 34 NY 205 intent governs 41 H B3H- UiH 7m 1 'Ir 3M iaM 2 K el 15NY e 153 NY exemplary cumpliance 69 M 144 answer title y H 521, 522 Via S zBo 399 trespass 6L 371 equitable lien IhaNY 569 456 lis 578 sua 456 137 231 52 634 184 6U8 431 danx. 614 343 369 376 628 260 218 68 H 103 NT 134 NY 534 411 505 395 510 referee wit- ness 59 NY 379 5 1 6 dividends 1 H 667 tormer suit 4TC 8M e26H e36M 4^ NY J unsdiction £148S {8BM 241 341 340 92 66 907 595 569 demurrer 19 NY 272 574 eiectmant a 7 NY 2M 580 eq. assignmt 43 H 482 e 62 US 407 assent writing 76 NY 217 587 demurrer 11 H 679 592 covenant 21 649 parol evidenoe 83 H VOL 12 9 joinder a 9 NY sSN e29 36 objectione 42 bar S9H answer 4Tr 37 NY pleading 27 M 46 167 614 519 39 36 rllNY e9H r9 T estoppel 17 H 61 537 536 488 243 373 97 406 602 debt sSN a 8 NY 6 1 comr. h'wy. * 10 NY 353 15 13S 620 prom, note 11 .641 6211' d20W ;. summons 368 624 ins. policy 39 233-4 notice to agent 2 1 sammons 23 316 320 process 20 AD 206 onus proband! 79 M 459 direct proof 141 S 208 . 37 contract e 16 364 measure damage 18 33S 50 84 21NY 268 performance 88H 3 Ab 3E 100 NY tender e26M jSN aONY rule damage 59 M oifer good 170S 520 attachment 16 369 30 443 37AD 25 non residence U5NY 87 request charge 3K. S8B a Tr I3i5 e 34M lyy 527 trustees 511 1 94 injunction f 26 H 206 1 98 a.sBignment 12 180 IS 631 sale on credit 17 392 n «6 13Ci > 11 NY 30f il NY 589 32 NY 67 US 222 16 337 relief s8NY a 9 NY 55 sL ISN 349 escrow 2M 26 NY 97 NY Hlluwances 71 M costs I. ■{II S 574 no NY U 15 dl5 d20 26 NY 71 349 355 318 207 394 491 25 510 59- 4 1 4 ejectment 328 358 34 540 title center st. 34 601602 519 37 403 7 Tr 136 38 NY 271 intention 42 468 469 jurisd'n pleaded 6H 344 nuisance 14 NY 518 easement 32 AD 12 H 38 H 3K 4Ab 36 M evidenoe 24 H return 31 NY joinder ( 97 M f 163 S 541 return 10 H 49 H eI6NY 353 fiduciary funds f 86 M 402 tl49S 329,330 debtor 172 AD 19^ 158 S 582 356 trustee 18 cestui qUR trust le 41 59 13 3Ab 600 676 539 160 390 246 2b 605 317 170 686 497 62 3K 2Tr 3Tr 4Ab 17 M 36 NY estoppel ILEA 646 419 232 289 139 284 119 664 218e 546 coexecutors 106 dedication st 27 NY 204 134 NY 406 r. r. right st 5L11A ,176 jurisdiction 8 NY as 457 dedication 19 40 H 1134 NY, 403 47lcul de sac e30H f 75H 2TC 35 NY le35NY 1 148 S 86 M decree 42H lasNY 191 135 465 221 223 910 599 514 461 27 authoiity 16 31 33 684 592 38 299 receiver 36 260 creditor trust 67 381 corp powers 35 H 360 10 NY 454 467 notice UNY 287 management 135S 211 presur^iption 150AD , 794 78 319 61 263 617 240 625 661 169 196 89 67 relig corpn 64 309 27 6H conclusive 41 AD 50 AD 100 AD confession judizt. 69 H 419 331 188 490 84 charge error 15 NY 626 set aside 185AD 344 99 bill lading 33 17 H 9 NY estoppel 65 NY 116 195 66 N$- 400 401 549 recovery 19H 148 40NY 404 equity 626 136 S«il61 AD S6'3 K ABBREVIATIONS: c, criticised ; 1, limited ; affirmed ; d, :, explained : c 554 st limitation 15 179 6M 214 578 adminissn. debt 37 8 NY 373 634 comp witns 26 582 18 633 11 281 642 jury questn 5L 102 ■SO NY 216 pleading 113 AD 800 645 comp. witns a 7 NY 481 12 61 9 NY 173 1 03 conversion 652 reversal *» AD 416 27 M 307 agents authority 2LRA 824n 657 jurisdiction 12 23 23 316 320 abandonment 62 H 320 661 costs 22 86 court's power 46 93 56 296 1 48 will a 8 NY sSN testamentary 159 AD 90 144 S 459 1 56 rescission e 29 418 45 NY 832 82 NY 639 1 6 1 officers a 11 NY 392 31 607 47 42 d 5 L 274 18 H 263e264 34 M 671 e 11 NY 672 1 68 assignment 622 274 372 68 634 521 616 223 a 6 NY 18 49 H 32 M 6 7 US 3 NY 25NY 32 NY bar 43 defraud 57M 536 631 534 if 3 referees 40 60 M 3 eq oonvsion 49 13? 8H SfiR beneficiary 24H 31fi trust executors 52 H 301 election 79 H 100 3M 440 140 NY 377 power sale 69 NY 712 fl 14 127 NY 669 estoppel 151 S 70?, proceeds sale 166 AD 245 distinguished ; . overruled ; s. f- followed: 1 20 ejectment a 9 NY 9 46 464 s SN 169 1 26 mayor ct. 43 316 1 28 sheriff 632 303 210 94 196 cashier 42 H 640 201 land under water 1? . 490 491 riparian owner 1° . ■ 1* boundaries 34 620 37 H 647 57 H 480 7'J-M 285 center stream 140 S 337 207 Jurisdiction 687 el38S 209 note 6H sSN rONY no NY payment 102M 348 224 463 599 6 90 2 1 5 amendment 60 98 54 414 '""0" assignee 378 60 1 usuryplead'd 66 AD 43B e 27 An i02 chat, mortgace 470 500 71 H 552 668 title absolute 484 I TC 562 exemptjouii 18 41 214 89 I 7 subscription 220 559 159 60S 1050 32 nuisance 140 NY damages 146 NY 43 45 usury a 10 NY . 19f^ 31 267 alteration e27H 34f sSN 225 neghgeuce 46 NY 289 50 dower 36 41 Z 57 NY 329 73 NY 362 27 476 93 169 value com- missions 276 63 contract _ 13 19 53 56 6 AD 18 AD rule 50 AD 52 AD 71 AD B86AD 2H 3H 9H 15 H 17 H 20 H 27 H 27 H - 28 H 31 H 33 H 36 H 37 H e38H 40 H 43 H 47 H 78 H - ITC 5TC .TC 1 SS 78 NY 18 NY 123 NY e 129 NY 176 NY 47 M 188 299 86 mandamus r7NY 106 dower 56 29 H construction 110 AD 258 318 213 . 1 6 legal ev 35 119 harmless error 44 . 123 3H 498 46 H ■ 11 5 TC 579 1 1 9 vesting 20 460 cond. subseg. 39 87 70 NY 311 297 84 NY 143 1 37 affidavit 546 16 c29 7H 192 31 NY power sale 32 H 352 303 384 160 406 618 I 47 aav. posses- sion 33 281 ■ule damages 11 458 463 335 195 576 34 565 61 435 643 105 66 350 232 122 162 154 412 427 441 644 434 318 456 591 121 398 261 661 63 21 391 433 623 262 274 300 410 611 223 114 91IJ 710 51 M 96 M :a AD 159 S reversal 129 AD conclusive 124S • 741 1 73 considerat n 13 tf 638 1 83 comment ?^. r. 235 7 AD 588 discontinuance 7 L on 10 NY 28 M discretion 60 H 88 NY 602 312 544 276 1 88 considerat'n 19 299 208 mandatory c 14 AD 661 e 58 H 466 discretion 90 AD 558 mandamus d 71 H 100 209 demurrer 682 434 274 569 388 283 ABBREVraTIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed: r, reversed- m rTu^!^Zr~'~^^ r-=^ i22 e. cnticsed; 1. hmited; e, explained; 0, overruled; s.' sime case; do?di!Ieiune c^n^^f'tLrliJ'^T^^^' "■ """'^ . i*, i/ataum case; q, questioned^ Vols. 13, 14 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Barbour d7L allegations 35 U 221 slander r 11 NY £15 e 36 3K 3Tr 17 288 347 S81 435 289 135 230 assignment 23 463 o 26 NY 407 49 NY 187 234 insurance rllNY 9 246 declarations HH 229 19 M 66 252 purchaser 23 H 121 heir's debts 60 H 79 H 105 NY 116 NY presumption 74 H 120 485 497 152 278 267 damages 40 NY 286 133 NY 347 297 parol ev. 7 L 373 e 81 NY 345 302 partnership 68 NY 279 76 NY 351 3 1 7 parol ev, 34 537 372 new trial h34S 17 bona bde elOH 4SH 380 traud siJN a9NY 13 NY 452 covenant 14aAU > r, r. fence ■' 183AD 171S 656 125 203 213 584 318 619 64 158 321 demurrer r9NY sSN 326 filing 18 65 H 71 H 12 M e 108 NY £ 217 NY rule public official 109 AD 721 f 169 AD 821 153 S 863 335 Bup.^pro 202 340 652 498 690 287 41 H 22 M 39 M 339 usury 30 33 NY 353 carrier 13 limiting risk 26 29 51 63 6L 4H 6TC 4K 2Ab 70 US 84 US 11 NY 20 NY 24 NY 46 NY 6Q9 648 660 362 645 136 78 353 327 390 damage 16 cattle guards 37 vested right 67 H 491 e 69 g 671 d 27 NY 272 d 86 NY 49 394 contract a 7 NY 210 400 orp. asylm. not a school 35 M 324 loan 6 42 NY 416 com Bcbl. fund 47 NY 616 do 154 NY 54 54 M 340 4 1 2 attachment 46 44 14 H . 382 jurisdictional 26 H vacation 38 H 6M 37 NY 75 NY d89NY 29 e76 AD 41 M 195 610 342 502 consideratn 20 154 11 M 370 49 M 370 legal obligation 128 181 53 £29 606 503 143 431ii SlOfraid 40 53 AD 77 AD new trial 3H 5TC undue influence 2K 243 3Ab 374 524 scrutiny »a M 170 147 S 88 526 damages 28 249 251 e 37 H 498 533 amendment 630 redemption TO .\I 470 14US ITS 632 damandf 4 AD ^38 d29 H 60 66 US 88 141 NY 218 137S 982 right action 77M 512 634 affidavit e 59 392 6 614 e 639 636 acceptance 31 e35 12 H el9NY agent liable a 9 NY 14 VOL 9 exemption 41 sheriff liable 3 TO e4TC 3M 1 5 sheriff lOH 418 212 623 231 686 27 diseretion 14 H 60 H aSAb surrogate 127 NY 406 133 NY 206 281 480 46 523 317 212 261 625 182 441 424 jurisdiction 31 H 168 128 NY 316 impeach consid. e 98 AD 431 incompetency 100 114 AD finding 51 M uonlempt 114 AD aceuunting 37 CP ulaim vs. lunatic 19A0 95n, 81 •83n 432 mandamus 641 464 273 26 34 45 49 rule 3L discretion 27 NY do 27 NY 250 72 458 261 265 402 407 382 385 17 536 infancy sl2 2L 8H 28 H 6Tr 37 NY 144 663 308 364 608 19 491 450 mandamus 67M 633 452 attachment 474 483 231 I 3d do 33 329lr3Ah 608 46 ( will I 9 NY 130 NY 111 198 112 491 176 212 289 36 1 carrier a 10 NY sSN 365 consideratn 67 AD 566 431 64 48 1 conversion 24 632 1 H 390 3 TC 603 493 contrib neg 22 686 44 166 trespassing ILKA 449n prescription 542 contract f 25 626 6 38 434 550 opinions 8 SN 176 r 9 NY 374 a 17 NY 340 56 I real piirty 26 640 567 parties 15 tax payer 16 393 400 injunction 17 446 24 192 230 authority 17 NY 467 c 18 NY 163 166 18 NY 166 regulation 183AD 170S 218 646 r r on street 16 222 18 247 28 661 d 68 H 521 rfl6NY 102 St. r, r. nuisance 5L11A 371n smoke damages ILRANS 5811 660 arbitration s 16 626 61 NY 323 155 244 577 illegal a 7 NY 228 594 cat. guards 32 672 676 e 13 NY 60 123 £4 «1. 603 distribution r 12 NY 326 pleading 89 M . 127 623 impeaohmt d 36 446 d 3 K 688 q 3 Tr 140 64 US 12 629 satisfaction 9 AD 396 eq defense 40 H 70 2 K 307 4Ab 314 582 641 contract 20 601 502 fraudulent 21 84 26 171 6H 679 49 H 66 implied promise 8M 648 31 128 32 177 182 36 282 e 21H 300 302 town party 22H conversion d33 H rescission 5SS 18 NY 83 NY 122 303 300 179 297 39 ev fraud 28 trustees 12 H assignment 47 H 4Ab acceptance 2K parol evidence 52 NY 134 52 mandamus 676 121 460 126 1 69 lunacy a 8 NY 381 50 640 666 contracts void 3 H 483 6TC 45 s SN 121 1 74 contract a 9 NY 93 36 604 39 H 304 s SN 161 1 82 allegations e 14 H 259 90 NY 630 1 93 inn keeper 12 261 a6L 116 33 NY 674 d 61 NY 39 1 96 mortgage m 9 NY 483 e 29 631 d 29 636 101 180 43 312 206 20 d33 36 1 H 3TC demurrer 32 62 expenses d66H 59 bond 89 AD 66 fraud conceal ment 20 662 binding 187NY value prop. 187NY 663 assault 39 counsel fees 82 AD 4L 24H 82U 20M 98US 82 135 4b 212 400 336 316 197 297 608 110 12 99 478 676 21 86 H 76 NY 88 NY ■ SN election 27 NY irregular 69 H 4 238 260 0< 61 86 600 328 intention 19 194 23 123 right alley 59 162 45 NY 560 dedication 69 AD 337 338 47 H 377 d 62 NY 65» 121 NY 428 acceptance 2Ab 2K 157 51 201 assume mtg 6LRA 276n 202 bond d 29 191 o 44 209 216 636 21 22 e23 25 2H 12 H 23 H 8M SONY 76 NY 4TC 76 guaranty d30 30 H 10 NY 261 654 626 144 322 206 notice 20 exceptions 29 waiver 43 366 hyp. question 36 H 665 assignment 22 NY 406 232 surety 39 613 614 364 fencing 18 585 21 498 22 685 e 13 NY 51 373 ministerial 242 bond 41 NY 13 108 NY 447 243 delivery 139 682 62 535 IS AC 85 sup. pro 39 M 272 267 188 330n 660 90 St. frauds s 23 131 r 12 NY 364 96 jurisdiction 62 442 37 AD 26 3L 48 s 40 H 283 101 resp. Rup'r a 7 NY 493 I 1 4 misjoinder r 11 NY 494 20 M 607 I I 8fact question 27 H 110 NY I 23 surety 63 H 66 NY 120 NY 131 fixtures 14 NY 380 642 427 332 40 93 25 28 f 177AD 7L 250 record 19 execution 21 47 leave 24 H jurisdiction 19 M waiver SUM 253 tenancy 48 notice 50 8 M 53 H 49 NY at will 60 NY 612 102 676 427 341 assent a 11 NY 20 66 NY 441 61 430 358 authority 24 25 64 67 H 62 US 77 US el4NY el5NY 34 NY 24 171 172 342 465 424 650 375 21 » 58 21 25 44 statutory 31 assessment 41 ultra vires 44 AD 376 appeal 17H 42 H jurisdiction 4K 3Ab 610 468 115 178 154 42 43 508 332 17 108 313 498 319 500 ! 268 661 246 351 263 32 104 259 directory a 8 NY 23 30 31 34 41 46 AD 2 L 20 H e42M de facto 38 39 67 318 699 613 399 627 99 147 358 234 572 69 381 jurisdiction e 2 TC 36» 28 M 53& 383 warranty 21 157 e 7 NY 37» misrepresentaioD 27 364 62 647 66 479- 17 NY 197 90 466 written clauses 38 NY 368 fact question 60 102 avoids policy 7'J M 269 140 S 210 396 quo warr'Dto- SN 230 405 property 20 H 393 4 1 8 fee simple 19 643 23 381 62 591 425 penalties 20 21Z^ d 31 283- ABBKEVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d. distinguished; f. folluwed; i c, criticised; 1. limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, , reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n. Bote; dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q, questioned. N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Barbour Vols. 14, 15 13 AD 203 e 23 M 403 injunction e 36 AD 660 98 AD 463 d 75 NY 369 unconstitutional e 45 H 213 153 NY 194 interdiction 68 M 52 invalid 123 S a67 434 monuments 48 228 10 H 489 18 H 288 441 adv. poss'n 33 281 17 AC 375n 456 exemptions 41 418 52 193 57 640 24 AD 607 4 L ,267 construe liberal 46 H 51 42 M 397 96 US 122 460 injunction rl2NY 381 471 partnership 27 NY 560 58 NY 279 d 76 NY 351 ultra viree 60 M 234 51 63 e 11 NY aONY 93 NY 6L 4K 2Ab /OUS 84 US 78 363 491 176 537 327 121 207 11.2 364 594 rescission VOL- 15 214 53 I dower rSl 36 37 H strict construct' n 52 129 62 532 7L 21 presumption 75 H equity 32 NY 25 241 , 27 654 9 mercer 32 182 74 NY 46 49 47 632 I 7 covenant ■i L 494 42 H ; e3t 199 21 H 130 20 prino. surety 33 H 182 21 H 348 92 H 392 5LKA 27Sn 374 ,3 M 679 23 assume mte *1^ 18 NY 312 6^^^^^. 276b 229 49 NY 171 626,.. d49NY lV2fO™ver do 49 NY 174l0»t 291 election remedy -i,wife purchase 151 NY 234d''20 6U 597 sale fraud, i^eisht of .v/*' 67 conclusive 31 637 43 310 436 425 533 27 33 70 merger rl2NY 39 M B19 180 74 land liab mtg. 5LRA ""'■ 2Slu 83 Indians . 52 taxation 33 NY aDsulute fee 127' AD do 127 AD 21, RA 155n answer 180 163 hypoth. defense 97 AD 3H denial 4H 5TC c6M 74 NY demurrer I6AU 6 1 I damages rl2NY 841 22 59 1 profits ,, 59 57S 5l3Ab ISO •'°° performance 64 NY 394 fact question 36 66 66 66 H 807 451 516 62 234n 27 AD 536 conversion 476 no part nership f 96 M 96 M t 161 lease 96 M e 161 f 161 S 195 19f 19 2U 199 ISl 22 481 subrogation 321 214 289n 534n 432 366 543 517n 468 825 042 483 107 467 784 7ftb 26 233 356 133 175 619 85 551 31 14 H 40 H 5LRA 68LRA e75NY 99 NY 100 NY payment 68LRA 488 lunacy 33 251 committee trust 56 201 63 465 e 2 H 4U1 10 H 486 36 H 360 4 TC 599 506 replevin d 20 359 e 9 H 689 30 M 91 34 NY 465 5 I I prescription 40 16M declarations 47 J urisdiction 53 16 AD title 89 AD 22 H r25NY strict construct u 2 TC 4^0 specif, agrmt 83 NY 491 general denial 101 NY 354 171 NY 181 548 limitation h2K 114 s3Ab 154 158 559 legislative power 606 829 title 31 NY e 104 NY : owner's rights 3LRA 833 638 Uen 26 M 644 demand 32 insolvency 2L 658 writings ■4NY 17 24 25 37 11 NY 2 K 80 US 82 US 18 35 NY 82 NY 97 NY use water 5LRA 286 460 268 490 39: 518 navigable 65 M 28C 524 carrier 29 136 137 negl. proof d61 11 4 K 120 2Ab 20R208ie2Ab limitation 60 NY 240 468 697 608 109 406 221 496 r r. companies 70 NY 350 administrator 94 WY . 548 564 contract d 69 NY 269 570 new prom. c34 14 H 23 H 72 H 579 laches 13 H 30 H 102 238 89 494 553 267 585 contrib neg. 22 586 d 46 270 46 271 66 61 e 1 K 573 382 333 32use oecupa n. 20 AD 22!> implication 1 H 166 3 TC 666 101 NY 681 37 title land . J K 199 .1 4 Ab 390 291 power court 146 S 299 • 47 jurisdiction 326 654 rents 19 AD 44V 86 AD 416 32 H 2S(] 52M 562 cl8 62 • 26 AD 91 AD 6L r6L 5 K ell M 20 M -1 M 23 M 28 DH , 21 61 391 621 184 449 662 extures 46 249 263 180 350 283 41 M e20NY 35 NY settlement 67 cond sale 2TC persoiial property 187 NY 82, 85 577 621 296 10 410 411 415 120 452 74 3aj 238 173 538 96 trespass 86 AD 4L 8H title 9 H 26 NY nuisance 28 H 35 H 5TC oLRA 25 NY do 115 NY 67 NY d 115 NY 171 NY 339 601 lateral support 68LRA 673ij objections 5LRA 462 I 68 limitation 19 488 r 18 NY 661 II NY 196 18 NY 559 1 93 r r in streets 15 246 14 NY. 618 legislative act 16 393 406 s 17 436 22 486 160 NY 389 injunction 24 d32 18 NY title in soil 34 37 16 NY franchise 13 AD streets in cities 38 160 161 publn will 17AC; 384n 3 1 license 27 AD 626 31 8 legis power 212 14 424 617 646 194 110 163 513 403 106 289 460 198 166n 456 338 245 272 227 2H 4 TO St. r. r. SLliA 148 438 nuisance 371n 1 05 malice 89 AD 35H 36H 21M 637 626 587 155 177 i 12 free schools 309 396 286 36 M remedy e24 NY return 102 NY error of iact 1U6AD 6L 410 411 appearance imy 32t. review 16AC 283, 2S3u 16 AC 28511 oecvice summons 184 N Y 100 5 I abandonment 74 NY 261 256 o5- presumption 14U AD 56 56 assignment 15 e 23 24 sSN 77 US unconstitutl. 191 N Y 122 50 201 60 432 29 122 legis power f 15 112n a 16 e 13 22 324 unconstitutl 191 N Y a 11 N^ 15 18 21 22 39 302 621 614 66 661 102 62 assignment insolvency 30 d67 eOAD e36 AD do 36 AD 37 AD 31 H 59 H 33 NY 646 266 302 26 28 206 336 338 478 96 122 50 359 468 432 1 32 tax'n costs 204 title public 62 U 92 244 injunction 16 393 24 195 d32 110 14 NY 618 18 NY 163 247 custody 37 539 44 249 lalse imprisnmt JUUNY ^ 284 249 subscription 20 lei 27 180 36 580 44 552 46 239 255 assessment 57 6 AD 39 H 24 H 1 165S benefits 99 NY 120 NY 178AD em.idomain 120 AD 46 8M retroaotivQ 14 M 49 NY 149 NY available 186NY 406 act pending ^ CP 289 M CP 388 390 323 assumpsit 23 178 15 H 343 35 H 112 e 42 H 181 73 H 464 2 TC 655 30 NY 86 fact question 56 H 492 liability 53 M 276 326 considerat'n 67 432 64 US 379 80 US 504 333 severance 445 477 681 1 707 dl4H 14 H costs 12!IS special 1 144 AD 1 39 relig Corp. 27 292 398 36 654 tfust 3L 364 e58 US devise void prefereneee 4 M 246 'such company" "1 AD 730 1+1 S 2LRA 2LRA bequests 3LRA I 53 arrest 3 60 AD jurisdiction 18 H powers 39 M 105 NY 144 NY information I13AD 388n 105n 380 275 337 204 rl9 20 4M 46 53 40 AD e2L 8H 15 H 24 H 35 H 46 H 21 M 88 NY partition d22 28 4M 306 313 657 856 264 assessment d 21 608 25 468 31 178 279 seduction s 18 212 219 44 588 50 212 282 presumption el4H 219 2. c. mortis 127 AD 76 286 incomp ev 137 59 668 448 351 187 401 40 213 325 43 450 80 678 602 124 638 670 292 361 337 presump ev. 84 H 61 NY 346 implied promise 40 IL 280 64 517 148 352 impeachmt 21 H 380 27 H 321 32 H 345 355 ejectment 20 365 title 20 evidence 46 32 e 45 K directory 62 NY 167 jurisdiction n«-lll3 AD 193 392 15 302 adm'r 26 133 43 419 28 guardians 32 458 56 634 43 218 1 H 410 304 declarations 5 H 22 671 34 H oil intention 139 H 26 77(4 TC attestation le 2 Ab. 11337 34041 NY 34 517 217 371 pleading 12 H 39 assignment 78 H 390 375 injunction 263 304 612 235 260 667 73 447 337 241 416 167 ABKREVIATIONS: a. afiirmed; d, distinguished; I, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed- n not, c. cnticiied; 1, limited; e, explained; 0, overruled: a, ■?a!ne case; do. dissenting opinion; p. parallel tis'.-; q. questioned Vols. 15, 16 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Barbour 101 misjoinder 65 H certiorari 14 NY joinder ir,.j AD 1.-,-, AD 140 S 299 236 539 352 253 399 ne exeat 4L 184 6 U 379 17H 695 21 H 24R 80 NY 35 406 dock sSN a 9 NY 266 676 4 1 3 insiirance a 17 NY 424 4 I 6 bequest r 13 NY 273 19 600 427 trustees rl6NY 160 60 384 5L 22 444 promise e43 I 48 : presumption 66 waees probf f 6H rule 36 H 55 H disallow 115AD 314, 609 658 318 449 admissions 26 H 113 47 1 construction c 27 99 trespassers o30 348 13 H 667 668 presumption 46 H 182 30 NY 473 o 36 NY 441 C 2 Tr 279 description 47 H 463 485 ejectment 11 H 617 87 H 58 privity 125 AD Sii 1 valid title 196NY I possession 198NY •>Kr f 161 AD 81!) deed void t 151 S 447 20 H 23 H 30 H 46 H 47 H 8M d33M el6NY 42 NY 506 fraud 13 NY 284 3.1' 173 656 250 149 62S 261 536 663 380 5 1 7 assessmen injunction 18 455 42 265 57 394 constitutional 1 H 269 3 TO 749 151 NY 84 520 notice 66 419 8U 932 presumption 51 NY 386 incompetency 224NY 858 524 award 16 46 36 NY r61 NY rule abrogated 3H 707 6 TC 199 23 M 628 28 NY. 172 e 175 42 385 290 32 possession ea AD assumption 46 H 50 318 trespaa* IM 239 fact question 31 NY 663 title alleEotions' 71 NY 38 122 NY 51 141 NY . 5 I iresumptlon n M 305 L31 S 21H 166S ■ 795 574 damages a 17 NY 163 578 slander r 12 NY 67 583 pririty 23 471 37 256 48 81 29 H 457 590 possession 46 265 266 49 176 50 34 37 H . 627 witness evidence 9H .196 genl exception lUAD ratification 6H joint action 19 H ' 61 H 76 NY 11 235 674 92 666 499 trespasser 20 279 license proof 260 55 247 30? 331 45 do 95 AD 110 AD enticement e67H justification 122 AD not enforced lOOM 420 165S 90/ 503 legacies charge realty 36 556 38 84 42 47 o 47 270 65 85 e 7 H 539 13H 610 525 practice 131AD 651 529 mandamus 20 297 23 348 49 607 72 NY 12 interest question 192 NY 387 county clerlt 173 AD 626 ISO S 59a 54 1 illegal 37 348 58 169 3L 111 17 H 479 481 .i relief lOlM 578 546 return 31 NY 605 550 expert ev. 65 467 2 TC 655 38 NY 177 555 sep. estate 21 292 S49 44 NY 616 560 i'd transfer 654 costs 29 AD 657 special act 74 533 478 43 J. 36 H assault 73 NY 75 NY IZO NY justify 1298 resistance 144 595 co-tenant 44 63 2L 34 H 4Ab. 1 M 39 NY 149AD 430 262 401 21b 90 375 242 13t! S3» conversion 66 56; 599 f'd intent 36 H 86 power sale 51 H 39(J 60 1 incomp 67 H- 502 couit powei 124 AD SB2 607 certiorari 23 24 32 36 43 3L 49 U 27 NY 43 46 91 AD 3L 49 H 27 NY 153 316 44 H construction do 60 NY award e 190 N Y 356 maps .evidence 124 S 593 fee vests 223NY 389 644 sp prfmnce al4NY; 32 650 certiorari 48 188 jurisdiction 60 11 M wait 1 hour 1 M 15M residence 34 H 46 NY 48 NY long summons e 20 M 308 367 464 497 174 60S 53 103 VOL. 16 9 foreclosure rUNY 29 notice 2L I 5 repeal 26 15 AD 3L 26 H 31 U 64 NY 81 NY 97 NY |1S3NY Impli cation 3L 169 301 424 114 AD 580 2 TC 72 bill lading 663 254 230 51 68 25 216 526 168 230 30 50 31 AD e 22 AD 43 NY modification 9H 39 312 64 306 18 309 permission 44 M 612 legis. discretion 27 NY • 448 unconstitutional 42 NY 418 '21 covenant 142 NY 89 princ. <& surety 5LHA 278n 22 assume mtg. 5LliA 276n discliarge mtg 5L11A 281 |26 declarations 25 AD 43 82 AD 525 j 33 partners 46 385 judgt. vs one 19 H 674 28 NY 172 e 175 61 H 92 76 NY 666 111 AD 11 declaration 23 M 627 Ijoint promise 47 M pleading 124 AD 174 AD 184AD 161 S 171S !3H 6TC 64 NY practice 13 IAD 707 199 657 46 posBession 39 608 43 611 40 NY 103 levy 1278 1018 54 ueg. pregnant 37 AD 662 e 74 AD 47 11 M 48 e 46 Id 446 448 142 NY 206 61 consideration 35 AD 23 lemurrer 40 H 258 348 167 477 112 643 544 440 431 386 644 261 547 440 431 386 62 action will lid I 36 or. promise SI) M 142 S a 21 NY 23 18 614 618 f'd intent declarations rl3NY 216 3H 322 22 661 tncompt. ev. tax rolls 27 H 428 50 M 6« 56 H 504 621 Vdsting 668 gen. denial 46 526 title 19 500 627 remedy 36 661 all NY 3US 46 H SO 18 H 469 65 H 412 boundaries 68 damages 16 275 measure dam 039 183 490 52 570 19e 20 a24NY 28 ■ 32 32 eSK 4 Ab. recovery f 3Tr agency 44 67 NY 82 agency a 18 NY 43 89 demurrer 23 213 US allegations 8 AD 96 AD proof perfmnce 471 85 602 24 610 732 370 191 20'i 892 96 jurisdiction 23 316 100 opinions 16 276 measure dam. 461 61 399 3 691 278 d56 o86 AD 5L 29 H 40 H discretion 11 NY appeal error 15 H I I 3 damages 16 356 e 19 465 32 659 a 12 NY 236 neg. presumptn. 18 NY 544 22 686 fact question e 114 NY 386 res ipsa loq. 92 AD. 104 I 1 9 insurance H 11 NY 664 13 I jud. notice 33 AD 81 46 AD 266 1 resptiPsei 20TNY 41 u.jU 373, a 16 NY 37 St. frauds 32 NY 171 NY 461 61 62 105 3 434 454 e56 o86 AD eOH 29 H 36 U e3XH 1 'IC 78 NY 129 NY 176 NY coiisequeu 53 [liscretioii ?33H liut.v award l.SOAD 362 compensation 92 M 422 155S 986 71 damages 505 49 636 401 1 40 post nuptial ILllA 519n I 4 1 declarations 37 340 12? 1 50 non-user 47 H 96 60 H 144 48 NY 462 1 60 deed map d 32 379 184 NY 205 mid highway 36 156 191 NY 367 263 delusions 136S 1100 1 7 1 ins. tic 19 177 surety 30 limitations 4SS 1 84 nn-user e47H .50 H 56 H e64NY 72 NY 134 NY 142 NY 62 M obstruction d48NY 137 NY abandonm't complaint 133AD intention 73 M 445 289 96 144 291 74 182 465 187 381 455 32C. 68 1 88 franchie 9H 309 waiver 44 M 610 constitutional 26 NY 1 93 crops. e23 H 180AD debts lien 32. H purchaser 122 NY 63 22 408 47; 480 I98exr. rl3NY 20 admr. 26 witness 93 246 witness 343 348 will proof 33 presumption 3H 141 2 I 2 diversion a 16 221 prescription 7!«M 69 r,-M 22 I f'd title 21 26 33 NY prescription 78 M 13 407 25 .-.20 551 433 272 304 dam 458 154 39 NY Hubscription 39 83 M 148 S witness 73 M attestation 132S I 46 findings 35 66 oral notice 77 AD 'demand 159 381 038 ]0.")(1 mark 105 48:i 468 542 82 237 corpoiation 23 335 majority 32 233 pew holders 18 NY 405 244 assesBorp 28 612 53 553 vol. payment 20 H 82 83 irregularity 34 M 353 249 fraud 1136AD 446 aHHUKVIATIONS: a, afHrmed : d. distinguished c. criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; ; f. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, now* s, same case; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q, questioneit N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Barbour Vols. 16, 17 251 dedicBtion 44 6UU 33 H eOa 121 NY r/J 254 parties plf. 43 AU 860 22 M 273 91 NY 199 259 test, oapcty 2£ 460 2b 46 54 5TC 25 NY ruiiDgfi 90 NY delusions f7 692 593 6 5 H 560 18 M 154 264 bona fides 46 214 presuxaption 109 NY 450 purch. money 132 NY 532 268 jurisdctioii 5 L 102 evidence d 30 H 258 27U possession a 60 NY lis e 2 H 484 e 5 TC 86 273 damaees 37 63 56 86 AD 9H 16 H 29 H 36 H e38H 26 NY 123 NY 129 NV 176 NY 51 M 1 96 M loB S 3 1 9 notice al2NY 4H 325 joinder d41 AD ^OAD 107 AD 18 H 63 NY 83 NY 418 458 460 U 106 68 3 434 463 63t 260 27 304 51 2^5 91. 280 Corp. assign 21 223 33 AD 233 4 M 246 plcadinc 26 466 gen. ussign't 5L11A 378II 289 insolvent e 2 L 64 29 I receiver rl4NY 567 16 302 3 03 niagistra e 1! AC 103ii u irrant 172 AD 73 159 s 6;c 309 conversjd 27 48 e9 H 88 H e 18 NY 23 NY pos.segsion 122 NY 363 54t. 237 20 313 269 466 576 641 199 519 137 599 306 30 439 parol ev 333 slander 17 NY 54 dpecial damage 0)7 NY 63 337 extinction 1 4 U 464 342 guaranty 27 86 bH 89 NY lo AC ilon, fraud 48 H 2K 3K 2Ab. 132 NY i-eJiancc K, J 2," AD 347 sale 29 notice 84 AD affidavits e7H 26 H 69 H publication 2 M 96 US construction 21 NY 89 NY nutitT r'ibln. 63M 195 82 236 430 309n, 326n 122 484 133 469 55 820 301 353 excess dam. 19 466 47 203 law question 43 H 30 31 a 13 NY 9 charge 19 NY 131 137 2u.; 3 I 5 nejrliRence 37 519 e 1 TC 246 18 >M II cattle guards e27NY 272 variance 66 NY jurisdiction 67 32f 102 care 29 32 prima f. ov. fi4M 580 360 marriage 38 121 367 affidavit 4 H 686 SS H 205 b70 quo wan mo 12.NY 433 27 NY 64 376 title I u 18 NY 39 mistake 63 evidence 6L 4 TC 448 226 95 26 72 146 226 26 47 48 60 3L severable 6 TO intention 47 461 bar 32 16 AD 83 AD e69 AD I 17 6AD 176AD 12 H 13 H 27 H 36 H 61 H <;86NY i: 163 S deieiiHte juM 163S jurisdictiPn' I3SS 08 168IS 38 469 party wall 4 Tr 149 37 NY IIU 589 488 374 375 268 801 803 208 38 581 569 464 273 38 329 3Su e23H 28 H e33H 2TC 32 NY 63 NY 124 NY 4 412 6U 628 S8 376 2S1 iraudlut convey 29 AD 96 24 H 468 548 usury 29 578 d 10 H 601 123 NY 198 2UJ ti 172 IN 1 25o2ou charge 30 title 34 Ignorance 3b 474 affidavit i3 171 486 ju hsdictiou lb AD 238 e82 1i 131 civil court o4 N y 563 waiver 38 H 322 4y I notes u ^9 41 7/NY a 495 indictment yj-i 94 uousp.racy 123 AD B.o inisdemeanor 1 96 M 630 162S 8a 315 150 264 443 invalid 62 63 bb AD 2D 7 11 e29 H /3 i± 35 NY 54JN Y delivery 8H e66NY 123 NY bona fide 172 NY loi value 135AD 558 Sep. estate 589 601 246 362 65 5/9 13b 592 69 297 611 528 2U3 267 d 28 31 election curtesy 26 24 AD 1 L jurisdiction h61 H 89 H 38 M 37 Jll distribution 37 M estoppel 37 M lit III tuccesn liiUrtD toil .tccuuntintf r2 i\i 031J ..2 S 4011 ITC 330 privity 2TC 433 598 accord 37 483 490 58 647 67 373 bar 21 H 162 performance 15M 220 76 NY 677 conslderattoi 186 NY 519 release 59 M 9:. uu accord 182AD 86u 1 5 party e38H 599 possession rl3NY 121 60 1 alienage a 12 NY 371 32 200 604 nee. parties, 13JAD 416 356 657 422: 44Bi 522; 6I2I 5ii 282| 596 608 invalid 33 »)12Bi'< ^•-vz.c.^a 38 332 ptnership credit 68 296 5 1 3 estoppe 18 44(1 s20 364 e57 289 4L 267 62 i lease p 89 11 6h 9M 4X9 27 M 726 :itle 40 233 variance 62 678 new matter i H 647 general denial VOL. 17 9 lunacv 37 H 309 [3 'lunatic' 1 LKA 270n lut 349 25 vesting 30 322 30 AD 261 66 H 78 58 H 494 70 H 277 BOH 426 26 NY 666 34 NY 113 146 NY 283 deliver deed 16AC 276n, 279n 590|b AD 69; 5U3 mandamus rl7Ni 584 36 660 661 3c 61 39 647 561 privity 6u 509 attachment e 14 M izis construction e 18 M 194 retrospection do 67 N y 438 pelidg. >j^ Cr 39i 321 515 628 371 346 392 taxpayer 24 195 o 18 NY 166 163 51 1 notice r 14 Ni 20^ assignment 23 20 AD e32NY waiver ti L 531 infants 47 N Y 536 cloud uo 90 AD 418 ,t)36 62 280 409 565 nuisance 29 393 63 262 78 AD 393 96 AD 132 569 revocation 143 S .^HII 29 M 449 H-2 M 22., 41 63 54 personall v I 19 AD 512 572 ademption ILKA 20 4i, levouatiun 6LKA 346 > 576 discontinue e30H 169n 646 dividends 482 580 vt-itness lo 633 21 282 412 legacy 54 I misjoinder al3NV 98=0 66, 1 creditor bill 7 585 proceeds 427 disseizin 2L 176 17 H 456 a 17 NY 16218 H 309 c 18 H 466 590 costs 7 H 4o4 22 H 551 13 H 140 171 NY 181 643 juris diction ^1 004 waiver 3 446 162 NY 2is3 ISM 204 82 deed avails f 170 AD 531 165 S 966 94 negligence 13 H 88 sSN 80 proof "^i.Ny :88 1 00 mtge, possn 26 406 eviction 41 75 redemptn remdy 35 H 619 law question 3 Tr. 156 service notice 38 M 80 intent 36 NY 695 1 02 notice forcls. 5L11A 284n ev. 488 65 I assessment 30 619 J23 NY 23 48 ISO ! H 374 33 H .283 284 pers property 33 120 626 d58 notice «) H 117 103 recital 19 trusts 27 277 398 damages ' 32 230 parol evidence 36 44 unity of person 62 532 7L . 21 25 NY 329 deed valid 26 NY purchaser 80 NY UBu/riict 3 L 484 1 04 indemnity 459 161 AD 209 ' 146 S 280 48 605 I I I expert ev 51 AD 151 67 NY 281 I t 6 pleading 26 466 remedy 42 AD 605 26 M 667 88 N Y 136 I 1 9 pleading 26 466 trustees 60 remedy 42 AD bar 19 H 26 M p 25 N Y 88 NY d 88 NY 132 agency 134 41 64 H 14 NY 17 NY 138 NY pub. policy 119 AD 357 486 02 404 449 177 137 sp prfrmnc 41 71 82 m 13 NY o41 lien limit 23 H filLS ISO 7 106 14 I pleading 12 H 39 I 45 protection 20 166 167 e 41 H 593 trespasser 17 H 354 renewal 170S 738 1 49 tenancy 3 AD 600 1 H 164 20 H 318 3TC 665 118 NY 31 R authority 86 M l:)l> 140 S 215 1 57 strictly fol- lowed 39 AD 607 e 1 L 522 38 M 6,57 substituted lienor 86 M 66.J 286 606 689 667 221 135 140 286 1 62 personal representative 34 180 40 432 I 7 I agency s 24 375 r 26 NY 505 509 e6] H 66 3 TC 526 inference M 467 I 79 jurisdictn 38 347 5L 260 18 H 133 74 H 341 1 84 demurrage 66 384 4 TC 265 2K 18 3 Ab. 324 I 93 maintain bridge r 12 NY 268 203 fraud 60 33 NY 224 affidavit 5H 7 M 236 probate 33 presumption 3 H 19 H 26 H d60H 5TC scrutiny 39 M 47 M 26 NY capacity 145 S 90 116 126 69 141 633 191 301 430ii 68 326 28 ABBREVIATIONS: a e, criticised ; 1, limited ; afiBrmed; d, diBtingniished e, explained ; o, overruled ; f, followed; r, 8, tame case ; do. 371 256 test, caiicty revorsed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel cue; q, qucationed Vols, 17, 18 N. T. Supreme Couit Reports— Barbour 136S 1097 SS2 248 52 276 550 173 260 demurrer 23 28 36 24 AD objections 71 AD 74 AD competent ev. 87 AD 127 burden proof 92 AD 343 d 16 H 629 33 H 301 covenants 211 NY 197 43 M 433 e44 615 mea^ damages 60 NY 412 123 NY 468 intent 69 NY performance 171 NY . c jastruction 191NY recovery 129S 72 M "agreement' 211 NY 197 168 AD 343 58 38-1 64 205 665 2(1 299 1024 546 20 AD 3H i23AD 1: 168 AD (■ 153 S 168S enforcement 65 AD 590 3H 6Bt 12 H 45 25 U 94 e 55 H 535 24 M 393 vU. GontractH 124 AD 60 curp* power b3M 205-6 ao recovery lUlM 582 unenforceable ISOAD 534 168S 3a e82H 4LHA 16 AC 60 NY 190 5668 45n 111 458 possession 42 34 471 recovery 271 parol, ev a 16 NY 336 can recover f 178AD 927 163S 109 276 considerat n e 35 NY 60 308 insurance a 19 NY 272 308 certificate ml5NY 9 16 H 564 s 17 NY 521 309 corporation 67 H 467 3 I 7 concurrent 177AD 240 410 support 23 25b 36 627 299 38 H 254 e 1 TC 8u 70 disqualified 41 4 AD e4L i>bjyi 123 a 1 aio NT wajver i27NY or er void 16 AC 378 estoppel 24 29 37 66 6H 14 H 73 H 3TC 86 US 22 NY 26 NY 34 NY e63NY ultra vires 17H 18 H 67 H pe nalty ILUANS 1045 384 limitation I TC 427 388 decision 20 discretion 21 construction 39 394 inheritance 379 311 607 113 72 471 454 308 679 278 209 216 71 335 295 467 205 403 211 85 381 311 385n ,14 disqualiiicn 50 AD 100 4L 211 e 65 H 398 16 AC 382n, 3ooii d77NY 111 .27 NY 311 uuruen proof iM AD 17b 424 amendment 48 833 20AC 21n confession judgt 14 H ■ ■ 329 exceptions 76 NY 283 428 infants 25 AD 390 394 497 238 386 169 650 527 237 82 61 H 5L 17 M 19 M 29 M :;04NY 154 AD Stat, frauds 23AD 1,3SS sp. performance ~n M fill repudiation 130 S P(i ■JOJ NY 237 489 impeachm t 29 621 13 H 448 40 H «26 corroboratfon 58 1 admissions 18 264 22 AD 646 subscriber 21 546 assessment 25 468 37 597 608 consent 47 proofs 75AD e 19 M strike ou 42 NY 347 125 AD privity 125 AD presumption 128 AD 362 3S1 114 353 4 ■.>on NY 492 title 41 satisfaction 57 discliarge 6H assignment 21 H pledgee e 136 NY trustee 160 NY luce value 123 S 'i7M no merger 74M 1.S.'?S 34.! 241 608 trademaik 47 463 482 49 591 67 534 562 3 K 696 f 59 NY 336 66 NY 76 infringement 6L 160 3Tr 169 1 Ab 270 6 I 3 contract 47 175 assent 53 67 6 1 7 compensatn "~ ■ ~ 64 336 286 288 583 416 233 37 AD e29H 348 63 H ;e63H 43 136 NY appeal 16o'e36NY [confirmation 560 4 H 313 5H 175 d 1 Tr 293 lutjQsure damage 6SM 255 644 embezzlm't 187 109 439 (>4li 7H 2M estoppel 13 M dismissal r!t M 579 fill 60 130 30 usurious 53 property 147 NY 397 illegal 20 37 53 337 356 602 43 I demurrer 23 582 allegations 15 AD 384 70 AD 5o averment 63 M 68 435 injunction s 28 228 32 104 ultra vires 34 53 607 38 parties el3 AD authority 14 NY 288 289 ,518 163 taxpayer 18 NY 448 bona fide 41 10 H 28 M practice 25 NY 647 556 125 364 d2S 506 constitui "'•ffet r 12 NY 593J1 « „„ jurisdiction |e 85 NY 50M 512'eonstruction ,-.^ i'22H 5 I3bail e |4 TU 3f M 384 'merger e 135 NY 578 62 NY ,,„ 108 NY 5 I o damages hduciary 42 39|l32NY deceit 210 641 503 566 194 506 73 AD 333 14 H 46 proximate cause s 161 S 501 174 AD 755 523 chat, m'ge 86 AD 169 canal boat e34H 188 Jen mortgage 105M 213 649 defenses 27 AD 519 79 H 571 654 diversion 530 demurrer r 13NY 23 63 allegations 2H 13 H 4TC rl3NY presumption 14B 542 582 616 34 670 276 542 118 538 fact quest' n 344 22 request 39 nuisance 22 41 e 73 L 3H nom. damages 96 Sis 332 282 183 4M 133 S76 47 71 d30 63 NY 79 NY 660 repeal 28 26 NY 63 form sufficient 40 AD 91 26 M 466 all, 622 modification 360 116 61 H intent 62 454 interest 437 10 H 526e52n J48 19H 597 35L,e 46 H 268 58 I incomnt ev e 52 24 18 H 274 567 subscription r 15 NY 583 17 600 91 US 379 242 683 adv poBsessn 37 250 SL 212 8S H 570 87 H S3 title entire 31 M 622 ABBEEVIA'TIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished e. criticised; 1, limited; «. explained ; oroverfXd? 68idet'ense nbj n . VOL. 18 9 surety r IS NY 41141 35 AD 64 I 4r ecitals 19 48!- 34 63? 36 391 center street 34 501 520 conclusive 96 AD 609 17 M 326 2U estoppel Sl^HA ! 24 cond precea e4U 1: 29 title 40 46 distinction 6H new matter 7H official act 62 M 630 526 ,51 f547 r 00 boarding e 52 111 Bupt. poor e 56 230 e 25 H 623 104 taxation e 22 H 233 e 88 NY 583 107 reimbtirsmt 124 NY 44 I 1 2 contract 40 M 100 1 23 pidg. facts 1 H 539 4TC 116 1 39 damages 484 32 construction 28 32li admissions ill 649 35 seal 42 H director 54NY 50 penal ty 161 NY 84 M 56 levy 27 damages 53 H 60 authority 53 28 NY C40NY prnol 141 NY 234 52 140 473 21 269 3b!- 69 power atty e 4 AD 622 presumption 79 US 303 80 waste 2'J 17 personal estate 41 66 heirs 34 174 42 400 34 NY 103 sparks damage I 52 answer II H d29H stockholder dSM e90N\ 31 144 545 552 358 I 59 voices legis- I ative power d 24 581 28 346 353 365 separate estate 28 366 28 44 curtesy 1 L 61 H 356 378 514 378 614 I 68 surety 39 consideration 46 197 179 rl9NY contract 262 567 193 392 231 612 114 441 f. followed; r, . same rase ; do. 66 57 AD d6L 6 H 6U 8H el6H 17 H e22 NY eposs sssion 77 H legal title 5 TO 2H £ 167 S vesting 29 NY presumption 52 NY eq. owner 127 AD can recover 175 AD f 161 S 89 sureties 50 AD I43 NY 464 193 132 50b 326 601 68 360 212 495 121 541 922 32 360 39 481 134 I 87 security 24 31 43 63 restriction 8H bona fides 31 NY 37 NY value consider n. 33 217 equities 37 464 465 I 93 objections 41 81 parol evidence 23 H 497 28 H 26 125 NY 673 filing delivery 65 340 109AD 721 71 H 552 2iM 497 e 108 NY 590 153 S 863 recorded f 217 NY 287 203 inference 30 78 concession 94 NY 312 2 1 2 seduction o 31 281 e 44 592 50 214 e 54 H 588 222 coutrib. neg r 16 NY 97 d62 310 compensation 51614 NY 618 reversed, m. modified; •, dismissed; n. notcj dissenting onininn ; p. parallel ca..; o, nuri.ti,,nr.i N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Barbour Vols. 18, 19 use Htreeta do29H 247 250 admiaaioiid rl6NY ■■iX\ 6M 6BS 24 M SO do 44 NY HflH scrutiny 68 M 18 declarations 124 S 859 260 demurrer 5fl M i pleading 152 S 127 884 265 co-tenant 40 S3H fi 332 complaint 38 94 amendment 9L claims 41 NY relief 48 NY 366 428 54 33 8 liq. damage 35 34 21 NY ■ 258 rule damace 09 M 551 344 e^. title 14H 303 'evidence 453!*^ H agreement 118 NY Si 347 weight of ev 22 149 61)7 42 title crop 49 NY liability 2U1NY 350 weight ev 44 48 330 60 170 5H 302 18 H 154 42 H 449 46 H 599 e 60 H 201 e 109 NY 57 122 NY 157 evidence value 9H 392 272 assignment [22 24 120 123 damages 27 345' 39 AD 46 1571*5 H 49 H 372 51 NY, I discretion 277 floating logs 120 NY r35N Y -I-""-" s30 72 NY 290 waiver 48 25 H 36 H 100 as void custom 63' 118 39i 29 315 1.16 484 600 616617 481 16 533 679 55 NY 425 libel 33 Hi AD 39 H 2TC 63M slander 1 18 NY S38 not actionable 183AD 770 171S 828 429 discharge r 13 NY 194 434 presumption ■■■■ 345 452 261 50 300 a 15 NY 46 51 47 AD el3M handwriting 13 M 469 444 civil action 135AD 825 451 construction 33 42 37 AD I H 3: 590 48ll65NY , Q4 breach injunction ,.., i?fi 36CP 165 '"' I 21 TC waiver 57 jury 2 covenant 166 87 NY 317 42 spec, prfmce. 64 '50 M 135 716[ 357 incomp ev. 298 604 22 H 2TC 297 subscription inference 638 265 274 269 770 451 749 281 394 33 532 admissions 21 281 54 1 forfeiture 26 661 waiver d 3 H 690 il 6 TC 334 549 presumption 22 661 554 partnership 19 625 ill J fi6a 62 e55H 169 N y pel's, liable lau iN Y liability 67 presumption 122 NY. possession 148AD 133S 256 686 16U 196 456 m 14 NY 18 H e 82 NY 467 trust 4 1. b'k powers 162 41 302 *««%»! H 18 20 21 d32 64 d22H 60 H h39M e24NY 58 NY e93NY cumul remedy 41 IBS conditional 67 661 662 3 1 subscription 64 640 assent 24 NY 166 58 NY 401 87 NY 301 311 e32H 161 162 467 543 .387 merits 617 621 25 AD 640 3 M 362 relief h24M 83 M 349 299 123 84 166 400 414 92 H eaONY e 116 NY e 136 NY sale power 132AD 251 35 661 8 15 128 331 755 58 1 dower 23 4L 11 H 4K do4K 3Ab do3 Ah 90 U8 49 NY 63 NY 138 NY 173 NY surety 66 64 AD 25 H 3oH IPC! 9M 141 US SONY 567 statute 17AD claim audit BOH 60 H 105 NY 574 j uritidictiou appearance f 145S 1098 393 pers bervice 25 62 AD 13 H e61 H 20 M obM 166 NY 197 801 1*73 sp. prfmce a 14 NY 289 646 330 211 :i6 597 334 177 397 divisn fence i*' H 162 3 1 2 subscribers 40 I sp. prf mance 23 22 r 14 NY 302 d22H 366t „, 407 oath 3 I 7 subscribers 'HI 473 14 H 395 atiidavit 116 NY 2801 UH 379 no contract |24M 625 163S 726 ackuowledgemt 1164 NY 530 320 new promise equity suit c22 — " '"" ' voidable 33 NY _..,., 96 NY 211 [1 45 591 infant note 6LKA 178n misei.'M"..'j' «".. 152I123 AD 684 543 409 objections > 412 Indian Kes- ervatiuu 327 warrant a 16 NY 206 66 AD 99,a64 0S i e 174 NY 293! trustee 420 opinions 484 ejectmt 79 H r2K s4 Ah 63M 19AC 138 AD part'I poss'n 186 NY 494 joinder 36 38 do 25 NY description 1 L jurisdiction 27 H disseizin 1 TC 500 tort o22 215 695 126 210 318 717 490 136 39» 4GS 536 64U 221 226 148 116 3U4 300 488 IS 624 36 129 296 640 634 697 2S0 6 422 5U 219 838 681 663 6 1 5 award a 13 NY d37 usurpation d42 compennati on 2K 402 delegation 95 US 664 646 dividend 30 e4i 22 AD 433 f66AD 415 do 178AD 125 25 H 136 US 164 NY 172 NY 209 NY ■jon NY e47M intention 146NY do 28 49 50 H 20 M q 23 M t 93 M f 158 S damages 62 appeal 8 H ubjections 127a availability 71M 583 waiver 16 M 92 US 18 NY 613 11 636 38 139 113 586 consignee 67 NY 86 592 releaae 39 H a 17 NY 522 fact question 57 d 1 L 46 H 530 waiver d 16 M 66 NY jurisdiction 28 M 351 35 167 143 463 63f 612 164 649 74 287 475 443 621 52: 132 136 110 364 595 discontinue 66 246 e 45 AD 33 jurisdiction 24 N Y 636 599 transfer r INY l!fl 28 183 608 assigi 30 d 23 H estoppel e86 AD JioNY surrender 5M 189 221 13 193 266 VOL. 19 1 8 redemption e40H 22 judicial 24 43 48 _4L e6L 80 H 3Tr 2Ab 22 M e36NY f36NY 476 422 497 62 162 291 fact question 24 M 69 M 125 S drainage 72 NY e 163 NY 163 38 742 214 176 construction 17 392 1 125 39 102 199 ell NY 307 172 2] 343 266 assignee 2] 204 666 192 141 46:! 4r>4 564 13P 246 30 jurisdiction e 32 H 227 36 M 743 36 damages al2NY 22 d29 i50H o47NY 47 NY carrier 102 NY 130 1 79 description 40 377 60 346 66 298 6L 171 6 H' 344 reservation right 9H 534 286 21 M 222 635 commissioners 5 I amendment lofficial capacity e lUM 53 partners 64 NY 68 transfer a 26 NY 43 80 29 33 670 506 247 19H 132 NY proof 24 H presumption 33 H 608 43 435 317 72 37H 48 H 'e 1 TC lljpractice 6 Tr 76e79 J37 NY 641 646 405icominissionrt 342 20 NY 255 28 NY 305 74 principal 1 1. 387 26 NY 123 129 incomp. evidence'costs 26 NY ■ 129 2 H pers. liable |4 It- 116AD 749 o 61 NY ■set off - 8 [ constitutional , 25 N Y I 96 res jrdicata e3L 187 !3 65 33 H 1 TC 19 NY 20 NY !d 42 NY 43 NY 409 415J' S3 266 332 498 628 |«L204 penalty ,44 ^ > i.l. extension st 64 62 46 i 418 is-rai 17 NY nee. party d29 600 19GNY 222 damages 106 contract 41 651 instructions rescission 102 US 571 145 damages 126 NY 236 III judicial jhO H 241 118 pleading 34 NY 46; repairs 6H q28NY carrier dam. 17 AC 145 compensation e 54 NY I 22 wager 1 Ab 447 128 surety m 24 40 1 TC 296 297 32 306 501 600 224 458n d74NY ilamages 66 .\Y recovery lOlM 168S I 57 fraud r 15 NY 243 delivery el2AD 196 16AC 278n deed delivery "" M 388 248 alteration le 46 386 27 H 349 546 joint promise 466 96 AD c 29 NY 171 AD 51 675 605 723 489 I 66 unconstitut 36 AD 602 47 AD 355 injunction 46 H 85 f 249 fraud 10 H 11 H 252 libel rl6NY 448 409 419 197 267 369 258 frd. relief 5LliA 189n 263 vested 46 H 15 283 trespasser AhiiLI.Y UUAD 409 413 55^ 419 131 609 277 105 7i>w 388 liquid dam 39 I commissi jns damages 3H 494 6 XC 3b administration 3U H 274 6 TC 3i, answer title ?1 NY 245 .290 195 4 1 6 valid sale 44 532 533 uovenauts 2H 596 vesting » H 263 1 TC 57a 1 NY -^VO assumpsit 4M' performance 4 Ir 37 NY entoreement 5 IV Ti 20. ^33 140 331 amendmenl 40 ■M2 43 33 covenants e64 433 acguiescenci d60H 53'1 341 excuse 24 177 BB- SS H 4f ratably e32 6Hh 44 5* 52 43 35 H 4f- d26N 283 death termn 119 NY 114 343 indorseraeni 61 617 P7 . 38 reference title e24H 346 carriers r 16NY 28 51 23 NY 356 receiver BiaNY 58 5L 556 515 411 77 337 643 634 186 364 nee. al9 c 119 NY lam. 370 474 371 canal 24 67 amendment 36 ; injunction 4TC 8 M 383 479 damages 29 NY 641 29 176 435 euutract 34 53 544 440 estoppel 6i 407 6 6J. H 351 e 1 Ab 3 105 Uti 30U 442 admjKsiou 49 -Oi 450 transfer e 58 H 320 trust deed 97 NY 24 455 cuntrt labiii d26 33 OU 3L 5L 1 H 3'IU 48 NY 05 NY 140 2U-, 146 522 :i45 402 58- /4 362 bale of gooUs 1,".4AU 99M 131' S 459 tender 67 4H oet-oli 142 11 4Tr 37 NY payment do 215 NY 460 payment 122AD 1 38 484 tenants 28 251 center stream j40S "37 boundaries 30 21 AD 15 H 18 H 49H 57 H 54 NV 134 NY 62 M 79 M bond 15 H merger 18H recitals ev. 101 UH 41 NY ejectment 81 NY 123 S 138 AD iiun-tidal 488 estoppel 5L11A 278n ■492 low wa mark 78M jurisdiction 13SS 16 15 89 460 38 480 385 360 196 285 460 247 438 389 694 718 58 1 contract pro- hibited s2S 33 44 'lab'tring" -i8M 595 agency al7 NY 69 NY 341 564 629 339 421 392 494 will rlSNY 505 legacy 15 M 412 178 517 PTs, liability iauN"i lye 537 written no- tice 53 411 67 391 540 margin 30 AD 47 lirectory 39 AD 116 120 IH e49H d3TC 17M 34 NY 144 NY' 602 captn. ord. 35 H 66 AD 95 AD 18 H 19H 92 H ';ontPmpt IR M" 1(!0 S 447 S 2fi 128 118 241 563 878 604 assignee 32 merger 11 H 1 Ah 74 NY necessy. 1S5AD consent 105M 173S 287 478 299 214 parties 416 484 529 808 trustees d 60 H 37 1 81 H 569 q 20 M 270 29 M 189 63 1 parol ev. 25 48 512 \ eating VOL. 20 9 advancement 61 299 6L 491 19 H 122 79 H 82 1 1 fact question 35 H 213 14 M 329 116 NY 220 law question 8 1 taxation 24 188 169 al6NY 421 9 1 commissni) r4Ab 5,8 5LB,A 1 8 no tic* 2L 32 H q32H 51 H 65 H 84 H 38M- 2 I contract 3TC a 14 NY 556 424 518 520 SIO 139 493 86 lOOintelDion 30 M 251 pier 59 NY end lieense 139 A.D 253 fraud 21. e 21 H fioiiS NY 67 NY 1 1 9 legia. power 30 39 48 612 2/ NY 448 curpuratiou ■ft J,L «12 25 party debt 19AC 185n 19AC 186n 26 chat. mtge. 101 402 169 ns.s 28 98 AD IL 133S delivery 7L 39 H 172 AD lOM 18 M 49 NY 158 S trust 113 NY valid trmis-fer el4H 480 recovery 37 H 311 KJft 3d person 1 LKA 536n r.plied 3M fit)! 108 3S0 53 452 625 22 11 , 59 32!, 63 a 9/ 4t.b 398 land' under water 37 56 3661 „„ 137|639 covenant 366lB2 691 410 644 adv. persn; 40 H bona 6de d8 AD 32 trespass 36 easement 65 NY 138AD ejectment 101 NY 1J3 S 138AD 330 381 158 161 524 123 ■m, 524 461 22 47 6Tr 22 M 38 NY do 69 NY demand 59 473 vesting 51 AD excess, dam 9U 202 2U1 671 lt-0 470 SO '■H M lie NY LUjacent 1 HAD ! 2!) S in town 323NY 350 2SA 388 70 NY 119NY T76 727 548 de egation 62 M 343 560 possession 36 50 75 H 1 TC 613 643 615 237 139 250 552 312 647 35 limitation 32 143 41 614 37 contract 34 e41 uncertainty 41 612 chat mortgage 62 323 27 H 92 legal title d82H e3 K 13Tr e4 Ab nee. parties 2 Ab future crops. 17 H 122 d65NY 467 executory 82 NY 376 lien enforcement 118 NY 136 15 407 392 62;i 293 313 430 653 exrs neg. 84 NY 319 657 canals r 13 NY 238 664 damages 65 234 defect plffs 43 AD e 16H do 15 H I4 Ab 568 injuii'aion 86 US 676 98 US 628 ;574 usury Id H estoppel 349 , „ ii 48 647 603 40 43 164 n do 177 NY 179 42 amendment 36 29 43 448 do 88 AD 417 waiver 42 16 43 448 30 AD 357 173 NY 495 parol extension 1 H 553 238 devise 56 H 483 67 4 TC 111 attestation acceptance !e 6 AD 48 631 jcompt. witness •It u / 01 1 23 itarol j*etitn i-t 549 oi 2 Xr 3BXN Y 118 NY 87 446 299 4 262 revocable e50N V 265 269 covenant 262 504 24» 1'4 1 trustee 26 ti. 2if M 598 21 30 NY 57 NY 147 NY privity 57 NY 275 venire 41 waiver 88 H 278 jurisd'n 35 AD pleading 41 H waiver 149 H 7M f 91 M- 649 460 11 167 11 101 563 16 1 48 strict com~ pliance 3 1 L 412 e4XC 622 2 M 2Dc> r21NY 160 e »a JN Y aaa cond precedent /,oi u n 17 NY ;;j^i;^8 1 challenges ■(1 M 577 47 580 394 184 509 1 O I consideratn 34 625 26 NY Bll 76 AD i»2 3 L 120 request 3XU 797 voluntary paymt. Iu3 Ai' 163 I 55 subscriber 32 621 623 a 14 NY 546 165 warrant di- rectory 20 30 55 33 AD IH 9H e41 H elTC 3TC 24 M 24 NY .enewal 170S 168 613 397 266 64 415 693 376 136 619 587 282 damages a 118 NY 534 18 M 36 15 NY 420 294 8 upervision 33 ood mandamus 33 608 298 promise 32 143 302 mandamus r 26 do 26 le 16 H 27 NY pleading d25 1 68 unconstitu- tional limitation 13 NY 378 20 224 605 64 AD 286 20 H 13 NY 216 235 222 3 1 1 damages a 21 NY 39 costs 35 H denial title 50 H 1 Ab 24 M riparian f 91 M f 154 S 466 92 185 541 181 207 righls 76 1048 32 I executor 101!dl6NY 95 479 224 jurisdiction 605 626 36 479 61 a45H do 13 NY 178 339 di .emurrer 248 66 new cunsid'n ]21 H ol AD 330i4i H 28 50 21 AD 31 M e 26 NY 28 NY transfer 93 NY asMignmant d45 212 amendment 35 73 75 incompt. ev. d 77 H 475 609 424 247 505 387 384 205 503 392 376 93 M 556 7T H 157 S 219 70 NY extended 'e 103 NY 93 M. 557 „._ CO . |246 prohibition ig^oeption 68 assent e2lNY 17,-i4 n Y 91 H 162 " 343 neg pregiil 79 AD 323 6H 440 248 ABBBEyiATIONS : a, affirmed; d, distinguished; £, followed; r, reversed; m, modMed; *, dismissed; n, note e, criticised; 1, limited: e. explained: o, overruled; s, same case; du, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; ti, quesiiunud N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Barbour Vols. 20, 21 SSOsheriff execu- construction e7M 608 VOL.21 e3L 269l31 264 reversal tion protection 38 407 92 NY 105 40 H 128 23 NY 476 27 M ' S07 9H 689 41 367 good title 9 laches 3 SA 469 misjoinder 32 NY 363 29 H 533 transfer 16A 136n SM 48S 127 NY 634 16 M 109 evidence 31 H 406 57 147 proceed'g in rem d 168 NY 247 do 187NY 443 50 H 663 refundins 547 transfer 97 AD 172 1 77 mistake statutory p 34 NY 466 13 H 600 57 147 1 140 US 269 48 NY 198 42 M 615 335 confession 1 50 NY 356 oompet evidence services 39 CP 238 1 73 NY 61 e 40 H 105 548 sale fraud 1 7 incompetent 181 usury 2 Ab 285 iinprobahle practice 2LRA 155n evidence a 21 NY 219 39CP 238 378 pleadine 38 416 40 136 tact question 247 surety 28 248 ] rC 219 559 tran.Tfer 51 473 32 M 391 4L 197 339 cross, exam. creditors suit 1 K 692 27 605 IL .. 286 Objeetione 27 228 68 635 notice affidavits securities 1 90 controversn 81 NY 169 e 67 H 188 26 AD 579 78 US 368 29 302 81 H 351 44 179 1 TC 56H 62 AD 93 67 NY 277 e7H 384 151 NY 609 11 AD 398 249 discharge contrib neg e 5 L 186 160 NY 601 legal title ISl AD ^36 surety 7Tr 29 I H 667 authority 31 NY 160 26 recovery 3H 286 35 492 18 NY 268 33 H 290 2.T NY 207 e 26 427 22 M 100 38 109 e 34 NY 629 4 TC 241 concliisive 567 oonstitut'l 42 162 38 M 170 296 e 39 NY 364 4 Ab 31 e 26 NY 462 rl3NY 378 consideration 66 NY 216 262presumption liability 9 M 651 pleadini indictment 56 424 162 NY 428 25 129 [ 27 528 541 parties 46 656 105M 402 dilii^ence 170 NY 167 intention d 36 AD 36 e 28 NY 224 8 93 US 386 348 jurisdiction 50 AD 94 477 off set 6 1 6 f oreelosure excuse 1 98 lex loei d 99 NY 316 73 AD 77 88 H 416 22 651 BL 280 29 497 34 476 277 19AC 189n -19AC 190n 34 450 11L 281 35 665 265 damages 35 1 new promise e 124 NY 112 conversion 34 abrogation 40 486 r 19 488 32 143 privity 186 NY 365 o25NY 277 20 H »67 8H 264 86NY 330 67 454 171S 791 comnt. evidence 43NY 324 delivery 3Tr 64 acknowlgmt. 387 objections d 22 139 2L 163 compt. evidence 65 468 mv/xm j aa e 1 L 492 56 subscription 41 H 589 36 NY 466 19 AC 42 4n joint judgment 620 conelusive 95 US 668 vesting new trial 53 NY 242 7H 366 26 NY 80 3 Tr 823 23 NY S49 361 illegal 107 AD 142 635 constructn. 65 fM assignrnt. 2Ab 439 e 2 Ab 440 275 discretion 32 520 37 348 479 damages a 22NY 40^ a 17 NY 22 e 3 K 600 3H 701 46 618 Liromiac 39 H 74 acceptance IBM 78 59 425 e 18H ■523 71 NY 297 surety 53 356 9 H' 520 71 H 236 insurance a 108AD 107 68 neg, damage dl3H 87 transfer notice 64M 166 18 NY 56 66 543 2H 694 64 NY 147 TTiortffagee 16 M 610 276 judgment 28 H 319 392 presumption a20Nv IS 1 L 197 187NY 36 f Sfi M 507 55NY 353 82 reseission 207 judicial 6 L 292 6SM 582 t 2 Tr 274 88 US 460 149 S 313 639 construction 46 470 35 NY 263 Z86 sep. eatacB 36 NY 534 lien 99 NY 279 estrays 4M 48 2L 496 9 31 631 quantum meruit I,9AC 870, 376 54 NY 21 18 NY 312 2 1 2 eonstruction r 18 NY 265 34 358 linbilitv 4L 23 severance 5LRA 286n 137 AD 513 644dam appraisl 86 lien 294 powers 4LRA 157n 26 H 586 7H 416 214 authority a 14 NY 366 mvalid 407 fixtures 481 estoppel 8 AD 225 28 70 8M 63 r 18 NY 28 r 28 NY 147 652 bail 92 damages 3T 436 e 39 . 545 legality 26 252 do 13 NY 484 65 234 authority 146 S 230 409 objections R4 548 jury trial 71 H 876 2 1 B parol ovid 1,33S 663 entire contract 42 39 construction ILRA 633n bailment 34 537 construction i 152 S 130 44 74 14 H 142 26 NY 350 surety 75M 498 f 89 M 444 conclusive r 2 Ab 209 e 160 NY 298 35 AD 64 30 H 13 do 67 M 145 311 retainer 38 1 interest parol evidence 48B submission 107 ment. capac intent 4L 69 26 538 114 NY 263 2LRA 181n 64 287 102 US 689 sp. perfmance 429 partnership 493 title 5M 204 25 NY 28 221 Corp. rights 41 168 24 H, 319 57 565 667 a 20 NY 184 15 AD 567 26 170 probate 4M 245 JO H 274 enforcement 32 179 323 69 M 127 geil. assient. executor 398 parol evi- 2 H 694 52 120 delusions 6LRA S78n 88 H 225 right action 183AD 480 dence f26 H 604 66 283 l.SeS 1100 prohibition e 89 AD 480 waiver 5 TC 146 4K 216 corpn. liable ^ 6LRA S78n description 58 AD 303 pleading 1 30 recognizee 69 NY 90 225 fractions 171S 65 9H 5 3 Ab 294 S6 H 307 150 NY . 229 409 easement deed construction 1 45 revers. error construotion 3 1 7 demurrer 23 462 87 H S3 2 TC 118 43 £29 196 NY 310 d 19 H 111 .ateral support 44 1 aver, prove 501 sale fraud agency 63 21 estoppel 161 AD 819 option 83 NY 78 34 658 61 107 48 37 2LRA 165n commissions 147 S 1066 319 verdict set 43 AD 416 misjoinder 72 AD 419 97 AD 162 15 M 109 509 estoppel 102 AD 348 230 diversion aside 110 AD 790 d 158 NY 247 25 251) d 157 AD 866 water 27 M 307 154AD 160 449 master neg. ejectment 34 352 do 2 Tr 58 11 M 113 SO 319 822 IS AD 342 "vehicle" 179AD 553 6 L 82 133 2 TC 277 62 629 47 169 31 NY 464 49 H 569 166S 831 2M 435 6L 442 extension parol e 36 NY 685 45 NY S63 16 NY 619 455 ond. subsq 39 88 IH 663 e 83 NY 382 108 NY 406 324 on payment 48 M 572 d 25 NY 344 41 H 576 enforcement d 164 NY 526 e 61 NY 471 23 All .^4^ e 56 H 484 do 143 S 169 injunction 57 NY 77 37 AD 350 4TC 111 authority d 194 NY 335 327 Incompet ev. 181 NY 262 67 NY 272 11 H 164 24 NY 369 f 144 S 851 no cause action SONY 586 97 US 697 70 NY 311312 161 NY 151 do duty broker do 194 NY 351 33 1 opinions 168 NY 165 147 NY 409 f 159 AD 683 compensation 138 S 923 ender f 96 M 224 37 287 damages construction 66 AD 564 abandonm't 129 AD 199 }5 AD 7(1 ?2 H 462 1 52 statement 24 1 objns. proof 48 H 401 2 Ab 490 491 f 95 M 651 31 37 67 89 e 82 NY 314 424 jurisdiction 5 1 8 estoppel 3T 774 egal evidence 38 444 OH 145 1 54 insurance authority 44 123 equity 468 acte for two i 33 594 ; a 17 NY 200 42 H 539 46 617 532 authority eqmty 333 presumption SH 353 NY 441 1 6 1 declarations 57 H 520 2H 112 74 H 377 34 287 33 171 88 H 235 36 276 543 sp. prfmce 1 46 . 156 1561 245 pers. injury 166S 795 439 objections ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinffuished ; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note criticised; I. limited; e. explained: o, overruled; s. same case; do, dissentins opinion: d. parallel ca«e; a. questieaed. Vols. 21, 22 N. Y.- Supreme Court Reports — Barbour 416 124 545 245 58S 205 38 , ■ alienation 47 67 t66AD 69 AD 13 H legal consent S2 AD 337 37 H ■ 292 do 206NY 352 160 S 834 fourteen years 96 M 599 448 promise a 18 NY 32 ■ St limitation 41 4Ab 565 trust 92 US 27 a 166 NY a 17 NY 578 title 32 42 ] urisdieiion dSO opening highway d 43 H 109 commissioners 74 NY 31 S do 104 AD 606 454 eubacription r24 NY 150 d 32 622 622 469 title 39 103 478 presumption 9 AD 152 484 proof 3L 117 NY assessment dUM 48 173 202 570 foreclosure 172: VOL. 22 '^^^ 9 inaur. interest r20NY 32 36 362 s 4 Ab 438 349 469 136 84 91 unnecessary 128S 585 fraud ■-'L !1 M U.RA 18 NY 589 judicial 5L valid deed 3TC 62 NY 98 87 78 154n 54 imputation 34 M . 458 alienation mtge. SONY. 387 notiice foreclose 5LRA 284n 60 entire dischg 5LRA 287n 68 authority e34 6 34 NY 72 de jure 16 H 196 178 524 „„_ 82 penalty 307,26 ' e86H lc44M 114| 83 court power 29 NY 340 80 NY 265 22MY 420 152 S 143 when contract made 88 M usury 92 M 155 S 1 30 carrier 24 presumption 28 law question 79 H ticket 4H 6TC 90 NY vested right 48fi 216 358 617 280 639 440 244 268 270 489fact question 22 H 290 9M 500 office rl8NY 32 NY not act 72 M 129S 182 139 362 alone 131 289 503 pleading •9 H 108 10 M 645 5 1 3 charter res- ervation 65 H 82 US e95US 24NY 520 lien a 19 NY 43 497 498 325 351 234 549 53 (joint remedy 44 654 14 H 320 judgt operative 40 U 214 6M 79 93 NY 213 54 1 subscription d 32 622 reservation 41 taxation 22NY 546 wives 28 35 pers. liable 38 construction 44 surety S2 husband and wife SS 420 55 1 Sep. estate 593 limitation 7 H 219 330 16AC 302-3n 596 ptnrs. fund 3H 723 6 TC 185 39 M 387 9 32 NY 80 BO 5 statutory 31 178 assessments 41 154 26 M 312 19 NY 36 6 1 I tax sales o36H 613 6 1 7 pub. interest 49 121 e 127NY 279 630 dissolution rl7NY 502 73 NY 390 646 contract 27 141 covenants 46 451 19 NY 91 650 associatio 36 H 564 168 354 444 369 131 26 18 NY 44 devisees 49 surety 62 422 282 369 54 131 1 34 warranty 53 25 M weight of ev. 11 AD le 14 AD 16 AD 24 AD 45 7H 40 H practice 24 M 87 time 23 AD new trial 22 M 121 NY 9 1 reversal 17 AD 3 H contrih. neg. e 29 H 5 TO l)urden proof 57 NY 390 do 57 NY 396 93 94!9 M (;09 fact question 235 213 671 467 52 479 10 AD 1 37 mandamus 35 114 amendment 45 indorsement 61 67 concurrence 62 e 35 NY tills e24H 97 conclusive 66 IL 14 H 17 H 40 NY 38 H e 2M 272 124 207 331 421 31 374 contract separatn 668 642 604 599 170 584 468 632 464 604 196 617 387 233 158 SSS 1 43 joint debt 12 AD 81 counterclaim 26 AD 1 L do 28 NY 84 NY strike out 24 H mandamus 74 NY 66 S7 628 41 discretion 51 amendment 53 528 631 81 AD 140 14nAD 548 reviewable 67 lis pendens 2 LEA affidavit 125 S 1 67 resale 62 IH 76 H 3TC 167 NY 117 US infancy 36 H 81 NY 157 NY 118 AD 24 AD e6L 37 H 4M 122 NY 163 264 60n 799 291 364 596 615 278 192 577 114 278 1 78 custody 57 296 298 141 S 124 welfare child 41 AD 49 AD 75 AD 156 AD 9M 122 NY 1.S5S nreRumption ■JOONY 285 best interests 75M _ 42fi unauthorized 407 93 368 ITS 243 242 684 448118 NY 628 1 injunction 468,34 507 513 183134 517 133'(lamages 36 nee 107 SOOwarrant f 95 M 3 1 4 parol ev. 34 636 11 AD 433 3 1 9 practiae 56 AD 44S 292 30 H reference e44H 6ndings 3TC 323 objeotions 15 H 358 junsdiction 76 H 29 360 670 666 54 H 434 eSlM 323 governnieut title 4Tr 211 37N1 258 St. r.r. nuisance 5LRA 371n prior council c 123AD 146 title fee do 121AD 707 valid title 193 NY 515,517 502 mandamus e 3 Ab 491 506 dog damage counterclm 81 326 27 29 25 NY 337 lieense 45 338 notice a 20 NY 69 5L 61 B 386 628 400 617 163 22 362 demurrer 92 M 156 S 1 95 will rlSNY 518 6 345 32 62 a4Ab ejectment 58 NY 23 1 recovery r41NY 619 445 9 H , ._ e28M I 47fact question 656 certioran 36 49 65 2H 4Tr e39 NY 29 M 116 NY trustee 11SNY 191 NY 191 NY 1 SA 107 NY indemnity 25 M maintenance 94 M 4flS 159 S .^B" *erminate agrmt 166S 962 12 471 470 5.58 679 565 10 AD el4AD 84 H 25 M error fact 16AC 562 62 270 239agency 477 H 28 NY 244 accduntinfi; 70S 626 objeoti"" 705 269 604 n2 M 584 conviction 451 i=;o AD 599 142 s 282n I 222 297 140 242 46 AD e 14M reversal 84 H e32NY 513 presumptn. 125S 628 415 370 451 353 5 1 6 guaranty 31 36 38 80 H e23NY , presumption 43 44 NY agency II.RANS 96 67 116 67 497 228 192 892D 522 levy 28 479 371 wives 28 364 358 legal estate c 52 423 1 L 520 separate estate c32 76 US 18 NY 42 NY 63 255 possession ,,_ . do 114 NY 557 I 50 new promise ea. pleading 13 AD 528 184 NY 91 reply 9 M 67 2e0 license 388 lien a 18 NY 461 1 2 TC 40 agreement 48 NY 123 19 280 641 673 662 184 143 22 73 29'.' 511 I QOwife's necea 52M 43 I I personal 62 603 23H 73 aasignee 34NY 384 I l4quowarranto 8 H 335 21 H 480 e 67 NY 336 14H consideration infant note 5LRA 178n ,_. , ,d64NY I D4 damages I 45. ■50S27I costs opinion value «« 34 H 177 27 H construction „g„ trial I 1 8 lex loci 38 46 5 63 34 H 91 US 15 NY 363 274 355 427 431 192 412 228 396 slander eSl H 33 M 163 1 294 248 S73 e2Tr 36 NY >o'^NY price value 47 NY optional 80 NY 169 26 H 278 ^Yi^l'-^t^O" 176''^° '* ^ .^278 delivery 090 28 622 182 991 90 1 6 1 conclusive 36 notice 3L 1 H 4H 3TC 6TC 1 Ab 93 US 118 NY 382 170 300 361 719 neg. damages 29 f41 NY 47 NY damages 3LRA 62S SfiS 34 590n 297 nuisance 604132 275 456 41 331 322 163 1 63 255 134 13864 70 186 229 527 insur. int. r 20 NY 52 57 82 e 95 US 388 77 NY 007 539 damages 4Tr 58 e 37 NY 216 66 82 550 construc'n 39 102 preference e 49 H 509 exact amount 54 H 466 80 H 63 fraud proof 116 NY 400 strictly fol- lowed 7 H 649 trustees 30 H 216 rule com. law 4f NY 383 delegation 7e. NV . ineffective 72 M 129 S 56 I carrier 46 M 47 M 568 323 194 711 402 inventor.v SAD 512 gift by lease do 206NY 147 404 mandamus 45 475 refunding 53 5P7 permisciive 2 K 411 4 I 4 taxpayer 26 268 436 443 S98 conversion 46 2L equity waiver 44 H severance 46 H 187 213 325 263 578 602 574 negligence 37 518 39 H 173 vesting 41 AD 98 presumption 168 NY 627 587 contract a 21 NY 27 593 attorneys 27 H 600 ABBREVIATION'S: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f. followed; r. reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note t, criticised; 1, limited: «, explained ; o. overruled ; «. lannrcase; do. dissentinn opinion ; p, parallel case : na fide 28 H 133 do 28 H 134 416 trade name infringement 682 313 slander a 17 NY 54 326 debts "due r 24 NY 283 336 amendment 17 NY 218 26 H 458 34 NT 539 34 1 carrier 19 581 31 42 Sunday work 331 569 d 44 624 "laboring" 38 M 339 344 police dist. a 15 NY 532 383 draft « 19 NY 436 49 55 67 3k 3Tr 1 Ab 23 M eSOUS e51NY 597 167 535 569 169 270 71 325 194 421 Vacancies n 17 NY 370 40 H 369 changes 25 M 76 officers 22 NY 139 428 bona fides 3 TC 414 q 27 NY 640 presume fraud 126S 377 establish credrs. TOM 174 433 contract ev 32 584 e 65 644 84 AD 416 29H 501 33H 219 72H 631 83H 405 meas. damages q 24 M .68 implied promise 4H 310 6 TC 559 sp. prfmance e 64H 602 23 M 717 72 NY . 406 value services 10 H 322 440 map ev r 34 NY 307 d 52 292 3H 490 5TC 615 449 maps ev. 16 H 590 r 34 NY 307 compet. ev. 17 AC 74n 455 residue IL fund 3H 6TC notice 64M 119 723 185 457 assessment 37 605 82 US 498 pleading 1.33S 1104 allegations 74M 277 474 construction p 28 402 cnnd. sale 35 590 47 245 5L 315 2 Tr 341 36 NY 657 40 NY 318 q 321 84 NY 127 possession 10 H 543 title vendor do 10 H 544 77 NY 397 fact question 66 160 161 trustee 1 H 416 3TC 602 484 fixtures f 31 602, 616 31 638 good faith 37. 574 39 M 553 rolling stock 47 109, 110 e 54 NT 320 51 61 notice 18 H 173 73 NT 610 care realty 52 NT 525 postponement 36 NT 322 rights creditor 75 M 395 135S 678 497 contract 41 359 4 TO 263 good faith 2 H 62 insurance poliey 10 H 430 warranty 3 Tr 288 d 4 Ab 138 36 NT .568 ^05 inoomp. ev. Bl AD 411 113 NT 63 delivery 7 L 427 nom. damages 74 H 558 ^\3 jurisdiction e 63 AD 22 12 M 645 e 138S 687 532 jurisdiction 44 AD 421 S39 bequest 49 H 316 powers 6 57 H 17 92 NT 305 motives 46 M 312 556 dup. wills 1298 1B2 578 flse repres 31 130 38 470 66 405 18 H 46 do 22 H '486 I Tr 102 39 M 342, 243 SR NT 30R 83 NT 84 ii verment fraud 51 138 wrongdoer 69 AD 146 594 lessor 33 H 436 2 SA 50 597 compet. ev, 28 NT 587 600 eontrib. neg s 27 532 32 168 40 208 e 7 Tr 29 a 1 Ab 211 nonsuit 18 NT 436 evidence 34 NY 18 fact question e 39 NY 864 605 shipping 20 NY 497 625 guaranty 434 contract 27 M 423 635 pers. serv- ice 26 485 52 AD 330 13 H 212 51 H 116 17 M 536 20 M 597 31 M 4 56 M 334 166 NT 177 statute power 33 AD 478 71 H 87 discovery 28 M 600 494 VOL. 26 23 repeal 35 ultra vires no H 366 116 NY 292 accommodaton 11 AU ■ 373 incidental 5LRA 676 intent 54M 31 pleading 59M 274 46 dissolution 39 147 55 vestng 39 71 64 H 384 12SNY 553 set-off 90 H 437 stay 2M 186 6 1 consideration 35 469 68 republication e 31 AD 387 revocation 15 H 413 37 H 248 intention 25 NY 424 78 impeachment 35 450 lost baggage 20 H 22 83 services 54 432 partnership 59 352 657 banking a 26 NT 450 54 235 662 title 8 AD 559 lien e 39 M 666 56 H 296, 297 138 labOT 1 H 402 1 39 contract p 38 212 60 146 36 526 1 H 522 31 420 4 H 567 3 TC 581 statute frauds 48 NT 20 do 48 NT 24 e 65 NT 862 hiring 51 546 I 47 st-ate decisis r20NY 210 do 2M 16 1 60 defraud cred II H 253 I 67 demand 32 181 eonversn pldg* 36 NY 323 119 AD260do261 407 OOofil bond d 62 NT 94 agency f 67 AD 174 NT icnuiesced 139 AD admissions do 1.57 AD do 143 S 97 201 305 806 1 72 leave 18 M. practice 114 AD 465 claim vs. lunatic 19AC 81n 82 sum. remedy 151 AD 164 1H5S 148 1 77 presump- 95 AD 583 a 23 NT 90 burden proof 153 NT 446 197 inadequate e 27 H 606 202 estoppel 91 US 64 208 St. limitatn 36 323 68 US 310 S.55 218 constitutnl 22724 NT 389 104 construct'n 99 NT 514 1 18 judicial n 17 NT 486 50 579 2 TC 21 122 AD 499 discretion 58 146 review 65 20 53 AD 619 audit e 9 H 442 jurisdiction 67 NT 114 122 duress 37 494 4 H 170 6 TC 487 2 Tr 325 74 US 215 36 NY 371 defense 221NT 408 (33 compensa- tion 49 121 62 631 d 66 H . 572 conclusive 7 H 356 authority 224 eq, convers. 95 NT 605 trust 107 AD 7 intestacy 1S2AD 850 f 137S 1006 236 trust f 51 M 448 240 confirmatn 32 38 written notice 53 411 252 will r 23 NT 894 256 pleading 77 NT 149 262 relief 24 H 650 40 H 137 289 covenant 30 299 50 H 303 90 H 29 72 M 174 d 69 NT 269 f 218 NY 501 129S 344 construction 31 647 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, foKowed; r, reversed; m, modified: ', dismissed- n, note: e. enticised: I, limited; e, explained; o. overruled; s. same case: do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q', questloni Vols. 26,27 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Barbour 30 1 injunction 50 190 65 H • 235 90 NT 41C 310 credits 37 229 / 2 Tr 94 e 38 NT 356 3 1 6 incompetent evidence 51 620 title 57 145 jarisdiction 31 546 decree appeal "' 455 285 463 195 676 406 309 409 waste 29 17, damages 1 TO 416 reTocation 41 29 M 34 M 82 M 34 NT 170 NT 119 AD 143 S personality 23 H 70 NT 78 NT 13 H 85 H 5 TO 9 M 20 M security 29 M rejection 33 M costs 29 H 26 NT estoppel 4 AD 72 AD 170 NT tax situs 68 AD pers. liability 273 656 486 44 608 82 589 54 449 489 223 203 391 512 S49 165 66M 123 S 447 555 418 revocation 5 LRA 34fi 4f9 equity 39 9 H 19 H 50 H 25 NT 424 515 122 86 329 423 mistake 1 L 170 lepcission 116 NY 164 adverse party do ITC authority 3H lOH 429 stay 39 M 35 AD 1 L 5 M 139 74 NT relief 5 SS 62 H witness 33 NT 251 59 14] 658 437 ceriotrari 552 325 exceptn 692 power atty. 116 AD 675 valid claim 63 M accounting 88 M 150 S 65 21 H d 22H discretion 9M 629 410 426 355 amendment 295 365 342 264 25 291 452 556 life policy r 23 NY 516 50 NY 619 562 perfmance 19 H 267 564 damages d48 130 41 NY 668 47 NY . 34 compensation 62 M 22 568 ultra vires 30 468 90H 323 U6NY 292 569 recei 1 TC evidence 3TC lien 31NY vesting 78 NY estqppei 02NY 635 pers. privi' lege 29 40 certiorari 43 23 usurious 49 NY 20 528 471 251 72 443 title 37 H adv. possession 17 AC 378D not enforce f 219NY 294 463 recovery 29 equity 50 AD 63 H 30 M 79 NT d 81 NT 124 NT Btat. limitations 27 H 573 7 H 432 lien realty 119 AD 699 39 OP 348 judgt. vs. land 125 S 140AD money jndgmnt, 140AD 633 367 set-off r 22 NT 40 c43 o43 mortgage 65 NY 468 rent 515 316 318 680 304 a Ss'NY 180 143 116 356 984 632 489 374 redemption 7 L 404 e 36 H 586 as H 587 660 644 64 1 limitation a 24 NY 181 liability 29 137 h 29 143 P29 610 fill 612 362 641 354 558 q4 H q6TC e84US 648 dam. 20NY 586 directory a 25NY 588 39 110 595 constitutnl. 66 AD 690 illegal Sir 665 12H 44 25 H 91 6X0, 171 597 conversion 59 M 169 603 construotiun 7 636 606 notice 52 H 220 17 M 152 24 NY B59 relatn dissolved 162 NY 170 admissions 16 M ' 68 declarations do 115 AD 547 6 1 I estoppel 472 title d42 577 67 AD 360 dSTC 30 e3K fiOl eSTr 324 4 4D 440 29NY 41 73 NY 254 32 NY 36 132 NY 76 475 partition 3 Ab 382 481 removal 26 605 29 HO 35 36 3K 3Tr 3Ab 42 NY 100 casement 73 M dedication d 132S 443 disap. 132 S 443 VOL. 27 9 discretion e 151AD 82 H family ISM anomaly 151AD right father 135S 1081 custody child 156 AD 141 S 34 judicial 30 42 AD 3S9 608 364 rule ftifi 'contract "jfieOONY M6 Icond. order 42 primary fund 96 NY 371 r 22 NY 200! , o-, j e 2 TC 7 ' oTnom damag^ 123 49 65 1 diligence 53 198 presumption 1 AD 389 657 Individ, lia- bility 67 264 4H 248 25 NY 623 repeal 7H 4S6 liresumption Tl M 31S 130 S 334 52 mtee. debt 62 divesting 5L lien 78 NY assent eotirt 138 NY review 5H 575 628 436 439 428 610 256 208 450 457 383 intent r 28 NT 28 evidence 64 526 title 66 367 presumption 2 H 610 good faith 85 H 570 487 mandamus (i"19 NY 188 liability 105M 603 5 1 6 St. commrs 6 1 2 incoxnp ev d 30 519 1 Tr 262 5 Tr 239 2 Ab 363 36 NY 149 6 I 5 seduction 50 AD 102 15 M 62f 42 M 616 infant contract e 21 H 48!^ 19 M 64f 424 187 517 421 ntract 24 NY 1 78 parties 333 title 51 1 K 2Ab right action 183 96 M 176160 S ^^^, 1 8 1 intent '67 H 262 642 64 13 AD 16A0 187 92n 467 55 prfmance 1 L 415 1 92 payment 2io'53 198 .undertaking 93 2 TC 343 note for debt 16AC 149n 153 277 37 c46 58 bond cond >29 H 100 NY 65 bonds 16 NY 73 tender 82 H demand note e4l NY 601 79 counterclaim 29 386 user 34 NY 461 8? parol contract 36 165 refuse charge 1 H 520 3 TO 661 89 pay warrant 29 98 mandamus 3? 457 94 pono. precedt. a SO NY 470 jurisdiction 32 135 136 86 395 5 I. 322 mandamus 46 fiO 66 87 AD d 43 H 1 M f 155 S eomm'rs jurisd. e*9NY 112 30 NY 472 36 NY 444 63 NY 895 d 396 196 interpetat'n 27 H 166 40 H 276 207 encroachmt 309 312 564 IL 3 TO qlSS ^„ e 31 NY *^'^ boundanes 64 prescription 53 H 2 I 4 jurisdietion 9H 621 user 34 NY compliance 69 M ans. title 126 S 6 1 8 negligence a 17 NY 539 notice 64 32 default mtge. c 109 AD 440 purpose honest 3LRA 92 equity court 28 39 q32H 62 H 12 M. 630 user r23NY 37 33 H 19.« 33f 53f 23P 484 61 67 608 609 66 287 357 64 35S 664 461 statutory law C'30 106 r 30 433 23 NY 47S 252 trustees 7L 105 judgt. in rem. conformity 4TC 133 623 653 317 44 284 67 381 260 trust c29 d33 3fi 31 M 4Tr repeal 27 H 3 1 pleading 10 H 382 3 I 5 strict CO pliance m 41 AD 468 29 H 406 44 H 259 322 presumptn 74 US 509 a 26 NY 474 335 irregular 9 H 636 337 jurisdiction 51 384 57 442 66 295 18 M 553 49 NY 309 objections 26 NY 459 waive objns. 18AC 429n 346 new trial 6H 41 3M 101 354 conclusive 286 2 1 8 negligenoe 32 63S 637 44 393 32 NY 497 22] oontriD.neg. 261 91 211 252 109 289 30 31 d32 40 e7Tr d34NY e39NY 109 NY charge error 1 K 2Ab law question 8H 34 NY do 189NY 262 479 161 428 168 208 29 629 364 22 33 warranty S3 NY estoppel d32H 71 NY insur. interest 22 H 325 false representn 577 310 560 254 196 280 391 99 d 173 NY 44 M 2TR 1 00 oosta e5fiH 69 NY 104 covenant a 19 NY 68 100 30 299 46 447 448 annulment 36 461 privity S2 4S6 45R release 46 . flssignment 230 redemption 39 368 6 M 195 e 196 184 NY 419 238 persons eorp 56 29 63 239 deposition e 20 NY 136 244 death dam. 27 248 statutory law 30 106 107 23 NY 475 479 481 77 NY 550 presumption 36 M 291 81 NY 371 devise a 26 NY 376 escheat 27 36 66 4Tr 37 NY ^^415 adjudication 37 H 69 construction 572 381 229 36 274 44 377 67 76 476 466 137AD 424 hen Si 59 NY authority 4Ab conversion 3U joinder e 124 NY 425 party 5LRA 124 503 108 164n 70 340 248 death dam. 48 431 construction 67 606 117 AD 712 445 constitut'l. 36 185 191 27 244!forfeiture ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, disnrissed; n, note c. criticised ; 1, limited ; e, explained ; o, overruled ; s, samt. case ; do. dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, queatumed N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Barbour Vols. 27, 28 564 I 150 S 28H 64 H 2 K 3 Ab 586 j/»rt . statutory 463 exeoutn sp 1 7 i \f 57 _„, . — - _ 142 369 87 M 583 330 duplicate wills 17 H 33 H 42 NY 68 NY 474 surety r26NY 480 vrirea 29 42 94 US 485 bond a 33 NY 489 parol 40 AD 37 H e3TC 7M 493 otrclaim 14 138 589 639 195 69 584 538 564 423 154 554 503 owner 32 460 parol evidence; 36 5J6 affidavit sale 7H 384 e 7 H 585 32 H 318 71 H 479 85 H 153 31 NY 60 505 exemption 34 24 37 5H 30 H conclusive 46 H waiver 59 H 31 NY selection 57 20 H 30 H 509 penalty 50 512 damages 6L immunity ILRANS 606 524 de facto 38 66 632 strike out 77 NY ■ 387 a IS NY 316 528 fact ques 29 d34NY 39 NY 364 coutnb. nee. 31 428 429 weight evidence 36 26 44 658 532 contr. neg e 7 Tr 29 543 corporation 42 85 commissioner T2M 2S4 30 VOL. 28 9 death dam. wills statutory l.'!2S probate 139 S amendment 141 S presumption 142 S compliance 89 M 154 S 562 supt. 20 H 575 constitut'l 159 4 H 702 a 2 K a2Ab 494 as NY 23 NY 714 a 99 NY ex delicto 113 AD 170 644 242 173 a 17 NY s36 36 a 18 NY illesal 100 NY 595 estoppel 235 185 186 315 277 61 67 do2H 7H 17H 65 H 2TC 5TC do 5 TC 2 K 4 Ab presumotion 2 H 40 259 402 567 516 124 546 429n 6 1 executors IL becfuest 3 H 453 5 TC 667 construction 64 NY 291 365 499 341 244 318 271 656 641 122 244 g2 I commrs. highway 44 o47 46 H 13) 34 NY damages 62e o 47 126 AD 564 . 344 31 not direction 140 S 650 direction 155 AD r 46 106 3 TC 738 294 277 66 467 476 d 100 NY 479 265 29 relief 32 17 44 52 AD 77 H do 124 NY default 109 AD 59 'M covenants 44 tender 13 H 76 H 38 labor S3 51 60 3L IH 71 4S 60 344 224 383 183 440 569 344 100 328 207 208 546 146 402 522 30 681 20 ne «3 TC 13 TC 48 NY 130 ™s*'i>e „ do 48 NY 49 NY sale _ 65 NY 119 e 65 NY statutF frauds 1.S8S 203 360 362 4 I death dam 8 1 Ab „„ 44 estoppel 820 4 L 17H 47 title 158S Dresumption 95 M 43 43 45 390 43 499 49 imprisonment eSI H 99 504 638 prfmance 629 41 625 ■ B52 recovery 34 88 89 waiver tort lOH 74 NY a 110 NY 118 NY do 104 AD 554 316 237 28 605 553 executor 65 90 7 L 484 1 TO 99 34 NY 183 556 subscription 49 66 332S 711 37 66 «6H 1 K a K Ab 4 Ab estoppel 13 M consent 42 291 35fi 307 449 122 616 595 579 561 99 presumption Idirect'n verdict l426 heirs 23 NY 602 39 NY 312J9 AD 81 2 TC preference 19 M 34 414 165 109 contruot'nl 438 658 1 1 6 illegal 38 409 284 costs 66 M7 legal practice e 163 NY 65 whole period 105M 173S 1 2 I conversion m 23 NY 69 44 H 319 bequest void 34NY 587 1 57 bill lading 32 502 e3 K 577 1 Tr 205 3Tr 96 4 Ab 19 fact question 123 27 61 8 43 287 party 50 AD 290 relief eSH partition 4M 42 48 9H 31 NY charge 95 US assumption 3K 3 Ab consequences e.2 TC 24 NY waive lien 20AC 302 356 143 400 639 ]26n 1 87 usury a 23 NY 30 33 NY 276 629 668 ■I 96 prox, 10 AD 266 presumptn 504 e 84 H contractor do 164 NY 267 488 210 joinder 67 M 124 S 384 neg. 113 677 795 94 325 351 293 hab. corpu 35 455 460 462 fraudulent 60 316 88 NY 671 299 services minor child 432 vesting 40 M 481 438 eonsiderat'n n 26 NY 604 34 525 63 H 571 441 pleading 33 25 NY cause action 156 AD 141 S 444 joinder 106 220 19 553 23 c50 50 parties 15 H 32 H jurisdiction 14 M friend -of court 37 M 26 3 1 notice a 22 NY 128 3 1 8 taxation 32 514 516 78 US 430 328 inheritance 36 389 214 179 124n 548 32 54 waiver 35 H 59 pleading 41 40 NY 228 franchise a 27 NY 112 574 414 65 Corp.' power 39 545 75 infant deceit 580 564 1 H 10 H conversion 61 NY contract S8NY 481 639 80 pers. injury r 25 NY 562 22 NY 354 221 894 217 bill d37 lading 570 611 594 646 450 276 32 87 278 618 971 master neg. 49 NY 531 fraud reoreaentns 7 H 225 rescission 62 H 444 90 discharge remedies 50 * coo 4LRA 145P „ 86 AD 82 „__ . e v wrath 658 stoppage P49 jj '? 300 f 168 AD 97 58H 48 153 S 724 1 *** 725 96 consideration |a 25 NY 189 do 153 S right stop do 168AD 9fi!40 240 joinder 35 ' 36 NY demurrer 67 24 AD 6L 63 M averment 7H complaint 11 H f 16.S AD St. limitations 49 H 39 title 90 H 508 duly" 129 US 2SB 254 subscription a 30 NY 116 e 25 H 94 265~ affidavit 32 608 evidence error 21 H 380 275 rr ticket 7H 673 13 H 632 stop over 333 lien 39 AD 176 NY- aoAC descent down 134 NY 491 343 coverture 40 112 52 423 curtesy e 1 L 521 e2L 21 construction 2 L 28 34 vesting 9M 124 NY 166 8 3S7 556 signature 73 M 564 trusts a 20 NY 6H 37 M 238 270 289 11 e8H in e71H ,639 misjoinder 149 AD 871 134S 384 447 damages rl9NY 262 454 election 36 305 intention 54 H 202 residue 92 NY 250 s3SA 406 148 S 6Hft 163 AD 352 593 consent 39 H 101 forgery 136AD 308 602 practice 33 238 non joinder 2H 518 50 C 714 pleading 10 H 557 contribution 462 arrest 13 H 440 466 law question 49 98 480 discretion 644 382 joinder 1 H 82 AD 3TC 393 title 84 NY 403 carrier 51 23 NY money levy eSONY 336 546 560 127 77 337 278 ABBREVIATIONS: ». affirmed: d, distinguished c. criticised; 1. limited; e. explained ; o. overruled ; s 51 4e 86 ri 270 4 I 2 insurance 36 377 compliance 63 NY 111 4 \ 6 jurisdictionil 3H 6TC 61 NY affidavit 40 NY objections 48 NY 565 318 518 102 99 42 1 foreclosure 48 569 363 517 614 516 328 102 1 H d2TC 3TC 485 carrier 57 2L variance 65 NY 503 stockholder d 48 522 523 disqualification 32 H 442 e 77 NY 107 112 5 1 5 expenses 66 81 bill exceptins 324 103 40 647 576 ins. policy e 44 AD 43 588 dower 42 e54NY 622 285 204 450 572 70 270 390 392 40 16 H 24 H parties 41 H 2M 25 NY drainage 5SS 609 asse 24M 616 E^s trustees 70M 660 622 oral prom. 34 NY 293 37 49 husb. property 42 572 postponement 44 280 trustee 67 H 240 630 justification 32 -279 p 67 . 445 26 M . 450 63 I jurisdiction 61 M 382 ICP NS 201 3TC damages 11 M f 168 NY 526 defense 39 mitigation 44 new trial 62 533 title 39 new trial 43 78 M 139 S warranty e6Tr 39 NY 276 689 537 399 519 514 633 curtesy 52 dlL wives rights e42 AD husband 4H 22 NY 281 538 423 541 136 224 538 undertaking 61 38 M 46 M e58 NY 539 ne 80 NY 128 544 406 688 25 423 521 445 250 113 644 auth ority 28 NY 269 555 proofs 136S 1104 661 stockholders 57 38 21 II appeal 5TC .3K rSTr r4 Ab 486 285 112 450 562 258 628 669 pri-vilege 184 NY {. followed, r. reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note ■ same case; do, dissentinit opinion; p, parallel case; q. questioned Vol. 29 N. Y. Supreme Court Beports — Barbour 613 351 207 VOL. 29 9 treBpass el7 AD conversion 6H 342 waiver 48 H measure dam S2 H 354 J- SS 183 consideration 138AD 536 25 parties 53 50 AD 3H e9H 12 H 22 H 127 NY 19A0 19AC 35 carrier 36 38 bailees 50 authority 6L connectine 7L 66 H 79 US 24 NY 27 NY 45 NY d53NY 49 39 175 94 95 608 440 238 463 459 187n 191n 28 NY I 1 2 trust 29 NY I 20 cotenant 94 AD 507 e86 H 206 devise 24 M I service process 88 NY 636 release 134 NY 412 132 limitation " 222 329 608 a 24 NY 4H 6 TO . e84US negligence 124 NY infancy elOH 222 oral sale 56 e7L 226 request rl4NY 5H 9parks nee, 8H 64 40 ighgei )NY 425 595 205 478 lines 64 459 85 278 560 189 370 172 59 money had 30 240 e 36 NY 226 227 do 55 NY 189 72 NY 204 68 construction 35 41 mortgagor 43 H 157 NY 77 a;ppeal 43 199 substitution 105 NY 675 81 supervisors 28 AD 523 166 307 I 45 trespass 34 notice 32 H 250 equitable lien 119 AD 251 I 56 election 32 299 d 55 NY 229 note for debt 16AC 145n i 65 location 44 NY 595 1 7 1 mutual 57 NY 234 implied promise 136 NY 609 164 AD 429 enforcement 120 AD 4Z9 breach contract 164 AD 429 f 76 witness a 32 NY 347 22 NY 354 ISO irregular 614 exceptions 13 H 16 H limitations 88 H 539 demand note 87 dicretion 52 AD changed 28 H remedy 29 H mistake 60 H 74 H 21 M 40 M 70 NY 72 NY relief 132 NY restitution f 82M 143 S I90NY _ 486 fact question 69H lunatic 143 NY 44S 724 563 591 lOn 218 505 600 234 nesligonce 36 239 239 penalty r 46 289 58 H 245 property rights 30 AD ■ 280 33 H 470 S4 NY 221 185 NY 364 fact question 140 NY 349 boundaries 19 M 21 limitations 117AD 408 325 presumpnt' 46 275 rate interest 8 H 454 335 waiver 46 240 subscription 22 H 364 a4 Ab 3 52 58 H authority 125 S parties 69M 55) 246 911 560 256 relig. corp. 3 21 NY 267 92 232 ejectment 38 H 4 277 sealed instru ment 48 limitation 18 H 33 H 50 H 57 H 36 M e 128 NY 153 NY foreclose 132 s enforcement 147AD 435presum payt r 3 Ab 350 land liab, for mtg. 5LR,A 282n 442 bonds seal r 23 NY 439 35 H 13 f 30 241 454revival covnt 57 NY 648 472 replevin p 1 TO 558 f 1 TC 559 480 transf wife 678 165 547 adiudicatn 179AD 166S 274 466 e4Tr 584 475 624 33 216 45 431 575 169 501 682 367 443 1051 14 M salary 220' NY 96 mandamus d75NY 100 rent a 26 NY 45 assignment 6Tr covenant e3M end lease 107 NY 44 498 614 327 234 619 105 impeachm't r27 NY 596 38 640 attachment 5LRA 196 penal a 21 NY 5H trustees 533n 268 21 521 1 98 verdict set aside' 38 102 c28H 6 10 M 442 204 extra com peusation 383 622 559 41 87 339 covenant 21 AD 179 142AD 368 54 H 622 18 M 502 127S 166 real party int 22 H 433 353 dividends 57 NY 208 363 conversion e 21 M 66 trade fixtures 141AD 108, 110 367 case appeal 32 666 35 433 objections 7L 195 369 stockholders r 22 NY 9 486 consideratn r 21 NY r35 guaranty d63 172 289 compet. ev, 2 Ab 495 IK 30 277 '90 463 14] 208 title 45 45 AD unconstitutional 49 12 compensation 139 S 925 212 vendee lien 117 AD 607, 50S do 117AD 513 192NY m Z 1 8 nm'aance 62 309 71 AD 443 139 NY 11 180 NY 56 29 1 nuisance 3 SS 496 295counterclaim 27 AD 61] 9M 71 same parties 2 TC 501 set off 137AD 192 297 affidavit B 4 L 491 2H 407 7H 383 4 TC 637 305 asseasmeiit 41 155 estoppel 42 . 654 6 H 72 294 22 H 334 309n assessment 41 155 4 Ab 592 3 1 2 contract 5H 98 3K 420 2 Tr 232 4 Ab 285 79 US 304 3 1 5 recovery 47 579 89 NY 391 3 1 9 adv. poss'n 63 78 AD demurrer IH SH 3TC 7M d38M 383 set-off 57 NY exemption 17 AC 515 255n 2H 9H mortgagee 53 H legal title 5 TO 178AD 165S equity d lOlM d 168S 176 197 735 900 588 547 S49 parties deft 198 NY 534 552parties in int 67 510 74 US 362 r 36 NY 139 560 partners r'30 NY 350 11 H 400 563 sp. prfmce 103 NY 421 315 469 334 388 exception 47 499 39 I nuisance 49 I weight of ev a 28 NY 217 44 558 expenses dam. 66 82 4 Ab 521 505 new considn 46 214 do 5 H 512 10 H 417 23 H 9 36 M 355 equitable lien 46 H 21 36 M , 355 val. consideration 2LRA 530n 2LRA 530n e24AD 39 AD 6L 6TC 99 NY 156 NY assessment 65 H 569 estoppel 35 3K f86NY enforceable 167 AD f 152 S 576 valid note 7H 579 585 forn receiver 436 610 401 212 859 66 76 447 289 .289 e37NY lex loci 115AD foreign law d 212 NY 212 NY 664 relief 26H ord. concluaion 14 M 429 e 94 NY 525 112 AD 808 228 44 158 234 32 492n 448 120 256 595 reformation 55 181 20 H 400 eq. new contr. 57 287 7M 592 relief 2 Ab 467 597mistke.refrm. 5LRA 157n 602 lim. liability 252 337 533 561 469 55 39 6 extrinsic ev a 35 NY 375 d 2 Ab 415 abandonment d 53 H 563 40 1 discharge 25 AD , 517 e3L 219 privy 5L 182 defense usury 15 H 567 16 M 57 40 NY 490 4 1 new contract 49 258 e 3 TC 20 d 3 TC 21 29 NY 218 82NY 539 53 M 554 substitution f 168 AD 697 4 1 9 legal ev. 44 123 128 NY 476 negligence d61 113 427 advances 509 carrier neg. el L 176 5 1 2 husb & wife r 31 NY 564 joinder 35 73 5« 60 n25NY 49 61 4H 6TC C84US neg. master ITC 24 NY 5 1 8 mortgagee el L 6L implication 35 NY e42NY recovery 187NY 523 legal ev 44 62 280 281 277 324 524 contract 40 227 surety 5LRA 281n 41 NY 181 51 NY 336 land liab. for mtg 6LRA 281n covenants 136AD 529 surety SLRA 538 surety SLRA 560 16 AC 78n, 85n'27 NY 281n 539 discretion r 21 NY 168 442 572 618 329 608 366 530 205 6 1 7 w. character 49 344 cond. precdt. 145 S 585 f 160 AD 682 622 jurisdiction 61 2H 8M 174 NY contempt 4TC 146 S 160 AD 625 234 168 105 474 50 668 63 I lien prior 27 M 449 633 carrier neg. 47 NY 33 644 crops a3K a4Ab 329 475 647 fences neg. IH 379 27 H 396 3 TO 539 construcn stat. 3 Ab 342 3191650 heirs at law /?5«SIV^V?^'^/ /' »''^™'*4; f distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note- C criticised; 1. limited; e, explained; o, overruled: s, same case; do, dissenting opinion; p. pirallel oaseTq? questioned N. T. Supreme Court Reports— Barbour Vols. 30, 31 VOL.30. I "navigable" 3LRA 617 9 obstruct river r 36 NY 464 center stream ]40 S 337 boundary 75 M 285 20 resoiBsion 82 H 196 76 NY 552 24 permissive 514 282 44 M r21NY 27 NY 34 appeal 59 M 42 revers error 81 AD 490 29 H 12R 3K 141 4 Ab 326 163 NY 171 books as ev. 197NY 192 47 pub policy 17 H 405 13 M 593 rulings error 29 H 555 void contract 60 H 29 M eood faitb 114 NY 66M husband 124 NY 19 H 24 NY 27 H 368 filinz stipulation 2H 96 4TC 93 NY 486 I 1 7 void judet « 41 H 274 d 48 H 659 1 34 undue inB 33 60 3H 5TC 15 M 16 M 39 M e35NY 63 NY 69 146 430n 216 183 &6 607 518 238 money had a 31 NY 606 4 AD 374 d 46 NY 77 d 55 NY 189 246 discretion a 34 NY 247 36 443 3K 6Se 265 payment r 32 NY 519 33 544 546 44 79 title 41 612 overt act 65 NY 27 268 lien priority 668 1 44 undue iiifl r 22 NY 418 31 37 33 70 I 47 trespass 79 H 503 I 59 jurisdiction 384 626 118 15 361 236 629 413 62 120 131 599 51 65 4H ITC 6 TO 12M 26 M 44 M 88 NY 21 H 139 NY preference 154AD 16AC 139 S 56 126 296 92n lOU U31NY 218 389 money had IH 427 3 TC 594 392 covenant 58 50 8 H 513 395 costs 18 M 524 exr assets 685 d22H 28 H 88 NY descent 162 AD 147 S 537 ejectment a 22 NY 44 553 stockholder 1 73 bar e 93 AD 318d319 accrual 4H 110 6 TC 396 48 collat. attack] pledge 139 S 694 47M 6C8 276 conversion 20 M 324 48 NY 92 67 NY 33 80 NY 366 do 156 AD 490 141 S 279 283 interested witness 19 H 79 a 2 K 348 292 devisee d 33 252 s39 84 consideration 49 AD 527 8 35 NY 204 403 eq. interest e 127 NY 323 421 request 9H 8 Corp. powers 90 H 368 116 NY 292 426 counterclm a 29 NY 494 433 pers. repren. 13 H 463 similar statute 36 M 291 23 NY 476481 483 444 water rent 71 H 38 notice 162 NY 331 IrfU s 222 73 M 111 79 M 7o 136 422 61 disseizin dam T 3 Ab 285 72 secondary ev. 12H 92 H »«ency q62NY merger 76 NY 81 adv possessn. 64 24 M estoppel 143 S 158 AD 97 429 624' 319 388 325 85bond and nLtge r 33 NY 55 99 pers. right e 13 H 453 23 NY 481 77 NY . 550 84 NY 53 31 H 359 similar statute 36 M 291 compensation 23 NY 476 479 ex delicto 113 AD survivorship 6LRA 71 I 1 discharge 44 42 NY recovery 64 66 defense IL 21 H 186 H validity 666 376 409 284 447 373 121 1 80 remedy 36 M 637 1 83 defense ans 56 AD 167 eq. action 190 NY 183 1 85 void e34' 12(1 21 H 339 193 emoluments 101 NY 633 202 remedy land 16 H 89 4M 32 17 M 647 2 1 8 corpn iable e3AD 6U2 elH 565 45 M 22U parol evidence e7H 366 25 H . 144 32 H ft4h f 152 S 202 89 M 618 principal liable 83 AD 619 e4TC 74 e76NY 387 contract ev 125 AD 180 225 conversion 6H 33 7 229 negligence 37 208 67 AD 214 215 17 H 37 co-employe 55 H 499 72 H 615 81 H 158 300 m. prose- cution 97 NY e85NY 305 ferries r20NY 407 468 477 176 331 vesting 67 , amendment 3TC 637 stock divds 458 will trust 47 H 79 NY 250 611 38 m39 ratification 17 AD e 102 AD treasurer 5H trustee e35NY 37 NY 52 NY 54 NY 56 NY 57 NY 66 NY 74 NY 84 NY 91 US 16 H 32 H 35 H 42 H 54 H 4Tr termination M amount 21 M voidable 75 M 548 543 217 330 523 526 694 389 370 3 1 2 suspend powr alienation a 33 NY 593 d 52 . 425 4H 746 severance will 2 Tr 362 36 NY 648 325 confess judt r 1 Ab 370 IK 29 33 I adv. possesn 471 stay a34NY 65 67 AD fretjd from lien 66 AD 41 77 AD 498 27 M 68 478charter party 12 H 628 30 NY 241 78 NY 50 78 US 601 483 leave court 819 329 461 491 453 568 654 202 589 391 382 100 129 344 88 774 22 AD 25 H 26 H c 136 US 164 NY 172 NY e 47 M income 209 NY 641 trustee 60 AD voidable 168 NY 432 206 105 663 19g 141 564 462 238 373 263 20 359 392 546 a 36 NY 37 41 59 NY 338 witness 3TC 231 250 531 50 270 344 plea title 49 assessors 2H 5TC 2Tr order void SONY 36 NY perpresture 13 H 468 498 635 43 16 AD 72 H contempt 39 AD 49 AD 83 US reference 45 H stay 139 NY 91 AD special motion 33 AD 120 37M 773 485 damages 3Ab 236 44 218 350 489 396 568dirotrs. tdlty. 2LRA 634n i.i^es 31 fiduciary l.'ilAD 494 580 policy void 32 628 member liable 37 36 609 e 64 AD 268 588 ministerial a 27 NY 45 e 5 L 220 2ndary evidence 10 M 101 quo warranto 42 NY 236 challenge 119 NY ISS con\mon law ILRA 83S 605 suit vs town a 26 NY 614 66 298 commissioner 25 H 619 collector 107 NY 487 544 assignment r 36 . 32S stare decisis 23 H e7M 155 S duty judge 92 M 646 bonds 36 H 63 H 655leachs 42 7 AD 21 AD 35 H STr 24 M . discretion 38 NY 635 215 VOL.31 undue infl. 40 67 77 AD 37 H .44H do2K do3 Ab 35 NY scrutiny 83 M 147 S 38 illegal 42 a 29 NY 44 65 23 M 49 eocles 4L 2H 5TC remedy 125 S 62 sheri'tl 131NY 529 469 350 422 178 243 374 592 170 83 250 16 666 358 270. law.'^ 366 553 99 874 255 »9 jurisdiction 55 4L 287^ 45 H 663 alienation 47 56 rlAb rlK 35 313 603 41 280 494 rsnt truste 64M 667 498 money nad a 31 NY 506 405 625 254 131 14 2TC domicile S6M 123 S 125 209 111 390 271 392 280 650 308 40 6 1 6 assesst roll 473 444 667 349 levy validity a2Ab 534 b3K 373 construe will a 29 NY 605 comp. ness 37 43 44 47 IK 6Tr 2Ab lJ6'4 Ab 23 NY 51 NY valid lien 39 67 49 298 42 AD e 100 NY occupant 7H e56H 387 mtge satisfn 422 261 200 239 363 559 397 415 384 378 360 62 1 eq. title ev. 39 626 17 M 427 65 NY 42 626 indorsers 63 ,, 424 usury , do 63 430 33 NY 668 40 NY 490 633 witnesses 39 521 gift land 51 311 78 trust heirs 11 H 153 84 stockhldrs d50 434 demurrer do 26 H 339 parties 33 M 373 92 guaranty 38 108 116 30 H 267 18AC 318n 27n 328n, 329n acceptance 17 M 140 cond. precedent 40 NY 188 100 pledgor 89 AD variance 22 H a3Ab a2K a3K 467 378 291 674 16S 1 02 usury proof 5 LRA 466m 1 06 irregular 53 494 order reference d 79 NY 557 d 163 NY121 122 authority 110 AD 453 121 damages 14 H 153 deceit- 18 H 46 83 NY 34 132 coverture 2H pleading e 42 H ■ |4TC 3Tr eq. claim 36 NY 1 34 relief 62 67 H 433 180 632 276 606 627 512 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; C •riticited ; 1, limited j e, explained ; o, overruled ; i f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; , same case ; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, questioned Vols. 31, 32 N. Y. Supreme Coart Reports— Barbour 42NY 32 65 NT 188 appearance 28M 527 ISSassessment d40 3SA 124 NY residence 48 63 34 H d46H 376 366 639 188 52 603 148 142 negligence 31 34 34 AD 89 AD eL 40H elAb e2K 154 877 100 522 254 413 73 143 37 230'waiver 57 damages 14 H 238 waivp 43 54 available 4 AD e43AD statutory law 26 M 252 158 NY 283 reimbursement 44 H 159 mandamus 121 AD 289 1 52 contract 34 5/3 155 construction 86 NY 606 f 58 bond costs e 17 H 600 8 20 NY 99 f 62 privileged 8M 175 i6 4 surety 62 18 H 83 NY 241 alteration 46 3 e 27 H 349 29 NY 410 258 legal corp'n 466 403 60 1 69 estoppel a 2 2 NY 249 42 NY 448 458 1 7 It requests 36 443 exceptions 48 413 IH . 182 3 Te 724 8 TC 404 3K 586 3Tr 138 172 construct 'n ?5 121 36 214 ministerial 44 115 44 AD 42 43 assessments e29H 93 26 M 312 27 NY 154 84NY discretion s 31 466 389 2 1 3 chat, mtge 297 guaranty 268 323 438 431 420 603 64 H waiver 44 M e4Ab p25NY 123 610 590 208 260 negligence a 2 K 294 267 parol ev e 3 TC 423 22 NY 354 273 special acts 62 487 146AD 394 right to action 6H 36 M do6H e51NY chastity 26 H 46 H incompt. ev. 27 H reputation 138 AD other acts 131 S 677 222 581 429 501 168 323 251 dS3 5H 66 NY 137 NT surety 191Ny 151 61 332 316 334 30 1 title transfr 57 145 304 partition r 34 NY 663 3 1 2 process prot 55 397 19 B . 270 3 1 4 tenants by entirety 162 IH 3E 6H 67 H 3TC 5TC 76 NY 92 NY 433 523 623 232 575 571 266 161 167 NY 111 403 place paymt 12 H 2»1 407 stockholde 67 NY 690 17 M 32g 4 1 3 presumptB 36 306 7L 504 election 43 528 4 1 9 pers injury » 36 217 r 54 NY 230 9L 436 439 sum ro. 36 666 24 M S14 747 277 eompt. ev 49 368 6Tr 328 consideratn 25 H 348 construction 53 H 394 330 connivance 27 H 299 339 advice court c 65 AD 256 345 election 38 273 350 "process" 115AD 308 cupl. proceedgs, 19A0 168 353 admissn at torneys r 22 NY 67 364 injunction 200 279 carrier 50 a 31 NY 214 406 180 ejectment a 21 NY 206 mast record i 160 S 16 1 96 M. 50 1 83 bona fides ••.37 466 violation 34 AD 165 i92concede true 17M 571 201 superior eq, SAt) 248 receiver 12 H. 121 148 13H 672 rents MH 51 29 H 96 282 penalties 45 H 452 6M 581 e 19 M 132 286 lease lands 56 429 relatn landlord 60 479 159 S 987 guardian mother 67 88 IH 156 title trustee 9H 445 mesne profits 2L 37 use occupation 3TC 61 153 S 267 168 AD 469 94 M 622 presumption 3TC occupancy 101 NY ejectment 105 NY do 13 M s44 49 128S no bar 61 6H 323 305 818 cloud on title 2 4 AD courts 3LRA 69 60 78 nuisance 134 «80 12 190 196 447 62 H 37NY 140 NY do6Tr 457 eq. eonversn 78 H 190 82 H 147 96 NY 71 "income' 45 M 475 per. property f 161 AD 671 146 S 976 461 charge court 48 AD 321 privileged 47 H 60H ibelo us 121 NY libel per se do 138AD laSAD estoppel 135AD 7 540 warranty r 40 .s Y 283 544 jurisdiction 43 415 13 H 463 104 NY 261 263 548contractvoid s 63 252 13 H 173 restriction 172 NY 158 covenant 210 NT 134 556 r r ticket 61 613 28 H 464 56 H 270 proper voueher SONY 650 title 36 £41 replevin 60 AD possession IH estoppel 49 U cond sale 3TC 655 ■ 52 NY 39 U realty 37 M 365 295 206 308 475 intention 2H 120 Jurisdiction 50 H 476 intention fact 83 NY 566 486 citiienship a 26 NY 359 329 203n 371 deed to husband r 32 NY 423 774 688 563 294 waiver po w 75 AD 12.5 381 9H damages 126 AD 30 H 10 M 24 M bar e 184 NY 163S single cause 160 AD judgment 98M contract 142 475 593 674 688 215 271 505 bona fides 43 454 5 1 I better title 132 NY 84 5L 213 5 1 9 advances 95 H 281 47AD 629 verification *M 36 360 5M 666 525 sep. estate 8 22NY 450 534pleadinK d42 41 damages 60 516 counterclaim 655 385 negligence a 32 NY 598 c 46 270 390 creditor suit 32 NY 53 46 549 67 380 395 conclusive 8 41 428 o 41 433 45 611 tender deed 54 NY stop over 68M 560 conting tate 47 12 H 4K 2Ab 562 devise 5LRA 564 in esse 3LRA 516 64': 309 621 37 178 106 699 17 AD 43 H 83 104 AD 2SS bar 41 NY 76 NY 77 NY 83 NY 98 NY 176 NY care patient 2LRA 588n demurrer 16AC 238 stay prcdg. 248 267 236 197 70 116 162 80 197 358 237 569 cotenant conversion ISH 5 83 NY 602 572 censtitutoi 42 562 45 362 title of act 22 AD 306 vacate reference 19 H 390 local ac*- 43 NY 18 578 jurisdiction 62 622 court's power 105 AD 590 2 H .'i28 vacate order 19 H 390 general waiver 66 NY 463 att'ys negligence e 17 M 236 on terms 78M 266 138S 214 174S 161 590 foreclosure 31 636 rolling stock e 47 109 61 61 filing chat mtge 61 AD 356 rolling stosk taxs 52 NY 526 54 NY 321 39 M 563 post pone mtge 136 NY 322 598 affidavit 125 S 475 6 1 9 personalty 590 641 trustees 305 S88 440 447 514 96 VOL. 32. 645 ancMtor's 71 420 £99 661 appeal 36 H jurisdiction 41 H 50 H conclusive 63 NY 464 469 220 108 299 31 47 52 NY 64 NY 636 no title 22 H 109 525 321 406 ABBREVIATIONS: 9 agency 35 467 authority 44 471 34 AD 16S 68 AD 462 IH 329 42 H 538 92 H 398 d3TC .535 27 NY 6.59 58 NY 606 83 NY Sfi application 112 NY 561 estoppel 21 M 290 agent authority 2LRA 8(Wn ratably 3LRA 306 disaffirmance 73 M .m-i ratification 132S 469 25 instructions 52 365 damages 40 H 351 2 Ab 277n 42 right burial 21 H 190 80 H 269 271 214 189 100 328 437 108 183AD 170S 47 tender for closure 13 H enforcement 76 H 109 AD 120 AD 48 jurisdiction 9H 500 5 1 jud't. Co. Ct. 46 H 54 66 H 363 iurisdiction 2LRA 831n 55 law remedy 34 H 163 4 TC 176 injunction 911 636 76 liab'ty of offi. r 41 NY 619 c 38 470 36 NY 206 e 1 Tr 102 79 irregularity 58 560 60 129 83 contract 34 638 order of arrest 36 14 43 412 3H 217 9H 211 22 H 385 5TC 296 71 NY 609 80 NY 412 38 M 189 70M 215 body ejection 126 S 717 enforcement 7JM 456 reversal 141 S 214 92 lien waiver 7 440 5H 454 65 NY 145 175 NY 179 3TC 269 261 2K 72 criticised- I l,„MteH- p ^,„f,'in S™^** ' ^' "J'ft'nBU'shcd: t, followed; r, reversed; m. modified; *. dismissed; n, note; e, criticised. I. lin.ited. e. explained: o. overruled: s. same case: do. dissentinc opinio^.: p. pandWl ease: a. OTeWnwd. N, Y. Sapreme Court Reports — Barbour Vols. 32, 33 2 Ab 144 45 501 46 H 20AC 126n 59 H 1 90 equity suit * L 102 injunction 32 NY 58 42 M 281 49 S3 33 H 90 NY 2L 108 AD ferries 62 M 67 1 94 BD prfmano 44 M 178 25 NY 202 „„, , , 293 defence 408 37 H' 418 consent divesting „„ 111 NY 42 zlM forfeiture 647 145 s 823 484 84 M 154 470 ^5? 374 construction 29 83 AD 41 *%1 title center st. 662 36 NY 125 -5^„ ^^' 381 covenant 410 9n7 .„t »^ 1 296 satisfaetion ^9 NY 672 410 207 not apply ig lyr ccf; 49 g 408 220 NY 91 IfX^^ „„te ^^^ o" eonstr'n 410 „,_ 6AC 14311 "and'' ,„ 217 prem. note 11 AD 433 524 33 6J2 "17 relief notes capital 53M 400 proof breach ^,' .r. 418 77 NY 391 i^/D 408 »H 147 195 possession '. }\^ 19 NY 344 14 H 41 ,„„ 201 sup pro 120 ferries 22 H 110 62 M 41 55 M transcript ev. ■ 22 authority 2LRA 83Jn 105 AD e 2 L 33 H 90 NY jurisdiction 192 NY expense 66M 214 38 , ._ amendment I cb assignment 41 102 pleading 464 67 AD 200 e 99 AD 327 31 H 121 501 6iNY 433 assignee 107 S 222 paper title 396 124 S 78 305 note fraud ?i§ 5^'*i'i**"'" 36 NY 130 BH 177 68 M 403 consideration s2 H °^^ti„n^ 52 NY 14i7M 480 235 complaint 1 Tr 23 616 r 37 NY 136 _ _ 398 negligence „5J„-, , 3l5pun damages a 34 NY" 226 241 mtge possn. 42 H 313 3b 123 66 AD 491 pleading 35 nY 42 NY ITr judges reasons 4TC restoration do 49 NY TC 36NY- objections 04 NY otle vendee 318 36 371 271 em domain 266 61 AD 483 397 45 H 632 judgment wages restriction 94 NY 1 K 2 Ab g22 32 M justification 1 22 AD 331 69 46 300 assignor 46 58 •« " i " payment notice P'^^S"* ™"?, 39 34 H 39 NY 6Tr 1 3 1 review a 63 NY 36 48 60 66 37 NY 39 NY 6Tr 6Tr 139 St Umitats. iIm: Ml |9''&'"'*°"°''238 't/^^ ., . 1S?S '"''^*'""'*' no action ? i} *" ?1* 6S NY 606 614 96 M 585 1 K 332 69M 432 f lei s 911 ejectment l44juryMUs8tios 191NY 318 322 pleading 55 11« 250 construction " *2 35 NY ®Sia26NY 328 2 Ab Al « *1« ^ Ad 483 oonsideratlon 26 H 242 title tovendeeee. 45 42 AD 2H i|U?'-7ei|«-eaning^^ 36 NY iWlr^f" ,85 86H lee i construction ®", ^, ^65 greater oare jQg ^Y 118 ^^^'''"'° fact questions 263 adverse title 0°°™''°° 60 1 15 2 H 4 33 H 76 H 139 4 TO 272 '«»! *>«« 24 NY 446 * ^^ "* "^ 107 NY alAb 131 268 conspiracy „„„ . V " 2 Ab 483 r 35 jjY 520 328 construction change grade ,,, 66 NY 103 IS H -^-.^c 1/1 rescission lateral support fee simple 484 ?? =«, if J 68LRA "''*'"*637n 22 H 42 661 563 intent 46 469 277 misnomer 58 NY 47 282 67 446 failure . 2 L 494 41 AD 660 98 M 1 H 573 52 AD 248 165S 92 H 264 80 AD 5 SS 43 e 87 AD disaffirmance 11 M 3 H 485 26 M 5 LC 592 30 M .damages designation 21 H 301 61 M 381 390 347 boundary 1 TC 33 H 108 183 lOP NS 210 a 33 NY 658 parol extension payment assignee no jurisdiction 67 NY 481 33 H 195 1 CP NS 200 354 accounting delivery fraud notice 35 AD 338 67 NY 2 TC 402 284 usury jurisdiction 23 H 126 75 NY 561 23 H 89 NY 279 72 NY 174 4K 244 290 exemptions 4 Ab 82 52 193 4 L 5H 341 515 9H 44 358 exclus 20H 122 e 98 AD 544 389 presumption 25 H 176 legal title 54 NY retain poas 16AC 436n go defense debt 396 conversion 601 420 em. domain issue a 32 NY 501 699 do 39 NY 416 134 109 NY 550 38 295 limitation 65 386 98 M 700 701 434 estoppel 24 677 165S 134 30 AD 357 449 involved construe statute 218 165S 626 191NY 31' 200 599 432 I?9 63NY bona fides 29 NY H H 398 486 130 s 33 136 564 new hiring 25 NY 183 36 H 276 covenants presumption 46 447 43 H cond. subsequent 50 H 9 H 534 52 H 76 H 46 I ejectment 87 H 32 472 118 NY covenants consent rule 46 447 125 NY due process law _^„ 166 NY 492 568 fence neg. „^ 3K 261 56 H US 50 AD 473gocd title 572oattIe passes g^ g r34NY 264 123 S 912 advances 35 110 114__. 376 services 26 NY 480 nogligence 46 71 AD objections 10 H 2K 1 Ab 269 35 H 443 72 H 119 NY 448 ,„_ . 169 00/ interest 1 v»u 327 s. 35 NY specify defects 46 125 S 252 15 M nonsuit parties 68 M 288 66 AD 13 H diligence 490 bill lading a 24 NY 33 H I4 NY 57 NY d60NY 337 336 - -- 670 220 43 4Ab fraud 4LR 3fi3 509 captl jtock 33 ^?? . 00 XTV 192 48 AD 4 1 use street 34 503 37 297 taxpayer suit 568 65 480 ___ __ 29 H 247 do 42 542 1 TC 106 rescession pre appealable 42 666 57 AD 632 5J a 23 NY 40 elTC 148 667 law remedy 459 4TC 301 em' domain 550 4 TC 16 27 NY 499 39 NY 117 NY 180 fact question 24M 153 412 69 M 33 125 S 742 176 438 204 416 573 158 S 369 ,„ . 60 1 attachment 22 820 347 32 H 142 6S8 604proofoonsidn 518 public pol'y 7 H 149 52 348 order publ'n prom note 14 H 75 36 NY 53 53 H 616 lien realty 522 indorsemnet 213 NY 288 a 33 NY 615 . „ 41 602 6 1 2 discharge mortgage 529 dower « 37 466 a 23 NY 331 28 NY 235 530 damages 181AD 71 76 130 S liability 429 71 M 512 135 37 H "" " 612 39_NY valid contract 207 4^0 jurisdicton 656 a il NY 327 520 149 445 jurisdiction 430 59 H 118 448 ejectment rgt. 32 536 32 638 17 H 638 44 H 52 68 NY 95 97 ___ , , ^ 577 593 debtor 19 20 168S 45 NY 750 09 & IL 138 |1@ breach dam. cinhid ; ll'l'lt'dj. U. ICiritllel i-H.,.' . n, n Vols. 40, 41 N. Y, Supreme Court Reports— Barbour 417 jurisdiction 42 H 138 425 legal title 63 NY 303 sue perfmnce 105 AD 291 433 undertaking IK 484 2 Ab. 254 435 mortgage L30S. 328 328 partition Tl M 2T5 26 H 442 lien r40NY 98 NY 214 NY 647 540 541 teacher's power 34 M contract 78M 49 1H8S 145 not separated lOOM 680 546 negligence VOL. 41 9 cump'd int 65 4 AD 3H i!l H e46 H 4'IC 210 367 270 174 127 l^b -1 42 divested 89 H 212 151 objections 290 m proseou 370 jnri 577 517 3S5 449 certificate 67 H . 289 prima facie ev a 41 NY 25 AD d24M 36 NY 'passenger" iiu AD . 2LRA 3TC 325 373 390 614 57 NY damages 63 NY 70NY altem record 82 NY 87 record evidence 118 NY . 286 writ hab. corpus 186 NY 176 465 f d transfer do 124 NY 255 488 fee simple a41 NV 66 e 52 14 partition deeds^ 216 367 78 28 708 166n possession ;Jli 28 bona fides a 51 JN Y e 1 Tr cBeNY 33 notice Z4 limitation 64 H S7 JnV 112 66^ lao 396 10 4Ab. vesting 116 NY intention 187NY 219 309 177 499 injunction e 74 NY 180 509 morrgage a 25 NY 566 38 AD 566 512 eq. remedy 13 AD 166 fraud repesntns 55 1 Precise prop e2M . 21 limitation 125 S 65 556 incomp ev. a 30 NY 365 6H 183 12 H 181 expert ev. 52 H 327 574 construction s 46 307 e 66 298 proof affidavit 14 AD 90 bonds void 17 H 384 8 67 NY 178 585 parol ev. r 33 NY 97 2 TO 334 826 jurisdiction a 39 NY 506 48 177 633nos8ess. title 47 661 t34 acknowlg i9A0 432n 644 Stat construe 45 sum. proced'g 66 AD 38 H e79H decree 9H toreign exrs 20 H jurisdiction 18 IAD IV IS 50 legacy a34 JNY 16 H 164S, revocation SLitA date of 177AD 654 42 43 248 690 637 312 99 10 H 24 H e38H 9M 15 M 34 M 174 NY 221 118 417 97 618 626 184 293 629 221 376 299 202 42 rebate 44 AD estoppel 61i 94 US assessment 15 H 26 M directory q68NY statute 77 NV 1 62 subscription a dO ^ Y 64 172 amendment 6L 6 presumption 36 H -465 181 ejectment 12 AD 116 mciosure 30 AD 280 8H 269 74 NY 243 improvement 42 AD 353 adv. possession 766 a 41 NY 619 d 61 AD 53 64 e 14 H 463 prima facie ev e 181 NY 7 1 19 AD 439 62 M 121^ 141 S 404 not conclusive 156AD 338 307 fraud 4H 82 H 52 NY 105NY 116 NY 123 NY 2 1. e40H 410 66 163 162 18 384 548 201 79 102U 346 death 840 60 chge. interest 670 217 90 277 235 5 1 3 jurisdiction 122 AD 584 84 647 230 170 262 626 52 1 undue infl 6H preservat on 2TC 7H e34NY agency 2M Stat, frauds 24 M burden proof 127 NY 148 claim vs atty 27 H 302 atty. client 18AC 241n, 247n client atty. rule 152 S 474 537 eq. defense 9H 438 44 H 253 e 34 NY 450 owner 130 S • .327 tenant at will 71 M 276 277 38 M 111 US notice e58NY 65 NY d 117 NY jurisd'ion proof 58 NY 92 distinction 213 NY 464 648 ratification 596 2H 6 1C 26 M 34 NY lien 153 NY trust 5H notice 11 H personalty 102M 168S 92 repeal by im- plication 3 I 8 f'd. transfer a41 NY 619 53AD 606 e llH 267 78 H 499 relief 2TC 513 reconveyance 541 121 123 103 497 322 173 AD 1 86 malice 62 AD 6H 37 H eSSS a4K a3 Ab 17 M renewal 64 194 levy a 39 NY 2L e7H el Ab. 2Ab 54 NY 9H 16 H 38 H 16 M 116 NY per trustee 191NY terminate 166S 48 62 3L IH 8H 69 H ITC 3 TO 4TC 72 NY pledge 49 41 NY measure dam 53 NY 659 default IDH 67 H 242 189 207 254 364 369 731 19 392 471 243 226 469 82 634 ^18 642 471 agmt, 962 154 664 517 407 397 62 717 564 625 603 28 isy •isdirtion U ul5 280 381 earnings 32 AD 510 S6H 92 31 M 177 68 NY 395 90 NY 29 96 NY , 276 obstruction dam lUH 536 385 attestation 61 • 261 13M 4B9 139 AD 24/ limitation 9 AD 347 22AD 622 uumpliance 128 S 1017 396 damage' i4 41NY 165 e42AD 8H 79 H e64NY e 56 NY 100 NY 471 319 412 173 13 105 24 M 73 NY fiduciary 108 NY f 8oM duress 36 H proof fairness 101 AD 62 103 AD 663 exception 58 M SO 165S 774 775 no delictum lOlM 582 not analogous lOlM 586 587 168S 549 illegal 168S 547 333 commiss'rs i4H 74 337 amendment 404cliat.mtge potential exiot 17 H 27H 26H 4SH 114 83 H d49NY 132 NY 16i 144- 598. 232 39- 155 471 ep'l. title 2 TC 652 11 M II* 43 M 367 477 interpleader do 42 612 104 AD 93 48 1 good title 24 H 26 H a3K a3 Ab eq. action 76 NY aid of court 162 AD 290. 390 136 295 368 809 491 surrogate 316 98 directory 7H waiver 88 H 43 M estoppel 70M. 200 surrogate disqualified 27 H 82 65 H 198 1 K 310 a 1 Ab. 341 61 M 677 2 1 I sup. comp'It 43 617 o 64 506 513 e 53 NY 6 revival 296 674 241 40 do 64 injunction h 26H e46H e65H a3K 3 3Ab d 122 NY bar 3 66H 660 164 617 424 76 428 129 228 122 62 325 39 1 396 40 64 33 AD 74 AD 3TC 6Tr 37 NY power court SIM decree 37r-p 409 usury 66 e75NY 143 NY 98 AD 46 M Sep .defense 129AD counterclaim 75 M 135S 417 title 4L proof 96 US 249 515 169 676 600 172 330 272 122 464 609 45 93 562 640 272 81 97 145 420 possession 199 87 75 67 4H 2 I 8 discharge 341 pleading s42 8 AD 40 M duress 2H e3L 7L defense 4H 7H 6-TO 49 NY tender e 167 NY 111 112 488 58 167 231 170 246 487 626 495 revival 6H admissions 30 H . _ H. oral ev 38 CP SOln, knowledgment 19AC 418n 419n- 5 i 5 surrogate d 40 H 368 525 construction 46 502 4 Tr 489 Intent e24H 438 exceptioBB 90 NY . 301 counterclaim d 1 Tr 93- 2 Ab 31& 36 NY 232 life estate 6L 141 541 26 H 29 H LIO AD debt" 663 91 225 r41NY 36 M 23 1 lease a3 Ab 110 517 102 jurisdiction 51 224 93 M 475 158 S 444 109 sep. estate 50 357 6 TC 244 1 1 4 conn vance 9 M 256 1 2 1 certiorari r36NY 218 139 laches M M 202 light parties 60 M 203 269 605 261 e9H recovery 4TC construction 60 M 343 allegation 96 237 trust e63 administrator 41 NY 326 255 warranty r36NY 307 269 remov cause d43 49 NY 285 trustee 38 AD legal title 7L IH 3TC 89 NY 396 220 608 48 326 242 398 i AD 353 agency 138 NY 359 bonus 7 11 usury 152 S 89 M 366master a41NY' SH 70NY 98NY 118NY 180 449 549 certificate 10 399]presumption B726M 597 1 9M 254 573 540 neg. 619 267 93 280 294 333 11 M 435 replevin 60 AD 448 explanation ^^ i,,„„„ ^port 11 H 645 e 76 H 555 17 M 86 36 M 200 receipted bill 116 NY 278 63 644 687 523- 441 authority a 32 NY 119 446 authority a 41 NY 619 52 NY 554 450 undertaking d 25 H 259 a3K 150 aSAb 615 454 parol ev. 82 H 385 allegations 122 NY 367 465 note blank 66 534 64 merits 3H 6TC 33 M affidavit e61 H t 159 S 555 void acts 422 64 283 o78 592 554 40 H ie92H estoppel 177AD 163S 558 wife's nee 595 80 54 702 lO'.implied author II H 47 H 60 NY 166 NY do 165 NY 176 NY other debts do 73 AD 294 323 190 439 442 78 B7- AlUmiiVlATlONS: i c, criticised : 1, limited : affirmed; d, distinguished; f. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, f^^te ». explained ; o, overruled : s, same case ; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case : q, questioner N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Barbour Vols. 41,42, 43 asency V L- 4? e82AD 160, „, . . narent duty I o limitation 6 H 57? 46 e6TC f 178AD 288 164S 967 implied prom* 85 H 29 claim estate 60 M necessities 185AD 173S 561 usury b45 o46 51 NY 44 119 424 23 139 admisaion 47 estoppel 47 48 107 AD 4L 210 218 90 163 267 Z4 new trial ev. decisive 445 571 demurrer a 40 NY 410 599 lex loci 189 NY 260 15 M 570 603 bond .• 45 NY 81 619 eood faith 427 67 fraud 65 vendee 16 H parol 22 H prox. relief 2M cancel lease 46 M contract frd 5LRA 629 fraud 2AB 207 223 363 413 273 699 97 48 661 335 124 302 519 305 142 136 45 SO 67 2H 36 H 82 H 4TC II M 16 M 96 US 3 1 assignee e6L 36 objections 44 74 assumption 8L 2TC 3TC 43 legacy ch'ges on realty 7H 540 13 H 609 20 H 284 30 H 173 66 H 68 I 1 9 injunction 5L 466 5H 207 63 NY . 334 power domain 2LRA 680n use streets 55 M 607 1 25 royalty a 41 NY 363 I 42 inauranca 48 454 1 62 construction ZSSaases^ment H 600 obligatiOQ 55 H 75H 4TC 20 M SOOf 'd. intent a 36 NY 72 169 illegal 11 H 453 614 320 480 32^ 565 13 32 50 limitation r 41 NY 581 o 50 338 elTC I 77 title 47 amendment 51 d5S 5L IH 10 H 3TC conversion 23 M pleading 65 NY executory 5L 1 92 costs e28H 18 M 40 M 114 NY 80 427 92 77 245 629 571 315 84 213 78 152 102 315 14AD 16H «6H bona fides 75 H amendment 4SS 304 possession 22 AU 313 3 1 7 estoppel 60 AD 4L dower e 62 AD 446 decree 13 H 106 AD jurisdiction 2 TO 626 170 86 621 330 602 393 417 116 649 4 AD 45 AD 38 M limitation e35M 426 deposit a4K al Ab 196 620 657 588 40 H do 40 H a2K 137 142 387 635 fraud Stat 56 519 paro gift 36 H 426 648 stipulaiioi 67 i2 9M 370 oral stipulation 497 28 AD 58 recovery .J delivery 305 685 192 657 194 f'd transfer 316 581 320 disoretion 6M 318 324 time 46 H 634 326 instruction 68 NY 291 construction 72 NY 420 558 461 435 strike out i 58 M 363 cond. precped. 68 M 364 44 1 strict prac't. 67 391 e63H 114 d 87 HY 413 107 NY 579 445 reformation s 46 483 6S 181 457 warranty «7 NY 77 46 I recovery 77 H 603 mut. mistake 119AD 93 465 description 42 M 363 554 conversion o 33 H 181 rescession 13 M 579 competent ev. 18 M 224 569 tranafer 33 NY 618 44 281 573 agreement 47 233 transfer title 8H 264 44 NY 601 71 NY 296 297 VOL. 43 9 delivery 25 H surety c40H q41H a 32 NY 27 AD penalty 5Tr 38 NY intention 28 H S5NY 509 310 76 146 266 45' 223 20 M 43 NY 55 NY 303 130 AD 144 88 wife earn'gs 94 US 584 70 review e 48 342 o 6 H 377 evidence eiror 3 TO. 1 99 notice 31 AD pleading 27 M 85 NY 151 353 title ev. 54 36 22 331 91 146 46 457 649 479 S7 22 H 4Tr 23 M 37 NY 42 NY practice d6TC 74 ev. value 121 AD 358 75 limitation 51 10 H 16 H 19 H 26 H 33H 41 H e46H 70 H 5SS 15 M 25 M 203quowarranto r 32 NY 365 4 TC 368 359 title office do 88 AD 436 2 1 5 construction 50 AD trespasser IH 3TC 42 NY seal not nee, e 153 US 570 101 545 516 484 621 211 32 66 22 559 280 79 trespass 74 NY 316 town liability 104 AD 606 87 partners assignment 26 H 79 39 H 101 10 M 961 145 261 43 465 26 eq. lien 75 H 85 NY 175 NY 20AC eq. relief 207 NY waiver e85H 20AC 172S 454 626 179 121 n 422 83 123n 385 578 trust ob8 NY 582 lease a 5 Tr repairs 1»AU 59 I decree 3K 182 76 new security 222XY 409 vendor's lien 172S 385 33 contract 56 AD 197 200 594 exceptions e 50 566 18 M 30 M promise 136 NY 280 384 609 5 possession 54J^Y 280 54NY 286 470fraadlnt sale 46 579 2L 70 7H 237 40 NY 566 express warranty 623 b'dg. house 51 NY 204 keeper e 1 L 487 quan. meruit 115AD 700 extra work 116AD 700 no bar 82M 454 obligation 19SNy 341 39 right buyer 136S 487 356 bona &de 44 168 ommifision effect 22 H 629 title 28 H 238 35 H 619 620 fj^ 'v,*-' mortgagee '•*° " '■ 116AD 476 488 recovery ,„„ 3 82 US 639 368 damages 43 498 482 oartnership 82 H 30 intent e62NY 520 521 d 62 NY 522 623 gen 1. partners 492 7 H hotel lien 189 JMV liability d 175S 468 464 70 619 227 nom. dam. 48 AD 474 102 AD 30U 178AD 457 4M 133 SM 288 230 warranty a 33 NY 571 44 666 255 assumed risk a 42 NY 484 implied promise 95 M 246 374 consideratn r 44 NY 298 59 518 34 496 p esumption • 3 L 343 34 H 9fi 38 1 mortgage ev 49 101 eq. estoppel e 33 H 176 bar 4LRA 205n 313 458 44 jurisdiction 627 widen st. 8H 40 e 89 NY 206 no recovery 2 H 394 153AD 764 8H 415| niandamus 4TC B08|£138S 1039 volut'y pay't. 9 H . 220 ggg ^j^^ strictly purs'd. 89 requests a 40 NY a 54 NY 47 267 note a 34 NY 270 bar 3SS 274 decree a 25 NY 284pracfcc3 528 44 26K 1 105 Sep. estate le4H 195 440 no 390 trustee (46 mortgage 4L do4L 12H 33 H ITC 42 NY 52 NY al Ab 36 H title 7Tr 39 NY 254 3 77 57 376 5 1 1 amendment lyAO 295n 513 discretion 83 Nl 239 5 I 5 alimony 61 AD 98 4 M 383 517 deposit a 2 K 564 a 2 Ab 403 35 H e43H 81 NY 409 326 330 408 536 489 525 94 259 512 52 1 protection 19 H 270 72 NY practice f32H parol evidence 3L 70 404 allegations IS AD 239 27 AD 314 4 I I lien e25 M altern judg't *? M 367 sheriff deed 96 221 dater bacU 63 572 197 114 72 M 131 S 48 contract 7L 35 H 75 NY 77 NY exceptions 10 Et interdiction 68 M invalid 123 S power city 149AD 133 S 278 60 17 210 74 135 532 lf« 813 54 mob damage 614 64 1 wife powers 49 322 57 construction 59 126 NY slander 4L e27H 8H assault 19 H 122 524 bond 89 H 533 income a 36 NY 15 55 H 506 508 commisn- ejctmt a 20 H 473 46 3 K e3Tr 11 d3Tr 3Tr 508 a 1 Ab 42 1 Ab e36NY taxation 47H el34 NY special term 63 construction 50 AD 155 156 423 27 317 360 646 waiver ■ 18 H 426 promise paymt. 20 H 164 543 inducement 179AD 166S 885 exact words 179AD 605 166S 886 651 ,r 55 NY 604 e 64 AD estoppel 6H 26 M 662 445 281 282 284 306 24 6n 664 391 343 295 58 set-off 66 137 10 H 53 NY 345 620 234 243 compromise 18 253 254 72 312 64 will power 655 bar 549 u.surpation 51 270 o 45 300 award evidence 46 30''!64 546 judicial 8 H 402 65 AD 482 3(1H .595 a 33 NY 42 H e57 H e92 N Y 9 8 surety 6 AD 386 33 17 302 609 102 limit, liability 666 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; », dismissed; n, note; criticised ; 1, limited ; e, explained ; o, overruled ; •, lame '^ase ; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, queitioned Vols. 43, 44 N. y. Supreme Court Reports— Barbour Sl Sl NY 1 1 6 affidavit 4K ' 69 3 Ab 487 20 M 349 21 M 93 479 1 1 7 surety int m 43 NY 244 124 St. frauds 65 412 1 TC 141 6 TC 442 79 NY 134 131 eq. relief a 42 NY 549 1 47 widow 24 H . 18 next of kin 40 NY 25S e 67 NY 390 69 NY e 95 NY 26 161 NY 10 148 next of Icin S7fi 521 1 62 servant 49 299 eeeretary e 5 Tr 78 e 37 NY 644 e 67 NY 647 e 68 NY 367 partners 11 H 609 stockholder 23 H 344 1 68 certiorari a 38 NY 461 1 72 power sell o 66 451 trust title 81 AD 499 88 NY 477 1 87 attachment , a 42 NY 132 59 624 198 intention 4 TC 362 203 cumul ev. 48 H 65 16 M 124 214 money had 7 AD 69 limitations 6L 99 7 H 219 330 65 H 20 68 NY . . 87 suspn. limitn. 16 AC 303n 225 presumption a 41 NY 620 2 AD 296 o 2 L 204 17 AC 437n, 17 AC 438-H 16 M 371 e 33 M 468 f 33 M 470 75 NY 14S neglieence ev. 87 H 546 e9M 187 18S 46 M 422 jud notice 5 TC 270 41 NY 398 iZ H 181 jharse error 3H 169 232 mandamus a 34 NY 616 49 607 discretion 6L 146 certiorari 3H 549 20 H 461 e 25 H 135 6 TC 610 6Tr 123 39 NY 88 131 NY 471 153 NY 376 239 bonds 43 300 64 NY. 626 taxation 7L, 366 5H 73 8H 67 33 H 137 266 costs 63 304 q27H 113 274 St. frauds 27 H 420 70 H 680 severable 42 H 578 do 3 SA 632 16 M 456 282 pier damage 8H 391 nuisance 117AD 588 19AC 894 292 incomp wit 47 423 5 Tr 200 Sl NY 47 298 mandamus 49 607 305 prec'd debt. 49 546 title assicnor "H 664 parol evidence e 69 H 190 agency 6i, 416 78 H 85 SONY 40S( 65 NY 21 authority B50NY 407 damages 18 AD 578 do 162 NY 300 do 162 NY 3uz fact question 24 AD 246 authority e 4 L 437 e 60 NY 407 373 indemnity e 11 H 870 nulla bona 17 H 61 p 42 H 126 62 H S13 379 bona fidea 71. 4 42 NY 442 61 NY 604 62 NY 143 395 inventory 44 197 d 43 H 232 130 N y 8«J pcedules 2LliA 32Sn 310 title 2M 12 M 403 628 311 no appeal 137S 1100 3 1 5 estoppel 14 H 463 33 H 419 waive, ctrclm- 18AC 121 323 fise. impris. 76 US 282 337 dismissal 8H 232 340 surrender 16 M 656 19 M 17 344 damages 26 H 576 351 waiver 57 621 61 346 5 L 277 649 2 H 361 371 9H 423 2 TC 633 4 TC 603 505 79 US 304 estoppel 10 H 400 57 NY 606 verbal contract 5-H c 16 H 331 88 H 248 400 compromise vei dice a 41 NY 620 22 AD 678 fraud intent 13 H 621 22 U 399 Presumption 91 H 270 conclusive facts 16 M 633 19 M 270 22 M 436 60s uew trial 15 H . 493 verdict objection 106AD , 348 assumption 143 AD 645 411 inj. property e45M 213 arrest 16AC 11 assumption 128S an 4 1 2 surrogate 80 AD 523 e 92 NY 76 authority 76M ICl 435 estoppel 4 AD 420 47 AD 248 partnership 7H 427 40 U 346 444 consideratn 9 AD 328 discharge 64 NY 467 448 f'd transfer 68 636 67 382 5L 187 14 H 278 20 M 72 88 NY 422 gen'l. exception 36 H 74 461 contempt l6*AD 498 49 AD 44 72 H 635 eKLKA 529n subrogation 6SLKA 534n 469 damages a 40 NY 69 18 H 267 nominal H9 NY 204 479 insur. int. e 6 SS 244 U2NY , 67 490 mob dam 46 662 664 lib. construction 50 AD 165 493 damages 26 H 123 494 review 89 H 611 e 91 NY 603 504 stockholder e 62 668 app'tm't receiver 67 446 e61 4L 481 SONY 604 505 stkhldr. rem 2LJiA 56UD 509 assignment power of partnr e 11 H 401 39 H 101 do 39 H 104 47 H 328 95NY 588 5 1 4 contract 67 406 sub-lease e 61 NY 391 529 brokerage 3 H 164 authority 5 TO 366 defect title 2 Tr. 58 e 16 M 386 36 NY 685 532 contrib. neg. 66 67 nom. damages 49 H 638 offsets SONY 417 539 certiorari 48 176 o48 132 D 53 234 61 284 284 55 AD 548 6L 107 e9H 619 16 H 402 e38H 40 H 239 65 H 411 e 5 Tr 228 q37NY -515 assessors duty 83 H 377 5 Tr 360 38 NY 92 judicial acts 6L 292 - 31 H 423 amendment e 7 M 300 569 assault e 116 US 604 577 accord 67 373 1 TC 65a 69 NY' 326 fraudulent e 41 M 629 602 contract 55 a 696 presumption 133AD 473 607 chat mtge. 60 132 notice 1 L 279 280 bar e4L 76 3 TC 326 72 NY 138 119 NY 627 611 title SAD 82 H a 33 NY a70 A» 161 673 620 408 6 1 6 revivor 64 613 e63 NY 160 6 1 8 presumption 47 90 62 H 104 e 19 M 90 79 NY 42 137 NY 160 622 evidence d 44 42 49 101 illeg considerat'n 4 H 170 6 TC 478 e 60 NY 160 172 NY 310 625meD. capac. a 33 NY 619 624 VOL 44 9 damage a 44 NY 104 1 4 lien r44NY 50 31 inn keeper r 46 NY 266 39 discovery 20 H 518 37 H 287 84 H 162 42 consideration failure 49 101 4 AD 267 14 H 216 3 TC 250 60 NY 160 46 reviews a41 H assessment 106M 697 175S 212 parks, etc, 106M 587 176S 218 634 fraud do 42 NY 429 645 sale stock 14 H 289 611 54 damages 52 43 55 287 warranty 6L 206 r 1 K 476 r 3 Ab 375 69 default 49 H e31 M 247 89 75 contract e70NY 8 1 certificate 21 AD 243 616 500 87 estoppel lOH bona fide 2K 380 3K 171 2 Ab 297 defense waived 152 S 574 89 M 542 96 intention 65 NY 27 98 construction 19M 42 M I I 6 defense 26 AD 120 objections d46 322 omit stamp 48 trespass d4H damages 48 H d2TC d6TC conclusion 75 NY proof 27 M 546 partition 22 H 269 550 gov't tax 44 AD 240 65 AD 647 do 65 AD 548. 119 NY 518 1 62 St. frauds e 2 L 282 dl6H 160- 72 H 461 2 TC 706. unenforcible f 98 M 346 I 66 presumption 47 94 fraud proof 25 AD 163 60 AD 28 a 79 NY 43 97NY 623 conclusion law 69 H 56 138 AD 902 pleading 131 AD 4 estoppel 1.'54 S 824 actual notice 169 AD 15T I 70 master ev. 123 AD 219' .intent evidence 48 M 31© e 41 M 327 intent immatrl. c 150AD 11? conviction 156 AT) 461 d 134S 6C1 142 S 40 1 73 guardian 92 H 241 I 75 pleading 11 AD 45 AD 3H 22 M 38 M 66 NY 90 NY 162 NY 170 NY credit holds 18 H 418 controverted 131 AD 23ff- I 80 demurrer r 33 NY 291 39S 18 28fi 100- 170 296 210 114 428 167 I 92 f'd. transfer e31 H 283 ,— 60 H 266- 697 80 H 63 478 inventory 13o NY 579- exam. assignee 179 36 H 138- mistake 54 H 467 198 v'd.marriage- 196 16 AC 310n 264 2r6 tnfe oral cnt 5LEA 325tt 401 246 528 154 207 eq. title SLRA 200 138 sp. perf'ce, SL 251 redemption e 5 L 69 parol evidence 7L 51 186 NY 548 eq. owner 12 H 408 1 48 mandamus 331 209 bond breach. 9H 469 36 H 610- 2 1 8 estoppel 12 H 320 232 priority 127 NY 627 239 eq. title (1 63 38. Corp. valid 81 H 254- ABBREVIATIONS: c. criticised ; 1. limited ; t, affirmed; d, distinguished; f. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, noic e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do. dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; o. questioned. N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Barbour Vols, 44, 45 25 1 f'd. transfer 3fiH 187 258 refilinc 2H 40 H 5 TO 34 M r44NY conatructioD 33 H 451 328 29 189 244 249 e27H 370 dower S6 28 268 tiusb. and trustee a 51 NY 8 ( 44 274 mfe prefroe 44 NY 302 271 huab. wife 258 374 aep estate a 44 NY 343 67 667 husb. as agent 3 Tr 274 83 US 31 36 NY 604 385 negligenee a 41 HY 469 authority 6L 605 2 TC 567 67 NY 393 472 estrays r35NY a 51 NY f 44NY 282 relig. 4H temporalties 3TC fiTC 3 1 2 notir-e 112 AD e2TC 626 302 corp 226 406 128 619 168 518 509 49 657 514 3 1 6 sureties 3 AD 271 13 M 494 32 1 extension m 37 NY 444 24 AD 329 bonus affect. 7H 2S4 327 conclusive 34 H 351 336 security SH 374 66 H 295 princ. surety 5LEA 278n 344 statutory £ 145 S 390 345 comp'l pay't 5LRA 278n 347 discharge 60 344 45 H S3 50 H 544 353 action lies d 75M 648 354 presumption 134 625 552 14 AD 51 NY 61 NY 75 NY distinction 104 NY 84 H com. law duty 2 SS 596 neg. corpor'n 104 NY 557 ministerial 54 AD 82 41 H 9i2 e 50 H 94 94 NY 30 St. care liab 5LEA 302 489 mut. acctg. 6H 81 dmissn. debt 38 OP 501 acknow,gDt. 19A0 417n 430n 494 compliance 89 M 643 154 S 242 498 r.r. bonds a 51 NY 27 10 H 297 fraud 40 NY 665 505 conversion r48NY 6 60 1 consid'ratioD 106 AD 404 606 mortgage 75 AD 551 12 H 408 618 Sun. cont. 77M 191 136S 92 not illegal 77M 192 liberal constctn 136S 92 636 harml error 33 H e4SS 35 NY 263n 396 foreclosure a 44 NY 39S 403 f'd. transfer r 41 NY 159 406 damages 56 412 66 H 251 4 Tr 380 37 NY 104 409ex!i'i. contrt. 123 S 373 equitable lien 138AD .565 potential exist. 128S 213 71M 130 legal title T2M 130 S 4H 79 H 164 NY delivery 24 H 6 TO title 114 NY mistake 25 H notice 26 H 384 604 573 577 363 countrolaim pleading 60 AD 372 33 H 192 8M 225 75 NY 615 366 contrao- 59 506 act construct 62 634 537 wife's rights e4L 4L 7L 8H 19 H d20H 167 423 26 34 317 366 473 52 1 usury 152 S 89 M 573 540 528 amendment 51 627 536 warranty 4H 231 9M 464 41 NY 491 541 declarations 47 6Tr 21 M discharge 37 NY demand 82 NY guaranty 83 NY 602 324 630 604 131 346 300 585 60 641 accord 67 7L 4H 5H d21H 66 H 6TC surety dSOH 72 H 19 M merger 6M discharge 7M 98 NY joinder 14 H consideration e2L 52 5L 10 22 H 447 82 H 149 148 S 447 655 warranty a 44 NY 94 395 74 248 140 162 172 605 366 613 176 79 320 52 420 check a 1 L . a 54 NY assignable 172S 451 563 290 424 fire neglig. q a H 324 51 NY 487 negligence proof 22NY 547 contract ■ r 44 NY 126 46 293 13 H 302 554 wght of ev. 71 H 618 conclusive 10 M 657 declaration 3 Tr 276 36 NY 606 liability 201NY 428 conversion 123 315 r48NY 53 66 2L 434 report r42NY 447 waste e 18 H 156 waste ootenant 193 NY 202 662 262 667 219 155 456 waiver 9M a 44 NY 459 objections sale realty 16 M 44 206 467 certiorari £L 364 560 power sale a 36 NY 49 50 H intentions lOlM 167S 617 132 268 345 1019 56 1 alienation 7 AD 439 577 loss services 47 5L e23H 54 H 3TC 50 459 72 588 693 29S fact question 130 NY . 248 excessive int. 57 12 596 obstructions 64 359 22 H 57 22 M 378 public highway 33 H 609 e 49 H 297 139 S construction 121 NY 430 469 VOL 45. 476 693 594 437 576 9 gilt 47 AD interest 65 AD 55 H 60 H evidence 114 AD 416 change name 197NY 428 "full name'' 69 M 51 124 S 994 34 not apply e 156 S 818 156 S 818 35 relevant 178AD 676 165S 813 37 guaranty 1 1 H 612 invalid 4TC 76 40 int. damage 27 H 396 58 chartering a 44 NY 415 e 107 NY 218 63 delegation 77 US 62 69 dower 20 AD 4L a4K a3Ab 69 396 404 526 220 73 em. domain 61 AD 482 86 probate a 1 L 166 95 incomp. ev. 44 H 229 98 misconduct 88 AD 294 40 H 574 122 NY 35 nonpayment f 97 M 161 160 S 865 i 38 injunction 62 636 5L 466 1 50 assessment 54 NY 188 152 sureties 33 AD 279 60 AD 134 1 56 f'd. repsntns e 93 US 95 conclusive 147 US 70 stop payment t 167 AD 116 1 64 certiorari 5L 354 damages 202NY 41 ?58 license dJt95AD 262 legal right 86 NY 329 269 canal boat 49 3H 13 H e5TC ISS e71NY statute 97 NY lien 127 NY insurance 21 M corporation 21 M 178 pleading IAD 10 AD 53 H justifies 113 AD 1 82 comp'd. int 428 83 133 883 480 530 62 79 138 72 66 161 437 458 539 254 409 4 477 48 323 511 77 235 1078 27 AD 43 AD 134S affidavits 28 H 3M 13 M 81 M 129S 142 8 ev. jurors 5LRA 525n incompetent ev, 72 M 106 cause reversal 74M 532 I I I insurance e 89 H 331 I 19 new trial 56 H 218 121 amendment 66 243 presumption fiL 500 1 24 presumption 29 AD 235 554 50 2H 5H 32 H 5TC life tenant 18 H trustees 92 NY e95NY executors e35 AD 27 H e78NY 135AD extra fees 123A-D 194 irregular 93 NY 97 amendment 55 M 95 M 103 133AD 157 AD 142 S 160 S 197 district atty 134 NY 20 1 quowarranto a 33 NY 688 53 16 208 legis. power 20 M 35 M 37 M 7oM f 83 M 165 NY 127 jury list e 103 AD 250 733 456 4.52 460 390 93 128 inference d 131 S 34? presumption d 72 M 468 136 mandamus 312 104 861 376 248 190 a 35 NY 3TC 8M 49 NY available ISO NY act. pending 37 Ci" 38 CP 388 66 243 14 517 406 289 390 2 1 4 parol ev, 58 193 surety 4L 197 25 H 169 e 30 H 268 64 NY 234 opinion evidence e 31 U 448 2 1 8 r 44 NY 305 226r36NY 362 231 liability 82 M f 144 S 96 254 S4g 633 618 577 417 478 211 289 764 274 Uen liab. a 48 NY 132 IL 136 e 124 NY 267 telegraph limit liability 4LRA alln 299 custom r 44 NY 465 304 notice 1 L 238 246 possession IL 49 H ITC 22 M e60NY jurisdiction 27 M contract 57M sum-pro- 129 AD 24S 348 336 598 225 726 562 497 307 mtge lien 7H 26 H 51 H SONY 144 NY not ice 112 AD 628 647 169 351 112 40S 3 1 7 assignment 24 H 6Tr 39 NY 67 NY prior lien 99 NY 127 327 200 642 204 327 jurisdiction r 51 NY 640 22 AD 243 6L 76 334 as executor 175 AD 623 162 S 529 340 lex loci 65 88 M 152 S usurious IH 13 H 4TC e77NY e81 NY 271 501 151 282 174 682 405 407 184 580 571 344 no powers f 160 AD 371 354 discharge 37 H 60S note for debt 16AC 146n 356 wast« 35 H 357 consohdation 51 H 110 359 leg, power a2 K 3S7 ABBREVIATIONS: a, afSrmed; d. distinguished; t. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed' n, nota^ c. criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; •, ume case; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q, questimiei Vols. 45, 46 N. T. Supreme Court Reports— Barbour al Ab 382 surplus 75 4 AD 323 6H 42fi suppport 159 AD 430 384 real party 67 fiUI 3TC 3K 18 H 102 ooDStruotiOD 84 AD 43! T3NY 150 390 jurisdiction U fil5 33 AD 2HS merits defendaDt 3H R4 5 TO 2R3 judgment 50 M 6U' 397 certiBcate 64 422 407 injunction 26 H 205 422 wife powr. S5 419 excess, interest 57 12 discretion 2H 4TC 125 AD conspiracy d 130 NY . join right sue 153 676 ■20 353 110 AD personal dTSM Terdict diriSS 793 injury omission 160 S 580 490 conclusive 6H 617 burden proof 59 H 120 account stated S5TC 4H ITr 3K 1 Ab 494 excise a 36 NY al Tr 499 title r51NY 47 19 H 22 H 502 carrier 47 NY preference 76 NY 714 107 286 335 S26 641 650 414 485 313 63 NY 91 NY 116 NY discretion 40 H findings 92 E 304 411 254 138 105 444 340 506 meas. dam 11^ AD 753 510 dividends d 45 632 r 50 520 9M 593 e 57 NY 206 517 limitation c 50 538 117 demand e 41 NY 596 698 524 bounties _.„'a48NY 438 demurrer «.41NY 619 SK 108 code evidence 12 H 20H destroy \yill 61 M ICP NS 448 will 51 handwrilinc 73 M attestation ILEA 261 469 162n 464 reversion 50 AD 126 473 mandamus a3K s3Ab 28 M f 87 M 1 150 S 81 502 744 609 17 476 collateral 7H 280 check loan 12 H 541 note for debt 16AC 147n 478 fraud refor- mation 55 $1 3H 20 H 30 H e79H 2 TO 5TC 71 NY 77 NY e87NY 181 376 138 113 400 517 72 415 428 159 231 47 mistake reform 540 418 309 339 47 332 578 554 tender dSL 9H 9M 61 NY 82 NY 560 pledge 49 200 470 3* AD 531 574 premium on gold 45 631 56 388 82 H 115 re-exchange 203 NY 96 579 legal tender 49 19 H 27 H 52 H 75 H 6M 16 M 99M 114 NY 96 US S 341 278 408 272 389 321 436 278 207 587 246 SLRA 585 review e2 K 96 judgt. crdr. 19AC lS3n 602 security 15 H 518 607 land liab mtg SLRA 281n 608 eqiuty int. SLHA 283d 610 pr'fmance 61 655 6 1 8 debt r76US 49 prem. on gold 56 388 money not gold 17 H 11 644 mandamus 65 AD 547 do 55 AD 548 119 NY 518 563 service a 4^ NY 514 waive notice 103 AD 37S l.'i7n'l3AD 640 30 entries books 6 H 103 116 witness party 17 H 472 33 indictment H venue 4TC 37 parol ev. 61 restriction 64 accord 67 VOL. 46 9 competent ev. 72 AD 66 assign « 6 AD 12 9M 12a 16 fls. imprism t e 116 NY 401 pleading 113 AD 80fl statute rule 111 AD 785 liability 137S 1092 assault 153 AD 220 warrant 172 AD 73K 159 S 570 1 9 bona fides ISH 418 23 H 324 21 excess a 60 NY 49 f46 25 83 NY 513 304 77 663 608 395 a 48 NY 9H stranger 31 H 70 NY assignee 151 N^^ delivery 156 AD 134S delivery 76M benefit 151AD 135S 1 27 evidence e25H character TC 108 NY 192 NY 43 attachment 64 H affidavits 14 H lienor 42 M party 37 NY 3rd person 75 NY 85 NY receiver e89NY 737 382 21 625 182 244 441 I 39 wrong doer 67 56 wilful torts 160 S 665 1 43 trust d 46 563 554 security 45 bill lading a 4s NY 49 counterclaim d 1 L 62 125 S 247 indep. claim d 68 M ■ 59i corpn. liable 98 AD 56 lien a 48 NY 8 AD 234 27 568 59 ot equity 52 668 18 H 18 neg. pleading 8M 658 80 NY 606 61 suspn. power e43 68 intent 18 H 55 H 81 NY 83 NY survivors 82 H per capita 42M 70 NY 81 NY 506 412 59 284 513 474 232 517 284 48 assignment 9H 585 expectancy 72 H 465 a3K 620 executory e 14 H 478 107 NY 192 92 nuisance e 81 H t 93 M 93 M damages 126S 103 carrittr r44NY 411 231 238 208 notice 77 H 266 2 1 1 notice 7L 9H 61 H 64 NY 79 NY 114 NY 49 H 3 495 21 83 43 533 606 512 64 66 H 359 219 325 residence 505 1 09 reservation 173 534 252 .'!12 161 394 978 363 grantor 120 395 a42 NY' 227 tender 2 Tr e 25 M 36 NY 93 US 55 429 302 437 230 7 L burden proof 142 S 235 note 41 AD estoppel 46 H 16 H 54 H 75 H 171 476 620 creditor's bill 68 H 272 76 H 520 151 fact question 54 H 527 1 58 declarations 47 423 IL 15 49 H 511 18 M 319 1 64 usury 10 H 74 167 payment a 54 NY 114 6L 148 9H 8 19 H 698 pt. pay't demand 91 NY 209 1 73 ejectment d 3 L 264 92 H 91 12 M 121 1 77 a 39 NY 325 1 83 conversion 5TC ^2 \ 88 conversion 66 AD 436 38 M 214 198 construction 7H 207 8H 470 e 67 NY 390 313 damages val. consid'n ISS elTr 36 M e36NY 59 NY do 79 NY o 135 NY title 34 H 76 NY may protect 123 S 361 218 forbearance 562 233 355 130 649 28 46 527 694 438 38 61 402 325 452 169 204 252 242 fixtures r 48 NY 278 6Tr 127 40 NY 293 254 mandamus 13 AD 37 e 3 L 407 5M 43 d 124 S 771 discretion 124 S 772 certif. deposit d 67M 532 259 discretiony. 67M 534 264 neg father 336 no juriBdtn. 70M 287 void 128S 606 340 constitut'l r 35 NY 449 IL 205 percentage 113 irsr 318 361 surplusage IAD e2 AD 141 NY reversion 50NY description 70 AD 134 NY vests' title 127S 142AD 375 prem, note 6 AD e34M 34 M 44 NY 272 usury a 41 NY r63 64 14 H indemmty 6H 209 595 696 459 303 350 626 415 642 260 54 278 notice 32 H absolute title 43 H crops grantee 135 NY 391 wine plants 20AC 107n 291 ev wife 6Tr 2 Ab 239 363 294 town powers a67NY 6L e7L 6H elTC S57NY 177 273 470 487 223 178 73 H 87 a 80 NY 99 342 234 333 notice 29 H oath officers 44M 71 NY waiver 88 NY e60H 12 M highway 111 AD stct. compliance 153AD 344 137S 1077 218 196 313 546 231 136 782 25 676 364 305 100 438 168 363 2 L 379 altera qlH q27H 3TC 10 M abatement 4H 6TC 303 506 349 637 361 49 240 389 foreclosure r 42 NY 334 400 trustee of title e4L do4L IH 12 H memoranda H 114 NY SONY 326 330 349 408 349 284 392 i 1 2 ins. policy J 48 NY 34 423 false return 56 NY 300 432 stockholders 105 US 157 439 possession 57 154 64 AD 7 do 48 NY 276 presumption d51 63 41 H 48 NY 59 NY 16 96 100 141 268 SO 470 construction 3 L 367 386 j bequest corp. '2 AD 27 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d. distinguished; f. followed; r, reversed; m. modified; *, dismissed; n. no«: c.criticsed: 1. limited; e. explained: o, overruled; s. same case; do. dissenting opikion; p. parallel case: q^questioned N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Barbour Vols, 46, 47 Btat. limitation 33 AD 507 intent 24 H '438 restriction 2 SS 556 d 107 US 177 9 4 Tr 485 499 in 2 Ab 319 323 22 M 173 corn, gift 2LBA 388n 507 bountv a 48 NY 386 e 1 H 424 e 3 TO 591 trustee 37 M 496 aasignment 169 NY 180 514 assignee 91 NY 31 518 surplusage 5L 368 general denial 17 H 125 43 H 146 171 NY ISl 143 AD 870 show no title 128S 909 540 cdr. bill 57 44 interest e 59 332 559 ne f -seat 4L 185 56 1 nusance 63 64 9 AD 15 AD IL Be7H 3TC 3SS 26 M 119 NY 257 358 51 346 65 293 287 494 54 238 ev boundaries 64 358 remedy 136AD 704, 705 570 accounting 22 H 421 confidence ^ 78M 179 137S 873 579 interest 51 H 79 588 m andam f 46 599 604 negligence 19 H 200 609 dower 45 H 419 a 2 K 568 a 3 Ab 407 6 1 5 limitation 17 AD 697 jurisdiction 18 H 482 6 I 6 contract 2H 694 5 TC 146 622 construction a 48 NY 57 ell AD 215 e 61 AD 22 abandonment 47 H 359 56 H 291 625 incomp. ev. 16 H 355 harmiese error 33 H 300 discretion 38 H 216 charge o 42 «Y 8 justification 93 US 479 17 AC 184n inadmissible 161 S 608 642 insurance r 44 NY 437 659 nuisance a 36 NY 297 118 e 83 NY 189 license 63 259 mob 60 AD 155 24 H 160 65 H 544 e 83 NY 289 G6I subst. right 137S 1100 VOL.47 26 discretion 42 AD 506 82 H 434 29 bona fides 74 NY 695 36 authority 69M 165 47 seduction 23 H 74 loss service e 54 H 693 130 NY 248 64 police power 98 NY 109 boards health 19 M 492 justification 40 NY 10 abate nuisance 136AD 201 hardships lOlM 222 167S 12 protection lOlM 167S 220 11 69 public nuisance 158 S 979 72 intention lOlM 345 167S 1019 9 I redemption eo L 59 e 8 H 377 22 H 629 26 H 638 29 H 403 61 H 4^2 e 138 NY 143 173 NY 346 costs 26 H 642 61 H 444 vested reward 29 H 438 agreement 79 NY 42 104 foreclosure r 64 NY 314 I I 6 notice 2H 5TC 550 97 120 alienation a 67 645 86 AD 161 39 H 41 79 H 613 88 H 543 1 27 p^ror court 67M 116 1 3 I error ev. q 1 H 436 q 3 TC 627 d 5 TC 681 64 NY 370 do 64 NY 376 1 35 construction a 38 NY 410 1 39agent liable 95 M 15 1 52 carrier 3L 204 6L 483 4H 380 rtS H GOl 6 TC 663 665 e 49 NY 622 insurance 5L 483 155 wife 6 TC 442 1 59 note 78 NY 526 1 63 ejectment 9 AD 24 31 H 388 license 40 H 586 172 restraint a 36 NY 572 2L 345 mutual do 172 NY 301 1 79 privies ev 48 81 d48 83 bond title 50 NY 387 79NY 43 187 omission stamp 60 304 53 383 55 424 57 428 494 196 excess, dam a 48 NY 655 2 AD 60 e 35 AD 49 e 8 H 289 11 H 626 e 48 H 302 6 TC 412 n 69 NY 470 no power 221NY 146 206 imitation 3L 27 31M 48 estoppel 56 H 486 31 M 48 75M 531 stct'coustctn. 62 M 172 rejection 130 S 401 not final 146 AD 62 reference claim 135S 805 2 1 2 parol ev 147 NY 472 225 prepond ev, 129 AD 517 proof claim 113 S 992 235 malice 44 H 284 243 executory contract 5 L 316 318 247 carrier r 44 NY 478 253 delivery mtg. a 36 NY 44 e 43 H 140 security 3LK,A 786d 257 trust limit e 74 H 429 e 127 NY 641 invalid SOM 16 141 S 704 263 ch'ge legacy 7 L 366 IH 561 7H 121 13 H 609 23 H 433 27 H 337 e29H 30 H 46 H 47 H 17C 3TC 4TC eS5NY 100 N\ 18 M 197 172 656 251 269 209 82 149 196 147 2 Ab 363 89 NY 391 jll4NY 46 428 discharge ' „„ 10 M 678 582 scientw trademark |r 51 NY 108 ILKANS 725n53 141 legal 151 NY 116 55 M 86'd 72 NY 613 276 rescission 6 2 1.- 496 - 42 H 3U1 do 42 H 304 42 H 306 49 NY 172 174 84 NY 409 287 boundary 3H 351 63 H 266 5 TC 402 493 44 NY 696 304 injunction 4 U 742 43 H 603 8H 270 jurisdiction 63 NY 231 3 1 1 boundaries ft, 379 317 partnership OL 142 8H 666 76 NY 58 40 M 593 320 acistn vs. judge IH 265 certiorari H 528 83 H 377 4TC 4 48 NY 112 reduce assessna't 7M 301 327esrtiorari e 48 AD 609 a 1 AB 441 442 329 assessment 34 M 272 335 Stat, frauds a 48 NY 348 338 search ev. 16AC 153n, 155n 16AC 150 367 limitation 125S 6' 370 gift T3 M 175 6H 110 149 S _ 23 renunciation 40 H 96 55 H 189 70 NY 217 transfer l.'i2S 476 388 retention 93 NY b66 right search 49 M 24 395 pledge 90 NY 448 404 evidence 2M 246 41 i contract 48 NY 301 419 incomp ev. 5 Tr 239 439 mortgage a 48 NY 253 447 construction 50 AD 165 e 24 H 664 452 collateral 105M 394 d 174S 198 455 trademark a48 Nl 374 68 AD 139 128US 621 164S 437 rule damage 199 NY 252 injunction 177AD 560 484 damages 52 427 3TC 18 497 exemption 57 AD 20 50 I bond ev. r 48 NY 313 503 assault 27H 595 505 delivery 71 AD 407 409 f 53 H 176 33 M 356 parol evidence 79 H 626 5 I 5 damages a 37 NY 287 52 I contract 55 H 596 43 M 556 523 objections 3TC 13 525 estoppel 67 M 133 530 objections 12 H 140 damages e 50 H 80 _ 1 TC 332 23 M 581 549com law L 343 statute frauds e 6 H 288 e 9 H 348 116 NY 141 oral promise 5LRA 632 presumption 206NY 201 damages do 163 S 1049 550 dividends f 147 S 107 624 rents a 37 NY 629 arrest 50 joinder 4L damage- 14 H 153 634 contract a 5 Tr OS a 4 Ab 260 642 duties r3K 8 3 Ab 557 lien 25 M 3 562estray . 19A0 368n 574 rescission 6H 473 12 M 139| recoupment 586 void 65 343 jl AD 576 presumption 6H l:;3 592 recapture 2LRA 623n 599 trustees a 61 NY 646 a 23 H 127 possession 87 NY 364 50 M 440 powers in trust 125 NY- 469 title 159 NY 103 618 lien proof 25 AD 496 79 NY 152 default 23 H 427 surplua 57 H 195 3 SA 416 26 M 451 36 M 353 79 NY 152 526 452 222 374 539 646 presumption a 40 NY 314 IH 278 title 19 H 414 3TC 75 aBBKEVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d. distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, moi'ifled; *, dismissed; n, not* criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, dissenting opinion,^ p, parallel case; q. questioned Vols. 48, 49 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Barbour 41 VOL. 48 9 conclusive 61 legis power 57 AD 173 S8AD 699 appl. incomp. ev. 40H 591 12 conclusion 61 41 error principle 18 AD 196 72 AD 398 f 7 harmless ev a 35 NY 125 6H 499 presumption 12 H 3ti0 discretion 60 H 467 . 27 attachment 9H 209 carrier neg. 20 H 67 H 3SA 6 125 NY 22 471 280 162 106 exemp dam 4H 179 6T C 409 I 1 6 afSdavit e7H 385 f 20 ejectment a 44 NY 666 1 32 removal cause r 45 NY 260 IH 703 e 1 H 707 4 TC 197 e 4 TO 200 vol. appearance 28 M 671 98 M 381 162 S 1077 1 42 bond 44 NY 428 supplies nee. 51 NY 461 1 46 examn. 67 oO prob. cause ■ 68 SAD 34 AD 38 AD 110 AD 2H eSQH 3TC 4TC do 62 NY iustiUcation 84 AD 19 20 H 466 51 jurisdiction a 51 NY 12 4L 163 exemption roll 431 334 320 55 461 443 211 319 264 266 443 26 134 NY 149 NY 229 libel r48NY 237 f'd intent 3 H 9L _ 14 H 278 6 TC 147 240 remedy 63 603 1.53, preference 681,35 H |36H 41 H ?'75H 472 606 243 assignee 66 337 authorit> 6 H 342 a 4 Ab 391 name of person 284 1 48 memoran. a 51 NY 61 delegation 3L notice 12 H 25 H 33 M 49 NY ITC 22 M 58 slander 72 NY actionable 130S 61 ejbctment 38 H 630 68 cotiversion 48 90 judgment void 386 21 420 841 84 551 105 618 42 614 276 3SA 122 NY 72 NY SONY compliance 85 NY conclusive 138 NY prima facie 63 H decree final 2LRA 256 usury 10 H pleading 14 H . 57 taxation 10 H 257 I 67 contract 5L 317 waiver e 27 H 419 fi3 affidavit 19H . . jurisdiction di7H 16 M 73 bar 4B privity 187NY 43 299 499 321 812 193 I 73 assessors a 48 NY 61 2L 48 NY ju risdiction 41 AD residence 88 AD 34 H discretion 5L 6L 65 AD 16 H certiorari .38 H 172 NY 70 286 546 283 603 146 no 84 632 570 146 674 201 87 H 130 86 248 521 551 364 assignee IH 340 3 TC 563 bets 48 H 403 371 trustees a 38 NY 201 402 payt. delay 66 596 412 eroeptions 566 statute 58 AD 376 61 AD 99 30 H leon 43 U 187 34 M 268 separation 9M jurisdiction e 97 M e 161 S 162 S 470 196 274 challenge a 36 NY 276 22 M 341 302 mistake 1 H 221 221 3TC 698 327 relatives 646 547 408 10 40 3H 6H 55 H 5TC .„„ 28 M 298;96 NY 104 cotenants 6 H 9H 15 H elSH 42 H 46 H 60 H 86 H 122 NY 647 658 596 667 348 221 302 391 316 155 449 600 201 260 157 8 64 IH 3TC 6TC 417 20 H 235 182 724 404 ineomu. ev. 167 391 S14 115 an 947 568 ackndgt 50 441 p 54 134 mandatory 41 H 32i 570 dower 60 NY 61^K,A VOL.49 21 damages 64 check B 43 NY 268 law baggage ILRANS 356 3 I mandamus 36 U 628 43 good title 17 H 218 will power e20H a4K a2Ab 86 NY 661 filbu 574 contr.sci a 64 NY 3Se 421 61 H declarations 84 H . 310 fact question 67 NY 569 evidence 122 AD 46 155 tenants by entirety 363 27 176 531 420 insurance a 51 NY 66 424 allegation d 23 M 677 428 defenses 162 S 700 438 interventn. f 86 M 224 148 S 410 445 warranty d 48 476 459 presumpt'n 11 AD 84 conversion o 41 NY 243 581 remedy 15 AD delivery 47 AD 70 H 41 M m trust 14 H 101 47i 476 477 342 62 infant 24 AD technical 17 H 49 H affidavits 55 H objections 18 M e80NY set aside 161 S 322 544 31 IH 3H IIH 34 H 50 H e76H e3TC 5TC 67NY efl2NY survive estt 2LRA 435n 430 bond convorsiou 18 H 20 H e24H a3K a3Ab 10 M 20 M 91 US 213 3fti 92parol ev 14 H 82 H consid 'n lease e 86 H 66 burden defendnt 75M 390 1S5S 527 97 construction 63 , 365 6L 328 1 90 incomp. ev. 6 H 116 183 1 7 H 472 1 94 govt stamp 53 , 385 jurisdiction e 62 664 e 5 L 604 197 discretion 104 bona fides 64 ■loan 12 H collateral 7H 69 NY 67 68 AD IH 4H 82 H new trial 4TC 2M 35 M 43 M 320 413 306 237 666 48 not adversely 129 S mo no recovery 71 M 267 maintenance 181AD 671 168S 802 disallowance 169S 802 330 eq.convern f 127 AD liable ( 157 S 922 can recover f 175 AD 39 f 161 S 481 463 receive r 74 H gift 2H 6H 3611 5TC legal title 3 rc 2M real partv 6H trover 50 AD privity oi AD 30 472 510 388 88 367 263 132 216 661 965 433 623 521 536 489 86 232 575 .Wl 269 161 86 construction 59 H 605 89 deposition 296 367 469 521 418 690 392 48 administrator e 24 H 469 a« a It . 466 marriage 98 M 530 478 encroaeht. r 42 NY 283 5 1 1 obj'n atp. 51 ^ 77 522 exam, eorc 14 H ih 74NY 436 524 powers 49 454 unconsti tutional 167 5 93 conversion n 62 N i 828 B4 lOB BL 472 6 1 4 stamped in. instrument 123el24 38 AD 3L complaiu't 18 H .nformation 28 H 66 H 74 H B2NY 148 NY 142 jurisdiction do 1S7NY magistrate 17 AC warrant valid 39CP 226 S3 maker e55 3L unstamped q6L marriage 33 H ans. ape ilic SOH rejection IS AD 86 H acceptance mNY 385 426 402 511 216 2S2 541 377 24 402 29 548 424 611 336 chg. int. 2H 541 8 TC 121 equitable title 46 NY 632 6Tr 37 NY do 37 NY license 59 M 548 intent e78NY 200 probate a 36 NY 463 '211 dedication 541 4 H 408 286 222 reliel 605lr 48 NY 344 679 34fi 602 55 1 tenaney 339 appeal e 64 4gi 6 H 377 4 H 468 f 2 TC 446 notice „ 7M 660 02 H 518 416_.._ , eSSS 536 344 f'd transfer 18 M 73 20 AD 76°" 3 H 592 552 legal tender 71 H 68 e IV H 7 80 H 481 do 17 H 12 23 M 7291 637 cestm que trust r48NY e6L 8H 97 US 133 231 232 342 1 66 estoppel 69 AD 386 NY 391 certiorari 36 H 89 I 76 construction 444 164 462 392 132 s51 58 17 H retroaction 20 H e45NY I 82 surety 12 H 74 NY 82 NY defense 26 H 620 136 131 490 45 48 420 49 269" 431 98n I 86 agency 676 665 96 intent 3H 40 NY prob. cause do 39 CP 225 fraud represns. do 144 AD 533 do 129 S 825 I 06 new trial 53 61 bar 63 H 111 presumption 19 M 237 mistake 27 AD conversion 41NY 203 pledgee 89 AD expenses 45 H 2 1 7 murder 60 470 341 243 497 353 276 486 585 274 381 107 656 nuisance 26 H 381 state control flCM 452 legis. consent t 213 NY 202 108 injunction 661 632 67 n66NY 62 damages 16 H 1 22 murder a 37 NY 413 I 28 trust power 99 86 293 296 535 576 r43NY do 55 h41NY d41NY C42NY power sale do 179 35 AD contract 6L mandamus 60 H 2TC 64 NY 71 NY 72 NY 136 court ev. 37 H 514 57 H 106 145 disregard error 165S 394 I 48 authority 58 H 351 221 check IIH bill exchange 12 H 540 70 NY 216 e 71 NY 330 160 NY 201 244 damages r51NY 211 250 debt lien 127 NY 211 259 discretion ABBREVIATIONS: a. affirmed ; d, dis.tinguished ; f. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; ", dismis-sed ; c, criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case: do. dissentini opinion: n. parallel 42 274 489 111 116 604 172 498 265 accounting m 51 NY 930 276 publish will 17 AC 397n 283 carrier 64 contract 91 AD assent 2H 63 N 4TC 391 444 50 326 306 note , gucsti■- e 78 AD 556 55 617^67 3 79 witness 3TC e26M 38 1 infants 28 AD 10 M 165 NY 385 estoppel 33 H e38H 31 M 406 249 290 112 13 360 264 383 469 57 NY 55 560 48 m40NY e6L 501 bond r39NY 3L 76 277 19 420 5 1 2 f'd luient 57 263 19 H 523 5 1 6 injunction 34 H 164 57 NY 172 e 177 NY 506 jurisdiction 127 AD 602 520 dividends a61 NY 207 543 crdr. bih 50 NY 84 96 562 election 123 20 H 267 surrogate 82 e 120 NY104ql05 lOO NY 242 397 res judicata e 68 H 182 misjoinder f 170 AD 156 S 407 stay a 52 NY -,. 65 424 exceptions 246 2 AD 573 certiorari 298 97 AD 132 mandamus 8 H 270 24 H 193 27 H time place IH 227 53 H 648 74 H 294 3 TC certificate 22 M 419 prohib. writ 36 M reopening rule 106 AD 46 48 67 NY 114 98 NY 234 174 NY 263 audit power 179 NY- special pwr. 121 AD judicial 122AD judicial 168 AD 783 39 621 341 647 419 172 384 440 326 509 608 259 251 419 499 — _^__ - ... „ ^ 476 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; ♦, dismissed- „ „«. . •.ermcued; L limited,- e, explained; o. overruled; ..same case; do, dissenting opinion ; P. parallel case- oquSjuo,^ Vols. 50, 51, 52 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Barbour 153 1074 587 attac ment r 51 NY 619 50 558 (i3H 2 bond creditor ■STC 594 audit a 3 A.b f. L 4H 23 H OTC 45Ny 74 NY 275 353 232 70 5' 6R9 391 464 601 penalty 86 H title tender 18AC 379n 6 1 2 damages r43NY 419 51 AD 99 presumption ev. 63 NY 413 joint t. feasor 147 AD 568 6 I 6 liquid dam 8 64 39 20 H 14 628 actual dam. 80 NY 393 118 NY 82 incompetent 128S 802 143 AD 634 sp.prfmance a 51 NY 246 639 title 42 AD . 298 construction 47 NY 459 62 NY 364 645test. capac 47 AD 179 20AC 43n presumption 34 M 414 gifts only 51 M f 92 M f 15S S conclusive ISAC 154 S incompetent 90 M 239 134S W^l hab. drunken'ess 90 323 361 315 ir>OAD 180AD 168S 9P1 VOL. 51. 9 reas. 94 US skill 497 I 3 assignment 163 c63 presumption e3L 33 M 6 48 NY released f 144S 83 M 93 96 61 420 267 423 137 devise o 4 11 construction 49 U 59 NY e 127 NY 148 bailee 20 M [275 irregular 726 OS 60 15 153 127 602 30 attachment 87 74 AD f2H 4H 9H 26 H 27 H certificate 2M 45 M amendment 59 NY 33 ins. boat a 41 NY 45 fixtures 11, 32 H 4LRA 309 369 379 634 209 471 269 440 61 596 619 221 167 286 65 memoranda 1 H 48 349 3 TC 89 588 114 NY 284 285 150 NY 392 69 carrier neg. r 51 NY 166 82 excess tax 68 irregular 60 e2H repavement 9H 560 129 507 1 59 recoupment r 51 NY 368 2H 394 4 TC 608 I86sp. prfmance - - - ■ 400 86 386 334 229 860 91 AD 5H 77 H 161 NY costs e88H waiver 116AD 560 129 I 96 fixtures 18 AD 66 AD 70 AD 924 H wine plants 20AC 107n 282 17 123 7 2(2 160 2 1 5 surety 2H 4TC 222 infants 60 15 M practice 58 M convresion S avu 35 276 123 168 143 dam 62 643 228 351 509 86 proceeds a 44 NY 81 H securities 151 NY right action 96 M 262 160 S 642 94 flooding e71H 517 incompet. ev. 82 NY 313 measure dam. 132 NY 202 99 incompet, ev 7 444 126 155 329 20 AD 6L 37 H 44 H e 166 NY harmless error 6 h 444 jurisdiction 58 M .510 105 deposition 19 H 283 objections 3 TC 40S I 1 6 averments 2 L 1 H 16 H STC pidg. 124 AD pleading 137AD fraud 334 346 265 585 892 327 225 waste ITC fact question 57 NY 610 244 privity 66 AD 478 IH 280 3 TC 676 undisclosed prin, 35 H 170 260 signatures 472 ev. el3M compet. 55 M declarat'on 58 M attestation 139AD compliance 123 S 169 48; 247 1017 263 bona fide e4L 73 68 M 157 dishonored 124S 82 jury question 124 S 83 t 68 M 168 267 extrin. ev. 8 H 402 1 H 149 estoppel 3 TC 376 e-xtra work 3M 154 270 alimony e 92 U 418 e 44 M 328 105 AD 313 e 44 M 328 v'd marriage 16AC 311 273 construction e 52 06if 277 award 61 3H e27H 11 M 24 M 33 M e62NY notice insuffic 97 AD reversal 129 AD usurpation 69 M 125 S 306 usury a 43 NY f IH e 3 TC 41 22) 412 693 620 651 674 614 710 32 741 35 434 o7b mjunction e43 AD 44 M 86 413 3 1 2 legis powerfc " 143 e63N5ir 72 NY 94 M prohibition 1 157 S 935 322 conversion I L 300 acquiescence 87 H 571 II M 457 326 use occupa. SH 671 31 H 381 334 trespass a 51 NY 666 346 new trial a 41 NY 12 AD do 60 AD 3 11 42 H 75 TC 56 NY 83 NY 162 S weight of ev. 25 AD 22 H uty court f 98 M 352 tax stock 4H situs 24 H f 30H 184 US 48 NY 61 NY d.85NY 88 NY certiorikfi 48 NY 395 398 508 492 328 589 398 629 364 583 360 contract 114 NY 556 368 construction e 52 069 injunction 57 59 e33H 54 NY jurisdiction 3L 45 NY order appeal e74H 449 294 158 468 180 664 396 damages 16L 40 4 1 4 ministerial 10 H 437 misjoinder d 48 H 599 notice d28ri 11 74 NY 192 436 inference 33 H 608 user 64 H acceptance 102 NY dedication 61 NY 134 NY 566 454 4U3 45 1 acceptance 44 NY 665 20 40 526 459 jury a 62 e62 97 NY uferior count e 12 AD 63 11 H 244 23 H 376 23 M 51 466 allegations 61 NY 238 1 L 286 time immaterial 23 AD 213 pers. liable eSM 107 475 mitigation 9 AD 5263 6 1 6 discretion 57 126 78 H 609 632 inn keeper r 41 NY 619 a 42 NY 25S 90 H 190 e 54 NY 266 642 taxation a 43 NY 107 s 1 L 465 647 extrinsic ev 17 H 79 H 85 H 26 M 484 slander 27 H 2TC 118 NY 24 563 528 246 365 633 183 493 husband 67 582 wife abandmt. 25 H 623 88 NY , 620 51 7tact question 71 H 332 532 neg. justi"e r 49 NY 35 57 29 e 44 NY 380 contract labor 146 522 402 490 581 60 3L I H 46 H •3TC sale goods 5L jurisdiction 44 H sufficiency 246 658 191 378 jurisdiction 57 444 q 1 H 658 4 TC 233 12 M 24016 M 18 M 5.58 71 NY 1 TC 192 552 limitation a 41 NY 619 29 AD 403 61 AD 426 19 H 616 30 H 641 33 H 621 41 H 211 76 H 380 660 104 570 release 5L 94 AD 8H 74 H e47NY d74NY 90 NY consideration 77 NY 102M 1688 labor IH equity fl47S 85M 589 title a 41 NY 64 NY 597 advancemt 10 477 561 70 554 206 334 141 159 635 402 654 534 397 267 VOL. 52 9 partition e 44 NY 21 not assignable 81 M 413 142 S 971 1 5 incbmp.ev. 15 H 274 harmless "rror 1 TC 338 value evldenc 120 US 43S 26 f'd convey 61 6L 61 M declarations 15 H notes will 114 NY 300 491 540 370 Sli a 45 NY 464 17 H 8C 65 NY 14 57 65. 6TC 42 NY C42NY 83 US 4AD 4H 62 H 6TC not free lOlM 168S 40 relief 67 165 NY 45 demand 16 H 72 limit liab. a 64 NY SL 105 taxable e2L elOH dl9H 75 H a 41 NY 46 NY 48 NY assessed 224NY 210 304 25» 675 ■ts 684 548 272 254 330 197 48i> 299 210' 461 400 61» 5» 104 123 I 1 6 parol ev. 7 H Se.'i 25 H 144 32 H 545 description 114 NY 187 1 25 wife surety 22» 326- 242 627 643 32^ 24& I 32 relief 66 counterclaim IL 62 IH 175 3 TC 70& remedy damages loSAD .'infi 138 S 809 138 stockholder a 48 NY 524- 141 wife 67 546- capacity to sue 16 H 174 construction ol8H .15- husb. and wife 33 H 654 116 NY 693 1 47 jurisdiction 205 422 258 !» 483 294 57 127 421 518 198 585 587 61 AD 14 H 21 H 36 H 40 H 75 H 16 M 76 NY 111 NY costs e62AD 62 AD error court 126 AD 139 MIKKEVIATIONS: c criticised ; 1, limited ; L, affirmed; d, distinguished: e, explained; o, overruled; s, f. followed; r, reversed, m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; same case ; do. dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, questioneil N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Barboui Vols. 52, 53 476 444 294 199 98 H 158 S finding 103M 171S 1 58 waiver 16 AD 625 1 59 subscription 14 H 394 10 M 458 1 68 sale stock 28 H 1^ 9M 441 662 per caput (-56 H 6i) ( 38 imprisonment 8 3 AD 40 waiver 19 H contempt 73 AD 42 authority 6H 40 H 56 U 134 NY f 168 NY 5 I agency 65 AD 54 agency 10 U 78 notice r41NY 56 NY 89 notice eSlNY 153AD 200 bond f 54 f 43NY 88 US 209 bond a43NY 212 ne exei 17 H SONY 233 211 659 557 184 698 26 225 assessment 76 637 372 154 136 296 476 546 104 210 55 149 105 oommitm't 67 H 825 79 U 682 I I I stockholder r 45 NY 505 1 34acknowlgm't f7L 9 1 55 accounting a 45 NY 646 1 64 joinder 32 U 333 election remedy e2M 119 20 M 296 1 69 local statute 55 261 61 465 e 43 NY 18 1 72 negligence a 4^ NY 47 s 1 L 81 I 79 Cjount'rclaim 56 a55H delusions 15 H M oM 15 M proof will 17 AC revocation 60 M 75M 135S compliance 98 M 162 S a 46 NY 6L 191 bar 63 AD 19 H 44 M 122 NY no bar 56 M dep. actions 127 AD joinder 137S coi'isolidated 310 162 48 309 273 45 691 91 1088 39 AD authority 17 H objections 84 NY 230 draft r47NY 15S 236 check 12 H notice 43 M inoperative 146 S 4Ba obligation 161 AD 275 27 1 dam. proof 71 H 384 274 test. 86 162S 948 presumed 98 M 531 337 improper ev 6H 116 appeal e 9 H 666 indictment 19 H charge error 21 H competent ev. 103 NY 618 463 mistake 6H 659 56 H 161 b. partioularn 4 M 611 VOL.56 9 nndings d5TC 679 422 411 468 requests 9H tex loci 56 H e27M 68 M 125 S 259 632 385 8 481 relief 57 NY .-M 68 H 44 H 151 NY- specif, prfmance 560 474 441 253 383 1 3 collateral e51 H d 71 NY counterclaim 89 H 372 d71NY 411 surety 151AD 321 2 I construction 41 AD 146 128 AD ■ 812 160 NY 298 30 contrib. neg. el3H_ 692 54 incomp. ev. 344 fiduciary s 1 L 85 L 17 M majority 17 M de facto 122 NY 308 25 708 721 196 27 H ' 61 H discretion do 70 AD 78 AD ejctraent 19 H 389 jurisdiction 19 H 270 92 H 563 216 10 599 294 469 e94NY e 114 NY e 138 NY 103M 169S allegations 77 NY trustee 114 AD 479 e 29 H 363 35 H 342le 36 H 91 b38 H 211 40 H S6H 460 q 83 H TO 418 36 H 168 360 202 damages 9H 260 reimburse f 171 AD 156 S 100 886 l'_- 118 NY 123 NY . 129 NY e 176 NY damages SIM 82 AD distinction 24 H e 67 NY ' 59 delivery 88 US oo 66 tender f 9 o 'pn 222 621 2 TO 389 52) 107 666 5114 947 51 120 404 highway HAD claims 48 AD injunction 31 H nuisance 7H 9 H 13 H e31 Al 35 H 35 M do 14r> AD do 120 S allegations 37 p legis. power 41 H , compensation do 129 S 947 authority do 14r) AD 490 construction 98 M 91 163 S 163 4 1 7 wives a 45 NY 33 H 422 invalid 6L 428 vesting: a46NY 37 infant 6TC 46 NY 497 dibcretion 2H 14 H 4TC 25 AD J63S misconduct 90 JI f 164 S avoids verdict f 179AD 544 153 451 676 20 514 574 514 80 guaranty 18 aO 326n 84 trustee 144 tiY 344 105 provocation 60 525 526 505 limitation 19AD 436 13 H 157 ._jl72NY 602 503 "Is for value 13 H 157 520 award 60 529 contrib. neg r tp a 38 NY. 433 15 H 334 230 654 551 opin. ev. a 42 NY 270 3 TC 796 585 justice ev. 3H 498 39 H 393 5 TC 579 disregard error 165S 394 610 504 774 694 43l<'onstitu 60 395 6 I 5 assignment 437 corporation! f5„^„, .„„ '^^ 52 H 442 fJ^S'P'- "^°"A^^ 443 express co. a 45 NY i; 447 right landl'd 620 levy TBM 278 4 H 450 corroboran 16 H 97 610 63, 77 H justification 140AD privileged f 161 AD f 146 S 511 238 967 2 1^ invalid 6 L 227 father f 178AD 164S 234 assault 643 NY 566 legal evidence 12 H 431 251 dower 46 H 01 122 NY 288 double purpose 3 SS 496 284 fact question 17 AC 139n 511 484 injunction 253 320 earner r64NY 678 340 injunction 5H , 73 eonsideration 8M 217 76 510 313 4 H U H 362 assignment 365 420 1 I I estoppel S5 M 494 148 S 933 I 1 4 construction 118 NY 219 judicial 71 M 130 S 487 notice 524 830 VOL.57 434 9 coverture 456 33 H 663 664 591 185 145 1 3 attachment serv. summons 652 39 H 624 waiver test 250 4 H 273 6 TO 304 review 84 NY 35 H 85 H 2SS 3SS 63 NY discretion 2SS 3SS 490 court's power 109 66 108 463 494 581 I 7 ministerial e 7 H 487 235 e 46 H 496 " 46 misdemeanor ojio 80 AD 368 57¥x™»''''"°*'°" felony 18 H 108 499 424 67 493 pers. injury r 45 NY 575 r. r degree care 2LRA 252ii 5 1 4 mayor 33 AD 468 powers restrictn. e 24 M 281 d 24 M 282 37 M 193 e 37 M 194 171 NY 308 521 App. Div. 47 AD 460 competent 369 redemption ■ " NY 634 f 161 S reversal 174 AD 534 trespass •i37 118 506 .0.7 119 damages '^' a 44 NY 430, 602 discharge e 81 AD do 81 AD do 178 NY 606 riot e 60 AD discretion 61 AD 12 H 3TC 97 100 389 155 314 216 796 14 H 73 AD 23 M 21 M 266 334 17.1 32 118 375 jury 10 M 750 unconstitutional c60 66 jatisfaction 95 NY 34» 231 note 6H surety 371 669 317 hypoth question. 662 83 NY 636 20 H 170 618 24 H 274 88 NY 558 440 98 22H _ _, cohabitatn. 7 M 109 161 S 85 ' 22H 493 d 86 NY 58 money had a 47 NY 656 88 construction 9H 4S1 insur. interest 13 H dl4H e65 H e89H 77 NY 84 notes 67 licenses 44 AD 4H 6TC 153 S 90' M defense 4H 6TC 66 NY jurisdiction f 88 M f 151 S 27 366 312 236 607 117 626 167 607 783 421 161 533 212 270 816 544 I I 8 repetition 380 assessment 137 1 2 I carrier neg 22 AD 550 126 charge 21 H , 402 intent crime 73 H 76 123 NY 267 264 144 NY 126 161 NY 389 e 173 NY 135 173 NY 142 3LRA 747r 136 construction 163 NY 147 I 5 I negligence 15 M 156 1 68 curtesy 22 H 270 I 77 construction 17 H 469 coud. sale 28M II 185 legal evid. 58 637 e 5 L 188 15H 73 I 97 guardian 50 AD 104 14 H 594 46 H 347 97 2 H oi valuation d46H 5TC 3SA 124 NY 542 uncoustitut r 52 NY 62 60 396 500 148 38 350 636 390 distinction ICF NS 86n 395 conversion 33 M J82 demand evidence 109 NY 225 invalidity 197NY 501 398 tax sale 10 H 387 559 extra work r 46 NY 444 567 rehearsing 81 H 99 38 M 142 591 copy will a 50 N Y 88 593 bona fides 310 408 fiduciary d34H 41 H 425 damages a 47 NY 282 63 267 430 conversion r 49 NY 57 62 NY 236 452 mandatory 5 H 660 56 H 518 662 liability 138S 1 216 NY 456 appraisal obligation e 86 AD 62 '>« AD f 86 AD 63 142 S 15 H 69, 1 148 S 24 H 2001 86 M 7H 396 51 H 48 NY 144 NY 69 M a 57 validity 165 AD 150 S 155 fro. convty. „_ . , a 48 NY 684 ^24 character 571 471 193 603 168 554 160 1 27 transfer frd 146 333 8H 600 trust a 46 NY 3H 10 H e 5 TO conting remd. 10 H 418 e 64 NY 353 647 auction sale e 34 AD 121 652 bailee 5 L 182 title stranger 27 M 545 allegations 71 NY 38 141 NY 5 62 H 3TC bar 3TC restoration 89 NY 326- 242 8S7 528 435 605 conversion 142 S 854 growing timber 157 AD X>,?. do 142 S real estate e 157 AD 249 f'd intent 31 H 284 265 accounting 38 M 412 'ancestor" 52 NY 71 277 estoppel 2H do5TC defense 176AD 163 S 567 118 596 900 29 I ectoppel r 43 NY 40 39 H 75 299 trustees 80 H 533 limit powers 42 M 7 178 NY 32 cannot recover 80 M 370 142 S 55:> 305 divorce r 4 L 388 e 2 TC 648 649 309 executors iniq .>uy executors ^"^^ a 42 NY 373 93 r 43 NY 25 e 2 AD e44H 1 76 legal ev 21 H 384 41 H 206 I 79 legal title a 47 NY 346 do 10 H 814 revival 63 H 416 2 Ab 6 construction 18 M 176 real party 18 M 246e689 204 exceptions 338 jurors r43NY 353 return m42NY e74NY 21 833 43 329 343 365 burglary a 43 NY 117 377 review 25 H 27 M a 57 NY s2L 11 H 14 H notice 124 S 140 AD 222note r42NY 6 334 191 200 421 125 40 383 legis. power 161 469 367 613 1U36 I4« 613 64 AD 79 AD 6L 8 H 36 M 586 188 195 97 98 605 395 invalidity 197NY 501 398 injunction e27AD do 27 AD contempt 2H ■8H 556 561 342 64 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed ; d. distinguished ; I. followed ; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; c. criticised; 1. limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s. sami? case; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q, questioned Vols. 57, 58, 59 M. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Barbour 4 TC 552 interests 36 M 624 8134 NY . 14 ehose in action 98 AD 256 stockholder a02NY 14 legal right 150AD 713 4 1 I discretion 5H 445 4 1 4 fraud S3H 51 NY 676 111 416 fr'd sale r 46 NY. 612 flubmission 4LRA 6S5n 421 St frauds r 43 NY 550 429 usury r 50 NY 95 3H 473 5 TC 485 486 438receiver 18 M 5 447 friv answer 13 H 181 34 H 430 88 NY 39 pleading 174S 687 448 relief 59 294 449 relief a 45 NY 637 59 294 res judicata 42 H 93 96 motions 14 M 180 83 NY 168 450 stay r42H 453 fr'd transfer 67 467 6H 84 2 TC .60 atty. client 2 TC 547 burden benefic. f 213 NY 328 479 .bonds r 49 NY 192 484 conclusive a 48 NY 527 57 509 compel proof 211 NY 443 49 I stsmp omisn 6L 510 54 NY 241 new trial 66M 234 497 release a 74 475 waiver 2 TC 258 damages do 172 AD 886 do 156 S 1145 504 Corp. judt. r 50 NY 137 f 7 L 207 5 1 Swaiyer 67 598 86 AD 120 5L 277 4H 801 2TC 632 c 57 NY 5061 66 NY 278 f 72 NY 601 e 73 NY 493 specific lien 16 H 504 17 H 468 general lien 10 H « 212 526 trade marK 1 TC 627n ILRANS 709n 721n 527 injunction r 45 NY 280 555 negligence 15 H 502 contrib. neglig, :i0AC 239n 56lburdenprool 17 AD 622 e 63 AD 444 14 M 601 80 NY 64 spec, oerfmce. 105 AE 291 law question 56 M 347 defense 59 M 292 562 duty court 125 AD 514 582 damages r 57 568 sup . complt. "H 198 e 85 NY 275 589 rferncing e 8 AD 393 593 transfer stk d 8 AD 501 review 45 H 56 67 H 601 2 TC 147 625 indictment 48 H 200 ruling ev. 55 M 52 637 exemptions d 1 H 352 5H 341 8H 292 30 H 244 46 H 319 d 3 TC 598 644 pers. injury r 49 NY 177 656 bonding 62 552 63 108 cond. subscript'n de 93 NY 415 67 1 damages a 48 NY 648 VOL.58. 20 damages n56NY 45 AD 26 H injunction 63 NY 208 114 247 5S2 443 36 warranty 60 e 65 NY 505 do 65 NY 521 51 character ev 192 NY433,435-6 6 1 judicial 105 AD 46 12 H 206 32 H 623 59 H 616 128 NY 238 71 sell credit 84 M 420 73 jurisdiction ILRANS 149 77 services 4 AD use credit f 146 S 242 89 incomp. ev. 3H 614 6H 183 e 37 H 502 42 H 162 e 65 H 221 1 00 damages 3 H 676 I 39 review 12 H 570 d 24 H 57 56 H 21461 56 H 462 22 M 622 county clerk d 125 S 106 reason' ble value 140 AD 229 I 52 damages r 61 NY 420 s5L 214 236 lease 66 AD 604 17 H 434 mutuality 34 H 78 7M 363 lOM 16 23 m 436 67 NY 236 109 NY 234 aot bnding 13 IAD 779 241 incomp. ev. 21 AD 60 81 H . 539 remedy motion 3 TC 405 1 60 NY 474 competent ev. 101 AD 444 248 prom, note a 47 NY 562 258 equity 19 H 668 e 21 H 72 264 sp. prfmance 43 H 9 63 NY 304 e 167 NY 111 270 for jury 1 TC 337 286 mandamus e 48 AD 55 e 2 TC 11 161 3L 402 e40H 23 r 46 NY 178 a 47 NY 566 construction 17 H 462 217 NY 240 1 65 pub. policy 86 H 21 5 M 503 1 74 publication r 46 NY 42 4H 438 8H 635 1 85 life insur. r 57 NY 638 1 89 rescission r 50 NY 19 1 H 82 3TC 76 1 95 carrier r60NY liability f 82 M 40 224 eq. lien d 46 AD 223 15 H 339 90 NY 643 141 NY 468 175 NY 179 233 COTltrBCt 54 4H 811 Corp. liable 4LRA 59 7 424 divorce » 45 NY 535 426 burden proof do 97 AD 424 40 M 15 prob. cause 66 H 116 NY 350 factquestion 5 SS 133 135 434 assessors a 49 NY 243 s 3 L 484 30 H 241 time 31 H 236 37 H 622 f 49 NY 352 325 pers e9AD change of 10 H 29 H 3TC 73 NY unearned 93 NY warranty 7 H 33 H repres 344 int. 696 86 482 450 prem. 78 661 64 349 assessment IH 339 6H 352 37 H 201 3 TC 62 563 fraud damages 5 TC 649 53 NY 140 96 NY 406 abatement 4H 49 6 TC 240 equity 14 H 45 389 fr'd convey 12 H 308 16 H 475 d 31 H 67 56 H 533 116 NY 304 165S 746 waiver 13 H 58 118 NY 234 reimbursement 51 H 80 invalidity 5LRA 622 401 set-off r 49 NY 605 4 1 3 easement n53NY 11 61 134 overflow 3 AD 161 61 AD 91 d66 NY 65 prescription FTjRA 279n VOL. 59 56 riparian 6H 54b 67 shipping 62 H 516 7 1 new trial 90 NY 347 87 demand 24 H 445 tender 3 1C , 30 449 damages 66 316 453 constructn 21 H 396 charities 56 M 206 'bsol. owner 27 AD 166 contract r 63 NY 462 specify defects 125 S 252 nonsuit 68 M 288 498 sp. prfmce r49NY 326 B 4 TC 649 508 waiver a 49 NY 676 37 M 132 93 execution o6L 214 104 limit iiab. a 47 NY 625 51 NY 64 1 44 appurten't a 45 NY 657 invol. pay't 4LRA 301n 1 58 assessment r 50 NY 662 61 609 jurisdiction 24 H 425 51N Y 19 invol. paymt, 4 LRA 301 n 169 a 49 NY f 49 N"i 524 agency r50NY 27 529 decree r 60 NY 538 e 8 H 302 545 106JI 331 557 assessment a 46 NY 575 consignment r 49 NY 188 s 4 TC 665 590 cav. emptor e 153 US 36 599 carrier rSONY 213 61 I authority 58 AD 421 625 new trial '2 H 299 9M 183 receiver title 105 AD 164 635 sep. remedy 186 NY 346 643 trustee a 49 NY 679 9 trust a44NY 36 H 38 parol 29 U 43 U 237 100 601 543 96 243 352 1 95 discriminatn 143 S 646 198 a 45 NY 812 6 L 166 prohibition 32 H 441 226 cashier r67NY 68 AD teller 89 NY 429 250 draft 8 66 intent 16 A D 120 127 462 618 265 bank e 41 H 509 check e 118 NY 463 demurrer 16A0 244n 275 demurrer 16AC 2441. 291 ejectment a 54 NY 458 295 reUef a 53 NY 202 s62 671 3 1 9 damages r 56 NY 22 344 partner r 67 NY 23 355 objections 31 AD 430 book entries d7H 616 15 H 471 30 H 298 34 H 229 43 H 21 « .17 K .IS' 364 joinder 83 NY 42 tort damages 115AD 607 injury property 99M 364 164 S 372 375 review 2 SS 494 4SS 87 91 383 sup. pro. 7H 26 contempt 3 TC 763 appearance 4 TC 200 jurisdiction 94 NY 45 390 sup. pro. 7H ■ 62 affidavit 63 M 31 40 I certiorari a 49 NY 356 4l3pollu. strm e 9 H 520 77 NY 56 damages 115 AD 4 surplus water 68LRA 141 434 trustee r 60 137 446 bonding r46NY 110 S2 552 presumption 63 110 taxpayer 47 NY 418 493 judgment 66 340 21 H 512 497 caveat emp- tor e64 AD 300 9 3AD 609 26M 757 US NY 116 f 149 S 488 impld. covenant 81 M 137 142 S 329 504 impl. covn 130 AD 579 158 S 652 505 prom, note la 54 NY 437 525 retroactiv e6L 99 531 allegation 5H 543 129 US 236 114 NY 527 "duly" 4LRA 660 123 S 965 139 AD 243 554 draft a 54 NY 472 556 agency a 50 NY 626 574 dismissal !l60 AD 423 f 144 S 1062 I 585 notice a 61 NY 61 H 88 21 619 recovery p 20 H 1 M ABBKEVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed: r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n. note c. criticised: 1. limited: e. explained; o, overruled; s. same case: do. dissenting opinion: n, parallel case; u, quesuoncd N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Barbour Vols. 59, 60, 61 628 usuary 67 NY 645 644 negligence 68 H 327 651 poaseaeioD r 50 NY 437 666 certioiari 8H 610 VOL 60 9 jurisdiction 37 M 30 damageb a 58 NY 62 45 division fence 82 H 152 48 fraud r 52NY 62 equity 07 presumption 07 declarations 15 H 69 undue infl. ■368 56 222 90 73 f3lH 137 NY 36 H ien 39 H I 3 SAD construction 133AD ' 'survivor" f 178AD ISoS I 8 1 deposit aONY 40 AD estoppel 21 M 216 adv. possess 4 L 2aJ. 7L 26 H 2TC IM 77 NY 136S 136S 129S inconsistent .■4M charge fraud 449 191 29n 46 641 1096 n04 ■JO' 524 124 158 606 905 673 806 410 5B 290 53 H • 176 subordnation 15 H 339 425 redemption 1 TC 562 119 NY 527 accounting 72 NY title 112AD 454 sep. 65 86 NY 234de facto 79 H color of riglit e73NY 68 77 640 250 seduction 54 H 593 138 estate 324 VOL. 61 9 stockholder 34 L SONY 33 privity 1 H 3TC 463 use occuptn 16o 60a 301' 588 267 381 136S 80 threats 11 AD 23 H 39 H 100 NY 116 NY 272 stockholder „„,39 AD 152 29 19 H 587 588 d 88 NY 140 IH 3TC 21 M 101 NY 153 S title proof 31 H not implied 168 AD 488 error ev. r SONY 669 183H 216 155 NY 2Ct care patent 2LKA SSSn 1091 179 36 76 226 611 84 warranties 35 AD 59e60 288 inad. price 111 AD 850 3 I 7 f d trust e 54 AD 552 332 construction 22 524 assault 63 mitigation 75 AD compet. ev. ILRANS 87 NY 77 r05 veto a 47 NY 659 IAD , 258 e 76 H 84el62 aqqointed 129 AD 479 61 AD penalty 64 AD highway e5 L 124 NY 160 379 277 4S2 606 266 attachment 2 AD 556 79 H 408 court's power 620 651 35 indictment 4L 487 d 33 H 506 37 limitation a 52 NY 644 H 676 e93AD 319 40 jurisdiction 2TC 273 judicial 3 H 7 M 130 AD 293 admissibj3 e4H 88 NY 54 appeal a 61 NY 6H 60 authority 33 H 56 H 134 NY 606 115 524 78 338 135 296 47;. 377 300 362 76 AD s5 I, advances 9H 90 H 143 NY objections 2TC dissent e24H disclosures 201NY 608 486 281 461 217 644 128 307 charge 3rror 86] r51 196 14011 527 court as wit 391 579 334 control absolute 201 NY 497 3H criminal 17 H review 22 H jeopardy 172 NY plea in bar 64 11 withdraw 64M 267 492 284 leg. NY 476 121 partv int. 67 ,438 taxpayer 34 H 144 I 25 undertaking 25 H 259 1 30 riparian Ti M S20 I 36 limitation e36H 310 partner r61NY 335 waivT a 65 NY 10 H construction do 37 M 347 order ev. 25 AD 3 356 usur;' d65NY 132 hip 123 399 560 107 penalty 67 udgment j3 H spec'l proceedg 78 NY ii70 I I 3 good will 79 AD 376 1 I 7 sum. pro 24 H 626 amend, complt. 24 H 647 service 49 M 449 judgmen roll 26 H 458 bar 28 H 213 irregularity 15 M 168 new pleading ISAU . 168 serve pleading ISAIJ 170 338 nonsuit a 45 NY 24 H 249 74 346 answer 25 M lib'l constr'n 52M 349 fi'J intent 260 261 61 566 repayment 44 H 5; 114 NY 3 inspection 27 M 21 598 vesting e 183 NY f 99 AD a 67 NY 351 116 NY 354 2LRA 830n f 1678 643 damages 160 AD 622 146 S 84 145 Sep. estate 66 324 m57NY 22 H 8 66 NY 366 void a 37 NY 24 AD f 39 M 378 trustees a 50 NY s 5 L 7L appeal 10 H irregularity 144 1 40 notes a 64 NY s4 L 586 103 643 485 660 59 322 363 236 16 438 479 406 wife powers 539 27 33 150 affidavit 32 H . 217 1 59 affidavit a 4U W Y 477 67 433 S.3L 394 I 63partition a48 NY 106 7 472 95 477 189 561 61 7cloud on title 432 274 191 216 1 312 218 410 21f 639 21 1 49 bonds 67 ILRA 530 358 abatjoient a 49 NY 125 36 I execution a 49 NY 160 52 AD 112 113 116 433 nuisanc e ILRANti 63n 437 pers. injury d 61 595 contrib. neg, 42 AD 534 commission q25H US 540 notice 48 H 167 >il62 NY 44 573 damages e 65 U 346 SSOfact question a 61 NY 506 e 11 H 104 notice defective 5LRA 146n 597 residence r 61 NY 261 6 1 I tickets 54 NY 516 6 1 5 indorsemt 67 387 e 24 H 564 6 1 9 misdemenr ct spl, session a 16 H 43S 20 H . 101 jurisdiction e 20 H 242 e20H 160 33 H 637 diluting milk 49 H 397 petit larceny e S3 NY 243 87 NY 834 7S M 669 !.•« .S 773 a 66 NY 62 AD e48 M warranty e2H d 14H restoration 16 H f 21 H f 21 H bona fides 22 H relief 41 M d60NY e 62 e7 L do7 L extra work 16 H 33 H 34 H 3SS presumption e 85 H 129 fact question p 2 SS .422 agency d 63 NY 613 2 SS 422 409 eq. lien 4H 478 96 AD 299nd^nH I 72 incmp ev. do 34 H 50 AD 130|38 H d79H i 80 int. damages f 10 AD e31 H Po 23 H , 18 M 95 NY bar 21 M qar damages 117 AD interest lo 60 M 473 80 81 685 43(-' 85 640 contract a 87 NY 656! 644 pers. injury a 54 NY 488 648 carrier a 57 NY 54 L fact question e 431 456 repeal e3"4H r 49 NY restoration 66 NY 97 NY 477 434 103 111 617 290 6.59 610 610 132 33: 587 444 190 limitation 72 AD 60S e 25 M 203 205 assignment r 61 NY 344 2 1 I incomp. ev. 6 H ■ 539 7 H 440 14 H 419 17 H 8 19 H 78 252 estoppel a 47 NY 493 260 ejectment rOlNY 52 s 15 H 680 582 title invalid •>AH NY 230 284 475 cotenants 76 NY 272 479 estoppel 1 TC 342 483 damages a 49 NY 150 61 521 constitutional 10 H 164 88 US 202 court's power d 224NY 209 489 assignment 67 H 104 497 tender 59 AD waiver 66M 121 S 373 312 ABBREVIATIONS; a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followea; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; c, criticised ; 1, limited ; e, explained ; o, overruled ; s, same case ; do, dipsl nting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q. questioned Vols. 62, 63 N. Y. Sapremc Court Reports — Barbour VOL. 62 1 6 jury trial e23 H 376 46 limitation 197 230 do 284 5 I audit report e4H dlS perB. liability £1 H 87 H 11 M €5 NY SONY 62 fr^ud 66 AD e26H 36 M 210 270 571 457 252 616 200 78 185 237 ripn. 128 AD 250 probate 69 AD 63 NY d70NY reconsidered 143 S for jury 81 M 256 malice r 26 NY 36 H law from ct 39 GP. i if 95 M 4381 insufficient 159 S 359 475 519 403 346 394 224 484 158 7 I false pretense 35 M 185 85 filiog map 32AD 1 H dl5H 46 11 3TC 17SNY 55 499 82 99- 635 82 due process l&w 36 AD 590 92 contract 124 NY . 159 109 alimony « 18 AD 35 129 NY 571 release bar 37 H 229 1 3 1 marriage 24 H 462 damages 94 NY 333 138 confession 29 M 672 37 M 30 corroboration 142 S 300 insufficient f 146 S 246 1 45 com'n law 64 AD- 281 presumption 206NY 2(11 1 50- notice neg 67 233 46 H 341 TC 636 ev. possession 126 S 96 occupier 69M 280 St. frauds ' a 53 NY 609 65 618 discretion 2 AD 21 39 AD 174 646 35 H 196 76 NY 544 inad. price 50 AD 56 AL 76 H authority 21 H 76 H 4o0 contrac aa notice 5H compliance 6 TO 35 M statutory r2M 131 S 609 564 696 339 696 295 possession a 58 NY 237 299 nuisance 66M 455, 456 123 S 560 3 I I damages r 61 NY 463 620 175 sureties 6 M 51 no consideratn. 208 NY 274 in full force f 87 M 458 150 S 788 1 8 1 life insur r 63 NY 339 I 88 creditors a 61 NY 306 218 CO. employe a 52 NY 632 14 H 448 e 15H 177 223 possession r 65 NY 581 's7 H 383 3 1 6 lien a 66 NY 459 86 H 629 18 M 204 145 AD 454 cond. precedent 129 S 970 exclusive possn. 145 AD 454 326 parol r 61 NY 568 344 amendment e 17 M 664 20AC 2:in removal case 110 AD 243 46 M 10-4 687 252 166 467 424 351 444 compromise a 41 NY 384 e 64 AD 263 460 payment 128S 879 TOM 379 accep'tance 65 NY 373 484 prior>ctfl e26H e27H 46 H 146AD damages 65 M other acts 131 S 490 cnarge 23 H f alsus in uno 2M 61 NY 66NY 4.NY 501 323 168 393 251 246 483 103 606 94 580 495 salary 155 N validity 126 a Corp. de facto 140AD 579 prove corporatn 150 AD .102 175S 691 6 1 2 affidavit 25 AD 296 6M 120 121 presumption d 9 M 467 19 M 33 23 M 238 184 NY ay service sum 36CP 337 motion transfer f 87 M 14 change venue 149 S 1056 623 negligence a 59 NY 366 presumption ILRANS 289n 630 injunction 102 NY 504 63 1 constructn. 128S 98 500 atty. lien a 62 NY 1 AD 17 H e71NY 73 531 451 5 1 7 labor 1 H 35 I intention 15 AD 90 NY 21 AD construction 18 H 36 H 40 H 82 M 144 S 127 NY guarantee 2LRA 161 S 178 122 415 177 , 69 251 638 481 424 183n 370 364 declaration a 35 NY 487 e 63 AD 595 competent ev. e 12 H 341 17 H 493 40 H 360 mental anguish 36 H 73 40 H 360 h. and wife 76 NY 267 395 resrraint do ) 75 VY 36 231 contract 420 consideratn a53 NY IH'elSONY 420 402 53 1 h. and wife 19 176 316 360 668 s7L 4H 8H 19 H 33 H ejecUnent e20H 473 assignee of husb. d33H services e27H 49 H do6TC 2SS 545 bonding e4L do 93 NY revocation 99 NY 557 notice e91H ITC 473 29 486 467 423 528 426 333 577 accounting 24 H 112 e 81 NY 683 jurisdiction e 92 H 293 interpretation e 89 NY S 593 contract 67 AD 360 29 H 497 636 warranty 36 AD 4H 63 NY collateral 170 AD 156 S 650 delivery 5H 12 H 47 AD 64M evidence 65 AD 594 696 indorsement 10 M 452 67 1 damages a S.l NY 202 59 787 408 853 894 470 313 476 227 VOL. 63. 9 jurisdiction 27 H 373 1 5 accounting 7H 593 presumption 55 H 596 2 1 conclusion 1 57 devise a 82 NY 72 H 630 24 3TC 1 6 1 assessment e SO NY 809 1 68 evidence el4H 213 67 14 H 16 H 22 H 10 M weight of ev. e46AD 80 H 91 H e92H 164 S new trial 164 S set aside 99M 164 S 170S 31 release a 67 NY . 16 H 53 wife 65 394 396 1 69 error ev. 3TC ^fj 101 US 4s9 1 77 trustee 115! 42 AD ''°^e46AD f 5H e29H :42H 67 NY diligence 10 M damages. 16 U salary 49 AD 253 690 690 659 443 184 637 73 567 388 677 668 943 377 199 649 60B 181 39 679 423 97 208 326 60 mitigation 123 NY 67 65 construction a 65 NY 22 H attestation e49H 86 NY 67 repeal 73 discretion 892 440 408 606 874 87 NY compet. e^ ILRANS 77 notice 13 H 658 139n 148 149 1 85 diversion 36 H 178 e 66 NY 66 171 NY 601 pollution waters ILRA 29Bn prescription ILRA 2P7n damages lays drainage t45 AD amendment 20AC 136 162 23r 8M profits 31 M e68NY 96 NY 188NY compevx-satory 40 M 242 objections 34 H 37 H 46 H 177 396 276 iid 135 42 60 271 guardian 4 AD 358 36 H 158 13 M 41 282 em. domain d 36 M 122 147 US 297 69LRA 754 160 NY 248 287 taxpayer 34 H 144 title act 82 NY 297 costs 42 H 299 notice 66 199 139 522 45 317 213 83 construction r65NY , 300 e 71 NY 483 99 AD 182 error assessmt. 30 H e27H I ITC alienage a5H 547 193 385 401 89 presumption 22 AD 310 24 H 28 .39 H 264 do39H 267 e3SS 250 33 M 420 1 1 1 nuisance 30 AD 68 e77NY 56 33 NY 184 evidence 34 H 226 e 126 NY 119 120 bona fides a 40 NY 299 205 tender 13 AD 40 H 7M 209 tender 50 AD 147 NY rescission 8LRA 213 rescission 841 887 607 344 236 368 5LKA 2 1 5 equity SAD partial value 3H 9H 23 H 33 H 51 H 8TC 10 M 66 NY 36S 160 693 324 87 543 287 502 441 444 237 fraudulent 8 AD 8H 512 usury 68 NY 530 a 61 NY s6L e86NY s61 NY 356 ouster r60NY 395 iUegal 32 H nuisance 1 45 m. prosecu. a 65 NY 385, s 6 L 360 260 damages 251 18 AD do 163 AD 31 H 33 H 38 H d67H 63 NY 3SS 482 454 do 148 S 593 damages 85 H 66 3 SS 494 496 restr'ng power 199 NY 212 448 483 600 164 107 307 581 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed- r c. criticised; 1. limifod: «. exnlained: o. overruled; s. same cusu; dii 1 5 1 depreciation 40H 691 evidence e 38 H 466 1 54 hd writing 75 NY 249 e32 AD 32 AD 19 H 509 611 366 charge of court 85 H excessive IH e48H 92 150 301 3 1 I interest 2H 4TC presume fraud 126S 377 establish credrs. TOM 174 335 possession r 42 NY 27 339 fr*d convey s 66 444 349 stipulations 542 319 174 554 451 490 437 public use e39H " 427 66 H 624 24 M 182 49 M 566 454 taxpayer r 69 NY 65 7L 9H elTC 3TC 64 NY waste injury 104 AD 192 461 357 358 151 297 626 65 461 lunatic e63AD 79 NY 177 NY equitable 182AD 1698 31 546 262 dfnse. 23 467 468 writ error r 6 L 149 e74NY 421 148 NY 101 485 misjoinder a 55 NY 85 H 14BAD demurrer !:US 472 501 .•)TI reversed; ni, modified; *, dismis.sed; u, iimx diss<..nlinE upininn : p. imrallel ca.-se ; q, que.siiuiiL-d N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Barbour Vols. 63, 64, 65 495 corporation VOL. 64 134S SOOcustom IH 11 H 33H 3TC appeal IH 506 warrai] a 52 NY 22 AD 79 H 6 99 NY 525 title 9 AD presumption 39 H do39H estoppel 127 NY adv. pbssessn 17 AC374n,379n 535 ballot SAD 14 M 836 161 222 340 698 231 416 253 55 528 25 396 458 198 547 countercKm 21 H 576 59 H 302 85 H 101 discontinuance 123 S 835 139 AD 119 552 discretion 67 • 44S 3 AD 48 31 H 403 35 H 156 ad, allowance 86 H 47'( 88 H 348 92 H 66 556 stock trust 33 AD 157 17 M 708 721 legal ow ner 120 AD 759 572 openins st. SAD review e46H 67 H 3TC 24 M 34 M 62 Ny 144 NY 295 303 180 227 40 656 S87 411 9 fact queaton d 53 H 253 fraud sale 20AC 79n 23 contract r53NY 394 55 tel. poles 31 H 602 public nuisance 131 AD 177 63 limitations 130 AD 220 69 smoke law do ILRANS 884 7 1 trustee 12 H 81 new trial 67 28 H 3TC good faith do 145 S 433 358 432 580 102 conversion a 53 NY 19 1 06 tort feasor 4Q H 115 competent ev. 110 AD 607 interest 16AC 50n error court f 162 S 418 1 42 authoritv 36 H 447 p 107 NY 499 1 46 atty. lien a 52 NY 489 I 56 residence « 63 NY 33 H I 82 audit 64 82 H mandamus 88 AD 2H BOH 82 H 4TC 595 appointmt 7L clerks 5H e6H d6 H d8H el3H dl6H elTC ■ a 53 NY 67 NY e67NY 103 NY 482 344 196 133 507 493 397 343 659 627 22 91 523 55fi 681 505 607 450 225 571 507 656 2 1 2 transitory 87 L 8H 2M ■ notice 145 AD 129 S 210 258 510 SI 7 1049 2 1 5 damages r 65 NY 444 239 partnership 7 H ii 427 255 note void 43 H 390 unenforceable 175 AD 279 f 160 S 146 277admiBsibility 27 AD e33 AD d66AD e8fi AD 79 H e 178 NY 376 625 243 446 595 483 299 weiaht ev. 71 H 343 390 610 92 H fiM 10 M 116 NY ^nnpplable 123 AD 73 182 657 298 10 131 S authority 158 AD 144 S no release f 172 AD 158 S 43& 866 43 189 382 435 bankruptcy a 63 NY 123 a 91 US 656 667 438'^.<. e48H 8M ncE^ligence 13 M h26M dam 301 659 311 197 449 call loan r 55 NY 236 454 discharge e 37 H 210 457 damages r 65 NY 200 463 denial e 79 AD 636 do 79 AD 538 636 206 99 333 authoritv 67 H _ 466 limitation 119 NY 267 353 encroachmt 18 H 289 6M 201 362 consideratn 51 H 611 373 incomp. 126 AD 379 neeligence a 56 NY RH limitation 43 H 127 NY 632 299 237 449 610 objections e 79 AD 324 6 1 8 contradictn 24 AD 14 21 H 401 65 H 219 62 1 removal 17 M 711 20 M 271 relief discretion do 181 NY 56 622 delivery 14 H 593 630 fact questo e 77 H 505 1 79. presumption e2H 40 e 4 TC 307 I 89 p. transactn II H 215 acquiescence 15 H 603 practice 25 H 493 no review 207 NY 580 I 99 practice e 24 M 262 proof will 17 AC 383n 205 competition 28 AD 558 advertising IH d3TC agency p7H 60 NY mandamus e2TC 96 NY discretion do 60 NY construction 96 NY 26 753 166 308 63 600 318 581 39 I 8t. frauds 37 H 611 406 sup. pro. a 65 NY 124 s 66 282 31 AD 38 410 pleading 16 AD 83 76 AD 367 jurisdiction 34 H 180 rule 118 NY 186 4 1 7 jurisdiction 21 H 268 42 \ publication 28 H 61 H 464 sureties 24H 468 notice 45 AD 116 NY 475 waiver 5LRA 167 93 192 568 593 considerat'n e 49 H 601 qe.assignmcnt 70 NY 218 609 mech lien a 62N Y 290 6 I 7 bailee neg. 17 AC 229n 620 subrogation a 56 NY 214 6H 638 28 H 23 628 prom, note a 59 NY 250 636 subscription d4H 71H 476 notice 92 H 513 e6SS 535 636 18 M 482 dower a 62 NY 493 claim e6H d24 506 bar a 63 NY 12 H, 73 593 93 421 1 143 75 AD affidavit 3H e43H 5TC 127 NY 52 64 631 283 425 chge venue 16AC 431 parol 40 H t84H surrender e4SS 18 M costs 3M not end 169n 237 431 522 ejectment 366 526 substitution e 2 M 361 536 insurance a 55 NY 222 543 certificate 3H 690 548 recitals 49 H 159 358 holding Aver 9M 489 construction 211 NY 455 563 refiling 2H 4TC 281 573 plumbing 31 AD payments 48 AD 53 H 208 539 76 580 trespass 47 AD 363 585 589 waiver 192 a 66 NY 505 6H 668 101 new contract lease I5LRA 431 294 753 VOL.65 9 review 21 H 24 H 22 contract a 58 NY 27 defense 154 NY 32 referee a 58 NY 92 H pleading 8M 528 286 361 414 128 84 43 fraud m56NY s66 e60H 22 M 89 US 48 court 3H 6TC exceptions 28 H discretions 38 H 72 NY do 145 AD do 130 S admissions 22 M 668 633 462 17 68 526 281 447 42 216 399 687 494 8 501 22 a6TC . declarations 7M 18 M authority 37 M 87? note for debt 16 AC 147n 1 70 assessors 6H 65» I 85 motions r 55 NY 618- 28 H 295 1 88 negligence a 60 NY 635- 1 92 partition 20 M 247 197 brokerage'' 241 54 partnership 30 H 46 58 new trial r S 8 NY 19: 3n 26; 35 H 221 74 assignee s 7 L 48: 112 NY 9! 92 negligence 33 AD 7H d3TC contrib. neg. 5H 23 H exceptions 11 M error 49 H defect, case 64M 58: 107 rede-nption 15 H 196 1 29 known risk a 56 NY 608 4 AD 206 70 AD 500 140 NY 462 167 NY 312 incompetency e 13 AD 442' contrib, neg, 7 H ■ , 86 assume risk 123 AD 560 136 deed fraud 405 289 41 598 a 56 NY 201 bar 35 H 37 H 31 M 2 1 dedication 40 H 400- 282 2 I 4 witnesses s 18 AD 460- 32 H 343 e 2 SS 95. 3SS 412 a 3 K . 323 property right 134S 1013 discretion jury do 134S 1018 227 mortgage 8 AD . 572- consideration 15 AD 45 82 AD 365 measure damage 14 H 276 110 AD 604 d 191NY 397-8 ■6M; 286 collaterally 53- 100 AD 44 M conversion d 110 AD full price 116AD discretion jury 76M 29a 246 73; 505 572- ■583 52AD 12 H 16 H 76 H delivery 7M 93 US 99 6] 72 660 102 127 nee 146 a66N 62 AD , pleadg 11 377 I 6 I discharge 8H 686 44 H 471 incompetent ev, c 79H 544 237 equity 61 M boundaries 135AD 366 368 equity relief 135AD 367 250 power sale 37 H 22: 62 H 373- 260 services r 55 NY 266 265 lex loci 13 H 407 77 NY 684 impeachment 36 M 272 relation e31 AD 29 H 35 H p54H el4M 23 M 42 M disqualify 85M 146 S 205 276 19- 496 148 673 83 3 220 987 275 receiver ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, fo ilowed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed- n, not»- c, criticised ; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case ; q, qnestionad Vols. 65, 66, 67 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Barbour 350 45 H remedy 37 M 77r 278 fiduciary a 59 NY 647 283 assessment r 52 NY 526 286 replevin a 55 NY 456 a 58 NY 73 293Berv. process 28 M 571 298 over paymt .1 59 NY 638 118 NY 26 304 contract T 55 NY 412 3 26 damages a 60 NY 469 d 124 NY 348 33 I competition 37 M 201 com. stndrd. e 64M 138 338 a.batenient 66 AD 428 344 damages r 56 NY 129 346 -duress 1 AD 230 21 H 394 116 NY 612 360 dama^-es r 56 NY 623 365 damages a 55 NY 653 369 lease 26 M 411 prsnl. property 185AD 297 173S 52 464 cross exam. 2H 45 4CT 317 value services 92 H 123 41 M 163 473 return r 35 NY 587 6 H 626 653 q 18 H 124 493 hyp. quest. 3 TC 332 64 NY 370 50 I allegations 18 AD 239 5 1 2oi;al contract 19 H 568 21 H 70 29 H 602 acquiescence do 66 H 34 sp. performanc 86 H 505 surrender 3 SS 607 516 contract oLliA 325n 518 enforce court 5L11A 324n 524 retain m'ny BUM 537, 538 380 costs 3M 383 notes a 56 NY 397 devisp B60NY 23 H 101 672 544 130 4 1 4 damages T 58 NY 185 41 8 ejectment a 56 NY 634 a 74 NY 245 431 terminatn. 14BAD 82B 432 lottery a 56 NY 424 435 certiorari' 563aiIegations ■39 i\l 434 583 partition 34 M 8 f 94 M 443 64 NY 354 jurisdiction t' 94 M 441 597 damages 38 H 259 taxpayer 34 H 145 cloud title e 47 H 50 limitation 2LRA829n 830n 608 parol ev. 25 AD 43 6 1 9 waiver a 56 NY 636 il AD 146 91 H 498 28 M 114 639 v. contract 35 AD 6 6 31M 386 notice 20 H 470 interest e 31 M 386 187 461 203 VOL. 66 9 relief 48 a •. 164 NY ; misjoinc'er 166 NY parties pIII, 53 .\1 joinder 39 CP no injunction 212 NY 505 21 entire contract do 138 AD 245 35 remedies 130 NY 231 43 negligence a 61 NY 666 57 rules of ev. 37 M 602 59 attachment 34 H 66 225 a 59 NY 232 tender a 66 NY 8H 30 H 245 counterclm. 144 S S4T 159 AD 514 249 discontinu- ance 123 S 885 139 AD lis 250 default 168 AD 325 154 S 65 251 costs 35 H 73 damages 11 M parties deft 106NY 85 joinder 35 H 41 H cross examn. 56 H 26 M 689 534 667 259 223 722 rescissio n 421 28 467 41 H IM 2M 22 M e 114 NY 121 NY 368 remedy 63AD 841 261 pubi'n will 17 AC 3»S 18 516 353 conversion 522 387 119 122 566 166 819 476 475 954 103 town bonds 14 H 428 estoppel 32 H 456 I 25 declarations 37 H 286 I 39 indictment 41 H 69 64 H 340 1 39 advice of counsel 55 AD 288 fact question 20 H 467 1 45 warranty e 47 AD 276 damages 113 AD 83 breacli dam 37 CP 136 1 5 1 indiv. liabil. 85 H 129 udgement.v.onfl 61 M 320 160 presentment 18A0 391n, 392n 1 89 partnership a 45 NY 410 53 AD 128 46 H 367 20 I cross exam . 76 AD 374 375 205 discontinue 31 H 19 209 discontinue 96 NY 244 conclusive 169 NY 499 2 I I verification d 27 H 371 2 I 5 relation t AD 197 268 release 14 AD 26 AD 282 equity a 66 NY 284 presumption 38 M 585 287 accounting a 66 NY 504 30 I trespass a 62 NY 626 3 1 7 will proof 112 AD 46 H 30 M 17 AC 148 S 496 467 23 396n 918 test capacity do 112 AD 498 presumption 61 M 559 averments 139 S 1007 Durden proof 142 S 161 142 S 171 make wills^ 180AD 672 171S 646 requirements 184AD 203 325 fire insur. a 53 NY 446 S2fi no review 143 AD 672 374 title 139 NY 184 NY f 156 S presume heirs 117AD 405 escheated 117AD 409 f 171 AD 6 title aliens 18AC 303 not conclns. 13 IAD 680 38 1 demurrage 34NY 1466 386eenL objn. 37 AD 34 uossession rent 43 AD 133 142 NY 84 389 spec.request 128 AD 738 390 contract a 69 NY 495 402 directors sl3H 22 H corporation 114 AD parties 114 AE joindei 37 CP 4 I 2 relief a 56 NY 22 M 502 duress d3C H d 116 NY 5 I 4 intent r45NY 35 H direct verdict 39 H 520 costs b20 H a 62 NY 33 I findings 9 M 56 H ,8M 61 165 476 202 676 498 competent 96 102 624 449 27 539 enforcement 56 AD 262 81 H 183 vs. publia policy 19 M 21 d 127 NY 375 173 NY 372 valid contract 119 AD 178 553 meas. -profits 126 AD 663 D yrs. acoountiaa VOL. 67. 9 cross examn. d 60 H 49 53 H 248 13 residence 106M 476 1 4 stockholder a 53 NY 371 23 H 259 341 recovery d 29 H 645 124 NY 32 33 cond. precedt. 126 AD 557 appeal a 66 NY 559 no el3 U 664 676 224 2LRA 1 9 waiver a 55 NY 31 M notice 63M 39CP 35 award ,1 66 NY 270n 673 338 182 62 533 333 attachment 17 H 336 trustee 17 AD 31 H e39H . permissive 25 H 42 M .57 619 323 393 35 30 426 construction d 100 NY 558 433 oral pledge 18 H 189 437 negligence 21 AD 311 36 H 593 600 452 remainder 10 H 193 construction f 22 H 429 idiot 38 M 390 462 insurance a 53 NY 603 67 358 p 1 TC 449 483 impressions 33 H 234 34 H 484 69 H 45 338 compet. ev. - . . _ gj 29 104 AD 48 M prima facie 61 M 341 set-off a 65 NY 33 M 233 120 83 345 redemption 564 CO ten ants- conversion r 56 NY 613 67 AD 433 570 contempt 98 M 488 582 partnership a 66 N Y 270 586 fr'd transfer 78 H 137 17 H 470 2NY 76 590 presumption 11 AD 666 170 AD 468 f 156 S 1-23 592 trespass 67 H 308 597 interpleader 2 M 444 6f I sp. prfmce. 66M 447 equity relief 123 S 555 6 1 2temp. injunc- tion 38 M 595 633 performance 13 AD 641 6M 314 50 M 143 489 equity 35 AD 119 492 spl. damages 657 <\ 2 AD 49M ISAC 495 lien 72 H demurrer 129 AD practices 128S estoppel 128S lien defense 157 AD 557 175n 645 services a 58 NY liSt 47 misfeasance 95 M 15 160 S 665 62 sureties 24 H 157 66 surrender 33 H 669 72 reformation a 65 NY 657 8 1 ext. allowance 29 H 476 33H 544 83 possession a 67 83 85 86 ejectment s 22 H 216 guardian 92 H . 241 proof supplied 19 M .51 20 M 654 661 \ 1 collision a 59 NY 292 1 06 weight ev. e 8 M 446 abuse discretion 9M 69 I I Svicious horse 80 AD 383 recovery 174S 699 I 32 contract e 42 H 576 1 54 relief 37 H 60 obstructing st, injunction 139 AD 272 123S 1014 1015 may unite 139 AD joinder 139 AD dedication 73 M 132 S 538I142S 464 908 431 383 272 273 99 442 167 courtyards 138AD 523 I 69 memoranda 8 AD 347 114 NY 284 150 NY 392 202 insurance d 42 H 249 205 law question 31 H 394 ABBUEVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished! t, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *. dismissed; n, note; ( i3 B 549 63 damages 64 B 361 66 construction e 2 M 206 68 laborer 46 H 339 71 new trial U M 7 \C 18AC 368 I96n 128n 209 517 74 overseer 4 jurisdiction 8 AD bastard 136S 1059 compliance f 216 NY 534 79 division fence 92 H 81 sewer .42 NY 3TC 152 87 authority t4H 185 final judgment 214 NY 601 101 construction d ,8 H 307 wife's necs. 64 H 88 6 TC 442 108 asm'd risk 200 1 50 admissions 2H 7 B 4TC reviaw 30 H 31 H new trial 40 H 63 B exceptions 82 H 75 NY 108 260 684n 627 469 235 156 198 294 1 72 consignee 67 NY 85 I 8 I sureties 19 H 593 1 90 CO. clerk II AG 222n 384 193 mortgage r 46 NY 384 notice 6LRA 2S6n 202 remedy 57 M 426 207 parol ev. 39 H 247 carrier 64 B 361 2 1 9 fixtures 26 H 204 222 repossession 284 422 617i 634 141 592! 273, d5 42 AD 109 AD 73 NY 17 H 69 H 68 B waiver el TC a 49 NY 666 8H 68 mitigation dam. 61 NY 249 123 NY 67 48 1 ouster r45NY 303 costs 5H 16 H 29 H 44 H 88 H 001 54 309 690 488 130 292 189 432 241 113 I2H 33 H 39 H I I I award 54 NY I 1 7 defense 39 H 121 estoppel 74 NY 92 125 demurrer 110 NY 409 contract (LRA 284 teleg. message 3LRA 601n 1 4 1- eviction a 45 NY 494 536 legal conclusion 23 M 67-6 objections 45 NY 192 force entry 127 AD 570 248 unconstit'I r 42 N\ 378 263 constitute a 41 NY 21 67 H 525 268 tort dam 42 NY 477 contract 58 NY 285 276 mtge. sale 6 281 34 H 59 60 H 11 conversion 66 H 260 282 sp. prfmo e dl9H 567 87 H 62 principal 46 H 160 75 NY 387 288 nuisance 8H 391 continuing 27 H 106 Bubsqt damagep 49 H 449 3 SS 496 not liable 98 M 317 162S 890 295 law action 348 dower 39 H 255 '67-8 38 I contribut a 67 NY 331 2 16 397 bailee m 46 NY 291 f 213 NY 258 innkeeper 17 AC 118n 125n counterclaim 151 S 688 enforce liabilty. ' 166 AD 136 405 sales in vio- lation of law a 45 NY 368 39 H 167 92 H 157 error deed 66 B 218 4 1 7con8iderat'n 4 166 51 H 611 436 appeal 14 H 492 sham pleadings 9 AC 167 171n sham denial 123 aD 813 443 limitations 96 349 373 197 472 212 676 484 board'g hse do 106 AD 435 488 eq. relief 124 NY 113 494 appeal a 52 NY 96 3 H 379 e 11 H 373 6 TC 190 86 US 686 remove cause 120 AD 449 508 curtesy r2 21 posthc-hild 69 H 668 368 36 2H 5H 21 H 51 H 101 AD 111 NY 15 M confirmation 27 H proofs 28 H sp'l proceeding 48 H 266 64 H 92 commencement 85 H 121 4 TC 686 5 SS 551 mistake 94 US 346 formal pleadings 2 AC 48 rectifying 4LRA 604n 45 I check a 64 NY 464 title a 43 NY 32 H 536 107 154 469 reference r 46 NY 4l8 19 H 390 474 partition a 42 NY 143 23 H 433 443 476 demurrer a 45 NY 676 M 80 10 AC 283-4n 16AC 245n ABBREVIATIONS: affirmed; d, distinguished; f. followed; -- — r;.".- -•-vV'""x' ,"' ■ ■-.-.-. —.—o-;."—, ...-.."">=«, i, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n. Bote; o, criticised; 1. limned; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q, questioned Vols. 2,3 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Lansing VOL. 2 I exi. expenses S M 135 146 «5M 143 141 10 AC 193n 9 contempt 3 412 1 2 creditors d27H receiver title 29 H 1 7 lodge 36 H partnership efllNY parties 2M must plead 14fiAD 130 S 564 70 S 565 225NY 828 172 94 evidence 8H new trial 14 H 486 misdirection 49 H 405 e 24 AD 265 406 2 I ten. curtesy 3H 8H 21 H ■6TC 54 NY 137 AD 695 610 382 144 287 23 transfer tax 137 AD 868 35 emblements r 49 NY 24 38 remedy 7 15 H 17 M ■expr, covenant 29 H 535 assign't mtge, 3LEA S76n ■41 \ritness 17 AC 386d publication f86M 149 S 417 90 32 647 460 43 legacy ^OH life estate ■99 NY 533 100 609 142 49 repudiation •63 NY -el2M 52 marriage a 46 NY advances 16AC 67 fraud '71 affidavit a 46 NY :24H jurisdiction 44 H 8 1 charge 23 H fraud 67 NY 133 US 170 80i S41 236 679 4, 600 676 90 Spl. Term power 445 477 428 202 360 797 14 H .d23H 26 H 32 H 144 AD ■costs review 41 H 214 92 H 465 •o£Fer and judgt o 63 NY 264 costs o65 B ilM 15 M SAO 5A0 costs 70 H 106 248 259 235n 236n 116 150 97 discharge d 1 H 453 d 3 TC 484 56 NY 406 106 partnreahip m 49 NY 97 adverse party 6H 255 16 H 509 e 1 TC 261 do 1 TC 264 1 20 limitations a 49 NY 153 authority payt. 4H 793 27 H 10 g 66 NY 356 1 27 good faith 82 AD 365 2 SA 435 filing mortgage 1 AC 87n 137 fraud agent a 47 NY 167 1 56 waiver 4H U4NY jurisdietion 40 H d50H 8H 32 H 35 H 37 H 44 11 SBH 2L,tiA joinder 77 NV 169 NY 325 260 BO-l 69U 264 647 41U 164 17 2 1 6 co-tenant 48 H findings 2TC 144 666 653 353 614 731 87 484 660 1 69 eubraissioD 193 NY 662 t 7 I cred r suit a 45 NY 892 lien 29 H 260 limitations 41 H 209 1 73 note ev. 47 NY 552 I 76 carrier a 49 NY ■ 12: 1 85 exemptions 36 H 584 586 41 24 26 556 124n 339n 49 H d3TC 1 119 NY e4 AC 10 AC pension 38 CP 180 192 possession 64M: 589 195 exemption 38 CP 187 1 99 carriers r 45 NY 524 206 opinion ev. 22 H 68 H 92 H 64 NY d77NY 299 207 126 596 180 2 I I co-tenant e 17 AD 40 AD 222 title a 47 NY 46 H good faith 71 H eq. redemption 86 H 127 227 arson r46NY 153 235 payment 9 H 8 79 NY 143 238 foreclosure m 46 NY 300 242 contempt 181 NY 469 41 H indictment 82 H 59 B 120 AD 137 AD TOM 71 411 544 48.49 8a7 580 335 exr. costs 5 H 555 67 B 378 340 partnership r 66 NY 288 contract void 5H 2S6 23 H 61 H 65 NY 17 M 346 water righta#9t. frauds r 47 NY S 65 B a 47 NY 16 H 446 bond r46Ny 130 502 253 364intereet el5NY 86NY 16 2 NY authority 127 AD 564 616 426 649 264 gift a 42 NY 362 265 carrier neg a«L,llA 511 267 appeal r 46 N if 539 parol evidence 43 H 272 legacy a 47 NY repugnancy 4H power sale 51 H 55 H executory 53 H 2SS 543 512 418 389 462 166 664 278 St frauds 1 TC 258 283 conclusive a 46 NY 689 4H 57 33 H 176 6 TC 243 287 guaranty 40 H 251 12 AC 266d 294 assessment a 46 NY 9H 10 H 68 H 48 NY 68 NY 46 508 210 78 104 556 300 insurance 2 H 442 305jointcontract 23 M 628 309 charge 6 266 corroboration 47 H 133 320 jurisdiction dl6H 6 329 perjury 1335 ' ' " 196 40'criminal intent 370 new trial a 43 NY 608 7H 227 25 H 274 cross examin, 50 H 48 1 TC 556 377bankruptcy r 47 NY 261 jurisdiction 63 B 344 assignee 65 B 452 383 consignee r 47 NY 619 H 381 386partne rs 68 H 176 47 M 446 ^89 liability 73 M 520 394 covenant 4H dl3H 25 H 137NY 6TC d56NY 5 30 H 3LRA U3NY eviction 148 S 186M 200 132 792 86 1071 48S 396 atty genl. 5 31 S3H 459 33 B 296 67 B 486 :8M 638 33 M 13? 220 NY 14 quo warranto 125 S 1049 jurisdiction 140AD authority il44S 158 AD 37 755 397atty. general 69M 549 127S 959 41 2 eq. assignee 480 65 NY 118 NY 333 35S 419 pun. dam 73 AD 333 recoupment 77 NY 291 422 fr'd grant »1 II 79 ervice notice e 84 H 493 433 signals 451 parol eolrtn 19 H 568 defense 19 H 621 trust 21H 73 equitable title 383 458 42 <27 519 470 death a47NY . presumption 2 rl actmn letters 4H e 101 AD decree evidence 6H 344 void conveyance 307 610 710 24: 19 H ITC 6TC jurisdiction 89NY title do 79 NY certiorari 112AD 477 negligence 161 486 296 833 371 604 6 3l 313 659 142 VOL.3 I f r'l alterations e55NY 10 M 151AD 135S 8 bond 7 63 H 418 361 130 207 430 216 authority mot, 8 AD 225 3 TC 436 1 4 estoppel a50N Y 222 26 stt-ict const'n 67 AD 437 d 104 AD 75 IM 11 Stat, limitations 109 AD 111 exception 17 AC 266 highly penal 95 M 2 29 notice a 57 NY 641 375 check payment 67 B 4iH 12 M limitation 16 M discharge 23 M proof loss 128 AD 34 usury fH 3TC 329 636 21 318 86 H 4 TO e 6TC 60 NY bond void 5 M 21 108 621 368 503 5 548 2 390 I I 6 agency dl5H 65 AD 87 H d77NY valid contract 10 H pers liability 61 B 148 consideration II M 370 1 29 lis pendens a 49 NY 478 9 AC 82n 1 34 expiration 23 H 366 I 36 cross exam. memoranda 76 AD 375 12AC 6n 99 1 48 review 63 AD 60 133 434 513 486 carriers a 43NY 598 3 201 4H 376 6TC 624 492 conversion r49NY 164 498 decision 6,1 N Y 587 506 negligence a 49 NY 21 H " H SOB e 62 B S AD d 88 AD doSl NY ITC STO e 112 US 672 606 388 32 220 616 71 72 626 323 360 4 391 53 irregular 5 111 37 M restitution 50 AD 82 AD 90 H false imprismt. 97 NY 598 order valid 45 H 103 NY 3SS estoppel 46 H arrest error 126 AD vacate order 114 782 188 655 566 136 90 52 281 45 64H validity 102M 168S 284 181 SOO 57 delivery t 3 H 361 24 H 296 109 NY 450 competent ev. 5 TO 492 68 incomppt. ev. 6H 116 74 certiorari f3 81 strict constructn 37 AD 46 80 renewal motn 4 AC 37n 86 warranty r 49 NY 269 16 H 276 1 5 1 assessment r 49 NY 349 28 H 31 1 55 fiduciary 24 H 476 e 52 NY 408 68 NY 273 e 111 US 680 i 60 CO. bridges a 52 NY 23 25 H 21 e 68 NY 116 I 67 atty fees 56 NY 89 incumbrance e 66 NY 39 172 subj. equit. 5L11A 2911. f 73 men. capao inquisition ev. 6H 658 8H 329 gifts only 51 M 90 174 recovery do 126 AD 806 I 76 open close d 42 H 177 56 NY " 406 I 78 injunction a 45 NY d 57 B- dismissal 59 B I 84 renewal notes IH d3TC 637 449 294 170 703 1 86 waiver objns 22 H 13 M c91 AD 20 1 carrier a 47 NY 68 H e26AD 2 1 3 custom r49NY lOSiUegality 4H 35511 H 8 H 346 3 TC 17 H 478[ comp'ng felony 1216 usury 52 149 383 658 601 594 652 220 698 AUBKKVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; c. criticised ; 1, limited ; e, explained ; o, overruled ; 1 f. followed'; r, reversed; m, modilied; ", dismissed; n, note, , same case ; do., dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, queationed N. 7. Supreme Court Reports — Lansing Vols. 3, 4 25 AD dl5H surety 31 H 517 567 438 220 preference 29 M e 104US 224 repeal 3H 5TC 30 308 480 588 234 warranty 52 NY ' 421 238 ratification 8H 244 notice 77 H Caches 4 AC execution 4. AC 54 386 351n 249 prfmance 6LRA 326n competent proof 6LEA 323n 255 declarations mSO NY 352 34 H 223 26 1 posResBion 26 H 662 265 bill 170S partic. 1008 270 lawqueBtion a 49 NY 657 70 H 254 privity ITC 297 278 use stream a 49 NY do 24 AD 9H trespass 2M damages 4M 283 denial el7M 672 628 353-4 434 240 29 1 certiorari a 45 NY 772 17 H 381 299 fraud m47NY 410 327disbarment 86 NY 673 333 lawguestion 8 H ' 228 demand 15 H 25 €7 B 410 338 stk transfer r 49 NY 286 341 insurance r 45 NY 422 348 bequests m43NY 157 S corpn. trust 60 AD deOAD 45 H 47 H construction 191NY decreases «2 M f 92 M 157 S 391 restrictions 2LRA 387n 424 672 334 336 371 61 275 394 ben. society r 46 NY 477 398 contract 4 275 e 13 AD 40 408 eontempt a 5 486 101 NY 247 4 1 7 shippine a43Nir 42 1 Bgenov 33 H notice 52 587 427 expulsion 48 H 508 428 ehg. a 61 NY 43 M venue 47T 116 429 park lands r 145 NY 234 434 restoration r63NY r6 443 carrier r49NY (53 NY 103 172 304 609 453 damages a 49 NY 420 66 B 340 469 negligence a 49 NY 673 26 312-3 50 H 171 NY 474 title e38 H H jurisdiction 40H 484 powers 28 H 30 H a 49 NY 54 NY 492 usury r49NY 633 536 483 31 241 243 66 373 509 mortgagor a 5^ NY 599 5 1 2 prior lien 4H 15 H 53 H 55 H s60B 519 bank a 52 NY 526 mistake r47NY 4H 6TC 337 339 176 147 409 VOL.4 I wife's service IH 366 husb. appearance 21 H 440 3 TO 61 rescission f 159 AD 697 6TC 442 4 performance 3TC 7 IH 42 H warranty d63B d52NY 708 175 576 523 421 1 36 centerst. 86 H 429 error charge 86 H title 5M penalty eieu tU easement 181 NY 319 147 expulsioa 21 AD 194 damages 88 H 182 8 eq. assignmt e 16 H 291 45 H 335 60 NY 447 1 7 penalties r50NY 314 24 power city 40 AD 336 76 NY 396 25 M 220 136 NY 411 34 partnership a 53 NY 627 28 H 222 41 rescission 111 AD 30 H 34 H 125 S reformation 61 M no reform 140 AD mistake fact do 213 NY 456 874 516 215 397 536 433 61 636 I 58 assessor a 47NY 19 H domicile 33 H iurisdistioD do 51 NY 655 19S 581 1» 164 marital con- tract e7 28 do 7 33 5 TO _ 516 earnings wife 14AC 211 n e 6 TO 466 do 6 TO 467 4H 173 separate contract e4H 175 8H 316 19 H 281 79 H 306 d 62 B 640 conversion 20 H 473 3 61 {limitation 67 B ; wife right sue ILEA 128 f3H e3H do 64NY e65M delivery el5H power in trust 179AD 224 X66S 629 263 exemptions 472 476 354 83 458 607 24 S5 26 120 12i 692 292 360 31 45 4 7diver8ion watr 8H 691 35 H 56 198 272 339 65 NY 171 NY misjoinder 166 NY 187 126 AD 663 14 AC 46 n cause action 1 45 AD 161 134S 045 63 right way 7 263 fact question lUNY 45 67 authority a 47 NY 360 43 H 621 oO presumption 91 AD 306 308 95 AD 112 AD 30 H 128M 93 US construction 89 NY 539 446 268 687 301 399 90 truest 25 H 343 e 26 H 699 .601 1 03 warranty a 54 NY 686 1 06 consignee 1 69 adv posses 37 AD 61 18 H 286 57 H 827 8 AC 7.0 n 99 US «59 1 82 ne exeat 6H 379 5 SS 630 1 86 payment 73 AD 530 foreign admr f 35H 185 36 M 156 mtge. security 144 AD 248 195 surety 25 H 18S a 54 NY 127 NY 500 446 412 I 1 4 wife 65 B separate estate 1 TC 141 ^ 2 TC 106 |2 TC 107 198 requests 16AC 330d 202 insurance e 55 NY 177 208 junsdiction 8 AD 517 65 H . 398 civ. proceeding 60 H 844 disqualification d 77 NY 111 16AC 394n 399 n 2 1 3 infants 81 NY 2 14 fraud r60NY 569 AD 24 AD 67 AD 6 57 AD AD 20 H demad 6H, 8H 19 H 37 NY selection 9H measure dam, 14 H 273 conversion 18 H 467 waiver 69 H 271 10A0111n39 6-8n damages I 51 NY 666 283 party wall a 60 NY 639 291 relief 61 H 459 70 H 513 adv. possession 86 NY 68 30 1 satisfaction r 50 NY 396 307 cond. prcd. 136AD 772 3 1 4 ejectment SO M 636 388 divorce estp 60 AD 602 e 62 AD 447 jurisdiction 9H 13 H 36 H 15 H sS7B e2TC 7 AC e 10 AC 72 NY 80 M 624 417 41B 71 305 648 649 50n 158 228 112 500devise widow 48 H 375 evidence 61 H 113 5 1 3 corpn. note a 64 NY 679 101 US 194 523 trespass r 66NY e88AD 37 H d 104 NY 261 195 378 233 counterclaim f 140 S 780 not estoppel 78 M 575 separation 80 M 110 392 no estoppel 138 S 641 393 dower a 57 NY 20 AD 528 bonding 17 H 380 defect petition d 93 NY 418 do 93 NY 426 99 NY 333 251 337 625 a 52 NY 33 H title ITC > dowable 146 S eq. title f 160 AD 335 reformation a TC 579n 339 eq. suit a 54 NY 661 82 H 133 137 e 82 H 134 369 cr. suit 53 NY 260 3 74 power court 88 H irregular 154AD 130 S conclusive 185AD 172S 411 586 191 276 803 322 69 399 exceptions 10 H Interest 37 H 409 audit 75 AD bonds town 1 H 2TC 4TC do 104 AD 64 NY a 49 NY 532 593 214 556 112 119 61 1152 662 421 wife husb e7 28 34 husb. witness 17 H . 493 wife rights 18 H 20 H 62 B q 62B 67 B 5TC 49 NY e 135 NY 361 473 640 641 369 516 514 206 377 execution 468 291 436 114 480 136 230 construction e 5TC 599 e 5TC 608 e 3H 466 trust deed 7H 34 H alimony 18H d21H 21 H commitment 25 H 689 96 NY 493 judgment irreg. 26 M 70 149 NY 527 380 certiorari e 10 H 349 verdict e 27 M 306 evidence 426 negligence r 67 NY 236 433 insurance a 50 NY 402 agency do 213 NY 455 440 discretion 37 M 696 444 cr. suit a 67 NY 587 446 damages a 59 NY 637 45 I mandamus r 57 NY 344 467 award dSONY 33 H 493 232 473 alimony 7 AC 256n 267n 482 equity 80 NY 606 483 stkholders. 2LRA 650n 484 burial lot d 36 H 426 487 indictment d 79 NY 657 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; ', dismissed: n note-' c, criticiaed; 1, limited; e, explained; o. overruled; s, same case; do. dissenting opinion; p. parallel case; q, que'stioned Vols. 5, 6 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Lansing VOL.5. 93 limitations 16AC 303n 304n joinder 580 126 AD 7 gift ID 47 NY 102 AD 600 lOObadfaitli 90 NY 334 consideration 102M 159 168S 635 assignment ^ 103M 451?^«stf!;ror 171S 335 I I directory 48 H consent d37M presumption 113AD 163 S powers 168 AD 153 S 365 549 378 475 1073 1 6 corporation a 60 NY 236 7 438 negligence dam IH 10 H 24 H s60B 4TC 5TC 671 479 13 378 124 624n 25 party int. r 67 NY 161 e 67 B 486 extr allowance 90 NY 674 92 NY 404 43 sidewalk dSH 532 d 5 TC 623 624n lo'e ^. pleading 23 H 215 NY 51 foreclosure a 50 NY 51 H 69 H 84 H redemption 2TC a 54 NY 230 contract 563 e 92 H 552 fact question 3M 518 45 jurisdiction 12 H 50 H 61 M 126 AD I 1 5 salary e 73 AD 86 220 NY 90 intent 22 H 442 443 1 29 good faith 99 NY 333 1 37 limitations 37 H 37 1 49 cloud title 136 2 AC 206 243 at. frauds 299 110 AD 321 a OS NY IH e3TC 90 352 402 582 250 negligence a 61 NY 237 d70H 154 261 cross exam 213 189 r63NY 51 H . 53 relief a 65 NY 98 NY 1 56 surety 16 AD do 15 AD 20 U I 60 trust a 61 NY 1 65 legacy d25H 29 H 36 396 314 418 174 184 277 88 166 NY tjR void Inpart 74 48M f 70 association 468 m 65 B 668 510 amendment 36 38 CP 416 324 warranty "3SS 391n 329 discretion 24 H 546 45 1 award ■■ 52 NY 332fact question s 7 6 461 witness 63 B a 45 NY 67 H 267 bonds r54 NY IH 8H 660 556 153 coror. highway 25 H e2TC 4TC 34 M 64 NY 517 112 119 571 U5 116 275 insurance 4H 801 e 13 H 25 162 AD 284 147 S 608 insur. interest 18 H ' waiver 2TC *8f do 66 NY 26 73 NY 377 280 damages _ 61 NY 513 99 NY d99NY 337 services 35 H 188 mother 56 NY 438 do 56 NY 446 340 variance d 6 H 442 344 neg. dam a47 NY 665 6 263 20 AD 266 57 NY 500 85 NY 263 350 m. prosecu. s 63 B 145 a 65 NY 385 352 certiorari 57 H 284 353 damages 13iAD 558 454 seduction 72 170 588 634 23 H 29 H 54 H 56 NY 46 1 injunction a 52 NY 510 466 hab corpus 2H 232 4 TC 473 d 69 NY 639 486 advances 355 illegal lOlM 580 545 103 168S 273 358 rescission 691 a 61 NY 285 allegations 491 222NY 380 493 6 I oflBcer de jure 6H forfeiture 67 NY defacto 76 NY 77 NY . 73 m. lien 519 a 49 NY 37 H 657 402 238 387 67 damages r56 NY 8H 31 H I 77 contract 70 NY 206 uncorroborated 46 m 241 1 83 assignment d 60 H 437 585 394 444 69 jurisdiction c 16 H 176 41 H 698 599 76 H 546 complaint 8 AC 378n 7 1 distinction 13 AD 445 oral contract 5H 98 78 purchaser 18 H demand f 19H 80 sureties r61 NY 84 damages dl3H protection 76 NY 89 bonding el7H 457 630 205 303 s5 forfeiture 39 H s60B lien d53NY 511 362 contract 73 H intent 65 NY 17 265 365 alteration , 64 H 91 332 5 "NY 60 ' pleadings 42 H ' 287 memoranda 639 391 181 293 negligence a 57 NY 20 AD privity 85 NY 372 mech. lien a 65 NY 196 warraoty 48 AD breach 22 H 30 H 65 NY 100 NY 113 NY e 116 NY 18M 32 M. eviction 148 S d86M obligation 90 M f 152 S 405 425 131 510 477 87 507 517 551 1071 488 151 951 298 award 2SA 113 NY 30 \ conversion : 144 NY 566 mitigation 66M 155 1 99 covenant 2LRA 334n 203 insurance a 50 NY 45 206 ejectment 175 r 65 NY 134 3 1 8?presumption 8H 412 420 30 H 253 3 TC 1^ 381 222 subscription! 109 NY 324 367 2 1 4 damages r 61 NY 496 296 263 247 660 304. warranty evidence 72 H 102 NY 163 NY 27 47 505 614 229 419 169 VOL.6. I probate rSONY a 52 NY new trial 104M 172S 5 damages i54NY 438 77 AD 9H e20H 24 H 90 H s63B objections 2TC 143 NY c^^mpetent fav. 136AD 687 623 •281 519 214 461 293 644 217 268 1 28fact question 242 iD 79& 625 8 TC 425 248 lateral support "1 LRA 692 522 I I damages llAC 139 n ILRANS 450 (6 iueompetev. a 61 NY 618 16 H 590 presumption 132 NY^ 497 map control 186AD 395 straight line 169 AD 262 2 1 ins. policy a SO NY 837 375 498 appl. «Tor 26 H 5 1 I damages 8H . 48 22 H 512 - ,^ sureties 145 84 H 558 659 prelim, injuncts 8 AC 468n 473n 8 AC 477n479D not recover 339 f 167 AD 98 152 S 672 25 receiver 39 AD 158 234 pleading 60 AD admr. rights 24 H 300 f'd transfer 41 H comity e56H eSAG B9NY demurrer 114 NY 376 joint bridge r 65 NY 322 3H 602 5 TC 595 94 NY 515 380 void deed' m 57 NY 637 e35AD HI 392 mistake 159 AD 144 S 397 title a 65 NY 21 H reservation 45 H 516 amendment -„, r 57 NY 112 105 d90 NY 548 200 NY 204 relief 128 136AD 482 □o amendment 136AD 48S 5 1 9 contract a 161 NY • 477 532 description ILRA ■ 298 n 219 343 307 demand a 67 NY 360 3 1 bounties IH 429 public policy 3 TC 596 3 1 3 delivery 64 B 396 71 NY 296 57 78 209 293 407 appearance 639 r 66 NY 179 9 3TC 32 error relief 184 NY 100 545 new trial a 49 NY 216 5H 111 14 H 612 proof interest 15 H 77 73 H 36B 75 domicile weight evidence 470 165 369 25 prom, note 66 NY 564 1 34 sureties r 61 NY 659 d 66 NY 332 1 46 payment a 61 NY 637 1 49 remedv 62 AD 496 s 63 B 468 review evidence e 74 NY 421 1 55 domicile a 61 NY 609 83 M 269 ■ 1 58 t;.'ade mark r 61 NY 226 1 62 interpleader r61NY 264 1 66 waiver *g 801 7H 456 10 H 399 13 H 194 1 TC 399 609 do 66 NY 28& 448 1 72 mandamus r 53 NY IDS 1 76 trespass 33 CO. treasurer » 55 NY a 69 NY 646 i on „ i „• false claim 19 M not final 66M 325 123 S «09 mutual acct'g. 66M 825 99 «nD I ou rei ^"^elTC V license '22M consent 60 NY new trial 57 M 44 et martial a 50 NY 274 50 partition a 62 NY 118 56 prom, note d 63 H 252 71 insurance 140 S 1047 liability 156 AD 146 6TC 547 87 M 79 damages r67NY 196 4 1 6 presumption a 69 NY 6 remedies 28 AD 90 AD 35 H 10 M 19 M 1 AC 133 127 601 423 102 678 134 274 436 neg damage a 69 NY 356 443 deViee 82 redemption a 65 NY 39 H trustee ee9H 92 notice S M 74 NY assessment 144 NY OS 336 598 225 561 1 85 assessment r 65 NY 616 130 NY 405 201 forfeiture a 61 NY 204 2H 542 3 TC 481 482 5 TC 121 206 judicial 4H 685 74 H 342 2 1 9 reformation e 7 H 395 waiver 26 H 109 68 225 assessment e 37 H 378 title centr st. 683 41 AD 69 42 S8 193 477 I 00 life insur r S3 NY 144 I 1 2 damages r 61 NY 34 116 assessment IrSSNY 49 55 e 88 AD 195 12 AC 379n381n e 104 NY 233 stone owner land 3LRA 832n 228 guaranty 80 NY 271 234 execution a 66 NY 30 17 H 57 30 H 17fl 251 mandamus 13 AD 37 95 AD 403 d44H 158 159 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note c, criticised; 1, limited; e, nxolained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, dissenting; opinion ; p, parallel ease ; q, question*" N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Lansing Vols. 6, 7— Thompson & Cook Vol. 1 *t 100 235 71 H 67 B 2TC 14 M construction 34 AU 26 H 39 H 40 H 255 damage! a SO NY 593 262 damages 11 AD 126 271 trusteea 7 95 do 92 AD 426 joinder 67M 261 proper parties 67M; 261 280 iiiriog e 9 AD 483 fact question ' '~ 546 466 176 206 638 29 349 131 390 408 464 a 53 NY *78 ,,„ 67 356 will trust IH construction 4H 565 statutory 414" ■■ 21 AD 62 AD e24H 35 H 611 15 M 22 M d35M d 101 NY 163 NY vendee arbiter ILRA 646 cond. precedt. . 6LRA 272 construction 127 AD 371 282 assessor 19 H 296 limitation 497 347 351 522 272 a 61 NY 9 AD do 9 AD 22 AD trustees e20H not accepted f 214 NY 443 299 judgment 10 H 510 f39H 151 152 neg, damages 642 6 duress 72 18 H 486 acknowledgem't 742 e 4 AC 161n 199 9 AC 46n 7H 620 I 1 contrib neg. ooi u 2H 538 3ol eontrb, neg. 2 TC 646 i53NY 215 NY allegations 62 AD 10 AC 98 NY 654 5 TC 74 577 174 119 403 waive lien 20AC 126n 408 easement 7 55 35 M 673 41 I ultra Tiies a 65 NY IH waiver 7H 13 H 4TC -95 US 66 NY 420 carriers a 62 NY 195 1203 466 194 16 183 23 262 430 negligence ii 36 N if 1 437 award a 66 NY 359 440 rescission 195 a 61 NY 614 37 H 126 92 H 392 o£fe return 88 AD 63 to jury 80 M prerequisite 80 M 40 H d67H relief SAC trespass 64M 19A0 342 629 296n 434 367 tenant liable 137 AD 511 affirmance 185AD 190 172S 842 303 attachment d 39 H 39 4 AC 349n 306 affidavit e 18 H 123 judicial 2TC 146 equitable action 3 TC 297 457 credibility 18 M 464 meas. dam e 10 U 469 damages a 53 NY 472 notice a 55 NY 26 H 482 parol 97 M 162 S 485 claim 16 AD VOL.7 75 NY 1 4 contract a 61 NY 1 9 services s62B SS 124 279 a 52 NY 450 444 531 423 36 discontinue 54 AD 178 7 AC 437n e 8 AC 509 fraud atty. 167 NY 609 572 39 reversal 56 AD 46 acquiescence 15 H 603 discretion 25 H d64NY 493 636 55 easement a 56 NY 275 23 H 437 59 H 281 57 easement f 87 M 215 62 carrier neg. a 61 NY 638 72 mortgage a 62 NY 243 75 penalty *50NY 245 IH 3TC 631 336 660 249 90 legaov 8H .^ 12 H 688 d 5 M rule 24 M ig minors 32 M accounting 326 e 36 M 301 preferred e42M 87 M fl49S 1 3 I presumption a 52 NY 409 17 M 359 false imprismt 97 NY 59 103 NY 838 1 45 expulsion 92 H 24.3 damages 186AD 823 revocation 203 NY 358 1 5 1 trade mark transitory rl,. 9n.=>NY 217 NY 440 246 220 certiorari 147 S 83 M 370 parol ev. r66NY 36 AD IH 3TC eSAC i 6 1 waiver *59NY 4H 6TC license 4 AC 1 67 refund r56NY 6 AC 1 74 pledgee a 52 NY 115 370 376 662 69n 681 317 562 349n 641 9n 232 1 77 commissions 6M 32 M 19 AC jury que 129 AD two parties 123 S brokerage 67 M 1 80 attachment 374 144 468n 560 779 20 H 9 AC 166 NY 17ft levied '° 139 AD execution 123 S 38 460 128 2H 29 H 72 H 13 IAD review 36 AD 4TC 225 intent a 58 NY e IIM express trst 195 NY 236 trust 127 NY 170 NY alien inherit 14AD 7J 160 654 535 211 toTC ^„„ LL.U.A 368 r 64 NY 567 376 notice SO d 43 H 29 38 1 limitation a 56 N Y 334 592 do 31 U 49U 440 statute frauds 3 TC 780 100 431 408 425n igs I 8 I f'd represtD -°r66NY 39 I 86 discharge r 65 NY 445 617 229 37 3 1 3 dower 42 AD 408 3 1 9 negligence a 56 NY a 61 NY e 117 NY 5 TO 332 robbery r63NY 347 burglary 174 542 148 24 476 493 equities 130 S 329 larties proper (1 M 278 502 p. transactn a 6'6 NY 107 2H 440 5TC 3 5 I 2 services s21H 366 92 H 274 5 1 6 books ev 18 H 444 98 title 62 AD trust estate 12 M void sale 154 S 169 AD 370 130 94 447 509 925 475 832 255 1 06 exemption 584 687 42 187 574 36 H -36H e49H 38 OP presumption 60 H gift 3TC I 8S 4 AC 10 AC assignment 90 NY I I 7 partners 17 H 1 1 2 I construction 42 24 125n 39gn 226 591 199 127 434 106 1 93veat'd rem'dr a 56 NY IH 4H 4TC 6TC 197 bank 25 H not payment 159 AD 746 payment f 144 S 981 204 alimony 7 AC 243n 136S 34i superseded 136S 342 240 ultra vires i 145 VS 406 ILRA 850D 249 reaerv'n 78 H 113 17 M 112 330 NY 471 forfeit easement 101 AD 671 18AC Sin. 57fi 16 AC 59 62 easement do 129 AD 842 264 authority a 55 NY 495 d 41 H 484 274 quowarran *55 NY S2S 304 dissolution 54 H 366 non-user 126 NY 44 314 sp. pfmanoe a 65 NY 663 43 M 96 3 I 7 dividend 26 H 440 transfer stock' ' e 47 H 148 7 6 NY 371 J 22 in junction r 664 NY 33 33 I accounting a 56 NY 621 340 appointmt a 77 NY 612 345 f'd convey 4H 642 67 B 210 3 TC 254 34 7 sale sheriff 43 H 685 49 H 159 s 64 B 64!: 393 presumption e 42 H 37» e 12 M 492 405 receiver 45 AD 363 4 1 2 revocation t 44 M 423 4 1 9 limitation 9 AD 346 347 498 206 penalty a 53 NY 32 H trustee 62 H ,, dl31NY 4911493 606 407 441 60 817n 401 14b 428 bond 03 H jud'l notice nua 182AD negligence 6T0 a 59 NY 20 contract a 68 NY 341 352 taxpayer a59N-r 4TC 210 lex loci 8H 11 H 64 B 20oNY jurisdiction 2M 7 AC 258 183 212 43.=. 510 56nl 359 life estate a 55 NY 3H limitation elll NY e33H 33 H 73 H valid trust 5 TC purchasers 93 US equity 676 4S 216 534 621 432 252 16t 264 n 440 foreclosure 52 NY 679 443 test oapac 27 M 194 39M 66 »2NY 79 undue influence 63NY 519 70NY 403 77 NY 641 452 incomp. ev. 47 H 42 reformation 146 S 697 161 AD 710 456 warranty 18 M 248 459 nuisance U H 596 87 NY 428 462 penalty - 44 H 496 20 M 121 47 I damages a 65 NY 1 481 jurisdiction 610 208 97 692 74 VOL I I review judgt 4 76 718 3 contract e3 582 acceptance proof 2M 126 5 acceptance 24 H 81 evidence 83 NY 74 I jurisdiction a 56 NY ■ 636 91 H 498 1 3 insurance r 58 NY 95 1 4 canal contract r 56 NY 368 I 6 fraud pleadg. 156 672 23 new trial r 68 NY 193 5 467 468 36 ejectment r 56 NY 157 42 trespass dam r 58 NY 186 45 pleading 124 S 170 60 waste 3 damages d63M 61 62 38 82 will bequest a 60 NY 644 surplus profits 89 US 637 91 guard' n eject. 22 H 216 94 NY 479e480 97 administratn s46 92 B 4H 425 126 NY 201 I I certiorari 1 221n f 3 798 I I 6 rent ctr.clm a 66 NY 420 slH 37 H slTC r4TC 3 6SB a^ignee 112 NY distribution 126 NY 492 realty m53NY 62 H dower 30 M UAC 506 fiduciary a 56 NY 5 1 1 trover 2M I.- 122 i aep. NY 134 201 351 301 401 398n 285 118 1 30 town bonds 34 H 145 'imitations 2LRA 829n. S30n 1 39disseizcedam r 68 NY 650 I 45 improp. ev. 3 . 332 decision reservd dS 681 s 65 B 493 reserved objn. 64 NY 370 I 48 malice proof 98 US 193 jury question 113AD 437 1 50 taxp'r suit 3 297. ABBREVIATIONS: a, afBrmed ; d, distinguished ; f. folio wed ; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; c. .r,r,cised: 1. limited: e. explained : o, overruled; s. same Case ; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case: q, questioned! Vols. 1, 2 N. T. Supreme Court Reports— Thompson & Cook 51 adr possn. 630 1 58 office title *55 NY 625 1 9 1 compliance e 14 M 126 1 93 discoDt hwy 2 353 54 AD 483 96 AD 60 d 67 NY 62 1 95 salary r S5 NY 74 209 sureties r 60 NY 421 21 I absolute fee 61 AD 12 construe will 35 H e 88 NY 232 2 1 5 insurance a 68 NY 677 221 estoppel 1 428n 226 claim vs hus 48 H 164 kanowl'gt 37 H 506 229 acknowlgnt. 19A0 42 6n 235 prepond ev 4 685 15 H 234 243 neeligen ev. r 63 NY 522 a 3 776 247 estoppel 5 534 25 I contract a 68 NY 674 142 S 161 142 S 169 presumption 142 S 161 36 1 discharKe 60 H 520 do 118NY eq. defence 102 AD rescission 163 NY 356 259 stay 2 469 266 devisee 44 H 317 280 injunction 11 311 289 impeacbmt 76 AD 605 290 neg. master 6 560 297fact question a 56 NY 660 6 500 601 4 H 162n 67 AD 218 309 injunction a 65 NY 391 319 master neg. a 60 NY 607 2 664 neg. coemploye 370 appeal 19 H 613 direction report 144 NY 411 377 mutuality 36 H 56 383 CO, court 71 NY 483e484 388 "children 131 NY 460 396 gift husb. 74 NY 122 397 parol waiver a 59 NY 1 6 595 9H 423 10 H 399 400 ineolvt bnk. r 59 NY 5 403 consent e6 342 6H 561 7 AC 409n 406 excess, tax r 58 NY 628 e6 45 413 taxation a 58 NY 402 4 1 5 fishery a 60 NY 57 4 1 8 partnership a 68 NY 272 422will contents 32 M 194 423 legisl power 4 H , 440n 425 certif. dept a 68 NY 314 486children heirs 35 H 250 e 127 NY 171 parol ev. 62 M 544 504 pub policy 17 H 405 506 declarations 20M 610 509 ptnrs realty 13 AC 143n 526 notice neg. 435 rr sprks neg a 58 NY 437 revoke will e 25 H 538 88 NY 381 87 M 475 150 S 1069 alter will 129 AD 586 original form 135AD 747 must probate 141 S 715 446 ferry neg. r 6 NY 656 22 H 37 448 declaratns. 63 NY 191 192 452 inj. servant r 56 NY 724 466 mistake rec. a 69 NY 649 «o »Tir ,_, 477 acquiescence r 62 NY 47U 16 M 160 351 burden prf. I483 release void 14 H 324 appeal 19 H amendment 37 M 333 assault r60NY 448 6I0 613 221 339 Insurance 433 repeal a 59 NY 228 46 167 537corp.tort neg a 58 NY 640 541 estoppel 5 114 554 cross exam, e 67 H 189 559 legal title f3 322 326 564 ruing except 3 347 572 judicial not 126S 998 compliance 141AD 609 575 charge waiv 2 424 81 NY 345 581 perpetuity e 26H 656 " case 1 appeal 4 79 6 718 4 assumptn. fact 6H 119 6 guardian bond r 58 NY 666 3 insolv. case 2 f 1 add 13 2 1 assumptn fact easel s2 35 H 119 22 excessive tax 5 44 23 neg. damag( a 69 NY 28 6 137 d 131NY 657 347 590fact question r58NY 469 2 395 e69H 523 by jury f 172 AD ■ 50 f 158 S 288 598 mortgagee a 58 NY 664 6 1 I taxn ship a 68 NY 242 s3 678 679 622 attestation 7H 293 27 H 34 execution e 67 NY 416 626 trade mark 8 AC 67n 630 taxn corpn r 69 NY 40 647 partition a 66 NY 359 649 estoppel 9H 479 stay 90 NY 5 discharge pldg. 13AGlnllnl3n 65 1 satisfaction a 68 NY 623 36 H 561 657 appraiser fee 63 NY 357 665 serv. process 8 AG 404n 406n 2 Addenda VOL.2. . practice * 59 NY 233 4 658 1 1 ptnr acctg. 52 H 43 8 audit h6 IKS cond. precedent 58 NY 306 70 NY 4B7 25 revrs error 5 462 20 H 168 d 26 M 574 reformation 2 M 180 55 assessment 5 34« 57 authority 16 H 494 62 construction 96 NY 581 76 city's dock s4 5% 40 AD 614 implied repeal 8M 209 unlawful sheds e 110 NY 579 680 care 134 NY 2 220 2 1 9exciBe lionse 6 600 orim ofifense 3 H 237n legislat.power e 64 H 489 224 arrest 168S 73 225 transfers a 68 NY 647 247 life insurnce r 69 NY 556 3 578 4 586n 259 overflo.dam 115 NY 212 26 1 parol ev. a 69 NY 521 275 excavtn da. a 68 NY 682 89 423 waiver ev. a 69 NY 655- 81 NY 345 427 estoppel a 58 NY 681 e 24 H 306 43 I assRflsmpnt 53 H 281 waste 465 83 adv. user 58 NY 662 88 will construe a 58 NY 336 1 04 note wife r 63 NY 639 10 H 604 1 08 town bonds 4 119 IH 656 64 NY 115 604 I 1 4 amendmt 3 695 118, e311 irotest 91 1 40 lay out sts. do 85 NY 14 157 challenge 205 NY 104 I 72 non-support 13 M 297 e 36 M 537 defenses 19A0 ITOn 1 75 reversal 10 H 610 181 estate vestg a 58 NY r2 3 5 32 H 3Sa 37 M 95 NY 186 NY 662 212 630 108 76 18 119 120 616 108 construction do 186 NY 123 do 124 183 judgment a 68 NY 662 2 1 2 abortion ev. a 56 NY 96 60 434 boundary r 58 NY 437 446 sale defec r 58 NY 359 458 rightswavr a 69 NY 374 5 447 460 construction a 59 NY 140 24 H 111 284 cond sale 10 AC 227i! 292 resettlement a 59 NY 342 8H 648 299 sheriff demd a 69 NY 22< 302 insurance 586 309 recovery 76 NY 552d 553 3 1 I notice file d 10 H 508 limited 81 M 565 distinction 81 M 566 3 1 8 practice a 59 NY 451 illegal lOlM 580 168S 545 324 assumption 36 H 119 330 bequest vd. m 69 NY 435 d 35 H 408 342 guaranty ev do 4 SS 51 350 coverture e4 632 360highway attn r 63 NY 306 370 assumption a 69 NY 649 35 H 119 375 delay excuse 11 M 617 380 contract sal e 21 M 427 no hailment 131AD 393 383 larceny e 83 AD 233 388 ruling excpt 724 467 costs 12 H 7 AC 404 discretion 38 H 423 chastity e 163 NY 96 416 intent 23 H 481 691 273n 470 appeal order d2 574 res judicata 24 H 35U 471 undertaking 2 AC 376n 475 indenture a 59 NY 629 reverse errors 123AD 208 486 no power 148AD 772 491 affidavit e 6 283 36 H 224 amend 83 M 526 498 pers. repres 40 M 96 decree 126 AD 774 rule pleadg 130 AD 345 set up facts 206NY 370 501 jury trial *56NY 6 26 H e25H 192 146 493 494 ,395billlading 2 1 6 res judicata 1 a 60 NY 40 5 1 5 naturalizn s 35 H 166 8M 483 532 slander 118 NY 183 538 partition a 58 NY 388 fees referee e 16 H 12 40M 390 401 e 40 M 396 13 AC 41 5a 545 discretion 6M 318 562 exceptions * 68 670 4 650 ABBREVIATIONS c, criticised ; 1, limited ; e, explained affirmed; d, distinguished; f. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; same case ; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; a. questioned , overruled ; N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Thompson & Cook Vols. 2, 3, 4 s4 674 case 1 m60NY 568 jiiriBdiotion ow*"^ 263 664 neg. master 9H 2SHea9e2 insolvency ., a i 10 H 394 ' ° ' 575 form will i9A0 37 M 708 675 appeal 577 foreclosure case 1 * 58 NY 625 • 68 NY 582cov'Dt repair d 17 H 100 100 AD 498 117AD 207 129 AD 543 covenants 69 M 475 136 269 586 construction 63 H 488 600 insur fund 59 NY 163 602 costs chrgea el8M 417 608 services a 58 NY 676 6 1 4 f 'd transfer a 59 NY 656 limitations 85 M 53-1 675 admx payt case 2 r 68 NY 66; addenda 6 parties r 59 NY a 58 stip NY 682 62 1 arrest a 59 NY 31U 623 implied war. p 60 NY 18 M 528 247 626 f'd transfer e 28 H 415 634preBumption 46 H 340 637 em. domain • 56 NY 144 638 appeal 2 638 64 1 survivor a 68 NY 69 644 negligence r 68 NY 248 e6 125 647 estoppel 62 AD 447 13H 417 10 AC 159 counterclaim f 340 S 7S0 653 compenaatn a 58 NY 623 e 25 AD 477 34 H 18 165 NY 182 14 AC 104n 96 US 298 conipt.evide nee 67 Ny 430 VOL.3 5 damages a 59 NY d6 500 1 6 damages 673 fee spl gdn a 59NY 641 77 AD 68 300 657 leav e to sue r 68 NY 215 658measure dam «4 674 661 f'd deed a 68 NY 976 664 mistake 92n -, Zl exemptions 35 H 650 1 SS 204 645 90 NY 498 627 168 193 personal favor 66M waiver 124 S 33 waiver a 60 NY d5H do 66 NY 73 NY 83 NY 619 567 285 150 140 40 guaranty a 59 NY 474 48 decree open 12 65 cross suits f 3 65 »5 706 74 damages 21 H 30E 79 letters rogatry 124 aD 485 82 larceny a 66 NY f3 r59NY 6 248 notes ev. 3'6 13 25 I certit ev 4 eq. title 602 197 394 203 698 90 mandamus 6 381 76 NY 164 1 02 resettlement r6 681 1 08 employmt 76 NY 164 I 1 8 wife rent S3 756 4 447 pleadg. variance 6 325 1 28 undue inS a 69 NY 636 IM 46 1 74 amendment * 158 NY 636 1 79 certiorari a 58 NY 323 1 8 1 sum. pro t3 182 1 85 parol, ev. a 60 NY 394 6 247 1 99 ev. other act a 56 NY 691 6 279 6 701 203 fraudulent 14 AC 33n 207 legacy chge. 29 H 197 2 1 8 estoppel 66 AD 105 228 impeaohmt 792 235 highways 'state power 258 vendor's lien 172S 385 266 mtge valid a 62 NY 267 f 52 H 173 270 ejectn cars e6 498 273 statements 69 H 17 28 1 carrier care do 191NY 32 liability 145 AD X\r, 129 S 1048 286 obstructn. 19AC 269n easement 19A0 276n 296 restrain tax a 64 NY 626 301 agister neg. 17 AC 228n 309 ejectment r 62 NY 476 3 1 5 proceeds 25 M 124 406 loss goods r 69 NY 288 4 1 6 eontrib. neg 6 95 16 AC 306n guard highways 15 AC 299n-0n 42 1 indorsement r 66 NY 433 431 supervisor 35 H 87 authority atty SAC- 318n 436 sale void 29 H 136 468 limitations r 60 NY 191 477 divorce r 58 NY 60£ 487 life insur r60NY 169 504neg aam. d 4 496n 12 H 304 521 704 waiver •60 NY s6 6M 81 NY 88 NY 322 eg. title 49 337 review opin. 105 AD 281 338 CO. treasurer 60 H 8 350 husb. wife a 60 NY 188 354 notice note 3 361 exceptions 61 H 422 362scienter prf. 139 AD 205 123S 725 364 exrs power 165 AD 169 f 150 S 694, 368 damages a 60 NY 488 378 contract a 60 NY 238 380 goods title a 62 NY 1 393 prob. cause c 60 AD 479 m proaecut- 194 NY 540 trade mark a 62 NY 427 557 trade mark a 68 NY 296 574 entirety 5 571 c 76 NY 27C 92 NY 161 576 temp, ailmt a 67 NY 695 70 NY 77 397 parol ag'nt r 60 NY 139 399 titlegoods r 60 NY 136 404 commission 10 AC 450n 524 reserv ruing 64 NY 370 527 vesting 10 AD 680 wives 4 695 joint owner 60 NY 614 l26 255 113 346 338 108 531 agency a 59 NY IH 634 325 580 sale 527 589 pub. policy a 69 NY 276 603 extension 16AC 160d 608 directory 168 NY 43£ 6 1 8 mistake m 62 NY 267 620 easement a 62 NY 66 626 undertaking m 60 NY 372 630 St. frauds r 62 NY 661 632 title consent 426 519 640 resultg. trst 6 a 63 NY 436 653 construe wll a 69 NY 202 641 669 exceptns. ev a 58 NY 354 671 agency p3 710 inotice 720 practice r62 NY 37S 6 400 734 mandamus a 3 738 745 substitution f 26 H 227 title conclusive 14 M 428 20 M 67 e 94 NY 526 e 78 NY 80 757 weight of ev r 58 NY 681 759 mining stk. a 60 NT 626 764 jurisdiction case 2 ISSAD 671 do 171S 294 768 contract » 60 NY 272 769 iden. name 69 H 16 77 1 neg. dam. a 69 NY 292 774 guardian 22 H 216 775 damages 87 B 229 V0L4 1 3 remov. cause f 69 NY 280 6 I other acts ev. a 66 NY 556 63 neg. dam. 137 85 incomp ev. 29 H 49 1 05 pub* policy r 60 NY 362 I 16 town bonds a 64 NY m 1 20 illegality defense 6 621 8H 347 126 vesting 776 excess dam. r 69 NY 468 777 insurance case 1 r 62 NY 699 amendment cape 2 a 59 NY 321 16 H 181 38 CP 21 781 injunction f25H 3 8M 301 222 waiver d6 783 review 36 H 119 794 compliance case 1 11 H 231 797 request payt 103 AD 183 lOS I 28 equities 1 AC 367u mortgage 74 M 549 132 S 288 1 43 foreclosure /lO H 356 I 63 Sep estate 6 443 445 1 7 1 discharge dr 32 H - 396 waiver 10 AC 286n 99 NY 460 1 74 injunction 41 M 664 14 AC 159n 1 85 assignment a 60 NY 155 2 1 5 arrest bail r 59 NY 110 62 224 receiver 3 4 683 226 indemnity r 69 NY 391 230 form action 5 231n 6 360 8M 341 266 sale realty a 62 NY 494 270 adv possen. 17 AC 371n 279 filg. original 1 AC 92n 282 ejectment a 64 NY 27 289 assessment s6 473 c 6 ■ 478 304 carrier r 62 NY 171 322 oral contrae 90 AD 181 342 oral oontrct 19 H 568 348 vacate tax 50 M 362 retaxation ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; {.followed; r, reversed; m, modified; '.dismissed- n note- o. criticised: 1. limited; e. explained; o. overruled; s. same case: do. dissentinz opinion: p. parallel c"L;q.quest?o"« Vols., 4, 5,6—1 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Thompson & Cook— Silvemail 122 357 title 67 AD 3S5 ST, 365 leg. diserefn fi 322 d 64 NY 106 385 'Construe wll a 66 NY 401 393 expert ev. s 5 204 399 em. domain a 63 NY 137 ' . 'J 413 cloud title r 59 NY 280 429 duress B 5 ' 690 444 wife rent a 62 NY 605 467 hab. corpus c6 265 6 284 intervention e8M 164 484 assessment r 60 NY 17 s 2 H 212 p4 657 S . ' 344 do 5 345 f5 , 350 353 49 I mandamus 6H 90 497 waiver r 62 NY 642 s 2 H 358 do 66 NY 285 5 1 2 sewer dam. r62'NY 592 5 1 8 appeala ble 6 189 264 545 appealable 6 189 551 St. constr'n fi . ' 170 582 flae answer 5 546 597 innkeeper r64 NY 377 606 form action r 62 NY 294 6 1 4 demurrer a 60 NY 88 63 AD 292 contempt 62 M' 558, S69 638 certiorari 8H S7 657 assessment case 1 6 353 666 damages r 62 NY .449 685 inoomp. ev a 63 NY 101 689 mortgage d 78 NY 561 690 misdirectn cape 2 4SS 4 11 M 467 VOL 5 27 mortgage a62 NY 34 tax,sale a62iviY 674 agency INY r60J 610 65^5 avoids verd f 176 AD 544 678 estoppel r 62 NY -70 a 62 depo NY 604 45 H e 127NY u;is 3S0 54 illecal ev. 4 NY 461 e64NY 406 / 56 demurrer 2 AC 279 57 indorsement a 62 NY -6 65 adv. possessn a 62 NY 40- 76 disqualified llH 207 ex contractu 8S NY 639 '84 em domain a60 NY 11 98 will exr. 60 NY 347 3191 VOL 6 104 line Sclient atty rule 216 583 trespass 6 566 585 agency p6 690 539 rescission 13 M 679 594 towns neg, 3 H 500 40 H 192 596 trust e5 605 trust 64 NY 166 AD 24 surety e71NY' 608 160 693 411 1 02 constitut'l 8H 113 I 5 1 intent 106 AD 504 1 7 6 aver prove a 181 serv. summons 86 AD 238 6 M 261 e 6 M 252 1 79 serv. suram. 6M 261 1 93 ins. policy a 63 NY, , 28 I95f'd transfer a 63 NY 74 205 civstody child d 105 AD 66 claim vs. lunatic 19 AC 8 On 2 1 2 pub. policy 19 H 61n 2 1 7 public use a 60 NY 616 29 H 4 277 other act ev 6 699 308 certiorari 4 60 NY 643 waiver 126S 1116 70M 456 345 assessment a62NY 498 637 d53 NY 479 e 119 NY 27 e 133 NY 616 sevant's neg a 64 NY 130 6 1 9 abandonrat e 64 AD 370 f 5 H 584 35 H 604 d 67 NY 262 203 e_118NY 173 628 boundary SAC 163n 664 bequest r 64 NY 278 678 misdemeanr a 62 NY 292 33 authority 123S 410 37'eumulat ev. 36 H 97 56 remov. cause 56 70 affidavit 2 AC 362 76 inmaterial variance 10 M 654 78 publication a 62 NY 634 95 NY 499 46 M. 540 compliance do 150 S 475 do 165 AD 956 89 constitutional a 64 NY 262 9H 286 1 08 life insur. a 64 NY 197 687 services 63 NY 45 117 costs a 62 NY 699 conversion .r 63 NY 181 198 484 usury m64NY 213 490 adv. possn. r64NY 180 530 husband gift 5LIIA 679n 539 conviction a 62 NY 119 550 title tenant ls3H 342 120 waiver juris. 42 H 89 151 oS. duties 6 222 i 64 compliance r 63 NY 239 1 69 electn rem'y 35 H 70 1 72 estoppel a 66 NY 114 1 83 contract r 64 NY 41 2! I exr. allowce e 6 M 142 2l4&cting party 68 M 416 2 1 5 murder ev. a 62 NY 230 253 reargument 13 AC 16n 258 certiorari r 60 NY 561 291 neo dartie.i 19 AG , 187n 292 joinder r 64 NY 173 309 novation 2 M 302 310m. lien con- sent 6H 661 316 amendment 1; 62 NY 840 8H 99 320 local act r 62 NY 457 331 life policy a 64NY 305 337 contempt lAU ■ lOOn 341 m lien cen sent 6 H 561 7 AC 409n 343 disaovcsry e 33 M 728 344 construotn e 131 NY 460 382 acceptance 38 H 352 402 scope agent 10 AD S21 405 abatement 63 NY 415 409 extra fare p6 409 12 AC 87 b 446 opinion ev, d,31 H 448 467 execution * 62 NY 2S8 473 taxn local function 79 AD 188 e 79 AD 195 36 M 604 488 ultra vires s 63 NY 177 495 expulsion excessive fare 1 70 AD 408 e 71 AD 203 204 1 10 AC .472 498 contrib. neg d 62 H 591 509 estoppel 76 NY 421 5 1 4 taxation a 64 NY 62 525 sale goods 2M 129 VOL I S2 probabilities 641$ 161 1 53 exoeptious 34 ^^^ 5 M 222 do 5 M 253 ■iM 268 313 books. ase» 19AC 201 449 insurance f 1 458 5S 898 459 amendment 95 AD 362 35 S 898 47 I corporation a 131NY 4 aSS 688 553 consideratn. 138 AD 536 689 proces exmt 133 AD 752 nss 213 527 exceptions s 4 H 264 49 H 610 589 easement a 64 NY 662 s4H 419 59 1 execution 10 H 399 604 lis pendens 2LE,A 50b 620 note defense 17 H 478 630 mistake 21 H 31S 632 pleading 31 M 261 645 defense do 3 H 84 85 653 warranty a 64 NY 412 665 exceptions 114 NY 317 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; • d, distinguished; {.followed; r, reversed; m, modified; •.dismissed; n, note; c criticised ; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; ••same case; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, questioned N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Silvernail Vols, 2, 3, 4, 5 VOL.2 280 trustee 19AC 247 VOL.3 62 restriction 30AC 20n. SI 287 affidavit ■564 confess iudt do UTS 1054 f 3 s 136 S 232 506 forgjry 19AC 141, 149n 589 bill partic. 19AC 39n, 40n VOL- 4 211 nuisance ownership 4 M . 86 595 discontinue 88 M 318 467 liability IflAC 2T8 519 co-tenant 133S 404 VOL.5 (42 other issuP 37 CP 9f 596 new trial t5 531 3 8 S 789 f4M U9 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished ; f, folio wed ; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; c, criticised; 1, limited; e, explained ; o, overruled ; s, same c ase ; do, dissenting opinion ;p, parallel case; q, questioned. N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Hun Vol. 1 VOL. I 1 oompeaaation ? 2UK g 286 333 law action 22 • B4() s3TC 90 affidavit 8 25M 4AU .■emedy 76 NY 154 1 5 intent ev a 66 NY ittl 3 44 4 510 10 159 14) HI 33 fl,i3 35 312 «3TC 191) 88 NY 659 19 larceny ev. a5 6Ny HH4 11 19 « 427 654 12 129 26 54C 6NC 431 sliTC 82 fiTNY 32(1 e74NY 422 d77Ny 127 86 NY 3S( 90 NY 14 B9NY 66;- 8 ubornatioD 49 allowance a 58 NY 621 63 279 2 NC 241n 3 TC 145 demur frivolous 13 AC 198n 51 benefits lolAD 13oS assessment 98 M 163 S 86 261 724 527 56 no extension 133AD 214 66 acoumulation I 1 3 delivery ev a 60 NY 394 h8TC 185 4 68 real agreement g 656 18 442 I 1 4 falie rdpres. f 26 227 a 3 TC 745 asBumption f 94 NY 525 I I 5 amendment 71 reargument *60NY 126 f4 79 acct. book bv. e27 e2S p28 e28 8 3TC s4SS e92NY perjury 16 a 68 NY a3TC 604 617 618 622 192 318 .519 636 174 402 24 letting public contract r6DNY 83 NY 7SNY 6 6 8 20 b3 rc 6 NC 7NC 82 NY 86 NY 91 NY 303 538 213 191 70 459 532 753 24 42n 42 73 certiorari f 16 462 9M 489 license D 102 AD 271 76 commission *59 NY 313 78 service papers 61 47 s 3 TC 755 6 Cl' 70 80 restoration 13 583 4 lun 3 NC 93 Stat, limitations 17 897 partial recission I I 7 strike out 3 219 I NC 303 3 TC 102 fact question 479 practice 5M lOOM 165S appeal 49 M 489 190 382 I 20 probate case 2 a 59 NY 636 s3TC 135 141 18 123 30 let. pub. cont r 63 NY S3 7 17 77 NY 85 NY 99 NY 111 NY il2NY 116 US s3TC 2 LRA 35 salary rSONY 8 27 28 33 s3TC jurisdiction dSONY 88 NY 91 NY 101 NY 239 685 331 110 137 306 234 459 ISI 362 155 605 185 441 286 262 261 576 131 126 251 271 533 38 construe will t6 eSTC 219 115 41 referee •59NY 93 NY 94 NY 75 interlocutory e 87 222 S6 AD case 1 r58NY 3TC review slONC 148 48 s3TC damages f21 14 NC want care 153AD 86 diabursemts. 110 112 74 303 305n 212 9 8 3TC remedy f 76NY 287 •108 154 272 1 22fact question case 2 a 60 NY 626 ! 3 TC 750 1 25 Sep. estate 2 202 6 528 3 NC 181n 132 will intent a 59 NY 202 641 653 416 135 160 1066 92 wife rent f 2 261 defense pleadg: 3 220n 55 AD 167 s3TC 118 2M 172 15 AC 68n partnership 26 178 presumption 9 650 alleeationa 13 NC 386 20 NC 358n 1 02 sum. pro a 58 NY 323 16 462 notice 64 AD 374 s 3 TC 179 constitutional 83NY 23 1 NC 165 I I I sureties admissna prins. 14 15 16 9 3TC 9M 20 M 26 M 492142 M 411 120 592 138 471 683 645 ■SOI 444 638 323 478n 704 338 346 93 348n 478 8 d57 32 AD 7AC . e3TC S8NY waiver fact 81 NY restoration 3NC reduction 20 NC memoranda 69 LRA counterclaim 195 NY 333 1 7 7 case all ev. 1-62 NY 387 3 699 verd. ooncluaive 51 434 s 3 TC 720 14 M 499 1 93 good title f 20 259 198 prom, note a 62 NY 615 244 St. frauds 19 M 662 252 statement P 34 548 ieciaion conclua. 71 28 AD 04 AD S7 AD . 4 TC J AC SAC 202 exceptions 128L62NY I 2 I excess, dam L ^ r^Q 681 767 3TC 11 NC 16 NC to class 103M 169S fiduciary 14 NC 2 I 3 appearance NC 73n 2 i 4 accounting 461 586 services 82 ■ 196 5 TC 660 6 TC 290 2 I 7 reeeip ex planatioD a 60 NY 614 11 645 8 3 TC 695 20 U 234 1 43 tax eorpn. 242 697 257 200 678 a 58 NY 4 10 deductions 5 s3TC legal situs 69LRA 1 46 neg. dam. a 60 NY 6 s 3 TC 686 1 5 1 use ocoupa. r 69 NY 343 25 140 s 3 TC 662 7TC 9n I 57 admissions 3 208 d 77 NY 310 I 6 I parol ev. a 60 NY 644 118 NY 633 cond. precedent 147AD 67 131 S 802 167 prem. notes a 60 NY 475 27 244 sSTC 701 240 388 13 264 449 506 578 616 55 1 223 286 2S9n 3 1 6 custom ev. case 2 a 60 NY INC residence case 1 16 AC 646 472n r60NY 3TC 3 NO 13 NC 167n 3 1 8 referee's fee 263 ev. value f 17 137 267 parties deft. f 35 M 355 estoppel LRANS 55 abatement 75M 211 135S , 41 no stipulation d 1S4AD 83! stipulation 1.54AD 83' 268 constitut'l 65 136 274 genl, denial 78 221 special pleading 2 AC 314n 282 revers. error 4M 621 case 2 a 58 NY 8 14 16 a2TC 321 disbarment 7 AC 7n i^jooonduct do 122 AD 323 set-off a SONY 288 fraud dam. f 21 292 waiver a 59 NY I 4 fugitive 55 s3TC 303 298 judgt. lien 79 404 303 fr'd diligen. 223 discharge bankruptcy *59NY 2 18 S2TC 7NC 233 356 191 1 181n 227 notice t9 650 partners profits 16 627 26 633 40 171 statutes names 7 NC 293n pleading 123 S 107 231 new trial surprise f 4 666 73 197 10 AD 479 47 AD 489 89 AD 473 67 B 320 4 AC 20 240 vested right a 58 NY 644 34 159 s 5 TC 716 36 M 409 10 AC 346n 349 remarriage 49 M 600 242 discontinue 77 1.3 TO 80 301 491 440 734 a 62 NY 21 M 41 M 42 U e67NY evidence 66M 661 716 186 309 517 388 528 28 12 538 4 1 7neg. damages d4 762 contrib. neg. 17 license e86AD 65AD trespasser 6NC 421 gambling 534 574 324 dis 59 NV 9 2TC 44 M e 129 NY 19 NC but 163 600 38 295 371n a59NY 8 3TC 23 M 430 disease a 67 NY s3TC 70 NY 325 authority a 69 NY 634 s 3 TC 531 167 NY 288 332 aasignment a 68 NY 294 17 430 20 213 a 3 TC 667 341 agenoy 199NY 184 344 memoranda 2 AC 310 352 veated int. 12 32 s 3 TC 18 NC 147 S 162 AD 634 75 527 304 703 268 357 revers. error m 59 NY 629 2 AD 21 3 TC 60S service process 304 discharge 13 AC 12n 14n 305 discretion 2 AC SSn 306 QOtiee mtge a 69 NY 634 4 708 7 NC 188n 307 rape charge a 68 NY 147 NY 2 AC 4NC 5NC 104 NY 37 377 488 585 308 restitution *58 NY 670 8 2 TC 562 e 140 NY 328 3 1 collision neg r 64 NY 201 3 I I exceptions *58 NY 354 14 486 a 3 TC 669 31 2 serve complt 46 M 658 3 1 5 stare decisis 367lr 62 NY 366 7471s 2 TC 667 623 417 144 76n 41 1 compromiae 413 598 187n 297n 76 622 673 IISd 275 589 347 559 567 77 432 surety discg 4 3TC 67 B x'ension 6 AC 367 603 342 150n 433 h.aud wife 3 entirety 50 '6 NY e92NY judgment 38 AD 3 TC 623 270 161 21 574 435 witness ev. a 64 NY 629 436 reserv. rulgs. 8 3 TC 524 6 AC 24Sn d 64 NY 370 437 stare decisis 59 NY 468 3 S TC 776 6NC 125 438 contract a 60 NY s3TC 606 768 655 779 367 tradit names a 62 NY 428 36 AD 367 3 TC 540 22 M 670 378 neg. dam. 62 295 do 120 NY 579 38 1 jud. notice r 59 NY 117 72 578 a 3 TC 506 387 assumption 62 M 502 390 divesting 34 AD 175 bona fide 138AD 453 recording 5LRA 285n 400 title veating f 4 273 11 601 8 3 TC 580 acceptance 164 S 418 439 appeal case 1 a 59 NY a3TC case 2 fact questio.^ r63NY 636 3 TC 773 443 open decree r 58 NY 609 s 3 TC 477 444 Stat const r f 5 145 5 CP 321 448 usage INC 472n 451 note for debt 16 AC 454 fraud a 60 NY recovery 39 e86 68 AD a3TC 19 M 156 NY 457 contract a 63 NY 650 s 3TC 417 460 life policy I51n 645 522 555 234 458 99 374 .\BBREVrSTIONS: a', affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note: c. criticised; I, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q, questioned Vols. I, 2 N. y. Supreme Court Reports— Hun reONY 8 3 TO 169 487 464 contempt 127 AD 910 469 depositioD SAC 17n 473 proceeds 20 NG lUu eq. conversion 186AD • 376 174S 546 478 res judicQia f 3 '737 jurisdiction 23 483 440 adverse poss'n. 88 392 8 3 TC 453 2 AC 122 48 1 limitation t 60 NY 190 63 479 • « TC 468 fiLOt question 4 SA 342 125NY 744 submasion 4LRA 6S5n 488 bm-ilen prf. 74 207 362 ?4 366 s 3 TC 486 489 sale delivery case 2 a 60 NY 635 *164 US 619 « 3 TC 765 490 fr'd recovery 8 60 NY 631 a 3 TC 761 49 I harmless ev case 2 a59 NY 643 6 ■ 121 8 3 TC 764 492 injunction t 39 599 76 21 496 consent (4 209 do 4 242 a 3 TC 632 1 NC 68n 499 uses trusts a 63 NY 434 8 3 TC 640 5 NC 328 504 note altertn f 27 349 s 3 TC 635 507 easement a 62 NY 65 s 3 TC 620 5 1 3 immediate delivery d 16 35 IS NC 394 fraudulent «9 681 8 3 TC 644 5 1 6 mtee poSBn f 34 61 107 AD 302 burden proof 77 AD 646 521 stav m 60 NY 371 209 NY 65 49 165 s 3TC 626 3 NC 64n 527 insur pol. r 62 NY 5 s 3TC 777 528 contract tn 62 NY 2i6 ^ 3 TC 618 529 parol contr. nase 1 r 62 NY 560 10 323 lU 236 8 3 TC 630 case 2 certiorari l.'rtAD 557 532 set oft 31 220 35 142 7 CF 243 cost? 6 AC 336n 537 demurrer 5 AC 459n 2C NC 366n 540 wife earning f 18 370 3 4 TC 135 21 NC 7n 544 certiorari 24 286 551 parol exten. 56 • 483 30 AD 368 s 5 TC 109 foreclosure 5S M 96 554 elm. vs. twn a 64 NY 112 8 644 8 4TC 116 75 AD 214 do 104 AD 612 557 Btoien ciieck 6 127 surrend certif. 59 580 31 M 503 559 cbaree realty ILKA 545n 562 parol ST. e 25 140 do 25 144 32 545 8 4 TC 71 586 equities 72 74 1 AC 357n 98 M 429' f 98 iM 430 163 S 131 mortgage d 74M 549 dl32S 288 570 comra duty 24 474 35 010 proximate cause 39 434 8 4 TC 122 576 converflioi? 34 M 628 infants liab 10 563 4 AD 683 48 AD 620 bailee care 17 AC 228n 578 infants f 171 AD 64 d 156 S 1011 582 indorser d71NY 411 585 time contrct a 60 NY 644 AD 463! 8 4TC 49 589 vested int 2 634 10 339 30 360 36 371 3LRA 816n 593 Stat conatrn 33 286 39 224 8 4 TC 87 596 evidence r 55 NY 81 a 58 NY 655 3 546 5 4 TC 61 60 I "heirs*' will r 69 NY 149 a 4 TC 103 6 NC 445n 11 NC 415 608fact Question f 17 422 a 4 TC 96 607 levy case 1 f 16 165 s 4 TC 41 6 AC 129n partners case 2 4NC 311n 6 I construction case 1 f 4 425 s 4 TC ^ 691 jurisdiction 37 208 6 1 2 illegality case 1 f4 355 8 347 17 478 s 4 TC 120 6 I 2 consideratn case 2 12 AC 259n 6 I 3 neg dam. case 1 16 M 610 6 1 5 pub policy case 2 r 60 NY 362 s4 TC 105 6 1 9 authority case 1 r 62 NY 31 s 4 TC 696 625 direct quea. f 13 638 628 waive tort f32 111 fraud contract d 52 606 s4TC 167 115 NY 8 off-set f 156 S 242 632 complaint d 11 146 25 AD 12 7 NC 2S6n 634 statement binding 8 4 TC 649 19 M 285 76 NY 229 6 NC 193 643 sureties r 59 NY 390 8 4 TC 226 647 objections 72 372 discharge 32 396 s4TC 171 complaint 16 M 358 10 AC _ 286n jurisdiction c 99 NY 450 650 vessel lien a 60 NY 649 110 AD 74 3 4 TC 154 655 authority 4 116 8 6 247 12 59 27 343 78 NY 181 pro rata 39 60 jurisdiction 38 AD 391 66 AD 598 do 88 AD 536 f 165 AD 159 s 4 TC 230 11 M 212 150 S 623 parties 26 M 341 recovery 20 NC 437n title realty 59 M 13 670 larceny a 58 NY 669 4 TC 203 680 int. rate a 77 NY 584 13 405e 407 2 NC 304 6NC 80 7 NC 77n 89 683 bond trust a 60 NY 154 d 26 362 4 TC 185 689 serv. proc. r 59 NY 116 a 4 TC aiS 26 M 506 SAC 406n 696 contract a 73NY 498 d7 396 s47C 148 7 1 attachment a 69 NY 697 4 317 8 8 522 440 2 AC 418n 18 NO 356 84 NY 618 714 charge int. ease 1' 4 196 272 5 499 s 4 TC 163 67 B 667 3 NC 182n 715 q. meruit a 62 NY 617 a 4 TC 666 7 1 6 injunction case 1 f 26 269 14 AC 160n s 4 TC 174 7 1 9 constructiOD a 68 NY 23 d 10 2.53 s 4 TC 177 6 NC 49n 66a 392: 721 findings I a 69NY 633; 3 6 TC 669 VOL 2 I adv. possn. r 69 NY 75 B 4 TC 270 6 NC 243 17 AC 371n G evidence 17 138 caption clerk 21 142 jurisdiction 28 230 entry order 13 NC 41n implied repeal 10 NC 41n give judgment 149 S 826 f 164 AD 760 31 partnership a 64 NY 204 a41C 274 7 NC 280 38 warranty 11 AC 176n failure reply 102M 242 168S 878 43 discretion f 19 190 material ev. 29*1 653 46exprc8B receipt r 62 NY 171 8 4 TC 304 4 LRA 246 52 demurrer m 13 120 final 29 673 »4TC 263 interloc. judgmt 21 NC 352 55 writ, possessn a 64 NY 27 4 TC 282 CP 366 58 authority f 36 448 64 injunctioni \ ! 13 NC 471 67 refiling mtge 1 AC 92n 9 AC 432n 70 certiorari 8 2 601 8 4 187 74 counterclaim s4 TC 245 21 M 713 allaeetn, proof 83 NY 250 9NC 6 78 limitation a 62 NY 494 46 654 69 163 8 4 TC 266 7 CP 271 90 eq. convers'n. a 63 NY 652 59 AD 245 186AD 376 8 4TC 318 174S 546 vested interest 27 M 260 28 M 274 94 election a 62 NY 563 4 762 s 4 TC 686 2 CP 438 1 02 taxn. rent, r 60 NY 381 1 07 re vers error 10 473 32 346 2 NC 19n 1 08 damages a 62 NY 615 1 1 1 jurisdiction 17 AC 105n I 1 2 presump ev case 1 235 enforceable case 2 9 AC 221n I 14 ejection a 63 NY 101 7 144 I 15 compensatn a 63 NY 136 s3 621 8 4 TC 399 3 NC 309o s4TC INC 336 441 122 special dam. 608 363 396 676 a 70 NY 56 s4TC 130 NY 124 mental shock 4M 1 26 stat limitatn f 48 103 16 NC 463n 1 28 revere error 39 304 implied promise 70 AD 130 e 28 M 349 d 79 NY 90 9 6 TC 204 leave to appeal 16 M 31 1 30 illegal ev. r 60 N"5' 610 S 183 8 4 TC 679 7 AC 479n 1 50 pi esumptioQ 39 114 151 merger 85 NY 504 ICP ' 228 20 NC ;24n 1 53 discretion. 125AD 20 inadmissible 176AD 475 162 S 433 I 56 duress case 2 a 66 NY 609 3 LRA 176 1 57 foreclosure case 2 a 62 NY 344 a 4 TC 424 I 58fact question r63NY 642 1 6 1 appeal a62Ny 4 TC 613 679 1 63 compensatn a56 NY 612 7 112 383 Injunction 18 113 mater'l obstrucn 28 AD 628 legal evidence 37 AD 41 commerce dock 127 NY 278 purpresture 2NC 214 prescription 16NU184n 20Sn no nuisance 126 4D 439 132 advances a 62 NY a41C 1 36 agency a 64 NY 1 38 release r62NY s4TC 1 39 demurrer o8 184 a 4 TC 417 1 42 assessment r 59 NY 280 s 4 TC 413 604 682 642 105 422 205 party 43 577 d 106NY 624 renewed motioD 61 286 68 389 88 384 s 4 TC 670 .208fact question f 20 467 6M 554 212 asseseroat r60NY 16 e 2 223, 282 2 281, 377 3 66 216 4 44 s 4 TC 484 2 1 8 appealable f 3 37 amendment f 4 614 14 652 a 4 TC 645 1 ., . , . 1 AC 49n 1 43 eatoppi mtg r 2 NY 69 22 1 assessment 6 TC 678 m 62 NY 624 7 CP 44 f 3 69 3NC 279 9 4TC 657 16 NC 821 224 compensatn 1 46monument st 27 66 AD s4TC use of street 107 AD llOAD 11 NC citv power 16AC legislative 107AD 73 339 435 411 70 282n 348 pwr. 411 671 4S0 226 habeas corp f3 773 779 60 mandamus 88 AD 32' 570 88 262 s 4 TC 467 e 8 M 164 INC 10 i power court 135S 371 4 Ohigh'ycomrs validity 7 . 461 150 AD 778 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; e, criticised ; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, qucslionri* N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Hun Vol. 2 238 marriage , 86 N V ■ r? . 2:i 20^ 9i in 253 wives liabil- nu-NV 606 (.24 s 4 TC 444 86 NY 4. .2 3N0 181 263 pub. instrn a 62 NY 160 6 90 d7 1G4 ofi^cers duties 140 S 1112 AD 806 268 339 jury trial 44 182 14 AC 94 n 145 S 657 t'itrht trial 100 AD 247 341 elty powers f 3 683 repeal 5 227 1 4 TC 551 345 specify e8 12 17 29 2CP ina:jdamU9 24 S34TC 684 269 tendancy 40 24 M 547 520 347 irregularity 448 specify 384 f 8 437 •*'* 39 AD 168 2r,4!ss AD 603 491JS4TC 647 levteneion time 4 AG 39 a 60 NY 12 . new trial 12 AD 53 AD s4TC C40: 236 410 226 638 349 amendmenl 20AC 2n 351 appeal f J4 "trjke out 492 7 AC 195n 20Uii!;R'rn 14NC 4{j!j;^"'^'-' 159 S ,771 not truthful ;,g2NY 175 AD 96 ^3 28 i aaseasment ^ * J^ m 62 NY 224Jnot^e 2 212n 66 NY s i TC 657 358 b'k entra.ev 642 21 497 285 237 appealable 3 379 4 54n service process 4 NO 41ii ■293 sewers dam r 62 NY 592 26 . 124 64 AD 603 s 4 TC 512 306 taxes mistk. 673 42; 84 355 488 32^ 4 5 58,' e :W AD a4TC demurrer 67 B right recover 174 AD 610 161 S 155 308, discovery 5 465 2 NC 144il 3 NC I30n fl NC ,69n 20 NC 2irn 3 1 I allegatii' fact a 63 NY 653 7 237 p 4 TC 624 tort fail proof 105 AD 286 324 commission r 62 NY 448 « 4 TC 666 12 NC 24 333jaches do 96 AD 626 leave to plead 13 AC 13n 337 appealable { 12 84 venue discretion 76 118 77 13 8 AC 3S3n change venue 86-M 502 373 undertaking 564 374 com'rsestm a 60 NY 319 375 frivi answer caa6 1 a 62 NY 637 377 ctr claim case 1 73 reference 142 NY 251 377 designation case 2 m 60 NY 457 8 4 TC 658 378 exceptn lile 19 AD 261 34 M 271 d 14 NC 513 379 attachment case 1 f 4 634 67 B 30£ carrier case 2 a:63NY s41C 402 warranty ins a64NY 64S s 4 TC 582 406 affidvt title d7 384 408 revers judl 91 ■■ 61 409 surrogate pr 10 AC 129 167 NY 344 jurisdiction d 141 AD 330 13GS 091 4 1 teffal service r 64 NY 642 S4TC 64 e 4 M 274 4 1 9 damages f 18 182 53 476 42 I fact question tj 001 426 pers. trans'n 68 581 2 NC 16n 428 ver-iict f41 576 37 AD 32 433 exemptions r K3 NY 291 5 . 443 lM.M^efit amount 43 121, 30 AD 31 42 s 5 TC 61 436 CO. elk. fees a 64 NY ' 637 6 551 eyclus. jurisdctn 23 239 construe title 25 632 36 55 i5TC 91 NY 685 438 constructiot) 31 48 68 681 2 NC , 16n improbaUla 39CP 222, 238 470 delivery 160 M 60 3-5 TC 475 tille a 64 NY TU 479 authority 10 AC 55u 432 possessn r r liUNY 116 a CO NY 4U7 5 TC 84 485 recovery 83 AD 619 4 SS 284 cominiseions 105 AD 404 488 indorser a 62 NY - 5 6 TC 57 674 147 S 70 87 535 death dam, a fli NY 656 282 89 489 direct verd't a64 NY 636 7 .556 fact question 21 399 120 NY 535 174 NY 51 6NC 112n J 3 TC 49 degree c^ise b;.i\ Y '620 492 Stat, frauds r 66 NY 82 9.-5 TC 14 15 NC 467 495 damages 64 ' 540 2 AC 279n 20 NC 103n demurrer i36AD 5 497 cloud title 479 665 380 set)aration *62NY 385 laches r68NY 8 16 3 4 TC location e28M 618 403 .57 463 638 86 392 assessment r62NY 3 recovery 9 s4TC 294 540 220 606 400 com< lunatic d 10 485 36 360 a 62 NY s5TC 105 NY , c 105 NY schedule 131 S judicial not 141AD 126S 443 trial fee f 33 332 f 93 M. 472 f 158 S 441 undue influence 1S6S 1105 445 undue infl. f 40 237 1.36 S 1105 persuasion 136S 1085 447 parol ev ILRA 817n 449 refile mtge a 62 NY 215 s 5 TC 27 452 mortjcage security a 62, NY ■ 406 69 sSTC 466 contract s6TC 85 NY 76 639 468 jurisdiction 17 NO 324 rule law 118AD 332 348 34 43 16 376 609 993 5 f estoppel d55 432 35 M 767 51 I pleading 14 M 315 23 ■ •• 461 contrib. neg. 37 ' 134 5 TC 122 11 AC 53n 70n 540 eq.convsrn 6 TC 707 V. neiship a lOi'.JI 5S4 d 160S 918 542 sale executn a 68 NY 225 =iTO 140 545 commissns a 63 NY 445 550appeal notice f 28 498 10 NC 224 Ljower court >■:. iVl 497 [ 148 S 037 552 jurisdiction r 60 NY 346 125 US 382 B 5 TC 98 17 M . 472 556 constitut'l f4 735 333 535 8 17 113 321 559 12 377 5 TC 102 559 estoppel 65 206 568 estoppel 35 M 76; 572 .copartners a 59 NY 659 64 232 B 5 TC 126 rights asst^ee do 146 S. 13 do 160 AD 735 joint adventure do 160 AD 736 sOTC INC 61 I complaint f 5 343 3 5 TC 696 6 1 3 trustees a 63 NY 14 3CP resignation IS 20 AD e52AD AD soTC IflM 31 M 34 M 12 AC 165 NY 141 US 129S iO :.i construction ;:;US 1031 6 1 6 deflt prem a 63 NY 27 s 5 TC 19a 519 remedy 9M 109 163 S 616 S26 joiuder 32 M 576 privity d9 276 5 1.7 pleading case 2 9M 57 520 prom, note case 2 a 67 NY 346 5 155 52 1 fire daniages r 64 NY 377 8 4 TC 597 523 title land case 1 a 63 NY receiver case 2 a 60 NY s4TC 19 NC 631 88 614 378n 526 partial pay t. 193 NY 71 53 1, deviae 32 35 18 NC life estate 75 404 303 580 St. opening * 62 NY 611 583 taxn stock f 67 NY 621 8 539 e 27 M 39 59 I contract r 68 NY 558 s 5 TC 143 16 NC 379 392n 4 LRA ,731 598 trespass case 1 d9 572 599 n. disc'd.ev. 35 97 82 48 14 NC 469 603 opng. judgt a 67 NY 104 s 6 TC 306 606 substitution * 60 NY 143 9 CP 102 609 dieath ev. r 60 NY 121 194 654 objectnaev 27n!f:M 13o 855 scopeauthor r66NY 464 6 TC 208 17 M 119 624 617 135 500 562 139 140 197 49 6,58 485 47n 10 , irA 367 605, 624 881 obgn jurisd f 15 368 SAC 382n m^.y waive t S7 M 14 1-U) S 1036 682 ratification 71 AD 120 AD S68 costs case 1 11 M 27 A.V 689 value lots f6 damages 29 33' 37 5TC 284 628 asBessment a 60 NY 398 630 collaterals a 63 NY 616 54 508 3 5 TC 183 leturn stock 134AD 433 right pledge 139 3 . 173 delivery 139 S 76 no tender 154 AD 436 632 certiorari f 2S 276 633. surface wtr. *70NY 19 . eSAD 8 5Te 5NC 614 ,321 161 163 173n 302 270 93 164 4 644 555 17 670 services 3 NC 182b 671 lunatic ase 2 U AC lability 133.AD 13SS. 1-2 NY 444d 485 253 282 649 603 207 672 final a 60 NY do 89 3 5TC „. . functus officio I-ISAD 648 133S 252 675 wife proprty easel r63NY 5TC 6 OP 5 NO case 2 5 AC 181 699 213 378, appeal 289b ■: water course MeS 641 1 211 NY 260 living stream 70M 270 6,37 waiver 92 31 643 accrual 29 444 sup. complaint 52 AD 17 ,55 AD 628 1 AC 94n new cause 8 AC 269n 270n 9 AC 272n e 85 NY 276 646 dedication a 62 N Y 649 8 6 TC 173 14 AC 268n property right 130 S 744 easement street 73 M 67 105M 488 173S 618 652error ev. f 13 638 676 dismissfU case 2 63 NY 45. 3 6 TC 687 677 divorce i r58NY 609 ^78 transtr. wife;' case 1 a 63 NY, 74 8 6 TC 195 678 reference . ease 2 3 AC 58b equitahle title 178AD 736 165S 900 679 contract a 63 NY 638 5,T0 688 681 appeal order case 1 *60NY 642 682 law questb a 67 NY 448 s 5 TC 216 683 leave appeal CEise 2 16 M 363 684appeal caael a 63 616 ABBREVIATIONS: a, aiSn^ed; d, distinguished; i, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; e, criticised: 1. Hmited: e, explained; b, overruled; s, same case; do. dissenting ooinion: p. oarallel case; q, auestioned. ' Vol. 3 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Hun VOL. 3. 3 copy pleading 45 AT) 506 s S TC 231 f20NC 13 6 burglary ev. a 63 NY 619 76 AD 247 s 5 TC 67C 9 poBsessn. notre 59 35f f 22 NC 405e I I mandamus a 64 NY 627 8 AD .562 8 6 TC 382 28 M 744 B4 NY 604 1 6 review f9 20 NC 22 AD 243 3 6 '1 C 2WH ♦ AC 78ii 24«n 5 AC MH 7 AC STn 25 NC 4nnn 120 NY 426 improper eT 38 4« 4 M 3«J 73 end lien 43 AD 115 12 M 628 213 302 20 voucherB t6NC 144 22 review 10 AD 594 26 libel 24 AD 91 e 93 AD 63' d 153 AD 'M: ridicule 74M f!lii 132 S 2 35 pub. instrrtn f 6 9C non-suit 162 NY 449d 45] estoppel 1 160 AD 211 145 S 570 t 213. NT 67 40 other acts pv a 60 NY 616 i 51 d 10 159 14 518 19 82 33 632 ,82 412 18 AD 242 B 6 TC 277 92 NY 427 44 construe will f 33 27 residuary 36 AD 140n 69 AD 270 62 Uobea 4 74 costs statutory 16 M 333 1 CP 300 315 19 CP 79 57 ad allowance 57 12: 60 aver, public'n d 43 631 66 AD 686 8 5 IC 279 10 AC 342 d 127 NY 498 20AC 231n 4 CP 278 135 S 108 show facts 140 AD 234 set aside 94 M 433 65 assessment a 62 NY 618 B 5 TC 349 70 trespass d 37 617 jurisdiction 46 141 80 dower right f 36 126 22 NC 404n 84 discretion a 67 NY 23 58 4.-)^ 8 5 TC 310 private Corp. 93 NY 321 lawful business 19SNY 9 97 mandamus 18 M 638 public use U NC 282n I I I findingH » fi3 NY 422 . 5 TC 305 I S 7 confirm repl U M 124 court's power IDOAD 41 .S 134S im 1 19 costs '6 234 <5TC 273 67 B 600 I 2 I undue infl. 1 63 NY 604 22 646 q 6 TC 402 139 undue influ. BO 301 26 M 37 I44fiaud 21 NC 68n 147 restriction f8 512 I? AD 7 » B TC 283 2 NC 277 certif. check 14 AC 457n 1 52 good faith e 8-» NY 385 6M 95 (Commissions 23 M 344 ! 56 supervisors a 62 NY 629 s 6 TC 393 1 64 judic. notice a 62 NTi 623 5 380 • 6 TC 266 1 7 i receiver 8 24 AD 46 66 AD 599 4M 619 12M 56 18 M 653 21 M 748 6 AC 402 404n 156, NY 203 eq. jurisdiction 09AD 216 18 NC 439 action will lie ISfl S 654 I 77 teachers employes 57 34 49 AD 149 removal 49 AD 312 4 SB 242 243 certiorari 14 M 120 2 AC 247 1 87 certiorari a 60 NY 643 s 6 TC 308 a NC 166 judge error 49 M 88 objn. waived 92 M 375 156 S 820 \ 90 presentment 20 M 567 24 M 389 1^2 equities 59 M 164 165 l95contrib neg r 69 NY 470 s6TC 202 robbery a 59 NY 659 24 64 s 5 TC 329 208 mandamus 3 14 s 6 TC 376 f 64 NY 604 2 I surplus moneys a 67 NY 84 s 6 TC 292 3 NC 164 2 I I reference t6 237 57 186 s 5 TC 297 4 AC 141n 2 f 2 assessment case 2 a 62 NY 637 0,63 479 s 5 TC 345 2 I 4board educa- tion case 1 f 6 8! trustees 23 571 s 5 TC 367 2 I 5 assessment r 60 NY 343 s 5 TC 343 2 1 7arreBt ground case 1 16 465 B 5 TC 294 atty's lien case 2 18 NC 40n 2 I 8 interest a 66 NY 260 10 526 19 698 8 5 TC 677 d 64 NY 633 16 AC 48n 2 I 9 reference case 2 a 62 NY 630 B 6 TC 670 220 payt defense 57 75 22 1 pers. iudgt. case 1 a 60 NY 63 B 6 TC 675 222 writ of error 223 findings case 1 s 5 T C 679 case 2 a 64 NY 640 a 6 TC 679 224 findings a 64 NY 631 s 5 TC 683 225 indictment d9 461 construction 28 63 9 NC 126 8 6 TC 496 244 ' 'right of dower" a 62 NY 644 a 5 TC 634 247mtge constrn a 68 NY 178 8 5 TC 493 a 62 NY s5TC 2LRA 299 678 464 250 costs d47 467 254 costs equity f 9 26 12, 376 oid by statute 14 284 exceptions ev. 20 168 168 "ew trial -6 220 6M 131 7 NC 362 land in trust d 48 316 do 48 317 s 5 TC 454 print case 135S 1103 stay 151AD 884 liability 140 S n29 anthoritv 140 S r-,20 272 tribunal irregular a 63 NY 36 d9 110 31 . 371 47 AD 545 » 6 TC 439 7 AC 234 new trif).1 f 237 US 338 285 pleading 33 545 denial 46 AD IR s 5 TC 449 7 AC 98 f 74 NY 62 16 NC 269n 275n 287 indictment f36 311 s 5 TC 4fi7 e35M 1R0 1S0S .'>07 compliance 120 AD 369 forcferv 145 AD 698 allegations 145 AD TOl 295 litigation f 4 742 23 > 130 a 6 TC 562 contingency 116AD 771 304 certiorari X6 462 326 value claims a 62 NY 636 53 212 s 4 TC 461 not lapse T4M 320 134S 226 legacy lapsed d 82 M 213 329 trespasser a 64 NY 129 8 5 TC 476 338 Bubseq. acts sSTC 6CP afiQdavits f9TNY 626 e 38 494 443 s 6 TC 81 expert evidence 12 135AD 233 306 certiorari f 24 revocatioD 29 66 e46AD 59 AD b6TC 10 AC case 2 r71NY sfiTC 14 NC 1241 631 361 mandamus 29 AD 261 84 AD 238 239 44 M 147 16 NC 51n tan expulsion notice ^2iil5AC 161n 618366 contempt 3 1 arson a 62 NY s6TC 2*1 1' 62 NY 4 AC 117 5 NC Ji;,! remedy 65M 639 631 271n 378n 490 323 h. to wife 34 i'370 commissrs 8 61C 528 fees chose in action f84NY 675 ;a 62 NY e9 637 216 286 retaxation costs 14 AC. 24n improper pldg. 27 394 s 6 TC 89 375 mandamus 28 285 jurisdiction 58 526 38 31 173 155 559 6 improper 24 31 62 e 108 NY s5TC IM fact question e 95 NY 553 master neg. d 16 175 U6 NY 402 duty r. r. 43 30 342 title to hay d 45 237 319 e 127 NY 164 I'jsififnment 72 M comnetent 131 .S retain title f 90 M f 154 S 345 usury m64NY s5TC 2NC 125 NY 204 NY 204NY 2.CP 3NC s6TC 105M f 156 S legislat. power 49 481 f 79 NY 690 67M 63 f 92 M 288 383 parties in interest 539 228 133 360 224 368n 266 216 578 919 212 484 216n 351 boundaries r 64 NY ISO a 73 NY 205 : 73 NY 211 36 NY 7a sSTC 49(1 8 AC 170n 352 authority case 1 79 644 352 brokerage case 2 a 63 NY 652 s 5 TC 707 B 67 B 266 354 ratification f 6 362 weight of ev. 21 98 a 6 TC 549 357 charge error a 60 NY 643 36 132 challenge juror 4 1 4 affidavits 35 97 6TC 37 4 1 6 non Buppot r 74 NY 320 11 293 20 NC 306 307n penalty 119 AD 143 424 inaur. policy a 66 NY 441 6 IC 643 429counterclaim 9 AC 245n 20AC 24n 437 suffrage r 62 NY 186 9 6 TC 636 246 323 480 487 398 478n 186 256 186 f4 7 15 35 s5TC 3 AC 2NC 284n 394 reservation a 64 NY 366 s 6 TC 680 395 will executn case 1 634 587 382 80n 499 a 62 NY 86 9 AD 8 6TC 93 NY court's power f 164 AD 827 395 construe will case 2 a 62 NY 627 trust 110 AD 307 397 affidavit 2 AC • 61n 398 time case 2 10 M 654 40 I specified a 71 NY 298 83 NY 106 8 6 TC 43 4 LRA 690 407 appearance 8 AC 318n power board 138AD 477 4 1 3 authority case 1 f 9 88 8 6TC . 67 conversion 71 51 50 443 sanity pre- Bum'd 38 120 e35AD 519 11 AC 435n 436n 11 AC 44;',Ti s 82NY 83 S87NY 603 79 NY 546 10 NC 'iS4 voidable only 177 NY 262 450 bequest in lien dower r64NY 278 9 328 9 5TC 664 SCP 316 8NC 419 17 NC 34« 18 NC 422 authority 124 S 821 454 claim f24 114 decrees 70 AD 376 s 5 TC 654 22 K 499 458 pers. repres m 67 NY 400 d 56 AD 308 s5TC 648 8 AC 339 341 345 5 NC 217 11 NC 6S 3CP 64 462 general employer e 15 AD 243 20 AD 176 e 67 AD 83 8 M 436 441 30 M 741 464 power in trust a 64 NY 332 3 476 5 TC 596 473 construction a 64 NY 159 5 TC 606 70 AD 266 bank liiible 73 AD 631 477 f'd represn f 3 . 482 3 5 TC 586 6 NC 32n 481 payt new promise t9 8 19 598 ABBREVIATIONS: J c, criticised ; 1, limited ; affirmed: d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; !, explained; o, overruled; s, same case: do, dissenting opinion; n. parallel case: q, questioned N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Hur Vols. 3, 4 sSTC 6M 13 M 589 IflO 579 49 I entorcement { 43 286 496 evrideaoe 1 4B 11 87 583 42 AD 462 reverse error 60 202 498 bona iides d 10 614 » 6 TC 6ie 500 joint liable r 30 negligence 40 s5TC authorized 217 NY 496 539 objection exception '35 117 24 AD 487 54 1 damages I 96 M 225 159 S 916 545 canal boat f 13 6S3 review 3 AD 189 • 6 TC HI ' 14 M 499 59 I waiver a 64 NY 7 29 AD 3 6TC 85 457 650 300 lie K. . .. 1(30 547 services catie I d 73 AD 590 594 37 47 24 503 relief 69 8 6TC surety creditor I 71 NY 411 508 corpn neg f 1') 304 41 122 39 M 631 care duty 254 929 1096 maintenance 181AD 671 168S 802 549 certiorari case 2 126 136 217 NY 76 550 demand 25 273 55 ! opinionfi 596 mandamus a BO NY t)42 24 M 13 598 appeal •eSNV 916 600 lescitsion 46 82 i74NY INC 604 joindei i:nbe 1 64 NY 5 iNC 6 NO 8NC BTC rcp 8C1' 636imprisonm't a 62 NY •59 NY 21 6'rc 12 NC 280 196 206 3UU alary 220 NY 90 a 66 NY 617 198 595 291 117 453 703 eq. iien 2M 406 1 AC 23 15fi 143 NY 571 4 NC B7n 639 contract r 03 N Y 336 I mG 46 i.ti nC 54n 2LliA 647 646 pleading 35 661 conversion 22 AU 392 VOL. 4 2 mandamus a 64 NY 148 6 NC 151 n 7 compromise ,39 M 225 706commitsions 6 NC 151n 6 iOTC 23 197 708faot question £6 165 6 NC 117n 7 1 2 recovery s 6 TC 148 1 84 NY 430 173 2B1 217 260 385 292 58 73 607 usury a 63 NY 619 716 self-defenso 848 aaseaameat a 63 NY 625 note merger 4 AC 287n note for debt 16AC 144n I 6 exam, witness a 62 NY 229 78 AD 327 s6TC 215 10 NC 24 negligence r67Ni; 6 s 6TC ■2Ce 3CP 654 assault aB3Nir 73 65 100 174 97 621 15 LRA liability 178AD 165S 5 1 5 verdict f 19 353 519 husb 4 wife 11 521 60 86 com. law rule case 2 63 NY 64 55 67 »5TC 1 AC e76NY 92 NY 7NC 12 NC entirety 85M 145 S cotenants 7:i M 133S sole owner f 160 AD 523 expert ev. 18 621 63 232 568 130n 270 160 308 291 125 502 450 404 353 lien farm cane 1 08 NY 614 ueg. coservt rase 2 r 64 NY 5 sOTC 1 4 LRA • 856 555 fr'd mtge. a 66 NY 636 558 demurrer * 74 NY 80 580 cbge venue 114 AD 699 17 AC270n, 271n change nume 608 reformation ease 1 a 64 NY 463 f'd transfer case 2 a 66 NY 614 sBTC 291 uec. parties 19A0 187D 6 1 rebuttal case 1 f2NG 21n 8 I I damages a 66 NY 604 15 NC 303 f 22 34 40 62 AD 5NC 110 AD justification 1'>RANS surface water SSAD 405 f 211 NY 259 298 135 692 420 173 73r 86ti 529 sidewalks negligence f 29 55 82 123 NY exception 136AD . 657 sUt. limitn f 34 290 SI 299 66 1 contract 614 f 37 e37 42 ■ 66 636 341 742 565 128 AD discretion 75M 333S 673 40n 308 pers. trans- action 339 502 151 223 a 62 NY 36 1/3 AD 159 S employees 40 6TC JM no recovery 136S 718 no liability i 152AD 44 compensation 172 AD 745 159 S 615 168 132 71AD 6TC 187 156 720 contract r 64 NY 41 s 6 TC 183 130 NY 622 6 NO 308 n 724 Teseiislon a 64 NY 29 !6TC 3 NO 14 NC 196 168 108 93n 307n 8 6 TO 69 appeal case 2 a 63 NY 2 OH 72 services case 1 a 70 NY case 2 cost copy f8 e 13 AD 78 AD 95 AD 130 NY 156 NY 14 AC 391 358 425 238 286 359 171 n 29 contract time 211 41 167 612 184o 20 NC salary 220 NY 76 services ca^ie 2 a 62 NY 77 injunction *66NY 78 rent case 1 a 63 NY 10 NC 636 656 272 736 undue infl. • 62 NY 75 8S 392 739 ctrclaim f 14 189 196 LBl AD 146 S strike out 4 f 26M fraud 936 62 666 injunction 260 6 1 6 usury case 1 66 NY 562 l««itla' pwi a 62 NY 339 99 316 561 310 539 143 79 411 473 533 running stream a 63 NY 482 6 5 TC , 625 riparian rights 5 NO 173n 6TC 568 m lien f 6 8 6TC 57 I cODftruction 14 706 1 NC 98n 575 declarations a 64 NY 209 580 f 21 " 303 ratificn defense 48 110 ^consideration 120 NY 587 restoration 3 NC 93n 585 pers. trans- act f 18 323 67 417 9 6 TC 288 644 567 76M 135S 587 insur policy 535 records co. a 64 NY 304 clerks office |s6T0 331 a 62 NY 484 i 6 I 7 undue influ- ence r 66 NY 144 6 1 9 testam. cap. 64 NY 82 I damages 8 AC 205n 623faet question case 1 •64 NY 660 assessment ease 2 r 62 NY 457 a 6 TC 320 S27 trade name 5 AC 68n 630 deSc. judgt. 30 265 33 AD 160 107 AD 110 27 M 591 6 AC 195 198n e 93 NY 214 hnal judgt. d 46M 153 632 semcea f 4 72 extr. compensn. 26 AD 683 's6TC 151 trustee 16 jurisdiction 42 b6TC e92US sheriff f 92 NY waiver < f87M 92 M 149 S f 156 S ISAC 392 89 120 84 414 bjns 14 377 1036 821 424n 82 122 679 4S6 744 estoppel a 66 NY' 113 6 TC 172 117 US 115 755 assessments a 62 NY 624 s6TC 129 e 04 NY 609 760 jurisdiction r 60 NY 659 8 M 165 297 4 AC 3 I mtce. *63NY 10 NC 33 dower 22 NC 36 legacy a 71 NY 14 29 6TC HOP 43 assessment m 62 NY 504 48 tort f 5 substitution 26 abatement 1 SS 83 84 restoration 3 NC 93n 112n disch 631 48 404n 92 307 172 229 90 60 228 50 f'd release 21 1 avoidance f 65 AD 10 NC no reply f 153 S 91 M 4 LRA 80; 72 680 salary f 4 publie officer d 4 . 645 32 AD 69 d 67 B 224 75 NY 41 94M 136 157 S 519 682 substittion f 4 71 claim vested 6 390 685 jurisdiction r63NY 37 statutory 60 s6T0 239 56 155 164 116 137 1082 232 692 f'd transfer f 27 428 9 6 TC 142 2 AC 32n 699 demurrer 52 inquest B7 B 600 new trial cOst 129 AD 836 costs 186AD 87 174S 79 54 estoppel 13 AC 160n 57 protnise pay 39 393 62 complaint AD 65 AD do 117AD 133AD i-9l,ef do 38 CP 66 contract d9 66 libel case 2 d 14 ISS 79 recovery 9 6 TC 253 f 81 NY 346 91 pers, judg't r 67 NY 563 2 NC 340 92 conclusive a 74 NY 95 24 M 40 94 refuse audit 71 664 99 wharf neg. a 76 NY 617 102 NY 409 114 NY 404 132 NY 170 1 00 const, evict. 3 AC 79n SAC 427n 14 NC 69n assume risk e 59 »1 201 I 02 conv'tn e a 63 NY 590 38 194 s 6 TC 369 objections 18 M 215 7 NC 181n I 07 delivery ev. f5 471 inference 7 678 consideration 17 496 sp. performance 82 103 time essence 4 AC 112n 520 117 224 432 156 1 1 4 state power 1-. 5 17 1 2 i market price 9 197 21 NC 359 123 guaranty * 70 NY 155 d 40 251 s 6 TC 387 c 109 NY 481 8 NC 281n negotiable 139 NY' not personal f 82 M 270 29D 326 40 486 68 discretion la 63 NY 610 'r66NY 631 I 28 m. lien case 1 a 66 NY case 2 restoration 3NC 129 notice a 66 NV 93n ABBKEVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; t, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; c criticised: 1. limited: e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, dissenting opinion; p. parallel case;.q. questioned Vol. 4 N. Y. Supreme Court ll%OTis — Hun 12 authority 80 s6TC 406 20!-. ^35 I SOconstrue will f 29 41'! 132 phys. exam f 29 156 73 424 I 33 conclusive ease 2 a 64 NY ' 236 23 27.5 7 CP ISO pleading proof , 30 AD 287 s e TO 364 review 1 M 6 CP 187 certiorari .69 NY 30: 193 sep. d S 11 17 i-6 credit fc: benefit 67 M 1 95 declaration (j7 " ' 240 10 AD 374 4, 2C7 '■ 134 intention 25 224 4S7 38 , S52 express trust . >: 30 AD 301 *g6TC; 3S2 137 sroclihHis case - a 64 H^' S34 4 M . 4S: 139 cotiveiaion r 64 NY 140 iUe r64Ni SMC ILEA 4LRA I 4 \ decrei! case 2 a 63 ^Y irapns 440 estaff 307 o43 ' 89 M'j 3NC 4CP 137 S 262 colnmissrs. a 04 NY tJ40 s TC 460 mcompet. ev 120 AU 57'a 265 titleb'krupt a 161 tit., 03b 90 AD'- . 410 266 trespass (Jaae 1 d 9 £.72 ticble damages u6 1S3 266 practice 140AD VMS 742147 AD 103:4 AC 390 179 305 remedy 7 3etitiorr f 33 276 em, domain 114 AD S76 386 corpn. neg. a 66 NY 8 12 el3 ICP 334 693 304 83 ■260 389 malice 35 585 except n general 90 114 NY privileged 11 AD 128 aD sOTC l>u]-den plainliff l.TOAD r 8liT 130S 300 399 collector d 42 230 liability 141 S . 406 exec, devise 63 ■ 156 17 NC 346 3 op, 314 409 negligence a 66 NY 642 562 317 608 80 06 203 91U e.'SO AD 7;> -M e :2AC ,el2AC oOnjlSO S vacate 4i3,P^arol waiveriynM 469 includes day ■*57ii30S , 203 .'.'.ofi; 691 455 forgery. 468 06 446 . , . ^ ^ , , ;o£ void instru- 4 1 4 Stat, fraud ment case 1 33 S75NY ; 446I35 d 7 .iSSiri 43 8 6TC ,61l!47 ■47 iM 168 NY 458 astignmobt 420 1 artncTship a 6/5,NY 42 I usury " ONC .. ;• 423 appeal aOQNY 648 010 424 neg. damag ease 2 ii63 NY i'ree acts lOlM 179 245 3)0 i21 4S5 52 .13 ,390 358 2D7o 671' 635 043; 7S by. parol .59 AD .\C S4NY 86NY proofs petition 109AD 817 461 chge grade aG4 NY . 061 466 deceit a 64 NY , 846 fraud represns. do 144 AD r,.-!:; 12!) S , ti.-i ! 1 472 certiorari 86 o57 AD i'.i" ,425cin«Lriic Hiir48l premel^tatu case 1' ;24 «495 a 66 NY 40S;.p7'„K „. h. 10 NC 357i*°' absence de- 3 LEA 140 426 consent wills! a 00 NY' 468 427 new trial case 1 a 04 NY 75 NY 20 NO 272 374 481n 427 appeal caoe 2 a 66 NY' 638 429 interest 14 AD IM 21 M 1.55 256 85 :432fact question 18 M • 68 election «0 M ' ■ 13(5 ,for jury 141 S CO.-) 435 aesessmrnt a 63 NY' '635 441 jury trial 13 .534 446 exemptions - 64 NY 6 user 15 18 14 .\C 11 20 3S 44 eOONY r 104 NY certiorari 55 45 1 tenancy e2 1 5 SS : 28 M 1 AC 0^4 AC 506 298 596 105 490 585 526 512 535 , . 73 2411 347n ducted a 63 NY 61 ' residence '''> 69 ■ " " s 67 B T\ M 79 M 140 S ^ ... distinction,." 133S amenable '' iHOS "•" validity T'..' M .ittacliment, 167 AD 152 S 647 436 310 275 320 476 437 120 397 121, 272 G55 495 dedication 310 487 571 436 501 desig: paper a 63 NY (i3T m 5 ,. .. .' 437 10 271 e 70 NY 177 503 insur policv 78 112 di.'isolution 139 S It do loSAD S7t 509 review'- ■ 8 - , 389- 5 1 i flse pretense A 62 NY' . 623 6 427 512 12 ,129 1(5. ' 400 33 AD. ,.343 d77NY 127 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed ; d, distinguished ; {.followed; r, reversed ; m, irio^fedi ,\ .dismissed^ ■ b. "ole : ,■. criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; 0, ovSrriiledi s, same case; do, dissenting opinioii; p, parallel case; q,.qnestiqiie(|.' N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Hun Vols. 4, 5 intent evidence 33 p4S 68- 64 AD s6TC d6NC other acts dlO SONY 119 AD incompt ev 14 19 1»AD 632 483 281 455 476 696 431 159 374d 234 517 83 242 93 NY 569 595 stk. foreign corp taxation 520 penalty 47 268 objectioD proof 83 1,5* onus proband! 7.) M 4Sn direct proof 141 S 206 525 death surety r 63 NY 246 529 creditors 12 78 bondholders 41 72 24 M after aquid prop, 48 AD 17) notice 145 NY 134 27 AD 153 compensation 3 NC 30911 relief 9 NC 261 b i63 HAD i 3M .;3M 21NC 121 US 88 NY 138 NY 599 appeal a 62 NY 33 Lil AD 630 20t 45: 58!> 392 19C 16t 1B2 bSi 64t 645 23i 2iHi a 66 NY 638 affidavit 295 696 demurrer 14 NC S7 73 i67B 2 AC 4CP 344 officer :i NC 204 291 330 362n 356 2n 606 after born 24 216 6 1 4trustee liabje 81 87 UM 1 AC SONY 6 1 6 waiver 647 oowerappnt r 62 NY 376 67 N i- 523 dS NY 277 73 NY 538 6 18 trustees i 63 NY i07 B 2 NC NC 369 173n r72NY U6AD 114 NY 6NC ■waiver do 148 AD judgt. pleadings L38 S 5J4 want capacity 153AD 411 211 1 practice* 128S reYJew AU 81 1033 702 mortgage equities r64NY 7NC 220 188e 493 79 658 270 571 457 58 612 30 3 6 TC 71 ad. allowance 7 AC 450b 1 NC 17 8 1 9 life estate m68NY 3 67 B 17 NC 18 NC 8CP 485 214 354 4i 324 422 261 292n 260 D 540 witness ev. d 106 NY 526 545 contract r 73 NY 238 550 restoration 3 NC 93d 558 attachment 6 237 reference 93 AD 545 vacate assessmt. 109 AD 198 817 56 I variance 89 11 10 M 054 1 AC 49n 565 title passing 320 gross laches d 46 609 82 1 partnesship a 66 NY . 633 48 AD 593 116 NY 66 625 sureties cabe 2 6M 439 627constitalionl a 63 NY U 8 67B 10 NC ICP a 73 NY 10 67 AD 9M 114 NY 262 543 3C>0 409 477 849 considera- tion 17 334 3 67 B 188 65) injunction a 69 NY 212 3 67 B 290 5 NC 278 352 stockholder e21 121 31 309 3 6 TC 694 performance 116 NY 233 recovery 3LRA 554 653 serv. onatty 68 132 857 elm surplus 39 607 858 reference INC lOgn 664 ctrclaim a 64 NY 638 344 72 672 709 St. frauds 4 802 3 5 654 acceptance 20 418 33 556 164 S 417 7 1 2 construction 794 open & close a 71 NY 604 795 m. lien a 66 NY 1 796 ratification 22 269 797impeachm't rule case 2 IM 284 2M 32; VOL.5 I declaration r 67 NY d6 construction 15 186 352 77 50 comm. waivr 3 63 NY 3 6TC 3NC 5NC IGP 176 488 323n 80 199 7 1 7 conclusive a 71 NY 30 63 NY 2NC 4CF S96 60 469 19n 16 72 1 devise chrge m 66 NY 42 * 60 NY 29 728 abuse pro- 63 NY 4 AC 320 20 312 183 478 365 fise represn case 1 r 63 NY 634 666 73 440 53(1 498 569 contract a63 NY 365 577 reference a 63 NY 3)6 3 AC 69n 119 AD 691 579 damages 35 203 d 58M 202 counterclaim 165 AD 474 150 S 999 583 authority 4 588 6 249 587 authority a 63 NY 640 6 249 628remove cause case 2 ft 04 NY 99 US collateral 68LRA case 1 condonation 65M 520 630 attachment case 1 3 AC 97n 1 OP 367 4 CP 178 9CP 173 632 directors case 1 9M 6' 633 preaump. ev a 04 NY 64 2 r 07 B 333 634 attachment 590 composition 18 569 637 overflow isleading 19; 798 waiver bSNY d 97NY I 2 over charge r 67 NY 215 58 107 mechanic's lien 34 AD 216 I6admr. benefic 848 542 101 100 34 348 580 afiBNY 20 26 35 41 M 23 excise law e 27 217 misdemeanor 362 f 91 M 465 799 mtge void a 66 NY 612 e 27 2U2 800 foreclosure case 1 a 63 NY 268 802 acceptance case 1 20 case 2 damages a,6o NY 14 NC 1 LHA 627 179n 733 civ. dam. act e 5 333 335n 5 532 320 constitutional 9 659 death husband 418 858 107n 666 804 resettlement d 63 NY 57 7 AC 493n 805 form denial 74 NY 26 15 NC 257n 30 M 34 M 6 AC ■procedure 180AD 167S 272 38B 722n 408 477 670 domicile case 1 17 NC 440e 672 reference case 2 1 6 523 873 mistake recovery case 2 a 63 NY 456 67 B 323 875 power sale £ 101 NY 416 68 I disbursemts e 125 NY 111 683 ejectmt r. a 66 NY 454 3 AC 314d 686 judicial 32 523 50 296 17 AC llOn 15 survival 34 e87NY 739 legacy a 63 NY 23 iNC itiC 17 NC iCP 2 LEA IS 274 497 221 130 278 116 182n 433 180 809 contracto a 68 NY y NC 8 I proof 46 AD 16AC 767 769 610 46 n payt 540 147n 46 olations 160 S d 160 S penalties 160 S 8 25 revocation f95NY 226 28 day of date e 76 . OS, sale on credit 90 AD 309 lessee 5M 265 increased rent 12 M 351 13 M 634 20 M 596 2 AC 24n 27 holding over 127 NY 182 168S 15 exclusive 7CM assent 135S assent rent 76M includes day 136S 295 60 AD 68 AD 53 costs 3NC 3CP 55 revival 90 121 NY repeal 13 M 60 joinder d 56 9 AD 7M 60 la 5NC demurrer 174 NY 3 AC obligat'n several 444 689 g5n 161 214 240 550 539 248 470 410 280 286 298n 3 AC 85 M fl48S misjoinder 149AD 134S liability 1 .ifi AD 142 S 299 2-13 341 371 384 863 6 63 witness ill 6 AC lOSn 67 contract' r 64 NY 404 I NC 157n 22 NC 92n 75 sparks ev. II 220 19 889 8 I I contract r 66 NY 347 8 1 2 presumption a 64 NY 24 AD J.6NC 17NC .".CP 9CP 417 296 ISin 395 7 148 31 master neg. r 63 NY 449 4 LRA 714 34disaolutncorp a06NY 111 US 2 LRA 687 tiustee r63NY 657 692 coupons r66NY 14 1 LRA 301 760 blasting rod NY 243 i AC 329n 765 contrib neg. i71NY 489 769 master servt r66NY 181 1 25 165 1 LRA 486 777 accruing action 22 AD 822 783 application r63NY 404 19 A U 260 792 int. in land f 13 NC 308 793 referee rept ^ase 2 a 06 NY 039 13 NC 118n| 8 1 3 evidence r6SNY 507 179 634 460 . proof 76 neg. ILRA 27n notice not nee. 195 NY • 338 83 forfeiture 77 386 eq. conversion 133AD devise lOSM 169S 381 149 151 1061 424 541 266 86 objector bur- den proof ' trial 41 13 27 43 44 67 I AD 23 AD 52 AD 53 AD d 55 AD 69 AD 3M UM 16 M 8 AC 10 AC II NC 2CP 15 CP t:usiH trial 13.) relief 49 291 316 33 321 651 580 45 625 478 91 571 101 236 513 a 66 NY 10 90 waiver 9 66 NY exceptions 28 evidence 65 73 mpeach 19A0 opinions 120 US credibility ev. 407 62 423 286 346 382 437 249 618 326 391 392nl89 NY 431 119 NY 217n|l31 NY 328'prior declarns 72; 13 448 d 40 428 152 2 SA 499 800 I corroboration g2'200>;Y 339 42 appointment 1 103 indorser * „,, 577 a 67 NY 95 q 68 NY 817 25 46 . . (notice 44 open acctg 'e 48 362 7, 611 14 NC 492 abatement itoreclosure defns 154 S 957 4 NC 14.J ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, noie c. criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled: s. same case: do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q. questiunc-d Vol. 5 N, Y. Supreme Court Reports — Hun 1 04 accomplice wife witness a 63 NY .143 46 82 striking out 2 AD 440 s 67 B 648 1 05 prior vacate case 2 • 64NY 60 140 137 right review UBM 498 1 06 fraud r 66 NY 482 107 damages do 131AD 558 109iinpliedproin case 1 85 8M 1 AC case 2 parent liable a 66 NY ratification 133S 321 963 I I Owife earninss 7B 306 I I 1 vendee dam case 1 d 48 582 88 AD • 63 TO NC 344n I 1 2 adv. poBsn case 1 f 3 NC 310b appurtenance case 2 r 78 NY 613 65 206 I ISeffectofas" 13 AC 200d 17 NC 194n I I 4 rescission case X a 67 NY 3SA 128 NY reversal 148AD equity 132S 304 549 648 57' 562 65 347 73 382 21 M 4U1 error court 1U3 S 624 competent ev. 138 AD 828 1 2 1 fr'd transfer m 66 NY 374 1 23 settlement f 33 4B7 i! NC 284n 140 Sep maintn 28 287 2CP 118 andorsement 64 612 custody 75 NY 228 refuse relief 125 S 1066 court's power 69M 441 authority agM 441 146 amendment f 8 NC 206n mipjoinder case 1 a 64 NY d41 AD 107 AD •ourt powers case 2 » 66 NY 618 e 26 535 112 NY 332 special motioB 54 315 Parties plff . 07 AD 137 waiver 20AC validity 154AD 139 S 651 199 137 lien 121n 294 99 1 8 I conversion r 66 NY 308 d 65M 580 1 82 referee 7 AC 177n referenc e 53M 179 Btctly construed 39CP 60 183 approp. de- posit a 66 NY 271 4 LRA 112 1 84 adv. poBsn. a 67 NY 588 3 AD 347 1 87quo warranto a 66 NY 237 190 contract r63NY alSS 8 131 NY 5NC 6NC 636 473 4 490 125n 243 police just- tice powers 16 341 11 NC 2n 245 lease void 15 M 136 36 M 246 advice court f 84 N Y 392 5"NC 354n costs 1 NC 188n authority INC 407n 257 practice judges e31 26 AD 78 AD 4 AC 4NC 4CP renewal 117AD UNC reservation UNC 3-10 repeal implication 26 410 606 38n 96 212 253 265 suit for use of another d6 137 7 228 credrs remedy 480 436 I I 5 trustee case 1 14 55 gift e 111 AD 453 direct verd'ct case 2 a 66 NY 630 3 LEA 273 delivery do 165 AD 625 I I 6 drainage commissioners e 19 24 64 476 c3AD 36 f 72 NY 6 163 NY 141 private property ' for private use 72 NY e 1 I 7 btatemts fy d32AD 70 not aFgepsable 130 AD 890 ] 1 8 surety r66NY I 1 9 neg. ev. 17 326 1 9 5 construction a 67 NY 21 salary officers 6 133 607 486 1 5 1 misnomer a 66 NY 616 1 67 maJ, prosecn m64NY 326 84 AD 50 19 NC 352 1 62 estoppel 102 US 36 1 65 fencing r. r. r 67 NY 426 6NC H7n 167 credibility' 33 982 discretion ■ 38 423 eomp't witness 175 NY 194 I 69 challenge a 63 NY 88 6 NC 32n 1 70trustee ex- prees trust 36 360 92 606 20 NC 99 1 72 constructive notice 12 AD 198 m AU IB 19 NC 299q 16 AC 364n 1 75 discontinue 46 535 1 76 damages f 101 NY 117 20AC 105n 1 77 ranal lea^e case 1 a 70 NY 247 13 d 16 16 AD 14 NC 17 NC 219 NY 398 343 550 106n 76 276 12 25 41 e27M 6CP beneficiary 22 NC restitution 117 AD conversion 194 NY 269 notice r66NY 10 AD 2 LRA I97BUpt. oompl. 28 274 e 29 445 SAC 277n lOCP 209 200 stocktaxat. a 64NY 641 3 IAD 589 138 NY 546 20 1 em, domain a 63 NY 326 66 NY 418 1 NC 68n 209 survival e 14 571 d 19 188 15 NC 471 8CP 282 2 1 4 directors f 2 NC 248n 220 damages 7 246 d 70 NY 644 e 3 M 22^ 222 jurisdictios 44 M 39 229 leg. eq. actD 32 AD 582 f 3 NC 92n 234 incompt ev 1 80 mtgfl. lien a 63 NY 78 359 493 284 95 314 400 301 621 813 8Sn 118n 7 S 6NC 10 NC 15 A C 347 318 371n 214 141n constitutional 12 32 42 SAD 12 AD 17 AD 25 M f70NY 363 524 276 420 69 174 78 291 3 1 7 contempt limitation a 66 NY 64 76 Ab 14 M 2 AC 17 NC 8CP 368 449 313 595 268 . 62 337 277 act delivery 63M 223 282cond. preced r 63 NY 353 contract 5NC 27 283 recovery 4M 527 illnesa witness 6 AC 108n 285 revival case 2 14 combinations 16 NC 393n 286 appeal e 12 AD 49 124 aD 91, e94 renewal motion 4 AC 39 lllAD 862 287 assessment f 69 N 465 293cond. subseg 32 1 insur. coUat r 70 NY 19 e 11 518 327 iudorser re- lease a 69 NY 607 IS 403 security enforcbl 79 400 d 29 AD 24 83 NY 60 implied trust e 148AD 506 132S 831 332 civ. dam. act e 8 321 constitutional 9 559 87 NY 497 338 satisf. judgt case 2 a 68 NY 528 1 NC 46n 315 21 NC 375n 130 NY 5 340 parol ev. case 1 a 71 NY 590 38 M 112 joinder 15 NC 181 bill' particulars 16 NC 233 fraud 123 AD 874 369 mayhem r 63 NY 207 17 NC 423u 382 discretion * 63 NY 202 11 196 order arrest 14 108 affidavit 29 389 39 255 constitutional e 42 AD 505 e 26 M 667 7AC 277 remedy 121 NY 530 statute reasonab do 81 AD 551 joinder 15 NC 181 bill particulars 15 NC 233 397 foreclosure 9 NC 252 parties 19 NC 379n 407 partnership 4NC 452 'e34 d 65 6CP a 64 NY 7NC 13 NC 14 NC 471 278 339n 18n 4 1 4 benefit 42 revera. error e89 nonfeasance 80 M 142 S 71 341 charge 8 67 NY t 12NC 13 NC 2CP 34 10 AC 191 US 132 NY damages 132 NY 10 AC 177 116n 350 481 481 llSn 237 village oblig 629 f 23 59 594 120 gin ,406 42 330 297 review 28 61 once in jeoprdy 139 AD 495 discharge jury 124 S 346 202 NY 131 30 1 patents a 66 N 459 7 CP 187 304 eg. relief 342 dam easel 46 3 2TC a 115 NY 319 400 259 212 533 332 374 551 343 allegations 60 131 344 fenses r. r 62 295 81 285 345 pleading 52M 294 348 defence f 21 373 Stat limititation 70 AD 129 350 case excptns d 12 267 21 19 352 inoompt.ev case 1 e 58 297 353 tech rules *63NY 194 4 1 7 appeal remedy 38 M 118 pleading 118AD 42 1 recovery f 12 657 rely tax clerk 174 AD 510 161 S 155 425 cr. suit 7 210 15 72 1 NC 37 surplus income e 3 AD 281 428 contempt a 66 NY 8 coats counsel 439 denial 71 AD 393 28 M 376 5 NC 90n 15 NC 274n 442 assessment r66NY 395 e 24 M 361 quo ran to 59n war- 163 210 410 453 proof Jcnowl' 8 12 516 64 AD 119 454inspectn pris case 2 5M 21 M SAC 2NC 3NC 9NC 494 469 266 l44n 130 590 455 assessment * 63 NY' 645 457 police powr. r 72 NY 415 6 NC 488 459 receiver 52 342 461 allegtn fr'd d 52 505 463 assessment f 11 79 26 429 55 520 e 75 NY 327 464 guaranty 16 160 11 NC 302n 468 inference f 7 676 gift delivery 12 313 125 NY 577 incompt. ev. 37 339 65 223 472 paper in ev. 86 AD 444 14 NO 471n refresh memory lOlAD 42 475 constjtut'l 7 453 8 99 s21 41 47 26 M 215 20 d33 36 45 3 AC 4NC 8NC compliance 41 533 549 381 173 148n 72n75 185 356 a 76 NY 11 fl 13 23 27 do 32 d46 el2 AD 33 AD 56 AD 75 AD 95 AD do 171 NY 6 NO obligation 131AD trespass 136AD liability f 145 S construction 1160 AD 10 NC 321' 434 assessment a 67 NY 441 5 463 9 617 validates 271 307 80 479 36 479 582 certif, 10 11 12 14 15 21 479 contrib. neg 607 335 331 451 100 624 187 155 592 514 329 114 169 106n 887 1051 606 ABBREVIATIONS : a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, tallowed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note C erltioised; 1, limiteA; e. explained: o. overruled; s, same case; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q, questioned N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Hun Vols. 5, 6 482 eai. domain r 66 NV 569 3 NO 377n 2 LRA 886 4 LEA . 839 condemnation 3LRA 175n 485 bond, towns 7 -453 el7 380 488 neg. coservt 21 110 4 AD 230 con. pleadi ug 16 NC 474n 55 1 conveyance a 74 NY 196 554 insvirance a 74 NY d96NY 11 4 AD free passe 101 AD master 53M co-servants 1 23 AD passenger 102M 188S 617 272 860 sr 135 neg. 134 428 497 title passing B7 B --"'"" 3N0 567 58B 184n 260 346 . power ■ 609 492' 503 lei a 71 N^ 8 bparks neg. 122 NY 123 e 9 AC 337n g 600 proper care 67 642 incompet. ev. 67 B S73 t 91 M 584 express agreem't 133S 474 inadmissible f 154 S 935 { 91 M 533 5 I 6 negligence a 64 NY 610 8 64 NY 58 101 NY 257 11 NC , 315 mooring logs 3LRA 407n 523 nuisance r 68 NY 306 530 loss support 8 129 e 87 NV d8 r67NY 555 costs case 1 a 67 NY 3 NC 98n 112n 555 rstint trade case 3 r 68 NY 300 82 NY 448 35 AD 418 556 trustees case 1 f 32 383 556 aaaignee case 2 r 71 NY 435 al TC 494 601- 11 557release dower 11 225 75 561 ti. and w.eontracl 16AC 22 SGOundiacldprin. cond. precedt. 102 NY 312 32 M 507 demurrer 35CP 79 pleading waiver 119 AD 576 must plead 39 CP 289 599 extra Care e 121 AD a69NY penalty 119 AU transfers 119 AD 227 602 waviei* a 67 NY 204 d9 582 13 NC 383n divers oamagt 11 S96 22 163 16 NC 102 answer liabilitj' 5LRA 128n 605 St limitatn case ^ 4 AC e i6 misjoinder 15 49 9M ■ 19 exemplary dam, 34 209 116 NY 635 536 illegal ev. 12 375 17 8 19 78 1 1 AC 19n 24n 2 NC Un 7 NC . 361 construe will 146 S 140 paid in full 160 AD 829 542 indictment e64 duly" 68 AD 139 AD 114 NY 129 US 4LRA 1J3 a 79 382 243 627 236 690 965 544 easement 131AD 411 547 vanance 142n 56 1 naw trial a 67 NY 678 e 64 AD 546 564 penalty 8 286 definite reply 56 M 42 566. insurance •72 NY 24 notice e38 pass book 53 certificatee 107 NY 104 AD 608corpn. a 67 NY 85 AD 13 AC 420 647 allowance case 1 27 172 special powers e 121 AD 420 rescession 4 AD certiorari 63 AD 106 AD case 2 new trial 11 CO law calendar 92 2 pleadga. issuea 92 187 649depoBitCo Tr case 1 a 76 NY 698 belongs, plaintin 615 623 48 580 9 568 usury r68NY 104 US 569 intent 63 g4M 157 S affidavits do 38 AD 423 dS mandamus 39 AD 71 NY C77NY intention 10 70 remedy INC 620 fact ques. 616 174 900 81 572 merger int. m 68 NY 346 68 NY 345 11 M 478 30 454 587 easement 76 AD 141 waiver 77 AD 462 59 1 div. damage 5 604 11 596 22 163 sewer liability 6LRA 128n plead and prove 151AD 385 13G S 114 595 pleading 15 42 14 AC 52il 597 aver, notice a 71 NY 13 e87NY 70 AD 88 AD e97 AD 10 AC BOO 96 268 259 160 91 pwrs. 315 529 280 .ii M teacher case 2 a 67 NY 18 NC 627 36 367u 6 1 2 asaessment 96 1S2 483 344 546 556 69 NY 38 81 NY 149 NY 166 NY charge error 111 AD 49 M 607 109 362 262 62 329 139 624 defect copies f 27 M 51 renewal 117AD 253 161 S 410 626 legis. pw'r 32 569n e32 99 NY 483 constitutional 150 NY 444 delegate power do 204NY 129 638 affidavit 14 268 642 offra- judg. d 60 549 trial fee 7M 643 644 presumption a 08 NY 610 85 NY 141 645 chat. mtge. a ^7 NY 36 646 counterclm. 182 588 624 412 437 413 342 42Bla 67 NY VOL.6. I misfeasance 59 will test 66 NY 3 LEA 626 22 193n 305n 392 214 537 Un 650xeiectnclm m oi N Y (iOO 66 i sue in own name 2M 262 20 M 409 aiuuuutiou ICl' Nti 6011 653 payments a 66 N Y 626 3 LEA 273 854acceptance b4 70 a 64 NY f 20 2 NO 12 NC 3CP arrest e 45 M lfi.5S 16AC willful injury 195 NY 408 165S 536 169S 611 willful defined TOM 216 liability t 210 NY 180 5 feelings dam. e 16 601 libel l.^SJAD 246 [ I com. council r 64 NY 499 I 8 specif, denial 51 100 14 NC 317n 15 NC 273n 5 CP 431 not strike out 626 273 84 commisanrs r 67 NY 73 2 CP 174 3CP 97 7 ( bankins IH AC 394n 74 adiournment addl. allowances 19 M ^ 235 1 24 converaion a 68 NY -616 ■ 86,NY . ' 407 28 M . 32S no authority 11 65M 68S recover 93 M 84a 1.57 S 342 604 308n 824; 178 71 AD eSM 11 M 28 M 9 AC allegation issue 46 M 131 24 corporation a 67 NY 227 35 229 jurisdiction 57 AD . 532 constitutional 12 AC 72n 29 wai 41 2 AC 7 AC 11 CP amendment do 57 AD 52 393 513 622 376 182n 544 170n 449n 421 273 3 1 trust valid a 64 NY 566 24 AD 561 discretionary 110 AD 308 court's power £ 164 AD 160 S 46 usury r.66 NY el2 3LRA 49 will test a 67 NY 6NC 827 511 3SS calendar 10 AC practice 117AD Kiilv remedy 134AD 570 special term 71 M 169 75 suscension 8 382 pend act. pldg. 6M 387 3 AC 220 80 objections q 18 1 mat, opn. acct. 53 AD 486 70 AD 129 47AD 217 .•11 S 1043 burden proof S3 AD 606 e 98 NY 221 acknowledgmt. 30 97 IM 252 38 CP 608 19AC 430n 88pub.instructn a 66NY 586 92 attendant r 66 NY 592 94 judgt. dSset a 64NY 546 good title 114 AD 506 I OOinference 7 676 discretion 23 060 88 367 15 AC 38n bk. entries etc. e 57 538 64 673 7 AC 476n 479n f 149 S 551 incompetent 87 M 192 446 576 146 348 446n 55 surend. chk. a71NY 597 44 113 consideration 80 AD merger 88 SM d6M payment 124 NY 16 M 1 aU I 87NY intention 47 e76NY 79 conting liability f ' ! 3 A-D 106 trade name 200 appeal -- 119 AD discontinue 92 26 AD 5 AC 21 NC ILEA \ 28 trustee f 88NY 72 132 interpreter d84 52 U NC 21. i 35 challen(« P 6 140 6 NC 32b de facto oSieer 30 509 10 NC 261 1 42 de factO'Crffi- cer e73NY usurper 204NY 343 4» 1 49 damgs ev 27 120 152 29 4 33 e44 e 36 43S 123 NY 250 61 M Sll 1 55 once mtze r 68 NY 499 e 91 AD 250 1 64 subacriptioB d 19 NC 78 166 relig. asen. m 68 NY' 570 5 NC 90ii 20 NC 481b 182 incomp . ev e38 1.57 9 276 2NC 179 quantuns meruit 3 M .5011 13 M .'>»4 21 M 41 S implication 113 NY 449 22 NC 289n 186 loan r67NY 138 197 default f INC 15 67 283 267ni 113 45n 203 power to aeU 1 09 exemp. tax. 569 256 269 79 35 555 462 622 233 525 215 a 64 NY 10 e42 98 AD 10 NC educational 32 AD 85 AD 23 M 656 246 31 240 429 202 79 a 64 NY 2NC 4NC 15 NC 18 NC 22 NC 115 a 70 NY 6 12 el7 37 126 AD 2NC 8CP notice 2d 79 incomp. ev. 695 182 181 273 477 387 311 17n 119 1 122AD 468 506 404L 122 137 3070 421a 2 1 Swill conversii r66NY 18 NC ?20.„ l4 AC 16? 8S 23611 223 injunction 10 damagea 11 s2TC 76 NY 263 442 571 195 225 forecloauee * 6« NY 4.56 ABBKEVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismisaed; n, note CMiticiaed; U limited; e, explained; o, oveivjled; 8, aamecase; do, dissenting opinion; p. parallel caae; g, questioned Vols. 6, 7 N. T. Supreme Court Reports — Hun 228 aajeasora B 64 NY. 634 229 contract case 1 r 67 NY 475 23 1 chat, mtge til 569 -e 4 SS 1 548 fraudulent 99 NY 172 232 chsl. panel a 64 NY 485 a 6 493 e 36 107 234 atty liable ! 137S 371 ;ause action 152AD 401 not bound e 152AD 401 tio recovery 152AD 402 267 commitm't U 202 e 107 NY 156 276medical 129 AD 129 f 18NC case 2 eoBtB a 66 NY 67 B lAC BNC 40il 646 600 290n 437 279 eodieil 47 compliance 58 21 19 M 679 4 AC 264n 280 rescission e 67 NY 309 3 NC 93n 236 guaaranty payment case 2 a 64 NY 669 15 237 atty '8 lien case 1 11 •64 NY case 2 atty's lien 11 SAC 25 26 97n 238 perpet. ev, case 2 ] NC 341 iDurden people f 88 M 472 152 S 206 239 fraud ev. 6NC 263 51 242 easement 13 NC USn 14 NC 52d sup. * 64 NY 250 habeas corp. > 64 NY 481 251 indemnity r68NY el4 7NC 17 NC 19 NC 254 appeal *58NY 256 com. ■ 76 AD 12 AC INC 7CP 355 600 185 41n 313n ncom 129 171 34 2d 11 783 285 meas. a 67 NY 25 AD dam 6? 292 290 party in int. a 72 NY 376 41 672 293 subscription 30 approval 72 AD 465 f 211 NY 231 neg. reversal do 125 AD 898 3 1 consignee e 36 M 646 38 M 364 notify 1273 609 L43 AD 119 3 1 4fact question a 64 NY 524 e 17 117 4NC 39 law question 18 195 320 expert ev. a 70 NY 112 118 d 97 NY 51S estate in fee 102 NY 624 47 M 179 negligence 2 NC 382n eq. owner L27AD d67NY 294 a 28 134 71 876 estoppel 137AD 42 ."i E 161 AD 48 f 146 S 259 liability 128S «0H stockholder riM 221 298 discretion 18 M 248 326 dif. cause 91 423 11 AC 469n ejectment f 112 NY 186 NY 109 AD 19A0 299 incojnpt. oasp 1 do 37 137 S case 2 ordinance r64NY 68 NY prohibited 77M 340 980 63 261 509 300 injunction dam. a 67 NY 600 8 AC 470 30 1 vested estate case 1 r 67 NY 63 16 NC 264 302 motion new trial case 1 377 528 297 224 257Btrand mean ing r68 NY 459 21 AD 15 261 trusts 71 M 304 .264 cond. prect 127S LSI S 147AD burden 73 M 149 802 67, OS plaintiff 470 proof issues \38S 391 taitaages 10 exceptions el2 13 303 defense 31 394 304 assessment case 1 a 68 NY case 2 a 68 NY 38 83 AD implied power 07M 303 305 assignee a 64 NY 657 72 214 mtg. interest 5LRA 291n 321 321 274 182 118 US £S4 e 14 AD 44 2 AC 408 46 1 jury question r 64 NY 535 d 19 34 470 contract a 71 NY 333 476 exceptnchrg 3 AC 238 477 estoppel case 1 a 69 NY 113 22 NC IfiSn 477 serv. aumns. case 2 a 66 NY 194 3 LRA 269 witness 3LRA 31 369 489 219 317 33 1 delivery, gift 3M 278 338 mistake bd 16 635 346 note partner a 73 NY 693 17 NC 194n 2 LRA 254 3 LRA 77 353 presumption a 67 NY 283 9 124 13 26 5 NC 247n 366 trustees liquidation 136 190 295 44 318n 56 31 M 134 NY 151 NY INC reformation 19 NC 448 375 ans. issue 27 M 632 377 motion neg. new trial e 10 628 e 12 297 378 ne exeat * 66 NY 617 24 112 e 89 NY 8 38 1 injunction a 69 N V 264 e 56 484 .construction 11 IAD 826 40 I construction a 72 NY 334 48 ,277 disqual. opinion B NC 23n 428 forgery a 72 NY 365 446 prox. cause a 66 NY 50 267n 478 malice dam 26 676 d 30 589 87 NY 399 INC 263 479 dower 10 M 431 ptnrshp realty 13 AC 12ea 486 dedication r 73 NY 660 489 Stat, power r 66 NY 127 8 NC 174o intent felony 113 AD 342 493 grand jury a 64 NY 436 30 103 107 108 37 M 353 10 NC 269 506 salary a 67 NY 609 d 8 487 492 509 false preten d 12 129 dlb 33 AD aOAC intention 64 AD 456e 457 458 344 62n 513 sale infants land a 67 NY 231 14 NC 504n 5 1 6jury question 29 inference 12 AD 193 11 M 72 5 1 8 foreclosure 61 443 26 AD 634 522 reference d2NG 189 524 prostitution a 64 NY 10 disorderly 129 AD in arrest 167 AD 153 S 659 139 774 333 126 528 attachment d 27 246 e 31 576 31 683 2 AC 361 4 CP 360 7 CH 149 528 Sep. entate case 1 a 70 NY 3 NO 295 178n 529 fidueiarr ease 1 a 12 482 14 108 conversion case 2 36 M 241 22 NC 76 53 1 tender 2 NC 267 532 reference 1 NC • 109d 534 judicial sale m69NY 16 divested 70 M not lien 141 S G63 327 404 322 543 notice r69NY 11 compt. evidence e 22 390 546 carrier neg. r 67 NY 208 liability 69M 426 127S 443 550 CO. elk fees a 68 NY 198 e 12 AD 146 553 reversiGn 14 5; 45 5 'real estate" 37 AD 556 mistake 16 assessment 35 eSl 587 controverted 21 116 (66 AD 116 1 NC 46n 59 I implied promise 11 136 NY enforcement 120 AD 279 609 429 600 damages a 67 NY 153 h2 421 15 334 4 AD 224 e 4 AD 226 604 highway a 68 NY 283 111 US 236 4 LRA 520 6 1 3 compound interest r 67 NY 162 2 AC 41 46n 7NC 42 62 1 wif es rent d 26 214 3 NC 184n 625 certiorari 274 19e 631 569 VOL. 7 limit liability a 76NY 65 7NC 42 5 insurance r68NY 625 7 pub. nuisance a 7 66 16 389 35 107 e31 M 322 191NY 341 perscript ion ILR 297n spl. damages ISAC 161n public nuisance 19A0 158 1 5 deed mistake a 67 NY 338 21 312 18 payt justice 17 241 18 483 36 M 64 20 incompet- ev. 16 7M 13 M 9NC 632 uaury a 64 NY e26 ownership 28 revival lien 35 subrogation 66 NY e94NY 218 638 72 294 212 23 132 366 85 13 26 68 disqualified 66M 123 S 560 improvements 14 584 85 M 243 148 S 351 owner consent e 24 539 e 35 179 e 26 AD 431 7 AC 409n 18 NC 69 77 NY 389 e 90 NY 137 NY 172 NY construction 125 NY 645genl denial 7 12 27 s6TC 22 M INC 20 NC 339 193 69 193 180 314 262 562 rent a70Ni' U 12 consideration 26 67 tenancy 21 NC 310n 572 discretion r68NY 114 484 136 167 646 718 476 363n 650 evidence d .38 169 2 NC 16o 652 certiorari 49 . 479 identification 113 AD 460 655 m. lien case 1 * 67 NY 311 8 144 7 AC 408n case 2 security r 70 NY 604 li 233 657 burglary case 2 44 2 8 12 8S 555 143 AD 365 274 68 1 256 85 575 wives nee. 11 294 loaa services 35 54 31 NC Kuardiau 50 AD father '.■■ duty t M 648 651 658 test, capac. case 1 15 NC 150 case 2 services 121 189i34 M. . 58S implication 10 n B 058 139 S 1003 366 609 105 659 relief notice 18 AD 84 23 place trial 68 26 28 M 680 129S 459 mandamus 145 AD 11 25 appearance atty. r 70 NY 253 12 444 8 AC 316n 319n 20 NC 249 2 LRA 268 26 trespass dam 3 AD 333 treble damage 38 CP 441 443 31 tr'd transfer r 66 NY 363 6 NC 471 33 certiorari 90 631 39 jurisdiction r 66 NY 606 72 AD 529 constitutional 160 NY 443 compensation 3NC 309n practica constrn taxpayer suit 16 NC 96n 44 corpn. mtge a 69 NY 328 52 fishi? arrest r 69 NY 238 56 conclusive a 66 NY 620 U '3S6 60 wife's liability a 66 NY 87 63 parties deft 88 NY 61 no preference 152AD 66 136S 610 585 -leg. dam. 660 defense 16 VI 610 165 NY 471 66 relief 36 107 aBBRBVIATIOKS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note criticised; 1. limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same ca.^e , Jo. dissenting ooinion : p. oarallel case; q, questioned N. Y. Supreme Court EepOrts— Hun Vol. 7 69 juriBdiition 9 , .. ... 693 coats reference n 23 S AC 99i] 73 taxation r 71 NY 29 227 235 160 109 498 550 74 cond. precedl a 66 NY 613 2,6 waiver SAD concIuBive , 14 M 429 80 variaaee U 450 verbal contracts 67 ;,., ■ 475 lex loci 52 AD 61 8 1 revers error case 1 a 70 NY 141 f27M. ■ 225 case 2 . willcoBStme a 70 NY 141 87 NY 438 perg. service 122 AD ■^limited 68M '123 S 122 342n 586 3-10 875 83 serv. process exetnptioTis case 1 a 69 NY 7 AC case 2 slander a 69 NY 122 77 NY 187 vacate order 60 M 146 ;84 contrib. nee. , 3LRA 367 86 partition 4 .VI 351352 88 opinion '31 32 1 ss • ■ ■ conclusions 91 M' 154 S 1 29 receiver accounting e 30 343 5 NC 3S3D 133 lost freight r69NY 625 S N Y 34 40 r. r. "stop over ' ' 56 -. 272 3 AC 313n declarations 84 , 310 I42etatements 6SLRA 399 ! 46 preference 31 68 69 AD 157 158 28 NC 335n 8fi NY 631 e Ml NY 231 diligent creditor 23 M 729 3LRA 139 n I 5 I construe will 6 N C 349 lenanf cuHesy 15 AC 227n 448 346 560 352 880 89usp occupation d ISO NY 122 164 NY 380 cause, action 104.M . 17 171S. 971 96 forn. Corp. e 14 126 19 480 1 00 infancy bar 4 AD 584 23 AD 364 no cause actu. 131AD 436 1 05 extr. allow m 68 NY 71 d 24 552 2 NO 323n 4 NC 171 18 NC 184n411 8 CP 230 bulkhead line 96 M 25 160 S 992 I 1 7 "residue" r 73 NY 317 7 540n intent 8 NC 125 iurisdictibn UNC 53-60 411 legacy interest ' 16AC 197n after 1 ye^r do 133S 149 duty executcr do 148AD 531 221 oonstitutl. t33 286 6 NO 291 59 M 679 581 construction 164 AD 552 S 80 8 CP 396 s2SS . 153 contest merits 3 AC 42 44n \ 57 pal asjree- a 7? NY 141 25 US 71 AD 42C rent e 120 NY 263 modifioattoii 54M 102 l64counterclaim 111 NY 455 8NC 28^71 not liable lOiM fi» 171S 205 I 67 fim,ptnrship a 69 NY 24 82 NY 423 1 7 1 rape ev, II AC 349n 1 75 injunction 29 578 51 405 58 55 67 308 101 AD . 105 12NC 464 ma vor power 62 M 102 1 80 survival *67NY 606 27 M 611 1 84 extra allow. d31 ■ 403 36 154 16 AD 213 4NC 2n 14 NC 102 20AC 194n 195 fiduciary * 67 NY 393 14 108 affidavits e 2 AD 338 202 vested re- mainder r69NY 36 do 8 47C parties e9 H02 24 Ifl iurisdictioo IINC- 41b 208 cred'r. suit e 18 466 executn. cond; precedent e29 33 34 e34 18 149 NY 31 M ) NO lONC 5CP execution,, 172 AD' 129 3 145 S 158 S enforce 14D AD on merits 144 S f 83 M 571 60 160 236 6S9 527 419 30 son ,429 244 ]0:>.H 398 195 paymnt 269 423 184 2 1 protest no- tice 12 28 AD S2M AC 7 AC 137 NY 2 NC 517 2,57 •595 2,5g 108n .382 70n Jcrve nntioe (1 ISO 812 2 t 4 legia. power 10 436 11 391 175 NY 444 f 91 M 513 f 155 S 375 indictrat defect 14 13 b.'d health power 17 19 37 33 AD 110 AD 73 NY ' 563 549 321 *78 14 70 218 Stat, limitation a 69 NY 608 75 311 burden proof 112 AD 290 16AC 302n 306n Gtuaranty 18A0 325 non refiidents 200 NY 81 220 parol ev. 24 e85 16 M 78 NY dQSNY 634 73 132 80 297 562 223 release 21 7CP debt due 34 ■ conversion 35 directn ezceptn. 56 442 ev, admissible 21 AD 133 73 227 deposition - ,r 67 NY 394 9NC 228 as 73 iV! 1.30 S ' 67b tiae -246 lo-i-s 229 authority 46 367 sp. perform- ance case 1 r69NY 24 M 8 NO 10 NC 12 NC 46 575 64 el2 70 NY relief 2NC £55 conclusive 116AD 688 260 conclusive e32 M 120 acknowledgment} 26 267 inaur a 09 NY e5SS 25 132 NY 309njlOOAD 3921 ^^ 276ni275 averment mt. 614 244 67 173 114 339 estoppel 10 21? 47; cvc.Utia lienl 6 AD,., .190 4.'; , I lit IS JI I 4;8 342 real party 10 513 e30 490: ' -i22 :iWr.icy 345imp'd' repealji'i.iin^ ' _^ case 2 30 e98NY ISNC 7 OP ■iS CP 19A0 97 221 194 90 27 AD 001 a7QJSry 8 12 SONY 3NC ONC 10 NO 2 OP 3 LRA 287 319 033 526 435n 107n 214 431 302 279 check loan 35 i odlis cq. ma S0Sir73NY 73 417|84.,., 276 ■a LRA 145 6?8 27S!a 69 NY 50:>|12 421n 230 ackno-ivldst ln.5M 430 174S 415 232 handwriting 10 AC 256n 233 indirection case 1 67 NY ••;40 ll'M ' '.'■125 9CP . ;i02 233 bilj lading case 2 ■ 2 NY i90 73 NY 352 235 recognizance e" lis r.^lief 1 1 176 AD ■ , 57 159 S - 777 236 materiaUty oa«e 2 2 NC 144ri 237 preference 161 AD 284 146 S 811 238 settleraen case case 1 *66NY 541 m2N0 305 forbearance con- sideration 502'357 prior mtge 23 24 30 -,.. 57 , ,■-. 4 AC 21 NC new trial 30 120 NY 842 35(; 507 173 283n 15B 288 .6 288 assignment 10 267 trustee sheriff 17 58 61 80 AD 381 295 justificat'n a 71 NY 466 e 90 NY 482 3CP 64 296 subscription r 67 NY 409 eSlM. 422 jud'. const 'ri. 4 AC 260 264n s 08 NY 298 bail *81 NY 82 NY 628 01 574 299 discretion f 34 242 645iplace trial _„„ !16A0 172n 239 allegations time 300 contract case 1 1 7 NO 266n 91 ■ ' 496,7 CP 220 14 NC '60ni 3 ( 3 ne exeat 17 698 80 NY 25 401 i 2 NO 197n 9s2^3l7 no title , 5-SRn 20? 148 AD M 235 ^ 122s 1020 ,0 so 320 assessment "''ir 68 NY 214 5(55 28 602 ^'^'^iSNC 478n .2g2 6NC 66n 239 commissnr case 2 a 70 NY 327 a3NC 10 NC 11 NC 20 40 2 LRA waivei 83 conclusive 19 NC 244 note seal '324 elms, purch a 70 NY 637;a69NY 322 14 2071 estoppel 1 330 limitations 50 AD 129la 68 NY 83 d98NY 297 94 NY 219 easement I 13 NC U7n:33 1 laches relief 14 NC , 62ni45 AD 574 8 CP 53,2 M 409 |12NC 361 253 usury m69NY estoppel 248; 334 damages ir70NY a 67 NY ■ 437 do 79 NY ' 40 7 NC 188n 284 eq. owner 3S M 032 y,7 ii ,4/> rat2:abIo interest lOo AD. 173 e lOH AD , 198 ' J7 M 42 .subordinate Jien 163 S 197 198 knowledge 163 S , ' 199 362 contract d 25 139 parol evidence 25 144 32 545 ■54 542 45 AD 91 127 US 604 114 NY, , 187 ■>bjections excep- ■ tions, 25 ■ 569 368 practice relf, a 71 NY '280 12NC ■ 344 4CP 31 370 stop over 0311 647 371 tax title 32 14 assessmt. owner 41 538 169 NY 28 375 acceptance 43 M 621 380 eiectmen' r 68 NY 153 12 NC HI 387 estoppel r 67 NY 600 10 56 14 , 353 392 recovery i9l2 361354 116 NY 166 22 NC 418n 399 carrier oeg r 71 NY 180 416' filing mtge. a 6S NY 629 f 11 640 61 AD 356 4 CP, 187 receiver liens 16 692 levy excused 23 ■' 49 91 72 relief 425 profits fosses ^^ , ,_t„213 '427 gains losses '■71 NY .,. 118 1 .. - ' «5'7 ■6 M ,. 386 4LRA 571 439 witnesses a 70 NY ' 385 .13 16 improper ev. 17 , 8 19 > 78 2 NC I5n I3I1IO AD 93 : A(j _ authority 1 l7An ■ 131 S 156 870 '8811 470 882 448 ultra 11 432 ■32 AD ' 582 449 preference 41 248 452 town bonds r 71 NY ,613 101 US OO5 103 CS 809 62 ,192 11 NO 171 4, LRA 691 454 new rial 12 : 171 27 314 24 AD 254 2CP 324 waiver 72 ..'■ • 427 e91 637 15 AD 8 25 M " ,331 13 AC ■476n 455 waiver a 09 NY 191 9 -423 458 waiver 20 M . 256 10 AC 450n 484 objn. ans 8 NC ■ ' 197n 466 ministerial 24 ■ 67 e 46 495 trespass liable 12 NO 2n 13 CP .253 470 irregularity 53 , , 208 • implied contract 48 .'VD 24 127 NY 581 trespass 11 NC .... . S5n 472 authority 53 208 478 pub. policy r 73 NY 107 19 NC 466n 479 exemption P 11 ■ 475 480 sup. lAC 92 M AnBREVTATIONS: c, eiriticised ; 1, limited : pro. 317n 334 a, afifirmed; d, -distinguished,-;, f. .{ol lowed; r, reversed; m^ modified; *, dismissed; n, note e, explaiihed; o'.'oveFruled: s.samccase; do. dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case; q, questioi^ Vols. 7. 8 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Hun 92; now proceeding 64 M 135 'S voidable d 58 M dismissal 38 OP 13 345 482 ' ' 'new matter' ' 77 AD 1 NC 5NC eeneral denial 20 NC 348n 485 demurrer 314 472n 90n tort survival e 62 259 76 559 i AD 210 5 7 1 expert ev. 10 M 737 576 usury pldg d 10 601 29 ISO note invalid 83 420 41 488 eq. lien 23 51 79 AD 37M 104 NY 125 NY 15 AC 12 NC 572 286 169 579 655 303 230 438n 407n eontract good 1C7 AD °67 492 infants par ties ■ fiDNY d3U 8 NO election e58 125 AD 553 372 5 336 393 494d'i-5afBrmanoe 130 AD 1^6 499 town bond 491 821 490 380 444n 186 481 580 trans. 16 AD stock 606 583 oral prom, e 62 129 590 partition 2L,liA 172n 59 1 preference 35 130 fact question 41 246 pa3 ment 73 349 fraud transfer 512 87 *°1 20 AD 76 592 presumption 16 AC 249n 655 em. domain a 68 NY 591 8 30 29 305 659 insuT. pel. a 72 NY 603 e 33 643 73 NY 160 662eq. conversn a 67 NY 556 668 mandamus m 68 NY 259 VOL. 8 I dis'tribution ■ 69 NY s 103 US J29US dI7 SNC 10 NO ICP 522 redemption 70 NY 557 525 waiver 77 368 lOAO 217n do 114 NY 650 perfect title 21 NC 202n conform proof 19A0 804n 530 prom, note 82 176 637 legacy chfi:e 20 284 e30 173 47 250 3M 467 8 NO 127 540 spl. damage 3SS 513 544 legacy mt 28 AD 652 66 74 33 AD 39 M 2 AC 13NC 5g4lieD 42 M 596 140 627 640 44n 351 lodging 221 670 13 28 stop over 362 464 674 license phv. 8 AC 196'n 675 evidence 17 9 37 339 65 223 677 election a 72 NY 6M 207 160 56 5M misconduet e 134 NY ultra vires 151 NY illegal act 167 AD 135S ratification 150AD 4 trustee a 69 NY 12 31 trustee lien 73 NY 135 264 296 680 787 712 eog 433 347 131 rght. diaooQtiuue 3S CP 471 37 joint liable a 71 NY 21 SNC 10 NC 17 NC ICP 2CP SSO 36S 282n 184 68 76 47U 384 6 assumption mtge. a 71 NY 26 11 504 1 NC 98n pers. liability 6 NC 227n 9 construe will 60 I trustees cor- poration r69NY 39e 608 mandamus r71NY 612 27 M 46 32 M 66 appeal remedy. 12 472 6 I 2 meniorand. ev. a 71 NY 10 31 34 3 AC r67NY 14 bond 77M 138 S jurisdiction S5M 148 S relief e85M 96 M 148 S amendment 159 S 551 12 appealable 84 552fact question a 67 NY 601 23 451 557 compliance 26 34 14 AD 57 AD 19 NC COP 306 371 394 518 368n 346 563 f'd tran.^fer 22 ,61 129 AD 115 698 530 246 226 144n 6 I 6 adv. possn. 57 AD 190 not endorsed 136AD 396 hold over 170S 510 no privity 186AD 239 623 lien equit 11 324 23 286 specif, prefer'ce 29 401 18 AD 203 16 AC 446n 629 note a 72 NY 80 632 tax payer suit 22 AD 279 636 waiver 58 58 11 AC 447n 448d 11 AC 452n 641 advancera'f r 68 NY 108 a 70 NY 5661 650 demurrer ' 387 672 494 935 496 184 936 516 1 6 neg. damages a 74 NY 609 24 10 estoppel SM 658 constitutional 1 AC 19 NC ILRA 262d 249 294 48 1 9 relief 86 assignment void 137AD 246 not defeat lien 79 M ;i66 140 S 4;«> enforcement "0 M 3CC 21 discretion 6M 93 23 variance 26 M 705 jury information 1 AC 5n 40 assessment r 61 NY 332 7 NC 276 13 NC 109 19 NC 192 46 injunction damaffas 8 AC 472n 474n SAC 479n 480 n 481n 50 preferences 101 partnership 15 AD 624 17 NC 179n joinder S9 AD 439 compensation 114 AD 459 remedies S9M 476 58 certiorari 16 463 58 rr. regulation a 79 NY 561 6 I directors tortious acts 38 398 18 M 158 3 AC 371n 10 NC 160 20 NC 437n 9 CP 316 stockholder 202NY good faith c 135S legal right ioOAD 160 S 91 00. ot. pocfrer a 77 NY 10 39 AD 71 NY INC 12 NC 16 NC 342 546 10 182 483 442 n 289 9NC 110 157 sheriff liable r74NY 97 delegation a 69 NY 506 9 155 1 00 m prosecutu 194 NY 12 02 probate 11 AC 337n destroy will 61 M lOP NS 1 1 surety d 19 71 misjoinder 9 AD 3 AC 5NC 17 27 6CP 395 444 463 214 176 I 7 1 mandamus 210 594 538 249 297 299 278n 280 I I2inj. to wife 9 _ 539 559 constitutional 18 364 exempl. dam. 34 206 42 312 116 NY 536 I I 6 pers. liabil. 13 326 r67NY 15 CP instruction 49 77 error SAD (M 11 M 3 AC 235n 1 76 intent a 70 NY 2NC 330 132 405 605 SO 404 248 236n 34 19n 178 certiorari 24 67 27 M 39 180 demurrer 26 »8 AD 16 AD acccounting 84 AD cause action 33 M 1 85 practice a 70 NY 11 14 110 565 339 393 719 dl4 18 SNC 246 257 601* NC 90 ^s^J^J-y 14 788 713 65 Sep. estate 10 76 11 55 law remedy 15 AD 153 e 1 M 461 6M 355 68 presumption 26 tender mtgee r70NY U NC 7M '42 M 84 M mu 146 S 149 S 4CP marriage 16AC 649 466 271 115 861 106 134 lOn 553 cironmstautl ev 374 30r.r titlelande a 67 NY^ 371 INC 43n 9NC 20S 16NC 1 68 201 19 NO 423 each costs d 142AI) 244 32 cloud on title r 71 NY 1 34 rei tiorari a 67 NY 40 3 NC laches 37 M covenants 8 NO 242 229 309n 132 241 84 M 672 78 pers. liability m 09 NY 280 11 503 1 NC 99n 5 NC 232 256 19 NC 31 3n 83 indictment a 67 NY 609 29 465 85ap«al remedy 06 AD 517 f 26 AD 623 87 implied pi-om 1 27 restrictive 13 17 15 80 incompetent ev. 26 274 e 29 608 2 NC 20n 128 constitut'l 9 559 prn. liabe 34 67 93 AD 87 NY 127 580 36 498 1 3 1 easement a. 71 NY 194 3 LRA 862 1 36 sett'mt atty r 71 NY 443 dll 1 NC 2 NO 10 NO 18 NO 2CP 3CP 4CP 5CP 9 OP 137AD 332 464 124 593 I 89 damages 12 18 36 AD 54 21 M 411 205 spo'l guard. a 74 NY 7 NO 14 NC 16 NC 448 469 504n 477 2 I 6 protection 149 NY 427 binding 132S 876 by by-laws 148 AD 3fil 1 42 Sep. estate ell 54 222 guaranty a 73 NY 211 e 18 94 180 knowledge 23 63 76 NY 1 NC 14 NC alteration 15 AD 417! construction 20 153' 13 NC 391n 242 1 224 injunction 44 161 190 154n 279n 376 394n 17 23n 356 146 186 425 278 9gn 492 18 230 cterclaim 1 44 pleading s 11 166 a 76 NY 608 27 642 23 366 17 AD 248 express consent 1S9N \ 90 179iCios.s action HAD 478 91 AD 397 148 constitut'l 1233 chae 3 569! 10 3 87 NY 493:49 55 AD 1 02 supervisor 1 1 SS 79 NY 60 27 179 8 AC 6411 651 i town rights 15. CP 97 M 50I34M 571' venue 678 77 471 428 366n' 83 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m. modified; *, dismissed; n, note- f, criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; 0, overruled; s, same case; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q. questioned N. T. Supreme Court Reports — ^Hun Vols. 8, 9 237 signature r67NY 432 115n 241 notice 1 NC intention 13 NC 247 pab.oliar. 17 520 24 264 83 NY 535 249 bill ladine a 69 NY 373 251 taxes 43 AD 20 31 M 130 15 NC 95 deft, remdy. 13 AC lS2n - 255iury question 11 594 4G 539 260 title passing a 71 NY 291 100 US 135 10 543 265 adv. posses a 74 NY 240 271 vested rem ILRN.^ 10t)5n 275 sheriff fees r 67 NY 330 280 claim tit! pleadings d 50 540 e 69 456 certificate 67 294 coats to deft. 128 NY 177 13 CP 193 283 overaeer 54 515 security 73 428 consent 3rd prsn 7 AC 432 13 CP 139 286 reduce dam 18AC 3 i 7 repeal 57 9NC 10 NC 24n 188 106n 213 319 inj. to wife 559 constitutional 559 s 12 376 damage act 34 274 e 87 NY 498 322 receiver 17 130 partition 4M 351 20 M 246 384 jurisdn, obj 27 372 387 neg. damage 64 183 d 87 NY 87 128 115 NY 221 ( 16 1 NO 427n specif, exceptns 327 sale lunatic 383 voidable 13 AD 3NC mtge. equity 76 AD 32 M 12 AC equitable 1B2AD 9M auisance 171 NY 117 AD 5LRA 33 339 590 464 123AD construction 19A0 397 obstruct highwy 180AD 678 167S 169S 395 515 120 dfnse 23 467 a 70 NY .15 conclusive 19 e 69 22 M 587 564 258 353 9 290 exemption selection 9 45 , privilege 65 521 waiver 10 AC 397n 398n 292 toll bridge r 83 NY 178 296 carrier nee. r 73 NY 351 305 sep. estate d23 89 3 I I conversion 18 M 608 19 M 131 3 1 3 partnership 18 M 566 ' 2NC 331 3 I 5 performance d 24 404 pub. policy 13 M 593 29 M 668 334 title of&ce a 67 N Y 334 348 conclusive 30 370 eond'u void 59 549 relief 100 NY 211 guard'uad litem 13 NC 29 356 allega. proof i7 483 36 I strike out 14 50 76 85 18 AD 72 AD 173 AD 44 M e48M 158 S d iscretion 2M 21 M 51 M irrevelency 61 M 492 242 368 528 14 89 b 584 360 1035 364 639 649 499 362 jurisdiction a 73 NY 12 *99US 12 206 5 NC 127 7CP I Dower of court 33 27 373 guaranty e71NY 16 3 d24 5 72 NY subrogation 35 e 71 NY ravers error 26 467 23n 268 57 d84NY 104 NY 179 623 47 1 agency husb r71NY 199 3 NC 171 14 NC 344 474 title defect m 68 NY 246 3 NC 309n 22 NO 408n 479 appropria- tion 316 343 salary 133 NY 237 494 prox. cause 395 injunction a 71 NY e69 17 NC duress 1 LRA 47 AD equities 144 NY 405 liability 67M 409 salary 33 465 4 1 3 assessment r70NY 497 d9 219 17 NC 35t 4 1 8 condn reiea 31 25L 23 AD 34. 424 credibility a 67 NY 14 AD e41 AD 55 AD 2 AC 4 AC 169 NY 596 42 216 15 407 130n 268 547 case on ap- peal 28 AD 578 6 AC 223 SSOmeaeure daB m 73 NY 306 43 173 557 indorsement f 4 SS 284 559 satisfaction 77 NY 124 NY 4SA 94 AD 16 M release 112 AD 141 170 319 477 564 403 r 68NY 75 31 AD 39 AD 1 NC 20 NC 30 50 459 660 246n 174 502 cred sales a 67 NY 598 23 627 fr'd intent 575 I S8 41n 13 NC 508 dissolution 132 NY 221 5 i lim recovery 67 46e SAD 7 21 NC 151ii 5 I 3 assessment • 67 NY 555 22 603 23 350 86 NY 638 5l5aoctg.appeal 7 NC 139n 5 1 6 aasignt valid 13 178 5 NC 315 562 credibility a 72 NY 571 3 AD 128 forgery USAD 799 566 freeholder 97 M 243 f 162 S 850 569 trespass 9 466 57 I notice neg damages 49 43 1 conflicting! decisions 522 pleading 60 244 585 action lies 75M 647 9 530,,-. 24 259 524 costs |a70NY 596 437 bond a4NC 1 ,„, a 69 NY 215 22 564 587 diversion 29 492 a 29 300 water SCP 31148 19* 72 NY 64 9CP 22 22 AD 32111 696 133 AD 240 43 276 440 salary il7AD ,83 84 276 a 68 NY 274 19 M 428 49 AD 457 |51 M 231 d 76 NY 62 443 salary '61 M 612 101 NY 143 12 656 i 83 M 178 642 15 NC 104 79 AD 466 1 14-1 S 401 PrraenpUon implied contract .f 145 S 386 ILRA 297n 66 NY 338 6 AC 48 52n ™1f" "»'«'' waiver 6 AC 147 51-KA 129n 118AD 601 ad. allowance 132AD 19 235' 60 ■(1 95 AD U M f 85 1^1 96 NY 130 NY 156 NY authority 147 S 27 686 160 238 56 47 667 289 359 71 577 title office r 70 NY 621 584 compromise 44 471 4SA 323 19 M 176 12 AC 463 n 124 NY 173 603 verb, agree- mnnt r 71 NY 63 30 449 606 life tenant 11 NC 227 1 OF 274 25 AC 230n 6 1 2 verification defective 2M 439 613 waive lien liOAC 128n 618 jurisdiction d 40 484 d50 550 623jury question 16 637 625 eoDstruetioo 10 370 Stat, frauds 66 AD 431 171 NY 401 632 remov cause r 67 NY 544 644 publication r 74 NY 72 15 NC 469n 169 leave to sue 6NC 227n discret'n appeal 12 NC 397 princ. surety 5 LRA 278n admissible 175 AD e 19M 449 damages l4 NC 9 ^„ b71 NY 604 494|4i 223 229 234 526 sUy Jel49NY 146 2 M 186 ^?o'-...- referee's fees 13 455 atty notice 40 M 395 403 1 NC 331 n 13 AC 47 56 161 S 375 bar 4LRA 251 518 457 assessment 528 order a 68 NY 009 12 381 order I a 73 NY 617 531 requisition r76NY 324 ICP NS 258 459 dividends 536 markt value a 71 NY 593 a 67 NY 516 362 9 651 579 certiorari 669 27 M 40 13d 14 ! 24 58 AD 64 AD 205n'4M 593 sup'lcompl't s 13 238 78 AD 492 9 CP 135 interpleader 46 M 558 9 2AC 238 insur. assigut. (! 102 NY 273 599 sparks neg. 92 283 4 AD 467 22 AD 012 e 30 AD 249 56 AD 527 9 AC 328n 331n 9AC 332 166 NY 351 VOL. 9 ABUltKVlA'riONS: a c, criticised ; 1, limited ; iitlirinud; d, distinguished; e, explained ; o, overruled ; i, followed; , same case ; do. 1 title a 72 NY 94 22 U 470 6 payments 19 598 eq. interest 7NC 53 7CP 286 1 2 trustees r73NY 113 specific lien 9NC 43o 23 costs di*oretn 23 86 e30 93 41 214 d56 36 e71 546 e85 67 7 AD 358 3 NC 310n presumption 149AD 742 134S 193 equitable action 73M 65.^ 131 S 307 318 NY 105 28 refereooe 69 613 30 cestui q. trust a 72 NY 457 27 "168 37 unoccupied ins. a 72 NY 117 13 374 e70 493 43 eoDclusive 46 318 45 pro rata a 70 NY 166 e89 235 50 ante nup agreement a 71 NY 154 18 NC 157 obiter 126 S 224 implied agency 155 S 629 acquiesced 155 S 629 169AD 856 59 costs 147 NY 675 12 CP 419 60 mandamus r73NY 604 63 joint nee 43 592 22 AD 279 68 Stat. fraud.i 11 M 383 73 parol ev. 6 27 64 e95AD 136 116AD 884 178 NY 346 validity 175 AD 709 162 S 572 memorandum 175 AD 708 inadmissible 175 AD 709 78 receiver d22 198 60 408 79 supreme ct power. revorsed; m, modified; •, dismissed; n. note. I, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, queationed N. Y. Supreme Courfe Reports-t-Hun a7\-^'- . 238 U.NW ! 2n 84 fieMtf»i , ^iiv. fo>'jiliy character ev. 192=N V >134ci4:S9 I'cluvant 1-J7S ^ 427 98 authoiity 9 l-i' 38 AD 307 167 NY 2S8 1 04 em domain 2o 176 = market value 27 e 33 ' •* ■ I 50 V ill 7S JSiY'. '■ fit- J2I 2 nertioiari [iiO :-:4.">'-0 iNU JO- vv'iiliout •I. 248 I 53 pract'al con- Biructiorj 3 NO 443n 155 allegations e 3B I5AD 151 AD .429 NY 176 NY 47 M award 130 AD intrinsic quality 121 152 (i44 63C 435 2 r>fl 272. 304 418 350 133S 2."n 106 acct Bitted 60 120 2 AG 44ii lOSstat. frauds . 1 73 NY o99 76 NY s 13 91 I 57ex'is » 72.\'Y 2LKA 564 342 496 bond 565 222 removal e32 119 lUP NS ' -626 coumy 298 charge a 71 NY 225 jurisdictiooi; d 3 SS 7 AC 6Un 159 vilage 1 i able If ?,;';' ^ 23 L coQiUusiT*e; I 72 NY . ' 506 30 284 290 233 proof Payrat 1UN\ 49.1 '|>236 order arre.-it 231 6 or no defense^ 09M 120 16^ S , ,.,379 I 6 ! chant; cldira 14 283 fr'd transfer 27 428 consideration i; Ibo AD 750 I 86 arbitration a 71 NY ^08 I7!cloudon title + 74 NY 28 605 419 contractor liab, do 114 NY -38 303 condemna- tion a 70 NY 361 3 NC 57 391 434 11 NC 2 l.R A 322 assent, e 03 2(j .M 239n -794 239 n^einoranda 24 AD oa2!328 meane 9 AC ISln 154n' fits 2 CP 174 SI 3U2 ,390' new, defense 17 amendment 40 394 street nqg a 72 NY indemiiitv e:102 AD liabibtv 20 NC 356 19i, 397renlov cause r 74 NY 53 74 NY ,436 49! citv not lia- ble tortious «et? officer a 74 NY le 26 '('13 declaratior] 19 « 121 insui. a 72 NY 190 335 policy 690 • 125 nom dam e 38 577 e 35 AD 290 e 2 M 84 10 M 22?; 127 4AC renew tioa 39n 131 joint debt d 14 320 20 513 t'"'l33 expert ev. ;34 .136 1 34 illegal ev 12 374 30 AD 38C 17 M ISO 7 NC 36) ,138 delivery ,.'16 AD 604 (75 truRt in per- sonalty UU AD 474 39 M 41E guardian 47 Jl 18A0 custody 5 id ofig 123 eij.trje 729 242 atty's agent 86 NY' 263 243condii;ionar' 38 C-f S02 246 ulterior de- vise a 70,NY 81 39 126 8 NC 121 253 damages 48n e41 1 132 NY i 30 4SA 49r3tt CP" 273 1 40 excess. ,dam ages 11 proof prtjfitp 71 4M OM title passing 11 liberol constn 7 NO' 58n ' 1,46 police jtlPtir a 70 NY 47 1 48 mt^e. exten- sion a 70 NY 63 434 195 436 208 601 1 78 prob- cause i LiiA 257n uference 114 AD , 653 jury Question U6AD 834 m. •prosecutioa 133S 1042 182 wharfage a 74 NY 612 I 85 judicial sale a 08 -NY 38i 16 NC 291 1 8 i judicial sale a 70 NY 607 194 neg, rr, fire .-71N'i 380 196 contract r72NY 461 198 laches r73NY 263 usury a72NV 19NC 4 LKA 234 683 143 108 150 691 limitation 79 AD 6C1' 330 limirati 4 sa 3^4 estoppel sOONY 48 84 4M construction e20AD damages 4M prfmance proof !2h:.7 2i.i'33AD'- ' ^*|t:^NY ,^^ IWU^, Y ■ - jj'.luegligence U Ai) --■ 619 589 618 ,'«2 liM 8NC 461 joinders r79NY .'?2M SAC 13 AC 3CP d35 471 48i 584, accrued ?al- ! '.. aries ' - :S9 AD 390, 284|587 227niC03ts 164n!s 11 320!ll [f 05 AD 469 judgt. final 139 AD 510 124 S ■|«AC improvid-i3 NC en.'e ISN'C ^ 475lrererence 478n481n;a3 AD 12 M 9 AC 48 M - 17 AC 517 atty lien, M 23 S26 462 306 78n 28Sn 24q 37lcomperisation;' 4ia 343 473 as.signec party 1 72 NY a 103 as e 24 70: OAC 603 fraucf, a 70 NY 3,M 301, profit sale S5|aB,M a J5d ■ *04 64)- :. 30 ;s,5ii' 493 Willi. .r,j!a79NY 14N0 636!408 non-user 2S6la 70 NY 432 17616 iM ' 201 44J! ,.,._|4I2 directory '^^T 39 . 331 J4M 9 AC r.i M 131 S must plead 174 AD d 161S. 14 137 582 370 iO( 267 acctg. abso- lute 56 AD ■ 446 269 estoppel 34 287 6 NC 2o9ij 277 authority 27 209 280 advaiices i a 7U NY ,. , 6: oan ' ' 07 -M 124 S 136 303 180 41 5 prohibition r 73 NY 310 116 US , 129 13 NC 382n 4 1 8 neg; damage 35 ,81 8S NY ■ 638 . i609 certiorari «27!20 74 604n|3S , , .,' 10 1*0 231 ) »2 242 ;S2NY ,,27s 503 d-^sessnnent a 72 NY 614[' ■ t> I o a.sses98d^il,'. - 6 NY t-7f4 12 4S0e49i565 24 M 4!'"-i^'r 5 1 7 polhition stream a 77 NY ,61 21 NC ; 475 520 compliance 69 M , 14-4 an, '3. title 126 S , 280 364 611 2NC 20 1 agreement d 88 234 relates' back 183AD 480 171S 65 203 contempt • fine da4 AD 40 27 M . 326 excessive fine*. 7GM 211 I34S 003 205 sheriS's fees r 68 NY 585 74 NY 58 NC 135n 10 NC 288 208 attachment 68 NY 629 370 «3SM 283 hduciary 90 A D 512 288 libel malice r 76 ,N Y e32 68 e3SS 78 AD eSl AD e B M e 10 M 604 317 479 580 SI 186 ISO 104 189 fact question 28 AD 517 35 AD ■ 273 e 77 AD ' 109 160 AD IMo exempt, dam e 94 N Y 62 e 121 NY. -467 132 NY 184 134 N Y 663; 177 NY llOellB 1 AD e51 AD e20M e42M discretion 120 AD 432 490 208 420 622 336 contract 95 M.^ .•"1*240 158 S 848]42Ipowerwaivei oy.n C73NY .6 340suret> a 71 NY 28 603 294 29 6 examinatioh same county 347 mernorand a 72 NY 257 13 NC 17 presumption 16AC 12ri „_„ /: 350 pollution water course a 74NY ■ '341 •> 92 • 310 lateral support 2 M 434 prescription 128S 150 355 injunction e 27 169 363 bill lading a 71 NY 353 tiNC- •< 426 370 judgment 67M il7J 383 actual ab«u lute a 78 NY JOO 38 89 total loss 155, NY 396 387 nuisance 1'17AD 590 388 consid. title 14 283 cotenant acctg. 15 316 d 42 450 46 600 50 201 424 lien e,-:tensn 139 NY 197 limited e.81M 565 429 sale stock a 70 NY 11 e 12 14 NC lex loci ILRA 202 473 253 486n 656/1 437 disaoltitioii 15 129 legal action 4 AD 8 AD 5M. 123 NY party 14 NC eii. defense SAD 5M 127 NY 437 60 587 167 538 105u 615 167 489 443 legal title 1.71 NY 474 2M ^ 142 446 excise law r 69 NY 175 10 603 9NC •: . 120 452 pers. prop. eriy ■" i d 10 424 457 death dam. r 70 NY 171 109 US 484 522 Stat, li.mitat a 72 NY 499 16 320 H 1 B ferry a 73 NY 606 54 AD, . 68 120 NY 426 2LRA 85 dua care 157 AD 645 142 S 737 not m possessn. 157 AD 615 obligation |G7AD 046 52S incompt. ev j 24 38 620 presumptiotj d 62 173 14 NC 304n neg. damages e.iectment e 108 NY 156 532 reservation a 70 NY 41'9 3 NC 309d 540 repaying st 52 AD 162 ■543 bankruptcy a 75 NY 506 553 pre-sumptio 20 M 370 eraaod offer 10 AC 220n 21 NC • 200n 558 civ. dam. act r 74 NY 52B 9 538 56 I authority a 72 NY 472 6 NC 76n 567 irregularity 161 537 concusive 29 AD 583 569 commitment iO' 82 573 "tsiennially *-* a 68 NY 479 628 582 direct ver- dict ■ ,; 13 NC 382n 583 burden prMf a 70 NY. eOS 9NC '■ ,?\f;3as. esM 210 extrinsic ev.. 165 AD ■ 205 151 S 88 622 divorce a 72 NY 217 nous 705 5NC 127 10 NC 331 7CP 17 633 demurrer 35 215 fina) judgment 52 AD 454 e26M 503 merger 15 M ft5 costs finah e 34 M I, 348 537 auspeasfen m70NY . 512- 37 19 life estate 3NC , 115 15 NC 115117 18 NC :■ (306n 19 NO, £ 14- 641 presumption. 89 AD 72 648 damages ,a72iiY . .; I9& U AC 7NC SNC 13 NC SOP 4n • ,', 293n, 81 -1 '* ,:li 276- 650) tax' bank St k. .; en MV if , 01 r69NY i' u m. 91 AD-UKEVIATIONS: a, affirmed-j d, distinguished! f, followed ; r, reversed; m, modified: *,^;disinis5ed ; 'n, note o.'ormcised; 1, limited; e, Rxwlained; o, overruled; s, same case-, do, disaentinc opinion ; p, Sft^alilfetaSeit-if. «iu«ti<»»«* N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Hun Vols. 9, 10 659 officei a 70 NY 613 d 21 164 28 116 664 review objn. 16 629 cond. precedent 23 250 49 18 Bp. Terra power 28 36 evidence 38 .169 specif, objection 85 66 d 95 Nl- 52 sped, proceed^. 81 NY 307 constructioQ 9 NC 60n 669 loss bai!gage a 72 NY 50 98 M 578 proof 162 S 1101 674 Corp. oeg r 74 NY 264 5 LRA 145n 685 notice defect 6LRA 145n 686 claim notice a 73 NY 45 ' 2CP 266 4 CP 383 695 assignee bankruptcy d21 315 706 judicial •12 569 708 land undei water a 67 NY 512 3 NC 503n 6NC 4]? VOL. 10 3 demand 24 97 7 incompt. ev. r 70 NY 61 55 AD 41 1 LRA 4( discovery 73 M 41 133S 4 unenforcible 147 S 176 85 M 270 9 parol ev. a 73 NY 189 107 NY 349 I \ town meeting d 57 356 6 NC 383n 16 services im plied contract a 70 NY 607 55 695 86 329 f 9 AD 626 70 AD 130 6M 507 e 28 M 349 43 M 566 134S 230 f 148 S 768 evidence 74M 333 18 mech. lien r 76 NY 50 109 US 179 9 NC 279 20 contract a 74 NY 619 5 NC 459 23 assessment a 74 NY 183 HI US 712 125 US 351 367 360 6 NC 244 10 NC 160n I I NC 43 1 l.RA 677 2 LRA 188 268 2 LRA 362 628 2 LRA 658 37 suit in tort d 19 49 41 prin. debtor 40 AD 80 subrogation e 94 NY 614 44 vicious dog a 73 NY 195 1 AC 60n 3CP 95 49 laches r 71 NY 315 e 82 AD 574 675 677 16 NC 158 56 parol ev. 24 654 d 98 NY 297 59 construe ins. 73 NY .399 e 43 222 66 surety 73 NY 315 14 680 5 NC 230n 68 fr'd transfer 12 310 title receiver 16 196 73 usury estop- pel r 76 NY 196 14 416 e 76 NY 201 3 NC 184n 77 partition r 73 NY 230 23 433 83 com. lunatic r 72 NY 184 r 3 NC 285 89 receiver a 72 NY 170 80 NY 649 9 I constitute 42 204 compensation 99 NY 305 taxing power e 120 AD 858 93 CO. judge a 72 NY 1 15 NC 13 21 NC . 314 axsability 142 S 592 actions pending 157 AD 492 95 Stat, limitan. a 72 NY 648 22 NC 337n 1 LRa 264 97 petition bar 25 484 15 M 659 25 M 281 42 M 164 153 NY 322 6CP 90 pagmt. voucherr 5 M 141 Burrogat'es powe 41 9S 27 CP 72 I 08 certiorari a 76 NY 613 I 09 amendme IBONY 198 19AC 300n I I I offer judt costs 60 649 9 AD 400 s2NC 90 I 1 2 assessment m 70 NY 476 I 13 assessment m 69 NY 353 I I 7 receiver rents d20 13 d 34 522 6 AD 248 70 AD 81 146 AD 122 130 S 372 taxes water rates d 73 AD 364 diligent creditor 83 NY 7 preference 131 S 250 specific lien 146AD 3eCi 14SAD .■5,-) 132S 1057 permission i23NY 225 166 AD 72 f 151 S 615 1 20 trial fee f 33 332 13 CP • 161 isrp 390 f 93 M f 158 S 472 441 1 24 conclusive a 89 NY 444 29 360 128 unincorp'n e 25 625 4NC 313 17 NC 114n 8 CP 302 3 LRA 43 In dlssol'n notice 20 M 88 1 33 bill exchang a 73 NY 616 1 37 disorderly a 69 NY 612 92 AD 247 4 LRA 676n 1 40 attachment a 73 NY 218 17 68 1 48 banks pref- erenee a69 NY 358 13 272 18 224 1 5 1 eviction 65 .AD 474 19 M 523 25 M 598 38 M 124 91 M 568 155 S 34 Hum. pro. 137AD 76 parol evidence ^24NY 420 1 55 precludes (3M 266 not recover 132S 688 „NC limitation "M M — NY _ 132 NY intention 21 NC 99M 66S 6 9- 1201 I- 35 69 SAD d78AD fr'd intent d58 37 M d 12 AC 11 AC certiorari 149 S equity court f 164 AD 20 I incompt. ev,, 83 NY fsf^g^NC 2 1 I new defense a NP 17 697 9 CP 27 12 CP 277 13 CP 175 costs proof 8 AD amendment 1 AC 38 CP I 56 lotteries a 74 NY 63 I 58 incompt. ev. 14 617 92 60 1 60 opening st. * 72 NY 442 2 CP 398 I 67 insur. policy r 74 NY 246 master's duty 100 NY 64 I 73 presentment do 24 96 5CP 57 12 CP 303 bond jurisdn. 44 307 presumptions 85 AD , 506 rate of interest eSM 197 payment 33 M 420 1 LRA 319n I 83 exr's acctg. a 70 NY 1 3CP 65 1 87chnge variue 14 498 189 gift feesim- 39 123 life estate 47 112 49 146 65 4 62 do 85 AD 121 14.1 AD 7S1) 130 S 573 power by will 69 .64 127! 262 injunction 418 d 15 CP 422 20 264 jurisdiction 625 e 12 146 3 380 5 NC 72n 272 alimony fu ture support 237 541 40 83 r71NY 94 vested right appealable 126 78 AD 577 „„ 364 ^77 costs 100 "" "" . 73 NY 129 US 74 d 10 732 11 . ,. 312 jurisdiction ]64n e 12 12 817 19 37 250 5NC 289 allowance a 70 NY 421 37n 14 224 abduction 54 AD 499 227 acceptance U5 M 514 160 S 821 232 >et-oS 22 35 586 142 586 3 CP 254 5CP 154 7 CP 243 enforce by suit 90 NY 206 236 atty's nee 36 397 44 AD 591 7 AC 384n 7 AC 390n 396n 242 payment pleaded 59 s el4 AD 35 M 2 AC o 130 NY 181 NY 200 206 315n 510 263 244 secure costs 2CP 46 M 14 406 246 exmpo' taxn 42 31 e63 AD 85 AD 2CP 1 248 contract a 70 NY f 83NY 5NC 185 81 604 120 31 253 conclusive r70 NY 27 42 AD 606 610 255 res judicata a 73 NY a 104 US 17 607 406 .598 59 7 AC 269 189 S 241d 500 223 511 268 396 146 229 623 311 78 2CP 7CP 481 36 315 36 176 1 203 _ legal consid. . AD 123 77 AD 335 1 M 620 27 M 423 12 AC 258n 260n 12 AC 264n e266 d 97 NY 284 118 NY 685 348 certiorari Ifl 482 allege 106M 317 17SS 722 358 malpractice a 75 NY 12 87 513 69 428 82 413 e 2 SS 70 155 NY 210 362 surety bkcy. 13 597 waiver 25 295 bonds a 76 NY' 609 279n 112n 299 relief 2 AC 4 AC 303 lis pendens 9 AC >i3n 60 M 557 304 ord. refernce *70NY 101 I ) 65 f22.AD 58 d 3 SS 280 1 M 346 8 NC SOSn 4 CP 304 5 CP 296 not reviewable 30 524 2 AC 274n 307 mandamus 13 NC 421 u 2 AC 274n appealable 12 S3 e 28 422 308 assessment a 71 NY 603 3 \ I jurisdiction a 72 NY 400 207 217 53 595 )602 384 617 320 264 220 13 5 NO 11 NC services oral con tract e 29 501 56 84 589 68 48 AD 55 AD 4 59 AD 71 AD 77 AD 26 23 M 26 M 37 M 8 AC , 33 15 AC 483n 489 5 uncertainty "84 AD 69 agreement by wi 34 AD 24_ spec, perfomance do 188 NY 1 requirements 103M 1462 717 251 609 644 171S 948 949 328 — trustee 79 NY 302 LRA 816n t. limitation 37AD 92 343 33S 366 ante nuptial agreement 27 66 e 28 509 33 216 e48 14 2 LRA 373n consideration 67 333 ante nuptial 2LRA 376 372 handwritins 57 NY 280 Jl 338 3O 383 378 eorp, dis- count m74 NY 200 18 295 3LRA 14 pleading 165 AD 130 i 150 S 710 397 waiver insu a 72 NY 604 13 194 47 39 80 AD 121 authority 4 AC 363 q 85 NY 283 148 S 128 estoppel 21 M 291 waive limit 226NY 37 405 certiorari 38 48 413 title « 73 NY 430 22 AD 313 156 NY 450 7 NC 188 420 pers. prop- erty a 75 NY 542 „108.VY 221 1 3 LRA 25 ° 426 neg. dam- ages 11 AC 72n ABBREVIATION'S: a, affirmed; d. distinguished; f. iol lowed : i c. criticised ; 1. limited; e, explained; o, overruled: s. same case; do, 1 428 warranty '" " 73 NY 452 d 21 80 35 AD 6' 1 I-RA 220 .reversed; m, modified ; *, dismissed; n noie dissentlnz opinion; p, parallel case: 4, questioned' Vols. 10, 11 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Hun 431 sureties a 74 NY 609 42 647 1 LKA 456n 435 COBStltut iona) 17 S63 ILRANS 923 license 19 550 legial. power 87 0^1 438 sup. pro lAC 316d 443 wcoDg doer 2SS S<6 4 CP 188 iOi' NS 2 iuriBdictioa 6 NC 72d right action 62 M 307 451 constructive trust m 81 NY SOS 94 NY 251 new trial 2! NC 36lD 453 iiregulanty r 77 NY 5h 17 406 79 383 94 NY 4S 5 M 365 traad transfer 16 NO 37n 19 NC 96 Tacate judftt 21 is61 sup. proceeding 20 M 51'J 459 insui. policy »74N\ 6 direct examin. 67M 108 466 iDSur. policy »74NY 296 468 u»ury plead ing r75NY 516 I 81 NY 15 e 14 195 47 1 improper ev a72Ni 21)9 e47 79 71 503 81 AD 229 opinions 22 NC 252 474 lessor repair d 39 619 bailee 17 AC 224n, 225n, 227n 126S 867 damages 142AI) 185 477 negligence rr 7 AD 522 jury question 'b5 ad 504 48 1 amendment 12 IBS 73 483 3 AD 392 13 UP 373 nee. party 128 AD 649 486 encroai-hmt 38 M :s 489 estoppel in- sur. f 14 458 21 90 7 AD 585 estoppel ILRA 218n 493 certtf. proof 42 260 267 494 allega. jur- isdition 41 599 d 76 545 91 496 125 S 759 5M 100 8 AC 372n allegations 141AD 39 495 a 74 NY 498 carrier deliv 21 M 46 500 usury plead- ing 127 NY 376 20 NC 353n defense 15AC 65n 502 allegations 13 342 506 distinction 81 M 566 143 S 617 5 I lindorseenote r74 NY 486 15 282 16 CP 182 party in int. d 16 348 compet. ev. 16 . 593 sham strike out 50 369 blank endors't ILRA 71 2n 5 1 5 com. council r 74 NY 338 520 iudgt. credr. 24 279 52E strike out f 22 462 interest e 39 305 costs not meas of services 64 162 90 AD 82 10 AC SSOn 528 new trial e 12 • 297 memorandum 31 244 53 f neg. barriers a 74 NY 610 35 61] n- .tice knowled'^e e 102 AD 34 109 AD 178 537 admission entirety 64 397 22 AD 546 42AD 13 5 AD 35:< ■6M 565 3SA 93 5 AC 65n a 94 NY '412 penalty 137S 147 540 title vesting 114 NY 478 545 assessment a 71 NY 481 14 310 jurisdiction 11 AD 390 39 AD 179 distinction IWAD RRS 179AD 750 167S 92 548 competent evidence 20 159 strike from roll 140 S 679 55 1 comr, high way a 74 NY 310 554 bar 36 173 560 infancy bai 4 AD 5S4 no cause 203 NY 467 variance 203 NY 468 566 new taxatn 3M 513 1 CP 31 4n I neg. iNY 305 57 I injunction a 79 NY 6E7 574 review 105 AD 281 578 place of trial I SS 428 28 M 680 S AC 35en 578 trustee d 21 571 580 joinder 97 NY 594 12 NC 309n 582 consent dis- cretion a 72 NY 491 15 .345 17 147 pers. liabilitv B NC 227n 12 NC 396 demurrer 15 NC 433 18 NC 144 160 589 consignors 14 611 assignee lien II AD 393 presumption 145 S 748 160 AD 704 59 I eonsiderat'n 52 19 e 57 529 d 60 284 e 84 599 value 9AC 202n estoppel 74M 5^ 593 change int a 73 NY 447 21 9] 29 86 3 LRA 173 Qon compliance e 40 104 Stat, limitations 9 AD 346 596 power atty a 72 NY 279 3NC 171 19 NC 156 598 injunction r73NY 579 604 cheek receiv r 71 NY 325 IINC 161n 21 NC 386 609 waive lien 20AC 120n indebtedness 185AD 266 102M 420 169S 842 not payment 173S 23 6 1 I advancemts interest on e 15 M 372 e 39 M 626 VOL. M. 1 itispectn books * 70 NY 220 e 63 322 28 M 728 38 M 448 6 AC 62n 6 AC 360 370 mandamus 3 AC 372n 9 AC 4g2n d 159 NY 259 20 NC 194 200 list stock holdrs do 133S .TO regulation do 147AD 888 8 stolen bonds a 83 NY 223 19 demurrer a 74 NY 161 2 1 eq. lien 23 285 70 contract cap nee e43 536 do 91 395 18 NC 49n 5 LRA 272n vendee arbit'r IT.RA 646 76 assessment e 75 NY 327 82 abduction 1 6 1 vesting 7NC no force 135S S7n. 1016 1 66 Corp. tract a 75 NY 7NC authority 160 S 173 AD 132a 185 842 d37 11 AC 89 warrant 17 6NC 193 3S0m 202 R7 96 distribution 71 NY 222 7 NC 209 remittitur 11 NY 226 I Oljury question 4101 63 AD 8 NC 308n 10 NC 392n 18 NC 30n waiver 93 AD 233 atty's lien 64M 168 29 costs * 75 NY 479 75 NY 481 26 642 strict foreclosure 61 442 2d mtge party f 62 247 redemption 20 AD 582 33 firm note e 14 M 609 38 order arrest 27 31 s 3 NC 3n f 36 M 488 2 CP 289 16AC 14n pers. injury g 145 S 399 41 inference 18AC 47n appt. guardian 18AC 51n 46 presumption negligence SAD 31 AD 5M 17 M 20 M 2 LRA 17 455 268 594 113 821n 49 new cause 8 AC 279 52 wife contract a 74 NY 82 56 sureties «7?NY 612 62 reference b28 42? 30 5?4 1 M 346 2 AC 274n 4CP 302 18 28 34 e34 71 39 AD elSS 7M 4NC 342 111 610 618 452 447 105 117 40 1 03 insurance r 83 NY 604 I l'6 exempt, tax t31 118 22 NC 27 1 24 jurisdiction 38 529 13 AD 326 4 AC 68 10 NC 70 revival e 98 AD 292 136 expiration charter m 73 NY 384 9 AC S5n56n 1 39 usury plead- ing a 74 NY 85 141 stockholder 29 545 80 NY 613 ILRANS 914n conetriie statute e 38 464 d 6 M 562 6 NC 259n 2 LRA 830n 1 45 indorser 72 167 construction 27 AD 422 1 47 suspn. power alienation a 72 NY 97 AD e95NY 23 M 28 M 48 M 7 AC 18 NC trusts 15.31 7 AC 84ri 16 CP '*21 358 jury trial 6 NC ■'4n 361 relief 15 AD I SS 146 S 365 wife's vires a 74 NY 13 18 130 NY 2CP 282 409 268 ser- 356 109 370 499 426 368 sheriff pro tected 73 396 374 excavation r 72 NY 307 s 4 NC 292 38 1 local assess- ment on hospital a 74 NY 610 18 582 84 NY 116 385 injunction damages r72NY 300 interest 117AD 824 390 indictment a 73 NY' 66 14 13 ordinance statu- tory force 33 AD 478 394 limit, juris, diction *73: 13 19 37 SAD 2LltA 603 365 624 311 28 85 397 pub. policy 8 4 382 399 implied as- sent a 82 NY id'. 39 101 403 power removal 32 74 AD no answer 144 AD 119 414 631 405 no answer 128S 257 406 dower right 278 100 732 163n Sl9n 103 168 14' d78 AD e37M U AC 15 AC 19 NC 428 bar 27 Bup'l complaint 3 AD 153 3 AC 213 217n IBO S 860 cross action 38 AD 374 432 profits proot a 75 NY 579 71 196 fi M 209 3 -AC 235n 23Kn objn. exceptns 1 1 M 248 I.RA 569 3 AC 235n-e value 24 AD 76 AD II M 18 M 13 AC discretion e72 appealable 123AD evidence lOOM 165S 16 34 66 254 476 236 576 476n 427 207 jurisdiction 36 41 46 34f 15 NC 477 2 LRA 177n 1 CP 37S cross action 52M 37R Former action 16 AD 4RS SAC 217 13 AC 15Sn 38CP 106 3ar 59 Jl 133 il AD 13i;NY limitations i 7011 27 I waiver 15 opinions 53 :J9 2SS 274 expert ev 10 AD 2SS d29 AD opinions 80 AD 208 bar 2LRA 177n 209 school neg r 75 N Y 303 amendment d 21 NC 90S 2 1 2 incompt. witness 15 355 175 NY 194 separate counts 63 439 75 NY 490 138S 376 joinder counts 105 AD 511 151 NY 409 >jjie offense VOM indictment do 179AD T2M do 166S in'surplusage 132 S 203 .294 634 353 113 340 I 09 rjit=harmpnt I I 73 amendn^enl 253 218 de release fense- e 95 NY ' 248 242 injunction |3 I 2 illegal ev. al4NC 329' 15 80 restraint |69AD 169 69 M ■72'gift c. mortis no notice I05AD 596 135 S 959 competent ev. llbNC 204n 247coHnterclaimi a 75 N y 511 3 1 7 adv. poss- 24 M 32 M e42M preference 88 NY jurisdiction 15 NC 147 537 447 475 477 192 329 iS J4 AD prayer relief il NC 148n plead usury 10311 240 168S 877 259 parol lease 17 320 holding over M 266 n NC 306 264 dissolution 6 221 369 488 304 73 576 72 44 109 282 limitations d 20 502 24 465 63 AD 384 391 23 M 429 289 assumed risk 39 432 40 348 49 491 70 458 45 AD 300 4 LRA 62n 293 jurisdiction 40 e40 e 75 87 estoppel f 91 M appeal 155 S 483 396 290 537 51£f 621 299 foreclosure a 84 NY 461 302 liability d 32 636 3 LRA 257n 306f'rd, transfer d 30 194 81 67 easiun r76NY e84NY 32 I estoppel t 14 455 reformation d 51 151 7 M 693 3 LRA 190d 325 foreclosure a 23 ■ 14 do 23 10 assignee equities 36 315 57 465 87 NY 463 332 title passing 43 AD 383 336 restoration r76NY 36 14 NC 310n J39 error court 5B AD 413 .42 S 131 342 partition e 76 520 oCP 202 349 mistake deed a 76 NY 452 116 NY 166 ground fraud 32 NC 418n 354 insurance a 76 NY 436 memorandum ev. 23 NC 119n 358 m. prosecu- tion 47 103 determination d 51 242 e 11 AD 330 360 ministerial 370 genl. legacy 125 AD 359 preference 87 M 509 f 149 S 92.> 374 discretion r 78 NY 155 r 7 NC 358 c 20 168 e 23 139 375 pers. trans- action a 80 NY 261 d NC 60n 376civ dam. act d26 616 378 disposses- sion 16 M 320 certificate 9 AC 44n 154 NY 530 equity suit 133 ierv!ce notice 1S.\C 254ii 38 1 appeal a 73 N y 600 appoint guard, 106 AD i)91 inciiinpelent 137AD 344 382 court powei 35CP 50 383appeal costs d48 114 AD 129 AD ICP 64 M 90 M 153 S costs 1S6AD 403 mtge.merger a 76 NY 526 208 43 110 675 161 d 19 21 52 16 NC 405 lien dl44S d 159 AD dowahle 146 S eq. title f 160 AD 4 1 3 mandamus a 76 NY 160 76 84 I AD 258 4 1 6 insurance a 73 NY 141 19 289 425 reasonable expenditure 198 240 811 17n 10; 835 310 3110 580 981 87 384 credr suit 17 60 d 78 AD 691 mandatory 9M 1 386 acknowldg- ment 30 *72NY 9 16 27 d39 42 d90 ultra vires 22 NC town purpose 5 NC 468n 607 130 169 242 556 520 90n 368 abatement 36 41 5M 130 c 24 M 146 14 30 e69 1 M e98NY 3B CP 19AC 388 appeal r76NY 558 97 425 252 221 508 430n 614 39 I Sep. estate 87 2 d 17 M 542 liable payment do 110 AD 899 394 amendment 17 136 396invest estate d30 25 32 76 59 316 3 AD 42 398 shipping a 75 NY 52f> e75 AD d 162 AD I M e9M dl47S II AC e 11 AC 12 NC monument 92 M 157 S next kin 103M 170S 428 stay 10 AD e4 AC 340 626 31 506 1018 430n 431 43£ 635 495 74 296 43 I trust estate 11 73 NY 127 U7US 476 25 AD 138 19 M 565 per", liability 6 NC 362 126S 727 personal action 143 AD 8 8 AC 316u 435 nes damage a 76 NY 593 47 AD 325 9M 6 89 NY 247 44 1 discontinu- ance 38 356 .9 AD 96 7 AC 438n 443 atty appear- a77NY 171 446 insurance ^ a 77 NY I'l 77 NY 17 451 T i AD 460 corpn's tract 9 discretion e8 AD 15 M 1 LRA approval 61 M voidable 207 NY 611 1.57 rniiie 469 321 172 194 851n 128 465<>olision dam 17 104 Hcope employmt 16 Wl 178 /^BREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note t. criticised ; h limited ; e. explained ; o. overruled ; i, tame case ; do. dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case : Q, Questioned N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Eun Vols. 12, 13 e 04 AD 49') ■ISiAli .M.l. lial'i'iry j:^:; AD 580 -'abaiul'inuient' "f 139 S 83 469 surrogin e *:rror a 70 NY ."r 3CP 4- 16 CP 1":; 478 epavemt^nl r76NY 174 12 MOn f rO MY ri20 483 iuriadiction 50 273 -52 2S 106 AD 64 132 SO NY 523 653 contract, |r7'5Ny 31 542pub. servanl: 0'' 50ii657 publication i'AC,,,, 3lJ7nJ*74iVY 08 4 LEA 327nl7NC 01 J4CP 279 550 Tease wharf _„ !i 7S NY 1,d58 composit 18 5oS burred. |33 NY 174 AD 510L,„„ 101 S 1,^5 ooO costs Is AC 558 repavement 7 AC 12 490n Sf NY 60S 609 57 S 185 *61 020 10 CP equity court 75SI removal 152 S injunction ,171 AD -157 S ' 488 preference •■31 338 SCP 134 6CP 34G authority . 34 371 stiict cotnpliuncL' do 14 AD 'Uli ' -493 iiiritditiii'- ; (1-59.M -567 504 new trial 3 21 122 31 14 508 ret- judicata 6 AD 421 38 M OO'.i 2.?0i'JY 5,38 ^ 82 admr set ofT j,74i\Y 4071 24 9.-, ,516 dilificnt in-, quii-y 28 AD 2,57 S AC 25S 7 AC 108j) 137 NY 382 521 alteration 27 .,.'-■ 370 85 U 51 400n lOU 440n 586 authority 120 NC I87n311 5NC 2n01n ^ • 14 NC 62noO a 77 NY 498 res adjudicate 72 M 1 046 ' jurisdiction 362 205NY lOi 6 VOL. 13 1 jury final a 70 NY 19 28 tS 74 7 ,M Sin 10 in estoppel ■" AD waivi;r 154 a ■fe7 28l>l9 AC ;i57 V 76 contrib neg --1)4 r 77 NY 831 . j .,.-,..;!20NC 220|27M 409I „ , ,,!39M :;0U'89 cond. precedl, i5j^ g 2871-7 ■'l.:!,12At 47'jldu 3 bA l/.3>'!.) ;>,( 1. ap|)0, -nee US 059 450 393 100 9 estoppel agenci 8 34 13 274 419 I 7 city title 6 Sb 572 134 NY 497 on>titulional !,3o 11 306 23 eq. owners a 77 N y ■ 005 09 603 70 492 conversion 108 AD 73 26 trespas er 24 conversion LOa AD 29 atty neg, 7 AC • 382n 380n 391n end contract U9.1-_ o-i 1 10 AC 5 >5 'unlawiul 8 173 AD 412 i 1,VJ d 2tOn|Hrresl ■143 , 62 613 602 cost flemurrer ISAC disretioo 13 AD 40,- ISlAD i!;7S 104 008 437^ 28' 58 27 314n 43 water course a 79 NY 625 29 237 4? limitation? r 76 N V 12: 17 ,597 ame^id 93 M 585 t 158 S 409 57 CDnsideratn. e ISIAD 24 167S 100-8 60 injunction ;iNC 390 63 discontinue 7 AC 434 n 64 ntandamus a 73 NY 443 3 LRA 176 37 1)27 68 easement * 75 NY ■ 474 70 assault a 70 NY '24 i76 asslgn.Tient ,i,,' 122 amendment' ■ 52 AD 30l]f 76 49nl32 AD averment 803 '51 Jl b3o'B0 M ! show facts 330 1.57 AD ■'SO o'JP ■ .. . 'c6o assign t pel "0 NY 585 280 315,316 594 48 778 77 NY, 36 AD 56 M , ' tii--cretiort , do 120 AD 000 ,__ .102 NY 1 aUsuspensnsuit e 1*52 NY ^:,'4,4A.U . 283 284,0 NC '-'■'^Idistinction il7NC ,,, jnsAD 9| 14SS -'^•'.note lor debt leouitv lOAC , 144ni,'87'j,r 273 346 411 24n 206 652 1 26 borrower *** '^12 j |g2 declarations' 242 chal. juror i 30 defense '9 ''*' IMP^ 2" pleading ' I'' " NC 1 e .10 S.3Ri I 87 contrib. neg ie 17 414 ,: "'*ir76NY oT-tnNr ! 33 declaration 33 ■ 102 25 AD 37 AD 48 iM est oppel 48 M" 43; 51! 191 waiver 17'a7CNY !32 20; 1 LRA 273iONC 1 22121 NC ■ 418 ILEA 277 cross examn. 21 52 20 AD 165 415 332 224 I ?;"? 'j^,- -1 uri»dn,i I 98 jurisdiction NY •!2:„ M •■■2 M liCP I 47 pro rata a 79 NY 630 d40 221 117NY 98 2p9 4(iM 13||„rig. return 261-^5 2921 So USAD 40 iM amendment 70 254 sparks ,neg4 28 364 108 AD 76 safe appliance 67 635 ,n9AC 334n33Gn 34!9.\C 341n 1 50 author do 78 set aside 94 M 159 S 1,53 parot tM value rny (il 433. ■4 78 510 251 62 140 NY 319 201 ktfidaviti rs M 259 decree 25 -AD • 115 266 irregularity 260 enerehmt. 103 NY , 163 12 NC 156n equity suit f 84 M 628 147 S 818 202 charge error 69 AD 588 204 Kond fpith 3. 27 AD verdict ISAC stipulation 371 015 448n »,!:ABBREVIATI0NS:' a, affirmed",* 4> distinguished'; £, {pllowed'; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed u i.uii c, criticised ; 1, limited; e, explained ; o, overruled ; s, samt'fcai«f- do, dissenting opinion ; "p, parallel case ■ tj, quei'tioiw* Vols. 13, 14 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Hun 359 338 a 100 AD new trial f 237 US 269 deposit ■ priority 18 224 d 70 AD 586 e 172 NY 380 e 36 M 358 273 cred. suit 9:i - 56 la ches limitn 39 AD 62 AD 40 M 7 AC 156 NY 157 NY 294 129 609 431n 511 181 280 valid lieu 23 365 284 appealable S AC 280 285 injunction p 29 578 Si 405 97 N Y 491 29 I bill partic 2 SS 590 17 CP 180 295 divisn. line 16 61 35 IDS 296 indemnity 96 AD 230 298 assignment a 78 NY 131 14 NC 385 24AD 215 6CP 167 301 consideratn, 81 M 183 142 S 375 303 extra allow, 24 174 32 289 Btenog. fees 43 155 10 AC 59n costs retax'n 2 M 501 7AC 320n 321n 9 AC 422n 125 NY 111 20 NC 184n 306 jurisdict'u a 81 NY 23 88 2 AC nonsuit 10 NC void will 20 NC 1 CP 6CP 130 433 392 122 33 103d 279 329 3 I 3 jurisdiction r 78 NY 64 3 I 5f'd restoratn 17 19 e9M 325 127 NY 502 14 NC 307n tll7AD 651-2 656 cond. precedent 130 AD 324 no demurre; 14n AD 17 1211 S 565 3 1 7 title realty a 74 NY' 88 319 pun. dam. 12 AC 78n 80n 321 usury a78Ny 137 a 7 NC 170 amendment 12 NC 320 329 prox. cause r 87 NY 88 p 18 398 e 84 NY 254 332 carrier a 76 NY 207 rlOOUS 118 r 1 SC 58 341 bond r 7b NY 564 118 US 161 15 CP 333 344 place of tria 1 28 M 680 473 100 41 AD S5 AD justices jury quest'n 116AD 834 395 reveru error justices 19 86 15 AD 551 judicial otficers dol53NV 4U1 219 NY 276 40 I lex luci 6NC 88 345 appraisal 15 16 17 28 35 e38 ■ 118 NY 123 NY 17 NC damages 5i M 66 68 262 350 427 B36 454 624 260 258 511 349 assessment a 74 NY 210 35 416 359 stop ov. rgt 28 464 e 56 269 366 assessment 405 usury a 77 N Y 13 s2NC 7NC 13 NC 300 408juryque8tion a SON if 40 stockholders 66 85 95 NY 147 NY lol NY Ccrtiiicate 11!4NY 549 465 r76NY 87 NY 368 contempt *73NY 613 d34 238 40 AD 18U d 74 M 330 removal trdstee 134S 232 37 I vacant prem 35 605 39 413 46 302 4(j' jury question _ |4S AD 414 divorce est 02 AD 447 10 AC 169 418 assault a 76 NY 608 422 illegal e/ r76NY 197 2» 1/7 427 demurrer 11 AC 220n 43 1 reference 54 440 waive ubjns. 18AU 4361. 44 1 tax coven't 39 67S 1 LKA a»» 446 chge stam't, 427 42 64 67 e 92 d 04 AD 45392 AD 25»e2aA 520 9 M 3U 321 601 227 368 343 618 e3:^ M 119 NY inadmissible 67M 175 corroboration MUKY 339 45 I lex loci 375 valet con- tract 44 516 counterclaim J (0 AD 488 f 156 S 45872"aD 33 01-7 ■ ^ ^ death damages o77 ejectment I7 mq K4n a79JSY bl9 ' ^ °^^ 454 law remedy ■ ■ "" Son 388 eq. relief ij^j^ ^q 35 107 j encroachment^^j458 ,i,, e 122 NY 12 "* ■*■" damages 12 NC I53u right action "2 il trustees 60 AD 193 AD HnR direct beq'st ^•'° 194 NY 484 ■^ S 712 deductions ,00 . |f 92 M 699 i\)£ accr entries f i 57 g g73 48 AD -268, varies 474 dis'ge mtge 21s NY 511 33 617 count stated '60 530 102M 59 63 613 57 AD 472 393 malice infer 2 AC 242n 20 466 485 prohibition d 132S 733 director e 147AD 445 132 S 754 489 new trial a 77 NY 414 38 486 76 61 terms 8 AC 394n 396n 492 stkholder 16 d48AD e48 AD 13 AC 537 466 467 296n 579 substituted service SAC serving 68 M 124 S ISn Eum'nG 526 838 24 SAC 494 notice 27 106M 174S specif, obj. 33 M defects 55 M 498 eq. relief 543 11 .?7I 361 503 634 235 470 314n a77NY d78NY 14 NC 506 bond a 75 NY 5 I 4 trustee par chase from 17 28 AD warranty 39 d41 14 AC 106M modiMcation e .iy 642 newly diecv. ev, 14 NC 467 526 debt stay 57 365 269 608 61S 226 2it4,-. 471 530 legacy a 74 NY 533 waiver a 74 NY 43 26 M 428 406 58 118 536 judgtmt cost e 68 529 538 atty. default 6 AC 31 409 541 sheriff neg. a 70 NY 121 53 590 11 AC 77 543 inaur policy r 77 NY 564 18 NC 105 557 parol ev 71 957 actual notice d21 33 9M 284 1 LRA 516n advances 16AC 78n, 79d validity 171 AD 165 156 S 773 563 sp. per'mce 92 296 568 facta alleged 63 AD 223 d 20 NC 343d 57 1 redemption 55 148 q 35 M 359 575 fraud int. 582 irregularity 16 475 35 89 118 NY 234 13 NC 383n 589 jury ques a 75 NY 605 35 593 302 indorsement l.-);iAD 279 141 S 303 606 construction 46 666 }ll stipulations IS 100 collateral 24 569 39 46 jury question az 227 622 security a 87 NY 409 87 NY 412 629 recp-iver il 25 3 NC 184D 632 lien vessels 37 64 j uriadiction 52 AD 552 635 title benefic e 24 433 4 CP 31 643 em. domain I VOL.14. I stay costs 7AC 279n 3 probate 36 discretion e 1 M 392 8 trust funds a 75 NY 39 43 77 S4 NC e78NY 96 NY 10 NC 19 NC 598 190 229 168 221 273 36 372 377n 1 exceptions 44 25 coata a 76 NY 16 3 I privity 4M 6M 289 a 79 NY 5NC 11 NC 65 1 notice 29 293 468 283n 586 654 maater ves- sel agent 67 622 655 costs 23 d24 12 NC 84 433 344 858 fences neg. LRA 186 14 527 86 38 composition 14 AC , 33n 41 nom. dam. e 34 180 71 116 e 22 AD 576 25 AD 289 30AD 427 e.\ces9ive dam 83AD 473 traud sale \!0AC Din new trial 170S 2 47 hrm debt 18AC 348n 20 12 24 26 ii9 d30 30 31 37 50 AD a5SS 15 M 29 M ) 4NC 1 CP misjoinder 14 AC 245 414 168 172 442 62 76 437 235 583 190 I i 601 236 71 48n 83 marine ins r 78 NY 7 86 co-executor 38 466 co-operation f 214 NY 344 87 remedy ans. 137 AD 667 89 jurisdiction 21 174 2 CP 175 120 AD 737 30 M 468 i-emedy answer 137AD for jury 182AD 169S 667 295 291 50 parties d33M 462 52 appeal relief 32 d4S 45 AD 5CP 14 CP 14 AC joinder 165 NY 161 S I 33 AD 140 S equity court 97 M 180 196 699 355 435 325 4Sn 187 125 424 46 67 1 receiver 29 29 e41AD 106 SAC 153u 55 admisaiona 6 AD 588 f'd represent'n 23 AD . 365 ev. age incom, 448^ 24 AC 277n open close 52M 508 63 covenant 12 NC 30n 70 stockholders * 76 NY 540 do 32 AD 754 27 M 348 73 serv. public'n 14 AD 398 31 M 56 19 NC 411 1 CP 144n 75 atenog feea 43 155 10 AC 61n e 125 NY HI 20 NC lS6n 79 discovery affidavit el6 54 90 jurisdiction a 77 NY 39. 28 230 5 4 NC 259 33 assessment r 78 NY 601 95 law conflict 5 NC 369 100 bill lading rSONY 71 129 US 44S I 06 fiduciary e 37 492 7M 583 16 NC 478 9 CP 225 I I ad. allow. 35 155 1 CP 198 1 12 sum. pro, . 2 AC 145n 116 no 188AD 171S trust 260 210 120 18 21 23 24 93 NY composit n 66 H 115 448 477 569 122 disnovery 16 56 26 170 4 CP 409 16 CP 70 57 M 362 'ri-rimination 39CP 44n 45n 126 attachment e 19 480 128 trust benef 53 515 70 325 23 NC 107 "executors" 22 NC 297 n AliUKKVI.^TKINS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, noif; C •riticited ; 1, limited; e, explained; u, overruled: i, same case; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case ; q, questioned N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Hun Vol. 14 1 39 Bubmissioii 26 451 145 lien el6AD 383 1 48 aSBesement r 75 NY B54 149 acceptance 33 S56 2 M 126 I 5 I conversion a 81 NY 285 1 52 disaffirm'ce IS 288 I 55'p:>3t dated cheolt 24 j284 8 AC 224D due course i08M 241 170S 14. I57insp'n bookt a 74 NY 434 18 AD 587 1 Cf 297 I 59 accounting a 75 NY 187 assign't credra , 5NC 307n316ij 162 license 123AD 884 1 64 trustee prf. B 77 NY 62S I 89 comnaissioD a 79 NY 54! 23 332 insane defense 31 168 16 AD 499 43 AD 71 80 AD 396 12 AC 119 equitable dfnse 182AD 23 169S 467 1 72 preference 35 130 intent proof e97 AD 141 waiver 2M 207 SM 123 18AC In motion transfer f87M 14 149 S 10o(i 198 presumption consideration fil3 ?07 124 374 686 211n 399 I 76 contingen cies do 40 454 \ 77comr*s high- way negligence 24 474 40 192 46 47 8 AD 123 5SS 141 7CP ,92 181 17 30 36 78 AD 103 AD 20 NC 19AC noD-supporl 492 a 74 NY 16 78 2M 7 M 9 AC 61 NY declarations 38 114 81 303 ev guarantee 12 NC 398 223 reference fees e23 151 34 396 399 66 454 83 NY 48 5 CP 219 S CP 419 226 mandamus a 76 NY 422 229 amendment issues 16 608 92 187 23 I assumption payment a 79 NY 409 72 494 lien 7 NC 36J 238 warrant 136AD 300 245 foreclosure r 79 NY 23 250 meas dam- ages 16 AD 474 5M 25 no AD 605 252 atty ag't. 51 437 21 AD 43 n NC 449 ONC 31) Vdl AD 379 atty liability 7 AC 401n 8 AC 433 131 S 28fi stipulations 9M not liable 146AD 280 parol ev. d21 70 84 484 trust 13 NC 339n 14 NC I8n 285 revoke will 10 AC 437n 29 I admr- acctg 4M 293duty ex 116AD 31 19 296 fun expense reasonable 82 89 75 AD IM 2M 3M 15 M 92 M 157 S 115 117 579 341 31 383 179 600 636 49S 11 AC 429n 432n 299 vest title 5 NC 378n fire insurance 23 NC 365n 301 decllaration 57n 580 79 M d79M 308 joinder r79NY d48 84 165 NY 14 CP 493 699 243 187 342 19 NC 355 ea, assignmt 15 292 364 receptance 76 NY 380 366 ins avoidg 15 254 29 86 371 mandamus a 76 NY ?.94 sl5 188 28 66? 41 S3 13 NC 114 16 NC 90r 3CP ?4 do 145 AD H37 do 130 S 485 375 dismissal 51 M 607 379 attachment r76 179 20 285 1 CP 243 3CP 77 7CP 91 383 damages a 79 NY 620 60S void 173 AD 81 158 S 710 387 offer judgt bond compliance 336 74 129 460 358 697 3 1 3 jurisdiction 21 95 next of kin 46 AD 631 d 22 NC 297n 3 1 7 subrogation 96 5 40 68LRA merger 6SLRA 214 529n 567 101 381 recovei'y 174S 869 a 79 NY 56 Art '^° 55 463 S2 242 19 M 827 |d 130 NY 44|incomp ev , 307 19NC iHUn h'exact cost' I 86 eviction '•''^^ 34 231 counterclaim 260 partnership d 92 139 267 ev, prob. cans 18 133 269 dam, proof " 263 356 363 162 640 383 58 51 AD 161 AD 146 S bond 2M 22 NC 376 49 93f! 62 .381 476n I S3 51 counterclm , 20 201 do 134S 1016 276 jurisdiction 35 47 9CP 1 M waiver 75 e 120 NY consideration 344 154 50 667 561 439 520'18AC 322 neg. signals r 83 NV 62n 326 commission 53 31 23 NC 68 16CP 74 433 contempt 56 440 comntiance 209 NY 69 327 presumption 65 566 review 10 M 292 liberal 121 S 820 St 335 dams, pldg. 10 AC 115n 337 deposition 63 AD 398 10 AC 179n 181 .urisdiction 4 AC 18 5M 238 134S _ 832 justification 113 AD 339 authority 17 AC 1099 f 17 46 d46 49 I AC SAC 64 NC 5CP 15 CP 616 1 690 30 31n 151n 97 304 128 389 construction 25 398 8 CP 272 3'^3 contract 62 AD 120 396 draft prom ise a 78 NY 371 118 US 134 398 eq owner 15 M 514 estoppel 76 M 070 133S 456 402 attachment 3 CP 108 15 CP 178 428 bar a 79 NY t22 2M contribution 34 M crdrs damages 15 NC 79n 434 opng default 79 166 2 AC 244n 6 AC service mail 112 AD 127 438clnudontitl( tt 80 NY 263 review judgt 10 NC leOn 2 LRA 628 440judge related r77NY 101 444 findings di; 26 202 31 385 41 414 e8 229 SAD 28 99AD 296 8 CP 433 446 safeappli- ance 3G 432 43 32 448 irregularity d22 404 e28 C affidavit jurors 86 63 67 AD 17 M e39M 217 NY object^ns 98 AD new trial I38AD 176AD 164S facts 3rd party rl» 188AD 5U] inadmissible 162S 434 14 M 315 S CP 65 433 order case 1 L25S 1150 costs 129 S 681 special term 1144 AD 797 478 legal title 113 NY 58 gift 111 AD 453 ^183 compensatn 34 81 484 signals ev 27 327 38 327 486 review ex- ception a 7SNY 166 487contract e79NY 216 cotenant repairs ■ 20 NC lOSn 55 I distribution a 79 NY 52 4 CP 134 73 M 3.39 132S 692 557 acknowled't 1 M 252 38 CP 508 19AC 430n 559bonds option a 79 NY L. 632 40 412 7 CP 192 guaranty 74 113 meas damages 25 AD 292 e 32 AD 238 562reimbursemt 490review 18 f 17M 21M 80 148 639 16 S3 626 381 476 725 452 insur agency 24^ 409 declarations 16 592 9M 471 26 M 646 4 1 2 sup, pro, 16 CP 186 341 signature ev e49 74 10 AC 264n 343 aseesflmente r78NY 562 414 usury 133S H4S voidable 74JM 47 418 legal ev 19 3K e20 168 23 417 31 419 16 AD 549 1 21 25 64 waiver 46 78 5SS 110 AD 456 agency 18 19 47 64 e 125 NY astoppel 21 25 46 7 AD 110 AD 9C 471 146 333 13 24:t 763 i93 accom. note 23 374 RIM 613 198 assumption 18 91 503 affidavit r76NY r6NC f 14 »6NC i,NC 10 NC 5 1 2 perjury r76NY r6NC 5 I 6 perjury a 76 NY 242 151 513 151 88 58 220 181 624 5l8meritsaffidt. 22 64 2 AD 338 2 SS lS2o 153 ■i AC 42 44 5?5 revere errot SO ,14 529 restore act n 109AD 287 27 89 AD 93 AD 79 M ISM 10 AC 460 194 223 HH4 140 467n burial evpenaes^ UO AD 7NC 17 NC 19 NO 22 NO 22 NC 24 M 52 M 77 l22n 272 87 272n 289n 141 543 545 objection expenses 141 S 327 568 penalties 18 499 dl9 188 572 67 allowance 144 Al) 129 S dower costs 319 683 688 577 surety a 75 NY 274 693 23 25 27 37 AD 14 M 5 LRA 187 347 379 173 685 290n 53 I legal ev, ■i 81 NY ■22 151 447 448 231 244 3 146 66 90 471 333 585 763 420 estoppel a 75 NY 417 11 M 174 423 demurrer r 76 NY 599 472 power court change decison ' "~ 428 532 636 350 351 214 110 524 84 465 28 634 i23 e25 32 36 U t6 n 92 3 AD e70AD 536 resultg trust ' 80 NY 538 I4NC 16 537 assigomeij bond r 84 NY 627 540 libel damage r75NY 495 4 CP 431 542 arrest bond a SO NY 202 546 certiorari 19 453 6NC 488 proof qualificn 71 AD 429 37 M 398 548 legatee election a 79 NY 478 39 216 20 M 246 581 menh, lien a 79 NY 273 24 540 18 NC 69 585 bankrupt discharge IS AC 114n 588 deceit atty 20 M 168 591 indemnity a 79 NY 19 91 71 593 guard, ad, 22 „T 57 21 10 CP 226 596 eviction 3 AC 80 602 estoppel 7 AD 585 knowledge do 149 AD 630 notice do 134S 441 805 stockholder 24 642 cond, precedent e 124 NY 33 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished: f. fol lowed ; r, reversed; m, modified; •, dismissed: n note- c. criticised; 1. hmited ; e. explained: o. overruled; s, same ca.se; do, dissenting opinion; p. parallel case ; q. questioned Vols. 14, 15 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Hun 609 jUFisdiction 30 152 fiduciary 37 (t92 7 M oS4 cojivergioD 16NC 479 6 1 2 revew eX' cept ons 18 29 30 288 88 : 208 6 1 5 drircctos a 81 NY 46 622 d27,AD 3S 3CP 135 6 1 7 sale of land *' 76 NY , 602 649 insur. policy a 79 NY 50P 2 CP 426 625 discoverv a 79 NY 630 628 costs appeal 27 . , 113 VOL. 15. 27 i 31111 i guaranty 18 18AC liability 163 S 602 89, M 4 eep. estate 3 Sy 477 1 LllA S23 2 LHA 347n I I delivery 7 NC ISSn 14 abatement r82NY ae2 ! 6 civ. dam act ebTNY , 497 I 8 disjoin corpn r77iNY 2UJ Mi; AD .i3 .36 NC |loO INV 3CF 6 01' 100 2113 12V 137 U 20 iidiiiissn at jd 20 124 scope authority !b9 ' 4, 87 594 23deinand notice a 70 N Y 61 a2 e 165 NY 40 26 flse pretenses m 80 N ^ 394 17 137 20 02 3 I chat, ratge d 17 393 imraed. pro\sn. 42 298 ■18 395 tj2 93 litle 81 173 piesumption f 86 NY . 339 creditors 124 NY 382 37 revers. error 43 AD 004 waiver 63 M 23 niuit plead lao.s son 146AD 5 1 revers. error r 79 NY 498 27 110 63 meaa. dams. 97 attaelimeni 84 NV 818 cuinpliauce 1268 972 do 142AD 447 4 457 591 569 63 624 273 304 175n 29 38 4 42 16 AD ■US NY o 129 NY 176 NY SLRA construction U NO 288b h'way obstruct 12 NC 165n 74 limitn poi. 5 M 252 10 M 407 2 I/RA. 7880 warranty 21 M 90 vol. payment d 108 NY 163 ins. child's life 130 S 548 stct. construct'n 80 jurisdiction 90 631 collat. attack ■27 AD ; COS j8 M 143 164 S 133 notice UNO 394 34 first order * 77 N Y 336 eceiver *11N0 139 jeoond' order a 77 NY 336 19 NC 371n 87expr.covenant 29 • 535 95 NY 51b 4M 32 limitation land 17 M 647 95 NY 350 ^■aive lien 20 AC « . 707. 41 AD laisc" entries Aa NY 46e 42. il 70 corpn. ta,\n $2 442 juiMsdi:tiju 122AU ,584 I 72 neg coserv'i asl Ni 39 1 LRA neg. cyservt, iLIiA •20b JB7 69a 176 12Gn 93 sureties a 75 N Y 100 NY 1 00 pn 32 M 17 AC bate 194 42t 387u i I 6 suieties 8 M 584 126 money h,ad r77NY 123 NY parties 175 AD 19 NC 161 S 23? 539 249 27208 51t. 583 379 17 358 125 107 303 430 I 29 joinder 54 23 AD 52 AD 16 CP taxp'r suit do 58 AD 83 AD 7TiM 130S supl. complaint f 2 M 572 8 AC 277,n 174 AD 513 I 161 S 221 restitution 123 AD 625 I 34 services 21 ' 366 96NY 221 113 NY 449 36 jurisdiction d 24 650 reformation 39 298 56 161 5 LRA 156 1 47 performance 72 632 Stat, frauds 90 AD 183 13 NO 348 153 one judgm t 81 AD 327 27 M 253 10 CP 41 155 forgery a 75 NY 484 I 78 new consid. 269 lis 626 295 296 32tj 177 432 abONY 34 11 guajauty i:2 NO ' I 84 title a 7,6 N Y [i2 UCP costs 128 NY 013NY i9Q title rec'vr 19 502 r AD 630 stai. coQst'n 35 241 197 iiTeguiarJty r ao HY 243 200 discretion a »i N y 622 43 4/ 51 AD 01 105 JNY 152 17 AC 4011) coroner jurisa Ji. -17 M, 65 17 AC 26, i:y uau:deVdeath djMjitA ■ 2s7i. dead bodies I oJii 712 justiiicatiou 43' AD 427 iJOAU US6 248 avoidance r 79 N Y 230 29 ^6 256 publicneerv. r 76 N Y 79 10 NC 333 336n 9 CP 332 4 LRA 134 267 sheriff esc SB NY U38 Lju conversion ' ' 133S 1025 action lies d 75M G1,S 269 revers erroi 2a!> 402 317 ISO 128 a 76 NY d21 25 M i AD 204 title office ti5 210 43 .M 185 11 NC 67 209 del' sn pwr. 24 428 75 671 139 AD 329 123 S 1007 appeal e29 47 151 JJY 88 jurisdiction SAD 466 517 2 1 4 discretion 57 AD .6 e31M 341 I LRA 6l0n incompetency 9 AC 280n282n 220 appeal 16 46;; 68 507 222 elections dl7AD 242 17 M 719 not. binding 204NY . li-S no "power 186AD 219 174S 316 sum. proceedng 186AD 219 authority 186AD 22,0 227 construct'A 32 406 230 compet ev 21 331 d26 12 d 33 229 e 62 324 6 347 :04NY 230 harmless error 73 382 235 sheriff bail 25 263 proof judgment e 43 024 12 M 621 ajurt power 124AD 862 239 city prop taxable presumption 21 NC 357d procedure 02.'Vf r.e;?otiable TOM i;-,."kS 1C7S 493 c;;:i 402 333 r 80 117 US 26 AD la NO 2 LRA 302 174 304 160 167 15 273 ev. m'k val. 48 401 275 covenant ; 12 NC 30n 277 illegal ev. 19 79 competency 142AD 114 282 f'd rescies'h 22 485 72 626 ■48AD 452 electn remedies e35 71 do35 72 23NC 16Sn 164n mpetent ev. 85 e86 3M' replevin 4M i;enl. objections 18 M 180 admissible £ 152 S 1006 187 362 506 94 600 625 276 420421 1 257 693 587 422 a76N'f a 85 NY 29 47- 70 9 AD 37 M 42 M 115 GP liability test 83 M 587 140 ■$ 274 308 construe tioD 29 590 3CP lu leave of court 88 13 1 30B partition a 81 NY 350 IS 156 jurisd'n cons. 21 94 co-tenant acctg 42 , 450 46 600 50 201 ,d 109 NY 57 122 NY 157 devi.^e limitation 11 M 312 covenants 126 AD 6B'l 3 I 7 assignment 18 236 367 declarationaL- W AD 374 137S SOU' 37 r subscription r 79 NY 19 NC 375 stay 3 13 AD 454 424 007 623 99 321 tax'n land a 811 NY el" AD '326, decree m 82 NY ,, 83 328 eq. estoppel r 82 NY 32 35 1 06 340 .talary min e 97 N Y 119 344eond.precedt 10 67 91 NY ileficiency- 12NC 37CP mtge liable 111 AD guaranty 52 . \ 267 269 398 396 4 23^1 '356 jurisdiction f22 4B1 68 M 426 allega. residence 41 waiver 76 47 AD 31 M SAC 18.A.C 125 S 289eg.a88iKnm't r 81 NY 458 49 293 new trial 11 M 248 359 linteiest' 12 M 519 -- 3 AC 235 599 545 612 136 3SlD 436n 46 296 equiten 35 M discovery 8.4 M 506 264 303 endorser eRl 38 216 NY 99.3M-" 164,'g 25 1 3S.f 2i.i 361 counsel feei 10 AC 189n 365caiuaiisJtJEh^ . i r77NY 'Im; 378 discbge lieris'- ' 6 ■« . , , ISS,- 1 38 1 note cons.'d. ,-82 NY. :018 383 hostiltyev. . .. case '2 ' ' 78 NY 595 1 AC, .. S8fl'' 337 waive'bbjns. l,>.\0 ■423n discretion iOlNY 419 liable 'I.46AD 4.50',' 131 S 317.: 395oloud entitle a 80 NY 647 I 42 M 864 365 12 AC , 1950 retaining fee 105 AD 416 description ai AD 121 AD boundaries 130 AD ,.;. 623 236 . 525, 399 de.,iceht I 80 NY iCP i7i:„ 329, 402 covenant t U 94 405 interpretn. , 105M G29 , , 4 1 revoke will ' 10 AC 440 , 1 LRA '91n;; 1.1 2. will exiepii'ilil ILliA 491n"„ 422 insolvency ' 30 64 intent ^. I AD 352 : 36 AD 675:;; 428 judgt finaflTi «77NY (0 27 M foreclosure iT4 _ .■■■.■;„ notice S2 M , 540 •< .AC 362 » LRA 50511 confirmation 112 AD 303 defiqienoK, : 4LR|A''' ' 205n -fina;!. , 4tRA 206n 432'discpvery 512: , 263 oil 07j6^ j 551 . 20 29 37 ICP sopi: ig?M 246 , 443 , 235 >■!,■;' '7M • 446 Ta«i-tt»77 451 i- Itfeliedwle-ifev." , teWNY , , :602>> a'37 »9S evidence errot*' , 13 NC . xi^la >: 440 cost* ABBBEVIA'TIONS: a, e, criticised ; 1, limited ; affirmed; d, e, explained ; distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed;' m, modified; *, dismissed; n,,,iiipliBi. 0-, overruled : s, sathe '■■ase ; do, dissenting opinidn ; p, parallel cue'; qi q^e'suaiaieil • N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Hun Vols. 15, 16 7 AC 332 44611 444 allowancee a 78 NY 16 26 27 91 NY 614 613 105 461 S15 5LRA281n.283n mtKe, sa'e SLllA 283ii cond. precedent 5LRA 28411 446 remov. com 76 AD 12 AC 129 171 447 receiver 13 CP 156 450 leg'oy vestg a 76 NY 134 15 NC 296 18 NC 294 18 NC SlOn 453 trust 7M 3: 20M 470 entries ev a 70NY 604 30 290 2 AC 312 9 AC 14911 475 tenancy 14 AC 344n 477 certificate r 76 NY 629 481 appealable 41 584 54 16 17 CP 376 assent 39 AD 418 7 AC 87n 484 consent 61 330 488 levy subseq. ratifiotn do 67 M 156 d 88 NY 431 spl. contract 158 S 359 scrutiny 94 M 333 158 S 360 extra services d 94 M 331 94 M 332 493 unjust verdI 186 AD 848 495 order 149AD 92f! 133 S 1129 496 neg. dam. a 80 NY 647 accuracy judg. 520 subj. 5 LRA equity 284n 52 I applicn ins a 78 NY 568 84 272 ratification 15 NC 237 526 interpleader r77NY 219 533 summons s22 229 537 police pwr 11 AC 293b 542 disqualified 27 81 105 AD 124 44 M 452 80 M 22U 16AC 386, 3900 146 S 9S7 intregrity U6AD 698 •em 178 456 280 299 7 57 466 556 elect'n 33 77 AD e2SA 35 M 37 M 38 M e 113 NY 23 NC 142 150 4LRA ISO 125 S 40 fi9 M 118 not conclusive 69 M 118 559jury question a 7.rNY 588 258 22 M 9 98 NY 526 excessive dam. 90 4 AD 40 M contrib. 20AC 3 562 554 203 neglig. 238n reasonable warning 158 S 926 duty signal 172 AD 602 504 warranty 46 e80 I M II M 11 AC pug AD 11 NC 327 308 138 539 70n 556 78 76 612 292n 288 179 43 53 AD 14 AC averment 78 M 138S wholesome 222NY 51 i foipolosure 6 LRA 2Sl-4n 518 subjt. mtge 564 usury 20 155 discharge surety 25 AD 517 568 dedication 14 AC 268n 575 reference 19 264 objns facts 46 605 1 3 AC 248n bar 217 NY 76 580 ejectment r 79 NY 93 16 NC 204n 2 CP 178 title invalid 213 NY 230 585 execution a 76 NY 596 e 10 AD 42 amendment 92 AD 177 equitable lien e 18 M 669 595"hereditartf' a 76 NY 426 32 406 3 LRA 493 600 review 2 82 NY a3 76 24 AD notice 13 NC . no review e 207 NY 265 15 519 467 llOn 577 VOL. 16. I dismissal 1 AC 327n absolute dismiss, do 155 AD 806 3 jurisdiction I M 38 II M 231 102 NY 160 9 CP 205 8 referee's fees e 40 M 396 13 AC 47 56 posting notice lOOM 192 165S 876 I 4 referee's fees stipulation 35 limitation 98 M 165S 701 135 76 residuary 67 AD 324 lapsed legacies 13 NY 361 construction I 27 trust 22 84 130 IDt cut off a 76 NY 190 136 jurisdiction d 18 M 242 4LRA 45 69 139 jurisdiction 49 17 el8 e27 59 10 AC eR7NY 8NC 17 legis 55 AD 8 4NC 240 197 527 237 296n 188 153 control 483 43 28 land contract a 91 NY 403 411 33 compet, ev. a 81 NY e65 7.T 46 waiver e84NY 26 M 164 347 382 238 697 108 50 estoppel 35 ?rac. location 1 332 8 AC 164nl66n 53 discovery f 21 do 24 29 30 31 37 62 AD 5SS 15 M 42 M ICP 414 168 442 62 435 236 158 190 192 77 55 71 80 chat, mtge r 81 NY 199 general denial 20 NC 360n construction 133AD 810 86 redemption 79 NY 54 93 declarations 54 53) 58 340 97 will proof 65 188i 662 a 77 NY e42 a 45 e47 04 S7 88 16 AD 24 AD 40 AD 37 M d 84 M 4 CP LRA attestation 13M 17 M 25 M elSS 95 NY e95NY e 110 NY 148 NY subscription 52 M 141 S acknowledgmnt 15.5 AD compliance d 146 S 146 S error court 184AD 171S individually do 148 AD 82 1 82 per«. service a 77 NY 17 33 685 1 43 ligitimacy test a 78 NY 275 16 AD 40 24 M 672 annt. guardian 18.\C _ intention H.'i AD '20 S "children" IT'A'D 1 .18 .t; 163 S 48n 227 961 l'^4 .9S7 734 I 58 guaranty ' 22 14 M 21 M „.„ 3 80 N\ 292p 9^ NY ^Qg! 163 partnership 142 231 7F,9 484 44 50 accounting 38 AD 455 626 465 41 342 152 331 200 lOn 339n 218 299 560 110 460 62.'> [ I 68 fr'd transfer 74 291 ,520 622 fi7n 354n 543 445,,, *^^\Tr, 68 75 eR7NY I16NC 4 LRA Qq« f 161 S 499, J":""*" *°^, I 73 limitation 4,R;rSl NY 143 ?!5AC 160n 95 NY 623 578J-CP 241 rppavng consinn 16 NC 206n 474 1 86 laborer a82NY 17 29 45 e52 73 d4SS SAC 6 LRA 90 NY stockholders 21M 229 I 89 title 31 294 1 92 certiorari rSlN-^ 1 I 96 assesHinent a 76 NY 202 200 note bank r 80 NY 100 3 LRA 278 203 stockholders 21 135 discontinuance 7 AC liability 74M 133 S 433n 56 048 205 contract d78 125 gift husb.t'o wife el' AD 213 consideration 124 S 946 209 usury a 81 NY 352 845 846 203 646 57 extra alio r 85 NY 478 6 AC 149n 8CP 59 60 disputd dm 83 405 65 trnntees liab, a 79 NY 404 28 375 34 287 74 , 330 ,37 AD 207 218 3 AC 395 9 NC 276 68 issues trial 30 155n compuls refer e 30 608 31 288 74 161 f 9 AD 622 1 M 381 117 NY 114 defense usury 9 AC 178n c . pwr. limit 128 AD 667 1 1 decree not conclusive 18 AD 363 I 04 new trial 64 432 97 M 153 ailirmance 185AD 190 172S 842 106 amendment * 81 NY 40 3 M f 158 S authority 60 M 13 625 585 469 649 174 construcfirtn 53M 139 limitation 124 AD 300 *76 jurisdn. obj 60 .59 35 381n 34 e41 6CP residence 8AC waive objns. 18AC 43Sn ! 77 vestinK as- jipnt 15AD 304 nersons liable f 213 NY 238 107 declarations eo 23 91 '^^ 1 7 1 construe will 22 429 I 13 certiorari r 76 NY 337 I 1 6 waiver 70 4 I 2 1 witnesses a 104 NY 506 123 authority 167 AD 716 153 S 176 I 80 amend com- plaint 476 605e 480 663 25 92 42 AD d73AD e54 AD e94 AD f 108 AD 118 AD 187NY 1 AC 13 CP 19A0 19AC 38 CP 677 429 342 161 468 416 293 8.? 267 268 33 176 307n 448 319 a. affirmed; d, distinguished; t, followed; r, reversed; i before court 132S 1036 2 I revers error 51 192 73 472 2 I 4 jurisdiction 86 73 92 2g8 habeas corpus 22 M 609 2 I 9 mandamus a 76 NY 45 95 AD 11 NC 2CP 70M 98 M 126S 163 S 326 273 402 67 69 390 3 368 308 75 crossmg 195 504 230 r. a 81 NY 65 specif, prfmance 13 NC 114 234 sureties 31 323 discharge mtge. e 108 NY 163 239 fixtures a 81 NY 38 242 jurisdiction a 81 NY 619 139 NY 145 108 AD .326 38 M 680 250 pern, injury damages r 80 NY 390 ...ABBREVIATIONS: a.amrmea; a, aistinguishnd; t, followed; r, reversed; m. modified; • dismissed- n not,- » orrticsed: I. limited; e. explained: o. overruled: s. same case: do. dissenting ooinionT p narillel cref «. OTesS^^ Vols. 16, 17 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Hun 255notice appeal e 19 304 257 nuisance r 80 NY 679 r 8 NC 35S do 72 AD 479 26 1 damages^ t 17 350 3 LRA I75d 264 pleading construction 6M 260 266adn'l award 65 319 107 AD 405 44 M 563 134 NY 88 137 NY 294 270 fr'd damga a 81 NY 101 278 carrier liab a 81 NY 638 . 88 AD 322e 323 283 aasesBment r 76 NY 432 2858p'l pivlg r82NY 218 29 1 receiver a 81NY 242 294powr selectn a 79NY 602 29 297 e 83 454 14 NC ■ 88 20 NC 475n chiir institut'ns e S M 631 632 bcnifieiaries 12NC 435 20NC 447 452 307 borrower a 84 NY 67' 37 376 122 NY 388 usurious 183AD 700 86 M l-'-J fl49S 147 170S 667 bona fide £ 167 AD 211 152 S 859 309comr accta a 82NY 491 3 13mandamus 22 540 24 M 224 3 1 7 insurance r82NY 543 9AD 345 12 NC 64 332 duty agent r77 NY 320 337 pledgp 22 358 mistake fact 75 453 do4 SS 50 s 2 NC 295 346 real party p 30 490 presump tion d 34AD 508 agency 25 M no trust 183AD 260 171S 210 349 discretion a 76 AD 601 422 I 170 465n 42 2LE.A liens 5 AD 310 7AD 81 doubtful title 22 :>tC 406n incumbrance 122AD 398 353 atty's lien mSONY 660 31 220 6 AC 336n 6CP 164 2 LKA 273n 4 LHA 858n consent 137AD 194 362 cancel tax a 77 NY 542 369 atckhldr liah r 77 NY 1 r 6 NC 258 e 60 221 20 NC 221n 227n 2 LRA 830n 380 damages a 95 NY 443 26 126 41 484 11 NC Son 390 trustees 62 24 14 NC 2i.O 396 larceny r77NY 114 rbNC 413 404 spec'l issues 25 493 407 certiorari case 2 38 10 40 231 55 AD 647 121 NY 554 409 drawer a82NV 400 e 2U 166 2 LRA 829 Stat, limitations 7 AD 404 e 16 M 317 415 n. trial grounds 47 91 48 474 CAD 191 35 AD 322 3 SS 351 2M 1S8 8M 596 9M 28 10 M 657 14 M 604 42 M 529 15 CP 161 exceptions 58 104 AD preponderance evidence 99M 676 164 S 567 422 sp. prfmance 37 77 42 7 105 AD 291 22 NC 412n dower right 136 AD 360 434 ancil. cxr 53 397 situs stock 13SS 728 211 US 351 44 1 bridge neg. 268 445 servitude 25 419 453app|. waiver e 43 155 e 52 182 d 54 685 costs e 32 AD 350 t 68 AD 529 d 103 AD 419 10 AC 376n f 379 delay waiver 14 AC 24n fee 63 M 65 454 serv. publn e 24 647 30 205 e 44 565 e71 53 5SS 411 131 NY 189 1 CP 142 145n surplusage 184AD 619 172S 378 458 chat, mtge fraudulent e 22 371 25 506 26 356 HO 647 60 17 89 87 e 33 AD 39 46 I certiorari d 22 616 28 329 465 composn deed a 81 NY 623 41 AD 468 14 AC 32n 468 nuisance I LRA 297 n 473 prescription ILRA 297n 474 verdict 13 NC 383n 476 indictment a 83 NY 609 * 78 NY 346 fi 27 M 492 484 appeal 08 607 9M 33' 21 NC 357n 487 usury estop 9 85 58 49 I construction 69 605 misrepresentn 118 NY 526 494 ins. estoppel a 85 NY 278 11 NC 149 a 78 NY 362 45 395 compliance e76 90 construction 52M 31 502 counterclm. 137 AD 911 503changeof int a 80 NY 21 e21 91 507 appeal SAD 321 II AC 454n 5 1 6 misrepreatn 118 NY S26 520 conclusive i 26 245 29 518 de jure 37 45 ^■iolation d 173 AD 341 d 158 S 759 526 authority s 26 632 e 46 367 116 NY 65 liability 5 LRA 590 528 default judt e 23 394 530 revocation a 81 NY 573 4 CP 424 7 CP 158 conclusive 15 NC 431 541 jurisdiction 19 476 546 substituted service a84NY SAC 671 20n 549 indictment 149 NY 104 552 forn corpn. 5 AC 401 156 NY 201 5 LRA 542n 555 aoknowldtg. a7 572 559willreexcun. a 77 NY 369 el.31 AD 388 6 AC 96 I CP 463 arm of court do 153AD 139 586 devise 17 CP 219 570 fraudulent r 78 NY 543 I LRA 242 577 certiorari 9 77 NY 331 583 rpvers. error 2M 92 7M 197 12 M 59 585 election 27 M 213 estoppel 129S 371 143 AD 55 587crd'r bill 4 CP ' 187 59 I declarations a 82 NY, 121 46 281 e 9 M 478 competent 166 AD 239 f 150 S ,1026 592 prom, note r 83 5fY 619 594 forged deed "orged deed 74M 624 damages 134S 671 character injury 207 NY 5 602 impotence d 8 NC 188n 16 NC 439 annulment, 16AC llln 140 AD 226 146 S 1020 aflirm defense 125 S 192 125 8 2 decree d 68 M 572 limitations 146 S 783 162 AD 26 amendment 161 AD 493 606 deficiency r 78 NY 414 9 NC 374 11 NC 357 615 implied co venant a 79 NY 154 43 M 433 622 discretion 26 105 prohibition 27 46: 91 NY 615 624 bond waiver 4 AC 66n 625 substituted serv'ce e 26 484 8 AC 22n 21 NC 80n 6 CP 371 628 instructions m 84 NY 643 27 575 14 204 TOAD 628 ^ 6 NC 234 6 AC 346n ?0 AC 448 6NC 234 construed 201NY 128 VOL.17 I struck jury f 104 AD 519 irregularity 16AC 369n 5 evidence r 79 NY 415 23 416 16 M 62 Stat limitations 16 M. 403 i LRA 603 1 3 trespass 82 361 20 designation r 78 NY 33 e 72 362 23 slander a 8 1 NY 246 23 61 adduce facts lOlM 122 166S 724 27 amendment m 81 NY 474 599 libel aSl NY 116 mental suffering 1 6 mistake a 77 NY 625 15 CP 20AC 170 AD £ 155 S 166 24n 394 1036 19 244 46 33S 47 37 64 145 e 110 AD 763 34 M 559 98 covenant 22 AD 544 epairs 115AD 712 136 269 I 02 scope em- ployment' r 87 NY 535 e 64 AD 494 06 illeg. contrct r 79 NY 186 I 5fact question a 82 NY 370 24 49 34 154 1 20 chat, mtge d 46 315 future crops 65 82 e 142 NY dl9NC 30 levy exeoutn. 533 157 383 68 29 97 NY 4CP priorities 62 M custody sheriff 62 M 68 34 jury qutstion 24 103 496 22 AD 276 45 pers. executn a 79 NY 633 49 jurisdiction 42 126 1 34 NY 530 64 jurisdiction 66 AD 445 d 130 NY 582 87 sale partner r 96 NY 663 oral evidence 128S 922 no power d 143 AD 550 59 damages 101 AD 16 AC 573 59 72 will probate 12? AD 8 I surety 166 NY 84 contract a 82 NY 13 NC 87 appeal notice 24 431 262 a 78 NY S78NY e31 c35 39 222 228 386 165 569 92 indemnitors substitution . e 24 536 98 NY 23 7CP 50 95 agency 514 579 283 1 23 genl. denial 43 146 20 NG 342n 362n estoppel 8 AC 128S 143 AD 174n 908 863 1 28 application of payments a 83 NY 79 I 29 partition 4M 351 20 M 246 1 3 I Bserepresntn a 82 NY 144 1 35 payt by chk a 84 NY 549 i 37 illegal ev 26 e6S 73 evidence d 188NY payme it e 188NY 12 347 382 429 I 38 findings re view 221 22 24 30 71 e71 82 SAD 4 AD e20AD e25 AD 45 AD 46 AD 75 AD 93 AD e3SS 3SS eSSS 140 NY 462 545 288 343 390 575 610 162 SO 448 123 291 629 176 280 632 324 329 412 494 121 253 1 40 money had a 81 NY 171 19 NC 136 1 44 m. prosecu. r 88 NY 270 1 46 contribution 24 585 remedies 20 NC 226 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished c, criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; , f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; s, same case ; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, questioned N. T. Supreme Court Reports — Hun Vols. 17, 18 1 48 prior lien 5 AC 368 Mtoppe] 135 5nr sss recording mtce- 7NC 188n 1 50 illegal BT- 21 73 37 387 4 AD 442 7 CP 285 8CP 119 152 Bubmisaion discontinue B 7 NO 24C 31 19 77 357 7 AD 449 4 CP 632 160 jurisdiction r 79 NY 136 1 66 covenant rSlNY 251 T 8 NC 336 6 LRA 39n 1 69 prefer'd stk. a 78 NY 159 14 NC 432 435n 14NC 446n 4 31 53 .preaump. proof lONC 101 188 recitals a 81 NY 176 8 8 NC 403 192 chge. realty a 85 NY 65 M 136 e24 8NC 249 illegal ev. 29 124 5SS 610 256 demurrer r 82 NY 449 45 256 trust title 28 AD 608 equitable suit 14 NC 112n 6 CP 325 authority 140 S 522 270 assignment r7 8 NY 471 r 108 US 379 10 NC 346 279 innkpr. neg. a 94 NY 1 286 mandamus a 77 NY 347 620 289 fund objn. 24 685 8 6 NC 227 equities 161 AD 745 293 certiorari a 38 639 e 32 AD 600 f 8M 35 3 1 6 jurisdiction 19 409 85 404 managing agt. 2 AC 70 136 NY 346 1 99 presumpt'n a 77 NY 245 « 59 324 extradition 128S 617 fugitive 71 M 355 204 certiorari a 80 NY 254 40 233 8 5 NC 137 2 1 Sep. action 26 367 rescission 157 AD eatoppel 61 M 465 damages 2213S'Y 470 suspend action 221NY 470 2 1 3 parol ev. 114 303 465 81 2 1 8 fraud 18 M 223 receiver 51 246 income 16 NC 29n 228 record'g act 160 NY 60 240 referees fees a 77 NY 476 atty's rights 11 NC 449 241 appeal costs 18 482 IAD 8 242 license fee d 42 M 606 franchise 3 1 9 lease el8M e 120 NY 32 I convsn dam a 79 NY 618 324 jury trial 44 182 160 AD 246 6 AC 266D 277n 279n 7 145 S 657 annulment 16AC 112n right trial 160AD 247 327 ultra vires a 78 NY 588 11 M 586 strangers 16 NO 470n public policy 19 NC 466n 338 damages r 81 NY 428 26 67 2 CP 217 34 1 legacies time draw int. a 79 NY 327 39 AD 374 e 124 NY 530 legacy vesting 10 NC 231 16 NC 263 344 eg. relief a 78 NY 24 AD damages 12 NC 17 NC 19 NC 423 278 156n 286 296 246 356 expert ev. 401 45 129 a83N ixpe Y 400 353 cond. precd 42 230 110 AD 505 Lnjunct. relief 79 163 366 incp. ev. 19 605 41 71 notice 80 133 370 sale "puffers" • 78 NY 38 20 AD 357 4 AC 388 n e394 374 town bonds 21 Mb 26 331 28 389 33 212 44 618 86 NY 321 e 114 NY 631 em, domain 59 609 com's. of excise 71 277 adjudicat'n 4LR,A 691, 692 385 power court a 87 NY 467 167 NY 508 atty's lien 10 NC 394n 18 NC 36n 39 1 parol ev. a 78 NY 618 36 85 76 656 finding void 124 NY 381 395iury question a 78 NY 338 19 73 35 592 600 37 130 2 LEA 520n ■i LRA 687 4 LRA 663 403 pub, policy 41 247 29 M 608 13 M 593 89 NY 332 94 NY 45 6 LKA 132n collateral attack 100 AD 448 separatn. con- . 14 AC 246n 4 1 cross exam, a 78 NY "611 29 123 d 20 AD 132 4 1 9 securities a 80 NY 82 100 US 703 429 preference d 45 345 432 parol agree't 56 AD 602 604 62 AD 121 1 M 296 PlOM 363 17 M 158 22 M 499 written lease 131AD 779 ancl'ry exectr. 1.">3AD 661 void contract lOlM 597 167S 467 435 subscription a 83 NY 313 113 US 458 19 NC 3 LRA 77 202 439 good faith 14 M 3 445 partnership books 65 AD 615 73 A 426 e 31M 220 discovery do 129S 471 liberal rule do 144 AD 600 disclosure lOlM 445 167S 56 457 adoption e 6 AD 111 h 8l)M 405 7 AC 37n 38n Stat, distributn. 36 M 476 parol evidence 37 M 380 463 laborer 29 45 d52 57 d4SS 3 AC 6 LRA aSNC 92 41 342 152 583 201 lOn 3390 467 insur. title a 82 NY 517 IM 116 470 illegal ev, 30 627 95 AD 133 construe statute 9 NC 60n incompetent 77M 137S 475 capital stock d 21 477 note r83NY 509 105 490 wife compt 20 NC 307n 497 counsel fees 26 d62 82 69 AD e7M 29 M 42 M 174 NY 20 148 334 140 141 299 688 169 50 1 appeals lieu r 85 NY . 323 taxpayer int, 16 NC 96 507 practice e 24 M 263 524 estoppel e55 380 112 NY 671 527 estoppel a 79 NY 384 2u M 462 53 ^ champertouB 38 M 17 548 copyright 84 18 552 recov value 21 NC 151n 555 examine directors a 78 NY 699 18 AD 587 inspect books 20 NC 381n 556 remov trus. d36 405 559 eonstitut'l a 81 NY 62 21 131 legis. power 47M 470 56 I drains arrest a 78 NY 232 564 receiver lavee 30 M 246 7 AC 252n trustee do I3SS 262 enforcement 20 AC 29on 569 title d 24 280 conversion 50 AD 26 573 bank liabil. a 78 NY 454 8 6 NC 31 575 indefinite 12 NC 407n services 99 AD 221 583 damages * 78 NY 484 588 sham plead 9 AC 176n 591 constructn. 103 AD 596 m 81 NY 474 discharge mtge. 16 NC estoppel 23 NC 599 libel dam. a 81 NY 117 2RLA 130 stay costs 7 AC 276n 600release 39 111 consideration 9 AD 328 4M 406 602 ev. suffic. 166S 839 604 redundancy 1 M 12a 5l5idm'twaivt. 58b 590 301 304 *78NY 46 2CP 6CP compliance 49 1 AC 14 CP amendment 14 NC offer judgment 20 NC 426n 15 CP 128 5 18 miandamus r 83 NY 528 24 264 520 chamberlain a 81 NY 161 286n 593 costs *78NY 122 48 5 AC 11 NC 1 CP 9CP 30 13CP 31n| 491 564 19 51n 218n 317 447 443 1S7 97 596 certiorari dS6NY 655 597 Stat. Jimita 76 447 no power 148AD 772 133S 333 598 ne exeat a 80 NY 24 VOL. 18 I surflty release a 86 NY 547 d53 98 14 AD 18 4 CP 446 subrogation 182AD 622 169S 850 remedy 175S 487 4 certiorari m 82 NY 2I§ 34 267 6 mtge. lien r 87 NY 92 10 bar 50 61 67 559 38 AD 371 374 4LRA198n205n another action pending 3 AC 228n 12 AC 466n 1 2 bar 4LRA 206n I 3 Stat, limitatn. r 83 NY 107 100 NY 327 I 6 commissions f 24 114q 116 327 d 30 269 33 M 164 64M o47 d 67M 42 d 124 S 621 conversion d 67M 42 trustee fees 143 S 35S I 9 constable teea c 53 163 22 embezzlemt' 78 NY 377 92 NY 568 27 judgt. proofs 9M 95 29 trustee title a 79 NY 631 66 348 profits interest 29 AD 449 39 M 027 31 reservation 74 ■ 165 33 privity do 31 481 36 bank notice a 82 NY 291 64 179 2 LEA 396 737 42 atty. client sum proceeding 26 133 38 AD 596 6 AC 12n 342 343 g NC 308nl 44 flse represn's a 83 NY 31 7CP 72 49 oosts fill AD 916 court's power 129 AD 228 disclosure 62 M 54 146 AD 110 130 S 683 ABUKEVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguishe.l ; f, ioKowed; r, reversed; m, modified: * dismissed- n note- 0. criticised; 1. Iimilea ; e. explained: o. (overruled: s, same case: do, dissenting opinion; p, parailfil case; q, qvie'stiouu ' Vol. 18 N, T. Supreme Court Reports — Hun 5 1 m. lien a 83 NY 279 94 NY - 188 56 contract a 82 NTi 490 59 quo warranto >■ 79 NY 279 24 178 64 attachment r 78 NY 306 2 CP 165 5 CP 132 67 tenancy 19 252 64 M 196 construction 137AD 607 73 letters admn ICP NS 336 a 83 NY 348 common law 17 NC 478n practice 130 AD 644 8 I ptnrship rel'y 73 381 36 AD 611 46 M 182 13 AC 128n 99 NY 610 parol contract 126 AD 57 88 reform deed 20 111 85 NY 42 98 joinder wvr 38 95 91 NY 193 105 reference d 65 600 e 67 622 I 08 neg, dam. 22 309 61 AD 479 109] 22 r.fencing 307 1 I ripar. right 16 NC 204n public nuisance 19A0 J55n 1 25 estoppel 92 293 disqualification 16AC 398n 132 arrest with- out proess 22 302 juriadiction 32 523 74 341 22 AD 190 63 AD 398 399 113 AD 113 139 AD 14 9M 673 19 M 670 681 39 M 458 69 M 327 9 AC 232n 10 AC 179n 181 e 148 NY 269 informn. facts 113 AD 116 11 NC . 123 justification 113 AD 339 commitment 125 S 710 1 34 deed to wife r 81 NY 584 2 LB A 646 139 misjoinder 14 AC 42i 46 compet. ev r 82 NY 278 24 11 23 NC 120n obstructions e 34 36 53 216 e 64 529 71 434 45 AD 130 fright damage ! 17 AC 127n I 5 1 note consid a 84 NY 655; 42 539 e 48 473 1 LRA 594n parol aKreement 22 M 575 consideration f 84 M 4il2 146 S 185 I 53 improvmts' d 31 525 CO tenant act e 42 450 50 201 e 85 230 21 AD 131 4M 351 h 10 M 63 164 NY 4 170 NY 129 remainder 20 NC 105n accountable 143 S 220 not accountable 51 M 292 I 57 tel. CO. rules 109 NY 236 124 NY 271 i LRA 611n I 63 estoppel r 85 NY 334 I 67 city neg. do 32 • 27 e 204 NY 428 reversal 135 832 jury question 120 S 151 I 75 certiorari * 78 NY 610 1 76 pledgee a 83 NY .338 6M 560 1 8 1 tenant rep. 20 M 659 8 AC 427d 14 NC 52n 1 83 eviction 17 AD 323 28 M 616 II CP 310 tenant pay rent 88 AD 39 f41 reimbursement do 95 AD 532 1 87 act of 1858 41 165 recovery ^8 446 avoidance 22 NC 340n 190 sureties a 82 NY 114 192 conirib. neg 24 600 56 AD 607 198 next of kin 20 160 3 CP 331 idence 44 147 200 trust realty r 78 NY 244 202 conversion a83 NY 201 37 599 207 mtge. int. 66M 281 2 1 extension 13 AD 452 212 adnl. allow 30 36 30 M 631 3CP 41! 217 advancem't e36 39 1 M 64 151 M 139 114 NY 5ie parol evidence 37 247 22 1 intereit a 78 NY 608 e 172 NY 380 36 M 358 225 damages 5 SA 574 120 NY 629 228 privity 6M 88 6CP 65 1 LRA 464n admissible 142 S 824 230 waiver 18 104 agency 47 37 232 assignm't 84 NY 391 construction 105 NY 486 239 ev. intent a 79 NY 424 112 US 254 19 68 21 329 33 632 waiver 18 NC 105 255 rule dam. 64 469 286 proof debt 30 366 guarantor e 42 190 4 LRA 268n guaranty 121 AD 333 274 jury trial 69 522 277 pledgee duty a 83 NY 267 2 AC 112n 284 declarations 57 326 25 AD 43 adv. possession 37 AD 51 24 M 319 acquiescence 8 AC 169n 170n 10 NC 60 288 hi ghwy user 59 49 d 92 133 149 NY 511 29 I Co. judge a 78 NY 403 293 estoppel r 79 NY 449 e 43 550 d 113 NY 426 loan to corpn, SAD 433 298 deed mtge. r 82 NY 385 estoppel 11 NC 48b 302 parol ev. 148AD 731 131 S 514 303 fr'd transfer e 24 471 39 277 48 412 e 62 147 308 commissions 28 631 7M 263 compensation 181AD 463 168S 972 3 1 I vacancies r 78 NY 356 d 19 324 authority 22 NO 214n 3 1 6 full notice 24 280 91 NY 331 130 NY 267 costs 4M 415 transfers 145 AD 308 130 S 66 3 1 9 illegal ev. 36 199n e 67 4T8 90 AD 22 40 M 296 324 assessment * 79 NY 622 327 mandamus 141AD 603 126S 989 SSOassault arrest 65 AD 571 333 revival r8 NC 377 r 81 NY 500 336 disputed claims costs 5 SS 551 7 AC 149n 340 jury ques 28 111 e 38 290 344 wife notes a 82 NY ■ 627 s3 NC 121 15 NC 401 347 jury ques. 19 73 neg co-servant 21 607 350 wife vs husb a 83 NY 676 20 473 demand notice 24 436 353 debts charge on realty e 23 122 46 654 7 CP 271 355 fr'd transfer r 79 NY 146 r 8 NC 50 23 426 19 NO. 96 316 execution 135S- 218 358 commissions a 78 NY 635 5 LRA 74n 2 CP 119 5 OP 442 360 demur costs 46 M 412 362 devise r 84 NY 321 365 instructions e6M 115 16 M 460 1 AC 9n 163 S 614 avoids verdict f 176AD 544 368 neg damage 3 19 341 e 40 351 21 NC 7n 37 1 injunctio M 79 NY 568 373 illegal ev 21 73 375 pleadings e 26 109 376change venue 8 AC 347n directory 108 AD 11 378 confirmatn r 78 NY 383 court power 64 M 266 withdraw juror 119.« 96 383 tax rolls r 89 NY 128 389 waive lien 20AC 130n 395waiver proof 8 AD 108 386 mandamus ' a 84 NY . 610 387 dissolutior 80 NY 607 8 NC 170 393 orig. entries 123 729 395 waive proof 8 AD 108 398 death neg damage e 84 NY 264 400 indorser a 83 NY 51 17 NC I87n 21 A 74n 3 LR 307 403 error .ev 20 170 persuasion 136S 1103 undue influence 136S 10S5 405 bill partio 8 8 NC 260! e 48 5481 74 348 9 NC 49n5 15 NC 223 21 NC 263 161 S 437 407 damages 5 LRA 264n 56 M 190-1 409 trust a 111 NY 22 NO 228 293 41 1 construe will a 81 NY 281 ION 415 4 1 4 tender 92 AD 334 defense 1S2AD 622 169S 350 417 bona fides 80 2S9 92 AD 54 180 NY 349 150 US 244 4 1 9 indemnity a 83 NY 518 e 36 332 427 estoppel 45 AD - 276 4 LEA 521n 434 estoppel 47 AD 356 24 M 40 438 sp perfmce * 81 NY 35 s99 AD 268 sll8 AD 151 443 entries ev. d 30 298 e 64 574 2 AC 312n 445 assessment a 80 NY 565 446 acquiescence r 80 NY 275 76 691 452 Stat, limitns 101 AD 472 456 demand 19 630 e24 92 conversion 33 185 458 parol ev. r 83 NY 610 62 326 83 401 67 AD 249 162S 924 461 actual 33 42 32 AD 55 AD 74 AD 15 M 19 M 20 M 2 AC 84 NY 22 NO notice 80 M possn 662 298 31 518 420 524 164 397 413 638 106n 603 464creditors suit execution return 23 49 e 24 471 28 415 41 436 42 362 52 AD 115 enforcibib _„_ 193 NY 2681535 separation 169S 1109 466 execution a 80 NY 166 e21 291 alimony cost 21 436 34 169 237 36 382 14 M 598 19 M 600 6 AC 13n 13 CP 29 470 mandamus a 80NY 152 19 NC 371n 472 dower right 15 AC 309n 475 authority li- cense 68 241 e 63 131 6 CP 145 479 order notice h3M 118 tie 3M 121 delivery to sheriff 24 M 398 1 AC 154d 48 1 appeal do 87 42 IAD 3 service notice 163 AD 157 484 duress plead 28 M 174 17 NC 269 127 AD 413 487 unlawfl aslt- a 78 NY 492 e 31 460 d 184 NY 243 10 NC 272 charge 36 131 murder Ist deg. e 80 NY 515 115 NY 524 119 AD 748 496 construotn rSONY 128 631 96 AD 259 Corp. liability 34 M 486 1 AO 2S7n 164 NY 2S0 502 declaration 27 AD 160 507 illegitimate r 91 NY 316 24 189 4 LRA 490 522 severable 118 NY . 626 construction e 108 AD 107 524amend ans. d 45 M 600 525changeoc(!U- panoy 74 157 527 law mstke. 140 S 823 156 AD 10 530 practice r 79 NY 682 41 M . 96 construction ,108 NY 281 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followea; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; c, criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, dire) nting opinion; p, parallel case; q, questioneo N. Y. Supreme Court Reports--Hun Vols. 18, 19 129 AD 64S 540 direi ( ory 46 ' 303 6M 35 inspectors 81 , 407 representation d IS M 514 illegal bcdj- 60 M 13 560 19 construe fn 42g 436 567 composition 21 23 9 avqidance 10 NC 115 448 428 318n 571 liability 28 128 136 d 158 NY 615 580 stockholdrs rSlNY" 86 NY 582 a 84 NY 360 470 103 VOL. 19. I arrest s21 e43 slONO 4 dower right 321 2O0 a 80 NY 15 AC 5 joinder 136AD 7 new trial e 25 29 33 lOP 2 OP 630 315-.1 282 49 55 293 257 287 19 256 54 66 254 236 385 250 639 438 1 4 redemption 21 53 17 AD review SAD estoppel 24 AD revers error 11 M 100 NY occupancy 127 NY 86M: 90 M 124- S 698 ,154 S 26 appealable 123AD 10 service notice 68U 355 -notice , failure 139 AD 158 evidence lOOM 113 165S '"'■' 340 residue void 167S' 598 1 7 cond. preced, 26 323 37 24 33 e37 30 8CP 101 iuriBdiction 64 476 52 AIJ 271 appeal 47 AD 359 Order nullity 124 67 3d restraint 34 12? 12 NC 154n 35e£ ai ev. 19 59,6 31 419 joint and several 75 AD 601 96 AD 448 i 171 AD 420 6M: 79 o,bjections 33 231 mter. witness 16 AD 649 promissory note 171 AD 418 38 cond precedt 35 . 233 44 277 22 NC 438 52ev -physician 30 563 waix'er 31 M 142 7 AC 347n 356 void pub. policy e 104 AD 389 renunciation 16 AC 371d 377 62 oertif acklgt 19 586 44 511 12 M 498 9 AC 43d 46n 49n e 101 NY 477 9 OP 283 compliance 89 M 40 68 real prop. ICP NS 89 69 jury question s 95 NY 277 23 280 8 29. . 35 declaration 113 AD 833 74 wages exemp 29 injunction e3M d 93 NY. 4CP 14 CP contemnt 174 AD 161 S ys 296 81 259 74 607 11,6 77 compt. wituB 19 59£ 31 41S 33 231 76 AD • 605 87 interest 116AD 63 88 trespass title 153 NY - 432 9 I fls. pretenses a 83 NY 436 evidence 23 NO 119n 47 pers. property a 82 NY 476 ffrowing timber 1 05 bar s7 NC 28 31 AD 63 AD 116AD 18 M 56 M 102 NY 122 NY installments 50 M judgment bar 136AD 692 construction 123 S . 681 liberal applicn. 138 AD 196 joinder 137S loss consolidated 103AD 2.-)3 452 254 303 348 422 378 691 S 45 .316 la 90 NY 2Lfi,A 1 26 resltg. 2LRA 683 147n trust 147n 1 27 preference f 21 409 cond. contract d 25 684 o 53 90 18 AD 396 ins, pol. ev. debt 4 AC 304 88 NY 428 17, CP 184 130 entries ev. 82 capital e40M ftcctg. error 15 NO 369n 55 2 SS .. • value'.-ervicea 431 65 347 133 NY 607 4 SA 248 54 58 9 AC 160 NY 162 NY interest do 144 AD do 129 S admissible 318 NY 137 conclusive 343 616 165n 530 ■ 426 842 597 a 80 NY s8NC 3 22 o31 52 22 AD 656 128 317 414 404 281 207 lien merger 60 ' 533 conclusive 10 M 342 unrecord assignt 162 NY 164 pers. property 123 S 209 legacy clig 38 . 264 eq. lien 122 ,113 charge realty f 214 NY 849 oartitioa > 314 NY , 351 21 6 neg coserv d 21 507 109 AD 240 220 un^rtajcing 446 517 16 NC 446 458n variance 58M ' 144 152 n, I a 83 N '?■ I 58 notice a 87 NY 51 1 65 costs 20 . . reject cost d 68M njunction 24 32 54 6 AD 30 AD 24 M 87 NY II NC 13 CP counsel fees 37 45 contempt 73 AD expenses £ne 33 2 e 10 AC trial fee."! 17 NC 277 remedies 59 20 280 wife services 79 , 306 14 AC 2l3n 282 stipulations 146 NY 279 2 AC 85 80n 10 AG450n 451ii 287 insur. polic'^ a 83 NY 613 292 lunacy 1 LRA 610n 299 affidavits 35 41 37AD 397 64 r 83 N^V 261 234 Stat, frauds e 134 NY , 74 238 presumptn 26 352 180 cond. precMent 33 218 629 532 551 124 376 666 18 390 67 334 173 536 549 I 1 2 devise e.86 110 157 Ad do 142 S 533 857 conversion do 142 S trover lies d 157 .AD ,838 534 I 16 order ref' a 80 NY el9 26 92 contempt 57 taxation d 66 AD surplusage 95 AD 544 390 544 241 67 8 I 74 estoppel r 80 NY 414 21 ., 90 180 authority 33 504 spl. property 34 M 545 sub contractr lien 110 AD 772 1 87 trustees liab 8 NC 386n 15 NC 471 1 88 writ of error a 79 NY 593 91 estoppel a»86 NY 339 d 56 514 85 . delivery 182AD .58M 109S 246 dower 22 imitations 39 do 116AD 672 ■.'Xt 963 £69 405 790 253 audit claim a 83 NY 514 Je 34 4 discretion 48 300 74 287 neg. damages do 10 AD 21 jury question 1 M 203 22 11 36 M 192 158 S 204 charge judge 21 NC 9n interference f 94 M 709 263 description e 47 463 466 e 19 AD 566 265 attachment 300 sureties r85NY 15 NC 3CP 7CP 157 249 303 appeal r79NT 10 NC 573 224 310 power to J el a 83 NY 17 3 I 4 compensatn a 81 NY 69 48 M 142 forfeit branch 2LKA 25611 forfeiture 103M 51 170S' ■ 479 3 1 6 approval 61 M 526 320 damages a 86 NY 140 379 87 350lifeinsuranoe r.SoNY '236 r 9 N 300 354 corpn con- versn. a SON Y 162 358 wife sue bus 20 :e27 06 110 AD 2GP 15 CP h and w. 18AC 473 30 387 648 682 164 contrast 32 362deed fraudu- lent 4AD 213 363 taxn. costs a 81 NY 233 32 298 title in issue 22 NC 463 335 earnigs ev eSo 92 31 M 177 90 NY lus.s income 186 NY incompet.ev. 195 NY 367 demand 86 NY 276 44 280 195 388 neg damage . 53 377 375 fixtures 192 NY 303 personality a6M , 383 arson a SO NY 513 327 389 order ret. * 81 NY 379 325 offer judKml^M 616 8 M (123 "'*^"'' bar e 1.50 NY 187 d70 16 26 198 neg. notice e 42 AD- B84 s 6 NC 246 3 LRA, 257n 269 abuse procs 4 AC 179n 272 meas. dam. 39 48 e36AD 11 72 AD 319 loss income ,20AC 104 273 preaumptn 327 contemp ? 67 260 73 AD 537 38 M 599 332 construe will r 80 NY rSNC 16 NC 20 NC 22 NC 5CP 321 102 260 105n 405n 65 33 ^ood titlo 36 44 48 M 22 NC ,468 459 510 16 410n 275 eompetnt ev 51, 320 .73 382 , ,„ 202 divis'n asstsliS M 372 I 1 9 parol trust laSlNY 629ljurv question 337 income 16 NC 341 costs r83NY 27 damage! 34 e40 29n 595 373 511 351 344 eq. assign- ment a 85 NY 618 343 disability 142 S 592 actions pending 15T AD 349 costs 27 t68AD 373 529 224NY 385 39 I construction 89 NY, 337 9 NC 279 394 wages e.xem f 23 f 29 e22M 17 NC exemption .=8M 94 M 158 S 396 parties e 47 e4S 54 e IS AD 6 87 AD el2M ISM 4 AC 194n 196n 4AC 197n d 123 NY 542 19 NC interest inft. 97 AD 529 399sxpresB trust a 88 NY 234 21 607 SAD 56 attachment 18 NC 323 532 98' 649 278 314 129 1091 240 448 416 437, 297 79 174 ABBREVIATIONS: a. affirmed; d, distinguished; £, followed; r. reversed; m. modified; •. dismissed- n note C erlticised: 1. limited; e. e^lained; o. overruled: s. sa:a e oase; do, dissenting opinion; p, parahel «?s" q.'questiSned Vols. 19, 20 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Hun 405 serv. sum- mons 86 404 a 29 AD 49 2 AC 70 136 NY 346 recovery 175S 416 410 eq. assignmt a 86 NY 686 30 583 waiver 10 AC 291n reference 53M 179 not app. to BTir. 39CP 60 41 8 partnership a 84 NY 556 16 NC 358n 424 challenge a 80 NY 484 430 construction a 80 NY 500 19 428 12 NC 176 441 misfeasance 56 471 66 AD 236 28 M 710 460 taxation a 82 NY 459 48 19 13 NC 7 473 jurisdiction e 24 468 d 32 601 39 278 284 TZ M 620 132 S 2Bf) no power J36AD 524 file mortgage 128S 1110 relief 70M 466 477 construction a SI 385 30 53 attachment 62 174 2 CP 332 16 CP 328 48 I demurrer r 84 NY 330 8 7 NC 433 s 29 141 s 35 657 incapacity 17 NC 508n 490 misjoinder 40 60 160 S 1004 494 sureties 29 74 84 AD 698 16 CP 326 500 trust fund 47 361 title vesting 7 AD 531 22 M 98 16 NC 38n 12 CP 210 503 highway a- bandonment a 87 NY 148 47 46n 41 M 163 13 AC 235n 238n 13 AC 241 243n f 174 AD 484 509 asBumd risk 40 348 limitations 63 . 469 jury question d 20 AD 98 5 1 3 limitations 63 469 42 AD 304 16 M 560 5 1 9 assignment a 84 NY 622 16 N.C 362 526partition sal? a 85 NY 427 8CP 217 tar 136S 281 534 levy 64 134 6 AC 126n 540 construction 38 629 15 NO 386 ease valid 75 399 46 AD 347 5M 127 33 M 627 no redress 148 S 238 85 M 120, 124 548 authority a 82 NY 324 64 142 550 foreclosure a 84 354 556 notice 2 M 32 560 election 176AD 816 564 verbal tru«l 21 72 569 sureties d 24 445 jugdment bart 31 395 36 87 81 86 7M 523 119 NY 420 577 receiver • 95 NY 314 25 64 26 233 39 AD 152 590 guaranty 28 37 parol evidence 123 S 232 67 M 395 liability 67 M 397 595 verbal trust 21 73 interest 41 AD 620 16 AC 48n compensation 79 AD 451 costs 64 93 66 280 5 SB 651 7 AC 151n wife's earnings ■ 14 AC 206n no bar 131AD 539 60 1 not excused 145 S 487 606 action plead 3 AC 231n 609 dismissal ap 49 AD 148 19 M 466 jurisdiction ' 183AD 671 do 171S 294 295 powers do 171S conclusive 225NY 578 622 assignee 24 86 627 bequest in- 63NY 629 conversicr 33 M 282 630 will probate m 84 NY 663 634 nonsuit 118AD 461 authority 39 CP 144 sell for cash 140 S 823 156 AD 10 ,67 VOL. 20 I I rents profits r 83 NY 11 e 28 600 1 5 compliance 44 655 1 9 body execute 1 81 NY 639 r 11 NC 377 e 45 M 213 4 AC 314r r H NC 377 7 CP 286 conversion 16 NC 474n arrest 16AC 11 23 discretion 31 386 403 35 155 55 165 74 193 77 508 92 65 SAD 71 2M 409 extra fees 20AC 194n 36 attach, judgt a 84 NY 1 39 contract a 87 NY 486s 491 contempt 60 M 64 46 discretion 40 AD 140 29 M 676 1 AC 316n 7 AC 2S0n 282 4 CP 274 164 S 421 second order 157 AD 613 143 S 976 sup. proceeding 157 AD 617 142 S 979 reversal 174 AD 607 161 S 116 48 discovery 48 150 10 M 447 ICP 71 6CP 99 affidavit 15 AC 409n 50 amendment a 82 NY 509 1 21 140 c27 20 2 CP 196 construction 4 AC 376n 22 NC 286 53 affidavit 1 M 1 CP 567 do 172 NY default 15 M 174 laches terms 43 M 408 parties 137AD 11 76 sup. pro * 83 NY 623 do 68 314 8 ! constr.evictn 8 81. NY 644 S NC 42 85 arrest rSlNY 8NC 99 46 55 att'y larceny r 82 NY 238 64 AD 133 70 distribution a 84 NY -516 34 M 674 21 NC 397n 75 foreclosure e 47 _ ^ 240 party in interest e64 416 15 AD 437 41 M 133 48 M 47S 4 AC 195n e 4 AC 197 d 123 NY 641 43 234 87 discharge 8 CP 8 30 90 answer ev 44 19 5 AC 66d complaint ev IM 285 133 NY 444 93 insurance a 87 NY 626 39 321 d 68 309 98 jurisdiction e 26 160 49 397 24 M 95 37 M 128 eS3 NY 243 reverse, error 113 AD 341 good faith 142 S 875 1 04 reformation r 87 NY 40 34 266 18 NC 325n counterclaim 18 NC 380n I 19 waiver 69 271 10 AC 398n 1 23 damages r 86 NY 324 1 26 negligence 35 • 170 set-off 3M 352 e 30 M 82 1 3 \ surplus 32 M 409 412 36 M 352 12 CP 143 133 foreclosure n 86 NY 428 I 37 certiorari a 82 NY 318 1 43 penalties a 85 NY 258 consideratn liab 16 NC 469n I 50 audit a 82 NY e74 . 80 255 1 53 discharge 25 AD 616 44 AD 191 1 56 pers. tran- saction 26 387 30 561 31 48 revers. error 95 AD 392 163 20 15^427 d 23 139 1 73 neg damage 80 AD 304 contrib. neglig. 20AC 238n I 76 affidavit » 85 NY 628 1 78 foreclosure a 85 NY 30 182 Serve atty 49 AD 407 a 20 NC 164n I 84 report fraud 32 290 1 88 imprisonmt a 84 NY 410 191 eq. rights a 86 NY 441 36 87 sp'l contract 39 AD 411 authority ev 159 NY 468 split causes "8 M 657 163 S 272 196 mandamus a 85 NY 641 20 \ statutes not extended 21 264 public use 11 NC 2S5n 206 post nuptl. agreement a 85 NY 421 22 NC 334 2 1 assignt. cl'm r 86 NY 96 613 113 US 467 68 322 15 NC 471 8 CP 282 2 1 4 gas main a 89 NY 493 2 I 7 Rapid Tran- sit * 82 NY 95 public use 10 NC 247 237 jury question 72 606 241 jurisdiction r 83 NY 240 26 161 49 397 10 NC 294 243 op'g. default 6 AC 321n 246 possn. title a 85 NY 637 do 106 NY 361 p 119 NY 392 34 358 distinction 48 542 fraud 21 AD 378 estoppel e94NY authority 56M 398 title property 129 AD 279 69 262 gift consent a 85 NY 616 36 609 receiver power 19 NC 370n 264 sup compl't 29 445 8 AC 277n 5 CP 328 267 doubt'l title 27 2 28 278 29 440 33 394 d 36 459 38 AD 380 22 NC 40Sn 2 LRA 466n compel purchase 10 NC 357 274 foreign exr 13 AD 326 27 M 380 4 AC 56n 68 jurisdiction 181AD 299 171S 202 2LRA 828n 278 ol'm vs de- cedent 16 AD 555 17 AD 11 3M 27S 2 LRA 828n presumption 176AD 557 163 S 193 282 legacy chg. 3M 487 d 33 M 523 38 M 496 56 M 425 285 attachment a 82 NY 88 14 CP 238 288 writ of error a 81 NY 629 292 remedy a 82 NY 10 4M 120 297 tax lien 41 310 299 judgt. lien e 78 AD 591 16 AC 120n 30 I assessment a 81 NY 631 f 22 615 23 326 658 26 431 53 479 compliance e 84 NY 603 303 flagging r 81 NY 139 305 assessment r 82 NY 243 308 discharge 11 CP 232 309 abortion SCP 8 313 injunction 23 583 a 24 354 25 269 20 M 192 lOP 446 2 CP 97 4 CP 165 17 CP 66 128 AD , 48 fraud restrain 14 AC 166n 316 sum pro 18 M 242 2 AC 146n ABBREJVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; !. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *. dismissed; n, note c. criticised; 1. limited; e, explained ; o, overruled ; s. same case; do. dissenting opinion: p. parallel case: n. questioned N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Hun Vols. 20, 21 320 insurance 61 AD 3S4 construction 3M 451 326 dividends a 84 NY 393 333 jurisdiction 32 115 50 164 343 arrest 39 127 AD Bupercedins 127 AD strike out 99M 163 S 25 349 iudgt complt r 84 NY 420 1 AC 94n OOP 11 355 mge, assen a. 85 NY 453 26 645 e20M 391 irote Corp, Btocis 14 NO 443n objections 62 M 249 360benef power m 86 NY 522 power revocatn, 14 NO 502n 377 construe will m 86NY 291 382 co-tenancy 37 18 162NY 319 388 prospective 24 . 466 26 38 27 2 33 394 45 339 o 46 209 64 382 71 277 e 103 NY 572 doubtful title 22 NC 408n 395contraot dam 11 AD ' 424 d 103 NY 264 396 spec, prfmce a 84 NY 641 17 NC ■ 179n 398 reformation a 85 NY 642 51 151 5 LRA 169n 400 reference 260 448 810 362 624 427 sp. prfmce. 36 477 right of way 130 NY 471 438 damaKea c52 76 446 not conclm 129 22 426 appurtenant do 30 134 5AD defense U5 AD 12!) S order de 145 S acquittal do 160 AD 924 1116 448 costs 29 547 450 rignt of wav reserved 130 NY 471 454 Stat, limtat 24 82 29 AD 47 AD ISA ■iiU 104 NY 113 NY 16 CP 136AD 48 1 refund 139 AD 124 S tax 416 489 486 fine expense 33 649 e 37 334 21 M 341 reject cost d 66M 218 492mtgee's right a 87 NY 23 89 NX remedy 34 fr'd intent 41 security e54 75 preference 124 NY 627 99 451 74 247 476 520 500 Stat limitatn 366 322 207 97 318 357 651 248 422 15 a 87 NY e24 25 87 NY 10 NC 459 indorsement .iLRA 39 462 examination 322 571 450 324 d2S 35 d57 ICP ury trial 41 constitutional 65 AD 289 49 M 33 a 82 NY 45 6 OF contempt sSNC mistake relief 6LRA 159n 402 final hearing 353 436 e23 d84AD discretion e31 notice h40 408 bank liable 21 M 246 42 I amend, pldg 352 373 552 e27 233 70 367 19 AD 237 12 M 20« 18 M 296 f41M 126 SAC 103n l(l5n 2CP 47 251 costs 20 NC ■ 7n new notice 453 1116 465 defense 145 AD 12ns order do 145 S acquittal do 160 AD 924 468 remedy 83 405 stat. limitation 70 AD 130 accruing 24 M 31 M 68 386 634 465 38 444 320 545 acts one ags. another a 81 NY 637 58 345 jdgt. admissible 168S 947 547 irregularity s21 614 25 263 306 36 235 50 544 549body executD 21 . UM judicial noti'ie 23 583 551 execution * 81 NY 63f 21 29) jeil liberties VOL.21 I disintermnt 43 47 3 AC 82n father custodey 14 AC 435d 5 exam d71 I 5 appeal 21 104 363 22 294 306 34 495 25 2381 304 I 7 prohibition 54M 7 AC 20 AC 555 malic, lis pendens r26 do 26 4 AC 27 253ii 2!1.9 .M satisfaction lOlAD 484 a coord 1C4M 63 64 171S 263 cond. precedent 1718 263 novation 171S 264 I 63 salary ;8 117 •V. on appeal I AC 128 I 66 addl. parties 153 S 903 90 M 563 106 order ref. "asp 4 1 82 NY 609 I ! Ocharge estate case 6 e25 5 f42 138 f 2 AD 16n 35 AD 252 e40AD 496 el5M 604 10 AC 457 1 1 4 discharge a87NY 110 23 44S 24 477 10 NC 31Sn new prom. 30 AD ev. 360 623 41 205n 692 47 irrelevant ev a 83 NY 610 21 401 bound by ans 48 342 declarations 9 564 53 securities rS5NY 36 59 title exr. a 85 NY 22 123 446 67 trustee 32 1 69 ; e6M e lOM J 169 NY i competent ev. 33 315 I I 7 stockholder 31 309 certif. conclusive 70 627 12 AD 395 7 M 42 SM 62' UfiNY 233 5 LRA 274 fraud proof 5LRA 274n 1 2 1 recovery 5LRA 554 I 22 presumption 42 378 jury question 12 M 492 38 M 658 30 city official e 102 AD 212 110 AD 383 e47M 367 99 687 a 84 NY 25 LRA authority 37 presumption 43 attachment NC 426n remedies 12 NC lex loci 9 NC domicile d 216 NY 487 578 219 400 197 I 84 mandamus 47 e54 54 24 AD 1 AD 80 AD 84 AD dl2M 543 209 218 225 424 499 354 239 253 custody corpse 14 AC 436n 203 2nd examin- ation 29 M 675 1 AC 317 7 AC 281n 282 286n 4 CP 274 second order l.->7 AD 613 142 S 976 sup. proceedings 1.-|7AD fil7 H2 S 979 205 receipt tice a 86 NY 187 2 1 6 attachment e25 85 10 NC 343 21 NC ISOii objn. iurisdicn. 30 35 397 24 M 684 I 32 release 1 CP 46 418 23 NC 195n 3 CP 346 7 CP 414 1 36 substitution 87 NY 144 a 84 NY 648 personal service 35 340126 464 delay '2 AC 418 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d. distinguished ; f. followed; r, reversed; m. modified: *. dismisbed; n. uoie . c, criticised ; 1. limited; e, explained; o, overruled ; s, same case; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; a. questioned Vols. 21, 22 N. 7. Supreme Court Reports— Hun compliance 41 227 will a 85 NY 28 64 153 245 23 1 unauth funds case 2 a 68 NY 201 231 ratification case 7 a 87 NY 6! 232 Ufe inaur aiicc case 1' r87NY 81 NY 277f r'd represntt case 6 a 82 NY 1 61 NC 79 232 tents case 6 a 85 NY 233 constiue will case 4 m84NY s7NC 235 trust r84NY r9NC 2 AC 609 83 146 345 238body executn 20 AD 88 86 AD 286 104 AD 24 e 109 AD 757 4 AC 314n 316 13 AC 318n 319n 321 240 counterclaim 88 258 24 1 mtgor estop- pel a 84 NY 589 244 penalty f23 9NC 246 lien estraya 72 AD 538 e 42 M 659 19A0 369n amendment 20AC 22n 253 guaranty a 86 NY 603 257 jurisdiction a 82 NY 62 AD 13 CP 16 CP coats 111 NY 619 585 586 258 56 518 259 damages 3LKA 273 265 commr. neg. 638 282 appeal case 6 84 NY 660 283 referee rep't case 7 m 82 NY 172 285 title tax sale r 100 NY 378 53 19 127 NY 250 288 contempt 23 360 40 AD 105 35M 337 7 AC 254n 10 AC 119 13 CP 29 interlocutory 29 674 95 NY 493 no defense 20AC discharge 20AC resettle 185AD 173S 298n 299n 538 247 293 remedies a 86 NY 75 21 395 59 26 13 NC 321 14 NC 207, 229 306n 304 coupons bond a 86 NY 317 4 LRA 691 306 mutual mis- take a 87 NY 327 13 NC 358n 18 NC 326a 3 1 6 bond acctg. 42 e63 142 NY 9NC 15 NC conclusive 138 NY liability 142 S f SIM 320 bail *82NY slONC 43 523 429 554 13gn 429 201 819 537 672 e43 e87 demurrer 15 NC 692 544 184 268 phys. exam, d 29 165 273 compuls. ref, 36 AD 274 legacy »84NY deficiency 20 NC 178 16 480 207 208 322 confirm rept e 36 M 154 f leading 3 AC 163n a 20 NC 345n defect parties do 182 NY 438 accounting ILRANS 166 r84NY 128 NY 2CP 349 sheriff a 84 NY 25 72 424 370 445 263 e97AD 41 1 conversion dam. case 2 r 84 NY 634 355 waiver lien 20AC 122n 172S 385 357 court's powr 38 35 AD 24 U 83 ISl 215 364 legacy 92 presumption 70 AD 34 M 115 NY emancipation 21 NC lOn 376 revers. error 274 76 609 134 33 86 9M rules of ev. 67M 234 464 182 602 381 curtesy 30 616 15 AC 220n 137 AD 869 383 competent eviden'ce a 83 NY 41 e71 25 M 6CP interest 180AD 592 205 502 460 344 397 387 whole case 30 AD 97 e 3 AC 237 ~£LRA S19n 389ehar. bequest 40 543 e 1 AD 162 396 assumed risk 11 U 660 399 larceny r 86 NY 390 403 atty'a lien 24 51 poasessioD 22 NC 106n 413 ejectment case 4 a 87 NY 463 rescessiOQ UNO 460 4 1 4 diaeharge case 2 60 80 AD 162 AD 147 S 620 367 516 1085 4 1 5 indictment a 83 NY 464 s8NC 2 LRA 874 43 1 order arrest e26 16AC 436pleading 33 642 14n 34 39 16 M 5CP 6CP 7CP 14 CP 14 NC 15 NC 16 NC 644 430 146 335 224 340 5 39 446 316n 260 269n f 35 51 3SS 8 AC 3CP 607 505 333 82n 84n 148 276 indorae ch'k case 7 a 87 AD 89 90 277 appeal case 1 328 a 82 NY 25 relevant ev. 33 52 66 73 revers, error 339 12 632 325 347 382 332 amendment 16 AC 250n 344 competent evidence 405 muni, bonds case 2 a 84 NY 403 26 335 406 judgment case 3 a 84 NY appeal case 4 a 87 NY 5CP 653 623 343 407 judgment case 1 a 87 NY case 6 foreclosure *85NY r86NY case 7 undue infi, a 86 NY 634 619 494 439huBb dcwife 33 659 10 NC 31 1 CP 277 S CP 394 6CP 52 443 indictment 38 420 450 deposit r 84 NY 145 specific lien 9 NC 43n 457 bill partic 27 28 48 62 AD 73 AD 17 M 9NC 10 NC 23 NC 19AC 502 267 230 132 324 278 49 478 432n 8n 6n 459 order arres e 48 605 1 CP 48 15 CP 136 462 banker liable do 46 102 4 SS 293 466 lotteries r 96 NY 362 29 467 e 147 US 466466 476 discretion 9 NO 166n 485 declarationa a 84 NY 666 489 annulment ,„„ „„ 123 S 1061 199 NY 507 divorce voidable promises 139 AD 125 lo8S 408 hyp. defense collat. attack complaint case 7 1 74M 634 154AD 489 couri s powr a 85 NY 483 76 AD 373 amendment 123S 1061 status plaintiff 71M alimony 129 S voidable 131 S 48 757 1058 493 contract r 86 NY 472 13 CP 283 394 579 assesBment ( 23 350 1 580 reaale parce S AC 361n 582 certificate a 83 NY 481 22 608 584 lease caae 5 a 87 NY r84 S?- 77 509 laches • 82 NY 669 8 M 102 1 LRA 487 irr^ularity 27 M 58 515 waiver 126S 1117 70M 456 533 repeal by implication a 83 NY 538 537 admiaan in partic. defenae rOlNY 22 AD 42 AD 75 AD e88 AD 3SA 5 AC 12 NC 392 546 13 353 337 93 62 64 390 55 1 compet. ev. 104 AD 637 559 injunction 41 exclua property e84 118 NY coercion 122AD copy-right 135 trade name 68 M 123 S 16 34 263 118 465 1093 568 construction f 37 342 344 147 NY 612 demurrer c 86 102 atockhldra liab e 2 M 396 147 NY 612 573 amendment 91 AD 467 574 intent 63 616 70 16 73 352 19 M 413 20 M 147 94 M 175 157 S 900 576 discontinue 6 AC 104 7 AC 436n 444n 577 t'd represntn a 86 NY 638 174 NY 184 9M 9! 15 M 618 enforcement 322 1049 3021 369 5 86 assessment case 2 m 84 NY 696 E89 authority case 6 a 86 NY 40 594 publieation 28 M d 112 NY inj . damagea 2LRA notice claim 59 M compliance 59 M jurisdiction 68 M 124 S f 156 S authorized £ 92 M 598trust 10 NC IINC 331 388 639 18 18 626 838 281 605 372 151 607 no costs 71 M 532 130 S 806 609 intervention e 27 263 d45 27 d 48 448 d 6 M 310 4 AC 196 10 AO 120n appear at will lOOM 186 165S 422 612 Corp. exiat- ence r 87 NY 636 6 1 4 amendment B 82 NY 610 25 263 306 6 1 7 eq, estoppel case 1 a 90 NY 607 680 6 1 8 appeal case 7 *82NY assessment caseS r85NY 1 22 NC 409n VOL.22 I coerce jury 10 AC 89n 93n 6 infant guardn a 94 NY 473 5CP 1258 8CP 288 8CP 147 money had 23 M 75 1 1 new mtge. a 27 665 • 40 328 19 affidavit 86 419 62 AD 168 e87AD 426 a AC 57 6 OP 446 produce booKs 11 NC 423 22 attachment »87NY 1B7 28 dower r87NY 163 33 neg. b lading a 84 NY 465 84 180 measure care 68LRA 156n 38 will a 84 NY 663 agNC 326 43 conversion 23 U 355 allow claim 5M 141 49 new tria a 03 NY 552 32 423 22 M 104 2CP 207 10 CP 105 10 CP 235n counterclaim 11 NC 101 53conversn elms 72 AD • 694 43 U 137 oyster beds 99 AD 517 larceny 194 NY 177 56 jury question 23 451 7 AD 618 60 pers injury r 87 NY 122 63 order arrest o2AD . 339 c 2 SS 152 163 c 3 AC 43 44n 64 advances 16AC 89n, gOn 69 practice • 83 NY 624 63 176 45 U 160 61 M 333 14 NO 99 13 CP 360 14 CP 145 interloc judgmt 21 NC 357n 72 new mtge. a 87 NY 114 5 LRA 283 n consideration 15 NC 469n notice foreclose 5LBA 248n ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note c, criticised ; 1. limited ; e, explained ; o, overruled ; s, same case : do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, questioned N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Hun Vol. 22 75 insur. policy a 84 NY 57 assets 83 7M precedence e22M 648 98 140 S94 254 1 33 voidable r 84 NY 190 33 M 186 corpn. trustee 14 NO 256 139 sum. pro.. 80 vests fee i 82 M 461 144 S 932 84 publication 85 587 13 M 556 17 AC 384n f 162 AD 584 compliance 67M 18 SGremov. trustee 66 711 186 do 181 NY 17 M 37 M discretion 146 AD 132 S a87NY 141 appeal case 2 a 84 NY 6CP s24 attachment case 6 a 84 NY 1 CP 1 42 appeal case 4 *82NY 932 '309 89 credibility 35 AD 203 remedy 47 AD 115 1 42 guaranty case 6 i NY 484 143 appeal case 4 a84 NY occupancy 38 WT 570 9 1 holding over 84 AD 363 5M 266 e 196NY 24 implication d 196NY 24 tenancy ij 127 AD 91 presumption do 140AD 690 95 deed poasessn a 84 NY 565 100 execution 52M , 420 101 demurrer r 88 NY 268 2 CP 128 1 04 receiver 5M 420 19 NO 379n 106 commiss a 93 NY 562 1 08 sup. pro. 66 M 622 I 1 covenants 25 225 I 15 objectionB 66 380 notice publ'n. 8 AC 364n 1 23 tender costs a 82 NY 576 7 CP 204 memoranda deci- sion 21 NC 3S8n 125 irregularity 92 M 385 156S 997 1 26 referee a 83 NY 613 proceeds 20 NC 108n 1 29 foreclosure a 85 NY 246 1 30 reference 28 421 2 AC 273 UNO 118AD 64M 481 676 326 224 669 1 63 1 82 separate tsc 39 OP 146 187 external means 44 603 45 315 o 112 NY 479 201 town bond- mg r84NY 208 intent 54 1 ev .value 24 AD judicial sale UNO 651 1 45 will vesting cases a 85NY 91 3LRA 695 construction 16 NC 118 1 46 bond guard ian f 24 385 ISOpoUut str'm * 88 NY 60 37 181 demurrer dam. 20 NC 432d 4 LRA 476n misjoinder 14 AC 49n pleading 118AD 817 819 joinder £ 174 AD 786 161 S 655 I 58 sewage dam 229 462 438 532 621 172 48n 224 rule practice 33 44 84 NY 160 AD £ 145 S power 72 M 131 S 636 183 287 248 658 referee 335 106 226 sup. pro. 6CP receiver 17 AC notice 126S 38 240n 101 NY 127 NY ILKA 5LRA SLRA 1 64 bond 31 63 1 67 insur. policy * 84 NY 493 bill particulars 143 594 297n 128n 129n 323 211 10 NC 13 NC 18 NC 4CP 9CP 477 208 209 250 68 241 78 228stat. limitatn a 89 NY 146 3 CP 302 23 1 taxatioiiagt r 85 NY 359 235cnBtrctn.will 11 NO 58n authority 120 AD 14 242 revers error 12M 157 245 assignment a 22 NO 386 249 opinions 60 55 4 AZy 443 25 3authenticatn 37 620 conclusive 38 274 invalidate 70M 288 12BS 606 26 1 construe will 1 74 judgment 6 AC 198 19 NO 69n right to sue 139 AD 420 176 condemnatn 627 33 d25AD award 130 AD 13BS present 151AD market 151AD 121 645 24 358 239 value 55 value , 56 180 costs discre tion 23 86 453 40 628 149 192 336 543 287 sureties 34 290 289 coserv't neg pl2M 11 master neg 53M 124 292 neg. coserv 4L.RA 17 293 Corp. resid- ence 20 AD 167 short summons 60 M 145 2 OM 368 297hypoth ques d26 118 11 AC 41n 300 affidavit! 74 341 22 AD 190 AD 398 10 AC 181 a 11 NC 123 construction 76 AD 32 without warrant IM 150 13 M 765 19 M 680 10 AC 47n 60n 68 AD 143 NY _ title vesting 114 NY 478 480 construction 153 AD 282 less 13' 354 conversion 64 120 negotiable 50 AD 146AD 162 AD 131 S 147 S subject sale 106 AD 10 AC 160 S jurisdiction d9M 44 M 92 M 1563 certiorari 137M justification 113 AD arrest 181AD 167S 62n 53n 496 673 268 373 820 637 330 739 56 74 AD 132 NY 266 curtesy 49 6 96 AD 15 AC 270 trustee r84NY assumption 219 NT 274 contempt e 49 416 278 nom. dam- 58 651 127 419 137 222 33G 24 s25 408 184 283 judgment e 46 361 284 degree care 304 consideratn a 13 NC 38i recovery do 151AD 181 do 135S 913 307 costs appeal 22 AD 36 AD SAC UNO 12 NC 4CP 321 585 48 53 218n 340 27 69 427 251 478 501 200 r94NY 437 title a 86 NY 359 ratification a 87 NY 294 632 28 137 60 33 30 AD 336 9M 426 5 AC 387 cond. precedent 93 M 433 158 S 112 367 requests 96 NY 643 369 chat. mtge. e 25 506 372 guaranty r 87 NY 209 4 CP 381 379 vacate order 60M 145 386 atty's lien d24 29 5M 16 M 18 M 3CP 13 CP 17 CP lONC 18NC 8 AC 26 528 77 560 44 14n 40 365 3946 34n 8Sn 429 covenants 54 622 covenants 147 N. Y 467 8 AD 183 21 AD 175 e 180 3 LRA 792n 18 M 502 measure damage 21 M 208 SAC 243n245n 4 AC 398n 399n 434 sureties 408 603 441 authority al2NC 65n 444 presumption a 89 NY B36 d32 415 dSS 231 res judicata d62 289 release 82 149 parties 4 AC 38Un contract 120 NY 5S7 15 M 541 37 M 6CP 389 competent ev. 25 61 26 AD 4: 450 opn'g. decree 33 237 56 AD 278 699 391 455 pers. trans- action a 85 NY 639 d SO 527 37 125 457 fr d transfer case 2 r 89 NY 405 court power lOAO In 458 appeal case 6 a 87 NY 310' 7M 'same time" 462 3 1 3 stkholders case 6 r91 NY 308 575 337 3 1 6 appeal case 1 '►82 NY 4 CP 3 1 7 pleading case 8 a 84 NY s8NC 3CP 3 1 8 appeal case 9 a 84 NY 8CP 320 part paymt.' 32 309 327 advances a 108 NY 242 33 . 594 estoppel 272 128 212 500 39 1 lease a 86 mr 143 AD tenancy 128S 465 881 868 396 damages e 87 419 new trial 17 M 83 412 Stat, fraud a 89 NY 616 72 461 int. damage 16 AC 46n sp'l. damage 189 NY 214 recovery 151AD 135S 176 910 419 partnership acctg. r 100 NY 386 17 NC 182n 424 easement a 87 NY 422 1 86 NY 253 damages 133 NY 347 LRA 87 334n 428 estate tail ,35 262 '8 AD 86 636 460 pers. trans" action case 2 do 37 28 AD 340 378 receivers 62 M 46 1 appeal case 6 a 89 NY 239 612 462 default judt case 2 r 85 NY 253 SCP 64 463 appeal case 3 a 85 NY 644 468 atenog. fees 9 AC 192n 20 NC 187n 472 substituted service a 84 NY 614 26 464 ICP 46 order vacating 31 39 8 AD 13 NC revival 2 AC 21 NO attachment 272 440 307 181 418 181n 18 NC 21 NC 356 176 474 objns laches a 84 NY 645 48 ISO 479 atty's lien case 1 r85NY s8NC 2CP SCP 8CP 284 308 365 146 353 481 false repre sentation i 7 AD 444 e 46 AD 553 2 LRA 154n competent ev. 69 AD 136 attach creditor 2 AC 15 irrelevant mAD 780 39 CP 271 485 sale fraud 2LRA 154n 488 defect title defect title d 120 AD 57 e 18 M 679 consent 23 M 550 good defense 128S 863 trust 144 AD 64 49 I supersedeas 13 CP 212 493 costs set-off 18 NC 350 8 CP 353 12 CP 91 18AC 281 u 499 parties d 36 M 92 502 discovery, * 84 NY 649 48 150 88 311 privilege 19AC 363n 39CP 39n incrimination 39CP 37n 506 lien f22 place trial 43 47 e70 41 AD authority 70 trustee 8M 16 163 245 79 80 460 .9 241 444 1025 508 foreclosure dSS f61 117 i security 65 99 41 AD 462 persnl. judgmt. d 152AD 821 137S 736 51 Unjuiiction da-mages 8 AC 468n 5 1 7 marine ins r 89 NY 559 525 indictment a 83 NT 462 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note criticised ; 1. limited ; e, explained ; o, overruled ; s, same case ; do, dissenting ooinion : p. parallel case ; q, questioned Vols. 22, 23 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Hun 527 redemption 26 35 40 e62 ejectment 116AD 638 619 53S 247 479 533 mandamus e28 24 M 2CP 3CP do 145 AD damages do 130 S 554 224 92 27 657 485 54 1 undue infl. 106M 174S 304 485 595 grant intent f 73 AD 217 description d 124 NY 29 M eSSA good title 185 24 M 629 233 339 216 318 encroachment 67 551 surplus 20 AD wife claim 10 NC 532 104 557 construction 60 138 559 sum. pro, r84Ny 287 563 sum, pro. r84NY ICP 3CP 4CP 8CP costs 12 NC 469 317 , 88 27 447 40 el3M 2 AC 8 AC construction e 130 AD 60 M S18 176 5n 87 169 598 resgination 30 M 600 attys' 29 43 3SS SAC 10 NO 18 NC 722 lien 526 485 334 85n 394d 30n VOL.23 I mtge. equities a 87 NY 457 463 270 474 47n 09 204 71 57 AD 5LRA priority 139 S valid lien 154AD 270 493 565 order arrest a 85 NY 73 20 NC ICP 2CP 502 247 224n 225 329 601 pleading 127 NY 659 61 I etkiiolders case 4 a 87 NY 622 124 NY 35 6 1 3 assigmnen case 1 r93NY 32 assessment cases f 22 614 616 566 sworn copy 106M 444 174S 685 568 injunction r84NY 153 14 NC 441 570 irregularity 45 247 final judgment 86 AD eosts 34M 1 AC 16AC 3CP 13 OP 21 NC 19A0 388 349 280 249n 254 101 352n 413n 573 assignment 13 NC 35 574 jurisdiction 23 5S1 123 666 584 set-oS 35 84 21 M lAC SAC SAC 3CP TCP 11 CP 18 NC. mtty. lien 112AD 18AG 142 247 718 195n 270 338n 98D 256 243 140 21 842 274 587 atty's lien 36CP 588 costs rSSNY 31 discretion 341 241 561 6 1 4 appeal case 2 m84NY appeal case 3 m84NY appeal case 4 m84NY 6 1 5 duress case 2 a 85 NY appeal case 8 iii84NY 6 1 6 appeal case 3 a 89 NY 672 67! 67' 615 672 692 1 2 equity aS9 NY e 24 24 AD 465 467 acquiescence 76 691 jury question 3 SS 453 sp'l issues 6 AC 270u new trial 137 NY 116 no exceptions 207 NY 576 1 9 misjoinder 67 238 86 75 pers. injuries r91NY S97NY s31 pleading 215 NY negligence 90 M 154 S 690 208 e3S 66 M adultery 59 AD 59AD 84 AD e77M 138 S 70 377 209 212 213 590 674 574 recrimination 12 NC 171 n 17 NC 245 pleadg. divorce 124AD 7SS justitication 193 NY 411 60 M 2UU 79 int. damages IS M 685 21 M 85 3 AC 321 ell7AD 771 82 extra allow. 24 551 31 382 43 25 discretion costs 131 S 307 not apply 73M 655 90 declaration 84 AD 101 case 4 a 84 NY 257 1 48 death neg, case 5 a 84 NY 1 49 contract case 3 r87NY 56 9 1 new trial d36 23 29 improvement 102 contract 121 AD 387 33 exceptions 172 AD 855 do 159 S 1093 37 atty. client r 87 NY 265 d30 d 96 NY I 19 lien 28 60 43 appeal a 89 NY 45 judgt. aS7NY 28 r33 42 22 NC 636 oredr 585 415 59 362 351 1 23 construe will a 88 NY 153 131 negligence 49 AD 467 11 AC 223n agent liable 50 intent ev, o47 e54 71 e25AD 110 AD e3SS 166S competent lOlM 120 166S assumption lOlM 75 521 492 283 442 679 722 724 123 724 122 60 character ev. a 85 NY 33 38 42 66 penalty a9NC 373 638 427 357 107 68 claims audit 34 4 71 loss device 129 S SI7 95 fr'd. transfer a 89 NY 644 99 atty's client 93 NY 529 quau. meruit 119AD 66 recovery 146 S 1045 power dismiss " 161 AD 615 1 02 exr. liable m 88 NY 384 28 500 4 LRA 532 I I 4 contrib. neg 476 1 50 reference a 84 NY 650 e34 3S7 398 4UU 5Cp 218 6 CP 419 extension 7 AC 175n Sling report 10 AC 291n 1 52 redemption 136AD 625 98 M 234 162 S 1066 privity of estate f 166 AD 685 34 M 122 NY 155 S f 92 M f 152 S liable 185AD 225Ny 173S 709 221 260 179 53 296 195 51 e62 AD 170 NY I LRA revocation f 82M f 143S 408 391 204n 224 550 436 622 414 120 95 M 160 S 15 665 34 notice d25 35 answer 60 64 not conclusive 66 314 408 SAD . 520 proper parties 11 NC 373 162 621 293 567 141 recovery 25 10 AC 114 NY Cond, sale 106 AD I46fr'd, fer case 8 a 87 NY 30 528 215n 45 166 trans- 624 194 1 48 attachment case 3 2 AC 363n 1 48 will transfer 1 59 death dam, r S4 NY 488 ordinance 167 AD 175 1 65 character a 86 NY 641 U AC 351n I69"exact cost" 6M 291 special value ~6M 285 do 134S 1018 1 73 injunction r86NY 1 76 discovery 223 trust limita- tion a 88 NY 92 74 301 e89 300 18 NC 294 IS NC 301 300 264 Stat, limitat 41 209 111 NY 211 170S . 545 intervention 203NY 521 proceedings 183AD 41 266 encroachmt. 13 322 e 122 NY d31M damages f 12NC 159 NY public nuisance 19AC 159n 19Ar; ia2a 153n 213 230 referee port re- 20 30 5CP SAC affidavit e2g M 443 62 328 446 362 eoi 185 27 79 bond alter 37 698 1 88 lex loci »67NY 84 AD 1 93 legacy e30 199 shipping a 87 NY 337 565 190 200 libel a 87 NY 231 pleading corapl't 10 NC gn demurrer 6311 471 2 1 3 construe will r 84 NY 89 2 1 8 new trial . 3 AD 24 AD eSOAD 11 M 5A.0 assignee 52 AD do 01 AD i oinder do 124AD appl. order 123AD 1 211 NY denials 133AD assignment 136AD nullity u 406 97 249 116 82 220 791 8 231 624 30 53 55 40 AD e49AD 7M 39M relief e31 73 new trial 83 M 145 S 156n 246 102 665 398 308 305 142 146 262 507 452 233 forselosure r 84 NY 47I 237 title eonetm r 88 NY r 106 U8 22 M 6CP 7CP 2 LRA 273 review 30 89 lU 159 77 207 274 nuisance 60 • 523 277 erect'n piers a 87 NY 204 11 NC 237n extension street <( 100 NY 06 279 neg, damage 88 NY 13 282 sum remdy 117 476 15n 52 3 95 321 348 588 241 sale sample 13 AC 225n good quality 105M 654 damage 308 332ii 244 neg rSONY 20 NC 249 referees rept * 88 NY 647 28 36 appeal c41 11 e 49 .17 sp'l proceedings 40 76 64 92 251 affidavit r85NY e7AD 19 NC 4CP 7CP 313 82 411n 279 379 255 judgt credr •91 NY 20 AD 78 A D ■ f 164 AD fl49S 641 259 33 148 490 256 stkholders r 89 NY 334 109 US 381 260 divorce r 86 NY 18 27 70 dower findings 10 AC 147n disqualification 10 NC 72 "children" 177AD 12"4 163 S 734 49 SIM 6 AC authonty 61 M 47 6 284 compensat a 80 NY 508 51 169 18HC 368 sub r/amages f 19 NC 261n 289'foreclosure a 84 NY 105 18 NC ISln 29 I bondholdrs case6 mS4 NY 190 f 88 NY 1 director power 14 NC 256 293 ptnrs acctg case 3 a 90 NY 294 appeal case 7 »89NY 580 617 294 judgt title case 8 r 87 NY 92 295 insurance case 3 a 90 NY 382 225 612 260 299 trust a 89 NY 28 16 NC error new trial 12 NC 276n 4 LRA 144 307 extend time 15 AC 347n 349n ISAC 162n, 153n relief 61 M 403 return answer 106M: 358 174S 501 3 1 2 appeal a99lfy 60S ^^^.^^^i^TIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *. dismissed; n, note; <, criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, dissentini opinion: n, parallel case: q, questioned N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Hun Vols. 23, 24 3 1 7 removal a 86 NY 149 322 plege stock ■d 91 AD 285 327 aasesBtnent m 85 NY 526 16 NC 291 332 dam proof 630 535 171 256 409 (18 410 636 660 199 134 384 64 361 789 498 754 904 24 42 45 67 53 AD €8 AD 73 AD 3M 14 M 116 NY 8CP 13 CF 17 CP 160 ft indemnity 68 M 124 S 132S cond. precedent 14SAD 434 erroneouR 154 S 580 judic determind f 169 AD 52 334 construction 30 173 18 M 278 31 M 397 e 33 M 523 legacy change 56M 426 339 certiEcate r 88 NY 410 16 AD 622 receiver powers 19 NC 3691 350 aggrieved r 85 NY 53( 19 NC 122 35 I police comr'a 31 210 40 55; 74 253 98 NY 335 353 decree final case 1 a 87 NY 572 7 CP 163 353 covenant case 2 a 88 NY 240 355 husb. credrs case 4 a 84 NY 438 13 AC 116n 356 contempt d 34 238 e 36 381 48 589 95 NY 493 7 CP 331 367 ptnra acotg a 87 NY 613 372 prom note e90 117 6 LEA «99n 39 I injunction e 67 187 17 CP 412 393 Stat frauds: 72 461 402 discretion 69 622 pers. transaction 29 AD ■ 43 S8 75 77 406 affidavit 75 AD 636 26 M 2 17 AC 3l8n, 17 AC 319n 4 1 receiver U AC 382n 4l2 jurisdictioD 14 AD 509 who may eject 21 NC 26n 4 1 4 pers trans. ^6 274 618 419 56 115 250 189 369 31 33 aa d40 35 AD loo AD jurisdiction 33 23 42 91 incompetent 87 M 405 1 149 S 770 397 fraud 25 478 7 AD 520 42 M 647 joint ownership 12 AC 35gn 484 costs r88NY 36 32 3 AC 9 AC 490 pers. a 88 NY 75 494 cred'ratlrg. 126 NY 191 18 M 458 preference ILEA 184 fact question 4LRA 537 notice 7S M 466 138 S 648 498 payt defense 57 recovery 72 AD 420 marriage a 89 NY 286 424judgmt credr 3b M 8CP 12 CP surplus 130 S 362 65 143 790 43 1 revera error E 23 440 jurisdiction 41 jury trial 12 NC 11 CP 372 389 86 439 jurisdiction 23 432 41 372 47 11 CP 70 86 445 flae repre su a 89 NY 299 a 114 US S58 13 NC 51 449 fact'queation 73 616 Qom. damages 11 AC 452 costa e4C 81 116 S 1 AC superseded 63 M 64n 629 363 785 19 187 454 instructions a 85 NY 75 28 45 lien for freight 35 97 473 neg. maatei H 24 496 i 25 310 478 beneficiary 60 158 53 151 74 366 2 LRA 163q 5 LRA 96n 97n benefit fund 636 88 486 abatement 198 383n 3l2n injury 264 213 75 336 84 304 relief 37 atadiiication 1.36AD 361 equitable lien W9AD 329 f 160 S 635 enforce lien 1S4S 275 509 insurance m 89 NY 592 91 NY 416 5 1 3 cond. sale 25 528 vendor remedy 10 AC 226n title 15 NC 394n 5 1 7 Stat limitn IAD Ob' 524 appeal a 87 NY usury case 1 a 91 NY 17 NC 2 LRA conclusive case 3 24 578 interest rate 25 ma usury i»2 130 q 86 NY 403 583 discharge a 85 NY 645 5S4 pol. power 91 M 407 638 324 431n 646 526 pera. injury r 89 NY 627 530 reformation case 3 15 CP 66n 53 1 claim coata oaae 6 m 85 NY 523 533 death dam case 3 a 86 NY 401 534 appeal case 3 * 85 NY 643 535 forbearance 57 79 f 65 AD 49 M 39 M 130 NY 173 531 263 400 1.02 420 553 jury questn 5M 348 infer fraud i:OoNY 265 559 divesting e 19 M 567 bonds execution 4 AC 350n valid obligation 193 NY 493 pledge security f 161 AD 131 568 mandamus rSSNY 641 573 interest a 88 NY 184 f 26 163 26 548 Jam. jury quea 41 AD HAG 119 88 70d 596 appeal •86 NY 620 601 affidavit 34 477 603 true test 122AD 264 6 1 I preference a 87 NY 578 53 14 6 1 5 conatruction 33 213 6 1 8 waiver stay 38 522 84 AD 621 7 AC 277n 625 sale credit a 90 NY 37 628 notices a 87 NY 9M 632 rehet r89NY rllNC rlOM trademark 11 NC 379 567 590 293 86 27 862 647atat. limitatn a 85 NY 629 d 36 104 47 641 133 NY 517 648 judgt. Con tract 12 AD 477 far'n judgt. fraud 46 M 351 new judgment 199NY 59 65 1 parol trust r89NY 36 61 79 UNO equity 147 S 85 M 352 51 100 497 53 654 535I 663 books ev case 5 a 88 NY 334 665 appeal case 7 * 84 NY 674 667 appeal case 5 a 90 NY 457 669 covenant s 29 476 19 M 228 687 certiorari r 101 NY 322 693 jurisdiction 36 358 112 NY 583 16 NC 156 698 assessment a 85 NY 307 VOL.24. I surrogate pwr 36 501 4M 394 36 M 1 evidence 48 386 e 82 172 1 2 diacretion a 94 NY 27 28 346 e 29 538 15 jud. opinions a 88 NY 487 HAD 395 second verdict 53 AD 649 73 AD 307 competent ev. 17 NC 502n507r 1 9 limit liability a 90 NY 26; 27 14t 24 leave atty. e 35 505 51 606 3 SS 333 1 AC 77n 8 AC 86n 10 NC 393n 27 deed ev. 187NY 106 presumption 19A0 381 32 pers transac. 26 275 35 505 1 LRA 464n 37 incomp ev. r 88 NY 398 31 31 40 injunction m87NY 627 88 NY 298 43 privileged s 28 430 e 46 462 464 17S NY 68 ev. physician U7AD 551 51 scope author 19 AD 533 compena dam. 50 AD 112 tort 34 M 514 58 estoppel 25 471 7 AD 585 5 SS 243 amendment 19AC SOln not final 163 AD 59 ABBREVIATIONS: a c. criticised; 1, limited; affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, t, explained ; o, overruled ; s. same case ; do, 66 certiorari *85NY 34 36 S3 e86 92 43 AD 51 AD 81 AD 5M 16 M 152 NY 17 NC 20 NC 49n evidence 120 AD not final 120 AD 628 322 693 378 518 352 202 200 122 58 317 531 470 45n 653 653 75 law remedy d 25 271 41 M 666 ostoppel 77 AD 120 remove sum. pro 14 AC l.'J7n 78 satiafaction 53 d65 do 94 AD 3M el5M 19 M 138 NY 394 494 233 416 221 176 238 8f appeal not 4M 47 28 M 552 new cause actn. 147 S 194 i 101 AD 754 84 fr'd transfer d 48 413 do 48 416 13 CP 373 87 mtgee poasn 16AC 438n 439n 90 replevin 10 M 179 93 counterclaim d 53 627 demand 22 AD 310 f 119 NY 61 99 coats 35 44 c 48 183 15 NC 478 1 1 negligence a 89 NY 219 92 152 1 04 prox, cause 54 627 109 w^do wallow 1 620 31 169 609 399 401 280 411 135n 174 175 42 r89NY e31 AD 102 AD 38 M e41M e42M IS M 49 M 14 AC 124 S _ . . h. furniture 118 AD f 119AD money had 126AD conversion 67M commission G7M 210 NY 124 S 516 761 442 42 42 87 621 I I 4 sole owner 195 NY 144 1 1 6 fr'd repns. s 32 470 1 2 assignment 39 546 title contingent 46 267 17 NC 354 22 NC 297u S CP 324 1 23 assignment e 35 266 e 39 540 41 325 65 571 revorsed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, queitioncd Vol. 24 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Hun 20 M 14NC 15 NC 22 NC 6CP 627 450 168 103 405 127 indemnity a 22 NC 476n 1 30 limitation 49 444 64 132 oral a^reemt a 90 NY 280 \ 37 fr'd dam, case 8 r 90 NY 272 1 38 rr. damascea case5 r 88 NY 351 13 NC 433 Sep estate case 7 a 90 NY 250 13 NC 433 ad'l findings case 11 1 34 683 139 pers. injury case 3 a 90 NY •'i58 £ire insur. case 6 a 89 NY 315 1 40 dividends case 9 a 85 NY 486 141 ejectment ease 4 a 88 NY 668 1 42 neg. damage case 1 a 88 NY 146 s 8 NC 41 services case 11 36 a 89 NY 108 1 43 deposition 30 36 f 8 M 459 3 CP 340 evidence 17 AC 77n 1 45 inspect bks. • 87 NY 625 15 AC 218 1 49 by-laws amendment 31 53 76 AD 156 sick benefits 20AC 53n 1 55 surety objn a 88 NY 286 1 57 earnings I AC 169n 159 wife liable 126S 934 141AD 813 1 6 1 creditr. suit 66 AD 167 1 62 discovery e29 37 70 e50AD do 74 AD 111 AD q ISM I02M 6 AC II AC 168S 139 287 540 684 352 315 414 77 326d 263 451 1 68 guaranty - a 88 NY 503 preference 105 AD 588 6 CP 428 1 72 extra allow. aOO NY 30 24 652 SAD 24 costs eiLpenses 125 NY 111 I 75 discharge e 35 206 35 M 131 163 NY 408 6 LRA 272n fact proof 62 AD 466 vendee arbiter ILEA 646 I 77 cross exam 56 223 damage proof 61 26 hostility ev. 89 NY 246 131 NY 329 1 8 1 practice d48 315 16 M 25 15 CP 4n polling jury 69M 418 irreeularity 127S 580 I 8l2 bar a 85 NY 617 29 628 atty's rights o 35 506 16 M 660 18 M 44 8 AC 83n 10 NC 393n 18 NC 34n 3 CP 148 13 CP 36 1 84 excess dam, a 89 NY 628 48 301 M 659 excess verdict f 164 S 168 damages f 180AD 564 168S 328 1 87 quiet title a 94 NY 624 40 37 vesting 132 NY 125 194 new trl. est 129 AD 835 195 revocation 56 630 196 lex loci a 91 NY 32 M 124 460 1 99 report comrs * 85 NY 489 32 290 41 503 provisions 16 NO 399 202 jurisdiction a 84 NY 622 77 270 17 NC 100 19 NC 411 207 guardian a 40 AD 678 18AC 54n father's right 139 S 689 2 1 after born i child I a 89 NY 555I revocation 120 AD 289 2 1 6 findings r 91 NY 625 22 1 new promise 30 AD 360 224 costs d 32 AD 353 10 AC 378 226legacy charee d30 73 23 1 legacy charge e 76 600 8 AC 162n conversion 47 M 40S 234 appeal case 2 * 85 NY 648 case 5 appeal a 87 NY 639 case 6 relPase a 90 NY 333 case 7 probate will a87 NY 514 6 CP 343 B CP 436 235 contract case 3 a 90 NY 423 ease 4 neg. damages a 88 NY 203 case 10 appeal a 88 NY 641 lOl NY 215 236 order case 9 r86NY SIS 238 contract a 87 NY 137 241 draft m89NY e34 412 391 246 contempt 27 304 29 302 250 canal judgt. 16 AC 123a 255 poundage a 86 NY 641 f 29 286 e 95 NY 468 2 CP 236 5 CP 294 257 attachment e26 27 28 113 36 467 44 63 4 AC 346n 2 CP 390 280 fact proof a 89 NY 629 14 M 432 263 compensatD r 91 NY 265 27 262 265 usury a 90 NY 110 28 AD 516 23 NC 402n 270 forgery d 32 181 d 95 NY 629 272 com. law marriage 15 AC 4n ISn competency 17 NC SOln 275 heirs assets e48 52 18 NC 148 277 bonds notice e 12 M 264 99M 135 163 S 344 28lpost'd check a 90 NY 678 9 AC 216n due course 103M 241 170S 14 286 title 26 390 d 52 226 95 M 45 158 S 543 presumption 71 M m? 130 S 334 293 delivery ev. e 111 NY 304 164 NY 552 » 9 NC 371 S LRA 121n 297 bondholders 35 100 delegate trust 2M 399 liabilitv d 147AD 880 133S 102 304 estoppel a 89 NY 637 62 AD 115 f 167 AD 20fl f 86 M 129 f 149 S 150 152 S 867 307 commissions m 87 NY 277 2S 631 73 55 97 M 216 105M 426 106M 118 23 NC 37 162S 859 174S 418 175S 601 3 1 7 executon 56M 450 d453 322 contribution 61 AD fil6 f 161 AD 830 liability 146 S 968 allegation 146 S 9R8 161 AD 830 325 commissions 28 631 9 AD 293 31 AD 41 103 AD S22 33 M 164 64M 547 328 pers. trans action e 30 358 consent 35 126 333 construe wit a 15 NC 122n 33 337 mandamus 44 676 audit f 145 S 693 I 84 M 186 340 judgment ' case 2 a 89 NY 638 claim audit case 3 114 NY 324 179 NY 248 341 expresstrust case 2 a 88 NY 69 3 LRA 541 carrier neg- case 5 a 88 NY residuary casel2 aSSNY 645 22 N C 298n 342 title in fee case 2 r 88 NY 228 343 order case 8 6 CP 153 344 appeal case 3 * 85 NY 648 order case 4 r 87 NY 10 345 set-o£f a 85 NY 628 40 374 22 M 385 159 NY 448 347inform, and belief 51 100 67 AD 368 6M 612 9 AC 170 182n 350 open com- mission r 86 NY 646 JONC 324n 351 new referee 134 NY 322 106 AD 88 353 new trial 33 213 irregularity 88 312 82 AD 595 4M 433 53 M 116 second examn. e 29 M 675 7 AC 282 limitation 125 NY 202 5M 486 sup. pro. 65 M 622 355 insur. policy 26 290 irregularity 10 M 448 husb, creditors 13 AC . 116n exemptions 70 M 277 139 S 62 360 dividends r 91 NY 496 25 440 divisibility 58 AD 679 14 NO 211 363 Stat, limitar tions a 89 NY 456 3 LRA 396 367 assessment a 86 NY 396 372 bailee neg. a 90 NY 4 378"layingout' * 85 NY 459 a 86 NY 437 382 attachment case 10 r 87 NY 141 13 NC 38 IS NO 341 349 7 CP 290 414 383 certificate case 4 r 90 NY 38 case 6 discharge r 90NY 33 r 117 US 559 case 6 certiorari a 93 NY 97 case 8 lien 18 NC 39n case 10 indictment a 86 NY 381 case 12 burglary r 86 NY 359 384 damages case 11 a 88 NY 527 386 guaranty 36 59 14 M 321 127 NY 425 construction IISAD 79 395 slander re- quest a 138 NY 522 35 587 e 11 AD 606 40 I consideratn a 91NY 381 110 AD 548 H and w.contract 18AC 23 405division fence 152 408 discharge 26 261 4 1 3 audit 82 607 66M 323 93 M 265 157 S 974 f 159 S 247 judl, discretion 123 S 408 county charge 173 AD 352 422 recovery 29 82 2 LRA 627n vol; payment 40 M 170 426 authority e 52 448 53 208 436 construction 123AD 112 440 judgment 46 443 15 OP 245 646 8 443 joint debtors a 92 NY 639 e 26 176 31 391 34 291 2 CP 114 surety 135S 651 liability 76M , , 554 contribution 206Ny 187 448 waiver 67 AP 73 2 M 70 249 7 CP 419, 422 45 1 notice 26 *3 ^ 118AD 15 NC 206n estoppel d71 416 3 SS 506 20 NC 114n 457 defense 52 326 adv. possession 27 AD 417 demurrer 133AD 859 461 lunacy de- fense 12 M 200 11 AC 444n impeachment 20 NC 284 153AD 485 liability 138S 253 f 212 NY 282 444 464 bar a 87 NY 25 38 34 357 intent 10 NC 320 467 relief 48 414 80 57 70M 466 file mtge. 128S 1110 cloud on title 127 NY 652 472 commr's highway 24 29 e34 40 50 67 negligence 2 AD 460 187 143 196 95 626 24 478 title 41 180 106 NY 287 2 LEA 526n release fee 105 AD 421 11 NC 285D redeem 126S . 1058 no estate in land 142AD 21 lee vested 149AD 742 134 S 193 486 appeal case 2 a 89 NY 637 487 foreclosure case 7 , 93 Nt 301 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; e, criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; 0, overruled; s, same case; do, djsscnting opinion; p, parallel os'j; q, questioned N. T. Supreme Court Reports — Hun Vols. 24, 25 488 prom. Bote ■case 3 a 88 NY review caae 10 objection 662 stay 5 SS 102 121 a 90 NY 298 184AD 619 caje 1 NC 293 172S 378 r 87 NY NC 298d r lig US 648 appeal 3 CP 874 605 fact question 119 AD 168 case S ise 3 vacate order stockliolder 90 NY 675 64M 284 a i 19 32 19 650 nulla bona 140 AD 489 injunction return cases 124 3 e 67 308 « 91 493 545 discretion s 9 NC 393 16 NC 236 607 489 damages 548Bp.prfmance case 9 d 30 231 r « 26 612 foreclosure d ^° *® 492 taxation d 56 case 6 remedies a 88 NY 578 122 NY 30 329 21 NC 166 553 penalty 9CP 266 6 494 contrib neg 12 CP 220 r case 1 a 88 NY 42 662 city mob a 96 NY 495 reareument e 50 AD f 25 310 e 110 AD riot 495 execution 188NY case 4 a 86 NY return 20 NC 496 recitals a 90 NY do 47 499 trespass a 91 NY 503 interpleader 578 discharge 2 AC 228n 233n from arrest •ROBfl ■ 27 506 aubflseimprismt o44 7 a 90 NY 77 11 CP 268 590 detention 617 a 91 NY 190 12 AD 57 1 evidence 116 a 99 NY 299 50 575 98 r 108 NY 5 1 4 surplus a 90 NY 286 19 NC 104 110 592 audit nio • a86NY 5 1 o_ nuisance g2 -93 M 157 S SI 9 relief a 90 NY 44 524 bar 142 AD new cause 6S foreclosure •do 214 NY 113 '^^ 602 order ,., case 1 *=*' * 89 NY syi case 2 eori recording act 526 intent 35 receiver 49 7 AD 52 AD 15 CP receiver title 602 69 AD 361 , 1 AC lS7n ^-, - lien sale °''SfW ■46 M 287 a 89 NY case 5 warranty rOONY 622 case 6 warranty r90NY 75 case 9 585 guaranty 262 269 m 90 NY too 3 12NC Sou master neg. case 12 -case 9 aeencv a 88 NY 225 a 91 NY .529 appeal case 1 *86NY case 9 amendment a 89 NY 27 2LRA «48 19 NC 74 78 warehouse- 650 assessment man r 89 NY 90 NY 430 la NC u 137 NY 286 80 written^ words___ 653 Parol ev 281 114 AD 89 6 651 620 prox. result g56 usury 511 case 9 .„„„ 626 a 90 NY 303 excepted (•««> 19 259 208 NY 479f^*eny a 86 NY 365 565 cond. preced 624 injunction 663 * 86 NY 44 25 42 453 14 AC ICP 4CP HCP 17 CP law remedy 15 M 41 M relief do 118AD d83 do4AD 207 617 627 507 242 185 692 627 injunction r87NY 14 632 physician 232 35 AD 113 84 M f 145 S A^ 60 f conviction 543 ease 2 a 86 NY case 8 460 675 604 coQ recoromg act 2S^a89NY 641 case 3 327 feond" r90NY case 4 363 603 220 1C30 44 IAD 39fi e 41 AD J b 51 AD 6SS 7M J lOM '33 M '538 lien law 603 laying street 49 M a 90 NY 336 case 3 ■d 26 139 a 90 NY 18 NC 69 case 5 f . i I u . J construe will S4I stockholder, ni 88 NY 1 90 NY 353 220 338 388 101 i> I 455 604 pers trans- newpleadng. action 750 1 2 guaranty 655 larency 93 NY 273 oaseS a 86 NY 376 , I 7 covenant case 6 90 NY 594 defiling woman 12 NC 43 070 657 pleading 264=^„^«12 164n 3 9NC 424 ;6NC 314 " ""*^ 65 ICP 3 CP 1 Cp 4CP ^Qg nuisance gg4 cai,e 4 "^ 92 NY 916 12 denial 33 9NC 658!forgery 8 AC' ""."iSeaw'NY prac. medicme ^^J-^vJ- 117 AD 650 552 128 US 714 case 5 148 S c 163 AD massage 102M 168S 303 103 18 NC 200 202 designate venue 11 AC316n317r 637 assessment d63 AD 331 61 M 21 1 AC 18 NC IPPNS 469 order 131 NY 18AC 167n. 168 -89 NY 19 NO .. 197NY 67 case 9 291 damages m88NY 29342 186 73 32 86 NY 369 30? 264 252 228 249 432 10 367 303 112 538 relief title a 86 NY 27 20 NC 22 NC 401n 575 272 405 635amendmeni 409n.412n.416n 65 AD 421 *1" case 6 stockholder a 90 NY 14 NO case 10 *87NY 87 443n 635 640 practice 659 certiorari 88 179 case 1 a 92 NY 306 642 appeal time ease 5 a90Nir 546 usury 27 388 r 92 NY 34 38 534 ease 11 5 CP 145 a 88 NY 17 9 CP 127 28 43 47 indirection 33 124 11 M 12s s 10 NC 261 12 NC 190 645 amendment 206 560 bill partic 555 case 2 33 a 87 NY 272 556 1 CP 17 464 568 ease 6 order 411 a 87 NT 179 518 case 9 "655 pOfs injuries 647 r 90 NY 26 446 case 13 384 lewdness 36n a 88 NY 192 202n 6n 66 1 ejectment case 3 190 a 90 NY 672 19 8 12 NO 2 ease 9 forecloaure defect eompl't a 90 NY ~ 144 176 1 LKA 518 M. 300 60 presumption .2M 303 case 9 338 20 M 193 a 90NY 44 M 411 caae 11 CP 96 will trust r89NY 4 fun. expenses _ case 12 308 I 96 26 AD 318 62 AD 8 li 73 2 254 2 AD 35 AD 40 AD 15 M 18 M 22 M 10 AC 6 authority 92 NY 6 1 f'dlt. release 552 case 2 a 89 NY 136 _ _ competent ev case 3 37 340 sheriff escape r 88 NY 629 1 3 distribution case 12 29 17 stockholder r 88 NY 129 20 quasi oorpn's ?J4e«cty 1^^62^Y— ■ 23 M 147 NY 43 AD r88NY 3LRA case 2 23 surety execution 43 AD 97e 103 32 appeal 9 U d21NC uity 33wives liability f^oS t^-v- 38 223 *'"*"'' VOL. 25. 138 3 LRA 146 372 16 4 LRA 146 252 eq, conversion 496 18 NC 29 604 5 CP 443 140 case 12 65 trust acetg. 457n 29 549 315 57 97 e 310 338 351n iquit 26 M 63 receiver case 2 r90NY ^^° 64 stockholder 623 36 construction " '"""'"'"^ «" |§|a90NY QQiT case 4 "*" Co. Court no II .• e7AD 03 allegations for iurv 61 '" -—■'--■' 143 AD 128 S 15 AD 40AD 50 AD 112 AD notice 83 AD 2M 4M reversible error 10 M 13 AC waiver 129 AD 44 indorsers 31 29 AD 538 354 602 169 481 364 237 199 618 345 ?2 r82'M' .5! 144 s 536 148 -Q 404 DO pers. transac- tion 144 case 10 459 r 90 NY 363 445 549 65 69 „„ __, „„, 69 surplus t 66M 594 92d^27 72 attachment 244 309 practice 419 69 76 liability 49 bonds acctg. 19 M a 89 NY 678 _ . 78 parties 54 pleading a 93 NY 35 117 16 M 25 AD 220 authority 47 AD 109 20 NC special damages 71 AD 342 86 appeal 83 AD 33 a 90 NY 20AC 164n impeachment 9 I contract void 12 AC 116n 65 AD 590 evidence error 8 M 320 114 NY 414 9 M 426 5 AC 385 57 injunction 10 AC 325 39 AD 647 19 NO 77 cash payment 59 entries ev 123AD 24 case 7 subscription a 90 NY 309 129 AD 337 case 8 certificate memoranda 140 S 467 a 91 NY . 451 345 555 S72 75 280 652 .^.ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified: *. dismissed- n nnt,- . enticised: 1. limited: e. explained: o, overruled: e. same case; do, dissenting opinion: D? oarile! «« f q. i«'sS2ned Vol. 25 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Hun 97 intervention 79 4US e 4 AD 56 1 1 indorser a 90 N Y 530 2 LKA 70] 107 demurrer 47 2RS t I I certiorari f 26 119 3S 46 106 NY 67 166 NY 170 7M 924 14M 177 8 10 NC 418 I I 6 parol e33 572 I 1 9 reference caBb 2 r 88 NY 45a 40 76 case 5 promissory note a 88 NY case 13 trustee r 88 NY case 8 law action 83 M 120 libel 164 S 122 cond. SI scription a 93 NY e3 AD. receiver 19 NC 74 190 662 126 367r I 78 nee. party 39 266 landlord 101 NY 161 179 30 mandamus 147 I 34 aherifr fees 43 609 8b 54 adl. allowance 9M 106 I 88 fr'd transfei case 1 rOONY case 2 irregular r90NY 32 396 1 24 usury a 91 NY 43 1 3 1 certiorari 12 NC 65n 1 36 contract r 94 NY 146 p 25 559 1 46f act question a 89 NY 376 32 416 safe appliances 108 AD I 50 answer d33 1 52 claim town 91 eSl AD 1 55 denial 38 e43 36 AD do 36 AD pleading e97NY 122 NY 3SA 24 M 121 28 458 264 310 675 580 376 282 107 456 15 NC 266 279n I 59 assent r88NY 29 211 130 1 63 neg. coserv't e21M 1 67 surety 36 8CP SLRA 1 7 1 asset. 64 AD 459 479 392 765n 560 377 162 92 1 89 assault case 3 a 87 NY 31 case 5 gift a 88 NY 16 NC case 8 foreclosure a 91 NY case 13 prom, notes a 90 NY ( case 14 pers. injuries r 91 NY ISO exemptions case 1 42 M gerv. publn case 11 r 88 NY, 2LRA mandamus case 13 C89NY 218 dedication 14AC 263n liNC 269n 5 CP 407 223 acceptance 38 362 mutuality 60 266 not precluded 11 NC 48u 227 inventory case 1 a 88 NY 434 229 eq. conversD case 1 561 429 325 167 264 r85NY 15 NC 3CP 7CP 39T 216 640 11 I9i prohib writ case 7 •89 NY 4 10 NC 16 NC 2CP certiorari case 14 a 88 NY slONC 152 37 242 180 193 an'l report case 2 and 3 1 89 NY r4NC case 8 strike out slONC case 13 demurrer • 9NC 1 94 costs e32 AD 36 AD 122 444n 107 352 585 195 motion rem- edy 85 173 1 99 costs appeal o 27 113 148 NY 291 201 dividend 22 AD 432 209 NY 403 earnings 154 NY 196 206 assume risk mSQNY 71 sllNC 13 NC 470 132 322 439 2 1 negligence a 93 NY 481 2 AC 177n 2 1 4 bill partic. 44 AD 73 AD 76 AD 99 AD 2M 96 M 4CP 160 S t 161 S 419 323 392 471 112 503 258 71 639 438 46 e47 56 e67 e86 AD e9S AD 4M 13 AC e95NY e 114 NY 180 NY 10 NC 18 NC 23 NC subrogation 5LK.A ause 120 254 show 1 AC tax costs e «9 AD 243 pwrs. limited 171S 1037 260 title to land d 35 161 abandon street 54 566 6M 202 36 M 93 13 AC 240n24]D construction 230 marriage ev case 4 r 88 NY 546 17 NC 505n 508n 232 trademark d 93 NY 64 8 AC 64n e 122 NY 73 234 party deft, e 32 AD 141 3rd pers. costs 1 AC 292n 6 AC 47 e 49 237 costs 31 bar 45 32 leave to issue execution 353 57 61 92 SAD 7M 54 M d 107 NY s9NC 9CP 17 CP presumption 39 CP 42 571 621 51 340 219 304 276 315 95 336 378 239 limitations a 93 NY 37 e71 75 28 AD 14 AC 14 NC 15 NC 19 NC 20 NC 22 NC 17 398 531 522 92 209n 338, 346, 349 353 402 407 245 160 332n 246r.r. corp lease r 93 NY 609 e34 71 14 NC 19 NC SLRA competitn ILRA 435 281 249 207 372 289n r. r. 861n 25 I prepond. ev 40 271 374 545 609 510 161 566 344 345 669 65 90 316 112 113 289n 169S ' 'and' ' 18'2AD 182AD 183AD 170S 170S 956 r' ' 550' 555 370 429 626 305 amendment 79 466 appeals 150AD 546 308 allegation 8 AC 382d 309 ultra vires case 1 r 93 NY 266 case 10 limitations r 91 NY 203 3 1 evidence case 2 r 90 NY 549 case 4 fact question 262 execution voidable rSSNY 611 3 30 649 e33 14 e 43 206 128 AD 48 268 injunction 264 283 192 665 153n 97 164 72 42 e82 20 M 41 M 14 AC 2CP 4CP 166S relief do 118AD 916 invalid evid. 174S 749 272 revers. error a 91 NY 293 e 65 423 15 NC 206n 17 NC 414 422n 275 penalty verd 30 AD 81 AD 492 23 M 403 279 costs statute 30 62 AD 92 AD IS AC taxing cost 61 M 247 199 81 34 612 280 exceptions 26 354 282 surety a 92 NY 391 290 eq. set-off 42 75 19 M 685 293 wife title a 96 NY 398 43 28S 19 AD S50 fraud fruits 19 NC 298aervice SAC 180 NY 243 861n 232 30 1 claim notice e 42 175 5 AC 310n 303 review c 109 AD 183 NY 637 232 r91NY case S certiorari e29 case 11 construction 37 332 126 58 3 1 I neg. death case 4 a 88 NY case 7 eontrib. neg. rSSNY case 11 extra work a 92 NY case 12 construct on 27 a 37 446 348 368 3 1 2 stenog. fees case 5 a 90 231 case 12 negligence r 91 NY 32 3 1 3 certiorari case 11 s 10 NC 169 3 1 4 parol ev. case 2. r99NY s40 s48 ease 3 pleading r89NY 186 3 I 5 misjoinder case 1 a 94 NY 22 3 1 6 ehge. route case 2 a 89 NY 442 case 3 grade crossing. a 89 NY 3 1 8 review case 4 46 ease 6 appeal ' ♦88 NY 442 324 110 3 1 9 allowance case 2 32 SSS case 8 amended return 70 52 80 34 118AD 610 32 1 possession e 36 627 e 41 454 S3 549 d 65 AD 287 292 34 M 438 447 49 M 34 legislative power 90 179 ruling surrogate 17 NC 78 325 mandamus a 86 NY 512 332 wife's int. a 90 NY 492 26 291 e 30 623 husband fundi » 102 NY 276 336 bankruptcy p30 319 e30 321 stay 6M 487 341 simple int. 51 266 29 M 264 344 extension e 63 AD 568 48 M 24 5 1.RA 209n consideraton 1 . 4AD 75: 350 baggage neg r 94 NY 278 35 31 355 eq. relief p2S 36 30 AD 26 M 6CP 7CP demurrer 43 AD 37 1 order a 89 NY 376 practice 27 31 32 33 35 AD 5CP 6CP 4 1 4 surety leave 36 581 43 AD 97 26 M 640 7 CP 169 4 1 8 foreclosure r 93 NY 488 37 262 423 indictment 417 581 354 640 244 169 97 618 436 611 172 159 226 131 103 112 39 1 compet ev. p 25 436 84 AD 418 19 M 168 395 attaebment c35 e39 do 55 85 4 AD 15 AD 16 M 11 NC 9CP 100 s 477 327 387 592 384 163 1d6 178 252 1026 tort damages 115AD 607 131 S 594 jurisdiction 164 S 372 injury property 99M 500 398 injunction 170 AD 421 156 S 227 405 neg. master r 101 NY 395 28 315. damages 60 74 409 surplus 38 4ia e20AD 64 eSM 11& q2SM 27 36 M 255 2 LEA 177n motion costs 147 NY 675 lien judgment 19 NC 140 4 1 1 jurisdiction 2LRA 177n a 90 NY 678 S3 277 43AD 474 n 430 leave tc sue 29 253 f 18M 607 SAC 39611 6 AC 2o: -206n 15 NC 433 18 NC 150n 434 assessment m 89 NY 648 437 re-entry 22 AD 528 trespasser 21 NC 311n 438 divisibility a 94 NY 204 68 AD 579 441 attachment e 25 S77I1 9 CP 171 15 CP 223 445 assignment d 47 314 449 award ease 2 a 90 NY 390 cases undue influence a 88 NY 367 22 NC 264 450 check cases r91NY cases sheriff fees mSSNY 74 429 451 damages case 2 r 94 NY 16 cases mdictment a 90 NY 498 453 exemption case 7 r 87 NY 668 454 interpleader case 4 r 90 NY 234 44 69 455 damages case 3 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d. distinguished; I. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; c, criticised; 1. limited; e. explained; o, overruled; s, same case: do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q, questiouco N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Hun Vols. 25, 26 mSSNY 32 293 254 456 defacto 42 275 publio polioy « 60 335 puniahment e 115 NY 620 23 NC 471 Bale franchise 153 NY 158 injury election 5SM 352 118 AD 620 compet. ev. I22AD 353 eligible do 196NY 252 burden proof 139 S 379 show right 134AD 776 469 waiver 5 SS 243 473 ap'I. verdict' e 148 NY 100 475 newparty do 31 460 49 27 50 AD 135 43 M 648 529modificatiou 2B 361 e36 351 46 110 71 524 92 84 465 14 M 513 SCP 65 537 revocation a 88 NY 377 lOOM 228 uiiiiteration 135AU 747 570 omisBion C3. clerk 30 176 e 12 M 496 574 tru9t power a 88 NY 179 18 NC 30 i postpone vestng 167 AD 160 153 S 212 577 attachment 33 441 242 97 n 171 384n mS9NY e25 29 SAC 9CP 14 NC 540 ministerial 11 AC 223n 543 allegations 574 54n r89NY 54 «g2 4CP 13 CP -amendment e73AD parties deft. 1 AC 21 NC power court 116AD 39CP 482 St limitatna d30 33 70 5SS 15 M e 166 NY 6CP 17 CP construetiOQ 23 NC 94 624 30 4 LEA discharge 35 38 demurrer trial 88 384 suppl. answer lb AD 76 40 AD ' 147 41 AD 569 IIM 395 10 AC 28311 bar release 95 AD 93 94 95 53 AD 581 1 ijti 142 173 NY 403 satisfaction 35 AD 33b amendment 92 M 316 23 NC 189 lU5n ICP NS 220 13SAD 126 171S 8£,3 suppl. pleadg. 56 M 329 bO M 46j 542 621 U6 22 559 377 5Il practice '2, 122 375 i5461egiB discraiD 195 526 583 485 dower title I*',, 28 239 ya d 42 372 i", n 61 480 I fR d 60 532 la^^D merger l.j., j. 22 AD 532e535ff44D 25 M 360'^*"^° 39 M 180 55|ori.negl 4oU 80 192 2UU Uo 64 490 frame issues 94 ad 12 AC 417n420n J? m 109 NY 12 147 NY At\0 J lloNO -4ao seduction I ■e27 124 42, 31, 57 4311, evidence ■d32 46 damages .55 M other acts 131 S 14fiAD competent 106M 175S S02 chat. mtge. ^2'' 556 chge. route g3^;a88NY 279 l^^sei illegal ev. 44 122 2.-)l 394 62 1 poor person r88NY 513 20 NC 307n d23vol, associns uO OU/ 7 LP 420 m 3 38 436 unincorporated e-^ m. 68 626 presumption 579 preference r89NY 401 IBNC 216 2 OP 41 1 2 LRA 796n 580'BtockholderB e 7 AU 368 583 distinction e 19 AD 232 ev. of debt i AC 339 587 contempt e36 e41 e64 do 48 AD 96 NY 100 NY 163 NY TCP 381 355 450 107 493 368 272 271 334 603 amendment lluAD 84 i9A0 448 608 irregularity 38 286 distinction d 83 102 6 1 error citing 585 21 460 24 r93NY 111 US 9 AD 8CP intent 43 AD 235 disbursements 16 NC 221 6 12 jurisdiction 68 63 e66 e34AD legia. power 55AD> 128 aD 0/M place of trial 8 AC 2e3n authority 124 S 821 614 judicial a 93 NY SbSsep.property e 36 M case 2 299 a 88 NY case 4 r91NY 28 «33 findings 124 NY J, 1 1 insurance 3*3 a-91 NY case 12 mutuality 34 13 NC 214 26 604 185 78 306 565 election 381 case 6 I12NC 15 515 money had 3 CP 207 £ 31 513' 21 NC 359n' 567 taxation a 89 NY 409 6 1 8 partiee 29 injunction e39 d46 dl22 NY leave of court 49 receiver 10 M 1 AC 19 NC 629 425 227 109 892 340 366n 524 incomp ev. l99 NY 184 6l9st>t limitata 77 AD 243 2 LRA 831 ' 'demand'* 89 NY 4<9 36 133 lOn 14 AD 1 AC bar »y NY recovery Jl NC odO taxation aalNY 674 2U 4^0 11 NC 44 20 NC 64n object of tax 27 189 634 implied war ranty a 98 N Y 246 inier. ueg. 117AD 689 tenant liable ii7AD lyAO utimance 19AU 31 638 writ error aaONY 248 640 pers. prop- erty m 94 NY 160 642 amendment 38 AD 534 690 896 645 rr mtge case 6 a 88 NY 31 ease 14 affidavit 36 397 646 mandamus case 4 r 90 NY 419 case 7 share fund a 96 NY 645 647 will trust case 13 a 88 NY 323 arrears income 56 M 83 626 192 384 VOL.26. I criminal mSSNY 41 2CP allegations 80 458 crim. contempt e 100 NY 368 court's power 145 S 391 mandate ct. f 160 AD , 373 I subrogation a 99 NY 28 33 52 I 9 atty'i 29 M 37 M 342 23 86 89 301 fees 298 385 1 20 claims 31 312 77 60ti 48 AD 10 land und. water 8 AC- I27n rule damage 101 NY 116 construction 98 M 162 S nuisance J33NY separate 223NY 24 actual fraud 87 AD 5 SB 13 NC 16 NC 28 removal a 94 NY 49 AD 46 36 368 451 210 38 fr'd. claim 19 NC 369n 46 sale lands r 88 NY 309 48 construe strictly a 97 NY 49 60 repeal 90 210 annual report 11 M 52'8 3 AC 396n amendment 106 AD 186 unliq. damages 61 214 160 110 AD demurrer f 91 M 154 S complaint 91 M. 687 577 963 53 discharge r 108 NY 508 .58 misdemeanor a 87 NY 533 33 637 6 1 liq. damages a 94 NY 630 1127 NY 487 26 M 323 648 conviction case 1 L_ a 88NY 458 >>' abduction jaSSNY 649 discharge case 4 90 NY case 6 levy tax a 96 NY case 14 services e94NY 76 flse pretense - 53 a 87 NY 661 82 minoty stock- 311' holders 3 AC 371n 114 NC 232b ,89 dividends r89NY 1209 NY r 11 NC 118 NC income '66 AD 24 M distribution 11 NC 164 NY 172 NY 479 465 401 191n 413 675 61 196 141 107 not insurer 98 M 163 S 664 440 91 163 274 cause 276 130 attorney a 89 NY 618 36 671 61 413 disbarment dSAD 611 37 M 419 420 6 AC 12n 1 34mechanc lien a 94 NY 394 90 NY 341 1 42 claims do 40 AD 339 1 47 fraudulent 34 665 7CP 76 1 48 accounting 32 548 i 50 aBsigoable ■39 472 benificiary 13 AD 532 I 53 gift trust case 9 a 91 NY case 10 appeal a 93 NY 1 54 appeal case 11 a 88 NY case 14 arrest r93NY 6CP 1 55 usury case 9 r94NY 200 affidavits 29 630 a 30 515 4 CP 381 amendment 40 301 623 82 AD 98 appeal merit 91 AD 297 656 567 442 129 I 56 jurisdiction d 42 199 1 6 1 claim e 69 444 22 NC 90n constitutional 216 NY 465 I 66 discovery * 89 NY 601 31 e37 53 e57 237 235 504 506 184 311 17 M 31 21 M 112 56 .M 36'^ 102M 77 4 CP 333 409 12 CP 11 17 CP 210 212 16SS 451 appealable 56 AD 256 ncrimination 116AD 579 d 39CP 40n 43n, f 44n privilege 19A0 858 I 73 judgment 7 M 523 17 NC I93n I 76 partnership •^i" 27 In I 79 construction J3 I 83 appe a 62 NY 39 e 104 NY 6CP 7CP 213 ble 251 64 205 249 158 368 I 87 scrutiny a 91 NY 36 22 NC 1 94 parties 138 14 AC 539 147 215 55 196 469 490 203 fixtures 134 NY 206 libel r 96 NY 372 209 subrogation a 94 NY 82 2l4comp'ls.accg a35M. 154 2 1 7 trust r94NY 44 104 78 225 dale valid a 94 NY 619 32 411 suppl. plead'gs. 14 M 428 229 assignment r 94 NY 387 234 cityUable 44 159 238 conclusive 70 56 240coDviction case 6 33 case 8 evidence a 91 NY 33 234 657 190 241 contract case 5 a 89 NY 36 29 83 remedies vs.State 16 NC 447n 242 judgment cast 12 a 89 NY 637 244 assumption case 1 a 94 NY appeal case 7 * 94 NY 21 NC 86 243 359n 245 objections case 6 26 618 «ritlcttcd ;^'*,Eyi4T10NSr a. affirmed; d, distingaishcd-. t. followed; r. reversed; m. modified; •. dismissed- n note- c e»n» . criticised; 1, limited; e. explained; o, overruled; = ■=»■"- .•»--• 'in mi. ..„„.:„_ ..,:'_: _ _i_.A r ™'"'" ■ "• ■«« : ae case; do. dissenting opinion; p. parallel case; q, questioned Vol. 27 N. 7. Supreme Court Reports— Hun 166 NY 13US 66 M other acts 146AD 393, el31S 131 S admissable 146AD 130 S 437 251 St)« 394 251 251 397 359 notice e86 255 b 22 NC 338n 364 damages IBS AD 150 S libelous 180AD 369 construction 325 signals ev. 31 400 13 AC 414n 328 rent Uxes e71 256 70 AD 73 liability 225NY 196 33 1 trial void 35 152 40 101 48 154 e4g 15t 66 304 64 60: 5LUA 323n sp. performance 22 AD IbM privileged 128 NY 424 168 NY 225 15 Al! 280l h.and w cooiraci 18AC obligation f 169AD 155 S enforced 186AD 174S 21s 808 878 299 476 533 840 400 diversion case 13 r92 NY 463 16 NC 185 100 406 18 M 9 OF 37 I costs 32 40 AD jurisdiction 134AU 373 costs 20 38 i6 AC extension 43 U2 AD d 148 NY 375 bond 73 AD 40 1 construe will case 10 a 92 NY case 13 scr 631 167 553 307 576 547 335 33 217 81 291 22 402 surety case 2 r97NY 29 S14NC case 3 incomp. evidence s 96 N If 222 405 amend ment case 4 335 lien realty a 91 NY 606 33 198 presumption SAD 35) 342 directors 9M 594 17 M 726 3 AC 369i 344 medical col leges e30 distinction 127S uutliorily 71M 380 bequests a 92 NY 433 33 412 heirs next kin 45 366 lapsed legacies e 46 530 ezcessve bequest 27 M 478 ,33 M 196 presumption 82 M 227 143 S 531 384 justices of the peace 29 519 powe. of court ;eed ev. 134AD 534 negligenc a 98 NY 628 536 surety d63 47 505 862 4 1 6 waiver e34 performance 50 264 42 1 assessment a 90 NY 652 e 63 638 deiiuctiona 53 541 425 secure costs d 29 194 73 428 7 OP 402 429 jurisdiction 38.M 69 439 easement r 92 NY 262 e 64 39 iftdef. void 105 AD 428 446 wife neoee sanes 24 M 141 447 fund income 10 AD 77 reimbursement 80 AD 194 e 93 AD 223 110 AD . 77 husband liable a 4 100 542 279n 287 631, 16 480 incompetent p3BS 3SS 31 M 32 M 6 AC 20 NC f 160 S care insane 66 M . scupe iiiquiy 37 CP 172 497 cond'l sale 35 483 do 15 NC 393 500 b.particulara 48 230 19 M 478 7 CP 218 13 CP 264 15 CP 184 19 AC lln 505 eurplusage 96 AD '26 508 accounting 39 278 3 LRA 322n 538 no appeal 57 186 74 191 mandamus 112AD 412 117AD 809 539 discretion 368 e 70 443 5 CP 261 2 LRA 266 intervention 5M 16 17 543 jurisdiction case 2 266 22 576 173n 426n 6i.i 603 tiust r 92 N Y 508; 16 NC 20n 605 certiorari 72 166 NY lOlM 166S 606 sale »90Ny 31 263 43 90 366 594 stay 308 573draughtsman 41 2U4 575 ri 6.M 13C 577 legacy ex^. a 94 N if 674 awaive objn. 18A0 439n jurisdiction 8j M 670 i4S S 1008 579 supl com Plaint r90NY 512 3 AD 15:j SAO 21 S 7 CP 163 265 cross action 38 AD 374 ur-r 176AD HOf. f 163 S 387 368 475 31 7 86 692 809 construe will m 91 NY 439. 6 CP 247 15 NC 137 6 1 partition 90NY 312 11 NC 367 6 I 1 St. limitat'n. 656 369 424 16 428 276 47n 207 *91 NY d39 91 40 AD e84 AD 97AD 1 AC 10 CP amendment 19AC 297n ."uit barred 20AC In. 6 I 3 will construe- case 1 1 r 92 NY 446 6 I 6 suretiej" case 7 a 91 NY 353 b'Jnd ea.'e 7 a 91 NY 363- PiOm note ease 8 * 91 NY 305 ovenant case 12 35 AD 4IS r92NY 5CP 2LRA case 3 affirmative a 92 NY 544 parol ev. case 8 r98NY 022 409 421u 122 56 assignee e45 555 508 file mortge. 128S 1110 relief 70M 46T 51 5 b. particulars 546 mandamus case 6 a 80 NY 411 case 12 mandamus *91NY 386 8 12 NC 262 .547 insurance ease 4 a 91 NY 57 548 contempt a 90 NY 2CP 7CP s 12 NC 19 NC 146 S 160 AD 582 iojuncton 3 11 NO 298 Forfeit franchise 22 NC 21 In 537 assignment 49 608 589 construction 37 49 e32M 325 e33M 512 1 5 AU 3o 592 costs appeal e38 235 43 217 32 AD 81 d 148 NY 291 144 AD 283 595 correct judg 129S 247 prop, procedure 402 379 9 25n 342 50 668 AD 238 467 d 88 21 M 5 1 7 affidavits s 10 NC 342 38 86 554condition a 23 NC 418n 557 coDtraot 148 AD 132S conviction f 141 S motion f 156 AD correction 150 AD 596 parties d54M 119 AD a 97 NY 23 NC 293 41Sn 565 chat. mtge. p60 14 206 46 AD 458 390'19M 51 32NY lUAC 1 9 devise a 92 NY 41 29 AD 126 NY 630 410 4?9n 6 1 adjudication a 92 NY 643 32 349 e96AD 299 300 64 appeal a 92 NY 65 89 partnership a 97 NY 262 21 NC 60n 74 dismissal SO AD 146 1 AC 325 32Bn judgment do 135AD 97 M 162 S notice 162 S discretion d 98 M 1 50 inquest a 91 NY 241 3 12 NO 172 38 200 43 338 const '1 rights 215 NY 290 f 215- NY 291 1 58 title a 93 NY 35 damages 45 19 NC 5CP 246 executors 31 178 187 129 461 204 1 78 negligence • 99 NY 673 1 84 paymt. int r 103 NY 32 36 61 84 3 1 4 maater neg 70 44 41 U 250 remedy 254 demand a 92 NY 884 60 676 2 LB.A 830n 26 1 order a 91 NY 270 247 30 470 77 draft r 101 NY 22 subrogation 38 210 34 M 709 6CP i71n 7 CP 291 25 chat. mtgC' 3 LRA 795n 27 merger 17 M 383 3 I assessment 4 LRA 304n 119 AD 716 35 note 3d pers 46 AD 640 587 895 145 600 439 58 195 parties 42 devise wife 66 eq. relief 17 M ISNC demurrer 47 M 63 38 affidavit of juror 97 100 79 secuty money 27 AD 153 93 judgt. bar »91NY 171 98 revival 22 AD 388 jury question 136 NT 383 I 08 appeal ev. 4 AC 127n I lOJuryquestion 34 610 618 71 452 I 1 2 prior lien 31 257 45 AD 290 injunction 146 283 683 166 2U d4AD d28AD d70AD for jury 78 M -DM fl41S safe place 139 S 3 1 8 services 47 330 178 350 552 511 26 232 31 37 40 20 AD e63AD 55 AD 97 AD dolllAD906 906 35 36 e38 3M 6 AC e40M 218 323 218n 293 51 burden proof 181AD 803 52 indictment a 101 NY 19 46 361 54 accounting case 3 m 95 NY 36 38 380 54remov offe . case 10 a 92 NY 191 2 LRA 793 55 authority case 4 31 73 22 NC 438 9 14 NC 328 22 NC 438 57 commissioas 86 AD 90 ,26M 111 7M 1 AC 3 AC lAC 136 NY 127 392n 93n 99n 347n 261 127 AD 682 bS3 do 686 equity question 44 AD 63 22 NC 352 equity relief 194 NY 408 I 1 9 assignment 39 573 42 258 73 369 6 LRA 142n mothers support 38 AD 603 d24 M 328 sl2 NC 25 e 102 NY 152 chge. benefic. ' 14 AC 18gn good cause 157 AD 286 142 S 197 1 22 stookholder a 94 NY 415 4 AD 605 do 4 AD 608 141 intervention 79 AD 357 200 jurisdiction 31 633 custody child -OM 674 7 AC 302n 17 NC 2B4 129B 490 204 construction d 43 569 79 AD 534 636 do 79 AD 639 admissions 109 AD 398 207 jurisdiction 43 198 8 CP 210 2 1 4 discretion d95NY 636 23 M 286 acco'unting 117AD 262 2 1 9 limit liabil. e 108 NY B02 21 NC 52 14 CP 140 227 contempt a 92 NY 416 not discharged 77M 17 laes i2j habeas corpus £ 87 M 598 150 S 25 235 dower bar 42 371 d 113 NY 301 17 NC «07n aSBUmd. mtg 4LRA 121 eq. redemption 4LRA 121n 240. assessment case 3 rOlNY 117 trustee liable case 8 a 98 NY 170 241 police trial case 1 e31 21 case 6 receiver a 100 NY 670 264 b.particulari 62 AD 132 269 non resident 36 392 35 646 juriadlotion 4 AC 247n new cause ao tion 8 AC 272n no cause action 109 AD 168 18 NC 434 274 sp, prfmoe. m92NY at 7M 609 13 NC 339n 17 NC 430n 22 NC 402n 408n 22 NC 417n 3 LRA 164n 279 attachment a92NY 256 284 mandamus ♦91 NY 666 90 * 96 NY 1 543 mandamus 40 574 56 78 72 368 38 AD 415 69 AD 557 558 e 85 AD 410 114 AD 223 145 AD 649 14 M 209 21 U 250 24 M 225 51 M 328 62 M 50 17 NC 311 130 S 479 maintain road do 145 AD 656 do 145 AD 655 do 130 S 480 do 130 5 434 election 77M 492 136S 725 discretion 181AD 814 168S 1037 560 probate . r 95 NY 256 22 NC 264 584 discovery 28 M 603 inspection 92 M 661 157 S 493 566 alimony 7 AC 239n255n 13 AC 310n 568 forgery a 97 NY 126 573 will trust m 97 NY 26 48 376 583 new pleading IoaC 166d serve pleading 18AC 170 584 judgment a 96 NY 653 587 assessment a 101 NY 284 589 request err. a 94 NY 490 62 AD 512 do 154AD do 139 S 153 595 assessment s 41 537 603 suspension * 97 NY 460 36 531 6l5accumulat'n r95NY 13 e 92 NY 51S* 626 accomplice a 92 NY 66 e 33 M 41 ev. ci-ime • 38 M 185 £ 147 S 113:; conviction £ 163 AD 866 629 commissions 3 101 NY 461 6 LEA 74e 634 windows a 100 NY 634 71 301 licene v 5 AC 15ii 639 exceptions 35 119 39 195 88 147 3 CP 171 7 CP 199 all evidenee 46AD 365 commissions 16 M 202 except'n findings 116 NY 198 640 publication case 1 a 90 NY 654 case 7 taxation r 93 NY 196 case 8 taxation r 93 NY 196 41 374 641 contract case 1 d 103 NY 264 case 4 annual report r 99 NY 390 case 5 assessment a 93 NY 361 case 16 mference a 93 NY 636 81 AD 96 642 judgment case 4 a 99 NY 670 case 8 imitations 50 576 a 9NY 690 case 9 trust land a 95 NY 7 case 13 negligence a 99 NY 368 52 11 643 commiss'ns case 3 a 101 *IY 621 case 8 accounting a 93 NY 48 3 13 NC 353 case 7 appeal a 93 NY 48 669 appearance 36CP 328 VOL. 29 I compensation 33 644 e 35 262 42 £69 86 AD 63 118 NY 624 e 129 NY 273 176 NY 304 17 NC 285 reverse error 129 AD 709 ev. award 66M 509 7 commissiona a 96 NY 327 35 274 39 52 54 204 3 SA 408 409 27 M 472 98 NY 535 e 46M 396 16AC 420 141AD 804, SOS resignation 127S 214 1 2 ex parte mot'n 50 107 mandamus chambers 71 241 15 AC 294n 15 CP 383 1 4 execution 38 M 67 17 misconduct referee 29 104 35 497 49 82 IAD 106 3M 444 14 M 674 35 M 242 42 M 3 20 wiU trust m 95 NY 103 34 commission 5LRA 74n 35 neg. dam. r 35 NY 274 30 282 cond'n mother 41 AD 89 II AC 61n 39 preference e 73 331 e 21 M 231 3 AC lOn 6 LRA 339n 42 judgt. bar a 96 NY 237 4 LRA 146n 160 14 NC 301n 17 NC 7 23 NC 142 165n 172n 44 aubstitution 54 513 47 filiation e4S 48 AD review 151 NY 68 quasi, criml. 123AD 896 50 jury question 40 165 68 592 p 58 593 d92 collision neg 16AC 328d 54 limitntinna 5 530 145 ABBREVIATION'S: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f. followed; c criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; a, lamecase; do, IM 16 M 141 NY 420 318 218 62 deed notice e 530 M 22 76 public policy 13 NC 214n 84 change of int. a 93 NY 75 19 NC 377n 87 compensation 39 62 assessment ins. 61 " 309 e 63 264 d 63 266 75 231 40 AD 42 by-laws d 43 M 341 i 160 S 875 forfeiture 124S 482 67M 285 no excuse 137AD 840 94 receiver r.94.NY 342 e 41 AD 207 SAC 113n 6CP 99 9CP 118 96 contempt r93NY 79 99 referee report 1 AD 106 14 M 674 35 M 242 105 public nui- sance a 95 NY 83 44 222 1 1 9 lost deed ev. a 101 NY 427 42 151 J 22 sum trial 56 629 1 25 incomp. ev. 45 57 74 253 86 611 discontinue e 142 NY 150 no error 172S 447 certiorari 184AD 695 141 incomp. ev case 1 186 case 3 gift invalid a 96 NY 603 e 36 667 case 6 construe will r 96 NY 164 1 43 costs case 12 secure costs r 92 NY 363 1 44 judgment case 13 a 100 NY 635 146 receiver 10 M 692 85 M 340 147 S 306 aew parties I AC 219 n 340 151 sureties J 75 legis. power 17 AD 171 60 AD 694 e 99 NY 583 unconstitutional e33H 218 construction 35 M 36 M Investiture 4LRA r 100 NY 273 154 phys. exbib. e67 43 AD 4SS fl3M 34M 4 AC 9AC 141 US 116 NY e 129 NY 3LRA 676 514 612 501 404 lljO 24 442 444 255 299 52 809 r92NY r 119 US case 13 executor a 100 NY 311 110 36 I 59 conclusive a 16 NO 477n 161 stockholder r 95 NY 93 17 NC 131 166 rescission 77 458 1 69 seduction a 99 NY 669 1 73 estoppel 7M 21 NC 313 604 no power 137S 1 8 1 alimony 110 790 IOAC liability 152AD 136S 117n 300 711 1 83 compet. ev. 46 327 73 AD 501 I 85 oomrs hwys a 93 NY 114 NY 34 1 86 defense 40 46 60 397 330 143 1 88 bus. name 1 AC 378n 1 93 secure costs e 73 428 7 CP 400 1 9 5 ch arge realty a 100 NY 191 202 parol proof e 30 645 e 12 AD 4 84 AD 378 36 AD 239 4 AC 190n 13 AC 185 i, 167 204 tax corpn. case 7 taxation a 92 NY 328 cases taxation m 92 NY 458 case 12 redemption r 102 NY 20 205 forn' corpn case 8 206 insurance r 129 US 259 16 NC 75n 208 executora case 1 a 96 NT 132 210 set off costs 18AC 276n 212 contiDK. int. a 64 NY 663 40 450 3 LBA 696 2 1 5 discretion 82 AD 132 NT restitution 6 AC sheriffs' fee 56 M 2 1 6 notice 60 lllAD bar 82 M 143 S 624 368 183n 125 231 783 443 1051 221 lapsed lega- cies c 46 630 presumption 82 M 227 143 3 551 225 bequests r96NY 166 12 NC 436n 16 NC 264 232 autnority a 100 NY 115 e 88 AD 481 19 NC 272n use water 236 a 101 NY 20 AD 39 AD 82 AD 46 M 620 184 97 558 483 239 chose in act r 96 NY 180 s 14 NC 383 6 AC 120n 19 NC 281 386 21 NC 245 243 limitation r 100 NY 27 8 CP 141 245 use Eitreets 49 AD 443 compensation 125 S 120 urban easement 125 S 120 140 AD 212 249 power sale - "16 348 190 147 NC 431n rs. property NY 71 S 976 AD 671 78 82 17 pers. 96 J" 146 161 i 25 1 leave to sue 17A D 247 17 M 241 6 CC 199n 16 NC 433 judgment 6 AC 201n not apply 189 AD 420 f, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note , dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case: q, questioned N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Hun Vol. 29 124 S IS 252right to Bue 139 AD 420 water mains 140 AD 211 Btat. restrictn. 124 S 191 253 Stat limitns a 95 NY 69 73 surplus f 66M 259 new 6AD 163 NY 31 164 433 trial 238 109 265 reUef llSAD 299 equitabale lein d 119AD 700 equity action 347 39 CP damages lOSM d 174S 268 appeal 64AD 272 error 36 24AD 393 198 546 74 291 274 injunction 70 11 42 M Bar 278 insurance caee 1 a95Y case 9 accretion r lOlNY 42 474 SI 600 279 contract case 2 r lOlNY 631 286 poundage 461 625 555 loa 510 76 408 266 a95NY 38 288 arrest 32 3CP exceptions 142 S 295 will m95NY 35 54 legacy interest 16 AC 198n 301 contemp 60 M 64 303 open are a92NY 629 d29 627 3* ' 446 46 90 56 292 42M 372 local act opng st 96NY 141 167NY 192 6 M .201 abandon highwy ).3AC 235n 247'n easement 200 NY 119 not apply 152AD 363 136S 1011 306 affidavit * 92 NY 630 31 574 32 279 e44 87 2 AO 362n 4CP 16 CP 365 363 312 309 injunction 14 NC 196n 3 1 8 dower 39 e39 e48 320 bigamy r92NY 34 321 assesat case 3 r92NY case 9 insurance *92NY 255 268 463 147 329 fr'd, 111 654 322 taxtlon case 2 a 92 604 case 3 will "airs' a 95NY 17 323 annl. rept case 5 r 101 NY 373 324 usury case 12 r 92 NY 34 325 condemn, award 33 647 e 53 285 24 AD 10 40 AD 284 meas. damage 65M 255 344 defense 39 M 384 answer 193 NY 271 348 directors 59 523 121 NY 228 357 commitment 133 NY 210 attachment r93NY 592 s 12N0 202 13NC 173 park depmt, 133AD 82 review 159 S 220 369 trade mark 124 NY e96NY 5GP review SAC 477 198 145 65n 377 intent a 92 NY d49 660 214 382 deliberation a 92 NY 554 33 123 cross examinatn 20 AD 517 39 I ins. premium a 93 NY 64 313 326 517 46 200 600 399 notice 51 97 M 162 S 163 S genl. laUguage 4 AD 13 50 AD 600e 601 e 108 NY 399 99 M 26 inadmissible 178AD 164S 404 revival 120 NY reservation 28 M 14 NC discharge 185AD goods sold £ 207 NY election 185AD 356 764 419 479 29n 914 722 645 407 chat. mtge. e 89 AD 412 certificate 6 AG 43n 410 pleadings f 59 Mi 162 4 1 2 intention a 93 NY 295 41 500 vested remdr. 15 NC 117 4 1 8 necessaries. 48 262 1 AC 297n 422 demurrer 186 NY e35 88 25 AD a 95 NY e63 AD e73AD 102 AD 171 AD 2 AC 11 AC 9CP 14 NC 157 S equity 183AD 202 286 85 364 486 202 557 428 729 276 278n 177178n 341 34 1071 suit 139 6 AC 14n 46 1 accomplice a 91 NY 137 61AD 543 3LRA 401n 470 beneficiary 42 215 13 AD 532 assignable 95 M 309 158 S 837 473 a 92 NY 98 discrediting 108 NY 179 NY compet. ev 12a AD 477 appeal a93Ni cross exam. 651 301 134 366 426 arrest r96NY 7CP 9CP 100 359 225 429 dissolution 372 17 551 dl66 347 938 580 con- 64 35) 253 162 407 34 52 53 e 1 AD ICP benefit 127S 70M 434 deed ditions r95NY 8 110 NC 31 32 22NC 441 discovery 37 236 443 amendment d 33 AD 556 9M 47 8 AC 275n sup. pleadg 53M 396 446 chge grade a 104 NY 68 450 discovery 70 639 do 74 AD 361 39 M 249 lAC 183n 186n 459serve order d 94 117 d 61 412 1 SS 293 d30AD d44M lAC 5 AC 6 AC counsel fees e48M 390 478 attachment 43 562 I 62 442 479 conversion case 5 r 100 NY 150 480 judgment case 1 a 100 NY 612 480 res judicata case 7 r 95 NY 212 481 contract ease 4 a 95 NY 181 481 accounting case 6 a 96 NY 635 483 bill partic case 11 * 93 NY 467 39 AD 47 AD 23 M 87 AD 435 211 61 488 484 appeal case 1 93 NY 634 485 conversion r 100 NY 577 51 697 488 alimony 462 330 229n 193 187n 152 49 I imprism't a 94 NY 640 vacate attaohm't 61 M 554 493 fr'd transfr 110 NY 89 498 compt. ev. 31 419 147 S 271 may testify 84 M 505 tender 52 42 M 127 NY 154 S 169 AD. 311 272 379 223 534 191 509 contract 39 AD 622 5 1 3 jurisdiction 31 363 368 e39AD 191 520 persumption innocence 38 170 194 6 64 76 competent ev. e 49 M 299 527 alimony d 35 379 7 AC 245n 18 NC 35n 529 execution r 97 NY 149 18 NO 321 534 deficiency a 95 NY 513 537 compt. ev. 48 386 82 79 546 recovery 92 AD 79 15 AC 28 548 assessment a 97NY 97 47 392 551 dower e 32 280 e 37 229 e 124 NY 600 2nd marriage 6'6M 131 bad faith 79 M 75 13'JJi 556 instructions S3 AD 598 do 5 SS 204 Qcg. fel. servant 16 M 226 41 AD (65 AD ( 119 NY 2 8A 16 U 23 M 127 S undertaking; 127S no stay 142AD 602 review a 93 NY 6 AD 606 teacher 42 AD 66 467 634 543 546 666 50 60 466 386 677 646 damages m 94 NY 287 36 436 652 appeal limit 20 M U AC 612 448n 637 8 1 5 stat. frauds case 7 r 100 NY 159 35 160 6 1 6 death neg. case4 r 95 NY 267 6 I 7 prom . note case 8 r 101 NY 434 567 assignee 48 689 49 . 226 contempt 40 AD 102 574 damages a 100 NY 618 67 303 127 NY 229 1 LRA 746n 580 same orime 70M 202 indictment 12 8S 877 do 166S 353 584 re-filing 9 AC 4aen 589 costs 40 42 44 63 230 488 592 separation 615 155 248 311 816 276 775 dl6AU d8CP denials 125 S 140 AD alimony 186AD 14CS 174S 594 sup. pro. 46 d37M 19 NC 598 stay 39 64 SAD 17 AD 223 774 373n 437 525 377 609 commission 33 641 35 264 37 312 8 I 2 amendment case 1 a 101 NY 289 21 NC 210 6 1 3 remainder case 5 a 105 NY i 51 1 LRA dividends case 11 a 95 NY 282 266 6 1 9 assessment a 101 NY 634 622 commissions s 95 NY 263 32 203 77 «11 6 CP 442 626oDen'g street .9SNY 135 34 445 628 judgment a 96 NY 625 ruling evidence 55 M 52 630 alimony 7 AC 25Sn 634 ner damage 64 AP 488 79 AD 124 liability 141 S 339 637 master neg. 698 31 314 148 464 307 654 costs 102 NY 51 88 57 AD 18 NC compliance 29 M presentment 7 AC 143a 146 657 securty costs 49 65 60 271 46 AD 287 298 47 AD 639 9 AC 73n 10 AC 2g9n 300a 3 CP 432 7 CP 201 15 CP 116 6 CP 108 660 injunction a 100 NY 424 21 LRA 636 riparian owner 70M 58 title land 127S 953 668 book entires r 94 NY 569 e43 21 54 343 670 appeal limit 11 AC 453n service gooi 138S 62 due service 153AD 586 673 assessment case 12 a 101 NY 429 a 100 NY I LRA 4 LRA 638 risks 4LRA 462 486 52n 52n 641 discovery r 99 NY 649 73 424 66 AD 169 AD 203 9 AC 276 276n authority 184AD 139 AD 5371124 S iisl 486 726 46S OJS.ILV ij\ii\jrto'. a, amrmcu i u, uiatiusuioiitu , », »u*.w wcu , i, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note* ^ cised ; 1, limited : e. explained ; o, overruled ; s, same c ase ; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, questioned! AUBKEVIATIUNS rriti , affirmed ; d, distinguished ; f, tollo wed ; Vol. 30 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Hun VOL. 30 I lurpluB profits 78 67 jury qupftiOQ 134 NY 254 ' 6 title refuse 32 162 22 NC 407u 9 fraudulent 34 565 7CP 76 13 jurisdictioD 35 614 cloud on titl 65 102 AD 105 NY e 174 NY 5M 29 award 32 SCP 69M 488 75 guaranty a 100 NY 613 77 compliance e 29 M 601 107 AD 110 15 CP 20 79 discovery 35 M 340 37 M 879 81 exemption 569 394 46 294 190 7 AC 82 decree cass 6 a 103 NY 83 order a 93 NY assesment case 218 284 338o 15ii case 1 634 34 ad'l allowce. 30 M 531 35 error ev. r 8 M 459 17 AC 77ii 37 afSdavite 33 35 e38 41 24M 32 M 2 AC i5NC 486 397 210 66 685 16 62 349q 481 a 101 NY 121 US judgment case 6 a 100 NY 14 NC 85 judgment case 12 r95NY 89 damages case 13 a 108 NY S13NC 22 NC 244 541 144 S 162 40 ISen notice 88 241 *7M 614 47 negligence 34 438 18 NC 434 waive objns. 18 AC 432i, 50 vacate time 42 M 21 57 certificate » AC 43ii 61 discovery 88 16 AD SSAD eSSS 10 M 67 M 1 AC 16AC privilege 89CP 63 contract r 100 NY 311 318 15 190 447 477 m362 170 404o 614 60 391 495 76 442n 179 68 hostile witn. S6 558 I 65 AD 42 e 104 AD 58 73 Btkholders 17 AD 360 iojunction 27 AD 18 M motives 135S good faith c 135S legal right disap. 150AD7i:i 74 lien deficient 107 AD IIU execution 126 S 132 127S 624 90 discretion a 102 NY 713 SAD 28 92 AD 335 foreclosure a I SA 78 94 "writing" a 98 NY 217 e 69 425 fact question 23 M 630 bar 16 NC 457 ackniiwldgmenc 3S CP 50b 98 objections a 92 NY 128 30 496 498 de facto officer 7 AD 566 139 NY 511 f 86 M 90 149 S 117 appeal right to 47 AD 211 87 AD 488 99 AD 373 abatement plea 36 M 486 indictment 8 AC40n41n44n 8AC45n46n48n 144 resettlem't 65 63 7 AC 492n 146 judt. vs. Town P 30 149 supt. schools 19 M 469 148 mandamus a 94 NY 263 1 5 1 accounting 2 AD 111 jurisdiction 31 AD 177 1 54 reference 53 245 referee's report 39 M 395 11 CP 101 report 118AD 344 39 CP 130 1 6 1 cloud on title a 96 NY 477 39 233 1 63 judt CO. ct. 46 54 d 65 363 leave execution 7M 220 6 AC 202n 17 CP 336 2 LRA 83n judgment 21,KA 831n 166 jurisdiction 66 630 1 68 town bonds 34 142 liability 123 S 556 158 1 7 1 legacy m 100 NY 41 £11 247 1 74 notice pend 47 AD 157 record failure 12 M 497 1 77 trust fund m 117 NY 649 17 AD profiits 86 AD 154 NY delay 16 M 660 448 2l2partiea •93 NY d48 stockholders 3 AC 370c 2 1 4 practice 36 162 case on appeal 61 624 73 377 7 AC 492n 2 1 5 devise a 100 NY 287 2 1 6 damages ease 7 a 101 NY 63b a 1 iJA 27 2 1 7 mandamus case 1 « 12 NC 84 219 obligation 137S 173 220 will oaae 1 r 95 NY 494 mental Capao, case 10 r95NY easement case 12 r 101 NY rlSA partnership case 4 a 101 NY 53 22 NC e59 277 41 AD eS7AD AD 16 M 316 265 241 331n 222 foreclosure case 9 r 106 NY warranty case 11 a 101 NY 439 616 271 466 26 439 631 10 AC 396397n 246 appeal • 95 N Y 663 248 afiidaVits 33 486 e 35 398 542 41 65 7 CP 413 jurisdiction 24 M 684 1^ NC 339 349n 16 NC 482 249 presumption 403 378 492 S80 124 475 299 assignment 100 NY 417 62 43 1 46 AD 183 300 injunction 79 193 304 declarations 79 306 costs 12SNY 8 12 NC d42 e 12M 19A0 12 7S 142 AD evidence 181 NY 105 title 132 NY 110 414 309 requests case 3 d 37 668 310 spec. legc'y case 11 a 101 NY 311 '52 204 31 I judgment case 7 a 101 NY rejection case 10 34 646 417 192 224 costs a 96 NY 36 37 41 42 e61 63 3 AD 7 AD 383 do 386 667 62 241 251 167 356 21 317 255 Sep estate 38 223 conversion 67M 42 258 commiss'ns 124 S 621 67M 42 trustee fees 143 S 358 260 final 27 M 676 4LRA 206n lien deficient 107 AD llO 266 demand pro- test 57 270 guaranty 18AC 33011 248 I 86 exr. claim r 96 NY 88 39 116 1 92 fr d transfer e 135 NY 22 NC 72 M 130 S 225 costs 6 AO e2n 713 SAC review do 114 AD challenge dl40S conviction 80 M 1 29 covenant alUONY 471 3 LRA 792 1 38 e jectment .1 lUl NY 50 142 recvr. e 54 d34M 20 NC 116AD consideration 77 362 liab. .546 534 316 505 p31 35 84 23 M e 101 NY 3 LRA 22 NC 66 130 340 729 232 139n 336n 20 1 reserve int. a 23 NC 419d 204 mandamus 131 NY service 184AD 172S mailing 184AD 190 suffic. 619 378 271 71 114 109' 137d 269 e88 f 160 AD diacharKo 66 AD 5 LRA custodian 145 S 594 177 20 U 188 e 142 NY 249 13 NC 385 23 NC 398n 376 wght of ev. a 96 NY 666 44 952 379 judgment a 96 NY 627 382 jurisdiction case 4 a 103 NY 84 13 NC 10 19 NC 66 contract case 10 a 100 NY a 116 US 19 NC a 6 SO 620 77 3 1 2 warranty case 10 a 100 NY 536 314 ratification d62 67 loan- of money eb2 71 stockholder 3 AC 398n 3 1 9 appeal 23 M 614 322 quo warrant a 96 NY 317 326 assignment a 96 NY 16 NC 18 NC 19 NC 22 NC 1 LRA 446 548 623 657 384 order case 6 ♦98 NY 385 probate a 95 NY 388 instructions 164 d38 e60 55 d57 lAC 14AC 424 369 277 534 lOn 128n 248 249 325n 40n 103 3327 681 adminis'tor 224 303 406 543n 814 282 new trial 619 209 vesting 26 AD 75 AD Corp. liable 66M 163 176 227 distribution a 101 NY 626 a 124 NY 266 35 134 e36 138 230 jurisdiction a 102 NY 696 23 1 demands 21 M 688 23 NC 256n not agent 212 NY 94 237 duress thieats r 102 NY 372 36 102 1 14 ISS 280 e 116 NY 612 240 asBessment a 9U NY 644 36 S 242 exemptions 34 66 77 SAD 2 24 AD 24 AD 56 AD 76 AD 4M 5M 6M 5 AC 120 NY 10 CP jurisdictioo 42 AD 85 364 605 54 266 406 528 628 400 25 98 116 6 132 609 342 accounting a 94 NY 636 349 life tenant 163 NY 218 8 11 NC 37 remainder 42 M 256 351 parol ev. 38 114 certif. deposit 75 112 admissions 81 303 39 I pers injury 6M 373 corp not liable 4L11A 324B 399 tender fare 3 AC 314n 409 trespass a 96 NY 18 constrn. possn. 73M 652 131 S 305 41 I subrogation " 346 124 m95NY 35 priority f 97 M 162 S 651 368 488 44 198 291 neg. dam, 35 364 25 AD 2£8 95 M 114 156 NY 359 297 illegal ev. 34 27 51 AD 4SS entries book 2 AC 312n 7 AC 476n 479n 126 538 430 517 354 review a 93 NY 42 87 AD presumption 16 M 120 statutory power 216 NY 328 uewly disc. ev. 161 S 602 362 discharge a 103 NY 406 person, liable 84 M 402 366 discharge a 103 NY 406 375 contract * 95 NY 648 a 96 NY 629 35 AD 88 araendmant 10 M 8 defeniie plpadg. 4 1 5 r. r. fencing r 99 NY 25 41 85 46 388 417 presumption 139 S 1052 155 AD 905 422 securities 81 AD 349 424 certiorari a 98 NY 454 426 neg. servant 70 AD 409 e83AD 18 91 AD 478 428 insurance a 96 NY 614 37 104 437 declarations a 100 NY 37 438 officer a 64 NY 37 443 exrs acctg. 13 AC 366n aduir- party 635 285 691 286 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m. modified; *, dismissed; n, note t, criticised; 1, limited: e. explained: o. overruled; (, same ease; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q, questioned N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Hun Vols. 30, 31 40 78 AD 133AD 19 AC 118 AD 380 158 S S4B presumption 95 M 46 444 aubstitutioD flAC. 312n practice 123 413 446 notice d 17 NO 187n Advances laAC 87d 455 ctiee venue 88 AD 126 xeaidence lOlM 166S 1070 16AC 166-7n 457&shiereB d 102 AD 457 46 1 abandonm't 347 202 627 881 173n 180n £triut construct'n 153 NY ' 635 judl. separation lOOM 564 166S 900 468 costs case 1 52 99 19 M 411 extra allowance 30 M 531 costs demurrer 18 AC 40i) tender case 2 a 114 NY 204 468 sum pro 8 13 NC 88 469 exr, trustee 33 342 commissions' 66 420 residuary S7 AD 503 472 costs 47 45 f 144 S 401 f 83 M 177 475 disqualifctn 16AC 388n, 396n 479 appeal case 3 a 100 NY 631 jury question case 5 a. 96 NY 14 480 covenant 623 508 260 210 488 legal title SO AD d34AD agent 25 M no trust 183AD 171S 49 1 jurisdiction 6 CP 259 8 CP 104 attachment jl M 554 (93 indictment P 31 527 8 AC 45n constitutional 12 AC 72n 73n 501 mandamus a 96 NY 628 8 12 NC 64 construction 357 487 r 101 NY 48 48 1 dower •case 14 ar4NY 482 pers injury case 2 r96NY fraud case 7 a. 102 NY sale of St. case r 101 NY 605 305 287 411 484 damages 32 614 141 S paymt. 145 S void 83 M 765 illegal 970 364 505 punishment 151AD 567 1.36S 859 508 reference * 94 NY 640 5 I conatltutL 120 AD 532 512 amendment 3 SS 459 82 AD 98 4 LRA 483n 5 1 7 relief neg, 4LRA 483n 52 1 atty's lien eSl d86 88 159 AD 37 M 142 S 2AC 18 NC no lien SOM 72 592 514 607 516 675 194 29n 687 523 discretion e36 22 269 36 16 AD 2SS 4SS 17 CP 632 449 87 91 319 comp. reference 2 AC 273n 274n 525 illegal ev. e 37 118d 125 42 150 528 reference 43 M 476 bequest 413 531 sp, 133AD adequate prtctn 179AD 435 165S 983 535 insurance 3 LRA 443n presumption 120 AD 262 537 limitations 33 70 26 15 M 561 17 CP 06 76 546 town bond'g r 101 NY -ion 490 S95NY 47 676 48 548 injunction e 30 644 appealable c 60 306 enforcement 147AD 148 132 S 201 553 arrest * 101 NY 639 555 illegal ev. 33 35 true test' 39 40 41 43 tn b't 1)7 11 CP dower ■iJ a .ijieresLed lasB iiJ AD 230 219 118 237 95 3i6 168 651 171 766 565 allow extra aUoNV 666 35 430 3 AD 22 568 parties » 96 N if 627 570 affidavit 41 198 5738upl. complt, e 07 aSb 62 AD 17 a AC 280n 10 AC 283n Reparation 21 M 379 nil AD 285 576 appeal • yaNi^ aiueiidinent i96NY £ 91 M 155 S procedure £ 157 AD ultra vires 157 AD 142 S new trial 142 S 610 370 454 249 513 511 624 025 579 lien bank 180AD 167S lien mdse. do 180AD do 167S 170 713 172 714 586 conspiracy 42 56 92 30 AD 55 AD 11 M 19 M 25 M 156 614 605 514 578 212 294 611 588 conspiracy 135AD 240,243 59 I parol ev. 35 41 37 601 48 IS NC 478 conclusive 22 M 436 604 596 neg. damgs. * 99 NY 606 4JM 274 161 S 444 605 marriage m 96 NY 201 trust deed 107 AD 466 deed valid 35 CP 99. 100 maintenance 137S 170 619 exemptions *96NY 32 S3 41 AD 56 AD 69LRA attachable 32 M 171 NY 646 480 346 392 346 90 322 628 penalty r 98NY 503 632 title vest'g e4lAD 417 636 no appeal 57 ?4 79 88 117AD maudamuB 112 AD modify order 36 AD 2 AC 683 bond e44 185 191 541 372 809 124 542 210 14b 644 enforcement 132 S 291 who question i47AD 148 646 book aects 12 AD 232 649 sureties case 4 a 96 NY 43 VOL 31 I new lease 177AD 864 164S 900 5 jury question * 95 NY 672 1 allowance 33 234 e 66 127 40 AD 33 52 AD 267 e 64AD 555 556 132AD 168 AD 245 13 M 347 26 M 253 7 AC 78n 80n 153 S 4 fee spl. gnardn. 19A0 91n restrict amount 203 NY 257 (3 new trial' e 30 M 486 e 101 AD 28 1 7 arbitration a 95 NY 242 r 99 NY 488 46 illegal ev. a 98 NY 640 37 125 339 20 revi 83 26 AD 5 M 38 M 4 AO 571 411 489 141 38n modification 49 M 604 abrogation 59 M 331 injunction 113 AD neg. 28 36 55 60 6 AD 34 AD 113 AD 175 AD 5 M 7 M 10 M 11 M 14 M d 20 M 29 M 87 M insufficient 4W M defect street' 127S liability 181AD 161 S 168S 274 notice 175 212 73 184 190 448 193 445 116 736 273 440 571 354 108 ev. 528 334 997 655 32 capital stock 72 130 36 commissions 95 NY 954 210 NY 87 d 39 AD 475 receiver fee 17 AC 197n 17 AO 201n 40 trial police 31 213 regular d 84 AD 373 42 arbitration case 16 a 95 289 43pers. injuries case 15 r 101 NY 396 45tax exempt'n case 4 redress 179 remedy 557 618 146 574 529 262 37S 158 543 736 253 181 161 561 408 47n 350 49 49 by-laws 50 e 54 59 39 AD 53 AD 66 AD 68 AD 76 AD e 78 AD 110 AD s 10 NO 19 M- ■iS U q 34 M e 37 M 15 NO 130 S amendment 54 M d 60 M termination By M interference sick benefits 20AC 54n 94 M. 131 132 157 S 468 55 knowledge 31 AD 301 not vicious 142 S 1080 57charge corrct 64 78 rc-verse error 113 AD 341 61 discovery 57 M 362 65 preference 101 NY 226 35 130 40 330 22 NC 335n 69 promise ? 53 233 judgment valid 87 highway case 8 a 55 AD 92 damages a 96 NY 55 AD 59 AD 632 93 637 563 620 582 59 474 96 allegations 11 M 428 98 insurance a 101 NY 362 1 00 death neg. a 96 NY 562 104 will dower m 96 NY 496 106 foreclosure a 98 NY 657 107 judgment a 96 NY 550 neg. liability 20 NO 17 1 12 easement damages 36 432 83 145 nuisance 1 LRANS 89n 1 1 4 surprise a 96 NY 676 60 AD e2M 1 32AD ICP NS remedy 134AD discretion 18 IAD 168S 48 M 72 costs a 95 NY s 98 NY 518 663 336 intersection NO 433 78change venue 624 517 263 S4 72 88 affidavit 26 M 27 M 3 AO 306 587 151n 8 1 evidence s 5 SS 83 expenses 131 S indemnity 74M 85 nuisance ease 13 101 NY 173 232 115 16 NO 256 86change case 11 97 NY waive objectns. 18 AO 436n oTade 238 470 549 211 358 571 814 1037 119 commissns. 167 16 AO 420n I2lwife contrct d 22 NO 291 wife liable 126S 934 141AD 813 122 negligence damages 40 335 167 111 AD 352 I25duty r.-r. co. 40 577 1 28 settlement e 32 67 64 647 attorney lien 77 572 34n 5 M M 18 NC discontinuance 7 AO 441n 8 AO 98n 1 29 limitations 102 NY 494 p 43 . 266 barred do 160 AD 501 I40court's pwr. 245 192 262 243 NO 264 confirmation 40 AD 7 M 24 M 39 M 565 308 337 395 I55afl'dt 36 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished c* criticised : 1, limited; e, explained ; o» overruled publn 224 1, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, not* s, same case ; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, questioned Vol. 31 N. Y. Supreme Coart Reports— H«n e 43 631 14 M 77 2 AO 97 20 AO 226ii e 127 NY 498 jurisdiction 71M 48 127S 242 157 jurisdiction 2 LBA 828n 158 jurors r 96 NY 115 21 NO 418 422 21NC 446 understood 216 NY 336 164 tenancy 5 AC 139n 166 evidence 6 AD 214 349 499 187 167 lunatic a 96 NY 665 7 AD' injunction 16 AD 80 AD jurisdiction 19 NO incompetent 114 AD 464 objections 19A0 76n 79 enforcement 137AD 345 l76BUspensioD: e 41 M 77 claim vs. lunatic 19A0 78n 183 vacate sale 41 615 46 215 eq. conversion 58 AD 446 doubtful title 22 NO 407n 1 87 sureties e 62 388 e 26 M 51 p 98 NY 286 138 NY 192 attachment * 95 NY 673 28 371 84 M 679 686 2 AO . 209 conversion 18 AC practice 81 M 143 S 417 331 222 judgment a 96 NY 660 costs 18 NO 352 225 assault a 94 NY 526 231 costs atty a 96 NY 660 37 M 385 18 NO 352 233 privileged 35 431 88 312 19A0 858 19AC 362n examination 12 21 M 114 d 36 M 414 incrimination 116 AD 579 f 57 M 362 235 conclusive 529 construction 90 609 jurisdiction 11 AD 389 lien 18 AD 62 241 book entries 34 226 a 102 NY 572 e 3 SS 517 247doubtfultitle 41 316 22 NO 411n 256 compliance a 101 NY 652 33 59 issue execution 138S I95right 141 S receiver 3 57 AD appeal 81 M 172 appeal 210 204 198 114 assessment AD 332 199 perjury a 94 NY 490 2 1 5 unexecuted e 40 41 261 44 219 costs ♦ 96 NY e 51 84 * 1 AD 27 AD 87 AD 6 107 AD IS NO 22 351 1 AO 195n 270 6AC 336n 338n 10 AO 404 atty's power 118 NY 59 set off costs 18AC 272n atty. 660 286 247 471 125 546 528 48 defense 56 fraud 1 AO 23 NO 560 346 392n 14n atllachment 194 NY 409 3 AO 93n 22 NO 352 jurisdiction 127 AD 682 injunction 127AD 686 687 260 draft 101 NY 4 267 damages 36 331 d 43 572 271 attachment 8. AD 307 3 M 29 M 5 AO 132 NY 16 NO preference 22 NO ■ schedules 2 LEA 328n 497 498 234n 559 83 331n 286 54 74 d 90 2 AO cts. pwr. 128 AD reference 146 442 161 279 173n limitd 667 290court's pwr. s 12 NO 159 89 531 55 440 temp, allowance 119 NY 521 293 adv. possn. 17 AO 379n 297 conversion 102 NY 120 59 AD 272 73 AD 271 272 73 AD 275 do 73 AD 278 usage evidence 112 NY 535 30 1 waiver 23 M 600 305 stockholder T AD .03 AD 45 M 310 costs 142 S 360 352 costs e 42 f 44 172 688 354 necessaries a 98 NY 610 34 269 res judicata 42 14 358 abatement 34 13 limitations 37 198 illegal evidence 17 AO 74n deposition 66H 225 156 AD 432 860 embezzlemt NY 188 382 suspend sentence 141 NY 293 15 NO '162 power court 149 S 408 estoppel 149 S 413 384 foreclosure aJlowance 39 570 571 review error court 103 d 60 132 71 AD 429 48 M' 171 demurrer 58 M 472 election 129 AD 398 434 discovery 37 235 437 discharge surety 25 AD 517 negligence 124 S 387 delay surety 139 AD 765 441 alimony * 95 NY 667 no payment 95 M 667 5 1 4 costs a 18 NO 164 AD 150 S 56 n 736 113 135 158 273 100 297 553 10 629 10 44 272separ. bills 103 NY 84 13 NO 40 160 S f 96 M taxation costs d 44 M 278 274 compliance 101 NY 504 59 41 215 assigmt. relief 22 NO 310 ])referenoe 22 NO 282assets 34 43 52 57 4 SA 330n fraud 565 232 51 31 1 pers. injury 97 NY 620 43 591 allegations 48 AD 10 ordinance ev. 167 AD 174 152 S 923 construction 98 M 91 162 S 163 3(5 Stat, frauds case 16 a 1 SA 20 316 stockholdrs 1 7 to 17 r 96 NY 49 327uon resident 16 AD 623 residence proof 8 fi.0 379n amendment f 118 AD 813 329 47 p 58 59 79 e 81 92 15 AD 37 AD 2 SS SS 11 M 4 AO 5 AO 119 NY 125 127 339 e 82 preference 23 150 474 110 267 157 120 207 87 483 20 502 149 409n 109 535 513 NY NY undertakng 201 14 82 1151 343 good title 207 41 65 e 71 85 88 92 discretn. 3 AD 66 AD 99 AD 214 623 547 57 229 84 appeal 28 284 296 extra allowance 152 NY 617 387 foreclosure 6 AD 248 receiver 8 AO 114n 390 vacate Juflt e 53 100 63 414 392contrib 22 M neg. 605 397 credibility r 98 NY' 198 31 394 discretion 35 155 4 AD 447 add'l allowance 86 474 88 348 92 54 AD 48 409cl'm vs state 103 NY 1 fraud bar 23 NO 168n 417 indorser 29 AD 220 117 NY 504 420exr. trustee 342 under policy 42 828 42 1 costs 57 a 20 NO 55 56n 424 amendment 41 42 62 d 76 90 4 M attachment 66M 66 169 304 281 42 546 540 426 compensatn e92 3M 1 AC SAO 8 AC 164 NY 22 NO 417 599 230n ISgn 140n 141n 147 9 58n court power 132AD 522 443 amendment 64 431 d2M 210 treble damage i8 OP 442 449nianslaughter f 119 AD 748 452burden proof case 5 f 43 246 453 sup. pro case'l e 36 111 458 personal. transaction case 6 r 98 NY 206 Limitations case 10 a 102 NY 720 a 1 SA 167 457 exemption case 9 p 35 650 E 36 585 458 admiuistratr m98NY 511 ei 611 chose in action tl7AD 6 2 SA 344 pers. repreaentns 16 M 524 17 NC 430n remedy 118 NY 656 467 illegal ev. 39 116 82 198 476 prom, void a 98 NY 426 61 108 484 deposit 101 NY 503 21 NO 383n 49 I prox cau se 39 434 54 629 79 506 i8AC 440n, 442n 500 implied re- peal 77 377 joint expense 136AD 177 522 assent r 120 NY 36 release dower 64 220 ins, and taxes 20 NC lOSn 526 jurisdiction 151 NY 66 do 184 NY 34 no appeal 3SCP 238 529 replevin 42 AD 458 67 AD 132 373 complaint 75 AD 338 30 M 599 53 1 town bonds 56 479 state tax fir. int 62 218 o 68 517 judicial notice 91 AD 305 308 presumptinQ use of streets 24 AD 364 376 e 24 AD 372 injunction 37 AD 43 fact question 95 AD f I44S 82 M appeal d2]NC 539 221 628 862n 535 undertaking a&pe 4 r98NY 539 hab. r96NY 72 M 132 S appeal 188NY 545 deed a 101 NY 281 corpus 381 645 250 444 647 S 229 302 134n e52 AD 104 AD nuisance dl7N0 18 NC interloc. judgm't 21 NC 350d encroachmt. 16AC 357 605 fr'd intent d 67 260 608 atty's lien a96NY 61 AD e87 AD 7M 9M 13 M 16 M lAO 6 AC 8 AC 10 AO f 18NC 629 352 646 387 564 613 617 76 335 337n 90n 403 2gn 550 assessment 240 361 410- 46 10 4190 a 101 NY "17N0 e98NY 558 costs c47 55 AD 9 AC 583 replevin 30 M 599 568 taxation « 99 NY 254 55 524 review 20 NC 47 50n 572 attachment d 44 73 3M 2 AC 87 291 68 360n 36 Id 575 serv. process 36 AD 62 •xpuls'n remedy a 15 NC authority 54M 39 OF 61n 284 302 578 demand note r 98 NY 379 582 premature 73 291 38 AD 459 2 AC 3Cln 596 waiver 20 AD 609 authority ♦ 95 NY 648 a 96 NY 629 34 - 468 remedy appeal 142 S 468 sheriff fees 105M 637 d 173S 814 6 1 2 disord child 21 AD 407 48 M 659 6 1 4 assault a 95 NY 541 6 1 7st. limitation * 119 NY 630 8 13 NC 413 62 190 evidence B 22 AD 376 575 4 SS 450 mandamus 12 NC K13NC 161 AD 146 S 156 413 827 889 619 limitation 2LKA 830d 622 accounting 77 AD 518 629 undertaking q 39 437 632 alimony ♦ 97 NY 623 634 costs discre- tion a 98 NY 186 45 579 64M 296 637 fraudulent case 2 e 34 565 638 jurisdiction case 1 B 20 M 78 640 divorce cape 7 a 102 NY 714 a 1 SA 74 infer marriage 71 NC 608n 118 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; c, criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, dipit jiting opinion; p, parallel case; q, questioned N. T. Supreme Court Reports — Hun Vol. 32 VOL 32. I remedies 69 26 a 23 NO lein 63 atty'a lien 67 647 5M 77 1 7 AC 441n * 13 CP 4 corpn. tolls 31 M 66 new trial 753 case 4 r 101 NY 7 employment oi case 6 childern contract r99NY 33 ' 204 ' 102 NY 228 353 funeral expense 68 fact question 23 M 22 III 65 case 9 1 SA 1S4 presumption Unt? ««°.7lplacetria, 119 AD 338 568 1 7 sale realty a 98 NY 1 7 CP 403 20 pers. injury r 96 NY 305 36 210 21 NO 4d 24 ice neglig a 105 NY 668 38 ' 288 290 46 49 68 AD 75 AD ISS d 122 NY do 159 NY SLRA 2 AD 7 AD 8 AD 3 AC 160n 153 108 AD 11 change venue 186AD 174S 39 CP directors 142 S 569 326 267 307 537 406 506 254n 29 inference r 102 NY 8 18NC 7 AD 35 affidavit r 101 NY 36 19 NC 7CP 487 246 410 73 vested rem'dr a 98 NY 372 54 504 78 bill partic 49 201 77 AD 518 2 LKA 481n receiver fee 17 AC 199n 79trustee interest 2LS.A 481n 82 unconstitu'l 394 398 38 bill lading r 102 NY 190 44 334 48 526 41 oral evidence 72 AD 383 94 AD 93 110 AD 46 judgt. lien 46 654 debt ohge. realty 121 NY "" " 433 d 26 M 48 M 49 trespass r 103 NY S14NC prescription 16 NC 5 1 good title a 102 NY e35 remainder 39 . unambiguous 91 M S not uncertain 91 M 110 38 53 parol ev 64M 599 123 conviction 54 referable 90 13 AD 31 M 75M 135S 23 300 439 514 35* I 669 99 NY 147 ins. policy 95NY 664 96 NY 666 53 taxation 99 NY 280 1 60 return depst 69LB.A 38n 62 joint liabil. 628 518 , 64 receiver e40 42 .^ do 204NY 461 jurisdiction ??1 b3AD 133AL rigni tii sue 134 S 15 virtue of mtge do 204Ny " SCO 440 341 229 r98NY 48 139 571 342 515 583 89 contract d36 40 claim city d26 AD appropriation d 10 M 134 t 159 S 661 159 S 93 discretion do 62 AD 1 05 fraud 67 115 NY I 1 2 removal S2 485 „.. . . . 74 AD 414 ^U4 injunction 228 14 M nnfi no answer """"1298 duty police bd. e 133 US 665 W4 AD 487 .„, ^ 2 1 dollar mark 126 a 96 NY 36 219 e81 in e 107 NY 219 s 14 NC e7M a 96 NY 130 1 26 will trust " r 104 NY 632 e35 38 592 17 M 743 58 cond. promise 78 511 seduction 81 391 140 S 459 1 38 jurisdiction 48 AD 520 3 AC 93n 94n 141 negligence 258*39 53 2 commisions 17 AC 201n 60 M 50 trustee 132 AD 802 46 69 ^4nx?S°°"° J?.?o costs condition a99NY 36M 1608 f 742 228 contempt 21 M 382 299 objections 404 239 damages 288 case 15 a 101 NY 526 „c. 240 damages R01 case 2 ^■'^ 102 NY 1 75 fr'd transfer 242 juricdiction 87 6 AD e71AD 37 M 1 78 jud'l notice a 59 NY 624 53 AD 354 184 trust a 6a d93 26 ICPNS 594 243 co-exr. case 15 r 103 NY 4 LKA 220 568 71 1 90 lex loci H AD 448 8M 295 12 M 231 46 M Bl 193 authority 19 AD 296 7 AC 255n 12 AC 177n 194 appeal 68 507 separate cause 64 AD 45 160 S 844 1 96 receiver 366 d 43 578 estoppel 87 390 339 revocation 8 40 M 37 171 2 AC 141 374 200 findings 5U M 112 i 64 69 257 34 M 387 466 77 121 124 160 75 631 7 CP 10 CP 135S 670 courts power 30 62 M 347 314 granting relief 338 d 75M 299 378 135 S 206 may restrain f 99M 310 209 indictable a 96 NY 408 14 AD 119 9nnj J doU dower A.n^ popular sense *"" do 188NY 487 lit. obscene 183AD 171S 220 lien 20 NC 223 trust fund 233 lat'l suppt 124AD 22 46 301 survivor ,g 238 tender ?2 184 -„j,p 1 1 co-tena: — „ ^^ Kiaca^eii ,„„„ e 19 M 202 „„ 6 AO 3^Jn ^^^^^^^ ^^ ^j^^^ 377 stockholder 457 „eg. dam 36 M 445 r 109 NY 454 , r» resid. legatees 1* M 16 NC . 135 ,_. , . construction •So* replevin 76M 83 8 35 136S 332 60 AD 366 lion 306 or. right 6n a 102 NY 647 indemnity 225NY 58 329 3 I 6 carp. 535 a 102 HY 245 exceptions e 10 M 366 superior title 36 M 203 rent 62M 552 maintain action 151 S 615 assign rents 166 AD 72 253 damages a 100 NY 641 8 AC 468n 470n 482n not recover f 167 AD 98 152 S 672 255 attachment 666 238 384 467 388 191 225n 5 AC a 96 NY 46 49 el4 AD do 173 NY 16 CP 20 NC 257 lease lien 34 90 law question 37 601 conversion 44 264 267 assignment 35 134 35 139 270 ult.a vires a 102 NY 44 66 13 AC 276 nom. dam d44 '" affidavit facts 754 88 AD 2 AC 6 AC 37 d 124 NY 77= marriage 606 114 NY °"° good faith 66M ^°*'' 288 bill costs a 101 NY 687 delivery 84 '" 236 S^'vi™'*''' interested. person ^^ ^D 120 AD 3 do IM severable 118 NY 130 NY eq. redemption 47/ 161 S 275 174 AD 377 605 189 f 448 consideration 18 M 179 f 398 considerat'n .-„, 64 403 472 hand writing libel 355 108n 3 1 8decreediscrn. 40 297 88 301 321 aumcient a 99 NY 1 92 35 1 LRA 563n ratification 51 AD 330 26 M 396 329jury question 646 594 359 525 246 _ 105 NY 7 AD waiver e8 AD e 13 AD 24 AD 332 joinder 3 AC 112 AD 7CP 8CP misjoinder 111 AD election 128 S repugnant 71 M 335 receiver a 98 NY 634 338 relief r98NY 38 41 306n 28 58 93 821 584 363 417 255 367 15 541 319 20n impeac'u witness 331 - 145 e 88 541 12 AD 265nl3AD bar 87 4 AC 204 12 AC 112n 451 ,„„ nn, <)..Kn..»»^.-.^« ^ — ^*" taxes 291 subornation ev. 152 166 NY 437 362n affidavits 88nl5NC 206n454,^,„y 347 damages 229 96 AD 298 350 dismiss com 120 a 98 NY 2 AC 131 131 S -M 501 ) general costs 89 M 608 360 referee fees m 102 NY 289 misconduct 10 CP 605 602 48 183AD 170S 365 warranty 47 298 '465 negligence 1 case 3 102 NY 362 prom, note case 9 102 NY 650 49 54 34 279 117 466 damages .„. case 1 2S? a 102 NY 107 exr. powers case 11 a 98 NY 342 e 81 521 221 *54 case 11 133 a 102 NY 489 no defense . 146 S 161 AD conclusive 88 M 150 S 408void contrao 16 NC 393n 412 affirmative defense 46 348 4 1 5 contrb. neg. r 98 NY 274 45 119 4 1 7 partition 97 AD 172 4 1 9 vesting case 1 a 98 NY 517 191 52 327 e53 111 e 34 M 103 10 AC 268n 26gn 420 sale case 9 34 case 12 appeal a 108 NY 20 621 432 bank neg. 69LRA 33 6n 434 easement 69 604 15 AC 222n 440prohib writ r 97 NY 630 100 NY 241 443prohib writ 66 AD 234 73 AD 344 345 223NY 254 446 demurrer e80 28 6M: 80 25 M 228 26 M 386 10 AC 284n 449 misconduct 602 69 a 102 NY 139 NY a 102 NY 105 457 exemption 1. a 97 NY 653 51 253n 119 NY 354protection [462 appeal 7JM. 231 a 96 NY 'laches 349 796 66 645 714 82 1075 135 NY 475 taxes a 99 NY 478 review *97NY 36 exemptions 56 AD attachaole 32 M 171 NY 456 181 606 587 346 90 322 48 1 disbursem'nt e40 42 f3S3 olSA 7CP 8CP 10 CP 11 CP 17 CP 15 NC 16 NC costs 8M o 103 NY 73 165 282 216 334 18 9 300 302n 214 453 216 469 681 486 no cause action 173S 474 49 I taxation m 98 NY 67 62 438 497 damages a 97 NY 630 counsel fees 82 AD 45 29 M 298 8 AC 464n 482n diligence 177AD 732 164 S 519 504 substitution 692 alOO NY 287 136 *1 129 54 87 9 AC S23n 13 185 508 widen street a 102 NY 81 - 39 241 648 57 284 682 change route 94 e 57 M 218 authority 57M 672 d.iraAgea 125 S 218 132 ABRKEVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m modified- * dismicisrH • 7~ c. criticised; 1, limited; e, cjtolained; o, overruled; s, same case, do, dissenting opinion ; P, pa'rallel case" q. quMtiM«l Vols. 32, 33 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Hun intention 140 AD 263 5 I 5 leg, custody 51 610 150 NY 58 foreclosure 197NY 41 executor's "will 96 M 426 lOlM 468 160 S 377 167S 165 521 jurisdiction 42 2" el2AD 68 d 17 AD 174 d 23 M 50 25 M ,77 15 AC 196n magistrate 17 AC 960 judicial 17 AC eoDtrib. neg eSH 628 justification dug NY 186 634 nuisance 17 AD 639 fixtures 82 llOn 526 negligence d 40 1S« e 42 1'' io AD 299 notice claim 5 AC 308n 3l0n e 105 NV 50 530 injunction 46 61" not enjoin 171S 546 533 city neg.^^^ 43 59) 4 LRA 3271, 536 definite trm m 97 NY 212 (12 ^°^ 7CP 409 habeas corpus 16 NC «4 140 S 408 538 i"'^i^'i''='iS9 123 S 68S relief appeal 68 M 30S 543 Corp. note 45 AD 91 48 AD ^^ 328 principal bound 83 AD 619 105 AD 404 545 allowance 48 252 Tm 370 encroachment 164S 924 55 I costs 40 AD 307 563 contempt r 99 NY 46S 45 491 4 LRA 104 1)99 jurisdiction 138S 1110 TOM 467 602 injunction r 102 NY 600 612 titip office a 101 NY 539 6 1 8 damages a 98 NY 636 d 38 AD. 476 commissions 16AC 412n 62 1 fact quetttion 40 AD 242 225 640 negligenee ease 11 r 102 NY 219 641 insurance case 6 a 102NY 200 642 foreclosure c&s« 2 a 102 NY 675 conversion case 10 i 102 NY 6X1 a 1 SA 70 conRtructioD ca»e 11 34 204 jurisdiction 16 M 645 affidavits 5 AC 378n 644 damages case 12 a 106 NY 503 50 4 SO ifniption AD 456 427 190 VOL.33. 7 bonds a 98 NY 553 I 6 contrib neg. r 2 BA 82 28 abatement a 98 NY 646 59 539 dower e 65 AD 304 305 8 AC 335 32 privileged 88 312 8M 176 12 CP 11 19AC 361n discovery 67M S62 i4 pleadings 59 455 73 616 24 AD 277 e 60 AD 374 67 AD 373 90 AD 190 1 S M 426 49 M 25 e 66 M .^7^ 133 NY 246 IHIAU 291 legal conclusion 166 AD 68 151 S 607 laws of Turkey e 213 NY 435 competent 161 S 846 44 authority 1 499 e 135 NY 277 47 court's duty 68 409 54 jurisdiction a 97 NY 619 42 91 57 creditor's sui' a 103 NY 302 89 277 48 660 fr'd preference 22 NC 340n 342n 5 CP 426 60«&>rfBfture r 99 NY 124 II AD 413 hot precluded 23 NC ^87 T reinsured 170 NY 99 70AD 71 73AD 162 27M 249 69 illegal ev, 37 122 e 68 586 68 688 86 403 48 AD 97 AD 432 15M . 290 competency 142AD 114 incompetent ev. 126S 1017 pers. commctn. 205NY 397 76 dower r 124 NY 689 37 229 §41 487 46 282 11 CP 301 82 as strangers 174 AD 511 161 S 155 89 legacies m98NY 311 44 330 18 NC 295 98 jurisdiction 97 M 256 162 S 847 I I I injunction 114M 118 dSNC 131 n infringement 119 AD 907 I I 4fact question a 97 NY 649 8 M e.'^S order a 97 NY 649 6CP 78 I I 6 alimony 26 M 492 imprisonment 7 AC 264n discharge 20AC 2nnr, 157 S lllR 172 AD 923 I I Qjurv question a 97NY U2 35 302 4 LRA 7.58 I 36 assessment r 97 NY 601 138 forfeit insur 48 285 77 385 136 NY 15) 2LIIA 120 estoppel 114 AD 770 143 pleading s 33 544 34 430 e 39 144 6 CP £o 9CP )2C « 14 NC 318 15 NC 269n 1 45 acctg. profit 66 AD 33 bar 9M 232 146 receiver rent e 64 546 148 em. domain del AD 486 "addition" 140AD 416 "-facility" 1.S4S 70.-, discretion 146 S 677 161 AD 333 1 56 receiver 34 371 45 AD 123 I 60 injunction 56 a09 55 M 3b 1 69 bar a 103 NY 25 39 4lj2 41 397 e46 132 47 638 5 LRA 693li elect remedy 10 AD 428 77 AD 456 23 NC 163n estoppel 4M 373 election 125 S 40 not conclusive 69 M 118 186 fire escapes s46 67 31 268 194 NY 48 jury question 9M 100 53 M 32 191 defense 50 . 342 193 bar 39 462 23 NC 166n 198 law remedy 48 100 147 S 65-1 85 M 535 -urefy .■!.->S 051 ■ability TP,M fi.-.! 200 assessment r97NY 492 17 AD 363 205co.d subseq 37 AD 350 45 AD 222 298 bail 16 AC 392n 2 I 4 antenuptial a 99 NY 29 e42AD 446 18 NC 158n 160d 18 NC 240 21NC 350n 2 LRA 377 220 oH'I. bond r 99 NY 532 107 NY 117AD 408 47 1 preference d 35 278 49 486 123 NY 575 474 covenants 557 creditor suit 43 149 160 46 630 87 324 mtge.void 27 AD 630 127 NY 624 findings 55 AD 618 520 injunction 39 M fraud e IBINY 16 AD 4 SA 132 NY release 7SM necessity ISIAD 168S 418 431 436 esult 478 351 768 484 affidavit • 100 NY 640 41 87 17 M 32 M 2 AC 16 NC 7CP 15 CP 65 262 274 243 16 62n 344 348 293 178 489 compromise a 99 NY 611 62 136 500 findings 23 NC 279n 50 I agency r 105 NY 283 r 18 NC 477 505 indictment 124S 45 139 AD 574 5 I 3 int. coupons 85 AD 39 520 sale bonds B 100 NY 608 4 SS 351 d 118 NY 144 d 20 NC 430 42 505 567 parol tract a 108 NY 71 AD 120 NY tenant surrender 8 AC 430n modi6oation 54M 72 M con- 31 420 263 574 salaries 138 S authority 153AD no violation 103AD additional 144 S 852 misjoinde a 109 NY 441 49 287 364 49 387 64 432 e 116 NY 696 7 01* 46 16 CP 147 192 abrogation 49 386 660incompet ev. base 5 r 1 UA 241 662 commissioub a9e22 a 98 N Y 527 664 pers. injury ease 36 a 99 NY 136 667 commission case 20 a 102 NY 678 a 1 SA 6; I eceiver case 22 2SS 472 pay 125 578 jurisdiction d35 45 90 71 M 130S substituted vice 120 NY e 128 NY 582 findings further 124 S 8 583 limited 40 48 waiver do 8 AD VOL 34 I lex delictocfl^ 48 AD 9 64 AD 277 .102 NY 311 objection 16 NC 433 burden deft. 217 NY 584 6 process defense 48 ?34 65 341 I I cause passing 37 198 abatement 113 AD 46 1 6 services 84 267 construction aSM ■ 510 Corp. liable OHM 140 liability 123 fci 277 I 9 penalties a 103 NY 143 26 ch'k proceeds d 9 M 346 347 undisclosed pnn i4aAU 505 131 S 199 33frlEh[ damages 17 Ai: I30n neg. damages 88 ohattxl mtge 1 57 alimony 46 298 668 stockholder case 7 « 102 NY 41C 445 70 234 588 84!) ser 496 396 662 217 108 589 estoppel a 106 NY 196 87 618 88 47 bill lading do 173S 655 a 102 NY 6S0 53 215 e 15 AD ■231 e 167 NY 320 usage ^U ivl 565 141 S 935 38 review 82 225 intent controls 69 M 298 tixtures 09 M 302 127S 265 transform 127S 263 47 chat. mtge. a 103 NY e42 e lUl NY 18 NC 19 NC 116 160 SOB 336 283n 50 fact question r 102 NY 663 e 43 240 57 chat. mtge. 59 41 e48AD 348 presumption 77 AD 107 AD replevin 84 M f 145 S 64 tender 21 AD 35 M 646 303 194 851 304 352 9 I cond. prece 91 607 fr'dlt transfer a23NC 14n 94 estate 48 154 Incompetent ev 4 as 269 bona fide holder 16 M 293 h. and v/. cntract 18AC 20n 97 contract 66 451 carrier neglig. 127 NY 449 1 04 recovery a 99 NY 616 e86 14 lOQrule damage iaa NY 251! 1 I 5 atty neglig. a 02 uoi e31 M 252 e 7 AC 390 122 NY 390 122 NY 150 void contract m NO 36311 lor jury 76M 135S intent l3oS true rule fiM 490 655 656 491 d 60 479 e71 365 366 d 129 NY 669 49 M 600 sup. procedure 1 AC 157n 4 AC 40n 1 6 I injunction 38 4 1 M 122 jurisdiction e 44 M 491 177 NY 507 12/ AU 602 I 67 assumption r 107 N Y 83 46 473 incompetent ev. 16 617 meas. damages 19 M 583 191 US 350 132 NY 480 191NY 3a4 1 78 new trial 36 169 161 S 5«4 96 M 281 aw question 43 47 60 4SS appeals 123 AD 192 authority 70 reservation 34 74 rejection 86 216 NY contract 118AD acceptance 140 S 565 377 319 316 523 80 abandonment ILTiANS 1182n I 2 I use streets r 102 NY 441 e 81 268 abutt'g owner e 122 NY 13 public policy 19 NC 1940 I 26 penalty 44 496 evidence error 67 580 1 2 8 Indorser 06 351 1 30 rule custom 42 80 76 184 ev. negligence 19AC 214n contrib. . neglig. igAC 209n 132 spi objectn 10 M 392 I 36 warranty 47 AD 276 e 92 AD 37 1 38 valid order 54M 3^ jurisdiction 390P 90 140 damages 126 AD 49i- I 43 town bonds a 98 NY 599 authority ISnS 4.37 no authority 77M ■ 364 1 50 remedies 106 AD 460 151 S 1004 I 53 master neg r 103 NY 325 20AC contempt 92 M 156S relief 92 M resettle 185 AD 173S 239 sureties d48 53 AD e27 164 S appear 177AJ) lOOM 165S 243 substitution 33 35 91 642 646 r98NY 15 NC 47 4 AC 18 NC 250 untenantable 31 AD 1 M 12 M 29 M 1 AC 5 AC 5 AC 60 67 469 375 377n 373 37 6n 376n 380i< 25 48 NY iiu comity ii7 M liability HOS 205 exemp e42 12 32 lis NY -ienors 186AD 388 ,468 dam 311 312 285 £3* 337 2 1 7 determiuatn i 99 NY 145 e89 661 ^ui rogate power e5M U6 24 M 498 22 I illegal ev. 40 54 d77 e86 S7 4SS 3SA 127 NY 128 182 629 471 478 556 38 459 634 10 AC 119n compliance 138AD 280 discharge 134S 23a 20 AC 2091) error court 74M 331 cond. precedent at snon 462 163 538 247 448 404 379 115 will 553 186 422 16 85 629 63 n 450 31 AD 48 AD 4M SAC reasonable 171 AD 157. S 472 143 207 431 time 707 800 224 entries ev. s 104 NY 674 a 1 SA 331 9 AC 150n 227 damages 148AD BT3 obligation 90 M 151 t 132 S 951 235 alimony povert y a98NiD 19 AD f 27AD 35 M 7 AC 252error award f 216 NY 548 254 insur. int. a 102 NY 623 42 25fi 263 reformation d51 151 345 143 AD 668 f 153 S 621 266 certiorari 85 418 267 expenditure 15 252 272 civil damage act r 99 NY 651 34 313 e61 93 275 reas. care 7M 10& 280 abortion a 98NY 630 292 neg. coserv't 1 62 12 16 M 226 122 aD 379 298 jurisdiction 22 AD 191 presumption 67 AD 454 139 NY 46 onus proband! 79 XI 45!) direct proof 141 S 20G 302 punishment ♦ 103 NY 178 44 M 339 4 AC 266n 131 S S(S5 ABBREVIATIONS; a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; c criticised; 1. limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, dissenting opinion; p. parallel case; q, questioned Vols. 34, 35 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Hun misconduct 72 M 429 3 1 2 exemp. dam 34 272 3 1 4 compensatn 64 26 320 limitations 115 NY . 86 right action 77M 512 no demand 137S 982 321 earnings •99 NY 66« 36 bi 40 602 assessment 126 NY nn 17 NC ■AT2 20 NC .4yn 33 1 damages e36 va excessive damage 82 157 charge • 23 AD 14H eS AC 127 334 estoppel 14 M 357 339 strike out 84 348 76 AD 136 7 AC . 263 n punishment 20AC 298n 34 1 nuisance a 108 NY 338 349 estoppel 147AD 378 153AD 484 132 S 172 undertaking 138S 252 J negl _ r 99 NY 185 8 43 459 o 83 651 8t limitation 20 NC 430 358 constitut'nl e 35 629 401 title office a 99 NY 43 4 1 4 r r consent 68 238 429 demurrer e 47 307 20 NC 3 43 1 amendment 65 210 62 305 84 AD 398 433pun, damage 42 62 71 79 92 24 AD 50 AD f 68 AD 71 AD el M 12 AC 12 AC 116 NY 312 236 81 38 244 620 113 628 476 372 79n 80n 81n 634 44 I pub ic park a 99 NY submit claim lli'J s e interest 144 AD 5B'J 365 dower r 103 NY 163 366 suits in tort a 103 NY 645 42 158 69 191 ' malice corpn. 61 AD 326 2M 304 5 AC 107n 106 NY 670 369 injunction 69 473 dissolution oorp. 756 444 condemntu 69i.RA 766 457 assignment a 106 NY 476 d 42 630 preference 19 NC 385q 22 NC 330n 463 hab, corpus 38 128 26 M 126 27 M 458 47 1 damages 42 590 3 AC 313n 146 S 318 order do 145 S 1116 acquittal do 160 AD 924 476 death claim 506 taxation a 99 NY 154 20 NC 64n 509 limitation e 48 173 112 NY 561 damages 2LRA 830n 5 1 damages 2LKA 830n 5 \ r certificate 9 AC 44n 46n 5 1 4 life estate r 103 NY 463 r 18 NC 291 5 1 9 Buppletory affidavits 41 67 521 reduce bid 135AD 739 preference 137AD 202 direct applicatn 149AD 840 134 S 82 524 foreclosure a 98 NY 664 44 662 1 129 NY 175 court's power' 67 M 588 124 S 526 acct. restAted 139 AD 677 585 open decree 9M 626 legatees' rights 1 AC 308n 588 certiorari r 99 NY 648 602 residence 528 indictment 64 347 e 36 AD 413 534 factor a 106 NY 91 32 662 d41 SAC waiver 66 16 AD do 16 AD jurisdiction 28 M 41 M 18 NC 147 S 599 373n 490 BIS 628 678 170 443d 547 a 103 NY altJA appeal case 30 a 106 NY aliJA forfeiture ease 38 a 102 NY 642 179 651 477 531 607 neg. notice a 104 NY 459 e 38 290 1 SS 242 243 I Sa 246 620 theats ev. a 99 NY 667 542 accouDtiDg 38 599 33 AD 125 544 partes deft e 43 526 fraudulent 6 M 422 423 new cause action 8M 477 counterclaim 18 NC 379 547 settlement e40 478 accord a 106 NY .(OM 45 391 83 14 AD 38 AD 373 tort 59 M disregard 151AD 137S 394 S79 518 sever. 761 41 360 122 125 127 651 320 ihippii NY 119 r 106 393 hab. corpus, r 100 NY 20 396 reference r 99 NY 112 485 sureties 122 AD 162 AD do 162 AD do 162 AD 135S 147 S dol47 S 322 323 relief liability 76M 553 487 possession 64 621 survivorship 60 75 67 234 184 NY 158 492 sp. prfmance 41 316 time contract 4 AC llOn 497 requests f 33 M 586 4 AC 44n 9 AC 192n 199u 63 AD 82 AD 21 M 5 AC 163 NY omit rul 13 3 AD 273 596 288n 101 518 55 1 capacity sue 107 AD 469 46 M 352 equity suit 35CP 103 560 possession 107 AD 615 562 attachment 41 63 fr'd transfers 17 M 338 566 notice defect 152 NY 210 5M 190 571 navigation a 150 US 705 580 amendment d 10 M 738 624 possession case 18 r 103 NY 40 fr'd transfer case 19 r 103 NY intent 22 NC 632 sp. prfmance case 9 a 1 SA 93 claim S7M 66 633 case; do. dissenting opinion ; p. parallel case ; i), que.tio»4 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Hun Vol. 35 1 53 allowance 8 35 148 19 M 23S 1 62 partiton 78 AD 606 1 68 set oS 61 AD 320 30 M 83 ] 14 NY 640 undisclosed prin 149AD 595 1 73 replevin 41 16 d2M 196 persnl. property 130 S 299 1 82 title a 102 NY e60 COcltB 128 NY B LB A 278d pension 38 CP 257 covenant 6LRA 278n 260 rule damage 42 £69 267 huBb. & wife 37 141 75 436 122 NY 320 IS NO 405 272 commisBions 730 642 177 I 86 loBB service 7M d 21 NO 30 lOn 161 162 208 395 409 420 8U4 214 193 user 39 AD 53 AD drainage 145 AD 145 AD cause action 184S 845 202 holding over 84 AD 363 6 M '266 9M 683 a21NC . 311n counterclaim 64 M 694 204 discharge e 118 NY 489 208 ordinance d45 44 2 1 2 libel a 116 NY 2 I 4 irregular 64 e46M 3BA 16AC 141AD , resignation 127S 275 services 55 596 B8 ' 384 express promise 6M 167 implied promise 19 M 94 113 NY 94 disallow 169S 802 28 1 demurrer lOS NY 203 180 t 43 M BID 4M 121 47 M 436 game for gain 56 M 289 public sports S8 M 645 128 AD 42 125 8 784 142 S BS8 159 S TC 3 moving pictures 62 M 104s crime when 69 M 55 wrongful acts 155 S , 966 authority 96 M 66 329 village neg. 122 AD 40 334 liberal con- struction r 108 NY 534 42 852 22 NG 91n 338 knowledge 11 AC 234n 441 267 243 428 BS 17 AD 25 AD B3 AD TOAD 73 AD 657 d 658 d 93 AD 400 W2 AD 428 127 AD 151 171 AD 729 do 171 AD 734 247 133 86 34 362 204 20 do 26 45 e 101 AD costs trial 7M 34 M 15 AC 21 NC 13 CP costs demurrer ISAC 41 In I 220 legal right 6 349 490 352n 100 IM 387 2M 618 10 M lU 14 M 696 24 M 60S 1 AC 342 2 AC 276 11 AC 176 177n 11 AC 178n IB NC 36i f 157 S 1072 157 S 1074 judgment 157 S 1071 equitable relict 171 AD - 730 183AD 139 a 99 NY 40 19 NC. necessity 113 AD 12 12 426 652 287 68M 238 construction 7 AD 631 128 AD 762 execution 22 M 264 58 M 623, 624 11 CP 353n 149 S 1050 lien on realty 87 M 17 f 87 M 18 applicable 149 S 1049 247 uncertainty 49 14 127 NY 171 253 new trial e 7 AD 406 24 M 214 laches e 4 M 609 d 21 M 154 254 foreclosure 106 NY 326 284 misjoinder 58M ' distinction 194 306 condemnatn 38 419 3 1 1 compliance 120 AD 369 indictment 145 AD 098 130 S 507 3 1 7 deed trust a 104 NY 45 15 AC 161n amendment 38 CF 21 324 authority a 42 609 liberal constctn 77M 417 137S 758 327 Sabbath breaking 65 162 140 NY 21ti 9 M 190 191 13 M 692 38 M 172 92 M 21 339 partition 27 M 611 341 receiver 61 666 11 M 205 do 204NY 518 action lies 139 S 600 344 irreguarity a 108 NY 661 47 154 jurisdiction 120 NY, 439 dismissal 51 M 667 345 demurrer d47 SM 818 e 27 M 633 10 AC 330n com. law proof 97 M 252 162 S 844 347 oontrib. nee. 129 AD 802 349 pers injury r 104 NY 434 47 663 355 stockholder 40 396 40 AD 428 68 AD 4 3 AC 369n minority stock- holders do 154AD 36 no injunction do 139 S 3' 366 jud'lsale r 99 NY 403 21 NC 3S8n 22 NC 402n 369serv]ce cor n 1 115 NY 14 CP 16 CP 17 CP manag agent B2M 409 220 NY 270 175S 414 do 175S 421 authorized do 175S 415 372 certificate 89 161 s 15 NC 241 9 AC 44n 60n 378 Btenog. fees 18 M 79 counsei fees 7 AC 245n 18 NC 32n 380 insanity 61 466 43 AD 70 75 AD 337 76 AD 396 11 AC 436n440n 11 AC 444n445 12 AC 120 386 note corpn - -■ 624 292 12 CP 57M 390P 11 362 87n 42n 465 468 434 equity 24 AD c24AD special iBBUes 6 AC 268n 270n 6 AC 271n 272n 137 NY 116 444 jurisdiction a 11 NY- 582 53 456 71 M 588 130S 849 447 probate will 167 566 15 AD 29 M requeatB 4 AC 9 AC authority 11 3 AD 44n 200n a 103 NY 42 455 waiver 16 AD jurisdiction d 11 M 28 M 12 CP. nonjoinder e32M appearance 33 M assignment 4 AC a4on abatement 19 NC 276 471 contempt 8M 161 200 393 constitut'l 112 NY jurisdiction 4 AC 10 CP county 2LiiA not apply 220 NY 395 aSEldavit 39 40 41 d44 77 19 M 2 AC 401 devise r 103 NY r20NC .38 trustee 4M 16AC .324 247 262 358 478 defects a 90 NY s 16 NC 43 485 53M 400 501 66 87 316 412 68n 650 471 591 a 99 NY 48 d 51 56 72 78 e85 65 AD' 2SS do 12 M 11 M t27M 27 M 2 AC 231 235n construction 76M 389 137S 90 410 sequestratn. 96 44 328 rlOTNV SAD 3M demurrer 21 M 16 AC costs 156 AD 14) S 623 108 671 283 2 84 662 377 294 r99NY 1 LRA 533 usage 2U 541 affidavit 39 400 41 68 2 AC 62n 12 CP 442 544 stockholder 202NY 14 548 appeal a 110 NY 627 553 sup. complt 29 AD 71 note issue 12 M 208 556 title pledge 43 141 delivery 82 M 149 143 S 401 569 jurisdiction 17 M 478 safe guard f 214 NY 386 575 presumption 637 notice do 77 AD 49» 64 1 right aliena- 92 41 AD 62 AD d67 AD 78 AD 16 NC 19 NC 676 309 87 138 NY waiver e 173 NY 74M 132S jurisdiction 208 NY eligible d 208 NY 480 cond. sale 1.13 S 1000 construction 230e234 488possessn. ev. 178AD 482 f 165S 172 492 ref. report set aside d 62 344 1 AD 106 3M 444 14 M 574 38 M 242 42 M 3 501 sp'l. damage 72 637 bill partic. 19AC 6n 504 atty's lien 806 333 77n 196 40 16 34n 163 255 237 64 128 681 617 393n 461n 558 306 180- 168 647 pension ex empt 49 41 20 AD 244 e 31 M 642 4 AC 124n 12Sn e 7 AC 469. e 119 NY 14 CP 38CF 124 S exemption 66M 627 personal favor 66M 627 waiver 124 S 168 65 I covenant 114 M 444 5LRA 279n corporeal inter. 128S 867 persnl^ property 18: .,143 AD 879 197 714 236n 60 173 61 3SS I AC II CP 13 CP 18 NC 679 192 301 430 603 33 297 405 19 353 483 •8 652 721 70 74n 4 1 4 condemnatn e 26 AD 24 42 I restrnt trade a 106 NY 473 d54 22 NC 199 4LRA 156n equity relief e 13 AD 213 1 LRA 461 4 LRA 166n injunction 179AD 428 430 discovery 76 611 88 312 506 error court 20AC 147n 507 surety a 103 NY Ul 512 bequest a 102 NY 154 NY 20 NC 516 constitutional 580 illegal ev 65 223 5 LRA 293n 582 repaymt txs 5LRA 292n 584burden proof 39 206 presume malice 45 122 privileged 5 AD 608 e 107 AD 309 burden plaintiff 150AD 867 135S 360 for jury t 146 S 834 60 I unoccupied 46 332 86 36 e 92 228 do 100 AD 284 606 prox. cause * 101 NY 17 47 56 18 AC 304n 6 1 Sburden proof 48 180 78 202 ego 121 24 M 40 813 654 subject mtg. ,„„ 5LRA 279n 196 663 larceny case 2 ■ al03 NY 587 indictment case 4- a 113 NY 647 case 8 app'al time s 2 SA . 89 case 15 limitatne. r 105 NY 636. r 1 SA 439 case 17 trespass a 106 NY 848 case IS subro atn r 108 NY 509 case 24 appeal, a 108 NY 128 case 26 contract ' a 103 NY 264 827 698 742 213 482n 24 42 126 NY e 172 NY witnesses 140 S read evidence 210 NY 206 155AD 145 528 prohibition 6 1 7 ejectment 35 M 540 mortgagee 116AD 476 134AD 256 assignee f 211 NY 88 no jurisdiction 217 NY 528 622 partnership 39 100 625 pollution of stream 37 184 633 value lease 120 AD 708 em. domain 124 S 825 665 findings case 7 m 1 SA 215 666 services case 14 a 103 NY 663 1 SA 209 case 15 services a 7 SA 203 case 20 appeal a 110 NY 634 case 26 freight a 106 NY 648 a 1 BA 395 667 rulings case 4 e 23 M 483 case 5 appeal 19 680. 583 r 108 NY mortgage case 7 r 107 NY rlSA case 9 appeal » 101 NY 641 appeal case 12 a 110 NY 634 exceptions 123 S 303 669 ejectmet't case 18 s 120 NY 109 670 trust devise case 26 36 371. aABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished: f. followed; r, reversed; ni, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; C criticised ; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel caM ; q, questioned Vol. 36 N. T. Supreme Court Reports— Hun VOL. 36 I re-maniage 43 376 oiv. damaEe act e90 47 6 civil death a 110 NY 317 f 60 524 1 2 trust fund 33 M 577 conBtructiou e 42 M 397 20 discretion 40 AD 658 16 U 124 24 presumption 39 224 19 AD 538 conclusive ev, 127 NY 79 44 coiti e37 41 61 del m2BB 8 AC o 115 NY 241 264 456 355 111 24&n 174 47 limitations d41 211 41 250 139 NY 469 52 discharce 43 289 title of act 64 67 73 1 151 NY 611 27 278 643 41 receiver 75 trust eSO SB assignment 9M preferences 86 149 NY 166 NY 87 costs il2 AD atty's lien 36CP lien costs 18A(J 90 demurrer 63 AD forgery 46 M 1 00 duress r 107 NY U6NY 1 04 costs e43 2461 1 65 discoverj 82 M 183 143 S 355 622 481 419 610 419 121 6:21 842 341 272n 388 87 111 612 18 1 68 deed trust a 105 NY 416 I 74 damages 26 AD 76 AD e5U 21 U rule 111 AD division 103M 170S 57 appeal • 109 NY 648 2 8A 55 extension payt. 16 M 675 114 NY 197 1 07 injunction "101 NY 640 e 132 NY 407 I 1 2 husb. & wife a 108 NY 25 1 tib 250 fr'd transfer e 115 NY 504 duress HB NY 612 613 I 1 5 presumption II AC . 419n signals evidence 13 AC 421n427n 1 22 exr. trustee a 103 NY 678 a 1 SA 220 134 sup. ia7AD pro. 718 66 authority , 39 178^ 1 38 personalty 65 6:43 53 e 125 NY 65 rents profits 180 NY 103 70 implication 39 149 68 38;i waiver e 13 AD 125 93 M lai extension time e 90 AD 543 93 AD 308 28 M 56 72 set aside ver diet 82 157 74 life estate conditional a 114 NY 307 d 67 246 description 68 494 fact question e 79 525 fee vested do 7 IAD 350 44M 439 divesting fee 131 NY 183 deed deliver 68M 388 transfer 125S 961 action fails 170 AD 530 44 31' 41 AD 207 chat, mortgage 19 NC 282n 32 AD 90 AD 107 AD 149 malice s 1 S e 11 AD 79 fraud, a99NY_ intent 673 212 417 4 472 740 stream - 379 179 1 77 drainage 75 424 85 AD 185 UlAD 740 181 disqualif'n. 45 312 e 20 M 522 1 94 bailment 17 M 390 1 99 neg. dam. 85 170 35 AD 479 res ipsa loquitur 80 AD 140 20 1 appeal right d 38 399 e38 70 reference 1 AC 408 discontinue 8 AC , 426n appearance 247 Umitations r 107 NY 303 253 error court laSNY 109 reasonable care 127S 391 142AD 340 256 legal title 134 .442 109 NY 34 asaetssurv ptner 17 NC 174U 258 open decree r 100 NY 206 e 33 AD 548 263 judgment r 107 NY 148 166 AD 67 M 98 M 123 S 151 S 162 S 169S 88 591 381 354 670 1077 1040 202 negligence a 107 NY 211 208 neg. dam. 21 NC 4 2 I I plea 3 111 NY 33 M 145 executory 104 181 106 280 607 560 283 214 loss income 186 NY 44 incomp tent ev. 195 NY 280 2 I 8 review B 16 NC 50 66 AD 1 57 guardian 42 522 46 347 e 57 20 114 NY 364 fact questions 221 affidavit B 14 M 77 2 AC 97 publication 2(1 AC 224n ^24 claim notice 207 897 332 281 1 M 20 S cotenant 160 NY allowance 130 S 71 M I 60 contract 47 70 AD 4SA error of law 2M instructions 6M 1 AC value services 33 NY 607 119 264 248 188 118 7n 363 227 334 set-off J 43 r5SS n nulla bona ILRANS 913n 337 ejectment a 106 NY 166 340 officers p40 d46M 2/0 salary ;iiiO NY 90 272 oonolusive e ?5 121 courts power 6 AD 142 275 commissions au 599 notice 62 432 wages damages 9M renewal ■M 2 AC i25NY 1U7AD continuous lOlM 392 461 3g2n 130 363 494 277 mandate a 101 NY : d 10 AD ; contempt lAM 2A(J 595 26 290 parol release 143 S 155 S composition 169 AD 606 16 413 293 instruction 95 AD o 128 NY reverse error 113 AD 142 47- 439 241 462 234 a 107 NY »9 227 aliens s37 Hev^see title 31M 132 NY 14 AC 665 326 480 702 318 427n 233 execution 50 544 79 466 41 M 557 241 juiisdiotion 103 AD 44 d 20 NC 307n abandonment 19AC 180n 238 219 defense 172 AD f 158 S 304 348 515 477 347 presumption a 110 NY 645 14 AD 217 court's power 73 AD 74 76 77 d 83 AD 168 s2&M 118 may amend 96 M 562 563 160 S 878 353 reply 8M 226 355 jurisdiction e 38 555 petition 112 NY 583 359 taxation r 100 NY 215 362 presumption a 107 NY 663 44 M 17 a 1 EJA 540 oomp evidence 20 NC 343n 365 construction 147 NY 612 368 partition a 108 NY 237 79 296 guardian 17 NC 426n doubtful title 22 NC 420n powerintrust 49 M 196 400 waiver .18 96 e.^ecutor party 82 149 objections 13 AD 338 dSM 342 demurrer e 26 M 341 new parties 1 AC 218n d 64 M 155 equity relief 138 NY 146 281 parties 38 CP 479 407 due process 45 e2 AD d80AD dl6M e43M 44 M void statute uo 13 3 AD 942 165S L-eceiver ao 144 AD concurring L.-n S 128S poundage f 179AD 296 contact d46 20 NC counterclaim e 108NY 278 30 1 allowance 68 M 418 303 interpleader 2AC 237n 322 meas. dam. 373 estoppel a 101 NY 681 76 59 b41 AD 65 AD devastavit 93 AD conclusive 0/ AD d 130 AD 133AD e 150AD 30 M, 436 549 232 458 519 57M , ICPNS 118 S 130S 41 17 M 34 M M 161 NY 106 AP breach 186 NY vender sue do 370P 305 368 632 288 339 365 24 245 378 contempt 37 507 41 355 e 73 193 do 48 AD 108 327 assignment e 39 99 e 39 105 1 42 529 legal title q 109NY 341 176n 17N0 436 809 683 662 259 248 322 266 977 bond e43AD 168 NY 'atisfactioo e63 M 49 I taxes 47 221 553 380 152 329 420 87 891 neg. 975 786 122n 372 414 lurisdiction 50M 621 waive objns. 18AC 432 423 trust i 18 NC injunction 102M 365 169S, 26 remove dead 172S 613 427meas damage 61 542 83 145 86 AD 61 e 129 NY 273585 nuisance ILEANS 90n 437 intention 6M 446 agency r 107 NY 451 waiver 112 AD 393 490 159 11 M 14 M 1 AC 2 AC 7 AC 163 NY 280 596 104 268 256n 274 276 382 gift inter vivos 70 . 477 construe will 51 M 139 advancement 190NY 433 393 revere error 22 AD 506 neg. attorney 7 AC 384n 454 abduction r 100 NY 590 456 partition r 100 NY mark title 20 NC 274 22 NC 405n 411 419n 460 vest title 41 AD 417 IM 266 discovery 119AD 142 administrator 175S 735 467sp. prfmance 163 547 435 126 497 jurisdiction do lo2AD 299 do 137S 143 500burden proof a 102 NY 251 49 436 56 10 justification 71 AD 189 d 163 NY 446 reform indictmnt 20 NC 376 5 1 2 order a 102 NY 724 a 1 SA 148 5 1 3 elect remedy a 103 NY 669 46 131 59 26 e89 20 40 AD 423 e 2 SA 289 4LliA 150 valid payment 11 AC 437n 23 NC 143 ratification B 113 NY 460 deed voidable 177 NY 262 equitable dfnse. 169S 467 528 compliance 47 7 relief 59 AD 107 AD 617 8 138 351 _ 66 144 NY IPNC 147 S 162 AD 198 162 304u 4(9 6.^9 483 surety 181AD 475 534 appeal 97 AD r ISA waiver 2 AC 170n 171n 109 NY 344 110 AD 624 546 estoppel 38 M 62 a 22 NC 272n attack will lOlM 59 1 166S 484 559 claim audit 70 471 release a 23 NC 195d settlement 86 NY 366 promissory note 171 AD 418 reimburse 166S 1048 contribution 179AD 614 562 meas dam- ages 6M 208 565 rfoewals d 42 375 4 AC 283n 569 agreement 6 AC 14n 176AD 801 bar 163 S 387 575 service 137S 112 '576 construction 14 M 80 ABBREVIATIONS: a e, witicised : 1, limited ; affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *.' dismissed; n. note e, explained; o, over, jled; s, same case: do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel cas";; q, quest ionco N. Y Supreme Court Reports— Hun Vols. 36, 37 579 demurrer r 100 NY 219 45 256 583 exemption e49 41 77 82 83 468 s 31 M 642 4 AC 124n:i25n e7AC 164 10 AC 399n e 119 NY 556 66M amendment 47 AD 116 pension 38 CP 180 124 S 168 592 discretion e 17 NO 369 40 602 f trict rules 47 ■ 447 57 358 certiorari 86 518 96 M 14 ( 159 S 780 settle ease 13AD 550 evidence 44 AD 394 81 AD 301 20 NO 63d harmless error 120 AD 654 appeal limitatn- 20 NO 55 598 corp not liab 4LRA 327r 80 I posassion d 20 NC 361n 607 gift trust a 102 NY 740 e 43 532 27 AD 444 79 AD 266 12 AC 353n 27 AD 444 6 I tax cance a 104 516 38 275 compliance 44 M 396 sales invalid 105 NY 46 318 6 1 5 negligence r 104 NY ■ 344 72 M />fi1 corpn. neg. 327n 4LA 131 S 975 6 1 9 mandamus 39 299 622 construction m 37 341 contract 86 102 demurrer c 13 M .759 directors liabil c 147 NY 612 630 misconduct 69 602 int'd. person 55 M 633 evidence 37 340 39 AD 624 '634 jurisdiction 5 M 630 532 637 execution case 21 19N0 96 638 sluice way case 21 1 SA 387 639 water case 1 a 101 NY 9 642 judgment case 35 a 104N1 641 a SA 276 843 taxes lien case 1 a 1 SA 524 case 30 adv. pogaesaion a 1 SA 168 644 jurisdietion case 1 U2 NY 68? 645 revaluation case 4 38 60; case 22 street opening e 82 682 847 carrier darn jase 13 r 106 NY 678 rlSA 513 '•ase 19 appeal 103 NY 647 r 1 SA 19-- VOL.37 I conversion 50 677 f 44 AD 5) 9 adverse title e 39 264 268 e 48 18U 1 5 per* legacy B3 78 19 M 200 e 1S2 NY 320 17 M 4au 19 suspn. aliena uon il M 202 /old trust 121 AD 636 23 payment ilo 4 SS 349 ibM 46 35 current aoct. 6 AD 689 38 damages 18 369 A5 60 ib AD 85 jbjns exoeptOA, 62 AD 4^0 i liti 496 498 reutruiniug pwr. i9H N)C 21J, equity suits ZUAC lOSn 42 nonsuit lU 224 otficer de jure 12 386 -73 . 407 Dond rejection 88 AD 441 violation d 173 AD 341 d 158 S 759 as sheriff 178AD 694 165S 976 47 taxpayr suit i48 48 36 M 498 etiforcement do 140 S 228 city party dn 155AD 36 243 57 usury r 106 NY construed 96 M 112 160 S 1033 84 banking d42 85 1 45 101 45 102 92 48 larceny 72 AD 94 ocime intent 50 M 203 95 M 112 199NY t 160 S 499 93 crime intent 50 M 203 96 jurisdiction S3 106 1 I complaint 71 AD 422 i30 M 255 48 M 171 election 129 AD 398 668 i)ne cause 128S 821 165S 428 test joinder n M 583 1 04 pers injury a 107 NY 347 107 neg. damag e41AD 216 d loti AD lou d 138 S 838 d 141 S 107 11 AC 55n ejectment 1J4AD 18-1 contrib. negl. -220 NY 312 135 allegations 41 79 26 M 538 I Ci" 145 1 40 wives liable e 38 225 e 4b 576 e 48 158 122 NY 316 16 Cr ^ 156 wife ptnranp 2LRA ^ 846 1 44 agenoy a 108 NY 763 77 58 lU AD 252 76 AD 9ie 21 M 496 iLKA 761 undiBOlosed principal 64H 9S liability 182AD 503 169S 922 1 52 aimony » 103 NY 284 43 186 vested right 130 S 926 divesting e 146 AD 280 1 63 oond. preeed 127 NY 250 261 serve notice 154 S 637 91 M 286 not conclusive f lOlM 378 lOlM 380 f 166S 1051 166S 10-52 I 70 pers'l tax 91 AD 305 objections 60 M 265 I 76 stockholder 40 163 rejection claim 78 193 re^'iver deft. 39M 92 AD 269 demand 174 AD 260 e 93 M ^49 157 S 35 160 S 302 I 8 I nuisance a 107 NY 679 17 AD 209 I 86 instruction 41 39 190 appeal a ini NY "taking" 114 AD 516 642 194 survival 4 AD 437 144 AD 1."i» 808 98 •98 d 128S fraud 114AD assignment 114 AD actuating 37 CP 168 205 receiver r 115 NY 267 43 667 212 relief court 61 M 156 ;:-jSumption i-iU S 179 IU3 AD 771 21 4 assessment 46 146 216 ejectment a 108 N Y 636 37 240 I LllA 20411 devise 44 332 advancements 39 M 72 failure legacy f 165 AD 278 f 150 tj 837 227 dower r 104 N Y 400 e 124 NY 681 15 AC 30au 232 discovery 43 96 80 AD IbB 10 M 44b 46 M 193 102M VV 168S 451 statutory 102M 77 168S 452 II CP 415 237 costs replevin 41 250 254 42 167 d 51 456 81 355 2SS lU 8 AC 245n lis NY 174 16 CP 160 17 CP 241 277 72 M 112 130 S 1096 242 att'y. client 51 437 40 M 629 128 NY 424 245 referee 37 244 40 AD 139 subpoena 115AD 309 spl. damages 19AC 163n sup. pro. 19 AC 189 246 advancemt 43 280 intestacy 1 M 39 M 72 190NY 434 revocation 158 AD 848 259 covenants 22 AD 529 70 AD 73 4 SA 430 132 NY 434 265 trust do 71 AD 349 3 M . 471 11 AC 404n 134 NY 214 bequest dower 183 NY 66 wife prefer lOlM 191 167S 464 27 1 retax costs 14 AC 26n 275 case appeal 3M 376 277 dividends 39 398 accounting 59 AD 163 limitation do 119 AD 261 132AD 454 f 147 S 65 1 85M 534 bnrred 50 13 1 198NY 2b4 198NY 269 286 discovery 70 64C e 50 AD 584 lAC 188n 283 amendment 82 337 e B M 368 I AC 383n age consent 34 M . 269 692 13 AC 84 160 S . 83» no intention 92 M 287 156 S 186 lourteen years 96 M 599 295 opinions 46 61 80 201 4 AD 557 6 AD 267 23 AD 23 50 AD 603 86 AD 366 301 admr costs 4U 63 lis pendens 125 aD 303 atty's lien 18 NC 25n 306 lunacy 51 14! 24 AD 251 2SS 4?1 31 M .34? 147 S 845 9 AC 279n 281 n lis pen Liens 86 AD 238 3 E prior suit 86 AD 238 ftrm debt 18AC 351n 31 1 no act at law 60 M 205 3 1 2 postponemt 87 23(' 45 AD 294 66 AD 296 297 4SS 3M e 1 AC 393 3 I 7 commissure 47 490 52 AD 125 22 M 44 24 M 154 entry consent fl84 NY 346 reversal 129 AD , 710 abandonment 19A0 177n 313 conpliance 1J5 S 559 adulterated milk r 101 NY 63* e41 25 e 44 1 64 eSO 417 68 343 73 466 e 102 AD 1 57 e 182 NY 7 d9 police power 58 AD 393 e76AD 14 1 LRA 56 constitutional e 89 AD 537 103 NY 399- 109 NY 406- el45NY 109 e 169 NY 57 182 NY 10 act,ev. crime 106 NY 323 strifct value do 198NY' ^ 94- intent 128S 195 exculpate proof 140AD 709 violation 140AD 711 deception 143 AD 629 adulteration 171S 738 329 contempt 67 265- 02 AD 594 68 AD 419 3M 560. 116 NY 134 8 CP 384 17 CP 361 mdemnitv 68 M 498 124 S 754 certiorari 160 AD 670 146 S 51 336 coutract 28 AD 37& 341 demurrer 86 102- e 13 M 759d 760- construction c 147 NY 612^ Abandonment 19AC 177n 346 appeal a 107 NY 682 fee street e 97 AD 618 349 presumption 36 M 25 110 AD _ ,24h license notci** 124 AD 5 352 party 57 AD abatement 1 59 AD 58 f 144 S 409 new plaintiff 159 AD 735 t 144 S 975 354 deposition 3 AD 472 21 AD 128 78 M 614 3 SS 49S- 139 S 302 139 S 503 liberty read 78 M fi14 iia ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; c. criticised; I, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q. questioned Vols. 37. 38 N. T. Supreme Court Reports— Hun 356 charce a 108 NY 400 77 406 360 damages 66 143 11 AC 217d 56 M 191 responsiblty ' 125 AD 316 368 usury 23 NC 419d 5 LRA 27911 372 subj. •5LRA mtge. 279d 377 highway! T 104 NY 229 379 negligence T 104 NY 229 167 NY 553 381 covenants ' a 107 NY 684 e 32 AD 554 e 21 M 589 385 illegal ev. T 104 NY 151 79 37 388 bill partic ■9 AD 616 2M 112 18 NC 71 389 neg. proof e 4 M 501 39 1 performance e. 161 NY 446 397 limitations 45 32 47 53 e57 571 28 AD 92 7 M 219 ] AC 25n issue execution 70M 487 135S 500 not limited do 135S 2' in conflict 150AD 466 400 securities 85 102 405 ptnership 37 104 38 224 122 NY 316 dol22NY 316 13 CP 274 20 NC 169 407 imprisonmt. 13 AD 139 conviction d 141 S 5 motion q 156 AD 904 4 1 3 ordinances 32 AD 601 419 fraud 111 AD d 91 M e 137 NY rescission 111 AD 427 good title 8 AC 441n accounting d 121 AD 210 430 accounting 103 NY 621 do 15 AD 288 construction ol7M 6 435 judgment d 60 317 9 5 SS 279 s 28 NC 161 440 inj. notice 82 AD 502 442 ronstitut'l 3 r 102 NY 343 22 NC 214n 46 1 mandamus 42 56 71 33 AD 37 AD 47 AD e79 AD 5M 16 M 28 M 35 M 152 NY 321 628 189 9 143 15 96 97 29 35 306 742 212 364 11 M 521 1 AC 188n right to take 136S 226 depositions > 151AD 721 537 r-move dam • 102 NY 734 s 16 NC 395 45 209 55 164 39 AD 116 121 s 1 SA 161 boundry street 62 U 196 f 94 M 346 do 212 NY 18 Itrescription 62 M 2 CONY nontldal 65M ownership 140 S 93 M 157 S 165 628 Testinf 43 trustee e 64 247 corpn transfer " ~ S82 adverse 155 AD 116 S 140 S title state 182AD 170S navigable 103M 473 replevin" a 101 NY 303 476 alienage 40 37 480 presumption d 83 297 48 1 aff . defense 35 M 206 abondonment 19AC 177n 491 title sl6N0 11 AD 477 393 495 admr's bond r 120 NY e53 e 110 NY 15 CP indemnity ILRA 676 32 312 874 422 appeal a 101 NY 38 382n certified check 14 AC 440n 425 aasm'd risk 11 M 550 84 166 610 379 491 227 422 277 337 possn. 683 1026 645 513 229 VOL. 38 7 certiorari 87 AD 20 NC 263 692 340 308 183 45 AD legal title 2U receiver 10 M 1 AC 157 NY J60NY maintain suit f 178AD 70 164S 603 634 submisnion a 109 NY 630 638 insurance case 23 a ISA case 31 damages a 107 NY a ISA I I bill partic. 458 9n 641 106 40 286 570 83 323 581 112 503 288 197n' 46 835 437 382 650 546 800 264 649 561 damages r 110 NY 654 r 2 SA 99 565 requests 4 AC 45n 568 certiQcate a 109 NY 635 9 AC 44d deed evidnce 187NY 106 presumption 19A0 881 576 remedies 408 221n 639 contract case 4 r 107 NY r ISA case 14 assm'd risk r 103 NY rlSA 10 AC 580 rape e50 submission 75 do 158 S reversible 46 394 1125 error 659 642 641 city neg case 7 a 109 NY 635 49 319 642iury question case 11 108 NY 57 AD case 12 632 79 » 101 NY 38 66 75 79 16 AD 73 AD 159 AD 2M 53M 2 AC 101 AD f 144 S 161 S juBtification 113 AD 833 65M 170 court's power 19AC In 1 7 joinder 93 AD 409 e 99 AD 502 right action d 157 S 923 27 consideration 107 NY 679 1 SA 558 invalid contract 150 AD 308 42 M. 30 14 AC 250d release iOlNY enforcible 129 AD 134 S terminate 166S f378 pleadg. divorce 124AD 787-788 joinder do 124 AD 791-2 7 1 jury question 41 92 57 AD 93 AD 2SS 5SS 12 M 14 M oral admission 6 M 586 24 M 50 scrutiny 63M 635 68 M 18 declarations 124 S 859 498 contract 24 150 65 223 504 St. limitatns 44 586 69 425 38 CP 605 dcknowlgmt. 19A0 426n 506 extrinsic facts 43 497 513 jurisdiction e 57 105 5 1 5 jurisdiction m 108 NY 445 50 532 5 1 9 charge 41 630 526compet'ntev 37 503 8 49 260 59 AD 624 529 foreclosure 8 AD 522 531 70 discovery do 173 AD 985 594 cnnr isidn 42 270 46 602 62 551 67 AD 432 reverse error 60 M 633 602 accom. note 48 473 do 4 SS 49 s 4 SS 149 person liable 9M 232 27 M , 271 note for debt 16AC 145-6n liability 106M 175 809 meas. dam 89 ,61 sale St. fraud 46 M 622 e 184 NY 214 interest 64M 187 6 1 5 mandamus a 116 NY 66S SM 191 623 attonment a 118 NY 156 pers, injury c ISA a43 fraud case b a 108 NY a2 bA case 36 jurisdiction a 109 N 1^ 82 ISA 576 628 31 470 196 1082 agmt 962 248 39 128 587 96 590 74 82 320 78 citizen 91 M 155 S 605 510 i 38 intervention 5M 16 notice motion 127S 944 71M 158 1 42 affidavit 44 691 64 62 1 44 reference 54 442 96 M 560 160 S 847 146 injunction 36 AD 561 25 M 52 52 omission 55 AD 422 d 167 AD 218 643 331 82 penalty 81 AD 492 e6M .682 judicial notice 91 M 345 92 M 84 148,8 75C 155 S 1016 ordinance 154 S 448 86 insurance a 109 NY 604 assured f 175 AD 22 161 S 684 I OOcompet'nt ev I 97 M 162 S amendment 84 AD 89 NY . jurisdiction 123 S 139 AD title f 203NY serve notice 152 S 648 398 406 750 176 590 30 Psr trustee itflNY 471 129 251 505 177 044 746 632 185 572 644 ooserv't neg case 12 1st dept. p 37 414 report uaae 12 2nd dept' a 114 NY t>34 case 16 damages a4SA 1 SA contract 89 M f 153 S as strangers 161 S 155 174 AD 511 37 license 41 AD 118 NY 169 NY 184 NY 144 AD '"a e terminated 127 AD 766 corporeal inter. 128S • 867 pers. property 143 AD 879 revocation 143 S 398 43 demurrer 340 199 193 256 645 divorce case 6 i 107 NY illSA 677 55a r 105 Nit 40 ISA 8 ISA 1 04 bill e48 66 e65 e8 AD 24 AD a 26 AD 123AD 2 AC 21 NO 19AC 123 S 45 4M jurisdiction 7M validity e20M em. domain 23 M 312 2 522 104 617 350 371 450 partic 549 40 529 306 545 355 492 198u 263 gn 359 48 69 74 82 2M tl4M 99 AD 124 AD ,107 waiver 46 7 AD review 26 M 149 NY 362 1 5/ competent evidence 132 S 838 incompetent 75 M 133 1 63 bill partic 230 341 348 359 112 127 471 514 1 65 valid gift 61 M 480 1 68 request error e 36 AD 395 I7lpub convey- ance e 59 AD 10 1 80 indictment 76M . J9 iurisdiction 138 S 538| application 93 M 802 118 252 49 notice claim 92 405 171 NY 73 57 guaranty 121 NY 282 el7M 531 judgment bar al7NC advances 16AC 62 larceny *109 NY 8 ISA 193n 87n 634 329 540 not tenant 67 demurrer 7M misjonder 56 M 376.6.377 169 1 1 3 consideratn 81 303 2 M I, 375 e378 parol proof 145 NY 666 I 1 6 relevant ev 46 327 e 68 108 73 AD 502 neg. future dam I NC 4n 1 22 int. coupons r 101 NY 439 1 25 creditor 37 M 473 474 142 S . 456 iurisdiction e 80 M 467 142 S 455 1 27 commitment a 101 NY 195 19 NC 142n 157 S 469 266 1 84 impeachmt 42 348 3 AD 128 72 AD 393 e 36 M 168 130 NY 145 1 88 confession r 103 NY 211 202 jurisdiction 86 2 AC 360n 365 2 1 4courts power a 10 2 NY 735 a 1 SA 162 228 limitation 47 . 112 vesting estate 54 . 87 eonstruction 52M 252 230 joint note o 122 NY 315 ABBBlfiVlATlONS : a, affirmed; d, distinguished; i, followed; r, reversed^ m, modified; ', dismissed; n, note; e, criticised ; 1, limited ; e, fexplained ; o, overruled : s, samenase ; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case j q, questioned N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Hun Vols. 38. 39 253 193 231 injunotion 30 AD BlSNC 234 costs 73 d 148 NY 506 291 236 conclusion 82 AD 13 AC authority 119 AD 240 att'y client 13 AD 607 new attorney 217 62 420 d 145 S substitution e37AD amendment 75 AD appeal 3M e4M 1 AC 242compel attendant 19AC 244 misdescriptn 531 367 2S9 410 687 355n 516 94a 616 396 609 e 11 AD 173 AD no title 12AD compliance 44 la 141AD * judicial notice 126S 993 uncertainty £ 158 S 338 246 insurance 47 603 255 banking 61 M 246 259 acknwlgnt. 19AG 430n 263 answer 36 AD 680 24 M 455 265 authority OM 543 268 vacate judt e 43 M 371 e 47 M 340 banktruptcy 194 NY 422 270 privileged a 103 NY 573 ■272 certiorari 39 231 evidence objn d 69 135 276 taxtn. corP a 105 NY 76 280 conviction 48 167 meas. punishmnt 4 AC 384n 98 AD 455 courts power S6M 431 incompetent do 152AD 370 restriction 140 S appeal lies 155 AD 283 myord error do 117 AD 369 283 pleadings 48 435 irregularity 53 208 estoppel 69 444 construction 63M 510 285 net r 108 N'i damge 567 293 place trial alO 1 NY 43 12 AD 34 AD 54 AD 94 AD 8 AC U AG e99AD 18 NC 656 434 603 2 359 442 262 357n 315n 306 20ln change venue 323 149 170 1001 1105 d 154AD 156 AD 16AC f 13&S 140 S amendment 19AC 295n prejudice 154 AD 323 138 S . 1001 294 fraudulent 62 94 298 contract 50 252 18 AD 541 299 corporation residence lOlM 385 186S 1071 30 I public Bts. 53 230 appeal 8 AD 549 9 AC lOOn 306iiicompet.ev. e 40 403 92 274 327 issue stock 46 250 330 title fund d 18 NC 123n 335 nonsuit r 109 NY 648 338 mandamus 41 AD 20 340 a; 109 1 661 44 AD n AD 14 M libel 121 AD 530 569 417 260 370 presumption a 108 NY 349 11 NO 419n neg. crossing 20 NC 324n 373 salary a 106NY 181 376 depositio s ISNC 446n 381 200 US 315 384 mandams rl02 NY 477 389 atty'a lien 1 AC 195n 6 AC 341n set off costs 18AC 270n, 281n 394 in trust P61 612 2 AC 344n as individual 125 S 69fi 141AD 78 charge exceptna 48 AD 321 477breach contract 215 NY 238 482 no relief 68 M 13 124 S 909 49 I juror ev. a 102 NY 238 21 NC 418,421 challenge 21 NC 446, 457n 500 conversionf r 102 NY 510 507 place trial 3 AC 151n change venu' 59 M 407 510 pera liablity 109 NY 153 16 401 hearing notice 6M 417 covenants 59 M 261 privity of estate d 172 AD 104 d 158 S 217 590 intention la 110 NY 1 AD 163 a 2 SA 581 593 tax exemp- tion a 104 NY 41 e44 119 NY 22 NC 642 appeal case 9 a 110 NY 310 a 1 SA 105:title 96 case 30 27 55'a 1 SA 660 97 645 683 187 597 committee 643 jury trial a 101 NY 580 case 33 Ir 109 NY 641 603 relig. society r 2 SA 39 allONY 33| i644aB8m'd riak 807 sureties case 31 r 107 NY 477 a 110 NY !»2SA 52 I costs stay 396 authority I'' ^C 279n 52 679 .„ , , appeal default =>^-* vested 60 317 mainder stockholders 3 AC 369n 161 NY 82 profits agent 53M 382 404 compliance a 108 NY 524 9 AC 45n 409 eq, relief s 17 NC 2 AC jurisdiction 122 AD 210 384n 584 623 140 S invalid lOlM 167S habeas 168S 023 649 706 corpus 709 345 special dam. 72 637 IAD 76 e 33 AD 668 6 AC 224 350 estoppel a 104 NY 139 353 master neg. a 109 NY ■ 496 360 inaurance a 103 NY 61 362 negligence 4 1 8 evidence a 104 NY 683 45 461 d 20 AD 328 credibility lllAD 377 49 M 85 conversion 164 NY 145 429 inspection 34 M 272 438 use of street 170 NY 306 148 S 881 1 163 AD 693 fee center street 12 AC 190n 465 incompt. ev. 51 8 62 20 30 M 81 co-operation f 214 NY 344 ._^ [569 signals ev 474 revers. error 13 AC 418n > 109 NY 611 69 360 libelous per ae 193 a 104 NY 5 21 NC 67 AD a ISA 19 NC 669 1 613 345 21 m 103 NY 453 528 amendmenf 62 305 139 AD 591 parol evidenc* 84 AD 398 1 AC 301n 98 AD 294 5 3 I interloc. judgment 41 4.57 21 NC 362n default judgt, 60 317 109 AD 623 P. 0' address 38 CP. jurisdiction 124 S 191 536 assessment 32 AD 499 d8M 34 admr. control 140 S 017 legal title 155 AD 611 540compenaat'n 10 AC 295n 548 pleading r 103 NY 242, 553 pleading 33 M sl6NC 152 560 incomt. ev. r 105 NY 332 6l2eq reUef a-104 674 32 311 e 66 176 e76 285 79 153 ^88 614 e,13AD 44 24 AD 611 34 M 461 94 M 352 e 148 NY 358 e 166 NY 218 damaged 184AD 517 172S 34 220 NY 625 76 377 623 release 92 satisfaction 31 AD 55 AD HI AD 159 AD One judgment 111 AD 8 337 841 751 625 lease to rr. 75 3 e 45 AD 347 satisfaction 55 AD 96 632 damages r 114 NY 236 e46 16 s86 51 634 damages 19 NC 466n 637 mandamus case 23 * 101 NY 47 AD s 16 NC e 123 NY 152 NY 640 1_ 96 160 364 368jury question e24AD 91 61 AD 91 AD e93 AD I16AD 37 M 74M 123 NY 179 NY 134S 607 263 533 614 309 623 210 163 577coste partit n 45 AD 157 7 AC 76n 79 58 I counterclaim 89 AD 366 640 contrib neg case 7 a2SA g partnership case 10 a 110 NY 658 a 2 SA 101 65 right purch. 5LRA 166n 72 not implv f 161 S 362 79 nuisance r 105 NY 46 e 49 47 85 negligence d 1278 142 88 tender r 110 NY 10 1 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished ; f. followed; r, reversed; m, modified- * dismi^ed- „ ^„,-. lcr,Mc,sed: t, hmited; ..explained; o, overruled: ..same case; do/dissenting opinion; prparalielcaTeTq^queitfo'il^i 132AD 70M 126S 278 426 638 sup. pro, case 29 * 102 NY s 16 NC 52 67 M 124 S 124 S remedies 55 M 325 alimony caseSO 8 lis AD 72 rieht creditor 139 AD 584 683 19n 530 548 456 755 641 pers. injury case 5 976,al08NY 64s ,-- a 1 SA 577 586 pajrtners _ [appeal 671 a 108 NY 470 case 30 VOL. 39 I fraud rep- resentations r 114 NY 458 5 excess verdict e48 302 corpn. neg. 4LliA 327n I 2 amendment 84 296 libelous 118 NY 1S3 charge error p 147 NY 630 not actionable 161 AD 719 183AD 771, 772 146 S 530 171S 829 I 8 ejectment ^ 31 AD 220 AC 394 22 town bonding r 107 NY 169 29 attachment " r 110 NY 435 d25M 417 preference 22 NO 332n 35 eomplianoe 14 M 3S8 actual custody 6 AC . 124 service copy 49 M 605 40 misjoinder 49 287 enticem't proof 79 513 e 79 594 11 AD 22 27 AD 375 jury question 43 AD IIG 116 NY S87 do 172 NY 444 wife may 140 S sue 798 44 award a 109 NY 164 47 meas. damage 69 527 72 AD 319 loss rentals 20AC lOln 49 receiver fee 17 AC 20ln commissions 123 S 76 138AD 486 54 parties 92 421 6 \ Jurisdiction a 104 NY e86 20 U personality 77M 137S 201 297 539 294 774 Vol. 39 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Hun e 119 NY 566 balance judg't 36 M 321 102 AD 63 185 NY title funds 175S 112 36CP 699 98 assignment a 109 NY 42 47 11 M preference 22 NC 333 ._. _. 529 48 AD 328 2 333o 1 08 divorce ev a 104 NY 88 legal title f 151 S f 89 M I 1 3 release 5LRA 382 212 386 103 266n 1 2 I repugnancy a 120 NY 365 2 SS 549 1 34asBignment a 116 NY 41( beneficiary 18 NC. 325n 1 40 demurrer a 116 NY 666 e 32 AD 296 agisters 17 AC 228n,229n 1 44 complaint 153 509 510 512 320 387 110 NY SM «5M 7M estoppel f 145 S as frivolous 183AD 48 171S ' 29 1 47 waiver ■90 AD 544 10 AC 287e I 50 vicious bull •e 67 629 estrays d 64M 434 19AC S71n tenant liable 137 AD 511 318 S 575 121 S 824 153 judicial sale « 58 263 1 58 illegal a lOB SO wilfulness 171S 174 lien 344 69 I 76 judgment a 109 NY 618 181 St. limitatns 511 36 petition I M jurisdiction 133AD aet forth fact 243 parol ev. r 116 NY 515 248 deed a 109 NY 4." 6 262 re-entry a 110 NY 537 269 apportion- ment a 110 NY 457 2 AC 340n 341 345 performance 432 275 jurisdiction 133AD do 133 432 a 1 SA 435 l87followfund 40 114 e91 81 37 AD 18 2LRA 481 191 travel fee a 41 104 costs e43 150 57 AD 104 10 AC 61n 20 NC 183n taxation csts ■>8M 362 193 all evidence 44 235 53 172 62 481 69 406 referee findings 47 152 51 66 law question 86 appeal 2 M 7 AC 107 NY 111 NY 120 NY 438 188 457 633 eili 231 169 1 66 declarations ■e 54 529 •66 616 25 AD 43 I 7 I damages a 115 NY 636 a 2 SA 326 82 310 jury question I 98 constitution a 109 NY 127 i 46 619 204 letter r 111 NY 143 2 1 3 executors 3. 104 NY 179 counterclaim 28 AD 489 d lOOM 166 d 165S 253 conversion 17 M 222 estoppel infant 20 NC 174n 220 judgment a 109 NY 619 non-suit 32 AD 139 2 AD 21 AD e 54 Au SI AD 41 M J. r. liability ILEA estrays 126 AD 183AD willfulness 188AD 119 343 636 613 403 405 611 613 613 39 223 amendment 69 145 10 M 246 324 estoppel 227 easement „f^- r 110 NY 695 jZd attachment a 104 NY 648 313 !24AD for jury 186AD 175S 291 843 206 a 109 NY 41 e42 92 title vests ILKANS 600 363 575 -. 276 60 71 493 s! 524 53 38 M 184 NY no power 136AD file mortgage 128S mc relipf 70M 467 285 assessment a 114 NY 439 24 M 36 29 I incompt. ev Kaj presumption error cl 400 2B M , 346 39 AD 400 y: — ,.„ , 44 disqualiiied 179AD 65 51 AD e79 AD e3M 170 NY 6 99 AD 223 74 314 282 420 83 294 lien ras'ger 144 NY 112 300 injunction S16AN 419 303 appraisemt 52 AD 190 307 injunction a 110 NY 643 d 127 NY 269 161 NY 105 308 neg. damage r 103 N Y 3 I I bail justice 97 AD 42 M cash bail 106M 174S 614 police 7 47 345 514 3 I 5 accounting 69,AD 143 pleading 119 AD . 427 bill particular UfiAD 2 f 168 AD 966 13ns ;-(S'i 153 S 1119 3 1 9 waiver 47 95 e47 548 55 e77 I8M 230 mandamus , a 103 NY 635!332di,,„,.„y 238 387 316 642 e54 20 233 cancel rotge a 121 NY 662 18 M interested 128S 189 a 101 NY 43 injunction 48 684 473 trespassing ILEA 449n 237 injunction 56 M 328 133 e 65 6 AD SAD 27 M 27: 341 instructions proof of waiver e 67 557 d 64 AD 348 interested 58 18 AD 12 M 92 prox. cause _ 54 642 92 492 jury question 51 2 34 AD 286 487 removal exr f Tsei ormi* /thama t Ci'l XyV ant ■> -.* H*" 848 360 waiver 31 M estoppel 53M 181 186 compensation 10 AC 292n extension 53M 39CP reference 53M not apply to surrogate 39CP 60 power referee 39CP 65 67 363 extra allow 338 423 184 6.' 179 27 AD 105 AD 146 128 366 amendmeni 402 426 181 012 468 ?15 47d 48t 4n 226 521 63 91 35 AD 71 AD 84 AD 62 M 1 AC 10 AC 20AC iCPNS 378 intent 54 382 spec, per- formance 85 AD 160 d> 114 AD 82L o7M 442 385 negligence 13 AD 442 compel ev d 20 NC 241n 388 permissive 42 M 30 14 AC 249 severally liable 47 M 449 394 eq. action a 108 NY 601 ' 51 AD 638 _ 1 S A592a 476 appeal 399 affidavits 77 42 AD 2 AC 69 42. __ 68n 363n 77 uo^ e 88 133 402 reformation information 70 513 33 M 459 1 AD 126 9 AC 234 e 40 M 69 ISO S 83 4 1 unoccupied 36 M 36 46 eg2 240 expendit'rs __. c 20 AD 15 summing up 'e 118 NY 419 injunction r 110 NY 586 424 public use 130 NY 259 430 assum'd risk r 116 NY 49 628 379 24 126S 1116'd46 419 70M 456 reinstatement irregular f 143 S 415 taaa 1118 contract waiver error 68 172 70M 458 new cause action designated . 8 M 277 crime mitigation dam. 130 182AD 342 602 lien 219 170S 342 20 AD 36 M 629 486 negUgence 1 135AD 342 r 109 NY 44 surplus a 19 NO error chaige 53 AD 435 valid bond 103 NY 647 9 AC 648 490 local or pri- vate bill d a 102 NY 471 65M construction 135AD 373 498 relig. society 6 | 7 warranty a 109 NY 612" -- ' liability 135A1> 374 439 attachment 147 NY 622 2 AC 419 a 21 NC 181n 442 mandamus 66 AD 69 70 county charges 507 remove police , 102 NY 683 39 CP offense -crime ' 4LUA 755 173 AD f 173 AD f 93 M 157 S ! 159 S intent 93 M 352 353 266 974 247 267 5 1 I mandamus a 102 NY jury ques tion 448 j'^int liable e 87 544 1 1 AD 509 449 bialiu notice 48 387 45 I dower gift a 104 NY 125 452 encroachm't 64 AD 160 456 easement f 69 AD 336 69 AD 336 337 105M 487 173S 618 injunction 60 M 454 460 replevin a 104 NY 23 NC election 4LRA 519 2M 525 review 41 J 66 SI 57 AD 71 AD 3SS 27 M 123 NY 602 164n 147n -166 foreclosure a 109 NY 663 44 79 468 appeal ev. r 120 NY . 3SA d3SA 668 12 5 S 43 919 316 affidavit ground 306 170 26 M 235 239n pleading 331 return all ev. 603 485 22S 4i M specify errors 369 140 AD 9 73' waiver f87M "281 uTc' alleged errors 607 ,7dM 483.130 S 137n 65 363 905 316 26 601 504 jurisdiction 104 AD 658 620 reference 4 AC e67 83 M 408 d 22 M d 122 NY 3erve atty. 121AD 365 34o 526 24 111 573 311. 41 SSI. 53 I alimony a 65 404 7 AC 216n 537 assignment 43 384 22 NC 34] 533 as8e."is recov a 104 NY 166 557 appeal a 114 NY mandamus 135AD 636 419 566 allowance 65 923 152 NY 617 165 AD 25 151 S 66 mtgee possii 16AC 43 in 57 1 vested right a 104 NY 143 e 73 370 87 M 655 148 S 208 57 ins. reform 18 NC 326n 551 122 576acctg excep tions a 109 NY 583 588 assignment r 104 NY 108 652 covenant case 7 522 a 2 SA 118 case 9 ,mtge. assum 599 discharge 'a 2 SA 596 credt'r suit 229 40 139 NY cond. precedent 130 S fiOl equities 73 Jil 27 106M 174S 470 696 623 deposition 149 626 contempt 264 668 70« 228 760 63 1 misdemean- or d 40 359 634 considerat'n SAD 52 lien wharfage a 23 NC 263n 639 coservt. neg r 112 NY 614 643 relief 42 54 misjoinder 51 .M 3 7 CP 186 583 351 334 646 alimony 7 AC 254n no defense 20AC 290n discharge 20 AC 29an resettle 1S5.AD 173S 648 award a 109 NY a2SA 649 ev. error e 58 297 538 247 638 35 65 I bill lading case 17 a 109 NY case 28 em. domain d 130 NY case 29 new trial a 109 NY ,=„a2SA 109 case 33 sparks neg r 109 NY 120 114 650 58 243 77 ABBREVIATIONS: c, criticised: 1, limited; I, affirmed; d. distinguished; e, explained ; o, overruled ; a. f. followed: r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n. ii«>u saiiit.- case: do. dissenting opinion; p, parallel case: n. questioned N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Hun Vols, 39, 40 -case 30 competent 22 NC ev. 33gn 8£ 373 '655 damages case 2 a2SA '657 services case 1 .a2SA dams pier -case 3 -a 109 NY .a2SA case 12 injunction 157 AD '658 open and close -case g m 105 NY 84 r 1 SA 3C iiidemnity -ease 25 m 106 NY flJ 1 1 SA 41 14 VOL. 40 I rr act 22 NC a 140 NY 21111 1 29 rr act fran- oliise 48 M 96 22 NC 214n 221d 35 alienage a 122 NY 31 M 105 AD 48 702 183 38 contempt 40 641 do 80 437 50 452 e I AD 493 77 AD 16 12 AC 175n 176n 12 AC 18S e 146 AD 248 e 130 S 916 compliance TOM 612 41 contempt 40 46 e57 59 e67 e80 51 AD line 56M 80 lien r 103 NY 88 AD 20 NO 245 217 35 9 1 atty. agent 61 437 128 NY 424 presumption d 60 264 trust 66 440 e 39 AD 101 103 AD 358 inter vivos 29 AD 44 16 M 411 lO'l insurance' d 13 AD 527 a 48 AD 442 1 08 frivolous answer 86 AD 44 averment 63 M 119 1 1 1 follow fund 2hK.\. 481 541 322 436 438 78 259 70 583 617 jurisdictional i 145 S 401 47 bill partlc. 48 230 73 AD 323 eviction 64 M 699 49 conversion 23 M 354 d 26 M 608 56 authority 13 AD 84 M f 145 S ■up. pro. 128S affidavit 144 AD receiver 135S title vests 150AD vesting 157 AD 142 S 806 255 531 1003 272 title 741 709 614 977 8U cause oi act n 44 M 61 costs ■ 105 NY 44 471 1 1 6 fraudulent in 106 NY 41 eompliance 46 amendment ISA 620 67 455 r 127 NY e 1 76 certiorari a 20 NC 62n I 78 declarationp 87 656 4SS 38 3 SA 459 127 NY 634 1 84counterclaim e80 28 21 M 718 70M 426 1 AC 280n 10 AC 284n 126S 976 cost demurrer leAG 411n 19 AC 414n 1 90 defense SAD 128 AD 168 NY 21 assignment a 109' NY 43 49 e21M 056 382 609 230 125 declarations 87 656 4SS 38 3 SA 469 127 NY 634 130 discretion 157 S 892 171 AD 551 145 assume risk HON If 634 ISOcompeasat'n 83 82 AD aim 19 M 31 M Btocktilbrs SAC 14 AC 635 131 470 23 748 sue 369n lOln prin. int. directrs 453 203 88 93 exrs. contract 21 NC 84u 64 jurisdiction 44 e24M 68 surplus a 109 NY limited 9 AD 199 497 363 397 72 costs recov. e64 ISA 8M 103 NY 75 statutory 73 AD contempt do 91 AD 92 271 486 601 77 269 120 NY 184 NY validity f 153AD f nsos directors 139 S 212 NY f 90 M powers 15:!AD 160 S act binding 121 S 143 163 710 246 260 131 88 835 623 218 aegligenoe town 46 43 B 60 100 80 105 commissioners not agents 58 27 30 competent ev 82 174 1 97 proof breach d6 M 636 husband rights 19A0 178n Abode husband 78 37 68 M 298 undertaking b'nd a 20 NC 24&n penalty 119 AD oad faith 105M 174S 17 AC contingent 137 AD 160 245 Stat, limita tion 17 AD e l.t,3 NY 163 NY 3 M 60.1 .64 62 148 248 guaranty a 122 NY 290 252 surety 35 AD 1S9 incompetent f 149 S 770 87 M 405 competent ev. 100 AD guaranty 121 AD 369 34 79 145 421 408 8 62 65 e72 c25M e 135 NY 20 NC 1 58 negligence r 116 NY 656 42 175 5 AC 308n 310n 1 6 1 negligence a 116 NY 46 88 dg2 p26 AD I 66 profits r 116 NY 112 327 322 147 317 61 203 covenant r 104 NY 192 55 333 2 1 2 crea'r suit 48 560 17 AD 247 6 AC 202n 216 amendment 79 AD 131133 364 73 41 60n 90n 91 n 372 234 power court 124 S 598 228 certiorari s6M e lOM »1 AC 1 AC 7 AC 12 AC a-! M 460 418 367 681 250 61n 256 title 45 mortgagee sale 48 471 119 NY 827 258 demurre. 77 AD 617 12 M 12 pleading 116AD 35£ interloc. judgnien 123AD 43 259 relief 3»CP 3 1 6 filiation 1 AD 608 323 statute 1 AC 233 declarations S3 . 404 407 tenant curtesy SI 380 oompt. witness 63 77 92 21 AD 75 AD 61 AD e24M 16 M interest 51 M 143 AD retrial 228 6 450 265 446 308 262 185 155 260 guaranty 85 214 263oloud on title 67 248 5 SS 289 269 parol ev. 224NY 420 278 authority 15 AC 435ti 286judgment a 116 NY' 656 48 274 54 451 460 master neg, 56 M 80 contrib. neglig 76M 60 135S 298 29 1 revocation am NY 687 88 301 e 17 M 625 administrator f 6S AD 649 next of kin f82M 143 S justified do 160 AD removal 166 AD lOOM do 152 S 165S misconduct f 153 S 1092 gon 332fact question 111 NY 14 AD 168 rule exemption. 220 NY 294 339 trespass a 120 NY 316 1 AC 62n 343reason. care dOAD question of law 88 AD 319 negligence 51 M 293 349 evidence e 50 AD 689 jury question 56 AD 558 damage 72 AD 599 49 M 619 21 NC 7n 353 exemption 6 AD 89 355 ejectment a 124 NY reversion 50 AD 18 NC 70 126 306 358 crim'nl law r 103 NY 388 360 surrogate r 102 NY 430 370 ratification 48 380 executory oont. C25AD do 25 AD 2M avoidance 158 AD 143 S 390 394 238 900 276 389 prox. cause 54 629 87 AD 229 e 87 AD 232 reasonable care SM 323 392restrnt trade 22 NC 206 397 highway 47 _ 395 dedicated road e 6 M 202 13 AC 235n 244n 14 AC 260n 405 contract tll2 NY e63 AD park land 25 M claim 161 NY 185 NY jurisdiction 124 S 30 5 115 127 849 143 780 94 646 189 80 297 amendment 82 AD 98 3 SS 459 310 judgment a 109 NY 659 easement f 69 AD 339 83 AD 435 517 162 AD 246 147 S 668 distinction lOOM 125 372 will trust r 108 NY 312 20 NC 447 374 judgment 159 NY 448 e 22 M 388 376 subrogation 48 29 AD e64 AD f 106 AD lessee rights f 140 S f 163 AD w. services 8n 378 a 21 NC 381 Btct. 127S comp. 718 134 121 383 will d 112 NY 26 M probate 2LRA 170, 180 386 discretion 104 NY 06 c46 386 tax elOg NY 17£ 4 1 5 fraud Stat a 116 NY 136 eSl 478 fact question 6 SS 337 option 120 NY 445 418 equit rights 6 AD 262 title 83 AD 93 94 67M 453 equity trust 44 M 405 422 amendment 5SS 89 424 waiver 91 M 506 428 reference d3SS 109 3 AC 68n '430 fr'd statute 10 M 655 evidence plain 76M 543 assumed 102M 569 169S 195 64T 460 600 498 461 453 369 612 2g7 23n 352n 407n 438 waiver alio NY 46 »1 do 20 AD 55 AD e 65 AD 5g AD 82 AD e2 AC 6 AC 7 AC d 148 NY negligence 2 AC jury question 16 AD 167 443 award r 105 NY 586 28 M 310 fee spl. guardn. lOAC 98n 455 jury quest'n 63 241 460 penalty 44 5g4d sgo repeal 55 AD 390 387 presumption 167 NY 168 465 title oflice 30 M 6 42 276 s 19 NC 138 57 279 11 AC 338n47AD 118 AUBREVraxiONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed .1. .' J ' ,'^:"." • .-' :■':"'"» m- «..© "•="*-" f *. iwiiwwcu, i, icvcrscu; m, moQinea; ", aismissed: n note- e. criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s. same case; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q, questioned Vols. 40, 41 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Hun 471 court 16AC nonsuit d 82M d 144 S power 446d 361 448 5SS 8M 473 foreclosure 50 AD 128 eviction 12 M 520 477 arrest 13 M 10 AC 765 57n 481 voidable 87 535 error onlv 93 M 476 158 S 444 489 arrest 6 AC 183 492 declarations i 212 NY 235 1 20 AD 773 499 assignment * 104 NY 297 504 trust power e 132 NY 467 121 NY 430 147 NY 663 no trust - d 166 AD 825 152 S 424 512 employee d 46 M 477 services 159 S 660 5 I 6 assignment a 106 NY 635 46 631 3 SS 430 127 NY 59 520 injunction 56 214 139 NY 118 526 reference alQNC report 93 M i 158 S 117AD 39CP intention 213 NY 47 50 54 84 SAD 96 AD 23 M e2SM 36 M 8 17NC 118 NY IS AC trial 13 M waiver d48M majority 66M apprised 89 M In 604 592 777 267 524 532 foreclosure e 82 AD 484 jurisdiction 7 AC 5£>n 536 pleading •" 109 NY 329 106 AD 156 540 alimony 57 contempt 67 q80 e80 51 AD e77 AD 126 AD 102 AD 122AD 22 M 40 M 56 M 12 AC 597 366 546 expulsion 277 170 227 449 597 602 144 S02 103 206 512 108 162 683 100 288 328 510 539 213 SSSinsurance all 1 NY 390 review 94 M 737 159 S 1058 563 exr. liable e 51 435 dS4 30 do 54 36 54 542 547 executor 27 M 271 pers. liable do 124 AD 605 89 M 302 89 M 304 t 89 M 30.5 spl. contract jury question 45 AD 228 96 AD 114 d 4 SA 346 reapond't superi-' 9 M 6 420 do 9 M 424 11 AC 424 negligence e7SAD U7NY non-suit e54AD e 145 NY prox. cause e 131AD 305 623 aaiendment 82 AD 98 1 AC 68n 93 M 583 584 f 158S 468 f 158 S 469 625 costs 138AD 15 M 22 M lAC 14AC 126 AD ]ia,bility 185AD 173S 535 715 852 566 accounting 18 AD 296 commission 28 AD 213 436 259 76 452 583 16 116 369 790 706 131 277 .185 570 mandamus r 104 NY 68 172 NY 96 B 17 NC 304 578 bank draft r 116 NY 201 do 4 SS 49 fact question 114 NY 44 585 contract d43 , 9 adverse title BAD 24 right possession d 38 M 637 588 em, domain 45 AD 256 260 52 AD 125 418 122 326 281 D 25u 632 partnership case 19 r 116 NY al 633 judgment case 14 ' a 147 NY mistake case IS r 116 NY a2SA case 27 foreclosure 82 AD case 43 salary a 114 NY a2SA 704 651 410 482 C26 267 634 costs case 6 42 43 SS 14SNY case^lO negligence r 104 NY rl SA ^ VOL.41. I fr'd statute m 116 NY 263 5 inventor a 118 NY 30 breach of trust c4 AD 679 562 16 495 93 120 9 claim a 110 NY d49 63 64 15 CP 20 stockbook 22 M 721 d 24 M 195 20 NC 193n 166S 906 23 constitutional 44 165 ordince weighing 91AD 446 knowledge intent 34M 275 26 knowledge 43M 275 29 specify amt. 128S 101 43 construe will m 111 NY 480 46 averments 41 . 580 election 64 AD 45 Sep. judgment. 52 28 mandamus 152 NY 514 a 152 NY 516 release validity 23 NC S3 duty surrogate 133S 1107 direct account 74M 313 1 00 intruder 28 M 65M 170S sum- pro, 59 M valid lease 186AD 174S "squatter" 174S 160 S 47 usury a 116 NY 43 bk. deposit 123AD 844 441 307 847 172 217 220 29? 652 319 6 I eompliance e 60 468 affidavit 636 evidence case 3? r 1 SA 377 637 judgment case 4 r 113NY 667 r2SA 255 638 accounting case 1 a 113 NY 622 objection rl6 NY 421 76 e9 AD 2M 17 M 24 M 31 M 2 AC '3 AC 12 CP ISCP 594 review 50 87 I 1 AD 598 assessment a 106 NY e45 92 2SM 126 NY 135 NY 542 bequest corp a 110 NY IAD e36 AD e 29M intent 106M ~ 678 162 234 208 425 545 certified 2 SS 627 561 536 167 198 132 352 474 178 251 £0 NO 60n 56n 605 authority a 113 NY 80 evidence 7 AD 124 NY performance 41 AD 670 277 590 649 75 530 591 509 646 240 463 109 trial jury r 114 NY 674 stkholders action eS AD 212 NY 90 M 160 S Fervices f 1S9S 173 131 87 623 263 reasonable value 153AD 839 compensation f 178AD 596 d 160 S 260 f 165S 877 demand unnec. 160 S 623 increases d 174 AD 52 1 1 3 memoranda 281 681 104 243 735 685 16 62n 363n 203 442 178 rll4 NY 79 evidence d4 AD 23 NC [ 1 7 nuisai 38 M 18 NC authority ■ 16AC regulation 82 M ql43S 76 compliance 46 591 confession judgt 57 304 e 44 AD 352 do 44 AD 366 statement facts 43AP 10 consideration 37 CF 146 80 damages 46 72 5LKA 87 costs a 1 06 NY e42 387 470 737n 667 175 89 all witnesses 129S 205 74M 26 83 M 289 compliance 83 M 293 duty proponent 83 M 295 duty Burrog. 83 M 296 95 fill inventory 280 598 29 118 606 133n 348n 120 297 18 NC . ISln counterclaim U5AD 8SS 1 63 ev. error e 48 445 avoidance 22 NC 340n 1 67 prom, note 9 AC 218n presumption 60 M 318 1 72 judgment a 119 NY 635 right to street 127S 520 142AD 586 legis. intent do 142AD 804 do 127S base fee do 142AD fee vested 149AD 134S 864 804 742 193 1 83 surrogate 34 M 684 executn. paymt. 38 M 66 1 88 notice 48 14 CP 167 245 203 undue inS 11 AD 587 evidence 70 AD 628 waiver 10 AC 448 disclosures 201NY 128 206 cloud title a 111 NY 204 32 AD 431 do 185 NY 464 St limitations 185 NY 464 547 57 229 567 1 20 h'way neg. 2 SS 387 1 23 joinder d 21 NC lln 1 25 life estate 47 112 e 52 305 33 156 67 247 276 54 71 AD do 71 AD 79 AD q 11 IM 120 NY will construe 58 M 220NY 346 348 531 312 380 99 443 1 39 contract 69 603 1 46 compe t. ev 17 AC 76n construetion 17 AC 69n 1 52 judgment a 114 NY 639 1 60 contract 27 AD 611 act on judgmt 5 AC 396n g AC 177n leave to sue 2 1 2 costs 71 85 SS 168 NY discretion review 39AD 366 judgment 50 AD 229 2 1 6 per. injury e85 91 2 1 8 breach con- tract a 109 NY 143 84 580 72 262 latent defect 149 NY 151 235 atty's lien r 112 NY 157 18 NC 31n 242 certificate 36 AD 571 d 24 M 206 110 AD 489 15 CP 388 264 privileged e 84 120 e 1 AC 331 10 AC 70n 72n 161 S 628 175 AD 17 257 demurrer 30 M 395 Complaint 3 AC 30Sn separately state 157 AD 721 142 S 661 268 jurisdiction 74 341 affidavit 63 AD 398 10 AC 181 270 exceptions e 86 435 nonsuit 8 AD 123 278 judgment a 110 NY 675 counterclaim 8M 151 26 122 28 1 pub. officer 33 M 55 salary d43M 284 res ipsa loq r 114 NY 462 e 122 NY 128 5M 269 287 judgment a 103 NY 657 e 41 300 d55 97 65 134 legislative power es AD B 17 NC lllNY argument d 139 NY 243 64 466 596 243 husband support 75 22 NC 249 costs d42 61 d63 22 NC 17 CP 72 M 130 S 521 334n 167 366 21 71 274 112 1096 299 liability 107 NY 220 4 LRA 327n 303 dismissal a 118 NY 685 meas, damages 34 M 632 insurance 36 M 288 307 assessment d 71 AD 573 authority atty 23M 5 40 M , 135 compliance 20 NC 51n 309 taxation 44 106 31 1 contract a 120 NY 79 47 106 3 LRA 739 4 AC 112n spec, prfmance 22 NC 411n 3 1 8mtgor mtgee 71 352 323 judgment a 103 NY 683 assignment 116 NY 415 e 125 NY 49 1 1 SA 237 326 intention e 48 499 BKEVlAilUMS: a, anirmea; a, aistinguisnea; i. loiiowea; r, reversea; m, moainea; , aisimsocu, .■,..«"•. :iticised ; 1. limited : e, explained ; o, overruled ; s, same case ; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q. questioneo N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Hun Vols. 41, 42 332 weight of ev. 44 189 lOS AD 298 preBumption e4M 227 6LRA ev. poBBession 126 S 95 occupier 69M 449 41 344 certiorari 135 NY 127M 345 trust r 112 NY ILEA 299 419n 351 judgment d48AD 11 M el7M 1 AC contempt 18 NC 107 280 219 104 217n 357 iuB. policy r 118 NY^ 389 S LRA 808n 36 1 opinions 59 92 warranty 150AD 193 NY 516 277 350 2S9 366 jurisdiction 47 70 injunction d63 d 112 NY probate 2LRA 179, 180 626 404 negligence a 110 NY 604 54 AD 31 2 LRA 615 jury question e 33 AD 598 future damages 21 NC 4n 407jury question 91 301 p 2 AD 63 d 2 AD 7S 410 judgment case 1 a 105 NY 681 a 137 US 345 a 137 US 258 right of action 83 AD 342 106 AD 189 4 1 5 St. limitatns r 113 NY 243 4 1 8 evidenoe r 118 NY 424 373 mandamus do 55 AD 548 377 administra- tor a 112 NY 41 661 280 203 93 227 98 137 321 157 387 431 135 155 457 personal contract 21 NC 84n pars, represent, do 148 AD 83 132S 1037 individually do 148 AD liability do 148 AD 44 88 e!2AD ell3 AD a2SA 12 M 25 M e 26 III sl7M slSNC 2 AC 105 NY 380 injury r 114 NY 609 45S 420 contract a 112 NY SAD elSM 230 545 642 422 libel e62AD 93 AD do 149 AD f 165 AD do 165 AD f 170 AD 33 M d36M e37M 171 NY 14 AC do 133S 150 S do 150 S 165 549 157 6 7 463 623 390 509 390 2)7n 861 466 467 156 S 100 101 special damage 165 AD 391 170 AD 461 150 S 1053 distinction d 166 AD 424 trust m97NY confessions e2gM divorce 12 7S 160 S 379 460 382 examination 46 626 68 313 315 384 juror 45 highway e20M 106 AD 450 785 acquiescence 142AD 850 425 steam rail- 311 522 49 386 declarations 110 NY 22 NC ILRA 395 fraud r 115 NY 4 AC 23 NC 211 337n 254 387 95n 164 398 negligence d 64 184 e 115 NY 223 damages way r 105 NY 97 110 AD 389 434 judgment 45AD 4H4 do 155 NY 31 H 42 M 635 182 M 637 e 101 AD 362 cause existent 90 M 563 153 S 903 447 presumption 41 AD 141AD 5 LRA , construct n 62M Intent 62M voluntary 123 AD do 123AD survivor 125 S co-tenants t 150 S 214 NY 414 S7 814 476 8 44 trust 247 864 881 365 91' 450 negligence r 113 NY 54 452 title 19 M e49M 476 34 317 161 360 658 361n 455 demurrer 60 84 13 OP appeal 2 AD 21 NC jurisdiction 124 S 191 amendment 139 AD 591 458 grant land under water a IIB NY 382 rights fisherman 43 AD 224 48 I ad- findings 191 466 85 661 64 66 92 Certificate e29M court's power 67 M 588 send bck report 139 AD 676 referee power 124 S 525 &ndings further 124 S 810 new trial 138AD 273 463 open decree 46 501 court 8 power 72 697 no relief 68 M 13 124 S 909 479 tax nonresi- dents r 123 NY 142 3 SS 317 492 foreclosure 90 AD 687 tender 16 M 603 181 NY 266 equity suit 223NY 74 5 1 assessment 24 M 36 5 1 2 evidnce neg 437 party in int 96 AD 334 439 franchise 16 AD 13 a 16 NC 307 444 judgment a 105 NY 7 e60AD 60 AD p60AD d5.M 1 LRA 580 681 582 333 69gn 529 certiorari e 166 NY 475 542 amendment do 67 AD 273 waiver 2 AC e26M 18 NC 600 actn dams a 116 NY 351 171n 545 stk. sub- scription r 120 NY 244 549 trust r 116 NY 120 553 legis. power 68 600 558 sum trial 50 5 AD 2 LRA limitatn. 104 AD 56 jury trial 59 AD 10 AC 629 221 24 56 I executor 31 AD 179 566 spec, pro- ceeding 6 M 120 571 demurrer 142 443 13 686 S30n fraud 666 601 limitation 2LkA 830n 603 assignment d 62 529 17CP 143 petition notice 88 76 AD discovery 48 AD 62 AD 79 AD 12 M 326 581 335 316 102 68 605 pleadings 72 83 74 AD 76 AD 95 AD SM 33 M 103M 169S stockholders 3 AC interest 139 AD 124 S justify 178AD 165S 332 451 63 520 190 629 373 78 369n 758 532 723 147 575 marriage r 116 NY 310 costs 10 AC . 64n 66n 577 guaranty a 111 NY 269 579 damages 71 466 incidental 217' NY 247 581 discretion e48 116 appeal 54 6 88 383 21 AD 632 31 AD 563 amendmt costs 43 AD 3SS 10 M 67 M lAC 7 AC 101 AD 17 CP 323 459 216 237 39 85n87 320 354 terms appeal 124AD 623 cond prcdt 63 M 6 pay costs 124 S 600 4 LRA769n797n 521 broker r 120 NY liable 8M 163 263 524 partnership 585 fraud el9M set off 54 M 609 390 59 1 authority 170S 738 594 demurrer 138AD 791 a 111 NY 644 d60 e22AD 30 AD e77AD 119 AD 129 AD 14 M 33 M 40 M 8 AC 48 M demurrer 16AC 244 476 510 314 796 18 483 126 270 386 458n 199 237, 609 lease lauds a 129 NY 675 e 46 AD 347 6 1 3 jurisdiction 49 603 15 CP 446 6 1 6 larceny 107 NY 21 NC 637 damages case 8 a 116 NY a2SA case 12 reference a 104 NY al SA case 13 partnership a 114 NY case 26 nonsuit r 116 NY r2SA 649 409 501 665 414 838 finding fact case 5 a 116 NY 654 a 2 SA 412 639 damages case 5 a2 SA r 114 NY case 25 covenants a 113 NY case 29 insurance a 116 NY 412 236 81 106 640 frd transfer case 1 a 115 NY findings e20AD 20 AD case 11 evidence a 110 NY a2SA case 13 criminal law 122 74 75 123 671 116 470 e 130 NY 582'a 103 NY 655 a2SA case 16 judgment a 116 NY case 17 damages a 114 NY case 20 a2SA interpleader a lis NY case 34 negligence a,114NY 641 collision case 26 a 104 NY case 33 contract a 114 NY 642 arrest case 15 a 103 NY' a ISA appeal case 20 104 rl SA case 23 partition r 104 NY 32 a 1 SA revoke will a 110 NY 341 657 341 648 682 216 690 239 643 290 643 481 265 284 643 ejectment case 6 rill NY case 8 accounting m 111 NY case 20 appeal a 114 NY a2SA case 37 master's negl r 111 NY IHS 644 conviction case 2 a 109 NY 61 a2SA ] case 3 contract r 115 NY r2SA case 26 contract r 115 NY VOL. 42 I reject title d 34 AD 422 22 NC 412n spec, prfmance 6M 246 presumption 169 AD 90 153 S 1034 9 guardian 48 252 wards expenses go 387 ■ 6 ccrtif. deposit 104 AD 91 22 vesting 49 674 supt. proceeding 81 99 satisfy judgment 7 AD 630 do gl AD 271 21 M 374 22 M 491 1 AC 151 lS8n order action 115 8 70 25 vacate order 61 M 37S serve order lOPNS 194 27 appeal a 106 NY 669 63 682 684 68 381 exempt tax 6 AD 89 UM 288 22 NC 54 exclusive use 32 AD 202 e 63 AD 186 683 327 645 amendment case 17 rlOlNY 669 case 1 7 a 2 SA 143 tr ansfer tax case 19 104 NY 306 19 NC 2221. 234n 2 NC 412 4 LRA 172 case 30 sp, prfmance a 113 NY case 32 contract a 116 NY case 37 appeal a 112 NY r 101 NY 646 trust 1 a H2NY case 19 construe will r 111 NY case 21 assignment a 115 NY 303 230 677 669 486 372 35 63 AD 85 AD eSSAD 684 79 80 34 att'y liable a 11 NY 410 39 appeal * 116 NY 671 45 rescission 26 AD 641 47 AD 40 3 M 649 4 AC 107n breach contract e 140 NY 293 future profits 47 AD 57 AD e23M 172 NY limited 139 AD recovery 125 S 154 S in advance f 169 AD 6 1 parol ev. e 122 NY 54 AD 40 406 649 408 1015 574 416 604 ABBREVIATIONS: i >, criticised ; 1, limited : .. affirmed ; d. e. explained ; i 68 uncertainty 42 66 parol ev. error e 54 AD 603 72 eq. set-off a 115 NY 1 61 344 e 135 NY 226 2 LRA 273n 126S 976 counterclaim ^OM 425 77 local custom 76 .184 distinguished; f. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note >, overruled : s, same case ; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case : a, questioned Vol. 42 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Hun Oiia 521 competent do 205 NY 581 contravention 155 AD 779 80 larceny r 106 NY 502 48 126 20 NO 37."> 90 rea. judicata 14 M 180 appealable 18 M 575 37 M 759 93 attachment a 107 NY ■ 673 e 44 AD 395 res judicata 14.VI 180 5 AC 380n 98 remedy 82 ' 131 pastor's rghts 120 NY 432 1 03 deposition e 172 NY 149 108 AU ^37 1 LRA 481 n 5 LRA 834d I 1 tender a 118 NY 676 71 482 141 S 330 proof breach 15 AD 58 rierformance 79 M 632 I I S domicile r 107 NY 55 8 AC 149n 150n 153l I 2 I levy return a 114 NY 622 e62 613 assets trust fund 82 AD , 50 130 appeal a 122 NY 671 1 36 fun. expense charge estate 71 398 e 2 AD 16n 35 AD 252 I M 32 18 M 140 22 M 66 10 AC 457n 469n II AC 430n I 40 remunerat'ii 51 169 l47incompetev 65 223 I 53 Corp. sland'r 5 AC 107n 100 AD 362 d 182 NY 605 allegation 89 M 577 153 S 720 161 excepton r 113 NY 386 91 325 16 AC 382n 3 LRA 230n 6 LRA 367n I64sp'l proced'g 48 256 e49 16 e 63 494 64 92 15 CP 120 1 66 costs a 110 NY 608 61 355 22 NC 71 17 CP 274 ru M 112 114 "i;M 115 '30S 109e 1 :!0 S 1097 ' 30 S 1098 1 67 costs e63 21 appeal waiver 2 AC 170n 1 70 costs 43 18 1 73 claim notice e 45 306 5 AC 308n I 86 civil rights 1 110 NY 418 192 no power -3 M flO 132S 158 I 96 misdemean 37 M 129 200 demurrer 84 243 202adv possesso I 120 NY 3lO 49 ■ 421 ?05 costs 72 23 '!4 M 457 406 221 207 costs 18 M 508 e 34 M 409 15 AC 31n 2 1 2 ohge. benefic 60 383 83 396 e 3 AD 469 do 57 AD 514 17 M 741 14 AC 195n 5 LRA 96n 98n 2 1 6 liability a 116 NY 682 70 254 sureties 81 442 town negligent e25M 116 complaint 20 NC 16 ipdicpte hy. 14 AC 264n 22 1 assignor 59 AD 388 4 SS 567 225 sum. pro. a 115 670 do 42 262 232 liquid, dam. r 112 NY 247 237 life insur. 55 106 breach contract 78 193 239 assessment r 106 NY 266 3 LRA 661n final judgment e 214 NY 601 245 insurance a 116 NY 637 c 42 253 2 LRA 787n 3 LRA 487n suicide 46 364 burden on plfT. e 46 427 oleading 1S2AD 874 170S 720 252 mut benef associatition 42 245 suicide 46 364 burd on plff. 46 427 proper action 51 499 52 259 5 SS 586 burden proof 55 576 d 55 578 2 LRA ■ 787n 3 LRA 487 n jury question 59 16 death benefit 17 M 638 law action 117 NY 319 benelciary 2LRA lein liability 177AD 819 164S 269 258 jurisdiction a 115 NY 562 crde- bar. 121AD 799 268 pleading 75 428 e HG 308 IAD 1.33 62 AD 145 83 AD 3 90 AD 191 131AD 290 1 33 NY 24fi -11 SOS 119 nrnof<5 necessary '1 71 M 313 cotenants 1 R3S 1024 action les T.-VM 648 Ipffal conclusion 1R6 AD 68 151 S 607 270 impeach ev. 19A0 329n 273 discharge r 108 NY 1 con.«?titutional 1.3.53 278 anpeala I. 50 AD .546 de facto officers 86 M 89 149 S 160 274 gift" rll3'NY 386 278 variance r 106 NY 616 a 113 NY 152 4 AC 191 28 I counterelm 92 ? 105 AD 271 131AD 389 improper pidg. 18 AD 566 105 AD 34(1 17 M 663 appeal 16 AC 447 no counterelm. 10PNS 299 "pviRjv 96 M 543 161 S 951 282no new trial ICPNS 300 29 I f'rd transfei a 115 NY 139 306jury question 52 281 3 I Oexemp. dam. r 116 NY 530 52 286 3 1 3 expert ev. 58 AD 366 reversible error f 66 AD 571 72 AD 370 46 M 490 rules of ev. 57.M 602 323 3d party 52 M 372 326 assets e68 ust 80 transfer tax 25 M 468 not taxable 103M ■ 520 171S 861 152 110 332 limitation 2LRA 830n 335jury question 80 47 confessions 13 AC 287d 161 S 610 347 credibility 3 AD 128 2 SA 432 36 M 1 lis NY 662 349 discretion 58 241 459 14 AD 560 65 AD 215 9 M 566 97 M 445 IRl S 430 admnatration 62 M 344 353fact question m 107 NY 205 44 192 allegations 55 472 revers. error 26 AD 481 359 ored'r suit 48 412 363 revocation a 118 NY 244 366 appeal 47 AD 21 1 87 AD 488 161 S 603 369 dower r 113 NY 293 374 extension 4 AC 287n 376 evidence 1 47 487 21 NC 374n 4 LRA 646n ?7P oossn. limifn i AD 315 que.«tion fact 12 M 492 38 1 assignment 60 265 62 148 22 AD 615 20 NC 160 22 Nr 332o 4 LRA 646n 384 forfeiture 46 396 s 57 303 de facto officer e70 4 violation d 173 AD 341 d 158 S 759 388 beneficiary r 115 NY 506 r 23 NC 452 392 damages I LRA 340n 394 indorsement 52 AD 60 lex loci 169 NY 544 88 M 485 398 foreelosure a 118 NY 46 no cross exam. 1278 55 142AD 260 160 S 1113 402' cause death r 116 NY 450 51 174 404 ejectment 116 NY 6 41 I partnership a 111 NY 404 4 1 4 receivei m 106 NY 423 s 119 NY 628 47 692 s 53 623 3 20 NO 36 4 1 9 inpuranee r 113 NY 147 423 adm power e 38 M 281 434 attestation ' a 110 NY 278 e45 4 74 AD 464 e 2 RS 220 1 LRA 162n 11 AC 251 acknowledgmn't el6M 210 440 douD ttit.le 22 NC 413n 442 reference r 111 NY 577 444 cotenancy d 1 AD 256 21 AD 131 relief pleading .53 AD 601 2 AC 279r •I'll tiuthority 81 M 49" f 143 S 492 459 appeal a 118 NY 49 36.= 213 465 mechan. line 54 423 470 adrainist't'n !rll2NY 525 2 LRA . 79Sn 472 lettrs admin. 2LRA 7r5n 481 pers. trans, r 113 NY 391 484 priority 161 AD 283 146 S 811 486 reformation r 118 NY 67 23 NC ISln 490 construction 37 AD 30 champerty 11 AG 286n 45 M 631 496 ultra vires a 118 NY 46 e45 88 13 AC 266n 267n I LRA 861n 502 place trial 46 AD 328 8 AC 355o 22 NC 327 504 estoppel 43 M 528 507 interest m 113 NY 198 61 265 52 361 5 \ 6 decree * 121 NY 664 codifv rule 201NY 129 disclosures 201NY 128 520 guardian r 114 NY 859 46 347 17 CP 25 accounting 47 251 action form of e 57 20 524 confession 29 M 672 37 M 30 II AC 203n corroboration 171 AD 135 142 S .".OO insufficient f 146S 246 528 preference a 1 1 6 NY 487 a 116 NY 664 .i8 193 201 4 SS 567 e 109 NY 341 e 124 NY 451 530 commissions •117 NY ens 104 AD 51 17 M 613 534 contempt 67 2S5 56M 462 cond. precedent 148AD 43'( fine HAD 401 jurisdiction 47 AD 236 adjudication 51 AD 583 RCtual loss 9."; AD 409 indemnity 68 M 498 p 124 S 754 132S 904 prove loss 68 M 499 536 authority a 115 NY 635 44 36j> 542 confessions f 157 S 12 545 atty. lien 137AD 186 549 injunction r 112 NY 206 e33AD 9 22 NC flln use streets 55 M 146 557 undertakng r 105 NY 627 49 496 64 AD 581 119 NY 309 22 NC 163n 560 tax d 128 NY 528 exemption 133 NY 393 563 will proof 32 M 194 1 LEA 162n 17 AC 394n 567 damages r 112 NY 186 114 NY 438 571 contract a 116 NY 539. 48 582 58 1 assessment 53 489 36 287 11 M 26& 21 NC 171 trustee 169 NY 29 d8M 34 592 partition m 106 NY 488 602 review 88 32!l ■>18NC 381 2 AC 13& 507 accounting 3 AD 413 court's power 40 AD 168. procedure 129S 427 petitions rule 144 AD 834 jurisdiction 155 AD .596 140 8 633 142 S 448 proceedings 105M 125 172S 647 6 1 4confirmation- a 104 NY 570 62 1 construction, a 107 NY 42 11 AD 119 139 US 428 unconstitutional 121AD 824, 828 633 probate rill NY 466 636 income e 3 AD 282 surplus proof e4AD 323 e 3 AC 161 prove fact f 159 AD 432 638 a ppeal ABBREVIATIONS : a, affirmed; d, distinguished: f. followed; r, reversed; m, modified: *, dismissed; n, note; c. criticised: 1. limited: e. explained: o. overruled: s. same case; do, dissentini; opinion; p. parallel case; q, questiotieo N. 7. Supreme Court Reports— Hun Vols. 42, 43 • no NY . 681 17 OP 196 64 1 discovery 52 M 94 643 contempt a 108 NY no e 1 SA 521 a 3 M lOo 33 M 123 1 AC 1003 646 effective f 145 S 813 official bond 160 AD 306 647 damages r 118 NY 297 65 1 contract cuae 6 r 111 NY 251 652 relief case 1 12 M 507 case 30 appeal a 116 NY 656 misdemeanor case 4 a 106 NY 321 653 service corp case 27 2 AC 76n 654 claim ndtice case 13 SAC contract case 8 164 AD 150 S 310n 532 225 655 report case 9 a 120 NY a2SA damages case 14 a2S A 657 r. r act case 32 aSSA 658 appeal 115 AD 834 579 417 336 266 659 accomplice a 104 NY 561 a 2 SA 690 VOL. 43. I executors a 118 NY 43 AD 1 LEA 4LRA by heirs 89 M 679 334 524n e06n 518 I I redemption a 120 NY 217 1 4 presumption 64 66 67 73 75 construction 4M 31 M 87 68 281 488 436 661 224 1 7 indemnity 20 AD 272 costs 29 AD 118 17 M 93 costs 38 CP 395 20 book entries 9 AC 154n 22 costs discret'n 45 AD 167 7 AC 73n 79 26 safe appliance 48 294 111 AD 621 '33 new trial S AC 392d e 101 AD 318 review 640 35 crim. law r 106 146 52 lien stock a 122 NY 423 d 46 316 55 review 69 77 88 dll AD 63 AD 41 M waiver 2 AG 65M 1263 70M 651 122 307 410 144 229 31n 167 1116 456 specify errors 140 AD 97 practice appeals 125 S 919 6 1 contract a 118 NY 237 9 AD 341 e 29 AD 73 67 highway ob- struction 147 NY 663 7 1 warranty r 118 NY 260 48 580 1 LRA 339n 5 LEA 703n 82 partnership 52 342 76 213 86 review order d 46 324' 88 er physician a 106 NY 298 45 308 hypothetical question SAD 76 incompetency 18 AD 493 95 inspection 6 AC 265n discovery 62 M 94 98 delegation e 48 224 surrogate power 53 597 distrib, share 10 AD 697 findings excepns e 44 AD 408 6M 138 1 02 illegal as- sessment a 122 NY 229 59 88 16 AD do 15 AD 24 AD 29 AD 30 AD ellM 24'M exempt 106M 175S 612 168 147 154 491 162 43 204 588 213 1 26 judgment 2LRA 831n execution 2LRA 831n 1 27 cemeteries a 118 NY 61 1 3 1 assr's oath a 106 NY 20 NC costs 167 AD 153 S 330 50n 859 794 1 40transf.pledge 18 M 187 1 42 action causie a 122 NY 322 63 373 e 87 AD 496 error court 95 M 586 f 159 S 846 1 47mortge filing r 118 NY 666 51 AD 90 r 2 SA 432 21 M 689 1 50 promise a 124 NY 633 78 632 92 268 5 AD 369 3 AC 28 1 54 waiver costs a 110 NY 657 d 52 182 54 686 disbursements 76 86 qSAD 57 AD e57 AD 33 U 2 AC 10 AC 10 AC e 126 NY ,103 AD ' 14 AC 20 NC 611 63 310 100 570 571 321 173n 59n 60n 66o 111 419 24n 184n bxation .costs 5811 362 d 142AD 3 costs consent 80 M 29;i £ 142 S 213 1 58 contract a 120- NY 623 d IBO NY 49 162 mortgage assignmeni 70 79 e 8 M 239 do 8 M a41 l84reS'e mortg 64 boU 9 AC 434n 167 conversion; a 114 NY 1B7 62 218 19 M 13U burden deft. 65M 536 1 79 beneficiary 53 161 d 56 261 160 S intent ,95 M 439 1 8 1 alimony m 116 NY 635 44 AD 636 94 48 413 g4u 27 9n 40 M e99 AD 182 NY 14 AC 21 NC 188 statement 176 AD 366 9M 373 5 AC 248n compliance 162 S 1025 201 final judg't a 118 NY 187 do 79 AD 431 ■*32 214 costs 66 88 20 AD 92AD 148 NY 16 Ac 16 CP 16,1 S statutory 87 M 623 220 272 81 292 26n 133 402 173 2 1 8 insurance 61 113 224 f'd prefernce all8 NY 86 25 AD 124 NY 22 NC 187 421 507 450 331n 233 damages 3 AC 401n 1 LEA 651n 4 LEA 646n carrier usage 2 LEA 76n 241 fraud 12 AD 20 M 137 NY estoppel fl49S f 164 AD 195 634 313 339 32 247 award costs 24 M 221 7AC 145n 249 party deft. 210 NY 466 254 prox.eause 61 174 63 63 2p8 assessment e60 222 23 AD 48 128 NY 371 263 impld repeal 4LEA 310 265 damages 132 NY 94 11 M 75 druggist negl. 16AC 268n.272 274n 271 damages II AD 122 «4 AD 603 III AD 366 1 LRA 297 n advancements 61 M 139 no warranty 138 AU 357 loss rentals 20AC lOOn 278no presmptn 180AD 880 282appeal a 120 NY 638 292 clear ev. a 112 NY 660 09 11, 4!) 4 SS 127 131 40 M 11 120 NY 656 f 153 S 621 299 charge ex- ception 48 388 3SS . 421 97 AD 469 30 1 bona fide hid 8 AC 229n 309 complaint 21 M 604 355 ev d 65 M lenant l.Si' S 74M fl49S prin.rght 144 right ,',64 401 (il6 358 blackmail a 104 NY 598 107 NY 104 365 sup. pro. 124 a 755 67 M 548 124 !■! 456 right creditor 139 AD 584 367 damages all4NY 885 371 ejectment r 118 NY 476 change venue d 154AD 323 434 judgment foreign a 113 NY 586 64 544 437 stay 7 AC 73d 443 new trial 377 debt stat. r 108 NY e 64 AD remedies 20 NC 269 'i,4 22 6n 379 preferences 21 M 230 387 separation 153 32 M 42 M 14 AC 6 LRA illegal void 130 AD 313 30 249n 132n 311 not 153AD appeal- able .324 328 res judicata 8 AC 21n 20 NC 67n 336 false im- prisonment d 47 347 s 24 NC 172 1 LRA 144n 342 services 21 M 461 20 NC 347n error court 123 S 624 competent ev. 138 AD 828 345 damages r 113 NY b3SA s 128 NY 64 3 LRA nuisance 11 BAD 632 501 595 630 257n 626 348 injunction 56 214 69 . 467 waive objns, 18AC 425n 354 order costs 86 500 165 397 criminal law 413 301 674 291 80 a 109 NY * 156 NY d46 156 NY 38 M 4 1 I arrest dam 45 AD 135 29 M 299 37 M 385 56M 624 5 AC 252 4 1 3 mecha'n. lain a 118 66 82 d 120 NY parties 119 AD 416 liability -"M 672 263 lei 211 392 238 419 declaration 80 AD 361 42 1 express waiver a 118 NY e48 2 AC 21 NC 6 LEA pers injury ILEA 77 302 80n 4n 242a l!4M 681n 425 damages r 118 NY 664 r 2 SA 437 427 involve pay- ment r 115 NY 637 125 NY 631 432 place trial 12 AD . 603 8 AC 357n 11 AC 315n f 138 S 1001 amendment 79II6 170n e93 AD 1 LEA decision 125 S laches 69M 359 191d 895 - 447 indictment 65 472 449 cond. sales - a 114 NY 7 59 26 452 b. particlrs 62 e61 82 ,';b AD 126AD 13ZAD 16 CP 87 211 369 550 26 179 38 454 tenancy a 118 NY 309 18 M 72 458 jury trial r 105 NY 567 o 83 551 6 AC 266d : 461 dower r 118 NY 649 470 master's duty 3 AD 149 472 judgment r 112 NY 627 2 LRA 206n 483 atty. lien 61 AD 18 M 35 M SAC 17 CP 72 405 44 572 ■ Sin 83n S65 487 subject liens 5LRA 282n , 491 subject eqtes. 5LEA 284d 493 contract e33AD 38 AD 55 AD 96 AD 96 AD 501 appeal a 112 NY 63 intent 125 S implication 141AD ABBUEVIATIONS: a, afiirmed;.d, •rtticaed; L limited: e, explained; o. overruled 248 562 618. .405 gOn 667 72. 882 58 505 pers. servioe- d 46 324 42 AD 154; 26 M iSg. 12 AC ISOn 14 CP 74 512 joinder 54 683 10 AD 517 29 AD 673 45 AD 354 60 AD distinguished 1 t, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *. dismissed; n, note- c ■ruled; i. same case; do, dissenting opinion: p, parallel case: a. questioned. 527 Vols. 43, 44 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Hun 89 AD f 119 AD 37 U 45 M 45 M 46 M 136 AD 217 NY party p'ff 39 OF 163 S 98 M 5 1 6 tender 118 NY 1 LRA 440 526 78 473 470 175 5 247 362 834 681 167 306n 52 1 oounterclm 673 422 23 332 210 577 670 126 369 264 266 a 106 NY 69 70 e42AD 57 AD 124 AD do 156 AD do 142 S >18NC d 166 NY do 166 NY lien disohftrge 106 AD- 201 abate- nuisance 134S 89 power court 149AD 477 do 153AD 145 do 138S 220 foreclosure 138S 218 settle rights 153AD 142 528 gift e 50 479 12 AC 3S2n 358d intent 175 AD 168 161 S 673 534 satisfaction do 91 15 M 22 M 2 AG contract 54 M 395 29 349 342 265 537 enforeement d 91 178 541- spec, per- formance » 112 NY 325 contracts ILRA 382n 546power court 123 S 73 138AD 483 547 appeal a 122 NY 663 552 conversion 16 AD 606 limitation do 193 NY 116 554 removal 570 indemnity e47 597 111 AD 100 572 abatement case 33 review a 106 NY 48 •lis NY 53 e53 104 AD 574 apnea r 106 NY 65 AD 493 339 481 533 619 310 638 meehan. lieu case 6 r 2 SA 438 case 20 trust property 580 ejectment a 118 NY 281 4 AC 129n 21 NO a74n 586 inherent pwr 60 M relief 98 M f 162 S 47 351 588 taxpayers d 87 549 22 AD 274 593 guardian 64 AD 541 12 AC 209n 597 instruction g AD 456 56 AD 256 8 1 I dam. relief a 108 NY case 29 award a 111 NY a2SA 640 draft ease S r 114 NY unenforclble case 12 147 S 641 trusts case 1 112 NY el2AD 17 AD 25 AD e2M 2 AC e4AC demurrer 12 AD 134AD 614 r. r street 89 35 364 515 278n 5 860 57 a llSNY 47 license fees 55 M ques. litegtd 126 AD 389 200 136 43 671 604 VOL. 44 3 complaint e53 17 CP 6 discharge r 114 NY 16 CP w 651 a 122 NY 629 affidavit 33 AD 136 d 127 NY 498 publication 20AC 229n 20AC 232n • 106 NY e47 SI AD 127S authority 127S 257 529 296 556 556 565 receiver a 115 NY 166 115 NY 275 633 damages cases a 53 AD negligence r 112 NY 634 appeal case 13 a 107 NY 635 appeal case 5 a 105 NY 107 NY case 40 foreclosure r 106 NY 648 234 676 523 425 269 636 bankruptcy case 11 a 106 NY 467 case 27 mandamus m 114 NY 245 637fact question 568 affirmative case 1 79 AD 535 a 111 NY 69M 638a2SA reversal case 4 126 S QSJappeal lain NY 686 131 282 679 123 17S 176 6861 500 258 23 369 714 9 demurrer f21M counterclaim 5 AC 240n 166S 451 12 expert ev, 47 432 18 M 32 future damages 21 NC 4n 1 7 pleadings 67 AD 326 3 SS 498 5 AC 66n 20 trust tax'n 21 NO 170 speculative 138 3 not a debt M3AD 709 24 poliae a 108 NY 105 31 oeveaaat r 124 NY 212 s83 612 33 relief 216NY 470 471 mandatory 166S 533 45 consolidation act s 18 NC 204 4 AC 209n stay vacate order 106 AD 387 49 recovery a 114 NY 58 7 AC 149 S 457n UU2 547 85 paymt note 4AC 283n 89 bill partic. 68 AD 487 9 1 party wall aH5Ny 95 will mils NY 59 41 M exemption 141 S intention 82 M 346 .550 383 711 552 1 02 tax exempt. r 113 NY e53 22 NC 1 07 appeal allSNY fact for jury d74AD 187 584 56 670 168 1 indorsement do 81 AD 621 525 d 19 M 179 178AD 61 agency d 134AD 624 not relieve 93 M 545 money only 98 M 28 161 S 1090 I 1 4 laches damages 165 AD 151 S 192 236 1 56 recovery 185 NY 127 1 62 crinsinal law a 106 NY 293 5S8 25 1 LRA 56 294 1 66 public health 57 38 2 LRA llOn 172 undue infll a2SA a 112 NY 16 AD 24 AD 25 M 26 M 134 655 616 478 559 37 76 478 55 interpleader 52 d69 75 10 AD 19 AD 21 AD 25 AD 30 AD 40 AD 77 AD 204NY 2M 16 M 24 M 28 M 2 AC attachment SAC 97 403 46 235 611 370 630 165 479 500 275 286 444 277 538 7 43 23Sn 950 I 1 9 incompt. ev. r 118 NY 304 e 48 171 e55. 306 21 NC 4n 1 23 injunction 78 165 s 19 NC 32 6 LRA 129n 1 26 books as ev, 57 dl3AD IS AD el3M 31 M 7 AC 197NY 538 209 26 635 273 477n 192 8 1 jury trial 68 368 76 J87 88 112 92 386 80 AD 152 156 160AD 249 478 f 160 AD 479 f 164 AD 527 12 AC 421n 42S 430 93n 324 988 497, 499 304, 305 207 210 211 4 123 170 658 53 77 733 247 128 up'I compl "" ■" 228 649 1 annual report a 120 NY 603 680 528 67 appeal a 111 NY 112 KY disqualification 9 AC 480n 2 LRA 796 Qon resident 1 LRANS 347n 348n 123 AD 214 70 attachment 25 M 659 75 mortgage a 118 NY 543 tact ques. trial e85A£; no issue 148AD demurrer 75M 258 133 S 426 133S 427 purpose supple- mentary plead. 148AD 648 149 AD 245 133.S 658 130 execution a 122 NY 635 67 ISS authority 113 AD 166 441 467 159 200 12 AC 14 AC 19A0 145 S 86 M 149 S £ 214 NY f 214 NY f 214 NY practice 11 AD 64M 38 CP 145 S preference 118 S strike out 157 AD Z41S right trial 160 AD frame issues 145 S 657 power rules 160 AD 250 joinder 149 S 276 1 84 forfeiture a 119 NY 450 2 SS 456 notice payment 37AD 681 51 M 782 performance 50 AD 148 lapsing 51 M 287 1 87 evidence 2AD 335 e 26 AD 481 62 AD 363 1 94 farm cross'g 49 540 197 judgment 206r. r. con- struction a 110 NY e39AD do39 AD pror right 19NC exempt f 218 NY injunction 177AD 164 S 128 36 44 426 279 702 431 149 eviction 61 435 73 294 AD 47 133 NY 347 measure dam'ges 156 AD - 141 140 S 1072 2 1 5 negligence a 110 NY 374 prcedure NC 432 2 1 9 negligence r 113 NY 378 4LRA213n240n 232 sp. prfmance 62 113 legal title 2M 142 3 LRA 339n 233 indictment m 107 NY 1 7 AC 461n 236 pers. injuries 61 356 598 a lis NY 81 89. evidence 13 AD 46 AU future BulTering 1163 NY 382 468 e 118 NY 87 122 NY ■ 98 239 power of sale 174 53U e72 79 partition 56 M 185 101 593 57M ippea a 112 NT 88 executors 12 M 20 M 34 U 2tAC 19A0 21 NC 118 AD 163 673 . 93 321 507 362 155 119b 846 242 neg. facts a 118 NY 527 247 discretion a 122 NY 669 55 218 261 conversion 16 M 679 266 jurisdiction 80 177. default appeal 91 300 14 AD 58 6 AC 41n appl. judgmt 16AC 444n 270 adv. posses- sion 88 393 2 AC 122 278 intent proof r 108 137 e64 76 amendment 196NY 368 293 com. council 85 607 construe liberal .^^al 14 M 296 c alio 77 79 42 U 298 deposit r 115 NY S37 679 316 85 20 10 ABBREVIATIONS: c, criticised ; 1. limited ; 304 coserv't neg. a 112 NY 64S 74 38 », affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note e. explained ; o, overruled ; s. same case ; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, questioned N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Hun Vols. 44. 45 83 ess 86 dSB damages 68 AD 118 NY signals er. doll6AD coservants 81 M 14a S 198 149 1S9 198 S63 407 674 182 313 236 2 AC 6 AC inequitable 73 M costs 132 S 387n SSSn 34 248 52 61 489 assignment a 118 NY 54 163 468 312 executrix a 116 NY e46 absolute fee 72 eonversion 81 ultra vires 80 1 Ac eIl5NY 144 38B 182 20 347 93q 294 374 vesting int. r 115 NY 251 9 91 AD 111 19 NC 274n385 378 wharf rights r 112 NY 263 5 LRA 64 rip. grants 5LEA 64n 386 forged draft • 119 NY 199 394 St. limitat'ns 320 eosts new trial 67 21 M SAC liability 73 M 133S 651 142 392n 525 281 49 I costs 81 1 AC supercedes 63M 493 legis. power 54 penalty 90 AD el9M 48 M eSOAD eSl AD elOM. ISM 25 Jf 33 Di 214 428 199 659 281 18 324 construe will e63 28 d63 71 1 M 64 f 3M 47 27 M 261 1 LRA 203n 204n 331 ademption lLRA203n, 204ii 333 compenaatn a 118 NY 629 342 oounterclm. 62 226 77 468 64M 15 allegation 14 M 489 344 impounds chattel BOM 440 construction f 80 M 441 warrant seizure 158 AD 592 141 S 297 143 S 853 346 delivery 60 574 signature ev. 63 341 349 compromise a 120 NY S83 66 172 357 devise a 113 NY 628 69 54 presumption 41 AD 417 lU 269 362 Gonfiiderat'B d 54 638 executed gift 9 AD 213 365 review a 118 NY 411 367servicea corp f 53M 276 371 neg. damage r 120 NY 164 372 atty'slien 1 AG 941 n 363 19 187 prin. office 69LRA 438n 548 legacy vest- ing 62 1 accounting case 8 a 115 NY 78 47 AD 1 LRA 7SM 138S 489 427 133 79 846 400 foreclosure 82 AD 484 412 warranty 8 122 NY 135 114 NY 635 420 one cause 8 46 509 60 131 cloud on title 88 393 2 AC 123 434 sale title r 114 NY 40 441 commissions 33 M 165 41 M 157 16AC 406n,408n compensation 145 AD 544 f 99M 210 129 S 943 £ 165S 796 448 findings a 118 NY 680 87 AD 603 45 1 St Umitat'n 9M 232 executor liable 19A0 120b charge 223NY 207 457 accounting 497 larceny 92 114 AD quiet intent 126 AD charge crime 135 AD 283 larceny , 136 AD 233,236 do 136 AD 240 507 adv posses sion 70 AD 80 AD 90 AD e33M 48 M d22NC 3 LRA good title 16AC defect, deed 17 AC 376n 5l5motionrelie 397 493 468 4' 14 410d 740n 133n 68 74 el2 AD 36 AD 47 AD 4 AC renewal 117 AD 13 AD 67 AD 68 AD 114 NY 14 CP 17 OP f 90 M t 154 S 175S 23 72 162 370 56 37 250 317 726 523 529 552n 240 160 552 revocation 63 AD 545 sl9NC 1 mandamus e 12 M 469 109 AD 198 reference 4 AC 140n 141n 9 AC 493n 554 amendment 189 NY 406 compliance 83 M 527 t 145 S 356 556 appeal time 63 114 do 118 557 transcript 29 AD 85 62 AD 671 prima facie ev 5M 533 2 LRA 831n 561 allegations r 112 NY g e 4 AC 382 16 CP 161 562 new trial 8 18 NC 484 389 188 432 524 583 34 38n 252 563 alimony 7 AC 253n punishment 20AC 298n 5 1 7 substitution 9 AC 311n 5 1 8 aliens devisees r 113 NY 28 70 AD 290 522 license in surance co. 13 AC 3971. 526 conunitm't a 106 NY 604 s 19 NC 142 628 decree case 14 a 125 NY 567 reference If ^ ^^ 37 165 hearsay ev. 136 NY 509 "=^86 16 court's power 129S 426 ultra vires 144 AD 834 530 demurrer 47 307 amend 't answer e56 334 335 336 371 672 622 bar case 10 r 118 NY rSSA 623 marriage case 1 r 116 NY case 8 accounting a 115 NY a2SA case 20 prom, note a 15 NY case 36 forgery r 106 NY 624 decree case 8 * 111 NY 252 157 310 258 288 523 625 fact question case 24 2 SA 958 626 negligence case 10 r 112 NY 371 case 13 undue influence a 2 SA 400 case 23 dissolution r 124 NY rSSA case 36 forgery r 106 NY boundary ILRA VOL.45. I will execution 47 8 e 2 SS 220 4 SS 234 46 M 640 6 assessors 76 AD 576 s 20 NC 44 certiorari motion 30 M 250 att'y verification 7 AC 376n 1 8 offer of costs 49 30 25 AD 140 e 7 M 529 5 AC 151n 153 23 alimony 6 AD strike out 76 AD 135 7 AC 253n 12 AC 140 intervention 5 M 319 4 AC 196n 10 AC 120n punishment 286 351 288 522n 732 388 r2SA 57'1 attestation a 10 NY 611 1 SS 625 1 LRA 162o 574 certiorari a 114 NY 317 82 303 28 AD 480 580 accounting * 110 NY 662 629 receiver e 9 m 106 NY banking case 40 B23NC . construction s 187NY 462 Stat, frauds 36 M 177 subscription 71 M 516 )30S 781 475 execution a 118 NY sl9NC 6 AC 23 NC 680 57 66n 223 480 false receipt B 19 NC 131 s 4 SS 418 487 exr. admr r 106 NY 645 48 184 qlSS pleadings 8M 123 NY 20 NC 13 CP 17 CP 133S relief spl. term 149AD 532 misdelivery a 124 NY 266 51 131 537 damages 51 131 545 corpn. tax'n 66 123 residence ev. 73 99 87 343 582 acknowlgnt, 19AC 423n 19AC 428n payment 475ldol51AD 331 043 468 54review 161 NY f20NC 65 new trial e 66 AD 92 e 8 AC 392 134 NY . 383 rights parties 73 M 265 recoupment 73 M 132S damages 132S 590 68 service cita- tion 38 AD 630 substituted serv 10351 421 171S 239 71 serv, process 4LRA 132n 84 contract 93 judgment 20AC 298n 6S9 317 400 533 608 846 512 30 bar 72 110 AD 174 AD 161 S retainer right 14 M 171 15 M 176 25 M 591 38 M 348 39 M 624 remedy ends 64 M 159 equity 147 S 654 85 JI 535 34 allegation 64 80 judgment con viction 12 AD 499 57 AD 421 duty of court a 120 NY 61 f 158 S bank fraud 21 M for jury do 172 AD 341 do 135 S remove bar do 151AD 381 591 limitations 2LRA 83 In 599 accid. insur 50 53 d 34 M 159 3 LRA 486n 608 justification 77 libel 16 AD 61 I bonds a 114 NY 508 83 518 591 197 681 813 940 581 68 303 267 688 €57 268 95 1 02 sealer 33 AD 19 CP 478 14 631 110 119 471 423 31 10 M 16 M e IBM larcenv 112 AD jurisdiction 132S information 148AD right counsel 92 M 371 152 S 891 genl. application 92 M 373 waiver 92 M 376 156 S 821 38 reference 61 AD 488 489 r 9 NC 259 267n 4 AC 140n revocation e93 AD exceptions 27 M 40 M 1 07 declarations 40S 74 53 AD do 53 AD 13 M 31 M 21 CP q 167NY173e 176 findings acctg. e 44 AD 408 liresumption 30 M 5 11 AC 338b competent ev. sa U 168 property right 105M 252 no interest 10511 253 I 13 assumed risk 55 4 AD 42 AD 120 NY master 53M 1 20libel 32 AD 83 AD 83 AD privileged 31 M 177AD 163 S summary 173 AD 159S 63 205 477 325 124 545 44 husb. wife d 44 M 333 49 highways 5 AD 580 e 1 SS 246 competent ev. 113 AD 449 589 474 476 478 39a 94 916 494 331 126 regularity a 110 NY 119 s 19 NC 421 4SS 9S 1 30 retaxation 14 AC 25n 1 33 execution 41 M 657 8 19 NC 62 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note: c. criticised : 1, limited ; e, explained ; o, overruled : s, same case ; do, dissentinz opinion ; p, parallel case : q, questioned Vols. 45, 46 N. Y, Supreme Court Reports — Hun 1 39 damageB r 120 NY 117 73 513 3 LEA 636n 1 44 defect no- tice 72 297 parties objoa. d 20 NC 343n 1 50 contract 3 SS 611e 512 damages certain ■ SAC 168 e 155 NY 462 meaa. damages 123AD 155 demurrer 1S8AD 895 1 53 rap. trans aet a 109 NY 32 156 eq. suit 36 AD 537 1 67 review 16 322 oontempt 95 AD 409 commitment e 17 M 219' 1 75 amendment 83 ^87 196NT S69 157 AD 511 142 S 624 variance 126 S 176 1 84 estoppel 87 205 39 AD 302 notice necess'y 19AC 222n 191 estoppel a 120 NY 168 s 19 NC 168 65 380 sp, performance 69 AD 505 193 stockholder a 121 NY 189 198 construction a 110 NY 569 61 353 IS LRA 89 authority do 96 AD 508 award 124AD 473 173S 326 2 1 habeas cor' pus ♦ 107 NY 607 construction 4M 554 219 receiver 140 NY 330 25 LRA 382 indemnity ILRA 1089 power court 123 S 73 cond. precedent 138AD 483 liability 80 M 400 141 S 268 consent necessary f 82 M. 387 143 S T61 225 will valid s 19 NC 36 47 AD 126 80 AD 76 104 AD 237 interest 16AC 414 incompetent ev.' 60 M . . 276 commission f 148 S 21 practice 163 AD 217 236 aasessment 127 NY 1S9 238j ury q uestion 10 M 714 240 appeal a 122 NY 649 waterside' 62 M 434 243 asieasment a 65 525 18 AD 30 certiorari 61 AD 200 51 AD 122 27 M 39 162 NY 431 246 demurrer costs 4M 349 a 21 NC 352n e 101 AD 133 15 AC 490 248 assignment a 114 NY 1 253 conversion 42 AD 342 miajoinder . 52 193 257 naiaanoe a 122 NY 18 259 extras bar e 77 340 L86 N Y 207 enforcement 134S 493 26 1 award a 121 NY 277 263 assignment a 115 NY 376 s 18 NC 330 e 55 571 265 judicial sale r 113 NY 17 24 CP 141n 272 review 88 AD 596 mandatory 3LRA 55ii 274 chge benef. 174 NY 167 113 AD 720 278 trust fund a 142 NY 632 e 31 AD 591 a 21LBA 389 9 9S 20 113AD 720 284acoounting 3 M 183 293 trustees r 107 NY 226 294oonBtrue will a 113 NY 366 Future interests 63 M 163 296 sp. prfm'nce a 120 NY 29 298 judgment a 122 NY 642 46 316 chattel mtge e25.AD 280 phange of title 116 NY 326 120 NY 616 305 treasurer 6 AC 310n 307 competent evidence d 26 M 66 3 1 oommis'nerB a 110 NY 080 r 143 NY 163 99AD oe5 3 1 3 external m- juries - a 113 NY 472 60 53 1 LRANd 423n aocident ina. 8S AD 87 viaible sign 16 AC llln 3 1 8 atipulation 46 316 46 353 e 92 609 12 LRA 861 title in tenant e 127 NY 164 chattel mtge. 46 352 contract 31 NC 222n 3 1 9 offer judgt. e 57 400 1 65 623 review c 91 AD 412 directory 17 M 367 eosts on appeal 16 AC 21n 323 ultra virea a 122 NY 671 e 57 365 designation 64 AD 689 329' preferences a 109 NY 631 d 62 153 e 73 332 d91 315 17 AD 196 do 17 AD 197 e 30 AD 323 36 AD 245 e 37 AD 109 S9 AD 484q p 3 SS 480 e 21 M 229 230 e 22 M 68 25 M 35 L27M 75] e 3 AC 23 e 148 NY 291 153 NY 61 6e 661 158 NY 529e 531 order f 140 S 1120 f 155 AD 017 347 receiver s 54 480 a 19 NC 350 354 corporations a 111 NY 66 a 136 US 152 371 restrictions 2LRA 388n 388 construction 8 115 NY 290 51 530 eq. conversion •> 121 NY 3 391 assessment a 108 NY 364 « 19 NO 117 notice 62M 316 396 neg. notice 49 320 15 AC 330n 398 nuisance 64 51 40 1 misjoinder 113 NY 608 64 541 ap performance 15 AC 2S9n 2LRA 406 trusts a 127 NY 652 e 2 AD 457 good title d 110 NY 74 fid. relations do 116AD 700 41 I assumption r 128 NY 35 127 NY 293 d 22 NC 331n 12 LRA 814 4 1 8 legacies r 113 NY 569 422 direct proof a 108 NY 67 46 482 486 corpus delict* 68LKA 38 432 injury e 63 586 non payment 160 NY 530 surplus money 6 AC 8n a 20 NO 163n Incompetent ev. H7AD 779 irrelevant ev. 39CP 269 578 dower * 113 NY 436 appeal a 120 NY 620 439 exclusion ev 43 AD 429 68 AD 206 206 87 AD 616 privileged 14 AC 123 442 estoppel a 108 NY 14 448 legis. power 122 NY 272 277 conditn precednt 60 M 506 453 subscription a 112 NY 51 50 M 506 458 fire neg. a 115 NY 579 460 conspiracy r 107 NY 427 26 M 614 21 NC 429 21 NC 450 5 1 9 dissolution rill NY 1 21 NC 131n 22NC_ 21 In alteration 47 M 199 552 assignment m 110 NY 351 22 NO 34lD 564 appeal a 120 NY 669 567 legal neg 46 389 67 300 575 legal ev. 125 NY ; 239 579 valid tender 72 M 641 582 admr. liable 107NY 624 e 24 AD 37 60 AD 171 do 60 AD176 179 e lllAD 283 e 12 M 325 33 M 76 37 H 331 liability f 160 AD 304 f 145 S 811 sureties 44 M 338 contempt 31 M 652 588fr'd represn'a case 17 a 120 NY 630 67 613 a 2 SA 576 589 contract case 2 r 2 SA 637 590 waiver cases 2 AC 80n 592 ejectment case 7 a 118 NY 602 s 133 NY 316 s 141 NY 373 69 614 593 damages case 9 a 118 NY 538 s 2 SA 152 22 NC 337n case 22 prom, note a 122 NY 667 a 3 SA 142 595 findings case 16 _ 3 SA 90 105 supersedeas case 18 a 110 NY 668 e 72 601 82 614 88 410 B 19 NC 150 credibility case 20 parties 3 AD 128 execution 85 AD 104 no application 185AD 482 173S 4 VOL.46 1 want of funds 86 483 2 AD 23 168 NY 124 counterolBim 36 AD 577 23 NC 39911 2 LRA 642n defense 126 AD BOO 9 instructions f 147 S 1016 162 AD 790 1 2 oompeneation a 137 NTT 556 114 NY 243 estoppel 4111 123 cause aotion do 129S 480 liability do 145 AD 102 8 oonaideratioB 20 AD 77 d 114 NY 21S 132 NY " 632 28 NC good faith 116AD 670 22 insolvency a 122 NY S59 67 AD 619 a 8 SA 13( 32 presunsptlon 15 AD 192 86 AD 610 611 153 NY 446 13 AC 345 84« competent ev. 118 NY 88 180 NY 90 15 AO legitimacy 59 M 122 consummated - 170S 23 66 AD 82 86 AD 106 e 93 AD 94 111 AD 434 118 NY 429 430 e 118 NY 4SS do 118NY 441 d 120 NY 538 163 NY 584 1S6NY 322 f 20T NY 511 opinions 123 S 731 139 AD 215 f 168 AD 401 no better evid. 225NY 292 08 construction 62 M 569 7 1 claim proof 93 AD 590 75 jurisdiction 41 appeal a 124 NY negligenee 66M 123 S liability 210 NY 341 702 105 48 constxuction 4M 364 exemptions do 46 U 279 52 transcript 56 274 e 67 568 e 62 AD 67 19 OP 213 jurisdiction 18 OP 339 18 CP 339 19 CP 213 4 LRA 35n 57 almanac a 122 NY _ 666 judicial notice 63 AD 146 364 77 AD 496 118 NY 622 64 surrogate 42 M 44 24 CP 268 juriadirtion 3LRA 814n 66 expert ev. 66 514 87 687 26 AD 396 444 47 AD 330 50 AD 587 a 122 NY 66 eSl AD reformation 8CP 84 281 396 295 82 demnrrer 11 AC 177n 87 St. non user a 122 NY 285 e 64 566 56 291 d6H 201 13 AC 24 AD <;76AD £79 AD 143 AD 49 M power 70 Jl e70M inteDtion do81 AD 5M 34 M 132 NY 141 NY will construe 58M 610 231 126 623 220 266 299 execatioB L31AD 298 Z 1 9 income trust sis 636 S5 507 64 ' 280 60 AD 444 135 NY 292 sale 531 789 207 ' 2 20 commissions is 2 S 47 378; 67 AC 52 379 d 37 M 839 846 1201 NY 215 454, 19'' 8137l|^' S 12 99 76 143 AD 258 1 50 civil action a 1 S 672 p 90 AD 424 I do 90 AD 428 71 signature s 1 S 692 10 AC 263n 76 change venue Bis 801 8 AD 621 8 AC 35an SOnen trial BlS n9t> 54 6 55 AD 91 3M 444 16 M 513 42 M a SAC 394n 396n terms appeal 124AD 523 83 g inter vivos sis 16 AD 17 AD 24 AD 53 AD f 66 AD 105 AD 30 M 1 9 I cond. sale 714 551 10 478 606 622 503 183 703 550 126 20 333n 348n lis 57 85 21 CP 22 NC execution 4 AC conversion 10 AC 225n 226n 1 00 recovery s 1 S 372 a 117 NY 354 e 136 NY 196 form payment f 219 NY 500 I 07 damages s 1 S 823 a 112 NY 419 I 14 jurisdiction sis 619 6 AC 14n f 1 7 bailee neg. sis 862 r 123 NY 57 1 22 appeal sis 850 a 121 NY 660 p 76 308 126 power city .s IS 640 14!IAD 105 48 M 79 not evidence 176AD 323 324 1 52 usury slS 30 M 680 366 676 619 superior claim 90 428 costs 22 NC 342n reimbursement 30 NC 2(30n 229 pers injury sis 633 f 18 M 412 22 M 553 insuf complaimt 25 NC 261n 233 conversion 1 57 execution i 1 S 599 - 3 21 NC 362il9AD 427 142 NY 303 -„o ^ 31 NC 362 238 show cause read together 's 1 S 450 IS » 111 NY pleading 119 AD 158 AD 134 1 AC 30 NC 1 63 stay sis d29M onstruction !00 NY 66 119d 406n 241 judgment s2S 46 s 20 NC 15 justice do 221NY 710 166 damages L._ . , 3lS 613(245 judgment r 117 NY 118'slS 623 272 estoppel sis 895 87 206 274 beneficiary B 1 S 902 8 AC 437n 276 legis. power s 1 S 896 17 AD 174 jurisdiction e 32 AD 146 23 M 51 278 jurisdiction sis 808 3 22 NC 28 113NY 133 d 86 202 22 NC 28 286 joint action sis 787 a 121 NY 683 e 41 AD 197 14 AC 44n 29 CP 311 290 set-oQ sis a 121 NY 292 tru««. sis e53 62 p54 AD e64 AD 89 AD 2 AC 23 NC 5SS 25 NC 266 199n I 89 security costs lis 22 AD do 56 AD c59 AD 98 AD 6 AC 2'jCP excuse delay 54M coats waiver 38 CP 487 171 damnges' s 2 S 195 r 121 NY 45 r 112 NY 573 249 adjudicatit#o 3 1 S 880 132 NY 458 trust 110 AD 306 254 doubt title s 2 S 60 82 214 259 appeal sis 651 a 117 NY 651 cqmpetent ev. 59 AD 524 282 taxation 2S 86 a 123 NY 76 1 89 vesting title 51 575 slS 854, authority 55 437;116AD 33 70 4771 12LRA 8191264 adultery assignment a 2 S 77 117AD 324 11 AC 204n I95receiverduty sis 919 4 SS 379 a 125 NY 693 209 anul. report 1 S 614 685 a 113 NY 623 e 118 NY 376 d 3 SS 355 146 US 688 2 I 5 arrest SlS 685 s 21 NO 321 tU-'. NY 67 285 redemption sis 900 81 261 f 68 AD 106 11 AC 148n 149n 328 38U 416 310n 127 NY 147 NY 184 NY dower 15 AC mtgee. possn 16AC 431n440n 269 contrib neg. « 1 S 907 4e 4S AD 39 270 will IS r 121 NY 913 432 748 107 788 259 201 104 107 6H 373 345n 60 294 highway prescription s 2 S 426 m 121 NY 420 42 AD 313 22 M 378 awards d 181 NY 368 299 eviction s IS 25 M 38 M d 54 M o8 'H 2 AC 11 AC 15 AC 27 NC 905 598 124 600 635 339n 144 467n 340 30 1 decree appeal sis 904 a 124 NY 640 305 review 2 S 144 26 NC 490n 308 county debt 2S 142 r 121 NY 345 SISpass by will 174 AD 156 322 claim notice s2S 57 16 M 18 M ISM 25 M 14 AC 20 CP J 35 NY 137 28do 32 304 306 258 428 208 125 370 compet. evidence 14 AC 307n 224 NC 278 333 indictment s 2 S 135 r 115 NY 185 336 life ins. ev. s2S 79 35 AD 356 14 AC 196 346 tenancy s 2 S 121 1 M '242 e 35 M 46 349 description s2S 113 a 112 NY 670 134 NY 43i> represen. capcty 142 AD 363 title vested 142 AD 364 35 1 sp prfmance s2S 113 70 AD 101 94 602 307 43 327 352 injunction 28 a 132 NY e67 471 e25AD 76 AD 254 255 104 AD . 85 insuf. compla'm 52 NC 20lD neg nuisance 117AD 591 ISSAD 213 85 M y 19AC 898 reasonable care 189NY 49 356 reference s2 S 127 r 117 NY 168 36 -warranty 1 S 159 3S M 460 364 tort s2S 61 11 AC S3S 66 new trial 70 77 SAD 12 AD 13 AD 17 AD 24 AD 29 AD 37 AD 169 AD J 51 AD 185AD 10 M 15 M. 42 M 2 AO 3 AC 5 AO 120 NY 16 LBA 37 OP practice 115 AD reserve 129 AD 152 165 233n 365 certiorari 8 2 S 148 3 110 NY 509 m 112 NY 597 370fr'd prefrnce s 3 S 589 a 22 NC 33911 373 prox cause 9 3 S 584 2 AC 405n £ 171 AD 485 377 negligence 3 3 S 585 3 55 512 e 2 SS 602 386 illegal ev. s 3 S 578 58 48 slander 86 AD 82 incompetent ev. 13 AC 311n316 390 excuse juror s3S 88- right of way 32 AD challenges 61 M waiver 132AD verd. not void do 142 AD 282 580 297 577 594 396adjournment s 3 S 578 16 AD 465 jurisdiction 157 AD 850 4SS 53 123 NY 74 duty to try 69 M 543 400 injunction 676 177 474 602 455 176 501 87 266 406 92 76 58 762 50 728 225 336 105u 235n 116 6 828 203 41 H 665 14 AC 157 not barred 103J1 220 450 competency s 3 S 478 s 1 SS 274 456 prox. cause 8 3 8 483 2 AC 405n 486 conclusive 8 2 S 253 a 117 NY 207 63 192 220 e 5i> 114 405deed delivery s 3 S 567 119 NY' 503 414 adverse pousessiOD 3 S 672 96 AD 137 1 AO 291n 21 CP 271 279 4 I 6 suspn's alienation s 3 S 570 a 123 NY 16 79 »10 92 156 aav. puBsess e 116 NY 37 Uo aD 137 15 AC 223n 422 law question s4S 119 a 112 NY 356 58 IDS, 4AD 454 12 AD m 37 AD 60B 3SS 422 3 AC 155n 425 mandamus 83S 560 54 20 e64 413 17 M 678 I18M 394 44 M 476 432burden proof 9 3 S 564 56 10 65 ■ 422 6 AD 397 do 120 AD 88 439 St limitat'n " 3 S 557 64 397 11 M 231 25 M 280 153 N"i 321 445 injunction s 3 S 480 la 124 NV 668 471 construct 'n 82S 264 f 18M 632 99 AD 21 473 custody child s2S 263 8 25NC 43 a 121 NY 679 a3SA 11 474 appearance s2S 265 27 M 331 59 M 606 B7 M 591 70 M 41 98 M 381 162 S 1077 1698 1040 not equivalent 65M 504 478 jurisdiction 32S 555 68 246 63 369 reviewed Supreme Court 07M 04 IAD 265 certiorari 217 NY 76 d 217 NY 77 483 wife's claim ? 2 S 540 123 NY 537 127 NY 360 distinction 6611 649 489 estoppel 2 S 525 a 22 NC 152n 498 equitable assignment fiS 544 79 AD 276 4 AC 325n parties 29 NC 35Sn 507 uncertainty 8 2 S 506 e 54 466 80 63 SONY 599 fr'd preference 22 NC 331n 5 I considcrat'n 3 2 S 535 89 54.-. 135 .\'Y 44 29 NO 314 5 1 3 contract 2 S 3.59 a 119 NY 204 524 title lands 2 S 546 a 126 NY 122 162 I1S 2S3 A13BKEVI.\T10.\S: a c. «riticised ; 1, limited; , arlirnied; d, distinguished; f. fullowed; e, explained ; o. oi'er. iled ; 8, same ^...ciiuii^ m, modified; *, dismissed; ii, uyiu upiniuil ; p. parallel l.i>- , tj, guc^nxn. ii Vols. 49, 50 N Y. Supreme Court Reports — Hun 535 damages a 2 S 1)12 11 AD 336 83 AD 601 72 AD 163 36 M 124 29 2 demurrer 113 AD 92 126 S 208 iTTegularity 142 AD 77 clerical error 142 AD 78 539 compensat'n B 2 S ' 478 118NY 624 550 city purpose 82S eS AD do 8 AD 162 NY 158 NY d22NC 37LRA 40 LRA 447 237 270 264 234 98n 791 169 legrislative powr. 204NY 481 ' public ways 77M 378 558 indictment b2S 421 a 112 NY 667 24 AD 35 M 593 separate counts 70 M 203 560 elect remedy s 2 S 348 a 121 NY 161 72 430 d 22 NC 271 23 NC 161n conversion ev 16 M 356 general denial 143 AD 870 57 1 judges powr s2S 315 e 7 AD 530 Bup. proceeding 599 assessment s2S 42! 56 118 109 AD eS2 29 NC , 35Sd 602 ejectmeot case 2 r 112 NY 364 605 easement case 11 s2S 69 « 70 AD 422 book entries sis 718 case 34 a 119 NY 620 2 tJA 601 limitations 161 AD 712 131 604 479 606 payment sis case 15 iU9 NV a2SA case 16 payment 3 1 S 74] 2 SA 479 48S case 17 libelous sis a 119 NY 47S 604 607 dsTise case 12 sis a 21 NC a 117 NY case 31 taxation a 112 NY case 35 title relief r 112 NY lis NY e37 garnishee IS e 67 AD 914 404 304 see 416 693 852 78 23 AD 52 AD do 91 AD 25 CP 1 AC 52M title 38 CP 347 602 271 55 ISSn 533 363 576 atty excep tion s 2 S 463 66 4 SB 29 M 31 M Indian law do d 121 AD 328 583lcloud ontitle 49 116 432 11 s 3S a 121 NY 13AD assessments 57 AD d61 AD tax nun resident e 73 AD 69 compliance 141AD 604. 6C9 594 affidavits b2S dS4 57 79 26 AD 17 CP review 16AC 381 80 307 2fi 298 370 2S7n 608 atty's lien case 12 sis 8S s2SA ♦113 NY ease 16 damages a 112 NY case 32 foraclousre a 112 NY 168 630 668 VOL. 50. 1 conversion a 2 S 369 2 AC 289n trust 49 M 586 statute runs 49 M 587 1 5 jurisdiction s 2 S 443 a 119 607 39 M 516 executor liable 19A0 lain accounted 214 NY 433 22 jury question b2S a 121 NY 13 AD 10 M 19 M 30 M evidence 14 AC 470 661 298 194 142 116 301n 609 services saae 2 si S m 121 NY rSSA case S public use » 112 NY case 11 probate i2S i 119 NY 851 I annuity 33S 9 65 e 61 AD J]3U^ ciaim notice e 107 AD 183 NY 12 AC 15 AC 191 342 318a 322D 586 vest legacy 686 288 118 234 81 30 NC 489 injunction 422 new matter b3S 310 9 M 356 1 AC 47n 425 eompet wit- ness s3S 317 r 117 NY 500 428 grading st 8 3S 144 56 £73 judicial notice 65 27e ' 3 SA 398 43 I injunction s3S 149 e 23 M 17 435 county liab. 8 3 S 221 a 115 NY 650 438 redemption s3S 38 S8 7 AD 80 CP 2M 85 M 25 M 38 M 31 M f 96 M 48 CP 21 NC 135 AD 446 570 165 123 24 479 174 748 588 damagea 3 3 a 497 70 26 67 AD 412 413 counterc aim 672 432 655 »B4 236 239n s3S a 130 NY 441 costs s3F SAC 324 11 297 52o 443resid. legatee a 3 S 309 39 AD 402 bond & mtge, f 68 AD 276 relief 72 AD 613 not barred 141 AD 908 446 partnership s 3 S 332 m 113 NY 482 448market value 336 168 527 -s3S 62 69 liability lOSM 220 45 1 Stat, frauds B 3 S 162 r 3 SS 590 12M 253 454st limitatn. e3 S 367 a 117 NY 159 2 AC 427 not enforced 184AD 119 lOOM 420 20 M p331I rs.M 133 S 137AD SAC 9 AC 246n a 248 £95!el0AC 362 363 18 69 I clubs liquo r tax law 93S t lis NY 28 AD e 149 N Y certificate do 100 AD uonversion 140 AD jurisdiction 95 M nSln 330 226 497 measure o5 quantity 3S 452 74 17 retardation icnl «i „ f 179AD 841 60 • P?™1 e^- VOL 51. 392 6162 519 coexecu«or 9 3 S 605 62 21 declarations 167 NY 178 9 uses and trusts s 3 S 608 e 83 364 parol evidence 84 484 119AD55.do559 89 survival 113 • 57AD 97 strike out alio NY 74 76 4 AD 29 AD 35 AD 71 AD 2M ellM el5M 24 M iiNC 453 293 e 134 NY 23LRA 1 57refltrain trade 1 2 devise 10 M 11 M 688 26 312 508 427 130 10 323 581 1 9 allegatioQB s3B 11 AD 44 M surplusage 72 M. indictment' lOlM 612 410 643 92 634 651 627 314 87 5 1 3 taxation s 3 S 462 a 130 NY 699 5 1 6 rescission 5 3 S 465. 88 248 14 AC 297n 523 surrogate ..3S 460 17 AC 528 pers 93S e22 AD 5 AC 7 AC 406n injury 711 243 30 57 n 534 title vesting s 3 S 730 37 M 214 statute frauds do 151AD 380 538 costs s3S e78 128 NY 31 CP 542 718 594 177 290 conversion 728 627 3 S a 123 NY 559 replevin 33 24 M if^R lienors 186AD 726 656 337 574 Bt. limit ns. 27 NO so s 3 S 593 477 husb.& wife 8 3 S 441 8 AD 49 578 foreclosure eertif. deposit s3S 684 39A"D 102 r 119 NY 324 103 AD 151 d49M 192 581 defect walk gift inter vivos IsBB 596 20 s2S 89 AD 14 AC 602 appeal case 5 s3S * 167 NY 74 AD case 26 appeal a2SA a 119 NY demurrer 117AD 603 reference case 9 s2S S22NC 592 480 316 476 595 538 557 664 326 796 299 30 demand sas 88 a7 AC 143n 148n 34 modify judgt. 33S 3AD 16 AD d55AD 4 AC costs 54 M f 106M 45 33S 84 51 AD lex loci 36 M 49 M 26 NC 604 "probable' case 8 3 8 67 e 68 AD 5i 605 executors case 10 s 3 8 308 s 23NC 78 606 review case 25 s3S 9 12NC 298 315 497 64 470 10 230 224 303 457 66U 350 574 424 627 405 543 178 179 623 404 168 301 177n 183n 48 e35AD 36M 127 NY 143 NY 13LRA 24LRA 28 CP 253 259 issuable averm't 8 AD 28 71 AD 543 presumptn knowl 23 CP 58 pleading 5bM 470 1 1 verdict s 6 S 288 e 27 AD 616 35 AD . 637 jury retire 1 AC a intimidate jury 10 NC 89n 94n e 156 NY 278 28 CP 299 presence judge 15 AC 448n p 100 AD 358 e 182 NY488 489 I I 4 paper town liable a 5 S 407 122 NY 246 personal service 6M 112 paupers 17 AC 16n S4S 53 d81 82 a 125 NY 2M 36 M 1 7 i evidence B 4 S 672 33 AD 102 4 SS 600 15 M receiver powr g 5 g ! 1 9 amendment 764 190 217 189 25 317 53 contempt 63 65 67 10 M damages 79 AD 40 M 1 AC a3S a 125 NY d66 11 AD do 91 AD lUAO 768 746 558 472 271 167n (right of action 19AC 167n discovery 179 NY 284 185 NY 65 58 comrs, h'way, 93 8 516 9 22 NC 387 63 agency 3 8 771 45 AD 192 7NC 113 notice sufficient 7 NC 107n notice applictn 2 LRA 795n 71 atty'B lien 3 8 380 e 86 592 514 2 NC 192n 74 frd. convey 1 9 5S 410 m 113 NY 485 5 NC 197n 459 402 60 603 126 253 471 48n 1 26 liabil limit'n 9 4 8' 666 3 AD 23 64 3 AC 124 130 1 32 Stat, frauds 348 67 AD 50 AD 87 AD 31 M 7 AC 14 AC 116 NY validation 61. HA contract 59 M distinction 59M when begin 105M 582 660 474 594 681 419 251 387 68 98 626 void 188 189 138 insanity s 4 8 664 * 115 NT 652 set aside 84 M 630 new trial 84 jy: 632 1 47 reformation s 4 8 665 92 117 e 83 AD 10 154 64 861 414 700 485 434 659 82 84 2 AC 3 AC 3 AC 5 AC 31NC 26 CP I64sp- prfmane* 669 593 105 108 224 140 252 eon 202n 203 206n 38 383 202 28-fl pers. knowledge 35M 12 account stated 146AD 726 208 appealabi 3 4 8 408 70 110 5 AD 596 delay citation 32 M 420 St. limitations 1 AC 220n junsdiction 114AD 755 fubstantl. right 1 33 AD 324 1 75 mortgage acknowledgmt 9 5 8 172 r 123 NY 211 2 NC 241u 26 NC . 454 record notice do 100 AD 317 9 lb AC 447 ! 84 fact question 4 8 936 59 238 11 M 13 I 88 safe place 9 4 S 940 71 686 duty inspection 56 AD 274 assume risk II M 6 care test £ 165 AD 893 i94 statute limitations ■934 437 186 109 258n 38 7|2I3 restitution 9 4 8 36 P 64 305 law domicile S8 no „ ^^ 162 3 AC 182n 183n 127 NY 83 12 LRA , 405 948 67 AD 76 AD 109 AD 9NC 12 NC renew claim 17 AC 264 I 99 lis pendens 938 880 f 72 AD 633 201 no jurisdiO' tion s 48 701 135AD lu accounting 138AD 792 796 construction 138 AD 793 204 affidavits s4S 76 SAD e9 AD do 9 AD 30 AD do 30 AD 38 AD 76 AD 87 AD 2M 17 M el8M 24 M 26 M 29 M 31 M 32 M 23 M 63 M 215 jugdt vs one s 4 S 492 1 67 339 tort, action e 182 NY 505 220as8ignee actn 4 8 37 23 NC 3n 224 interested witness s 4 8 406 g®o„ 586 2 8S 441 competent 204NY 230 227 copartners liable 8 4 S 202 124 NY 113 14 M 483 cause action 116 AD 721 counter claim 38 CP 216 oringin party 157 AD 293 232 new trial 3 129 NY s4S 4 AD 4M 21 M 30 M 35 M 28 NC 29 NC 638 280 333 511 154 488 783 21 6 581 590 396 397 76 70 85 104 243 737 89 084 71 109 11 466 722 31 244 receiver s4S 681 s 20 NC 443 56 14 130 662 324 358 _„ 221 83 39 M 21CP143 361 363 248 action pend- ing s4 8 137 3 AC 230n committee liable 13 AC 366n Supreme Court loS AD 753 incompetency 224NY 358 280 contlngencv 3 4 8 243 e 56 124 67 280 ABBREVIATIONS: : c. criiicised; I, limited; ,, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followea; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dism='sed- n note ■ e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, difsl nting opinion; p, parallel case; q. questionej Vols. 51, 52 N. 7. Supreme Court Reports — Hun 288 bill partic. B 4 S 167 2 SS 690 29 1 title land 355 taxation s4S eOAU 13 M boundaries 10 AD 56 AD 17 CP. good title 124AD 328 72 208 141 32 180 850 298 cashier agnt a 4 S 165 91 AD 99 18 CP 284 legis. power 132AD 417 service on Corp. 182AD 419 jurisdiction f 159 AD 421 fallow strictly f 174 AD 486 302 fixtures s a S 869 a 125 NY 1 82 225 3 1 mecliaQ.lien s 3 S 892 a 126 NY 361 do 72 AD 82 AD lOOAD 8M el4U 34 M 41 M 115 NY 142 NY 150 NY 163 NY 42M 46 M 24NC 360 appeal s4S 97 AD intervention 43 M 364 libel s4S a 121 NY 375 discovery 3 1 6 comp. ev. 84S 227 65 347 73 882 12 AD 183 s4S 61 accounts 54 M 632 no reference f 96 M 560 3 1 Sdaamages s 4 S 61 65 347 26 NO 268 321 mortgase s4S ,772 a 124 NY 349 dl7CP 321 84S 50 AD 140 AD 15 M 25 CP 378 presumption a4S G6AD 143AD 37 M 92 M 9NC proof heirs do 117 AD 325 poor support a 4 S 368 lOS AD 131 329 lease tenant 8 4 S ■ 117 f 23 NC 362n 332 assignment s 4 S 698 r 117 NY 532 337 execution will 83S f68NY 37 M 41 M 48 M foreign 128 AD will 187 887 70S 7 46 202 340 res judicata case 2 s 4 S 691 a 113 NY 656 345 annulment e 4 S 330 3BS 463 351 contempt * 115 NY 661 8 3 S 855 19 M 308 4 NC SpSn forgn depositions 14 AC 236n cuoimunication do 120 AD 743 s3S a 112 NY e73 87 6 AD 7 AD 57 AD 433 677 98 197 408 161 104 107 213n 56 306-6n 247 do 72 AD 346 360 362 220 432 15 148 318 33 456 361 fie 338 92 IS 136b INC 28 NO 16AC privilege 117 AD Bpl. contract 120 AD 536 aside verdict 89 M 304 liability 185AD 715 438 attachment s 3 S 852 1 66 387 fraud, intent 66 605 70 16 42 M 17 446 gambling 948 26 13 M 307 408 319 674 453 replevin 948 r 115 NY e56 2 88 costs 8 NC 245n 462 master neg -245 683 534 413 195 b3S a 121 NY 69 d97 AD 59 493 287 456 480 405n 407 380 assessment 93S a 117 NY 63 66 49 AD 386 wUl s4S a 117 NY 889 623 274 16 285 422 266 397 party wall 84 8 39 e 6 M 351 353 covenants 59 M 261 privity estate d 172 AD 104 401 obstruction 8 4 8 334 a 127 NY • 224 71 291 injunction 38 M 39 407 atty's lien s 4 8 239 57 178 63 AD 410 6 NC 14n 19 CP 34 28 CP 121 423 substitution s4 8 63 * 116 NY . 666 9 AC 303n 312d review action e 112 AD 761 429 att'y testify 8 4 S 369 d 94 AD 162 admra liable 9M 231 limitation action 24 CP 29 NC 239 2))3 507 foreclosure a4B 65 127 NY 197NY 12LRA 130 293 41 814 5 1 I 'trusts 67 s48 m 126 NY 600 684 697 197 170 389 111 5 1 9 assume risk B 4 8 671 11 M 6 524 will intent 67 600 4 8 288 544 demurrer 8 3 8 906 115 NY 496 e 84 247 496 88 119 1 NC 267 550 contempt 882 681 377 394 468 reformation 116 NY 861 s 4 S 322 470 enforcemeni 4 8 143 AD 472 libel s4S r 123 NY 10 NC 10 NC 295 347 378 420 68n69n 70n 256 700 766 95 483 assignment b48 a 121 NY 40 LKA controlling f 212 NY lien ' prior 224NY 487 casts s4S 62 AD e 110 AD e34M demur, coats 15 AC 18AC 490 490n 489 highways a 4 S 266 e67 95 distinction 172 AD 119 495 ina. anawers 948 a 117 NY e7 AD 5 8S lOLRA 501 bridges 48 * 126 NY 270 310 581 686 386 282 88 505 atty's lien 8 4 8 680 e 65 453 4 SS 321 24 CP 239 28 CP 116 24 M 8 AC 90n 19 CP 441 444 247 476 666 196 218 948 a 113 NY •113 NY 63 17 M court power 126 AD 32 notice sufficient t 139 AD 677 562 usurious 4 8 73 143 AD 135 573 eq. relief s 169 US 269 B 4 8 405 a 123 NY 627 575 declaratioaa 848 a 123 NY d69 beneficiary 116 AD 578 bequest corp'n s4B • 125 NY 33 AD e68AD 22 M 28 11 583 abolish office s48 d53 e 13 AD d24AD 80 AD 585 vested rem'dr s4S r 117 NY 64 596 tax exemp tion a4S 93 7 AD 161 153 NY 339 598 obstruction a 3 S 904 dollSAD 789 prox. caiwe 18AU 446n liability i9A0 271n nuisance IQAO 275 600 uae track 8 3 8 901 d 38 AD 498 r.r. transfer 28 M 387 603 contrib. neg s 48 666 a 123 NY 666 80 278 76AD 329 IINC 426 master liable 96 AD 115 24 NC 199n 605 damages s4 8 662 a 123 NY 652 m 80 396 607 assume risk s48 a 124 N"X d59 39 AD 521 339 606 726 335 212 622 l42 403 565 l71 6 1 3 fraud intent s 4 8 297 64 78 indictment 20AC 58n 6 1 6 surviving partner a 4 S 823 a 134 NY 442 620 right arrest 413 433 504 587 neglig. liable a 4 8 382 44 M 262 589 assessment B 4 8 666 r 123 NY 31 59 I highway neg s 4 8 626 a 121 NY 697 30 NC 314n 60 277 649 422 381 645 229 648 643 vol. paymt. 2d dept. case 21 3 4 8 350 a 121 NY 685 a 3 SA 43 96 M 40 644 parties case 1 8 4 8 430 432 848 dl6M use street 121 AD authority 18 IAD lOlM 112 636 801 381 485- 629 expulsion member 848 21 NC a 123 NY privilege 67 M 401 459 609 248 633 void tax b4S . 868' a 121 NY 703 10 AD 583 5 NC 206n 139 NY 136 constitutional 91 M 271 636 discovery 6tbdept. case 4 s38 7 s 19 NC 4 waste case 14 948 9 dl4M 2 case 9 a4S d38M transfer mortgage case 26 b4S e49AD partnership case 30 s4S 73 AD double liability do 137AD 803 640 conversion case 2 s 4 3 133 a 113 NY 272 64 1 Source in- formation case 6 848 21 M discovery 121 AD VOL. 52 I bondB pledgee b4S a 119 NY 6 legatees s48 a 127 NY d6S8 discretion 182AD 734 263 737 668 461 43 229 446 879 642 attachment 3d Dept. case 30 s5S a 116 NY 2SA 951 666 405 9 master's duty 8 4 S 774 61 132 67 ■ 490 e69 377 sis 510 V 1 7 actual facts 8 4 S 784 57 620 note proof 60 281 comparison 90 381 competent ev. 67 AD 328 1 AC 162n 10 AC 266n consideration 49 M 367 23 release 8 48 761 a 119 NY 28 1 76 130 party aggrieved 11 AD 361 . surrogate power e 80 AD 81 39 M 479 injunction 171 AD 73 AD s22 NC ejectment case 13 4S r 128 NY a 130 NY 3 8A 33 43B 393 681 88 SOS 481 30 review s4S 62 pool playing 69LKA 757 238 118 33 exceptions 8 4 8 787 20 AD 159 instructions do 150 NY 310 improper rmks. " 216 NY 569 220 NY 405 18AC 76n, 7Sn no prejudice '47AD 35 39 acctg balance 638 highways cases 8 4 8 938 r 147 NY 657 594 damages s 4 B 626 r 12S NY 715|639 appropriate r 3SA 3161 street 776 474 166 266 64.S 1025 a4S 56 109 AD 54 M action lies d 75M disss cond. precedt. 84 M 36 must account 188AD 460 43 ordinary care 9 4 S 790 a, 117 NY 644 46 declarations = 48 768 e 87 556 cross exam, rule 1 M 284 2M 327 9M 163 52 dam, remedy s 4 S 763 a 126 NY 353 55 signals neg. s 4 B 79^ r 124 NY 519 iBBUEVlATIONS: a c, criticised ; 1, limited : affirmed; d, e, explained ; distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, disinissed; n, note, o, overruled ; s, same case ; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, questioned N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Hun 7oI. 52 60 exr. allow'nce • 4 S 754 1 AC Sin 63 pleading B 5S f SQM 68 affidavit 9&S 57 discovery 6 AD 80 AD 37 M 4SS 34 M 16 AC 63 152 211 117 463 166 865 366 224 Win 5 evasion S4S 86 discovery 6 AD 49 AD 67 AD 2 AC 129n 133 disclosure lOlM 445 1 23 discovery 75 damages 3 53 101 r 125 NY 155 r 3 SA 276 80 debtor cred'r a 5 S 109 a 123 -NY 664 85bill particulars 119 550 575 452 227 156 sSS 27 AD «AD do 74 AD 121 AD 137 AD 23 M 39 M 40 M 50 M I AC 6 AC II AC 140 AD s5S 56 AD 188 AD f 2M 7M e44M 88 pwr. surrog. s 4S 859 156 AD b67 93 assessment s5S r 115 NY 95 affidavit 85S d64 law question £75 interpleader el9 AD 40 AD 2 AC 100 costs a5S r 117 NY 64 7 AC reference 8M 87 178 65 426 46 610 500 229n 105 411 94 153n 469 1 02 domicile a 171 NY 638 s 5 S 90 90 237 jurisdiction 60 AD 603 e62AD 444 445 62 AD e 10 AC dower e 173 NY estoppel 38 AI divorcfi 125 AD 17 TAD 451 156 507 202 916 165 109 negligence s 4 S 841 68 AD 362 i 1 1 legal ev, s 4 S 848 57 103 d 78 170 measure damage 29 AD 389 32 AD 511 63 AD 426 4 SS 501 5 AC 347 reversable error 45 M S80 14 AC 301n 795 45 171 407 69 161 aeeountiog 3 5 S 131 a 132 NY 264 164 reference S3M 179 1 66 injunction sSS r 123 NY r25NC 118 122 6^68 354 876 937 40 240 563 473 184n 313 266 534 136 125 statutory s 5 S 121 154 AD 387 1 27body execu'n 1 74 bar s6S no injunction e 10 AD 332 service papers 66 AD 447 carried on tog'thr 14 AD 322 153 NY 207 notice 128 AD 2UU 1 8 1 conclusive s 5 S 150 16 AD 469 61 AD 419 1 84 notice lien s5S 86 AD 104 AD 109 AD 23 M 27 M e45 M 4 AC 6 AC 88 286 24 757 725 123 213 314n 236 412 s5S e87 AD 154AD 1 162 AD 13 AC318n319n 13 AC 321 arrest 16AC 7n 10 costs otherwise lOOM 178, 180 130 forefeiture s4S r 123 NY a 147 US do 147 US 797 109 187 189 133 no rescissn s 5 S 133 67 M 186 1 39 service deft 8 4 855 7 AD 471 1 42 pers action 4 S a 115 NY e 57 AD 146counsel s 4 S a 123 NY 48 AD surety costs 69 AD e35M no recovery 72 M not liable £ 160 AD 1 5 f employee S5S e73 I 17 AD 1 27 M 7 construction 91 3 AC 4 AC 903 450 603 fees 140 335 315 6 250 154 husb. & wife 8 4 S 856 59 AD 211 168 AD 216 1 58 legal title s 5 S 126 a 130 NY 117 124 91 410 appeal 60 542 legal evidence 92 258 prox cause SAD ■ 133 51 AD 610 presumpt'n facts 43 AD 489 SS 585 cause of action 17 M 638 law action 117 NY 319 260 ins. policy s 5 S 230 a 132 NY 539 267 charge court sSS a 125 NY 87 AD 14AC 269 foreclosure 219 217 544 154 245 54 ■ 5S a 127 iVY a2SA estoppel 167 AD tender do 167 AD 773 161 557 405 526 508 193 19 1 lien 80 S 69 a 115 NY 205NY assignments 85 104AD implied warranty 133 AD 216 mechanics lien 67M 294 200 bequest a 5 S 164 30 NC 238n presumption S2M 79 identity £ 165 AD 278 206 intention ev s5S b55 96 AD 122 NY 14 AC 158 132 116 116 27Un 2 i 7 law question s4S d54 222 dower S4S 129 AD 922 43 920 558 225counterclaim s 6 S 353 r 130 NY 514 14 M 486 227 bill lading 6S a 127 NY waiver 112 AD 166 AD 140 438 618 717 240 power of sale 2 6 S 575 s 127 NY 426 249 recovery s 4 S 92: 158 AD 880 252 liability 164S 269 255 proof facts B 5 S 215 55 576 348 sum g5S 6 46 AD 353 damages s5S 86 132 NY 355 impl. sS S 187 NY 217 209 421 70 770 276 negligence s 5 S 285 74 199 284 exempldam . 5 S 272 e 164 NY 535 292 partition s S S 466 a 127 NY 562 303 conptructioo 35 S 249 47 M 42 307 demurrer s 5 S 236 59 128 charge on land 80 374 3 1 I consolidat'n 5S 355 a 115 NY 442 3 1 8 discretion 359 66 51377 558 664 197 2g9n s5S 70 92 40 AD 17 M 24 M 8 AC appeal 16AC 448n not in default 83 M 301 remedy 93 M 478 32 1 legal ev s5S 73 sSSS s24NC 486 348 382 549 144 328 annual rep't s 5 S 351 a 125 NY 25 a 3 SA 212 340 jurisdictiop s5S a 125 NY 48 AD aSSA 361 300 199 343 parol proof s 5 S 36: a 127 NY 135 d 13 AD -595 363 210 82 84 AD employment. 107 AD 248 429 203 power 317 407 359 legacy int S s 5 S 326 a 127 NY 402 62 282 363 damages s 5 S 345 r 123 NY 470 r 26 NC 194 31 NC 222n 366 alien woman s 5 S 3^4 57 392 370 oysters takg s 5 S 337 r 121 NY 313 373 prom note s 5 S 303 r 125 NY 710 r 3 SA 331 380 chge, grade s 5 S 240 39 AD 24 382 defense s 5 S 241 3 AC 217 383 dismissal sSS '473 1 AC 327n 385 stockholders s 5 S 306 43 M . 143 note prin. interst 184 NY 163 recovery 135AD 434certiorari s 5 B 581 a 117 NY 136 • 140 UB 694 446 mandamus a 5 B 600 a 119 NY 636 456 trust income s5B 79 37 M e 149 NY intention d28M distinction J.43AD 208 388 school tax s 5 S 280 a 125 NY 367 69 638 390 compensat'n s 5 S 281 U M 460 392 construe pol s 5 S 278 r 117 NY 451 398 conversion s 5 S 518 do 62 allegation rule 53 AD 347 405 allowance sSS 18 AD 7 AC 5l4 35 44d 587 201 456n 408 revie -v s5S 57 7 AC law questions 62 481 120NY 616 unpd. Bubscriptu e 181 NY 271 4 1 4 salary s5S r 115 NY 495 302 421 renewal sSS 593 461 559 363 SAC 30 NC 492 cond. preced 604 273 14 629 356 4»4 s6S 59 amendment e74 44 AD 61 AD 87 AD 126 AD 44 IM tender nee. 147AD conformity 79 M 659 458 reference e g B 507 a 117 NY 625 az , 35b paramount ordr. 79 M 519 erroneous 88 M ultra vires f 88 M 662 legisl. power 224NY 196 46 1 waiver stay s 5 S 512 76 AD 237 81 AD 149 e 84 AD 621 sell defense 81 M 419 464 age limit sSS 20 M stay costs - 7 AC stay waive 12 AC 468 construe will s6S 46 do 171 NY 287 288 473 parti defense s 5 S 718 74 123 brokerage f 84 M 452 ntire complaint 78 80 extra allowance 52 AD 454 commissions 67 AD f 93AD e 109 AD 130 AD 45 M 70M .5NC whole contract 71 M 421 503allegations s 5 S 682 e 4 SS 488 507 exemptions sSS 608 74 AD 660 3 1 exr. acctg. 712 220 276n 66 52 916 345 656 617 200 2]3n 478 stockholder s 5 S 927 e 5 SS 225 483 certiorari s 5 S 638 a 126 NY 621 486 possession s 5 S 865 53 44n res gestae ev. 55 126 evidence fraud 60 . 257 e 3 AD 300 27 AD 4 e 3 M 497 5AC 226 234n 250o 23 350 376 366 384 493 434 474 566 482 545 bSS 59 trust fund 190 NY 5 1 4 fraud s5S 41 M good title 18AC 634 247 106 676 35 133 n 520 partition 3 5 S 872 * 117 NY 621 524 damages s 5 S 668 e 55 347 do 55 368 22 AD 529 527 remedies 3 5 S 703 55 M 325 subp. d. tecum 139 AD 584 sup. pro. 137 AD 718 produce books 7J M 529 532 spl issues s 6 S 8'93 6 AC 266n 542 designation 8.6 S 10 28 M 707 555 performance a 5 S 623 r 125 NY 263 56 1 "due" s 5 S 629 a 117 NY 648 57 306 566 master neg, s 5 S 710 a 126 NY 667 e 64 374 scope employm't 4 AD 20 AD 34 AD 50 AD 95 AD U AD 93 AD 179 NY 113 AD aiithority do 160 AD 634 liability f 178AD 653 570 ins. policy e58 626 428 575 13 449 240 478 466 161 445 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d. distinguished; I. followed; r, reversed; m, modified- * dismi^sB,! ■ o, criticised; 1. limited; e. explained; o, overruled; s. saiuc case: do, dissenting opinion; p. parallel case; o.'Que'st"°'L Vols, 52, 53 N. 7. Supreme Court Reports — Hun a 125 NY 65 82 316 576 authority ■ 5S d 127NY 83 80 AD 12 M 596 damages b5S a 123 NY GDI deposit • 5S a 117 NY 529 617 91 5S4 905 657 713 515 782 361 29n 6 1 receiver title l8t Oept case 4 ■ 4S 69 AD Testrictions 19A0 26n, demand ehaoge venue case 12 bSS 97 e 68 AD 282 do 112 AD 127 116AD 497 commissionfl case 17 • 5S rll7Ifr r2SA service mail 112 AD case 31 178AD VOL. 53 I will decrees 3 6 S 676 126 NY 418 4 order arrest s 6 S 537 a 117 NY 623 46 AD 158 exemption e 29 M 250 duration impris't 7 AC 211 e 7 AO 214 7 AC 255n 20AC 200n no rearrest 112 644 456 127 513 798 6 1 1 arrest case 21 84 S s23NC bill particular ease 26 s4S 814 65 AD 30 6l2miBJoiDder ease 14 »5S 171 8 23 NO 187 no new trial lOPNS . 300 613 penalty ease 6 soS 64 AD ejectment case 33 b6S aSSA 2' 160 58 demand nee, • 6 S ' 940 74 AD 83 11 AC 190 produce collatrl. 137AD 170 AD relief 71 M 349 332 534 146AD 130 S 60 party 5S a 134 NY 56, 63 usury s 53 48 M 87 combination S 433 a 119 NY 9 23NC 8 24NG 7 demurrable 181AD 627 1 2 preemption 3 6 3 934 a 126 NY 307 1 5 redemption 9 6S 20 a 127 NY 241 2 1 undisol. prin B 5 S 576 70 AD 616 30 conclusive i5S 65 courts' duty e58 9 23NC compliance i09 NY 3 I dissolution 490 440 80 720 449 148 176 j6S r 135 NY 124 NY 12LRA. accounting I55AD 32 pleading 185 NY 36 assessment 3 68 48 r 125 NY 617 r26NC 325 39 jurisdiction 6l4moneyhad ease 3 b6S * 126 NY alleeations 3SA ease 16 s6S 63 AD neglipence case 38 s5S a 123 NY a3SA 309 703 273 209 316 645 184 358 76 31 NO affidavits 87 AD 31, NC 2 AC 6 1 5 assignment case 3 B 5S rUONY r2SA 602 627 523 941 35 636 606 10 alleKationB 16 AD 32 H justification U3 AD 65M 1 34 legaoy 86S r 119 NY 46 298 99 74 druggist neg. S3M 595 78 ejectment s 6 8 363 84 810 compens dam. 83 266 833 170 183 77 1 37 master neg. a6B 601 a 117 NY 646 instructed 175 AD 558 139 discbarge 6S 134 do 28 M 208 hiring at will 2 AC 390n392 do 169 AD 42 14ldiBcharge veteran 68 a 133 NY 24 AD SO AD 82 appeal b6S 28 AD [29 AD qS7 AD I 57 AD rei AD f IM 84 accrual s6S * 130 NY 55 disability 68 88 practice s6S a 119 NY el9M 112 623 628 244 621 612 424 67 635 113 359 483 687 Ktension 64M 87 888 368 202 202 62 40 discovery 5 S 889 25 NC 89 39CP 74ii 44 aaaignment 9 5 S 910 a 126 NY 624 60 257 legal evidence 80 61 ? 4 AD 145 withdraw'l funds 27 AD 4 5 AC 226 236d fact question 51 AD 600 50 binds defts. s 5 S 869 £ 94 M 144 52 ultra vires • 68 937 a 197 NY 9R2 9 1 gambl's debt 3 6S 362 a 119 NY 612 consideration 71 M 259 95 rule proceed 6 8 441 a 130 NY 313 67 AD 438 rOI inquiry s 6 S 78 r 130 NY 206 70 164 1 08 signatures 8 68 87 a 125 NY 711 d 135 NY 456 I 1 2 revocation 8 6 8' 69 r 117 NY 606 10 AC 438n I 1 9 jurisdiction 3 6 S 342 81 314 129 suppression deposition 9 6 3 172 10 AC 452n 1 30 em. domain 1 90 redemption • 6ti 718 a 127 NY 70 80 610 194 compen sation • 63 .716 a 119 NY 344 e81 210 97relevytaz 8 6 8 732 a 117 NY ■( 1 202 claim notice _ 6 B 842 a 127. NY 360 constitutional 112 AD 206 contract s68 a)27NY 128 203 666 l45ciistodychild s 6 S 132 7 AC 308n excessive dam. IS AC 199n 1 49 legal heirs s6S 161 66 301 1 52power sale 2 1 residuary s 6 8 777 36 AD 143 2 1 4 pera injury 844 40 27 B 168 7 54 348 380 • 68 a 132NY 69 do 71 AD 120 NT expectant estate t 167 AD 420 1 57 fees con- stable 6 68 163 a 119 NY 126 1 67 obstruction «6S 96 a 127 NY 696 1 69 lease tracks 8 6 8 108 d 38 AD 498 presumption 160 AD 601 171 law question J 68 99 a 127 NY 683 62 481 review facts 79 567 exceptions ev 91 326 120 NY 616 1 73 assignee 8 68 116 r 126 NY 256 91 71 29 NC 328n 1 8 1 judicial in- vestigation 9 6 8 120 36 AD 326 construction 83 AD 107 85 allege proof a 127 NY 92 notice 52 AD eSBS hSSS 82 54 576 s68 a 127 NY dll AD evidence 22 AD e33 AD intention 8M estoppel do 131 AD 12M SAC admission 76M 546 74 223 55 374 62 563 2 1 7 privileged 28 NC 66 220 benefit ins 6 8 602 r 127 NY 608 60 641 228 negligence s 6 S 381 148 AD 723 236 priority lien s 6 8 721 a 127 NY 620 239 jury quest'ii b68 a 119 NY 244 review a6B 66 73 power court 40 AD e 49 AD 24 M ' 39 M 42 M 23 CP new trial 138 AD b6B a 119 NY 1 32 rulings a 117 NY 77 79 172 141 634 608 B70 247miBtake fact 6 S 595 ( 165 AD 518 68 a 119 NY e64 pardon 1D4AD SOM f 94 M 99 M 38 459 589 192 262 667 398 337 396 568 390 278 175;p3SS 319 612 p 5 88 264 261 substitution 9 AC Sian 329 536 536 263 prac. loca- tion 6 8 613 8 AC 16Cn 267 negligence 6S 618 8M ^ ,437 servant deft, do 135 847 i 175 AD 469 274 indictment s6& 611 111 allegations e 86 136 e 24 M 642 names unknown e 8 AD 136 178 NY 524 one crime 147 AD 447 280 em. domain 750 20 AD 24 AD 39 AD 40 AD 69 AD do 62 AD 11 M 342 24 M award 27 M 36 M 67 M 169 NY 596 284 605 274 6B3 620 374 561 193 459 meas. damage 65M 255 usurpation 69 M owner L44AD profits 96 M set-off 219 NY 340 trademark s 6 8 38* 68 164 ILRANS 72ln 347 courts'powr s 6 S 388 58 . 182 examination e 90 345 e4SB 366 1 AC 18«n 11 M 520 extend time ans, 15 AC 362n 18AC 148n practice to stay 148AD 625 laches d 92 M 227 350 Pleading s 6 8 136 26 NC 129 352 assault s 6 8 220 55 216 359 bill partic s68 76 103 AD 14 AC affidavit 19 M d38M 20 CP 306 588 589 g7n 478 673 143 144 S2 735 560 408 305 demurrer a 6 S 488 7M 470 26 NC 3; 362 conclusive a 6 S 703 a 75 101 137 NY 242 reap superior 120 AD 130 367 guaranty s6 S 156 AD distinction 174 AD bond 226NY surety 226NY 20G 311 23 24 23 CP 358 372iury question 312 pleading s6S 411 16 M 335 3 1 6 damages 858 672 518 868 a 712 NY do 122 AD party wall 133AD liability 71 M liberal construe. 67M 253 408 138 368 a 127 NY £64 AD 195 AD p3S8 d3SS 10 M 21 M 145.NY reckless 112 AD distinction 18 IAD 321 charge s6S aal2M 641 516 320 669 619 84 276 324 714 618 516 436 888 38 I accessory s 6 8 806 19 M 303 388 pledge policy s 7 S 143 r 127 NY 452 s 23 NC 436 254 mandamus 324 dower par- 8 6 S 691 tition 25 M 460 9 6 8 146 2 AC 66 » 117 NY 520 392 conBent „„, "''« " '™"' „,„ 18 AD 312 B 6 8 469 833 73 M 24e28NC 124n'd65 494 650 Id 88 347 80 258 pass book 329 sewers neg. 44 AD 487 .„-s6S 586 s6S 463164 AD 418 48firll7NY 421 a 117 NY seilsiAD 44 45 332 28 M 253 d 5 SS 188 15 M 221 504 138 NY 238 19 20 260 new term 338 abatement e 148 NY 331 312g6S 617 s6S 195' . ABBREVIATIONS: a. t, eritieiied: 1, limited; affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note: ), explained; o, overruled: s. same case; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel os'^iq, questioned N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Hun Vols. 53, 54 271 400 380 368 sen 472 61 394 sncUliary admr res u 125 NY f 209 NY 70 law action 4 AC 160 NY eqaity suit 199 NY no autiiority 153AD 660 398 not apply 8 6 S 479 201 NY 132 414 charge s 6 S 3S2 d 47 AD 309 10 M 10 master liable 13 AG 64n 6Sn assault carrier 45 11 42i 4 1 7 real party ■ 6S 205 14 M 13 420iury question * 117 NY » 119 NY ell AD 45 1 confession judgment s 6 S 236 r 117 NY 432 4 AC 309 455 certiorari ' 140 388 130 607 236 185 >6S a 130 NY dS AD 33 AD 54 AD el3H 28 NC 425 charge 863 a 127 NY e41 AD prox. cause 201 NT 39S 658 363 639 43 107 49 229 64S 215 224 457 divorce s6tj r 127 NY a 160 UB S23NC 427 ejectment s 6 S 303 51 AD 277 62 AD 103 e 62 AD 144 145 73 AD 184 169 NY 388 430 cheeks 8 6 3 283 a 119 NY 636 433 trustee sale realty s 6 8 464 a 119 NY 609 437 proofs s 6 S 274 34 AD 209 construction 48 424 142 a 52 AD 57 AD do 71 AD amendment 129 AD permissible 158 AD 775 239 441 practice 8 6 S 273 85 182 decision referee 88 460 8 23 NC . 279 requests to find 27 NC 117AD findings 116 AD 212n 415 418 621 169 442 law remedy aS 491 32 M 73 acknowledgmt. lOSM 431 448 matrimonial actions s6S 447 624 519 200 s6S 23 NC lOM 29 NC 68 IAD 16 AD 42 AD 4 AC lost lien 137AD 463 town bonds eO& 301 70 9 place of trial 92 46 f 68 AD 483 judgt. occounting e 1U2 AD 425 partnership do 125 AD rescission 139 AD 130 130 472 services s6B 413 a 131 NY 589 e 14 AD 353 139 NY 389 verbal lease 30 NC 429 478 assessment _ 6 S 184 a 119 NY 24 480 special pro- ceeding s 6 S 401 26 NC 45n 482 taxation B 6 S 137 r 119 NY 286 490 uses & trusts '6B 649 s 134 NY 9? e 83 364 496 distinction s6S r AD reversal d 154AD no proof lOlM 499 allegations 198 538 160 s6S e66 66 62 66 C42AD do 132 NY 28 NC 22 CP 405 343 344 575 264 621 517 269 135 50 1 firm name s 6 S 393 s 23 NC 339 11 AC lOn 503 discovery 68 e4SS 7M 33 M legacies 16AC 246 365 6 576 l9Sn 51 I security 276 101 84 118 5 1 6 new sureties B6S 416 AD 12 6 AC 18 5 1 9 evidence s6S e86AD 53 1 lien 63 a 121 NY s23NC 860 444 706 393 241 534 assessment s6 8 a 119 NY 49 AD 151 NY 625 628 285 20 541 transfer tax s6S a 117 NY penalty 158 AD 467 660 79 545 attachment s6B 311 57 460 warrant 20 Ce 281 282 553 construction 6 6 400 e 64 397 copartnership e 16 AD 430 illegal evidence 38 AD 380 9 23 NC 397 556 adv possesn B 6 B 779 22 M 38 17 AC . 370n dedication 14 AC • 268 n map final 13 IAD acceptance IBIAD 160 AD revocation 72 M 575 compound interest B 6 S 236 124 NY 652 d56 180 580 assessment s 6 8 869 9M: .642 64M 276 compliance 72 M 650 587 neg. levy 6 8 888 79 148 11 AC " 220n 591 performance s 6 8 784 d5e 28 62 113 73 349 77 4 55 AD 319 SAC . 330 exceptions 2 M 140 142 contract 18 M 523 ouster 56 35 594 iudl. powe srS 775 28iNC . 73n jujssdiction 122 AD 597 costs s68 SAC 708 708 99 201 565 commis sion s 6 8 369 s 23 NC 208 568 indefinite s 6 S 281 93 M 675 57 1 jury question 224 702 220 602 197 11 4S 230 968 a 125 NY 3 AD 7AU 58AD e 61AD 79 AD 216 NT right of way lOAD e 16AD 22 AD a2AD 63AD do 77 AD 96AD 186AD 10 M 69LRA presumption 65 AD 70 AD rights St. cars 67 M . 158 due care 204NY 95 f 186AD 68 352 85 427 9 427 166 489 67 642 306 466 32 use eyes 186AD 104 462 797 245a I 1 costs 86 S a 127 NY 870 678 61 I Stat, limitns 6S 802 e 60 AD 422 117 AD 287 76M 486 76M 487 presumption 175 AD 373 161S 966 r 132 NY s57 8 2SA 293 590 645 633 assessment case 16 8 6 8 716 47 AD 362 364 634 power trust 2nd Dept case 21 s 6 8 201 38 M 492 635 forfeiture case 7 s6S 4 s 23 NC ii contract case 16 s6S a 125 NY a4BA, bill partic. case 23 b6S 69 AD 402 742 33 636 restoration case 1 s6B 59 AD abatement case 30 s68 » 117 NY B23NC Uhury case 33 368 a 127 NY 8 23NC not sustained 154AD 226 811 517 386 649 290 144 673 419 637 stipulation case 6 b68 913 32 M 488 atty's lien case 8 BBS 466 a 9 8 193 alSQNY 681 e63AD 410 411 Btat. limitns. case IS s 6 B 431 r 126 NY 203 6l5declarations 8 6B 475 8 6 8 94 M 916 174 6 1 7sharft holder 8 68 943 90 358 demurrable 92 25 ell AD 464 620 trust fund s7S 36 a 129NY 302 5 7 39 623<^°untere'bii s68 r 119NY 630 waiver 38 CP 63 1 liability case 39 s6S 73 M 632 appeal case 1 s6S a 119NY a 2SA resettlement 2nd Dept case 13 68 937 54 201 964 commissions case 35 8 6 8 262 a 125 NY 68 e 64 AD 436 638 right action case s 6 8 94C 66 AD 52C mandamus 21 CP partition case 21 s68 a 126 NY a4 8A no remedy 226NT 66 113 831 683 476 96 602 61 553 39Sn VOL. 54 5 removal s7S 69 discretion 92 31 AD 8 AC terms appeal 124AD 523 8 indictment s7S 89 24 M 546 ''way" "works' 151AD 436 1 4 coats concl'n. s7 8 90 66 290 f 26 AD 627 11 AC 373n 374n appeal 11 AC 378n 1 6 preference B 7 8 125 s7 364 63 AD 247 discretion 65 173 174 mandamus 19 AD 570 148 NY 125 retake 217 NT 569 22 confid, comun s7 8 85 96 AD 145 7 AC 361n 26 notice agency 6 7 3 119 a 130 NY 634 21 M 769 spl. contract 126 AD 635 44nuisance dam s7S r 12 6 NY 124 NY 168 614 324 66entirety 8 7 8 225 e 6 233 82 203 husband convey 24 NC 233d 27 NC 59d 70 limitation 7 8 f 96 M 96 M 72 tax sale s7S a 129 NY 177 586 587 187 247 74 mtg. estoppel s 7 S 236 r 130 NY ■ 637 e 19 AD 560 78 'communica- tions with jury 8 7 8 184 83 294 92 197 1 AC 6n 80 assesBment 233 27 9 878 24 M f8TM judgment f 162 AD 637 85 wjll construe 212 99 7 S 58 M 88 discontinue 7 8 217 AC 448n 93wiUgift s7S a 125 NY 1 02 frauds s7S r 129NY e55 preference 62 65 assignment e22AD 127 ND 284 606 211 1 lis 595 444 262 280 i 06 construction 8 7 S 283 r 125 NY 544 1 09 estoppel s 7 S 287 87 520 597 insurance waiver 22 AD 41 AD 58 AD 120 AD I 1 3 devise 87S e24M construction 566 136 605 461 266 5S 67 M 365 244 19 127 I 1 6 title 878 8 59 e86 cond. vendor P 91 372 64 AD 238 12 M 545 22 M 126 25 M 340 7 AC 188n 10 AC 209n 223n 10 AC 224 not realty f 159 AD 529 1 26 gift conting s7S 264 d 60 273 1 3 1 competent evidence s 7 8 289 a 126 NY 423 76 AD 448- entry judgment e 24 M 261 undue influence *7 M 559 may waive f 87 M 14 149 S 1056 declarations 87 il 498 1 43 contract a7S 355 a 125 NY 422 1 47 disqualified sJS 243 16AC 390n 149 license patent 878 277 27 AD 626 1 56 negligence » 7 3 426 * 126 NY 670 1 66 illegal ev. 878 S6S fl 651 68 687 86 403 13 AD 492 vest interest 24 CP 211a competency 142 AD 114 interested ...ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; t, foUowed; r, reversed; m, modified; *. dismissed- n n^tTT. onticised; 1. limited: e. explained: o. overruled: s. same case: do. dissentinK ooinioa: o. narallei o.„. . ' ?_'^''-> «• QUestimed. Vols. 54, 55 N. 7. Supreme Court Reports — Hun 143 AD 172 pers. s7S 75M C90 estate 300 590 1 79 interested witness s 7 S .368 60 AD 476 error rulings 17 M 92 . 1 83 competent evidence « 7 S 221 r 130 NY 654 I94r. r, grant «78 170 NY p5M 25 M presumption 124AD easement do 124AD 439 307 63 634 646 648 300 conclusive s 7 S S80 a 132 NY 154 26 M 48 305 restitution s 7 S 694 e 4 SS 415 29 NO 35911 308 affidayit s 7 S 568 57 discovery e88 117 309 examination 60 AD 462 75.AD 624 d 40 M 666 197 extra allow. 313 776 437 459 6 371 402 479 394 65n 264 522 s7S a 125 NY 27 AD 114 AD 123AD 5SS a3SA ' 38 M e 46M SAC 140 NY commissions t- 172 AD 16AC 404n 417 16 AC 425 fees admr. 122AD 446 19A0 121n . £tat. compnsatn 77 M 302 . 137 S 77f) '207 conclusive s 7 S 345 82 135 agreement d 12 M 253 jurisdiction e 20 M 238 23 1 trust devise s 7 S 382 a 130 NY 29 272 reoveier title 3 1 affidavit atty s 7 S 649 e 39 M 426 3 1 2 replevin 8 7 S 434 r 119 NY 414 3 1 8 alternative s 7 S 442 55 662 62 694 76 124 64 AD 413 sup proceedings 6 AC 194n a 6 AG 195 64M 118 detect affidavit 22 M 487 21 CP 238 execution d 31 AD 308 vacate attorney d 102M 162 judgmt. crdr. d 102M: 163 b7S r 124 NY SAD s21 NO 380 324 320 383 463 466 141 599 190 605 318n 276 autliority s7P el23 NY 67 e64 76 40 AD SAC 26 NO 116 12311 jurisdiction 98 M 101 279 crim. intent s 7 S 582 r 123 NY 264 60 115 292 indemnity B 7 8, 557 a 130 NY 637 175 AD 174 . liability 105M 365 294 false answer B 7 8 589 e 27 AD 490 175 NY 38 eompensation c 68 AD 40 i22NC ' 164 ■ 26 NC 1 s 18 CP 406 387 interrogatve 8 7a 116AD SOU 80 M 142 S pertinency 80 M 80 M 929 87 633 635 155 633 634 415 party con- dition »7S 16 AD 18 M U 4 AC (4 AC d 123 NY 322 trust will 37S .542 a 125 NY 751 a4SA 347 328 residence s7S 678 « 119 NY 661 65M 175 SGM 306 T3M 633 8,> M 681 96 M 6 4 1 9 mechan. lien 7B 771 r 130 NY 182 Jurisdiction 112 AD 751 435couaterclaim s7S e78 84 89 C26AD 332 robbery ev. s 7 8 665 a 123 NY 631 335 right arrest s 7 S 660 114 AD 872 10 AC 66n 66n false imprisonmt 16 AC • 202n probable cause 133AD 705 not liable 147AD 5B2 d 172 AD 733 presumption 147AD 562 not chargeable do 153AD 854 339 trustee ev. s 7 8 536 r 126 NY 113 349 dower »7S r 124 NY 474 689 354 dissolution 8 7 S 406 r 124 NY 682 69 388 competition 37 AD 394 husb. wife s7S 620 66 428 400 condemna- tion >7S 90 a 148 NY .445 314 651 234 314D 409 confess judgt. s7S a 130 NY 56 preference 69 127 NY 698 421 289 632 289 656 437 174 408 195n 197 641 493 mtge. valid B 7 S 939 r 136 NY 326 2 AC 242n 269n 500 residuary 613 20 245 372 204 438 reference 8 78 712 [ 3 AC 62 446jury question 7 S 719 721 769 43 548 168 276 164 97 s88 a 124 NY 59 vesting eSAD 29 AD 29 M , irested remder ILRANS 1005n construction 152AD 749 505 receivers a 126 NY 58 79 82 22 AD 41 AD 49 AD negligence SAD 406 45 Ipleading a 121 NY 664 p 19 M 687 454,neglig, dam. « 7 8 70S a 126 NY 727 40 AD 387 signal q, jury 13 AC 421n dl46 NY 407 46 I assignment 8 7 8 777 r 130 NY 686 eSO 69 469 easement at. s7 8 71© 66 623 86 432 62349 AD 446 168 NY 30 NC public use 19 M 666 public ways 77M 376 136 S 400 473 creditor suit s7 8 717 a 126NY 653 1 68 291 refusals exceptns 73 442 480 claim proof s8 8 31 a 121 NY 678 s 69 308 8 25 NC 78 485 remedies 8 8 48 90 AD 426 e 19 M 133 two penalties 148 M 79 490 defendant 888 47 73 263 arror ev.adultery 68 AD 116 39 M 339 11 AC 196n immaterial i96NY 876 136 379 not limited 156 AD 411 decree evidence ISOAD 318 pr Bumptn payt 40M 304 waive jury trial 2 AC 31n 6 AC 229 160 NY 470 fr'dlt transfer 166 NY 67 primary evidence 2 M 327 532 jurisdiction 4fi 664 316 41 205 716 s88 a 121NY SO d 33AD e33 AD 36 AD 29 M crdrs rights 37 M ndorsersubrogat 51 AD 304 517lawquestion 34 328 308 303 306 664 6 278 88 71 charge 79 libel e25AD 136 492 284 b88 80 540 pers s7 8 s88 AD 13 AD 33 AD e46AD 9 M 9 34M 40 M 7 AC 164 178 146 362 liable 781 516 116 194 118 366 133 634 200 59ne9 315 spi. contrat 26 AD 636 new trial I 134AD 983 personal claim 138 AD 131 552 cond will 888 119 e 47 AD 607 61AD 314 21M 268 condition void SOM 14 invalid SOM 16 6 1 9 husb. wife eSS deo 67 82 covenant 21 AD 142 NY 166 NY decisions ISM cotenants 73 M 16S 380 232 208 17B 87 344 602 450 556 obligatory s 7 8 907 87 11 30 NC 229 558 dedication s7S 88S r 134NY 397 e 67 560 567 inspectors s 8 8 264 a 119 NY 176 577 misjoinder ". ' 8 8 88 14 AC 49o 584 waive appeal 3 8 8 82 2 AC 173n retax costs 14 AC 25n 586 abduction s 7 S 909 130 NY 239 587 levy liab. 24 CP 598 tax corpn s7S J a 121 NY 666 604 construction 623 allegation b8S 92 e 70 519 5 AD 668 625 scope em- ploy, etc. s 8 8 107 78 626 52 AD 572 neg. 3rd party 40 M 213 prox. cause f 1C4 AD 106 633 asBessment case 8 s8 8 937 a 119 NY 667 s 119 NY 664 634 accounting 2 s 7 8 438 42 M. 16° vacate judgment case 3 s 7 8 281 e 93 AD 479 635 covenant repair caee 13 878 a 130 NY 49 AD master duty case 16 s7S 74 AD 523 corroborat'n s 7 8 927 8 , 697 fact question 77. 470 obiectns error 82 400 competent ev. e73 420 26 AD 401 38 AD 184 31 M 70 61 AD 304 67eAD 698 21 M 763 88 e9AD tax benefit 110 AD conclusive 66 AD 106 AD 24 M certiorari 101 AD 104 460 70 229 49 40 299 6 1 title act s8 8 123 88 667 e 75 AD 131 2 AC 203 6 1 4 private tribunal sSS 121 a 130 NY 232 2 AC VOL. 55 I order arrest ■ 88 588 67 ^ „j33* produce affidavit do 110 AD 809 7 privileged b8S d60 61 72 48 M admissible 213 NY 678 263 106 498 486 332 9 prox. oauae s 8 8 573 e 76 130 29 civ. dam. aet s 8 8 600 a 132 NY 386 35 bill partie. 38 bill partio, s8S : 62 AD 38 H 40 defect s88 47 M 45 farm ahares s8S a 128 NY 76 17 AD 306 281 296 637 will case 23 s 7 8 696 a 126 NY 766 a 4 SA 32S notice case 13 s 7 S 454 147 AD 307 74 M 177 204 NY 113, 122 132 S 911 132 S 921 638 appointm't case 24 s8S 67 preference 63 AD 148 NY 960 364 734 644 400 639 fraud case 6 s7S a 124 NY a3 8A jury question case 7 s8S 83 r 126 NY 737 r 4 SA 669 joinder remedies case 10 s8S 74 AD will 18 SSS e69 AD denial 286n!l71S 69 149 160 346 212 a8S 78 33 AD s24NC 6 AC 29 NC 276 604 666 246 223 224 413 132 673 27 283 380 216 211 47 parties con- dition s7S MB 90 AD 434 do 90 AD 438 jurisdiction 31 M 18 Indian law do d 121 AD 321 62 M 94 58 per capita 8 8 8 284 a 126 NY 636 66 607 e90 164 6 1 wife posses- sion sSS 279 37 233 liable debts lAC 166n 64 constitution'! 378 813 alio NY ffRR 6 89 AD 536 e 136 US 443 78 school tax sSS 393 d74 345 e76 427 do 100 AD 1.S3 collection c40M 447 185 NY 61 80 conclusion s 8 S 388 30 NC 32Sn 83 presumption 9 8 8 246 186 NY 499 custom law 64M 528 oSEspring 1.55 AD 785 ABMRKVIATIONS: a, aflirmcd; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; c. criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; a. same case; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q, 'questioned N. 7. Supreme Court Reports— Hun Vol. 55 91 taxpayer suit 3 8S 26S rlaONY 304 98 ins. disabled a 8 S 263 84 AD 533 103 ins. breach sSS 248 e 178 NY 540 9M 261 127 devise class 822 672 S2 I85cau8a morti? b7S a 125 NY b24 NC 1 9 I referee report a 7S 24M 38 M 30 M aSS 24M 27 M 138 corpa s8S r 123 NY election 173 AD 581 184 574 361 neg* 262 405 554 319 173 1 43 coU'r bond 8 8 S 503 m 127 NY 316 1 54 remedy eSS ; r 124 NY ( e6e I r4SA < 194 defect. maciiiQe s78 88 AD 96AD assumed ris^ 13 M 394 1 98 uncertainty a 8 S 161 e 86 466 113 AD 766 64M 503 condemnation 1 60 disability s8S 76 a lie NY 626 1 63 appraise damages B 7 S 863 50 AD 502 awards 52M 318 1 65 appraise damages b8S 86 AD 95 AD e 118 NY 120 NY 176 NY 167 transfer tax s 7 S 852 35 AD 131 127 NY 12 1 69 legis. power s7S 914 a 120 NY 637 5 AC 20Gd taxes interest 323 132 NY 171 usury s78 r 130 NY 173 tender 873 a 132 NY 75 02 AD 867 102 840 28!i 389 334 175 what may be sold s 8 S 74 37CP 7d 178 premiums 8 8 S 150 a 121 NY 337 180 breach con- tract a7S r 130 NY B28NC 2 AC misioinder 14 AC 724 500 478 315 43n 1 83 conatruct. will s ? 8 036 e 68 72 72e 337 112 305 ■ 78 a 121 NY 64 33 M„ aa AD conversion 170 NY 1 161 AD 161 AD limitations do 193 NY 844 677 300 130 4 265 766 768 116 a 121 NY 367 335 joint debtors 695 115 300 190 339 amendment s8S a 123 NY 988 a 123 NY do 88 AD S23NC legal conclusns. 166 AD 254 libel s7B 4 AG 7 AC reply 10 CP 68 832 220n 291n 767 257 legal keira IAD 14 M 45 M petition 1S7NY pleading 38 CP 141 192 192 303 125 b8S 66 beneficiary 10 M 230 206 204 trust Gorpn. s 7 S 836 ♦ 119 NY 660 207 defect title 8 7 8 868 84 AD 397 service infant 134 NY 573 personal service 13 TAD 209 absent infani 137AD 210 jurisdiction 137AD 211 no interest 105M 253 21 I damages s8 8 51 60 73 caie 49 M 528 defect liable e 6 AD 180 notice defect 261 set-ofi s8S 26 AD <*(>unti?Tclaim 136 AD 497 270 St. assessmt s8S m 126 NY 274 surety s8S 89 51 AD 75 AD 174 AD 21M prcsumptn pavt, 40 M 304 waive jury trial 2 AC 31n 186 AD 864 285 mandamus do 6 AD 184 5M 445 11 M 273 14 M 441 20 M 571 negligence 38 AD 487 113 AD 44H fSTM KIS insufficient ev. 49 M 62S liability -7M 1.5(1 f87M lOK repairs landlord 160 AD 269 2l4B8BauU s8S 241 6 AD 201 credibility 7M 628 SING 272 222 nuisance s7B 7RS SAD 432 20 M 56 contract 125 NY 651 248 admrx acctg. B 7 8 848 a 110 NY 622 a 2 8A 548 251 pleading 232 301 33 234 168 938 271 304 508 530 753 834 372 376 566 384 434 581 69n 339 SSS a 130 NY e74 S3M 51 AD 126 AD f 217 NY lAG limitation b173 NY equity liability a 355 67 AD 430 441 365 serv pubin 8 S 894 s 121 NY 604 87 287 36AD 80 do 131AD 764 neg. instrument 303 672 636 4 1 4 annual re- port s 8 8 444 r 130 NY 366 4 1 9 trade mark a 8 S 671 a 23 NC 275 422 contract em- ploy S8 8 623 e 21 AD 547 e 30 AD 621 6M 604 2 AG 343n 395 e 148 NY 255 433 bonds trust 728 463 463 175 AD estoppel do 222NY 457 gift s8S a 125 NY 70 AD 558 536 720 427 632 465 serv. publ'n B 8 8 717 130 NY 625 not apply do 154AD 931 467 amendment s 8 8 760 r 130 NY e77 B4AC levy 18 AD T7AD 19 M 6 AC residence in 119 AD recovei i 189 NY 458-9 dubat. serv. 50 M 15 compliance 59 M 17 jurisdiction 171 AD 39 CP 401 365 609 2.560 597 222 66d 220 552 s8S e 57 60 62 pl5AD 62 AD 2 AC age limit 20 U denial e 137 NY veteran prefer- ence 24 AD 566 38 M 434 take as true T.i M 246 296 ins policy sSS .411 a 125N Y 76« 14 AG 189n 303 hypoth. quesion s 8 S 525 57 125 121 NY 257 measure damage 375 will trust 8 8 627 3 130 NY 292 381 penalty 98 8 505 e 127 NY 292 90 .534 30 NC 248n 391 jurisdiction sSS 451 a 123NY 219 396 affidavits 98 8 87 AD 3 AC 4 AG 17 M SAD 84 AD 6 AC contract 241 US 208 359 ISOn 493 309 jury question s 88 433 58 08 3 1 2 trade mark 88 414 68 164 8 AC 64d 3 I 5 aqueduct GommiBsloner 8 8 439 396 424 602 120n 659 s88 62 HI AD gift 2 AC trustee 117AD evidence 114 AD lawful trust 62 M 216n 324 666 553proceBed 469 indictment |note b8 8 908is0 8 r 130 NY 455 e 58 02 472 legacy church s 8 S 806 r 121 NY 701 r 3 SA 55 438 court's duty s 8 8 676 a 121 NY 675 e 68 184 compliance 209 NY 60 440 considerat'n 548 333 s8S e85 eOAD c9AD 16 M 18 M suspension cl7 AD p5 88 16 M c4 AC extention do AD el6M oOJrl 445 certiorari 383 r 121 NY r3SA 620 85 203 88 243 736 ELllegations fraud 2 AG 68n 26 CP 28 398 execution s8S dSO damages e70 d 128 NY do 128 NY ownership 130 S 401 alimony 988 •119 NY 75 AD 109 AD 12 AC good faith 134 AD 707 367 388 471 479 376 448 519 566 504 15 421 406 irregularity r88 111 r 134 NY 170 r 28 NC 356 409 polire powrs 679 615 322 329 556 226 420 439 656 ,280 337 675 341 640 716 57 a 134 NY 115 unenforcible f 168 AD 299 53 1 cond.amendt s 9 S 129 a 125 NY 728 80 AD 49 defna, compt 126 AD 677 strike out 62 M 554 no estoppel 200 NY 92 540 insurance 10 8 44 67lirl30NY 537 379 title 81 474 servicee 98 8 758 g AG 196n 479 considerat'n s88 719 12 AC 260n 485 defective material 634 273 658 767 48 a8S » 132 NY 489 gifts s8S a 126 N If 8 AD resist payment 7 AG 149n 492 chge. grade 226 739 217 203 125 559 regularity ■ 98 20 e 34 AD 477 24 CP 130 10 M 202 561 alternative sOS 15 62 504 76 124 64 AD 413 defect warrent 6 AC 35n 42n affidavit 102 AD 13 AG 21 CP esii s8S s66 63 AD 142 NY by usage 160 AD 160 661 628 264 447 liable s88 46 AD right entry 55 M damages 18AC 482n, 483n 448 mandamus s 8 8 666 a 120 NY 646 no eviction 85 M - 405 450 partition b88 e74 64 AD S24NC 23 CP 73 M 94 M entirety d 71 M ji.int tenants 73 M 449 452 duty warn 88 a 130 NY el5M liability do 145 AD do 129 S instructed 660 417 126 219 283 430 530 54 717 658 156 897 1134 494 landlord tenant 9 08 016 a 132 NY 348 496 negligence s 8 8 664 22 AD 276 s 9 S 93. modified ;• dismissed :o^^^ c. criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case, q, question N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Hun 473 findioss' ■ 10 S 459 8fi M ISl action lies d 75M 848 477 town bondB a 10 S 14 a 123 NY 661 e 62 193 481 estoppel slOS eSOAD 61 AD 19 U 124 NY title timber 107 AD 201 367 e29AD 20 AD do 29 AD d3M gSOM SSM e2AC e6AC SAC 7 AC e 148 NY 22 NC 30 NG 21 CP 489 643 bill of sale 401 case 7 bOS 499 456 74 AD 706 165, 167 case 11 2911 27 28 42 M 353 3507 case 12 93, 98 60 38M 330 25 CP 67 m CP S78 bank bills 213 153 247 489 agency slOS 88 authority 92 87 AD 117 118 d 149AD 502 3M 364 29 M 647 not limited 171 AD 174 493 policy ins. slO S 205 a 134 NY 345 501 ev error s 10 S 561 60 106 2 AC 2S2n 127 NY 634 findings requests BIOS a 125 NY a 141 US 28 U 27 NC 82 368 373 174 ;!01 165 s 9 S 729 520 328 170 367 581 surplus slOS 79 pledgor expenses 80 AD 467 party in int. e 7 M 326 160 NY 218 590 will power S'lO 8 183 a 134 NY 220 e67 449 86 109 repreeentation 3M 196 607for'n receive 10 S 39 63AD contract case 10 SlOS a 134 NY a4SA 645 weight of eT cas6 208 8 AC 406n 610 damages illS 9M 11 M 29 M 31 NC uiail answer 38 CP 131 36 212 602 319 453d 507 confidential B 10 S 210 86 AD 162 2 AC 79n privilege 117 AD 247 authority 38 CP 94 waiver f 92 M 371 5 1 6 transfer shares s 9 S 866 r 134 NY 174 r2&NC 120 530 fr'd vendee 8 9 S 852 m 134 NY 520 537 franchise 8 9 3 833 r 121 NY 536 543 reservation. ?t,?sP'''»"''«.«, s9S 829," J" |p *61 • 132 NY 552 ' ^° ^° a 134 NY 11 68 481 6 1 7power of sale a lis 16 a 126 NY 81 826 indictment Bios 161 a 123 NY 660 61 331 mandamus 37 AD 46 AD S24NC 6M 133 NY 143 391 477 29 35 220 82 notice claim IAD 16 AC 548 53 361D 553 prejudicial s9S 11 AC requeets 27NC review 72 M 929 33n 210n 334 639 damages case 13 s9S 97 62 AD 606 undiscl. principal case 4 b8S 916 65 AD 546 640 amendment lease 10 'b8S llOM 912 120 560 partition ! 642 serv. corpn s 9 S 849 case 6 28 NO 128 89 S 96 r 121 NY 71 396 VOL.57. 1 growing crop absolute fee 102 s 10 S a 136 NY gs power trust 74 M limitations 161 AD 644 preference case 1 622 5 court's power 267 SlOS 60 AD 74M compromise 4 AC aiipulation 132S 420 176 AD 417 protect rights e 74M 527 963 492 2 712 700 248 646 698 682 BIOS 73 AD case 11 siOS 75 M 647 appeal case 12 s9S a 125 NY s3SA negligence case 13 Bios a 132 NY 64 AD det:larations case 45 s9S r 127 NY rSA 283 307 340 390 351 338 a 123 NY e24AD use highway 610 170 N Y 387 62 contempt s 10 S 270 146 9 construction s 10 S 264 d 23 M 233 30 NU 229 234n own property lOlM. S33 507 6 AD 320 528 67 safe appliance s 10 S 382 224n r4 A S 123 r 132 NY 705 72 deposits liab. a 10 S 278 21 M 244 liability 173 AD 483 1 2 assignment BIOS eSAD l4w'U SlOS a 141 NY 363 396 376 671 22 delay shipmt 10 a 132 NY 897 164 NY 738 sale wheat 887 do 181AD 368 647 192 649 interest case 1 SlOS a 126 NY a4SA case 5 89S d 116 AD divorce case 10 s9S MAD negligence case 24 89S r 126 NY r3SA jurisdiction case 7 ,r.p. 8 92 S 1!02 66 AD 666 666 417 840 481 25 notice s 10 S • 392 a 135 NY 366 12 AC 320n 183 NY 400 35 CP 2UU pers. injuries 98 AD 378 claim notice 123AD 293 lOVeuarantv ritiatea notice ' Vi B^^anty liV AD 449 858 694 848 596 33 employee a 10 a e 49 AD 150 salary 49 AD 212 t 66 AD 6 AD lAC BIOS 4f9j3%X^- 36 public health r 134 NY d 140 NY 414 22 Vols. 56, 57 307 574 I22allowanee " 10 S 802 61 836 164 NY 414 1 23 physician ev 8 10 S 826 60 498 e 87 686 1 26 landlord and tenant 349 471 304 78 hat mtge alOS 823 r 124 NY 376 83 rreg. verdict B 10 S 476 r 126 NY 324 6M 116 do 6 M 118 97 jurisdiction a 10 S 445 e 146 NY 671 e 22 M 264 1 00 receiver bond a 10 S 468 a 134 NY 643 26 NC 29Un 102 opinions SlOS 432 d 46 AD 630 e 63 AD 48 - 12M 14 future conseq. 14 AC 300n ilOS i 138 NY I 1 contempt s 10 S 444 do 48 AD 107 ... 466 1 4b eommisaion 40 limitations issue execution '6M 487 43 complaint s 10 S 370 r 125 NY 280 48 ntochau. Uen 565 grad'g st, SlOS a3SA 575 waiver SlOS 8 24 NC 66 rSSA easement 3go'oaBel8 :s9s |al32NY 169a4SA 62' 953 430 427 BIOS 67 8 AD 17 AD 28 AD lAC bar 22 M 378 668 671 340 186 ' 92 26n 490 Bios 76 d34AD 24 M d 8M 669 607 215 161 630 51 acct stated s 10 S 602 40 AD 111 2 AC 46n 53 amendment s 10 S 391 83 AD 183 56 consent r. r 10 S 146 S 467 lOln proof 333 566 175 AD 116 improper 184AD 896 434 628 16» 440 346 • 134 NY 10 S B2SNC 1 28 relief SlOS 67 strike out 85 7 AD 84 AD 2M 1 35counterclaim 8 10 S 427 a 132 NY 472 e 33 M 432 e 9 AC 248 139 appearance s 11 S 27 s 25 NC 93 f 4 1 burden proo^ s 10 8 • 803 1 AD 678 6 AD 626 positive evidece 149AD 734 1 44 affidavit 8 11 S 26 87 262 274 , e 9 AD 682 446 17 M 243 735 610 presumption 2 AC 68n 363n 3 AC 203 26 CP 25 28 400 391 109 661 566 603 defense pgo 19 AD 20 AD 29 AD do 29 AD e29M parol evidence I 38 AD 243 note liable 41 AD J 76 44 AD 101 45 AD 240 29NC378n433n 8 AC 223b e 153 NY 133 consideration do 38 AD 245 43 AD 78 172 NY ^ 302 accommodation 116AD 86 I7f eonsideratn SlOS 442 a 126 NY 630 8 AC 216n 1 76 atty's lien SlOS e63AD f 15M 16 M 8 AC 8 AC 26 CP 433 361 368 560 Sin 84o 88n 140 181 punishment 8 10 S 684 a 132 NY 403 e 67 . 2S4 ex parte order 74 igj 36 AD 642 repeal intern cond. precedent 161 AD 217 I 1 3 arrest s 10 S 27 NC do 28 NC 449 85 269 I 1 6 discovery * 123 NY BIOS 25 M 5 AC residence 4 AC 30 NC 14 AC 1 52 restore SlOS 84 AD 30 NC s lOS -88 58 AD 75 AD 80 AD IM .2M 3M 12 M 34 U e36M 39 M 6 AC 22 CP 647 310 96 624 166 90 346 615 69 224 412 260 327n 164 I 1 9 amendment 3 10 S 761 88 AD 184 45 M 203 96 M 49 allegations 10 M 29 120 AD 661 bill particulars f 97 M 84, 379 complaint 638 733 355 326 309b 68n 233n 867 337 30n 86 17 AD 10 M 103 NY contemn e 6M 4 AC 12 AC 16 AC impld. repeal 125 AD 6 l85vaoatejudgt f 9 1 surplus sll8 a 126 NY a3SA 26 M 200 verdict 3 lOS IS AC 1 57 disclosure s 10 S 886 a 132 NY 661 68 S49 compensation 62 49 do 63 AD 149 iso e86 AD 8M 141 NY 107 AD 161 vesting SlOS 61 1 65 bequest a 126 NY BllS 269 371 619 299 817 £33 73 139 1 69 directing verdict B 10 S 864 d 68 101 knowledge e75 11 ; 84 108 247 372 460 184 131n 112n 442 748 411 461 863 386n 204 construction 8 10 S 663 8 25 NC 307 2 1 5 eviction s 10 S 654 16 AC 467n 2 1 9 eviction SlOS 714 3 88 402 224 agency 8 10 S 651 a 134 NY 569 7 M 501 606 warranty dam 16 M 590. 13 AC 226n 229 gift promise 8 lis 182 r 124 NY 638 ?^§i.*''^''"iswer 29 CP 22 S ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed: d, distiniruished • r fMi„ J .....cscd: 1. limi.ed. -P-^/^olS^S^^i. ^.^'i^^.^'.ISlL'o^ir^'-^r^^ Vols. 57, 58 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Hun 239burden proof 77 AD 8 10 S 919 60 11 (r'dlt mortgage 45 AD .293 fraud conclusive 19 M 165 184 366 jurisdiction 253 illegal er. 8 10 8 774 24 AD 291 53 AD 349 259 libel charge 9 11 S 164 a 127 NY 600 specific acts 146AD 394 272 title street s 10 S 764 39 M 632 12 AC 380n 280 dajnagse 8 10 S 787 131AD 558 307 waive pro- test 8 10 S 669 13 AC notice 112 AD knowledge 112 AD slOB e24AD 25 AD 11 M 24 CP 184 NY SAG right appeal 91 AD appearance 3SCF review 16AC 147n 404 406 3 1 2 mandamus s 10 8 604 a 123 NY 639 e 79 AD 343 negligence dam. 177 NY 22 3 1 6 intent 3 10 8 * 125 NY 70 87 AD 97 AD competent ev. 91 AD 440 327 neghgence slOS 512 a 132 NY 146 15 AD 230 direct damage 62 M 23 speculative do 147 AD 517 332 affidavits s iU S 589 do no AD 909 77M 414 576 614 299 464 431 100 380n 10 328 286d 430 lien s lu S a l:i4 NY e23 AD excusable 71 M 433 punishment 8 118 211 7 AC 252n 2S3n 7 AC 254n 20AC 296n aOAC 297n 441 notice slOS e2SM 367 indictment BIOS 593 79 51 371 neg. bridge s lU 8 fi07 40 AD 699 376 foreclosure s 10 S 810 a 126 NY 624 assume risk do 121 AD 892 378 dissolution 3 10 8 907 a 125 NY 513 382 im. prom. 11^ AD 376 8 10 8 833 384neg. h'wav sl0 8 a 132 NY 40 AD 41 AD 57 AD distinction 207 NY 797 222 695 296 442 141 386 trust powi a 132 NY 313 3 108 888 395 eonstructoin 8 10 8 692 71 83 27 M 352 distribution 24 M 574 398 court order ' s 10 8 799 c 91 AD 412 400specil legacy 61u 586 69 401 147 178 439 339 safe place 8 10 8 12 AD 343 wagei 8 108 80 75 . 86 ultra vires 13 AC 266n269n 181 NY 233 material e'v. 61 M 80 357waive assestE 8 10 S 940 m 126 NY 166 39 M 464 362 mandamus 8 10 8 687 65 174 19 AD 670 7M 2Bi! preference e 148 NY 161 quo warranto 23 CP 336 12 8 i22AD 405place slOS S26NC a 134 NY 91 AD 29 M MAC party 63 AD 247 277 830 510 106 289 consideration 03 341 84 599 532 notice sll8 1 AC 535 books ev. 727 223 all 8 60 84 31 AD 61 AD 163 NY ia7NY 452 negligence s 10 8 636 18 AD 46 do 176 AD 43( do- 176 AD 438 46 M 456 adjudication 20AC 209n 456 performance 8-10 8 819 82 AD 138 abrogation 61 M 374 ciiange plans 184AD 247 459 kidnapping 10 S ■ 629 do 96 AD 180 463 objections 8 11 8 20 76 AD 74 execution costs 7 AC 278n 24 CP llnl2n 466 burden proof s58AD sll8 61 proof sufficient 13 M 635 540 mortgage 3 11 8 226 83 AD 645 28 H 138 36 M 1'64 31 NC 222n right by gift do 147AD 4(il 545 title a 11 Sj'SB 15 M conversion 131AD 558 debt exists 248 129 316 469 St. limitatns 689 729 37b 39 2J3 burial 682 ??fi-|37 M 329 369 436 SlOS a 126 NY an AD 186NY 37 C P 474 title land 8 11 8 87 3 25NC 276 r 134 NY 356 486 consolidat'n 249 591 70 79 55 491 482 sll 8 a 128 NY 61 e61 dl3 AD 407 ins waiver 10 8 748' a 132 NY 334 Ij6 360 41 1 contract 8 10 8 869 r 134 NY 67 4 1 4 tax costs 8 10 8 659 a 126 NY 693 4 1 5power of sale E 10 8 821 a 123 NY 402 4 1 7 probate wil 8 10 8 844 a 131 NY 624 a 4 SA £6 e 129 NY corporations 149AD 532 496 atty's fees 9 11 8 247 SAC 66 244 lln a 134 NY parol ev case 12 8 10 8 >25NC 239 89 122 430 490 171 587 foreclosure case 13 8 10 8 8 25NG e45 AD injunction e33 8 10 8 a25NC 448 171 248 9 118 a 128 NY 72 561 title 118 e50AD 14 AC insuf. 16 M e20M jurisdiction 24 M 29 NC 122AD sum. pro. 201 NY 563 legacy sll 8 r 133 NY 416 297 533 434 437 163n petition 320 193 277 58 686 458 466 504 206 753 300 32 903 334 896 1 865 528 588 survivor liability 10 8 261 case 7 e 67AD 441 442 ■.imitation case 10 Bios s26 NC court power s 1U8 74M case 25 60 AD not sustained 134AD 220 590 legis power cas 4 8 lis 148 42 M 684 bar case IS sll 8 r 134 NY r4 8A s21 NC ;V0L.58 7 relief fund 8 11 8 321 a 124 NY 661 exemptions 7.1 M 277 recovery 223NY 504 1 6 will execution a 11 S 606 r 124 NY 455 2 1 illegal ev 11 8 498 59 297 81 136 g limit 384 479 257 127 320 305 8 lis m 124 NY -:03NY 66 1^1 idditional costs 137 AD 457 40 contrib. neg. 3 118 361 r 124 NY 420 45 illegal ev 8 11 8 8 135 NY 33 AD 86 AD 13 AC 106 590 466 478 59 I jury question case 21 8.10 8 e67AD q67AD public use case 29 3 10 8 a 125 NY a4 8A board action 138 AD 14 691 218 219 881 131 325 567 limitation 3 118 366 368 8 AD 340 17 AD 186 28 AD 92 c22M 491 1 AC 26n 572 foreclosure 8 11 8 579 132 NY 466 592 prox. cause case 16 8 10 8 822 67AD 63 assignment 10 8 364 e 169 NY 208 577 intent a 11 8 66 29 NC 314 133 ■238 498 reversal s 11 8 3 144 NY 3 168 NY 3 69 24 M 268 60 561 617 346 516 expressed 8 11 8 60 6 1 8 burden proof ■ lis B 127 NY 60 f 171 AD 171 AD 294 219 278 92 283 749 750 585 attachment 8 10 8 280 case 1 62 AD 186 mutual insnce. SlOS case 15 f 69AD findings 8 10 8 case 16 a 126 NY a3SA 503 681 419 763 437 586 bond 8 10 8 case 9 a 134 NY a4 8A building contract 8 10 8 275 caeelO 276 415 609 642 82 316 109 bonds tax ' s 11 8 31S a 127 NY Sa 3 AC 183n I 1 9 affidavit 8 11 8 511 87 AD 264 atty affidavit 23 M 432 1 2 1 jury question sll S 523 77 463 92 399 jurisdiction d7M 206 172 U8 409- 1 22 jurisdiction 1 11 8 514 7 AC 61n. 1 3 1 service atty 3 11 8 359 al2S NY 695 1 34 indefinite 8 11 S 492. 62 AD • 12i 50 pub. officer 9 lis 829 r 128 NY 345 56 waiver 3 118 381 24 M 26« exteus'n stipula- tion n AC 451n 6b authority sll S 75 li8 M advance ments 154AD 466 452 4tSS 502 7 1 debvery prop 9 11 8 374 43 M 625 dower rights U AC 155n 76 assessment 8 118 439 r 126 NY 147 81 recovery 3 11 8 638 e 69 AD 108 60 AD Mb revocation f 93 M 97 87 false report sll 8 391 62 41t 27 NC 449 93 negligence 3 1 L ej 344 d 34 JVl 476 96 negligence s 11 8 468 a 1 3-1 NY 187 17 M 96 1 1 lien notice 8 118 66 e82 102 AD 165 NV 170 NY enforcement 83 M 558 validity lien 399 425 20 6 304 412 105M 331 369 249 340 291 528 297 547 174 273 386 246 362n. 88ll 1 43 reUet sll 8 39 M 1 47 affidavit sllS 73 35 AD pleading 11 M 14 M 16 M 30 M 34 M 35lyi 2 AC 6 AC 25 CP 233 1 49 preference 9 11 8 832 a 125 NY 530 92 176 36 AD 22 24 purpose legisl. 156 AD 732 1 56 costs demur, 8 11 8 353. 18AC 411n. 1 58 authority 3 11 8 505 e7M 217 146 AD 134 review 134 AD 566 strike out 198NY 438 161 consf ruction 9 11 S 96K 68 31 affirm allegation U M 428 injury proof 26 M 474 suit vs corpn. 25CP 69 1 67 cause action sll 8 556. a 125 NY 714 87 AD assignee costs 1 AC -2870 1 72 cost a 11 S 509 e64 94 8 U 469' 1 79 attachment 8 lis 812. ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note: C criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, dissenting opinion; p. parallel case; q, questioned' N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Hun Vol. 58 r32NY B24NC 8 28NC. 6 AC 363 236 176 182s 181 discovery sllS dgo dSSAD 25 CP practice 148AD 337 345 577 97 to stay 62-1 r 134 NY 67 AD 12 AC 122 250 467n 185 pera. injury 9 lis 617 73 474 92 243 recover damage 110 AD 254 charge 34 M 395 new trial coKts 8 AC 392n 394d S AC 3»5d damages 17AC 462-3 i 90 preferences BUS 842 r 124 NY 444 203 guaranty sllS 840 r 137 NY 626 205 bona fide holder a 12 S 334 a 132 NY 597 224 policeman counsel « 11 S 841 a 126 NY 62" 226 trustees neg, B 11 8 490 73 478 77 AD 646 230 rr. CO rights a 12 S 341 8 67 632 right, deft. f 84 M 611 annoyance 89 M 492 238 ordinances 8 11 S 826 33 AD 478 79 AD 406 24 1 pleading 8l2S 143 d 85 174 24 AD 443 parties 09 M 560 275 s Ct. justice 8l2S 10 r 125 NY 486 278 rep'td atatB 8 11 S 249 62 120 287 consent r r. 8l2S 318 15 AD 197 24 AD 338 86 AD 289 294 law question 8 12 S 306 81 147 161 1 AC 71 298 nom dam. 8 lis 864 87 neg. duty 70 delegation d 14 AD proof damagcB 47 AD 308 intent allB a 131 NY 245 venue 8 12 S 259 a 126 NY 723 28 AD 33 55 AD 390 a3SA 372 Supreme Court 67M H4 248 surety co. sl2S 271 a 126 NY 623 25 1 objections exceptions Bl2S 63 e82 e30AD 59 AD 20 CP 778 341 384 133 524 439 266 presumption sl2S 303 a 128 NY 240 92 410 272 foreclosure » 12 S 68 270 473 632 792 567 436 domicile >7J« do 91 AD construction 157 AD ayr 325 money had a 11 8 920 • 134 NY 509 8 AD 433 Stat, limitationc 25 AD 550 p 166 NY 556 333 pers injury 3 11 S 917 a 128 NY 677 337 competent evidence «H S 926 a 12 S 896 a 126 NY 661 a 4 SA 448 347 nonsuit ev. BUS 871 61 422 351 public use sl2S 116 a 128 NY 408 359 damages 9l2S 181 r 134 NY 156 iud. notice ILIIANS 114n 360 evidence 3l2S 129 Nl 23 AD e26AD 88 AD 152AD 19 M 4 AC 11 AC 179 669 74 612 341 37 200 112n 31n chancery rule [31 AD 115 364 estat vest'g 12 S 207 a 129 NY 211 366 death proofi 3l2S 172 r 132 NY 331 e20AD 116 368 bail bond B 12 S 40 r 125 NY 372 369 diBcharge s 12 S 58 a 126 NY 760 e 94 AD 103 16 At; 117ti 372 pleading a 12 8 132 60 AD 122 counterclaim 61 AD 49 i 160 AD 47 37 M 840 38 M 119 9 AC 172n sham denial 123 AD 813 '11 'laoiages d 139 AD 191 covenanta 69 M 430 376 delegation 8l2S 164 71 AD 294 compliance 53M 31 nre escapes dol21AD 892 194 NY 46| 378 tax transfer 8 12 S 203 r 127 NY 1 38 1 prim, facie negligence 1 12 S 188 a 131 NY 631 81 128 prox. cause e 62 AD 4S a 4 SA 66 384 corp'n dam 8l2S 26 a 129 NY 66) a 136 NY p91 exemption IM 22 M a 164 NY 649 140 464 186 246 62 M 404 game law s 12 8 24 r 134 NY 393 407 distribution s 12 8 48 r 124 NY 600 12 CP 390 4 1 2 police power 8l2S 41 a 134 NY 606 1 AC 257n 4 1 9 annual rep't s 12 8 631 a 134 NY 262 424 carrier dam. 8J2S .301 136 NY 612 431 pera* injury 3 12 8 627 e 85 159 |434 acknowl- edgment s 12 S 363 19A0 421n 19A0 422n promise pay lOSM 432 437 recovery s 12S «ni ICPNS 141 apportionment 173 AD 787 94 M 236 f 94 M 236 94 M 237 46 1 carrier neg. s 12 S 406 17 AC 432n 470 assignee costs a 12 S 494 a 125 NY. 760 lAC ' irer 474 ds 8 12 8 762 3S AD 362 dSSAD 363 necessary party 50 AD 94 45 M 268 478 injunction 1-2 8 616 1 70 598 8M 534 482 unsworn statement s 12 S 49S 156 AD 5-1 484 partnership 386 trust fund • 12 8 a 126 NY e6gAD charity f ,211 NY burden proof 85 AD 78 exceptions 23 M . 96 147 NY exemption 202 NY 307 679 68 127 68 440 eoata atty ■ 12 8 • 128 NY 38 AD reference 43 AD attachment 12 M 6 AC 12n 14n right not pass 203NY 496 790 67 696 117 42 326 389 instruction 8 12 S 67 20 AD 595 jury queetion 10 M 3.4 14 U 616 39 1 admr. liable il2S 197 « 128 NY 650 393 vicious dog • 12 8 162 1 AC 61n knowledge 11 AC 232n do 179AD 244 395 mandamus 8l2S 171 r 126 NY 615 396 prox. cause 8 12 S 22 2 AD 119 e 4 AD 223 298 lis pendens 8l2S 196 a 124 NY 400| 400 transfer tax ■ 128 201 443 court's pwr a 12 8 444 37 AD 188 removal trustee e 8 M 239 do 8 M 241 in function 75M 300 in possession f 99M 310 grant stay lOOM 189 450 pleading 8)28 368 60AD 375 376 accounting 43 M tmist 172 AD pG4 77 455 discretion 879 660 657 90 B 344 287n 886 101 363 12S r 134 NY r28NC 492 dama^ee 8 128 8 14 AD 497 legis. power 536 imprp. rmks. s 12 S 836 18AC 77n 639 St timitatns a 12 8 480 63 474 643 fraud s 12 S 691 44 AD 817 notice 20 M 88 error evideno* 36 M 646 impeaehmt fraud 2 AC 45n 552 dispossess'a 12 8 767 an 46 redemption 112 AD .20 390P 7 18 AC 261 meaning rent" 14 M 347 e 18 M 418 do 47 M 634 555rea8on gro'nd s 12 8 903 25 M 6 AC goud 66M 672 158 n 12 8 * 128 NY 3 141 NY s 144 NY 3 146 NY 9 87 469 93 535 257 356 612 501 agreement 9l2S 630 8 1 AD 612 505 by appeal s 12 S 497 76M 406 508 charge error al2S 612 el2AD 168 51 I withdrawal sl2 8 810 e 30 AD 77 do 176 NY 236 513 sp'l. partner 8 12 8 738 r 129 NY 498 5 1 7 defect title sl2S 14 AD f 171 AD 36 M 136 construction f 65 AD 125 license 9 M _ 565 moving pictures 62 M 104 adminiotrative sl2 8 a 128 NY 66 AD 182 NY injunation gM f 90 M surplusage 30 NC 103 AD 46 M trustee ILKANS allegatiunB 141 AT) liability do 148 AD individual 210 NY not barred 103M 848 626 661 433 619 83 328n 103 862 85 112 compet ev case 13 3118 68 AD trust fund case 24 a 11 8 82 AD jurisdiction case 26 SllS 62 602 legal title case 30 B 12 S 957 66 AD 367 603 rape aaaault case 24 s U'S 04 AD certiorari case 26 sUS • 169 NY faith 697 31n 557 exception S 12 H 499 12B AD 426 563 public use B 12 8 859 * 128 NY 600 566 construe will 12 8 484 a 127 NY 100 569not enforced 12 S lOOM 175, 571 verdict s 128 64 e37 AD 163 NY elOM 580 176 6114 489 8 109 436 578 construction 8 12 S 647 68 31 competent ev, 11 M 425 admissions S2M 209 error court 70 M 237 585 supervision 8 12 S 673 * 128 NY 662 590 damages s 12 S 683 a 128 NY 633 negligence debt 176 AD 433 do 176 AD 448 220 595 judicial sl2 8 62 notice 19 AD 6M 746 341 603 50 764 617 464 411 486 564 561 135 604 lex loci inspection case 1 8 11 8 636 73 AD 426 case 26 11 8 610 73 AD 369 606jury question case 1 sU S 931 6» AD 476 prejudioial case 10 3 11 S 906 66 ' 337 807 club sale intox. liquors case 13 3 12S 40 149 NY 11 7M 65 609 demurrer case 18 s 12 S 381 62 AD 193 case 9 damage appeal 21 CP 126 610 probate wilt case ■ 23 s J2 S 741 a 26 NC 389 presumption 77 M 80 136 S 828 6 1 I injunction case 5 12 S 834 46 AD 235 38 M 516 bill particular case 6 8l2S 62 AD award case 21 s 12S 74 AD enforcible d 198NY 764 132 856 342 528 covenants al2S 403 a. 126 NY 681 531 prom, note Bl28 a 134 NY 60 1 no licenae case 3 s 11 8 149 NY e7M ahenation case 8 401 s 11 8 60re62 AD 694 11 605 419 624 154 156 .AliliKKS I.VriDNS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note: e. criticised ; 1. limited ; e, explained ; o. overruled ; a, same case ; do. dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q. questioned Vol. 59 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Hun VOL 59 I proof costs s 12 S 665 7M 707 phnoipal bound d 40 M 57 Nonpayment 181 NY 264 breach contract 138 AD 534 1 7 conclusive sl2S a 126 NY eQl cond. sale 22 M 25 M 10 AC not realty f 159 AD 619 643 372 126 340 9,23n 529 40 demurrer s 12 S 378 e 107 AD 303 51 information do 100 AD 324 121 negligence sl3S 151 a 128 NY 813 do 6 AD 186 d 7 M 646 650 27 allegation 9l3S 118 18 M 427 •! 26 M 653 1.29 Stat Umitns sl3S a 128 NY 25 AD exceptions 17 M 688 538 136 603 211 185 319 sl2S a 136 NY e8 AD 60 nuisance ■ 12S r 131 NY 9 68 no legal title e21 AD 63 construction s 12 S 642 75 76 92 M 698 resettlement 76 668 2 AD 28 value estate 55 M 480 college beqist 59 M 103 actual fact 152AD 689 d 173 AD 471 no authority 224NY 339 75 affidavits 8 13 S 144 5 AC 380n 80 "building" s 13 S 12G 167 AD 044 84 assignment s 13 S a 126 NY 135 655 142 678 384 376 91 pleading 8l3S a 128 NY 78 claim realty 29 CP 95 declarations 8 13 S 110 IISAD 545 do547 97 absol devise 8 13 S 120 11 M 312 107 information 114 327 137 642 sl3S e74 85 e24M distinction 128 AD motion f 178AD 664 932 1 1 4 pers knowl. sl3S 170 23 M 38 declarations 115 AD 645 do547 1 17 jurisdiction s 13 S 166 10 AC 70n 84n a 129 NY 155 2 1 2 assessment s 13 S 452 a 128 NY 669 d 34 AD 355 2 1 4 injunction s 13 S 783 a 126 NY 342 225 eontrib. neg. s 12 S 932 d61 131 311 8 8S 369 362 38 234 authority ^ 8 12 S 806 9 AC 423n 84 167 265 2S5n 660 1 43 vested sl3S 92 AD stipulation 2 AC not bound 155 AD 1 53 trust valid . s 13 S 202 a 133 NY 473 1 58 construction sl3S 217 71 AD 359 1 6 1 contingent remain Jer 8 lis 148 8 11 AD 361 366 remainder class 148 aD conclusive 41 AD e 154 NY 237 mitigation 3 12 S 785 79 561 e 25 AD 284 jury question 36 M 18 239 prin debtor a 12 S 783 84 551 248 dower sl2S • 128 NY 9 90 AD 85 329 539 1 73 undertaking 8 13 S 437 r 128 NY 303 1 77 pers injury 8 13 K 491 a 129 NY 624 no defense 134 AD 392 1 79 trespass B 13 S 439 3 AC 225n 181 money in lien s 13S 128 13GAD 360 1 86 parol ev s 13 S 473 3 135 NY 186 86 ' , 66 1 92 servitude 3 13 S 545 r 128 NY 60 200 demand s 13 S 396 19 AD 296 punishment 44 M . 338 compliance W5 AD 848 202 court's pwr 9 13 S 490 a 128 NY 669 57 AD 531 204 vacancy 8 13 S . 447 a 128 NY 657 73 407 d 173 AD 341 mandamus do 38 AD 543 207 general Stat 5 13 S 398 a 126 NY 469 209 land under water 9 13 S 493 815 661 7,B 890 632 258 permissive sl2S a 128 NY mandatory 222NY 260 not mandatory 173 AD 539 268 damages s 12 S 783 e 24 AD 60: waiver e 67 AD 24 2i 69 AD 439 10 AC 396 3g7n exemptions elSM 531 assert exemption 31 M 495 contempt dU M 63 272 water-right 8l3U 12 r 136 NY 6U 282 royalties Sl2fci s 14i!i a 126 NY 299 o£f-8et B 12 b a 128 NY 30 AD 824 9t> 664 640 81 304 jurisdiction s 13 b 2i 49 AD 53b near larceny 16U AD 638 307 interest 8 12S a 126 NY 40 AD t 161 AD 69 16 declarations 83 321 18 M 142 30 NC 136 change benehc, i 14 AC 185 !i7 M B56 distinction a7M 111 34 1 on the merits 13 S 93 92 S'J 342 compensatn a X3B 101 86M 5U3' construction 68 M 503 345re8idence prin- othce 8 13lj 44 AD e49 AD 64 AD- 88 AD lOlM 8 AC IB AC 141 391 34 3S9 282 384 269n 262 man 347cond. precedt 8 138 164 92 AD 598 u 12a AD ooz defendant 196 NV 237 place payment. 13 IAD lender lU M i47AD lex loci JU2 NY 351 C2I allow 8 13S 66 d 162 NY 26 CP 1B9 346 4U2 239 97 623 613 378 36 1 marine ins Sl2b 811 a 129 NY 490 365 injunction 8 12 S 804 a 128 NY 624 69 leave to is- sue execution 13 B. lOO a 131 NY 80 371 demurrer aI3S 77 f66 512 87AD 313 37 M 526 14 AC 64n 375 interpleader 13 S 43 2 AC 239n e 34 M 733 award personal 13 AC 24gn 4l3costitut'nl 8 13 S 390 do 81 AD 66 privilege 19AC 364n no discovery 390P 48n 420 accounting 8 13 S 388 a 128 NY 578 8 25 NC 478 424 ev. confesn. 13 R 382 184 NY 509 infer crime 63M 281-3 428 joinder 13 B e60 jury trial 69 56 AD s26NC i)6 M 43 1 parties sl3S a 128 NY 133 NY 434 ev. value s 13 S. 864 a 133 NY 628 e 60 493 e 46 AD 259 el 27 NY 470 J. admissible I31AD 54 133 S 238 447 eq relief s 13 S 527 63 154 f 42 AD 20 joint clectn. 128 AD 145 parties d 157 AD 263 450 exclusive jurisdiction 8 13 8 366 e 85 AD 375 454 foreign jud' sl3S 361 74 626 78 386 allege and prove 383 draft bank 12 S r 128 NY 864 26 86 125 892 679 657 284 3 1 I legacy vest 8l3S i 27 M 262 29 JVI 71B 3 1 7 prob. cause s 12 S 936 85 AD i 320 appealable s 12 S 943 1 AC S3d 15UAD 546 ,_„ ^. 407 award error 336 assumption! s 13 S 404 33 !37l» 128 NY 654 387 trust sl3S 72 395'rejoct 74 i 78 surety a 14 8 66 AD cuveuauts i7-W 457 70 719 186 470 1 83 neg. interest s 14 bi 721 » 136 NY 96 189 jurisdiction 8 14 £j 692 6 AC 98n 204 ratification a 14 ti 686 a 129 NY 106 U2 20b 21 5 tax sales d 14 iS 694 r 128 NY 384 294 mtge. right a 14 S 601 a 133 NY 638 67 232 wife party 1 AC 132n spl. damage 19A0 1.61n adv. possession 140 AD 294 298 undue infi u 14S 763 i7 M 464 burden proof 13 M 332 3 1 3 rr f encmg 9 16 8 U d 62 297 315 6Q- assets sJ& S ilSAD 5S 135 130 pleading s 14 S SI AD S2M 1 32 retrial sl4S 67 8 74 asaumption 6 AD 135 parties sl4S 16 C So 205 294 631 162 646 116 106 133 263 32 dispute claim 9l4S a 128 NY 9 AC practice 123AD conclusive 152AD 130 S 85 books ev sl4S r 131 NY r28NC 7 AC 198 614 2500 59: ass 700 255 169 104 473n 44jury queation s 14 S 498 75 314 parol evidence 86 439 I 48 exception sl4S 619 f 60 130 eq. jurisdiction 83 153 not nuisance 98 M 90 I 5 1 absolute fee s 14 S 666 a 139 NY 210 72 182 1 56 intervention 225 taxation a 14 8 129 NY r 141 NY 61 65 70 4 AD ulU AD lunitation 61, certiorari e tii capital stock 78. waiver 111 AD 869 668 471 65 266 610 392 783 369 86 72 783 235hyp queation 8 14 8 612 SAD 77 243 demurrer 682 654 125 658 126 al4S )U6 AD e 112 AD practice e41 M mail service U2 AD double time ■in vy 460 451 112 AD 128 time service f 63M 270 strike out 16AC 243n 248 fraud 14 8 e3M SAC 706 497 23'6n .sl4S a 128 NY 62 AD nugatory 16M a3SA insuf. sffi lavit 17 M 243 2 AC fiSn 674 601 569 167 618 259 waiver sl4S rl31 NY 3 AC 268 bequest 8 14 8 r 131 NY 67 280 actual facts s 14 8 591 171 AD 749 290 partition 8 14 S 680 a 137 NY 119 e 61 AD 4 5 10 11 8 M 475 3l9Ubel 8 14 S 848 C 86 481 o 8 AD 4o2 o 24 AD 289 nominal verdict :i9AD ■ 169 324ev exception a 15 S 41 a 135 NY 417 Ic 96 AD 145 328 designation a 14 8 867 S3 AD 630 f 34 M 393 e 52 At 3UU vs. public policy 163 NY 158 revocation 94 AD el9M authority 140 AD b o2M constitu^i-gnal 203NY 507 procedure 172 AD 436 367 exemption 841 609 40n 135n 409 al4S a 131NY e4gM 14 AC family" 49 M man head fam. 71 M 60 372 rescisaion 3 148 865 a 133 NY 187 e 30 M 373 379 wife poss'n s 16 8 62 636 e 67 233 382 beneficiary a 16 8 15 a 131 NY 205 385 juriadiction 3 IS 8 470 10 AC S4n 462 bank's duty s 16 8 236 e 48 AD 221 96 AD 332 41 M 619 176 NY 72 jury question 69LRA • 324n 69LRA 338n 466 affidavit , 3S4v. a IS 8 r 131 NY 69 Hofrer 686 249 64 6ir 69b 309 337 modification 8l4 8 16 AD 24 AD 39 AD e2SM 47 M el9M 4 AC S21 472 461 647 478 372 332 228n 347 jurisdiction 3 15 8 27 f31M IS Indian law do d 121 AD 321 350 prim, facie a 14 8 834 r 131 NY 622 65 368 burden on deft 20 AD 624 33 M 484 358 coventfnta a 16 8 344 a 136 NY 219 381 affidavit a 16 8 S6 f32 AD 23 residence 13AG 464n466n -ution 63M 26 order £ 164 AD 957 364 mistrial 3l5S a 131NY 65 discretion 144 AD 60 118 397 396 value sis 8 9 AC 584 20Sn 399 impriamt. a 15 8 512 a 128 NY 629 40 1 tax duress 16 8 474 a 135 NY 460 404 part paymt a 15 S 62 f 56 M 622 405 consideratn. s 15 S 467 94 AD 52 48 M 486 3 15 8 a 129 NY 79 dSl e9 AD e53AD a2M 47 M 14 M 2 30M pAC 2 AC 2 AC ecovery 88 AD tender 112 AD 208 663 614 564 682 205 206 17 735 685 638 61n 39^n 203 152 897 470 power sale 3 16 8 1S3 77 210 62 AD «66 21 M aeo 473 compliance a 15 S .ipi e 109 AD 523 d 30 M 743 38 M 662 UAC 461n452 no waiver o8M 4 1 2 prom slS8 , al3lNir note 596 462 4 1 4 attachment 9 15 8 514 r 133 NY 248 r 28 NC 327 4 1 7 wUi a 16 8 a 131 NY 3M 3 27NC 470 391 47 151 a ISS e6 AD 35 AD 48 AD 83 AD do 132AD 2M review do 119 AD _, uitable relief AD 358 422 board health 8 IS 8 487 75 AD 213 84 AD 68 do 104 AD 611 423adv possessn 9 16 8 103 AD d 140 AD 42 M 22 511 295 62 442 findings 8 16 8 44 d 66 453 3 27NC 197 i 163 AD 970 f 148 S H24 AUHKEVIATION'S: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f. followed c. criticised ; 1. limited ... 446 water works 8 16 S 477 18211 65 NY 30 nonce insuf. 38 CF 30 M notice 32 M 477 alimony 378 341 630 466 sis 8 a 129 NY 71 78 AD 153 AD • 1 AC 4 AC 198 566 366 181 462 lS7n 40n 48 1 discretion 227 565 338 645 162 644 181 292 surroeat e power 126 AD 748 review 136AD 833 486 mandamus SlSS a l48 NY 3 20 AD salary 24 AD eSlM 308 766 452 19 562 49 AD 149 do 154 489 evidence 3 IS S 232 97 AD 624 cross examin. 12 AC 4S8n 495 evidence 3 16 8 f65 68 d34 AD 12 M 176 623 458 78 14 reversed : e. oxolaiued ; o, overFuIed ; s. same case'. do.'disae'nt'ing'opmiM" p'parall'el c^""^ quMtio^^ Vols. 60, 61 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Hun 504 suretieb 8 ISS 122AD do 162 AD do 162 AD discharge 60 M 237 360 126 127 570 507 discharge a IS S 242 dlSAD . 597 mandamus 50 AD 289 completion work 29 M 701 5 1 will vesting B 15 S 240 a 131 NY 686 5 1 6 objections slSS 74 IAD 24 M 37 M 91 M 239 365 622 41 251 699 364 e 62 AD 302 foreign recv'r case 17 a 14 S 873 5 AC 407d transfer tax case 26 sl5S 2 s 27 NC ■ . 28 m prosecution ca3e39 s 15 S 215 a 133 NY 697 s 28 NC 256 584 negligence case 1 15 S 1! e 73 AD IC covenant case 3 diss a 135 NY 8 29NC award case 4 slSS 8 27NC 5l8dischg servt il5S 80 AD 162 AD 163 NY SAC 219 367 gi6 359 288n 523 authority s 15 S 214 d 79 AD 524 528 assignt valid s 17 S 360 67 AD 472 535 benef assn sis S 309 f 48 AD 637 543 parol ev B 15 b 336 e7AD 687 authority 8 AC 316n former suit p'dg'. 13 AC. 160d 546 suit pending B IS S 261 3 AC 227n 562 declarations s IS S 363 a 131 NY 649 566 compensat'D BiSS f e82 107 57 1 gift intent 8 15 9 398 65 AD 693 696-6 complt. delivery 172 AD 535 103M 453 577 nonsuit case 11 s 14 S 329 14S AD 274 148 AD 18 132 S 235 129 S • 1040 581 larcen> case 8 s 14 S 637 64 AD 464 not disturbed 166 AD 754 582 particulars case 19 b16S 119 99 AD 471 583 construction case 7 3 14S 898 166 312 218 256 166 VOL.61 I. partnership S'lSS 391 a 133 NY 664 6 "meal "flour s 16 8 490 42 M. 397 8 notice claim s 16 S 387 77 442 d 86 471 e 33 AD 73 e 42 AD 479 83 AD 583 584 107 AD 191 I I neg rr rules 585 liability 18AC 373n, 374n 586 allowance case 7 s 15 S 601 * 135 NY 413 sl6S 73 66 AD 83 AD 96 AD 96 AD £ 133 NY f4SA charge jury 111 AD reason. .care 121 AD 1 7 assignment s 15 8 359 d 86 609 85 AD 244 "conveyance" 20 5 NY 11» 103M 17 29 NO 87 limitation 15 S 431 28 M 574 acknowldgment 38 CP 510 19 AC 4l7jl 19 AC 427n 9 1 ins. policy 15 S B9T 133 NY 408 384 273 530 60 441 44 670 270 833 142 1 1 admissible s 15 S 425 213 NY 332 105 contract a 16 S 420 a 133 NY 460 oontr. neg. ILRA 450n I 1 insur. policy 9 15 S 429 r 133 NY 394 charge rule HI AD 833 I I 5 felony slSS 173 NY 23 damages i 15 S * 131 wy 44 56h 440 148 I 1 8 parol ev. 3 IS S 673 r 136 NY 547 AD 58'' 125 safe place 26 assignment s 15 S 330 3 66 318 do 172 AD 00 f 175 AD 48S 29 M 299 f 162 S 172 30 waive protest 16 S 318 40 A I ) 536 83 AD 144 13 S 153 33 tees 3 ISS 127 AD 291 410 46 compliance s 15 S 369 150 AD 71 48 authority 3 15 S 321 88 562 15 AC .432n jurisdiction 27 M 723 58 M 500 8 AC 39411 domestic corpn. 7 AC 374b amendment 98 M 480 53franchiBe tax 8 15 S 711 r 129 NY 664 63 450 67 AD 334 66 organiz. tax 8 15 S 635 r 129 NY 474 SSdoing busin's 3 15 S 446 a 131 NY 04 65 255 257 d 65 261 1 AC 344n 89 98 equity s 15 S 165 AD 412 618 657 490 .'J77 530 420 97 294 628 403 sl5S 67 e69 s70 SO 85 71AD d., 95 AD 2SM contrib. neg. 2 AC 179n question fact 20 AD 255 inspection 143 AD 904 risk master do 144 AD 884 1 33 injunction 3 15 S 624 168 NY 234 public use 49 M 566 77M 3TC 1 40 injunction - 3 15 S 762 r 135 NY 3) 1 6 1 injunction 3 15 S 763 r 136 NY 393 1 64 vicious dog 8 15 S 765 m 135 NY 201 1 65 fact question a 16 S 766 172 US 409 -171 jurisdiction B IS S 724 * 133 NY 696 a 145 NY 487 78 87 counterclnim 17 AD 248 98 AD 576 180 inquiry agency s 15 S 890 69 22 M 25 M 27 M IS AC authority 116 AD notice 61 M 185 note s 15S 10 M estoppel 76M 13GS 545 547 176 281 S25n 843 107 liable 924 361 194 989 s 25 NO 299 189 damages 8 15 S 908 69 568 £ 72 639 1 93 competent 3 16 S 551 a 145 NY 601 24 AD 250 31 M 345 33 M 635 9 AC 280n 285 12 AC 362n jggrestrnt trbe s 15 S 887 a 136 NY 333 38 AD 602 208 bill paxtic corporation breach 16 S 80 131 NY 354 92 AD 2B5 310 compet. ev. 16 S 77 131 NY 314 88 211 314 credibility 15 S 915 14 M 320 318 miB-trial 8 16 S 132 64 26T satisfaction 106 AD f85M 325 tort s 15 S 135 NY s 16S 82 126 AD 138AD 7 U 212 neg. q SlSS 169 NY repair track 6M collision 16AC 359 26 179 179 fact 927 127 263 2 1 4 reference e 76 362 sl6S 13 2 1 9 limitations 8 16 8 o4AD e30AD 68 AD 70 AD 946 462 216 161 404 223 jurisdiction sl6S 16 M 25 CP 231 penalty 3 16S eSgAD do 158 AD nullity f 158 AD 16 618 393 7 11 800 798 161 138 AD 372 legacy S16B 145 NY 36 M 329 634 885 306 327 variance s 15 S 917 * 131 NT 667 * 133 NY 214 331 will revoke 3 16 S a 131 NT 51 M 5 AC 29 CP marriage 61 M 113 318 318 24 72 318 335 extra allow 3l6S 32 4 AD 446 164 NY 414 337 strik out 8 16 S 72 26 M 204 amend comp'aint 8 AC 103n 338 mandamus 8 16 8 118 s 27 NC 422 not an action 312 142 AD validity 145 AD remedy 156 AD 635 389 233 lease oral 3 16 S 870 31 M 277 246 pers. fTana s 16 8 721 32 AD 440 61 AD 283 254 fire escapes 8 16 8 820 r 131 NY 90 272 life insur. s 16 8 753 a 131 NY 478 279stenoa fees new election 186AD 2: 343 aet-oS sl5S r 135 NY r29NC 354 costs 16 8 7 AD do 7 AD 6 AC "" M 892 223 200 865 383 388 136n 114 483 180 666 19 sl68 16 AD 282 will 8 16 S 760 647 trusts 137 a 131 NY 331 356 perfm dam SlSS 911 62 AD 77 e 9 M 336 1 AC 370n 360 depos, bond 8 16 8 S3 a 131 NY 286 365 spl proceed s 16 8 120 • 131 NY 569 80 247 368 witness ar- rest 816 S 129 7 AC 337n vacate ot-dpr 386.Heave to sue 8 16 S 74 16AC 26gn 388 surplus 16 S 33 a 129 NY 48 406 compet. ev. s 16 S 273 20 M 387 418 baggage s 16 8 220 39 AD 406 competent ev. 17 M 160 impeach 133 AD 261 427 eq. relief s 16 8 240 a 137 NT 223 B 88 430 covenant recove 8 AD 182 96 AD 47 meas. damages 150 AD 141 do 156 AD 143 value realty 214 NY 583 438 foreclosure 16 8 267 138 NY 133 30 NO 329 447fun'l expens s 16 S 233 22 M 247 4531unatic deed 8 16 S 251 17T NT 262 o 76 AD 336 U AC 438n440n 11 AC 444 460 jiu*isdiction B 16 8 229 64 166 13 AC 169n defense 8 AC 210n 212n 28 NC 372 bar 176AD 801 467 questn ■ fact B 16 8 279 8 AD 132 86 AD 88 prox cause death 51 AD 610 waive forefeiture 70 AD 199 construction s 16 8 436 full amount 197NY 61 472 surety rent 8 16 8 236 59 AD I 267 93 AD 619 exhaust remedy 19 M 664 demand neccssy 200 NY 353 479 pave track 8 16 8 225 24 AD 494 e 26 M 211 e 35 .M 616 490 legis intent 8 16 8 36> ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, not* c. criticised: 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case ; q, queitionx) N. Y. Supreme Coun Reports — Hun Vols. 61, 62 80 370 496 foreclosure ol6S r 135 NY r29NC deficiency 37 CP persnl. 137S 369 275 294 8d judgmt. 736 SOD pub office 332 644 62 133 609 sl6S a 131NY p84 lOM el7M incumbrance 18A0 421 504admr. assets s 16 S 371 a 131 NY 575 5l9civil process s 16 S 325 r 136 NY 585 r 30 NO 51 528 remainder s 16 S 395 r 135 NY 137 533 receiver s 16 S 385 a 136 NY 316 e 69 579 file chat, mtg, s AC 83 85r 539 easement 392 155 16 S r 137 NY damages 1 LRANS 544 transfer tax s 16 S S88 m 131 NY 274 551 transfer tax s. 16 S • 391 r 131 NY 274 552 injunction s 16 S 397 78 448 9 AC 365n 375n 13AC 396n397n material mens 169 AD 849 557 partnership s 16S 337 a 136NY 43P delivery 55 M .19 564 allegations s 16 S 347 el4M 113 e 16 M 103 41 M 186 566 amendment s 16 S 368 a 133 NY 674 s 87 352 serve pldg. 18 AC 199 568 insane notice s 16 S 306 a 131 NY 641 571 "property' extortion 1 145 AD business 145 AD 864 590 mark title s 16 S 421 69 AD 331 incumbrance 31 M 616 19A0 84n recovery 5M 100 performance IAD 774 restrictions 178AD 740 18AC 419n 595 surety s 16 S 424 s 76 264 266 604 cost s 16S 64M 859 293 608sue on bond s 10 S 465 12 AC 466n 613' injunction 16 S 13a NY 61" case 16 s 15 137 S T7 M 419 481 619 lien notice 403 134 450 329n 15 S case 22 20 AD 14 AC 620 ejectment s IS S 418 case 12 135 NY 40 29 NO 314 disord. house 15 S case 13 66 AD s 15S 147 AD 132 S 630 540 F)98 f.78 573 s 16 S r 133 NY 67 91 26M boycott 43 M 9 AC 137 NY indictment 436 649 306 491 61^ 600 lln 38 621 injunction s 15 S 790 case 14 f 67 AD 628 622rep'r bridge a 15 S 795 case 15 48 AD 600 623 competency s 15 S 942 case i7 a 149 NY jurisdiction case 31 sl6S d33M waive objns. 18AC 578 427n 624 widow sup Iport 9 16 S case 19 e64AD 77 M 137 S 716 26B 210 533 a 147 NY 709 627 harmlees er' 313 SU ■ 16S case 12 S7AD 49 f 117AD 613e614sl6S l23AD 109lca8e 8 625 verdicts sl6S case 2 73 AD 307 626 coaerrt neg. 66 VOL.62 77 AD 246 1 allegation 8l6S 117 38 M 434 tax warrant 2 AC 871 'a 16 3 is 27 NC 4 iUeffal evidence |01 sl6S 410,43 AD s90 394 48 AD s60AD 14713 AC 4 AC 1 2 competent ev 1 134 N'V I M sp prfmance 29NC 22 125 AD pledge faih do 125AD 16S 32 M 401 1 5 stkhldr liab. s 16 S 407 44 AD 73 verify pleading 122 attachment 619 361 508 470 621 g9n 347 630 300 69 233 r.r s 16S 27 AD 86 AD 237 revocation s 16 S 667 a 131 NY 302 410|2SCP 31 CP 24 CP 1 8 surplus sl6S a 133 NY 6 AD e9M el9M 160 NY 26 costs Bl6 8 46 AD 7 AC 7 AC 13 AC 1 3 1 penalty sl6S 664 71 162 6M 162 4n! 1 37 h'way neg I3I6S 503 44R|rl31NY 447 687 1 67 1 1 53 remedy 896 9 16 S 586 361 167 76n 76n 79 30d 133 NY 83 160 bigamy s 16 8 a 133 NY e49 AD lex loci 141 AD 3 I receiver b16S a 131 NY 66 343 494 101 425 406 121 125 neglig. 909 378 IS 238 legatees S16S 737 m 131 NY 466 240 dower right s 16 S 736 * 131 NY 646 P78AD 100 dOOAD 76 37 M 733 11 AC 152n 39 car rigkt way 319 199 321 sl«S e 145 NY 11 M 42 laches Bl6 S 82 certiorari f 110 AD 46 sl6 8 r 142 NY r31NC 52 coats sl6S 6 AC 7 AC eoliditions 63 M 401 6 894 commissions 367 70 464 430 S2ii 461d 520 63 stkbldr loan s 16 S 545 51 AD 261 f 98 M false report SAC . 397d subscription 60 M 608 74 sp. prfcaanoe 8 16 S 678 a 149 NY 680 86 mandamus 601 669 165 nuisance 'slRS 538 20 AC »8n I 70 h way neg 8 16 8 640 T 131 NY 382 1 8 I neglig. dam s 16 S 499 160 NY 626 633 1 85 mandamus s 16 8 488 a 131 NY 644 81 AD 246 1 90 recoupment 8l6S -613 a 137 NY 179 P 62 210 1 94 inter vivos s 16 S 476 746 r 137 NY 69 208 costs 8 168 33 M 243 covenants s Ifi 8 685 r 140 NY 175 31 NC 223 n 245 foreclosure ' 16 S 646 s"160 NY 327 s69 74 250 right dower r 133 NY 640 3 16 8 66 r 133 NY 640 5 AC 104n 257 receivers sl6 8 602 * 131 NY 648 82 307 56 AD 438 pers.inj. survival 24 AD 225 do 24 AD 227 27 AD 396 56 AD 431 432 24 CP f 1 AC 9 AC do 9 AG 263 allowance a 133 NY 694 s 16 S 826 265 mandamus 734 462 2 1 town bonds 340 ,8 16 8 607 a 137 NY 170 sl6 8 a 131 NY 94 set-oS sies a 136 NY p62 136 NY construction 26 M implied 17 AC 109 AD 192 407 466 repeal 411 667 626 666 99 prior mtg. 8 16 8 633 a 137 NY 332 1 AC 367n 22 1 pub h, way s 16 8 683 e 33 AD 582 discontinue 6 AC 99 106n 7 AC 445d 224turnpikecos 8 16 S 697 r 133 NY 254 23 1 trespass Bios 828 I 10 sp. prfmnee. s 91 191 8 18 S 621 r lU NY 679 64 602 parol eostraet a 138 NY street award 20 AD liability quail, meruit 70 M damages d 92 M voidable 161 S 361 362 303 amend writ 8 17 8 78 90 49 AD 61 AD 26 CP 649 62 42 £66 603 179 306 damages sl7 8 B42AD .•.70 184AD injunction 13 AD 24 AD 51 AD 36 M divert water 24 AD reasonable 1 91 M 210 409 559 516 45 611 170 467 62S use 82 207n 141 66n 69 68 61 sl6S a 131 NY 190 NY validity 75M disregard 95 M 768 670 34 502 698 269 pub. policy sl6S 757 a 133 NY 336 143 NY 439 assumption 121 AD 450 275 remainder- man s 17 S 93 76 534 life interest 85 , 574 logaey intere 16 AC 193r next of kin d 173 AD 471 286 res judicata s 17 8 228 r 135 NY 320 298 "chose in actn. " 8 17 S 196 98 AD 256 15 AC 316 3l7forn judgmt Is 17 8 6 AC 324 UBury s 17S a 136 NY 329 trust 17 8 a 131 NY 75 e3H 221 206n 171 634 238 629 241 166 341 new trials 17S 218 lOOM 523 346 deposits ^^^ 14 AC 84n oank neg. 69LRA 336n 353 construction 1 17 S 232 R AD 122 358 award s 17 S 88 27 AD 44 AD 71 277 167 233 369 will sl7S 19 AD jo'nder 41 AD ratification 16 M 86 M 60 206 612 87 200 376 stoppage in transition sl6S 906 3 AC 47n 383 surety b17S r 138 NY 153 361 391 auctioneers . 17 8 r 136 NY 400 ooihpet. 8 17 S e98 AD 102 363 510 465 407 false report 46 444 30 628 397n strict constructn _ 17 8 s27NC 61 AD 1 M ISAC ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, c, criticised ; 1. limited ; e, explained ; c distinguished; f. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n note- , overruled; s, same case; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q, questioned Vols. 62, 63 N. T. Supreme Court Reports — Hun 158 AD 727 4 1 6 extra allow- ance s 16 S 900 3 AG 66ii 428 remainder- main B17.S r 136 NY 75 profits 85 168 560 674 439extendpa'inb 8l7S 144 4 AC 283 445 vacate decis aieS 918 10 AD 506 incumbrance 18AC 4l5n 452 restriction 8 17S 13 19A0 82n 169 AD 319 right contract 169 AD 91 public highway 224NY 508 458 trusts a 17 8 . a 136 NY 55 114 465 award dam sl7S 124 6 AD 54 467 construe will p 17 S 86 e 29 AD 379 e 3fi AD 214 471 bona fide holder sl7S 3 s68 30 473 chffe. venue Bl7S 2 r 133 NY 442 a 22 CP 205 479 mccban lien sl7S 88 ^B 423 KBO 82 19P°°a«'"1 „ no review fact|_^J^ 1^3 SjjY 290 456nli--7^ 0/4 arrest con- ioei conversion '■""'s 17 S 94 42 AD 621 construction 74M 309 removal d 155 AD 4T1 discretion 155 AD 472 534 removal 8 17 S 91 118 AD 486 39CP 114 536 jncomp. ev< 9l7 S 244 e 3AD 255 31 NC 273n 543 survival 8 16 S 92.' 6 AD 483 SAC 309 31 Id 9 AC 322u 548:restoration 4i 609 367 sl7 8 8M 43 M estoppel 101 All defenses 16AC 83 205o 551 libel s 17 S 393 83 AD 474 476 privileged 177AD 94 554 insur risk s 17 S 106 138 NY 16 557 affidavits 8 17 8 133 3 AG 399n inspect books 12 M 469 4 AG 167n 9 AC 487n488n title stock 3 AC 372n 9 AC 489n 582 undertaking 3 17 S 68 27 M 99 security 127 AD 647 6 1 indictment sl7S 1 11 AD 643 6l2condin terr s 17 8 316 68LRA 45lD intent prevails . T6M 109 6 1 8 contract case 28 8 16 S 566 s 28 NC 142 6 1 9 construe will case 13 sl6S ( VOL. b3 6 title executor s 17 S 441 136 AD lOQ next -of kin 310 40 70 modification 493 a 133 NY i 164 AD 95 M 8 servant neg, s 17 tj 438 a 137 NY ;i44 I 1 partnership 620 surety case 8 3 16 8 e6 AD discretion case 12 sl6S 89 AD 622 tender case 24 sl7S 42 M 623 damages case 4 8 17 8 f 13AD 4 AC njunction case 2 3 17 S 133 NY 820 609 689 625 128 379 22 304 74 125 672 7 AC allegations 41 M 484 residence 8 17 8 s26NC a 133 NY 7 AC 200, 22 M 316 1q?1 579 replevin lOgiisHS 193 '"''°i43 M 368 493 party a 17 8 8 137 NY 3 AD 6 AD protection 27o|T2M 231 444j 271:587 negligence 254 s 17 8 302 [8 79 6il 499 public use sl6S 894 59 1 attachment a 133 NY 329!s 17 8 556 75 337 514 shipping 1 76 124 665 a 17 8 167 524 bond Bl78 8 139 NY a 139 NY 80 5 AC 41n42n 395 143 NY 354 „„i596 action rent 9? 8 17 8 4S 2J| e 13 M s; ■^66 gtat . fraud 130 AD 53 1 trustees 8 17 8 91 602 gift 13 AD 340 8 17 8 protest estate |r 137 NY d 45 M 550' 313 410 215 sl7lS r 139 NY 1 9 coats ana m 135 NY d7AD .„ (a ju. 72 M a62 3J3 415 ■Mb 38b 112 113 114 23 gift vesting 8 17 CJ ;i81 ax 138 NY 222 8b AD 431 434 32 jiegligenoe 8 17 ci 328 r 136 NY 239 17 AD 189 36 damagea s 17 ti 273 c 35 AD 281 9 M . MU 24 OP , Sb surrog. jurisdn e 47 M 42 uunsLrue will 69 M 314 validity 9B M 418 40 leave of court ana e80 d52 AD bar i AC 143 NY 31 OP retroaction 19 AC 1X4 lis 22 671 ii2 36 42 lib. oonstrctn 8 17 8 418 SO AD 98 48 ap. prfmaace 8 17 8 • 443 a 137 NY 889 56 mechanic lien 8 17 8 el4 AD d21 AD SAC ' SAC 156 NY 574 644 22n S9n 118 80 106 conditional 8 17 8 biO 38 CP 502 51U loknowldgunt. 19A0 418n 19AC 410n427n I 1 2 appeal time sl7 S 630 5U M 03U II AG 460b I 1 8 at limitatns sl7S (iib 71 596 123 "hawking" 3 17 8 bOS a 140 NY 187 1 34 St. limitatns a 17 8 696 8 147 NY 414 P 71 bis I428tat limitatn 18 AD 72 AD 59 AD I23AD 152AD 9M s 17M do 67M 1 AC 2 AC 4 AG 7 AC 24 CP sl7S 52 AD 53M review 23 M new promise 28 M admit debt SCP acknowledge 38 CP 19 AC 419, S82 68 465 630 374 499 690 160 90 408 800 819 74 217 102 4I4c 267n 272n 274 218 218n 220n 4 44n do 9 AD . construction 123AD 1 97 order aasigt a 17 8 667 67 104 200 damages sl7 8 672 a 137 NY 663 8S 6' 209 cap to use 3 18 8 85 39 AD estoppel 26 M 147AD revocation 103M 654 ■173 465 597 .379 102 506 418n 4^511 156 devise a 17 8 r 136 NY. construotion US AD 715 227 34 3l7S a 140 NY 641 366 532 205 392 59 intent sl8S 65 gift vesting 3 AD law remedy e45 AD 76 AD 8M vested remainder do 71 AD 351 24 M 176 construe will e 101 AD 124 115 AD 24 authority 123 AD 139 express trust 195 NY 100 no action' 4 69 M jurisdiction 88 M. legal title 1G3M 346, 1 65 certiorari 8 17 8 655 26 M 42 HI exr. oommission e 46 M 393 16AC 41Sn 1 69adv.po8seBsn 224 partition s 17 S 572 s 89 361 229 stock note 8 17 8 737 9 74 617 147 NY 694 235partnership s 17 8 805 ♦ 133 NY 671 s28NC 36 24 1 sp prfmance 8 17 8 821 r 135 NY 590 247 leave to sue fl 17 i? • 760 16AC 295n 254 prob. cause slSS 215 5M 554 263 aaseaament 8l7S m 138 NY 23 AD 1 75 appeal a 17 8 36 AD 681 26 11 644 638 1 79 survivor ,„,8l78 678 iS 82 474 ex elusion 27 M 352 128 425 347 82 construction 8 17 8 85S a 136 NY 645 1 86 signals oros- aings sl7S . 652 r 135 NY 583 a 74 32 107 AD 344 'luestion law 109 AD 627 HO AD 595 1 88 disqualify 69 M 25 190 sever action s 17S GoO d 74M 482 severance 89 M 537 195 contempt 8l7S 649 362 8b6 297 extr allow- ance 178 789 68 AD 140 300 damages e 17 8 765 r 137 NY 596 306misdemnor s 18 8 25 » 139 NY 32 3 1 5 Buap'n p alienation 3 17 8 829 a 135 NY 650 320 mandamus I 18 8 63 a 133 NY 673 31 AD 73 6 AG 66 360 9 AG 492n e 159 NY 259 324 carriers 8 17 8 a 137 NY e 137 NY requests 166 NY limit liability e 91 AD 444 47 M , 644 notice 26 M 390 queation j ury 855 699 464 124 251 485 254 596 597 3 178 a 135 NY 75 forfeiture 40 AD contract 23 M .852 282 230 no AD 17 AG carriers 02 M 95 M. do 95 M fact question 136AD 333 neglig. per ee 136AD . 353 not personal 153 AD 524 burden bailor 153 AD 525 330 trademark ISS I 7M 462 8AC ' 64n 333 'urplusage 88 271 certiorari 17 S 903 65 15 232 79 613 19 AD 45 275 damages 8 81 8 50 a 138 NY 252 38 AD 315 280oharge realty sl7S 910 a 136 NY 106 e67 14 290 death claim 8 17 S 850 89 AD 96 excuse 30 M 320 verify petition 5 AC 260n 292 Stat limitns 9 18 S 22 AD 351 8 18 8 105 AD 71 M contract 111 AD f 161 8 recovery 117AD contract tort 38 CP 366 allegation 84 287 312 615 377 351 97 M 433 r,t lis itns 874 432 335 St. sl7 8 73 competent ev. 90 131 equitable suit 50 A.D 365 30 M 304 prospective 38 M 604 3 27 NG 289 repeal 10 AC 257n 258n 10 AC 259n 15 AC 142n lien realty UD AD 700 equitable action 39 CP 349 charge land 136AD 120 creditors Buit ABBEEVIATIONS: a ti, criticised ; 1, limited ; affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; e, explained ; o, overruled ; s, same<;ase ; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel cue ; q, qneitioned N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Hun Vols. 63, 64 138 AD 345 attachment s 17 S 913 a 137 NY 689 350 rental dam. 9 18 S 235 flSM 10 78 2 M 368 memoranda ev. 2 AC 306n ultra vires 13 AC 265n 2e9n 30 NC 12 )8 IBS ■■148 NY 352 disherison d 6^ s 18 S 309 66 444 tax franchise 611 690 420 qower removal 39CP 114 536co(lat attack case 6 Hiss 86 AD a 141 NY S7AD 660 67 323 363 correction Bl8S 7M 19 M 3AC 641 334 6 AC IZOAD 452 certiorari s 18S 504 271 a 138NT 582 169 460 limitations 106n s 18S 419 216 R29 367 jurisdiction slsS 267 66 237 204 NY 480 86 M 688 105M 257' unconstitutional 54 AD 631 place trial S AC 263n Supreme Court 67M 63 370 gen denial b18S 31S 13 M 634 375 impeachm't 8 18 S 270 62 AD 373 d 69 AD 468 380 flseimprsnt 8 18 S 290 SAD .419 389 "willful" B 18 S 282 21 M 743 removal trustee 67 M 469 sum. pro. 142 AD 104 a 140NY 634 473 jury questn IBS 480 45AD 311 33M 420 4871iable waste s IBS 37.6 59M 4B1 do 59M 482 presumption ,142AD 498 suffer waste 142AD 499 not liable 213NY 256 500 interested party s IBS 55' 74 39' injunction SO' 128 discontinuance 90AD 257 83 AD 205 order reference 80 AD 52 163 AD 77:i 505 jurisdiction B 18 S 674 e76 506 error cured 393 demurrer slBS 26S a 138 NY 209 76 AD 416 3M 328 127 6M 385 388 19 M 264 31 NC 138 400 amendment s 18 S 293 64 AD 661 1 AC 49a 20AC lOn 404 fact question a 18 S 297 e 34 AD 222 dSOM 1^6 408 cumul- ins. • IBS 287 16 AD 222 4 1 3 sureties 8 18 8 m 138 NY .4AD joinder 67 AD liability 76M 685 192 249 439 52 439 ratification Bl8S a 138 NY e73 I 6 AD 48 AD 62 AD 89 AD 600 614 464 170 540 236 72 609 4 54 I equit.y SlBS r 139 NY 626 461 550 demurrer sl8 S 646 p 24 AD 6. 24 M 390 SAC 110 553 infant contrt slSS ' 643 a 136 NY 626 13 AD 548 554 injunction SlBS 636 r 136 NY 46 557 penalties «]8S 632 a 142 N y 663 s 28NC 390 550 pld's vaiver a IB S 664 a 138 NY S32 75 372 plead defense s IBS el3M 14 M 509 draft 8l8S a 138 NY 632 219 317 646 494 5 J 2 mandamus s 18 S 601 r 136 NY 76 r2aNC 173 5 1 6 exceotions 8 18 S 486 87 AD 157 husb. and wife 156 AD 413 74 M 565 519 parties 8 IBS 391 135AD 859 incompetent 74M 565 52 1 deed execu- tion IBS 476 a 138 NY 318 s 28 NC ] 66 529 construction 499 644 262 88 440 8 IBS 79 AD e24M 141 M 24 CP remittitur 27 CP retrial 17 AC 341 76 SAC 136 S . no relief 86 M 604 210n 338 642 565traud. presen's. 9 IBS a 138 NY do 154 NY' 63l> 629 412 569 considerat'i' SlBS 541 67 AD 666 572 mechan, lien 8 18 S 576 17 M 361 575 trespass SlBS s87 S2BNC waiver 69 M 332 534 386 144 579 indictment s 18 S 467 14 AD , 307 24 M 646 111 AD 526 118AD 203 pidg. libel 39CP 86 587 jury question 8 IBS a 138 NY SAD co-servt neg 42 AD d79AD 112 AD master neg. S3M 609 663 616 127 369 821 124 595 estoppel s 18 S 406 r 136 NY 30 607 mtge. trust 8 18 S 334 a 143 NY 390 6 1 6 master neg, 682 664 396 8 IBS a 136 NY 163 NY liability 151nl98 AD 442 6 1 9 construction SlBS 680 a 133 NY 693 d 147 NY 572 221NY 97 624 receiver case23 sl7S 333 37 M 63 627 replevin case 2 19 S ■ 1007 613 666 20 case 6 beneficiary 17S r 136 NY" case 14 slander damage s 17 S 748 r 147 NY 697 628 illegal ev case 36 sl9S 673 44 AD 308 45 AD 259 629 jury questn case 7 9l7S 756 a 137 NY 560 s 28 NC 205 case 19 fr'd assignt. s 17 S 782 a 137 N1 567 e 66 AD 297 case 26 evidence sl7S a 144 NY 67 AD pleading 47 M allege waiver 70 AD 56 95 AD 87 must plead 39 CP 286 636 contracts case 2 s 18 S 429 149 AD 199 133 S 690 849 644 52 389 630 jurisdiction case S sl7S BB2 62 AD 95 case 29 review exception s IB S 80 e38M 142 63 1 sup. pro. case 8 SlBS 292 68 AD 319 case 15 pleading 8 17 S 927 s 28 NC 236 case IS merits s 18 S 87 11 AC , 109d 032 extra work case 29 s 18S 484 77M 101 634vacate jud ease 4 8 18 S 428 s 28 NC 97 case 5 leave to sue s IB S 396 s 28 AN 246 case B estoppel 8 18 S 475 47 AD 57 caee 5 interpleader 6th Dept SlBS 8 28NC 466 460 635 partition case 3 sl9S 419 a 149 NT 380 VOL.64 I trustee power 3 IBS a 138 NY 657 86 AD 251 23 M 219 45 M 649 improper discretion 95 M 37 I I power dispose sl8S ,711 12 AC 474d 26 sup. pro s 18 S 748 f 47 AD 643 27 presumption 8 IBS 700 139 NY 390412 19 S e 71 201 416 1 20 subscription m 136NY 662 sl9S 37 9M 425 129 AD 337 1 29 insur. policy a 136 NY 375 8 19 S 293 73 title land . 24 AD intention 34 M 8 28NC description 12 AC 69t iig 704 183 200n 134 easement •139 NY 390 412 Ul8S 704 3 28NC 190 inierest street 166 AD 570 41 opin not ev: 18 S 728 64 271 47 opinion ns s 22 M 728 436 50 transfer tax 3 136 NY 347 s 18 S 603 9 AC 113n 54 limitation ^ 18 S 571 9 AD 347 accured action 22 AD 622 59 title 3 IBS 3 74 63 guardian 9 IB S a 138 NY 65 ratification eg AD 727 562 616 333 62 619 72 accessory 8 19 S 114 62 AD 360 reverse error 113 AD 341 83 wife's neces- saries sl9S 110 75 521 presumption B8 61 92 • 370 107 AD 559 90 costs 8l9S 91 53 AD 320 8M 469 7 AC 162n 163n neceesiares 11 AC 86n 96 issues fact 8 19 S 103 a 138 NY 353 6 AC 271n I I I exam, record 1 86 tender a 143 NY 605 s IS S 1 37 agent's mis- tal^e SlBS 834 a 138 NY 642 70 491 147 abrogation sl8S 827 a 138 NY 674 66 589 illegal evidence 77 359 p85 74 contract parol do 13 AD 599 21 M 213 1 49 no bar e85 19 3l8S 801 hold over ISM 137 1 55 exr. power SlBS 830 36 AD 263 aurrog. jurisdn 59 AD 264 exr. allowance 67 AD 1 2 e&M 140 s 28 NC 370 10 AC lB7nl96n 10 AC lU8n jurisdiction 117AD 685 118 AD 329 87 M 52 allowance d57M 626 authority 126 AD 536 spl, contract 126 AD 638 exr. probate 131 225 ally's services 74M 541 I 63 bequest 8 18 S 820 1 M 444 e41M 306 1 67 certiorari r 135 NY 245 68 244 s 19 S 142 reduce assesst. e 7 M 300 I 7 1 bar limitn sigs 40 M 13 AC remit bail 13 AC 134 137 33 32n I 72 assumed risk 3 IB S 890 9M 401 I 75 Individ note a 19 S 136 a 139 NY 314 I 79 nuisance s 18 S 915 e S3 AD 16 117AD 590 1 AC 138n construction 19AC 397 885 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f. followed c, criticised ; 1, limited; e. explained; o, overruled: s, same case; do, r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case; q, questioned Vol. 64 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Hun 147 AD 367 194aeency a 139 NY 284 sl9 S 142 200abandnmt 8l9S ' 132 1 AC 316n 205 Stat. limitnB 275 defen8e.-j a 19-S 77. AD demurrer 77 AD sl9S 58 certiorari S,2 dismiss writ 73 AD special term 125 AD practice 176 AD 208 cosii. s 19S 1 AC 7 AC OS 675 417 277bequest trust a 135 NY 292 9 18S 913 48 M 433 281 surrender lease 8 18S - 80 AD 132AD 10 M 12 AC discretion f SBM 45 2gOE ."951' 209 breach dam, s 18 S • 907 84 AD 621 13 AC 202 2 1 7 foreclutfure r 133 NY 506 sigS 51 227 partnership r 138 NY sl9S s'28NC r30NC 369 151 288 213 245 title iiisur. do 6 AD 261 sl9S 1 replevin e 157 NY 308 equitable action 160 NY 182 •30 OP 196 249 coutrib. nee sl9S 194 el7M 680 69LRA 341n bank rules 43 M ' 13 14 AC 82i. sav. bank 4 69LRA 318n care 69LRA 319d bank neg. 69LRA 332n bank not liable 65M ■ 469 31i 909 338 89 (155 443 140 284 surviving ptnrtner 3 19 8 149 i AC y07n 288 Stat frauds a 144 N y 635 -19S 87 293 contract fraud 32 AD dl9S e3 M : 143 NY 429 298 ratification s 19 U 252 a 138 NY 631 68 219 fraud £on version 369 limitations 68 AD 159 al9S 637 com. law rule 172 AD 742 373 scope em- ployment s 148 NY 369 78 626 s 19 S 821 375 tender fees 8 19 S 773 70 120 377 illog. con- traut a 142 NY 27 AD 37 AD 145 AD 166 AD sl9S 34 M no liability f 152AD strct. constrctn. 88 M 227 legal charge f 88 M 281 a 69 399 75 46 27 CP 269 204NY 287 adverse claim 19 AD 611 40 AD 479 24 M 7 2 AC 238n 29 CP 200 428 ipintly liable s 19 S' 640 17 M 153 rely on pleadins U AC 176n 434 liquidation 635 363 189 644 759 613 742 44 75 AD 11 AU e 110 AD 176AD n M uo authority d IJ5M 93 M diversion 140 AD justification r2M liability" d 103 AD p 84 M lorgery 220NY 178AD 338 446 639 846 167 535 546 221 500 447 262 estopp sl9S 99 AD waiver 154 S 75 593 106 308 will executo a 139 N V 223 s 18 S 923 23 M 558 28 CP 28 requirements 184AD : 3 1 7 surrog pwr 274 demurrable sl9S cl AD 55 AD 77 AD 119 AD 19 M c22M c32M 34 M 41 M SAC 9 AC 16AC 39 CP defna. 126 AD defense do 127 AD do 133AD strike out 62 M 69 M 47 223 534 313 315 480 401 281 164 52 573 469 469n 411 24ln 263 compt 6 343 364 a 19 S * 135 NY e71 AD depositions 39 CP provisions 175 AD 327 ballot sl9S ■ a 135 NY 64 67 79 66J 286 149 57 22 M 27 CP 5 1 3 costs sl9S 27 AD 6 AC e72M 689 424 gbO 357 380 defense 67 62fi 99M 119 not retroactive 69 571 21 M 275 hi eh way neg. 11 AD 510 notice 33 AD 469 42 AD 453 48 AD 435 i 19 S 637 construction 143 AD 756 384 ijijunction a 136 NY 169 r 154 US 256 i 19 S 565 39 1 spec, damag a 133 NY SO _18S deposits 67M atty. general do 164 AD 868 444 contempt a 135 NY 638 s 19 S 643 453 jurisdiction a 142 NY 630 8 19 S 877 458jury question 8 19 S 776 74 136 79 132 463 neg. liable s 19 S 644 dol2M 616 damages 28 M 142 467 damages r 140 NY 27 AD sl9S 19 M 43 AD 84 AD nl9S 33 M 36 M ISAC 608 311 784 623 244 179n 394 limitation a 140 NY 9 AD party action do 9 AD <19S ellM 409 351 360 623 321 297 613 380 364 173 346 perjury '135NY63S639 sl9S 331 348 extradition a 135 NY 71 sl9S 398 relationship basis privity 92 268 8 19 S 885 st. limitiation 2 M 341 342 consideration 3 AC 28 408 mandamus 70 310 788 683 463 630 13611 X12 5l5Ufeinsurance 8 ISS 41 r 136 NV 60 522 ordei app'l 8 19 S 626 SI 402 9 AD 242 25 AD 342 service' summon 16 M 645 jurisdiction 122AD 2S£ 526 right liable 19 S bSl 17 AC 128n limit duty 80 M 56- 534 judgment 8 19 tj 432 73 323 beneficiary 41 M 189 540 limitations 8 19 S 487 70 AD 180 misjoindea* 14 AC 61n 547 assesst roll 19 B 531 d23M 319 550oo. court pwr 8 19 S 521 176 NY 107 AD 111 f 45M 77 48M . 487 custody child 70M 586 requirements 103M 644 594 right privacy s 19S 264 s 70 598 e 64AD 38 39 e 64AD 40 6M 291 171NY 551 552 600 contract do 73 AD 573 878 74 AD 487 11 AC 246n 247n 11 AC costs case 30 s 19S a 138NY 64 s 17AD B 3 4 AD t2AD 13AD 48 AD 56 AD 64 AD 77 AD 77 AD 105 AD 18 M 16 AC 332 675 589 312 611 443 416 387 319 320 695 25 26 462 336 522 285n parol contract 23 M e26M 31 M 37 M 49 M 8 29NC SAC e 155 NY 717 261 639 380 79 19 633 680 47 1 curative laws 3 19 S 488 208 assesst notice 34 M 722 order nullity 124AD 1)7 due process S5M 43S 476 neglig. St e 70 AD 366 s 19 B 406 478 file aesignt e 20 AD 487 s 19 S 49S 483 misconduct e 37 AD 10 s 19 S 483 elOM 441 r 141 NY 187 NY 24 AD 3 19S e30M substitution 137AD 264 330 7 589 768 565 485 insurance a 138 NY 446 9 19 S 504 490 will construe 170 dSAD sig S 553 assessment 19 S 628 64 647 560 discovery 139 NY 652 _ 19 S 340 3 28 NC 463 41 M 620 book entries 2 AC 312n g AG 14Sn 572 ev. books s 19 S 260 31 AD 430 61 AD 491 13 U 835 7 AC 477n 479n incompetent 71 M 642 f 87 M 191 87 M 192 specific perfmce. 27 AD 48 AD do 5S AD 39 M 41 M 166 NY 178 NY 186 NY do 186 NY adoption 18AC contract 127 AD restraint 1G3M enforcement 186AD 177 384 162 217 650 269 40 184 198 112 98 642 300 254 sl9S 899 10 AC 67n case 19 sl9S 33 132 S 571 636 damages case 28 a 138 Nl'' 644 sl9S 833 637 defect alk sl9S 459 case 17 e64AD 60 638 new ev aeg easels e 73 AD 493 639 inher tax sl9 S 446 sase 1 S19S 292 e3M 163 a ppeal a 138 NY 868 sl9S 13 s30NC 31 S (objections 3 19 S 321 e76 3(2 383 9 76 " 368 d29NC 75 wills case 21 sl9S 315 73 M 486 607 injunction s 19 S 278 59 AD 142 67 AD 6 14 AC 157d 6 1 5 fraud intent r 138 NY 19 S 66 rSONC 496stat. limit'ns 4 \ 7 revision 69 539's 19 S 614 judicial 369 652 554 75 356 ballotn a 133 NY 31 AD 9l9S 271 493 447 302 105 AD judgment 116AD 135 641 424 interpleader sl9S 791 576 remainders a 140NY 516 19 AD 278 597 1 8 ISS 424 2001 433 al9S I 141 NY 499 release sl9S 93 AD reservations 173 NY 522 409 533 681 463 5 1 negligence sl9S d71 8 72 18 AD ol8M 417 581 639 425 457 S06 585 spec perfm a ISS s29NG 34 AD e43 AD 55 AD 59 AD 71 AD 84 AD ISM 23 M 41 M 7 AC SAC 166 NY incompetent 170NY consideration 335 38 611 415 320 623 220 508 522 719 651 38n 331 270 ev. 557 435 J62 447 '-46 624 judgt costs 19 S 319 1 AC 290n 627 laches Bl9S 44 M 268 271 632 malpractice 18S case 6 a 136 NY 815 1 202 835sp prfmance 59 507 162 290n full disclosure 140 AD 528 revoke will case 22 sl9S 13 al9S case 5 8 68 a 46 AD 1 AC ABBREVrSTIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; c, criticised; I, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel ease; a, questioned N. T. Supreme Court Reports— Hun Vol. 65 VOL. 65 5 damages • 19 8 86 AD 600 356 Sapeo prfmance ■ 19 S 880 a 143 NY . 630 I I extend time ■ 19 8 630 7 AC 175n fee of referee 10 AC 291ii 17 AC 61n 1 4 injunotion • 19 8 (79 1 7 lex fori ■ 19 8 67 AD 20 26 CP 723 613 878 428 foreclosure 197NY 41 persnl. property 146AD 716 131 S 443 141 authority s 19 S 944 a 136 NY 279 a 49 M 405 14 AC 136n 1 45 intention s 20 8 12 a 136 NY 52 88 AD 118 1 55lwauli8B due B 20 8 30 a 136 NY 2 44 1 59 will money 223 b20S a 136 NY proceeds 140 AS 605 4S1 21 foreoloBure • 19 8 a 138 NY 27 sureties sl9 8 a 136 NY 56 AD 694 384 457 32 annoyance s 19 S 603 a 140 NY 207 d 79 482 conseq damases 26 M 497 complaint f 158 AD 727 37 verify ans, s 19 S 745 d 87 M 419 39 construction s 19 8 627 a 142 NY 636 S3 AD 39 43 Stat limitatn' B19S 728 30 AD 18C notice 52M 100 53M 557 demand necessT 200 NY 353 57 ameiidment 8l9S 618 74 376 81 183 ■ 90 376 387 44H 474 7 AC 493n 14 AC 71n 77 arflon intent a 19 S 865 a 137 NY 68 99 construe will 8 19 8 e40M 47 M 890 474 671 conversion 144 AD validity 77 M 449 305 ?r?£°" 307 24 204 394 6 1 sabbatli breaking; 20 8 9 a 140 NY 214 legis. power do 127 AD 359 public sports 58 K 646 I 63 valid enact- ment 8 20 8 19 e 14 M 339 e 46 M 461 non essential 67 M 384 knowingly ISoAD 774 1 66 law question 8 20 S 27 m 136 NY 405 13 AD 380 1 69 mandamus 8 20 S 21 19 AD 570 preference 63 AD 247 1 79 picketing B 19 S 992 a 137 NY 565 e 67 306 contempt 192 NY 390 jurisdiction 195NY 445 review 208 NY 439 1 82 assignment s 19 8 956 a 138 NY 648 1 84 partitions 8 19 8 941 a 152 NY 104 1 87 cert, check 8 19 8 14 AC revocation f 93 M 203 estoppel s 20 8 146 a 167 NY 603 208 allegations s 20 S 327 76 AD 406 quo. warranto 76 AD 408 law action 177 NY 506 2 1 2pa8sive trust B 20 8 143 99 AD 697 f 161 AD 843 2l5iDcompt. ev, 8 20 8 140 e 79 AD 315 225 waiver s 20 8 285 13 AC 162n 227 injunction 8 20 8 281 6 AD.. 275 conso'idat'n act 44 M 133 176 NY 35 236 apportion.- raent act B 20 8 293 a 135 NY 473 384 trust 3 20S a 139 NY 252 taxforeig corporation - 8 20S al38NY 22 AD 27 AD B29 NC 5 AC 287 I 284 456 85 280 392 mis-trial H 20 8 209 a 142 NY 130 400 partnership creditor 8 20 8 214 39 AD 88 407 vendee title 20 8 183 107 AD 41 4 1 4 certiorari 8 20 8 165 74 88 33AD 280 49 AD 5 52AD 623 420 amendment 8 20 8 187 s 73 473 charge error 9M 362 17 AC 192d justifiable 17 AC 77n 432jury question s 20 S 359 88 281 actual notice 37 AD 317 172 AD 44 434 "otherwise'' 975 451n 97 191 bar s 20 S 28 65 AD 93 joint tort feasors eS5AD ,94 one satisfaction I 1 2 annoyance , , _„ ^ _ sl9S 793 lo*AD a 139 NY 548 ,„, 79 482 194 lease s20S 136 "•aoney"' a 141 NY s 19 S 973 s 29 NC 48 M 2S0 repaying 49 M 409 d 77M 14 178 658 100 533 263 apportionmt s 20 8 97 m 136 NY 473 65 240 e 261 300 mandamus 20 8 1 4« AD 3R9 50 AD 100 307 fire insur <20S 216 a 143 NY 311 1 4 AC 338n 321 conclusive B 20 S 233 a 144 NY flfi 2M 365 337 filing mtge. s 20 8 1 77 1 AC 89n 342.bank int 9 20 8 171 r 139 NY 614 349 legal ev. 3 20 S 278 96 AD 58 354 burden deft a 20 8 247 33 M 484 36 1 primaf. ev. s 20 S 232 efi2AD 571 juriad'n judgr. 6 AC 202n 203n 362 jurisdiction s 20 8 232 33 M 691 365 mal. proBecu 3 20S 213 84 AD n 178AD 954 49 M 318 179 185 384 658 613 472 34: 364 154 201 s20 8 83 AD 165 AD. collusion 170 AD 4,\ 437 good title s 20 S 352 rl41 NY 499 452 atty's lien s20 S 343 d34M 622 8 29 NC 252 enforcement 8 AC 77n 90n 454 alimony B 20 8 339 a 142 NY 625 7 AC 248n 457 reservation B 20 S 34'' a 142 NY 371 460 city bonds » 20 8 396 a 136 NY 221 464 legis. power 448 566 374 9 370 371 b20S d71 f75 objctions d8S 88 tender accept'ce 15 M 220 el48 NY 293 494 assessment 8 20 8 596 al43 NY 669 660 e 98 AD 642 502 rr farm crossings 9 20 S 458 a 142 NY 173 508 sales waiver 8 20 8 388 33 AD 274 intent 143 AD 329 5 1 2 conversion s 20 S 683 a 142 NY 570 82 392 5 1 6 compensBt'n a20S 600 a 143 NY 133 71 533 legislative power 24 AD 366 do 24 AD 374 9 20 8 •■4AD 24 AD 52 AD f 87 M 87 M injunction 151 AD 04 47npossn. notice 9 20S 392 15 AC 365n 478 publication 9 20 8 85 9 AD retrial 17 AC 486 waiver 20 S dnllSAD 158 AD 394 .'187 382 3.86 345 314 489 jurisdiction 9 20 S 39; 1 6 AD 628 I do 179AD 922 stipulation 62 AD consent 36 M 44 M 31 CP 68 M 268 64 85 77 425 49 1 ratification 107 AD 519 sureties 9 20 8 50 AD 524 bequest 3 20 8 a 141 NY 411 679 68 529 oBer judm't 3 20 S 527 AD 400 532 possession 9 20 8 661 r 142 NY 176 n70 36 538 costs discre- tion 3 20 S 673 83 413 fl9M 232 543 plead, suff. s 205 516 76M 225 proof 185AD 760 553 evidence s 20 S 477 1 24AD 526 55^. jurisdictn. s 20 S 514 156 AD 324 557 3 20S 38 AD e3M II M 13 M e25M s29Nr 112 AD agreement 55 M plaintiff show 157 AD 865 commisB'ns 547 91 423 376 501 512 Sfifi 277 546 562 dower s 20 S 571 e 65 AD 304 8 AC 336 construction 196NY 181 not apply 161 AD 522 567 judg'mt ev. 8 20 S 608 a 141 NY 352 61 AD 176 573 negligence B 20 S 623 76 292 26 AD 491 96 AD 176 124AD 73 31 M 641 jury question 266 387 100 474 30 664 98 AD liability 217 NY 18 IAD 585 trust 3 20 8 r 140 NY 9 141 NY 591 contract s 20 8 491 r 141 NY 414 598 mandatory s 20 S 570 2 AC 47n submission do 214 NY 148 601 attachment B 20 S 666 70 « 76 14 337 allegatfn alterna- tive e 32 AD 3 e 39 AD 20 6 AC 41n grounds stated 18 M 360 2 AC 160n 143 NY 354 606 void transn. 3 20 8 495 17 AD 244 6 1 title tender 9 20 8 487 18AC 380n ,6.1 2 affidavit 1 20 8 60S 2 AC 60n 6 1 9 champerty 10 3 19 S 734 a 138 NY 643 a 29 NC 66 harmless error, case 24 3l9S 11 AC case 30 Inspection S19S 67 AD 746 36n 742 68 620 bill partic. case 5 19 S 733 69 AD 143 621 quantum meruit case 10 3 20 8 e69AD release case 25 9 19 8 e66 AD 26 403 622 appeal time case 10 9 20S 986 r 136 NY 211 r29NC 469 623 order case 17 »218 477 71 614 625jury question case 7 9 20 8 346 e70AD 389 169 NY 127 pers mjury case 11 8 20 8 «»() a 148 NY 125 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed- n note- c, criticised; 1, limited; e. explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, dissentinz opinion: n. parallel case; q, questioned Vol. 66 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Hun VOL. 66 4 fr'd burden 8 20 S 822 85 41 pleading iK^ 289 34 AI) 479 1 AC 320 322n Btockhl'dr liabil- ity 147 NY 601 8 fr'd transfer « 20 S 810 r 142 NY 286 1 2 answer » 20 S 736 f 82 29fi judgt onpldg. 28 AD 295 amendment er. 44 AD 366 126 AD 434 f 217 NY 581 variance proof 19 M 427 2 1 deduction 8 20 S 797 a 137 NY 544 31 AD 317 144 NY 100 party aggrieved voidability 184 NY 163 trust honesty 57 M 392 gratuity" dSlM complaint d 164 AD 150 94 jurisdiction s 20 S 772 a 142 NY 189 J 31 NO 301 I I 8 exr acct'g s 20 S 824 139 NY 51 105 AD 18 fair value 65M: 215 I 22 tax'u corpn s 20 S 821 a 138 NY 158 I 25 compeneatn > 20 S 906 40 AD ?.0 extra allowaniie 54 AD 60 AD d92AD 101 AD 33 M specify error 66 AD full performnce do 143 S 129 28 reimbursem't B 21 S 10 43 AD 30 54 AD 7 AC 30 M 203 NY cost 132AI) 63M 33 frauds s20S r 142 NY 38 bill partic b20S 2, AC disclosure 76M 136 S 780 404 749 197n in 315 42 term fees s 20 S 733 734 10 AC 235n236n 103 AD 591 interest 51 M 155 48 prob. cause 8 20 S 740 a 149 NY 655 57 status judgt. B 20 S 746 98 M 424 64 indictment a 20 S 777 a 137 NY 569 69 227 intention 64 AD 455e 456 admissible 183AD 879 69 trusts 8 20 S 751 a 140 NY 116 75 ultra vires s 20 S 788 19 AD 164 S3 AD 250 28 AD 613 614 £ 160 AD 179 162 NY 454 consideration d 37 M 680 442 37 572 257 34 184 I 70 compromise 3 21 S 127 5 M 221 consideration 40 M 106 compensation 65M 294 do 66M 469 allegations 138 AD 503 1 73 injunction s21S 121 a 142 NY 633 compensation 13 AD 45 24 AD 628 25 AD 84 equity 94 M 353 indispensable 184AD 516 1 79 assessment s 21 S 147 r 144 NY 241 do 177 NY 217 189 injunction B 21 S 124 a 143 NY 673 194 court's p'wr 226 192 S9n guard, ad. lit. 63 M 184 fee spl. guardn. 19A0 92n additional costs 137 AD 457 five per cent 203 NY 258 award 168 AD 244 130 organic, tax s 21 S 48 a 138 NY 614 s 29 NC 233 1 33 verification s 21 S 55 20 AD 450 47 AD 269 14 AC 325n 136 complaints 3 21 S 81 88 AD 413 claim notice 12 AC 316n I 40 pere. liab. 3 20 S 971 a 148 NY 728 56 M 191 1 46 corp'n tax 3 21 S 7 e 74 109 prop, outside state 75 AD 166 prin. ofHce 69LRA 440n 1 49 privileged s 21 S 33 8 M 174 1 5 1 counsel fees 3 21 S 209 10 AC 203n 1 57 admissible s 20 S 968 175 AD 251 I 60 certiorari 3 21 S 34 9 36 AD 138 1 67 tax interest 3 21 S 79 a 138 NY 690 s21S 79 38 AD 4 IAD . 55 AD 97 AD 110 AD s21 S 60 AD 1 AC l99open s 21 S f 90 M decree 114 224 205 tenancy 21 S a 141 NY lease d 187NY 40 606 140 209 f'rd transfer s20S 938 rl41NY 144 2 1 4cbange grade 3 21 S 42 al42 NY 118 f70 600 d 114AD 328 220 fire insur. 121S a 142 NY e72 81 sion \D 184 NY recovery 35 AD estoppel 10 M waiver e 160 NY contract 128 AD 60 641 525 374 74 611 61 180 194 213 226deed mtge 8 AC 263n Supreme Court 67M 63 256 relief s21S SAC 168 319n 265 election s2lS 43AD el7M 278 coats 3 21S e83 279 316 679 154 406 7 AC 149n 150n 282jury question 159 549 438 619 29 460 595 288 coats B 20 S 904 11 AC 373n374D 291 liability s 20 S 920 66 AD 186 35 M 606 covenants 57M 470 297 beneficiary b20S ».143 NY distribution 190NY 302 election 8 21 S 933 662 62 245 180 3SAD 35 AD review appeal 17 AD .'i32 o 121AD 677 stat. construct'n 150 NY 247 306 public use 21 a 131 169 NY 81 el 84 NY 360 ricrht completp 151 AD 412 3 I I dower »20S a 144 NY 947 388 a20 S m 142 NY 230 liberally construe s20S r 141 NY' 74 H 74 87 M 233 costs 1218 RAD 91 AD 92 AD 16 AC 68 M 909 290 913 538 324 342 284 323 wharves s 21 S 277 si 42 NY 566 ) 69 614 329 conetructive eviction 8 21 8 296 142 NY 263 3 AC 78 33 1 demurrer 87 223 412 81 22n 427 236 legis, power 8 21S 116 55 AD 389 128 AD 704 place of trial • 21 S 26 M examination e33M «llpiration 37 M no cause 74M not prox. 74M 349 indoraer s21 S a 144 NY 73 f83 505 392 517 194 356duty commr. 3 21 S 290 68 M 287 362 intention 21 S 379 40 M 40 366ap prfmance s 21 S 1046 r 144 NY 152 412 229 619 377 authority s21S 503 r 148 NY 640 78 477 8 71 AD 462 38 1 good title o21S 493 a 142 NY 23 77 252 389 res judicata s 21 S 515 S2r 5(0 party s21 S • 14 AC 205 7 340 451 395 400 48 36 r 137 NY 67 B29NC f 29NC 401 bar b21S • 29NC 89 23 M court's power 88 AD 336 vacate order 64M 234 406 election 21 S b84 retraction 11 AC U AC 509 474 6n6n 7n8 422 mechanics b'en 218 8 82 f29AD 33 M 166 NY mistake d 98 M 400 19 630 73 303 428 trust 8 218 r 140 NY intention 103M 444 reform deed 336 524 135 170 218 a 142 NY S29NC 452 referee s21 8 c64AD 41 .'5 636 413 241 417 e87AD e93 AD el9M ao recovery 137 AD 693 authority 343 AD 452 procuring cause 152AD 757 492 remander s 2] S 404 r 142 NY 322 504 injunction 8-218 314 a 142 NY 621 38 M 515 lOOM 175 8 C 214n enforceable d 198NY 154-6 do 159 lOOM 176 damages do 198NY deft 39- 45n 5 1 5 implied warranty s 21 S 390 a 142 NY 681 14 AC 283d 522 sale stock s 21 S 552 16AC 176n S3 1 kidnapping 21 8 • 741 a 139 NY 87 538 sav bank 21 a 643 26 AD 77 543 payment 583 title poBsn. s 21 S 815 ILRANS 4S2n 588incompet ev. 3 21 S 831 83 405 in writing ■ 182AD 835 590 contract 3 21 8 859 139 NY 251 139 NY 110 595 conversion 218 a 193NY f66 218 77 546 waiver s218 a 142 NY 74 79 7 AD 734 423 664 3R2 16S 120 684 577 592 623 609 621 cause 624 458 loaa baggage 21 S 8 89 24 AD e39An s99 AD 335 mandamus s ?0 S 470 r 138 NY 96 341 mortgage 8 21 S 196 78 191 318 494 269 407 241 550 writ issue s 21 S 659 172 AD 436 554 stockholder 8 21 a 657 a 143 NY 672 557 order app'l s 21 8 683 do 91 AD 271 rnntmnt BP pro 185'NY 66 558 probate will 21 S 801 86 588 a 141 NY 553 testam. capacity 97 AD 211 retrial 17 AC 144n 145n 563 jurisdiction 465 mandamus 21 8 381 a 144 NY 685 41 M 292 469 parttaership 8 21 8 633 a 142 NY 316 488 comznias'nB s 21 8 362 84 290 569 obatruction damages s 21 8 836 25 L KA 634 574 indictment s 21 S SIS r 137 NY 617 24 M 646 578 costs appeal b21S a 183 NY f82 fgo 25 AD (62 AD 853 655 614 254 438 623 871 646 635 600 cbage 8 21S 92 AD visible" 15 AC _ _ rule of evidence do 143 AD 371 604 construe wilt 582 lOOn S22S a 143 NY 8 66 d20AD 31 125 635 103 560 626 14 560 s21 S e77 23 CP 72 M 131 S show title 139 AD 838 32 418 278 60 841 6l9abutt'e owner 8208 a 142 NY e6AD s20S use highway 107 AD 622 77M 376 168 NY 234 e 158 NY 239 water mains 140 AD 211 urban easement 140 AD 212 diBtinction 140 AD 212 626 atty's lien case 19 a 147 NY 37 8 20 S 960 8 AC 94n 628 chat mtge. ease 11 218 46 AD negligence case 14 8 218 t74 case 30 title passing 3 20 S 976 r 147 NY 268 566 negligence .8 21 S 844 30 AD 414 81 AD 137 32 419 100 137 629 trust deed case 14 s 20 S 964 a 143 NY 6S1 630 illegal ev. case 22 s22 8 U19 ABBREVIATIONS; a, affirmed; d. distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note c. criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, dissenting ooinion: p. parallel case; g. Questioned N. Y. Supreme Court Eeports— Hun Vols. 66, 67 81 AD 384 e 100 AD 236 14 AC 53d inoomp. ev. do 118AD 140 AD prejndice 161 AD 905 »48 393 631 cancel mgt. 2nd dept. case 25 a 21 S 186 Bl48Ny 410 632 contract ease 16 s21S 47 AD covenant 6 47 AD coBerv't neg. case 21 » 21 S 17; a 149 NY 582 347 300 302 VOL. 67 I unauthorized a21 S r 144 NY 114 NY 5 surrogatv power r 137 NY <|21S r29NC 691 399 73 403 768 473 633 partition eaae23 8 21 S 563 a 142 NY 555 a 29 NO 467 634 bill partic. ease 7 ■ 2IS 66 AD 19 U eaaeO 30nd precd • 21S 37 M eaee 12 receiver s31S 66 AD eaec 15 accounting 8 22S a 147 NY 635 ins. policy ease 25 a 21 8 751 a 143 NY 167 636 entirety case 14 ■ 22 8 1120 8 148 NY 235 a 2 AC 40S amendment 342 604 479 232 365 543 599 1120 678 19A0 170 AD 448 612 9 wife income 8 21 S 746 79 269 alimony cred'r e 149 NY 526 creditor's suit 143 AD 435 f 3 powerf sale 8 21 8 685 65 AD 600 error court 199 NY 329 pel. procedg. 199 NY 332 jurisdiction 199 NY 340 21 occupn tax a 21 8 556 ILRANS S82n 29 party wall B 21 9 848 31 M 53 38 measure val. s 74 671 s 21 S 739 41 pub officer a 21-8 675 a 137 NY 610 51 212 service forn corp 2 AC 77n 13 AC 3g7n 44 final decision s 21 8 806 a 138 NY 635 70 11 34 AD 603 8 AC 4Sln 52 police power a 22 8 56 r 138 NY 410 private rights 73M 617 16 SOB 371 61 intent 228 7.23S 19 M 4 AC 26 CP show title 139 AD 455 jury trial 8 23£i 81 AD 458 tax a23S 59 AD so M 402 327 648 432 131 460 pwr. a24S a 144 NY r 169 US court 219 50 432 471 at will s 23S 397 179AD 476 verdict dir't a 23 S 460 do 4 AD 607 479 loss trunk s 23 S 415 e 81 475 84 638 reasonable time 27 AD 696 1 AC! 303n 482 nonsuit 8 23 S 432 92 148 negligence 17 M 166 484 open decree a23S a 140 NY 8 82 HAD 55 AD 1 AC 726 421 420 354 127 306n 711 598 203 236 841 507 damages oompetentev 28 AD 68 a 23 S 395 5 1 5jury question a 23 S 609 a 143 NY 670 5 1 9 jury trial s23S 704 a 142 NY 688 d 88 133 eq. eatoppel 22 M 401 5358chool purp B 249 5 du 134AD 173 539 estoppel s 23 S 1091 BM 297 54 1 iforeeloaure 8 23 S 941 a 143 NY 484 543 agent's authority s23S 22 M 25 M 55 M 116AD 8 crutiny 79 M 94S 547 176 279 834 563 546 eoBsiderat n s24S 13 8 AD 426 62 AD 248 27 M 271 560 .oonatitut'l a 23 S 942 77 122 judgment 46 AD 463 error appeal 51 M 73 specify errors 140 AD 97 estoppel 143 AD S82 no jurisdiction 157 S a66 554 mech'n lien s 23 S 1134 trust proceeds 6M 14 s 31 NC 86 578 mice valid B 24 a 21 r 143 NY 476 81 173 202 r 1 AC 81 reversal 186AD 478 584 oir dam act VOL 70 6 damages a 248 68 AD 8M a 141 NY s23S guardian 134 AD recovery £ 214 NY 588 lies s23S 31 NC losi right 147AD 596 Toting 238 42 M bailottB ILRANS 158 963 669 918 223d 232 964 6^2 S67n 601 drainage s23S 41 AD 944 623 608 appeal s24S a 141 NY r 142 NY do 69 AD 647 652 e 63 AD 373 6l3factquntios case 14 8 29 AD a 26B new trial 3 26 8 ise 28 86 86 1103 1130 480 6 1 4 appeal s23S ease 3 a 141 NY wharves case 6 8238 r 142 NY appeal caae 10 8 23 S 1146 378 614 6 1 5 distinction ease 6 8 23 S 19 d 61 AD 48 legacy dower e 5 M 217 489 error ev 8 23 8 410 89 428 33 AD 173 83 AD 4 21 CP 382 pleading proof 90 AD 6M 18 M variance 112 AD 185AD 1 M 924S 10 M 99 AD file liens 73 M 634 311 467 397 562 stockholder a 143 NY 511 8 23 S .965 565 construot'n 569 345 11 240 188 427 recovery proof 69 M 428 497 denial 8 23 8 67 AD 713 69 s23S 69 70 72 21 M 15 AC change 958 787 697 621 276 141n procedure 217 NY 240 legitimate 217 NY 246 573 agreement a 140 NY 641 373 374 370 684 19 483 239 13 threats s238 20U 1131 147 17 restrictions' a 23 8 1109 a 147 NY 712 f 163 AD 451 22 counter claim a 23 S 1119 • 33 M 432 137AD 236 23ii 9 AC 245d e249 26 converaion 27 CP 22B 27 injunction a 23 S 1065 r 144 NY 21 37 negligenaa „„ a 23 8 llOO d46AD . , 61 assumed nak 112 AD 820 4 1 Stat, limit'na 8 23 8 1081 r 144 NY 498 44 oond. aala a 23 8 1073 10 AC 226d 46 pars, injuries a 23 U 1074 4 AC 21 2n 99 admiaaions a 23 e 1076 35 AD 641 04 dtat'n delay a 23 S 1127 82 M 420 e 46 H 230 eoDStructibn 60 M 629 1 1 1 perjury a 248 140 NY 92 dl64AD I22andueinfl. a 248 71 iU 464 1 3 1 aum. pro. s24 8 64 20 M 626 demand rent 21 M 480 23 M 466 680 eonoluaive 33 M 387 149AD 561 waiver 46 M waive objna. 18AC 437n 8 a4S f87M 1 42 license ■ 24 8 a 141 NY defense 67M SI return • 23 8 118AD 1094 610 63 Sling mtge, 8 23 8 1079 a 143 NY 668 1 AC - 87n 56 aaaignraent 8 23 8 1092 a 144 NY 271 a 1 AC 144 146 4 AC 114n debts 205NY 142 59 discretion 6 1 7 eosta case 3 8 23 8 1147 8 168 NY 561 063 91 163 51 377 208 668 640 319 664 368 447n 8238 77 81 92 9 AD 40 AD S2AD 101 AD 17 M SAC 16AC 61 diamiaaal a 23 8 1104 83 160 claim intereai 26 AD 270 sp'l proceeding 39 AD . 92 atat limitations 16 M 660 e 22 M 493 26 CP 17 90 counter claim s 23 S 1124 8 M 151 95 court's power a 23 8 1083 25 AD . 496 surplus money 36 M 363 197 impeachmt 8 24 S 290 17 M 238 defenae fraud 6 AC 206n 200 life ineur 8 24 8 a 141 NY 8 24 8 32 M 194 484 359 123 202 forecloaure a 24 8 a 144 NY a 12 AD 8 ion a 24 8 f91 24 AD 78 AD IIU 257 1 35 may waive 408 14 433 1 45 atatutea ev a 24 8 176 29 AD 399 anawer 28 CP 266 preaumption 18AC lOn, lln 1 49 partnerahip 8 24 8 277 a 70 1S4 new trial costs 8 AC 394n 3g6n 52 certificate a 24 S 406 a 143 NY 659 1 74 495 authority inquiry e75 67 78 402 1 65 aale buainesi 269 689 266 156 147 182 545 474 208 diamiaaal 1 643 23 375 378 308 2 1 I paym't loan s 24 S 167 a 144 NY 702 216 dismissal a 24 S 164 a 139 NY 6S7 01 658 lis AD 192n 222 performance proof 8 24 8 170 a 144 NY eS6 163 NY 326 harmless error 11 AC aSn 239 constitutnl a 24 8 600 a 141 NY 129 79 583 243 habeas Corp. a 24 8 780 246 prom, note . 428 672 a 24 8 a 141 NY limitation 56M 202 662 574 24 8 a 143 NY 250 per. s24S a 778 a 81 parti ea elOAD 4 AC security 132AD negligence do 138AD 265 tender 3-24 8 56 M 1 64 busineaa names B 24 8 273 a 141 NY 660 1 AC 378n 1 75 prom, note a 24 8 271 16 M 613 1 78 real estate a 24 8 412 a 140 NY 162 eS9 530 1 8 1 negligence a ^4 S 43 a 6 AD 360 a 11 AD 142 el3M 315 1 86 sp prfmnce s 24 8 292 a 144 NY 426 injury 296 242 441 348 778 city 8 46 444 267 legal title 8 24 8 29 89 AD 404 power by will d 9 M 320 31 M 201 34 M 209 36 U 87 56 M 204 trust e39U 413 appointment 127 AD 659 273 bequest vesting 8 24 8 226 a 144 NY 622 27 M 261 296 pleading 8 24 8 149 13 AC 163n defense 179AD .304 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note: c, criticised: 1, limited; e, explained: o, overruled; s, same case; do, dipslnting opinion; p, parallel case; q, questionea JN. Y. Supreme uourt Reports — Han Vols. 70, 71 3l7aollateral at taok 8 24S 89 59 AD 69 AD trustee e33M 42 M trust 144 AD 437 539 S13 517 270 585 142 334 damages 48 605 217 297 a24S a 14INY 3-62 AD liability 170 AD do 170 AD 301 345 preEtentation praetice s 24 S 265 115 AD 302 proper party C4M 459 348 attachment 79 622 clerical errors 225NY 328 387 damasea 9 24 S 32 gH 669 397 residence 3 24 S 63 47 M 228 399 personalty a 24 S 70 8 AD 571 62 AD 126 24 M 474 40 1 chge. venue 814 116 447 346 a24S a 143 NY affidavits 77 84 remedy SAD resumption lAC Code Civ. Pro 2 AC 361n jurisdietioB 4 AC 248d new trial 37 CP 366 35 1 dedication 3 24 S 37 14 AC 271n 357 foreign exr. B 24S 19n 52 AD 56 4 AC 361 joinder s 24 S 231 r 139 NY 468 5 AC 390n 366 new note of issue a 24 S 67 e 31 AD 139 e 25 M 352 26 201 433 notice of trial 41 M 126 8 AC 104n 105n 28CP 20 344 superseding 127 AD 809 369 admission s 24 S 178 I AC 267n denials 16AC 241n 374 fee damages s 24 S 422 e 12 M 347 377 covenant a 24 S ~ 179 a 144 NY 633 382on the merits B 34 S 375 6 92 83 162 AD 3 80 M court's power 72 AD 437 79 AD 564 do 166 AD 339 II AC . lOen 112 non-suit 148AD 18 s24S f73 affidavits eSl 83 eoAD SAD SAD e2SAD 2SAD 62 AD SAC 278 255 79 34 112 557 149 616 13 158 ISln 479 title dispute i 24 S 145 a 147 NY 704 3 AC 140d 490 insur policy 3 24 S 384 a 147 NY 478 495 negligence a 24 S 381 57 AD 241 498 lien surplus s 24 S 461 13 AC 142n 507 corpn tax 3 24 S 208 70 599 74 110 burden proof 82 317 advances 16AC decision 130 AD 557 ripanan rights a24S a 42 AD damages 184AD 516 565 gift interest s 42 S 267 41 AD 417 gift c. mortis 68LRA 128 568 contract 24 S 93 AD 41 M 4 AC dismissal f87M 85o 403 discovery s 24 S 215 6 AC 269D 405 agt's power s 24 S 430 t 80 219 227 4 1 5 law remedy 460 254 218 618 s24S a 147 NY 84 l7AD 333 512 stat limit'n a 24 S 369 r 144 NY 104 1 AD 125 90 AD 490 40 M 59e 61 5 1 5 strike out 96 AD 400 r 24 S 129 45 M 600 5 I 7 place trial 428 ejectment s 24 S 337 a 149 NY 587 432 default 243 134AD 439 notice 8 24 8 ISM 301 573 3 24S 5 AD 15 AD afSdavits e 26 AD 29 M 131 55 937 116 657 193 411 280 463 42 107n 150 376 16 530 safe appli- sance a 24 S 403 a 142 NY 639 72 406 80 418 420 3 AD 585 163 AD 212 aasumed risk 57 1 trust Co. 3 24 S 212 a 144 NY 652 575 life insur. 9 24 S 306 77 556 indef. contract 62 AD 121 contract vd. 132AD 492 583 chge. grade s 24 S 234 a 140 NY 637 t 1 AD 129 130 attorneys 94 M 137 589 notice defect s 24 S 182 f 21 AI 633 83 AD 663 585 12 AC 31Sn e 142 NY 347 compliance q 165 AD 735 593 demurrer s 24 S 1S6 1 AC 267ii VOL. 71 decision S24S a 140 NY 49 AD e57 AD e47M 9 AC 294b 296 2 sureties s24S 145 NY lAC 783 639 378 244 96 e83AD vesting 92 AD 39 M 4 libel s24S a 1400 NY amend 19A0 784 217 242 499 73 answer 304n 1 1 oonteoapt s 24S 546 172 AD 44 64M 617 d 67M 98 on merits 160 AD 670 preinature 164 AD 795 1 3 life estate 9 24 S 577 e 162 NY 144 24 assumed risk a 24 S 616 a 142 NY 631 25 service notice 445 guaranty s 24 S 258 r 143 NY 495 449 1 a24S r 145 NY dam 401 ■427 453 ejectment a 24 S 388 d 70 459 456 negligence s 24 S 501 a 77 36 472 new consid'n s 24 S 379 46 AD 434 48 AD 669 promise valid 56 M 529 472 covenant a 24 S 42 83 AD 486 duty landlord 8 87 AD 155 liability 129 AD 89 475 valid trust 4 AD 33 AD 65 AD 13 M contnb. 2 AC 115AD error court 19AC inspection 143 AD 536 discovery 24 S m 141 NY 87 AD 180 NY claim suit 2 AC executed .1 211 NT 284 179 529 209 37n 205 219 428 400 lig. 179n 590 211 904 233 584 361 316 521 414 580 5 24 8 e50AD do 74 AD HI AD 11 M q 15M 96 M 7 AC 168n 159 7 AC 158 nl59n e 11 AC 268 25 CP 195 proper party 64H 459 party to act. 66M - 227 depositions 151AD 721 545 sureties s 24 S 372 f 70 599 fees town charge 28 Ad 479 547 review limit, a 24 S 339 • 30 AD 4 8 24 8 87 jurisdiction 88 AD rovers, error 115AD complaint 87 M 597 weight of ev case 4 s25S 73 AD boundary, case 21 25 S a 144 NY f 54 AD 100 AD 1131 422 163 62 598 damages case 5 s24S 3 24 8 3 87 injunction case 15 3 24 8 r 147 NY «30NC 215 1142 347 599 chat. mtge. case 6 s24E> s70 376 594 413 735 210 282 43 503 27 probate will 3 24 8 609 a 141 NY 384 30 right of way 8 24 S 613 r 150 NY 139 37 water rents s 24 S 806 a 152 NY 327 ,42 minority stockholders a24S 614 a 147 NY 3 ' 241 3 AC 368n 66 quan meruit 3 24 S 497 a 161 NY 111 34 M 660 68 commissions a 24 8 580 a 144 NY 636 78 174 certif. performnce 48 M 146 72 aource inform 8 24 S 591 2 AC 364n 77diatribution s 24 8 586 24 574 exclusion 27 M 352 84 certiorari s24 S 629 a 140 NY 1 91 ejectment 24 8 . 526 a 141 NY 395 15 AC 277 94 ejectment a 24 8 583 a 151 NY 463 97 mandamus a 24 8 563 r 142 NY 271 101 injunction a 24 8 801 r 144 NY 462 d 10 M 583 lOScontrib. neg. 142 ausp'n alienation 9 25 8 r 141 NY 1 44 city neg. a 24 8 _ 143 NY ministerial 141 AD 523 670 678 537 262 1 46 suicide 8 24 8 3 78 defense burden 21 AD 125 r 149 NY 48 cause death 68LRA 294 149 B'd health 3 24 8 626 a 140 NY 12 I 53 ripariao right's !23S 27 m 144 NY 975 30 NC 88 164 obstructns 8 24 8 748 m 144 NY 453 I 76 accountins . 24 S 1128 a 147 NY 710 I 79 removal s24 8 i 144 NY 35 AD crOBSinga 171 NY 3 24 8 a 144 NY for jury 155 AD 45 scrutiny a 24 8 166 NY , 47 libel 3 24 8 43 M 135AD 679 67 609 23 32 49 deed descrip- tion s 24 8 533 a 143 NY 679 180 NY 366 5 1 publication s 245 596 20AC 223n 56 devise realty 8,24 8 610 a 140 NY 337 59 dredging s 24 8 644 a 144 NY 660 perfomt work 220 NY 384 603 653 560 1 09 not liable s 24 S 603 80 M 249 bar action f 170 AD 786 170 AD 787 I 1 2 assignee costs 3 24 8 621 a 139 NY 482 1 AC 2SRn 175 AD 397 I 17 land under water 629 140 467 8 24 8 d78 f 90 M title f 90 M 1 23 green goods 8 24 8 519 r 140 NY 130 1 27 assumed risk a 24 8 533 a 144 NY 649 5M 324 |33confeasion a 24 8 521 37 CP 145 668 446 613 958 I 82 privleged a 24 8 621 73 AD 347 14 AC 237n 1 84 cheek trustee a 23 8 2111168 r 141 NY 100 a 141 NY 563 1 88 mandamua a 24 8 532 37 AD 143 152 NY 364 1 94 meaa dam. a 24 8 567 6M 208 6 AC 178n 1 97 mech'n lien i 24 S 601 79 210 87 91 pending no bar 23 AD 358 13 AC 159n foreclosure 75M 333 cumulative 152AD 641 199 insurance s 248 507 141NY 219 obligations do 140 AD S6S mortgager's int. 145 AD 726 no recovery do 145 AD 62 trust s24B 540 1 1 37breach prom, s 24 8 531 a 151 NY 727 202 mandamus a 24 8 754 a 142 NY 113 enforcement 20 AC 293n 207 foreclosure 643|s24S 525 a 144 NY 654 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; «, criticised ; U limited; e. explained; o, overruled: ■. same case; do» dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, questioned Vols. 71, 72 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — nun 2 1 1 >t>y eoBta • 24 S 618 7 AG 2a8n 2e0n 66M 567 f 93 M 325 169 AD 419 2 1 Sjiiry queation • 34 S 805 80 493 216 bill of sale • 2fi S 222 r 149 NY 127 221 enfoTcemt. s 25S 219. do 1S6AD 466 227<)«rtif ev. s 24 S 991 r 140 NY 71 12 AD 102 presumption eaM 28 232 Bood'e dam a 24 S 1083 a 148 NY 7S8 T7 608 dsmaeea e 68 M 238 f 86 M 507 236 inspeotprs o{ eleotion a 24 S 1039 • 139 NY 446 d 6 AD 299 not party TOM 594 352 inaurance a 2S S 35 a 148 NY 726 356 gift 2.'>S a 161 NY 252 etatutory a26S 266 424 HAD 72 M . authority 35 M 457 recovery I 17AD 352 267 surpluaage a24 S 1074 105AD 287 contract t'^rt ■ 3S0P 366 260 corpn neg a 24 S 1014 d 13 AD 505 285 eaaement a 24 B 1097 a 147 NY 338 292 maater a 24 8 1072 53 M 124 295 pract looat a 24 8 997 a 144 NY 701 8 AC 167b party va^ia II AC 468n471n 309 mandamus a 26 S 60 a 147 NY 426 26 M 236 320 limitation s26S 120 r 146 NY 65 r 1 AC 197 327 prac. looatn ■ 24 8 1122 8 AC 165n 167d 34 1 juryqueation 435 breach prom 1 741 491 jurisdiction i26_ 38 AD 114 AD 92 M 16 670 361 injunction a 24 8 1137 HAD 561 363 set-o£E a 24 8 ' 1129 7 AC 261n 161 AD 523 367 rule damage a 26 8 24 e77 606 69 AD 311 371 stookholder s 26 8 19 s86 39 40 AD 691 696 1 AC 323n 381 referee 8 26 6 32 84 657 damage! 93 AD 336 112 AD 677 29 M 104 3 AC 4egn 47en 8 AC 4S2n Expenses f 112 AD 679 386 nom dama. a 24 8 1134 a 161 NY 641 4 AD 448 void convey 46M 39 4 aaaign polcy a26 S 25 a 149 NY 679 13AD 632 within atatute e 109 AD 380 wife'a Int. 17 AC 303 307n 402 oonatruct'n a 24 S 988 a 163 NY 399 a 11 AD 468 16 M 614 405 contract s 24 8 956 a 88 367 9 11 AD 396 107 AD 264 427 law remedy a :!4 8 1108 a. 46 NY 602 76 604 8AC 211n 431 obstruct street neg. a 24 8 977 f a 93 270 11 AD 277 16 AD 231 31 AD 371 e 43 AD 41 46 AD 130 a 46 AD 131 475 438 24 8 161 NY 442 agency b26S a 145 NY 981 508 11 602 449 juryqueation I 24 S 968 a 148 NY 750 86 470 41 AD 122 10 M 282 54 H 463 no negligence 178AD 929 453 incidental s 24 S 944 217 NY 247 457lformer' actn a24 8 986 13 AC . lein counterclaim 81 M 340 464 conatruetion a 24 8 959 e86 463 469 forerunners s 24 S 943 173 AD 498 472 unincorp. asaoo 24 8 971 35 M 142 478 ap. prfmnee a 24 8 1011 86 144 483 justice s 24 S 076 16 M 438 485 libelous a 24 S 1060 a 147 NY 624 179 N Y 164 22 M 670 492 undue inS s 24 S 1062 U AD 687 41 AD 156 no presumption e 46 AD 212 commissions 84 M 311 504 license s 24 S ' 1090 623 jury question 11 AC 419n 5 1 6 flooding s 24 8 1009 77 606 damages 69 AD. 311 5 1 9 court's powr a 24 8 1031 92 84 7 AD 71 84 AD 197 526 fact queation s 24 8 1087 36 husb. com Ian right elOM 610 34 M 631 2.AC 147n estoppel 14 AC 2l4n negligence d 348AD 72,1 632 cure error 9 24 8 1006 a 147 NY 520 61 AD 284 536 misjoinder b24S 1081 9 AD ■ 248 23 M 466 3 AC 299 several 85 M 248 fl48S 341 540 redeem coat a 24 8 1076 8a 67 68 7 AD 368 26 AD 632 36 AD 177 authority 69 AD 183 diaoretion appeal SAD 28 not recover e 92 M 11 equity court 218 NY 105 547 filing mtge. a 26 8 39 1 AC 80n 559 diaoret on a 26 8 134 86 118 573 findinga I 24 8 194 4 AD 448 review 26 AD 292 46 AD 280 577 contrib. neg a 24 8 1068 70 540 13 AC 426n 582ma!:ter neg S24S 1101 a 146 NY 610 d 11 AD 464 12 AD 669 1 16 M 223 593 Stat, lim'n a 6 8 525 al44 NY 517 90 AD 46 a 1 AC 20 598 juriadiotion a 24 8 1094 87 AD 64 91 AD 438 97 AD 140 34 M 196 54M 171 6 1 1 asseasment case 1 24 8 613 a f 87 617 6 1 3jury!qucstion caae 6 a 24 8 613 80 493 6 1 4 injunction caae 1 a 24 8 1144 a 147 NY 496 case 13 death claim a 24 S 1147 a 151 NY 94 case 18 conatruetion s24S 1146 a 147NY 894 6 1 5 fraud caae 3 a 24 S 1080 r 147 NY 411 VOL. 72 5 leas baggage s 25 8 678 a 149 NY 576 6M 638 limit toss do 184 NY 289 186 NY 158 charge error 186 NY 155 61 M 606 limitation 139 AD 22 binding 151 AD 554 1 8 foreign corpn* a 25 8 309 r 140 NY 576 1 AC 344n 26 revere, error a 25 8 664 120 AD 523 33 agency 3 26 8 a 147 NY agent &2M 666 393 362 39 truat eatate a 26 S 290 a 144 NY 669 43 covenant 1 25 8 293 t 65 AD 280 legal 55 M 86 injunction 61 M 132 134 lOOM 176 inj. relief 133AD 67 enforceable e 198NY 151 1B6 f 170 AD 762 lOOM 175 lOOM, 420 46 weight of ev ,25 8 666 77 643 5 1 ap. prfmnee • 26 8 601 r 147 NY 642 80 .676 covenant limited 93 AD 678 92 relief 3 24 8 a 149 NY 663 163 97 injunction 37 OP 67 98 explanation 9 26 8 306 a 160 NY 661 46 AD 444 parol evidence 13 M. 130 liability 151AD 744 105 representa'n 9 25 8 288 r 148 NY 129 1 09 valid trans. 9 25 8 . 402 a 150 NY 570 e 20 AD 76 not conclusive f 68 AD 280 I 1 3 conaiderat'n 9 25 S 305 9 30 NC 434 I AC 205n 1 1 9 estoppel 8 25 S 672 a 148 NY 18 M 520 646 26 deduct debt a 26 8 340 a 141 NY 196 81 24 138 damages s 26 8 363 46 AD 463 1 4 1 ins. policy 9 26 8 301 9 151 NY 123 s 83 612 t 29 AD 163 166 9 64 AD 388 ,33 66 AD 632 timely notice UM 619 1 47 good defnse; s 25 S 649 154 AD 517 1 50 ejectment s 26 8 676 a 148 NY 102 58 amendment s 25 8 401 a 148 NY ■ 39 60 diatributioD s 26 8 694 e 85 194 estoppel 55 AD 468 e66AD 669 460 further security a 29 M 273 1 64 open default a 26 8 380 6 AC 36n 1 66 indoraer s 26 8 389 25 AD 12 171 oountercl'm a 26 8 375 a 147 NY 718 104 AD 670 43 M 647 time contract 4 AC llSn rule f 115AD 344 offaet damage 129 AD 206 covenanta 130 AD 462 legal atatua 62 M 466 estoppel 195 NY 330 remedy 106 NY 330 rule waiver 158 AD 317 not recover 84 H 130 1 76 legal bar a 25 8 642 81 21 power of aale 1 AD 288 20 AD 169 22 M 586 co-tenanta 53M 511 gartltion 6M 693 61 M 186 194 ina. policy a 26 8 295 a 144 NY 703 197 eostrib. neg a 26 8 378 no bar 76 AD 66 ineompet. av. 13SAD 4M 205NY 60 199 pleading a 25 8 348 117AD 226 38 CP 167 202 flae represen s 25 8 36S 43 AD 14 profits 64M 115 2 1 I atty'a lien a 25 S 651 8 AC 03b 2 1 6 non-reaident alien deviaee s 25S 410 70 AD 288 14 AC 427n entire estate 73 M 439 ''purchase take" 91 AD 313 314 hold lands 70 M 414 22 1 waiver 5 25 S 361 18 M 206 225 partnership a 26 8 248 76 OS a 70 348 238 diatinction a 26 8 300 13 AD .367 26 AD 262 nuiaance damage 9M m 254 implied war- ranty a 26 S 570 a 78 616 136AD 712 263confcaajudt a 25 S 644 a 148 NY 739 272 co-truatee a 25 S 585 r 146 NY 462 do 110 AD 911 282 marine ina. s 263 414 a 147 NY 711 299 Burplua in- come " 26 8 1110 e 3 AD 282 e 3 AC 161 prove fact f 150AD 432 SOOopen default a 26 8 464 6 AC 36n 3 1 I remediea a 25 S 682 a 147 NY 124 84 *» a 2 AC 327 326 eq. relief 79 105 615 7 AD 386 demurrer 74 AD 63 8 82 AD 295 82 AD 303 do 82 AD 304 95 AD 190 limited liability d 168 NY 199 168 NY 204 210 pleading 57 M 137 ABBREVIATIONS: a, afarmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, e, criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; 0, overruled; a, aame case; do. reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed: n, note; dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; ^^ questioned N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Hun Vols. 72, 73 334 liability 8 25 S 432 206NY 63 deceit fraud 20AC 78n fraud sale 20AC 94n 344 bailee s lien ■ 25 S 6U0 10 AC 143d 348 stockholder 176AD 666 354 certiorari 8 25 S 776 a 142 NY 228 3 AD 108 370" waiver 8 25S 350 13 AC 18»n 372 bill psrtii:. 215 NY 68 407 contract a 25 S 337 r 148 NY 426 412 neg.damag 9 25 S 17£ a 145 NY 283 78 568 4 1 7 separate lien s 26 S 202 a 148 NY 596 14 M 523 422 public use 3 26 8 213 18 AD 678 425 discretion 503 legal ev. <■ 25 s lei a 148 NY 112 86 429 meaa. damages 126 AD 189 506 consideratn 26 S 212 a 146 NY 446 24 AD 261 9 2SS 71 AD„ 113 AD 161 AD 5 1 4 grounds »26B 5 AD affidavits 26 M 38 M SAC 519 ins s26S 9 AD 66 AD 114 AD 511^ 19AC 406 616 604 192 502 In 6 416 48 450 69 428 rescission i?l s 26 S 373' prom note s 25 S 447 a 149 NY 532 81 35 376acquieacence s26S a 148 NY 22 AD SXC 365 30 87 18 81 17 M 529 attys lien 627 667 306 291 151n policy 438 374 349 65M 330 correct error lOPNS 290 no relief 68 M . 13 598 court 8 power 8 25 S 88 body execution 85 AD 194 29 M 616 order arrest 183AD • 594 185AD 482 173S 4 6 AC 273 410 602'damage8 s 25 S 264 76 487 managing agt 200 623 355 231 380 constructive notice 8 26S r 150 NY 75 29 M law question 28 AD 83 384 legal bar 8 25 S 560 81 21 parties 50 AD 95 direction liable a25S s72 fraud 83 not a bar HAD 4 AC 91d92 94D pref-srence 39 M 423 431 contrib neg 8 25 S 151 a 151 NY 642 80 94 435 referee s 25 S 179 f 41 AD 617 bill particular 134AD 568 452 assignment s 25 S 225 s 31 NC 76 458unen£orcible s 25 S 297 98 M 346 462oouaterclaim 25 S 76 86 AD 98 AD bar 110 AD 114 AD SAC 28 CP 17 AD 66 AD 69 AD 78 AD 94 AD S31NC SAC proof e 160 NY 34 596 146 336 378 29 364 c>69n 426 392 guardian 8 25 S 693 * 141 NY 551 393 notice trial 8 25 S 3S7 52M 312 improper 91 M 120 no trial fee 91 M 120 394 destruction 431 413 s25S 112 AD judicially 151AD 415 395 parol assignt 8 25 S 565 17 M 137 403 jury ques- tion s 25 S 205 8 81 197 notice risk do 29. AD 626 contrib negHgnce ll2 AD 388 635 346 648 330 608 468 94n 310 78 k86 12 M 27 M 62M 92 M 27 CP 535 damages 8 26 S . 689 a 146 NY 152 54 1 contrib. neg. 8 26 S 445 a 156 NY 700 42 AD 477 e 96 AD 435 city negligence 15 AG 326n 545 pers. injury s 25 S 638 a 148 NY 727 552 neg. damage 25 S 85 7M 16M SAC conversion 171 NY 27 CP lien defense 157 AD 281 656 434 389 95n 240 233 432 26S a 146 NY d79 63 M 467 rules nee. 25S 276 20AC 143n 469 recoveries s 25S 229 203NY 521 471 negligence s 25 S 247 21 AD 327 151 NY 442 477 accid. ins. 230 596 630 384 558 183 33 298 406 479 721 409 445 46 36n VOL. 73 639 dismissal case 1 9268 a 147 NY pleading case 4 8 25 8 9 30NC assignment Case 7 9 25 S 1066 B 147 NY 689 appeal case 25 9 27 8 1119 a 147 NY 718 462 433 7 answer proof s 26 B 1080 86 347 denials 94 M. 391 1 6 competent ev 9 25 S 1060 a 143 NY 638 18 AD 160 22 decree appeal 55 6 CO court pwr 9 28 S 633 8 AC 297n 562 neg.damage 8 26 8 531 a 147 NY 715 568 resid. clause s 25 S 537 a 146 NY 121 s2SS r 148 NY policy 143 AD 485 master neg. 8 25 8 . 443 a 145 NY 603 489 persb injury 8 25 8 1136 r 146 NY 81 498 good faith s 26 8 237 a 147 NY 714 73 AD 296 575 authorities s 25 8 231 144 AD 792 do 144 AD 795 580 accounting s 25 8 283 r 142 NY 224 583 costs dis- cretion s 25 S 265 83 412 r r. crossings 171 NY 597 88 AD 205 25 M 336 27 M 136 587 legis power s2SS 155 f 90 11 r r. crossings 11 AD 283 167 NY 260 594 no limitatn. s 26 S 270 131 AD 84 care person 604jury question 9 25 S 244 11 AD 155 76 AD 329 proximate cause 95 AD' 115 607 res judicata 8 25 S 277 67 AD 67 no extension 137 AD 628 serve notice 83 M 491 ' 'renewal* ' 172 AD 100 6 1 1 negligence s 25 8 184 e 61 AD 31 exceptions 65 AD 85 6 1 6 towns taxes 8 26 8 196 e 166 NY 111 construction 21 M 276 622 damages 8 25 S 522 e 11 AD 239 46 AD 452 4 AC 96 626 offer judg' ment s 25 8 854 second offer e 8 M 621 d34M 717 5 AC 148n 628 compet. ev s 25 8 161 84 AD 416 633 contempt 25 S 186 r 143 NY 342 49 AP 44 637 bill partio case 9 25 S 346 66 AD 604 69 AD 460 19AC 7n spl. damage 19 AC 5n costs case 21 s268 83 AD 393 183 638 opening default case 4 I 8 25 8 399! s26 8 a 141 NY d83 priority lien 8M indemnitors d22M liens 216 NY do 216 NY 442 1 86 M ma; lien attaches 166 AD 928 686 203 346 676 433 232 91 M direct reply 138AD ■» will null vodi 72 M . 588 rely order 152AD 700 discretion 91 M 233 81 allegations s26 8 1029 7 AC 287n 81 AD 157 8M 646 14 AC 418n individually do 149 AD 157 presumption 165 AD 392 libel do 133 S 861 87 allegations :s26S 1036 860 .consideration 116AD 396 26 new trial mutuality s26 8 1064 1LR.ANS 31 M 426 609|l22 D duty court lunilateral 98 M 61 127 AD not binding 89 M 629 447n 348 32 contrib. neg. s25B d86 d91 9M 10 M 17 M 40 contract 8268 a 146 NY 1009 113 36 484 123 166 no covenant f 95 M 525 581 tustee 900 618 46 constitutional s 25 S 1089 eSAD 248 27 AD 198 public safety 64 AD 261 city powers 206NY 131 53 commissions 90 mtge s26S e9AD assessment a 25 8 916 882 87 197 620iresidence corpn. 8M 61 certificate - LRA 437n 102 damages 8 25 3 922 148 NY 729 105 negligence 9 26 S 904 a 144 NY^ 704 B 26 8 934 186NY 668 e 27 M 472 e 41 U 73 74 46 M 399 f 89 M 681 97 M 217 106M 118, 120 16AC 425 162 S 859 trustee 132AD 802 99M 208, 213 d 99M 214 not assignable 76M 585 compensation f 99M 209 d 99M 213 d 99M 215 56 assignment 8 25 8 1058 a 144 NY 705 61 admissible dol85AD 37.,^j^^^ ^^^^^--- 66 extortion \^^ ^ ^^ ml^NY ^?^c 1 22 amendment 1 07infringement 8 26 8 ,„ 9.11 a 147 NY 647 109 statute limitations 8 26 8 RRO 24M 166 1 1 3 surrogate's powere 8 25 U4U 76 205 90 M 227 cond precedent e81 429 8 81 697 22 AD 37R 41 M 227 estoppel 6M 58S 15 U 666 40 M 231 79 M 341 25 CP 160 indictment. 112 AD 119 621 8 26 3 7 AC 1020 464n 7'8 use of tracks 8 26 8 1068 79 390 1 new matter 71 AD 39 I reply i 41 M 578il3l poolseUing 289n 290 3 26 S 802 125 use body as shield s 25 S 965 8 80 550 a 2 AD 376 ABUREVraxiONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; e, criticised; 1, limited ;>e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do. dissenting opinion; p, parallel 1 case; q, questioned Vol. 73 N. Y. Supreme Coart Reports — Hon 8M jurisdiction 176AD 1 38 release 8 26S a 147 NY 296 128 714 . 99 title S25S a 141 NY d33AD I 43 findings ev 90S 690 383 143 63 436 293 195 b25S • 144 NY 78 demurrer 50 AD 65 AD 154 NY 78 M admit will 221NY 1 45 remedy 825S 1038 a 148NY 732 I 50 damages B 25 S 924 a 149NY 69b 18 M 30 1 67 injunction s 25 S 106-1 a 148 NY 607 76 so,s review 83 g improp. oenif. 6 AD 191 7 AC 462d I 73 foreclosure b25S 109S e 86 184 objna liens 7M 618 notice 26 M 453 construction el AC 116 224 203j ury question s 25 S . 1012 a 142 NY 629 2 1 2 usurious s 25 S 835 160 AD ■ 800 2 I 8 contract s 25S 1070 a. 147 NY 387 22 1 partnership a 25S 1086 a 117 NY 686 177 s 26 S 54 M refuttable 39CP paid in full 160 AD presumpt n 877 304 378 829 179 dismissal s 25 S 875 14 AC , 327n ',M 251 affidavit' insuf 2 AC a4n substitute serv. 56 M 322 publication 20AC 231n 20AC 232n \ 85 postponem't s25 S a 142 NY 76 e76 dSS 909 219 267 403 246 192 counsel fee s 25 S 867 1 AC lOOn 74M B38 contempt 116AD 544 38 CP 266 arrears alimony 74M 53fi I 95 new trial »25S * 141 NY 21 AD 50 AD 73 AD 75 AD 21 M 914 602 617 625 449 490 3 174 946 886 612 177 372 res judicata 33 M 319 collat attack 37 M judgment 94 M 33 287 assumption B26S 414 86 80 personally liable 140 14 610 £98 227 practice s25S n7AD invalid 3 46AD 229 s 25 S 220 NY 1018 817 675 931 143 233guaranty s 25 S 1043 f 73 616 laws of Turkey 213 NY 435 238 finding fact 3 25 S 1023 a 147 NY 574 SAD 88 fraud proof 2 AC 45n construction 204 NY 480 244 receiver s 26 S 1032 d 66 AD 577 246 order arrest s 26 S 1042 a 142 NY 628 f 78 614 248 stockholder s 25 S 860 a 147 NY 713 255 grounds s 26 S 866 e 6 AD 657 256 reviewable 8 26S 67 AD 102 AD authority f 162 AD 92 privity 14 AD affidavits 65 AD 87 AD cause of action 31 M 195 2 AC 360n 361n 29 I damages s 26 S 299 s 88 402 «6 AD 47 Jo 156 AD 14S presumption 214 NY 583 298 construe will 26 S 426 r 146 NY 192 302 costs double s 26 S 254 a 142 NY 670 d 42 AD 251 2 AC lOSii 3 I distinction 8 26 S 375 21 M 213 564 532 101 333 26 1 new trial s28S 24 M adultery ev 11 AG limitation 1B6AD not limited 156 AD 266 337 1960 879 411 265trespasdam s20S 31 1 a 151 NY 620 exculpation 65M 16: 270 discovery 8 26 S 406 rl6] NY 579 88 336 274 assignment 8 26 S 371 150 NY 269 a 13 AD 632 28 1 presumption 26 S 296 14 383 warranty 8 26 S . 413 a 145 NY 414 398 conversion s 26 S 206 B 92 346 404 services s 26 S 280 67 AD 491 possession books " AD 441 office vacant d 173 AD 341 408 possession s 26 B 668 45 AD 140 109 AD 619 e 18 M 242 construction 51 M 230 sum. proceeding lOOM 670 4 1 6 insuffic. ev 26 S 919 21 AD 160 42 1 inspection s 26 S 429 9 AC 276D 430 devises s 26 S 447 a 149 NY 61 creditors suit 138 AD 78 433 open decree 327 employees s26S a 158 NY d91 4 AC preferences el7AD e21M construction SAC order f 155 AD 917 335 judgment s26 8 '268 r 149 NY 86 quantum meruit 173 AD 244 340 contract 8 26 S 177 a 144 NY 704 357 submission 26 S 200 a 142 NY 690 r 161 US 276 365 ownership 3 26 S 248 a 146 NY 576 371 coDstruotton 8 26 S 166 68 AD 383 map control 136 AD 89B 377 case settled and signed 8 26 S 193 S3 AD 75 378joint adventr 263 757 273 3 26S a 148 NY 29 AD evidence 18'M 372 188 AD . 828 parol agreement 13 AC 128n 129n 'contract 121 AD 470 a 148 NY 86 a 2 AC 495 award s 26S ■ 143NY a 166 US 62 AD 26 90 469 224 337 517 27n 455 117 379 387 198 956 685 124 507quan. meruit 8 26 S 381 4 147 NY 420 509./oyBter bed 8 26 S 307 a 148 NY 463 5 1 2 earngs proof B 26 8 162 12 AC 33n ejection 13' AC 67n not excessive 13 AC ■ 75n 5 1 6 complaint s 26 S 83 25 AD 30 M surety 192 NY 437 appeal 8 26S 76 1 AC weight of ev. 77 set aside deed 47 AD 424 443 trustees nee;. 26 B 642 s 5 AD 625 448prea't. corpn, 101 196 12 726 607 5 1 9 countrclaim I 26 S 107 a 148 NY 752 522 discovery 26 S 162 88 312 1 AC lS9n 57M 362 39CP 38n 524 life tenant a 26 S 114 64 M 196 528 transfers s26S 37 AD fraud 37 AD cl7M 3 26S a 149 NY 6 AD 474 614 170 457 penalty s 26 S 272 a 145 NY 105 I AC 261d 124AD 81 substitution 8 AC 96n 46 7jury question a 26 S 386 r 145 NY 408 41 AD 623 476 discretion a26S 12 AD reversion SOAP 437 80 126 485 will construe a 26 5 394 31 M 224 493 contempt a 26 S 449 8 1 5 M 64 d 86 M 647 495corp. boundr s 26 S 450 a 142 NY 343 496 rescission s 26 S 28!* 109 208 180AD 708 214 219 443 prohibition 1 AC 4a0n 532 Stat limit'n s 26 S 121 t 80 AD 496 not accounted d 170 AD 457 534 opening cose 8 26 S 390 18AC 68n impi(-per rmks, 18AC 74n,, 76n 540 surrender 26 S 255 80 429 542 conviction s26S 1121 r 142 NY 366 545 defense ev. 9 26 S 151 1 AC 62n vicious proof 11 AC 231n 547 m. prosectn. a 26 S 149 194 NY 9 action not lie f 160 AD 756 550 bona fides s 26 S 141 102 AD 165 grant sound f 169 AD 105 presumption 556 discovery s26S 112 39 M 240 560 excess dam. B 26 S 342 r 148 NY 88 86 473 562 pers. injury s 26 S 1050 a 148 NY 733 allegation 14 SAD 710 566 bail bond s26S 313 181AD 894 567 negligence s26S 31i a 148 NY 745 p85 41o 569 negligence s 26 S 321 147 NY 721 not imputable 3 AD 372 6 AD 208 12 AD 159 41 AD 92 57 I contract 26 S 419 9 148 NY 568 r 3 AC 21 575 annulment s 26 S 164 1 AC 384n 16AC 107n 576 nuisance 8 26 S 165 9M 14 47 M 391 19A0 394 competent ev 20 M 339 17 AD 588 590 construction 19A0 397 allegations 74M 277 581 condemnt*n 26S. 422 a 141 NY 297 583 mandamus 8 26 S 28i r 146 NY 357 587 taxation a 26 S 191 a 141 NY 479 3 AG 179n 189 607 ejectment s 26 S 806 * 141 NY 88 23 AD 11 608 injunction s 26 S 807 * 141 NY 88 6 1 injunction s 21 S 807 * 141 NY 88 6 1 5 conversion :ase 2 s25 S a 148 NY 11 AC judgment case 12 25 S a 148 NY 6 1 6 report case 8 s26S a 162 NY case 9 assignment s26S a 148 NY case 12 neg. gas co s26B r 147 NY case 15 appeal s 26 S 1125 a 151 NY 627 case 17 report s 26 8 1126 a 148 NY 728 590 bonds neg. 8 26S d 159 NY 595 costs 26 S e 148 NY 98 362 435 229 597 place of be- ginning 8 26 S 103 12 AC ISOn 148 AD 780 OOlimprp'rmk s 20 S . 257 18AC 69n 602 identity a 26 S 313 55 AD 478 register evidence 95 AD 146 e 111 AD 847 14 AC 277n 18AC 235 Qompet. ev. • 58 M 484 882 284 728n 112 748 1126 637 1128 1128 529 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distingruished ; {. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; f, dismissed; ».■»'•! c. criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q, questionea N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Hun Vol. 74 VOL.74 3 fraaehise 9 26S 189 65 AD el2M taxpayer 83 AD wast* 48 M ise 264 532 601 107 85 a26S 58 highway 3 26 S 16 AD 59 contraoi s26S 17 M 10 obstruotion a 148 NY 432 8 26 S 143 quantity water 138 AD 451 1 8 exemption r 141 NY 478 a 26 S 155 1 9 app'nt K'rda • 143 NY 623 B26S interest 92 M lOlM 258 infant 91 178 25 damaicee >26S 156 52 AD 588 cause of action 82 AD 546 demurrer 114 AD 419 26 amendment 178 180 236 600 d87 s26S 35 H 28 appeal a 145 NY stoek delivery « 16 AD 604 ■ 26 S 370 debtor and ored'r 39 U 373 32 neglii. rr. r26S 397 ■B 135 NY 684 siffnals 107 AD 344 4]ue8tion of law 109 AD 627 no AD 59S 39 iesis. power a 141 NY s26S 42 appeal a 148 NY »26 8 Jlflg. fact queatidn ■ ~ 34 401 123 294 766 310 SAD 132AD safe plaoe 114 AD 38 44 authorities s26S 384 144 AD 792 46 authorities s 26 S 293 144 AD 792 do 144 AD 795 48 authorities 8 26 S 385 144 AD 792 do 144 AD 795 S3 deposit trust r 147 NY s26S r2 AC 80 a 2 AC SAC 12 AC 43 322 144 148 344 79d 3S8n 492 314 512 135 344 68 agreement a 152 NY 624 B 26 S 369 7 1 aoeounting r 148 NY 721 <■ 26 S 401 SO 401 73 jury question r 148 NY 67 a28 S 106 86 470 76 co-extensive s 26S 290 lOOM 509 78 title receiver 26 S e20 AD 53 AD 15 U 1 AG 4 AC 340 441 4E8 641 158n 381 8 1 assessment f74 b26S 83 certiorari 26 3 81 33 AD 35 AD 45 AD 63 AD 49 AD 80 AD 98 AD 101 AD 166 NY audit claim 51 M 637 382 89 life estate a 142 NY 449 8 36S 161 9 I change venue 26 S 63 AD do 97 AD 40 M 160 414 424 15 93 compensation s26S 10 AC 99 new 9 26S leAC 405 359n trial 436 130n 56 annulment a 147 NY 7l9 101 appeal a 14 3NY tax corpn. 75 AD s26S 1 5 appeal a 148 NY s26 8 care degree 67 AD 73 AD siirnals ev. IIOAD 1 2 1 defense s26 8 25 M 30 H 28 CP 16AC 166 462 748 659 216 37 182 431 243 44 239 104 204n 24 rr. corpor'tn s 26 S 859 18 AD 535 e 31 H 574 exclusive right 68LRA 797 preference 71 M 244 129 eatrays s 26S 808 19AC 866n 1 30 praotice a 26 8 329 105 AD 616 106 AD 613 by appeal 179AD 537 137 jury queetin a 148 NY 762 86 470 s 26 8 1123 138 note preeumpt'n 33 AD 627 s 26 8 238 11 M 342 153 NY 308 49M 98 1 4 1 coBtnb. neR 8 26 8 a 147 NY 91 dS AD do 8 AD 98 AD 13 AC for court 182AD 271 178 7 141 490 354 422n 453 1 50 negligence a 148 NY 26 8 729 245 1 57 reference a 26 8 650 accounting 118 AD 38 OP SOD 352 1 78 review a 26 S $19 a 148 NV 741 92 122 apply money 84 M 322 recover rents 93 M 461 1 79 stay 438 443 376 34S 262 a 80 30 AD s 26S renewal 117AD appealable f 164 AD 198 negligence r 145 NY 201 g 26 S 323 202 rule rr ejection s 26 8 628 13 AC 60n 63n 13 AC 66n 75n 13 AC 76n death negligence d 156 AD 158 reasonable care 212 NY 446 205 revers- error « 26 8 815 80 461 prima, f am't 82 113 179 NY 224 amendment 216 423 305 616 42 r 144 NY 91 s 26S 7M r 1 AC no substitution 180AD 841 226 new trial e 30 AD 96 s 26 S 221 228 guaranty r 150 NY 232 a 26 S 620 241 information 9 367 a 26 S 222 246 receiver costs a 142 NY 668 s 26 B 378 248 open com- mission s 26 8 445 186 NY S39 23 M 261 617 25 1 revers error s 26 8 610 e85 612 allow'ce audit 47 49 63 1.39 307o a 45 AD 45 AD 57 AD SAC 221 appeal s26S 43 M 2AC 98 AD 493 327 360 174 243 264 inadmisble. f 166 AD 311 269 open*< jugd ment s 26S 626 lOlAD 150 do95AD 625 27ljury questioD s 26 S 425 55 M 597 279 agreement 9 26S 811 54 AD 380 ratification 68 M 44 282 assessment a 145 NY 593 s 26 S 814 284 damages s 26 S 690 77 509 86 473 16 AD 483 97 AD 423 DM 429 15 AC 275 interference f 94 M 709 3 1 corroborata a 142 NY 84 eSl AD f 160 AD s26S rape d 166 AD 629 71 561 391 674 322 323 information s36S 78 85 d88 IAD SAD 18 AD 24 AD e34AD 61 AD AD 19 M 33 M 9 AC 9 AC 10 AC . iustiScation 113 AD 339 like indictment 142 AD 157 allege, time,place 77M 197 specified crime -7M 198 329 reoovery 818 76 137 500 134 135 621 444 209 561 562 398 681 170 233n 236 238n 181 368 indictment 11 AD e26S authority 10 AC 44S 417 49n 370 revocation a 26 8 803 41 M 77 injunction 59 M 296 372 amendment s 80 241 a 26 8 614 power court f 149AD 859 substantial justice f 79 M 367 442 reargument r 148 NY 8 26 8 f75 eq relief el2AD SAC jury trial p23M 337 S40 611 26S 21 4n 593 446 note accept- ance a 148 NY 698 s 26 S 822 24 AD 233 448 restoration 148 NY 624 a 26 8 692 a 29 .AD 547 380 harmless er 454 safe applice a 26 8 595 s 26 8 852 11 AC 19n3AD 17 7 AD 409 breach coven't 100 AD 399 458 pers knowl 9 AD 16AD 64 AD 8 26 8 SAC 312 584 4 £53 390 395n 336 same eourt s 26 S 236 do 100 AD 323 338 property rights 26 8 410 72 M 280 339 burglary r 148 NY 264 s 26 8 408 346 affidavits * 141 NY 563 51 AD 381 26 S 457 32 M 444 39 M 424 2AC 66d bill particulars 109 AD 687 nsuf. reason 112 AD 776 289 test oaths 6 AD s26 8 f39M 14 H 318 225 581 195 294 Stat. limitation r 148 NY s26S : 297 trust r 145 NY a 26 8 304 appeal *,142 NY discretion 76 AD .359 8 36 S 649 corpn. etkhlder SAC 371 111 670 669 490 424 409 156 349 sham "26 8 4 AD 35 AD 24 M 9 AO 170n 174n 9 AC 180n 28 CP 254-9 for jury 77M 651 352 test purpose s26S 77M abandon 104M 302 305 266 358 business r 145 NY 98 8 26 8 683 18 AD 306 proof burden 58 AD 584 153 NY 328 power surrogate e 12 M 325 vested estate 19 M 475 transfer tax 80 M 608 invention f86M 591 385 warranty a 26 i 433 78 108 79 168 84 130 direct verdict 79 M 271 395 injunction 93 AD s26S 338 844 398 deed a 26 8 12 AC description 121 AD adverse possessn 75M 314 a 143 NY s26 8 S6 67 AD a 2 AC 2 AC IS AC contempt 72 M 641 195n 236 400 draft a 147 NY s26 8 474 manslaughtr a 141 NY 266 a 26 S 694 483 chose in action 258 770 405 interpretatn 8 26 8 do 88 AD 96 AD a 31 NC 850 300 327 121 4 1 2 absenea m 148 NY 306 26 8 m2AC 1 AC 25 CP 622 424 213n 307 418 eapitalstk r 141 NY s26S 251 519 542 25 M 423 pleading s 26 S 657 157 AD 447 425 will trust 81 AD 406 s 26 3 703 39 M 362 429 proceed sale rl46NY 200 s 26 S 2g0 r 2 AC 16 432 prob cause s26S 471 51 AD 325 435>ncerp. ebjn s26S a 148 NY 437 appeal a 148 NY 8 26 8 accounts 2 AC 632 58 733 70 46n 639 518 44 70 128 134n 21 9n UP r 148 NY 3 26 8 78 S17AD 441 482 96 365 505 fr'd stock p74 3 26 8 7AD subrogation 119 AD 5 1 7 salary a 147 NY b26 8 521 appeal 8 26 8 76 s87 103 AD creditor 12 AD 46 U authority 24M judgment 6 AC 528 54S 36 9 117 20S 586 826 316 146 102 477 351 588 199n 527 opinions B 26 8 823 13 M 194 counter claim 24 M 680 28 CP 266 529 fr'd certif. a 148 NY 727 a 26 8 553 533 demurrer 9 26 8 842 d 38 M 345 538 oause action a 26 8 483 25 M 6SS 28 CP 366-7 542 findings s 26 8 esi a 148 NY 270 92 eg . .ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished: f. followed- r revcrooir- m ,„„^:c^j. • j- • criticised: 1. limited: e. explained: o. iverru.ed:'^. sami'^'se-Tot'dis'seLSg^^opinTonrp'Srel'^^^^^^^ Vols, 74, 75 N. 7. Supreme Court Reports— Hun 551 judgi a 161 NY s26S a 105 AD 21 M 8 41 M a 3 AG :ment 122 443 £S0 237 633 344 SSGjary question s2es 87 new trial 7'AD e30AD 53 AD 68 AD QM 2dM 30 M contrib 13 M 596 591 402 96 477 478 3S1 361 626 neg. ev 166 weight of ev. 33 M 422 42 M 626 scrutiny 1158 AD S9a 589 mea dama«;e a 148 NY 382 s 26 S 662 576 neg easem't r 148 NY 661 B 26 S 600 606 indemnity a 148 NY 241 I 26 S 663 6 1.2 Stat, frauds alSONY 314 8 26 S 847 6 1 7 paymt ev r 147 NY 694 a 26 S 831 II AC 27d 6 1 8 pers liability s 26 S 866 a 144 NY 363 79 563 625 fiduciary s 26 S: 606 43 AD 19 74 AD 13 89 AD 164 166 cause sc cion 93 AD 109 deed executiou case 7 8 26S a 148 NY 1119 740 638 foreclosure case 2 8 26S 1120 r 151 NY 204 ultra vires, case 3 s 26 S 287 a 151 NY 24 640 business names caM3 s26S 1 AC review 208 NY 93 AD 195 fraud 119 AD 147 limitations 39 OP 167 not apply 72]tf ?Hf laches 96 M 484 stockholders 105M 714 630 findingt . s263 R3fl e44AD 4n» 47 AD S16 dSSAD 198 75 AD 344 SOM 111 632 substituted service B26S 956 a 143 NY 648 SAC 17nl9ii 103M 421 637 damaces ease 3 8 26 8 127 r 147 NY 322 q 14 AD 473 restrictions case 4 8^6 S 160 r 148 NY 42 report 986 377n 136 VOL. 75 I fllaims proof 9 26 8 IAD 4 AD 20 AD 75 AD 16 M 41 M scrutiny 63M 6 conclusive 1018 184 443 123 324 538 278 68B 470 d86 e 22 AD redress 39 M admission ev SAC 213n I I books ev 3 26 8 1028 52 AD 499 9 AC 157n 159n 137AD 172 13 affidavit 8 26S 39 AD grounds 18 M SAC 143 NY 960 20 360 37 41D 364 7eompetent ev 8 26 8 973 a 148 NY 739 59 AD 137 2 1 discovery 48 jury questioij 8278 ' lie 76 4 d77 463 78 40f 19 132 72 at 93 AD 661 31 AD 45S 49 AD 464 157 AD 138 11 M 616 8 24 AM 149 31 CP 320 55ii't-y question 8 26 8 1065 a 148 NY 612 75 103 b78 402 28 23 12 AD 206 8 14 AD 255 B3 damages 3 26 8 H«h s81 60? 1051 613 624 181 268n 48 49 s26S 89 fSOAD 8 31 NC 5 AC blackmail 212 AD juriadictibn 68 M 384 inspeot.books 68 M 384 co-partners 1 13 AD 496 full disclosure 140 AD 628 lOlM 445 26 blackmail 9 26 S 998 » 112 AD 48 diebarment 131AD 617 131AD 670 30 costs demur, »27S 6 f92AD 614 113 AD 124 19 M 264 8 31 NC 84 1 AC 27fln 281 n 18AC 406 406n ?4 CP 408 interloc. judgt. 142 AD costs 156 AD 82 60 39 fee vesting 989 573 348 492 43 ibierpleader 8 26 8 a 144 NY do 71 AD 38 M b26S 85 12 AD 40 AD 16 M 2 AC 29 CP 991 391 80 479 500 538 230n 238n 161 197 200 204NY 287 68 conversion a 27 S 93 a 148 745 e 36 AD 638 74 bequests s 26 S 1021 r 144 NY 644 80 book entries 961 330 566 165d 528 s26S 16 AD 18 M 9 AC 160 NY 1 33 demand s 27 S 276 11 AC 163 uquitabieremedy 48 M 401 equity action 60 M 206 140 AD 441 1 40 estoppel 8 27 S 34 51 AD 330 147 conclusive 8 26 S 1063 al45N^ 641 33 M 288 estoppel 1S5AD 726 1 5 1 constructn s 27 3 90 a 144 NY 717 88 AD , 256 259 maintain suit 152AD 84 1 55 accumula- tioui s 26 S 1087 f 82 M 14 161 indictment B26S 1041 a 143 NY 107 new trial 49 M 83 1 8 1 consideratn 83 cond Precedt s 27 S 156 e 8 AD 356 14 AC 33iD com petent ev UOAD 607 89 demand 8 26 8 a 148 NY 19 AD 22 AD SO AD do 156 AD a 161 NY 671 52 AD 93 allege negligence 26 8 84 9 AD surety 19 M 1036 12^ 522 392 679 96 receiver order 8 26 8 861 79 348 1 AC 336 1 00 Corp. liabil s 26 S 1061 a 148 NY 662 resp. superior 120 AD 130 104 paymeiit ■ 26 8 a 161 NY 32 M I 1 4 trust s27S a 142 NY 980 666 413 281 644 I 19 court's pwr ,«27 8 145 * 143 NY 249 e 6 AD 142 29 construe wil 26 S a 145 NY 51 AD direction ?9M decree 51 M accounting 41 U 51 M 8 13 IAD 958 599 317 452 266 75 266 659 1097 356 828 partner 684 special objn. 28 M 481 1 85 surcharge interest 8 27 8 7 a 142 NY 668 8 AD 345 1 86 mandamus 3 27 S 283 e 9 AD 568 f 14 AD appeal stay 30 AD 375 e 38 M 698 pleading 17 AC 410n 414 188 authority s 26 8 1G39 8 AC 3l8n d 109 AD 669 "M 101 waive objns. 18A0 434n admr convt. 17 A.C 410n 191 damages s 26 S 966 SAC 464n47lTi 128 AD 462 167 AD 599 recover costti 128 AD iri? taxable cost 1B7AD 282 193 contract s 26 S 1025 r 148 NY 708 20 I withdrawal 8 27 S 44 87 670 11 M 456 16 M 428 deduction 62 M 522 209 assume risk 8 27 S 16 109 AD 2 1 4 chat. 8 27S 80 8 31 NC f 90 M 187 mtge 114 294 224 578 129 AD 735 proper grade 136AD 121 290 discovery s 27 S 43 HI AD 315 2 1 6 sparks neg 3 26S 1102 9AC 333n 220 thirty days s 27S 477 d 17SAD 333 224 certiorari B 27 S 41 e 13 M 544 227 meas dam. s 27 8 8 8 31 NC 210 23 1 forfeiture 27 8 11 78 706 40 AD 42 239 trust duties s26S 1 80 M 38S 248 waive dam. 292 authority 8 27 8 19 M s31 NC 4 AC error court 126 AD reviewable 73 M jurisdiction 95 M 68 589 259 204 139 471 87 297law question 27 8 1 AC 26 CP 308 bar 56M 8t> 160n 238 691 859 19 451 623 109 AD 27 8 time essen. 62 M . certificate T9M 255 objectioiic s 27 8 62 128 AD 294 264 relief s 26S 1066 198NY 193 268 performance 8 26 S 1076 83 . 341 16 AD 129 4 AC 236 substitution do 205NY 405 271 evidence age 8 26S MAC 273 per. i s26S a 148 NY 1081 27 6n njury 1078 741 278 jurisdiction 26 8 81 83 e 13M 19 70 M 92 M 95 M 1007 341 306 767 564 681 457 374 109 arrest warrant 26M 601 f 62 M 688 10 AC 52n warrant office 95 M 108 142 AD 158 before m'g'str'te 147AD 347 283 compliance 9 26 8 1068 LOAD 490 not nsurer e 13AD 512 ffuard machinery 162NY 404 79 AD 46 47 13 M 177 unfoi 309 suspn Umtn s 27 8 79 16AC 305n 3 I I contract 8 26 S 1000 a 148 NY 762 86 439 3 1 6 warranty 3 26 S 1069 103 AD 121 14 AC 284n 323 assume risk 1010 374 280 427 90 585 330 289 s 26S r 148 NY 75 80 e86 3 AD 4 AD s ;n NC not assumed 206NY 358 329 forgery ev. 8 26 S 1030 r 142 NY 38 336 attachment 3 26,8 76 94 M affidavits 88 62 AD 15 M 33 M 2 AC 2 AC 6 AC 1003 565 173 373 187 412 655 160n 162 367 43n 340 knowledge 26 8 1082 1 AC . 322n 355consti'uctien s 27 S * 151 NY 18 AD e31M ^ exclus, right 68LRA preference 71 M 674 533 575 797 245 363 neg. notioe 8 27 8 77 US 462 364 costs 27 8 61 AD 113 AD 19 M 7 AC 323n 324o demurrer oosts 18AC 402n. 404n 83 296 126 264 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, not* c, criticised ; 1, limited ; e, explained ; o, overruled ; s, same case ; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, questioned N. T. Supreme Court Reports— Hun Vols. 75, 76 18 AC 410d 366 pleadiDg g 27 S 105 7 AD 166 30 AD SI] 373 res judicata 8 27 S 84 a 144 NY 607 3778tat. liinit'n. i27S 15 M 24 M 68M S5M 26 CP HI 560 156 '>4Q-1 534 17 legacy inlerest 16AC ISOd barred 166 AD 316 19 419 liable master 115 AD 688 aoQ-feaaance 130 AD 635 445 court's pwr a 27 S 529 9 92 606 30 M 490 31 M . 118 administration 13 AC . 367n vendor's lien 175 NY 179 real estate S4M 162 distribution 126 AD 157 503 bens 8 27S 24 M d33M 608 162 630 461 pleading 381 signa 8 sev 8 27 S 13 AC . 449 416d 387 bar s27S e84 18 M tender 32 M 453 177 227 508 stenog. fees s27S 511 57 AD lOOe 571 e 33 M 322 10 AC 67n taxation costs S8M 362 5 1 2 statutory 27 B ' 461 59 AD 190 do 13SAD 687 154 AD 307 appeal 122AD 668 place trial 53 M 558 award a 27S 84 15 AC wife party f57M protect dower f 166 AD 251 136AD 708 remedy 136AD 704 705 98 M 87 597 395 312n «67 455 646 389 damages 8 27 S 438 a 145 NY 319 civil action i 9911 163 396 leases Indians 8 27S a 149 NY e45 AD s27S SM demurrer 40 M .^ e 105 AD 106AD option 194 NY^ [ 162 AD mutuality 139 AD 678 eiiforcement 150AD 804 memorandum 103M 352 95 290 211 379 74t) 153 562 stay costb 27 S 636 24 CP 7 568 ._- _ s 27 S • 684 d 83 305 d 8 AD 466 :51 M 267 5l7fr'd transfer'delegate autho'y s 27 S 728 Ul AD 636 a 151 NY 628 *|l|8ation qUAD 22ll3»jA'^ account, excess !i. .'UJ^ do 29 AD 125 la'> AD 70 AD "" 108 572 indictment partial paymt s ^t o 193 NY 71 e24M jurist^tion 440 1128 761 589 444 405 subscription s 27 S 60 30 AD 317 172 AD 310 good faitb 41 AD 446 vs. public policy 49 AD 593 strike out 58 AD 379 negative pregnt 7 AC 49 in 29 CP 365 4 1 4 Stat frauds 8 27 S „SH 13 M 236 416 stockholder s 27 S 806 f 211 NY 443 as trustees 70 M 660 422 drainage 8 27 S 739 a 151 NY 1 648 85 AD 185 98 AD 405 211 NY 260 425 rule plead 'g s 27 S 682 8 M 646 466 good faith 3 27 S 478 a 148 NY 747 37 M 6S 472 fishing . privileges 9 27 S 481 a 147 NY 723 43 AD 222 pub. property 131AD 411 527 negUgence 573 libel 8 27 S 496 s 27 S 6 AD 198 25 AD moving <"*''°*,„, 530appraisem'nt 83 AD 525 20 AD 572 91 AD 263 59 AD 530 24CP * 14 AC 337n remedy action conclusive 8 M 124AD 243 29 M [demurrer 533 construe will "SM 612 assignment case 3 s 29 S 1050 a 148 NY 227 reinstatement case 5 s29S ' a 148 NY : 69 AD , i new trial case 7 s 28 S a 148 NY credit's suit ca^e 12 • 28S a 149 NY new trial -o-lcase 14 329 9 27 S a 149 NY appeal case 15 s28S a 149 NY case 25 ,28 8 a 148 NY VOL. 76 handwriting 8 27 S 957 15 M 212 one witness pr f 145 AD 3 parol ev 8 27 8 13 AD transfer 49 AD 133 56 referee s 27 S 696 r 145 NY 327 31 M 300 waiver 2 AC 48n 60 valid lien 624 599 464 7 habeas corpus 8 27 8 a 148 NY 69 AD 1 AC foreclose 177AD 113S 117 8 27 8 88 remanding 92 jurisdiction 57 AD do 100 AD 851 26 380 458 323 670 543 1120 668 1126 698 113 749 1 3accord case 4 s2S8 1129 184NY 326 legis. power 131AD 412 479 nuisance 549 651 373 8 27 8 85 495 674 10 AC dismissal 15 AC 520 281d 338n 428 warranty 8 27 8 93 AD 115AD 167 AD no title 19A0 relief e 87 JI 432 life estate 9 27 8 674 a 149 NY 617 28 M 423 437 damages 8 27 S 499 67 60 77 eoe 262 331 469 424 491 189 500 67o 241 607 405 88 278 277 B27S e75 75 17 AD 49 AD LliANS damages 57 AD state's duty 94 AD d98AD 102 AD 151AD for jury 151AD obstruction linlawful 211 NY 26U 487 flood dam. 27 S 474 a 152 NY 634 211 NY 260 492 judgment 8 27 8 458 87 223 d 30 AD 78 44 AD 502 497 lien notice 537 master neg. 27 8 1113 149 NY 569 2AD63do68e 72 d3AD 388 p5 AD i 539 disclosure 27 S 489 26M 54 d 162 AD (HI 541 declarations 9 27 S 494 20 M 387 465 115 8 27 8 52 AD. execution 59 M 24 51 M 233 19AC 23n 24 notice defenda 53M 306 enforceable 193NY 268 amendment 19AC 22n 611 415 379 116n lien 798 62 reference 8 27 S 622 s 22 AD 541 e 80 AD 153 12 AC , 427 counterclaim 10 gift mistake 8 27 S 616 a 149 NY 432 1 5 rescission 8 28 8 638 a 148 NY 392 19 injunction s 27 8 661 * 143 NY 265 6 AC 64 damages 8 27 3 a 149 NY 280 619 612 23 jury question s27S 611 8 83 111 e 52 AD 22 agency 16 M 35 545 sureties s27S a 142 NY p75 e90 578 pera injury 8 27 S 819 a 149 NY 954 581 assembly districts ^ 27 S 657 a 143 NY 631 582 certiorari 9 27 8 671 r 145 NY 296 585 reference 3 27 S 606 a 141 NY 485 547 assumption 9 27 8 1113 e 8 M 447 9 M 498 548 pers. injury s 27 8 608 28 M 519 59 M 247 ejection 13AC57n71n72n 552 quit claim deed 9 27 8 853 a 149 NY 447 46 M 8 556 chge. venue 590one proceedg 9 27S a 150 NY 30 AD 90 AD description 187NY oleading .J8CF 9 26 8 e88 AD 89 AD 6 94 AD 13 IAD 178AD e 45 M 38 CP 1029 58 ti25 577 242 670 236 562 13 267 306 st"V.erance 144 AD 125 738 6Q3 certiorari a 27 8 591 a 142 NY 645 805 negUgence 3 27 8 594 a 148 NY 749 e 51 AD 32 808 injunction 3 27 8 87 74 AD 122 AD 55 M f lOOM 604 253 349 195n 67 lease 8 27 8 - a 151 NY a 3 AC 2 AC ... tenant rights 73 M 267 hold over 76M 178 71 appealable 27 8 a 142 NY 857 642 588 600 66 51 750 36 372 encroachment 120 AD T64 . intention 29 negUgence 8 27 S 722 a 144 NY 717 32 foreclosure _ 27 8 614 a 145 NY 620 3 AC 112n limitation 136AD 15 title vested 142 AD 363 burden defendt. d 151AD 102 36 expense exr. s 27S 613 136AD 519 37 damages 8 27 8 93 AD SAG 468n481n 24 CP 7n 4 1 proof fraud 8 27 S 583 81 AD 145 controverted 151AD .500 44 negUgence 3 27 8 593 30 M ' 19U 46 impeachment 9 27 8 579 a 145 NY 698 2 AC 45n reputation do 138 AD 686 51 affidavits 3 27 8 a 143 NY 21 AD jurisdiction 38 AD knowledge 31 M 54 defective plan 27 8 a 48 NY 87 664 581 410 279 63 347 97 459n 76 review 8 27 8 86 92 do 4 AD 63 AD „ do 79 AD 181 NY 16 AC burden relator 4 AD 270 32 AD 396 void judgment 6AQ 245 certificate 37 AD 163 79 injunction 27 S 493 d89 83 80 construction 9 28 8 600 40 M 489 appointed" 129 AD 479 no vacancy do 209 NY 163 85 due process 3 27 8 843 77 AD 502 court's power f 99M 319 99M 321 92 remainder 9 27 S 828 m 14S NY 298 23 M 394 geni. legacies 55 M 481 1114 625 385 76 623 753 430 98 incompet. ev. 9 13 AD 68 s 27 S 834 not conclusive e 32 M 300 Til M 340 103 judicially s 27 S &17 151AD 415 1 I 1 certiorari 9 27 S ■ 837 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note, c. criticised; 1, limited: c, explained; o, overruled: s. same case: do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel ca^e; q, questioned Vol. 76 N. 7. Supreme Court Reports — ^Hun a 142 NY 82 TOAD 123 301 426 I 1 2 penalty cost a 27 S 82fi a 142 NY 670 116 discretion s27S 88 fSAD. 86 AD 3 AC SAC 13 AC 832 253 621 693 ISln 348d 401 a 146 NY ,317 1 94 pleading s 27 S 794 a 148NY 758 aatiBf action 13 M 188 200 cond preced change venue e 108 AD 11 U6AD 498 a 153 AD 193 affidavit 17 AC 317n -demand q 69 M 209 210 147 AD 684 132 S .504 J2I alternative a'27S 822 a 143 NY 36S 76 StiS 42 M 17 amendment e59AD contempt ■ 73 AD warrant d91 AD 2 AC 5 AC 129 536 439 160n 36n 37 267 waiver 9 27S r 166 NY 271 costs 8 27S 18 AD 1 AC 813 60S 227 8 27S 8 90 41 M practice 80 M 104M probate will 59 M 150AD presumption. 59 M 123 95 M 417 421 estoppel 75M 577 com. 1. marriage - -- 267 27 517 US 683 280 amendment B 27 S 771 90 42 25 CP 179 283 damages a 27S a 148 NY 22 AD 286 cost s27S r 143 NY 305 225 632 1 25 substitution s 27 S 566 * 143 NY 642 9 AC 309o 312n 315n 1 28 proceedings 8 27 S 572 a 141 NY 544 HAD 353 1 34 reference s 27 S 569 a 143 NY 623 1 5 1 Stat, frauds s 27 S 653 a 145 NY 158 1 59 ejectment 8 27 S 551 a 148 NY 294 a 3 AC 51 162 damages 8 27 S 643 a 151 NY 463 I75fact auefition 686 383 417 581 8 112 367 392 149 453 84 H marriage 88 M 90 M i 92 M jurisdiction 88 M 425 104M 521 widow decedent 92 M 98 burden proof- f 98 M 396 170 AD 912 discretion 104M 520 construction 186AD 450 209 opening et 8 27 S 766 a 143 NY 621 f76 610 Btreet easements e 34 M 706 boundaries 42 M 365 nominal value 160 AD 708 289 negligence- s 27 S 125 AD 302 lessee 8 27S a 149 NY 87 presumption 70 AD lease rent 187NY 308 recovery b27S a 150 NY 37 AD 99 AD 42 M ■ 6M el 84 NY 21 1- eq. action 27 S 61 M laaAD partnersliip f lea AD ancillary, 104M j27S a 146 NY 82 d5AD 41 AD 55 AD 59 At 186AD 54 M neg. damages 17 AC 129n duty comm'r. 68 M 287 fault commisanr 142 AD 838 1 78 employment s 27, S 570 do2SM 208 2 AC 167n 1 8 1 neglig. ev. s 27 S 561 388 511 a 8 AD 615 1 86 use land B 27 S 576 788 626 504 662 220 receivers 27 S 733 a 160 NY 42 25 M .. .224 waiver objection 42 M 30 14 AC 249 239 trusts 73 M 487 240 construe will s27 S S05 36AD 286 2S I jurisdictioo a 27 S 773 86 196 63 AD 21 257 transfer tax 8 27 S 741 a 143 NY 120 258 damages 8 27 S 746 r 148 NY 674 preponderance evidence 80 M 22? 284 siu-eties s 27 S 743 a t4R NY 251 724 257 717 466 16n 768 347 613 764 69 709 73 777 392 189 122 1376 344 atty's lien 27 S 723 1 AD 388 _ AD 548 114 AD 468 8 AC 94n 346 chge. grade 8 27 S 703 a 148 NY 763 71 AD 636 compensation . 57M 83 intent 64M 576 199 NY 631 certificate 16|^D 300 356 attachment 8 27 S 802 r 142 NY 216 r 31 NC 201 24 CP 197n source knwl. 131AD 931 361 Superior lien 8 27S 787 90 428 32M 59 discharge surety 59 M '29 741 583 470 476 290 691 216 3 1 4 justification 8 28S AD appeal 13 M- 18 M libelous 124AD iai7 AD demurrer 77M 165 267 323 • 696 777 689 effect 195 323 improper order s27S 6 6 AC atty's lien SAC 9 325 agency i27S 62 AD 694 222 bill particulars 41 AD affiavits e22M 23 M 32 M discretion 101 AD construction 64M 371 larceny a27S 8 31 AN 375 award s27S 39 AD 750 227 766 640 328 exemption s 27 S 727 90 166 330 parol ev i 27 S 700 S3 AD 660 337 review i27S 1039 37 145 filin;r exception tOAD 96 67AD 621 before court 93 M 604 340 exception e27S 86 37AI1 16AC 34' . 27S 24 CP presumption 6M 1108 434 632 382 708 18n4 378 ilfe insur. 27 S 696 _ M 601 answers false 20 M 232 384 damages s28 S 110 35 M 327 390 board of education 8 28 S 120 r 150 NY 450 do 190 NY 148 33 AD 93 399 transfer tax 9 27 S 10S6 m 143 NY 327 404 improp ordr s 27 S 1037 a 145 NY 654 2 AC 258n 408 transfer eV. 5 27 S 1025 a 148 NY , 750 f76 - . 497 excmptioUfl 39 M 410 4 1 4 delivery • 27 S 1049 83 219 28 AD 275 424 credr's suit 8 27S 1047 12 AD 477 6 AC 401 n 46 M 361 427fact question 8 27 S 1062 a 149 NY 211 83 8 10 certificate of ev 7AC 462 434 pers.knowl. 827 S 1022 8 2 369 357 19 622 443 171 65 abutter 35 M damage 121 AD 48 284 488 law question 439 superior lien s27S 1121 90 428 44 1 construction 28 S 168 f 76 613 SAC 45 444 limitns proof a 28 S 104 106 AD 334 449 notice lien 8 28S 107 m 149 NY 439 30 AD 275 lien invalid eSl AD 468 469 454 deduction 27 S 1082 23 M 190 458 land under water s 28 S 102 S AC 129n rinn. rights 126 AD 437 462 gift evidence B 28 S 59 e 16 AD 556 el7AD 10 37 AD 422 U6AD 649 dentification b27S 60 AD libel 68 AD innendo 14 AC 49 I tax exempt s 27 S 1058 a 142 NY 348 493 transfers 8 27 S 1059 a 148 NY 751 6 AD 115 497 nom. dam s27S a 152 NY 42 AD 26 M 38 M new trial 75 AD 171 AD coats SAC 48 AD 53 AD t66AD eSOM 8 31NC gift facts 116AD 54 M 222 607 621 183 159 650 58-1 489 construewill 8 27S a 154 NY e24AD trust 17 M s21 M 23 M 27 M 29 CP 1045 540 98 10S9 619 147 182 379 614 401 161n 548 deceit s28S 230 91 , , 637 not bound 161 AD 876 55 1 parol ev. s 28 S 234 a 115 NY 664 13 AD 599 117AD 764 765 557 6ndingpev a 28 S 6S1 9 AD 115 37 AD 219 fraud transfer 129 AD 115 burden proof 129 AD 115 562 implied repeal 8 28 S 208 AC 142n 565 attachment 212 412 160n 368 37 43n a2SS sl6M 2 AC e2AC 5 AC 508 aggrieved 8 27 S 1053 42 AD 544 71 AD 3 right appeal 106 AD 183 trust 96 M 209 5 1 6 will p obate 8 27.S 1078 47 AD 50 73 AD 348 olat will evidence e 104 AD 326 1094 706 241 431 756 279 101 177 475 forgery note s27S 1070 10 M fiRl 215 NY 491 warranty 22 M 724 482 safe place 8 27S 1093 e 16 AD 287 484 pers injury 8 27S 1020 * 143 NY 643 a 148 NY 749 486 consent »27S rlSl NY e89 19AD 162 NY c 178 NY 185 NY . 102M easements 186 NY d77AD e78 AD 1034 666 430 183 366 497 355 720 355 96 300 S22 court'spowr s28S 114 f 77 174 1761 set-oft 16M 120 receiver powers 10 M 686 1 AC 337 preference 78 M 45« 53 1 rental dam. a28S 94 2 AD 403 540 preierence 8 28S 206 a 149 NY 581 86 419 543 walvei s28S 210 16 AD •623 47 AD 612 186AD 131 157 AD !) 201 NY 166 do 84 M 94 f87M 14 estoppel 60 AD 460 allege residence el7M 369 31 M 136 41 M 167 8 AC 379n 381ii 26 CP ^ Q3 64 waive objns 18AC 4360 jurisdiction d 179AD 923 68 M 426 201 NY 167 negligence f 201 NY 165 no merger 74M 57 567 discretion a 2S S 203 e 2 AD 28 value estate 55 M 480 construction 92. M 698 57 1 sham pldg. 8 28 S 232 106 AD 689 9 AC 169ii 171n 9 AC 175n 190n 28 CP 256 lor jury 77M 6S1 575 safe applict 111 AD 621 s 28 S 187 579 aasum'd risk a 28 S 196 1 79 611 89 591 CO servant neg. 9 AD 133 19 AD 258 e 25 AD 696 74 AD 475 475 S8 AD 75 214 585 review a28S 92 386 24 AD 467 il-acretionary 181AD 814 6 AC 73n 277n 14 AC 96n conclusive 160 AD 249 592 discretion a28S 39 AD negligence e50AD nadequacy 66 AD . inad. price f 119 AD 121AD 192 646 608 4 663 742 795 598 demand s 28 S 218 8 AC 349n construct 16AC 165n cnang^e venue lOAC 166n 117 601 relief b28S 201 AUTIREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *. dismissed; n, note c criticised ; 1, limited ; e. explained ; o, overruled : s. same case : do, dissenting opinion : v, parallel case : q, question^ N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Hun Vols. 76, 77 8B 66 law rem. pleaded 8 AC 213n VOL.77 6 beneficiary d 23 AD 264 605 dism'l app'I.B 28 S 27$ 8 28S 220 57 AD S12 7 AC 48Sn waiver 13 AC 28111 283d restriction 62 M 73 609 coservt nes case 9 b27 8 1112 r 144 NY, 552 6 1 attachment case 9 s27S 4 AD trustees case 10 s27S s88 judgment case 11 ' a 148 NY a 29 S memorandm 69LRA 396 6 1 I trade mark case 4 a 149 NY s29? e xceptions case C a 148 NY s27S assign certififite eSOAD I I laches • 143 NY b28S SAC 1114 384 1116 579 763 1142 616 1100 759 1109 6 1 3 fraudulent conveyance case 1 a 149 NY 587 9 27 S 1029 spec, perf'mance case 4 r ISO NY 28) e 54 AD 634 635 .^29 a 1140 345 663 279 354n 1 4 wife's services 94 AD 52 s 28 S 273 2 AC 148n 14 AC 208n signature 5 AC 288n consideration 9 AG 213n 2160 48 M 1 8 forfeiture s 8 AD 499 e 32 AD 543 f 167 AD 473 jurisdiction 77 AD 617 28 S 231 23 ev. value B 28 ti 239 31 NO 29711 delivery notice 184 AD 359 27 exempt. levy s 28 S 285 e 24 AD 607 exempt taxation 47 AD 116 10 M 331 4 AC 125n do go AD 482 38 CP 176n 1S6 certiorari d9M injunction d35M pension title 38 CP .640 174 186 30 waiver 87 AD 9 28 8 nonsuit 2 AC 21n 251n 14 AC 117 33 complianc a 149 NY s28S e86 88 d33AD e42AD 57 AD 83 AD 183 NY remedy c 123AD neg. notice 126 AD reversal e loOAD 563 226 473 282 73 479 441 584 342 297 notes paymt. 3 16 AD notice claim d 193 NY 65 usury r 145 NY 9 28S 561 S24 169 465 69 passenger 102M 134 77 servt. neg. r 146 NY 181 9 28 S 314 damage nonsuit 41AD 83 mortgage 69 - " NY ] r 150 9 28 8 87 negotiable 35 AD 43 s 28 S 312 90 discretion 3 28 8 92 26 AD e29 AD 40 AD 101 AD 310 51 298 68 668 319 446 2801. 9 AC 313n 317n 29 CP 299 92 pardon a 143 NY 665 s 28 8 300 habeas corpus f 215 NY 347 99 dismiss s28S 10 AC waiver 10 AC 286n maintainable 197NY 319 v.'ant capacity 153 AD 411 103 bastardy r 161 NY 570 B 28 S 458 107 persona transaction d 38 AD 433 s 28 8 296 I I I exr commis- sions 9 28 8 305 1 AC 308 18AC 421D trust fund 190 NY 106 s28S 160 NY 144 privity 9 28 S I 122 AD 463 162 431 202 1 49 contracts ^ r 146 NY 4 3 28 8 434 159 legal title 77 611 r39M 676 vesting in lank 31 451 s28S 407 21 M 95 25U 721 43 U 47 checks assets JAD 213 certification 14 AC 443n pleading 132AD 99 allegatn insolvcy 75M 538 preference TSM 430 156 AD 521 liability 156 AD 717 no jurisdiction f 157 AD 875 182 voluntary payment s28 8 344 a 144 NY 488 7 AD 155 26 M 567 41 M 489 duress recover 41 M 481 192 strike out s28 8 329 108 AD 296 demurrer 16AC 234d 2 I 9 accumua] e 162 NY 144 s 28 8 735 trust ends 96 M 209 225 illegal as- sessment al61N^ e 13 AD 8 28 8 2 AC libel per se 31 M legal rights SO M 75M f 9911 38 12 225 548 159 AD 325 transfer tax 353 estoppel 162 M 148 16 458 366 88n 230 minors 8 28 8 355 9 AC 479n 236 opng. judgt. a 146 NY 598 28 8 34U leading pl3 AD 80i 24 1 neghgence 81 44 parties e 10 AD b28 8 neg. city do 133AD 269 324 244appt trustee 193 reject claim 9 28 S 449 9 AC 263n 258n g AC 259d 1 98 eviction a 28 8 353 17 M 607 23 M 352 Presumption 2 AC 25n Il6eq. 22 AD 9 28 8 set off 608 288 282 39 condemnation Is 28 S 464 180 450 )13AD 602 25 AD 24 44 void contrac 8 28 8 do 156 AD 24 M iu\alid 68 M compliance 71 XI 400 680 395 429 120 constitutnl 73 AD 581 682 do 78 AD 9 28 8 10 M labor law 32 M e 166 NY 139 303 78 79 34 49 knowledge rl INY 1 IS 28 8 242 d82 219 1 24 contracts S41AD 26 9 28 8 440 1 34 taxation 9 28 8 476 80 690 exemption 27 AD 475 137 negligen ce 28 AD • 67 > 28 8 471 1 39 expert ev. 201 appoint, guardian 3 AD 46 M 47 M a 28 .'J 25 CP 18 AC guardian 18AC abrogation 110 AD void act. 18AC statute rules l8Ai; 166 223 3U 36U 43 49 46i) 473 208cloud on title e 82 214 a 28 S 327 2 I I transfer tax a 144 NY 6 9 28 S 351 2 I 5 injunction 50 AD e91 s28S 36 M picketing 39 M 493 321 749 30 AD a? AD lien liable 90 AD a 28 8 new trustee 200 NY 463 166 AD 822 249 service in- fant a 145 NY 524 > 28 8 332 presumption 7» M 112 289 Stat, frauds 89 671 20 AD 214 a 28 8 334 31 M 251 4 AC 324 7 AC 388 309 profits damage " AC 177n damages ILKANS 450 298 Co- tenant a 154 NY 199 e lOAD 114 inheritance tax 38 AD 20 veat in executor 42 AD 142 a 288 400 charit. bequest 22 M 166 213 So M. 644 3 13 alEdavits 62 AD 569 a 143 NY 3 AD e44 AD d99 AD do 44 AD d86AD 89 AD e 111 AD e 180 NY e 216 NY a 28 8 29 M 39 M e44M i 85 M apecial tax SAC e 150 NY e 167 NY 641 480 344 800 346 463 351 166 302 170 330 670 134 191 27U 170 7 283 a 28 8 87 9M lotteries 4 AD 87 AD e93 AD 152 NY 33 I eq. relief 2 AD 472 a 28 8 453 mjunctiou 37 CP 68 f 90 M 33 332 injunction reliei a 27 8 945 14 M 132 a 31 NC 256 337 performance 60B 165 262 625 198 833 80 82 24 AD 54 AD e 69.AD s28S parol evidence 21 M 213 written contract 13 AD 699 provision valid 185 NY 207 372imp'd. repeal a 143 i\ y 84 8 28 S 871 construction 54M 27 380.cond. sale a 28 8 849 12 AD 215 appeal e 26 AD 65 waive forfeiture power judge f 161 AD 451 399 time cards evidence s 28 8 803 2 AC 306n 402 imconstiut- tional 817 255 701 81 76 293 17 4 1 I prudence ' 84 59 8 28 8 792 fact question 10 M 228 4 1 8 payment a 144 NY 716 36 AD 345 e 39 AD 286 11 M 862 ins. notice do 39 AD 300 s 28 8 794 reinstatement ' 24 M 63B 425 demurrer 8 28 8 170 AD 37 M 16AC 800 74 145 237n 502 224 612 334 107 816 9 28 8 18 M 19 M 42 M 2 AC 2 AC 428 642 412 20 60n 61n 363n 399n attachment 2 AC 361n 315 24 CP 235 isft'i! M 3 1 7 demurrer 9 87 347 5S 9 28 8 423 14 1 error court 43 AD e52 AD 80 AD 161 NY option e 120 AD foreclosure 124AD delauU iuterst 59 M 569 waiver 80 M 530 I 171 AD 29 389 safe place a 28 8 883 e92 76 39 AD 138 incompet. ev, 179 NY 25 395 weight of ev 881 3 28 8 82 discretion 83 88 42 AD 60 AD 71 AD 16 M new trial 32 M 42 M 8AC_395n396n':e 92 432 jurisdiction e24AD . 616 s 28 8 808 27 M 172 436 dissolution a 145 NY 267 s 29 S 259 440 compliance e 86 742 88 33 AD 42 AD f 219 NT notice 83 AD i 169 AD 8 29 8 16 M 283 73 479 186 amend notice e 109 AD 183 NY 443 verdict a 150 NY 61 AD 8 29 8 686 560 105 304 333 342 565 690 77 467connter o'aim a 288 870 04M 15 468 questn fact 166 NY 67 a 28 8 1078 472 diacietion 9 26 8 125 AD 107 28 47 478 final r 151 NY .557 1395 e8S 140 114 d7 AD 480 544 s29 8 99 455 appeal 418 156 NY 48 513 do 166 NY 62 403 48 1 tax 01 lector 626 a 161 NY 131 ABIIKEVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distineuished ; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, disirissed; n, note c, criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled ; s, sanlecase; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, quntiana* Vols. 77, 78 N. Y. Saprenie Court Reports — Hon s 28 S 1089 town officer liab' a 4 AC 50 49 I infanoy * 150 NY 547 B 28 S 805 e 99 AD 59. 498 vol. oonfeBBn «28S 13 AC 506 laches s29B , r 149 NY 42 AD 1081 28Sd 107 472 660 51 1 contracts a 151 NY 669 8 29 S 87 5 1 9 incompetent servant r 145 NY 408 8 28 a 890 rnegligence sl35AD 755 524 safe street 8 28S 887 •a 148 NY 735 14 AD ,^ 96 AD ,. 435 contrib. neglig. 114 AD i 527 Stat. 89 90 b2SS 4 AC frauds 571 597 892 324 529 iurisdiction s 28 S 930 e 29 M 282 53 1 purchase foi value 8 AD 571 s 28 8 890 15M 172 535 jurisdiction s 28 S 921 27 M 172 537 taxation 8 28S ! 26M 49 539ma8ter negl. 8 28S 894 do 134AD 918 545 discretion s 288 ■ 922 B 80 60U f 83 613 security costs 500 180 542 79 121 383n 391n 24 86 56 AD 80 AD 14 M 27 M 9 AC 25 CP 29 OP s 28 S 1048 right possession r4 M 447 23 M . 249 66 OP 399 discovery 119 143 Mo M 423 4Z0 S69 authority a 2S b 1035 da UP Vi 574 privilege il7AD 24? 578 harmless error 28 S 1016 63 AD 484 11 AU . 2on jupy question 129 AD 512 580 questn facte 18 AD 366 828 S 1U42 pay owner J 4a AD SOT 587 nonsuit 9 28 8 1026 2 AC 256n 11 AC llOn 589 parties verd s 28 8 lOOO 8 AC 29Sn 59 1 offer judct. s 28 8 1U46 2a M 44b 34 M 716 29 CP 33U »2SS fl30NC r3AC crdr action eS a 166 NY s288 sp prfmce case 7 a 160 NY 8 28 8 595 strike out evidence a 148 NY 86 6 AC adultery 32 AU 8 28 8 735 601 73n 66 1067 60 553 consent verdict s 28 8 901 11 M 174 199 556 compliance 8 '28 S a 149 NY 39 AD 104 AD 931 616 30t 203 559 safe place * 144 NY s28 8 12 M si AC 613 918 .376 176 564 sum proceed 11 AD 290 6 AC 294n 29b 598 overpaymt s 42AD 334 s28 8 1067 .mutual mistake 119AD 93 604 errors rev'r 3 28 8 104 e 55 AD 86 88 ADD 16 129 AD 432 charge exception 10 M 728 21 M 529 3 AC 236d 13 AC 47ii damages 69AD review 134AD exception 158 AD t 172 AD reversal 180AD 607 appeal case 1 a 149 NY 3 28S witness case 2 r 149 NY 3 28 8 burden proof case 3 a 149 NY 22 AD s 28 S. . negligence case 4 1- 151 NY 311 707 trial 86S 13 1136 362 283 677 1136 84 1136 623 397 1136 3U) 33 346 H34 609 damages case 4 s 151 NY 63 AD a 28 8 170 NY use street 181 NY 321 right action 14 AD 604 6 i demurrer case 4 a 152 NY contract d&4 AD do 170 NY 28 8 appeal 1st Dept case 3 a 161 NY 65 29 8 114 611 wills 1st Dept case 1 a 148 NY 683 9 29 8 114^ judgment ist Dept case 2 a 149 NY SOS* 29 8 1142 6 1 2 insurance case 3 66 AD 28 8 judgment case 6 a 147 NY s28S judgment case 10 a 152 NY s28 8 . reputation case 11 a 164 NY d85 3 28S acceptance case 14 a 160 NY 71 AD VOL.78 excess damage? s 28 8 1001 r 146 Nl: 373 86 4 T discretion jury 9 36 M 192 recovery neg. 39 M 7 trustees s28S m 144 NY 47 1123 719 1119 628 1121 764 187 1126 delivery mtg. 36 M certiorari case -16 r 143 NY *28S 673 407 1120 364 a 150 NY 78 82 4 AD 5 AC 5 AC 155 NY 86 74 informaton 264 220 1 3 negligence 8 29 8 247 89 AD 426 429 e 89 AD 430 contrib. neg 2 AC 318n 1 8 demurrer s29S 85 IAD 18 AD II M. 93 M 28 8 3 84 d89 contract 26 AD 21 M 8l AC 26 CP 1069 246 372 204 717 266 269 348 23 repugnancy s 28 8 1014 14 M 198 28 corroboration s 29 S 271 a 143 NY 666 32 service corp. legal conclusion 24 AD 444 court's power e 13 M 769 17 AD 427 33 171 d 44 M 630 insufficient 9 AC 235n 236 state facts 132AD 893 like indictment 142 AD 157 no jurisdictn. f 87 M 278 73 strike out s 29 S 263 68 5^ denial as defense 3 28 8 IAD 12 M 16 M 27 M 1 AC 2 AC 1039 136 483 5 721 232n 75n manag. agent 62 M 409 f 92 M 44B 220 NY 270 222NY , 46 36-non-support s 28 8 1002 a 143 NY 667 abandonment 19A0 175n 19AC 177n allege time place 77M 197 38 discretion 8 28 8 1033 88 253 66 AD 206 89 AD 626 43 competeiicy s 28 8 1062 219 142 AD 1123 611 117 1133 567 164 1136 107 declarations 152AD 211 50 frivolous b28S IAD 16 M inconsistent defn 106 AD 689 275 682 336 46 609 316 289 210 210n 4 d 165 NY 30 water consumer ILKANS 96Sd 1 54 jurisdiction 267 137 134 621 75, 76 111 SAC aoiense IGPNS 13 AD 466c answer 255 524 83revooation s2 6 8 334 r 149 NY 617 13 AY 624 £ 153 AD 112:; cancellation 93 M 669 87 em domain 8 29 8 a 145 NY 90 pledge s28 8 a 151 NY 81 AD title 114 AD 96 contract 30 8 a 166 NY 269 482 1100 666 372 604 144 220 981 332 646 341 196 461 411 328 725 59 154 1022 8 28 8 IQAD 11 AD 1 162 AD discretion 16 M d 184 NY e44M 194 US contempt 176AD 37 CP d37CP 163 8 review appeal 160 AD 668 1 69 meas dam. 8 28 8 966 d 22 M 703 1 7 1 damages 8 28 8 937 46 M 8 1 73 res judicata 3 28 8 971 a 149 NY 683 1 76 injunction s 28 8 938 9 AD 726 refer damncee 80 AD 52 181 instruction s26S 911 835 94 prima facien 92 544 13 M 439 pers. injuries a 146 NY 238 torts i28S LIS AD 621 904 800 239 assumed risk i 28 S 829 a 149 NY 569 242 damages 9 28 S 825 3 61 AD 349 246 collusion 9 28 8 828 20 AD . 612 mechamc lien 114 AD 463 248 inj. child s 28 S 816 153 AD 380 252 contrib, neg. 9 28 8 866 r 161 NY 424 p82 38 r 3 AC 334 255 insurance 9 28 8 928 a 149 NY 430 258 discretion 9 29 Si 1151 1 AC 306n 260 appraisal 626 167 947 681 52 same s 28 S 166 AD claim 1086 613 58 amendment s 28 8 1039 49 AD . 566 certiorari 91 AD 546 objections review 39 M 464 reduction 73 M 651 63 capital stock 8 29 8 92 "99 prepond ev. 8 28 8 1072 68 AD 371 68 AD 343 104 by-laws 3 28 8 1076 a 160 NY 167 23 M 14 AC lOOn waiver ILRANS 1069D 1 09 insurance 8 29 S 260 a 149 NY 382 1 2 1 contract 8 28 8 992 a 146 NY 78 141 easement s 28 8 968 a 162 NY 637 37 M 109 1 46 pub*, welfare 8 28 S 987 20 AD 296 h 43 AD 624n 82 AD 428 intent benefit 22 M 609 a 10 AD d46AD 196 828 'S a 149 NY 202 construction 8 28 S 963 a 146 NY 361 84 260 2 1 I testam. cap. s 28 8 942 a 146 NY 599 133AD . 912 2 1 3 stock bonds 933 410 623 139 359 8 28 8 r 150 NY 96 AD 14 M r3 AC 220 gen'l denial s 28 8 903 26 M 498 lOPNS 258 222 construction 328S a 151 NY f87 warranty d 81 AD direct verdict 19 M waiver lasNY 2 AC a 3 AC 38 CP 952 196 19 68 366 79u 294n 292 201 9 28 8 18 AD 40 AD 72 AD 78 AD award M 910 196 288 398 624 334 262 burden proof 28 S r 149 NY 21 AD 67 AD 952 45 125 141 274 transfer tax 9 29 8 212 a 144 NY 163 277 inad verdict 9 28 8 861 23 AD 131 review damages 72 AD 323 bases for damage 11 AC 55n 66 11 AC 59n 60n llAC 69n 280 user road 28 S 858 a 155 NY 683 e 84 442 fine obstruction 22 M . 378 conclusive 24 M 40 private way U AC 462n use 20 years 153 t 83 M fine 88 M character 88 M prescription 89 M 163 286 declarations CG8 user 610 234iury question 3 28 8 827 e 14 AD 586 25 M 599 235 neg. damage 8 28 8 . 819 3 28 8 e89 AD 287 fraud 28 8 9 29 8 a 150 NY 857 446 855 615 664 292 accounting 9 288 911 ABBKEVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note, e. criticised ; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, dissenting onininn : p . para lleLcwe; q, guntioDcd N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Hun Vols. 78, 79 a 161 NY 654 293 court's pw'i a 144 NVr 621 s 28 S ei7 54 AD 133 295jury questiOL 9 28 S 914 4 AD 419 427 297 divorce ■ 28 S 959 a 143 NY 681 f 78 610 aervice oncorpn 1 AD 136 12 M 483 1 AC 232d 2 AC 76n manas agent 62 M 40S 298 res judicata B 29 S 909 a 144 NY 601 304 Stat, limitna s 28 S 976 a 160 NY 584 e 36 AD 476 46 AD 356 e90AD . .47 suspa limitatioa 16AC 308n 309 coBtB action' 89 AD 107 AD 12 M 39 M 54U 54 M 496 601 211 240 62 273 274 2AC 67 61n 6&n 7 AC 160 352 case appeal a 162 NY 166 .i29S 7 AC agency 49 M 8 29 S 30 AD 38 AD 51 AD 6 AC discovery 68U b29S 83 e86 85 91 54 AD 66 AD 29 M 31 M 2 AC e2AC- 8 AC 168 494n 303 363 insp't bookH 118 306 145 626 270n 384 407ji2ry question 8 29 S 143 a 149 NY 579 60 AD 473 41 I compet ev a 29 S 169 59 AD 529 Ui4 AD 371 164 NY 244 prohibited 77M 509 417 damages s 28 S 1105 2 AD 317 jury question. 37 AD 469 nonsuit proper e 146 1«Y 199 420 contract 3 29 ij 191 a 144 NY 716 54 AD e81 AD 22 M 113 406 123 691 93 16 283 562 299 48Q&5 50 13 137 365 aontract e 29 S 149 SeM 419 beft. liabl 59 M 418 conclusive 130 AD 530 order bindg 134 AD 419 receipt evidence 95 M 597 370 judgment s 29 S 179 f 78 616 487 221 36 323 conviction B'M a 196 120 AD 332 33 I foredoBure s29U r 156 NY 334 laclies s29B e6AD 20 AD 28 AD 34 AD 48 AD 82 AD 123AD 161 AD 14 M 141 49 i 16 M 27 M 33 M 28 M 56 M 2 AC 25 CP four montlis 120 AD 157 46S 454 484 512 133 Sfl 8ifi 120 435 161 663 360 588 27 247 91 98 336recover taxes 8 29 S 178 a 146 NY 364 discretion lOlM 446 337 iUegal tax 3 29S 176 78 336 348 unpaid note 21 AD , 114 9 29 S 499 88 257 351 affidavit s 29 U 113 839 34 851 34 373 insurance 29 !j "interest" 113 AD 77M 128 731 226 426 bill partic B 29 S 148 i4a !H y 647 429 contract 8i29S a 146 NY 434 appeal s27B a 31 NC 439 defense s29 S pleading answer 8AD 45AD 36M 8AU 14AC 487 damages 69 M 843 492 reason rules 8 29 S 633 70 AD 500 rules necessary 20AC 142n 496defense » 29 S 557 103 AD 563 not free acts lOlM 684 500 exemptions s 29 S 667 7 AC 330n 332n 503 bill partic. s 29 S 621 IAD 76 33 AD 565 69 AD 450 6 AC 223 8AD duty 211 NY 260 84 AD 607 mens, damages 122 AD 131 65K 247 liability 120 AD 826 duty defendant 151AD 277 diity state 151AD 278 572 amendmen s 29 S 529 84 129 conclusive 82 AD 461 waiver e 13 M 269 14 AC 277n 575 atty's lien 225 a28 S a 151 NY report case 12 -28 8 jurisdiction 50 M s30S a 161 NY ptner by estoppel case 13 8 28 S 47 M Ubel case 14 8 28 8 ' 147 NY waive objns. 18AC 437 motion transler f 87 M 14 378 weight of ev s 29 S 156 a 150 NY 573 63 AD 62 AD 65 AD 7 AC 76 234 246 246 466n 443 waiver s2us r 144 NY s22AD 13M 380 demurrer s29S 181 65 AD 53 amendment 17 M 4?r undue influence 38 M Sfif possession 142 AD 49H 166 AD 95 56 M 184 78 M urn title 54ItI 151 compliance 141 AD 10 void assessment 141. AD 11 easements 88 M 701 387 title defense 8 29 8 133 a 149 NY 610 44 M 64 99M 1U9 393,as8um'd risk s29S 226 a 144 NY 718 41 AD 340 docks public 50 AD 53H 59 AD 91 owner duty 30 AD 127 defendt's duty f 180AD 86U 400 auttiority 8 29 8 168 r 149 NY 174 450meas damage b2uS 223 11 AD 663 competent ev. 25 AD 87 454jury question d 29 s 23U do 118 AD 436 436 199 144 860 16' 366 101 11 2;0n 46n 388 '316 626 127 462 reformation s29.S ^33 a 149 NY 92 amendment lAC pleading IISAD recovery 75M 49n 473 injunetion s29 8 187 a 151 NY 166 d 17 AD ■ 69 479 probate will 8 29 8 a 147 NY s 147 NY m 148 NY 8 161 NY SI4AD 117 AD 38 CP adl. -evidence 80 M 24 136 699 721 403 431 1£0 299 288 487 adl allow 8 29 S 205 33 AD 139 compensation 1118 443 1117 622 3411 625 1118 83 1117 59 509 seduction 3 29 8 542 r 144 NY 361 81 391 52 1 legacy vest^g 403 535 529 553 240 8 29 8 a 145 NY 47 AD 31 M 78M construction 31 M 664 same meaning d 78M 251 524 scope em- ployment 3 29 8 540 e 64 AD 494 527 notice re- moval 3 29 8 481 r 149 NY 605 11 M 148 537 life estat e s 29 8 216 144 NY 562 after- burn 125 AD 19S revoke will 19A0 18n 541 meas dam a 29 8 628 27 M 611 carrier neg. 17 AC 423n 424n 29 8 a 145 NY e34M SAC elOAC 10 AC 15 AC expenses 61 M 37CP admr. funds 37 CP 260 attorney fees ( 142 AD 517 enforce lien VOL. 79 covenant tax 3 29 8 21 M \3 eq 3 29 8 2 AC 18 libel 3 29 8 466 208 relief 510 384n 446 communication a 151 NY 656 23 revers error 544 ruling 3 29 8 e3AD substitution 1 AC 355ii error appeal 6 AC 73n atty. general 68 M 63! 549 sparks neg. 3 298 625 22 AD 613 J ary question 55 AD 627 67 AD 193 560 vicious dog 29 8 805 • 161 NY . 662 knowl. defense lAC 81 567 town bridge s 29 S . 563 671 603 11 87n 4 loen 188n 322 261 61 I ejectment case 2 8 28 8 831 a 163 NY 229 222NY 102M 586 iiabeas corpus 8 29 8 24 AD do 24 AD 360 638 613 aesumpsit case 2 s 28 8 8 a 149 NY report case 4 8 28 8 a 150 NY decision case 6 3288 a 149 NY verdict case 6 28 8 a 149 NY 211 309 310 588 negligence a 29 8 426 d 69 AD 95 f 107 AD 288 599 opening default s 29 8 475 1 AC 65n 6 AC 36n 601 dutyr. r. 29 S 49U a9LRA 524n error judgt. 69LH.A 545n550D injury child 153 AD 38U 603 mortgage infants a 20 8 213 e 23 AD 364 e 26 AD 392 necessaricB 66 AD 674 14 AC 71n 6 1 4 fraud sase 1 8288 f 78 decision case 2 8 28 8 a 150 NY 615 contract case 2 s20S r 149 NY S report case 6 8 29 8 a 149 NY 6 1 8 implied warranty case 4 609 cond void. case 4 b28S 51 AD 24 CP waive right case 8 184 NY 8 28 8 jurisdiction 60 M damages case 7 s28S r 149 NY report case 10 8288 al49NY28867i> partnership case 11 1049 314 7 99 117 622 1117 39 1021 587 1116 576 1117 578 1113 618 863 614 1113 563 1151 585 J 28 8 r 149 NY 136AU arbitrators case 6 s28S a 149 NY decision case 9 s2SS a 149 NY appeal case 10 ■ 28 8 143 NY order case 11 8 28 8 a 149 NY deciesloQ cas 12 3 29 8 a 149 NY ins. policy case 16 s28S r 149 NY damages case 17 8288 r 147 NY 1107 137 '112 1108 343 1109 592 1108 643 1107 580 113 590 1110 307 1110 308 560 101 294 198 689 2 20 483 3 29 8 e 81 83 92 e31 M 1 AC 3 AC e7AC _ communicatn. 88 M 117 consent lOOM 626, 627 capacity 185AD 470 28 strike out 29 8 526 46M 346 incompet. ev s 29 8 S26 126 AD 311 prohibited 77M 509 32 delay nee. a 29 8 "732 206 right recovery ° ?i „ 343 e 19 AD 533 f 86 M 55 law question li ^5 456 96 AD 596 exempl damaees SO a£ 112. fS t 68 AD 628 70 AD 76 AD 93 AD 30 M 12 AC 12 AC 408 326 465 650 78n, 79n 83n, 84 servant's tort 24 AD 620 error charge 71AD " 476 rr. CO rules 71 AD 96 AD •34 M asault 192NY pun. dan 128 AD 477 596 514 373 !S 183 39no negligence s 298 650 178AD 929 44 reformation 3 29 8 a 150 NY entirety 265 674 &)S 48 averments 647 597 351 637 198 AliilKEVlATIONS: a, afifinned ; d, distinguished; f. followed; r. reversed; m, modified- * dism;.:.,^ 0. criticised: 1. limiteU; e, explained; 0, overruled; s, same case; do. dissenting opinion; p, parallel 129 8 I 145 NY 92 1 27 AD - H8 AD competent 181AD 53 warranty 3 29 8 639 1 166 NY 171 ^2 AD 263 i«M_ 66 n, note; case ; q, qusstione Vol. 79 N. Y. Supreme Cotirt Reports — ^Han 56amend com'lt ■ 29 S 644 87 AD 100 63 prom note 505 244 ■ 288 • 81 usury 4 AD 687 e33M 11 AC 328 34d 65 merger ■ 29S 6SAD 36 M -Covenant 16 AC451n,4S4D 16AC 46011 462n negligence 73 M 267 damages 104M 586 69 sp. prfmance e 29S 1146 > 8 AD 366 7b oilat. attack 1 3 1 jury question s 29 S 479 85 571 law 'question 23 AD 29 134 lien levy s 2gs 43 M authority 54 M 633 507 147 79 consideration s 29 S 630 a 145 NY 639 40 AD 90 83 complaint 8 29 S 508 10 AC 285n 87 jurisdiction s29S laAD e 12 AD d23 M 29 M 37 M 67 M ' 616 26 64 51 286 129 36b 93 receiver s 29S 147AD 1 5 I injunction s 29 S 729 a 150 NY 575 26 CP 6 1 56 new trial s 29 B 768 8 516 . 59 iimitationa s 29 B 274 59 M 296 1 62 answer deft 3 29 S 517 119 AD 391 167 remedies s 29S 524 75M 333 1 74 new trial a 29 B 539 a 150 NY 681 f 88 613 ncitice liability 37 AD 317 41 AD 192 do 49 602.608 99 commissions 8 29 S 656 20 M 560 50 M . 549 power sale 72 M 243 103 equity reliei 8 29 S 636 a 152 NY 121 1 AC 322n receiver ev. 124 AD 747 I07t:ood faith « 29 S 37 AD 11 M preference S2 M 118 AD 1 13 review e29S a 151 NY 62 conclusive 55 AD 68 AD 659 '207 500 216 284 406 624 224 84 1 1 7 fact to court 8 29 S 5ia a 149 NY 477 7 AD 578, 584 120 Pers. injury 8 29 IS 496 a 147 NY 49 1 28 harmless error 8 29 S 433 50 AD ^l?fl s29S m 147 NY 81 1 AC 8 AC compliance 47 AD 106 AD m 2 AC assignee 136AD 757 150 345 77n 93u 236 510 351 772 187 NY 31 64 M 433 19 AC 366n, 370 2 1 5 vendor lien s 29 B 502 r 161 NY waive lien 20AC 106M 71 belong estate 152AD 751 283sp. prfmance s 29 S 372 649 230 a 151 NY 126n 220 jurisdiction 3 29 B 507 55 AD 293 S AC 409, 411n dismissal costs 8 AC 412n 222 contract s 29 B 568 a 146 NY 381 226 execution s nyH 555 d 52 AD iiij disocntiuuance 27 M 30 54 M 4o7 229 preferences 396 586 149 239 234 261 292 394 24. s 2M B a 149 NY 84 87 4 AD 22 AD 46 AD lAC 199 NY 286 delivery a 29 S 345 92 466 28 AD 275 290eq Gonversn. 8 29 S 384 58 AD 446 s 31 NC 468 not contingent 179AD 227 296 homicide s 29 B 376 a 143 NY 669 declarations 120 AD 771 d772 f 212 NY 23p 304 wife earn ings e88 AD 111 AD 159 NY compliance 112 AD 176 costs s29S 1 AC 36a 82 26 82 726 308n 1 83 trade secret 8 29B d4 AD do 4 AD' injunction e27 AD d68 AD 126 AD 34 M 61 M 131 agreement lOOM patentable 185AD 1 97 costs 8 30 S 1 AC bastards 177AD 1143 574 679 225 291 929 314 ,132 419 lie 308 124 203 reformation s 29 S 537 95 AD 565 206 cumulative remedy s 29 S 622 23 AD 358 foreclosure 75M, 333 2 1 reversal s29S 613 8 AC 159d .29 8 e61 AD 75 AD 43 M 2 AC 14 AC 15 AC vest in 82 M 430 50 126 659 148n 206n 284 wife 565 235 conversion s 29 8 352 a 147 NY 215 241 new trial s 29 B 361 138 AD 278 247 Kilt title 29 B 419 37 AD 291 revoke gift 63 M 89 250 rescission M B 416 d 12 AD 366 21 M 98 255 expert ev s 29 ii 368 85 305 excessive dam. 47 AD 630 258 demurrer 9 29 8 410 65 AD S3 1 AC 267n 10 AC 283n 264 statute limitations ' 8 29 S 350 7 AD 465 cond. precedent 16 M 318 25 CP 40-405 268 surplus in come s 29 S 440 m 149 NY 520 3 AC 164n enforcement 143 434 power court 151 AD 107 275 indemnity" 9 29 8 423 92 139 52 M 372 280 income n 29 8 362 221NY 386 ?() M 68 307 release ev. _29S a 161 NY 16 AD 50 AD AD 96 AD 155 AD 19 AC restoration 136AD restitution 145 AD 17 conclusive 437 666 205 91 402 112 386 439n 289 82 M 450 3 1 counterfeit- ing evidence s 29 S 381 a 144 NY- 647 3 1 4 covenant 29 8 488 s 162 NY 324 31 M 615 348, receiver accounting 8 29 8 373 8 79 351 8 20 AD 402 35 1 leave to sue 29 8 376 16 AC 295n 352 undisclosed principal 29 8 484 a 160 NY 209 358 privilege s 29 B 434 83 AD 474, 476 1 AC 331n 364fact question 29 8 450 8 AD 611 366 injunction 29 8 467 f 79 614 369 annul charter 29 S 449 B 81 , 542 371 negligence 8 29 S a 146 NY dg2 pleading 117 AD 38 CP 4 AC 26 CP 409 demand 29 8 810 108 AD 11 8 A.C 25gn, 34gn 4 1 arrest manner 29 8 46 AD e 13M 37 M jurisdiction do 216 NY 541 216 NT 543 451 327 113 225 17 38 1 lis pendens 3 29 B 791 *144 NY 643 382 impeach- ment s 29 8 792 86 AD 4 387 allegation 8 167 AD 388 reply 8 29 8 7 AC 793 102 770 287n 242 334 403 601 796 302 767 637 461 devise s29S e 10 AD 50 AD ntent 68 AD 383,384 463 imprisonmt 29 8 983 7 AC 211n 467 discharge 3 29 8 .— a 147 NY 589 457 400 374 110 415 IM 995 performance 114 AD 774 incumbrance 18 AC 415n. 420 19 AC 34n 3 19 good title 29 S 459 r 149 NY 460 329 bonds int. 29 8 347 f 9 M 684e 686 335 demurrer 8 29 S 427 124 AD 521 jury question 18 AC 38n burden plaintifl 149AD 150 AD privilege 184AD 390 negligence s 29 S ,784 11 AD 155 requests error 79 AD 22 392 complaint 8 29 S 783 a -43 NY 665 47 AD 392 87 AD- 36 f 92 AD . 614 cause action do 149 AD 165 394 unauthorized 29 S 794 20 M 564 jurisdiction 7 AC 53n 397 security 3 29 8 782 a, 149 NY 360 400 lis pendens 29 8 798 a 144 NY 140 62 M 70 M 75M 92 M f 95 M compliance 168 AD remedy 92 M 375 reasons reversal d 216 NT 535 95 M 111 42 1 construction 29 S 961 23 M 651 426 trustiuvalid 29 8 995 27 AD 289 construction 66M 392 trusts 7.'5 M 487 434jury question 29 S 979 4 AD 534 AD 395 83 AD 329 13 M 166 25 M 669 credibility 129 AD 656 436 verdict 29 8 1023 a 149 NY 596 44 1 estoppel 3 29 8 981 87 346 party in interest 975 177 472 parol 8 20 8 a 156 NY 18 AD 1032 666 260 475 discharge 8 29 S 966 a 143 NY 407 479 damages .29 8 a 151 NY d67AD do 171 NY f lOOM 1000 578 485 4 482 recovery 9 29 S 980 a 144 NY 494 f52 571 86 313 invalid assesst 26 AD 381 483 credr's suit 963 660 661 37 163 9 29 8 a 150 NY 17 M 36 M do 110 AD lien realty 119 AD acquire lifen 39 CP heirs of heirs 136AD 118 money judgmnt. 348 1002 143 89 e 90 61 M conclusive 28 AD e37 AD 15 M 150 NY 25 OP 445 „ 29 8 25 CP 868 611 340r reversal 29 8 364 8 151 NY 661 91 AD 509 407 trial facts 29 8 81 4 AD 17 AD affidavits 25 At) 35 AD 110 AD 797 386 55 326 191 422 334 366 162 588 360 117 666 166 136 990 160 488 devis 3 29S a 151 NY , .- no est. in land 142 AD SI 493 trust s29S a )46NY Tesentment ; 987 467 plaintiff 686 449 29 s 58 M burden 149 AD loOAD 45 1 danlages 29 S d4AD d6 AD 28 AD e43 ND 35 M 971 169 582 387 81 49 453 construction 29 S 968 87 114 456 demand 29 8 a 150 NY 11 AC 168n 140 AD f 151 AD 633 911 917 13 507 Possession 29 S 899 64 M 589 suspension 70 M 282 5 1 1 alienation 3 29 8 941 88 *53 23 AD 544 charge court 27 AD 376 delivery deed 61 AC 276n motive _„ 71 M 578 5 1 7 deliver deed 9 29 8 904 16 AC 276u 526 estoppel 3 29 S 878 4 AC 380n 184 NY a 74 construction 96 M 208 531 extensions s 29 S ■ 925 575l«0AD 483 consideration . ABBBEVIATiON8 : a, affirmed; d, distinguished; I, followed; c. crmcised: 1. limited; e, explained! o, overruled; s. same t;„.,e ; d reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, now o. disseiuing ooinion: p. parallel case; q. questionea N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Hon Vols. 79, 80 9 AC 49 M 22011 400 535 pleading g 29 S 933 107 AD 137 14 AC 49n 609 report case 3 b29S a 15) NY, new trial case 8 s29S a 151 NY 1145 643 1148 626 54 1 weight of ev s 29S 930 610 contract 3 92 70 case 7 legal error s 29 S 1143 143 AD 607 a 149 NY 489 103 AD |^76 548iury question s 29 S 871 s 151 NY 635 a 152 NY 623 82 171 172 199 22 AD 55 AD 97 AD 18 M 145 AD 275 29 30 450 504 77 61 I jviry question case 9 s29B r 148 NY yerdict case 10 s29S a 149 NY VOL.80 I account 13 AD 208 a 29 S 810 books evidence 7 AC 473n480n 4 reduce verd't B 29 S 8 AD courts power 72 AD 323 damages II AC 57 75 adjudication 1147 182 1148 612 8 stockholders 47 AD contempt s30S 19 M [.,• 40 M SIM 1 AG 7 AC 816 12 AC 409 demand 51 M reversal 123AD indemnity 68 M 550possession s 29 S 881 19 AD S20 38AD 86 50AD 141 16M 578 555 damages a29S a 151 NY 560 intent s29S a 151 NY 25AD 36 M 28CP competent lOlM 565 review 8 29 8 7 AC 612 excess dam case 1 8 29 S 337 s 86 265 613 decision case 2 8 29 S 1142 a 150 NY 576 29 8 e84 87 32 AD 51 AD d77AD 148 NY e 159 1 43 AD 1107 139 1 I rental dam 8 31 S 13 2 AD 403 restrictions 48 AD 458 measure dam, 69 AD 312 65M 255 1 3 conclusive s 30 8 103S 49 ment'I capac s31 !S 47 AD proof IflM presumption 18 M 27 M 177 180 74' 163 421 142 AD conclusions 77M 1 50 fencing sSlS , a 156 ifY a 144 NY e9AD jurisdietion 15 M 57m 25 CP not binding 141 AD 1 5 pub. policy 700 424 657 619 161 b31S 6 81 AD 179 NY 14 AC 139 AD 174 AD invalid 144 AD 281 422 92 366 733 700 109 1 8 notice lien s31S a 151 NY e 165 NY invalid d 148AD mistake d 98 M 73 636 301 691 336 20 purchaser s31S 159 a 146 NY 386 24 competent ev 42 611 s31 S 34 AD misjoinder 41 AD allege proof 16 M 19 CP surety 192 NY ; 27 damages s31S 6 AC 196 567 309 501 29 spl, partner B 31 S 324 r 145 NY 488 39 mechan. lien s 31 S 286 r 153 NY 476 46 discretion s31S 38 35 M new trial IAD 175 AD 16 AC 162 114 683 46 496 117n new desc'd ev 4 AD 21 AD 32 AD 42 AD 45 AD 53 AD 55 AD 60 AD IIM 103M 333 626 150 396 544 378 477 631 468 334 469 weight of ev. 68 AD 478 16 M 613 not known 153 AD 265 51 partnership 8 31 S 68 a 162 NY 638 62 Stat, limit'ns s 31 S 65 16 M 403 harmless error 11 AC. 20n authority 116AD 4 67 extra work a 31 S 186 r 158 NY 276 7 AD 508 do610 election 33 AD 314 priority 185 NY 127 73 set aside deed 862 195 100 634 1 58 performance s3lS a 152 NY 86 110 AD interest 81 M recovery 54 AY 4 AC 295 626 338 398 61 625 108 210 NT try title 93 M 202 ) (ability 68 M s3lS 12 AD 76 against s 31 S . f 91 M 80 lunatic 9318 1 a 151 NY 6 how enforced 94 M 34 75 179 city 88 483 88no iniunction i 318 17 97 M 287 125 d 282 improper claims 68 M ■ 544 93 trade names s31S * 148NY 92 SAC lO; 732 67n 98 Stat, frauds 31 S 202 a 153 NY 696 1 08 monument s 31 S 671 76 AD 341 11 AC 429n 432 110 AD 77 accountings 31 M 80 construction 137 AD 607 ( i 1 7 surplus in- come ' i318 164 4 AD 323 alimony 153 AD 464 cred'rs of wife 161 AD 523 duty trustee E 96 M 212 1 25 demurrer 3 318 91 10 AD 133 HAD 436 ecclesias court 18 AD 238 admissions 94 AD 636 ecclesias right e20M 44 M 87 M 16 AC 16 AC finding 239 176 323 167n 341n 1 64jury question 331S a 146 NY 86 88 92 4AI> SAD IS AD 26 AE 39 AD 41 AD 49 AD 13 AC 317 367 167 199 151 496 460 411 663 643 619 . 97 420n 1 73 presumption s31 8 13 AD 326 664 179 bar s31S 977 r 181 US 155 a 165 NY 12( 4AD- 531 cruelty 21 AD 145 74 AD 691 21 M 37f a 5 AC 92 counsel fees 7 AC 245d necessity 194 NY 183 iOPNS 158 103 285 pers, injury 3 31 S ■ 479 do 47 AD 630 292 flse represn 190 accounting s 31 8 413 8 AD 401 25 AD 632 30 M 78 incompetent 56 iVI 16 199 discretion s 31 8 ■ 307 90 88 74 AD -566 37 CP 67 abuse disctn. 137AD 103 2 1 5 ratification s 31 S 299 a 151 NY 671 17 M 164 226 foreclosure 9 32 8 64 * 145 NY 606 227 conclusive s 31 8 274 8 AC 167n 232 parties s31S a 146 NY 39 AD 66 AD 173 NY 38 M tenant curtesy 48 AD 373 allegations LI M 306 controverted f 153 AD 558 adverse claim 230 363 106 308 97 667 238 intention s 31 8 272 43 AD 283 partition realty 13 AC 132nl41n 143n pers. property do 160 AD 298 copartners 160 AD ' 295 242 contempt s3rS 373 r 147 NY 290 262 personal transaction s31S 1.^4 AD 369 265 award s 31 S 83 M 254 334 268 vol. expos, 3 31 S 343 a 147 NY 693 7 AD 429 89 AD 391 proof defendant 174 AD 599 281 discretion s31S 90 90 M 32 CP abuse disctn. 137AD 470 88 269 231 s31 8 a 151 NY 43 AD 298 parties s31 8 92 authority 35 AD 45 AD 57 AD e 94 AD e33M 44 M SAC certiorari 53M 303 survival s318 24 AD 3 1 AC 9 AC remedy ^ 82 M receivers 180AD lOOM 487 278 16 363 amendment s3lS 41 AD e76 AD el2AC may sue 85 M. 248 15 76 67 117 146 224 197 457 307 74 337 228 13S 66n 522 194 475 308 willfulness 183AD 613 3 1 3 appraisal 318 245 HAD 451 a 147NY 69 capital stock 179AD 724 3 1 8 presumption 318 185 8 AD ■ 408 neg. overflow 16 M 17M 36 M 46 M neg. 66M 47 596 526 601 679 320 preeumpt'n s 31 8 481 s91 74 Stat, limitation 16 M 403 26 CP 314 323 counsel fees s 31 8 502 a 146 NY 398 82 AD 46 199 20 M 316 29 M 299 338 certiorari 31 S 499 152 NY 51 156 NY 64 82 614 s 22 AD 172 352 exemptions 3 31 8 245 a 145 NY 373 353 show cause s 31 8 472 e 37 M 607 s 1 AC 118 46 M 592 pendente lite 37 CP 69 357 bill partic. 31 8 496 29 AD 394 124 514 party affidavit 81 AD 442 27 M 607 32 M 444 150AD 150 AD "fraud" 158 AD 426 bequest s318 r 153 NY 143 366 misjoinder s 31 8 474 44 M 471 389 partitions s 31 8 490 91 AD 190 376 receivership s318 340 f 91 227 levy 14 AD 338 380 insurance s 31 S 237 d 26 AD 280 388 ordinance a 146 NY 365 s318 234 86 AD 141 ev. negligence 19AC 21Sn 163 AD 24 390 conversion 31 S 342 2 AC 41 2n 396 equity courl s 31 S 259 a 152 NY , 622 5 AD 628 harmless error U AC 27n 31n 40 1 compet. ev. s 31 S 251 88 . 211 wife's earnings 51 AD 50 89 AD 118 43 M 669 2 AC 14Sn 14 AC 20811 vest in wife 82 M 565 405 estoppel s31S SAD 167 NY 409 intent s31S 37 AD d 162 NY indictment 137 AD 157 AD 239 620 243 267 284 631 827 342 4 1 5jury question s 31 S 364 a 164 NY 767 55 AD 112 duty commr. 68 M 287 418 no relief s 31 S 263 68 M 13 73 M 582 419 discretion s 31 S 263 * 146 NY 637 23 AD 207 74 AD 222 creditor's money 73M 582 open decree 150 AD a 152 NY right whole 7GM cotenants f 91 If 476 84 219 36 37 38 371 432 discretion s318 610 42 AD 660 436 amendment s 31 S ' 740 94 AD 599 18 M 662 439 power court s 31 8 968 a 146 NY 366 87 346 86 AD 293 99M 245 testam; capacity e 27 AD 627 e 43 AD 3S9 99M: 252 law question 19A0 286D not final 94 M 577 expert evidence 1658 732 449 goodspledge 3 31 8 706 a 147 NY 223 460 acquiescence s 31 8 781 84 AD 669 107 AD 363 hirine year 127 AD 285 462 luriediction 500 authority 3 31 S 776 a 145 NY 596 2 AD 34 508 certiorari s 31 8 781 a 145 NY 696 509 judgment 8 31 S 716 a 145 NY 606 5 1 5 lien depoBic s 31 8 530 a 147 NY 184 a 2 AC 288 523 execution s31S a 147 NY 86 31 CP creditor lien 53 AD contract 147AD 470 devise class s318 729 719 646 731 479 expres trusts s 31 S 654 30 CP 179 e 13 AD 347 lease meaning e 162 NY 148 162 severance 39 M 362 488 compenstan s 31 S ' 614 78 AD 469 114 AD 4S9 survivor duty 3SM salary 114 AD 494 devise bequest s 31 S a 174 NY 86 22 M 85 M 478 519 693 2S2 213 644 31 8 147 N\ 87 AD elect remedy 56M; 527 parties 9 318 a 147 NY el3AD 47 AD relief 49 AD intervention 72 AD 169 NY reservation 36 M 704 275 306 637 686 385 348 136 183 361 533 damages 9 31S 610 a 162 NY 641 do 173 AD 750 ruling error 144 AD . 652 no extension 75M 638 presumption 177AD 754 537 construot'n 3 31 8 622 e7AD HI fr'd judgment 12 AD 494 18 AD 435 26 AD 579 26 CP 93 15 M 401 24 M , 299 permit judg't 3 AC 3B8n ABBREVIATIONS: a, afltirmed; d, distinguished; f. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; •dismissed; n, mm e, criticised ; 1, limited; «. explained; o, overruled: s, samecase; ao, dissenting opmion ; p, parallel case: q, questioaM N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — ^Han Vols. 82, 83 545 deed record U 155 NY 8 31S 527 negligence a 152NY 39 125AD 553 bond reoirals 1)313 714 a 146NY 210 556 negligence 649 71 396 591 471 603 190 644 73 VOL 83 1 AC 190n counterclaim 16AC 462d ■ 31 S 6 AD 53 AD 72 AD q 168 AD 22 H 36 M request exceptn. 148AD 715 559 preeumption B 31 S 541 a 152 NY 636 561 reference s31S 548 a 145 NY 595 atty's lien 40 M 413 8 AC 88n 9 AC 229n before court 93 M 604 570 void assmt. 8 31 S 783 a 145 NY 641 575 amendment 4 certificate ev a 155 NY 671 614 poor person s 31 S 113S{9I costs - 7 AC 461n8 31S r 146 NY 9 presumption s 31 S 632 16 M 511 discretion 20 M 352 ceriif of ev 7 AC 461n 462n 1125 627 1125 447 case 1 s33 8 r 151 NY fraud case 4 s33S a 156 NY new trial case 5 s33S a 152 NY damages case 7" _33 8 a 155 NY report case S 9 33S a 152 NY new trial case 19 _ 33 8 a 152 NY order arrest 18BAD 594 i31! f 15AD e41 AD 69 AD e78AD 84 AD e94 AD 118 AD 170 AD 33 M 61 M 1 AC 19AC 187NY 38 CP ICPNS 1130 625 1126 112 1136 635 1134 652 737 627 556 102 489 468 416 83 613 381 384 32 448 268 117 204 6 1 5 certiorar case 1 31 8 r 152NY new trial case 5 _31 S a 155 NY case 6 trespass sSlS a 151 NY pers. injury case 7 _31S a 151 NY ejectment case 11 s318 - r 152 NY amendment 29 OP. 326 I I certiorari r 144 NY 483 8 31 S 769 1 9 damages 8 318 692 e 86 380 jiury question s 90 280 283 221NY 161 transfer corp 55 AD general scope 80 AD ratificaton 95 AD 501 51 1129 632 274 853 401 55 il3 AD 126 127 23 M 8 1 AC . 278 construction 113 AD 128 costs demur 18AC 411 19A0 412n 38 CP 188 53 M 39 interlocutor; 19A0 410 92 construction p2SM 8 31 8 a 151 NY 92 81 AD d81 AD validity 205NY 406 657 576 372 374 449 1 39 insurance r 145 NY 863 8 26 8 s31 S 1133 143 abuttors s 31S 630 73M 649 I 5 1 conclusive II AD 561 eq remedies e 41 AD 360 s 31 S 582 1 53 contract a 155 NY 636 s 31 S 660 1 55 commissions 192 surety 8 31 8 192 NY 397 507 1 96 negligence s 3 AD S63 365 s31S 102 AD 121 AD 130 AD 137 AD 20 M compensation 80 M ■ 533 507 347 745 419 568 560 acctg. 602 308 295 580 opens street 8 31 S 732 a 148 NY 764 585 prom, note s 31 8 605 a 146 NY 20 59 I annual repo't 8 318 si AD 29 M authority 56M 702 368 47] 392 594 compet. ev s 31 8 543 49 AD 636 partnship prop. 13 AC 129n 130n 602 accumulat'n a 31 8 764 86 AD 437 82 M 13 income 53M 204 607 contract s 31 8 724 15 AD 299 allegations 126 AD 346 6 1 I power sale case 15 8 30 S 1020 31 M 195 613 appeal 4tli dept case 3 8 33 8 1128 1130 4i: 1134 173 25 com, s318 4 6 AD costs 61 AD objections 86 AD 560 power ceases 19M 690 discretion court 13 AC 19n jurisdiction 13 AC 365n 368n 96 town liability s 148 NY. 737 s 31 8 402 1 03 certif ev. i318 361 7 AC 461n 107 constitutn'l s 31 8 390 21 M 279 I I carrier neg. a 155 NY 668 s 31 S 357 17 AC. 215n 30 parties 17AD 45 AD 8 31 8 619 355 513 I 57 constitutn'l 8 31 8 564 21 M 279 future legislation 36 M 285 onus proband! I 1 2 knowledge a 155 NY d2AD s31S II AC 631 143 230n 32 grounds s 31 8 608 e 5 AD 557 expert witneeees e 15 AD 95 e 88 AD 59 S3M 23 151AD 82 change venue 38 OP 66 66ii 34 recoupment e 55 AD 620 8 31 8 514 43 consideration 27 AD 225 318 trademark ILRANS 709o I 1 4 parol 3 318 HAD 63 AD lease privilege' 50 benefits 31S 64M 421 7'J-M I 59 accord d78AD 87 AD 8 31 8 el5M 19M 21 M 1 60 accruing a 146 NY s31 S trusts 49 M 459 589 485 588 629 22x 176 77 386 650 revers. error el9AD due care 60 AD 473 8 318 618 136AD 666 res ipsa loq. 149AD 427 obligation 81 M 313 20 5 replevin s 31 8 598 154 NY 668 125 S 475 208 dismissal a 162 NY 333 8 318 662 a 4 AC 151 2 AC 2S4n 21 I jury question f 89 605 59 AD 367 s 31 8 757 limltatn liability 89 AC 117n 54 M 449 primary cause 71 M 35 pioximate cause 78 M 567 240 ne^ trial s 31 S 399 7 AC 207n 243 „ 6 31 8 144 NY 620 701 250 pers injury a 158 NY 681 6 31 S 305 254 certificate 654 541 52 AD t 169 AD 13 M 2 AC extension 187NY parol ev. 55 M hold over 83 M 103 602 665 195 375 252 492 586 1 68 services r 146 NY 332 s 31 8 . 655 law question 1 162 AD 515 1 74 assignment 67 596 a 153 NY s31 8 735 270 53 consideration s31S 38 M 73 appeal 3 318 a 148 \Y 935 370 713 737 76 objectns error 17 AD 186 8 318 368 86 trespass dam. a 165 NY s31S 88 eviction 8 31 8 19 M election 538 370 358 524 I I 6 commissions a 151 NY 673 3 31 8 392 agreement 55 M 546 1 24 conclusive 8 31 8 371 44 AD 233 27 M 275 remedy 59 AD 260 coUat. attack 98 M 143 1 27 sup. pro 8 6 AD 609 8 31 8 627 1 AC lS5n not vest receiver 157 AD 615 1 30 trustees a 144 NY 616 18 AD 318 s 31 S 758 constitutional 171 NY 82 409 410 659 a 145 NY 4 AD authority s318 ratification 21 M 626 219 257 consent a 146 NY 375 8 318 1101 7 AC 412n 415n 259 reiirburse- ment a 146 NY 257 s 31 8 588 269 objections 58M 139 271 contrib. neg 8318 8 7 AD 18 AD 22 M 42 M 1 78 review 82 AD f 82AD 8 31 8 . . _ e8st district d 181 NY. 27 181 discretion 38 204 not appealable 6 AD 8 31 8 593 mandamus 44 M 477 2 1 3 pleading SjSlS 588 s 87 AD 496 sp> pleading 122AD 829 2 1 4 weight of ev. a 152 NY 640 8 31 8 391 2 1 7 compliance 23 AD 264 by-laws d 43 AD 31 8 318 665 change benefic. 28 M 685 14 AC 185n 220 Ubel proof a 152NY 621 s 31 8 567 S6 482 115AD 817 Stat limitations 19 AD 435 return of debtor 20M!"54 .^ 340 16 AC ' 304n damages 22 M 670 burden proof 112 AD 290 guaranty 18AC 325 1033 515 520 426 457 79 155 1 85 assessment e91 IAD 3 318 e24M certiorari do 101 AD 279 law remedy 4 AD 562 31 S 920 no compulsion f 161 AD 193 282partie8 dowe 8 31 8 921 11 M 257 damage 198NY 410 284 urisdiction 16 AD 499 8 31 8 941 pro rata 114 AD 465 72 M . 259 claim vs. lunatic 19A0 74, 82 83 not preferred f 75M 162 286rights tenant 1 88 counsel fees 3 318 591 7 AC 241n 242n alimony i 177AD 7 AC order f 158 AD 830 247n I90bailee'i 3 31 8 10 AC 948 lien 599 144n a 156 NY 672 e49 AD 138 3 318 963 conclusive 14 M 530 entire rent due 2 AC 340 defense 8 AC 428n 429n direct verdt 59 M tenancy 59 M reversal 59 M 225 contempt a 154 NY 747 ; 3 31 S 664 ; 215 exr. trustee 20 182AD 525 1 592 230 sample sale 8 31 8 601 ' 13 AC 223n , 233 agency 8 318 585,. „ 29 M 639 7 AC 481n undisclosed prin. L„_ 44 M 333,295 presumption a 153 NY 652 234 pleading I*? AD 333 464 469 470 293 communi- cation 92 198 3 318 914 3 AC 20 17 AD 8 318 237 costs a 145 NY 8 318 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f. followed; r. reversed; m, modified- c. criticised: I. hmited; e, explained; o. overruled: s. same case; do, di '- "v.'""""'™. 40755AD 122 68i!a31S 936 ll3 AC 340n 341n 597; 298 tenancy 569 3 31 S 954 dissenting opinion ; p. dismissed ; n. nuie . parallel case; q, questioned Vols. 83, 84 N. y. Supreme Court Reports — Hun 14 AC 349n 303 new trial 15 AD 45 ev. coQcluaive 32 AE 026 sBlS 042 corroboration £ 167 AD 76 307 books ev sSlS 918 2 AC 312n 9AC 148n 3 1 order fsa s31S 61S 1028 3 1 7 contract r 153 NY 51 s 31:S 917 320 compet. ev 50 AD 365n sola 304 declarations 91 AD 437 s 31 S 938 18 M 142 327 retrial 47 AD 181 69 AD 476 s 31 S 680 presumption 18 M 152 for jury 81 M 394 332 guaranty a 146 KY 368 3 31 S 742 338 neg atty s 31 S 987 46 M 124 7 AC 388n performance 68 M 40 342 discovery 48 AD 335 no knowedge 89 AD 496 9 31 S 965 jurisdiction 28 M • 603 source informatn 38 M 251 5 AC 270n 54 M 273 344 construction b31 S 990 35 M 485 privileged 2 AC SOn 353 election * 48 AD 298 141 AD 849 s 31 S 985 39 M 423 presup, knowldg 149AD 576 estopped 81 M a 103M 106 362 Stat frauds s 13 AD 567 24 AD 441 title vesting 26 AD 406 s 31 S 903 parol agreement 119 AD 565 do 658,559 express trust 68 M 553 368 contribution s31S 961 36 M 276 remainder 71 M 61 special devisees f 163 AD ao 371 damages 43 AD 96 AD 9 31S 474n 90 912 379 waiver aSlS e26M no waiver 146AD privileged 33 M 2 AC inadmissible 183AD 744 907 57 377 554 SOri 381 performance 15 AD 68 s 31 S 924 393 chge. beeficn s 31 B 875 14 AC 19Un 398 parol proof 763 767 81 878 299 48n 135 s31ti 117AD 403 costs 54 AD s31S 31 M 2 AC SAC 407 intersect r. r d 56 AD 633 103 AD 167 3 31 S 746 417 usury e 31 y 946 49 M 421 constitutional do 189N Y enforcement 74M 22 48 420 entire estate r 147 NY 660 8 31 S 950 42 M. 142 426 new trial r 152 498 BAD 56 31 S 861 432 authority 92 22 AD 43 AD 61 AD e 99 AD s31S 5 AC 588 281 26 511 112 • 749 307n 446 affidavits s31S f5AD 8 AD 28 AD 155 AD 934 112 567 619 34 SUb 449 public use rl47YN 104 e 33 AD 610 B 29 S 950 s31S 1131 lease amend 158 AD 755 462 exemptions a 160 NY 660 e 41 AD 394 do 41 AD 397 56 AD 346 347 d 165 NY 582 s31S 1038 465 authority 9 AD 28 14 AD 10 loss jurisdiction 7B AD 183 8 31 S 908 10 AC 84n 87n 12 AC 67 waive objns. 18AC 425n 47 1 frd transfer e 90 608 35 AD 607 •a 31 S 1042 473 jurisdiction a 152 NY ■ 297 42' AD 570 s 31 S 1049 nom. damages 27 M 246 DieaB. damage 30 M *7 479 negligence a 32 S 36 79 AP 241 98 AD :iU5 482 commissions 70 AD 46 B 32 S 71 deit. not held' 143 AD 452 486 execution 8318 1119 11 AC 271 489 valid trust 261 131 87 lOSn a31S al58Y IAD 81 AD 18 M d 160NY 95 AD notice SAD 1105 672 499 236 267 114 231 296 492 reference s 32 S 32 terminatn notice 31 M 78 338 10 AC 293n 53 M 178 not apply to surrogate 390P 60 494 directors loan 37 AD 403 s 31 S 1046 500 notice s 32S 10 12 AC 176n 180n contempt ellO AD 22 serve atty, 121AD 760 509 open default s32S 17 6 AC 33n 51 I jury question s31d a 155 NY sl57 ..Y r 158 NY s 158 NY 64 AD 1057 686 874 140 683 552 522opinion rule 32 S 84 £ 168 AD 402 526 divesting B 32 S 480 a 148 NY 761 1 AD 288 power of sa'e 71 AD 26 27 106 AD 447 91 M 361 eq. conversion 147AD 749 534 salary a 152 NY S2AD a 33 8 14AC 541 appeal s32S coat* 3 AD 546 share holder a 152NY 829 17 AD 35 s31 S 1068 Stat limitations 22 M 490 avoidance 4AC 328n pleading 124 AD 733 jtkhldr. right 124AD 734 553 exceptions a 145 NY s32S 26 AD action 683 48 382 3UU 555 judgment a 3m 1113 1 155 NY . 689 560 insolvency s 31 S 1096 a 148 NY 316 569 damages a 32 8 U6 AD 42 M reference 118AD 65 lb 588 192 t 61 AD £92 AD 19 M ■ 31 S 27 M ntjw trial caee 6 a 152 NY s31S services case 10 a 153 NY a 31 8 verdict caae 12 a 166 NY B31 S 572 infringemnt b32S 11 19 AD ' 626 24 M 86 e 57 M 107 9 AC 36en Corp. name 62M 274 380 repugnant s 31 8 1072 3 M ■ 402 593 construction a 31 8 1060 28 AD 418 38 AD 429 598 reserve fund a 318 1120 a 145 NY 606 d 150 NY 114 19A.D 81 persistent mem- bers ' 31 AD 160 605iury question 90 512 J 31 8 1046 reversal f 170 AD 340 6 1 direct verdic case 3 a 151 NY s31S easement case 7 a 147 NY 8 31S usury case 10 a 162 NY 8 318 696 1129 367 1127 128 536 6 1 1 damagCE a 164 NY 8 318 711 517 466 1130 567 1130 6 1 2 covenanta caae 3 r 147 NY a 318 legacy caae 4 a 144 NY a 31 8 decision caae 5 a 157 NY a 31 8 verdict 'case. 10 al52NY 8 318 ' insurance case 17 r 151 NV 8 28 AD CS4AD 8 54 AD 8 66 AD 8 31 8 667 1130 622 1127 VOL. 84 I parol ev. 8 318 a 155 NY 16 M 1084 616 634 103 163 386 389 632 1134 613 secure costs caae 2 265 613 264 1126 121 626 1127 641 1132 633 1135 61 4 libel caae 1 a .65 NY do 01 AD a 31 8 unearned premium caae 3 a 162 NY d2AD d26AD a 31 8 title case 5 a 155 NY e97 AD 31 S 8 34 8 right cancel 2Z1NY 169 221NY 170 6 I 5 over flow Sth. Deot. caae 7 m 149 NY 496 31 8 1135 228 263 1127 635 330 94 1131 297 169 1129 1146 1 2 copyright 8 32 8 41 a 161 NY 637 r 156 NY 241 28 undue inS. a 31 S 1053 f 121 AD 400 34 abutng owner s32 8 a 156 NY d27AD 40 trust! 8 32 8 a 152 ND 6 474 197 4 630 e6 ^C 13 AC pleading 17 AC 163 301n 3n 45 fiBe represent a 32 8 74 rl55 NY 344 52 voting reaide a 31 8 1043 a 146 NY 284 £84 611 54 inj. damagea a 31 8 1080 sO AD 486 69 AD 119 60 blast damage 8 318 1091 28 AD 41 proof cured 19 M 61 jury question 20.M S54 64 prohib. writ a 328 ^ 18 a. 148 NV 75 61 AD 10 incomp. witness d 53 AD ' 339 juriadn to review 13M 10 power comr's f 212 NY 167 1 37 bar action 9 32 8 1067 43 AD 35 38 conviction 181AD 116 |d| surety 3 32 8 192 NY 83 defenae a 32S 49 a 158 NY 739 8 AD 366 8 AC 213n mistake paymt 27AD 342 appeal judgmt. f 91 M 17 27 103 liable coupons 3 32 8 a 164 NY 694 696 s 17 AD 636 provisions note 33AD 628 f 92 M 169 certificate 169 NY 149 provisiona bond 177 NY 105 I 1 contrcts liab B 32 8 69 do 164 NY 38 executor 69 M 30' I 1 4 foreign corporatn action 1 8 privileged a 32 8 461 a 156 NY 661 60 AD 516 517 60 AD 520 10 AC 68a 69n 70n. 121 bksev clerk s 32 8 465 7 AC 472n 24Ufeuae 8 32 S 563 e 64 AD 217 do 64 AD 220 construction will e 75 AD 299 do 81 AD 464 do 85 AD 121 37 M 719 absolute title 71 M power 70 M e79M sale 228 378 379 1 28 proof death a 32 8 d82AD conclusive el M am6nd 93 M proofs 1S6AD 513 461 260 584 60 417 507 1 44 neg q fact a 32 S 437 a 155 NY 636 13 AC 420n 1 46 defense 332 8 537 r 166 NY 446 9AD 121 8 AC 210n demurrer 46 M 480 jurisdiction 99M 369 1 48 preference 8 32 S 453 22 AD 261 150 trespass - urvey s 32 8 607 d 88 569 d2AC .. 204 examination 5 AC 270D 154 neg con- clusive s 32 S 459 s 8 AD 167 1 58 interloc judgment 8 32 8 r 156 NY s31S 87 dl3AD 57 AD ISM e24M 41 M si AC 5 AC 1107 619 15 209 424 681 244 343 39 444 521 l65questioa fact 8 32 8 90 20 AD 1 72 tender s32B 18 M 26 M 656 526 16 463 228 618 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, noic c, criticised ; 1. limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s. same case: do, dissentinz opinion; p, parallel case; 560 order notice 8 32 8 1148 62 M 237 56 1 affidavit 8 32 8 861 52 AD 540 2 AC 61n 398n 563 counsel fees s 32 S 869 e 28 M 612 10 AC 186n 10 AC l68n 197n reimburse 113 AD 226 em. counsel 196NT 97 expense exr. 136 519 368 747 453 148 166 eetoppel 62 M prove will 127 8 valid devise 142 AD 368 probate will 78 M 714 527 foreclose 9 32 8 85 r 146 NY 296 533 mortgages 8 32 8 738 a 165 NY 34] transfer debt do 137 AD 802 constructv. ntce. lOoNY 111 537 baggage 8 32 8 29 AD 24 M innkeeper 17 AC 64M 140 AD liabilitv 140 AD 849 592 78 116n 82 418 419 570 eq. account- ing s33 8 411 al52nY 644 84 AD 545 mjunction 57M 107 575 assignment 9 32 8 727 9 9 AD 576 19 AD 541 577 injunction 3 32 8 730 * 145 NY 637 581 pubsoript'n will s32S 845 a 152 NY 645 e43AD 397 8 49 AD 418 67 AD 117 S97AD 509 d32M 614 s34M 444 8 AC 370 e 162 NY 8 probate e42M 81 99M 624 legisl. intent 152AD 239 98 M 95 539 executor s 32 8 850 55 AD 271 no appear 151AD 236 54 \ void purch s 32 8 859 a 152 NY 305 15 M 584 546 conclusive Is 32 8 840 in writing 79 M 673 refuse probate 81M 103 physical end 98 M 96 586 affidavits J32S 851 75 AD 350 86 AD 323 54 M Jfi attv. client ABliREVIATIONS: i G. criticised ; U limited ; affirmed ; t, explai; distinguished ; Truled ; ■ f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; '*, dismissed; n note- samc-;ase; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q, questioned Vols. 84, 85 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Hun 38AC 241n 59 1 CGznpetentcy s33 S 462 45 AD -JIS 594 letter credit 8 32S 63S s 168 NY 64£ a 9 AD 410 412 605 judgment case 6 a 155 NY 681 8 31 S 1128 judgment case 11 a 155 NY 633 B 31 S 1129 coQstrue will case 12 r 154 NY 283 B 31 S 1098 607 performance 3d dept. case IS 612 1150 case 7 641 1141 r 156 NY s32S judgment 3rd dept a 153 NY s32S contract 3rd dept case 9 a 152 NY 540 s32S 1138 fereree rept. 3r. dept case 10 a 152 NY 636 r32S . 1150 malpractice 3rd. dept case 13 r 155 NY 201 s32S 1149 609 contract case 1 s 32 S 859 f 23 AD 39 6 1 I probate 1st dept case 1 case 7 1145 228 s32S a 154 NY discharge 1st dept 8 32S a 152NY voting reside Ist dept case 12 s 32 S 689 -a 147 NY 117 SAC 149n 162n residence case 18 99M SAC 355 153 8 1 5 sup proc case 2 s32S rl47 NY 1142 666 VOL. 85 I intent trust 9 32 S 608 3 AD 292 96 M 209 invalid bequests 22 M 165 27 s32S 66 AD 114 AD e41M 3 1 .proofs s32S r 165 NY 20 AD S66AD 33 defective s32S 20 AD 74 AD ISM si AC affidavit 99 AD 101 AD 109 A D ' equity suit 123AD amendment f 98 M 38 recovery s32S a 168 NY necessaries 601 574 788 537 594 349 277 48 587 513 369 662 300 542 247 332 684 43 unconstitutn'l s 32 S 524 e 20 AD 496 157 NY 616 do 167 NY 21 136 420 46 conclusive s32 S 665 73 631 632 601 487 123 11 AD f 24 AD 29 AD d47AD 22 M review judgt 107 AD 673 reveraaL power 113 AD 477 17 AC 234 72 M 305 49 incom pet. ev 122n 343 waiver lien 20AC variance 79 M vendor's 207 NY not settled 82 M 85 negligence lien 416 s 32 S a 155 NY d 46 AD do 46 AD 46 AD evidence 85 31 M revei-8. 19A0 684 653 1 169 414 141 177 error 2ian 93 fact s 32 S 4 AD s 20 AD 32 AD 53 AD question 680 -487 252 564 500 100 AD 118 perfmce. excuse 45 M ■( 46 negligence s 32 S 62? a 165 NY 64i e 27 AD 378 68 AD 407 scope employ 138 AD 400 1 55 negligence s 32 S 479 4 AD 552 8 AD 142! 65 AD 676 1 60 biU lading s 32 S bU4 do 73 A D 2/t, 23 M at laches 2 A(J 174 deiiv. transfer 99 conversion s 33 S 652 85 615 616 judgment 44 M 35 discontinuance 6 AC 105n 7 AC 432n 1 07jury question B32S 88 SAD 12 AD 22 AD 52 AD 55 AD 55 AD 66 AD 97 AD s32S 85 coat 7AD 46 AD 62 AD 45 M 671 6162 117 75 671 358 58 costs s32S 7 AD mtgee. posen. 16 AC 437ii accounting 87 M 346 63 conclusive s32S a 166 NY 11 AD 640 66S 661 70 parole ev. s32S 13 M 15 M 647 44 131 75 pers. liable s32S 92 conveyance 39 AD 45 AD 657 740 214 223 647 268 32 462 275 321 29 30 328 352 460 I 14 jurisdiction 9 32 S 668 27 AD 479 5 AC 307n I 19 acdunting 134AD 189 590 407 636 24 204 47 307 600 S32S el3 AD rejection 82 AD a 2 AC stipulation 31 M services 32 M 1 25 cond. sale a 32 S 693 e 25 M 340 7 AC 183n not realty f 159 AD 529 128 liability a 32 S 467 e 17 M 542 d 21 M 432 44 M ; 1 30 information s32 S dSAD 24 M 178 NY 1 38 rulings s32S 88 519 136 640 524 waive payment 106 AD 606 141 infant affirmance a 32 S 476 a 167 NY 715 86 372 infant liability d 13 AD 548 83 AD 562 e 83 AD 563 e 83 AD 564 convey title I 67 care s32S 7 AD J 2 AC 387n3S9n conversion 128 AD 277 1 7.1 objection a 32 S 584 8 AC 321 n strike out J: 90 M I 75 conctruction s 32 S 688 20 AD 18b 109 AD 194 1 78 incompetent 3 32 S . 677 43 AD 498 42 M 223 sufficiency 96 AD 142 37 M 63 1 84 incompetcy 9 32 S 482 r 165 NY 216 16 AD 492 d 16 AD 496 188 conclusive s 32 S 579 a 154 NY 766 88 AD 259 atty. authority 18 JM 2 AC 6 AC security 29 M 284 165n 41011 273 payment infant 16 AC 190n authority do 210 NY 511, 197 atty ' authority s32S 21 AD 31 M 33 M 7 AC SAC client liable 48 M referee 17 AC 1016 43 260 506 400n 402 433 428 57 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed.: 200 recovery s 32 S 999 a 156 NY 185 226 accounting s 32 S 1069 * 170 NY 122 21 AD 131 69 AD 122 do e 116AD 790 23 1 contract 3 32 S 960 a 165 N Y 688 242 estate tax s32S r 147 NY 11 AD 29 M 906 69 222 738 250 recovery 9 32 S 1069 r 166 NY 389 10 AD 628 257court'B powr 9 32S 1013 91 637 9ubstitution e36AD 42AD 57 AD 90 AD 1J2 AD- 128 AD 93 M ;05NY al AC 7 AC 9 AC 169 604 22 435 792 834 270 402 347 393n 226 defense usury 80 M 195 285 notice 3 32S 28 AD 989 623 289 reaciaaion a 32 S 1023 a 158 NY 675 2 AC 334u 300 prox. c s32S 14 AD objection' 11 AC 309 accord 3 32S 12 AC 953 54 46d 1064 453n 261 3 32S 13 AD 9 AC 263 ap. s32S a 155 NY 22 AD dSS AD e58AD 1 AC compromise 906 559 217n prfrmce' 1036 555 663 154 158 409 266 insurance s 32 S 1026 3 6 AD 651 "addition' 70 M 155 269 pleading s32S 80 AD L17AD remedy L27 AD amendment 36 CP ■J9M 1127 604 471 449 2!0 362 24 25 26 224 '486 638 146 313 54 457 667 271 accounting 9 32 S 081 do 74 AD do 70 AD 78 AD 84 AD 87 AD 36 M r.,37M relief money 113 AD. fiduciary 55 M law action 128 AD rule pleadg. 130 AD 345 set up facts 206NY 370 279 relief a32S 1011 a 155 NY 676 86 163 156 recovery 23 AD appeal . 52 AD ■ judgment 33 M Eoreclose lien 149AD 682 121 122 366 3 1 3 review 32 S 1146 1 AD 601 26 AD 621 45 AD 384 3 I 4 partnership s32S 1106 r 147 NY 241 33 AD 451 34 3 1 5counterclaim 29 AD e87AD 48 234 408 negligence 3 32 S 1021 138 AD 856 41 I conaiderat'D s 32 S 1056 a 165 NY 672 verdt vs evidence 15 AC set-off 64 M indirect T4M 38211 390 denials 100, 4 1 7 affidavit 9 32 S 888 f 69 AD 617 79 AD 120 54 M 273 274 420 legacy int. 32 S 887 16AC 195n interest penalty 8 32S a 155 NY 68AD 137 AD 976 991 576 682 320 forgery s32S~ 1037 a 148 NY 29 inadeq. price Ul AD 850 defraud '57M 30S 343 evidence 9 32S 933 16 AD 376 do 71 AD 141 359 corroborat'n 9 32 S 943 2 AC 303 362 interloc. udgment s 32 S 1018 39 M 603 new trustee 166 AD 823 367 authority a 32 S 1032 93 AD 184 8 AC 226d new trustee 200, NY 463 373 bill partic a 32 S 1009 87 229 41 AD 622 86 M o02 376 compromlge 9 32 S 1031 9AC 217n 218h 377 arre9t 9 32S a 146 NY 969 397 380 consideratn' a 32 S 980 30 AD 364 389 interpleader s32S 12 AD 162 AD 165 AD 2 AC 80 605 162 227n 7!IM 422 repeal 9 32S a 147 NY 90 61 AD 94 AD el8 M M 42 M 15 AC 17!) 884 700 210 96 519 275 58 3 133n 424 valuation 32 S 4 AD e72AD 72 AD do 78 A D ISIAD ^"ecial use 98 M 891 254 395 398 529 .56 719 432 opg defau s 32 S 896 134 AD 573 436 gift cau9a mortis 9 32 S 901 e 22 M ^»7 3 AC 195n 117AD 367 438 riparian owners 32 S 897 20 AD 184 45 AD 256 260 award ev. 132AD 575 449 action on ^ 32S lOOM debt 882 185 451 defective petition 32 S 889 39 CP 139n 454 receiver a 32 S 830 8 AC 116n 462 relief 9 33S 283 opening default b32S 905 403 service AC 33n'B32S 992 109 464 marriage a 33 S 105 15 AC 16n construction 83 M 242 468 damages s 33 S 101 r 156 NY. . 600 criticised- 1 nmit»,1-"'."-™i-~"'j''' '''s''"8;u>shed ; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n,, nuts criticised, 1, limited, e. cjcplain^d; o, overruled; s, same cue. do, diaientinr opioion ; p. parallel case ; q. qu«g«i- N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — ^Hnn Vols, 85, 86 470 accord b33S d78AD 87 AD 26 M 6 AC 148 NY lU 485 588 135 288D 33U 477consideratioD B 33 S 129 96 AD 333 f 94 M 703 assignment void 137AD 246 waiver lien :!OAC 120n validity 7!" M 365 erforcement 7a M 3CG indebtedness 554 a33S d30AD 79 AD el3M 27 M dS AC 171 NY adoption 18AC 119n, 123n waiver 171 AD 185AD 10211 482 dower ' 8 33S t86 91 AD 13 AC 266 420 99 617 199 143n , 485 scrutiny 8 33 S 138 91 93 6 AD 638 21 M 179 41 M 278 costs award 7 AC 152n 489 security s 33 S 134 16 M 555 note for debt i _ ^^ 18AC 139n 580 publication convsrsion 103 478 372 502 148 242 243 500 557 rescission 33 S 167 86 612 56 1 bool£s ev. 3S 203 2 AC 313n 7 AC 474n 564 presumption s 33 S 123 3 AD 295 fact question 31 AD 458 cliamperty 125 AD 345 do 128 AD 363 actual possession 6 1 6 personal ' injuries case 4 s35S a 166 NY salary case 19 8 35 8 r 147 NY 1113 219 1113 169 VOL.86 I negligence s33 ti 69 AD 21 M 36 M 6 1 7 action cause case 1 s32S si AC appeal case 10 s33S a 155 NY certiorari case 11 8 32 8 a 147 NY complaint 183AD 6 1 8 appeal case 3 s32S 511 a 165 NY 126 AD conveyance 140 AD 351 575 waiver s33S 32 AD 70 AD 8 2 AC 7 AC f 94 M 198 634 15 77 348n 556 note debt 16A0 139n 492 intention s 33 S 406 45 AD 91 500 misjoinder 5 33S 202 I40AD 371 raise question 149 AD 371 522 strike out 8 33 8 33 91 AD 42 M 10 AC biil partic. 123AD 138 AD 19AC pleading 138 AD E 530 suflScient s 33 8 524 13 AD 431 77 284n 574 gn 540 demand s33S 4 AD d87AD 14 M 29 M conversion do 119 AD 544 practice 8 33 8 116 AD new trial 37 CP 400 617 95 315 431 261 330 202 356 547 obligation s 33 S 763 90 78 relationship 92 3 AC 150 382 594 229 780 540 210 384n 33 8 9 AD 10 AD 81 AD 109 AD 46 M e 16 M 17 AC declaration do 165 AD 956 evidence do 165 AD 956 implied 98 M 57 59 I fr'd intent s33S 121 11 AD 313 2 AC . 283 copartnship use 85 M 513 595 compet. ev 5 33 S 282 e'102'AD 231 48 M 19 601 disqualif'n 6 1 9 certiorari case 4 3 32 8 a 147 NY appeal case 6 32 S a 155 NY £ 170 AD 620 hab. corpus case 1 32 8 883 p2AD 617 contempt 7 AC 219p 165 181 406 608 33 S 90 c4 AD neglience 42 AD harmless error 44 AD 394 51 AD 106 55 AD 196 j urisdiction 66 AD 236 do 164 NY 223 disregard error 184AD 695 6 I 5 consideratn case 1 s 32 S 663 158 NY 322 discontinue case 2 656 106n 268 s 32 8 28,6 AC 1160 106 1135 643 971 684 1138 668 6 cond precedt 8 33B 112 17 M 369 9 counsel fees s 33 b 136 10 AC 186n 197-9Sn 65 M 18a reimburse 2Z3Nbf 208 1 2 fact question s 33 ei 360 8 AD . BH 1 7 rescission 8 33 Ci 402 a 166 -NY 676 92- 391 1142 334 1028 653 86 lien s34 8 a 168 NY 674 10 AC 142nl46n 20AC 127n no delivery COM 248 20public 18UAD policy 22 contracts a 33 a 387n 167 NY 714 33 S 143 13 AC 387n 30 judgment s 33 b 326 3 AC 370n 35 unoccupied s 33 tj 404 92 228 64 AD 372 do 100 AD 284 37 negligence s 33 IS 205 34 AD 7S 39 AD 138 42 inspection 8 33 y 287 67 AD 69 26 M 129 31 M 221 8 2 AC 128 5 AC 266n 269n 51 stenog fees 158 100e570 333 345 69n 24n taxation costs a&M 332 s34U a 162 NY 10 AD 14 AD 66 AD 83 AD by jury 153 AD objection 48 AD 176AD neg. rule, 128 AD mfr rule 128 AD for jusy 152AD 145 AD rules safety 216 NY 177 20AC 134n 20AC 133n admissible 165 AD 602 00 liabiUty 4AC jurisdiction 137AD 1 87 lease s33S p 178 NY 77 AD 89 AD 190 liability 1074 614 670 450 30 31 89 984 500 98 601 806 499 1041 731 104-5 432 8 33 8 dl9M 194 tax 8 33 8 a 148 NY 57 AD 100 AD 1 99 forfeiture s33 8 1064 a 166 NY 669 206 preference s 33 8 802 7 AD 112 18 AD 435 el6M . 402 jurisdiction 7AC 66n 210 accountiog 8 33 S 1016 r 152 NY 320 2 1 5 covenant 8 33 8 38 AD 82 AD 8TAD 146AD 19 M 20AC conatruction 100 AD 794' 55 M 1020 617 6 356 741 228 74n 256 336 ABBREVIATIONS; a, affirmed; d, distinguishe c, criticised; 1. limited; e, explained: o, overruled ; d; {.followed; r, reversed; m, modified: !• 'l's"'i"<=<'= "•, ."'i'^' same case; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case : q, queiUoBM N. T. Supreme Court Reports — Hun Vol. 87 encroachment 142 AD 48S free use f 171 AD 15 2 \ 7 amendment s33S 43 AU 4 AG 7 AC 67 M 1021 323 216n 87 91n 237 227 order B 33 S 7S3 f 87 619 bill particulars 41 AD 622 28 M 306 229 dissolution B 33 S 835 r 147 NY 24 paid in full 160 AD 829 233 consolidat'n s 33 S 836 4 AC 208n 236 preferences « 33S 1037 chat morgage 22 AD 4S AD 66 AD judgment 66 AD 261 294 29' 296 243 complaint b33S 1047 22 AD 4/8 77 AP 314 loo AD 353 strike out do 171 AD 579 246 special dam s 33 S 764 91 689 incomp ev. 3 AD 128 spec damages 18 AD 402 22 AD 403 71 AD 560 19 M 59 jury question do 138 AD 309 257 attachment B 33 S 826 17 M 243 no presumption 67 M 406 262 objections s 33 S 831 24 M 251 37 M 699 pleadings 214 NY 432 f 91 M 363 269 orig papers B33S a 146 NY affidavits 87 4 AD 13 AD 21 AD SCAD 65 AD e88 AD 14 M el6M 16 M 17 M 23 M 54M e24M 2 AC 2 AC 3 AC e6 AC 26 CP 25 CP source knlds: 821 406 262 384 16 386 274 26 1S2 77 147 167 243 735 523 62 681 363 n 398n 203 156 220 224 U6AD 121 123 ISIAD 981 25 CP 369 for court f 87 M 447 276 cts. power 33S 136AD 808 250 279 order s33S a 159 NY t87 allowance eSAD 17 AD spec damages 32 AD 472 exclus. right 188NY not enjoin 1055 S5S 619 21 269 136AD 285 trial 33 S 220NY 10 AD 4 AC 223 819 538 346 298n 3 1 negligence s 34 S 366 5 AD 493 89 AD 339 d89AD 427 431 2 AC 318n 315 injuncti'^n s 34 S 373 37 CP 66 3 1 7 evidence 9 34 8 1134 39 AD 660 3 1 9 ev error s 34 S 342 do 2 AD 128 326 judgment a 34 S 321 a 147 NY 722 80 AD 295 presumption 79 M 112 95 M 497 288 new trial 33 S 1031 S7 619 n AD 334 16 AD 249 34 AD 479 s 1 AC 319 qumcient facts 15 AC 339n demurrer 195 N'Y 377 293 denial p ead -134 8 ■in sn AD 77 AD 91 AD 03AD 129AD 34M •IIM -12M SAC hSAO Q AC 'Ipfpnp 126 AD 362 485 SSJ 313 101 323 16 S3 572 76 ■589 451 41n compt 677 864 466 ' do 133AD nraffipp dn 127 342 ■(trilrp out deni, «? M 6S4 19 M 75 295 ronstruct'n 34 S 17AD execution 23 AD 379 597 346 124AD 199 329 opinion 934 8 dl69 NY 32 AD 97 US 427 274 569 406 334 receiver 34 S 212 rl56 NY 481 339 complaint 300 742 39 ?34S a 148 NY 26' M parties SO M 5! purpose section '7-H 285 variance TliM 343 not settled 82 M 648 341 resid. corp'n s34S 2fi« 1 147 NY 715 91 59S 20 AD 167 46 AD 24 31 prin. office 69LBA438n439n 128 AD 586 29 B discharge " 34 S 346 227AD 34 removal 15 M 14 299 examination s34S 9 AD 17M '1 M 23 M report- BAC rlisc^very 57 M nrivilege 390P 303 appeal 348 SAC 433 209 31 112 617 328n 362 1161 288n 304 mandamus s 34 S 388 r 147 NY 366 conBtructinn V3 limitation 34 S 315 59 M 296 law question 19A0 286n 347 ev. error ■> 34 S 306 29 M no supple answer 4 AC 215n dissolution 9 AC authority ISfiAD 62n 32fi 349 witness s34S 9 AD Dublicatioji 105M 302 568 334 352 pledge lien 9 34S . 308 s 2 AC 107 355 negligence s34 8 379 20 AD 136 64 AD 479 obligation 200 NY 495 362 atty's. . compensation s34 8 1141 7 AC 123^n 98 AD 288 363 trial de novo s34S 16 AD undertaking 16 M 352 46 108 368 trial 8 34 8 8 49 AD ( construction 94 M 671 ?72 irregularity 182AD 120 377 mortgages 8 34 8 443 156 NY 692 19 M 654 384 corporation 323 34 137 426 717 8 34 8 a 148 NY 2 AC 393 license a 34 8 a 147 NY 397 discharge s34S 304 s 6 AD 386 s 2 AC 166 393n 107 AD 363 hiring year 127 AD 285 406 constitute. ■ 34 8 147 NY d3 AD liability 12 AD 13 AD prospective 78 AD 87 AD fixed right eSSAD eR9 AD 17M f2AC 11 AC do 96 AD 26 CP rptrnn cti ve 12 AD do 12 AD 217 N Y new cause do 214 NY lis 4 I 4 appraisal 32 428 650 146 267 262 42 263 52n 209 152 S2I 52R 240 s34S a 155 NY 14 AC pxemption 113 AD distinction 161 AD 332 6R2 34lD 302 428 negligence s 34 8 310 34 M 748 430 injunction 8 34 8 21S * 151 NY 638 444 dorporation s 34 8 370 95 AD 21 authority 137 AD 677 452 ev. of usage s 34 S 392 53 AD 488 judgment s 83 AD 501 knowledge 74M 71 462 authority 3 34 8 209 a 165 NY 67 prove as defense 174 AD 447 465jury questioD 9 34 8 375 a 162 NY I 47 1 unliquid int 8 34 8 328 r 155 NY 369 477 agreement, a 34 S 384 56 AD 503 177AD 236 71 M 274 written law 131AD 776 483 title vesting s34S lOlP a 147 NY 348 9 AD 604 20 AD 103 487 funds 3 34S a 166 NY 1144 657 493 assessment 3 34 8 1010 a 56 NY I 499 damage .'I 34 8 1009 72 AD 323 502 easement 3 34 8 102S a 148 NY 214 507 towns 9 34 8 34 M 77M 5 1 I fraud «34S 64 AD 110 AD 21 M 7:1 M 286 S72 359 501 197 690 23 .344 5 1 6 payment 9 34 8 577 a 166 NY 668 e 55 AD 4 519 assumed risk 34 8 273 39 AD 137r 522 possession 34 8 489 a 157 NY 703 168 NY 730 530 damaees 9 34 8 479 a 1 51 NY 676 bill particulars 55 M 41 amendment 20AC Sn B3'5 possession 9 34 8 29fi 10 AD 478 21 AD 632 538 pers injury 3 34 8 297 a 156 NY 662 542 examination s34S a 154 NY 8 AD opinions HAD 283 547consideratn 8 36S B20AD 26AD 76 AD 9 AC 138 72 345 71 142n 563 mortgage 8 34 S 476 r 166 NY 122 r 6 AC 79 568 dismissal 9 34 8 1147 a 156 NY 668 573 alter rate s 34 8 561 d91 26 42 AD 129 580 judgment 3 34 8 549 47 AD 487 30 CP 293 trespass T2 M' 277 584 new trial 34 8 a 159 NY 76 AD verdict 107 AD 572 69 347 253 1 7 AC 206n 207 59 I assessments 3 34 S 563 4 AD 541 waiver 41 AD 134 9uspension 41 AD 136 fact question 53 AD ' 649 weight ev. 73 AD 30 598 corporation 8 34 S 541 SAD 46 81 AD 29 26 CP 89 605 tax money 9 34 8 685 a 155NY 105 6 1 2 chge except 9 34 S 277 a 156 NY 662 11 AD 580 3t. railroad 2 AC 318n 6 1 7 leave to sue case 2 33 8 868 r 162 NY 69 decision case 6 9 33 8- 165 NY 1125 678 618 judgment case 1 9 33 8 a 155 NY review case 3 9 33 8 a 165 NY 1134 630 807 673 6 1 9 amendmenti case 6 8 33 8 r 147 NY 8 34 AD demurrer 1st d ept. case 8 1134 69 479 3 33 8 e2AD reference 78] 'case 9 Bills 33 8 r 147 NY 509 decision 'case 4 1131 363 1127 237 s 34 8 479 8 33 8 1034 8 16 AD 249 621 judgment regular case 3 3 34 8 a 169 NY decision case 4 3 34 8 a 156 NY decision case 7 9 34 8 a 169 NY implied agreement case 9 3 34S 317 24 M 69 1148 50 1145 669 1145 641 623 decision case 6 3 34 8 a 168 NY appeal case 8 = 34S *148Ni 1142 724 1134 731 ABBREVIATIONS: a, afBrmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note c. criticised; 1, limited: e. explained : o. overruled; s, same ease; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q, questioned Vol. 88 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Hun VOL. 88 I jurisdiction s34S 79 M 85 interest 3 34S 505 363 496 233 4 conolu&ion 8 34S 24 AD burden proof 17 M 35 26 M 738 presumption 71 M 318 21 revocation s34S 511 42 AD 447 10 AC 442d eauity court T5M ST8 25 fact for court s34S 5S7 a 159 HY 194 d88 31 bona fide holder 12 AD 624 25 AD 419 16 M 567 8 AC 229n 230n accomadtn. paper 87 wife's earning a 34 S 628 ml 53 NY 294 308 34 M 629 3 2 AC 146 transfer stock 16 AD 606 94 insurance 3 34 S 545 a 156 NY 966 67 AD 626 compensation 170AD 150 151 loss liand 223NY 457 1 1 aismissal s 34 S 606 10 AC 281n 15 AC 333n 106 AD 27 parol ev. s34S 23 M 35 interest 16AC 559 532 267 48n 49 servicep value s34S 17M 15 AC 52 costs 8 34S 113 AD 15 AC 506 332 284n 731 124 485n costs demur 18 AC 404 408n 56 attestation s34S a 153 NY 536 679 596 342 336 59 consent s34S 24 AD 25 AD r. r construction 77 AD 492 12 AC 205 64 necessaries wife 522 I 68 default S36S a 148 NY 91 43 AD a 3 AC 1 69 default note case s35S 3 AC 4 AC 1 03 lost will 3 34S 167 NY 53 AD do 104 AD 30 M 35 M 11 AC 583 168 107 326 5 705 338n s34S 9 AD 22 M authority 9 AD 44 AD 73 AD 98 AD court's duty 89 AD 14 M quo. warranto 96 AD 62 I 76 extra allow 612 320 1 09 waiver s34S e7AD jury trial t 96 M I 1 5 deed lunatic 3 34S -587 177 NY 262 possession 12 AD' 198 15 AC 366n 3B7n incompetent II AC 433 435n 11 AC 440n 442n reimburse 131AD 229 1 2 1 voidable 71 M 229 s34S a 148 NY 49 M 71 M costs 62 M 1 22 issuance 3 34S a 147 NY 26 M 679 722 682 626 81 558 8 34S 11 AC 66 damages s34S a 166 NY 605 93d 624 700 67 reviewable 73 M 471 68 transfer tax b34S 616 SAC 195n 618 554 72 ejectment s34S a 159 NY 74 title 8 34S a 156 NY 30 AD 88 AD cend. precdt. 136 AD 464 80 recovery s 34 S 620 a 152 NY 646 608 161 120 265 1 28 costs 12 AD 132AD ndivid. costs 126 AD 13 d 14 135 certiorari 3 34 S 692 4 AD 642 e 22 M 427 e24M 164 44 M 196 not available SAD 397 construction 22 AD 146 power review 70 M 286 I 4 I "agents' s 34 S 525 8 AD 393 1 47 exception s 34 S 607 1 AD 601 26 AD 621 1 48 prfrmance 9 34S 51$ 29 M 467 authority 121 AD 278 1 64 assessment s 34 S 633 a 154 NY 570 531 256 508 471 88 532 169 95n 346n 173 confidentia 487 60 300 253 453 467 314 64 367 13 AD 19 AD 20 AD 21 AD 60 AD 55 AD 74 AD 86 AD :j34S 21 M 3 AC 11 AC 11 AC default f 62 M 780 219 2 1 5 costs s34S p88 affiadvit defectve 32 AD 13A(J without ICPNS 991 107 607 5uy 326 219 costs s34S 148 NY lien 23 AD • 16 AC 22 1 relates 183AD 1 77 objection 3 34S' 416 4 AD 447 179 amendment 3 34 S 424 e 3 AD 425 19A0 302n 181 variance 34 S 424 s 166 NY 394 3 21 AD 193 197 a 32 AD 391 p 76 AD 309 114 AD 784 meas. damages 17 AC 456n pleading 122 AD 259 1 86 new trial s 34 S 413 SAC 300n power court 16AC 448n 1 90 set aside s34S 412 5 AD 526 I 96 contrib. neg. 3 34 S 714 s5AD 619 30 AD 88 burden 39 AD 439 200 prep, proof s 34 S 652 60 M 594 203 authority 3 34S 661 92 AD 99 AD 254 208 wife's earnings 3 34S 51 AD 89 AD 43 M MAC competent 82 M 667 60 118 669 208n 50-1 2 1 I presumption SAD 112,113 12 AD 193 303 513 149 24 468 123 579 580 125 720 248 33 199 200n 32; 236 note for debt 16 AC lS9n 258 habeas corp 3 34 S 734 e 86 AD 193 37 M 642 263 contrib neg 23 463n county 5n 722 292 402 26ii hack 480 3 34S 4 AD SAD 18 AD 272 award 3 34S s 154 NY s4AD 279 notice s34S 33 AD 37 AD 96 AD 172 AD inspection 136AD 283 error 3 34S ;6M 663 28 226 appeal s34S SAD costs 6 AC 152n ^29 court's powr 34 S 337 92 122 harmless error 18 M 247 11 AC 22n 233 demurrable 34 ti 77 68 M 14? presumption 72 M 305 238 mechan. lien 3 34 S 598 r 157 NY 322 248 non prfrmance 34 S 741 88 AD 63 jury question 14 AC 294n 191 NY 498 250 chg venue 3 34S 16 AD 66 AD 86 AD 29 M 254 liability 3 34S IAD 25 AD doing business 657 93 206 513 657 717 346 416 SAD 64 AD 102 AD 112 AD 19 M 20AC lex toci SAD compliance 20 AD payment 16 M verification dl7M remedy 26 M not doing busin's 13 AC 379n contracts ■ 13 AC .387 n 562 141 9 805 38 21 In 448 655 555 267 345 744 487 496 120 416 396 615 737 74 317 56l< 44 261 7 AC 146n 147n 7 AC 152nl63n claim rule 60 M 3fi SIBassum'drisk s 34 S ' 408 11 AD 568 25 AD 317 323 muster neg. s 34S 739 20AC 133n 325 inspection s 34 S 257 62 AD 316 by petition 99 AD 29t 328 breach war- ranty s34S 13 AC 227 411 370 285 harml. error not pub ot'ieers 34 AD 10 s 34 S 794 30 AD 387 290fact question 34 S 406 28 M 108 109 AD 780 292 conversion s 34 S 970 a 153 NY 671 304 jurisdiction 764 634 37 281 681 457 374 3 34 8 21 AD 43 AD do 106 AD 19 M 70 M 92 M information 9 AC . 232n magistrate 17 AC 110 waiver 125 AD 149 70 M 456 71 M 618 read charge 83 M 316 307 privilege 9 34S 38 AD 56 AD 76 AD 128 AD 17 M 2] M 31 M 34 M 6 AC 19A0 89CP discovery 80 AD 34 M E57 M irregularity 82 AD 46 M 53 M 748 139 266 258 618 553 31 112 674 224 328n 361n 43 n 166 224 362 .595 609 11 790 228 n 335 language 3 34 S 724 a 156 NV 670 s 34 S 724 examination 78 AD . 327 343 discretion s 34 S 398 a 167 NY 289 SAD 48 348 compliance 34 S 754 27 AD 406 359 negligence 3 34 S 824 r 154 NY 263 24 AD 306 3 37 AD 130136 70AD389do393 excessive verdict 11 AC 68d 364 cross exam. 9 34 S 861 15 \C 37n 47n 368 co^structn. 3 34S B2G 136AD 490 372 surplusage 3 34 S 826 5 AC 43n 374 tr'st constro 3 34S 831 9 92 97 7 AC 494n 105 AD 224 378 declaration 9 34 S 829 SO AD 19 381 plead£suffio 394 right action 8 34 S 816 61 AD 406 401 interest 9 34 S 805 a 152 NY 647 407 exieciition 3 34 S 843 a 157 NY 710 jurisdiction 50 M 514 protection 65M 118 order arrest 183AD 594 4 1 2 party deft 34 S 787 6-AD 36 28 M 328 4 1 6 witns attest 9 34 S 821 37 M^ 688 438 easement 3 34 S 840 r 166 NY 636 443 mandamus 9 34 S 404 112 AD 412 413 no appeal 117AD 809 9 34S 21 AD 42 AD 48 AD imendment 138 AD 167 AD terms 180AD 834 632 476 125 585 791 incrimination 39CP 3 1 2 costs s34S 161 NY 40 AD 53 AD 66 AD 21 M SIM S7iJ 385 inj 3 34S a 157 NY 20 AD nuisance nlLRANS 448 bill partic. 3 34S SAD 26 AD 3 2 AC 56 M lOOM 332, 876 306 555 196 333 172 452 alienation 9 34 S 777 23 AD 544 27 AD 375 good faith 148 AD 485 458 reference 34 S e76AD 461 agency s34S 27 M notice 61 M 874 624 872 231 107 464 negligence 9 34 S 85 16 AD 149 89 AD 339 438 question fact 72 AD 472 16A027n 3.30n 488 iieg. r. r ris 881 664 209 355 271 s34S a 153 NY 48 AD 88 AD d 114 AD revers. error 189 NY 761 34 118 320 283 179 301 propert 810 692 599 75d 389 partition 9 34S 813 r 148 NY 149 B 2 AC. 118 r 420 allegations 51 M 305 480 47 1 signals neg s 34 S 978 13 AG 410n421n for court 182AD 453 496contrih negl s 34 S 877 f 168 AD 42 220 NY 68 d 220 NY 69 498 jury right 9 34 S 888 11 AD 410 16 AD 465 adjournment 66M 479 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed c, criticised ; 1, limited ; e, explaii ; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, "»<•''! ned ; o, overruled ; s, samei^ase ; do, dissentinK opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, queitioned N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Hun Vols. 88, 89 503 atty authority 8 34 S 786 J 27 M 447 505 stolen goods s 34 S 974 r 148 NY 96 509 negligence 8 34 S 908 B 8 AD 615 513 atty. lien 3 3118 78R 159 AD 607 37M 516 no lien 80 M 687 515 new trial s39S 911 7 AC 194-95n 7 AC 199n 1 6 AC 118n 130[i 569 appeal forcl sS AD a 157 NY lien 9 AD 30 AD 106 AD 35 M authority 52 AD 634 S appoint trustee 557 5 1 8 criminal contempt s 34 S 146 S 160 AD 976 50 63S 689 90 93 198 472 222 890 26 AD option 120 AD eq. claim 120 AD compliance 183AD 647 (appeal case 6 8 34 8 1135 ial56N7 663 j attachment case 9 s34S r 148 NY sllM raAC master duty 134AD 195 105 682 598 sham pleadg s 34 S 769 9 AC 169n 17J!u !) AC ISln sham denial 122 AD 813 520 new trial s34S 30 AD 8 1 3 notice defect case 2 s52 AD r 159 NY 3 34S negligence „ case 3 973,36 8 99 r 156 NY 522 surface watr s 34 S 109 AD statutory 66M town liable 68 M do87M not liable 184AD 344 340 28' 209 474 527 corp taxn s34S 117 f 88 531 530 taxation 8 34 S 713 r 148 NY 759 532 memoranda s 34 S 776 21 AD 22 535 demand s 34 S 856 s 22 AD 309 promissory note 35 AD 124 parol evidence 29 M 560 inadmissible lOOM 691 544 bondE Corp. tax s34S 801 25 AD 18 9C d66AD 156 75 AD 166 554 trespass b34S 848 a 147 NY 721 s2AC 199 560 authority atty. s34S X49 76 AD 269 98 AD 144 101 AD 285 27 M 178 723 15 AC 346 15 AC 423n 15 AC 429 564 burden deft. s 34S 772 75M 390 53 20 1126 1102 104 1116 670 1112 213 632 739 MO 698 6 1 4 appeal case 2 b35S s 156 NY rip.rightd case 4 a35S r 156 NY, partnership case 5 s34S a 154 NY credibility case 15 s34S a 157 NY pers. injury ease 16 s 35 S 1104 a 156 NY 244 partnership acctg case 17 3 34 S 632 a 135 NY 655 6 1 6 ins. judgmt case 2 s3SS 1111 a 166 NY 667 iuterloc. judgment case 3 5 35 S 1104 s 156 NY 664 6 1 7substitute service case 1.3 s 34S 146 a 147 NY 702 case 9 . s .34 S 113' 73 M 471 620 consideratn case 1 s34S 17 M r ecord case 5 s34S a 156 NY 62 I receiver case 3 34 S a 166 NY devise 3rd. dept s34S a 152 NY 1137 383 1145 533 case 4 1144 602 1139 177 287 384 VOL. 89 1 remedies 8 34 S 1004 10 AC 460n enforceable 102M 246 funeral expense d 102M 247 2 new trial s 34 S 1051 13 AD 602 dismiss on merits 52 AD 52 2 AC 248 7 AC 431 11 AC 104n 109 AD 875 direct verdict 52 services townjcounterclaim s 35 S 94|60 M (89 605| f 88 M 4 review s 34 S 168 AD 7 certiorari 3 35S a 147NY 8 discharge case 2 s35S 29M 1 disregard 144 310 999 25 90 701 514 60 150 NY 14 AD 1 4 connect. s35S e89 AD f27M 138 pi 39 181 NY 436 1 8 UabiUty s34 S 1052 57 AD 139 42 M 46 21 forclose lien 3 43 S 1065 41 AD 209 title receiver 72 AD 577 24 stipulation s 34 S 1064 8 AC 351n 27 bill partie s 34 S 996 8 AD 306 26 AD 355 29 construction s 35 S 42 3 158 NY 707 32 em. domain 8 35S t a 148 NY 743 iustifiable 144 AD 704 public use d 144 AD 708 passed grantee 69 M 372 42 dam. trespasp g 35 S 97 63 AD 453 44 jddgt bar 8 3SS 23 M 65 AD 183 e 17 M 440 liabihty town 14 M 220 limited power do 216 NY 54 56 imputed s 34 S 1060 81 M irai 142 S 3.3.T 65 surrendr lease s 35 S 69 18 M 449 U AC . 476n 67 memoranda s 35 S 82 s 2 AC 299 21 AD 22 17 M 84 73 respond su- perior s 35 S 31 59 AD 66 23 M 94 neg. hosp liable 78 AD 326 79 AD 346-40 128 AD 217 177 NY 22 corpn. liability 199 NY 237 178AD 683 75 charge jury 8 34 S 1072 r 156 NY 224 e 77 AD 389 do 390 1 20 agt mistake s34S 1132 a 166 NY 10 1 26 ejectment 8 34 S 1086 a 156 NY 1 129 judgment s 34 S 1007 f 108 AD 355 bailment 3 M 402 no bailment f 89 M 387 no cause action lOiM 800 135 colhsion s 34 S 1069 a 155 NY 692 1 38 valid assesft s 35 S 78 23 AD 47 66 AD 303 110 AD 30 141 liability 8 36S o 88 AD 76 exceptions 35 S a'156 NY 4 AD 36 680 199 78 consent 8 35S a 157 NY 79 AD consideration 93 AD . 595 accept assignt 81 705 276 49 surrog power S35S 3SM jurisdiction 117 AD 72 M accountig 53 M no jurisdiction 79 M 667 complaint 185AD 247 586 6.30 179 155 258n 75 829 46 M. novation 15 AC 124AD 132AD covenants 132AD assignee 132AD 79 mandamus a 148 NY 166 8 36S 59 J no defense s34S 1039 15-1 AD 392 190 payt costs 35 8 40 AD 23 M 28 CP 29 CP 192 libel 35 8 a 157 NY 1 96 lien 3 34S 10 AC construe intent 137 AD 701 207 appeal costs 151 785 waiver exceptn 472n 486 138 631 117 13 AC 187NY 38 CP review 13 AC 1 44 rtlet 3 16 AD 9 AD 35 8 148 dismissal 3 34 S • 1023 f89 610 1 5 1 ord. money a 154 N If 707 3 35 3 12 I 55 injunction 3 35 8 11 a 157 NY 710 1 56 contract 8 10 AD 459 462 d90 215 8 35 8 47 1 59 acknowledgt 84 mortgage s35S a 154 NY d 153 NY 22 M 53 783 627 68 3 152 NY r 154 NY 38 AD notice 42 AD 3 47 AD i36S I 67 corpn. 3 35 8 a 163 NY 55 AD 88 possession s 34 8 1041 6 AC lOn 9 3 crdrs. assignt 34 8 1031 m 148 NY 588 m3 AC 1 02 parol ev. s34S do 157 AD 108 relief s34 8 21 AD U AC stockbroker 46 M IGDl 563 1066 56 176n 163 599 8 568 470 88 299 79. 684 1017 132n 34 8 a 148 NY 89 208 hen =i34 8 7 AD 56 AD 643 518 491 452 242 17 loan 610 672 89 disolutn. jurisdn. 31 M 171 rent 8 36 8 a 159 NY 185 26 640 75 covenant 3 34 8 1130 6 AD 125 19 M 229 1 79 justice Hab 3 34 8 1034 s9AD 176 nonsuit f 82 M 360, 361 exemptions 176 AD 275 1 83 law remedy s 34 8 1037 1087 289 609 562 158 213 oonstitutn'l 3 34 8 1044 a 157 NY 453 15 AD 202 23 M 379 e 25 M 336 connection f 25 M 336 2 1 9 dower 3 34 8 1002 11 AC 161n 15 AC 313 220 audit claim 3 35 8 64 27 AD 479 mandamus 34 AD 169 31 M 661 229 insurance I 36 S 670 a 157 NY 363 241 grading void s 35 8 91 164 NY 389 s 6 AD 225 appointment v'd 157 AD 236 246 nuisance s 35S 1109 64M 213 259 equity suit s 35 8 39 f 89 83 289 608 48 M .425 comr. discretion 14 M 263 16 M 424 26 M 230 pub- h'way 25 M 384 26 1 munie. powr. s 34 S 1073 e 160 NY 392 23 AD 128 26 AD 333 336 rr franchise e 102 AD 60 AD 52 AD 90 AD fraud 53M consent 133AD requirements 179AD 207 561 34 273 279 486 562 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; t, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; e, criticised; 1, liniited:V. explained; o, overruled: s. same case: do. dissentinc ooinion: o, parallel case: a, 9tie3tf«ned. Vols. 89, 90 a, X, Dupreme uqiu'Ii Acpuxus — xxuu 277 notice lieu s 35 S 623 15 AD 250 86 AD 146 e 2 AC 240 4 AC 159 9 AC 43q strict c'nstructn do 162 AD 61 conditional f 171 AD ■ 655 280 eq assig'mt s 34 S 1005 * 156 NY 90 284 interpreter 8 35 S 648 r 148 NY 724 288 em. domain s 35 S 43 r 157 NY 105 292 civil servcel S35S 161 a 148 NY ' 216 14 AD 499 303 death deft 8 35 S 171 r 153 NY 163 310 poor tax'n 8 35S 191 m 148 NY 71 3 1 R voidable s 35 S 566 £0T NY 128 329 ins.' contraei 8 35 S 449 8 153 NY 656 4 AD 521 333 ins restrictn 377 damageb 35 S 305 3 AC 401n 5 AC ISln 348s 382 delivery I 35 S 397 S5AU 317 39 1 aeknowledgt j 36 tj 4^ti II 149 NY 99 1 J^V lS2n 399 injmiction ai&ti 509 24 M 80 d 169 AD 8a9 trade mark i AC 68n 4 AU 373n use of name 169 AD 848 179AD 719 409 contracts 8 35S 417 a 163 NY Obi 4 f 7 servt. liab. i35t> 316 a 157 NY 71t liat)ility U6AU 68s aon-feaa'nce 130 AD i!36 425 certificate 3 36 S 316 36 AD 297 a M 160 Lin AD 'mz .45 AD 490 ^lead fraud 141 AD 95 s35S r 156 NY dSAD exception 85 AD forfeiture 6SLRA 374 628 360 199 8S 340 negligence case 2 8 35 395 a 156 NY 666 42 cotenants 8 35 S '577 m 157 NY 393 accounting 74M 216 occupation 185AD 248 400 780 320 656 364 title 1/4 AD 475 laches 8 36U 80 AD waiver 129 AD 477 claim dii6 H a 167 NY 41 AD waiver i:j1 ad 1 564 stockholder 460; liahility s 35 S S50 {46 AD 247 320 voluntary convey 527I18M 117 610 568 St. a35S 20 AD costs 36 M e4 AC waiver 3il 378 483 29 606 479 jury trial s 35 b 324 80 AD 152dl5b 12 AC 426 430 conclusive idU AU 249 480 order a 36 S 393 1 89 611 483 strike out a 30 8 369 41 M- 574 42 lH 70 ■i-± iVl 3ui rcluae com pit. 120 677 487 demurrer a 36 Ci 406 aA AC 16411 69M. ' i-i HALj ^4i 4'29viaductdam i 35 ij 506 .1 2 AD 102 14 AD 307 4 4-1 jVl 539 JOCF 235 437 imp. coven't 492 baggage J36S i'60 IS m 159 NY transfers 71 AD s iU9 AD 10 AC 35 S i 167 NY I AD 94 AD usage 37 41 intent LIS AD correlative ill NY promise J22NY 496 686 6U9 407 272 equal 198 92 35!l partition 8 35S a 154 NY validity will 24 AD d22M 39 M no bar 17 AC 149n probate will 153 AD fioa 218 NY 593 368 subrogation s35S 412 61 AD 304 sureties e54AD 136 26 M so 374 damages a35S a 162 NY 81AD llAC 66 AD 169 NY 14 M 8 2 AC 23^ 736 372 654 451 fi9n 614 268 499 402 frauds 647 214 321 324 582 574 reald.legatee 39 AD 402 monument cost 11 AC428n430n 92 M 636 157 S 496 582co.treas.liab. 9 35 S 286 11 AD 220 588 safeplace 35 S 634 6 AD 36 11 AD 464 a 20 AD 622 20 M 36 coservant neg. 9 AD 133 16 AD 107 86 AD 106 594 negligence a 35 Ij 540 1 2 AD , 693 97 AD 23 competent ev. 609 withdraw stock case S 8 36 S 80 a 158 NY 694 negligence case 12 8 84 8 1149 r 165 NY 611 610 divorce el s36ij 666 24 M 336 ev. adultery 11 AC 2046 122AD 38u 134AD . 143 construction 88 M 677 674 241 461 202 4»2 470 449 140 998 24b 449 bonds 3 35S a 158 NY .ibsume name 13BAD 456 ins. limitn. J 35 S 322 10 AD 11 460 mandamus 3 35 S- a 147 NY 39 M 465 gift 3 35S SAD 10 AD 16 AD 17 AD 30 M 3 2 AC delivery 51 AD presumptive evidence 120 AD 817 685 34 390 31 595 545 475 181 216 540 92 498 negligence 36 S 316 a 161 NY 3J a 23 AD 434 440 51 4 fr'd convei 3 36 S 437 154 NY 486 si AD .44 525 real estate aSbS 409 54M 162 529 real estate s 36 S 33i 126 AD 16» 53 1 appi trustee 335 a 61b 69 AD 613 beneficiary 42 M 142 543 quiet title a 35 S 346 a 164 NY 541 9 AC 309n adv. posaesson 128 AD 360 17 AC 377n 548 equity suit s36S 291 92 107 606 judgt. merits 126 AD 418 552 chge, realty 3 35 S - 342 J, 164 NY 714 8 AD 353 contrib.ne gg. 114 AD 809 dOSAD 66 M 603 Uen case 6 3 34 Ij 34 AD 604 obstruct St case 3 S34I8 r 154 NY judgment case 5 a 38 b a 154 NY J udgment case 6 3 34 Ij al54 NY VOL.9 4 inoompet. ev s36ti e73 AD 6 AC IS AC 9 rr. track a 35 b a 162 NY 24 AD 86 AD 163 NY 1110 202 397 1109 622 6 i I attachment ease 6 s36S r 1 48 NY r^AC reference case 13 s35b a 149 NY assessment review case 14 s36b 1114 a 148 NY 766 8 1 2 appeal case 5 s35b al65 NY g uardian 360 566 244n 287n 339 632 337 291 233 1147 90 s35b *148 NY stay case 11 a36S a 148 NY brokers case 17 s36b a 153 NY judgment case 9 35S a 166 NY 1144 783 1146 733 90 620 1146 619 1146 606 605 discharge . case 1 3 36 b a 149 NY injunction case 3 3 34 b a 149 NY certiorari case 4 3 34 b a 149 NY executors ease 6 s34b r 163 NY removal case 6 a 35 b 63 AD appeal case 8 3 34 b a 152 NY 607 appeal case 6 a34S a 155 NY 1114 666 1109 742 1112 744 415 679 1106 666 8 1 3 aoot stated case 3 s35S 310 14 A<1 371 Full disclosure 140 AD 526 20 construotioD S 36 S 621 7 AD 470 30 negligence s 35 S 599 r 163 NY 266 35 affidavit s 36 b 629 5 AC 374n 39 amendment a35S 619 69 AD 129 103 AD 494 18 M 662 5AC 37 grounds suffic. 17 M 272 56 corpoiation- a 36 b 602 67 AD 332 toll exemption /2 AD 244 aXJPiication a JM 27'. 62 examination s 36 O 697 C85AD 676 I AC 168n oommiaBlons 18 M 334 frame cdmplaini 14U AD ,63o 65 fel. servts. s 35 b 581 a 153 NY 680 82 AD 601 tact question I I AC 54u 11 AC 63ntiua 13 AC sgap conatiutional . . ILUANB &S9n estoppel f 92 M 560 18 oBHsament s 35 8 635 a 15d NY 427 24 M 36 42 M 684 dedication 14 AC 260n 164 AD 62 presumption 98t M 144 127 costs s35S 31M agency 36 M 645 300 170 135 payment/ s 36 S 624 32 AD 276 remedied 7 AC 133n 138 executnwill B 35 S 798 r 153 NY 259 r 4 AC 269 _ 1 45 mandamus s 36 S 349 749 9 AD 254 19 AD 872 S6 AD . 269 63 AD 247 e 17 M 864 f 19 M 673 1 55 performance a 35 b 737 r 157 NY 201 157 will proof 776 /O valid 3 35 b J14 NY trust 457 484 74 contract s35b a 166 NY 82 AD not a party 82 M 453 s35S 9 AD 28 AD 37 AD 51 AD joinder 126 AD parties 19A0 conclusion ' 19A0 , 289n 162 transfer tax 360 117 646 583 28Sn s 36 S . ^ d 106 AD 107 AD 26 M 28 M limitations 42s I ; 52-1 15a .VI 782 218 194 635 650 147 490 296 1148 124 1136 663 00 • • .■ 1 69 demurrer 83 injunction L 35 g 736 a 35 a °°i'26M 593 74 AD. 5'>°,l«uines8 calling ImTd" 237ld» 138 AD 308 114 AU •^3'limy question I37 AD °'""' *" "* ^° ^°^ 1136 686 608 notes lost case 3 3 34 b 1039 a 158 NY 672 89 damages a 35 b a 156 NY 93 obstruct St 3 35 b 359 a 156 NY 699 99 power of sale 8 35 b 616 66 AD 600 jwn title 73 M 422 title vests 73 M 423 103 ins. agent ls3SS 612 103 1 7 1 discretion 9 35 S 786 SSSTiss'nY 619 618 s 33 AD 469 461 7 AC 441n malice ^__ 114 AD 653 cond. precedent 152AD 6.W 182 waiver 3 35 S 945 20 M . 160 jurisdiction 39 M 76 12 AC 143n 144 1 87 innkeeper 8 85 S 739 AJJBKEVIATIONS: c, criticised; 1, limited; e, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, noie; explained; o, overruled; s, same case; .lo, dissenimi opinion': ti. parallel case: u, questioucu N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Hun Vols. 90, 91 28 M 214 17 AC 118n 120n 1 93jury question s 3S S 936 SAD 618 18 AD 522 1 98cloud on title ■ 35S 732 s 164 NY 754 206 biideea CO. ■ 36S 887 31 AD . 634 32 AD 631 166 NY 9(1 d21M 280 contingent 160 AD 4U9 2l8{alMTepieBn ■258 619 11 AD n4fi 28 AD 224 S3 AD loa 8 36S 113ti 85 M 327 action for fraud 60 AD 473 63 AD 263 do 164 NY 41 res ipsa ioq. 149 AD 427 master liable 81 M 322 274 cond. preoed s 3S S 964 49 AD 216 277 reference 8 36 » 931 a 148 NY 683 d 6 AD 117 280 commiisiona 166 AD 93 M opinion 103M 424 13 14 226 druggist nag. 8 36 S 661 16AC 274n 230 duty court B 35S 218 NY 233buTd. B 35S 139 AD domicile 87M 548 316 proof 69 121 196 238 2 years E 378 117 igAO 281n test, capacity 97 M 680 254 court's powi 66 AD s36 8 278 ■ liability 124AD injunetion 133 AD 699 721 732 124 258 former suit • 35 S 960 13 AC 169n 259 answer s 35 a 689 80 AD 63 260 injunction ■ 36 8 806 23 AD 378 2669epcrate acto B 35 S 935 93 AD . 293 negligence 16 AC 274b 267 negligence B 35 8 780 r 156 NY 109 r 6 AC 331 3 AC 332ii 4 AC 71n 354 demurrer dl93NY 437, 438 aUegationa b36S 18 AD 124AD 18 M 81 M B35S a 157 NY 30 AD 80 AD 89 AD 39 U for jury 221NY 284 legacy 8 36 8 a 149 NY 769 694 406 91 72 688 161 a 36 8 a 167 NY d6AD 27 M no power t 211 NY ultra vires 72 M 779 673 285 recovery ■ 36 8 762 a 164 NY 769 22 M 726 288 conspiracy 932 39 463 204 85 567 a 35 8 77 AD el6M 43 U 55M injunction 77M not illegal lOlM 290 purchase a 35 S 807 a 153 NY 652 298 contract a 35 8 a 6 AD 66 AD a 77 AD 868 342-43 596 38f41 303 adulteration a 35 8 956 a 149 NY 688 a 33 AD 422 422 8 46 AD 65 67 AD 396 S2 AD 44 expel mandam. 15 AC X64n 3 1 2 condemnatn 36 8 920 a 148 NY 540 legia. power 111 AD 773 330fact question s35S 36 AD 41 AD 340 uBm*y s36S a 164 NY 865 347 134 805 738 271 negligence b35S a 157 NY 7 AD evidence d56AD do 66 AD jury question 984 686 407 381 383 342 presumption 9 35 S 693 a 6 AD 374 41 AD 476 time serve an8w. 15 AC 351n appeal right 114 AD judgt. appeal 37 CP 205 cond. precedent 148AD 625 practice to stay 148AD 625 Q40P1 ^ ^43 505 59g' uurden plaiuiitt 137 72W 158 676 361 revocation a 36 8 896 a 163 NY 413 365 indorsement 89b 684 363 31b 160 76 power corpn. 149AD 358 370 pleading a 36 8 812 a 160 NY 579 4 AC 215n 374 approximate 8 35 S 909 a 157 NY 716 33 M 269 10 AC 256-57n 398 eonaiderat'ii 35 B 944 a 163NY 130 29 AD 561 cond. delivery 439 commissionfi * 158 NY 38 AD 81 AD 1 157 AD misrepresentatn 03 M 441 441 jurisdiction 45AD240 29M 401 waiver 368 3711 61 M discharge 118AD 404 fraud S35S a 163NY 6AD 117AD intervention 20 AD 160 NY consent 118AD ratification 151AD stockholders lOSM 241 603 811 132 360 696 689 661 257 149 586 646 499 481 715 4 1 devise , 8 35 8 881 30 AD 69 construction 66 M 503 4 1 4 discharge s 35 8 877 5 AD , 498 5 AC , 98ii 7 AC 260d enforcement 20AC 292n 4 1 9jury questioii 8 36S d7AD 32 AD 89 AD d95AD 16 M due care 206NY 918 316 15 19 433 121 163 87 422prom.note s36 8 a 149 NY 83 AD p20M 44 M reference 126 AD 164 AD compuls.ref. 744 S73 455 156 589 92] 218 180AD I 93 M aba 7 429 restraint s 3a S 978 35 AD 410 competing buu. 138 AD 3'Z2 436 oS-aet a 36 8 • 12 AD 816 302 9K3 663 8u a35U e46M review 116AU 465 will ev- 137 8 a 163 NY 898 198 465 oancelmeut s 36 8 54 b8AD 107 110 premium 45 AD 184 468fact question s 36 8 971 11 AD 268 474 taxu stock , 37 8 968 r 164NY 1 477 review s36 8 25 AD 39 AD 39 CP 642 judgt, bar 8 36 8 24 32 M 347 not prejudiced e 71 -M 112 564 carrier 8 36 8 26 23 M 668 36 M 566 presumption f 84 M 113 560jury question s 36 8 22 62 AD 679 56 AD 477 563 tenant dam. 8 36 8 68 15 AC 465n 565 infant's atty a 36 S 1006 d 66 AD 12b 82 AD 555 566 affidavit a 35 8 881 62 AD 672 e91AD „ 439 do 110 AD 909 25 M 417 568 apportment 56 424 439 481 conatitutL 8 36 8 36 62 AD 432 69 AD 315 43 M 269 488 prohib writ 8 36 8 p90 59 496 501 coatB s36d 65 33 AD 183 4 AC 126n pension tax 38 CP 182 509 prejudice 3 35 8 IIOU 170 NY 401 37 AD 32S 72 AD 39:^ reversible erroi 186AD 648 for jury 186AD 549 5 1 5 reinstatemt, s 35 8 964 a 149 NY 676 521 statemntev. 8 36 8 687 20 AD 116 assignment 117AD 324 525 taxation a 36 8 r 149 NY 540 sum pro. 8 35 S 961 8 42 M 230 s36 8 r 148 NY mandamus 61 M 40 187 199 584 parties 8 36 8 976 32 M 2Sb plaintiff's right 142 AD 625 588jury question s 35 8 976 78 AD 340 not irregular 151AD 761 589 gen'l denial 35 8 a 157 NY 46 AD 69 AD 62 AD 78 AD 87 AD 90 AD 14 AC plead statute 114 AD Stat, frauds 37 CP by answer 181AD 986 674 444 624 116 37 420 26 66n 767 210 605 appeal case 1 8 36 8 • 149 NY inference case 3 8 35 8 a 167 NY 16 AD 33 AD assignment case 4 s36S a 166 NY negligence case 5 8 35 8 r 166 NY mtge bonds case 9 8 35S 17 AD assessment case 13 s35S a 159 NY 1100 616 1132 692 606 644 1106 614 1109 187 lUl 166 1149 427 Judgment case 15 8 36 8 1119 a 166 NY 671 non compliance 184AD 943 606 recovery case 1 a 158 NY e33ND s35& 737 624 1112 607 orders case 6 s36S 1106 a 162 NY 623 r.r crossing case 7 8 36 8 a 162 NY legal effect le 17 1107 632 s36 8 1107 16 AD 3U SAC 321n review case 1 8 35 8 Mf a 167 NY 681 172 AD 732 508 tax exemptii 8 35 8 118(, a 148 NY 311 attachment case 4 8 35 8. 1102 a 149 NY 607 execution 3 114 AD 440 appeal case 5 S35 8 ,110^ a 148 NY 756 attachment case 6 s'3SS nic a 149 NY 588 609 taxation case 8 9 36 8 a 160 NY VOL. 91. I contrib neg. 8 36 8 r 158 NY 83 697 9 jury question s36S 112 a 153 NY 683 12 jury question 36 8 a 167 NY 1 7 accord s36S d78AD 87 AD 12 AC election 78M 102 687 95 486 588 451n 126 2 1 compensation 8 36 8 88 32 AD 129 21 M 146 paid by town 72 M 455 28 jury question 3 36 8 106 d 6 AD 603 27 AD 56 38 memorandum s3AD 488 r36 8 99 53 will 8 36 8 822 a 149 NY 539 action pending 38 CP 391 55 negligence 9 36 8 686 s 161 NY 660 a 168 NY 699 4 AC 183n SAC 309n 12 AC 321n 67 execution 8 36 8 18 AD 19 AD d4AC 6 AC 176 436 260 343 124n 76 assignment 9 36 8 a 154 NY trust 186AD 168 767 110 89 claim 8 36 8 21 M 29 M 31 M 41 M 0311 7 AC 9 AC interpreted 98 M 601 179 662 302 278 687 162n 149n 94 liq. license s 36 8 678 35 AD 74 101 constitHt'l 9 34 8 8 36 8 a 148 NY 89 14 AD 44 AD 45 AD 152 NY 20wiU s36S a 154 NY 641 677 360 296 487 472 75 365 131 313 1 34 transfer tax a 363 538 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; i. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n note- c. criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s. same case: do, dissentinz opinion; p, parallel case; q, questioned Vol, 91 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Hun a 154 NY 22 M 144 authority s 36S 371 lOlM 435 246 214 asBessment ■ ISSU 36 S • 211 m 158 NY 41 43 AD 337 e 24 M 615 41 M 489 I 46 corporation » 36 S 277 a 158 NY 709 1 52'. Stat constrn 534 242 362 185,lii6 597 297 284 491 8 36! 32 AD 52 AD 106 AD 19 M e21 M 36 M 85 M impose tax do 165 AD 323 220 jurisdiction 8 36S • 148 NY 14 AD 66 AD several 78 AD 94 AD 1 58 tax GorpD 368 608 248 284 589 s36S a 149 NY d5AD 22 AD d29 AD 36 AD 44 AD 464 5 AC 2l4fa 13 AC 372-73n contract 167 AD 230 conclusion 9 36 S 159 s 3 AD 352 70 AD 418 233 presumption 9 36 S 160 r 149 NY- 649 13 AD 70 improper ev 50 AD 163 s36S 61 AD receiver 287 546 1 65 will s36S a 159 NY ev. harml'ss error 11 AC 22n probate will 19A0 282n incompetent ev. 356 288n udgm 213 682 162 AD 19A0 1 70 final B36S * 156 NY 1 73 conuniss'ns s 36 S 347 a 158 NY 696 1 76 power re- moval s 36 S 331 37 M 374 1 84 sate appli' ce s36S a 156 NY 20 AD 42 AD 278 phys. exam, s 36 S 149 47 M 356 279inad verd. 151 744 S38 699 336 382 8 36S a 157 NY 53 AD 281 costs s36S SAD 54 AD 20 M f26Nf 6 AC SAC 360 236 diligence >936 S 153 7 AD 416 26 M 486 notice protest 7AG llln de facto corpn. 12 AC 220n 225n surety ■192 N Y 607 241 bridge con- struction 8 36S 1131 a 151 NY 190 !43 safe place 36 S 208 r 157 N 261 22 AD Y 592 247 trial notice s 36 S 149 108 AD 318 250 exemption 936 S 156 10 AC 896n etain money 66M 538 25 1 weight of ev 667 254 400 36 S 91 s21 AD 23 AD 39 AD 53 AD 66 AD 73 AD 19 M 1 87 plea of prfmce. s36S 70 AD 31 M 10 AC jurisdiction 138 AD pleading t 166 AD 437 29 426 679 209 1 94 usury bank s 36 S 214 49 M 421 do 189NY 23 I97genl. verdct s 36 S 325 6 AC 21 7d 204 guardian 259 cummiss'ne s 36 S 141 a 152 NY 648 261 agreement -fiS 114 a 159 NY 623 disaffirmance 111 AD 788 266 title office s36S 18 AD 209 will b36S D 1123 113 344 142 323 72 75 134 649 649 339 307 482 s36S a 151 NY 6 AD 202 497 611 69 M 498 201 683 484 199 421 24 431 501 163n 166 24 2n 294 weight of ev "3S 1122 7 AC 461n 15 AC 380n 386n 295 requests 8 36 S 294 29 AD 66 submit fact 141 AD 677 299 open default B 36 S 333 6 AC 41n appeal 122 AD B68 SOOjury question 9 36 S 293 r 157 NY 244 302 complaint 9 36 S 290 8 AO 209n 308 veteran 3 36S 172 r 149 NY 215 3 1 3eraployee 9 36 S 17 AD 89 AD 21 M 27 M 30 M s3AC 4 AC 526 196 4S3n 232 761 49 4 2g4n 25 3 1 7 mandamus »35S. 213 r 151 NY 386 s37S 1143 damaises 139 AD 320 review 3 3RS ., 26 AD d39AD S7AD 19 M 261 424 646 624 482 56 AD 486 487 sa/le power I32AD T4.>> 98 M 122 124 338 injunction 36 S 246 17 M 537 340 stop over ticket 8 36 S ^ 768 175 NY 19 AD 533 compens. dam. 50 AD 112 no recovery laeAD 734 344 excise law 36S 755 a 148 NY 648 346 oonsidera'tn 9 36 S . 226 a 157 NY 696 9 AC 203n 349 ejectment s 36 S • 220 a 167 NY 445 354 larceny 36 S 493 33 AD 340 349 64 AD ' 466 456 360 amendment _ ! • 311 7 AD 82 II AC 166n court's power 35 AD 181 383 oond sale s 36 S 178 a 167 NY 683 R4 AD 234 23 22 M 125 10 AC 210 10 AC 213-14n q 10 AC 220. consideration 65 AD 412 96 AD 166 III AD 788 hen election 118AD no lien 143 AD lien chattel S2M 425 certiorari S 861 20 AD 381 removal f 82 M 683 429 damages 8 36 S ■ 838 a 157 NY 437 1 AD 371 374 67 M . 429 indemnity 146 AD 84 440' proof allege tion s36S 34 897 ICPNS 226 233 200 360 402 337 46 313 143n 264 104 430 14 AD 31 AD 44 AD 20 M e23M 70 M 8 2 AC SAC 181 NY pleading S2M 103, 84-M guaranty 61 M ■ 647 burden defendt. 65 M 516 repudiated 70 M 447 review 9 36S a 168 NY 16 AD 17 AD 21 AD 47 324 dismissal 9S6S 3 AD 22 AD 57 AD 7 AC 15 AC objections • 156 AD .1022 76 631 191 461 n 386n 2S!i 272 review 9 36S 24 AD. 6 riparian owner 82 AD 558 e 105 AD 21j! 181 NY 85 276iury question 8 36 S 263 a 157 NY 697 21269 AD 366 329 assumption 36 8 1020 do 1 04 AD 604 d 106 AD town board 41 M 573 196AD 848 Dower board 138 AD 477 335 construction 8 36 S 231 a 157 NY 697 41 AD 332 616 373 open default » 36 S ■ 762 a 149 NY 690 6 AC 42n 375 sale mdse 9 36 S , 846 9 1 65 NY 544 9 38 AD 629 384 pier dower 36 S 129 18 NY 292 389 bad faith 3 36 S 248 a 148 NY 563 39 1 sp. prfmanee 9 3fiS IRf a 158 NY «93 14 AD 427 defect proof t 116 AD 613 398 will gift 5 36S 317 a 153 NY 134 42 1 amendment s 36 S 223 62 M 316 19A0 297n 20AC 3n 387 722 692 361 79 463 damages 8 36 S 756 a 157 NY 687 470 stipulations. s36S 315 8 7 AD - 3?7 474 reV-ers. error 8 ;6 S 1034 a 148 NY 631 157 NY 348 477 St opening 8 36S 311 a 149 NY 575 480 indorsement s36 S do 81 AD 49 M agency 49 M nthori-ty f 215 NY 240 621 555 556 274 270 451 452 453 512 352 352n 429 111 50 AD 52 AD waiver 65 AD e55AD e 53 AD 82 AD 7AC 7AC allegation 83 AD 141 AD assumption 19 M 270 28M 115 incompetency 113 AD 735 for jury 147AD 526 502fr'd transfer s36 S 648 16AD 592 43 AD 471 52 AD 369 91 AD 117 509cn3struction ■i 36 S 576 151 NY 282 q 2AD 28 declarations 5AD 164 105 AD 220 CO llat, attack 590 taxation 8 36 S 842 a 149 NY 689 f 91 ^ 597 prin. office 69LRA . 439n 599 contract a 36 S 653 r 167 NY. . 213 605 accounting 350 178AD 20 M 535sureties "36 8 a 167 NY f 161 AD 662 830 682 877 539 ndorser 9 36 S 254 a 153 NY 411 542 injunction 176n 279 245 347 s36S 9 17 AD . 136 8 bar 52M recovery 18 IAD 545jury question 9 36 8 ■ 753 108 AD 92 547. spl. damagec 9 36 8 18AC 554 pledge t36S a 167 NY 7 AD 180 .183n 355 651 608 489 injunction i36S do 170 NY 2 AD 74 A.D 24M 26M e31 M 39 -M tl M 57 M 81 M 9 AC e9AC lUC J70P dsmag'es RfiM 487 msv strike 174 AD 249 303 343 521 112 29S 611 664 58 331 99 645 lln 16n 23ii 210 211 723 632 appeal s36S * 148 NY e 163 NY 163 NY construction 17 AD jurisdiction 23 AD 635 appeal case 1 - 36 8 a 148 NY seduction cas^e 15' 9 36S r 153 NY trespass case 16 a 163 NY a36S review case 20 a 153 NY 35 8 negligence ise22 163 NY 36 8 628 765 573 66 ^97 346 1131 766 1130 90 428 1127 666 970 274 1124 565 rule pleadng 36 S a 155 NY 23 AD 20 M 40 M usury 46 M 146 AD 184AD voidable 184AD do 184AD 835 641 355 62 62 431 7. 822 charge 34 H 395 mental pain 20 lAD 469 compensatory 203NY 358 64M 75 250 partnership 8 36 » 942 19 AD 438 spec, perfnce 112 AD 282 256 accid death s 36 d 931 a 157 NY 690 43 A P 490 260 replevin s 36 S 612 a 154 NY 784 264 promise B 36 S 875 11 AD 424 3 3 AC 22 enforcement 182AD 321 269 obstruetst. 3 36 S 672 a 157 NY 312 15 AD 231 contrib negligen. 31 AD 371 272 harmless error 3 36 S 952 4 AD 442 services 70 AD 130 3t. limitations 97 AD 359 15 AC 285 116AD 211 incompetent 147AD 7 323 undertaking 3 36 S 904 a 154 NY 761 327 accountable 3 36 S 742 124 288 impeachment 18AC 4S8n recovery 75M 280 277 amend by- laws 647 648 223 occupancy insurance 3 36 S 873 64 AD 372 e 100 AD 281 vacant" s36S 169NY 19 AD 40 AD 69 AD 74 AD IBM 19 M 34 M 734 48 83 688 581 531-32 266 183 632 301 contract 3 36 S 765 a 168 NY 361 306 highway s 36 S 870 22 M 378 13 AC 243-44n dedication 14 AC 260n 3 1 1 breach s 36 S 962 a 149 NY 606 80 AD 498 construetn stat 19 M 693 38 M 104 26 CP 240 318 renunciation 3 36 S 882 29 M 39 37 M 686 right dower 14 AC 254n Letters admnistru e 29 M 723 33 M 326 3 37M 589 715 LOO AD 483 16A C 372n discretion 123 AD decree f 130AD administration 159 AD 41 d 80 M 485 84 M 680 next of kin 159 AD 42 construction 161 AD 260 i!12 NY 218 prerequisite 84 M 681 17 M 413 369huaband liab 3 36 S 665 46 AD 348 85 AD 174 40 M 366 107 AD 559 presumption 122 245 373 discretion 647 651 568 32o 216 893 s36S * 151 NY 40 AD remit bail 13 AC sureties liable 15 AC 391n 29 CP 299 378 commitment 3 36 S 995 60 AD 100 24 M^ 531 jurisdiction do 100 AD 323 incompetent do 152AD 369 38 1 personal transaction S36S 690 13 AD 493 21 AD 233 24 AD 448 60 AD 130 29 M 72 30 CP 43 usury 66M 102 competency 142 AD 114 construction 205NY , 395 385 adultery conclusive a36S WM a 175NY 236 6AC 277n 30CP 43 33 1 fixtures 3 36 S 928 20 AD 461 62 AD 126 retroactve elTect 20AC 53n 282 neg. sparks s36S 719 4 AD 467 22 AD 613 9'AC 334n 335 satisfaction s 37 S 411 159 AD 751 347 warranty 3 36 S 868 14 AC 291n 85M 465 wholesome 222NY 415 349 taxation 3 36 S 531 • 151 NY 664 354 indictment s36S 511 a 149 NY 1 397 crdr receiver 3 36 S 764 r 153 NY 490 400 request verd 3 36 S 660 16 AD 610 404 audit claims 3 36 S 760 a 168 NY 695 406 commisBTon^ 3 36S 991 a 4 AD 265 6 AD 246 37 AD 163 37 AD 163 40 AD 660 do 99 AD 348 certif. con. r.r 15 AC 456n disclosure 136AD 606 do 136AD 610 4 1 2con8tab. liab s 36 S 762 11 AC 222n 4 1 5 annul mar- riage s36S 24 M 6 AC alimony 44 M 610 373 187n 327 8 AC 141n 143n 419 nee parties s 36S 662 19A0 191n 16AC 308n *rH,?L^d^^W?mifed- e' ^nKil^l Vjfv"°^,''^'' "' '°"'' "^^ = '' ^""«37S r 158 NY 324 flxrs fe«0 220 junsdn. 8 37 8 r 151 NY 788 172 223 insur policy 8 37 S 769 39 631 632 228 allegations 9 37 S 720 33 44 33 61 50 137 do 50 138 102 307 neg damage, commission 126 accountable 135 liability do 148 ' individual 210 NY 240 notice 38 S SAC 8 37 8 s3 AC 123 27 M 37 M 38 M allowance 122 328 tender 8 37 3 dl3 26 surrender 1 221NY 332 character s 37 S 974 62 363 revers. pttot 129 677 336 attachment 13 255 85 112 613 220n 245 infant neg s 37 8 792 90 673 258 construction 8 37 S 696 r 157 NY 449 37 M 272 264 bona fides 8 37 8 706 158 NY 690 267insurance 8 37 8 811 a 154 NY 752 346 trustee for heirs 38 M appraisal 14 AC 292 waiver a 37 S 53M 280 332n 736 549 295 presumption 8 37 S 909 8 19 367 e 109 880 17AC 434n 436n 17AC 438 voucher 91 443 444 299 remov.vetn. 8 37 S 718 do 12 642 301 contract 8 37 8 742 a 157 NY 710 37 404 restoration 94 124 minority stk hldr 3 AG 38gn ratification 151 481 969 224 469 609 201 852 64 6 162 662 479 447 867 524 94 178 8 37 8 f 3AC vacate order 4 25 M 34 M affidavits 28 CP 340 review s37S 24 46 849 40 23 666 811 363 854 631 365 359 certiorari b37S removal 6 18 S2 37 M 848 289 210 254 374 361 insiuance s 37 8 712 (2 617 8 36 50 legislative power 28 340 20 M 468 59 M 680 369 authority a 37 8 726 • 168 NY 663 19 164 S3 249 250 124 912 do 76 427 428 d 164 NY 129 authorized 65H 326 oompet evidence 123 740 not justified 143 146 incompet ev. f 149 503 quantum meruit ~ ■" 406 jurisdiction 146 636 appl. authorized 166 222 4 1 9 extortion a 37 8 1005 r 150 NY 365 do212NY 86 87 change venue 114 702 ev. other crimes 62 LRA 328n 444 removal 37 8 991 a 151 NY 664 17 484 490 129 482 explanati'tn 489 62 129 280 282 221 97 M 374 charge a 37 8 r 158 NY 12 21 22 M 17 43 48 53 e58 62 do 166 NY 17 M certiorari 27 212, 214 173 202 NY trial police 130 770 73 504 547 703 452 trusta 8 37 8 a 158 f2 ratification 84 M 387 negligence 342 partnership s37 8 838 7 170 surety 18 504 41 666 46 639 47 M 587 do 47 M 690 591 62M 172 do 67 M 147 67 M 143 principal debtor 139 930 explain cause 221NY .3! 37 S dl3 dl9 s22 26 d32 56 48JliI 60 M 830 298 J 33 629 644 16-20 329 530 294 121 346 findings 837 S 8 152 NY a 154 NY 23 31 gartnership 1 72 el06 33H 35M e44M intention 63M f 96 M amendment 148 dismissal 157 751 642 767 668 56 348 432 649 482 697 294 16 197 777 719 354 admission s 37 8 841 a 158 NY 735 62 546 76 363 oond precedt 188NY 504 error d95 construction 119 24 set aside vd. f 59 M 37 tangbl. proof 181 480 contrib. negtig. 156 31 390 appeal 8 37 8 a 158 NY certificate 7 AC exceptions 104 794 693 58 396 injunction s37S S3 AC * 150 NY 150 NY f4 39 damages 54 67 982 264 395 398 611 663 257 48 404 settlement s37 8 36 25 M 40 M 959 513 221 106 408 felony 8 37 8 998 m 150 NY 366 change venue 114 701 17AC 273n no appeal 128 77, 78 lllS 117 43 214 372 1080 333 53 253 49 145 108 714 1032 69s 618 810 a 37 8 f 109 8 3 AC 7 AC 17AC 498 8 37S 5 56 ev excise agt 65 204 93 203 record evidence 78 434-5 168 NY 494 50 1 deposition a 37 S 1078 9 3 AC 16 15 AC 219n 503 negligence a37S 1111 a 158 NY 736 impeach ev. 19A0 325n 334n 508 fraud 8 37 8 a 1 53 NY do 144 insufficient t 160 460 damages 37 8 1037 d 58 186 f 90 M 83 default eSM 474 construction 69 it 68 value property 90 M 3i interest lOlSI 442 477 attachment a 37 8 1086 8 6 219 a 2 AC 397 a 146 NY 406 r 148 NY 202 service summons 7 609 valid lien 16 186 valid levy 62 539 479 new order s 37S 1092 102M 657 483 encroacht 8 713 426 59 9 38 8 a 157 NY 14 15 mark, title 38 132 40 40 358 81 211 97 17 24 M 318 SAC 4n burden proof 50 M 437 bad title 122 877 easement 184 3491552 attachment 90 M -- 8 28 8 49 33 CP 328 336 645 646 496 costs stay 102S 681 533 513 indorser 8 38 8 22 a 159 433 518 special performance s 38 8 23 144 .786 522 parties 8 37 8 1119 20 M 246 525 damages s37 8 a 157 23 75 37 M 37 M 1093 718 598 305 616 617 53 I income s 37 8 1086 81 167 vested interest 73 M 198 534 order ref. s 38 8 26 s 3 AC 140 24 M 305 e38M 113 separation 129 648 536 record pers. a 38 8 27 5 329 168 NY 494 assumption 17 302 weight of ev. do 26 186 a 153 NY 65 545 damages a38S 4 a 158 NY 466 a 68 516 519 9 121 114 405 49 I res judicata b37S 1083 .. .- s 14 188 702lfl 170 NY 281 s38S * 149 NY 114 119 37 CP. 36 591 124 819 187 cond. precedent 49 142 82 478 undertaking 329 124 420 100 43]M poundage 114 p 44M a 3 AC adjudication 82 477 479 no lien do 179 373 556 appeal s37 8 1104 103 102 561 jury queatn a 38 8 13 82 608 19 M. 645 566change venue a 37 8 13 AC 7, 119 39 CP 106M 1098 149 461 338 341 300 569 irregularity s 37 8 1025 44 S3 trustee 98 substitution d 166 NY e35 M 613 566 152 574 descriptive s 37 S 1076 70 100 amendment 73 / 243 8 3 AC 112 "as" in titles 13 AC I97n title vested 142 363 166 907 identify f 158 831 577 attys under- writers s37S 6 17 f 20 32 34 37 41 58 dl8M elOM 21 M 58 M s3 AC 4 AC 4 AC 1114 543 41e42 82 87 37 466 469 503 297 593 243 287 530 116 359 368n 590 prop, in state al50 NY 27 8 38 8 131 114 214 transfer tax p2 619 3 477 30 M 20 6 10 amend verd. s 38 S 29 32 38 104 e 101 120 .57M 5 AC 6 AC review 106M 210, 33 355 251 582 467 76 829 374 355 220 496 615 new trial case 11 ABBREVIATIONS: •.,.•• J ■ ,. -.J .-'.affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; ♦, dismissed: n. note- e. criticised: I, lunited: e, explained; o, overruled: s. same case; do, dissenting opinion: o. oaralle) case: a. ouestione'dr Vols. 2, 3 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division 739 1147 150 1150 641 672 « 37 S 1145 a 157 NY 696 judgment case 13 .« 37 S 1145 a 158 NY 732 616 new trial case 2 a 154 NY B 37 S case 15 s37 S a 157 NY case 16 B 37 S 8 152 NY a 153 NY case 19 appeal s 37 S 457 a 150 NY 219 617 undertaking case 2 • 37 S 1146 a 161 NY 636 case 16 services s 37 8 1147 B 22 631 618 judement easel s 38 S a 158NY case 3 s38 S a 158 NY bill particulars 144 154 1146 697 1141 69« 619 transfer tax case 2 s 38 S 378 a 150 NY 36 620 reargument case 12 e38S b84 case 20 damages B38S ■ 161NY 1148 433 1142 63 VOL. 3 6 nonliability s 37 B 965 21 M 219 I I neg. preaum'n s37S 8 67 17 extr. 8 37S 28 029 443 243 allow. 988 623 22 telgiii delay 933 123 26 valid 156 120 837 S3 AC 19 insurance d65 , agency el7M strict constructn 98 442 152 55 36M 788 gross neg. 120 441 limit liability do 79 M 22 26 court power s 37S 1070 133 89 special term 144 797 30 drainage s 37 S 1056 a 155 NY 703 38 conatruotioc s37S a 158 NY e20 152 renjainder 29 16 6NY 167 NY intention 31 M 43 bequest S37S a 154 NY d33 2SM costs TAC 1107 679 102 749 199 408 493 534 1079 734 54 470 270 46 1022 18 11 dl8 77 license 8 38 8 12 86 reUef pldg. 8 38 S 917 recovery proof 11 AC 176 dismissal 157 719 91 authority B 39 S 402 24 94 87 M _ 148 proof service 24 298 state claim 119 B56 laches 169 409 410 103 ord. 3 39S f3 appeal 618 243 25 340 do 26 342 filing mandatory 25 M 84 29 M 446 56 M 114 lis 121 65!! election laws flOS 273 276 construction flOS 274 authority 155 722 109 witnesB failure to call partition 81i> 48 review b37S 25' 68 69 1061 292 371 343 51 request error B 38 S 229 19 563 set aside 24 264 correct error 76 628 new trials 151 762 lOOM 113 no waiver 79 M 27 60 stipln. neg. s 38 S 1066 s 3 AC 126 36 M 786 gross neglignce 75M 568 liability do 79 M 22 65 insur. policy 8 38 S 986 22 388 incumbrance 62 M 120 70 prepond. ev. b39S s3 AC 13 18 21 22 46 74 74 86 20 M 21 M 22 M 36 M 37 M 11 AC 11 AC inferenue 105 presumption 52 M 274 29 330 248 24 539 381 678 680 126 71 24g 603 2SS 486 126 32S 298 500 139 com. aee'tg s38S 39 401 308 309 86 S60 13 AC 366 compensation 59 M 366 1 44 negligence B 38 S 49 assume risk 26 358 153 7 duty master 62 95 1 49 another action pending 205 rule dam. s 38 S 393 84 369 5 AC 180n 208 transf tax s3SS a 149 NY 25 74 e86 100 23 M f 94 M 34 M 38 S s3 AC 38 78 33 M. 13 AC 164 210 374 591 66 164n 1 55 former ev. s 38 S 193 88 463 custody child UO 126 e46M illegal ev 17AC guardian 18AC appt, guardian ISAC 46 L 116 163 872 452 277 618 96 79 556-7 377 233 75 366 eq conversion e 167 NY 232 28 M 605 30 M -30 e 32 M 493 jurisdiction 67 M 363 fractnal intrst, d 176 104M: 853 515 i 57 injunction s38S 319 e 89 384 surface water 98 405 211 NY 259 211 NY 263 s38 S I 1 8 contract s 39 S 420 62 120 stock subscrptn 123 24 not enforoible 129 339 invalid 93 M 484 1 27 witnea* s 39 8 393 impeaohment of e 20 318 20 326 76 805 12 AC 112 1 29 faarmleas er 8 39 B 366 88 341 II AC 31 2n 1 32 negligence s 39 S 363 co-servant 16 20 • 57 1 64 taxation s 38 8 222 a 169 NY 36 606 166 , 861 injunction 66 LRA 104 ounstitutional 206 NY 38 f 166 854 170 co-tenants s 38 S 399 a 150 NY 90 1 7 1 certiorari 8 38 S 392 40 611 s38S s28 ' f6 10 16 32 112 stipulation d51 law matter 68 do 77 certificate 7 AC 460 462n 22 1 rule damages 66 LRA 378-9 jurisdiction 117 813 pleading 120 653 1 73 direct verd. b38S s3AC 29 40 do 40 23 M 26 M submit 141 fact 350 109 66 172 174 114 821 677 104154 LRA 262 177 75 160n 176 illeg. acts 8 38 8 466 a 159 NY HI 25 337 finding facts 111 453 1 98 estoppel s 38 S 209 10 557 41 . . 316 restriction 2 1 3 parties 8 38 8 IW."! 6 79 jurisdiction 43 M 289 2 1 5 warranty s38S 253 a 154 NY 743 a 160 NY 342 5 4 } 626 27 467 acceptance 34 26 M 14 AC assignee claim 104 . 193 16 771 286n 244 election law s38 8 a ISO NY 35 254 equity b38S 63 M 348 242 180 ct. 204 121 6 AC 72 M 137n 114 257 oomm'ns s 38 3 400 B 10 444 259 negligence b38B 456 a 158NY 674 5 494 do 77 167 263 rule 'dam. s 38 8 384 6 53 266 Buretiea s 38 B 199 r 158 NY 65 273 stkholder b38S a 157 NY 48 e29 M compliance 140 277 surplus 38 8 8 3 AC 45 34 M do 165 233 717 13 5 581 363 157 338 110 85 219 crossing neg 362 446 611 362 85 9 558 346 102 166 b38B e70 116 72 131 36 M 4 AC 57 LRA 227 equity s38S a 161 NY a 167 NY 230 rulings a 38 8 a 167 NY 21 18 M recoupment 32 M 461 537 744 78n 525 211 109 202n 459 659 712 482 714 41 209 151 235 easement b38 8 72 98 131 25 M 67 M 197NY 417 563 231 7ff8 633 510 368 396 267 100 284 damages 8 38 8 a 166 NY 18 intent 39 53 70 notice record 95 231 neg. attorney 26 CP 383 298 assignment s 38 8 368 a 26 344 withdrawal in tent 27 - 4 61 600 5 AC 326 236n 3 1 8 suplm. pro. s388 29 M 196 262 387 90 256 472 182 34S 360 550 728 305 lien 3 38 S fill £158 f 159 81 M 308 Gonsideratn s 38 8 273 47 424 gift proof 106 COS 3 1 3life insurance 8 38 8 costs 7 estoppel 10 dl5 warranty 258 383 485 121 496 356 490 35 106 proofB death 50 474 50 , , 475 limitation' waiver 63 281 f 66 22 fact question 24 M 738 costs 4 AC 150 322 trustee a 38 8 e87 37 M 43 M 44 M wife, widow 137 540 152 55 329 real estate B 38 S 316 37 274 eq. portion 157 145 334 Corp. mtge. s38 8 f3 17 estoppel 57 assignment elSM osjecion 62 M 347 discharge s 38 B 314 e 36 375 veteran 63 248 construction 58M 283 350 authority 299 353 iud'l accounting 81 M 38T 353 reversal 619 156 449 110 260 1063 B 38 S 535" s38S a 3 AC 24 280 231 266 84 86 81 202 13 366 180 practice 115 new trial £ 172 37 CP review power 134 707 359 evidence 33 B 290 18 M 306 252 construction d 37 M 567-8 363 negligence 8 38 8 s 151 NY a 157 NY 19 e20M due care 60 136 obligation 81 M 486 659 718 590 36 472 667 313 366 assessment s 38 8 521 a 168 NY 673 370 negligence 8 38 8 3 161 NY 41 charge 84 15 AC 206 636 518 36n 379 nuisance 8 38 S 989 diversion water 11 122 18 262 78 519 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; c, criticised; I, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q, questioned vVj N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division M 104 87 3o3 error dam* 8 3S S 934 s 3 AC 153 385 neg. care s 39 S 245 11 155 389 alter writ a 38 S 651 31 M 328 39 I note comtee 8 38 S 707 a 151 NY 622 27 M 501 construction 60 M 377 395 taxpayer s 38 S 922 s 16 519 8 m. lien 8 39 8 69 121 121 24M limitation 99 119 parties d 121 lien bond d 60 M not apply 206 NY 887 42 318 134 379 467 626 762 460 393 643 32 neg. exceptions 74M S53 champerty 37 CP 12 e.Kceptns. proof 159 330 equity s39S 9 335 labels 3 39 8 a 158 NY 552 266 464 223 306 47 M stockhldrs 184 powers 184 207 actn 226 787 263 stay action s 39 3 163 16AG 263n 869 121 63 M assignment void 137 246 1 40 partnership name 9 39 8 81 S7 98 fictitious names 70 M 533 1 47 admissions s39S 114 67 328 151 credibility 40 67 462 25 M 192 28 CP 203 1 56 construction 9 38 8 1097 a 180 NY 669 1 64 mandamus 3 39 S 76 el3 310 311 minimum age 152 155 193 contrib: nog. 8 38 S 1104 f 125 d44M 202 instruct jury 104 419 motion dismiss f 138 744 requests 16AC 337 1 98 amendment s38S 97 20 AC estoppel f56M waiver £ 127 1112 276 2n 616 340 202 discontinue 39 8 24 f 27 d33 6 AC 7 AC 9 AC 181 684 991050 428n 432n 226n substitution 112 792 206 servicefl 8 39 8 206 29 M 440 14 AC 372n 208 undertaking 222 strike out 9 39 8 30 42 M 10 AC demurrer 106 45M 218 255 9 284n 287 266 228 compul ref. d 119 8 39 8 134 43 M accounting 118 38C reference 164 691 204 774 163 300 352 218 227 discretion s 39 8 140 a 160 NY 570 118 300 23 M 296 232 construction 8 38 8 66 injunction 37 CP lOOM 311 280 69 175 240 accounting a 39 8 141 a 159 NY 638 judgment 109 646 246 tax foreign corporation 268 negligence s39 3 r 158 NY 134 273 for'n judgt s39S 117 a 151 NY 640 276 conatitutl. 8 39 8 164 a 162 NY 72 fS 621 33 M 690 283 diaaolution 8 39 8 124 * 151 NY 511 resettle order 48 M 361 estoppel 168 77 284 op'g default 8 39 8 124 • 151 NY 611 6 AC 36n order 26 M 130 342 rehearing s 30 S 323 d 23 441 contract 628^62 120121 e77 38 public poliey f77 41 37 LKA 711 66 696 intervention 66 696 illegal 185 780 vd. pub. policy 185 ' 706 *160 NY 830 8 90 20M 21 M exclusively 68 M 349 contrib neg 8 39 S 30! el9M 110 safe plaoe sll4 38 354 conaideratn 424 easement 8 39 8 248 8 AC . 127n prescritpion 200 NY 422 62 M 227 adv. possession 140 294 f 217 NY 14 317 NY 17 432 assm'd risk 696 302 679 35 469 642 r 158 NY 8 39 8 do 9 17 18 e20M oral 134 109 228 414 390 126 663 agreement 779 373 accord 8 39 8 11 19 M 21, M 26 M 199 99 176 77 773 38 1 real estate 290 rap. transit a 39 8 23 39 M court power f 114 760 478 20 216 120 309 Burplua 8 39 8 67 incumbrance 122 limitations 131 lien . discharge lOPNS 296 3 18 eq. ooan 168 NY . 682 s39S 37 mtge. lien S3 el8M 21 M d33M 3S0 34M bailee lien 4 AC 430 436n 10 AC 13Snl39n 13 AC I12n unliquidated 139 751 398 125 s39 8 8 dll 52 dl7M stay 209 NY 137 617 46 438 644 67 s39 8 d23 31 d49 64 e77 e98 f 104 a 149 NY d 157 NY 163 NY dSlM 32 M 161 531 264 110 142 191 84 629 623 164 472 667 s39S 17 reoonverBion 49 M void trust 121 direct sale 78 M 324 contract 241 309 8 39 8 56 b72 8 79 s84 171 NY 184 NY 3 40U 8 84 86 '108 291 616 616 81 662 269 260 410 229 306 269 260 161 268 274 546 328 689 488 189 392 aasigBment 8 39 8 29f 16 260 398 damages 8 39 8 294 sl4 438 48 466 404 diseoaUnne 8 39 8 307 6 AC 103s 408 waiver 8 39 8 212 36 197 contract evi 142 15 value services "7 299 84 416 impl. assum. 129 397 412 ins. trustees s 39 S 313 177 759 441 oonatruetien b3&S 609 27 668 23 M 6 448 26 H 534 7 AC 26n prohibition 18 M 6S6 444 open acct. s 39 S 48 138 901 burden plaintiff 168 S8 448 limitation a 168 NY 737 8 39 8 216 sealed instrumt. 160 837 459 accounting r 169 NY 118 B 38 8 1107 residue 162 666 464 joint use B 39 8 20 8 6 206 38 496 enforcement 145 647 472 books ev. s 38 8 1100 9 AC 142 n 480 partnership B 38 8 1060 51 349 charge 63 478 483 damages s 38 S , 1102 J? 1« 71 602 e 20 M 34 contrib. negli. 141 628 492 negligence s 38 S 1077 34 74 46 282 89. „ 339 482 IBAC 328n contrib. neg. 190NY foi' jury 206 NY 495 equity 8 38 8 25 M 498 bar s39S 43 H 313 86 1069 726 36 65 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r. reversed- m ninHifi,.rt ■ ♦ j:.~- j c, criticised; 1. limited; e, oxolained; o. overruled; s,' same case. io. diss^Sng opii'ionf p! p^Vallilt^Tri iuSti^^S Vols. 5, 6 N. Y. Supreme Court Beports— Appellate Division alimony 7 *C 250ii enforce decree 148 508 20 AC 2a2n 499 dam. neg* 8 38 S 1089 33 . 2S0 contrib. neg. 63 ■ 607 assumed risk 62 282 do 128 791 rules necessary j.35n 555 affidavit a39S 434 25 116 27 319 67 342 120 624 29 M 657 change venue 45 M 23f> 559 doing busin. *iuty 20 AC 505 < s38S' 8 • 12 , oonclusive 68 20 M 1079 38S 179 637 603 33 628 508 estoppel s 38 S 1083 e 23 M 180 30 M 171 5 1 5 default 8 39S f 25 appeal 41 ' 45-, 16AC 446n return filing 47 -JSS 24 M 19(i 8 AC 300n ten days d 91 M 518 5 1 7 negligence a 38 S 1075 9 142 counter claim 15 AC 469n 520 illegal 8 38 S 10S7 15 12 523 certiorari b39S removal 95 do 25 60 131 133 283 339 . 259 '734 *53, 78 positive 149 B27 objections s 38 S 1062 36 M 686 iiarmless error 11 AC 33n 629 recovery a 1'68 NY 673 a 89 S 520 535 nodertkg s 30 S 486 35 237 stay terms dl42 497 544 negligence a 1S4 NY 783 s 39 S 437 d 23 20 33 goo 79 443 446 con trib. neg. 25 M 65 86 M 495 discreet attendt 72 M 559 not negligence f 86 M 492 547 h'd writing s4as 769 27 M 88 10 AC 260 26Sd 432 238 15 141 9 805 127 222 360 620 51 262 379-Sln 388II 21911 s39S 8 3 AC 25 64 102 112 20 M 40 M e 45M 53M HTM £ 92 M 13 AC 13 AC 20 AC court facta 56 584 leg. contract 128 248 cond. prfecdt. 66M 544 562 compt. ev s 39 S 413 3ttM 22 interested 179 850 565 marriage a39 S 396 15 AC 19n presumption 75M 452 570certiorari 8 39 S 372 a 158 NY 708 authorize 185 489 577neg damage s 39 S 381 t 11 358 17 161 18 95 62 . 86 guard highway 98 580 15AC 298n statutory 138 28 dismissal 183 187 590 construction do 149 159 6 1 3 discretion 8 39S 350 18 M 248 19 M 194 6 1 4 neg. rules s'39 S 464 14 72 54 LRA 112n 126n 163n 1142 681 667 1106, 6 1 9 negligence case 1 8 38S a 163 NY 30 partition case 2 m ISO NY s41S appeal caae 4 s41S 1111 a 150 N Y 569 receiver case 13 s41S 1118 a 153NY 522 app'l case 20 * ISO NY 680 8 41 a 1126 620 dem'd recess cabe 2. - 108 s39S default 8 AC. new trial caae 4 a 163 NY s38S 11 203 355n 691 1144 appeal case 4 8 39 S 8 150 NY appeal case 6 a 158 NY b39S appeal case 6 a 167 NY 8 39S 62 1 failse imprsn case 4 a 162 NY 8 39 8 discretion case 5 s39S 24 M 87 1133 73 770 27 369 348n 292 484 371 100 s 39 S 14 AC 592 breach 25 88 8 39 S 596 neg, bill, part 8 39 S 446 15 AC 176n 598 boundaries c 39 S 438 10 141 60 1 neg damages 440 s32 88 59 619 77 164 604 nuisance s 40 S 728 s 17 140 607 privileged 8 39 S 460 128 96 burden plaintifT do 149 158 622 appeal case 7 «39S 155 NY dismissal a 166 NY s3gS mandamus case 32 a 161 NY 9 39S 1129 amendment case 33 s39S 1121 f 7 609 623 pen. inj. case 4 ♦150 NY s38g new trial case 7 a 168 NY 1122 657 692 1130 651 226 1142 691 1146 725 1129 new trial case 8 a 168 NY b39S retroaction 38 CP 392n 924 fraud intent case 1 8 39 412 e 13 13 625 conclusive case 1 r 159 NY 6 39S 79 new trial case 3 a 168 NY 8 39 164 447 126 606 1124 1129 579 700 1135 717 1136 VOL- 6 acceptance 8 39S 34 67 24 M performance 60 M real estate 89 M 461 16 41 708 343 746 137 671 6 curtesy s39S 96 AD _ 160 NY f 184 NY 43 M 15 AC validity dev£se 142 367 1 2 tel. poles r 158NY 231 a 39 S 522 f 6 609 B 168 NY 234 legislat. power 107 AD 411 h9 audit 8 39S r 150 NY 9 employe 33 e33 former appointees 165 I vesting 78 M- 720 62 tliTldend alSSNY 740 s 39 S 6^ 71 601 70 neg. damages 472 92, . . 104 idubmiSBion error 111 335 1 2 I aewer damgs 8 39 8 892 e 34 M 461 127 notice rule 186 41 425 71 171 72 599 89 190 102 260 f 161 867 77 do 166 886 316 22 M 603 221n 36 M 190 191 61 request void go 148 716 82 ev. negligence 119 q 168 471 73 diversion s 39 S 744 8 13 189 18 342 eompt. ev. 26 443 damages 61 229 6 AC 172n 631 570 250 619 620 306 26 mandamus s39S 514 30 316 420 99 • 25' 114 17; 127 78 demurrer return 138 560 pleadings 156 388 28 partnership s 39 8 527 Hi 154 NY 5P3 37 M 388 33 master neg. «3g,S 9 b22 b76 78 20 M 34 LRA 4-64 93 467 619 ISO 35 11 On 42 neg. damages 8 39 S 613 51 514 11 AC 62o 63n 63n 71n evidence 73 499 50 estoppel s39S 69 22 M 740 348 401 55 cohtingent s39S 10 e30 d36 g43 d43 92 M intention 47 50 do 111 23 M 31 M 47 M distribution 40 M disinheritance 115 728 619 678 264 472 413 594 529 409 600 510: 535 44 478 78 jurisdiction 8 39 B 468 43 M 289 84 presumption 8 39 8 494 12 184 16 646 57 10 SO certification s 39 S 509 7 AC 462 93 procur'g cause 690 478 38 429 758 488 s40S 187NY notice form 139 verification f75M 1 34 officer 581 42 874 473 990 237 267 36 21 a 158 NY b39S 18 69 152 19 M commissions 117 819 99 infant neg. s 39 8 741 c 90 673 102 revocation s 39 S 636 a 162 NY 662 47 104 30 M 699 dedication st. 14 AC 267n 1 38 assessment s 39 S 1037 a 154NY 766 1 4 i r. r. law 8 40 8 334 r 167 NY 37 72 414 144 authority s 39 S 878 73 M 408 not punish do 20tNY 130 right attachmt 147 599 |48writasEistnce s 39 S 996 16 AC 23Sn 1 80 contempt s 39 8 1012 r 163 NY 634 1 66 authority s39S 30 d40 41 89 178 21 M 65 M liability 53M compet. 123 enforcible 159 ev 791 408 248 116 72 534 34 326 276 740 586 1 06 adoption s40S til f,23 32 150 165 NY 7 AC 54 630 624 379 627 143 36n parol evidence 37 M 380 presumption 131 691 lapsing legacies 78 M 197 statutory 150 624 M 3 fd. transfer s 39 8 475 26 66 82 638 1 1 7 neg damages 8 39 8 417 IS 222 269 21 153 30 168 248 82 26 1 70 discovery 8 39 S 1036 5 AC 268n must answer ' f 98 M 444 I 72 Sep. actions 8 39 8 1029 r 151 NY 186 s 3 AC 302 4 AC 21 4n 1 75 beneficiary s 39 S lOia d 37 617 97 648 14 AC 197n interpleader d 61 193 e 34 M 269 I 78 negligence s 39 8 1022 a 164 NY 753 liability d 169 114 115 185 650 1 87 foreclose v'd 40 S 1013 119 59 39 CP 154 .^BBREVITCriONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; c» criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; 0, overruled; s, same case; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q, questioned N. T. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division Vol 6. 190 certification s 39 S 1008 6&' 245 7 AC 461n stipulations 45 M 684 1 92 exemptions B 39 S 875 e 39 M 772 f 40 M 643 49 M 284 8 3 AC 192 196 death dam. 8 39 S 9S 26 394 597 204 joint use 24lcond precedt s39S 36 e75 certificate 81 do 99 105 r r franchise 99 15 AC 1150 496 626 114 327 8 i40S e38, forfeiture 72 178 NY do 221NY 40 M 20Snegdami 8 39S el2 62 impute nsg. 132 2 1 I decree s39S a 154NY f 25 35 49 61 s26 M e42M adl. evidence 80 M 24 jurisdiction 99M 198 lOlM 657 217 contract s 38 S 327 137 403 220 f d transfer s 39 S 896 5 AC 199 22 I court order 810 750 625 280 3 422 180 237 8 39S 1034 f 91 412 eosts 92 81 27 M 13C 29 CP 297 15 AC 22n 23n 32 recover costs fSOM 685 225 mandamus 8 39S 983 r 154 NY 381 IS 335 336 1004 617 109 247 341 274 remedy 138 damages do 146 lo2 constitutional 207 NY 613 355 883 854 349 accounting 666 667 341 347 s 39 s *58n J 166 NY 248 receiver s 39 S 1031 30 368 71 280 6 AC 304n 8 AC 116n superior lien 70 81 254indef deosion s39S 6 13 dig 20 28 31 54 71 86 87 90 9U 98 e32M 7 AG 8 AC mistrial dS2M equity t 37 CP costs lOoil 886 253 117 623 307 615 582 831 209 506 437 555 164 260 423 501 267 16 264 excptn error s39S 17 evidence 30 50 . 86 neg driver 65 LEA 998 186 444 603 366 728 229 amend judgt s 39 S 1001 40 252 29 CP 283 23 1 bids rejectm 8 39S 9871131 a 151 NY 640 234 new trial 8 39 S 1009 33 350 evidence d 173 262 236 intent notice B 39 S 993 18 M 275 37 M 364 public bearing 135 668 do 672 356 tax elevat rr s39B r 152 NY 365 costs 98 682 417 65 24 > 373 discovery a 39 Ij 596 41 476 55M 33 ccnd precedent 148 Ui5 practice to stay 148 625 376 relief s39S ' 163 NY 39 M SI UP 579 275 654 48 378 suppl answr 3 40 S 201 73 187 do 95 626 4 AC 214n 385 incomp ev s 39 S 553 62 459 116 62 386burdeQ proof a 39 S 641 17 AC 191n 398 assumptions 673 537 606 271 injunction s 39 S 780 village tax 104 54 2 7 7commr j urors 3 40 S 535 a 150 NY 459 35 M , 30P construction 38 M 196 legislat. power 41 LEA 628 630 local governrat. 199 NY 187 obiter dicta 199 NY 136 jurisdiction 204NY 482 constitutional bodies f 87 M 628 327change grade 520 611 61 348 »39S 12 15 authority 62 38 H justified 38 M use street 67 M 598 133 135 3 40S s6 17 99 demurrer 24 24 compensation 278 42 59 63 do 74 3 166 NY 19 M jurisdiction e 154 NY 633 503 543 614 616 74 234 635 404 eonsideratn a 39 S 664 d9 421 99 133 23 M 108 37 M 853 41 ( accounting s 39S 577 105M 125 4 1 4 hab corpus s39S 31 61 140 23 M 34 M 77 M 1 215 NY res judicata 38 M pleading 57 appeal 188NY f 175 not conclusive 77 M 530 status infant 176 144 d 220NY 538 equity court lOlM 589 690 122 99 479 268 22 527 346 669 145 445 200 restraint lOlM 589 425 objections s 39 S 543 genl denial 43 M 2 account stated 14 AC 371n 432 annulment Ji M 140 f'd representns 8 39 S 637 30 452 70 678 679 71 514 516 519 537 330 768 113 330 198n 446 d78 17 M 21 M 34 M si AC 3 AC 9 AG 10 AC 473n 474n marriage 88 M 303 court's power f 92 M 288 presume valid i04M 629 validity lOoM 372 440 secret trust s 39 a 678 a 151 NY 634 a 158 NY 694 18 260 f 29 630 445 mandamus a39S 677 a 161 NY 674 do 12 642 relinquishment 121 479 notice 01 M 361 449 perjury a 39 U 658 7 AC 199n 459 discovery 3 39 S 670 80 166 98 151 6 AC 328n 463 assignee 3 39 S 688 62 258 volunteer 91 M 199 467 laches s39S 20 28 q34 48 49 61 82 114 161 27 M 28 M 33 M 56M 698 454 139 514 132 124 244 583 3 827 161 663 588 360 27 481 abatement s 39 S 68 d 44 258 B 3 AC 308 substitution 9 AG 319n 485 construction s 39 S 648 m 154 NY 250 9 605 492 expert ev s 39 S 595 a 159 NY 188 496 exemptions B 39 S 564 e7 154 do 72 346 350 352 el53NY337 338 assessment 1 19 716 499 atty's fees s39B •155 NY 3 151 NY 20 M 34 M 4 AC 700 265 637 45 318 494 169 509 demurrer 3 39 S 707 s 150 NY 672 17 35 18 594 698 10 482 483 d39 8 168 NY 81 e 154 NY f5AC SAC a 13 US variance 114 trustees 51 M pleading 118 818 124 732, 733 jurisdiction 118 825 misjoinder 119 431 stlchldr. right 212 211 16 489 72 73 76n 34 785 344 760 768 147 vested dl47 532 bona fides B 40 S 390 113 107 535 incompt ev s39S e38 45 61 e75 170 NY 33 CP 650 143 311 213 341 421 68 585rever. error s 39 S 540 56 598 23 M 337 unliq. damages 61 LRA 556 competent ev. 107 - 88 open close 52 M 508 59 1 presumption claims evidence 113 23 recover cl'm, d 161 566 not presumed f 161 ■ 5f 540 underwriter 585 42 28 87 37 39 591 693 243 299 287 316 408 507 359 313 124 jury trial do 170 62M equity 61 M distinction 150 liability 81 M 734 678 359 584 672 98 four months "0 no remedy 169 796 469 weight of ev 3 39 S 673 a 159 NY 549 23 M 144 472m, prosecunt s 39 S 601 s 36 632 15 AC 264n 5 I 8 neg. atty s 39 S 592 3 151N Y 326 a 158 NY 691 7 AG 383n 384n 524 servce hlday 686 611 784 226 343 129 s39S 20 M 25M 7 AC contempt 118 39 P inherent power 39CP 129 527 construction 9 39 S 671 m 154 NY 142 47 72 147 758 annuity e 41 240 241 test trust 188NY 39] I valid trust 8 39S dl7 120 20 32 42 dl8 M e 19 M e20M 21 M 26 M 32 M 4 AC 26CP 55 LEA 193n 200n 206 insurance 8 M 6.30 550 construction 3 39 S 547 39 631 554 objections s 39 S 558 17 325 19 M 582 28 M 662 incumbrance 19 M 654 submission 110 697 time essence 53M 627 630 excuse tender 120 £0 not error 210 NY 166 563 discretion s39S 71S 51 348 legal error da 132 645 distinction 136 833 571 appealable i 39 8 61 594 will 3 39 a 165 NY discration dl34 598 strike out answer 9 39S 3 39S 12 AC serve atty. 76 121 contempt no offset 110 54M 39 S 768 540 900 627 164 804 1126 140 135 760 22 672 390 773 600 discovery 9 39S 19 33 57 84 34 M 46 M 52M 4 AG 6 AC 26 CP 38 CP answer 38 CP 957 320 243 575 195 318 224 194 296 331 327n 357 115 114n 326 569 428 424 640 189 342 147 758 s40S a 150 NY 6 AD discretion d39 39 74 review 86 209 211 89 167 e203 NY , 246 em. domain 126 849 commissions 129 721 583 implication 3 39S 654 50 16 d 69 358 burd. plaintiff 174 4r55 I law question a 39 S 774 *151 NY 641 6AC 262n 263 discretion UO 257 6AC 279n 280n case ! 121 931 framing issues 12 AC 421 n 605 notice s39S 973 a 159 NY 552 dSO 528 foreclosure 27 M 65 609 surety case 1 ssgs 1132 a 154 NY 784 conclusive case 2 3 39 8 1127 20 M 603 6 1 disbarment case 3 s39S 11!?6 a 151 NY 662 remedy case 4 s39S 1134 9 61 mandamus case 13 s39 8 1131 a 151 NY 640 ABUREVIATIONS: a, affirmed ; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed- n nme ..«it.c..ed: 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled: i, same case; do, dissenting opinion; P, parallel ^se?q.q"esUo,'«d Vol.7 N. Y. Supteme Coart Reports — Appellate Division VOL 7 466 i notiee 8 39S 793 r 164 NY 716 48 2.3 27 M 65 27, M 67 diamisaal 27 M 614 BlAC 407 a 199 NY 380 power o( Bale 27 M ■ 66> 454 I I allowanoe s 39 S 763 40 31 certification 7 AC 81B Epecl. guardian do 110 908 19A.0 tin discretion f 215 NY 582 eq. conversion f 215 NY 583 1 3 ineome s 40 S 494 a 154 NY 737 60 444 in lieu dower e 106 61 49 M 187 interest 16AC ISM construe will 18 irregularity 26 H publication 20 AC 223n 84 -pave between tracks s 39 S 959 130 833 89 juriidiction "IS 964 80 84 SSf'd judgment a 408 202 18 436 23 H 366 4 AC 146n 147n 1 3 contract a 40 S 99 37 488 670 I 1 8 separation • 40B •161 NY ■ 17 151 NY 141 20 income s39S s23 23 M 31 M specify e75M 46 800 467 286 296 378 27 aesaHment 8 39 S 776 a 161 NY 639 18 22 e31 318d 319 78 316 23 H 195d 196 deduction debts 161 NY 204 fair test 143 47 48 modification >39S 18 M 31 M 57 no bar s 39S 134 66 trustee 8 39S a 158 NY 25 M 27 M successor 149 9 AC 964 61 396 784 460 971 328 726 437 13 309n 91 180 e 179 NY 164 pleading 9 39S 1103 62 146 67 partners 1 64 636 56 122 40 8 24 s48 73 97 Bl6M 19 M 24 M 29 M 31 M s2AC aliirmance 66M return 80 M rescission 103 360 624 193 149 327 152 605 421 789 333 297 benefits 7 196 290 s40S a 168 NY 8 161 NY 33 67 68 173 NY 33 CP presumption 68 discharge 101 48 682 645 229 442 576 339 308 577 307 470 253 negligence 8 40 S 148 10 362 11 166 40 312 40 313 55 509 97 397 fact question 112 559 30 M 615 40 M 202 258 meas. dam. 48 172 authority s40S 30 62 61 SAC 63LRA 273 • 40S 81 do 81 do 81 155 178 93 M agency 134 114 616 618 622 623 524 512 61 544 626 partition action 40 S 3 70 M 142, 418 278 parties 940 S a 164 NY 185 Judicial 8 40 S 286 a 160 NY 444 447 1 28 contract s 40 S 81 12 395 impeach certif. pleading 66 467 36 M 633 arbitrator 145 no bar do 205 NY condusive 151 i 160 value work f 160 15 60 78 removal do 78 d22M veteran's 143 substantial 143 rehearing 143 reversal 143 490 127 89 287 515 1 32 exemp dam 198 distribution 8 40 S 294 e 37 M 276 vesting 37 M 276d 277 203 removal 8 40 8 12 31 22 M 8 40 8 a 161 NY 68 82 96 objections 23 M misconduct 72 M cond. ]48 968 171 468 183 70 costs 8 39 8 66 25 M 63 M special term 144' 797 7 1 construction B 39 S 978 28 586 3 3 AC 187 naked trusts 66 32 M 34 M 79 costs 8 39 8 171 362 208 279 620 422 84 409 247 precedent 434 139 term fee s 40 8 298 10 AC 22gn retaxatioF 14 AC 26n 142 discovery 8 40 8 271 73 524 39 M 248 1 44 jurisdiction s 40 S 102 118 26 1 45 vol. paym't B 40^ 120 975 a 153 NY 331 274 324 261 268 301 rights 20 20 21 21 60 171 641 506 21 204 abolition s40 8 80 remedy 213 NY notice 169 275 171 205 155 630 conviction f 121 336 appeal a40S a 164 NY 87 460 150 62 173 n 349 105n 152 341 207 ratification 8 151 NY a 158 NY s40S 15 71 118 120 153 223 Btay 38 40 8 29 M eg. pleading 38 CP 117 247 removal b40 8 27 M 632 209 130 7 302 391 6 794 636 40 478 167 325 280false represen s 39 8 1002 71 324 283 negligence a 39 8 770 d7 267 27 55 22 M 84 295 injunction s 40 8 212 8 AC 203n iurlsdietion 114 223 301 conversion s 40 S 51 a 13 625 308 conolufflve 8 40 8 117 49 174 97 606 311 mandamus 8 40 S 1026 46 509 49 212 93 28 M 42 312 negligence s 40 S 93 28 406 36 479 73 167 fact questijn 78 104 80 140-2 89 427, do 433 IS M 386 res ipsa loq, 116 667 274 639 227 328 339 transf tax s 40 B 1013 gift causa mortis r 163 NY 223 22 M 195 fl98 a 3 AC 184 343 co-court s39S 73 36 M 8AC 345 lunatic s39 8 16 19A0 incompetent 99 114 pleading 98 M 21 M s 151 NY 99 289 298 941 499 79 60 4S4 309 350 extra s 39 8 20 AC 352 remedy 8 40 8 do 90 costs 25 M fees 930 192n 424 vol exposure 8 39 8 912 a 158 NY 689 64 87 46 ury inference 56M 535 43 I suspension 40 8 1022 r 154 NY 683 442flBerep8ent'n s 39 8 106 46 663 57 453 445 discontinue 8 39 8 1048 6 AC 106p 459 chge venue 8 39 8 1089 15 93 39 416 66 205 124 536 465 employm't 66 482 458 8 39 8 p7 do 40 54 I8M 24 M 8 AC 359 assessment 3 40 8 f51 23 M tax title 26 M 372 review s40S 57 380 costs s40S 16 e27 185 e4 AC 6 AC 9 AC 72 M neg. 16 AC 248 sp. 8 40 S perfmce. 36 ev. 326n 330d carrier neg. 63M 670 error 53M 571 3 1 7 eq calendar s 40 8 169 7 609 e 78 390 lOAO 159n 321 requests s 40 S 222 4 AC 44n 9 AC 197n 326 larceny b40 8 a 151 NY 17 658 77 212 965 154 213 121 630 193 160 137n 419b 112 392negligence ev 8 39 8 944 407 20 164 46 530 53 484 fact question 66 362 harmless error 11 AC 27n 147 355 signals ev. 13 AC 412n 8 161 NY 60 ev. future conseq 14 AC 300n 400 weight of ev s 39 8 899 24 271 403 new trial s 39 S 1019 16AC 131n 664 60 b40S e 161 NY 87 indictment 119 laches 153 1105 478 173 75 78 675 677 20 in 206 474 gas Bupply e39S 1110 a 158 NY 678 8 AC 201n jurisdiction 114 223 penalty 149 767 482cond. precdt 8 40 S 266 69 M 200 488 insurance a 158 NY 688 s 40 8 248 9 364 494 compet ev- 8 40 8 229 41 316 93 587 50 1 contract 8 40 8 48 37 M waiver 49 M omission d 65M may ratify 75M authority 75M f 92 M estoppel t 163 186 r 84 M 85 M e 22 M 89 90 5 AC Sin 84 12 AC 182n 27 CP, . 94 «q. redemption e 46 M 287 jurisdiction f 94 M 639' 535 pool selling 243 409 75 707 108 550 order entry s 40 S 146 67 470 lien execution 6 AC 127 n 553 dist. atty 8 40 S 153 121 45 157 M 579 application 183 370 575 fraud ev. 40 S 300 a 168 NY 680 12 193 209 62 138 estoppel 15 234 18 612 conclusive 32 605 617 330 34 mistake 67LRA good faith 26 M waiver 16 86 inference 22 4|B 69 48 M 733n 32 601 121 539 381 257 521 595 negligence 233 22 434 486 504 509 8 40S a 154 NY 23 37 42 49 c90 154 LRA competent ev 607 recovery 39 S 599 a 158 NY 689 608 hab. corpus case 1 s39S a 160 NY relief 719 209 156 87 405 negligence a^9 8 46 M 1016 336 107 403 409 protest 8 40 8 195 7 AC llln 4 1 7 pers. injury s39S 916 5 1 5 negligence s 40 8 253 39 439 65 504 69 LRA 521n- 541 n care to blind 69LRA 521n caution 69LRA 64lD 523 sup. pro. s 40 8 268 52 602 21 M 540 172 770 24 190 528 472 673 188 366 681 439 case 4 418 105 41 M 53M order case 5 b39 8 f 7 upon t 78 M 1116 560 637 545 1125 608 609 appeal case 6 8 40 8 a 161 NY pleading case 7 s40 8 39 41 M 1144 619 272 618 366 c. critii EVIATIONS: a, afflrmea; a, aistingiusnea ; i, louowea; r, reversea; n., mocinea; -, aismiisBeu, u, uuio cised; I, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, dissenting ouinion: p. parallel case: q. questioned N. Y. Saprcme Coart Reports — Appeflate Division Vols. 7, 8 fee spl. gdn. 19A0 97n 612 taxpayer caee ssgs 8 163 NY appeal aase 10 1)39 8 * 162NY 1131 357 VOL.8. 8 commiuioQB s 40 S 140 61 368 176 428 1 5 privae park 1131 649 s40S o8S 27 denial s40S d24 f 166 29 M 1S3 264 1018 153 739 SIS 3 I corpn. neg- 8 40 S 401 65 328 34 duty s 40 S f 165 deft. 397 733 40 depoaitfl a40S e 12 2 OB NY 32 M 392 598 403 375 42 misjoinder 8 40 S 464 11 464 ,521 61 29 parties deft. 70 98 M 334 682 74 expert ev. g 40 S 419 37 CP 172 78 water rate s40S a 163 NY fS 20 M SAC dl65NY 466 436 613 136 204d 30 I 50 injunction B 40 S 609 a 155NY 629 62 49 demurrer 4 AC 327n 90 562 601 69 LBA 847n towns claim 61 M 31 obiter dicta 138 479 429 404 105 422 158 ISO 106 263 444 46 intent 8 408 69 gift 103 d44M 85 M construction 52 M banlc deposit 123 847 voluntary trust do 123 854 title 131 401 presumption 141 - 57 ?uisb. and wife J M 660 cotenants 155 663 917 SOvalid contract 84 vesting 8 40 8 19 M fees not pass do 149 355 90 pledge f'rds 8 40S 411 a 163 NY 579 93 estoppel s 40 8 393 d 85 333 suffer conseqn's 72 M 191 96 contract "40 8 r 158 NY 99 parol ev. s40S 12 do 27 41 21 M 37 M construction 45 396 339 403 619 304 315 486 780 128 1 60 contract » 40S 499 227 s 39M 669 660 ^ 40 8 169 NY 287 a 182 NY ovid act drrctrs. 184 NY 163 liability 63M 277 222NY 27 credibility 338 669 d 10 AC 62 64n 66n tax costs 142 80 M 2 235 312 conclusive 316 47 242 115 1 8 1 meas.damges 8 40 8 96 s3AC recovery 148 distinction £ 159 524 presumption 1:14 NY 583 indemnify 104M 611 I 86 insurance s40S a 158 460 431 408 '48 {lien 64 promise if 82 94 M 433 669 652 640 259 54 conviction a 40 8 425 e 18 M 230 8 AC 427n 430a tenant liable 117 590 repairs 1 16 AC ■ if:451n wardships lOlJI 222 59 transfer tax a 40 S 567 r 162 NY 93 64 construction 8 40 S 408 22 %61 69 discretion 3 40 a 459 35 620 extra allowance 99 403 113 411 20 AC 192n 105 fee highway s 40 8 407 12 AC 199n naked fee 182 741 1 1 8 limitation s 40 8 583 4 AC 183n 6 AC 309n 1 23 earnings s 40 S 484 41 615 31 M 177 neg, for jury 109 627 \ 27fact question 8 40 8 a 158 NY 51 86 construction 123 judgment 1140 f 20.5 NY ' 'means" 224XY unforseen 224XY accid 184 613 723 610 88 109 901 G06 192 gift vivos 40 8 d37 d39 69 e 1U3 survivor 92 131 29 M intent d44M 19 M gift deposit 118 451 voluntary trust do 123 854 presumption 141 57 Inter 340 294 102 158 lau 631 401 169 105 193 1 93 damages injury 284 1 33 information 8 40 S , 491 34 209 37 22 9 AC 238n 138 nonsuit 3 40 S 471 8 17 623 charge 46 2S7 jury question 52 605 IS M 604 assessment 24 M 43 1 43 character 8 40 S 4S6 U AC 351 s40S 18 complaint 145 restoration do 145 1 97 devise s40S 48 e27M 31 M 336 578 16 438 229 616 200 230 spec'l jury s 40 8 607 a 162 NY 275 31 140 construction 39 3 56 340 constitutional 64 689 court power f 114 380 legis. power 204NY 481 competent 152 363 commissioners 207 NY 620 compensation 170 630 288 rescission 8 40 8 956 s 33 364 293 mandamus a40S 160 NY 62 294 award 3 40 8 52 1140 279 365 949 34 314 361 520 651 593 666 650 421 s40S 66 89 27 M 29 M 98 M 839 268 229 164 412 40S 520 402 contrib. neg commissions 16AC 418n 3 1 5 defense 8 40 S 942 abatement 13 AC 163n stay 16AC 259-60n 3 1 6 discovery 8 40 8 946 36 M 414 6 AC 327n 328n IS AC 219n 318 affidavit 40 S 961 9 682 586 do 9 690 691 693 21 38 ISM 21 M d24M 5 AC 323 rei s41 S 8 41 8 37 M 385 77 662 445 686 38 tidence 365 1128 359 s40S 13 d26 39 41 49 do 64 66 72 73 81 18 M. damages 11 AC 63n 68n signals ev. 13 AC 413d weight ev. 73 621 review 11 AC 66 o[.inion evidnce 147 355 866 487 314 438 93 619 96 108 362 323 621 410 605 409 eq. relief s40S 55 s 166 NY 418 COstK s40 8 54 20 M SAC replevin 6 AC 163n 862 479 485 845 24 431 242n 164n 241 402 20 1 doing busin, 417 619 15 436 687 152 166 6 261 262 280 8 40 8 a 151 NY 25 27 29 30 75 154 NY 173 NY ( 92 M 5 AC 214n 57 LEA 90n 92n decree 89 229 27 M 164 412 2 f 9 tax sales s 40 8 457 a 151 NY 540 3 42 294 298 1.5U 10 remedy 125 341 842 223 damages 8 40 8 313 al.5fiNY 702 33 M 34 M 35 M f 92 M damages do 139 162 legisl. power 73 M 384 oeuter blocks 98 M 724 303 spec prfmce s 40 8 946 32 M 388 contribution 161 485 subrogation 1 161 433 804 bill particul s *0 S 954 26 355 105 311 122 81U disclosure 76M 19 306 pers service a 40 8 994 47 2i discontinuance 87 276 27 M 619 308 foreclosure s 40 S 948 24 M 17 6 AC 303 304n receiver rights 8 AC H5n a ISO NY 671 serve as juror 185 455 33 1 law question 8 40 8 829 40 M 14 prob cause 49 U 31& allege malice 138 574 337 Stat, limitan s 40 S 816 17 186 341 legacy 8 40 8 3gM 791 636 354 estoppel 8 40 8 817 a 158 NY IS 234 360 dijscretion B 40 S 799 18 66 32 539 waiver 26 M 448 jurisdiction 7 AC answer SAC 371 deed 8 40 8 r 158 NY 64n 210n 309 stenog costs s40 8 57 113 60 124 e33M 51 M 93; 67l 402 31 249 321 356 ya 781 458 387 accounting a 40 8 786 121 210 395 certiorari a 40 8 839 397 com. acctg. a 40 S 847 46 308 S2M 631 power ceased 99 M IfiR 422 consideratn 8 40 8 836 62 248 27 M 271 427 estoppel 3 40 S 850 f 166 692 220 NY 83 433 neg.damagps s 40 S 89n 1 25 522 S4LR 649 439 neg. damages s 40 8 899 25 624 60 472 res ipsa loquitur 86 26 due- care 136 667 obligation 158 303 SI M 313 444 contract s 40 8 871 18 M 425 21 M 14 27 M 632 46M 61 doing bumness 10 239o 102 SAC license 13 AC 13 AC 13 AC 450 Ubel 3 40S 3 24 22 M practice 115 aewtrial 37 CP 151 review 153 380n 387n 388n 759 2jg 670 202, 36 i 762 458 8 40S 22 718 . ■-d inspection 775 692 464 no s 40 8 f 167 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed ; d, distinguished ; f, folio wed ; r, reversed; m, modified; •, dismissed- n m^^;: mt,c.sed; 1, l.mited: e. explained: o, overruled; s. same case; do, dissenting opinion ; p, paralldMsesq', questioned error 827 76 Vols. 8, 9 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division 468 remoT. tretn s 40 S 577 m 153 NY 381 d34 9 clerk 152 106 475 condemnatD s 40 S 707 43 M 306 compliance f 90 M 83 479 contrib. neg s 40 S 783 35 296 483 pers. injury 8 40 S 821 a 160 NY 362 491 exception ? 40 S 761 15 AC 383n 495 laches a 40S a 158 NY. 169 state claim 119 509 review a40S 72 intent 24 M 473 41 M . 180182 full price 116 - 572 burden defend. 140 729 trover lies d 15T 534 575jury question 40 S 918 d 10 486 58 1 jurisdiction b 40 S 922 e44 79 585 interpleader s40S r 154 NY 709 450 410 556 764 323 514 bastardy 8 40 S 779 83 72 23 M 140 5l8disoharge lien 6 1 6 assignment case 6 B 40 S 1147 a 159 NY 382 6 1 7 laches case 6 s40S al51 NY stay 53M 43 422 38 GP 426 reargument s 152NY 629 914 172 562 563 892 201 819 484 s 40S 106 estoppel 161 parties lOSM 524 custom s 40 S 856 19 M 287 reargument fee 63 M s40S d29 e82 relief 85 f31M amendment do 116 118 118 do 39CP parties 99 52M lower court 116 191 NY practice 122 death liable 38 CP 8rd party court no power 85 763 486 811 812 179 10 462 483 207 38S agcp 529 estoppel s40S a 154 NY 878 737 547 appeal s40S 9 AC d 166 NY recovery 60 M 865 lOOn 270 68 550 town audit 8 40S 840 43 26 556 receiver s40S a 154 NY 34 e36M 32 CP 443 243 61 127 357 565 subscription a 40 S . 912 d 38 594 567 cond. sales 925 40 44 451 191n 216n s40S 15 d20 7 AC 10 AC vendee 47 66 food faith 6M realty 27 M personalty 35 M 274 275 37 222 32 646 76 1145 288 959 511 VOL. 9 new parties B 40 S 993 Si 137 canal deed s 125 506 4 negligence s40S 1113 a 158 NY 726 p 19 5L2 137 6?? limit liability 227 US 673 818 affidavit case 3 8 40 S 946 28 34 62 168 S3M 23 chg. venue 38 CP 620 center at case 1 al68 NY 3 40S f 77 84 178 NY 9 contract s40S a 154 NY 739 1103 572 41 111 621 services case 4 s40S a 158NY 621 appeal case 8 8 40S a 158 NY 1141 346 1145 689 114' 207 102 676 254 516 59 1 notice 8 40S 36 M conclusive 155 NY 40 LEA suspension 66M unlawful 72 M not interfere 73 M 12 bias 210 NY 380 602 cond. precdt s 40 S 1021 22 M 593 rescission 121 240 605 services s 40 S 1016 78 564 6 1 I disbarment s41S 1141 a 152 NY 590 621 taxation case 13 s40S 1147 r 152 NY 490 6 1 3 trespass case 2 40 S a 158 NY 6 1 3 mine case 3 s40S 8 81 594 637 6 1 6 ejectment case 2 s40S 1143 a 168 NY 570 actual interest 10531 483 616 judgment cases h40S 1144 a 160 NY 694 6 1 6 damages case 5 6 1 negligence 1097 172 12 contract 9 40S 1098 a 162 NY 610 79 SS" IS M 207 judgt, nonsuit 82 M 360 reimbursed f 91 M 63 20 adv. poBsn. s41S 136 17 255 32 137 138 title 91 314 14 AC 429 27 jurisdiction 41 S 140 14 11 10 AC 79n'82n 83n 29 costs s 41 S 132 11 471 3 418 * 151 NY 44 54 requests 59 negligence 64 116 633 544 622 424 364 558 56 M 140 hypoth. question 72 442 fact question 116 ■ 34 pers. in int. s41 S s 14 51 Will 34 CP . law action 105 eq. action ellO at law f61M 111 699 546 92n 578 559 588 94 668 124 36 loss negl. s41S 23 M 52M. burden plain'ff 142 ' 130 charge correct 143 553 43 parol ev. s41 S 25 48 remedy s 41S 186 704, 5 I negligence s41S 17 400 18 269 res ipsa loquitur 124 705 20 30 49 56 68 64 71 72 117 127 submission 34 M 58 veteran S41S r 152 NY 135 136 168 15 194 523 . 479 214 217 458 786 245 143 699 386 623 130 242 s41 S a 158 NY 10 s45 95 d24M agreed coostr'n 1:21 626 nuisance lib a^O f626 631 damages 198Ny 468 do 116 625 liabilities 116 628 prox. cause 116 631 notice 223NY 191 68 presumption I I 5 surrender s 41 S 73 80 334 e 335 rule damages 29 M 644 reletting assent 45 M 365 6 AC 229n no duty 180 3'52 122 value serv 3 41 S 164 a 151 NY 645 10 AC 354n 127 appliances s41 S 18 26 50 54 LPvA notice 45 657 79 collision 3 41.S 16 d23 d47 do 47 288 contrib. neg. 28 M 92 114 623 287 289 199 82jury queatiort 41S 134 206 NY 87 receiver 3 41S a 153 NY e63 32 M mtg. interest 106 superior 120 90 215 88 42 670 406 133 198 682 9 1 asBm'd risk 3 41 S 66 78 180 86 106 neg co-servant 54LRA llOn 94 easements 41 S 76 a 153 NY 309 e 11 626 98 neg. error s 41 S 86 18 207 incompetent 143 . 889 1 1 reverse er. 8 41 S 162 33 M 593 implied contract 155 380 106 3 41 S creditors f 93 M 359 6 AC partnership 112 474 27 M 114 1 63 consideratD b41S m 158 NY 18 21 32 deficiency do24 decree 96 extension eSOM 33 M 1 72 warehsman s41 S 51 224 389 514 151n 9 1 29 apphances s41S 12S 26 498 30 31(1 35 324 50 519 89 378 176 oTi neg co-servant 64 69 159 8HH 54LRA 107n llOn 139n lK5n Safe place 188NY 342 202 NY 279 11 435 157 201 pers, injury 122 1X7 not liable dn 149 393 135 champerty S 41 S 146 11 AC 283n 1 39jury question s41 S 57 certificate 7 AC 143 meas. 8 41 S 21 certificate 7 AC contract 133 170 110' 128 461n dam. 141 35 460n 664 487 l.45jury question s41S 23 26 contractor 65LRA liability 141 124 488n 781 108 easement 3 41 S a 162 NY 51 22 M 32 M 8 AC injunction 183 81 217 22 M 108 632 520 466 548 11 567 151 S41 20 33 .8 54 jury 35 38 463 466 ISO 44 313 257 196 266 353 435 364 253 110 769 113 frd. convey ABBREVIATIONS: a, aflirmed; d, c. criticised: 1, limited; e, explained; resumption 185 183 602 604 577 questibn 311 314 576 renter lake f 219 NY 14S 64M 150 I 58 basis costs s 41 S 148 32 47 '40 M 693 c3SM nutifled 66M 143 166 175 1 75 judicial 3 41 S 61 a 161 NY 664 82 45 176 275 crime 100 323 constrirction 59 M 501 8 1 fee highwy 8 41 S 87 12 AC IQOn 163 688 689 I86c'mvs CO. s 41 S 68 m 154 NY 661 47 257 364 d 34 M 574 extra work 5 AC 144 s 154 NY 663 remedy 82 M 68 1 9 1 mandamus s 41 S 154 26 299 303 expulsn ground 37 M 222 waive defect 48 M 103 justification e 147 707 194 residuary s 41 S 244 150 883 206 discretion s 41 S 376 40 558 discontinuance 95 159 s 3 AC 356 7 AC 438n false imprismnt 101 319 210 lien mtge. 3 41 S 285 a 159 NY 547 36 M 37 214 authority 3 41 S 168 18 351 16AC 352n 216 easement s 41 S 172 38 379 80 597 spec performance 112 595 48 M 145 deficiency 55M 467 distingaished ; o, overruled; s. f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, not« same case; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, quMtioncJ N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division Vol. 22 1 privilege s 41S 167 19A0 SSOo 223 elect n lav s41S a 150 NY d94 party name e 105 41 M {45M emblems 149 177 566 495 246 502 199 choice 98 362 trade i>ai 62 M distiaction 62 M 363 233 waive payni f ll S 465 e 105 330 party defendant 210 NY 465 f 166 899 remedy city 178 656 rght unaffected 178 655 236 constitutnl 9 41 S 491 37 M 237 elections 279 ev. neglig. s 41 S 519 do 214 NY 550 283 meas. dam 41 S 511 22 M 594 ease rtghtB f 47 M 134 commiss'na 586 1111 603 505 157 49 548 217 33 721 407 372 undue infl. 285 s37 S 8 41S 57 41 M 60 M 64M 97 M e 162 NY 47LRA 30 CP exectre duties e 49 M 387 trust fund 190 NY 8 41 S r 150 NY 500 638 489 297 410 248 120 399 3T1 517 247 joinder s41S s3 AC 50 M 85 M nonjoinder 136 amendment 137 misjoinder 149 170 distinct contract 156 862 liability 156 863 250 former appointees s 41 S 398 165 306 252 mandamus s 41 S 494 75 485 254condemnat'n 8 41 S 45 38 M competent 107 ,al 17AC compliance 67M scrutiny 89 M 106 297 oorpn's, 8 41S a 158 NY P9 4 AC employe 65LRA 193 607 630 237n 654n 481 212 272 76 641 449 damages 8 41S a 159 NY consent 150 452 advice s41 S 65 384 legatees 41 S 294 a 154 NY 141 39lcomform prf s 41S 299 19A0 305n 400 recovery s 41 S 497 24 413 406 condemnatD 9 41 S 293 11 626 default 52 617 32 M 658 102M 656, 657 7 AC 485n 487 1 167 458 repeal 9 41S 24 43 63 23 M legisi. intent 58M libl. constrc 124 308 presumption 841S 33 damaged 27 M acceptance 30 M 14 AC 184 14 201 71 296ii 407default 9 41 S f9 16 21 - 6 AC 7 AC 13 AC 31 I directors s41 S 8 3 AC p 14 16 27 59 21 M 190 389 409 584 33 699 711 397 323 626 8 41S a 159 NY 11. nuisance ILRANS 256 reference 316 r elease sure- ties s41S 14 18 37 53 55 57 75 guaranty 50 M waiver 65M term contract 154 410 339 insurance 8 41S 80 42 M injunction 128 recovery f 83\ M 260 costs s41S 28 67 44 M 492 52 687 581 518 117 1^7 269 acct'gcorpn 8 41 S 566 103 100 e 300 a 158 NY allegation f 108 78 75M stock holders 3 AC 369n 493 353 336 »7 328 18 505 172 522 397 474 401 340 393 discretionary 146 874 409 letter credit s 41 S 586 a 158 NY 641 419 St. frauds 8 41 S 321 a 168 NY 741 422 revers error 8 41 S 212 28 360 not binding 141 467 425 restrint trde 41 S m 164 NY 38 M waiver 134 defense 183 304 449 280 835 365 certificate s41S 78 M 369 repeal s41 S 13 f 19 21 31 36 construction 19 M 899 70S 4 AC 26 CP appeal d30 36 467 591 627 633 264 353 698 219 203 598 53 353 277 632 636 476 43n 485n 2S2n 209 218 364 256 cond. precedent 319 343 139 236 561 28 204 461 9 41 60 126 pleading 463 136 758 orders pnbln. do 131 764 action in rem. 67 M 557 148 301 f 168 35 specific proprty 67 M 560 publication 103M 419 jurisdiction 185 559 465map controls s41S 214 r 154 NY 299 56 32 473 Coupons 8 41 S 457 * 151 NY 660 al53 NY 645 bankruptcy 62 307 67 LEA 599n 48 1 jury question 89 632 20 M 564 6 AC 282n 503 press reprsn 8 41S 662 14 134 26 242 do 64 478 life tenant e 160 NY 600 trust 24 M 504 642 distribution SIM 136 vesting 79 M 31(1 next of kin t 89 M 358 52 1 negligence 8 41S 62S a 159 NY 64« 37 Sfl due care f 150 7.54 evidence 150 756 529jiu*y question s 41 S 577 d 15 435 533 damages 8 41 S 693 s 163 NY 654 interest discontin 49 M 333 compet. 187NY 197 536 pers. injury 622 222 33 324 s41S r 152 NY sl5M s2AC 41 S 38 54 40 M 428 345 500 519 254 265 veteran s rights s 41 S 520 143 20 43 I injunction s 41 S 352 21 425 433 cred. insur. 8 41 S 281 a 163 NY 677 55 598, 509 d 166 NY 426 436 repeal s41S 22 22 M 32 M 109 185 NY 15 AC 17 AC 9 41S 13 f 23 recovery 32 487 joinder 41 S 37 38 51 25 M 3AC- 32 CP 283 257 572 256 667 178 130n 411 439 transfer 8 41 S 349 a 151 NY 673 443 negligence s 41 S 633 8 27 115 20 M 52 326 616 55 621 276 117 176 546 248 305n 299 542 appliances 8 41S 617 16 279 287 64 LRA 147n 546 dissolution s 41 S 914 s 14 320 322 o 153 NY 26 CP 554 stay s41S 38 M 120 controverted f 153 558 490 earnings s41S 13 t 13 21 87 M 94 M contetnpt e4AC 73 14 624 191 364 129 42 492 intervention s 41 S 323 41 M 227 referee 34 CP 283 accounting 104 463 widow decendt. 98 912 92 M 170 500 assessments s41S 1112 37 266 50 I cuthority B 41 S 353 76 e93 96 112 121 137 d 159 19 M 20 M 21 M 24M 26 M 29 M e30M 31 M 33 M 38 M 41 M 47 M f82M 4 AC SAC 28 CP 31 CP 32 CP affidavit 58 M 77 M 80 M incompetent 217 NY 593 liability 71 277 107 897 633 858 643 367 95 445 685 71 108 639 16 722 10 244 291 369 86n 311n 414 143 40 617 trust mtge, 8 41 S 812 a 158 NY 729 621 removal power case 8 s40S f 12 49 appeal case 13 s40S d 162 NY 31? 278 437 108 41 S a 159 NY 21 3 62 18 M 19 M 23 M 3 3 AC 5 AC 491 708 28 17 325 558 e 526 lis 340 140n 596 re-execution commission s 41 S 602 51 378 remedy 124 485 602 estate vestg 207 329 920 598 754 570 open comisn s4lS 28 66 d67 e23M 23 M affidavit 54M costs trial 55M 808 60 643 547 261 618 274 26 s41S 20 36 51 24 M 39 M X54NY d 164 NY 171 NY rostponement 112 735 218 NY 582 intention 63 M 150 vested interest 72 M 252 96 M 384 contingent 573 preemption 8 41 S 692 9 39 491 77 478 89 571 73 M 174 106M 608 579 pers. knldge 607 poor person 3 41S 12 f 13 14 17 288 d33 38 44 53 60 710 444 624 91 323 17406 306 77 81 412 206 76 737 103 473 24 63 104 540 77 362 81 M vested f 182 f 182 limit f 182 412 estate 78 184 80 3 41S 13 20. 64 77 do 84 97 9 AC 821 376 335 498 213 e 214 464 162 89n 6 1 notice s41 S 69 LRA 620 191 r6M 19 1151 629 240 1160 649 622 appeal case 15 8 40S a 168 NY pers. injury case 16 s40S r 164 NY 623 appeal case 6 9 41S a 158 NY St. frauds case 12 s40S r 168 NY 624 restitutiom case 2 8 418 8 2 AC r 151 NY election law case 15 s41S r 151 NY Contempt case 17 s41S 16 1139 724 1140 223 1121 738 1150 617 116 348 55 ii 1114 359 1124 65 626 warranty case 3 9 41 S 1129 a 158 NY 700 election law case 4 s41S a 151 NY 572 369 627 appeal case 11 s41S a 154 NY 160 NY damages case 37 s41S • a 154 NY 1103 742 647 1123 675 628 foreclosure 6 1 4 bill partic. s 41 S 823 68 632 66 604 114 192 19AC 6 146 470 s41S a 153 NY appeal case 11 s41 S a 165 NY 630 appeal case 6 s41S a 158 NY 632 appeal case 2 s41 S a 154 NY appeal case 7 *159 N Y s41S s 152 NY 112S 670 1131 629 1109 728 1134 756 544 1315 163 aBBUEVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d. distinguished; t. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; c. criticised; I, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; i, same case; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel ease; q, questioned Vol. 10 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division VOL. 10 9 insurance ■ 41S 95 30 libel 8 41S 23 49 631 358 688 465 . 21 3Glis pendens ev. s 41 S 705 23 M 80 release 74M 212 lien attached 177 ■ 798 40 receiver s 41 S 740 fl4 334 335 336 ! ultra vires 138 516 special term 144 797 98 negligence s 41 S 824 11 155 48 M 656 revers. error 46 518 fact question 56 510 511 offer judgment 78 M 65 personal judet 78 M 65 100 res judicata B 41 S 1022 93 449 225 528 15 36 155 partnership elSM relief 22 M attachment 21 notice necessary 72 M 60 execution 155 527 43 stat'limitat'n 670 667 543 723 199 391 94 315 s41S r 154 NY 20 56 contract l41 S a 158 NY 74a 229 356 966 731 62 jurisdiction » 41 S 773 e 43 M 383 £AC 349n U AC 160n service notice 18AC 254e 64 pers. injury 1 04 bequest s41S m 154 NY 23 M absolute gift e26M amendment 62 M secret trust 171 77, 78 84 M 306 trust binding 84 M 308 309 distinction 167 94 1 25 fact question s41 S 819 85 273 26 M 661 1 30 undisclosed principal s41S *154 NY e22 ■ 44 88 rent »41S r 159 NY ■waiver 62 M 935 278 ?24 641 825 392 456 75 construction «41S 680 ,27 248 commission f 98 M 88 meas damagei ■ 41 S .782 13 245 21 36 d 35 446 28 M 142 4 AC 106 offer judgment f 101 345 5 AC 152 n reasonable value d 164 NY 413 contract 53 LRA 29' eq. assignmnt. 99 46f- 97 court's power e 41 S 577 26 16 77 266 94 59S 25 M 468 ■ecurity costs 33 CP 171 report 127 154 519 s41S d70 demurrer 100 44 M contract 134 34 CP parol proof S9 M incompetent 77 M C72 513 468 208 429 41 115 629 83 parol ev. s 41 S 909 3 668 53 245 1 89 foreclosure s 41 S 971 a 159 NY 648 p 54M 389 rule couiiterclm M 426 195 contrib. neg s 41 S 774 23 443 1 98 warranty 41 S 910 8 19 140 34 293 3 47 621 79 322 207 negligence B 41 S 927 17 125 carrier neg. 16AC 322n 333n d 114 860 2 1 Sresult. trust s 41 S 979 138 516 2 1 6 prom, note 3 41 S 779 a 161 NY 663 burden proof 55M 586 recovery 55M liability 174 1 37 title objn to s 41 S a 154 NY 14 25 42 74 113 19 M 20 M 8 AC (riv. answer 28 CP presumption 117 reservation 156 77B 294 122 204 82 523 310 583 476 6n 254 750 222 1 42 cumulat ev. b41S 20 I 5 1 acotg. 3 41 S a 163 NY 1013 746 148 1 56 construction s 41 S , 862 a 169 NY 643 decision review 30 CP 23 1 73 sham pleadg s 41 S 908 9 AC 168n 173n 181n 1 76 sureties dam 5 41S 891 I5.T NY 644 56 69 SAC SAC SAC 17 140 467n,'471 476n, 478n 479n, 480n 586 295 223 limitation 41 S 772 a 158 NY 727 extend payment 46 M 617 promise v'd 16AC 141 225 insurance a 41 S 675 a 159 NY 418 230 demand s 41 S 896 13 AC 103n 233 interpleader 964 614 370 630 662 479 501 17 429 180 299 275 204 394 162 404 7 200 43 208 269 162 200 92 93 287 41 S 19 21 25 39 40 46 64 72 73 77- 81 96. 165 20 M 24 AI 26 M 28 M 35 M 27 CP 29 CP 66 LRA 204NY 240 sureties s41 S 23 31 ;8 3 89 105 81 401 280 529 97^9 6 441 35 M 29 CP 556 60 962 740 138 375 447 650 610 276 51 6 133 629 664 387 727 274 sureties s41S a 158 NY IS 1 a 99 22 M 23 M 25 M 28 M 34 M e42M validity lien 113 remedy 118 foreclosure 119 law action 149 discharge lien, 149 728 parties 210 NY 409 278 insurance s 41 S 1042 r 159 NY 547 288appeal laches s 41 S 976 do 14 S 972 do 14 228 236 irregularity ICPNS 176 290 en or court s 41 S 889 172 18 294 accretions s 41 S 938 a 164 NY 61 308 pers injury s 41 S 792 s 19 137 49 507 f 20 M 437 21 M 19 58 LRA 461 neg. master d 134 798 3 I 6 cond. sale s 41 S 758 a 162 NY 634 323 statute frauds s 41 S 1024 20 214 e 216 25 292 4AC 324 328 abatement s 41 S 804 14 320 13 AC lS9n jui^sdiction £ 162 341 disability judge 157 491 351 consideratn s 418 886 105M 216 354 use streets remedy s41S 16 52 170 NY 358 surety s41B a 154 NY f 86 admr liability 120 669 160 308 40 M 621 360jury question 8 41S 1017 23 24 23 623 32 9 40 311 58 102 112 659 contrib. neglig. 657 55 89 22 M 98 364 negligence 335 transfer s41S 121 d 121 10 AC penalties 51 M aggrieved 51M 118 construction ellS 798 583 585 468u 37 673 860 861 344 ev. exceptns s 41 S 802 d23 75 a 19 M 201 4 AC 298 legatee 110 906 347 jurisdiction 41 S 882 95 25 1109 631 276 307 766 765 54 673 931 665 lis 362 s41 S a 161 NY 89 Warning 1S6NY 371 declarations 8 41 S 1006 31 CP 238n 376 collision s 41 S 1026 » 153 NY 667 negligence 180 598 382 prox. cause 41 S 56 64 d71 do 71 151 164 165 t 171 36 M 1009 101 496 441 449 450 71 119 894 485 369 18AC 440n. 443n negligence 115 lability 214 NY 54 M 70 M 671 52 603 557 386 infant s4lS ego 873 573 387 ejectment s 41 S 762 a 168 NY 470 must record 96 M 51 393 amndment 400i'efuse probt a 41 S 1129 72 M 571 402 description s 41 S 874 13 161 d 50 601 intent contract 110 679 404 demurrage 8 41 8 801 61 M 373 4 1 2 loan B 41 S 1054 a 160 NY 661 212 NY 55 construction 67 M 258 4 1 5 discharge e42S 1 18 199 good faith 80 14 171 4 1 9 considerat'n < 42'S 99 a 168 NY 725 69 346 425 conclusion 8 41 S 1087 32 439 foreign court 38 NT 122 election 169 347 430 error ev. s 42 S 262 87 119 438 revers. error s41S 1083 35 344 9 3 AC 324 ooutrib. negl. 65 LRA 663 444 ct. error 8 42 S 306 571 446 eq. relief s 42 S 295 121 844 845 prejudice 20 M 125 s 4 AC 19 6 AC 210 212 483 waiver s 41 S 1060 fact question 43 502 44 555 void policy 80 352 estoppel 81 286 491 employment s 42 S 26S 26 M 600 disbarment 7 AC 2n 7n 8n misconduct 169 647 5 1 6 reformation s 41 S 1090 29 573 24 M 509 451 review s41S 20 22 456 new trial s42S r 162 NY 9 64 fi4 obstruction 59CRR 993 3 365 4 129 525 528 62 463 negligence 29 630 614 539 429 41 S 21 24 25 48 49 51 lOPNS 769 90 632 110 376 511 665 503 225 395 redemption s 41 S 760 32 368 369 373 42 LRA 100 estate 123 900 s42S s 152 NY a 162 NY 43 M f 165 NY 54 LRA 87n 88n 112n 125n 470 legacy int. 3 42 S 303 16AC 199n allowance 94 M 443 475 verdict dam s42S 6 35 630 7 AC 481n 10 AC 113n 477 rehearing 8 41 S 1069 18 266 32 251 discretion 47 498 phys. exhibition e 68 353' 5 1 8 master ser- vant a42S 29U 76 168 offer judgment e34M 717 d35M 803 amend'nt terms 7 AC 88n 523 waiver s42S 47 a 157 NY 701 35 •167 assignment 46 583 584 94 491 e34M . 499 • 157 NY 701 527 recovery s42S . 74 54 M 466 529jury question s42S 3!i3 ell 142143 49 M 647 duty warning 50 M 565 earner neg. 52M 541 negligence d 123 633, e636 533 insurance s42S 348 s 154NY 758 22 497 27 487 30 286 f 75 609 estoppel 81 examiner 44 M 286 481 535 neg. im^erest s42S a 158 NY 11 96 f 175 9 AC 103 742 52 54 357 863 326n 333 335u 340n 16AC 49n 160 NY 633 f65 NY 351 54 1 title care 8 42S 61 Us pendens 115 no cloud 133 title good 133 60 504- 511 279 280 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished: f. {ollowed; t, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; e, criticised ; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel ca»e ; q, qnestinneil N. Y. Supreme Cavrt Reports — Appellate Division Vols. 10, 11 542 unconstitutn P 42 S 417 8 159 NY 212 44 430 24 M 166 550 sp perform, B 42 ST 43S 21 137 laches SO M . 126 555 noml. dam. 8 42 S 335 42 M 265 val.oonsid. do 128 181 consideration 159 927 98 M 153 legal effect 165 '921 presumption 180 708 n ec' 1 dam. s42S 1103 8 23 113 32 473 injunction 90 493 25 M 384 190 NY 276 d74M 500 589 eviction 8 42 S 78 SAC 42gn 430n 74 M 53 593 gift proof s 42 S 133 31 566 37 291 47 474 51 371 89 459 122 707 review award 65 111 intention t 66 decision 597 461 62i 357 449 357 97 914 341 688 138n 563 lien s42S case 3 143 a 167NY 21 M 10 AC power A 38 CP lien charges 66M 192 private storage 158 357 566 vacate judg D. 288 80 189 541 118 573 5 238 25 40 183 s42S estoppel 40 res judicata 85 92 23 M a 4 AC jurisdiction 29 CP estoppel 29 dp . distinction 176 572 dfemurrer s42S 412 8 42 s m 154 NY 634 13 24 M 604 e 33 M cotenant « ap "1 ,. 808°^lity not divested ^ rk 141 807 vesting 79 M 310 86 M 108 eventual estate 96 M 448 pre • 37 M authority 47 51 bar 51 425 426 53 567 A. D. Div. 117 299 ad'I. evidence SUM 24 by equity 171 474 603 weight of ev 8 42 S 370 11 140 14 16 18 19 21 24 29 47 55 61 64 25 M 8 AC 10 AC remedy 4 AC 170 831 585 468 472 475 107 453 18 632 601 456 486 487 634 41 158 599 299 103 230 reversal power 107 573 113 477 131 394 17A0 23 county court 71 M 334 58 1 assessment 8 42 S 6: a 159 NY 32 552 224 195 259 117 95 749 83 106 d 169 do 172 178 notice 26 M s 152 NY 172 NY assmt. valid 133 829 580 642 315 196NY tax not 805 guardn title 356 216 187 447n 20 1107 229 1114 730 626 decision case 18 s41 S r 154 NY case 19 s41 S a 158 NY negligence c^se 26 s41S d46 do 46 627 judgment cased s41S, 1133 a 159 NY 545 1110 167 168 169 6 1 dividend 3 42S- 160 NY 8 16 s34 80 remedial 85 430 438 488 680 133 46 249 214 NY 625 appeal case 2 s41S s 153 NY parties case 3 s41S sl3 dismissal case 5 /<41S lien 13 Ir 152 NY 340 1108 650 1123 382 1128; 311 20 alienation s43S c23 43 damages 145 wife may sue 80 M VOL. 11 I modification s 42 S 385 30 356 83 83 in writing 71 M 445 t commutation 03 128 « 42 S 251 15 AC 2S0n 1 quarantine s 42 S 258 3 AC 382n 1 6 neg. inspectn 8 42 S 140 a 159 NY 548 17 594 e 23 M 530 competent 174 606 a 155 NY d55 164 NY assumption 86 damages 8 42 8 e78 11 AC cross examine 637 6 288 846 5 70n 79 544 111 2 40 87 46 survivor S41S 1131 33 457 discretion 9 AC 313n laches 121 264 9 AC . 315n 50 oompt ev. s42S 915 a 162 NY 630 78 326 107 137 9 AC 324n 333 338n 11 AC 28n cause of action 137 351 74 49n 107 1 165 NY 90 M interest 16AC t 175 55 burden deft, s 42S 987 58M 85 not set aside f 82 M 507 42n 851 456 280 139 11 AC 93 election s42S 77 conclusive 33 CP pleading 68M not conclusive 69 M 118 99 suppl answer s42S. 1058 8 16 76 1 1 contempt 8 42 S 588 s 34 226 * 156 NY 676 1 05 nuisance 8 42 S 241 ' . 72 police power 91M 407 108 mandamus a 43 S 135 66 69 claim 02 22 1 I 1 instructions 3 42 S 936 22 194 20 M 52 1 1 4 mandamus 8 42 S 657 a 152 NY f 20 success suits 8 42 S 576 13 190 surface water a 153 NY 26 71 130 germane 181 invalidity 181 686 193 287 729 507 509 18 22 49 52 78 f 104 262 411 457 560 518 519. 87 89 481 588 63 jurisdiction 's 42 S 35 68 waiver s42S a 159 NY 22 f 23 620 549 386 624 7 1 use wharf s 42 S 762 a 160 NY 657 40 614 water pipes 61 LEA 42n 74 discretion s 42 S 886 28 141 59 453 filing consents 23M 712 7 AC lln 15n franchise 56M 54 not concluded 60 M 131 77 bona fides is 42 S 979 65 LRA 263 265n 1 23 coven't neg s 42 S 1040 a 160 NY 660 20 296 e 96 226 23^ liability 143 344 203 NY 114 127 pub policy 50 mortgage s 42 S 954 62 115 167 212 1 52 neg. dam. s 42 S 883 16 114 34 250 40 311 47 502 6 56 , 510 reasonable care 84 619 88 262 34 M 188 1 56 mtge service s 42 S 444 22 510 23 200 sum. remedy 6 AC lOn restoration 7S' M 315 160 covenant s 42S 650 124 510 104M 10 1 64 new trial 8 42 S 654 24 266 civil law r 153 NY 66 M 628 54 1 77 deed mtge. s42S a 162 NY duress 118 f 167 86 M 182 pi s4 2S 14 exceptions 23 expert ev. d21M prejudiced 185 893 599 207 192 24 Tox. cause 896 46 916 1 SSburden proof B 42 S 611 8 151 NY 658 a 161 NY 663 79 266 i 99 allowance f66 8 4 AC parent f 175 484 7 liable 408 1,6 Sjuryquestion 371 585 32 632 234 487 s42S 91 24 M 40 M conclusive 91 assessment , 52M 683 213 35 597 306 623 ABBREVIATIONS: •, erii^icised ; I. limited 134 neg. dam. 8 42 S 888 20 610 141 b'k entries s 42 S 1046 a 159 NY 556 90 197 9 AC 147n deposition 14 AC 237 declarations 52M 473 147 constitut'l 8 42 S 899. 8 42 8 14 penalty 20 rovers, error 24 17AC stare decisis 47 Co Court power 65 624 61 450 107 673 113 477 25 M 599 review on facts 30 CP 293 reversal power 113 477 1 7 1 heirs restric- tive 3 42 S 613 a 160 NY' 151 d 59 553 next of kin o7M 622 1 73 non suit s 42 8 606 s 13 126 31 462 direct verdict e 46 147 30 CP 66 submission 48 discretion 60 53 f 61 29 M weight of ev, 68 47S 150 321 s42S f43 8 AC alimony j7M 586 621 187n 201 203 justificaion s 42 S 681 39 M 13 206 payment s 42 S 614 do 94 236 135 396 208jury question '"" 919 263 626 4SS 5 181 474 237 s42S 21 f32 42 44 47 t69 42 M costs 42 45 for jury 81 M 215 394 2 1 2 highway s 42 S 960 non user 3 26 466 61 22 22 M 379 13 AC 242n 245a 218 NY 99 appropriation 170 NY 307 revocation 68 dedication 128 reversion f 88 M 529 455 477 623 636 75 mandamus s42S 506 47 183 220 legacies 3 43 8 419 a 153 NY 6 . , 175 transfer tax 52M 446 224 assessment 943S 468 24 M 614 230 election s42S 39 M s4AG demurrer 150 estoppel 103M 971 423 90 233 r. t. oertif . 1071 Is 42 S a, affinned;d. distinguished; f. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; •, dismissed- n n«f- ' e,expU.ned; o. overruled ; ...amecase; do. dissenting opinion ; P, parall'el c^ef q? qu^iti"^' Vol. 11 N. Y. Supreme Coiirt Reports — Appellate Division 15 AC 460n 245 warranty breach a 42 S 228 29 135 249 reovr. debts e 42 S 211 40 142 distinction 181 731 259 inaur policy 119 411 74 876 i42S a 159 NY defense 183 264 demand per eonal • 42S 23 M 24M 25 M do47M dispossession express waiver ^ d79M 505 redemption d 79 M 506 3 1 certiorari 9 42 S 502 a 152 NY 59 tax cap employe 57 LEA 90d 3 1 6 appeal 42 S 571 5 , 572 law question d 159 731 a case 91 M 431 3 1 9 paramount 217 647 736 59.S s 42S 120 no bar £ 213 NY 225 4S2 27 M proof 37 M statutory 26 M 723 40 M . 207 service notice 18AC 253n. 258n 266jury auestion .42S 152 41 8 IS AC 303n defect f 81 M 476 27 1 revers. error »42S 116 d 18 463 275 neg for jury • 42S 113 17 464 43 41 ee 396 112 279 31 lU IS? 10 AC 102 fright dam 17AC 129n 130n 17 AC 132n 280 conclusive «42S 1011 B 159 NY 546 18 571 street 33 CP 104 legislature judge 1 163 12 286 substitution arrest 055 252 327 2nd s42S 74M malice prosectn. 152 707 332 meas.dam. 450 679 14 1112 611 s42S 49 allegations 63 assumption 86 e43M contract 102 demurrer 119 do 129 f 173 174 neg .damages do 125 643 601 530 326 307 28 182 193 45 337 construction 3 42 S 148 161 NY 71 e 35 M 576 344 jurisdiction 1004 627 361 i42S 9 AC 289 admr b42S does 23 CP file answer 119 95 M 333 226d 346 292 250 143 425 29 1 meas. dam. e 42 S 6! r 159 NY 37: 54 40J e 25 M 69: 301 Gond* sale 1 42 8 dsg 106 140 167 24 M 41 M 52M 100 200 728 71 474 184 649 75 5 AC 21 conclusive 45 229 78 M 170 second verdict 53 649 acquiescence 66 339 72 . 30 weight of ev. 73 307 76 436 f 81 ■ '446 17AC 207 third verdict d 96 119 f 107 253 fact question 140 413 judcl, opinions 169 837 judgment 105M ; 853 396 pleading 42S 368 58 128 construction 77 M 221 402 ice neglig. s 42 S 518 do 29 533 403 false answer s 42 S 446 27 487 409 deft's rights a 42 S 373 16 465 waiver 65M 157 115 447 revers error e42S 319 20 160 325 discretion SAC authority lOAC maurance 285 399 411 s42S a 162 NY estoppel 153 420 public policy s42S a 161 NY 42 aggrieved 71 i 33 CP 3i surrogate power 80 8) 175 NY 312 Ending 111 85S 118 330 359 construction 42 S 921 m 154 NY 532 e 23 M 743 24M 573 clats distribution 111 663 186 NY 133 373 damages a 42 S 231 14 54 378 contract s 42 S 94 a 158 NY 634 185 NY 210 burden proof s42S 20 negligence d96 37 M liability . 143 authority 184 426 waiver s42S 31 5 AC 6 AC 7 AC 165 NY 188NY 38 CP amendment 188NY 339 296 22 227 343 857 69 M recovery ,104M 39 I lien 3 42S 10 AC 294 58 137n 394 supl. answer a42S 1123 310 185 244d 23n 354n 647 356 201 357 53n 48n 449 taxation a 42 S 317 a 156 NY 690 exeinptions 57 LEA 45 57 LEA 45n 452 negligence s 42 8 343 86 105 co-servant 96 42 54 LEA 122-3n 132n 456 acct, books s 42 8 255 80 118 9 AC 157n 160d 458 fraud 42 8 165 NY nuisance 105 242 no bar equity 134 231 joinder 138 176 177 other parties 181 ■ 424 468 new'trial 483 f'd intent 42 8 331 75 628 487 forfeiture s 42 8 314 a 155' NY 640 lapsing 51 M notice 19A0 TbM 492 extrinsic ev. s 42 S 365 36 M 85 495 indictment s 42 8 756 * 153 NY 651 62 360 502 town bridge 911 632 379 187 a 42 8 s 163 NY 72 M 93 M 104M 569 399 106 247 355 470 sp proceed'g s42S 91 set off 10 AC contempt el07 motion f 155 practice 81 M 329 271 404 527 915 417 10 AC 2B8n 224n a 158 NY 742 432 contract s 42 8 243 a 154 NY 764 435 neg. proof s42S 326 33 74 142 494 54 M 450 59 LEA 231249 facts stated 15 AC 341n pleading d 132 405 162 171 complaint suf, 136 208 Cause action 149 737 440 prejudice a 42 8 - 322 r 160 NY 269 24 405 no defense 68 M 287 58 1 undue infl. s42S 41 decree el07 bequest 17AC 588 neg. dam. s 42 S 595 287 225n 676 602 privileged 8 42 S 626 20 267 609 information s 43-S" 315 d74 94 19 M 9 AC 71 M 3 42 8 f 11 508 notice 3 42 8 33 42 compt. ev. 69 e94 declarationa 183 NY highway 97 779 464 475 323 8 146 496 5 1 1 taxation 8 42 8 800 102 394 396 Inadequate 173 942 5 1 7 relief s43S 33 M 522 amended complaint 9 42 S 497 d 36 M 731 525 contrib. neg 472 damages s 42 8 358 162 NY 594 38 . 313 56 297 conclusive 24 M 160 133 665 attk. certificate 139 792 certif, binding 145 490 plead fraud 141 95 477 consent s 42 8 256 7 AC . 410n no unity interest 131 125 serv. sumns. e4M 391 adv. interest 64M 391 lost lien e 64M 392 unity interest lOPNS 296 480 lack of fund 3 42 S 351 25 . 2 neg. eommiss'nr 52 88 15 AC 299n 54 M 449 3 42 8 18 pleading 154 670 157 76 171 135 554 302 389 do 393 s 41 S 1120 a 154 N Y 758 appeal case 24 e 44 8 1114 a 154 NY 765 appeal case 25 s 44 S 1123 a 154 NY 781 f 95 M no waiver 71 M 92 M q 92 M 541 400 680 681 233n 240n 76 111 338 373 376 RISexectra. trust 103 103 3 42 623 6 1 7 rescission s42S 109 f 165 623 appeal 3 44 8 a 151 NY a 155 NY 166 4 518 1130 667 632 808 451 613 626 condemnatn case 1 3 42 8 155 a 159 NY 334 discontinue caae 2 a 42 8 321 6 AC 106n servant care case 3 a 42 8 761 85 564 13 AC 284 certificate 66M 198 532 forfeiture s 42 S 646 a 162 NY 604 notice neg. 19A0 222n 539 pleadg proof 630 766 626 285 473 536 131 132 539 96 a 42 8 a 154 NY f 12 37 43 86 21 M 24 M merger 44 M 627 contract case 4 42 8 f 11 628 intent easel a 41 8 a 161 NY m 159 NY 40 M 12 AC false representns 157 770 55 1 presumption s 42 8 642 36 551 125 364 170 468 64M 159 557 damages s 42 S 590 565 assumed risk s 42 8 813 a 162 NY 596 39 138 632 appeal 'case 7 1125 627 981 668 169 334 359n 630 judgment case 6 s42S sl64NSr a 160 NY appeal caae 19 a 42 8 a 152 NY 1133 733 693 1131 633 63 1 appeal case 2 8 42 8 r 154 NY revers error case 3 a 42 8 24 conclusive 47 1123 692 458 632 487 ABliUEVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; ', dismissed; n, note; e, criticised; I, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case: do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q, questiont N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division Vol. 12 VOL. 12 I summons only s 42 S 178 15 447 13 AC 166 weight of ev. 24 271 25 424 629 do 55 499 84 378 parol evidence 4 AC 192 190n I I jurisdiction s 42 S 174 20 67 equitable relief do ISa 299 23 process valid 484 452 204 195 430 538 measure care 80 236 94 43 instruction 20 M sui juris lis 60 jurisdiction -42S 16 39 e39 h53 124 29 M 67 M 8 42S 19 20 39 53 jurisdiction 124 e25M 29 M 67 M TOM SAC 564 78 286 374 181 380n waive objection 18AC 431 local courts 67 M 370 no waiver 216 NT 535 28 lex loo' u42S a 153 NY 73 80 authority 83 statutory f 89 26 M interest 11 AC hmitation 80 dam. interest 16AC 50 neg. county 133 808 197NT 319 no interest 83 M 162 new cause do 214 NY 113 by comity do 168 407 restriction 224NY 107 171 688 351 344 141 253 540 72n 344 39 i insurance s42S 20 45 14AC waiver 21 M interest 143 relief 174 defect 185 539 277 282 330n 129 351 308 378 party 716 47 renewal e 42 S 225 4 AC 39d additional papers 48M 360 appeal 111 862 124 _ 94 50 fact question s 42 S 182 s 42 S 1105 52 93 knowledge 68 610 855 41 195 429 430 538 564 286 376 unconstitutional 24 M 270 25 M 78 52M 330 "town officer" 39CP 96 local courts 67 M 370 73 mterpleader e43S 19 29 M 104 f 44M 46M 204NY 84 tort 8 42S a 4 AC 358 611 355 91 317 557 287 1035 1 9 I neg damages b42S 43 liability do 178 223NY 1031 137 940 287 98 Stat, govern, s 42S 1027 103 title objn. s 42 S 529 17 265 s 24 344 adv. possession 36 627 128 689 41 11 29 CP 261 prove pos- session 137 836 construction 216 NY 372 I I Bfact question s 42 S 219 75 4 1 26 compet. ev- B 42 S 716 152 NY 212 20 M 339 unanimous ^ i 38 LRA 615 ] 32 commissns. s 42 S 674 e 41 M 158 1 39 taxation s 42 S 1065 66 8 searches 68 M 110 1 47 concurrent neg. B 42 S 661 79 257 1 60 ejection s 42 S ■ 678 13 AC 77n 1 64 conclusive s 42 S 578 a 161 NY 627 86 872n 17 damages 59 LRA limitations 62 M 57 law and fact 131 883 waiver lOPNS 2."; 1 73 new trial s 42 S 574 87 13 50 17 f 172 185 revers. error 117 188 fail to except 147 677 1 76 undue infl s42S 42 47 relief 63 scrutiny 87 certificate 9 AC error court 127 weight ev 131 834 230 424 170 517 50n 155 114 1 88 certificate S42S * 158 NY a 160 NY pl2 9 AC court duty B5M 1 99 estoppel 38 01' - a 42 al62Nl 41 68 s 159 NY Corp. liable ILUANS 827 706 39 177 49n 643 67n 781 67 117 415 529 177n corporate eutity f 159 880 2 1 2 waiver s42S f 171 80 M 2 1 8 award 43 S 59 8 82 14 AC tender 549 29 530 431 530 33 6n 328 90 M conclusive 124 243 cond. precedent 130 324 227. assignee 9 43 S 771 32 M 315 235 abatement 439 644 139 653 250n 102 s42S a 153 NY 89 el9M 7 AC rescissions d 72 M specific duty 74M 536 arrears alimony 74M 536 85 M 254 95M: 234 in contempt d ISO 843 enforcement 20' AC 292n order f 208 NY 601 242 estoppel s 42 S 764 a 164 NY 760 245 h and wife s 42 S ?34 a 152 NY 4S7 260meas. dam. s42H SAC 53LKA rx)ntract 69L11A 76 173n 76n 157 283 jury trial 42 H 34 damages 58 266 review 8 42S S3 exceptions 21 M ICP 508 308 268 511 230 321 149s 615 35Sn 500 524 S67 265 267 costs 14 AC exception rule 54M 561 presumption 139 768 145 525 62 M 63 269 recitals S42S 36 99 aifi davit 31 M 7 A.0 377n 378n -,-, . 380 additional papers f 1U8 30 48 M 360 conclusive 126 628 93 M 234 271 bequest s42S a 159 NY do 33 103 22 M 26 M si AC B 164 NY gift statute ^04NY fiduciary 220 NY construed c 220NT 278 will s42S a 164 NY 904 557 507 349 173 96 148 745 209 740 333 283 injunction damages s 42 S 33 f 12 627 14 596 294 parol ev 3 42 S 564 a 159 NY 639 300 dismissal i 42 S 92 80 145 116 232 17AC 179n ISOn 243-5n laches 92 neglect 112 SIM neg. burden 119 delay trial " CP 252 183 229 45 neglect trial 38 OP 324 good faith 137 62 delay - unreasonable 155 805 302 authority s42S 391 22 M 547 24 M 180 p 17 412 d 164 NY 332 3 12 abatement s 42 S 767 al53 NY 687 a AC 121 foreign corpn, 156 325 622 409 277 297 78 457 160 316 215 144 664 314 authority B42S 23 57 ratification 89 39 M 3 19 lien 3 42S a 153 NY 19 160 382 523 72 588 549 507 418 326 negUgence s42S s48 30 M 328 waiver a42S d50 431 624 197 559 347 8 42td dl6 d27 56 62 f 66 24 M 31 M 3:iM conclusive 147 133 atcck. certificate 139 792 certif. binding 145 490 plead fraud 141 m 396 demurrer 42 S 51 39 M 219 12 AC 163n ISo 398 custody a 42S 423 sl53 NY 984 31 125 91 325 124 568 superior right 151 421 335 per capita s 42 S 202 a 154 NY 778 8 12 629 41 M 16 construction f42M 232 3 152 NY 631 construe will 56M 84 350 guaranty 8 42 S 207 a 162 NY 477 B42S 53 99 20 M 53M f 94 M 4 AC 356 s42S 126 126 do 28 d29 43 d46 47 neg. owner 156 26 491 60 629 137 544 431440 45 294 587 534 817 71 75 173 NY 61LRA 65 LRA 148 755n 66 LRA contractor 65 LRA liability f 93 M remedy 181 123n 465n 812 366 neg. dam 8 42 y 848 62 418 372 distinction s 42 S 554 68 M 186 378 securities s 42 S 45 a 154 NY 759 154 NY 341 381 negligence 8 42 S 512 141115 410 37 459 384 pers. injury s 42 U 744 r 154 NY 466 39 1 certif. final s42S 102 108 NY 3.7 M 63 LRA 39n 40n 409 new trial 941 226 602 125 34 701 25n 7 AC 193n 206n 421 arbitration 404 627 123 153 b42S fl2 e 104 reference 118 enforcement 214 NY 496 equity suit 186 467 430 practice s 42 S 222 d 44 395 8 4 AC 32 renewal 117 252 434 good title 42 S 290 a 160 NY 156 e46 88 61 183 82 214 adv. possesn 188NY 3S4 44 1 presumption 8 42 8 122 20 M 95 affidavit 29 M 108 454 life insur. - 3 42 S 752 * 152 NY 629 460 rule evidence 3 42S 707 188NY 42i9 464 rape evid- ence ABBREVIATIONS: a e, criticised ; 1, limited ; aiSrmed; d, distinguished; f, followed e, explained ; o, overruled ; s42S 25 27 prior acts 62 LRA , 721 587 543 332n corroboration do 152 442 157 799 lOOM 438 475fr'd.traafer s 42 S 35 f 12 626 8 52 368 29 M 495 jurisdiction 60 98 99 104 ^^ 108 113 117 46 M 349 subrogation 59 M 60 cond prcdt. dl31 238 479 affidavit 58 M 318 481 interest 8 42 S 38 a 162 NY 327 22 56 157 584 16AC 41n 42n establish value 180 NY 232 487 damages 901 499 83 66 35n 38 492 title asaigne 8 42 S 802 o 16 404 preference 31 ■ 96 d 41 609 SAC 411 495 new trial 3 42 S 749 r 152 NY 136 57 420 421 63 144 arrest el9M 681 92 M , 373 tcBtimony 162 932 9 AG 195n 359n 9 AC 360 361 right counBel 92 M 371 50 1 neg.damages 9 42 S 245 charge f 12 626 21 127 508 minutes 3 42 S 694 9 4 AC 43 9 AC 200n prox cause 789 171 43 631 514 64 374 95 443n 512 8 42S dl3 14 f21 55 70 85 36 M 18AC expert evidence 84 638 construction 89 , 253 probate will 60 M 34 in time 77 M .^34 negligence diss new cause f 82 M 6.10 484 r, revorsed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n. note 8, same case; do. dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case; q, quMtione64 decision 126 atty a lien 113 607 30 =69 232 289n 97n 228n 322 i45S 42 111 35 M 84 AC 4 AC SAC 9 AC 18AC 35CP entire case 137 184 lost lien 137 185 186 substitution do I'O.'iNY 403 1 3 1 dividend 8 45 S 137 a 160 NY 677 34 46 indemnity 80 249 85 430 consideration 214 NY 341 1 37 attestation • 8 45 S 122 12 AC 43n 1 4 1 contract s45S 111 a 162 NY 486 1 46 negligence 154 aggrieved 154 no damages dl54 249 stkhldrs. 705*163 NY 594 ! 339 prom note TOo s 44 S Is 28 708 B 42 do 42 30 M 1033 254 620 621 726 255 607 b44S f 16 s34 , 42 2iJ,I 26 M creditors e21M plea defense 1 350 mech. lien d 182 380 g 44 s 1026 708 b 5 AC odd surety 479 192 NY 506 2^^ 347 accounting 520 669,44 8 894 I a 160 NY 693 708, 252 no defense s 44 S 641 76 M 19G dl30 httacnment d ICPNS 536 218 258 preference ^5?i?*° 3 44S 623,, ° 45 292 ijl 316 215 32 389 221 222 472 81 565 30 190 434 foreclosure s45S a 162 NY 438 estate s 45S 65M 454 equity s46S 25 U AC demurrer 68 M 27 305 192 138 44 364 172n not presumption 140 422 1 88 contempt s44S 713 s 4 AC 308 f 22 141 142 143 146 deposition 14 AC 240n 241ii 194 charge ct s44S 745 87 421 Stat frauds. 14 AC 70 credibility 123 581 204 impeachm' 44 S 7 AC 266 taxation s 44 S 718 m-i A- \. a 154 NY 762?*?° ' ^93 54M 331 deduct debts 270 pleading s 44 S 675 42 M 77 272 master neg. 721 98 261 112 121 s44S 50 57 95 recovery 93 jury question 19AC 434n release 91 M 232 233 1 9AC 440n restitution 145 17 evidence 145 612 207 promise s45S fact question 25 28 56 72 89 warning 1 86 NY deerep care 120 I 544 407 407 472 314 354 645 365 175 150n 44 S 30 s43 waiver 13 AC contract 60 M 178, 179 reimburse 135 430 SO M 602 f 90 M .'!41 674 501 n 1022 156 485 364 indictment 8 44 S 1003 a 155 NY 662 35 M 715 46 M 522 44 S 17 34 57 76 84 28 M 697 423 517 518 59 45 30 498 287 compt. ev- s44S d46 14 AC 29 r trusts s44S 50 M will intent 120 615 530 300n 710 385 464 628 91 296 bar s44S 50 fact question 60 M 115 304 compet. ev. 3 44 S 631 33 M 597 3 1 I f d natural'n s 44 S 695 a 162 NY 654 * 156 NY 679 35 M 852 64M 222 presumption 137 438 do 174 NY 120 176 415 burden proof 47 M 417 56M 622 bankruptcy 34 CP 312 379adjoumment S44S 1124 d 28 M 386 orderi 15 days 7 AC 12n 381 cloud title 3 45S 21 d U6M 300 95 M 327 39 1 incomp. ev. s4SS 4 45 491 exception 58 174 395 power sale 457 who may bring action 32 CP 2 458 agency S45S a 163 NY J 62 waiver s 44S 65M 466 CO court 3 44S 21 71 M judgt. final 61 s4AC relief 8 A.0 476 arrest 3 44 S 54 M 480 libel s44S r 162 NY 91 157 935 18 334 419 228 299 954 54 507 private use s 44 S 930 r 155 NY 23 16 539 5 1 5 affidavits s44S 1012 85 209 commn'r. int. e 20 M 522 interested party 55M 2 5 i 8 shareholder s 44 S 1031 49 . 591 tender certif. 5 AU 385n cond. precedent 154 437 528 injunction B 44 S 1014 a 159 NY 436 33 61S 521 presumprtion 90 265 3 155 NY 625 unconstitutional 42 348 right of way 19A0 61n center stream certificatea d75 607 usury 344S a 162 NY street r r 46 M immaterial f 91' M 612 pub. policy B44S 20 29 M 32 M 42 M a 161 NY 18AC separation cont. 14AC 243n 6 1 6 parties 65M 276 293 503 128 475 540 gift ev. s44S 37 111 90, M delivery 47 competent ev 56 669 76 601 scrutinized 58 , 587 30 M 181 182 66M 403-4 improper ev, 31 CP 264n 557 review _44S do 55 864 154 915 338 169n 485 bar s44S d22M 13 AC cross action 52M 377 378 38 CP 109 distinction 189NY 92 490 negligence 8 44 S 926 3 64 14 s45S 173 24 M personalty 38 M implied lOlM 57 544 417 564 351 408 conclusive s45S 7 62 78 26 M 512 ser incom. 956 499 357 981 602 332 973 680 667 313 30 550 24n 1057 58 s44S 36 jurisdiction d 162 25 M 41 M 173 NY 28CP consent juris- diction 68 M. 425 subrogation 81 LRA [810 631 use street case 3 s44S 170 NY surrender 20 3 45S 80 r 162 NY replevin case 1 s 144 S 287 189 168 462 199 1113 307 1141 334 388 84 K follow 84 M 774 193 property 195 901 749 281 44 396 464 496 44 S a 154 N Y 27 49 inliibition 80 contempt 114 claim vs. lunatic 19AC 81 502 water wks. s 44 ,S 876 m 161 NY 176 33 642 61 LRA 45n condemnation 71 549 567 interpreter 3 44 S 946 39 M 495 572 expert ev. 3 44 S 949 24 436 reversible error 86 109 21 M 726 579 f'd. transfer s44S 1112 34 496 58 \ recovery 3 44 S 999 a 163 NY 68' 21 M 711 587 invalidate s 44 S 979 140 569 stipulations 177 neglect 177 633 sub-cont'or s45S 1130 25 M 709 635 assessment case 22 8 44 S 1127 a 153 NY 685 substitution case 25 9 44S 1129 a 153 NY 686 59 1 fraud 8 44S r 162 NY 20 inference 23 M review 21 985 259 77 731 79 60 1 conversion 3 44 S 969 66 13 f lOOM 398 ABBREyiATIONS: a. affirmed; d, distinguished; t followed: r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed- n noie c. criticised; 1, limited; e, explained ; o. overrulea ; 6. same case; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case: q. questioned Vol. 17 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports—Appellate Division VOL. 17. I gift evidence s44S Si 16 556 29 44 37 293 47 474 53 606 607 89 402 116 650 121 582 i 160 576 30 M 183 quantum proof 176 557 13 waiver B 44 S 862 a 162 NY 657 22 555 39 319 58 605 20 M 541 d 49 M 70 1 6 warranty 8 44 S 818 21 M 90 55LRA130nl32n 1 9 provisions s 44 S .857 d 31 M 209 37 M 201 29 fraud B 44 S 883 t 17 617 82 30 collusion directrs 45 M 231 license 13 AC 375n equit actions 89 442 24 M 509 complaint 25 M 247 jurisdiction 46 M 175. stockliolder right 124 734 counterclaim 60 M 60 equity 71 M ■ 278 f 98 M 680 conspiracy 81 M C7.5 f 97 M 77 f 97 M 82 parties affected 99M 869 36 no appeal B 44 S 636 73 M 459 38 insurance s44S - 887 37 469 S5LRAig3n201n 205 58 M 530 plead insufficent 198NY 454 54 condemnat' n 8 44 S 844 8 153 NY 676 a 154 NY 550 21 633 24 632 compensation 42 533 52 31 32 33 f 169 322 S7M 86 costs 94 145 rental damage do 129 723 96 M 569 constitutional 207 NY 613 63 paving street 8 44 S 852 r 161 NY 484 17 21 37 M 201 72 b. association s 44 S 3 162 NY 606 r 164 NY 248 misrepresntatns i 163 861 174 588 SO'misdescript'n 8 44 S 814 e 43' . 287 practice 115 new trial 37 CP 356 87sin. appraise 3 44 S 832 1 4 AC 338n 94 assessment s 44 S 81 a 163 NY 3( 22 301 302 35 163 e 26 M 218 tax law 113 3 104 master neg. s 44 S 944 s33 643 39 226 I 1 2fact question 3 44 S 942 31 424 d 96 432 munio. liable 15 AC 321u I 1 5 undertk'g s 44 S 934 * 153 NY 668 127 new trial 3 45 a 155 16AC 131n I 29 conversion s 45 S 149 67 432 S4 M 22 135 negligence s 45 S 152 d 40 550 139 knowledge s 45 S 156 II AC 231n 299 453 1 46 notice 9 4SS 26 M 1 52 estoppel 8 45 S 141 a 163 NY 423 72 645 8 163 NY 426 1 58 negligence a 45 S 145 d91 410 dismissal 183 187 l62contrib. neg a 45 S 147 h55 30 jS5 38 1 65 jurisdiction 3 45 S 347 a 155 NY 270295 32 146 d 147 legis, power •'A M 266 1 77 contr, neg 8 45 S 302 32 156 183 amendment 45 S 39 2^ M 296 94 491 367 6Su 418 689 859 67n nmsance 1 87 oral ev 3 45B a 172 NY 224NY 23 M notice 59LKA nuisance ILKANB national right 182 567 1 94 employe 8 4o iS 354 a 153 NY 612 27 M 751 3 4 AC 249 204 affidavit s 45 S 487 87 M 12 207 s45S a 163 NY 17 51 of&cer 31 M sewage 34 M 3 164 NY f 164 NY pollute water ILRANS 125n injunction 91 M 81 2 1 emblements 3 45 8 364 108 117 212 subrogation s 45 S 492 119 117 2 1 8 appearance s 45 S 539 27 M 327 receiver 17AC 239n 240n 224 value ev. 3 45 S 552 d 32 176 1 172 169 10 AC 362 3971 365 581 194 171 126 460 609 610 226fitay 3 45S 7 AC 541 278n 228 adminsiohs s 45 S 725 62 572 pers, knowledge 93 277 24 M 685 31 M 16 232demand note 46 -S 583 a 162 NY 628 when payable 138 346 234 eta power 3 45 S 568 a 153 NY e 115 828 legal owner do 145 373 validity 145 635 246 pleading 3 45 S 587 38 , 376 liquid, damages 91 leave court 6 AC 201 n 202n defense 110 598 13 AC 161n spc'l. proceed'g. d 46 M 153 cross action 124 557 189NY 90 right to sue 139 420 249 prop atty. e 102 301 8 45 S 710 parties 117 841 waiver 56M 72 257 r r streets 8 46 S 687 m 163 NX. 608 267 probate s 45 S 563 f 161 NY 84 iL»3om ev. 31 CP 264 n 277 acc't stated 8 45S 14 AC liability 178 764 374n 956 282 preferences .-i 45 S 680 52 342 24 M 536 So M 466 5 AC 410n 286 contrib. neg, s45S 175 21 M 660 288 revival 3 45 S 217 67 231 9 AC 320n 290 preference 8 45 S 271 f 26 628 d 58 540 5 AC 413n 29 1 practice 8 45 S 243 f 17 635 30 1 certiorari a 4SS 260 56 53 97 506 303 diacretion s 45 S 201 a 161 NY 633 59 264 36 M 447 jurisdiction 117 585 94 M 542 306 conversion 224NY 338 3 1 2 services s 45 S 248 27 174 equity 61 230 11 AC 173n conclusive do 165 NY 602 limitation 182 NY 272 35 CP 37 claim 35CP 37 no bar 126 ^^- 426 319 ev ction 8 45 S 207 28 M 615 titl« 35 M 537 325 attachment s 45 S 214 25 191 33 294 35 422 58 , 611 merits 31 M 49 35 M 598 3 4 AC 241 6 AC 88n 184 practice 106 515 e 110 334 jurisdiction 44 421 7 AC 50n 52 57 M 343 1 92 M 605 merits 32 M 459 36 M 598 affidvit d7M 342 327 jurisdiction 8 45S 215 44 421 70 M 586 f 92 M 605 7 AC 50n 52 328 b. partic. 3 45 S 267 26 364 88 288 96 164 98 635 100 509 f 104 2l 118 91 122 610 156 382 39 CP 163 23 M 621 25 M 662 28 M 441 56M 332 lOOM 172 pleading 118 832 denial issue 153 58 329 securities s 45S 219 90 - 236 e 91 281 119 116 133 20 87 M 234 29 M 85 39 M 713 tender 57M 316 contract pldg. 209 U.S 376 pledgor pledgee do 151 , 875 illegal do 151 876 conversion do 151 879 215 NY 238 control stock 157 319 pledge wrongful f 83 M 395 f 83 M 396 336 pass title s 45 S 172 228 US 503 346* canal deed 3 45 S 294 125 506 349 negligence 3 45 S 261 d 51 399 402 75 557 376 pol. holders 8 45 S 232 a 154 NY 95 392 neg. dam s45S 178 38 61 for jury 147 526 jurisdiction 161 834 397 res ipsa loq. 3 45 S 161 30 168 49 15 29 CP 142 408 earner 3 45S r 164 NY 352 trust agmt 8 45 S 184 a 160 NY 701 372 m. lien s 45 S 272 a 154 NY 747 14 AC _2n service sumns. 64M: 390 374 pers. 45 S 25 M judt 226 276 s45S 3 158 NY e74 97 negligence 26 M 14AC176nl7 excavations 14 AC preaumpticu do 92 f! 176 NY 402 infer, neg. 9 45 S 117 liability (24 19AC 215 589 170 B95 286 324 419 premature s45S 275 19 IM 24 M 732 release 36 ■ 397 s4AC* 27S note for debt 16AC 139n suspension ISO 580 422 master neg. s45S 234 42 40(; 52 432 S4LRA 63n 71 n lln 143n 145n 215q 176ii SAC 21.5 demand 11 AC equity 103 281 do 198NY 192 equity relief 132 199 146 40 construction 71 M 409 d 71 M 410 demurrer 93 M 669 jury calendar 179 641 448 mandamus 282 704 237 107 695 182 456 483 455 damag i 46 S 118 reject bids 121 198NY liability 163 right 99 M 229 163 464 410 229 action 15 465 vol. payt. 3 45 S 291 30 464 do 30 473 open areas 42 M 536 537 470 lease s 45 S 174 a 163 NY 437 illegality. 102M 535 commissions d 102M 536 474 pro rata 45 S 508 28 • 77 78 f 55 601 ambiguity do 55 605 606 148n 152n 69 331 inspection duty 69LRA 938 483 review master's duty a45S 519 131 374lsl55NY 701 62 253 430 voidable I a 154 NY 732 500 contract a 155 NY 58M 628 12 432 injunction 8 45 S 182 438 inj neg. a45 S 239 31 247 notice 108 259 recovery neg. 64M 670 44 1 dismissal 3 45 S 166 a 163 NY 554 171 330 revera. error [66 do 66 do 70 e7S 78 law remedy 146 667 568 669 23 25 220 222 224 43 s 45 S 524 r 162 NY 322 spec, perfmce. 48 U 148 interest do 143 860 509 meas. dam, s 45 S S16 a 161 NY 638 75 30.5 f 17 634 remainder man S3M 138 515 reference 3 45 S SSj s 4 AC a9T disqualified 72 M 335 submission do 214 NY 148 517 limitation s 45 S -707 r 162 NY 513 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed ; d, diatinguislied ; {.followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note c. criticised; 1. limited: e. explained ; o, overruled ; 3. same case: do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case: n, questioned N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division Vols. 17, 18 33 M 663 93 M 226 judgment 102 17 juriBdiction 106 322 521 revocation b 45 S 554 52M 25 construe will 59 M 645 vested remaindr 152 481 after born d 207 NY distinction 207 NY 373 374 528 8upl. ans. s 45 S 704 8 4 AC 214 discretion f 213 NY 164 532 relief b45 S 114 553 201 533 prom, note B 45 S 594 m 38 450 536 notice s45S 102 r 160 NY 26 I 34 4 AQ 5 AC 305, 3i0n strict construct' n 29 267 e 55 426 427 B92 311 123 226 312 186 540 title a 45 S 703 68 319 138 564 civil contempt 138 565 i 91 M .421 542 trustee s 45 S 543 27 289 depreciation 38 421 102 543 154 NY 192 153 NY 163 NY 573 56 603 certiorari 8 45 S 836 43 26 6 1 trespass 8 45 S 376 r 164 NY 415 6 1 8 demurrer case 2 a 44 S 919 f 46 M 480 party interest d 49M 2 620 transfer tax case 18 s 44 S 1129 27 • 474 621 indictment case 3 s44S 1126 * 155 NY 662 case 4 civ. serv. s44S 1127 m 153 NY 381 case 13 decision 3 44S 1130 a 162 NY 622 case 17 report s 44 S 1134 a 153 NY 691 case 21 law question ■: 4n= 48!) 56M 347 weight of ev, 125 514 burden proof 76 M 270 case 2 s45S a 161 NY new trial case 3 a45S 7 AC n. disc. 16A0 1144 638 279 201 D ev. 131n 635 judgment caae 2 a45S a 31 a 164 NY appeal case 4 3 45S r 153 NY 1147 930 594 1146 629 637 appeal case 2 s 45 S a 162 NY appeal case 13 9 45S Pl7 555 dismiasal 8-45 S -577 a 154 NY 775 567 option perfm s 45 S 693 48 M 637 fault plaintiff 183 578 58 1 vacate order b45S 21 M 48 M judge order 80 M 579 251 606 81 582jury question 8 4SS * 161 NY 8 46 22 M 8 7 AC new trial sl46 596 632 106 85 195 776 623 report case 7 3 47S 1136 a 165 NY668 669 ca.xe 18 sewage s47S 1134 a 163 NY .581 164 NY 6U custom evK . 111 KIC liabilitv case 13 s47S 113.1 128 405 199 NT 395 1151 633 1142 417 638 appeal case 16 3 47S 1138 s 30 483 s 38 622 s 25 249 624 appeal case 1 s47S a 164 NY case 19 s45S si 63 NY a 163 NY case 2 s47S a 163 NY p 164 NY 113R 589 496 560 586 1139 610 588 damage 8 45 S 474 24 599 58 386 596 time fixed s 45 S 305 r 163 NY 561 e 100 construction 628 highway Else 1 45 S 241 a 163 NY 658 629 pers. acq. 45 S 530 4 AC 161 630 foreclosure s 45 S 590 a 162 NY 604 contract 117 764 633 receivers 8 45 S 263 10 AC 352n 359n 634 damages case 1 „. s4SS 1143 27|a 161 NY 339 'appeal VOL- 18 I negligence 8 45 S 479 a 160 NY 699 50 492 31 M 253 7 AC 382n 387n 7 AC S'Jln, 395 ordinary skill 160 157 not liable 160 157 plead defense 160 158 liability f 161 496 dereliction 161 501 8em. domain 57LRA 943n damages rule i67 fact question Is 45 8 s30 e56 67 444 424 326 328 63 73 accounting s 45 S 426 s36 64 40 M 595 parol contract 126 ' 57 partnership do 67 M 418 471 776 f 96 M 225 release s45S a 154 NY 34 83 reformation s 45S 460 a 160 NY _ 697 (34fact queetion 40 3 45S " e20 75 d78 80 d 165 NY assumption 22 463 8 45 S presume safe 32 117 903 35 negligence '56 B 63M: 594;e78 576 728!a 22 M 294 610[parties proper 558!7l M 27 562iConstruction 401 , f 81 M 411 426' 1 (85 earn.'nga 920 511 49 558 559 85 I 37faot question 31 M 12 "visitor"neg s 45S 464 a 162 NY 625 1 7 appeal s45 S 456 f 23 626 d 65 228 243 f 175 200 certiorari 199 NY 166 not barred 151 45 S 29 - transfers 105^5 .\C 10 AC 13 AC 58n 62n reargument 30 622 437 loss income 15il86NY 321 469n 21 89 certificate s 45 S - 467 f 65 109 release 30 M 385 94 rcvnrsal 5,45S 448 135 832 97 new trial 22 sewage s 45 S 404 e45S 473* 154 NY 731 22 411 '60 468 58 522]njeas. damages 61 347 78 148 111 366 12 AC 298 61 LEA 709d:191NY 394 negb'gence misconduct e 117 774 99 593 25 book^ ev. s45S 81 80 31 M 7 AC cond. „_, IGi eonatitu'l. 374 g 45 s 422 „ 491 ja 1.53 NY 673 118-1 I9llegisl. power 273 477D precedent f 87 M 27 trust s45S ■ 54 modification 5 AC alimony 99 family -IM 67 36 comnuBsions s45S 91 387 430 4 1 review s45S i 32 presumption 89 339 432 neg. q. fact e 111 334 for jury do 176 438 47 burden proof s 45 S 388 18 274 180 NY 232 54 performance 8 45 S 450 22 M 62 .383 407 487 41 603 83 21 ."i 1P3 294 92 I 1 accounting s 45 S 600 a 161 NY 651 I ( 5 validity devise s4oS 61^ 1 42 m 110 106 review s45S 47 61 22 M 30 M 35 M 10 AC 30 CP . 32 CP 121 adv. poss'n. s 45 S 730 90 470 50 M 438 title doubt 50 M 435 intention 128 690 oral agreement 134 779 128 sheriff s 45 S 720 30 194 33 553 surety CA J- .■ ,27 M 24 64 discretion oq nv rq 8 45 S 394 29 CP 68 32 539 revers. error 119 637 sp. prfmnce 193 NY 45 53 'so 132 dismissal s45 S 713 25 131 133 tech. charge 323 146 fomplaint s 40S 135 pleadings 159 758 543 1 89 will i45S *157 NY 194 award s45S 39 91 177 870 671 50 I 51 tender s45S 18 163 contract 41 repudiation 114 435 230 187 31 785 640 576 34 125 398 402 524 256 54 I 55 diligence s 45 S 433 75 351 72 78 144 151 revival 129 confirmed 129 8 JI market value cll30 353 360 H 216 NY 517 f 92 M 423 justification 138 668 710 712 719 I 58 contempt s 45 S 442 s 4 AC 270 7 AC 21 8n 67M: 99 limitation 67M 96 stct. constrctn. 67JI 97 199 good faith 945 S 940 80 171-172 205 incompetent s 45 S 889 143 889 reverse error 163 46 208 removal a 45 S 887 254 1 62 justices Appel Court 3 45S '7^,5?, 28 M 708! 173 pnw'r Governor [32 M 122 149 37 M lesalitv [power board 191 NY 118i45M 491 374 250 power legis, 6411 570 constitutional 147 .33 f 220XY 490 1 69 partition 8 45 S 768 36 388 71 M 2S7 \ 75 strict con*tn 3 45S e78 87 96 25 M 38 M lien 83 41 M 939 117 98 140 744 109 549 44 fctitious names 70 11 533 177 negligence s 45 S 954 d41 338 I 80changegra de p45S 864 41 402 jury question 132 401 supt. 435 power 147 pleasure commission 157 358 salary 172 428 do 172 434 21 I implications s 45 S 956 a 155 NY 646 50 409 construction 29 M 166 38 M 23 f 92 M 688 disinheritance 115 728 2l61awquestion 3 46 S 959 18 355 28 520 8 40 618 219 authority s 45 S 946 e32 M 138 221 neg. proof 3 45 S 941 19 589 590 95 84 182 contingent 30 248 s 45 S 937 reva error ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distingttished; t, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *. dismissed; n, note; c, sritieiKd: L limited: e. explained; o, overruled: s. same case; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case: o. guestiontd. Vols. 18, 19 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports—- Appellate Division 21 SAC 124n|si6S presumption |a 163 NY 30 82 95 negligence 115 223 defect machine s45S 108 231 ejection 8 45S 3 4 AC 153 1276 ^consent |l68 36o|340 use water 168;26 265 personalty 84:66 192 NY 730 realty 27 M s 163 NY fixtures ) 168 147M 942 121 947 317 235 ecol s4SS s 154 NY s 155 NY courts 762 433 35 243 master neg. 8 45S 26 co-servant 35 39 46 52 873 389 325 231 423 436 250 f'd. transfer 293 commissions 3 46 S 228 a 162 NY- 622 28 213 e 154 NY 731 176 429 296 insolvent s 46 S 326 a 162 NY 634 80 272 duty broker 74M 73 301 business ex 46S 190 19AC 113n adequate remdy 148 527 219 322 431 7« 401 52 309 404 3 46S 53 55 d2gM 171 NY 30 CP 59LRA voluntary 54M fraud relief 135 462 void f 89 M 710 impid authority 222NY 20 26 1 sewage 3 46 S 226 22 411 267 negligence 3 46 S 321 burden on deft. 43 LEA 343 oharge 163 NY exceptions 29 instructions do 71 presumption 34 40 71 82 145 23 M relation 36 515 553 454 218 76 151 217 535 525 661 248 432 17 302 646 362 114 405 B46S s32 47 99M 398 moas. damages 52 l86 [ 69 303 305 e 27 M 13 164 NY 2511 51 LRA 697 64 LRA 245 246 66 LRA 740 injunction 194 NY 336 64 LRA 259-60 68 LRA 179 subterra water 68LRA I'lg percolat. water 128 38 55M 448 96 M 2^6 distinction f 96 M 228 306 contempt -46S a 154 NY 34 44 M 30 CP compliance 160 jurisdiction 161 103M 350 773 32 339 175 488 527 187 3 1 dower int. 46 S f 67 right dower 318 NY SOM 86 M remedies SIM 142 S election lOOM 313 reference s 45 S 833 32 453 10 AC 294n 3 I 6 annulment 9 311 215 135 558 448 301 18 896 644 res ipsa loquitur «4 72 78 82 64M: waiver 64 31 M 73 M 177 NY 187NY 38CP fact question 165 458 168 565 581 517 474 510 35 486 138 e43 M alimony SAC order case 3 f 115 320 divorce jurisdiction s46S a 155 NY 21 s5 AC 329 tranfer s46S 74 141 257 455 d 457 372 961 624 487 341 332 364 588 61 353 accord 3 45S a 162 NY 44 47 51 87 107 election 78 M alternative SIM value services 176 429 358 receiver s46S r 164 NY 23 a 157 NY s 4 AC 300 6 AC 121n 30 CP 168 property right do 119 657 fire ins. Policy S9CP 649 levy do 39CP 830 397 jurisdiction 8 46 S 345 [ 34 627 26 M 470 residence I6AC 172n 399 injunction 8 46S 390 libel ■ e 32 M 352 40 M 422 e 423 50M 12 404 larceny 68 LRA 6Sn 407confirmatiOn 126 194 s46S 67 decree SO 410 defense s46S 26 return stock 154 on fraud 157 457 125 52 23 4S1 183 688 363 considerat'n s 46S 23 6 AC 368 consent s46S 48 M 87 93 )0u 337 certiorari 34 M 745 25 114 47 79 56 194 183 NY . 150 presumption 113 439 presume neg. I probation 143n 910 177 62 264 85 90 333 negligence s46S 18 25 84 rule negl. 115 230 389 114 517 579 37 1 power sale s 46 S 53 S3 546 31 CP 105 374 income' s46S 18 13 AC 189n 379 pleading s 46 S 411 e 80 344 38 1 fact question s 46 S 407 a 160 NY 330 23 251 res ipga loquitur 41 342 49 15 incompt. sv. 38 387 d 110 725 presume neg 53M 588 387 negligence s46S a 155 NY 23 49 171 399 628 534 129 518 s46S 25 41 84 55M rule negl. 115 399 114 615 517 219 579 393 attachment 3 46 S 397 a 165 NY 637 79 608 609 469 365 photo evidence 79 127 465 discretion 8 45 S 1106 37 264 5(65 467 bequest 3 45S 1117 3 19 626 475 summary pro. B 45 S 1088 a 163 NY 567 42 M 228 481 insurance s 46 S 392 a 162 NY 639 110 764 4'88 compliance 8 45 S 1096 39 300 Incompetent evid 112 380 compet. 37CP 62 f 90 M 381 interested 179 849 495 sureties s46S d55 159 distrib. 31 M liability 81 M 4|2 abrogation s46S ' 444 24 M 436 good faith SO 171 415 assesment 8 46 S 48 a 164 NY 619 39 177 45 412 coercion 71 230 233 construction 21 M . 677 demand interest 21 M 578 recovery 45 414 416 59 335 338 420 negligence s 45 S 1108 98 563 27 C 65 427 preference s46S r 163 NY 31 32 M SAC relief d41 injunction 127 eq. relief 194 NY 91 340 422 411 537 408 447 negUgence 46 S a 162 NY 158 655 452 request s46S 18 negligence 81 contrib . neg 22 M 79 42 M 155 369 426 137 458 new trial s45S 1112 25 474 132 460 463 50 share 118 503 501 release 4 46S 55 bond 75 partner liable 47 M 'Urety 67 M joinder do 67 M 40j 591 143 503 excensn cred 47 M 591 506 contr neg s4&S * 159 NY- s51 e53 9 169 NY 682 567 618 574 122 5 1 4 usage ev s45S 1122 e 25 M 28' 37 M 272 520 negligence 54 LRA 133u 327 preference 4.j S 1091 71 M 249 538acceptance 113 602 143 739 60 M 249 amend, return 105 appeal 16AC new trial 131 f 96 M ICPNS allegation 131 demurrer ICPNS 340 447 389 543 298 889 299 VOL. 19 nuisance s 46 8 204 a 156 NY 688 t 19 627 41 367 373 18 waiver s 46 S 163 NY 33 50 568Iegis. intent 200 NY 118 575 insurance 8 46 S 30 a 162 NY 652 584 discovery 46 S 38 76 132 41 M 64M 39CP not party ICPNS matter right f 91 M 500 590 stockholder 317 138 681 175 438 458 42 n 80 672 62 65 29 assignee s 46 S 1049 24 586 do 30 186 presumption 5 AC 368n 35 liens 8 46 S 1067 a 162 NY 626 10 AC 139n 41 assessment s 46 S 1053 388 194 147 536 729 676 730 46 S 69 eq. relief 46 M demxirrer 124 81 M joinder 124 609 assume risk 8 46 S 65 33 28 r 165 NY 565 £ 86 M 575 presumption f 82 M 87, 88 61.7 revers. ev. s 46 S 995 66 280 f 62 623 stct. constctn 108 101 140 152 138 436 complaint 186 a 163 NY 67 e26M 61 LRA 562 269 563 67d 46 civ. service a46S 143 58 C08t& s 45S il32 '■•■ 1033 614 I 970 873 60 enforcement 8 46S s24 8 26 s29 f49 63 30 CP 916 133 623 573 26 411 281 61 exemp. dam s45S 1016 e 68 627 64 assessment s45g r 164NY 19 d22M 811 122 628 480 623contrib. case 2 5 45S 136 neg. 893 342 45 S 57 72 30M 46M 216 NY 1120 536 564 57C 58e 319 35 557 611 548 subscription 8 46S r 164 NY s63 stock corpn 62 M 78 ICPNS 100 nonstock corpn, 146 26S 565countr. claim s 46 S 33 106 271 625 excepted case 3 s 45 S 712 208 NY 479 627 atty fees case 1 3 45 S 977 10 AG 358n 359n 629 appeal case 9 s46S * 155 NY 76 good title s 45 S 814 8 AC 442n 79 by-laws amendment s46S f31 fSO 23 M fl69 NY authority 137 retroactive cfEct 20 AC 51n 91 construction 8 45S s40 1150 325 1133 432 629 appeal case 20 s45S s 164 NY 630 reinstate case 4 8 46S 1146 e 32 360 a 166 NY 687 10 169 404 88 49 680 1050 349 1 20 lien 845 S ;d33M insurance 109 do 109 wife's interest 17AC 298n 311 computation 69 M 1006 698 384 530 126 verdict s45S 100 972 399 1 28 tenancy 8 45S 991 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed;, d, distinKuished; c, criticised ; 1, limited ; e. explained ; o, overruled ; s. f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, not« case ; do, dissenting opinion odinea; ', aisnpisacu, i», ""^ ; p, parallel case ; q, questioiiH N. Y. Supreme Court Reports—Appellate Division Vol. 19 al63NY 568 130 neglisence a 45 S 1051 e32 do 32 75 19 48 294 50 M safe place 89 339 432 neg. q. fact B 111 334 construction 119 24 139 insurance s 45 s gg& r 34 293 s 47 621 1 47 pers. injury 8 45S Hm a 160 NY 706 1 55 pleading s4SS 99 V 73 ■ 338 84 107 demurrer 16AC 239n 98 M 34fi defense 126 677 contract 165 ."iSR 82 M 437 complaint 165 537 I 58 sum. remedy s46S 4 39 M 664 s4A0 332 review 122 737 not review 150 a41 do 150 244 1 60 pub. policy s4SS 110? a 162 NY 45.^ do 76 431 98 613 damages d 164 NY 129 power S3 25(1 complaint d 164 159 196NY 315 16AC I87ii 192 iggn 200n 198 premature 8 46 S 979 * 156 NY 683 note for debt 16AC 139n granting relief d 75M 299 199 injunction s 45 S 80 181 166 75 M 75M power court 60 M 979 46 840 648 299 300 476 no jurisdiction 138 comity 144 271 77 1 65 flse.pretense S45S 37 29 CP 29 CP 95 M appeal order 103 583 201 equity 8 45S 26 damages 32 law remedy SAC 216d demand relief II AC 174n practice 172 50 214 transfer tax s 45 S 881 III 163 a 154 NY 746 211 US 483 484 212 US Lord V. Glynn on right success'r 27 474 on property 39 65 jurisdiction 21 M defense 31 M 160 NY non-resident 211US 478 479 personalty 211 US 483 no power tax 567 482 901 185 454 894 228 levy ?28 a 46 S 71 139 e 18 395 139 e 33 337 16|e79 607 609 '39 M 135 ^"■^.actual custody ie-7 u 'e 4 AC 303 340n 167 pub. nuisnce e4 AC 336 ?Qff? J2?6AC 121n ,.^t-V-^ ■'■'**°,incap.manualde- ''55'l"y „,J livery lo3 215 30CP 38nl68 property right 1 79 consent Ao 119 657 s45S 999 ;insur. policy a 162 NY 362 39 0? . 331 debt right 183 meas. dam. 8 46 S 1085 22 551 ■ 70 M 470 effect loss pleasure 'r 46 S do 76 M 472:26 M ;6AC 186 salary SAC 8 45 S 1018;3S CP do 39CP 330 236 amendment 117 204 306n 106n 346 r 163 NY 18 preference 41 M 126 192 s 45 S 984 34 CP 16 legacy interest date of issue 103 503 97 534 130 462 new notice 60 M 287 127 448 91 M 369 superceding 127 809 strike out 99M 362 238 fact question s 46 S 129 f 23 251 do 96 630 243 jury trial 8 46 S 28 34 damages 47 56 do 167 s 162 NY 185 537 169 171 308 59 184 397 650 247 levy 3 46 S 102 s 4 AC 340 6 AC 128 D 256 neg.damagcB s 46 S 184 B 38 . 150-152 master's duty 134 195 not negligence 154 822 262 instructions s 46 S 180 a 162 NY 643 266 will 8 46 S 189 s 156 NY 698 * 160 NY 695 question fact 109 807 268 contract s 46 S 97 a T65 NY 662 apl. from order 123 8 272 construction 8 46 S 148 a 157 NY 716 316 b46S 37 M 8 4 AC discovery 6 AC injunction 112 SIM 285 liability 8 46 S 146 contrib. •iO AC for jury SIM 76 646 neglig. 243n 323 292 certif property 8 45 S 1073 24 62 25 226 46 392 69 220 94 448 117 876 31 M 728 s 4 AC 384 7 AC 23n 9AC 462n 454n 10 AC 1 e 162 NY 548 assignmt. certif. 27 629 quality property 154 ■ 852 295 demand 8 46 S 106 73 264 77 16 88 600 7 AC 253n 255n 12 AC 185 20 AC 300n contempt 127 726 185 538 cond. precedent 20 AC 300n punishment 20 AC 297n proof default 297 damages 8 46 8 128 a 162 NY 620 306 revival S46 S lis s 4 AC 37n 6 AC 1676 substitution 9 AC 313n 309 covenants 8 46 S 27 charge f 54 637 jury question 139 686 3 1 4 covenant s46S 2 166 NY 344 21 177 44 179 3 4 AC 398 toll 110 763 328 326n 746 645 324 negligence s46S 1 29 343 167 NY 156 liability 126 430 329 levy 8 46 S 484 69 . 671 assignee 164 400 334 all evidence 8 46 S 262 5 AC 289 7 AC 463 338 accoimting 8 46 S 587 *155 NY 667 46 6S6 341 affidavits s 46 S 493 f 176 544 344 pers. propty 8 46 S 492 ?L 315 102 465 chose in action 66 433 Sling 50 625 26M 675 347 commissions 8 46 S 497 a 154 NY 769 affidavits 68 M 53 352 trans of tax s 46 S 506 82 109 29 M 407 e 29 M 651 appraisal 31 M 657 36 M 434 9 AC 119n 9 AC 123n incompetent cv. 31 CP 264n deduction 31 350 56 257 interviews 31 353 taxation do 116 186 m 156 NY 423 expenses 79 M 376 366 carrier 8 46S a 166 NY 91 voucher 91 689 117 443 444 368 defense _ 46 S 285 a 164 NY 658 do 29 334 adulterous 30 462 34 461 8 22 M 307 legal status 5 AC 104n 57 LRA 166n divorce construe tive service 59LRA 170 171 pe.ra service 125 915 divorce invalid 157 631 370 discovery 46 S 302 5 AC 268n 375 restrictios 46 S 495 26 M 7 376 revers error 8 46 8 685 23 M 461 3 8 I contempt 468 439 r 164 NY 116 3 4 AC 265 385 partition 46 8 4S6 154 NY 748 46 498 86 M 666 390 defense s 46 8 555 accom note 31 M ■ 467 8 AC 223n 392 tax payer 8 46 8 471 a 156 NY 16 legis. power f 19 630 use streets f24 374 625 333 26 143 407 cotenants 8 46 8 590 a 160 NY 471 accounting 74 M 215 occupatioii 185 248 4 1 1 transfer tax 8 46 S 264 a 154 NY 109 4 1 6 lienor int. s 46 S 467 21 629-630 f34M 320 82 AC • 124 prior right 151 609 preference f 85 M 596 423 malice 8 46 8 481 68 143 57 LBA 476 privileged 18A0 43n burden plaintiSE do 149 158 43 1 certiorari s46S 617 f 68 199 e 123 , 594 tax payer suit 76 409 mandamus 67 33 CP 209 434 amendment 8 46 8 713 58 494 d 58 495 construction 3 M .376 iiuspn. limitn. 16AC 303-4n limitation fC3M 543 438 intent s 46 8 593 51 348 442 compet. ev. 3 46 S 761 189NY 351 446 for jury 46S 302 28 CP 9 45 1 construction 3 46 8 504 74 874 allegation proof 8 AC 377n review on facts 30 CP 293 31 CP 264n tax payer suit 33 CP 209 title office 33 CP 209 wave, objns. 18AC 430n 454 reinstate 8 46 8 672 e27 399 vacated' 43 M 141 494 no waiver 3 468 569 135 302 144 304 f 66M 23 express waiver d 79 M 504 waive pub. sale 79 M 477 redemption 79 471 505 review s46S 55 57 457 ballots s46S a 154 NY 31 e31 d48M 55 M 156 NY 701 750 374 445 451 10 47 52 466 ordinance s 46 S 696 19 632 32 601 li cense 59 7 9 173 NY 211 police power 60 LBA 789 regulation 82 M 260 penalties 166 551 47 1 neg damages 8 46 8 267 3 30 167 171 478 jurisdiction 8 46 S 557 9 AC 108 disputed claim 9 AC . 263n errors evidence 74M election 103M 227 108 605 84 168 31CP revival 55 M tender 57M liability 23Sn 193 316 509 burdenproof 3 46 8 576 25 520 E 37 625 142 139, 141 negligence 30 35 38 M 586 5 1 9 conversion 46 8 277 38 87 48 417 108 73 113 4.52 lo 119 261 f 93 M 533 demand 23 M 463 replevin 84 M 194 530 assault 3 46 8 521 67M 81 60 114 70 402 71 202 209 178 NY 361 34 M 614 10 AC 469n 471 472 66 LRA 624 consq. damage 64M; 76 538 demurrer 3 46 S 574 1 6 AC 245n 54 1 payment ev 3 46 8 • 610 a 160 NY 702 545 priority 3 46 8 602 d22 211212 estoppel 129 406 liability t 164 313 552 assignment s 46 8 288 95 367 35 M 372 fund protanto 72 M 495 no authority t 163 777 558 sales 3 46 8 850 a 166 NY 632 561 revers. ev. 3 468 523 '24 264 lOOM 113 567 civ. service 3 46 S 664 mandamus d62 34 63 247 e 79 151 80 • 172 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d. distinguished; f. followed; r, reversed; m, jnodified; *, dismissed; n, aote; c. criticised ; 1. limited ; e, explained ; o, overruled ; s, same case ; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, questioned Vols. 19, 20 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division 24 M 26 M 33 M certiorari 89 334 3 65 532 29 CP 656 ^^ 620 city duty 3 46 S 355 , 128 701 574 taxation s 46 S 670 a 154 NY 101 625 trade marks capital stock f29 590 90 e90 67LRA case 3 600 «^C 89" 626 appeal 577 assumption „ ac; q s46 8 600 ^ *° " « 35 962 a 163 NY 581 offer judt B 46 S 298 22 M 660 30 M 86 586 estoppel s 46 S 621 114 6l8 ■waiver 119 592 588 negligence s 46 S 357 presumption e 25 102 30 168 60 473 presume neg. 53M 588 res ipsa loquit. 149 4L'7 590 tax Gorpu 3 46S a 154 NY 19 148 57 LEA exemption 19 pers. estate e52 capital stock 92 521 174NY 596 taxation s46S a 154 NY good will f25M 386 763 599 42d 601 371 a04NY 162 161 196 887 165 68n 1133 16S 627 appeal case 1 s45S s88 appeal case 10 s46S 21 appeal case 26 46 S a 163 NY note case 32 9 46S a 164 NY equity claiip case 33 s46S 42 1136 333 1091 633 1094 561 1102 268 632 appeal case 3 r 165 NY appeal case 13 s46S a 155 NY appeal case 14 46 S r 158 NY s46S a 165 .MY appeal case 6 46 S a 164NY judgment case 6 46 S a 164 NY appe ai case 9 46 S 162 NY appeal case 10 3 46S 1094 341 599 taxation s 46 S 388 a 166 NY 417 patents 6 AC 21 6n 57 LRA 57n 628 appeal case 2 s46S 3 164 NY .. 166 NY damages case 6 _46S r 164 NY appeal case 10 3 46S r 156 NY appeal 436 case 16 3 46 S a 103 NY 299 taxation 437 case 22 3 45S 543 a 154 NY costs d 102M 602 damages 5 46 S 190 NY benefits 6411 limited 156 605 trustee a46S 39 M 42 M 44 M assignable 59 311 359 270 892 629 decree case 27 s46S a 154 NY appeal case 33 3 45S a 160 NY appeal case 36 s46S a 158 NY 306 771 142 617 520 607 contract e 46 S 282 a 162 NY 627 609 interpleader s 46 S 295 s 2S 142 40 600 57 377 72 ISO 81 204 96 304 137 286 1097 669 614 1098 127 1098 302 1101 567 1145 128 355 1097 423 1145 302 1098 712 630 transfer tax case 19 s46S r 154 NY review case 20 s46S 53 31 CP 354 242 457 230 149 63 1 judgment case 1 s46S a 163 NY bond case 10 s46S a 163 NY 32 M 1134 663 1146 653 367 27 1099 1 1098 385 1091 623 1092 158 1092 581 1094 6S1 1095 VOL. 20, I irregularity s46S 27 M certiorari 22 e 110 ministerial 121 626 581 365 373 170 3 allegation s 46 S 643 118 430 8 allegations 8 46S 61 28 1tt affidavits 30 M 60 equity s46S 24 surplus d 6611 not conclusive disap. 69 M 118 70 co-tenant 327 22 conclusive s 46 S 627 35 359 v.-aiver 197NY 114 27 mandamus s 46 S 045 57 M 68 34 location 46 S 647 8 AC 171n 39 val. coosid. s 46 S 545 22 632 waiver 10 AC 144n contract, recover d48 M 636 not enforced lOSM 37 40 fact question s46S a 162 NY t26 filing 46 good faith 69 3 160 NY s46S a 161 NY 200 NY 30 do 33 41 47 645 620 496 87 421 160 169 170 312 468 29 32 35 3C 272 53 56 60 67 97 125 contrib, do 78 d86 87 13 AC 166 NY presumption 125 . neg. 281 461 290 412 320 213 428 286 286 666 898 446 66M 605 construction 1.56 73 M 732 512 741 277 594 75 321 171 734 310 310 419 168 661 s46S 56 co-servant 57 81 M 6411 assumed risk 97 71 73 latter master 139 851 1 77 use water 9 46 S 922 a 161 NY 627 80 trustees s 46 S 719 32 37, 40 56 LBA ■ 193n 200n 205 4 AC 369n 42 ' 691 stipulations 21 M 287 4 AC 359 cond, precedent insurance 5.S M 630 83 body execu 5 46 S 1047 3 4 AC 313 13 AC 318n proof necessary d 71 M 314 1 00 remainder s 46 S 765 a 164 NY 496 29 199 1 1 4 misjoinder s 4B a 6£ 14 AC 51n 1 I Spun damages 3 46 S 69 1 25 447 22 M 671 crdss examine 15 AC 3Sn 47n 1 2 1 state claim 39 59 LRA 46 M pleading 07 852n 483 366 presumption ev. 123 244 43 M 424 easement 113 780 riglits riparian owners 140 restriction 173 44 trust s46S intent 40 121 123 24 M 597 negligence do 156 400 48 ballots 9 46S 31 mandamus 225NY 7 5 1 sheriff fee s 46 S 642 a 164 NY 608 53 compliance s46ii evidence 45 75 84 39 M 41 M 752 280 324 633 688 '278 1 24 negligence s46S 64 el44 do 144 ddOM 874 479 481 877 883 882 394 fact question 34 M 191 139 arson s46b r 156 NY 1020 253 622 230 s46S 21 authority 23 43 52 judicial notice 85 615 61 LRA 739 majority 66 507 341 161 pers. injury fl 46 S 847 a 162 NY 633 1 66 allegation s 46 S 989 8 AC 373n 377n 1 68 trust s46S 41 169 74 590 181 NY 55 33 M 200 due process 87 148 171 negligence 954 627 56 245 alienation s 46 S SOS 43 111 25 1 negligence s 46 S 800 32 564 255 constitution 8 46 a 841 a 155 NY 9 e 42 498 499 form action 155 742 f 164 148 264 malice 8 46 S 792 48 293 privileged 150 866 271 extra allow s 468 1070 133 299 275 filing proof s 46 S 934 45 282 103 116 releif 174 378 292 indp. cont. 161 con- 802' 298 501 62-63 188 indep tract 46 S r 163 NY 48 61 incompt. ev. 63 420 liability 5 AC 172n prospective dam, 53 LRA 41n damages 123 155 nominal damage ?6 M 290 1 94 cond. deliv- ery s 46 S 796 45 240 parol evidence 93 484 defense 138 193 200 amendment 46 S 790 20 534 45 290 203 serv.Satdy s 46 S 961 128 222 2 1 2 practice 46 S 1044 33 42 a 4 AC 322 236 foreclosure B 46 S 983 a 163 NY 569 35 237 24 1 scrutinized 1040 119 3 47S 22 49 54 do 57 60 73 65 LRA 969 438 620 46 S 91 estoppel 107 exemption' 38 CP pension fund 38 CP 186 waive except 60M 627 ownership 178 736 156 185 7 464 15 71 86 561 259 481n 224 176 652n 845ii 66 LRA122nl27D negUgence 236 user 106 degree care 50 M liability 117 595 599 62 M 272 195NY 428 224NY 439 19AC 403, 407 301 costs 15 AC 1081 24ii 304 decision s46S 39 40 52 54 29 CP authority 71 remittitur 47 75 e75 77 86 87 judgment entry 90 555 decision form 7 AC 499n 501n reverse error 8 AC 257 no cost 134 870 remit case e 202 NY 311 308 penalties 992 247 652 79 210 133 217 209 316 344 624 500 505 437 s46S a 166 NY ' 24 34 indictment ,20 AC 970 237 445 549 57n 329 default , , 8 46S 814_ ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed -^ d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismisBBd; n, not* <<, •riticiaed ; 1, limited; e, explained; o, over, jled; 8, same case; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; qp questioned N. 7. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division. Vols, 20,21 6 AC 39ii 41ii 330 discorery « 46 S 818 6 AC 2r0ii 332 repleyin s 46 S 765 *159 NY 530 waiver 102 588 126 719 129 493 legal evidence |62 LEA 377 71 M 004 [verified lien notes paymentsil4 AC 325n 75M 355|notice lien corroboration 60 M _- 484 155 493 L-„ 3 60 391 [452 diacretion 333 discovery 8 46 S 38 6 AC privilege 19A0 39CP 837 138 327n 364n 41ii 334 poor person 8 46 S 807 9 AC ggn 336 court pwr 8 46 S 949 86 293 extra fees 20 AC 192r 339 new trial 8 46 S 763 21 429 76 242 31 M 509 jury question 568 34 1 award s46S 40 727 284 346 8p._,perforni- ance 8 46S 8 4 AC auction void e4SM disclosure 141 94S 112 125 352 presumption 1035 593 401 588 309 271 Sin s46S a 166 NY 29 24 M 27 OP bequest 66 note 67LRA prove statute foreiga state 148 408 limitations 168 523 356 assessment , 8 46 S S55 a 156 NY 688 363 compet. ev. B 46 S 766 a 154 NY 770 26 446 117 617 620 do 130 598 other crimes 111 498 18AC 208n 209n 216 168NY 341 accomplice 155 495 156 625 f 161 228 62 LRA 200 200n 209 306 57M 168NY 203 NY 213 NY f 216 NY do 232NY 223NY similar acts 205NY 283 rule evidence not accomplice |9 46 S 782 f 160 393 394. a 168 NY 125 „„„ ;27 M 689 380 police s 155 NY 656 46 S 723 laches s 43 138 49 160 154 382 jurisdiction a 46S 787 30 CP 179 384 incompet.ev a 46 S 784 a 163 NY 687 26 59 compt. evidence 43 452 455 statute s46S 43 M compliance 160 488 not chargeable 810 289 163 94 459 damages s47S r 161 NY 388 default !20 s 46 S 819 recovery 6 AC 35nl54 ,„„ |30 M 390 atty lien s 155 NY 9 46 S 822 4 AC 2!5«|466 money had order !s 47 S 89 525 333 658 46 1VI 152 395 ahmony s 46 S 820 sS AC 1 6 AC 188 compt, evidence 13 AC 31U 397 negligence 3 46S 812 64 LEA 86 n 400 accounting 9 46S 815 a 155 NY 660 404 description 8 46 8 a 155 NY t65 street cente 83 95 35 M d36M limitation 39 M 12 AC 832 638 392 626 610 476 468 598 190o 4 1 2 trusts a 46 S 689 s 46 S 902 a 154 NY 774 20 416 appt. trustee 109 587 418 debt, defined s 46 S 57M s 155 NY a 161 NY 47a eq. s 47S 65M 668 82 action 54 501 473 negligence 777 636 638 216 603 794 38 46 S 3 48 do 137 liability 54 M evidence do 135 estoppel 151 res ipsa loq 159 691 480 modification i 47 S 33 78 606 laches 43 M 408 483 prop, right 8 47 S 38 162 N'S 646 25 225 94 448 chose in action 32 274 equity claim 42 341 53 333 31 M 728 certificate 33 III revocation 7 AC 114 840 waive lien 20 AC H9n 5 i 4 taxation cor, 8 47 S 122 £ 20 522 64 LRA 40n 46n 55n 6 AC 216u new quality f 218 NT 205 218 NY 2U7 52 1 taxatn.corp s47S r 155 NY 67 LRA 64 LRA 123 408 45n 63n 523 substitution s 47 S 158 9 AC 320n successor 172 673 527 adv. poEhn a 47 S 229 186 NY ejectment 19AC 317 532 confess j adt s47S a 154 NY 45 8 4 AC indefinite 93 M 113 749 290 395 675 539 res judicata s47S *155 NY g34 9 48 301 102 603 546 undertaking s47S f 21 37 M damages SAC arrest 16AC 969 625 385 25 In lln do 153 liability 153 164 . f 215 NY 823 461 «g assignment 246 23n 529 717 338 23 35 624 588 62 307 440 receiver s 46 S 1055 8 4 AC 379 444 character s46S 79 46 476 114 425 913 363 449 fixtures s46S a 164 NY 153 24 M 26 M 27 M lien on fixtures I 721 589 21 473 132 646 489 no fee s 47 S 152 county charge 207 NY ,33 217 NY 493 494 constl, law s 47 S 56 a 157 NY ] unconstitutl,. 136 420 507 eqmty relief 9 47 S 49 34 M 5 paymt notice 114 454 advance payments 548 resignation s 47 S 302 33 CP 300 70 M 605 70 M 62.1 acceptance e27 40 417 79 138 80 581 582 174 NY 252 33 CP 300 350 stockholders 86 M 262 560 construction eq. action 124 574 authority 622 appeal 244 lease 1 s46S 8 47 8 52 121 do 160 144M implication 151 liability 151 284 574 712 634 210 521 521 577 public policy 3 47S 79 87 50 M 18AC 581 co'iti' 8 47 8 45 M 289 293 436 297 24n 267 74 receiver 412 38 39 335 583 8 47 8 66 party 78 restoration 117 65: 145 1' 69 M 4 acquiescence defens' 176 317 336 499 598 503 59 1 waiver 8 47 8 84 negligence 84 68 LRA permanent inj. 14 AC 304n imputed neglie 68LRA 350 596 domain 8 47 8 344 a 165 NY 604 60 1 contrib. neg. a 162 NY ceitincate case 4 8488 *161NY- assumption 90 M 624 appeal case 2 46 8 8 165 NY a 163 NY appeal case 11 8 46 8 r 160 NY 1095 655 649 662 380 1090 694 214 VOL. 21 I return defense 8 47 S 454 27 M 24 (3 possession s 47 S 280 91 M 447 I 6 holding over 1096 462 626 damages case 1 s47 8 a 163 NY appeal case 4 8 46S *154 NY 1096 776 635 new trial case 3 s 47 8 16AC 134 S 10 cause case 2 s47S 76 M 226 127D 1039 119 434 374 503 610 329 481 527n 605 149 159 133 8 47 8 83 15 .AC objection 35 M enforceable 184 566 "custody" 273 533 228n 347 8 47 8 a 166 NY 6 AC 8 154 NY 310 125 128n 738 569 atty. neg. 3 47 8 286 a 162 NY 644 37 M 95 7 AC 391n 396n 57 1 award s47S a 162 NY 59 82 94 14 AC 481 627 9 47S 27 66 75 113 LRA 22 M e 171 NY do 171 NY do 58 LRA charge 594 scope employt. 95 115 negligence 69LRA 527n 197NT 454 prox. cause 1 8 AC 445 805 negligence 9 47 8 389 3 156 NY 680 8 160 NY a 162 NY 640 jury question 119 447 119 448 presumption 119 447 8 1 6 conclusion s 47 S 340 68 195 measure damages 49 M 97 135 557 sale securities 135 559 630 .'notice margin 239 16AC 178n 106 liability 336n)do 139 61 636 appeal case 5 s47S a 160 NY case 6 s47S a 162 NY paid in court case 1 3 47 8 57M 637 appeal case 3 9 47 8 r 162 NY appeal case 9 5 47 8 a 163 NY appeal case I 3 47 8 a 165 NY case 5 = 47 8 32 M \147 694 1150 638 1145 272 1136 119 1146 650 282 150 527 313 487 350 1133 619 s47S 23 38 61 M review 47 election 29 M surrender 5 AC 137 142n new relief 8 AC 299n weight of ev. 30 CP 294 new trial 135 700 limited 135 701 county court 71 M 334 91 M 530 1 8 presumption s 47 8 315 a 162 NY 656 74 580 10 AC 386n 11 AC 328 25 safe places 3 47 3 258 r 163 NY 1 45 300 52 LRA 170n 30 quan meruit 47 8 360 23 123 76 305 115 699 38 M 139 46 M 325 reasonable time 40 M 100 , charge exception 22 ivf 106 126 456 performance 142 ,469 notice required 149 86 42 atty client s47S 33 M 48 M 8 AC demurrer 45 M pleadings 117 126 fee referee 17 AC complaint 69 M join issue 38 CP 253 506 428 433 107 832 404 57 68 45 master neg. s47S 8 34 d 163 NY safe tools ILEAN-S 949n 285 218 464 948 ABBREVIATIONS : 47 em domain s 47 S 418 3 155 NY 675 8 156 NY 671 51 partnership a 47 8 323 a 165 NY 621 r.i,!,.u.A. 1 1- -.J *' "ffi™?"!; d. distinguished; f. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed: n note; .criticised: 1, limited: cexplamcd; o. overruled: s. same case: do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel caseT a. que'stronrf Vol. 21 N, Y, Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division 51 347 54 bank eDtries 8 47S 376 9 AC 147n misappropriation 34 ' ' 324 fraud 16 AC 182n liability 142 847 62 services s47S 296 79 451 quantum meruit 146 97 8 47 8 s41 43 exceptions 80 liberty read 78 M 66 quo warranto s 47 S 601 a 154 NY 439 72 neg. damages 1 24 fact question 190 revers. error 331 625 491 22 614 8 47 S 402 f 34 624 i 76 295 income business 94 M 129 1 92 damages b47S 45 2d verdict 53 76 3d verdict 66 73 107 4th verdict 81 review 17AC 204n 207 motive infer 327 229 649 436 339 307 253 446 1 29 oral evidenc 8 47 S 255 a 164 NY 1 56 615 1 34 sp.prfmance. s 74S 299 a 162 NY 626 restriction 19 AC 27n 1 42 presumption 8 47 S 270 7 AC 459n 76 351 resettlement 6 AC 289n cruelty "" M 434 8 47S 50 70 8 76 s32 125 authority 180 explanation 184 77 estoppel. s47S a 162 NY 59 66 review 91 a 161 NY 540 534 112 411 309 389 390 460 462 a 166 NY 394 20 1 assignment s 47 S 503 91 replevin 108 23 M 90 I 32 M 662 champerty II AC 286n288n liability HI 100 204 ultra vires 236 trust 8 47S 59 59 covenant 109 lien 35CP r 163 NY 661 d 38 425 639 521 289 117 619 146 S47S 61 78 d86 penalties b96 138 burden proof 120 23 onus proband! 79 M 459 156 objections s 47 S 409 revers. error 349 218 77 446 325 14 f 171 1 60 review s47S a 163 NY 88 objection s 47 S 395 25 110 'laches discretion 61 242 32 CP 77 amendment 62 M 315 ICPNS 225 by mandamus f 171 306 171 . 307 regular channel 171 307 348 400 583 8 47 S 518 26 3 34 106 40 179 62 503 89 70 e 26 M 658 33 M 203 charter power 65M 660 209 recovery s 47S 435 75M 339 2 1 revocation 47 S 369 27 529 7AC 23n certif asproperty 9 AC 453n 457n e 162 NY 549 release 516 S20 540 178 do 175 NY 55M 298 revers. error 241 covenant 8 47 S 685 a 163 NY 583 f 163 362 245 jurisdiction 113 113 prohib. writ 3 47S 184 NY 49 M discretion 35 CP 145 8 47S f 23M 300 denials 8 47S 9 66 36 M referee fee 10 AC 676 32 74 234 531 247 contract 47 3 8 28 30 affidavit SAC subscription 119 appeal 8 5 AC 252note ev. s47S 104 677 442 336 388 564 272 601 537 254 prom, note 505 430 43 91 334 694 478 291 14 27 OP 29 CP 66 LBA 204NY insurance 35 371 discontinue 8 47 S 399. 6 AC 105n 7 AC 442n 373 usage ev. 290 528 698 488 304 intention 8 47S a 155 NY 59 40 M residence 47 M 3 1 I libel s47S r 161 NY 25 cities sewage 61 LRA 7 457 700 434 371 228 s47S a 160 NY 53 larceny 72 V. reversible error 170 NY I recovery 211 NT B 47S a 165 NY amendment 53M 256 interest s47S do 178 NY 94 penalty B47S . a 165 NY 43 523n 71 38 M consent valid 116 7.52 97 authority s 47 S 4.52 f 157 73 305 628 628 183 548 1 65 water suppy s 47 S 506 *166 NY 591 1 68 neg. mines s 47 S 386 36 M 103 complaint 59 M lex loci 78 M 450 plaintiff's rights 87 M 159 1 72 sup. pro. s 47 S 493 a 154 NY 777 87 241 jurisdiction 13 AC 461 461n ICPNS 6n 1 74 covenant 8 47 S 489 44 179 180 146 798 166 NY .344 no breach 142 365 183 567 equity claim 42 341 not chattel 154 852 quiality property 154 852 213 coroners 47 S a 154NY f 21 e94 107 f 152 29 M 47 M 180 NY 34 CP 17AC submission 31 city ofScers £ 152 title f 210 NT 180 naturaliza- tion fees b47S a 154 NY extra pay 121 133 lees clerk 133 221NY 495 734 626 284 339 40 556 69 279 65 30 537 40 564 659 622 318 351 321 negligence 8 47 S 788 a 163 NY 559 68 613 614 618 68 619 620 621 108 18 174 NY 314 master 66 LRA 163o competent ev. 179 NY burden deft 52M degree care ILRANS 144 66M guarantor 67 M 259 fact question 8 47S f 32 42 17AC decision 44 f 72 new trial 107 17AC reversal 17AC 681 626 488 139 5 617 5n 1382 170 whole evidence do 153 732 266 Supreme ct. 269 162 197 93 287 172 643 643 427 revers. error 8 47 S 540 337 weight evidence 71 502 149 156 381 liens s47S 24 M construction 51 M own property lOlM 533 383 attachment s 47 S 442 f 21 635 387 discovery s 47 S 557 d 34 524 54 188 d 36 M 412 source inform. 39 M 250 b. particulars 6 AC 328n vacate order 431 172 96 M ILRANS liability 132 85 M d 96 M 218 NT expert 184 199 428n 430 378 200 409 evidence 263 59CP 392 Uens s47S r 160 NY 10 AC 395 8 47S a 163 NY 339 resale s 47 S 731 f27 593 adjournment office abolished 221NT 416 101 mandamus 8 47 S 403 a 164 NY 133 J 14 amendment 8 47 S 352 r 154 NY 483 e 38 622 25 M 249 8 5 AC 67 70 28 CP 237 183 construction I 1 8 insolvency s 47 S 486 B 47 S 383 50 M 189 a 155 NY 827 powers limited 33 152 153 152 432 e 161 NY 446' 433 776 47 514 512 267 513 T 4 188n 383 2 1 9 appeal 8 47S r 155 NY 8 5 AC 6 AC alimony 173 NY vested interest 61 LRA 803 right modify f 81 M 512 231 ejectment s 47 S 666 s 36 425 competency 142 li incompetent 151 36 s 47S 133 appeals 154 validity f 99 M 689 188 56 66 expenses 67 M 342 user s47S 36 73n 658 549 143n 571 586 equity 53 defenses 153 32 40 45 M fS4 negligence f 25M relief i26M f 27:a d27M 30 M e31M cootrib. neg. f 109 jury question 64M 568 98 M 57 78 617 120 568 419 850 642 823 766 509 31 432 amendment s 47 S 563 d 63 377 f 99 i30 435 ejectment s47S a 163 NY 442 pledge 47 8 r 158 NY ■ 8 158 NY 697 454 609 1 7 405 contract 47 S 580 r 160 NY 516 409 residaace 8 47 S 569 25 196 460f'dl't transfr s 47 S 576 37 413 f 40 263 s 46 615 pi oof intent 31M 52 466 execution 8 47 S 649 87 103 contempt 33 M . 124 modification 175 431 348 nuisance 8 47 S 641 *159 NY 245 62 600 by injunction' 272 alimony 47 S 470 f 21 631 6 AC 188 7 AC 242n attorney's lien 7 AC 258n 178 565 public policy 114 260 136 49 285 service notice s 47 S 339 d 163 156 290 patents s 47 § 462 565 546 1138 618 216 NT 357 award s47S 35 e35 f 21 468 564 409 411 638 548 45 634 496 56 424 63 21 494 658 45 5 AC 468 trust 47 S a 163 NY B 159 NY 62 M 14 n 554 554 565 566 8155 NY 361 contract 8 47S 522 r 164 NY 234 8 85 584 construction 31 CP 264 369 interpleader 3 47 S 448 e 40 501 72 180 24 M 7 208 4 1 3 contract s47S 33 CP a 162 NY 174 lOlM construction 58 72 73 174 43 M 33 CP cons, contract 157 690 most favorable 168 141 4 1 6 discount 8 47 S 562 17 AC 179n 243n 246n 17AC 180n 181n discretion court do 155 806 472 perfmce.prf. 8 47 S 567 31 226 232 39 55 475 biU'partic. case 1 562 290 550 282n-3n 3 47S 101 case 2 s47S f 56 13 AC 476 motion 8 47 S 688 f 163 962 477 pers. knowl- edge 420 demurrer 655^35 M 3 47S f 51 89 31 M 36 M judicial 189NY 623 612 540 205 10 195 3 48S 52 60 93 137 24 M 31 M 41 M 32 CP 692 540 76 277 859 685 16 244 40 50urce knowledge 56M 324 transfer tax a 48 S °*l al55NY_?i^ note; ABBREVIATIONS: a, afBrmed; d, distinguished; t, followed; r, reversed; m, .'"od'^^*'' *;, ?i™i!'!?U^aooe4 e criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; », samecaae; do, dusenting opinion ; p, paraUd caie , q, qaeiuoDw N. 7. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division Vols. 21, 22 71 484 legacy 8 47S rlS9 NY 583 436 514 492iiU'y question 3 47 S 585 a 162 NY 642 21 M 635 50 1 indenmity s 48 S 508 35 H 335 503 unearned rent s 48 S 594 a 162 NY 636 f 49 138 eviction time of 352 597 jndt. s 47S 64M discontinuance 139 119 ^„^ 633 appeal caee 2 9 47S s 164 NY case 20 a47S 803 b. particulrela 164 NY 8 47 8 780 insurance 40 488 29 CP 275 15 AC 175n 23 M rent due d23M^ 2b M {43M 44 M SAC whole rent 61 M 697 ISO 394 221 425n 625 514 assignment s 48 8 60? e 29 e 5 AC 39 260 518 may E 48S 103M waive 639 281 533 notice s 48 S 389 39 283 289 warranty 24M 402 592 123n 542 levy s48S 6 AC 544 bid s48S a 164 NY 24M vested interest 32 621 552 waiver e 48 S 601 7 AC 353 n 565 assignment e32M reliance 142 681 276 crdtr. 772 114 599 warranty s 47 8 778 *159 NY 564 29 135 847 467 631 expert ev case 1 s 47 8 4' 8 21 6; atty. lieu case 2 a 47 8 7 AC 472 2S8n 1138 760 1136 561 1143 237 528 603 520 s48S a 155 NY 29 M 395 666 237 570 good considerat s48S do 153 doloS new agreement do 153 876 211 876 878 804 trustee 3 47 8 e84 108 40 M 200 629 amendment 38 CP 16 lOOM 142 amend parties 19A0 307b new liability 152 306 809 discretion 47 S 835 84 404 40 M 132 134 13 AC 176n contempt 13 AC 179nI81n 186 enforcement 13 AO 174nl7Sn _. purchaser 116 310 614 election s 47 S 786 f 162 396 6 1 6 replevin 8 47 S 756 23 M 601 6 1 8 replevin 8 47 S 754 23 M 601 substitution 39 607 623 pleading case 1 s 47 S 251 8 55 626 opg. highway case 2 8 47 8 269 61 618 money case 25 8 47 8 a 163 NY town borrow's caee 31 8 47 8 1146 a 154 NY 628 constitutional 207 NY 613 634 new trial case 11 b47S a 163 NY appeal case 14 8 47 8 a 165 NY 1147 SS8 1147 614 636 compliance 69 M 388 subject equities 69 M 388 . VOL. 22. I subscription s 47 8 906 33 233 234 337 433 129 93 M liability 140 682 916 220 624 agency a 47 8 39 120 e 39 M 637 638 implied warranty 39 222 14 AC 289 n authority 67 M 446 breach warranty 137 736 warranty 158 463 166 235 1 6 assignment 8 47 S 850 r 155 NY 401 24 unauthorized pledge a 47 8 880 m 166 N Y 469 33 construction a 47 8 824 r 164 NY 434 conatruction 8 47 8 841 a 161 NY 11 87 contempt s 47 S 802 68 417 419 426 do 68 420 72 90 134 363 33 M 726 67M 99 do 102 7 AG 218n 219n remedies 95 409 not limited 638 appeal case 4 8 47S *156 NY case 23 8 47 8 *156 NY 639 appeal case 11 8 47 8 *16S NY 1142 136 1146 66D 1145 322 579 foreclosure 8 48 8 36b 15 AC 237b 61 M 97 right not aStd 62 M 642 assistance writ ICPNS 352 583 new trial 624 laches case 1 s47S 73 signal 13 AC 420 494 415n 625 damages case 1 8 47 S 37 M 1130 386 43 gift intent 9 47 8 , r 160 NY 30 M 31 M delivery 41 M 870 476 181 121 342 74M 92 bar 3 47 8 a 155 NY 93 68LRA notice 19A0 538 800 309 263 326n 24n 95 secure costs 174 839 133 337 611 175 486 428 747 404 621 282 s48S 27 deposit d lOOM 589 appeal 8 47 8 6 AC 398 31 814 188n 592 master neg, 8 47 8 809 28 178 d70 350 626 appeal case 9 s47S s 166 NY case 20 s47S a 164 NY case 26 8 47 8 a 162 NY 19SNY 1133 680 1132 735 1151 667 468 54 pension fund s47S r 163 NY do 32 request 52 burd, defendant 63 601 24 M 688 25 M 168 similar employm. 63 LRA llOn no interest i 167 457 57 certificate a 47 8 936 81 372 title e22M reissuance 6 AC 370n 64 recovery 8 47 S 830 f 22 626 626 3 47 8 33 f 65 37 M _ CP 38CP_ discretion 42 6 AC 167 168 n 9 AC 73i 10 AC 302 54M 52 waiver 89 M 154 1 02 pera injury s 47 8 815 a 162 NY 641 109 foreclosure s 47 8 913 s 36 464 6 AC 304n I 1 decision s 47 8 913 e 67 142 mechanic's lien 85 68 I 1 3 laborer a 47 S 1018 St. constn. act right to appear f 217 NY 65 objection 98 M 715 1 3 1 review s47S 899 136 482 132 liability s 47 S lOU 141 109 1 40 contempt B 48 8 60 r 156 NY 333 depoationa 14 AC 236n 1 49 f'd asaignmt 8 47 8 926 d 33 639 5 AC 234n 52 reversal 8 47 B 955 e38 619 50 146 I ^6 negligence 3 47 8 961 32 M 292 e32M 30 CP 67 contrib. neg. 16AC 331n ;/ractice 201 NY 357 Bpecif. questions e 94 M 179 1 6 1 certiorari s 47 S 1020 * 156 NY 308 41 497 f 49 388 51 201 e 67 102 time application 191 allegation 378 187 1027 439 s48S 109 195 onus piobandi s47S 79 M 2l0prior mg. 8 478 1038 5 AC 369n 2 1 2fact question a 47 S 1034 41 1 618 sped, evidence 134 731 objection 142 219 2 1 6 accounting s 48 8 422 a 162 NY 635 jnriadiction 138 795 220power court s 47 S 1047 85 M 497 222 extra fees 47 S 1017 20 AC 195n 223 quantity ?47 S 857 48 M 147 discrepancy 138 641 234 intention 8 47 8 866 323 69 543 devise 50 M 364 31 CP eSOM 42 M 163 NY 168 NY 1 70 relief s48S 8 35 r 156 NY delegated 68 M 27 647 92 389 446 183 104 64 632 34 71 annuity 9 47 8 29 vest title 48M 75 b. parti c. s47 8 e73 403 818 ■435 121 763 324 32 40 52 do 78 change. 38 CP 178 485 363 139-140 venue 65 77 indictment 9 47 8 92 M proof 61 35 M verdict f39M penalty 100 629 181 practice 845 725 501 695 271 144 question proof 117 9 eiceptna. proof 1 1 7 reconaider- ation by jury 8 47 8 920 27 614 34 325 error court U9 206 correct verdict 56M 503 do 138 778 jury power 69 M 421 1 20 taxation a 47 S 958 a 155 NY 661 1 24 county court em. domain s47 8 62 67 102 appeal d 151 damages ■ 87 M 965 480 531 101 753 123 1 76 sp.proceedg s 47 8 1023 27 369 44 M 266 constitutional 28 M 707 1 79 judgt.by con fession 3 47 S 1036 s 59 352 1 86 ice neg. s 47 8 1032 f 55 264 neg. gueatn fact 16 AC 324n 1 89 allegation s 47 S 1039 63 398 10 AC 181 preaumptiosk 67 454 affidavit 94 400 jurisdiction 43 M 297 69 M 327 9 AC 232n 234n 9 AC 237n justiUcation 113 339 240 jurisdiction s47S 7b7 a 162 NY 638 s5AC 26 f 105 440 7 AC bVn damages 34 CP 326 249 warranty 47 8 743 122 321 254 repeal s 47 8 767 39 M 496 65M 117 258 preference s 48 S 984 a 163 NY 43 187 NY 422 6 AC 236n 266 conclusive 47 8 45 evidence • 46 M administn. 119 863 111 367 111 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f. followed; 270 champerty 8 47 S 855 e37 30 86 584 11 AC 287n 29 CP 31 273fact question s 47 S 933 41 162 55 29 30 97 451 277 joint liable 5 47S ■ 995 13* 173 . criticised; 1. limited: ■.7.xprainidro;o;«-a;dT;. '>^^7i^£:.nH^'o^fii^ft^lr^.lf^r^\,.'^;t!^^ Vol. 22 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division 282 tax corpn s 47 S 949 doing business 25 15 27 456 29 688 30 152 102 269 5 AC 280 57 LEA 90n 92e 285 relief s 47 S 883 * 155 NY 441 692 55 249 258 judicial e28M constitution 31 M discretion 32 M 56LRA monopolies 168 NY 64LBA negligence 70 M authority 177 707 672 7 858 731d 20 674 299 title act a 47 S 900 22 M ^ 566 308 presumption e 47 S 1124 33 M 420 3 1 2 J udgment s 47S 940 133 205 f 146 509 3 1 4 authority 371pwr. remedv s 48 S 99 139 416 restoration a 155 NY 71 233 375 amendment 3 48 S 32 - 34 173 d 63 377 election estoppel 91 189 380 order insur. fund d 49 S 184 24 M 599 burden proof 61 558 389 parol ev. 48 S 196 154 527 393 contrib neg. 977 619 472 233 s47S a 162 NY 69 ■ 185 injunction 77 3 1 9 costs s 47S sSAC 51 M f 83 M 117 989 641 183 489 502 987 47 231 178 73 32 1 fact question s 47 S 738 62 373 328 committee s 47 S 971 a 160 NY 702 74 472 accounting 33 CP 149 s47S 40 395 acct stated s48S * 162 NY pleading 101 not final 60 M not recover do 166 167 400 order arrest s 48 3 279 16 AC 9-1 In 406 nuisance s 48 S 132 a 1 62 NY 584 78 519 4l 7 preference 48 S 162 d 51 249 426 negligence s 48 S 38 d 26 603 intersections 162 NY 196197 63 427 62 401 33 M 288 292 5 AC 230 res judicata B9 453 not final 71 M 45 serve personallv 149 457 448 jurisdiction s 48 S 265 a 163 NY 571 35 176 39 176 182 £ 87 M fl assessments 24 M 361 exemptions 35 209 211 e 34 M 20 pension taxes 38 CP 184 power remedy 139 416 460 sub-cont'p 333 contract s47S a 161 NY 76 346 infants claims s48S r 160 NY 36 3 155 NY 942 182 614 S48S 44 49 54 do 57 66LRA delegation 60 negligence 76 106 do 170 f 163 183 NY 224NY 31 M 428 trust s48S 175 a 161 NY 108 28 288 56 412 413 do 70 468 469 do 178 131, 132 pq. conversion 51 M 173 accumulation 86 412 424 426 111 779 780 56 278 592 654 353 assignment s 47 S 877 a 164 NY 252 22 615 356 pledge duty 53 LEA 588-9n 360 sale s49S s 158 NY 36 180 705 112 173 177 178 f 178 e33M 43 M e 162 NY interest 111 37CP (lificretion do 187 life tenant 155 dividends £ 173 209 NY void do 177 429 .509 121 122 679 242 144 895 25 605 34-4 430 467 207 584 501 71 86 135n 561 13 223 211 54 136 439 512 475 strike out p 48 S 30 77 314 do 171 579 46 M 574 48 M 199 485 party wall 'l M 62 M lOPNS 48 S SAC 6 AC 483 neg. i 48 S 121 98 M 489 bar claim 16 14 132n 640 350 23 550 486 .ndep. contract 386 349 15 259 7 344 230 430 273 95 liabilitv 224NY 62 M neg. owners 195NY 427 prioprietor 200 NY 91 466 master neg. 48 S 153 495 agency 48 S 26 44 49 80 99 estoppel 170 NY 26 3 170 NY 27 57 LEA 323n examr agt. of in- sured ' do 49 479 199 378 655 476 352 538 539 s48S 42 75 166 39 CP 188NY G M proof 25 M 8 5 AC s48S 33 63 67 d68 106 527 public policy 178 181 366 inspection remise 44 1 mutual s 48 S • 274 s 48 S 61 389'* 162 JJY 121 378 260 265 assumed risk 59 72 9 75 78 64 LEA Gafe place 157 188NY 202 NY pers. injury 122 not liable do 149 coRorvants 159 74 220 381 382 226 444 445 414 8] 51 616 I'O 11 On 201 342 279 187 869 470sp prference 48S' 26 power sale 26 101 124 mandatory 152 sn 320 463 100 60? 325 473 judgment s 47 S 994 -9 619 33 M 189 501 prelim exam 8 48 S 85 123 180 508 misconduct atty. s48B 40 23 200 e 110 802 excessive fee 18AC 242n unconscionable 79 M 317 lot justify -9 M 345 5 1 1 ev.' value s 48S 42 66M 504 5OC1 5 1 6 robbery s 48 S 241 a 158 NY 722 520 laches 9 48S 29 service notice 1S3NY - 397 35CP 196 personal injury 530 reissuance s 48 S 269 AC 370n 540 order a 48 S 15 eSO 153 160 ord. reference 225XY 123 542 admissions 187 13- 353 787 174 42s 565 181 6 1 sparks neg. 3 48S 110 prima faci ev 57 193 9 AC 337n 62 1 burden proof 31 CP 264n 622 damages 3 47S ■i 159 NY 623 lease 3 47S a 163 NY 139 [appeal case 9 s48S r 156 NY 821 573 778 575 624 jurisdiction 755 58 98 limitatio 186 NY 38 CP 139 in time f 77 M negligence dl53 212 NY new cause 171 382 39 233 448 020 213 394 523 requirement .48S a 165 NY 34 M sSAC 9 AC refiling 35 prospective 57M compliance 147 89 634 189 54 429 576 22P 460 not conclusive 99M 343 552 inference 3 48 S 123 50 148 credibility 57 70 waiver 58 604 605 must plead 168 759 561 so perfmce B 48 S 102 15 AC 289r 564 tax corpn s 48 S 1060 s 34 143 573 compromise s 48 S 106 a 163 NY 662 46 325 57 16 incompt. ev. 36 M 196 579 equity relief 9 48S 114 a 163 NY 673 584 reference 48 S 103 f 45 629 98 114 14 AC 58n 588 negligence ■? ~ 86 35 15S 89 30 CP review 16AC new trial 200 NY s47S a 163 NY proof 32 3 82 628 appeal case 1 48 S 22 m 164 NY appeal case 2 5 48S m 164 NY preference case 4 .47S 27 M equity suit 984 565 474 281 1117 628 1117 583 966 751 1112 231 633 appeal case 11 B 48 S 1115 a 162 NY 680 629 presumption case 4 3 48S 45 appeal case 39 3 50S 3 155 NY 3 156 NY sham. pldg. case 45 3 50S 9 AC 388 67 lOln 630 appeal cases 1 & 2 3 48S ..„ al65NY614-«15 appeal case 4 3 48S a 160 NY limitation case 13 3 48S r 157 NY 593 notice s48S a 165 NY 34 9 AC f 165 NY 31 CP 195 NY 112 612 448 162 284- 224 170 596 occupancy 9 48S lis 55 486 526 covenant s 48 S 65 s40 69 no privit.v 805 election s48S 91 stay 91 24 M 16 AC no bar 62 M stay 177 192 397 402 622 256-7n 149 1100 591 1127 654 697 1130 180n 1102 1106 561 1112 70 case 17 9 48S a 164 NY appeal case 18 9 48S a 160 NY appeal case 23 3 48S a 162 NY appeal case 25 3 48S a 164 NY 1117 562 1100 1106 596 1112 560 83 I certificate case 1 s 48 S 24 q 31 M 392 7 AC 459 460n 632cbangevenue case 1 48 S '39 3S . 58 S9 625 discovery a AG 326n ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; c, criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, dissentinsf opinion: p. parallel case; q, questioned N. Y. Supreme Cotirt Reports— Appellate Division Vol. 23 VOL.23 I negligence B 48 S 425 fact question 2S 124 34 M 47S 54 LEA 75n Sin 97-8n master neg. 117 52 liable neg. 127 802 5 life insurance s 48 S 463 a 162 NY 636 lapsing 19A0 22 In 8 constr posessn s49S a 163 NY 57 SAC estoppel 61 M evidence 129 . no title in fee 78 M 580 adver. possessn 103M 602 587 191 130n 488 521 26 pleading B 48 S 383 8 165 NY 610 29 meas damges 8 48 S 665 47 542 tolls 53 438 440 contract 93 595 money damage? 6 AC 266n 43 contrib. neg. b48S 25 d46 46 f 77 82 costs 8 AC weight ev. 44 454 314 247 249. 2S0 495 496 392n 554 48 meas.damage 48 S 346 61 M 65 f 165 151 51 damages 8 48 S 382 a 164 NY 563 53 permissive 8 48 S 548 53 169 31 CP 132 defense d 119 669 escape payment 135 778 assignment 95 M 312 313 57 contract 8 48 S 544 d32M 510 competent 171 890 6 1 authority s48S f 23 35 36 . jurisdiction 147 obligation 212 NY 604 624 351 328 670 70 techn. error 1103 86 348 227 232 8 48 8 100 24M findings 41 M review 6 AC 273 11 AC. 31n 32c exceptions 110 36 134 256 rulings 151 77 reverse error 131 116 75 damages s 48 S 420 f23 625 78 repeal 3 48S a 159 NY 27 M 59 LEA limited 144 concession 164 contract d 164 83 parol ev a 48 S 468 f 69 498 34 M 233 6 AC 206n 1 47 hold over 224 power court - 48 S 598 8 48 S 737 38 527d25M: 132 .s65AC 134d34M 414 71 M 313 no power 686 558 152 610n 809 166 170 77negligence 48 S 81 30 168 179 liability 32 88 new trial 372 160 s36 638 47 M 356 16AC 119 129n discretion 45 378 ?§„ 631 102 400 9 I consideration s 48 & 341 30 M 253 103 burden prf s 48S 374 64M 580 1 20 services s48S a 163 NY 576 1 24 injunction s 48 S 656 f 23 625 law remedy 159 896 1 3 1 inad dam, 3 48 S 904 25 288 30 428 87 67 108 253 11 AC 54n 59n64n 27 CP 137 compn. dai 84 M 635 1 39 prior mtge 3 48 S 974 *15S NY 697 contract 129 96 gift 180 603 1 4 1 shock dam. s 48 S 914 do 41 223 83 607 102 276 s 5 AC 124 fright damage 16AC 69n 70n 72 nervous shock 142 512 162 793 181 I 52 insurance 48 S 927 228 collision 163 NY 114 s - ~ 63 new trial 48 S 630 35M 34 23 I admr. power 3 48 S 740 i 70 em. domain 119 466 3 48 S 901 „- . 163 NY 572 234 amend.eertif trespasser 184 NY j>48S 349 31 M S 892 8 48 g 776 48 149 complaint 164 I85future estate 8 48 S 889 131 297 I SSserve process -50S *157 NY set aside 70 M 784 671 112 201 jurisdiction 866 36 617 63(! 3 48 8 m 156 NY f 69 f 72 ballot 24 M 448 452 sl56 NY 45 204 notice S48 S 729 46 M 12] knowl. essentl do 179 244 207 incompt. ev s488 ■ 741 78 327 81 311 distinction 74 M 23 2 1 pleading 8 48 8 a 164 NY 214 commis<«ioni 3 48 8 102 76 M 2 1 5 penalty 3488 e36 M e41 M jlu-isdiction 30 CP exclusion color 48 M discretion 148 admissible 81 M 8 48 8 37 75 25 M 3 5 AC 12 AC 30 CP exceptions 51 conclusive da 166 376 51 _48 8 85 67 704 982 89 451 249 18 166 743 289 remainder 8 48 8 26 49 M distribution 23 M vested interest 27 M 260 lOlM 573 construction 53M 507 surviving grandchildren 182 186 future vesting 186 374 ^^ „* 392 c 7 AC 459 464n 235 title plff. s 48S 745 178 469 240 foreclosure 779 8 5 AC costs f 101 personal jadgmt a 78 M 243 nuisance 8 48S 70 92 M 246 usage s48S 80 M [40 M 62 41 I notice 140 734 s 48 8 437 184 335131 M 341 342 344 mental capacity „_ '35 M 698 234,9 AC 281 "^(committee ,..!43M 588 15*1 due process 1 138 46 '09 neglig. defect \6i^ 120 240 42P pleading „s,„is4SS 336 o»6!23 M 201 209 — ,-■ „„„ stockholders 293 contract '=M 38877 207 s 48 8 456 cumulative ,36 M 67 3 156 NY 679 152 641 a 1 61 NY 661 discretionary 433 negligence 79 M 51s48S 323 298 pers. injury „„„ |r 161 NY 48 8 366 360 demurrer 48S 239 446 set-off . 24 623 s 48 8 41 603'al62NY f 170 783:e91 misjoinder I 26 M 3161451 negUgence 55 LEA 198 199n'8 48 8 352 14 AC 45n3 56 372 liability f 163 141 f 170 786,25 M 196 single action t 218 NY 33 466precatryclse jury question 153 121 345 302 presumption „^ 348 65 67 365 neg. defect d 110 25 990 64 M 581 224 29 308 contract - 48 8 28 a 160 NY 703 title evidence 192NY 169 1067 564 253 new trial s48S 36 457 91 631 stmt, counsel do 71 138 "exhibition" t 77 M 200 construction f 77 M 201 258 exhibition --. 483 742 58M 330 96 M 105 106 construction 96 M 104 856 3 48 8 23 construction 116 327 decree 3 48 8 69 Limitations 93 distrust 42 M pleading 124 fraud sale 20 AO 261 by-laws 8 48 8 937 a 161 NY 633 . d43 . 31 1054 chge. beneficiary 493 510 f58 736 28 M 348 98 M 596 97 14 AC 594 43 67 255 686 67 548 194-7d 953 267 carrier 284 3 48 8 292 32C 29 594 law question 175 62 jr reasonable 616 143 36 M 27 care iin „„„ 275 obstruction 239 s 48 8 a 163 NY 221 power court 69 854 568 282directors 566 s 488 479 04M 146 nee. parties 16 134 867 349 accord 285 pledge 8 48 8 m 164 NY 48 163 NY 125 108 i48S 3 I 5 franchise 515 295 137 333 186 8 In 339 good title 3 48 8 363 28 123 65 658 155 NY 655 right entry 31 M C13 not assignable do 151 127 344 fd. transfer s 48 S 231 - 56 166 m 163 NY 54 347 reference 3 48 8 24 47 49 546 do 88 98 125 229 28 M 579 lOlM 339 14AC revers error 56M 299 jury trial 284 61 M s48S '156 NY 360 355 352 usury 5 48 8 154 16 551 184 349 116 845 451 692 58n 608 227 251 678 301 355 notice s48 8 44 settle issues eSO remedy 39 M equitable 6 AC 30 CP waiver 122 foreclosure *('5M cumulative 152 35 318 637 51 363 mtge. by infant s 48 S 152 97 162 false statement 23 M 347 foreclosure 42 M 6 defense 42 M 48 not estopped 206 NY 19? Judgt. pleadings 80 M 182 366 contract 3 48 8 309 d 77 412 377 supl. complt Is 48 8 a 163 NY 31 M specify 75M 792 281 296 378 472 injunction 316 16 17 s48S 62 new cause 99 8AC right review 138 140 s49 8 39 M .'court powel f 114 499 levy 8 49 8 statutory 31 6 AC 28 CP court trial 145 not comply lOlM „OEi508 reveiw 2||l8 48S 47 55 380 authority s48 8 a 165 NY 41 57 23 M 26 M 237 60 722 380 241 116 140 153 635 222 81 corpn. f 176 bound 383 commitmt. s48S 27 M 29 CP 389 fees 3 48 8 3 5 AC 5 1 4 power 8 48 8 rrA a 155 NY °°l]212 NY 523 oq \T 524 '*'' '^ 658 ,„. id 0^* taxation 582 s 48 8 553 a 155 NY 665 23 530 532 537 702 173 290 451 217 458 193 313 128 393 counterclm s 48S 225 178 457 398 surety s48S 8 38 43 do 43 e86 35 M 29 CP 306 629 97 99 102 531 556 60 623 16 265 163 194 64 f24 tl07 capital 31 fl57 NY assessment 52M: tax corpn' 117 book accounts 151 767 768 530 conclusive s 48 S 658 a 155 NY 665 65 227 532 dividend 8 48 8 557 d 28 M 31 ABBBEVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, now: e, cnticisea; 1. limited; e, explained; o, overruled; b, same case; do, dissenting opinion; p. parallel case; q, queation«4 Vols. 23, 24 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division 533 trial ii48S 578 49 128 witness jud'l. d53 339 removal 123 857 do 123 862 542 alienation 8 48S T32 ineomp. evidence 27 375 376 43 111 S4 620 69 585 liability do 148 486 178 164 declarations f 66 245 distinction 128 804 procure cause do 141 926 loss consortium 145 840 no presumption 178 164 548 force entry e48S 777 61M 231 "forc'ble nian- ner 202 NY 42 552 ultra vires b48 S 722 124 732 ,736 trust fund d 196NT 103 unlawful 149 886 559 alimony e48S 727 61 98 122 786 6 AC 187d 560 good faith s 48 S 799 50 M 414 frd. transfer 63M 223 57 1 supl. complt. b48S 948 40 149 s54 314 new cause 58 121 SAC 271n 275n 575 b. particlara 8 48S 663 33 566 16 AC 223 578 waiver • 48S 859 94 290 590 accounting e49S 116 a 163 NY 553 25 184 32 M 316 Jebit balances 219 NY 512 implication 219 NY 512 601 f'd. intent >49S 314 33 188 60 78 117 176 122 264 25 M 22 29 M 101 injunction i57M 107 606 demand 8 4SS 912 73 264 77 16 12 AC 176n 185 sum. proceedings 51 M 477 contempt 51 M 478 56M 277 608misdenieanor s 49 S '60 66 581 101 138 duty officer 35 M 715 clean bands 44 M 5 45 M 99 eq. relief 47 M 422 injunction 47 M 433 prevention 73 M 4 623 intersection case 2 s 48 S 345 a 161 NY 35 e 87 129 96 489 cove nan tb case 4 s 51 S 1006 49 M 173 624 appeal case 4 s48S a 162 NY authority case 10 s48S a 165 NY 35 adoption case 16 s48S a 155 NY 32 f43 1105 643 1118 136 351 1116 140 379 415 625 constitution case 3 s48S 1112 65 243 case 10 167 176 franchise case 11 s 48 S 1101 a 156 NY 437 626 appeal case 9 s 48 S 1140 a 162 NY 610 tax case 11 s48S 1113 34 147 VOL. 24 I carrier 49 S 164 102 420 acct. stated 130 307 jus tertii plead 76 M 309 7 restriction 9 49S 119 37 64 value lands 40 284 public street 120 301 map final 131 708 owner's right 66M 449 meas. damage 142 99 65M 255 12 error court s 48S 861 178 906 1 5 laches 3 48 S 936 15 M 344 1 7 mandamus s 48 S 1043 f 34 630 f 42 622 d 46 197 e 31 M 552 discharge 26 M 293 constitutional 72 529 25 surety s 49 S 93 s 60 169 170 do 60 174 178 vol. accounting 84 554 s 31 M 651 s 33 M 75 76 supl. citatn. 132 487 4 I receiver 3 48 S 967 r 156 NY 196 50 serv. procsss 8 48 S 973 120 737 51 revocation s 48 S 989 59 219 7 AC 22n 23n B 10 AC 19 burdens 161 602 personalproperty 46 392 395 9AC 452n 460n liquor tax certif 68 M 443 f lOlM 26 certif. property 154 851 58 accounting 8 48 S 839 38 374n 8 44 382 8 86 623 91 128 129 117 262 133 194 16S 56 172 664 f 173 793 33 M 231 34 M 77 41 M 75 51 M 266 decree 131 85 51 M 266 no bar 59 M 143 effect decree 135 14' conclusive 66 M 413 1 CPNS 291 relief 87 M 236 63 complaint B 48 S 978 24 M 390 9 SAC 106 slander f 171 389 disap. 171 390 171 391 73 injunction 8 49 S 49 a 156 NY 169 contract 45 M 463 bridge highway e 48 M 232 89 libel s 48 S 976 93 535 s 34 349 113 284 effect publicatn 74M 619 95 appeal s 49 S 92 10 AC 310n 46M; 422 97 injunction s 48 S 1051 stay 53 79 d 67 188 lOOM 190 1 1 contrib. neg 8 48 S 863 59 170 jury question d 113 750 104 repudiation a 48 S 1046 a 163 NY 183 39 554 35 M 164 trust costs 112 19 trust valid 145 872 876 1 10 death dmgs. s 48 S 940 *160 NY 571 a 164 NY 163 51 2 next of kin 84 651 s 3 AC 383 8 5 AC 121 9 AC 310n meas. damages 51 LRA 238 executor's right d 112 744 sped, proceeds 51 M 320 96 M 128 admr. action 37 CP 104,256 I 17 easements s 48 S 1061 119 400 123 conclusive 3 48 S 771 118 805 193 NY 396 1 28 meas. dam. 3 48 S 728 48 473 87 306 102 143 125 634 57 LllA 204n 52M 369 130 acceptance t. 48S 945 135 364 1 33 new cause s 48 S 1020 8 AC 279n 1 37chaDge grade s 48 S 1065 a 155 NY 661 31 224 damages 75 limitation 76 571 145 1 43b. particulars 9 49 S 182 94 314 163 117 16 A 175 n 1 52 pleading s 48 S 788 39 425 66 LRA 648-9n strike out 141 662 1 6 1 reference s 48 S 748 98 116 1 25 845 14 AC 58n 1 63 reves. error s 48 S 1005 charge refusal indorser 60 426 e92 "293 rule error 113 117 1 72 reformation s 48 S 1083 8 31 S 630 65 249 68 637 mistake 186 511 190 payment s 49 S 104 10 AC 198 201 variance s 48 S 967 a 156 NY 546 69 592 697 2 1 4 mandamus s 48 S 796 s 24 . 624 civ. service e 110 569 removal 116 137 preference 69 M 38 functus officio 185 489 223 revival a49S 12 66 428 429 do 56 432 438 439 6 AC 121n 9 AC 55 57 60 230 full value 8 48 S 403 31 406 233 incompt. ev. s 48 S 482 74 647 one erime 36 M 593 247 incompetent s 48 S 476 a 167 NY 704 9 AC 280n set aside 84 M 631 255 contract s 48 S 427 a 164 NY 201 stkhldr right 47 M 204 f 94 M 47 267 gross neglect s 48 S 461 210 NY 72 271 conclusive 3 48 S 496 63 M 147 273 pleading s 48 S 611 a 156 NY 461 libl. constmctn 175 115 280 ratification 8 49 S 561 48 297 9 52 615 io 62 616 authority 159 378 usurious f 89 M 547 lOOM 154 288fact question 9 48 S 506 36 291 186 843 ineomp, cv. 37 288 303 contrib. neg s 48 S 603 37 135 42 553 554 45 301 306 d 55 349 want of care 70 do 70 392 393 169 NY 125 fact question 96 153 do 106 619 do 105 621 occupancy 96 163 309 imprison- ment s 48 S 749 26 569 s3M 478 remanded 152 371 3 1 4 will 3 49 S 292 8 33 627 judgment void 106 322 jurisdiction 195NY 442 estoppel 75M 577 father plaintiff 173 807 327 foreclosur e s 48 S 671 a 161 NY 631 plead usury 146 734 159 514 102M: 240 330 presumption 9 48 S 492 a 163 NY 276 36 191 335 r r law 3 48 S 842 r 163 NY 228 24 .631 ultra vires t . i 52 274 343 ejectment 8 48 S 675 a 163 NY 684 354 rescissionl 3 48 S 686 24 M 60S law question do 189NY 55 36 1 use streets s 48 B 916 96 125 legislative power 107 411 injunction 104 229 16AC 357 377 warranty s 48 S 753 - 37 157 39 261 81 88 89 53LRA193nl98n insurance 48 M 390 390 insurance s 48 8 757 50 4 8 168 NY 706 395 fraud s 48 S 1078 3 39 650 t 94 M 467 402 new trial court's remarks 8 48 S 760 37 328 58 174 do 71 75 27 M 323 9 5 AC HI error court 118 508 175 119 reversible error 186 648 407 probate 48 S 414 d24 . . 540 subscription 76M 174 4 1 mistake 3 48 S 559 r 163 NY 374 417 limitation 416 159 384 187 450 350 512 9 i8S 5 AC 134 7M ^7M 78 M six years 80 M 421 pollution s 48 S 519 r 162 NY 563 35 259 6 AC 349 429 award B 48 S 702 a 165 NY 661 434 incomptnt. s 48S 576 183 799 437 trusts 3 48S 3 46 63:! parol agreement 119 656 do 659 title vested 68 M 553 442 complaint 3 48 S 471 30 Ml 45 198 101 487 ABBKEVIATIONS: a, afiirrned; d, distinguished; t, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note c, criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s. same case; do, dissentinjr opinion; p, parallel case; q, questioned N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division Vols, 24, 25 186 27 46 M 678 strict constrctn. 140 152 138 436 neg. exceptions 74M 253 446 witness 9 48 S 501 29 M 72 98 376 construction 31 CP 246d 449 discretion 8 48 S 52M new trial 175 37 CP 96 M 490 15 496 383 281 454 street r.r s48S 849 8 158 NY 708 a 165 NY 462 new trial 8.49 S 255 an65 NY 624 43 M 611 6 AC 270n 485 objections s 4RS 80 86 d 177 NY amendment f 217 NY 53M 1073 94 351 15 581 563 77 194 579 officer 8 49 S 525 » 166 NY 689 45 50 compensation 51 M 124 without fee BSM 230 supervisors 146 284 582nuisance 8 48 S 710 122 373 injunction 135 226 584 parol ev. 8 49 30 1104 566 489 assessment B 49 S 244 r 167 NY 33 502 exe. verdict s49S 17 31 452 28 CP 48 charge 33 594 321 17 declarations 24 M 396 594 no cause s 48 S 827 i 158 42S 599 waiver 3 48 S 996 24 604 f 172 54 construction 42 264 480 cond. precedent 83 583 585 588 do 90 321 139 875 f 91 M 299 service notice 42 480 requirement 139 876 no authority 172 55 602 prerequisite 8 48S , injunction case 2 18 49S 1144 Ir 164 NY 303 ;d 49 459 63 1 judgment ■ ^ca8e 11 s48S !a 163 NY 'case 12 8 48 8 a 165 NY r r law licase 14 .3 48 8 r 163 NY appeal case 16 s48S a 165 NY VOL.25 I admissions 8 49 8 defense 40 89 126 168 NY 68 M 1104 615 1105 228 1106 660 632 discharge case 2 'b48S r 163 NY allegations case 23 8 48 8 26 1107 351 310 602 328 500 124 287 1113 376 633 judgment case 5 s48S lllE a 162 NY 644 'case S 3 48 8 1119 a 163 NY 65C raising funds 68 M 287 9 jiu-isdiction s 48 S 1042 39 430 I I friv, answer 8 48 8 1000 85 44 pleading 97 56 objn. motion 10 AC 284n surety 192 NY so: 13 "doing busi ness" 8 48 8 102 36 M 40 M f 92 M 57LRA 92nl08n 41 656 399 190 5 1 9 contract 6 49 8 B 155 NY r 164.NY order 113 53 1 decree s49 8 72 27 M 30 M evidence 33 M jurisdiction 30 CP 175 176 acknowledgment 148 905 544 bill parti c B 49 S 695 126 26 32 288 168 IS 329 588 605 waiver 3 49 3 69 10 AC exemption 38 CP 185, 1 439 397 186 608 damages 8 48 8 683 81 274 184 517 6 1 3 jurisdiction 3 48 8 690 97 37 126 140 6 1 7pun.damagse 3 48 8 1026 50 112,113 12AC 8n 84n of 55 1 income trust 8 49 8 981 r 163 NY 13 AC family 71 M 66 560 entries bank 6 49 8 691 6 AC 154n 53 LEA 529n 563 mandamus 73 not enforced s 49 S 270 f 166 692 82 diversion S49 8 a 164 NY 105 217 31 M damages 36 M 138 injunction 181 NY rental value US 89 taxation 3 48 8 r 156 NY 57 LEA 250 602 218 377 528 565 85 1 25 prob cause s 49 S 203 t 26 342 complte defense 145 456 acquittal do 160 924 1 35 trustees 3 48 S 994 42 173 174 40M 200 individually do 148 98 M ISO 98 ' party to actiov '66M 228 73 M 285, 286 1 79 injunction 9 60 8 819 a 164 NY 696 59 LRA 843 843n Si 617 76n 77n 99d 1028 10 269 179 222 262 80n 9 I certiorari s48S due process d26 83 penalty 8 AC 6 tax corpn, . 49 S 10 117 64 a 156 NY 688 57 LEA 91n average capital 57 339 f 177 NY 55 exempt tax. 117 66 20 hab. corpus 623 leave answer case 1 8 48 8 9 AC 223 298ji — 624 appeal 164 case 9 ISgn s48 8 158 NY s49S s25M r 166 NY s 166 NY 570 parol ev. 760 636 136 149 s49S 625 appeal case 24 48 8 * 165 NY 3 169 NY certiorari case 30 3 48 8 a 165 NY 1102 719 1106 696 245 1112 701 -48 8 e77 22 award -49 8 50 e 103 29 CP 66 M 1030 151 319 576 106 61 310 882 28 575 31n 94 transfer tax 993 627 79 149 366 363 interest 1015 217 26 tax on dogs s 48 S 625 a 165 NY 517 26 92 93 police regulations 42 89 SAC25n30n32n mandamus 161 NY 272 187NY 158 34 tax sale 3 49 8 35 M 405 actual owner 125 348 tax on lana 64M 590 626 negligence case 1 s 49 S 1142 887lr 165 NY 241 53 insurance s49S a 164 NY 38 M d lOOM f 169 NY 32 CP f 162 d 182 s48S f 32 74 24 M 34 M 67 M fractnl d 176 96 Ubel 48 8 » 5 AC defective affidav do 110 909 order arrest 16A0 8n perl, knowledge 77 M 413 mere belief 77 M 413 98 negligence s 49 8 236 m 164 NY 30 29 387 56 380 381 indep. contractor 66LRA461n 463n res ipsa loquitur 49 M 133 liability 62 M 273 f 94 M 75 105 presumption 3 49 8 198 10 AC 386n 1 07 amendment 384 s 49 8 227 49 565 62 M 316 1CPN8 225 I I I coutrib. neg. s 49 8 209 30 446 139 costs 48 8 ..5 AC 117 976 161 783 1 40 contempt 949 8 195 d 68 320 84 IBS s SAC 7S 141 rewards 3 49 S 201 19 AC 135 n interpleader 204NY 287 145 default 3 48.8 1076 13 AC 181l f 50 new cause a 49 8 199 8 AC 274 n sup. p adg 53M 396 I 53 trust fund s 49 8 222 a 156 NY 316 crdr. action do 184 346 1 82 accounting s49S 377 32 M 316 land under wtr. 73 M 285 185 order a 49 8 291 74 417 84 4R4 9 AC 92 poor person 68 LRA 422 52M 7 19A0 312 petition 9 AC 9fi consen attorney 9 AC »R 11 AC 257 admr. sue 38 CP 233 administratrix 38 CP 234n defective 169 420 . 6 1 pleading 3 48 S 1095 51 307 60 29 96 39 fraud 107 11 certificate stock 1 9 1 attachment 3 49 8 114 35 422 110 334 23 M 623 d 24 M 682 57M 342 d 6 AC 166 195 complaint s 49 S 303 e 79 M 107 96 guaranty 46 M allegations 126 346, state facts 131 conclusions 138 39 147 346 29 607 628 378 209 282 599 275 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed- c, criticised ; 1, limited ; e, explained 62 evidence 8 48 8 1009 48 303 68 discretion 8 48 8 1036 a 159 NY 661 f 37 . 67 liq- certificate 111 34 waiver 49 187NY' 38 CP 403 486 13S proximate cause 84 516 reversal 25 M 472 d 30 M 105 imputed neg 68LRA 350 I I 5changevenue 8 49 S 220 28 34 623 64 621 affidavit fl27 69 53M 23 902 164 oonstitutl. 3 49 8 230 a 155 NY 420 170 NY 109 trustee power 132 74 lease stone crushers 155 755 practice condemned £ 160 147 not authorized f 174 734 I97sp perfor- . mance s 49 S 357 0. 163 NY 410 f26 M 449 substitu'd serv. SAC 14 equities 120 839 206 demurrer 3 49 8 344 counterclaim 78 M 288 209 comtnissio a d40 do 40 24 M 29 CP -49 8 a 160 NY 627 529 530 487 578 268 269 363 568 e 27 M 472 decree bar 219 1 73 discovery s49S do 74 76 31 M 40 M 7 AC 11 AC 33 CP 133 352 353 624 546 662 158n 454 264 158 proper party 64M 459 1 75 construction s 49 8 214 275 657 53.% 49 2 1 4 vesting s 49 8 361 a 1 61 NY fiSK 28 M 30 M 31 M intent 75M same meaning 78 M 251 remainder 92 M 688 2 1 8 negligence s 49 8 307 contrib. neg. 61 M 641 special damages 36 195 147 109 .''U'^ii'i''^''i'^'*' *• f°"°wea; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; , o, overruled; s. same case; do, diPslnting opinion; p. parallel case; q, questionefl Vols. 25, 26 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division intersections 39 f61 66 do 77 pleadinfi do 78 82 500 16 602 166 107 17 33 397 73 105 197NY damages 27 M 824 12 AC 19n 20a 213011 inadmissible 20 AC 169n 222 demurrer 286 702 817 23d 221 161 S49S a 155 NY 30 M evocation 7 AC 59 48 M pers. property 9 AC 452n 453n 10 AC 22 contractual 156 452 lOlM 27 228 common law s49S 40 M ffaznblins 64LRA note 67LRA 337 460 166d Sin 234' damages 8 49 8 r 163 NY d48 54LRA 409 472 125 lign 39 25M 3'6M 28 CP 526 527 245 18 239-241 285 inadcg dam. 486 428 506 372 481 . damages 635 jury 244 290 conclusive s49S 30 55 80 34 M compn, 84 M error 177 B49S * 155 NY s 165 NY 41 45 6AC 14 AC 538 699 664 62 280 240n 67n 292 award costs s 49 S 517 98 243 review 16AC 285n287n amend error 133 862 300 assessment s 49 S 502 f 27 630 59490492495497 35 M 449 taxation 1 LEANS 767n 239 remainder s49S 44 167 24 M 27 M 37 M 29 CP 289 290 160 504 642 101 466 177 trust personalty 28 M . 355 next of kin 77 M 88 245 exclusion 447 267 813 535 140 s49S 53 construction 128 intention 78 M remainder f 85 M 250 pleading » 49 S 305 117 591 rule liable 117 595 allegations 19A0 398 "permitted" 7D M 467 254 privilege 8 49 S 301 150 865 no publication 84 M 503 329 tax payer suit s 49 S 713 a 160 NY 377 339 enrolment s 49 S 72? 14 AC 16n 20n authority 155 722 348 discovery s 49 S 597 98 151 examination 102M 215 361 jurisdiction s 49 S 553 35 176 exemption 35 209 210 39 177 recoupment 45 411 24 M 217 362 demurrer 49 S 500 38 370 112 859 186 NY 202 s 103 455 relief eq. acctg 365 arrest s49S 72 eiectment 154 220 NY death negligence d 156 158 282 mitigation duty carrier s49 S 523'f 213 NY 511 256 acceptance s 49 S 137 B 56 625 275 rule transfer B 49 S 570 38 M 109 obligator 220 NY 309 368 consent lien s49S a 163 NY 37 56 62 d32M 43 M 85 M 7 AC 478 564 407 453 602 669 278 241 41lD 172 NY 66 69 391 60 LRA 317 petition inequality 143 818 373 assessment 49S 484 49 564 376 assessment s 49 S 489 a 164 NY 605 179 NY 290 383co-sery,t neg 49 S 481 183NY 50 54LRA127nl78n 388 infants s49S r 160 NY f33 14 AC 72n 494 578 642 74n 38 do 70 78 84 103 practice 60 M demurrer 134 burden 180 376 25 26 224 486 455 434 proof 269 510 120 184 308 397 character s 49 S 704 119 360 spec, instance 39 CP 343 spec, miscondt. 390P 343 compet. ev. 138 681 reputation do 138 683 414 indorsemnt s49S full value 31 105 ea2M 8 AC SAC 542 405 24 498 226 226 227 229d presumptioE 125 ■MU renewal 179 278 428 suspension s49S 605 34 391 53 587 26 M 535 30 M 363 7 AC 19n 20n vested rights 28 M 337 construction 57M 51 432 rent basis 8 49S 546 * 156 NY 678 38 M 207 76 33 M 160 NY 252 515 382 385 46 1 objections S50S 29 M attachment 45 M verification 49 M defit. judg't 16AC waiver C4M estoppel "IM 982 574 418 306 446n 595 109 465 master neg. 8 51 S 5 42 402 54LRA117nl42n assumed risk 45 92 177 475 rent b49 3 a 165 NY fiduciary a75M: 479 enforcement 394 312 859 718 179 120 701 587 590 365 324 s49S a 164 NY 65 81 10 AC mileage books 31 323 8 AC 18611 penalty 8 AC 189n 484 conclusive s 49 S 730 24 M 160 cond. precedent 118 708 49 1 confiscation s 49 S 862 c 54 148 151 insolvt. assoc'n 499 recitals 3 49 S 722 7AC 379n discovery 55M 32 501 rovers, error 54M evidence 198NY earnings 74M value 88 113 438 remedy s4gs r 162 NY 29 M 627 12 373 447 consent s 49 S 1052 a 155 N Y 39 101 mortgage 101 relief 75 94 59 LRA , shareholder 113 stockholders 16AC 489 565 23 176 745 149 36 535 negligence s 50 S 63 s 37 631 45 591 ordinary care 89 97 do 89 318 e 95 120 res ipsa lonuitur 48 M 530 59 M 37 547 accruing s 49 S 1049 a 164 NY 224 34 M 627 55 1 improvments b49S 31 52 accounting 31 M partition 116 equity 126 no defense 68 M off set 164 987 533 254 226 812 6S3 269 709 569exceptn rule s SO S 957 145 140 57 1 superior neg s 49 S .734 117 65 blasting neglig. 1 LEANS 669n 577 durese s49S d30 do 30 33 26 M 26 M voluntary 78 M 622 469 475 354 48 567 655 58 1 enf orcemt. s 49S 136 85 M default 80 M 521 6 494 164 583 rape 8 50 S 984 a 156 NY 694 corroboration illicit relations 62 LRA 331n do 152 442 621 check case 4 s49S a 163 NY claim' case 7 s49S a 165 NY 622 appeal case 12 s4gS a 164 NY game law case 13 s 49 8 r 164 NY 623 appeal case 14 s49S 74 costs ease 18 8 49S f64 1134 397 1140 70 1149 609 1144 162 1133 233 1133 567 VOL.26 I ultra vires 8 49S 34 62 f 66 e26M 33 M 8 injunction s49S 755 106 503 625 6S8 203 527 922 399 264 573 676 624 injunction case 17 s 49 8 1138 a 156 NY 169 625 foreclose case 1 b49S s 158 NY a 161 NY appeal case 2 s49S a 155 NY appeal case 19 8 49 8 a 162 NY 1136 676 580 1138 695 1149 653 212 NY 629 hab, corpus case 1 s 49 S 599 57 149 interpleader case 2 s 49 S 512 55 614 630 sp.m prfce. case 1 s52S r 162 NY negligence case 3 8 SOS e84 appeal case 7 s50 8 488 336 1124 38 253 a 162 NY 1124 653 s49S 29 100 131 curtesy 15 AC 853 44 86 116 230d 917 601 110 604 680 656 unenforceable 175 279 514 estoppel s 49S 955 184 . 337 5 1 8burden proof s49S 38 M 521 charge s49S g 25 700|a 163 NY 382l34 M 949 586 1077 627 568 777 590 exception s 49 S * 163NY 35 177 e 15fi NY 48 M waiver 213 NY 596 new trial s 49 S 921 s 156 NY 680 603 requests s 50 8 426 38 66 29 M 772 d 29 M 773 !tl M 472 29 CP 149 6 1 marriage « 49 S 803 45 M 274 16 AC 9n character f 84 M 673 631 appeal case 1 sSOS a 163 NY appeal cases 2 and 3 1 2 reference s49S r 156 NY 77 vesting 24 M judgmtfinal 27 M confirm report 34 M 124 s 156 NY 404 33 CP 171 constructiop HI 661 class distribution 186 NY 133 divesting 75M 372 22 negligence 8 49 8 34 M SIM 26 surplus s49 8 »156NY 30wiU 8 49S *156 NY 28 f28 distribution 51 M dismissal 17AC 176n 177 244n construction 765 516 35 984 1071 684 361 62 536 191NY 38 reply s49S 27 275 1076 20 1125 669 sSOS a 163 NY appeal case 22 8 50 8 a 163 NY appeal case 25 s60 8 a 165 NY ch'nge venue case 29 a SOS e3S appeal case 30 3 50 8 a 164 NY 1125 570 1134 568 1135 650 1127 187 1130 607 40 authority s49 8 670 s 38 299 300 32 M 659 46 employer neg s 49S 669 65 LRA 64« 48 contr. neg s 49 S 868 r 161 NY 317 33 224 57 pers injury s49S 30 85 waiver 53 M prejudiced 185 610 394 59 562 916 825 632 streets case 9 sSOS r 156 NY 60 prepond ev. 8 49 S °"' 31 M 64 practice 3 SOS d62 30 CP 73 libel 3 49 8 44 M 209 609 377 894 30? 76 notice 1132 8 49 8 570i2g 615 507 ABBRE'VIATIONS : a, afSrroed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, ""•'»• c, triticised ; I, limited ; e. explained ; o, overruled ; s, aame case ; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel caae ; q, questioned N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division Vol. 26 359 iOin 64' 252 61» 38 pub. lettlne e69 e88 2SM illegality 33 M Btrict compliance fl06 459 damages 198NY 411 84 weight ev e49S 31 M 509 91 surrender s 49S 677 f 221NY 178 95 naeas. dam B 49 S 761 a 163 NY 665 28 M 227 1 1 reference 8 49 S 624 24 M 393 105 lease Msal 811 632 420 s49S a 165 NY 63 merger 69 454 parol evidence 31 M 258 repairs 48 M 609 counterclaim 16 AC 460d exception 181 618 coUat. promise 180 767 132 540 344 183 I 10 draft s49S a 165 NY bank's duty 46 54 1 23 dam neg B 60 S 190 f 94 30 CP 154n 274 1 25 pleading s 49 S 840 32 584 I 40 tax payer s 49 S 1088 f34 552 25 M 648 injunction 26 M 270 taxpayer's action 1 67 accord 3 49 8 *158 NY 23M 6 AC 698 711 360 286r< 1 7 1 replevin s 49 S 867 f 26 626 1 73 contract 9 49 S 903 s 156 NY 681 a 164 NY 582 1 76 injunction s49S 53M affidavit 34 62 44 M 53M 28 CP 20 CP 964 397 247 518 411 397 229 230 61 by complaint f 161 624 97 M 183 1 77 pleading 1033 107 852 251 4 156 170 100 15 s4gs 84 114 36 M 131 defense 106 120 132 71 M counterclaim 168 228 1 9 1 administn s 49 S 1026 42 M 461 estoppel 134 79 f 61 M 454, 455 200 negligence s 49 S 901 s 38 632 202 set off s 49S 971 G4M: 48 counterclaim 136 497 208 services 3 49 S 915 72 115 e 35 M 456 cond. precedt covenant repair 178 NY 461 16AC 4Sln 455 16AC 462n damages 100 183 31 M 43 M 58 M 90 M 10411 104M 69LRA tenant 51 M assume risk 131 ICPNS duty landlord TDM 231 complaint 89 M 569 no duty 182 821 2 1 3 vote on st s 60 S 95 47 M 206 vested right 129 348 stockholders 187 680 right transfer 143 ISO 2 I 7 attachment 496 543 722 26 539 384 84 586 683 614 11 313 trade name { 169 849 62 M 362 material's mens 169 849 285 discretion s 49 S 687 a 163 NY 493 46 489 292 aUmony a 49 S 612 6 AC 187n 7 AC 249n 257d 802 3 49S damages 48 do 48 69 973 241 243 138 31 M 96 M 1 44 trust s49S m 163 NY 60 76 27 M 214 NY 208 30 745 417 339 69 44 484 ( 56 procuring cause s 49 S 663 152 757 I 58 sp prfmce. 8 49 S 908 8 42 620 good title 8 AC 451d 110 2 1 rent s49S 38 e38 measure dam. 100 47 M repairs e76 31 M f 90 M tort 76 93 negligence 99 165 23 M 31 M e32M 1 64 leave sue e 49 S 953 33 120, set aside 76 84 M 63ll 363 962 442 443 499 385 416 776 629 454 359 419 274 93 633 349 681 master safe plare 109 792 contract not tort 101 2 106 271 145 822 pers. mjunes 72 178 179, 3 1 I relief s 49 S ejectment 130 219 ♦155 NY 693 llAC164n 166d 3 1 4 assessment s 49 S 798 26 317 objection 44 308 309 45 259 30 CP 237 inadequacy 45 damages 139 value land 71 M 'profits T4M 'nadmissible 74 M 111 compensation 623 276 486 toe 340 prob cause s 49S 799 134 140 p 144 730 31 M 383 rules of law 144 728 error court 156 445 for court 181 262 347 alimony 3 49 S 781 8 AC 187n 7 AC 242n-248n 349 injunction a 49 S 742 24 M 86 use name 169 848 353 b, partic. 3 49S e79 96 122 6 AC 679 40 41 164 610 221 n 2 1 9 cunsiderat'n 49 S 966 80 107 9 AC 203n 225 construction s 49 S 969 29 267 5 AC 305 310n 228 hab. corpus r 50 S 66 3 167 NY 110 53 LRA 361 237 factor lien s 50 S 23 58 316 24 \ considration s 49 S 652 35 605 255 contract s 50 S 12 a 163 NY 556 261 justification a 49 S 634 155 NY 615 49 379 f68 42 80 293 pun. damages 96 468 97 423 14 AC 218n 15 AC 212 276 "mitigating' ' 140 314 146 392 395 plea brood as charge 141 310 instructions do 149 168 for jury 86 M 227 I 169 3 1 6 award S.49S a 159 NY 319 ouster s49S 1 207 NY 322 356 pleading s 49 S 786 39 425 45 559 360 right of way s 51 S 661 153 446 363 ev ft'aud 49 S a 164 NY 81 833 113 145 685 533 290 322 improper re, marks a49S 88 e24M e28M 793 371 121 127 326 just com- pensation s49S 138 not final 159 795 172 667 279 injunction 49 S 938 12 231n 419 29 M |28CP 327 damages 49 S 25 M 330 use s49S 147 877 112 proper 779 22e 333 neg. dam. 8 49 S 785 a 161 NY 636 54 LRA 78n 336 negligence 3 49 S 796 36 311 312 134 258 amendment d 47 326 82 436 request error 30 M 419 31 M 472 difference 134 reversal 134 variance 186 258 259 372 waiver 8 49 8 a 165 NY 36 submission 49 delivery 60 cond. precdent 62 M 549 381 profits s49S s36 814 608 464 479 429 739 434 386 master neg 3 49 S 906 r 163 NY 627 46 426 427 54 LRA 105d 39 1 fact question s 49 S 777 72 472 395 evidence '8 49 8 c 79 dl2 AC good will 121 683 378 284 218 398 assignment s 49 8 874 8 5 AC 227 ratification 149 803 402 sp. prfmce 8 49 8 a 163 NY 119 stat. frauds d 115 parol agree't do 119 37 CP no trust d 133 in trust do 133 694 696 fraud relief 135 462 788 674 566 95 659 343 693 enforcement 202 NY 33 equity powers 84 M 300 ratification 84 M 310 408 practice s 49 8 929 30 383 113 274 49M 603 renewal U7 253 abrogations 59 M 330 4 1 3 ejection 8 60 8 79 13 AC 59n 60n 420 lien fixture 3 60 8 197 129 493 434 repairs H 60 8 98 do 64 301 445 subornation s 60 8 63 a 156 NY 561 ev other crimes 62 LRA 210n 276n competent ev. 117 618 447 authority 8 50 8 71 32 M 659 451 contr. nee 3 50 8 85 30 446 87 666 negligence 121 728 487 negligence 8 60S 28 do 37 46 a 47 do 47 65 LRA 65 LRA own relieved do 130 assumption 65M liability 155 181 f 93 M 217 NY not liable 159 authority 159 369 441 97 545 428 431 436 437 636n 637n 466n 639 508 590 100 59 387 127 618 499 foreclosure 8 60 8 h36 laches 75 deceit do 92 276 355 366 420 5 1 5 arrest B 50 8 299 87 223 false repres 13 13 AC 468 5l8contrib. 5 50 8 76 M neg. 518 608 455 fraudulent 5 50 S 55 76 M 640 competency 150 406 456 negligence 3 50 8 77 f 26 621 460 chg e. venue 226 68 8 60 8 88 117 discretion do 89 demand 8AC affidavit f 127 venue 183 625 348n 576 462 power sale s50 S 298 e 101 100 124 608 mandatory 152 325 464 non-user 8 50 S 647 a 164 NY 660 218 NY 98 13 AC 246n 246n distinction 164 844 accepted 174 484 470 2d offense 8 50 S 377 a 156 NY . . 541 prior conviction 195 NY 194 indictment 68 M 308 former convictn 154 487 522 hurd. proof s 60 S 629 f 168 793 527 assessment s50 S e 99 . d45M taxable 135 523 277 14 646 532 fore close 8 50 8 542 3 30 622 a 158 NY 668 surplus costa 119 212 surplus money 193 NY 440 not sufficient 149 838 535 incompt. ev a 50 S 516 126 230 542 tax corpn 60 8 680 e 165 NY 340 544 expert wit- ness 8 50 8 729 14 AC 367n extra fees 59 M 115 550 false repres 8 60 S 495 1 32 627 8 32 631 counterclaim 82 627 120 501 553 enoraocht. s 50 8 , 905 SAC 8n 559 negligence 3 50 8 434 43 376 46 286 ABBREVIA'TIONS : a, affirmed; d. distinguished; f. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; ♦, dismissed; n, nota; c. criticised; I. limited; e. explained; o, overruled; s, same case: do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q, questioned Vols. 26, 27 N. Y. Supreme Court Keports — Appellate Division 584 fine s 50 S 483 a 157 NY 681 t 35 624 632 d37 23 imprisonment e 23 M 478 570 presumption B 50 S 337 53 635 31 CP 119 sell property 142 BOS 573 assignment « 50 S • 568 rl 54 172 creditors suit 60 , , 279 24 M ■ 299 62 M 640 intervene 150 245 do 150 245 58 I compensn s 50 S 473 a 164 NY 592 36 327 extra pay 121 133 rewards 86M 90 6 1 5 misapproptn B 50 S 294 t 28 623 55 8 demand jury d 24 M 500 accounting 29 authority 35 250 trust duties 135 47 514 584 submission a 50 S 334 32 39 587 review 8 50 S 432 63 319 exceptions 59 625 588 res judicata B 50 S 626 26 523 conversion e 23 M 583 estoppel 74M,, 53 conclusive f 209 NY 44R 592 certiorari s 50 S 424 93 476 595 damageB B 50 S 421 30 222 54 595 constr notice SO M 697 e 43 M 147 reversible error 111 22 incompt.. ev 127 905 600 collision s 50 S 333 40 316 29 M 122 paramt use st 40 318 603 consent s 51 S 678 141 739 144 662 limit liability 170 735 6 1 4 affidavit s SO S 209 39 506 f 42 622 53 97 1 59 628 26 M 865 f 28 M 784 d 36 M 159 443 255 620 exceptions s 60 S 636 53 319 623 bill partic. case 1 3 49 S 662 123 492 159 581 19A0 lOn case 2 s 49 a 937 6 AC 221n 624 pleading case 2 s 49 S 933 13 AC 361n appeal case 3 B 53 S 206 a 163 NY 588 625 appeal case 16 s50S 1132 * 155 NY 693 628 preference case 1 a 51 S 1142 case 3 s 5XS 1149 8 AC 487n appeal case 4 3 51 S 1141 s 167 NY 688 r 164 NY 481 VOL. 27 I Bup answer B 60 S 159 1 62 626 f 64 633 d 102 249 discretion do 95 625 d 34 M 623 3 fact question 50 S 105 6 AC 224 51 500 7 certificate 3 50 S 187 66 245 26 M 713 7 AC 460n 461n negligence 76 417 do 97 64 do 99 420 f 170 586 31 M 776 revers. error 76 454 remedies 16AC 453n not liable f 168 670 1 neg,. damages s 60 S 215 8 40 397 do 40 390 1 8 friv answer s 50 S 108 f 67 600 73 146 37 M 840 38 M 119 22 damages s 60 S 261 a 164 NY 187 167 NY 106 38 313 30 new trial s50S 111 94 188 43 M 611 i 94 M 655 3 1 director s 50 S 266 r 166 NY 1 38 160 52 497 f 29 M 468 48 negligence s SOS 207 a 161 NY 657 34 493 54 LRA 63n 78n competent ev. 113 449 52 negligence 8 SO S 284 77 164 94 395 67 st limitation 9 60 S 166 r 160 NY 483 80 director 8 60S 318 r 103 NY 380 s 64 206 comp. evidence s 54 209 210 s 101 390 87 contract s 50 S 123 a 165 NY 613 e 46 622 conclusive do 77 240 90 affidavit s 50 S 132 44 413 d 76 . 71 jurisdiction 70 M 578 mitsatioQ 42M 21 merits 44 M 311 8 5 AC 311 irregularity 54M 62 attachment 128 604 97 defect complt 8 60S 116 el 08 240 99 domicile 3 SOS 135 42 102 8 AC 262n 13 AC 372n 70 LEA 696n place trial 16AC 162n chge. venue 119 16AC 167n 171n 39 CP 340 I 03 mortgage s 50 S 93 a 163 NY 576 1 2 I commissions ■5 50 8 113 f 27 622 discovery 73 624 39 M 248 1 23 contempt costs s 608 126 107 528 conclusive t 95 M 261 l25incomp ev 8 50 8 153 96 379 1 33 contract 56 LRA 636n 136 s 50 S 175 184 940 137 costs sSOS 838 40 402 44 revivor 3 50 S 536 r 157 NY 100 33 466e 467 laches 58 249 s 157 NY 672 1 45 extra allowc 8 50 S 516 106 128 1 46 bona fide a 50 8 748 aieiNY 632 declarations 116 543 158 estoppel s 50 8 419 111 881 guaranty 66M 165 sureties 145 106 1 60 preference s 50 S 622 46 563 120 383 150 669 26 M 433 28CP notice 68 185 45 M 63M: 264-271 322 804 172 379 strict practice e 23 M 604 24 M 108 38 M 45 46 d 6 AG 20 waiver 48 187 117 476 8 AC 488 38 CP 268 when made 66M ■ 230 1 62 mortgage sSOS 476 b31S 630 3 5 625 recover share f 168 154 1 69 master neg s 50 S 417 s82 624 34 61 e 23 M 531 54 LRA 45 n 811 1 73 costs 8 60 8 663 * 160 NY 696 37 627 58 98 995 quan. meruit 70 130 133 134 97 369 services 1 SAC 285 opinion 71 624 d 85 234 limitation 182 NY 272 34 CP 37 compensation 116 211 claim 35CP 37 njunction S5M 35 1 80 preference 8 SO S 676 r 167 NY 166 36 22 stockholders 46 317 d 24M 431 1 86 n discd. ev b50 S 618 73 494 76 360 100 221 185 110 new trial 2] 1 6AC 122n 1 90 relief 8 60 8 697 28 383 384 40 344 adv possession 29 180 18 74M 21 damages 42 618 25 M 14 e 36 M 501 48 M 130 f 1 62 NY 229 208 agency s 60 S 604 suspension 33 123 8 43 68 219 injunction 3 61 S 93 61 M 131. 132 covenants 162 703 patentable 185 425 240 reUef 8 60 8 191 S C. jurisdictD 31 176 assault 70 202 scope employmt 29 M 66 27 CP 371 law question 104 385 105 625 248 evidence s 50 S 692 a 163 NY 573 265 award s 50 S 62) a 168 NY 721 40 524 130 155 270 neg dam B 508 457 r 133 NY 461 54LRA 115n 163 279 serv. sum. s 50 8 471 114 464 claim vs. lunatic 19AC 79n, 80 leave court 73 M 75 282 restriction 8 SOS 584 f71 616 76 597 163 361 d 37 M 442 65. M 336 e 180 NY 427 70 LRA 74n covenants 20 AC 69n 285 deduction B 50 S 623 r 160 NY 607 38 421 290 contract 3 SO S 664 a 163 NY 568 293 law action s 50 S 670 59 M 622 299inadmissible 3 50 S 257 f 172 754 305 ne gl igence s SO 8 87 69 398 inspection — S3 54 LRA 129n 161n liability 157 183 309 contract 8 50 8 168 b67 248 rule damages e 74 172 173 99 192 f 172 105 172 100 3 1 2 demurrer s 50 8 950 104 197 3M 637 16AC 238 24 In defense 132 100 126 677 42 M . 412 51 M 623 3 1 6 conversion 9 50 8 69S e 28 M 568 defense 91 M 34 3 1 8 chge venue ; SO S 166 67 342 9 27 M 587 affidavit 120 624 326 Adiron Pk 9 60.« 3b do 39 injunction 25 M 245 37 43 86 345 contract 3 49 8 1041 88 486 101 307 discharge 116 492 do 124 117 f 85 M 446 353 investigatn, 3 60 S. 366 r 167 NY 78 69 LRA 608n Btrct. constrctn 88 M 227 371 disbarment 3 50 8 163 7 AC 6n 374 alienation 3 60S 3 60 240 incompet ev d66 246 motive 71 M 676 llful intent 178 164 376exclus.cl 50 8 191 d86 If 379 dismissal 960 220 384 2 412 9 SO 8 a 163 NY 52 eq relief 34 M compliance 186 NY performance 149 199 383 penalty 3 49 S 1127 a 165 NY 274 f88 147148 repeal 26 M 218 overcharge fare 14 AG 7n 387 election 9SCS 5 a 156 NY 680 60 594 lOlM 634 392 chge. benefie 3 50 8 470 14 AC 190n ruling court 183 148 400franchise tax 9 60 S 302 a 158 NY 666 404 statute SOS 275 135 758 compliance 179 816 427 conversion 9 50 8 550 ABBREVIATION'S: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; c- criticised ; 1, limited ; e, explained ; o, overruled : s, same case ; do, dissentinz opinion ; p, parallel case : q. questioned N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division Vols. 27, 28 69 245 5 1 contract s62 627 s SOS 511 ]^astifn burden 1 129 406 124 79 27 M 41 M culpable neg asM commissions 38 M 50 M Stat, compenstn. 1 77 M 302 exr. burd. proof 10 AU 196nl98n 49 M 400 presumption SOM conipe-nsation 175 301 waiver 127 78 M 161 1 5 1 7 inconsistent 8 60 S 609 26 M 651 479 496 123 f 173 no relief 86 M 95 M 438 trust S50S » 158 NY 6 520 175 38 341 128 447 juatificatioQ s 60 S 82 25 M 74b 452 interpldr. 363 64-1 249 366 142 279 S60S e78 102 455 taxatio sSOS 64 42 M e6AC 57 LRA 91n 92n 457 serv, proc. B SO S 329 44 M 172 notice trial 6 AC 306n ILRANS 836d extend time 18AC 146u no waiver 71 M 144 fraction day 71 M . WK irregular elOO f 109 e 182 NY 15 AC power court do 138 777 correct record 69 M 420 no valid verdict 801 684 684 293 96 464 contract s60S 43M pleading 133 691 18 71 470 exemption '3 50 S 583 13AC 367n 474 transfer tax s SOS 586 52M 446 520 prooate s50S a 160 NY 66 mandatory 86 opinions 36 M direct verdict 99M 252 set aside 99M 255 527 revocation s 60 S 497 a 166 NY 407 e 26 M 304 restrictions 33 M 247 certif property 9 AC 464n-4S9n 530 injunction s 50 S 506 d 63M 391 535 rape ev. s 60 S 674 r 162 NY 632 88 198 201 62 LRA 33 Sn corroborative 22SNY 494 56 1 revocatioo 50 S 640 a 166 NY 691 46 39S construe rule 47 113 169 626 7 AC 14nign25ii libl. constctn. 368 143 488 448 f 175 621 costs case 1 SOS 82 28 M counsel fees 9 AC 496 160 46 260 492 628 chat mtge b60S 314 r 161 NY 356 61 foreclosure e 26 M 706 630 discretion case 3 3 SO S I S2 6 right offset 185 63 1 appeal case 4 8 SOS a 164 NY tax city case 17 a SOS a 157 NY aopeal case 20 s50S * 156 NY 193 113U 661 1132 42 1133 677 133 295 71 577 wages 3 SOS 35 liens 85 implied repeal 15 AC 134n 94 M 42 584 new disc ev SO S 637 7S 9 590 mortg. Bale s SO S 499 66 64 480 insurance 1 593 removal 8 60S 626 s SOS 520 49 476 476 71 _ 429 do 170 NY 67 LRA review 16AC 37 327 373 37 M 398 597 new trial bSOS 53 3SltI 500 spec damage sSOS 848 7 AC 177 NY 62! „, 14 AC 304! 804 award |bSOS 506 discretion i57 s50S * 168 NY 165 37 M 100 renunciation 771 226 684 l£6o IOCS 445 872' counterclaim 713I132 277 168 1 712 6 1 2 construction 483 s 50 S 776 ■ 157 NY 704 632 dower case 5 sSOP a 162 NY tax case 6 3 SOS a 168 NY allegations 39CP petition suffic. 39CP 137i! 1131 130 1132 162 137 VOL.28 scienter s SO S 780 93 408 representation SO M 194 7 exrs, trustee 50 s51S r 157 NY 42 22 affidavit 9 SOS insufficient 99 e25M 27 M 29 M 7 AC 27 259 175 735 22 449 827 676 283 62 25 adv poss'n. s 60 S 902 36 626 30 affidavit 3 SOS 28 62 155 d7J 53M bond 93 place of trial 27 M certiorari 27 M penalties d35 venue 108 38 CP 1004 623 158 399 600 23 33 31 39 227 11 63 37 negligbuce 16AC 373n'e38M 680 conclusive constitutional f 178 199 12 AC 74n302n ' 303n s50S 71 86 65 LRA 491n 635n 66 LRA rule liable 117 liability 155 52 C D act s52S s 156 NY a 164 NY 59 open com- mission 3 SOS 1032 292 23 479n 043 051; 75 insurance a 61 S 84 a 163 NY 677 81 good faith s SO S 1067 3 SO 423 9 I limitation 3 60 S 920 39 8 AC 203n application ISO 462 94 liable s 50 S 1016 t 91 M 414 clear notice 182 722 1 03 fd transfer 3 51 S 147 53 427 428 vacation 75 282 109 atty fees 3 50 S 885 s 163 NY S8S I 1 5 discharge 8 SOS 43 40 M 220 FT 320 NT pleading 81 debt revival f47M 869 58 235 166 167 474 148 182 18S 537 304 677 501 272 726 fee disctd sts 87 do 87 95 e42M * 156 NY f 166 NY damages 119 do 131 eminent domain 127 618 compensation 130 526 f 217 NY 159 award 197NY 519 street closed 149 64 216 NT 11 constitutional 173 37 220 confidence 151 113 title grantor 467 merger 153 172 I 1 9 brokerage B SO S 989 * 159 NY 624 ! cond. prcdt. 131 878 intention 225NT 516 590 181 661 600 60 guaranty 3 SOS 29 64 interpleader 8 50 S 842 35 172 40 501 162 198 « 26 M 287 2? l27Suuday sal liquor 8 50 S 977 61 „ 601 46 M 498 pleading proof 63 207 28 M 409 revocation 7 AC 22 25n 135 affidavits s 508 874 148 239 1 38 removal s SO S 919 27 M 155 1 40 material 8 SO S 909 36 534 25 M 214 612 1 60 negligence s 50 S 843 e 60 681 183 contrttcf 9 51 S 79 9 64 396-390 3 66 532 rl61 NY 513 1 70 new matter sSOS 886 42 16 damages 47 59 8 up. plead g e 77 344 8AC 275n 30 CP 178 discretion 79 585 1 73 performance s SO S 880 a 169 NY 527 1 76 negligence > SOS 846 42 254 44 499 70 350-364 113 528 promise master 80 466 e 174 NY 396 396 question fact 99 S 248 181 injunction 8 60 S 947 38M 39 40 681 40 M 8 86 new trial e 60 S 972 83 473 29 CP i,o£jtfo, _i.-c 204NY 287 2?,,'^^'^'"'^''*;,^ ! (5M 175 88 bailment l^^'SP**'"" 51 n 8 60 8 974 27 M 310 174 461 7 AC lln ISn 28 M burden deft. 36 M bailee 103M 72 appeal s60S • * 157 NY 14 AC 30 CP 55 LRA 73 review 3 SOS 35 179 180 893 706 235n 377 128n 180 92 ministerial 48 M f 91 M remedy exclu've ■ 35 184 897 431 d 69 M certificate 209 NY 143 title 8 52S al57 NY d41 construction 86 127 128 discretion 56 133 588 409 592 SO s 78 M valuation 85 M f 85 M opinion 103M 1074 179 327 329 14 227 wife nee 8 60 S 884 r 165 NY 289-291 38 129 228 neg. dam. 3 51 S 13 r 161 NY 659 fact question 104 605 238 rent b60S a 164 NY 1107 659 246 contr neg. b50S a 163 NY 43 53 92 do 122 do 133 23M notice 36 M fact question 1088 Sr76 137 144 158 17 909 698 222 170 534 534 650 661 1 9 I brokerage s50S 80 entries ev, 9 AC 876 118 ISOn 1 99 devise sSOS a 163 NY presumption 77 M 443 1079 678 209 revocation b50S 7 AC 2 1 3 fire ins. 3 60S a 160 NY 143 24n 106 due care 145 great care 145 i 83 M for jury 75M duty landlords 151 653 152 460 253 evidence 8 60 S 1063 s 42 620 d 45 191 protest notice 46 e32M 92 M SAC e7AC 79 596 361 533 108n 110 63M 346 duly addressed 89 M 311 92 M 366 264 demurrer sSl S 68 26 M 158 s44 38 particularity attachmt, merits 110 336 conjplaint S7M 343 26 M 168 272 compet ev 68 190 73 134 443 922 695 3 51 S do 129 280 costs 8 SIS m 162 NY construction r64 e 183 NY 450-452 292 direction s 51 S 36 25 M 749 30 1 calendr pref, 8 SO S 1002 8 AC 491n 304counterclaim B 50 S 102 a 158 NY 72 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d. distinguished; f. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; •, dismissed; n not* e, criticised; I, limited; r. explained ; o. overruled: 5, same case; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case: q, questioned Vols. 28, 29 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division 308 demurrer b51S 8 47 583 25 M 547 3 1 I filing s 51 S 64 60 624 26 M 675 fraud transfer do 66 433 3 1 9 construction solS 10 eS3 216 82 345 163 278 d 29 M 717 vesting 33 M 309 706 good title 129 632 divesting 138 814 residence 82 M 191 326 contract s 51 S 268 8 62 417 cond. precdt. 136 464 328 damaees 8 51 S 377 s 49 645 646 28 M 439 8 170 NY 28S 296 298 33 CP 16 45 M 130 irrevocable 116 109 132 291 rescission 37 CP 371 186 77E 34 1 neg pregnt s51S 152 e 46 M 496 7 AC 491n conclusive 54 M 626 354 res Judicata fl 51 S 284 * 167 NY 672 f 2S 626 32 372 64 221 34 M 649 48 M 409 demurrer 29 M 557 9 AC 296n 298n iistribution 51 M 536 pleading 114 851, 8S2 do 114 854 156 328 act allegation 114 855 164 730, 731 164 732 362 lease 8 51 S 38 f61 29 M sum pro. 63 M surrender 66M 365 note ev. s51S s40 371 claim s51S *156 NY with costs f 86 M 249 624 614 98 23 157 621 138 681 644 jury trial i 99 M 110 379 damages s 51 S 290 40 344 f41 511 n 42 618 title t.74 177-179 s 108 286 f 25 M -14 f 29 M 22 f 162 NY 22 396 labor organ ization s51S 180 63 234 236 f 69 484 injunction f27M 115 29 M 247 33 M 137 picketing 39 M 58 discharge 174 250 24 M 298 public policy 174 249 404 negligence 3 51 S 145 1 29 L._ 56 407 d 89 314 427 428 do 89 433 69 LRA 329n contrib. neg. 16 AC S33n 407 care bank s 51S 140 69LRA 329n negligence 69LKA 329d 4 1 I contract 60 S 1093 8 180 NY 291 r 180NY 280 30 573 38 429 48 M 649 modification 56 491 conclusive 79 126 laches 25 M 563 28 CP 331 assignment 48 M 549 condition sales 79 M 501 433 subscriber s 53 S 188 r 165 NY 108 442 judgment 3 51S 111 101 147 s 6 AC 271 445 negligence sSlS 1 41 92 451 injunction s 51 S 186 a 165 NY 651 d 89 384 174 434 d 27 M 139 immunity ILRANS 61 n 457 prob cause s 51 S 88 do 97 424 burden proof 40 M 15 15 AC 277 46 1 damages 8 51S 112 do 32 391 discretion 34 268 court's power 68 M 187 221NY 147 463 pleading 51 S 118 e 81 214 e 28 M 118 complaint e 59 M 7 publication 20 AG 233n 467 dismissal s 51 S 128 40 604 78 66 15 AC S3]n ..push stick'" 83 5 10 AC 282n 469 replevin 3 51 S 104 50 318 470 Indians s51S 142 r 162 NY 467 164 52 29 M 432 162 NY 466 472 negligenc 8 51 S " 106 28 450 f 73 692 693 e 97 288 f 176 516 130 686 65 LKA 649n rule license do 125 645 475 supervisors 8 51S 114 a 159 NY . 567 certificate void 157 234 478 capacity s SIS 115 178 378 480 retirement 8 51S 119 63 163 82 582 485 rescission s 51 S 124 28 639 counterclaim 195 333 do 175. 616 49 M 240 54 M 594 s 5 AC 283 7 AC 380 appeal rule 116 534 omit ruling fl33 518 appl. on record 117S 631 508 malice s51 S 36 177 NY 184 libel per se 83 do 91 24 M d31 M 179 NY strike out 42 M 104M 586 491 demurrer 8 51 S 105 114 419 493 covenants s 51 S 117 20 AC 74ii 495 covenant s61S 130 96 230 consideration 29 M 254 notice 171 164 gift 180 603 504 revers. er, 8 51 S 247 63 273 31 M 265 I 275 273 114 402 210 263 239 237 163 77 ABBREVIATIONS: a, .affirmed; d, distinguished ; 17 liability _ 51 S 202 67 M 517 $50 costs 67 M 518 >I9 guaranty 51 S 206 1 60 452 52 1 supervisors power ^ 51 S 203 35 361-353 d 86 M 505 524 bridge 8 51 S 228 r 160 NY 249 tide land 64 LRA 337n 529 separation s 61 S 222 8 41 362 .140 counsel fees 165 72 e28 M 576 29 M 711 30 M 51 e 34 M 550 40 M 95 s 6 AC 292 7 AC 239 262 69 LRA 72 recovery 143 969 husband liable 150 334 not final 150 335 services 150 336 no recovery 153 294 no cause 175 830 relief 221NY 429 535counterclaim s 51 S 300 25 M 229 544 consideratn s 61 S 226 30 M 254 548 negligence s 51 S 546 553 trust 51 S 192 46 449 revocable 102M ■ 196 555 lighting s 51 S 337 do 48 32 construction 29 M 687 work 65M 95 not ultra vires 157 399 competition 105M 577 pleading s 61 8 207 60 531 case record s 65 269 8 5 AC 219 91 M 431 580 transf. tax 3 51S 331 a 159 NY 532 , 38 225 49 550 d 146 291 13 AC 353n f 160 NY 492 493 d 160 NY 494 194 NY 285 86 M 6 trust fund 66 169 170 construction do 49 554 65M 124 59 1 bonde 51 S 446 a 160 NY 635 41 M 221 mtge party 129 13 621 appeal case 3 63 S 1103 sSlS 1140 rl65 NY 420 830 appekl case 12 s62S * 166 NY 622 parol i case 1 s51S r 164 NY notice case 3 s51S * 161 NY appeal case 8 8 51S a 165 NY appeal case 9 s61S r 165 NY report case 14 sSl S a 163 NY liq'd dam. case 15 3 51S r 161 NY 1139 171 1143 629 1151 608 1147 146 1139 686 1140 47 623 checks case 12 8 61S 1149 a 164 NY 281 deposit case 29 3 51S 1140 a 166 NY 53 624 affidavit cases 5 and 6 s61S 1148 31 M 180 625 appeal case 2 8 518 1143 *167 NY 672 appeal cases 3 s60S 912 1 56 420 1 73 306 627 foreclosure cases 2 B 61 8 261 p 29 6301 VOL 29 1142 1 accounting 8 61S 323 45 365 relief 24 M 609 one bill costs 172 261 181 885 no costs 184 914 8 compens. dam. a 61 8 216 d30 622 60 112 71 204 8 6 AC 816 10 AG 472 rules 13 AC 63d construetaon 61 433 111 46 86 M 210 transfers dllS 16 52M 582 90 M 677 90 M 678 unlawful 67M 80 assault 67M 81 illegal limitatn. 67M 82 13 penalties 52M 682 transfers 52M 688 16 notice city 3 51 S 190 111 839 26 device 8 518 648 a 163 NY 478 3 1 fact question sSlS 820 41 623 37 gift delivery b61S 380 37 291 prohibition 154 364 45 lerv, process • 618 646 104 667 manag. agent 62 M 409 49 contract ■ 618 371 • 46 440 55 substitution 8 51 8 862 • 167 NY 700 BAG S16n 59 request 8 618 630 97 261 66 joinder ■ 518 891 e44 623 e77 466 S8 72 33 CP 280 election 141 849 70 amendment s61S 636 101 277 72 defense s 51S 393 183 876 .DDMn.EtV in.i.±\jiyj -. a, auiniicu^ u, Qisunguisnea ; f. followed ; r/'reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; c, criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, dissenting opinion; p, ied; *, dismissed; n, note; 1. parallel case ; q, questioned N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division Vol. 29 75 verification a61S 33 4S objeotion 35 M wmiver 49 knowledge do 174 80 appeal • 61S 29 penalties 76 M 388 642 662 601 666 712 886 62 166 distribution 244 roinatate 9 51 3 51 M e 55 M partit on 61 M premature 156 1 70 partiei b61S d72 89 85 no s 51S 66M defense 804 583 95 f'd. transfer s 51 S 409 a 161 NY 63' 101 b'd&mtge 8 52 S 37 a 163 NY 486 f 97 M 42 I 1 7 statutory s 51 S 486 lo-l «87 I 1 9 partner note B 61 S 440 54 568 1 25 police powr B 51 S 482 a 164 NY 510 36 260 39 433 f 75 32 33 6 AC . 349 construction 122 75 reserved power 122 754 sky signs d 61 M prohibition 329 power city 110 good faith' 183 174 amendment s 51 S 811 112 780 18A0 127r 1 82 trustee >51S 92 429 264 105 1 3 I false answei 861S d39 49 material 76 warranty 93 oond. precedent do 100 76 1 37 certificate B 61 S 667 r 162 NY 163 81 372-376 441 266 474 272 531 I 49 libel 8 61 S rl62NY 839 100 I 60 aaeessment e51 3 114 illegal 39 27 M 111 judgment 111 jurisdiction 51 M strict constrn 124 51S certiorari 67M 649 equity suit 349 896 654 331 652 608 628 636 257 526 536 593 186 534 803 8 107 s61S mandamus 84 34 M 252 negligence B 61 S 368 a 164 NY 690 36 M 196 256 good will 104 9 61 S s38 79 12 AC 165 NY 64LRA illegal trust 64LRA conspiracy 55 M 1 9 I vesting s 51 S 1038 a 161 NY 274 205 revivor 51 S 789 79 492 burden plaintiff 74M 445 limitation 13() 15 74M 447 2 1 construction 3 51 S 862 54M . 294 separation 70 M 63, 64 divorce 30 AC residence 20 AC 26n 27n 215 burd. proof s 51 S 883 d 219 NY 414 225 reference s 61 S 652 54 364 73 508 sum remedy^ 8 AC 310n 313l atty accounting 131 455 227 authority 3 51 S 437 e 26 M 176 55 LRA 782 31 CP 343 229 presumption 5 45 S 966 s 61 S 796 66 493 40 M . 551 construction 383 31 CP 264n 32 CP 260 239 in^ unction SIS 109 33 affidavit 34 62 44 M complaint 96 109 HI 676 pendente lite 37 CP 243 laches s61 S dSlM dacovery 54M 92 M 427 552 633 247 618 168 11 562 678 73 434 219 67 295 420 239 329 573 640 376 282 552 300 712n 85 26 1 negligence 437 71 404 318n 326n s61 S 34 56 16AC 333n fact question 314 339 89 431 432 care 16AC 318n 263 waiver 8 61 S r 160 NY 42 notice d43 f 172 construction d55 s6AC copy claim 119 no authority 172 307 neg. dam. 8 61 S 430 58 663 fact question I 109 822 liability 77 M ISO 309 negligence 8 51 8 471 a 164 NY 121 29 464 3 1 8 pros cause 8 61 S 580 71 295 87 229 230 233 624 71 M 142 32 5 double tax 3 61 S 667 110 195 331 default s 51S 365 134 673 335 fact q uestion s 61 S 563 65 39 342 negligence 51 S 464 39 603 346 negligence s 51 S 413 rl 70 M 409 270 evidence 8 51 S 435 25 M 750 274 presumption 61 S 597 56 321 9 AC 403n 31 CP 208 129 196 77 M 443 validity devise 142 367 282 discovery 3 51 S 497 67 68 , 6 AC 261 84 M 264 286 award 9 51 S 576 62 272 f 165 199 rule damages 81 compensation do 56M 473 298 recovery 351S 162 NY d46 award archt, do 77 d31 M 300 warranty 416 617 622 240 751 8 51 S a 164 NY 304 usury s61 S ♦ 164 NY a 166 NY 55 penalty 117 793 693 418 476 255 572 431 6 AC 346 reverse error 45 M 680 390 revocation 8 62B 1146 8 49 S 669 46 396 7 AC 16n 20n 393 bill partic a61 S f34 38 51 affidavit 81 f 181 32 M 394inBpn book 618 1054 s 5AC 269 396 bequest 3 61 S 704 350 affidavit 467 51 8 104 d32 217 NY s5AC d6AC 6 AC 370 laches 3 518 preference 48 51 150 authority 83 practice 36 M 8 AC 8 AC 31 CP Tiotico 127 AD notice nee. i;3M 586 468 255 381 351 210 219n 642 187 379 285 495 487 490 491 492 264n 448 379 377 bequest 8 51 8 538 35 214 admr claim d 46 552 30 M 160 163 34 M 69 income gift a 221NY 386 382 negligence 61 8 560 40 M 200 385 negligence 51 8 481 31 346 73 269 liability 62 M . 272 proprietor liable 153 i14 388 negligence s 51 8 690 incompt. ev. 63 426 profits d 78 559 1079 630 119 381 442 864 443 11 AC 63n 66n reversal f 175 881 466 collision 8 61 8 724 r 163 NY 447 476 alimony d 51 S 1057 8 AC 187n 479 op default g. 103 26M 28M 40M 31CP 362 357 470 111 112 459 154 156 construe will 117 714 18 AC 7n foreign statutes 74M 442 159 703 perpetuities 90 M 97 403 contract 55LKA 634n sp. performance 93 M 665 418 discharge 3 51S 962 1 16 49: 420 assumed risk 8 51 8 a 169 NY 106 f 29 428 evidence 620 659 414 629 8 51 8 * 157 NY 432 wiU 3 618 9 31 1 165 NY 439 conversion 1083 366 1097 627 66 697 697 511 153 5Bt 302 303 51 S i 160 NY 38 61 liability 118 f 93 M 93 M trust duties 135 449 composition 951 8 977 a 164 NY 604 453 alienation 51 S 963 d 69 320 69 684 separate clause 133 15S 455 amendment 52 8 i * 167 NY 40J 459 review 9 51 S 72 damages f 73 1092 323 318 carrier neg, 59 W 414 reversal f 134 259 559 note s51S 1018 cond delivery 8 61 8 8 6 AC 50 M 483 waiver 9 61 8 106 59 f 164 164 eSOM 9 6 AC 7 AC 193 NY proper 164 privilege e 164 50 1 notice 9 51 8 r 162NY 38 1078 29 50 985 361 369 626 631 707 22 3501. IS witness 637 628 41 45 presumption 60 enforceable 63 authority 100 568 demurrer a 618 1012 33 126 75M 256 construction 51 new cause SAO vlcading 148 no issue 148 585 construction 720 446 359 507 contempt 9 51 S 797 1 149NY 520 1 162 NY 50 9I44 222 223 alimony modfn 7 AC 179n 5 i 3 truat 3 52 8 f39 43 M demurrer 77 38 M b urden proof 117 remainder 147 260 634 484 394 166 711 431 524 neg. dam. 3 518 710 4B 104 68 lln 15 AC 327 city negligence 126 54) weight evidence 180 590 539 incompt ev' "518 * 156 NY 84 • do 28 M surplusage L29 634 095 498 757 398 542 neg. snow 642 500 316 144 676 556 11 AC 53n 66n31 M 8 518 r 169 NY 546 fire ins 9 63 8 96 AC 3 160 NY a 16?. NY waiver 226NY 552 intervention s 51 S 1089 48 M 481 party defendant 160 279 558 fact question s 51 8 1066 91 376 AHURKVIATIONS: ! c. criticised ; 1, limited ; , affirmed; d, distinguished; e* explained : o, overruled ; ■ f, fol lowed ; same case •475 177 240 416 484 67 390 279n 648 649 s61S r 158 NY d24M 6 AC 57 LRA 59 I carrier s51 8 24 M carrier lien 119 innkeeper 64M 487 168 682 166 46p 636 87 82 597vacate publn a 51 S 943 189NY 452 lis pendens 123 530 GOO weight ev s618 177 55 634 61 41 85 205 107 573 10 AC 103 reversal error 113 477 131 394 17 AC 231n 23^ conclusive 63 M 147 602 notice entry 3 518 178 124 99 604 assessment 8 51 8 854 r 164 NY 258 165 NY 155 609 assign mtg. 5 51 8 529 50 138 6 I 2 time book s 51 S 688 a 166 NY 566 'reasonable time" 617 3 61 S a 173 NY e38 Infant' 93 limitations do 130 220 224 155 441 680 681 538 HI 823 damages case 2 63 S 671 49 16 reversed ; j - ■ ™. modified; *, dismissed; n, no'e- do, dissenting opinion ; p. parallel case"; q, questioned Vols. 29. 30 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division negligence 124 531 624 stockholder case 1 8 52S 113S a 158 NY 157 judgment case 22 aSlS 1143 a 164 NY 658 627 appeal case 8 s52S 1141 s 162 NY 662 new trial case 9 s52S 113t 39 65> a 167. NY 57C ejectment 115 10 judgment case 12 s52S 114S a 165 NY 654 msurance case 13 s52S 1136 a 159 NY 561 e64 26 verification case 14 sS2S 1143 31 M 275 by attorney 7 AC custody case 21 s52S a 158 NY judgment case 27 s52S a 164 NY surety case 31 sS2S sge r 165 NY 628 custody case 7 s53S 28 M modified £ 164 374 1144 482 1141 561 1150 441 216 1108 286 534 629 dismissal case 1 s53 S a 159 NY 102 560 630 lien case 1 s53S i a 165 NY S 33 M expulsion case 2 B 53S 1016 e 28 M 103 transfer case 3 8 52 S 1151 r 164 NY 41 63 1 contr neg case 20 s62S VOL. 3D. I injunction b61S a 160 NY 5 damages 8 51 S * 157 NY 90 768 350 763 50 267 1 4 note mtge 8 61 S 916 r 166 NY 21 41 365 equities 5 AC 369n 24 opinion s 51 S 897 e 72 269 270 Eront foot rule 39 H 293 487 assessment 109 750 43 certiorari s61S a 167 NY ripar. rights 188NY f 219 NY 77 M bulkhead 77 M 50 removal s51 S 37 8 159 NY remedy 75M 515 709 149 403 743 45 162 192 66 pers, injury s 51 S 761 47 108-109 liability 159 e33 1150 224 69 review seis a 156 NY e87 76 referee ^ 51 S 126 ultra vires 133 78 taxation s 51 S 747 a 156 NY 693 57LRA 107n 85 negligence s 61 S 776 41 161 162 fact question 694 781 693 273 779 510 516 217 492 430 a 160 NY 166 NY 14 judicial 55 imputation 48 M force of pardon 154 486 482 826 I |5time essence s 51 S 828 125 229 53M 62' notice 123 600 mark, title 224NY 349 1 2 I accounts s61 S a 162 NY a 166 NY admissions £ 218 NY inference 222NY 846 662 630 397 465 1 30 compet ev. B 51 S 478 59 624 135 civ service s61S a 167 NY 140 a 49 171 s50S 641 368 633 127 517 444 I 50 taxcorpn. 57 LRA 9lTi 1 66 negligence b61S 162 NY 82 86 a 166 NY res ipsa loquitur do 138 118 burden defend- ant 158 I 73 appeal s61S 36 e76 29 CP vacated 16 318 CP 452 3 42 55 do 65 60 87 97 13 AC 89 equities sol S * 156 NY r 169 NY 41 94 weight ev 62 S 76 costs trial 66M discretion 135 70 M new trial 150 627 29 36 272 213 451 428 749 645 137 209 26 153 369 322 106 compensate s61 S 691 541 287 40 8666 37 county courts £ 92 M 731 complaint 92 M 732 power court 95 M 94 no acceptance 106M 624 1 80 franch. tax 61 S a 157 NY 41 e66 d90 e98 e 179 NY 181 NY 57 LRA 771 676 22 160 589 687 52 336 42n 77n capital vested 134 84 taxable d 198NY 242 [ 86 discovery B 51 S 760 s 6 AC 43 6 AC 826n 1 9 I sup oomplt s 61 S 306 33 558 194 m. lien 8 61 S 1000 a 164 NY 583 99 448 1 99 atty's fees sSl S 44 6) 87 28 M 64M s6AC 7 AC e7AC e 10 AC 68S 186 540 197 304 208 165 119n 124 107 2 1 3 accounting s6lS o38 42 o68 e70 c40M limitations 170 217 609 606 267 161 404 325 457 covenants 72 M counterclaim 72 M 179 estoppel 104M 27 .741 587 f 161 3 1 8 reference 261 contingngift B 61 S 614 m 161 NY 54 nmsance 8 51B 41 90 elOl streets safe 116 1058 110 65 357 629 227inadmissible 3 51 S 1075 151 140 238 judgments 8 51 S 801 s 5AC 395 51 M 42' I vacate judgt 51M 420 24 1 mayor 1(51 S a 166 NY 32 1094 694 514 Power removal f 158NY 229 246 non £uit s 51S 933 95 84 presumption 10 AC 385n negligence 116 730 613 149 141 411 251 stay 6 51 S 34 injunction 34 28CP power vaci ' 173 253 pleading s51 S 557 85 143 42 M 9 1 AC 284n 106 287 149 468 acctg demurrer 45M 266 255brokr ccmisn 968 54fi 623 8 51S 171 45 M 256 review 61S s32 54 353 396 629 258 meas. dam 8 51 S 360 57 37 future profits 87 125 stay )6AC 456n 459n 266 covenant 3 51S e42 48 M rr. franchise e45M city's rights 63M use streets 55 M bill boards d 58M injunction do 194 NY city corpn. 136 trustee power 136 404 136 405 city powers 68 M 191 end contract 663 47 233 464 131 146 425 28 403 b51 S 36 54 85 f 114 jury trial 80 956 178 440 619 161 152 477 title 146 capacity 77 M license 153 privilege 210 NY 271 transftax 135 39 8 51 S m 167 NY 274 m. lien 8 51S a 163 NY 595 46 954 680 277 presumption 937 564 99 747 493 951 977 132 350 s51 S a 164 NY 78 " 165 do 180NY 58 LRA notice 70 LRA extension 53 M construction 120 no title 94 M 441 442 285 new trial 8 51 S 967 a 164 NY 582 do 75 609 false answer 44 M 481 305 sewer neg 61 LRA 705n personal injury 67 LRA 270n 308 negligence s 51 S 494 50 519 3 1 3 abatement B 61 S 802 51 418 appealable 264 30CP 331 3 1 6 pub policy 8 51S 49 X difference e 74 dll AC estoppel 137 973 693 317 280 321 employer s 51 S 818 89 483d 324 copy serve s 51 S 932 90 M 321 326 m. Uen s 51 S 980 a 164 NY 588 toreclose lien 149 682 162 57 334 subscription s 51 S 969 t30 317 68 170 119 564 do 567 156 277 distinction 39 M 82 s 5 AC 384 338 dower s61S 68 f 163 30 M e32M: 35 M 50 M 80 M 172 NY 12 AC intention f 163 881 389 390 358 24 666 486 426 450 387 167 355 341 by-laws s 61 S 922 67 610 511 58 256 14 AC 188d vested right 59 M 186 reverse error 59 M 186 346 contract s 52 S 1044 97 648 constitn. by-laws 43 493 58 256 70 92 81 4 355 estoppel 8 51 S 1048 51 330 d61 25 39 M 267 268 receiver 6 AC 304n 8 AC 113n contract 61 M 63 d 98 M 347 359 bankruptcy s 61 S 1003 r 165 NY 18 363 consideratn 8 51S 40 43 74 77 102 12 AC 13 AC 974 34 496 447 336 97n 269 ISOn 368 decree s 61 S 1050 a 163 NY 693 trust 59 M 144 95 M 33 34 374 mitigation 8 62S 5 82 84 stay 38 M 598 contempt 174 607 advice 174 607 378 amendmnt sSlS 928 32 439 10 AC 150 381 modification 8 51S 49 M res judicata 117 163 926 604 252 219 384oomp't prf. 8 51 S 626 £ 96 M 516 396 affidavit s 51 S 362 26 M 71 63 M 32 s 6 AC 381 401 affidavit 8 61 S 824 68 556 burden proof 126 173 404 brokerage 8 52 S 77 agency scope 40 247 57 523 enforcible 159 585 4 1 negligence s 61 S 658 r 162 N Y 62 8 61 293 rr law compliance 61 296 299 418 appealable s 51 ff 355 99 254 424 diBCre'ion s 61 S 945 83 473 87 68 434 discontin'ce s 51 S 1072 109 287 438 negligence s52S 11 41 92 84 518 87 566 447 annulment s 52 S 72 71 51 10 AC 474n475n 16AC 107n llOn 56 M 70 99 M SO full knowledge 99 M 91 453 neg rules 8 51 S 958 sf 40 38 44 6209 457 contract 53 LRA 36 41 461 alimony B 52 S 228 s6AC 193 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; e, criticised j 1, limited ; e, explained ; o, overruled : f. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed;' n, note; B, Bamer:ase ; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel cue ; q, quesliooed N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division Vols, 30, 31 6 AC 186n 7 AC 304n S9 LRA 170 enforcement 54 M 413 463 vol payment 98 M 524 bond sS2S e46 67 452 585 435 692 292 ll52S a 159 NY 42 e93 95 compliance 42 183 NY tort damages 115 60 voluntary 78 M 655 injury property 9911 500 476 counterclaim 436 170 a 52S 67 137 s5 AC 10 AC 387 412 474 232 368 420 564 438 534 burglary s 52 S 35« 143 365 536 trustee s52S 35a 44 54 65 393 90 HV 166 H?,?. 35 M 476 new trustee 200 NY 46;i adv possession 58 vw mark title 16 AC I33n 3 52 S 65 40 M 41 M 9 5 AC * 157 NY 14 AC 14 AC 48 1 amendment s52S 8 38 s25M 28 CP 19AC 20 AC stkhldr 124 331 622 249 237 294n 5n right 734 548 accounting a 52 S 360 a 164 NY 603 damages G6M 61 550 parol ev e 52 S 406 r 164 NY 266 564 injunction 486 services 8 52 S 312 a 163 NY 584 489 services s 52 S 283 a 165 NY 341 494 services 32 CP 190 not justified 143 451 498 check bank s 52 S 464 a 160 NY 190 508 strike out sS2S U7 M 157 33 s62S 30 s54 55 62 72 84 120 25 M 32 M d34M 44 M 45 M 8 AC 10 AC pleading 159 48 M discretion 51 M irrelevent 51 M conspiriicy 135 complaint 135 476 518 520 213 533 377 84 439 438 317 611 614 469 264 497 580 276 8 1 authority 392 346 172 646 275 720 148 3380 612 judgment case 4 s52S a 164 NY negligence case 5 s52S r 160 NY f41 appeal case 10 s52S w 163 NY substitution 1142 592 1143 618 voLsr I commissions s 52 S 304 97 264 114 668 29 IVI 730 title 114 569 6 bank lien 8 52 S 290 91 137 10 AC 142n vested right G4U 48 1146 560 s 160 NY review case 19 s52S a 161 NY 690 1147 353 1149 609 NY 99 27 M 433 570 60 412 197 235 487 spec performance e 44 459 580 Contract s 52 S 446 8 44 38 40 misjoinder 117 30 38 CP 406 589 creditors s 52 S 335 55 519 598 countrclm. " S 231 81 M 340 602 substitution 3 52 S 203 a 157 NY 678 622 appeal case 3 8 52S a 163 NY nusconduct case 8 8 51 S 612 27 M 326 624 unconstitutl case 1 8 53S 1111 f 176 607 due process law 09 M 401 vagrant do 144 *7 77 247 case 3 new evidence e 101 410 3 62S 1139 I I sureties s62S S6AC 235 16 authentication d 54 196 5 1 b. particulars s 52 S 530 s 6 AC 21 456 173 677 201 499 240 contingent fee 35 57 3 88 s88 29 M 34 M 7 AC 9 AC 10 AC 543 5 1 7 boycott s 52 S 481 84 439 520 weight ev 8 62 S 310 39 668 8 72 26 76 241 83 473 42 M 526 verdict to stand 110 by action 50 58 ftward UO 58 attys lien 58 services 171 NY e 185 NY 169 22 457-468 464-471 629 624 168 227 40 201 265 464 202 paymt out fund 324 506 . 3 pleading s 62 S 385 31 M 656 not control 03 M 109 compensation do 66M 473 eviction 221KY 373 abatement 221XY 873 1 6 exemp dam s 52 S 390 31 215 77 107 95 468 15 AC 212 mitigation rules 44 325 69 623 19 prerequisite s 52 382 e 123 52d 24 uridertaking s 52 S 351 44 145 e 27 M 318 e 28 M 489 9 AC 390 67 a( s a2 i 49 M commissions 138 210 NY 49 affidavit s62S 39 115 141 29 M 38 M 64M 5 A 487 867 507 140 924 376 10 86. 8 372 tency 531 303 70 inspct'n bka s52S a 169 NY 53 120 31 M 6 AC. 343 260 94 769 617 53 167 e26M 26 M d26M 8 AC 28 CP 586 352 201 204 109 348 i 39 appeal s52S a 167 NY 47 99 112 126 188 not appealable 168 836 I 46 distribution 968 628 211 373 867 76 360 25 good title e52S a 163 NY 73 124 38 M bad title 57M 30 negligence 582 248 161 704 247 84 trust deed s 52 S 819 a 161 NY 1 94 preference s 52 S 543 r 162 NY 268 41 609 5 6 AC 409 98 implied pwr. s 62 S 527 37 M 148 103 trust 8 52S a 167 NY 562 402 456 561 609 judgment s52S s88 final order 46 M interest d 172 342 467 152 645 8 52 8 39 44 97 30 M 32 M 651 600 165 656 602 262 397 -tSl 616 636 601 509 198 312 17 559 ABBREVIATIONS: a c. criticised ; 1, limited ; fact question 39 55 do 173 assumption 40 61 112 contrib. neg. 51 M 641 33 collision s 62 S 605 a 164 NY 601 28 M 179 29 M 295 180 39 receiver - 52 S 877 39 680 103 522 referee fee 17AC 197n 198n 200 n I 1 2 easement 8 52 S 533 28 M 20 1 2 I jurisdiction s 52 S 814 s 25 M 676 680 d32M 7 habeas corpus 109 534 rights children 77 M 529 compliance 209 NY 6( I25burden deft s 52 S 764 t 94 M 708 127 contract s 52 S 646 a 165 NY 618 d 45 622 62 77 s53S 167 NY f66 d30M e43M discretion 52 M not divested 141 eventual TOM 96 M surplus 96 M 166 172 573 625 26 245 85 770 275 119 15 AC strike out 44 M 302 incompt ev 162NY 103 mitigation dam. 39 626.627 satisfaction 49 266 159 751 one judgment 111 841 bill partic. 19A0 8 mental suflfering 807 estate 35 448 450 ■4M competent 154 admissible 154 2 1 6 appeal 8 52S d 158 NY 55 judgment e93 2d new trial 40 M s5 AC 225 performanc receiver notice 8 62 S 867 * 159 NY 634 39 565 698 d 37 M 774 1 72 amendment 741 634 51 52 53 465 686 176 494 662 541 ^29 462 739 52 1 33 conveyance in trust s52S 133 e 161 NY a 164 NY 37 CP Stat, frauds 115 do 133 delay do 116 no trust d 133 title vested 68 M 553 1 37 calendar practice s 62 S 772 note issue 110 922 694 636 606 348 694 101 695 s52S a 165 NY 79 e79 diBcretion 34 M 39 M 30 CP juri diction 44 do 166 court's power p51 M dismissal 118 122 accounting 122 87 M surrogate decree 37 CP -273 Sep. acctgs. 135 10 complete relief 137 571 I 80 agency s 62 S 759 s 40 466 468 60 429 insurance 91 600 602 s 167 NY 684 I 9 I compromise s 52 S 653 62 345 s 157 NY 701 a 160 NY 705 173 NY 194 199 204 cond precdt s 62 S 555 s 48 638 82 29 commissions 024 4.03 494 636 70 169 236 471 389 S52S 3 49 Proof 67 70 86 210 27 M variance 138 37 M 40 M 43 M mecfi lien US 812 56 299 62 146 351 398 324 24 804 195 18 131 228 contract s52 S 560 d 114 83 no tie margin 114 dama-fes J 137 for jury 151 84 371 653 232 performance 3 62 S 747 r 160 NY 72 238 jurisdiction e39M 2 I excess. 3 52S d 158 NY 49 97 114 0. dam 539 664 262 423 192 s52S 761 47 236 30 CP 168 injunction 127 686 not comply lOlM 293 244 harmless ev. s52S 866 11 AC 36n city duty 128 701 ecovery neg. 6iM 670 248 removal 3 52S I 167 NY 134 p36 repeal 52 e25M e26M (1 27 M 29 M 16 AC [aches 48 27 M 28 M 950 90 627 494 374 623 219 156 155 252 136a 133 Ifil 664 403 affirmed; d, distinituished ; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; • dismissed i n o«f^ .explamed: o. overruled: s. same case; do, dissenting opinion j p, paraUil ca^r^^^uSii^ Vols. 31, 32 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — ^Appellate Division 255 execution 3 1 3 possesBion s63S 87 26 M attachment 42 M demurrer 109 438 37 759 21 677 263 assessment s 52 S 921 m 167 NY 159 35 48S 271 report s52S 63 35 M 42 M waiver 131 removal 1 145 a 63 8 r 157 NY 35 covenants 109 SAC lien 35 CP 624 507 237 540 361 178 a 161 NY 42 72 688 B 6 AC 91 will executn 63 M 175 389 service corp 3 1 Sasseasmnet 872 140 242 3 251 423 278 conclusive i52S 105S a 164 NY 31 M e32M 35 M fiduciary f 86 M 773 441 636 816 197 556 funds 402 s51 S 3 53S a 168 NY a 171 US al79 US f36 60 27M 33 M 38 M 54 M capital 58 full value do 110 ev. value 198NY 320 ultra vires 281 discovery 9 62 S 766 98 151 288 defense s52S 66 86 81 24 M SAO 10 AC s52S * 159 NY as 30 M 8 6 AC 985 574 14 635 65 295 contract s 52 S . 731 a 164 NY 587 298 commision b52S 617 58 218 (wmpliance 144 798 299 kick horse s 52 S 623 152 204 302 bar b52S r 170 NY do 64 26 M 32 M 34 M d35M d37M pleading 60 damages b 60 M 817 40 96 97 357 285 184 128 478 527 374 305 discretion s 52 S 613 49 631 92 326 26 M 201 s 26 M 433 8 AC 106n new notice 167 586 307 trustees s 52 S 627 s 6 AC 194 309 salary 8 52 S 871 f31 631 d 34 154 26 M 216 312 stay terms s 53 S 722 d 142 497 1102 1111 709 276 287 636 284 387 34 205 7 558 19? B62S a 160 NY 9 AC 403 note b52S r 161 NY 41 s62 SAC 267 589 u90 365 631 186n 323 324 373 703 268a 315 520 365 621 230n 407 burden proof s 52 S 1028 * 161 NY 655 60 68 41 M 161 4 1 2 neglieence s63S s6 AC 103 annulment 16AC 206 NT 334 grade croasg 8 62 S 234 a 158 NY 410 336 negligence s 62 S 366 f 51 617 73 693 65 LRA 644n 348 transfer tax s 52 S 362 88 157 9 AC llSn 123n 13 AC 478 s 161 NY 640 taxation do 116 186 review power 134 707 356 paymt proof s 52 S 443 e 35 M 256 validity lien 46 M complaint 148 54M answer prool 119 limited 119 allegations do 140 425 books ev. s 52 S 691 80 118 43 1 loss business s 52 S 638 B2 152 32 CP 122 moving cause 83 525 606 748 246 390 683 361 salaries s 53 S 156 r 167 NY 151 364 negligence s 52 S 229 e 157 NY 320 fright liable 17AC 135n 375 slander B 52 S 320 a 165 NY 496 378 injunction 8 62 S 318 * 167 NY 674 e 27 M 137 instruction rr. 103 166 382 republish s 52 S 929 503 ministerial 52S 308 226NY 59 51 I negligence s 52 S *160 NY 40 privity 133 income IITS 523 confidential s 62 S 197 a 167 NY 676 34 10 23 41 459 73 468 veteran act 84 M 189 527 mandamuB 600 107 171 112 504 8 52S b52S 25 M 28 M 30 M as true 168 disregard 95 M 438 court's power 52 S 92 62 s 164NY 643 431 88 673 448 loss damage s 52 S 836 73 501 11 AC 66n 453 witness int. s52S 714 71 217 36 M 196 exception rule 54M 561 464 presumption a 53 S 619 116 25 469 eviction 3 52S 172 * 169 NY 672 8 AC 431n reason time f 171 707 477 covenant a 62 S 212 s 43 449 s54 64 concluded 66M 838 costs counsel fee 67 M 429 public highway 224NY 508 116 1 143 875 565 gift causa mortis 8 52S 37 e41 47 74 77 proof gift 150 86 M 401 1060 450 747 327 559 698 574 lien a52S a 166 NY 36 construction 578 penalties s 52 S 221 121 196 not limited 138 759 531 partition 8 52 S 128 62 254 m 52 255 construction 31 M 226 535 insurance 583 waiver 52 S 427 120 564 forfeits rights 174 708 590 trust s62S d34 3 52S 32 submission 193 NY law action 209 NY 537 negligence 33 39 562 52 S 91 d95 97 d98 104 138 do 182 NY care 16AC 355 , 133 380 513 222 414 408 239 850 314 319 51 542 construction B 62 S 93 d 81 502 603 sing, estate 51 M 98 M 265 508 546contrih. s 52 S 138 215-NY 549 appealable 496 calendar b52S s6AC 10 AC 308n310n 498 flse represn s 62 S 139 42 M 612 fraud sale 20 AC 86n 20 AC 87n neg. 30 114 case 13 s53S 142 a 161 NY 293 judgment 417 case 14 474 8 53 S 55 a 164 NY 524, will case 21 768's53S 318 r 161 NY report case 24 404 8 53 S 596 a 163 NY 221 632 appeal 426 case 21 s62S a 165 NY f60 requesta 117 621 522 d 191NY 340 1102 606 1113 696 1107 429 1118 664 124 116 322 637 622 634 judgment case 1 s 54S a 159 NY report case 7 s53S a 161 NY 595 negligence s52S 92 603 bonds 8 52S 90 funding 135 137 160 6 1 damages s62S * 167 NY construction U3 236 104 781 345 471 418 223 604 1098 444 1104 661 634 negligence case 22 s 53S 1104 a 161 NY 666 635 appeal case 2 s 63 S 1109 a 167 NY 669 case 9 s 63S 1117 160 NY 661 637 appeal easel 7 s 63 S 1108 a 166 NY 166 617 exemptions b52S 37 M 39 M 41 M e42M 42 M 48 M MAC 700 464 222 307 38S 389 390 280 281 137n 17 AC349n 350n 352 353 set off 49 M construction 102 409 e62S slOl f 170 553 mayor s62S 32 557 audit 3 62S 49 120 130 320 906 160 614 89 6 563 559 construction s52S 168 34 213 mech. lien 114 453 allegations 119 390 genl. contractor 185 265 limit liability 186 339 128 o2M 52M money 64M allow. 30 441 426 427 662 624 undue influ. 8 52 S 471 a 164 NY 564 627 interpleader case 4 s 54 S 1075 a 165 NY 236 628 necessity s55S 6 18AC 190n 629 insurance 8 64 S 1048 a 164 NY 440 630 civil service case 1 8 64S 1112 e 34 303 62 254 trust VOL.32 4 distinction s 62 S 671 47 259 relief 53 619 6 judicial 8 62 S 618 do 174 712 28 M 707 compliance 55M 19 1 inher tax s 62 S 710 a 160 NY 704 73 327 328 legacy 48 M 64 1 3 negligence s 52 S 1051 a 164 NY 686 34 ' 74 44 614 do 89 319 89 315 339 89 426 427 429 f9l 423 119 23 50 M 294 fact question 95 120 111 335 171 NY 313 evidence def. 9 M 38 revers error 128 867 jury question 134 630 22 sup. pro. s 62 S 309 34 162 affidavit 13 AC 463n execution 63 M 26 without county ICPNS 5n 23 exemption 8 62 S 622 a 167 NY 363 pension wife 38CP 182 26 b. particulars 62S 41 73 79 11 AC 961 t522 510 631 ">. 198 29 possession s 52 S 750 74 420 refiling 9 AC 433n 436n 106 479 32 partition s52S 314 91 190 bill partic do 120 313 33 supl complt s 52 S 492 40 147 stipulation 26 M 409 5SLRA193n200n insurance 68 M 630 41 title s62S 34 36 39 encroachment SAC 8n 449 421 625 ABBREVIATIONS: a, afUrmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m. modified; *, dismissed; n, note: e, criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q, questioned N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division Vol. 32 46 habeas corpus 617 149 305 9 52 S 8 6 AC no costs 22SNY 49 quo warranto s 62 S 2S0 76 409 33 CP 209 98 M 368 1 20 mandamus 9 62 S 860 a 165 NY 362 1 24 indonement 9 62 8 a 164 NY surety 192 NY 699 827 607 5 1 discontinue 281 684 368 593 100 s62S discretion 33 68 27 M s 6 AC 6 AC 99 298n 300 7 AC 446n 54 filing map 9 52 S 473 36 617 Erade crossine d47 319 compliance 64M 501 eminent domain 142 57 salary s52S 45 62 divorce s52S s6AC connivance 76 M 729 778 463 509 291 672 66 residence B 52 S 1057 40 M 371 76 weight ev 9 52S 40 65 59 100 contrib neg 88 698 617 624 617 619 479 612 83 conclusion . s 62 S 667 *159 NY 543 32 M 215 87 fact question s 62 S 602 e 41 620 92 partnership 3 62S a 158 NY 32 160 NY s62S do 70 112 40M not partner 127 185 64M 786 24 474 466 507 408 656 98 "shall" future s 52S 861 180 116 1 03 contract s 52 S 963 a 161 NY 629 90 181 consideration 9 AC 213n 221n 49M ^ 368 106 good faith 1 28 preference s 52 5 gae 63 248 1 3 1 fact question 3 52 8 611 91 404 1 39 ejectment a 62 8 864 s 6 AC 45 1 44 legis power 3 62 S 696 53 622 1 48 new trial a 52 8 939 46 378 76 9 costs 29 M 740 _- disc, ev, 16AC 117nl2Sn 151 demurrer 3 52 S 941 16 AC 246r 1 54 town neg. 3 52 S 804 d41 8 eSO 81 54 463 14 AC 170n 1 58r r commrs 3 52 S 901 a 168 NY 421 1 68 pleading 3 62 8 966 49 277 f 67 500 38 M 119 1 78 constitut'l 8 52 S 916 do 78 138 d 84 M statute 105M 203 taxation s53S a 167 NY 32 exemption 74 f 97 99 126 do 194 NY 552 410 66 679 202 659 315 626 726 120 construe statute a62S 8 38 s47 extension e 46 M 168 NY fl83 NY repeal ll5 AD 131 caxsale 187NY substitute 73 M not exempt d 84 M tatute 105M 40 161 30 197 2S4 362 552 410 I 79 certiorari 908 711 168 207 206 master neg. 3 63 S 162 382 444d 446 208 commission s 53 S 63 f 98 M 889 212 trspassdam. 3 40 8 968 9 53 8 1115 *167NY 30 69 LRA 862 216 construed s 52 S 990 170 857 226 parties deft s 168 NY 703 258 foreclosure 1013 432 636 368 1118 459 268 banks 8 62 3 a 169 NY not creditor 220 NY 142 assumed 220 NY 142 272 chose action » 52 8 1005 9 AC 452n 456n e 162 NY 649 not chattel 154 852 cefrtif. property 349 attys fees 8 52 8 1041 f 68 629 10 AC 376n e 10 AC 379 reargumtfee 63 M 66 357 civ. aerviee 8 53 8 7 f 32 638 69 402 185 869, 875 362 detention 3 52 S e46M 374 parol s53 8 a 161 NY 39 e37M el54 167 274 fees d52S s44 851 949 3 52 8 9 6 AC pleading 113 973 129 661 1001 58 B 528 134 1 1 3 taxn rr s52 8 a 157 NY 67 LEA 69d 893 620 869 677 97n (83 uncertainty s 52 S 943 a 161 NY 652 e 100 34 parol evidence SI M 418 189 delivery s52S 910 a 165 NY 631 66 81 84 premium paymt 34 M 739 197 assessment 8 53 S 67 a 167 NY 677 32 204 85 76 construe statute e 33 M 714 34 M 503 exemption 63 684 74 559 85 78 d 81 f 97 315 99 530 126 724 do 144 823 not exempt 23 I denial 3 52 8 62 M denial good ICPNS 273 233 lateral supp a 52 8 993 9 26 M 575 d 123 262 124 22 15 AC 266n injunction 151 734 237 Stat, frauds 3 52 8 99S^ 112 801 single contract 112 802 239 construction s 52 8 1019 86 M 68 245 warranty 8 52 8 978 a 161 NY 650 43 533 81 88 980 16 9 7 AC 132n 139 276 fact question 8 62 S 975 44 . 614 carrzer neg. 16AC 232n 281 negligence 3 52 8 1097 jud notice 53 356 80 356 3 I I use streets 3 52 8 1026 38 498 vested right 43 508 609 74 436 em. domain 167 NY 463 property rleht 125 42 filing map 200NY 543 1084 461 114 478 18 380 s63S 38 66 248 verdict B 52 8 1007 9 6 AC 207 new trial 140 231 incompetent ev. 72 M 106 alTi davits 81 M 77 257 hyp question 8 62 S a 160 NY 3 1 6 frd. checks 3 62 8 1064 a 164 NY 498 58 71 60 245 247 249 books ev 80 118 s 167 NY 702 duly bank 17AC 480n 481d -483n 324 devastavit 389 damages 3 63 8 123 76 309 394 layng out st 9 53 8 46 f 54 629 59 183 A eight ev 64 260 397 party wall 3 62S 109 2 a 167 NY 698 use of flues e 75 322 cloBes window 85 32 light and air t 43 M 63 9 6 AC 132 reservation e 156 222 easements d 91 M 566 5S7 f 91 M 571 400 jurisdiction 617 104 564 673 294 520 220 391 598 482 305 644 S70 422 854 301 66n 293 8 53 8 3 40 8 48 d55 f61 s61 63 appeal 174 NY do 174 NY 26 610 542 288 414 418 617 19 20 237 244 346 wilful trpasB a 52 8 849 ordinance neg 45 68 69 167 request 76 contrib 19AC reversible error 19AC 213n ev. negligence 983 do 214 NY 550 3!57 12 20 477 174 33e neg. 209n 105 137 138 146 159 179 NY 7 AC 16AC injunction 69 LRA 676n 689n reference 26 M 11 leave to sue 16AC 292 title realty 59 M 12. 13 408 title necessary s 52 8 82 M f67 82 92 e94 e 160 NY strike out 77 charge 82 ev future dam. 14 AC 307n high degree care 98 M 39 423 ejectment s 53 8 215 a 44 630 430 tax laws s 63 8 41 a 164 NY 591 performance 166 NY 206 435 exception 8 53 S 149 62 179 not conclusive d 72 M 93 442 executor s 53 S 127 a 161 NY 634 86 434 94 M 550 disbursement 87 28 trustee 30 M 557 454diver8nwater JJ^!503inoompev 8 63 S ~ 209 63 42S profits dam e 78 559 fact question fS 89 87 123 ev. damages d 126 252 death cases 219 NY 535 5 f 3 misfeasance b53S 158 NY 34 32 M removal 36 M 104 authority 57M 230 221 677 573 123 86 218 10 667 238n 345 274 520 8 10 545 415 s63S a 160 NY 84 LRA njunction 60 M 458 review 8 63 8 32 34 60 87 465 libel s53S 8 6 AC no publication 84 M 503 468 allowance s 53 8 312 601 90 494 495 injunction 25 M 384 storage 40 244 474 negligence 1033 76 8 52 8 a 166 NY 43 9 169 NY 169 NY 1125 660 4 1 f sewer dam 81 LRA 686 713 4 1 4 dock maetrs B 63 8 110 a 158 NY 666 f 32 462 water register 34 8 mandamus 61 273 salary 75 362 80 266 28 M 322 4 1 9 negligence a 62 S 1088 a 165 NY 603 1074 142 600 672 394 478 discovery s 62 8 1094 d 41 477 80 166 8 6 AC 313 phys examn 12 AC 89n grounds belief 137 824 486 reason rule 520 coDBtruction 9 53 8 1028 a 161 NY 66 529 laches 9 53 8 17 a 166 NY 247 45 266 565 Btkholder 953 S 607 r 159 NY 285 51 217 578 fact queetion 3 53 S 236 80 151 152 d 80 155 15S f 172 SO 585 privilege 9 52 8 1120 S3 478 headlines 173 494 read together 177 94 592 contract 8 53 8 66 s 79 360-353 consent 91 M 409 no title 220 NY 236 596 ordinance 9 53 8 4S 33 478 restraint 39 433 602 sureties 9 53 8 18S 42 38 55 457 67 73 26 M 640 30 CP 176 606 negligence s 53 8 145 489 no lien 3 53 8 a 164 NY 74 496 legal title s 53 S 22B 153 611 53 8 e39 79 6 1 wages 8 53 8 a 167 NY 70 163 331 369 98 630 521 624 certiorari 8 52 8 269 a 157 NY 51 625 tender 52 S 1018 145 70 corroboration f 167 76 626 retrial 17AC 143n jury trial ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, diBtinguished ; f, followed- r reversprt- m ™„.i!«.j. « a- — ■ 1 C criticised; I. limited: e. .xflainedl- o. overlSled; s'. .km"e c«e? do%L\™^rg ojlnirf 1,' V'iraliel'jr !^r 242 1112 289 1117 525 652 Hen 1103 658 75 1112 70 s65S a 164 NY bill sale case 12 8 65S a 167 NY appeal case 14 b66S a 163 NY 1138 663 1144 202 1147 671 633 mandamus case 3 8 65S a 158 NY dismissal case 14 s65S a 168 NY 825 appeal case 4 s55S a 170 NY mandamus case 5 s56S a 169 NY 57LRA 77n99n tax corpn. case 9 3 65S 1146 r 168 NY 14 630 f d. transfer case 1 s56S a 166 NY partnership case 8 s55S r 164 NY 1142 582 1140 278 1105 867 1142 446 577 544 proper order 150 833 without notice 181 878 discretion court 181 878 589 contract s65S a 166 NY 86 d 179 NY dl53 166 619 206 404 45 63 1 appeal case 1 b65S * 160 NY appeal case 6 s55S a 165 NY new trial case 7 8 66S a 166 NY appeal case 13 8 66S a 165 NY 632 appeal case 3 r65S s 160 NY a 165 NY dismissal case ] 1 1148 676 1142 609 1143 661 1140 662 1149 664 675 1146 671 1141 647 VOL.36 I priv nuisance 192 484 141 422 319 172 97n 109b 431 86 55 S 39 do 66 62 72 29 M ■iO AC ILRANS injunction 64 vibration 132 unreasnable use 72 M 280 impair health lOOM 622 I I certificate B 65 S 229 72 33 subrogation d91 285 pledges 10 AC 145n proceeds 57M 317 318 1 7 preference 8 56 S 206 r 161 NY 639 41 638 such disregard 7!.i M 226 139 S 975 not limited 156 732 intent legisl, lofi 734 secure equality 99M 504 63 equity s66S * 170 NY 71 10 AC action lies d75M f 83 M must account 183 460 60 forfeiture s66S f93 277 614 372 357 612 480 6-18 402 67 conclusive s66S 38 s42 64 estoppel 60M damages 60 M 606 27 621 124 372 372 77 abatement 3 1 variance a65S 76 109 97 295 281 parties 33 8 65» 45 M 69 M 97 M encroachment 50 M 399 4 1 easement 140 268 77 507 s55S 29 M 33 M 39 m: 50 M reservation el56 806 438 59 287 434 223 3 66S 61 9 AC 30 CP 87 subst. i 65 S 59 M 90 cd r suit 8 55S s49 s 167 NY 614 418 318 330 servt 386 15 464 631 121 I07incomp ev. s 55 S 483 75 71 26 M 870 I 1 2 bank neg b55S s59 1 30 tenant s55S misfeasance 47 no appeal 73 M f 91 M 1 33 devise bS5S a 166 NY 646 104 382 196 459 17 390 641 72 144 n aiver pleadings 119 675 580 390P 285 amend 39CP 291 must plead 151 490. 39 CP 286 proof waiver 39 CP 291 performance 167 782 79 M 50 recovery f 167 1 40 fel. servt. 47 prima f . ev s 55 S 105 51 M 90 conclusive 18AI' 361 49 insurance s55S 33 M 3 56S 52 147 title a 56 S s 165 NY 188 38 s65S a 161 NY 61 e 29 M s 159 NY file report 47 M 163 70 146 282 324 806 53 excuse s66S 47 70 waiver 101 27 M 30 M incompetent ev. 51 . 383 variance US 132 57 negligence 55 S 132 ?l ,. 376 45 M 589 59 M 414 I 378 433 469 391 I 52 directors 467 649 604 473 630 461 I 56 attacLi ment s 55 S 422 42 M 17 781 1 63 negligence 8 66 S 41S 101 67 1 67 stipulation s 66 S 404 r 166 NY 460 61 526 1 76 jury trial 8 66 S 763 80 161 152 33 M 423 reference 124 775 1 79 insurance 8 55 S . 459 a 60 428 1 8 1 conclusive s55 S 388 a 167 NY 240 1 85 provisions s 55S 462 178 555 1 89 judgment s 55 S 383 a 159 NY 659 1 9 Ifact Question 394 193 569 189 s65S r 162 NY 87 33 M 1 96 consent 3 56 S 686 7 AC 416n lien consent 126 831 submission do 172 596 201 cotenants s 56 S 889 126 '663i apportionment 126 664 208 relief 66 S 36 do 70 73 174 17AG 734 . 448 23 25 556 S5S 407 9a 1 59 excuse 8 55 S 624 47 70 dismiss complt 52 384 compliance 86 362 sill 176 34 M 659 ccnd precdt. 50 148 incompetent ev 61 383 70 174's6SS quantum meruit '98 M jurisdiction 106 aiv- 78 224 71 M 332 accounting d SO 412 4ia d 135 408 37 M 3ia 52M 191 amendment 84 393 486 equity 92 - 289 U AC 173 176n 178 reversal 164 895 220 law of road ' 306. 485. ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n. criticised; 1, limited; e, explained: o, overruled; s, same case; do, dissenting opinion; d. narallel case; a, nue: . note; c :stjnned N. Y. Supreme Coart Reports— Appellate Division Vols. 36, 37 verdict excesgive c 41 M 535 fact question 116 657 224 construction 8 56 S SO 82 e29M dSlM intent 106M 240 Ubel s56S 3 47 324 413 393 212 87 426 728 606 139 776 variance disregarded 146 772 approximate 148 208 242 law question a 56 S 780 63 698 neffllEence r 60 616 64 426 246 neffXieence s 55 S 266 80 127 oers. injuries S6M 339 res ipsa loq' 64M 581 250 insurance s 55 S 292 s 79 165 265 nesliffence 8 55 S 308 8 36 274 49 503 d 73 404 73 497 92 104 e 94 473 privilege waiver 7 AC 345n joint tort feasor 73 503 amendment f 78 95 126 66 M discretion do 126 evidence 324 no reversal case 1 149 privilege do 149 professional privilege do 149 808 degree care 185 869 273 revers ev. 8 55 S 314 176 930 43 M 376 275 laclies 8 65 S 225 75 355 366 359 B 162 NY 646 estoppel 134 401 281 notice 8 55 S 232 a 165 NY 620 45 187 195 99 313 lib'l construcn 7 AC 117 284 t'd claim 8 55 S 276 a 158 NY 532 amendment 132 794 incrimination 197NY 246 distinction 302hu8b &wife separation B55S r 165 NY .'b63 e65 99 116 38 M 14 AC renewal cohab. 38 396 paymt pleaded 45& alimony 50 M no waiver V4M: enforceable 77 M allowance 84 M conditions 106M 480 363 239 344 230 526 807 808 256 91 364 475 562 817 460 243n 154 183 175 360 463 insurance 355 neslisence 8 55 S 269 co-servant 49 607 safe place 96 44 33 M 465 assume risk 134 797 362 8 56S * 161 NY 56LRA agent 172 468 vesting s55S r 164 NY 58 152 q33 M 842 120 201 n 533 revocation use name 324 298 424 673 402 s5SS s44 132 8 AC d73M trademark ILRANS ILRANS 720n 309 revers error 55 S 290 82 436 f 134 259 31 M 472 amendment d 47 326 request chg. 133 145 r. r. negligence e 134 258 3 1 2 accounting 8 55 S 364 59 255 t'raud sale 20 AC 89n 317 consideratn s 55 S 251 67 M 264 319 asm'd risk s55 S 199 38 40 52 93 32 I sp-procdg 55 S 345 a 160 NY 686 a44 M 266 audit 50 486 disbursements d 103 534 compensation 98 398 397 125 192, 196 51 M 124 investigation 59 M 392 fees constable 166 23 339 pers. injury 8 66 S 263 d 54 367 notice entry 58M 378 343 insurance s 65 S 236 * 159 NY 642 348 insurance 298 606 879 68n 91 725n 718n 722n 378 contr. neg. 8 66 d40 s41 d44 8 46 d48 59 stare decisis do 46 sS6S 46 consents 63 151 ^OM 7 AC 822 71 212 582 309 54 395 61 687 363 14n ISn 18n 20n certificate 33 M 246 measurements 761 198 629 630 828 629 627 658 619 254 8 55S a 166 NY 352 jury sSSS 143 waiver 13 AC 102 234 321 420 362 366 jury question d 121 620 379 judgment 8 55 S 401 * 171 NY 663 27 M 58 386 direct par'n s 55 S 370 Tl M 287 389 improper Bumming up s 55 S 410 * 162 NY 619 71 132 49 M 87 criminal intent 73 429 presumption e 49 M 86 401 false audit 8 55 S . 530 r 158 NY 542 420 not charge- able s 53 S 375 do 153 854 424 adv poss'n. 3 55S 35 a 165 NY 621 50 M 440 426 insurance s 55 S 363 r 166 NY 174 443 employment s 55S 840 s46 91 3 68 109 446 damages s 55 S 948 50 551 allegations e 100 21 450 nuisanct s55S a 159 NY prescriptive right 91 M 458 overflow 473 limitation s55 8 449 90 47 16AC 301n immaterial 200 NY 83 476 mandamus 8 65 S 889 tort servants 36 469 ministerial 61 346 88 450 munic. liable 111 906 report superiors 112 85 liability 70 M 642, 644 482 appropriatn 41 M reference 31 M 39 M privilege 52M 412 46 647 540 county cts, s 55 S 692 92 M 95 M 542 exr acctg 721 B55S 36 44 30 CP lien 91 title vesting 101 Ji04 489 319 37 137 304 553award s5ES 85 commission 129 damages 73 M 227 power court 87 M 591 558 injunction 8 55S 133 27 M 35 M 58M damages 103M 492 jurisdiction s55S a 163 NY 33 M 7A0 s 161 NY authority 109 drainage 47 70 M 657 133 190 51n 664 562 demurrer S65S a 158 NY d36M equity 37 M counsel fees 358 27U 5 1 bona fides s 65 S 858 a 161 NY 656 47 542 81 44 consideration 9 AC 21 7n 21 9n 5 1 4 certificate s 56 S 938 75 110 amendment d 72 M 463 5 1 8 mandamus s 55 S 522 a 158 NY 720 520 qualification s 55 S 832 63 273 522 recitals 56 S 816 637 31 M 7 AC 7 AC 829 266 377n 379n 380 525 negligence s55S 48 a 165 NY 461 d 69 355 387 P 70 204 179 33 assumption 131 479 second appeal 68361 LRA 529 covenant 697ii|3 55S 't31M 731 9 66 S a 161NY 725 654 599 injunction » 66 S 917 32 M 481 m 166 NY 363 6 I I partnership 8 66 S 253 46M 182 117 758 parol contract 126 57 6 1 2 stranger b55S 72 benefit 35 M 623 pledge case 3 s55S s36 716 394 24 398 344 639 10 AC 568 costs ^55 S 110 697 720 268 284 203n 761 489 166 J 680 307 672 29 623 625 good title case 1 s 55 S 107 a 166 NY 617 627 reversal case 1 8 55 S 148 8 AC 169n 11 AC 19n 629 mandamus case 1 3 64S 1112 rl58Ny 686 632 judgment case 1 8 65S 8 161 NY a 162 NY VOL- 37 I tax basis 8 56 S 317 55 267 e 61 377 54M 331 1 5 presumption e 56 S 708 a 159 NY 532 50 36 54 38 accounting 32 M 566 trust 37 M 706 706 2 1 information s 55 S 701 p 37 625 9 AC 237n 23gn objection late 110 616 jurisdiction 142 1148 641 656 572 denial 3 56S 34 M d 39CP pleading 100 do 178 486, 489 strike out 39 CP 119 178 484 58 I revers error 477 310 119 352 633 levy case 13 s57S 1 8 112 6 AC 634 contract ca8e21 s5SS a 165 NY 635 appeal case 5 s56S 159 NY 367 410 636 m. lien case 14 56 S 1109 rl6S NY 61 9 55S m 168 NY 95 10 AC costs 31 M 7 AC « 168 NY 796 578 334 334 301 153n 581 587 decription 966 3 611 s55S 33 M agreement 41 M 593 sales 8 55S i... s92 77 charge error 50 M 347 burden plaintiff 148 919 1108 633 waiver 182 24 affidavit 8 65S 32 M 183 343 731 16 597 taxation 502 a 56 S 960 349la 167 NY fii7 28 aSBignment s 55 S 736 91 108 credibility 39 M 306 intent 11 AC 287n spec request 128 739 35 use water 8 55 S 463 d 53 352n 70 546 injunction 32 M 479 nuisance proof 36 M 626 8 AC 130n do 188NY 102 ripar. rights 188NY 83 e84 63M 210 legal evidence 6HM 447 right access 77 M 400 44 certiorari 6 56 S 337 a 159 NY 162 Bl69N5f 166 49 ev possess'n B 65 S 699 48M 17 57 em domain 8 55 S 685 8 177 NY 677 * 166 NY 286 59 LRA 857n nuisance daxn's 59 LRA 867 consent not nee 133 480 owner's right 66M 449 appropriation 151 366 66 certiorari s55S a 161 NY mistake 111 599 645 34 69 revets, error s 65 S 596 117 188 fail to except 147 677 no jurisdiction ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d. distinguished; f. followed; r. reversed; m, modified; ♦, dismissed- n mote- c. criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q, questioned Vol. 37 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division 152 707 98 master neg. B 55 S 1091 d 46 424 oo-Bervant 52 . 433 asBumed risk 64 428 106 preference 8 55 S 1024 d 89 484n 1 1 sparks neg s 55 S 1121 r 165 NY 347 I 1 4 probate s55S 1118 d45 118 alleeations suf. 32 CP . 238 complaint 19A0 284e controverted f 153 558 I 24 meas. dam, B56S 219 94 29S |27fact question 3 55S 1124 43 61 53 468 469 127 808 damages II AG 6Sn 136 incompt ev. s 55 S 784 61 257 I 4 I town audit 8 66 S 781 43 25 certificate 105 214 1 46 assesst ins s 55 S 768 76 160 eversible error e 94 363 1 47 local statute B 65 S 803 98 498 intention controls f 163 717 I 52 forfeiture 8 56 S 775 49 479 real party 72 104 106 63 LRA 194n 33 CP 117 burd'jn deft. B7M: 117 1 62 weight ev. B 55 S 895 53 63 64 260 do 99 348 1 67 release B 66 S 1028 a 165 NY 372 66 397 75 401 98 M 346 in writing 170 892 1 73 bequest s 55S 908 50 LRA 667 31 CP 308 1 80 pub policy s55S 799 ;4M 743 mforcement 145 645 jtrct. constrctn. 88 M 227 I 87 negligence B 56 S 1013 e 76 327 80 239 jury question d I88NY 166 I U4 damages s 56 S 864 70 532 633 203 assignment 8 56 S 139 52 340 e 64 173 31 CP 271 preference 118 284 corporations 156 730 220 civil service 55 S 837 89 68 224 indictment 8 56 S 789 a 160 NY 371 228 ordinance s65S 792 112 726 234 penalty 3 56 S 770 f 39 465 f 49 630 52 689 59 222 10 AC 26 surety 120 658 90 M 164 remedial 165 AD 230 242 sales s57S a 167 NY 520 576 248 prooeed'gs s 56 S 1067 a 162 NY 616 44 M 196 253 contract s 56 S 998 a 166 NY 632 257 fixture s 55 S 924 e 99 277 123 466 d 46 M 14 20 AC lOGn ta-sable 135 646 272 construction 3 55 S 942 39 ■ 371 compensation 57M 8S eq. portion 157 145 276 record s 65 S 827 616 competent ev. 32 M 267 166 NY 169 certificate 73 M 153 90 M 218 d 90 M 219 280 arson s 65 S 932 r 162 NY 520 improp remarks 62 LRA 220n 289 intention 3 55S 810 d 59 168 59 640 103 151 85 M 660 clear proof 66 622 fact question 67 555 delivery 44 M 105 gift causa mortis 99 81 49 M 191 bank deposit 123 847 voluntiry trust do 123 854 survivorship 146 294 policy of law 155 663 295 lease s 55 S 753 160 NY 114 covenant 140 673 cause action 104M 17 307 damages r 65 S 850 a 165 NY 619 11 AC 63d public offi 145 463 negligence 172 44 d 183 NY 149 defense U2 669 32 I other lienors s65 S 826 119 392 323 s 56 S 280 £ 163 932 327 improp sum mingup s 66 S 282 71 132 do 216 NY 577 revers error d 58 174 72 393 158 NY 561 46 LRA 663 new trial 175 118 340notice s57S 611 3 159 NY 566 a 62 NY 647 a 166 NY 630 d62 169 change by-laws 98 612 contracts 180 725 reduction 180 729 348 knowledge '57 S 705 45 222 351 jurisdiction s 55 S 1111 do 155 335 355 equities s56S 73 a 166 NY 642 69 175 359 partnership s 55 S 1103 46 14 4S 46 8 48 592 33 M 482 366 substitution s56S 1 9 AC 224n new retainer 84 M 256 368 admissions s55S 1114 a 165 NY 649 175 NY 128 in compet. ev. 19A0 325n 374 accounting 56 S 8 a 161 NY 530 386 rate of speed s 66 S 1068 97 304 396plff proof 3 56 S 288 129 289 399 fund 3 56 S 1080 3 160 NY 673 a 161 NY 671 405 consent s 56 S 1009 r 163 NY 122 e 57 667 d 9 AC 291 414 "duly' 3 55 S 1045 70 437 10 AC 42G 33 CP 3, 5n order nullity 59 M 150 jurisdiction 138 679 178 935 425 rent neg 3 56 S 64 a 166 NY 630 69 LRA 336n discretion 118 262 434 deposits 56 S 13 a 63 997 443 guaranty 9 66 S 33 f 61 M _ 274 dissolution 69LRA 130n 455 charge ev 3 56 S 22 a 165 NY 664 73 173 contrib. neg 77 163 56 LRA 193n 194n 200n 460 constructn s 55S 1063 f 148 470 465 mistake s 56 S 68 41 528 629 insurance 68 M 530 ev. payment 59 M 508 472 libel a 56 S 26 49 21 e 72 192 114 178 construction 135 32 476 contrib. neg. s 66 S 18 129 502 infer neglig. d 134 due care do 134 678 483 considerat'n B 56 S 1074 78 _ 158 rescission d 181 24 43 M 519 agreement d 103 326 contract 61 M 63 95 M 240 novation 132 666 49 I practice s56S do 63 32 M 3CP review 61 M new trial ICPNS 184 special verdict 137 AD 847 complete record 137 AD 847 88 92 292 67 143 21 322 528 chat, mtge 8 55S 1106 a 166 NY 427 Counterclaim 60M 60 534 bill partic. s SOS 292 igAC 42n 45n 536 contract s 66 S 326 54M 266 542 notice mail s 55S 491 125 14 547fact question a 56 S 236 s 167 NY 668 62 605 prima facie ev ef 97 23 neglig. per se do 205NY 583 550 inspect bks 306 79 656 497 bastardy 3 66 S 1043 56 467 do 66 471 500 notice s 56 S 1096 83 487 490 coupons 95 . 10 St. limitations 123 246, 248 competency 80 M 678 waiver f 163 . S 117 do 148 remedy 9 AC 103 106 do 122 56M 20 5 1 demurrer s 57 S 443 B 84 309 93 404 37 CP 135 measure dam. 113 82 no demurrer 134 5b do 171 738 5 1 8 commission s 66 S 97 87 116 131 143 rule 116 137 412 118 613 454 evidence 717 694 jury question 138 557 procuring cause 143 4.54 no recovery 74M 308 complaint 103M 685 52 1 variance s 56 S 78 91 M 426 525 sealed in- strument 8 56 S 96 B 44 642 76 514 evidence error 488n 209 351 642 511 conjunctively 141 664 553 conversion 3 56 S 284 3 50 200 580 tax N C stk s 56 S 295 a 166 NY 694 d67 605 5 8 4 oral negot >na 3 56 8 a 164 NY 56 42 M demurrer 37 CP written 131 161 562 606 498 3) lease 776 575 ins proof 260 178 429 335 defuse 496 254 elOO covenant 134 real party t 69 M jurisdiction 77 M 468 3 56S a 167 NY 50 86 establish 87 147 special plea 119 578 must plead 39 CP 289 notice necessry 19A0 219n 229n new matter 185 368 598 snow neg. s 56 S 237 68 111 e 96 371 16 AC 326 city negligence 126 541 e642 60 I bank duty 3 56 S 244 a 165 NY 629 recovery 120 131 6 1 4 ben. assn. 3 56 S 339 compliance 43 493 by-IawB ,84 208 28 M 686 chge beneficiary 28 M 720 14 AC 198n contract 97 648 6 1 8 monop. act s 66 S 288 32 M 12 66 M 68 59 illegal trust 84 LRA 73ln courts 56M 129 assu mptlon 121 450 625 per law case 13 s56S 1108 a 159 NY 149 surrogate case 14 3 56 S 1105 a 169 NY 129 77 M 294 report case 16 s66S 1112 a 164 NY 599 new trial case 20 s56S 1118 a 165 NY 616 new trial case 21 s55S 1118 a 161 NY 665 contract case 24 s56S 1195 a 166 NY 614 report case 27 3 56S 1108 a 166 NY 620 626 hq. certif. case 3 s66S 1112 a 161 NY 645 dog tax case 7 b66S 1114 a 159 NY 125 dismissal cas e 12 s 56S 1109 a 170 NY 567 629 bailee s59S 148 630 new trial case 4 56 8 a 167 NY contr. neg case 6 s56S r 162 NY appeal iel3 8 66 8 60 607, 630 812 1100 611 1108 21 1113 608 631 negligence easel s 57S 114» a 165 NY 635 do 89 318 632 appeal case 2 8 66 S 1104 8 42 603 633 judgment case 3 -56 8 1112 a 165 NY 666 commissions case 9 66 S 1115 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; t, followed; r, reversed; m, modlBed; *, dismissed; n, noM c, criticised ; 1, limited ; e, explained ; o, overruled ; s, same case ; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, questioneo N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division Vols. 37, 38 a 162 NY judement case 11 s66S a 166 NY juedment case 16 s56S a 172 NY 31 1116 629 Ills 629 634 attachment case 7 3 56S 1116 • 160 NY 766 VOL.38. I judge not court 56 S 121 161 f 163 f 171 statutory 102M 5 damages bS6S 53 prepond ev 30 M 163 NY 308 762 734 966 957 77 293 396 TIM 198 68 appearance 8 55 8 88 do 88 101 166 67 M Ti'M 98 il 15 AC 75 affidavit 8 55S 727|42 148 704 f 181 864 32 M 443 971 276 278 287 88 691 123 f'd transfer 41 a 66S 545 381 70 108 434jlien 135 391 1 20 fees taxn. a 56 S 663 a 167 NY 639 ?I§, 128 services 427 a56S 7 competition s66S a 166 NY 43 M I 6 practice 9S6S 79 I 9 transfer tax 228 631 170 304 585 489 436 643 33 159 564 s56S a 159 NY 70|rl65NY lO^ d 66 fl 71 82mandamus „ qo B 55 S 1018 28 M a 57 173i®*' 58 , . 6»8il30title power of city 'g ge s gu 138 °21|50 121 o_ . s 58 289 85 conversion , nctice in fact 55 b 915|128 362 568 22 discretion s57S 72 equity e92 ,41 M notice 165 925 533 6?S 501 's 47 219-221 81 50 183 possession 133 87commisBion 994 2 48 579 161 1 |34confessnjudg 3«5;ai65NY 174 demurrer s 56S 650 186 5 1 76 acceptance s 56S 649 135 364 oroper practice 152 98 1 78 partnership 610186 80 89 786 46 M 157 578 682 350 surrogate S66S f 38 B 29 M 3 29M 8 160 NY 764 636 477 479 663 47 49 27 M 128M d28M 8 6 AC 374!s57S e 6 AC 393 396n powers 6 'AC 397n 399n 56 jurisdiction |28 M 46 100 29 M 60 460 30M 154 loSidSlM 07 M 378,39 M do77M 174141 M construction 77 M 1 1 89 firm name 8 56 S 593 f 27 M 694 11 AC 9n I 94 teachers 3 66 S 642 removal 32 M 64 65 198 consideratn 3 66 S 566 54 M 539 construction 273 perjury s 56 S 967 a 170 NY 351 credibility s 56 S 602 „,.a6M 168 oo^ cross question „__ . , ^. 87 M 492 2y9 information ^^fjS 967 355 corpn, no jurisdiction 129 S 1010 e44 variance e 122 835 32 confession s 55 S 973 e 172 885 38 assumed risk 18 55 S 992 52 93 f 1S7 d28 M 37 M agreement 55M brokerage 127 liability d 67 M 269 867 1 538 625 91 M 353 656 I37pnvilege s 56S 540 19A0 363n incrimination recovery 78 M misrepresentatn 83 M 441 8 39CP 37n 45d 546]|39amendmt !s 66 S 637 274 e 80 604 7 AC 89n new pleading tSAC 167n 392 49 weight ev 8 55 S 984 e 162 NY 385 35 M 84lig4 fg„^„g presumption u =70 68LRA 803n^^^fNY 41 118 52 charge error 191NY 157 presume neg. 135 53 error ev 8 6SS 61 85 fact question 39 52M 908 226 638 284 216 99 alienation 491 635 674 -,,„ o 66 S ?i?28M 327js30M ^° income 117 68 720 140 prohibited s 56 S 561 77 M 509 1 44 inspn banks a 66 3 f 38 4 f fl03 discovery 85 87 88 667 640 470 621 35 676 473 549 irAfi 979'^' 1 1 ^ ;'" 1 46 assignment 07 i99 r„=„"ii;^' "'"?. sSeS 583 L u, f82M 14f37M 171 probable cause 'enforcement edlM ^83 107 laches 81 M 220 I8S7S 414 56 error ev |73, 469 494 8 65 S 1020 full costs s38 528 50 M 620 8 62 14 16 general denial f 209 NY- f 209 NY dishonesty 89 M 402 403 457 962 new trial 16 AC 125n 109 stipulation 8 66 S 636 e 97 534 60 damages s55S a 165 NY do 171 NY 58LRA presumption 69LRA561n 662nis 56 S 69 LEA 665n;56M resident 147 1 1 I amendment B 66 S 604 636 'pleading 159 8 AC 133 1 1 12 sup. pro. 627 121 lOSn 67 commissions 8 65 S 976 31 M 269 36 M 645 19AC 468n duty plaintiff get names 52C'1CPNS 195 e61 M 376 designate pers.j. ICPNS 194 I 1 9 affidavit s 66 S 640 81 443 153 defense s 56 S 126 708 demand damge? 126 708 1 59 directors s 56 S 642 44 563 565 566 presumption 34 M 485 72 M 2 1 64 title street 66 S a 167 NY 65 e73 do 73 106 e36M 8 169 NY 537 207 pun damage 66 S 647 12 AC 79n80n 87n 2l5vacate order 56S 637 136 645 220 taxn new s 56 S 712 f38 629 630 affidavits 44 M 278 9 AC 420n 14 AC 26n diPburFements 51 M 643 retaxation 122 384 04M 37-8 223 gift inter vivos s 66 S 496 a 160 NY 489 49 550 trust deed 120 268 227 bona fides s 56 S 991 e 28 M 125 30 M 595 inequality 134 718 513 625 236 9 AC 26 258 606 408 72 482 129 270 126n 284marriage set'*^ tlement n 67 S 30 a 162 NY 104 295 atty author ity 57 S 604 r 167 NY 285 27 M 445 29 CP 154 3 1 I damages s67S a 167 NY 3 I 4 consent s57S attorney d95 compensation 9 AC 46 101 s 56 S 443 power in streets 93 416 f 162 48 360 title lien s 56 S 696 50 94 d 179 11 nee. party 116 847 848 '18 :38 19 AC 186, 191 365 ordinance 8 56 S 609 test 81 10 131 369 relief 8 56S 84 ;;07!S 103 bar 97n91 95 3l5ad'lcost3 176 8 67S 9'34M 60 25 723 230 456 128 396 406 801 769 3 I 9 jurisdiction 8 66 S 989 111 38 39 M 479 41 M 79 remedy 18AC 141 cost retax 64 M 37 38 no accounting 405 234 full costs 146 323 license 3 67S r 160 NY 13 AC 1038 109 491 94 118 704 184 394 389 393 416 468 469 567 s66S f 38 new trial d41 82 175 special damages 12 AC 23n 57 LRA 882n com pet. ev. 18AC 227 negligence proof HI 562 allegation inj 111 562 admissible 20 AC 176r ejectment 58M 39 evidence title 145 611 240 drafts 5 57S r 167 NY 121 194 253 constitut'l s 67 S 21 r 167NY 194 e 44 607 604 rights 95 identity 52M 377 cross action 124 557 optional 189NY 91 two actions 37(1 38 9 374n 333 delivery 9 57 S 126 59 698 336 b particulars 56 S 997 80 153 fl31 808 review order 153 384 no review 185 713 38 CP stay 181 106 138, 140 377 title 8 56 8 a 169 NY 69 covenant 109 lien- 36CF 380 new trial 4/0 534 331 540 178 8 66S 72 e79 46M intent 76. M 662 465 13 241 defraud 639 384 conversion 8 56 S 356 339 coupn bonds 61 165 a 68 S » 5 , 8 169 NY 535 388 jurisdiction 344 collateral 3 58 S 16 a 166 NY 631 37 M 284 realize pledgee 146 302 349 chge venue s 66 S 666 s56S 40,3. 66 698 doss 536. 142 4.5,S f 165 159 8 179 NY 301 do 205NY 438 215 NY 263 action local do 205NY 439 ABBREVIATIONS: j c, criticised ; 1, limited , affirmed ; d, distinguished ; f, followed ; r, e, explained ; o, overL jled ; a, same case ; do. reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note dissentiriK opinion; p, parallel cas**. ; q» questioned Vols. 38, 39 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division 13 title realty 59 M 12 intervention 209 NY 182 394 ejectment a 56 S 447 ■a 166 NY 632 14 AC 250n executory 04 M 490 398 declarations 8 56 S 467 63 590 592 1E,7 478 61 M 613 negligence e 77 629 80 127 distinction 192 NY 487 proximate cause 157 479 cause accident do 185 377 403 trustee s 66 S 460 i 96 M 441 442 commissions 426 445 756 472 109 318 504 690 591 730 176 213 38 60 111 27 M 190 ^Y waiver 51 57 105 29 M 49 M 99M trusts f 96 M 447 excess income f 96 M 456 4 I 3 mandamus s 56 S 364 d 55 559 8 AC 205n 61 LRA 95 4 1 7 trust funds s 56 S 618 m 165 NY 485 188NY 314 counterclaim 54 M 594 pay income f 88 M 451 426 injunction s 56 ri 597 127 231 restraint trade 193 NY 502 431 compelfev s56S "551 s 47 636 185 NY 376 204NY 228 flOq 369 desiguatn paper ,138 610 incompetent 87 M 406 436 express trust s 56 S 470 121 534-5 44 I damages s 56 S 423 76 453e 454 f 47 M 385 repairs 16AC 455 455n 458n 460n 461n counterclaim 132 89 165 474 72 M 27 451 discretion B 56 S 659 76 M 440 457 judgmt on pleading a 56 S 479 7 AC 97n 463 exceptionu s^6 S 428 d 72 443 466 eviction s 66 S 632 8 AC 423n 425n error do 94 M 249 469 damages 8 56 S 420 53 396 prima facie ev 68 21 fact question 105 525 presumption 145 525 473 exr acctg 523 520 583 618 438 s56S s48 9 58 69 axecution 114 commissions 16A0 41511 jurisdiction s 114 913 determination 166 227 election do 166 229 t 89 M 662 compensation do 166 232 t 89 M 662 480 contract s56S a 160 NY f39 f 65 s 159 NY maintain 97 M 580 144 639 421 528 actus. 288 522 new trial 605 465 371 547 480 369o up 917 653 s56S 72 88 158 NY 126 15 AC summing 134 error 84 M improper remarks do 216 NY 579 525 holdg over s 56 S 611 61 M 313 assignment 185 751 right re-entry 185 751 251 528 surety s56 a 58 53 I directors 56 S 645 liability fixed 59 534 deed s56S 60 601 471 63 543 jurisdiction 8 56 8 351 M 465 466 pleading 44 M 18 496 89 M 128 recovery 136 presumed f 98 M 469 492 488 mistake 8 56 S 456 pub officer 42 assignment 52 preferences SO M 453 343 466 499 contract s56S r 166 NY 505 parties a56S * 169 NY 41 43 M 588 292 511 146 480 310 549 allegations 8 56 S 426 95 406 counterclaim 44 M 56 553 contract s 56 S 624 55 618 discharge 156 648 564 countr elm s 56 S 654 60 M 61 103M 492 573 contract s 56 S 484 a 167 NY 540 580 amend ver diet s56S 104 120 exceptions 185 5 1 5 covenant 8 56S d44 79 82 ' 163 20. AC 70 LRA construction 87 178 e 180 NY 48 M dwelling ■ 164 restrictions 14 NY 341 483 3 6 362 75n 748 356 426 427 47 823 699 467 829 325 595 remedy s56S 49 sura procd 65 148 153 attorneys 72 s6 AC SAC 665 26 526 60 375 81 341 312d 599 vested int. s 58 S 1149 87 M 655 authority f 182 274 607 limitations 8 57S 1)8, 66 68 86 d86 e40M 344 161 433 435 326 6 1 penalty s57S 116 59 11 216 NY 219 6 1 2 fact question s 56 S 939 e94 412 6 I 5 removal s 56 S 943 48 450 6 1 9 appeal case 1 8 55S 1105 *159 NY 542 B22 bill partieul case 1 s 56 g 15 AC discovery case 2 310 183n VOL.39 5 contrib. neg. B57S postponement 11 AC 375 8 subrogation 8 56 S S2I 104 143 1 2 distribution B 56 S 917 37 M 466 1 8 pledge bonds 8 56 S 865 39 22 2 I possession a 56S 867 133 385 22 chge. grade 8 56 S 938 e 83 138 86 216 179 KY s58S 39 M 18AC appeal case 3 s55S 58 S *159 NY 84 240 194n 59 1142 531 624 malfeasance case 37 8 56 S 1046 S 439 a 167 NY 538 627 appeal case 7 s56S 1116 a 166 NY 637 628 fd transfer s 56 S 998 r 166 NY 82 50 27 M 70 knowledge lOOM 611 829 estoppel case 2 s56S 711 a 165 NY 534 630 pledgee case 2 8 56S 1107 r 167 NY 121 63 1 conclusive case 2 s 56 S 1000 170 NY 278 r 167 NY 608 636 stay case 1 s56S 8 29M 8 160 NY 1115 47S 663 640 injunction case 1 8 57S a 165 NY consol act case 7 8 57S a 159 NY bab corpus case 10 8 57S a 16« NY appeal case 21 8 57S a 167 NY 1141 572 1138 225 1144 570 1136 .539 25 lien notice 8 56S a 167 NY 90 14 AC filing 34 M 331 452 537 •326 600 34 r r branch B 56 S 869 r 160 NY 226 r 176 US 335 doctrine limit 177 703 appropriate Ind 177 703, 70S 89 nuisance 8 56 S 731 a 165 NY 631 136 201 73 right way s 56 S 847 r 16S NY 524 83pers. liability s 56 S 603 199 NY 339 9 I amendment 3 56 S 586 39 M 95 ice owner 8 56 S 690 43 224 46 M 483 99 deposit a 56 S 693 a. 161 NY 564 gift deposit 118 450 103 parties 9 56S 48 56 e38M 54 M 71 M partition e61 173 NY presumption 98 presume deliv'y 138 453 adverse claim 310 NY 465 794 373 308 656 527 278 10 97 290 107 filing s56S a 165 NY 41 M 791 636 184 110 fishing priv s 66 S 834 description river 13 219 3 58 S 239 extra allow 113 411 781 179 427 reservation 62 M 197 abstract water 62 M 209 no rigbt 65M 276 adverse possn. 155 683 title in state f 219 NY 75 f 82 M 75 excluded 104M 179 1 23 grant 8 56 S 681 a 159 NY 636 land under water 57 276 279 J 166 NY 457 130 fd check 3 57S 100 50 consideration 50 107 presumption 99 122 1 33 negligence 3 57S 16S a 169 NY 579 s 58 S 190 57 466 1 44 fact question s 57 S 182 73 38 right of appeal 154 174 1 5 1 stockholder s 57 S 187 a 162 NY 179 51 215 217 8 162 NY eSlM 30 CP comity. 125 AD receiver 78 M capacity to ■ 87- M 186 193 314 311 sue 434 1 62 overflow 8 57 S 198 61 91 1 66 notice 8 57 S 172 604 174 recovery 3 57 S 284 f41 624 45 411 71 233 31 M 159 a 167 NY 637 1 90 unconstitutl s 57 S 266 53 . 640 legis power f 44 M 359 212 vendor lien s 57 S 137 2U? NY -416 106 cquit. lien 123 104 2 1 8 warranty 505 s57S 14 AC proof 158 46 53' 39 M 106 28911 463 431 612 637 63S mplied conditns 113 £81 223 negligence s 67 S 145 s 53 498 499 229 negligen s 57 S 109 fellow servant 49 506 64 70 136 54 LRA 124ii not liable 156 43 232 serv on corp s5TS 104 105 waiver 51 M receiver 16AC 6S7 305 641 52M 624 exemption 38 CP 182 taxes pension 38 CP 183n power remedy 139 416 1 83 constl law 3 57 S 290 a 169 NY 613 107 478 109 274 stockhldrs 194 NY 233 1 88 pers injury 3 57 S 293 292296 rr. acctng. 37 CP 273 236aerv. process s57S 111 9 AC 267n 104 675 241 wife 8 57 S 236 crdr of husband 61 475 do 61 477 agreement void 14 AC 209n 18AC 25n 245 construction s 57 S 261 39 652 f 39 655 7 AC 601n 248 preference s 57 S 131 37 M 473 474 251 warranties 1009 568 616 273 179 s56S a 167 NY 52 d76 .i7M burden deft. 78 20 warranty fact 81 89 cond. prcdt. 62 M 549 265 certif con- viction s 56 S 930 111 . 321 commitment 71 M 619 278 misstatem't 3 57 S 60 58 81 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, disipissed; n, «ou c, criticised; 1, limited; e, tixolained; o, overruled; s, same caie. do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, quMtio»W N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division Vols. 39, 40 equity 40 M 60! breach damagea 106 i(55 302private sale s 56 S 963 5-t M 458 309 to jury s 56 S 905 do 98 M 225 321 realty s 56S 925 182 300 subrogation do 183 88 327 nee dam. s S6 S 933 a 161 NY 660 333 assessment s 56 S 976 a 167 NY 68 110 971 f 87 M 9 67 LRA 850n presumption 80 M 420 353 new trial s 56 S 954 69 M 424 36") bequest s 5T S 407 a ino NY 68 1 56M 246 379 assessment 8 57 S 338 a 167 NY 597 f 52 621 ref to statute 95 554 558 34 M 723 6 160 NY 669 390 intention B 57 8 ! a 167 NY 582 54 123 7S M _ 5:t3 reformation 73 113 statute limitns. s40M 61 e 46 M 320 398 claim s 57 S 349 e 68 276 eq. jurisdiction 1 160 486 403 presumptiou g 57 S 437 a 162 NY 87 29 M 741 4 1 3 commission s 57 S 336 48 634 change venue 57 635 f 64 625 66 205 89 625 98 153 124 636 8 4B M 235 4 1 6 protest 8 57S 416 B 45 188 7 AC 106 waiver lie 495 38 CP 29 420 part'tiin s 67 8 341 8 66 307 47 M 21 424 friv plead'g 8 67 S 355 45 559 9 AC 166 167 426 jurisdiction 8 57 8 336 43 46 119 672 39 CP, 314 legislative power 53 540 82 M 632 432 reaaonable 8 67S 347 79 408 102 106 51 LRA 157 arbitrary power 117 864 435 contrib neg- 8 57 8 344 do 81 410 for jury 145 78 440 lien sale 8 57 8 201 75 97 covenant dam 110 480 482 reservation 110 482 eq. relief 121 84; rescission 121 844 no demand e 221NY 140 enforce lien 221NY 141 45 1 damages 8 57 S 422 96 347 dismissal 132 349 uinendment 132 351 454 conviction 8 57 8 ' 420 73 432 459 surety s57 8 139 f 49 120 90 M damages 93 137 32 M gambling 114 81 M 203 NY 372 661 630 658 164 33 393 261 656 261 77 466 report abso lute 8 57 8 427 al61 NY 643 72 106 34 M 271 4o M 82 S160NY 512 acctg exceptions 33 C 118 477 chat, mtge s 57 S 338 55 519 482 nuisance s 57S 330 injuncn. damage 29M 172 e 31 M 634 33M 665 100 410 impair health lOOM 622 485 testator pwr 9 57 S 390 a 166 NY 673 110 476 appt.guardn. 18AC 50n, Bin 18 AC 52, 52n sp. compensatn. 145 548 490 neghgence s 57 S 225 s 89 571 103 316 incomp. ev. 117 379 497 negligence s 57 326 law question 47 483 a 56 181 58 102 62 375 e 97 397 st intersection 84 599 fact question 63 91 167 65 486 73 250 85 89 97 451 30 M 615 assumption 112 659 502 pers. injury S57S 314 r 167 NY 163 506 jurisdiction 8 57S? 317 59 130 93 377 38 M 10 5 1 accounting s 57 8 444 28 M 679 distribution f 172 817 41 M 382 515 defects s 57 S 299 cured by ans. 50 342 97 423 discretion 15 AC 275 16AC 335 n complt suf. 117 224 libel pleading 120 575 relief do 38 CP 156 525 mitigation s 57 S 303 63 62 32 CP 164 71 M 111 529 20 days s 5.7 8 323 f 173 678 532 practice s57 8 313 8 AC 490u 533 stipulation 8 57 8 306 60 320 court's power -4M 52S 536 neg Jam. 3 57 S 587 r 165 NY 457 warning 186 NY 354 fact question 16AC 323n 543 practice s 67 8 332 8AC 490n 545 neg charge s 67 8 318 67 63 d 172 255 548 trust vn'd a 57 8 452 97 644 34 CP 75 trust valid d 118 4 express trust 121 534 563 demurrer s 57 8 080 i 188 NY 673 567 negligence s 57 S 708 e?l 159 576 jurisdiction s 578 776 133 288 58 1 admissions ■i 57 S 670 e 50 334 335 reUef 28 M 732 court power 54M 89 no power do 138 296 586 subrogation s 67 8 703 37 M 37 589 em domain 57 LRA 937n fixtures f 213 NY 36 69 M 300 598 neg dam. 8 57 8 755 d 74 394 54 LRA 123d 602 presumption s 67 S 706 48 264 80 • 118 505 surety s 57 S 972 a 160 NY 504 43 681 d 44 249 251 252 e 80 606 609 transfer tax 8 57 8 786 1160 NY 87 f 167 NY 460 6 1 7 contract s 58 S 405 I: 167 NY 450 624 damages 3 57 S 784 d 59 69 65 66 s78 319 320 79 348 d 97 38 39 65 LRA 381 breach e 105 272 hospital neg, 18AC 370n 4ndeinn)ty ISAC 371n 61 M 503 90 M 2 liability 128 215 negligence A 135 180 new trial 96 M 293 629 discovery case 3 9 56 8 633 73 624 3tf M 248 63 I insurance 3 67 S 683 r 167 NY 261 638 appeal caae 18 s57 8 1136 al70 NY 678 certiorari case 21 s 57 S 1144 a 159 NY 536 trust valid 145 875 639 partition case 3 ' s57S 1137 a 160 NY 494 appeal case 9 s 57 S 1140 a 165 NY 635 97 J* 288 640 award 57 8 102 52 ^124 125 85 211 confir med 129 712 53 M 333 rental damage do 129 723 105 633 64 1 appeal caae 3 s 57 S 1136 *160 NY 667 accounting esse 5 s 57 8 1138 a 165 NY 584 646 injunction a 5TS 104 ^'ase 2 01 M 131 647 weight ev f57S 203 50 91 53 648 a 06 337 338 65 I asaault case 1 a 57 8 1136 a 168 NY 690 assessment case 2 3 67 S 263 a 169 NY 571 652 damages s 57 8 133 s 70 422 654 objections 57 LRA 908 172 855 655 new trial case 2 3 67 8 1136 a 169 NY 593 negligence caae 6 3 57 8 1148 a 173 NY 597 appeal case 27 59 8 1108 *159 NY 570 656 chge venue case 20 s57S f39 810 667 657 appeal case 2 s 67 8 297 a 167 NY 542 658 review caae 2 a 57 8 416 court's power 40 452 490 53 230 case 4 act aside verdt 357 8 716 46M 426 31 C P 14 66 1 weight ev, case 1 s 57 S 376 31 M 825 estoppel 147 379 153 484 conclusive case 3 3 57S 311 136 375 injunction 35M 366 662 damages 57 8 435 d 42 614 663 negligence 3 57 S 4^4 8 61 216 do 61 218 5 87 321 do 87 325 664 damages 3 57 a 320 8 49 630 665 commissions a 57 8 687 a 167 NY 606 f 39 667 3 63 148 e 86 269 667 commisBioa& a 57 S 691 63 148 668 contract u<.se 1 s 57S 305 65U 575 dangers case 2 3 57 S 334 42 M 25 f 172 135 ev. negligence 185 271 670 appeal case 1 164 709 case 15 s57S 1144 *160 NY 688 67 1 misstatemt case 18 B 57 8 1137 33 M 246 7 AC 12n VOL. 40 I restriction 8 57 S 569 a 166 NY 621 75 597 87 359 covenants f 172 204 55M 336 d 210 NY 249 d 210 NY 250 injunction 58M 441 easement 132 626 7 bar s 578 561 40 213 quan meruit 45 328 53 601 do 99 479 mitigation deft 63 350 13 fr'd trnasfer a 57 8 839 18 appeal ■■i 57 S r 168 NY 791 242 23 remediea a 57 S 502 67 442 26 signal neg. 3 57 .S 577 69^ 387 120 457 law question 76 493 »1 376 tieg rule 79 . 34 carrier neg. 59 M 4H jury queation 134 630 76 M 197 contrib. neglig. 136 766 28 recital s57 3 bi6 48 483 costs 30 M 632 30 taxable costs 3 57 8 623 a 160 NY 448 a 160NY Gffi excess •45 625 49 3 authority 28M 310 34 M 101 3 7 AC 28 allowance 186 NY 540 e80 514 132 34 60 M 572 guard ad litem 33 M 184 costs 132 34 fee spcl. gdn . 19 AC 88n unlawful e 182 374 34 notes s57S 479 a 167 NY 584 waiver 60 M 608 41 assess ac. ins. 8 57 8 527 s42 626 ABBREVIATIONS: a. affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed: n, note- e. criticised: I, limited; e, explained; o. overruled: s. same case; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel tis-j; q, questioned Vol. 40 N. Y. Supreme Coart Reports — ^Appellate Division 46 revocation 33 M . 327 8 57 S 634 private examin a 160 NY 96 9 AC 46n 59 219 222 10 AC 17 95 lien proof consent s 57 S 663 28 M 627 40 252 8 161 NY 119 intervention 41M 122 43 M 408 55 liability 101 contempt s 57 S 525 s 57 S 663 173 484 a 161 NY 115 no notice 52 624 174 166 84 406 109 36 58 bond lien 13 AC 187 8 57 S 727 163 NY 274 165 NY 301 31 CP 47 mechanic's lien jnriidiction 120 449 51 M 32B liability demand not nee 149 727 65M 164 i 83 M 482 compliance 1 08 jurisdiction 79 M 363 8 57 S 531 not defeat lien 97 263 79 M 360 reference 31 M 300 65 certiorari s 57 S 636 admissible 318 NY 389 a 159 NY 569 1 1 2 writ of assistance 5 57S 639 certificate exemption d 121 231 190NY 501 15 AC 239n prior lien 69 jurisdiction 1B3 608 s 57 S 844 168 88 * 170 NY 577 7AC 55d 1 1 4 limitation 8 57 S 835 73 accounting 42 256 57 S 548 30 CP 176 95 452 31 CP 212 a 163 NY 6S1 costs duty trust 47 361 45 M 302 a 47 491 genl. guardian 54 446 178 7 35 CP 38 f 90 M 536 ord conclusiun surplus income 85 673 178 6, 7 accounting do 178 10 f33M 17 56 M 226 78 authority execution leave 8 57 S 542 105 588 f 71 209 surety 120 fact question 78 173 3 54 S 28 81 95 ? 57 S 582 merits 51 334 90 555 intent decision form 37 M 69 7 AC 501n 98 260 124 frd. transfei covenants s57 724 57 M 470 67 LEA 608n exonerated lien trust 145 107 62 M 640 81 reargument s 57 S 632 b57S 1123 1 29 courts power s 57 S 712 49 M 634 f 57 626 special injury 75M 229, f 230 connection r r 89 384 181 NY 436 maintainable 78 M 219 motion 51 M 646 pleadi ng 52M 485 demurrer fl5M 520 amendment 65M 520 \ 33 consents 86 conclusive s S7S 629 8 57 S 559 33 M _ 646 87 66 revocation practice 32 M 463 7ACllnl4n24n 128 876 lOOM 117 8 AC 123 I37pwr. at end ultra vires 8 57 S 614 140 253 139 676 89 presumption l4lbondholders s 57 637 s 57S 892 a 167 NY 599 133 289 distinction 181 731 1 44 negligence s 57 S 896 d 47 502 contrib. neg 86 390 109 208 circumstance d30M 615 I49burden proof s 57 S 833 57M 554 bailee liable 133 95 negligence 71 M 105 1 56 will trust g 57 S 916 123 . 236 1 63 fact question 208 contract s68S g a 170 NY 568 2 1 I irregular 8 58 S 22 s 54 672 2 1 3 discharge 8 57 S 1038 burd on deft 53 601 contract entire do 63 360 breach damages do 99 479 2 1 5 intent s67S U AC contract )3AC 66 S a 166 NY 44 46 f 107 t 212 NY f38M 86 M libel per se 57 ■" Uemurrer 4 AC 853 392 530 316 , 626 344 690 227 9 417n 1069 671 619 421 1 65 guardian a 67 S 862 a 160 NY 685 appt. guards 18AC 53d unauthorized 92 M 618 power court f 220NY 539 \ 69 deposit s 57 S 847 demand reason- able 8 54 76 8 AC 207 penalty 8 AC 202i, I 75 discretion 225 title s67S a 159 NY f44 penalty 70 M adv. possession 224Ny 350 23 1 note for debt 8 57S 1059 16A0 142-3n 234 substitution a 57 S 1037 9 AC 228n 230n 236 exrs & trus- 9 67S 102 i ability 124 directors 129 854 339 731 44 1 80 insurance 3 57 S 871 r 160 NY 19 193 commissions 3 57S -sg? 112 636 197 ct. error s67S 50 58 conclusive 59 38 101 851 530 387 241 802 68 200 adv. possn. s 67 S 106) 50 M 441 202 lease 57 S a 167 NY 1121 570 204 damages s68S 11 185 752 61 M 81 206 direct acquittal s 58 S 84 M 13 352 1103 2871. 389o 220 no consent s57S 74M 1125 263 268 license 9 57 S 983 13 AC 385 n 275 assignment s 67 S 1049 28 M 692 e 97 649 184 NY 492 written consnt 115 99 281 award 8 58 S 68 219 NY 408 interest taxes 69 605 136 441 Eonfirmations 36 M 464 deduction 169 NY 459 460 right interest 150 218 150 219 date damages 173 255 296 f'd transfer s 57 S 1023 r 165 NY 481 error amend 216 NY 226 93 M 588 305 jurisdiction s57S 51 1073 507 238 pub. use St. sS7S 1112 43 50U lOOM 503 jury question 127 . 420 paramount right ( 168 609 245 commission 8 58S ta 67 523 service corpn 37 M 681 253 incomp ev. e59S 84 52 56 255garties 20-1 61 1() 68 30!; adverse possessn 173 NY 97 construe will 57M 50-J 260 f'd intent s57S 107(1 SO 346 347 111 37(: 31 M 62 validity 172 'Mh good faith 102M 400 108M 75 264 trust 9 57S 1006 83 283 171 88U trustee 33 M 405 39 M 503 504 partition 51 M 173 conversion d 137 17 do 164NY 223 31 CP 330 339 343 damages 8 67 S 1063 s 159 NY 573 a 162 NY 202 348 conversion s 67 S 323 84 M 22 354 m'k title 8 67 S 1094 a 167 NY 599 69 331 81 211 50 M 436 burden proof 50 M 437 adverse possessn 50 M 438 359 receiver s57S a 167 NY powers 44 58 1018 301 42 169 s67S a 16 NY 7 AC 70LRA 134 215 NY f lOOM 1033 543 53n 548d 576 540 485 307 contrib neg 8 57 S 907 a 166 NY 58!) 44 166 fact question 509 373 566 657 602 262 404 198 570 615 63 "i 242 185 190 698 556 e91 do 178 187NY 30 M 32 M 58 M 77 M requests 56 collision 124 assumption 112 error charge 160 282 320 neg damage 3 57 S 969 a 166 NY 103 diligence 155 187 324 master neg 8 57 S 989 a 167 NY 542 68 474 65 LRA 276n 33 1 sup'l complt 8 67 S 1039 a 160 NY 691 58 122 unauth judgmt 164 NY 213 do 164 NY 221 do 164NY 222 366 discontinue s 67 S 985 7 AC 428n 367 accounting s 57 S 961 58 416 37 1 h & wife 58 S 76 a 166 NY 627 14 AC 263n fontract obligtn 150 209 93 M 680 381 negligence s 57 S 1075 169 165 •WO liability 57 S 1100 d 214 NY 564 405 in.' unction s 57 S 975 391VI 42 52M 204 .J8 CP 49'; positive allegatn 39 M 49 118 31 409 firemen 57 S 1047 sS9S 75 provision 90 33 M SAC 9 AC discretion 120 receiver 125 a 165 NY half-pay "40 3 160 NY 4 1 2 assault 57 S 32 M 419 plea unnecessary s 57 S 143 pleading S8 M 654 620 669 977 674 980 869 424 ultra s57S 32 M minority stockholders do 154 vires 1015 273 35 429 neg. atty s 68 S 266 7 AC 387n 44 1 negligence h5SS 132 71 21 444 amendment 146 620 323 400 186 316 237 s6SS f40 43 dl55 error 61 98 67 M reimbursement 81 606 terms costs 7 AC 86 91n 109 158 129 411 131 80 ICPNS 245 terms appeal 124 523 reason for terms 139 679 cond. precedent 63 M 51 446 covenant 54 309 3 504 lllij 242 322 543 447 vendor lien a 68 S 115 f 40 620 r 169 NY 555 45 1 decision 358 S 167 53 230 31 CP 149 452 assessment 3 68 S 100 a 161 NY 622 rule e 46 55 56 e 49 116-118- 51 439 85 369 !)8 M 724 nterest objectns e95 06 107 s29M 36 M 3 39M 569 426 24 491 592 734 699 460 adultery i 68 S 143 193 NY 411,416 i7 M 674 defense 36 M 536 support wife 119 641 no bar f 84 M 410 465 construction 8 58 S 244 a 167 NY 684 58 . 141 ans warranties e 81 88 89 waiver 151 f 151 151 38 M authority 60 competent ev^ 45 M 699 insurance £ 217 NY 217 NY contract 222NY warranties d 184 267 268 289 270 ' 482 42P 342 345 43 234 ABBREVIATIONS: a, iffirmed; d. distinguished ; {.followed; r, reversed; m, modified; /. dismissed; n.|>u't c. criticised; 1, limited; e. explained; o, overruled : s. same case: do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case. o. quesuon™ N. Y. Sapreme Court Reports — Appellate Division Vols. 40, 41 477claim basU s S8 S 129 46 17 104 93 204NY 287 480 SUpCt. PWT. 8 58 S d45 iurisdictioQ 56 74 diecretion 9 AC reappraisal 9 AC 126 482 St construc- tion act f 171 245 legislative power 105 421 right of way d 120 281 do 120 284, 283 do 120 287 award 426 e 120 construction 130 135 easement f 143 impld covenant 143 570 128 481 460 116n 303 527 524 568 b58S 138 f52 363 do 78 138 -140 31 M 56 salary e40M 535 estoppel 121 866 489 ct s power s58S 12fl 40 452 S3 23f 31 CP )4a 525 countrclaim S58S S8 _ . 73 40|DU7 weieht ev- demurrer suffic. ! case 2 593 neg d&m 3 58 S 168NY defense 126 68 M 99 M contrib. 20 AC 642 6 1 9 trade mark case 11 s58 S 1138 56 148 e 29 M 249 9 AC 31 500 28V 119 neglig. 24411 603 appearance i58 S 70 8 AC 319n non residents 166 88 170 143 622 490 libel s 58 S 134 42 M 78 strike out relevnl 120 317 45 M 276 f 173 910 493 reimburse- ment s 58 S 179 e 93 223 funeral claims 75M 82 regularity q 75M 81 498 interpleadei 49 M 533 waiver 58 S evidence 83 98 M 13 AC 152n 153 no variance 148 881 mdorser 98 M 622 539 jurisdiction 9 58 S 42 a 167 NY 533 92 183 544 nuisance s 58 S 36 £ 172 615 s57S ;al68NY 85 3 159 NY 691 206 563 125 236 180 276 s58S 60 72 77 104 28 M 35 M 32 CP 66LRA 204NY 502 dismissal 8 58S 110 78 66 15 AC . 331n lessor neglig. 51 M liability 19A0 552 allow s 58 S f 161 284 608 negligence s 57 S 544 40 145 d 47 502 e 56 512 contributory e 86 390 109 208 609 damages case 1 s 57 S 541 a 166 NY 628 6 1 decree case 2 s57S ^48 3 61 61 620 amendment case 1 s 58 S 147 terms costs 81 606 7 AC 91n 109 158 Bill 175 ICPXS 245 cond. precedent 131 80 63M 51 amendment case 3 b57S s 160 NY a 165 NY 621 note case 1 s57S * 160 NY VOL. 41 I damages 8 58 S 67 r 165 NY 657 substitution 137 264 6 certificate ev. s 58S 82 31 M 393 7AC 459 460n 8 adv possession 5SS 65 59 622 1 2 revocation jharge 581 88 84 error 33 M 93 right of way 9 58S 619 a 168 NY 610 1 06 ordinance el03 1146 675 650 1014 665 a58S AC 24 services s58S a 169 NY f69 557AppDi vision s 58 y 35 101 319 557power court s 58 S 85 M 622 discovery s 57 S 986 41 M 620 623 f d transfer case 1 b58S ; 89 36< 1150 542 644 414 418 617 622 Supreme Court e 63 19 20 do 174 NY 244 624 loan 8 57S a 167 NY 626 charge s57S 33 M 6 I I stay case 1 35|s57S 497 9 165 NY case 2 3 57S a 165 NY 559 certiorari 93!s58S 94 43]al60NY 202 208 'd 53 65 46 1 92 93:564 confirmance 287 [9 58 S 50 49 398 39 M 395 42 M 658 eio , practice 613 appeal 1,30 196 o^«" Power court i^ 1 oa wv 130 196— 8,"!''="^ ICPNS 183 1 referee report 624 604 51 605 301 57 506 merger 9S8S r 167 NY 182 348 5 1 3 contract s 58 S 91 54 227 230n combination 85 e30M 175 NY 64LRA legal 55 M injunction 129 450 679 15 695 697 731n 6 I 2burden proof case 1 s57S s 165 NY a 169 NY 583 666 120 1146 411 92 M ICPNS new trial ICPN^S £ 83 M 615 accounting Qni lease 3 lriOiS57S 1128 a 162 NY 611 burd. contest- ants 73 51 574 182 597 756 5 1 9 descript on e58S a 161 NY intention 83 163 622 338 516 568 pleading s 58 S 49 72 223 570 jurisdiction s 57S 1131 a 160 NY 687 71 230 574 partition a 85 S 45 r 166NY 406 58 I insurance 3 58 3 119 74 531 590 exception 8 58 S 52 1090 538 994 794 s58S *166Nr 90 dl07 city liable e 124 46 M streets safe 116 292 23n 266 590 54 353 165 11 629 1 7 1 eond. deliv. 3 58 S 831 45 240 law question 62 622 97 250 fact question 50 M 291 parol notice 63 484 100 12 valid agreement I 23 contractoi 100 oral 117 liability f71M a58S 9 160 NY ial61Ny 277 trespass 582|ll7'^ 84 liability non-performanc 117 6. 7, damages 417 13 90 173 NY f 181 NY interest 111 116 f 167 16 AC error court 135 no interest 140 unliquidated 80 179 657 81 173 521 674 661 308 309 327 d 130 appropriation T7 M 545 181 211; 126 laches 4oi s58S 44 a 169 NY 2051 „,,[I3I waiver 8'"9 59S 6 1 7 discretion a 57 S 914 68 479 change ev. 125 554 burden proof 128 135 6 1 8 appeal case 23 s58S 1144 a 165 NY 663 6 1 8 damages case 24 B 58 S 1145 a 166 NY 394 628 insurance s 68 S 148 8 160 NY 670 a 167 NY 596 ' 'building' ' 85 M 600 632 contempt 8 57 S 987 51 ( 122 369 DO contempt 132 333 72 M 119 punishment 140 328 103M 538 teas, certainty 148 432 633 appeal case 1 s 68 S 1144 * 160 NY 686 award damages case 18 s 58 S 1139 185 NY 561 633 mandams case 22 s58S 1146 a 160 NY 103 30 sale damages 3 58S 612 a 169NY 671 40 forgery 9 58S r 168 NY 439 10 43 stockholders s 58 S 346 45 321 107 474 confiscation 124 266 764 612 613 79 298 299 limitations 124 79 plaintiff's righ; 173 302 as agent 173 301 40 construction 9 58S a 168 NY 48 intent 82 441 658 290 22 1 48 right of way conversion' i?Q.f? -«« bo? s58S 413!^''^° ^°" ^2° 53 79 title s tone Si 9 58P 54LRA CO Pervant 123 c 138 81 M 117 195 reasnable access 57 pub. policy 9 68S 353 62 121 67 587 ■jquity 86 544 66 negligence 210 61n 679 22 322 78 negligence s 58 S 193 65 355 juivq ion 120 649 84 pecuniary cir- cumstances s 58 S 223 *160 NY 665 57 636 allppations 109 187 89 fact s68S 52 f52 146 necessity 81 M 196 35D 48 proof 67 496 263 1 78 notices s58S e95 29 M 34 M 794 30 30 603 H65 669 739 698 356 28 1 53 undue infiu. s 58 S 450 38 M 272 90 M 533 burden proof 68 M 586 capacity 90 M 238 1 58 negligence 8 58 S 797 a 166 NY 616 d 133 463 do 156 400 contrib. negl. d 133 465 185 182 take chances 156 807 fact question 55 29 do 55 35 60 272 64 109 97 45] freedom from neg 35 M 36 M 40 M elOo local option 120 900n resubmission 57M 677 compliance 62 M 337 validity 20 AC 254n 193 misjoinder 3 58 S 816 101 611 14 AC 39n resp. superior 192NY 507 200 note gift s 58 S 745 s 161 NY 639 a 167 NY 97 204 discretion 3 58 S 812 63 369 2 1 3fact question s 58 S 490 55 514 83 609 59 LRA 498 prox. cause 110 667 135 326 do 330 201 NY 224 2 1 8neg. damages s 58 S 479 a 168 NY 667 224 tender 58 S 58 67 77 do 78 87 113 13 AC 71 167 NY 73 74 168 NY question 281282 628 411 211 212 425 428 24 505 532 655 229 mark, title 8 58S 47 e28M personalty 34 M 38 M ratification 171 NY estoppel 55 93 rule 113 conclusion 130 133 150 title proceeds 133 681 conclusive ICPNS 322 470 348 661 420 176 657 458 518 901 809 683 662 ABBREVIATIONS : c, criticised ; 1, limited ; affirmed; d. distinguished; f. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; :, explained ; o, overruled ; s, same case ; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; a. queationsd Vol. 41 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division 235 construction city liable s58S 536 T 3 M 650 r 166 NY 156L„_ el06 83 85:298 competev s 58 S 245 damaees B 58 S 467 52 660 167 404 247 vesting 8 58 S 635 81 502 ■alienability 49 M 7 255 perm injuiy s 58 S 462 « 73 256 257 jurisdiction s 58 S 510 a 161 NY 492 do 155 335 m 406 92 266 s 160 NY 674 receiver 155 333 separate fund 164 590 just distribution 173 321 f 173 322 269 teachers ^ 58 S 468 right prnmotion d 85 49 54 qualitication 127 238 27 I consent 8 58 S 632 do 53 590 59 174 219 59 223 e 28 M 627 assignees .33 M 247 revocation 7 AC 23n 25n 9 AC 460n liq. certit prop. e AC 4S4n rebate forfeit 177 22 10 AC 18,29 not authorized 177 22 as security 177 25 274 neg. dam. s 68 S 606 32 M 573 280 alimony 8 68 S 667 a 162 NY 406 d 169 599 40 M 163 modificafion 7 AC 179n a 181 US 183 s 160 NY 671 58 LRA 472 65 LRA 817 appearance 126 602 ■fl-aiver consent 138 471 remedies 142 462 construction 143 431 290 adv. possess s 58 S 402 a 167 NY 234 50 121 amendment 51 383 384 82 97 53M 563 293 neg. notice 8 58 S ' 499 57 442 SO 43 M 85 M 54 LRA 494 474 S9101 408 174n 302 master neg. 8 58 S 458 82 511 masters duty 149 821 54 LRA 69n safe place 188NY 343 jury question 134 240 nol co-servant 78 M 549 reasonable care ( 78 M 549 construction f 102M 9 305 police s 58 S 401 53 432 307excess verdt S-5B S 640 76 M 610 3 1 1 foreclosure s 58 S 464 s 170 NY 570 3 I 6 contract s 58 S 523 57 626 626 321 trust s 58 S 460 214 NY 485 debtor crdr. f 180 166 324 conclusive s 58 S 562 41 481 42 260 56 486 100 497 presumption 160 422 construct 105M 480 334 neg dam. 3 58 S 543 s 51 242 106 496 reverse error 112 6 339 neg dam. s 58 S 628 s 179 NY 137 d 51 291 292 69 91 81 612 82 639 32 M 722 36 M 149 duty rr co- 53 . 285 pub right 59 91 negligence S2M 167 pri\ate property 127 386 344 evidence B 58 S 661 77 293 347 separation 858 S 503 59 . 215 216 legal proof 83 126 not condoned 74M 56'; knowledpe 70 M evidence 156 673 412 352not intervne s 58 S 477 f 86 M 457 355 b. particul. s 58 S 497 101 171 357 consents 8 58 S 518 627 36 1 wife uecessr s 68 S 476 counsel fees 89 140 40 M 95 services d 43 M 679 legal advice 143 969 not final B 150 336 370 corp dam s 58 S 533 s 44 630 63 LRA 655 37& exemption s 68 S 558 41 394 taxes p«n3:on 38 PC 183n 38 1 statute 8 68 S 493 stricty fol'd. 40M 207 do47M 633 serve notice 1 8 AC 253n. 267 defect f 81 M 470 384 admissions s 58 S 550 112 331 3JjB sheriff fees 88 S 722 e 45 M 396 39 1 exemption s 58 S 774 a 165 NY 578 56 346 1 38 M 670 insur moneys 10 AC 4001^ 171 NY 320 321 399iurv question s 58S 839 132 40 safe place 133 805 408 findings B 58 S 783 29 M 169 co-tenants 61 LRA 170 174 interest 52M 446 secure wife 66M 415 4 1 service amended ans. s 58 S 822 79 23 8 AC 109n power strike out e 97 634 joint tenancy 79 887 4 1 3 joint iepoist 58 S 778 53M 613 husb. and wife 41 409 29 M 169 36 M 748 95 M 78 construction do 123 852 presumption 141 57 85 M 294 equal interest f 144 804 4 1 9 right pensn. s 59 S 735 80 M 310 423 no title s 58 S 726 162 325 425 weight Bv 8 68 S 867 52 217 f 34 M 801 426 negligence s 58 S 863 68 474 70 LRA 629 scope employ ment 70 LRA fi30 master neg. f 134 646 429 construction 3 58S 877 r]65 NY 472 433 trust s 58S 8S5 41 497 33 M 200 d 39 M 503 65M 137 vHsted 199 NY 464 443 corporation 3 68 S 865 exception rule 42 M 199 trustee 53M 383 profits 54M 116 good faith do 160 735 446 lex situs 8 68 S 856 d68 181 29 M 664 trespass committed 164 206 449 title 8 58 S 882 102 425 partnership d 125 129 130 458 pub. officer s 5SS 929 a 160 NY 689 46 196 confidential 73 468 78 267 X76 NY 465 civil service d 56 M 296 46 1 no recovery s 58S 951 lOOM 153 463 affidavit B 58 S 988 449 mandamus 163 232 99 M 11 465 contract s 58 S 983 54 M 621 legality 69 681 76 245 e 31 M 731 32M 701 44 M 145 15AC 164 by laws 130 132 unreasonable d 137 841 distinction 70 M 624 467composition 1 58 S 982 s4 AC son 470 prob. cause 8 68 S 992 do 85 100 inference 114 663 5 1 I prom, note s 58 S 60 a 166 NY 612 insufficient 78 M 292 counterclaim 78 M 293 waiver f 167 jury question 115 61 M 63 M 879 128 243 452 costs 3 58S 54 8 AC appeal 103 fO irre?. verdict f 108 322 reversal 17AC . 25S exemption 79 479 456 sup. pro 3 58 S 769 75 287 default 80 369 appeal 132 94 f 29. VI 746 40 M 250 authority 127 179 474 phys exam 6 58 S 984 12 AC 90n 3 7 CF 205 rule practice 114 829 discovery i56M 33 vacate order 143 214 practice to stay 148 025 477 trust s 58 S 1094 d 39 M 503 party interest 46M 179 482 comp ev. 3 58 S 710 r 167 NY 368 e 86 444 e 178 N Y 483 490 brokerage 8 58 S 807 judge's question 86 374 67 LRA 382d 493'due process' s 58S 180 74 M 177 498 taxatn s 58 S 670 71 230 42 M 92 506 iniunction s 58 S 650 42 62 74 relief 162 NY title d62 do 62 618 312 178 229 293 297 662 5 1 6 atty client 58 S 668 d 101 435 520 b partic 3 58 i? 820 73 510 79 631 11 AC 199 523 right dower 5 58 S 693 15 AC 311n case 21 526 insurance 68 S 656 * 160 NY 676 omit to plead 171 551 530 parties s 68 S 715 44 225 65 . 216 rent liable B 58S 643 45 M 22 532 assignee 3 68 S 643 69 LRA 683n 46M 220 privity 116 504 535 assignment 3 68 S 717 e 54 173 preference 30 M 221 44 M 35 31 CP 271 distribution 32 CP 354n secure equality 99M 504 540 encroachm't 3 58 S 671 8 AC . lOn bad title 122 877 judicial sale 58M 366 relief 184 349 544 ceri s"5S S 44 S e51 55 71 85 11 40 M e39M 40 M 47 M 30 CP ' ;orari 648 241 201J202 646 229-231 445 175 642 130 653 228 399 55 1 serv. publn. 8 58 S 697 r 167 NY 421 46 311 misnomer 52 248 218 261 682 684 633 substituted 30 M amendment 33 M 686 35 M 291-687 61 M aon presumption 47 M jurisdiction 111 objections HI designation 61 M nee parties 62 estoppel lOPNS 200 203 nullity ICPNS 212 correct mistake lOPNS 211 56 1 partnership s 68 S 790 retiring partner 46 639 surety 58 M ■ 572 567 amendment 8 68 S 724 62 M 316 ICPNS 226 571 deduction 3 588 713 63 560 574 master neg. s 58 S 659 53 91 581 discharge s 58 S 742 s 162 NY 60S 586 meas. dam ^ 3 68 S 736 44 233 street closing f 160 97 damages do 179 177 595 subpoena 58 S e65 40 M deposition wit- 695 347 130 14 AC 229n 596 affidavit 3 68S 682n 74 566 599 contract ^ 58 S 663 e 57 M 613 66LRA . 827 quan. meruit 119 ■ 66 atty. client loss 594 disbursements 57M . 613 attorney's lien 155 26 603 champerty 3 68 S 677 77 347 112 AC 253 6 1 2 wages 3 58S 287 r 169 NY 14 competency 80 M 5o5 6 1 3 death neg s 58 S „ff a 165 NY 666 54 LRA 1700 negligence 121 64 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, pote; I. eri'icised : 1. limited^ e, explained; o, overruled; •.same case; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, questionw N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division Vols. 41, 42 616 nee d s58S 59 6 1 7 appeal easel SS8 S a 167 NY appeal case 6 b58S m 161 NY 7 47 ! dismslc omplaint gy referee 68 S 160 NY 1143*^^. *81 6 exceptions 8 58S 1146 fl 19? 83 case? sS8S a 167 NY dismissal case 20 sSSS a 168 NY appeal case 32 s58S * 172 NY 623 appeal case 4 oS8S a 167 NY acctg cases s58S a 166 NY appeal case 13 b58S * 161 NY appeal casR 16 sSSS a 165 NY deree s 116 624 dissolution case 13 s58S r 160 NY appeal case 18 b68S a 165 NY liq certif case 23 s58S 33 M 1149 603 1145 587 1142 660 1142 596 1149 595 1145 616 1144 673 subrogation 174 9 error court 3 58 S 546 75 353 admission 76 M 672 1139 500 1147 664 674 24 nuisance 1144 s S8 S 246 116 negligence 99M d 10 IM 1146 23d 32 declarations s58S 931 * 167 NY 586 50 171 629 fact question tender 625 revocation case 14 s61S 7 AC dismissal s58S a 167 NY case 2 sSSS s 46 48 f31M 631 srevice amendt complt case 5 VOL. 42 65 58 61 920 do 135 689 186 476 73 M 66 perpetuity 58 S 665 __ 417 44 145 76 32 105 602 46 M .6 AC 510 7AC q7AC fram'g complt f65 74 1 4 new cause s 58 S 683 74 442 8 AC 265n 276n I 6 stockholder s 68 S 784 of record 71 393 mtgor neglect tax c 109 438 option d 120 107 foreclosure 124 816 unconscionable 133 210 21 failure prosec 106 592 8 58 S 663 dismissal 17AC 176 nl77 179n 245n reviewable 137 62 delay unreason- able 155 806 565 do 74 93 95 105 31 M 39 M 40 M 7 AC 11 AC discovery 46M 50 M 35CP 137 140 s59S 75 76 858 £ 95 M 559 37 license 291 s 68 S 73 d 102 d 38 M relief answer 8 AC 210n 212n Jood faith 64 M 417 139 609 public use 136 404 end contract 146 477 privilege t 210 NY 40 f 213 NY 79 legality 104M 144 appeal 131 885 do 170 210 252 52M 157 deft, repair 588 902 459 UAC 907 129 624 42 58 310 157-159n 464 260 135 liability d 224NY reasonable 224NY duty 105M 1 4 1 trust s58S 34 M covenant 72M 469 460 348 353 355 426 421 428 45 240 562 663 157 159n 260 1 43 reversal s 68 S 1056 nom. damage do 84 8 AC new trial 138 193 472 ■ 9 937 534 582 69 will -58S a 169 NY substitutional 152 749 76 title mtge. s 58 S 913 113 presumption 117 82 M 040 83 mandamus s58S r 161 NY 953 233 - . - 92 trust 266 s 58 S s32M 242 „, 396 95 bequest s68S s 160 NY 573 1 04 injunction 90S 894 664 11 78 M 683 bring action 200 NY 132 438 care 438 51 1043 40 582 291 156n 368 1 47 bonds a SOS s53 a 170 NY 51 635 62 1 52 contempt s 59 S 21 s 160 NY 700 serve attv. 121 ■ 760 I 60 cross exam. s 58 S 1039 n ew matter 46 662 d63 b65 qi n fact question "67 ygQ requests e70 73 prox cause 131 86 66 63 610 173 107 90 B 58 S ei2 37 M 611 1 09 license 282 8 58 S a 167 NY construction 967 183 NY 452 performance — e 65 M 1111 619 1 23 neg. dam. 8 68 S 943 r 167 NY 543 58 1 34 simi. pro 8 59 8 52 fom. insur. 8 58 S 996 41 M 483 488 sufficient cause 108 101 lex loci 63M 439 74M 84 900 102 889 677 648 604 49 e65 72 148 SAC 30 CP law action 153 136 review s59S 33 M 65 29 626 81 60 312n 282 375 114 lOPNS landlord 129 157 190 577 312 88 1 66 extra allow s 5 S 163 52 264 defense d 64 557 costs 7 AC 77n 79n statutory 87 M 173 1 68 accord s 68 S 1049 102 63 36 M 320 custody money 185 NY 112 title tender 18AC 380, 387n 171 surety s 68 S 1044 r 167 NY 31 e 95 369 costs 7 AC 153n individually 159 754 1 78 flse represn, 8 58 S 1032 58 303 1 83 encroachmt s 59 S 88 8 71 379 191 party in int. 64 LRA 605n 20|reform.policy s59S 7 124 688 do 150 733 208 removal public officer ssgs 45 eSS injunction 184 956 453 162 119 943 441 573 448 1 96 award b68S * 161 :»Y 1051 623 1 98 no claim s 5S S 1029 2 12 ballot b59S e 3211 42 M f 44M irregularity 112 571 do 580 certiorari 50 M 252 1 M 93 presumption 143 751 218 prepond ev 8 59 S 724 a 168 NY 213 87 310 privilege waiver 7 AC 356n 117 248 f 92 M 571 authority 3S CP 94 burden defend- ant SO M 61 f 02 M 499 233 rule damage 8 69 S 643 50 41 237 recovery B 59 S 1098 71 231 238 cond. sale 8 59 S 1008 d 45 525 96 166 125 340 d 159 527 7 AC 182n 191 certificate 7 AC 462n remedies 10 AC 218n title 111 _ 788 lien election 99 S defense J69 255 decree 59 S s47 260 waiver s58S 38 M 78 M surrender 7 AC 248 297 254 491 1120 302 47 163n 263 audit claim s 59 S 16 d 102 313 494 service notice 172 54 55 claim 67 LEA g28n 283 removal s59S veteran 44 48 53 58 80 118 waiver do 159 d 159 127 S 241 assume 8 59S a 168 NY 92 34 530 528 723 risk 225 689 312 30 658 450 432 595 171 247 signature s 59 S 19 62 M 288 f 91 M 253 252 negligence ^ 58 S 1125 d45 9,10 113 528 fellow servant 49 506 assumed risk 64 429 70 361 354 80 466 contrib. neg, e 174 NY 395 jury question 285 master neg s 58S 1014 do 184 918 emergency 182 15 290 tax sales e 59 S 216 s 161 NY 640 r 162 NY 371 not binding '25 343 compensation 1 25 340 lax title 195 NY 312 301 Urn tations s 59 S 105 56 M 228 306 charges 8 59 8 114 96 255 3 1 2 prescripione s 69 8 103 a 171NY 69S public highway 73 M 57 3 1 3 imprisonmt 8 59 8 200 8 42 629 3 1 8 ev. crimes s 59 S 101 e 84 320 62 LRA. 207n prior crimes 18AC2 00D.201n 207n inadmissible f 168 844 32 1 neg. dam. s 59 8 140 79 247 330 foreclosure 8 59 S 76 r 166 NY 251 335 liq. certific. 8 59 8 65 70 261 9 AC , 457n amendment 187NY 268 38 CP 354 damages 8 69 8 84 59 623 96 468 15 AC 212 356 accruing »59S demand 43 301 new promise 35 CP acknowlgmt. 19A0 43 In limitations 170 203 78 6n 363 contract - 59 8 160 r 166 NY 257 611 waiver 7 AC SDln 11 AC 13n 366 certiorari s 59 S 144 1 60 NY 690 370 party objtn s 59 8 121 62 M 186 burden proof M 372 waiver B59S B 160 NY 377 notice s59S 31 CP 591 142 666 plea 152 23nS 39 I n. disc. ev. 59 S 193 75 9 60 S 710 63M 697 319 extra allow s 60S 666 149 451 323 neg dam 60S 616 rules 59 623 pleading 63 63 64 77 107 106 367 42 M 77 44 M 303 32 CP 156 practl. defense lOlM 123 32S evidence s ej S 668 s b AC 245 presumption 46 M . 263 277 assumption 50 M 645 competent ev, 186 210 329 lien 3 60S owner 51 M 620 74 485 consent 7 AC 409- good faith 56M 676 rgt sub-contract 736 131 125 payment price ICPNS 295 333 appeal s 60 S 631 59 617 weight of ev. 45 M 120 337 injunction 3 60S 716 f 54 197 f 96 M 41 discretion 114 237 340 transfer tax 3 60 S 927 a 167 NY 280 464 3 99 300 39 M 134 d44M 191 357 lien s 61 S 156 s 44 638 a 166 NY 380 amendment 126 434 373 adoption s 60 S 1094 s 7 AC 33 176 421 18 AC 103— 5n c onsen! a 167 NY 601 37 M 379 •4M 495 inheritance 187NY 261 transfer tax 123 207 rights 184 480 38 I accounting 3 61S 15 86 623 91 128 109 683 168 56 390 venue s 60 S 1080 54 359 residence 38 283 lOlM 384 8 AC 260 262 16 AC 168n 39 1 chge. venue s 60 S 1091 a 167 NY 582 39? RDDeal s 60 S 1009 St. limitations 61 241 referea 81 301 certiorari 10» 47 waiver 114 171 disreg'd errors 184 695 395 renewal ^ 60 S 1108 117 252 399 contempt 3 60 S 703 34 M 492 402 certi-orari s 60 S 1088 a 162 NY 659 56 262 prohib. writ 73 344 33 CP 134 166 NY 466 175 615 198 230 404 decree b61 S a 162 NY surrogate e53 65 31 CP 237n 235 cestui quetrust 121 205 217 review 72 M 334 4 1 2 allegations s60S 101 pers. knowldge 60 93 112. 32 CP 137 source 31 M d41M 44 M 56M 54M 76 277 897 40 859 16 244 311 324 62 notice of motion 106 615 4 1 3 speculation 3 60 S 1087 58 387 4 1 5 royalties 8 60 S 1086 a 167 NY 445 418b. partic. s60S 1131 99 471 44 M 165 77 M 143 420 jurisdiction 3 60 S 1083 340 3 7 AC 48 8 33 M 662 37 M 268 71 M 238 423 libel per se a 60 S 1103 f 48 275 57 9 425 eq relief s 61 S 37 a 168 NY 83 55 482 reimbursement f 57 584 f 62 609 e 87 202 a 56 LRA 848 constitutional 509 563 278 10 494 44 88 92 92 M d 166 NY Stat, hmitations e 179 NY 486 illegal 144 317 431 assignblity 3 60 S 1092 e 67 474 435 law question s 61 S 268 a 168 NY 45g 57 .596 449 mandamus 8 61 S 41 226NY . 59 effect verdict 49 157 58 595 e98 ,?? 98 314 review do 67 453 89 59 s 6 AC 248 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished ; f, folio wed ; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; c. rriticised; 1, limited: e. explained; o, overruled; s, same Case ; do, dissenting opinion ;p, parallel case; q, questioned. N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division Vols. 44, 45 648 525 161 NY 163 NY by jury 46 .'■ 607 78 '^ 348 regular clerk 188NY 494 { 165 944 454 reap supr 8 61S 133 33 450 409 462 review 8 61 S 89 Qui sauce 68 LEA class legisltn 68LKA 409 judgment f 116 925 soft coal 159 795 467 estoppel s 60 S 973 66 105 469 negro chil dren education s 61 S 330 a 161 NY 598 474 new trial s 60 S 897 50 11 476 fact question 8 60 S 1062 51 602 52 623 8 46 285 480 injunction s60S s54 55 covenant 75 79 f 163 d 178 37 M 20 AO easement 210 NY reRtrictions 214 NY 846 619 597 3 362 427 176 72n 133 277 484 insurance 8 60 S 80 a 167 NY 60 78 M 126 acquiescence e 173 299 492 objections 8 60S 32 CP cause action 121 all parties 70 M 885 579 496 pers. injury s 60 S 783 539 police 64 429 s 60 S assumed risk transfer 80 466 '. 60 8 6 AC 77 M 460 399 162 51 d78 99 507 sum. pro. 8 60 S 805 69 220 revocation 7 AC 22n e 10 AC 21 509 reimbursmt 8 60 S 933 44 426 574 dedication 230 fact question 376 89 339 559 liability s 60S 966 136 ' 100 562 an'l report s 60 S 923 48 236 30 CP 255 f57 t62 e87 110 56LIIA 584 609 202 46 848 849 d 166 NY 494 179 NY 486 constitutional 482 157 183 563 83 85 817 88 168 NY illegal 144 public purpose 221NY 226 520 demurrer s 60 S 871 contract f 45 624 77 455 456 f 77 457 misjoinder do 173 814 e 37 M 77 d 174 NY 286 33 CP 279 396 3£ not conclusive 69 M 118 524 insurance a 60 S 806 a 168 NY 588 51 94 527 fact question a 60S a 162 NY 61 86 M libel 37 M demurrer 63M 844 662 608 227 509 579 533 abatement 8 60S a 166 NY f 182 NY 89 decree 42 M 14 AC 865 613 413 139 31 250 obligation ends 161 tSlM 523 513 s60S 8 162 NY a 167 NY 14 AC 577 charge 8 60S 55 1017 606 541 267n 913 15 580 discretion 8 60 S 802 do 101 527 137 102 581 delegation 60S a 169 NY 49 discretion 74 reap, superior 89 345 65 LKA7S2n846n user 106 new trial 132 indemnity 141 notice do 141 947 581 501 566 224 244 496 507 587 a£adavit a 61 S 91 84 597 588 countrclaim a 61 S 75 7 AC 392n (lability 160 compliance t 89 M 157 577 592 officers a61S powers 48 do 48 51 21 36 233 598 conatruction s61 S 126 70 185 do 80 7 603 jurisdiction 123 562 e 174NY 396 47 M 140 distinction 70 348 352 354 50 1 referee s60S duty e72 88 reversal 144 902 216 281 293 506 jurisdiction B 60 S 970 f 45 624 46 1 93 556 reinstatmt 612 612 d35M 546 remainder a 60 S 1069 a 167 NY 604 549 new trial 8 60 S 959 7 AC 209n 554 waiver 8 60 S 945 a 168 NY 592 80 352 170 NY 25 57 LRA 323n s61S 111 f45 625 46 193 ao 460 3 AC 378n -.1 M 162 89 do 89 111 16AC 427 432 335 33 2n 6 1 5 re CO very 60 M 42 prove request 68 M 618 review caae 1 3 60S do 80 case 2 conversion 8 60S 8 163 NY a 167 NY 272 193 63 1 contract caae 8 8 60 S 456 8:56 291 404 590 579 6 1 9 foreclosure caae 1 s 60 S 389 a 161 NY 626 620 foreclosure case 3 a 60S s46 621 partition easel s60S 110 a 167 NY 585 res. judicata 153 241 case 2 und. influence 8 60S 38 M 75M 95 M a 163 NY 65 272 86 470 £95 623 accounting s60S a 161 NY liability 149 87 644 281 624 contract a 60 S 94 f 61 622 recover 90 M 421 628contrib neg case 2 8 60 S 289 e59 60 124 699 fact question 11 impeachment 91 157 605 good will s 61 S 225 16 8 NY 512 86 114 trade marks 629 tax sales caae 1 8 60S 104 exclusive 210 NY 632 damages case 1 s60S 109 SAC application 149 appealable 35CP misconduct caae .S s60S do 122 161 f 163 VOL 45 I St. use, Corp. 405 540 488o 602 179 451 534 958 960 634 damages case 1 a 62 S 419 114 420 case 5 s 60 S 1150 34 M 395 modification 52M 652 635 revocation case 37 s60S 1141 r 163 NY 205 lOAC 24n 637 discreet attendant case 4 s 60 S 1142 72 M 559 638 conjecture case 1 a 60 S 659 164 417 61 S 8 162 NY a 168 NY consent 49 penal 53M right action 145 604 I I right way 210 609 650 446 524 a 61 I 114 167 evidence 163 1 7 denials 8 60S 73 friv, answer 76 s7AC 19 Daired s60S 69 M 150 25 evidence 60S 47 113 477 176 800 338 412 95 waiver 13 AC 147d 844 74 482 776 4 231 808 646 10 81t 172 797 5 In 26 easement a 60 S 16 AC weight of ev. 17AC 207 limit use 148 314 32 discontinue 641 contrib ca8e2 neg 8 60S 752 r 166NY 280 642 appeal case 8 30 S 1136 a 166 NY 6fln case 15 diamisaal a 618 1145 a 172 NY 607 caae 17 exemption ■5 61 S 1147 e40M 290 1133 181 rule 416 49 81 Is 60 S 909 127 8AC 9 AC ILRANS use name 67 M trade name 153 488 agency 8 60S 87 case 7 new trial a 60S a 165 NY 1138 599 1135 65! a 60S 51 7 AC 98 M 34 adv. s 60 S 50 M 37 stay 8 60S a 47 811 172 429n 76 possn. 816 440 93 bond s61S 60 conversion d50M vesting do 126 stay 74M d 106M limit admn- 74M B, 10 87 M 82 too demurrer a 61 S 585 incompetent ev. 36 M 10 1 02 corp trust 8 61 S 639 r 167 NY 73 60 334 I 1 2 profits s60S 48 8 55 12 AC do 66M 74M 138 meas. 65M 1081 358 359 210 296n 471 110 552 damage 253 111] 190 1122 628 432 36gD 722n 281 54 630 books ev case 2 60S a 165 NY case 3 ejectment s60S r 168 NY 6l3contri'b. neg. case 16 a 61 S 7|mandamui e68 24ns 60S 1145 f78 477lal62NY 613| 1150 222 1134 225 ABBREVIATIONS: I, criticised ; 1. limited 42 rehef 8 60S 45 48 reject claim 48 M 90 appeal regular 98 394 ultra vires p 65M 229 authority 77 M 382 58 assignment 60S 1118 a 166 NY 610 65 improvement 8 60 S 1045 town board e 33 M 226 44M 467 68 mandamus a 61 S 452 a 163 NY i-i 79 152 153 86 claim 8 60S 1109 a 161 NY 643 64 224 226 228 152 651 89 agency 8 61 S 682 48 328 protest notice 7 AC in3n I I 5 practice s 61 S 231 68 226 100 369 10 AC 382 husband suit 32 CP 299 19A0 285n demurrer 19A0 282n 129 neg. fright s 60 S 1035 129 663 132 undertakng s60S 8 81 .. 37M 45 M damage 56M 1047 343 383-385 494 624 135 full effect s 60 S 1067 f 214 NY 350 1 39 detainer s60S 42 M f 42M 1040 405 406 218 292 I 4 I crops 8 61S r 173 NY reservation 129 747, 748 personalty 80 M 546 1 45 mandamus 148 70 633 s61S r 163 NY preclude 56 M delegated 68 M 632 spec, objection 179 .784 I 55 partition 60S 8 7 AC 1 58 will s60S a 165 NY 1089 73 1064 451 a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; •, dismissed; n note ; e. explained; o, overruled: •.same case: do. dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case : q. questioned Vol. 45 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division 1 63 cancel duty s 60S 1037 61 LRA 863 1 66 evidence s 61 S 25S a 166 NY 238 65 586 sp'l allowance 69 601 accounting 32 M action 177 565 1 72 arrest s 60S d37M 177 160 1050 insurance b61S a 165 NY t51 d 166NY 177 NY 45 666 618 324 74 139 858 just cempensatn 138 172 inadmissible 74M 111 260a3sessment s 60 S 1106 35 M 60 262sp. prfmnee, 61 S 2 5 M 327 268 contract 61 S 84 143 weight of ev. 46 422 s57 620 life corporation 35 M 15 accounting HI 709 pleading st fds. 1 87 pleading 8 60 S 1071 45 186 s 7 AC 100 1 96 doub. com'ns s 61 S 190NY discretion 82 M SO 107 53-1 206 jury trial B 60 S 1020 53 51 107 52 175 653 17AC 140 n test, capacity 38 M 271 Appellate D 117 299 38 CP 28S retrial 17AC 139 140 probate will 58M 106 jury question 121 894 ad'l evidence 8(1 M 24 216 construce' tive notice s 60 S 1056 73 M 70 225 2d verdict iOlS 53 72 73 3rd verdict 81 107 231 corp s 60S a 169 NY 239 value a 60S a 167 NY 9 AC liability f71 M 9 649 30 307 446 263 pldgs 1050 29 1105 594 209n 263 358 presumption 3 60 3 849 a 167 NY 600 54 517 personal liab. 34 M 534 8 AC 403 369 parol ev. 61 S 310 59 13] release 112 612 19AC 435n consideration 133 505 373 new disc, ev 1114 1i AC estoppel 59 M 67n 34 280 consent 96IS Bling 79 f95 f95 costs waiver 30 M 41 M 7 AC 148n 152n 11 AC 321n 287 fraud 61 S 66 131 632 209 632 636 506 138 297 296assumed risk g 61 S 202 a 166 NY 227 do 39470 contrib. neglig. 152 421 3 1 4 legis. pow er s61S a 169 NY 109 36 M interest 38 M 116 vested right 57M 85 611 273 36 328 50 425 stat3 contract 13S lability 145 f 85 M off set 153 tl53 165 no defense lOlM 469 175 124 125 414 137 323-paym'( s61S 71 35 M 12 AC 53 LRA 295n 46n receiver 600 607 474 159 9 60S 75 100 102 175 e40M e44M 16AC 124n 29n apply 143 221 399 472 523 549 117-116 131n test 496 384 death dam 9 60 S 824 a 167 NY 307 54 LRA 98n 396 deficiency s 60 S 974 a 168 NY 590 406 restoration 61 S 315 a 162 NY 235 71 233 4 1 6 pleading 9 60S s 79 a 163 NY incidents 9911 486 good condi s 61 S 365 f 88 M 16 489 impeachmt s 61 S 409 78 415e 416 492 s61 S * 162 N f 32 M limitation 112 substitute lienr. 86 M 665 666 priority 86 M 670 jurisdiction 93 M 476 499 receiver 3 63 S 642 a 169 NY 589 48 238 executors 96 7 266 L02 769 stockholders 38 M 178 32 M 35 M legality f 173 interest 187NY 116 liability IBS 145 819 360 79 421 cyclist s61S s53 SAC 424 appeal 8 60S a 162 NY f 109 313 490 119d 963 612 250 231 126n 9 AC transfer tax 40 M 156 9 AC 123n 124n 428 master neg. s 60 S 840 a 167 NY 381 441 guaranty 389 326 252 24 1 flti okholder s 61 S 21 r 167 NY 158 8 12 AC 277 249 gde crossing s61 S a 169 NY award 52 78 85 132 f 169 s 167 NY amended 166 231 ?4 524 211 575 444 614 335 trust ^und s 60 S 1030 a 166 NY 345 339 recovery s 61 S 281 a 169 NY 586 349 accounting 8 61 S 27 f 70 622 jurisdiction do 126 636 356 assessment 8 61S 31 35 M 516 s60S a 167 NY pers. liable 123 liability 205NY 981 583 239 483 450 impl'd pwr 60 I 67 M 769 3 454 sale s61 S '. d47 ; d62 ! good title 38 M 175 176 8 AC 448n 459 mandamus 61 S 647 a 162 NY 660 467 patrolman s 61S 609 542 assessment s 61 S 432 143 817 over valuation 06I 118 157 155 t63 619 65 227 proof f 77 432 81 124 125 126 48 327 298 50 77 469 503 invalid s 61 S 400 51 503 sp'l proceeding 53 617 ev not on oath 166 NY 583 506 pleading s 61 S 325 copy annexed 75 635 81 577 5 1 2 ord'r bill 3 61 S 443 42 M 309 resultant trust 138 516 518 civ. service s 61 S 469 rules d 45 637 d 49 126 mandamus 145 473 522 cond. sales s61S 417 3 7 AC 182 217 NY 569 remedies 10 AC 212n 224n waive title 159 528 526 other lienors 3 61 S 341 99 449 119 393 528 construction 3 61 S 448 a 166 NY do 124 34 CP pleading 114 704 92n 887 83 318 340 295 304 465 466 475 q33M f34M e3gM 39 M certiorari o 117 813 specifications 121 600 estoppel 64M 273 ev. reduction 161 474 discretion 104M 237 1 104M 237 549 construction 9 61 S 565 e 62 325 d 34 M 68 554 modification 3 61 S 326 101 83 557 pleading 9 61 S 371 93 185 58 380 'Strike out 141 602 562 notice 9 61 S 257 58 322 185 804 waiver SAC preference 120 383 624 appeal cage 7 36IS *132 NY 488n 564 admissions s 61 S 322 88 M 718 569 relief s61 S 53 33 CP pleading 62 368 601 122 152 573 amendment s 61 S 403 7 AC 90d 575 referee 3 61 S 404 s 7 AC 172 10 AC 293n 578 referee 36IS 43 M 696 476 8S3 53 1 accountable 1U3M 848 537 civ. service 9 61 S 472 certification 174 500 7 9strict con struct! on .9 61 S 46 156 72' 586 variance 3 61 S 590 d 47 32P 90 569 112 240 163NY 454 593 pleading s 61 S 407 73 383 605 Countrclaim 3 61 S 374 r 167 NY 13 67 96 616 Uen s61 S 89 official files f 169 362 608 106 623 review 3 60 S 116 802 627 1139 616 36IS a 167 NY case 6 negligence s61S r 168 NY case 7 game law s62S a 164 NY 109 42 M e42M case 9 appeal s61S 161 NY case 28 insurance 8 61S r 169 NY 625 entries ev. case 17 3 60 S 869 115 696 19AC 201 626 jury trial case 2 3 60 S 1100 17AC 139d 627 negligence 9 61 S 62 9 62 560 628 negligeuce election law case 12 61 S dol21 case 13 96I S a 162 NY casel6 appeal 61 S a 162NY 79 taxation 51 M surrogate 93 119 case 19 bond s61S r 166 NY refund £ 164 1131 170 1136 659 1144 613 99 182 6 489 124 1133 59 858 629 penalty case 6 s64S r 168 NY case 7 contract s64S r 167 NY case 11 personal injury 1138 65 1138 591 3 61 S r 167 NY case 14 mandamus ^61S a 163 NY case 17 appeal 36IS a 172 NY case 19 new trial s61S a 167 NY case 20 negligence 9 61S rl67NY 630 costs s60S 64M 1146 346 1144 598 1147 667 1151 683 1152 440 1033 297 63 1 assessment case 3 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distingoiBhed ; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; ', dismissed; n, not*; e, criticised ; 1, limited ; e, explained ; 0, overruled ; b, tame case ; do, dissenting opinion ; p, paiallel case ; q, questionea N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division Vol. 46 VOL 46 I eq. relief s 61S 295 142 778 innocence 90 M 641 6 parcnersnlp s 61 S 351 al67 NY 605 d 47 598 600 do 47 601 602 construction 47 603 604 48 45 46 i 6 interpleader 79 set aside 1 56 contempt - - 394 a 61 S _ 61 S d 83 M 458 8 7 AC presumption 7 AC 83 M 461 84 sp. prfmce 8 61S 358 74 524 66 LEA 704n good title 16 AC 224NT 89 munc. s 61 S 63 M 760 209 254n rder arrest 201 NY punishment 20 AC 300n 1 70 deposit s61S 653 476 presumption 115 title vests 16AC 276-6n 85 M 528 229 filing 61 S 39 M 64 137n'69 350 waiver f 107 s61S 204NY 1 8 alimony 8 61S a 65 modification 82 8 7 AC 11 AC 329 287 299 242 178 293n 20 an'l report 8 61 S f46 a 167 NY 33 probate b61 S 11 AC pro .t 328 53 175 agency s 61 S 49 M 623 623 587 430 313n 90 salesman s 61 S 336 8 58 109 96 demurrer s 61 S 348 66 293 state separately 157 721 98 jurisdiction s 62S 703 £ 30 M 768 769 771 175 540 727 303 1 8 1 stockholder sfilS 69 103 f 108 c43M 14 AC recovery 135 salary 135 validity f 153 182 147 100 353 142 102n 208 710 I"6'?3'^"*""'i84 187 mandamus H 104 1 07 s 61 S 537 d lUi •^"' a 161 NY 646 f 46 629 37per. property s 61 S 549 95 M 303 46 advancement s 61S 556 181 646 statutory 181. 646 intestacy 181 646 52 assessment ordinary care 09 M 597 weight evid. 180 590, 591 reasonable time 180 592 8 61S a 162 NY 49 51 85 do 95 96 142 724, 36 M 437 658 115 440 350 561 504 do 725 593 10 5 2d verdict 61 S ,53 new trial 54 sl46 185 34 M 63M 94 M 7 AC unconstitional 34 M 723 58 assumed risk a 61 S 338 112 820 62 adulteration 560 394 570 21 210 321 502 r61S s 57 69 contract b61S 48 31 M taxpayer 91 discretion 128 75 preference s 61 S 300 notice served 54 195 8 AC 489n 77 notes 8 61 S 349 30 M 726 service notice 539 4: 649 301 776 110 397 34 711 193 614 606 805 16 I I I trustee a61S a 167 NY ILRANS care insane 56 M remove trustee 69LRA 923 power court 84 M 588 1 20 receiver 8 61 S a 167 NY 63 688 258 241 injunction 61 S 634 59 . 142 possession rcbt e 87 . 64 jurisdiction 115 127 33 M 82 M 105M res judicata 67 no trust i;6M trust 6BM 428 429 30 'right remv 3 61 S 59 M no defense 92 M f 216 NY jurisdiction 5 M 220 147 374 543 302 precedence 402 80 118 495 23 57 590 591 243 negligence 8 61 S 97 1 143 194 vicious dog. s 61 S 696 notice 11 AC 233n knowledge 112 438 1 95 office 3 61 S 709 e 32 M 491 37 M 375 pwr. superintdt d 147 435 public policy d 172 428 431 200 innkeeper a 61 S 659 17AC 115n 116d 125n 20 1 pers. injury s 61 S 672 s 58 606 3 77 506 97 394 rules necessary 20 AC 145n 256 hen s61S a 167NY 56 other lienors 119 indebtedness 185 266 102M 420 305 604 452 326 521 249 61 S SI delivery e53 131 presumption 65 71 consent beneficiaries do 147 307 acctg. com. 3 61 S 640 13 AC 367n 309 compliance s 61 S 686 47 M 251 365 election 3 61S 597 r 163NY 201 92 . 87 88 construction do 179 NY 192 370con tract s 61S 513 a 165 NY .666 375 receiver s 61 S 545 7 AC 60n 379 inference 3 1 2 mandamus 61 S 656 36 M 761 3 I 5fact question s 61 S 705 1 60 619 10 AC 137 528 436 evidence s6lS e72 44 1 weight s61S 85 99 99M 14 AC conclusive 136 jury judgment 88 M 8 61S f6S 80 36 -M 10 AC 878 380 326 288 387n 392 383 merger 8 61 fc 36.M lien alive f 173 790 37 672 881 568 ev 875 206 544 676 66n 375 676 681 813 611 502 3 I 8 executor s61S 716 a 166 NY 620 264 mandamus s 61 S 263 3 49 73 _^__ must plead 324comprcmise 150 749 s 61S 692 387 revocation s 61 S 884 a 163 NY 552 f 46 634 59 220 e32 II 622 10AU10al5n 20 legis power 130 649 77 court's 179 jury trial 103M 101 99il 445 trust s61S * 166 NY 54 revocable 102M 450 damages 61 S 767 55 355 454 findings s 61 S 854 a 168 NY 593 55 518 460 conrib. neg. 8 61 S * 167 NY 77 s 166 NY judicial f 87 M 92 M 34 M 47 M s 162 NY S9LRA election 222XY 821 554 404 302 533 154 620 697 295 108n do 104 7 AC surety 192 NY 507 duly addressed 89 M 311 1 43 new trial a61S r 167 NY 50 s75 75 8 93 review 163 NY « 163 NY nonsuit 70 M direct verdict 99M 817 66 9) 669 560 239 399 400 406 245 204 employer s61S 66 LRA 206 right discharge 36IS 148 674 853 811 433 2 1 no privity s61 S ICPNS 62 M remedies 62 M sum. pro. 135 lOlM assistance lOPNS statutory lOlM 624 350 640 642 35 267 writ 352 255 notice 268 84 267 injunction 3 61 S 420 f 46 627 630 authority 47 638 642 65 535 franchise lapsing 116 752 estoppel 125 83 condtns. lawful 216 NY 43 278 warranty 3 61 S 660 a 168 NY 653 280 negligence 3 61 S 690 joint feasors 73 497 care 327 assignment 61 S 680 f 48 M 31 real estate • 164 205 329burden deft, s 61 S 643 f 171 752 354 f 133 703 402 mistake 8 61 S 779 a 168 NY 591 liabilities 163 205 332 cotenants 222 partnership 3 618 191 s 63 617 13 AC 127n 148 receiver s 61 S 793| 225 precedence 53M 1618 61 S 542 89 427 432 warning 186 NY certif neg. 16AC 328n333n prox. cause d 59 M 414 296 laches 3 61 S 308 e 47 639 f 80 626 security coats 339 74n 76n s61S s67 action lie£ 75M 335 relief a61 S s72 79 trustee 32 M s34M preference 120 482 432 648 power 2B6 409 no s 61S do 179 knowl 79 244 753 618 170 305 604 335 581 357 453 215 4 I 6 finilinga s61S 55 specif lien 86 13 AC fraudulent 34 M enforcement 13 AC 142d copartnrshp use 85 M 513 422 master neg 246 763 529 566 287 466 certiorari 3 61 S 738 97 132 106 48 reaudit 177 391 473 g*de crossing 61 S 748 a 166 NY 96 3 166 NY 75 intervention 130 649 amendment 132 870 compensation 67 M 512 constitutional :07 NY 613 484 estoppel s 61 S 387 149 803 502 lessor neg. 49 M 9 AC waiver 134 f 96 M 217 653 347 prsumption 3 61 S 484 40 M c trust 65 LRA 551n wife not liable 67 M 389 348 revocation 61 S 569 9 AC 483n 352 foreclosure s 61 S 574 100 86 165 NY 532 deny remedy ICPNS 2711360 conversion 298] la 166 NY__626la61 S injury 667 s61S a 170 NY exceptions 515 566 731 605 490 30 32 33 3 s61S a 167 NY 82 84 do 84 127 54 LRA162nl58n machinery 144 346 429 Vi arranty 61 S 725 53 612 48M 414 assumption 182 542 43 1 reformation s 61 S 849 108 62 43 M 69 promise valid 56M 529 d 124 541 contract 82 M 437 61 S 51 M nuisance 116 liability 19A0 74M 76 M orig. 172 promise 619 1054 301 58 461 501 505 civ service s 60 S s61S 49 review do 67 mandamus 89 99 e33M 38 M 965 75 453 59 94 353 435 •it 5 1 3 incmpt. ev s62S a 165 NY 63 181 NY 17 AC rule evidence 126 571, 572 120 659 154 263 75n 517 dismissal s61 S lOOS 56 510 48 M 656 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; c, criticised ; 1, limited ; e, explained ; o, overruled ; s, same case ; do, dissentins opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, questioned Vols 46, 47 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division 518 salary f 136 896 628 damages VOL. 47. 53 duress 1 26 franch. tax 209 indictment B 62 S 146 right relief iase 1 s 62 S 314 s 62 S 191 B 62 S 224 a 167 NY 567 205NY 463 i 61S 712 1 surety s 165 NY 639 a 162 NY 654 64 173 d 49 212 similar name 18 AC 484n B 61 S 1022 85 213 70 M 449 d80 13 1415 169 848 not exonerate 81 48 58 discretion appraise value d^lOl 250 review 119 467 £ 169 849 73 M 426 brokerage 8 62 S 333 87 488 bar infringement no eviction 127 274 56 186 cap. stock 166 222 f 31 M 561 180 554 85 M 405 liability 79 585 31 M 440 dismissal f 33 M 54 statute frauds d67M_ 392 57 LRA lOOn 105 148 d 33 M 316 61 M 517 574 transfer tax 862 S 395 47 M 332 333 32*lf* 417 deductions 9 AC 117n 97 M 251 commissions f 157 867 63 res judicata s 62 S 339 will proof 33 CP 136 e 32 M 173 e 36 M 327 damages e 35 M 643 629 mandamus case 5 misrepresentatn 83 M 441 s 52 447 93 619 1 33 civ service 37 M 356 44 M 350 43 M 12G a 61 S 1144 41 M 607 8 62 S 102 8 AC 44 47n53n e78 NY 491 a 161 NY 646 1 7 attachment d 60 395 10 AC 313 suspension case 10 s 61 S 1033 69 q. meruit authority 173N Y 399 116 333 appeal a 165 NY 193 s 62 S 292 62 255 right appeal fit office title 579 repeal s 62 S 68 e 167 NY 456 81 467 mechanic's Hen a 61 S 1133 65 222 69 368 112 867 116 886 UX KJ L ^tJKT f 46 629 notice compliance 136 jury quest'n do 114 713 mandamus do 91 112115 f 85 M 54 s 62 S 195 f 161 602 117 78S 630 appeal 113 361 111 728 no appeal compensation 188NY 494 case 3 3 61 S 529 32 CP 224 70 corpn. neg 8 62 S 364 master neg. d 131 371 147 228 recovery 30 M 344 218 NY 610 56M 583 22 commissions r 166 NY 188 2l4undueinfl. 320 542 8 62 S 27 68 520 146 pleading B 62 S 124 f 75M 341, 34i assignment 34 M 499 35M 632 63 1 lien a 165 NY 643 73 203 162 S 134 r 164 NY 352 modification case 3 17AC 200n 8 74 372 191NY 106 38 M 272 75M 339 8 61 S 278 s 36 M 365 due care 10 AC 144n 32 laches 62 M 371 221 review 527 compet. 6V. 590 privilege s 62 S 39 8 62 S 240 81 insurance s 62 S 61 s62 S 1 e 632 relief 50 161 8 62 S 218 159 liability 55 86 al68 N'y 592 70 335 case 2 51 379 s 47 628 3 62 S 238 145 153 74 602 127 823 s 61 S 770 33 M 388 8 57 629 127 584 appeal permanent 36 M 414 r 169 NY 109 8 AC 488n 143 222 s 62S 66 79 43' 19AC 362n preference 86 reformation do 135 589 88 28e determination 633 m. lien 8 AC 486 8 62 S 104 1 65 assignment disapproval 97 14« 116 579 case 2 65 248 s 62 S 329 174 794 14 AC 29£ 39CP 37n 38n s 62 S 1100 35 contract pleading a 169 NY 575 discovery f 46 633 s 62 S 372 131 4 53 LRA 862D 225 penalties, 531 dismissal 119 331 case 5 a 167 NY 601 cause action 865n B 62 S 654 s 61 S 104C 168 673 report 66 222 186 511 prima f. value 47 634 negligence 18AC 196n s 61 S 1131 presumption 70 119 88 excise 99M 341 61 M 22S 81 M 363 a 166 NY 622 damages 229 jurisdiction 17AC 176-178n f 86 M 6 fixtures s 62 S 130 99M 342 s 62 S 652 -246n 594 discovery 41 M 180 182 r 162 NY 240 88 393 delay 8 62 S 20 634 new trial 44 M 314 94 order 169 ev. conclsn claim disputed unreasonable 13 AC 455n case 4 conclusive 3 62 S 221 33 M 323 155 805 52 M 641 s 61 S 1146 146 787 8 62 S 153 37 CP 168 36 M 313 Inspect books a 167 NY 689 t 151 • 912 9 AC 253 255n 533 submission 39CP 94 189 US 423 39 contract 1 02 dedication I73eq.lien 11 AC 318n 8 61 S 1046 case 6 8 62 S 284 8 62 S 259 revival 93 694 607 preference appeal 8 57 403 8 62 S 166 64 503 55 M 193 implication s 61 S 977 s «1 S 1160 quantum meruit 34 M 660 r 163 NY 642 not established 103 38C f 47 621 a 168 NY 654 s 164 NY 369 1 77 jury trial 147 218 f 50 161 case 9 35 M 631 1 07 exceptions s 62 S 376 541 negligence notice negligence ^^%^ ATA. \J%J JL damages 132 91 53 51 232 reUef 8 61 S 1061 f51 379 s 61 S 1133 s 62 S 166 conclusive 8 62 S 640 47 432 8 AC 488n r 168 NY 555 r6asonabl6 time 83 33 74 337 8 AC 30Qn do 47 44C case 17 l^iO IQfi pleading 18AC 361 f 93 M 479 66LEA943n95lE 609 order revocation ^v\I ^ ^ u 197NY 73 90 M 239 appeal judgt 117 596 s 61 S 998 B 61 S 1133 42 parol ev. 12 AC 19n presumption 16AC 449n 19A0 403 e£fect entry a 162 NY 612 restrict proof 113 736 737 e 67 469 59 220 8 62 S 347 197NY 73 34 M 440 234 contempt 546 negligence 85 M 451 constitutional a 165 NY 658 admissible gifts only s 62 S 646 s 61S 963 10 AC lOn 50 600 20 AC 172n 51 M 90 s 47 634 64 LEA 166n 62! negligence jury trial St. boundary 1 1 1 revocation validity master liable cases elOAC 15n20 68 525 526 f 90 M 534 240 assignment 20 AC 160n s 61 S 304 case 19 construction 8 62 S 201 8 62 S 92 89 391 appeal 100 62 7 AC 16n 26n 187 stay a 168 NY 587 550 Bae represen 20 AC 242n s 61 S 1147 actual location 1 1 4 exemptions a 62 S 261 8 62 S 51 r 172 NY 250 80 M 273 f 59 624 250 audit r 167 NY 427 623 anl. report appeal case 22 title good s 62 S 353 8 62 S 276 case 1 8 61 S 1137 lOOM 534 31 M 495 191 uo limit d48 494 557 speculation 8 61 S 1134 a 170 NY 565 inoomp ev. s 62 S 123 do 159 460 8 61 S 983 a 167 NY 587 47 attestation 36 M . 196 78 M 46 34 M 422 424 e 85 200 case 21 8 62 S 294 pension, taxes certiorari e96 71 new trial 136 792 793 38 CP 182 1 94 neg notice 53 343 14 AC 306n s61S 1149 12 AC 42n B 62 S 99 57 136 137 future conseq. a 168 NY 661 34 CP 268 r 20 probate s 62 S 187 87 154 e 67 . 139 138 62T ease 2 compliance 51M 551 d 86 M 74 75 in trust 46 M 640 a 166 NY 610 liable option 563 mterest s 61 S 1150 competent ev. 73 345 182 602 60 413 861 S 1056 164 405 do 104 328 80 75 76 contract 72 66 debtor 3rdr. 55M 168 33 CP 135 202 assault 159 457 damages 180 166 inference 74M 4 B 62 S 179 34 M 673 33 CP 49 56 M 164 "intestate" rules company d 82M 70 625 contempt 139 246 171 . 411 96 51 696 remedy 568relief easel probate will will execun. 13 AC 58n 61n 159 458 8 62 S 366 s 6 1 S 520 58M 480 60 M 276 63n 64n 69n 82 M 68 101 299 f 47 640 declaration averment county charges injunction 58M 486 74M 2 204 application 159 458 156 583 627 injunction alteration practice s 62 S 199 not authority 170 421 case 3 139 247 163 217 a 168 NY 665 159 459 60 M 225 s 61 S 719 competent 212 NY 313 not limited 46 630 51 counterclaim 102M 649 207 ejectment limited 135 274 f 47 642 b62S ■ 244 letters admr. s 62 S 140 159 460 judgment 8AC 255d 73 40 102M 649 13 AC 76n ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f. followed; r, reversed; m^ modified; *, dismissed; n, not«; I, cri*^icised ; U limited? «, explained; o, orerruled ; t, eamccase; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, questioned N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division Vols. 47, 48 262 parol lease 8 62 S 56 67 M 181 tenant duty 171 570 64 LRA 6S4d review 50 M 111 I s62S i47 award 265 residuary 52 s 61 S 1019 76 M 424 7 mandamus 42 640 267 notice s62S e87 14 AC 101 244 326n 320 costs 8 62S 7 AC 270 25 25n 68 368 do 71 451 f 90 M 370 owner's duty 190NY 457 causa causans d 135 891 323 neglisence a 61 S 1052 270 fee referee e62S 48 M 429 10 AC 294n 295n limited 17 AC 59 273 warranty B 62 S 96 65 238 79 114 92 39 measure damage a 168 NY 82 214 amendment 92 reversal f 134 327 damages 3 62 S 115 101 el06 113 37 CP 278 tax 8 62S a 166 NY 24 104 83 136 180 629 283 rule larceny s62 S 9 186 NY 416 55 M 54 new trial 183 880 286 fact question B62S 55 contrib neg f84 289 m. lien >62S 172 NY consent 115 172 33 509 616 710 586 681 436 325 259 33 1 acct. st'd. s 62 S 267 d54 73 option 71 650 41 M 287 over payments 103 457 343 mark title 3 62S 4 a 170 NY 371 476 477 538 458 119 449n 52 d52 55- 91 SAC 486 fact question 441 41 158 150 103 4 1 5 ohge. venue s62S 400 E47 644 74 25 do 164 547 a 7 AC 262 11 AC 115 discretion 128 674 4 1 8 contempt s62S 337 73 139 536 147 395 94 M 115 8 7 AC 322 reversal 123 s62S 61 64 32M lOAC review 49 51 54 55 - 59 82 85 89 reversal 131 ioo:.i 17AC 490 decree 3 62S 8 49 sl07 35 OP 274 indemnity fine 68 M 498 42 1 burdn proof s62S 77 integrity 119 appearance 54 M scrutiny 181 fact question 103M 388 447 180 328 397 233 302 nonsuit ev. s 62 S 21 llAC 103n 104 10 306 compensa- story damages s62S 1 70 409 mitigation 89 489 13 AC 57d 65n 13 AC 66n 67n 13AC 73ii self defense 116 711 liability 146 805 31 I negligence s 61 S 1043 * 163 NY 591 67 190 assumed risk d 59 252 fact question 102 27 143 904 contrib. neglig. 155 558 165 704 obvious risk 104M 36 1 percolating wftte" s 62 a 227 64 LRA 23Sn 365 construction 8 62 S 87 a 168 NY 666 371 damages 3 61 S 1005 a 164 NY 522 e 69 303 306 fdl version 55 M 448 percolt. water 128 38 428 negligence s 62 S 453 r 166 NY 305 66 LRA 466 636n 447 consent a 62 S 242 47 639 178 NY 113 448 surrogate 8 62 S 369 61 422 compet ev do 129 190 377 equity s62S 69 79 137 38 1 contempt s 62 S 208 s 47 643 r 162 NY 437 hab, corpus S7M 455 estoppel 8 62 S ■ 47 M 470 law suit s62S 80 discovery 87 88 4) 390 penalty s 62 S d 98 M 67 249 394 assessment 8 62 S 321 a 163 NY 320 a 186 US 230 405 diversion water s 62 S 444 a 169 NY 577 82 568 659 4 1 negligence 62 S 3 60 3 1 5 decree s 61 S 997 f 75 343 344 31 CP 238n 286'e54 64 74 91 trespasser 56 297 479 600 479 599 427 194 60 190 670 634 817 539 206 191 394 113 231n 420 636 311 11 592 m. lien s62S 51 dismissal dl04 demurrer d 160 597 partnership 5 1 I prob. cause s 62 S 495 40 M 14 genl. damage f 168 953 526time essence 62 S 481 t 78 M 239 same meaning d 78 M 253 vesting f 88 M 395 534 foreclosure 3 62S 511 al70 NY 568 a62S a 168 NY binding do 152 506 65G 612 301 537 trespass s62S a 168 NY 33 M for jury 147 675 173^ 244 nominal damage 78 M 288 543 resettlemt 8 62 S 488 s 7 AC 229 qualification 16AC 395n 550 reference 471 recovery 3 63 S 580 a 164 NY 58 distribution 15 AC 189n 472 sp. prfmce 8 63S 97 delivery f 172 41 M 64H certificate 33 CP 792 298 536 342 227 104 479 inference a 62 S 697 d 68 380 80 326 fact question e97 . i presumption lOAC 386n 391 54 M ■-. 566 9 62S 125 d49 14 AC items 98 554 chat. 8 62S 39 M bankruptcy 192 NY 142 172 579 845 184 57n 116 mtge 618 264 237 316 28 558 commiss'ns s 62 S 609 83 M 238 employment 87 M 310 311 560 will s62S a 166 NY compliance 46 M 640 subscription 76M 174 acknowledgmt. 83 M 248 97 M 553 1053 330 58 1 taxpyr suit s 62 S 685 164NY 205 585 new trial 62 8 666 54 301 185 110 44 M 549 n. disc, ev, 185 110 16AC 118n 125n 129n 567 383 136 120 ?ase 3 9 62S a 164 NY case 4 assessment s62S a 163 NY d 165 NY dol65NY327 328 case 5 exceptions 63 S 55 notice 57 641 654 883 604 pub. policy 8 62 S 610 51 313 ccndition void 80 M 14 609 jurisdiction s62S r 164 NY 60 5] 52 162 31 M e41U 68 M e 165 NY 5 AC 375 380n waive objns. 18A0 437 6 1 3 injunction 3 62 S 708 66 596 134 397 62 1 fact question case 6 62 S 264 a 166 NY 593 625 appraisal case 11 62 S 1146 a 161 NY 631 validity lien 593 81 219 543 602 287 135 169 425 178 442 632 contract 3 63 S 884 a 168 NY 662 634 restraint case 2 s62S * 163 NY case 8 appeal 8 62S a 165 NY case 20 assignment s62S r 167 NY case 3 compliance 62S 5M 113 case 1 4 appeal s62S a 163 NY case 38 negligence s62S do 84 distinction do 135 629 1143 659 1148 204 607 1144 579 1146 594 317 ;!0 507 1133 603 1134 671 1134 360 VOL. 48 I mtg enforcmt 5 62 S 688 al66 NY 630 lien on realty do 133 436 take notice 136 _ 855 appeal decision 199 NY 331 6 demurrer 62 S 587 88 . 60S legi^. adoption 114 423 56 M 40 42 M 399 jud'l constructa. 156 732 in tort 163 564 98 M 91 1 2 stockholder 1141 17^ 636 foreclosure case 3 3 62 S 4& a 168 NY 659 46 M 358 competent ev. 610 138 641 appeal s 62 g a 165 NY 642 appeal 6ase 4 6 62S r 163 NY 383 667 1151 665 643 contempt case 1 3 62S r 163 NY ease 3 wiU s63S * 166 NY 1140 S96 1104 634 €44 chge. grade case 7 62 S 1133 * 166 NY 638 626 insurance case 1 s 62 S 155 a 171 NY 673 827 change venue 38CP 67 628 mandamus case 3 s62S a 166 NY case 14 567 insurance s 62 S 553 a 167 NY 607 1133 607 s62S a 168 NY 1147 663 629 certiorari case 2 s62S 1146 a 163 NY 598 606 590 657 8 62S 163 NY a 168 NY 1 4 trustees 3 62S 91 eatoppel f 163 186 37 M f 84 M 85 M general words 606 321 719 209 435 156 87 323 good 331 power 144 ction 83 M official 105M contract 186 39 improp s62S a 164 NY 51 b particular 62 S 621 69 143 113 306 54 CO mpet ev 3 62 S 692 r 168 NY 126 90 stmt 573 565 62 transfers 3 62S p96 85 51 e42M demurrer 10 AC 66 assault s62S * 164 NY 580 324 430 434 512 46Sn 671 57 69 confidential ABBREVIATIONS: I, criticised ; 1, limited : 8 62 S 682 d 51 363 good faith 78 473 80 171 remove hearg. 135 21 lAiedy 213 NY 134 74 custody s 62 S 529 * 168 NY 358 s 49 636 e65 234 d 34 M 23 s 7 AC 300 53M 25 83 test capacity 3 62 S 673 I, affirmed; d, distin^ished ; f. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note e. explained ; o, orerniled : i, lame case ; do. dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case : a> Questioned Vol. 48 N, Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division SI 638 S3 211 133 012 fSOM 623 ev. insufficient 15S 151 98 contempt s 62 S 632 r 163 NY 269 109 amendment s 62 S 660 72 149 93 M 584 I I I assiffnment a 62 S 613 a 168 NY 658 d 72 M 268 pro tanto 171 505 appropriation 103M 285 i 1 8 pers. injury B 62 S 562 S9 617 verdict aside 109 31 45 M 120 1 2 1 dismissal B 62 S 627 a 168 NY 656 8 AC 21 5n damages 123 276 165 267 restrict lien i 162 57 1 26 damases a 62 S 604 inadequate 80 372 128 remv'l office 8 62 S 603 129 482 preference 120 150 383 670 188 notice pro- test s 62 S 104 89 M i 92 M release 63M injunction 34 CP diligent 80 M 92 M 434 311 307 481 368 203 illegalvot ing s 62 S 816 a 164 NY 570 206 negligence r 166 NY 60 M 269 reply 3 62S 3 7 AC 27 1 libel 9 62S 37 M 245 233 791 286 781 508 275 revocation 9 62 S 846 32 M 222 a 86 M 544 10 AC 18n 31n school house s62S 74 81 s 168 NY 840 225 68 635 2 1 I will excutn. s 62 S 785 8 AC 367n 218 gift c m 131 laches b62S 61 82 87 161 56 M e87 32 CP 630 241 246 583 392 827 27 350 76 582 646 134 default b62S iappeal » 168 NY undisclosed pr. 136 25 liability 156 797 leal principal f 211 NY 70 1 40 eviction a 62 S 564 eonstructive '8 AC 430n 431n 'tenant's duty 64 LRA 654n 144 discovery 8 62 S 706 113 496 132 W9 133 730 d 39 M 308 147 mortgage b63S 8 84 r 169 NY 1 86 notice 8 62S 63M waiver 58 8 AC 489n iSla 853 426 314 815 379 322 s62S eSS 65 92 95 41 M s 175 NY residue fund 33 CP payments 69 LRA 324n by-laws 69 LRA 338n ury question 69LRA324n338n no action d 209 NY 961 624 625 595 508 332 519 72 104 15 223 will gift s62S a 163 NY 836 602 230 reargument 8 62 S 793 13 AC 16n 233 penalty s 62 S 775 49 638 647 f49 director 56 330 presmnption 34 M 485 book entries ev 9 AC 159n retroaction 171 NY 192 pld. new matter 75M 643 240 attachment a 62"S 843 69 140 counsel fees e 35 M 334 335 damages 56M recoverable f 169 72 M not liable f 160 624 657 9 69 248 discretion s63S r 166 NY do 65 57 LRA 167 305 188 42n 265 acct stated 3 62 S 746 68 M cancelled 164 495 804 219 607 515 279 m Uen s64S al67NY 129 counterclaim d 166 140 89 M 223 285 construction s 62 S 657 53M 309 291 burden dft s 62S 717 do 149 159 plead privilege 150 867 295 imdisclosed principal s62S d65 84 preference 39 M agency 114 no election 149 elect remedies 81 M not bar 177 384 30 1 declarations 663 10 343 423 448 576 62 S 92 318 libel s62S do 83 11 AC 671 321 908 210 8In 321 executors s 62 S 905 78 443 114 148 36 M . 628 nunc pro tunc 34 M 98 327 signature s 62 S 972 62 M 288 333 discovery s 62S 101 33 M 12 A.C allegations 140 737 574 lln 528 337by law valid s 62S 1047 136 722 344 good faith S63S 77 107 354 waiver s62S 55 co'ur-liance 26 646 303 1111 427 80 copy claim 119 357 interest s63S 55 loss profits 138 437 608 203 210 552 363incompetent s 63 S 274 95 M 139 371 possession a 63 S 269 a 166 NY 590 61 11 admissions clear 109 397 173 NY affirmative proof 15 AC 225n burden proof 136 11 120S 124 378 oral agreet a 63 S 80 a 59 289 39 1 notice s63S s63S d57 83 f 219 452 domain a62S a 169 NY 380 160 441 583 585 186 395 compound e 63 S 76 61 376 taxation 33 M 569 64 LRA 34n 60n 69n 401 tax corpn s 63 S 179 s 34 M 659 403right redress f 86 M 487 obligation 90 M 151 incumbrance 169 319 4 1 3 inj horse 3 63 S 104 66 178 fraud sale 39 M 715 423 application 255 621 246 93 s63S 85 certiScate 33 M 91 M alse statements e 39 M 699 41 M 413 10 AC 16n 17n revocation 128 872 estoppel 147 379 compliance 75M 173 no certificate 75M 175 char, statement 155 367 426 jurisdiction s 63 S 1 s 7 AC 314 428 objection 63M ICPNS authorize 185 317 136 489 433 award s62S 494 a 169 NY review 38 M 583 584 accord 130 91 439 ace d ins. a 62 S 1044 s 96 277 indemnity s 190 NY 45 445 removal 3 62 S 930 a 163 NY 599 d 50 394 abolishment 80 14 171 977 160 468 guaranty a 62 S 944 a 168 NY . 649 99 355 472cand'l eale 957 232 109 s62S d64 lOOM damages 50M 64 remedies 10 AC 209 220 e 10 AC 221 68 LRA101nl02n contract 68 LRA 101nl02n 475 amendment 3 62S s89 138 B 180 NY motion 10 AC decree s 21SUS pleading 167 1042 619 125 458 282n 585 477 promotion 3 62S d54 do 54 57 f 166 NY ■ do 166 NY 185 NY 482 941 340 341 157 450 452 252 successor power s 62 S 982 46 M 441 484 liquor tax a62S a 163 NY 488 trust s62S m 164 NY 492 review s62S 53 ^ 190 NY audit 57 69 134 M 134 M mandamus 159 sole remedy 159 902 602 888 196 964 343 34 116 413 423 672 458 "458 498 com s62S 63 demurrer 78 1098^ 148 ev 949 420 493 649 1 163 75M merger 49 ICPNS no miergi 62 M ' pleading 148 • 167 ;er 465 250 636 269 486 646 585 SIDjprop. party s 628 1051 f 48 M 324 interested 170 951 5 1 5 neg damage 8 62 S 912 65 568 108 256 care f 65 188 inference neg 67 101 notice 44 M 201 5 1 8 attachment S62S 114 a 165 NY 32 M executors 114 execution 114 861 44(1 669 90 438 441 525 submission s 62 S 863 a 167 NY 458 529 bastardy s 62 S 1060 q 56 467 equitable lien c 106 17 537 cond. prced 62 S 1115 a 166 NY 354 82 29 a 162 NY 647 542 trustee 8 63S 10 1118 * 163 NY 209 8 61 413 414 416 8 61 417 420 8 174 NY 238 554 scope employment 54 538 43 M 131 jury question 105 525 line of duty 67 M 443 557 negligence 8 62 S 927 a 31 M 291 559cond. precdt 8 62 S 897 I 171 305 private person 17i 307 567 contract a 62 S 918 f 82 640 conai deration 101 126 108 52 67 M 264 valid contract 114 800 56M 529 569 prox. dam a 62 S 890 63 226 care sick 69 LRA 520n do 115 793 miscarriage 99LRA 520n fright damagee 16AC 71n mental pain 120 469 rule damages 123 649 584 credibility 62 S 1119 36 M 168 590 oral ev 8 62S 54 partnership 157 946 604 710 594 inhei. tax 62 S 975 a 166 NY 618 73 327 328 trustee 77 admr. liable 185 NY divesting 72 M security 153 179 protect estate 179 435 619 76 829 43 S 598 construction s 63 S 1108 156 732 603 accounting a 64 S 423 a 169 NY 572 84 393 s 163 NY 592 61 I reinstatemt s 63 S 156 a 163 NY 604 f 35 M 612 6 1 3 jurisdiction^ 63 S 91 f 59 262 do 59 26 125 704 f 166 642 39 M 586 50 M 228 sp. perfmce 77 26 amendt terms e79 St. frauds 87 relief 173 33M 34 M 39 M . accounting 107 lex fori 64M 6 1 7 bailee neg- . 181 I7AC liability f 171 171 623 picketing case 1 8 62S tS6„ 50 M injunction 74 39 M e9AG 16 24n26 11 AC 210 52 169 81 179 465 217 624 288 228d 750 621 7 112 58 624 dismissal case 3 s 62 S 1138 a 165 NY 671 ab:breviations : c* criticised ; 1, limited a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f. followed: r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; e, explained ; o, overruled ; s. same case ; do. dissenting opmion ; p, parallel case ; a, qu»Uonad N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division Vols, 48, 49 decree case 4 s62S r 164 NY 1148 485 625 claim B 62 S 623 s 56 623 628 atty. lien s 64 S 820 90 82 633 liq bond case 37 S62S 1141 a 166 NY 274 88 885 appeal case 20 8 63S 1115 al71 NY 630 appeal case 33 s63S 1111 a 168 NY 652 634 new trial case 16 s62S 1151 a 167 NY 671 waiver d 118 603 .635 claim case 2 8 63S 112 * 170 NY 683 93 579 168 255 41 M 287 new trial »62S 1137 a 169 NY 592 public policy f 173 744 636 dismissal 8 63 S 1110 a 169 NY 575 638 report case 11 S63S 1118 a 168 NY 641 findings case 12 a63S 1118 B 166 NY 263 Pleading "366 23 s 63 S 1104 10 AC 330 license 13 AC 386n 388n 391 n 639 accounting case 3 8 65 S 1139 a 168 NY 662 VOL. 49 I allowance s 63 S 227 52 263 132 34 88 M 410 fee spl. guardn. 19AC lOln unlawful 182 374 4 certiorari 63 S 114 53 623 f 54 627 628 do 87 60 166 NY 171 jurisdiction e 75 214 106 46 town law 34 M 572 8 neg damages 8 63 S 107 a 60 20 21 23 safe place £ 164 755 88 M 7 I I neg. damages s 63 S 286 54 71 55 102 71 502 95 237 22 authority s 63 S 211 49 629 attys lien 50 263 264 1 61 631 58 505 508 d 63 411 113 447 e 32 M 267 85 M 250 31 CP 98 e 8 AC 82 8 AC84n87n89D 10 AC 38 41 contract d 33 M 779 d 34 M 622 foreclose lien f 158 700 29 negligence 8 63 S 296 fact question 54 624 57 28 59 618 62 373 13AC 414n 41 authority s «3 S 527 153 528 45 substitution 8 63 S 530 f 49 637 9 AC 228n atty'e hen 8 AC 97n 166 810 47 warranty 8 63 S 405 88 17 56 defense s 63 S 449 reasonbl doubt 57 93 71 189 burden people do 120 88 64 prepond. ev. a 63 S 186 59 139 60 631 7 1 civ. service s 63 S 258 a 163 NY 556 76 default s 63 S d53M 476 261 78 neghgence 3 63 S 195 97 394 54 LRA 124o 80 jurisdiction d 63 S 298 124 660 40 M 247 82 evidence s 63 S 591 incompetency 59 147 148 84 liquor certif 9 63 S 560 33 M 246 revocation 10 AC 26n consents 113 161 88 appointment 3 63 S 723 r 164 NY 22 90 hab, corpus 3 63 S 497 e 75 368 child welfare 156 176 94 negligence a 63 S 402 59 59 3 63 -619 do 64 108 sui juris 80 236 do 81 410 f88 11 fact question 102 497 99 revocation s 63 S 531 10 AC 20n 101 good faith a 62 S 969 s 63 S 209 51 230 78 376 1 08 assessment s 62 S 1107 f 60 629 98 84 jud'l constructn e 31 M 554 perm'nt business e 39 M 284 e 41 M 147 42 M 424 57 LRA 91n taxation 62 M 560 1 1 1 neg. questn. act B 63 S 204 L09 725 I 1 4 assessment a 63 S 468 a 162 NY 661 518 85 350 96 426 107 24 142 724 objections 35 M 66 accrues right e 36 M 593 interest 51 439 96 426 e 39 M 599 39 M 600 601 St. opening 120 205 I 1 9 pleading s 62 S 1095 con struction 70 185 do 80 7 complaint insuf. 184 232 1 23 diacretion a 63 S 71 53 95 laches e 61 146 61 244 e 87 351 87 392 114 4 123 72 138 498 33 M 361 66M 28 as true 168 559 f 95 M 698 1 25 dismissal a 62 S 1097 a 164 NY 64 56 172 lachea 61 189 74 247 1 30 review 3 62 S 1059 f 117 689 removal 120 606 cond. precedent 160 87 1 3 I rent 3 63S 62 153 622 1 33 interpleader a 63 S 158 35 M 208 30 M 656 55 M 200 135 rent a 63 S 88 a 167 NY 611 direct verdict 59 M 464 tenancy 59 M 468, f 469 reversal 59 M 470 liability 65 M 29 1 4 1 poundage a 63 S 94 82 478 119 819 plaintiff liable do 179 373 1 43 Ucenae s 63 S 128 a 165 NY 431 56 370 mandamus 82 36 rule 43 M 129 removal teacher 106 61 108 20 tender 71 M 597 df-inurrer f 153 4.S0 I 70 rescission a 63 S 197 74 23 171 lex loci a 62 S 1066 27 197 must allege 130 568 most favorable 168 141 1 73 absence a 63 S ~ 36 a 163 NY 551 without leave 51 503 73 446 e 77 163 77 637 d 39 M 168 169 NY 455 dismissal 182 893 1 80 neg, dam. a 63 S 73 r 169 NY 136 I 83 reference a 62 S 1058 88 348 125 845 e lOaM 692 14 AC 57n62 test 94 M 660 I 84 truat 9 63 S 46 m 164 NY 152 I 93 books ev 3 63 S 55 a 168 NY 649 1 97 allegations s 63 S 242 a 168 NY 653 67 613 spl' pldg-dam 12AC 29n exeption revera 49M 24g admissible 20 AC 173n 203 neg. dam. s 63S 44 r 168NY 508 208 veteran s63S 6 salary 113 132 33 M 316 teacher 43 M 129 pend'g appeal e 178 N Y 49 removal valid 119 469 title office 119 470 2 1 3 damages a 63 S 41 34 M 718 i nterest 116 211 2 1 8 indictment s 63 S 18 a 164 NY 600 reopen case 204NY 553 223 expert ev 8 62 S 1088 r 168 NY 372 232 assessment - s 63 S 29 r 165 NY 142 238 civ. service a 63 S 145 - 65 177 98 6 242 discovery s 63 S 223 137 578 244 authority s 62 S 1064 152 152 247 discovery 8 63 S 96 67 68 57 LRA 481 sped, damages 112 248 averment 186 NY 441 226NY 6 libel per se 119 341 do 119 342 corp. libel 125 867 corp.pleadg 131 64 do 131 68 individually 149 157 do 149 157 separate cause do 149 170 Qo bar 150 175 presumption 165 392 258 trust s 63 S 369 a 166 NY 608 2B3 demurrer 3 63 S 417 3 49 421 1 49 639 110 739 156 871 misjoinder 80 518 119 523 139 183 do 166 661 14 AC 39n f 49 M 2, 3 party 39 CP 359 not apply 180 413 270 death dam. a 63 S 235 a 172 NY 631 276 friv pleadg s 63 S 162 67 500 63 185 38 M 119 demurrer 118 7 nullity do 133 439 incident do 137 801 debt discharged 141 , 197 281 jurisdiction s 63 S 52 53 636 affirm relief U3 476 138 42 assessment 114 523 286 rent a 64 S 153 f 49 648 relief 70 185 91 354 92 334 misreprentn 61 M 285 restitution , 73 M 506 counterclaim f 89 M 425 293 services s fi2 S 1061 558 18 58 M damages dl30 distinction 130 19 authority 74M 462 298 limitation 3 63 S 38 185N'i 207 302 dismissal s 63 S 887 r 172 NY 327 f 120 741 330 arrest 3 63 S 553 a 166 NY 325 73 46 181 117 3 10 AC 44 213 NY 610 34 1 h. & wife 3 63 S 301 e 18AC 21 consideration 32 M 505 pub pol. void e 36 M 561 42 M 30 495 separation 123 422 14 AC 243n 248 39 CP 170 void contract 110 547 119 766, 767 191NY 470 651f 502 f 97 M 200 public policy 58M 390 illegal 130 165 345 injunction a 63 S 435 r 169 NY 170 3 72 110 72 136 reservation 36 M 362 349 draft f d 63 S 58 a 170 NY 88 estoppel 148 7 liability f 161 347 362 allegations a 63 S 526 72 84 84 440 438 strike out 125 855 124 620 369 contract a 63 S 503 73 310 375 innuendo !63S 423 53 292 8 63 62 83 208 211 93 533 32 M 40 86 M 228 14 AC 413 practice 47 M 97 decision former 9 AC 29Sn 177 NY 369 118 661 justify 71M 15 106M 163 ABBREVrSTIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; c, criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q, questioned Vols. 49 ,50 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division 380 neg dam. 8 63 S 367 86 f 60 593 595 safe place 59 83 compensation 446 will 82 s 63 S 91 a 168 NY 54 LRA 162n direction charge judge 143 58 scaffold 20 AC 202n 385 misjoinder B 63 S 532 a 163 NY 384 a 168 NY 446 e 74 131 assessment 113 714 393 commission s 63 S 359 89 IS 137 300 spl. term power 42 M ■ 558 395 divorce s63S 431 92 301 303 findings 39 M 395 sp*l term power 42 M 558 courts duty 130 196, 198 63 M 183 lOPNS IRS referee report 86 454 waters s63S 164 NY 51 LRA ICPNS 400 waiver s63S 35 M cures error 63 M 180 395 846 603 406 discovery B 63 S 381 13 AC 450n 4 1 revocation 8 63 S 544 10 AC 435n 4 1 4 declarations ?J S63S 86 dismissal 134 291 100 206 S.67 119 67 s 97 d 197NY 31 M acctg. claim 40 M e42M reimburse 131 227 223NY 259 gifts 52M 437 445, 447 626 transfer tax 636 62 M 151 95 M 421 556 assessment 752 61 319 694 460 bona fides s63S 611 88 268 465 liability s 63 S 691 73- M 297 95 M 15 473 lifeinsur- s 63 S 674 s 94 610 170 NY 13 480 dissolution 1 63 S 738 54 149 160 areholder 76 113 adjustment 77 e94 44 M preirdums 101 preference 106 dividends 143 do 174 specification 121 amendment 62 M ICPNS petition 72 M 23 149 582 176 298 487 16AC 30n 32 36 143 estoppel 485contrib. negl 137 425 s 63 S 535 211 US 610 597 neg. notice 493 negligence 3 63 R 615 a 169 NY f 57 621 co-defendant lOOM 443 450 !S 574 161 817 712 600 315 225 652 s62S * 163 NY case 4 will s62S r 167 NY 632 appeal s63S a 168 NY 577 demurrer s 63 S 477 50 138 answer deft 119 391 f 93 M 103 582 ctrclaiia 3 64 S 389 76 519 589 construction s 63 S 635 81 29 credr's corp. e 74 318 ell AC 280 sequestration 32 CP 140 597 liability 140 363 572 582 653 898 592 910 117 251 664 634 st frauds 64 S 46 M partnership 117 636 appeal case 12 9 64 S a 176 NY attys. lien 111 18AC case 22 divorce s63S * 168 NY 35CP 779 182 758 742 551 1113 358 322 640 accounting case 1 s 63 S 10 f 49 63 pleading 84 43 ijtnke out 124 51 M aggrieved 136 621 499 s63S a 169 NY 3 LRA 473 124n 134n 503 negligence 631 465 1 6 1 2 transfer tax s 63 S 79 51 M 85 M 216 NY decree 89 38 M 796 510 508 Pleading 473 ^ "3 S 445 e 228 208 421 pleading IS 63 S 422 67 M 572 order f 164 897 controverted 170 423 trust s63S a 166 NY 74 383 619 429 legal remedy a 63 S 540 131 237 437 use street 3 63S 76 111 55 M- abuttors 59 M 482 666 704 560 586 r 166 NY e42H 520 substitute s 63S 601 221NY 139 no demand 221NY 140 53 1 larceny s63S a 168 NY jurisdiction 132 f 217 NY 522 604 793 176 538 liability s 63 S 620 180 225 54 M 605 541 gift causa mortis 3 63S a 163 NY 66 76 110 37 M taxation 83 694 607 169 208 478 666 633 99 182 68^ 17( 168 641 constriiction 110 697 VOL. 50. I estoppel s63S a 167 NY 68 8 7 AC plea of title el02 517 618 119 363 250 4 insurance 8 64S s67 waive tender 122 159 25 teleph. CO. 659 9 75 704 426 583 490 516 155 340 487 3 63S a 168 NY enforcible 126- 643 m. lien 3 63S a 168 NY 270 118 689 228 230 228 468 remedy appeal e41M 417 actual notice 140 703 51 M 180 appraisal 9 AC 114n 125 surrogate 60 M 486 law error 119 123 courts power 119 124 153 88 6 f 7 dismissal 3 63 S 339 a 166 NY 589 ratification do 149 .S46 . 73M: 805 duty plaintiff 149 344 authority 159 378 629 appeal case 2 _ 62 S a 170 NY- 648 interpleader case 13 63 S a 166 NY 630 bond case 1 8 62S a 166 NY case 2 ^ new trial 1105 579 866 410 645 allowance s 63 S 230 r 170 NY 278 dismissal 65M 627 647 an'l report case 1 s 63 S 198 1 66 330 1110 605 use streets 52 84 111 48 M 59 M authority 62 f 167. allegations 83 102 53 M dispos'n franch. 90 279 96 125 35 M- 450 676 delegation power 102 340 110 627 do 110 631 tatutes 112 complaint 53M rght from state 125 81 inherent power 747 483 80 M estoppel 81 M franchise 181 96 M discretion 183 fraud 188 33 trust 8 63S » 165 NY 167 identification 101 644 696 61 162 146 251 427 7 1 flse impnsmt s63S 95 15 AC authority 10 AC liability 153 352 468 201 54n 848 75 trade mark 9 63 S 333 8 AC 66n fraud intent 117 176 true test 122 264 87 impeachment s 63 S 365 95 112 112 612 53M 679 fact question 60 M 11 restitution 145 17 92 party nee. ;63S 818 118 137 119 391 42] 135 857 859 f 164 354 179 . 12 representative 113 231 securities 133 672 32 M fraud 36 M 38 M 670 672 21 567 217 129 649 587 510 38 damages s63S a 169 NY error charge 96 measure dam 97 243 122 322 37 CP 135 offset 113 82 real estate 8P M 187 44 signature ev. B 63 S 692 57 260 58 certiorari B 63 S 362 a 167 NY 619 63 waiver s 63 S 293 76 611 no recovery 72M 530 66 negotiable 8 63 S 41Q 95 distinction 3 63 S 622 72 M 423 101 seduction 9 63 S 372 42 M 616 99 M 161 1 09damagea s 63 S 645 compensatory 411 20 15 469n 395 624 467n 70 71 118 10 AC 34 M 66 LRA CO. rules 10 AC jury question 110 261 110 708 e 178 NY 360 17 AC 468 action in tort 34 M 514 10 AC 470 transfers d 118 16 86 M 55 unreasonable 67M 81 I I4by delivery 63 S 565 f 163 187 1 17 law remed; s 63 S 568 153 309 counterclaim suit 349 88 424 321 684 486 366 31 132 sureties a63S 66 153 39 M 43 M 46 M 76 M notice 149 not conclusive 166 360 1 36 countrclaim e63S 941 73 40 76 519 Conclusions 94 536 78 M 293 demurrer 10 AC 283n complaint 16AC 247n 1 44 waiver s 63 S 1008 36 M 308 must allege 168 757 1 49 mob dam. s64S 63 110 riot 188 NY 411 604 61 259 I 58 prox. cause 8 63 S 599 131 107 60 infant 63 S preference 33 M 388 8 AC 485 487n 1 63 ejectment 8 63 S r 172 NY 33 M reversal 148 724 784 348 586 576 181 money follow s 63 S 80 lUO 490 sureties el22 82, 83 53M 419 receiver's duty 122 86 appeal 69 M 310 permissive 183 360 1 89 appt. guardn s 63S 7.37 ISA c 51° 192 damages s 63S 811 131 246 199 conversion s 63 S 761 s 163 NY 59 r 16 NY 533 other evidence 76 M 290 f 160 123 title s63S a 169 NY 73 1 27 title s63S e33M new trial 307 NY 47 347 368 291 387 328 225 204 usury s63S 169 NY 800 357 2 1 nom. dam 9 63 S ?64 85 365, 367 alice intent 18 . 721 injury feelings 74M 477 inference 80 M 527 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note c. criticised ; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled ; s, same case; do. dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q. queitioii«4 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division Vol. 50 218 jurisdiction 746 176 £02 4S9 374d 566 8 6»S rl66 NY 62 M 31 SAC B 164 NY 22lc.q. trust S63S sg e84 33 M merger title 34 M 266 surplusage s 63 S 1092 93 406 771 376 574 200 612 273 jurisdiction 8 63S a 169 NY a 191 US 80 statutory 166 748 23 239 relief s63 S do70 demurrer 84 309 393 93 404 do 171 733 demand U AC 176n leasee not liable 62 M 123 settle rights 153 142 apportionment e 153 143 construction 153 147 allegations 180 571 276 coats s63S s7 AC i 76 89 M 106M 244 objections s 63 S 911 ^L„ 241 173 905 32 CP 324 demand s 63S 135 reinstatement 135 221 987 506 327pol. premim. 8 63 S 1055 58 M 532 test authority 373 42 67 304 280 attorney s 63 S 981 disbursements 7 AC ' 401n 78 M 33 1 bar 1006 il*" 320 64 9 90 res judicata 37 M estoppel US 771 19 AC 263n 619 608 246 transfer tax 286 veteran s 63 S 163 NY s61 removal 62 do 62 135 mandamus 34M exemption 121 notice 190NY waiver d 132 77 73 M demand 135 8 63 8 al63 NY f 221NY f 61 f58 f 60 t71 d82 flOO 150 106 181 186 f 167 NY 205 US constitutional 1079 59^ 20 214 619 630 464 153 516 807 18 129 177 230 481 176 NY 150 39 M e 95 M ulra vires d60 title 182 NY - new estate do 182 NY taxable 62 M 95M subject to d 150 429 809 138 408 290 247 266 447 409 tax 811 993 523 186 221 228 21 120 230 500 53 254 21 294 conclusive s63S 70 sp. perfmce 96 48 M jurisdiction 839 M objh, title 255 plead ng s 63S 1012 10 AC 429n 90 M 380 burden proof 87 M 329 defective f 93 M 70 26 1 atty lien 1036 505 508 361 623 250 89 38 41 no recovery 154 534 foreclose lien f 158 700 S63S relief S8 63 d34M 85 M SAC 10 AC SAC election d 61 M 585 defect clerical d 61 M 586 no cause 75M 4 cechnical 154 410 298stay procdgs s 63 S 939 59 M 567 308 removal s 63 S 912 a 165 NY 606 3 1 1 constructn s eaS 999 146 700 3 1 6 countercl'm s 63 S 97" 137 236 143 914 157 682 f 35 M 104 subj. action 132 539 lien defense 157 432 1064 s 64 S 21 10 AC 214 160 124 105 477 336 pleading s64S .189 121 -623 E 31 M 775 cond n prec'dt 32 M 607 15 LEA 197n 339 pleading 8 63 8 1071 a 169 NY 673 184 492 dismissal 15 AC 335n 344counter offer - -. 8 216 NY 1074 264 349 title t 63 S 64 M possession 56 1002 iudgment 96 133 f 146 22 easements 1« 88 M 1068 151 509 701 18 354 death dam s 63 S 1059 407 codicil 222 443n disinheritance 115 728 182 83 4 1 6 reformation 8 64 8 112 a 169 NY 590 62 137 138 77 do 95 41 M 4 1 9 vendor 8 64S a 169 NY 342 619 288 101 583 422 proms, note 8 64 8 65 a 169 NY 581 428 warranty 64 S 290 a 168 NY 665 79 323 consideration 12 AC 258n 267 pleading 76 M 249 430 construction s 64 8 144 77 335 consideration 102M 111, 113 8 64S s69 106 85 M 53LRA 434 detainer s64S 102 271 proof title do 127 571 'forcible manner'' 148 202 NY 42 jurisdiction 205 72 M 37 M 86 d 40 M 56 material prf, 18AC 188 465 default 8 64 8 236 a 164 NY 578 13 AC 178n 468 want bar s 64 8 68 a 169 NY 679 473 insurance 183 393 490 408 197n 476 complicat'n a 64 8 10 a 7 AC 369 478 negligence s64 8 114 d 54 600 601 owner's duty 190NY 457 f 319 NY 445 482 vol service 8 64 S 170 54 377 res judicata 68 238 presumption neg. 52 318 permanent inj. 55 607 d63 314 101 68 535 wharf 64S 61 LEA d 134 602 compt ev 141 960n 297 I 64 8 538 teachers a 163 NY 699 604 neg dence s64S 67 prima facie 96 presumption 542 perm injury 606 inadequate 8648 56 SS hypothetical e85 14 AC 34 507 286 203 610 fr'd transfer 304n 544 insufficient S64S m, 1145 621 negligence ■'*' '^"'case 2 547 survival s 64 8 129 248 301n 554 filing 8 64S 13 AC indemnity d 70 M right assignee lOOM _ 63 S ■ 499 „„ d 96 431 28 697 62 1 appeal case 4 -63 8 1116 a 171 NY 577 307 7n lOn a 167 NY 58 359 record ev s64 8 2 52 295 d66 63 361 limitation 8 63 S 585 8 64S 3 e 32 M 74 creditor's suit 138 78 enforceable 138 80 369 prom, not 8 63 8 1062 parol evidence a 166 NY 688 must plead 178 488 372 63 S f 90 M 320 substitution 3 63 S 1039 -68 34 36 M 523 termn. contr. 42 M 25 consent 32 CP 274 fair dealing f 96 M 365 1089 377 pers. injury 8 63 3 1066 56 606 sui jiuris SO 236 380 civ. service 8 64 8 r 164 NY rule 62 authority 152 158 166 255 152 439 rent lease 8 64 8 136 112 193 rescission 76M 189 490 construction 8 64 S 116 60 66 562 562 construction B 68 636 s 64 S 310 .„„ , . m 166 NY 606 499 replevin 64 449 s 64 8 94 68 383 384 168 NY 666 52M 249 __ suspension 502 demurrer ~ ' " 30 s 64 8 73 10 AC 283n affirm, defense d 102 299 62 I appeal case 5 - s63S 596* 163 NY a 169 NY 282 399 sale book 8 64 8 147 r 169 NY 85 441 waiver objn s 64 8 26 53M 267 new trial 16AC 12Sn objection 39CP 133 court's power 153 264 not known 153 265 newly disc, ev. 103M 469 446 complaint s 64 8 69 sufficiency 60 437 allegations 153 793 450 Stat, rate s 64 S 246 62 M 305 fee printer lOPNS 15 453 discretion 64 S 83 165 694 460 contri. neg. 8 64 8 198 36 M 338 case Italics 7 AC 494n 462 discovery s 64 8 202 79 636 34 M 224 36 M 413 5 1 2 neg. damage s 64 8 232 d 55 . 54 proximate cause 55 424 expert ev. 78 169 61 M 601 safe appliance do 96 313 exemption 134 241 5 1 8 charge ev 8 64 S 193 60 530 neg. presumption 52 31 64 137 582 74 393 76 39 43 77 366 94 311 97 3 fact question do 97 365 104 104 134 243 s 166 NY 640 safe appliance fl02 316 scaffold 195 NY 422 20 AC 203n master liable 20 AC 160n 20 AC 161n assume risk 153 404 70 M 178 551 570 m. lien s64 8 a 167 NY 82 construction 119 219 73 M 399 right payment 70 M 529 construction 3 64 8 197 60 620 590 3af e place do 97 186 609 592 592 199 566 524 575 387 712 333 575 award 8 64 8 71 78 132 do 144 confirmed 129 83 M justification 138 668 just compensatn 138 172 152 502 not set aside do 147 517 presumption 165 200 M 334 577 conversion 648 - 200 185 161 579 St frauds. 648 461 60 461 95 86 new agreement 10211 688 581 discovery 64 8 96 111 315 E 137 937 50 M 473 370 6 648 292 210 366 76 70 145 21 525 ,64 8 156 12 71 563 795 s64S 67LRA 206 594 lllS 526 672 622 alimony case 27 63 8 770 cross examine 48 M 160 case 2 appeal s63S a 169 NY case 3 appeal 8 638 s 165 NY a 169 NY case 8 neg. damages s 63 8 1108 a 166 NY 628 case 12 habeas corpus 1114 580 1118 627 611 s63S f67 case 17 revocation 8 63 8 a 164 NY case 26 appeal 8 63 8 a 170 NY 623 liens case 2 s63S a 167 NY bad faith case 1 184 1113 3 1105 686 1116 572 756 632 655 628 appeal case 2 8 63 8 1111 a 172 NY 35 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguish«d; f. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed- n note- c. criticised: 1. limited: e, explained; o, overruleo; s. same case; do. dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q. questioned. Vol. 51 N. T. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division VOL.51 I death dam. s 64 S 291 a 164 NY 146 5 surety s64S 1077 86 553 enforceable 177 797 1 8 intention s 64 S 476 36 M 445 63 M 156 25 neg damage s 64 S 511 r 169 NY 289 35 inher. tax a 64 S 4S5 73 327 328 38 local option a 64 S 471 f69 348 120„ 900n 51 M 366 merits f 63 514-516 notice obligation e 34 M 602 637 34 M 35 M 739 e 36 M 696 40 M 357 e 44 M 388 mandamus 106 30 44 liability s 64S 897 132 473 rewards 19A0 127n 47 Doard B 64 S 747 wife's servces 89 118 110 54b 14 AC 206ri husb consent 43 M 559 h and w contract 18A0 23 vest in wife 82 M 565 52 liq. tax certif s 64 S 756 r 163 NY S36 57 declarations s 64 S 433 156 760 70 incompet ev. B 64 S 501 ■e 79 315 77 certiorari E 64 S 494 61 376 64 LRA 50n56n 57n 83 title s 64 S 542 a 171 NY 655 8 AC 443 n voidable 121 205 102M 39 87 good faith s 64 S 347 36 M 163 subordinate 13 AC 301n 95 waiver s 64 S 164 1 02 jurisdiction s 64 S 457 65 196 injunction 66 234 f 238 1 06 charge s64S 417 a 170 NY 561 declarations d 120 772 I 1 7 counsel fees s 64 S 386 a 165 NY 675 74 460 66 M 185 application 99M 456 not a debt 176 794 121 assignment s 64S 315 103M 451 126 parties deft s 64 S 279 166 255 contracts 94 M 736 129 surrender s 64 S 307 34 M 543 134 dam. relief s 64 S 525 96 M 41 1 42 indictment, a 64 S 579 r 166 NY 50 l45cond. precdt s 64 S 532 140 613 authority 140 616 1 52 authority a64S 627 59 304 84 127 60 chat mtge. s 64 S 640 56 519 filing time 13 AC 300n 1 63 election B 64 S 646 ral64NY 10 I 69 injunction s 64 S 589 a 168 NY, 664 69 35 91 M 80 f 91 M 82 damaged 184 517 1 73 removal s 64 S 775 * 165 NY 676 jurisdiction e 55 196 8 57 340 s 165 NY 626 1 78 tax law 8 64 S 539 71 230 182 sheriff liable s 64 S ' 503 46 M 396 I88written v.'ird s 64 S 549 122 654 191 application 353 s64 S 241 766,128 - 911 jurisdiction f 177 674 1 9 8 certiorari a 64 S 676 f 61 632 f57 112 71 229 charter 71 230 refunding 84 124 review 34 M 302 judicial do 174 713 2 1 2 transfer tax a 64 S 1013 63 286 13 AC 349n 2 1 8 venue a 64 S 962 80 328 225 acquiescnc 64 S 877 f 54 621 s 7 AC 403 7 AC . 416n consent lien 125 843 144 663 53M. 304 227 notice a 64 S 973 a 164 NY 573 233 services s 64 S 904 f 66 627 60 645 removal e 75 364 80 14 33 M 316 distinction 119 21 recovery 75M 339 preference 225NY 215 239 6se imprison 64 S 869 76 324 assault damages f78 308 dof78 312 maater liable 80 460 e 91 479 93 465 105 525 109 290 scope employmt 112 297 247 preference .s 64S 950 154 296 74M 595 valid lien 154 294 purchaser 103M 18 250 assessment a 64 S 863 a 166 NY 233 J259 b'kpresd't 8 64 S 888 83 65 268 compet ev 8 66S 5 a 169 NY 674 72 426 11 AC 47 waiver do 133 438 17 AC 124n 274 lease cancel- lation 864 S 1007 a 169 NY 381 e 39 M 644 65M 562 deposit 40 M 248 survival 61 M 637 28 1 bar s 64 S 965 a 166 NY 617 287 for jury s 64S 915 136 197 289 r r. neg s 64 S 925 64 330 d 67 218 220 E 78 M 662 duty care f 69 457 d 74 601 e81 610 56 297 e 34 M 47 10 AC 409 292 negligence a 65 S 21 p 54 623 30 1 sp'l pleading a 64 S 922 12 AC 33d 3 1 waiver 64 S 1029 57 504 60 445 40 M 514 49 M 179 commission HI 756 76 M 588 not binding 152 751 condition void 80 M 14 disregarded 442 32 I prob. cause s 64 S 1016 e59 612 60 475 477 99 320 do 184 NY 516 16 AC 263n corpn. liable 284 taw question 97 221 revers. error 121 286 jury question 133 229 63 M 147 137 846 rule conduct 165 328 328 es toppel 8 64 S 348 a 172 NY 822 a 171 NY 662 332 truat a 64 S 1021 * 165 NY 676 53 184 54 106 243 64 500 56 667 660 77 519 89 372 38 M 583 intention 175 167 1 40 M 334 possession e33M 710 541 salary d 120 recovery d 75M 341 338 legal ey. s e>4 S 996 109 358 344 certificate a 64 S 957 7 AC 462n 347 order exr s 64 S 920 a 79 58 a 164 NY 573 350 atty lien 64 S 1050 38 M 266 41 M 434 8 AC 91n 11 AC 158 355undicl'd prin cipal 64 S 1026 51 318 gift cauaa mortia 65 597 evidence 357 counael fees 12 AC 146n costs 121 582 allowance 68 M 418 statutory " 68 M 414 costs to party 63 M 43'! 106M _ 228 discretion 149 289 to client 106M 418 359fee by client 68 M 417 360 confid'l posi- tion 64 S 593 e 85 382 364 pun. dam. s 64 S 663 a 169 NY 375 64 27 127 870 d 171 NY .445 16 AC 202d 369 incomp. ev. s 64 S 630 32 484 68 16 413 82 22S 63 609 spec 1 pleading f 68 53 78 105. 533 do 78 10.7 do 78 103 17 83 37 12 AC 18d 14 AC 308d restrict proof 197NY 7S pleading 197NY 7 special damages 20 AC 16411 no recovery 20 AC 167r 378 pref. calen dar 3 64 S 605 SAC 488d 380 b, particulrs e 64 S 674 affidavit 81 443 e 39 M 425 reason insuf . 112 776 38 1 prfmance 3 64 S 733 proof waiver 67 52 101 282 defect pleading ( 76 164 10 AC 427n 12 AC 30 amendment 126 434 63M 563 385 arrest s 64 S 615 69 M 326 387 contract 64 S 699 54 634 394 neg s64S 75 8 AC 67 LRA verdict do 140 judicial 141 positive 156 liability 171 105M corpn. 693 557 119n 2700 right 48 act fi72 duty 442 828 510 402 demand 9 64 S 606 69 82 90 8 reply pleading 84 480 valid liens 114 524 406 center st a 64 S 728 a 168 NY 517 84 41 34 M 706 417 accounting s 64 S 660 33 M 673 420 estoppel s 64 S 667 69 521 Stat, limitations 404 404 9 111 177 32 M 611 57M 539 91 M 380 accounting 1 60S 429 dismissal 3 64 S 662 17AC 180n246n 430 transfers a 64 S 745 f 96 324 42 M 612 434 sum. pro b64S 691 8 AC 3Un 436 assessment 3 64 S 717 « 163 NY 606 83 518 85 350 report objectionH 36 M 66 36 M , 123 142 724 44 1 transfer tax 9 64 S 897 9 AC 118hl27n ptnrship realty 13 AC 127n jurisdiction 55 M 474 compromise 155 232 450 °ee. walk s 64 S 636 I 86NY 448 449 e 49 M 310 depression i^ -1 117 84fi defect neg. 119 435 show defect 129 731 liability 140 S37 weight of ev. 143 633 not liable f 169 655 461 alimony s 64 S 635 82 69 34 CP 81 decree II AC 382n 463 eviction s 64 S 617 a 169 NY 593 104 422 86 M 405 470 illegal ev. s 64 S 753 36 M 23 suppress depos'n 15 AC 50n 477 sureties s 64S 740 do 162 125 65M 165 48 1 neg. dam 3 64 S 655 a 168 NY 666 presumption 160 601 488 malice 64 S 713 punit.damageB e 68 101 78 80 HI 271 49 1 authority s 64S 613 183 857 502 ceritorari 64 S 736 amendment e 73 446 5 1 2 damages s 64 S 878 inadequate 479-481 84 579 481 100 53 s63 72 34 M 37 M retrial 64 311 5 1 7 incumbr'nce s 64 S 681 r 169 NY 220 40M 227 b8 AC I construction 60 M 168 522 contract 8 64 S 935 a 169 NY. 583 presumt tioii 142 1T4 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distingaished; t, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; c, ■riticiaed: 1, limited; e, explained; o, overrulert: i. same case; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel ca»e: o. aueitionea. N. Y. Supreme Court ReporSs — Appellate Division Vols, 51, 52 usages 165 custom du 165 535 title s64S 58 587 589 868 466 583 cODtempt 9 64S 68 73 139 94 M defects evidence £51 40 411 856 329 808 66 33 M proof heirs 117 407, 537 relief b6 4S ep. prfmanc 115 certificates 162 equitable action f 165 158 stockholder 181 423 540 bankruptcy 8 64 S 838 13 AC 12n 14n 542 interpleader 953 347 556 569 362 201 378 defect papers 40 M reversal 123 alimony 122 833 226 67 8 64S 45 M 46 M power court SIM 79 K jurisdiction 55 M 7-^ M 545 will e64S schedule burden proof 84 relief 10 AC 382 32 CP 299 heir at law 19A0 283n 19 AC 284n 549encroachmtl s 64 S 831 a 169 N'V: 615 d81 210 8 AC In 5n covenants 48 M 146 553 insurance s 65 S 333 60 144 145 do 60 151 152155 64 188 fraud e 32 M 401 565 hab. corpus 8 65S 114 34 M 700 construction 96 M 104 piano playing 96 M 106 567 amd'compl s 64 S 824 80 505 erve pldg, 18AC 165n, 168d 569 not apply s 64 S 848 199 NT 356 suppress dep 124 637 cond. precedent 933 417 138 536 555 115 132 274 584 m'^rtCDgecs s M s sr 143 82 59 f sp .prfmanc. 3 64 S 908 a 169 NY 372 595 att'y lien s 64 S 901 * 164 NY 576 577 f 168 37 e 41 M 434 restitution SAC 31 [n vacate order 64M 283 6U2 probatt case 2 s64S 1144 s 75 293 805 findings case 1 8 64S 1137 a 167 NY 631 608 party int. 64 LRA 6j.7n cases new trial 64 S a 168 NY case 9 appeal 64 S a 168 NY case 13 pers injury 64 S a 169 NY do 169 NY case 21 iodictment S64S .1 164 NY case 24 appeal s66S 3 165 NY * 172 NY case 28 convietiuo s66S a 164 NY 607f1ockh'.drs case 2 se4S t 62 M 24 61 I order case 5 3 64 S 113 a 164 NY 8 1 2 la\i action case 8 3 64S 36 U 56 M ciefense 153 case 9 discharge s64S * 170 NY 64 case 10 appeal 8 64S a 169 NY 6 1 6 equity sU5S t 161 G4M 6 i 7appeal case 5 s64S a 169 NY case 10 appeal s64S a 166 NY ca&e 25 board power sts s66S 1146 110 386 local authorities. 1146 540 260 371 643 1132 669 409 1135 680 69 830 492 1131 59 1146 623 U32 663 1133 667 1148 118 12i 1145 137 1138 638 659 1139 565 VOL 52 Stel CO. use street 3 64S 96 HI 37 M injunction no 627, e629 police power 6 1 9 accounting cabe 2 3 64 S 59 a 166 NY 62 case 3 report 3 65S a 173 NY 620 appeal s64S a 166 NY 1138 804 125 704 46 229 48 M 48 M rtmtady 104 complaint 16AC 357 right from state 125 81 authority f 167 516 1 3 sup pldg. s 64 S 821 99 28.'i 173 697 8 AC 277n 10 AC 2S3n 60 M 468 r;ght review 1142 616 623 pers i«jury case 3 3 64S 1131 * 166 NY 599 case 6 encroachment .h64S. 1136 a 169 NY 298 case 8 report s64S a 164NY cases 1 A: 13 appeal s64S 1141 lue 140 798 130 138 rS merger 3 64 S r 170 NY 27 commrs. 3 64S a 165 NY 71 compensation o7M d 571V1 1149 574 a 166 NY case 20 appeal s64S r 168 N-i 625 1135 SOO 626 neg injury case 1 s 64 S 817 55 506 632 res. ipsa log case 18 s 64 S 724 71 M 135 633 contempt case 2 s 64 S 073 122 369 no contempt 132 333 pifnishment 140 10311 638 appeal 3 64S a 170NY s 165 NY 328 538 608 571 611 150 165 144 793 579 contempt 6 1 8 insurance s 64 S 930 case 2 m 164 NY 473 s 64 S 1144 indemnity fine 8 68 47P 68 M 498 r 166 NY 310 639 ilismissal cases 3 & 7 s 64 S 1 1 16 a 165 NY 606 64 1 contempt case 3 s65S 1145 * 164 NY ,671 769 605 566 8S 84 do 129 723 96 M 569 award 73 M 2 constitutional 207 NY 613 36 labor hours s 64S 865 65 LRA 37n 40 water power 64S 67 LRA easement 147 73 M covenants 210 NY 50 discontinue 870 403n 262 68 3 64 S 43 M f 94 M 3 7 AC 109 139 assault 88 M 67 lex loci s64S r 169 NY 841 377 152 425 875 119 120 1063 638 67 limitation 3 64 S 861 63M 462 38 CP 50111 intention do 63 58 55 M 600 parol evidence 64 165 ilo 152 82 Dew promise 95 604 35 CP 5n 3S CP .501r, written acknlrni 33 M 376 38 CP 506 aHmit d ebt I9AC 419 38 CP 499 89 neg. damages s 65 S 49 a 165 NY 667 62 374 concurrent neg 79 257 C 258 84 not bar case 5 148 t 160 contrib. 208 NY 518 035 407 neglig. 362 78 estate s 65S 133 f 166 denials 133 privity t 92 M covenant 225XY liability 185 40 78 685 179 296 84 dam. negli- gence 3 64 S 1088 61 622 e 33 M 226 s 171NY 101 90 negligence s 64 S 1002 fellow servants. do 60 64 3 12 AC 64LRA 133n danger 112 96 dower s64S 11 AC 1 00 sum pro. 22 95 111 llSn 204 70 369 370 confirmed 129 objections 69 M 712 26 1080 623 601 1 3 1 m- lien s64S 8 66 s 174NY f 174 I35an'l report 3 64 S 1070 stockholder 169 NY 587 59 600 64 5 125 20 r40 sum pro. 3 64 S 1066 54 628 cond. limitation int. 165 576 356 100 103 109 46 M 94 III forfeiture 60 M 25s 621 222 1 45 damages s64S 1101 a 169 NY 591 61 62 67 LRA . 199 revise verdict 122 105 special damage 66M 262 1 57 repairing 3 65 S 163 a 166 NY 604 1 63 dividends 109 s66S a 170 NY 120 oqtion 120 election 120 default do 120 59 M tender goods 128 145 225 opng acct. s 65 S 168 • 170 NY 575 234 estoppel 65 S 257 76 384 pleadg sp. dam. 12 Ac: error ev do 131 evidence do 131 500 64S 54 42 M tenancy 58M privilege 176 I 04fact question s64S 1060 a 164 NY 567 si 69 NY 304 109 execution 66 S profits 171 unlawful 981 174 5 153n| i 70 expulsion 8 65 S 57 r 164 NY 335 electiuns 54 M 283 pol parties 543 39 CP 301, 302 renew I 82 construction 3 65S 14 s 86 301 91 665 145 243 restoration s 65 S 373 P 52 625 71 233 vol. payment 201 NY 414 247 s65S SAC amendment 61 M ICPNS demurrer 213 NY 1040 628 228 411 s 64 S ILRA 51 M 19 M 19A0 i044 371 233 26 24 24n intent court 64M 576 authority 89 conversion s6SS 19 79 lis 1 92 dower s65S 8 3 63 409 I 95 conversion 3 64 S 1093 93 266 271 cond. precedent 86 M 666 I 1 8 chge. grade 3 64 S 1063 63 293 former theory, 104 4S8 construction 631 r 170 NY 3 180 NY 206 opinion s BoS 103M 233 219 d 110 124 M variance 114 par 128 76 292 553 784 209 interloc j udgment 3 66 S 294 retrial 71 209 210 86 s7AC 506 49' [22 comm ss'rs. 3 64 S 1074 a 164 NY 575 71 555 award 2 1 I parol ev 426J3 65S ■ a 169 NY 56 (ISM 216 possession s65S 293 prin. office 69LRA 43Sn authority 79 II 562 2 1 8 foreclosure 24n 144 misnomer 432 18n 387 208 435 250 countclaim 3 65S 76 137 157 42 M lien defense dl57 379 516 474 433 662 432 258 exr. acctg. s 65 S 358 a 170 NY 427 132 34 fee spl. guardn. 19AC lOln 264 jurisdiction 470 342 54 G73 111 s66S consent 53 36 M by court 15.^ no power 179 276 election s65S 3 57 remedies 96 weight evidence 50 M 662 conversion 116 338 replevin f 38 CP 192 280 nom. dam ^ 65 S 87 11 AC 137n 117 294 rule damage 128 712 382 201 90 284 lien law 3 RS S 50 M rJ^r,;sx^t-^-Jss'^f'^is=.ri.i^'zir^i=i^^^^^^ dismissed; noie ; Vols. 52, S3 N. y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division 290 contract s 65 S 84 88 82 commissions do 137 568 181 431 295 certiorari s 65 S 134 dS6 52 301 leview a 65 S 83 37 CP 208 60 M 111 303 decree 8 65S 8 60 remedy • 55 M not modify 98 M ■ 103 67 472 520 306 negligence s 65 S 179 a 169 NY 585 transfer ticket 71 202 scope employt. 83 14 assault 91 478 10 AC 471 servants torts. 183 NY 391 3 1 2 insurance s 65 S 219 r 169 NY 1 99 8 7 AC 497 53 LRA 819n 823n S24n equity f 87 M 652 presumed 87 M 650 3 1 7 negligence s 63 S 149 a 164 NY 653 67 365 fact question 74 393 395 safe place 77 365 97 115 361 death ne do 130 509 reasonable care 132 104 p facie ev. neg. 20 AC 154 325 act of God s65 S 279 41M 665 14 AC 166 14 AC 345n 338 preferences s 65 S 194 50 M 466 presbytery 67 M 324 construction 67 M 258 obligation 212 NY 55 343 contract s 65 S 160 a 166 NY 618 102 659 349 contract 8 65^S 174 r 169 NY 246 356 perpetuity s65S 81 55 M 468 inference 55 M 468 "all" 86 M 607 358 tenements s 65 S 308 a 166 NY 587 f 68 373 labor law do 78 139 notary fees 84 350 repeal statute 36 M . 284 construction 106 185 e 106 186 363 receiver s 65S 147 54- 517 34 M 634 SAO 400n 403 367 cred. suit s 65 S 122 s 60 98 99 cond. precedent d 131 237 8 60 04 108 do 60 113 46 M . 349 subrogation 69 M 60 371 mandamus s 65 S 342 f 52 626 e 61 189 379 discovery s65S 111 13 AC 449n 4 13 AC 449n 455 456 n 52M 641 57M 95 in>pect book 126 815 39CP 94 382 m. lien 8 65S a 173 NY 614 90 8 performance 79 M 50 recovery 103M s 173 NY 194 418 notes 5 S IS? a 167 NY 107 cond. precedt. 136 464 421 remedy s 65 S 205 424 damages 65 8 260 84 234 428 negb'gence 3 65S 136 54 LRA 142n 434 jury trial 8 65S 234 551 s 36 M 649 36M 654 437 pleading 8 65 S 118 59 M 223 439 conversion 3 65 S 133 89 87 443 conclusive s 65 S 101 54M 89 446 stay s65S a 165 NY 229 385 removal 8 65 S 204 veteran 78 375 80 171 387 lying in hos pital s 65 S 120 a 165 NY 607 390 in trust s 65S 440 86 250 252 d 86 253 402 waiver 8 65 S 330 a 165 NY 672 71 393 135 404 pledgee 38 M 323 conversion 118 269 liability 67 M 439 validate 183 635 cond, precedent 183 637 notification 183 638 407title s65S 8 60 116 613 4 1 I contract s 65 S 288 62 346 129 674 448 libel dam. s 65 a 73 e 68 103 error court ■ 130 608 smart money f 173 493 modify do 175 925 452 costs 65 S d55 131 543 467 accoimting s65S 125 r 167 NY 89 473 marketabl title 8 65 S 183 a 170 NY SAC voidable 143 32 M 79 recovery 166 679 491 preference 8 65 S 385 54 488 e 38 M 44 d 44 JVI 45 R AC 487n 494 ^'dl probate s 65 S 405 r 167 NY 28 495 undue infl. s 65 S 391 f 52 626 minutes evidence 490 e 76 563 boobs as ev. 136 245 original minutes 80 M 477 501 objections s 65S 467 33 M 100 8 AC 377 381n 505 notice s 65 S 44J 56 293 512 flseimpris. 8 65 S 434 56 202 assault 70 409 ejection 13 AG 65n 76n 5 1 5 decree 8 66 S 212 a 164 NY 571 willful default 110 64 522 pers. injury 8 65 S 370 r 175 NY 401 s 176 NY £60 122 290 529 ev. demaixd s 65 S 47b 50 M 330 partnership 18AC 346 443n 152 481 pers knowl 65 S 113 99 246 48 M 494 15 AC 350n 17 AC 316 no knowledge 106M 36.1 483 dene s65S neg. evi- 97 16 spec'l damages 66 413 e 78 533 98 132 12 AC 18n restrict p] oof 197NY 73 inadmissible 20 AC 170n 485 atat. c instn act 3 65 S 274 a 166 NY 588 52 358 do 78 139 Ufi 18 387 533 title 8 65S a 166 NY 38 M 175 SAC 448d 539 attachment s 65 S 38e f 52 628 67 548 afE davit 114 248 grounds 44 M 311 540 admissions 8 65 S 486 s 87 490 do 110 870 s 110 practice pleadng 154 514 550 lien 3 65S 8 67 350 636 558 rule damage s 65 S 31 115 747 748 123 173 driect damage°i 62 M 23 speculative do 147 517 562 neg. am. s65 S 299 a 166 NY 289 scope authority 105 525 575 reason, use s 65 S 454 148 399 583 Sep. counts s 65 S 319 82 o46 joinder 112 31 misjoinder 56M 162 163 601 affidavit s 65 S 439 51 M 595 56 M 48 606 ctrclaim 3 65 S 994 a 170NY 565 f 160 47 6 1 3 foreclosure 3 64 S 809 62 622 usurious 89 M 547 6 1 6 default rape 1 64 S 1012 102M 657 warranties 57M 180 case 2 3 65 S 365 f 62 621 634 f 52 635 167 948 6 1 7fact question s 65 S 263 90 465 title do 90 463 621 appeal case 9 8 65 S 1138 a 167 NY 697 623 cestuique trust case 1 3 65 3 190 59 521 bonds 84 412 624 agency case 14 s65S 1135 8 164 NY 566 a 167 NY 244 625 refunding case 16 s65S 1133 a 167 NY 621 vol. payment 201 NY 414 626 discretion case 6 8 65 S 203 33 M 504 9 AC- 242 627 St. fi-auds case 2 s 65 S 200 a 169 NY 407 assignt security 110 395 628 pleading case 3 «65S 108 a 169 NY 673 70 186 630 lienor case 5 s65S 1136 32 M 384 compliance 45 M 602 case 13 appeal 8 65S 1139 a 169 NY 600 case 33 appeal 8 65 S 1130 a 164 NY 574 63 I Corp. power case 4 _ 65 S 1133 d 56 M 282 case S admr. 3 65 S 1146 r 169 NY 467 case 35 res judicata s 65 S 356 a 165 NY 48 residence case 9 . 65S 1144 185NY 51 68 M 320 creature of contract f 158 390 633 nonsuit case 1 8 65S 1139 a 170NY 591 case 5 apeal s 65S 1130 a 175NY 523 634 negligence case 1 66 S 1137 a 167NY 208 case 18 appeal s65S 1147 * 164 NY 577 635 appeal -use 4 60S 169NY case 5 VOL 53 I not judicial s 65 S 451 152 578 6 accounting s65S d33M conclusive 41 M 100 133 9 claim 9 65 S 459 34 M 608 services value 9 AC 214o burd. defendant 76 M 634 no consideration 79 M 619 allegation 156 807 1 4 nuisance 8 65 S 442 * 166 NY 634 ev. error 87 605 1 6 weight of ev 8 65 S 498 a 169 NY 609 64 260 waiver f 177 447 22 incompet ev. 65 S 481 119 828 1148 504 excise 66 8 174 NY 16 S NY IS bond 66 6 168 c&se lu findings 66 .8 .67 NY 113 132 1139 43 1135 314 436 707 607 274 681 25 dog tax 8 65 8 fli« 8 SAC 24 29 misjoinder b65 8 614 a 165 NY 183 34 M 606 joinder 68 M t.32 32 revocation s 65 S 538 a 167 NY 113 56 583 false reprsns. 57 551 bond 37 36 assessment 8 65 8 581 r 166 NY 110 41 limitations 3 65 S 543 8 84 88 deed void 210 NY 420 45 mentl. capao 8 65 S 533 38 M 271 52 neghgence s 65 8 699 fact question ao 236 signals ev. 13 AC 421n 6 1 weight ev. 9 65 8 597 a 164 NY 572 64 260 81 . 249 necessity rr. 15 AC 46in 74 certificate 8 65 S 687 review 62 234 65 245 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; t, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; c eriticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o. overruled: s« same ca se; do. dissentine opinion; p. parallel case: q, oaestiened. N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division Vol. 53 85 7 AC 55 M 178 461 n 198 I 50 substitution intimidation a 65 S 738 82 55 614 d 83 76 legal rights 728 201 190 703 65 S 145 stay lOOM 80 decree 8 65S conversion 126 a 169 NY liability do 148 individual 210 NT 86 jurisdiction s 65 S 753 s 103 492 I 52 conclusive s65S 64 161 retirement s65S a 164 NY I 64 estoppel exceptions 60 .„ 7 AC 460n65 859 malic, reports 124 e 99 614 eq. jurisdiction t 174 248 832 may strike 572 - - • 13 8 65 S 61059 865 conspiracy 621 89 neg, damaeea 8 65 S 842 a 170NY 570 66M 81 93 insp'n books B 65 S 926 refusal remedy 9 AC 4g4n 495a 12 AC 12n flood faith 106 mandamus 117 :57 96 affidavit 8 65S do 59 85, 1 67 beneficiary !s65S 815 112 e 86 449 d 37 M 47 95 M 430 insurance 119 escape payment 135 778 350 349 329 174 interference 221NY not illegal f 221NY 172 notice nee 732 628 97 amendment s 658 920 19AC 303n valuation 85 M 327 opinion 103M 14 105 presiunption i 65 S 879 a 167 NY 163 incompetent 169 391 I 20 trademark » 65 S 735 a 169 NY 478 s 8 AC 50 122 jurisdiction 750 376 585 340 832 345 557 107 s65S 60 eSl 93 131 57M 92 M attachment 110 vacate levy 60 M 546 I 27 firm note s 65 S 872 a 169 NY 688 136 leave to sue s 65 S 760 d76 78 81 75 rulea of law 128 468 not sustained 154 226 I 40 charge cou r s 65 S 894 s 53 627 75 587 duty landlords 152 460 s 6jS 19A0 78 M 86 M one year f 166 I 78 trust 3 65S 54 56 89 33 M 39 M 40 M 889 220n 225n 673 660 629 725 105 502 667 373 711 431 334 I 8 1 assessment s 65 S 935 d 57 108 review 63 128 1 87 assessment s65S a 165 NY f53 t67 interest 44 AI 1 93 decree 8 65S a 165 NY lurisdictioQ 855 658 631 271 133 907 645 72 M 595 620 s 65 S SAC 334 review 72 M 200 jurisdiction s 66 S 59 persn. knowledge 8 AC 76 47 M 70 M test proof 176 present facts 176 53M 215 65 369 9s65S 463 f 53 174 249 250 f 221NY 354 f 221NY 355 252 356 359 do 171 16AC innuendo 14 AC 174 issuable 71 M denials 106M 245 ultra vires s 65 S 826 do 76 431 119 306 s 169 NY 576 d98 613 615 discovery 114 378 construction 115 392 251 assignment s 65 S 733 65 520 pleading 35 M 205 bank's power 106 559 party in int. 66LRA note title 68 LEA 68LRA 587n 609n 211 311 260 monument 8 65 S 912 166 NY 92 56 337 exceptn to grant d 77 451 86 536 39 M 36 46 reservation 135 574 not divest 149 60 title in city 140 271 substitution 273 eviction 3 6SS 806 33 M 130 8 AC 71 291 . 497 129 212 276 assumed risk 111 418n 422n 423 426n 83 29 I demurrer 812 627 70 52 578 243 n 41 In 465 fact 13 163 293 discovery 3 66 S 758 36 M 154 11 AC 258n 18AC 196n cause action 121 885 295 form action s 66 S 766 63 387 74 538 receiver ev. 124 747 30 I grading st a 65 S 89 877 635 313 restrictions = 66 S 244 60 M 600 injunction 156 531 320 ante nuptl. 3 65 S 577 55 431 59 LRA oral contract 171 NY 401 certification 7 AC 458n voluntary 54 M 404 322 reference s 65 S 693 119 691 sole remedy 159 458 343 assumpsit s 65 S 709 79 403 counterclaim 67 M 257 98 M 324 out of tort 98 M 324 lien filed 105M 673 350 neg. in st. 8 65 S 867 58 691 judicial notice 96 329 104 89 ripan rights 188NY 83 358 domain 66 S 1056 59 259 tax time lien 60 85 128 508 74 79 e 179NY 56 judioal duty 86 257 tax no lien 69 M 462 nund. precedent 113 338 384 pleading case 2 8 65 S 1036 74 538 no exceptions 87 602 7 AC 460n consent beneficiaries do 147 130 special term 79 M 109 4 1 1 contract 486 objections 8 65 S 1049 432 transfers _ 65 S 1068 96 324 leased extensions f 36M 42 M 10 AG new trial case 8 121 waiver 39 CP 1 railway fares 324 mbrtahty tables aa ev a65S 59 73 damages 11 AC 642 504 58n 252 830 108 DRn not excessive ^•^^ 71 M 525 74B 327 brokerage LJ" ..ceo /. 8 66S 208act will bind s 65 S 778 153 150 2 I 2 conatruction 3 66 S 818 a 167 NY 135 223 new trial s 65 S 742 r 165 NY 33 227 labor organ- ization s 65 S 946 a 170 NY 315 59 484 injunction e67 15 no coercion 154 822 279 civ. service 65 S 844 r 166 NY 44 283 negligence 65 S 764 trespasser e 81 612 -614 41 M 403 ri.sk assume 183 NY 73 duty 112 434 286 contract s 65 S 838 3 80 62rt s 90 149 s65S 70 42Sn ratification d 34 M authority 13 AC enforcement 104 authority 109 638 46 268 478 323n 138 48 330 revocation s 65 S 673 59 223 property right 94 448 rebate 9 AC 468n jurisdiction 10 AC 14n 29 336 diamissal .^ 65 S 696 80 323 94 290 96 3 339 certiorari 03 S 707 '!2 M 69 393 eviction r 169 NY 8 AC 4 330 427n 395 shade tree 3 65S f 181 NY 90 14 AC easement 197 NY I equest 148 redress f 96 M 1090 321 390 317n 104 exceptn 716 28 29 .COS » 169 NY 171 - stqppel 148 195 NY 10 591 431 772 330 159 by jury 84 M 641 628 354 677 s80 -82 39 M judic. notice 112 898 presentment do 72 M 45 bank agent 406 512 469n 910 i04M 490 cyclist _65S a 175 NY 8 AC 491 relief ^65S 92 8 8 AC jurisdiction 118 68 M 443 costs s65S 57 f 89 M one item e36M 40 M 85 M discretion M 447 police 3 65S a 166 NY 3 54 pay officer 34 M SAC 453 may must 386 1123 99 610 200 183 474 1030 592 165 684 246n a 164 NY s64 conatruction 64 40 M 402 sale court s65S 1120 69 613 presumption 64 402 sureties 177 554 13 AC 367n custodian 160 308 407 contempt 3 65 S 1028 68 426 82 404 95 409 13 AC 179n 180n amount fine f 169 53 04M 619 cond. precedent 148 434 reversal f 169 52 4 1 sureties 3 65 S 1051 * 165 NY 638 4 1 3 negligence s 65 S 1044 56 513 78 420 requests 70 610 4 1 8 appeal s 65 S 1 093 97 532 376 380 4 59 neg corpn. 3 65S 1033 * 170 NY 54 f 72 632 462 junsdictioh 3 65 S 1083 e 33 M 300 465 defect 65 S 1046 164 416 470 burdn proof 3 65 S 1062 a 168 NY 669 67 451 construction do 67 456 f 69 399 400 f 69 407 475 new trial 3 65 S 1085 d65 91 discretion 480 939 523 119d 999 172 70 431 64 68 71 terms SAC 419 48 416 391 392i, retrial error 104 77 82 478 discretion 65 S 1077 72 .579 497contrib. neg. s 65 S 967 126 770 d 171 964 507 countercl'm a 65 S 964 46 M 269 526 remedies 3 65 S 987 262 68 376 15 AC 156n expulsion e34JVI 561 d 662 interference 72 M 474 531 legis. power s 65 S 1004 82 il 632 541 decree 3 66 S lOlO 62 624 86 156 168 547 bankruptcy s 65 S 1001 37 M 232 trustee 132 296 prerequisites 155 44 551 canal sewe r i 65 S 970 61 LRA 852 561 wampum 3 65 S * 169 NY 3 164 NY 1014 588 564 1022 275 628 565 decree 65 S 61 note in lien e96 award in lien 41 M 308 title vesting 14 AC 139n -et-')ff waiver 49 M 408 exemptions .53 M 221 tid'l evidence ao M 24 571 negligence B 3 65 S 989 a 169 NY 689 169 NY 125 127 110 622 56 LRA 854 AliUREVl.ATIONS: a. allirmed; d, distinguished; £, followed- r reversed- m mnHifi.,! . • a:.^:, ,a c criticised: 1, limited; .. explained ; 'o. overS\ed: s.' s^Jme caTef do^STng'op^ioT:^ pa«lielH«e?5f USUi^^^^^^^^^ Vols. 53, 54 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division 576 revocation s 66 S 13 a 165 NY 618 10 AC privilege 52M; certificate 216 NT consents 184 23n 327 457 625 592 negllg.dam. sL66S 1116 8 62 473 476 neg-co servt 122 376 599 demurrer s66S 11 40 M 54 55 11 AC 176n defect complt. 101 307 relief 62 M 623 52M 36 counter complt 60 M 60 complaint suffic 149 265 602 aselenment s 66 S 24 a 167 NY 536 burden proof 104 516 608 implied war ranty s66S a 173 NY 14 AC warranty d 158 f 162 f 170 1114 593 287n 464 910 6 1 3 certiorari s 66 S 49 m 166 NY 163 amend charter 637 injunction case 2 s66S parties sl08 s 164 NY r 168 NY case 4 lease s66S r 169 NY case 6 certiorari s66S a 166 NY case 10 robbery s66S a 168 NY case 12 new trial s66S a 166 NY case 16 appeal 8 66S * 164 NY case 17 appeal s 66 S 1133 * 164 NY 579 personal service 149 305 639 nonsuit case 1 s 65 S 1027 61 455 640 commissons case 2 1147 286 569 597 1141 377 1140 g42 1139 593 1142 599 1125 680 689 1134 421 1142 663 95 M 626 appeal case 6 s65S a 169 NY case 11 reformation e6as m 170 NY case 13 damages s65S a 166 NY case 17 appeal s6SS a 172 NY 627 retroaction case 2 s65S 60 e66 74 627 report case 4 s66S a 167 NY b65S 88 case 14 appeal e66S * 165 NY 64 1 negligence case 21 65S 955 59 252 64 357 1126 82 1146 611 je 13 new trial s66S 76 B 169 NY lawful act 181 1142 317 614 435 645 removal s65S a 165 NY 79 113 178 NY 1142 540 1145 658 1146 263 452 535 1149 530 628 appeal s 65 S 834 a 166 NY 611 act] damage do 129 297 63 1 new trial case 1 s65 S 1150 a 165 NY 669 635 bonds s 65 S a 170NY 801 643 330 545 48 648fact question 3 66S 1148 _ 66 337 339 s 66S 444 81 447 weight of ev do 103 321 649 report case 1 s66S a 171 NY case 2 frM assignment a 66 S 1128 r 169 NY 293 case 3 report s66S a 170 NY case 5 repoi t r66S a 169 NY 1136 649 1126 564 1131 588 757 58 650 ejectment case 1 s66S a 169 NY case 10 costs 8 66S r 165 NY f67 1127 399 1147 204 318 221 184 1 4 discontin'ce s 66 S 241 f 54 617 defective tender VOL. 54 1 certiorari s66S 8 8 AC a 166 NY review 186 209 124 697 141 6 per stirpes a 66 S 218 170 13 9 agency s 66 S 199 NY 105 1 7 costs 8 66S 66 8 8 AC 23 costs s66S 8 AC 83 84 270 283 134 340 241n 26 neg damages 8 66 S 347 91 410 54 M 449 8 8 AC 116 29 jury question 8 66 S 280 61 M 100 33 physician 8 66 S 303 55 413 illegal 39 M 95 s 8 AC 190 SAC compensation 102M 105 37 trust fund --.:. 314 e 37 M 70S identification 155 113 no preference 167 21 45 trial calendar 8 66 S 299 do 70 23 26 222 641 42 M 19A0 35n jury question 119 180 privilege 68 M 353 69 recovery s 66S 334 204NY 4211 74 penalty gas s 66 S 292 3 8 AC 199 83 ejectment s 66 S 289 a 8 AC 162 86 misrepre sentations s 66 S 344 94 M 467 90 amendment s 66 S 321 d 64 365 12 AC 22n 56M 343 99 direct verdict s 66S 349 rl70 NY 1 1 03 intention 327 66 567f 568 deposit trust 349 1 37 fr'd transfer 66 S 430 * 167 NY 613 40 M 11 presumption 152 207 evidence clear 152 208 f69 f 77 82 89 38 M e39M 40 M- 44 M ILRANS ^„^j depositor 305 51 M trustee 19A0 1 42 loan ass'n s 66 S 422 * 166 NY 612 shareholder 72 496 •13 149 eq. adjustment 1 88 discovery 8 66 S 37S f 54 630 89 20 18AC 192n, 196n necessity I8AC lOOn. 191n 1 9 1 sham ans 23 682 583 179 487 489 597 296 S 310 75 77 94 101 c 106 44 M 45 M 46 M receivers 16 AC 29n, 31 n 16AC 33n stockholders IGAC 30, 32, 36 security 16AC 38ii I 53 intention 8 66 S 417 62 126 -66S s54 68 106 no waiver 135 acceptance 135 proper practice 152 98 1 92 show facts s 66 S 691 46 M 273 1 99 amend ans- 1 55 leave appl. 78 179 jurisdiction 78 8 8 AC eq.relief 92 veranda 65 M 224 208 290 336 47 nom. dam 3 66 S 288 61 441 le 8 AC 155 49 amendment 8 66 S 257 64 651 e 69 324 69 325 79 51 19A0 306n special term 79 M 109 54 limitation s 66 S 282 17AC 64n construction 135 373 61 incumbrance 8 66 S 276 a 166 NY 606 431 334 623 792n 379 248 109 authority s 66 S 337 64 374 sum. pro 63 M 23 agent 136 700 I 1 8 sher'f. sale a 66 S 401 s86 618 1 24 master neg 8 66 S 398 a 172 NY 660 65 47 fellow servts 95 118 Ul > 586 assumed risk e97 73 liability 129 615 distinction 64M 175 no coservants 81 M 318 1 26 conversion s 66 S 397 s 8 AC 237 amendment d 45 M 294 296 dl03 68 1 32 merits s 66 S 396 90 655 a 8 AC 256 deciaion defect s66S 8 8 AC 223NY 1 57 title 611 514 464 373 ,„, ^ 350 s 66 S assumption 411 246 43 468 525 199 62 deed control 38 M 12 AC intention 100 monuments do ::42 3.".o actual location 80 M 273 1 64 negligence 8 66 S 367 d 64 294 _ 60 274 fact question 62 373 74 196 35 M 389 1 68 jurisdiction s 66 S 370 d 60 280 judgt credtr. 44 M 36 preferences 50 M 466 1 75 appeal a 66 S 361 a 167 NY . 506 by defendant e 86 322 att'ya lien 87 a 8 AC atty. client d 116 attorney^'' 38 CP 1142 631 379 571 3G3 363 649 331 359 149 468 271 254 s66S e71 f 108 affidavit 81 91 show facta e45M 117 54M relief merits 180 842 200 "truetee" s 66 S 604 e 37 M 74 security costs 9 AC 383n 386n 202 trust fund s 66 S 631 f 54 632 discovery 13 AC 455n equity interest 137 205 fraud s66S a 170 NY 36 M 38 M 101 2 1 4 taxation s66S a 170 NY 44 M indefinite 55 M divesting 71 M 198 231 792 357 I 80 election s66S ' r 164 NY final order f 158 527 ABBREVIATIONS: e c, criticised ; I, limited ; 1 86 amendment 260 s 66 S 376 ,„ 160 614 IdJ sureties i arrest 233 waiver - 66 S 414 67 M 402 a 66 S a 170 NY 5S3l ^62 443 670 505 217 129 390 573 587 396 435 230 2 f 7 taxation a 63 S 766 a 165 NY 645 n tM bank stock 57 603 actual value 60 283 84 474 92 622 construction 84 476 476 review injury 101 602 dom icile tax 69 LRA 435n 223demurrer a 64 S 276 a 175 NY 1 S 615 85 448 combination do 85 460 461 64 LRA 736 eq. pleading 134 469 708 109 , afBrmed; d, distinBUiahed ; f, followed; r, reveraed; m, modified; *, diamissed; n, noU e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, dissenting: opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, queationni N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division Vol. 54 238 distinction sfiB S 678 54 M 561 prepond ev. 136 375 150 841 99M 676 liy jury 84 M 641 new trial 99 M 31 palpably wrong 99 M 32 244 b. ladine 299 discharge 52M 66 S s54 s65S newly 185 348 TiSBlnoticeappt. 633' 58M 181 369;not bind plaintff 110 302 pers. injury 8 66 S 533 r 166 NY 433 145 374 salary s66S a 166 NY temp, appt e33M 309 money had a 66S 171NY 248 trust 6 66S 39 M 40 M 252 neg. ev. 517 212 591 431 334 66 S 8 65 fiduciary 146 recovery 87 M 3f5 not excessive s 66 S £ 94 M 221 611 596 S09 811 611 522 562 263 a 170 NY 63 skill 65 LRA468n500 644n servant defendt 152 573 not servant 84 M 492 378 substitution 66 S 633 f 54 637 ^■'■^ 1382 damages 014S66S 788 "^ lrl7lNY 208 386 insurance .,-,a3 66S 651 532 533 711 3 1 8 indorsement 8 66 S 817 f 102 535 323 by-Iawe s 66 S 613 34 M 623 329 contract s66 'binder' 46 M 398 contract 8 66 8 60 10 AC a 170 NY 57LRA 258 snow neg. 66 S 13 AC i 66 S t68 ^95 15 AC 623 331 costs 112 113 b 66 S 376 3 3 On 262 domain s66S a 185 NY 59 36 M discretion 71 M 519 644 572 525 439 28 863 266 arrest b66S n 171 NY 76 172 neg fel servt. 43M 131 271 banking B 66 S 773 a 176 NY 549 enjoin merger 124 275 carrier s66S a 170 NY liability d 201 NY 513 387n 621 255 costs 531 456 will trust e 67 S 200 a 167 NY 472 212 479 award 8 67 S 57 f54 634 abandonment highway 96 60 13 AC 249n 14 AC 267n easements 128 48 aom. damages 128 49 488 preference 1027 44 45 487n conclusive 210 NY 545 negligence s66S 71 73 not liable 65M duty care 153 45 759 31 62 666 196n 405 transfer tax s 66 S 636 a 166NY 602 408 amend after trial s 66S 771 19AC 306n e38M d44M 8 AC 489 67S 177 495 appeal 3 66S * 170 NY 1118 292 593 508 361 619 injunction case 1 s66S * 173 NY s55 case 2 neg. evidence s66S d63 due care 136 549 guardian b66S 1014 42 M 7 good faith 103M 73 559 reformation 6 199 s67S 57 usury 40 M e41M 342 389 ^* 566 notice 864 1028 591 498 certificate s 67 S 23 58 205 500 allowance 4 1 2 accord „ ,s56S 134 984i9 67S 1149 634 81 44 265 841 148 396 334 order 66 8 f54 compet examn do 166 NY 452 342 banking s 66 S 662 a 172 NY 102 345infringmt. 66 S 626 68 140 „, copy trade mrk] presumption 149 54835 similar name 88 AC 4 1 4 commissions s 66 8 936 95 213 family 71 M 6« 422 nuisance s 66 8 838 67 32 s67S s 166 NY 64 trust 70 186 new trial 80 93 " 121 52 M reUef 11 AC 97 npinif'D 38 CP waive lien 20 AC 847 169 349 intent s66 8 r 166 NY 358 residence 396 315 contempt 55 M 28I^eference e 66 S 664 11 AC 321n jurisdiction 55 M 181 reference proper 75M 530 284 monument 9 66 S 668 56 337 29 I negligence s66 8 88 8 8 AC 16AC lOlM 360 evidence 8 66 S 514 73 49 s66S d60 77 cf^ntrib neg. 82 do 84 94 i nstructlon 116 594 276 164 16 205 395 160 296 settle rights s 66 S 700 153 142 prior lessee 153 143 construction 153 147 702 522 660 283 268 168-911 385 238 427 injunction s 66 8 66 33 M „,, r 172 NY damages 184NY e 111 167 17 M nuisance 143 89 637 568 110 638 231 362 524 526 168n 492 512 partners 1019 230n 8 66 8 8 AC 570 weight ev 1007 534 616 |a 168 NY 647 .1 295 631 surety 595 9 342 263 666 621 m lien case 1 s66 8 a 169 NY case 2 fact question 8 66 8 419 93 652 59 M 615 623 negligence 8 66 8 436 a 166 NY 604 signals ev. 13 AC 416n 625 recovery case 1 3668 a 169 NY case 10 monument s66S e56 case 21 injunction s66S 77 286:176 NY 615' 632 corrobortan case 6 8 66 S 677 45 M 12a payment cost case 4 s66S 54M 16 M 66 60 63 review 82 85 new trial 12 AC cond'l sale 106 public policy 155 756: 539 205 125n 167 573misdemeanr. s 66 8 995 174 806 575 allowance B 8 1009 a 172 NY 595 69 601 damages waived 737 470 665 1 21 171 839 617 s66S 61 accounting 84 41 M 103 discovery 18AC 5 1 4 receiver a 66 8 f 173 NY 8 57 SAC 102 1034 620 645 446 519 197d 179 582 order b66 S 170 NY successor 118 54 435 reference s 66 S 996 do 62 71 L77 454 36 M 632 43 M 162 363 reference 66 S 628 73 600 sum pro. 8 AC 310n 313n atty aoctng 131 455 44 1 remittitur |s66S 1112 365 injunction 's 65 NY 288 6 66 8 666199. 244 63 336 strictly followed subseq. lang. 89 488 incompt. ev. 94 8 review 48 M 358 charge controls 99 494 declarations 52M 471 473 rullnga 144 146 454 atty. client 151 costs 151 s66S s8AC alienable 81 M remedies 179 782 309 413 759 976 593 626 400 362 426 1028 19 332 66 8 a 173NY 90 omissions 172 626 appeal case 4 8 66 8 a 171 NY case 5 new trial 8 66 8 a 165 NY case 7 _ new trial b66S a 169 NY case 16 mandamus 66 8 e55 case 19 appeal h66 8 al71 NY strike out 11 case 22 s66S 129 1146 563 1129 33S 755 308 438 1129 78 46S 833 596 8 1150 633 tax case 2 s66S a 166 NY discharge case 3 6 66S p54 I case 4 order 66 S 585 contract 66 8 1092 s 71 619 592 evidence 8 67 8 a 172 NY error f54 laches 54M cost 11441 case 4 670 s 663 liOlI 1142^**1 613 1140 12s 1125 308 559 632 1129 78 468 634 discovery case 1 ,orS66S 610 136 73 524 6^^ 39 M 248 11 AC 25911 case 2 promotion s 67 8 1142 r 166 NY 444 126 657 1128 695 262 435 526 navigation s 66S 1031 64 LRA 979n 530 penalty a 66 8 1096 e 66 128 67M 63 Supreme Court 532 negligence s67 8 r 171 NY 59 76 8 95 assault 33 CP 63 377 41 345 250 204 91 incompetent f 177 596 neg. dam s 66 8 1052 d 74 600 604 accounting s 66 8 1000 41 M 161 6 1 6 negligence case 2 s 66 8 1128 a 166 NY 210 f 62 624 62 626 6 1 7 revocation case 13 s66S r 165 NY 541 cross exam s 66 8 1098 6 1 8 appeal 89 410 case 16 . error court s 66 8 133 261 'a 169 NY 628 appeal case 4 s66S a 167 NY case 13 new trial .■i66 8 a 170 NY case 17_ new trial 8 66 8 a 170 NY 629 appeal case 3 »66o a 167 NY case 7 appeal .66 8 8 166 NY a 173 NY appeal case 12 1127 623 1135 576 1125 619 1128 256 1127 624 594 636 new trial a 66 S 605 a 166 NY 622 jury question 139 68S 637 serv. sums case 20 8 67 S 1134 a 61 171 case 37 insurance B 67 S 1138 a 170 NY 94 jurisdiction case 38 s67S 1136 38 M 65 1132 188 _ 6'7 S d 171 NY case 14 credibility s66S a 169 NY 630 appeal case 3 s66 8 a 165 NY report case 4 1130 631 638 merits case 19 67 8 35 M 1147 246 1130 616's66S 1130 T54 659 642 359 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; c criticised; 1. limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, dissenting opinion; p. parallel case; q, qae8tien«4 Vol. 55 N. Y. Supreme Court Eeports — ^Appellate Division VOL- 55 8 costs «67S f57 101 15 AC 279 627 130 487 1 neg. dam. B 66 S 1107 r 169 NY 254 34 M 188 11 AC 58d 1 6 serve sumons a 66 S 1024 9 AC 271b managing agent 62 M 409 20 license corp b66S lies 13 AC 383n 23 neg. dam. B 66 S 1072 a 170 NY 589 69 127 neg. quest*n fact e 103 49 fact question 97 449 59 M 616 nonsuit error 139 728 40 bomidiiry line B 67 S 27 a 171 NY 403 RO review 136 172 49 neg. damages a67S 74 does 57 conjecture 164 417 73 M award d 164 80 exception 8 67S 83 83 review b67S * 166 NY 68 deficiency 87 no review 136 87 estoppel s67S 89 authority 39 M 63M f 85 M enforcible 159 90 new trial b66S 110 18AC 38 AC vacated 52M $10 costs 71 M 55 contract s66S a 171NY 34 M 58 notice b66S 114 66 M 1003 659 654 1042 617 189 imconstitut ional 64 64 72 e79 80 do 81 178 NY nonsuit f 68 no excuse 125 Buiiic. excuse 200 NY 323 269 270 292 527 439 437 565 217 264 314 sum. pro 66 s66S B 166 NY 8 AC «8AC attorney's 10 AC 18AC funds 103M 68 intent s 67S 183 e4M authority 68 M 74 allegations B 66 S 972 45 M 349 77 future dam s 66 S 1005 discretion 157 032 1121 641 311n 397 lien 37n 55i) 142 84 369 576 631 221 898 54 600 172 600 205 625 1046 371 30 389 507 521 1 55 guaranty B 66 S 809 44 M 382 y;uarantor 60 M 180 159 conti-ib. neg a 66 S 764 do 184 NY 298 163 pleadine s 66 S 1)4 122 complaint 123 135 87 M allegations 62 M 150 92 reservation 66 S 1066 9 93 580 173 NY 463 release 61 LRA 447 810 satisfaction 159 751 95 bona fides 3 66S 1116 d 60 630 allegations 62 145 d39M 17 18 98 neg damages s66S 64 68 do 71 104 proximate ■ 151 164 165 103 appeal 66 S a 168 NY 1021 496 369 450 65 cause 71 119 894 1063 680 I ! I evidence ? 67 S 116 54 M 449 duty commisnr. 68 M 287 I 13 errtr court 5 67 S 43 156 413 1 24 transfer tax 8 67 S 46 171 NY 96 147 pwr. s 67S 105M accounting d 106M costs 106M 1 5 1 receiver B66S 9 56 court 18 445 382 383 1039 181 815 108 75 508 374 155 526 705 conclusions 208 no interest s 66 S 959 f 175 863 2 1 bailee proof 8 66 S 781 1 107 301 bailee neff. 17AC 225 225n 226 2 1 2 damages s 66 S 835 171 NY 269 223 commission s 66S 827 57 34J 225 prejudice assignment s 67 S 149 69 s 62 538 62 539 541 s 106 343 344 injunction 66 law 142 175 801 1 65 champerty "■ ~ 921 564 345 544 29!t 58u 344 90 8 66 111 s34 M 35 M 36 M s 42 M 4211 on s66S a 170 NY 125 except ions 99 106 15 AC ejectment 25 169 review 128 question appeal 151 759 weight of ev. 157 67 1 70 bankruptcy s 66 S 780 8 8 AC 281 236 US 557 liability 185 604 1 72 mortgage 8 66 S 902 a 170 NY 562 1 76 safe applinc 66 S 899 70 388 1 8 f contempt s 66 S 1836 8 56 151 discretion 82 438 1 86 strike out 67 S 96 40 M 134 135 543 516 f 61 130 92 1 28 route 8 67S 35 M 439 674 )34 town liable a 67 8 118 104 600 1 43 negligence s 67 S 185 a 169 NY 616 d 95 314 57 LRA 1 90 appeal 8 66S 8 8 AC jurisdiction 51 M 195 bias s66S 57 66 51 617 118 107n 951 294 553 849 347 206 chge venue f s66S 847l 165 894 e46M 236 277 penalty s 67 S 38 f62 623 pure milk 136 133 281 nuisance s 67 S 122 s 36 M 398 284 assumption 8 66 S 874 50 M 83 292 serv sumns 8 67 S 165 s 8 AC 404 9 AC 267n 295 compliance J 66S 963 39CP 284 302 substitution S 942 8 AC 332 9 AC 319n 18 617 279 428 227 493 103 104 s 173 NY 156 161 discretion 114 237 234 indictment s 67 S 26 I 166 NY 361 238 non compliance 66 164 1084 582 1056 590 583 110 241 laches 8 66S a 170 NY 92 15 AC before burial 70 M 29 compliance 91 M 543 245 privilege 8 67S r 168 NY 73 33 CP a 168 NY construction 121 authority 177 492 89 •347 137 696 155 674 260 certiorari 66 S 884 r 166 NY 462 263 walks neg. s 66 S 821 15 AC 320n 270 aggrieved 8 66 S 784 71 8 33 CP i not aggrieved 151 236 repres, rights 139 713 272 neg dam 9 67 S 78 80 319 fact queBtion 231,83 ' 613 ction upheld duty delegation 212 NY 173 do 96 313 I for jury 401 fixtures s 67 S 157 a 171 NY 629 s 169 NY 696 192 NY 303 20 AC llln 405 legal effect >6S 968 222NY 21 927 624 163 165 523 612 587 621 462 144 387 287 508 3 1 5 contract s66S a 166 NY 58 do 58 59 f61 87 f67 77 84 121 33 CP rules 84 party interest 91 237 consideration ■ 37 M 380 8 8 AC 326 adoption 12 AC 233n 18AC 105n, 10f>n 107n 114u competent ev. 170 NY 667 specif, prfmance 174 NY 68 e 46 M 80 16 AC 290n custotly child "OM competency f 158 32 I neg. damage 66 S 910 e 75 277 d75 2?8 8 93 83 329 an*l report 952 129 95 301 4 1 physician s66S r 172 NY illegal 39 M, s8 AC compensation 102M 105 4 1 9 irregular s 66 S 866 * 166 NY 698 53 M 250 97 M 639 amendment lOOM 266 38 CP 347, 349 423 insurance 586 907 s66S a 171 NY 33 1 lease s66S a 166 NY complaint d 171 damages d 171 861 184 979 77 368 improper statement 3 66 S 884 372 conviction s 66 S 889 55 372 improp statemts 71 do 72 90 reversal 164 132 390 424 388 chge venue s 66 S 931 a 165 NY 649 8 AC 262 16AC 169n legis. power e 128 704 705 implied repeal 149 repeals 149 395 surety s66S a 170 NY 75 irrevocable 170 847 896 917 684 401 559 103M 586 470 chge venue 8 67 S 176 16AC 161n 119 338 39 CP 340 471 record ev 8 67S a 171 NY 66 tax sale title 86 41 M 109 f 161 limitation 66M waiver 161 489 neg. dam. 67 S a 172 NY costs 6 do 126 s66S r 173 NY 82 waiver 119 172 990 72 433 592 53 430 marriage s66S a 171 NY 433 widow s67S r 173 NY exemptions 39 M 967 396 108 163 222 440 foreclosure s 66 S 862 a 166 NY 621 liability 97 M 435 444 contract s66S 64 81 a 179 NY 867 144 419 542 871 387 449incompt. 8 66S 137 waiver 20 AC 28811 inadmissible ia3M 551 454 sureties 67 S 97 66 623 67 73 58 M 603 ) 464 neg. coaervt '. s 67 S 104 aenl. objection 304 172 355 'must account s67S 95 111 18AC compet. ev. 58M 90 M identity 135 objection f 78 M 13 145 847 236 484 244 502 475 local act 8 67 S 291 a 166 NY 486 vested right 102M 320 immunity 102M '314 484 covenant 112 324 581 226 358 124 3 647 189 636 923 50 1 care sick s 66S 1059 69 LRA 521n 507pers injury s 67 S 403 83 609 5 1 5 receiver 8 67 S 229 a 168 NY 354 sup. pro. 89 407 valid bill e 64M 335 523 sparks neg s 66 S 9 AC 107 973 338 136 528 party 67 S 8 65 418 555 529 surrender 8 67 S 269 r 173 NY 50 532 demurrer s67S 65 77 171 strike out 91 do 93 f 171 34 M 41 M 44 M e 69 M 8 8 AC 9 AC defense pldg 84 108 idn 127 343 274 52 313 576 98101 323 510 62 311 574 301 580 74 453 411 ABBREVIATIONS: c, criticised ; 1, limited a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f. followed; r. reversed; m, modified; 'dismissed; n. »»" f. explained; o, overruled: s, same case; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case; q. questioneo N. 7. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division Vols. 55, 56 do 133 42 M 46 M denials 86 126 358 91 M pleading 136 364 76 438 67 500 100 686 a 172 NY 624 827 report cases s67S a 169 NY 534 presmntion s 67 S 342 9 AC 404n 544 certiorari J67S * 166 NY dll4 71 72 91 241 154 860 229 46 47 175 report 371 549 an s67S 104 stockholders 128 525 555 franchise 8 67 S 413 a 166 NY SOI s 55 528 consent 98 285 286 566 contrih. neg s 67 S '*42] 67 101 f 47 M 106 fact question e 44 M 201 108 267 570 waiver s 6Y S 434 89 M 542 576 demurrer s 67 S 427 e 95 186 a 167 NY 625 37M S20d.621 pleading 135 243 585 acceptance s 67 S 350 a 170 NY 162 8 57 631 84 255 "sample" sale 92 204 42 M 182 13 AC 224n 229n s 170 NY fil2 175 NY 390 594 assignment s 67 S 447 r 166 NY 416 61 370 607 constructn s 67S 271 f 148 476 VOL 56 4 accounting 1144 603 627 salary case 18 67 S r 167 NY 1133 85 627 pleading case 10 s66S s8AC 628 life ins. s66S e86 presumption 120 declaration 134 479 804 201 262 629 authority s 66 S 1047 164 73 5 67 S 47 M 9 trial term 8 67S m 172 NY e78 elOO I I contract s67S 66 demurrer do 70 87 suit at law 128 178 35 M eq. relief II AC injunction 64M 633 trial fee 3 67S 82 costs d84 d 176 NY 416 958 634 weight ev. s 67 S 124 61 41 lOAC 103 636 contrib neg case 1 66 S * 172 NY 882 644 636 report case 6 s67S a 171 NY 636 appeal case 15 67 S 166 NY 1137 646 1146 636 636 negligence case 28 _67S r 170 NY 53LRA 1144 115 109n 637 meas. dam. s 67 S 218 f 61 613 640 dismissal case 4 9 67 S 1137 a 171 NY 673 6 1 4 discovery !67S 95 liberal rule do 144 disclosure 101 M 6 1 7 allegations 267 550 600 145 s67S 70 95 accounting 84 111 ex. contract 124 625 warranty s67S 368 185 405 393 615 146 640 appeal case 6 b67S 3 167 NY a 171 NY 640 error case 7 a67 S r 170 NY 1147 614 647 1135 577 382 306 395 410 221 411 345 568 23 538 667 696 146 170n 292 1 4 attachment s 67 S 376 a 166 NY 639 costs 69 140 141 s 8 AC 461 counsel fee 137 281 282 159 564 20 mandamus s67S a 166 NY 340 603 23 equity s67S 61 39 M discretion 114 transf, to law 56 9 injunct. relief 48 M 464 60 M 422 use reasonable 391 233 721 237 131 35 trustee s67S s8AC a 167 NY 181 249 435 128 43 fr'd transfer i 67 S 472 3 70 47 5 I amendment s 67 S 433 62 M 351 ICPNS 225 410 50 54 easement 120 66 S injunction 161 b71 jury trial elOO 172 mandamus 138 239 f 241 61 pers injury s 67 S 409 f 91 614 45 M 336 67 intervention s 67 S 262 r 166 NY 402 71 competent ev s 67 S 719 a 168 NY 589 78 169 91 461 master neglig. 30 AC 159n opinion rule 1 168 402 9 I construction do 167 867S ml 73 NY 164 38 M 105M trust limit 118 burden proof 116 9P mandamus s 67S a, 166 NY 56 do 66 58 contract 77 37M estoppel 58M 612 404 838 696 277 701 1 463 465 132 30'J 202 270 I ] 3 pleading s 67 S 564 a 170 NY 109 f 69 324 1 22 file map s 67 S 603 a 166 NY 495 1 36 nuisance s 67 S 541 a 171 NY 662 1 43 infringment 67 S 8 71 s9AC police 162 595 616 27 sr 71 s67S f66 73 222 salary 8 67 8 34 M I 49 restoration 570 672 208 168 224 contract s 67S 593 s 118 128 225 jurisdiction 3 67S s67 8 70 93 allegations 124 I 55 bond 3 67S a 171 NY 1 60 venue b67S 8 8 AC 108 119 39 CP limitations 138 1 70 sup pro. s67S s56 680 546 628 561 492 11 338 340 416 171 veteran s67S *166 discharge 61 35 M mandamus e36M notice dismissed 170 398 I 76 accounting 652 638 719 s67S ii67 a 166 NY 3 170 NY 654 72 640 621 1 79 secure cost s 67 S 622 9 AC 389d 1 8 1 collision s67S a 171 NY 1 83 parties s67S F60 79 damages 649 692 397 J82 jTCS judicata 191 negligence ,82 s67 S 660 82 536 res. ipsa loquitur 82 665 aec. quest'n fact 111 357 duty care 214 109 110 do 73 465 466 111 38 M 469 appraisal 9 AC 124n 125n 9 AC 126n f 96 M 121 158 1 95 waiver s 67 S e62M 259 master neg. 8 67 S 782 a 170 NY 681 ern 268 revocation ^53 8 67 S 733 *'blimds nno • • 71 490 203comnusslon3'75 303 e 36 M 645 19AC 467n procure party 71 M 198 reinstatement 82 36 regular clerk 38 M 435 176 NY 372 unclassified 132 49 306 ejectment s 67 S 909 a 187 NY 108 110 875 3 1 7 presumption 272 b. paiticulrff s67S 96 190 reverasi 160 735 209 68 594 2 1 7 notice pro- test b67S 620 275 poor person do 104 539 s 67 S f 65 220 discretion 629 618 231 66 e68 19AC good cause 746 80 613 94 313 693 583 8 67S a 174 NY e78 176 37 M 48 M 710 509 241 569 .274 104 232 bar 67 S 160 commissions £ 218 NY 23 9.S I 3 9 AC 52M copipensation 10 AC 318n affidavit 38 CP 234n 277 conclusive 8 67 S 879 UO 649 surrogt's pwr 116 692 decree open 38 CP 314 280 exchge tax 664'3 67S 182 a 167 NY capital 69LRA 893 1 241 certificate 8 67 S 638 e 80 488 s 9 AO 32 8 105 448 16AC 342 defective deed 104 490 52M 387 artification 142 47 i his knowledge 147 532 244 lobbying s 67 S 623 s 57 426 e 61 128 pub. policy 93 88 91 180 603 pleading do 93 286 secur. cost s67S e66 3 9 AC elOAC 38 CP discretion 64M waiver 89 M 289 usury 3 67S a 171 NY 8 95 161 f 162 15 AC 92 361 707 751 61n71 617 369 685 fact quest'n do 118 128-29 deny relief f 168 300 unenforcible 97 M 510 invalidity 182 464 illegality f 182 471 866 337 70 302 486 52 978 665 294 conclusive 8 67 S 887 62 78 74 428 attack certif. 139 792 certif. binding 145 490 plead fraud 141 96 299 eviction 8 67 S 736 120 49: 8 AC 423n 425d abandonmen t 102M 16AC abatement 84 M. remedy t 167 88 M 462n 68 364 72 253 transfer tax aflS 911 302 construction 8 68S H471e67S 839 8 67S 143 36 M 67 M 72 M 77 M 9 AC curtesy 72 M 743 288 734 662 467 443 403n 511 not marketable f 210 NY 162 322 weight of ev s 67 8 767 r 171 NY 309 s 87 630 329 cncroachmt »07S 1054 107 411 343 exemption s 67 S 872 r 171 NY 314 350 license 67 S 814 40 M 230 salaries fixing 109 428 432 no recovery 56M 1 76 358 negligence 67 S 73 * 166 NY 59 365 demurrer 8 67 S 753 d 37 M 520 79 M 84 368 reinstatemt 8 67 S 836 a 167 NY 626 372 neg notice 67 S 71 378 neg. s 67 S 128 liability do 144 182 805 217 injury 810 252 18 602 388 lis pendens s67S 62 e 111 113 dloO 162 9 AC 38 CP pleading 121 courti 60 M 772 540 278 60 00 659 78 140 757 power on 548 393 presumption 3 67 S 4SM assoc'n rules 48 M remedies 57M expulsion 15 AC 167n 399 foreclose s67 S 798 818 109 625 414 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished ; f, folio wed ■ r reversed- m moHifi^ . • j- '■ Z .r,.,c.«d, 1. hmited: e. explained; o. over^led; »;,Wca"se1'do\ TsYenlAg^ironf^LrWfe"^^^^^^^ "-."S''' mg opinion ; p, parallel case; q, questioned^ Vols, 56, 57 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division b9AC 127 403 injunction 755 S64 48 167n 238 !67S 41 M 61 M 14 AC rent 120 SIM eviction 64 M unconstitutional 37 M 202 precluded a 166 NY 144 55M 633 right relief 106M 587 466 jurisdiction 405 care degree B 67 S 833 89 313 339 89 427 42S 89 432 433 110 523 warning 186 NY 353 change venue 16AC 318n 326n weight ev. d 121 731 732 408 dividend 8 67 S 759 a 172 NY 137 c 70 466 beneficiary do 70 470 cestui que trust 40 M 514 47 M 565 life tenant 155 344 4 1 4 elm proof • 67 S 763 « 38 M 719 98 M 45 allowance 178 540 56M 225 227 lOOM 243 definite issue ■IS M 194 validity 168 254 4 1 9 collision b67S e73 ctrclaim sm 422 libel s68S a 166 NY fills 67 S 862 ■61 426 59 3 62 609 appealability 106 177 125 580 479 furrogate s 67 S 795 power 74 460 35 M 368 remedy appeal d79 99 39 M 78 85 M 678 jurisdiction 36 M 756 38 M 228 468 s 9 AC 101 484 jurisdiction a 67 S 789 a 166 NY 601 85 328 488 practice a 67 S 120 r 180 NY waiver 137 748 306 594 74 180 426 abatement B 67 S 937 1 168 NY .9 AC a 10 AC 448 lien law !i67S a 171 NY 62 liability 141 170 70 61 238 776 676 602 740 735 i67S 454 jurisdiction 867 74 731 446 867 148 15C 35 M 54 M f 217 NT estoppel 62 M authority iOM validity devise 142 3C7 rdmit will 321NY 195 459 mandamus «68S 767 ministenal 68 132 discretion 77 516 claims 34 M 423 827 397 280 443 53 1 recoveries 8 67 S 258 42M 290 99 475 535 h. & wife 67 S 356 e 110 547 f 36 M 661 38 M 461 14 AC 244n valid contrct 191NY 468, 470 18AC 20 h. and w.con tret. 18AC 21 illegal void 130 166 544 appeal s 67 S 642 68 M 540 district claims 94 M 386 549 bill partic. 8 67 S 475 101 291 126 20 138 676 555 loss service 3 67 S 654 72 ■ 600 14 AC 214n 562 inad. price s 67 S 488 121' 79S 566 compet. ev. 497 authority 3 68 S 968 43 xM 674 written lease 131 776 agreement 131 779 508 oontrib. neg. s 67S 358 48M 656 presumption 76 M. 303 5 1 4 contract s 67 S 380 171 NY 409 e 184 NY 230 champertous 108 . 161 pari delicto 37CP 43 520 civ. service s67S 650 ll6 665 522 injunetion 3 67 S 539 a 173 NY 586 59LRA 48 spl. damage lOAC 158n 525 negligence 3 67 S 483 r 172 NY 666 624 neg. ev case 13 67 S 1133 a 171 NY 670 d 56 407 weight of ev. 121 73 case 26 s GSM 1145 plead statute 70 M 134 8 67S 69 76 trust 69 82 89 . 39 M 40 M 480 295 601 511 464 337 431 334 573 mortgage s 68 S 239 a 168 NY 679 8 57 626 63 367 370 fraudulent 97 80 a 167 NY 316 585 leave to sue 16AC 291 n 588 white act s 67 S 248 e 35 M 120 59 I damages s 67 S 461 96 329 d 46 M 320 limitation 89 M 711 595 contract 3 67 S 227 s 76 506 76 son 8 93 62 527 neg. dam a 67 S 508 59 621 particulars e 71 565 72 484 84 696 16 AC 176d 528 negligence 6 1 guaranty 8 67 S 843 64 144 3 67S 60 83 96 error court ,1 120 rules necessp.ry 20 AC l,S9r 413 6 1 7 appraisal case 1 8 67S 9 AC appeal 9 AC possession case 2 sfi7S 135 766 116n 126n 7 609 50 M 99 Injunction 50 M 6 1 9 picketing case 2 67 S 381 s9AC 5 62 1 m. lien s67S a 170 N Y 14 AC 623 report case 2 e67S a 171 NY 801 680 32nq 1137 644 Hi)! 603 1149 482 1140 602 625 trustee case 44 sBSS a 166 NY will e20 s68S r 170 NY appeal case 33 s68S a 166 NY dismissal Cases 40 & 41 s68S 1136 a 167 NY 576 appeal case 42 8 68S 1141 a 171 NY 663 626 certiorari case 2 68S 1146 a 179NY 644 629 appeal case 9 s67S a 171 NY 1150 176 VOL.57 I incompt person 8 67 S 647 109 668 17AC 412 constitutional 64 175 275 631 595 337 736 441 28 2n 168 119 waiver 192NY persnl note 130 5 conclusive s67S a 169 NY 74 113 34 M 9 AC 37 CP incompetency 113 736 37 CP 168 conatitutl 1 26 799 9 probate will ^ 68 S 24R 60 M 3'. assumption 64M 228 1 7 note value s 67 S 1042 a 173 NY 596 s 9 AC 201 1 9 pleading 8 67S s57 429 61 chge grade 970 626 22 substitution s 67 S 961 58 463 s 9 AC 224 23 incompet ev 67 S 1046 t' 65 446 27 negligence 8 67 S 1076 67 101 29 discretion s 67 S 1002 d 64 366 amendt improper e 76 384 99 490 56M 343 19AC 302n trial error tl05 32 for jury a67S 162 60 M liability 105M 94 1040 235 403 510 s67S * 173 NY d61 S3 160 57M 962 595 464 138 159 220 845 898 798 67 negligence s67S 1059 a 171 NY 677 67 96 64 617 prima facie 68 21 master 80 297 299 97 73 illegal 112 272 resp. superior 122 6 jury question f 178 708 64M 169 authority f 135 new trial case 5 142 relationship 141 presumption 145 525 liability d 182 197 d 203 NT 199 83 M 113 servant defend! 152 572 net liable 153 821 'jonstruction 185 389 91 manslaughter 8 67 S 1033 charge 71 189 burden people do 120 88 justifiable 17AC 188n 191n 94 negligence 8 67 S 1095 a 171 NY 507 f 62 617 80 297 299 f97 73 64M 172 resp, superior 57 certiorari 129 268 7471 391 618 picketing oasp 4 s 67 S 630l 34 dam. profits 67 S 972 87 125 eviction 20 AC 267n not apply 104M 583 44 interest rate 8 68 S 44 74 157d 168 36 M 421 48 M 435 ( 86 H 139 construe will 141 4.-, 48 undue infi. 3 67 S 1028 68 226 10 AC 382 56 contrib neg. s fS S 50 64 M authority f 135 new trial 142 relationship 141 not liable 153 98 costs s68S 174 7a( 28 77 474 610 85 M f 89 M costs successful 76 M 20£ withdM juror 35 M 272 40 M 183 sheriff's fees 15 AC 67n trial fee 58M 362 e6M 572 stenographer's fees 145 674 costs consent 80 M 20S 101 review s67S 1097 1 1 3 abatement s 67 S 338 159 58 I 1 4 mandamus s 68 S 41 69 413 f 1 8 surplus lien s 67 S 1025 60 532 1 25 credibilty s 67 S 985 64 480 safe appliance 80 143 e 94 564 high degree 129 790 98 M 39 1 35 CO elm vs a 67 S 981 60 413 42 M 46 certiorari f 82 M 69 1 40 information 59 66 12 402 84 546 471 151 660 15 41 496 599 524 s68S 81 review 86 evidence 94 34 M 37 M 39 M appeal 44 M jurisdiction 57M 77 M hab. corpus 57M 74M f 87 M jud- notice 129 sufficient cause 160 820 no review 77 M 15 1 52 request s 67 S 1044 99 644 exceptions 76 438 441 no review 136 376 cbjection 154 . 698 request instruct 154 693 155 promotion s 68 S 267 49 M 328 1 58 transfer s 68 S 173 r 170 NY 642 I 64 340 341 Corp. powers 66 M 283 security ists 185 213 542 382 360 164 C( s68S 57 80 a 9 AC 38 CP notice appln 10 AC 298n 116 930 d 117 564 judicl. discretn. 146 624 I 66 widng street a68S 196 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; I. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, noti; c. criticised; 1. limited; e. explained: o. overruled; s. sams case: do, dissentinz opinion; p, parallel case; q, questioned N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division Vol. 57 a 167 NT 624 16AC SS 106 legis. intent 58M S9 M germane 134 use street 138 em. domain 167 464 1 73 estoppel s 68 S 203 71 M 109 1 76 ordinance S80 695 521 s68S 94 99 151 61LRA B68S d98 ]5AC 210 303 324 179^- . proceed s 68 "f 201 185 NY 66 68 right parties 37 CP 126 I 82 foreclosure 8 68 S 188 a 172 NY 632 242 answer s as s 1S7 36 M 11 s 9 AC 292 decision order 103 102 118 661 47 M 97 compliance 170 950 252 expulsion 1 85 adv possn. 269 85 8 68S 127 claim title 36 M 17 AC evidence 129 86 M may waive f 87 M 25 379d 521 201 14 92 spark 8 neg 182 328n 76 317 588 s68S 9 AC 108 193 not reformed s 68 S 174 206 abatement s 68 S 325 9 AC S2n license corp 13 AC 389n 390n 13 AC 393n assignee 114 422 f 423 2 1 2 secure costs s 68 S 316 116 930 9 AC 386n 390n 38 CP 360 presumption 117 565 2 1 4 life insur 8 68 S 290 s 9 AC 392 oresumption ■ 179 598 22 1 picketing s 68 S 161 39 M 58 tax payer 112 605 607 discretion 183 628 fraud 183 628 227 chge benefic s 68 S 128 14 AC 200n 232 oractice s 68 S 155 142 201 jurisdiction 215 NY 213 332n 335 tax corpn. 236 rovers. err. s 68 S 122 119 779 not recover 146 8 cause action 93 M 518 239 duty state 131 607 56 278 861 n s68S m 168 NY within state 75 d8S 90 177 NY 57LRA assessment 114 21 672 166 215 594 55 lOOn 320 s68 S a 171 NY 261 review s68S al72 NY 71 jurisdiction 82 183 663 230 44 265 amendment s 68 S 292 84 392 impchmt fraud 95 112 release 19AC 438ii 273 certiorari s 68 S 10 a 166 NY 453 288 obstrt drain 61 LRA 705n 297 equality i7S 925 L77 836 340 jurisdiction s68S 64 * 168 NY 675 e 66 237 173 56 action upheld 212 NY 173 342 covenants 3 68 S 100 d 190NY 412 35 1 tender ev. 8 68 S 112 74 526 SD prfmance 123 921 63M 454 196NY 38 construction 75 M 560 357sham answer 302 taxn r r s68S a 168 NY 57 LRA 305 title s67S f66 315 itemize s 68 S 164 135 1 6un 8 67S 65 38 M 9 AC 106 123 1108 176 673 162 586 819 1068 222 94 211 3 1 7 transfer tax 8 68 S 18 9 AC 124n a 9 AC 299 106 218 surrog. power f 93 M .416 320 mdef. s68S 142 distinction do 142 residuary 76 M beq'a 647 650 424 329 chg venue s67S 67 98 16AC 1106 343 625 153 163n 234 carrier 8 68iS 33 I tolla s68S la 172 NY neg 1 application 121(96 M S 662 277 367 mandamus 8 68 S 298 r 166 NY 477 372 conversion 3 68S 217 do 133 574 163 371 375 substitution » 68 S 406 37 M 378 party deft. 124 852 interpleader 204NY 287 378 neg dam.. 8 68 S 407 8 62 624 383 hab corpus s 68 S 279 58 134 do 58 136 34 M 22 jurisdiction 109 534 390 exemption a 68 S 232 64 148 do 64 149 serv.' summons 9 AC 267n s 9 AC 354 393 impeachmt s68S 311 a 171 NY 329 a 192 US 189 36 M 204 403 damages 8 68 S 228 a 170 NY 580 35 M 631 law profits 12 AC 296n 408 secure costs 8 68 S e70 d73 74 e76 78 176 308 150 377 33 CP 11 AC discretion 42 M s9AC cause action 141 836 4 1 1 trade name 8 68 S 236 a 9 AC 363 injunction 57M 111 4 1 9 disorderly conduct 8 68 S 276 preserve ev- 80 38 M 94 M a 9 AC 11 AC 162 allegation 94 M 464 284 141 357 312 932 140 422 not demur s 68 S 263 158 238 information 162 676 677 as principal 172 118 426 contract 430 exr. acctg s 68 8 243 new trial 3 60 423 75 347 434 resid ahare 8 63 S 322 s 68 S 1148 34 M 340 438 negligence 8 67 S 1013 75 277d 278 107 191 defect notice 183 NY 342 f 219 NY 186 265 3 157 158 457 449 s68S 61 8 95 118 deny relief 182 nvalidity 182 221 128 361 128 65 464 9 623 r 173 NY 66 73 468 consideratn a 08 S 68 a 171 NY 648 86 142 143 180 NY 354 extend time 132 527 476 reatriction s 68 S 309 r 172 NY 164 3 93 69 480 foreclosure a 67 8 1062 a 172 NY 83 484 substitution 8 68 S 116 s 9 AC 302 authority 123 412 552 m lien s68S m 172 NY sQAC 24 60 286 6 1 7 foreclosure 8 68S * 166 NY 558 cbg. benefic s68S 174 NY 14 AC 61 LRA 116 designation 189NY • 353 consent person 486 assessment 8 68 S 86 m 166 NY 648 494 commissions 1004 445 a67S 60 111 97 M m 170 NY 37CP trust fund 190NY double commns. 190NY 107 exr. interest 61 M 570 66 163 192n 794 608 89 M 563 sale 67 S f 171 569 costf 3 68 S 3 68 S 13 228 992 292 460 1146 402 574 diacovery s 68 S 600 84 195 318 21 151 52M 296 53M 112 18AC 198d right absolute o»= 39CP oi o depositions 151 106 597 620 report case 1 s67S m 171 NY accounting 111 case 6 nuisance 67 8 a 171 NY 62 I report case 12 8 67S a 171 NY case 14 deposit s67S m 170 NY 1133 664 709 1136 331 1139 667 1128 166 139 107 575 answ er s 68 S 38 CP 443 judl sale 8 67 8 a 173 NY 45 M estoppel 126 143 f 99 M usury C6M repairs 218 NY 591 128 150 677 156 102 502 450 fraud 8 67 8 r 171 NY 61 1017 520 612 454 same court 8 68 8 246 do 100 ^ 323 by indictment SO M 541 jurisdiction 142 183 458 expenaea 3 68 S 234 US 328 cond. precedent 167 49 |46l assm d risk 43si8 67S 1017 184 577 title s68S r 169 NY 507 beneficiary ®^8 S68S r 171 NY 82 e45M 60 M .80 616 434 322 462 103 623 469 5 1 5 entry s68 8 a 167 NY f67 custodia legis 78 593 presumption 42 M 21 520 brokerage 3 68 8 32 82 83 115 704 19AC 464n 07 M 610 jury question 129 550 procure party 173 109 n M 108 binding 143 451 rot justified 113 451 530 em domain 60 74 damages 35 M 108 easemen ta 16AC Sin 53 n cond. precedent s68 8 a 172 NY 102 warrant 136 no appeal d 151 right to appear f 217 NY 65 301 665 101 301 753 532 my heirs' 18 S 257 77 M 517 distribution ■325NY 313 542prohib. 67S 721 563 114 622 conversion case 11 s67S a 171 NY case 24 appeal s67S a 171 NY 32 report 8 67S 8 167 NY a 171 NY 670 270 623 622 178 501 208 161 583 referee s68S a 168NY 168NY f62 gratuity 68 voluntary paym't d 179 NY 486 unconstitutional 69 183 do 87 200 202 10 803 1136 80 83 609 157 92 M 590 usury loci s 68 8 46 M 62 LRA waiver M lex 704 498 58n 542 60 I tax impost 8 68 S 606 a 170 NY 40 M 70M do 100 persnl. 173 374 448 12 133 liabilitv 581 6 1 I sup.complt s 68 S 509 1 69 436 d99 284 6 1 3 parte matt s68S writ do 131 1035 limited 4 170 1129 235 1137 696 1144 613 667 623 new trial cases s 68 S 177 a 171 N\ 692 626 dismissal case 13 8 68S a 171 NY case 23 new trial 8 68 8 a 175 Nl fei el02 case 25 suspension 3 68 S 78 case 29 injunction s68S 1141 63 367 370 maintainable 205 NY 492 1138- 667" 1144 476 622 352 1146 376 1145 537 627 conviction case 21 386 8 a 167 NY case 29 appeal 68 S 1136 - 171 NY 674 18 AC 332n demurrer 155 643 S28 easii „ 3 68 8 14 AC pci?. injury 117 213n 629 appeal case 4 s68 8 case 6 3 68 8 a 172 NY case 12 highways 8 68S a 168 NY 1133 1135 657 1134 423 ..-'r 630 nuisance 616 case 7 60 a 68 8 1150 a 171 NY 698 456 case 22 ^V'.^^fZy^V^^f'-^^' »ff'™?'J: "i. distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m. modified; *, dismissed; n, note- c. criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case: do. dissentini opinion: n. parallel case; q, questroncd Vols. 57, 58 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division wciglil s68S a 172 NY case 24 judgment b68S a 173 NY 63 1 Tvill case 1 s68S a 171 NY evidence 1143 618 1145 679 1147 341 633 discovery lienor elm. ease? 1141 S75 1141 155 duty 1144 413 s61S d57 ease 16 laches s68 S 59 case 17 referees s68 S 58 case 23 appeal 8 67S r 168 NY case 24 mechanic's lien s 69 S 150 119 390 14 AC 48n limited 119 390 proper deft. 1133 157 1 8 indemnity s68S a 171 NY 64M: 634 appeal b69S a 167 NY 635 appeal case 5 »6SS a 171 NY case 6 sale realty s68S 182 NY i case 10 appeal b68S a 171 NY case 12 liq. tax certif 391 528 626 il45 672 1139 321 1144 664 s68 S r 167 NY case 13 appeal b6S S a 173 NY case 14 dismissal b6SS r 171 NY 636 appeal case 7 8 68S a 172NY case 8 appeal b68S rl70 NY case 22 appeal 8 68S a 168 NY rl91 US case 21 5 68S not enjoin 186 637 appeal case 3 s6sa a 172 NY case 4 appeal s68 8 a 172 NY 1145 391 1145 594 1150 416 1135 621 1 143 434 1139 586 17 ,1V0L.58 I jurisdiction 8 68S r 167 NY 68 66 10 AC slOAC 527 338 606 610 39 125 8 substitution s 68 S 574 8 463 57 • 103 8 AC 229n 1 I Bliort decision s 68 S 617 exception 83 34 special dam 111 55] 1 2 AC 30n competent ev. 18 AC 226 606 661 492 495 229 25 salary s68S slOl 217 NY not binding 134 132 33 accounting B 68 S 610 a 170 NY 694 99 463 36 limitation 3 68 S 440 a 172 NY 697 42 laches s 68 S 568 73 459 494 f 46 M 6] new trial 124 28 161NY 637 49 guaranty 51M 272 d 94 M 144 s 68 S 596 54 amendment 3 68 S 694 61 186 19A0 307n terms appeal 124 53 terms cos ICPNS 215 57 guaranty s 68 S 569 61 error court s 68 S 505 90 M 380 95 M 5SC G6 acct. books s 68 S 699 a 171 NY 673 80 118 consideration 139 106 73 pers. judgt. s 68 S 462 r 170 NY 409 66 unconstitutional 85 69 enforce lien 122 26 76 brokers 3 68 S 591 s 170 NY 314 meas damages 16AC 183 80 insurance s 68 S 618 a 171 NY 432 competent 143 867 estoppel 143 869 85 accounting 3 68 S 443 3 9 AC 414 its appeal 60 M 2gs 87 damages 3 68 S 539 69 104 92 discovery 3 68 S 551 80 166 36 M 412 39 M 260 99 1 88 sham ans. 8 68 S 680 66 176 9AC 178n 184n denial 38 M 434 672 106 689 1 9 I perpetuity 1 00 negligence b68S a 171 NY 62 do 77 d 115 637 666 373 167 870 103 3 68S- a 171 NY conversioii 665 675 570 645 94 5] 541 1)34 197 1149 630 I 1 2 devise s68S s78 8 178 NY intent 111 122 trustee life ten. do 145 797 construction 78 M 53: I I S supl complt. 3 68 S 661 f 62 618 e 77 344 court's power 123 624 1 3 1 mandamus 8 68 S 448 61 224 1 33 bab corpus i 68 S 656 e 109 634 137 warranty 3 68 S 683 a 172 NY 669 81 88 no mutuality lOOM 15 77 dSl 82 84 34 M 36 lU 40 M f40M 42 M 473 466 468 78 464 640 271 124 126 132 a 172 NY 1 79 estoppel 8 68S al71 NY 62 10 AC 8 167 NY 8 170 NY 59LRA amendment 73 656 641 668 447 158 680 614 696 243 8 68S a 170 NY 207 trust s68S 171 NY construction 62 d:^%^°^ -.„ , . :al68NY ob^ authority ;case 9 s 69 S 266 'appeal 10 AC 54DS68S 1140 a 172 NY 632 739 473 457 124 627 1153 633 1141 648 25 revocation s 69 S 14 a 168 NY 645 39 M 694 53M 360 362 10 AC 16n 21n consents 216 NY 458 30 injunction s 69 S 193 81 334 61LRA 694 696 ILRANS 134n 68 M 239 91 M 80 83 Pollute watei ILRANS 125n 39 scienter s 69 S e 123 lor jury TIM liability 159 defense do 179 79 fact question 44 96 468 274 167 389 100 88 5 1 03 bank neg. r 69 S 82 a 173 NY 272 114 s 6! £ invitation 69S 47 176 780 96 39 40 55 243 45 ev. appeal s69S 3 167 NY 52 appeal s69S * 167 NY 1 20 contract s 69 S 236 s 86 403 1 171 206 I 28 attachment 68 S 1089 68 190 s 73 647 amendment 103 494 by demurrer 98 M f J 30 consideration s 68S 1091 e 133 502 132 cond. sale s 69 S 12 d 37 M 798 10 AC 219n 220n 10 AC 225n for defendant 178 337 135 pers. injury 166 443 140 438 796 voluntary trusts 123 854 title 131 401 money had 67 M 453 presumption 141 57 incompetent 154 363 intentions 79 M f 91 M cotenants 155 165 387 669 663 917 86 612 60 burden proof s 69 S 176 71 217 fact question 72 458 63 master neg. s69S e79 exemption 85 damages 97 177 NY respond, supr, 112 18 AC Indemnity 18AC liability 128 199 NY not liable f 211 NY f 211 NY 106 346 78 s69S 81 rebate 87 9 AC mandamus 36 M 1 75 award claim s 69 S 63 105 576 52M 605 pers. property 705 788 sogs d69 56M evidence e76 185 1 40 sum pro. -69S 67 injunction 41 M f 61 M 14 AC 183 57 665 49 156n 22 665 369 372n 215 237 128 129 70 hiring for year s68S 63 6 87 127 d 172 removal 37 M public policy d 172 42 1039 472 599 285 429 375 I 43 ultra vires 9 69 S 61 t70 4 181 NY 41 M 190 reservation e 78 M 459 niece family e 78 M 460 159 constructn. s 69S 203 183 36 1 66 money had 368S 93 40 M jurisdiction 120 141 40 M 140M ratigcation 50 M 1043 225 166 217 851 171 173 322 172 fisest'ments 111 73 50 459n 761 s66 83 76 M conduct 84 cruelty 60 M adultery 193 NY e 77 M misconduct 153 153 168 218 NY commissions 156 2 1 7 waiver 9 69S 76 revocation surety 41 M rebate 9 AC slO AC limited right 12 AC 74 not authorized 177 22 property right ( lOlM 26 jury trial 103JI 101 211 127 673 591 200 411 674 239 241 216 528 691 309 363 122 468 n 9 713 823 26 116 132 102M damages 131 138 173 chose action 69 M 371 right personal 83 M 467 I 80 r r law 8 68 S 1046 a 172 NY 542 compliance 154 secure costs s69S 4 d 98 285 laches 149 746 may waive 89 M 155 1 56 survivor s69S 9 531 359 105 f 84 appeal 3 69S d59 a 171 NY hold over f76M assignment 185 damages 185 1 87 appeal s69S 61 102 126 180 no appeal 151 92 f 167 44 M gift el03 intent 49 M bk deposit e 123 847 husband and wife 123 849 79 M 660 150 151 193 111 113 23 1 indictmt «69S 513 a 168 NY 649 233 certiorari e 69 S 574 a 167 NY 621 f 61 1X6 239 negligence e 69 S 435 66 602 231 85 89 242 distribution 8 69 S 663 a 168 NY 169 ''* •♦ u, S51 equitable convrn 51 M 172 partition 51M 173 oersonalty 77 il 424 250 negligence " 69 S 570 64 356 256_ counterclm. 576 31 s 69 S 693|86 M 179 751 258 domain 8 69 S r 169 NY 752 57 572 456 26 I jurisdiction 8,69 S 1146 d 167 NY 498 s 82 605 686 382 39-M 849 210 753 1 92 extra work s 69S 387 185 NY 201 nullity 175 178 202 liability s 69S 352 137 73 207 condonation F 69 S 326 270 damages s69 a 270 NY 73 'spent bill' do 73 variance 75 enforceable 155 third parties 155 57 275 contract s 69 S 589 d 163 861 174 588 396 586 271 277 102 56 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, diatinguished ; f, followed; r reversed^ m ^^wT^T . .-^ c.cnt,ci3ed; l.hmited; e. explained; o,overru.ed:^;same..ase; d\Sago"pinr„ttVaU^^^^^^^ Vols. 59, 60 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division 282 misapprop nation B 69 S 375 a 173 NY 619 defltg purchaser 116 313 288 evidence s 69 S 407 a 170 NY 554 conclusive 116 649 294 excuse payt a 69 S 291 99 24 302 comptioUer s 69 S 263 61 715 84 367 manufacture 99 64 tax corporation 64 LEA 51n69n 3 1 estoppel s 69 S 289 a 172 NY 623 59 299 3 I 4 certiorari s 69 S 283 f 73 94 review 98 582 conclusive f 166 541 3 1 9 alienation s 69 S 245 69 584 32 1 waiver s 69 S 831 36 M 309 329 certiorari s69S 837 83 576 89 5g 66M 483 334 restoration s 69 S 853 71 231 233 36M 14 assessment 40 M 43 44 objections d 72 M 415 346 no tender s 69 S 851 local option 51 M 36 invalid 20 AC 256ii 350 conclusive s 69 S 839 a 173 NY 614 79 125 353 assignment s 69 S 355 a 170 NY 582 91 437 do 110 162 d 41 M 261 delivery 110 AD 162 106M 178 damages 103M 698 360 parol ev 8 69S 251 f 35 M 53) incompt. ev. 57M 551 363 h way neg i s 69 S 551 15 AC 298o 54 M 449 20 AO 286n 70 LEA 118 primary cause 71 M 36 proximate cause 71 M 39 waive privilege f 164 626 370 trusts B 69 S 391 a 171 NY 693 s 167 NY . 615 not responsible 209 NY 261 381 backing of water s 69S 249 9 LEA 885 383 assignment 3 69 S 827 r 169 NY 460 390 penalty s 69 S 247 e 43 H 682 s 9 AC 485 do 139 436 400 judl sale 8 69 S 581 default bidder 13 AC 178n 404 new trial 3 70 S 312 f 182 NY 534 reasonable care 105M 510 4 1 9 damage 69 S 113 a 172 NY 634 430 taxation s69S 1 59 625 40 M 371 a 179 NY 59] residence 7S M 477 £ 85 M 130 435 partnership s 69 S 102 * 178 NY 692 456 legal title i 09 S 374 123 888 97 M 46 46lconstructns. B 69 S 181 96 M 238 464no conversn. s 69S 234 651'. 474 467 neg damage « 69 S V71 a 172 NY 60. competent qups. d 100 230 jury question 134 240 improper 151 398 470not excesive s 69 S 370 71 M 525 476 in writing s 63 S 231 73 M 570 482 boycott 8 69 S 349 * 170 NY 673 99 609 43 M 600 485 consideratn s69S 9 AC 221 210n 488 taxation s 69S 388 ILRANS 767n 493 certiorari 69 S 366 a 167.NY 576 taxation ILRANS 767n 498 chge, grade ' "" S 152 a 168 NY 659 d 207 NY 57 damages do 146 883 152 854 166 956 200 NY 143 value lessened 152 855 503 accounting 8 69 S 417 a 170 NY 596 estoppel 141 401 authorized 90 M 141 525 damages s 69 S 344 a 172 NY 663 59 626 626 75 229 award 82 238 e 94 106 94 107 appraiser 14 AC 337n frd. award 124 244 538 fact question 8 69 S 241 67 555 intention e 44 M 107 gift 49 M 192 purpose 122 779 lOOM 631 54 1 preference s 69 S 299 a 170 NY 271 title vesting 139 32 power of sale 139 33 555 f'd transfer S 559 63 602 preference 431 77 278 12 AC 248 "reas. cause" 136 25J 564 discovery s 69 S 659 80 166 18AC 195n 566 reference s 69 S 681 f65 162 do 98 246 138 245 deposition 58M 3S4 power of court 125 172 576 leg. relief s 69 S 693 e 78 227 f 80 151 « 155 150 132 199 acct. suit for 68M 384 royaltiea 132 election 78 M 126 580 books pro- duction B 69 S 635 70 335 76 581 d 87 159 149 36 M 414 41 M 438 13 AC 450n 453n 581 decis'n ordr 9 69 S 826 103 102 584 ex r interest 8 69 S 753 a 167 NY 629 86 252 39 M 627 48 M 67 investments 45 M 549 95 M 34 discretion S2 M 534 duty trustee f 88 M 363 95 M 38 answerable 219 NY 504 591 inspect as- assessment rolls S 678 a 167 NY 398 148 29 595 anl. rep't B 69 S 758 a 172 NY 66 64 2 71 315 value received 153 555 603 award 69 S 742 a 167 NY 627 36 M 464 169 NY 459 460 219 NY 408 right interest 150 218 6 1 I negligence case 2 69 S 124 80 439 6 1 2 findings case 2 s69S 191 * 167 NY 500 * 171 NY 680 trustee case 3 69 S 214 a 170 NY 621 6 I 4 contract case 2 s 69 S 88 a 169 NY 597 a 172 NY 621 6 1 7 contrib nei case 2 8 69 S 210 82 16 620 appeal case 6 3 69S 1151 a 171 NY 668 gen'l denial 42 M 76 pleading case 12 s69S 1133 42 M 76 62 1 appeal case 6 623 exemp. case 1 s69S 77 St frauds case 2 e69S 84 libel 33 CP allegation 129 contract 182 s69S 1132 * 167 NY 612 jurisdiction case 9 s6gS 1148 * 166 NY 636 mandamus case 14 9S 1143 a 167NY 627 dam 298 107 861 143 234 397 327 624 damages case 10 69 S 1139 9 78 635 a 174 NY 506 decree case 11 .69S 1131 a 167 NY 619 remedies case 18 s 69 S 1138 13 AC 180 183 13 AC 184 transfer tax case 27 s 69 S 1140 a 169 NY 449 625 highway case 1 s69S 1128 59 a 173 NY 249 appeal case 17 s69S 1144 a 171 NY 584 appeal case 20 s 69 S 1137 a 172 NY 66s appeal case 21 s69S 1137 a 172 NY 664 appeal case 22 i 1137 a 172 NY 664 626 assessment case 1 s69S 1143 a 168 NY 644 e 39 M 293 penalty case 22 ! 1137 96 107 conviction case 27 b69S 1141 a 168 NY 47 627 appeal case 3 s69S r 172 NY appeal case 7 b69S a 173 NY rape case 9 8 69 8 r 167 NY appeal case 19 r69S a 173 NY 1137 291 1129 584 1141 520 1149 203 VOL. 60 I transfer share s 69 S 702 a 172 NY 630 54 M 369 I I amendment 8 69 S 764 a 169 NY 34 80 136 1 9 master neg a 69 S 729 a 172 NY 595 do 176 498 23 reformation s 69 S 673 65 248 misstatement 3£.M 654 allegation 126 34, pleading 131 4 Corp. power 6311 205 burden plaintiff 145 212 judicial notice 145 408 ultra vires do 150 594 cause action 186 511 29 tax'n coats s 69 S 676 dlO AC 58 s 51 M 97 142 2 stenog. feea 124 249 181 728 80 M 293 32 service publn s 69 S 698 586 688 9 AC 270n 271 n 10 AC 342 344 manag agt. "- M 409 47 no authority s 69 S 684 s 69 S 770 77 M 364 5 1 devise void s 69 S 690 82 580 56 taxpayer a 69 S 770 a 170 NY 687 47 M 313 restitution 61 LEA 76 cause action 65 839 proof necessary f 165 840 damages 149 941 pars, knowledge 112 897 77 damages 3 69 S 863 a 168 NY 644 80 624 change grade S8M 454 order 127 920 81 change venue^ 8 69 S 736 122 741 45 M 235 83 interest s 69 S 778 36 M 248 notice sale 69 M .4B'0 92employment'- s 69 S 676 * 172 NY '646 misconduct 162 886 94 pleading 8 69 S 708 60 128 63 192 constitutional d78 73 creditor suit 71 109 84 218 220 64 decree s69S 41 M 687 607 commisBiong 46 M 395 16AC 419 420n conclusive 150 662 comxaensation 186 325 69 demurrer a 69 S 728 65* 52 do 171 579 16AC 243-4n 75 affidavit 8 69 S . 680 d76 71 1 87 426 93 43 M 47 M 48 M 58M 77 M 277 61S 291 624 31S 278 86 92 107 do 134 46 M d46M 13 AC 3 348 466 346 348 351 igOn 194 juriadiction 86 « uses & trusts 51 M 210 trusts 187NY 288 38 CP 40 equity lien 3SCP 98 cond. precedent f 159 429 persnl. property 170 831 I 1 8 atty ev. s 69 S 941 d 94 162 no merger lOlM 652 1 22 easement s 69 S 994 r 168 NY 134 127 cond. precedent s 69 S f 159 850 429 1 33 serv publn B 70 S 139 63 191 9 lOAC 279 39 CP 32t non residence 119 649 r.leading 126 767 publd. summons 67 M 559 specif, property 67 M . 560. jurisdiction 139 461 ABBREVIATIONS : c, criticised ; 1. limited ; 1, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r e, exrlained ; o, overruled ; b, same case ; do, , reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note^ dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, questioned N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division Vol. 60 ■ 38 law actiOD s 70 S d 78 222 equity relief do 198NY 192 24 1 deposits ..„„ do 146 119 discretion """■ 92 M 1 6 1 contract 6 70 S 46 a 174 NY 617 conclusive 133 664 144 260 624 2S3 338 634 62 189 462 180 amendment s 70S 65 133 88 1 84 incomp. ev. s70S a 171 NY 87 liability 182 do 182 14T 1 68 sureties e70S a 172 NY 111 44 M s 168 NY liability do 118 39 CP decree 198NY b70S m 171 NY 250 labor law 3 70 S 133 a 168 NY 117 255 adulterated s BOS 1120 case 146 259 by-law a 70S a 173NY f 69 amendment 78 549 651 37 M 408 413 retroactive efEct 40 699 60S 20 AO 49ii 103" " 34' substantnl right vestg. legacy 78 M 61 53M 193 gift corpus 264 neg. dam H86 452 s 69 S 1026 91 498 494 46 U ,330 331 291 294 335 490 2'JO NY 220 NY nuisance 131 183 00 M 1 9 I neglisence 6 69S 1107 q 76 345 f48M 615 conform prf. 1 9A0 305n I 93 damages S70S 61 a 172 NY 628 s 70 S encroachment 60 M 434 20 I prom, note s 69 S 1099 39 M a 172 NY 628 60 613 293 injunction 324 207 850 25 671 670 673 617 317 credibility b70S 123 43 M 375 449 246 219 892 t 163 limitations 179 43 165 318 prtct rghts s 70S 230 - 74M 527 81 court's power Iwaiver 74M 52891 424fact question s 69 S s 69 S 1041 69 90 475 m. proeecu. 978 284 right relief 176 600 warranty breach 491 321 prepond ev 417 6 106 authority 116 _ 70S 139 325 answer s 70 S 67 50 M 580 66 883 18 478 626 327 trust s70S a 172 NY 41 M 300 304 estoppel 66 181 598 433 law question 8 69S 83 91 105 pleading 40 M act question 102 "824 1 79 NY 116 complaint d 153 799 438 trustee s 69 S 1036 m 169 NY 153 160 274 negligence s 69 S 1095 82 373 74 196 d» 83 332 277 not limited s 70 S 170 62 M 640 intervene do 150 245 282 taxation » 70 S 120 do.l80 NY 69 fair value 05M 215 286transfer tax s 70 S 196 r 171 NY 48 37 M 471 contitutional 38 M 636 133 s 70 S 118 344 reformation a 70 S 267 41 M 287 288 jurisdiction 114 239 contempt d 83 M 565 349 pleading s 70 S 95 f 160 122 365 grant motion s 70 S 206 157 201 reformation 160 510 371 pleading 3 70 S 1007 9u 191 139 631 378 delivery s 69 B 921 41 M 342 382 presumon s 69 S 889 944 759 5 1 5 libel s69S slOAC law question 128 97 f 105 597 a?jsolute 224XY 446 157 168 164 165 364 421 66 74 d 74 do 74 80 interest 36 M profits 37 M commissions 45 M 305 76 M 587 legacy intent. 57M 634 construe will 141 45 distinction 141 48 446 damages s 69 S 924 66 36 s 71 527 10 AC 11511 449 appealable obligation f 81M 313 599 dower s 70 8 220 a 172 NY 651 e 62 462 62 453 466 jurisdiction 38 M 202203 a 173 NY 606 d 10 AC 165 168 52 1 demurrer 69 S 967 70 186 40 M 55 41 M 124 528 pleading s 69 S 912 d 160 121 10 AO 428n allegations do 160 120 531 waive lien s 69 S 951 AC 117n 536 libelous 9 69 S 895 80 617 f 107 307 C36M 419 14 AC 411n jury question 117 638 spl. damage 129 29 54 1 civil service 68 f 98 M release 48 M final 16AC validity 177 78 M judgment 96 M 6 1 3 appeal case 6 s69S a 172NY 6 1 4 appeal 3 69S a 172 NY 297 accM insu s 70 S 32 36 M 288 rule damages 106 356 303 discovery s 70 S 24 13 AC 464n 307 larceny 8 70S a 168 NY 91 counterfeits 94 3 10 AC procedure 146 173 182 342 455 245 817 51 647 95 construction 100 62 40 M 438 practical location 413 202 470 106^ 10 654 164 205 mistake 6 70S a 172 NY 208 duress s 70 S d 118 f 162 f 86 M 105M extortion 105M no waiver 105M 224 allegations s 70S 124 33 CP 5n t'25 bonds inter- est 3 70 S 68 r 173 NY 216 o-o • . , , 3 1 2 sp perform- 4 1 2 co. claims ^dJ interpleadei ance Is 69 S 880 8 70S 223 s 70S 74 a 168 NY 187 65 , 216 66 650' °^3is Irestrictions |4I6 amendans. 72 180,101 189ls69S 1002 73 299|noti''e la 170 NY 694 77 275 69 M 268 s 75 346 347 78 26 absent infant bar 35 M _ 208 137 210,17 28 substitution inon resideai application do 132 5181137 212 76 M 486 moving papers ' ' 'mandate do 186 02 M boundary 96 M 389 equity s69S s66 relief 73 11 AC distribution 78 M 403 distribution 32 CP 354n 69 S 52M waiver J6M objections ~0M ; 90 M 1033 507 549 213 399 451 surety bond s 69 S 902 155 505 457 mtge. foreol 3 69 S 89S 3 71 527 surprise ICPNS 358 459 estoppel 3 70S 1010 40 M 626 44 M 82 460fact questn. "" S 930 68 479 69 LRA 379 by-laws 69 LRA 388n 467 new trial S 69 M without do 162 859 37 power 123 548 i«lief 3 69 8 a 169 NY 93 demurrer 39 M Roman law 75M 363 397 215n 165 573 1136 629 667 625 6 I 7 consoldn 70S ■ 169 NY 699 62 I damages s69S 910 r 173 NY 649 622 sewer 8 70S a 171 NY case 10 appeal s70S 1150 a 172 NY 627 case 19 appeal 3 70S 1149 a 170 NY 349 open default 125 214 f 98 M 459 296 628 628 tax corpn. 3 70 S 836 a 167 NY 622 42 M 424 629 suspension case 38 s70S 1147 a 168 NY 642 3 69 S 54 M surprise 132 no bar 134 975 521 211 460 470 negligence B 69 8 989 86 26 due care 136 666 AI!l:UI'.\ I nTTONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; B. eriticised. I. limited; e, explained; o, overruled: i Supreme Court 92 M 518 553 substitution 3 69 S 1097 9 AC 307r 557 brokerage s 69 S 1052 82 83 102 347 loramissions d 76 M 597 560 competent 3 69 S 1027 106 224 neg, owner 195NY 427 562 parol ev 3 69 S 1028 350 572 acceptance 3 69 8 1060 87 680 satisfaction 36 M 328 78 M 120 583 demurrage s 70S 101 74M fiO 592 election s 69 8 592 a 167 NY 297 S3 552 1092 ^30 f.d transf 603=afe23 ^°«s68^ 7 j case 8 appeal 42flls 70 S 857 278 r 173 NY 3 176 NY 630 sale case 11 s70S * 176 NY Case 13 default s70S * 168 N Y case 16 appeal s70S * 172 NY case 22 transf tax 3 71 8 a 167 NY taxable 62 M 1141 644 558 1138 547 1141 596 1146 650 1135 227 447 631 appeal case 17 3 70 3 a 171 NY case 19 appeal b70S a 173 NY case 20 evidence S70S 86 1149 647 1140 579 1139 630 632 sp- prfmce case 4 8 70 8 1135 67 621 i, lol lowed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed- n nm,- I. same case: do. dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q, queitioni Vol. 61 N. Y. Supreme Court Beports — Appellate Division VOL. 61 I parties ■ 70 S 163 66 308 309 38 M 656 173 NY 97 record title 73 • 111 93 M 202 revera. error 121 271 conclusive f 164 724 1 2 use St. r r b70S 66 asseasmeiit s 70 S 129 s73 SS tax provision 125 162 64M S90 84 damages s 70 S 143 a 172 NV 626 78 519 104 631 natural right 182 567 32 453 negligence 70 assumption 97 j ury question 112 559 1 8 revocation s 70 S 201 68 506 abandonment 41 M 152 13 AC 236n 237n 13 AC 240 241n 23 option s 70 S 216 120 106 tender late 135. 823 3 I conting. int B 70 S 252 81 453 appearance acctg 104 464 35 conspiracy 8 70 S 237 e93 127 40 conclusive s 70 S 478 64 168 B 10 AC 97 negligence 14 AC 405n highway ILRANS 241 recip. rights ILRANS 224n jury question ILRANS 229n fright damage 16AC 71n 92 mplied repeal 113 s 69 S 1109 489 15 AC 141n repeal prior statute 155 505 s70S a 168 NY e81 93 application e86 evidence 116 ■ jurisdiction 117 correct assessmt 155 86! 1 63 evidence 96 reas. ground s 70 S 72 122 787 mere belief 77 M 414 court's power f 92 M 288 1 00 penalty 3 70S 2 a 179 NY 546 compensation 65M 661 authority 216 NY 42 intention do 216 NY 53 nat. gas co. 184 I 56 certiorari 462 661 123 216 48 456 813 238 review 70S 106 waiver 114 a 70S 87 95 waiver ev, e 68M 20 AC admissible 213 NY 419 19 334 165 285i) 332 1 70 insurance s 70S 403 a 170 NY 145 1 79 concluded s70S 105 intention 118 444 448 750 118 73 enforcement f 119 44 adeg. compsn. 74M .598 jurisdiction 105M 169 don't deny facts 98 M 481 337 report 8 70S r 168 NY "trial" 67 M fi04 47 171 247 objection s 70 S 364 85 59 declarations 40 M 622 impeachment 353 427 544 123 take risk 105M 431 evidence 8 70S rl70NY sl07 784 1 05 resettlement s 70 S 334 f 120 902 strike out 175 181 1 1 5 certiorari s 70 S 556 a 168 NY 646 I I 7 certiorari 6 70 S 360 a 168 NY 441 8 168 NY 446 I 1 9 accounting s 70 S 457 a 173 NY 359 1 29reasaessmeat 1 84 amendment s70S 410 131 87 terms cost ICPNS 245 1 87 discharge 18 AC 251 70S 186 268 foreign divorce a 70S 62 10 AC 20 AC 59LRA legitimacy 118 51 M 279 appeal s70S al702^Y 8 70S e36M probational f 99M 195 appeal 8 70S a 171 NY 442 720 582 620 648 386 276 202fact question 138 dismissal 138 42 authority s 69 S 1122 d 160 417 46 negligence s69S 1112 r 170 NY 394 B 77 44 s70S a 171 NY 78 deductions 94 value lease 120 121 500 641 316 466 706 664 a 70S 62 63 do 173 187NY 77 M charge 78 negligence 89 e97 5 I prima fac. ev. s70S * 170 NY 82 181 NY 62 M prob, cause ev. 15 AC 268n 119 439 190NY 281 not conclusive 156 338 134 contrib. nee -..3 70S- 350 212id63 619 589le 78 407 407 t 92 621 7 I39release 3 70 S 361 62 M 554 718 373 91 198 579 186 420 215 462n 451 902 406 453 166 26n 167 73 313 341 residence s 70S 4.?3 16AC 163n 343 defective sewer 70S 525 61 LRA 68gn 350 severable s 70 S 662 t 108 107 file mortgage 70 M 464 357 accounting s 70 S 563 173 NY 683 364 dismissal a 70 S 65S a 174 NY 617 compliance 84 M 222 281 731 672 444 251 651 666 lllr 434 merits s70S a 171 NY 11 AC court's power 141 733 442 chge. grade 3 70 S 630 51 M 187 f 142 303 160 160 a 169 NY 39 M d 87 M 5 18 dower a 70S 8 12 AC a 172 NY 614 656 49 696 163 381 447 not limited s 70S 679 d 136 758 453nonsuit error • 70S - 616 98 323 decision 161 297 456 assessment 373 manufactg 70S 344 688 241 526 259 286 discretion 8 70S 79 8 10 AC coercion 199 NY 294 retaxation 8 70 S 359 f 92 613 losts 113 construction 113 costsam'nt 53M tax costs 53M cost demurrer 18AC 412 19A0 411 412n interloc.judgmt 38 CP 188 127 ' 128 40 264 99 380 appeal s70S 67 102 180 no appeal 151 616 64 880 367 10) 210 753 383 eh. venue -70S * 172 NY a 174 NY e74 all AC s 172 NY 713 600 509 26 114 645 8 70S a 168 NY 46 1 appeal s70S a 173 NY 473 remedy a 70S 68 646 677 623 697 646 412 126 1 45 civ. service 3 70 S 405 62 255 laches |87 360-1 392 205 agency 8 70S r 170 NY inadmissible 85 M 261 85 M 262 2 1 4 negligence 8 70 S 630 8 87 321 do 87 325 223 mandamus 8 70 S 482 * 1-68 NY 6 120 754 58 contract s 70 S 80, 12 AC 294n 295n 147 covenants damages 's 70S 434 123 165 „. , , I52attylien 64 sham ass'mt. a 70 S 356 s69S 1115 8 10 AC Id 65 176[ml68NY 63 76 412 compensation 106 589!tlo 38 CP 178 484l 226 damagea s 70 S 499 67 36 71 142 38 M 36 74 M 593 encroachment 50 M 434 injunction e 109 810 140 627 46 50 M 422 'legitimacy 296 demurrer s 70 S 474 47 M 662 uncon stitutional 49 M 276 bailee lien 56M 400 299 incompetnt s 70S 483 178 446 3 1 2 indictment a 70 S 307 105 153 35 M 693 315 proof nee s 70 S 536 129 518 323 taxpayer 8 70 S 465 a 72 624 40 M 7 333 jurisdiction s 70 S 416 8 10 AC 78 98 M 481 discretion e 75M 30Sls 70 S 390 insurance s 70 S 664 a 173 NY 1 7 construction 118 788 405 receiver a 70 S 637 66 599 e 92 266 99 216 155 333 B4M 113 court's power d 138 483 jurisdiction do 155 335 407no jurisdctn s 70 S 702 73 M 216 4 1 3 trustees s 70 S 641 s 63 19 20 174 NY 238 "ourts' power 121 206 no relief 68 M 18 426 jurisdiction 8 70 S 680 72 629 el06 177 428 review error s 70S 593 133 430 review exception 70 M 232 617 319 480 condemnatn s 70 S RflS a 170 NY public use 147 147 additional do 147 eminent 151 172 505 510 land 808 domain 411 486 reference a 70 S 36 152 227 489 banks ev s 70S 675 19A0 19311 7.97n 198n cond. precedent f 87 M 190 incompetent 87 M 192 494 mandamus 52 1 neg. dam - 70 S 688 81 441 119 800 37M 729 529 parol ev s 70 S 694 s 168 NY 668 r 172 NY 447 534 must plead a 70 S 38 151 490 real estate 89 M 187 538 atty fees 3 70 S 639 s 10 AC 105 10 AC 317n mandamus 54M 209 54 I accomplice 8 70 S 621 10 AC 255n * 545 decree 8 70 S 578 a 168 NY 604 ground violatn. 77 M 198 562 claims 8 71 S 71 r 170 NY 75 9 AC 256n 570 supl. pleadg. 3 70 S - 818 f 56M 330 572 aflfidavi e 3 70 S 900 114 176 fatal defect 157 576 title 8 70S 66 compet. e 58M s70S r 168 NY denials 118 684 187 26 500 defense 8 70 S 594 92 M 725 burd. defendnt 185 124 502 parol ev. 70 S 697 84 398 106 322 505 negligence 3 70 S 29 97 . 143 jury question 01 M 580 substitution s 70 S 869 e 88 587 588 demand 135 21 583 damages S 70 S 778 f 175 23 587 accounting 429 caveat emp- 662 100 508 appeal s70S a 171 NY 710 646 5 1 Seqcouversion 70 S 634 223 816 393 485 -70S a 168 NY suspension 63M case 4devi£e I 119 covenants 72 M 933 640 193 866 583 594 notice unec s 70 S 767 f 9.0 M 305 duty court 95 M 314 S98 mandamus s TO S 755 a 168 NY 643 78 568 incidental exp. ■ 84 368 37 M 430431 54 M 209 •*• '^^.?^i^y^^^i^^^ ■ ^..sffirn'sd; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; e, criticised; 1, limited; e. explained; o, overruled; s. same case; do, dissenting opinion: p. naralle! case; q, ouestioned. N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division Vols. 61, 62 10 AC 31711 320 courtii power e 39 M 440 counsel fee d 80 M 322 expert witness 157 48S 601 appeal s 70 S 920 a 172 NY . 643 on report liable 47 M 461 605 for jury s 70 S 759 86 M 227 1144 638 1134 678 106 1145 293 6 1 2 new trial case 1 8 69S 1141 a 170 NY. . 618 court decision cafe 3 s 69 S 1143 47M 97 case 7 adult'd milk a 170 NY 590 622 appeal case 19 8 70S a 171 NY case 22 accounting 8 70S ♦ 168 NY a 176 NY case 27 reference 3 70S s75 case 28 judgment 3 70S a 171 NY case 30 ^ new trial 70S a 172 NY case 31 fact question s70S 1149 r 173 NY 627 s 102 352 VOL.62 I contract 8 70S a 171 NY 8 contract 8 70S a 173 NY 1 8 parol ev 8 70S 71 886 634 798 25 B6flS 73 140 analysis e79 do 79 case 9 1142 485 707 390-395 1134 645 1149 627 956 388 29 remove vete- ran s70S a 168 NY e79 civil service 89 review 100 discretion TOM • 845 642 162 67 241 undertaking 59 M 584 186 864 1 82 attackznent I 1 2 mortgages 894 633 124 246 128 8 70S a 172 NY 86 M estoppel 47 M f 86 M transaction real f 167 211 valid considatn. 183 700 I I 6 exception s 70 S 951 s 172 NY 646 a 174 NY 550 77 451 misconduct 162 S86 void pub. policy 8 70S 91 affidavits 110 116 130 tort damages 116 607 construction 136 49C injury property 624 negligence case 16 s70S 1149 r 171 NY 99 600 43 neg, for jury 8 69S a 171 NY a 193 US case 11 constitut'nl 8 69S a 172 NY case 18- condemnation 1129 670 581 law 1146 285 i70S a 175 NY case 19 appeal 8 70S a 172 NY damages case 21 8 70S a 170 NY sample test 136 140 613 stock case 7 8 70S r 172 NY case 10- insurance «70S a 172 NY 6 1 4 appeal case 3 8 70S a 170 NY 70S a 173 NY 68 labor law do 91 4G sum. pro. s70 S 158 1149 72 1136 626 1138 459 132 70S 1150 508 1150 490 1144 593 6 1 6 dismissal case s70S 1140 a 178 NY 679 618 right oU 8 70 S (J 140 74.S 620 examination case 1 103 s70S 621 eq 8 71S 85 519 6H power 193 160 spec, performnce 114 820 57M 442 790 530 20 150 5 I contrib neg 8 70 S 763 40 M 203 54 amendment 871 52 8 70S 79 discretion 89 reversal 98 127 243 56 no jurisdictn. s 70 S 856 158 791 63 mandamus 82* 2 185 123 pers. arty s70S f 210 NT 75 167 chattels dol4C provision dollG 1 27 intervention 3 7 OS 930 155 101 43 M 408 57M 369 plaintiff party 706 764 13 179 250 789 700 162 131 b 8 70S 73 £ 168 ]9A0 637 particulrs 868 324 887 2n 4n 936 439 336 38t; 411 f 169 46 M discretion 115 damage 136 99M inferences 104M 1 89 joinder a 70S 166 89 demurrer 109 166 necessary 176 195 costs s70S 114 36 M 39 M 10 AC obiter dicta 68 M 500 963 657 439 683 6S7 party 802 913 198 172 441 310 429 der self ope'ela 173 NY TO M 525 s 173 NY recovery 89 M 257 present facts 176 215 cts evidence 184 -163 s70S s89 insurance 8 180 NY 72 paving 70S r 171 NY contract - 137 392 942 61 217 1 33 relbrmation 8 70 S 809 r 172 NY 471 92 441 do 95 619 constructive fraud. 105 191 waiver 105 20 I contract 8 70 S 1074 a 172 NY 623 relief 53 M 544 2 1 9 vet preice s 70 S 901 a 168 NY 416 94 313 79 152 163 155 51 410 construction 213 NY 132 entire term f 213 NY 133 veterans 92 M 310 581 79 trust estate 8 70 S 839 e 84 572 162 331 allowance 12 AC 147n dnub. comns. 190NY 107 vesting 134 335 d 72 M 255 conditions 182 186 into personally 1S6 374 96 transfer tax s 70 S 853 m 168 NY 399 101 St. frauds. 77 857 d 80 M 3 compliance !80 M 384, '339 compromise 144|3 71 S 29 76 192 194 |43pleHding &uR 5 70 S 796 59 M 35 I 46 pleading B 70 S 873 74 38 fr d representn's 105 392 I 50 slander pleading 8 70S 171 NY 59LRA libel per Fe 114 178 170 461 general damage 23 1 certificate s70S ( a 172 NY. 631 presumption e 101 49S objections 15 AC review 18AC exceptions 18AC 266 ejectment 70S 1101 168 NY 632 271 em. domain s 70 S 1127 a 168 NY 254 275 title vcste.i 5 70 S 10S3 142 254 by delivery 155 56 279contrib. neg. 70 S 1086 6 M 808 283 imprisonm't a 70 S lllf' 54M 28 286 alimony s 70 S 1107 10 AC 117n 10 AC 411n specific duty 101 522 74M 53'i 290 injunction 70 S 1088 r 173 NY 644 74 183 299 coupons 8 71 a 51 a 170 NY 68 s 170 NY 71 3 I I injunction 3 71S 27 f 74 183 348 news stands s 71 S 97 r 168 NY 390 357 incompet ev s71S d69 reputation 118 pleading 145 charge acts do 154 S3 do 154 54 misdemeanor 89 M 602 364 fact question s70S 1113 387 35 480 614 700 368 negl. s70S 36 la ev. 1116 369 371 fact question 8 70S 1118 )7 461 35 M 389 376 pleading 8 70S 1094 72 . 84 e77 315 82 216 84 440 8 10 AC 17^ 13 AC 62 strike out 106 638 169 785 proof plaintiff 138 408 3 1 5 'nspection books corp 386i 33Sl s7lS 70 76 33bn 240 chat mtgs. s 71 S 822 a 172NY 394 617 s70S a 171 NY liability d 138 861 659 266 106 st frauds 8 70 S 782 84 143 37 CP 210 plead statute 114 767 882 390 313 114 bii; pirtie IDAO recovery 149 libel do 140 165 192 238 1 391 1 57 affidavit s 70 S 875 78 642 1 74 trustee 8 70 S 1066 76 524 constitutl. 249 no redress s 70 S 98c f 173 discretion 173 51 809 335 581 576 379 ejectment 8 70 S 737 f 86 620 388 eviction s 70 S 832 38 M 301 389 charge error 52 257 forn . admr. 3 70 S 897 73 527 260 jury trial s 70 S 1122 98 268 262 attachment s71S 14 76 116 dam. pleading 85 385 88 162 41 M 246 Illegal evidence 99 22 compliance 99 298 41 M 438 petition n M 644 irregularity 76 M 428 discovery 80 W 146 error order 157 252 3 f'6 trust estate 3 71S 1 a 171 NY KM 86 432 d 140 518 804 639 36 163 392 25 553 45 mtent 39 M construe 52M invalid 182 363 942 344 70S a 172 NY 80 limitation 186 NY c 210 NY do 139 allegation 121 agreed value 58M liability d 201 NY 396 210 NY 393 construction do 201 NY 307 implication do 201 NY 398 limit liability 151 554 e 555 f 151 556 396 contract 1057 676 617 327 surety 3 70S 168 NY [62 adjournment d 100 440 15 AC 393n undertaking 73 M 206 presumption 826 638 3 70S a 172 405 legacy s70S a 170 NY 39 M 4 1 3 death neg. s 70 S 973 a 171 NY 661 64 480 71 158 833 388 435 AliUKliVlATIONS: a, affirmed; d, I, ^ritici:>eU ; i, limited; e. explained; c distinguished ; , overruled ; s. f, foUowea; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; same case; do, difsl nting opinion; p, parallel case; q, questioned Vols. 62, 63 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division- 366 £97 negligence 116 290 f 216 NT 386 waiver 119 382 386 measure care e 189NY 344 duty owner 154 805 421 nuisance s 70 S 1130 99 505 89 M 493 425 landlord 31 J 70S * 170 NY 71 . practice 122 ultra vires 133 1099 S6S 209 451 516 75 encroachmt, 120 sky signs 129 ordinances d 77 M 459 90 M 417 50 1 ultra vires s 71 S 95 defense 73 pleadios 15 AC waiver 131 428 constitut'n' B 71 S 40 71 287 12 AC 68n 59 M 584 138 10 construction 50 M 20 437 service pub 1 ication s 71 S 104 r 173 NY 503 106 116 38 M 199 200 203-4 a 10 AC 146 amendment 133 459 incomp. s 70 S 116 1133 62 765 266 610 66n 88. af&davits 91 577 "raised' s71S a 173 NY 588 bailee s71S 10 AC 10 AC 595 hack stands 449 607 603 604 505 jury trial n ti 70 115 1911 election 147 590 508 indictment 71 S 129 36 M 282 of one crime 62 LRA 197n 5 1 4 contract s 71 S 78 a 75 191-2 517 injunction s 71 S 53M 3 5 1 9 claim s718 73 8 71S 93 s38M 38 M abutters f 67 M relief 146 validity f82M 599 lien law 3 71S 172 NY 604 sup. pro. 84 616 521 confidential s 71 S 134 146 432 525 contract 460 rescistsiun s 70S 1096 65M 63 463 prin. right s 70 S lllC 127 372 467 commissions s 70 S 1106 86 370 470 neo. party s 70 S 742 76 533 e43M 312 do 150 298 both parties 150 293 third party do 150 295 478 civ service s 70 S 774 f 79 636 mandamus 145 473 484 grant s 70S 750 61 LRA 65 76 78 estopped f 216 NY 46 490 neg damage s71 S do 72 no power £156 282 625 850 53 I mandamus 3 71S 88 92 t 168 election 40 M construction do 179 NY 108 538 lis pendens a 71 S 8 173 NY HI 113 37 CP 159 error court 178 parties lOGM 1100 568 28 528 i70S 75 jury trial dl02 73 M assumption 105 364 contrib. neglig. 63M 595 86 M 334 497 injunction s71S 155 disap. 67 410 76 190 87-8 375 540 82 156 279 60 140 60 676 635 440 185 235 81 140n 146n case 28 appeal s70S s75 620 appeal case 2 s71S a 168 NY case 9 foreclosure S71 S a 183 NY 570 313 104 370 62 1 framng issue case 6 s71S f64 98 623 appeal case 12 3 71S r 172 NY case 16 appeal 3 71S a 172 NY 8 71S 137 809 appeal 3 70S 125 610 appeal 70 S 1 6 AC 614m. lien case 1 a 70S a 172 NY declarations case 2 a 70 S 115 248 718 890 680 916 442n 820 634 770 543 6 I 6 revocation case 1 a 70S d75 10 AC caae 2 liquor law a 70S * 168 NY 822 303 2gn 1146 677 1148 348 1132 660 1150 564 VOL. 63 I pers. inj. dam s 71 S 326 a 170 NY 592 7 contempt s71S a 168 NY 65 624 300 1132 269 1151 636 624 preference case 1 8 71 S a 168 NY 86 1147 385 155 625 appeal 8 71S a 173 NY 628 fees e71S 10 AC I I misdemeanor 8 71 S 212 88 68 14 AC 131n forfeit bail 15 AC 392n pers. present 83 M 317 14 terms appeal s71S 414 124 623 tersm cost ICPNS . 245 1 6 trial calendar 71 S 195 83 285 1 8 eq action 71 S 401 r 174 NY 230 25 lunatic deed 67 609 163 194n 630 reference case 3 s71S r 168 NY case 9 appeal s71 S a 171 NY 1134 484 1139 636 6 1 7 undertaking case 1 s72S a 172 NY case 2 demurrer S71S a 168 NY case 6 competency a 71 S 1137 a 172 NY 625 case 14 source knowlge. 631 appeal case 16 3 71S a 176 NY case 17 CO treasurer 8 71S 1160 al74 NY 1149 676 1117 633 1145 673 542 presumption s 71 ti 88 56M 195 543 costs stay 122 121 550 296 24 449 71 S 79 91 33 CP answer 33 CP bar ISO f 82M case 27 demurrer a71S a 175 NY case 28 appeal 71 S a 171 NY 551 injury risk s 71 S 140 do 95 629 jury question 109 725 566 attachment s71S 181 f 62 631 369 1142 494 1132 676 8 1 8 appeal case 37 b71S a 168 NY case 39 appeal s71S a 168 NY reimbursemt d 55M 265 1145 674 1138 643 6 1 9 appeal case 8 3 70S r 171 NY 1148 633 451 639 ti4 request cugs s 71 S 177 e 70 61U error charge 80 39 104 627 86 dismiss coitipt s 71 S 406 r 171 NY 610 79 33 81 439 court power 16AC 103n special verdict 137 847 complete record 137 847 93 constitutnl 71 S 352 d 69 321 99 reference 3 71S 77 134 164 accounting 118 J8 CP s71S a 177 NY avoidable 116 400 riiM d 191NY ratification 116 election 159 343 252 401 229 461 402 347 38 ev form trial s 71 S ■ 363 d78 77 rejection of ev 16 AC 62n incomp .ev. 17AC 71n Buppress depn d(>124 638 41 third party s 71 S 380 139 578 receiver 189 579 reduce posse^sn 157 ■ 616 44 impeachment s71S .38? 18AC 453n f 173 448 49 leg presmptn 71 S 376 90 609 54 ack nldgmt s 71 S 441 a 173 NY 618 96 604 61 libel. 3 71S 42 M demurrer el06 46 M defenses 16AC 78 mitgn 348 78 367 57 213 176 774 218 300 352 100 note waiver s 71 S 420 f 129 93 13 AC 146n surety 119 370 notice necessary SO M 478 108 damages 3 71 S 355 a 172 NY 400 72 166 instalment e 169 13 1 1 7 begging ev 3 71 S 224 a 169 NY 668 122 trade mark a 71 S 209 13 AC 433n 1 26 b particulrs 3 71 S f69 73 f87 97 116 16 AC 256 577 324 657 138 894 179n 128 certiorari a 71 S 390 m 169 NY 432 1 34 referee s7lS 63 6 94 46 M fee 227 141 438 598 test, decision lOlM 371 I 40 stipul. fee 3 71 S 10 AC practice 14 AC 231 296n 27n 82 83 892 I58ev s71S 82 S3 62S 604 644 645 365 271 255 165 per inj. neg. s 71 S 268 a 170 NY 588 73 250 fSS U contrib. neglig. 185 200 1 72 dies non j. 8 71 S 263 e 37 M 855 1 74 assessment 1 71 S 265 r 168 NY 361 e 94 460 181 exemption 3 71 S 257 m 168 NY 494 1 63 613 1 90 objections a 71 S 264 10 AC 279 10 AC 283n lO AC 286n amendment 130 4.= 1 58 126 ] OPNIa 163 1 99 leg. redrees 71 S 70 73 d92 277 20 557 289 405 demurrable do 70 127 150, 182 do 171 leg. Ac eq relief d 73 557 98 666 730 24 151 621 734 194 e 171 distinction J3M dismissal 135 131 insuf. complaint 37 M 434 204 misnomer 8 71 S 69 132 urisdictiou 87 132 56 M mistake 56 M 197 102 691 382 692 350 319 206 revocation excess uam ■ s71 S a 170 NY 78 f 36 M 11 AC concurring neg 84 517 91 160 321 692 e 7U4 6bu ABBREVIATIONS; a c, criticised ; 1. limited: 220 pleading s 71 S 38S 117 526 J19CP 28 affirmed; d, distinguished; f. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, i.uu :, explained; o, overruled ; s. same case: do. dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; o. Questioned 142 evidence s 71 S 274 162 932 94 M 140 1 45 St obstructn a 71 S 274 Rl LRA 592 1 47 commiss'ns 8 71 S 260 a 176 NY 49; 1 5 1 declaration: B 71 S 335 71 S d75 93 f 107 45 M 10 AC 10 AC 21 1 carrier 71 S a 177 NY s75 exemption 128 competency 156 437 303 430 607 498 12n 27n 28n 424 565 431 174 683 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division Vols. 63, 64 holder note 149 166 167 20 738 761 793 223 fright 8 71 S 115 redress do lis fright damages 16AC 71-72n responsible 207 NT 8 23 1 separation s71S 411 8 169 NY fiOl a 173 NY 266 relief court 105 Slf v'd marriage 16AC 312 314d voidable e 128 M 68 M MA annulment 63M 5RS no decree 105M 502 235 authority B71S AW * 168 NY 671 82 104 40 M IW depositions 14 AC ':>.Wn discovery 50 M iTA 240 reference s71S ?m f 65 161 correct rule do 98 625 deposition 5SM 3.14 power of ct 125 172 243 mandamus 8 71 S 3sn 226NY 59 80 170 dSO 177 73 M 255 249 transfer right vacancy s 71 S 266 80 175 252 transfer tax 8 71 S 445 a 168 NY 670 13 AC 349n 257 neg. Jam. s 71 S 836 s 73 625 89 34 contract e 94 469 excessive verdict 110 883 264 test, capac. B 71S 330 133 912 276 mandamus power appointmt 86 288 36 M 280 13 AC 354 apply fund 103M 146 286 chge, grade s 71 S 571 * 171 NY 639 f 64 620 621 78 M B weight of ev. 171 NY 254 exemption 40 M 7 294 insur. pol s 71 S 546 m 173 NY 352 disli guished 126 574 300 demurrer 1 71,i6 5SS 124 574 16AC 245n 329 assessment s 71 S 499 f 72 632 65M 633 338 no title <; 71 S 50 f 161 843 340 recovery s 71 S 579 99 476 42 M 290 minutes trial 45 M split cause do 196NT instalments 72 M £ 169 on merits 82 M 8 71 S 80 73 M 280 waiver s71 S r 172 NY f 66 578 170 255 525 482 22 613 353 neg dam 3 71 S 696 11 AC 58n 356 atty lien r71S 513 173 NY 491 f 64 622 39 M 107 36olien oer.'ional ■! 71S 565 133 299 370 future vestg 8 71 S 780 129 633 162 270 upon, then 152 749 construct 84 M 330 374 fact quest'n 1 71 S 568 16AC 325n 377 master neg. 142 157 d 43 M 296 8 10 AC 179 justice liable 106 27S 15 AC 198n justification 113 339 affidavit 114 248 f 87 M 278 magistrate 17AC 105 106i. jurisdiction 139 14 75M 23.'; authority 146 494 87 M 284 40 I receiver s71S 913 r 170 NY 451 e 88 600 602 408 reference 9 71 S 559 73 508 4 1 9oral agreemt 71 S 552 f 69 453 105 497 d 45 M 380 45 M 609 construction 49 M 242 incompet. ev. 136 742 49 M 537 inadmissible f 93 M 467 oral evidence 183 180 423 neg. error 3 71 S 531 65 455 91 167 demurrer 70 185 special profits e 78 559 certificate 85 26 parol evidence 107 670 reversible error 45 M 580 cnll. crossing 124 599 damage 126 25 right of way 134 855 204NY 311 implied repeal 62 M 637 454 contract s 71 S 1098 r 173 NY 303 no estoppel 98 M 426 46 1 forfeitures s 71 S 857 211 NY 51 construction lOlM 345 468 employment s 71S 629 d 87 699 107 363 fairing year 127 286 89 M 615 intention 159 475 473 signal neg S71S 866 a 171 NY 6?8 77 45 97 46 480 renew note s71S 861 a 172 NY 642 liability f71M 2G3 defense 68 315 f 105 626 scope employ do 138 400 526 trustee 8 71 S 607 37 M 769 party in interest 64 LEA 687n 530 easement s 71S 826 impost 161 475 537 contract s 71 S 740 a 173 NY 592 540 mandamus s 71 S 707 a 169 NY 605 s74 606 138 355 intent legislation do 74 610 616 79 309 83 621 545 weight of ev s 71 S 616 e 68 478 488 jurisdiction 71 S 795 86 98 SXGCUtiOFS I 177 NY 222 553 assessment acquiescense • s 51 S 399 550 declarations s 71 S 705 67 420 do 107 77 17 AC 17? s71S 78 382 murder b71 S a 170 NY judgment 108 167 limitations 121 103M 603 180 428 allegations s 71 S 577 141 39 429 seduction s 71 S .'iS? 68LRA 108 438 Co. gen. com s 71 S 528 a 168 NY 639 political parties 90 M 447 442 revocation s 71 S 497 601 13 AC 259n 586 weight evidence • 1125 614 9 335 448 exemption 8 71 S 617 a 182 NY 373 192 NY tax lien 283 transf. tax 8 71 S 644 66 1761396 information 112 iJ, .1 i§*^ ''1 S 541 assessment 60 M 507,94 400 62 M 69 M 406196 109 136 '113 39 783 564 465 131 126 20.''i aggrieved do 140 7:i!i not aggrieved 151 236 discretion 106M 228 495 receiver s 71 S 849 37 M 63 s 10 AC 184 12 AC 147n 71 S a 173 NY 563 construction s68S s71S 498 ev. value s71 S 63 37 M preference 67 74 79 72 M 788 580 671 2.39 93 578 210 1141 630 103 case 5 appeal s71S a 171 NY case S 8 718 a 168 NY case 9 s71S a 169 NY 6 1 5 value case 1 s72S a 168 NY 77 tax books 161 review 81 f86 346 1148 1144 676 114.') 602 1124 674 432 126 48 409 1145 226 507 injunction s 71 S 610 54M 285 stkhlder 39 CP 303 nonstock corpn. 146 264 exempt 72 M tax sales 161 570 t'd transfer s 71 S 903 a 171 NY 658 a 176 NY 622 58 1 exemptions 8 71 S 933 86 79 80 586 incompet ev s 71 S 884 94 8 rulings 62M 348 603 mob dam. s 71 S 719 a 176 NY 545 607 ev stk. out CIO, , 5 '■IS 647 Ol^ local option 64 366 s71S 613 Id 69 107 f 66 615 review damages 120 900n new election 36 M 696 mandamus d40M notice 44 M el05 submission 112 resubmissn, t 118 invalid 20 AC 357 389 30 678 533 253n ABBKJ5Y1AT10NS «. •riticised ; 1, limited S36;5I7 master neg 40 8 71 S 169 21 72 78 U AC pleading 82 a 1 3 appeal case 3 8 71S m 168 NY 6 1 4 device case 2 s72S dower 199 NY a 170 NY prohibition 323 533 57 229 1146 669 24 49 401 appeal s71S a 173 NY trade name 62 M case 12 contract s71 S r 170 NY case 15 appeal 8 71 S a 169 NY case 20 bankruptcy »71 S 38 M case 21 hab corpus 8 71 S 1144 a 170 NY 46 controlling 155 238 1 104M 237 6 1 7 demurrer 1143 586 362 1133 219 1140 600 1137 307 5fi.3 87 114] 637 U42 695 3 71S 63 M 6 1 9 appeal case 4 71 S a 172 NY case 5 orders s71 S a 169 NY case 6 appeal s71S s 168 NY 620rep. capacity case 13 s71S a 172 NY a 102 case 15 s71S actual time 63 M limitations 202 NY breach contract 202 NY 489 VOL. 64 I annual report s 71 S 731 71 . 315 112 685 9 parol contiact 8 71 S 670 5 90 613 justified d 179 321 1 4 per. inj dam. s 71 S 734 ' a 172 NY 637 22 accdt insur s 71 S 692 87 46 30 injunction s 71 S 876 r 171 NY 538 declaration 69LRA 111 112 114 115 trees 685 533 391 321 322 764 4 1 shade s71 S a 177 NY _90 181 NY 14 AC 70LRA show damage 134 286 44 pleading s 71 S 704 42 M 9 46 constitutM. e71 S a 168 NY validity ■ 165 654 671 ri37 661 352 1137 80 487 37 63 right award s 71 S 680 not liable 1.56 43 7lg. crossg. dam 3 71 S 674 a 169 NY 605 131 713 presumption 128 151 damages 138 823 173 26 authority 75M 512 right award 9 M 35 80 explanation 71 S 687 77 623 181 NY 492 84 notice claim s71S 747 do 81 648 83 585 688 do 90 321 do 114 622 requirement 7.39 876 89 negl damage s71S 623 *170NY 616 master's duty 70LRA 831 95 contrib. neg. 8 71 S 721 81 407 88 359 91 156 49 M 523 Case 6 f 119 919 a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m. modified: * dismissed- n. not. e. explained: cover. Jed; ., same case; do. dissenting opinion; p7parailel cTs" q.qu^stfonld Vol. 64 N. T. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division reversal 123 793 1 09 reooTory s 71 S 695 211 NY 71 admissible 165 602 consent 91 M 409 I 1 7 waiver s 71 S 713 13 AC 149n l25joint tenants 1 82 insur. 8 71S a 171 NY indemnity do 128 s 71 S 146 73 M partition 73 M .94 M accounting 74M 717 295 449 451 530 215 1 9 1 stipulation s 71S 924 135 888 209 counsel s 71 S 1067 66 53 do 132 673 veteran's rights 143 20 212 decree s 71S 1108 f 182 909 22 1 life estate fSOflse pretence a 71 S 803 20 AC 60n I34pers. injury s 71S 851 135 538 not liable 156 43 distinct element 157 283 138 parol ev. (8 71 S 799 72 126 49M 114 doing business d9S 99 «102 112 143 146 147 do 183 40 M 41 M 45 M 53M 84 508 7 805 652 620 03' 73 222 244 360 520 ufle 918 25 531 92 M 390bd. 72 S e 86 268 pers injury jurisdiction s 72 S IO4I7O M f 68 264 215 NY remedy 72 510 uuconstiutiton'l 72 527 83 686 ordinance reaabl. 81 131 St. limitation 72 524 do 81 655 duty neglig. 112 85 notice claims 114 617 56 M 189 8 71 S d7S d 37 M 60 M intent 81 on merits 82 M 110 308 710 503 CIS 223 legia. power 3 71 S 1049 97 280 waiver e 97 281 legal claim L52 550 '229 certiorari 1052 74 71 S 86 M 231 title 3 71 S f39M slO AC 68 LKA price 50 M lOOM authority 153 13 AC 374n379n 13 AC 380n 384n 13 AC 388n 20 AC 21111 allegation 11 64 agency S6M 523 right r'^covery 65M certificate 67M merger 78 M admissible 78 M confirmed 178 1 45 waiver fl71S 184 NY 545 239 certiorari s 71S 1044 186 141 243 state clai m s 71 S 1041 d 97 282 consideration 190NY 412 246 atty lien 827 99 I 50neg. injury B 7] S 853 sS4 64 1 63 St. limitatin s 71 S 834 95 601 books as ev. 19AC 195n acknowldgmnt. 19AC 419n memorandum 94 M 98 1 67 indictmeLt 8 71 S 893 a 173 NY 395 e 36 M 328 f 44 M 350 10 AC 314 1015 314 204 102n 160 109 educatn 91 539 constitutional 67 M 568 hazardous 170 36 393 f d transfer 8 72 S 76 40 M 12 293 damageb 8 72 S 171 f 85 620 305 mistake 872 S a 173 NY judgment 115 38 CP 408 contract s72S 69 4 1 election s72S a 169 NY 72 312 ''veteran 8 72 S 84 f 68 643 e 79 155 3 1 6 certiorari 8 72 S 191 a 169 NY 521 33 1 sureties 3 72 S 87 r 176 NY 150 337 transfers 8 72 S 150 a 170 NY 618 eq. lien LIS 138 139 Corp. powers 56M 283e 284 346 constructn. 67 M 305 467 213 125 79 M 450 election 3 72 S 253 r 169 NY 339 36 M 477neg. s72S 69 d60M duty care 123 158 for jury 158 174 713 66 586 168 4 1 2 allegations 8 72 S 99 lf)2 432 9 73 S 1139 r 1 74 NY 76 6 1 6 conversion case 22 3 73 S 1035 r 171 NY 191 VOL- 66 I remainder 3 72 S 962 a 171 NY 281 9 ratification s 72 S 1021 a 169 NY 606 71 . 243 relief pleading f 73 554 II AC 164 directors 16AC 39n 1 4 fixtures 3 72 S 1026 70 122 47 M 405 right lost 173 NY 599 ILRANS 1194n waiver f 93 M 533 1 8 certiorari 3 72 S 957 do 86 277 23 usiiry s73S 12 f 74 624 114 554 183 423 42 M 485 error court 146 583 natural meaning 74M 430 defense usury 166 14 29 corp jurisd. 3 72 S 1008 43 M 669 56M 671 3 1 .concluded 9 72 S 941 a 174 NY 549 34 detention 3 72 S 922 10 AC 114n 37 sale title 3 73 S 233 77 497 notice r 174 NY 377 42 seduction 9 73 S 270 42 M 615 bar 10 AC 412n cancel judgment 15 AC 124n 46 insurance 3 73 S 120 3 96 118 53 new trial 9 73 S 88 16AC 124n not known 153 265 newly discv. ev. 103M 469 59 fact question 73 S 125 83 351 66 'reasonable' 3 72 S 568 t 164 91 reimburse f 164 97 mandamus f 88 M 639 county charges f 93 M 266 80 insur s73S 9 85 waiver 105 281 86 waiver s 72 S 481 10 AC 397n 88 town negl 9 73 S 86 69 326 327D ' 'vehicle' ' 179 553 97 tax warrant 3 72 S 673 e 174 NY 294 101 admr expn s 72 S 667 a 175 NY 521 e 41 M 281 105 in), negl s 72 S 862 67 341 master negl 82 490 89 377 48 M 618 res ipsa loquitui 100 399 12 AC 388n I 1 4 signals ev. s 72 S 863 13 AC 423 424n I 1 7 mandamus s 72 S 782 ml70 NY 93 unenforceable 88 M 228 1 23 restoration s 72 S 668 87 31 1 36 intention s 72 S 968 81 355 trust 3 118 468 470 I 57 taxation s 72 S 950 75 170 capital stock 86 580 availability C3M 118 I 62 gift causa !i] s 73 s :is m 170 NY 42.3 117 367 tax succession 79 M 657 167 368 171 taxbl int. s 72 S 984 288 13 AC 354 construction 106 20 1 79 challenge s 73 S 279 a 172 NY 146 1 84 covenant 8 72 S 948 8 172 NY 606 67M 469 6470 1 87 indictment s 73 S 130 r 169 NY 487 20 I discovery 3 73 S 118 55M 327 cts . power 67M 364 authority 134 436 discovery 139 limtd 726 204 chg. venue 8 73 S 108 e88 69 60 d 89 625 207 crossg. neg 3 73 S 48 a 174 NY 516 flOO IS 21 I mandamus s 72 S 945 125 72E 98 M 367 discretioi d 70 M viOO 2 1 6 taxable inb 9 72 S 597 93 179 e41M 182 notice e 101 439 ^ood title 125 76.= cond. sale 133 417 personalty 185 467 228 fixtures s 72 S 694 13 AC 349n 231 probib writ 3 72 S 718 73 344 168 557 82 M 631 iurisdiction 41 M 43] 312 NY 172 239 alienation 3 73 S 22 161 mitigation ev. 121 225 259 mandamus 3 72 S 806 a 176 NY 132 appeal .57 M 414 94 M 737 interference 2 M 474 267 exemption 3 . 2 S 81 r 171 NY 4 273 compliance s 72 S 691 159 462 277 affidavit s 72 a 894 98 492 appeal 99 296 284pria. agt. 9 72 S 769 * 171 NY 700 elect, void do 131 268 fraud forfeit 145 781 290referee'srept s72S 615 s 10 AC 287 70 414 17AC 54n 56 f 47 M 666 54M 261 stipulation 48 M . 428 pers. liable do 124 60S joint liable 66M 880 referee's fees 137 753 140 205 293 f'd asaignt s 73 S 114 a 171 NY 637 299 estoppel 9 72 S . 774 110 30 306 partition 3 72S r 173 NY parties 73 75 675 91 HI 30 309 vetn. perf 9 72 S 699 80 174 3 1 2 decree 9 72 S 714 r 172 NY 547 3 1 4 co-servant 9 72 S 677 76 478 master duties 111 622 3 1 7 damages ■ 9 72 S 705 review assessmt. 66 411 S8 738 41 M 131 14 AC 350n 14AC 357a 14AC 35Sn 323 benefits 3 72 S 755 a 172 NY 665 74 535 188 NY 285 330 coupons 72 S 786 a 172 NY 635 336 discretion b73 S 38 9 81 446 448 479 contradict ev. 68 480 review 17AC 202n 340 appeal 179 NY 72 S 563 1062 367 parties 9 72 S 687 43 M 309 ohge venue 16AC 105-6D 372 error court s 72 S 679 167 269 171 468 383 reservation a 72 S 86,S r 175 NY 268 395 negligence 9 72 S 745 a 112 279 398 rescission 9 72 S 936 115 776 release 174 40 19AC 437n restoration dl36 289 do291 407 accounting 9 72 S 657 118 300 38 CP 352 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note e, criticised; 1, limited; e. explained: o. overruled; s, same case; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q, questioned N. Y. Supreme Court Reports —Appellate Division Vols. 66, 67 agency 61 M 227 409 pers. inj s 72 S 881 » 169 NY 336 prox. cause. do 68 451 bodily injury 78 533 review rule 30 41 M 131 sped, dam. 12 AC 18n ign 12 AC 20n 25n stipulation 100 228 restrict proof 197NY 73 inadmissible 20 AC 170n 4 1 5 new trial s73S 49 M 423 reUef b73S S2 434 draft B73S a 171NY 103 226 296 203 172 1084 644 188 439 chee eradef e 73 S 10 B 171 NY 685 damages 116 553 constitutional 207 NY 613 fee in trust 88 M 180 443 jurisdiction b73S 69 do 81 6 81 ei03 157 169 183 46 11 demurrer do 77 M amendable 78 M limit jurisdictn. 157 425 no jurisdiction do 84 M 92 132 .._ cond. precedent f 161 217 467 necessaries 8 73 S 231 73 64 credit wife do 73 68 42 M 203 11 AC 96 101 470 damages 3 73 S 376 97 638 equity suits 20 AC 105n 473 foreign corp s 73 S 347 a 174 NY 636 13 AC 385n 387d 607 57 2.35 193 424 497 410 257 400 388 395 266 426 465 372 476 94 M rescission d71M compliance 204NY 104M recovery 79 M certificate 225 US prerequisite 83 M 512 counterclaim 104M 194 478rights crdrs s 73 S 290 68 M 271 480 pleading s 73 S 301 139 928 state separately 157 721 174 540 482 ex delicto ■i 73 S 296 113 72 178 NY 134 25 593 534 demurrer 3 73 S 236 a 170 NY 584 72 283 37 M 688 690 89 M 602 indictment 86 111 120 157 40 M relief 45 M pleading 59M rule 127 590 injunction 634 561 370 225 308 100 656 s73S 8 87 ofevidence 512 171 275 486 ejectment 613 448 construction B 73 S 594 m 174 NY 398 retroaction 78 549 661 reservation 37 M 409 453 mandamus s 73 S 331 a 171 NY 627 e 84 441-2 106 691 dismissal 262 193 614 476 407 45 26 59 154 17AC 176 8 73S 8 77 107 116 f 117 do 133 8 44M foreclose vd. 119 39 CP possession 16AC 433-4n 493 proof heirs 117 407 50 1 objections 8 73 S 256 s 99 370 507 pleading s 73 S 386 8 77 414 4] 6 96 311 do 103 282 110 362 siiffic complt 542 commissns ■> 73 S 249 114 539 a 184NY 602 552 jurisdiction s 73 S 244 76 133 modification 11 AC 293n s 12 AC 136 instalments 217 US 24 554 compet ev s 73 S 256 79 595 85 8' expert evidence do 106 430 559 ac. insur. 8 73 S 341 r 175 NY 239 566 relief 8 73 S 247 11 AC 170 17lD do 171 733 law action 128 178 managing agent d 72 M 262 159 420 set aside 94 M 483 cond. precedent 180 748 403 260 30 732 124 119 412 536 779 131 133 40 M ev44M stockholder do 88 161 attachment 92 266 267 172 312 receiver appoint 99 218 limitations court el03 3 title realty 59 M 12 receivership 133 124 jurisdiction 1130 698 592 1131 parol license 42 M 266 266 report case 4 3 73S 8 169 NY a 173 NY appeal case 7 s73S a 172 NY appeal case 10 s73S a 176 NY 3 176 NY appeal case 16 8 73S a 173 NY dismissal case 19 s73S a 176 NY dismissal case 22 8 73S a 173 NY f 165 603 bill s73S 75 77 elOl 114 51 M 19 AC 19 AC 19 AC 667 696 569 ubel s73S 3 72 improper ev. e72 370 572 infant, nee. s 73 S 322 87 370 14 AC 71 n 575 receiver 'court's power 169 429 455 certificate s 73 S 352 B 71 596 recovery f 160 10 AC 2S3n demurrer 16AC 248n rights parties 176 506 463 contempt 8 73 8 s74 8 84 40M 45 M 522 ultra vires s 73 S 313 288 a 173 NY 616 196NY 153 130 742 pleadg. defense 82 233 206 NY 538 13 AC 273n 13 AC 20 yrs. 385 492 401 133 514, 179 180n 527 injunction proof is 73 S 369 3 73 8 e72 120 125 53M discretion .37 M notice 150 f 167 f 186 order void 181 328 578 321 543 17 518 833 940 900 159 partic 242 324 319 45 192 502 2ii 6 7n 605 new trial s 73 S 291 18 27n knowledge 181 74 61 I delegation case 1 3 74 8 do 96 578 313 6 1 2 appeal case 21 3 73S » 169 NY 1130 699 578 ta.x s 73 8 161 sales 298 4 582 agency 373 8 77 f87 8 10 AC proof service 98 authority 132 420 service corpn. 136 273 211 235 138 6 1 3 new trial case 11 3 73 8 costs 69 10 AC new trial case 14 3 73S costs 135 in AC 1132 572 431 1136 1134 547 696 1138 617 1145 493 1143 585 6 I 7 assessment case 1 s73S a 172 NY case 5 appeal s73S a 175 NY case 8 appeal s73S a 176 NY case 10' contract s73 8 a 173 NY negligence proof 111 279 case 18 negligence 3 73 8 r 173 NY 3 101 case 22 legacy 3 73 8 r 173 NY 1143 649 1143 475 1146 550 1146 149 VOL. 67 I transfer tax s 73 8 475 d84 611 distribution 126 693 1 4 conspiracy s73S J 82 159 39 M injunction 174 67M 518 8 468 58 250 99 1 6 indictment 8 73 8 a 171 NY 72 620 627 69 417 460 549 25 damages s73S a 171 NY 89 167 adeq compensn 74M 593 injunction 50 M 422 liability 116 661 50 excuse waiver s 73 8 496 70 174 commissions e 93 ^ 453 f 49 M 482 201 NY 215 variance 37 M 804 defective title 37 M 846 defeat statute 143 102 1137 79 611 1132 4-3 6 1 8 opg. street 614 appeal ca?e 1 8 73 8 a 178 NY Corp. deb't case 2 3 73 8 114S. ml70NY» 473 appeal case 7 3 73 8 a 176 NY new trial case 22 1133 63f 1145 574 3 72 8 a 169 NY a 170 NY 623 m lien case 2 3 73 8 r 174 NY case 4 sureties 3 73 8 r 171 NY case 5 sureties 3 73 8 a 176 NY case 20 appeal 3 73 8 al74 NY case 21 beneficiary 3 73S a 174 NY 61LRA f 174 846 602 576 1140 499 1129 1 472 800 802 53 bar s 73 8 121 f 121 deny relief 72 M 361 counterclaim 166 474 lead fraud t 169 793 58 fact question a 73 S 488 52 64 discovery 8 73 8 456 13 AC 452n 454n 84 M 264 99 danger place b73S 606 44 M 203 f 47 M 106 excessive dam 11 AC OOd contrib. n eglig. 19UNY 210 for jury 145 137 degree care 166 263 1 02 discretion s73S 640 S2 596 strike out t 164 357 41 M 574 42 M 79 44M 301 resettlement 120 317 43M 362 denials 158 500 104 title e73S 617 a 177 NY 539 f67 616 reservation 73 M 290 1149 576 1136 503 1138 146 793 796 3 73S costs 69 135 10 AC 1132 672 153 432 172 6 1 6 tel poles case 2 Is 73 S 1129 875i41 M 110 70 sureties s73 8 a 175 NY 600 150 614 314 75 attachment s73S a 173 NY judgt. nee. 128 8 1 demurrer s73 8 44M 137 submission 3 73 8 fsg 180 defective 95 jurisdiction 193 NY 504 580 16 86 bona fides s 73 S 549 37 M 768 90 assessment s73S a 173 NY 678 611 98 review s 73 S 18AC certificate 18AC amendment 18AC 340n 541 336r 339D I 16 Bup'l acctg ) 73 S 675 1 197NY 473 e 42 M . 82-4 counsel fees 10 AC 199n 3 97 512 reimburse 131 227 validity 143 695 121 sp'l procdgs. s 73 S 450 118 343 39 CP- 29 129 1 27 stock note 3 73 8 674 a 171 NY 699 ILRANS 916n 130 allegation 3 74 S 390 163 70 132 not lien dower . 74 S f 168 election lOOM 395 356 644 692 632 434 630 663 I39burden proof 3 73 8 37 M 6 37M 1 4 1 m. lien _73 8 85 513 861 862 604 68 I 43 jurisdiction 3 73 8 667 107 695 145 claim rule 3 73 8 • 388 75 , 263 implied warranty 14 AC 287n warranty d 158 464 f 162 336 '^^UuZli^iTI^iei)e!':^p!^>Le%'l:'^^^^ i?--5-^= "•■ P-x^'fi^"!^ -..dismissed: n. note: , o, oipiamea, o, overruled, i, same case; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q, questioned Vol. 67 N. 7. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division 148 Crust 73 S 598 d 76 221 construe will 124 617 to the issue 152 749 151 do busiuess s 73 S 668 173 NY 633 221 husb. 8 73S s91 91 93 102 147 do 147 do 183 42 M 45 M 13 AC 20 AC 211 NY 220 NY contract f 127 147 13 AC 220 NY 304 8 269 537 8ST 72 212 360 379 381 218n 427 267 318 795 3S8a 317 1 58 renewal B 73 S 609 r 175 NY 266 s 98 2g!J 1 76 transfer tax wife 592 551 652 223 master servt ri 73 S 733 122 190 228 bank nee. s 73 S 648 3 83 66 pleading 124 734 survivorship 144 235 relief 8 73S s80 92 160 216 373 172 veterans 81 M 342 88 354 pleading s 73 S 785 70 266 demurrer. e 81 557 possessn act 130 219 359 center st. 319 b73S * 171 NY 83 62 M 818 652 534 15] 1 83 construe will 614 84 B 73 S 56M issue 152 f 163 187 stay B73S do 135 16 AC lOOM practice 125 651 court power 135 906 convenience 71 M 179. 182 1 89fact question B 73 S 673 !l02 526 536 action 596 907 • 256n 18 64 M 453 19 I injunction s 73 S 653 a 172 NY 454 dp 95 627n distribution e 43 M 581 44 M 443 46 M 228 d 48 M 482 484 d48M 591 agt 656 298 196 prin s73S a 174 NY acquiesced d 139 806 agency d 139 803 804 e 139 806 212 master nes B 74 S 196 69 350 86 294 reasonable care 49 M 620 signals ev. 116 due care 136 liability f 211 NY 182 84 241 negligence 3 73 S 390 r 178 NY 84 245 foreclosure s 73 S 172 a 170 NY 498 indemnification 114 642 267 recovery s 73 S 378 44 M 132 297 contrib neg 3 73 S 392 a 173 NY 616 312 inj damage 156 310 214n 3 73 3 12 AC negligence d 110 want care 153 367 r r intersect 8 73S r 178 NY 14 AC 3 1 9 veniie s74S r 174 NY U AC 506 83 317n 322 intention 3 73 S 167 41 M 342 gift d 83 M 447 acts binding f 89 M 135 competent ev, 186 210 330 eviction s 73 S 738 15 AC 466n 333 franch. tax 3 73 S 746 r 174 NY 475 75 166 337 corp' taxn, 3 73 S 493 42 M 150 54 M 449 15 AC SOln raising funds 68M 287 duty commissnr 68M 287 34 1 chge. venue s73S 89 f46M affidavit 120 772 625 236 624 344 demurrer s 73 S 774 167 335 349 civ service s 73 S 823 73 466 statute valid 80 172 mandamus do 145 s73S s88 a 170 NY e77 teleph wires 92 92 damages 41 M 794 202 298 572 90 91 113 655 335 75 111 107 363 res ipsa loq. 737 387n 26 213 s73S * 170 NY 102 Qo appeal 151 180 744 573 101 753 210 368 construction s73S a 170 NY 76 allegationB 37 M title olUce 33 C. P. submission 306 NY 434 claim s74S a 173 NY rejection el04 objections 109 surrogate 62 M stct construct'n 62 M 172 443 jury trial 8 73 S 906 11 AC 103n 99 601 error charge 115 471 445 discovery 8 73 S 957 121 879 39 M 241 446 rebate a73S a 173 NY 741 185 407 198 207 504 375 assessment s 73 S 689 a 170 NY 186 79 190 title office 44 M 252 unconstitutional 160 violation 160 389 sworn statement s73S 75M 433 293 219 398 certiorari a 73 S 970 a 171 NY 354 a 192 US 21 use streets 55 M 146 cond. prcdt 125 331n 403 buildg. code 8 73 S 684 85 361 pub. nuisance 19AC 154n compulsorv 161 143 hy injunction 216 NY 468 4 1 ctrclaim s 73 S 641 137 238 e 239 157 s 10 AC 43 M conversion 140 75M 431 360 210 531 654 4 1 4 inj. negl. 8 73 S 788 661!* 173 NY 600 424 limltatlou 3 73 S 779 16AC 306n right living 99 M 152 430 action lies s 73S 790 75M 64" 987 605 408 601 543 542 465 95 ell7 117 134 duplic receipts 87 51 ministerial 48 M 180 onus probandi 79 M 459 457 re-argument 3 73 S 986 r 171 NY 579 13 AC 20 doing business d 48 M 367 13 AC 381 386n 13 AC 390-2n 463 pleading 78S 979 128 128 contractual d 93 M 435 473 contracts 3 73 S 873 e 83 320 483 use streets 8 73 S 856 8 78 418 70 32 487 notice file 8 73 S 890 108 302 493 unmarried a 74 S 206 a 171J!fY 652 498 friv pleadn. 373S 875 93 186 102 371 do 123 S13 6SM 579 affidavits practice 157 466 502 demurrer 3 73 S 1013 89 38 66M 223 misjoinder 101 150 266 642 504 encroachmt 8 73 S 1006 97 17 102 46 e 107 419 consent not necessary 64M 413 incumbrance d 139 527 pract. location 74M 503 county judge 163 732 516 inj. servt. 3 73 S 1108 * 173 NY 620 53 1 surrender s 73 S 1016 a 174 NY 518 lease ends s 69 M 476 not conclusive 69 M 485 535 indorsement 8 74 8 221 3 73 492 539 wiring neg. 8 73 S 973 s 170 NY 615 al74 NY 508 e89 682 party insur. co. f 175 39 545 construction s74S tS7 conmiissions 118 39 CP affidavit 64 M 274-5 598 libel 3 73S 71 d71 107 114 innuendo 14 AC 684 608 774 247 605 negligence 8 74 S 336 do 70 370 d 82 128 special damages 12 AC 24n 106 363 fact question 132 401 S2M 347 duty deft, d 198NY 3,47 admissible 20 AC 174n 547 attachment 8 73 S 1019 76 116 549 parties s73S 43 M 903 309 557 namenewCo s 73 S 981 140 782 no action 207 NY 445 bill directors 207 NY 445 560 "in trust s 37 S 967 s 92 167 competent ev 60 M 506 trust trustee 71 M 302 create trust 82 M 224 genl. objection 1 M 196 567 advance 8 73 S 877 d 102 291 46 M . 183 16AC 88-90n 573 description s 73 S 1027 a 175 NY 475 77 492 12 AC 205 presumption e 121 234 intent deed 78 M 197 78 M 198 conduct parties 209 NY 198 583 niU sale s 73 S 882 P 78 619 589 interpldr. B 73 S 852 d 81 201-2 £ 162 606 construction 81 203 204 demurrer d 39 M 26 595 representns 3 73 S 966 e 101 509 pleading 118 817 849 568 669 308 178 413n 6 1 5 receiver case 1 s73S 167 case 6 negligence s73S a 173 NY case 7 appeal s73S a 177 NY 289 615 1131 565 1129 539 617 jury questn case 2 s 73 S 324 d 73 251 do 73 256 P 74 195 6 1 8 appeal case 1 3 S 1144 a-170 NY 620 619 appeal case 2 8 73S a 175 NY case 4 appeal aJTO S s 176 NY dsmissal case 24 s73S ► 171 NY vol. payment 201 NY 414 not apply 72 M 10 1139 482 1146 69 1138 650 case 27 • appeal s74S r 175 NY case 27 appeal s74S r 175 NY case 29 appeal 8 74S r 175 NY 30 appeal s74S a 173 NY case 35 judgment s74S * 171 NY 99 surety 110 15 AC 62 1 evidence case 1 s73S 3 84 3 parol ev. 3 73S p 174 NY 624 appeal case 4 s74S a 174 NY case 12 appeal 3 74S a 172 NY case 16 award 3 74S a 176 NY 1146 485 1134 484 1140 484 1126 613 1141 666 394 679 1129 624 643 63 1121 607 1149 620 1121 60S 625 certiorari case 11 s73S * 172 NY case 5 appeal s74S a 170 NY case 6 admissions 3 74S a 176 NY contracts 126 627 appeal case 10 a 177 NY 3 73S case 11 codicil -73 3 a 170 NY case 12 banking s73S a 170 NY case 16 security s73S 42 M case 23 dismissal s74S a 174 NY 1144 112 1139 448 1147 124 599 546 1140 30 84 1150 1143 150 1120 645 820 pleading case 12 s73S r 170 NY demurrer 3 110 surety 110 73M . 1142 439 135 679 207 628 replevin case 1 s 74 S 1130 8 173 NY 637 r 174 NY 140 case 5 creditor sutt s 744 S 1132 r 176 NY 520 report case 10 s74S a 177 NY case 11 s74S 1136 545 1146 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d. distinguished: f. {ollowed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, no*«! e, criticised ; 1, limited ; e, explained ; o, overruled ; s, same case ; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, qucBtioned N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division Vols. 67, 68 » 173 NY 603 appeal -case 13 B 74 S 1121 * 170 NY 186 cafie 14 8 74 S 1137 « 170 NY 186 case 21 injunction s74 S 1146 s 176 NY 346 68 M 239 a 81 293 f 81 334 96 133 case 23 appeal s74S 1149 a 174 NY 507 177 NY 206 change track 112 S87 damages do 145 4 apportion 145 2 no power 156 860 91 M 81 VOL.68 Istockholdr suit s 73 S 1039 94 387 5 reviror suit B 74 S 297 a 171 NY 653 12 body executn s 74 S 194 116 338 38 CP 193 18 pers, inj. dam 3 74 S 35 93 552 do 173 925 jury question ILEANS 230n master neg. 1 LEANS 235n presumption 145 525 strike out 59 M 152 27 transfer tax s 74 S 450 m 172 NY 69 do 172 NY 75 amendt. law 37 M 472 39 M 618 38 charge proof s 74 S 78 96 381 libe] law questn. 14 AC 411 n evidence 146 399 contempt 64 M 618 insufficient 226JJT 91 47 discretion s 74 S 34 98 301 49 neg. proof 8 74 S 267 * 175 NY 476 70 205 a 102 614 Special damages 12 AC 18n 20n 12 AC 26n 14 AC 307n carrier d 49 M 508 inadmissible 20 AC 172n negligence d 90 M 666 60 ment, capac, 8 74 S 109 r 174 NY 317 77 121 86 293 38 M 370 371 direct verdict 99M 246 mere opinions 99JI 253 70 indorser e 74 S 64 a 174 NY 222 construction 127 565 surety 65M 392 82 atty. lien s 74S 217 18 AC 101 86 demand s 74S 78 182 93 88 injunction 8 74S 84 r 171 NY 40 M 384 422 94 poor person s 74 S 146 11 AC 255n 95 expr. malice 74 S 317 78 80 forerunners 173 493 I 4 wife redeem 3 74 S 212 184 NY 416 mtgee possn. 16AC 43 In 440n 1 07 ice negl s 74 S 261 a 174 NY 518 95 376 II AC 34u 15 AC 328n negligence walk 122 916 d 148 723 liability 129 53 right to wait 143 218 I 1 6 sum pro. 9 74 S 243 r 174 NY 97 prejudicial 160 276 I 1 9 license 9 74S revocation d 75 303 13 AC 254n jurisdiction 13 AC 261n evidence 13 AC 263n 182 1 23 neg. damage 9 74 S 143 77 165 f80 626 contrib neg 82 16 84 205 91 156 94 395 103 217 116 150 52M 577 evidence habit do 143 207 1 25 transfer tax s 74 S 190 171 NY 684 d 77 358 do 77 359 84 236 exchange seat 174 NY 256 e39M 617 1 26 ans objns. ■9 74 S 147 * 171 NY 631 1 28 libel per se 3 74 S 290 71 460 allegations do 112 249 9pl. damage 18AC 180n 1 34 damages 3 74 S 180 r 176 NY 111 137 trademark s 74 S 184 r 174 NY 327 141 privileged 3 74S 561 18AC 41n 144 jurisdiction 3 74 S 148 113 470 legatee 118 328 successor 118 332 148 innueodo s 74 S 214 160 694 harmless 165 391 allegations 165 392 1 54 pensions 9 74 S 172 a 171 NY 263 public policy 96 M 333 1 58 Umitatiom 8 74 S 443 8 87 467 98 9 Ul 177 118 332 122 455 138 165 170 457 173 905 12 M 163 45 M 263 57M 539 70 M 471 accounting 91 M* 379 I 63 assignment s 74 S 260 r 174 NY 69 f 68 634 preference e74 484 74 486 do 74 487 E94 57 bankruptcy 15 AC 81 liability do 154 6 1 67 supervision 5 74 S 165 141 753 (75 not suspended s 74 S 89 d 163 563 actions tort 98 M 91 1 79 actn. pdmg 3 74 S 56 not bar 132 543 13 AC 159n 1 80 chge venue 3 74 S 13 d 86 514 16AC 17lD 1 82 title 9 74 S 234 3 41 M 6 48 M 46 Stat limitations 47 M 459 foreign will 128 203 I 89 amendment 119 74 S 74 97 irregularity 76 93 97 attachment 60 M 76 116 377 76 548 1 9 I pleading 3 74S 116 98 602 rule law 114 418 counterclaim 56M 165 each complete 163 236 allegations f 91 M 576 1 93savines bank 8 74 8 140 14 AC 83n bank neg. 69LRA 336d I 96 reinstate 8 74 S 94 89 . 57 ministerial 123 595 135 93 202 terms trial s 74S 117 18AC 29i 204 pers. injury 8 74 S 126 95 215 212 removal s 72 S 436 3 74 S 155 14 AC 437n f 114 120 19AC 50n 51n 54n court's power 19AC 55 2 I 7 costs stay 73 S 1093 12 AC 64n 329 62 M 352 iiu stay 138 ruling 143 171 225 revocation 73 S 1073 s 10 AC 381 II AC 384 228 neg. charge s 74 S 238 a 173 NY 634 23 1 audit 74 S 284 a 174 NY 519 889 467 48 M 90 conclusive 113 531 157 458 olM 131 tax payer 113 634 variaJice 123 874 not 6nal 66M 325 collat. attack 147 671 82 M 70 jurisdiction 207 NY 28 binds city 159 459 239 ins policy 8 74 S 177 a 174 NV 489 f 68 645 242 neg. proof 73 S- 1130 83 104 262 munic. liable 3 74 S 97 I5AC 324n 277 conspiracy 3 74 S 159 72 259 28 1 chge. renue 8 74 S 64 rOS 645 • I 112 129 116 497 498 service mail 112 122 f41M 17 38 CP452, 4S3ri demand timely 108 11 residence t6AC 168n 170n 296 assesflhient 74 3 144 r 172 NY 309 299 executor 74 S 122 78 442 limitation 146 569 302 body injury s 74 S 49 * 170 NY 617 78 633 e83 34 12 AC 27ii surprise 123 27 iidmissible JO AC 174n 3 1 Om, prosecutn 8 74 S 59 85 614 d 107 442 186 NY 404 45 M 4911 318 legal title s 74 S 10 80 M 84 IBS 564 civil contempt 138 665 f 91 M 421 320 cord, fees 8 74 S 70 m 170 NY 7 39 M 379 8 12 AC 362 atty. clieut 53M 516 327 corpus, s 74 S 18 a 173 NY 598 12 AC 221n handwriting 64 LRA 309n 319n corpn. de facto 140 579 give judgment 162 356 342 incompet ev a 74 S 101 82 460 14 AC 277n ex. pedigree 18AC 231 346 oral ev s 74 S 231 72 551 8 79 131 83 223 e 83 224 8 12 AC 367 371 entirety 72 M 172 357 appear acct. s 74 S 75 104 464 party in int. 34 CP 286 eift vested 136 833 362 prox cause s 74 S 130 71 444 79 126 do 79 129 do 102 442 113 442 18AC 440n, 443n ca'isa causans 71 M 142 negligence 115 671 prox. cause s -4 S 130 71 M 36 370 prepondev s 74 S 104 69 343 gift evidence 111 453 spec, pertorm'nce d 114 819 revocable 168 235 legis. power f 172 74 93 M 235 375 amend plead- ing 3 74 B 189 47 M 677 54M 173 20 AC 20n interference 72 M 474 377 failure to call witness 3 74 S 167 394 e 80 325 1 10 AC 385 t 102 329 104 60 d 105 399 Inference 120 115 do 129 569 142 509 £ 161 97 170 315 charge 123 187 jury question 129 565 381 exr acctg - 75 S 1S5 92 14 map control 136 396 intention 136 799 f 88 M 382 385 beneficiary 75 S 188 42 M 647 388 dower 3 74 S 259 m 172 NY 26 f 80 259 260 surrogate jurisdn U AC 406n 390 change rule 3 74 S 376 80 326 presumptn ev q 39 M 60 e 11 AC 468 fright proof 106 203 396 certiorari s 74 S 294 al76 NY 471 cemetery d 134 252 4 1 4 contempt 8 74 S 486 95 409 134 363 64M 61S ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; I. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, mote; c criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q, questioned Vols. 68, 69 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division 428 obstruction B 73 S 930 a 175 NY 502 injunction 70 LRA 204n overlapping 185 216 436 repairs B 73 S 963 87 154 52 M 156 good cause 131 12 ICPNS 314 damages 88 M 524 44 1 trench neg. 8 73 S 842 a 174 NY 519 73 6 prox. damage 83 609 110 669 125 604 pleading I2AC 26n proof negligence 111 551 proof claim] 18AC 226 competency 142 277 admissible 20 AC 17511 451 negligence 8 73 S 830 assumption 77 e70 458 flse repreaen B 73 S 924 r 174 NY 181 466 master neg s 73 S 912 al75 NY 495 si 76 NY 660 123 580 d 53M 40e 475 weight ev. 8 74 S 29 8 79 644 change ev. 125 555 < 481 rescission s 73 S 817 139 180 d 139 13] third party 71 M 250 483 evidence 8 74S f86 163 remedy 124 219 bill partic. 19 AC 42n 488 highway 8 74 S 343 8 176 NY 594 a 178 NY 561 13 AC 238n 239n 240 246n 218 NY acceptance 106 194 14 AC . 263d ripar rights 188NY 83 encroachment 120 765 766 prescription 141 722 dedication intent 141 710 f 164 58 88 M 612 abandonment f 164 843 83 M 219 218 NY 99 public street 88 M 185 88 M 189, 190 508 construction 8 73 S 1047 a 171 NY 689 e 70 168 170 128 728 10 AC 413d 6 10 AC 416 417 15 AC 122n pleading 124 144 entire record 128 729 not concluded 183 ' -127 52 1 encroachmt 3 73 S 1022 38 M 3S monuments do 142 330 actual location 80 M 272 boundary fence 96 M 470 528 reargument 8 73 S 898 10 AC 376 no discretion 70 M 540 531 warranty 8 74 S 224 s78 42 121 30 14 AC 294n meas damages 121 32 d 134 657 542 pleading 74 S 277 do 105 35 552 penalty s 74 S 241 e 96 107 581 per. injury 8 73 S 827 a 174 NY 543 eontrib. negl. 185 183 f 84 M 511 568 ball club s 73 S 864 101 307 a 174 NY 535 tender^ 71 M 597 waiver f 166 496 578 scaffold s 73 S 908 6 76 41 ■?0 AC 203ri 195 NY . 422 construction 110 753 neg. master 125 683 structures 153 84 161 141 195 NY 421 labor law 133 415 592 trust s 74 S 43 c 84 217 c 13 AC 193 60 1 death neg s 74 S 301 r 174 NY 310 e 78 122 negligence 125 73 liability 132 432 contempt 67M 99 623 pun damage s 73 S 835 12 AC 87n 65 LRA 277n 634 warranty case 2 s 73 S 893 a 174 NY 508 635 trust s 74 S 175 a 178 NY 137 636 title ins. s74S 170 a 176 NY 65 638 count rclam case 12 s 74 S 1148 452 do 137 349 638 appeal case 21 s74S 1143 s 73 458 639 appeal case 7 s 74 S 1143 s 86 623 640 appeal 8 74 S 135 a 176 NY 646 642 review case 2 s 74 S 191 71 M 109 645 dismissal case 24 3 74 S 1137 a 174 NY 543 case 27 appeal s74S 1120 a 174 NY 642 G4Q next of kin case 1 s 74 S 33 f 82 M 143 justified do 160 94 f 89 M 719 removal lOOM 82 650 constitul case 1 S74S 1142 a 170 NY 105 general usage ■ f 173 953 case 9 adoption 8 74 S 1136 r 175 NY 454 case 12 parol ev a 74 S 1137 r 174 NY 108 case 13 new trial s74S 1142 a 173 NY 613 case 14 appeal s 74 S 1146 s 173 NY 603 a 174 NY 513 ie20 ale s74S 113fi a 174 NY 331 case 27 appeal s74S 1148 a 176 NY 54P VOL. 69 I trespass ' 74 ff 630 54M . 432 revocation 123 263 lateral support 128 107 1 gas mains 3 74 S 664 a 174 NY 538 I 4oleomargarine 5 74 S 570 * 173 NY 599 e89 187 unconstitutional 73 M 410 21 allegations 3 74 S 528 84 440 88 438 164 358 50M 132 22 new trial 3 74 S 481 42 M 526 discretion 45 M 408 113 48 costs trial 135 152 trial court f 161 * 451 27 neg. damages 3 74 S 518 a 173 NY 645 recovery lOOM 51 33 pref. bnkrupt 5 74 S 499 e 48 M 36 37 spl. partner s 74 S 624 r 171 NY 15 45 f'd transfer 8 74 S 643 40 M 11 53 certificate 74 S 558 a 173 NY 639 78 550 f 78 651 37 M 410 prospective 15 AC 414n Forfeiture 20 AC 55n 58 receiver 3 74 S 585 a 171 NY 654 11 AC 363n relates back 1.57 61.=) conclusive, t 95 M 261 63 injunction s 74 S 634 d 109 808, son ion 812 f 162 535 187NY 250 58 M 464 luthority f 97 M 503 76 declarations s 74 S 567 145 222 80 elm vs city 8 74S 589 r 173 NY 414 85 jury question a 74 a 482 56M TOM 348 38S 87 bill partic 3 74 S 514 f 109 423 113 30j 90 trustee right s 74 S 549 78 M 498 92 neg. damages 3 74 S 631 a 172 NY 587 1 03 neg. damage ■. 74 S 573 special do 78 107 oiental e78 633 pleading 12 AC 18u21n 27n restrict proof 197NY 73 inadmissible 20 AC 171n I 08 proof knwl .s 74S 553 63M 231 i 1 2 contrac 8 74 S 2558' s69 int 9 nl 1 21 accou i s 74 S 04 155 176 52M: 190 1 24 weight of ev s74S - 551 do 104 627 47 M 353 bill paiticulars 147 630 improper 154 394 1 27 bonds tax case 2 s 74 S 508 a 171 NY 682 a 188 US 189 100 376 84 513 114 209 40 M 432 I 30 excess dam. 8 74 S 624 a 174 NY 514 134 liability s 74 S 496 210 NY 82 137 injunction s 74 S 502 a 174 NY 166 damages 81 117 82 45 recoverable f 169 657 72 M 9 1 4 1 pleadg rule a 74 S 483 119 428 bill particulars 146 2 I 44 stockholder 3 74S 617 a 176 NY 119 71 240 6 94 387 115 38E 154 1'" do 154 34 89 M 241 247 enforcement 147 right of action 1B4 337 liability 164 337 e 164 342 I 53 conversion s 74 S 694 a 174 NY 542 chat, mortgage f 84 489 defense d 39 M 16 I6D negligence s 74 S 648 172 304 1 70 deposit s 74 S 602 a 174 NY 513 1 76 disallowance s74 S 812 398 i79 NY. 486 ratification 53M 78 power board 138 477 illegal t 87 M 426 201 composition 8 74 S 606 s'l72 NY 602 a 175 NY 521 measure damage 150 121 2 1 1 pojtnership s 74 S 826 a 174 NY 306 22 1 stockholders s 74 S 787 47 M 204 205 15 AC 475n 237 transfer tax a 74 S 702 r 172 NY 575 60 M 508 247 neg damage s 74 S 599 77 163 165 eontrib. neg. 82 16 331 205 606 12 540 280 a 174 NY 84 'itle 95 271 merger 103 351 trustee benefic. 110 330 test trust 128 225 genl. power 132 144 ill trust 144 . 64 197NY 313 273sup. pleadg. s 74S .660 186 381 inadmissible f 176 705 282 rule condct s 74 S 747 165 328 285 interpleader 8 74 S 749 8 72 476 s 74 620 286 declaration 8 74 S 755 90 21 jury question 135 703 qualified 68 M pleadings 214 NY f 91 M 251 fact stated s 74S 682 132 206 all parties 160 385 254 discontinue 74 S 620 13 AC 163o premature 70 M 213 jurisdiction 161 847 77 M 158 f 83 M 411 207 NY 291 limitations 154 155 limit jurisdictn, 157 425 not entered f 82 M 40C 258 collateral s 74 S 639 74 268 d74 318 unpaid stock 11 AC 275 281 pvo rata 146 34 264 beneficiary 8 74 S 649 554 432 363 302 meas dam 8 74 S 673 r 174 NY 196 71 618 75 254257269-60 75 262-3 30S 3 101 94 basis damage 65M 245 3 1 4 legis. pow'r 3 74S a 171 NY do 69 tax law 18 AC diatinction 99 M 782 7 534 322 amendment a 74 S 670 86 554 325 neg. evid. s 74 S 699 94 8 c 66M _ 341 notice claim 318 NY 146 329 right of way s 74 S 906 120 280 easement 60 M 455 public street 67 M 276 dedication 73 M 99 damages 184 324 105M 487 340 trust valid s 74 S 820 145 876 consideration 150 873 172 292 349 neg. wires 8 74 S 809 a 174 NY 520 ptligotion 200 NY 495 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m. modified; *, dismissed; n, note; c, criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; a, same case; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; 4. questioned N. 7. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division Vols. 69, 70 duty care 158 i 211 NT 214 571 438 exemption 353boardiDg car B 74 S 966 e 72r 183 J ury question 87 41 91 . 376 carrier neg, 59 M 414 356 extra compensation alOAO 440 death damages 74 S 75 107 74 S f 165 361 m lien 8 75 S a 174NY contract 128 do 172 lien attack 186 913 665 466 638 213 442 discretion 74S 988 133 217 448 bill partic. 74 S 1026 77 319 115 404 452 parol ev s 74 S 1061 f 105 497 distinction do 183 180 454 neg. damage 381 handwriting B 74 S I06U r 175 NY 36 389 em domain B 74 S 1019 f 69 , 620 remdrman 53M 137 limitation 124 298 392 credibility s 74 S 1083 129 656 direct verdict 79 M 271 85 M 408 400 civ service 8 75 S 122 a 172 NY 316 contingent fee 111 423 406 mandamus b74S a 173 NY f 69 95 rebate ell7 409 rebate «75S * 171 NY 1104 604 400 601 543 37 373 1009 872 413 defense B 74 S 114 practice 126 '339 limitation 146 569 420 compul. ref. B 74 S 1005 • 172 NY 269 423 substitution s 74 S 993 trustee 39 K 667 426 contract B 74 S 1050 * 171NY 678 433 salaries s 75 S 16 a 174 NY 521 71 492-493 435 new cause B 74 S 979 d 99 284 437 death dam. B 74 S 977 11 AC 67n 984 393 987 620 103 a 171 NY 277 509 truat 75 S a 173 NY 82 576 bill, partic. 70LRA intent e40M e 179 NY costs 38 CP gift deposit 194 NY 131 1 626 464 506 373 717 334 126 46 894 36 901 203 204 181d 999 445 131 406 405n 226n 3 74S 71 108 slOAC 14 AC auto use ILRANS degree care ILRANS 228n 17 AC 361 jury question ILEANS 229n 459 incompet'nt evidence s 74 S 981 a 174 NY 540 151 360 competency 142 115 462 requirement s 74S 1003 177 584 64 403 512 city magis- trate s75S a 171 NY repeal f 187NY 145 election 203 NT district court justices 146 360 mandamu3 i 149 291 474 probate 8 74 8 6 93 el03 jury trial 107 do 107 115 133 17AC 138n 17 AC for jury 137 141 81 M case 4 f 149 1002 374 62 53 76 874 914 141 171 546a8Bisned acct 8 75 S 31 f 80 627 549 mandamus 8 75 S 202 a 172 NY 90 136 670 St. surf. 205NY Sdi 560 negligence 8 76 S 46 a 174 NY 522 8 69 620 89 339 432 fact question 16A0 325n 563 dismisBal s76S 11 AC 105 184 394 decree 924 476 impeachmt s 74 S 995 12 AC 110nll6n 481 probate will s 74 S 1046 80 M 34 73 M 324 assistance i 85 M 658 subscriptions 87 M 583 f 89 M 648 487 compromise 8 74 S 1052 15 AC 88n 489 orig. min. s 74 S 1023 80 M 477 499 att'y client 74 S 976 f 43 M 139 502 referee s75S 229 s75S 116 126 127 45 M 16 AC 147 578 reasonable 3 75 S 101 54 M 621 by-lpws 130 132, f 133 no waiver 360 74 26 608 165 33 CP 164 66M arrears 137 8'. default f 137 8'. 582 alienation 8 75S 115 116 589 mandamus 6 1 8 dismissal s 74 S 1014 a 171 NY 688 * 173 NY 638 execution 8 114 440 6 1 9 trustee case 2 8 76 8 89 transfer tax case 9 8 76S r 172 NY 9 75S f69 110 modification f 110 affidavits 88 do 179 NY recount vote e 183 NY 278 617 355 366 19 192 278 113 104n 566 gifts 8 74 8 s75S 12 AC evidence 78 M assignment 103M: 570 new trial 741 48 357n 471 8 75 8 86 120 104 slOAC 12 AC extra allow. 46 M negligence SOM costs 135 f2 18AC 34 475 880 82 430 216n 68 600 153 527 31n 572 necessaries a 75 8 81 f 169 856 11 AC 87n Judgment 66M 613 subrogation 60 M 4 7 J parent obligatn. 203 NT 463 advance- remedy 153 294 not liable 179 858 574 crossg. neg a 75 S 171 a 174 NY 621 598 spec, perfm ance a 75 8 8! 85 160 604 jurisdiction 3 74 8 114 appeal do 114 121 146 172 174 opinions 128 106 706 711 228 636 269 362 674 296 240 232 1122 609 620 transfer tax case 10 3 75S * 171 NY new trial caae 28 s75S a 174 NY 69 appeal case 40 S75 8 * 171 NY 1129 662 1124 622 561 1122 691 VOL 70 bill particulars 8 74 8 1107 f 87 557 15 AC 181n 2 aecure costs a 74 8 1051 e 73 157 74 457 78 438 11 AC 304n 306 cause action 141 836 4 waiver corpn. a 74 S 1069 41 M 190 ultra vires 181 NY 66 5 truatee s75 8 * 172 NY 190 NY 83 39 M 41 M commissions 47 M 62 1 pleading case 6 s75S 1136 r 171 NY 675 606atty. client 3 74 8 1054 d57M 8 609 death dam case 1 a 74 S 499 11 AC 67n 6 I I contract case 2 s74 8 613 f69 611 6 I 5 larceny case 19 s74 8 a 171 NY execution case 21 s74 8 107 mandamus case 41 S76S a 172 NY eq. lien 36CP intent steal 133 6 1 6 relief case 8 3 75 8 r 174 NY 3 176 NY 91 1141 697 1124 466 1129 50 616 1130 266 595 392 6 1 7 costs stay case 4 a 74 8 1132 79 120 discovery 12 AC 332 I 33 trust s74S * 174 NY appeal 3 187NY 1032 625 531 494 107 281 504 156 565 I 2 pera. transato 3 74 S 1055 a 100 367 harmles error 120 233 20 AC s74S I 6 relief 3 74 8 d73 f 73 s 81 pleading 65M demurrer e92 288n 1095 1095 567 568 536 394 e93 289-290 405 566 600 151 621 734 146 122 127 162 do 171 68 M acct. suit for 58M 384 55M 399 8 M 659 e 11 AC 175 177n law remedy d 40 M 593 intent pleader d 112 860 joinder d 55M practice 60 M taw action 128 distinction 63M damages 63M injunction 64M dismissal 135 equitable ql57 171 cause of action q 157 41 82 M 624 26 negl. damages s 74 S 1079 73 251 fact question 392 434 667 194 197 292 131 40 729 78 d83 f s94 8 97 129 do 173 77 M revers. error a 189NY 668 40 commissioDS s74S 1088 74 395 authority 109 48 13 AC 323d not justified 143 451 not chargeable 143 452 50 discovery s 74 8 1093 18AC 196n 52 waiver s74S 39GP 95 119 48 M pleading e 110 168 10 AC averment 53M contract 54 M fomplaint c26 dl40 Imust plead 151 490 39 CP 286 proof waiver d 39 CP 292 prove complince 80 M 44 allegations t 168 755 80 M 45 56 ap prfmance 1062 37n 78 0750581 516 343 754 426o 58 440 766 880 17 581 s75S a 178 NY procedure 75 M adv. possession OlM 487 83 420 334 620 1 452 129 198 185 60 spl. findings s74S 1113 e 80 386 94 M 179 power court 114 802 judgt on merits 11 AC 105n 112 623 revers error 121 521 prox. cause do 135 330 direct judgment 135 883 special verdict 148 ^ 874 dismissal do 148 876 64 assessment s 74 S 1065 m 174 NY 123 69 reinsurance s 74 8 103S a 174 NY 541 180 NY 396 71 landlord s76 8 a 174 NY 65 411 73 husb. wife s 76 8 66 a 172 NY 652 ABBHEVIATIONS : a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, fallowed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, not* «. witicited ; 1, limited ; e, explained ; o, over, aled ; s, same case ; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, questioned Vol. 70 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division specific lien E 74S 1076 148 permissive 166 22 3 NY 55 72 225 82 contract fi76S eSS 91 M contract 150 145 489 426 void 738 90 by-laws e74S a 174 NY 81 retroactive 20 AO 1057 650 5 48r 178 95 sp. prfmance B 75 S 19 a 174 NY 636 9 226 encrochmts 50M 436 commissisons SO M 548 ftermisslTe 134 stoop 69 M 228 no cause 75M 5 mot recover 172 106 97 descriptive ■ 75S 101 188 title vested 142 363 166 907 gift absolute r 175 NY 139 equity suit 133 612 who pays pre- miums 139 888 presumption 139 890 not premature 139 891 before admissn. 139 892 legis. power 138 834 206.202 pleading 886 a 75 B 377 a 174 NY 539 12 AC 20n f 47M aeg. damages 116 317 do32a earner neg. 56M assumption d 131 evidence 142 admissible 20 AC 1 42 performance s7bS 110 119 170 f 173 waiver 115 39 CP 76 M 105 review s 75 S 16AC equities 120 set aside 74M I 1 request b76S 93 ellO f 47 M direct verdict 130 reversible 69M to jury 146 error court 158 391 1] lOln 785 262 90 357 697 96 83 633 804 493 1 1 4 requests « 75 S 93 ■ 175 NY 472 e 97 251 « 110 698 70 LRA 760 aitle fixtures 116 472 store fixtures 125 671 , ILEANS 1196n 66M 512 estoppel do 147 230 124 undertaking 8 74S 1116 BO M SO 127 compensa- tion 8 76 S 72 97 359 116 211 Stat, limitation 15 AC 285 134 insurance 8 75 S 150 157 399 575 829 .153 133 285 o4 M 111 show tender 127 AD 527 allegations 127 AD 627 verdict 131 621 ordinary care 158 4 1 55 intervention 267 271 601 479 513 e75S 174 NY remedies 16 AC estoppel f 177 1 62 partnership 166n r 74 S 78 I 66 bar s75S slOAC a 176NY 183Ny 87 fraud e93 e96 38 M demurrer 176 NY discharge 114 reversal 17AC no waiver 132 pleading 137 1072 459 40 410 501 27] 621 322 89 129 317 777 334 175n 206 Gonting. fee B 76 S 389 a 174 NY 546 2 1 8 dumpg £rd 76 S 342 a 173 NY 612 nuisance 122 373 224material- man s 75 S 299 a 174 NY 635 recovery 183 444 232 sub. contctr 8 75 S 337 a 174 NY 53' 238 limitation s 73 S 1105 a 177 NY 540 242 waiver s 75 S 401 f 164 28 252 surplusage s 75 S 4I3 129 398 a 171 NY 302 256 no title s 75S 158 405 822 260 jurisdiction s 74 S 901 126 102M 450 369 263 urisdSction s 76 S 1030 80 M 467 298 constitut'l B 75 S 34U f84 90 303 certificat'n s 76 S 420 s 10 AC 449 deposition 63 M 53 306 in county s 75S 260 184 813 32 1 remedy 8 75 S 272 55M 472 326 compliance s 75 S 246 113 585 329 discovery s 75 S 268 168 673 41 M 438 81 M 363 incrimination 11 AC 259n 39CP 37n privilege 127 19A0 complaint 140 664 137 insufficient 148 allegations 102M 438 credibility 47 50 M 1042 634 443 corp stock 8 75 S s94 s 183 NY title Testing 111 life income 111 37CP accumulations 428 612 428 427 849 23 823 362n 267 surety s75S a 178 NY 314 1 72 waiver s 76 S 100 proof admiBsns 87 493 1 79 tender s75S 92 331 334 1 86 trade mark s 76 S 267 13 AC 431n 192 fr'd deed 8 76 S 397 s 172 NY 647 a 176 NY 495 f 70 613 burden proof 78 395 82 341 incompt. ev. 82 knowledge 82 good faith 102M 340 400 407 580 271 justification 8 74 S 835 39 M 13 273 waiver s 74 S 902 11 AC 14n 20 AO 286n 70 LRA 118 inadmissible 535 336 master nee s 76 S 49 r 174 NY 386 80 466 362 fact question s 75 S 173 52M 347 370 executors s 75 S 24 a 171 NY 691 8 383fact question s 75 S a 176 NY 69 105 liability 144 216 487 153 640 title 197 576 666 373 103M 286 title s74S 91 alienage do 109 46 M 14 AC retroactive 61 M 551 •967 314 747 612 427 485 29 1 discontinue s 76 S 243 f 70 621 ad'l allowce. 124 504 139 119 294 designation 395 adv. 876 S * 176 NY s 172 NY 17AC constructive poss 109 244 titlejprescriptn. 61 M 486 401 limitation s75S dSO 170 405 assault 8 76S r 175 NY 8 75S 120 495 457 427 grade comr s 75 S 516 r 176 NY 420 435 pleading b75S s79 141 f 166 44 M 8 10 AC compliance 119 f 91 M 39 CP cond. precedt 119 674 91 M 484 646 457 209 219 420 123 dividend 130 209 NY conclusive 151 do 177 estoppel 151 12; 334 469 172 530 173 476 life insur. s74S 1108 r 175 NY 96 f 93 607 481 tax rent s 74 S 961 a 177 NY 23 489 considerat n s 75 S 106 81 44 accord 87 588 495 death dam 8 75 S 136 r 174 NY 1 505 pers. injury s 71 S 226 a 173 NY 631 ccntrib. neglig'e 142 307 51 I undisclosed principal 8 76S 140 a 174 NY s 88 384 subrogation e 101 422 68LRA524n536n enforcement 77 M 630 548 harmls erro s 76 S 532 11 AC 36n 551 discovery B 76 S 681 d 62 M 641 13 AC 456n 467n inspect book 390P 555source knowl 700 931 s 75S 131 710 454 485 165 12 314 373 432 14n 523 waiver s7SS 8 10 AC 11 AC proof U AC 338-4ln 162 586 admissible 166 213 NY 639 332 529 profits s75S 12 AC 153 proximate 104M 538 bonds b76S a 174 NY damage 197NY 261 296n 283 loss 586 417 515 142 674 579 284 209' "duly" 543 UBe water s 76 S 1100 a 175 NY '469 tax easemt* ,..116 730 53 ' remote conting. 05M 219 560 repairs 8 76S f76 83 87 contrib neg 131 recovery ICPNS personal duty f 170 208 200 NT 91 non-delegable do 170 210 not inheritance 224NY 439 567 constitutl. s 75 S 589 e 78 466 8 10 AC 466 waiver 12 AC 74n procedure 75 M 83 92 M 88 569 sale stock s 75 S 60 16AC 183 evade liability 155 514 576 annulment s 75 S 62: 8 10 AC 473 579 distribution 60 M discoverji case 3 8 76S a 174 NY 80 18AC contempt 156 626 78 549 166 197n 780 6 1 7 harmless er case 8 s 75 S 1123 s 171 NY 678 r 174 NY 832 618 passive trust case 17 s 76 S 1133 d8S 30 mandamus Case 19 b75S 175 NY, counsel fees 114 case 17 invalid s75S 148 764 410 469 779 1128 23S 620 new trial case 1 8 75 S 1121 a 174 NY 647 s73S a 172 NY 87 interest 116 mutual 172 563 371 140 4b debts 162 598 will gift 8 75 S 702 a 173 NY 618 606 requests s 76 S 683 s 92 620 73 173 prox cause e 78 389 s 78 635 charge error 80 39 83 236 93 240 104 627 613 dismissal case 3 b75S s 172 NY case 4 acct stated s75S 14 AC 1126 647 21 373 n 6 1 4 contempt s 74 S 1089 8 74 62f unauthorized 135 48 6 1 SconsideratioD case 1 s 74 S 1049 90 177 621 countrclaim 1 8a6S a 775 NY julgment case 13 S176S a 175 NY f 70 usury case 21 b75S r 175 NY 622 appeal case 9 8 75 8 a 176 NY assmd risk case 12 b75S r 173 NY aside deed case 10 s75S d 202 NY 623 decree case 7 875S. a 173NY exemptions case 9 8 75S r 171 NY dlBmissal case 16 s76S * 172 NY mandamus case 20 3 76S a 175 NY insurance case 22 8 75 S a 178 NY 623 appeal case 23 s75S s 176 NY 624 appeal case 12 s76S a 175 NY 1126 229 103 473 621 1120 264 1122 491 1124 466 1131 121 1122 616 1134 266 1122 603 1113 483 1129 697 1132 649 1122 487 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; {, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note c, criticised: I. limited: e, explained; o, overruled: s. same case: do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q, questioned N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division Vol. 71 , VOL 71 I decree a 75 S 6S7 93 114 writ assistance 95 194 iury question 17 AC 142n right appeal 126 20 ' 1 4 death dam 8 75 S 718 II AC 69n res ipsa loquitur d 106 . 465 oeg landlord 129 88 2 1 sale power s 75 S 567 * 176 NY 553 a 179 NY 555 28 harmless error a 75 S 625 s 11 AC 13 11 AC 31n waiver 20 AC 281n 32 wife's nee. 8 75 S 726 73 67-8 79 480 living apart 11 AC 90nloo 35 mistake b7S S 8 10 AC 619 481 37 direct reply s 75 S 678 138 468 reply order 152 709 47 labor law B 75 S 610 76 299 e99 51 master neg. d 134 308 62 acct. stated s 75 S 740 60 M 233 compet. ev. do 129 190 77 auctioneer s 75 S 615 e 40 M 230 surety liable 109 173 9 1 trust income 8 75 S 526 a 173 NY 621 40 M 615 46 M 637 47 M 563 principal 45 M 473 dxvidends 111 778 subrogation 123 126 principal trust 181 473 181 564 apportionment 106M 380 102 law action s 75 S 588 171 797 1 04 trust foreign s 75 S 728 13 AC 191n 1 1 0-custm proof s 75 S 600 149 751 I 1 6 gift class e 75 S 674 f 78 59 co-tenants 115 728 I 1 8 bribery 3 75 S 630 a 172 NY 643 procedure 105 148 improper remark do xu7 ffco5 prokib, writ 112 427 civil code 139 492 amendment 137 764 accomplice 156 625 indictment 84 M 102 jurisdiction 84 M 103 criminal case 225NY 208 1 43 damages 3 75 S 695 r 175 NY 353 s 176 NY 560 encroachment s 120 172 mandamus 138 239 f 241 1 48 notice lien 8 75 S 531 r 175 NY 492 186 NY 466 e85 510 e 89 9 IC e95 74 e 96 364 100 442 106 406 107 281 120 449 162 54 60 do 163 61 e 40 M 570 defect lien 137 854 compliance 122 471 95 74-75 pers ]udgmenL 96 36-1 150 designation s 75 S 654 a 173 NY 617 42 M 647 authority d 181 659 1 52 pers inj ury 3 75 S 540 a 173 NY 626 155 negligence 5 75 S 537 1 16 291 prox. cause 161 213 I GOmisdemeanor 8 76 S 591 a 171 NY 423 1 68 indorser s 75 S 561 a 176 NY 593 8 176 NY 613 1 7 1 client liable B 75 S 534 48 M 428 reference 53M 179 jurisdiction 53M 180 17 AC 57, 60n CO relief by motion 130 610 not apply 39CP 60 no jurisdiction 39CP 61 without power 164 137 1 73 contrib neg. s 75 S 714 89 391 65 LRA 132 iO AC 241n fact question 40 M 105 139 f -161 justified 168 180 liquid dam 8 75 S r 174 NY 161 f 161 e38M 39 M f 39M construed 97 M 203 14 295 867 472 544 492 655 657 547 351 645 353 f71 611 f 47 M 228 illegal tax 73 M 501 234 commissions 75 S 698 a 175 NY 463 235 jurisdiction s 75S 608 40 LRA 545i, 238 demand s75S 813 s 89 543 94 387 8 41 M 149 corporate asset 103 98 100 244 receiver s 75 S 899 f71 611 284 earner oeg. 75 S 909 17 AC 214n 255 (.reference 1 85 compet. ev. a 75 S 688 e 90 232 justifiable 17AC 187n 192u 195 trust fund s 75 S 675 73 292 1 99 ptmit. dam s 76 S 67Q eI78NV 360 slOAC 462 12A C 79n 80n 66 LRA 624 transfers d 118 15 90 M 674 677 90 M 678 unreasonable G7M 82 no contract d 165 438 204 exceptions 8 75 S f 71 dg8 judgment 134 reference 99 M 2 1 charge error 822 612 75 d f71 wai^-er 117 dismissal 38 CP notice nee. 63M 379 257 construction 706 611 269 546 667 546 139 620 188 75 S H 174 NY 80 102 193 NY burden proof 12 AC 94 resipsa 1. 117 785 2 1 9 compromise s 75 S 542 81 44 specif, prfmce 84 608 probate will 100 273 impress trust 59 M 89 222 hypth ques s 75 S 597 84 222 11 AC 46n s 183 NY 1 master neg 35CP 117 incompetent 183 799 227 assessment 8 75 S 576 1123 476 25i' 847 87' 128 3 75 S lis int award 120- re-entry 144 754 beneficial int. 144 755 272 accoulitme s 75 S 750 * 172 NY 608 f 87 632 278 receiver s 75 S 817 e 99 258 178 648 d 178 644 motion f 133 919 unauthorized 135 48 dispossession no rent 65M abrogated 93 M distinction 94 M prior right 1 174 489 305 284 legis. power 3 75 S 838 80 728 constitutional 138 le 288 negl. dam 913 371 23 238 125n S75S 3 85 5 M 66 LRA remedy 107 263 264 contrib. negl. 109 728 illegal evidence ellO 50 negligence ev. 122 588, 590 safe place 136 472 "on" meaning 155 815 399 arson s75S 84 demurrer 168 551 30 1 damages 8 75 S 828 * 177 NY 539 16-AC 175n 183n 137 713 915 171 489 r3asonabIe time 120 837 law question 130 604 error court 135 554 intention 153 794 wrong rule 171 489 309 prox. cause f 75 8 568 175 NY 292 3 1 3 anl report 3 75 S 967 84 137 3 1 6 revocation s75S ■ 1102 110 248 right manager 189 NY 185 injunction 90 M 476 320 trade mark s 75 S 964 a 171 NY 679 13 AC 432n 324 corroboratn 3 75 S 945 a 171 NY 669 106 518 328 wages 3 75 S 925 a 173 NY 621 181 NY 26.S 330 affidavit 95 S 1099 71 140 81 468 do 108 359 45 M 271 54M 79 relief merits 180 842 340 bill partic 3 75 S 1090 77 319 343 construction 9 76S 5 f 161 843 46 M 212 will construe 58 M 99 35 1 preference 375 S 976 71 612 3 72 619 74 309 96 165 do 98 109 e 98 147 12U . 383 34 CP 102 discretion 541V 84 permission 138 476 366 contribution s 73 S 953 156 509 377nom damag 8 7SS 1116 a 175 NY 489 39 1 denial 8 75 S 947 .82 101 pldg rights 62 M 254 demand 98 II 249 395 license s 75 S 1092 a 173 NY 626 950 637 402 delivery 8 75 S 960 94 112 inference 135 51 413 bill partic. s 75 S 902 88 184 45 jii 205 ^ns. definite ' 15 288 96 M 51 pleading 55 M . 42, 428 complaint 156 382 41 5 prepond ev 8 75 S 842 42 M 164 discretion 113 48 50 M 597 trial court £ 161 451 4 1 8 performance 9 75 S 90^ 54 M 102 profits ev t 121 214 estoppel 132 398 enforcement 156 12J 42 1 pleading s 75 S 903 48 M 171 58M 472 election 129 398, 668 test joinder 71 M 583 422 sheriff 8 75 S 794 a 171 NY 529 f 71 622 custody books 41 M 118 pwr.common council 131 37 no expulsion 196NY 237 432 services 3 75' S 856 85 587 119 30 atty. client 18AC 243n employment 93 M 614 436 use highway s 75 S 723 45 M 20 infringemt. 119 904 concurrence disap. 196NY 485 439 prox, cause 3 75 S 866 r 174 NY 47 79 125 f 104 605 ABBREyiATIONS: a, afiirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, criticised: 1, limited: e. explained; o, overruled; s. same case; do, dissenting opinion 131 201, 202 165 767 liability f 159 55 f 165 767 219 NY 65 452 highway s 75 S 824 a 177 NY 550 construction 113 604 605 459 spl. damages s 75S 861 18 AC 182n 461 transfer tax s 75 S 835 a 172 NY 617 49 533 50 M 331 55 M 477 f 87 M 521 tax succession 79 M 657 466fact question 8 75 S 755 80 127 83 91 not negligence 149 821 negligence 120 480 infer neglig 130 443 468 fee simple title s 75 S 876 do 151 126 forfeiture 311 NY 517 472 exr. liable s 75 S 753 90 M 162 474 punit. dam 75 S 893 76 325 12AC77n82n84 r r rules 80 478 96 596 13 AC 64n 479exemptions 9 75 S 738 a 171 NY 683 special contract do 107 218 construction 17 AC 222 203 NY 386 apportionment 85 M 608 or otherwise 165 201 483 ballots s 75 S 732 40 M 540 488 'revocation s76S 2 a 175 NY 524 f 212 NY 301 s 71 622 13 AC 253a 13 AC 2S5n 261n injunction 217 NY 109 49 1 salaries 8 75 S 904 a 171 NY 690 494 construction B 75 S 863 123 788 10 AC 467n 46 M 243 14 AC 9b defence neg. 50 M 120 modified; *, dismissed; n, note; ^ : D. DaralleS case; q. Questioned. Vols. 71, 72 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division penalty 50 M St. surf, 205NY 5S3 498 prohibited s 75 S 747 174 586 509 annulment B 75 S 878 r 174 NY 467 P 78 577 178 NY 68 fraud 10 AC 473n 476n 521 discretion 6 75 S 1097 116 91 522 obj excepn B 75 S 859 11 AC 45n 101 42 526 merger B ?5 S 1021 57 M 235 breacli covenant 138 585 534 irregularity 8 75 S 923 51 M 93 '■tto appeal 18AU 364 537burden deft, s 75 S 846 171 750 538 liability s 75 S 126 f 166 171 185 63M 83 M may terminate 92 M 179 assignee 235NY 195 540 strike out B 75 S 887 106 689 544 water co. b76S 11 r 176 NY 239 61 LRA 48n ■uot exceissive do 148 561 559 reference 841 556 686 928 296 649 44 value interest 75 M 64 error appraiser 95 M 460 584 ccnstutl a 76 S 205 a 173 NY 103 s 72 616 59 1 no jurisdctn. s 76 S 301 85 M 104 595 amendment 369 132 237 126 132 316 86 373 296n SOOn 347 245 s76S 67 M 138 costs d79 98 131 12AC 19A0 19 AC 18M ICPNS court's powfer 67 M 237 598 vested int. s 76 S 201 73 M 198 78 M 328 mere legacy 76 M 426 contingent 86 M 624 vesting f 88 M 386 802 value stock s 76 S 186 111 233 92 M 644 606 transfer tax s 76 S 222 a 172 NY 608 accounting do 181 90 ie7 s76S r 175 NY trademarlc case 14 s76S r 176 NY 6 1 7 appeal case 8 s76S * 172 NY appeal case 9 s 76 S a 179 NY construction case 19 9 76S m 172 NY appeal case 25 s76S a 174 NY appeal case 34 s76S s 172 NY a 176 NY 1032 385 1009 28 1032 606 .017 581 1009 488 ld08 542 1014 646 476 8 76S 77 dH9 accounting 91 95 178 691 125 563 neg. damag 8 76 S . 131 84 696 16 AC . 177n bill particulars 142 71 56M 433 566 intention B 76 S 197 83 208 210 innuendo 114 182 recovery ■ 160 694 149 238 for jury 160 694 581 transfertax s 76 S 220 a 172 NY 616 taxation 1 193 NY 663 6 1 2 parol ev. cases s75S 1127 case 4 s76S lOlf r 176 NY in? amendment case 6 s76S 648 e84 468 20 AC 7ll power court 150 41 ISO 402 6 1 3 culm allow. case 1 8 76S 653 f 110 86 V libel damages case 2 s76S 536 t71 414 damages 92 143 109 437 place of tria el09 582 f45M 239 6 1 4 submission case 2 75 S 846 8 612 46 M 120 6 1 6 covenant case 4 s 76 S 1081 m 177 NY 218 amendment case 6 s 76 S 1036 89 77 sales 6 1 8 damages case 8 8 76 S 1029 a 173 NY 623 82 141 102 658 increased costs 164 133 6 1 8 appeal case 18 8 76S a 175 NY waiver case 20 s75S 1016 480 737 375-6 620 appeal case 2 s76S t71 appeal case 3 76 S r 172 NY appeal case 11 s76S a 173 NY 621 appeal case 7 8 76 3 a 176 NY foreclosure case 22 s76S * 171 NY 3 173 NY 1015 620 1027 305 1011 630 1018 496 1010 691 340 622 reargument case 4 s 76 S 1028 a 175 NY 624 case 16 s 76 S 1027 a 171 NY 681 habeas corpus case 17 s 76 S 1027 a 171 NY- 681 VOL. 72 I inadeq. dam. s 76 S 256 e 75 477 130 388 II AC 64d fl2AC 17 9 confessions 8 76 S 276 8 96 33 13 AC 292n 1 5 foreclosure 8 76 S 106 a 171 NY 682 9 negligence s 76 S 262 109 85 23 pers injury 8 76 S 167 74 196 83 332 e 333 38 M 376 contrib. neg. 51 M 641 26 court's power 128 145 263 346 206n S76S 98 107 15 AC 17AC 7 1 fiduciary s76S 91 127-128 93 328 valid trust 124 accounting 155 418 176 76 damages 9 73 S s 76 S 116 79 sum. pr s76S 148 82 pleading 3 76S 84 88 106 16 M 49 M 55M complaint 156 96 M more 184 139 12.? 449 IIT 60 284 439 184 538 205 322 43 382 51 .n 574 141 n b76S 8 171 NY a 174 NY 166 lien 324 687 548 613 30 88 35 transfer e 76'S 53M phys. delivery 172 536 103M ■ 453 38 insurance s 76 S 143 a 173 NY 455 estoppel d 110 695 directois 110 do 698 699 insolvent corpn 111 194 court presence do 138 778 mandatory 183 18 45 certiorari s 76 S 219 110 341 U9 714 47 neg mastei B 76 S 296 - -,75 assume nsks 123 661 safe place 139 754 55 pool selling 8 76S penalty 73 75 not party 120 783 680 450 664 60 indemnity s 76 S 336 a 177 NY 651 f 87 500 503 Teeularity 102 404 read into 110 679 construction 73 M 210 not proved 214 NY 454 surety ■" M 460 67 constitutionl s 76 S 293 85 392 394 85 construction s 76S 100 75M 444 presumption 90 M 262 88 contempt 9 76 S 96 96 409 97 . 492 67M 99 do 101 QOpresent check s 76 S 211 138 808 false pretence - ■ " 59d 62n 388 418 454 637 26 420 386 20 AC 20 AC 95 rent 8 76S a 175 NY prohibit 158 agency d 98 M 177 491 706 268 76 8 e76 damages 76 82 repairs 43 M do 99 47 M meas. damages 16AC 466 1 80 interpleader s 76 S 448 48 M 627 204NY 287 substitution do 132 518 moving papers do 146 617 1 8 1 boarding car 1 03 guardian 3 76 S - 194 a 172 NY 660 I 1 3 expert ser vices 9 76 S 137 f 72 618 14 AC 3690 I 16 death neglig s 76 S 347 d 156 159 company liable 171 775 121 implied war' ronty 9 76 S 340 14 AC 285n bill particulars f76M 4 confirmed 178 474 1 28 cancel jud 9 76 S 332 15 AC 121n debt bar 17AC 332n 132 court power s 76S 269 133 490 owner fee t 161 175 147 ev cbjns. s76S 486 d 79 133 d 12 AC 374 amendt. costs 131 80 12 AC 370n terms costs ICPNS 245 amendment 67 M 238 1 52 damageti s 76 S 412 86 352 162 negligence s 76 S 306 142 403 175 116 1 66 disclosure 8 76 S 361 e 106 620 coiroboration 157 799 186 225 lOOM 438 176 demurrer 76 S 91 carrier nej 59 M l84Ubel s76S 78 competent 154 int. trt. f 160 411 376 414 429 82 493 feasors 193 1 96 sub cont'r 8 76 S '438 s 84 492 9 179 NY 5lS conclusive 133 664 147 144 2 1 I commission 3 76 S 61 a 172 NY 67 16AC 417n 220 certificate r76 S 126 96 54 notice claim 12 AC ^320n eond precedent 66 M 189 228 fact question s 76 S 171 79 . 173 90 369 108 ■, 76 error evideni^ II AC ■36n 233 uncdnst'l 8 76 S 203 1 72 629 236 priv agent 9 76 S 174 49 M 630 241 application s 76 S 215 96 M 277 248 diversion water S76S 167 8 72 629 67 LRA 377n 260 assessment 9 76 S 49 III 764 112 139 114 331 276 value stock s 76 S 36 c84 431 parties 93 163 28 1 proper ev s 76 S 57 a 175 NY 517 38 M 184 criminal liable 78 M 4 286 jurisdiction 3 76S 37 , s 72 621 motn. to vagate 76 M 376 290 supl. ans s 76 S 40 8 85 226 276 128 521 discretion 136 497 294 r.r. commr. 8 76 S 69 r 171 NY 689 e 45 M 521 304 right o way B 76S 46 19A0 68n 308 unconstitutl 2 1 3 ctrclaim 8 76S 88 160 reversal 144 191 281 448 293 2 1 7 att'y client 8 76 S 164 s 94 504 conversion do 184 186 52M 212 213 s76S 102 70 LRA 111 108 212 83 373 3 1 7 election 76 S 87 loss rentals 30 AO 99n 20 AC 102n 321 review 76 S 85 s U AC 50 U AC62n63n71 331 preference 76 S 92 496 a 177 NY 68 77 278 2 AC 243 ABBRHVIATIONS: a, aflirmed; d, distinguished; t, tollowed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, not*; e, criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; b, same case; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q, questioned N. T. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division Vols. 72, 73 Icnowlg imputed 130 628 34 1 assessment s 76 S 617 72 365 356 oonnrmation 66M 500 357 fires dam. 8 76 S 515 8 11 AC 76 360 prescription 8 77 S 282 75 187' 8 92 97 8 105 633 59 LEA 838 845 jury question 199 NT 220 363 neg. notice s 76 S 492 a 179NY 536 perjury 372 s 76 S " 606 a 172 NY 165 166 corroboration 110 2 394 condemnatn s 76 S 28 * 173 NY 640 em. domain s 116 798 799 appeal s 189NY 36 award s 123 710 130 352 marjiet value 130 .359 92 M 422 present value 151 56 438 incomp. ev s 76 8 671 83 87 440 improper ev s 76 S 533 11 AC 46n 449 consent s 76 S 552 a 175 NY 478 454neg. reversal 3 76 S 24 do 125 898 for jury 153 692 t 211 NY 231 456 res fpsa log. s 76 S 578 127 245 459 counsel s 76 S 540 improp statmt 371 94 30 15 AC 99 16 AC 374n new trial 126 480 summing up 134 917 error 84 M 653 654 / 468 neg damage 3 76 S • 548 3 12 AC 87 94 contrib. neglig. 137 50 for jury do 176 438 474 receiver 8 76 S 576 8 74 620 527 evidence s 76 S 600 155 449 532 assignment s 76 S 625 173 N Y 922 concnrrence np'« TOM 579 joinder f 97 M 317 jointly act 102M 298, 299 539 chat mtge. 3 76 S 647 94 124 parties 155 727 compliance 3 76S express 85 s93 easement 113 docks 98 M 404 oonaenmatn 8 76 S 958 476 nmsance a 177 NY 548 3 76 S 620 88 2041 a 177 NY 547 e 41 M 608 njunetion 483 pers. injury 253 3 76 S 604 rights 27 St. r. 98 JI 715 4 1 6 commissions B 75 S 994 72 597 S5 62 d 102 347 76 M 596 424 impeachmt s76S r 175 NY 8 72 40 M fill AC 18AC 20 448 455 621 37 450d 429 reference fl75S 1016 -a 82 412 134 7^1 evidence 112 282 707 receiver 53M 16 434 master neg 8 76 S 565 * 172 NY 605 88 75 8 11 AC 103 improper judgt 104 nonsuit 116 56M dismissal 125 162 direct verdict 67 M 403 s 76 S 173 493 loans 8 76S 41 M dividends 16AC 10 843 600 266 3 84 595 bill particulars 142 71 15 AC 177n 56M 433 485 withdraw juror s76S £ 8 11 AC 487 upon facts 558 479 36n 496 transfers 8 76 S 777 * 178 NY 593 95 258 extension st r.r. 106 243 forfeiture 103M 51 505 constitut'l s 76 S 631 80 406 s97 86 12 AC 321n duty neglig. 112 85 reasonable opportunity 86 M 501 remedy 90 M 462 99 conversion 126 184 943 547 reformation 3 75 S 1031 a 176 NY 480 finding 184 256 55 1 contract 530 64 378 779 707 555 instructions s 75 S 1088 d 93 382 559 assault 75 S sll AC 992 18 562 contract s76S r 173 NY entirety 66M 561 426 866 565 books ev 3 76 S 605 80 119 admissible 5 M 394 cond. precedent f 87 M 190 prf. 790 49f 5fi7 burden s76S 156 mistake d 177 764 weight of ev, f 181 400 575 sup. pro. 8 76 S 559 11 AC 361n 578 inadeq dam s 76 S 528 11 AC 64n 582 injunction s 74 S 388 8 76 S 1016 * 172 NY 644 1 179 NY 556 587 compliance 76 S 283 162 586 589 counterclm. s 76 S 573 139 745 590ev neglignce s 76 S 574 168 471 625 sale 593 oysters own- s 76 S ers la 173 NY s 76 S 539 517 409 595 commissions s 76 S 556 1 107 485 126 737 terminate 179 3 598 meas. dam B 76 S 535 49 M 519 druggist neg 16AC. 27ln274n jurisdiction 122 384 60 I sureties S76S do 110 48 M not barred 141 258 165 71 908 6 1 5 contempt case 2 s76S a 173 NY mandamus case 3 3 76S a 173 NY mandamus case 4 s76S a 173 NY mandamus case 5 s76S a 173 NY 1026 5S9 1026 1026 587 1026 589 6 1 7 appeal s76S * 172 NY 102 604 618 pers. injury case 3 s 76 S 123 a 176 NY 590 6 1 9 penalties case 1 s 76 S 1022 a 173 NY 622 3 180 NY 5 91 91-93 cross appeals 95 470 s 40 M 31n contrib. neg. case 2 76 S r 173 NY appeal case 11 s76 S a 174 NY appeal case 12 s76S a 172 NY 1029 327 1008 544 1017 655 620 appeal case 22 3 76S 72 appeal case 24 a76S s 175 NY appeal case 28 a 196 US s76 S *171 NY 1009 289n 1019 4S1 68 1037 690 623 r. s76S s40M r. corpn 584 287 278 628 appeal case 3 76 S a 174 NY appeal case 4 s76S a 176 NY 1010 606 1008 97 629 appeal case 6 8 76S a 172 NY , , ins. Feverable co.se 20 108 3 76S appeal case 21 76 S a 175 NY appeal caiie 25 _76S r 172NY 629 appeal case 29 3 76 S r 172 NY a 188 US 1011 620 107 1012 1013 494 1008 421 1026 176 691 630 appeal case 1 s76S a 171 NY a 171 NY appeal case 2 8 76S a 171 NY 694 695 appeal case 3 3 76 S ii 175 NY 1010 563 492 631 appeal case 6 3 76S 3 172 NY appeal case 14 s76S a 178 NY 1015 601 1033 566 632 allowance case 2 8 76S 78 appeal case 7 3 res a 171NY appeal case 16 s76S 8 172 NY a 176 NY 1012 568 1013 685 1008 603 106 633 appeal case 18 3 76 S 1009 a 174 NY 212 VOL. 73 5 feloniously s 76 S 65 95 M 112 I I jurisdiction s76S 105 355 226 376 20 bond 8 76S 6 76 material 68 M const, liberally 72 M 553 22 infringemt. s 76 S 420 119 907 easement 73 M 66 burd. defendant 73 M 70 29 cond, precdf 3 76 S 406 119 191 limitation 56M 372 34 steam neglig 3 76 S 321 74 599 due care 134 830 38 counterclaim right salary 223NY 44 89 special term s76S 129 concliisive f 166 82 M removal 160 requirement lOlM 328 268 541 688 15 s76S 76 41 arrest s76S 111 181 46 assault 3 76S r 179 NY 79 12 AC barge 127 incompetent 159 54 tax deed s76S a 173 NY 125 55M 64M 60 wife's nee. 8 76S r 176 NY 85 sll AC 66M 37] 519 425 627 117 477 130 397 288 826 580 624 162 431 590 390 75 174 85 614 69 co-respondnt 8 76 S 628 8 11 AC 73 HI 248 251 252 77 M 344 answers 77 M 346 75 sup. pro tax 109 devise s 76 S 664 slOO 116 revers. error 121 271 1 12 counterclm. s 76S 402 124 577 I 1 4 default s 76 S 121 567 389 1 20 labor law s 76 S 396 a 177 NY 145 65 LBA 59 62 e 98 441 1 29 death dam. 8 76 S 344 100 . 399 assume risk 121 896 134 rev s 77 S 71 M 835 100 1 37 civil ( tempt 5 77S 147 not justify f 177 139 verdict s76S 3 11 AC 132 395 99 872 117 747 391 s76S f73 91 jurisdiction 161 distinction 96 M 160 S 775 615 269 562 878 78 receiving stol en goods s 76 S 630 a 175 NY 164 62 LEA 271n 8 1 contract s 76 S 224 73 M 511 I 43 party 9 76 S el 06 notice 35 CP 51 54n committee 114 466 guardian notice 35CP 51 73 M 74 claim vs. lunatic 19AC 77ii not party 137 346 I45friy pleads, s 76 S 771 93 185 claim vs. lunatic 19A0 84 1 47 liquid, dam s 76 S 827 a 175 NY 518 69 M 5S4 construction 69 M 289 contract binds 149 recovery 149 forfeiture do 185 legal rights 186 not penalty 106M precluded 106M 275 103 393 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, disUnguished; f. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; •.dismissed; n. not«- c. criticised; 1, limited; e. explained; o. overruled; s. same case; do, dissentinz opinion; p, parallel case; q, questioned Vol 73 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division' I50ans. demurr. s 76 S 754I 138 439 relief spl. term 149 266 I 56 secure, costs b76 S 669 75 447 e448 bankruptcy II AC 304e 158 amendment s 76 S 808 187NY 268 118 83 38 CP 6, 16 19AC 448 451n amend parties 19A0 307n I 64jury question s 76 S 7Si 78 104 burden proof 80 139^1 12 AC 394 395, e396 presume neg lis 567 carrier neg. 53M 507 burden plaintiff 228 US 241 \ 70 charge erroi B 76 S 772 80 83 236 104 627 measure damage II AC 63n 54n I 74 Sunday tria e 76 S 728 105 45 jurisdiction 149 795 e 150 114 f 150 115 power court 160 116 conflicting 205 NY 49 1 78 inspection by-laws s 76 S 730 f .75 . 567 discretion 117 79 183 voidable s 74 S 748 f 163 635 I 185 trial court B 76S 690 136 381 200.perB injury s 76 S 758 50 M 5g2 res ipsa loquitur 74 316 82 490 12 AC- 391n rebuttal f 158 425 reasonable care 158 452 207 certificate 8 76 S 821 r 173 NY 67 2l3construction s 76 S 861 60 M 168 counterclaim f 171 853 220 waiver B 76 S 725 a 176 NY 520 224 counterclm, 76S 802 179 741 230 injunction B 76 S 749 f 73 626 232 civ service s 76 S 67S d 73 .239-240 DQandamus 187 NY e88 586 40M 430 borough's lists 68 M 520 237 mandamus 8 76 S 682 f 73 626 error objctn. 51 M 76 error court f 168 65 239boro'hs lists s 76 S 683 ^8 M 520 240 represent- active capacity fl 76 S 692 s 79 551 552 554 84 524 f 90 M 51 -'as' use 13 AC 197n 204 construction 112 831 amendment :«CP 21 19A0 44711 448n amend parties 19A0 307n description 70 M 239 omission "as" £ 79 M 432 245 good title ? 76 S 743 16AC 135-6n burden proof 23 89' UM 236 by review 104M title 106M 245 249 charge s 76 S 832 a 175 NY 602 78 420 contrib. negl. 89 13 pleading 12 AC 24n admissible 20 AC 172d 258 master neg. s 76 S 657 79 7 89 345 65 LEA 843n 95 237 jury question 120 649 infant neg. 85 598 95 237 l05 363 degree care 50 M 176 liability 73 M 520 i 153 210 proprietor liable 153 214 262 contempt 8 76S 813 77 16 f 177 830 notice 12 AC 17?n 184 265 carrier 3 76 S 838 a 175 NY 409 petit larceny 128 532 283 trust e 76 S 676 a 173 NY 444 289 trust 8 76S a 173 NY 707 631 293 trustee 8 76 S 721 r 176 NY 589 s 187 NY 316 s 103 40 300 trustee s 76 S 851 a 173 NY 480 305 pera injury s 76 S 684 * 172 NY 599 iS: 448 [weight of ev. 'do 103 321 f 107 263 107 369 54M 318 17AC 202n 208 new trial 70 M 382 verdict stands 83 M 239 set aside 98 M 60 99M 677 3 1 2 paving s 76 S 796 r 173 NY 474 3 1 6 death dam. s 76 S 755 llAC 57-8n 69n negligence d 172 254 reversal t 175 881 319b partic a 76 S 671 77 319 80 166 e 101 45 172 105 311 109 423 116 134 f 143 388 150 124 157 363 159 581 166 808 53M 288 62 M 265 65M 520 556 34 CP 4 1 CPNS 54 conversion 62 M 459 disclosure 76M 10 325 inher. tax s77S 4 a 172NY 649 transfer tax 155 232 329 damages a 76S 716 84 521 13 AC 202 55M 226 335 pleading s 76 S 68? 84 10' 89 92 do 103 282 113 113 16 AC 202n 339 surrog. pwr s 76 S 865 81 226 105 602, 613 prohib. writ 168 557 223NY 254 habeas corpus 168 557 by appeal 179 537 350 dam. int s 76 S 745 II AC 72n no interest 83 M 162 352 receiver s 76 S 818 * 172 NY 609 355 b partic s76S 6 — 80 166 discovery III 315 18AC 198n f 91 M 489 357 collision s 77 S 60 damages f 83 636 f 85 476 16A0 admitted do 180 4450 537 434 partnership s 77 S 138 in realty 13 AC 129-30n 13 AC 133n 141n 441 meas. dam. ages s 77 S 54 84 360 s 84 SIS d90 68 11 AC 57n62n earnings ev. ILRANS llSOn contrib. neglig. 20 AC 241n 445 police 77 S 43 a 173 NY 610 447 enforceable s 77S 285 a 198NY 154 156 lOOM 420 injunction 164 146 lOOM 175 ' 'jug handle' ' d 102M 390 45 I license 77 S 294 f 81 636 363 collision B 77 S 117 r 173 NY 435 161 885 negligence dll5 917 pub. adml f 161 834 ILRANS 890 3721aw question s 77 S 64 123 242 383 fee of st s 77S' 24 al76 NY 551 e73 97 600 622 178NY 111 39M 598 12AC 195n Presumption 95 610 131 T54 construction 120 299 121 239 description 121 237 238 exclude fee 71 M 483 394 non user s 77 S 31 e 109 581 401 degree care s 77 S 122 185 875 98 M 39 41 f 98 M 42 ordinary care 185 869 4 1 2 remainder s 77 S 46 * 172 NY 654 82 345 4 1 9 partnership s 77 S 142 a 175 NY 188 knowledge 115 488 428 relevant s 77 S 71 47 M authority 61 M f 160 643 s77S 124 39 M e39M 45 M restriction 125 524 trust s77S a 176 NY 310 428 453 damages s 77 S 300 a 175 NY 480 f 73 622 waiver 147 96 binding 159 384 complte contrct f 177 23- 102M 662 457 n. disc, ev 1 77 S 30'; 16CP 125n 459 must allege s 77 S 216 130 568 averment 138 735 libel facts 69 M 212 462 civ service a 77 S 223 a 172 NY 323 85 380 39 M 456 42 M 356 468 undertaking s 77 S 207 a 179NY 548 liability 94 M 669 47 1 revocation 3 77 S 292 55M 641 473 laches s 77 S 350 8 114 499 grand larceny 77 M 655 489 new trial s 77 S 209 123 367 494 joint and several 8 77 S 309 ! 76S 802 12 AC 177n 184 appeal s 77 S 71 b 77 S 309 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, e, criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o. overruled; s, same case; do, dissenting ooin a 174 NY 512 78 339 f 169 31 loss society 183 50 509 bill partic. 8 77 S 203 8 11 AC 194 103 589 155 203 5 1 I disbursemts S77S 317 8 103 593 518 compensatn s 77 S 222 d 90 M 665 520 discovery 197 65r 240 243 247 58 652 256 377 72 admr domicil 84 148 creditor s suit 107 469 eq. feuit 35CP 103 mege. security q 144 AD 248 vesting 186 380 545 chge venue s 77 S 956 e 94 442 all AC 313 99 306 547 prom note s77S * 172 NY 125 164 complaint 168 one action 98 M demurrer 98 M assignment do 178 98 M not res judicata 98 M 661 40 604 738 352 111 658 659 649 660 549 b'd health s 77 S 136 a 173 NY 612 d 102 299 552 accountine f 90 M 421 559 revocation s 77S 178 r 172 NY 360 s 176NY 695 8 95 59 51 M 157 8 97 127 11 AC 247n s 12 AC 55 will valid 109 868 do 109 869 " 94 M 556 579 indictment 77 S 7 * 176 NY 667 75 450 580 constitutnl a 77 S 16 r 175 NY 84 do 78 139 583 "Ontinuing 8 77 S -46 126 426 wanton action 1?9 710 587 death dam. s 77 S 128 11 AC 69n 59 1 master neg. a77 S 22 65 LEA 649 130 585 176 516 597 jury questn a 76 S 742 351 opinion ev. 91 82 599 chg. venue s77S 89 607 waiver a 77S 131 pleading 70 M 206 NY 6 1 I appeal case 1 s76S a 173 NY 614 ejectment s 76 S r 176 NY e93 1 514 626 41 881 134 538 1022 598 1037 IIB 122 s76S a 172 NY 84 demurrer 92 e97 do 171 sll AC consolidation 114 liability 60 M 195 assign action 37 CP 164 presumption 52M 282 cause of action 734 B5S 289 391 733 160 9<. f 157 82 M eouity 222NY 88 M rescission 41 624 380 622 6 1 5 appeal case 2 s76S a 171 NY 6 1 7 appeal a 76 S r 176 NY authority 222NY 6 1 9 appeal case 3 s76S a 171 NY appeal case 4 8 76S a 174 NY appeal case 8 s76S a 176 NY 620 appraisal case 12 111 234 s 76 S 1017 1017 687 1028 179 1029 689 1021 548 1018 modified; *, dismissed; n, note ion: D. parallel case; q. questioned ^. Y. Sopreme Coart Reports— Appellate Division Vols. 73,74 appe&l •case 14 a76S x 175 NY Appeal case 17 s77S ji 174 NY case 22 s 77 S a 179 NY ■appeal «aee 24 s77S a 173 NY B2I mileage s76S case 3 * 199 US a 171 NY 622 report case 9 s77S a 17S NY ^23 appeal case 2 b76S 1016 176 1121 179 1139 4 IS 1131 628 S13 1141 481 VOL.74 1 assumed risk s77S 3 75 270 4 negligence s 107 221 f 76 S 80C Buoervision 141 753 7 stockholders s 76S 854 105M 714 20 contract s77S a 176 NY 24 chge. venue s 76 S 6S sll AC do 164 discretion 128 874 S06 624 negligence s 77 S 339 a 174 NY 615 ssg 34 110 883 626 remedy disbarment 138 case 8 s77S 104 damages case 16 8 77S r 175 NY 16AC forgery case 17 s77S r 175 NY appeal case 19 s77S a 175 NY appeal case 33 b77S a 172 NY 896 1123 229 1139 219 357 1138 323 1127 488 1138 630 627 insurance caae 19 «77S a 175 NY 1133 226 8 550 113 547 27 expense s 77S 136 674 57 177 ILRANS 669iJ 74 discretion s 77 S 251 101 44 171 bill partic. f 132 890 i 159 582 76 transfer tax 8 77 S 76 89 353 e 39 M 125 39 M 226 d 42 M 92 cond. precedent f 143 338 deduction lOOM 249 8 1 demand note 252 614 273 135 38 leave to sue s 76 S 826 16AC 293n 62 M 557 cor tempt 62 iVl 559 40 assessment s 77 S 303 r 173 NY 347 44 sale sample s 77 S 229 39 M 529 3 11 AC 180 neg. pregnant 542 448 99 46 M pleading 77 M 575 50 encroachmt s 77 S 250 .120 764 mjunction 122 750 f lOOM 372 54 proof clear s 77 S 213 86 M 319 delivery do 175 169 55 patrolman s 77 S 348 d 78 203 58 dig. grade 3 77 S 36 83 140 remedy 75M 192 intent statute 91 604 aggrieved 68 M conclusive 82 M s77S a 174 NY e84 95 M pledgor 89 all AC tender 57M reasonable 127 89 reUef s77S 92 set-off 143 to trustee 172 467 187 316 11 172 131 I 1 injunction 8 77S 3 11AC 67 M boycott 67 M 366 208 223 222 423 211 1 1 3 committee e77S sll AC care insane 56M orig. prcdg 129 587 1 18 libel s 77 S a 179 NY 1 28 champerty 711 27 541 688 82 interest s 77 S 139 not party 165 64 agency 8 77S a 174 NY 202 758 619 341 512 s77S a 173 NY f86 d 174 NY sll AC enforceable 112 atty, client 18AC remedy 137 498 624 630 23 283 154 248 a 176 NY cumulative e39M interest rate 48 M f 86 M intention 131 435 141 215 1 66 pers. inj 3 77 S 624 a 173 NY 628 169 recovery 3 77 S 577 99 193 b. partic. 53M 288 meas. damages £ 172 105 1 75 compensan 725 504 440 3 77S r 175 NY f74 fee damages t74 deprivation 65M property do 66M 628 467 1 92 dam excess s 77 S 386 a 174 NY 503 recovery 151 244 negligence 75 604 83 332 d 333 97 452 for jury 156 888 1 97 trust title 9 77 S 737 a 174 NY 26 distinction 64M: 269 2 1 corrob. ev. a 77 S 602 77 188 217 practice s77S e78 113 dismissal 123 jury trial 123 error court 132 521 348 130 278 278 62 answer 667 improper f 170 prac. 923 1 30 certiorari 8 77S 436 a 172 NY 618 ISSpolice power s 77 S 540 162 71 1 40 considern 77 S d 103 a 175 NY 78 533 326 489 158 68 master neg. 3 77 S 344 92 311 97 394 blast peg. 147 misjoinder 8 77 S 518 112 28 1 50 legacy s73S 6 77 S * 173 NY 718 687 602 221 hearg. proofs s 77 S 658 53M 221 citation 183 854 224 collision s 77 S 470 •i81 68 23 1 unauthorizd s 77S 465 135 48 234 volt, payt s 77 S 563 a 176 NY 475 40 M 231 238 contract s77S r 176 NY compet ev s 130 condn bond i 130 appeal 130 surety 132 771, do776 248 removal B 77 S 605 446 269 752 753 754 78 260 255 crdr suit 77 S 488 83 538 e 106 185 9 11 AC 268 261 alimony 3 77 S 476 a 173NY 377 82 68 vested property 82 70 3 11 AC 292 due process law 138 839 statutory f lOlM 459 27 1 reorganzatn 3 77 S 657 * 176 NY 553 a 177 NY 576 278 contempt 77 S 610 execution 84 406 13 AC 187 284 findings 77S 523 a 175 NY 37 40 M 334 intent donee 40 M 336 29 I restoration 1 77 S 691 e 78 200 do 78 206 38 M . authority 51 M 485 munic. officers 149 298 will a 180 NY 77 S 494 73 595 310 neglig. prool s 77 S 63i e 100 398 notice 156 788 3 1 6 assignee a77S an AC cause action 118 demurrer d 144 contracted 144 320 false rep. s77S a 176 NY 330 legacy s77S a 175 NY 52M 599 27? 496 607 438 168 528 505 431 336 gifts only 3 77 S 663 51 M conclusive 113 L8AC 37 CP presumption 113 make will" 180 736 361 168 737 672 338 probate 3 77 S 513 a 173 NY 629 80 600 burden proof 19A0 285n undue influence 14!) 487 no presumption 1.52 673 341 award s77S 85 do 144 68 M f 92 M '•view" 66M not excessive 416 211 387 88 421 497 do 148 judgment 166 343 award s77S * 172 NY authority 127 special use 98 M 561 666 653 719 347 discover} 8 77 S 614 e 95 422 40 M 663 96 M 580 140 534 356 burden proof 5 77 S 699 51 M 56 65 M 10 359 innuendo 8 77S 83 e93 177 NY 14 AC 461 207 533 369 412n 364 fiduciary s 77 S 444 67 M 260 368 parol ev. 3 77 S 541 84 398 order corpn. sale 45 M 61 37 1 death dam. s 77 S 626 a 174 NY 505 74 315 e 99 426 degree case d 106 465 154 808 ordiry. care 131 751 duty owner 154 805 380 b partic. 77 S 531 f79 39 89 92 19AC 4n 8n 219 628 687 388 asauind rak 77 S a 82 89 master negl do 95 125 prima facie neg. 97 3 duty safe scaffold 1 11 144 20 AC 162n submission 155 410 negligence f 167 602 a 175 NY 520 221NY 106 t 88 M 290 lOSM 271 performance 126 832 consent 144 662 prove work 152 188 404 affidavit a 77 S 475 t^7 426 54M 273 274 discovery I8AC 192n 406 dismissal 8 77 S 704 a 173 NY 606 jurisdiction 173 56 4 1 5 poor person s77S c77 84 e87 sll AC 19A0 defective 169 546 213 214 464 161 255 312n 420 mtge 428 96 621 417 chat 3 77 S s 111 316 NY possession d 79 M 499 change possn. SO M 604 file bill sale 216 NY 421 breach tract B77S 104 conclusive 133 201 NY 622 637 201 664 57 430 atty client 8 77 S 417 f 87 631 authority d 130 487 133 501 f 91 M 31 H7S 628 434 trespass B 77 S 816 r 175 NY 367 74 184 f 74 629 441 stipulation s 77 S 575 119 735 m 173 NY ■ 608 ^^ 179 NY 482 681 evidence 255 17AC 397 authority 8 77 S 501 13 AC 323n undue influence 71 M 637 400 m. lien s77S 76b 444 estoppel 8 77S 483 132 662 limitation 95 M 7, 8 452 water rate 8 77 S 467 90 175 s 11 AC 237 456 secure cost s 77 S 515 s 11 AG 304 75 449 38 CP 486, 487 jud. discretion 78 438-9 42 M 150 54M 52 ex parte 509iS4M 52 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, c, criticised ; 1, limited ; e, explained ; c distinguished; f, followea; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; , overruled; s, same case; do, difstiiting opinion; p, parallel caae; q, que'stioneA Vols. 74, 75 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division may waive 89 M 155 458 value estate s 77 S 603 120 740 authority 55 M 474 46 1 will excutn. s77 S 643 a 173 NY 620 -109 765. 780 46 M 540 s 11 AC 242 attestation • 158 71 intention 135 747 ev. publication ()7M 18 p 84 M 660 acknowledgment 140 S26 d 148 905 revocation 76 M 38S f 87 M 475 compliance 158 71 publication lOlM 654 106M 234 468 accounting 6 77 s eye 120 201 474 bill partic s 77 S 456 b77 f 164 213 172 89 476 party deft s 77S 435 124 852 surrogate 51 M 262 478 relief s 77 S 494 92 • 172 declaration 184 788 48 1 lien notice s 77 S 547 r 178 NY 632 e 96 364 61 M 360 492 iud'l sale B 77 S 453 a 173 NY 607 B 84 401-2 13 AC 182-3n res judicata 116 310 do 313 496 excess dam s 77 S 426 75 387 505 pers neff. s 77 S 684 a 173 NY 627 508 usury B 77 S 1070 a 17 4NY 530 defenses 180 223 527 requests t 77 S 770 a 177 NY 100 89 322 535 default s 77 S 837 r 175 NY 133 entitled appeal 102 428 appeal lies 148 210 appeal 165 509 92 M 373 information 95 M 110 547 assigne title » 77 S ^ 783 ['resumption 75M 49 construction 129 205 do 177 521 79 M 581 conversion 131 16 186 376 no modification S6 M 161 f 86 M 163 553 exemption i 77 S 840 a 179 NY 535 S5 78 d 81 not exempt d 84 M 550 561 assumed risk 1 77 S 813 94 43 565 injunction s77S 812 e78 39 567 lost will s 77 S 748 a 174 NY 504 3 11 AC 336 572 master neg s 77 S 762 88 75 CO servant 129 771 575 presumptn- case 2 trust 3 77 S 776 a 180 NY 183 appeal , attys. lien 18AC 98n 87 514 s 11 AC 323 U AC 467n 14 AC 121 576 CO. treas. s 77 S 776 173 . 626 581 false repn s 77 S 763 f 75 609 105 392 60 M 193 585 sp. prfmce s 77 S 788 f 75 609 vendees riglits 68 M 233 59 I separation 3 77 S 568 a 178 NY 621 596 future conseq 77 P . 820 190 NY 457 14 AC 302d negligence d 140 688 O M 557 f 90 M 370 604 g'd crosse s 77 S 754 * 173 NY 682 79 B09 commn dam 83 621 remedy 138 355 certiorari f 168 306 88 M 155 539 in presence 620 pensions s 77 S 832 lease 3 77 S 1137 r 172 NY 305 622 recovery case 1 8 76 S 812 a 177 NY 670 624 incomp ev case 7 s77S 1141 r 175 NY 372 report case 34 s 77 S 1124 * 173 NY 600 625 appeal case 1 s 77 S 1140 a 178 NY 683 mandamus case 3 s 77 S 1122 a 171 NY 6 case 28 ne^lg. s 77 S 1134 104 615 626 receiver case 1 1st Dept s77S 1130 * 173 NY 647 case 1 3 77S 1129 a 174 NY 529 hold over case 6 s 77S 1130 76M 180 damages Dept. case 3 S77S 1125 s 172 NY 602 a 173 NY 366 larceny case 6 2nd Dept B 77 S 1136 a 175 NY 479 628 new trial case 1 77 S 1125 r 176 NY 503 B29 new trial case 1 s 77 S 1132 r 176 NY 504 630 appeal case 1 3 77S 173 NY case 6 - 77 S a 175 NY 176 NY isase 15 3 77 S 180 NY s 106 strut case 2 s 77 S a 180 NY liability case 4 . 77 S r 173 NY negligence 139 1026 601 1122 525 560 1126 543 400 1121 183 1138 418 810 63 1 countrclairn case 10 s 77 S 1125 m 175 NY 214 mandamus case 14 s77S 1136 * 172 NY 653 632 demurrer case 2 s 77 S 1130 a 176 NY 430 77 308 appeal case 4 B778 1121 VOL.75 I neg. damages s 77 S 798 r 176 NY 163 6 diligence s 77 S 802 100 22] new trial 16AC 126n upon case 153 264 not known 153 265 no authority 84 M 43 n. discv. evid. 103M 469 1 I agricul law 9 77 S 805 a 173 NY 629 constitutional 92 572 e 573 f 92 574 102 111 106 269 amend pldg. 183 867 com. penalties 138 869 delivery 137 552 violations 208 NY 142 adulterated 164S 8 2 1 foreclosure 3 77 S 953 77 582 6 94 175 adjustment 185 NY 194 e 101 489 565 106 597 109 784 113 148 46 M 309 stockholders 16AC 28n 35 23 pleading 3 77 S 957 36 438 strike out 59 M 152 discretion 130 61 construction 52M 252 28 construction 3 77 S 964 S6 309 75M 447 life estate 167 421 80 M 503 later clause 77 M 43 repugnancy 89 M 65 cut down 105M 178 3 1 ordinance 3 77 S 987 81 131 bill particulars 112 726 construction 122 753 reserved power 122 754 police powe;r 60 M 538 sky signs d 61 M 429 prohibition 129 264 33 ministerial 3 77 S 973 42 M 71 141 573 39 murder b78S 6 a 174 NY 605 8 11 AC 348 8 49 M 294 equity 186 NY 15 character 17AC 193 juror's adm 128 804 harmless error 19AC 151 discretion 217 NT 380 47 attachment a 77 S 9.'ig 76 116 98 141 afSdavits 79 M 435 resident d 79 M 437 54 bankruptcy s 77 S 969 14 AC 382n eviction 20 AC 266n 60 neg. seivt. 3 77 S 794 a 178 NY 631 66 parol ev. 3 77 S 792 s9S 617 126 824 220 NY 398 48 M 553 parol proof 115 342 f 82 M 433 error court 68 M 36 sp. perfmnce. s'77 S 786 a 186 NY 597 72 inadmissible s 77S 766 f lOOM 867 83 sheria s 77 S 1018 a 177 NY 575 90 eq. mtge s 77 S 722 43 M 549 e 100 313 15 AC 439 95neg. damages 3 77 S 668 110 480 enforce lien 221NY 141 98 occupation 8 77S 716 168 469 42 M 216 47 M 137 1 03 property s 77S 674 f 178 828 106 certificate s 77 S 380 105 274 I 1 7 new trial s 77S 457 ICPNS 22 reinstate verdict 148 87? 121 prom, note E 77 S 378 a 184NY 544 125 presumptn s 77 S 364 f75 615 r 181 NY 454 title earnings 14 AC 207n 1 27 penalty B 77 S 410 * 17fi NY 497 131 franchise 3 77 S 382 a 175 NY fill do 142 806 1 143 176 d 152 25: 67 M 474 85 M 584 privilege 160 777 135 notice s 77 S 357 98 M 154 138 water sup ply 8 77 S 376 a 173 NY 606 t 162 48 1 4 1 sale land 3 77 S 392 a 177 NY 588 145 joint tort feasors a77S 37S 83 217 do 175 NY 38 picketing 39 M 51 58 100 361 complaint 77 M 40 93 M 342 relief equitable 99M 370 prohibited f 178 279 intent 106M 55 149 agency s 77 S 362 49 M 303 1 54 charge ev. 6 77 S 337 89 470 11 AC 227 knowledge essential do 179 244 1 62 awards s 77 S 397 d 52M 318 I 64 capital s 77 S 398 rolling stock 75 171 173 NY 261 1 67 neg j. p s 77 S 385 s 11 AC 216 1 69 francb tax 3 77 S 40 m 173 NY 256 s 173 NY 266 89 128 deduction 202NS 594 1 80 neg dam. 8 77 S 396 75 6lS 1 84 maudamuB s 77 S 676 r 173 NY 297 186 prescription 3 77 S 678 f 75 614-5 1 88 inspection 8 77 S 714 106 350 12 AC , . . lln error objection 51 M 76 discovery 142 754 inspect books 106 350 145 428 191 St frauds 8 77 S 665 a 176 NY 645 recoverv 110 ■ 659 114 783 1 95 assault 8 77 S 679 8 77 586 3 11 AC 329 3 12 AC 236-7 201 "lankruptoy a 77 S 1028 a 176 NY 313 3 11 AC 378 debts bar 17AC 331n discharge 122 97 204 legis power a 77 S 1020 41 M 117 21 I certiorari 1022 548 252 87 335 74 247 611 173 s 77 S 94 M 370 387 1 76 trade fixtu's s 77 S .SC8 141 108 b77S r 177 NY 179 NY 84 90 86 M unliq. claim 85 do 104 town liability „ do 104 608 44M . . 457 munic. officers 149 494 dismissal 163 67 220 chg. route e78S 24 ai72NY^ 462 add'l land 114 875 226 fire ina 78 S _ 44 award suit 94 107 e 95 266 51 M 467 230 vesting 78 S 20 40 M 40 239 strike out answer B 78 S • „ 2 76 238 s 11 AC 372 12 AC 66 241 authority s 78S ,1 134 434 243 by-Jaws B 78 S 85 ABBREVIATIONS: a, afBrmed; d, distinguished; £, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, noM c, criticised ; 1, limited ; e, explained ; o, overruled ; s, same case ! do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel ca»e ; q, questioneo N. Y, Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division Vols. 75, 76 44M 102 130 15 AC reasonable 54M 137 147 469 132 167 621 309 obstruction- 393 requests 78 S 178'8 78S 38 178 NY 624'al78NY 569 11 AC 459 840 841 246 limitation s 78 S 165 51 M 146 250 prop, in state s 78 S 91 114 214 not taxable 138 883 252 use water s 78 S 66 a 177 NY 140 262 use water s 78 S 160 r 177 NY 568 267 neg. dam. s 78 S 69 3 92 611 274 neg. dam. I s 78 S 60 8 97 82 279 sup. pro. 8 ?8S 1 86 3e4 282 election 8 78 S 99 13 AC 70n 72n pers. injury 59 II 241 liability 69 M 348 285 vacated B 78 S 96 38 CP 376 116 surety 117 82] modification 117 823 application 150 462 no power 84 M 98 county courts f 92 M 731 288 surety 8 78 S 98 97 2.12 290tender s 78 S 90 55M 444 292 admissions s 78 S 101 184 NY 62 privileged 3SCP 337 297 absolute ti'c s 78 S 140 71 M 228 power sale e 79 M 378 301 revocation 8 78S 118 93 430 13 AC 264n 304 use water s78S 168 a 178 NY 583 damages 180 313 atty. client - 78 S 124 180 NY 547 32 1 flues use in party wall 78 S 11 AC 323 claim 78 S d97 98 d IS AC contract 111 325 neg scope 134 115 54M s78S 95 105 n25lcommissioners 3 11 AC 418 «* M S32 fact question i,^_ 98 186 *23 salary 131 138 is 78 S a 173 NY 330 high degree I "Sreement 308 receivi s78.S sll AC discretion 120 • 142 401 constructioD 78 S 35 -2 448 3 11 AC 392 time exclusion 15 AC 92n 29 — 403 decree 467 s 78 S s 11 AC 383 presumption 1541 f 84 M 4 6 359; 84 M 8 491| interlineations 286 84 M 8 869;4I2 temp crosg s78S 113 ,al75NY 468 85 290-1 277 78 S M 333 trover 3 78S 5 U AC conclusive ISAC 51M degree care ■34M deed void U8 U practice q 224NY 620 202|151 39|labour 178 employment 189180 433 dockmaster 143 M 661150 M on I compensation 119 21 580 129 325 431 carrier 358 s 78 S 359 a 177 NY 56S 360 .„. 435 good faith 339 executor | Tlo^y 6m s 78 S 130 %i^^ ^^ % '^^ih^ 427i;i,hority d 162 62bi;^3'7 claims evidence 44 1 discharge 478 poundage 8 78 S 283 d 82 478 108 313 314 119 820 d 44 M 420 sheriff lien do 179 373 plaintiff liable do 179 373 jurisdiction do 179 374 480 civ. service 78 S 385 a 173 NY 646 f 45 M 52 486 accept deed s 78 S 561 73 M 140 vest remainder 167 160 trust 225NY 311 497 demurrer s 78 S 473 f 78 643 e39M 711 503 dismissal 182 894 509 disoontinu s 78S 320 B 12 AC 362 513 dedicate et. 3 78 S 348 14 AC 262n 5 1 8 file lien s78S 83 679 342 demand 'tP ^ 3 78 S 186 1, An 62 M 163 ^ ^ 345power court s 78 S 171 171 550 35 I entire-::y s 78 S 132 131 54 admission 76 M 565 notice late 17AC 281 103 119n 330n 360 wages 78 S 145 447 secure cost ^7RS 310 78 438 136 9 449 indictment 316 57 33 s78S r 175 NY eS7 legis. power 114 54 502 1691 473' 322j, 369 wf. support s7SS 193 619 s 180 NY 4.58| decree s 215US 207' opn'g judgment 67 M 594 388 surrender s 78 S 16S sll AC 47.'i 391 assault dam » 78 S 170 110 70S contract i 47 M 677 compen. damage 52M 391 damages 187NY 392 jurisdiction 129 65Si 451 guaranty s 78 S 440 a 177 NY 527 455 cash bail s 78 S 338 6 12 AC 1 tlcciaration 00 M 208 may rebut 94 M 153 presumption 96 M 013 receipt 96 M 614 460 bill partic. s 78 S 327 e 101 46 19AC 3n lOn lln ^77 mad dam. s 78 S 286 12 AC Ifi 336 511 522 mandamu' 3 78 S 314 S12AC 9 17AC 85n 86d 157 320 57M 323 stockholder 117 349 motive infer 125 640 no relief 149 827 524 mandamus 279 198-9 200 6 208 S7SS d84 do 84 3 12 AC estoppel 69 M property deft, 96 M 613 527 r r taxn 3 78 S 308 a 174 NY 532 532ueces. party s 78 S 276 160 293 170 874 third party Jo 150 295 do 150 297 maintain action do 150 298 534 affidavit a 78 312 17AC 317n 538 practice 78 S affidavit 76 77 89 necessity 194 NY CPNS 323 92 274 138 183 158 limit 150 power 310 553 no obligat'n s78 dl41 70 M trespasser 143 355 519 557 77 559 counsel fee s78S s80 b93 duty care 102 284 233 239 297 561 guaranty 3 78 S 274 52M 236 565 alimony 78S 304 e 12 AC 14 3 109 603 good faith 134 421 modification do 166 341 567 inspect bks. 78 S 429 distinction M 610 576 tax law s 78S 381 132 196 584 ev. neglig. 78 S 342 214 NY 551 588 fr'd deed s 78 S 436 a 176 NY 588 value proceeds 157 714 593 easement 78 S S7 restriction? do 119 f 161 214 NY covenant 125 f 131 137 t 163 d 168 20 AC 647 357 407 810 z'r 768 758 580 362 451 7 On 602 death dam. 3 78 S 624 a 1 76 NY 607 67 452 presumption 70 M 302 for jury 156 8SS- compensation 163 47 606 ejection s78S 82 pleadg ev. 98 13 AC 16 AC 657 216 7f 61 336 ABSKEVIATIONS: a, ndlrmed; d, distinguished; c. criticised: 1. limited; e. exnlained: o. overruled; e 609 aoccounting case 1 3 77S 112f a 1 76 NY 592 182 NY 321 certif liq.tax case 6 s77S 1121 a 175 NY 606 appeal case 9 a77S 1128 a 177 NY. 576 assessmt. ins- 61 M 461 6 1 accent case 7 s 77 S 681 87 68t estoppel 146 174 tender E 95 M 282 6 1 2 damages Babe 1 3 77S 47C sll AC 225 6 1 5 custody case 1 3rd Dept s78S 23 sll AC 381 17AC 42n probate case 12 a77S 1138 a 176 NY 61 J appeal case 20 S77S 1142 a 177 NY 545 do 180 NY 38 neglig. CO. servt. do 183 NY 532 demurrer case 21 s 77S 114^1 a 179 NY 552 sl2 AC 153 accounting case 22 s77S 1139 a 176 NY , 687 571 612 610 VOL.76 I request ev s78S 92 exceptions 53M instruction 39 CP 169 evidence habit do 143 207 ocompetent ev. 3 78S 620 10 rresumption s 78 d 644 89 295 116 266 77 M 549 1 5 partnership 8 78 S 631 a 177 NY 643 13 AC 126ii 128n 25 vote power 3 73S 638 3 78 S 986 109 673 breach peace 96 M 653 3,4 "strMcture assume dl47 risk 160 616 damages s 78 S a 186 NY 55S 6 1 9 death dam. case 5 3 78 157 s 95 3 103 neg. CO. servant 106 414 restitution case 4 s 78 S 153 82 555 625 reinstate case 4 s78S a 176 NY libel Case 10 s78S a 177 NY 1131 568 1112 131 630 contrib neg case 7 78 S r 177 NY new trial case 19 3 78S a 177 NY 1137 224 1121 579 b'78S 8 92 d94 97 161 prima fac. 98 assume risk 102 construction 122 labor law 134 recovery 20 AC scaffold 20 AC alteration 153 664 225 152 3 141 neg ^50 316 753 406 673 698 153 38 48 parol ev- s78S 102 a 178 NY 68M secret trust 84 M 306 69 non-resident 3 78 S 553 f 84 £02 allegation 87 598 47 M 292 on knowledge 70 M 497 72 3rd party* 78S 659 5 85 costs stay 12 AC 64o 33 In nee. parties US 812 undertaking 155 94 protection 155 95 80 expulsion .1 78 S 3 12 AC implied lOlM 87 assessing 3 78 S a 175 NY 218 NY f 76 126 127 do 164 175 739 128 737 509 240 612 741 674 881 522 f, fo lIowed;r reversed; m, modified; ', dismissed; n, note same case; do. dissenting opinion; p, parallel ease ; q, questioned Vol. 76 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division 8? M 638 98 M 159 block to block 218 NY 240 90 affidavit s78S t76 77 726 612 274 yS 'Bot accte B 78 S 713 14 AC 161n injunction 61 M 48 distinction 137 628 counterclaim 72 M 361 defense do 165 813 105 contract 8 78 S 705 B 86 . 625 cause action 47 M 19-20 not pres»l2ned 155 630 I 1 2 easbment 8 788 1040 93 377 declaration 69 M 208' affidavits 79 M 435 I 1 8 indictment 3 78 S 721 a 175 NY 479 l26G0m. incomp 1 60 charge er. 8 78 S 454 89 394 8 12 AC IS Pleading 106 397 amendment 126 434 restrict proof 197NY 73 inadmissible 20 AC 165n 65nee -damages 8 78 S 433 * 175 NY 463 772 168 174 title B 78S 137 estate 434 91 16 367 58 i78S 8 12 AC care insane 56M enforcement d 130 appeal d lOPNS not binding 76 M s»» 1 32 preference B 78 S 743 e 43 M 264 8 12 AC 136 12 AC 248n ounsel fees 111 1S2 Fed. questn, 117 581 prohibition 55M 1 77 new trial 8 78 S 366 150 322 12 AC 2I6n 18AC 30n costs trial 55M 26 discretion 135 153 79 M 369 178 vol. paymt 8 78 S 3S 103 183 I 83 jurisdiction 8 78 S 365 s 12 AC 66 waiver 184 NY atifry & ,stop 48 M 267268,272 appearance 3SCP authority 75 M 399 224 corpn. aotn. s78S 516 m 179 NY 107 103 98 interevene 169 214 232oonstruction 9 78 S 408 66 M -84 leaving lease 152 529 236 costs stay 8 78 S 637 84 620 113 7.58 8 12 AC 64 17AC 323n 325n right amend 37 CP 150 self defense al 384 319 350 714 d 122 remedies 137 justice 137 defense 138 court's power do 171 501 72 M 120 punishment 20 AC 298n 137 contempt B 78 S 687 82 82 1 43 award 8 78 S 942 76 611 libl consiruction 124 204 96 M 113 certiorari 138 172 prevent awards 202 NY 192 151 assessment 6 7SS 611 q 94 362 B 94 542 1 85 claim offer 8 78 S 297 s 12 AC 37 rejectclaim 17AC 261n file consent 18AC 137n not established 147 2L3 short statute 75M 529 cond. precedent 159 927 1 89 reference s 78 S 444 * 174 NY 524 194 equity 3 78 S 170 NY .328 SI 308 99 master neg. 134 300 costs trust s 79 S 122 46 M 85 302 certiorari s 78 S s79S 15 AC 304 recovery s78S 48 M 17 AC 138 waiver 81 M 714 418 538 62 77 238 retrial S78S 99 104 weight of ev, ^0 M 383 243 admissions s 78 S 578 r 178 NY 400 13 AC 29 3n 355 constijtut'n [iOl question '• • 112 s 78 S 522 43 M a 176 NY 555 179 NY 556 extend district 109 417 750 1143 460n 396 429 69 allegation 47 M 3S5 49 M 64'6 meas. damages 16AC 465 362 jurisdiction; waive objns. s78S 466I18AC 163 249 franchise 78 S 470 accept in toto 178 NY 115 257 construction s 78 S 462 a 173 NY 181 96 107 262 assessment s 78 S 423 60 M 254 title proof 60 M 268 265 demurrer s 78 S 430 148 820 no variance f 165 692 267 authority s 78 S 457 101 285 15 AC 423n 374 35 200 construction 78 S 377 51 M 175 69 M 123 jurisdictn trusts 79 M 395 cond. precedent 308 damages 8 78 S 419 17AC456n 457n special damages 61 M 64 312 reasonable certainty s 78S 501 148 432 314 privileged s 7SS 505 18AC , ' 43n 323 presumpt n 78 S 469 e 90 507 s 12 AC 77 327 pleading s 78 S 497 13 AC 391n 330 cotenants s 78 S 486 126 66? apportionment 126 664 limitation 197NY 446 332 reference s 78 S 431 14 AC 25Bn eicempt husband 74M 425 forfeiture 77 M 675 no bar f 84 M 410 separate agreement 93 M 680 violation d 106M 403 a 173 NY 610 41 M 393 13 AC 253 pers kinowedge 82 446 e 96 106 constitutional 40 M 8 12 AC 27 1 fact quesTton b78S 43 M 103 ans warranty 2 356 26 rule pleading 74 M 276 demurrer 126 346 76 M 635 Injury damages construction 13 AC 262n waiver 52M intervention 130 amendment 212 NY f 170 426:60 M 68 'assume risk 585 481 324 649 301 11 313 365 denials b78S 106 39 M strike 151 371 covenant s 78 S 498 16AC 462n 461n repairs 93 M liability 179 no duty 182 469 589 546 635 out 637 501 742 821 373 cross exam 8 78 R 394 8 12 AC 96 375 collision s7SS 8 174 NY s 176 NY r 177 NY 788 522 656 63 393 incompt'cy 8 78S sl2 AC practice q 224NY 334 coversion 582 s 78S 485 133 573 do 575 88 M 427 44 M 275 fire ina 78 S a 177 NY estoppel 112 SOM 207 gifts s78S 491 33 533 13 AC H67n dft inter viv 5 52M 445 taxable f 161 86 2 1 2 attestation S78S 440 8 12 AC 41 221 appeal 878 S 39V notice service f76 622 480 748 672 602 684 279 claim surety 78 S 661 87 9 285 highway !> 78 S 531 8 178 NY 167 292 examination s 78 S 109 87 M contempt f 87 M exemptions f 94 M 546 281 363 364 129 296 neg. guard s 79 S 276 336 collision s 78 S 482 84 699 fact question 85 88 f88 11 340 expulsion E 78 S 478 13 AC 65n 67n 346 set aside verdict 8 78 S 432 107 253 17AC 206n 207 349 dedicate st s 78 S 500 14 AC 272n review 18AC 334 n certif. necessary 139 195 35 1 phys exam. 8 78 S 410 8 12 AC 87 131 ICPNS right tenants 182 821 not neglect lOSM 52 422 ultra vires _ 78 S 508 a 179 NY 544 13 AC 266n 273n contract 131 881 estoppel 177 45 435 strike out s 78 S 849 99 644 aside verdict 107 253 practice 55M 62 review 17AC 206n 207 443 accounting 3 78 S 62' E 65 M 598 weight of ev. 141 732 449 reargument 709 118 360 S78S 812AC leversal 17 AC compliance 63 M new trial 137 82 M 796 124 76 364 399on or about s 78 S 746 64 M 255 401 jurisdiction s 78 S 417 dead bodies e 79 237 86 66 disinterment 19A0 50n consent court ' 166 903 405 tax payer 8 78 S 779 a 175 NY 432 fact question 139 336 409 pleading s 78 S 782 39 M 634 friv. answer 120 677 178 484 4 1 3 landlord s 78 S 855 79 M 231 neg. damages e 78 564 contract breach 79 636 99 420 599 contractual f87 prox, cause d 59 M 620> 414 494 franoh. taX' 8 78. 8- 813i 90 282' 504 impeachm't 3 78 S 549 s 12 AC 109 cross examinat'n 142 26a estoppel 186 2501 506 contract s 78 S 574 93 63: s qs. 67 pnvity 111 752 5 1 2 contract s 78 S 550 e 100 469 134 429 a 177 NY 634 spec, performce 112 59 parties plf. 139 281 parol proof 69 M lis 516 constructn. 8 78 S 143 contract 79 M 526 bond b78S a 178 NY ' 'material' 145 68 M liability 68 M 600 789 241 584 681 529 375. 375 529 objection 8 78 S 568 a 177 NY 566 77 628 contrih. neglig. 137 100 534 sp. prfmce. 8 78 S 800 a 176 NY 518 451 contract s 78 S 776 79 101 repair damages 47 M 385 meas. damages 16AC 455 131 12 deny recovery ICPNS 313 464 vicious dog 8 78 S 686 8 12 AC 99 471 burden deft 3 78 S 604 117 373 charge binding 85 M 425 knowledge lOOM 492 552 negl ev s 78 S 696 „„„ 84 583 636 20 AC 146n ^ireverEe judgm't 475 assume risk 8 78 S 617 115 523 do 1S3NY pleading 146 547 56 1 books as ev. s 78S 594 136 245 564 tel. poles s 78 S 598 e 86 259 street burden 111 704 5SM o60 567 trustee s 78 S 544 42 M 145 480 per injur, s 78 S 72B a 178 NY 553 negligence 217 NY 330 571 assessment ;s 78 S 764V 174 NY 90 08 estoppel 64M certiorari 67 M 490 inj. dam. 8 78S 542 2f7 400 5.58 273 649 579 books ev 8 78S 596 ABBREVIATIONS; a, alTirmed ; d, distinguished; f. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, noM 1. criticised ; 1. limited ; e, explained ; o, overruled ; >. tame case ; do. dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case : q. questioowl N. y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division Vols. 76,77 gS . S43 98 149 diBtinction 41 M 43S 13 AC 4S0n 582 life insur 8 79 S a 177 NY 579 588 sisters salary injunction 8 79 S 127 a 177 NY 317 damages 112 676D 592 liability s 79 S 592 97 M 485 596 conversation with decedent s 79 S HI B 90 60S compet. witness 129 qualified ICPNS 62 1 tel. poles case 2 s78S 12 AC 818 117 602 appeal s79S jurisdiction 80 lien mortgage 105M 213 606 declarations 150 290 s78S r 178 NY 6 I 2 appeal case 2 s78S a 176 NY appeal case 3 s78S * 177 NY 6 1 4 appeal b78S sSl 489 364 1140 508 1117 552 8 173 NY assessment case 38 s79S a 178 NY 647 1142 562 576 ]92n U25 550 1125 639 VOL. 77 I pecun, s 78S ICPNS loss 653 77 69 error evidence 6 agent comissn 3 79 S 130 49 M 303 presumption 149 866 12 contempt s79S e 100 d 121 127 146 t 177 51 M 56M S12AC 268 331 768 726 248 830 478 277 175 622 appeal case 1 S79S a 179 NY undertaking cases s79S *173 NY appeal casp 7 3 79S 1131 a 179NY 534 serve on atty. countrclaim ,59 M 239 'JSoxT-.^ 1137 service suffic. r 178 NY , 219j64M 478 cross appeals due process "=%»el9 ,,,,'94 M 505 s 79 o 1137 a 178 NY 589 „„ os» 20 consideration I 79 S 100 15 AC . 289n 'declarations prove 160 corporatn 102 78 S 3 99 109 ncompet 122 1043 370 465 ev, 882 47 M 326 apply proceeds 122 202 test capacity 141 193 burd. proponent 207 NY 228 72 com'r fees 623 appeal case o s79S a 179 NY 1144 589 do 123 854 629 139 624 dues rec^verj28pers tax case 1 !a 79 S s78S 493'al73NY a 179 NY 582 f 81 damages [certiorari case 3 91 _, s 78 S 415 niandatory 3 84 612 ^ 1^* NY291 295 (Warrant seal „„_ . . 183 NY 0^7 commission f 172 case 1 140 m "11^ 794 title biU t04 fl*" M '"* IfS tax warrant 78 S 42 M 78 relief s 79 8 126 81 appeal s78S S12A0 leview 106M 83 good will s79S 6 78 99 156 s 12 AG firm name 17 AC 87 m lien 8 78S r 177 NY 49 M waive lien 214 NY 1048 286 1 55 revivor s79S sSS 6 1 5 inspection books s78S 106 12 AC mandamus 157 607 350 12n 329 236 646 655L^ y4 renewal 219S79S a 178 NY d89 29 445 1059 208 496 37 46 o 289 582 225 45 n 1086 362 496 367 572 1 6 1 contrib. neg 78 8 80 94 do 97 110 colU 60 493 602 i 02 excess dam 109 • 48 weight of ev. 49 306 571 6 1 9 appeal case 9 s79S a 173 NY * 201 US case 17 s79S r 177 NY election Jaw case 27 s 79 S B 67 M award case 29 s79S rl77 NY 1143 611 650 1140 566 1136 64 18 appeal case 2 -80S a 177 NY equitable lien 182 208 superior lien 182 208 628 appeal 1135 247 case 3i 79 S *174NY 1146 625 629 new trial case 1 S79S u 177 NY 195 NY legisl 93 M power 244 31 __ 95 3 79 S 446'a 177 NY s 177 NY 83 97 15 AC pun. damages 127 B87 366 208 33 judgment 3 78 S 961 s 97 643 43 court right s79S 147 47 extra 80 S 20 AC 83 M 108 194 890 195n 680 49 assignment 1145 wife's consent 547 is SOS 148 |a 177 NY 574 17AC 307n 53 sewer neg s 79 S 278 |rl76NY 495 66 106 114 311 423 276 1 76 fairness proof 79 S 103 87 equity 54M I 13 undue inflii s 78 S 1001 a 17aNY o>S6 80 604 do 606 evidence 56M 156 jury question 54 M 480 56 U 348 99M 247 law question lOAC 286n aireet verdict 89M: 2521 :xpert evidence 1096 38,39 331 606 12 395 456 676 689 ligation 146 560 weight of ev. f 173 906 1 68 contract - 78 S 1016 3 106 468 r 177 NY 71 1 7 1 parties 3 78 S 1072 43 M 308 16AC 164n 119 422 174 accounting >. 78 S 118 128 38 CP reference 134 certif. competent 45 M 698 14 AC 107n strict rule 126 161. presmpt ev 130 14 221 pers inju y s 78 S 1069 177 NY 566 224 extra work 3 79 S 17 185 NY 210 102 557 106 97 227 1000 300 687 35L' 774 148 authority 148 principle 103M recovery 104M not liable 104M 773 7T5 295 ev- value s 79 S 225 84 416 quantum meruit 97 471 e 106 441 111 361 129 397 156 (j83 f 173 lis 179 139 utervention 125 357 contract ev. 142 15 implied coutrct 185 309 307 taxp suit s79S 199 f 77 643 310 redundant 248 241 note St. limitn s78S d 110 without reward 139 604 out 1061 35i) 43 8 517 397 245 vagrancy s 79 S 59 f 77 643 do 144 627 constitutional j 20 343 344 n M 84 due process law 09 M 401 25 1 counterclms 3 79 S 208 a 174 NY 534 64M 390 256 exceptions, s 79 S 213 e 77 389 9 91 164 185 corroborat'n . 78 S 114 267 purchaser 110? 3 78 S 16 1 92 reopening 3 79 S 31 do 104 542 error 107 613-14 ejectment do 133 45 1 99 affidavit 620 report case 1 s79S a 201 US alimony s 109 a 178 NY appeal case 6 s79S a 173 NY report case 36 s79S al77NY appeal case 37 s79S 1133 562 .502 557 114 607 1149 569 1143 60 construction 3 78 S 1066 103 349 62 com'r deeds 9 78S fees f 77 42 M services 190NY 1067 637 286 239 99M 1 26 costs S78B 79 M. S12AC new trial 53M costs trial 135 6611 terms trial 18AC rule practice 61 iVl 253 1044 869 216 403 153 26 28n 441 78 S 116 test proof 53M contract 176 107S 38; 369 211 131 weight of e\ burden proof 138 244 65 de facto cor- poration 3 78 S 1056 3 12 AC 218 79S 19AC bequests lOAC delivery do 176 49 248n 240n 169 142 undue influ. s 78 S 10U2 46 M 384 203 partners s 79 S 52 68 M 829 209 serv sumns s 78 S 1009 f 78 646 98 138 iianaging agent 159 420 2 1 2 poor person 1089 18l 431 208 18 20 3 78S 84 li'AC guard e87 1022 464 312n ad litem 161 175 NY 3 87 3 12 AC binding t 165 guardian ad litem do 165 272 practice 3 78 S 1046 85 390 interpleader 96 395 204 NY 287 276 exceptions " 205 9 311 874 145 240 22 ( 348 79 8 80 do 93 41 M strike 106 120 122 f 171 172 a 48 M 62 M 16AC irrelevant 45 M liability 117 nuisance 3 117 demurrer 119 163 C 171 91 M 16 AC defense 126 uwner liable 19AC 406 .i9AC 403 infer, neg. 9 117 589 aggrieved 157 660 244 6 323 673 638 317 671 511. 755 199 554 241 u 277 696 589 795 371 510 100 241-3n 677 317 pleading 79 S do 124 f 171 bill partic. 116 146 f 1,59 t 100 166 175 "6M f82M 187 697 456 134 469 581 807 808 396 173 47 79 S r 177 NY do 77 30 31 ^12AC 284 rulings ^9 a 52M 2 I 5 beneficiary 3 79 8 13 3 175 NY 466 i 177 NY 58^ 290 ev. error 3 79S 153 a 177 NY 523 TS 150 12 AC 300 impeachment L13 63b 18AC 451n, 45f 'credibility i 215 NY 409 lot impeach 173 446 burden defendt. f 166 807 times & places 186 808 too broad 166 809 32 1 former action pending 5 79 S 233 * 173 NY 638 '81 169 i 92 332 13 AC 165n cnder lien 184 504 J2S evidence S 120 ' 97 458 i 118 121 329 sham.pldg s 79 8 159 .AlillKICN i.ATIpNS: a, affirmed ; d. distineuishcd ; f, followed; r. reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed- n nobT ccntic-eJ: 1. hm.ted.; e, explained; o. overruled; s, ..,.,. case; do. dissenting opinion ; P, paraUd case ; i^^u^,^ Vols. 77, 78 N. T. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division f 77 639 S12A0 271 for jury 77 M 651 332 guaranty B 79 S 217 s gs 3gl lOSM 112 B 12 AC 267 consideration 179 NY 4 102M 111, 113 construction 130 331 338 express trst. s 79 S 74 62 M 411 cause of action 140 RSI. adapt relief 166 866 345 champerty s 79 S 194 r 174 NY 15 s 12 AC 250 confident*] positn lUl 52 f 85 M 170 presumption 79 M 345 355 transfer tax B 79S 201 r 174 NY 254 39 M 617 pers. estate 40 M 610 36 1 nesl, dam. B 79 S 241 a 177 NY. 569 assume risk 153 404 367 demurrer S79S 319 f77 374 641-2 surrender rights 137 648 384 guaranty s 79 S 294 81 145 fact question 91 404 negligence f 105 exceptions do 115 484 consent 159 398 39 1 burden prool B 79 S 33" 117 711 396 perjury s 79 S 340 a 175 NY 315 f 77 642 B 99 372 407 appeal s 79S 299 do 135 588 f 161 651 contract 166 390 mutuality 102M: 662 review 106M 496 4 1 3 partial de fence s 79 S 312 do 103 282 new matters 52M 104 defenses 16 AC 202d 4f7 valid 8 79 S 331 68 M. 558 f82M KM 88'. 422 not comply s 79S 327 lOlM 293 424 overflow s 79 S 334 a 179 NY 548 SO 21 lability 117 692 124 167 19A0 399 428 review s 79 S 309 e 81 124 reduction e86 48 72 M 651 certiorari o 117 813 estoppel 64M 278 application 64M 274 law Question 72 M 650 1 104M 237 433 com'r fees 8 79 S 192 t78 judicial 78 497 affidavit 80 288 454 demurrer 8 79 S 286 a 174 NY 272 46 M 480 14 AC 49n not demurrable 79 M 84 discharge 173 811 election 182 503 458 sp. prfmce s 79 S 303 f 77 465 misjoinder 87 313 92 66 81 M 65U 14AC 46n demurrer e 92 465 60 M 198 necessary party 47 M 20 will oral contract 15 AC 283n no bar equity 134 231 not demurrable 79 M 84 4B7short calendr s 79 S 328 s 12 AC 276 469 bill lading 3 79 S 1103 a 177 NY 591 472 judgment pleadings 78 S .95 personal judgt e40M 1 notice of lien 152 on 950 74 124 53 M 106 95 M 450 37 CP 285 not taxable 73 M 174 exemption 41 M 473 13 AC 358n valid trust deed 107 466 35CP 100 stock constructn 113 « gift inter vivos 52M 437 intention 73 M 174 impose tax 79 U 657 lOOM 650 strict constrctn. 79 M 657 lOOM 650 tax succession 79 M 657 after death do 177 879 adequacy lOOM 652 not succession 184 667 presumption 106M 608 484 injunction 8 78 S 937 a 178 NY 508 s 12 AC 189 added burden 77 M 234 493 contrib. neg. s 78 S 1059 128 874 496 injunction s 78 S 1052 r 174 NY 373 499 judgment s 78S 1051 134 870 authentication 202 NY 310 remit case 202 NY 811 nunc pro tunc 81 M 422 no appeal 213 NY 150 539 insurance s79S 1 B 12 AC 233 adoption 18AC 104n 113d 542 servt. deft, s 78 S 919 152 573 545 duty comr. s 78 S 890 68 M 287 558 demurrer s 78 S 889 f77 560 repair briage S78S 1101 106 362 562 dismissal s 79S 180 117 137 57 1 center st b79S f 77 84 12 AC tel. poles 92 injunction 41 M 580 mortgage amt due 1081 243 674 501 notice s78S 89 repeals do 135 maintain suit f 155 759 f 163 236 505 master neg s 78 S 953 115 634 rules necessary 648 266 648-9 41 196n 91 177 632 175 489 597 787 .298 79 S a 173 NY 49 elOl loe f 109 44 M e aesocn. receiver 185 NY 191 46 M 310 stockholders 16AC 28-30 32 34 35n 584 assault s79S 89 2 AC 569 489 236 592 m lien s79S a 178 NY burden show 261 622 228NY 283 20 AC 509 trust s78S t82 44 M revocation 89 40 M relief eOl 145n 1074 606 117 373 91 402 641 473 transfer tax s 78 S 930 83 533-4 110 480 115 210 40 M 331 41M 473 52M 441 515 mandamus s78S 45 M 520 trust 8 79S 40 M contract HI 997 522 280 39 289 70 297 404 329 330 81 155 612 admr. s79S s 185 NY 92 demurrer e93 jurisdiction 118 72 M incapacity do 148 complaint 153 construction 84 M 464 624 new trial s 78 S 956 __77NY 568 contrib. neglig. 100 91 107 103 admissibility do 153 441 do 176 454 632 new trial case 3 s79S a 178 NY case 11 a 179 NY case 14 s79S a 177 NY 1129 618 559 1139 592 assault case 9 6 79 S 1136 r 177 NY 314 appeal case 19 B 79 S 1139 a 177 NY 653 633 appeal case S s 79 S 1129 r 175 NY 139 appeal case 14 8 79S 1147 a 173 NY 608 new trial case 16 s80S 1150 a 177 NY 580 635 cotenant case 1 s 79S 1149 r 178 NY 391 appeal case 2 s 78 S 1064 m 176 NY 441 637 appeal case 1 s 78S 1029 covenants 66M 147 njisrepresentatn 88 M 441 case 2 8 79 S 176 a 176 NY 687 extra fees 105 426 services 190NY 239, 240 burden proof 133 244 642 stockholder case 10 79 S 1134 do 92 407 appeal case 15 8 79 S 1143 m 175 NY 511 643 appeal case 31 s 78 S 1021 a 176 NY 430 644 practice case 13 79 S 1127 8 40 M 573-4 VOL. 78 death neg 8 78 S g9n 12 AC 161 neg. per. se do 205NY 583 6 injctn. damage s 78 S 951 236 9 good cause actn s 79S s 102 618 realty 121 311 313 courts 121 312 85 M 123 Indian law 121 320 85 M 107 retroaction 38 CP 390 partition 62 M 144 Indian rights 04M 522 right recognized 155 777 155 779 constitutional 82 M 52 legis. powers f 83 M 328 statutory 83 M 328 remedial 165 230 jurisdiction f 165 639 1 8 certificate s 79 S 89 r 178 NY 535 warranties 57M 179 22 deposits s 79 S 91 99 -27 107 105 36 demurrer s 79 S 212 180 NY 333 14 AC 65n 42 warranty s 80 S 34 14 AC 297n 121 30 49 right protect s 79 S 782 i 91 k 504 52 employment s 79 S 479 80 14 f 102 621-; veteran e95 309 civil service 40 M 410 pay waiver 43 M laborers 50 M 325 compensation 119 21 129 56 construction s 79 S 566 104 523 a 176 NY 519 72 M 302 substitutional 152 749 64 dismissal s 79 S 879 91 477 178 684 44 M 71 void transfer e 9S 125 294 non resident - 100 244 pleading 51 M 215 creditor suit 194 NY 77 foreign executor ICPNS 152 jurisdiction 71 M 43 domestic ev, 158 86 74 witness con- tradiction 79 S 607 178 NY 127 ^ 86 . 446 use of evidence 17AC 72n 95 seizin s 79 S 646 90 77 8 12 AC 306 d 160 810 dower 95 M 372 101 res ipsa loq B79S 588 a 177 NY 578 80 140-1 e 12 AC 395-6 pleadg. dam. "" 132 12 AC. 32n ?pl. damages 18 AC 21Pn 222n restrict proof 197NY 73 inadmissible 20 AC 167n 107 easements s 79 S 614 d 43 M 64 111 563 113 724 e 54M 600 75 M ^ act. question 18AC 4S2n eviction do 147 233 1 1 3 contract s 79 S 510 96 140 s 12 AC 343 insurance d 118 847 fictitious names 70 M 533 prohibition only 70 M 534 I IR ne.^ltgence s79S ' 813' do 111 926n 1 27 divorce s 79 S 5.45 adultery proof 80 57 90 90 construction 88 M 677 1 30 arbitration s 79 S 627 a 177 NY 571 conclusive 117 . 4S0 jurisdiction 38 CP 245 1 34 labor law s 79 S 599 a 177 NY 271 1 4 1 decision s 79 S 528 s 12 AC 302 111 540 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, notci c, criticised; 1, limited; e. explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q, questionpo N. Y. Supreme Coart Reports— Appellate Division Vol. 78 1 44 appeal 8 70S 87 484 602 1 46 conversion e 79 S 633 8 12 AC 294 meas. damage 65M: 254 profits do 66M 471 prospctve profts 74M 110 1 5 1 rescission 8 79 S 699 ^3.M>. 520 8 47 M 444 costs 104M 690 I 63 res ipsa loq s 79 S 634 12 AC 393: expert ev. 61 M 104 160n 411 569 48 M expulsion 15 AC review 57M no review f 209 NY jurisdiction 176 2 48 Certiorari s 79S 1085 a 175 NY 510 268 pleading s79S 911 rules 42 M 77 271 indictment 79 S 997 r 175 NY 45 601 1 7 1 equity s79S s 78 171 81 defense 126 exonerated 145 551 639 76 708 107 1 78 nee damagr s 79 S 567 82 601 180 alimony s 79 S 530 153 462 not assignable 161 523 attorney's lien 178 565 1 84 mandamus 8 79 S 640 * 175 NY 158 88 450 1 99 mandamus 18AC 21 8n restrict proof 197NY 73 344 proceedes void 8 79 S 989 d 41 M 248 355 opg st dam 8 79 S 1031 84 314 528 36 1 license s 79 S 943 a 176 NY 671 222NY 271 use pier damages 282 annuity s79S f78 103 174 assignment 110 833 637 358 537 40 287 residence s 80 S 534 90 11 d 40 M 370 f 85 M 130 301 exemption 3 79 S 971 d 118 872 306 servt neg s 79 S 969 a 176 NY 610 master liable 105 525 3 1 3 tax corpn. s 79 S 975 82 373 scope review 179 NY 144 renewal £ 169 306 786 282 522 s79S £78 £78 e 87 724 205 639 644 351 204 reinstate 8 79 S 722 r 174 NY 626 do 78 204 639 212 will 8 79S r 177 NY 92 assessors 93 £42M assessment 132 57M requirem*ints 152 174 366 trust lien s 79 S 1010 a 178 NY 551 trustees 146 872 368 notary fee 79 S 985 42 M 286 373 mandamus s 79 S 728 d89 91 abolish position f 99 293 "lay off" 135 220 reinstatement 77 M 554 384 calendar s 79 S 1016 d 78 631 note issue 84 465 386 charge ev 3 1 7 charitable Institution 1004 616 402 2 1 9 law action 692 413 538 667 696 404 8 79S 80- 87 128 discretion 43 M relief money 113 . 54 132 199 royalties 132 198 incidental 157 710 share profits 168 56 513 4 224 intestacy s79 S f 82M residuum 225NY 229 pleading s 79 S 1068 a 181 NY 542 e 90 . 191 presumption s79S f 78 215 79 607 80 607 310 93 104 390 exr s80S 82 292 294 180 s79S d97 d 96 M f 96 M liability 128 61 M negligence d 135 no distinction f 211 NY 132 cause action f 96 M 297 324 distinction s SOS 71 74M 23 33 I misjoinder s79S 964 630 541 S3 1046 632 550 39 40 236 240 527 acctg 319 605 422 not negligt s SOS 360 179 670 426 death dam 80S 48 a 177 NY 623 inference ev 129 567 do 569 432 certiorari s 80 S 300 a 174 NY 533 437 discretion s 79 S 1083 d 136 9 42 M 150 440 executor 8 80 S 120 a 177 NY 663 449 good will B 80 S 363 m 176 NY 143 s 176 NY 499 113 99 462 17AC 43n 45n compensation 114 469 assumed name do 67 M 162 asset f 153 713 460 labor law " 79 S 969 a 175 NY 470 464 assumpsit s79 S 65 75 M 82 470 reinstate s 79 S 803 r 174 NY 136 d 78 476 475 reinstate s 79 S 806 r 174 NY 511 476 fact question 50 1 removal s79S a 174 NY 101 43M reduction 92 M 506contrib. neg. s 79 S 762 138 745 5 1 reversal s 79 S 706 83 87 122 882 513 duty land lord s 79S 98 15 AC negligence 52M licenses 136 471 do 476 com, law duty do 136 478 nonsuit 180 453 s79S 89 e 111 16AC 752 339 432 335 325n 478 amendment e88 parties 41 M e41M demurrer e41 M judgmt. creditor f 164 148 4 1 8 negl. dam 337 compt. ev. s 79 S 1054 s79S 1035|al77NY 570 a 177 NY 33 for jury spl. damages 'do 173 198 394 voluntary conveyance s 79 S 1014 82 341 111 370 396 transfer tax s 79 S 1048 a 177 NY 218 399 disinterment s 79S 899 402 death dam 80 S 161 a 177 NY 626 4 1 3 witness 79 S 1043 s 87 . 509 contradict 92 261 impeachment 14AC 115 18AC 457n 460n t 169 76 incompet. ev. eSM 316 s79S a 174 NY a 177 NY 96 126 sl2 AC 56 M discretion do 126 481 negligence 811 523 359 363 237 333 344 239 s79S e48M q 49M 186 NY 113 119 depression 117 law question 117 Iiabilit> 140 83' weight of ev. 143 633 not liable f 159 655 604 533 310 448 679 435 846 ' 847 136 38 CP 19AC 446, d 19A0 591 19 452 448 49 1 demurrer s79s as 7oM 2E 148 64 pleading 167 585 62* 169 201 168 411 557 loss income s 79 S 922 186 NY 44 incompet* ev- 196 NY 280 560 spl. dam, s 79 S 685 pleading- 12 AC 28n competent ev 18AC 225D admissible 20 AC 171n 567 counsel s 79 S 766 compensation 12 AC 375n mandamus 54M allowance dl57 80 M 663 79 337 167 570 ordinance s 79 S 747 81 130 sanit'ry code 61 M 125 police power 61 M 408 579 tend costs s79S a 180 NY sl2 AC remedy 169 515 drainage s 79 S US review 122 520 award 79 S r 176 NY sSlS do 147 774 505 1022 138 10 517 584 presumptn. 530 exceptions s 79 S 677 33 pleadg spl. dam 87 72 f 105 379 111 340 12 AC 26n 18AC 218n, 222n restrict proof 197NY inadmissible 20 AC 167n 534 deposit s79S S12AC intent 122 no delivery do 147 630 351 536 annulment s 79 S 657 r 178 NY 64 540 chg venue s 79 S 886 * 176 NY 465 546 retroaction 8 76 S 805 79 S 684 do 96 209 103 . 224 ins. vested rights 110 733 15 AC 414n 17 AO 296n 84 OoSOjegis. power 810ll30 548; 484 consideratn s 79 S 914 139 106 486 amendment s 79 S 631 118 - 13E prospective 75M forfeiture 20 AC 264 55n 209 488 323 607 560 340 158 1104 550 39 527 636 347 634 sp. perf ornce 3 79 S 489 a 175 NY good title 124 boundary 96 II s79S 79 80 104 633 support 3 79S a 177 NY s79S a 180NY 95 149 152 40 M easement 181 778 560 51 742 303 438 365 589 cancel judgt. 79 S 732 e 44 M Sit 15 AC 119n 596 admr. title 79 S 753 45 M 638 intent 140 199 607 admr. title s 79 S 947 45 M 533 election 59 M 306 title executor 138 165 authority 138 166 620 civil service 79 S 671 r 175NY 19 f 82 644 comisnrs, judici act £98 64 626 alimony 7U S 612 103 44 strct constructc 629fact question case 1 s79S 1145 a 176 NY 691 new trial s79S 1126 a 176 NY 589 our children" case 15 s 79 S 1133 a 177 NY 39 630 highways case 7 79 S 1146 m 177 NY 465 19 appeal 79 S 1134 179 NY 543 632error charge case 2 516 161 fence 470 635 neglig dam case 1 s79S 8 92 637 appeal case 2 s79S 178 NY 650 623 907 587 639 mandamus e2 S79S 1142 174 NY 526 640mechan. lien s 79 S 523 a 176 NY 589 64 1 raechan lien D 78 640 s 79 S 521 176 NY 586 643 mandamus :ase 8 rSOS 1146 a 173 NY 651 644reinstatemnt case 26 9 80S r 174 NY appeal ase 31 3 80S 175 Ni: •■181 NY ippeal ase 37 s 80 S a 17S N Y 1149 87 113S 500 503 US 139 I9A0 desertion 119 133 abandonment e 152 69 412 368 178 84 881 1138 564 645 legal intent -jase 11 3 81 S 62 122 541 i 178 NY 94 trustee life ten. do 145 797 ABBREVIATIONS: a, afarmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m. modified; *, dismissed; n note- c. criticised ; 1, limited ; e, explained ; o, overruled ; s. same case ; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q^ questioned Vol. 79 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division VOL.79 I restrictions B 79S 822 132 627 161 105 enforcement 140 627 i 170 695 covenants f 163 362 e 163 363 20 AC 76n 6 pers. inj. 8 79 S 825 89 345 95 ,. 237 safe conditn. St. 105 363 Jiability fl53 210 proprietor liable 153 214 1 5 constitutl s 79 S 900 83 197n c 83 199 o 83 202 86 342 89 182 45 M 179 47 M 151 e49 M 107 187NY 94 19AC 387 cominission 86 338 13 AC 322n 13 AC 328 misdemeanor tS AC 332 une^TtDstitutional J 15 704 inapplicable lOlM 221 24iuri8dictiDn B 79 S 906 94 402 41M 290 71 M 70 f 87 M 278 information d 43 M 296 grand jury 113 41 specified crime 77 M 198 i 87 M 280 prohibit writ 104M 686 26 s 79 S 93C f 172 942 32review «79S 1017 81 439 neg.que'''t'n fact 49 M 250 contrib. neglig. 136 766 dismissal ermr 76 M 196 for jury 76 M 197 37 tenant b79 S 1066 s 84 581 93 515 assumed risk 59 M 201 39bill partic. 8 79S 978 19AC 8n 41 discretion s 79 S 698 91 ^69 amendmt terms 12 A C 368n 12 A C 370n-ln AllllKKVl.ATl r, , n .P,J . I. h 43 civ war vetn' 8 79 S 828 44 M 630 45 carrier s79S 12 AC 785 493 386n 49 amendment 8 79 S 718 131 80 V2 AC . 368n lerms costs ICPNS 246 review 67 M 239 56 executor s 79 S 1080 e 44 M 185 .62 master neg. 8 79 S 1050 s 175 NY 498 a 178 NY 620 competency , 80 M 5G5 conditions 179 840 67 contract s 80 S 62 a 178 NY 599 memorandum 175 86 charge parol 181 417 78 audH s79S 1111 113 533 r 174NY 259 illegal 158 _ 332 conclusive 179 139 32 mandamus s 79 S 710 r 174 NY 450 94 mandamus * 79 S 934 .*175 NY 513 * i75 NY 614 98 transfer tax 3 80 S 336 a 175 NY 613 89 363 refund 97 438 f 164 858 law e rror p 61 M 180 181 cour t power f 119 123 100 amendment s 80 S 38 106 260 1 02 priority s 79 S 979 m 176 NY 293 1 1 1 warranty damage B 79 S 829 106 104 I 1 9 costs stay 3 79 S 708 81 149 109 147 91 549 139 728 66M 568 9 12 AC 328 17 AC 324 121 prox cause s80S 114 r 178 NY 118 130 amendment s 80 S 82 s 12 AC 367 67 M , 235 1 34 discharge s 79 S 1039 8 12 AC 362 136 resignation s 80 S 338 a 174 NY 247 80 581 85 receivers 144 483 d 155 328 70 M 631 141 partnership 3 80 S 327 a 176 NY 590 do 47 M 692 limitations 57M 630 liability 138 785 206 NY 61 copartners 199 NY 380 1 49 preference 8 80 S 296 a 174 NY 531 79 167 110 569 156 qualificat'fa s 80 S 274 142 125, 130 preference 142 123 I 7 1 negl. dam s80S 4 97 . 143 sparks engine 108 76 174 will s 81 S 231 r 180 NY 360 reversal 185 635 1 79 coUat. attack s 79 S 1100 106 322 1 83 office s 80 S 85 r 174 NY 417 term c 88 245 constitutional . 79 643 a 199 US 1 franch. tax 196NY 68 214 defense s SO S 107 126 500 2 1 Slight of way s 79 S 807 153 446 f%r"" 799 a 179 NY 539 249 damages s 79 S 936 a 178 NY 451 254 death neg s 79 S 890 d 188NY 645 contrib. neglig. 208 NY 362 not defense 20.8 NY 364 260 warranty s79S d. 83 8 105 money had 111 recovery 117 ex contractu 124 225 title 3 79S s 103 1013 598 236 jurisd ction s 7HS 1114 19AC 50n disinterment I 9 AC 52n 239 r r negl s 79 S 697 a nS-NY 554 invitation 125 646 242 meas dam, s 79 S 695 |42M 349 791 28 287 616 351 146 264 gift wife s 79 S 592 a 176 NV 603 12 AC 367n 69LHA 36d contract tort 38 CP 366 prepond ev 129 617 absol. gift 19A0 243n punishment 72 M 428 267 contempt 8 79 S 687 a 176 NY 604 44 M 339 misconduct 72 M 429 272 novation 8 79 S 744 a 178 NY 621 97 303 32 188, 3211 15 AC 260n 277 r r tax s 80 S 128 a 177 NY 189 291 pub. policy s 79 S 579 50 M 297 alimony 110 548 172 824 fom divorce 16AC 212-13n 218n intervention 138 271 h & w. Contract 18AC 23 recorder f 92 M 418 296 executor SOS 76 a 177 NY 538 19A0 121 122n accounting 114 460 536 45 M 82 allowance 50 M 496 services f 172 530 55 M 183 refunding 77 M 295 profits assets 77 M 295 authority 77 M 296 extra compenstn 77 M 297 f 77 M 298 306 certiorari 8 80 S 452 * 174 NY 530 3 1 incojnp ev . s 79 S 688 42 M 51 328 removal 8 79 S 764 a 178 NY 46 d 178 NY 49 remedy f 172 934 334 pers injur 8 79 S 369 a 177 NY 16 respond, superin 112 666 ISAC 36< charit. institut'n 112 666 liability 178 99M 657 ISAO 37311 taxation 66M 12] 358 eq. suit 6 79 S 434 a 175 NY 467 146 40 362 master neg s79S 1106 86 196 88 620 105 act God 102 12 ONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; I, folio wed; r, Ited ; e. explained : o, overruled ; s. same c ase : do, 369 contract s 79S 622 ISAC 119n 373 goodwill 8 79 S 583 86 113 s 12 AC 277 384 intent 8 79 S 470 426 adulterate milk 102 lS9n 162 incompetent ev. 140 71C [or jury 140 700 exculpa*.? nrooi 140 TOP 396 conviction s 79 S 454 f 96 485 486 8 12 AC 286 plea in bar 65M 455 402 reasonable s 79 S 449 68 M 54 presumption 179 20 414 center st s 79 S 1060 112 622 4 1 9 transf elm s 79 S 444 a 175 NY 509 426 judgment s 80 S 36 a 179 NY 551 compliance 73 M 273 intent not cure 79 M 566 433 notice SOS 65 a 178 NY 213 do 81 551 B 12 AC 313 compliance 119 ~ 689 distinction 200 NY 398 447 hiring entire 125AD 99 s SOS lOU limitations 74 M 447 460 salary 8 80 S 522 a 176 NY 473 f 79 645 e 94 138 475 separation cont. s 80 S 44 14 AC 258n 48 1 fraud transfr s 79 S 736 s 1U2 148 case 16 insurance 1 12 902 do 902 lien on realty 183 831 519 n. disc. ev. 8 SO S 680 100 219 527 security s 81 S 119 49 M 207 pers. property 85 M 228 change will 220NY 443 not dispose 183 338 54 1 remittitur 8 SIS 101 41 M 89 jurisdiction 75M 3u 546 child neg. 8 SO S 174 d 85 598 550 amendment s 80 S 454 a 178 NY 578 56 I judgment - 80 S 143 . 84 268 162 2 conclusive 133 824 do 166 338 65M 628 81 M 217 final 70 M upon merits 1" chat mortgage 66 M 374 e375 coUat .attack 69 M 337 583 discretion 8 SO S 316 108 287 f 170 322 182 43 43 M 408 587 negl b80S f91 95 ev. 177 376 108 59 1 collision B SO S 191 a 176 NY 610 error court 167 363 596 admiss'ty s SO S 4.S5 69 M 567 parol proof f 82 M 433 601 attach insur, s SO S 428 109 678 6 1 4 diBcovery - B SO S 277 SO 625 inspcn books d 87 474 e 103 35 13 AC 453n laches 13 AC inspection p 116 objections 159 f 184 184 2 80 M 185 modification do 166 342 legal rights 185 59 565 construction s 80 S 285 a 179 NY 850 ordinance 81 131 conviction case 2 142 U08 570 decision s 80 S 462 89 , 72 fraud transfer 103 407 bankrupt assets 47 M 464 72 M 210 preference 120 215 461n 891 763 943 6 1 8 certiorari 8 80 S 385 a 176 NY 114 626 discovery 8 80 S 154 13 AC 455n 13 AC 4S6n inspct books 140 AD 528 631 seperatn ev. case 3 s 79 S 613 99 284 amendment 77 M 632 632 allowance case 1 8 80 S 37 e95 209 184 953 634 m. prosecu. case 2 3 80 S 2 8 119 438 ad'l evidence 80 M 24 635 devise case 2 81 S . 918 m 177 NY 76 636 new trial case 1 8 SOS 1135 * 175 NY ,, 465 contractual cafe 2 101 2 3 80 S 1136 mandamus case 13 sSOS 1146 I- 175 NY 196 Mlgbillpartic.^^ 45 M 266 pleading 55 M £3 reversed; m, modified: *, dismissed; n, note; c. dissenting opinion; p. parallel case:q. questioued. N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division Vols. 79. 80 642 dismissal case 1 s80S a 178 NY damages ease 4 sSOS m 177 NTi appeal case 7 b80S a 174 NY 113S 594 1144 577 1146 532 1143 561 48 1145 417 53 1145 417 53 1145 417 53 417 643grade crossing case 16 s80S a 176NY a 199US constitutional case 7 rSOS r 174NY e 199US case S s80S r 174NY a 199US case 9 sSOS r 174NY a 199US case 10 r 174NY case 15 grade crossing s SOS 1151 644 new trial case 2 sSOS a 178NY appeal case 3 sSOS a 177NY case 4 s80S alTBNY case 5 deny new trial s 803 1131 a 180NY 525 case 10 s80S a 177NY case 20 s80S r 177NY case 21 s80S a 178NY VOL. 80 I pleading s 80S 518 42M 413 denials lOAC 241-2n not demurrable 95 M 169 170 defective 172 589 8 explos'n neg. sSOS a 176NY 175 611 12 services s80S a 176NY 95 f92 dl20 54M recovery d7SM civil service 116 332 168 609 310 621 541 60 34] 1137 20 marriage s 808 184 00 17!) s 181 NY 481 depositions e 180NY • 8' burden deft. 64M 580 reversible erroi f 176 565 24 pers inj 626 3 80S 513 |d43M 636 negligence 11481 107 231, 232 580^^'i^nary care 198 M 39 1149 degree care 553|185 875 3 1 freight s SOS 226 40M 643 I carrier neg. 1138 134^ ,. •liel oAsI burden shipper 1 134 418 11441 show fact 73 1130 600 645 r r extensn case S sSOS a 178NY appeal case 12 sSOS a 17SNY salary case 14 sSOS a 175NY case 15 sSOS e94 new trial case 16 sSOS a 178NY mandamus case 18 5 SOS a 176NY tax case 23 sSOS a 177NY 1144 75 1131 601 1130 474 1135 138 1132 558 1132 564 134 417 37 contr. neg. s SOS 231 94 395 104 527 512 747 443 541 244 1147 576 646 new trial case 3 E 80 S a178NY 40 inspection 1 80 S 120 106M complaint 62 11 discovery fl48 67 M 561 562 jurisdiction 176 842 43 adjudication ■? SO S 146 98 . 260 decision required 113 864 direct judgt 37 CP 157 in writing do 144 separately 176 53security nee. B SOS 233 135 15 functus, guardn 160 308 judgment f 160 authority d 210 NY 888 511 55 divorce sSOS 83 misconduct 76 M 187 372 669 63 express trust s SOS 49" 121 534 suspension void 76M 87 invalid 181 513 73 will proof 3 SOS 410 a 175NY 471 ILRANS 1000 COM 270 77 jurisdiction sSOS e98 a 175NY s 176NY e41M 59M 475 124 304 563 210 567 72M 595, 620 85 corporation 438 S 180 89 703 s80S r 177NY 178 90 M binding 147 enforcement 175 486 authorized 178 596 98 evidence s SOS 413 previous trial !)5 390 ( 03 default s SOS 504 80 626 holder for value excuse Proof a 175NY 525 126 300sl76NY 560 res ipsa loquitur legacy* interest 126 786 16AC lS7n burden plaintiff 228 US 241 1 44 res psa loq. SSOS SlO delay dismiss 106 592 112 . 183 dismissal 116 232 17AC 177 179n 17AC 243n neglig. burden 119 64 delay trial 38 CP 141 neglect trial 324 355 62 430 38Cp laches 134 good faith 137 covenants 69 M delay unreasonable 155 S06 1 45 warranty s 80 S 552 90 79 s 12 AC 416 jury trial 64M 124 ounterclaim 551 903 44 injunction 3 SOS 288 131 840 granting relief d 75M 2r»9 1129|valua holder 61!) 62 M 347 33 431 301 201 106 109 525 295 103 4SM r2m: SIM bonafides 113 53M 59M full amount 174 defense 174 296 N. Y. Eule 224XY 537 1 1 5 books of acct. ev s SOS 347 5 90 157 s 12AC 399 19AC 194n 195n 199n 200n memorandum 56M 562 acct. stated 157 122 appeal 3 SOS a 177 NY 1 36 appeal notice S80S S12AC 582 296 537 144 waiver d 73 M 1 6 1 waiver 8 SOS 13 AC 356 526 472n 164 discovery sSOS 109 dllS 124 428 41M 53M e53M 95 M 18AC 39CP affidavit 52M 643 improper 140 805 bill particulars 150 124 1 67 mandamus 529 16 590 854 628 317 437 255 535 442 194n 72 74n beneficiary ROM 619 eventual estate 146 92 ( 94 accounting s SOS 321 r 178NY y 206 estoppel s 80 S 188 f 88 M 285 2 1 BUDway s 80 S 536 229 a 173 NY 470 construction 55 M 140 mandamus 153 292 provoked s SOS 225 140 313 plea broad as charge 141 310 294 jurisdiction sSOS 244 61 M 386 95 M 492 496 designation 1CPNS 207 295 pers. injury 73 M 524 765 647 698 496 809 138 580 134 233 iijfant a SOS charge care 79 eSo 106 fact question 113 131 do 166 238 income s 80 S f 86 M "profits' ' 178 679 243 meas. darn . s 80 S W4 295 conclusive d 121 800 80 246 construction s 80 S 250 93 40S !5 1 hide over 8 80 S 247 12 AC 407 254 no interest 844 87 s 80 S 208 NY 258 dower a 179 NY sSOS 163 549 24] 358 sSOS do 89 do 89 do 145 73M abolition 103 51 M remove hearg. 135 21 reinstatement 135 221 alter writ 76 M SIM lOOM veteran act 420 58 55 602 255 363 77 389 342 579 84 M remedy 213 NY not party 91M 189 136 necessary party 218 NY mem 1 260£re iusurnce sSOS 256 a 177 NY SS^ 30 h3l 217 NY 346 estoppel 112 fi02 waiver 151 267 f 151 270 262 damag es sSOS 249 13AC 73n 74n 272 broker ins s80S 238 a 17SNY 551 policy void 74M 76 s80S a 177NY 161 authority dl35 244 581 637 845 301 jury trial s SOS 691 f 133 398 305 depositions 8 80S 741 10511 725 309 highway s SOS 1034 a 180NY 524 3 1 3 maudamus 3 SO S 726 * 176 NY 668 eligible list 69 M 81 discretion f 160 28 3 1 6 negl. dam s 80 S 76/ a 178 NY 688 proximate cause 166 889 320 waiver bSuS 94 357 constitut'l 8 80 S 84V 119 . 463 special sessions 154 542 359 imPeach2n''t s SOS 692 a 178NY 474 s86 441 86 446 362 investment s SOS 755 117 896 legacy intent 57M 534 business exr. 19AC 114], liable executor 19AC 123n 364 ejection s SOS 710 13AC 65n 13AC 78n 367 discharge 8 80 S 691 162 516 368 appeal SOS 7.38 51M 664 8CP 393 adoption 18AC 119p. 371 inad. dam. s 80S 96!3 87 68 378 lev.v fees SSI S e44M 68; 290 324 inference S 80 S 71 129 567 326 lunacy 8 80 S 917 12 AC 365n crriginal procdg. 129 587 vacate order 64M 283 333 acceptance sSOS 8 12 AC surrender 136 339 IJtle SSOS a 178 NY 264 178 trusts 386 Is SOS 563 280 certiorari s SOS 309 r 175NY 304 284 revoke a 179NY 522 s SOS 251 ILRANS 345n qualification 17AC 339n 747 436 724 570 342 cond.precdt s SOS 075 197 NY 319 133 810 per. injury d 137 69 defense pleaded 142 53 89 M 114 time essence 214 NY 106 new cause do 214 NY 113 348 power sale s SO S 829 59 M 140, 142 352 negligence s SOS 780 12 538 liability 82 625 384 upon merifs ESO S 73'o 79 8^* 597 power court 114 802 do 135 882 revera, error 121 523 mandamus 61 M 363 special verdict 137 847 distinction do 148 877 29« 607 28S no power 157 388 refimd SSOS a 175 NY e 179 NY order 97 438 Burrog. powers 1 19 125 e41M 417 modification 51 M 183 power court 153 87 395 incohipeten s 81 S 30 114 46t hen 63M 620 claim vs. Innatie 19A0 73n 75n 19 AC 79 representative 72 M 258 398 l^roof neglig a 80S 1008 f 105 364 105 622 law question ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed: d, distinguished- f followed- r rrvrroil • ». _»j;<: j • j- ■ ...Hticised: 1, limited; ,. explained: o.overrl.ed:n:.L'^l'^:rVi.s«S^'g Vols. 80, 81 N. Y. Supreme Coort Reports — ^Appeflate Division 122 482 proof due care 82 M 450 402 amendment B 80 S 713 94 359 retroactive etict 20 AO 52n 407 pool selling S80S 02!) 87 75 enilty knowldge « 92 M 69 4 1 acccounting I04U 694 al76 NY 11 487 mark title s 81 S 110 102 262 16AC 133 19A0 380 ev. execution 104 490 acknowledgement 16AC 342 346n certification 142 474 147 533 494 limitation 8 80S 95 M law action 84 87 i28 178 incidental 157 413 agency s 81S 128 543 538 667 696 719 89 570 81 S al76NY 91 d 170 89 M 493 jurisdiction 3 SO S 704 42 M 538 55M 269 retaxation costs 368 at- 415 medical tendance s 81S 214 r 176NY 201 433 stairway 58 M conversion 125 499 check 9 81S a 176 NY opinion ev. 66M s81S m 177NY pavement 51M 434 notice sSlS comply 102 «106 226 190 440 124 90 379 508 damages s 81 S 187 Rno a 178 NY 593""° 448 jurisdiction 872 465 582 583 125 151 233 656 S! 585 G31 101 8] s80S a 176NY 143 143 e44M e44M disorderly 137 d7M 543 71M commitment 143 65M authority 140 repeal 7GM construction oifenses 143 682 5So 71 M S2 legisl. power 143 586 458 master neg s 81S 109 44M 210 authority 121 712 do 160 684 scope employ d 72M ■ 390 liability 151 521 522 465 waiver B 81 S 133 188 726 477 ejection s 81 S 106 13 AC 61-63n harmless error 13 Ai^ Sn 480 salary S81 S 139 591 608 457 711 659 192 611 159 lien 572m S80S 103 107 e42M notice lien 123 162 f 162 filing lien 206 NY 73 M 578 appeal S80S * 178 NY 85 794 571 283 133 77 55 58 33 430 839 572 585 negligence s 80 S 1022 119 80) 599 burden prof s SOS 1011 19AC 286n favor, inference 19A0 287n test capacity 149 490 .,„ 99M 254^°-'° prima facie ev. '%^i^^^ 638 review case 1 flSlS 121 640 will case 10 s81 S a 177 NY new trial 11 s 81S a 177 NY mandamUii cdfle ] 7 sSlS 176 NY civil service a 106 damages case 26 sSlS r 178 NY 353 362 1127 527 1125 551 1140 674 29 1127 347 64 1 neg. risk case 2 81 S r 178 NY appeal case 4 1132 377 VOL. 81 I submission s 80 S 775 a 176 NY 597 by-laws ina, 14 AC 193n retroactive effct 20 AC 4711 1 fiduciary 1 80 S 979 86 , 436 jomder eq. act'n d 119 431 49 M 352 51 M 345 pleading 118 818, 124 jurisdiction dollS 118 828, accounting 37 CP 82 M trustees duties 82 M 622 single transactn. f 98 M 60 605 indemnity S80S a 178 NY 23 :S8l S 'do 111 1119 566 1136 916 212 147 79 M 573 122 80 S 20 AO 5l4misjoindsr a »i S 129 do 166 661 e49M 3 14 AC 39n 526 waiver s 80 S 1028 129 610 527 contract s 80 S 864 non-performance B9 00 104 167 541 notice s80S 83 83 87 240 .396 782 705 339 355 617 246 51 622 chge grade damag es s 80 S 842 47M 220 5'ipeachmnt 127 546 18 AC 453n 454n explain d 157 402 not impeach 173 041 1 strike out 447 26 1 legacies 8 80 -S 878 a 177 NY 653 273 injunction s 80 S 837 do 151 308 282 error agent b80S 81 do 95 a 179NY estoppQ^ t 170 886 290 610 53i 854 287iu3. aswer a 80 8 ! a 179 NY 535 29 1 discretion 8 80 8 912 381 error reverse 861 236 195 614 53n 848 565 776 8 SOS m 178 NY affidavit 112 ordinary care i 164 118 164 119 ne-vf trial 184 322 441 bill partic. 480 construe nrd 8 80 S 851 d98 493 trust sSOS 43 M gift 52M cotenancy 152 perpetuities 152 legatee 89 M 591 libel s 81 8 359 114 178 spl. damages 456 453 172 172 18 AC 177 933 593 extension 196'sSlS 422 a 178 NY 464 251 liability 117 373, 695 19 452 612 635 certificate case 4 s81 S a 178 NY case 7 s 81 8 a 181NY dismissal case 1 1 s81 S a 176 NY 1151 208 1132 585 1134 673 1143 557 1119 591 750 526 203 d 165 £ 97 M 596 inj. neg. sSlS a 177 NY sui juris" 410 652 51 2 liable agent i,™^^' g^^ S81S ^03Z\sr''"'s5, 136 196 a 180 NY 44 M lack authority 646 ■ 236 140 e 93 M payment 155 178 220 NT 833 544 603 amendment sSl S 131 ,,„ 12 AC 513 costs 1 109 241 530 civil rights s 81 8 384 r 180 NY 341 543 retroactive 81 S 482 351 80 371 158 245 1 143 ICPNS amend costs 98 31P 58M 347 67 M 239 terms appeal 124 523 cond prcdt T55!63 M 51 559 corroborat'n 606 trespasser s 81 8 114 158 562 r r neg 80 8 a 178 NY 79IS81S Sield 127 41i41 M assume risk 183 NY 1063 complaint 627f50M 396 841 403 73 349 s 80S 112 affidavit 148 8 80S e 100 do 102 48 M , 14'AC error ev. 118 615 incompet. ev, d oils 140 201NT 490 misconduct 62 M 310 inadmissible 151 398 e 78 M 42]|sS0 prejudice a 180 NY 161 393 104 llife estate 386 Jurisdiction 160 M s81S 452 decree r 176 NY lif 182 826 776 party 764 444fact question „ 3 80 H 945 905 a 177 NY 664 848 £ 94 610 do 103 321 pap. court 16AC 97n 443, garty acctg. 1067 515 464 503 909 567 forgery i6 1 4 insurance 8 81 8 519i authority r 177 NY 434is 81 8 i |f 50 M 349 576 pldg. default c I -7 . _ s 81 S .366(617 damaaa s81 8 61 M new trial 132 serve copy 1G5 225 if >81S basis 373 |4 108 954 356 359 477 478 252 622 persl tax sSlS a 176 NY 41 Si 586 511 577 negligence s 81 S 400 •184 NY b97CU"j^ 582 jurisdiction |626 default s818 619is 81 S 366 93 339 340;d53M 261 e96 111 f 99 172163 I injunction 131 832 case 2 157 306 3 80 S 1029 161 83sid 53M 372 178 663 ''a5e3 appeal 636 appeal case 1 s81 S a 178 NY dismissal case 39 a 81 8 al77 NY def petition. 39 CP 137 objn. jurisdictn. ICPNS 28 638 amendment case 2 s 81 8 186 12 AC 369n books as ev. 19A0 194n 34 f appeal case 1 s81 8 a 178 NV 645 appeal case 15 3 81 S a 177 NY no tax f 79 M 96 M taxation 95 M 646 decision case 3 3 81 8 a 178 NY case 5 new trial s81 8 a 179 NY services case 7 s81 S a 177 NY I construction s81S 87 92 e 97 HI f 180 NY spi. damages 18AC 223n distinction 134 covenants 20 AC 434 356 162 521 481 428 903 76n 413 441 7 illegal act s 818 131 combination 68 M 534 boycotting 67 M 225 70 M 296 conspiracy 159 174 468 250 1133 626 1134 593 381 533 1143 624 1147 554 13 pers. injury s 81 8 442 94 . 396 contnb. neg. 116 159 127 690 136 343 £ 173 906 spl. damages 18 AC218n, 223n I97NT 73 obligation 146 560 inadmissible iO AC 166n I 9 partnership 9818 177NY 424 526 633 83 25 plumber s 81 S r 182 NY eorp.plumbg 1 129 218 cond. precedent 76 M 512 -^-5 reinstatement 1136 587 3 818 a 176 NY f 98 f4 4M office title 116 pub. office £ 188 NY right salary 119 61 M 412 371 61 578 886 495 467 517 37 suspension s 81 S 468 1 178 NY 559 construction 324 lg?dolOO- 654 report case 2 s818 a 178 NY case 5 ' prox. cause. 147 agreement s81S 1143 3 81 S 546 a )79 NY 547 a 176 NY 611 trust fund 655 appeal s 81 S a 179 NY case 2 _ exceptions 3 81 S a 179NY report case 9 9 818 a 177 NY judgment case 15 81 S a 176 NY s 190 NY equity case 20 s81 8 r 178 NY 1155 546 1131 539 1136 583 1120 308 84 511 594 98 513 judicial notice 145 408 reduce capital d 72 M ultra vires do 150 55 assault s81 S a 175 NY justification 18AC .iCw trial 18AC 72n, 73n 555 517 71n 65 alimony IS 81 S 1147 B 46 M 325146 M 806 152 169 .ABBREVIATIONS; a, affirmed; d, distinguished ; f. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note c. criticised , 1. limited ; e. explained ; o, overruled ; s, same case ; do. dissentinx opinion ; p, parallel case ; a. questioned Vol. 82 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division vested right 127 743 prospection 217 US 25 no authority 218US 24, 25 material 125 377 not modify 81 M 512 72 pers. judgt s 81 S 794 8 178 NY 236 84 454 124 810 do 135 610 611 d 153 63 41 M 186 42 M 252 jury trial 85 606 113 628 155 502 f 169 21 220 NY 395 lien void 53M . 103 discharge lien 118 nee. party 119 389 393 waiver 60 M 240 distinction do 185 607 undertaking do 135 608 d 81 M 557 liability 201 NY , 74 security 73 M 552 lien valid 72 M 552 q 149 729 subject lien disap. 149 726 party defendant 80 M 303 issues framed 220 NY 396 defect party 185 716 8 \ contempt s SIS 638 120 309 79 M 530 defenses 54 M 137 intent order do 223NY 507 8 6 review bSIS 718 a 175NV 503 85 660 interrogate witns 49 M f" 94 amendment 8 81 S 586 a 178 NY 559 £ 98 M 417 referee f 84 446 91 465 no power 148 772 103 jurisdiction b81S 416 50 M 469 56 M 320 14 AC 225n 107 transfer ta:i 8 81 S 428 deduction 89 353 106 219 I 1 7 stocltholder 8 81 S 848 f87 313 14 AC 41 lOPNS 09 limits tioi. 113 783 1 24 St rr nee- 8 81 S 748 a 178 NY 638 129 drctrs. fees s 81 S 708 133 623 services 161 118 1 36 interfere dam s 81 S 773 a 102 668 abrogation 61 M 473 increased costs 164 133 change plans 184 247 |44cond.precedt s 81 S 747 s 103 450 trust s 117 491 145 amend ans. « 81 S 701 45 M 270 1 47 transfer tax 8 81 S 762 r 176 NY 486 13 AC 347n te&tam. dispositn 103 353 205US 481 taxable 62 M 446 447 1 55 husband s 81 S 376 185 118, 119 a 178 NY 587 wife s nee. 91 552 48 M 397 do 49 M 238 medical services 49 M 419 liability £ 164 915 45M 419 credit wife 67 M 278 1 68 noml dam. s 81 S 725 95 68 1 73 electn law s 81 S 784 a 175 NY 415 1 93 damages s 81 S 758 e 88 386 202 reference G 81 S 737 a 177 NY 542 competency £ 163 546 2n6 death dam. 3 81 S 705 r 178 NY 242 2 I good title Case 2 s 81 S 536 f 119 872 2 1 5 ejection s81S 771 s 13 AC 66 2 1 8 tax lien s 81 S 723 r 176 NY 363 d 42 M 92 liability f 66M 348 222 inj. pleading 8 81 S 755 105 397 spl. damages 18AC 221d 227restrict prf. s 81S 752 inadmissible 20 AC 170n 230 ultra vires 8 81 S 827 Pleading 13 AO 273d authority 113 199 124 451 174 447 180 445 61 M 69 discretion 145 627 cond. precedent 148 771 must prove 103M 580 234 award 8 81 S 767 e 94 106 14 AC 339n eq action 124 244 240 discovery i 81 S 394 55 M 32 242 loan ev. s 81 S 739 u 178 NY 560 transfer note 106 559 payment judgt. 98 311 254master nee a81S 916 97 3 263 neg. burdens proof s 81 S 952 io 47 M 657 presume neg 53M 588 279 intervention 8 81 S 695 43 M 408 * 181 NY 5U3 289 error judgm t s 81 S 99" 115 494 equity 116 495 nee. party 119 391 38 CP 279 practice s 122 42 parties 155 100 306 revocation s 81 S 1079 a 176 NY 609 13 AC 251-3n fixing salary 120 98 31 I constructn. s 82 S 118; 156 543 31 R mech. lien s 81 S 946 r 180 NY 248 325 modification s 79 S 407 s 81 8 1045 e 49 M 253 335 annulment marriage e 81 S 923 f 96 39 e 111 190 137 290 177 293 8 13 AC 79 339 oredr suit b81S 931 8 91 117 not final 156 906 342 divesting s 81 S 959 138 314 residence 162 278 82 M 191 346 rent admr 8 82 S 108 a 178 NY 691 plaintiff's right 173 152 348 tr'd deed I s 82 S 1025 178 NY 629 f 87 243 354 obstruct St. 3 81 S 563 107 563 359 physicn. ev s81S 813 a 178 NY 63 a 198 US 508 waiver 20 AC 289n 362 chat mtge. s 88S 780 8 81 892 full price 116 572 actual notice 120 683 368 assessment s 81 S 898 57M 310 374 pass trust 8 81 S 861 a 176 NY ^ 597 title vested 142 !VU 380 fl3e- repres. a 81 a 871 109 611 383 incomp. ev s 81 S 1017 97 435 386 presumptn, s 81S 906 75M 49 construction do 177 521 396 acceptance s 81 S 801 f 110 916 111 409 bill lading 111 409 52M 336 80 M 44 distinclion 136 354 153 524 95 M 596 contract binding 151 684 f 171 511 not presumed 153 524 399 rers.rror s 81S 868 131 278 404 conviction s 81S 818 181 116 408 tax remittur s 81 S 823 a 181 NY 24 s 109 246 4 1 I accounting s81S 891 a 178 NY 582 47 M 305 incidental 157 719 4l3secur uost. 3 81 S 896 f 82 644 costs 103M 258 416 ex contractu s 81 S 608 111 615 124 146 4|9titleia husb. s 81 B 575 108 251 husband next of kin 146 707 superseding 79 M 539 injustice ( 89 M 29 423 nee. dam. s81S 616 do 95 629 429 liq'd. dam 8 81 S 877 d 92 343 431 chge. bencfic 81 S 855 14 AC 185n divesting 84 M 31 consent wife f 87 M 660 valid assignmt. f 172 639 89 M 229 adjudication 177 175 435 reverse error (41 S 836 48 M 646 49 M 648 larceny s 114 482 new trial fl3B 146 negligence e 134 258 445 revocation 8 81 S 567 f 82 643 s97 112 unverified ans 41 M 395 petition 116 152 unconstitut 130 649 certif. property 154 851 458 estoppel 81 b 840 * 175 NY 497 95 89 do 135 661 n. limitat d 49 M 70 ev, Pedigree 18AC 23 1 construction 53M 51 no limitation 39CP 20 471 inad dam, s 81 S 866 87 68 new trial 145 546 474 poundage 8 81 S 532 88 455 114 124 44 M 420 attachment 114 124 119 819 37 CP 187 sheriff' fees 108 313 plaintiff liable do 179 373 489 res ipsa loq. 81 S 612 89 377 48 M 618 12 A C 392 492 contrib nee s 81 S 672 529 only inference 147 695 appeals lOOM 112 826 503 trust s81 S revocation 89 373 506Jury question 81 S 830 59 M 616 509 waiver 1 S 916 20 AC 288n 5 1 6 trust 8 81 S 878 160 reasonable care 97 363 M 39 ordinary care 185 869 degree care 185 875 52 1 assumption s 81 S 828 173 195 523 impeachmnl s Ml S 603 18AC 451n,452n adverse user 127 86 law question d 140 204 527 contrib. neg s 81 S 614 a 179 NY 552 fact question 79 M 511 531 res ipsa loq 8 81,S 838 l8A(;295n 296i) inference 133 202 burden deft. 136 109 541 practice s 81 S 606 127 40 form execution 70 M 218 543 joinder s 81 S g3g> 78 M 454 553 guardian * 179NY 1ft 556 use stream 8 81 S 636 rl78NV 27a 560 3rd party B 81 S 869' d 85 85 39CP 76 amendment do 116 486, power court 116 483 191NY 207 order case 5 f 115 90S nee. parties 118 • 812 39CP SH practice 122 388 563 res ipsa, loq 18AC 296b want of care f 158 215 567 trial fee s 81 S 527 r 176 NY 213 571 laches sSlS a 178 NY 463 trust a 81 S 843 '535 mens, dam r 177 NY asT's 81 S 628 1 LEANS 91n84 678 irrevocaDle 89 373 42 M 472 466 atty. lien 8 81 S 927 a 176 NY 566 18AC 5bn s81S 84 reversal 91 IIOOM 17AC judgment f 151 899 Ipresumption I99M 340 562 111 233 n 579 618 578 suiplusage 8 81 S 576 r 176 N Y 317 580 mandamus sSlS 816 * 178 NY 632 laches 114 4 f 123 72 132 50 161 628 584 s 81 S 583 166 738 genl. averment 167 151 589 m. lien 8 81 S 848 a 178 NY 6 construction 119 219 73 M 399 costs 78 M 6S novation 98M 330 593 dismissal „ s81S 863 88 615 s 87 ^, 87 reversable error f 46 M 609 discretion 51 M 63 objection 126 167 835 936 608 sup. 3 81 S 53 M pleadg. 1057 J96 ABBKISVIATIONS : a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, e, criticised ; I, limited ; e, explained ; o, overruled ; followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, '■"''i do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel cue ; q, queitiooe* samc^ase ; N. Y» Sopreme Coort Reports — ^Appellate Division Vols. 82, 83 6 1 7 assasBment 8 81 S b81S 1014 al79 NY r 178 NY 263 appeal 94 361 Case 7 aS) S 62 1 ctrclaim s 81 S 1052 ( 120 501 ! 1144 540 VOL.83 629 new trial case 1 8 81 S 257 8S 612 45 M 120 63 1 new trial case 1 s 81 S 937 a 178 NY 586 635 new trial case 5 s81S 1126 a 177 NY 535 636 assessment case 6 a 81 S 1141 a 81 S 1128 s 99 324 326 will Case 2* 8 84 S m 180NY report case 5 c81S s 178 NY new trial Case 36 8 81 S a 178 NY 637 appeal case 36 s84 S a 179 NY negligence case 39 sSlS r 178 NY dismissal ease 40 s80S a 176 NY case 8 s 81 S f 163 a 176 NY case 8 s81S 176 NY case 13 sSlS a 176 NY 1133 326 1128 see 1144 566 1127 551 1127 458 1139 573 1124 462 639 merits disms case 1 s 81 S a 179 NY appeal Case 2 c80S b82 case 3 prepond, ev. s8l S * 179 NY 104 74M 99 M discretion 154 834 136 1130 645 803 533 96 589 32 813 640 1'esultng trust s 81 S 82] a 179 NY 653 643 appeal case 1 fil certif. nom * 175 NY 506 contr. neg case 4 "81 S 1124 r 178 NY 1 fi44confidentia case 21 s81S 1140 8 85 618 645 modify judgi case 2 6 eq relief B 81 S 1043 112695 265 5541 1 1 2 services 1122 8 81 S 1074 566'r 1793NY 156 |91 478 1125 299' 1 9 neg for jury s 81 S 963 91 404 neg. damages 126 785 2 1 requests s 81 S 1085 152 699 1102 480 |f 83 M 70 [not negligence 149 _ 821 contrib neg 129 503 f 217 NY 353 safe place d 144 666 9 1 money had s 82 S 525 67M 454 10 1 pers. injury s 82 S 485 do 89 319 carrier neg 16AC 319-20n 328[, collusion 170 27 variance s 81 S 1089 114 784 29 appeal 8 82 S 220 87 602 allegations d&m e 97 144 d 106 203 spl. darnage 18AC 220n, 223d 197NY v3 restrict proof 197NY 73 inadmissible 20 AO 16811 36 construction 8 81 S 1058 e 178 NY 543 trus.teu power d 104 120 demurrer 126 410 42 negligence s82S a 179 NY 1 56 sum pro 8 82 S 470 61 M 653 allegations 39 CP 136n surrender 66M jurisdiction 201 NY ICPNS 610 139 674 607 473 624 456 139 189 569 44 libel s82S 93 do 1-10 special damages 165 391 509 549 157 45 question enforce rule s82 S E477 133 790 95 441 54 certiorari 8 82 S 627 r 176 NY 500 84 M . 203 60 certiorari s 82 S 626 * 176 NY 558 73 carrier neg. s 82S 552 17AC 417n 433n 82 contract s82S a 178 NY 185 NY negligence 113 admissible 145 503 595 208 220 84 mecfi. lien s 82 S 515 109 461 reversal 122 882 88 reasonable care 82 S 527 f 113 690 negligence 1 05 reliet B 82S 64M repeals do 135 illegality 140 construe lib'ly d 140 609 86 M 508 value land 67 M 497 remedies TO M 317 f 83 M 365 presumption 76 M 650 taxpayers suit f 168 236 77 M 363 f 83 M 164 maintain suit f 155 759 1 20 consent walk s 82S 466 r 181 NY 120 1 23 separation 3 82 S 568 106 lis presumption do 121 624 domicile 71 M 46 20 AG BOn not defense 76 M 672 domicile husbnd 154 497 1 30 constr Dtce a 82 S 483 do 62 M 487 ICPNS 271 133 estoppel s 82 S 474 f 86 M 640 137 constitut'nal s 81S 1049 f 102 265 change grade r 179NY 393 estoppel 134 79 1 4 1 demand note s 82 S 481 s 13 AC 144 waiver 101 282 1 44 cartman 3 82 S 489 Lien 87 SO s 13 AC 154 146 corpn.waiver 8 82 S 561 a 180 NY 524 1 52 waste, facts s 82 S 449 1102 .340 1 57 trustee s82S a 178 NY B13AC 1 6 1 review s 82 S do 119 516 600 100 491 292 163 upon merits s 82 S 471 80 M 185 165 jurisdiction s 82 S 514 15 AC 352n (79 authority ■• 82 S 4,99 115 704n 51M 14s implied power 67 M 303 "itrg vires 434 305 f 83 M 206 Ubel s82S r 177 NY do 84 innuendo e88 86 M malicious do 91 libe per se e93 14 AC 2 1 2 notice s82S 88 166 construction 15fi amendment f 170 587 166 366 213 495 228 263 633 221 44 608 313 543 69 147 f 67 M findings 174 878 1 84 parol ev 82 S 494 a 178 NY 637 performce excuse f46 M 570 1 89 contrib. neg s82S 185 86 390 109 209 9 1 contract 8 83 S 338 a 178 NY 570 192 NY 442 94 M 147 1 93 assessment s 83 S 106 a 178 NY 622 91 M 283 1 97 commiasion s 82 S 89 authority 86 . 342 police power 221 890 544 322-3n 332 179 621 216 single action 82 S 64 100 360 joint feasors f 93 M 340 218 Corp. electn, 3 82 S 228 115 827 inappropriate 186 220 226 not larceny s 82S 215 64M 277 d 136 23fi 237 injunction 8 82 S 124 104 470 control sts. d 54 M 434 242 rescission B 82 S 130 r 173 NY 526 fraud sale 20 AC 84n 254 construction s 82 S 37 8 89 67M "" 103 f 110 42 M 13 AC 13 AC 46 M _..._. 47M 151,343, 389 legia. power 114 , 54 constitutional 187NY 94 19A0 387 unconstitutnl 115 120 defenses 34M 704 n 352n 137 203 discontinue ABBREVIATIONS: c criMcised ; i, limited a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f. followed; 8 82S 8 93 163 consent 42M expenses s 112 recovery 148 336 773 687 679 288 pleading s82S 165 a 178 NY 671 290 trade mai ks s82S 164 13 AC 433n 292 sublease s 82 S 87 d 45 M 423 performance 54M 102 295 undertaking 8 82 S 42 43 M 425 54 M 102 no obligation f 177 240 presumed 106M 177 298 instruction 8 82 S 1 116 160 contribute neg. do 164 662 310 new trial s 82 S 65 f 162 926 seduction 183 72 3 1 9 contract 8 82 S 171 a 178 NY 594 327 new trial s 82 S 25 50 M 535 evidence 50 M 536 weight evidence 50 M 557 124 902 contract 114 creilibiity 129 80O 658 330 contrib neg 3 82 8 a 178 NY costs 239 siiSS 255 incompet. ev s 82 S 102 122 882 259 stockholder 8 82 S 104 a 178 NY 623 s 103 475 268 pldg jury 89 94 do 97 103 f 109 do 46 M 52M assumption 110 sS2S 125 entirety 131 notice 159 272 will s82S Indefinite r 176 NY 127 20 54 271 94 55 591 605-6 12 396 465 217 90 91 595 675 147 335fact state. s 82S 122 132 206 339 notice r 178 NY S82S f 83 356 f87 617 s 631 89 249 e 102 51 construction act 94 178 13 AC 86n o^o • 1 1 -J 343 assm'd risk t^b interlocjudg a82S._ 274 3 82 S s 108 trust fund 190NY 107 double coms. I90NY 107 new trustee 166 823 200 NY 463 trust duties 80 M 388 285advancem'nt s 82 S 152 176 NY 374 49!a 179 NY 323, do 97 20 379 351 notice 3 82 S 203 116 323 f 326 employ'rs liab ac f 89 246250 d 95 341 prima facie neg. s 13 AC 86 97 3 20 AC 153n condition precdt. f 102 50 . expUined:-<.:ove.Tuied7;. '^•'^■^er^J.S!:::^ o^^ft^dj^^/^r^^:^ Vols. 83, 84 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division 169 579 177 500 res ipsa loq. 123 589 18AC 297n 358 bankruptcy si82 S 280 * 182 NY 523 363 mortgage B 82 S B 180 NY 154 481 165 530 right publish 103M 636 ultra vires 185 262 270 517 370 relief s 82 S 17 AC 224 88i) 381 taxation 96 M 400 not retroactive 103M 357 388 eommissns s 82 S 284 a 178 NY 68 393 hand write s 82 S 334 a 178 NY 596 evidence 74M 419 399 partition s 82 S 299 a 13 AC 123 realty do 160 298 534 credrs claim 403 receive pobn B 82 S 198 d 105 575 46 M 28S 52M 533 54 M 406 title 38 CP 363 construction 73 M 447 4 1 4 pers injury s82S 307 s96 617 43 M 376 419 trd. assignt dismissed s 82 S 3('2 »181NY 645 113 233 482 estoppel B82S a 178 NY notice 42 M privity 49 M lability 129 joint feasor 130 conclusion 65M 66M 77 M parol evidence 200 NY 298 competency 80 M recovery 161 indemnity d 213 NY not inherent 224NY 439 49 I defense 82 S 430 120 170 on contract 165 403 amount lien f 169 82 vests lienor 185 267 lien attach 186 336 495 ultra vires 82 S 432 90 . 43 1 10 69S 13 AC 271n joint contract 100 21 107 H 141 558 347 446 89 347 547 338 110 678 267 128 aS2,S a 180 NY 98 parties lis distinction 62 M ICPNS 539 agency s81S 50 M authority 163 319 254 119 607 80 101 1114 646 596 70 M physical 184 609 neg. master s 81 S 1099 do 96 313 618 commissions s 82 S 317 f 105 404 principal 121 486 pers. liable 123 239 428 neces. party s 82 S 462 93 112 449 default s 82S 444 134 574 strict rules 143 485 452stockbrkr3 B 82 S 452 e 44 M 69J reference 61 M 443 accountings d 138 902 456 certiorari a 82 S 439 * 184 NY 560 459 injunction s 82 S 288 67 M 39 may strike 174 249 conspiracy 174 252 467 burden dft. s82S 401, n 16 149 159 do 149 159 plead privilege 150 867 privileged 509 lien fixture s 82 S 426 129 493 lien file SI M 573 5 1 3 assessment 543 chat. mtge. B 82 S 71 r 180 NY 355 right by gift do 147 461 no defense do 180 537 548 recovery s 82 S 153 96 140 ficti tious names 70 M 533 pleading d 160 121 550 jury trial s 82 S 157 93 389 bar 114 643 644 amendment 51 M 173 554 consttitunl s 82S 172 133 856 559deed as mtge a 82 S 176 p 114 643 45 M 71 limitations 161 712 565 cotmsel sSlS 1112 improp state mt 88 371 16 AC 374 100 623 vests fee S82S 90 gasement 5o 120 417 14 284 530 exemption 3 82 S 390 a 178 NY 676 11 M 473 13 AC 358n transfer tax 110 478 480 116 210 135 411 do 412 559 injury 470 a 82 S a 179NY 643 dismissal case 13 s82S 1111 a 176 NY 608 damaees case 17 B 82 S 1096 a 178 NY 339 a 82 S intention 132 189 NY 59 M construction 198NY 611 83 120 396 52 629 commissDs. case 2 3 82S authority 13 AC bill partic. 140 acquittal case 4 a 81 S do 160 473 323n No.1 S39 1097 924 632 breach dam. case 2 82 S 578 179 NY 200 57 I mandamus 82 S 21 89 68 576 covenant 634 new trial case 1 s81 S a 178 NY appeal caae 6 s81 S a 178 NY appeal case 16 81 S * 176 NY a 176 NY appeal case 19 3 81S a 178 NY a 81 S 117 153 1093 886 82S do 161 d 179 d 188NY 62M 96 M lOOM 37 CP consideration do 177 87 60 M 67 claim debtr. 129 669 tax succession 79 M 657 not taxable d 177 223NY 10211 498, 106M under will d 184 881 4 279 441 450 650 285 875 7 500 811 666 58 I notice sS3S do 90 219 NY comphance 107 114 requirement ab solute 139 1111 523 ll2fl 697 1136 635 1126 655 602 1146 556 636 coUision case 1, 1st Dept 9 320 185 191 622 82 S r 176 NY dismissal case 6 3 82S a 177 NY 639 appeal case 1 s82S a 178 NY 429 383 1096 539 76 694 876 IS 648 699 208 681 831 604 neg quea fao a 82 S 160 a 179 NY 667 s 100 227 e 110 61" fright damages 16AC 70n f 162 793 f 184 469 not nefflisent 589 forgery s82S a 176 NY 145 599 in trust 82 S a 181 NY 132 640 dismissal s 82 S 70 17AC181n 245n 641 motion a 82 R 3 187NY appeal a 189NY 74 676 606 642 distribution case 8 s82S a 177 NY case 9 judgment s82 S t 100 appeal case 1 1 s82B a 178 NY mandamus case 19 1095 532 1094 516 1106 628 VOL. 84 poSBession s 82 8 27 15 AC 362n,446n 166 907 actual notice 120 683 133 841 9 m prosecution B 82 S 369 f 89 108 fl94 NY 6 abuse process d 167 139 e 43 M 110 complaint 165 327 f 168 966 f 103M 84 public policy f lOSM 85 96 3 82 8 61 M I UO appeal e82S a 178 NY 94 declaration 123 140 admissions 146 23 motion s82S 5 82S 142 35 101)4 004 27 disniiss appea 3 82 S 193 * 179 NY 613 er, judgment 132 935 39 center st sS2S 112 178 NY suit V. state 62 M 42 death dam sS2S r 180 NY 191 622 111 194 12 178 NY 102 92 divert water s82S r 181 NY 46 M 574 80 484 ins> 551 460' 497 561 661 84T 74 1 1 reversal a 82 S 585 17AC 234n 1 05 denials a82S 126 do 127 171 42 M defense 120 157 separate 82 M 631 677 342 575 76,412 170- 671 plea 490 III refusal to charge 5 81 s loer 92 512 charge error 47 probable cause 82 S 186 r 181 NY 1 15 AC 270n 55 town chge. s 82 S 620 r 176 NY „„513 d 102 399 301 59 pers injury a 81 S 1109 e94 25 a 179 NY 569 IS AC 93 64 neg. damage 82 8 8! r 178 NY 5( 127 I 1 4 appeal b81S a 177 NY 96 costs 134 34 1102 641 64 60 1 19 joint note 3 82 8 138 109 440 1 22 mandamus a 81 8 51 M case 4 f 126 final 193 NY 1105 202 920 132 65 probate sur- rogate s 82 8 310 46 M 540 reversible error 19AC 287n 7 hwater co right lay mains s 82 S 466 a 176 NY 36 s 176 NY 696 83 clmv. town 82 S 212 go 335 d3 104 611 119 754 town board 92 18 19 127 easement property s 81 8 1041 138 466 1 29 bankruptcy s82S 80 m 179 NY 369 1 35 an'l report a 82 8 78 112 685 44 M 86 M 88 tax sale 3 82 8 r 176 NY 9 1 center st s82S 468 74 .556 424 192 138 damages 82 174 118 9 180 584 230 789 1 45 admr b82S a 177 NY f 212 NY 158 trustee action 107 ' 151 authority B 828 597 56M 398 overt act 142 182 no delivery 151 376 ABBREVIATIONS: a c, criticised ; 1, limited ; affirmed; d, distinguished; e, exrlained ; o, overruled ; £, followed; r, revorsed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; 9, lame caae ; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel ca»e ; q, queitionea N. Y. Sapreme Court Reports— Appellate Division Vol. 84 uo assent do 151 380 sustain loss 165 335 159 vest title 6 82 S 538 a 179 NY 570 construe will 59 M 316 1 68 franch tax s 82 S 621 m 177 NY 461 1 74 franch tax a 82 S 582 r 178 NY 194 227 stay 8 82 S 723 91 396 afBrmative relief 110 328 relief 181 139 235 mandamus pleading 17AC practice 106M _82S a 176 NY 218 NY 44 AI 15 AC interest plfif. 89 M 237 24 1 water meter 179 mortsage s 82 S 91 106 198 247 costs sell property s 82 S 770 142 502 s 103 591 no levy f 92 M 433 249 acceptance s 82 S 835 634 562 121 148 16SD 317 358 charee 91 459 307 Burplusaee s 82 S 609 e 93 404 406 98 666 relief equity 17AC 88n 91n 92n judgt. pleading 130 392 do 171 735 ICPNS 72 no demurrer 360 construc'n s 82 S 891 a 181 NY 518 6 193 lease possession s82S * 176 NY 184 corpn. liable s 28 239 s 1 356 1 86 dist notion sS2S 62 M ICPNS retained ICPNS 194 discovery 235 80 101 258 res. judic. s?;2S 641 98 151 18AC 196n 196 sum. pro. s 82 S 5SK 64M 37 92 M 353 96 M fi14 dismissal 38 CP 345 relief 208 NY 202 still pending BOM HI).' ■Jri7 Git may rebul 94 M 153 103 'trade 67M 260 name' ' 151 s82S a 177 NY 582 conclusive 133 824 SI M 217 fact question f 159 153 262 assignment 82 S 594 a 176 NY 386 266 biil partic 828 567 124 .TO? 128 AD 644 148 643 268 deposition 82 S 633 134 do 171 relief do 149 160 95 M 56 733 4G4 795 334 787 442 600 442 310 libelous 82 S 111 a 179 NY 186 NY special damages 112 24S 129 29 18AC 181n genera] damages 107 307 114 193 19A0 S cause action 114 179 312 damages s 82 S 576 167 810 318 prior crimes 3 82 S 749 18AC 212n inadmissible f 168 844 do46M survived 120 re -entry 56M 97 M 98 M covenant d 66M f 86 M sum pro. 61 M split cause do 196NY limitation d 184 continuous lOlM lessee liabl( 225NY 563 17 247 350 5 388 326 634 28 267 194 choice pleading 161 356 price ev. value 223NY 31 418 St. opng. tax s 82 S 965 f 181 NY 509 366 mandamus 3 82 S 916 54M 209 unauthorized 157 789 369 jurisdictn 428 parties B82ij 93 S17 163 437 strike out s 82 S 106 120 169 discretion 130 99? 533 318 785 S51 a 178 NY 628 49 1 costs appeal s 82 S 1086 s 179 NY 516 conclusive 133 664 500 attachment s 82 S 982 95 521 insuffic. allegn ' 43 M 618 on knowledge 70 M 497 502 extra work 440 niand no bar 86S 592 3 S2S e 106 papers 115 stay costs 17AC 443 m. lien S82S a 178 NY 66 M 475 178 742 601 343 3 82S 884 d86 312 d88 62 certiorari e93 475 dismissal 97 410 151 330 reinscatement 143 •JO 374 damages 201 contrib neg a 82S 726 a 177NY 344 205 beneficiary s 82S 733 a 178 NY 629 14 AC 191.. 210 remission 6 82 S 671 60 M 526 doctrine 169 . 573 cond. precedent 172 review 181 580 893 515 2 I 5 income b82S a 177 NY 170 sis AC 51 M tmstee 138 legal means 138 516 cond. precedent f 159 429 22 I contr neg. B 82 S 588 91 575 ev. defective 183 NY 2, 3, 4 master duty s35CP 117 274 authority 3 82 S 823 d 120 537 disci'etion 124 2S0 d 128 226 E 53 M 159 trustee e 63M 421 valid trust 132 142 sale power 132 145 do 134 585 f 166 827 trust void 133 99 32 I overflow 82 S a 176 NY inspection SIM due care eSlM 28 1 allegation s 82S 769 lOOM 173 287 contract B 82 S 781 3 96 366 292 BubmisBion 3 82S a 177 NY 296 bond s82S a 177 NY f87 evidence 116 evocation 52M principal f 90 M 304 default ans s 82 8 642 48 M 494 695 574 827 573 631 714 60s 771 586 34: 34f 324 iurisdic'n s 82 8 908 rl78 NY 485 91 387 104 548 654 d 43 M 263 330 review assest 82 8 sl3AC demurrer 46M 90 M 764 158 480 564 s82S 156 £ 170 175 510 bonds s83S a 176 NY 60 M 1020 12.J 220 179 63 665 234 450 contract 82 8 902 s 87 460 43 M 18 ury trial 113 62s personal judgt 119 381 recovery GSM 380 waive jury 71 M 331 455 compensatii 82 S 1027 7 M 256 nominal value 160 708 5 1 4 collision 3 82 8 1016 a 177 NY 636 90 68 right way duty 109 606 114 477 54 M 452 5 i 8 collision s82S 1047 a 13 AC 197 special damages 130 580 174 239 16 AG 464n Individ, cost 126 pleading 62 M liability 19AC con.atruction 51 M 390 relief = 82 8 686 17AC 89-90n partnership 60 M 234 accounting 67 M 416-8,486 amendment 483 poor person s 82!j 995 19AC 311n 313n defective 169 420 averment 106M 82 8 ; 99 100 ;oi pleading 190NY 334 off* ? 82S 136 341 contract 3 82 8 a 178 NY no election '147 347 waiver 3 82S a 176 NY 664 467 615 604 291 935 878 846 674 18 906 586 35 1 contempt 3 82 S 887 m 185 NY 540 104M 354 by appeal IGO 669 354 ev error s82S 912 85 477-8 82 8 1848 90 s 94 prfmce H^S 394sp 82 8 a 178 NY 136 142 64M voidable o8M affidavit 60 M practice 130 no costs B3M rule technical ICPKS 176 400 contempt s 82 S 679 96 409 s 13 AC 173 inapplicable esM 164 4 1 4 quan. meruit 83lill| 493139 M G31»«CP 1001 33 413 293 83 812 446 3, 22 403 418 12 363 409 457 19AC 448 450n _"'^ence B 187NY 13 301 construction 182 98. 575 mtgee. possn s 82 8 760 16AC 438n 582 pleading 8 828 951 d 132 405 complaint suf. 136 208 negligence 142 404 rules necessary 20 AC 139n 585 counterclm s 82S 1000 171 560 74 M 450 588 error court s 82S 1022 148 569 misconduct 153 241 591 tor jury s 82 8 957 125 290 594 b- pi.rtio. s 82 S 928 f96 91 142 71 15 AC 174 596fact queatioD 82 8 729 85 89 d 121 520 600 town bondg 104M 525 review award 3 82 8 852 do 101 430 construct notice dl48 damages 167 66-1 810 3 82 8 e93 106 coQsent 134 970 403 613 271 606 neg. error chge a 82 8 102 890 297 610 not presumed f 238 US 220 * 82 S 111 129 131 172 contract ev. 142 932 361 399 76 221 265 469 outside State 3 S3 S 33 69LIIA 446n construction 116 162 taxation do d 116 163 477 irreg. ple'g s 82 S 071) 141 911 482 eq acctg. b82S 1051 B 89 587 589 reference 134 164 partnership 154 168 534 stock servic's 3 82 8 1070 106 551 accounting d 135 408 act for self 181 13 546 credrs claim s 82 S 689 107 467 tfubject mortgage 107 468 assignable 3.5CP 100 552 termination 3 82 S 73! 120 II 555 negl. dam 8 82 S 753 a 178 NY 590 774 218 664 06 487 chat, mtge s82S 1054 613 neg. error a 82 8 778 112 279 meas. damages 56M 603 112 279 818 self defense s 82 S 996 SI M 410 621 bar debts 8 82 8 lOlO 1 7AC 328n 557 employmt s 82 .S r 180 NY 107 583 surety s82 8 a 178 NY firm debt 18AC 667 76 363 841 631 63lrevers. error 59 M 146 3 81 8 1091 632 appeal :ase 2 s82S 1097 a 176 NY 692 case 6 3 82 8 1104 a 178 NY 635 new trial case 7 3 82 8 1099 a 177 NY 531 jase 10 reference 3 82 8 1093 r 179 NY 9 case 13 stipulate costs 3S2S ma ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, noie* C criticised; I. limited; e, explained; o, orerruled; s, same case; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q, questioned' Vols. 84, 85' N. Y. Supreme Coart Reports — Appellate Division a 179 NY 545 641 appeal VOL.85 a 178 NY 60P do49M 237 21 1 joinder 355 build'ng case 15 case 6 necessaries s83S J 851 regulation B 82 S 1101 3 82S 1094 1 disbursement 83 replevin 104M 72 r 177 NY 51 3 83 S 442 a 186 NY 515 a 178 NY 696 s 82 S Q4■ 113 477 315 defect fatal a ^^ .(1A w It disclosures 635 appeal 67 M ■ 566 171 711 s 82S 541 187NY 212 case 4 discriminate 1 4 1 misjoinder t 90 M 571 148 766 ndictment s 81 S 1129 69 M 79 a 83 S 143 weight of ev. allegation 120 370 a 179 NY 655 44 M 470 114 264 308 140 277 157 22.1 canal tolls 57 eXPcution 45 M 266 116 734 89 M 602 case 10 s 82 S 96S 69 M 52 118 466 b81S 1137 r 177 NY 124 cum. penalties 17AC 231n-234n 319b. partic. too constl law r 178 NY 167 1 86 620 do 133 874 52M 58 s S3 S 366 i S3 S 460 services 37 CP 172 96 269 86 612 case 13 55 intention 145 St. limitatn Conclusive 109 687 njunctii n S81S 1140 1 82 S 918 s 83 S 559 53 M 147 reversal 122 746, 764 a 176 NY 571 59 M 52 dead body a 181 NY 439 ■eversals 131 894 160 594 bill boar is 58M 407 638 appeal TOM 20 1 54parol agreet lew trial 320 attachment cases 90 M 483 s 83 S 99 30M 563 s 83S 426 107 miLdamus 9 81S 1145 protect remains 119 556 12 M 364 a 179 NY 213 S3S 622 a 178 NY 585 70 M 2D sp. prfmance varranty t 177 NY 296 57M 442 151 772 324 iurisdicn Denalty 637 arson 68 per. judgt Supreme Court authority 9 83S „ 398 6AC 262n case 3 s 82 S 959 87 M 68 SI M 493 a 184 NY 365 conclusive s 82 S 1109 8 87 461 92 M 383 S5 346 145 648 a 180 NY 58 111 360 361 162 awa< construction 617 485 173 , 862 864 576 301 215 303 278 13 99 M possession S4M 88 M allegations f 86 M 475 f 169 483 practice 118 released f 93 M 206 110 589 222 184 485 interventior. 413 47n s83S 68LUA 369 602 92 488 defense sS3S al78 NY do 93 buffic. pleading 15 AC 69n contract void 150 738 498 sublease S £ 84 M 501 deposit s 83 S f 109 equity rule 175 477 221 334 II 204 604 732 651 369 576 631 180 a 83 8 a 176 NY 156 intent 169 183 64M GSM liquor tax 69 M ntent controls 157 307 512 notice lien 450 632 466 amendment 81 M 401 f 163 465 only complaint 173 678 230 62 1 revocatiOD case 4 a 83 S 123 13 AC 266-8n compliance 75M 173 581 contract i622non-prfrmce s83S 539 lease 5 8 176 NY 556 a 83 S 1106 a 176 NY 613 a 178 NY 369 atty'a fees excess 111 425 services 119 30 18AC 243n distinction 70 M 41 s83S a 178 NY 186 NY 89 10 e 96 364 100 442 106 406 107 281 120 do 162 59 M exaggeration 115 134 compliance 122 471 98 M 421 lib'l. constrctn. 138 568 lien invalid 1 ■ 105M 674 605 jury trial 3 83 S 396 f 215 NY 472 employment 93 M 614 . .„ 592 ccntr'b. nee 4|?3 83S 405 ,^ia]76NY 594 '"'" 91 160 164-5 98 135 120 165 "sui juris" do 133 850 sane degree 72 M 558 520 guaranty 3 83 S 343 a 13 AC 264 51 M ^ 274 dissolution 114 136 530 bulkhead a 83 S 469 a 176 NY 408 fee estate 113 ■ 86 relief damages 51 M 116 14 AC 264d title in trust 75M 314 do 217 NY 20 subservient do 217 NY 23 542 mandamus s 83 S 382 a 176 NY 567 cond. precedent do 95 M 28r 1.13 628 155 502 f 169 22 eq. action lien bJ 44 demurrer 106 341 17 AC guan. meruit d 60 M 483 personal judgmt 71 M 333 607 practice 3 ^ !j 362 6 1 I excuse case 2 s 82 S 920 78 M 17S 613 not liable s 82 S 704 146 581 6 I 4 carrier f 96 M legisl. 181 power 549 construcn 55 case 2 s82S 87 13AC 192 3 83S r 177 NY counsel fees 114 556 larceny 3 83S a 178 NY 548 86 779 372 563 1008 8C 159d 6 I 7 larceny uase 1 S83S 88 a 177 NY 526 618 judgment case 15 s 82 S 110' a 179 NY 541 562 appeal ser i vice papers 1 6 I 9 appeal s83S 285 case 18 3 13 AC 281s 82 8 1101 a 177 NY 544 564 new trial jsurplus money 83S 419, case 20 179 823 882S 1115 a 176 NY 561 575 discovery , a 83 S 428 620 appeal 98 I4'J ease 4 13 AC 450e 3 82 S 1106 petition inspectn a 182 NY 565 99 298'case 11 46 AI 194 appeal books produced s 82 S 1108 80 M 146 a 179 NY 534 case 16 577 am'd pleadg landlord liable s 83 S 287 s82S 1116 471 Ir 179 NY 273' case 7 appeal s83S a 181 NY case 16 b83S a 177 NY 1107 541 1111 530 623 obstruction case 1 s82S 1111 a 178 NY 672 francliise tax case 2 b83S a 178 NY case 3 a S3 8 a 178 NY appeal case 6 s83S a 176NY 1114 573 1115 673 Ills' 531 demurrer s83S * 181 NY case 9 appeal 3 83S a 177 NY case 11 s82S e96 e86 ice inj 15 AC 1116 544 1113 536 577 431 223 mun. liab 323n 624 title entirety case 11 82 S s 100 appeal case 13 s82S a 178 NY case 14 3 82 8 r 177 NY ca^e 18 s82S » 177 NY 1094 117 1099 637 1116 631 1117 650 VOL. 86 I sup'proceeding i 838 423 a 177NY 556 record verdict 105 637 9 information s 83 8 245 94 398 401 * 183 NY 569 94 M 508 jurisdiction e 44 M 152 57 M 656, 657 commitment 65M 654 disorderly 137 233 71 M 81 legis. power 140 101 lepeal 71 M 81 construction 71 M 82 offenses 143 94 collat. attcck a 83 S 538 a 180 NY 548 conclusive 185 276 96 exr. cnmisans, s 83 S 630 46 M 399 16AC 410n425n not assignable 76 M 585 statutory 94 M . 39 1 1 negl dam. s 83 S 624 96 I 10 good will 3 83 § '. 121 : firm name 17AC 583 14 rule liable a 83 S 714 117 595 liability 117 596 599 19A0 403 res ipsa loq. 18A0 286n trespass 94 M 649 33 accounting s 83 S 193 120 871 a 152 8Ub 46 reduction as- sessment 8 83 8 1114 f 101 a 178 NY jurisdiction 117 superseded 104M 50 sureties 8 83 S 120 liable f 160 55 em domain s 83 S 613 a 176 NY 301 66 ins. descript'n 6U9 577 237 521 669 83 8 a 181 NY 22C 472 73 new trial 3 83 8 236 51 M 581 84 M 461 reverse error 56 M 565 rule verdict e 127 314 for jury 153 692 76 m prosecutn 8 83 8 415 s 13 AC 308 83 accident ins- 106 490 202 breach dam. 8 83 8 627 r 179 NY 399 1 1 5 ins. vacancy s 83 8 456 a 179 NY 567 not recalled 141 relief 174 378 126 wharf right a 83 S 325 a 179NY 206 1 36 libel per fc 207 tax" redeem 8 83 8 670 109 643 645 21 I pers injury 3 83 S 672 r 176 NY 324 2 1 7 tax pyr. suit s 83 S 667 a 178 NY 636, authority. d 57M 474 ,-221 icy sidewalk *2 s 83 8 620- 96 430. 15AC 322n 224 tax deed s 83 8 643 44nal77NY 530 •• redemption do 161 7 83 8 107 140 pi 8 83 S a 177 NY also NY 152 notice s 83 S 95 M 226 chg. tonef. .„., 8 83 S 659 303 a 177 NY 546- 14 AC 195n - 60 M 426 - 233 construe contract a 83 8 641 - do 105 54- 236 party int. 133 87 lien 499 s83S 13 AC defense 120 554!°° ^'sy ■lio.l- 170 ''^i 218- NY 897- 16Sn, 12 579 ■ 28 - 1 59 alienation s 83 8 6-28- 128 803 632 240 chge realty 82 3 83 S 75], |a 179 NY 338 construe will 56 M 159 . 163 strike out 3 83 8 175 do 115 794 ^ 95 M 245 neg. iuoomp. ^83 8 833- r, 179 NY 7- f 169 785|247-iSvestmenta 86 M 549^. lilt'-' -'?6ii-ii-'^ '^^ a 13 AC* 298^ ^ demurrer r 185 NY 381. 106 estab. DM 80 618 crcdit'jrs 174 254 taxation 1 72 anouiXies - a 83 8 s 178 NY, a 179 NY 114 bar a 114 intention 75M:- 1 79 devise a83S- a 176 NY. a 180 NY 3 83 8 e93 fl63 judgment do 140 614 238 366 558 noi 89 fact question s 83 8 140 43 M 102 breach warranty 1013 607 581 629 639 501 213 608 a 83 8 a 181 NY 838 614 1 128 608 - right to fish 154 371 260 trust 8 83 8 r 177 NY IS8 819 ' 117 263 evidence negligence s 83 S 692 168 471 . 265 commisBs pera. -injury 3 83 S 259 a 178 NY 635 not 1 delegated f 217 NY 598 t 217 NY- 599 I95i e83i 120 iresumptlon i 149 262 .3 83 8 130 267 corpn. by-laws 3 83 S 109 employment 79 11 710 420 663 . 48 243 AUBCEVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d. distinguished: C criticised ; 1, limited ; e, explained ; o, overruled ; s 270 veteran s 83 8 789 r 176 NY 462 : 'salary f. fol lowed ; r, reversed ; m, modified ; •. dismissed ; n. note ■ same cue; do, disMntingiopiiiraii;. Ppparalld-casc^ q, quettioneit- > Vol. 86 N. Y. Supreme Coart Reports — ^Appellate Division 44 M 530 removal trial 47 M 523 crim. contempt 160 867 by certiorari 160 669 278 contempt s 83S 843 149 248 circumstances f 171 272 284 assignment s S3 S 763 s 13 AC . 318 costs execution 104 24 109 757 false pretence arrest e 45 M 213 negligence 16AC 10 286 transfer tax s S3 S 825 106 20 a 176 NY 570 6SM 444 s 13 AC 347 jurisd. limit. 65M 445 powers 146 remainder 204NY 270 ijot taxable 349 271 26 69 383 260 697 457 83n 400 487 204NY 82 M f 95 M 106M taxable 204 NY construction 80 M taxation 157 f 172 290 will s 83 S t 121 149 court power 19A0 287n extra allowance 19A0 289n test, capacity 141 19X 293 neglig. care' s 83 S 823 a 181 NY 582 prepond. evid. 185 796 296 signals s 83 S 795 42 M 153 13AC415n417n son contingent s83S ROfi 70 M 38 303 income s83S 747 125 712 53M 204 3 1 dismissal s83S 70S 117 44b authority e 87 575-6 88 62 91 5H2 e97 409 erasures ev. 89 29t extr.penalty 130 715 substantial 143 20 reinstatement [abandonment 20 348 21 21 735 143 £ 162 reversal 143 rehearing 143 new trial 149 3 1 6 signals s 83 S 827 42 M 153 13 AC 426n contrib. neg. 42 M 165 32 1 atty client s83S e93 set off cost 112 18A0 attys. lien ISAC 711 653 844 lOlD 277 909 634 323 fire ins s83S a 178 NY appraisal 14 AG 338D 328 insurance 3 83 S 730 106 316 avoidability 141 912 331 new trial 3 83 S 732 a 180NY 551 54 M 512 16AC 129n case 8 f 141 921 333 insurance 8 83 S 728 a 180 NY 550 f 86 329 335 objections "3 8 899 89 1S2 3 13 AC 322 comissn author'y 47 M 151 unconstitutional 45 M 179 e 49 M 107 waive defense 49 M 643 commissions 547 568 50 M do 137 constitutnl 187NY 19A0 waiver 49 H services a 76 M cond. precedent 94 387 133 881 c 152 69 19A0 179 180n 156 692 insu£[icient ev. 151 519 future support do 156 694 359 publication 183 271 362 residence s 83 S 847 172 273 281 lOlM 422 368 commissions s S3 S 808 117 818 132 3 fail disclose 134 293 377 holder value surplus income 62M 393 res judicata 123 487 direction void 59 M 141 custom 148 277 undue influence 149 487 reservation £ 86 M 638 prescribe 95 M 34 437 trial court s 83 » 103 48 M 62 M 81 M 91 M bona hdes 54M 59 M 525 defense 174 no defense 174 N. Y. Rule 224NY 379 carrier s83S * 179 NY 383 deed ev. fraud s 83 S r 180 NY 386 costs sS3S 86 e 101 15 AC 749 33 431 301 201 225 127 526 733 589 760 517 130 487 388 contrib neg. s 83 S 836 109 208 s43M 148150 112 345 instruction 131 119 charge court d 148 690 39 i jurisdiction s 83 8 700 55M 283 6I1I397 signals 512 76 M recovery do 180 illegality 226NY 349 contract 8 S3 S 740 s 109 153 164 156 s 112 43 M evidence 55 M variance 138 pleading 160 352 alimony s83S 103 proof charge 115 proof burden js 83 S 139 363|ml79NY 359 IS 298 121 812 876 552 562 422n 866 363 35- s83,S 8 176 NY a 180 NY 13 AC dismissal 112 mandamus ei M practice 201 NY court's power e 94M 179 180 for court 182 453 401 resid. rights s 83 S - 794 f 107 403 stat. frauds 83 S 871 1 44 r 179 NY 4121405 construe will 507 charge ev s 83 S 736 f 95 161 a 180 NY 88 s 13 AC 340 construction do 122 634 512 ch'ge venue 677 229 785 951 874 392 due . 300 s 83 S 86 M strike out f 169 application 184 439 parties s 83 B 119 show bal 144 441 practice s S3 S 687 157 401 447 warranty s 83 S 768 d 96 243 option 135 778 protection 84 M 78 95 M 430 451 forn. Corp. s 83 S 841 49 M 454 456 13 AC 386n exceptions ■ 165 65 infer author 215 NY 423 458 transfer tax 6 83 S 769 44 M 191 65iyi 477 99 113 37 CP in writing do 144 864 157 551 s83 S 119 f 168 45 M 515 costs s83S 101 16 AC pleading 45 M defenses 16AC 245n 727 506 261 235 762 130 4S7 362 249n 517 member right 83 S 723 a 180 NY 646 521 civ. service 8 83 S 800 a 176 NY 602 529 interventn. s 83 S 773 160 485 53 1 pool selling 83 S 78 r 178 NY 51 e87 7 conviction f 181 154 537 constitutl. s 83 S 803 07 M 5I?8 removal t 82 M 683 303 s 540 sp. prfmce binds widow 183 717 464 bankruptcy 3 83 S 879 a 180 NY 508 786 288 92 demurrable e97 . 298 demand relief 17 AC 89n pledg. perfin. i,3 405 470vestedremd L,_ . s 83 S 696 545 ins. waiver 119 540 J ^yg ^j,g 472 terms trial s 83 S 821 18AC 29ii motion case 3 145 939 election 147 500 481 attys. lien 8 83 S 775 109 284 287 485 devise perfm s 83 S 834 15 AC 291n 488fact question s83S 816 d43.M 136 negligence care 98 408 110 19 499 contempt s 83 S 70S 156 780 judr. discretion £ 159 293 503 decision 91 M 416 performance 110 399 119 575 show waiver 39 CP 286 reply 162 285 547 amt. lien s S3 S 680 114 468 849 „ 64!b 83 S 685 55 1 nullity s 83 £■ f 165 780 924 555 transfer tax 3 67 S 966 s84S 1135 a 177 NY . 662 eq. conversion 47 M 569 559 incompt s 83S 1106 a 176 NY 607 s 13 AC 365 566 election 8 83 8 lOlS a 177 NY 628 567 extra work 8 83 S 1002 185 NY 207 106 228 577 election s 83 8 998 r 178 NY 433 foreign corpn tax 105 177 582 attorney s S3 S 993 44 M 336 586 unconstitut 8 83 S 1009 B2 M 376, 379 iCP NS 48, 51 592 order 8 83 8 1017 8 13 AC 398 court's power 139 677 593 judgment s 83S 1021 f 136 945 reargument case 14 138 911 604 receiver s 83 S 1034 3 88 209 13AC 402 8 1 1 reformation case 2 83 S 380 45 M 120 6 1 3. partnership case' 1 3 106 546 550 83 8 6 1 7 report case 2 s83S 8 96 competition 190NY 230 301 620 transfer tax case 1 9 83 8 436 a 178 NY 560 623 submission s83S 1111 a 178 NY 6Q2 626 new trial case 5 83 8 a 177 NY reinstate case 9 3 83 8 a 176 NY appeal case 10 8 83 8 a 176 NY hab. corpus case 13 3 83S a 176 NY misdemr case 14 3 83 8 a 176 NY Case 19 vendor 3 S3 S a 179 NY Interest ase 20 8 83 8 a 176 NY injunction case 28 s83 8 1109 572 1113 565 1106 569 1113 677 1116 577 1110 53 1112 297 r 178 NY 20 prohibitions 149 846 construction 149 847 as principal 149 849 627 judgt final oase2 s83 8 665 a 180 NY 556 situs case 10 s83 S 1110 8 108 324 113 359 119 650 case 20 stipulation s83 8 1107 a 180 NY 520 3d party jase 21 sS3S 1117 a 177 NY 558 service process 39 CP 323 168 384 reversal 181 782 628 new trial case 12 s83 8 1112 a 177 NY 534 neg ev. case 14 s83 8 1117 r 177 NY 379 629 champerty case 1 2nd dept 8 83 S 805 a 791 NY 642 112 164 caae 6 absolute judgmt s 83 8 1112 a 183 NY 519 Dew trial case 10 s83S a 177 NY case 12 appeal s8.?S a 181 NY negligence case 13 s 83S rlS.. NY ■ Mv and 18 AC 1115 629 11-19 573 1118 468 cli'^nt 248 630 commissions ase 3 _ 83 S 682 r 182 NY 43 632 mal.proFecu. case 16 83 S 1110 r 180 NY 243 costs case 19 B83S 1117 95 93 1116 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; i, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; 11. no". c.«ritici«ed; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled: •.same case; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q, qucsiioned R. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division Vol. 87 VOL. 87 I costs 8 83 S 1057 * 177 NY 558 94 M 386 8 unilateral B 83 S 1045 153 777 right offset 185 193 1 3 declarations i83S 90 error ruling trust fund 49 M s lis 2 1 fora. corp 1091 21 334 695 471 s83S 8 13 AC i 108 d 45M 46 M waiver 114 demurrer 17AC 26clerical duties " ~ 1068 1054 370 333 359 539 615 516 424 s 144 632 inadmissible 20 AC 168n 72 pool selline 3 S 1088 a 178 NY 679 crime lOOM 212 83 jurisdiction 8 83 S 1073 £ 87 613 91 438 default 91 441 f97 139 140 personal knowl 137 859 13 AC 467n aflfidavit 54M 77 M attachment 29 i 167 f 172 f 94 M 142 519 549 29 atty client s 83 S 1076 * 176 NY 606 title tender 18AC 3S2n 32 pool selline s'83S lOBl d 93 381 35 demurrer s 83 S 1041 109 677 aid lien 114 441 47 assign certif. 8 83 S 1025 104 206 revocation f 88 M 262 52 distinction 1081 475 86 sureties b84S 91 451 462 executor liab. 42 M 666 44 M 182 17 AC 462 97 certificate s84S 120 s 177 NY fci681 a 180 NY 563 firm name I AC 46n 1 1 substitution 384S 111 a 177 NY 557 18A0 yan 1 04 vici 'US dog case 8 s 84 S 60 S87 614 presumption 113 857 animal neg. 18AC 473 s 83 S f 168 54 record s83S i 104 111 conclusive f 158 1077 27 424 693 56 audit review 8 83 S 1083 e 109 62 dismissal s 83 S 1067 82 M 495 66 new trial s 83 S 1082 145 546 award 84 M 635 68 improper ev. s 83 S 1078 91 82 8 126 692 neg master 91 577 spl. damages 18AC 220n restrict proof 197NY 73 expert evidence s 84 S a 181 NY bar S3M 1 50 liability 3 84S 129 good cause 131 lOP NS not neligent 156 had notice 176 duty 10511 30 12 314 787 s 14 AC 1 excused 184 357 discharge do 184 368 240 sup pro. 8 84 S 276 s 13 AC 458 241 m lien notice 51 169 278 641 107 dividend s 84S r 181 NY 1 1 6 authority s 84S 106 155 512 I 1 9 right way s 84 S 76 96 490 f 23 meas. dam. 3 84 S 90 16AC 458-9n 125 damages s 84 S 7h 49 M 447 127 right way s84S 1126 96 490 I 3 I school law a 83 S 1098 e 177 NY 494 137 bill particu lars 3 84 S 6£ f 109 423 157 363 1 39 reference s84S 114 m 177 NY 231 review 122 816 1 44 life trust 183 I 56 strict con- struction s 84 S 3" 156 413 I 57 discovery 8 84 S 32 8 13 AC 448 119 331 122 885 £ 91 M 489 unauthorized f 162 817 1 63 affidavit s 84 S 70 54M 78 taxable costs 67 M 239 1 85 new ritaj s84 S 49 16 AC 123n 75 M 524 1 70 interp leader s84 S 95 * 178 NY 603 204NY 287 1 74 neg. question fact 34 724 84 S a 181 NY -83 16-J 56 do 162 62 defective statement f 98 M 388 245 bks deposit 8 84 S 294 8 90 . 196 defect service 14 AC 248 order s84S 43 M contempt 121 cond, 148 255 pleading s 84 S 377 f 93 613 259 recital order 3 84 S d 109 (77 Sep. 5S4S 142 152 reports 18 788 11 1 93 constitutul. a84S s 177 NY 54M assumption 214 NY 206 signals 8 83 S a 179 NY 42 M 8 13 AC for court 182 97 587 209 1029 582 163 409 453 2 I 5 transfer tax 8 83S r 179 NY 44 M 222 sale s84S sl3 AC 1049 601 76 372 465 227 chge venue 300 328n s84 S 16AC 233 service 84 S 8 136 authority 132 managing 159 308 138 628 420 agent 420 236 cancel mechanic Hen s 84 S 356 235d 279 362 667 precedent (■25 84 S 100 262 title 84 S a 177 NY 96 good title 188NY 319 516 369 656 624 380 269 certiorari case 1 8 84 S 341 f 87 . 624 jurisdiction d 150 457 275 app. court 5 84 S 369 61 M 226 277 suspension 8 84 S 380 43 M .92 compensation 64M 610 306 paymt insui s 84 S 316 f 100 616 3l2stkhldrB liab ?84S 323 8 14 AC 38 Dot demurrable 79 M 84 317 verify complaint 8 84 S 306 246 corpn receiver 111 702 receiver ev. 124 747 147 781 waiver 128 493 temp, injunction 147 781 320 pers inj dam 84 S 368 a 180 NY 552 326 spec per- formance s 84 S 467 a 181 NY 603 329 contract sale s 84 S 802 e 179 NY 406 335 endorsement s 84 S 1001 112 401 * 181 NY 278 344partner8hip s 84 S 426 f 87 630 346 mandamus S84S 666 e 96 399 laches 56M 28 138 498 f 170 230 386 bribery s84S dl56 150 4G1 621 633 772 recovery 126 disregard 144 514 466 amen d complaint 84 S 707 263 391 mandamus s 84 5 947 120 6731= ?; M qualifications e *o lu 79 M 1301, _„ ,. conclusive Hi i'^''°^^%^-i IfiT 479 s84 S 711 "" 88 S48 inspect books 103 36 478 mandamus a 84 S 766 a 178 NY. _,. 576 waive jtinsdictn. 48 M 101 waiver objn. 395 common law suit 8 84 S 166 £ 166 471 866 867 405 shifts risk s 84 S 511 78 M 565 409 commissns. B 84 S 449 143 454 urocuring cause 143 454 4 1 7 employment s 84 S 410 90 26 s 14 AC 64 statute frauds 95 „85 112 275 by demurrer £ 175 128 uuenforcible 67M tribunal 148 estoppel 205NY obj. no 203NY 411 391 361 avail 350 289 bill s84S 109 partic. 354 424 291 title defense 8 84 S 336 102 484 abuse process d 104 9 138 226 d 167 138 arrest 63 M 76 295 intervention 5 84 S 362 d 97 529 299 sewers s84S a 180 NY 349 507 302 meas. dam. 385 834, 636 359 144 s 179 690 180 510 • 84S 126 f 62M 84 JVt £ 98 M recovery 181 &2\ laches 314 8 a 18(1 NY 49 M 592 236 387 699 352 easempDt 3 84S d 112 abandonm't 62 M complaint 133 enforcement 140 627 f 170 695 93 M 328 violations f 170 695 359 satisfaction s 84 S 440 d 98 180 366 infant liable s 84 S 806 do 111 651 8 14 AC 71 not binding 164 810 371 profits s 84S 437 do 66M 471 measure damags 138 550 usable value in AC 103n bate nuisance 427 neg ques fact 3 84 8 464 r 180 NY 315 430 amendment a 84 8 506 90 408 96 60 enforced do 138 .296 judgt remittitur 14 AC 365n f 94 ]\I 375 title s84S ISAC 471 418 417n 380 foreign judgt 8 84 S 413 a 181 NY 563 recovery 136 4 346 686 487 presumptn. s 84 S 823 71 M 607 e 93 M 703 assumption £ 213 NT 46 93 M 704 490 amend ans- wer s 84 S 983 110 150 breach ques fact do 110 484 do 110 504 incompet. 608 1 no plea waiver 143 fulfillment 151 must plead 222XY 497 release surety s 84S lOllI 434 separation 3 84S 444 14 AC 242n 176 903 decision required 113 864 37 CP 157 \x. and w. cont. 18AC 23n in writing do 144 551 438eq conversion 3 84 8 897 a 179 NY 692 129 851 do 183 8V 48 M 112 68 M 410 ntention 56M 412 459 pera. judgt s 84 S 851 119 381 177 1" 65M 380 money judgmt 124 811 recovery 65M 380 462 delivery s 84 8 693 a 181 NY 520 118 303 304 132 28 869 870 867 882 870 731 56 503 privileged 84 8 887 £ 162 16 4 3M 101 98 M 599 s 14 AC 106 incompetent ev. 03M 316 waiver 20 AC 283n limit evidence £ 95 M 597 516 amend ans s 84 S 782 46 M 269 f 49 M 440 518 frd comissns a 84 S 793 f 107 299 s 109 695 522 revoke truts s 84 S 99S 101 460 vest title 103 348 363 a I50NY 201 532 manslaugh- ii84S ■I 178 NY 780 584 536 jury caldr s 84 8 774 89 596 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; c, criticised ; 1, limited ; e, explained ; o, overruled ; s, same case ; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, questioned Vols. 87, 88 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division fiduciary 56 M 457 royalties 132 198 accounting 65M 540 incidental 157 719 shares profits 168 56 B39 b partic. ■s 84 S 728 •97 138 15 AC 183n -643 atty lien s 84 S 830 90 82 112 843 55CP 341 18A 274 costs belong client 106 400 ^et off costs 107 527 18AC 279n lien costs 165 684 550 injunction s 84S 1052 135 226 552 res ipsa loq s 84S 558 42M 627 64M 581 556 bill partio s 84 S 505 15 AC 182n 116 894 558 not recover s 84 S 526 174 269 56 1 ri'-ht way s 84 S 544 ■e 43 M 150 572 jud. sale s 84 S 494 -a. 177 NY 561 573 findings « 84 S 487 S3 476 «7 409 presumption 161 732 S76 partnersbi s 84 S 478 do 94 232 limitation lis 626 legal title 148 144 584 distinction s 84S 483 do 134 585 585 accord and satisfaction s84S 6 r 180 NY 367 98 180 597 employment f5 84 S 537 50 M 319 at will 119 499 t 178 815 agency 121 18 123 762 vacate attachmt 179 61 604 mis pleadng. s 84 S 560 110 735 R05 affidavit s 84 S 563 54M 275 809 appeal case 1 9 83S 1108 r 178 NY 26 surety 2 3 83S 1106 ft 177 NY 655 ease 3 deed as evidence s 83 S 1118 a 181 NY 155 accouQtine case 5 b83S 1117 a 178 NY 564 not apply 179 458 610 exrs&admrs case 2 B 83 S 1107 fl 109 211 a 180NY 544 612 appeal case 6 83 S 1111 a 180 NY 520 case 11 firm name 3 83S 1118 a 184NY 533 6 1 3 appeal case 6 s83S 1104 a 180 NY 543 6 1 5 corpn con tract s 84 S 1144 a 180 NY 35 6 1 7 partners case 30 s84S 1126 3 91 365 case 32 referee report 3 84S 1147 a 183 NY 607 case 33 appeal s 84 S 1142 a 179 NY 686 36 insurance s84S 1117 r 180 NY 337 ins. policy 116 460 461 619 appeal case 17 s83S 1107 a 179 NY 683 620 contrib. neg case 1 3 83 S 1102 r 181 NY 198 case 8 final iudgt s84S 1146 a 179 NY 585 621 appeal case 14 3 84 S 1150 a 180 NY 548 622 appeal case 2 s 84 S 1123 a 179 NY 358 case 6 624 weight ev case 2. _84S 95 371 395 626 appeal case 1 s84S * 181 NY 628 order Case 5 9 84S f 124 1124 527 63 r contract case 1 s84S 1125 a 179 NY 689 - 93 172 case 5 appeal s84S 1123 a 181 NY 583 negligence case 8 s 84 S 1127 r 178 NY 147 condition precedt 102 50 case 12 salary 3 84 S 1147 a 179 NY 473 case 13 1122 537 atty lien s 84 S a 179 NY pase 9 appeal s 84 S 1 143 a 180 NY 561 1117 644 919 case 27 9 84S * 179 NY discharge 53M 45 45M 92 'duly Bcheduld' 154 157 84 S 1150 a 179 NY 580 accounting case 27 9 84S 1127 a 178 NY 613 632 error reject evidence case 1 s 84 S 1120 r ISl NY 486 case 5 judgment s84S 1136 a 181 NY 532 trust void 140 518 633 appeal Case 15 S84S 1140 a 178 NY 692 case 16 deposition 3 84S 1122 a 180 NY 86 case 17 notes estoppel s84S 1121 3 182 NY 511 a 183 NY 92 case 18 appeal 3 84S 1145 a 182 NY 633 case 19 judgment s 84 S 1134 a 180 NY 544 case 20 appeal 3 84S 1135 a 180 NY 523 title case 23 3 84S 1124 a 177 NY 371 appeal case 24 3 84 8 „ 1117 * 178 N Y 616 cancellation judgment case 26 3 84 8 1148 44 IVI 518 45 M 330 final judgment 45 M 682 allowance VOL. 88 I stay costs 3 84 S 489 91 549 4 jurisdiction 9 84 S 518 do 100 323 review 16AC 287n 9 new trial 84 8 785 107 488 fright damage 16AC 69n contrib. neglig, 185 200 44 vaccination 3 84 8 712 a 179 NY 235 52 exr. costs s 84 S 790 43 M 472 trustee duty do 110 911 57 change venue 3 84 8 738 f88 616 f 89 625 f9l 417 92 641 131 242 d 178 670 45 M 236 38 CP 67 62 recovery s 84 S 682 137 736 tender sufficient 137 736 64 negligence 3 84 8 737 89 625 48 M 533 not liable 149 .48(1 S5 bail liable s 84 S 703 s 14 AC 124 15 AC 392n 68 dam. neg. s 84 8 799 r 180 NY 373 e 112 368 73 improp. judgt 3 84 8 751 104 10 76 stenog. fees s 84 S 736 145 674 78 chge benefic s 84 8 989 9 14 AC 185 vested interest 67M 110 right wife £ 87 M 657 81 commis9ions s 84 8 867 93 397 173 109 compensation 116 704 brokerage 67 M 610 83 Case 4 ass'gnment s 84 S 951 f 128 885 126 residt venue 3 85 S 81 c 103 425 f 110 920 16AC 166n 167n lOlM 383 burden proof 53M 21 16AC 172n reference 16AC 166n residence 138 637 e 141 43 172 278 133 amendment 3 84 8 337 97 136 res ipsa loq. 18A0 288n 1 40 priority payment 3 84 S 329 160 470 (44 allegation 3 84 8 333 150 256 147 overch'ge rr. 84 8 a 184 NY s 14 AC St. surf. 1 203NY 383 351 6 3G4 150 damages 3 848 396 136 144 1 53 couit ev 3 84 8 374 8 13 AC 469 96 669 review errors o 106 298 133 420 134 707 158 868 not binding 112 598 agency 115 611 reserve decision 129 432 review law 147 104 "except' ' 184 494 1 58 pleading 3 84 8 697 n 177 NY 499 1 67 no neglig. s 84S SOS 75M 524 170 agency 3 84 8 696 a 180 NY 93 181 pidgdofin 3 84 8 669 98 315 120 660 122 259 45 M 204 55M 41 96 M 49 bill particulars 149 468 45 M 20-t 49 M 326 97 M 83 practice US 287 complaint 156 382 distinction 171 408 improper 184 289 689 691 693 696 574 I 85 recount B 84 8 406 92 88 take as true '73 M 246 mandamus f 168 375 225NY 7 192 sidewalks 9 84 8 699 a 183 NY 616 SV 221 198 not evidence s 848 401 134 113 intercourse 134 760 161 948 212 NY 258 St. r. r. rights 98 M 715 208 tempreceiver s 84S 117 s 201 NY 383 133 authority 138 security 138 validity 138 no consent 138 reversal do 138 699 218 fasch. tax 3 85 S 467 r 179 NY 228 corporation 92 M 380 228 foreclose s 85 S 452 « 178 NY 567 237 bill partic. 3 85 8 428 47 M 6 f 165 945 242 extension s 85 8 462 e 95 33 34 246 dedicate st. s8dS 423 s 14 AC 259 jury question 191NY 498 251 nonresident actnioD 3 84 S 1053 182 NY 395 construction S8LRA 137 35CP 106 disqualification 17AC 337 265 holder value s 84 8 1043 99 122 f 162 23 piesumption 58 M 560 270 reformation 9 84 S 977 45 M 125 279 ctrclaim9 3 84 8 1092 3 96 63 reversal 144 293 28 1 chg. venue s86 8 7 _ 177 NY 657 38 CP . 66 place trial 53M 23 residence 138 636 637 £ 161 834 e 171 457 lOlM 383 lOlM 385 ABBREV1AT1U1n:s: a, amrmea; d, diiunguunea; l. tollowea; r, reTerseaj m, moaineo; -, aisnusscu, "• rr~i c, criticised ; 1. limited ; e, explained ; o, oremiled ; a, same case ; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, questionea N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division Vols. 88, 89 distinction 181 a 180 NY 501IU2 indorser 549 362 J perm, injury 59 M 522 B 85 S 9 estoppel 14 AC 304d lOOM 153 writ inquiry i 57M 159:367 contnb. neg. Is 84 S 655 294 ultra vires !do 97 455 s85S 55|116 159 157 5111 Improp, remarks invalidity 100 8 222NY 78 5 AC 373d [new trial 297 secure costs ] 126 480 B 85 S 25 misconduct a 177 NY 265 62 M 310 i error 302 surety liablty 84 M 653 s84S 617' 15 AC 391n 372 contrib. neg certif, doubt s 84 S 18AC 133n a 181 NY for jury m 181 NY 463 427 reserve deed s 65 S s84S rl81 NY 443 s 85 S do 170 621 1119 178 174 937 452 poundage s85l:i do 108 e44M e 45 M attachment 114 104 317 420 395 a 178 NY 442 522 relief 3 85 S 95 9 96 411 526 poundage s 85 S 316 43 M 330 529 oorp. acctg s 85 S 310 r 179 NY 294 [378 CP plaintiflf do 179 127 41 liable 373 309 neg dam. s 84 S 622 a 183 NY 78 a 96 175 149 374 bank by-laws 3rd party liable Is 14 AC 51 M 294;» 84 S neg. defects r '.SONY 125 . 70, d 74 duty bank basis of law f 93 M 137 125 71 liability neg 380 transf tax do 125 70, 7o;g84S 630 duty defendant iqr i.qn f 90 M 411 „„_ , „ 387 chge routerr 320 delivery s 84 S 678 fS? 457 St. opng Jam °2*sSoS 275 s 185 NY 661 s 110 201 203 207 evidence 126 570 17 AC 70ii competent ev. 135 6 admissible 154 606 sB4S 112 carrier ev. 53M 324 only inference s84S 14T 523 658|a 179 NY 615 not limited d 136 758 ])ub. crossings liOS NY 48^ 291 651 is 84S '|e 111 330 court's pwr.jigAC I5V li^-^ 81 M 328 98 M 46 vacate order 64M 283 distinction 180 449 103M 111 392 jurisdiction 640 37 196 138n 363 339 separation s84S s 14 AC 57M divorce 159 1090 92 140 no power 133 judgment s 198NY stct. constrctn. T5M 438 822 279 396 drainage 1 84 S 725 115 505 125 772 99 129 48 M 155 cond. precedent 142 713 pleading 142 714 money claims 98 M 91 61 1 attestation s 85 S 1127 158 3 84S r 180 NY sase 21 judgment 8 84S a 180 NY case 27 appeal s84S a 181 NY 1148 311 1150 552 VOL. 89 I reinsurance 9 85 S 262 a 180 NY 389 parol evidence 181 428 1142 3 name corpn 525,6 85 S ,153 53li accountmg 6 1 2 weight ev s 85 R 104 1 case 2 s 99 624 s 84 S demmrer ,95 124 728, 729 contrib. neg. pleading 1 109 124 733icase 3 misjoinder rent 136 120 s 84 S do 166 661 > do 97 71 1619 mandamuB 'pleading s 84 b 795 4 o 153 a :79 NY 598 ?° ^"^ 282 411 7g9 620 reinstate 395 case 5 may Ido 153 7 notice lien I f 186 NY compliance 106 114 expenditure GSM 467 atty's lien s 85 S 98 106 128 AD 18AC 125 160 605 642 97n 343 reference s84S 634 a 179 NY .SIS dllO 96 sl25 845 B 14 AC 66 94 M 660 burden proof d 164 208 349 rr. rules s84 S 646 d 114 271 not neglig ence 20 AC. 140n 356 contr neg s84S 607 92 111 reversal 123 793 a 181NY 537 36 factual notice s 84 S 638 140 703 401 stockholder 57e s 84 S 810 "'"a 179 NY 587 f 90 613 not fully paid 140 582 certificate 208 NY 150 binding 91 M 264 4 1 cond precd. 365 recovery s 84 S 8 84S 95 139 149 complaint 96 119 notice e97 limitation 35CP notice rule 187NY proviso 62 M allege complce. 39 CP 661 265 875 810 54 574 343 80 384 492 liDel 8 85S 3 14 AC libelous 55M distinction 143 28 422 injunction 666 s 84 S 965 471 speed auto s 85 S 120 14 AC 406n regulations ILUANS 219n 320d 475 infant sue 8 85 S 91 288 poor person. 19A0 313n 477 breach s 85 S 83 d 99 220 do 479 f 93 M 154 cond. precedent 94 M 200 202 performance. 134 560 d 85 M 54 f 85 M 446 intention 137 29 entire contract do 158 .246 80 M 221 damages 185 8 102M: 526 111 215 670 140 197 374 499 661 44 496 denial s85S s92 135 141 amendment 64M conjunctively 141 664 498 execution s 85 S 141 109 36 506 truBt b85S 266 542 authority 614 appeal s 85 S i30:case 16 559JS 84 S 'a 179 NY 459jcase 22 659 guard shaft !s84S 389 !r 181 NY tax law 554 neg.damages,case 26 s 85 S 184 s 84 S r 179 NY 378jal77NY appeal 560 certiorari jcase 27 s85.S 20(j;s84S 150 192p- 177 NY depositions ' . „_„_ m 721'6l5ini. dam. ev- case IQ S84S q, a 177 NY " ■„ase7 I removal |=|,al79NY conviction jcase 9 ,s84S 1145 « 178 NY ^ig case 10 , r. liable cows 1-1=4 !s84S 1148",ip* 1123 " ISO NY 61] i'^Sii ^^''621 10 contrib. neg. 1141 ; 85 S 663 a 180 NY 1100 llff 106 ^120 [59 M 1140lcompliance 5861 122 notice 308 546 442 609 406 281 449 280 471 237 19 151 48 M mandamus d 48 M 54 law question 120 779 permissive ev, e 120 no damage 134 damages 146 no review do205NY authority 75M case 2 b84S r 181 NY allowance case 7 8 84S case 4 ,s 85 S misdemeanor ido 97 _84S 11401102 a 181 NY 532;d 108 case 7 , 114 sold for taxes [ 169 SK,|S85S 1145 f 184 NY '"'■' i 179 NY 565'do 98 il 'revers error rr. liable cows 1117 11371 585 1120, 1145 33 i F4 S 1150' heedless r 181 NY 448ido 143 case 18 I for jury oral contract Id S3 M 181 456 298 16 275 167 151 197 315 1123 780, r 178 NY 605 case 8 allowance 48218 84 8 1147 V 178 NY 407 443 case 22 referee report s84S 1150 a 180NY 554 314 512 567 demurrer s 85 S 160 6 1 6adl evidence case 13 153 s 84 S 1141 489.80 M 24 583 reinstate s 85S d 99 f 112 589 libel b85S f 110 a 178 NY 593 mandamus So S 161 a 179 NY 625 svaiver 120 809 604 contrib neg. s85S 89 97 do 97 103 dl08 110 114 118 136 164 f 184 NY instruction 116 ;6 I 7 constitutnl 193 case 1 91s84S 912 a 177 NY 'case 8 I appeal 259 s 84 S 889 a 182 NY 610, case 14 I appeal ■8 84S a 180 NY 604 499 1123 534 1130 553 180 I 1136 395 6 1 8 mandamus case 3 s84S a 177 NY „_ case 6 12|iudgment 398 s 84 S 465 a 180 NY 217lcase 12 16| claim 675 s 84 S 275, a 183 NY 1137 562 546 343 659 151 160 606 persnl. injury notice 8 85 S 150 case 15 appeal s84S a 179 NY case IS judgment e84S s 181 NY 19 admrs. liable 1144 561 1144 583 1148 517 ABBREVIATIONS: c. criticised ; 1. limited s84S a 181 NY 122 296 1136, 163 17 necessity 3 85S 52 M 18AC 189n, 196n 19In examination 52M 296 {depositions ,151 721 21 discovery s85S 1.^4 38 CP 115 28 frd. transfer 885S 305 s 100 307 misjoinder do 166 661 33 excess verdict S85S 93 110 883 res ipsa loq 18AC 295n 37 pleading s85S 89 126 19 38 nuisance s85S 404 a 180 NY S-W ILRANS S6n f 163 481 authority 131 177 def inLte cause 66M 223 property rights 72 M 2K(I reversed 158 875 not liable lOOM 199 50 abolish office s85S 406 103 363 civil service a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; • dismissed- n nor^ • : e. explained: o, overruled : s. same case; do, dissenting opinion ; P, parallel 4™ "q. questronld Vol. 89 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — 'Appellate Division 45 M 54 * 179 NY 527 discretion 70 M 600 61 appointment 8 85 S 413 a 181 NY 643 error court f 178 534 76 affidavit s 85 S 98 f 166 744 45 M 269 271 relief merits 180 842 84 trover .■s85S a 180 NY ■S& custody sSSS a7AC 457 558 442 42n -89 pleading s 85S 438 66M 182 99 sale stock s SoS 434 16AC 174n .1 13 trst relat'n a «4S 945 136 106 1 1 5 wifes earning s 84 S 1063 s 14 AC 201 119 ct. power B 8SS 473 137 285 jurisdiction 141 575 '127 amend ans s84 S 1088 sS4S 1141 •a 177 NY 584 deduction 202US 65 I SOasSUmed risk s 85 S a 180 NY 94 rules master «6 128 20 AC 57 515 43 554 62 140n ■137 survival fi 84S 1015 134 322 lecovery 143 969 counsel fee 76 M 204 I4luncorrobortd s 85 S 63 a 180 NY 557 e 49M 298 159 degree care s 85 S 842 185 875 84 M 50 98 M 39 ordinary care 185 869 1 66 confirmn s 85 S 876 44 M 127 167 interloo judt 171 implication 3S5S 1100 116 334 party interest 61 M 449 protection e 143 713 qualifications 74M 511 constitutional 132S 502 veterans 84 M 189 t 84 M 176 183 retrospctn. 9 85S 91 . J 102 3 179 NY petition 155 by court 155 185 828 563 263 398 67; 673 oleomarge rine s 85 S 834 140 152 188 declaration 3 85 S 755 :< 93 568 6 95 65 s 95 631n request exceptn 148 716 aegligence 102 260 1 151 407 f 161 867 inference ) 133 202 I 93 separate est H 85 S 820 110 77 ■'intermeddler' iuM 80 207 jury ^ 85S L34 ques 791 630 209 contrib. neg. i 85 S 799 e 102 28 for jury f 158 480 21 1 jury question 85 S 837 54 M 453 214 for jury s 85 S 807 do 173 1 222 permit -5S 122 763 755 s85S B 101 * 183NY new trial a 188NY title 121 766 195 509 590 226 surrog, pwr 3 85 S 924 129 419 35 M 687 decree ICP NS 114 power court 153 88 petition f 209 NY 38? 231 district claims s 85 S 943 94 M 386 237 quan. meruit 3 85 S 886 HI 4 recovery 103M: 6 363 51 612 355 616 604 do 97 do 97 e 102 151 166 169 liability act 99 501 < notice injury 178 NY 152 17 AC 280: jury question 112 204 com. law neg. 132 377 not titles 104M 625 262 00. clerk fees 3 86 S 933 a 182 NY 541 266inj-brakeman s 85 S 814 a 181 NY 523 272 ev. mal.pros 3 85 S 1018 49 M 317 281 foreign oorpn 3 86 S 38 r ISO NY 346 48 M 366 286 injur notice 949 599 492 349 legacy 3 85S a 179 NY d50M tax rate 114 720-1 do 722 reduction 187NY 257 133 754 S2M 441 442 taxable 155 232 stct. constructn. 79 M 657 tax succession 79 M 657 distinction 89 M 354 compromise 92 M 103 359 presumptn. 3 85 S a 180 NY e 104 negligence 156 906 547 16 371 229 245 construction 8 86 S 49 c94 178 291 consent franch. 3 85 S 87S 110 72-J 54M 23 56M 67 presumption 1S6 809 54M 23 77 M 549 use streets 153 633 296 penalty s 85 S 866 117 445 130 715 [■emoval do 134 974 303 discretion ■J 85 S 863 125 891 reviewable 78 M 269 right to stay 150 881 relief E 160 596 3 1 1 warning s 85 S 967 a 181 NY 515 186 NY 353 neg. damages 16 AC 32611 319 fav. inferenc 85 S 843 ! 107 361 tender 145 70 330 cont. sale 3 85 S 795 a 181 NY 627 338ne damage s 85 S 958 89 . 313 warning 186 NY 354 340 safe conditn 3 85 S 902 105 duty owner 106 49 M negligence 62M liability 62M 363 224 134 567 273 85 S 76 M 383 offset s 85S 132 estoppel 176 368 trust s85S 9 178 NY rl79 NY elOl 874 302 945 278 846 928 G04 112 109 m 180 NY 106 188 559 4l2executn. q'. ;act 3 85 S 920 109 780 415 pera injury s 85 S 819 97 57 negl. due care 104 65 f 110 19 inference 151 70 proximate cause f 151 71 164 119 165 894 f 171 485 421 tax sale 8 73 S 1095 3 85 S 762 r 182 NY 477 127 287 425 pers inj s 85 S 960 a 183 NY 521 89 . 313 contnb. neg. Ill 406 negligence l6AC 320n326n 590contrib neg 497 "promotion" ? 85 S 667 3 S5 S 853 106 649 114 595 eq. relief s 85 S 626 508 amendments 92 290 s 85 S do 111 wpiver do 124 126 158 20 AC 38 CP 188NY 847 520 773 273 279 288n 206 360 construction f 124 770 193 NY i, 5 1 2 asses xnent s86S a 179 NY f89 435 eq. action 375 scaffold s 85 S 935 20 AC 203n 95 M 130 379 inj. damages s 85 S 938 a 181 NY 431 injunction ILRANS 56n 386negl damage s 85 S 896 * 178 NY 619 389 justified s 85 S 911 168 472 duty rescue 168 473 liable 99M 663 392 negligence s 85S 855 119 801 395 cross examin 3 85 S 763 15 AC 39n 47n 398 sorv. payt. 3 85 S 975 101 40 400 gift 3 85 S 907 102 600 evidence clear 121 582 134 122 delivery 172 75M gift proof 122 not presumed 73 M 605 s S5 S 116 99M fiduciary 58M quity 71 M joinder 138 parties 99M 981 898 369 right, 183 386 278 8 affected 369 wrong 208 445 eviction AC 266r 449 police power 3 85 S 767 68LRA 409 judgment f 116 926 soft coal 150 795 457 wrongful ejectment 3 85 S 883 d 110 254 carrier neg. 17 AC 459n 463 sp. damages 61 M 64 463 right lost s85S 800 ILRANS 1194n 465 reasonable 3 85 S 760 127 400 470 new trial 85 S 801 46 M 68 475 description de 536 61 779 certificate 18AC 339n a 179 NY f 108 130 530 129 6 1 I annoyance case 4 s85S 1140 rl79 NY 46 do 90 246 6 1 3 dismissal case 4 s85S 1142 a 178 NY 613 case 6 annuity wish 651 57t 627 704 326 603 271 526 penalty s85tj a 179 NY 90 43 M comply excuse 47 M 238 garbage 203Ua 583 legislature lOlM 218 hardships lOlM 222 539 insuf. defens s 85 S 99 153 demurrer 56M 665 507 643 371 541 demurrer s 85 S 583 a 181 NY 638 548 meas. dam s 85 S 673 * 178 NY 92 172 550 551 154 664 9 86 S a 181 NY reference case 13 s85S 93 case 24 mandamus s 85S * 179 NY cond. precedent 130 649 6 1 4 mandamus case 36 8 85S * 177 NY case 10 appeal s 85S a 182 NY 1144 16 1129 544 1144 626 1142 586 1140 537 do 111 e 138 161 167 65M profits do 66M il8 NY 6 1 6foreclosure case 15 8 85l:j e94 _ ,- 22 new trial s 85 S a 181 NY case 26 udgment "i- 3 85 S 568 a 181 NY 1841 case 6 s84S 1145 176 1150 565 1150 564 1134 622 839 253 neg. highway '^ r 187NY 336 6 1 7 new trial case 1 1140 617 471 „^u „^ 10l[sS5S nominal damage a 178 NY do 76 M 2U0l ""' isable value ,619 annul mar f 170 509,riage AC 103n case 2 business done AC review 169 J08 NY damages 90 M 104n 3 85 S r ISO NY 922 452 620bldg. contract 563 discontinue 85 S 90 1 68 M 918 I 136'case 2 s 85 S 789 a 184 NY 531 quantum meruit 150 361 454 603 eed 3 86 S 9 14 AC £4 318 565 costs 3 85S 96 vesting 186 406 transfr notes 3 85 S 964 486 final charge 3 86 S 981 99 494 490 street openg s 85 S 858 |45 M 164 622 new trial 467'case 1 B 86 S 1136 a 179 NY 591 663 100 627 referee rept. ■lease 1 380 s 88 S 1093 a 179 NY 579 569 neg. liable allowance s 85 S 712 ease 2 1 180 NY 518's 85 S 1151 104 341 f 89 631 586 partnership 63 Is 88 S 1103 Is 85 S 599'referee'e report ABBliESIATIONSi a. affirmed; d, distinguished i t, followed; r. reversed; m, modified; *. dismissed; n, note; c, iritieiaed: 1, limited; e. explained; o overrulert: s. same case; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case: a. Que»tion«a. N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division Vols. 89, 90 a 180NY 6339 8SS ease 6 BlSONY case negligence 101 67 556 1138 521 VOL. 90 I receiver 3 85 S SSM discretion 223NY 661 369 109 right way 114 77 title costs 224 4 .performance 8 85 S 732 a 181 NY 11 133 715 interest Ul 175 180 181 116 211 123 276 125 certiiicate 51 M competition 133 60B 477 889 513 400 712 118 274 recovery 104M s85S s 182 NY 106 110 61 M costs deft" 123 . clients costs 18 AC 99 215 NY 474 35CP 424 729 taxable costs TOM 45 for review 89 M 290 to client 106M 418 797 249 1 3 opng. street s 85 S 650 rl78 NY 421 16 declarations s 85 S 689 188NY 265 126 609 incompetent ev. 122 882 cks. presume 64M 159 presumption 170 468 22 contract 3 85 S 669 112 253 276 f 86 M 41 demurrer 150 430 presumption 159 475 28 proof heirs s 85 S 601 117 407 411 mark title 139 664 purchaser burdn lOlM 47 32 security costs 8 85 S 1126 8 94 420 36 use street 3 85 S 636 a 180 NY 27 compensatn. do 149 659 damages 157 787 178 153, 154 do 178 157 39 chg, beneHc 3 85 S 613 3 179 NY 517 estoppel 60 M 463 change grade 221NY 288 43 submission 3 85 S 592 a 178 NY 223 50 city liable 8 85 S 616 s 180 NY 53 3 190NY 486 87 divorce ev. s 85 S 640 a 183 NY 520 53 M 439 circumstantial evidence 165 696 92 Corp. coupon. 8 86 S 164 r 182 NY 27 adnusaiona 188NY 425 39 CP 174 103 mark, title 8 86 S 12 8 91 613n 105 448 mandatory 138 453 I 09 subscription stock 8 86 S 144 a 180 NY 554 125 larceny 8 85 S 1056 a 179 NY 518 f 90 605 compet. ev. 117 61 conspiracy 156 168 1 86 petition s86S 98 8 48M by motion 198NY allegation 148 684 283 98 750 192 depositions 3 85 S 1089 8 177 NY 400 » 14 AO 224 14 AC 236n regularity 139 pro e 780 199 cond. precdt s 85 S 735 188NY 504 204 pleading 3 86S 66 131 292 207 pleading s 86 S 60 120 392 2 1 3iury question 3 86 S 85 a 180 NY 519 do 95 390 t 49 M 249 307 sales 8 85 S 633 92 589 600 3 1 1 negligence s 85 S ft 180 NY 98 104 tl05 126 reargument 110 neg. defects 125 liability 195NY t 163 do 166 invitation 153 644 509 266 341 10 73 118 481 479 960 479 219 homicide s86S a 179 NY conspiracy 68LRA conviction 120 acquittal 156 116 126 194n 332 418 759 206 I 40 rceiver 8 86S 132 200 313 1 49 sale contract s 86 S 1044 a 182 NY 326 1 5 I memoranda 8 85 S 768 a 181 NY 520 I 6 I beneficiary 3 85 S 775 a 181 NY 684 17AC 305n written consent 115 399 170 water meter 8 85 S 750 115 216 132 736 52M 594 59 M 198 58 good charactr 3 85 S 627 90 231 instruction 114. 490 distinction d 118 263 66 vicious dog s 85 S 693 a 182 NY 536 1 76 considerat'n 3 86 S 129 r 181 NY 477 47 M 86 plead statute 114 767 37 CP 210 contract 52M 404 quan. meruit d 117 855 233 broker dam 3 86 S 42 a 180 NY 561 119, 116 stock margin 16AC 173-4nl79D tender 57M 316 conversion do 151 877 do 151 87n 221NY 446 239 disorderly 8 86 S 77 178 194 r 179 NY 678 245 submission 3 86 S r 119 oontracv, 190NY competition 190NY injunction 190NY allegation 67 M 25 1 gift ev s85S a 184 69 862 305 308 500 610 255 suscriptions 3 85 S 503 a 181 NY 636 267 contract 3 85 S 621 a 181 NY 563 cond. precedent f 87 M 269 275franchise tax 3 86 S 218 m 179 NY 99 payments 143 218 NY d 218 NY license fee 7 .»24 493 752 3 1 4neg. recovery 279 514 84 715 s86 3 a 1S3 NY 97 notice f 171 324 trusts 3 86S s 100 360 509 336 village bonds 3 85 S 488 59M 403 invalidity 137 419 348 h'way neg. 3 85 S 47 1 a 180 NY 516 obstruction 116 787 19A0 272 fright damage 17AC 131n 35 I seduction 85 S 465 8 110 510 611 356 negligence 3 86 S 497 a 181 NY 633 97 176 107 174 out of order f 164 423 36 I mtg. assignt s 86 S 510 r 181 NY 205 382 neg. dam 3 85 S 657 a 179 NY 526 386fact question s86S a 181 NY 90 3 14 AC 478 313 612 317 39 \ ins. waiver s 86 S 546 a 184 NY 537 397 damages s 86 S 156 106 34 assessment 111 759 certiorari 67 M 648 407 remittitur 8 86S 99 d 119, 3 14 AC enforced do 138 175 244 582 360 2 96 408 no violation 86S 141 133 868 4 1 3 insurance 3 86 S 98 8 14 AC 330 special plea 119 682 limitations 39 CP 293 422 penalties s86S 415 do 100 511 48 M 79 civil remedy 122S 512 amend answer 138 126 res judicata 67 M 528 intent immate'l 140 815 criminal intent f 88 M 43 not evidence ,176 323 no estoppel 176 324 443 indorser s 86 S 350 r 181 NY 98 453 new trial s 86 S 397 a 181 NY 515 474 amendment s 88 S 429 60 M 680 f 125 93 sick benefits 20 AC 53n no certificate do 162 144 484 dischgemtg s85 S 1064 46 M 320 502 pub officer s 85 S 553 r 184 NY 100 107 443 5 1 3 counter elm B 85 S 677 a 178 NY 611 8 107 653 costs lOSM 646 555 constitutnl. a 86 S 445 117 872 legislature 72 M 420 discretionary 77 M 580 not . controlled 179 20 legisl. power 105M 369 560 taxation 8 86 S 386 a 182 NY 521 125 208 average amount 151 766 distinction 161 767 567 conformat'n 520 taxation 3 85S a 180 NY certiorari 217 NY 481 532 77 536 liens 3 86 S 7' 102 31 8 14 AC 3; pers. judgment 124 810 538 memoranda 8 85 S 746 43 M 653 542 waive objn.«. s 85S 727 iSAO 151n, 152n motion late 150 250 548 town action 3 86 8 a 184 NY 96 61 M amendment 8 116 412 582 601 31 530 553 transfers s86S 411 98 260 authentication 202 NY 310 remit case e 202 NY no appeal 213 NY 311 160 s86Sj, 127 126 2HN al85 NY 613 110 687 113 1S4 amendment case 12 112 907 pers injury a 185 NY • 613 variance 112 240 127 578 138 258 cond. precd 116 324 master liable 17 AC 2VSn 57 1 infant care s86S 176 130 122 166 392 reasonable care 72 M 564 577master liable 3 86 S 72 a 181 NY 519 17AC _, 289n cond precdt 116 324 oeg. coservant 118 349 liability act 118 350 superintdt. 121 39 liability law 17AC 278n intent legisl. do 72 M 44 purpose statute 164 734 not hazardous 169 750 construction 170 167 585 legacy lien s80S 139 a 181 NY 258 588 corpn tax s86S 420 r 179 NY 49 94 566 99 64 59 I corpn tax - 86 S 193 deduction 125 298 distinction 151 767 596 possession s86S 18H e96 149 cloud title c 64M 586 tax sale c 133AD 828 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified: *, dismissed- n note- 0. enticiaed; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case: 3e appeal s 86 S 862 a 179 NY 603 exceptions 153 81 485 Prox. cause 86 S 1018 54M 452 paramount right t 168 609 496 notice s 86 S 1000 97 M 46 538 atty's lien s 86 S 838 f 119 463 settlement f 39 CP 366, 367 547 stay costs 8 86 S 1022 109 147 66M 568 17AC 323n 324 324n 139 728 551 hush. nee. 86S 1101 186 lis, 119 553 damages sR7S 1 141 59.3, 5 construction 141 interest 141 d 96 M no interest 149 offset 149 99M 'order f 151 925 598 620 621 651 593 injunction 8 87 S 125 e 45 M 290 com.law nuisance ILRANS 240n 597Iife insurance s 87 S 210 a 181 NY 585 602 assault dam. S87 8 144 101 137 construction 140 67 taxpayer suit 89 M 497 not apply 92M -2 607 on account s 87 S ■ 139 d 170 457 61 1 unpaid tax case 1 s86S a ISO NY dissolution case 4 s86S * 179 NY mandamus 133 1132 41 1143 521 r 179 NY 572 dismissal case 26 s86S 1130 a 179 NY 688 deliver books case 33 8 86 S 1140 a 178 NY 576 6 1 4 attachment case 10 s 86 S 1132 poundage 44 M 421 inj. negligence case 12 s86S rl85 NY 1137 879 642 1146 442 1132 250 764 429direct result s 86 S 899 143 45S 430 sum pro. ,502 dissolution 109 8 86 S 917 a 181 NY 543 s86S d 112 62 M stay 18AC dismissal 919 121 498 262 506give judgmt. s 86 S 952 162 356 5 ! Ojury question 8 87 S 162 * 181 NY 526 r 182 NY 307 97" 415 104 239 557 certiorari s 87 S 19 a 179 NY 531 563 chnge grade s 87 S 24 r 178 NY 416 not retroactive £ 171 499 569 jurisdiction " S 837 50 M 511 513 may appeal 160 480 compliance f 160 482 6 1 2 notice case 7 8 86S 100 contract case 9 s86S a 183 NY encroachmt 8 120 verdict case 10 8 86 8 1162 a 180 NY 666 decisions case 12 8 86S 1136 a 181 NY 642 decisions case 13 "86S 1136 a 181 NY 542 verdict case 16 8 86 8 1137 a 181 NY 517 certiorari case 17 s 86 S 1143 a 179 NY 564 aeg pers. injury case 18 s86S r 180 NY case 19 57 1 negligence s87S 219 94 66 duty master 125 694 156 371 1133 384 aSi S a 120 verdict s86S a 181 NY 1132 762 case 21 1135 536 580 transfers 8 86 8 871 50 M 121 16AC 264-5n VOL.92 I trust 3 87S a 179 NY 86 M ratification 57M compliance 59 M accountable 133 65 520 403 24.S 683 burden defendant 64M .-180 degree care 146 98 M 107 8 87 8 £ 164 5 construction s 87 S 318 73 M 181 surplus 75M 595 not property 149 351 fees not pass do 149 liability 140 1 6 certiorari S87 8 a 179 NY 106 mandamus 123 discretion 76 M 40 trust vests s86 S d62M trust sift 62M 355 281 270 829 ■83 85 47 paymt note s 86 S 773 f 92 616 99 122 162 252 bona fide holders 180 NY 349 54M 128 oldest items 162 254 collat. security 98 M 269 56 nee, party 736 145 284 47 M 20 party defendent 124 612 misjoinder 81 M 651) 75 offer judgt. s 86 8 889 s 16 AC 20 costs 68 M 427 recover costs f 80 M 685 82 canvas vote s 86 8 892 8 179 NY 174 89 em. domain 809 364 961 1 1 2 neg. damage 1 87 8 311 124 30 specl. damages 18AC 224n 197NY 73 restrict proof 197NY 73 inadmissible 20 AC 165n I 1 9 election law » 87 S 407 *.178 NY 616 designation 111 263 1 26 r.r. certif. 8 87 8 334 15 AC 457n 116 67 cross streets d 155 64 1 3 1 discharge 3 87S 316 a 179 NY 601 no jurisdiction do 130 874 1 35 ins. use hgs. s 87 8 368 8 109 919 1 38 suppress def, s 87S 343 do 124 638 incompetent do 124 1 42 libel 3 86 8 f 109 venue f45M 641 1111 5S2 236 143 tort waste s 86 8 122 damages 171 1 47 appeal s86S * 182 NY damages s 123 1098 342 1105 617 s86S f 92 compliance f 90M 771 615 83 148 161 9 I will trust 8 87 8 sl05 cause action 186 NY 345 possess fund 169 413 613 certiorari case 20 's868 1143 a 179 NY 624 incompet. ev case 21 s86 8 1135 c 179 NY 195 [ costs 114 169 I removal case 22 s86S 1133 96 easemt dam 8 87 8 338 s 106 633 100 neg. injury s 87S 864 m 181 NY 521 res ipsa loquitur 18AC 289n 284 153 coservt neg. sS6 S 1103 118 658 safe system 123 ■ 617 assume risk e 123 618 160 extra allow. 3 87 8 75 m 180 NY 414 1 64 appealable s »K S 1121 W2 434 104M 691 1 67 considerat'n 8 86 8 1069 a 182 NY- 630 48 M 486 Irdlt. transfer e 98 123 promsory rote 12 16 247 1 7 1 preferences s 87 8 10 d 99 429 Vols, 92, 93 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division 109 877 120 . 213 equity action 103 dl03 f 107 el08 109 47M equity suit 116 201 NY 54M • law action 59 M 4oe 407 695 58 877 652 216 500 214 336 178 damagea B 87 S 225 a 179 NY 364 138 550 551 1 87 new trial s 87 S 41 a 181 NY 573 Bale by sample 103 4„ measure damage 79 M 30 acceptance 82 M 471 205 stolen prop, 8 87 S 3S8 a 179 NY 540 2 1 7 contract s86S 1116 a 181 NY 664 223 defect neg, s 87 S 261 d 104 104 safe system 123 617 assume risk e 123 alteration 153 618 406 252 warranty s 86 S 1118 78 M 288 105M 654 262 vested right 87S 185 64M 48 attachment 164 403 172 312 284 demurrer s 86 S 1123 _- . 566 practice 53M 120 intervention 63M 194 relief C3M: 197 cause action 157 41 jury calendar 179 641 294 accounting s 87 S 181 117 689 f 92 M 495 liquidation 121 207 cause actijn 121 885 survivors ship 125 572 300 power court s 86 S 1078 130 196, 198 ICP NS 183 duty court 3 OP NS new trial f 83 M 376 admr. s 87 S 16 t92 380 92 381 alien executor 17C 336n 379 alien admr. s 87 S 18 17 AC 336 n 382 corpn stock 235 considerat'n s 87 S 176 a 181 NY 536 242 reversal s 86 S 1065 172 137 stay do 172 138 243 discharge s 87 S 172 93 608n 95 324 98 620 249 dismissal s 87 S 38 106 692 17AC 177 180n 244 244n negligence 61 M 38 CP delay 112 neg. burden 119 good faith 137 order f 163 183 45 62 91] 25 1 dismissal B 87 S 37 92 260 137 61 17 AC 179n 180n 243n neg. burden 119 45 38 CP 324 laches 134 355 taxable costs 138 277 order f 163 911 74M 484 s»7 S el03 till distinction 67 M authority 168 427 breach 3 87 S r 180 NY 369 479 922 200 280 a 179 NY 594 e 103 150 joint ownership 111 453 83 M 378 construction 52M 444 survivor 167 53M 513 husb. and wife 123 849 intent deposit 194 NY 56 survivor f 166 532 will s 87S s87 S punctuation 72 M 242 326 614 436 mech. lien s87S 151 a 178 NY 632 440court's pwr. s 87 S 67 M 442 order case 13 s 87 S f 139 542 bill partic. s 87 S 257 45 M 266 544 trust s88S m 181 NY 86 S 1131 113 127 19A0 411 53M 40 construction 113 new trial case 16 s86S 1148 * 180 NY 517 short decision case 17 3 86S 1141 r 183 NY 123 joinder case 18 1149 r 182 NY 37 50 M 49 deposit case 20 s86S 1133 * 181 NY 546 101 109 costs amount 53M 40 18AC 412 interloc. judgt verdict case 25 s 87 S 1139 a 184 NY 583 30 128 s 87 S 1141 a 179 NY , 528 tax nonresident case 31 s 87 S 1144 a 180 NY 506 98 84 104 629 107 . 16 certiorari case 6 87S 1143 a 179 NY 524 certiorari case 34 s 87 S 1148 a 179 NY 530 referee report case 37 s 87 S 1148 a 181 NY 540 107 237 181 597 303 compel attendance s 86S 19 AC 1109 169D 306neg. coservt. 3 86 S 1070 f 102 128 assume risk lU master neg. 118 detail work do 133 445 demurrer s87S 114 a 180 NY 622 161 137 calculate time f 86 M 690 449 vol. paymt. s 87 S 214 145 887 a 179 NY 580 65M 101 whole contract 71 M 421 295 235 257 349 916 322 amendment s 86 S 1089 99 238 131 80 terms costs lOP NS 245 325 actual int. s 86S 1080 105M 483 330 foreclosure s 87S 206 120 108 not enforced lOlM 572 forfeitures lOlM 620 352 appeal 3 87 S 126 56 905 366 circum- 8 86 S 1113 f 171 272 368 trespass s 86 S 09 f 90 M 94 M liability d 136 1095 136 374 649 435 137 907 109 222 564 insolvent s 87S 78 136 251 prerequisites 155 44 575 venue waive s 87 S 12 121 506 consent 155 400 578 insurance 9 86 S 1055 a 180 NY 527 s 15 AC 100 before burial -lOM 29 policy 143 367 rule of evidence 462 claim 9 87S a 178 NY sl5AC 128 606 83 467 contract s 87 S 285 s 47 M 444 accounting 117 262 consent mutual i 178 729 49 I eq. trial s 87 S 348 92 618 506gift C mortis s 87S 258 19A0 251n 5 1 negligence s87S 314 46 M 119 114 477 167 174 charge error 127 34 513 negligent s 87S 345 183 557 5 1 8 tax certior. s87S 104 523 interest award 9 87S m 179 NY e95 304 54 38CP 614 costs case 1 18AC 113 1.56 s87S case 2 costs 3 87S 113 acctg appeal case 23 3 87S * 179 NY mandamus case 30 9 87S a 178 STY do 143 death loss 207 NY 584 carriers s87S a 181 NY 157 waiver 225NY 587 vendor case 9 s87S 108 371 166 30 533 308 496 659 529 title deposit s87S 54 6 1 I judgments case 1 s 86 S 849 * 182 NY 649 * 186 NY 553 liquor tax case 3 a 86 S 1144 a 179 NY 93 6 1 2 tax costs case 4 3 86 S 1142 * 180 NY appeal case 8 s 86 S 1149 a 181 NY 578 decision case 16 s86S 1151 a 183 NY 660 carriers case 18 s86S 1138 a 181 NY 186 appeal case 27 8 87S 1129 f 92 613 613 costs case 7 188 407 126 60 1138 1133 125 1140 517 1145 615 6 I 5 report case 9 9 86S a 183 NY case 15 will 86 S a 1 79 NY 1133 546 1140 386 6 1 8 appeal case 1 s87S a 182 NY 507-08 case 2 8 87 S 1138 a 182 NY 47 620 will "unmar ried" case 2 3 86S a 179 NY 1137 1149 261 621 appeal case 3 S86S 1143 a 181 NY 535 appeal case 16 s 86 S 1138 a 183 NY 652 mandam case 19 3 86 S 1143 * 179 NY 663 civil service 49 M 608 622 appeal case 17 s 87 S 1-126 a 181 NY 539 lottery case 18 3 87 S 1143 a 179 NY 69,5 appeal case 21 s 87 S 1147 a 181 NY 537 appeal case 23 3 87 S 1147 a 179 NY 579 VOL. 93 com agencies s 86 S 971 105 392 representation 60 M 193 1 4 negligence s 86S 921 s 183 NY 524 3 1 liquor tax s 86 S 1003 f 100 515 liq . tax bond SIM 643 revocation 52M 608 right rebate 134 466 damage 137 393 scope employ ■ 72 M 390 intent immaterl. d 150 113 criminal intent f 88 M bond 10311 43 102 40 dam neglig, s 86 S 947: 100 S13 53 pers injury s 86 S 817 s 100 611 57 deed reform s 86 S 924 a 183 NY 568 68 mortgage a 87 S 268 r 184 NY 690 title interest 60 M 246 80 negligence 105M 609 86 void contract s 86 S 986 a 182 NY 8 15 AC 533 58 707 137 44 161 54M intention 92 M -public policy 180 60S illegality 182 471 93 defect walk 3 86 S 944 15 AC 321n duty corporatn 204NY 354 98 party deft. s 86 S 941 160 279 1 02 spec, perfrm s87S tl05 e45M 47 M contracts 57M reply 62 M equity 162 104M 140 336 80 516 543 460 691 1 05 limitationa s 86 S 1009 do 130 223.224 e 155 489 e 155 440: AB:BREVIATI0NS : a, affirmed; d. distinguished ; f. followed; r, reversed; m, modified: *, dismissed; ». "o*** c, criticised ; 1, limited ; e, explained ; o, overruled ; s, same case ; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; a. queitioneo N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division Vol. 93 155 441 103M constructiTe frd part realty 155 438 185 within the time personalty f 215 NY 17 185 laches 96 M 484 181 demurrer 77 I 1 4 probate s87S do 107 retrial 126 204 17AC 14111 172 party aggrieved 72 M --- 8 87 8 99 23 a 102 134 authority uo 117 pleading 55M trike out 1 1 Sbefore judge s 87 S 28 f 84 M 259 1 1 9 voidable s86S do 116 evidence 145 equity 162 104M 588 141 friv. 976 403 612 460 691 124 restrnt. trade s 87 S 412 8 IflONY 373 I36burd proof use care 73 M 415 niay recover 181 3 1 38 one action s87S 2 116 899 150 706 relief 17AC 88n 90n 143 incomp. ev s87S " - 117 ext allowance 65M pro. 149 sup s 87 S 20 AO 301n f 85 M 254 1 53jury question b87 S 623 98 105 e 45 M 570 78 60 M 466 238 neg. q. jury s 87 S 69- 467 104 627 a negligence 69LRA 627n 539 515 511 Sfil 148 580 149 062 demurrer 273 1 86 comm'sBions 8 87 S 567 172 521 46 M 420 tOoM 347 16AC 409n 429 general legacies 89 M 345 1 90 valid deed s 87 S 563 eq. relief a 185 NY 383 owner in fee 37 CP 212 206rent advance s87 S 658 52M 150 ratification t 164 195 2 1 I bill partic 3 87 S 653 do 120 313 120 311 186 517 2 1 2 taxation 137 263 contract 3 87 S 687 i 180 NY 219 r 180 NY 216 274 affidavits 3 87 S 740 109 114 284 pers. knowledge 112 897 papers insufficient 38 CP lOJ 278 assignment 3 87 S 673 ' 182 NY 53S consideration 117 presumption 123 560 s 87 S 379 a 179 NY evidence 116 130 „. 57M 519 relief 129 543 529 456 362 310 .476 2 I 7 assign con- tract ,^ s 87 S 61 m 183 NY 398 Performance — e 56M 1 57 ins. jurisdn. • 87 S 525 a 181 NY 392 164 elect remedy s 87S 554 124 681 1 69 ins. evidence « 87 S 630 a 179 NY 590 19AC 196n judgment roll dill 418 performance 54M lOM 1 75 bona fides B 87 S 646 e 101 439 good tittle 125 765 pers. property d 126 769 fixtures 137 48 62 M 484 ICP NS 268 conditional sale d 158 594 f 173 466 estoppel s87S 120 49 M 55M 221 jurisdiction 704 627 money 141 implied contra 71 M 65 d 97M: 597 parties bound f 216 NY 5« s 87 S . . do 171 commission „eieht ev 226 s 87 S 143 - - M complete answr 148 43 error requests 148 44 229 contempt 8 87 S 754 97 492 misconduct juror 99 593 review 121 362 554 70 LRA 539n demand reUef ,.„ 17AC . 88n 91n 346 commissions law action 88 S - 181 NY damages f 1" 166 252 construe will 16An 3 87P 747 I' "■ r 180 NY 516 title estate 356 direct verd 3 87S no 130 request jury ■47M to jury 146 error court 158 32 244 358 brech repair 716 590 2 356 457n 480 87 S 99 101 contractual 112 pers injury 16AC damages 60 M action in tort 7.57 580 282 trust 8 87S a 183 NY Stat, frauds 134 AD 870 292 lottery s87S r 179 NY 776 164 303 doing busins s 87 S 869 a 183' NY 98 102 269 112 64 2 AO 217n condition precedt 45 M 360 309 waiver s 87S 881 d 64M 254 677 3 1 2 acct. redeem 548 s 87 S f 114 604 47 M barred 175 i?' 320 bar debts s87S !>7n97 so; o «7» had ^''^'^ 330n 333n ..fl'}, 324 stay costs ■■^"^ S87.S 891 17AC 617 128 566 7»? 4IOmunic. corp. m-,^ .. iable 182 answerable 182 183n 809 804 652 697 83 95 804 403 165 359 appeal sS7S t 109 a 183 NY reversal p 165 for jury d 165 273 670 913 553 288 286 364 master neg s 87S 640 do 134 918 368 material pr. s 87S 672 18AC 88n 370 demurrer 8 87 S 658 8 101 15 AC not libel per se do 138 308 872 911 o,-, 508 510 373 retrial a 87 S 666 604 17AC 142n 377 easement 878 9 87 S a 183 NY 379 appeal s87S 671 680 324n r 181 NY 398 326 fr'd transfer 931 202 Hi 100 456 accounting "' 117 trust 186 234 review 's87S 74a 347 262 110 335 injunction 3 87S a 179 NY 112 expenses 112 counsel fees 117 862 531 677 679 383 demurrer 8 87S a 179 NY liability 128 393 ord .care s 87 S 697 116 528 d52 s 87 S burden deft. 146 170 64M 579 396 commissna 8 8V d 50 M do 137 568 178 667 96 696 -87S mandamus a 179 NY fee in trust 59 M franchise 67 M f 162 lOOM 789 569 585 473 48 573 416 at. imprvm^ 3 87 8 798 185 NY 123 authority fil M 301 424 mater'I ev. s 878 693 134 220 427 liq. eertif. 3 87 8 f 107- 43 M meal' 117 157 ( 163 660 607 499 9 440 462 43 I law remedv a 87 S 800 48 M 271 undivided cost 126 13 436 instruction a 87 S 763 a 183 NY 506 contrib. negl. 63M 594 strike out f 161 52 442 estoppel s 87 S 682 a 184 NY 663 authority 113 200 reap superior „™ 120 130 129 acts binding 486 144 692 not enforced f 166 692 449 quan. s 878 66M meri 653 171 452 negligence 3 87 8 f 10 9 brokerage 130 773 f 84 M 649 452 453 nom. dam = 87 8 810 524 warranty 786 128 ~ 82 595 not examine 78 M 139 243 trespass f 82 M 429 456 costs tax 57M 676 146 459 option 8 87 8 — 100 669 f 102 548 contract d 112 546 472 co-partner ship 87 S 648 not recover 146 516 87 8 95 fciorari 680 633 476open default s 87 S 050 78 M 267 relief terms f 171 479 mark. .87 8 t93 residence S2M 551 title 663 618 ID] ft a 44 care 117 reason. t9AC public 153 484 propoaalfl 3 87 8 831 108 17.^ 3 109 913 486 transfer tax 8 87 8 842 r 179 NY 308 49 1 negligence s 87 S 814 61C 274 596 care 402 nuisance 209 496 contrib. neg 3 87 8 836 98 348 142 305, 307 observations 109 43 judgment f 113 913 presumption 125 285 500 taxation 3 87S 179 NY 257 5 1 6 conclusive 833 681 15 540 reference b878" 817 e 97 126 109 197 court's power 179 239 546 spl. damage s 87S 927 165 391 18AC 183n, I84n libel do149 157 562 wharfage s 87 8 S87 127 388 564 coven't lease 887 563 864 461 842 878 133 E82M decrees 63 M no bar 142 442 95 M 32 not binding 649 152 751 i7rt advancements " 92 M 132 f^^ 520 competency 473 s87S SOM 8 87 8 e95 57M 111 beneficiary 111 180 388 816 403 demur! --„ a 87 S 339 juriBdiotion 98 s 87 8 885 1 do 171 t'r 1469 lease dam. 7018 87 8 714 566 48 M 539 733 I 53 1 libel 8 87 8 14 AC 124 665 d 153 102 construction 627 ridicule 74M not libel do 154 414n 77S 247 620 456 s87S do46M re-entry 128 deficiency 93 M premature 182 rent unpaid 104M 551 566 incompet ev s 87 8 883 d 98 221 104 13 neglig. corpn. 146 74 569 neglig. dam. 3 87 8 893 8 45 M 448 injury child t 133 910 575 coservant lease 3 87 8 101 116 d 4 J .\1 repairs 171 f 171 69 M 889 4 352 4 570 570 482 579 commissns. s 87 8 940 5SM 23-- 580 not to sue s 87 S 930 140 4 fairly construct 76M 187" 582 bag'ge neg. 434 518 a 88 8 a 183 N Y liability 123 'ex loci 130 credibility 145 penalties 72 M 722 450 478 242 588 right to — refer 9.38 439 87S 75 M 388 'ex loci 79 M 639 not implied 869 168 469 535 mandamus 8 87 8 856 * 179 NY 513 591 lien filed . 878 lOSM 593 appeal 8 87 8 112 review 18 AC fact question 68LRA ^S^rS^^Sie^ ^t^iflA^^'^: ^IIS o^n^f^lir^^lef^i-Utin 900 673 . 811 253 333 724 Vols. 93, 94 N. y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division 1133 577 604 CO. ti'eas. fees case 1 B87S 1144 a 183 NY 114 appeal case 3 B 86 S 1144 a 179 NY 696 appeU case 6 B 86 S 1135 a 181 NY 581 appeal case 8 e 86 S 1140 a 181 NY 565 jury queBtiOQ case 1 5 B 86 S 1129 B 10 5 621 605 office case 7 a87S majority e49M wager contract case 16 s 87 S 1137 r 181 NY 231 appeal case 21 B 87 S 1130 182 NY 545 606 assess dam case 9 a 87S 1130 r 182NY 286 assess dam case 10 b87S 1130 r 182 NY 285 appeal case 13 B 87 S 1130 appeal case 14 B87S 1141 a 181 NY 580 judgment case 17 s 87 S 1148 a 184 NY 621 bkrupt. frd ease 20 s 87 S 1160 r 183 NY 267 appeal case 24 s 87 S 1150 a 183 I'fY 558 607 sale 4th. dept. case 1 s87S 1136 m 183 NY 182 demurrer case 6 B 87 S 1134 a 178 NY 625 case 7 6 87 S 1134 a 178 NY 468 appeal case 9 s87S 1140 a 182 NY 540 appeal 4tu. dept. case 12 b87S 1148 a 181 NY 618 mail answer case 18 .s 87S 655 8 CP 453n public hackman 146 313 validity f82M 104 608 salary case 2 b87S 1144 111 161 609 breach sale s 87 S 588 f 99 632 6 1 2 salal-y case 1 B87S a 182 NY case 2 competent B 87 S 206 NY 1132 24 dismissal case 4 8 87 S 1147 a 183 NY 519 appeal case 9 8 87 S 1131 a 180 NY 513 dismissed case 10 s87S 1136 a 178 NY 614 trustee resign case 18 s 87S 1131 a 181 NY 513 inspectioDcase 19 3 87S 1139 c 183 NY judgment case 20 s87 S 1133 a 181 NY 566 6 1 3 corpn, case 3 s87S 98 tax 1144 84 demurrer case 42 1130 33 1139 48 646 8 87S r 183 NY case 44 St. nuisance 9 87S r 180 NY liability 142 appeal case 45 3 87S 1129 a 182 NY 538 appeal case 46 s 87 S 1135 a 182 NY 634 6 1 4 appeal case 1 3 87S a 183 NY appeal case 3 s 87 S 1148 a 183 NY 618 6 1 7 accept title case 10 s87S a 185 NY 1151 617 1141 572 1127 521 617 6 1 8 appeal case 7 8 87S a 180 NY notice 114 letters admin. case 16 s 87 S 793 * 180 NY 528 6 1 9 ins. breach case 2 8 87S 1127 r 184 NY 339 VOL 94 I remedy s87S 82 M 4 rulings s87S S2M 66M requests 152 534 68 901 348 342 699 9 books as ev. s 87S 924 19 AC 198n 19AC 200n 1 4 negligence s 87 S 921 d 109 227 notice 116 326 assume risk 17AC 288 19 indictment s 87 S 897 a 179 NY 459 24 improp remks 8 87 S 951 100 8 dollO 898 899 15 AC 369n contract Sunday do 110 70 M time rule 185 NY sl5A0 improp. 51 M new trial 126 construction 70 M 852 9 90 cond't 648 480 error 84 M barred 180 3 8 87 8 98 8 109 156 351 658 1143 601 906 382 91] 432 measure duty 157 334 38 fact question s 87 S 911 110 603 labor law 113 649 19A0 210n employment 119 672 master neg. do 214 NY 551 56M 135 unforseen 128 732 cond. precedent 146 69 certificate 83 M 220 NY preference 120 137 priority e 149 763 superior f 161 152 245 764 422 58 negligence s 87 S 1054 a 182 NY • 544 67 liability s 87 S 1086 96 M 603 71 remedies s 87 S 956 94 M 737 77 water rights s 87S 991 99M 377 84 indictment s87 S 962 126 672 perjury 60 M 316 99 discharge s87S 1112 a 180 NY 603 S15AC 114 compliance 53M fiS 104 cq. action 8 873 1076 124 244 1 07 appeal s 87 S 1077 128 877 law question 877 transfer 1089 840 128- I I 7fr'd s87S 109 xtra allow 114 625 626 122 135 f 125 88 strict constrctn. 20 AC 188d preference 170 353 1 33 employee s87S 116 salary 220 NY 1083 333 55 47 promise payment 9 87S * 182 NY 105 105M consideration 111 642 e 45 M 77 48 M 488 lOOM 651 947 527 256 614 53 mech. lien s87S a 182 NY sl6AC 55M lOlM 917 545 75 637 34 139 ratification s 87 S 1066 120 6 143 $50 costs s 87 S 1014 67 M 518 149 exceptions 8 88 S 123 a 183 NY 561 1 56 privilege 8 87 S 1059 129 228 disclosure 146 119 1 65 shares stock 8 87S stkholders 16AC 30n 34n 36 36 1 77 res ipsa loq. 3 87 S 1006 18AC 297n recovery 20 AC 162n 179 foreclosure s88S 173 a 186 NY 564 not discharged 174 531 1 83 master duty 8 87S tl08 contract do 128 for jury 150 998 213 186 187 new trial s87S a 179 NY f 94 M 98 590 655 1011 639 1 92 appeal s87S a 182 NY adv. possession 17AC 2n3n 199 distribution s 87 S 1038 115 417 personalty 115 420 do 426 188 NY 262 prtnrship realty 67 M 418 1118 114 I 7 1 corpn. s88S a 182 NY 185 NY elOl 106 date 109 46 M bldg &. 1 assn 456ill3 103 646 194 489 697 2 1 1 change venue 8 87 S 1005 154 323 2 1 6 bar debts 8 87 S 1020 17AC 331n 2 1 9 partnership 3 88 S 21 m 183 NY 173 237 judgment s 87 S 1046 al82 NY 540 8 179 NY 596 66M 121 fict names 61 M 378, 379 designation 61 M 388 ICPNS 197 198 recovery 136 compliance ICP NS 199 describe person ICP NS 208 a 182 NY 8 179 NY 431 560 271 exempt tax s87S 1107 d 99 526 repeal law 105 7 s 16 AC 125 278 removal 8 87 S 1022 e97 29 for cause 129 880 justification 141 642 282 coroners s78S 1122 a 179 NY 602 city oficers 152 authority 162 submiBBion a 184 NY 63g 357 v'flt'd rights s 88 S 44 reduction 48 M 569 reasonable 48M ~ 567 retroactive" eftct 20 AO 52n 40 46 287 certiorari s87S r 179 NY 291 flse. s87S r 184 NY 105 60M 1017 253 repres, 1049 179 392 193 491 244 bankruptcy s87S 1070 a 182 NY 644 257 bill partio. 8 87 S 976 45 M_ 266 definite answer 1 15' 288 96 M 49 259taxpay'rsuit s 87 S 1094 47 M 313 pwr. commissnr f 172 235 authority do 172 241 marginal way 298 pawnbrokers 8 87 S 1068 t 104 616 preferential 66M 586 300 satisfaction s 87 S 96 62M 62 accord 20 AC 274n 303 performance 3 87 S 973 99 261 bill particulars f 148 643 76 M 261 306jury question s 87 S 1031 d 102 509 312 bill partic. 8 87 S 1003 IS AC 180n 163 117 322 waiver ' S 1 20 AC 288n 331 assignment 83 511 93 637 731 s88S a 183 NY tl07 47 M discharge 120 by delivery 71 M 319 liability 156 717 release liability 161 275 credit check 161 277 213 NY 305 legal effect f 161 278 342 oral contract 366 stokhldr suit 8 88 S fg4 176 agreement dill joinder 61 M liability 124 pleading 124 accounting 37 CP 118 injunction 131 act void 70 M constructive trust 84 M 29S 383 stkhldr suit s 88 S 313 103 100 108 248 388 contrib. neg. 8 88 S 33S 103 217 instruction 116 160 obligation 146 .560 superior right f 173 196 384 666 194 34ii 732 733 327 893 732 678 397 crim. law s88S 1103 e44 M jurisdiction 123 information 64M 95 M lOlM arrest 69 M 92 M n» waiver 71 M 93 M 343 595 378 289 279 110 697 326 376 838 376 s88S a 185 NY 106 119 scrutinized 62 M 91 265 404 breach dam. 8 88 S 73 105 20 e 111 105 168 62 intent 115 393 probable profits do 160 . 170 cause action 90 M 358 covenant 180 570 408 demurrer s88S 70 f SO M 389 19AC 448 one ( 149 243 413 powT amend 289 293 s88S 43 108 827 f 110 limitations 187 a 187NY 784 98 M 352|i00M 245 recovery 310 I 187NY 266 accounting |353 partition (amendment 148'8 87S 978 s 88 8 60 118 270 273 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; ♦, dismissed; n, note c, criticised; 1, limited; e, Rxolained ; o, overruled; s, same case, do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, qaesti»»«' N. y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division Vols. 94, 95 136 591 38 CP 22 19AC 448 mistake 56M 349 res ipsa loq. 18AC 288D. bar 38 CP 8, 11 change name 62.M 632 429 removal s8SS 58 f 145 423 impartial 158 59 security 172 425 no doubt 97 M 268 test decision 10111 371 439 venue s 88 S 235 99 360 143 828 change venue 154 323 443 instalments s 88 S 161 218 US 24 no authority 218US 24, 25 445 revocation s 88 S 164 d 55M 618 prop right 130 647 intervention 63M 517 449 accounting s 88 S 52 s 120 154 a 180 NY 532 contempt 68 M vest title 90 M 142 453 crim. law 8 88 S 40 a 179 NY 553 463 realty chge 8 87 S 745 b88S 1113 a 179 NY 666 466 negligence 8 89 S 58 110 883 servant deft, do 135 847 474 release 8 84S b87S 112 SOM indorser's 220 NY 481 verdict s 88 S 99 M 922 872 403 593 duty 150 485 trust prop 8 88 S 17 194 NY 76 alienate ICP NS 150 493 party name 8 8S S 107 d 45 M 200 504 conversion s 87 S 1101 s 52M 212 65M 529 141 105 equal shares 146 296 509 easement s87S 1104 r 180 NY 401 46 M 627 5 1 4 imp. repeal s 88 S 115 a 179 NY 529 16 AC 133n repeal 192NY 200 designation 162 39 40 93 M 621 522 franchise s 88 S 34 do 125 368 maintain road do 145 656 right to build 77 M 492 532 pleading = 88 S 13 f 109 556 163 70 co-tenants ILRANS 478n demurrer 161 137 541 corpn certil 3 88 S 162 r 182 NY 453 544 deposits s 88 S 246 a 183 NY 545 554 recovery s 88 S 228 117 309 f 170 102 judgment f isa 916 liability 213 NY 258 174 757 cause action 167 761 564 franch. tax 8 88 S 197 a 180 NY 16 99 64 575 chge venu* 8 88S 113 e 45 M 236 578 liability 3 88 S 487 f 134 643 136 100 592 road public 3 88 S 379 i 174 484 595 spl. term s 88S 368 137 501 600 coservt. neg a 88 S 407 107 297 605 duty state s 88 S 468 351 278 construct bridge 166 466 609 tax sale case 7 s 87 S 1146 a 181 NY 540 109 124 161 4 169 349 appeal case 11 8 87 S 1141 a 183 NY 547 recovery case 12 s87S 1149 * 179 NY 601 credibility case 14 s 87 S 1143 case 16 master duty s 87 S 1142 r 183 NY 317 6 1 credibility case 1 8 87 S 904 a 181 NY 514 case 2 prom, notes 8 87 S 1001 f 94 612 S I I decision 3 88S 1114 a 184 NY 618 6 1 2 coserv't neg case 4 s88S 1101 r 183 NY 46 referee rept. case 8 s88S 1115 a 182 NY 537 accounting ease 9 s 88 S 1104 m 183 NY 425 case 20 I rape 3 88 S 1112 r 179 NY 345 6 1 3 decision ease 18 3 88 S 1096 a 184 NY 632 appeal case 19 s 88 S 1105 a 183 NY 546 fraud case 23 3 88 S 1106 r 183 NY 78 negligence s 125 72 614 judgment case 7 3 88S 1102 a 183 NY 510 amend record case 18 s88S 1105 a 18 3 NY 376 gambling case 19 s88S 1108 m 183 NY 109 costs case 20 s88S 1110 100 229 ICP NS 246 d 5 miss case 27 s 88 S 1095 3 180 NY 629 a 183 NY 579 appeal case 29 s88S 1114 a 184 NY 547 neg, walk damage case 30 3 88 S 1092 r 183 NY 338 6 1 9 larceny case 13 3 88S 1111 a 182 NY 529 reduce police case 14 S 1113 a 183 NY 579 appeal case 15, 16 8 88 S 1110 a 183 NY 553 power refer- ence case 18 B 88 8 1096 109 197 620 man- slaughter s88S a 180 NY appeal case 37 s88S a 182 NY appeal case 38 s88S a 183 NY case 35 1112 510 1116 533 1109 517 VOL.95 I recovcrv s88S 443 6 injunction 3 88 S 742 53M 397 1 3 negligence s 88 S 483 r 183 NY 353 res ipsa lo(iuitur 18AC 294n master liab 112 292 293 1 8 legis power 3 88 S 573 107 481 stockholders 66M 550 authority 137 677 23 liq. tax law a 88 S 509 e 95 . 29 resubmission 112 578 invalid 20 AC 252n contempt 96 M 562 160 S 878 28 liq. tax law 8 88 S 612 97 442 ballots 112 574 compliance 62 M 337 validity 20 AC 251n 32 deliver books 8 88 S 633 a 179 NY 600 37 costs s88S a 184 NY 405 586 38 r.r necessity s 88 S 522 e 103 124 16 AC 462n 44 fraud tax s88 S 11 s 101 223 264 48 injunction s82 S 647 3 88 S 625 a 184NY 684 presumption 149 742 servitude 152 303 158 13S easement 181 365 57 retrial s 87 S 793 17 AC 146nl47n enforced do 138 29r. 62 commissions s 88 S 462 66M 484 84 inference s 88S 460 133 202 66 error jury s 88S 425 177 244 68 contract s 88 a 470 d 120 493 4!I4 quality 65M 71 tender s88B 56M 466 467 482 597 73 notice lien s 88 S 441 106 338 jury trial 113 628 pers. judgment 17AC 91 195 NY 376 135 586 60 M 564 71 M .331 78 delay damage 8 88 S 479 f 46 M 261 damages 80 M 46 d 88 M 36 82 negligence 8 88 S 463 d 97 134 84 contract 88 S 499 112 276 69 M 188 term ends 105M 583 86 ins waiver 8 88 S 530 119 676,580 48 M 518 49 M 70 must plead 39 CP 286 proof waiver 39 CP 292 cond. prcdt. do 135 662 no waiver 135 741 139 185 inadmissible 148 773 89 defect prem 3 88 S 517 B 16 AC 171 bill particulars 109 816 142 71 92 costs s 88 S 478 f95 360 66 M 458 90 M 399 jurisdiction 65M 42 not reviewable nt) M 617 no appeal 09 M 622 f 89 M 439 t 90 M 399 94 market value 8 88 S 507 176 215 present facts 176 215 102 assume risk 8 88 S 446 a 184 NY 683 108 negligence 8 88 S 447 97 402 fevers error 113 439 108 em. domain 3 88 S 426 99 625 629 tl04, 61 award rule 113 819 1 1 impeachnm't s 88 S 732 112 612 not a bar 53M 680 release f 92 M 713 19AC 433n 19 AC 436n award 113 819 restitution 145 17 impeach release 155 335 I 1 2 mastr liable s 88 S 816 106 525 scope employmt 112 297 I 1 6 liability 3 88 S 55-i 129 610 coservants 81 M 313 I 1 9jury question 8 88 S ■ 422 111 335 res ipsa loquitar 59M 38 122 strike out s 88 S 504 169 784 126 encroachmt 1 88 S 829 116 621 ilreets safe 116 629 review 116 627 authority do 145 499 city liable do 145 503 132 e toppel 3 88 S 511 62 M 291 l34parolevid 3 88 S 495 106 211 113 .807 specif prfmce f 108 339 description 128 584 specif, realty 137 5 140 reverse error 3 88 S 870 113 439 1 42in8 warranty s 88 S 821 104 573 ife insur a 194 NY 677 00 liability f 78 M 503 1 49 death dam 8 88 S 847 3 15 AC 184 expenses 51 M 322 adrar. funds 37 CP 260 finding 146 299 additional ev. 80 M 24 1 59 construction 3 88S 500 do 122 634 1 62 bill partic. s 88 S 52 tl04 2 118 9 122 61 ABBREVIATIONS : a, affirmed ; d, distinguished criticised; 1, limited: e, explained ; o, overruled ; 6, ; f, folio wed ; r, reversed ; m, modified ; *, dismissed ; n, note ; c, same c ase ; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, questioned. Vol. 95 N. Y. Sapreme Cotfft Reports — Appellate Division 156 45 M 56 M 382 203 332 1 64 goods sold 8 S8S 440 1 7 1 unlawful 8 88 S 537 96 M 211 183 proof will s 88 S 734 112 496 testamentary capacity 112 498 f'89 M 649 presumptn 61 M 556 burd proponents 73 M 323 90 M 234 burden ehifts 70M 147 burden proof 179 545 make wills 180 672 1 87 parties sSSS 107 839 596 192 writ assist, s 88S 502 99M 378 I 94 St ordin'nce a 88 S 704 a 182 NY 665 abuttor do 189NY 227 1 99 inj neglig. B 88 S 438 a 184 NY 522 202 reliance s 88 S 401 130 850 misstatement f 168 851 205poor person s 88S 403 19A0 311n 208 award costs a 88S 565 no costs 18AC 140d right to costs 18AC 139n 143 106 2 1 I vesting s88S 110 . 310 eomniissions 16 AC 416n gift 76 M 416 title lOlM 73 213 defense s 88 S 685 141 278 2 1 4 inj damage B 88 S 767 184 NY 528 2 1 7 taxation B 88 S 694 a 180 NY 536 f 95 632 56 M 301 proportion 143 87 226 easement s 88 S 762 r 184 NY 391 a 183 NY 129 106 223 49 M 134 50 M 176 24 1 ins warrnty s 88 S . 757 beneficiary 111 388 243 enforcible s 88 S 850 174 587 249 damages 8 88 S 796 r 183 NY 387 253 construction s 89 S 41 a 179 NY 450 e 96 325 do 111 46 86 M 210 266 test trust 988 S • 916 128 225 27 1 mandamus 88 S 965 8 110 894 280 indorsement s 88 S 578 a 183 NY 522 103 461 f 160 270 review facts 123 825 160 271 injucion 129 review 207 NY 287 usury sSSS r 183 NY 628 163 292 larceny s 88 S 622 180 NY 148 297 contracts 3 88 S 641 rl84 NY 308 purpose 53M 309 parol evidence 122 653 311 r. r. negli'e s 88 S 609 d:41 844, 845 323 certiorari s 88 S 657 143 20 329 atty power 8 88 S 686 8 109 25 bank negligence 69LR 339n survival 129 697 parol agreement 129 697 comp. witness 62 M 602 compliance s 136 518 error ruling 136 519 interested 73M; 187 uot parties 152- 322 336 neg. notice 8 88? 102 f- do. 116 17 103 .107 AC Buperindent 1 on 120 681 507 596 182 326 281n 602 234 walk neg 737 342 nom'ldam. 8 88 S 1070 3 lis 326 346 exception s 88 S 665 392 581 352 insurance s 88 S 717 a 183 NY 581 discontinue 132 246 indemnity d 141 496 dismissed do 141 510 order 163 675 360 profits dam S 835 105 20 contract 118 128 130 pubic policy 8 118 129 measure dam. 54M 106 127 721 129 894 discretion do 126 239 amendment 19A0 301n invalidity 182 464 365val. assign' t s 88 S 607 139 462 d 72 M 269 fund pro tanto 72M 495 assignment 225NY 323 368 undertaking 8 88 S 576 a 184 NY 521 a 180 NY 500 120 305 67M 99 prerequisite 64M: 618 4 1 ins comissn 8 88 S 676 105 403 actual intent do 158 245 conclusive 166 344 417 affidavit s 88 S 661 53M 400 discovery 18AC 193n perpet. evidence 140 535 426 dismissal s 88 S 722 141 185 186 432 pleading 8 88 S 700 8 103 377 109 559 17 AC 405 waiver 176 749 437question jury 8 88 S 758 104 162 112 204 assumption risk 110 573 do 110 579 147 77S liability act 118 349 132 377 17 AC 278n law question o 128 784 not applicable 136 317 master neglig. 20 AC 133n 371 acc'ntprom 443 accounting ^88S 5Sfs88S 798 101 471U 181 jjY 562 __. , exr. comissns. 374 neg. wk L 46 M 393 3 88 S 690 igA.C 416 419n 122 916 126 641 «5J"'*3' „ costs 129 . 53 a 00 a right to wait l| 112 143 "■"• dismissal 156 - 454 blackmail 117 381 appeal 388S a 183 NY oral proof 102M 388 witness s88S 8 182 NY use of ev. 17 AC 781 „,.;= ix^ 41 43 ^^^ 8 15 AC 193 no warrant 133 652 liability 153 848 652 not liable 546|d 172 733 112,469 fish law s 88 S 881 a 180 NY 7 597 f do 96 619 510 72n 393 weiglit ev. 8 88 S 638 49 M 404 druggist neg s 88 S 568 stay 16AC 257n relief 17 AC 88n cross action 124 557 lex loci 144 73 1 407 contempt Is 88 S 678 109 298 48 1 certiorari s88S p96 -uw reference 630 53M assessment 56 M proportion 143 774 615 336 10 37 489 reference 88 S 98 f 110 148 f 67 M one trial 178 867 116 893 240 563 697 492 privilege s 88S 963 19AC 356n 501 irrevocable 8 88 S 906 f 50 M 478 fll3 _ 903 em. domain 117 _ 556 construction 117 557 revocation 135 581 138 188 award 185 548 5 1 Oappeal s 88 S 714 e 99 394 15 AC 397 5 1 4 comr report 8 88 S 947 a 181 NY 549 not excessive do 148 561 5 1 8 prf m partic s 88 S 929 e 99 261 bill particulars f 148 643 76 M 251 522 recovery s 88S 934 181 25 524 appeal 8 88 S 592 * 179 NY 562 3 105 643 533 presumption 3 88 S 769 109 901 award f 119 882 highway s 119 883 em. domain 127 618 compensatn 130 526 easement 196NY 118 131 702 153 174 160 83 173 37 182 608 183 382 damages 131 715 do 724 f 160 103 compliance 71 M 482 extinguishment 153 173 f 216 NY 12 public streets 183 382 542 distinction 8 89S 4 124 37 books produced 80 M 146 error order 157 ■ 252 discovery d 157 702 545 arrest s89S 126 427 45 552 title vested 224NY 207 562 reformation s 88 S 1012 do 150 733 clerical error 159 496 duty investigate f 159 497 566appeal demurrer 3 88 S 993 a 180 NY 535 574 corpn. tax s 88 S 1030 r 180 NY 62 f 99 459 579 marriage s 88 S 874 f 96 607 62 M 159 63M 480 96 M 166 presumption 111 676 59 M 122 62 M 161 96 M 167 ev. pedigree 18 AC 232n 598 rebates a 88 S 1022 e 117 544 134 468 cond. precedent 128 541 revocation 62 M 513 63M 517 forfeiture f 88 M 261 602 promise 8 88 S 1052 106 396 38 CP 501 ,506 compet. ev. 35CP 4 Bcknowledgmt 19A0 416n parol evidence 78 M , 569 60 5 partition a 89 S 26 a 184 NY 193 binding 81 M 435 618 finding 8 88 S 1096 r 183 NY 802 6 1 9 appeal case 1 s 88 S 1091 a 183 NY 551 mandamus case s88S 1113 a 183 NY 570 620 mandamus easel 388S 1113 alSONY 642 105 214 audit case 2 s88S 1113 625 sup. answer s 89 S • 1107 8 95 633 626 distribution case 2 - 88 S 1108 * 179 NY 666 48 M 592 628 negUgence s 88 S 1106 113 . 503 master neg. 122 429 629 appeal s 88 S 1098 a 183 NY 652 63 1 motion dis- miss case 10 8 88 S 1105 * 179 NY 661 632 dismiss case 3 s 88 S 1093 s 179 NY 661 a 182 NY 641 affirm order case 12 s 88 S 1094 8 105 629 jurisdiction case 13 3 88 S 1116 * 181 NY 506 633 mandamus . case 16 B89S 1113 a 181 NY 609 tnal policeman case 23 , 3 89 S 1113 r 180 NY 237 620 report case 17 S88S a 184 NY 1110 535 620 appeal case 21 88 S 1114 a 183 NY 554 penalty costs a 116 620 62 1 warranty case 4 3 88 S 1092 a 183 NY 487 622 new parties 8 88S 1099 a 180 NY 503 ABBREVIATIONS: a, alBrmed; d, distinguished; f. followed; r, e, criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; 0, overruled; s, same case; do, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, nott; dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, questioned N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division Vol. 96 VOL.98 I certiorari 3 88 S 1060 a 181 NY 550 5 judgment s88S 1018 a 182 NY 543 body complaint 183 619 1 4 diBinissal 9 88 S 954 15 AC 342n constructive trust 84 M 296 minority stockholder 176 666 I 8 sp prfmnce s 88 S 973 a 183 NY 557 waiver 120 556 no cause 75 M 23 estoppel s 88S 709 64M 67 waiver 138 920 27 filiation s 88 S 924 8 105 499 quasi criminal 155 449 35 state nesli'e s 88 S 823 142 494 averment 149 34 legal conclusns. 166 68 pleading 184 191 40 neg. coservt. s 89 S 55 102 296 master neglig. 113 636 jury question 104 162 charge rule 111 833 rules necessary 20 AC 141n 45 warranty B 89 S 21 fllO 811 meas. damages do 156 143 presumption 214 NY 583 48 judgment e 89 S 49 112 240 52 amendment s 89 S 284 a 180 NY 533 f 110 allegations ell2 64 114 425, 745 17A0 In 4 cond. precedt. 140 613 143 651 f 45 M 360 94 M 607 190NY 223 assumption 113 384, 386 waiver 114 744 do 746 cause action 114 428 demurrable 125, 103 147 535 60 M 368 pleading do 122 511 190NY 221, d222 dol90N-^429,230 compliance 67 M 83 M 104M 140 recovery d 146 presumption 145 S73 585 512 193 613 578 56 credibility s89 8 i a 181 NY 524 6 1 costs s 89S 134 65 conversion s89S i 112 I chat. mtge. 195 NY 216 NY substitute 195 NY evade law 160 245 621 247 364 69 error charge 3 89 S 71 US 476 126 503 future conseq. f 138 627 8 1 neg. coser'vt s 89 S 23 a 183 NY 556 85 elect, remedy 88 S do HO 91 trespass s89S 8 106 99 costs s88S 114 1079 904 346 1083 198 I 02 illegal liquor traffic 1074 631 323 sSSS f 96 pleading 52M affidavit 114 212 NY 248 301 I I Ofranchise tax s 88 S a 183 NY' good will elOl f 105 105 do 120 1066 574 326 134 328 901 I \ 7evidence def . s 89 S 35 1 20 basis tax s 89 S 72 130 .334 1 22 delegation s 89 S 79 legis. power 110 704 111 027 169 316 use streets 48 M 425 restraint trade 55 M 344 exp. lesrlslation 133 estoppel 81 M franchise 181 644 696 30 good faith s 89 S 74 46 M 291 1 36 seizin in fact s 89 S 414 a 184 NY 74 a 15 AC 220 tenancy curtesy 137 870 139 s89 70 M ptnhi. only S 485 5o4 1 43 privileged 3 89 S 482 a 179 NY 281 117 24S 120 734 58M 165 review .evidence e 68M 165 authority 38 CP 94 148 redeem, tax s 89 S 416 r 180 NY 24 1 54 cond Bale 9 89 8 118 f 108 143 19AC reverse 123 481 17. 34 93 898 253n 255n error 167 disaffirmance 111 788 (iff set t9AC 256n purchase price 69 M 333 retaking 86 M 415 rescission 179 644 I 57 injunction s 89 S 19 f 96 631 s 46 M 291 1 60 pleading s 89 S 85 131 4 1 63 prefrnc cal eudar 3 89 S 200 do 111 249 165 preference s 89 S 199 54M 83 1 69 negligence S a 183 NY f 110 125 distinction 51M liability t 153 f 167 181 217 NY reliance 154 18£ 512 119 73 293 479 436 100 387 805 188 Covenant 8 89 8 135 do 46 M S6M survived 120 203 174 664 388-9 17 sum, proceeding 637 38 91M 684, 93 M surety 98 M 35M limitation d 134 "otherwise' 97 M premature 177 220NY 20 1 contempt 589 56 350 542 656 3 89S a 179 NY 19 AC privilege ILRANS constitutl. 126 oath 193 NY objn. exception 364 594 346n 356n 169n 394 238 193 NY 21 3 Privity b89S elU 144 negligence 114 Liability 115 143 54 M covenants d 181 not liable 182 240 395 752 829 23 558 341 601 541 813 236 damages s89S 317 s 112 191 48 M 539 possession 137 259 142 term office 180 NY 268 269 249 substantial s 89 S 343 143 20 256 revers error s 89S 273 8 105 405 46 M 42] 268 bill partic 9 89 8 208 109 687 reversal 160 594 270 architect neg. s 89 S 226 a 184 NY 545 amendment 19AC 303n excess 71 M damages f 89 M 151 456 275 indemnity s 82 S 292 8 190NX 46 2S\ injunction s 89 S 201 a 185 NY 584 covenants 20 AC 72n 284 collision s89 8 98 55M domicile SO AC 216 88 407 30n 290 state separately s 89 S 296 157 721 293 larceny s 89 8 181 1 184 NY 612 2961iability test s 89 S 260 83 M 587 305jury qUi^ation i 89 8 349 100 397 exceptions Case 19 fsljg 865 safe tools 141 260 incompetent 149 i 315 rights parties s 89 S 176 172 506 3 1 9 mistake 9 89 8 258 46 M 320 323 construction 3 89 S 298 96 342 penalty 106 e 45 M 223 46 M 582 l6AC262-3n266n transfers 47 M 50 M intent 183 a4M authority 68 M 120 119 369 576 631 401 guaranty s 89 8 222 a 184 NY 586 18AC 314n 4 1 judgment 8 89 8 210 106 648 f 174 457 105M 647 vacate judgment HI 191 mandatory 183 18 4 1 3 bankrupt 8 89 8 212 e98 67 r 186 N Y 58 4 1 8 trust vesting s89S 126 a 183 NY 605 340 penalties 9 89 8 1115 m 179 NY 4" s 180NY £ f96 ( e45M : 344 damages 3 89 8 325 a 184 NY 356 dismissal 132 349 352 353 remedy s 89 8 234 19 AC 259n 358 mech lien 9 89 8 689 m 183 NY 342 107 208 111 851 presume intent Ul 851 intent notice 51 M 606 £ 94 M 703 pers judgt* 135 195NY 71 M inquiry 80 M 586 376 331 337 365 liability 9 898 289 67M 89 full indemnity 7C M 469 no error 106M 481 376 libel 9 89 8 sill 263 267 383 unconstitu- 989 8 193 102 106 police power 125 695 392 party deft s 898 310 124 85 notice essential 148 760 inlerplcajer 165 162 204NY 287 397 I s 89£ 67M best 75M enl. guard. 1 206 5 interest 427 487 right of way s 89 8 99 do 113 892 49 1 benefioiarv s 89 8 65 a 185 NY 578 48 M 667 569 15 AC 41 5n forfeiture 20 AO 55n 495 contract s 89 8 114 50 1 assesE 8 89 8 a 180 NY 168 738 618 518 142 82 43 506 off set 8 89 8 113 estoppel 121 meas. damages 37 CP 135 515 not recover s 89 S 78 146 8 5l7mtg. assigmt 9 89 8 154 96 639 impenchmnt !8AC 453n primary fd. C3M 478 make repairs 218 NY 502 535 constructn s 89S 116 f 148 476 424 St opening e89 8 180 107 24 539 nonsuit award Interest ' s 89 3 92 120 293 72 M 164 169 f 143 224, entirety 178 3 427 city neg 8 89 8 130 16 AC 329n law question case 1 do 153 935 381 517 441 surety s89S a 184 NY books as 19AC 196n joint several 171 420 books entries 185 799 454 legacy -- 8 69 96 M 207 458 grde crossng 8 89 8 12? r 180 NY 192 e98 640 134 692 :raud 53M 483 465 labor law s89 8 107 47 M 186 master neg. 56M 13? aie certif. do 134 146 47 1 construction s89 8 41S 56M. 04 479 conviction s89 8 564 *180 NY 546 72 M ; 172 limitation 148 460 construction do 148 464 550 neg.rule 9 89 8 137 128 62 rules necessary 20 AC 138n 20 AO 141n 557 dam. notice 8 89 8 67 a 183 NY 581 notice defects 172 43 575 neg. charge 9 89 8 112 d 125 631 581 priority 89 8 238 r 182 NY 387 594 practice 8 89 S 689 102 417 598 damages s 89 8 630 f 101 607 towns claims 61 M 31 607 subpoena duces tecum case 5 s 88 8 904 s 99 324 s 15 AC 214 case 6 labor law s 89 8 1113 r 179 NY 411 produce books 79 M 528 ^t^inS^^i^VP^fu^' ^ffi'P.ed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; ., criticised. 1, limited; e. explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do. dissentina opinion: p. parallel case; q. questioned dismissed ; n, note; Vols 96, 97 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — ^Appellate Division contempt 627 decision 638 decision VOL. 97 d 139 788 f 110 79C preaumption 79 M 530 case 12 s 89 8 119 171 S31 123 261 83 M • ' 81 3 89S 1103 a 184 NY 543 1 master neglig. s 15 AU 251 without notice 608 order a 183 NY 522 s 89 S 612 84 appeal s 89 S 671 68LRA 681t 93 M 500 ■^ ^ ** ^^^ Vlul case 1 dismissal 639 verdict 98 250 s88S 1033 case 13 case 1 104 104 a 183 NY 550 I63„ title 252 negligence a 180 NY 534 i89S 1100 s 89 S 1108 infer neg ig. s 183 NY 566 s 90 S 76 a 89 S 945 attys. lien a 184 NY 611 a 183 NY 516 130, . 443 city duty walk a 186«NY 554 a 184 NY 696 123 7o assessment case 11 p. facie neghg. 112 85 attorneys lien a 100 610 case 36 3 89 S 1118 20 AC 153n remedy s 76 M 332 102 296 6 1 3 foreclOHiirfi j89S 1114 a 186 NY 558 90 M 462 sale realty 127 845 case 1 a 181 NY 509 dismissal !5 pract locatn 168 154 master neg. s88S 106F jurisdiction cases s SOS 624 1 1 1 fencing 118 . 349 m 184 NY IRS ■1 150 456 457 8 89S 1101 74M 593 s 89 S 652 185 protection assume risk jury question d 150 459 a 184 NY 519 easement 187NY 33 s 89 S 870 134 797 ILRANS 2321) annulment 90 M 405 estrays 91 M 222 neg. damages case 2 831 chg venue case 10 case 12 8 89S 1103 1 9 place trial 19A0 373 205 NY 364 187 services 258 vesting s 89 S 939 sSSS 102(5 d89S UOl * 180 NY 562 eviction case 1 2 HI- 190 9 89 S 621 a 89 S 856 110 310 sllQ 854 137 290 16AC 171n 1 1 4 reason, care e45M 412 177 293 s 89S 579 recovery 276 validity act 615 referen ce 23 mandamus 132 104 60 M 78 3 90 S 18 c 'se 1 ^898 1110 s 89 S 574 res ipsa loq. liability 9 190NY 409 8 88 8 779 al82 NY 234 a 179 NY 668 64M 581 131 332 equitable claim .'3 M 336 f infi 61 F scaffolding 132 551 1 AUU UAU removal 28 "for cause" 142 200 191 judgment "and" "or" 6 1 7 ciiange ev case 19 3 89 S 719 safe tools case 3 223NT 214 = 88S 752 8 89S 1113 129 880 142 287 5 89 S 817 125 654 * 179 NY 602 justification 151 162 f 115 882 283 allegation dismissal 141 642 submission securities 3 89 S 929 620 certiorari case 20 155 410 193 NY 287 i 101 35 sSSS 631 a89S 1112 31 receiver for injury liability a 183 NY 640 624~revooatl,in a 183 NY 583 case 21 appeal s 89 S 1112 3 89 S ■ 582 no defense do 180 537 f 158 487 1(8 sheriff fees 81 M C33 198 amend, ans. 286 degree care s 89 S 959 f 176 516 s88S 9i; a 183 NY 582 s 89 S 593 b89S 858 123 f 163 268 692 mech. lien case 26 3 89S 1115 35 jurisdiction s89 S 601 d 163 9 f 87 M 228 1 22 liquor tax 19A0 303n 202 lien filed 289 transfer tax s 89 S 979 a 181 NY 551 d 188NY 271 116 210 37 CP 285 625 decision r 183 NY 306 3 89 S 683 s 89S 834 case 1 judgment 37 power appeal a 181 NY 527 105M 673 s8«S 1104 case 28 a 89 S 619 97 630 a 184 NY 603 a89S 1118 104 134 205 teat, capac. trust 3 183 NY 562 indemnity 126 will valid s 89S 871 immune 150 809 vested 150 808 not taxable 76 M 382 case 2 decision 18AC 371n, 372n s 89 S 661 133 912 s89S 1102 case 33 liability s 109 S68 47 M 484 s 89 S 1103 128 215 do 109 869 212 probate will 122 495 a 184 NY 595 f 211 NY 128 do 109 870. 872 3 89S 865 judgment 3182 NY 628 f 211 NY 129 revncation 58M 106 case 4 good title 18AC 39S burden proof s88S 1094 125 766 39 master neg. review 68 M 585 296 sp. pertmce a 183 NY 556 pers. property 3 89 S 580 164 240 undue influence aS9 S 960 dismissal 125 768 53M 124 71 M 638 103 473 case 6 cond. salens rules necessary i 3 1 certiorari sS8S 1095 140 728 20 AC 137n 8 89 S 826 218 appeal 299 injunction s89S 969 115 621 a 183 NY 556 167 71 3 106 45 B 89 S 823 conversion 48 Indorser authorize * 180 NY 531 case 11 632 alteration 8 89 S 658 185 489 * 182 NY 509 no bar s88 S 1096 s 89 S 152 d 118 416 defense 162 641 r 184 NY 121 case 5 notice 133 burden deft 15 AC 266n privilege 220 NY 395 sodomy 146 160 192 NY 513 s 89 S 669 reverse error case 13 pleading 124 16 114 054 a88S 1111 634 excess 129 18 115 835 301 inovation 8 89S 954 132 188 329 a 180 NY 555 verdict 170 394 137 affidavit advice counsel certiorari s 89 S 314 s 89 S 606 121 225 case 14 113 49 58 excavation 48 M 626 intent- a 15 AC 257 s88S 1114 B 89 S 664 bill partic. 135 383 a 180 NY 506 636 dismissal a 184 NY 537 116 894 "declaration" 305 liability s 89 S 9o5 f 99 M 136 compet. ev case 1 liability 179 440 158 582 case 15 3 89 S 1105 140 474 notice appeal 222 insurance s88S 1102 m 179 NY 438 sustain will B8M 181 r 183 NY contract 233 case 3 8 89S 1114 88 M 112 no duty - f 90 M 647 reaenbl.care a 89 S 849 m 184 NY 136 307 amendment s 89 S 9'° sl31 240 137 217 a 182 NY 527 do 88 M 115 do 122 482 negligence dividends obligation spl. damages 228 devise ease 18 s88S 1093 case 6 9 89S 1100 168 117 18AC 223n competent ev. 18AC 226 8 89 S 854 a 184N Y 534 312 tax exempt 8 80 S 95 a 180 NY 631 a 185 NY case 20 570 a 185 NY 590 case 8 65 allegation s 89 S 607 230 pleading presumption s 89 S 1109 165 409 141 neg. proof s 89 S 843 316 title lands s 89 S 982 140 163 s88 S 1001 r 186 NY 40 3 89 S 695 3 112 69 3 1 12 70 117 782 150 341 dismissal S9 neg. coservt elll 651 petition case 10 B 89 S 627 do 122 482 convey nothing 158 435 own title f 13R ''3-t patent void 98 M TOS case 23 8 89S 1102 e 102 48 56M 140 s88S 1093 a 183 NT 643 129 616 admissible 241 real estate * 180NY 528 626 damages rape case 13 s89S 1113 distinction 64M 175 liability 20 AC 174n 1 47 foreclosure s 89 S 841 89 M 187 case 21 * 184 NY 623 f 141 755 3 89 S 647 244 burdn. plff. s89S 1107 larceny 81 M 321 r 183 NY 548 s SO S 8M a 196 US 405 case 15 142 577 331 specific a25SC 362 s89S 1113 73 attachment 150 poor person s 89S 649 74M 210 performance jSOS 37 50 M 135 fl44 damages a 180 NY 511 s 89S 587 ,;ood faith case 28 subs service 177 862 19A0 31Sn 71 M 464 s89S 1110 case 18 f 93 M 108 f iTioljY- 573 • 179 NY 567 s 89 S 1104 82 liability 1 53 lateral supt 3roof plaintiff s * 181 NY 511 8 89 S 618 s 89 S 6091 82 M 391 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, «, criticised ; 1, limited ; e, explained ; distinguiahed: f. followed; r, reversed; m. modified; •dismissed; n, nott; 0, overruled: «, tame case; do, diaaenting opinion ; p, paraUe), caie ; q, questioned N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division Vols. 97, 98 337 suffic facts sggs t 181 NY a 97 s 101 108 ailegiiiioDB 119 do 90 M 39 Ci' strict construtn. 140 152 execution 140 pleading d 71 M 2a f 85 M 150 state each fact 77 M 363 344 contract 9 90S f 114 121 696 948 560 637 10 101 574 663 284 352 347 equity title s 89 S 1046 161 379 352 neglig. dam. s 89 S 1049 a 184 NY 545 ordinary care 185 869 degree care 185 876 355 ™les ev. 389 S 1051 53M 589 res ipsa i. J SAO 2927 358 !imitatioas«' s 90 S 27 110 211 360 neg. for jury s 89 S . 1074 104 104 labor law 133 415 master duty s89S a 181 NY surrogate 50 M 119 modification 51 M authority 103M 95 M 385 appeal s90S a 181 NY restitution f 97 114 liability 128 eause action do 146 equity 88 M 1 90 M 222XY 131 28 512 637 785 622 421 380 392 liability s 89S 1072 137 73 395 contrib neg s 89S 1042 r 184 NY d 132 136 negligence d70M 148 360 342 40 r 41 I nonsuit s SOS 1040 P 70 M 410 d 411 413 neg. q fact" s 89 S 1027 a 107 256 4 1 6 malic, pros. s90S 5 r 184 NY 504 s 15 AC 261 probable cause 177 692 153 SOS 435 403 434 gifts sOOS 103 . admissions 118 195NY trust deposit 131 194 NY 58, 64 incompetent ev. 131 403 204NY 418 declarations 205NY 48 t 96 M 116 438 transfer tax 977 560 486 126 183 124 90 S d 197NY 131 5 14 appeal 8 9dS a 183 NY privileged 58 M 167 44? wife charge ,s 89 S 1031 122 246 impeachmenb 18AC 455n ICP NS 45 necessaries 104M 72 447contiib. neg B90S a 182 NY do 109 124 142 Instruction 116 for jury 125 150 do 173 59 M 20oNY ordinance d 185 818 667 92 873 524 160 290 289 198 661 229 19! 457 evidence s 89 S 10.57 s 118 . 124 470 services 8 89 S 1088 100 442 quantum m ;ruit HI .361 t 173 lis 46 M 324 res judicata 120 346 474 penalty s 89 S 1004 f 114 670-ldo673 477 no obliga'n s S9 S 1030 d 141 519 480 trespass 8 90S 102 111 98 M nuisance f 109 48 M penalties 76 M injunction 181 490 review s89S 121 contempt 67M 744 89 426 155 980 3C2 99 493 accounting 8 89 S 978 a 181 NY 513 496 realty chge s go S 3! r 182 NY 320 500 aflSdavit s 90 S 137 53 M 531 complian.:e 144 798 502 pending s 90 S 162 r 181 NY 308 507 reimburse 190 473 227 168 5 I 8 covenants 8 90 S 233 183 NY 36 525 libelous s 90 S 147 121 851 527 for money 63 1 dism complt case 31 i89S 1115 a 184 NY 628 632 neg. deatli case 3 3 89S 1100 a 182 NY 393 appeal case 5 9 89 S 1104 a 184 NY 624 appeal case 10 s 89 S 1105 a 183 NY 582 appeal 2nd dept. case 1 s89S ■ 1107 a 183 NY 660 634 award case 1 3 89S a 184 NY 636 appeal case 1 8 90S 183 NY 182 185 138 176 90S lOOM 530 trust 8 90S 98 new trustee 200 NY 166 532 pleading s 90 S 216 127 809 535 alienation !i 90 S 228 (1 118 4 122 437 uistribution GSM 82 invalid 154 610 perpetuities i 161 464 545 change beneficiary 8 90S HI 55 1 jurisdiction s 90 S 499 53 M 50 misconduct 129 831 supreme court 390P 19 justification 141 B42 580 ejectment 8 90 S 608 r 181 NY 346 easement 106 416 420 award 120 300 629 costs appea case 2 3 89 S 1116 • 179 NY 577 630 liquor tax case 11 > 89 S 683 a 181 NT 527-30 case 10 89 S 1102 ev. value 66M 504 award 67 M 193 1106 622 1116 613 637 appeal case 11 s90S m 181 NY appeal 90S a 183 NY case 16 3 90 S I 188NY elections 91 S * 180 NY 1094 129 case 14 1115 569 1104 575 case 22 889 519 638 equity case 1 8 89S r 184 NY 1069 17 639 appeal case 20 s90S 1101 a 182 NY 666 surplus case 24 s 90 S 1091 3 181 NY 607 552 640 accounting case 9 s 90S 11 11 a 180 NY 540 habeas corpus case 23 3 90S 1119 a 180NY 541 joinder case 28 3 90 S 1093 a 181 NY 660 641 adulterat'n case 11 90S a 182 NY appeal case 15 90S a 184 NY 1108 636 1105 551 642 new trial case 9 3 90S 1104 a 183 NY 511 tax title case 16 3 90 S 1090 m 184 NY 629 specif denial case 21 s90S r 184 NY milk law case 24 s90S r 182 NY construction SO M 49 1116 117 1108 1 643 negligence case 2 9 90 S 1094 r 184 NY 320 condemn, coats case 7 9 90 S 1091 r 181 NY 322 breach case 16 s90S a 185 NY appeal case 23 90S a 183 NY 1089 614 1117 661 tneas. damages VOL. 98 7 accounting iOOS a 181 NY 104 163 91 M Stat, limitations fill 177 178 185 653 464 44 379 do 167 169 173 46 M e57M 70 M 398 406 905 231 539 471 112 697 13 affidavit 8 90S 218 52 M 643 material ev 134 '220 29 stkhldauit 9 90S 714 a 184 NY 83 merger r. i 125 806 power broad 97 M 479 49 charge nea. sOOS 521 e99 127 53 transfer title s90S 456 a 184 NY 605 receivers f 86 M 70 64notice exeoutn s90S 524 el03 542 131 640 179 533 179 534 68 demurrer 8 90S 598 a 182 NY 619 validity 166 613 74 injunction s90S 693 109 551 do 135 907 146 4 153 366 172 137 court power 120 210 62 M 347 no stay 60 M 466 131 840 do 172 138 prop, practice 145 200 76 per. injury 8 90S 473 107 263 s 15 AC 331 license 136 471 do 470 exclusive 136 473 safe guarding do 136 477 error court 178 684 nonsuit e 180 453 82 "doing bus- iness" s90S 313 do 147 887 112 64 a 182 NY 563 183 NY 103 211 NY 427 220 NY 267 tax nonresident e 183 NY 265 interstate commerce 220 NY 317 85 collusion 3 90 S 438 175 844 56 M 407 88 ins. extensn 9 90 S 418 a 184 NY 554 f 98 619 92 constitutnl. 90S 117 contempt d 171 740 44 279 95 bill partic. 8 90 S 142 109 423 116 404 97 conclusive 9 90 S 784 [22 816 1 1 trial pref. 3 90 S 773 a 181 NY 521 98 145 147 f 98 619 620 f 100 516 unconstitutional f 107 249 preference 185 805 56M 124 power court f 167 127 1 1 1 revere, error ■i 90 S 780 56M 608 reference 126 846 long account 164 208 1 1 7 reference 3 90 S 681 118 809 1 22 settle accts s 90 S 786 dismissed 182 NY 652 surrogates 'pow'r 72 M 569 72 M 621 92 M 128 184 NY 44 jurisdiction 130 810 59 M 567 72 M 595 620 no power 136 524 equity action ICP NS 324 relief 70 M 467 130 spl. damage 18 AC 219n 220n Incompet ev. 18 AC 226 restrict proof 197NY 73 inadmissible 20 AC 166n 133 for jury 3 90 S 685 121 572 136 berv. corpn s 90S 671 136 fi28 172 875 cond. precedent 180 748 139 fraud relief ■ 90S 561 AlillKEVlATlONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followea; r, reversed; m, modified; * dismissed- n note- n, criiici>ed; 1, limned; e. explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, diss) nting opinion; p. parallel case"; q, que'stionea Vol. 98 N. 7. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division a 180 NY 541 affidavit dn 124 320 publication 20 AC 23411 143 stipulation B 90 S 673 a 16 AC 343 discretion S3M 644 106M 204 1 46 preference s 90 S 734 f 98 619 IfO 383 148 amendment B 90 S 729 106 260 a 112 650 46 M 195 discovery 212 885 140 584 sub. d tecum 180 74 58M 353 complaint 140 535 t 162 817 152 knowledse s 90 S 691 168 261 155 conclusive s 90 S 731 118 805 146 49 193 NY 396 1 60 appeal ,90S 721 a 182 NY 666 163 bill partic. B 90 S 741 113 306 179 accord 3 90 S 687 56M 620 20 AC 276n 1 87 trust deed 8 go S 496 do 111 668 equitable relief f 94 M 429 197 parol ev. s 90 S 518 67 M 395 liability 67 M 397 204 extra fees s 90 S 574 20 AC - 195n 83 M 580 212 trespasb 8 90 S 646 f 107 336 338 lex loci 115 432 ripar. rights r 188 NY 74 by our laws £ 88 M 498 222 spl damages 3 90 S 661 18 AC 221n, 224n admissible 20 AC 173n 225 notice neg. s 90S 644 19AC 222n 228n 228 performance 8 90 S 605 114 774 presnmptlOTi i 130 419 restriction 172 204 317 ipAC 26n 233 ac'knowlgml s 90S 678 s 90S 793 19AC 416n 42211 237 assessment s 90 S 488 a 181 NY 511 not exempt f 84 M 552 rents received £ 178 679 244 custody child s 90 S 703 lUi 473 136 829 220NY 538 17AC 33n 39n 247 neg. dam s 90 S - 541 r 184 NY 519 1 02 479 labor law 112 334 scaffolding UO 734 30 AC 204n 254 dower s 90 S 481 B15AC 307 73 M 27 261 negligeenc s 90 S 652 do 114 917 liability 155 453 267 partition £90 3 516 a 181 NY 117 576 275 waiver 3 90 S 57M ( construction 125 22 em. domain 64M 501 appeals 180 210 283 may waive s 90 S 603 89 M 155 285 compensatn. s 90S 710 133 590 287 poor person a 90S 739 19 AC 310n security 173 535 291 jurisdiction s 90 S 420 144 247 294 modification 90 S 582 d 206 NY 219 30 1 nonsait 3 90 S 596 110 754 15 AC 320 city negligence 126 641 305 default s 90 S 589 170 474 308 prop, person 8 90S 642 waiver 56M 427 accountable f 160 837 3 1 2 mandamus 8 90 S 689 111 743 8 113 771 regular clerk 1S8NY 493 eond. precdt. 132 835 71 M 597 authority 152 46 3 1 4 pleading 3 90 S 680 55M 41 31 6 amendmnt s 90S 701 131 80 19AC 306n terms costs ICP NS 246 review 67 M 239 pay costs 15fi 50 160 903 j20 unenforciblc s 00 S 651 80 M 520 748 615 326 wager s 90 S £ 46 M bet Ling 59 M 426 recovery 74M 545 illegal 84 M 380 328 atty's. lien s 90 S 903 e 106 132 18AC 94n 343 observations 90 S 239 r 184 NY 530 108 145 349 law fact question 90 S 264 s 100 614 negligence cane 13 t 11 2 902 63M 595 355 misconduct 8 90 S 268 a 98- 634 affidavit 58M 318 74M 530 81 M 77 99M 575 f lOOM 608 indictment f 116 910 error court 63M 644 incompetent ev. 72 M 106 not apply d 104M 135 36 1 negligence B 90 S 222 s 109 184 question law f 107 621 366 strict.constn. 3 90 S 208 127 . 611 competency 142 116 376 pera. injury 3 90 S 653 r 183 NY 395 390 claim s90 S 48 M 318 90 399 diversion water s 90S 268 103M 379 402 divert water 90S 315 a 186NY 505 liability 127 834 surface water 129 824 do 825 f 211 NY 258 f 211 NY 259 211 NY 261 no liability 180 677 436master liable s 90 S 725 a 184 NY 379 public policy d 143 644 445 distinction s 90 S 565 f 89 M 594 450Court's power 3 90 S 762 56M 431 burden proof 126 173 civil action 175 461 461 forgery s 90 S 706 r 182 NY 257 474 bdn. proof s 90 S 796 156 405 480 redemption 8 90 S 493 ml84 NY 411 489 services 3 90 S 769 109 400 at. limitationa 112 376 scrutinized 62 M 187 494 stipulation 8 90 S 790 e 181 NY 410 499 allegations s 90 S 913 f 91 K 576 577 507 waiver s 90 S 264 f 118 601 5 1 I contract s 90 S 303 a 184 NY 541 5 1 6 guaranty 8 90 S 247 a 184 NY 520 8 100 510 52 1 exemption B 91 S 87 r 182 NY 99 546 transfer tax 3 90 S 244 r 184 NY 299 f 107 198 do 107 198 550 r. r. intesec s 90 S 236 a 183 NY 07 amendment s 100 509 554 assessment 8 90 S 263 m 185 NY 300 waiver 63M 235 easement 64M 272 no estoppel 141 11 implied waiver 74M 182 563 Iciniudgt, d 90 S 977 102 428 demurrer 106 340 relief 17AC 91n 93n 17 AC 94 covenant 128 390 sp. allowance 133 395 568 pleading 91 S 179 56M 401 577 neg. h'way 3 90 S 760 s 15 AC 298 584 corpn. tax 3 90 S 755 a 181 NY 328 exemption d 134 85 588 direct verd. 79 M 271 594 ins. waiver s 90 S 485 r 183 NY 368 fl05 191 600 rule equity s 90 S 533 160 47 606 stipulation B 90 S 631 a 184 NY 525 6 1 9 dismissal Case 1 8 90 S 1097 a 184 NY 554 preference case 3 3 90S 1112 a 181 NY 531 reetoratn caae 14 a 90 S 1103 a 181 NY 565 _ lee case 15 a 90 S 1089 114 422 taxation case 26 8 90 S 1109 a 180 NY 537 exemption 119 282 624 certiorari case 24 8 90 3 1110 a 181 NY 559 certiorari case 25 3 90 S 1109 certiorari case 32 contempt a 90S 1111 a 180 NY 536 certificates case 38 s90S 1100 114 216 a 181 NY 547 627 charter case 16 s 90 S 1087 r 183 NY 496 conversion case 4 3 90 S 1116 a 188NY 653 628 interloc. judgment caae 8 s 90 S 1089 * 181 NY 606 631 waiver a 90S r 184 NY 620 removal caae 2 s90 3 e 111 622 dismissal case 6 a 90 S 1105 a 182 NY 647 dismissal case 8 a 90 S 1105 * 182 NY 618 limitation r 186 NY convictn case 10 s 90 S 1109 a 181 NY 586 623cancel record case 1 3 90 S 1088 a 183 NY 538 accounts case 2 8 90 S 1090 * 182 NY 552 larceny case 6 sgOS 1109 a 180 NY 556 267 315 633 reargument case 4 s 91 S 599 98 633 appeal case 8 3 90 3 1092 a 183 NY 514 m a er neglig. case 9 8 90 3 " 1116 r 183 NY 18 amendment case 16 s 91 3 699 98 633 634 appeal case 8 s90S a 182 NY case 9 3 90S 3 90 S a 186 NY exceptions case 16 8 90 8 a 183 NY' strike out case 21 8 90 3 a 181 NY credibility case 22 s90S s 181 NY r 184 NY. warranty ms 3 116 1112 646 1106 1107 668 1101 607 1119 522 1112 506 666 635 appeal case 1 s90 3 1105 f 56 M 332 case 6 s90S 1115 a 184 NY 626 appeal case 14 s90 3 1107 8 182 NY 612 a 184 NY 532 liq. law case 16 s 90 S 1108 a 181 NY 561 reduce verdict case 16 s 90 S 1101 s 109 912 ABBUEVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished! t, followed; r, reversed; m, modified: *. dismissed; n, irate; C •riticiaed; U limited; e, explained; o overrtiled; s. same case; do, dissenting opinion; p. parallel caae: a. questioned. N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division Vol. 99 VOL. 99 5 not privileged s 90S 1007 74M 569 disclosure 164 prohibition 221Ny 630 453 1000 357 10 damages s90 S 8 192NY 18 mtge. lease s 90 S 947 s 15 AC 361 28 foreclose s90S 711 s 15 AC 292 91S 131 f 174 175 SIM allegationa 114 complaint 136 negligence 14a 162 3 I injunction B90S * 182 NY 34 francMse s90S a 184 NY 4 1 divorce a 90S r 182 NY 801 553 746 408 121 valuable consideration s 91S 353 102M 712 126 revers error s 90 S 89 128 237 13 1 promise valid 3 90 S 967 d6M 529 orig promise 130 800 do 802 consideration 67 M 264 47 negligence B 90 S 530 sill 19 master neg. 134 308 guarding belts 71 M for jury 146 40 386 76 title s91S 364 19AC 249n proof necessary 86 M 318 gift 103JI 98 81 incompetent s 91 S 378 163 87 88 mandamus B 91 S 432 187 NY 57M 58 substitute 137 264 94 chge grade sglS 412 a 181 NY 132 off set 140 730 106 amendment 169 486 !91 S do 116 parties 52M power court 116 nee. parties 118 piactice 122 3rd party court no power 39CP 76 do 80 each liable 38CP 86 462 483 812 38S way comrs. 172 636 I08h s91S a 184 NY el06 authority 114 joint liable e 136 not apply do 136 powers comra. do 136 187 f 172 1 19 construction 1040 357 657 115 461 36o BUf 208 4DS 171 195 construction s 90 S 1029 a 184 NY interest 153 218 NY 201 money s90S 141 waiver lOOM 544 769 370 had 985 831 209 jury question s 90 S 1052 1S6NY 35;. 2 1 4 jurisdiction s 90 S 1010 do 155 335 rommonl. vie. 62M 415 temp, recov. f 64M 112 receiver 155 333 2 1 Snot recover s 90 S 1005 f 85 M 446 cond. precedent 94 M 200 performance 185 I 35 trespass 3 90 S 948 a 184 NY 525 pers. injury 16AC 227n231n „„, _,. ,. 17AC 24Rn 2';in|231 affidavit 114 248 rp-examination 57M 310 not assess 130 890 288 firm nauie -I 9u S 964 1 7 AC 43n46n 290 "lay off" s 90S 907 135 220 297 verified oetit'ofi e 90 S 960 56M irregularity 76 M 428 143 offers ev. s 90 S 1055 115 541 incomp. ev. 115 541 inadmissible 78 M 403 152 negligence s 90 S 1019 r 184 NY 245 fact question 16AC 232n j't. tort feasor 17AC 251n I 59 assignment 3 90 S 974 a 184 NY 518 1 63 baggage loss 8 90 S 1042 a 184 NY 597 3 15 AC 353 I 69 letters admr 3 90 8 107 168 resident f 161 161 962 186 444 835 835 I 75 negligence s90S a 185 NY 105 s 111 162 degree care 30 M 86 M death neg. 133 for jury 73 M s 162 1078 629 364 837 790 176 334 528 852 1 86 employment „,„s90S 1011 272 f 184 NY 542 352 19 1 sp. perfmce s 90 S 933 48 M 146 pleading 171 179 contract 84 M 35 236 affirm order s 90 S 1023 do 108 359 amendment 115 502 19AC 293n 302 pleading 145 140 166 744 not amend 174 217 245no knowldg s 90S 918 106M 361 248 sp. prfnince s 90 S 990 m 185 NY 568 253 mandamus s90S 127 no appeal 144 pleadings 1.56 appeal 184 961 78 388 153 119 ineas. 257 receiver rt. s 90S 980 05M 491 knowldg. notice 151 537 subordinate 151 538 280 bill partic. 90 S 929 126 26 fl4S 643 f 181 967 262duty inspect s 90 S 1045 a 182 NY 567 100 398 res ipsa I. 149 822 53M 125 711 ISAC 283n,2S4n damages 118 AC 292n presume neglig. 142 for jury 154 267 laches 3 90S 54M 560 1002 77 273 place trial 90 S 939 112 488 355 demurrer s 90 S 1062 a 181 NY 571 construction 124 224-5 d 92 M 60 jurisdiction 124 22 penalties 63M 445 implied repeal 92 M 62 n-tA X |36I injunction 274 assessment r qt q .>9n 3 90S 904'i%6NY is a 181 N X , 549 infringement 124 247 364 assessment s 91 S 219 a 181 NY" 25i unenfc-ceable J 206 NY 31 constitutionality 206 NY 504 367 libel s 91 S d 153 74 M 193 247 620 433 trusts 3 91 S a 183 NY 98 M 370 incomp. ev. 605 3 91 S 207 50 M 289 298 transfer tax 3 90 S 923 a 180 NY 300 303 notice trial 3 90 S 920 f 99 623 308 arrears diimony 5 HOS 982, 1113 74M 536 ill contempt 74M 538 d 150 843 disap. 150 844 312 presentment s WIS 142 18AC 390n, 393n IS AC 394n 3 I 6nialic. pros s 91 S 107 49 M 317 prob. cause 116 defense error 142 638 323 authority s 88 S 904 139 584 produce books e 79 M 528 contempt 79 M 530 327 award int. 91S i31 120 293 negligence 137 408 slat, damage 137 409 recovery 137 416 unliquidated a M 126 f 97 M 682 334 appeal 3 91 S 226 a 181 NY 93 review r. r. com- missioners 15 AC 459d practice f 1 18 522 372 appeal 3 91 S 486 114 706 713 no appeal 126 76 168 836 review 166 221 374 practice s 91 S 205 114 113 114 bill particular 134 568 56M 435 19A0 41n 19AC 42n 46n compliance 179 441 63M. 255 377 stockholder 91 S rl86 NY 391 surety 9 91S a 181. NY 110 f 175 73 M f 73 M Sl5 AC compliance 80 M 239 286 210 556 677 92 206 207 39 77 res ipsa loq. 499 neg. election 18AC 283n, 289n 8 91 S 60 107 490 427 tr'd transferlSS CP 376 s91 S 103 f 107 law question 113 , preference 120 jurisdiction 54M law action 69 M equity 201 NY jury trial 185 795 292 remedy 408 1 116 698 liab act 17AC 277n 279u complaint 129 688 168 92 error dismissal 152 203 182 213 509 431 equity accts: s91S 149 504 complaint s 91 S - 129 127 152 defense 153 644 507 situs busi- 2a f 91 S 195 358 168 443 mech.. lien 3 91S a 184 NY 121 validity lien 113 67 M eq action US foreclosure 119 nee. party ys. . limitation 119 121 by court 79 M 264 530 467 629 637 387 393 467 51 450 damages 3 91 S 295 103 practice 117 128 divorce pldg. 124 784 judgment ■iS CP 84 counterclaim 70 M .SfiS d 169 791 455 taxation 3 91S a 181 NY elOl 48 flOl 906 do business do 147 887 30 AC 211n 211 NY 427 220 NY 318 514 bad faith 39 IS 112 pleading 121 ■ lenjurrer 134 uiscretion 69 M strike out 141 friv 149 114 916 598 0C2 demurrer 27:i 5 1 6 oysters title s91S 51 a 184 NY 168 525 repeal ex- emption 3 91S 136 a 183NY 151 repeal 115 31 157 405 not presumed 157 40G 533 service mail s 91 S 178 s 15 AC 387 50 M 277 ifl 535 life insur i^l B 90 S 856 ""* f 112 922 399 trustfund . 3 91S 265 a 184 NY 523 4 1 dismissal 3 91 S 258 al80 NY 642 106 231 465 construction sHlS 299 IIO 219 73 M 399 assignment ■ do 172 91 f 221NY 7 470 bill partie 3 91 S 280 109 619 124 547 163 117 4|7 per. injury 472 sale damage s 91 S 216 s 86 S 66C 51 M 613 3 91S 1105 services a 181 NY 211 a 138NY 630 liability 481 pub. policy! do 138 120 s 90 S 854 complaint r 183 NY 207 89 M 569 not liable 487 error rr. tria! 183 543 3 90 S 87!^ 183 735 105 94 56M 34:-. 422p"e um. nea 3 91 S 202 496no presumtn 127 302 3 91 S 51 38LHA 803i.'145 .';65 541 jurisdiction 3 91S 103 106 139 109 3 f 216 NY 397 118 367 demurrer 142 418 3 1 1 eq. mortgage s91S 624 8 15 AC 436 3 1 7 flse imprt s 91 S 671 195 NY 395 325 contempt 3 91 S 528 103 609 r 182 NY conspiracy 135 relief equity 99M '370 366 ev. insanity 8 91 S 769 a 186 NY 370 106 267 incompet. ev. 19AC 288n Competency 178 449 373 transfer tax 868 524 209 i!36 s91S a 182 NY 1.14 situs bond 50 M prop, in state 114 213 389interloc jud. 3 91 S 477 47 M 97 393 negligence 3 91 S 821 104 15 res ipsa loquitur 149 822 53M 126 18AC 292n ordinary care 194 NY 212 presumption 141 26S 142 560 error court 70 M for jury 154 conditions 179 433 employment 3 91 S 837 112 251 436 compliance s 91 S 811 80 M 77 440 notice lien s 91 S 69 107 120 notice 128 S3M good title 120 compliance 221 defect notice 128 281 449 584 750 47 443 receii 3 OlS a 183 NY discovery f65M 839 505 31 449 bankruptcy 3 91 S 488 a 182 NY 264 550 29( 840 403 request 8 91 S 484 114 804 court's power do 132 451 direct verdict 67 M 403 407 nuisance 3 91 S 439 a 184 NY 548 476 per injury jurisdiction s 91 S 491 170 508 17 AC 248D 453 sp. prfmance s91S fififi 3 lis 242 155 630 4 63 parties con sOlS fl(il a 183 NY SOS 112 5F parol evidence 137 a77 48 M 599 8p. performance 112 69 rescission fraud d 114 676 contract' 125 177 134 4S9 f 166 620 agency d 125 It-'l judgment case 3 137 896 estoppel 137 b'M parties 59 M 505 145 61V 160 83 V N. Y. Supreme Coart Reports— Appellate Division Vols. 100, 101 479 withdrawal B 91 S 706 16AC 373n circu m st'l. 70 M 483 extradic ton 8 91S 7 s 183 NY 56 * 185 NY 59 indictment 142 601 488 follow fund 8 91 S 720 * 182 NY 512 492 diacovfiry s 91 S 129 s 15 AC 103 affidavit 52M 643 495 covenant will comp. ev. case 4 s91S 1103 r 184 NY 54 157|neg. damages case 6 i91S 104 117 133 136 59 M repairs 129 f 171 f 85 M damages 145 171 60 M 687 423 91 S 1117 a 183 NY 523 appeal case IG s91S 1116 a 184 NY 538 judgment case 17 3 91 S 1093 a 185 NY 615 contrib. neg. case 20 3 91 S 1097 a 183 NY 52] neglnce case 21 3 91 S 1044 r 183NY 191 5 1 3 judgment case 6 s91 S 3 184 NY VOL. 101 negligence a 91 S 437 105 271 contractual i 112 356 pers. iiijury 16AC 457n 539 58M 208 209 appeal 1096 695 78 269 475 case 9 391 S a 184NY negligence case 25 5761391 S 416,r 185 NY uegliKence 3 119 534 31 570 482 499 performnce s 92 8 56 a 184 NY 58 125 69 M 105M legisi. power 119 excuse 51 M contract do 156 174 1104 550 1120 276 3 repairs s 91 S 547 174 . 689 69 M 482 restoration 159 842 177 408 6 tenant duty 5 91 S 808 141 741 9 execution 3 91 S f 101 133 earnings 72 M 532 5 1 5 muinc. cont case 7 3 91 S r 182 NY appeal 1096 IS 600 602'oase 11 5931S91 S llflla 182 NY -QijiSIB crime '*'''|case 1 970,3 91 S '"'' al82 NY 167 680 20 21 appeal 1115 543 1107 416 335 111 1092 case 2 s91 S a 184 NY larceny case 3 S91S a 180 NY transfer tax case 9 891 S a 182 NY 5 I coserv't neg appeal case 10 case 46 s91S 1102 s 91 S e 107 33 a 182NY neglignce case 13lcase 50 b91S IO86I39IS a 183 NY 515 a 184NY 509 will trust case 12 s91S r 183 NV case 5 s91S bin paticulars S6M 383 case 14 dismissal s 91 S a 184 NY 1111 585 51 |inj. trespasser case 5 s91S 1119 r 184 NY 290 tax collection case 13 sQlS 1090 „„ report case 951533 preference s91S 1027'WM 466 a 183 NY 520 conviction case 20 1105 598 1108 561 1091 92 1111 535 1110 533 5 1 7 deed case 1 sU9 S al87Ny waiver 3 123 case 4 dismissal 3 91 S a 184 NY 737 607 1 2 warranty s 91 S 448 106 492 18 speculation s 913 763 63M 596 22 damages s 91 S 870 85 M 502 25 testator int. s 91 S 797 19A0 116n 32 commissns. s 91 S 431 201 NY 215 43 court's pwr. s 91S 872 19AC 9b bill particulars f 159 582 48 fr'd transfer 3 91 S 917 103 663 atty and client 47 M 165 f 85 M 1 53 bailee neg. 3 91 S 566 17AC 226n 229n cause action .71 M 102 93 injunction s 91 S 780 66 M 471 97 construe will 8 91 S 549 59 M 651 t 96 M 663 mandatory 152 325 1 1 inspect hotel s 91 S 929 47 M 424 529 injunction 113 425 610 trespasser 116 806 enter force 16AC 473n 478 jurisdiction do 125 789 courts duty 61 M 423 108 trust 3 91 S 51 M 19A0 908 380 250 1 12 measure damages s 91 S 544 f 164 570 I 1 6 tax sale s 91 S 869 e 102 407 109 US 51 451 1093 555 a 181 NY 510 110 495 do 110 491 5 12 men. ;apac. case 1 s91S 1101 m 185 NY 70 negligence case 2 8 91S 1086 a 18.S NY .W> 55 appeal * 181 NY 16 AC 1103 15n 65 jury question 3 91 S 508 110 669 69 amendment 3 91 S 464 o7M 374, 376 82 no authority s 91 S 552 84 M 26 83 presumption 3 91 S 794 113 907 88 liability s 91 S 849l f 83 M 451 ixtend life I do 180 301 contract 180 293 644 I 1 9 reviewable s 91 S 937 70 M 35 1 28 costs s 91 S 876 e 109 133 t 134 s 15 AC 485 order f 113 911 demur, costs )8AC 402n, 411n 134 liability act s 91 S 883 . 7 AC 284n superintend 123 liability 154 employee 102M (36 order s 91S f 134 659 816 576 940 I 40 frd* convey, s 91 S 852 111 368 851 burden proof 134 022 banks proof 138 496 intent notice 61 M 603 1 47 amendment s91S 611 106 484 court's power d 147 591 150 mandamus s 91 S 533 * 182 NY 522 \ 55 mandamus s 91 S -154 a 181 NY 558 legal right 93 M 632 1 59 tax owner b91S 503 182 NY 493 trade fixtures 20 AC 107n 167 compen^atn. s 91 S 428 69 U 366 I69biilpartic 921 687 361 s91S 109 d 115 affidavit 54M 1 72 practice s 91 S 513 122 451 1 83 mandamus s91S * 180 NY s 181 NY a 181 NY f 101 553 563 530 547 606 299 new trial s91S B 103 admit bail 141 may rebut 94 M 962 597 654 187 mark.titte 191 S 497 16 title 142 166 vested 363 907 I 89 exrs acctg 3 91 S 933 a 182 NY 519 i 93 conclusive s 91 S 912 t 164 724 207 ins assignt s 91 S 690 r 183 NY 291 216 dismissal s 91 S 715 161 747 752 220 appeal 3 86 S 577 3 92S 1120 a 182 NY 642 223 certiorari s 91 S 1006 r 181 NY 300 196NY 62 8 101 612 248 affidavit 3 91 S 746 62 M 518 248 surplus cap. s 91 S 711 155 847 limit 177 17 25 t certificate 91 S 977 a 184 NY 663 s 15 AC 45? 254 misjoinder s 91 S 986 150 642 265 intent 3 91 S 1004 do 106 307 283 ten days 391S 129 not limited d 131 force d ICP NS 668 835 279 296 not conclu. s91S .649 do 126 919 in;(Unction 79 M 294 violate statute 169 847 153 306 dismissal 3 91 S 935 do 124 117 f 162 515 other employmt. 164 240 rule contract 192 NY 442 rule damage 128 .712 causes distinct 149 266 burd. defendant 80 M 161 forjury 156 384 tendernecessary 90 M 303 3 1 3 jurisdiction s 91 S 960 17AC 9Sn arrest error 126 46 imprisonment 127 280 immaterial 127 281 317 review 3 91 S 945 16AC 447n 449n terms appeal 124 .523 power rerview 157 142 322 annual tax 91 S 950 .89NY 398 325 francb. tax 3 91 S 955 a 181 NY 512 383mtge balance s92S a 184 NY 95 II request 114 327 estoppel s 91 S 116 8 145 powers 217 NY 948 48 844 330 jury ques'n s 91S 998 133 476 338 award 3 91 S 765 67 M 543 544 342 taxn costs 8 92 S 250 a 181 NY 556 ' M 66 persnl. judgrat. 78 M 345 license 92 S a 184 NY injunction 65 187 546 i3imc 1« 885 352 pers. injury 3 92 S 179 a 186 NY 694 366 abduction 3 91S 1027 a 181 NY 570 369 appeal ev 3 91S 1069 a 184 NY 589 affidavit 115 386 iei.|arations 123 661 3 91S 1062 a 186 NY 550 deficiency ■114 15V 105M 683 defense do 114 159 105M 682 comity p 192 NY 378 ex loci 127 19V 38 M 486 construction 133 674 direct verdict 67 M 403 141 677 170 501 388 deposits 3 92 S - 13 s 184 NY 606 105 393 395ma8ter duty 3 91 S 1029 1 13 764 refuse chg, do 132 383 no delegation 136 339 400 dismissal 20s 582 568 804 direct verdict 170 182 07 M f 88 M f 102M 501 92 403 310 174 423 damages s 92 S 22 a 183 NY 540 111 760 74M 168 subject review 168 873 432 atty client s 91 S 1059 a 184 NY 548 authorized 24XY 425 436 notice s 91 S 10.54 118 35 good t.tle 125 765 pers. property 125 76S estoppel 142 RS 1U31I 78 cond. sales dl,38 504 442 guaranty s92S 93 a 184 NY .538 28AC 31 6n in-tn 448 negligence 1 92S 2H2 i 107 181 821 113 37 S2 132 675 superintendent 118 537 120 601 121 40 134 637 13G 587 61 M 607 ury question 66M 684 iabi ity act 17AC 284n ABBllEVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; c, criticised ; 1, limited ; e, explained ; o, overruled : f, fallowed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note ■ s, same :ase ; do, dissentinii; opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, queitioaed' vols. 101, 102 N, Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division 453 no rights s91S 157 1032 359 1065 555 883 652 771 645 456 trust s91S a 182 NY 118 156 do 174 validity 76 M beneficiaries 76 M 646 trust valid 76 M 646 4B8 limitations s 92S 129 149 fi04 account stated 179 698 473 atty client case 3 sgiS 102 110 lien atty. 117 18AC 38 CP correct rule 117 nee, party 119 3SCP client nee. party 18 AC waiver 82 M 402 539 decree s 92 S 68 M 18 511 1034 609 712 113 96n 164 116 391 244 476 dividend B 91 S 1046 a 185 NY 571 debt due 157 597 484 new trial case 6 s 92 S 62 f 102 s 16 AC 550 chargeable s 92 S 195 8 116 315 do 115 320 reargument 132 748 expense exv. 136 519 inferences 115 320 566 easement s92S a 184 NY sia AC non user M2 trespasser do 129 injunction 148 , enjoined 148 533 592 51 237 842 313 324 588 obligation s 92 S 154 waiver 154 statutory f 92 M court's power f 92M: 583 584 cannot change f 92 M 582 184 251 251 power 581 593 will gift s 92 S 177 a 184 NY 605 600 taxation s92S 5 r 182 NY 314 106 529 111 case 4 s92S neg. walk r 186 NY judgment case 3 3 92 8 a 186 NY 829 1117 518 1118 444 6 1 2 transfer tax case 6 sg2S 1128 a 181 NY 553 report referee case 14 s92S 1142 a 184 NY 562 lease rents case 18 s 92S rl87NY case 22 s 92 S s 114 27 492 voidable s92S 58M 494 not binding s 92S 132 134 132 reasonable 86 M 108 additionl salary 217 NT 229 500 interpleadr s 92 S 51 155 198 165 162 507 rescission s 92 S 136 a 184 NY 557 f 102 611 124 760 fraud sale 20 AC 84n 5 1 8 receivers s 91 S 1079 s 108 365 111 702 124 774 527 assessment 8 92 8 8 a 182 NY 281 transfer reality 60 M 221 142 681 606 mandamus case 10 * 180 NY s918 s 181 NY a 181 NY 563 llOS 530 548 607 neglig death case 7 s 91 S a 185 NY judgment case 17 s91 8 r 183 NY 1097 570 1095 347 60S appeal case 20 s91 8 a 184 NY 1107 534 534 negligence s 91 8 1052 s 115 283 reasonable care 158 782 609 stkhldr suit case 4 s92S r 184 NY appeal case 9 s92 8 a 184 NY new trial case 10 s92 8 a 184 NY judgment case 11 8 91 8 a 184 NY case 17 s 92 8 a 186 NY 1130 152 1145 540 1146 539 1093 531 1135 657 6 I I neg q, case 7 s92S 119 r 184 NY ase li 5 92S jury 1125 373 698 1127 1147 372 1127 908 VOL. 102 80S 579 228 f mech lien s92S a 184 NY pleading <)o 190NY doing business 67M 20 AC 216n recovery 146 578 1 5 incidental s 923 1003 74M 516 18 good faith s 92 S ■ 77 51 M 672 penalty lOAC 263-4n 29 construction s 92 8 176 househld furntur 118 516 allot widow 52M 42' construe will 126 441 money allow. 64M 662 32 impul. notice s 928 79 135 515 39 contract s 92 8 86 a 184 NY 325 f 110 888 44 lis. pendens 92 8 107 106 553 107 419 f 63 M 7 encroachmeute 80 damages 92 S r 184 NY 556 1 436 274 877 e509 514 517 lib 907 50 M title bad 121 122 vendee lien 117 608 do 117 119 192N Y order Dase 9 124 Vendee no I'en 89 CP -316 47 negligence 3 92 8 95 * 185 NY 632 49 pre requisite 3 92 S 101 116 326 120 597 17AC 282n 283n 53 attv's. lien s 92S 97 18AC lOOn 56 legacy 8 89 S 606 3 92 S 1 123 a 183 NY 62 construction 94 foreclosure 8 92 8 614 f 201 619 99 warrant s 928 478 136 301 no appeal d 151 753 review pub. use 180 210 1 03 class legisla- lion s 92 8 497 110 261 monopoly 112 606 I 1 2 weight of ev s 928 474 17 AC 290n I 1 8pref erred stk f d settlement 116 889 1 remedy S3M separate 39CP relief 38 CP contg. suit do 131 863 enforcement 157 228 may waive d 103M 281 no equities 103M 284 171 165 52 action 21 78 s92S r 184 NY 387 267 lOlM 60 tender 3 92 8 r 186 NY 71 judgment case 16 8 92 8 f 116 do 115 8 hours 198NY 189 372 109 1 2 I negligence 8 92 8 253 108 131 Stat, dt'tv ILRANS 24n recin lignts ILRANS 2i6n com. law rule ILRANS 2?6n jury question ILRANS 229n fright damage 17 AC 135n 360n 361 1 25 weight of ov. s 92 S 365 142 69 17AC 290n assume risk d 72 M 85 75 ,V1 606 set aside 72 M 88 130 burden proof 8 92 8 270 122 164 138 liability 892 8 843 141 797 damages . 84 M 144 I47frd. transfer a 92 8 326 1 12 902 151 exculp'te p "9; 176 for jury s 92 S 304 154 813 do 218NY 196 |88 pera. injury s92 a 186 NY 637 514 s92S el40 legisl. 143 21 700 power 630 1 63 judgment case 5 a 92 8 493 t 128 888 presumption 180 708 168 unlike scaffold 92 S 149 342 821 1 70 compromise s 92 8 361 do 104 692 lib. construction 106 605 atty's lien 113 66 t 67 18AC 91n, 93n 37 CP 119 195 right action s 92 S 5&-) 207 no authority s 92 S 665 77 M 364 209 ousting offic. 3 92 8 661 a 182 NY 301 229 declaration s 928 938 134 589 155 794 f 171 224 parol evidence 142 325 232 recovery a 92 S 709 a 186 NY 555 25 1 estoppel 3 92 8 454 a 182 NY 522 185 NY 425 release notice 109 663 recovery f 86 M 617 259 negligence 8 92 8 451 49 M 650 request exceptn. 148 71 G question fact 153 821 262 measure dam 3 92 8 622 a 182 NY 224 269 force entry s 92 S 460 d 146 476 sum. proceedng, lOOM 670 293 indictable s 92 8 434 92 M 72 294 reason, care s 92 S .380 158 782 302 evidence s 92 8 425 170 394 67 M 396 306court's pwr. s 92 8 436 79 M 30 pleading 157 336 counterclaim 178 457 313 master neg. s 92 S 382 20 AC 158n 20 AC lOln i 1 7 reform deed s 92 S 431 a 185 NY 427 324 negligence 8 92S f 110 submission 155 for jury f 158 327 verdict s92S a 184 NY instruction 142 inference 120 170 104M charge 123 477 920 410 487 4C6 546 509 115 315 243 187 330 neg. safe tool s 92 8 506 112 204 superintdt. 121 40 master liable 17AC 286» 336 authority 272 vacate judg- ment 3 92 8 453 50 M 631 conclusion 128 825 275 negligence s 92 8 386 s 16 AC 68 276 damages d 92 8 420 60 M 374 284 solvent man 944 630 92 S _106 foreclosure a 187NY 3 16 AC validity 8 92 8 116 170 allegations 126 illegal acts 139 f 169 170 pleading f 163 unauthorized 170 471 484 521 471 346 251 118 472 241 344 commission 439 665 745 419 760 64S 596 663 73 _92 8 a 186 NY 121 130 f 162 50 M 76 M revers error t 120 455 liability 67 M 392 plaintiff show 157 Sfi.-5 duty broker • 159 683 349 com-mssioM s 92 8 417 f 109 23; 354 pers. injury s 92 8 855. ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; c, cntieieed; 1, limited; e, explained; o, OTerruled; b, same case; do, dissenting opinion; d. parallel case; q, questioned N. Y. Supreme Coiirt Reports— Appellate Division Vols, 102, 103 S80 347 428 244 338 496 338 a 185 NY joint feasor 130 indemnitor 195NY new trial 132 concltlded 66M indemnity 142 costs 66M on contract 165 403 collusion 183 553 360 foreclosure s 92 S 631 a 185 NY 590 f 162 379 363 filing mints n 8 92 S 674 8 102 622 628 365 premature s 92 S 848 164 795 367 sup. pro. s 92 S 656 a 181 NY 558 master duty 112 204 assignee 93 M 314 371 op'ghighw'y s 92 S 841 a 186 NY 547 377 will trust s 92 S 833 8 116 765 383 variance B 92 S 604 114 781 56M 581 evidence clear 152 208 389 submission a 92 S 613 a 186 NY 573 398 apply test s 92 S 777 143 496 new trial do 218 NY 196 405 use evidence 8 92 S 619 54M 577 4 1 commissions s 92 S 418 16AC 417n 4 1 2 demurrer 8 92 S 449 f 102 626 defect 174 504 419 conversion s 92 S 645 r 187NY 121 jus tertii 76 M 309 burden proof f 160 63» 424 partnership s 92 S 459 d 125 129dol30 rescission d 139 130 131 426 leave court s 92 S 512 f 170 73 429 ord. publ'n s 92 S 385 r 182 NY 228 sill 433 master neg. s 92 S 883 62M 166 neg damages a 186NY 567 liability 63M 339 juridical cause 71 M 34 proximate cause TIM 36 cbgc. on Ind s 92 S 546 a 183 NY 550 454 final judgmt s 92 S S22 16AC 97n larceny 124 12 458 adoption s 92S 463 197NY 197 "lawful issue" 154 229 529 prom, note s 92 S 891 a 184 NY 599 417|al84NY services s92S a 184 NY 464 foreclosure 3 92 S 482 a 185 NY 577 467 by-laws s 92 S 846 130 132 unreasonable 137 840 841 473 contract s 92 S 860 a 189NY 526 20 AC 204n 536 gift inter vivos a 92 S 873 f 105 503 imcompt ev. 68M 524 544 bill partic. s 92S 879 t 166 J.46 65M 520 548 extra work a 92 S 897 a 185 NY 210 549 bids 113 damages 148 154 200 NY contract 143 recovery 145 104M: 301 660 116 155 735 492 246 557' case 2 143 163 6 1 4 appeal case 4 92 S * 181 NY decision s92S a 184 NY contract s92S a 185 NY appeal s92S * 186 NY do 105 case 12 s 92 S 1126 a 181 NY 555 lobbery case 13 s 92 S 1138 a 182 NY 530 report case 18 VOL. 103 95 stockholder 551 1121 613 1131 530 477 pers. injury s 92 S 849 a 186 NY 555 master neg do 118 561 scaffold 196 NY 422 jury question 184 241 res ipsa loqu*r 143 r>9 480 innuendo s 92 S 852 f 111 440 47 M 176 485 payments 560 contract s 92 S 950 a 185 NY 676 566 overt act s 92 S 606 a 182 NY 529 105 388 92 M 75 indictment 112 523 ati;empt crime 133 40 judgment f 131 935 abortion 152 374 573 employment s 92 S 917 s 183 NY 272 * 183 NY 567 recovery 67M lOJ conting. fee 67M 105 liability 1123:s92S 1134 6451a 184 NY 562 case 6. deficiency 1119'a 186 NY 552 case 11 case 7 s 92 S 1121 contract 669 r 186 NY appeal 1125 case 21 527 s 92 S 6.^4[* 186 NY new trial case ; s92S 11191620 report a 183 NY 510 1 case 1 verdict case 15|s 92 S 3 92 S 1145 * 184 NY 566 a 184 NY 547ldecision case 8 case 16 ]5 92S 1148 s 92 S 1126 a 184 NY 613 *186NY 62S life estate case 9 monyhadcasel7 s 92 S 1114 s92S 1149 r 184 NY 62 a 185 NY 567 taxes exempt test trust case 18 case 10 3 92S 113lis92S 1141 7 atty. & client s 92 S 862 110 801 12 appeal s 92 S s 182 NY reformation a 185 NY r 183 NY 440 s93S * 182 NY 108 guaranty a 186 NY 498prob. s 92 S do 160 19 515 149 561 profits 832 170 500 subrogation 92 S 619 a 185 NY 557 226NY 3 505 objn. appeal 3 92 S 914 17 AC 279n surplusage do 165 941 140 214 NY client rights 70 M client's f 161 6 1 5 accounting case 1 s92S 1131 9 182 NY 614 a 185 NY 651 water rights case 6 92 S 1144 a 182 NY 361 reinstatement case 8 9 92S 1141 183 NY 672 usury case 31 s 94 S 404 sl05 542 usury case 32 s 94 S 404 s 105 642 decision case 33 3 94 S 1167 a 184 N"i 593 case 34 appeal s 94 S 116" a 184 NY 693 44 error 613 do 161 discharge 172 f 174 88 M 585 jury trial s92S tl03 practice 78 M 589 release s92S till 279 259 616 new trial case 14 92 S 1144 a 182 NY 608 arbitration case 16 8 92S 1128 _„„ a 184 NY 114 I 9^ S transfer tax ^ J* j- ease 16 I «' u°d"'8 '=»f , " s92S 1137,3 92 S 1U5 a 183 NY 238!'* 182 523 617 307 853 532 625 593 904 912 5 1 sureties 3 92S a 182 NY decision 118 860 524 661 5 r7 erro;- charge 3 92 S 826 47 M 657 do 658 52M 579 524 insurance 9 92 S 685 596 764 649 514 578 3 92S 111 allegations 206 NY 1 00 appeal s92S f 106 demurrer 79 M 21 negligence 8 92 S 8: 106 586 113 635 25 conversion 8 92 S 666 s 104 620 110 643 follow fund 53M ■ ■ 378 indorsement al87NY 115 hold for value SI M 201 91M 225 defense 174 296 34 objections a 181 NY 403 decision case 12 s92S 1151 182 NY 532 62 I file minutes case 1 _92S s92S a 190NY 3 102 judgment case 6 s 92 S 1123 a 184 NY 649 neghgence case 8 1116 1144 538 628 s 92 S 159 36 practice s92 S 117 damages 38 CP 830 763 853 128 92S 188 NY 1145 160 622 sp. perfor case 1 3 92 S r 187NY s 16 AC s 19AC 87S 101 132 373 624 accounting case 3 3 92 S 1124 m 182 NY 270 contract case 4 :3 92S a 186 NY verdict 1121 571 caes 6 1133 550 84 39 notice assignt 92 S 629 18 NY 316 45 uegligence 3 92S a 183 NY do 109 i 125 due care 112 death neg. do 130 jury question 139 378 contrib. neglig'e d 142 9l6 for ju.-y 157 47 695 508 470 146 534 697 491 337 83 103 bill partic. s 92 S 980 68 M 58 107 depositors 3 93 S 73 do 124 102 judgt. right 124 101 title 19AC 249n 1 1 3 no estoppel s 93 S 50 82 M 91 I 1 8 cond. sale 3 93 S 69 e 111 787 offset 113 , 82 paroi '"evidence r 186 NY 334 warranty 18AC 164n, 156n remedy breach 18AC 158n meas. damages 37 CP 135 rescission 72 M 640 I 23 St. rr. certif 3 93 S 68 a 184 NY do 131 15 AC certiorari 128 816, 817 131 506 576 514 462n 510 6 I jury trial 3 92 S 043 133 914 17 AC 138n undue influence 617 mandamus 625 pers. injury paap 1 case 4 s^ls 1132>92S 1123 187 N Y 12Sia 185 NY 691 601 reward s 92 S 114 19AC 130n 133 133n 135n 66M 90, 91 609 decision case 7 3 92S 2 a 184 NY 651 6 1 I judgment case 1 3 92S 1132 case 13 s92S r 181 NY damages s92S a 185 NY jurisdiction case 15 s92S r 184 NY 1145 339 case 14 1134 577 1147 36 demurrer case 17 s92S 626 award case 18 3 93S a 182 NY 1132 1122 520 6 18 constitu- tional s 02 S 331 82 M 52 6 1 9 compensat'n case 10 3 92 S 1132 a 186 N Y 551 627 partition case 4 3 92S lllU a 184 NY 590 services case 27 s92S 1134 r 186 NY 520 1 116 for jury 137 141 874 105 194 64 gift deposit 92S 6 52 19A0 242n transferee 47 253 74 alimony fees 3 92 S 634 1 104 620 183 NY 261c 262 allegations 35CP 170 counsel fees 16AC 115n 79 corroboration s 92 S 508 liiS 147 158 148 86 chge. record s 92 S 590 114 889 mandamus 57M 7 d 98 M 367 I 26 indeterm. sentences 3 93 S 80 r 181 NY 425 commutation 16AC 467n 130 penalties s 92 S 956 76 M 566 aw actions 20 AC 104n damages period 20 AC 104n 1 38 ct. review s 92 S 627 171 711 weight of ev. 114 264 1 7AC 233n reverse judgt. 37 CP 172 131 394 conclusive 63 M 147 public policy 67M 48 warranty 151 772 1 40 disqualif ctn 3 92 S 913 16 AC 398-9n 61 M 577 court's power do 84 M 91 1 4 1 appeal s92S 3 182 NY bank deposit 123 847 P 124 100 do 102 578 568 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed- c. criticised: 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ' n, not< questioned Vol, 103 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — ^Appellate Division / 85 M 660 husband wife 123 849 judgmnt right 124 101 trust deposits pl24 103 eoDStniction 52M 445 admission igSNY 435 jury question 19AC 248n incompetent ev. 19AC 239n declarations 204 NY 418 205NY 48 f 96 M 116 I 53sbare holder B 92 S 689 a. 182 NY 531 110 556 exception FO M 25—27 164 track conctn s 93S 37-1 a 190NY 544 132 566 168 annul, marr. B 93 S 396 s 16 AC 106 172 relief s 93 S 393 173 81 s 93 S 43b m 185 NY 368 192 opinion e 92S 1089 lag 748 for court f 162 578 243 presumption s 92 S 1010 48 M 521 252burden proof s 92 S 1071 110 675 instruction 116 160 evidence habit do 143 207 contrib. neglig. do 165 760 256 no acceptna. s 92S 1047 132 21 for jury 160 448 263 Mun Ct jurisdiction 92 S L62 d 169 183 e49M 50 M f 84 M f 93 M no power T8 M do 84 M 1067 479 406 872 468 654 89 510 276 92 135 assignment s92S 107 do 110 164 surety first do 67M 145 liquid, damages 69 M 588 duty f 176 110 not assign 104M 527 200 adoption s92S 1019 do 111 667 f 163 732 18A0 109n heir at law 111 665 Ise.NY 134 riglit inherit 150 631 155 657 statutory f 160 410 208 inspect book s92S 1084 117 79 f 169 422 69 M 71 mandamus 17AC £0n H'd 2l5jury question s 92 S lOOv dl21 620 instruction 116 160 2 1 8 constit law s93S 60 r 182 NY 330 235 will gift 6 92S 107.6 m 188NY 327 269 life insur. s 92 S 1105 r 186 NY 62 273 defense i 92 S 1025 95 M 170 277 parti defens 638 27.5 279 a92S 130 practice ICP NS demurrer do 143 1052 317 893 282 lease corp s 93 S 207 a 187NY 24 129 254 majority binds 81 M 691 3 1 recovery 3 93 S 46 al85NV 581 competent ev. 139 852 law question 159 198 316 authority s 92 S 1056 159 878 319 set aside 5 92 S 1015 7B M 169 three verdicts 169 835 negligence SO M 152 inconsistency do 179 683 322 novation 1 92 S 1096 r 185 NY 508 327 declaration devise 55 M construction 191NY exemption 191NY invalid do 19SN Y vested estate 137 487 test validity do 149 128 trust merges do 149 129 trust personalty 156 651 36 1 death benefit s 93 S 16 r 185 NY 141 367 preference s92 S 1101 48 M 337 B6M 585 insolvency 165 569 372 notification s 92 S 1006 80 M 480 375 new notice s 92 S 1107 127 448 378 liability 92 S 1061 f 159 660 novation f 173 955 38 I compliance s 92 S 1099 119 674 39 CP 284 388 bill partie s 93 S 41 140 550 393 return 3 92S 1112 112 34 certiorari 57M 396no contempt do 165 f 168 notice 179 423 change venue s92S f 103 U9 16 AC residence 39 CP 141 143 85 102 533 994 606 338 160 340 41 830 428biU exchange s 93 S 87 a 1S9NY f52 437 jurisdiction 3 93 8 1 48 M 152 s 16 AC 2i0 conclusive 149 457 legal residence 59 M 320 annulment 71 M 50 incompetent 204 NY divorce 20 AC 418 25n 500 legacies int s92S 1109 130 d 133 60 M d 196NY s 16 AC 462 92 287 316 isr- 399 power atty s 928 993 f 103 382 404 equity sui 92 485 853 712 s 93 S a 185 . NY objections 114 next of Uin 117 construe will 1 17 714 intent 117 715 76 M 648 trust valid 117 719 92 S cfise 2 153 f 175 1082 970 1012 216 509 213 923 3 928 116 201 NY peference 120 new trial Case 4 123 54 M 214, 215 voidable 59 M 337 409 contract s 92 S 1021 137 840 no excuse 137 840 420 execution 3 92 8 lie 38 CP retroaction 130 B4M 131 trust estate 138 837 trustee notice 1094 723 76 547 147 640 1039 491 447 trust s 92 8 117 sp. performnace a 187NY 516 453 dividends s93S 128 s 110 m. ohent liable 48 M 42f referee fee I7AC S8 recovery 133 395 459 ssrvices 8 93 8 12H s 183 NY 56F a 185 NY 556 463 fact queston s 93 8 113 f 108 329 damages elll 198 Ep. prfmance r 188 NY 259 f 220 NT 25 remedy 131 d 87 M 746 236 480 waiver 93S 121 52M estoppei 121 do 121 174 371 140 371 374 return property 124 72 waive breach SAC 156n implied warranty 18AC 156n, 157n reifiedy breach 18AC 158n 490 attachment 3 93 8 140 a 185 NY 592 same facts 94 M 173 498 assumption e93S 122 no gift 19A0 award 138 84 41S 239n 254 504 damages 3 638 53 r 185 NY 335 112 2«? 1112 264, 2a5 prescription 116 323 324 5 1 1 burden proof 3 93- 8 76 54M 91 debt bar 176 415 17AC 329 . default 53M 399 jurisdiction 64M: 220 discharge judt. d 137 439 remove cloud 137 440 Hie schedule 203 NY 262 application 203 NY 262 burd. bankrupt 185 606 520 incompetent 82 111 commissions 132 37CP 56 M 76 M 899 803 26 14 586 523 will _86S s93S a 185 NY devise d 63M non assignable 86 M 606 530 authority 604 1128 438 410 s93S 1.51 costs 208 NY 262 446 588 jury trial s 93 8 t 116 57M submission 38 CP insanity law question 19A0 324 authority only 73 M 17 535 jurisdiction s 93 S 152 138 800 ratification 139 257 collateral attack 166 598 540 execution s 93 8 149 116 723 H8 CP 76 retroaction 130 547 e 64M 147 not retroaction 131 640 constitutional 67M 165 as trust estate' 138 837 trustee notice do 165 85 notice 179 533 542no jurisdictn s 93 8 138 67 M comity 144 jurisdiction 7oM 155 271 165 77 299 554 pari delict ^ J3S 291 ILEANS 1013d penalty rule e 58M 80 fraudulent f 82 M 185 moral obligatn. lOlM 583 exceptions lOlM 586 not analogous lOlM 587 fiduciary lOlM 575 ground recourse lOlM 576 567 notice lien s 93 8 184 120 450 f 162 58 filing lien 73 M 430 amount lien 128 585 waiver 135 821 20 AC 118n separate lien 159 729 may combine 172 5 1st. dept. case 11 s92S 1126 a 184 NY 600 breach contract 1st dept. case 13 3 92 8 1121 a 185 NY 693 574 value s93 8 118 734, 54 M 132 738 311 577 master neg. s93S ILRANS 127 liability 143 150 78 M d 91 M complaint d 153 161 235 586 221 476 R02 250 799 159 426 140 171 / de^th neglig. case 39 s ?2S 1143 195NY 514 liq tax law rase 3S i92S 1138 ft 181 NY • 570 revocation 114 6ia pers. injuries case 42 s 92 S 1146 a 185 NY 680 strikeout case 43 3 928 lOSO a 184 NY 600 597 fise. reprsn 1st dept cased 3 92 8 1114 a 186 NY 682 598 appea case 5 a92S 1119 a 184 NY ans appeal case 15 3 92S 11S5 a 184 NY 588 fraud void case 7 3 928 1125 74M fin public policy 182 618 599 stkholders case 15 8 92 8 1138 i 103 599 600 services 3rd. dept 5ase2 s92 8 1117 a 185 NY 614 case 10 s92S 1035 sl6 AC 173 607 pers. injuries s 93 8 145 _„ . . , , !a 186 NY 699 DU4rmsdemean r| s 92 8 a 183 NY 595 breach con- L ggg tract case 1 '^ 186 NY 3 92 8 1126 oprvifAS a 185 NY 573 ^"™6 ease f s 93 g 1151,al88NY 1155 609 use occupa- 242 tion 1147 690 dismissal 3 92 8 a 184 NY appeal s92 8 a 183 NY goods sold case 3 3 92 8 a 187NY case 6 92S strike out 63 M case 11 s92S 146 1145 ^ injunes case 5ipneo 7 •^58 a 185 NY 1128 520 1118 56'l us- es 7 596 specl. jury case 8 s92S 1129 3 104 517 transfer tax case 23 s92S 1132 m 182 NY 23f tax Sale 62 M 447, m 1120 685 1132 562 1132 675 621 pers. injuries case 8 3 93S al85NY case 17 3 93 S stock 3 I87NY a 188 NY sp. perfrmance sase 20 3938 1148 a 185 NY 647 certiorari case 21 3 93 S 1U3 m 184 NY 566 neglignce oaseM i 93 S 1139 a 185 NY 586 3 1 appeal case 35 AMnRE\'IATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; c, criti^isrH; I limited; c, explained; o, overruled; s, same ca se; do, dissenting opinion; p. Darallel case; q. auestioned. N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division Vols. 103, 104 s 93 S 1142 * 183 NY 568 performance case 36 s 93 S 1124 a 185 NY 549 appeal case40 s 93 S 1149 a 184 NY 607 jungment case 38 s 933 1148 « 1 86 NY 520 VOL. 104 4 due care s 93 S 152 7 law action s93S 113 37 CP nonsuit 116 71 executor 93 S 321 109 294 1 33 nonsuit 209 reject claim 123 17AC authority 337 862 76 negligence 166 a 93 S a 113 480 500 „„„ 595 10 impeachment terms new trial 843 60 M GSM s93"S ■" ' 244 18 AC 18AC 456n 82 damages I41mprd notice s 93 g s 93 S 217 a 185 NY f 84 M 455 1 7 chge. grade s 93 S 309 160 160 5SM 463 78 M 4 20 bill partic. s 93 S 334 118 92 156 382 56 M 332 lOOM 172 denial issue 153 58 2 1 non-residence s 93 S 356 f 87 M 197 construction f 87 M 198 23 body execute s 93 S 286 a 182 NY 526 109 757 wilf. conversion 195 NY 403 arrest lawful 92 M 719 trespass a 185 NY authority 131 26 record 1 I pers s 93 S 215 8 93 S HI 424 a 185 NY no appeal 28extend paymt 35CP s 93 S 335 neg. master 160 399 126 do 154 42 mtg. contract scaffolding s 93 S 853 128 49 M 265 195 NY performance T. 121 45 appeal 8 93 S 50 M 51 M 52M 114 default open 52M review 52M 147 s 93 S 260 n 109 stay costs 218 17AC 137 brokerage 641 8 938 159 19A0 468n agency 139 30n 579 408 409 171: 90 equity claim s 93 S 304 139 940 p.ertificate !8 M 708 94 evidence 8 93 S 547 ■07 573 113 477 17 AC 235 74M 589 jury question 56 M roM discretion 150 reversal 166 new trial 99 M set aside 99M 676, 348 282 546 31 677 8 93 S 51 M 179 153 contrib. neg, 128 infer neglig ail 130 538 death neglie 558 do 130 'struct re'' 157 195 NY labor law 133 116 114 5 I regular face s 93 S 349 130 302 equity suit 149 896 56 exceptions 8 93 S 388 112 354 review 18 AG 336 7n 18 AC 8n 62 master neg. s93S 113 66 delivery 8 93 S 118 recovery 132 271 303 27 res ipsa loq. 64M for jury 20 AC alteration 153 105 ordin. s 93S 180 683 5 575 422 4U5 576 443 509 282 421 415 '581 151n 406 care 316 591 214 NY 496 i92a^>snee title 3 93 S 434 125 738 waiver do 178 650 484 147 323 50 144 noUce claim 93 S 307 120 61 129 682 aeg notice f 163 212 17AC 282n liability act s 113 745 123 395 notice defect 129 683 147 contract s 93 S 590 152 403 I SScontrct sate s 93 S 346 a 185NY 582 157 negligence 8 93 S 273 3 123 548 rules necessary 20 AC 141n 1 95 pleading s 93 S 505 a 16 AC 233 198 contrct sale s 93 B 967 ■» 182 NY 516 205 hq.tax certif s 93 S 492 a 185 NY 546 disqualification 164 804 revocation 217 NY 107 f 88 M 262 207 negligence plead & prom. 1 62 mandamus 8 93 S 300 s 107 340 120 754 174 451 88 M 682 ^♦..ju 1- ^x salaries contnb. neghg j^-„ 250 ?{^ 65M 19B ^„„ no legal remedy 34 jj injury "^ *^^ duty city ??^ 1 67 trespassser 466 s 93 S 117 742 right of way 169 689 suas B 114 214 order 5 93S case 3 f 126 249 789 216 654 223 encroachmt 937 907 397 8 93 S 119 95 M obstruction 124 57M nuisance sl21 s 145 368 503 al89 NY pass title 228 US 272 contract 93 S 754 m 185 NY 617 conclusive 160 13 412 claim proof 147 290 per s 93 S 152 77 M ' 'issue' ' f 163 t 85 M f 87 M 144 capita 811 526 663 536 620 533 s 93 S 112 scrutiny v. 119 120 62M 416 carrier s93S 18AC 8 116 303 conditional agreement s 93 S 744 a 185 NY 587 309 impeachmnt. _93S 18AC 637 45911 866 569 135 312 will s93S a 185 NY d 145 inadmissible t 85 M 168 337 p rs. injuri s 93 S 777 8 110 115 132 no power 198NY distinction 69 M. mandamus 138 145 authority 22 221 _,, 347 contract 741 s 93 S 806 s 109 50 delay surety 139 765 261 u. 856 131 228 241 626 357 negligence 104 I 1 new trial 8 93S- 230 104 617 1 12 enabl'g act s 93S 732 135 491 trust continues d 77 M 368 no power 86 M 110 enforcement I73against city s 93 S 542 f 91 M 483 2?2 140 no permission 154 405 ultra vires i 154 409 public nuisance 154 409 ordinances 1 79 repeal s 93 S 339 s 183 NY 549 157 405 cloud on title a 185 588 tax provision 125 162 presumption 200 NY 109 not presumed 157 40G not repealed 83 M 173 exclusive rule 210 NY 416 charter city e 210 NY 419 182 reargument 242 stckhldr 476 forfeiture 8 93S 943 68M 178 486 mandamus 8 93 S 928 17AC 84n 85n negligence 137 65 no variance 84 M 13S no liability d 90 M 314 488 burden proof 8 93 S 935 50 M 437 appeal -.- a 186 NY 575 aBBKEVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d. distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed- n nni.. o. criticised: 1, limited; e. explained; o. overruled; s. same case; do. dissenting ooinion: D. parallel Ms^'q.a'ueHionJd 3 93 S 3 113 184 notice 8 93 S f 87 M 1 88 will a 93 S a 182 NY 465 467 342 536 404 154 174 f 91 M 91 M 92 M delegate SO M liable d 182 403 662 344 344 84 power 101 493 232 practice 8 93 S 728 163 217 237 warning s 93 S 671 186 NY 35 16 AC 315 s93S 77B n 115 4fi9 amendment 19 AC ?,94 jurisdiction 142 453 f 165 159 251 discontinue case 2 s93S f 114 821 900 191 restrictive covenants , ^^ ^ s 93 S 355(263 stkhldr suit 142 109 540S93S 799 res ipsa loq s93S . a 185 NY e 111 135 reversal 123 inspection 130 163 liability 150 895 669 843 514 738 261 199 103 640 375 827 157 187 neg. 741 331a 335 420 tenant dam. s 93 S 684 sill 179 rent 60 M 93 tenant repairs 74M 438 compliance 77 M 120 duty tenant 137 570 encroachments d 159 843 174 108 783 588 629 427 rent 3 93S a 185 NY tl04 counterclaim 72 M 361 weight of evid. 164 670 misrepresention d 91 M 525 442 oonsideratn s93S 113 159 91 M liability 174 669 21 586 225 295 378 injury neg. s 93 S 697 a 116 509 do511 prox causs 193NY 331 new trial 170 317 95 M 593 384 complainr s 93 S 059 a 185 NY 583 16 AC 371 393 mech. lien s 93S 8.-16 16AC 917 404pers injury .933 a 186 NY master neg. 117 appliances ell7 dl42 147 220 NY performance do 117 rule excuse 131 liability 136 -., d 65M 900 do 132S detail 74S 661 391 392 540 160 187 391 375 838 573 227 53S 451 recovery 3 93 8 s 184 NY r 185 NY full face 174 916 587 308 587 460 will legacy 8 93S p 104 182 NY party 8 117 interested 142 intervention 142 836 622 280 702 429 429 465 amendment 8 93 S 768 120 S29 57M 374, 375 no power f 170 348 184 953 468 subway 3 93S 117 160 Vols. 104, 105 N. y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division a 16 AC 339 certificate 147 533 496 police sergnt • 93 S 720 a 183 NY 573 501 plea answer B 93 S 678 57M 139 extend time 18AC 152d pere imury a 186 NY 597 town s93S r 185 NY 503 impute neg* 93 S 663 55M erroneous 182 567 494 1 615 injunction case 1 B 93 S 249 a 187NY 560 219 366 507 bldg, code 8 93 S 911 168 551 517 strict GompUance s 93 S 725 i 160 436 520 will 93 S 676 110 401 intent 60 M construe will r 187NY 400 53 1 report s 93 S 1074 8 111 509 534 reopening B 93 S 1042 f 83 M 449 544 service sum- mons e 93 S 1048 p 104 629 revocation 104 p56l 661 550extrinsic ev. s 93 S 1052 £ 153 73 559 service sum- mons ■ 93 S 1069 P 104 651 562 St. limitatns s93S 1067 a 182 NY 562 133 361 demurrer 133 361 568 distinction 6 88 S 412 115 344 waiver do 126 663 158 31 off set damages 617 contract case 13 8 93 8 a 186 NY case 17 s93S equity 120 1128 S6b 1132 784 159 63 1 spec (case 30 s93S a 185 NY rescission case 29 s93S a 1S8NY damages case 33 s93S a 187NY 6 1 8 trespass s 93 8 1146 a 1S3NY 520 new trial case 3 s 93S 1145 132 244 6 1 9 award case 5 s 93 S 1122 r 186 NY 625 2nd dept case 1 5 3 93 S 1136 a 185 NY 689 case 22 s93S r 183 NY damages case 20 s f)3S r 186 NY sp- prfmance ca,-e 11 '3 S 1136 a 186 NY 563 negligence case 21 3 93 fS 1149 r 186 NY S25 622 release s 93 S 837 89 M 353 624 appeal s03S 115 674 68 1149 161 702 899 626 negligence 129 covenant 62 M estoppel 148 195 NY not recover 171 431 84 M 180 295 452 772 330 571 ineligible s 93 S 575 78 M 503 576 delivery B 93 S 423 16AC 278n 580 new trial B 93 S 883 r 183 NY 460' I 105 s93S a 185 NY 629 tax case 1 s93S r 183 NY contempt case 2 s93S a 185 NY 1128 567 1143 264 787 588 630 conversion case 4 3 93 S 1144 a 186 NY 684 breach contract case 8 3 93S a 185 NY new trial case 18 s93S a 184 NY contrue will case 22 s 035 1139 a 186 NY 99 construction 3 118 368 agreement case 17 93 S 1121 a 1S6 NY 613 159 445 1133 683 1123 699 629 record prfm 1148 685 1142 592 1134 660 VOL. 105 I services s 93S 452 d 133 513 powers board 139 887 8 for jury s 93 S 407 155 417 1 2iury question s 93S 457 139 295 16 prob. profits s 93 S 413 do 160 170 21 prom, note s 93 S 449 a 191NY 536 renewal 179 278 25 negligence s 93S 634 112 677 resubmission 118 633 local option f 120 899 900 notice 57M compliance 62 M settlement 73 M submission 75M 88 new referee s 93S 849 136 265 without power 158 182 90 presumption s93S do lOS due care 119 amendment 56M 96 costs 93 S s 114 di scovery 63 M 920 262 436 343 115 123 17AC 37 CP new trial 8 69 M weight of ev, 142 set aside 72 M 145, 844 287n 269 231 88 140 proof will 844 816 338 261 f75M invalid 20 AC illegal SOM mandatory 183 182 183 549 289 37 guardian s 93S 3 d 137 346 170 873 40 publication s 93S 426 f 105 629 43 exemption s 94 S 230 150 862 176 275 actual malice 152 694 46 exemptions s 94 S 194 38 CP 176n 48 contract 94 S 1031 188NY 395 59 obstruction s 93S 827 19AC 269n 63 custody s93S 17AC 192 98crim. contmpt s 93 S 711 68 M 480 unconstitunl. 74 M 176 f204NY 112 204NY 122 constitutional f 204NY 113 notice necessy. 204NY 122 94 M _ 505 no notice f 147 .397 imprisonment 147 590 rules of law 154 077 lost right 164 639 s93 S s 118 1 47 appeal s93S 113 case 10 t 126 no appeal 126 right appeal 155 1065 502 926 _| codieil 938 1004 46S 705 370 a 182NY 110 revocation 113 123 £ 87 M 18AC construction 117 75M 76M pwr. surrogate 72 M 572 96 M 149 authority 374 476 474 399 579 121 77 M statutory 184 847 42n 73 complaint 93 S 909 163 240 fraud do 223NY 183 223NY 184 77 negligence 9938 796 s 111 921 85 mandamus s 93 8 828 account M 596 597 I I I trespass s93 8 924 d 54M 432 owner vault 123 263 direct damages 62 M 23 139 239 easements f 173 637 65M 289 speculative do 147 51' date of award 81 M 326 species property £ 163 693 I 15 discovery .s 93 S 895 18AC 194n case 8 146 918 perpet. evidence 14:0 535 statutory f 181 935 102M 77 \ 1 9 disqualify s 93 S 797 s 16 AC 380 85 M 220 I 29 maintenance 5 93 S 954 d 154 350 73 M 261 132 franch. tax s 93S 971 a ISSNY 546 cap. employed 105 32S 136 assume s93 S 115 147 68 M d 72 M 76 M court s'duty 120 412 jur.v question risk 979 584 137 577 85 605 823 149 liq. taxlaw s 938 982 a 183NY 544 indictment 110 616 143 256 154 oral proof s 93 8 993 126 189 meas, damage 126 191, 192 liability 169 318 157 scrutinized 646 16 s 93 S 68 M I59trusts s03S a 186NY equity suit f 178 SO 488 976 33S 70 229 jurisdiction 8 93 S 1016 116 526 forest park r 186NY 66 236 affidavit! s 93 8 833 115 140 239 separ. rights s 93S 1009 a 186NY 45 joinder 124 243 pollution dam. ' 172 401 dividends 103M 92 water course 103M 383 164 limitations s93S 1012 f 111 911 membership a 186NY 613 not binding 20 AC 47n 171 presumpn p 93 S 990 75M 452 nullity 97 M 46 1 75 reassessment 3 938 aJ82NY 105. capital tax 112 license tax 148 369 526 328 515 186 inference s 93 S 445 t 172 59 f 93 M 72 193 mtge void s94S a 188NY allegation 76 M 53 197 ballot 948 a 183NY 48M 55M 219 scrutinized 94 S 707 68 M 16 remuneration 68 M 18 767 46 635 553 objn. 996 53S 420 7 243 election law 3 938 1023 r 182NY 442 247 limitation 3 93 S 998 ; 16 A.O 298 250consi deration 8 038 418 48M 4S8 105M 614 obligation 216 NT 609 256 test capacity s 93S 665 aJ85NY 128 87 M 583 26!) contractual s 938 428 119 356 273 acknowldgm 5 93S 584 4SM . 6S6 disqualification 16AC 346n certiorari 127 481 278 dismissal 93S 416 f 147 118 282 personal knowledge " 8 1071 175 949 284 recovery s 94 B 700 117 351 contract 38 CP 366 287 damages 8 94 S 695 55M 151 enforceable 139 153 150 804 enforcement \ I'. liKKV rTTKiXS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; '. dismissed; n, note; c, criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q, questioned N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division Vol. 105 150 804 sp. performance f 177 147 223NY 63 memorandum 103M 352 292fact question fi 94S 765 113 669 136 345 iaferences 52M 341 epprfmancejlTAC sSSS 8 93S r 186NY 1034 1146 89 302 jurisdiction B 93S 995 s 16 AC 288 a 182NY 568 contempt 62 M 558, 569 307 costs stay 356 termination 8 94 S 171 120 16 155 511 vacancy 175 689 functus ofl&cio 17J, lOOM 633 appeal stay discovery 122 stock books 125 motive infer 125 81 620 539 540 e93S s 107 17AC reversal lOOM 959 525 325n 310 bill partic sOSS 110 118 62 M 39 CP ICP NS 953 553 346 265 243 5 186 22 312 v'd marriage s93 S s 16 AC 119 f 162 162 96 M 105M 1001 307 3do8 601 602 168 281 do 38 CP330, 336 divorce 57M 15 Interlocutory 178 436 196NT 130 95 M 14 dovrer right 134 B2S amendment 141 invalidity 141 abatement 75M ratification lOSM 614 614 211 281 3l5iiicompt ev. E 93 S 950 120 187 87 M 192 objection 91 M 196 3 1 9 assessmen s 93S 1093 a 182NY S5S t 105 637 358 expr. waiver s 94 S 1 84 126 273 20 AC 287n admissible 153 497 cross examinatn f 164 626 362 degree care s 94 S 1171 73 M 527 impl'd notice £ 84 M 455 precautions f 84 M 456 reasonable care f 86 M 333 86 M 334 366 incoinpt s 94 S 241 f 122 885 123 253 opinion rule f 168 402 373 jury quest'n s 94S 12 evidence do 143 tor jury d 154 376 title 5 94 S s 123 250 habit 207 880 236 452 33 1 injunction 5 86 S 613 s 94 S 1147 a 189 NY 529 f 170 278 53M 149 335 competev s 93 S 864 61 M 318 381 principals s 94S 225 105 512 indictment 112 523 389 reprsenta- tions s 93S 834 «0M 193 395 spl. damages 9 94 S 190 .18 AC 21 9n incompet. ev. 18AC 225nl restrict proof 41 3 judgment case 4 s 94S 210 f 133 88 not conclusive 72 M 21 422 competent s 94 S 574 17 AC 6 436 death dam. s 94S 203 a 182Ny 56S statutes in force 220 NY 187 445 good title s 94a 352 107 418 114 partiea 110 325 112 238 449 care insane a 94 S 270 e S6M 16 UUM 213 457 power court 8 94 S 277 116 483 adl. parties 125 738 no authority 39CP 76 counterclaim 157 679 third party 175 250 lOOM 182 185 478 iuclament case 2 s 94S 1 f 117 9 notice d 125 500 valid gift s 94 S 292 122 779 505 other crimes s 94 S 617 e 119 234 larceny 136 233 520 jury question 8 94 S 449 57M 653 533 new trial 8 94S 1144 r 182NY 482 537 accounting s 94 S 238 a 186NY 519 burden' plaintiff 168 57 542 conclusive 8 94 S 404 122 685 impeachment 122 Si collateral stk. 59 M 268 stipulation 135 888 sum pro. 201 NY 452 open default 78 M 267 561 contract s 94S 119 m 184NY 614 129 194 572 limitation s 94S 221 112 169 oers. property 116 70S 132 788 102M 36 award 62 M [605 hose action refere 175 201 IS 492 tender s94S 112 494 stay costs 69 M 371 S94S f 109 122 123 138 d 166 52Ji Ci6M f 93 M 577 costs 3 94S = 109 atty at law 157 61 M 897 i 580 facts stated s 94S 281 132 206 171 701 177 147 616 283 539 683 9 568 325 589 commissions 197NY pleading 197NY liable 200 239 400 pers. 8 94 S 123 not liable 146 581 actual intent do 138 245 parol evidence 176 248 17AC 322n 324 paym't costs 38 CP 234n 164 926 poor person 19AC 314 indemnity f 170 78 496 parol ev. s 94S 65M repairs do 65M s 94S a 185NY dill o8M waiver 206 NY 547 554 756 134 485 618 assumed risk 8 93S 1125 a 184NY 603 110 623 623 conversion s 86 S 557 94 S 1157 a 186NY 559 625 restrain power of sale case 7 s93S r 185NY tax 98 life insur. 3 95 S 797 a 190 NY 211 1 03 insurance 3 96 S 682 a 186NY 609 585, 586J2I7 damages lOOJI 163 )06 notice agent 3 95S 3 17 AC a 185NY effective 147 678 259 534 218 1 1 ] change venue s 95 S 3 17 AC 114 106M appeal do 114 146 discretion 149 75M fair trial - oM riejudice "5M 116 tax law s95S r 185NY 790 1 124 fl92 Ni 294|s 9SS " 684 may waive '113 677 89 M 155 [ejectmen'. al86NY 486 150 agency con Is 19 AC 315 9 95S 815l *186NY 6191222 negligence commissions s 958 774 case 7 Is 17 AC 277 fll2 887|al85NY 556 allowance ai5 gg^ f 113 918 superintendent 39 537 508 extra fees 20 AC 191i 153 prfm, balance 121 lis 61 M master liable 55M 582 jury question 132 505 134 636 f 5SM 584 ie/» . 1 , iJi^dgt. on verd. 63 contract prl, 13 6 290 3 95 6 818 instruction 3 95S 3 112 158 mil 3 958 4gM 857 369 821 385 64 M 200 165 partnership 669 255 36' 144 reinstated do 150 reversal 151 7nfl!54M 74 '84 M I action lies 71] d75M o^ois 96 a 636!cond. precedent | jgg 84 il "'" 134 409 848 803 p,ci230 liahility *M° s OR s 410 416 57(1 1117 534 1136 521 455 f 108 345 classifi- cation s95S 916, 1153 1118 3591 1163 519 f 81M 38 liability s 95 S 90 M 300 1 1 9 trespass 3 95 S 1029 a 187NY 550 ta.x sales 161 4 132 stay costs s 95 S 102: 1117 50S 367 guardian case 1 953 a 183NY appeal case 8 1114 573 s 953 n83NY 1141 392 123 148 powers 150 410 reduce salary 359 evidence ca.se 18 3 95 3 ine contrib. neglig. 167 363 94 M 649 duty repair f 175 534 42 rescission s 95 S 1040 t 77 M 128 counterclaim 77 M 129 45 employment s 95 S 62] 79 M 243 660,123 383 17AC 1 66 error s 9.5S 185 ^^ido 166 Jl75 court 716 for jury f 93 M 1 768 776 828 117 237 pers. injury 3 96 3 49 a 186NY 590 I 68 brokerage 8 95 S 1089, 130 656! f 84 452{2i]| receive- whole contract s96S ■^1 M _ 42 J 3 ,7^\c commissions .rlvpr^p 76 M 200'^*^ "^ burden plff. ' 76 M 200 j 75 inadmissible s 95 S 645 f 158 csf; 61 M '97 31 2831 waiver 27f 2 100 26: 432 627 681 f 159 160 f 83 M promotion f 160 salaries f 163 173 88 M pract. construcn f 166 577 220 NY 63 a 220 NY 63 353 dismissal s 95 S 326 114 782 354 reargument ] case 2 I r 186NY 429 360 ad. allowncp case 1 s 958 *183NY appeal case 8 s 95S *184NY redemption case 6 s 95 3 m 187NY will legacy case 6 8 95 3 r 1S8NY 111 677 1122 558 1128 166 1122 9 361 inspection case S 3 96 8 726 p 115 891 49 election 3 953 al83NY limit power d 71 II 512 invalid 203 NY .148 53 bailment 95 S 1061 1S4NY 599 no cause action 10111 300 55 amendment 138 126 65 covenant 953 1053 1 IS4NY -584 injunction 156 531 67 M 570 64M demurrer 159 325n 642 800 135 notice cl.aim 3 96 S 1020 120 61 132 809 134 liability act 17AC . 281n notice insuffic 129 665. 682 91 M 176 s 953 45M impute 135 „,(j 178 not ^i*** s 95 8 do 160 waiver ev 139 authority s 95 3 1097 175 496 143 indictment 3 958 993 a 186NY 558 f 110 922 1 46 stay costs 645 5^7 nor^'*' 615 apply 652 634 1 80 death neg. 246 stipulation 3 953 816 *184NY 672- 252 injunction 3 963 la 3 109 91T legis. power 124 265 194 NY 220 224 Wemurrer s 57M 418 421 constitutional 119 728 57M 424 accounting case 2 f 126 937 828 -feg^' 694l' s 95 3 sI7 AC 123 164 f 166 62 M 66Sf 93 M f 97 M stay trial 139 order case f 143 865 321 283 926 683 353 567 335 198 729 3 950 148 secure costF s 96 3 6701 a 186 NY 594'^?. ^ ,, 348 policy holder 183 variance 62 M 411 s 953 793 1^2 224-5. 186 188 194 NY 239 inadmissible f,™,?"^™* ,»„ 186 94 d 72 M 462 189 constructn. s 95 S 839 f 88 M 696 right to tax f 170 228 f 95 M 065 recovery 176 942 I 95 amendment 3 968 3? *184NY 614 109 819 liquor tax 115 452 20 jrs. proof 132 270stockhldrs 3 96 8 1109. 293 reject c'aim i 93 8 133 17AC 260n 202n not established 147 210. 295 game law s 963 286 rl84NY 126 S 109 917 32lsupl. answer 3 958 64.'?; „, 1'9 356 333, mandatory !59 iM 268 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed- m inndifio.1. * ^- ■ j, .. criticised; 1. limited; e. explained; o, overruled: s, iame case;' do, £Zti% o^infonllr^p-arahel'^r :l =qu^stU°n'li Vol. 109 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division 330 «rror not fatal s 95 S 879 f 169 560 compliance f 219 NT II 334 revere ev s 95 S 833 128 907 339 neiglegnoe s 95S 884 r 185NY 270 341 negligence 688 £36 s95 S a 190NY statutory 66M liability 87 M 349 judgnlent 8 95 S 882 a 187NY 618 35 1 order s 95 S s 115 675 883 358 mandamus s 96 S 32; a 189NY 542 361 Pnb. sofcioolp r 96S 161 fi 184NY 42) 375 insurance s95S 8 17 AC r 187NY 127 limitations 187NY exemption do 97 M -80 293 347 818 356 337 394 accdt. insur s 96 S 2R2 a 187NY 617 error court 88 M 84 398 presumptn. s 96 S 147 f 159 22 404 liability s96S a 190NY 115 judgment case 13 do 126 415 551 810 903 406 mortgage 3 96 S 633 a 189NY 267 enforcement S6.,I 375 4 1 4 injunction 9 96S 193 NY remedy 75M taxpayer 183 428 344 192 533 418 damages 96 S 431 al86Ny 175 421 bill partic. s 96 S 412 157 363 166 808 424 not apply s 96S 70S 98 M 92 . injunction 181 172 427 mandamus s 9RS 1 30 *184NY 120 isalaries 115 66M c^/il service 119 approval 94 M 677 754 374 177 465 457 433 trust mtg. s 96S 80 ^ ill 912 foreclosure r 186NY 501 440 contribut'n s 96 S 85 a 188NY 606 presumption 126 304 444posessn,not' 3 96 S 9tj a 186NY 601 continuing 126 426 stct. constructn 126 426 waiver •20 AO 283e 449 negligence s 95 S 693 s 118 447 471 for jury s 968 629 65M , 375 pub. opinion 96 M 647 476 expert ev, s 96S 375 99M 252 489 libei s 96S 381 135 32 63M 679 491 baggage s 96 S 548 188NY 608 495 mech lien s 96 S 533 a 190NY 508 502 good taitb 622 134 421 5 1 4 amendment s 96 S 313 131 80 7 M 237 terms costs ICP NS 246 court's power 150 402 5I51eaveof court s 96 S 661 37 CP 8n 517 possession s 96 S 519 S144 560 144 565 s 149 041 52 1 notice entry s 96 S 392 d 54M 592 e 52 M 456 f 171 254 526 jury question s 96 S 338 19 AC 207n pleading 143 143 530 as agent "" S 378 172 151 533 hab. corpus 3 96 S 371 r 188NY 440 claim parent 75M 428 535 vacate judgment s 96 S 306 164 818 537 jud 1 sale s 96 S 566 58M 366 =ipplication 149 602 marketability 172 317 546 surrogate d 96 S 372 51M 32f! 549 no stay s96S 60 M damages 68 M 491 466 461 556 pleading s 96 S 366 s 17 AC right corpse 143 90 M 566 trust s96S a 184NY life tenant 202 NY 426 483 562 574 161 569 services 3 9B S 681 m 186NY 603 575 easements « 96 S 557 51M 281 f283 presumption 119 583 inad- missible s06S 74M 397 829 570 586 account- ing s 96S 579 148 215 588 tenancy s96S e 111 lis pendens 113 relief 61M 598 examination 402 238 s96S f UU discovery 128 131 ICPNS 561 865 317 799 370 600 jurisdiction s 96S 331 135 422 judgment 70 M 513 notice of Taction 153 195 enforcement 181 870 603 pers. injury "6 S 324 a 187NY 622 612 amendment 96 S 244 20 AO 9n sum,, proceedng lOOM 670 613 i^s judicata s 96S 620 3 109 631 3 109 633 634 constrct possn. 61 M 230 force entry 61 M 231 621 master duty s 96S 303 112 307 626 Gontrib. neg. s 96 S 246 117 748 630 estoppel s 96 S 626 170 787 638 foreclosure s 96 S 162 m 187NY 216 65! no neglig. ao S 251 153 306 659 satisfaction mortgage 309 420 915 652 J96S r 186NY case 5 f 110 trustees 79 M 665 jurisdiction s 96 S 686 a 187NY 178 ccmstiiutional 119 175 repeals do 135 672 670 evidence 3 96 S 389 114 50 electors right 194 NY 109 679 law conclusn s 98 S 356 117 263 684 reversal s 96 S 396 160 594 638 liability s 96 S 58S r 185 NY 64 judl. opinion do 67M 147 696 complaint 3 96 S 336 62M 623 96 M 565 performance 179 646 702 duty supt. 96 S 513 96 M 39 706 costs limit s 96 S 555 70 M 227 amend judgnit. 90 M 399 709 carrier neg. 751 amendment .s 17 AC s96 S liability sl46 98 M 415 602 661 578 718 nunc pro tunc 96 S M judgment d53M filing 643 279 47 38 CP 128 f 169 f 217 NT r37CP effective 144 valid legislation 154 775 spl. deputy elks. 208 NY 461 726 negligence 421 687 821 287 265 483 77 M 6 77 M 802 injunction s 96 S 844 a 187NY 243 140 627 814 bill partic. 3 96 S 761 120 391 o96S d 3 116 19 AC 122 214 NY for jury 150 387 142 211n 589 541 187 737 by motion 177 838 s 96 S 154 conclusive f 178 74 1 escheat 9 96S r 184NY aliens 18 AC 748 assessment s96S case 8 f 109 omission 106M 199 671 467 298 697 919 588 3 96S case 1 1 9 110 852 libel s 96S f no 55M designation 170 s 96 S 111 762 decree 96 S s 17 AC a 187NY compliance 139 e7oM publication 71M 6 M ubscribing witnesses 74 M 777 little credence s 96 S 97 M 571 864 729 380 703 246 433 630 580 28 435 553 781 corpoiation 851 a 185 NY 555 f 110 920,921 50 M 26 shareholder 113 148 b and f. assorn. f 112 887 do 113 146 foreclosure 120 90 non-stock corpn 264 146 788 salary 3 96 S 120. audit 116 emoluments 146 286 793 death neg. 3 96 S 866 3 17 AC 440 798construe wil 96 S 1014 56M 84 86 legal issue 127 379,381 per capita 152 626 818 not final s968 111 practice 78 M no review lOOM 663 a 188NY 691 668| 9 1 1 negligence case 16 s 95 S • 1154 a 186NY 648 damages 156 432 teleph. wire case 12 3 96 S 1137 e 1S6NY 493 authority 155 779 Indian right 751 86-a 34 821 pers. injury 3 96 S 754 r 186NY 139, 838 preference 9 96S 717 170 353 60M 466 850 new trial 913 920 822 920 671 461 64 M trespass case 4 s96S a 186NY contg. remdr case 14 s 95S 1165 a 1S7NY 172 622 1164 602 912 prom, note case 5 s96S a 186NY negligence case 1 3 95S a 185NY 1122 520 1128 659 856 advantai?c 96S 441 69 M 585 859, evidence s 96S a 185NY tax law ev. 18AC 861 will 6 968 *186NY presumption 52M 876 541 933 642 298 120 282 876 equity suit 96 8 466 116 216 878 carrier neg. 96 S 826 3 17 AC 434 94 M 126 884 probate will 827 668 917 constit. Ian case 3 s 96S rl84NY license case 19 96 S 153 172 179 3 96 S a 188NY costs 64M allowance 64 M 295 892 police comr. s96S a 184NY reinstatemt. 125 certificate 128 868 268 153 903 ^^^ insurance 3 95 S al86NY 904 appeal 96S al 86NY 1112 670 801 689 910 negligence case 11 s95S 1131 a 186NY 665 pes. injury case 2 s95S 1161 913 contract 2nd.dept. case 1 s 96S 1138 a 185NY 691 9 1 4 jurisdiction 205US 915 estate case 14 sfe6S a 183NY 521 1166 676 1145 134 129 211 918 replevin 9 96S 494 s 186NY 596 919 contract case 6 s 95 8 a 186NY by-laws ease 2 3 9.") 8 a 188NY 1137 597 1112 281 920 negligence case 1 1 95S 115P. r 184NY 3! 9 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f. lollowed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note c, criticised ; 1, limited; r. explained; o, overruled; s, aamecase; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case: q, questional N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division Vol. 110 VOL. no 7 negligence B 96 S 810 d 70 M 409 70 M 557 13 leave appeal s96S 1039 111 919d reguiarion 5SM 427 police officer 05M 450 use street 67 M 635 delegation 72 M 421 light public 80 M 100 20 remedies s 96S 905 137 349 justice do 137 330 court's power 72 M 120 punishment 20 AC 297n may be heard f 162 589 stay f 169 418 23 negligence s 96 S 903 d 120 644 defect catch 120 645 not apply d 71 M 463 28 impeach ev. 8 96 S 1051 30 spec, object B 96 S 1054 £ 91 M 239 in treasury f 91 M 239 240 mandamus 170 228 229 in trust 172 766 32 trust s 96 S 899 a 187NY SI 6 superior lien 120 682 haiinless error 136 392 37 vested B96S 1052 m 191NY 157 gift 63 M 426 sMenable Ui 540 1 161 133 valid assign' iiient 1-17 S41 vested interest 147 842 42 separation s 96 S 804 f 121 896 public purpose 75M 511 44 constitution'! s 96 S 800 141 031 73 M r,ii f 92 M 7 10 mandamus 144' 311 prospective f 173 • 334 compensation 221NY 227 48 negligence 3 968 530 ftl85NY 566 jury question 122 590 proximate cause 71 M 36 52 waiver 1 96 S 1034 118 207 f 167 756 satisfied 138 863 58 damages 96 S 907 al88NY 255 51 accounts 3 97S 23 a 18S NY 539 69 assessment s96S 862 112 133 judicial 168 475 enter block 98 M 724 72 lien 3 96S 1061 m 184NY 568 1 JS 648 78 irregularity s 96 S 1006 i 17 AO 450 18AC , 32n stipulation 18 AC SSn presence judge 18 AC 34d conclusive f 178 199 82 for jury 5 96 S 475 f 141 922 ^8 overt act 3 96 S DOS 142 192 95 reference i 97 S 107 125 845 99 complaint 3 97S 52 i 110 659 apcounting a 188NY 624 jurisdiction 151 321 104 certificate i97S 3 '183 NY 536 review I.8AC 33511 1 06 attachment i97S 156! 113 352 'urisdiction 57M 346 acafe levy SO M 546 108 oontrib. neg i97B 137 114 809 812 appea' s 186NY 614 f 120 168 1 1 7 negligence 97 S 109 '.19 13t- lo 154 ■ afe appliance 26 790e, 791 jury question 138 815 iutv defendant do 185 849 122 int. in firm 8 97 S 5 139 580 125 Corp. right s 97 S 125 174 929 130 default costs ' " S 1095 56M 446 rule practice 6] M 598, 699 ICP NS 35 133 error judgt s 97 S 92 118 662 practice 123 41 demurrer 127 731 do 144 554 dndings judgt 124 76i admissions 143 892 discretion do 144 553 dismissal 22.5XY 356 1 49 costs s 97 S 38 89 M 008 f 89 M 609 106M 363 152 will trust a97S 117 a 185NY 633 205 NY 218 165 affidavit i97S 91 .53M 631 171 mandamus s 96 S 609 a 187NY 5!- franchise 117 87 143 17(^ consent nee. 69 M 202 205NY 262 permit 69 M 202 concession f 216 NY 43 200 aftv. com- pensation s 97S 14 r 186NY- 560 208 master duty s97S 7 114 661 ordinary care 194 NY 212 212 construction s97S 68M 128 75M 49 86 M 160 94 M 538 215 undertaking .< 97 S 270 a 186 NY^ 698 'lurety 123 326 not released U7 374 220 declarations sy7S ii-J 123 831 54 -M 201.' dismissal 134 201' claims clear 74M 340 evidence f 160 576 80 M 168 45 754 231 larceny 8 97S 132 7S4 236 account 9 97 S 274 3 17 AC 466 a 186 NY 611 f 178 60 obligation 161 274 cond. precedent do 170 754 f 171 323 241 trespass s 97 S 66 a 188NY 600 amendmeni 54 M 173 revocation 124 25d damages 97 S 329 3 17 AC 455 255 right con- tract s 97S 322 a 185 NY 267 public policy 174 249 267 power s 97 3 246 168 476 279 liquor tax certificate B 96 S 656 a 184 NY 679 lOlM 27 due process 94 M 505 294 validity statute 3 97a 336 a 185 NY 107 303 no discretn. s 97 S 259 63 M 130 3 1 3 valid will s 97 S 131 129 245 (or jury 99M 262 326 lex loci s 97 S 142 144 73 enforcement 145 426 stay 181 139 329 practice 8 97 S 76 114 200 119 840 331 Jittaohment 3 97 S 104 34M _ 66 complaint •i7M 343 not on merits 143 292 336 certiorari s 97 S 333 119 714 341 waiver proof ^ 97 S 73 114 752 do 126 665 iverment 53 M 5: pleading 126 75 allegations 346 election s 96 S 341 r 183 NY 274 e 117 42 356 presentmenl s 96S 383 18AC 392n 360 demurrer . 97 S 200 f 173 834 366 interest 5 97 S 27S 157 5.S.=> 184 248 f 91 M 584 370 verdict new trial s 97S 20 sill 236 vacated 62M 507 absence judge 18 AC 35r 378 injunction s 97 S 311 a 186NY 9 pllO 390 390 constitutlty s 97 S 320 a 185 NY 529 392 proper ev 97 S 86 115 306 libel constrctn. 132 40,n 396 meoh Uen s 97 S 280 a 186 NY 699 performance 119 575 show waiver 39 CP 285 bill particulars -0 M 251 432 mand;imu8 s96S 362 *190NY £30 appointment 141 517 three names 10511 385 440 prob. cause s 96 S 999 173 909 443royaltie8 96S 968 sl21 13.l24 461 jury question 130 83 not error 210 NY 165 d 210 NY 167 specific questn& 172 306 699 talse pretenses s 97 a 469 146 101 701 probate -- S 506 59 M 127 will election 60 M 276, 277 11 61 M 479 codicil 71 M 387 105M 464, 455 republish 73 M 155 be attested 72 M 257 incorporated do 222NY 242 72 M 616 intent 176 642 705 damages ^ 96 S 747 a 187NY 3 contract d 56M 639 92 M 720 709 atty's lien s 97 S 447 E 111 913 117 113 85 M 250 correct rule 117 116 .J8CP 164 nee. party 119 391 ciists deft. 123 271 713 receiver 97 S 529 147 781 723 compliance s 96S 496 134 . . 271 inadmissible T4M 568 certificate ev. 156 723 728 mandamus s 96S 444 a 185 NY 804 penalties 136 807 730 show right s 96 S 446 154 776 732sick benefitf ! 97 S 413 30 AC 53n 734 rulings s 97 S 424 153 434 735 cond precdi i 96S 448 75M 348 737 transfer tax s 96 S 466 al85NY 544 161 839 d' 85 M 688 jurisdiction 62 M 446 taxable 62 M 44S vested 150 808 refund £ 164 858 740 promotion 8 96 S 446 a 184 NY 576 742 constitu'nl 3 97 S 433 a 184 NY 494 747 pers. injury 97 S 422 a 188NY 596 neghgence I) 123 192 (1 126 543 d 142 176 7 55 negligence •I 97 S 417 120 480 d 174 850 detail work 126 166 760 fire insur. s 97 S 436 a]89NY 526 767 jury ques. fiase 1 3 97 S 414 iU4 798 ordinary care 98 M 39 40 f 98 M 42 770 good title s97S 431 125 765 133 417 rt'uive lien 20 AC 116n 774 St. opening 3 97 S 508 m 185 NY 115 f 11 776 sp- perfscn 8 97 S 442 a 186 NY 602 7871at'l «upp't 3 97 S 283 al93 NY 643 123 261 124 21 178 411 use waters 1 94 M 347 damages f 95 M 652 797 f ranch, tax 8 97 S 197 d 136 166 162 436 capital stock employed 155 845 799 new trial R 97S 202 134 983 unconscionable 79 M 317 not justify 79 M 345 809 warranty 3 97 S 239 m 188NY £17 3 1 6 mtg. tax law 3 97 S 550 a 185 NY 285 enforce tax 63 M 134 821 mtg. tax law 8 97S 535 a 184 NY 43: f 110 820 843 damages R 97 S 676 a 187NY 652 866 negligencp ease 6 3 96S 1115 a 187NY 262 867 contract case 1 a 186 NY 422 case 2 s 97 S 38 a 186 NY 611 873 perjury case 2 8 96.S 488 a 185 NY 615 contrib, neg. case 1 3 96 S 490 56 M 301 875 trespass ease 1 97 S 11 a 187NY 106 879 notice s 97 S 121 151 655 886 negligence 3 97S 89 119 434 887 appeal case6 8 96S * 185NY judgment case 7 S96S a 186NY case 12 statutory power £ 92 M 581 8R8 libel case 5 1124 531 1139 403 1150 47t al84NY ca.=!C 6 3 96 S lis a 184 NY 589 contract case 1 2 396 S 112^ a 186 NY 57i discretion case 4 s 96S 1132 148 781 83 M 579 889misdemeanoi oase 16 s96S 1141 al84 NY 853 appeal case 19 _96S 1134 * 184 NY 65b contract case 6 s96S list a 186 NY . 57i use occupation case 12 B 96 S 1121 contract case 10 3 96S 1142 case 11 3 96S 1121 a 187NY 651 a 18GNY 588 case 20 .3 96 8 1122 mechan. lien a 190NY 63? 890 services case 1 r 187NY 60 120 523r 89 1 decision case 15 s96S 1116 184 NY 588 transfer a 187NY 553 892 order casel7 s96S 1141 a 184 NY 573 inspect bks case 20 s96S 1141 do 122 642 a 184 NY 578 do 148 658 mandamus 135 419 injunction case 10 - 96 S 1 145 a 187NY 186 recovery ease 11 3 96S 1133 m 187NY 395 neg. damages a 187NY 550 893 Pcrs. injury case 6 s96S 1114 a 186 NY 550 construe will ease 8 96 fc 1117 r 185 NY 23 895 extra work s95S 114£ m 186 NY 603 897 intimes. s96S 1144 r 186 NY 6 909 trustee acct s95S 1131 a 184 NY 663 9 1 5 contract case 3 3 9CS 1120 S188NY 17 9 1 6 pleading cane 12 96 S 1143 case 4 s 06 1142 3 112 359 iaonds case 9 3 96 S 1148 a 186 NY 432 pers. injury case 6 i96S 1150 a 189 NY 62 917 prom, note case 13 _ 96 S 1124 a 186 NY 484 9 1 8 insurance ase 11 3 96S 1128 a 186 NY 577 negligence case h 3 96 8 112- a 187NY 73 sp. performance case 3 396 S 1126 a 188NY 675 919 hab. corpue case 5 3 96S 1125 a 184NY 694 appea 1 case 7 3 96S 1130 I ; 86 NY fiOR 920 judgment case 1 s 9GS U.'-S construe will case 9 sQeS 1138 a 184 NY 611 borrower case 16 s 96 S 867 a 185 NY 1 f 109 781 f 120 90 death damages case 5 3 96 S 1134 r 187NY 341 921 hab. corpus cases 96 S 1140 «184 NY 613 foreclosure case 1 3 96S 120 trial venue case 11 s06S 850 97 VOL. Ill I ep perform. .■ 97 S 514 a 188NY 616 amendment 19 AC 303n 8 judgt- V. one « 97 S 616 61 M 320 joint contract f 146 7 12 construction B 97 S 532 78 M 535 16 limitation s 97S 519 197NY 448 19 extra fees s 97 S 20 AC 83 M 521 19on 580 138 ,, .. 23 lien IWo s 97 - 817 922 franoh. taJ commissions case 12 s 96 S 1132 a 189 NY 542 chg. venue ease 6 8 96 appeal do 114711 do712 146 636 *184 NY 670 923 franoh. tax case 6 s96S a 183 NY a, 202 US contempt sth dept. case 3 171 695 536 143 170 proper expenses 165 196 175 352 atty. services 99M 231 jurisdiction JIOOM 58 '■^^ sane person 103M 142 35 prom, note 1141 575 684 496S *183NY appeal case 17 s06S 1S8NY 1113 53B 1149 556 3 97S *185NY s 191 NY barred 55 M demurrer sl33 judgment 3 198NY 1117 541 180 279 645 669 374 104 S57 39 penalty 3 97 S a 187 NY d 192 NY authority a 138 liability 202 NY discretionary 93 M 242 63 services 3 97 S 582 a 190NY 613 authority p 138 104 171 444 70 estoppel 8 97 S 670 t 131 636 limit rule 160 567 80 devise s 97 S a 185 NY 653 295 87 beneficiary 3 97 S 661 r 189NY 346 94 indem. bond 3 97 S 561 a 188NY .')96 101 order 3 97 S 566 case 11 f 116 918 cause action 90 M 358 mutual right 222NY 91 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; I. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; c, criticised; 1. limited; e. explained; o, overruled; s, samft case: do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q.quesuui'-j N. y. Supreme Court Eeports — Appellate Division Vol. Ill 1 17 modification 631 9U0 injury 552 494 s97S case 2 112 122 pers s97 S a 186 NY 200 NY pleading 130 prox cause 130 131 347 348 107 133 debtr. erdt 5 97S 465 132 22 ( (42 master duty 3 97 S 421 125 6S7 .safe scaffjid 20 AC 162n 20 AC 163n 145 bad faith s 97S 595 152 transfer tax s 97 S 553 a 186NY 549 160 Salary s97S case 4 123 judgment CAAe ti 122 917 800 170 new trial s 97 S 592 a 188NY 682 uieasu, damages 138 550 551 167 8 usable value 20 AC 102n 1 74 no interest s 07S 603 149 88 accounting 607 609 44 176 3 97 a 185 NY 163 68 M limitationa 122 do 167 170 173 .; 57M TOM estoppel 176 178 interest s 97S 116 d 76M covenants a 188NY duty tenant 157 174 455 398 457 905 539 471 196 right action £ 176 222 I961aw remedy s 97 S f 162 d 87 M 199 one purpose s07S do 147 600 605 236 623 514 206 conversion s 97S 415 209 directors 97 S i 186 NY pleading 124 validity 76M 722 28 733 17 230 transfer tax 97 S alSSNY 50 M ippraisal L14 a7 lis » 97 a 113 ;i5 51 M ;7M cancellation olM 444 543 493 721 penden 6R8 60 176 79 147 80 240 admissible < 97 S 609 d 151 526 answers 77 M 346 right correspndt 155 . 418 f 158 33 do 170 174 £ 92 M 566 254 contrib neg 1 97 S 719 f 120 _ 168 assume risk 120 638 259 enforcement i97S 116 valid 177 191NY separation e 123 747 817 254 474 423 604 211 593 570 108 181 may be heard s 97 S 602 f 162 589 189 annulment s 97S 586 137 290 177 293 80 M 338 separately 94 M 706 entry judgment 105M 647 19 1 dissolution s 97 S 557 86 M 119 pleading 121 747 28 1 contempt s 97 S 459 a 186 NY 5i'4 161 527 compliance 138 280 error court 74M 331 discharge 161 52 285 confirmat'n 8 97 S 503 a 185 NY 39) condemnatu 120 836 143 302 em. domain 126 849 s 135 563 law nf appeal 38 CP 393n appealable 135 565 f 152 425 injunction 168 388 306 new 3 97 S fll3 parol 148 trial 733 919 evidence 730 314 discovery 97a 56M f 91 M 18AC order case f 138 f 167 ■37 43■_ 354 designation s99S f 114 ofli paper m 186NY s 99 S alOSNY f 131 162 taxation 179 711 610 394 208 488 268 negligence 3 99S 794 a 188NY 559 dam 771 563 199 improper ev < 97 S 7fi 1 19 840 no appeal 13S 879 estoppel 168 77 202 transfer tax a 93S 630 a 186 NY 47 216 eas supply » lOOS 81 114 242n do 114 243 iniunction 272 death s99.S a 187NY 275contrib. neg a 99 S 763 139 8R7 142 240 278 mortgage < 99S 772 s 124 6 281 waive lien 99 S 770 20 AC 128n 290 notice nee s 99 S 890 142 171 uegligence 157 in? 167 363 296 redemption s 99 S 856 19 AC 253n 80 M 520 title necessary f 116 346 118 93 37CP 69 discretion 116 347 gas compnny a ISBNY 209 *ix rates 95 M 690 bond 104M 160 nay rate 104M 161 ■conclusive 104M 161 99S I 187NY 159 915 104 908 548 361 good faith s 99 S 874 do 160 735 joint adventure do 160 736 366 burden plff. 3 100 S 3S5 142 . 139 same carrier 155 381 common carrier 186 545 370 disbarment 3 100 S 42 188NY • 590 175 834 376 inspection 7 99s 1057 3 118 363 387 appeal stay T99S 1094 125 583 3 19 AC 102 no appeal 126 66, 16 do 126 98 error court 126 67 susp. hentence do 135 479 right appeal 427 428 310 85 M t 85 M intention 184 306 conclusive 3 99S 768 75M 385 affirmance 79 M 445 court of review 171 711 315 pleading _ 99 S 721 d 58M 472 unenforcible f 98 M 846 319 refunding 9S 852 326 assessment . 99S 657 r 189NY 6f 334 amendment 99 S 807 20 AC 19n .,,,,. ..... 823 do 176 403 166 222 390 sale 3 lOOS 145 al87NY 547 partition a 126 662 400 injunctions s99S 1067 a 193 NY 662 .58M 74 reservation 125 528 527 132 189 do 167 896 trustee damages do 125 531 56M 359 in trust f 161 176 405 jurisdiction a 99 S 1064 a 187Ny 638 title huSband f 167 264 410 not apply sons 1036 147 414 417 allegations s99S 1005 122 70 ad litem 10311 90 ABBREVIATIONS: c. criticised; 1, limited; 1, affirmed; d, distinEuished ; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note e, explained ; o. overruled ; s, same case ; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q. aueatinfi*4 Vol. 114 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division 420 coatract s 99S 1122 r 190NY 231 pleading do 122 51] construction 6YM 127 427 amendment s 100 S 123 196 NY 369 132 530 794 436 sale b99S a 188NY merger 129 1127 652 519 inequitable s 100 S 140 166 857 526 pers. injury s 99S 1114 a 189NY 564 532 accounting slOOS 3 19 AC refunding 77 M authority 77 M 210 446 recovery s 99 S 1030 d 85 M 22 450 mechao. I s lOOS a 191NY iblM burden proof 143 102 163 761 equities f 149 764 payment void 155 426 bad faith f 83 M 559 455 fees admr. s 100 S 49 122 448 compensation d 123 6 Stat, compenstn. 302 44 517 f 77 M 462 lien s IOCS 53M insane s 19 AC 71 personal claim 138 181 by petition 72 M 259 467 report s 99 S 982 118 . 344 93 M 604 courts dower 129 229 reference report 39 CP 130 470 ordinance s 100 S 208 167 174 charge correct 182 480 larceny s lOOS 135 136 requests 154 affidavits 1 169 81 M 160 284 233 12 111 296 538 commissions. lOOS 121 118 777 120 4 122 48 39 CP 247 pers. knowledge 79 M not apply 79 M 67 546 usury bank 1080 117 433 f 167 378 do 189NY 23 bills notes f 116 ■ 914 189NY S usury defence 59M 522 recovery 133 85 M raid 65 M superseded 153 M repealed 166 notes void do 89 M usurious 183 668 320 200 788 392 15 423 85 78 555jury question s 100 S 68 134 226 board power 134 228 competition 65M 614 compliance 171 142 565 expenses s 100 S 38 79 M 17fi commissions 92 M 651! 97 M 217 105M 42C 574 damages s 100 S a 186NY waiver d61M surplusage 131 good cause ICP NS eminent domain rt 149 654 change grade f 157 788 e 221NY 289 compensation 166 196 591 easement 8 99 S 1015 133 819 596 injunctions 3 99S 1009 al90NY 506 adv. possn 3 19 AC 60 necessity 81 M 359 600 exception s 99S 1052 115 867 prior crimes 18AC 200n, 201n 203n credibility 1 8 AC 21 3n 607 allowance 99S 1070 188NY 589 88 M 410 spl. guardian s 19 AC 86 6 1 Bnotice claims 1022 56M 189 pers. injury r 191NY 441 q 125 313 623 adl. allowce 3 lOOS 229 122 135 extra fees 20 AC 190n 626 recovery s 99S 989 a 190NY 507 intent deposit 194 NY 56 vests title 131 401 justification "- M 571 634 accounting 5 lOOS 27 a 189NY 563 640 unimpaired 669 penalty s lOOS 177 a 188NY 632 673 amendment "98 1026 52M rescission a 187NY 540 307 10 493 redemption s 100 S 1 a 190 NY 51 175 eOi 605 appeal B 124 257 actual notice 151 654 513 abduction s lOOS 259 * 187NY 557 new trial 184 901 312 578 conspiracy 100 S 31 rl89NY 180 55M 75 83 extra costs 130 502 no cause actn. 131 436 no right in rem 22" US 636 583 damages s loos 62 d 146 447 do 178 159 a 186NY 645 no power 150 193 179 405 slOOS 71 M not apply do 151 recovery fSl M operatn. of law 85 M 631 e 85 M 532 not a bar 179 29 646 recovery s 99 S 996 d 130 146 f 84 M 238 774 ejectment 8 100 S a 193 NY 186 677 678deatb neglig 3 99S 1111 a 189NY 518 d 134 42 681 commissions s 99-3 1079 56M 483 143 455 173 13 684 neg. dam. 3 99S 1103 rl88NYil56ll60 693 revers. error s 99S 1081 rl87NY 97 law exceptioi 121 618 697 no appeal lODS 126 d 128 439 appeals ordera 146 636 appeal lies 147 228 172 260 174 36?, prejudice -5M 416 at>pl authorised d 166 i'iZ change venuj 106M I 718 transfer tax 9 99S 1049 r 187NY 253 decree 9125 115 723 forest presve 3 lOOS 19 a 187NY 142 demurrer 74M 278 condemned 147 274 734 neg damage s 99S 1020 r 190NY' 137 743 demurrer 3 lOOS 119 a 190NY 217 error court 145 574 747 notice claim 776 motion 8 lOOS 373 case 6 f 115 discharge 130 , provable 156 207 890 84 499 519 778 decree s lOOS 243 a 188NY 541 reinburse 131 227 e 228 costs A 197NY 473 expense exr 136 s;ood faith 130 520 78 1 variance s 100 S 263 M 349 actual fraud 83 M 350 789 per. injury lOOS 110 a 190NY 571 791 bill partio. 8 100 S 192 124 514 792 practice s 100 S 196 115 667 opng. default do 126 294 protection f 91 M 672 795 lis pendens lOOS 206 65M , 45 cancellation 121 261 797high degree s 100 S 278 98 M f 98 M 42 ordinary care 185 869 14 . 918 80 1 nonsuit 3 lOOS t 114 revers. error 121 823 128 266 practice 201 NY 357 804 pers. injury d 69 M . 213 inadmissible 141 204 libel 216 NY 179 827 cond. precdt. s 100 S 251 148 62o ineffectual do 148 . 627 jurisdiction - 163 920 830 corroboratn 100 S 202 149 733 assumption 150 787 834 advance s 100 S 241 payments 143 102 838burden proof s 100 S 367 163 761 legisl. power 93 M 244 fix rates 95 M 688 850 allegations 100 S 231 164 730, 731 856 directors s lOOS 249 r 186NY 215 857 countercl'm s 100 S 283 132 89 859 ooservant lOOS 269 123 805 nee. incident 155 841 865 accounts 8 lOOS 206 64M 632 reference 123 418 177 454 54M 632 868 accounts slOOS 61 M allegations 80 M must plead 168 226 276 756 slOOS r 190NY 807 signals 3 lOOS do 116 ' contrib neg 52M suit 239 623 650jiiry question 3 99S 115 654 gambling s 99 S 1007 153 513 761 tax pr .» lOOS 3 123 rewards ,66M 1100 a 19 AC 834 766competnt ev. s 100 S 279 151 360 90 126 659 judgment 9 99 S 1077 f 132 948 666 liability a 99 S 994 do 146 253 276 310 ev. 235 182 571 194 632 886 trust mtge, s lOOS 624 r 187NY 307 ■T 890 mandamus e lOlS 858 » 186NY 1 r 188NY 185 mandamus s 116 912 900 ptnrs. debt case 3 s lOOS 1161 construe will a 190NY 649 case 5 3 lOOS 1149 a 188NY 637 901 contract case 26 3 lOOS a 188NY certiorari case 25 s lOOS a 187NY case 20 s 100 S injunction s 192NY 1123 663 1137 645 1151 678 902 rescission case 6 lOOS a 188NY parties case 1 9 lOOS r 189NY assessment case 11 lOOS al86NY 1106 609 1104 169 1137 585 641 227 771 restriction 8 100 S 187 172 204 317 178 740 19 AC 28n private contcts. 218 NY 344 3 1 3 contract s 100 S 267 a 190 NY 512 814 tax costs s 100 S 172 s 100 S 267 139 205 316 sp. prfmce. 3 lOOS 167 57M 442 821 carrier neg 5 lOOS 190 a 191NY 101 824competnt ev- s 100 S 185 lOOS 54 M reference 186NY jury trial 61M show fact 150 108 burden proof t 164 208 105M 21 87 1 oiScial 9 iOOS 200 126 339 874 r. r. law 8 100 S 175 133 149 903 foreclosure guaranty ase 16 IOOS a 189NY partition case 16 IOOS a 190NY express trust 73 M 420 construction 73 M 420 case 19 a IOOS 1122 120 107 forfeiture lOlM 620 1105 624 1119 331 883 assesst vd 284 301 11 SlOOS 130 141 assessment «3 M f 93 M 141 compliance 141 serve notice 91 M 286 insufficient 99M 390, 391 lOOM 432 904 deposition cape 11 s IOOS 115 atty's lien case 15 s IOOS r 187NY report case 7 s IOOS a 188NY case 3 SlOOS 186NY contract Case 6 IOOS * 189NY case 7 186NY 237 1140 149 1106 28S 1133 550 1106 584 1135 233 233 698 30 609 905 case 13 s IOOS a 186NY case 15 slOOS r 187NY case 16 s IOOS a 1S6NY 1141 537 1105 1 1141 637 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, c, •riticised ; I, limited ; e, explained ; distinguished o, overruled ; •. same case f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; ».?'»''; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, questioneo N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division Vols. 114, 115 531 1127 906 will decree case 3 * 187NY a lOOS case 4 s lOOS a 193NY case 10 B 100 S m 188NY warranty case 13 B lOOS al88 NY pers. injury Case 11 s lOOS r 189NY case 5 s 100 S r 188NY contract case 15 slOOS a 193 NY 1126 653 1109 115 1121 637 1145 294 1149 416 s lOOS a 189NY case 10 law action 1003 1138 529 1139 912 easement case 4 larceny lOOS a 186NY case 15 a 188NY waiver Case 14 3 lOOS 8 121 case 3 chose action 69 M 371 covenants d 69 M 1136 413 581 1124 691 373 1128 670 907 water Co Case 2 s lOOS m 189NY case 3 damages s 100 S a 192NY easement d. 67 M dSTM 908 nuisance case 14 s lOOS m 189 NY jurisdiction 122 1110 ■323 1139 660 629 630 1127 40 1110 39 1114 1132 498 1118 186 dam 391 543 1147 570 case 1 s lOOS a 189NY bond case 5 s lOOS case 15 s 100 S al89NY death neg. case 4 s lOOS r 191NY 909 death case 2 s lOOS a 186NY case 8 s lOOS a. 187NY 910 negligence case 1 s 99S 1136 r 188NY 13) revers.error Case 2 s lOOS 1145 a 189NY 568 91 1 performance case 11 3 lOOS 1146 a 188NY 644 stk. pledged case 18 slOOS a 188NY assessment case 17 s lOOS a 187NY accoimtinjK case 12 s lOOS al88NY indemnity Case 1 SlOOS r 190 NY fire insurance Case 4 1106 633 1133 562 1146 583 1151 41 sp. performance Cases lOOS 1140 r 189NY 481 pers. injury case 9 lOOS a 18SNY Case 13 s lOOS a 189NY. constitutional 68M 434 921 foreclosure case 9 s 100 S 1151 r 190NY 121 1141 564 1143 574 913 sate case 7 3 lOOS a 188NY appeal case 13 3 looa faw action 59M trustee 201 NY jury ti'ia] d 152 201 NY lis pendens 57 M preference slOOS s 120 a 188NY 915 tax bank stk case 10 3 lOOS r 18SNY appeal case 12 3 lOOS * 187NY reargument case 13 s lOOS s 118 street use case 1 s99S r 190NY . contract caie 7 3 lOOS a 191NY authority do 136 1104 552 335 334 510 147 nil 214 584 1136 1 1149 533 1119 680 1049 84 184 918 insurance Case 2 3 lOOS a 189NY C3S9 3 s xOOS a 188NY pers injury case 13 conspiracy 3 lOOS 1123 r 190NY 371 917 commiasins 1123 567 1148 640 lOOS al89NY 919 appeal case 16 3 lOOS 187NY 1130 527 1127 529 920 mandamus case 6 s lOOS 1134 a 188NY 617 tort damages Case 7 s lOOS 1140 3 120 468 141 74 499 16 17 261 386 17 VOL. 115 I overflow 3 lOOS d 61M damages e61 M 65M 103M 106M apportionment 103M 216, 217 duty court 106M 7 7 estoppel defense s IOCS 504 75M 250 1 2 negligence 3 100 S 497 133 469 J36 366 8 1 meas. damage 3 100 S 673 66 M 264 prospect, profit 74M 110 84 good will slOOS a 196 NY el21 s 126 135 f 170 e 60 M f 92M 92 M basis of f 161 89 ejectment 3 100 S 641 a 191 NY 515 no violation 15 s lOOS f 182 569 882 1 7 will legacy 3 lOlS 853 a 188NY 25 25 tax sale s lOOS 616 a 187NY 279 repeal 124 67 131 197 37 conversion s lOOS 588 a 190NY 505 40 Contract 3 lOOS n 190NY damages dl42 error court 78 M 142 173 669 510 218 271 851 688 509 645 647 648 value 82 150 devise 129 no trust £133 in trust do 133 174 equity 144 769 702 693 690 33 163 I 02 assume risk 3 100 S 679 120 264 198NY 101 use greater care 347 638 for jury 152 459 assumption d 152 459 1 04 reargument s 100 S 677 6 119 481 42 contract 3 lOOS 596 a IflONY 514 44 neg. damagF 3 lOOS 593 aigiNY .526 limit liability f 130 700 distinctioif 130 700 do 145 578 51 defense s IMS 11 12, 115 58 discrinlination 137 163 duty carrier 82 M 40 court relief 225NY 406 64 conveyance 3 lOOS 597 a 188NY 566 69 water rates 674 579 286 729 34 732 624 643 100 s 100 s 115 gas price a 188NY just rates e 122 626 661 215 106 appeal 3 100 s 188NY damages 121 demurrer 124 213 US pleading 124 misjoinder 60 M 150 allegations 63 M 182 false represns. 132 290 71M _ 584 state negligence 142 404 duty landlords 152 460 correct error lOSM 271 1 1 2 injunction 3 lOOS 711 fll5 114 115 476 478 I I 8 app'I dism 3 100 S 71" mandamus r 186 NY 203 s 115 21!- 71 pers injury s 100 S 663 a 191NY 547 dismissal 147 137 78 pers. injury 3 100 S 665 a 191NY 248 one cause 155 534 126not recover s 100 S 696 f 173 153 1 35 prejudiced s 100 S 712 f lis 214 appeal 3 187NY 532 572 recovery a 189NY res Itv d 123 804 breach vendor 129 510 141 juryquestion 3 100.«1 731 116 249 120 65 412 assumed risk 147 137 146 impropparts 3 100 S 739 3 124 129 151 bill partic. s 100 S 681 156 382 lOOM 172 156 accounting 100 S 687 ■■ 191NY 196 services f 90 M 88 168 requests lOOS 737 117 522 report findings 1 17 622 1 72 amendme nt s 100 S 681 131 80 132 113 d 155 400 terms costs , ICP NS 246 68 M 135 full costs f 158 486 !73 forf-closure < lOOS 722 a 191 NY 201 1 80 judgmt s 100 S 766 f 128 926 no limit 78 M 46 1 96 review law s lOOS 93T 147 104 damages 1588 316 205 trsnafer tax s lOOS 917 r 188NY 274 21 I notice s lUOS 843 e 119 48 49 136 846 knowl. i-ule 133 719 dismissal do 133 728 218 electn law lOOS 927 a 187 NY 327 mandamus f 164 252 61 M 512 one cause 155 534 226 frd. transfer 3 100 S 1037 123 748 *191NY 503 231 good 100 S 172 I 74 discovery lOOS f 115 116 118 f 119 122 123 127 f 163 e 521tt f 53 M 96 M 704 537 862 855 763 797 817 209 544 642 535 57 38CP 35,72, 327. 373 163 814 637 401 38 OP practice 118 120 121 construction 53M uecess ev, 123 816 819 liberal rule 124 3 necessity 28AC 190n right absolute 39CP order case 11 f]42 006 full examinan 147 57 take deposition t 97 M 461 176 courts pwr. "i lOOS 763 f 60M 558 lis pendens f 165 864 1 77 indefinite bequests s 100 S 681 142 81' intestacy f 99M 99M 444 44S will 779 559 234 covenant lOOS 970 53M 454 incumbrance 18AC 415n 421n restriction title 18AC 418d estoppel 81M 222 241 lease s 101 S a 193 NY 217 635 247 lien realty' s lOOS 800 a 191NY 539 254 conduits s lOlS 55 a 18SNY 523 mandamus 69 M 201 f 140 934 201 NY 328 revocable licen'e d 201 NY 332 264 constructioa s lOOS 903 m 187NY 454 irrevocable 69 M 203 269 100 s 219 NY 913 83 278 money loand lOOS 878 a 188NY 568 286 limitations 3 lOOS 976 .%M 578 motion 136 938 distinction 171 408 more certain 184 574 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; I. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; c, criticised ; 1, limited ; e, explained ; o, overruled ; s. same case : do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, questioned Vol. 115 N. y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division 295 order » lOOS 808 a 187NY 543 incuiabrance • 18AC 415 •aarketability 172 204 317 299 prob. cause B 100 S 893 S6 M 1 307 sup pro. a lUO S 965 s 19 AC 165 reaigumeat 132 748 discovery d 67 M 548 same judge 150 579 310 ccounting slOO S 993 a 187 NY 641 expense exr 136 ■ 519 definite issue 73 M 194 revision 74M 541 323prescrintion elOOS 911 120 691 330 structure e 100 S 777 £ 122 753 pub. nuisance B 19 AC 153 limitation 95 M 7 333 by-laws B 100 S 888 money haa a 190 NY 511 337 authority 9 100 S 881 parol evidence 126 821 138 37 145 721 342cov euants s lOOS 1029 62M 452 rule waiver 1S8. 317 not recover 167 45 171 481 84 M 130 strike out 99M: 362 346 disbarment s 101 S 507 a 188NY 49 350 practice B lOOS 807 S4M 651 default S6M 460 motion 134 501 354masteradutv s 100 S 898 125 687 scaffold S95NY 422 20 AC 201n not liable 20 AC 162n 362 discontinue « lOOS 781 132 246 53M 647 84 M 117 conditions 63 M 520 366 demurrer s lOOS 943 a 187NY 544 teacher contract 54M 608 125 803 ly-law duties 67M: 190 powers 150 410 £ 219 NY 262 94 M 457 reduce salary f 159 278 160 267 377 assignment 3 lOOS 891 a 190NY 539 380right action s 100 S 818 96 M 504 385 knowledge s 100 S 783 70 M 497 338mutuality s lOOS 960 a 190NY 1 122 348 unilateral 127 525 not binding 69 M 628 rescissiou fl45 24 intent parties 75M 129 powers 85 M 626 "promise" 170 720 no obligation f 177 240 177 626 396 assignment 3 lOOS 035 a 188NY 564 400 dismissal s 100 S 907 S2M 495 403 bill pa'rtic s lOOS 786 121 870 146 469 182 237 405 alimony s 100 S 865 120 354 165 7_ f 177 240 separation 20 AC 28 contempt f 177 83 20 AC 301 410 abandomnt s 100 S 698 s 19 AC 171 f 133 881 f 141 oS2 68M 46 105M 419 proof burden e 139 ' 363 cond. precedt. 68 M 292 spl. proceeding 68 M 292 insufficient ev 151 519 413 partnership s lOOS 869 al88NY 238 429 usury slOlS a 188NY 65 108; 238 448 revocation s lOlS 680 f 178 150 453terms appeal s lOlS 386 124 ^ S23 amendment* 131 80 terms costs ICP NS 246 review 67 M practice f 168 288 458 assessment s 91 R 395 alOlNY 527 47 \ amendment s lOlS 435 127 557 475 contempt s 101 S 464 8 115 478 479 appeal s 101 S a 19 6 NY 470 52 488 rule s lOlS 371 117 278 281 492 courts pwer s 101 S 455 do 192NY 395 one judgment 159 800 499 amendment s 101 S 320 s 19AC 291 140 543 145 140 166 744 not amend 174 217 442 409 92 502 costs a 101 S B 19 AC not apply 98 M injunction 181 172 509 no cloud s 101 a 413 133 279 516 contracts s lOlS 399 116 202 522 reovery s lOlS 418 r 190NY 24 bankruptcy s 132 279 537 discovery 3 lOlS 411 56M 436 390P 72 538 new trial s lOlS 374 s 126 687 s 149 678 f 126 691 149 679 partnership s 145 228 145 230 do 153 870 rulings do 145 234 inadmissible 78 M 403 incompetent 184 883 549 contract s 101 S 454 155 580 injunction d 155 583 damage relief 96 M 41 552 liabiUty s lOlS 402 54M 601 city Ddg. d 128 464 128 465 not liable 182 813 81 564 order slOlS case 12 f 115 905 change venue * 187NY 556 174 619 566 res ipsa 1 . 8 lOOS 1012 118 573 d 53M 570 568comiiussir42order case 5 3 106 S 553 f 149 923 247assume risk s 101 S 631 d 72 M 85 252 compensatn s lOlS 611 118 123 173 26 30 damages 131 713 138 823 d 173 255 chose action 69 M 371 lot numbers d 69 M 372 iueouitable d 142 896 relate back 144 704 right award fl59 865 83 M 468 pers. property 102M ■ 36 title vested 224NT 207 257 contract a 101 S 726 9 193 NY 678 limitation 64 M 475 competition 84 M 160 26 1 nuisance lOlS 616 f 116 269 liability 74M 449 . 269 title 3 lOOS 634 18AC 417n forfeiture 140 321 274 construe will lOlS 651 a 188NY 296 do 147 803 presumption 126 289 285 neg. damags. 3 lOlS 467 a 192NY 550 289 pers. inj. s lOlS 505 1, 197NY 522 291 estoppel s 101 S 602 f 98 M 294 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished e, criticised ; 1, limited ; e, explained ; o, overruled ; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed- n, note- s, samenase : do, diasentine opinion ; p, parallel caie ; q, qautkmcd' Vol. 116 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division 295 judgment » lOlS 568 Case 9 120 876 30 1 direct reply s 101 S 138 171 discretion 142 91 M 98 M reply necessary 152 708 152 709 SI M 232 302 exam.officer 526 468 608 466 233 43 I lOlS 119 examination 125 discovery 64 M dl58 eflicer corp. 390P 587 764 S3S 466 702 86 306 deficiency s 101 S 476 95 M 714 315 change ev. B IMS 510 B 125 552 tangl. proof 131 480 320 employee 350 378 61 41 812 S-IOIP 118 liability act 118 132 noti ce claim 120 prerequisite 121 notice neg. 121 eontrib. neglii 147 136 72 M 392 error court 132 380 eond. prcdt. 135 235 mot applicable 136 317 no variance 138 258 327 fd. transfer a lOlS 481 a 191NY 530 33 1 dismissal s 101 S 678 MM 6£ 349 encroachmt. a lOlS 574 220 765 power court 149 477 alteration do 174 79 M ewner bldg. do 157 submission dl58 tost removal 158 538 restoration 159 842 177 408 structural repairs 174 689 353 constitutl, t lOlS 606 S8M 434 362 waiver s 101 S 845 693 155 571 537 20 AC 284n 366 venue s lOlS 892 122 741 137 755 145 198 367 appeal s lOlS 893 s 116 _ 378 revocation a 188NY 584 rem, one trustee 137 672 surrogate's pwr. 137 571 sale stock 156 liability 95 M removal lOOM 237 82 379 labor law s 101 S 562 t 116 397 constitutional a 189NY 131 period rest d 163 626 police power d 163 629 unconstitutional 163 621 397 demurrer 3 lOlS 1011 55M 410 presumption 123 . 600 rule pleading 123 501, do 502 ejectment r 191NY 452 voidable 66M 32 404 ultra vires lOlS 1027 case 11 e 11 886 65M 113 4 I 4 foreclosure 9 101 S 832 a 194 NY 600 allegation 149 858 discretionary 79 M 366 pleading 154 633 justified 93 M 448 451 423 jury trial 828 249 140 322 23 478 121 s lOlS 160 57M divorce 3 19 AC 76M no waiver f 160 64M acquiescence 145 850 by the court 73 M 17 425 justified 3 lOlS 814 118 799 manslaughter a 189NY 520 homicide 19 AC 325 437 sale lien 3 lOia 980 e 121 837, d 838 442 contract 3 lOlS 938 r 192NY 42 445 meas. damg 3 lOlS 948 123 505 61 M 334 452 relief s 101 S 1021 129 476 457 title realty s lOlS 995 m 191NY 361 462 prob. cause s 101 S 737 86 M 18 473 title parties 3 lOlS 812 117 408 477 eontrib neg 499 power 481 292 805 519 990 62 659 42 68 slOl S fl29 164 £ 168 220 NY d 220 NY 482nec. parties 3 lOlS 986 191 NY 207 118 812 125 738 practice 122 387 487 duty chauffeur 1 175 860 s 101 s 1000 d 97 M 613 495change venue s lOlS 769 C 116 499 500 recover rent s lOlS 1034 aigONY 546 220 NT 177 res judicata 61 M 633 94 M 244 no assignee 136 864 conclusive 149 ,567 507 prox cause s 101 S 938 r 193 NY 322 not excessive £ 94 M 711 5 1 2 construction 204NY legislat. 204NY recovery 104M not liable 104M 292 f 185 918 530 amendment s 101 S 810 131 80 132 113 terms costs ICP NS 246 532 rulings 3 lOlS 133 vesettle 117S 631 535 coniient rule slOlS 602 a 191 NY 556 126 843 141 739 consent 225NY 153 539 assessment lOlS 595 a 191NY 534 not final 125 341 542 mech. lien lOlS 801 a 191NY 549 enforcement 72M 546 lienors 186 337 544 court power 3 10 IS 128 156 204 NY jurisdiction 141 absurdity 94 M 1037 5 732 480 630 326 516 forgery 3 lOlS 1016 a 188 NY 591 knowledge f 98 M 564 5 1 8 remove exr, s lOlS 776 3 118 484 additional ev. 80 M 24 522 damage 3 lOlS 124 jurisdiction f 119 204 NY 204NY recognition 74M 952 82 756 479 5U2 536 court of law 583 probate a 101 S 882 a 189NY 503 594 for jury s 101 S 961 140 709 602 equity 101 S 867 89 M 229 consideration 98 M 68 613 parties s 101 S 925 140 20 const: tutional d 73M 379 6 1 8 damage 101 S 938 s 198NY 467 645 scrutinized s lOlS 977 66M 404 651 eontrib. neg. s lOlS 956 case 7 do 122 899 657 death neg lOlS 59M contempt 127 do 142 proof default 185 537 726 465 545 estoppel 101 S 709 £ 86 M 640 549 damages s lOlS 928 do 146 883 157 789 constitutional 307NY 613 555 damages 3 lOlS 966 r 189NY 163 em. domain 3 189NY 537 558 judgment s 101 S 914 131 922 563 costs trial 968 612 154 27 323 973 slOlS 54M 135 153 56 M new trial 150 f 171 discretionary 79 M 369 79 M 370 568 good faith s lOlS 878 103M 78 573 privilege s 101 S 846 9 19 AC 343 172 832 854 discovery 168 144 f 171 construed 172 974 836 slOlS a 193 NY liability 149 996 616 520 171 828 665 books papers lOlS 992 a 188NY 649 proper remedy 83 M 322 669 admr. bond 3 lOlS 920 a 192NY -591 677 em. domain 3 lOlS 1047 a 190NY 468 legislative do 147 330, 513 163 12 good faith 147 320 691 chge. grade lOlS 1073 a 188NY 370 696 rehearing s lOlS 433 66M 2 disqualified 161 53 704 chose in actn 1104 455 371 722 retroaction B 101 S 1110 130 547 not retroactive 131 640 trust estate 138 837 726 marketable s 102 S 43 19 AC 378n title perfect f 91 M 446 729 certiorari 3 102S 6 a 189NY 652 assessment £ 213 NY 12 153 725 737 abbutter tel s 102S 34 66M 137 rural easements 140 211 740 equity suit 9 102S 112 s 123 713 823 26 89G 704 s lOlS 58H 69 M damages 131 ISB 173 inequitable dl42 relate back 144 right award f 159 865 equitable lien f 169 827 assignment 17B 30 715 commission 3 102 S 14 131 613 143 454 no recovery 137 693 74M 398 jury question d 138 557 procuring cause 143 464 proximate cause 143 465 fact question 154 687 d 154 688 719 sp> perfmnce ---IS s 102! 64 M 20 418 902 664 509 253 443 S102S case 3 f 122 causeaction 129 79 M . complaint 129 68^ separate causes 138 259 152 203 175 409 surpluspige TOM pleading 201 NY 442, negligence 141 98M error dismissal 152 203 796 mark title s 102S r 188NY 798 appeal s 102S r 189NY award 9 123 conclusive 140 47 75 749 order S102S case 11 f 116 924 53 M 396 396 no condition 155 749 756 insurance 102S 164 122 488 758 prox. cause s 102 S 223 143 11 763 resid. estatf 102S 258 a 191NY 605 construe will 127 132 772 meas. damg. 3 102S 8S 123 contract a 192NY d 215 NY pleading do 160 special 179 605 656 106 167 damage 691 777 damages s 102S 25 a 192NY 64f stet, constctn 137 228 waiver 213 NY 6 780 contract S102S 27 a 191NY 541 indefinite term 78 M 382 787presumption s 102S 91 54M 398 cancel deed a 193 NY 638 burden deft, t 138 73 79 1 no lien sl02S 80 M 18 687 793 order case 3 834 15 378 22 34 710 340 801 legis. judge £ 163 12 804 jurisdiction slOlS 1106 do 125 789 courts duty e 61 M 424 police officers 68 M 444 807 distribution 102S 232 do 125 201 t 134 167 815 certiorari s 102 S 72 M 816 void s 102S lOOM 8 1 8 report . 102 S a 194 NY 1 414 106 563 181 617 829 pld. damage il02S 139 158 436 832 negligence s 102S 395 d 136 816 d 165 621 174 341 181 100 reason, care d 138 366 liability 145 657 839 nonsuit ° 102S 363 56M . 600 direct verdict 67 M 403 merit proofs 145 .2',^ ' 'upon merits note; ABBREVrSTIONS : a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; c, criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; i, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, questioneo N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division Vols. 116, 117 80 M 844 powers s 102 S 402 217 NT 490 S49 damages s 102S 385 *190NY 619 129 81 854 discovery 324 817, 828 208 544 74 717 436 57 461 894 8 102S 123 127 f 163 180 f 180 56M 96 M right affidt 129 order f 136 right absolute do 87 M 296 compliance 147 57 commissions f 80 M 645 take deposition f 9711 461 855 practi-e s 102S 277 do 127 342 defenses do 133 364 not reviewable' 76M 47 denials 129 16 158 500 858 phys. exam ■3 102S 123 859 waiver sl02S 138 inequitable 79 M give notice 178 276 653 461 861 b. panic, s 102 S 306 116 893 863 Kame law s 102S 362 * 192 NY 542 865 serv s 102S 119 publn 306 68n 162 449 memorandum 175 708 admissible 175 709 885 civil service s 102S r 188NY order case 6 E116 325 489 927 887 atty client 102S 209 p 121 612 890 constitutnl, 104M 227 892 bill partic. 3 102S 463 126 38 127 901 147 639 179 440 896 partition s 102 S 130 149 equity 71 M adverse 210 NT 481 180 202 278 claim 465 909 appeal case 1 167 pers. injury case 5 s lOlS a 191NY case 7 3 lOlR 1 188NT summons a 189NY 1117 516 1115 636 511 869 cross action s 102S 124 estrictions 134 f 161 178 99M enforcement 134 covenants 147 title do 159 estoppel 181 mutuality 103M 874 warranty 299 661 212 101 429 352 610 42 102S 121 130 137 76 M a 191NY 342 372 566 736 529 527 880 present prices s 102 S 449 910 contract case 14 3 lOlS 1147 r 191 NY 400 stare decisis 3 133 626 money had case 2 3 lOlS 1139 a 188NY 541 tax basis 16 case 15 lOlS a 191NY surety liabl case 12 3 lOlS 1147 116 33 1148 617 1117 516 913 contract case 7 3 lOlS a 191NY case 6 3 101 S a 187NY joint answer 135 253 reinstatement 143 20 a 189NY 499 contract case 24 s lOlS 1140 a 191NY 635 case 1 s lOlS 1120 a 191NT 562 918 appl. case 13 3 lOlS 1123 189NY 541 new trial case 9 s lOlS 1146 a 190NY 649 920 fraudcase 12 s lOlS 1144 a 191NY 532 921 serv. casfc s lOlS 1129 r 190NY 132 fraud case 2 3 lOlS 1150 a 191NY 631 pers. inj. case 3 s lOlS 1123 a 191NY 634 attys. lien case 17 3 lOlS 1140 a 190NY 516 damages case 5 8 lOlS a 193 NY 929 injunction case 12 s 102S 1149 a 191NY 562 930seciLre costs case 1 s 101 S 1105 146 825 have order 160 appU'^ation 161? 1119 622. 922 incident case 1 3 101 R 1137 a 188NY 478 pers. inj. case 4 lOlS 111 a 190NY 551 chat, mtg case 9 s lOlS 1133 a 191NY 541 abortion case 14 lOlS a 192NY penalties case 10 s lOlS a 192NY death damage case 2 s lOlS 1134 a 196 NY 514 1138 531 1112 538 923 death neg. case 2 s 101 S 1119 a 190NY 548 refer claim case 4 s lOlS 1121 a 191NY easement 3 133 823 pers. inj. case 4 lOlS 1121 a 191NY 515 I judgment 1139 s 198NY 646 924 damages case 7 al02S 1142 a 191NY 53 279 9 1 4 transfer tax case 14 lOlS I 124 a 189NY 561 partition case 5 s lOlS 1142 .190NY ' 552 bill exchange case 7 s lOlS 1148 1 192NY 560 usury law 166 16 9 1 7 accounting cases 3 101 S 1148 926 pers. injury case 10 s 102S 1136 a 191NY 653 927 reinstatment case 6 s 102 S 327 r 1S8NY 623 928 electric r. case IS S102S 1141 al89NY 428 injunction case 8 s 102S II 38 a 191NY 5081 VOL. ri7. 5 "meal" s 102 S 37 157 440 f 163 462 direct verdict 165 346 burd. defendant 185 123, 124 2 1 contract s 102S a 191NY 27 misjoinder lOlS 1088 f 117 31 170 518 amendment 119 333 137 399 34 were essentl. s 102 S 9 157 669 affidm defense 157 671 171 554 inconsistent 157 671 admitted do 180 537 39 jurisdiction dismissal do 158 97 services s 102S a 191 NY 336 645 107 judgment 3 109 S 1146 f 124 , 939 122 41 167 370 66M 100 copy trade mrk 149 543 regulate use name 109 848 f 169 849 ,,„ .. ,. 1 78 accounting 1 10 atty. hen g io2S 271 fl?2S ,,,???!» 189NY 600 ^ V-l„,, 117-119'revocation a 191NY 544 65 M 68 641 slOlS 125 motion 163 1061 374 907 93 628 40 murder 3 102S alOlNY constitutional 59iVI 362 at trial 133 172 error cured f 173 403 50 pers. injury 3 lOlS 1076 a 191NY 543 127 802 56 estoppel 3 lOlS 1093 t 66M 215 conclusive t 124 132 f 163 381 authority 77 M 50 not binding 152 751 not conclusive 79 M 349 uot adjudication 177 510 62 taxation sl02 S a 188NY taxable 151 66 oral lease 85 551 768 8 102 S 131 contract 135 102 776 496 77 order s 101 S case 5 f 133 inspect books 69 M 71 80 mandamus 1108 890 s 102S a 188NY 137 Qd'] . issue do 137 validity ■151 242 361 812 appeal S188NY jurisdiction 189NY 458 presumption 209 NY 365 1 1 7 attys. lien case 2 s 102S 373 a 191NY 544 corpn. check case 1 3 102 S 373 1 18 attys. lien 8 102S 373 a 191NY g 544 1 1 9 appeal 3 102S 191NY 374 644 125 covenant 3 102S 334 r 189NY 61 lis pendens 126 757 129 discretion 8 102 S 276 144 412 secure costs 146 626 130 check procds 3 102S 60 r 192NY 61 1 5 1 misjoinder s 102S 35& 73M 455 154 extend time s 102S 374 a 188NY 549 s 123 330 no reversal 212 NT power Co. court 172 444 aet aside verdct do 184 843 1 60 not limited s 102 S 400 60M 460 163 sp. prform 3 102S 313 60M 469 jury calendar 179 641 180 64 judgment case 3 139 929 trust lapsed 155 127 revocale 158 792 f 85 M 293 presumption 92 M 321 185 weight ev. s 102 S 302 149 668 review loS 869 new trial f 172 13 196 intent steal s 102 S 289 133 616 206 covenants S102S 2 a 191NY SI 136 269 f 171 568 e 85 M 417 repairs L29 634 171 570 f 171 570 f 85 M 416 215 title realty 8 102S 122 a 191NY 533 award s 67 M 193 244 atty. client sl02S 143 contract 182 12 181 327 168 game law 3 102S f 117 U9 f 117 penalties r 193 NY do 193 NY jurisdiction 86 M 349 171 909 481 486 170 ! 3 102S 119 ame law 351 818 /72 injunction i 102S 309 248 damages s 102S 330 Case 1 f 120 876 251 amendment right 381 818 868 38 3 102S 118 173 matter 147 practice 78 M 34 not adjudicata 163 219 distinction 176 838 255 demurrer s 102S 279 a 189NY 501 stkhldrs actn s 124 610 267 amendment s 102 S 327 19AC 300n 269 presumed s 102S 413 137 438 discharge judg. 137 439 notice 185 606 .^. ABBREVIATIONS! a.afKrmed; d, distinguished; t. followed; r, reversed: m, modified; *. dismissed; n, note; c •ntiCTsed, 1. limited; e, explained; o overruleil: i. same esse; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case: a. auestionedr Vol. 117 N. ^. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division 284 limitations s 102S 317 a 191NY 446 292 damages 8 102 S 162 a 196 NY 576 not review 185 489 294 guardian s 102S 211 a 190NY 522 P 117 301 additional ev. 80 M 24 305 damages s 102 S 190 d 130 327 liability 213 NY 258 316 criticism s 102S 78 136 392 318 no conflict 370 burden plff s 102 S 478 166 43 374 election s 103S m 188NY 379 waiver a 102 S 134 85 M 89 M 96 M discretion £ 173 38! assignment 3 102S 616 a 191NY 512 387 neg. damags s 102 S 153 135 381 321 life insur. s 102S lOSM 168 518 1 102S I92NY no liability 136 ,395 s 102S case 4 f 125 325 appeal s lOlS 1065 s 118 913 * 189NY 606 328 no knowldge s 101 S 1067 133 B9 332 abrogation s 101 S 1056 61 M 473 enforcement 175 753 336 appeal s lOlS 1070 a 189NY 555 authority 134 21 em, domain 69 M 375 340 interventn, s 101 S 1045 f 169 556 343 billpartic, s lOlS 1043 f 164 213 d 56M 333 348 mandamus s lOlS 1039 122 620 157 330 infer motive 125 540 discovery 142 754 inspect books 145 428 no relief 149 82 352 recovery B 103S 1125 a 192NY 546 justified 155 512 agency fact 183 298 357relief caes 3 s 103 S 177 138 922 360 gift c mortis S 102 S 236 f 62 M 152 7oM 59, 60 f 85 M 297 taxable 92 M 324 672 217 499 155 658 868 order f 131 933 only complaint 173 678 472 contract s 102 S 690 a 193 NY 621 475 preference 3 102S 704 120 383 150 670 notice nee. 63 M 379 when made 66M" 230 notice 185 804 477 interest 599 182 604 922 102S 120 153 award a 191NY 185 authority 185 732 687 401 relief s 102S 188 NY presumption lOlM 51 102M 41 purchaser burd. lOlM 47, 48 4 1 1 requisition 3 102 S 878 a 1S9NY 124 power of governor 211 US 471 habeas corpus 211 US 474 425reas. excuse s 102S 596 ICP N3 257 publication 486 inspec books 102S 636 126 815 488 impress trust s 1028 707 a 191NY .544 limited 170 456 493 cloud on title 571 164 102S 3 192NY true ground 133 acceptance C9 M 20 AO 229n 428 prom, notes s 102S r 191NY 432 larceny 3 102S r 188NY 630 69 758 167 438 trial police s 102 S 666 130 714 449 life insurnce s 102S 722 a 192NY 546 455 insufficient s 102S 544 148 47 pleading f 166 2 458 judgment 3 102S 729 case 6 f 124 920 462 compet. ev 3 102S 714 120 49 a 188NY 673 470 amendment 3 102 S 026 128 695 162 394 176 601 construction do 128 69 527 demurrer 8 102S 564 59M 270 forn. judgment 195NT 523 court power 136 260 judicial notice 71 M 77 M 87 M 534 not actionable 102 S 161 785 612 768 437 732 502 construe will 3 102S 592 a 191NY 579 vested 199 NY 464 gifts absolute 199 NY 464 no suspension 156 65;i not suspend f 89 M 200 trust fund 184 801 505 judgment s 102S 648 a 192 NY 588 f 120 172 vendee f 119 f 120 192NY rescission 192NY equity lien 132 lien 872 89:i 847 87, lis 132 331 519 findings 3 102S 117 118 appeal 3 18SNY contract r 192NY practice 192NY 130 requests q 191NY letters admr. lOP NS a 613 387 330 622 113 11 644 339 525right transfr s 102 S 647 f 166 739 I 524 10 433 685 720 539cond. precedt 102S 776 128. 541 63 M 370 right rebate 134 465 468 burden proof 67 M 527 546 conviction 3 102S 678 a 189NY 517 f 202 NY 624 pub. health law 122 842d 843, 127 383 162 290 practice med. 163 massage 10211 553 award s 102S 124 185 revocation 138 559 order sl02S f 117 213 408 162n 391 318 136 168 213 NY 19 AC 19 AC f 63M 70 M f 86 M 90 M allegations 131 occupier 60 M not liable 149 additional ev. 148 682 duty care 153 want care 163 no dismissal 90 M 691 689 335 626 519 , 215 212 600 costs s 102S 127 137 603 extortion 303 103 667 473 548 s 102S f 145 a 190NY OM business 146 corroboration 391 unlawful 213 621 affidavit 884 562 102S a 188NY f 117 elections f 117 election law f 124 563 discretion s 102 S 611 144 412 secure costs 146 625 572 conclusion s 102 S 60S 144 519 burden plaintiff 76 M 634 complaint 76 M 634 allegation 165 409 575 defective s 102 S 60S 82 M 303 576 serv process s 102 S 642 r 189NY' 241 serve process 140 368-370 jurisdiction d 120 737 do 126 761 138 471 non negotiable q 153 563 79 M 619 583 jurisdiction s 102S 774 171 475 56M 195 588 jurisdiction s 102S liability 124 t 153 153 f 86 M 220 NY nuisance 857 167 210 215 35 295 790 367 53 579 863 537 452 864 851 685 629 637 918 628 affidavit s 102S 845 a 188NY 586 do 117 62S do638 election law f 124 918 637 election law s 102S 856 a 188NY 686 f 124 919 643 cond prcdt interference lOOM 603 686 cause action 952 885 689 442 sl02 S 121 m 188NY legal title 134 unsuitable per. d 142 457 construction 155 472 ■4M 309 justification do 155 474 690 nee. parties 182 42 698 burdn proof s 102S 808 119 441 construe will m 191NY 2,54 65M direct gift do 149 authority do 149 test validity do 140 128 charit. trusts 70M 120 next kin f 177 843 222NY 229 presumption 223NY 611 793 obatn .d.lm 426 129 130 ell02S 192NY 8 102 S 130 restitution 145 pleading 75M: equities 206 NY rescission 180 no cause 182 549 324 17 251 13 535 326 659 indemnity 8 102S a 191NY surety 132 recovery 164 67 1 injunction 915 501 77) 934 208 131 78 3 102 S a 189NY 198NY franchise d 213 NY plfif's. powers 213 NY 79 mandamus 138 241 for private use 154 406 ultra vires 775before court B 102 S 983 93 M 604 782 retaxation s 102S 1012 * ISONY 519 restitution «6M 455 costs 66M 572 788related back 3 102S 1087 120 755 57M 641 retroactive 170 399 791 imp. remks. «102S 1089 19 AC 460n 1060 551 1098 762 747 S!72 739 stranger 102S 957 102M 134 742 for jury 102S 912 103M 71 749 presumepyt s 102 S U8] 123 44 82 M 640 83 M 185 752 open def'lt s 3 02S 1037 136 6 754 contract 3 102S 1025 a 192NY 557 756 unenf orciblt s 102 S 1079 157 517 762 guaranty 8 102S 1042 a 190NY 555 incompetent ev. 134 128 limitation 81 M 340 consideration 221NY 441 768 award 3 102S 977 r 190NY 235 int. damages . 172 646 99M: 329 773 damages 3 102S 1010 d 55M 260 nes. cits f 118 89' surface water 132 19 notice not. nee. 800 option 8 I02S 126 162 mul uality 61 M action fails CM 78 807 transfertax 103S 6 m 189NY 288 81 I superseded 104M 237 817 brokerage 103S 305. 126 609 820 restitution 3 102S 1013 122 28, do 30 825 magistrate) s 102 S 980 71 M 867 826no jurisdictn s 102 S 988 d 166 607 831 complaint s 102S 1000 e59M 7 rule pleading 126 404 demurrer do 127 157 nullity 84 M for jury 182 395 burden proof 182 295 f 164 64 M diligence f 165 liability 671 409|181 343 256 38 836 causes distinct s 102S 844 140 266 f 162 20 838 resipsalog. 3 1028 1039- 123 689 jury question 123 8" 127 222 151 161 159 273 damages 61 M , labor law 134 238 safe system 123 617 material da'y,, 136 544 co mplaint note; 641 dismissed ; ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; >, o'^misscu ;",■•---; r, criticised ; I, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, difsl nting opinion; p, parallel case; q. quesuuu N. y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division Vols. 117, 118 157 283 case 2 's 102S 1134 841 nuisance 'a. 193NY lis s 102 S 1046! 168 551 910 injunction case 4 842 misjoinder « 102S 5SM 126 a 127 150 allegationo 129 irrevocable 132 joinder 71M repugnant 71M pleading d 180 complaint d 184 1039 390 390 266 643 583 584 536 102S a 193 NY fraud case 1 s 102S a 195 NY case 2 sl02S sll9 119 case 5 S102S • 192NY 1144 641 11S6 548 1149 373 375 1127 590 a 191NY prom, note case 9 s 102S a 191NY accounting ase 12 3 102S a 191NY assessment case 2 102S a 192N Y rent case 4 8 102S a 193 NY 843 Pers. injury s 103S 1130 al90NY 56«|ai9"lNY defect street [counsel fees 913 death neg. case 3 3 102S 1135 a 190NY 659 sp. prfmance case 11 3 102S 1143 404 d 163 172 09 M liability 140 142 52 493 837 131 advs. claim 131 340 damages case 4 849 liability 8 103 S 266 8 130 268 854 not binding s 103S 296 134 133 quantum meruit 1 164 695 856 revocation 8 103S 275 r 189NY 18 permit 122 765 882 penalty s 103S 370 119 62 146 466 interloc. judgt Case 8 f 128 890 rights parties 76 M 567 884 sum pro. s 103S 371 a 189 NY 555 serve notice 88 M 491 covenants 213 NY 521 intention 213 NY 524 887 neg damase 8 103S 368 r 190NY 294 890 intention s 103 S 446 f 84 M 474 898change venue s 102S 962 57 Jl 359 127 69 904 insurance case 1 s 1G2S 1127 r 193 NY 323 908 pers injury case 3 s 102S 1134 a 191NY 535 damage case 1 8 102S 1138 a 191NY 543 ante nuptial Ij 339 1135 553 1145 58e 1127 547 507 1127 546 1148 548 1133 578 1147 664 923 pers injury case 10 3 103S 1134 a 190NY 481 deposit case 4 3 103S 1129 a 191NY 529 compliance s 136 518 924 case 2 172 244 s 102S a 191NY wages f 180 ] 914 certiorari case 1 3 102S a 188NY case 10 sl02S a 192NY 91 6 pers injury case 3 s 102S 1144 a 193 N^ 663 9 1 7 extrinsic ev. Case 5 3 102S 1137 r 190NY 35 death neg case 2 1 102S 1133 a 190NY 548 i-.ase 12 s 102S 1147 a 190NY 556 f 140 838 .-ervices case 1 s 102S 1149 a 194 NY 551 168 272 918 death damge case 5 3 102S 1136 case 13 s 102S 1135 a 191NY 503 not liable p 140 45 9 1 9 divorce case 3 3 102S 1126 a 193 NY 638 case 4 s 102S 1150 a 192NY 555 921 contract case 17 3 102S 1150 a 191NY 423 case 14 3 102S 1137 a 191NY 538> 922 undertaking case 3 3 32S 1132 J VOL.118 I suspn alien, 3 103 S 307 136 785 57M 258 one trust 63 M 604 lupport will 76 M 427 trust valid 164 839 expectancy f 164 474 ionstruction 177 572 105M 277 intent do 177 575 suspension 102M 653 6 nullity 9 103S do 133 appeal do 135 incident 137 Icbt disjharged !4l 197 10 fact questioo 4 103 S 262 126 304 three verdicts do 126 313 13 transfers i 103 S 310 123 536 88 M 25 88 M 99 90 M 678 subordinate 67M 83 3Jection d 86 M 214 d 90 M 675 1 6 reverse error 4 103S 369 123 167 rescission 179 336 439 588 801 644 20 recovery s 103 S 273 a 191NY 551 vol, payment •-'00 NY 576 23 power sale s 105S 240 •» 197NY 869 25 mandamus 3 103 S 617 f 164 251 a 189NY 509 denial insuf, 137 authority f 164 249 27 stock s 102 S a 193 NY 1029 626 123 29 appeal 3 103S reversal 122 703 receiver 132 851 osts 141 sa.'i 32 good title 5 103 S 17 125 766 oers. property 125 769 convereion a 193 NY 22 d 217 NY 669 173 783 fixtures 62 M 484 ICP NS 268 election 165 871 62 M 34 waiver 132 99 file mortgage 70 M 464 file contract 14C 788 estoppel 103M 78 40 appeal s 103 S 1 a 192NY 547 118 47 preference f 159 585 170 353 must prove 170 353 47 appeal s 103 S 139 a 192NY 547 50 services 102 S 1093 a 191 NY 560 proof do 185 767 56 damages 3 103 S 61 3 19AC 453 improper remks. do 157 108 64 judgment case 3 s 103 S 150 f 127 941 r 193 NY 634 attorney's lien champerty •>.0 AC 178n 89 partition 102 S lUl9 r 190NY 458 76 guaranty s 103 S 127 a 191NY 545 f 177 823 contract 83 M 28 80 amendment 3 102 S 1066 a 189NY 542 131 80 136 592 f 170 614 s 19 AC 441 f lOOM 143 mistake 56 M 349 38 CP 28 amend parties 19AC 308n 309n terms costs ICP NS 21S court powers 70 M 24 86 limitations s 102 S 1053 131 125 self operative ICP NS 296 91 bill partic. 3 103S 12 153 156 382 f 56M 332 lOOM 172 94 insurance 8 103 S 70 188 NY 643 a 192NY 86 situs debt 125 549 100 good title a 103 B 129 125 765 iterest ceased 185 266 (05 enforcemt, s 103 S 14 140 627 f 170 695 1 07 constructn, s 103 S 137 83 M 239 I 09 decree 3 103 B 118 probate 129 partition 197NY uphold will 170 97 M 92 injunction s 102 S 1017 119 855 10 195 553 1 17exrapt taxn. 3 103 S 180 192 NY 466 assessment 62 M 536 set off 178 655 title vested 224NY 207 1 23 services s 103 S 333 a 192NY 553 127 demurrer 3 103 S 480 a 189NY 600 invalidity 182 464 i 30 lienf und 103 S 312 sec, Larties 19AC 184n estoppel f 84 M 888 legal title d 179 11 nee. parties 179 12 143 binding s 103 S 631 90 M 563 1 55 inference ev 3 103 S 134 129 567 1 60 consolidatn 103S 5 133 742 153 253 10211 366 costs d 102M 355 162 discovery s 103 S 13 56M 43 fi 63 M 67 S2 M 403 170 brokerage s 103 S 25 8 19 AC 463 1 77 quo. warm to 3 103 S 146 a 188NY 618 bond 126 220 181 new trial s 102 S 1033 Case 11 f 123 923 decision s 135 175 1 86 revival 3 102 S 1105 a 189NY 543 (90 relief court s 103 S 63 61 M 155 premature 169 658 undertaking 93 M 323 194 renewals s 103 S 20 119 499 construction 121 21 contract r )92NY commission 87 M 394 197 pers. injujy 3 102 S lO.M a 192 NY 403 205 no duress s 102 S 1051 86 M 24 f 167 192 threat to sue f 164 175 170 746 waiver f 167 756 extension 10511 673 208 inclosure 3 103 S 156 a 192NY 221 213 fiduciary 3 103 S 125 67 M 260 215 fund appl. ■< 102 B 1047 60 M 620 221 appeal s 103 3 160 a 194 NY 315 224 damages 3 102 S 311 120 902 149 931 title 132 930 confirmation 198 NY 2S8 award 137 632 227 actual dam 3 103 S 456 d 130 141 248 rule transfre s 103S 486 133 856 54M 269 f 121 908 reasonable rules 73 M 464 2561ibsl per se s 103 S 496 do 138 ."(OS 171 105 construction 165 6 259 forgery s 103 S 393 69 M SS."* sale realty 202 NY 486 discretionary AliliREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *. dismissed; n, note; C criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled: a, same case; do, diissenting opinion; p, parallel c^se; q, questioned Vol, 118 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — ^Appellate Division f 172 757 263 replevin s 103 S 490 a 193 NY 622 272 taxes rue 5 103 S 441 54M 322 appeal * 189NY 512 compet. ev. 56M 318 rule damages 58M 611 market value 130 354 1S9 bC5 Rtrct. value 198NY 8C (lo94 erroneous tlieo. 66M 501 award 66M 510 281 preference B 103 S 648 288 oreference" s 103 S 547 118 289 insolvency r 192NY 183 299 ct. vn limit 8 103 S 463 128 677 300 contract s 103 S 381 a 192NY 655 tender 129 533 recovery 132 27 304 contract 3 103 S 621 a 195 N"X 530 320 jurisdiction s 103 S 410 120 12 do 166 662 B 193 NY 645 practice 130 644 accounting a 195 NY 509 135 10 87 M 52 letters admr. ICP NS 337 title exr. 138 165 joinder 166 657 allegations 95 M 46 138 258 ground denial 25 815 347 neg. master, s 103 S 351 126 165 coservant neg. 127 845 "av question 1 oo 334sp. prfmnce s 103 S 353 s 193 NY e 342 spl. procdg s 103 S 505 124 130 autliority 198NY 286 nullity 161 619 judgment t 161 620 before court 93 M 604 345 bill partic 8 103 S 433 120 390 121 658 137 622 142 71 159 582 172 892 1 181 950 56M 433 no variance ' 128 784 liability act 132 377 detail worls do 133 . 916 accounting 134 707 not applicable 136 317 compensation d 141 902 assume risk 147 772 216 NY 588 common law 136 42 356 commissns i 103 S 377 r 193 NY 644 interpretation SO M 504 364 misjoinder sl03 S 50 142 418 Dleading f 181 77 368 appeal 8 103 S 403 s 193 NY 645 assume ri^^k 195 NY 510 jurisdiction do 166 662 378 constru wil 3 103 S 391 r 190NY 128 91 M 664 compensation 142 , 737 389 disavowal s 103 S 482 73 M 804 412 indorse! 3 103 S 684 a 192 N if 499 432 carrier neg. 3 103 S 1065 r 192NY 203 446 change ev. 3 103 S 516 126 655 burden proof 128 133 449 no gift s 103 S 499 19 AC 239D 143 864 452 not liable s 103 S 861 146 581 455 rescission s 103S 265 76M 189 457 authority 8 103 S 258 132 118 custody f 132 939 459 plead anew s 103 S 439 69 M 331 discretion in ct. 148 780 83 M 579 sell for cash 156 10 4S3pers. injuries 8 103S 1078 a 192NY 654 error court 136 358 employee 174 358 176 133 benefit 177 57 468 construe will s 104 S 4 r 191NY 166 valid trust 68 M 257 482 trust fund s 104S 29 65M 402 construction e 155 472 74M 309 justification do 155 474 490 subscriptns 8 103 S 607 a 194 NY 616 ■stockholders 105M 715 497 estoppel 8 103 S 339 143 868 499trade name s 103 S 362 f 160 618 5 1 1 conviction s 103S 249 118 913 a 1S9NY 408 52 I certificate s 102 S 1112 * 1S9NY 522 131 509 510 do 611 612 528 excise subm 3 102 S 1070 a 194 NY 560 53Rjuryque8tion S102S 995 f 66M 684 death neg i 191NY 506 superintndt 134 636 61M 509 detail work 129 506 instructions 144 348 547 inj. servant 8 102 S 993 8 19 AC 433 equitable relief f 92 M 713 550 pers injury 8 102 S 991 a 193 NY 637 553 pers injuries 3 102 S 1008 a 191NY 564 555 safe system 8 102 S 1037 123 611 assume risk e 123 618 iudffment f 121 929 neji. master 126 scaffold 20 AC 202n 153 407 d 221NY d 221NY 239 241 566 jury ques. 8 103S 508 136 668 567 call loan s 103 S 189 f 159 50 571 insolvent s 103 S 158 145 834 set off 186 665, 669 not an asset 186 668 579 inquiry s 103 S 631 f 159 826 benefit finding 164 309 585 judgment s 103S 535 s 134 907 estoppel 149 803 593 burglary s 103 S 186 a 190NY 54:0 597 salaries s 103 S 340 163 436 605 stkholders 3 103 S 34 a 189NY 600 equitable action 146 31 35 debts assets 62 M 79 valid claim ICP NS 101 liability 137 425 153 121 178 597 excuse cmplnce. 185 433 6 1 I compet ev. s 103 S 343 d 125 248 145 691 633sp"pprtmce s 103S 612 * 196 NY 502 s 124 248 641 easement s 103 S 805 m 192 NY 255 652 forgery 103S 627 a 190NY 61 rules of ev 67M 603 662proper party s 103 S 678 119 387 better practice 149 727 order f 173 962 665 dam. control 3 103 S 641 r 192NY 200 meas. damage 79 M 165 678 construe will 3 103 S 779 a 190NY 657 usepub lie 193 NY 453 taxation 66M 121 charity had 694 580 685 money 8 103 S a 192NY princ liable 129 evade liability 155 514 8 103 S a 196 NY 161 objections 138 89 M 327 793 forgery s 103 S 903 a 189NY 528 800 forn judgt „„ 6 103 S 681 309 59 M 636 reargument 132 893 mandamus 671 568 629 561 699 performance s 103 S 050 142 469 7 I I title realty s 103 S 659 a 194 NY 647 construction 168 575 723 game law s 103 S 434 119 319 733court power 8 103 S 620 s 120 208 a 190NY 551 parol ev. 137 277 vesting 157 61.5 742 title vests s 103S 740 d 66M 390 authority do 149 130 trustee 76M 86 gift- direct do 149 128 cannot take 168 520 validity 98 M 169 756 direct verdt. 3 104 S 12 122 624 99 M 14 contract a 192NY 54] distinction 75M 502 M 16 ultra vires 156 S47 right of action 99 M 15 recovery 99 M for jury 222NY 270 17 766 principal 8 103 S 870 133 616 772 mandatory s 103 S 849 70 M 530 t 84 M 40 commission 153 887 f 93 M 66 777 sp. perfmnce s 103 S 8"" 8 191NY 784 insurance 8 103S 638 r 193 NY 142 118 789 789 resettlement s 103 S 902 119 169 748 810 court power 3 103 S 667 191NY 207 practice 122 38? amend, parties 138 126 19AC 308n 815 pleading 118 B 103S 826 deceain 39 CP 164 no election 39 CP 165 accountable 153 719 conspiracy f 97 M 78 joinder f 174 786 822 pleading 8 103 S 840 124 733 827pleading s 103 S 837 118 829 24 734 accountable 153 719 839 interpleader 8 103 S 680 133 235 t 177 60 f 93 M 184 840 reimburse s 103 S 692 34 M 86 845consent nee. s 103 S 710 139 183 successors 139 183 850 courts oraer 8 103 S 674 8 121 672 discovery 121 879 122 797 137 578 examination 8 126 835 presumption 130 136 material ev. 134 219 pleadings 147 120 858 good faith s 103S 695 119 232 transfers 121 583 54M 643 penalties S f 55M 205 207 208 d 192NY 366 ' 'aggrieved' do 5SM 209 862 public nuis ance 3 103 S 1000 a 189 NY 561 152 378 152 875 177 378 865 asBcssment s 103 S 908 a 189 NY 508 tenant fixtures f 213 NY 36 69 M 301 142 686 damages 165 200 869 status corpn s 103S 688 138 529 532 71 M 392 396 statute controls 71 M 9fi f 2ip NY 219 relioriouik corpns. 7133 97 statutory f 80 M 465 separate bill 86 M 583 charter 167 589 f 177 790 874 assessment s 103 S 1069 120 204 exemption do 136 44 legisl. power 73 M 334 profile map 77 M 481 881 assessment 103 S 748 a 192NY 562 888 void gift s 103 S 520 r 193 NY 446 cbarit. uses 193 NY 455 beneficiary 62 M 156 89 1 appeal case 1 8 103S 1122 131 110 896 judgment Case 9 103S 1130 o 129 918 o 129 918 898 contract case 9 s 103S 1124 a 192NY 653 case 10 s 103S 1124 a 195 NY 579 a 196 NY 580 901 judgment case 12. 8 103 S ll34 t 118 901 903 contract case 8 s 103 S 1124 alOlNY 550 904 negligence case 2 3 103 S 1119 r 191 NY 476 906 contract ease 11 103 S 1140 . 191NY 651 case 10 103S 1141 . 193 NY 621 foreclosure case 8 103 S IHO . 191 NY 555 case 6 103 S 1120 insurance ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguislied C criticised; 1, limited: e. explained: o. overruled ; f, followed; r, B, same case; do, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, notfl dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, questionea N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — ^Appellate Division Vols. 118, 119 B 139 a 189NY case 7 s 103 S r 189NY 66 100 1138 1U4 907 encroachmo i case 5 s 103 S a 193 NY case 6 1141 29 s 103S, 119 case 9 sl03S a 189NY 909 practice case 20 s 103S 130 accounting a 195 NY case 23 sioas r 188NY 1126 •84 3133 VOL.119 I appeal s 103 S ft 190NY f 162 162 marriage void f 93 M 260 invalidity 177 165 894 524 601 603 12 duty master s 103 S 932 132 035 142 nonsuit 135 1125 644 510 720 910 appeal case 3 sl03S 1121 r 191 NY 49:- Case 5 s 1U3S 1116 s 189NY fiSf new trial a 193NY 64n comity case s 103S 11?fl r 192 NY 376 9 12 conveiRion case 9 s 103S a 193 NY do 184 112 667 186 913 validity act case 9 S103S rigONY equitable case 12 slOSS 8 144 1150 406 1151 826 916 contracts case 5 slOSS a 192 NY 1124 579 9 I 7 appeal case 3 S103S sl32 Case 9 S103S * 189NY 1142 640 17 sp. prfmance. 3 103 S 94B a 192 NY 589 vested remaindr 152 748 162 269 20 salary SlOSS mv. 61 M 618 1150 416 damages 132 not liable i 90 M 329 56 judgment s 103 S 963 ( 127 924 partition r 193 NY 423 3 135 705 s 149 213 6 1 penalties s 103 B 951 55M 106 cond. arecedent 76 M 564 64 Quan. meruit s 103 S 862 123 681 compensation 61M 119 restriction TOM order £ 143 entirety 74M 8 1U4 S a 190NY dol51 securities 133 134 pledgor pledgee 138 902 control stock 157 319 1 1 9 transfer tax s lOOS 850 sl04S 115 a 190NY 527 power court 44 913 395 836 66 lien 3 103 H 22 carrier neg. -^8 CP 8 103 S 998 .1 59 M 37 reverse ev 128 867 ordinary care 128 867 jury question 134 630 24 demurrer s 103 S 960 do 129 182 libl, consctn 132 400-1 30eq. conversn. 8 1U3 S 930 139 301 32 pers. injury 3 103 IS 867 alOlNY 511 lor jury 30 AC 144n 35 gi'i- in trusi. 3 103 S 946 19 AC 244n trust deposit e 144 416 f 92 M 348 trust absolute 530 321 108 47 74 allowance 207 NY 482 81 accounting 3 103 S 970 155 175 not partner f 86 M 304 82 cond. precdt. s 103 S 1068 68 M 292 abandonment 152 69 88 ordinary care 3 103 S 1002 123 721 63 M 202 88 source knowl. 3 103 S 1038 131 £ 165 92 M. 124 1 13 conversion 153 authority 103M 130 order a 103 S f 119 mandamus a 189NY payments 143 sped 172 88 975 879 324 franchise 130 931 926 151 im 92 M [irrevocable 1146 ^55 '^*° delivery p 92 M 918 conversions ease 6 3 103 S 1145 a 191NY 392 per. injuries case 1 3 103S a 190NY case 4 s 103 S s 123 1142 256 1131 113 919 oontrih cai-e 2 9 103 S * ISONY case 3 SlOSS r igONY aeg 1116 127 38 judgment case 6 3 103 S £ 137 89 neg. damage s 103 S 852 r 191NY 152 9 I recovery 3 103 S 886 a 193 NY 625 96 gestation s 103S 943 946 144 285 presumption f 175 111 1 34 reargument 8 103S 962 s 105 S 1124 Case 4 a 120 897 136 employers s 103 S 1047 163 178 138 assume risk 973 137 576 a 103 S 125 68 M reversal 137 safe place 163 321 1 40 discovery s 103 S 868 95 M 423 425 143 suit on bond 8 1U3 S 881 a 191NY 368 146 not apply ■-• ~ 151 236 189 bankruptcy s 104 S 247 195US 621 196 at will 8 104 S 671 £ 87 M 392 203 courts power 8 104 S 452 125 775, 776 214 mecb, lien 8 1U4 B 653 3 122 611 payment 73 M 899 notice lien 76 M 591 cond. precedent 165 711 contract price do 172 90 novation i 98 M 330 file assignment f 221NY construction do 221Ny i: 223 penalty 3 104 S a 192NY 302larceny {do 161 538 a 104 S 725' 172 924 925 120 388 i 173 123 incompetent £ 96 M 99M 517 692 104 S 72 M 'fraud" 1,58 96 M voidable 102M 371 484 233 larceny 8 104 S 647 a 194 NY 554 presumption 166 842 236 abduction 9 104 S 539 * 194 NY 556 238 judgment s 104S 661 f 134 962 f 162 44 240 accounting s 104 S 6U9 a 192NY 90 245 conversion 3 104 S 6: a 193 NY y_' extra fees 20 AC 189n 27 I mandamus s 104 S 649 a 189NY 550 repeals do 135 672 implied repeal 151 611 315 injunction 8 104 S 334 r 194 NY 359 326 scrutiny s 104S 402 181 233 331 subp.d.tfc'm 3 104.S 698 166 943 61 .VI 80 36 1 appeal s 104 S 319 a 189NY 544 d 64 M 378 366 remedy exclusive s 104 S 251 153 283 f 164 131 368 indorser 8 104 S 217 3 130 2, 10 fraud vitiates 165 215 332 ministerial 104S 236 376 parties peim. residence s 105 S 976 J 36 480 d 121 628 169 909 64M 391 recovery 336 chnge venue G5M 380 sl04S 230 allegations 135 732ido 140 683 141 42 complaint 1 148 748 339 demurrer [better practice s 104 S 202 149 727 r 193 NY 666 party defendant Corp. pleading 131 04 presumption 165 392 maintain action 25NY 52 libel 42 order Case 3 103 S f 119 injunction 61 .M 134,136 1 I reargument 853;sl03.S 1136 897 Case 1 120 J jury question 1 23 628 150 , 186 liability act 125 135 936 896 47 dismissal 3 103 S Sl.f do 133 133 tioiice 136 1118 43° 860 720 719 ;i26NY 344 conviction SO M 304 pers. judgment 180 836 competent ev. 185 187 1393 priv.easmts. Ti 104 S 128 3 lot a 277 120 33? assault a 191NY 533 350 condemnatn 3 104 S ■/M 121 835 dismissal a 190 N i' 528 duty award 130 H,52 market value 130 3.59 161 55 92 M 422 543 48 355 practice cbtains S104S TOM. .severance 102M 39 277 atty. client Is 104 S 571 169 bonds stoo ' r 190NY 66 358 abrogation sl04S 152 f 123 681 3 101 S 244 401 injunction ■i 104 S 462 >i lt2 NY 490 4 1 fire in.sur. 3 104 S 434 a 193 NY 639 construction t 161 18 426 bill partic. s 104 S 699 146 2 defenses f 168 966 430 misjoinder 3 104 S 683 124 734 „., 80 M 551 ooi pleading 54 124 730 misfeasance 168 98 M 676 a 192 NY 586 103 remedy mtn ■i 103 S 942 127 80C) 104 accounting 3 lOOS 862 182 846 3 104 S 112T s 104S m 189NY 202 186 51 eviction s 103 S 935 107 practice 184 contingent 30 AC 264n3 94S 1082 a 104 S jl30 044 do 123 53 collateral letters admr. notice 103 S 865 ICP NS 336 126 176 ir 435'jurisdiction 1168 173 1 72 constitutnal 8 104 S 260 a 192NY idem Honans 127 estoppel 84 M 175 pleading 3 104 S 233 123 421 geni denial 131 8 227 816 169 464 793-4 787 280 recordg. mtg 8 104S r 190NY 643 323 exemption 126 284 assault s 104 S 1S9 NY 727 526 514 294 not waived s 104 S £ 91 M 513 422 295 agency 3 iu4 S 123 injunction 121 f 86 M distinction ig8NY perform'c 185 457 153 spec. "IM 121 ijiadmissable 138 discovery 122 124 128 137 142 149 specify act 131 discretion 131 ICP NS material ev. 134 219 153 ICPNS prove issue 140 natural ev. n25 144 f 169 material 637 e 182 185 432 show defect 3 104 S 440 129 731 defect patli 145 196 not liable 644 140 480 629' reasonable care 317; f 86 AI 334 577| "unusual" T52'97 M 370 20'J| 437 prob. cause 3 104 S 155 02 M 127 !69 281 i77 588 440 survival 3 104 S 147 63 M 228 65M 424 burden proof 65M 426 tnust prove f lOlM 354 445 pers. injuries 81G!s104S 72 'a 192NY 65 ABBREVIATIONS; a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, not« c. criticised ; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, quationed Vol. 119 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — ^Appellate Division duty warn f 97 M 450 lien B 104 S 128 612 judgt 327 642 4t)2 not a bar s 104 S 17.-; f 158 814 464 civil service s 105S 950 a 190NY 375 reduction salary 190 NY 382 472 mandamus B 104 S 92 58M 288 478 pleading 5 IB new trial s 104 S do 121 vendee lien 192NY order 124 order 124 645 life insur 174 a 104 S 928 118 B10 3S 1026 126 19 practice do 127 342 defense do 127 343 do 133 364 den'als 129 16 158 500 state separately 157 721 f 162 468 482 limit devise B 104 S 153 484 title s 104 S 130 140 fee 163 21 272 052 175 688 905 907 a 189NY valid order 132 666 deft. B 104 3 72 M 5 1 8 reargument s 104 S 164 Case 7 B 120 896 520 right trans. 104 S 219 M 98 521 misjoinder s 104 S 323 do 166 662 complaint 166 657 parties affected 99M , 369 dividends 103M 92 536 preference s 104 S 143 154 296 542pers interest 54 714 186 447 457 pay 257 529 679 reference 104S 134 682 imp. S104S do 157 296 774 remks 421 106 685 foreclosure a 104 S U9 689 Order sl04 S r 189NY 350 927n 303 558 45 702 163 s 104 S 162 547 devise 8 104 S 129 equity 144 ladies 169 560 subacrlptio.'i 698money judgl s 104 S 29 140 633 damages 105M 3i 701 discretion a 104 S 684 s 128 674 704 robbery s 104 S r 190NY reversal do 151 f 158 95 669 138 689 487 deatb neg. s 104 S a 190NY 493 sure s 104S 134 interpretation 103M 195 496 construction s 104 S 214 121 21 502 receivers s 104 S f 125 do 125 r 189NY new trial do 121 enforcement f 166 issue stock 178 sl04S 68 M 503cling. s 104S 106M 506 order s 104 S f 119 venue 144 f 168 509 waiver s 104S 103M 1136 477 venue 275 74 177 897 60 261 273 149 513 discovery s 104 S 1 123 817, 828 127 209 f 163 544 551V1 436 full examinatn. 147 57 515 authority s 104S IfiS 76M 74 86 M 199 not bound TOM 76 69 68 26 617 48n 277 597 67J 43; 7(i4 40 709 defense 104 S 665 169 90 7 1 3 assessment 71 M 512 570 master neg s 103 S 1063 66M 132 labor law 19 AC 209n 573 cond. prcat s 104S IOC do 135 662 no waiver 135 741 inadmissible 148 773 compliance f 91 M 579 allegations d 102M 463 586 neg. damage B 104 S 39 r 190 NY 198 notice filing 133 402 618 neg. damags s 104 S 37 a 191NY 548 622 revocation s 104 S 26 a 190NY 523 revocation 73M 546 638 new trial 8 104S 222 19 AC 4S7n impr- remarks do 157 10(1 3 104 S a 190NY 716 equity 104 S 214 NY 719 murder s 104 S a 190NY new trial 91 M 723 award a 104 S m 193 NY 164 556 752 written order 104 S 640 f 163 67 755 damages B 104 S 275 124 82 services 190NY 542 right to sue do 73 M 511 legisl. power 204NY 481 757 exemption s 104S 568 m 105NY 143 761 liberal rule B 104 S 523 124 37 106M 200 privilege 19 AC 349n 363n 140 525 irregularity 150 222 amendment 176 841 180 717 (Bxamination 106M 202 785 void contrct BI04S 541 191 NY 470 illegal void 130 165 maintenance 136 51 767iury question s 104 8 637 125 854 777cause action 143 dismissal f lOOM 830 report j 104 S i 189NY 175 349 130 466 f 171 93 M 782 order 104 S a 189NY records 104M 786 indorser S104S 418 r 194 NY 461 422 518 342 544 794 strike out 734 admissions s 104 S 1 88 M 717 736 mech. lien 3 104S 137 a 197NY 529 costs 78 M 66 738mech. lien a 104 S 3 s 120 904 cond. precedent 79 M 50 performance f 90 M 396 740 inad. price 3 104 S 179 121 795 validity 205NY 449 743 manslaugbtr s 104 S 166 a 192 NY 577 749 mandamus sl04 S 556 a 189NY 560 construction ;i04 S 129 demurrer 134 759 106 740 892 S47 335 mandamus 104 S 922 a 189NY 649 339 reviewable s 104 S 896 134 217 discretion 144 412 841 convlctiun i 104 S 872 a 189NY 562 843 judgment 3 105 S 1013 130 902 172 893 encroachment 69 M 228 lOOM 600 [347 pleading i 104 S 898 58M 34b amendment 144 861 93 M 683 power court 145 139 150 41 856 pavements a 1U3 S 1146 r 190NY 29: competition 67 M 215 865 death damgp case 15 s 105 S 111 r 190NY 444 master neglig. case 19 s 103S 1151 a 193 NY 188 872 order case 10 a 104 S fll9 reargument case 9 S104S sl20 lax law case 6 104S r 195 NY 874 salarj- caae 8 3 104 S a 189 NY a 191 NY 1151 505 869>P-Prfmance case 7 case 18 « 104 8 s 103S 1122 al92NY 556 871 maodamu? case 9 8 104S 190NY 1137 518 1124 895 1123 893 1123 . 204 1130 602 506 663 886 mandamus case 2 si04S 1122 a 189NY 659 888 habeas cor- pus cas0 1 sl05S r 193NY a 105 3 a 189NY atty's. lien case 18 s 105 S r 189NY 866 vacate order case 7 s 103 S a 189NY certiorari Case 1 s 103 S a 189 NY forfeiture case 3 s 103 S a 192 NY 1138 609 875 charge err (.-ase 11 sl04 S II3.T . 192NY 172 sp. performance case 2 104S 1131 194 NY 376 876 damages case 11 104S 1148 a 193 NY 667 378 contract case 2 s 103 S 1119 59 M 610 salary a 194 NY 595 879 ejectmt.dam case a s 103H 1134 a 192Ny 552 882 assessment case 2 s 104 S 1133 a 189NY 551 compensation 130 . 526 public easement 112 590 797 damages sl04 S 702 a 195 NY . 137 proofs parties 145 536 variance 165 560 cond. precedent 103M 214 808 innkeeper 104 S r 193 NY new trial 181 87 G 397 867 sp. prfmance case 8 B 103 S 1130 a 190NY 556 infringement case 13 s 103S a 192N Y frd grant case 9 s 103S a 194NY 817 jurisdiction s 104S 935 do 179 374 825 scrutiny ev.i a 104 8 120 140 e 167 atty. client s 124 rerequisite 887 73 640 827 67? 1119 560 1126 600 1128 m 193 NY 67 illeg. arrest case 6 s 104S r 193 NY case 1 s 104S prom, note a 193 NY 1143 272 1134 1133 6G6 1137 546 1140 422 1137 231 1105 417 889 permit case 4 s 105S 124 case 11 s 106 S contract 190 NY 890 biU partio. case 9 ■i 106 S 1130 119 881n referee report case 5 3 105 S 1119 a 189NY -552 transfer tax case 4 3 105 S r 190NY services 1139 492 118 70z 383 724 103 519 868 mandamus case 6 a 103 S a 189 NY contract case 1 sl03 S a 191 NY covenant sl03 S a 192 NY life insurance case 2 s 103S 1143 a 194 NY 520 1138 559 1126 514 case 3 1144 584 196 NY l31 183 damages do 131 t 160 award 197NY extinguishment 163 173 153 174 private easemt. 160 83 173 37 f 216 NY 12 883 appraisal s 107 S 543 190 NY 671 vested 160 808 B84 wild animal rase 3 3 101 S 191NY abatement 3 134 contract case 1 s 104S 192 NY case 2 s 105 S 191NY 894 filiation case 3 3 104 S a 190NY answer case 12 s 104 S a 190NY 1139 519 1122 524 1124 523 898 mandamus case 1 3 104 S 1137 a 189NY 508 898 (ncrcachmi s 104S 1139 a 193 NY 661 910 leinstatmt. )S8 1133 21 543 112 586 885 ^P- prfmnncf 3 104S r 190NY 9 1 3 appeal case 9 104 S 189NY spec, prfmce. m 192NY 162 assessment :aae I 3 104 S r 190NY case 3 s 104 S a 191NY judgemnt case 5 3 105 S 190NY 9 1 4 appeal case 11 1127 540 1137 284 1137 600 1149 530 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished: (. followed: r, reversed; m, modified; *. dismissed; ". ■"" c. criticised; 1, limited: e. explained ; o. overruled ; s, same case: do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q, quesiiom N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — ^Appellate Division Vols. 119, 120 8 104S * 189NY ejectmenL case 9 ■ 104S a 192 NY nj unction case 6 s X04S a 193 NY damages case 3 8 104S a 193 NY 1127 923 new trial 546 s 104 S 1149 r 59 M 231 1124 681 1131 683 1135 07" 915 insurance case 7 8 104 S 1150 r 200 NY 320 9 1 6 sp. prfmnoe case 5 E 104S 1137 a 193 NY 639 9 1 7 certiorari Case 6 8 105S 113S r 189NY 521 proper writ 179 394 pers injuries case 8 s 105S 1149 a 193 NY 616 reargument C.I se 5 s I05S 1109 a 193 NY 682 ep prfmance ci-.&e 10 s 105S 1129 a 193 NY 676 gas fixtures case 7 s 105S 1106 a 194 NY 576 9 1 8 injunction ease 10 s 105S a 193 NY case 9 s 105 S expenses 138 825 waste dam s 104 S 551 a 193 NY 197 927 pers. injuries case' 13 8 104 S a 192NY case 4 8 104S 192NY rape case 11 s 104S a 193 NY 928 life insurae ase 5 1104 8 1 190NY contract case 6 s 105 S 192 NY 215 NY damages 210 NY ase 3 104S 1148 r 195 NY 550 Dbgligence case 7 s 104 S 1151 1144 341 419 9 1 9 damages case 4 s 105 S r 193 NY contract case 2 s 105S a 193 NY pers injuries case t s 105S 1119 a 193 NY G50 920 pers. injury tase 1 s 105 S r 192NY patents (.ase 3 s 105S a 194 NY lllL 11 1138 642 lUi) 179 1150 272 921 pers.injuries case 4 s 105S 1145 a 193 NY 61P 922 death damge caoC 7 s 105 S a 191NY contract case 1 1 s 105 S a 192NY goods sold case 6 8 105S 193 NY Mil 502 1148 559 1138 551 1132 677 1136 607 I damages s 104 S s 129 error charge 129 recovery 135 deft, not held 143 452 6 affidavits 8 104 S 138 discretion 79 M objections 79 M discovery 155 1149 546 1148 419 104 125 s 104 S 120 lOOM 250, lOOM termination 155 authority 103M ] 16 not liable s 104 S £ f 173 173 86 M 220NY 153 case 10 s 105S i inONY al!)2NY 507 1114 520 540 VOL. 120 160 505 836 418 court 66 68 1 temp. admr. 832 760 251 633 611 615 747 326 656 ( 93 M d 95 M 97 M •39 611 357 20 conviction 3 104 S 946 a 190NY 541 162 290 onus proband! 7 9 M 459 29 practice 3 1U4 S 1009 124 492 not binding d 134 132 too indefinite f 217 NY 229 no contract 178 242 £ 173 243 36fact question 8 \01 S 991 57M 622 sole judge £ 89 M 420 tl20 93 95 93 forecloaur? s 105 S 120 95 95 judgment 074 963 827 1 104 S f 124 iniendment 125 order case 5 f 126 mandamus 161 not legislative ■ 163 433 99 cancellation s 104S 1047 221NY 281 102 default int. 3 106 S 38 170 559 59 M 569 tender good 128 145 construction 162 311 1 10 delivery 3 105 S 53 r 193 NY 203 1 19 protection 799 132 mandamus 138 reversal 138 240 239 179 consent 3 104 S 1005 152 641 185 objection 8 104 S 1084 91 M 196 1 89 contract 3 lOoS 78 a 198NY 629 192 error char'e s 105 S 90 143 8 not liable 166 838 u "105 S c 190NY l99accouating 105 S- 122 135 jurisdiction 125 relief 137 168 M 223 739 10 704 3 1U5S 120 damages r 194 NY contract 129 iut. proceeds 144 754 305 205 116 671 473 superior court I205NY 224 Istate facts Il52 826 discretion £ 215 NY 584 201 assumpsit, s 105 S 315 m 192 NY 459 use old street 13 1 183 799 264 trust 9 105 S p 120 pl20 revision trust r 191NY 33 27 1 construe will 125 271-n 272 139 560 217 273 decree a 105 S a 190NY ' 'principal 97 M commissions f 98 M 49 personalty 186 325 275no presmptn 105 S 160 f 84 M 354 improper f 216 NY 569 278 easement 8 104 S 1106 a 193 NY 667 foreclosure 153 724 287 posthumous s 104 S 1090 130 866 do 8BS d 124 234 130 866 19 M 643 distribution do 126 200 vested remaindr 481 eminent domain 8 145 866 134 penalties 3 105 S 258 d 192 NY 374 limitation 06M 423 over charge 81 M 209 f 86 M 441 right transfer 2 1 1 money paid £ 88 M 98 144 discovery 721' 152 207 no stay I s 105 S 188 do 135 907 145 201 s 104 S 124 146 pleading 125 ;inswer 146 796 656 435 653 436 1 47 mandamus i2 indictment I" \'}*^^ ^%^ 3 104 S 805 a ISONY 565 76 M 580 t/'iDgible prop larceny s 20 AG 56 Ij.'; f 163 174 539 622 323 50 bill partic. ,-- B 104 S^ 918 'Sp/IPO'-t 121 603 ' f 164 212 ' separately £ 165 171 : 59 notice neg. 104 S 122 125 132 809 134 :35 notice claim 123 statement 125 1068 714 188 815 23s 238 394 849 1133 62« 74 construe will 3 105 S 138 r 190NY 422 89 foreclosure s 105 .« 33 910 52 i s 11)4 S 190 NY preference d 86 M lien good lOlM 1 54full interrst s 104S 804 £ 178 26 168 rescission ■lOIri 1099 1 24 580 *vere essential I. -37 060 letiirn benefits siO M 343 state separately 171 554 172 adl. party 5 1(15 .S 12 1 105 S 287 a 190NY 5Bi; law action 59 M 335 jurisdiction HI R-.l 185 3 trustee 166 867 ;;oiNY WIS jury trial d 152 334 201 NY 511 on contrac 164 532 218 damages 3 105 S 44:1 r 193 NY 48b compliance e 207NY after born 82 M 89 M 29 i award s 105 S a 194 NY a ;cord !0- AC 234history acts s 104S 858 135 186 247 state neg's. 3 104 S 1045 142 494 demurrer do 75M 650 legal conclusns. 166 68 250 for jury s 104 S 1076 1 52 459 proper light I 83 M 653 82 M 381 513 106 145 589 276n 297 map final 8 105 S 319 131 708 304 contempt 3 105 S 120 1 20 794 power court 150 843 £ 1G7 578 3il b:il 5 lu5 S 123 p.iri,. 246 26 3 1 5 strike out 3 105 B f 120 g:ermane 135 pleadings f 173 159 296 318 910 677 319 notice ownei 3 106 8 60b 125 644 proper order 150 833 323 new trial 3 106 S 448 a 196 NY 522 338 restraint s 105 S 554 143 587 260 presumptn. s 105 S 87 f 93 M 524 347 suspension incompetent *= int<^ in'.f AllliREVXATIONS : a, affirmed; d. distinguished; f, followed; r, c. criticised ; 1, limited ; e, explained ; o. overruled ; s, same case ; do,' 353 contempt s 105 S 340 30 AC 301n f 177 830 enforcement 20 AC 301n alimony f 177 830 ^,55 fender good 8 105 S 407 12s J45 try issues 160 51 construction 162 311 368 indictment s 105 S 395 145 697 147 as f 162 578 561VI 6 377 appeal s 105S 15!) a 102 NY 538 suspended 182 570 378 disbarment 11)5 S i>4 do 122 530 382 notice nee, s 106 S 243 63 M 379 when made ''6M 230 preference 100 660 670 384 amendment 8 105S 1103 120 828 change verdict 124 62i 387 allegations s 105 S 294 137 657 liability do 149 156 sue separately 150 172 libelous 150 173 fraud 183 618 388not evidenc 3 106 S 57 f flS if 513 incomptnt. ev. 99M 692 389 bill partic. - 105 S 203 125 815 142 71 159 582 ■'vaiver 137 443 396 reference cv 3 105 S 214 130 422 accounting 73 M 31 prove I088 207NY 633 400 neg. wt.ev i 1U5 S 221 Case 2 3 124 919 i03 u*"ler arrest 3 10.) S 327 ' ISO NY .536 oroce.ie exempt l.^.' 751 privileged 1«1 454 reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note dissenting opinion : p. parallel case ; q. questioned Vol. 120 N. Y. Supreme Court Beports — ^Appellate Division 406 revocation s 108 S 615 f 120 409 4IOa8Bume risk B 105 S 398 6S M STi d 72 M 85 76 M 605 set aside 72 M 88 courts power 71 M 134 negligence d 173 368 417 new trial s 105 S 50 145 546 compns. damage 84 M 635 419 good cause s 104 S 1055 71 M 329 personal judgmt 71 M 333 422 breach con. s 105 S 28 164 429 implied promise 103M 690 430 authority s 105 S 51 139 82 433 contract s 104 S 1016 f 121 281 agency 127 289,190 p 56M 494 telegraph co a 193 NY 293 442 contract B 105 S 5 a 193 NY 617 445contrib. neg. s 104 S 1069 76 M 609 448 reject surplusage s 104S 10?2 138 568 162 55 filing lien 73 M 430 discharge lien 148 65 liability 149 726 f S3 M 482 leave to sue 79 M 360 compliance 79 M 363 order f 173 962 lien labor 179 438 45 I construction 8 104 S 1013 at M 259 vacate Id 3 157 456 rever". error B 104 S 1039 128 237 ordinary cart 69 M 5fi7 459 appeal 6 104S 989 a 102NY 587 463 power trust s 104 S 1033 152 432 467 constitutl. 9 104 S 1102 a 193 NY 223 58M 434 consq. damage 64 M ^ 76 injunction 220US 505 construction 162 300 471 liability s 104 S 1060 f 211 NY 84 478 pers injuries B 104 S 1069 a 193 NY 630 Qot negligence 149 821 484 mandamus lOSa 528 a 190NY 31 490 eviction S 105 S 384 20 AO 264n 20 AO 268n for jury £ 107 364 498 ctrclaim s 104S 1118 181 249 504 Practice B 105 S 303 130 643 letters admr. ICP NS 336 findings facts 155 473 cond. precedent 160 87 507 cOnd precdt 9 105 S 504 133 281 sp. performance 95 M 327 5 1 6 reargument s 105 S 325 a 195NY 254 Case 5 f 120 . 893 construction 123 788 52 1 defense s 105 S 842 154 635 524 prox. cause s 105 S 40S 71 M 37 528 full title s 105 S 487 a 197NY 513 127 273 right I. r. sts. 148 752 180 677 209 NY 14') 537 negligence s 104 S 1072 165 704 539 recovery s 104S 919 ( 75M 341 reversal f 158 908 contractual f 166 283 542 prom note 3 104 S 1040 a 194 NY 680 545 appointmnt. 104S 941 127 239 senior teacher 133 264 salary 136 723 201 NY 465 promotion 89 M 122 548 injunction s 105 S 16 r 193 NY 318 no estgppel 152 732 552waive appeal B 105 S 19 168 59 554 parol agrmt. s 104 S 1087 a 189NY 545 557 services s 104 S 1002 a 193 NY 627 waiver 132 55 public policy 70 M 401 561 negligence s 105 S 183 d ISS 898 563forfeit right s 105 S 388 174 708 565 exemption s 104 S 1115 156 299 570 transfers 3 104 S 907 120 518 construction ] 23 788 195 NY 259 penalty a 193 NY 659 liability 177 712 571 mandamus s 105 S 533 a 190NY 666 574 libelous s 104 S 1081 57M 195 576burden deft, s 105 S 184 d 151 385 581 inconsistent s 105 S 151 s 105 S 1150 72 M 300 301 intention f 172 84 83 M 691 gift to wife 86 M 391 584 meaning s 105 S 207 f 169 119 f 87 M 442 maintain action f 87 M 444 legality 223NY 180 590 reargument is 105 S 117 8 120 889 595 rev era. error s 105 S 372 122 376 neg, co-servant 121 246 122 37P tieg. death do 124 896 liability 154 816 superintendence 168 399 604 amendment Case 6 B 105 S 44 s 121 903 gambling d 153 518 610 interest 3 104 S 1061 133 79- 639 oontr'b. neg s 105 S 547 123 232 20 AO 246li jury question 132 50t 641 bill partic. s 105 S 644 128 760 130 690 645 degree case s 105 S 357 139 789 excavation 73 M 518 liability f 153 21( trespassers 176 779 655 revocation s 105 S 72 90 M 163 659 bill partic s 105S 7S 149 48J f 97 M distinction 171 40f motion definite 96 M 51 improper 184 574 662veteran act s 105 S 537 84 M 189 665 burden plff. s 105 S 474 141 674 discretionary 146 874 667 recovery s 105S 549 d 66M 8 cond. precedent 160 309 672 no waiver s 105 S 914 1 M 517 676 no bar s 105 S 278 f 213 NY 14 679 foreclosure 3 105 S 291 a 195 NY 589 684 prescriptn. s 105 S 828 do 171 190 692equity court s 105 S 838 85 M 517 700 award s 105 S 779 f 165 199 709 accounting 8 105S 815 135 408 717 order appeal a lOS S 766 a 190NY 631 120 729 examination 63 M • 468 commrs. powers 139 773 728 order 3 105 S a 190NY 772 531 729 accord s 106 S 588 do 123 ' 428 56M 621 61 M 237 certificate 152 763 consideration 155 623 retain money 81 M 189 to client d 81 M 192 tender f 95 M 282 735remedy ans. B 105 S 662 137 667 distinction 138 472 by demurrer 157 256 738 appeal s 105S GG7 a 189NY 556 res adjudicata f 89 M 100 impose tax f 89 M 101 conclusive 165 829 172 457 disregarded f 170 841 full tax 174 469 742 easement B 106 S 686 67M 486 award 127 537 746 discovery s 105S 657 d 148 245 176 841 inspection 106M 444 748 mechan. lien 586 584 105 S dl28 iefect notice title realty a 194 NY 128 677 588 75 1 chgs. writng « 105 S 606 57M 678 change grade 134 481 title 71 M 542 certiorari 150 192 moral obligation 75 M 512 accrual 166 303 conclusions 104M 619 782 set aside s 105S 634 74M 262 authority 75M 512 786 judgt. B 106 S 741 Case 3 f 128 926 error court 130 229 larceny 141 155 duty magistrate 150 422 not a bar f 158 814 information 170 377 183 66 795 injunction s 106 S 661 123 510 f 170 762 61 M 136 lOOM 176 inj. relief 133 67 f 175 927 unenforceable lOOM 175 lOOM 421 contract d 102M 391 746 533 618 296 475 870 801 3 105 S m 192NY 127 do 162 f 162 amendment 132 mandamus 138 240 824 170 . 629 construction d 149 60 162 473 807 reinstatemt 9 lOS S 606 * 190 NY 561 own knowledge t 157 359 810 acct. suit for s 105 S 681 58M 384 liability 136 122 762 encroachmt 3 105S 612 a 190NY 547 abandonment r 189NY 83 M 219 authority 84 M 627 public nuisance f 163 691 lOOM 301 8 1 4 prohib. writ 3105 S 809 460 162 479 94 M 423 distinction 96 M 148 769 manslaughr 3 105 S 436 a 192 NY 581 774 damages 3 105 S 730 131 713 138 823 146 444 173 829 alternative 105 S 655 d 79 M loe 833 contract s 106 S 773 a lOONY 556 error court 135 554 838 tax stock 88 54 r 191NY validity 167 assessment 167 56 849 awards s 106 S 751 56M 308 em. domain m 190NY 350 compensation 185 553 871 partition 9 105 S 1113 3 192 NY 594 accounting 152 806 872 costs s 105 S 1112 120 . 872,893 atty's lien a 191NY 611 875 demurrer case 15 s 105 S 1131 a 190NY 603 damages case 9 B 106 S 1134 a 191NY 238 rescissioQ case 10 3 105 S 1112 m 192NY 128 contract case 12 3 105 S 1114 a 192NY 561 covenants case 4 s 105S 1141 a 193 NY 624 conversion case 16 s 105S 1145 a 193 NY 660 impress lien case 11 s 105S 1110 a 196NY 456 construction 77 M 173 jurisdiction 80 M 39.1 not liable 185 846 876 death dam. case 1 9 105 S 1131 r 191NY 77 case 9 3 106 S 1127 alOlNY 602 construe will case 8 sl05S 1119 a 190NY 568 case 10 s 105S 1106 s 139 437 139 412 878 stkholder case 10 > 104 S 319 64M 378 26'r 106 S 993 879 ejectment case 16 el05S r 191NY new trial do 133 case 10 s 105S a 192 NY case 17 s 105S Ir 193 NY icontract case 12 IIS 105S life 306 45 111-1 584 113S 37 1144 ABBREVIATIONS: a, c, criticised ; 1, limited ; affirmed; d^ distinguished; f, followed; r, revorsed; m, modified; *. dismissed; n, note. e, explained ; o, overruled ; s. same case ; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, quratione<^ N. Y. Supreme Coart Reports— Appellate Division Vols. 120, 121 a 913 NY case 7 s loss mandamus 132 880 decree Case 7 sl05S case 8 B loss . 189NY I 193 NY ontract case 10 s 105S a 192 NY enforcement 140 case 6 s loss 192NY rent lease case 9 s loss a 193 NY guaranty case S B loss a 193 NY per. injury case 4 s loss a 195 NY 664 1138 833 1126 1111 553 186 1142 589 1141 545 1125 630 1111 632 1149 545 882 transfer tax case 11 s 105 S 1140 a 190NY 525 case 9 s IOdS 1114 separation TOM 63 domicile husbnd 154 497 883vacate order case 3 s 105 S 143 discovery do 148 1117 214 626 884 contract case 2 S105S no a 192NY 56 885 partition case 6 s 105 S 1109 a 191NY 509 886 pers- injury case 1 s 105S 1114 a 193NY 620 BSTjurisdicti'n case 3 s loss 1120 3 193 NY 64S 888 reargument Case 11 sl05 S a 120 . s 193 NY order Case 5 sl05S s 189NY reervices Case 13 sl05 S a 189NY m 193 NY prom, note case 3 s loss a 192NY cjntract case 7 s loss a 192 N'V 1131 897 620 1126 548 1132 570 369 1124 589 1127 586 case 3 8 105 S 1142 a 196 NY 557 certificate void 157 234 891 license neg. case 9 rl05S r 190NY damages s 192 new trial case 4 s 1053 a 193 NY 1141 452 444 1126 654 892 pers case 10 3 loss r 192 NY I] 21 492 893 contract case 4 s 105S a 193 NY penalty case 5 B 106S al95 NY default lOP NS 144 895 resettlement case 11 s 104 S 190NY satisfaction case 1 B 105S a 193 NY 1141 629 1145 560 1137 618 1122 625 898 decree Case 6 3 105 S a 189NY death neg. case 10 s 105 S a 191NY 1141 557 1116 504 899 local option 3 loss 1145 a 189NY 549 resubmission 75M 182 75 M 183 invalid 30 A'^ 253 notice necessary 80 M 549 902 damages case 12 J 105 S 5 191Ny case 6 s 105S 1 192NY case 11 8 loss election 193 NY 1124 522 1115 592 1120 218 9U3 per injury case 10 3 105S a 195 NY case 11 i4sl05S a 195NY 1134 582 11; 582 890 injuction- 904 appeal case 7 105 S 190NY consideratn case 6 3 105S 1149 r 193 NY 289 fire insurance case 3 3 105S r 193 NY ^oods sold •use 10 i loss > 193 NY 1150 564 1142 631 1151 VOL. 121 I new trial 3 loss 6! Case 3 f 122 8i do 185 persnl. cil24 ql24 184 189 injuries 358, 359 360 949 a 193 NY 640 administrative 62 M 344 use street 143 68 M 96 M power 84 M limit 718 458 62 125 affirm or revrse 185 190 9 waiver law 8 lOS S 510 132 55 18 construction s 105 S 493 87 M 394 28 damages s loss 390 a 197NY 528 implied warranty 158 464 35 compliance 9 105 S 429 128 234 pers injury a 194 NY 598 notice auffic. 132 606 142 276 170 256 notice object 142 275 151 401 44 compensation s 105 S a 191NY 133 rewards 66M 559 286 513 59 49 meas. damage 3 105 S 470 s 20 AC 97 122 131 58 contract s 105S 562 137 357 6 1 conditions s 105S 440 179 840 66 pers. injury 8 105 S 524 a 192NY 544 bridge defect 142 333 proximate cause 71 M 36 70 pers. injury 3 105 S 513 a 193 NY 623 alter ego 145 84 72 jury question 3 105 S 522 r 193 NY 362 81 rules neces. 105 S 583 JO AC 145n 84 mandamus 3 105 S 576 r 191NY 16 98 M 367 96 gift in trust 8 105 S 696 88 M 451 105 revocation s 105 S 725 145 601 60 M 487 632 injunction I 1 6 removal s 105 S 517 r 195 NY 145 123 mech. lien 8 105 S q59M m. lumbers a 194 NY co-partners 129 certified 129 register nee. 132 law practice 68 M 508 698 323 126 new trial s loss 514 a 197NY 517 statutory f 165 272 N. J. law 186 91 129 transfer tax s loss a 189NY exemption 60 M t 77 M exceptions 129 broad sense 138 644 553 374 529 133 contract 3 105 S 593 3 127 943 new trial 214 NY 81 140 rules neces. s 105 S 610 20 AC 137n 1 43 error court 3 105 S 600 contract f 126 358 a 193 NY 635 cond Precedent 29 602 performance 140 105 167 782 recovery f 167 781 1 47 prohib. writ s 105 S 702 r 189NY 46C 120 . 814n delegation 96 M 148 1 78 dismissal s 105 S 126 599 351 254 182 carrier s 105 S 3 134 title vested 142 cause action 76 M 504 transitu 152 415 87judgt. costs s loss 581 183 628 erroneous bid 183 628 1 90 pleading s 105 S 812 124 622 tender waived 56M e estoppel f 56M 695 194 judgment 3 105 S 689 Case 1 and 2 f 121 900 Case 10 f 121 899 Case 11 f 121 899 Case 12 f 121 899 alias summons 65M 523 200 jurisdiction s IDS S 850 e 86 M 598 215 NY 213 202 accoimting 105 S 872 a 190NY 560 good will 126 270 135 851 f 92 M 645 92 M 647 rebate back 135 853 asset f 153 713 nominal value 84 M 298 computation 161 80 liability 63 M 339 64 M 250 permits s 105 S 824 96 M 53 54 269 posan not ne, 3 105 S 807 61 M 185 partition posse'n 149 71 M 272 equity s loss 3 127 202 274 84S 70 compensation 161 82 liquidation £ 213 NY 284 224 inadmissble 3 105S 674 148 53 226 certificate 3 105 S f 121 reasonable 59 M certificate 59 M 174 appeals 146 172 appealable 166 677 901 343 372 362 637 269 229 civil service 3 105 S 637 r 190NY 497 23 I evidence 3 105 S 659 129 521 hostile witness 19 AC 327c 239 money had 3 105 S 854 133 448 source title 181 23 245 revers. erroi 3 105 S 852 122 37P neg. master 123 540 neg. co-servt. 122 376 pers. injur:v a 193 NY 629 superindentence 143 940 247 safe place s 105 S . 821 63M 339 2/5 estoppel i 105 S 785 o6M 492 carrier neg. 59 M 229 127 290 conclusive 130 530 carrier notice 130 700 enforced 151 contract binding 151 684 repudiation 78 M 373 282 injunction 8 105 S 601 m 193 NY 336 consents e 68M 397 287 contract s loss 803 r 197NY 286 172 766 validity 75 M 502 specific object f 91 M 289 290 trust power s 105 B 672 133 192 limited do 133 195 nstruction 376franchi3e tai 3 106 S I a 193 NY 671 378 nut liable 107 S 138 146 581 credit principal ' 86 M 47 965 380 572 576 579 581 583 592 419 will 806 214 171 79 M SOM 80 M SOM SOM SOM SOM 198NY construe 3 148 s 85 M intent husband 80 M 576 as trustee 80 M 578 293 transfer tax 3 105S 887 r 189NY 554 consent 131 905 309 Indian law 3 106 S do 121 155 64 M S2M jurisdiction 64 M 165 d 85 M riglit surrogate 155 776 64 325 779 522 452 52 519 640 126 322 autLorily 106 S 74 5 IS rights 452 I2e 775 Indian's 79 M 85 M powers 155 right surrogate il5ii_ 77S constitutional 82 M 52 330 burd. proof s 105 S 1069 a 219 NY 414 335 direct judgt. s 106 S 2SS 126 60» rescission 129 333 355 conversion s loss 1041 r 198 NY SOS 366 warranty =.106 8 S a 195 NY 518 action lies 145 27 indemnity 167 94S 208 NY 429 recovery 181 25 381 pers 3 105S 128 repres 1098 607 395 death dam, 106 S 104 r 190NY 397 398 undue infL S106S 131,1136 149 487 100 order i 106 S 98 127 919 right to costs 139 eO'i 402 appeal 106 S 4i 153 321 404 sate place s 106S 59 ' 136 351 CO- servant negL fl4S 4071egis. 106 S f 1S9 "smoke' ' 159 oft coal 159 415 notice 106 S do 164 701 power 61 789 791 liea 94 873 426 objections 106 S 18S 89 M 702 deductible £ 89 M 702 433weight of ct s 106 S 16S 143 63S ABBREVIATIONS: a, afRrmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note- c, criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; 8, same case; do, dissenting opinion; d- parallel case; q, queBtionej Vol. 121 N. T. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division 434 contract B 106 S a 193 NY 441 eviction ■ 106S ■ 191NY a 195 NY 163 66] 17£ 15!- 88 21i 797 22P 443 injunction s 106 S 116 a 195 NY 56F v&lidity 150 738 Ko xurisdiction i! 177 " 328 462 interest a 106 S 127 149 d 59 M eomputation 133 liability 163 mandamus 99 M 11 99 M 12C right of action 99 M 16 4861ien expend s 106 S 56 67 M 637 no action bond 74M 212 unenforceable •i06 NY 31 46Q compet*. ov 8 106 S 48 138 I 473 illegal e! a 106 S 114 127 30 inadmissible 145 197 *rror court 173 14C 474 new trial a 106S 1 Case 2 1122 Case 12 fl23 f 132 amendment 1125 60 M seversal i 196 NY insurance d 134 validity 144 setroactive 20 AC injunction do 223NY 478 notice ■ 106S eiM 146 581 487 ordinary c'e s lOiJ S 128 69 M 507 488per. injuries s 106 S 106 * 200 NY 654 49 f damages s 106 S Case 1 f 121 Case 5 .fl21 Case 11 I 121 injunction a 193 NY no interest 149 77 907 910 908 641 88 560 494 appeal Case 4 s 106 S 47 f 121 909 496deoree appl. s 106 S 113 * 190NY 564 secure wife 05M 415 entirety end 81 M SS 560 deceit sioes 143 error court 145 cause action do 146 218 ^raud sale 20 AC 93n 578jury question sioes 129 581 costs s 106 S 162 106M 904 913 941 408 740 110 361 499 franchise s 106 S 130 06 M 61 501 discovery s 106 S 28 124 656 f 165 770 no accounting US 777 discretion lOlM 446 502 assessment s 106S 195 a 198NY 196 504 consent s 106 S 168 155 40(1 507 foreclosure s 106 S 173 a 194 NY 601 5 1 appeal sl06S s 129 480 chang dersn 8 106 S 126 ultra vires 140 estoppel f 99M costs 225NY 13 578 507 328 178 63f 516 amendment s 106 S 13' 19AC 303n f 170 69 lurisdictiou 130 132 5l9chrg. correct 5 106 S 201 145 606 521 nonsuit i 106S 19S 128 265 528 test trust 3 106 S 329 al95 NY 92 im])lied trust 70 M 336 531 legacies 5 lOGfi 63 M 204 power sale 109 684 546 trade marks s 106 S 249 r 194 NY 429 infringement 68 M 464 232 936 549 costs 3 106S case 6 'i 126 revers. error 128 879 ev. negligence 98 M 48 554 instructions s 106 S 233 144 348 558 contrib neg s 106S 136 203 343 280 659 369 331 228 582 transfers 3 106 S 378 a 192 NY 361 585 mcciian lien 3 106 S 372 r 195 NY 81 587 res ipsa loq i XU6 S 279 125 266 presumption 133 398 589- guaranty s 106S 374 182 613 593 certiorari 106 S 330 a 190NY 566 599 estoppel 3 106 S 305 64 M 273 assessment 143 817 604 lien mtge. 3 106 S 782 a 195 N Y 398 607 itemize s 106 3 373 164 209 8 1 3 conviction sl06S 319 a 193 NY 616 indictment 6D M 309 cond. precedent f 87 M 2"- not binding 103M 372 lien 390 149 825 mech 5 106 S f 5711 bond lien 58M d 60 M 67 M unenforceable J06 NY 31 380 543 637 73 M 276 636 discovery 30S 828 629 817 310 577 587 118 816 122 421 198 199 492 634 ans suflic. s 106 S 803 73 M. 275 pleading s 106 3 123 124 128 f 137 137 144. f 163 169 173 fS2 M 84 M 91 M dCPNS discretion 131 798 proof plaintiff 149 111 com, practice 75M 206 bill particulars 159 454 examination 164 932 645 admitted s 106 S 514 190NY 315 automobiles 72 M 420 highway law 153 177 652 vacation s 106 S 333 fl21 655 656 656 sum. review 106 S 430 66 1 assessment s 106 S 336 a200 NY 509 067 undiscl. pr. s 106S 393 d 136 26 162 884 rights owner 140 592 principal enforce 156 797 personal trust do 156 801 contract s 160 675 enforcement 88 M 561 678 practice 9 106 S 440 s 124 125 personal 143 276 684 safe place s 106S 421 136 472 legis. power do 136 477 689 bill panic. s 106S 388 136 568 ICP KS 17 701 damage s lOOS 500 197NY 14'^ 702 condemnatn s 106 S £03 r 193 NY 503 708 new trial s 106 S 517 122 8 scope employ d 72 M 390 liability 151 521 no authority f 100 632 per. injury a 195 NY 738 murder ev s 106 S 455 192NY 80 740 amend after trial 8 106S 506 19AC 306n authority 145 496 variance 159 481 nieas. oam 8 106 S 109 85 M 25'! prospect, prof, 74M 110 proximate loss 104M 586 485 not liable « 106 S 147 ABBIiEVlATIONS: a, affirmed ; d, distinguished ; f, folio wed ; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; c. rriticised; 1. limited; e, explained ; o, overruled ; s. same c ase ; do, dissenting opinion ;p, parallel case; q, questioned. authority do 160 684 716 contrib. neg 3 100 S 522 123 d 231 232 791 127 139 d 152 . 276 neg. collision 123 228, do 796 jury question 123 230 132 508 543 235 744 recovery s 106S 573 181 27 748 enforcement s 106 S 491 20 AC 30111 756 contempt 8 106 S 632 practice ' "1 763 8 125 834 64 M 477 serve on atty 59 M 239 d 64 M 436 lOOM 407 serve personally 146 250 cond. precedent 148 625 761 contempt 106 S 536 s 121 757 125 - 835 order binding 68 M 353 779 pleading s 106 S 649 do 122 511 reargumeat a 123 495 s 124 93 do business 20 AC 216ii 94 M 607 788 construetion 9 100 s 130 intent ICP NS 793 resale s 106 S t 91 M 593 377 698 439 pers. mjury 128 notice insuf . 129 ' 665,682 compliance 129 notice claim 130 136 d 198NY error court 132 liability 132 233 665 60' 836 76 380 874 shipping 3 106 S 508 m 194 NY 506 878 discovei y 808 815 receiver s 106 S 639 132 851 819 injunction s 106 S a 192NY 836 loans 3 106 S a 195 NY 909 558 1056 600 839 judgment s 106 S 764 f 131 898 84lreconveynce, 106 S 986 162 850 221NY 141 846 injunction 795 886 144 457 175 153 797 enforcemt. s 106 S 718 145 426 res judicata 76 M 439 counterclaim 165 474 separate cause f 173 880 810 neg. notice 9 106 S 675 122 71? 125 850 132 809 do 81R 133 772 s 106 S s 125 164 t 86 M lOOM demurrer 133 distinction e 198NY enforceable d 198NT 154. d 198 NY 156 spec, performa'e -1 M ISS 852 elm penalties .■i 106 S 793 .59 M 22 iudgment nase 4 i 128 904 constitutiona 137 552 8S6 bribery 3 106S 1046 a 191 NY 862 salaries 3 106 S d 163 d69 II » 195 NY services 59 M a 195 NY ripht office 127 law action 137 recovery 70 M demurrer f 173 not a bar 99M defense 178 983 436 75 601 608 614 517 906 106 S 121 124 171 show proof f 86 M ■ statutory 102M 865 887 656 104 103 77 888 discovery 3 106 P 871 121 888 893 fire escapes Case 5 s 106 S t 121 lury trial case 9 s 105S 126 prom, note case 7 s 105S a 193 NY condemnation case 6 s 105S r 195 NY refertiif, 140 1123 907 1117 203 1135 627 1110 447 894 prom, note case 7 3 106S alOONY case 8 105S a 192 NY damages case 4 s 1053 a 193 NY money deposit case 12 8 105S a 194 NY endorsers ie 5 s 105S a 197 NY 1149 554 H13 591 1150 037 1109 554 1122 14 895 pers injuries case 7 s 105S 1115 a 193 NY 619 896 separation case 1 s 105S 889 r 193 NY 409 898 death neg. case 4 .■^ 105 S a 190NY franchise ca.se 2 3 105 S r 190 NY contract case 9 s 105S a 193 NY 1141 554 1137 268 1108 633 868 bill panic, s 106 S 81." 157 30R 870 justifiation 3 106 S 497 123 319 drawer neg. 65 M 4 899money haa case 7 s 105S 1117 a 193N Y 665 900 deliver deed case 10 s 106S a 194NY damages case 11 3 105S r 190NY forfeiture case 3 s 105S r 197NY 1132 521 1132 414 1131 114 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division Vols 121, 122 902 damages U lOI? case 2 e 69M s 106S 1133 a 197NY 523 1124 397 903 contract case 13 s 106S 1135 a 194 NY 578 neg. damage case 6 s loss 1132 a 195 NY 507 904 Pera injury case 6 s 106S 1119 1.194 NY 6S3 905 new trial case 8 slOaS 111 a 191NY 507 906 guaranty •case 1 s 106S 112) a 193NY 660 907 decree case 4 s 106S a 194 NY award case 5 s 106S a 196 NY 924judgt effect: case 9 s 1068 1139 a 193 NY reargument 132 . 748 conclusion ev do 134 345 yera injury case 12 8 106S a 194 NY case 17 sl06S a 200 NY VOL. 122 I suspension 3 106 S ! a. 196 NY t 8 revocation s 106S 847 £ 178 150 1 3 ev. negligence |13 damages s 106 S 696 a 196 NY 554 1 18 law action a 106 S a 133 motion f 137 1135 558 1139 559 s 106 S 145 19 AC contrib. do 133 925vacate order case I a 106 S 1129 143 214 1128 594 926 contempt case 14 s 106 S a 191 NY f 169 iiijunctiOQ case 4 s 106S s 132 f 83 M 649 652 use greater 147 638 negligence d 75M 346 lor jury 152 459 render necessity 152 459 1149 496 72 1144 533 908 stipulation case 10 s 106S 1139 185 887 909 mandamus case 3 s 106 S d 191 NY tax lien 128 accounting case 6 s 106S a 194 NY 927 order case 6 al06 S 3 121 penalties case 2 s 106S r 193 NY 1141 523 230 1143 581 918 tax prs. sui case 12 s 106 a 191NY case 7 sioes s 190NY contract case 10 s 106S a 193 NY case 4 sioes foreclosure a 197NY 5ia 919 rear ument case 2 s 106S * 193 NY decree 140 error charge cnse 9 s 106S 1143 rn94 NY 3 1131 231 1127 521 1129 672 1122 113G 646 862 920 partition case 4 sioes 1148 a 197 NY 608 921 contract case 2 e 106S 1129 a 193 NY 672 pers. injuries case 4 s 106 US'; a 195 NY 521 candidates case 8 1119 796 790 533 212n negl 908 909 41 order s X06 S f 122 877 43 606 817 case 14 881 139 125 67 M 271 coUat attack do 160 924 equitable relief 177 553 250 contract 1 20 stipulation s 106 S 89 M 123 costs a 106S * 197NY 702 476 583 524 128 extra fees 8 106 S 611 20 AC 189n natural right 182 567 43 negligence '11-26 931 1140 457 928 stck. subscn case 4 3 106S 1110 a 125 51 929 stockholders suit case 9 s 106S a 194 NY per injury case 8 s 106S a 195 NY case 12 s 106S i 195 NY case 4 a 106S vol. payment 201 NT 414 refund tax 139 414 scaffold use sl06S 141 45 order sioes fl25 discovery 162 5 1 realty 8 106 S 128 59 r. r. 880 370 785 377 948 635 135 larceny 3 106 S a 191NY 153 plea in bar 64 M new jury 64 M indictment 152 admissible 183 li4T 39 1116 531 1150 576 1148 153 930 .pers. case 4 sioes al95 NY 407 1143 508 93 1 per. injurie° case 2 s 106S 113) a 194 N Y 599 crossings Case 5 3 106 S 655 a 192NY 634 f 122 896 P 130 343 has power 73 M 116 117 authority £ 213 NT 121 162 408 177 447 64 false label 8 106 S 134 69 bribery a 106S a 191NY 90 nonsuit a 106S 135 621 153 590 22 566 721 93 tax valid a 106 S 738 134 22 96 claim out off a 106 S do 123 diacharge 130 f 167 70 M 1012 IS.'^ 84 261 493 106 sue corpn 3 106 S 729 133 12 dissolution do 133 15 enforce claims 145 349 extra fees 20 AC 189 ( 10 cons, will a 106S 726 a 197NY 541 expectnt. estate '" M 450 740 217 108 260 263 384 s 106 S a 195 NY 254 rent s 106 S f 88 M surety 93 M 787 578 892 590 460 260 "monitor' s 106 S 1016 130 514 trade name do 130 617 damages proof s 199NY 251 274 demurrer e 106 S 970 r 195 NY 372 defect complt 137 857 mechanics lien 134 41 recover judgmt. 71 M 330 waive jury 71 M * 200 NY 550 336 stock tax s 106 S 878 a 193 NY 636 submission ICP NS 142 not subject tax 151 370 not taxable do 151 371 transfer 222NY 100 345no covenant s 106 S 1053 f 177 240 f 95 M 581 349 vot'gmaoh, s 106 S 1076 194 NY 106 right office 8 134 6; 416 award sioes a 192Ny 138 assessment 142 do 142 86 M enhance value 84 M 619 419 transfer tax S89 57$ 254 723 72« 299 152 cancellation s 106 S 732 93 M 569 158 recovery a 106 S 597 a 195 NY 517 other charges 173 725 160 death dam 3 106 S 602 r 194 NY 205 proximate cause 183 286 172 contract 3 107 S 646 a 195 NY 587 178 construction 3 106 S 963 127 111 133 834 unconstitutnl 64 M 691 qualified 134 form of 90 M 5 years' t 172 97 action 439 limit 95 188 stct. constn a 106 S 975 132 808 175 410 193 temp, recvr. a 107 S 133 forecloaure 136 Hen 138 certificates 138 trustee 138 237 289 699 203 constitutnl a 107 S r 191NY diamissal 3 190NY 127 341 123 562 465 246 stranger to judgment a 106 S 771 331 278 St. surf.r.r. s 106S 735 r 193NY 553 280 negligence s 106S 708 128 733 f 173 371 283 certiorari s 106 S 968 127 _ 481 aggrieved party a 195 NY 157 287 real propty. a 106 S 704 63 M S50 owner 151 754 289 illegal ev. 3 106 S 710 127 307 296 jury queant 723 570 3 106 S do 133 negligence 3 138 138 308 equity 106 S f 214 NY 723 724 713 349 314 mandamus a 100 S a 191NY Case 9 124 319 right damages a 106 S 210 NY real estate 89 M 325 bill particulars s 106 S d 155 716 35 917 952 92 884 Cl.S 329 injunctior. 3 106 S r 197 NY 332 libel s 106 S 1068 76 1073 345 401 45 207 354 general legacies s 106 S 89 M f 91 M 94 M M not specific 91 M 401 received 97 M 220 compensation 181 463 counsel fees 181 463 364 dismiasal 106 S 996 126 927 correct nuisance 132 86 no contempt 132 333 injunction 135 punishment 140 103M 3 106 S 192NY 161 69 M taxable f 168 62 M vested 150 renunciation 86 M 408 distinctions e 102M 384 424 competency s 106 S 777 80 M §64 844 636 839 404 89S 44S 808 428 220 328 538 373 trial court s 106S 899 136 381 375 liability B 106 S 837 154 810 f 162 329 prove negligence 157 GO." 377 liability s 106 S 94 M validity 94 M 834 403 404 pers.mjunes 458 674 valid 152 426 17» 56S 385 practice s 106 S 839 a 191 NY 205 amendment 19AC 3D8n 388 adultery ev. s 106 S 993 134 143 misconduct 76 M 669 393 presumption O06 S 1041 123 22.S corrected a 107 S a 194 NY 435 trust s 107 S 76 M ^40 decree 107S a 192 NY recompense d 78 M 34S 453 limitations s 106 S 818 170 457 lO M 471 456 notice not necessary s 106 S 77J t 163 532 172 567 461 jurisdiction a 106 S 907 127 77 92 M 124 equitable court 92 M 12E 467 discontinue a 106 S 89t p 122 46» 143 17S 470 compliance s 106 S 971 f 162 54 79 M 36S 473 sp. prfmnce s 107 S 15S f 91 M 68» 480 cond precdt s 107S 9T 75M R4* 144 286 396 tender unnec s 106 S 817 do 133 284 marketability 75M 483 liabilitT 3 107S 149 Ifl? 52» 485 contract a 107 S "•195 NY 172 54? 492 exp. intent 3 107S 185 ( 75M 28< vest remainder 167 169 8,497 audita Is 107 S 28S ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note c, criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o, oTerruled; s, same case; do, dissentinflf opinion ; p, parallel case; q, ques'tioactf Vol. 122 N. y. Supreme Court Reports— Appelate Division a 195 NY i no action 170 475 512 latl. support 444 261 346 25'1 255 s 107 S 123 damages S8M 67 M action 132 appeal a aoo NY 527 presumptn. « 107 S 462 76 M 402 535 constructn. « 107 S 439 78 M 535 185 371 617 inspection 9 107 S 188 122 635n stock books 125 539, motive inferred e 125 540 mandamus 148 157 676 new trial 652 330 548 liability s 107S 67 M > 107 S intention lOOM 452 397 452 258 524 296 627 433 46S 127 128 552 contrib iieg s 107S 37" I 134 970 560 contract 8 107 S 313 T 195 NY 231 569 perjury 3 IOC S 426 a 191NT 514 lOOM 102 582 limit scope » 107 S 694 68 M 340 construction 201 NY 435 586 judpmept s 107 S * 127 negligence t 164 172 1 217 NY admissible 168 iuU force lOlM 604 941 551 590 negligence ■s 107S 530 d 64M 175 595 labor 1. ev. 9 107 S 434 MAC 210ii judgment do 135 915 €05 abatement 621 no power s 107 S 157 623 trust s 107 S r 195 NY d 132 irrevocable 155 155 disaffirmance 155 499 628 boldg. over s 107 S 611 a 193 NY 570 633 contrib neg s 107S 522 136 344 do 98 M 197 evidence habit 143 207 635stock books s 107 S 369 125 539 right inspection do 125 542 discretion 137 864 do 148 656 state motive do 148 657 mandamus 148 652 157 330 court's power lOlM 512 S107S 70 M slander 150 verdict 83 M 95 M 677 review s 107 S 3 192NY contract a 195 NY 316 382 799 stands 239 188 527 550 68 M 140 surrogate 70 M superior 205NY 473 108 court 224 I discretion s 107 S 779 64M 124 law question 73 M 22 waiver 73 M 22 counterclaim lOlM 609 69 1 construe will s 107 S a 195 NY 59 M void ToH suspension f82M 698 28 99 31 28 643 discovery s 107S 137 E 162 272 577 897 sl07S 75M Sdentity ll 165 301 22 278 648 report 107 S 122 [guaranty a 195 NY 156 terms 154 15G assumption d 179 657 stock security s 107 S a 195 NY 608 bill partic. 1 107 S 490 153 58 lOOM 172 610 supJ. answei B 107 S 604 122 614 ■615 stay costs 515 658 544 310 contract 446 311 522 544 I 107 S 123 134 138 1 166 170 60M 69 M 03 M poor person 497 283 676 538 683 919 567 335 325 661 adjudication S107S. 401 138 820 not conclusive t 83 M 49! 666 appealable 508 409 1"" s 107 S 130 d ICP NS oleading do 135 no appeal 73 M part plant f 157 587 898 669 def. oompli .1 107 S 379 132 100 70 1 receiver s 107 S 708 132 851 706 larceny s 107S 849 192 NY 542 indictment test 76 M 580 712 statement s 107 S 855 125 849 f 126 947 notice good 127 injurv 232 notice insuffic 129 665 defect fatal 129 666 682 negligence pf , 129 681 132 809 notice defect f 129 683 147 75 notice claim 130 63 M e 133 ll 139 error court 132 pers. 128 756 assignment s 107S 570 148 838 f 163 494 extrinsic ev. 165 205 770 exemplary damages s 107S 774 179 380 774 new trial 9 107 S case 6 i 124 intent 131 show proof "8 M evidence e 7E "" 607 68 773 143 380 719 discovery s 107S 846 137 193 577 140 300 good faith 144 588 material f 125 377 723master neg. s 107 S 729 723 appearance 842 602 823 3 107 S 126 172 estoppel f 81M 511 736 not review 107 S 150 do 150 738 relief s 107S 137 777 241 244 740 venue s 107 S 741 144 60 66 151 83 185 575 convenience witnesses 156 140 748 injunction 3 107 S 478 t 122 745-6, 766 do 122 747 'sky signs" 124 166 do 166 61 M courts power 129 263 construction 138 653 85 M 600 85 M 602 police power f 161 141 642 78 80 429 80 M 9 817 same care s 107S 656 do 136 198 826 availability s 107S 757 65M 529 829 judgment 3 107S 680 a 197NY 534 mortgage d 138 110 construction 138 108 848 party wall 3 107 S 891 196 NY 183 privity estate 172 104 172 105 858 m 192 NY assessment a 202 NY conversion case 7 B 106S r 194 NY salary case 6 a 106S a 194 NY new trial case 2 sioes a 197NY 296 612 1146 394 1128 666 1132 528 pers.injunes 792 936 401 470 471 76 intention d 153 burden deft, do 175 170 deposit gift 177 248 780 levy proper 3 107 s sen tl41 027 situs contract 102 M jurisdiction d 102M 786 divorce 3 107 S 122 471 904 788 787 contempt 3 107 S 905 127 726 135 47 enforcement AC 294n adjudication 20 AC 299D 790 mandamus 107S 137 certified 143 list 833 312 151 795 discovery 107 S 893 76 M 255 206 title 835 206 sl07S title fee 133 860 legal S107S fl33 occupation f 161 allegations f 86 M 868 not negligt s 107S 767 147 228 872 no waiver 3 107 S 64 il 831 124 876 reUef s 107S 184 423 349 878 hab. s 107 B a 191NY corpus 415 526 d85subq tecum case 2 3 106 S 608 f 162 817 58M 353 888 contempt case 2 106S 126 case 4 106S njuRC tion r 193 NY contract case 14 s 107S a 196 NY per. injury case 11 106S » laS NY 1128 834 673 1143 324 1120 518 1122 582 notice 737 800 infants 57lls 107 S 784 889 libel case 9 106S a 194 NY judicial case 12 s 106S 1140 197NY 353 false imprism't case 16 3 106S 1140 197NY 499 foreclosure case 15 s 106S 1128 a 197NY 625 890 em. domain case 15 sloeS 17 893 commision case 4 s 106S 1141 a 194 NY 573 894 pers injury case 8 106S 1134 r 194 NY 92 895 reverse error case 2 r 106S s 191NY a 195NY disorderly s 129 contrib neg case 3 s 106S r 193 NY mecb. lien case 4 s 106S a 195NY death negligence case 13 3 106S * 194 NY insurance case 1 s 106S a 195 NY case 12 S106S a 197NY partial restraint 150 739 1140 291 546 774 1132 592 1116 646 1141 672 1121 512 1133 526 898r. r. crossings case 4 slOOS r 194NY case 5 r 194 NY s 106 S 192 NY 130 new trial case 6 s 106S a 194 NY 1127 488 48 669 534 337 1123 616 900 ejectment case 2 R 107S 1146 a 196 NY 546 90 1 pers. injury 4 s 106S 1119 a 195 NY 581 903 injunction case 2 sl06S a 198NY case 4 897 life insUr. case 11 s 106 S s 191NY a 194 NY case 10 s 1003 a 195 NY case 7 sl06S a 197NY 6nal acctg case 2 s 106 S a 102NY iecree case 9 3 106 S a 191 NY performance case 4 s 106S 1132 a 195 NY 554 898 mandamus case 2 MO 767 1143 520 576 1127 522 113S 516 1139 567 1119 499 145 S107S a 190NY 185 mandamus 75M decree case 4 8 10 7S a 194 NY life insurance case 7 s 107S a 194 NY case 3 3 107S a 190NY 08M 6SM transfeia e66M sp. prfmance case 9 s 107S 1144 a 196 NY 64 899 dismissal case 6 3 107 S 1131 " 190NY 563 death damages ease 7 s 107S a 194 NY practice case 4 s 107S r 195 NY contract case 2 s 107S 196 NY 473 1142 667 487 508 1119 540 1121 1142 56T 105 107 195 1125 552 1136 40 1131 545 1134 512 slOOS 3 126 3 145 case 7 s 106 S a 194 NY just realty case 8 106S 1142 a 104NY 520 death neglig. case 13 3 106 S 1148 a 192NY 1136 164 1144 563 139 904 new trial Case 2 s 106 S f 123 f 132 amendment 124 f 125 reversal f 196 NY dp perfmance case 5 106S 1135 196 NY 612 1160 913 941 43 407 905 appeal case 19 9 108 S 192Ny death neg case 10 s 106S 1143 52S 1124 ABBKHVI.MIONS: a, aflirmed ; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; 8. criticised : 1. limited; e, explained; o, overruled: s, same case: 4o, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q, questioni N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division Vols. 122, 123 a 194 NY 524 pers. injury case 7 s 106S 1142 a 195 NY S33 909 ejectment case 4 s 107S 1129 r 196 NY 9 1 accounting case 13 s 107S 1145 a 194 NY 618 912 judgment Case 8 s 107 S 1137 e 122 913 914 probate case 3 a 107 S a 192NY new trial case 5 s 107S a 195 NY pers. injuries case 4 s 107S 1135 a 197 NY 525 9 1 6 deed of trust case 2 s 107S 1128 a 194NY 552 sp perfmance. case 3 s 107S 1121 a 195 NY 581 9 1 7 em. domain case 21 s 107 S s 193 NY 1130 538 1142 62 1130 168 918 order case 1 S107S a 197NY case 12 3 107 S a 191NY rescission case 9 B 107S al95 NY 1123 607 1146 523 1146 514 920 domicile case 15 s 107S a 192NY case 19 a 107S a 194NY guaranty case 20 s 107S a 195NY case 16 s 107S a 195NY 1139 238 1144 576 1146 520 1137 556 921 award case 15 s 107 S 1143 a 191 NY 624 express motion f 83 M 470 assessment case 9 s 107 S a 192 NY taxable 135 crdr suit case 6 s 107S a 194 NY a ICP NS injunction case 4 s 107S 1119 a 195 NY 516 case 5 sl07S sl2o 1129 579 1127 1129 696 1138 534 1139 315 1139 922 liquor tax case 17 s loss a 193 NY contract case 4 s 108S a 194 NY prom, note case 6 s 108S a 195 NY case 8 slOSS a 194NY case 18 s loss p 195 NY perfmance case 15 s 108S 1139 a 196NY FS,499 pers. injuries case 14 s 108S 1145 a 199 NY 572 923 ppeal case 8 a 108 S commission 3 124 contract case 3 s loss a 193 NY prOm'. note case 5 B 108S a 195 NY 1129 479 1141 678 1148 531 VOL. 123 1 vendor sign s 107 S 422 138 265 sp. performance 79 M 60 forfeiture 79 M recovery 154 82 2 commissions s 107 S 277 138 487 97 M 220 extra compenstn 77 M 29" d 78 M 343 Stat, compenstn. f 77 M 302 e 77 M 300 7 appeal S107S 455 123 806 amendment 129 41? esr. decision 129 43? review law 147 104 tl s 107 S 329 123 flOfi good title 127 ?7f performance 141 14 1 3 construction 3 107 S HRl r 195 NY 210 23 pleading 3 107 S 331 128 128 invalid 93 M 433 non compliance f 93 M 434 enforcement 220 NY 83 stockholder 176 947 cond. precedent 322 1141 666 646 1121 69 146 30 nrder i 107 S 750 123 907 competent ev. d 125 247, 248 145 128 services a 195 NY 521 34 anon, court 3 107 S 829 58 M 653 35 fi^rant valid 3 107 S SI 51 M 21 cloud title 77 M relief 77 M jurisdiction diss 495 911 77 M no avail f 147 46 accoimting a 107 S 916 8 191NY 51 set aside deed a 194 NY 615 voidable 129 453 affirm 185 346 63 cost of work B 107 S 826 125 629 * 193 NY 598 65 mandamus s 107 S 746 91 M 289 67 serve process 762 374 s 107 S 173 publication 140 71 laches s 107 S 161 f 161 828 628 630 72 dismissal s 107S 722 137 61 motion case 6 f 137 895 case 7 t 137 895 duty plaintiff 154 321 74 lien services s 107 S f 170 899 635 75 notice s 108 S 145 162 f 162 f 169 invalid 148 may combine 172 589 79 circumstantl. 476 685 55 58 818 GOl I ISmentl capac. s 108 S 112 67 M 348 1 1 7 submission 3 108 3 298 a 196 NY 536 trust 181 473 181 564 1 28 discharge s 108 S 379 130 84 1 4 1 continuous body s loss 331 136 129 148 competent evidence s 108S 336 149 231 1 63 motor V. law s 108 S a 192NY fireman 73 M ( 66conditl. 108 S 144 f 91 M recovery 79 M 79 M 450 193 640 sale 253 303 258 474 478 548 172 407 434 38 defense 107S d 179 40 demurrer 3 107 S 127 liability t 72 M dismissal 225NY rent due 225NY 45 waiver ■! 107 S 755 243 840 731 373 3 108 S 59 M decree a 194 NY inference f 96 M presumption 96 M 175 86 no appeal 5 108 S 483 d 144 575 reinstatement 151 298 abatement 151 estoppel f 169 mandamus 218 NY 300 596 119 83 franchise s loss 126 railroads r 196 NY authoritv 80 M (02 vendor's liel s 108 S 233 b195 NY 55n AC 114 (06 constructn s loss 186 184 284 I74duty retreat 108 S 416 213 NY 244 191 city neg. 3 108 JS 159 d 126 543 negligence d 142 17G I 93flse imprism 3 108 S 22] r 195 NY 391 probable cause 133 705 201 power sale 108S 234 a 197NY 365 knowledge f 161 810 207 no power 5 108S 287 148 772 2 1 2 administerng B 108 S 281 a 192 NY 312 212 NY 218 issue letters d 160 89 220 error court s 108 S 428 156 413 226 annulment 3 107 S 1063 f 131 912 notice nee. 135 352 f 127 f 133 complaint 130 149 agreement s 200NY not liable 146 no cause 146 costs 143 cause action s 143 145 liability do 152 contracts 156 f 96 M equity 224NY person, 186 708 452 274 10 244 273 774 197 liable 242 foreclosure s 107 S f 123 accrual 73 M barred t 73 M 1047 250 79 80 251 illegal ev 3 107 S 944 127 307 competent evid. 61 M 318 254 damages 8 108 S 84 154 160 r 196 NY 43 lateral support S195 NY 53 liability 66M 270 excavations 184 856 272 contempt s 1G7S 94 M 135 recital 70 M 275 slOSS 140 f 162 no 949 114 47 interest 53 suit damages 165 267 court 1101 52 ABBEEYIATIONS «. •riticited ; I, limited 228 show care s 107 S 1008 142 18 123 792 a 165 910 233 Invalid test s loss 110 136 786 suspension 79 M 195 79 M 198 236 eftect judet 3 loss 31 277 error 3 107 S 132 remit cause 169 597 279 liability s 107S 1072 179 742 take risks 105M 731 282 paymnt.cnsl 3 107 S 128 d 166 stay f 169 £ 172 f 93 M 93 M 972 271 683 583 902 325 497 283 ontract 3 107 S 955 a 193NY 668 contrib. neg 3 107 S 1103 288 jurisdiction s 107 S 1103 92 M 29 1 pers. injury s 107 S 100 196NY S06 cond. precdt. 138 824 139 448 limitations 84 M 443 in tort 163 664 98 M 91 damages 164 639 298 conversion s 107 8 976 a 196NY s38 303 pers injury s 108 S 5 130 692 al95 NY 519 contrib. neglig. 172 322 76 M 608 323 negligence 107 S 973 58M 52 331 surety bond 3 107 S 989 rl9S NY 516 '339 injunoticn s 108 S 91 Case 2 124 934 358 error s 107S 1080 134 461 cumulative ev. • 175 472 369 contract s 1C8S 181 r 197NY 527 information 157 494 376 inspection 8 107S 936 s 136 486 incompetent 201 NY 490 improper 151 398 inadmissible 78 M 421 reversal 172 144 residence 106M 475 381 imp. remks 3 107 S 1089 19 AC 458n 384 divorce pldg. s 107 S 1093 124 785 separation 20 AC 28n 386 no appeal s 107 S 942 145 228 167 936 389 per injury 107 S 1001 128 232 -omplianec 125 234 notice insuf. 129 665, 682 compliance 129 665 cause 63 M 69 tct. constn. 132 809 notice negligence 132 809 notice claim a, affirmed; d, distinguished; 1, followed; 377 198NY 76 , . .• - r y-' -' ' ■' reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed- n. nota .explained; o. over, .iled ; s, same case; do, dissenting opinion; p, pirallel cas" q? quMtion'd Vol. 123 N. Y. Supreme Coart Reports — Appellate Division judgment case 8 £140 notice purpose d 151 400 396 new tnal e 107 S 960 132 890 400 order office 3 s 107 S 1044 f 123 404 abandonment f 79 M 558 judgment f 98 M 435 404 liability s 107S 1063 do 179 312 A 1 1 amendment S107S 1110 131 894 416 cts. pwr. lien s 107 a 1088 1 28 667 140 402 conipula.reference 128 67J 424 good faith p 107 S 1096 d 61 M '-'38 acquiescence 139 107 97 M 679 680 97 M 682 d 97 M 683 98 M 625 accord f 178 20 AC dispute d 93 M deduction do 178 834 272n 885 465"fi3rturea"" s 108 S 251 a 198NY 509 s 20 AO 106 168 114 65 M 33 470 pleading s 108S 528 alOTNY 526 waiver 85 M 349 enforcement 172 311 220 NY liability 178 597 cond. precedent 183 322 474 res judicata s 108 S 489 a 192NY 35 480 termination s 108 S 526 155 611 lOOM 633 487 conclusive s 107 S 962 p 157 833 189 bill partic. 537 supeiintndce s 108 S 132 liability 154 no breach 166 457 808 816 duty 747 107 S 138 146 494 trial s 108 S 134 yu3 574 469 505 503 585 428 eleclion s 107 S 946 129 609 amendment 19 AC 296n|75M test joinder 71 M 583 508 enforceable allegations 495 reargument s 108 S 821 s 124 937 stock corpor. 66M 596 92 M 206 assumption 68 M 68 M compliance 07 M Iiresumption 643 547 negligence 108 S 193 s 20 AC 133 rules necessary 20 AO 141n 558assume risk s 108 S 142 154 2aj 57 1 reversal s 108S 74 180 851 579 liability s 108 S f 220 NY 143 172 78 M d 91 M not liable f 162 175 E 83 M f 83 M damages 214 NY witness 220NY 228 117 221 525 302 250 753 823 30 140 252 433 631 neg. damage < 108 S 1 126 785 not negligence f 173 126 642 loss profits s 108S 120 a 198NY 402 645 correct address s 108 S 175 172 567 646 amendment s 108 S 59 133 862 irregularity 97 M 639 689 authority 777 submission 8 1 7 security s 108 S 140 690 affidavit 59 616 648 rule neglig. 108S 128 liability s 139 655 costs s 107 S 162 657 reversal 8 108 S s 144 liability 154 38 408 989 159 140 088 816 152 383 92 M 461 431 meas. dam E 108 S 402 125 534 84 M 144 recover profit 137 545 215 NY 105 contract alive 221NY 103M damages 179 126 440 partition 3 108 S 289 a 195NY 58;. adverse claim 210 NY 465 446 lis pendens s 108 S 35S 128 636 sp. performance r 194 NY 496 waiver 130 420 453 liability s 108S 391 a 197NY 161 construction 13G 249 provable 156 502 108S lOSM 307conclus ? 108 S 68 M 347 133 law 546 152 3l4secure costs 108 S 146 have order 160 5 1 9 surety 3 108 S a J92i\'Y s 129 bankruptcy f 132 do 132 incapacity dol4,S complaint 153 559 625 18 385 227 167 917 918 582 contract 3 108 S 2C a 195 NY 586 comp. contract 137 920 public policy do 180, 539 586 per. injury s 108 S 25 r 195 NY 24S 591 ministerial s 108S 49 135 93 no review 152 511 598incumbrance s 108 S 57 169 310 604 competency O08S lii' 142 27- paramount rie:h( f 168 609 606 admissible 15; 528 serve procesF ' 108S 249 50 M 542 motion f 136 890 531 judgment 5 108S 105 i 134 933 :ransfer 86 M 45 direct route f 88 M 97 108 S 2U AC 61 I con 1. 1U8S d 61 M. 80 173n p e d 48 253 665 right bear arms s 108 S 24 3 54 420 construction 154 425 667 stare decisis s 108 S 40 fl29 620 669 ass'nce title s 108 S 54 125 738 sp. performance 60 M 459 672 liability s 108 S 45 134 31 142 28S masters liability 76 M B04 676 coservant slOSS 130 138 23 81 M 313 81 M 322 not conservant 81 M 3in 680 atty's lien 108 S 152 o 191 NY 621 a 195 NY 637 contingent fee 01 521 149 6 I 4 death dam loss a 194 NY s 20 AC scaffold 195 NY 422 620 converfion 107S 1074 a 195 NY 532 622 restitution 108 S 178 83 M 367 626 prox. caust slOSS 10 1 .M 33 629 contract 181 888 s 108 S 62 M 69 1 appeal 3 108S 124 appraisers a 192NY 65 518 230 926 570 693 error court s 108 S 368 r 195 NY 386 706 pleading s 108 S 547 132 113 136 142 f 91 M f 94 M 102M 668 517 480 '4, 5 64] 'anconscionable 102M 640 682 reverse error SI07S llOl 123 717 129 675 S85 decision s 108 S 40 a 199 NY ft4a 687 owners s 103 S. 157 144 737 amend defects lOOM 433 707 contract s 108S 602 61 M 53 709 condemnatn s 108S 635 a 192NY 571 717 liability s 108 S 236 f 160 419 719 carriers s 107 S 1113 63 M 201 innkeeper 64 M 82 727 notes paymt s 108S 42 75M 355 no defense 174 297 732 new trial s 108 S 362 19 AC 456n Bumming up 184 s 103 S a 196NY liability 141 452 s 108 S 560 62 M 804 454 128 779 taxa'e costi slOSS 70 -M 215 NY to client 106M 542 45 474 418 784 recover right s 108 S 417 192 NY 371 128 131 limitation 66M 423, 424 through car 204NY 443 right transfer 88 M 98 789 pers. injur. s 108S 245 197NY 507 797 contempt s 108 S 551 152 819 on merits 160 670 805 amendment 3 108 S 548 129 412 560 581 917 733 pers 3 108 S a 193 NY nuisance 85 M injury 305 11 739 burdep nrf. s 108 S 261 132 780 not justified 143 451 742 renew law 108 S 344 808 pleading 8108S 124 12,'? 126 128 131 132 134 178 insufficient 1 87 M pleading rule 224 632 707 325 140 289 950 759 484 286 143 144 order f 128 901 denials 129 16 140 1-46 152 942 158 500 amendment 64 M 43 defenses do 133 evasion 144 59 M 30 answer bad new lease 77 M 564 f 93 M 86 not permissible 78 M 513 746 authority |™ S"*'"" s 108S 4871 '9 *I 223NY 80?°*aPP'y ... 178 69 154 463 judgt. pleadings 510 249 824 review 8 108 S 207 NY no exceptions 160 270 827 discovery s 108 S kz 127 209 J30 230 163 544 d 82 M 421 832 damages s 108 S 586 a 193 NY 653 837 intention s 108S 239 f 170 12 840iuryque5tion a 108 S 604 124 24 charge correct f 75M 265 safe place 157 201 846 title deposit slOSS ' 493 a 194 NY 613 do 216 NY' 95 benefit wife 05M: 434,, 435 survivorship 141 57 167 359 167 367 65M 436 f 91 M 93 M secure wife 66M 415 f resumption 41 S7 164 78 85 M 295 entire interest 142 20O bank book do 143 865 equal interest f 144 804 no intei sst 147 252 intentions 79 M 387 joint tenancy 79 M 658 hush, and wife 79 M 659 vest title fund 83 M 378 evidence gift 186 189 862 conspiracy 418 749 damages s 108S 414 141 360 /50 divorce s 108 S 534 a 200 NY 72 within 5 yrs. 69 M 438 strike out 157 77 753 contract J 108 S 640 195 NY 651 not enforceable 89 M 362 765 per. injury 3 108 S 667 a 1H5 NY 540 d 79 M 165 frivolous 102M not deny 102M 814 parties 3 108 S f 124 127 £ 90 M order f 186 1142 discovery f 163 171 f 175 96 M 102M 551 948 323 919 201 36 894 901 544 104 940 57 624 51 541 4S5 761 61 108S a 192NY 145 156 165 competent ev. 125 241 judicial 136 310 admissible f 160 548 883impl consent 3 108 S 325 131 135 885 life insoj- 108S 432 . 66iM 12< wife's right 66M . 125 •assumption 87 M 4o5 construed 98 M 5£? ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; U followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, tuMj^ fi eriJicised: 1. limited: e. explained: o, overruled: s. same case: do. dissenting opinioii: p, parallel ease: «. ( n n" N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division Vols 123, 124 896 burden piff, s 108 S 350 134 250 vendee proof 144 773 903 accounting case 2 s 108S 297 a. 195 NY 50 907 life insur case 8 s 107S a 195 NY case 12 s 107S a 194 NY 752 520 1130 456 908 damages case 8 . s 107S 1145 a 195 NY 53 contract s 83 M 410 909 larceny case 7 s 107S a 196 NY case 8 8 107S a 192NY penalty a 193 NY 1149 549 1141 543 675 910 per, injury case 3 slOTS a 196 NY case 6 s 107S a 196 NY death neglig, trade marks case 10 s 107S 1132 a 199 NY 596 1145 560 1147 482 91 f stck. subscn case 5 s 107S r 195 NY case 6 s 107S a 195 NY case 10 B 107 S sl25 case 11 s 108S a 195 NY 1146 70 1128 526 1120 52 1140 632 r 196 NY case 12 a loss f 125 r 196 NY fier injury ife . insurance case 13 8 108S 1183 foreclosure a 196 NY 553 director •195 NY case 3 slOSS * 195NY aside deed case 4 s 108S 1150 a 198NY 530 85 M 522 73 1130 93 405 562 1147 552 914 mandamus case 7 104 case 8 s 108S a 195 NY case 9 108 S a 192NY oers. injury case 10 8 108S a 196 NY trust case 11 s 108S a 195 NY 967 1148 167 1144 544 1149 582 1148 597 9 I 5 contract case 10 s 108S 1151 r 195 NY 118 neg* damage case 5 s 108S r 195 NY perjnjury case 7 s loss a 195 NY notice 155 1141 176 1135 589 11 9 1 6 sp.prfmacen a 194 NY 535 case 9 s 108S al94NY new trial case slOSS s 136 1145 533 1126 264 912 appeal case 3 s 108S 11^9 a 194 NY 626 underwriting case 4 slOSS a 197NY case 8 s 108S r 195 NY case 10 s 108S a 196 NY case 1 1 s 108S * 193 NY 1138 545 1150 76 1129 592 1141 919 sp. prfmanc s 107S 1132 r 196NY 32 1147 552 913 amendment case 1 a loss a 195 NY referee fee case 2 s 108S case 6 • 108S a 195 NY alimony case 11 s 108S 923 money had case 8 1 107 S 191NY a 195NY nonsu't case 11 s 107S r 195 NY contract s 135 contract Ooojcase 7 s 107S a 196NY a 194 NY' 925 case 12 slOSS * 191 NY mech. lien case 11 s 1088 a 195 NY personal case 10 s 108S a 196 NY contract case 6 s 108S a 196 NY accounting case 2 s 108S a 196 NY 927 order case 9 j 108S * 193 NY 165 667 1134 526 1143 536 injury il38 638 1139 641 1148 608 1133 663 968 VOL. 124 1 rule damages 596 611 256 94 1131 619 546 1147 63 178 1147 1143 535 924 certoriari case 20 i 108S 192NY penalties case 19 I50|e loss 547 a 194 NY {bond case 12 133 s 108S 1144 577 1143 522 262 176 337 s 108 S 58 M revocation 130 stct. value do 198NY 10 larceny shell fish SlOSS r 194 NY for jury 156 petit larceny 159 446 1 2 negligence s 108 S 265 160 791 1 8 latl. support a lOS S 506 129 715 a 192NY 64 anticipation 133 224 public nuisance 143 51 22 parties Case 3 108 S 60b t 124 913 parties Case 4 f 124 913 29 >^pl, damage 3 108 S 917 133 846 s 20 AG 1B4 restrict proof 197 NY 73 43 relief fund s 108 S 267 148 647 retroactive ao AC 46n J 54 essential f 99M element 511 47 certificate 108 S a 192NY discretion 137 53 damage a loss a 195 NY iraud sale 20 AC iO AC 224 US 288 673 454 590 91 82n 73 58 assessment 108 S a 196 NY not final 139 judgment f 142 lex loci [ 88 M 66 tax sale s loss 132 repeal 83 M final rule 210 NY 68 damages 108 S r 193 NY dismissal 78 M 155 503 629 920 485 242 623 89 counsel fees e 108 S 964 a 194 NY 181 ulimony s ICP NS 157 99 deposit trust s 108 S 214 124 101 a 194 NY 523 103 deposit 8 108S 216 E 124 109 106 noiisuit 8 108S 189 135 721 master neglig. s 136 136 liability do 165 940 I 13 amendment a 108 S 921 132 449 1 1 7 variance s lOS S 135 185 18S 91 M 427 120 amendment s 108 S 1132 132 113 121 unforseen 3 108 S 616 128 736 ontrib neg 129 603 d 134 307 imputation 135 120 primary ctiuse 144 718 126 conclusive 8 108 S 909 f 163 381 not adjudicata 197NY guarded 144 177 1 33 nonsuit s 108 S 64 M discretion 134 510 896 101 666 1 95 change grade s 108 S 903 131 649 award delay 136 439 certiorari 138 172 eminent domain 7u M 594 damages 202NY 191 419 preferred stock „,„|l94NY 234 717 corporation 129 directors 129 complaint 154 stockholders do 154 majority trust do 154 41 majority cont'ls 81 M 692 205file designtn 8 108 S 704 154 139 St. limitations 173 222 210 contract 3 108 S 707 a 196 NY 608 215 bill part;c. 3 109 S 7 s 109 S r 191 NY 40 14 20 36 1141 341 writ 737 772 443 512 446 222probib 3108 S • 131 63 M penalties 136 63 M license J3B by appeal 179 230 error court 8 108 S 654 f 168 65 ii32 construe wil 645 576 646 take 37' 417 410 255 293 73 novation 8 108 S 210 132 188 329 79 M 219 contract a 195 NY 558 price nairt I42canceljudgt 3 108 S 888 a 194 NY 549 discovery 184 948 not in tort 150 328 efi'ect decree ISO 148 sham til ember s 108S 203 NY protection 143 removal d 143 32S 848 109 714 l^.ri^S7i'^T^S'^v /• »ff'™=d; d, distinguished; f. followed; (.cri'icised; 1, limited ;«, explained ; o, overruled ; 177 new trial 3 108 S 799 s 132 915 parol evidence 148 730 180 contrib neg 3 108 S 805 129 S03 judgment 3 132 925 master neglig. d 134 307 ' removal s 108 S a 192NY 69 M hild v»ill 1 200 NY vested remaindr 152 481 compliance 207 NY 372 245 trade name 3 108 S 874 a 169 NY 575 •43 a!T!dav!t costi 3 108 S 734 142 2 order case 3 149 925 right to tax 80 M 23 stenog. fees tax 80 M 293 251 pi. of trial s 108 S 79£ 155 89< convenience witn essef 156 149 253 secure cost- 273 stipulation e 108S 793 135 888 277 construe will s 108 S 775 r 193 NY 683 no discretion 166 826 69 M 129 valid trust 177 188 287 improper judfrment 8 108 S 94.3 157 714 accounting f 82 M 186 289 mech lien 8 108 S f 130 material 68 M 816 877 376 295 damages s 108 S 862 a 195 NY 539 prescription 66M 379 312 appeal 108 S 9.^4 dissmissed ■ 192NY rule judgts. 31 M surg. power 131 665 660 a 108 S 256 appeal 108 S 124 amendment 192 NY 72] 530 260 jurisdiction s 108 S 733 192NY 631 262 injimction 8 108 S 971 124 236 24 192NY 35 316 collat. attck 108 S 753 do 131 766 rescission a 195 NY 649 publication 20 AC 222 322 bill pp.rtic. 3 108 S 876 125 815 325 discovery s 108 S 953 171 104 328 lease street 5 108 S 894 130 692 revocation 71 M 459 331 transfer tax < 108 S 926 ell as I 126 953 deduction 67M 22 95 M 460 333 oral examn i 109 S 41 124 663 335 oral examn. 3 109 S 42 124 663 345 competency s 108 S 663 SO M 565 . . reversed; m, modified: • dismissed- ...am.case; do. disaenting opinion ; p, parallel ca™ ' n, note; q, questioned Vol. 124 N, Y. Supreme Court Reports — ^Appellate Division 357 severance suit s 108 S 686 139 one judgment 159 800 new trial do 185 189 370 delay s 108S 667 lOlM 413 372 struck jury s 108 S 801 124 666 speical jury 133 302 377 stay s 108 S 811 69 M 311 382 no cloud s 108 S 887 133 279 280 not valid i 164 517 384 misdemcanr s 108 S 830 129 91 lOOM 409 void contract 159 3-50 76 M 533 recovery e 150 478 cond. precedent 76 M 512 legal remedy d 212 NY 358 f 170 942 unenforcible 180 534 226NY 99 f 98 M 606 illegal 179 reversal d 222NY bribery do 180 d 222NY 116 346 539 347 396 salary basis s 108 S 807 f 157 415 presumption 103M: 579 401 merger r. r s 108 S 823 D 125 SOJ local authority 130 631 public rights 137 819 consent court 140 615 authority 140 616 violation f 160 141 validity 175 700 412 s 108 S f 165 992 927 413 accounting s 108 S S6S 62 M 357 trust 172 664 421 divorce s 108 S 864 a 195 NY 540 427 mandamus s lLi8 S 1061 a 192NY 668 authority 60 M 13B political parties 90 M 447 434 labor law 3 108 S 796 r 192 NY 438 Corp. powers 1080 134 26 404 s 108 S a 196 NY do 167 inquiry f 97 M 465 assessment 3 109 S 2 a 192NY 539 revocation 138 188 award 185 548 478 interroga- tions 108 S 1129 3 108S 1020 14G G83 49 1 quantum meruit s 108 S 791 217 NY 232 498 neargjnce s 108 S 937 59 M 215 502 discontinue 3 108 H 955 1 32 246 84 M 117 ani. allowance 134 666 505 bill partio s 108S 927 I2S 644 148 043 508 covenants s 124 S 1036 79 M 90 recovery 97 M answer bad 77 M 664 judgt. pleadings d 79 M 552 533 admissible s 108 S 950 20- AC 175n 535 chng. venue s 108 S 932 146 689 f 168 . 261 convenience witnesses 399 149 967 545 insurance 9 108 S 939 a 192 NY 58 indemnity 1 170 495 548 divested s 108 S 1047 72 M 227 express trust 73 M 420 trusts 89M 60 103M 52 gift absolute lOOM 294 555 order s 108 S 973 f 144 904 consolidation 410 511 re.iect surplusage 108 S 992 568 sufficient 146 153 102M 569 state separate 109 S 171 138 notice 72 M 515 compliance s 109 S 70 65 M 211 519 complete defense s 108 S 975 ■141 310 522 terms court 3 108 S 129 lOP NS amendment 131 132 67 M 941 411 246 80 113 238 payment costs 139 172 679 892 523 orders 3 108 S ilHC Case 3 ■ 124 93(1 amendment 64 M 4£ 530 liability s 108 S 911 f 165 767 53 1 denials 3 108 S 881 til M 437 155 156 168 54 1 appeal a 108 S 127 543 change venue s 108 S r 151 970 921 963 916 210 NT 6 1 9 strike out s 109 S 125 germane 142 135 "aggreived' 135 136 material 158 pleadings 159 225 861 458 544 544 163 inadmissible 78 M admissible 172 reversal 172 682 bill particulars B 109 S d 155 762 627 discovery 138 253 355 286 554 575 consolidatn. 109 S 1139 578 rescission 3 109 S 179 9 129 334 641 mandamus s 100 S 335 f 129 266 644 co-tenant s 109 S 83 do 132 929 injunction r 196 NY 500 prescription 138 353 654 discovery s 109 S 95 ^ 165 770 171 104 657 mandamus 583 security 133 s 109 S r 192 NY 973 140 286 eOOpers. 3 109 S a 194 NY mjury 120 675 joint liable G6M 386 t 85 M 17 18 stenog. services 08 M 439 t 97 M 632 referee's fees 137 753 liability 185 715 609 accounting 332 500 800 672 slOOS a 104 NY f 167 decuritiea 133 proper parties 145 284 f 167 799 demurrer 160 489 adverse claim 3 109 S 128 136 135 140 142 f 82M ICP NS material ev. 131 discretion 131 135 113 317 654 285 804 752 421 3 220 798 286 421 36 143 186 613 633 prop slOOS s lOOS 14fi prac, 77 1125 677 3 109 S 63 M ministerial 135 184 trial venue 138 165 368 93 780 817 661 depositions s 109 S 151 discovery 91 M 44C 721 665 fraud 109S f 176 injunction 178 deception 178 490 105 710 670 default 1 109S 3H7 < 135 911 93 M 448 449 374 mpropr . ev s 109 S 131 131 749 improper 151 39t 180 5Hf 19 AC 453n 45fii judgment 131 901, safe place p 135 sn 198NY 69 161 392 incompetenl e20I NY 40( 684 consent courts s 109 S 228 166 903 686 cons true will 195 NY 436 3 109 S 349 iudg. binding 134 333 7G5 alter ego 3 109 S 428 127 846 death neg a 194 NY 634 constitutional 129 860, do 862 vice principalo 133 201 148 354 negligence 197NY 456 liability 140 854 lole functions 140 855 complaint "0 M 253 judicial notice 145 749 vacate order 138 483 749 demurrer s 109 S do 144 dismissal 225NY 572 554 356 764 751 change venue s 109 S p 124 755 closed s 109 S f 175 d 98 M 714 complaint s 109 S 60 M 138 f 102 166 f 167 misfeasance 98 M recovery 60 M joinder 64 M misjoinder 136 36 M all parties do 148 f 86 M 99M for jury 223NY 163 44 moving papers do 146 617 notice essential 148 766 891 burden deft case 2 slOSS 60 M reversal s 108S 577 f 75M 399 burden defendt. 1 75M 390 dismissal case 1 s 108 £ M 677 610 125 142 894 death dam case 1 s 108S 112!> a 194 NY 619 895per. injury s loss a 196 NY 1149 683 31 502 896 co»t B 109 S a 196 NY jury question 136 66S not conclusive 68 M 171 902 tort case 1 s 108 S do 174 590 85 252 684 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; £, followed; r, reversed; m. modified; *, dismissed; n, note; r. criticised; 1. limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q. questijned N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division Vols, 124, 125 903 libel case 12 * 193 NY guaranty case 4 a 19SNY 597 519 904 reargument case 3 E 109 S s 126 damages case H s 108R al95 NY nz 337 1134 539 905 misconduct case 1 * 193 NY 367 906 per. injury case 5 a 196 NY 543 920 death dam case 14 s 1088 a 194 NY 134 f 93 M liability 105M case 4 1083 a 195 NY services case 6 s 108S a 194 NY 909 atty. lien case 3 s 108S 1140 131 contract a 195 NY foreclosure a 197NY 53 512 912 discovery case 10 s 108S 323 132 278 1134 536 335 69 603 142 556 648 1126 595 921 mone.v case 5 s 108S a 196 NY contract a 196 NY bad 1127 577 558 76 M justify f 160 per. injury case 3 s 109S 1138 a 195 NY 555 discrimination f 72 H 352 72 M 35; authority 72 M 354 212 NY 413 938 contract case 20 s 109S a 194 NY damages case 21 s 109S a 194 NY 913 per. injury case 4 s 109S 1140 a 195 NY 549 914 slander case 12 s lOS S 1145 a 125 920 misconduct case 6 s loss 1141 * 193 NY 673 death damage r 194 NY 529 SIB damages slOSS 1125 case 7 61 M 71 65M 261 reargument case 4 s 108S * 193 NY royaltied case 9 s loss a 195 NY 923 contra el case 19 s loss 768 a 196 NY 633 close street case 1 s loss 1136 do 131 724 postponed 132 R71 per. Injury case 3 s 108S 1142 110 a 190 NY 504 money paid a 197NY 51 1140 640 1128 513 916 damages case 16 slOSS 611 case 15 s loss 1144 lOlNY, 523 pers- injury case 18 8 108S a 194 NY conversion case 11 s 108S a 195 NY forei-lfh-iure case 5 s 108S rl97NY 924 recover tax case 1 s 108 S- 1136 152 118 opening street 152 damages 152 173 distinction case 4 s loss a 194 NY case 15 f 97 M 118 120 20 1127 522 134 928 title proceed case 4 s 109S a 195 NY 1124 568 929 decree case 9 s 109S a 194 NY 1127 540 1140 575 1141 109 1136 35 917 gitl. i vivos cases 7 & 8 s. 108S 1138 r 194 NY 49, 00 9 I 9 money fraud case 4 s loss 1135 dl94 NY 661 930 ejectment case 4 s 109S • 1137 a 105 NY 59 934 contract case 3 s 109S 57' a 196 NY 560 costs appeal s 139 625 error court s 139 02 536 good title case 2 s 109 S 125 a 196 NY nvoersion case 16 s 109S I 195 NY 1131 70."^ 547 1123 404 937 construi-ito case 1 109S 1136 d 127 .161 175 528 529' f lOOM 304 duty nprsnnnl 29; 81 1128 669 1145 573 939certif deposit case S s 109S a 194 NY rent case 9 s 1098 a 195 NY new trial case 4 a 195 NY 1128 572 553 VOL 125 I tel "ervice « 109 S 125 7 larceny s 109 S a 200 NY gist crime 163 109 9 assess^nents s 109 S 367 a 194 NY 555 125 96 liabiity 63 M 439 collat. attacls. 197NY 283 right action 197NY 287 22 with draw appeal s 109 a ; s 194 NY I judgment case 7 a iSl i 56; 940 (itle to land case 3 8 109S 1138 s 109 S a 196 NY 332 615 43 services s 109 S a 190 NY 5 1 check s 109 S a 194 NY ratifies f 172 369 553 153 667 718 54 jury question s 109 S 417 r 195 NY 269 1 29 787 69 per. injury a 109 S r 195 NY negligence 153 £ 90 II for jury f 153 liability f 107 172 478 478 41 436 76 contract 3 109 S 381 a 195 NY 425 rights corpn. t 7UM estoppel f 155 do 155 SIM enforced do 216 NY from state 169 39 81 83 644 316 91 foi-feiture s 109S 101 s 60.M 576 amendment SO M 579 sick benefits AC f 93 M Ijy-laws do 153 53n 165 145 94 insurance 3 109S 374 197NY 279 do business AC 220n 97 services 109 B 194 NY 92 584 101 judgment < 109 S 450 1 132 947 1 05 amendment s 109S 262 s 20 AC 210 recovery 146 678 pleading f;ase 5 I 126 902 do business 131 661 143 652 66M: 595 78 M 183 cond, precedent 65M .044 objections 71 M 217 incidental con- tract 147 795 1 1 4 transfer tax a 109 S 417 a 194 NY 400 I 17 constitutl. j 109 S 494 a 192.\Y 319 shoutd elect 72 M 301 1 27changevenue . 109 S 648 i 193 NY 663 jermanent inj. •• 129 720 land situate 164 205 132 contract 3 100 S 562 do 128 792 per. injury a 195 N Y 584 not final 135 122 fact question 72 M 84 86 burden on deft. 147 770 for jury 150 186 not assumed e 163 920 1 37 review 3 109 S 05 M commitment 71 M 92 M waiver 71 M appeals people 06 NY 619 728 by 619 144 severance s 109 S 138 liability 7CM 102JI 167, 304 785 54 169 152 will trust s 109 S 664 r 194 NY 288 not apply 152 850 compens.Ttion f 85 M 675 157 judgment + 1US 106 case 1 f 126 _ description m 200 NY sale lands 9M 901 515 387 172 constructn. s ions 0:i 7.-.JI -->M I 74 sp. prfmnce. 3 109 S 134 a 193 NY 656 covenants 134 429 ratification 66 M 506 no error in law 98 M 601 183 trespass s 109 S 75 a 196 NY 612 186 pers. Injury 3 109 S 103 128 232 compliance 128 234 notice insuf. 129 666, 682 142 941 defect fetal 129 666 notice defect f 129 683 132 P09, 814 notice claim 198NY 76 common law 15G 42 1 9 1 submission a 109 S - 340 a 195 NY 59i 1 96 presumption s 109 S 407 (41 86 settlement 163 502 f 148 S 559 t 78 M 698 perfect title 169 90 205 dismissal s 109 S 90 a 193 NY 602 209 prescription s 109 S 310 129 343 21 I opn. default 234 png. S109S p 125 3 109 S 116 do 126 296 129 6.W 133 141 133 376 d 134 66S 177 476 •62 M 235 78 M 207 f 93 M 452 relief 128 260 right order 129 327 rule practice 61 M 598 ICP NS 35 216 for jury s 109 S 325 159 924 2i9compensalK s 109S 652 128 126 q 83 M 189 counsel fee 61 M 363 costs 02 M 328 spi. proceedings 365 Aliii DEVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, c. criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; < d 130 repeals do 135 140 indemnity 74JI no repeal 151 unconstitutional 44.;|flo 151 574 44y construction 83 M 189 [u'esumption 164 659 full value 672 205 116 449 184 417 230 forbearance s 109 S 148 79 M 340 remks . 190- 261 244 impeachmt s 109 S 125 131 156 145 128 admissible f 172 36 examine jurors f 175 494 256 mandamus s 109 S 403 a 196 NY 551 domicile 73 M 479- 265 judgment 109 S 694 case 16 f 125 911 267 n.it binding i 109 S 328 134 i32 discharge a 195 NY 584 sp. performance 91 M 635 no agreement f 93 M 150 f 217 NY 231 enforcement 103M 250- 272 contract ev 109S 159 127 96 167 827 law question 129 599 150 519 scrutiny ev. 134 206 stronger proof 150 258 do 177 592 74 M claims 74M lOoJI 33S 340 357 280 contempt s 109 S 187 140 256 enforcement 103M 702 282 ev. neglig. s 109 S 16lt 145 533 due care do 149 4i negligence 185 5H(> d73M 34(t E 83 M 654 :or court t 104 415 286 damages s 109 B 97 r 195 NY 260. 291 res. ips a Ion TOS: 3 109S 71 M 135. luisance 153 207 want care 153 213; 296 franch tax; s 1098 866 a 197NY 577 31 I amendment- 1 109 S 43& 127 934: distingiiished ; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; , overruled; s, same case: do. disseminz opinion : n. parallel case: q. questioned! Vol. 125 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division judgmt. case f 143 972 318 tax sale 8 109 S 423 132 523 withdraw appl 6 195 NY 603 new issues 136 326 variance 185 188 328 regulations s 109S 868 do 147 891 average amount 151 766 distinction 151 767 do business 20 AC 216e 4 1 3 eq. action s 109 S 787 m 193 NY 262 420 commissn s 109 S 747 201 NY 215 424 compensatn 3 109S 827 a 192NY 574 attorney's lien 159 606 333 ciiampcrty 647 363 303 295 B 109 S do 128AD tax title a 195 NY s 208 NY occupancy do 145 distinction f 213 NY annulment 102M ejectment s 224NY 352 presumptii. s 109 S 132 354 contract sl09S 140 444 687 429 interference s 109 S 906 87 M 282 437 injunction s 109 S a 194 NY exemption 202 NY 452 costs al09S s 62M dismissal 138 457 practice 3 109S 126 lunatics r 192NY 885 628 326 917 351 539 514 no recovery 137 864 state motive do 148 657 strict constrcm. 76 M 567 ^42order case 3 s 109 S 139 uotice 150 158 order void 181 617 pere. injur. 3 lies 55 a 198NY 571 contrib. neglig. 147 136 619 conclusive s llOS 80 66M 412 963 898 625 practice 833s 110 S 1 34:152 194 j concurrent 878jurisdiction 539 358 decree s 110 S 69 a 193NY 67 do 126 94 burden legatee f 87 M 511 362 injunction s 109 S 779 a 195 NY 614 private person 139 34' operation 158 253 375 separation s 109 S 910 d 169 790 791 378 trial venue s 109 S 758 138 817 380 motion s 109S 726 f 136 890 384 judl. notice s 109S 900 134 902 154 150 no issue 84 M 174 475 notice good 109S 875 127 678 129 663,665 132 810, 812 479 damages 109 S 8 139 128 485 St. opening s 109S 950 137 41 498 injunction •3 109 S 132 demurrer 109 NY 213 US 848 190 568 35 without notice ■220NY 181 878 £ 186 900 629 death neg, s 109 S 1076 545 motion 'a 194 NY 526 case 1 I 109 S 1058 634 assumption 139 940 s 109 S 1079 notice essential 133 347 148 768 not apply not served I'S M 511 92 M 449' , sustained ,640 compt'Dt ev 1186 36l'sl09S 1075 133 219 55 1 burden proof I , _ 3 109S 1019 647 waiver 12S 135 s 109S 1073 negligence -^^^ 821 80 M 152 504 mot'n dism s 109 S 924 8 194 NY 536 appeal nrder a 196 NY 499 rescission 157 366 522 indictment s 109 S 840 63 M 308 527 damages 3 109 S I 131 138 do 167 173 556 judgment s 109S 1015 f 134 942 defendant title 172 782 568 liquidation 109 S 102? 134 442 579 no appeal 109S 1116 126 76 5JM 292 3 584 neg. master 109 S 1006 •» 132 805 807 complaint 172 502 s 110 S d 139 precedence 71 M convenience 71 M defects scaffold 20 AC 163n 20 AC 200n 69 1 dam. injury s 110 S 87 61 M 640 expert evidence s 144 633 695 encroachmt, s 110 S 129 138 740 motion dismiss 138 744 697 not retreat s 110 S 83 158 190 702 jurisdiction s 110 S 41 f 166 642 stay 105M 183 assignability do 178 649 98 M 654 waiver do 178 650 98 M 656 demurrer 98 M 659 one recovery 178 646 741 power ref. s llOS 96 ICP NS 7 746 citations llOS 93 183 854 750 cost offset s 110 S 129 3 125 792 f 793-4 91 M 72 787 no injunetn. sllOS 60M 61 M Sunday law 64 M validity d 104M: 213 4S7 424 940 418 350 708 estoppel slIO S 134 7 1 duces tecum 649 damages 24 128 178 182 65 I discovery s 110 S 08 129 461 130 230 134 614 136 647 d 149 111 material ev. 132 109 134 220 146 435 exam, witness 139 136 s 110 H s 204 NY 62 M decree fl42 * 196 NY validity s 201NY distribution / 77 M rents profits 152 751 752 costs s 110 S 152 |77 M „.|no costs °° 157 157 residence 185 571 .815 287 59 2!)2 339 005 513 298 50 59' """fo^ity, f U 8°''" no 3 110 fa 03 a 128 4.)g 130 463 request charge L^^ 133 146 "66 death neg iS 110 S 592 undertak's.'f IM NY 669 s llOS a 197Ny 170 74 143 for 175 jury 787 71 5 compet ev 3 110 S 2>s do 132 385 incompetent ev. 19A C 326u 718 no review s llOS 142 lOP NS 142 722 mandamus 791 injunction s 110 S 219 9.1 M 72 795 concession s 110 S 306 70 M 7 valid f 158 519 charge proper 161 748 804 leases B 110 S 186 94 M 677 649 808 negligence 650U llOS 9) |64M 64C 373 defendant proof 1159 760 754 reservation s llOS 320 81 1 allegation s 197NY enforciable 198NY 248 151 760 contract s 110 S 176 61 M 273 verdict f 131 764 cond. sale 3 110 S a 193 NY t UBM authority B6M assigned 106M 136 610 219 713 823 397 393 condemntn. s 109 S 921 r 193 NY 117 402 title to fund s 109 S 977 a 193 NY 681 contract stands 70 M 40 f 94 M 5 champerty 20 AC 177n not champrtous 96 M 262 532 sale breach s 109 S 792 3 132 657 recover profit 137 545 179 692 215 NY 105 damages 179 180 , 84 M reasonable 179 reduction 170 690 510 145 cost 691 805 „„„ , . 668 replevin cm . . s llOS 8 597 .contract, J, igsNY 519 "Oo trade fixtures 510 20 AC 112n S109S a 196 NY actual notice 151 654 compns, do 163 636 605 actual notice slODS 151 610 order sllOS f 155 1072 654 25 000 695 538 penalty s 109 S S53 61 M 280 inspct book." r 196 NY ' 302 613 ballot mark; llOS 13 60iM 422 not established 147 216 interest ceased M 612 615 estate sllO S 147 673 practice s llOS 140 176 417 676 revocation SllOS 67 case 6 f 126 929 police power 59M 37J 681 neg scaffold 6 216 llOS labor law a 195 NY 125 134 structure' 153 162 415 686 238 84 584 master neg. s 110 S 164 20 AC 157n 724 enforcement 110 S 174 20 AC 296n 725 duty court s 110 S 499 79 M 46 730 order s.llO S 314 a 193 NY 626 grand larceny 77 M 655 primary right 83 M 391 good title 175 securities 176 s 110 S 133 158 review * 195NY conversion r 198NY good title f 154 file cond. 154 personalty 159 185 f 210 NY f 217 NY realty f 160 225 41 594 1 bills 91 526 468 13 567 378 s 110 S 175 do 175 128 801 802 8l3 bill panic 142 71 159 582 825 due care s llOS 170 136 666 liability do 144 18 burd. appellant 149 738 827 recovery 3 110 S 182 130 145 830 prosecution 3 110 S 18 a 194 NY action not lie 160 756 procurement 160 757 pernl. property 167 estoppel 103M 250 78 60S 511 735 equity SllOS n M ultra vires 144 atlegation 14U 162 counterclaim 157 equity suit 157. 277 464 670 770 judgment s 110 S 108 Case 8 129 903 amendment 132 449 780 injunction 836 dismissal s 110 S 153 839 order case 13 3 110 S f 139 842 pevoiitted s llOS p 125 210 785 1 787 792-91 668 126 f 172 61 M 91M law action p 125 Sunday law 64 M objection 69 H intervention 140 validity d 104M 418 784 injunction 467 424 72 78b 640 217 601 679 s llOa ITl 301 303 907 124 39 sllOS 65 M infeience 65 M 844 long acct. s 110 S 950 164 208 burden proof 164 208 reference lOlM _692 injury bS7 232 846 pers. uos 128 notice insuf. 129 665, 682 132 809 134 I'38, 635 error court 132 . 380 notice claim 198NY W ABBREVIA'TIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; t, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note c, criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled: s. same case: do. dissentinj opinion; p. parallel case; q, queBtioaed N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division Vols. 125, 126 contrib. neglig. case 10 147 damages sllOS do 149 1301s llOS • a 196 NY R87 164 850 libel s 110 S 859 do 149 16J actual malice do 166 92 £ 97 M 32 855 germane s llOS 148 135 544 aggrieved 13G 163 pleadings 159 677 865 stenog. services s 110 S 643 68 M 439 868 brokerage s HOS 909 135 026 no recovery 137 693 fact question 154 687 d 154 688 881 recovery B HOS 135 f 167 validity f 153 as trustees ]53 fiduciary d81 M no power 183 901 title realty sUlS 111 m 200 NY 105 claim 8 151 143 902 jury trial case 7 3 109S 1128 126 203 903 death dam case 4 3 109 S 1139 a 194 NY 560 pers. injury case 10 sl09 S a 195 NY case 6 ! 109S r 197 NY injunction case 4 8 HOS a 192NY 80( 20P 886 mandamus sins 151 r 193 NY 605 889 commissions sUOS 1(109 * 194 NY 541 177 101 6^ M 111 authority 137 224 court's pwr 4B 183 475 895 discovery s HOS THC 134 94f 897 warehouse man case 1 s in9S 1124 a 195 NY 365 898 Ie?l. counsel case 2 S109S 1131 63 M 510 competent ev, 139 8 Cgn partitioji a 201 NY 576 900 pers injury Ciise 8 s ions U35 a 194 NY 173 death damge case 13 s 109R 114 a 194 NY. 520 rice 3 1126 634 life insurance case 16 sllOS 1122 a 195 NY 558 922 amendment case 11 VOL. 126 I I costs personal a nos i 194 NY f 210 NY 1137 654 1134 6S s lllS 126 I2S appeal case 4 s HOS 8 193 NY damages a 194TSy award CHSe 9 8 110 S »195 NY contract case 6 a 110 S a 196 NY off set 136 ,. liability "2^ do 148 52 521 1138 045 527 1139 526 1135 657 343 562 930 judgment caf=" H SllOS 1136 B 195 NY 587 damages 141 -r. ejectment 905iury question » 202 NY case 1 3 110 S 1123 r 194 NY 42 904 expenses 138 419 908appraisal case 2 s 109 S 1149 a 193 NY 613 909 sp. pirmance case 9 3 109 S 1137 a 195 NY 548 burd. corporatn 146 466 910 compensat' case 2 ' 109 S 1144 « 192NY 579 912 ejectment case 7 s 109 S H3(i H 195 NY 594 case s 109S 1123 o 197NY 531 93 1 services case 1 s HOS a 194 NY contract case 10 sllO S a 195 NY individual 210 NY 15 contract s 110 S a 195 NY 179 687 112 85 18 state separately s 110 S 75 157 721 157 723 do 174 684 24 bill panic. s 110 S 132 140 166 B51I 77 M 191 179 271 808 518 143 33 bill partic s 110 S 104 130 103 uu recovery 20 AC 171n 33 license fee 'l^^l^sUOS °'"'a 193 NY f 12ti labor law 1" 196 NY 1145 576 720 680 41 43 324 39 license fee s HOS 722 a 193 NY 679 12ti 43 money allow. ;)|3 franch. 1 197NY tux 577 112!) 9 I 4 error charge case 6 slOOS 114-1 r 194 NY 37 915 no jurisdictn 4 109 S " " 157 decree 181 8y M 1143 O.'Jl 763 524 9l7duces f-e 3 109 S 62 JI piiwer referee ICP NS 918 will I 197NY 1024 339 64. M liability 138 1 authority 138 1 42 license fee 8 110 S a 193 NY liability 138 662 913 679 44 injunction s HO S 75 M 701 301 43 supl. i HIS I2ci answer 102 521 bankruptcy ans. 1128 528 {attachment ■a 193 NY a lOP NS discretion 136 o{£ set e 136 vacate 78 M damages t 78 M 586 92 I pers injury nse 15 HOS a 194 NY sc 13 S8S < UOS a 195 NY 1138 625 1150 533 003 143 49- 498 warrant 499 I 109S a 195 NV AHIIKKVIATIONS: a. affirmed; d, c. crilicised : 1. limited: e. exjilained ; < 58 rights electors 5 nos 149 mandamus do 140 validitv do 149 165 motion j5 HOS i*198NY jno appeal llfil 498 1020 70 80 699 602 68 damages SllOS 080 141 234 180 510 reason, cost 179 691 72 no appeal s HOS 793 1 28 438 439 168 836 200 NY 443 146 637 inspect min. 65M 156 93 M 707 crnninal proced, 139 492 65M 152 amendment 137 764 Hnal judgment f 140 002 stenographers 7U M 196 indictment 168 172 71 M 93 M comity 71 M right appeal 155 £ 168 no review £ 165 review 166 authority 174 109 268 603 702 609 823 836 59 221 362 83 no power s HO S 236 £ 90 M 647 89 election law i HIS 140 r 192NY 443 conviction do 125 887 126 887-8 105 sp. prfmnce a HOS 282 r 195 NY 359 I 18 intention s 110 S 551 83 M 691 125 bldg bridge s 1-lOS -488 s 136 275 city's power d 136 284 137 jurisdiction s HO S 535 95 M 87 I 42 ultra vires s HOS 62 M ICP NS estoppel 143 merits el47 556 82 103 70:j 151 malice s 110 S 648 t 96 M 037 155 order s 110 S a 193 NY personalty 158 personal injury £ 145 896 l87cond prcdt e 110 S 344 6 M 549 warranty 159 190 171 penalty B 110 8 338 144 489 1 73 pers. injur, s HOS 941 197NY 529 502 179 sell sllOS 142 182 r. r. fares s HO S 936 73 M 465 penalty 177 712 199 for jury 257 good will 629 609 713 68S 645 240 460 510 82 s HOS 137 141 143 admissible 213 NY 166 650 105 131 689 332 639 210 release s 110 S 362 19 AC 433n, 438ii vestoratiou do 136 29J cond. precedent do 155 38^ 22 1 death neg SllOS 308 a 194 NY 524 due care 132 462 not delegate do 145 434 229 immaterial 110 S 523 f 173 140 231 liability 110 S 291 .M 251 98 M 233 no release 72 M 386 622 651 820 164 co-servant s 1 10 S 549 129 717 errur court 132 381 mere detail 134 39 236 amendment s HOS 503 137 434 motion relief 140 646 error court 91 M 70 240 alter ego UOS 5H 127 846 constitutional 129 860 do 862 (>ers. injury 1 196 N Y 542 vice principal 197NY 455 244 master neg. SllOS 490 r 194 NY 88 248 pedestrian s HOS 893 136 813 lor jury 13G 344 large verdict 149 800 crossings 180 102M analogy 182 698 s lies 60.\1 153 170 £ 92 M 97 M damages 183 a 196 NY for jury 161 misrepresentatu 94 M 467 no conspiracy do 183 465. 272 privilege s HOS 657 127 21 waiver s 20 AC 281 20 AC 287n admissible 153 497 cross examinatn f 164 626 282 devisable 138 207 right award f 159 865 etjuitable owner £ 175 39 285 accounting 3 HOS case 1 . £ 126 distribution a 193 NY "children' ' 136 £ 97 M i>68 937 603 640 305 520 601 289 mandamus s 110 S a 193 NY authority 66M assigned 106M 291 reviewable 110 S 42a 78 M zijU. 297 death neg- s 110 S a59 a 194 NY" 634 140 669 defendant proof ' "" 780 d 159 negligence 160 303 appeal s 193 NY contract a 196 NY justification 78 M final verdict 169 jury trial 169 837 176 55 ineonsistency do 179 68S; special master 222NY 330- set aside 105M 353 320 notice claim, 791 64r 536 170 836 419 552 s 110 S r 193 NY- pleading 131 142 327 cnnd. B HOS 61.M d 131 commissions 75M 822: 6?1 280 714 prect, 855 253 87S: :!Oft distinguished ; I, overruled : ^. followed: r, reversed: m, modified; *, disnrissed; I. rase: uo. dissenting opinion : p, parallel cas<- ; o. f Vol. 126 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division 337 limitation ■i 110 S 528 146 569 340 trial ev s 110 8 350 132 64 343 pleading s 110 S 542 f 163 241 350 trial police s 110 S 414 130 714 i 162 348 352 variance s 110 S 682 156 288 355 new trial 8 110 S 749 132 890 357 performance s 110 S 583 133 715 167 782 362 recovery s 110 S 517 70 M 517 demurrer f 173 904 363 negligence s lies ■ 857 102M 517 370 eviction s 110 S 562 132 115 20 AC. 263n 37 1 discrimina. s llOS 603 JS7 1 385 instractions s 110 S 617 do 134 128 388 allegations s llOS 663 129 669 irrevocable 132 291 test joinder — " 583 643 71 M misjoinder 150 complaint d 184 53 39 1 election law a 110 S 728 a 193 NY 232 must answer f 98 M 444 402nicch. lien s 110 S a 196 NY 68 M estoppel 98 M 724 546 377 409 ^P- perfmnce sllOS 284 a 195 NY 597 414 repayment 8 llOS 769 193NY 131 appeal a 193 NY 601 421 constitut'al s llOS 585 140 275 67M 76 ■f 93 M 359 94 M 459 424Quan. meruit s 110 S 777 144 678 427 autliority s llOS 897 179 947 43 1 amendment s llOS 575 ICP NS 245 216 NY 226 pleadings 172 502 435 public rights s 110 S 545 r 193 NY 378 special damage 147 90 439 construct'n s llOS 708 67M 127 jud'l constructn. 156 732 446 waive con- sent s 110 S 613 t 138 471 451 affidavit s 110 S 1056 85 M 577 469 damages s llOS 78 138 874 174 178 646 f 95 M 553 inadmissible 175 709 477 penalties alios 512 m 194 NY 130 479 imp.reraks a 110 S 646 157 103 do 157 106 do 157 lOS 19 A.C 458n summing up 134 917 error court 84 M 654 484 pub. cnvncs sllOP 820 a 195 NY 574 492 discretion 3 UOS 862 case 8 f 1 26 938 137 820 505 habeas corpus sllOS a 193 NY 592 en 508 ultra vires s ! 10 S 335 133 516 5 1 I fences s 110 S 506 f 86 M 273 II ■"', ' 519 interest s 110 S 405 158 646 529 Contract 3 110 S 779 d 143 493 trustees may sue 74M 541 person liable 185 715 89 M 305 544 recovery s 110 S 717 95 M 400 548 waiver s 110 S 712 20 AC 289n 556 contract s llOS 295 a 198NY 536 575 parol ev s 110 S 801 130 320 581 rec. parties s 110 S 938 139 738 demurrable 141 526 584 parol ev s 110 S 508 130 320 598sp-prformce 3 llOS 594 126 599 judgment 136 148 601 voluntary appearance s 110 S 686 f 164 109 610 assessment ^ 110 S 577 a 195 NY 618 exempt tax 138 613 do 138 616 operate cars 172 130 6r6atty. general s 110 S 280 53 M 632 319 interlocu- tory judgment s 111 S 72 150 791 637 cross exan.n s 111 S 153 .131 696 implied promise 142 700 liability do 142 701 647 denials s 111 S 130 f 165 120 550 estoppel 3 lllS 76 126 685 intervention 74M 203 657 franchise 8 110 S 1037 a 194 NY 19 660 off set s 111 S 231 164 709 liability 96 M 603 occupation 185 248 665 indictment UlS' 133 60M 316 f 98 M 557 pleading 63 M 465 constitunl rights 71 M 358 materiality 146 268 perjury base 76 M 582 lOOM 102 inadmissible 163 113 675 pleading s Ills 225 66M 182 136 684 176 864 no denial 66M 182 were essential 157 669 separate plea out 490 356 510 378 465 164 82 M strike f 164 f 171 surplusage f 93 M denials 174 106M 163, 679 future vest 8 110 S 1108 129 633 partition a 195 NY 596 gift vested 136 152 748 162 270 construction 152 161 vesting 162 260 78 M 720 95 M 45 residence d 82 M ini 687 declarations s 111 S 300 s 145 230 s 149 679 inadmissible 145 231 rulings do 145 234 partners do 153 870 703 pleading* 1 UIlS 126 126 650 70B 104M 149 liability 128 512 126 650 sureties 145 106 estoppel 80 M 367 defense denials f .165 120 demurrer f 173 833 713 exception s Ills 332 221NY 464 715 judgment 8 111 S 56 3ase 6 f 133 889 720 assessment slUS 177 r 194 S 189 731 mutualitv " 185 s Ills 144 Jo 135 recovery 77 M commission 172 748 practice s 111 S 115 129 171 692 133 60 d 150 529 counter claim do 129 176 160 510 f 166 766 equitable issues 145 834 unauthorized 150 531 special term 156 493 grant motion 157 291 750stockhldrs s 111 S 386 r 193 NY 306 notice trial 9 129 78 specif, property 67 M 559 jurisdiction 139 461 publication 147 112 763 appeal 8 111 Ci 404 a 196 NY 506 negligence f 162 792 f 215 NY 69 for jury 167 322 776 contract s .111 S 215 f 164 745 786 assumption s Ills 218 65M 508 neg. nonsuit { 135 797 custom proof 149 751 negligence do 154 5 802 labor law 8 111 S 305.309 subrogation r 196 NY 487 new trial B 154 654 807 prima facie s 111 S 196 a 193 NY 676 legisl. intent f 208 NY 247 rate wages f 208NY 248 construction f 208NY 250 314 disclosure s 111 S 172 140 528 inspect books 73 M 21 8 1 5defects neg 161 639 s Ills 61 M .-^afe place 4271134 288 318 740 exceptn rule lllS 334 127 674 assessments 150 135 do 164 881 ( 175 522 218 NY 240 98 M 159 error court f 135 297 915 818 oral ev. 3 111 S 133 parol 181 293 749 evidence' 428 829 demurrer a 111 S 322 132 181 compliance do 138 912 contract sl56 consent do 172 118 594 836 judgment 111 S 27 ease 1 f 133 459 accord 20 AC 275n f 212 NY 273 848 inadmissible 8 111 S 222 151 . 54 limited 156 892 852 injunction 3 111 8 937 126 896 do 898 change grade 140 723 904 income trust case 3 3 llOS 1122 a 194 NY 659 905 contract case a a llOS 1138 a 195 NY 591 new trial a 198NY 514 906 trust fund case 3 s UOS 1136 a 196 NY 509 907 sTibrogation case 1 s lllS 309 a 196 N y 4S jurisdiction 213US 42 909 condemnatn case 1 s llOS 1132 a 195 NY 583 case 3 s llOS 1139 rl93NY 72 reform cont. case 8 s llOS 1121 a 195 NY 677 91 I contract case 4 s llOS 1146 a 195NY 678 judgment 197NY 508 9l2unconstitu' i-nsn^ A i llOS 1141 r 193 NV 14S appealable "0 M 524 tc-ms default 70 M 523 appealable 74M ■ 451 9 1 3 chattle mget case 3 s lies 114r a 194 NY 442 commission case 9 s llOS 1129 a 195 NY 59-. libel a 197NY 475 9 1 4 committee case 4 s llOS 1127 * 193 NY 60i certiorari case 8 s llOS 1140 * 1 94 NY 54 :( review s 136 630 1184 555 1130 618 9 1 6 appeal case 6 a lies a 195 NY guaranty a 196 NY case 8 s llOS a.l93 NY neg. damage case 11 llOS 1146 196 NY 421 apl. perfmance case 12 s llOS 1141 8 195 NY 68« 919 trade name a 197NY 173 920 audit tax case 2 3 llOS 46 a 195 NY 582 easement m 196 NY 552 case 4 s llOS ]140 r J93NY 12 collision case 7 .1 llOS 1137 al95 NY 288 921 compuls.r case 5 s lies 1142 a 195 NY 615 case 9 ? Ills 1145 a 193 NY 433 922 fire insur'e case 1 s Ills 1118 B 196 NY 501 case 2 20O NY 562 master neglig. case 6 s Ills 1127 r 197 NY 27 foreclosure a 197NY 530 923 prs injury case 9 3 Ills 1111 I 194NY 625 appeals case 14 s lllS 1131 129 834 services a 198NY 512 f 172 940 924 larceny case 6 lllS 1110 196 NY 468 case 8 lllS 1148 _ 194 NY 561 sureties ease 9 lllS 1135 194 NY 424 brokerage 925 adl allowo ase 5 lllS 1133 * 193 NY 697 change venue case 8 s lllS 1114 a 193 NY , 653 926 construction case 9 s llOS 665 * 193 NY 600 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; t, (ollowed; r, reversed; m, modified; ', dismissed; a, a""^ c, criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q, questionud N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division Vols. 126, 127 dismiss motion ICPNS 141 928 injunction s llOS 738 61M 131 f lOOM 419 932 accounting case 2 B llOS a. 195 NY case 5 B llOS a 194 NY 113] 599 1149 S47 933pers. injury B 110 S 1124 a 199 NY 557 934 damages case 2 s llOS B 146 s 193 NY r 199NY court power case 7 s llOS 1146 64 M 28 accounting a 198NY 514 case 8 B llOS r 193 NY 1129 499 681 103 1148 525 936 decree case 2 B llOS 1121 a 194 NY 562 false arrest case 5 s llOS 1126 128 878 aeg damages case 7 s lies r 195 NY limitation r 197NY case 10 s llOS r 194 NY death damage case 13 s llOS 1130 a 193 NY 605 rear ument 937 distribution case 1 B llOS 868 a 193 NY 602 injunctions case 2 s HOS 1135 1127 409 210 1129 15 r 194 NY' 213 US defacto 161 212 42 938 floodi' g dam case 9 s llOS 11X£ a 192NY 54.- order case 11 s lies 1140 a 193 NY 652 services r 197NY 190 pers. injuries a 198NY 559 939 estate fund case 1 s llOS r 196NY negligence s 153 do 153 case 2 s llOS a 194 NY award 135 1150 324 508 509 1150 563 941 injunct on case 3 s HOS 1150 130 71 942b. particular case 1 s 111 S 350 t 164 213 944 assessment case 1 s HOS 829 a 193 NY 614 misappropriate case 2 s HIS a 196 NY ev. value 198NY 1123 765 88 946 certiorari case 6 s HIS 1139 a 194 NY 542 ease 7 8 HIS 130 a 193 NY 611 reduce grade case 9 s HIS H39 a 195 NY 615 947 notice claim case 4 s HIS 1119 130 607 notice purpose 133 773 commissions case s HIS 1126 133 9 case 12 s HOS 1108 a 196 NY 537 contract a 198NY 537 ipl. performance case 15 s HIS 1143 i 195 NY 599 948 enrollment case 5 s HIS 1120 r 193 NY 612 950 petition case 8 s HOS 1117 a 194 NY 583 goods sold a 196 NY contract a 196 NY case 14 a 194 NY 168 557 559 571 241 95 I transfer tax case 3 s HIS a 194 NY case 10 s HIS a 193 NY 1115 627 1147 430 case 12 li HIS a 194 NY equity 198NY 1135 588 180 571 952 intervention case 4 a 194 NY case 9 s HIS * 193 NY 538 1122 657 954 transfer tax case 1 s HIS 1135 133 295 intervention 64M ( constitutional {141 140 case 7 HIS 1145 4 193 NY 613 956 cost person case 6 s IHS 1117 a 194 NY 5S' VOL. 127 6 restoration B 111 S a 193 NY dismissal 138 270 607 497 (5 no waiver do 67 M 433 mistrial do 67 M 434 1 7 ev. neglig. s 111 S 58 f 158 448 18 for jury s 110 S 1040 d 154 880 32 no insurer s 111 S 132 104 employer risk 72 M 540 show care 151 162 defects neglig, 20 AO 155n not liable do 177 892 36 appealable sins 28 TO M 524 appealable 74 M 451 39 no extension 9 111 S 313 64 M 37 4it positive ev. s 111 S 92 149 734 52 instructed s 111 S 23 175 558 54 for jury s 111 S 255 139 161 145 in7 do 149 395 assume risk 576 68 M 58 negl. Ill S f 159 person 379 300 69 modification s IHS 136 72 order sins * 193 NY 248 361 250 659 77 mandamus s 111 S s 133 no appeal 184 22 140 158 79 dismissal s 111 S 191 82 M 49 sum. procdg. lOlM 25 jurisdiction lOSM 83 full title s 111 S 127 injunction i 196 NY 89 tenancy s 111 S r 196 NY joinder 136 installment 23 567 273 508 694 169 13 92 loss vendee 8 HIS 85 a 197NY 168 devisable 138 207 94 sp prmance. 8 111 S 344 a 194 NY 79 verbal change 158 285 rules claim 158 admissions 158 certiorari f 83 M clear proof 177 f 216 NY 283 282 924 39 98 cross remdr. 373 204 520 35 s 111 S 129 do 177 will trust r 198NY probative force 158 285 1 07 construction i 111 S 133 834 cancel tax d 134 97 no limitations 133 834, 835 validity 71 M 232 aggrieved 150 10 no valid motion 83 M 175 barred 220 NY 121 I I 8 will trust r 195 NY 339 122 murder s 111 S 258 a 199 NY 542 1 26 scaffold sill S 114 195 NY 422 30 AC 201n 130 trust fund s HIS 341 65M 420 1 47 no demurrer 5 111 S 354 134 56 I 53 correction s 111 S 476 128 886 compensution 133 797 no interest 140 88 I 65 amend order s 111 S 129 appeal a 195 NY for jury 156 481 411 535 334 I 67 lien trust s 111 S 514 62 M 540 Corp. assets a 196 NY 99 prior judgment 66M 598 affidavit 145 279 trust fund 2 CP ] enforceable 87 M 432 appeal d 170 170 1 74 probate 129 1 78 appeal a ins 128 132 143 f 86 M 749 750 10 311 102 94 94 20 92 M 78 243res ipsa loq. 70 461. HIS 180 250 s 111 S 94 11 51 542 186 certificate s 111 S 503 93 M 492 192not justified s HI S 523 143 451 194 artisan lien s 111 S 46 20 AC 127n 195 insurance s 111 S 76 a 195 NY 693 197 trespasser s 111 S 47 129 528 do 67M 87 no jurisdiction 136 691 199 nonsuit 8 HIS 48 a 197NY- . 51] 203 negligence s HI S 54 152 204 208 discovery 111 S f 163 f 180 64M 96 M order f 136 case 11 f 142 right 147 21 544 717 463 57 894 906 examine 120 209 minors s 111 S 62 M 11 106 215 reassesmt. s 111 S *193NY 6 217 875 252 injunction 8 111 S 210 d 144 237 258 notice negl. sill S 132 265 party sins f 147 120 811 wall 240 523 267 judgment case 5 s 111 S 569 f 149 924 eminent domain o 212 NY 108 212 NY 110 adverse possessn q 212 NY 111 273 liability s 111 S 1 a 67 M 392 recovery 78 M commission f 15T 867 misrepresentatn 83 M 441 52 receive^fi s 127 allowanct. 140 ■ompensation 140 754 220 for jury s HO S 1086 159 273 222 covenants 9 111 S 333 132 168 assignee 132 328 235 senior tchr s 111 S 334 133 267 salary 136 723 201 NY 465 higher salary 165 479 promotion 89 M 122 241 knowledge s 110 S 1090 f 92 M 68 penalty 92 M 73 277 liability 5 111 S 328 141 14 estoppel 183 578 278 prob. cause .«111S 202 133 705 assessment 66M 640 282 employment s 111 a 163 196 NY 548 :i86 compliance s 111 S 123 141 604, 606 Sep. assessment 210 NY 415 94 M 439 298 irrevocable 3 111 S 462 132 291 joinder 169 954 pleading d 180 157 300 distinction sins 368 134 607 negligence 67 M 437 particular defect 74M 689 305 ev. neglig. sins 281 do 134 316 310 airent deft. s 111 S 659 134 214 317 do business sins 147 do 147 211 NY 20 AO 498 537 887 427 215n ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; c. •riticised ; 1, limited ; e, explained ; o, overruled ; •, same case ; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, questioned Vol. 127 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division 319 husb. wife s 111 S 588 r 196 NY 335cOQStruction s 111 S 670 r 193 NY 537 339 practice s m S 546 152 194 concurrent jurisdiction 220XY 539 347 judgment s Ills 507 f 136 896 355 for jury 6 111 S 575 144 274 356 Sund. sports --" " U93 996 8 111 S d 173 174 do 181 61 M f 91 M 92 M 575 579 91S! 40 582 J9 moving picture? 62 M 91 M 91 M f 92 M 98 M nuthority 174 96 M e 96 M 424 damages sll2S 1136 a 193 NY 460 423 waiver 1 111 S 602 133 210,211 cancel bond a 196 NY 549 repeal prior statute 155 505 440 em. domain 3112 S 1149 a 194 NY 545 B9 M 375 444 designation s 112S 130 134 7R4 140 61 authority 140 60 publicity t 88 M 233 101 72 277 258 575 66 67 364 construction s 111 S 130 500 25-1 368 sole judge s 111 S 594 f 89 M f 92 M 420 547 no review f 176 376' legal issue'" 448 new aotice S112S 152 71 M 1-M strike out 99M 362 450 pers. injury 1 U2 S 149 a 196 NY 505 457 set aside verdict ■i 111 S • 519 'W M 597 462 powers ^ 111 S 486 143 796 468 mandamus 3 111 S 551 r 193 NY 675 ^78 no defense a 111 S a 195 NY 141 173 contingent f 91 M personalty f 173 6S( 48P !)0i 4oe 146 382 estoppel B 111 S 431 a 193 NY 13:- 385 use wharf s 111 S 432 a 196 NY 5 39 i securities a 112 S a 194 NY 5B1 S 403 reversal s 111 S 140 408 cause reversal slllS 74M reversal H9 affidavit! 99 M f lUOM 700 55S 531 54(1 575 60fl 41 I deed aside s 111 S 713 a 199 NY 574 4l5water sup'ly s 111 S 504 69 M 378 530 contract 8 111 S 892 »193 NY 648 a 197 NY 514 534 discretion • s 112 S 33 132 871 539 justification s 111 S 882 152 22 540 finding s lllS 1030 p 135 472 no 1 bonds 138 110 544 estoppel s Ills 989 do 135 790 discredit witness 157 402 173 447 555 improper s lllS 872 184 574 557 penalty s lllS 833 a 194 NY 544 justification do 212NY 420 hazardous 170 ■ 36 disapproval t 175 new trial lOOM limited 104M administrative 105M 604 132 868, 870 easement 132 871 173 23 compensation 67 M 512 postponed 132 871 awards 142 787 cond. precedent 140 64 620 contract 927 548 278 624 draft ■i 111 S a 190 NY defense 141 consideration 213 NY 306 630 insurance 3 111 S 1048 r 196 NY 337 634 trade mark s 111 S 746 al96NY377, 381 162 71 646 security s 1-11 S 1080 529 384 563 assumption 111 S r 155 261 78 480 rr const ■ ctn •ill2S m 194 NY certiorari 195 courts power. 131 511 111 S • 76 M discharged :6 M 565 liable 102M 133 543 104 493 disbarment 1 111 S 905 r 193 NY 655 revocation f 178 150 499 jurisdiction s 111 S 879 f 170 545 503 prom, note 9 HI S 974 r 195 NY 586 510 misdemeanr 5 112 S 4.T a 196 NY 77 indictment TO M 202 522 contract 3 111 S 791 a 194 NY 553 fonsideration 174 762 122S 506 not binding f 177 522 (;U M 029 rescission 145 24 whole amount 154 436 cond. precedent 154 437 567 treble dam g 111 S 985 a 196 NY 573 guarantor S7 M 292 572 bona fide 3 111 S 820 72 M 401 580 liability 912 543 56t 1057 221 476 117 801 302 neg. lllS s 135 757 64 137 175 relief 176 d 87 M 650 assessments 897 948 728 •J3B 3 111 S a 193 NY 99M filing map 200 NY discontinue 159 99M court's £ 99M 895 658 324 543 411 321 sanctn, 320 656 suspension si lis 1118 S2 M 381 no power 160 48 563 conversion 3 H2S 77 I 197NY 509 slllS 143 150 63 M (8 M 78 M master d 134 646 scope cmploym't 14l; 168 allegation 153 not liable f 83 M f 162 175 damages 214 NY for jury f 167 214 NY f 90 M evidence 90 M ^8 M 565 798 140 753 823 252 509 253 070 671 591 iurisdicticn ill2S 57 141 575 6!2 amendment s 111 S 1051. 672 review case 1 s 111 S s 111 S 144 objection s Ills 179 road bed 180 no appeal 184 omitted 106M non 106M 593 594 assessment case 2 734 736 750 736 507 432 228 590 679 frd. transfer lllS 886 a 194 NY 403 688contrib neg. a HI S 91S 129 62 132 360 136 344 164 659 assumption " 173 196 692 Burpl. money sins 736 a 193 NY 439 701 not conolu sive s lllS 1021 135 378 704 pwr. court s 111 S 993 145 272 liatiility do 152 881 721 judgment s 111 S 899 case 11 a 133 893 724 remedy 3 111 S 734 132 464 contempt do 142 4R^ 85 M 255 enforcement s 20 AC 290 729 discovery 3 HI S 1026 132 840 133 d 730 730 demurrer s 112 S 31 do 144 554 733 services i lllS 899 197NY 521 740 contempt ■■' 111 S 788 127 . 743 not modify SI M 512 not retroactive 100 596 168 939 746 mil sconduct s 111 S 932 151 590 forfeiture 162 501 761 judgment case 2 s 112 S 13 139 925 a 198 NY 54 contrib. neglig. 155 391} 804 death dam 4 111 S 812 m 195 NY 86 808 amendment s 111 S 844 f 163 465 8 1 Oiuadmissible 3 111 S 856 f 93 M 467 817 iudgr.7ent s 112 S 107 s 140 017 907 certiorari fills 1136 127 916 160 ■ 669 contempt a 195 NY 610 914 security L-ase 10 s HIS 1114 a 196NY 643 823 privilege s 112 S 140 122 625 832 s 112 S f 90 M 118 75 9 1 5 services case 12 3 HIS a 193 NY 196 NY revocation case 13 HIS a 193 NY order case 14 3 HIS a 193 NY ejectment 197NY 111 S do 164 218 NY 98 M right wav f 168 98 M 916 881 240 159 477 714 677 norce negl -.111 SI 1007 132 811 do 819 134 635 reliance 142 276 shifts risk 53 770 Indiana 3 112 S r 196 NY source title 140 79 I oral agreet 3 111 S 815 129 821 reversal ICPNS 120 enforcement 197 NY 508 incompetent e 167 837 competency 178 449 798 pers. Injury 838deatbneglie. 8 HI S 859 a 194 NY 598 843 death dam 3 HIS 797 a 194 NY 562 constitutional 129 860 liberal constrctn 143 354 846 reinstat'emt 3 111 S 808 a 193 NY . 655 veterans dischg -4M 68 competition 70 M 615 show vacancy 153 885 851 certificate ^ HIS 924 r 193 NY 248 854 submission s 112 S 1138 a 199 NY 583 87 1 presumption s 112 S 10 f 175 552 valid debt f lOOM 649 beneficiary 224NY 238 875 damages 3 112 S 229 a 194 NY 566 162 738 recovery f 161 . 190 compensation do 213 NY 496 880 damages 3 112S a 194 NY 885 libel s 112 S a 195 NY 1125 598 555 1114 609 1122 610 547 9 1 6 contempt case 2 s HIS 1114 *195 NY 610 9 1 7 pers. injuries case 7 HIS 1139 •193 NY 165 918 appeal case 1 3 HIS 1143 193 NY 617 prom, note a 198NY 513 9l9fire insurnce a 197NY 512 pers. injuries 73 M 847 f 96 M 509 authorized 186 446 395test joinder s 113 S 843 331 71 M 583 quantum meruit 6 114 S f 63 M a 199 NT excused 73 M insurer 73 M 426 415 326 inquest s 113 S 654 134 571 liuecial term 14.^. 1G9 335 invalid s 113 S 408 93 M 433 enforcement 220 NY 82 83 339imp. consent s 113 S 886 145 262 154 409 346 stockholdrs s 113 S 734 137 680 partake profits d 152 139 355 distribution s 113S 747 a 198NY 631 361 weight ev. s 113S 828 180 590 ordinary care 180 591 367 transfer tax 144 156 172 f 173 179 f 85 M proper 75M . 88 choice pleading 151 336 order £155 admission f 87 M allegations 92 M implied contrct. 185 309 404 proper party s 113 R 995 64 M 459 405 certificate 138 570 4l0ameDdment 948 572 82 529 715 367 62 372 s 113 S a 195 NY 140 exemption 138 145 130 77 M 86 M corporation f 177 790 71 M 392 d 210 NY 220 d 210 NY 223 educational e 145 712 71 M 393 397 excused 73 M 415 special burdens 76M 91 burd. comptrllr. f 77 M 60 benevolent trust f 93 M 392 678 68.3 221 115 139 54 charges 000 301 461 s 113 S 132 order 134 full costs £158 245 113 979 4SC 412 neg. super- intendent s 113S 240 136 545 153 417 418power court s 114 S 33 153 88 85 M 687 427 due care 3 114 S 228 134 613 review law 147 104 requests 152 698 reversal 180 HI pleading 186 181 435 prox. cause s 114S 70 185 891 441 commission S114S 114 dl57 866 4-13 death negl. s 114 S a 199 NT 447 trust s 114S a 198NY 158 585 146 591 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d. distinguished ; (.followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *. dismissed; n, note; c. criticised ; 1, limited ; e, explained ; o, overruled ; s, same case ; do, dissenting opinion ; p. parallel case : a. queationsd Vol. 129 N. T. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division 459 material ev B 114 S 211 134 219 specify account 131 185 pleadings I d 147 120 86 M 101 462 gamblers s 114 S 174 a 195 NY 591 467per. injuries s 113 S 1048 a 199 NY 5l41 490 appeal s 114S 154 a 198NY 560 crimes distend 77 M 205 fixtures 206 NY 646 495 enforcement s 113 S 1082 156 124 500tnaster neg. s 114S 87 do 134 918 license 144 666 51 I prom, note s 113S 1053 a 135 786 lawful holder s 135 790 514 by court B 114 S 214 79 M 51 516 practice B 113 S 991 B 129 S 519 paroles 62 M S45 deed mtge a 198NY 538 522 warrant S114S 258 jurisdiction 77 M 15 judicial notice 182 604 102M 406 527 exceptions s 114 S 344 68 M 321 529 reinstated s 114 S 296 case 9 ' 129 921 533 repairs B 114 S 13 206 NY 646 f 85 M 41 duty tenant 157 570 171 569 538recover chk. a 199 NY 516 do 215 NY 91 P 543 death negl 8 114S 282 a 197NY 599 547 brokerage s 114 S 179 67 M 610 551 mandamus s 114 S 312 63 M 614 injunction 68 M 642 558 evidence 9 114 S 66 130 266 561 replevin 3 114 S 86 3 133 275 563 requests S114S 17 133 391 r 197 NY 64 niferences 142 509 174 789 presumption ■ 161 97 623 blasting remedy 138 549 extra costs 83 M 580 630 submission 172 967 572 for jury 3 114S 276 136 345 574 injunction 114S 313 198NY 287 114S J98NY construct 143 162 residence 82 M contingent " 164 ffift ■ 220 NY power sale ' 220 NY 110 C09 436 388 655 922 578 police s 114S a 195NY 579 affidavit sll4S 63 M f 82M judgment case 10 t 129 sp. performance a 199 NY 517 uubli cation 20 AC 22 5n 581 arbitration s 114S 49 r 199NY 65 584 change will 3 114 S 197 f 144 261 587 costs s 114 S ■ 246 s 131 284 jurisdiction 215 NY 213 burden proof 215 NY 214 589court's right s 114 S 107 76 M 480 596 cross exam, s 113 S 1093 174 644 598 scrutiny s 114S 64 134 209 6 167 827 stronger proof 14M 338 for court do 177 592 600 mech. lien s 113S 1071 r 204NY 404 608 pleading 3 114 S 74 f 129 609 complaint t 165 43 6 1 3 master neg 8 114 S 38 d 64 M 175 not coservants 138 24 supervision 141 coservants SI M 313 92 585 238 278 191 215 684 ordmy ca.se s 114 S 34 688 all terms s 114S 234 139 533 216 NY 314 753 637 contract 3 113 S 1084 194 NY S8S damages a 198NY 563 639 new trial s 118S 989 134 982 uo duty 172 324 647 extension s 114 S 15 140 324 652 coservants 114 S 280 do 145 94? do 145 04D 654 judgment B 113 S 1046 129 919 657 no appeal s 114 S 182 138 534 exclude power 93 M 498 658pers. injury s ll-lS 178 a 197NY 543 660 amend ans. s 114 S 65 138 126 exculpate proof 140 709 661 notice neg. s 114 S 223 132 812 do*8l9 notice claim W8 NY 76 iniury servant s 141 770 notice purpose 151 399 666 test joinder 8 114 S 255 s 114 S 1134 71 M 6«3 allegations 92 M 461 no debt created f 175 875 not profit 103M 459 one cause 184 536 67 i defense s 114S 236 136 719 rule of law 143 536 678 notice neg^ 3 114S 264 132 813 notice purpose 151 400 demurrer case 1 153 f 166 >9I unauthorized s 114 S 447 150 531 grant motion 157 291 694 strike out s 114 S 139 139 52 170 63 902 952 695 assignment 8 113 S 1080 72 M 268 698 caveat emp- tor 3 114 S r 199 NY 78 222 354 590 70 1 devise s 114S a 197NY disability 76M: 703 pleading s 114 S 486 157 336 707 erroneous theory 8 114S 75 66M 501 award 66M 508 reversal 66M 510 claim 67M 98 M 129 762 validity 129 763 discrimination 137 162 injunction m 199 NY 128 762 new trial a 199 NY 525 763 judgment sll4 S 194 f 132 94 768 judgment case 1 s 113 S 986 _ 137 880 irersonal injuries * 201 NY 528 772 amendment 113S 1097 132 794 competent f 206 NY 599 777 judgDjent UBS 946 case 9 s 137 931 780 services 8 114S a 198NY liability 207 NY 66 719 71 I just compen. 138 _ 172 not set aside do 147 517 not excessive do 148 561 713 tor jury s 113 S 1017 143 51 153 214 nuisance 143 52 7 1 7 rehearing 707 930 522 227 228 s 114 S case 7 f 129 damages 67 M 73 M a 73 M power court 87 M 591 728 negllg. ev s 113 S 959 137 757 735 bond s 114 8 f 196 N'i 866 removal s 114 S 375 * 197 NY 44 justification 141 64 890fidelity bond 198NY 531 891 deductions 3 113 S 1133 case 5 132 836 895 reargumeut case 1 3 113 S 132 decree case 9 113S al95 NY 242 568 521 care 631 80 501 745 indemnity - — 44 567 785 ordin, 8 114S 185 869 degree care 186 876 791 for jury s 114 S 667 143 689 798 corroboratn s 114 S 687 212 NY 253 805 assessment 114S 779 a 198NY 570 816 claim clear 8 114 S 127 153 576 competency 79 M 673 167 827 821 duty state 3 113 S 1101 161 278 211 NY 260 833 not apply s 113 .S 1056 162 921 90 M 680 county court f 91 M 518 843 Corp. indict s 114 S 755 a 195 NY 102 847eq. conversn 8 114 S 855 87 M 48 85 1 petit larceny 3 114S 833 r 195 NY 190 176 186 941 431 1129 S9 1128 S70 pers. injury a 197NY 584 897 em. domain case 2 3 113S 1143 a lOSNY 385 90 1 contract a 198NY 635 903 services case 1 s 113 S 1146 contribution a 198NY 531 death damage case 8 S113S a 198NY case 7 s 113 3 194 NY brokerage a 198NY case 10 sllSS allegations 138 911 policy insur case 13 s 114S * 194 NY cancel tax case 7 8 114S a 195 NY i n tervene case 12 s 114S * 196 NY 1127 574 1125 686 621 1127 141 904 judgment S113S 112 cases t 133 888 goods sold a 198NY 541 pers. injuries a 198NY 545 deed void a 199 NY 518 905 transfer tax case 1 sllSS a 194 NY 85 M vested 150 1136 505 685 808 8 114S !i 198NY cotenants 149 subrogated f 86 M 752 rentals S114S 339 906 ev. proof 198NY 175 injunction m 198NY prom, note 198NY partition a 198NY new trial a 200 NY accounting a 200 NY 858 judgment 3 115 S 1063 ca.'ie 6 fl33 920 death damage a 197NY 588 defendant liable 151 135 998 employer 546 590 632 529 530 910 sum. review case 5 8 114S 1130 a 194 NY 592 mandamus case 7 E 114S a 196 NY revocation case 6 s 114S a 196 NY 1142 617 1127 523 1140 594 1118 529 1122 564 912 mandamus s 114 S 1142 s 139 88 concluded s 139 95 9 1 6 money loand case 4 s 114S * 195 NY contract r 199 NY remittitur sl48 modification sl48 case 1 s 114 S 162 1118 524 342 683 ' 684 689 721 1128 394 9 1 9 reargument case 2 s 114S s 132 liability 146 496 case 6 change venue s 114 S 1128 154 323 920 mech. lien 198NY 542 9'i\ vacate judt le 1 8 114S 1143 a 195 NY 573 case 3 law question 114 S 149 jointly case 6 8 114 .S 149 1132 204 1132 649 909 liq. tax law case 12 s 114S 1149 r 195 NY 214 death neglig. a 197NY 537 m 199 NY 466 prom, note a 198NY 566 922 liability r 19SNT 390 sp. performance a 199 NY 579 fire insurance a 202 NY 569 923per8. injury a 197NY 596 new trial a 198NY 626 924 case 2,3 51143 1141 1 196 NY case 4i ^ 8 114S a 196NY case 6 s 114S a 196 NY ease 7,8 s 114S 567 1141 567 1141 567 1141 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguiihed ; f. followed; r. rerened; m, modified; •, dismissed; c, criticised; 1. limited; e, explained; o,. overruled; s, same case; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q, n, «o<«! N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division Vols. 129, 130 a 196 NY dismissal case 9 S114S a 199 NY valuation 104M 662 1147 536 r 202 NT 402 1142 140 1147 60 573 704 925 mandamus case 2 s 114S 5 133 damages case 12 s 114S s 195 NY a 198NY lis pendens case 4 s 114S 1143 * 195 NY 1B7 dismiss police case 7 s H4S 1142 a 195 NY 617 929 each costs case 9 sll4S 142 147 f 86 M f 96 M 96 M 938women d 137 invalidity 137 vote 419 VOL. 130 I new trial s 114 S 31 fl40 9: 681 144 656 584 45 47 930 sp. prfmnce a 198 NY 584 931 discovery case 11 s 114S 1183 a 194 NY 597 death neglig. a 197NY 585 932freight chge. a 202 NY 569 contract case 2 fire insurance a 202 NY 569 case 4 fire insurance a 202 NY 569 case 5 fire insurance a 202 NY 569 case 8 S114S a 199 NY privity 72 M case 10 a 198NY 1125 572 173 591 933pers. injury a 198NY 631 a 199 NY 592 934 easement a 198NY 160 liquor tax bond a 197NY 535 935 neffligence r 198NT 221 ejectment s 137 462 personal injury a 200 NY 393 936 death dam. a 197NY 587 damages a 198Ny goods sale a 198NY surety a 201 NY 468 540 578 937 liquor law case 2 • s 135S 1137 a 195 NY 595 inj. servant a 198NY 362 warranty s 114S 117S 17 negligence 293 1014 459 933 394 20 order sll4S f 131 162 amendment 164 873 173 790 27 conclusion s 114S 326 132 343 pleading prf. s 133 73 74 impress trust 199 NY 589 38 life insurance 114S 268 al95 NY 571 written clause d 106M 141 42 pay back 114 S 424 94 M 611 46 affidavit 114 S 417 151 414 177 642 not defect 161 477 by lot. Block nos. 161 477 53 equitable s 114 S 497 70 M 366, £ 367 94 M 451 equity court 153 646 refuse relief 153 647 statutory 153 97 M 97 M limitation 153 dismissal e 173 without decree 98 M 529 estoppel 177 165 decision limited 177 166 equity relief 105M 503- clean hands 105M 504 no answer 10511 88vacate award s H4S 289 179 110 185 887 92 superior lien 8 114 S 489 137 619 attorney's lien d 176 73 M 103M motion £155 may waive d 103M no equities 103M 165 34 282 915 281 214 possession s 114S 536 f 215 NY 17 66M 301 limitation 155 439 441 155 442 deed voidable 161 65 94 284 I 1 bill partic s 114 S 271 153 58 lOOM 172 1 1 2 mandamus 8 114 S 702 a 19B NY S19 civil service f 130 118 laken as true do 145 654 affidavit 151 414 119 sui juris a 114 S 508 do 133 850 burden Infant 166 391, 392 72 M judgment case 12 t 152 350 appraisal 3 114 S 571 229 discovery a 195 NY a 114 8 473/ order 65 M 171 f 134 compliance stct. value 71 M 441 do 198NY 96 97 231 no liability compensation -•■•■■"= 607 66M 503 838 market value 74M 1 f 92 M 491 evidence 370 s 114S 136 648 115 141 650 768 70Iiability 114 S 83 M no breach f 163 78 penalty 114S 198NY 8G reversal s 114S 135 to jury 146 allegations ■^4M provable 156 167 172 error court 158 505 test 455 587 772 506 684 349 435 80-1 223 499 261 306 238 "siu juri 3 114 S 582 eviaenct do 133 850, 851 239 US jury rjuestion do 133 death neg 195 NY 151 24 1 per. injuries valuation 562 933 corpatn. dummy 476 153 284 1 24 larceny s 114 S al95 NY 135 embezzlement 117S 628 default 137 842 1 34 discovery s 114 S 34S 137 940 d 168 143 1 35 prox. cause sll4 S 591 134 430 148 compensat'c s 114 S 5fl5 142 683 !66 judgment case 8 s 114 S 623 f 137 945 178 partition sn4S 398 119 202 (82reason. time 253 order 3 114 S f 130 652 199 201 90 114 S 150 no breach contract 150 waiver 10411 (93 new trial s 114 S 960 138 273 f 83 M 597 200ind. contrctr s 114S 646 136 544 protect wrkmen 139 76 assumed risk 148 630 493(reversal 251 335 appeal ' 140 528 s 114S 636lbooks evidence * 195NY 5621182 310 343 conclusive kge unsafe bldg s 114 S 642?'? 14. S lOlf a 200 NY 287 precautions 180 87 130 a 197NY 851 356 appraisal s 114S 575 563 a 196NY 573 540 present value s 114S :i 198NY for jury 147 f 167 674 532 861 360 order 129 resp, superior . 114 S £ 130 do 147 870 cause action 429 718 886 365 not binding 259 submission s 114 S 561 r 202 NY 624 265 new trial ill4S 130 s 114 S 76 M conclusive 152 610 b83 267pers. ? 114S a 197NY negligence case 8 do 138 175 right to wait 143 218 not liable 204 NY duty city 314 NY injury 578 544 924 359 393 267 276per. injuries s 114S 516 r 198NY 540 297 assessment rii4s ,S53 141 1( dismissal f 93 M 59fl insufficient 9gM 393 305 acct. stated s 114 S f 92 M 329 order 114 S 131 binding 159 assumption ■ 179 166 157 81" 921 384 procedure 157 relief 160 331 98 M deemed true 332franchise u 89 M 114S 460 95 M . 198KY 605 dividend 158 113 ■! 410 affid. proof s 114 S 896 o,.^41. ^01 Kv-j requirement ^''*f82M 37,368 007 jurisdiction ^^^ 102M 429 417 brokerage s H4a 997 137 564 173 109 105 86 M 38 burden proof 172 315 recovery 1.81 27 160 E 178 55 Sll 424 conversion s 114S 1080 a 198NY 575 440 contract B 114 S 864 72 M 478 _ex loci ,72 M 479 presume neglig. s 145 273 20 AC 20 AC scaffold 20 AC 797 589 110 371 damages s 114 S 846 97 M 358 378 restriction s 114 S 949 145 788 386 by jury s 114 S 893 84 M 641 38? judgment s 114S 890 135 430 138 819 144 537 do 144 550 do 149 464 do 171 733 180 683 89 M 537 95 M 96 M 98 M appeal 135 585 do 588 „„ , motn. to dismiss 146 68 M 547 costs rules at trial 143 144 145 motion pleading 73 M 403 admissions 149 16 bill particulars 140 motion 157 1018 702 151n 156n 200 444 justice deft. s 114 S 1023 137 32T on merits f 162 892 446 lex loci s 114 S 964 149 905 171 138 78 M 451 distinction 79 M 640 presumption d 138 101 recovery d 162 101 45ljudgt. pldg s H4S 135 138 65M 73 M appeal -- - do 135 334 agreement 257 s 200 NY 309 by motion 141 no cause s 143 956 436 819 555 403 588 IS 800 10 245 273 454 construction 3 114 S 975 a 195 NY 346 — - f 94 M 49 471 „„- 465 pleading 28-J s 114S 98 ,do 13."; 286 part plant 795 309 587 537 334 470 contract s 114S 969 a 198NY 336 478 authority 393 allegations s 114S 1065 114 S e58l74M 480 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d. distinguished; f. followed; r, reversed; m, modiHed; *, dismissed; n, note c, criticised ; 1, limited; e. explained ; o, overruled; s, same case; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case; q, questioned Vols. 130, 131 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division 87 M 148 491 death negl. s 114S 1044 a 197NY 597 not delegate do 145 434 496 judgment case 21 s 114 S 1052 f 137 924 504 safe scaffold s 114 S 1036 s 141 5^0 not justified 20 AC 16211 5 1 8 trade nan s 114 R 103 130 514 appearance 166 8 52 ( injunction s 115S 23 a 198NY 623 title a 198NT 622 compensation 67 M 512 easements 160 102 173 37 182 608 183 567 528 order bindg s 115 S 6 134 419 carrier 130 697 limit liability 139 20 contract binding 151 684 repudiation 78M 373 receipt ev. 95 M 597 555 cnipnl.ref S115 8 43 135 55 s 135 549 561 presumptn. 8 115 S 34 79 M 76 authority 106M 822 576 eviction s 115S 40 117S 879 581 responsible s 115 S 54 M 396 reversible 140 S 665 liability 155 590 598 structures s 115S 564 do 66M 471 for jury s 202 NT 589 605 purp. notice s 115 S 334 133 772 cond. precdt. 135 23 notice clain* M8NY 77 msuffic. notice 142 y4r 609fees referee 115 S 339 f 164 139 689 bill partic. s 115 S 332 159 876 '1 177 459 693 judgt. pldg. s 115S appeal do 135 136 406 588 436 311 696 costs S115S s 131 568, 569 contract 137 distinction 139 estoppel 68 M carriers 199 NY 229 20 326 170 value property s 131 936 834 repavmg 8 115 S 872 130 840, 842 f 154 936 839 judgment s 115 S 876 f 154 936 845 complaint s 115 S 93 d 77 M 475 allegations f 158 437 89 1 pers. injury * 197NY 546 liquor tax a 200 NY bond 564 199 NY effectual 151 enforced 151 actual loss 156 error court 223 US 176 853 531 mecii. Hen s 114S 1107 p 136 30 a 199 NY 600 f 91 M 243 materid.! man do 138 509 200 NY 498 preference f 200 NY 98 M lien attacks SIM lien f 172 dSlM 81 M destruction 81 M no action f 89 M construct do 172 priority 172 499 335 69 567 219 92 774 546 not retroact constitutional s 115 S 28 131 640 67M: 165 6? M 165 trust estate 138 837 subject levy s 144 548 parol S115S 68M strike 149 169 out 288 469 784 610 contempt s 115 S 500 * 195 NY 612 618 deposit s 115S 503 a 198NY 590 estoppel 173 290 626no leave ct. s 115 S 393 140 617 632duty emplyr s 115S 425 136 488 death damage a 196NY 576 liability 155 590 645 intervention 3 lis S 457 137 768 64 M 626 property right 68 M 368 iury trial 103M 101 650 fee s 115 S 578 163 688 abandonment 181 371 654 brokerage 115 S 383 f 84 M 452 653 stree t r. r. s lis S SSI r 196NY 158 678 relief 138 142 stockholders a 201 NY 184 s 201 NY 185 rights 164 497 use capital stk. f 164 497 164 498 707 receiver s 115 S 330 132 851 7 1 6 general act s lis S 755 133 562 taxing power 136 423 constitutional 157 702 160 174 853 liability s 115 S 140 advances 80 M f 91 M commission 105M 860 relief s 115S 137 jurisdiction 68 M by motion 68 M surrogate 70 M 625 7 732 new trail s US S 284 do 134 393 for jury 144 274 748 contract s 115 S 769 s 154 523 760 conviction s 115S 374 a 195NY 554 punishment 157 494 felony 158 219 76? conclus'e ev s 115 S 141 49S 783 incredibile s 115 S 533 142 546 failure proof 151 36 165 569 796 services a 200 NY 560 liability 151 744 reversal 165 186 consideration 165 537 94 M 259 contract 165 538 orig. promise 172 619 debtor 224NY 501 958 15 648 903 571 474 336 542 200 892 will * 195NY tax sale a 197NY death neglig. a 197NY 609 set aside deed a 199 NY 590 foreclosure a 200 NY 596 167 885 subdued action 166 380 893 death neg. 635 foreclosure a 198NY damages s 197NT 298 * 197 NY 298 smoke nuisance a 199 NY 207 g07sldew'k neg, r 199NT 79 803 accountable 8 115 9 622 133 68 819 motion 115S 698 863 after born s 115 S 938 200 NY 374 875 death dam. 198NY 102 876 probate 195NY 570 877 money had 197Ny 586 surety bond a 198NY 583 demurrer 198NY mechanics a 200 NY complaint do 147 damages 153 510 892 755 413 626 li< 5.53 suflPic 800 424 878 undertakg, 135 433 879 services a 197NY 610 880 review asst case 5 s 114S 1142 a 196 NY 520 assessment a 195NY contract 198NY money had a 198NY 568 352 587 882 assessment a 195NY 608 884 services case 6 s 114S 1120 * 195NY 605 life insurance 198NY 535 887 contract s 314 S 1150 s 141 20 888 assessment case 10 s 114S 514 a 195 NY 618 198NY motion 198NY 894 venue s 114 S 137 delay lOlM 896impress trst. a 197NY 552 fire insurance a 198NY 577 897 surplus 115 S 1108 a 200 NY 501 898 adoption a 197NY 193 publn. portrait s 197NY 558 foreclosure a 198NY 546 pers. injury 198NY 589 damages " 201 NY 2irp 900 election case 1 s 114S 1142 a 195 NY 493 902conBtr'e will a 197NY 545 foreclosure a 198NY 547 sp. performance a 198NY 565 premiums a 198NY prom, note a 198NY goods sold a 199 NY 172 588 595 893 903 motion I95NY mech. lien « 198NY contract r 199 NY "appointed' case 5 84 M 94 M 559 565 557 455 905 damages case 1 * 195 NY probate case 4 115S a 196 NY decree 195NY dander 197NY pers. injuries » 197NY 553 » 197NY 609 assessment 1 199NT 71 906sp. primnoe. ■ 195NY 561 611 1127 565 603 482 VOL. 131 I pleading 8 115S 360 r 198NY 348 conclusion 138 902 burden plaintiff 145 212 8 judgt. pldg. s 115S 475 135 436 appeal do 135 588 repairs landlord 166 269 proximate loss 104M 586 duty 105M 51 1 7 recovery s 115 S 402 d 146 573 compliance f 85 M 481 assume 102M 233 18 surplusage 102M 697 24 construction s 115 S 413 s 141 486 recovery 72 M 476 30 removal s 115S . 664 a 196 NY 221 executive act 70 M 11 no power f 82 M 289 63 individually s 115S 809 do 149 157 presumption 165 392 75 default open sll5S case 3 140 79 relief sllSS 131 full costs f 158 amendment 159 f lOOM 962 145 241 236 143 8 1 effect decree s 115S 239 135 147 parties bound f 82M "fraud" 158 application 99M 16 371 9 1 superior s IISS 137 value land 67 M approval lOOM 456 lien 495 619 497 431 97 for jury s 115 S 224 144 274 1 01 prox cause s 115 S 291 71 M 34 duty master 144 673 1 1 exception 'll5S 305 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f. followed: r, reversed; m, modified c, criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, dissentinz opinion; p, parallel case dismissed; n, note: q, qucationed N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — ^Appellate Division Vol. 131 131 2S6 competent ev. 139 852 damages a 199 NY 542 ev. insufficient 152 87 120 prom, note 8 115S 227 a 197NT 595 burden defendt. 149 f75M reversal £75M dismissal 88 M 277 390 390 131 no recovery B 115 S 345 77 M 226 136 3ui juris 8 115 S 93 do 133 8S0 rr. negligence s 141 8S0 140 reargument 8 115S 135 r 198NT 572 I42pers. injury 263 630 s 115S r 198NT evidence 142 error court case 2 t 139 513 921 I47abuttinelnd s IISS 133 title fee do 133 awards do 133 nom.daiuages do 133 335 l52proof neglig. "" " 130 152n 208 323 333 334 s 115 S 20 AC Bcaffold 20 AC d 95 M for jury 1 165 199n 130 755 1 57 vitiates policy s 115 S 372 f 164 647. I661>y execution sale lands 99M 38 199 indemnity 8 115 S 591 m 213 NY 124 210 judgment 8 115S 923 f 132 915 injunction 216 damages s H5S a 198NY 741 586 224 decree 8 115S r 197NY motion 8 132 688 4S6 896 228 detail work 8 115 S 635 do 133 916 233 allegat ions 8 115 S R7r f 165 120 98 M 481 don't deny fact 98 M 481 236court's pwr. 8 115 S 7'^1 138 483 injunction a 203 NY 113 239paymi. costs s 115 S 139 778 679 629 931 940 241 order S115S fl57 167 rural counties f 90 M 56 244 reasonable time s 115 S f 162 648 826 247 liable 8 115 S f 97 M 720 375 s 115 S 144 notice 177 174 public nuisance s 115 S 78 M d 209 NY validity 159 255 657 253 judgment case 1 s 115 S 673 t 137 899 269constr'e will £ 115S 804 8 136 678 cond. precedent 88 M 427 277 incompetent il48 negligence s 209 NY 925 ice 303 judgment s 115 8 338 f 131 917 pers. injury f 84 M 48 306 appeals s 115 S 779 r 199 NY 268 328 evidence 8 H5S 8 136 binding f 91 M 832 134 333 death negl. 8 1158 767 a 197NY 605 339 propr charg sllSS 817 m 196 NY 95 347 new trial s 115 S 796 131 92] constitutional f 199 NY 187 neglect damages a 199 NY 178 valid statute 142 124 qualifications 7411. 510 cond. precedent 158 136 fix fares 95 M 688 amend charter 95 M 68! 352 ejectment 399husb. & wift 8 1158 1036 65M 447 448 79 M 660 intentions 79 M. ownership f 158 absolute title 158 340 authority 158 1 387 338 564 injunction s 1153 926 a 198NY 576 429 motion s 115S s 132 conspiracy 70 M no redress f 160 damages do 223NY 341 207 305 443 allegations sll5S 316 CM 340 jurisdiction 144 92 447 negligence ^ase 13 8 115 8 Ho 138 s 212 NY 389 914 141 8 1158 a 198NY reservation do 151 forfeiture 211 NY 734 575 517 297 193 211 794 I84materl e^ B 115 S 254 134 218 193 cloud title 8 1158 644 * 198NY 597 test tax titles 150 12 judgment fl55 repeal 157 83 M exclusive rule 210 NY 416 913 405 173 8 115 8 case 4 153 590 938 697 149 714 278 extras sll5S r 200 NY pleadincf 142 form denial 151 409 70 M 135 not permissible frivolous 202 NY 92 78 M 513 288 laws of Turkey 8 115 S 213 NY legal eiefect 177 ' 356 liberal construction s 115 S 175 115 116 36 1 insurance s 115S 480 198NY 495 365 lien realty s 1158 289 a 198NY 633 3728caffold neg, 8 1158 327 d 136 103 master neglig. 20 AC 156n f 167 602 387 law questn. s 115 S 273 169 717 391 authority 8 115 S 911 81 M 493 92 M 383 power court 650 435 30 1 judgment s 115S 865 171 f 90 M rcverasl 182 711 571 92E 396 relationship s 115 S 829 141 796 new trial 142 898 general service e 83 M 114 453 reargumenl s 1158 340 8 132 945 461 electors 8 115 8 407 174 718 472 demand nee 572 spl. damage 3 1168 71 66M 262 26,1 damages 141 •JM 145 165 146 84 592 new trial 8 116 8 204 a 199 NY 591 contract a 199 NY 518 599 libel 8 116S fi7X * 196 NY 515 not libelous 180 764 605 fact questn. s 116 8 155 154 687 d 154 688 617 invalidity !i lies 11 182 466 822 624 120 100 293 178 16 70 127 815 126 421 346 8 115 8 r 200 NY bonds 8 163 liability 179 477 contrib. neg s 115 S 364 156 31 492fellow servt 8 115 8 1019 144 669 vice principal 148 nonsuit do 145 liability 160 354 89? 606 494 contract s 115 8 999 a 199 NY 314 503 conditions 8 115 8 483 155 59 528 injunction s 115 8 1026 d 144 237 542 damages s 115 8 319 8 138 409 545 review assmt 8 1168 1057 a 196 NY Sli- 555deny damag. a99 195 s 115 S 72 M review 91 M 559do business s 115 S 625 143 652 147 537 20 AC 213n 625 for jury s lies [148 exhibits 158 limit rule 160 trover lOOM 399 639 not retroact 61 177 537 147 172 s 116 S 132 118S retroactive 64 M disap 133 difference 196 NY execution 135 judgt. creditor 67M 164 641 admitted s 116 8 55 73 M 429 647 certiorari 3 116S 138 r 197NY 548 12 110 98 940 891 235 147 611 654 severance suit s 116 8 139 f 169 ■ f 173 181 658 decree 8 116 S a 195 NY income f 88 M 682 inadmissible sll6S 59 148 636 685 recovery 8 116 8 96 146 573 tIo business do 183 688 order s 116 a a 195 NY 72 014 613 696 damages s 116 S 471 a 197NY 518 132 138 141 152. e 160 162 do 179 f 216 NY barred 139 confirmation 142 786 pay interest 144 578 premature s 145 authority T5M street closed 149 64 do 162 296 167 629 e 173 20 182 608 opening street 152 118 dedication 152 754 presumption 860 512 153 award 153 168 174 private easemt. 160 82 173 f 216 NY 13 219 NY 40e street differs 160 99 easements 182 settoff 186 f 131 197NY 794 363 795 discovery 8 116 8 138 140 141 146 180 64 M 65 M 87 M f 93 M ordei 134 318 251 804 521 413 718 464 171 278 133 946 608 673 742 accounting 8 1168 135 revocation e 162 747 reversal 51 408 116 8 172 751 order sll6S f 156 description e 209 NY 209 NY 90 143 R-J' 33S court power 135 . 285 801 atty's lien s 116 S 385 341 lOii pro tanto 141 197 decision binding do 141 197 812 nuisance B 116 8 46 f 91 M 123 823 discovery s 116S 95 d 148 245 f 160 260 826valid defense s 115 8 215 138 _ 89 ph ys. joined 75M 619 in writing 154 3S8 oral evidence ( 9911 511 829 death dam. 3 1168 249 ■i 197NY 434 jurisdiction 197NY 439 no jurisdiction 70 M a 144 834 decree s'116S a .196 NY 755 easement s 1168 a 198NY injunction fSlM 149 581 522 759 parties plff. s 116 8 228 139 283 publication 20 AC 235n 767 authority 353 511 444 s 1168 136 63M legislature 99 M 774 error court s 1168 234 do 135 290 letting complete f 91 M 21 11 terms 94 M 696 •oral evidence 177 236 780 alteration s 116 8 306 79 M 155 791 atty. lien s 116 S 245 341 94 243 633 837 injunction 3 116 8 404 a 196NY S23 75M 300 153 • 366 in personam f 99M 310 854 retroactive s 116 S 289 20 AC 45n 859 atty. lien s 1168 339 s 136 771 objection 136 773 865 guaranty a 199 NY 517 868 order 3 116 S a 196 NY 872 award s 116 3 a 200 NY 336 571 334 511 877 coramissn. sll6S 75M demurrer 155 intention 325NY 358 305 516 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, dUUnguished; f. followed; r, rcTersed; m, modified; ♦.dismissed- n not.- c, criticised; 1. limited; e. explained; o, overruled; s. same case: do.'dissentinz ooinionrS Siral el r,T/? n •„„';;.?°'!j aissentmg opinion; p. parallel case; q, questiooed Tols> 131, 132 N. 7. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division 879 contract > 117 S 365 * 199 NY 529 143 165 885 reas'be care slieS 311 142 340 judgment ease 5 fl42 907 distinction 151 580 897 contract a 198NT 574 898 recovery case 5 I 115S 1132 s 195 NY 616 fire insurance T 198NY 569 contract a 198NY 572 a 199 NY 593 injunction a 199 NY 544 900 goods sold ■ 197NY 556 pers. injuries r 199 NY 283 goods sold a 199 NY 546 90 1 contract s 115 S 1128 1114 a 199 NY 541 a200NY 530, 531 pers. injury a 199 NY 545 republisli 73 M 155 902 ease 7 a 217 NY 620 903 amendment * 195NY 575 salary ease t 115S 1138 118S 484 appointed ease 6 84 M 557 905 mandamus a 195NY 571 9 11 pers. injury ease 4 a 197NY 601 9 1 5 power sale case 4 a 115S 1119 T 196 NY 330 claim a 198NY 619 retax cost * 196 NY 561 016 services ease 2 a lies 1141 » 196 NY 614 917 special performance ease 7 I 115 S 1142 a 203NY 603 equity court 1,64 66 918 report case 2 s 115 S 1118 a 203NY 592 case 15 a 197NY 420 relaxation case 13 196NY 561 919 per. injury s 115 S 1125 a 200 NY 550 judgment f 143 972 920 foreclosure a 198NY 633 921 motion a 195NY 563 mandamus a 198NY 533 recovery a 198NY 621 contract a 198NY 636 appeal 200 NY 234 922 insurance case 1 171 673 case 2 s 148 817 a 199 NY 188 case 4 r 197NY 324 s 209 NY 33 case 5 a 200 NY 582 property rights case 8 d 148 826 923 decree case 13 s 115S 1136 * 196 NY 564 lunacy * 19.5NY 574 services a 202 NY 560 924 death neg. a 197NY 596 a 199 NY 515 925 notion case 1 B 115S 1J23 s 196 NY 6re insurance a 197NY 547 partition case 1 a 200 NY 561 926 negligence a 197NY 591 slander a 197NY 60« compensation a 199 NY 40!i 927 goods sold case 1 B 115 S 1144 a 207Ny 717 929 s 116 S 165 124 926 93 1 pers. injury r 198NY 592 goods sold a 199 NY 597 932 recovery a 197NY 604 credit suit a 199 NY 97 dismissal a 199 NY 526 .sham member 202 NY 109 933 atty. lien case 2 a 196 NY 258 935perB. injury a 198NY 844 abortion a 196NY a 196 NY contract s 150 554 554 515 VOL. 132 3 libel s 116S r 197NY 362 488 7 reformation s 116 S 402 133 317 plead issue 133 3t8 135 749 allegation 89 M 577 10 pers. injury s 116S 352 a 197NY 541 22 contrue will a 198NY 688 25 tender delivery s 116 S f 163 complaint 179 380 188 29 permits s 116 S 248 96 M 40 50 waiver s 116 S 73 M 871 253 56 substitution s 116 S 317 f 188 786 199 NY 381 liability 76M 53 6 1 public health 138 3] 68 for jury s 116S 518 ■99M 679 99M 681 7 1 injunction s lies 1071 * 195NY 613 r 197NY 457 76M 42 75 condemnatn. s 116S 495 a 195NY 502 authority 65M 326 82cond. precdt. s 116 S 433 67 M 586 property rights 72 M 280 usable value 20 AC 104n noise nuisance t 94 M 476 89 authority s 116S 453 148 24 93 not appealable s 116 S 309 93 M 49 96 counterclaim s 116 S 411 168 228 I03employ. risk 5 116 S 326 7« M 540 presume neglig. 30 AC 151n 20 AO 152n master neglig. iO AO 157n scaffolding d 155 404 not liable f 160 18 171 824 108 diseorery s 116S 466 134 614 pleading 146 435 74 M 200 1 1 implied contract s 116 S 445 155 390 1 1 2 full costs s 116 S 454 f 158 486 1 14 eviction s lies 512 146 435 dl49 9 20 AO 261n 20 AO _ 262n deposition 74M 200 no examination -4M 200 I 1 6 discretion s lies 530 180 321 1 1 8 trespass s 116 S 532 a 200 NY 5r!3 adv. possession 138 586 f 174 335 construction e 216 NY 372 125 will gift s 116S 466 a 198NY 297 128 services s 116 S 513 s 196 NY 564 1 33 contract s 116 S 514 do 156 680 134 residuary s lies 756 a 19SNY 701 lapse legacy 68 M 280 gift to close 138 282 CO tenants 76M 83 broad constrctn. 80 M 204 gift to class 106M 137 139 good title 3 116 S 389 134 5S4 do 585 judgmt. case 9 t 143 951 terminate estate 144 760 fee vested 202 NY 474 title passes 147 47 vested remaindr 152 748 95 M 44 and to the Issue 152 749 allegations 78 M 558 86 M 642 cond. subseqnt. 84 M 210 vested estate f 84 M 211 award judgmt. 166 95 I46grand larc. slleS 91 al96 NY 506 I56relay paymt. B 116 S 765 77 M 239 requirements f 161 295 169 discovery ell6 S f 158 f 171 r64 M 91 M d 91 M 97 M spl. circumstnc. 136 648 67 M 562 bill particulars 136 652 exam, witness 139 136 139 672 liberality 106M . 199 241 submission 702 424 469 «90 492 390 196 NY 135 607 284 1042 405 505 176 retroaetive B116S rl96 NY disap 64 M execution 185 167 859 141 12 j^idgt. creditor 67M o 67 M 177 bill sll6S 149 77 M 164 164 parti c. 805 271 143 180 appeal s 116S 812 s 135 583 584 do 588 practice 74M 208 motion amend 74M 207 (83 judgment s 116S 954 f 136 939 attorney "client s 150 433 reservation f 167 394 192 pleading s 116 S 947 142 714 estoppel 144 862 145 844 200eq. eonversn s 116 S 834 do 139 802 submission f 161 872 inferences 183 776 207 new trial s 116S 977 132 925 power court 145 273 no authority 84 M .43 amend pleading 170 394 217 Judgment s 1163 841 f 186 939 no trust 176 759 error court 176 753 sll6S sl41 barred dp 141 dismissed do 141 509, 510 254 damages - 116 S 889 r 200 NY 88 258 ahandonmt, a 116 S 893 f 167 89 f 88 M 127 260 not exempt s 116S 994 f 135 23 personal d 66M 524 coroner's phys. 145 291 mandamus 83 M 373 coterminous 165 189 265 damaECS • 116S 906 a 196 NY 471 limitations 92 M 246 268 judgment s 117 S 63 f 141 927 274 ctrclaim B 117S 26 136 496 practice 74M 207 forcing judgmt. m 204NY 628 f 94 M 298 offset f 161 680 278 in trustee s 117 S 45 f 94 M 370 286 repugnant s 116 S 1110 71 M 584 misjoinder 150 643 single cause do 174 683 293 representves 117 S S 132 748 300 demurrer a 117 S 21 t 132 82.5 constitutional 133 611 equity suit d 133 613 suit on bond 231 larceny s 116 S 870, 196 NY act valid 135 larceny 135 liability 138 law action 138 _ 138 joinder 138 surety 146 162 distinction f 172 do 186 4S 277 280 175 175 176 176 77.'! 20 114 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished: {. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; •g criticised ; 1, limited ; e, explained ; o, overruled ; a, same case ; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, questions n N. Y. Supreme Court Reports-^Appellate Division Vol. 132 311 8 116S 1083 a 133 •940 do 133 941 147 781 case 2 t 132 937 316 ou merits s 116 S 1093 162 321 tax 8 117S a 196 NY 49 570 323 acote rule 6 117S 1 132 79 reference 134 774 138 278 327per. liability 8 117S 78 136 737 no judgment 155 467 J.72 892 modified 172 893 331 any sum money 8 117S 42 184 745 338 discovery s 116 S 1100 68 M 453 345 certiorari s lies 1041 a 205NY 168 348 dismissal 8 116S 859 65M 627 contract a 198NT 588 no error 106M 481 359contrib. neg. 8 116S 698 136 344 361 fee referee s 116S 723 a 198NY 502 69 M 77 364 new trial a 116 S 621 5 199 NY 551 368assume risk 8 116S 609 132 935 liabilitv 141 772 compensation d 141 902 rules necessary 20 AC 136n give notice 154 858 373no variance 8 117 S 641 138 258 375 compensa'n s 116 S 878 d 141 902 reversable error £01 NY 487 f 172 502 construction 205 NY 512 155 551 negligence ^ 154 '858 393 order case 1 8 116 S 718 f 132 937 394 liability 116 S 759 146 496 99M 659 397 enforcement s 116 S 726 156 124 right repudiate 156 272 .99 negligence 5 lie S 760 142 494 pleading do 161 386 387 95 M 335 complaint 175 116 construction 184 492 406 habeaecorp 9 116 S 990 a 196 NY 520 410 life insur. s 116S 985 m 198NY 15 415 aerv. sumns 3 116 S 1012 * 196 NY 531 managing agent 1 72 M 159 420 follow strictly f 174 436 1^26 per. injury 3 116 S 1051 a 199 NY 546 lessee liable 163 594 77 M 149 96 M 199 due care t 213 NY 409 nuisance 213 NY 408 not liable d 96 M 200 433 repudiation s 116 S 931 162 933 442 building i 117S 10 T 197NY 542 mileage 66M 570 452 title 3 116S 904 r 198NY 261 455 life insur. 3 116S 989 I 197NY 607 equity lien 139 168 lien policy 72 M 530 458 for jury s 116 S 921 f 170 172 462 contempt 8 116 S 83 64 M 63 142 463 punishment do 142 46S E 182 923 465 taxable ! 116S 816 65M 448 irrevocable I.!I5 128 f 92 M 424 deposit 155 500 89 M 637 92 M 322 92 M 350 470 direct judgt s 116 S 969 214 NY 583 f 102M 174 485 securities s 116 S 901 200 NY 56! no appeal 213 NY 150 489 incomp't ev 8 116 S 896 66 M 502 490 contract s 116 S ( r 200 NY 299 495 authority s 116 S 960 158 36 498 degree care 5 117 S 1098 139 789 501 notice purpose i 118 S 31 151 400 506 due care 3 117S 956 134 830 death damage r 197NY 430 509 prf- mance 3 118 S 59 134 509 entire contract 158 243 do 158 246 d 85 M 54 counterclaim 185 i 515 reason. dC' mand s 117 S 1077 189 940 moving papers do 146 617 order substitutn 146 615 interpleader 204NY 287 good faith fl49 6 522 final rule 8 116 S 728 210 NY 417 524 conversion s 117 S 3! a 200 NY 593 528 allegations s 117 S 57 95 M 119 535 counterclm, 6 116S 1116 e 137 238 ccnversion 140 511 539 nullity s 117 S 32 84 M 38 546francfaise tx. s 116S 1078 a 198NY 501 200 NY 331 64 547 em. domain 3 116S 952 66M 491 492 496 view 66M 497 refuse confirm 66M 499 548 contract s 116 S 966 a 200 NY 501 557 individual 8 116 S 820 210 NY 112 567 ejectment s 116 S 916 r 200 NY 130 574 award 8 117 S 68 M 87 damages do 139 241 d 152 770 just compensatu 138 173 award limit 138 173 counterclaim m 200 NY 572 not set aside do 147 517 not final 159 667 premises 186 396 589 fees discretion s 116 -S 827 M 638 593 verdict not void s 116 S 821 do 142 282 waiver 205NY 102 f 91 M 509 i9S liability s 116 -S 776 do 142 701 148 492 207NY 521 604 remedy s H7S 81 do 137 364 further return 143 33 authority 143 41 requirements 152 174 196 NY surrogate 81 M 6 1 1 damages 117S a204NY 96 M 106M liability f 87 M cond, precedent 103M 214 108 682 568 30 591 528 123 620 encroachmt. sll7 S 542 s 140 621 injunction f 149 910 f 170 695 mandamus 148 S 133 634 motion s 117 S 496 s 196 NY 616 contract a 197NY 536 one cause e 155 534 641 decree la 117 S 461 646 new trial s 117 S 520 175 118 664 judgment s 117S 434 135 436 196 NY 533 67 M 585 motion a 196NY 532 substitute f 160 187 667 certiorari s 117 S 429 143 20 674 judgment s 117 S 492 f 139 932 684 vesting s 117 S 465 152 . 528 696 judgt pldgs s 117S 404 74M 205 697not justified 8 117 S 551 143 451 707 discovery 8 117 S 534 144 598 equity account^ 149 269, 484 no accounting 148 777 examination 96 M 58 disclosure lOlM 445 716 ancient documents s 117S 582 185 799 174S 254 719 covenants s 117 S 567 e 172 398 20 AC 73n restricting 178 740 732 subrogation s 117S 387 a 197NY 294 777 authority s H7S 648 6511 326 97 M 405 inquiry f 97 M 404 scope agency 97 M 404 782 pleading s 117S 599 s 65M 308 65M 810 135 436 138 819 184 899 court's power 73 M 402 admissions 149 16 complaint 157 28.1 142 S 196 95 M 334 785 lien award 140 632 do 140 634 pers. property 102M 35 36 183 790 indictment 8 117S 664 r 186 NY 362 796 reference s 117 S 554 138 278 164 218 799 % rates 8 117S 539 d 67M 28 commissions 186 324 76 M 586 106M 120 12] as money 97 M 217 802 commissns. f 89 M 681 804 notice nee. 3 117S 826 135 236 Qotice claim r 198NY 71 no variance 138 258 set aside 78 M 169 strict constrctn. 175 410 trial evidence 176 55 821 forgery s 117 a a 196 NY 874 to account s 117S 585 185 832 890collisn. neg. 137 8 death neglig. a 197NY 588 r. r. negligence 144 79» for jury 144 • 800 bill particulars f 159 583 900 injunction s 116 S 1130 a 200 NY 594 discretion 73 M lis 90 1 judgment 198NY 578 902 presumpt'n 845 574 831 reinstatemt s 117S 813 135 221 reduce clainl 141 20P compensation 141 3'i0 f 163 433 mandamus M 518 cond. precedent 71M 597 reinstatement 177 550 employe lOlM 602 837 discovery 3 117 S 796 d 133 730 f 160 26C 849 dissensions s 117S 118S lies 143 dismissal a204NY 903 appeal case 1 s lies s 196 NY mech. lien s 198NY a 201 NY irjunction a 201 NY 105P 8541cgis s 117S do 136 mechanics lien a 199 NY 577 cond. precedent 140 613 f 89 M 442 relief 150 dismissal f 89 M powei 456 47' 46 442 859 error dismiss s 117 S, 171 424 330 864 new trial B 1173 407 £ 134 982 867 St. closed sll7S 149 damages 149 841 64 66 807 1140 171 675 1145 517 596 581 589 904 contract ■ 198NY 511 9 1 3 taxpr. suit case 1 s 1163 1087 a 196 NY 178 9 1 7surety bond a 197NY 547 921 contempt case 2 s 1173 70 138 294 do 138 295 a 196 NY 571 922 accounting 8 116 3 807 f 86 M 291 923 pleading s 116 S 892 160 703 924 accounting a 197NY 603 new trial a 198NY neg. tel. co r 199NY findings a 199 NY reinstate a 199 NY damages sl48 637 88 347 539 872 loss costs is 1173 449 925 surety bond case 10 177 case 17 a 196 NY labor law r 197NY new trial do 198NY services a 199 NY conversion a 199 NY d('£th damage r 201 NY 548 381 563 413 312 599 530 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distingnislied ; f, followed; -, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, not* c. criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, dissentin-g ooinion: p. parallel case; q, questioned Vols. 132, 133 N. Y. Siipreme Court Reports— Appellate Division 928 death neg. a 197NY 604 a 197NT 606 Teargument B 133 939 administrator a 199NY 56 jurisdictioQ r 199 NY 323 appeal E 199 NY on merits case 12 161 • sureties 161 332 501 504 929 insurance cas^ 4 s 118S 1140 a 197 NY SS practice s 136 479 480 conversion a 200 NY amendment 139 atty. lien a 199 NY a 199 NY sale accountingr a 200 NY bonds a 201 NY certiorari a 202 NY counterclaim a 203NY 568 e140 731 943 death neg. c 197NY 450 ejectment a 198NY 318 divert water r 199 NY 489 neg. 535 484 542 532 589 588 581 502 674 555 930 em .domain case 12 a 196 NY 25S compensation 160 483 931 certiorari case 2 B 117S case 3 r 196 NY 117S r 196 NY 1144 270 1144 650 933pers. injury 8 116 S 611 r 202 NY 408 936 default ease 3 133 903 937 bookmaKing case 2 s 116S a 196 NY mandamus a 197NY mechanics lien a 199 NY 591 592 habeas corpus a 196 NY 551 aside deed d 202 NY 121 may deduct case 1 f 84 M 436 8 116 S 1144 938 foreclosure a 197NY 439 discharge a 196NY damages ■ a 199 NY 944 death r 198NY a 200 NY negligence r 200 NY conviction a 198NY pers. injury a 199 NY 587 946 pers. injury case 8 s 117 S 1138 ■a 199 NY 578 case 9 reasonable use s 117 S 1134 148 399 9471iq. tax bond case 3 a 197NY 534 recovery case 8 a 199 NY 601 per. injuries case 13 a 199 NY contract case 5 a 199 NY case 6 a 199 NY couseq. damages case 4 s 117 S 1135 73 M 223 948 damages s 117 S 1148 s 138 712 judgmeat case 1 fl39 92] nre insurance a 199 NY 575 contract a 200 NY 535 promissory note r 201 NY 167 720 260 538 473 549 576 551 213 939 injunction case 10 s 116S al99N Y certiorari s 200 NY 1148 69 94 ( death a 197NY reinstate 523 neg 60] VOL. 133 I recoupment s 117 S 514 142 345 liability 142 349 146 184 may recover 148 148 conclusive 165 401 10 authority s 117 S 866 145 848 continuance 145 350 against corpn, 149 631 corporation sue 104M 441 18 accounting s 117 S 481 138 902 admission 182- 416 25 certiorari s 117 S 852 160 668 29 amendment 185 296 117S 135 35 perjury '<117S r 196 NY 40 burden S117S aol48 779 362 743 •372 plff. 639 93 44 ejectment s 117S 723 r 198NY 23 52 strike out ? 117 S 1 196 NY 810 671 893 966 493 57 order s 117S t 134 special term 156 grant motion 157 291 reformation 160 510 166 765 62 good cause 83 eamiugB s 117 S 809 72 M 484 common benefit f 91 M 147 89 payt, legacy 8 117 S 791 1 196 NY 311 92 contract a 200 NY 661 97 accounting 8 117S 773 a 198NY 679 100 not 8 117 S 153 apply 714 6 775 424 143 343 198 372 91 s 117S s 135 injunction 198NY obligation ■ 168 211 NY mutuality -- M promise 222NT 69 pers. liable s 117 S 676 86 M 107 warranty 198NY 449 75 direct denial s 117 S 734 70 M 135 form denial 151 409 not .permissible 78 M 513 privity estatfi f 166" f 92 M covenant 225NY liability 685 179 195 103 conviction s 117S 718 a 198NY 566 106 demurrer 8 117 S 793 143 339 equity suit 76 M 259 ( 1 3 admissible s 117 S 400 146 114 1 1 9 reversible « 117 S 233 69 M 633 death damacres r 201 NY 235 authorized 175 787 127 replevin s 117 S 288 a 200 NY 553 1 36 contract s 117 S 414 a 201 NY 603 enforceable 105M 133 (39 issue bonds s 117S 474 136 670 146 oondemntn " ' " 443 631 e 150 151 105M: practice f 150 82M 782 564 258 782 173 191 trust s 1178 468 m 198NY 415 construe will s 148 806 s 85 M 214 85 M 216 construction 80 M 572 80 M 592 as trustee s 80 M 578 power to dispose 80 M 593 not absolute 80 M 580 disqualify s 85M 226 legal title 171 965 198 for jury s 117 S 892 do 145 892 lib'l constructn 148 354 practice rule ' 211 NY 64 203 new trial s 117 S 4S6 case 8 f 133 926 judgment f 146 509 all conditions 166 possession 166 98 M eitsements 88 M no cause 89 M 95 95 702 254contrib. s 117 S 86 M 261 salary a 117S 136 201 NY 265 date of writing s 117 S 154 278 default S117S 80 M defect title f 169 neg. 363 .496 578 723 46S 667 231 706 491 91 763 track 11 s 117 S a 196 NY authority 136 additional 205NY change route do 205NY 20 right defendant 84 M 610 annoyance 89 M 492 159 baheas corp 9 117 S 323 d 196 NY 622 f 216 NY 348 168 ' 656 commitment 93 110 111 554 138 f 167 restraint f 167 detained 168 not competent 185 796 1 79 bab, corpus 3 117 S 625 133 184 136 702 74M 496 d ISO 777 Icgis. control 150 781 jurisdiction 215 relevancy s 117 S 896 143 693 220 criminal s 117 S 418 166 82 226 for jury s 117 S 376 137 846 233 demurrer s 117S 348 66M 184 f 86 M 20 234procur cause 216 51 183 184 50 s 117 S 177 i 93 M released f 93 H interplead f 177 commissions 185 684 237 certiorari s 117 S 488 197NY 582 t 133 924 242 officers act s 117 S 197 200 NY 53 245 judgment s 117 S 488 I 133 926 lease valid 72 M 151 ratification f 71 M 462 293 Iig tax lav s 117 8 774 a 198 NY 218 forfeiture 136 540 privilege lOlM 432 297 allowances 8 117 S 695 71 M 610 foreclose lien 181 731 300 spl, jurors 8 117 S 273 212NY 261 262 304share8 stock s 117 S 596 a 199 NY 599 310 due care .s 117 S 698 134 613 138 365 nonsuit B 141 777 s 212 NY 119 s 212 NY 120 prudent men 177 86 3 1 5 reformatn. 8 117S 930 135 749 equitable action 170 506 349 impress . trust 8 117 S 97 r 199 NY 359 356 pleading s 1178 339 66M 182 trust created 141 59 73 M 601 plead limitatns, 143 870 persnl. property 153 admitted do 180 185 deinurrable 106M 367 relief s 117 S 67 M easement 106M 398 537 614 333 379 276 487 370supl. comp't s 117 S 336 173 697 373 order II117S f 133 3S5 923 375 reargument 8 117 S f 133 389 s 117 S 172 63S 931 356 967 321 award s 117 S r 196 NY 337trans£er s 1178 * 196NY f 152 161 immune 150 vested 160 t 152 order f 138 alienable 156 intestacy 91 M not taxable f 168 taxable 181 102M 346 requests 8 117S 142 152 judgment case 9 f]42 not apply 79 M for jury 165 866 286 tax 679 561 230 838 810 808 230 756 208 895 128 385 195 208 699 903 511 463 400 allegation 8 117 S 612 98 M 89 402 for jury s 117S 641 136 345 404 liability 254 139 power 67 M 71 M police 148 za» f 161 140 value work 168 117 ratified f 173 315 409probate will 8 1178 838 196Ni' 530 196 NY 531 construction 171 • 802 3 M 181 time execution M 611 89 M 58 90 M 256 presumption f 217 NY 115 specific bequest do 171 807 special legacy 181 103M vesting 186 601 183 380 419 review , exception sllTS 653 70 M 232 law error 144 678 428^ no acconte 148 . "7 inspection 148 778 disclosure lOlM 446 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; ">• .»°".' c, criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same ease; do, dissenting' opinion ; p. parallel case; q, questionBO N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division Vol. 133 431 limitation 8 117S 753 a 198NY 209 441 party deft. s 117S 346 186 445per. injuries s 117 S 611 a 199 NY 598 446 recovery s 118 S 178 a 199 NT 595 source title 181 23 453 judgment s 117 S 1070 { 143 974 461 ev. habit s 117 S 1058 143 203 incompetent do 143 209 incompetent ev. 205NY 60 467 not neglig. s 118 S 56 157 642 176 678 471 no claim s 117S 1095 ICOM: 50 4766tate*s pwr. s 117S 1048 65M 301 compensation do 66M 470 intent legial 146 164 481 judgment B117S 3 c 133 936 f 133 936 483 ' 'works clay bank s 117 S 1072 138 6:>9 486spl. proceed, s 117 S 796 71 M 508 499 reliance s 117 S 601 f 91 M 32 agreement f 173 389 503 certiorari s 117 S 676 a 201 NY 532 520 by motion s 117S 730 198NT 351 52 r compliance s 117 S 1065 141 192 98 M 56 547suspnd time 146 530 S3] 565per. injuries 8 118S 152 a 197NY 694 5791ien expend 8 118 S 123 67 M 637 release 74 M 212 unenforceable 206 NY 31 s 118S a 196NY a 196N Y ^plit fees 172 unprofessional 174 97 98 180 556 authority a 118 S 242 a 196 KY 218 public necessity 145 333 128 COl 582 rent sllSS a 201 NY contract 71M 458 enforceable 71 M 459 equity charge d 144 739 license only 184 169 73 M 293 592 default s 118 S 232 177 476 78 M 266 596 easement s 118S 156 a 197NY 578 unrestricted 148 . 318 allegations 73 M ■ 558 f 86 M 643 604 prior lien s 118 S 203 97 M 46 BIO indemnity 3 1)8 S 207 a 196 NY 452 liability 138 175 equity suit 138 175 remedies 69 M 598 enforcement 143 140 ■surety 14G 773 jurisdiction 146 773 construction 146 773 single creditor 146 774 617 estoppel s 118 S 274 do 216 NT 54 621 commission s 118 S 225 m 199 NY 472 630 crimes ev. 118 S 199 r 203 NY 267 635 mandamus s 118S 290 65M 340 a 200 NY 527 fraud 146 216 permission 81 M 644 no power 97M: 194 franchise f 181 696 656 conclusive s 118 S 216 147 144 f 165 269 notice 165 268 677 estoppel s 118 S 261 I I r, eq. conversion 141 402 conclusive 150 662 do 152 299 686 foreclosure s 118 S 244 a 200 NY 534 691 new trial s 118 S 195 s 199 NY 564 no violation 150 769 70|not chrgabH sll8 S 257 do 153 854 not liable d 172 733 pleading 95 M 169 waiver 95 M 169 706 place trial s 118 S 230 137 755 145 198 710 error court s 118 S 172 f 89 M 455 performance 167 782 172 116 717 earnest money 3 118 S 139 a 200 NY 268 723 rcco'r debt s 118 S 16.1 a 201 NY 561 fact question f 159 153 728 discovery 3 118S 238 133 731 732 733 requiremt. s 118S 241 lOlM 15 739facts excuse s 118S 214 137 200 741 lex loci 8 118 S 215 144 78 order case 9 f 144 904 750&erve procss s 118S 212 a 197NY 377 756 consent s 118 S 136 69 M 276 public policy f 162 87 71 M 513 certificate valid 158 387 760 death neg. a 198NY 510 764 reas. sll8S do 148 safety 101 377 78 1 contract s 118 S 66 I- 200 NY 125 737 negligence s 118 S 82 f 140 922 law question do 145 551 rules necessary 20 AO 135n judgment case 3 do 152 956 798 remedy s 118S 5 65M 341 802 degree care s 118 S 71 139 865 waiver 20 AC 287n 807 death neg 8 118 S 88 fl3i: 23 830 do 168 407 m 197NY 316 not serve ans. 138 472 amendment 166 831 20 AC 12n lex loci 78 M 582 new cause do 214 NY 113 814 rights by grant s 118S 109 147 263 prescription 105M 488 non user 105M 488 821 upon merit s 118S 235 65M 628-9 judgment r 198NY 279 s 198NY 279 final 80 M 184 conclusive 81 M 217 826 jurisdiction s 118 S 315 d 71 M 232 cloud title a 202 NY 573 occupancy f 90 M 436 90 M 437 842 negligence a 117 S 1118 s 140 086 847pers. injurj s 118S 78 r 197NY 600 857reason rules 8 117 S 1055 73 M 464 r. r. fares 73 M 465 865 criminal penalties s 118 S 15 a 201 NY 105 874 insolvent s 118S 48 r 198NY 470 879proof burdn. s 118 S 75 139 364 172 962 885 not accomplice case 1 s 117 S 381 f 160 393 888constr'e will E 118S 286 a 197NY 593 889 services 8 197NY 580 conversion a 197NT 603 agreement r 200 NT 18 installment a 199 NT 577 contract a 200 NY 531 prohibition 73 M 418 costs s 143 345 unconstitutional 73 M 410 890 mandamus case 5 a 196NT 523 case 9 s 118 S 1123 148 910 a 197NT 581 e 218 NT 492 d 218 NY 493 em. domain case 12 m 196NY 175 order case 13 a 196NY 527 892 guaranty s 118 S 1118 a 200 NY 532 insurance case 16 a 200 NY 562 infringement a 200 NY 563 893decree s 118 S 1123 case 4 m 196NY 4)6 rape case 1 s 118 S 1131 a 199 NY 543 death neglig. case 10 a 200 NY 551 damages case 9 m 200 NY 577 contract case 11 s 118 S 1120 a 203NY 580 construe will n 197NY 606 allowance )66 482 invalid 181 513 894 maadamus case 3 s 118S 1134 s 196 NY 570 a foreclosure r 198NY 29 certiorari m 198NY 48 s>. performance a 198NY 509 895 relief a 196NY order a 196 NY 572 396 em. domain r 198NY 84 contempt d 67M 98 assessment a 196NY 520 a 196 NY 52) 897suppt. child s 118S 1117 a 196NT 525 a 196 NY 526 901 partition slISS 1115 572 903 pers. injury a 117 S 28e a 200 NT 21 a 201 NY 603 905 pers. inju'cs s IIT^S 644 a 201 NY 575 contrib. negl. f 83 M 649 652 9 1 negligence r 197NY 348 916 contract s 117 S 10S4 5 141 79 918 prom, note s 197NY 560 mech. lien a 196NY 538 » 196 NY 538 damages 199 NY 596 920 motion case 10 a 199 NY 550 contract case 5 s 117 S 1136 a 199 NY 547 defendnt. liable case 6 151 335 924 certiorari a 197NY 582 case 9 s 118S 1124 order a 196NY 568 926 presumptn. s 117 S 484 72 M 151 932 decree ease 9 a 1188 1124 a 196NY .573 order a 196 NY 568 contract a 199 NT 586 933per, injuries a 197NT 690 claims a 199 NT 571 Corp. capacity s 138 474 935per. injuries a 198NT 630 order * 196NY 531 party defendant * 196 NY 531 decree a 199 NT 515 937 diversion case 5 r 196NT 421 mineral spring r 196 NT 421 trade marks r 199 NT 247 promisory note a 201 NY 134 938 death dam. a 198NY 561 prom, note a 199 NY 574 939 submission s 118 S 1109 199 NT 597 discretionary 73 M 351 nonsuit a 203 NY 601 940 order s 118S 117 case 3 do 148 912 943 conviction case 1 181 116 944 conviction a 198NY 542 trust money a 199 NY 571 contract a 199 NY 575 accounting a 199 NY 576 certiorari a 201 NY 538 76 no review 143 581 grand larceny a 202 NT 571 case 6 91 M 348 945 services * 197NT 612 deficiency * 196NT 516 right judgm.ent 137 594 ABBBEVIATIONS : a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, e. criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o. overruled; s, same ease; do, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, questioned Vol. 134 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — ^Appellate Division VOL. 134 ISpers. injuries E 118 S 34 199 NY 598 17 taxation s 118S R59 a 198NY 413 149 418 22 orders B 118S 9B f 134 909 amendment r 198NY 615 20 AC 12n ordpr do 134 909 corrpct compU. 139 li97 28 liability s 117 S 1081 142 288 courts power 71 M 134 32 onfempt. a 118 S 3 * 196NY 538 r 197 NY S3 certorari 160 670 39 for jury s 117 S 1118 do 145 892 presumption f 160 600 45 contract s lies 703 a 197NY 511 62 contrib. ueg. s 118S 651 136 535 65c[uo warranto 6 118S 712 a 197NY 539 75 em. domain s 118S 742 a 198NY 439 estoppel 224NY 205 186 158 80 occupation corroboration 152 497 158 147 212 NY 253 intercourse 186 228 I 14 scrutinized s 118S 810 66M 404 [nust establish T5M 61 proof clear E 163 41G burd. defendant do 175 170 123 inadmissible s 118S 852 74M 509 ISOright dischg. s 118 S 846 30 M 156 no waiver 80 M 156 for jury do 80 M 158 plead defense t 166 146 134 not liable s 118S 827 f 178 929 a 196NY 569lreleTancy assessment > 143 196 NY 569 174 commissns s 118 S 806 a203NY 695 s 118 S 1145 176 contract sllSS 1113 a 200 NY 578 1 82 complaint 136 no sl18S 142 title B 118S 145 do 145 66M £ 90 M redemption a 198 NY notice 102M: 83 tax law s 118S r 198NY 756 88 40 108 436 501 607 885 54 89 revocation s 118S 873 a 197NY 585 93 tax sales s 118 S 912 a 200 NY 332 99 application s 118S 969 a 197NY 1 issue stock a 197 NY 1 may demand f 159 538 no eq. jurisdctn 804 58 597 sllSS 149 contracts 156 807 274 774 1 84 in transitu s 113 S 982 162 415 no notice 171 668 (92 liability s 118S 893 147 158 201 ultra vires s 118S 911 136 873 compliance 139 104M 96 208 entorcemnt I39rules of law s 118 S '828 144 728 probable cause 86 M 18 141 evidence 5 118 S 801 76 M 666 668 misconduct 76 M 669 861 42 sllSS 14T covenants 165 172 204 317 violation 182 212 for jury s 118 S 885 : 118 S 1125 206 NY 88'298 liability burden proof 823 587 144 new trial s 118 S a 200 NY for jury 146 83 M contrib. 180 68 56 neglig. 378 916 686 253 new trial s 118S 906 f 134 935 neglig. damages s 142 511 do 162 794 miscarriage 207 NY no recovery 84 M 505 255 consefac mortgagor s 118 S 951 161 492 accounting 87 M 346 260 enforcement s 118 S 977 a 201 NY 2.TO 266 jurisdiction s 118S 949 e 104M 556 272 submission s 118 S 876 206 NY 504 281 use land s 118S 960 104M 449 interference 10411 450 distinction d 104M 452 easement 78 M shifts risk 78 M plfE's. 87 M f 104M 294 pers. SllSS * 201 NY requests 152 4£)4 iniurv 867 549 d 159 215 costs s 118 S 85 M waiver . f 96 M 694 936 499 658 2 1 7 discovery 186 798 1 1 Olaw questn. s 118S 136 817 809 151 penalty * 200 NY 556 adulterated case 9 146 892 iadgmt. case 1 ■{ 148 928 error court f 178 719 154 warranty s 118 S 821 77 M 141 representations 91 M 524 eviction d 94 M 189 1 62gift absolute s 118S 833 lOOM 294 1 67 discretion s 118S 830 136 878 t 161 452 f 165 694 practice unfair 139 148 137 848 order 158 949 £ 163 917 170 certiorari 3 118S 838 sllSS dl49 f 159 f 163 f 177 d 91 M 1000 111 921 918 894 486 22 1 court power s 118S 844 d 136 872 £ 86 M 43 formal order 136 873 226 contract s 118S 903 186 208 9 228 equity 138 236 submit jtif 053 58 214 sll8S 143 error court ,158 inference f 93 M 243 for jury s 118 S I 154 880 118 S M 582 565 rights 159 368 intervention S119S 72 do 149 465 not apply 167 668 372 scaffold s 119 S 75 s 215 NY 458 95 M 130 new trial 142 808 servant defendt. 152 573 liability 83 M 113 468 damages s 119S 347 a 198NY 136 supl. complaint 173 697 473 privilege 6 119 S 247 140 525 540 378 election B 119 S 134 order a 196NY decision d 134 379 burden proof do 152 86; 381 cost evidence value s 119 S 136 73 M 416 for court 73 M 416 386 compliance s 119 S £ 85 M 105 54 trial 100 382 61 871 556 30 1 contract s 118 S 882 s 146 510 320rght. dower s 110 S 41 66M: 35 abatement 75M 211 negligence 95 M 14 325 enforce lien s 119 S 3 a 201 NY 599 vested remaindr do 165 496 350 motion s 119S 77 f 136 901 agency f 90 M 26 353 dismissal s 119 S 47 f 82 M 397 f 163 911 no award f 97 M 393 358 postponemt s 119S 134 65M 61 engagement 65 M 61 a 196 NY 540. 361 on merits s 119 S 69 160 670 389 new sllOS TOM f 98 M discretion 150 282 verdict stands 83 M 239 reversal 166 546 judgment 105M 353 394 r. r. neglig. s 119 S 112 144 799 410 concluded s 119 S B 143 usury f 150 167 e 167 173 173 480 damages s 119S 136 d 162 certiorari a 200 NY authority -5M no award 150 award 150 298 441 401 525 512 666 668 statutory power 150 decision case 9 f 151 487judgt. s 119S 65M 667 24'6 do 158 demurrer 94 M 614 counterclaim 185 6 563 joint rates s 119S 641 r 198NY 433 further return 140 59 evidence dehors 138 172 strike out 137 362 immaterial matter* 67 M 404 improper ov. 143 794 evidence 159 818 567 limit proof s 119 S 487 138 788 practice 141 70 bill particulars 146 46» mandatory f 163 542 941:669 special term B 119 S 483 pldg. 143 109 383 strict rules 555 143 485 open default injury 239 619 103 307 410 235 236 593 597 248 burden plff. s 118 S 979 363 lex loci 143 596ls 119 S 37 413 injunction s 119 S 309 s 140 414 f 85 M 384 432 third party s 118 S 1104 139 580 power court 161 737 176 202 evidence 161 737 440 good faith s 119 S 285 do 160 735 joint adventure do 160 736 int. in surplus f 92 M 495 450 bill partic. s 119 S 253 140 550 146 470 S 148 64.'? 76M 19 76 M 251 453 relationship 8 119S 321' 141 796 493pers. 119S a 198NY no obligation 141 51! duty owner l.'iS 516 complaint 98 M 316 SOOnot preclu4. s 120 S 39 145 834 506 contract s 119 S 577 a 201 NY 551 5 1 6 foreclosure B 119S 455 f 134 523 finding 182 415 527 amenable s 119 S 600 f 166 102 547 committee s 119S 556 a 197NY 583 162 890 f 167 189 incompetent s 199NY 39 s 137 585 discretion 152 conclusion f 165 free faith f 89 M 157 181 168 10 583 555 oonsideratn s 119S 266 224NY 354 558 rules atlrial pn9S 705 143 1*4 judgment do 144 74M 95 M amendment 74M 551 205 334 206 entire contract 897 885 620 683 583 325 387 575 stay s 119 S d 166 f 169 f 93 M 93 M costs power 215 NY "540 174 891 lOOM 485. 579 judgment s 119 S 520 143 951 not party 72 M 75 courts right 76 M , 480 jurisdiction 88 M 337 587 for jury 119S 489 148 780 declarations 155 794 594 discretion s 119 S 427 150 281 282 reversal 164 739 166 546 599 no defense 138 31 act offense 180 771 606 damages case 1 , ir 1^ 608 covenants s 119 S 444 146 "28 170 2f 20 AC 73n demurrer 157 ^ 611 judgment 119 5 S ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f. followed; r, reversed; m^ """^If'^! *',^J™?"^L5ti»«* c, criticised; 1, limited; e, Rxolained; o, overruled; s, same case, do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case . q, q" N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division Vol. 134 case 6 requests 152 GI4 after issue s 119S 831 140 535 discovery 146 435 {661 death 919 damages B 119 S 439 3 201 NY 520 s 149 805 f 170 617 bailment s 119S 390 s 137 94 ?ioof good faith DM 175 fraud transfer s 147 121 147 122 1 94 M 686 appeals do 147 131 not conclusive 151 37 €23 conversion s 119 S 317 UZ 1C8 93 M 547 lack authority 140 833 93 M 544 payment 155 513 514 672 negligence 6 119 S &t3 r 202 NY 129 679 pers. injury 5 119 S 645 a 202 NY 568 superintendence £ 165 725 168 399 f 93 M 589 03 M 593 detail work 93 M 588 not liable £ 93 M 594 63 178 f 95 M f 98 M law suit 355 60 688 28 515 629 for jury s 119 S 492 76 M 198 63 1 liability act. s 119 S 430 a 198NY 132 assume risk 137 385 fact question 139 141 notice sufficient 139 ir>l 151 f 164 79 M for jury 139 f 165 463, alter ego 145 f 169 error court 175 142 399 400 624 509 161 464 84 957 406 686 life insur. 5 119S 480 * 197NY 614 69 1 taxpr. suit s 119 S 526 f 88 M 159 legality 180 857 697 accounting s 110 3 401 a 201 NY 501 vesting d 72 M 255 future vesting 156 105 future conditns, 182 186 705 all errors s 119 S 138 158 868 82 M 392 indemnity 162 191 85 M 424 7l21aw question s 119 S 119 68 M 325 hinds shipper 163 522 shipping receipt 60 U. 44 plaintiff bound 759 pregnancy s 119 S 259 158 148 sexual act 225NY 493 76 1 designation s 119 S 387 138 607 140 61 93 M 624 77 1 motion s 119S 372 s 198NY 623 reference 164 218 775 foreclosure s 119S 304 197NY 891 137 137 146 88 1 equity trust s 119S 137 167 trusts m 201 NY r 202 NY 90 M 78 1 venue B 119 S 155 953 399 694 638 333 790 638 93 155 532 103 1132 394 1137 579 865 581 790 offenses s 119 S 859 78 M 516 grand jury 91 M 230 792 not neglig. s 119 S 537 158 898 800 coservants s 119 S do 145 liability 157 816 rent 3 119 S 203NY 896 injunction s 119S 812 r 204NY 370 907stolen goods case 5 s 118 S 197NY waste case 2 E 118 S a 201 NY crossing cases 6 and 7 B 118 S 1149 a 208 NY 513 construction case 9 e 118 S 1113 a 199NY 694 case 2 8 118 S a 201 NY forfeitures f 160 541 916 negligence a 198NY S70 918 negligence s 118 S 930 r 201 NY 76 920per8. injury s 11* S 1008 a 202 NY 558 ^937 guaranty -sll8S 1134 144 827 938 mandamus a 198NY 505 75M 45 541 809 399 92 1 injunction case 1 s 119 S a 197NY f 161 d 172 178 428 430 restriction 225NY sp. performance case 3 a 302 NY allowance case 2 83 M 554 f 171 f 181 lOOM stipulate 186 405 948 641 466 643 512 961 19 546 640 negligence s 119S 460 f 134 982 pleading s 139 679 not copartners 157 646 644responsiblty s 119 S i 94 M deviation 94 M negligence d 172 182 f 95 M 95 M 441 716 717 251 901 57R 577 65 1 practice s 119 S f 168 litigate 184 652 liable damage s 119 S 170 454 288 762 333 532 722 whole price s 119 S 12S (!9M 590. 592 s 119 S 144 143 784 729 negligence sll9S 141 142 249 not negligence 158 20 736 injunction s 119S 515 do 223NY 507 742franchise tx. 3 119S 534 r 198NY 250 752 liability s 119S 766 3 136 901 756 penalty 3 119 S 474 3 202 NY 338 reasonable 158 .256 758 demurrer s 119 S 451 831 judgment case 9 s 119 S 592 t 138 916 protect poor 79 M 504 as to waiver 79 M 478 defense 89 M 114 inoperative 106M: 181 843 new trans. s 119 S 184 86 M 38 845 ejectment E 119 S 175 d 155 445 defective 155 448 849 contract s 119 .S 157 a 202 NY 521 853 St. crossing 908 injunction s 118 S 1150 a 200 NY 29 pers. injuries a 200 NY 533 a 201 NY 577 death damages a 199 NV 616 waste s 199 NY 523 perjury a 201 NY 560 mechanic's lien a 200 NY 517 accounting a 202 NY 557 191 926 contract s 196NY 562 motion 196 NY Roods sold a 201 NY cUma title a 201 NY accounting a 201 NY 569 817 laches excuse 138 498 extortion 200 NY recovery s 146 939 trespassing a 200 NY 558 usury 3 202 NY 8 waste a 203 NY 112 discovery m 202 NY 552 964 services case 9 _._6ll9S 1113 338 a 201 NY 602 life insurance case 11 a 201 NY contract case 8 a204NY 8 160 940 reargument s 119 S 1148 s 146 324 942 will gift s 118 S 1149 m 202 NY 156 945 order a 196NY order a 196NY order a 196NY 540 562 584 520 680 675 965 dance lie. case 14 198NY 1 title lands case 6 a 199 NY 531 not final 159 667 966 motion * 197NY, 557 certiorari' a 198NY libel a 201 NY dismissal s 231 US 503 571 376 542 r 967 false .„- - imprisonment construe will 'ellQs 1117 a 200 NY 589 1 202 NY 530 §''?o2w^'' KA-, 969 reargument 329 614 S119S a 204NY 863 order s 119S a 198NY motion s 198 NY 97 379 618 550 909 deatb ncg, a 197NY 594 crime _ 198NY amendment r 198NY ejectment 198NY pers. injuries a 200 NY 534 Limitations r 202 NY 289 9 1 OHq. tax bond case 4 a 197NY contract case 3 „ 197NY practice case 9 s 139 promisory note case 1 r 200 NY 300 personal injury case 13 a 202 NY 568 accounting case 8 s 118 S 1108 r 204NY 413 869 authentictn s 119 S 327 202 NY 310 remit case 6 202 NY 311 regular course 81 M 423 no appeal 213 NY 150 870 commissns s 119 S 271 927 appeal case- 2 s 197NY personal injuries a 200 NY 565 order case 9 a 198NY allowances case 4 sll8S a 204NY 620 535 602 388 302 617 1111 565 928 railroads 3 119 S 1133 a 199 NY 288 929 mandamus 198NY 606 91 1 easement 197NY 12 9l2pers. s 119 S 200 NY injury 1128 183 930 reargument s 134 824 negligence notice r 201 NY 479 foreclosure s 198NY 601 a 201 NY 582 referee report r 202 NY 306 commissions a 203NY 596 933 death neglig sll8S 1096 a 200 NY 589 934sp. perfmnce case 6 E 118 S 1104 a 208 NY 522 935sp. perfmce. s 118 S 1112 a 202 NY 419 certificate a 202 NY 559 r 196NY 541 947 reargument s 136 408 948 damage a 197NY 578 application a 199 NY 562 949 reinstate a 198NY 508 eq. laches p 137 595 950 receiver m 197NY 579 95 1 injunction d 137 582 s 148 188 954 probate a 197NY 583 commissions r 201 NY 210 s 119 a s 140 970 accounting 198NY 217 death neglig. a 201 NY 1151 414 515 973 dismissal a 198NY 607 975 no appeal 134 989 955 services s 118 S 1106 a 201 NY 573 burden proof r201 NY 466 new trial case 7 185 9l3per5. injury case 1 sllSS 85! a 202 NY 5ie insurance 110 957 per. injuries case 13 3 118S 1151 a 204NY 636 960duty plaintfC case 2 . 119 S 502 154 321 977 affirmance case 7 s 119 S 1123 144 799 980 pers. injury sll9S 1136 a 201 NY 582 981 discretion 3 119-S 655 139 202 983 goods sold " 199 NY 519 984 assessment a 198NY 614 life insurance a 201 NY 587 987franchi8e tx. a 198NY 508 962 direct ev sll9S a 200 NY cnntract a 206 NY 1120 565 434 988 irregular case 2 s 120 S 550 f 139 336 partition case 4 s iins 1114 * 201 NY .^64 a 203NY 532 infants case 1 sll8S 1100 r 203 NY 465 173 9 936 decision 963 death neg. sll8S 1120* 197NY 555 a 200 NY 588 tersonal injur. 989 hold over insurance a202 NY 617 134AD 975 in 201 NY 573 street railwavs death damage Il42 ■ 40' a 198NY 584 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modifi.ed; *, dismissed; n, note; e, criticised ; 1, limited ; e, explained ; o, overruled ; s, same case ; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, questioned Vols. 134, 135 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division VOL. 135 contract 1 a 201 NY 587i riparian rights | admissible m 202 NT 898 g 119 S ., Il54 990 validity will fllOS 113 J a 201 NY 549 personal injury a204NY f 94 M may waive f 169 f 85 M 991 separation * 198NY 507 appeal * 19SNY 506 personal injury r 201 NY 667 a 202 NY 567 judicinl comity a 200 NY 472 disturb funeral a 199 NY D47 992 death negl, B 119 S 183 r 202 NT 242 993 injunction s 119 S 1133 a 202 NT 571 personal injury a 203 NT 642 994 enforcement case 6 s 119S 1143 r 204NY ( impress trust •'■ase 9 s 119 S 1132 r 202 NY 879 goods sold case S a 203NY case 13 S119S a 203 NY 643 objections 179 803 606 337 550 448 840 571 1133 640 995 death neg. s 197NY -559 election a 197NY nepHgence r 200 NY penalty a 200 NY 579 478 664 7 jurisdiction s 119 S 769 d 138 790 accounting f 138 792 200 NY 451 supreme court 200 NY 401 additnl. trustee 141 809 surrogate 81 M 123 13 judgment s 119 S 819 f 160 888 authority d 210 NY 511 error court f 176 540 I6publie policy s 119S 777 lOOM 591 19 reinstatemt. s 119S 808 135 221 ?ham member 202 NY 109 suspension T4M 67 f 91 M 130 board's power £ 166 59 immaterial f 166 dismissal t 168 92 M removal f 169 jurisdiction 211 76 M "eTroneous 102M 581 48 rfbed aside siius ay a 202 NY ll^i 52 check raised 3 119 S 881 a 203 NT 86 55 contra'ct s 119 S 988 s 162 . 14 67 indictment sllOS a 200 NY witnesses do 145 83S SSfi 812 75 judgment case 6 s 119 S f 138 renewal f 165 conversion 175 174 tender excused s 119 S 1025 163 187 178 liability H9S 1033 99M 180 s 120 S i 169 821 908 94 notice s 120 S 173 I 10 trade namr 567 153 468 60 66 312 205 173 24 relief sl]9 S £158 30 libelous sll9S 156 56 860 403 875 33 sum. pro. 3 119S 781 69 M 820 p 135 87 attonement 7 491 512 744 508 204 172 65M abrogated e 93 M remedies 181 103M title lOSM landlord tenant do 186 245 38 for jury s 119 S 668 144 274 44 transfer tax 8 119S 914 a 198NT 618 pay in full lOlM 537 46 no contempt s 119 S 895 153 883 recital s 119 S 68 M iurisdiction 74M 261 990 132 621 734 331 731 334 127 order s 119S f 135 demurrer 162 do 171 dismissal 171 f 171 relief 95 M spl. perfrmnce 105M 515 authority 105M 516 I36fire insur'ce B 120 a 7 a 203NY 580 1 4 1 liquidation o 120S 34 m 198NT 456 1 5 1 order s 119 S 1001 907 384 481 322 138 no costs TOM 2 M new trial 150 not penalized 77 M 211 costs 153 205 discretionary 79 M . . 370 no condition 155 749 1 63 prox. cause sl20S TOM liability 171 182 destruction 99M 24 560 828 12 662 172 condition s 119 S 1007 93 M 40 97 M 350 privilege limitd 177 541 570 41 785 178 not liable s 119 S 1033 169 440 f 211 NT 128 f 211 NT 129 no distinction f 211 NY 132 (87gift to class s 120 S 1125 200 NT 189 l95election law s 119S 106J m 197NT 336 libl. constructn 176 -338 203 unliquidatd s 118S 1093 179 657 206 voidable 710 613 120S 147 validity f 153 as trustees 153 to account 155 court intervenes SI M 451 refuse voting 224NY 489 2 1 3 conveyance s 120 S 819 f 144 927 2 1 8 suspension s 120S 42S 74M 67 no * recovery 148 303 224 great cautn sl20S 148 injunction 82 M f 96 M test trial f 91 M 418 155 500 42 595 227 instructions s 120 S 387 69 M 601 234 insuf. notice 120 S 142 not liable f 168 176 566 941 839 930 238 conspiracy B 120 S 546 155 do 183 damage 183 351 464 460 244 extensions 8 120 S 370 140 36] counterclaim do 149 108 247 devastavit 138 164 equity suit 138 '164 trust funds a 201 NY 518 contribution 72 M 239 240 liability do 148 156 illegal 156 individual 210 NY revocation 160 subrogation f 215 NY trust funds 177 85 805 805 112 160 260 judgment case 10 s 120 S 7 fl40 9 injunction s 207NT 64' 268 judgment s 120 3 471 case 9 f 141 931 appeal 200 N Y 555 right relief 205NY 463 injunctions 1.56 583 similar name 169 848 f 169 849 infringement 180 554 276 conversion 511 99 31 108 sl20S 141 set-off f 213 NT money 186 cond, precedent 186 110 sell credit do 186 113 285 discovery s 120 S 362 137' 824 286 commissns. s 120 S 392 a 202 NY 293 172 318 291 ev. habit s 119 S 785 do 148 207 judgmt. case 7 f 149 946 295falBe answer s 119 S 801 152 21 298 no waiver s 119 S 752 87 M 656 144 304 estoppel 79 M 477 waive valid 79 M 502 waiver £ 167 73 79 M 473 no cause action f 158 857 f 167 • 230 313 liability s 120 S 1127 137 722 725 on inquiry' 141 E 176 distinction 141 on notice 267 848 26? 141 271 do 271 do 170 685 money had 166 124 322 prox. came s 120 S 1 a 207 NY 221 duath negligence d 156 101 361 realleged 5 120S 534 147 381 365 waiver s 120 S 323 f 166 313 37 1 guaranty s 120 S 397 67 M liability f 210 NT 603 424 384 judgment case 13 s 119 S 977 f 139 901 39 1 admissible s 120' S 11 f 160 830 400 conversion s 1193 937 a 204NY 561 validate 183 635 cond. precedent 183 637 407 incidental s 119 S 984 157 7ir 409transfer tax s 119S 888 a 199NT 29 420no presumpn s 119 S 994 140 422 426 material s 119 S 1010 69 M 211 burden plainti.f do 148 93 actual malice f 97 M 32 428 indemnified 143 K4 motion proced're 157 285 realty do 160 298 436 verifies answer s 120 S 333 89 M 637 443 reference s 119 S 739 138 278 equity accountg 149 269 B 153 742 153 743 4S7bp. perfmce. s 120 Sf 18 169 682 202 NT 572 enforcement 146 660 £ 174 199 intervention do 149 465 insuf&cient ev. 150 766 467 constructn. s 120 S 764 p 138 f 138 judgment f 138 104 110 sl20S 80 M reimburse f 84 M 48." 602 85 432 judgment s 120 S 426 f 139 932 discharged 161 502 undertaking stands 161 502 do 162 127 not retract f 92 M 152 appeal 102M 716 435 dismissal s 120 S 333 68 M practice 74M 96 M judgmt. pleadgs 67 M 586 75M 22S 95 M 334 98 M .308 321 by motion J41 SOO rules at trial 414 20B 258 IP.l 473 fbduction s 120 S 491 a 198 NT 110 480 surety e 120 S 496 m 201 NY 335 over payments 177 587 484 damages s 120 S 487 r 203 NT 181 494 judgment s 120 S 317 case 3 f 139 contract 91 M 901 635 503 nons'j't sl20S 623 r 202 NY 79^ 508 covenant s 120 S 381 3 120 S 1120 a 202 NT 660 85 M 452 515 reference s 120S ■ 238. 278 164 218 cond. precedent f 168 46 517 libel 8 120 S 498 144 _ 25 criminal libel do 144 28 indicted f 171 391 520priv. easemt- 138 do 138 s 120 S 139 207 208 420 771 530 receiver s 120 S 420 157 209 536 Pri"l«S\„ s 120 S 522 197 NT 381 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; °> "^ i:, criticised ; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case : q, quesuonw N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division Vols. 135, 136 recovery 157 100 395 rape do 168 correct errors f 171 46 5381iq. tax eerf. s 120 S 1006 a 198 NT 556 t 150 680 542 pleading s 120 S 543 150 680 159 676 inadmissible 172 755 546 sale B 120 S 377 a 203 NT 369 S49weiglit of ev. sl20S £l22S 137 complaint s 144 947 36i 709 513 634 disbarment s 121 S 250 a 199 NT 539 writ, testimony. I hO 377 misconduct 51 593 duties attorney 176 65 644 taxable 8 119S 1057 135 647 objection 135 047 f 648 Assessment n I98NT 607 real estate 105M 649sp. perfmce. - 916 insolvency • 198NY 557 injunction a 202 NT 568 918 atty. lien 1- 197NY 301 ^p. performance a 201 NY 500 919 file account I 199 NY 52' concealed weapons a 204 NY 39- death neglig. a 201 NY 115 nonsuit ■1 201 NY 353 instalment B 202 NY 533 prom, note s 120 S 1147 a 202 NY 561 920 negligence case 2 s 120 S 1132 a 202 NY 575 personal injury I relief sl20S 142 597 551 3G8 363 537 540 532 6 in writing s 120 S 126 85 M 494 7 rule varied s 120 S 161 67 M 541 revoke license 160 789 discretion 171 658 91 M 623 not controlled 179 20 S cause action sl20S 121 d 141 836 f 168 959 10 accounting 8 120S 124 * 198NY 616 l3perBni. injury -- '■ 184 570 case 13 sl20S 76 M 1134 257 B 120 a a 202 NT 22 liability sl20S 156 equities 88 M no defense do 180 850"case 5 VOL. 136 210 758 163 797 562 537 31 agent corpn. s 120S . 161 d CeM 539 nullity 138 471 47 pleading 119 S 686 138 876 separate support 149 56.-! enforcement 153 722 78motn. dismiss s 120S 628 198NT 595 dicta trusts 67 M 620 fair intent 144 866 representations do 144 868 trust companys r 203 NY 331 accountable f 160 837 83 corroboratn. 120 S 634 f 163 462 100 for jury ■i 120 S 141 slol recovery 157 rape do 168 correct errors f 171 46 qualified do 222NY 536 (04 foreclosure s 120 S 825 a 207 NY 697 liability 97 M 435 110 death neg. S120S 517 do 142 013 n.52 7.58 77G 100 395 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed- n. note 0. criticised; 1, limited: e. explained: o. ovennled; ■, same case; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q, questioael Vol. 136 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division 116 misjoinder d. 172 s 120S 583 323 149 371 123 insurance s 120 S 641 s 159 292 130 amendment •s 120 S 618 £ 170 69 136 objections s 120 S 171 139 757 142 affid. proof s 120 S 168 141 200 evidence facts 176 215 77 M 279 146 inadmissible s 120S 415 74M 570 1 50 obligation s 120S 649 181 900 1 55 asssssment s 120S 528 a 198NT 608 f 212 NT 479 depreciation 156 612 60 M 655 renew machinry 167 306 203 NY 22 23 203 NT 238 earnings dl59 • 143 replacement 156 613 e 181 343 f 212 NT 484 six per cent 157 license fee 157 set aside fund 157 755 ISO strike out 219 appeal s 120S 926 8 137 481 224 pool selling 5J20S a 200 NY distinction 177 259 409 226 larceny s 121S 17 a 199NT 1 24 1 dividends s 120 S 976 a 201 NY 527 lOOM 611 246 order s 120 S 1065 £ 163 935 £ 174 93 253construe will s 120 S 1089 a 202 NY 622 258 appeal withdrawn s 120 S 1089 203NY 607 no notice 148 compliance 163 incompetent 163 792 138 175 pleading 201 Nr indefinite s 144 primary cause a 144 675 assume risk t 144 720 147 137 common law 154 225 give notice 154 negligence s 159 442 214 858 393 no privity s 120S 1093 do 186 414 397 impress tr. » 120 S 9 200 NY 597 request charge 453 complaint s 121 S 12C 156 210 lis pendens 162 659 457 tender 145 acquital do 160 456 924 745 753 sl20S 342 172 material 158 724 199 263 duty court s 120S 960 lOOM 523 265 damages s 120 S 1000 171 570 271 contract s 121S 11 a 204NY 564 274 compen't'n 181 458 755 762 6 120S do 142 easements 146 injunction a 204NY 1081 806 (63 tax corpn. s 120S r 198NY 166 claim sl20S a 204NY 131 238 609 igQilleg. invasn s 120S 588 136 296 misdemeanor 105M 403 204 plead negl. s 120 S 336 162 171 complaint 175 116 2 1 2 per. injuries sl20S 917 ♦ 204NY 613 for jury 151 243 do 185 202 reversal 151 244 contrib. neglig. 185 197 2 1 7contrb. s 120 S neg. 956 159 562 509 323comptnt. ev 8 120S 1011 185 187 329 particular defect s 121 S 28 74M 639 334 liability b 120 S 905 141 772 death neglig. * 201 NY 529 jndgmt. case 1 1 148 931 340contrib neg. s 120 S 1020 171 925 do 186 75 76 347 negligence s 120S 9 148 35 1 carriers s 120S 1008 8711 167 f 07 M 611 present interest 67 M 167 loss baggage 1140 926 a 203 NY 52 not apply do 145 judgment f 150 not presumed 153 524 578 931 286 reinstated s 120 S 1074 do 150 893 174 93 reversal 151 301 29 1 in rem s 120 S 1044 68 M 99 order case 1 f 143 960 civil action 153 505 misdemeanor 105M 403 297no jurisdctn. j 120 S 1070 175 214 77 M 451 303 rule of law a 120 S 1096 143 536 reversal 149 requests do 154 876 67 315 no variance s 120 S 1059 138 258 201 NY 443 separate causes 337 for jury s 120 S 910 76 M 602 361 death neg. s 120 NY 90n a 201 NY 523 373 for jury 120 3 1078 150 840 84 M 641 876 negligence s 120 S 1017 160 791 378 not limited s 120 S 982 156 411 382 withdraw Appeal s 120S 1036 8 198NT 627 El46 891 failure proof 151 36 reversal s 151 883 388quan. meruit 3 121 S 35 r 202 NY 828 incompetent f 159 452 400 mandamus 8 120S 962 a 198NT 605 taxpayer's suit d 77 M 363 capacity title 77 M 365 408 mandamus s 120 a 1029 137 486 62 M 37 lis pendens 199 NY 534 417 hab. corpus 8 120 S 1053 a 198 NY 539 43 1 demurrable s 120S 981 148 233 433 liability s 120S 996 74M 484 blasting 147 S 897 not trespass f 90 M 374 no recovery £ lOOM 438 interest 8 119 S 298 156 662 71 M 543 a 198 NT 504 202NT 192 199 damages 138 172 eminent domaii 70 M 59 1 redress intent 70 M 597 authority 75M 512 no interest 75M 267 statutory right 160 666 restricted £ 210 NT 398 173 48 s 121 S f 218 NT 467 no oDliga. 140 61 » 240 726 262 143 144 B121S 141 negligence a 201 NY 183 construction 148 260 obligation 148 161 f 161 police power £ 161 140 to jury do 214 NY 552 ratified f 173 315 nonsuit 180 453 479 App. Div s 121 S 159 139 591 amend notice 200 NY 204 amendment f 159 203 169 909 f 90 M 648 489 presumed s 121 S 280 f 98 M 469 492 pcrfoiman'c 55 1 negligence s 121 S 156 case 2 f 150 899 555 contract 8 121 S 188 a 202 NT 562 not assume 220 NT 178 566 no stay s 121 S 1144 t 142 933 unauthorized 149 249 57 1 demurrage s 121S 82 147 80!) 574 price paid a 121 S 80 154 35t essentl. element f 99M 511 598 compensa'i. s 121 S 41 dl41 90i 60 1 extra worl (H 12.j 221 52 f 176 91 M 370 672 702 424 490 492 65 1 exam, vrits, 8 121 S 139 discovery f 158 f 171 91 M d 91 M 97 M 390 391 liberality 106M 199 653 improper B 121 S 353 140 805 discovery 149 112 f 164 234 654com. law ev. S121S 156 £ 170 a 202 NY 604 damages s 121 S a 205 NT • proportion 182 241 61t 53i sl21S 142 coftdition pre't. 634 534 142 eosts a 203NY interest taxes 223NY 663 495 divesting 8 121 S 189 144 393 84 710 581 444 award 8 121 S 143 160 s 173 r 199 NY proportionally 86 M 542 damages 186 462 447 discretion 8 120 S 882 144 412 security 172 413 448 employment 8 120 S 881 140 16 error court 1 75M 463 advances d80M contract 83 M offset 95 M 192 634 831 499 not enforceable 8 121 S 170 89 M- 509 penalty s 121 S a 202 NY legislature 99 M 73 722 362 S 528 83 513 amendment 8 121 S 45 168 939 £ 86 M 563 522 surrogate 5 121S 54 a 202 NY 134 150 661 525 forgery 8 121 S 129 a 199 NY 584 5L 51 927 492 183 658 gift S 121 S s 144 loans 147 668 197 139 797 620 reversal S121S 149 laches 153 verdict 98 M 623 liability s 121 S 390 185 300 f 98 M 234 valid assignmt. 98 M 234 assignee 225NY 195 626 set aside 8 121 S 368 94 M 433 cond. precedent 180. 748 103M 559 629 demurrer s 121S 30 136 631 motion case 2 137 POf 636 'children' s 121 S 285 182 363 186 364 f 87 M 410 f 96M 135 13( 664 duty deft. 8 121S 473 do 185 849 667 no power s 121 S 589 155 448 171 85 677 construe will 8 121 S 590 r 202 NY 90 679 terminate s 121 S 486 97 M 411 683 essential S121S 472 157 6C!l 685 confidential s 121 S 512 146 432 explanation 214 NT 254 688 incredible 121 S 418 sl47 il 147 50 540 personal injuries s 121 S 180 3 201 NY 572 superintendence 647 36 173 644 rehearing s 121S 35e 67M 140 order self operative 4/iO M 52- pay costs 74M appealable 74 M 153 liability 154 546 award a 199 NY 417 645 453 451 646exam. witn' 8 121 S 399 139 136 2 proceedings 67 M 562 discovery 692 joinder E 121 S 154 164 single suii- 160 fSl M estoppel 159 99M -^"^ s 121 S 483 141 3( do 152 . 926 mplication 143 465 509 187 2.53 ir>( 480 699 damages s 121 S 417 £ 86 M 334 E 121 S 401 164 '■'» injunction a 207 NY s 177 damages s 221Ny 105M 7:1 730 208 91 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; «, criticised; 1. limited; e, explained; o, overruled: s, same case: do, dissentinR opinion: d. parallel case: a. nue&txonea N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division Vol. 136 713 error court s 121 S 370 139 299 damages a 204NY 646 717 corroboratn s 121 S 507 £ 160 391 721 ineligible B 121 S 491 67 M 297 excess salary a 201 NY 457 724 consideratn s 121 S 514 73 M 144 contract a 202 NT 57S 733 new trial s 121 S 458 f 137 894 reason rule 145 92 ejection d 88 M 214 transportation 88 M S 734 new trial s J21 S 535 f 137 894 736 enforcible s 121 S 392 172 do 177 151 sp. performance f 177 145 741 inadmissible 8 121 S 446 f 93 M 467 747 suit at law s 121 S 489 72 M 97 not dissolved 73 M 406 limit powers do 147 619 bank 147 594 legal title 152 65 not nee. party 161 283 custodian 165 lOlM set-off 186AD reconvened 60 M 420 legisl. power 207 NY 612 3/5 votes 223NY 217 765 'or jury 413 138 667 750pay moneys s 121 S 426 a 199 NY 537 limit corapen'n 70 M 4t d 71 M 541 attorney's fee; fl42 517 legal fraud 147 8.-,0 not apply 91 M 480 752 surrender sl21S 433 s 141 37 756grade cross, s 121 S 528 152 408 authority f 213 NY 122 760 authority 8 121S 524 136 757 177 447 grade crossing 843 m 200 NY 121|S]2l S correct record |71 M 420 197 440 900 121 S 76 M 767 order s 12 IS t 136 reurgument 138 misjoinder 138 774 complaint 3 121 S 447 77 M 475 852 costs appeal s 122 S 89 s 139 767 take notice 180 404 855 notice s 120 S 1132 152 608 give notice 154 858 857no evidence s 122 S 98 145 534 due care do 149 42 contrib. neglig. f S3 M 649 652 859 terminate s 122S 198 179 39 898 appeal s 120 S 1150 a 198 NY 560 tp. performance a 201 NY 583 E 120 S 1130 personal injuries a 201 NY 5S8te08 pers. injury 86 1 sub. d. tecum s 122 S 111 139 771 enforcement 140 627 507 781 probate s 121 S 467 a 198 NT 608 uphold will 141 90 intention 77 M 51 d 79 M 195 .,, ,. construction 87 1 discretion 177 572 s 122 S 4 i7 M 53/ "1 452 revocation ??' ivl"^"™ f 96 M 393^1 •"■ no suspension | 96 M 413 888 appeal 102M 653 case 12 perpetuities s 120 S 1121 105M 276 197 NY 589 788 attestation l889 election B 121 S 452 case 13 139 •.;*7!S 120 S 295 170 196 s 119 S 1134 compliance I a 197 NY 340 73 M 154 guaranty presumption case 7 87 M 571 6 120 S 1135 lOOM 84'144 327 probate I 98 M 58 891 decree ., Jcasfj 2 796construe will g 120 S 1138 8 121 S 918 * 197 NY 551 t 202 NY 476 92 M 145 800 liability 'gga resale s 121 S 793 case 5 68 M 206 s 119 S 1132 railway fares 1* 198 NY 503 68 M 386 conversion St. surface r. r. case 8 205NY 305 s 119 S 1146 presumption 1197 NY 611 77 M 549| 893pers. injury 809 judgt. pldgs case 7 sl21S 726 s 119 S 1147 f201NY 403 8 120 S 1112 strict follow ia 202 NY 629 201 NY 403 new trial case 2 order 'case 8 i 141 927 E 110 .S 1112 f 174 391|i201NY 5fi 818 contract 1 894 s 121 S 673, case 7 a 203 NY 351 s 169 141 no power 834 comensa'n s 183 203 sI21S 8G3 141 902 895 constructn. judgment jcase 2 f 154 936 s 120 S 1150 give notice |a 198 NY 234 1 54 858 piTsonal injury case 9 839 commissns s 121 S 736 •202 NY 587 420' jari.sdiction 801 148 120 S a 201 NY 1145 586 896 foreclosure s 199 NY 521 a 202 NY 301 ideatli neglig. 's 2 iifpeal 165 500 519 691 291 714 1 39 amendment 3 132 S '1019 150 do 173 practice f 168 litigate il84 42 700 288 762 1 44 complaint - - 935 475 32 allegation I 122 S 593 150 256 35 assessment i 122 S 769 1 200 NT SIP 1 162 650 1 169 134 eourt's power 93 M i interference 92 M 39 $1 new trial 3 122 S 557 i 216 NT 149 / 75 three years - - 620' 265 s 122 S 77 M fraud sl57 distinction t 89 M no waiver 89 M 800 423 134 178 objections b 123 U 29 in M 68 186 em. domain s 122 S 1034 a 190 NT 341 award 185 548 190 prom, notes s rd-6 a 61 a 2U3NY 571 203 em. domain iippeal s 1H2 S 1124 J, 199 NT 560 nominal value 160 708 easeinent 162 239 ( 213 NT 442 eq. owner 102M 460 commrs. erred 186 462 208fact questn. s 123 S 103 f 167 200 contribution t 167 200 ev. agreement 167 201 141 834 error dismissed 152 203 state separately 152 203 175 . 409 complaint 156 382 260 sl23 S sl45 binding 159 160 218 384 269 jurisdiction B 122 S 941 155 54? 272 new trial s 122 S 885 f 83 M 597 274 judgment pleadings E 122 S 966 70 M 342 motion amend 146 B2 previous born 97 M 212 319 good will s 123 S 1146 m 200 NT injunction 139 do 139 fl41 424 149 privil. 5 122S n M defense privilege 141 311 law question 141 313, 314 160 no redress do 149 libelous do 148 150 crt. 978 13 694 171 213 contempt s 121 S 987 a 199 NT 558 172 792 215 ' indirect denials s 122S 1004 74M 100 abuse process d 167 138 233 annulment 74M practice 177 74M demurrer 153 153 f 170 modilied 156 motion flo7 f 163 limited f 157 judgment 179 error court 180 20' 903 2Uti 2Sb 3Ui) 323 913 885 940 894 569 not waiver 186 28 41 642 644 92S 436 transfer tax s 122S 800 75M 56 441 liability 330 nuisance S123S ISS r 200 NY 423 339 liability s 163 422 349 change grade s 122 S 922 r 201 NT 43 357 vesting s 122 S 718 152 325 359 damages s 122S 778 783 s 202 NY 542 sl22S r 201 NY 446 agent s 122 S do 173 837 3iO 915 282 375 negligence s 122 S 1077 s 146 El46 163 454 annulment s 122 S 892 72 M 213 99 M 94 misrepresentatn 88 M 275 £ 94 M -372 102M 446 465 assessments s 122 S 835 a 203NY 632 467 reply req'd 82ii 908 90] 70fc 86 M 583 educational 149 713 71 M 8S7 not taxable 145 715 f 93 M 392 taxable 164 46 77 M 63 64 not exempt 79 M 588 lOOM 77 statutory f 80 M 465 167 S89 533 no appeal 23S- SOi- 273 S122S 141 149 e 152 pleading 143- reply necessarj 154 141 279 contempt s 122 S 974 do 138 296 92 a. 452 no discretion 74 M 330 punishment d 103M 539 281 consolldatd s 122 S 36 M 970 522 91 decree s 122 S a 200NT «olice power 158 573 f 573 aevise order 35S 576 96 constitutionl a 122 S 872 J 139 order case 4 143 f 144 950 941 , order case 920 f 148 merits 152 1 164 court discretion f 167 98 512 44 36 M rivileged r<0 negations 165 justified 165 92 866 228 866 392 B 122 S 153 judgment f 155 s 215 NT scaffold 95 M 393 160 misjoinder s 123 S 166 do 166 661 jurisdiction do 166 662 entire estate 95 M 46 vs. express trustees 177 160 237 enforcemnt. s 122 S 1030 145 262 approval 134 411 public nuisance t 163 691 249 discovery 168 rulings 349 58 103 contract a 122 S 1053 a203NY 641 authority 171 444 107 submission 1 122 S 994 a 203NY 529 < 123 S 03 M new trial 70 M certiorari 146 202 NT personal view 1S2 770 evidence f 159 817 818 award 1R4 f 92 M 5fl-( 445 192 248 421 907 548 933 459 131 s 122 S • 200 NY ord3 a 205NY 548 897 int. award s 122 S 1137 a 199 NY 559 833 execution sl23S a 201 NY retroactive 144 remedial 165 841 labor 123 S a 207 NY 614 358 289 538 747 845 bill partic 5 123 S 519 138 844 vacate order 143 215 846 distinction s 123 S 385 144 98 defeat title e 161 88 transfer stock 145 146 taxation a 204NY 153 must pld. dfnse. 7oM 56, 57 160 153 160 154 inadmissible 76 M 499 849 alienable s 123 S 343 144 540 f 161 133 854 remedy s 123 S 412 f 98 M 258 85.9 damages s 123 8 656 a203NY 45 867bp. prfmnce. s 123 8 733 t 159 855 874 not availble 34U 607 1104 218 910 inapection s 123 S 1123 142 456 912 lien case 1 s 122 8 f 174 9I3competnt ev. 900 demurrer case 3 s 123 S a 199 NY 1113 566 903 sale case 1 s 122 S a 203 NY case 2 block rule s 122 S t 164 175 1056 273 1149 882 522 905 contracts case 3 s 123 S a 199 NY motion case 2 s 199 NY goods sold case 2 a 203NY 1130 479 554 595 907pers. injury case 17 S 123 S s 202 NY a 203 NY case 11 a 203 NY mechanic's a 203 NY services case 8 sl23S m 203NY new trial case 13 150 1138 585 576 574 lien 579 1116 1598 322 908 Ccrtioiari case 12 a 201 NY 3 123 S brokerage case 4 s 123 S 20RNY case 13 a 204NY case 15 S123S r 204NY 924 pers. case 8 sl23S r 204NY 745 796 925 goods sold case 2 s 123 8 1120 a 206 NY 664 926 motion case 9 s 123 8 s 199 NY s 124 8 139 contract case 5 S123S a 203NY case 4 s 123 S r 203 NY rescission 203 NY 1122 852 1128 592 1108 399 fig'ts 111- 400 lien 9(4 fencing case 2 s 123 S 1122 r 203NY 518 personal injuries case 13 r 204NY 324 s 212 NY 141 915 contract case 10 s 123 S Ills a 203NY 591 goods sold r 203NY 600 916 penalty case 5 s 123 S a 203 NY 917 adult, case 5 sl23S r 201 NY pers. injury 8 123 8 s 123 S case 6 r 203 NY contracts case 4 S123S a 204NY commitment case 10 a204NY 931 ripar. 6 123S case 2 a 200 NY mechanic's case 7 s 123 S 1124 a 204NY 559 death neglig, case 15 e 123 S 1132 a 201 NY 58fl personal injury case 1 sl23 S 203 NY case 11 a203NY case 9 a 200 NY conversion case 10 sl57 liable 177 lOlM 1144 640 milk 1135 151 1127 1128 1116 632 644 3 123= 420 74M 449 damages 174 P 178 646 8 1 8 counterclm. i,:23S 491 141 473 court's power 73 M 402 jadgmt. pldgs. 75M 237 95 M 335 512 880 903 877 appeal s 123 8 f 138 177 estoppel 168 77 881 transfer tix case 3 s 123 S 39(1 534 11 4< 1125 533 iccount stated case 6 1 203NY 567 918 condemnatn case 10 s 123 S 1111 a 199 NY 566 pers. injuries case 4 sl23S n07 a 204NY 631 distinction 79 M 475 920 insurance s 123 S 1128 a 203NY 595 921 for jury case 1 s 123 S 1141 f 154 S 909 services case 9 s 123 8 1147 • 20n NY 502 s 139 mechanics lien case 8 E 200 NY 507 a 203NY 603 promissory note case 11 I 203 NY 575 contract 922 no stay case 1 s 123 8 1130 923transfer tax case 11 s 123 S 1110 a 199 NY 562 161 838 vested 150 808 1114 351 1139 553 591 I decree s 124 S a 199 NY 6 authority s 123 8 139 complaint 70M 221 70M. Ill: 321 641 522 380 606 932 certiorari s 123 S 1137 a 200 NY 522 933 certiorari case 14 s 123 8 r 199 NY mandamus case 12 * 200 NY conversion a 203NY contract case 9 sl23S a 204NY 1135 382 1122 034 934taxing stock case 1 s 123 8 113S m 200 NY 328 VOL. 139 list 56S 418 81 222 223 IQfalse Imprsm^ s 123 8 497 * 203NY 6U 15 discovery s 123 S 539 91 M 492 17 bi sl23 a 201 NY reversal fl48 73 M liability do 175 632 635 rage iiegl 865 38J 78 413 28 accounting s 123 S 897 s 148 7« 47 employment 123 8 837 do 171 503 79 M 243 5 1 demurrer ease 1 123 S 50» 153 908 strike out 80 M 41,7 54 report refer'c 6 123 S 671 a 200 NY 58S brokr short sale 144 Silt 641ife insurance s 123 8 471 r 203 NY 507 69 compensatiott s 123 S 61i» * 199 NY 549 173 30 street closing 145 858 149 6« authority 75M interest 150 damages 156 right award t 159 868 not final lOSM S 73 damages s 124 8 789 f 89 M 456 83 assessment s 124 S a a 200 NY a 200 NY f 213 NY 143 153 easemenia 153 512 219 777 518 51» 11 892 72S 72? 88 abatemeift s 1238 84-S » 200 NY 14S reinstatement a 202 NY 554 statutory 226NY 69 ABBREVIATIO^fS: i c. criticised ; 1, limited ; affirmed ; d, e, explained ; i distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note i, overruled; s. so mi case; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case : o. quratioa^ Vol. 139 N. Y. Supreme Court Keports — ^Appellate Division 97one judgment s 123 B 881 159 800 indictment 87 M 277 costs 181 236 1 09 judgment s 123 S 918 f 157 920 lis usury ■ 123 S 832 IS9 514 discontinue «4 M 117 extra allowance i 170 206 f20 proof deft, s 123 S 1056, 70 M 365 status plaintiff 71 M 48 annulment 71 M 50 94 M 452 jurisdiction 74M 632 eollat. attack do 160 924 (26 stay s 123 S 875 144 73 145 201 181 139 pijhwer court 146 4 153 366 counterclaim 149 86 oruSr case 1 738 149 151 804 830 828 442 6 123S do 177 do 177 distinction 150 f 155 roveitant 155 mutuality f 166 specif, perform. " 177 147 memorandum lOSM 352 155 title award s 123 S 720 a 202 NY 604 not apply lOlM 377 written notice 180 278 102M 607 1 58f act questn. s 123 S 649 147 770 7Z M 84 86 f 152 venue 164 reversal d 172 918 136 1 52 enforcem'nt 81 M not final f 159 award 159 s 84 M duty jury £ 168 244 presumptn. 123S 1115 lOOM 84 249 injunction 1 64 pers. 3 123S r 205NY in), 406 453 166 lien policy s 123 S 683 72 M 530 1 69 subpoena 5 123S 745 147 598 (72 hold over 102M 556 173 certificate not necessary 134 discove'"y s 123 S 084 A 158 702 137 motion ease 3 s 123 S 479 t 139 910 139 serve notice 1 123 S 959 141 757 142 275 physical cause 151 400 prox. cause 71 M 31, 33 no cause d 71 M 32 primary cause d 144 675 property 144 718 350 188 notice sufficient 144 352 Indefinite 144 214 defect notice J 47 75 distinction J50 804 direct result do 154 189 (45 discretion I 123 S 4T4 f iea^ ' 452 specific questns. 94 M 179 new trial 184 322 (48 restored s 123 S 493 157 895 J123S dl47 175 title 3 123 S 1 :r03NY notice d 167 807 582 749 590 218 1 79 cond precdt s 123S 840 147 818 limited 169 778 assume risk I 169 779 recovery lOlM 189 rule equity 3 123 S 653 160 47 dismissal S8 M 142 192 defense s 123 S 750 £ 171 520 194 all evidence 1 123 S 743 : 159 731 !99amend. note, i 123 S 759 \ 200 NY 199 -ovenants broken rsl M 540 violations t 170 738 1l7inadmissible 123 S 78 M notice ^9 M 92 M 585 403 809 361 220 damages s 123 S 755 144 682 225 pers. injury s 123 S 998 a 203NY 581 238 damages s 123 S 1018 151 85 73 M 890 98 M 719 date of award 320 666 620 124S a 204NY pleading t 163 show facts 1 M 107 647 590 333 invalid s 123 S 1048 d 83 M 322 waste funds 173 9 347 franchse tax s 124S 200 a 204NY 512 355 not exempt class 148 134 mandamus f 217 N Y 48 36 ( conviction s 124S 57 105M 419 365 mandamus s 124S 60 a 200 NY 521 378 not fatal s 124 S 92 169 561 390 contract s 123 S 1094 a 207 NY 258 constructn. s 123 S 994 a 203NY 588 162 609 610 end trust 75M a7 M 153 94 M revocation f 173 reservation 154 154 submission 157 constitutional f 87 M 132 e 87 M 132 366 133 801 427 799 451 452 3U 269 easements s 123 S 1012 162 245 278 parties s 123 S 104S 145 617 «6 M 505 by parties 160 837 286 negligence s 123 S 1037 144 876 883 291 juQgment s 123S 1040 fl48 931 vice principal 148 354 proximate cause 78 M 565 78 M 567 justified 168 472 30Ooq. conversn 3 123 S 932 37 M 48 302 insufficient s 123S 944 OflM 390 99M 397 327 duties s 123 S 1065 97 M 442 701 393 s 124 S a 211 NY 407 test authority s 124 S 8 M prerequisite 78 M reversal do 153 263 573 54 304 412 taxation s 124 S 487 a 201 NY 408 4 1 7 judgment a 124 S 16 f 139 924 423 new trial 124 S 124 m 201 NY 143 428 bankruptcy s 124 S 137 r 201 NY 50* 446 judgment s 124S 600 do 148 916 not accrued f 151 333 212 NY 213 in time f 77 M negligence d 153 aeath damages f 208 NY 567 new cause 171 473 presumptn. G 124 S 351 155 ^43 488 habes corp'? s 124 S 341 i 142 422 power couit a 202 NY 188 acquittal 152 874 discharge 152 874 184 581 plea in bar 152 874 arrest judgment 152 875 not consent 184 582 309 not apply s 124 S 241 143 385 factor's act r 204NY 434 530sp. perfrmce s 124 S 121 a 203NY 604 sale of goods 154 357 99M 513 compliance 216 NY 314 534rgt. dissolve g 124S 152 104M 138 542 contract s 124S 254 n. 204NY 588 no power 204NY 606 55 1 impose tine s 124 S 206 76 M 212 f 93 M 528 557 conversion s 124 S 234 a 201 NY 526 modification 146 damages f 166 206 NY 76 M 572 perjury sl24S a 201 NY materiality 76 M 98 M 47 168 5t 284 334 620 394 455 order 124 S f 158 a 200 NY fund pro tanto 72 M 495 301 931 586 463 repudiation s 124 S - 116 do 164 482 contract alive 321NY 126 103M 486 47 1 extradition s124S 47 141 655 not protected 150 13 44 5fw: 583 557 576 continue receiver s 124 S 44! 157 61( reduce possessn. 157 61C. one examination 157 Gli vacate attorney 102M 162 sup. proceeding d 102M 164 582produce bks. s 124 S 79 M limitation 79 M contempt 162 79 M 586 proper charges 5 124S 75M 454 52f S89 amendment s 124 S 189 a 200 NY 199 f 159 203 592 order relief s 124 S I 182 146 61o adverse cl^im do 146 ) 617 interpleader do 204NY 291 595 extortion e 124 S 68 145 267 156 759 evidence do 155AD 155 exceptions f 165 65 conjunction 168 206 infer guilt 184 770 603demand nee, s 124 S 63 85 M 635 606end contract s 124,3 22 146 477 617 foreclosure s 124 S 178 1 203 NY 646 337 339 f lOOM 311 debtr. insolvent 99M 341 no trust f 178 880 right collect 181 624 costs s 124 S 143 do 143 175 140 246 247 632 negligence 124S 141 640 case 2 sl24S. injunction sl41 651 judgment s 124 S 210 f 144 do 144 297 92"j charitable 76M 132 217 NY 464 bequest void 74M 328 f 87 M 42 67 1 discovery s 124 S 203 91 M 490 liberality 106M 199 672 discharge mortgage s 124S 441 r 204NY 458 687 constitutnl. sl24S 527,1023 74M 377 690 penalties s 124S 484 a 204NY 641 695 mileage s 124 S 364 f 82 M 62 719 death negligence B124S 511 a 201 NY 599 724 discovery s 124 S 463 152 164 161 738 f 82 M 407 particular book 90 M 44 90 M 45 727 no stay case 1 s 124 S 491 s 139 934 costs t 143 613 personal injury a 205 NY 627 736 demurrable s 124 S 293 141 526 740 ambiguous s 124 S 504 143 80 court's power 513 896.78 M 896 order adv. possession 157 •i07 NY 244 complaint s 160 88 M 931 779 553 657 partition .,124s''°""T8"0 7«countercln, 143 71 M judgment t 143 659 motion s 124S s 199 NY spec, performa'e a 201 NY 549 665 bequest S124S 149 a 201 NY _ 546 trusts valid 939 B 124 S 274""" 934 278 555 344 530 194 t 145 168 203 NY f 77 M trustee 76M validity 149 f 159 f 163 f 169 873 521 889 75 86 124 848 340 137 573 474 165 reduction 165 *72 judgments 103M 492 746 judgment s 124 S 325 f 160 897 751 pers inj. s 124S 295 r 204NY 341 755 cause action 124 S 529 142 "' no interest fl42 * abutter 142 ^"' not nee. party 148 120 specif, namett^ 155 290 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, Meowed; r, reversed; m, modified; *^^^ e. criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; a. »ame case; do, dissenting opinion, p, parallel case, q, ^ N. T. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division Vols, 139, 140 I 759order case S E 124 S 139 437 936 884 life insur. 762 gnar. bond « 124 S 885 a 203NY 802 769 practice S124S fiflT TOM 2] process d 143 52!j objections 143 524 subpoena 147 5U( f 174 9 IS 180 42S limits right 74M 181 96 M 638 authority 177 674 £l23S a 201 NY equity t 87 M BQSmerit case 3 s 123 S 145 damages a 203NY 852 616 proof 750 274 597 1126 561 1134 B20 780 insurance s 124S 496 a 204NY 190 786 licenses s 124 S 494 146 475 176 548 795 conviction s 124 S 521 case 2 150 911 reversal error do 173 985 800 liability B 124 S 689 d 143 668 authority do 157 855 807 negligence 5 124S 382 r 204Ny 240 81 1 limitations s 124 S 501 a 200 NY 253 821 not final s 124 S 545 143 182, 185 832 jurisdiction s 124S 334 147 670 895 trade name s 123S 476 a 204NY 630 _ J presnmptn. s'l23 S 539 72 M 235 impress trast a 203 NY 842 not apply t 72 M "fraud" 158 216 NY stockholders case 2 105M 714 236 371 209 1149 525 526 900 accounting case 6 sl23S a 201 NY cfaim case 3 a 201 NY services case 1 r 204NY services case 2 a 204NY damages ease 13 a 204NY 905 transfer tax case 16 s 124 S 199 NY case 18 s 124 S a 200 NY power court case 14 B 124 S 1133 153 88 95 M 460 906 prior lien case 5 s 124 S 1123 a 199 NY 5 cause action case 14 s 123 S 1103 145 211 907 valuation £ 124 S 1125 143 42 909 consolldatd case 10 s 124 S 1131 200 NY 513 910 contract s 123 S 1117 r 202 NY case 7 * 223NY case 8 limitation 159 90 1 contract case 8 S123S m 201 NY case 2 a 203 NY case 8 S123S a 203 NY 841 reversal s 124 S 97 170 285 848 liability s 124S 541 d 149 379 853 injunction s 124 S 317 s 200 NY 570 a 203NY 647 estoppel f 86 M 641 863 contrib. ne| S124S 142 36( 240 872pers, injury 8 124 S 50" a 206NY 713 f 219 NT 181 Don compliance 219 NT 184 want notice 178 293 877 poor law costs s 124 S 558 139 883 581 657 560 1119 45 657 1115 531 902 motion s 124 S s 199 NY s 199 NY certiorari a 200 NY liens case 11 S123S a 203 NY title deposit case 15 a 201 NT contract case 5 sl23S a 203NY services case 3 S123S a 204 NY case 9 a204NY 903 appeal case 3 s 123 S * 199 NY contract case 8 r 203NY 1112 553 556 520 a204NY 924per. in; case 5 s 124 S 199 NT a204NY judgment case 3 t 143 925 surety case 1 123 S 203 NY 926 mech. case 7 s 124 S a 203NY percentage case 3 sl23 S a 203NY 624 1133 550 642 974 1117 407 lien 1146 574 1111 589 compensation cue 3 71 M violation sl52 152 588 conTersn case 9 s 124 S 1128 203 NY 469 goods sold case 11 a 204NY 644 483 531 89 9 1 3 dismissal 927fire insur' ce case 11 s 124 S 1111 a 203NY 626 personal injury case 2 a 203NY 633 928 guaranty case 6 a 205NY 559 929 bank books s 124 S 1128 a 201 NY 562 S123S s 200 NY damages case 13 r 201 NY case 10 m 203NY duress case 7 a 204NY 914 libel case 11 s 123 S a 203NY 915 order case 12 E124S sl42 1112 508 140 579 566 1140 582 1109 902 930 new trial case 1 124 S f 76 M joinder 79 M 931 sum. pro. sl24S a 201 NY injunction 5 sl24S a 203 NY 1120 435 522 112c 57f lion 657 658 1137 552 575 904 not enforci- ble case 6 s:23S f 82M 9 1 6 commission case 7 s 124 S 1113 a 202 NY 526 921 covenants case 8 3 123 S 1105 a 205 NY 600 personal injury case 9 s 123 S 1106 r 211, NY 79 922 discovery case 13 s 124 S 1110 * 202 NY 552 personal injury case 4 S124S a 203NY f 171 case 2 S124S r 204 NY estoppel case 6 do 161 f 175 f 98 M 1137 1116 587 95 1115 184 43 882 298 VOL. 140 exemption 184 915 I pers. injury Istrctly. constrd. a 204NY 58 105M 410 8 judgment S124S sl57 40 452 1127 450 1116 390 932 undertakng case 16 s 124 S 1110 a 203NY 599 personal injury case 11 S124S a 203NY contract case 8 a 204NY 1120 035 679 933 larceny a 201 NY money had case 1 a 201 NY 585 589 935 contract case 3 s 124S 1115 a 204NY 560 923 adoption case 2 s 124S 1128 936 vol. sale case 10 s 124 S 200 NY services case 11 a 200 NY mechanic's case 1 s 124 S 1116 a 204NY 659 938 interest case 7 s 124 S 1123 a 200 NY 524 1132 177 512 lien H water rents s 124 S 140 a 201 NY mandamus 140 14 services s 124 S a 206 NY contract 83 M f 86 M necessary party 140 921 not bound 143 nandamus 143 446 942 88 submission s 124S 917 a 204NY 649 notice f '207 NY 189 268| 26,95 waiver error 570 s 125 S 918 |70 M 458 26 alleged error 182 342 533 703 1 02 perf nuance s 125 S 952 71 M 445 113 for jury s 124 S 1107 f 84 M 112 19 mandamus s 124 S 406 ' a200NY 527,,, 117 not enforceable s 124 a 1106 127 178 907 89 M 362 127 24 mandamus s 124S 270 a 204NY 664 27 extortion s 124 S 420 V 200 NY 275 150 647 appeal motion s 204NY 629 habeas corpus d 150 775 30 stockholder s 124S 1112 m 204NY 301 33 employment s 124S 321 r 204NY 535 fact question 204NY 539 38 prox. cause s 124 S 272 f 90 M 378 ( 1 9 negligence s 125S 8 a 205 NY 538 !2I intent will E 125 S 1124 m 201 NY 247 f 89 M 697 1 3 1 promisory note s 124 S 1072 s 201 NY 528 goods sold a 205 NT 624 134 judgt. pldgs s 124 S 1066 141 800 amendment 74M 205 (41 injunction B 124 S 1033 s 143 70 44 negligence S124S dl47 49 alienate S124S 70 M 248 019 58 appeal s 124 S r 200 NY 328 525 designation 153 625 proper writ 179 394 62 services s 124S a 204NY authority 75M 282 630 510 1069 170 73 arrest s 124 S 95 M warrant 182 76 assessment 5 124S a 200 NY taxable 155 construction , 156 298 1 144 pleading rule s 124 S 1031 143 141 form denial 151 409 .,-„ not permissible 58878 M 513 frivolous 102 M 262 150 penalty s 124 S 527 OM 421 160 boundary s 124 S 1096 169 110 174 85 vest people 174 80 173 recover money 124 S a 206 NY 165 damages 165 319 NY ]iot recover 165 192 unmarketable 219 NY 338 319 NY 339 record evidence 219 NY 340 949 584 585 232 1014 708 190 191 342 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distingnished ; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, not* «. criticised : 1, limited ; e, explained ; o, orer^ jled ; s. samecdbe: do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel casr; q. guest luurd Vol.140 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division / 179 bribery s 125 S 164 a 201 NY 511 1 88 amendment s 124 S 1029 143 519 194 enfoTcemt. s 124 S 1105 144 299 196 charge rity. s 125 S 101 80 M 301 lOlM 270 intention £82M 5 201 no claim s 125 S 111 146 322 all title 96 M 36 203 real estate s 124 S 1053 s 142 896 services 97 M 158 159 206 no avail B 125 S 116 154 705 liability 169 318 222 negligence s 134 S 1082 152 434 226 amendment s 125 S 1 161 493 227 certiorari s 125 S 105 a 203NY 564 230incompet ev, s 124 S 1016 72 M , 106 inadmissible 81 M 75 affld't of jure 93 M 247 232 order void s 125 S 107 157 471 238 report s 124 S 1112 199 NT 567 assessment a 199 NY 570 presumption 74M 377 240 amendment s 125S 13 74M 205 liberally construed 95 M 335 252 clerical s 125 S 109 174 457 estoppel f 99M 507 mandatory 188 18 correct errors 225Ny 327 255 contempt s 125S 2 85 M 255 enforcement 103M 702 257 amendment s123S- 128 152 505 lOOM 433 incumbrance 169 319 necessity lOOM 431 265 invalid 3 125 S 93 172 78 79 90 M 308 272 bond s 125 S 1143 r 205 NY 514 85 M 356 unconstitutional 94 M 459 277 leave to appeal s 125 S 161 attorney's do 161 179 618 lien 617 282 s 125 S f 97 M 173 266 289 adverse possession s 125 S 201 £ 217 NT 14 297 discovery 3 125 S 261 1 42 751 144 588 159 899 £ 165 247 306 s 125 S e 172 244 903 308 venue s 125 S 224 144 60 66 155 399 185 575 3 1 1 instructions s 125 S- 212 do 149 168 privilege do 140 t 161 158 364 316 discovery s 125 S 225 91 M 492 319 conditions B 125 S 171 79 M 121 323 strike out 5 125 S 182 do 140 325 326 punishment s 125S 176 103M 538 589 329 charges 3 125 S 193 f 96 M 630 350 voidable < 125S 320 140 481 353 malpractice 5 125 S 428 ■36 M 589 358 relief 5 12oS 394 149 102 waiver by const do 149 108 mistake rescind 152 197 finding d 79 M 300 mistake d 177 765 78 M 400 f 84 M 245 rescission £ 159 697 700 mutuality 166 765 362 insurance « 125 S 470 a 207 NY. 180 1367 iurisdiction s 125 S 405 s 125 S 1142 a 202 NT 547 154 140 157 . 254 service valid do 157 257 £ 166 913 default judgmt. 90 M 560 unconstitutional i 94 M 460 370 jurisdiction a 125 S 479 £ 89 M 693 411 pers. injury s 125S 295 a 205 NY 602 414 refuse stay s 125S 504 3 148 190 428 fraud grant 3 125 S 357 a 206 NY 109 evidence 165 568 rescission . f 169 807 intent 183 766 enforcement 186 300 438 party deft s 125 S 305 147 106 allegations 173 268 442 contract s 125 S 335 r 206 NY 506 453 partition 3 125 S 286 a 206 NY 661 460 champerty s 125 S 417 145 152 467 not exempt case 2 s 125 S 361 f 95 M 652 657 not delegated 178 408 498 recovery s 125 S 664 99 M 17 try issues 185 620 503 mandamus s 125 S 562 150 393 ultra vires do 150 395 396 final order 76 M 506 stockholder 310 NY 272 no authority 92 M 316 471 damages 422 704 125 S fl 206 NY liability 88 M no duty do 88 M obligation 168 489cont. govrns s 125 S 510 79 M 26 492 papers s 125 S 3 165 423 present facts 176 216 495 non compliance s 125S 410 184 944 507 s 135 S 175 834 969 509 complaint s 125 S 807 164 64 523 discovery s 125 S 392 168 673 81 M 363 529 repugnant 3 125 S 366 71 M 584 150 643 532 discovery 3 125 S 427 £ 140 586 £ 181 935 542 error court s 125 S 797 91 M 70 549 bill panic, 3 125S 796 f 148 642 551 f'd transfer s 125 S 1108 208 NY 637 557 insurance 3 135 S 374 a 202 NY 610 3 302 NY 611 1 3Uf NY 484 mortgage clause do 145 727 subrogation 3 150 671 yroof loss L6U 780 different intrsts do 150 733 not apply mortgage 159 320 stipulation e 177 359 impracticability 177 358 mtge. clause lOBM 101 570 issue stock s 125 S 57^ 157 HOB 178 597 liability 157 309 220 NY 86 unlawfully 213 NY 587 binding £ 91 M 264 591 order case 5 s 125 S 70S ! 142 OOh amendment 3 141 ai^ s 125 S 86: false entries 202 NT 465 forgery " 202 NT 585 do 177 155 595 cause actnl s 125S 772 184 759 equity remedy 225NY 102 602 order case 1 sl25S 865 f 140 926 may intervene f 168 • 236 injunction £ 216 NT 462 £ 168 237 do 168 238 authorized £ 92 M 253 f 170 957 peculiar rights 170 471 illegal waste 9'9 M ■ 69 6 1 1 franchise sl25S 1045 a 201 NY 594 62 1 injunction 3 125 S 929 f 149 910 do 149 910 eminent domain 163 588 634 vesting s 125 S 876 152 326 construction £ 81 M 411 650 sale realty s 125 S 1005 r 202 NT 466 659 new trial s 125S 527 185 110 680£orclose lien 3 125 S- 594 149 682 685 risks assumed s 125 S 542 55 417 a 208 NV 540 687 r. 1. neglig. 3 125S 626 a 205NY 371 __ 1 compliance s'l25 S 606 1 M 543 695 liability s 125 S 637 178 " 541 80 M 367 recovery 178 542 699 title S125S dl59 671 len s 125S 1139|'823 a203NY 550 ' veterans dischg. 74M 68 show vacancy 153 S85 92 M 293 726 distinction s 125 S 721 79 M 505 file contract £ 160 376 within statute £ 167 71 733 platform s 126 S 143 77 M 178 a 205 W y 627 proximate cause 165 700 735 authority , s 126 S 132 £ 87 M 591 739 contract B 125 S 861 s 202 NT 543 745 highways s 126 S 2'96 86 M 282 750 allowances s 126 S 155 * 202 NT 561 legal duress do 157 179 756 liability s 126 S 128 171 706 762 mandamus E 126 S 291 a 201 NY 545 769 tax district s 126 S 259 88 M 596 ministerial 170 228 88 M 597 no estoppel £ 88 M 598 mandamus 170 228 city entitled f 95 M 665 776deny injunc. s 125 S 850 145 3 water courses f 151 306 786 constitutnl. s 125 S 817 r 202 NT 53 789 injunction S126S 198 a 201 NY 521 792 damages s 125 S 497 £ 164 313 BOOcourt's pwr s 125 S 561 £ 159 293 70 1 pers. injuiy 5 125 S 584 a 206 NT 722 716 eonviction s 125 S 680 a 202 NT 624 162 ■ 290 practice med. 103 305 723 mandamus s 125 S 583 806 damages s 125 S 148 award s75M 210 NY 810 discretii s 126 S 154 new trial do 218 NT 551 14) 813 10P 433 _ j compliance s 125S 8Rfi d75M attestation 158 71 requirements 83 M 247 probate £ 84 M 660 89 M 31 publication 84 M 660 ■cknowledgmt. 84 M 662 publication will 106M 234 probate evid. 105H 335 830 conversion s 125 S 813 a 206 NY 668 estoppel d 84 M 448 genl. manager 93 M 547 title good 220NY 481 not liable f 183 442 835 nonsuit s 125 S 801 s 163 139 839 constitutnl. s 125 S lOOO 143 781 act void 153 137 reasonable 158 256 846 admissions s 125 S 689 146 74 £ 173 146 reversal 172 148 848 B 125 S 728 r 208 NY 421 167 53S 852 damages 3 125S 644 s 149 21T 656 mutuality sl25S 567 71 M 211 857 prove contrl s 125S 641 74M 462 liability 76 M 501 859 will proof B 125 S SSS 201 NT 596 86 1 decree S 125 S 702 a 202 NT 613 864 penalties 9 125S 684 a 204NY 419 874 carelessness s 125 S 622 158 418 878 injunction sl24S 2 a 204NY 56S 881 certiorari case 3 B 125S 843 895 a 202 NY 436 iromiBory note case 2 a 203NY 508 g 124 S^ 1128 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; ", dismissed; n, no:e: c. criticised : I. limited ; e. explained ; o, overruled ; s, same case; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case; o.. questioii'O N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division Vols. 140, 141 contract case 4 s 124 S 1111 a 205 NY 607 S82 injunction case 4* C.124S 200 NY im 666 negligence a 201 NY 163 personal injury case 5 S124S a204NY tax deed case 9 a 205 NY title plaintiff 214 NY 575 case 14 s 124 S 1120 a 203NY 601 spl. performance 90 1 insurance case 1 s 125 S 1121 a 205 NY 620 guaranty m 205 NY 621 case 2 s 125S 1130 a 205 NY 606 ' 'means' ' 224NY 1118 558 604 s 124 S 1115 a 203NY 636 personal injury 883per8. injury case 8 E 124 S 1126 r 203 NY 413 taxation case 9 s 124 S 1126 a 206 NY 633 885 case 5 B 124 S 1112 s 174 333 334 893 injunction case 1 8 125 S 1117 e 205 NY 609 case 6 s 124S 1115 a 204Ny 631 must affirm 161 403 motion redemption case 2 a 210 NY 580 case 11 8 125 S 1123 a 207 NY 732 divesting case 12 s 125 » 1123 144 659 attornment 103M 507 894 reargument case 3 s 125 S 1111 r 200 NY 536 895 covenants case 4 f 125 S 1132 154 855 case 8 s 12SS 1134 a 205 NY 606 discovery 896 insurance case 1 s 125 S 1139 a 200 NY 582 injunction cases 8 & 9 S125S 1148 a 204NY 635 irrelevant s 158 420 897eleotion law case 2 8 125 S 1114 a 200 NY 59 20 902 crimes case 3 3 125 S 1137 200 NY 443 no review f 165 59 903 mandamus case 3 s 125S 540 a 203NY 550 904 removal case 9 s 125 S 1123 r 202 NY 104 own knowledge f 157 359 909 contract case 4 s 125 S 1125 a 200 NY 594 persni. injuries case 7 r 205 NY 548 case 13 I 205 NY 615 surplus income do 165 88 9 1 competent case 2 s 125 S 1132 m 205 NY 621 case 7 s 125 S 1111 a 204NY 684 separation loreclose lien case 9 s 125 S 1112 a 206 NY 24 contract case 16 a 207 NY 649 'jase 17 s 125 S 1137 stolen goods •208 NY 578 73 M 457 91 I services case 6 s 125 S 1151 1 205NY ( county charge 153 326 cases 7 and 8 s 125 S 1132 E 200 NY 5T1 fees m 205NY 181 not CO. charge r 205 NY 194 Petitions name injunction case 10 s 125 S 1115 a 207 NY 647 912 quo warranto case 8 E125S 1139 a 201 NY 194 915 fraud case 15 r 202 NY contempt sl48 425 170 917 insurance case 5 s 125 S 1114 m 205NY 467 case 8 a 206 NY 710 case 10 s 125S 1130 r 205NY 33 9 1 8 reinstatemt case 4 s 125 S 1141 a 207 NY 698 contract case 7 e 125 S 1133 a 204NY 636 damages case 10 s 125 S 1151 a 202 NY 559 9 1 9 appeal case 2 125 S 1149 r 205 NY 518 iflotion case 7 B 125 S 1127 ' 207 NY 730 nonsuit r 208 NY 334 case 9 s 123S 1146 a 204NY 661 920 new trial case 2 s 125S 1145 a 204NY 641 921 labor law case 5 s 125 S 1151 il 205 NY 651 case 6 !, 125 S 1125 r 201 NY 271 unconstitutional 165 604 death neglig. adv. possession case 7 s 125 S 1141 r 208 NY 364 922 stolen property case 5 5 125 S 1137 •.'00 NY 568 insurance case 9 1 204NY 357 925 injunction case 2 s 125 S 786 s 147 785 926 constructn. case 4 s 125 S 439 145 394 promissory note case 3 1 205 NY 626 guaranty 164 670 case 4 95 M 159 95 M 588 929 no reversal case 1 s 125 S 502 f 157 525 930 removal case 9 5]2.iS 1148 r 201 NY 415 juij^diction case 6 s 127 S 1119 150 459 932 libel case 16 s 125 S 1126 .s 146 21 a 206 NY 641 933 contract case 12 s 125 S 1128 * 202 NT 541 liquor tax law case 10 a 202 NT 52S personal injury case 14 sl25S 112B a 205 NY 616 934 legis. power case 8 S125S 1133 a 201 NY 321 167 316 s 235 US 179 judgt. pleadings case 3 a 201 NY 533 discovery case 7 152 164 f 90 M 45 938 per. injury case 2 B 125 S 1149 r 206 NY 83 case 3 sl25S 1131 a 205 NY 541 penalty case 4 s 125 S 1137 - 206 NY 714 case 5 S125S 1123 5 148 933 case 6 s 163 272 939 goods case 4 sl25S sl4« case 5 S125S a 204NY necessaries case 8 E 125 S a 206 NY negligence case 10 s 125 S a 207 NY sold 1123 219 1122 686 1125 188 1340 674 940 revocation case 13 S126S 1123 a 205 NY 535 941 sup. pro. case 1 s 126 S 1133 r 201 NY T-ersonal injuries case 3 s 126S 1126 * 201 NY 572 motion case 5 s 205 NY 586 a 205 NY 625 s 126S ■ 1132 master neglig. case 6 E 126 S 1129 a 206 NY 355 case 7 B 126 S 1131 r 207 NY 133 case 12 I 126 S 1150 a 207 NY 727 942 appeal case 6 s 125 S 1112 r 207 NY 34 persni. injuries case 7 s 125S 1117 a 205 NY 608 right parties case 12 s 125S 1117 s 205 NY 540 943sp. perfmce, case 5 r 206 NY 385 case 10 223NY 475 476 944 award case 8 s 126 S 1121 a 201 NY 531 mere stranger 144 110 appeal case 7 a 202 NY 606 attorney client case 9 s 125 S lllS m 205NY 398 persni. injuries case 2 a 205NY 570 law practice f go M 24 case 8 f 170 825 945 gambling case 9 s 125 S 1136 a 203 NY 73 case 13 167 536 bets wagers s 125 S 1137 case 6 a 203NY 530 ejectment case 11 s 125 S 1135 a 205 NY 618 franchise tax case 13 s 125 S 728 m 208 NY 421 946 abduction r 125 S 1137 a 200 NY 593 negligence case 7 a 204NY 543 case 6 a 295 NY 540 case 10 a 205 NY 619 VOL 141 I carelessness s 125 S 642 158 41S 8 statutory B 125 S 677 93 M 599 insufficient 99M 390 1 2 sp. perfmce. s 125 S 553 a 205 NY 486 26 convention S125S 704 141 30 mandamus 141 80 31 in force s 125 S 783 84 M 365 40 residence s 125S 614 d 147 698 168 445 jurisdiction 147 525 43 legacy s 125 S 713 79 M 17 49 gen. denial s 125 S 597 e 209 NY 403 commissions 176 553 54equal interest s 125 S 878 a 201 NY 534 f 144 804 accounting joint tenancy t 164 48 79 M 387 79 M 658 £ 85 M 272 presumption 85 M 294 cctenants 165 917 to wife 95 M 78 evidence gift 186 189 award f 144 256 257 73 M 233 appraisal a 202 NY 606 order case 9 £ 147 934 1 23 damages s 125S 1052 a 205NY 478 1 30 injunction s 125 S 1030 a 206 NY 221 139 estoppel B 125 S 1116 73 M 417 constitutional 151 457 review 154 68 bill partic. s 125 S 647 149 271 83 settlement s 125 S 717 f 78 if 6yp 89 equities s 125 S 668 d 93 M 107 95 construction s 125 S 699 77 M .';a f 94 M 538 I I I corrobora- tion s 125 S 72r, 209 NY 339 I 15 judgment case 4 6 125 S 592 f 141 020 no estoppel f 165 70 1 20error ruling s 125 S 697 71 M 486 precedent 71 M 487 188 158 murder 6 125 S 1079 201 NY 201 requests 154 51 1 70 contributn. s 126 S 51 156 509 t 161 829 161 830 a 206 NY 179 180 benefits E 126 S 12 a 208 NY 538 188 information s 126 S 33 98 M 56 198 affidavit s 126 S 120 77 M 278 evidence facts 184 163 conclusions 184 163 205 constructn, 223NY 241 equitable 106M 141 208 reversal s 126 S 6 143 462 217 duty corpn. S126S 38 204NY 354 notice proof 150 137 dismissal 156 117 relief 156 792 exonerated 220 NY 294 232 meas. dam. E 125 S 1090 30 236 lien 125 S 1037 173 220 250 deposit s 125 S 1104 a 205 NY 621 25 1 ten. entirety s 125 S 1071 73 M 450 one-half rates q 74M 215 demurrer 93 M 669 averment 185 248 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; t, followed: r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; c, criticised: 1. limited; e, explained; o, overruled: s. same case: do, dissentiiME opinion: p. parallel case; a. qqei rthwo d. Vol. 141 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division 255 CO. servt. negligence 102M 265 justiflcation s 126 S 72 M on inquiry 166 £ 170 d 174 f 174 174 f 176 liability 173 84 M f 85 M notice do 170 d 176 no notice d 174 for jury do 176 890 221 56 680 169 170 171 848 484 449 623 685 848 166 849 363 mandamus 14S 415 366 damages s 126S 1122 r 205NY 431 468 apartment 372per8. injury ^"y^^f 272 legal lees s 125 S 1035 a 206 NY 706 274 draft S126S r 204NY 280 contract sl26S r 20oNY damages d 154 extra work do 154 do 168 requirement do 154 107 505 61 343 116 463 decree void 9 126 S 551 167 544 any party 172 463 617 863 3 126 S r 205 NY negligence sl57 161 do 161 compensation 169 237 380 commissions s 126 S 219 205 NY 617 382 distinction s 12B S 256 84 M 503 386 services 126 S 339 I- 205 NY 628 211 s 126 S f 163 347 472 discretion QRo s 136 S 324 171 508 98 H 43 295 authority s 125 S 6L_ s 126 S 47 143 415 phow vacancy 4001aw question i 126 S 265 do 145 552 judgment s 144 932 :' 144 932 'skids' not way £ 163 513 215 NY 591 ways works 120 215 NY 589 152 1 '408 indictment 120 s 126 S 522 70 M 445 manslaughter - 527 475 payment s 126 S 430 76 M 222 estoppel 154 467 478 personal representations s 126 S 229 157 287 next kin f 177 843, 844 dying before lOlM 355 representatives 223NY 512 485 accounting B 126 S 419 a 207 NY 662 3 53 301 libel s 126 S a 203 NY 318 trustee life tenant B 126 S do 145 as trustees 148 security 153 691 a 203NY conviction L46 d 168 waiver 150 835 353 27 396 797 215 332 LO exceptions 332 liability s 125S 1061 222NY 133 336 modificatn. s 125 S 1087 3 144 508 a 206 NY, 708 improper judgt. 157 714 339 constructn, s 126 S 325 165 6 business name 170 462 349 appeal s 126 S 690 " 202 NY 536 anv party 172 463 352 construe will 5 12RS 086,1145 a 205NY 204 360 judgment i12fiS 303 432 indemnity s 126 S 271 f 153 183 f 153 184 218 NY 4 441 act promptly s 126 S 226 f 170 f 130 769 448 407 153 673 421 equity s 126 S 25 162 461 £ 96 M 260 746 443 parties S126S dl57 145 motion 1 126 S e 206 NY 450 inspection 20: 249 405 365 149 £ 78 M offset 149 appeal 148 judgment £147 £175 578 damages S126S fl41 170 easements 178 854 821 493 liability a 126 S 555 143 obligation 147 insurance m 206 NY 510 money separate " 173 33 609 271 670 exonerated 203 s 125 S 220 NY 621 679 inspection 638 s 126 S 455 81 M 347 ^„.„.. 934 due care 96 M 448 903 all persons 81 M 348 income ceased s 126S 801 221NY 93.5 683 judgment 1S9 s 125 S 582 508 505 do 155 241 905 621 925 35 36 649 591 order sl26 1142 149 f 151 interest d 96 M 99M enforce set-off 178 656 99M 651 600 mandamus s 126 S 986 15U 13 caucel tax 206 NY , 43 presumption 155 ■ 243 identification 155 243 no notice 210 NY _ 415 serve notice 91 M 286 material 94 M insufficient 99M compliance lOlM 440 392 380 s 126S 102M 456 duly perfmd ■lU'CS US 163 520 discovery s 126 S 409 144 175 f 165 247 525 waiver s 126 S 440 £ 163 65 529 negligence b 126 8 304 do 154 b 535demand note s 126 S 366 154 179 545 coservant s 120 S 289 146 646 556 judgment ^„ s 126S 497 203 J 205 NY 53-; 569 mandamus „,„ :. 12GS 380 B75 Jo 149 75 relief 6 M 323 252 f 92 M 6 1 I alternative 5 126 S 317 146 annulment do 146 d 207 NY lex loci E 97 M 97 M 623 opening st. 201 46 496 593 no power f 92 M 593 sum, proceeding 92 M 594 limit jurisdictn. ^et out facts 148 98 M compliance t 91 M 47 419 579 458 disbarment s 126 S 456 902 a 2C1 NY 572 77 M 90 M [■eview 155 169 77 M recount 169 33 446 722 304 33t: 303 576 bill partic. B 12("5 321 11 41 518 519 448 104 113 80 1 accounting/ 900 Under stat 941 s 127S 211, lisb s 127S 1140 294 147 f 86 H distribution £ 77 M eventual estate 944 917 690state'B pwr. s 125 S 991 f 162 390 693 new trial s 121 S 396 f 149 961 f 159 918 f 161 944 713 enforcement B 126 S 436 s 147 893 154 844 720 land under water s 126 S 910 r 200 NY 1 730fliiding5 fact s 126 S 755 165 206 77 M 390 mechanic's lien s 152 184 B 164 949 85 M 243 not nonsuit 77 M 397 dismissed f 178 675 743 sale bonds B 126 S 926 S 155 312 755 negligence s 126S 644 s 148 758 physical cause 151 400 763 mech. lien s 126 S 313 - a 206 NY 72a 284 partnership 118 154 064 293 public user 88 M 611 81 1 'necessities s 126 S 932 f 163 for jury 179 hot liable 185 s 126 S 152 IG2 524 pers. injurv s 126 S 489 755 presumptn. a 206 NY 744 ^"^26 8 '■' 149 630 public purp 78 M S126S n2injunc T5M 511 i. 207 NY constitutional dedication f 92 M 7 164 221NY 227 prospective f 173 354 special session 182 648 injunction 743 _ 2 t 648 a •^40 removal s 127 a 542 14" 19 admit bail 73 M 208 utmost care 73 M 211 656 mandamus s 126S 54P 179 20 659 denials s 125 S 993 do 161 9SH 165 948 769common Law 126 S 739 .54 .225 personal injury a 207 NY 69! 773 amendment S120S 574 11.93: 625 case - ,,. 12C S 114i 207 NY 252 case 14 126 S 114> „ 20s NY 3101 1009 90S 93 1 dissolution c.Tse 2 908 592 a 205 NY case 3 S126S a 205 KY pleadings ca."!e 8 1131 63* AilbKEVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f. 'o'low'^: r, reversed; m,modifie^^^^^^^^ c, criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, dissentin* opinion, n. parallel case, q, q N, Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division Vols. 141, 142 sl26S r 205 NT iDJunction case 9 a 205 NT f 169 rent case 10 sl26S a 209 NT assault case 11 s 201 NT contract S126S s 203NY case 14 91 M royalties case 15 r 201 NY 420 personl injuries 933pers. injury case 10 s 126 S 1148 a 205 NT 600 promissory note case 11 s 126 S p. 207 NT rontract case 14 e 126 S a 207 NT 1128 526 619 849 1126 607 527 1127 637 348 1137 516 1132 660 VOL.142 8 duty engineer s 126 S 480 153 381 13 indebted 3 126 S 678 143 292 choice pleading e 151 356 written contrct 179 655 18 ejectment s 126 S 1056 a 206 NT 448 Hie notice 171 480 25 damages s 126 S 514 3 202 NT 537 1 206 NT 173 change decree 227 US 638 29 addnl. fare 3 126 S 449 r 206 NT 440 J3I pers. injury 3 126S 745 I 205 NT 541 issume risk 154 221 36 St. surf r. r. 5 126S 792 203NY 366 vice principal 148 354 f 165 890 cause action c 157 830 44no restriction s 127 S 1150 77 M 493 mandamus a 202 NY 516 219 NT 357 discretionary 93 M 242 fix fares 05 M authority 225NT 688 555 53 time essence 880 106 109 s 126 S t 214 NT compliance 214 NT new cause do 214 NT 114 defense d 169 468 89 M 114 legal theory 169 469 57 resale land s 126 S 464 1 201 NT 596 deficiency plff. 1 153 68 '^9 abutter • 126 S ! 12 •'■late interest US 127 n4 manslaughter 3 126S 674 I 204 NY 678 39 hill partic, 3 126 S 448 159 582 172 892 90 presumption s 126 S 486 1B9 262 87 94 award 3 127 S 131 a 205 NY 539 151 364 title to bed f 160 209 160 213 public highway 179 410 damages 179 411 102 removal s 127 S ' 14 a 202 NY 612 106 deposit 3 120S 1011 a 203NY 384 I 1 8 quaranty s 126 S 1097 a 206 NT 550 122 mandamus 3 126 S 1027 X 201 NT 535 illegal 73 M 433 i35 carriers 3 126S 857 d 74M 350 a 206 Nf 7U5 143 supl. mtge. s 127 S 30 174 326 155 prob. cause s 127 S 33 86 M 18 aifi davit f 87 M 278 I 59 for jury s 126 S OSJ f 158 80J 166 not liable 3 127 S 220 i 83 M 140 169 judgment b 126 S 1035 ( 142 920 not negligence 167 363 1 72 usage s 126 S 996 do 165 593 i741aw question case 1 126 S 863 dc 153 935 1 76 replevin 3 .26 S 834 a 206 NT 716 facts stated 183 776 184 prox. cause ■1 120 S 866 1 206 NT 89 186 paid in full s 126 S 994 160 829 198 jurisdiction s 126 S 1066 d 36 SI 598 315 NY 213 ''vidence gift 186 189 ?02 notice I 126 S 982 ■ 171 715 205 no power s 126 S lOBP 90 M fi4H 207 assumption c 126 S 864 155 417 for jury C 165 463 209 decree s 126S 1078,1149 s 147 41) reargument do 147 414 additional ev. 80 M 24 220 taxation 1143 43 s 126 S 106B reduce asessmt, 57 735 224 assumption B 120 S 90fc 151 313 mandamus 171 125 226 foreclosure 5 126S 944 s 140 804 f 165 nuisance 99M t 221NY 352 motion 126 S 206 NT 240 costs s 126 S a 2U3NY 147 d 79 M 835 637 656 293 245 no neglig. s 1203 son 148 421 249 money due < 126 S 11.-3; 200 NY GC4 i6Q phvs. caus s 126 S 1020 lai 400 notice 154 224 282 death neg s 126S 823 a 203 NY 57( 286 judgment sl26S s 145 nonsuit d 151 f 172 for jury £158 292 void f 89 M 979 909 347 628 487 71C 300 change grade s 126 S 728 160 160 307 inapproprte 186 220 313 to trustei s 126 S 104( 172 28 f 95 M 365 331 per, injuriei s 126S 1074 a 203NY 571 efficient cause 155 416 £ 150 55 339 death negl s 127 S 391 1 205 NY 55! no cunflict d 133 38], 'M3 may recovr 3 1208 nr US 14S 911 1467 notice required sl26S 149 216 NY rescission a 208 NY B 165 568 238 671 S42 730 831 358 not sur' plusage s 127S 138 do 148 28 Stat, running 73.M:, n identity f 158 vest title 166 907 damages 104M 609 398 inj. servant 3 120S 511 5 205NY 379 3 148 914 3p. performnce. 162 637 iWI not s 125 S 78 II abortion 152 1106 Sfi 250 253 relief 120 740 695 470 eq. S127S 146 f 170 liability f 172 restrictions 96 M 49 1 new trial 554 res ipsa 1. s 127 S 149 sl56 76 M inspection 165 verdict 98 M 44 822 370- 337 891 51 8 127 S 143 judgment t 145 complaint 175 4M 561 insurance 204 s 127 S 589 8 206 NY 062 92 569 burd. proof s 127 S 595 f 83 M 413 inadmissible do 83 M 416 572 950 941 74M 74M liablp averment 83b WO . .^.,. 301 admissibility 147 , 402 prostitutionlcause action a 127 S 98 149 - 201 NY 570 allegations 154 374 negligence 157 407 parties 166 s 126 S 954 pleading s 127 S 1150 do 161 r 201 NY 427|reasonable .185 tax 840 119 578remove trek. 116|B 127 s sia 273] a 202 NY 212 rule pleading .consolidation 02 159 330 27«l 592 sum. pro. :!l's 127 S 438 a 208 NT 103 0.58 damages 42 1 franch. s 126 S r 203 NY jeopardy 184 426 decree 8 126 S a 202 NT s75M 495 stay s 127 S 174 73' 93.-. 899 386 care 187 48 185 598 cor. S127S 157 fugitive 177 752 error 382 788 605 accounting s 127S 764 r 205NY 450 presumption 149 903 546,623 mortgage 53]^ 'possession 507 inference '? 127 S 479 s 127 S 73|164 70S 965 170 315|„„ 614 b26equity court ■5fl;>R,ni-ud^men. il^'il ^ |51 '510 judgment (05 j. right account is 127 S 221 75M 000 f 142 n4.« coc„ 'mental suffering fSpm. prosecutn. 431 judgment 207 NY 314° 126 S 143 436 burd 159 not adjudicatPd 95 M 31 365 730 469'"" "^ 1^ ipers. injurv ,640 jlirisdictn. proof ]d 184 817:fright 2851184 127 S 206 NY ni86 M 101 5(4 conclusive 8 127 S 78 f 71 M ■ 540 compensation 71 M 541 i 91 M order | 4.0 jms 173 47& 304 655 449 right 10 inspect S126S 1101_ H^I^B^ iq'l'iiiS 93 r parol evidence dl4S l»l'forty per cent |101M 26S 645 difSculty s 127 S 641 __, 72 M B16 477 decree f 149 946 power sale f 166 a 451 minority stockholders s 126 S do 154 147 contract f 170 'f 94 JI ']^Q9(j| contingent SnU 658 authority gi-TE 127 S 374 5'a 206 NT 71S 454 remove trustee s 127 S a 201 NT 459 n 126S f 182 16 590 923 465 defense s 127 S ^ 76 M 24: 91 M 233 reply neccssarj 152 70^ 91 M 232 102M 638. 641 522 for jury s 126 S 77 M for jury 150 665 not final s 127 S 379 159 667 18.'S.o'P dissolution 537 liability s 127S ■ 147 1: 543 fraud transfer s 127 S 1 8 151 i fraud s 165 5C not sufficient 127 S f 154 do 154 677 expert S127S 148 prepond ev. 76 M fl56 40S 925 925 431 16T 402 940 680 damages s 127 S 777 165 200 ABBREVIATIONS: a,'&ffirmed; d. distinguished; i, followed: r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n. mjit c, criticised ; 1. limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s. same case: do, dissenting opinion: p, parallel case; n. questioned Vols. 142, 143 N. Y, Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division 687 sum remedy s 127S 70a 149 273 702 contract s 127 S 738 fl42 716 cond. precedent 149 judgmt. £148 f i56 168 893 940 924 72 1 assessment s 127 S 396 84 M 619 86 M 299 s 86 M 300 733 difficulty 8 127 S 680 72 M 616 construe will r 203 NY 325 91 M 664 distribution 163 244 74 1 actual notice B 127 S 725 151 654 750 bill partic. s 127 S 724 84 M 200 discovery f 164 224 753 mandamus s 127 S 348 149 825 755 demurrer s 127 S 782 150 714 f 167 679 760 damages s 127 S 500 I 208 NY 115 765 intention s 127S 671 223NY 239 785pay intereit s 127 S 445 e 144 578 Sep. proceeding 855 pleading S 127S 836 851 142 877 * 202 NY 581 ejectment s 170 441 876 litigate s 127S 851 184 762 880 order 3 127 S 787 i 150 925 cancel judgment f 206 NY 89 1 per. injuries s 126 S 1136 1 205 NY 622 892sale property s 126 S 1144 a 206 NY 171 489 705 894 case 2 s 127 S * 201 NY 1116 593 898 appraisal case 8 * E 124 S 1053 t 126 S ' 1124 u 201 NY 537 899 constructn. case 4 s 125 S 1133 a 204NY 686 personal injury case 8 B 125 S 205 NY case 10 a 201 NY 1135 623 513 900 death dam case 6 125 S 205 NY 1150 533 152 789 motion s 127 S n42 order £148 £148 right appear 148 appeal 159 compliance 159 211 NY 117 632 795 903 materials case 3 s 126 S a 206 NY case 8 s 126 S s 201 NY labor a 206 NY 1122 065 1126 550 127 r 205NY answer bad 77 M 564 denials 77 M 564 death damages case 6 s 126 S 1135 r 205NY 267 907 damages case 7 s 126S 1140 a 205 NY 532 908 forgery s 127 S 3 127 S case 5 a 202 NY certiorari case 3 ft 201 NY case 3 salary 319 NY 710 113S 456 592 262 92lpersni. prop. casp 4 8 127 S 1131 8 202 NY 531 conversion a 205 NY 535 922 assault case 2 8 127 S 1134 r 206 NY 105 923 partition case 4 s 127 S * 207 NY case 7 E 127 S a 207 NY case 9 6 127 S a 203 NY 909 stayed case 10 s 126 S 1150 161 416 9 1 negligence case 2 sl26S r 203NY case 3 S126S a 205 NY 1904 costs 920 "^asC' 6 921|S 126 S 1130 death neglig. taxation 5 127 S ql43 203 NY 811 s 128 S 170 -lofla 207 NY ""case 8 s 126 S a 202 NY accounting case 9 F 126 S 143 case 10 71 358 1 858 43 126 665 1121 548 1131 947 35 908 823 commission s 127 S 537 1 150 928 839 give notice s 127 S 354 175 83 845 judgment s 127 S 504 f 150 903 damages s 126 S m 204NY 905 order case 1 178 99M d 96 M ease 3 e126S fl42 case 7 t 151 offset 149 1131 292 656 651 1132 905 925 621 906 pleading case 4 S126S 1134 1120 230 1133 625 9 1 1 pers. injury le 1 s 126 S 1127 s 127 S 1117 a 206 NY 666 9 1 2 accounting case 6 s 126 S 1127 a 202 NY 516 913 (or jury case 3 126 S 1151 r 206NY 701 915 death negl. 127 S 206 NY e J 17 death damages s 126 S a 207 NY 936 divorce case 12 s 127 S a 205 NY case 14 s 127 S a 205 NY case 15 a 205 NY 1120 623 1112 622 627 1146 704 1150 664 1148 250 1123 573 1134 668 1131 G08 1093 704 919 partition case 1 r 205 NY case 4 S127S ■i 204NY r 206 NY case 12 S127S a 206 NY 502 1114 238 471 1117 707 920 covenants case 11 s 127 S 1127 a 201 NY 445 death damages case 6 6 127 S 1120 a 205 NY 532 firp insurance ,e 2 s 127 S 1123 207 NY 675 assessment se 4 127 S 1126 r 216 NY 486 undertaking case 14 s 127 S 1128 205 NY 542 925 contract case 9 s 126 S 1148 m 206 NY 528 926appeal order case 1 s 126 S a 205 NY insurance case 3 E 126 S a 207 NY case 5 sl27S a 204NY decree recover money case 6 s 126 S 1121 205 NY 604 928 appraisal case 13 s 126 S a 202 NY case 3 a 207 NY s 126 S case 4 s 126 S a 207 NY case 5 s ]2r, S a 206 NY damages case 9 s 126 S a 207 NY 1124 545 703 1149 1121 713 1128 707 1136 721 929 invalidity case 1 8 127 S r 203 NY case 9 S127S a 206 NY accounting case 11 sl27 S a 208 NY 1139 201 1119 721 1148 603 932 appeal s 127 S 1150 s 202 NY 536 goods sold case 3 s 127 S 1150 a 206 NY 626 933unauthori2ed s 126S 1103 149 249 935 mandamus case 1 s 127 S 1137 a 203NY 551 foreclosure case 24 8 127 S 1148 a 206 NY 067 s 206 NY 670 937 injunction case 7 8 127 S a 204NY damages case 8 reinstatement 1115 682 407 1125 712 1151 580 a 209 NY case 10 127 S 207 NY case 12 8 127 S * 202 NY final decree s 148 190 negligence 938 irregularity case 15 s 127S 1113 146 675 939 sfflickholder case 15 s 127 S s 127 S a 202 NY mandamus s 127 S case 4 a 203NY VOL. 143 7 records ev. S127S 74M entries 185 506 22 800 26 franch. tax s 127 S 91f r 203 NY 119 reduce assessmt. 157 735 certiorari 157 737 not competent 157 738 48 s 127 S 686 172 968 1112 1140 11 1134 548 945 prom, note case 8 127 S a 206 NY case 9 s 127 S 206 NY 1147 716 1149 704 947 reargument s 145 606 948 negligence s 127 S 1126 144 268 d 144 270 271 collision 147 647 56 platform s 127 S 692 77 M 178 not appurtnance 153 407 69 decisive s 127 S s 127 S a 206 NY injunction 81 M judgment £ 163 582 1140 719 645 873 78 equity suit 5 127 S 569 do 148 107 a 206 NY 711 recover share f 168 155 185 58 83 injunction 9 127S 974 148 313 construe easmt 148 316 terms grant f 92 M 268 89 pers. injury 127 S 1085 a 206 NY 720 error court 167 363 94 complaint 127 S 1002 160 779 obiter dictum 160 780 99burden lienor 128 S 25 163 761 83 M 558 payment valid f 163 767 1 1 2 malicious prosecution * 209 NY 584 1 1 7 duty notify s 127 S 607 166 709 131 specificatns. s 127 S 654 137 40 42 form denial 127 S 69'! 51 40E' reply necessary 154 141 83 M 126 not apply 154 463 motion 157 95 M official book 182 288 285 334 145 surety liable s 127S . 572 146 774 147 discretion 8 127 S 623 163 44 150 no recovery s 127S 972 74M 69 165 good cause s 127 S 109a 156 515 178 60 may recover 93 M 543 547 estoppel 176 846 167 appeal 127 S 1000 149 960 162 756 open default 157 897 sufiScnt, order 186 532 no power 186 533 191 inadmissible s 127S 233 r 205NY 50 2 1 1 pleadings s 128S 130 147 120 discovery 148 025 do 148 U2U 2l6notice proof s 128 S 45 150 137 220 liability s 128S 149 f 162 163 172 175 78 M d 91 M 121 370 753 785 525 823 31)3 250 223 interest 8 128S 124 106M 45b 229 disbarment s 128 S 163 a 203NY 613 162 503 not criminal 175 312 237 residence S128S 230 162 278 32 M IJl death time 180 192 244 taxation 5 128S 230 sl2SS 1123 r 202KY j4U 251 unlawful s 128 S 549 a 202 NY 618 indictment 148 32.1 162 tioi specific facts f 160 i4'i 258 open street sl2SS bWI r 204NY 4lM 18 M 714 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; £, followed; r, e, criticised ; 1, limited ; e, explained ; o, overruled ; i, Bameeue ; do, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, J^***^ diaienting opinion; p, parallel caie ; q.qiieiuoMa N. Y. Supreme Court Eeports — Appellate Division Vol. 143 casement 77 M 251 265 premature 112 84 partic. 9 58 s 128 S 144 271 bill bl28S 147 273 indemnity s 128 S 157 a 207 NY 644 ?ublic policy 174 249 277 jurisdiction s 128 S 119 a 202 NY 599 certiorari 167 58 282 discovery s 128 S 505 168 673 81 M 363 286 presumptn. 164 593 152 234 80 147 authority 184 732 344 merger B 128 S 297 a 207 NY 425 356 motion 3 128 S 3 202 NY s 206 NY attorney's ' 207 NY 533 565 717 lien 667 s 128 S 146 148 155 77 M surrogate 155 presume 103M for court 225NY 293crt's sanctn s 128S 74 t 99M 320 297 foreclosure 382 insurance s 128 S 553 r 207 NY 162 386 bill partic. s 128S 565 188 518 389 abutters 8 128 S 569 73 M 652 cot taxable 73 M 647 assessment .1 202 NY f 213 NY 153 , avoid tax f 160 522 distinction s 128S 482 147 5U8 527 liability 128 S 399 534 corroboratn s 128 S 257 £ 84 M 357 537 identiflcatn. 396 97 550 12 725 235 120 402 authority s 128 S n 207 NY enforcing 172 441 283 607 425 891 938 441 302 award S128S a 209 NY appealable f 152 appeal f 154 157 210 NY confirmation 210 NY 440 210 NY 442 305 trust fund s 128 S 751 s 128 S 1135 a 206 NY 722 s 173 592 defect party 185 716 501 438 235 3 1 1 usurv s 128 S f 150 167 173 592 593 173 597 judgment 1 154 890 32 1 mandamus s 128S 115 85 s 128 S 172 161 685 424 tort 128 S 150 mental anguish 90 M 483 dissection 220 NY 258 428 alimony 6 128 S 259 a 208 NY 97 remedial 165 230 amendment 169 599 judgment final 172 825 437 take notice 128 S 149 luthority 149 451 866 471 pleading s 128 S 632 93 M 5 479 lease valid ■i 127 S 1038 76 M control do 162 not liable do 152 560 927 489 s 127 S f 167 927 984 914 . 204NY 666 492bcnefit state 127 H 979 ■3 30(3 persnl. contract 327 assessment 6 128 S 106 a 202 NY 550 335transfer tax s 128 S 48 a 202 NY 556 338 right action p 12SS 226 98 M 617 499 no presmtn 191 191' 853 sl28 S 157. • 839surrog. 6 128 S 153 7IOcontrib. neg. s 128S do 186 285 76 7(2 pleading 128 S e 73 M uiandamus 412 249 620 7l7reserve pwr. s 128 S 363 109 316 redress 96M 28 use of streets 96 M 61 62 remove buildng. 225NY 438 722 authority s 128S 038 75M 509 f 92 M 7281iq. tax law s 128 S 646 a 202 NY 574 750 vote of town sl28S 75M assumption 151 f 167 547 187 313 944 756 taxation •i 128 S 361 s 128 S 1140 a 203 NY 312 769 report s 128 S s 128 S a 202 NY mandamus do 145 fix rates 95M 384 1139 547 658 785 contract t 128 S 306 80 M 168 no authority f lOOM 467 obligation 185 569 lOJ lo:; pwr. 626 324 842 no delivery s 128 S 425 f 158 790 847 submission s 128 S 833 a 206 NY 712 852 insurance s 128 S 822 d 214 NY 564 145 678 conditions 148 72 862 petition s 128 S 755 a 205 NY 59 866 estoppel B 128 S 906 a 208 NY 215 92 M 461 do 92 M 464 unnecessary 94 M 21 871 refunded s 128 S 20f 218 NY 425 f 81 M 520 894 lien chattel f 172 783 82 M 61( condtnl, sale 179 643 rescission 179 644 901 payment case 3 S127S 1140 a 202 NY 608 902 per. injury case 2 a 210 NY 534 905 assessment case 1 E 127 S r 200 NY dl50 case 12 3 128 S 203 NY 132 franchise tax m 203 NY 231 six per cent e 157 745 proper rule £157 allowance 157 sinking fund 157 756 755 906 injunction case 6 s 127S 1135 149 140 1127 522 COS 907 accounting case 2 E 127 S 1146 a 206 NY 416 mechanic's lien case 3 B 127 S a 205 NY case 4 sl27S a 205 NY not partner 157 63(i case 8 B 127 S 1118 a 205 NY 552 908 motion case 6 s 128 S 1112 * 202 NY 582 913 counterclm. case 7 s 127 S 1128 s 144 355 foreclosure 203NY 556 law remedy 153 309 915 assessment case 1 sl27S a 202 NY no right 160 case 2 S127S a 202 NY contract case 12 m 206 NY 927 motion case 1 S128S services * 202 NY case 2 8 128 S * 202 NY indemnity case 3 sl28S r 208 NY 1113 1146 583 1130 427 928 certiorari case 1 s 128 S a 203NY case 2 sl28S a 207 NY case 13 B 128 S 114.Sr 206 NY 1140 552 1129 761 separation case 15 s 128 S a 206 NY case 16 s 128 S r 206 NY contract 165 s 176 1137 620 778 11.38 621 9 1 7 dismissal case 2 sl28S 1138 a 203NY 632 918 death drags case 1 E 127 S r 205 NY contract case 2 ■ 127 S a 207 NY case 10 s 127 S a 207 NY 111! 1129 746 111 725 9(9 mandamus case 1 sum. pro. 113(' 48'. 14: 939 S127S r 203 NY insurance case 3 s 127 S a 201 NY contract case 6 B 127 S a 207 NY case 8 B 127 S a 206 NY 1134 493 112 597 1148 467 1146 710 1146 726 1115 747 1125 423 290 465 929 award case 2 3 128S 1134 a 203NY 558 case 5 assessment s 128 S 1139 a 202 NY 609 932 certiorari case 8 s 128 S a 203 NY injunction case 11 s 128 S a 206 NY construction case 14 s 128 S 1146 d 156 131 defect notice d 156 132 1140 615 1143 587 934 retaxation case 14 S128S r 202 NY partition case 17 a 205 NY 1128 549 533 935 release case 2 sl2S S 118 a202NY 188 assessment case 4 s 128S a 203NY case 8 B 128 S s 202 NY a 203NY 1141 62!> 1125 540 629 constitutional 939 per. injury case 2 s 129S 2.30 a 204NY 648 920 goods sold case 7 3 127 S 1110 94 ( robbery case 2 E 127 S a 208 NY case 13 sl27S 1114 515 a 201 NY 591la20.SNY 643 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; •, dismissed; n, note criMiiscn; I, limited: e. explained ; o, overruled: ■.•UMCcse; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case : q. questionctt Vols. 143, 144 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division 946 dismissal case 4 s 127S 1138 a 203NY 563 947 appeal case 2 s 128 S 1124 * 202 NT 619 foreclosure case 8 s 128S 1147 a 205NY 563 a 206 NT 718 948sp. prfmnce case 2 5 128 S 1147 r 207 NT 670 case 6 r 207 NT 670 949 motioa case 8 s 128S 1120 s 202 NT 566 a 206 NT 711 951 report case 10 s 128S 1127 a 204NY 610 952 judgment case 1 8 128 S 1148 motion * 202 NT 582 case 2 s 128 S 1149 do 143 961 et off r 207 NY 346 955 motion case 1 a 206 NT 727 case 2 E 128 S 1148 s 202 NT 537 injunction a 206 NY 727 case 3 E 128 S 1137 a 206 NY 713 divert waters case 5 s 128 S 1144 s 202 NT 584 case 9 a 206 NT 715 956 book making case 8 s 128S 1138 r ?04NY 261 case 5 a 129 S 1130 * 206 NY 655 conclusion case 2 6 128 S 1119 a 207 NY 213 957 bill boards easel sl28S 1129 s 145 907 case 3 s 128 S 1145 personal injury a 207 NY 707 case 4 sl28S 1112 n 205 NY 572 reversal case 8 S128S 1118 f 145 907 death neglig. case 9 f 128 S 1134 151 244 jSSpeTE. injury case 6 s 128 S 1122 . 202 NT 623 ejectment case 5 3 128S 1145 I 205 NY 536 )59 report :ase 1 i 128 S 1147 > 207 NY 715 .■ase 3 i 128 S 1150 i 207 NY 720 960 reason rule case 1 i 128S 1118 • 204NY 623 175 214 case 2 i 128 S 1122 145 91 '■ase 10 < 128 S 1121 personal injury ■ 207 NY 641 )6 1 damages ;iise 5 i 128 S 1119 .■ 207 NY 311 ■asement ■ase 9 i 128 S 1128 . 208 NY 40 97 1 restitution "ase 1 < 128S Ilia : 205 NY 536 ;>ossession ■ase 2 < 127 S 1112 lamages lase 4 , 127 S 1115 1 207 NT 460 a 207NY 670 :ase 5 s 127 S 1120 . 204NY 658 QCgligence -".ise 7 , 127 S 1123 . 151 777 ervices •ase 9 . 127 S 1129 J 206 NY 725 372 motion v-ase .5 i 127 S 1180 ■1 202 NY 566 damages a 2! 6 NY 746 •ase 6 s 127 S 1138 1 203NY 558 ■ase 4 < 127 S 1131 I 207 NY 663 173 services ase 2 i 128 S 1151 1 207 NY 661 lamages :nse 3 ^ 127 S 1150 a 207 NT 666 974 decree case 1 5 128S IIST a 204NT 667 VOL- 144 I misconduct 3 128 S 352 152 89 90 \^-ritn testimony 150 377 151 593 176 65 1 9 validity s 128 S 1020 164 601 24 crim. intent s 128 S 837 a 212 NT 612 89 M 601 f 96 M 637 37 demurrable 8 128 S 830 150 401 jury trial 155 502 220 NT 395 complt, insuff. 174 407 53 not effective s 128S 809 lOOM 407 38 venue s 128 S 884 150 644 151 83 f 152 101 185 575 6 1 partition ■i 129 S 1137 1 202 NT 614 good defense 154 517 oSchange venue ■! 128S 739 1 144 67 150 664 f 165 970 185 575 78 demurrer s 128S 936 939 f 144 82 regulation 97 M 483 91 jurisdiction 6 128 S 933 153 351 t 161 833 161 835 demurrer 153 253 f 170 323 discretion 173 539 95 must plead defense S128S 902 T5M 57 inadmissible 156 347 76 M 499 lax paid at time 76 M 499 justified f 159 820 accountable t 160 837 record defeasce 1 88 M 288 I07invld. notice s 129 S 1112 146 120 agreements 158 545 f 86 M 290 la"\v practice f 170 825 174 699 700 f 90 M 24 legal advice 180 497 I 13 revocation s 128S 1009 lOlM 402 131 lease s 128 S 898 f 153 892 do 171 189 s 216 NT 627 93 M 87 new trial 179 822 138 loans s 128S 1017 147 797 piesumption r 205NY 171 143 motion s 128S 840 E 146 92a nullity f 92 M 353 no power lOOM 593 service papers lOOM 593 149 waiver s 128 S 798 146 8 153 bill partio. s 128 S 965 7 8 M 202 106M 167 155 right exam, s 128S 751 147 120 discovery 157 040 156 knowledge s 128 S 882 e 92 M 69 1 58 survival s 128 S 807 f 168 33 £ 96 M 261 1 6 1 pure trust s 128 S 803 f 174 34 174 35 1 64 pleadings s 128 S 79] 157 466 95 M 335 demurrer 167 665 i 68 practice < 128 S 782 168 493 78 M 34 170 reliance E 128 S 951 154 805 evidence 158 812 180 services s 129 S 1146 I 203 NT 499 separate trial 149 21 162 462 171 115 01 M 235 f 92 M 715 discretion 157 291 183 107 182 burd. deft. s 128 S 948 72 M 16 f 75M 390 not extend 158 163 account stated 146 726 dismissal 88 M 142 187 complaint s 128 S 1064 s 157 378 196 mandamus s 129S 280 990 a 202 NY 615 illegal 81 M 285 207 new trial E 129 S 280 r 207 NY 689 213 pers. injury s 128 S 974 r 206 522 221 not apply s 129S 35 lOlM 377 232 court's pwr s 129 S 54 £ 166 243 178 712 239 injunction s 128 S 1079 158 945 statutory £ 160 371 244 jurisdiction s 129 S 129 d 162 646 249 leave of court. s 128 S 992 150 126 169 576 notice necessary 154 226 discretion do 156 672 175 940 252 mandamus E 128 S 371 a 203 NY 554 255 awards s 128 S 724 s 128 S 1071 73 M 233 eminent domain r 203 NY 241 259 holograph s 129 S 5 84 M 8 267 collision s 128S 107-t 147 647 27 1 vacate ordrs •i 128 S 1003 150 709 exam. Sd person f 80 M 391 dictum misled 157 614 error court a 157 G15 power court 158 476, e 477 274 validity s 128 S 1024 f 165 11 liability 175 814 178 956 282 procedure s 129S 247 148 , 326 157 341 must plead do 150 601 motion f 156 904 correction f 156 905 grand larceny * 210 NY 585 resentence 176 320 287 default a 130 S 1109 78 M 260 2961ien attaches s 128 S 977 72 M 547 prematurity 149 682 SOOpublic policy B 129 S 14 154 376 not final 154 379 express waive 79 M . 47 79 M 47 recovery 79 M 478 cond. sale 79 M 503 f 91 M 258 protect poor 79 M 504 statute 79 M 474 not waived 82 M ma excess 82 M 615 ,"'05 contract s 128 S 1027 93 M 128 308 mandamus s 128 S 1082 s 128 S 1139 m 203 NY 1 statute 185 463 318 constructn. s 128 S 1028 f 164 167 official power 105M 90 326surety bond, s 128 S 1007 207 NY 672 343 judgment s 129S 45 1133 £144 .. 903 pers. injuries a 205NY 57? physical cause 151 400 negligence - 214 NY 15,3 cs52 responsiblp E 128 S 1012 8 M 396 355 rule equity s 128 S 1129 160 47 361 assessment s 129 S 273 a 203NY 555 taxation 155 610 372 attachment s 129 S 577 a 203NY 61 1 172 410 £ 92 M 440 35 408 contract » 208 NY 614 41 1 have order s 129 S 240 160 18 413 deposits a 129S 267 a 205NY 308 B 129 S 241 a 208 NY 514 420 recovery B 129 S 408 78 M 53 commissions f 83 M 441 428 iibel B 129 S 448 153 745 430 complaint 637 634 B 129 S 76 M allegation 165 76 M non negotiable q 153 553 d 161 829 jurisdiction f 168 on appeal 185 560 388 trade name B 129 S 310 155 57(1 injunction 84 M 483 397 bond 9 129S a 205 NY 291 577 409 635 440 constructn. B 129 S 421 a 205 NT 609 447 award s 129 S 1147 203NT 610 458 appeals 129 S 629 s 129 S 1143 202 NT 430 466lgl- services E 129 S 634 a 207 NY 643 defense 92 M 725 470 nuisance s 128 S 190 163 ^ 677 distinction 166 83 476sp. prfmnce 80 M IM s 167 623 480 receiver s 129S ■ .546, 5">1 • 204NY O-IS I'carsay evidnce 74M 5M 488 penally 02DS 205, .TO a 2n4NY 6^1« 224NY ■ 147 modified 180 770 50 1 inadmissible s 129 S 22* do 170 789 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; i 0. ariticiied ; 1, liihited ; e, explained ; o, overruled ; •, lame case ; do, , reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n. noi<-. dissenting opinion; p, paralleil case; .). ipk-sm.hi'J N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division Vol, 144 516 complaint 431 634 s 129 S 76 M allegation 153 165 171 76 M legal conclusion 79 M 619 non negotiable 554 negligence 686 409 554 635 553 829 393 587 460 807 290 525 order B 129 S 819 s 129 S 1138 accountable 154 165 negligence 158 2 cause action 160 628 175 437 q 153 d 161 defective 82 M 521 wife's necessaries s 129 S a 203 NT recovery 146 hold liable 157 105M 35 3 129 S ■ fl50 83 M 717 898 64 558 3 129 S 91 M 859 677 569 reversal s 129 S 761 172 143 574 pleadings s 129 S 603 156 388 ao mandamus 218 NT 119 576 interest 1 129S 779 a 204NY 2T2 compensation L50 218 St. openings d 210 NT 455 easements 222NT 372 583 denials s 129 S 764 f 165 120 144 148 166 173 91 M property 161 219 NT appeal 558 559 212 007 587 discovery iii s 12&S 521 522 O t t t t 4 A can 132 16 i 162 74M 81 M 362 _ _ __ 475 examination KSB 96 M 8] ^^ 184 949 914 014 589 discovery s 129 S 522 SI M 36] breach promise 177 384, 885 1^/""''°° f 76 M 2.43 88 M order a 203NY trust f 145 do 145 wj.^ .TioQ c 155 641 d 644 %}-lf,° assignable 610 258 88 M 414 motion amend 7411 207 judgmt. pleadgs £ 171 294 77 M 474 70 M 546 95 M 334 98 M 321 enter order f 171 295 79 M 82 issue of law 665 261 167 172 79 M alienable 155 t 169 208 NY reversal f 171 future vesting 156 105 vest possession 208 NY 501 share fortune do 209 NT 594 authorized f 159. fact issues f 83 M distinction 84 M effectual f 165 to class f 168 . not assignable 640 811 500 294 823 629 329 671 right of action 96 M 138 642 license s 129 S 745 s 129 S 1147 144 648 modification 144 650 65 1 presumptn. s 129S 606 177 754 )53 liability ^ 129 S 681 do 170 210 n M 150 655 jurisdiction B 129 S 713 154 595 664 liability 3 129 S 666 160 606 duty signed d 172 602 677 compliance ■3 129 S 602 E 85 M 54 678 negligence 129S 232 204NY 424 a 204NY sl45 delegated 166 20 93D 861 727 error court s 129 S 705 156 445 probable cause 174 799 177 695 86 M 18 lawful 177 697, 698 dismissal 180 850 732 no claim s 129 S 828 78 M 685 no authority f 99M 401 164S 12 737 probate will 5 129S 590 r 204NY 448 746 objection 825 privity s 129 S 626 149 801 vendor's lien a 207 NT 407 832 dismissal 3 129S 425 204NY 662 jurisdiction 155 590 837 accounting s 129S 594 r 205NY 2T1 843sp. perfrmce 416 558 motion case 10 s 128 S r 207 NT s 162 case 15 s 129 S r 207 NT s 129 S a 205 NT contract s 157 101 228 536^practice^^^ 585p,^,e. to stay ggo damages H8 625 dower s 129 S I 205 NT f 144 dl49 SIM SIM 684 clamages --; s 129 S 101 111 a 207 NT 668 061 589 _. __ 475 examination 96 M '81 592 s 129 S 168 1037 925 593 eq. acctng. S129S 466 149 149 484 -examination 96 M 58 60 1 demurrer s 129 S 556 a 203NY 560 61 (habeas corp. ■! 129 S 646 E 144 628 - 202 NT 616 examine procdgF 1.54 1.50 due process 94 M 505 by appeal f 176 607 1204NY 894 comity ■■ 160 68" 55] 757 appeal S129S • 204NY submission a 210 NY 687 residence s 129 S 1 f 171 457 f 93 M 560 690 for jury 5 120 S 585 157 314 694 prove negl. 129 S 604 3 150 840 702 authority =. 129 S 317 152 754 equitable lien f 159 827 intent f 86 M 147 assignments 173 30 public right 180 642 noml. damages 186 462 710 .ioint feasor 761 contract E 129 S 791 r 206 NT 591 with costs s 91 M 607 right relief 237 US 540 s 129 S 149 Deglisence do 154 a 207 NT recovery 157 170 75] R54 aside 572 386 805 enforcemt s 129 S 720 173 266 714 set verdict s 129 S 146 assume risk 628 removal do 150 189 case 2 unfoTseen 3 129 S 255 154 189 a 202 NT 610 direct result do l.';4 189 o j-^<' '^ 634 death negl. euarding wires 216 NT -129S 378 182 708 „,^ , 812 order 721 pwr. taxatn s 129S 406 s 12flS 834 a 203NY 022 014 539 847 contract s 129 S 461 a 207 NT 644 851 jurisdiction Sl29 S 435 79 M 187 854 compromise s 129 S 873 73 M 299 enforcement f 86 M 410 113^ 65! 14 1131 241 897 partition case 3 s 129 S 11 I ro 206 NY 728 pi-omissory noti- case 6 s 129 S a 207 NT mandamus case 9 B 129 S r 207 NT case 11 211 NT warranty case 12 * 211 NT 111'; 70i ii3e 22i 530 53; 772 judgment 723 943 745 745 192 532 s 129 S f 144 a 207 NT f 207 NT land under water 89 M adjoining 183 780 not apply s 129S 751 lOOM 159 784 modificatn. s 129S 181 740 144 650 easement 144 do 144 795 costs s 129 S 161 797 s 129 S f 169 860 estoppel S129S t 160 74M amendment 150 863 estoppel sl29S 81 M 872 waiver s 129 S f 171 s 182 874 carelessness 5 129S 158 for court f 164 644 04 680 622 598 916 803jnt. tenancy B 129 S 600 79 M presumption 85 M 294 f to wife 95 M 922 211 608 e98cancel judgt case 6 B 129 S 1125 a 203 NT 25!' 899 partition case 20 s 129 S 1137 a 202 NT C14 900 accountinjr case 4 s 129 S 114- a 207 NY 74- 902 report case 3 S128S 1121 a 204NY Oa" 210 29 103 784 418 415 884 injunction E 129 s m 207 NY 888 order case 3 sl28S do 148 384 671 7K3 912 893 award case 7 s 128 S 1147 r 207 NY 203 case 10 B 128 S 1150 a 204NY 611 894habeas corp. case 5 s 128 S 426 a 202 NY 608 a 206 NY 466 912 sale realty case 2 s 128 S 1148 203 NY 522 914 death negl. case 2 s 128S 1147 a 205NY 565 915 damages case 11 sl29S s 203NY deceit a 207 NY 1131 546 701 920 not liable case 1 104M 248 927 sp perfmnce * 204NY 585 928 contract case 5 s 159 '■ case 10 B 129 S a 207 NY 1132 709 903 pers. inj. case 7 5 129S 5;; a 205 NY 57.^ injunction case 8 s 128 S 112! a 207 NY 04] 904 costs case 9 E 129 S m 208 NY m 216 NY l]3f 131 682 929 dismissal case 7 91 M 133 931 royalties case 11 s 129 S 1111 a 207 NY 276 subrogation case 12 s 129 S 1123 a 209 NY 603 932 irtjury sen-t case 1 94 M caes 8 sl29S r 205NY case 13 c 129 S a 208 NY case 14 B 129 S a 208 NY 905 dismissal case 2 s 129 S a 203NY injunction case 10 B 128 S s 203NY a 207 NY illegal 174 114] 031 114! 54i 77! 457 112G 379 1131 539 1124 539 895 mandamus .^ase 14 s 128 S 1121 79 r 202 NY 602 commissions case 20 s 128 S lllfi a 206 NY 48] 809 limitations s 129 S 519 209 896 ejectment case 1 128 S 1122 a 207 NY 717 mistake fact case 2 *-211 NY 533 1241 908mchnics. licr case 10 s 128 S 111.' a 207 NY 60r 909 services case 9 s 128 S 114.'^ a 206 NY 730 910 taxpyr suii case 1 sl28S a 205NY case 9 3 128 S sl44 934 misjoinder case 4 s 129S 1137 s 148 070 936 award case 9 s 129 S 1112 a 204 NY 625 938 report case 1 s]29S a 2q4NY ordinance case 7 a 204NY 114( S-1 ]12f 930 91 I appeal case 7 s 128S 112; • 205 NY 547 1150 663 6S3 939 mandamus case 5 s 12ns 1128 a 203NY 553 foreclosure case 7 B 129 S 1135 s 203NY 545 a 207 NY 675 wrong doers ]51 702 written contract d 151 419 case 8 f 165 931 178 280 106M 55 labor unions not assignable 160 406 s 12as M34 a ^uaii i ao" '.'.•. '-•"^ o"" ^:^^^i_i:j: — ^^_^^j;^;:^^^^^:^:^:^^ ABBREVIATIONS: a. affirmed; d. distinguished; f. loUowed; r, reversed; m,. "od'^^* :*',,d'™'f!^„^ 'f' .?"*!] e. criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; 0, overruled; «, same case; do, dissentmg opinion; p, parallel case; q, questioned Vols. 144, 145 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division 252 166 injunction 166 254 174 251 252 89 M 512 94 1 determine claim case 2 s 129S 1132 B 205 NY 543 9438p. prfmnce case 8 B 129 S 730 a 207NY 745 183 532 V0L.I45r I wncer courses s 12u S 391 f 151 SOS nuisance m 208 NT 14 life insurnce s 129S 563 r 204NY 621 20 estoppel s ISO S 147 174 762 28 appeal s 130 S 350 a 207 NY 696 34 redemption 1 129 S 767 ' 205 NY 597 occupancy 90 M 437 4 1 damages i 129S 567 a 204NY 381 5 1 state release =1 12ns 368 73 M 415 T5M 18 liability 89 M 476 55 death neglig. 29S 243,1129 a 205 NY 568 ■lo cause TG M 434 7( death neglig. i 129S 262 ;i 20oNY 567 84 .lustlfied 5 129 S 304 f 83 M 89 90 M 675 eiection fl 86 M 214 form transfer 88 M 99 I04snit on b'lul ^ 129 S 104 1 207 NY 738 Iia.bility 166 108 surety bond 5 129S 142 1 205 NY 543 ; 1 7burden deft. 1 129 S 125 s 146 886 ^^ M 356 nenalty ' 207 NY 258 judicial notice 178 715 91 M 346 93 M 84 122 death negl s 129 S 107 I 205 NY 614 123 admissible s 129 S 122 f 172 36 129 declarations s 129 S 165 78 M 641 1 36 deft. neg. s129S 159 f 158 804 (38 insufficient s 129 S lOE f 166 744 error court f 181 919 e 91M 70 reversal 185 883 141 eq. construction s 129 S 92 77 M 386 1 45inadmissible ■i 129 S 18 76 M 499 95 M 319 defeat title t 161 88 defenses 171 509 148 judgment i 129 S 139 - 151 898 deed void t 96 M 42 152 disapproval s 129 S 13 174 794 1 56 privileges s 129 S 20 ir)9 43 idministration 159 45 312 NY 219 166 accounting i 129S 982 m 204NY 212 1 72 nuisance s12ns 1084 ? 149 470 1 77 foreclosure 5 129S 986 \ 203NY 559 I BSpower court e 129 S 913 146 4 195 error court i 129 S 1028 178 146 incompetent 179 841 '97 change ■enue i 129 S 913 !51 83 L55 399 199 power court s 129 S 1005 158 366 d 172 137 203 submission s 129 S 1042 tn 207 NY 650 207 obligation s 130 S 15 f 175 553 223 commission s 129S 961 965 s 129S 966 f 145 915 legal representn 5 150 573 150 574 liii'l descendnts s 208 NY 155 228 Sep. trial s 130 S 47 ■! 149 67& partners do 153 870 24 1 reversal s 130 S 29 164 304- 244 consent 186 462 25 1 extrinsic ev. B 130 S 31 t 153 73 256 not barred s 130 S 27 t 217 NY 245 93 M 226 limitation 177 651 259 mandamus a203NY 613 f 84 M 626 public nuisance 154 409 do 157 572 f 163 691 approval 154 411 authority f 84 M 625 84 M 627 encroachments f 95 M 396 lOOM 573, 574 injunction 174 434 264 threats s 129 S 974 156 760 exceptions t 165 65 268 money jdgt s 129S 1035 74M 539 judgment . f 149 912 159 229 :ilimony 153 462 161 521 522 172 244 85 M 255 277 judgment creditor s ]30 S 84 170 749 280 misjoinder s 130 S 54 SI M 659 piirties 160 490 289 motion s 130 S 211 a 206 NY 630 coterminous 165 189 294 extra costs s 129 S 1070 s 162 179 83 M 581 318 reorganiztn s 128 S 1139 a 203 NY 299 167 296 297 f 169 437 development expenses 157 749 not repealed 167 294 reasonable rate do 171 634 342 order s ISO S a 203NY 4 584 353 enforcible s 129 S 951 do 150 594 contract a 207 NY 59 judgment f 154 93fi 361 invalid r 204NY SI) 377 appeal s 130 S 37 a 207 NY 681 39 1 damages s 129 S 1030 a 203NY 627 negligence f 157 195 limitation 88 M 36 95 M 159 95 M 588 liability 106M 500, 501 value baggage 106M 502 398 hold for val. s 129 S 977 81 M 201 91 M 225 conformance 91 M 225 defense 174 296 406 contract do 150 593 409 prom, note s 129 S 1078 a 207 NY 721 416 security s 129S 1088 f 72M 343 418 bill partic, i 145 421 422 security s 129 S 1076 172 425 no doubt 97 M 268 428 injunction s 129 S 1053 8 207 NY 724 assume risk f 158 783 436 duty court s 129S 1025 147 13 wages a, 207 NY 659 442 insufficient s 129 S 957 165 424 vacate attchmt, 179 62 448m. prosectn s 129 S 966 145 506 conspiracy 156 761 acquittal do 160 924 456 demurrer E 129 'S 993 i 153 902 85 M 174 complaint 173 394 178 540 SO M 3(K f 97M 150 enforcement [ 86 M 261 answered 173 396 47 1 exempt 73 M 559 legislative 147 409 civil service r 204NY 2531 correct error 147 409 483 coliclusive i 129 S 929 151 89 156 361 f 165 269 pleading 149 919 eight hour law s 158 457 recovery f 160 288 cond, precedent 89 M -220 495 inadequate s 129 S 944 f 168 923 5l3by the court s 180 S 458 f 83 M 644 89 M 251 traverse 181 407 522 evidence s 130 S 473 160 590 complaint d 87 M 175 prima facie ev. 314 NY 253 negligence f 167 509 do 167 515 527 mech's lien s 129 S 920 a 207 NY 81 530 prohibition s 130 S 553 82 M 631 532 due care do 149 42 negligence 75M 345 duty landlords 152 460 contrib. negl. f 83 M 649 652 535 realty 3 129 S 888 r 20'^ NY 190 to enjoin 157 55;, 537 set aside sl29 S 870 f 82 M 453 540 presumptn. s 129 3 941 f 163 338 charge realty 91 M 397 lOlM 184 547 negligence s 130 S 423 a 207 NY 696 560 presumptn. s 129 S 865 f 161 97 568 plead new matter s 129S 879 75M 643 implication 154 555 doing business 162 212 85 M 479 481 574 repudiation 78 M 373 contract £ 95 M 596 588 presumptns s 130 S 339 77 M 442 599 damages s 130 S 264 207 NY 736 606 demurrer s 130 S 402 206 NY 740 609 ejectment s 181 S 1143 f 87 M 110 6 1 5 not a party s 130 S 436 82 M 524 enforce claim i 166 630 621 decree s 130 S 303 a 204NY 613 623 default E 130 S 414 s 145 632 630 inapproprte 186 220 new election 186 221 645 enforcerat. 3 130 a 477 77 M 490 remedy 181 695 662civil service r 73 M 562 rorrect verdict f 147 422 mandamus i 204NY 626 do 147 409 do 147 410 light correct error 147 408 change rules 147 408 078 liability 8 130 S 439 d 214 NY 564 680 limitations ^ 130 S 488 f 164 277 692 presumptns s 130 S 354 7 M 442 request sufiicnt. 153 504 695 forgery 205 NY 533 plain statement 162 677 704 insurance 6 130 S 546 r 207 NY 315 tax 499 027 708transfer slSOS a 203NY exemption 77 M f 93 M 39; purpose corpDi d 210 NY — 63 223 724 insurance s 130 S 294 a 207 NY 482 734 deposit r204NY 200 784 will J 130 S 571 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed ; d, distinguished ; f, folio wed ; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; c. rriticised ; 1. limited; e, explained ; o, overruled; 8. same Case; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, questionea. N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division Vols. 145, 146 r 208 NY 536 power sale £ lOlM 198 812 cancellation ra 204NY 687 imperfect decision d 164 261 817 judgment case 12 f 148 806 828 no costs s 130 S 542 152 816 city court 164. 114 residence 185 373 S36 830 stay f 145 reversal 171 257 836 prob. cause s 130S 361 182 499 838 cancel lien s 130 S 427 a 204NY 684 849 compensatn S130S 545 s 203NY 605 administration f 165 443 letters testamentary 99 M 167 855 compensatn a 204NY 670 damag( 156 776 do 162 295 Inmtations 156 777 private easemts 173 37 219 KT 406 861 Iiab. corpus s 130 S 698 a 206 NT 632 unlawful 186 213 865 assessment a 203NY 564 869 accounting 172 847 137 253 449 a 205NY estoppel 151 validity f 15a f 169 charitable f 170 f 219 NT , sustain trust 1-217 NT 463 217 NT 464 877 construction a 205 NT 556 75M 444 judgment case 6 f 148 896 884 nuisance s 130S 602 99M 238 896 neKligence s 129 S 1134 r 208 NT 164 898 not taxable s 129 S 1121 145 674 899 pers. injury case 7 s 129 S 1115 a 206 NT 723 case 5 • 129 S 1113 damages a 207 NT 389 900 taxation case 4 r 205NY 74 B 129 S 1139 negligence case 5 r 205NY 226 seduction case 6 129 S 1139 r 207 NT 506 case 7 s 129 S 1142 a 207 NY 743 case 8 6 129 S 114] m 203NY 167 trust mortgage s 129 S 1140 901 pers. injury case 2 * 202NY 584 commitment case 6 s 129 S 111] a 206 NY 723 case 12 s 129 S 112r a 202NY 617 902 construe will s 129 S 1119 case 8 r 205NY 236 negligence case 9 B 129 S 1130 r 207 NY 342 903 damages case 1 s 129 S 1139 a 207 NY 642 97 M 355 case 2 189 S 1122 r 205NY 423 a 207 NY 700 personal injury case 6 s 129 S 1137 a 207 NY 709 904 jury trial case 13 a202NY 617 905 death damages case 2 B 129 S 1147 a 207 NY 702 case 9 s 129 S 1147 a 205 NY 553 906 pers. injury case 1 s 129 .q 1123 a 206 NY 725 case 4 a 209 NY 446 case 13 S129S 11.30 s 146 880 insurance case 15 6 129 R 1129 I 207 NY 350 907 life insur. case 8 s 129 S 1135 a 205 NY 565 908 undue infl. case 1 a 207 NY 713 case 6 a 207 NY 320 case 8 r 205NY 3fl a 207 NY 320 909 pers. injury case 13 a 208 NY 517 910 negligence a 210 NY 528 case 7 r 205NY 230 case 11 S129S 1113 s 146 886 913 case 2 s 130 S 34 f 146 933 915 contract a 207 NY 645 9 1 6 injunction case 6 a 20oNY 442 guaranty case 2 a 207 NY 671 917 accounting case 19 a 207 NY 649 surety bond aese 17 a 207 NY 664 918 probate case 5 a 205 NY 570 contract case 3 a 207 NY 06] case 4 a 207 NY 722 maintenance case 7 s 130 S 111] •203NY _ 54a death negligence case 10 a 203 NY 570 case 11 s 1.30 S 1108 a 203 NY 562 case 13 a 205NY 560 919 insurance case 5 a 205 NT 538 case 7 a 207 NY 660 case 10 B130S 1109 r 206 NY 84] contract sale 920 penalty case 1 a 204NY 672 case 13 94 M 457 925 test, trusts m 203 NY 380 trust valid s 203 NY 382 96 M 210 928construe ■will a 207 NY 71P 93 1 remittitur case 1 147 584 case 2 a 203NY 609 new trial 147 case 3 f 170 589 912 932 set aside case 7 a 203NY 6,13 936 award case 3 a 203NY 503 report case 6 a 203NY 631 personal injury case 5 r 207 NY 246 case 4 a 207 NY 733 937 fraud case 4 a 207 NY 705 938 award case 2 a 203NY 561 negligence case 5 r204NY 430 942 case 9 a 212 NY 552 943 pers. injury case 14 a 207 NY 706 case 12 a 207 NY 718 644 crimes r 207 NY 560 945 state hghwyj case S a 204NY 1 injunction 204NY 9 950 title bank books case 5 a 205 NY 562 case 2 r 206 NY 20 case 7 t 207 NY 719 95 1 damages rase 2 s 130 S 1118 5 203NY 544 a 207 NY 66: case 9 a 207 NY 735 VOL. 146 3 power court E 130 S 569 153 866 d 172 137 5 waiver s 130 S 563 95 M 226 I4sp. perfrmnce s 130 S 882 f 91 M 638 enforcement 91 M 635 1 8 exceptions s 130 S 581 f 161 651 23 judgment E 130 S 532 f 154 936 28 enforcement G 180 S 748 147 880 208 NY 530 .»ers. liability r 153 120 eubscriptiona a 207 NY 673 as defendants 182 ^ 379 pers. liabilitv 185 432 ;t7 contract B 130 S 642 152 400 45 assignment B 130 S 629 ' 202NY 580 accounting case 10 f 150 J22 do 150 922 claims 9.06 NY 59 66 motion E 130 S 55."; * 203NY 553 minor 180 378 construction 180 75 libel f 154 456 86 judgment s 130 S 621 f 151 942 motion 206 NY 729 will codicil r 2m NY nr, s 209 NY ion f150 fl.Sn eventual estatp 163 379 178 776 93 breach contract s 130 S 625 171 444 (02 nustifled s 130 R 373 155 512 '1 09 apneal s 130 S R1? a 207 NY 68? 1 17 address client s 130 S 682 162 R41 f 164 141 disclosure 93 M 405 (21 specific lien s 130 S 371 f 146 566 permissive 166 72 223NY 225 1 25 award s 203NY 606 a 204NY 626 agreements 158 543 f 86 M 290 ( 39pers. injury E 130 S 552 p 146 143 151 injunction 6 130 S 978 m 204NY 471 78 M 284 barge canal f 82 M 70 reservation iS2M. 77 extra allowance f 213 NY 164 judgment •313 NY 166 read act 104M ^ 186 improve river 104M 187 power state 104M 188 construction 186 386 104M 189 reimburse 106M 27 f 106M 28 no obligation 106il 34 181 not liable sl30 S 961 156 457 no recovery f 94 M 414 legally liable f 173 156 (9( necessitv s 130 S ini6 223NY 126 181 351 78 M 47P 81 M 33r reseravtion 156 222 f 90 M 406 202 averment s 130 S 932 f 96 M 475 209 liability E 130 R 9RR a 205NY 2ai 146 20R f 164 313 sustain loss 165 335 adopt methods 88 M 624 22.5 claim clear s 130 S 9.';i 153 576 insufficient s 177 420, 425 238contTib. resl s 130 S 887 76 M 609 152 768 for jury f 165 463 forgetfulness 170 233 222NY 442 250 judgment s 130 S 917 do 151 949 255 ultra vires s 130 S 935 74M 235 non-stock corpn i 74M 236 266 materw\lity s 130 S 967 8 205 NY 554 a 206 NY 669 155 712 76 M 583 law question 155 712 show material 155 712 f 98M: 557 lOOM 102 demurrer 98M 557 270 constructn. s 130 S 906 95 M 44 f 96 M 273 validity 99 II 192 278 divorce 130 S 925 a 205NY 355 dower f 163 349 286 transfer tax s 130 S 970 a 204NY 677 292 co-tenancy s 130 S 944 f 176 564 f 93M ■ 261 300 negligence s 130 S 688 80 M 497. 30 1 return stock s 130 S 778 154 433 304 assault E 130 S 690 305 no bar s 130 S 775 84 M 406 307 penalty s 130S 704 f 103M 291 3 1 4 services B 130 S 691 203NY 445 318 obligation s 130 S 616 162 153 319 foreclosure s 130 S 781 a 210 NY 537 s 147 904 f 151 558 163 920 341 negligence S1.30S 766 f157 193 distinction 90 M 110 348 transfer tax s 130 S 686 m 204NY 265 350 election E 131 S 364 a 203 NY 158 98 M 373 363 mandamus E 131 S 135 f 146 871 validity r 203NY 144 ABBREVIATIONS: a, aftimed; d, distinsuished ; f. {ollowed; r, reTcrsed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, Bote: c, criticised ; 1. limited ; e, explained ; o. overruled ; s, same case ; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, questioned Vol. 146 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division jurisdiction 157 587 37 1 mandamus a 131 S 140 r 203NY 549 372 taxation 8 131 S 49 a 204NY 648 net earnings 157 741 f 212 NT 479 proper rule f 157 747 license fee 157 753 388 instructions « 131 S 247 do 149 168 irrelevant do 149 162 400 contract ^ISIS 160 83 M 17 412 discovery s 131 S 262 f 93 M 133 424 decision s 131 S 475 f 146 953 162 251 enforcible 7oM 354 436 bankruptcy 3 131S 157 s 147 904 220 NY 169 440 legist power ,s 131 S 327 r 205 NY 301 s 2n5NY 305 certiorari 150 192 discretion 152 7PH subject revir -' 154 .11 lack powe . <1 354 111 159 815 456 replevin s 131 S 295 a 210 NY 588 must affirm f 161 403 for court f 163 596 f 96 M 197 464burden Corp. p 131 S 255 79 M 647 467 distinction s 131 S 271 159 515 bill particular^ 159 581 470 no replv s 131 S 334 76 M 207 485 admissible s 131S 639 186 _ 251 assoc. criminals 186 259 49 1 no iurisdctn s 131 S 693 t 87 M 278 497 bond s 131 S 792 a 203 NY 577 SOI negligence s 131 S 681 s 147 934 504 negligence s 131 S 658 d 154 327 507 relief s 131 S 727 78 M 559 5 1 7cu8tdy child 5 131 S 671 207 NY 446 legitimate 92 M 395 construction 177 127 520 court's pwr s 131 S 841 76M 34 \ralidity 78 M 85 j29 per. injuries - 131 S 129 I 205 NY 603 discredit witness 157 402 a 172 255 173 447 i33 cruelty , 131 S 260 ^ 148 233 alimony 184 952 341 co-servant . 131 S 286 1 211 NY 78 t 170 171 lability 164 492 563 permissive i 131 S 257 166 72 323NY 225 367 three years i 131 S 314 f 153 826 578credit princ. i 131 S 278 f 86 M 47 381 defense isury i 131 S 168 166 14 383 decree , 131 S 245 ,1 204NY 665 circumstances 105M 217 388 negligence ■i 131 S 273 159 920 t 165 927 rule practice £ 90 M 54 59 1 deposit < 131 S 311 a 205 NY 569 594 report ^ 131 S 633 « 148 922 204NY 677 compensation 224NY 216 '"•08 judgment case 12 1 131 S 357 f 152 933 5 1 2 interpleader! ■! 131 S 376 r 204NY 281 204NY 75M good faith 1 14U 2871 600 618 do business s 131 S 322 do 147 887 104M 598 ^11 NY 427 62 1 discovery 3 131 S 408 148 112 good faith 148 641 f 159 921 set aside 87 M 448 323 have order s 131 S 398 160 18 628 judgment s 131 S 386 f 156 944 contract d 168 344 d 88 M 507 d 88 M 508 a9 M 397 construction a 89 M 400 J30 lien lost J 131 S 388 n M 505 f 86 M 307 contract a 210 NY 627 insufiicient 162 60 i 178 918 requirements 180 834 333 review 5 131 S 567 166 222 172 268 not appealable 168 836 355 pub. policy s 131 S 460 -J7M 509 fraud intent 179 615 561 liability s 181 S 496 79 M 53 baggage rings 79 M 56 damages a 210 NY 573 383 counted ■i 131 S 455 ;06 NY 245 registration 153 520 586 sum money slSlS 594 a 208 NY 541 not nee. party 151 283 85 M 173 riistodian •165 418 lOlM 138 superintendent d 173 393 authority 96 M • 317 693 trust mtge. ? 131 S 489 1 4fi 702 a 208 NY 520 702 submission 8 131 S 495 a 208 NY 520 703 practice s 131 S 523 147 149 demurrable 156 60 709 appeal e 131 S 504 t 207 NY 189 *208 NY 51!) 720 negligence s 131 S 445 175 193 darkness 105M 309 724 error court s' 131 S 487 75M 637 allegations do 150 129 130 averment £ 159 643 burden proof f 85 M 634 dismissal 88 M 142 727 not neglig. s 131S 472 179 670 duty city 182 813 735 not amend s 131 S 451 215 NY 463 742 motion i 131 S 407 * 204NY 584 746 reargument j 131 S 454 i 149 909 lo 149 909 real party 85 M 173 749 decision 176 896 appeal case 1 s 131 S r 204 NY contract case 3 8 131 S T 207 NY 1101 61ii 607 719 427 915 contempt case 3 a 204NY 565 916 contract case 11 1107 B 131 S 1142 377 a 208 NY 90 ABBl!E\ lATIONS: a. affirmed; d, distinguished: t, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *. dismissed; n, note: c. ■riticMed; 1. limited: e. explained; o overruled; t. same case; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel caje: u. questions. N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — ^Appellate Division Vols. 146, 147 538 1130 913 918 discovery case 6 a 210 NT case 8 slSlS sl47 a204NY 919 mandamus case 7 a 20SNY 24 92 1 per. injuriei case 10 a 210 NT case 11 s 205 NT 923 crimes case 9 r 207 NT case 4 B 131 S a208NY a 205 NT 559 942 not taxable case 5 s 131 S a 206 NT f 90 M 947 libel case 1 176 case 2 r 210 NY 541 563 17 1130 563 924 title validity case 8 a 207 NT f lOOM foreclosure 183 case 10 r204NY 712 152 699 614 926 primary cause case 1 s 131 S 1119 154 190 burd. defendant 154 187 927 sum. pro, case 1 E 154 588 933 mandamus case 9 ' 203Ny 63S 934 replevin case 8 s 131 S 1121 s 150 90 938 false meas. case 15 a203NY 634 939 negligence case 6 a 209 NT case 12 8 131 S a 207 NT case 15 s 131 S r 205NY conclusive 78 M judgment 105M 353 940 intervention case 1 E 131 S a 207 NY covenants case 3 a 210 NT case 5 176 case 6 a 207 NY kidnapping case 7 a 210 NT injunction case e 131 S * 205 NT case 13 E 131 S a 148 stockliolders case 14 s 131 S 1129 1143 656 523 13 950 death negl. case 5 i 205 NT r 204NY negligence case 6 a 210 NT VOL. 147 8 assignment 569 619 113 s 131 S r 207 NT liability do 154 16 election a 131 S 173 do 173 80 M title 166 joinder do 173 95 1 damages 210 NT 113 contract case 2 B 131 S a 207 NT case 3 sl31S a 207 NT 233 US trespass case 7 a 209 NT case 9 s 131 S a 208 NY 627 171 631 811 813 136 455 814 1 1 1 order case 1 s 131 S 805 f 147 9ii9 serve process f 155 631 155 632 I ( 4 contract s 131 S 871 a 209 NT 604 1 1 8 discovery B131S 157 86 M 1130 740 1149 728 596 605 1120 517 21 St. surf r. r. s 131 S 686 205NY 368 negligence i 152 485 cause action 157 830 vice principal f 165 AD 890 733 556 31 forgery s 131 S a 205 NT no prejudice f 84 M 354 DO presumption t 84 M 355 prac. condemnd 220 NT 405 953 defense case 15 s 131 S 1113 a 211 NT 505 3 74 M 469 74 M 470 956 indemnity case 1 a 209 NT case 3 B l3l S a 208 NY case 5 a 208 NY case 7 r 210 NY murder case 8 * 209 NT 611 605 1108 553 598 79 606 1110 711 1140 330 170 39 title S131S do 159 700 212 44 resettlement -. 131 8 661 1 147 929 s 149 918 res judicata 8 164 84 trust term s 164 87 51 negligence s 131 S 643 s 158 291 t 165 931 special master 222NT 330 71.'! 940 102 121 fraud transfer s 131S 829 838 £147 dc 147 900 pledge m 210 NT 137 133 injuries s 131 S d 92 M 780 147 141 s 132 S f 167 297 917 145 no waiver s 132 S do 153 demurrable 156 powers 183 not reviewable do 183 584 :89 413 60 533 1121 710 598 427 759 559 1106 544 1132 55 55 discovery 957 trust funds yf S 683 case 1 If ifiq 1544 £ 182 897|f III 544 278180 717 case 6 m 204NY 63 loan money s 131 8 799 a 207 NT 336 77pers. injuries s 131 S 789 a 207 NT 739 87 summary review s 131 S 877 155 722 court's power 92 M 89 3 131 S s 217 NT s 218 NT 100 review s 131 S 155 judgment 160 new trial 185 pleading 186 594 750 659 95 755 718 898 150 mandamus s 132 S 148 169 428 1 6 1 reinstate s 132 S 80 150 342 171 deflc. judgt. s 132 S 87 f 76 M 243 80 M 172 1 88 negligence 5 132 S 143 s 148 933 195 carriers m 208 NT 312 205 authority s 132 S 31 r 214 NT 236 construction s 149 934 damages f 163 693 2 1 4double time s 131 S 1041 153 493 220 limit duty 5 132S 28 SO M 566 224 franchise s 131 S 1000 96 M 61 62 227 review s 131 S 1012 166 223 237 damages s 131 S 935 a 210 NY 599 242 for jury s 131 S 1033 151 162 DO defense do 151 788 negligence do 154 5 do 166 959 personal injur> a 208 NY 51o liability absolute do 214 NY 552 253 life insur- ance s 131 S 1087 209 NY 611 s 166 626 255 construe deed s 131 S 1129 m 210 NY 127 costs extra 83 M 577 267 addl. costs s 133S 1101 injunction 205NY 531 316 em. domain 8 131 S 918 a 205NY 409 339 damages s 131 S 932 s 160 357 349 collision s 131 S 738 sl58 374 356 limitations s 131 S 744 156 878 375 penalty bond 166 d 16 431 432 d 172 458 foreclosure s 131 S 909 a 211 NT 511 462 for jury s 131 S 709 76 M 605 evidence same do 153 440 464 eq. considerations s 131 S 741 151 546 466no jurisdictn s l3l S 882 163 121 468 authority s 131S 881 106M 208 480 contract s 131 S 839 a 210 NT 543 tender delivery f 163 188 163 189 483 for jury 578 insurance s 133 S 528 f 147 581 588 no power 8 182S 597 221NY 146 593 banking 8 133 S 62 r 204NY 313 96 M 312 96 M 632 doubtful questn f 176 488 624 new trial s 132 S 615 8 209 NT 513 sl49 922 8 131 S 148 appeal m 207 NT revocation f 87 M S132S r 208 NY estoppel 208 NY 170 26!) 274 lOOM 228, 230 491 adulteratn ■ ~ 798 1 393 contempt s 131 S a 208 NY 494 decree 132 S r 205 NY 132 S 153 on merits 160 9 528 228 585 396 con ' mpt s 132 S 908 a 204NY lOS 403 mandamus s 132 S - 205 NY annul list 185 4 I I gift ev s 132 S 203 r 207 NY 298 420 mandamus s 131 S 931 a 204NY 676 veteran act 84 M 189 436 violation s 132 S 747 a 206 NT 373 not enforced f 166 692 conviction 183 878 452 marriage s 131 S s 132 S a 206 NT f 220 NY 163 do 163 95 M 96 M 97 M 98 M 105M 631 evidence 8 182 S 548 160 58 new trial do 177 88 usage 181 181 748 932 750 475 582 591 502 not public use s 132 S 159 151 411 522sp. prfmnce. 8 132 S 153 a 210 NT 558 524 per. injuries - " 88 574 8 132 S a 205NY 529 deeds sl32S sl48 certificate £ 89 M execution 184 541 922 767 533 error coiirt s 132 S 600 ToM 637 sales from stock t 92 M 262 good cause do 183 71 537 liability 733 205 206 861 1132 653 111 87 87 416 168 110 531 281 verbal contract 8 132 S d 163 mandamus 163 620 229 23- 544 appeal 132 S 044 s 154 942 sale f 163 898 557 damages s 132 S 628 a 210 NY 567 a 210 NY 568 not liable 634 reargument 8 132 S 609 148 919 640 mandamus s 132 S 567 * 206 NY 691 642 new trial 8 132 S 801 £ 167 937 649 pers. injur's. s 132 S 539 r 208 NY 431 652 title deposit s 132 S 635 205 NY 544 666 judgment g 132 S 151 f 154 907 668CO. elk. fees s 132 S 588 r 207 NY 22 not recover 96 M 333 676 not assume risk 8 132 S 572 78 M 553 fact question 79 M 511 review e 158 869 distinction 102M 8 nee. constructn. 102M 9 679 inhabitants s 132S 639 183 670 685 negligence s 132 S 579 158 898 159 920 f 172 302 693 negligence s 132 S 641 8 148 929 for court 182 453 698 accounting 8 132 S 76 a 207 NY 742 corporate entity f 159 880 ABBREVIATIONS': a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f. followed: r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; c. criticised ; 1, limited : e, explained : o, overruled ; s, same case ; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; a, questioneil Vols. 147, 148 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports -Appellate Division 174 88 183 432 may ratify do 176 850 704 mandamus s 132 S 59 a 204NY 71 I new trial s 132 S a 208 NY 48 518 715 unlawful s 132S 37 185 424 no power 186 524 use knowledge 186 625 719 injunction s 132 S 220 d 76 M 349 737 may waive s 132 S 65 80 M 357 741 decree s 133 S 122 a 205 NY 599 eq. conversion f 87 M 50 specific gifts 95 M 72 vesting 186 380 753not violated s 133 S 48 a 212 NY 615 172 101 I 855corp dummy case 8 s 133 S 166 set aside f 167 107 430 767 on facts s 132 S 79 M 783 joinder s 132 S a 210 NY do 154 conversion r 210 NY 104 509 237 51 457 10 788convince witnesses sl31 S 156 790 s 132 S a 210 NY 796 title S132S a 208 NY 806terml. s 132S 177 995 149 181 534 92 C35 point 41 217 810 judgment s 133 S 165 f 154 988 815 estoppel s 133 S 153 liability a 210 NY 169 170 f 173 d 175 187 25 235 778 497 104 642 825 reconveynce a 204NY 667 835 contract governs 8 183 S 173 f 91 M 477 f 94 M 5 129 87 1 eounterclm s 138 S 95 a 212 NY 613 f 171 853 881 new trial s 133 S 25 r 211 NY 420 f 147 892 transact busin's do 161 794 78 M 183 892 s 133 S 33 f 211 NY 420 211 NY 573 895 condemnatn s 131 S 772 r 205NY 1 900 pledge s 181 S 838 a 210 NY 137 s 131 S 1133 a 203 NY 648 918 death negl. case 7 B 131 S a 208 NY case 9 e 131 S 1 207 NY case 8 a 208 NY case 10 e 131 S a 205 NY 1106 521 1146 737 616 1111 566 935 peis. injury case 8 B 132 S 1128 a 208 NY 546 937 appeal ease 2 B 182 S 1143 a 207 NY 694 612 1122 935 90 1 pers. case 2 r 205 NY 903 forgery case 5 a 205NY case 4 violations * 209 NY 503 275 517 908 judgment case 8 s 131 S 1108 a 208 NY 561 907 judgment case 4 s 131 S 1121 case 12 f 152 98 908 disorderly r 204NY 627 conversion s 149 792 no cause action lOlM 300 909 dissolution case 1 s 131 S 1144 a 207 NY 718 9(2 death negl. case 1 a 205NY 563 9 1 5 divorce case 1 s 131 S r 211 NY 1086 163 916 rent case 3 s 131 S sl48 case 4 6 131 S r 308 NY s 167 1104 900 1109 12(1 184 9 1 7 per. injuries case 2 6 331 S m 207 NY case 3 a 211 NY case 6 s 131 S ■I 205 NY realty case 7 s 131 S a 207 NY 1116 500 567 1141 570 1106 742 9 1 9 certificate case 2 a 208 NY case 7 sl31S sl48 case 9 sale contract r 210 NY 41 case 10 a 209 NY 586 case 11 e 131 S 1144 a 207 NY 739 920 negligence case 1 s 131 S 1151 r 208 NY 108 new discovd. ev, case 8 t82M case 9 reversal 89 M 921 sl31S sl47 204 970 928 926 res ipsa loq appeal case 2 s 131 S * 207 NY case 5 a 208 NY case 13 s 131 S r205NY 1107 567 612 1110 336 927 not exempt case 4 f 210 NY 224 928 further return case 2 a 210 NY insurance case 5 a 204NY trespass case 7 1 211 NY case 8 a 209 NY 593 608 579 603 929 mandamus case 8 s1.=!1 S 1114 a 204NY 675 further return a 204NY 608 resettlement 149 918 930eq. considns. 132 S 569 151 .'>46 178 923 934 constitu- tionality case 2 s- 132 S 905 do 147 606 case 5 personal injury a 209 NY 546 VOL 148 I intent controls s 132 S 1017 451 454 567 455 236 632 157 do 157 prom, note a 210 NY intention do 157 f, 220 NY title passes fl58 not recover 184 221 payment peril 184 774 not liable 184 776 8 submission s 132 S 130 a 210 NY 536 |4"on merits s 182 S 238 162 2 77 M 104 responsibility 7S M 396 21 appeal s 132 S 50 a 209 NY 583 26 inspect minutes a 205 NY 158 d 148 181 78 individually s 132 S 1033 t 159 755 r 210 NY 107 210 NY 111 iudivid capacity f 210 NY 109 86 liability s 132 S 1059 76 M 501' 502 89 libel s 132 S 1101 a 212 NY 344 94 132 S 1061 a 212 NY 573 693 110 covenants 6 183 S 18 a 208 NY 566 ( ( 6 notice purpose s 131 S 1021 f 148 120 151 399 3 1 bona iides s 131 S lOOR 157 909 proof fraud 162 485 34 kick horse a 131 S 1048 152 204 serve notice d 152 203 37 legal conclusions s 131 S 1083 166 f 166 estoppel 93 M damages do 223NY liability do 181 67 920 366 305 960 40 not recover s 131 S 1050 156 168 procuring cause 156 114 44 allegation E 132 S 1053 162 £ 91 M pleading f 166 conditions 168 496 579 209 579 49 false arrest s 132 S 1085 a 210 NY 529 54 permissive 132 S 1056 166 72 223NY 225 56 B 133 S 1133 212 NY 574 68 damages s 131 S 994 78 M 498 96 injunction s 132 S 1074 a 206 NY judgment fl56 misjoinder do 166 not liable ( 168 649 935 662 1 73 new trial s 132 S 1096 s 159 152 1 77 mandamus s 133 S 129 a 205 NY 148 inspection 181 868 185 certainly B 133 S 208 152 760 I93burd. piff. 83 M 105 real plaintiff 84 M 298 appeal a 210 NY 566 205 laches E 138 S 211 NY 153 larceny lOlM conviction 183 103 607 108 878 800 (21 order f 148 cdmpliance 159 71 reduce salary f 159 278 I24spec. named s 138 S 68 155 290 people defendt. 155 290 vacate judgment 159 70 l29order case 7 s 182 S 115 f 151 926 mandamus 170 125 217 NY 48 146 surety s 133 S d 76 M conclusive 165 limitation 88 M damages 88 M liability 183 118 366 401 582 583 554 150 presumpln. 8 132 S 1026 155 284 sp. performance 210 NY 156 1 55 extend time s 133 S 203 157 67."! f 169 612 161 boundary 132S 1092 lOlM 710 adv. possession lOlM 711 void champerty lOlM 711 no privity do 186 414 2 1 1 amendment s 148 218 practice 91 M 677 217 appeal lies s 133 S 46 78 M 370 appeal 80 M Sps 219 dismissal B 132 S 1044 79 M 616 consideration 84 M 402 222 law remedy 8 132 S 1021 168 56 182 239 225 mandam\is f 204NY 673 a 204NY 674 227 trusts B 132' S 1004 B 79 M 352 trust estate ra508NY 367 234 accounting s 182 S 1114 m 210 NY 631 error court f 169 700 238 orders a 132 S 1028 f 151 934 243 discovery 148 248 f 169 939 176 841 182 461 inspection 106M 444 251 new trial s 133 S 159 a 208 NY 627 258 penalty s 133 S 152 a 205 NY 593 police power f 161 140 obligation £ 161 144 vested rights 183 663 275 acct. stated 132S 126 179 698 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followea; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; c, criiici.^ed ; 1, limited ; e, explained ; o, overruled ; s, same case; do, dif>sl nting opinion; p, parallel case; q. queationed N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division Vol. 148 284personaI tax! 151 s~i3i a 1094 r 206 NY 1 298srTe. procesa s 132 S 1046 d 155 632 default * 210 NT 602 no jurisdiction f 164 112 2991)7 publioatn 8 132 S 344 £ 168 35 action in rem f 168 35 304 appeal s 138 S 168 * 210 NT 576 307 easements sl33S 33 r 209 NT 186 324 correction s 132 S 1025 £ 156 905 resentence 176 320 326 amnt. lien 6 133 S 23 a204NY 671 345 per. injury 8 132 S 885 a 210 NT 569 355 judgment E 132 S 871 1 153 937 363 over draft s 132 S 20 a 210 NT 584 368 per. injury s 132 S 850 a 210 NT 634 sl5T 500 primary cause s 132 S 154 for jury 154 liable 103M 378 construe S132S a 208 NY children 182 384 639 discovery 104 s 133 S 225 149 112 f 93 M 134 vacate order d 76 M 253 f 159 921 good faith 87 M 447 1039 190 186 384 will 842 633 362 503 transfer security 132S 829 148 513 5l2rem. motion s 132 S 835 m 205 NT 135 314 license tax s 132 S 789 a 206 NT 634 520 conspiracy 3 132 S 950 £ 168 807 525 vesting 186 380 title disputed 186 380 533part expense s 132 S 933 r 211 NT 279 539 'on merits s 132 S 857 77 M 104 546 contract s 133 S 60 r 210 NT 122 damages s 210 NT 126 564 legal rights s 182S 178 new action 178 641 bill partic. s 133 S 271 76 M 251 644 objections 87 M 643 658 admissible s 133 S i 160 contract a 210 NT damages f 94 M principle 103M 663eq. damages 984 746 571 s 183 S a 212 NT 384ripar. rights f ^S^^w^e duty 8 132 S 926 m 206 NT 319 s 149 AD 929 confirmation 99M 392 county charge s 132 S f 170 401 808 336 403 death neglig. s 132 S 954 a 208 NY 629 412 irregularity s 132 S 960 s 203 NY 605 422 establish S132S fl58 loss 895 421 452 enforcement s 132 S 971 81 M 333 reformation a 210 NT 225 473 commissns. s 132 S 821 a 210 NT 565 481 neglect s 132 S 995 151 612 s 132 S 169 560 407 easement 224NT 202 290 134 758 liability s 133 S 336 154 645 763 affidavit s 133S 289 f 181 864 765 not served s 133 S 320 92 M 449 767 waiver B 133 S 328 159 486 give notice 178 461 authority 180 445 221 586 810 293 68 584 county charge s 132 S 868 f 170 336 588 telegraph co s 133 S 288 r 210 NY 59 598 injunction "" ~ 372 554 614 8 133 S 206 NT f 167 678 legal conclusions 8 133 S 166 682 modified 8 132 S 990 162 722 688 lien invalid s 132S 892 105M 674 697 opinions s 132 S 859 159 358 176 930 place unsafe 223NT 56 7 1 3 negligence s 132 S 1012 s 149 953 725pre3ent dfns s 132 S 937 f 166 543 727 hearing s 132 S 758 166 541 123 solicit trade 186 524 use knowledge 186 525 850 liability s 133 S 84 M estoppel f 170 178 854 usury s 133 S a 207 NT 860 a 133 S a 210 NT 776 establish right B 133 S 176 error court 178 disclosure lOlM 245 203 445 864 discovery s 133 S 623 f 169 921 f 93 M 134 871 spc. Questns. 779 ejectment s 133 S 319 a 208 NY 626 extra costs 83 M 578 title fee f 86 M 522 148 S 842 781 pers. injury 1 208 NY 564 886Judgment incompetent d 210 NT 269 s 133 S 247 i 154 859 171 183 assume risk 517 447 753 291 a 207 NY 691 894sup. procdg. case 1 s 133 S lin 205 NY 647 895 contract case 20 r 210 NT 211 case 18 a 210 NT 34 5B5 264 601 545 602 179 290 890 s 133 S e 94 M dismissal 177 new trial do 180 not on merits 182 697 884 motion case 1 8 132 S 206 NY case 2 E 133 S a 208 NY 896 certiorari case 7 s 133 S a 204 NT case 4 f 94 M 98 M disorderly case 11 s 132 S a 205 NT contract case 12 s 132 S a 208 NT sl32S sl49 1059 586 46 56U I 133 S i 164 890 mandamus qqq negligence 786 obsolete case 1 case 1 8 138 S 207 r 210 NY 88 j 132 S 112 458 case 7 ,. ^.,.^ 8 132 S 176 release 791 no liability a 2O6 NT 589 s 155 case 3 commissions a 209 NY 608 s 133 S r 211 NT f 148 613 s 133 S r 211 NY 730 presumptve evidence 8 132 S 166 usury s 166 guaranty f 177 383 554 6 1 5 submission 8 133 S 298 £ 148 622 £ 148 623 insurance a 210 NY 570 622 insurance s 133 S 303 a 210 NY 571 623 discovery s 133 S 239 155 213 813 12 15 823 733 damages s 133 S 322 96 M 669 739 good title s 133 S 340 £ 160 313 744 mandamus ? 133 S 361 a 205 NT 590 validity 177 645 employees 177 177 794 mater of law s 133 S 162 assumption £ 173 805 review E 133 S 208 NT 80 M s 85 M money had s80M construction 80 M c80M 80 M accounting 80 M disqualified 85 M legal title 171 859 243 882 196 89 1 process case 18 a 210 NT _ mechanic's lien ease 16 a 210 NY 646 751 assessment s 133 S 348 a 207 NY 683 privilege 160 777 sp'l franchise 167 431 384 136 593 215 571 572 591 592 594 216 965 813 individually s 133 S 44 159 755 8 1 5 insurance s 209 NY 34 costs d 186 88 824 damages s 133 S 910 a 210 NT 529 injunction 171 672 583 537 1139 551 60 104 1141 69S case 3 a 208 NY insurance sl59 292 shares stock case 11 a 210 NY 539 908franchise tax case 1 s 132 S 1143 m 205 NY 578 case 11 a 206 NY probate case 7 a 210 NY injunction void 1124 46 lia: 012 897 negligence case 2 r 210 NY 252 898 corporation case 2 180 716 899 negi. deati case 7 s 132 S a 205 NY case 8 a 206 NT 1132 654 lU s 132 S d 153 71 s 165 estoppel B 155 contract case 9 a 209 NY. 60S 915 ^ms personal injury „^j.g ^ 149 case 7 „. 9.1(1 659 1138 266 562 .34 609 906 540 892 rent case 2 a 210 NT case 6 E 132 S 164 a 208 NY sl59 case 13 contract r 209 NY f 180 893 appeal case 1 & 2 a 210 NY contract case 6 r 211 NY warranty case 8 214 NY case 9 s 132 S a208 NY case 10 a 211 NT case 11 a 210 NT paving a 210 NT divorce case 13 B 132 S 1143 case 7 a 209 NT bond case 6 a 209 NT sl32S 9 149 foreclosure case 4 a 210 NT e 901 damages case 1 a 210 NT case 4 B 132 S a 208 NY case 9 a 210 NT case 10 r 211 NT 652 645 499 364 1145 209 753 case 8 174 83 M case 9 E 132 S r 208 NT license fee 157 balance due case 10 a 211 NT 555 case 11 218 NT 492 d 218 NT 493 91 I order case 7 B 132 S 1139 ♦ 204 NT 668 913 no review case 13 8 134 S 801 150 144 914 judgment case 6 a 210 NT case 7 do 148 ■^«:^ contract 620 a 214 NT case 12 a 210 NT recover money ■'1 case 13 a 210 NT 564 914 564 533 644 610 512 11 3S 931 535 65 675 1126 568 535 632 632 1130 568 210 NT ease 3 E 133 S a 207 NT damages case 7 a 210 NT ■ontract case 9 a 211 NT services case 11 a 208 NY case 12 B 133 S a 208 NY 903 decree 132 S a 206 NY 906 recover moneys case 6 a 210 NY case 10 a 210 NY 907tax privilege case 10 s 132 S 1142 a 206 NY O.Tl partition 817 681 543 533 636 1128 220 631 574 1116 567 9 1 6 easement case 2 a 208 NY injunction case 6 a 210 NY case 8 6 133 S a 208 NY 565 2 544 1145 563 917 assessment case 2 s 133 S a 206 NY taxation 155 revival case 7 r 208 NY 1115 739 610 475 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d. distinguished; f. followed; r, reversed; .".. ""'^'fi^'^; „*■, 'i'^"'"='l', "/j"?*? e.eritici8ed; l.limited; ^.explained; o, overruled: s.samecase; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case, q, questioned I^^fllj^' 149 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division 920 practice case 3 r 210 NT 162 92 1 proper party case 3 157 s 211 NT 464 358 1121 052 923 ■ S132S s 149 negligence case 12 r 210 NT 924 sl32S sl48 925 pers. injury case 4 s 132 S a 208 NY negligence case 5 r 209 NY s 209 NY contract case 10 a 210 NT 1132 929 1138 553 VOL. 149 5 constructive eviction s 133 S 155 70 M implication 104M 522 184 247 545 1 trusts s 133 S " M 582 61 pldgs. 519 603 334 545 927 case 11 s 133 S 1136 r 212 NT 117 928 extortion case 1 a 212 NT f 178 case 2 s 133 S a 205 NY conviction 152 613 719 1137 534 180 930 death dam. case 13 a 208 NY 576 931 judgment case 5 r 210 NT 96 case 8 ' f 148 case 6 a 206 NT 933 board claims case s 133 S a 204 NT 1 4judgt. » 133 S f 159 95 M special damage 165 391 20 discretion s 1.33 S 627 157 291 prior trial 1.57 292 162 462 91 M 235 separate issue f 92 M 715 finding 182 415 29 not evidence f 168 81 M f 87 M do 87 M not iinal 97 M (13 validity s 133 S t 159 t 163 167 168 85 M construct lOSM counterclaim 185 131 change venue do 164 43 libel 133 S s150 150 do 170 820 362 293 297 463 828 848 340 545 521 282 262 construed s 133 S do 169 95 M 99M good cause f 96 M 696 42 335 368 565 266 incidental 546 852 Ifin 17011 729 133 S 166 31 licensee s 133 S 176 35 bonds s 133 S a 208 NY 37deatli damage 533 360 572 548 529 4 9 478 934 pers. injury case 1 a 209 NT damages case 7 a 210 NT 507 608 935 forgery lien case 4 m 210 NT 257 case 8 E 133 S r 207 NT case 5 a 208 NT case 1 r 210 NY 1138 195 359 s 133 S a 208 NY negrligenee t 83 M 52 liberal construction s 133 S 95 M 55 s 133 S s 175 608 601 172 intervene 134 S s 207 NT «rder a 208 NY leave court 169 (31 ■ 134 S 151 1 151 1 169 98 M eoncluBiTe 1 168 704 680 513 576 1074 727 728 S66 159 465 141 atty's lien 3 134 S 801 * 206 NT 681 157 judgment a 134 S 696 * 206 NY 635 J59 liabilty e 134 S 736 162 397 169 damages 847 619 writ 910 s 134S 183 fSOproMt. » 134 S f 215 NT 350 184 CT. neglig. ( 134 S 782 214 NT 541 190 no power t 134 S t 150 e 154 159 damages I 206 NY r94 order » 134 S s 206 NT 691 195 111 815 33 693 634 f95 contract B 134 S 839 a 211 NT 534 waiver 104M 90 202 bankruptcy « 134 S 697 « 153 800 208 complaint ■ 134 S 649 f 168 484 sp. perform 178 611 2l2appeal right - ""' " 730 206 f 168 465 assessments 1 169 f 218 NT 98 M 99 M 566 240 159 42 226 violation s 134 S 931 r 206 NT 670 un constitutional lOlM 28 right property 105M 403 246 s 134 S a 212NY 1028 614 257 conformnee s 134 S 825 152 505 claims clear 153 576 judgmt. jury d 105M 353 clear evidence 356 702 949 105M 278 s 134 S f 175 280 reversal s 134 S 689 166 546 168 924 283 motion B 134 S 646 * 206 NT 628 f 163 920 '289 nee. party s 134 S 1018 170 874 298 stockholder s 134 S a 206 NT sl50 s 83 M judgment 95 M hv directors 174 262 635 7 911 342 335 306 counsel fees s 134 S 1081 s 151 545 court's power f 92 M 288 134 S 155 appeal lies 157 493 215 St. opening t 134. S 844 A 210 NT set-off 219 NT 455 408 22 1 amendment « 1343 655 176 841 223 authority f 165 361 conclusive 314 s 134 S 168 1041 924 369 misconduct 9 135 S 612 a 212 NT 610 151 593 391 sum. pro. s 134 S 1104 r 210 NT 270 92 M 316 e 173 895 403 perjury s 135 S a 206 NT 407 salary 8 135 S a 208 NY 49 661 85 550 power to reduce f 159 160 f 92 M f 219 NY 413 will m 208 NY domicile 156 185 £ 88 M f 94 M one's act 183 277 266 411 284 617 594 396 419 85 408 4l9information s 135 S 159 173 191 174 111 173 592 597 424fraud. grant E 135 S s 160 e 79 M 77 744 533 434 reversals s 135. S ! 167 235 439 accounting s 135 S 32 211 NY 527 445 duties atty s 135 S 438 176 65 453 change grade 135 S a 150 a 206 NY a 206 NY 132 453 658 660 317 damages s 134 S 1025 a 208 NY 555 f 162 350 714 957 32 1 order s 134 S 154 no condition 155 749 costs d 156 56 333 reoompnsed s 134 S 652 f 165 72 221NY 42 338 salaries s 134 S 759 163 486 358 exemption s 134S 1077 184 657 361 s 135 S a 210 NY 126 542 460 fees R 135 S 154 construction 220NY 487 23 519 475scop. employ s 135 S 22 153 798 476 recovery sl35S f 212 NY ROM damages SOM law action do 180 .52 356 31S 316 540 493owner check s 135 S £ 172 500 rape s 135 S a 206 NY for jury 154 weight ev. 183 121 159 491 693 48 5 1 4 new trial s 135 S 428 *■ 209 NY 531 distinction 83 M 592 527 eq. cntrolm. s 135 S 549 154 432 166 766 return stock 154 433 special term 156 493 title s 160 312 reformation 160 510 error court £ 164 179 530eq. entrolm. s 135 S 550 £ 164 116 532 jurisdiction s 135 S 504 155 596 541 jurisdiction s 135 S 274 s 135 S 694 151 566 habeas corpus a 206 NY 46 56 1 exceptions s 135 S 555 173 954 171 validity do 171 656 denial s 135S 183 668 notice s 135S 185 498 501 972 48 760 804 670 fire insur. s 136 S * 206 NY £ 161 do 161 not apply dl59 769 683 918 918 322 678 demurrer s 135 S 78 M complaint £ 165 strike out 169 766 273 43 784 563 by court s 135S 177 408 492 568 Stat, power s 135 S 77 M f 160 order appeal a 206 NY 677 62 680 372 573reBid. estate s 135 S 40) a 208 NY 153 577 stay exam s 135 S 435 80 M 395 580 motions s 135 S case 20 150 582 s 135 S 211 NY 500 927 900 578 595 sentence K 135 S 1049 78 M 673 habitual crimnl. m 208 NY 169 604 verdict s 135 S 773 98 M 51 612 liability 135 S 893 78 M any loss dl56 158 853 621 inheritance 849 657 135 S 155 adoption 155 £ 163 statutory f 160 658 732 410 653per. obligatn s 135 S 1070 159 855 constitutional 169 212 jurisdiction 681 presumptn. s 135 S SOM marriage 172 88 M 96 M burden proof 105M 118 723 456 249 305 166 689 demurrer s 134 S s 153 libel a 207 NT 691 liability sl35S 81 M accounting a 210 NY 670 745 714 672 643 s 172 765 appeal s 135 S a 210 NY 335 573 770 no power s 135 S 373 82 M 173 prohibit writ 177 379 220NY 493 783 employee s 135 S 309 174 76 77 789 residence s 135 S 334 162 278 82 M 191 790 court relief s 135 S 248 81 M 514 property rights 164 215 supersede ' 87 M 141 final decree 178 436 792 right S135S fSlM modify 210 512 704 demurrer « 135 S 825 155 739 recovery 155 740 represent suit 155 741 168 542 form action d 155 742 708 dictum misled s 135 S 740 e 157 614 examination f 80 M 391 709 issue void s 135 S 785 167 679 compliance 177 343, 715 stockholder s 135 S 785 m 207 NY 113 728 judgment s 135 S 80(1 f 156 ■ 944 746judl. notice s 135 S 718 87 M 92 M mandamus 185 268 84 487 750 liability 135 S 229 154 808 761 s 135 S 161 170 949 794 injunction s 135 S 311 s 78 M 3 798 no slander s 135 S 332 £ 160 874 80 1 mutuality s 135 S f 166 enforcible do 177 223NY purchasers 103M 245 442 150 353 805 trust deed 896 foreclosure case 6 E 134S r 208 NY a208NY case 11 s 134 S * 206 NY case 8 a 206 NY s 135 162 S 240 175 87 M lOOM f 168 540 248 895 8l3ev. sufficient s 135 S 477 f 164 3, 16 discharge 213 NY 96 M 393 620 840 review S135S ,158 147 842 divorce a 208 NY .600 no proceeding 95 M 234 845 disput^ s 135 g '323 95 M 251 848 pleading s 135S 221 181 ,741 656 awards a 208 NY 588 106M 452 859actual malice s 135 S 325 152 694 exemption 176 275 863 privileged s 185 S 365 165 825 868 appeal s 135 S 948 sl51 919 875 alienable sl35 S 1056 156 758 next of kin 173 803 885 s 135 S 1138 f 159 929 893 ejectment case 3 r 210 NY 198 210 NY 201 s 174 333 B34 94 M. 610 304 306 1180 684 688 894 franch. tax case 12 a 206 NY 206 NY 133S a 206 NY case 4 * 206 NY case 11 a 206 NY 895 costs case 4 8 134 S f 154 contract case 10 a 211 NY 689 1146 387 509 1140 203 610 1141 672 658 897 award case 3 a 210 NY 603 898 certiorari case 2 s 134 S 1142 a 205 NY 598 interest case 4 m 208 NY 84 personal injury case 7 a 210 NY 577 899 allegations case 6 B 134 S 1138 f 153 798 900 prohibition case 10 a 205 NY order case 5 a 206 NT 597 631 901 pleading s 152 S 589 902 decree ease 15 a 210 NY case 16 E 134 S HIT • 207 NY 685 rrelevant 156 208 case 18 * 214 NY 653 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; c, criticised ; 1, limited ; e, explained ; o, overruled ; s, same case ; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, questioned N. Y. Sapreme Court Reports— Appellate Division Vols. ISO, 151 903 allowance case 2 a 210 NT 596 rase 3 • 210 NY 613 contract case 15 a 210 NT 648 alimony case 16 a 210 NT 647 motion case 18 E 135 S 1107 a 208 NT 650 904 appeal case 5 c 135 S 1148 « 207 NT 690 905 intent 150 409 906 mandamus case 10 8 134 S 1143 a 205 NT 588 908 report case 2 a 206 NT 655 9 1 1 change venue case 3 * 206 NT 672 912 counsel fee f 151 549 914 sp. prfmnce case 3 6 135 S 1109 r 207 NY 286 9l6cond. precdt, sl35 S 406 s78M 38 78 M 39 917 appeal case 3 a 208 NY 922 attys. case 2 a 210 NT case 8 s 135 S a 207 NT larceny case 10 s 135 S 206 NY r 206 NY trust case 11 8 135 S a 208 NY 584 lien 595 1132 643 a 214 NT 671 case 8 a 211 NT 561 case 9 a 207 NY 762 cage 13 a 207 NY 769 trust case 14 a 211 NT 1 929 motion case 12 r 210 NT 467 brokerage case 13 s 135 S 1099 s 206 NT 674 case 10 1 208 NT 337 moneys case 13 a 210 NT 631 damages case 15 i 210 NT 634 personal injury case 17 :> 210 NY 604 930 larceny case 4 310 NY 582 contract case 8 s 135 S 1132 •208 NY 552 death negligence r 208 NY 582 manslaughter case 14 a 209 NY 541 case 9 a 210 NT 606 case 12 a 211 NT 364 97 M 463 931 const i-uctn, case 1 ■I 210 NY 536 loss trunk case 4 a 210 NT 581 case 5 s 135 S 1113 * 206- NT 728 death damages case 6 a 210 NY 579 VOL. 151 I notice order s 135 S 328 rs M 279 8 decree 6 135 S 172 r 206 NT 653 transfer tax £ 156 931 construction do 156 932 1131 60 55 1099 569 923 violation case 3 s 135 S 1133 a 206 NY 709 conclusive 163 310 219 NY 111 925eancel judgt. case 10 « 206 NT 686 926 motion 153 15 * 206 NY 688 927 waiver case 21 a 211 NY 9 928 order case 1 a 210 NY 579 case 2 a 210 NY 597 case 6 14 s 135 S f 173 213 950 17 appeal s 135 S 208 a 206 NT 741 22 s 135S 289 i 182 923 24 motion j 135 S 349 s 206 NY 673 vendee's lien f 158 495 foreclosure a 210 NT 594 28 bill partic s 135 s se f 170 910 78 M -378 30sale property s 135S 253 f 178 793 35 fraud s 135 S 113 s 165 567 not sufficient s 165 568 42sp. perfrmnoe s 135 S 930 162 637 50 valuation s 133 S 1134 s 135 S 234 f 160 7 65 prox. cause s 135 S 944 164 119 78 M 565 72 sp. prfmnce, s 135 S 813 a 210 NT 586 75 damages 5 136 S 375 a 210 NT 607 1G2 248 t 163 693 173 255 justified 170 357 77 divorce s 135 S 830 i 210 NY 602 81 order s 135 S 779 157 931 negligence 159 920 venue f 165 185 970 575 87 contract s 135 S 978 r 212 NY 145 99 burden deft. s 135 S 843 88 M 142 1 1 order B 135 S 960 a 206 NT 689 1 1 3injunction s 135 S 384 a 206 NT 110 I 16 forfeiture s 135 S 392 i 209 NY 566 personal injury a 211 NY 515 i 28 alteration s 135 S 206 81 M 165 1 3 1 assault s 135 S 355 d 154 195 free ticket 171 692 employee 102M 132 142 costs s 135 S 432 t 91 M 609 151 findings s 135 S 411 s 135 S 1107 r 206 NY 678 98 M 5, 6 1 59 for jury s 135 S 137 £ 165 755 166 'annuitant s 135 S 344 s 135 S 1098 s 213 NY 534 86 M 606 not suspend 177 505 distribution do 177 530 1 98 injunction s 135 S 303 r 211 NT 241 SIM 645 234 'aggrieved' s 135 S 143 153 584 240 new trial s 136 S 131 a 208 NY 611 contrib. negl. 185 198 ordinance 185 199 for jury do 185 202 245 mandamus s 135 S 747 a 210 NT 598 264 waiver s 135 S 735 s 162 926 do 92 M 194 do 92 M 223 274 construct bridge s 136 S 128 166 466 reasonable care 166 466 29 1 revocation s 136 S 115 s 135 S 869 161 207 297 mandamus s 136 S 377 a 210 NT 370 304 injunction 136 S 383 a 211 NT 301 309 mandamus s 136 S 865 r 209 NY 202 appeal 84 M 108 317 reversal s 135S 985 s 103M 277 332 death s 135 S 474 a 208 NY 621 345breach duty s 135 S 472 f 217 NT 280 351 liability B 135 S 509 79 M 29ti duty town 158 345 infancy excuso do 159 472 negligence 213 NT 400 353 conversion s 135 S 416 s 157 89 s 157 91 liable 177 380 355 written contract 179 655 36 1 title to bed 8 135 S 496 f 160 209 160 213 367 tax law B 135 S 981 a 208 NT 144 372 certificate evidence s 135 S 418 156 723 375 transaction s 135 S 939 a 208 NY 503 387 appeal S136S 730 392 award jugt s 135 S 1084 166 95 395ootic6 suffic s 135 S 1063 79 M 509 negligence r 210 NT 262 175 406 404 negligence s 135 S 1086 153 305 407 not apply s 135 S 954 94 M 391 413 justified s 136 S 88 159 820 authority £ 87 M 282 419 infant's interest s 135 S 1080 92 M 91 93 M 399 interest 220NY 538 ■■, -■■iesjj'?* 11 lOlM 173 426 judgment s 135 S 865 case 10 £ 151 922 44 1 when s 135 S 891 89 M 24 444 real estate 6 135 S 921 t 153 906 order t 154 897 costs r 208 NT 69 allowance 83 M 189 191 application e 83 M 190 456 injunction s 135 S 869 £ 170 165 217 NT 107 458 no power s 135S 919 180 274 465 equity s 135 S 990 162 460 5 1 6 reply good s 135 S 872 s 211 NT 5ii7 83 M 127 520 authority s 136 S 309 do 160 634 522 damages s 136 S 306 r 209 NY 440 77 M 344 527 irrevocable s 136 S 110 155 128 deposit r 208 NY 508 532prerequisite s 136 S 108 172 116 535 prior right s 136 S 105 £ 174 305 539 taxability 3 136 S 83 84 M 334 87 M 540 91 M 210 lOOM 248 when assessable 89 M 24 laws govern 91 M 212 98 M 106 deed trust 179 42 lOlM 389 54 1 order s 136 S 184 case 2 £ 151 927 mandamus £ 172 131 545 counsel fees s 136 S 249 T 206 NY 561 55 1 carriers s 136 S 355 r 210 NY 389 557 8 136 S 163 82 920 561 jurisdiction s 136 S 854 £ 158 946 172 444 relief 172 448 568 accounting s 136 S 96 a 208 NY 545 572 order s 136 S 360 s 136 S 1140 case 2 £ 151 922 costs m 208 NY 25 allowance 83 M 189 "or others" 83 M 190 578 pers. injury s 136 S 79 a208 NY 615 589 attorneys s 138 S 54S a 209 NY 354 606 banking s 136 S 466 a 206 NY 390 preference £ 161 430 161 431 85 M 596 613 good faith s 136 S 367 do 160 735 181 13 joint adventure do 160 736 error court 181 158 6 1 8 consideratn s 136 S 648 151 621 £ 151 622 £ 165 480 627 tort creditors s 136 S 354 156 728 f 99M 504 eq. claim 176 627 631 s 136 S 226 f 159 901 636 denial s 136S 192 183 48 637 money had s 136 S 969 a 208 NY 636 648 contract s 136 S 423 a 211 NY 456 655 statements s 136 S 200 98 M 250 659 mandatory s 136 S 532 £ 158 912 660 penalty s 136 S 219 a 208 NY 549 method sale ,176 163 ABBREVIATIONS : a, affirmed ; d, distinguished ; f , £o ilowed ; r, reversed ; m, modified ; *, dismissed ; n, not* c, criticised ; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, questioned Vol. 151 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division 663proper party intention s 136 S 223 84 M 289 672 receipt ev. s 136 S 489 95 M 597 695 motion s ISO S 193 s 207 NY 755 enforcement 156^ ■ 124 perform -work 220 NY 384 707 contingent s 136 S 218 f 316 NY 139 709 mandamiis s 136 S 191 f 159 490 711 judgment E 136 S 205 i 154 890 enforcement 81 M 369 714 implication s 136 S 193 f 163 488 7l7srve process B 130 S 216 d 80 M order f 168 privilege d 214 NY d 222NY 185 832 certiorari 136 S 1031 r 207 NY J 07 NY do 207 NY dismissal do 158 148 850 25 749 no appeal s 136 S 245 •208 NY 504 756 not void s 137 S 37 r 211 NY 228 80 M 250 770 decision s 136 S 316 for jury f 82M case 3 s 152 363 916 776 for jury s 136 S 1024 d 174 785 B 136 S f 166 884 972 790 corroboratn. S137S f 156 as principal 156 810 s 137 S s 214 NY 19 626 627 399 140 8 1 3 examinatn. s 136S 178 4S4 149 0(5 usury s 136 S J55 167 f 173 173 f 173 173 595 596 do 173 597 do 173 598 d 222NY 182 void assignment a 211 NY 507 i 167 234 security f 167 tender d 222NY 774 585 236 588 593 594 285 181 case 7 S135S a 206 NY 86 93 103 878 1137 513 743 1143 680 353 joint will 3 136 S 961 s 157 553 186 303 lack of ev, 186 455 will evidence 186 299 form decree do 157 556 866 acct. stated 3 137 S 616 U 87 M 237 conversion 215 NY 238 885 demurrer case 3 S136S sl51 a 206 NY appraisal case 5 s 135 S a 206 NY nominal value d 160 708 172 403 legisl. power' case 7 s 135 S 1148 156 783 886 negligence case 3 8 135 S 1120 r 208 NY 77 888 demurrer case 7 s 135 S a 206 NY 319 NY 155 legality 155 corporations case 9 s 135 S 1110 a 209 NY 263 accounting case 10 6 207 NY a 208 NY 894 cloud title r 208 NY 159 possession land case 1 a 210 NY 412 case 5 s 135 S 1141 r 208 NY 159 collateral attack case 9 s 135 S 1107 163 474 895 injunction . case 1 s 135 S a 210 NY f 172 contract case 9 s 135 S a 210 NY case 11 s 135 S a 210 NY 1059 110 274 216 218 674 626 889 certiorari case 8 s 135 S 1134 a 209 NY 523 890 practice case 1 s 76 M 3 a 206 NY 110 case 7 •206 NY 412 891 case 2 s 135 S 1110 a 211 NY 559 892 motion case 3 s 135 S s 206 NY a 208 NY case 7 3 135 S s 151 1130 674 613 1139 892 893 mandamus case 2 s 135 S 1111 a 209 NY 54' linnd 110& 679 905 damages s 135 S 1077 a 208 NY 610 906 relief s 135 S a 211 NY 311 NY 211NY 335 326 909 negligence case 5 s 135 S r 212 NY case" 11 s 135 S 151 1151 626 789 1141 61U 1122 587 897 injunction case 8 s 135 S 1137 a 210 NY 027 898 banking case 5 s 135 S 1107 s 135 S 1123 case 7 s 135 S 1128 a 308 NY 218 appeal case 5 * 207 NY case 9 s 135 S a 211 NY 753 1105 577 899savings bank case 2 s 135 S r 208 NY case 3 f 175 do 175 1127 474 475 900 grde. crssng case 5 f 172 789 case 8 s 135 S 1104 a 211 NY 553 validity case 11 a 211 NY case 12 s 135 S 1110 r 208 NY 309 90 1 appraisal case 10 s 135 S 1122 a 210 NY 609 902 stockholders case 2 s 135 S a 208 NY estoppel E 161 case 4 s 135 S 1112 a 211 NY 575 personal injury case 7 s 135 S a 209 NY case 13 s 136 S sl51 1124 628 48 1140 602 113S 174 904 death nesl s 135 S 818 r 208 NY 383 502 321 324 1102 440 1106 913 9l0tort partner case 7 s 135 S 1115 r 211 NY 30 foreclosure case 9 s 135 S 1117 s 210 NY 609 pers. injuries case 11 s 135 S 1120 a 210 NY 175 damages case 13 s 135 S 1122 a 210 NY 596 91 leg. mortgage case 10 s 135 S 1132 a 206 NY 609 franchise tax case 7 s 135 S 1135 ft 207 NY 270 use as highway case 11 s 135 S 88 M 89 M libel case 12 s 135 S a 209 NT 922 master neg. case 2 s 136 S 1140 en 208 NY 25 foreclosure case 6 s 136 S 1142 a 211 NY 511 176 151 pers, injuries case 8 s 136 S 1148 r 210 NY 513 partition realty case 9 s 136 S 1148 a 206 NY 687 case 10 151 426 3 135 S 1139 a 210 NT 649 contract case 21' 3 135 S 1106 a 209 -NT 582 case 22 3 135 S 1123 a 210 NY 595 938 injunction case 8 s 135 S 1101 a 210 NY 587 623 injunction case 2 3 135 S m 208 NY case 3 s 135 S^ a 208 NY contract case 9 s 135 S a 208 NY 939 read together case 1 s 135 S 85 M 924death child case 4 s 135 S a 209 NY case S s 135 S r 208 NY 1138 604 162 1139 583 912 new trial case 4 s 135 S 1146 •208 NY 57] negligence case 10 s 135 S 1107 r 211 NY 60 bankruptcy case 11 s 135 S 1105 a 208 NY 496 case 13 a 211 NY 321 211NY 325 326 913 mandamus case 13 s 135 S 1136 a, 206 NY 738 9l4st, franchise case 1 3 135 S 1134 mandamus a 206 NY 7 case 4 s 135 S a 206 NY valuation 158 1138 209 253 1104 57:^ 1104 237 1110 245 940 gambling case 10 3 135 S 1131 208 NY 578 charitable use case 12 B 135 S 1107 87 M 262 206 NY 601 1123 24.1 1144 371 925 case 7 S 136 S a 206 NY 1134 . 687 926 libel case 6 a 77 M 3 order case 4 f 151 926 case 7 217 NY 43 927order case 1 { 151 927 928 stkhldr. suit case 1 s 136 S sl53 929 order case 1 s 136 S a 206 NY 347 826 1130 685 932 pers, injur case 3 s 136 S 1130 s 206 NY 604 a 210 NT 604 933 disorderly case 2 s 136 S a 206 NY dentistry case 3 3 135 S a 213 NY 1144 59S 1132 92 918 practice case 13 s 135 S 1140 •206 NY 412 919 foreclosure case 4 s 135 S 1101 * 206 NY 691 934appeal rem, case 6 3 135 S 1143 153 681 mandamus cffse 4 3 135 S 1137 a 200 NY 085 937 death damages case 18 s 135 S 1123 a 211 NY 521 case 19 a 208 NY case 6 3 136 S r 211 NT case 11 8 136 S r 207 NY 1141 666 581 1097 606 1131 93 94 1 damages case 9 a 206 NT case 2 3 135 S a 210 NT will codicil case 14 3 13-6 S m 209 NY libel case 1 3 135 S 1129 a 209 NY 582 prom, notes case 4 s 135 S 1116 a 210 NY 629 contract case 7 3 137 S 9 a 210 NY 590 case 11 s 136 S 1141 r 211 NY 346 case 13 3 136 S 1131 a 211 NY 555 942 equity case 16 s 136 S a 206 NT .iBury case 11 3 136 3 a 206 NY prom, note case 4 5 136 S 1136 a 210 NT 590 contract case 5 s 136 S 1149 r 211 NT 39 award case 9 3 136 S r 210 NT 1144 400 1143 602 273 394 943 contract case 7 r 210 NT 496 abandonment case 8 s 136 S 912 88 M 138 945 partition case 6 3 136 S 278 a 211 NT 507 946 case 1 damages 8 136 S 1137 572 1140 237 1148 11 947 motion case 3 s 136 S 1142 s 206 NY 732 cancellation a' 210 NY 635 5 a 213 NY 656 case 13 8 138 S 1146 * 208 NY 606 case 14 * 208 NY 60S 948 motion case 2 a 137 S 1147 a. 210 NY 635 B>2ff6 NY 732 insurance ca8e 6 s 136 S 1149 a, 210 NY 647 foreclosure conversion case 7 8 136 S 1149 a. 210 NT 642 limitation case 8 r ,208 NY case 11 s 136 S a 208 NY award case 13 s 136 S a 208 NY prom, note case 10 s 136 S 1150 a 210 NY 610 228 1150 615 1150 575 949 judgment case 4 s 135 S 1120 s 153 931 money had case-'l 8 135 S a 208 NY carriers case 11 8 135 S a 210 NY 429 1144 624 1124 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d. distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m,. modified: *.,,i'smissed; n, note; 8. eritioised; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, diBsenting opinion; p, parallel case, q, quesuu N. y. Supreme Court Reports — ^Appellate Division Vol. 152 VOL. t52 14 warranty s 136 S 793 d 97 M 12 unenforceable 284 257 184 103M rejection d 184 23 motion E 136 S s 207 NY 235 800 754 rule compliance do 162 295 leglsl. intent 173 20 compensation 173 • 22 1 24 trust -fund s 136 S 059 156 727 illegal transfeiis D8 M 677 must restore 32 contract a 136S 80fl lOeM 8» 39com. law rule s 136 S 715 a 211 NY 552 172 742 743 valid 172 744 city officers 221NY 416 52 accounting s 130 S 711 a 206 NY 690 58 construe will s 136 S 703 a 209 NY 553 net rentals f 168 635 64 submission 178 recovery 178 134 s 136S £ 177 466 601 510 913 8 136 S f 163 preference 164 67 liability f 136 S "^9 M 76 parol ev, E 136 S 78 M 608 959 403 679 58 737 569 83 death damage 654 635 34 S136S a 208 NY may sue f 168 remedial d 219 NY 86eont. witness s 136 S 675 174 707 91 invalidity s 186 S 1015 .i 'Me NY 455 restrictions 169 insurance 169 98 M objection 178 219 219 35 881 97 waiver s 136 S f 97 M I GO change venue s 136 S s 136 S f 152 ( 165 596 395 592 594 99 970 1 1 limitations s 136 S 546 t 184 277 136 surplus 3 136 S 602 162 92 1 40 contract i 136 S 742 160 S 874 1 47 authority s 136 S 811 r L'U6 NY 570 mandamus 185 487 1 58 residence s 136 S 605 d 82 M 191 L62 267 1 62 discovery 657 407 45 136 S f82M inspection ]• 90 M 1 68 death negl. i 136 S 733 I 209 NY 522 ( 75 certiorari 136 S ■J. 1'07 NY not apply 166 objections 104M 667 695 228 taxability s 136 S 557 34 M 834 37 M 540 construction 161 839 laws govern 91 M 212 231 cons. will S136S 512 mjiOSNY 261 235 will S136S m 209 NY 171 859 54 342 704 179 forfeiture s 136'S 651 f 168 125 not mandatory 172 580 181 mech. lien ■i 137 S 27 S 1G4 949 consent 172 586 174 221 i93 condition jrecedent s 136 S 172 ,175 904 567 563 949 95 order 136 S 1S6 S J2 artition 20B NY escission 159 mistake 160 625 629 201 509 1 04 certification 6 136 S 688 r 206 NY 405 I 218 s 136 S t 172 245serve notice s 136 S 514 166 446 249 taxation s 136 S 575 169 694 ('9M 135 sped, franchise 172 130 i53 enforce equality s 136 S 1019 J 211 NY 508 violations 104M 348 266 damages i 136 S 578 i 211 NY 522 discrimination do 169 200 275 for jury i 136 S E L09 159 f 170 172 280 trustees i 137 S 132 a 209 NY 252 158 371 SO I easement d 181 856 appurtenant 181 365 304 personal 136 S i 165 .lability 106M 578 847 B 136 S 582 177 378 a 206 NY 747 376 larceny s 130 .S 995 a 207 NY 667 385 merger s 136 S a 208 NY 707 32 914 607 827 39 1 appeal S136S m 208 NY foreclosure s 165 res judicata do 165 834 error court 167 722 399 implied s 137 S 360 £ 158 495 su'ct. constrctn. 166 144 reason, time 181 450 general release 495 rape 137 S p 152 penetration 152 corroboration 157 799 158 147 not corrobora- tive 158 veracity 223NY 180 do 181 495 grade crossings s 137 S a 213 NY 84 M laches £ 94 M 409 for jury 455 270 117 533 £156 916 294 439 44 U 148 520 557 499 award s 137 S 207 NY judgment 166 374 686 137 S 164 422 appeal t 137 B i 154 589 411 329 891 176 307 Sunday Ibr. i 130 S 786 108 460 contract I 211 NY 24 3 1 Bcomplete gf t b 136 S 747 y il 222 no recovery a 209 NY 12 oayt. checks 184 330 323 construction s 136 S 990 f 81 M 411 183 265 335 forecolsure 136 S 39 r 208 NY 492 342 s 136 S I 211 NY 872 369 434 for jury s 137 S 266 i 173 871 438 corroboratn s 137 S 2H0 157 799 444 liability s 137 S 273 160 606 45 1 negligence -- - 827 654 137 S f 83 M 466 s 137 S f 175 review 106M 468 motion 137 S .'i 207 NY a 215 NY 476 appeal S137S •200 NY 479 after E 137 S m 207 NY 257 200 806 678 663 264 241' bon 341 865 482 remission s 137 S 306 .1 207 NY T7C forfeiture f 168 125 669 745 distinguish s 137 S S)'. 868 disbarment 768 14& submission 483 explanation 606 negligence 156 2' s 187 S 1052 968 136 S 1001 s 137 S 290 s 137 S 431 conclusive a 210 NY 553 79 M 62f f 171 96C f 163 HRl ,.^v, ...,..„s. .=„. . ^„„ „„_ S.^M .53 99 M 18:870 4 appeal s 136S 563 493 new trial- scaffold eventual estate s 138 S 62 136 S 662 181 728 672 public s 137 S 28? f 221NY 24116 M 44 a 213 NY 664 a208NY 592 miisaiiCB s i:i7 S 1148 oer stirpes ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distingnislied ; £, followed; r, reversed; m. modified; *, dismissed; n, note; >*■ criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; 8, same case; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q. questioned 5O3acquir0 land s 137 S 339 * 206 NY 577 506 justified s 137 S 360 159 820 179 20 administrative 160 789 injunction 160 904 179 18 514 signatures s 137 S 387 do 162 862 nominations I 162 913 election law m 206 NY 231 522 valid will s 137 S - a 208 NY I 85 M limitation 82 M ' 'issue' ' f 163 £ 87 it 6 14 penalty s 137 S 600 r 210 NY 62 1 no authority s 137 S 496 f 217 NY 499 633 toll bridges B 187 S 486 a 207 NY 582 discretionary 81 M 326 costs 221NY 394 £ 83 M 335 not apply 164 558 extra allowance 221NY 395 638 per. judgmt 180 836 642attys. lien s 137 S a 208 NY violation J19 NY do 174 09-1 631 194 853 573 630 620 335 53 533 543 mandamus 137 S 207 NY 552 appeal s 137 S 207 NY complaint 165 393 42 57:. 471 802 478 436 570 s 137 S 168 special master 222NY 829 575no certiorari 137 S 405 207 NY 767 161 194 579 right appeal s 137 S 400 155 823 review 166 222 581 mandamus 137 S 207 NY 601 s 137 S 215 NY 384 450 650no protectn s 137 S 643 t 161 609 663 give notiCL 137 S 580 154 85 667 affirmativel s 137 S G3.i 158 483 show facts 99M 256 577 new issues -5 137 S 627 174 841 186 182 687 decreases s 137 S 559 92 M 697 690 exemption s 137 S 176 695 appeal s 137 S 207 NY 5 275 705pwr. review s 137 S S3(; 162 280 judgt. pleadings 99M 364 718 not lien B 137 S d 79 M judgment E 168 subject 59- 30. 929 723 deed S137S a 208 NY irovid 5g:- OO: 727 will sl37S sloS 52: 47! 743 damages s 187 S 7; a 208 NY 5: 99 M 178 not adjudictn. 177 510 income ceased 221Ny 886 752 nominal damage s 137 S 817 £ 162 240 /56 not recover s 137 S 552 156 168 758 unwarrnted E 137S f 177 76 f 6 137 S r 211 NY 767 appeal s 187 S a 206 NY evidence 159' 775 pers. injury 138 S 642 a 208 NY 610 545 99 796 596 819 750 777 reference s l.?7 S sl58 788 costs s 187 S 162 805 motion S137S s 207 NY 211 NY 836 182 825 160 801 079 506 81 (child 16 yrs. s 137S 699 180 376 prohibition 180 377 minor 180 378 construction 180 383 814 no costs s 137 S 803 157 c-in 817 on merits s 137 S 747 160 670 834 appeal sl37S 81.-. a 207 NY COS 844 constructn ion J 553 521 400 508 irade 999 sl37S a 209 NY do 177 validity ' 167 177 853chnge g 137 S 207 NY 856 independent nomination s 137 S 718 a 206 NY 694 865 revocation s 137S 1069 178 150 Vols. 152, 153 N. Y. Supreme Court Beports — Appellate Division 870 habeas do 177 corpus prom, notes 157 case 7 s 136 S 877 submission a 210 NY s 137 S 1057 ■^"oi^^wv f IS 904 foreclosure a 214 NY 633 ^ase 11 211 NY 881 syndicate agreement s 136 S 600 906 reversal a 209 NY 884 case 6 s 138 S 154 419 case 5 s 137 S £158 886 replevin case 2 s 136 S a 210 NY 888 mech. s 136 S s 137 S a 206 NY s 160 1013 907 motion 899 case 9 s 137 S 1119 s 207 NY 687 personal injury 646 a 211 NY 572 630 ease 11 s 137 S 1120 10 NY 6S8 742 784 89 1 contract case 7 s 136 S 1149 a 210 NY 600 892 case' s 136 S s 162 £ 169 lox loci d 88 M lien 597 1128 909 certificate , case 2 b 154 appraisal case 4 s 137 S __ 206 NY order case 3 s 137 S 207 NY 527 934 78 503 896 accord s 136 S 352 97 M 679 680 897 pers. injury s 136 S 351 a 208 NY 618 f 178 834 898QU0 warrnto case 2 s 136 S e 207 NY notice case 1 s 136 S r 210 NY 1130 430 284 525 692 353 399 900money paid case 1 s 136 S a 211 NY f 213 NY case 2 s 136 S 1133 r 212 NY 341 casOf 3 s 136 S 1148 a 210 NY 630 90 1 forgery case 7 E 136 S 1144 r 207 NY 147 personal injury case 1 s 136 S 1133 a 210 NY 599 case 6 s 221NY 135 s 221NY 139 902 death neg. case 7 s 136 S r 209 NY contract case 5 n 211 NY liability case 11 s 136 S m 213 NY 86 510 1137 447 207 NY 645 r 208 NY relief s 224NY 1145 case 7 616 s 137 S a 211 NY case 8 - 211 NY 85 relief 223NY 1118 92 1 preference s 137 S 908 1 155 282 1143 743 923 award a 207 NY 925 case 2 s 187 S 214 NY 932 report case 11 s 137 S 155 appeal case 4 s 137 S • 207 NY 1130 762 910 prom, note case 1 s 137 S ♦ 207 NY 1124 729 Si (stolen goodi case 10 s 137 S 1134 a 207 NY 715 case 2 s 137 S 1131 a 208 NY 608 1136 769 8 207 NY 748 personal injury case 1 s 137 S 1130 a 210 NY 637 912 abduction case 4 s 137 S 1137 a 207 NY 354 case 1 s 137 S 1135 a 207 NY 736 habeas corpus case 3 s 137 S a 207 NY robbery case 2 s 137 S a 210 NY rentals case 13 s 137 S 1147 m 210 NY 641 not at large £ 87 M 598 9 1 3 constitutnl. case 6 s 137 S 1127 m 206 NY 240 915 requests 1137 f 169 832 546 283 ejectment VOL. 153 case 6 381 s 137 S 1115 I remedy a 214 NY 639 E 138 S 1148 case 7 " 577 r 211 NY s 170 482 950 order appeal 124 case 1 uncon- stitutional s 171 745 case 4 916 B 137 S 157 693 547 636 1112 482 1140 695 1132 545 1115 521 933 condemnatn case 11 s 137 S m 206 NY surety case 5 s 137 S r 210 NY --. personal injury s 154 280 motion s 207 NY 677 damages death case 12 s 137 S 1123 a 208 NY 416 934 motion case 11 s 137 S 1139 a 208 NY 558 surety bond E 207 NY 677 case 10 s 137 S 1139 a 210 NY 636 new trial s 163 26 935 balance case 6 s 137 S 1150 a 212 NY 610 case 11 s 137 S 1109 a 210 NY 639 ^l^a 936 contrib. neg case 4 s 137 S r 208 NY 937 money had partition 6 no CO Q 916 motion s 207 NY 678 recovery case 2 s 137 S 1140 , 213 NY 24P 9 1 8 tax sale case 5 s 137 S 1142 s 137 S a 208 NY case 1 s 137 S a 208 NY 943 case 5 s 137 S s 158 79 M 214 a 208 NY 441 new trial 161 8 statutory s 138 S 386 £ 160 1146 1 7 gas fixtures 833 95 1 exclusive rt. case 11 s 137 S 1110 s 84 M 464 952 nonsuit case 7 E 153 937 case 10 a 211 NY 581 s 137 S 1110 death damages case 11 s 137 S 1129 a 211 NY 509 953 death damages case 2 s 137 S a 208 NY case 8 s 137 S a 209 NY _ establish lien case 7 E 137 S 1146 a 210 NY 645 negligence case 10 E 137 S 1122 a 211 NY 522 1113 022 1143 548 S138S a 214 NY 81 M 83 M not permanent 83 M 639 improvements 170 735 221NY 105 85 M 240 248 92 M 184 consent 174 221 23 limited s 137 S 1064 169 778 duty insurer 170 497 obligation f 173 954 penalty case 2 B 137 S a 208 NY motion case 4 s 137 S a 209 NY negligence case 7 s 137 S a 211 NY case 8 s 137 S 1116 r 211 NY 74 955 negligence case 5 8 137 S 1133 ISS 4 1114 5G1 1121 .522 1141 515 956 negligence 1123 oase 3 ■445 s 137 S 200 NY 1125 40-4 case 9 1116 s 137_ S 590 1148 622 1118 718 209 NY 549 deposit m 209 NY 16 equity cases 73 t 161 510 survivor 625 175 f 89 M 943 error court " 168 92 want care 725 95 M 186 liable 357 id 182 493 634" 216 assault s-13Ys--1024l2'o"NY "'" 82 structure 95 157 282 371 requirements f 163 negligence 13 ■ - " 684 573 85 modify 640 s 138 S r 215 NY B 85 M d 163 151 152 by parol lOlM 508 234 conviction B 138 S 7 t 155 913 information 157 493 authority 106M 627 90 citation '• s 137 S 1040 85 M 667 668 affidavits 85 M 669 85 M 670 93 conviction 104 32 „ s 137 S a 211 NY 40 motion s 137 S • 209 NY slo9 amendment do 159 1094 574 1066 521 202 205 57 bill partic. s 137S 1043 lOOM 172 60 dismissal s 138 S 242 _ 89 M 223 precedence f 169 820 public improvements do 172 91 not apply £ 177 269 65 boundary s 137S 1050 lOlM 710 69 paid in full s 137 S 1105 829 71 jurisdiction 996 s 137 S 95 M 1132 ^3 reversal 6' 555 • , 223 contract 148,6,137 S 1017 a 208 NY 586 191 442 687 S138S a 209 NY 167 immunity 162 conversion do 167 responsible 215 NY 117 liability s 138 S 2D8 153 801 m 208 NY 524 f 85 M 175 129 reasonable 520 24 483 242 actionable s 138S 206 £ 177 94 249 by trial s 137 S 1084 f 170 323 affidavit 102M 354 263 n. disc. ev. s 137S 1079 103M 469 4P,j 226 250 640 sl38S 225NY 158 81 M fix rates f 175 95 M force of law 178 842 147mentl capac 872 690 138 S 153 a 211 NY 153 case 1 s 138 S a 211 NY case 2 s 138 S a 214 NY 124 153 58r 12 _ 580 258 635 1135 7^0 944 mandamus case 11 s 137 S a 206 NY 949 draft case 5 s 137 S a 200 NY 1144 224 76 83 240 028 _ 138 S do 153 do 154 54 173 exceptions 155 presumption 15!^ 654 . 172 377 intent trust 155 602 new trial 153 7 judgment 153 23 final judgment f 153 56 dismissal 156 SfiO 164 not extinguished s 138 S 107 ,,^, f 160 83 AQ-i distinction 160 ion 90 M 10 nominal value „__ 160 708 pUb compen. damage do 163 630 176 relief s 138S 175 270general sift s 138 S 194 80 M 9. 98 M .'i04 106M fil.'! entire estate 88 M 4li4 disregardec 99M 44H cut down 105M 178 277 s 138 S 1HS s 158 166 286 foreclosure S138S 32 s 208 NY 543 a 213 NY 154 293 complaint s 137 S lO'U s 165 71 72 liability 185 11!^ 299 s 138 S 29 170 934 302 limited 5 137S 1()4S f157 S04 merits f 170 334 1046 915 180 indemnity s 138 S , 330 r 218 NY 1 1 99 negligence s 138 S 370 a 208 NY 631 f 211 NY 231 206 nuisance s 138 S 84, 90 M 6891 s 137 S 159 as defense 182 333 o§q 310 on merits ^^'' - 138 S 2 164 723 312 life tenant s 138 S IS 155 ?•*' interest surplus 82 iW -KS estoppel m 200 NY 4o0 trust s 166 548 903reform deed case 8 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division Vol. 1S3 I. 325unauthor- 409 appeal S137S 157 ized 1097 488 327 life tenant 8 137S 181 334 „ s 137 S 167 1010 410 1015 211 343 objections s 137 S 1076 i 162 756 jurisdictional 173 284 345 jurisdiction s 138 S 478 165 372 157 304 161 835 enforcement 78 M 543 SIM 46 87 M 159 comity 160 406 publish welfare 224NY 110 352 s 138 S 486 a 214 NY 680 359 s 108 S 444 a 211 NT 567 362 8 138 S 511 a 214 NY 642 365 motion s 138 S 546 s 210 NT 584 372 new trial s 138 S 555 f 153 918 379 liability K 138 S 560 160 606 382 false representations s 138 S 491 do 169 48 d 81 M 229 f 81 M 233 consideration f 171 353 entire contract 169 45 47 f 83 M 476 477 do 83 M 478 85 M 407 . entirety 83 M 479 not warranties f 170 852 material f 170 852 invalidation f 170 853 388 for jnry s 138 S 496 f 170 930 B 138 S 541 a 207 NT 691 superintendent d 173 393 waiver 106M 90 414 error court 394 decree B 138 S *20S NY 620 586; 138 S 175 418 order s 138 S f 153 appeal * 209 NT control f 174 472 406 594 91C 423 judgment S138S 4Vo £156 93C no evidence t 166 361 88 H 586 relief s 88 M 711 425 reargument s 138 S 432 165 90 431 death dam. s 138 S 279 a 209 NT 510 liability £ 162 202 f 88 M 421 reversal f 88 M 240 439 negligence s 138 S 273 r 209 NY 135 442 appeal case 7 s 138 S 129 f 153 931 a 215 NY 664 456 injunction s 138 S 338 f 90 M 473 460 alimony s 138 S 230 161 522 ered'rs of wife 161 523 470 injunction s 138 S 557 a 211 NT 524 474 duty deft. s 138 S 224 £ 80 M 41 167 436 liability £ 167 436 warranty £ 167 437 482 damages s 138 S 251 a 212 NT 374 494give judgmt. s 138 S 221 162 356 liable 163 755 equitable court i 92 M 125' 40 1 common law s 138 S 549 159 510 160 896 liability | absolute 174 85(1 do 214 NT 5.11 183 703 not liable 183 707 express waiver 164 632 500 license s 138 S 246 175 159 502 costs s 138 S 276 84 M 110 507 B 138 S 482 r 212 NT 572 516 bang bag s 188 S 287 a 210 NT 646 distinction 95 M 596 532 order s 138 S 344 m 207 NY 706 tang, property 174 323 541 s 188 S 320 a 211 NT 469 547 certiorari s 138 S 341 r 208 NY 435 551 order s 138 S 110 £157 885 value received d 161 829 allegation 165 409 557 partition s 188 S 910 166 863 562 contract s 138S 866 105M 172 567 usury B 138 S ■ 50 a 207 NT 622 control £ 174 290 572 scrutinized s 138 S 41 79 M 596 B 155 943 587 water course s 138 S 746 a 209 NT 299 594 dissolution s 138 S 78 a 208 NY 545 treasury stock 93 M 436 modified 182 252 603 conclusive s 138 S 917 163 269 218 NT 593 equitable power £ 88 M 436 6 1 7 survival s 138 S 894 a 212 NY 207 155 68 estoppel d 155 71 623 mandamus s 130 S 761 s 138 S 1136 a 208 NY 621 645 strict proof clean hands 105M 504 no answer 105M 505 651 admissible 3 138 S 700 156 133 error court 158 214 burden defendt. f 159 580 5 161 928 655 ancilliary s 138 S 725 r 209 NY 375 right duty 175 310 66Irsp. superior s 138 S 009 153 duo burden defendt. do 157 914 not liable £ 158 552 liability £ 83 M 113 f 94 M 633 general service e 83 M 114 for court i 161 637 personal injury 94 M 634 63b specl. master 222NY 329 665 certiorari R 138 S 7U7 m 207 NT 771 684 duty tender s 137S f 181 294 weight ev. 181 317 693 measure damages s 138 S 76S a 212 NT 566 156 141 do 163 636 s 138 S 91 M equity 94 M dismissal 173 177 602 119 451 768 166 697 liable s 139 S m 212 NT do 153 good will £ 161 to account 155 184 fiduciary d81M dSlM accountable' 157 pleading 181 reimburse 184 236 121 843 613 258 450 451 601 77 259 711 £ 90 M 88 7 1 9 alimony s 138 S 633 156 650 relief do 102M 633 724 easement s 138 S 654 161 696 do 698 90 M 106 cloud title d 161 695 due process law 213 NT 12 728probate will E 138 S 784 B 207 NT 765 737 meaning "such" s 138 S 842 156 734 740 negligence 8 138 S 762 f 159 508 742 exr. fees B 138 S 831 164 604 759 mandamus B 138 S 1055 m 207 NT 743 770 foreclosure s 138 S 935 a 211 NT 526 783 penalty s 188 S 71.1 85 M 320 797 s 138 S 600 * 211 NY 583 804 joint stk. CO, s 138 S 64H 158 387 814 trustees s 138 S 969 d 160 837 819 error court s 138 S 981 £ 164 874 r 214 NY 675 d 218 NY 349 218 NY 350 resp. superior do 177 776 special master . 222NY 329 liability do 180 524 182 198 distinction 183 364 825 validity a 215 NT 634 s 139 S 253 f 153 710 not accountable f 153 710 fiduciary d 81 M 45C accountable 157 601 174 52 184 258 voidable 166 534 184 256 jurisdiction £ 90 M 86 90 M 88 reasonable compensation 178 596 no power 183 81 844 s 138 S 1017 a 214 NT 681 d 172 733 arrest unlawful 181 117 854 conviction s 138 S 776 a 207 NY 714 865 accord s 139 S r 212 NT 264 s 180 620 879 s 138 S 1013 154 899 882 motion s 138 S 1110 •207 NY 676 default 177 476 883 case 2 8 138 S f 175 884 mandamus case 2 8 137 S 1055 a 209 NT 533 injustice 213 NT 134 885 mandamus case 1 s 137 S 1057 218 NT 119 889 case 1 s 138 S 1119 a 211 NT 603 case 2 s 137 S 1103 i 159 921 890 removal s 138 S 385 157 79 a 214 NY 698 mandamus £ 159 490 891 negligence case 1 £ 178 328 case 4 s 137 S 1119 r 209 NY llu 892inspect bks. case 13 s 137 S 114S a 207 NT e8a case 8 s 137 S 1118 E 207 NY 751 a 214 NY 633 contract case 7 s 137 S 1143 a 208 NY oot) prom, note case 9 s 137 S 1129 a 211 NY 513 894 damages case 19 r 211 NY 187 case 21 s 137 S 1124 a 210 NT 639 895 motion s 207 NY 67!' damages s 137 S 1149 a 210 NT 638 698 mandamus case 5 8 138 S 1138 a 207 NT 084 case 2 a 208 NY 601 899 motion case 1 s 138 S 1106 E 207 NT 773 a 214 NT 644 title proceeds case 9 s 138 S 1137 a 214 NY S37 a 214 NY 698 a 214 NT 699 a 214 NT 700 case 15 8 138 S 1126 a 211 NT 513 900 prom. note case 11 8 138 e 113» a 208 NY 59e case 6 E 138 S 114S a 208 NY 628 royalty case 18 s 138 fi 1124 a 210 NT . 648 vacate judgmt. case 17 s 138 S 114* * 209 NY 567 901 appeal case 4 s 138 S 112» a 214 NT 68J case 9 s 131 S 1137 a 209 NT 538 177 688 902 banking case 1 s 137 S 1147 a 208 NY • 5S 903 s 138 S 503 a 215 NT 74S 906 case 4 E 137 S Ills s 171 S 67« E 222NT 693 907 contra ct case 1 B 137 S 113S a 211 ISTT 68 case 4 s 167 9? 908 abetting case 1 s 137 S 113S 157 38i SIO services case 1 s 137 S 112S ♦208 NY 597 912 trust deed case 11 s 137 S 114t s 155 451 case 12 s 137 S 114S a 209 NT sot 9(5 case 5 B 167 9f 916 motion case 11 s 138 S 112» * 208 NT 54S appeal case 8 8 138 S 598 * 209 NT 57S reargumen 153 42S 917 case 5 s 138 S 113S a 213 NT 62r 9(8 iud.gmenj case 8 s 138 S llli r 211 NT 19? 919 motii&n s 208 Ny ■52S case 7 8 138 S 112S a 211 NT 55« case 9 8 138 S 1138 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; {. {ollowed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, nota; c. criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s. same case: do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q, questiciifi^ Vols. 153, 154 N. Y. Supreme Couit Beponts — ^Appellate Division a 214 NY 632 S^P i^andumus case 2 B 138 S 1127 « 207 NY 7 921 s 138 S 101 r 216 NY 220 928 case 1 a 221NY 678 930 costs case 1 5 138 S a 210 NY case 2 s 138 S a 210 NY case 3 s 138 S . s 208 NY case 4 s 157 a 214 NY case 6 E 138 S a 212 NY 1106 640 1105 641 1105 577 153 637 1108 615 93 1 sp. prfmnce case 1 s 138 S 1110 r 214 NY 344 case 4 is 138 S 1115 a 211 NY 502 ease 9 B 138 S 1124 a 207 NY 7G8 res ipsa loq. Base 14 s 138 S 1128 a 211 NY 203 222NY 484 want of care 222NY 485 932 ease 9 s 138 S 1141 a 214 NY 628 933 motion case 1 s 138 S 1147 personal injury a 208 NY 634 ease 3 t 138 S a 212 NY case 4 1 138 S slo5 ease 10 B 138 S s 157 939 revocation case 2 a 20T NY 687 case 13 s 138 S 1108 a 211 NY 682 940 insurance case 8 s 138 S a 209 NY 209 NY case 9 equity s 138 S r 217 NY 81 M case 11 s 138 S 1124 a 214 NY 642 1116 570 1115 883 1134 172 934 death ease 10 I 138 S a 209 NY f 217 NY f 217 NY 1149 5U 353 354 935 negligence case 4 s 138 S 1147 a 211 NY 563 cfise 5 r 211 NY 512 936 negligence case 1 s 138 S 1129 r 211 NY 33 937 nuisance case 1 s 138 S 1131 a 211 NY 575 Oil se 5 E 138 S 1116 r 211 NY 47 938 appeal case 1 s 138 g a 208 Ny case 2 s 138 S a 214 NY case 3 a 223NY case 6 s 138 S r 214 NY s 167 1116 629: 1111 644 543 1126 447 956 V 01. J 54 1 liability s 138 S «95 157 654 162 687 safe place f 159 127 3 protect public s 139 S 17 B 216 NY 360 97 M 479 show damage f 177 326 no jurisdiction f 177 328 44 conspiracy 11-45 29 34 1107 709 422 s 139 S a 209 NY for jury f 210 NY indictment 168 weight ev. 183 71 138 S 703 211 NY 582 83 fixtures S138S s 154 conversion a 208 NY order 163 title 167 lOi 138 S 214 NY 137 311 359 600 J'filjudgt. pldgs. s 138 S 852 f 154 Wi pleading a 207 NY 587 166 appeal case 1 s 138 S 835 a 207 NY 7T4 case 2 s 138 S 1090 right judgment f 165 479 principals 218 ■NY 308 .170 motion 138 S 975 S 154 901 f 154 902 right appeal 183 36.0 738 93 591 920 713 790 645 190 order e 138 >S f .154 i 09 discretion 5 138 S 659 159 816 by certiorari f 164 249 112 3 188 S 1029 1 211 NY 560 881 913 129 596 083 290 424 847 168 638 411 125 123 s 138 S s 158 130 5 139 S * 212 NY 1 42 ouster 3 138S a 207 NY jurisdiction 157 161 f 163 SOM 83 M f 89 M limit jurisdictn. 1 57 425 cannot enlarge 157 426 legisl. court 157 589 :onstvuction do 157 591 not enter f 82 M _ 406 unconstitutional 165 34 small causes 102M 81 1 56 correct iddress s 138 S 915 172 567 1 58 damages s 138 S 921 * 214 NY £ 95 M 659 651 185 for jury enforcement f 94 M 245 no damages 94 M 246 penalty do 94 M 249 ri^^lit money 177 762 276 two causes s 138 S s 214 NY 214 NY 159 negligence r 160 844 656 674 9 IS 893 S138S 157 oinder : 174 278 133 S 166 1002 900 282 revocation 193 error court s 138 S 834 167 363 203 under oath s 139S 104 185 92 restriction 185 93 incompetent 185 94 212 new issues 138 S 1039 164 778 slight evidence 183 505 218 jurisdiction s 138 S 900 215 NY 675 negligeiice f 173 368 225 order s 138 S 1005 t 157 029 233 shares pass s 138 S d 86 M valid lien 170 reversal 182 invalid 105M 859 533 488 330 238 preferred s 138 S 952 f 158 050 250court'5 pwr, s 138 S 1082 f 92 M 582 cannot change f 92 M 582 58S 256 habeas corpus 138 S 1073 208 NY , 590 guilty knowldgfe f 92 M 68 evidence 92 M 76 872 261 extradictn. s 138S 1095 181 407 380 int. passes 270 as assignee s 138 S 829 162 _ 139 8 f 88 M .-- 86 M 59 not limited " 86 M irefiidue ' 163 272 deposit s 138 S 964 . -. 161 656 177 do 177 545 220NY 656 388_custom liq. damages - "- '~ do 161 173 97 M ,;i39S 664 8? M 614 ordinary care 355 9a M. 105M 55 3Q, 397 public 266 495 962 408 785 862 930 nuisance s 139 S a 215 NY ■ 163 691 693 95 M 399 unmarketable 172 316 91 M 138 lOOM 534 encroachments lOOM 535 Irelator rights lOOM 574 413 crime 139S- lOSM 1050 595 79 586 s 138 S a 208 NY 221NY f 171 plaintiffs 91 M ss right owner £ 170 404 £ 93 M 688 power lessee do 177 26, 27 277 403 428 no eq. relief 292 priority S139S 159 purchaser 103M 300 not actionable 138 S 89 M 97 239 18 1048 527 SOSissue warrant s 138 S 961 80 M 439 construction f 80 M 441 uon compliance do 158 591 cond. precedent ol58 justified f 160 332 award B 139 S a 208 NY 592 899 93 530 trial 88J 343 new s 139 S 155 ejectment s 166 471 351 distinction 139 S 214 NY 99M 366 s 139 S 215 NY 634 69 51 76 543 373 cond. sale s 130 S 587 a208 NY 396 503 ilirect judgment s 139 S do 158 59,9 161 161 163 819 389 a 215 NY 5068ingle cause e 139 S 160 dimaees £ l66 [On trial 95 M 327 187 683 335 S139S 157 discretion 164 442 motion 5 139S s 207 NY liability 80 M 106M guaranty a 210 NY 16H 675 181 750 47S 176 528 447 revocation s 139 S 192 162 609 610 f 173 799 173 87 M 87M 94 M dispose trust e 173 801 personalty f 173 803 804 i 178 793, 794 800 132 133 427 453 libel s 139 S m 208 NY 200 5nc 509 decree S139S 186 a 209 NY 540 ultimate gifts 1,716 328 remainder 177 388 99M 196 gift valid £ 99M 195 validity 222NY 73 vesting 103M 364 515 equity s 139 S 314 £ 214 NY 349 520 libel S139S 102 * 209 NY 560 s 162 2 525inadmiBsibIe IS 139 S 611 a 214 NY 638 f 159 398 529 certiorari S139S 180 a 207 NY 758 167 59 court's power 167 60 542 remedy s 139 S 811 a 213 NY 641 f 86 M 6 553 sales from stock s 139 S 195 f 92 M 262 558 delegated power s 139 S 896 a 207 NY 533 584 conclusive s 139S 190 185 276 596 trust co.'s s 139 S 969 r 213 NY 185 no preference do 177 180 469corroboratn s 139S 182 481 for jury c 139 S a 208 NY pardon - 603 admissible 65|s 139 S 887 719 f 94 M 387 damages 339 SOM 99 M corroboration conviction 233 US 643 56 5 491 s 139 S a 214 NY 88 645 6 495 new domicile 138S 78 £ 177 163 72 96 M" 128 6 1 8 made here s 139 S 819 157 . 770 construction 1S7 771 libel a 210 NY 592 'publish'* 178 855 63 1 allegations 762 120 s 139 S f 165 645 s 139 S a 214 NY 641 651 discovery 139 S 639 616 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed,; d, distinguished; £, foUawed; ,r, t, criticised ; 1, limited ; e, explained ; o, overruled ; s, same case ; ao. dissenting opiaidn li&ed; ", dismissed; n, note; ; p. parallel case ; q, questiouea N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — ^Appellate Divisioii Vols. 154, 155 159 166 90 M 652 „ s 139 S r 214 NT £62 s 139 S 168 fiO 943 276 207 468 428 56 776 e 139 S a 215 NT 783 delivery S139S f 83M 789 s 139 S 214 NT 423 632 373 635 s 138 S s 165 case 17 *207 NY S67 judgment s 139 S 367 (154 953 personal inury * 209 NT 515 674srch. warrnt £ 139 S 440 a 208 NT 16 "notice" f 94 M 505 .508 lOlM 555 679subject tax sl39 S 436 156 347 a 207 NY 761 construction t 164 167 689 contract s 139 S 362 a 214 NT 691 694 guaranty s 139 S 405 8 211 NT 529 a 214 NT 677 699 negligence s 139 S 379 s 160 34 707 negligence s 139 S 398 s 163 210 796 liability s 139 S 751 214 NT 687 86 M 215 216 800 negligence 139 is 385 216 NT 379 888 decree case 3 s 138 S 170 a 2U7 NY habeas corpus ■ 164 151 i 154 216 NT order f 154 944 381 1149 529 749 1136 948 tj»5 8896P. prfmnce. Ciise 11 8 138 S a 211 NT rent case 18 B 138 S 8 214 NT 1141 523 1120 308 952 7 1 6 conviction al39S a 209 NT 728 appeal S139S * 209 NT 831 541 809 new trial 139 S 409 do 218 NT 196 deny motion d 175 97 personal injury do 175 94 8 1 4 master liable s 139 S 359 157 475 162 330 93 M 591 592 error court 170 407 superintendence 93 M 589 detail work 93 M 595 for jury 174 315 819 strike out s 139 S 745 t 174 605 840 prohibition s 139S 758 221NY 453 828 519 732pers. injury s 139 S 799 i 154 741 defect ' 'way 155 394 f 170 162 part plant 157 1 162 f 163 due care 215 NT fl59 f 217 NT liability 159 169 lor jury i 174 890 case 1 s 138 S 1148 214 NT 639 173 592 case 2 s 138 S 1125 212 NT 577 891 judgment pleadings case 5 8 138 S -1125 a 214 NT 685 case 6 s 138 S 1117 a 214 NT 685 pers. injuries case 8 s 138 S a 211 NT case 12 s 138 S a 211 NT case 14 8 138 S a 208 NT 845 appeal S139S 209 NT 748 526 898 779 513 590 273 280 272 360 856 reversal 8 139 S 781 165 251 879 judgment s 137 S s 139 S 8 154 182 m 213 NT 194 9 1 5 death neglig case 1 s 139 S 1115 a 214 NT 435 case 2 3 139 S 1115 214 NT 628 case 4 8 139 S 1121 a 208 NT 633 case 9 214 NT 613 9 1 6 tax mtge. case 4 8 139 S a 208 N Y case 7 s 139 S r 212 NT case 11 216 NT 1120 523 1138 559 1118 583 1139 40a 1138 112 700 1122 549 1117 677 1133 631 9 1 7 death dam. case 4 8 139 S 1145 a 209 NT 511 918 case 8 s 138 S 8 156 1117 879 9 1 9 accounting case 2 s 139 S 87 m 209 NT 552 recovery case 6 s 139 S a 211 NT case 10 s 139 S a 215 NT case 12 8 139 S 213 NT case 14 a 213 NT 685 215 NT 742 937 case 5 s 139 S 1149 a 214 NT 631 case 7 a 214 NT 674 case 8 B 139 S 1115 a 214 NT 640 case 12 8 139 S 1129 a 215 NT 650 case 14 s 139 S 1135 a 214 NT 696 938 surety bond case 7 8 139 S 1116 a 214 NT 701 case 11 s 139 S a 211 NT case 13 8 139 S •208 NY a 214 NT case 4 8 139 S a 208 NT case 7 8 139 g a 208 NT case 11 alimony B 139 S sl56 683 1139 594 1149 557 1144 61 921 case 1 * 217 NT 922 equity case 1 a 209 NY 636 174 892 case 8 8 138 S 1129 a 214 NT 671 893 contempt case 1 s 138 S * 208 NT 924 partnership case 1 r 209 NT 40 1144 198 40 764 764 879 1117 952 453 883 740 chain tongs 8 139 S "805 i 162 588 215 NT 590 skid part o£ plant i 163 513 742 error court s 139 S 740 95 M 590 760 reversal s 139 S 418 173 182 184 767 quo warranto s 139 S 572 r 208 NY • 431 881 bill panic, case 3 8 138 S 878 ) 154 882 883 foreclose case 1 s 138 S 914 a 213 NT 630 321NT 334 884 damages case 1 s 138 S 1146 a 210 NT 646 case 2 s 138 S 1144 a 211 NT 604 903 costs case 7 s 138 S a 208 NT case 9 8 139 S a 214 NT case 12 s 138 S a 211 NT 886 services case 11 s 138 S r 209 NY case 12 8 138 S a 212 NT damages p^se 14 1114 395 1116 572 1111 602 1129 641 1130 583 925 dissolution case 1 209 NT 207 NT s 207 NT 930 usury case 1 8 139 S m 208 appeal s 207 NY validity will case 2 s 139 S a 208 NY 570 905 motion case 7 *208 NY case 6 s 138 S 1116 * 215 NT 663 907not on merit case 1 8 138 S 1142 s 155 252 155 253 death damages case 3 8 138 S 1143 a 209 NT 510 908 franch. case 1 s 139 S a 208 NY Lax 885 506 909 nuisance case 1 s 139 S 392 1138 563 1146 523 944 order case 1 s 139 S 8 216 NT f 154 case 2 s 139 S a 217 NY 391 771 952 401 671 1134 182 752 842 480 932 grand larc. case 4 * 210 NT 5o4 case 5 s 139 S a 207 NY case 6 s 139 S a 209 NT case 9 motion s 139 S 1130 s 214 NT 709 *207 NY r 215 NT 949 appeal case 8 8 139 S 1131 210 NT 549 053 conviction case 1 8 139 S 209 NT case 9 a 207 NY law service case 6 s 139 S 209 NT case 7 s 139 S 160 case 8 s 139 S a 208 NY f 160 1132 727 1148 174 750 554 933 appeal case 17 s 139 S •207 NY case 4 s 139 S a 214 NY 1141 754 1124 636 936 appeal motion s 209 NT 560 1135 536 764 372 515 113S 910 1138 521 910 954 appeal case 10 s 139 S a 209 NT case 4 s 210 NT 956 appeal case 3 s 139 S a 215 NT case 4 s 139 S s 210 NT c 216 NY case 6 s 139 S a 209 NY case 8 s 139 S a 213 NY 957 title case 1 s 139 S 1118 524 1125 651 1125 611 145 1116 532 1129 641 VOL.155 .1 damages 8 139 S 542 a 214 N T 622 negligence 166 792 f 217 NT s 139 S f 162 14 s 139 S a 211 NT 650 547 922 731 579 21 lien attorney 8 139 S 666 r 209 NY 360 48 obligation 8 139 S 555 a 211 NT 602 £ 164 103 error court 95 M 590 53 8 139 S 561 a 214 NT 694 57 certificate 8 139 S 627 171 368 66 negligence s 139 S 579 f 159 910 79 estoppel s 139 S 736 a 216 NY 40 83 contract 8 140 S 60 r 209 NY 211 impress trust s 84 M 293 9 1 replevin s 139 S 1037 a 209 NY 145 undertaking s 163 711 97 accounting s 140 S 55 a 209 NT 539 1 IQimnress trst sl39S noi a 208 NY 593 owner check E 172 159 s 175 970 s 220NY 446 discovery s 181 17 prior right 182 683 constrctive trst. 186 110 1 14 estoppel s 139S 1()H5 104M 590 1 18 denial 171 236 123 deposit trust s 139 S 986 f 89 M 637 92 M 349 f 92 M 424 presumptio n 92 M 321 delivery book 92 M 350 351 134 s 139 S 1044 a 212 NT 558 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note, c, criticised: 1. limited; e, explained: o, overruled ; s, same case; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; a, questionad Vol. 155 N. Y. Supreme Court Reporis — ^Appellate Division 1 62 contract S140S *208 NY warranty 95 M 171 s 140 S 168 1 82 eviction s 139 S 80 M nuisance 102M 577 623 1050 94 184 compliance s 140 S 161 163 199 i 163 848 192 s 139 S 1041 a 215 NY 749 1 99 pub. liealtli s 140 S 17 a 209 NY 218 f 171 906 204 appeal lies s 139 S 1075 a 211 NY 552 157 493 information 157 493 72 s 140 S 278 oumul. ev. false pretense 554 contrib. 315 99M 268 negligence 788 d 99M 259, 260 6 140 S 165 433 limitation 100 s 137 S 54 559 36 s 140 S 1119 s 140 S a 215 NY 10 a 214 NY issue stock use name 174 285 divorce s 140 S a 212 NY title free 169 294 s 140 S a 215 NY do 176 112 410 690 876 339 no estoppel s 140 S 345 s 83 M 659 83 M 673 347 allegations s 140 S 380 .6 M 250 damage 183 460 no conspiracy do 183 465 207 indorser s 140 S f 155 213 s 140 S s 155 217 211 277 224 224Iease subwy s 140 S 423 153 214 228 compromise s 140 S 13 d 92 M 103 233 presumptn sl39S lOOL 158 821 103M 120, 121 236 dismissal 395 514 147 440 449 paternity 6 140S 180 4S5 order s 140 S f 155 467 accounting 363 _ 140 S a 213 NY 321 659 372 comity f 92 M 478 382 competency s 140 S 167 387 Sep. s 140 S £ 162 391 motion S140S *208 NY liability 159 ' 'defective' f 170 174 260 118 cause 351 762 263 581 272 162 883 397 change venue s 139 S 1034 17"* IsO 502 liability sl40S s 209 NY r 213 NY tax lease material 94 M abbreviation 177 644 252 interlocutry. s 140 S 109 156 379 d 158 33 234 demurrer s 140 S 284 f 164 612 not baiTed 98 M 639 258 abandoned s 140 S a 213 NY f 164 174 non-user 218 NY 96 631 843 567 98 262 damage s 140 S 127 s 208 NV 580 r 213 NY 468 162 738 271 negligence s 139 S 1028 f 159 921 105M 714 1 ,. 565 307 s 140 S 668 m 214 NY 514 918 s 140 S i 83 M revocation 83 M f 83 M authorize d 165 166 475 costs s 140 a s 83 M indentity 163 286 677 678 680 196 505 271 575 793 480 not amend s 139 S 1027 174 217 486 corroboratn ■ 553 391 225 228 s 140 S t 160 (• 161 y.ccompUce c 161 496 appeal sl40S a 209 NY dnposit trust 89 M f 92 M delivery 92 M 724 532 It 637 424 351 283 40 ( amend 139 S 173 405 nonsuit sl40S 157 409 mechanical contrivances a 217 NY 704 s 140 S 330 f 164 831 4 1 1 evade usury s 140 S 354 167 209 418 correspond- ent s 140 S d 102 1080 85 M 679 612 391 589 509 check ertified 638 161 f 95 M authorized e 93 M delivery check 178 61 98 M 625 515 emergency s s 139S 182 5 1 6 restitution s 139 S diss do 170 I 92 M 1088 33 174 566 sl40S s 210 NY a 213 NY 157 125 modify (jontract s 140 S 50 . 83 M 558 payu]ent valid f 163 767 burden proof 163 761 authority 185 265 131 not justify 140 S 8 166 260 allegations 95 M 149 541 82 t 443 i 659 judgment 523 defense matters 140 S 570 s f 163 610 a not necessaries 1-- . f 169 787 deposit implied agency t 169 856 husband liable lOOM , 49 necessaries 179 858 680 escheat f 177 s 140 S 643 769 166 179 833 motion 704 adv. possession s 140 S 102M 602 s 209 NY 839 690 indemnity 698 s 140 S 527 162 r 213 NY 860 liability ■ 848 699 damages 895 676 575 probate s 141 S ."i a 209 NY 535 d 84 M 662 requirements 184 203 attestation 106M 618 580 injunction s 140 S 858 156 531 validity 175 700 584 void usury s 140 S 862 167 236 e 173 594 086 liability s 140 S 176 85 M 85 M 590 appeal 3 140 S 210 NY 600 liability S140S t82M s 140 S r 213 NY r 213 NY f 90 M 7 1 1 material s 140 S 887 i 96 M perjury lOOM 99, 716 judgment s 140 S 855 160 898 720 review s 140 S 914 169 304 court's power 663 515 441 442 630 557 625 163 607 assessment s 140 S J 209 NY authority lOOM lOOM 614 250 633 s 140 S f 163 623 not final S140S 831 759 . 150 900 s_ 140 S 249 s 140 S 700 150 900 s i4u . iti 161 275 not fraudulent d 83 m do 105 298 a 213 NY immaterial 902 136 649 74 649 102 92 M 594 735 order s 140 S a »14 NY 155 no joinder f 86 M judgment creditors £ 164 149 953 679 948 550 750 coiitract sl40S a 215 NY pl55 t 165 172 d 83 M purchase sale — ^ 135 7G1 575 contempt 155 invalid f 83 M 76c . „„ „ 164 quantum meruit 812 bill partic. d 83 M 167 782 coudtl. sale 868 179 544 636 test, trust s 140 S 811 a 213 NY 315 762 5 140 S * \v> NY 558 s 139 S 1133 a 214 NY 677 646 foreclosure „„^ s 140 S 681 314 a 214 NY 517 14 no recovery 106M 158 567 655 distribution 140 S 160 doption 213 NY 559 409 765constitutinl. S140S 112:. 82 11 5i distribution 86 M 126 e 86 M 127 798 strict construction s 140 S 951. 159 631 penalty rule 140 S 213 NY 55 75 184 89 M lOOM read s 95 M 525 levy assets s 140 S 753 • 209 NY 551 536 696 939 357 239 636 631 whole 67 670 grade dmge. s 140 S 694 a 209 NY 575 590 40'; t 1 168 f 93 M error court 170 93 M 594 593 for jury 174 315 employee 176 941 negligence deft. 223NY 53 842 appeal s 140 S a 210 NY in business 162 169 taxation 217 NY estoppel 177 capital stock 179 724 850 no injustice s 140 S 495 f 83 M 304 147 880 motions case 3 s 175 968 529 case 5 544 s 139 S 1117 666 r 213 NY 655 case 9 330 a 215 NY 722 case 12 841 B 139 S 1141 400 a 213 NY 672 881 case 3 s 140 S 1141 a 213 NY 684 case 9 214 NY case 11 r 215 NY SOI 549 43 G 435 450 45 76 882 validity s 139 S 1139 case 1 a 207 NY 592 884 certiorari case 6 s 166 s 139 S citse 9 s 139 S a 207 NY 856 mandamus s 140 S 4BS r 209 NY 554 634 682 760 839 781 165 866 distinction s 140S 678 179 749 862towns liable s 140S 675 99M 660 869 parol ev. s 140 S 655 a 215 NY 666 177 765 875 new trial 643 case 1 s 139 S 555 82 M 36-) 041 165 876 not liable case 5 a 212 NY 54f 1049 156 45 grand larceny , a 207 NY a 211 NY 877 death neg case 1 3 139 S 1141 s a 214 NY 60-1 case 5 635 930 897 E 159 802 s 140S do 176 809 damages s 140 S 882 r 209 NY 13!' 821 review s 140 S 618 166 222 825 specific performance 140S 68S 48! 272 112-2 s 139 S s 163 163 case 6 s 139 S -- a 214 NY 704 case 11 216 NY 699 case 14 s 139 S 1127 209 NY 21' 657 472 1123 1129 767 885 case 1 s 139 S 1054 s 155 885 887 privilege case 1 s 140 S 1134 171 863 889 negligence case 2 s 140 S 84 m 213 NY 232 891 pleading s 139 S 1104 f 163 408 893 show pertinency s 189 S 1070 158 appealable 158 817 81T 894 case 1 s 139 S a 214 NY case 3 s 139 S 1146 1117 case 8 ■6(' s 139 S 1119 213 NY 690 case 9 214 NY 620 ,se 10 139 S 1118 214 NY 646 112f 898 new trial 270 ease 4 ■ 140 S 1123 . 209 NY 590 a 215 NY 655 case 10 s 140 S 1139 » 214 NY 652 case 12 , s 140 S IWf s 156 »^1- 879 em. domain rase 4 r 208 NY case 2 s 139 S r 212 NY case 7 s 139 S a 211 NY 18f 114t 13i- 114S 6O0 ggg dismissal case 8 s 140 S s 209 NY partition case 3 s 140 S a 209 NY 1145 514 1130 528 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed! d, distinguished j f. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; >. '*'s'"'"«' = "• ,f°'!i c.criScised; I, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, dissenting opinion; p. parallel case; q. questioned N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division Vols. 155, 156 900 case 5 s 140 S 1132 a 213 NT 673 case 7 s 140 S 1133 a 214 NY 686 case 8 s 140 S 1131 * 211 NY 605 90 1 approval case 4 s 140 S 1138 94 M 457 902 practice case 1 s 140 S 1125 s 156 809 905 material case 1 6 139 S d 94 M 908 s 140 S a 214 NT 1051 440 247 705 913 larceny case 7 s 140 S 1135 a 212 NT 571 case 4 8 140 S 1124 a 213 NT 661 9I4cause action case 4 s 140 S 155 negligence case 6 8 140 S 8 105 1120 »14 1121 236 mandamus case 11 s 140 S 1139 209 NY 530 92 1 habeas corp. case 2 s 140 S 1139 * 209 NT 527 177 811 case 8 a 215 NT 488 922 conspiracy case 2 s 140 S 1135 * 209 NY 518 case 4 s 140 S 1144 r 215 NT 225 94 M 736 923 mandamus case 1 s 140 S 1138 a 209 NT S25 lOlM 602 case 2 s 140 S 743 95 M 52 53 929 transfer tax case 4 s 140 S 1144 a 208 NY 602 case 6 s 140 S 1129 a 214 NT 696 case 9 s 140 S 1147 a 213 NT 632 case 10 s 140 S 1142 a 214 NT 640 case 13 order 163 848 •208 NY 585 VOL. 156 937 appeal 155 94S 940 appeal case 2 s 140 S 1129 a 215 NT 030 case 3 s 216 NT 267 941 forged clik. case 2 s 140 S 1120 a 216 NT 660 case S 8 140 S 1134 a 215 NT 98 case 9 8 140 S * 209 NT case 10 s 140 S * 209 NT 943 case 8 E 140 S r 216 NT case 10 r 215 NT 22 partition sUl S a 209 NT 915 designation case 2 s 140 S 1116 a 214 NY 692 case 11 s 140 S 1138 a 208 NY G manslaughter case 10 8 140 S 1136 * 209 NY 518 917 pers. injury case 3 8 140 S 1108 a 214 NY 626 case 4 s 140 S 1118 a 214 NY 634 case 5 5 140 S 1119 r 213 NY 141 9r3iibel case 7 8 140 S 1134 " 209 NY 516 T 214 NY 352 ipiicai case 9 8 140 S 1136 ♦ 209 NY S17 819 "nler case 2 s 140 S 1121 f l.i5 1 1114 704 930 case s 140 S 214 NY case 2 140 S 1112 a 214 NT 643 931 injunction V\'. 920 motion case 5 8 140 S 1121 a 214 NT 673 case 7 8 140 S 1126 s 20!) NY 529 a 215 NT 644 case 8 8 140 S 1127 a 213 NY fiSii sl56 572 456 131 649 933 case 4 r 215 NY 95 M case 5 a 216 NY case 7 140 S 1129 a 218 NY B89 934 case 7 8 140 S 1143 a 214 NY 680 case 9 s 140 S 1148 215 NY 640 case 10 8 140 S 1140 215 NY B4 case 11 s 140 S 1140 a 215 NY 631 176 664 935 mandamus case 3 a 215 NY 637 case 5 a 216 NY 626 case 8 s 140 S 1140 a 209 NY 524 case 9 8 140 S 1148 a 209 NY Mf 936 mandamus case 1 s 140 S 1142 39 assume risk 141S 11 177 859 46 inadmissible 1133 561 1109 561 1122 173 181 49 costs s 141 B 100 ei|. counterclm. 164 116 609 944 case 1 s 211 NY case 5 8 140 S 1131 a 214 NT 617 case 10 s 140 S 1124 a 213 NT 66(, case 13 r 215 NT 009 case 14 s 140 S 115G a 217 NT 694 case 15 s 140 S 1117 a 213 NT 674 945 em. domai case 5 s 140 S 880 155 93- 946oxclusive rt. case 2 s 140 S 1109 8 84 M 464 case 3 8 140 S 1147 a 214 NT 625 equity power case 6 s 140 S ( 88 M stayed 183 case 11 s 140 S a 216 NT 1112 436 1122 656 130 573 31 8 140 S 909 a 215 NT 673 35 1 38 warranty 8 140 S 1070 f 159 355 m 214 NT 578 523 140 S 214 NT 835 678 8 141 S 213 NT s 141 B 136 a 215 NT 744 179 938 50 903 51 improper ev. 8 141 S 133 166 311 prelim, exam. 174 30'/ 55 witness fee s 141 S 117 p 15C 57 inadmissible t 166 311 31 alimony 8 151 S 14 d S3 M 601 85 revocation s 141S 74 J: 17 8 150 87 construe will s 141 S 41 r 210 NY 19 101 future vesting 224 stocks s 141 S m 210 NT 86 M criterion 86 M 247 variance 8 141 S 409 83 M 349 actual fraud 35 100 672 24 1 592 sl41 S dl56 178 95 M 103jH partition J, 209 NY construction 164 501, 502 f 218 NY 582 318 NY 583 decree f 175 941 distribution 182 103M 186 1 15 notice s 141 S f 162 96 618 I 17 error court 170 220 s 141 S 89 a 213 NY 669 oxlra work 175 179 126 custom s 141 S 2 a 213 NY 670 104 605 ^afe guards >20 NY 18 Fck care 185 885 |34incompetent 8 141S 98 179 841 f 159 144 liability 140 S 1045 96 M 676 154 death 104 499 327 consider together s 141 S 396 176 205 335 probable cause 8 141 S 402 165 2 343 mandamus 168 s 140 S 1085 a 214 NY 702 1 74 custody sl41S s 209 NY child 5'j sl41 S a 209 NY discretion 159 record defeasance 1 88 M eq. mortgage £ 88 M 288 348 reason, cart 141 a 458 86 jtt 338 200 foreclosure s 140 S 10.5" s 158 91 ; 460 83 3SS 368 gross carelessness s 141 S 1 159 negligence 165 369 141 S 214 NY M 216 NY not apply 8 168 89 M conversion 175 258 requiremt. s 141 S 41- a 215 NY 177 f 177 350 209 903 711 603 653 584 585 263 S 141 S 215 NY 268 8 141 S s 215 NY a 216 NY 287 743 3oe 353 645 271 no authority s 141 S 271 do 165 8 277 141 S £ 167 304 92B 279 extortion s 141 S 8:i i 208 NY G2b blackmail 170 727 295 mandamus s 141 S 138 a 209 NY 53 301 exemption 5 141 S d 94 M 307 s 141 S a 215 NY 11£ 531 473 526 821 288 351 mech. S142S 209 NY lien 90L SSI 588 874 486 701 372 foreclosure 3 I-IO S 85f s 141 S 428 213 NY 63( 375 alimony s 141 S 393 379 correspondi s 141 S 425 f 92 U 566 do 170 174 381 bill partic. s 141S 587 10011 172 383 liability s 141 S 399 do 166 960 386 waiver s 141 S 394 394 negligencp a 213 NY 636 s 141 S 105. .-i 159 691 f 162 new trial 185 831- 175 403 upon relative 8 141 S 94 M waived 99 iM 1031 36 318 prom, note s 141 S l:i> * 209 NY 55fc 323jurisdictior. s 141 S 506 r 214 NY 454 168 ■ 9GP 95 M 493 86 M 450 iiq. tax certificate s 141 S 1039 a 209 NY 182 d 221NY 80. 81 167 41 172 791 93 M 69a equity action 98 M 691 identity 172 790 453not estopped 8 141 S 1026 a 215 NY 63S f 85 U 54» t 85 M 552 457 validity S141S 1(114 r 209 NY 434 466 order S142S llrt fl56 923 franchise tax a 209 NY 502 477 appeal 8 141 S 437 a 215 NY 681 485 s 141 S 275 a 215 NY 641 490 not apply s 141 S 432 a 213 NY 563 do 160 505 fraud defense do 160 509 contract 166 765 414 murder 3 141 S 107S 1- 218 NY 21 440 nuisance s 141 S 995 f 167 510 f 167 51; gov. function f 167 517 due care f 167 517 443 prob cause i 141 S 991 r 21R NY llf 497 conversion s 141 S 342 a 215 NY 233 504 surety bond s 141 S 491 a 212 NY 292 515 services 1 141 S 364 r 214 NY 279 contract s 168 859 not recover do 179 682 519 8 141 S 347 a 213 NY 627 522 no payment s 141 S 374 a 216 NY 655 82 111 480 525 applicable s 141 S 310 a 215 NY 751 87 M 804 waiver 87 M 304 fraud statutes 175 828 532 procedure s 141 S 33S 81 M 381 552 duties directors s 141 S 561 r 215 NY 33 f 158 i 562 3 141 S 442 a 215 NY 672 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, aot« t. .riticised; 1. limited: a. Molained: 0. overruled; s, game ease; do, dissenting opininn; p, parallel case; q, questioned Vols. 156, 157 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division 577 injunction s 141 S 157 £ 167 f 86 M disability 99M infringement , 180 554 not limited corportn. names 178 179 713 purpose „.. do 167 598 trust fund llH 98 M 550 ' 'such'* ay 98 M liability 292 98 M 584 demurrer S141S a 209 NT 75G construe liberal carriers 568 182 591 not final s 141 S 9 £ 83 M 260 £ -87 M 253 coUat. attack r 211 NY 15 conclusive £ 172 473 60 1 punishmt. 8 141 S 728 £ 92 M 19 736 violations 951 s lii s 209 NY 737 directors s 141 S 156 violations 603 proper rule 3 141S 677,^= , , f 157 747 '45 construstn taxing 209 NY going value m 210 NY 479 618 accomplice s 141 S 1089 do 222NY 114 93 M 707 636 contract s 141 S 773 81 M 246 £ 89 K 420 f 97 'M 20 dissatisfaction £ 97 M 21 fact question 179 155 644 divorce s 141 S 1065 a 209 NY 420 66 1 mandamus s 141 S 734 a 209 NY 538 666 contract s 142 S 122 * 209 NY 564 673 contract s 141 S 386 r 215 NY 322 68 ! quantum meruit s 141 S- 451 £ 173 115 £ 175 547 689 separation s 142 S 501 168 s 141 S 1- 218 NY 167 lOOM 376 427 564 " 58 656 712 obligation s 141 S 161 release "abimy g^^ ^j^^i^^^l _ certification = 1^2 S u„ r 213 NY 301 15« .. ,°"° 1Y2 163 non ^negotiable 724 directors s 141 S sl56 "concerned pl56 violations a 209 NY rate interst 659 81 730 s ( 383 stop payment 181 674 818 679 s 142 S ^.„-. — a 213 NY 665 s 141 S a 213 NY 67)9 178 221NY 501, 503 830 mandamus ■ ' S142S 464 a 209 NY 86 M 598 estoppel 375 91 M 727 216 NY consignee 95 M 668 lower rate 570 186 842 appeal — s 142 S 736 a 215 NY vioiatiuua aaminisxraiioii ",X„ « -.-.nr a 209 NY 570 £ 219 NY 284 s 140 S 1135 739 use name s 142 S 94 169 849 99 M 849 not liable si s 142 S 135 575 a 216 NY 660 166 768 749 security s 141 S 742 96 M 119 753 vested remainder 3 141 S 370 do 165 496 d 173 802 176 519 756 conspiracy s 142 S 102 a 216 NY 727 165 6] 168 206 exceptions f 165 /62 motion s 142 S f 160 854 mandamus 141 S 1044 209 NY 569 856 demurrer 65 37 885 769 compliance s 141 S 945 93 M 436 775 compensatn. s 142 S 120 I 209 NY 571 879 depositions private easemts ,.„„„ i 173 37 ''a??.i„ ..„.. 37 784 damages 3 142 S 99 a 215 NY 659 do 170 210 f 167 525 due care 517 167 215 NY 517 533 lou 802 nAri S 142 b afs a 215 NY t 161 829 10 demurrer 142 S 440 s . 159 747 738 check lOOM 34 209 NT 105 case 11 3 141 S 162 1132 case 10 22 \u 691 taxation case 1 s 141 S 1145 „ all NY 541 „,. , . , ^ £ 93 M 393 914 ^e* trial 569 3^ 17 501 892 case 5 s 140 U a -214 NY 893 appeal 804 case 3 a 141 S 2uy NY 106 ... 646 administration 895stolen goods gig negligence certificate 99 M 14 17 own opinion autf NY case 8 ,J14 NY 16 624 896 a al4 NY case 8 s 140 S 1132 a 215 NY 679 899 141 S 1109 m 218 NY B4b s 142 S a 213 NY 182 remedy 182 861 order s 142 S 1- 209 NY 472 634 34 34 4 576 864 sum. order s 142 S 62 d 157 394 374 judgment s 142 S 208 t 160 888 877 bill sale case 1 s 140 S 818 s 160 362 s 138 S 1120 a 215 NT 717 case 2 a 216 NY case 8 _ 211 NY 789gov functn. f J|o g 1132 s 142 S 401 „ „,n NY 474 546 a 2 „ — , case 2 .i 210 NT 474 s 141 g 880 conviction case 2 s 140 S a 208 NY case 4 8 140 S „ » 208 NT 606 s 229 f 163 596 81 M 881 relief case 1 s 141 S t 160 889 contract case 6 140 S 1137 s 209 NY 559 9 556 s 141 S 1140 a 209 NY 551 1143 37 913 case 1 s 141 S 1117 1117 £ 163 940 69S case 6 s 141 S 177 £ 91 M case 10 a 219 NY 662 979 case 12 U86 s 141 S 1148 156 yio „,„ 915 ease 2 316 a 141 S 1149 213 NY 683 682 ijGO damages case 8 s 141 S d 209 NY liability 184 case 11 s 141 S a 215 NY 1110 587 857 1116 648 901 disorderly house case 1 141 S 1118 213 NY 639 case 4 s 141 S 1127 166 687 a 215 NY 642 case 6 s 141 S 1126 -. 214 NY 682 stolen goods case 10 s 141 S a 209 NY case 11 s 141 S a 209 NY 1137 542 1137 546 731 902 appeal 1 s i41 S 1150 925 motion ;10 NY 555 ^^^ 3 1141 a 214 NY 664 904 procedure 1135 case 10 614 s 141 S 4 157 341 1142 grand larceny -~- 210 NY 585 91 1 case 9 141 S 1115 42 9 1 2 assault case 2 141 S 1 M 6 _ 215 NY 191 890 attachment is 141 S 570 not complete case 7 r 209 NY -' 141 S 1108 'Case 7 93 1 transfer tax case 2 , , a 209 NT 587 I jranch. tax c 1 <«1 O ^1 1124 421 935 case 4 s 141 S 1146 216 NT 251 case 6 ' s 141 S 1124 a 215 NT 668 936 assessment case 6 s 141 S 1142 a 209 NT 578 937 hab. corpus case 1 s 141 S 1141 a ao9 NT 556 case 7 s 141 S 1112 215 NT 636 case 8 s 141 S 1113 213 NY 352 917 case 10 s 141 S 1119 a 215 NY 655 919 liability case 1 s 141 S 1128 a 213 NY 237 920 damages case 6 s 141 S 1144 214 NY 586 s 175 951 case 7 s 141 S 1144 a 216 NY 657 case 9 s 141 S 1146 a 213 NT 589 921 damages case 3 s 141 S 858 r 215 NT 330 923 pavemt. tax 119 496 938 motion „„ ^^ -- case 13 88 M 659 s 141 S 1116 _„ ^. r 210 NT 216 oSnotice appeal 218 s 210 NT case 14 --- ^ , . s 141 S 1119 ""der'aking 209 NY 619 ^ 216 NY s 210 NY 548 „„ a 215 NY 750 80 s 141 S 637 939 certiorari » 215 NY 674 case 5 a 221NY 563 84 liability case 7 > 141S 580 s 141 S 114l'184 175 a 210 NT 618 88 replevin 940 case 15 s 141 s 900 s 141 S 1113 r 215 NT 185 a 213 NT 660 liable 941 realty case 2 „„ r- 3 141 S 1113 3 141 S142S a 209 NY 924 case 1 r 217 NT case 5 s 141 S a 216 NT case 8 3 141 S 1107 a 213 NT 676 635 1142 661 case 3 . 141 S 118 a 213 NT 629 case 7 s 141 S 1149 3 210 NT 562 216 NT 656 926 own knowledge case 8 s 141 S 157 1J.0 — 1 000 mandamus ^'''^ a 210 NT 173 315 359 624 52 930 transfer tax 1128 case 2 118 s 141 S 1131 a 209 NY 38(1 1138 case 3 207 a 215 NT 750 s 141 S a 210 NT 10 8 141 S a 216 NY 12 s 141 S a 218 NT VOL. 157 633 621 676 693 687 661 24 nuisance s 141 S 970 172 615 38 complaint 1141S E 162 82M demurrer 98 M 673 430 624 s 141 S "751 168 413 95 prox. cause 15 NY 74 case 3 s 141 S 1123 a 213 NY 668 case 12 s 141 S 1136 r 209 NY 34J 944 contract case 8 s 142 S .. __ M d 88 M case 12 s 142 S 3 209 NY case 13 s 142 S r 215 NY 168 393 J 140 507 508 1126 563 1121 214 344 647 216 NY 178 f 90 M 373 rape do 168 correct error £ 171 46 single cause £ 175 409 £ 175 410 102 s 141 S 1009 a 215 NY 678 1 19 fraud S141S m 209 NY 945 case 3 3 142 S 1126 a 215 NY 670 case 5 s 142 S 1118 213 NY 1-64 case 9 r 217 NY 402 case 10 s 142 S 1143 215 NY 601 946 case 1 142 S 1116 215 NY 68S 177 880 ]04n SCO 140 no release 983 189 846 734 863 456 602 273 a 141 S f 172 149 „ 3 141S a 220NT 183 relief 5 141 S d 85 M rebuild f 91 M f 96 M 194 s 141 S 966 a 215 NY 649 196 liability s 141 S 811 do 166 960 201 not guilty s 141 S 853 164 131 211 report s 141 S 891 a 211 NY 530 ABBUEVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distingaishedi t, followed; r, reversed; m.m eritieked; L limited; e. explained; overrule!!; j. same case; do, dissenting opinion .odified; *. dismissed; n, note; c p, parallel cane: n, nnestioneH N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division Vol. 157 224 not demur s 141 S 812 158 238 162 677 motion * 209 NT 591 230 privacy s 141S 842 f lOlM 7 233 judgment 5 141 S 955 a 213 NY 634 f 157 891 237 -conclusion s 141S 852 178 506 241 injunction s 141 S 807 158 150 sup. proceedngs. * 209 NY 574 245 weiglit ev. B 141 S 827 f 162 880 253 sympathy s 141 S 961 171 500 259 not accord 8 142S 131 99M 337 senior participt. t lOOM 311 264 presume valid E 142 S 199 i 163 233 new trial f 163 600 burden defendt f 167 118 f 92 M 714 276 due care s 142 S 420 159 273 liability f 217 NY 598 s 142 S 506 284 relief s 142 S 195 95 M 334 as true 179 255 289 refoirmation sl42S 416 160 510 166 764 765 not available 98 M 324 294 habeas corp. s 157 300 no authority 84 M 43 302 jurisdiction s 142 S 241 161 753 * 211 NY 557 306 subscriptn, s 141 S 967 r 213 NY 585 313 s 142 S 393 a 215 NY 400 326 on merits B 142 S 139 i 162 _ 892 328 main facts 8 142S 247 lOlM 514 332 by law 3 142 S 219 a 213 NY 694 335 eviction s 142 S 281 a 213 NY 678 165 191 337 instructions s 142 S 258 85 M 564 not .retroactive f 163 188 defense 164 790 34lEr'd larceny s 142 S 256 s 210 NY 585 344 power surrogate s 142 S 493 d 92 M 133 partial distribution 173 568 346 error court s 142 S 140 s 161 801 do 161 863 351 mandamus B 142 S 426 a 209 NY 597 authorized 173 55 361 bill partic. s 142 S 265 f 164 213 181 863 364no recovery s 142 S 261 f 163 411 370 benefits s 142 S 293 d 93 M 83 interpleader 106M 374 374 s 142 S 95 M 244 102 379 abduction s 142 S 278 a 209 NY 604 383 trespass s 142 S 250 s 209 NY 589 a 215 NY 657 387 offset s 142 S 253 r 216 NY 237 d 164 469 counterclaim f 164 472 392 investment s 142 S 339 161 631 400not impeach s 142 S 592 f 169 76 173 446 strike out 174 . 005 404 repeal s 142 S 657 r 216 NY 232 83 M " 173 exclusive rule 210 NY 416 sale realty lOlM 44 407 order a 142 S 626 fl58 94- 416 weight ev. s 142 S 357 f 162 830 423 validity s 142 S 267 f 165 35 428 appeal s 142 S 382 r 210 NY 550 counterclaim f 164 117 94 M 193 one action 106M 334 442 appeal s' 142S 159 350 20.^) 448 liability s 142 S 387 a 215 NY 726 f 161 351 d 184 221 error e 161 352 New York rule a 161 353 check certified 161 275 refund 164 282 in due course 184 219 not recover do 184 221 payment peril 184 774 459 other persons s 142 S 924 167 125 adverse possesn 169 20 462 complaint s 142 S 915 fl.'ST 400 a 211 NY 355 jurisdiction f]57 4R1 166 180 88 M 686, 687 adverse possesn 169 20 474 immaterial s 142 S 606 a 214 NY 621 162 330 liability t 162 841 detail of work f 163 599 f 93 M 591 93 M 595 no recovery 93 M 592 for jury 174 315 cause accident do 185 377 481 s 142 S 572 s 171 670 s 222NY 695 485 qualificatu. s 142 S 595 s 164 576 492 allegations s 142 S 634 158 218 information 162 290 forbid practice 105M 556 496 assessment s 140 S 691 a 209 NY 599 valuation 167 430 waiver 104M 240 501 no transfer s 142 S 902 a 215 NY 740 f 215 NY 741 89 M 362 not enforced 105M 37 court's power lOSM 38 510 s 142 S 622 91 M 455 513 fraud s 142 S 602 174 756 519 tender s 142 S 721 m 218 NY 46 522 manslaughter s 142 S 833 r 211 NY 475 525 contract s 143 S 852 r 214 NT 571 535 contract s 142 R 743 a 213 NY 633 f 167 255 reversal f 167 256 542 g 142 S 862 m 216 NY 687 553 joint will s 142 S 962 r 214 NY 66 561 s 142 R 835 a 216 NY 583 56fi submission s 142 S 808 r 215 NY 427 1 RR 5S7 cost removal f158 sa.l NTirroachmcnts d 159 843 572 s 142 S 702 m 218 NY 851 586 jurisdiction s 142 R Ti" T 212 NY ."iR 181 860 fiOl set aside verdict s 142 S 89 d 164 613 f 170 976 609 vested s 142 S 162 surplus 165 _ receiver 165 do 167 discovery do 167 denied 174 972 455 210 212 182 182 607 618 evidence s 142 S 926 m 211 NT 406 no prob. value f 175 111 628decree valid s 142S 748 181 763 633 equity pwr s 142 S 729 166 642 f 88 M 436 637opiiiion rule s 142 S 804 f 168 402 not dangerous 176 677 642 s 142 S 735 a 215 NT 678 648 costs s 142 S 775 f 158 915 t 160 253 personal service 164 113 65 1 liabilitv s 142 S 739 do 166 960 658 assess tux s 142 S 714 85 M 079 66lpers. injury s 142 S 045 r 216 NT 139 666 denials s 142 S 825 158 Ron f 165 120 181 664 f 91 M 100 admitted do 180 537 95 M 168 inadmissible 172 755 672order wrong s 142 S 652 f 169 612 676 practicp s 142 S 933 157 675 no rescission 176, £ defenses do 176 586 679 counterelm s 142 S 785 166 867 686 review s 142 S 758 a 210 NY 623 688 guaranty s 142 S 790 a 216 NY 297 reformation s 173 206 98 M 190 691 reconsider s 142S 719 d lOOM 364 698 evidence s 142 S 942 173 828 711 s 142 S 724 a 216 NY 670 715 dismissal s 142 S 79 168 56 222NY 154 apportionment 181 772 729 vacated s 142 S 767 do 173 70. 731 assessment 700 7(5.1 141 s 142 S a 212 NY f 212 NY 218 NY 157 157 tl59 opinion evidence f 159 142 f 159 144 franchise ta.\ f 159 151 modified f 159 full value f 159 develop, exp'ses f 159 149 832 s 143 S s 211 NY libel r 215 NY ;844 s 143 S 986 a 215 NY 230 605 175 221 727 475 855cond. precdt s 143S 161 a 217 NY 637 179 107 commissions 181 431 146 145 760 s 142 S 1010 a 212 NY 534 763 expenses earnings s 142 S 792 n 513 NY 583 fl59 14." 766 s 142 S 842 r 211 NT 5S,T 773 decree s 142 S 720 a 210 NT 552 estate costs f 86 M 388 779 garage permit s 142 S 643 783 173 s 142 S a 215 NT 313 771 666 786 damages s 142 S 839 s 210 NT 617 178 154 change grade 868eq. s 142 assignmt S 822 f 164 811 incompetent 177 174 876 s 143 S 183 167 953 883 s 141 S 1125 a 217 NT 677 884 incest case 1 a 216 NT 753 case 8 s 141 S 1136 a 212 NT 570 cnse 12 s 141 S 1136 a 211 NT 524 885 forfeiture case 8 s 141 S 1119 a 215 NT 254 f 161 87 case 11 s 141 S 1134 a 214 NT 703 case 9 * 216 NT 684 886em. domain case 7 & 8 s 141 S 1110 r 209 NT 127 889 insufficient case 2 s 141 S 1128 f 166 744 do 1, _ f 221NT 794 award s 142 S a 211 NT f 162 d 166 798 159 289 776 599 902 301 891 reversal circumstnl evidence s 142S 620 lOOM 438 other evidence lOOM 438 corroboration 186 225 804 excess intr case 1 B 141 S a 213 NT case 2 s 141 S a 213 NY case 4 a 215 NY 746 case 5 s 141 S 159 case 6 141 S a 217 NY s 143 S d 164 interest f 179 contract 184 649 188 611 335 819 damages s 143 S 205 jr 214 NY 310 828 Is 143 S 247 Ja 213 NY 682 1118 87 959 683 1122 59 1128 a 215 NY 643 892 no bar case 3 178 438 893 case 2 s 142 S 1107 a 213 NY 670 case 3 s 142 S 1111 r 215 NY 1 case 6 s 142 S s 158 1126 453 894 case 1 s 142 S ■ 1124 a 218 NY 654 case 5 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; £, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, not* ^. criticiied : 1, limited ; e, explained; o, over^jled; s, same case; do, dissenting opinion: p, parallel cas*^; q, questioned Vols, 157, 158 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division a 215 NT 748 1 170 323 897 decree case 9 . s 142 S 1107 a 209 NY 601 commissions f 163 876 S98 liability case 1 215 NY 169 590 360 899 realty case 5 T 200 NY 900 case 6 r 218 NY case 13 a 215 NY 392 259 739 90 1 franchise case 1 s 141 S 1122 m 213 NY 570 case 8 s 141 S a 209 NY 114] 548 902 case 4 s 141 S a 217 NY 1147 668 905 case 1 m 217 NY 192 906 motion case 1 f 160 i 561 662 s 209 NY a 215 NY case 2 s 142 S 1130 a 212 NY 446 case 5 216 NY 359 disorderly house case 6 s 142 S 1135 210 NY 629 perjury case 7 5 142 S 1135 a 210 NY 144 TiKht defendant case 9 a 210 NY 202 will case ID s 142 S 1132 a 209 NY 585 9 1 7 reward case 6 a 216 NY case 8 s 142 S 1149 * 209 NY 563 r 219 NY 26 662 g 1 8 damages case 3 9 142 S 1112 3 159 159 revocation case 10 a 212 NY JlO 812 299 9 1 9 discontinue case 6 3 142 S 1131 209 NY 577 909 motion case 1 S 142 S * 209 NY 341 589 910 mandamus case 1 s 142 S a 209 NY 1133 581 913 case 8 s 142 S a 215 NY case 9 s 142 S r 210 NY 1129 654 1135 154 923 vacancies ie 1 s 142 S 1138 209 NY 151 924 negligence case 1 157 02' 925 case 1 3 142 S 1145 I 213 NY 663 1121 667 753 914 certiorari case 5 s 142 S 1137 a 210 NY 551 case 7 s 142 S * 215 NY case 8 a 215 NY case 10 s 142 S 1110 a 213 NY 668 915 motion case 1 s 142 S 1127 a 213 NY 662 s 169 49 172 316 case 2 s 142 S 1148 a 213 NY 667 case 7 219 NY case 9 s 142 S * 211 NY case 11 s 142 S r 215 NY 290 1136 545 1106 658 when asssessble 89 M 24 938 report easd 5 142 S 1144 a 209 NY 5R1 school site case 3 s 142 S 1112 ■I 210 NY 488 accounting case 4 s 142 S 1128 a 211 NY 546 939 award case 1 s 142 S 1145 I 209 NY 580 941 insurance case 5 s 142 S 1114 a 215 NY 660 942 case 1 a 216 NY 738 case 5 r 217 NY 325 943 right review case 5 s 142 S 1140 209 NY 304 case 8 a 215 NY motion case 9 s 142 S 3 210 NY case 11 a 216 NY 65: 920 case 3 2 IB NY 671 926 pleading case 1 s 142 S a 212 NY rescission do 180 578 352 539 584 1106 547 VOL. I5S 14 for court s 143S 176 182 ■ 453 28 correspondt. s 142 S 908 do 170 174 f 92 M 566 33 lien realty s 142 S a 215 NY +1 report s 142 S I 210 WY 44 order s 142 S £158 63 sale s 142S 182 980 660 982 623 1012 895 103 69 witnesses 3 142 S 829 f 158 r>72 96 M 388 compliance t 84 M 661 acknowledgment 84 M 602 74 mandamus 142 S a 209 NY 84 eq. suit 142 S 219 NY 944 case 1 s 142 S 1115 213 NY 675 case 3 a 216 NY 69S 92 release valid 1124 413 916 forged check case 1 s 142 S 1139 929 validity case 2 a 215 NY 742 case 8 s 142 S a 209 NY 930 case 1 s 142 S 1129 a 213 NY 639 932 mandamus case 8 3 142 S 1138 a 209 NY 577 934 award case 11 s 142 S 1110 t 164 898 935transfer tax case 7 a 216 NY 749 case 9 s 142 S 1109 a 210 NT 618 692 578 561 372 143 S r 211 NY 162 !05 s 143 S a 213 NY 110 s 143 S a 217 NY 365 374 100 316 68' 313 605 I i 6 counsel fee 5 142 S 801 I 209 NT 572 statutory do 170 143 compensation 184 418 136 limited s 142 S 5 f 175 157 no right 175 158 146 corroboratn s 142S 782 223NY 520 veracity 183 469 149 judgment s 143 S 27 160 901 153 mandamus 52 538 171 s 142 S I 96 M 1102 596 ISJmot'n order 3 143 S 1109 a 210 NT by referee t 174 duty court lOOM 551 523 297serve notice s 143 S 26 f 160 587 309 waiver s 143 S 249 167 44 not conclusive 167 45 new agreement 41 638 183 s 143 S a 213 NY legis. power 176 398 (92 practice s 143S 19 q 224NT 360 196 3 143 S a 213 NY 184 319 order 213 NT f 158 certiorari 183 exempt 183 115 663 2 1 7 information s 143 S 162 290 219 defenses s 142 S 1'090 161 714 222 report 3 143 S 1110 a 210 NT 626 estoppel f 166 955 228 contract s 142 S 1096 r 216 NT 500 230presumption s 142 S 1089 92 M 321 232 good title s 143 S 75 160 313 235 gambling room s 142 S 1092 a 210 NT 546 requisites f 160 indictment 162 326 nonsuit s 143 S 389 a 213 NT 1 334 not ousted 143 S 373 213 NT 676 165 917 342 negligence 642 677 24 ( counterclm, 8 143S 126 185 247 Stat, frauds s 143S 130 97 M 251 251 readjustmt. s 143 S 148 258 143 S 218 NT 143 S a 211 NT 159 s 143 S r 216 NT 31 300 166 motion s 143 S 35 3 211 NY 526 a 215 NT 671 169 to jury s 143 S 24 s 163 867 m 210 NY 45S 120 648 231 706 909 803 3 143 S 159 348 decree s 143 S 210 NY 352 s 143 S * 216 NT 378 471 433 617 42(1 632 465 duties atty. 8 143 S 577 220NY 570 176 65 467 suspension s 143 S 594 158 470 489duty master s 143 S 545 f 159 869 494 B 143 S 593 r 216 NY 246 496canoel certf. s 143 S 727 r 209 NT 567 review 169 304 legal presumptn 158 595 498 strike out s 143 S 706 f 158 501 defense denials ■ 165 120 367 not apply s 143 S a 216 NT 105M 373 death damages s 143 S a 213 NT 398 s 143 a a 212 NT 417 206 713 383 681 454 1 414 death dam. 3 143 S 57S 169 163 for jury 176 220 422 negligence s 143 S f 163 s 165 f 169 f 93 M 21-5 242 814 482 440 adjudicatn s 143 S 662 f 158 820 no title 158 822 letters admnr. lOSM 116 43 565 28 427 173 273 sp. perform s 137 S s 209 NY a 216 NY rules 177 103M ev. definite 182 288 incompetnt s 142 S 713 a 216 NY 683 164 575 290 spl. master s 142 B 1056 222NY 330 f 165 931 s 162 . 337 175 95 M 946 168 510 presumptn. s 143 S 1138 s 135 S 192 93 M 244 Uberal construction 95 M 688 517 s 143 S 819 a 213 NY 635 525 directory s 143S 739 179 674 528 no title 3 143 S 822 171 66S sales a 220 NY 232 larceny do 185 678 533cnoroachmts 826 843 690 694 s 143 S d 159 liability f 174 do 174 542 agreement s 143 S 835 t 86 M 290 g.-16 contract s 143 S 959 s 166 523 551 for court 443 barred s 143 S 603 f 98 M 25 449 for jury s 143 S 63? 161 7a show ent. dutv 158 - 425 not negligent f 169 «14 90 M 333 £ 93 M 482 817 637 356 456 contract s 143 S 599 a 217 NT 577 461 warranty s 143 S 587 633 635 s 143 S f 161 do 166 liability f 94 M 94 M ipecial master 222NT 329 lervant hirer d 183 366 552 divorce c 143 S 841 s 164 718 560 not hazard f 143 S 830 a 218NT 634 577 grand larc. s 143 S 861 a 209 NY 610 ABBREVIATIONS: a. affirmed: d. distinguishe* ; f. tallowed; r, reversed; -"^ ""^fi^"*; *;,,5,'™'!?*'„ue8,°o^ed e. criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overraled; a. same case; do. dissenting opinion; p. parallel case, q, quesiio N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division Vols. 158, l59 584 undertakng e 143S 806 184 902 591 ioBtified B 143 S 858 160 899 604 amendment s 143 S 808 s 163 866 607 misconduct s 143 S 852 s 160 523 616 other issues E 143 S 916 159 800 waiver 218 NT 560 counterclaim lOOM 167 628 determinble s 143 S 967 f 169 40 contract r 216 NT 591 638 s 144 S 70 f 159 930 do 163 665 stipulations damages 89 M E 143 S 162 do 167 limited liability i 95 M 258 95 M 587 255 983 106 744 682 no wairer E 143 S 1063 95 M 313 687 assumption s 143S 1082 180 281 697 motion E 143 S 870 s 210 NT 615 f 161 890 execution a 210 NT 622 court's power f 93 M 487 93 M 488 704 s 143 S 876 * 211 NT 556 a 214 NT 616 712 s 143 S 885 * 210 NT 612 718 s 143 S 948 a 217 NT 639 729 lease B 143 S 952 r 213 NT 516 738 new trial s 144 S 24 . a 211 NT 286 760 modified s 143 S 931 s 158 765 recovery f 159 884 763 appeal s 143 S 931 s 159 883 P 159 885 768 death dmgs B 143 S 1053 a 214 NT 116 826 786 s 144 S 508 a 216 NT 696 793 penalty s 144 S 468 a 216 NT 217 80 1 trespasser s 144 S 237 d 174 77 805 eontct. sale s 144 S 383 r 217 NT 585 810 for court s 144S 297 182 453 812 information E 144 S 203 170 377 818 not conclusive s 143 S 1027 f 83 M 499 letters admnr. 103M 116 828 s 143 S 873 * 213 NT 642 829 E 144 S 110 a 216 NT 664 843 pleadings s 144S 94 177 130 851 Rubterfuffp s 144 S 268 f 163 462 direct verdict 165 346 853 no waiver s 144 S 48 a 216 NT 687 f 167 73 167 229 not effectual 218 NT 299 new aereement 218 NT 299 not barred 98 M 639 859 s 144 S 152 a 216 NT 744 862 may avail s 144 S 40 95 M 582 873 injunction case 2 E 84 M 291 8 142 S 912 84 M 296 875 case 1 s 142 S 1148 a 218 NT 655 876 s 142 S 715 a 216 NT 659 878 certiorari 1 210 NT 527 879 contract case 2 s 142 S 1119 m 216 NT 343 debarred s 179 688 884 will case 1 a 213 NT 680 925 421 179' case 2 r 214 NT 616 889 case 1 s 177 case 13 r 217 NT 85 890 probate case 2 a 211 NT 537 s 143 S 1117 case 11 r 216 NT 259 89 1 damages a 238 US 260 892 constitutnl, case 5 s 143 S 1137 r 212 NT 183 82 M 52 894franch. case 5 a 215 NT case 6 s 142 S case 7 s 165 s 142 S case 8 s 142 S a 213 NT case 11 s 142 S s 88 M do 169 case 14 s 142 S a 209 NT case 15 s 143 S ^ 212 NT case 2 r 215 NT 548 908 case 7 a 223NT 909 motion case 1 143 S 1137 a 213 NT 706 case 9 s 210 NT 614 912 forfeiture case 1 s 143 S 1135 * 210 NT 644 913 motion case 2 s 143 S 1116 a 211 NT 526 a 216 NT 684 tax 665 1126 683 1146 1129 673 1117 667 366 1138 COO 1137 561 929 case 4 s 162 895 contract case 3 a 214 NT 619 case 7 * 209 NT 562 s 142 S 1143 case 8 a 216 NT 1 896 jurisdiction case 1 s 142 S 1041 169 466 183 372 case 2 r 217 NT 695 897 case 1 a 215 NT 681 900 defenses s 143 S 276 do 176 586 903 case 5 a 215 NT 680 case 8 s 142 S 1116 158 900 905 motion case 9 s 210 NT 612 case 10 s 142 S 1124 906 mandamus case 2 s 142 S 1135 s 209 NT 590 manslauehter a 211 NT 514 case 5 a 209 NT 598 907 check case 1 160 580 915 costs case 3 181 235 920 report case 4 a 210 NT 553 924 motion case 1 s 143 S 1131 * 209 NT 588 928 a 217 NT 706 488 930 case 5 s 143 S 1140 s 162 18 932 motion case 5 s 143 S 1116 a 213 NT 640 case 7 a 216 NT 737 s 210 NT 563 case 11 a 217 NT 713 case 12 r 217 NT 289 933 case 1 a 216 NT 686 s 175 377 case 4 a 216 NT 681 case 6 172 310 936111 competent case 2 s 143 S 627 r 211 NT 136 944 mandamus case 1 s 143 S 1148 3 209 NT 557 945 case 7 a 216 NT 690 946notice insuf, rase 3 f 83 M 371 injunction case 7 s 143 S 1139 s 211 NY 528 a 216 NT 703 947 case 6 s 143 S 1149 a 214 NT 627 g48common law case 8 174 415 case 4 a 216 NY 745 case 5 s 143 S 1107 a 213 NT 76 case 8 s 143 S 1119 159 510 a 216 NT 694 949 discretion case 2 & 3 s 143 S 1133 f 161 452 s 162 882 950 motion case 5 s 160 900 r 221NT 1 95 1 order s 143 S 1140 case 5 a 211 NT 547 case 6 r 217 NT 349 952 case 3 a 213 NT 656 case 4 a 218 NT 656 953 injunction case 5 a 216 NT 662 case 7 a 216 NY 199 case 13 r 212 NY 303 954 death damages case 3 s 143 S 1108 do 166 960 case 6 s 143 S 1140 a 214 NT 32 955 case 12 91 M 84 VOL. rsQ 7 res adjudicata' 8 144 S 2541 I 159 928; jurisdiction 102M 376 1 authority s 143 S 1090 s 169 713 12 indictment s 144 S 242 a 210 NT 191 27 credibility s 143 S 1077 1C9 77 33 reference s 143 S 895 s 144 S 1120 s 164 266 37 rate interest s 144 S 337 f 165 409 40 construction s 144 S 429 1- 212 NT 214 161 260 46 title legacy s 144 S 403 95 M 45 53 negligence 144 S 322 214 NY 49 responsibility 103M: 384 57 not abate s 144 S 408 f 172 27 59 trial justice s 144 S 383 f 84 M 640 74 discovery s 143 S 961 90 M 276 reversible error f 176 565 81 cause action s 144 S 257 178 702 f 178 703 f 92 M 196 damages 223XY 332 86 8 144 S 457 m 216 NY 603 98 bailee s 143 S 849 174 461 103M: 177 liability 174 461 102 no bar s 143 S 865 95 M 32 1 05 remedy exclusive 8 143 S 974 e 164 131 extra allowance f 170 266 principle 184 248 103M 395 1 2 1 appeal iS 143 S 1009 's 165 508 8 220 NY 366 do 165 510 124 duty deft, s 144 S 102 a 217 NT 643 do 185 849 136 8 144 S 74 a 212 NY 606 a 212 NY 607 1 60 grant land 8 145 S 346 £ 169 448 ejectment a 217 NT 162 171 complaint s 144S 357 177 610 1 86 insurance 8 144 S 424 r 216 NT 560 201 leave to amend s 144S 1 222NY 13 2nd appeal d 222NY 13 207breach covnt s 144 S 489 f 161 809 estoppel 181 166 236 not sold 8 144 S 195 167 103 241 co-exist 144 S 390 r 213 NY 68 f 163 232 252 canals s 144 S 367 f 159 932 mandamus r 211 NT 90 258 negligence s 144 S 330 r 216 NY 209 268 liable s 144 S 272 a 213 NY 683 181 812 275 mandamus 8 144 S 198 s 210 NY 643 power reduce £ 92 M 411 979em. domain a 144 S 373 r 211 NY 174 291 motion s 144 S 193 s 210 NY 611 a 211 NY 547 298 employees' negligence s 144 S 240 217 NY 355 expert evidence £ 173 948 116 contract 313 subrogation s 143 S 1046 8 145 S 432 8 144 S 1118 s 161 957 a 220NY 749 a 216 NY 692 f 162 805 177 355 I ABBREVrimONS : a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note: e. criticised; I, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q, questioned Vol. 159 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division 329 evidence B 144- S do 164 admissible 173 699 894 317 344 bar s 145 S do 173 119 813 35 1 contracts s 144S 613 105M 270 356 no defect wages 212 930 485 authority s 144 S 562 f 161 555 488r6inTestigatn s 144 S 161 497 s 144 S 901 r 217 NT 714 505 s 144 S B 144S 176 361 s 144 S a 217 NY 247 652 365niemorandm. s 144 S 725 r 216 NY 310 f 162 justify 175 451 775 394inadmissible 538 747 828 218 NY 737 509 assume risk s 144 S 688 a 217 NY 604 106M 586 649reason, care s 144 S 868 t 163 233 173 193 e 180 592 ordinary care 180 591 675 pleading s 144 S 876 f 159 678 inadmissible 160 motion 5 60 public policy f 87 M 1 672 896 172 679 5 144 S a 217 NY 684 notice s 144 S f 175 s 144 S * 211 NY f 175 412 s 144 S f 159 557 564 477 •■678 414 4l8manag. agi. - ' ■ " 602 446 433 315 s 144 S f 92 M 94 M service 180 422 a 216 NY 3 144 S 433 award s 144 S a 210 NY 757 690 660 451 5 1 3 counterclm. s 144S 546 102M 240 525 rescission s 145 S 83 a 217 NY 565 d 165 ■ 871 531 jurisdiction 3 145 S 503 a 215 NY 689 f 159 548 legisl. power do 171 615 546 increased rates s 145 S 513" a 215 NY 241 burden plaintiff f 169 449 f 169 450 563 no damages s 144 S f 167 453 discovery 517 816 122 199 932 s 144 S 169 173 84 M order £ 160 plead neglignce. 162 172 bin particulars 163 56 163 117 d 176 682 176 638, 684 estoppel f 163 118 755 849 656 843 557 695 rescission s 145 S 59 f 165 518 f 166 903 judgment costs 821 findings 3 145 S 27 172 261 824 award 3 145 S 18 171 316 829 more certn. s 144S 1068 184 574 830 s 144 S 959 m 218 NY 616 840 ratification s 144 S 1004 atructrl. repairs 689 408 193 183 704 s 144 S r 218 NY 738 s 144 S s 161 "rendered' f 90 M 628 96] 919 613 743 not complete s 144S 979 lOOM 34 no payment 178 181 ?6I 8 144 S 3 159 567 s 144S a 222NY 523 718 575 by jury s 144 S 649 92 M 100 578 bill partic. s 144 S 833 163 56 117 172 f 84 M defined f 164 £ 167 as proved 96 M 892 200 927 940 766 libelous s 144 S 1030 f 170 780 780 s 144 S lOlS a 213 NY 69] 782 disbarment s 145 S 65 s 163 88] 786 sanitation ■ ■ ~ 707 894 552 311 284 314 510 455 services s 144 S a 212 NY 464 rights strikers s 144 S 88 M forbidden 89 M conspiracy 174 250 252 property 178 280 106M 55 47 1 negligence s 144 S 451 a 213 NY 397 478 damages B 144 S 652 a 214 NY 12 583 error court s 144S 894 f 178 534 596 new trials 221 145S 185 602 s 145 S a 217 NY 628 s 145S a 222NY 640 tests s 144 S 176 781 175 258 414 595 841 212 644 mandamus s 144 S a 211 NY f 166 e 106M remedy 953 549 855 584 60 106 873 765 Degligence case 6 s 143 S" 1111 r 213 NY 348 case 10 s 143 S 1120 a 213 NT 677 d 94 M 415 195 f 164 atru 174 f 177 eviction 105M 845 charit. use s 144S 105M 861 lien s 144 S a 211 NY 185 153 882 548 57 870 negligence - ■- ~ 22 613 704 363 317 s 145 S r 216 NY 165 £ 169 s 174 877corp. 3 144S 183 885 case B 143 S 3 159 entity 982 433 937 885 59 598 97 8 144 S do 164 authority 216 NY 173 admissible 173 presumption 173 801 burd. pl£E. 888 case 4, 6 a 211 NT - a 211 NT case 5 a 212 NT 893 validity 3 144 S s 145 S 89 M f 94 M privilege 172 94 M fixed locality 98 M 569 compliance 98 M 162 316 317 898 death damages s 144 S 3 211 NT a 215 NT s 144S 102M 803 s 144 S a 212 NT 839 559 553 810 Sep. actions s 144S 825 99M 368 299 1150 232 522 895 526 922 case 5 s 144 S 1146 a 214 NY 625 case 6 a 217 NY 670 352 156 901 ease 1 a 216 NY case 3 s 169 case 7 a 212 NY case 9 a 216 NY 747 902 bankruptcy case 6 3 143 S 1149 a 212 NY 290 904 case 12 3 144 S 1121 a 216 NY 750 s 211 NY f 173 f 178 905 usury case 2 r 216 NY case 3 B 144 S 1137 a 210 NY 592 case 5 r 216 NY 564 637 20 304 702 638 923 will. case 1 B 144 S 1105 r 213 NY 328 924 appeal case 1 167 damages r 216 NY 481 case 4 s 144 S 211 NT case 8 a 212 NT 751 441 530 559 s 212 NT 696 r 216 NT 495 3 173 525 case 10 r 217 NT 484 937 case 2 a 216 NT 703 case 5 a 217 NT 703 case 6 a ai6 NT 736 938 case 4 r 216 NT 265 case 6 r 214 NT 606 925 case 3 a 216 NY 689 906 case 9 s 220 NY s 165 908 title case 4 8 144 S 8 162 case 5 8 144 S 8 162 366 508 1107 603 1146 614 926 jurisdiction case 1 s 144 S 306 r 211 NY 328 927 case 2 3 143 S 1110 a 214 NY 631 • 182 278 928 motion case 1 a 216 NY 680 case 4 s 143 S 1121 a 213 NT 696 negligence case 12 214 NT case 14 s 143 S 1118 211 NY 551 744 569 407 528 909 case a 216 NT case 7 169 657, 658 910 ca8e 5 a 216 NT 663 case 12 s 144 S 1125 a 212 NT 554 gl I case 1 a 217 NT 223 912 negligence case 2 f 160 r 216 NT £ 169 899 judgment case 1 B 144 S 1144 s 161 713 no bailment oase 3 B 143 S f 89 M bailment lOlM 913 case 2 f 163 955 38 300 900 extortion case 1 a 216 NT 688 918 neghgenca 814 certiorari case 3 case 6 s 144 S 879 s 143 S 1145 b 144 S 1150 £ 164 24P a 218 NT 667 8 214 NT view premises case 4 r 214 NT f 217 NY 75 a 211 NY 514 death damage 921 819 case 5 case 6 3 145 S 80 8 143 S llllla 217 NY 651 a 218 NT fi82lr 213 NT 341 893 356 967 915 300 929 mandamus case 1 3 143 S 1138 a 210 NY 619 218 NY ease 2 a 217 NY liability case 3 a 211 NT case 12 s 143 S 1145 a 213 NY 682 425 642 107 914 undue infi. case 6 s 144 S 1103 r 213 NY 322 916 case 2 8 144 S 1141 s 211 NY 606 T 216 NT 362 930 case 4 s 143 S 1151 a 214 NT 673 93 1 motion case 6 s 144 S 1142 8 211 NT 532 notice _ 214 NT 383 s 177 78 932 mandamuB case 5 m 211 NT 505 933 test, trust case 3 3 144 S 1104 r 213 NT 525 case 6 r 216 NT 374 152 149 934 case 1 a 216 NT case 4 o 214 NT case 5 s 144 S 1145 736 621 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d. distinguished; f. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; * dismissed; n, note c, criticised ; 1. limited; e. explained; o, overruled; s. same case: do, dissentinx opinion; p, parallel case; a. questione N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division Vol. 160 VOL. 160 6 value not enhanced B 144S 646 178 1 1 proof negl. s 145 S 165 1 170 31 718 385 29 8 144 S 1002 a 212 NT 547 32 appeal lies s 144 93 M 34 s 145 S 918 416 629 107 13 14 96 easement s 145 S 173 167 90 M 216 NY d 216 NY compensation 179 174 presumption 179 175 damages do 179 178 lOSmisdemeanor s 145 S 117 a 211 NY 539 1 1 Oem. domain s 145 S 131 r 213 NT 34 I l2iointly liable divorce 164 526 unconstitutional t 164 526 issues f 165 29 invalidity 214 NY 201 268 disapproval s 145 S 591 a 214 NY 174 277 rights s 145 S 164 284 s 145 S 168 a 216 NY 755 37 discretion s 144S 1073 180 811 41 right of supt, B 145 S 121 a 211 NT 540 f 161 284 f 173 394 stockholder s 145 S a 214 NT 170 127 s 145 S a 217 NT 106 617 146 747 138 145 175 lOlM liable 178 541, 543 t lOlM favor plaintiff f lOlM 141 46 as defense s 144S 753 182 333 48 marriage s 144 S 774 s 145 S 1144 f 84 M 272 52 8 145 S 392 a 216 NT 746 55 warranty 8 145S 462 167 436 f 167 437 negligence a 217 NY 382 60 joinly liable s 145 S 468 a 211 NT 360 170 726 615 a 217 NY 617 144 certiorari s 145 S 545 a 211 NY 542 169 384 enforcement 169 386 158 damages s 145 S 495 f 160 352 f 170 927 161 recovery s 145 S 182 r 216 NY 579 168 62 672 794 543 497 b 145 8 1111 f 161 615 •ttorney's client do 161 616 166 810 absolute fee 172 307 424 larceny s 145 S 239 a 212 NY 256 445 disregard defect s 145 S 124 166 98 counterclaim 604 270 s 145 S r 218 NY 190 libel 8 145 S r 217 NY 543 114 146 1 77 contract 209 228 161 264 SOOincompetent 8 145 S 808 a 217 NY 501 cond. precedent f 217 NY 606 315 s 145 S a 217 NT 707 331 liability s 145 S 325 173 489 notice d 176 848 344 deduction s 145 S 205 a 217 NY 634 165 401 349 entirety s 145 S 497 216 NY 114 356 applicable s 145 S 554 172 31 36 1 damages s 145 S 624 a 216 NY 618 f 171 449 s 145 S r 212 NY 472 benefits s 145 S a 212 NT 98 M 475 3 145 S 161 853 611 48 537 590 725 a 215 NY 215 NY 548 assets s 145 S 175 damages do 223NY 46 52 689 764 698 805 772 693 461 466 679 283 200 not illegal s 145 S 201 a 216 NY 175 estoppel 170S 69 174 917 240 819 497 498 501 3691egis. s 145 S 90 M contempt 174 power 388 447 387 208 s 145S a 221NY 567 42 71 jurisdiction s 145 S 427 163 7 how elected 94 M 326 80 em. domain 8 145 S 254 a 212 NY easements 167 f 90 M e 216 NY compensation 179 174 presumption 179 175 86 administratn 222 compliance s 145 S 424 94 M 403 issue bonds 94 M 404 ?251egal capac. 538 629 108 13 f 173 f 96 M liability- 224NT 104M 232 damages 8 145 S a 211 NY 94 M remitted 166 authority 166 do 166 906 264 451 18 145 S a 214 NY 394 531 267 272 560 641 645 236 counterclm. s 144 S 1028 a 213 NT 675 179 739 240 not alter statute s 145 S q 160 by jury f 164 86 M waiver 373burden proof s 145 S 477 f 167 253 title plaintiff 178 469 381 state facts s 145S 791 184 961 proper parties 186 202 dismissal 186 203 385 no error s 145 S 699 a 212 NY 57 t 213 NY 48 394 deficiency s 145 S 549 a 214 NY t 160 477 by jury s 145 S 160 f 164 86 M waiver 86 M f 86 M unconstitutional 164 526 issues f 165 29 invalidity 214 NT 206 482 complaint s 145 S 1033 3 160 490 a 212 NT 600 490 s 145 S 1033 a 212 NT 601 491 recover tax 145 S 800 m 213 NY 457 certiorari 167 6] 554 8 145S a 220NY no cause 183 fraud do 183 cond. precedent 106M 195 557 mandamus s 145 S 853 a 212 NY 463 appeal 104M 568 563 regulations s 145 S 768 a 211 NY 265 565 estoppel 8 145 S 716 a 172 89 M a 212 NT 173 authority f lOOM 651 benefit doubt s 146 S f 171 662 3 146 S s 215 NT 407 317 304 44 688 67lplffi's rights s 145 S 107C 87 M 159 162 673 8 146 S r 220 NY 94 320 908 571 8 145 S 213 NY 575 replevin s 145S r 221NY 8 221NY 794 680 678 amendmen 8 146 S 55 s 163 464 justification 10651 163 68 1 witness s 145 S 585 217 NY 520 698surety bonr! 8 145 S 674 217 NY 268 competent evid. 180 509 damages 180 509 785 49 51 578 145 S 171 754 948 584 not liable s 145 S f 162 172 175 damages 214 NY agency f 220 NY f 220 NY 503 not binding s 145 S 579 166 765 counterclaim 98 M 513 s 145 S f 167 525 3 146 S 323 577 910 652 479 819 497 400 8 145 S a 214 NY 553 610 40 1 distribution s 145 S 440 f 88 M 96 M 98 M 341 138 539 42 f compeusatn 8 144 S 1060 a 214 NY 256 181 695 783 lien good s 145 S 99S r 217 NY 284 169 586 787 not controlled 179 . 20 action merits 179 20 795 demurrer 8 145 S 722 f 93 M 368 798 counterclm. B 145 S """ f 167 778 204 807 dower s 146 3 95 M allegation d 95 M 37 872 374 819 motion 8 146 S 133 B 212 NY 586 167 568 838 liability 702 allegation 145S f 176 presumed f 176 8 146 S 107 170 501 217 NY 558 90 M 188 negligence r 217 NT 551> 845 punishable B 146 S_ - 15Z 7 1 2 inference 747 ni 215 NT ""' d 177 866 851 a 218 NT 708 753 523 823 252 117 435 145S a 217 NY 90 M 709 711 554 607 jurisdiction s 146 S 22 168 778 protection f 168 780 781 f 170 420 176 737 89 r 214 NY 293 530 equities 3 145 S 955 161 746 534 s 145 S 1022 * 213 NY 698 good defense f 90 M 310 demurrer f 173 905 537 compliance 8 145 S ■ 711 a 217 NY 98 M indemnity 98 M 619 damages 146 S a 221NY d 160 166 limitations f 160 law actions 96 M 625 146S a 221NY 719 8 145 S 1075 a 217 NT 720 725 contract s 146 S r 212 NY 164 good faith 181 8 96 M 507 955 737 8 145 S a 220NY 53 569 864 „ 8 146 S a 213 NY 345 689 871 case 2 s 144 S a 212 NY 921 554 872 delay case 3 lOlM 413 1051 718 873 case 1 m 216 NY 695 876 case 1 *223NT 648 35 542 sufBc. pwr, 8 145 S 748 ] 665 626 801 626 86 665 629 s 145 S a 220NY 635 excuse delivery 8 145 S 89 M 640 145 S a 213 NY 1043 694 740 damages 8 146S r 221NY 3; 752 must allege 8 146S 181 758 3 146 S r 218 NY 8 175 764 s 146 S a 220NY 75 116 69 645 556 877 case 1 r 216 NY case 3 a 216 NY 768 case 4 a 216 NY 226 768 883 case 14 a 220NY 735 1054 276 1061 688 644 regulations 8 146 S 3"" 66 711 768 negligence 8 144 S 921 166 904 assume risk d 222NY 442 771 spl. franch, s 146 S 112 172 remedy 384 police case 1 s 144 S 1138 a 213 NY 707 d 162 31 case 2 r 217 NY 320 case 3 3 144 S 1135 * 211 NY 544 case 4, 5 s 144 S 1103 * 212 NT 585 case 7 a 216 NT 695 130 case 9 a 217 NY 645 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, dUtinguished; f. followed; r, rerereed; m, modified; • dismissed; n.BOte; c, criticised! 1. limited; e, explained; o, overruled; a, same case; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case, q, questioned Vols. 160, 161 N. Y, Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division 885 ease 4 a 216 NT 767 ease 7 t 221NY 46 ease 8 a 215 NY 7.32 886 decree ease 2 ■ 144 S 1121 a 212 NT 567 887 case 6 a 217 NT 716 ease 13 a 217 NT 707 888 guardian case 4 a 217 NY 641 case 14 ■ 144 S 1118 a 210 NY 505 889 motion ease 2 s 144 S 1135 * 211 NT 545 ease 4 8 144 S 1107 s 213 NT 697 a 218 NT 724 ease 7 a 212 NT 549 890 foreclose lien ease 2 ■ 144 S 1122 a 213 NT 308 892 liability ease 2 « 145 S 29 i 163 592 negligence I ?13 NT 404 893 case ] 1 169 898 case 3 a 215 NT 967 734 903 ease 8 s 216 NT 669 ease 11 r 221NT 1 904 negligence ease 1 s 144 S 1118 B 165 235 e 165 236 case 2 a 216 NT 690 905 mandamus ease 5 • 144 S 1137 * 211 NT 537 906 ease 7 s 210 NT 615 a 218 NT 140 907 ease 4 a 220NT 705 case 8 a 213 NT 689 a 218 NT 140 ease 10 a 221NT 694 908 case 1 a 144 S 1111 a 212 NY 556 case 2 s 144 S 1109 a 215 NY 623 case 8 a 223NY 529 909 case 10 s 144 S 1134 * 212 NY 563 case 7 s 144 S 1134 164 954 case 9 , a 217 NY 716 910 case 9 a 217 NY 718 912 case 2 a 214 NY 609 case 3 a 216 NY 754 case 4 a 216 NT 754 case 12 185 569 f lOOM 467 9[3 case 8 a 217 NT 646 914 case 2 a 216 NT 756 discretion case 3 182 667 case 7 & 8 s 144 S 1148 r 212 NY 488 case 11 a 216 NY 75 case 10 a 218 NT 680 915 case 2 a 216 NT 756 case 4 a 214 NT 612 case 6 s 145 S 1129 a 210 NT 025 case 10 a 216 NT 752 case 11 a 216 NY 756 case 14 r 217 NY 333 916 contract case 3 s 145 S 1115 s 165 966 919 case 1 a 216 NY 766 104M 152 921 sureties case 1 s 145 S 760 s 165 206 s 165 207 924 case 2 a 216 NY 751 case 3 a 217 NY 644 925 certified case 4 f 160 925 case 10 a 210 NY 443 929 robbery case 7 a 214 NY 619 case 9 s 145 S 1138 * 211 NY 544 930 case 2 s 145 S 1135 a 216 NY 739 s 210 NT 620 case 3 s 145 S 1137 a 211 NT 386 931 case 12 s 145 8 1135 * 212 NT 589 liability case 10 r 214 NT 259 932 divorce case 4 s 162 587 case 6 B 145 S 1136 a 212 NT 567 935 liability case 4, 5, 6 a 211 NY 540 VOL.161 s 146 S a 216 NY 31: 740 25 expenses s 146 S 389 r 213 NT 51 33 insurance s 146 S 613 r 220 NT 447 s 220NY 454 invalidity do 178 493 defense 183 876 49 ejectment s 146 S 666 a 217 NY 479 54 for jury a 216 NY 759 s 146 S 350 222NY 442 59 no waiver s 146 S 232; 92 M 2181 63 transfer s 146 S 291 r 213 NT 15 67 3 146 S 284 a 217 NT 647' 79 vest title ! s 146 S 499 90 M 123 f 90 M 523j good will ' 170 688 92 M 647 91 right of way a220NTmem 81 f 146 S 259 f 92 M 266 f 92 M 267 98 covenants s 146 S 438 165 916 restrictions 174 405 violation 182 686 runs with land 225NT 395 intention 225NT 396 [ 22 constructn. s 146 S 301 e 172 575 38 M 265 dismissal 224NT 82 138 police pwr. s 146 S 403 172 74 ratified f 173 315 191 no relief s 146 S 386 a 212 NT 179 £ 169 901 203 damages i s 146 S 299 m 213 NT 411 i 205 revocation s 146 S 473 d 86 M 544 e 88 M 261 termination t 214 NT 216 22 1 conspiracy s 146 S 637 a 213 NT 37 148 s 146S a 220 NT 583 216 154 motion s 146 S 513 s 211 NT 529 1 65 reservation s 146 S 410 r 213 NT 543 1 87 damages s 146 S 395 a 217 NT 31 180 740 f 214 NT s 146 S violations 182 404 invalid s 146 S a 220NT 181 414 usage s 146 S * 212 NT a 221NT 173 230 s 146 S s 163 572 929 242 contract 8 146 S 534{ r 217 NT 549! protocolized 174 267 250 insurance s 146 S 453 a 214 NT 326 255construction 5 146 S 495 312 NT 218 262 accept findi^igs s 146S 380 a 221NT 708 lOlM 155 pari delicto lOlM 166 268 fraud s 146 S 457 a 217 NT 726| do 164 288 certification t 93 M 9^ 286 i 146 S 340l r 212 NT 604 288 ; s 146 S 343! r 212 NT 604 292 s 146 S 357 1 213 NT 638 420nght to lien s 146 S 449 169 231 220 NT 50 lOlM 38 427 performnce s 146 S 348 169 682 429 preference s 146 S 801 a 213 NT 629 s 161 435 161 437 f 161 489 175 51 subrogated f 175 50 435 preference 8 146 S 804 a 213 NT 629 i 161 489 439 commissns. a 22 INT 484 296 award proper s 145 S 88 M appeal s 93 M 95 M ' 1112 329 9 568 341 fraud s 146 S 720 do 164 , 292 366 gift 146 S 212 NT 711 315 381 x-ray exam s 146 S 321 £ 175 474 do 175 475 383 complaint s 146S 530 175 116 387 s 146 S 762 s 218 NT 701 f 175 960 400 trustee pub 165 916 243 593 686 678 688 627 624 563 512 721 865 951 589 pwr. court s 146 S 881 176 176 adoption 181 442 s 146 S a 220NT 699 740 458 prevent intestacy s 146 S 657 a 214 NT 614 f 165 483 deed prxitt do 165 494 validity 222NT 73 income 182 372 separate trust ' 182 372 469 assessment s 146 S 734 a 214 NT 1 479 preference ' 8 146 S 870i a 213 NT 628! 489 ejectment s 146 S 777 r 217 NT 526 494responsxblty s 146 S 649 *220NT 686 8.5 M 555 506 constructn. s 146 S 671 t 163 961 a 211 NT 396 186 450 521 alimony s 146 S 569 8 215 NT 559 525 contempt 8 146 S 707 s 161 $28 330 title street 8 146 S 600 a 212 NY ,325 Corp. capacity 104M 12 541 a 146 S 648 a 213 NT 658 555 imputation B 146 S 890 171 7p6 563 8 146 S 922 a 213 NY 659 573 s 146 S f 167 422 423 591 s 146S a 221NY 201 957 560 594 evidence 217 NY 725 8 146 S 825 f 165 397, 399 610 liability s 146 S 1041 214 NY- 259 219 NY 170 .contract govern t 91 M 477 absolute fee 1.7|2 307 621 usable value 8 146 S 10.33 f 170 509 218 NT 91 B 218 NY 98 624 duty court s 147 S 49 97 M 1,83 634 not servant 8 146 S 1016 163 784 liability f 87 M 306 conclusive do 166 356 special master 222NY 329 servant hirer d 183 366 649 review ^ 146S 883 106M 496 651 guaranty 146 S 939 , 213 NY 708 enforcemspt do 89 Id: 404 f 94 M 245 whole deposit f 167 169 no penalty 93 M do 94 M damages " 173 174 do 177 _ 186 S7 M as penalty 97 M 41 249 614 917 546 12 357 355 667 valid title s 146 S 973 174 143 672 Stat, fees 8 146 S 896 * 214 NT 711 106M 454 ABBREVIATIONS: a. affirmed; d, distinguished: f followed; c, criticised; 1, limited; e, explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, r, reversed: m, modihed; *, dismissed; n, note; c, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, questioned N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division Vols. 161, 162 £75 motion s 146 S 750 215 NT 433 889 case 7 s 145 S 1143 case 7 * 211 NT 607 VOL. 162 169 demurrer s 147 S ^10 337 contempt s 147 S 851 s 211 NY 531 803 restriction a 212 NT 648 6 163 116 B 215 NT 688 s 147 S 773 929 s 147 S 376 175 116 176 725 681 „ a 217 NT 655 890 case 4 a 220NY 712 6 146 S 930 225NY 397 case 5 a 221NY 537 177 469 173 distribution 354 harmless a 217 NT 727 restrct covenant s 145 S 1144 case 10 s 147 S 329 s 147 S 856 £93 forecloBure 5 146 S 902 r 213 NT 9 178 430 99M 351 a 217 NT 701 a 217 NT 653 2( e 147 S 280 f 175 933 i 91 M 208 do 165 468 8 1 1 foreclosure 894 case 1 930 case 3 s 173 883 fix tax f 91 M 207 371 supervision s 147 S 603 703 s 146 S 685 r 218 NY 155 3 147 S 1061 a 215 NT 198 827 prom, note a 216 NT 746 £ 221NY 241 903 a 214 NY 609 933 25 demurrer 5 146 S 782 s 146 S 1019 98 M 518 178 a 214 NT 46 381 venue s 146 S 966 case 5 a 213 NT 708 s 147S , 251 s 147 S 283 708 motion s 146 S 696 * 213 NY 700 P 161 831 consideration 168 823 case 10 s 145 S 1124 * 213 NY 643 s 167 97 941 28 certiorari s 146 S 1050 a 222NY 623 190 warranty a 212 NT 568 164 204 tj J-V i» A I ** « case 2 r 212 NT 348 s 147 S 754 385 deposit 712 conclusive 831 T. r. resid. 905 forest *222NY 667 a 222NY 588 e 147 S 385 s 146 S 644 s 146S 963 preserve case 2 a 220NY 582 case 3 38 contract d 169 770 f 166 679 f 88 M 82 224NY 110 lOlM 383 s 145 S 1118 s 211 NT 608 s 146 S 1021 a 211 NY 580 203 cond. precedent 186 110 7 1 5 procedure s 146 S 622 836 case 5 s 145 S 1138 a 217 NT 696 case 6 106M 142 s 147S 721 m 222NY 189 394 f A69 820 lilt in fund s 146 S 898 a 212 NT 604 case 6 c 213 NY 61 a 213 NY 226 case 8 s 145 S 1138 a 213 NY 226 r 217 NT 475 case 9 52 s 146 S 1056 207 s 147 S 726 s 147S 832 do 184 957 170 388 by devise * 213 NT 644 a 217 NY 722 a 212 NY 598 f 164 856 942 f 169 818, 819 distinction 3981egis. power 718 f 168 894 file assignment 179 487 s 147 S 333 £ 146 S 529 remainderman case 5 175 576 taxation f 175 975 *220NY 716 168 895 a 217 NT 698 do 221NY 11 f 179 488 f 87 M 640 not taxable 906prohib. writ case 9 description block by block 720 dismissal r- 95 M 475 case 3 s 145 S 1142 d 98 M 332 209 good cause 87 M 641 s 146 S 604 differentiate r 216 NY 598 a 217 NT 698 s 147S 732 objections a 214 NT 43 102M 382 s 180 792 case 8 62 trade mark do 183 71 98 M 160 f 161 731 taxable case 4 a 217 NY 699 s 147 S 138 ■contrib. neglig. 102M 385 s 145 S 1145 case 9 f 162 75 215 405vd. pub. pol. 173 925 * r 214 NY 140 a 217 NY 724 r 220NY 522 s 147 S 487 s 147S 1031 do 186 75 341 absolute case 12 case 11 emergency a 212 NY 561 185 706 bequest a 211 NT 51 s 222NY 580 182 14 730 S 146 S 611 s 146S 106 103M 136 907 case 6 s 145 S 1115 a 212 NY 553 943 motion . 75 223tang. propty s 147 S 465 410 s 147S 313 a 214 NT 605 844 case 3 s 146 S 1106 s 147S 1136 r 220NY 769 174 823 325 a 223NT 592 731 presumption s 147 S 116 s 212 NY 587 229 417 inhuman « 146 S 581 169 148 r 220 NT 416 859 error court 908 case 10 ' 211 NY 531 dismissal a 213 NY 652 218 NY 714 79 usurp power s 147 S 1 f 92 M 506 s 147 S 411 a 220NT 748 s 147 S 286 d 174 414 733 s 147 S 182 s 185 159 944 236 easements 421 s 146 S' 556 168 92 case 2 case 2 81 dividends s 147 S 661 s 147 S 761 f 163 966 s 145 S 1139 s 146 S 827 s 147 S 382 m 213 NY 438 a 220NT 697 by CO. court 878 legal r 212 NY 197 a 212 NY 599 a 212 NY 360 186 462 i 168 419 representation negligence 181 603 426 s 147 S 149 909 case 1 corporatn. law 248 s 147 S 769 738 separate contract 98 M 692 case 9 a 214 NY 618 s 146 S 1119 s 214 NT 149 181 557 s 147 S 498 a 220NY 732 a 220NT 710 s 146S 92 182 386 881 case 1 case 10 a 217 NY 648 214 NT 152 94 liability 256 cotenants 433 certiorari s 147 S 611 lOOM 158 a 210 NT 625 948 assault s 147 S 360 s 147 S 695 a 213 NT 702 renewals case 3 910 case 3 *220NY 701 f 91 M 219 do business lOOM 160 S 145 S 1121 case 4 a 217 NY 721 162 10 vest remainder 169 435 a 219 NY 661 case 6 injunction f 96 M 396 capital stock 742 new suit S 147 S 200 883 case 4 9 1 1 case 1 a 215 NY 752 case 8 s 169 691 construction r 220 NT 206 179 724 175 940 f 175 502 a 218 NY 651 s 146 S 1104 182 98 285 438 case 5 case 6 r 211 NT 284 s 147 S 586 s 147S 628 745 mandamus s 147 "S 186 s 145 S 1146 a 213 NT 637 s 145 S 1148 a 210 NT 628 case 10 s 146 S 1106 119 liability s 147 S 317 f 170 908 *223NY 525 s 211 NT 609 a 212 NT 599 884 prom, note 913 case 1 r 212 NT 249 93 M 462 *22 3NY 534 288 punished s 147S 681 443 justify s 147 S 655 185 487 case 3 r 217 NT 517 949 105M 558 175 775 a 216 NT 765 case 3 case 7 140 756 baggage case 5 r 217 NT 2'J8 s 172 882 s 147 S 262 29 1 immaterial 458 discretion s 147S 133 s 145 S 1148 s 165 33 s 147 S 631 s 147 S 803 a 220NY 549 m 214 NT 332 918 case 2 950 s 165 34 * 213 NT 654 f 167 123 r 214 NT 33? S 146 S 1094 case 6 173 36 f 168 282 764 conversion a 212 NT 548 f 168 957 142 for jury by the court 172 47 s 147 S 78 885 block by .-^ s 147 S 289 do 179 178 f 92 M 712 174 780 block 922 955 case 1 do 172 341 pleading case 2 s 145 S 681 r 212 NT 174 297 91 M 234 775 a 220 NY s 145 S 1126 f 161 923 156 s 146S 999 eauitable relief mem. 135 87 M 641 958 case 7 s 147 S 243 do 10 IM 6 f 92 M 714 s 147 S 94 case 6 924 s 146 S 1119 a 212 NT 556 separate trial liability 8 169 945 case 3 s 163 960 321 ( 173 350 1 174 690 s 145 S 1116 158 statutory s 147 S- 619 175 949 ■do 174 694 886 case 1 s 210 NT 649 s 147 S 195 t 163 918 s 145 S 1151 a 214 NT 611 do 170 143 466 state sep. 781 liability s 211 NT 556 case 6 327 super- s 147 S 931 s 146 S 813 a 218 NY 653 s 146 S 1105 161 parties intendent 171 554 87 M 431 case 2 r 212 NY 72 s 147 S 276 s 147 S 609 orders a 216 NT 698 162 634 168 ' 400 469compensatn. f 167 928 928 f 93 M 590 s 147 S 599 888 case 1 ease 6 164 no recovery a 213 NT 651 796 compliance s 145 S 1145 s 146 S 1098 s 147S 254 d 93 M 592 e 173 22 •8 145 S 815 161 957 ■i 213 NT 647 a 220NY 751 immaterial 173 25 a 213 NY 685 a 217 NT 654 f 95 M 267 access ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed ; d, distinguished criticised; 1, limited; e. exolained: o. overruled: s. ; f, folio wed ; r, reversed; m. modified; *, dismissed; n, notCj c, same case; do. dissenting opinion; p. parallel case; q. questioned. Vols, 162, 163 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division f 103M outlet 103M mandamus 186 477 s 147 S a 212 NY 314 61 1 inspection I s 147 S 915 316 182 310 f 90 M 46 produce books t 170 600 examination 185 62 671 615 595 480 competition 3 147 S 617 167 275 486 injunction s 147 S 579 86 M 444 i 86 JI 457 not 'enforced lOOM 175 495 pleading s 147 S f 166 98 M conditions 91 M compliance f 91 M 496 immunity 576 209 419 579 s 147 S 169 cliaracter 169 510 s 147S a 222NY 755 s 148 S 213 NY 613 pleading 147 S 978 213 NY 429 pay legacy 95 M 45 46 6 1 9 redemption s 147 S 1090 r 213 NY 416 demurrer 171 do 171 law action f 96 M 731 734 256 713 632 641 589 558 623 order s 147 S s 213 NY a 213 NY invalid f 99M conditions lOOM conditions subsequent 1016 646 704 447 void 75 513 termination s 147 S 1083 f 170 646 34 7 643 221NY dismissal s ISl 5'7 „ s 148 S a 213 NY 532 easements s 147 S 1040 164 928 543 no notice . s 147 S 1045 171 merits 167 668 370 595 s 147 S a 212 NY 962 593 599 marriage void lOOM 644 5 147 S E 172 647 147 S 213 NY 659 favor widow 148 S 172 174 do 176 validity 222NY 674 s 148 S s 218 NY 218 NY f 220 NY 435 56 053 759 no cause s 148S 165 105M 129 777 liability s 147 S 1024 r 220NY 708 167 846 do 167 848 784 chain tonE;s s 147 S 1012 215 NY 590 79 1 damages s 148 S 39 do 162 795 fright f 184 469 physcl. injury 184 794 relief f 168 470 300 72 959 961 955 653 214 456 158 650 230 439 681 716 806 s 148 S 98 M f 98 M interpleader 181 423 stockhldr suit 114 309 309 901 case 14 s 146 S 1103 213 NY 650 902 case 9 s 147 S 1133 211 NY 600 211 NY 601 a 211 NY 602 903 strike out case 3 186 441 case 5 s 146 S 1107 a 214 NY 710 case 7 s 146 S 164 case 10 s 146 S 164 case 7 218 NY 926 case 2 s 148 S 1160 a 214 NY 630 case 3 r 217 NY a 221NY case 7 222NY 8 162 case 13 a 217 NY 1119 401 1098 357 907 case 7 s 146 S 1106 a 212 NY 576 case 5 a 217 NY case 10 a 221NY case 11 do 178 593 570 652 I election directors s 147 S a 212 NY 542 566 590 932 336 927 case 4 s 147 S 1099 a 217 NY 719 928 veterans case 3 s 147 S 1139 s 211 N Y 606 a 217 NY 719 case 7 s 147 S 1103 r 211 NY 333 I Opub. purpose s 147 S 1057 170 428 condemnation 170 428 1 3 em, domain B 147 S 960 213 NY 218 2 1 f orgn. Stat. 181 811 s 148 S 214 NY 818 s 148 S a 220NY memorandum 103M . 353 1069 29 29 s 147S f lOOM legality • lOOM ratification 105M validity 105M 603 aid of court s 147 S 162 998 809 691 validity s 147 S a 221NY 175 704 8 147 S a 220Iv[Y 725 s 148S *220NY 731 148 S m 218 NY 264 739 147 S 1009 212 NY 594 607 trust s 147 S f 173 173 f 174 do 174 e 87 M 94 M next of kin 173 803 80S f 87 M 519 91 M 210 vested remaindr do 165 496 right bequest d 168 893 1058 801 807 769 773 133 428 532 507 700 493 747 133 763 423 59 650 608 908 case 10 s 146 S 1105 a 212 NY 569 case 9 f 98 M 631 909 case 3 s 146 S 1117 224 706 840 error court 147 S 170 93 M liability a 217 NY for jury 174 750 407 591 506 315 749 pub. policy s 147S 180 illegality 182 842 limited s 147 S 765 169 777, 778 85 1 discretion s 148 S 170 s 175 793 179 651 855 foreclosure n 148 S 100 r 213 NY 334 859 frd. claim s 148 S 155 a 213 NY 680 t 90 M 516 867 discharge s 147 S 1005 164 562 760 640 s 2,12 NY a 216 NY case 8 a 217 NY case 12 184 9 1 1 new trial case 1 s 146 S a 210 NY a 222NY 163 164 f 171 181 929 damages case 5 a 220NY case 9 H 214 NY case 15 s 147 S 1141 214 NY 101 930 case 3 r 220 NY case 4 s 147 S 1107 a 212 NY 602 case 8 s 147 S 1110 214 NY 249 f 167 509 197 628 410 924 904 815 99 920 case 3 r 217 NY 117 case 5 f 170 126 217 NY 43 case 13 s 146 S 1115 s 211 NY 533 a 213 NY 691 174 179 case 15 10211 459 707 616 314 VOL. 163 511 336 s 148 S 170 new trial f 170 67 502 605 * 219 NY 547 119 f 168 958 121 obligation B 148 S 403 s 213 NY 648, a 218 NY 743 t 165 77' 1 27construotion s 148 S 473 90 M 261 1 3 ( damages s 148 S 458- s 166 701 138 ' 167 B 169 931 incompetnt case 2 222NY 622 case 3 s 147 S 1102 r 214 NY 199 932 case 5 218 NY case 6 a 218 NY case 7 8 147 S a 215 NY case 9 allegation s 147 S 94 M 28 weight ev. S 147 S 1092 do 169 150 33 new trial s 148 S 370 f 163 973 37 use water s 148S 308 99M: 378 45 retaking 8 148 S 389 94 M 286 47foreclose lien 8 148 S 401 95 M 521 in custo. legis 163 648 50 new cause 8 147 S- 475 s 148 S 509 do 214 NY 113 54b. particulars s 148 S f 176 60 8 148 S a 218 NY 62 allegations 748 1100 652 1133 140 1137 603 471 752 liability s 147 S a 221NY 172 175 d 91 M 214 NY dismissal 170 agency f 220 NY 1087 511 525 823 250 593 935 117 563 873 s 147 S a 220NY 881 r 220 NY f 163 414 744 51 972 921 validity case 8 f 163 a 211 NY 923% case 7 a, 216 NY case 9 8 146 S 1109 a 212 NY 550 sell realty a 214 NY case 10 a 217 NY 897 equities s 146 S d 93 M 899 case ] 8 146 S 214 NY 611 107 1099 651 727 565 758 369 650 933 case 3 8 147 S a 217 NY 724 934 case 1 f 169 case 2 218 NY case 3 220NY case 7 m 221NY 923 case 7 r 220 NY 24 924 non user 1 S 146 S 1116 511 902 166 city court s 147 S 875 r 212 NY 421 175 judgment s 147 S 1053 f 163 factory f 178 179 921 307 253- 180 not retroactive 8 148 S r 215 NY f 163 27 62 B02 requests chargd. 164 f 164 instruction 166 damages 215 NY 790- 961 263; 775 683 441 723 148 S d 164 parties 182 733 732 727 |84cond. precdt. f 168 40 191 town olerk- s 148 S 36. a 212 NY 577 f 93 M 581 submission 94 M 419 county board 183 102M 104M 195 order s 148 S 163 76 allowance s 148 S 531 s 149 S 1085 r 213 NY 160 rebuild f 91 M 602 79 exclusive s 147 S 789 do 167 742 78 493 565 85 contract s 149 S 1081 do 165 lid 96 M 935 forgery case 2 8 147 S 1132 r 214 NY 75 91 eq. conversn. 8 148 S 541 97 M 560 96 damages 936 case 1 r 221NY case 2 a 221NY case 4 r 220 NY case 12 133 483 s 87 M 593; r 220 NY 431 958 169 s 148 S r 220 NY 100 „ 8 148 S a 214 NY 164 103 „ s 148 S 467 19? 63 963 199 fact questii s 148 S a 221NY. i 163 189 623 208 208 „ s 148S a 221NY 219 „ 8 148 S r 212 NY 195 524' 287 236 538 188 412 607 920 227 mandamus "l48 S 129 ■> 214 NY 653- 99 M 11 232 burden pU- s 148 S 415 f 92 M 714 ordinary care 180 581 239 demuire* s 148 S f 163 236 241 construction 91 M 664 498 J^^"^^; l:^^i^^^^^^^V^^^:V^ '=^^h^^i'^^^^^^^^^ N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division Vol.163 253 obligation s 148 S f 164 negligence f 164 liability t 103M stipulated 186 s 148 S a 218 NY 270 „ s 148 S a 219 NY s 180 274 not speculate £ 148 S t 169 recanvass 181 479 103 196 157 798 589 795 593 922 882 763 f 171 417 liable s 148S 182 answerable 182 249 654 809 804 553 mandamus s 148 S 1002 1U4 897 170 204 s 90 M 401 distribution 170 179 423 contractual s 148 S f 166 437 lees s 148S r 221NY 808 283 864 260 279 intention a 222NY 169 liability 179 292 s 148 S r 219 NT 5 219 NY do 174 562 299 708 98 101 864 445 estoppel 148S 896 221NY 536 181 166 459 direct verd s 148 S 679 165 846 not guests 185 124 463 pleading 167 585 466 s 148 S ^ 220NY r 214 NY 709 s 148 S 214 NY 714 reversal 556 148S 221NY 1016 664 56 1 examinatn. 148 S 1010 d 164 641 actions tort 98 M 91 565 interstate (.uinmerce s 148 S 1034 ; ; I. iimileil : affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followea; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note: ;, irxplained; o, overruled; s, same case; do, dird nting opinion; p, pasallel case; q, questionea Vols. 163, 164 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division 933 case 4 a 220NY 934 case 1 a 218 NY a 219 NY T31 295 60 935 case 2 3 147 S 1133 a 213 NT 651 case 11 a 221NY 936 case 2 a 222NY case 5 a 221NY 675 704 676 937 insurance case 11 s 148 S s 164 1140 645 553 sl48 S 1131 213 NY 27 956 case 3 s 148 S 1110 a 215 NY 718 case 12 a 223NY 957 case 2 __ 214 NY case 3 177 a 221NY 958 case 3 a 220NY case 5 s 148 S * 213 NY case 7 a 218 NT 608 645 521 938 case 4 s 147 S f 165 736 1139 697 618 VOL. 164 I crime a^ 213 NT 1*^4 d 164 immunity 164 15 Clime a 213 NY d 164 164 368 15 25 388 26 30 25 Indictment r 213 NY 388 30 liability s 149 S 338 f 97 M 636 32 accomplice s 149S 321 do 222NY 114 959 liquidation 1121 ease 2 984 s 148 S 414 la 213 NY 280 939 case 1 r 219 NY 443 961 lease 7 s 148 S 44 discretion 940 case 3 1 170 897 444 943 case 1 f 167 case 2 s 148 S 1122 * 214 NY 707 a 220NY 757 944 case 5 s 148 S 1137 a 212 NY 605 167 859 947 appeal s 148 S 1117 case 11 a 212 NY 593 case 4 s 48 S 1 87 M suspended do 165 taxation r 213 NY case 8 a 220NY case 10 a 221NY 165 964 case 1 218 NY case 2 £ 168 a 221NY f 170 d 172 case 7 177 1112 919 s 149 S f 176 45 a 214 NY 51 s 149 S a 222NY 432 882 710 438 665 313 929 550 738 398 427 63 negligence f 164 70 s 149 S s 220NY 220Ny 956 1151 265 322 109 720 533 966 case 7 a 212 NY case 6 s 148 S 113(5 * 212 NT 616 mala iides 186 case 8 ( 171 447 687 753 1 6 1 forfeiture s 149 S 661 f 165 926 t 167 913 first offender 103M 334 163 order s 149 S 563 „ 213 NT 706 com. council lOOM 573 authority 181 51 173 legal remdy s 149 S 756 170 746 lien filed 105M 673 177 tried first s 149 S 638 166 766 ISO certiorari s 149 S 636 * 214 NT 652 183 law action s 149 S 653 f 96 M 256 185 use name s 149 S 748 169 848 1 9 1 presumed s 149 S 657 t 88 M 589 579 213 957 970 must plead case 10 „ 220NY 94 M 971 case 7 s 148 S • 217 NY 75 cotenancy 89 M 636 79 prosecution s 149 S 377 do 167 181 89 county charges s 149 S £ 173 £ 93 M a 215 NY 18 35 1 complaint s 149 S 620 168 111 355 not demur s 149 S 665 £ 171 510 plead truth 174 466 358 modified s 149 S 728 £ 164 365 discretion 178 777, 778 accumulations 105M 153 363 accumulatn s 149 S 89 M discretion £ 178 490 not liable B ISO S 279 f 168 839 498 vesting 731 337 778 621 r 222NY s 150 S a 218 NY f 88 M contingent 95 M £ 96 M construction ' 96 M 537 507 not valid 335 573 386 41 s 149 S f 169 513 s 149S a 221NY 522 e 149S a 223NY 559 770 126 §25 give facts B 149 S 826 170 119 633 allegation s 149 S 867 98 M 481 denial 98 M 481 636 discovery s 149 S 1016 £. 217 NY 198 a 220NY 633 ,.fe45 in J's 150S *f 176 's 176 788 690 650 assumption 36Rnot enforced s 149S 642 lOOM 175 ' Mug handle' 102M 390 370 statute bar s 149S 807 lOOM 22 additnl. facts ' 102M 232 doing business 104M 525 divorce s 149 S 302 a 2ri4 NT 204 53 1 no jurisdctn 223 661 516 296 302 314 317 s 150 S 93 M relief 98 M s 150 S 183 £ 88 M £ 90 M lOlM 102M do 102M 736 441 1123 662 572 353 266 206 separately S 149 S 73G f 165 171 £ 167 900 228insufficiency s 149 S 176 234 s 149 S a 220NY 238 practice 97 labor law a 214 NY 121 108 jurisdiction s 149 S 443 96 M 70 623 264 654 608 598 759 835 376 s 149 S s 169 38 1 insurance s 149S 859 r 221NY 113 385 negligence '--" 86 228 56 918 919 66 128 309 533 decree s 150 S 213 a 214 NT 660 540 fair trial s 150S 8 106M 7 658 damages s 149 S 1003 do 166 919 f 91 M 548 contrib. neglig. do 186 76 d 91M 549 new trial a 221NT 538 186 71 689'iuan meruit s 150 S 376 217 NT s 150S r 221NY 389 s 149S a 22 INT S 149 S f 91 M 245 s 149S a 222NT 703 5 629 539 812 513 948 case 1 a 218 NT case 2 s 148 S 1136 a 212 NT 602 case 3 a 220NT case 4 m 220NT case 6 a 220NT case 7 a 218 NT 677 755 391 748 673 658 949 exemption case 4 s 148 S 1111 a 215 NT 620 952 case 5 s 148 S 1121 a 212 NT 594 953 case 6 s 148 S 1115 a 212 NT 591 955 conversion case 1 a. 22GNT 698 case 2 972 case 2 218 NT case 4 s 148 S 1134 * 214 NT 649 973 case 10 s 148 S 1147 a 212 NT 592 case 6 a 222NT case 7 174 265 atty lien B 149 S 631 IIOsupl. compltm 214 NT 361 s 149 S 484' do 173 litigate 184 I 1 5 tried first B 149 S 491 166 766 699 257 interference s 149 S 771 f 164 271 89 M 236 suspension f 176 629 762 571 87 974 case 2 s 148 S 1123 212 NT case 5 220NY case 6 148 S 212 NY 119 adioummt. s 149 S 819 f 172 757 758 134 149 S s 173 279paymt. peril 591 758 70 608 530 1004 399 preference s 149 S 683 f 216 NY 196 vacate attachml 172 313 412 death negl. 150S 225 185 590 417 reversal s 150 S 93 172 144 548 s 150 S a 219 NY costs 22 INT full value 184 565 s 150S a 22 INT 142 not enforced s 149S 445 lOOM 175, 176 150 information s 149 S 452 170 377 jurisdiction 170 377 170 948 160 s 149S 221NY 149S 184 296 s 150 S 218 NY new trial 186 775 774 317 725 844 232 713 B 150S a 222NY 173 589 76 588 107 591 573 no relief 8 150 S 229 166 296 577 dwelling s 150 S 94 f 164 823 restriction 172 396 397 337 309 310 assume duties 193 424 s 150S 222NY promise 222NY 430 223NY 118 304pre sumption s 150 S 410 95 M 46 314 prom, note s 149 S f 164 802 462 estoppel s 150S do 222NY 472 s 150S a 221NY 986 325 324 - 149S a 221NY 993 729 332 directors s 149 S 880 210 536 556 172 586 s 150 S s 214 NY 597 illegal preference s 150 S a 215 NY f 89 M set-off 89 M 715 trust fund s 149S e .102M expenses e 102M 718 damages s 150S 199 180 501, 502 721 try title s 150 S 207 93 M 202 725 compliance B J.49 S 610 f 172 687 f' 173 .910 motion dismiss 98 M 419 lien defective 290 260 659 305 395 409 182 737 „ B 150S a 222NY 740 „ s 150 S a 218 NY 284 691 190 743 -L 410 1746 eauality B 150S 600 hab. corpus a 222NY B 150 S 302 178 a 215 NY 622 99M 477 sale goods . 150S r 221NY 483 s 150 S s 215 NT a 220NY 17 120 251 557 605 extra compensation 99 M 207 not binding 105M 604 s 150S a 221NY 528 authorized 178 597, 756 „ s 149 S a 215 NY 323 567 612 burd. plffi. 102M 559 615 596 605 599 823 711 761 demurrer s 149S 978 r 221Ny 58 102M 333 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distins:uishedi f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; c, i;riticised; 1. limited: e. explained i o, overruled: s. same case; do. dissertinc opinion: p. parallel case: q, questionea. N..Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Divlsioii Vols. 164, 165 774 liability s 149 S 836 B 167 492 821 'private' 8 150 S 435 172 399 restriction 178 429 regulate use 103M 628 825 8 150 S 509 a 215 NT 719 829 s 150 S 164 t 219 NT 419 837 constructn, s 150S 263 105M 277 uphold will 105M 277 case 4 a 220NT 846 s 150 S s 172 512 598 852 compositn s 150 S 1096 a 215 NT 091 166 794 169 606 854 jurisdiction B 150 S 1098 a 215 NT 703 f 94 M 80 862 appeal s 149S 1001 m 222NT 14 865 instruction s 150 S 439 172 601 867 liability s 150S 442 185 27 870 easement s 148S 517 lOOM 128 871 s 148 S 949 a 218 NT 483 873 case 2 s 148 S 433 r 218 NT 345 173 790 878 order f 173 ! 880 order a 213 NT 705 882 appeal a 213 NT 702 884 countrclm case 2 184 442 886 appeal a 215 NY 628 895 case 3 a 220NT 896 case 2 s 165 730 897 damages case 4 90 M 401 898 case 3 a 214 NY 7]2 738 900 case 1 t 164 900 m 217 NY 24 case 2 164 901 case 3 164 900 case 4 164 900 case 5 a 220NY 729 case 8 a 213 NY iSO 164 900 902 case 6 a 220NY 724 903 case 1 f 171 815 222NY 414 104M 252 burden proof 181 99 904 * 216 NY 673 905 motion case 1 s 214 NY 706 a 220NY 727 s 184 720 case 6 *220NT 759 906 reversal case 7 164 907 case 8 a 220NT 724 case 10 a 221NY 547 case 15 * 214 NT 669 case IS a 219 NT 670 case 19 s 215 NT 697 a 222NY 587 907 case 1 a 212 NY 597 case 6 a 214 NY 697 case 7 a 223NY 537 908 amend case 2 f 164 909 s 164 965 909 case 2 164 case 3 a 220NY case 5 a 219 NY 145 case 7 a 218 NY 725 913 m 219 NY 35 917 case 1 a 221NT 519 case 6 a 213 NT 701 case 7 s 164 789 918 case 6 a 218 NT 199 965 742 9(0 case 1 s 148 S 1117 a 218 NT 744 case 4 a 221NY t 9 1 ( case 1 a 217 NY 684 case 2 a 214 NY 611 case 5 a 221NT 541 case 6 s 166 246 912 case 1 a 220NY 713 case 4 a 220NY 721 920 case 8 a 221NY 528 922 case 4 217 NT case 8 r 212 NT 514 424 520 923 case 5 a 221NT case 6 * 216 NT 672 case 8 s 166 246 925 appeal case 1 * 215 NT 619 929 case 1 a 214 NY 661 930 discbarge case 3 d 166 59 d 170 398 931 case 2 f 174 851 932 case 1 f 164 224 933 case 8 s lOlM 140 935 appeal case 3 * 214 NT 181 do 183 622 743 232 case 6 * 215 NT 704 case 7 * 215 NT 624 941 case 9 s 149 S 1100 a 218 NT 702 case 11 a 221NT 516 case 13 a 219 NT 533 942 case 4 r 214 NT 488 case 7 a 221NY 518 a 221NY 536 513 943 case 1 a 221NY case 4 * 215 NT 686 case 5 a 220NY 752 944 case 6 * 214 NY 60' 945 case 12 r 223NY 948 case 1 a 220NY case 7 a 220NY case 9 a 218 NY 949 case 8 174 a 221NY 950 case 1 £ 164 952 case 8 s 214 NY 953 case 1 a 218 NY case 5 a 221NY case 7 171 954 case 8 a 221NT 956 case 1 214 NY 957 case 3 E 166 172 case 5 r 215 NT case 7 165 958 case 3 s 214 NT 959 motion case 1 * 213 NT case 7 a- 220NT 960 case 10 r 214 NY a 219 NT 963 case 2 s 177 966 case 5 r 218 NT 967 case 1 * 214 NT case 4 * 219 NT case 5 a 222NY case 15 r 217 NY 176 968 case 7 a 22 INT 969 case 4 *221NT case 13 a 221NY 970 case 2 a 222NY 741 630 752 221 98 648 688 534 920 517 712 445 649 461 923 701 737 662 1 494 648 654 635 105 273 553 522 595 VOL. 165 i prob. cause s 150 S ■ 440 95 M 170 4 complaint s 150 S 464 a 214 NY 713 e 170 462 ordin. meaning 226NY 93 8 liability s 150S 497 a 220NT 766 178 956 26 construction s 150 S 906 173 494 44 s 150 S 502 * 215 NT 713 55 divert funds s 151 S 74 f 168 384 not authorize 103M 299 59 conspiracy s 151 S 164 a 215 NT 416 67 title pass s 151 S 96 a 219 NT 601 a 219 NT 601 176 149 a 214 NT 553 142 review s 150 S 480 169 304 152 s 150 S 593 a 219 NY 607 156 transfer stock s 150 S a 215 NY stockholder 181 separately 183 102M 347 70 s 151S 93 m 221NY 425 limited liability 185 119 s 150 S f 166 981 896 89 issue stock s 150 S 668 r 222NY 22 176 400 178 597 69 96 rescission s 150 S 758 f 165 113 f 90 M 421 96 M 260 offer to return 96 M 251 relief do 175 443 equity suit 222NY 380 224NY 58 misrepresentns. do 223NY 185 I 17 strike out s 150 S 719 169 785 denials f 171 298 180 529 181 664 95 M 168 lOOM 410 admitted do 180 537 t28 insufficient s 150 S 709 r 214 NY 662 s 171 423 do 92 M 465 strike out 177 905 135 insurance s 150 S 5R7 274 s 150 S s 166 621 259 423 160 one action s 150 S 662 172 138 174 no interest s 150 S 649 f 175 863 1 80 contract s 150 S 238 165 538 186 s 150 S 329 a 214 NY 664 189 s 151 S 234i r 219 NT 334 202 eq. relief s 151 S 85 f 170 67C 206 recovery B 150 S 525 f 91 M 546 2l9civil service s 150 S 626 r 215 NT 389 221 injunction s 151 S 49 170 432 224 emergency s 151S- 56 182 14 ordinary care 185 870 227 demurrer s 150 S 1056 r 217 NT 235 231 s 151 S 157 m 218 NY 459 not authorize 104M 231 241 S 151 S 144 f 173 902 244 for jury s 150 S 831 f 97 M 20 248 reversal s 150 S 820 f 171 122 252 jurisdiction s 149 S 1118 r 215 NY 209 92 M 135 264 s 150 S 809 s 169 21 270 not apply s 150 S 992 d 96 M 296 276spec. legacy s 150 S 83S f 94 M 4» 279 election s 150 S 828 f 170 898 f 171 35S do 171 357 separation do- 172 769 182 22t f 94 M 489 not rescind d 106M 401 288 s 150 S 1006 s 176 465 298 vacancy s 151 S 261 a 214 NY 216 165 310 mandamus f 166 395 312 « 150 S r 214 NY 94S 308 294 s 150 S 216 NY 911 612 517 714 323 s 151 S 13S a 214 NY 665" 329 s 150 S lOlS a 219 NT 599 343 not guests s 150S 914 185 124 356 s 150 S 314 a 216 NT 642 362 description s 151 S 69 f 165 368 f 171 233 367 penalty s 150 S S8S 215 NT 16a 373 defenses 8 150 S 944 r 222NT 9S 171 509 377 libelous B 150 S 1044 170 46« deceit 170 461 395 s 150 S S2S s 219NY 551 173 796 399 Uability s 150S 1009 183 554 406 negotiablty, s 150 S 1032 99 M 261 412 authority s 150 S 78S t 172 S65 96 M 317 def«n^e lOlM 138 p. facie case f lOlM 133 AUHKFJVIA'TinNS: a, aSirined ; d, distinguished; f, fo) towed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, notes •i cnticiied ; t. limited ; e, explained ; •, overruled ; ■. fame case ; do, dissenting opinion ; p. parallel case ; q, questioned Vols. 165, 166 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Divisidn Siability 104M 449 ease 1 I 150 S I 214 NY case 2 I 214 NY 933 154 629 469 oounterolm. .150 S 995 173 638 476 promotion i 150 S 847 a 218 NY 301 as M 122 506 lea^e court ri50 S 1039 { 170 73 636 ejectment s 151 S 136 171 12 replevin 171 14 640 legal title 3 151S 180 646 151S 768 discovery s 152 S 485 783 3 151 S 1 215 NY 35 801 325 I 221NY 700 burden plaintiff 103M 240 651 s 151 S 349 * 218]SrY 621 prescription 313 „ 8 150S a 222NY 957 612 526 dismissal i 150 S 771 a 216 NY 643 173 712 177 567 „ 151 S 219 NY 597 „ s 151 S I 218 NY 529 KtelouB : 150 S * 218 NY 180 f 181 nioltotiona 183 838 625 46 931 616 533 contract s 150 S a 215 NY 175 1 98 M 843 695 279 345 191 551 11 329 7 363 712 702 forgetlul- ness s 151 S 531 170 233 issume risk d 222NY 442 222NY 566 707flle assignmt 292 547 744 567 787 trust 1 151 S 1 97 M d lOOM 103M charitable use 105M 153 resid. legatee 105M 153 /95 burglary 151 S 482 217 NY 187 799 eviction s 151S 335 r 222NY 47 815 usury s 152 S . 611 compound int. £ 90 M 90 172 487 488 contract t 172 486 £ 174 872 846 allegations --- " 120 92 548 „ t 151S 1 221NY necessary findB. 183 18 s 151 S 175 novation f 98 M _ description d 98 M 7 1 I intent s 151 S 549 57.6 330 332 3 151 S 174 853 s 151 S 216 NY 1 151 S 171 a 216 NY 725 557 dismissal J 150S 265 222NY 154 561 construction i 151 S 307 a 215 NY 335 171 956 one half finger a 216 NY 658 72 1 information i 151S 522 179 525 723no recovery 547 82 i 173 177 573 „ 3 151S a 221NY 595 „ I 150 S 168 605 e 150S a 221NY 609 taxation « 150 S 799 a 215 NY 507 334 30 148 690 891 633 s 151 S 93 M not liable 93 M 726 lihel s 151 S s 174 730 void act 415 592 346 728 858' partition s 151 S 221 m 216 NY 430 862 intervene 3 150 S 784 £ 165 865 594 332 866 conversion s 150 S 969 a 221NY 679 t 165 872 payments due 217 NY 569 872 subject lien s 150 S. 973 t 165 869 8731avrful claim 3 152 S 1120 169 case 9 223NY case 11 223NY 905 case 5 a 218 NY case 6 221NY 908 case 15 a 221NY 909 case 5 a 221NY case 7 * 214 NY case 11 214 NY 910 case 5 r 221NY case 6 a 219NY case 7 m 222NY 172 91 i case 2 a 222NY case 3 214 NY case 4 a 221NY case 10 a 218 NY 9 1 2 motion case 2 218 NY case 4 a 215 NY case 6 a 214 NY a 216 NY s 175 case 7 a 221NY 620 warranty s 151 S t 167 f 90 M 621 „ s 151 S r 219 NY s 151 S f 174 737 5 150S a 321NY 743 s 151S 222NY 755 s 151 S f 171 757 ^ s 152 S a 219 NY 280 437 41 112 349 1022 706 215 568 485 974 500 594 760 change beneficiary 5 152 S a 217 NY f 91 M 97 M 763 „ 152 S 740 532 555 54 655 708 442 660 305 442 620 667 671 739 7 41 650 716 720 325 562 929 motion I'ase 2 r 214 NY case 3 * 214 NY 931 case 3 a 218 NY 932 case 1 222NY 933 case 6 a 222Ny 938 „„ a 218 NY 942 case 4 223NY case 11 a 220 NY 943 case 15 r 220 NY 946 case 2 a 221Ny damages 184 case 3 a 214 NY a 219 NY case 5 a 221NY case 6 a 219 NY 916 right relief case 1 881 s 151 S a 215 NY 883 3 151S 220NY 885 discover s 151 S 3 168 privilege f 92 M 138 42 279 569 3G1 072 235 887 Corp. liable -- - 694 354 506 689 247 33'9 626 larceny - 8 151 S 314 s 215 NY 217 NY 172 502 645 s 151 S r 217 NY for jury r 223NY 902 177 903 case 2 a 221NY case 4 a 220NY 904 case 4 223NY 559 632 545 176 case 8 182 917 case 1 a 214 NY case 2 £ 165 920 order case 2 a 216 NY case 3 a 214 NY 92 1 burden proof case 3 166 case 5 * 214 NY case 6 216 NY case 7 * 216 NY case 8 98 M 927 case 5 a 214 NY case 9 a 220NY 16 707 740 667 561 747 162 126 569 711 666 case 5 r 221NY case 8 216 NT case 12 a 214 NY 984 case 2 r 222NY case 5 a 221NY 986 case 3 222NY case 5 a 221NY case 6 a 221NY case 8 a 220NY case 9 s 214 NY case 12 a 220NY case 13 a 221NY 987 case 2 m 214 NY case 7 218 NY 989 _ * 219 NY 695 case 8 ""^ - 219 NY 558 605 526 594 417 686 715 931 641 641 947move tracks case 3 . 214 NY case 13 a 223NY 949 s 173 case 10 s 222NY a 223NY 950 36 7 _ 221NY case 8 181 case 10 r 228NY 951 case 7 s 150 S 217 NY case 6 218 NY 952 case 2 a 221NY case 3 „ 173 173 970 f 90 H venue 185 183 685 212 89 549 552 467 449 7"45 655 710 674 460 653 587 607 VOL. 166 9 estoppel s 151S a 223NY lOOM usurious 183 lOOM 25 s 151 S * 215 NY 735 401 153 423 154 679 684 401iolder burdn s 151 S 616 95 M 161 43 property s 151 S 618 169 95 94 M 10, 11 not apply 179 300 51 s 151 S s 219 NY m 222Ny 595 549 556 58 suspension 277 692 606 545 439 32 1105 670 727 834 838 54 585 130 66 205 s 151 3 f 91 M dismissal f 168* removal £169 rules board 170 398 jurisdiction 173 55 60 obligation s ISIS 634 183 656 63 three-fifths s 151S 613 64 permissible s 151S 604 a 221Nr 540 r 223NY 217 lOOM 23 jurisdiction 104M 74 s 151S a 221NY 89 E 151 S s 175 560 750 725 660 175 99 conclusions s 151 S 741 91 M 352 construct d 173 754 106 title fee s 151 S 641 a 217 NY 1 745 928 case 5 s 166 95 M 936 119 972 case 1 218 NY 973 case 1 175 978 case 6 * 214 NY case 10 r 219 NY 979 case 4 * 01R NY 575 596 983 649 306 117 5 151S a 223NY 729 591 1 2 1 conversion s 151S 756 s 176 844 178 60 137 counterclm. s 151S 702 lOOM 171 141 damages s 151 S 1045 89 M 612 performance s 168 957 f 89 M 615 Btct. constructn. £ 169 . 43 cancellation . ^^rsJ^^iA^^i^^^^^^^^:^^^^^^^^^^' '""^ 1 case ; q, questioned N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division Vol, 166 £ 171 146 s 151 S 1036 i 172 890 150 eq. powers s 151 S 1072 a 215 NT 700 f 167 916 92 M 129 92 M 336 f 99 M 232 fipcl. limitattxB. 1 178 1881 1 99M 456 statutory 180 403 223NT 83 103M . 188 jurisdiction 183 670 construction 186 530 155 hold over 151S 185 estoppel do 186 796 752 245 1024 713 79 702 368 669 236 s 150S a 221NT 240 „ s 151 S a 215 NT 167 f 91M right aurviyor 93 M 418 no pwr, court 178 712 unity title 180 612 not taxable 180 614 25 1 injunction s 151 S 877 f 165 930 £ 165 931 s 166 895 89 M 512 be£ore court 220 NT 337 r 221NT 342 f 99M not justify 22 INT a 223NY 539 384 s 151S 222NT 549 363 822 685 604 488 164 void s 151 S s 215 NT a 222NT 1 171 subrogation 174 510 impeachment 182 417 175 title free s 151 S 785 169 112 m 218 NT 677 182 boundary fence s 152 S 605 96 M 470 193 conclusive s 151 S 733 £ 168 464 lowest estimate f 168 464 commissioners not bound 178 688 award proper 178 689 203 s 151 S 1027 a 219 NT 482 208 direct verdict s 151 S 170 pleading 172 96 M 262 151 S a 219 NT 264 assignment s 151 S a 222NT d 171 271 151S a 22 INT 274 s 151 S 173 284 s 151 S a 219 NT 297 s 151 S a 218 NT 303 s 151 S a 215 NT 309 s 151S f 176 176 495 350 724 592 210 accounting s 151 S 486 a 170 599 2 1 6 precedents s 151 S 257 f 166 936 99M 369 220 information s 151 S f 166 173 174 statutory i 174 authority 174 224 s 151 S a 216 NT 322 936 191 111 362 194 716 552 610 390 s 151 S a 219 NT 609 617 662 653 a 221NT 716 528 increases s 152 S d 174 m 224NY accounting 184 402 evidence s 151 S 1024 third party a 219 NT 677 f 98M 60 406 certiorari 152 S 295 216 NT 95 166 412 excessive £ 166 413, 414 415 illegal acts s 151S 180 420 s 151S a 224NT 1068 150 1052 671 102 52 40 258 538 judicial s 152 S 113 £ 169 757 justify lOlM 30 550 not enforce s 152 S 18 a 215 NT 626 91 M 72 legisl. power 174 580 91 M 277 ordinance void 607 569 257 600 692 580 246 624 555 310 661 791 694 808 929 946 425 set aside s 152 S 29 £ 167 129 by agreement 105M 282 441 not binding s 151S 1000 177 146, 147 £ 91 M 567 s 149 S s 213 NT 573 s 151 S * 216 NT 278 741 819 705 583 demurrer 3 1 1 no dismissal s 151 S f 98M election 183 850 309 619 3 1 6 injunction s 152 S a 216 NT 56 486 328 s 152 S * 216 NT f 179 163 735 951 342 s 152S a 222NT 37 696 348employment s 152 S 22 a 222NY 551 f 171 958 959 175 285 f 177 774 358not evidence s 152 S 59 176 323 324 362 1 151S 9 443 s 151 S s 152 S a 216 NT £ 167 s 152 S 172 587 151S a 221NT 593 dismissal 977 1105 104 464 discontinued 224NY 208 s 152S 103M 599 s 152 S a 219 NT 456 s 151S a 222NY 1001 705 460 amended s 151 S 1007 * 214 NT 688 170 191 power surrog. 171 471 s 151 S a 220NY 473 s 151 S 219 NT 484 151S 221NY 475 1015 604 105 295 557 705 497 misdemeanr 117 45 409 572 540 438 s 152S 177 lOOM liable 179 law action do 180 not a bar 185 general welfare e 185 440 no consent 185 444 504 s 151 S 1022 a 217 NT 073 507 penalty s 151 S 1075 a 215 NT 172 522 s 152S 65 261 1038 707 681 stay s 152 S £ 169 172 f 93 M 97 M 684 rent s 152 S 92 M liability 185 686 grievance 8 152S 68 221NY 148 688 prohibition s 152 S 470 70 583 902 324 198 52 179 a 217 NT 174 unlawful 186 628 700 694 serv. proc, s 152 S 257 184 619 q 92 M 606 personal service d 92 M 696 s 152 S a 219 NT 706 s 152S a 222NY 607 840 a 222NT 844 8 152 S a 220NT 852 s 151 S a 215 NT exempt £ 179 authority 181 mandamus lOOM provisions 106M 870 s 152S 222NT 882 s 152S *222NY 889 case 1 a 220NY a 221NY 890 case 1 a 215 NY case 2 a 221NY 122 628 720 705 584 585 407 487 245 643 631 553 55' 7 i 8 authority 84 261 61 660 605 jurisdiction s 152 S £ 170 621 s 152S a 221NY 625 s 151 S d 98 M 632 s 152S r 215 NT 261 600 92 699 1084 460 263 434 152S 183 733 s 152 S a 218 NT 739 s 152 S f 167 637 presumptn, s 152 S 46 97 M 563 639 one action 152 S 172 demurrer 99M 183 138 649 relief s 152 S a 215 NT f 166 necessary party 176 802 accounting d 18Q 664 will s 152 S r 215 NT 173 710 640 607 130 561 677 contribute 760 680 681 692 152 S f 166 f 166 a 215 NT 680 s 152 S 98'a 215 NT 763 692 285 557 431 857 338 656 363 860 892 reversal case 5 172 144 103M 496 893 case 9 s 150 S 108 214 NY 666 894 case 2 s-150 S 1090 215 NT 466 762 plead fraud s 152 S f 167 f 169 covenant s 172 237 779 793 766 notice s 152S 175 827 828 779constitutionl s 152 S s 152 S r 215 NT 428 1137 374 782 s 152 S a 220NY 342 640 806 bill partic. s 152 S 175 811 s 152 S a 215 NT 815 s 152S a 222NT trust ceased d 103M 829 party s 152 S 174 co-plaintiff 186 836 s 152 S a 222NY d 168 258 396 445 725 417 516 329 603 307 553 722 895 case 1 221NY case 4 s 151 S 214 NT 896 case 10 218 NT 897 case 2 r 220 NT 680 270 216 34 616 904 case 4 s 170 case 5 a 220NT 905 atty's lien case 1 s 150 S 166 case 3 166 906 case 1 r 223NT case 2 a 221NT 907 case s 150 S 232 739 1108 810 902 56 1106 a 216 NT 513 908 case 4 a 214 NT case 10 a 221NY case 14 a 221NY 623 909 case 3 a 221NY case 7 a 219 NT 554 583 914 case 2 a 215 NT case 3 * 215 NT 633 918 case 9 * 216 NT 742 case 10 * 216 NT case 12 a 219 NT 919 623 742 678 898 case 2 a 219NT case 3 s 150 S 1097 * 216 NT 708 899 case 8 222NT case 11 a 218 NT 900 ease 9 a 221NY 903 case 4 a 215 NT case 1 s 214 NT s 222NY 183 case 5 s 151 S r 215 NT case 6 s 171 case 7 a 219 NT 568 656 670 627 1139 451 659 a 218 NY 746 £ 220 NY 70 case 4 98 M 338 case 9 a 223NY 544 case 10 s 176 6S0 a 221NY 431 920 case 1 s 152 S L105 £ 170 972 223NY 329 case 2 a 221NY 677 case 4 a 221NY 549 case 6 a 222NY 582 921 case 2 172 47 6 case 3 a 22 INT 723 case 5 r 216 NT 83 178 713 case 9 a 221NT 628 922 case 3 r 222NY 34 case 5 * 215 NT 687 case 8 a 22 INT 703 923 case 2 a 218 NT 7fal ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; c, criticised ; 1, limited; e.explained; o, overruled; >, •ameeaw; do, distenting opinion ; p, parallel cue ; q, queitioBea Vols. 166, 167 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — ^Appellate Division 927 ca.se 11 a 222NT 929 case 1 f 166 f 167 Case 2 a 217 NT 935 case 4 s 215 NY a 216 NT 178 936 certiorari case 5 a 215 NT 624 933 914 630 712 720 488 967 case 1 a 221NY case 5 s 151 S 1105 a 217 NT 624 case 8 a 219 NT 968 case a 222NY case 2 a 221NY case 11 a 221NY 635 937 case 2 r 218 NY 938 case 3 f 166 940 case 3 a 215 NT case 5 * 215 NT 941 case 7 s 215 NT a 219 NT 329 938 625 684 720 666 535 649 VOL. 167 I discovery 698 237 942 case 1 r 218 NT 225 944 case 1 a 221NY 698 948 liability s 151S r 221NY 969 case 1 a 222NY case 5 s 217 NT a 222NY 970 case 4 a 222NY case 5 0, 221NY case 7 s 214 NY a 220NY case 10 a 222NY case 11 £ 182 case 14 a 222NY 971 case 2 215 NY case 3 r 214 NY case 7 215 NY 575 664 515 605 706 599 567 s 152 S f 167 91 M 4 transfers s 152 S a 215 NT 167 judgment 167 do 167 preference 171 f 90 M 90 M genl. creditor £ 90 M 272 3 491 152 s 153 S a 219 NY 162 B 152 S 170 517 475 32 146 492 509 )r 511 537 733 144 Jl 407 952 case 16 s 151 S 170 953 case 5 a 218 NT a 224NT 1105 857 746 688 a 222NY 640 954 case 2 a 223NY 561 621 378 32 s 152 S a 215 NY s 171 167 33 certiorari s 152 S 301 a 218 NY 626 do 177 28 duty official 221NY 79 42 new agreemt 592 971 case 3 s 151 S 1140 a 215 NY 621 case 5 a 222NY case 6 * 215 NY r 214 NY case 8 a 221NY 972 case 7 a 223NY 207 674 1038 859 356survivorship 460 611 167 surety s 152 S 1041 93 M no off-set f 98 M 178 „ s 152 S a 215 NY 182 sum. s 152S r 222NY 910 692 pro. 582 249 2(7 jurisdic- tional defect s 152 S 647 f 176 574 223 trespass s 154S 184 s 152 S a 220 NT 281 231 619 406 s 152 S 170 230 usury s 152 S r 222NT f 173 173 640 572 62 estoppel s 152 S 394 218 NT 300 98M 6i 76 mandamus s 152 S 625 a 216 NT 625 219 NT 260 686 378 80 vested gift 691 s 152 S £ 176 90 s 153S r 224NY 585 956 case 1 £ 166 964 a 215 NY 729 957 r 219 NY 597 960 s 151 S 1107 a 215 NY 723 962 case 2 a 223NY 963 case 1 a 222NY case 2 a 217 NY case 3 s 169 a 220 NY case 4 a 220 NY 964 case 3 a 220NY case 5 a 223NY case 6, 7 a 215 NY a 215 .NY 546 618 669 903 348 348 637 549 729 731 787 329 680 429 a 217 NY s 153 S f 91 M 93 M to wife 95 M complete 183 99M cotenants 99M test transfer 183, 716 evidence gift 186 189 609 164 669 418 78 715 469 469 224NY 536 reim1>urse " ~ 179 710 137 541 valid trust s 153 S 216 NY 170 recove^ f 170 365 taxable s 153 S f 91 M 97 M a 217 NY to wife d 95 M cotenancy 180 not taxable ISO 58 069 591 608 78 613 614 686 178 588 695 237 practice « 217 NY s 152 S s 167 180 waiver 104M 242 s 152 S 217 NY 257 s 152 S a 215 NY 259 order s 152 S £ 173 enforcible 10 IM 606 822 243 23 693 826 606 638 708 369 trespass s 152 S d 168 399 s 153 S s 172 4 1 1 power s 153 S do 174 423 s 152 S s 167 £ 178 426 s 152 S 167 428 218 NY 121 s 153 S 173 gift trust 103M 105M resid. 105M 557 s 152S a 221NY 581 s 152 S 173 173 453 438 567 28 legatee 153 796 717 _ 218 NY 672 169 35 726 sidings B 153 S 478 _ 219 NY 227 f 173 77 738 burden piff. s 153 S 374 175 241 liability r 222NY 195 817 678 670 588 by charter 655 964 358 104 appeal s 152S 771 167 112 s 168 555 1 1 3 ultra vires s 151 S 853 £ 175 553 1 1 7 legal rigbt 263 part of est. s 152S 102M 995 57 511 121 689 182 837 579 426 957 581 425 635 s 152 S f 177 591 £ 170 433 deft's neg s 153S 131 179 255 defective brake 179 256 475 s 152 S 1058 a 219 NY 589 902 282 s 152 S 168 discretion t 168 172 £ 92 M burden plaintiff f 92 M 714 separate trial 282 47 712 279 s 153S a 219NY 314 s 153 S a 218 NY 218 NY 324 s 153S r 222NY t 173 175 124 s 152 S f 169 18 565 244 417 419 51 155 479 s 153 S a 217 NY 488 153S 222NY 503 s 153 S a 220 NY 332 indictment 350 949 868 20 1 26 preference s 152 S 833 170 956 185 805 1 40 fix amount s 152 S 938 a 217 NY 604 94 M 40 e 94 M 549 s 153 170 information ,' 173 174 336 notice s 153 S £ 168 174 341 s 153S r 216 NY 125 376 191 111 200 876 297 146 273 879 790 960 747 s 153S r 222NT 774 a 222NT 70 280 669 784' accountable B 153 S 333 r 216 NT £ 167 387 800 604 rescission £ 93 M 179 condition Bale a 218 NT 505 counterclaim 182 334 614 disability a 216 NY 712 222NT rehearing 182 617 „ s 153 S 173 d 177 622 s 216 NT m 223NT 223NT 798 s 153 S r 216 NT 800 s 153 S r 216 NY 801' „ B 153 S r 219 NY 812 B 152 S *219NY 367 451 162 618 44 761 662 342 38T 343 387 78 523 1087 67a 8 1 7 contract B 153 S 40O a 218 NY 64 846 damages s 153 S 327 r 219 NY 415 849 no accord s 153 S 227 f 92 M 562 862proper party 627 easements s 153 S 139 a 216 NY 7 173 21 36 10 632 151 482 520 284 632 a 217 NY 637 „ s 153 S 316 NY 528 show facts s 153 S 554 f 167 535 presumption 168 equality 168 protection f 168 hazardous f 169 171 reimburse 170 349contrib negl s 153 S 49 d 172 323 405 40 C 839 384 42 533 reimburse s 153 S 559 170 42 535 taxable s 153 S 541 216 NY 651 678 300 704 654 lien lost s 153 S 159 a 216 NY 348 do 168 98 99 660 notice s 153S 34 181 692 defendant's rgt. d 182 316 666 cor. errors s 153 S 41 f ni 46 669 compliance s 152S 803 177 343 694 power sale s 153 S 91 M 864 „ B 153S * 223NY 880 s 1S4S_ a 222NY 897 £ 169 on appeal do 182 77S 599 757 294 71S 785 852 1124 722 s 151 S case 3 a 221NT ease 7 s 166 a 219 NY 60S 37 s 152 S a 219 NY £ 98 M nugatory f 220 NY 704 „ s 152 S 840 673 121 231 83^5 w«« probation case 3 * -33.6 NY case 5 r 221NY case '8 a 219 NY case 10 * 216 NY 167 f 168 f 171 632 166 5B8 70S 580 5 517 903 case 4 a 215 NY case 5 a 215 NY 109 706 . 5.JNY lax e a'l m u..a " - ' — _ — " ^ ^XRMREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, toIl'ow«l; r reveried; in, »o*'fi«'^: *•. ,^?»'™**= "•-tinned criticised; 1. limited; e.exp/ained; o, overruled- s. same case ; do, dissentins opinion ; p, parallel case , q, questioneo N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division Vols. 167, 168 136 f lOlM 906 case 5 167 587 908 s 151 S 766 a 217 NY 61 909 deposits case 2 a 222NY 715 case 5 * 215 NT 712 912 case 1 a 222NY 577 case 2 a 2aiNY 578 case 7 s 151 S 1106 a 217 NY 621 913 case 2 « 216 NY 666 914 case 7 s 151 S 1137 a 217 NY 681 929 case 8 a 222NY 579 case 10 220NY 647 931 case 2 172 887 890 915 case 4 a 222NY case 11 a 218 NY 658 597 916 case 1 a 215 NY 620 case 6 £ 167 915 917 case 4 a 222NY 661 920 new order case 2 102M 657 925 case 8 a 218 NY 686 175 577 case 12 a 223NY 554 926 motion case 3 a 220NY 574 case 4 s 216 NY 634 a 219 NY 608 case 7 a 222NY 534 case 9 a 2aiNY 692 927 case 1 a 222NY 547 182 721 case 10 a 220NY 774 case 11 a 220NY 602 928 demurrer case 9 r 216 NY 57 r 216 NY 629 case 10 r 216 NY 57 a 216 NY 726 action No. 1 construed 98 M 675 case 12 a 223NY 536 934 case 10 * 215 NY s 216 NY a 223NY 935 case 9 s 218 NY s 220NY a 221NY 940 case 1 181 t 186 case 2 a 216 NY 942 case 6 * 216 NY case 10 a 219 NY 944 case 9 a 218 NY case 14 a 221NY 945 case 12 f 169 a 215 NY case 13 a 215 NY case 14 a 215 NY 720 710 547 623 566 695 878 900 681 658 670 712 180 514 529 738 957 case 8 a 223NY 539 958 case 4 185 175 case 6 r 219 NY 409 a 219 NY 650 case 11 r 222NY 85 959 pleading case 2 174 179 case 7 a 221NY 719 case 11 a 222NY 638 demurrer 184 474 346 case 7 s 174 67 947 case 1 • 216 NY 666 do 171 974 949 case 1 contract 220 NY 386 case 2 s 152 S 569 a 217 NY 627 t 171 675 no authority f 171 587 950 a 215 NY 629 951 case 2 a 222NY case 4 a 221NY 567 case 5 a 219 NY 648 952 case 7 a 221NY 175 182 295 339 550 715 953 appeal case 2 r 223NY 9 case 5 a 216 NY 646 case 4 a 216 NY 647' case 7 a 219 NY 596 955 case 6 s 152 S 1110 a 217 NY 613 case 9 r 223NY 21 case 10 VOL. 168 3 s 153 S 872 168 968 judicial determ. f 171 517 annul list 185 488, 489 6 r. r. repair a 216 NY 722 f 175 196 12 s 153 S 852 a 218 NY 513 24 error court s 153 S 803 s 170 698 31 jurisdiction s 153S 866 181 298 185 560 41 s 153 S 673 r 220 NY 64 47 consideratn. s 153S 810 181 13 58 em. domain r 216 NY 489 63 suspension s 153 S 926 216 NY 651 f 91 M 130 110 writ 92 M 311 removal f 169 205 no appropriatn. ! 219 NY 262 67 s 153 S 740 a 216 NY 649 75 no appeal s 153S 8 177 903 78 estoppel s 153 S 772 f 96 M 260 83actual notice s 153 S 731 169 122 89by fi.remen s 153S 727 ,102M 415 ^1 may recover s 153S 745 181 95 intransit 3 153S 723 r 223NY 169 100 s 153 S 735 * 216 NY 644 amendmt. valid f 179 534 108 not ivailable i 153 S 893 f 173 455 1 24 review i 153 S 111 172 580 181 893 126 new trial 5 153S 704 r 220NY 504 131 s 153 S 532 * 217 NY 676 1 39 guaranty s 153 S 1075 f 171 519 142 s 153 S 330 172 922 145 chge. venue s 153S 109 d 178 670 158 s 153S 1051 3 176 805 169 tender s 153S 268 176 809 171 s 153 S 929 f 173 984 187 conclusive s 154 S 789 170 25 212 cohabitatn. 153S 256 180 562 184 949 218 error court 3 153 S 549 f 170 371 ballot void / 170 372, 374 f 170 481 176 339 invalid lOlM 716 cross mark 179 619 233 injunction s 153 S 545 r 217 NY 100 f 168 239 on merits t 172 73 172 74 sky sign 174 433 relator right lOOM 574 239 s 153 S 549 r 217 NY 622 on merits £ 172 73 240 practice medicine s 152S 977 177 688, f do 177 ( unlawful 177 689 distinction 177 690 criminal f 177 692 292 pub. policy s 153S 1020 a 225NY 685 180 603 105M 586 illegality 182 471 30 1 conclusive s 154 S 711 a 217 NY 12 taxpayer's suits " M 69 326no authority 153S 1008 £ lOOM 469 329 modified s 153 S 1039 a 224NY 651 p 168 336 bank justified 1-73 489 notice d 176 848 allege prove 184 502 permit transfer 105M 617 change account 105M 619 335 s 153S a 224NY 245 s 153 S a 218 NY 29.T 644 248 s 153 S 42!) f 168 964 253pub. policy s 153 S 895 f 173 744 Cnr court do 177 592 256 review s 153S 876 106M 496 280 separate trial s 153 S 1027 £ 173 350 1039 650 345 reversal s 153 S 879 a 217 NY 119 injunction s 179 356 351 protection s 153 S 499 a 216 NY 284 £ 168 406 equality 168 406 constitutional f 169 180 f 171 96: 370 s 153 S 277 r 215 NY 356 f 168 960 961 £ 168 961 962 £ 168 963 s 170 367 380 revival s 153 S 433 a 216 NY 183 181 732 385 s 153 S 796 a 216 NY 63 388 s 153 S 466 a 220NY 624 396 superint. s 153 S 22 93 M 593, 594 d93 M 595 403 incident s 153 S 505 a 216 NY 544 f 216 NY 549 a 216 NY 763 f 171 68 410 bastardy s 153 S 30 r 216 NY 527 irregularity 95 M lie 421 reimburse s 153 S 221 170 42 injuries f 171 175 529 425 indemnity s 153 S 598 167 619 do 169 455 purpose law f 169 187 f 174 357 judicial do 169 459 evidence f 170 39 173 379 employee do 170 107 94 M 615 cost product ' 173 385 employment 180 55 58- do 184 460 lOlM 671 scope limited 180 35 award do 184 45S 452 s 153 S 1066 172 960 457 s 154S IS a 225NY 610 463 a 217 NY 621- 465 K 153S a 222NY 437 636 466 s 153 S 266 a 219 NY 615 473 assessment 8 153 S 1072 m 217 NY 96 170 915 f 177 934 f: 95 M 354 106M 592 St. openings P8 M 715 liability 180 432 frontage 106M 593 non-assessable 106M 593, 594 479 s 158 S 1069 a 216 NY 738 483 s 154S 54 a 222NY 673 492 jurisdiction s 153S 102.i 220NY 539 494 larceny s 153 S 1045 r 217 NY 204 500 reference s 153 S 997 98 M 376 503 objections s 154 S 85 a 219 NY 76 168 552 512 constnictn. 8 154 S 65 92 M 700 contingencies 92 M 704 gift invalid 97 M 547 f 9911 446 lOOM 74.5 525 to trustee s 153 S 1010 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed ; d, distinguished , f, iollo wed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; c, criticised; 1. limited; e, explained; o, overruled ; s. same c ase : do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case; q, questioned. Vols. 168, 169 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division 172 28 533 amendment s 153 S 104 175 232 SSfi dissolution s 153S 186 542 s 153S a 222NY 552 s 154S a 219NY 213 353 312 578 85 544 695 679 649 607 712 s 154 S a 217 NT 731 s 154 S « 217 NY 735 statutory 8 154 S 652 218 NY 544 39 commns. 877 365 327 553habeas coip 8 153 S a 215 NT 558 „ 8 153 S a 217 NT 569 „ s 153S a 222NY 188 339 154 687 835 675 94 M double f 173 175 186 nullity 186 324 compensation 186 326 746 insurance 60 1 inalienable s 153 S 1041 175 370 371 184 s 153S a 220NY 615 „ B 154 S * 217 NT 800 689 640 373 612 154 S 169 769 use s 154 S 169 782 s 154 S a 220NY 794 s 154S a 222NY 800 154S 1 222NY 558 188 name 391 848 897 case 2 221NY 898 case 1 a 222NY case 2 222NY 900 case 1 * 216 NY 707 case 2 a 217 NY case 3 * 215 NT 475 546 573 658 633 903 case 7 a 219 NY case 8 a 223NY case 10 a 222NY case 12 a 216 NY case 13 a 222NY 618 521 672 639 626 904 case 1 la 215 NY 728 431 case 4 607 216 case 8 180 618 awards s 154 S 351 170 942 175 58 816 jurisdiction 805 3 154 S 217 NT 220NT compensation 220NY 548 624 eviction s 154 S 452 94 M 189 643 reversal s 154S 580 d 185 529 666 liability s 154 S £ 170 not liable 188 not neglect 105M 367 586 543 671 s 154S 180 359 717 674 loss hand s 154 S * 218 NT 183 893 692 164 678 „ s 154 S a 217 NT 685 „ s 154 S a 217 NT 346 688 517 618 688 complaint a 217 NT 619 8 154 S 168 513 685 693 s 154S T 223NY 699 „ B 154 S a 217 NT 542 27 ^21 „„, 599 905 387 600 376 667 626 case 3 a 219 NT case 7 176 910 case 8 a 221NY 726 532 7 188 s 154S 224NY 103M 826 discovery s 154 S 449 168 827 336 negligence 5 154S 468 912 case 8 218 NY case 10 218 NT case 11 a 221NT case 12 a 219 NY r 223NT 343 219 NT 49 39 358 weight of evidence 154S 400 do 179 682 867 r 217 NT 45 870 jurisdiction s 154 S a 217 NT 217 NY 874 notice s 154 S 174 102M 539 70 75 612 297 712 385 amendment case 3 176 841 887 discovery case 2 s 153 S 1139 f 171 424 891 „„ r 216 NT 79 396 adultery 739 case 2 692 173 NT 673 934 669 805 916 iSe 5 216 NY 917 case 8 s 216 NT 218 NT case 9 216 NT 919 case 7 216 NT 921 case 1 a 222NY case 2 222NY 922 a 218 NY 132 705 621 724 947 case 8 a 216 NY .729 £ 169 926 948 taxation case 6 a 216 NT a 216 NT case 9 222NT 321 638 924 case 8 t 169 956 r 215 NT 356 a 222Ny 591 case 4 i 219 NY 181 a 222NY 581 720 753 727 611 913 case s 216 NY a 221NT case 2 a 223NT s 216 NT case 4 a 219 NT case 5 a 215 NT 167 exemption 183 test transfer 183 716 case 6 ' a 221NY case 7 a 216 NT case 9 construed 98 M case 12 178 102M 630 722 542 634 671 447 358 715 714 679 675 466 167 925 case 2 a 220 NT 929 case 2 » 222NY case 3 a 221NY 930 case 6 a 222NY 931 case 9 218 NY 932 case 7 a 216 NY 933 case 8 215 NY 914 case 7 a 216 NT case 11 a 221NY 669 718 701 163 171 616 amount - 154S 175 for jury 179 949 case 5 217 NT ^ase 10 218 NY 950 case 9 216 NY case 12 a 219 NY 951 case 2 a 216 NY case 9 s 179 953 case 1 £ 168 957 case 7 a 220NY a 222NT case 9 • 216 NY *221NY 958 case 1 170 case 11 a 219 NY 960 case 9 s 170 r 215 NY s 171 680 471 312 154 642 964 VOL. I( 154S 223NY 385 522 146 s 154 S a 216 NT 159 B 154 S a 220NY due' 570 278 162 for jury 22 not a crime s 154S 504 177 154, 155 27 accounting s 154 S 509 96 M 127 s 154 S 860 r 220 NT 176 l66contrib. s 154S do 186 170 employee s 154 S 426 do 170 107 38 s 154S r 222NT 420 215 43 insurance s 154 S 519 a 218 NT 18 E 172 965 54 life tenant s 154 S 527 £ 92 M B75 out of income m 219 NT 459 gj^^ 97 M 232 565 60 stipulations 680 571 377 620 367 356 963 727 711 915 compliance case 1 a 221NY 726 case 4 a 222NY 668 case 9 94 M 510 520 98 M 566 142 case 10 ■ 216 NT 665 935 case 1 176 case 2 r 217 NT case 4 a 223NY case 6 * 215 NY case 9 a 216 NY 936 case 6 a 219 NY 939 case 1 219 NY case 2 217 NT 941 case 2 r 216 NY do 168 942 case 2 a 219 NT case 7 s 215 NY case 8 a 219 NT 945 case 14 * 215 NY award 350 541 714 670 471 950 614 612 633 356 356 356 961 case 1 r 215 NY 356 case 2 r 215 NT case 3 215 NT ise 4 215 NT 962 case 1 215 NY 356 case 2 215 NY case 3 215 NT case A r 215 NT s 154S 177 63 3 154 S 171 73 - 154S a 224NT 77 s 154S a 222NT 79 vests lienor 154S 185 221 83 inadmissible s 154 S s 154S f lOOM 356 356 356 963 case 3 170 215 NT case 2 _ 215 NY case 3 215 NY case 4 215NY 965 case 4 a 222NT 968 case 1 a 223NY 367 356 356 356 356 591 538 753 929 700 „,, 470 217 154 S 172 88 - 15BS a 222NY 660 818 648 847 573 804 27 378 neg 884 76 177 employee s 154 S a 217 NT do 170 d 173 accidental 175 £ 176 179 compnsatn, paid 178 399 employment lOlM 671 189 s 154S a 222NT 620 627 107 866 227 126 556 538 194 injunction s 154 S 643 169 611 f 171 901 d 173 497 206 jurisdiction _ 154 S a 223NT 171 154 S a 217 NY ' 725 f 171 267 736 a 220 NT 606 s 220 NT 596 655 498 472 626 915 605 38 45 236 exclusive 423 223 1032 699 107 record title s 154 S 174 174 115 3 154 S s 216 NY r 223NT 120 title s 154S 180 128 „ . 154 S a 218 NT . 154 S 065 172 f 92 M remedy 94 M disability 172 fl76 reversal f 185 lOlM burden pM. 185 355 867 7R1 176 814 661 728 636 239 damages s 154 S 415 a 217 NY 610 £ 177 90, 91 (36 cliar. trust s 154 S 744 a 219 NY 446 trustee's intn 179 272 140 laches s 154S s 183 474 410 915 671 fZ54S a 221NY 849 515 278 no interest 154S "'*** 222Ny 263 285 B 154S m 222NY 840 272 292 probate 806 s 154 S 827 204 r 217 NT 363 Is 175 4*9. ABBREVIATIONS : a. affirmed ; c, criticised; 1, limited: e, nxola.ned d. ^I^^niiiiiS^edi f. followed: ^..««"=d:m modified^- d»^^^^^ o overruled; s. same ,.ase. do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case . q. >i» N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division Vols. 169, 170 95 M 456 295 s 154S 705 a 222NY 204 SOOconstruction s 154 S 708 92 M 595 B 171 130 304 E 154 S 435 a 219 NT 675 310 sp. profits s 154 S 1059 a 218 NY 738 96 M 569 324 new trial s 154 S 675 s 169 344 f 170 932 350 irrelevant s 154 S 481 s 174 211 357 s 154S 809 a 223NY 610 363 B 155 S 25 * 217 NT 701 377 s 154 S 1027 a 220NY 617 388 competency 6 155 S 388 97 M 565 revocation lOOM 228, 230 395 s 155S 310 s 219NY 552 a 224NY 597 423 no appropriation s 155 S 326 f 219 NT 262 430 certiorari s 154 S 1053 r 217 NY 443 443 s 154 S 1089 m 219 NY 67 f 170 938 when title vests f 177 9 450 validity s 155 S 1 r 218 NT 435 (1 173 69 liability 173 70 464 amendment s 153 S 985 170 69 jurisdiction 183 372 472 injuries s 155 S 12 218 NY 318 not hazardous f 178 326 compensation 184 680 479 allegation s 154S 1034 183 606 construction 183 607 492 disbarment s 155 S 459 174 97 502 conversion s 155S 491 178 578 509 blackmail s 155 S 473 *220NY 570 170 727 527 not qualified s 155S 485 178 150 544 disbarment s 155 S 517 174 97 558 s 155 S r 219 NY 418 178 564 s 155 S 605 r 218 NY 234 568 s 155 S 495 r 218 NY 55 571 s 155 S 512 * 217 NY 672 not mandatorv 172 580 review 181 894 577cond, precdt s 155S 442 177 500 58fi lia.bility s 155S 549 222NY 133 595 s 155 S 438 r 218 NT 115 597 recovery s 155 S 423 172 824 pecunry. judgmt f 177 252 602 defense s 155 S 350 f 173 652 607 s 155 S 538 a 218 NT 663 610 civil rights s 155 S 515 a 217 NT 212 613 compensatn s 155 S 524 f 171 3)9 179 565 c. law remedv 175 798 f 95 M 151 liability 102M 175 suits, claims 102M 177 enforcement 102M 180 619 disbarment s 155 S 420 174 97 626 not qualified s 155S 465 f 178 150 638 advertisemt s 155 S 428 175 343 184 827 code 184 826 642 misconduct s 155 S 426 175 284 644 disbarmeni s 156 S 283 a 217 NT 602 174 97 649 mandamus s 155 S 431 r 218 NY 124 656undertakinp 9 155 S 493 d 93 M 323 663 s 155 S 808 f 169 678 678 bribery s 155S 169 r 222NY 347 686 s 155 S a 220NT 176 611 695 s 155 S 564 a 216 NY CT-I f 170 956 704 s 155S r 224NY 757 413 709 liable s 155 S 790 £ 97 M 652 712 s 155 S 773 a 218 NY 675 enforcement 181 687 98 M 349 727 liablfe s 155 S 669 f 97 M 375 73 ( withdrawal s 155S 663 180 ■ 723 7421egis. intent s 155 S 860 94 M 691 hazardous 174 360 d 177 44 d 179 949 construction 180 122 743 s 155S 860 do 181 900 745construction s 155 S 665 a 218 NT 325 170 157 not hazard 173 436 hazardous 174 360 750 negligence s 155 S 633 r 220 NY 153 755 justify s 155S 323 lOlM 30 759 s 155S a 221NY 778 568 765 s 155 S 888 r 220 NY 237 797 s 155S 718 a 224NY 729 802 enforcemt. 8 155S 873 186 300 8l2revers. error S155S 848 186 829 8(4material ev. s 155 S 799 f 173 123 817 recorded f 217 NT 287 a 222NY 662 82fi poison ivy s 155S 854 r 221NY 472 178 352 832 trial' ev. s 155 S 766 a 220NY 564 176 55 176 919 inconsistency do 179 683 838 s 155 S 750 a 218 NY 252 f 173 386 843 infringemt. s 155S 706 a 224XY 670 180 553 corportn, names 179 719 864Iaw reversal s 156S 93 r 222NT 443 887 artifice s 155S 867 179 720 891 administrtn s 155 S 727 * 222NT 712 93 M 625 903 case 2 s 216 NT 631 a 216 NT 717 case 3 a 217 NT 676 case 6 a 216 NT 653 case 10 a 216 NT 713 r 219 NT 394 904 case 4 a 219 NT 647 case 5 a 220NY 560 905 case 2 r 223NY 103 case 6 a 217 NY 179 case 9 * 216 NY 653 182 445 case 10 * 216 NY 101 906 case 2 r 216 NY 650 case 7 a 222NY 663 794 s 155 S 907 case 1 818 s 157 S 442 909 case 3 a 219 NY 911 case 2 * 216 NY case 5 a 219 NY case 6 a 216 NY case 7 a 222NY a 222NY 913 case 5 * 219 NY case 4 r 220 NY 914 case 4 a 222NY case 5 r 220 NY case 12 a 222NT 916 rase 5 s 157 S 9?3 case 1 a 219 NY case 2 a 219 NY 924 case 2 s 181 case 4 a 220NY case 8 a 219 NY 925 case 3 a 223NT case 5 a 216 NT 929 case 9 r 222NT 930 case 2 a 222NT 931 case 7 r 220 NT 933 case 12 a 222NT P34 case 2 a 2'I« NY case 5 a 222NT case 10 n 21R NT case 11 a 222NT 935 case 13 a 222XY 936 '•asp 2 T 219 NY case 4 a 222NT case 11 a 219 NT rase 12 * 217 NT 937 case 5 * 219NT case 11 * 220NY 617 742 613 718 629 630 597 92, 607 180 628 433 667 621 IT 562 653 584 716 210 940 172 case 8 181 941 case 2 a 219 NY 943 a 222NY 956 case 10 a 218 NT 958 case 1 a 216 NY 959 case 2 * 216 NT case 3 ra 217 NT 960 case 10 a 222NT 961 case 1 a 219 NT case 4 216 NT 962 case 2 a 222NT case 4 r 216 NT 963 case 6 a 219 NT case 9 a 222NT 966 case 6 a 219NT 967 case 2 B 217 NT a 218 NT VOL. 170 580 4 liability 235 s 155 S 702 170 94 thirty per cent 181 58 652 640 6 dependence s 155 S 703 f 171 58 f 172 389 179 558 180 52 10 s 155 S r 220 NT 845 225 34 not hazard B 155 S 709if^l'73 «''^lf%5 176 authority 175 hazardous 179 99M new trial lOOM distinction d 179 514 676 631 916 386 436 a 5 472 628 522 363 3 522 37 actuality 602 s 155 S 946 ,f 173 380 449, cost product |£ 173 385 386 not hazard 173 436 ^ T Q hazardous °^'* 174 360 180 734 99M 363 570 ; 1968 case 6 513 a 222NT case 9 a 222NY case 11 563 s 176 case 13 r 220 NT 721 5.98 70 627 343 576 663 660 726 42 equity suit 590 s 156 S f 172 47 526 16 661 71? s 155 S 609 r 220 NT 301 51 s 155 S 532 627 a 217 NT 693 606 59 s 155 S 401 290 a 220XT 603 18 64 s 156S 47 a 222NY 375 78 s 157 S 507 a 22 INT 526 98 s 155 S 694 a 218 NT 422 103 hazardous s 155 S 1(176 a 218 NT 410 f 175 123 d 179 522 d 221NY 403 employees 22 INT 40 b 223XY 86 180 oo persnl. injuries f 179 520 179 521 not hazardous 180 763 compensation 181 673 1 19 death dam. s 155 S 857 r 218 NT 84 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; L followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note t. criticised ; 1, limited ; e. explained ; o. overmled : >, lane case ; do, dissenting' opinion ; p, parallel case ; a« Questioned Vol. 170 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — ^Appellate Division f 171 958 124 liability s 155 S 653 r 217 NY 40 133 "final' s 155 S 638 f 171 57 helper 175 879 138 s 155 S 792 r 218 NY 88 144 5 155 S 642 a 218 NY .708 (47 compensatn s 155 S 909 f 171 960 180 137 (53 injuries s 155 S 761 a 219 NY 581 174 721 175 227 220NY 559 outside scope 176 8, 9 "out of" do 176 12 incidental 224NY 128 employment i 183 169 award 184 821 158 s 155 S 586 B 175 784 164 s 155 S 869 f 171 930 176 s 156 S 32 s 218 NY 693 m 219 NY 537 a 2a0NY 657 205 s 156S 10 r 224NY 436 218 competent evidence s 156S 58 180 509 222 s 155 S 1079 ,f 95 M 500 227 s 156 S 70 f 171 973 county liable 176 943 230 box level s 156S 840 r 222NY 437 265 s 155S 1088 a 225NY 631 267 3 156 S 124 a 218 NY 665 289 s 155 S 905 a 218 NY 704 307 liability s 155 S 879 { 170 803 314 s 155 S f 171 655 922 322 judgment s 155S 918 179 363 324 3 155 S 976 a 216 NY 741 234 s 156 H 44? r 220 NY 326 237 restrictions s 156 H 332 e 172 39fl covenants d 172 399 178 426 334 s 156 S 148 t 172 941 349 s 155S 934 1 222NY 701 358 3 156 S 214 m 216 NY 732 364 elections < 156 S 205 m 216 NY 732 170 359 invalid lOlM 716 illegal ballots 180 854 379 s 155 S 660 a 220 NY 86 t 185 896 395 < 156 S 66 r 217 NY 470 s 177 548 400 revocation 5 155 S 1049 \ 220NY 663 f 171 586 newer lessee do 177 26 could transfer ■221NY 76 iuty official 22iNY 79 405 for jury s 155 S 1064 1 223NY 613 174 315 408 s 156S 81 s 222NY 724 416 disability s 156S 223 99M 292 corptn. names 179 719 liability 184 685 423 s 155 S 950 r 217 NY 183 240 s 156S a 224NY 452trstee liable s 156 S 76 £ 170 458 do 99 M 287 457 as trustee 103M 91 458 s 156 S a 170 80 453 464 s 156 S 120 3 217 NY 660 a 220NY 615 469 authority 3 156 S 538 a 224NY 726 175 628 f 178 925 f 178 927 181 957 476 3 155 S 979 m 216 NY 732 ballot void 176 339 484 legal excuse 1 156 S 179 f 172 968 105M 111 486 demurrer s 156 S 457 174 918 invalid 105M 330 492 s 156S a 224NY 381 640 429 side track 449 3 156 S 198 634 176 31 245 s 156 S 387 r 217 NY 454 439 3 156S 186 m 222NY 642 500 3 156S 357 * 224NY 547 502 recovery s 156S 327 r 224NY 351 504 nuisance ■i 156 S 651 a 224NY 731 d 171 252 proof 186 182 509 s 156S r 224NY 493 512 ? 156 S 468 171 937 519 i 156 S 474 I -218 NY 709 524 easement ^ 156 S 465 96 M 24 531 fraud 5 156 S 63 ■x 225NY 238 95 M 280 533 attorney's services 3 156 S 810 99 M 231 537 suspension 156S 487 178 581 558 relief s 156S 695 a 224NY 668 182 621 565 no return s 156S 575 180 536 571 3 156 S 748 r 218 NY 270 575 156 S 61 a 217 NY 674 578 partition 3 156 S 108 • 218 NY 27 172 969 3 178 899 584 3 156 S 172 415 968 594 contract 3 156 S 647 r 217 NY 432 no action 171 499 discretion 173 540 598 inspection 3 156S 794 182 310 605 lien 3 156S 223NY 553 203 3 1 amendment 3 156S 658 186 329 618 s 156S a 224NY 497 652 j24 easements i 156 S 730 173 21, 23, 38 176 883 182 608 631 . 218 NY 640 136 155 S 1006 217 NY 685 640employment s 155 S 1044 176- 708 discharge 222NY 696 179 813 553 155 S 1059 217 NY 623 dividend 181 555 558 liability ^ 155 S 1036 t 173 92 660 3 156S a 224NY 737 663 665ev. condemn 156S 675 do 181 8S3 368not dischrge 3 156S 601 184 676 674 burden prf. s 156S 637 r 224NY 522 lOOM 491 679 trust funds s 156 S 563 173 490 218 NY 106 bank liable 174 171 error court f 174 172 jury trial 105M 327 686 s 156 S 579 s 218 NY 692 a 219 NT 634 702 s 156 S 671 a 218 NT 749 CO. of Bronx 175 323 707 s lo6S a 225NY 725 s 156 S s 173 718 525 534 790 740 lien filed s 156S 401 106M 673 751 s 156S 582 a 225NY 711 754 3 156S a 224NY 529 683 76 1 enforcement s 156 S 598 f 173 789 injunction £ 177 457 lOOM 175 176 764 S 156 S 509 a 219 NY 589 779 ' 3 155 S 929 a 217 NY 683 780 insurance s 156 S 38 a 218 "NY 29 do 174 865 788 3 156S a 225NY 49 648 802 s 156 S 679 a 219 NY 562 8i i error court s 156S 483 3 181 94 alteration 182 782 818 illegal s 166 S 641 174 707 legal advice 180 496 651 practice law 186 100 830 cr. action s 156S 478 lOlM 104 vested trust lOlM 105 837 3 156 S 648 a 219 NY 656 172 457 844 contract s 156S 619 r 224NY 363 849 s 156 S 892 *220NY 568 870 9f8 s 156 S 713 case 3 a 217 NY 439 a 223NT 626 capacity sue 920 106M 90 case 4 879 demurrer a 220NT 629 3 156S 700 case a 180 547 B 218 NY 624 validity a 222NY 663 182 415 923 case 1 890 a 220NY 606 a 222NY 594 925 case 1 896 a 223NY 590 case 3 a 219 NY 664 926 case 8 897 s 173 837 case 2 case 10 r 222NY -332 a 219 NY 630 case 6 a 222NY 720 927 case 1 case 10 a .217 NY 612 a 219 NT 592 case 3 case 12 r 216 NT 112 a 222NY 693 case 4 case 13 a 216 NT 669 a' 218 NY 567 898 alimony 928 case 7 case 8 * 217 NY 601 94 M 489 case 13 case 10 „ 'a 222NY 716 ■a 222NY 601| 902 929 lease 4 case 6 * 216 NY 724> 222NY 674 903 932 lease 3 case 5 s 177 421 a 222NT 696, 907 mech. 933 l'™,case 7 case 11 „„, r 222NY 290 a 222NY 20i case 10 a 222NY 714 908 1 case 2 ,934 case 1 a 223NY 535 a 219 NY 661 case 4 -, conclusive a 222NY- •531 case 4 a 223NY 545 909 case 8 case 3 180 682 a 222NY 671 935 910 case 7 case 8 a 220 NY 111 a 222NY 696 case 8 case 10 'a. 222NT 664 m 222NY 449 936 911 case 2 case 5 a 216 NY 607 a 216 NY 714 case 3 912 r 222NY case 8 a 222NY 121 ease 2 a 216 NT 652 705 case 11 913 a 222NY 633 case 1 r 222NY case 7 135 case 14 s 216 NT r 222NY 635 149 s 216 NY 7ns a 222NY 598 937 case 1 915 a 219 NY 665 case 5 case 4 a 222NY 633 a 224NY 653 106M 592 case 5 a 217 NY 626 916 case 3 case 6 a 222NY 584 r 219 NY 670 case 7 case 8 a 222NY 609 a 217 NY 638 r 219 NT 439 938 ease 6 917 mandamus a 222NY 707 case 4 case 8 a 217 NT 570 f 177 9 case 6 a 216 NT 723 939 plea bad 98 M 690 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d. distinguished; f. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note c, criticised ; 1, limited; e. explained; o, overruled: s, samecase; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case: q, questionea N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — ^Appellate Division Vols. 170, 171 483 248 344 661 635 728 102 203 555 770 631 475 882 297 940 case 2 a 224NT 942 case 5 a 218 NY case 11 T 222NY case 12 s 217 NT a 220NY 943 case 3 a 220NY 945 case 1 185 946 case 10 s 183 949 case 2 186 case 6 * 216 NY 950 ease 1 * 218 NY case 5 s 174 £ 176 951 case 182 952 case _ * 216 NY 770 case 11 & 12 a 217 NY 607 953 case 1 a 219 NY 954 case 7 r 222NY a 222NT 955 case 2 a 216 NY case 8, 9 a 216 NY 956 case 3 185 case 6 a 216 NY 957 case 4 a 216 NY 959 case 1 * 216 NY dismissal 173 a 219 NY 960 case 2 r 217 NY 962 case 3 a 223NY 966 case 10 178 563, 178 971 case 10 a 218 NY case 12 3 218 NY 975 bribery 'case 5 r 223NY 325 223NY case 9 222NY 975 bond case 14 218 NY 976 case 1 218 NT 978 case 3 217 NY 329 634 15 not conting s 156 S f 175 280 21 s 156 S 41 r 218 NY s 177 notice 183 272 .i-! 681 514 720 668 667 805 674 459 724 581 260 551 565 506 715 216 n03 s 157S 559 a 219NY 53 56 partial dependency s 156S 179 f 180 findg conclusive 218 180 52 s 157 S • 218 NY 66 law question a 220NY s 156S 899 f 171 58 221 amend 171 estoppel 98 M not decisive 224NY 7 1 infection VOL. 17 180 s 157 S — =•. s 219 NY 1027 a 223NY 47 184 s 157S a 224NY 944 711 79 191 for jury s 157S 273 178 34 156S 224NY 197 oral 799 s 157 S 356 s 219 NY 176 287 634 12 s 156 S do 176 72 3 156 S 218 NY 219 NT 86 s 156 S f 174 89 dependent 5 156S 971 180 SO 94 reconsider 875 21 920 619 604 808 902 s 157S 224NY 229 219NY 237 157S 225NY 860 36 88 422 735 - 156S lOOM 98 n. disc. s 156S m 225NY lOOM 108 storage s 156 S 864 f 173 386 173 435 hazardous f 173 516 174 360 not hazardous ( 179 602 I 1 6 validity •i 157 S 171 demurrer r 225NT lOOM 795 53 724 I 20two theories 694 157S 185 123 a 216 NY (40 s 157S a 221NY lability t02M 17 43 subrogatn 157S 42 336 damages ;>21NY 92 48 1 157 S 218 NY 722 349 185 s 156S 624 a 224XY 665 572 demuiTer s 157 8 698 354 not rescind 98 M 344 772 liability s 156S 345 d 106M 364 violation do 178 5J 370 rigbt duty 583 duty ofRcial _ 156S do 182 413 623 373 no power 226 s 156S 179 293 644 310 639 576 363 684 381 validity f 178 09 conclusive 178 398 dizziness d 182 443 385 no review - 157 S 174 388 Corp. _ 157S do 180 357 633 246 quantum proof s 157 S 182 176 657 258 several s 157S 242 177 819 262 liability 1 157 S 177 171 774 406 no surprise s 157 S 440 175 115 bill particulars 278 5 157S J 225NY 71 858 284 179 constructn. 550 288 s 157 S s 175 f 98 M V dgment 179 300 s 157S a 219NY 312 offset s 1S6S 178 98 974 349 29 577 656 s 157 S 725 s 157S 316 bar 5 157 S f 97 M elect remedy „ ^„ , lOlM 289 s 174 good defense „„, 179 566 521 188 102M 178 s liability 102M 175 528 liable s 157 S a 218 NY f 175 175 327iury calendr ^^^ 179^'^^ 641 53?^employee 321 no duty _ 157S 321 127 177 441 157 S L74 75 347 217 NY 466 1050 40 1 580 ultra vires s 157 S 707 r 219 NY 602 176 . - s 157S 148 221NY 588 1038 s 157S 111 r 225NY 83 180 liable 410 624 594 s 157S 225NT 604 set aside 96 M 280 stenog. minutes 186 533 919 607 s 157 S 218 NY 643 power commsr. 175 872 fares 223NY 258 f 176 amend 183 429 sale _ 156S s 182 439 157S 223NY 458 5 157 S . a 220NT 178 460 157 S 218 NY 486 s 158 S s 95 M damages 176 496 objections s 157 S 862 a 219 NY 657 f 173 540 678 514 872 103 337 646 133 709 307 599 534 593 503 equit. lien _ 157S a 224NT 103M 200 450 518 new trial 690 285 447 _ 157 S a 219 NT 157S" ' 900 177 92 353 compensation 681 9 184 547 157S 104M 3 178 limited £ 178 s 157 S 219 NY f 175 916 420 629 84 do 175 630 181 prf. conversion 736 776 79 s 167 S *220NY 642 796 374 a 157 S 1079 __ 219 NT 575 right client 727 177 681 626 professional conduct 181 498 800 s 157 S 756 219 NY 263 intention 181 576, 600 103M: 137 dividend 181 576 545 circumstntl evidence s 157S 523 184 543 653 lien good _ 157S *224XY lOllI 657 157 S 218 NY review lOOM 662 „ s 157 S a 220NY parol 181 565 699 533 212 630 681 evidence 880 674 s 156S a 224NY 680 s 157 S 174 684 s 157 S a 219 NY a 219 NT 1092 692 590 895 649 687 negligence 157S 223XY 700 a 225NY 725 demurrer 943 s 157 S 571 177 181 98 M 723 724 lOOM 20 959 569 810 no equit. jurisdiction s 157S 703 186 798 814 warranty _ 157S 222NY a 225NY 104M 561 414 70 252 834varlance ev. "4 629 852 reply s 157 S 98 M 870 157S 225NY 882 "-nse 1 a 218 NY 883 fase 4 * 217 NY case 7 a 223NY 884 case 9 606 do 181 642 643 887 case 4 a 220NY 740 case 5 277 a 220 NY case 9 a 222NY 647 321 635 710 674 003 593 917 613 137 673 638 889 suit "fq eqnitj 9Sfi 183 5°° accounting III 1°«^ case 7 a 223NY 1067 case 8 160 r 220 NY 627 „„„ 659890 case 7 139 a 218 NY 183 891 lease 10 736 damages ^ 225NY 157 S i 173 reduction L79 948 422 755 justify attachment omission 755 s 157S 897 case 3 566 m 224NY 898 case 2 a 222NY 522 131 707 44 513 717 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; i, followed; r,. reyersedj m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; e, eriticised; 1. limited: e. explained: o, overruled: s. same case: do. dissentine ooinion; p. parallel case: a. Questmidd. Vols. 171, 172 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — ^Appellate Division 903 a 217 NT 680 gOSconcI. precdt case 5 a 223NY case G 523 ease 3 £ 171 927 case 220NY 173 186 case 10 s 176 907 case 3 a 216 NY case 8 1- 217 NY case 9 a 223NY case 12 a 222NY 908 case 1 172 case 2 a 218 NY case 3 a 217 NY case 7 * 217 NY f lOlM case 10 s 218 NY a 224NY 910 case 11 a 217 NY 912 case 1 r 225NY case 2 r 224NY case 7 a 218 NY case 10 a 224NY 9(3 case 3 r 223NY case 4 a 224NY case 5 s 218 NY case 11 * 219 NT 914 case 3 s 218 NY a 222NY case 6 a 224NY 915 ease 5 a 223NY 920 case 2 a 217 NT case 6 a 217 617 12 869 928 case 2 a 218 case 4 98 M 730 358 610 637 538 637 689 663 135 618 662 NY 274 714 715 310 284 528 626 660 929 case 6 a 222NY 932 case 2 a 220NY 935 case 1 r 224NY case 2 r 225NY 225NY 938 case 1 r 22 3 NY 941 case 1 a 220NY case 3 218 NY t 219 NT case 4 i 175 610 619 case 7 a 218 NY case 8 a 223NY case 9 217 NT 955 case 2 a 220NT case 4 * 216 NY case 6 a 224NY 958 case 4 r 218 NY case 5 r 218 NY case 6 218 NY case 9 171 171 do 171 t 175 959 case 1 219 NY 581 629 284 893 942 se 6 177 case 15 217 NY 944 ease 2 * 217 NY case 11 a 223NY 256 313 659 614 675 642 633 6B2 530 532 533 285 221NY 182 case 3 a 218 NY d 175 do 175 aight watcliman 275 200 636 731 732 973 case 1 a 220NY 176 case 11 222NT case 12 r 222NY case 13 219NY 974 case 4 a 220NT case 6 * 217 NY case 8 r 222NY 975 case 1 a 220NY case 3 a 224NT case 6 * 218 NT r 218 NY a 224NY case 7 217 NY 217 NT 620 948 680 VOL. 172 6 remedies 167S 1100 e 181 744 10 exceptions s 157 S 175 reversal 180 recovery 102M 654 622 696 722 611 694 945 case 8 a 217 690 697 546 659 700 692 NT 921 case 3 665 675 679 960 NT 682 922 case 4 a 222NT 924 case 1 r 217 NT case 5 * 218 NT 699 111 620 925- case 1 a 220NY new trial 186 contrib. negl. do 186 75, 76 do 186 77 947 case 8 224NY case 9 224NY case 10 224NY case 11 228NY case 12 222NY 948 case 1 a 225NY case 5 a, 217 NY 949 case 8 a 222NY 951 case 12 218NT 952 case 3 s 222NT case 4 a 219 NT case 9 a 224NT case 10 a 224NT case 14 225NT 581 527 718 729 609 71 690 554 545 703 678 954 case 3 a 224NT case 4 a 224NT do 176 case 4 a 220 NT case 8 218 NT f 174 case 9 223NT 960 case 4 217 NT case 7 173 961 ■ case 2 a 219NT case 3 218 NT case 5 219NT 1 225NT case 7 218 NT 962 ^ case 1 223NY case 10 a 218 NT 963 „ case 2 218 NT Qfifi case 1 a 224NY 968 case 10 a 224NY 970 case 4 a 223NY case 12 £ 173 971 „ case 7 a 225NT case 13 a 222NY case 14 218 NT 66 657 573 648 199 70 677 148 553 686 628 I 239 628 706 976 case 3 r 222NT question fact case 7 a 225NT' case 12 186 case 13 a 223NT 977 case 2 _ 216 NT case 3 160 S 192 s 158S 225NT 928 440 24 18 ultra vires s 157 S f 175 stipulation d 186 sell credit do 186 31 _ 157S a 224NT 955 553 109 112 150 666 433 619 426 579 594 34 competent s 158 S 175 a 218 NT 640 f 175 494 material evid. 177 169 39 error court R 158 S 470 173 914 f 175 295 inapplicable 182 339 46no serverance s 158 S 285 175 691 71 mandamus 158 S 208 ., 218 NT 540 sky sign 174 433 80 novation s 157 S 447 „ 224NT 687 do 181 933 98 M 330 com. law lien 201 counterclm. s 158S 522 177 826 party agreemut. 177 826 22 1 damages s 159 S 257 219 NT 469 227 per. injury s 159S 282 r 224NT 99 230 marginal way s 157 S 768 98 M 352 244illegitimacy s 158 S 413 s 175 940 96 M 166 178 lOOM 30 256 -constructn. s 158S 339 177 801 263 injunction s 160 S 708 219 NT 270 98 M 396 172 444 437 individual surety s 158S 812 225NT 641 182 267 455 impose tarx s 158S 657 103M 357 464 not controlled s 158S 421 179 20 action merits 179 274 residence 98 M 94 „ s 157 S r 220 NY 96 rent 157S 223NT 107 s 158 S f 173 333 1054 118 s 159 S 172 f 96 M lOlM eood faith 172 287 s 158S m 225NT 314 recovery 132 272 157 420 274 743 342 158S 181 324 „ s 158 S a 219 NT 341 = 158S 221NT 20 467 s 159 S 59 a 219 NT 566 declaration 183 408 domicile 185 396 478 s 158 S 774 s 219 NT 546 485 s 158 S 785 m 219 NT 505 406 27 480 355 497 505 509 commission _ 158S 763 104M 643 523 agency s 158 S 840 _ 220 NT 117 not recover : 220 NT 435 authority 181 895 530 s 158S 1100 a 219NT 642 no delivery 103M 452 538 s 158 S 1099 a 219 NT 557 562 s 158 S 661 175 904 949 relief merit 180 842 972 case 2 178 635 524 380 654 623 700 303 f 171 334 56 912 128 car mileage s 158S 287 lOlM 210 1 32hrdn servnt s 158S 271 " 225NT 637 f 179 666 admissible e 179 667 350 1009 s 156 S 260 952 1 42 improper . 158S 10311 158 s 158S a 224NT 200 499 563 eq. action 222 552 375 duty hank s 158 S 1020 175 357 386 dependency s 158S 883 180 51, 52 contributions necessary 180 52 393 construed s 158S 895 178 430 not business 182 704 4 1 3 accrual f 184 895 lOlM 369 s 158 S f 97 M jury trial f 10 IM 810 150 136 566 due schedule 158S 842 179 75 diligence 184 . 132 law question 184 134 569 assumed s 159 S 174 damages 224NT 186 rent s 158 S f 172 s 176 exp. agreement 176 594 knowledge deft 185 774 380 192 590 54 20 73 423 justified s 158 S 532 97 M 268 426 s 158S 225NT 908 210 435power court s 158 S 948 581 motion dismiss s 158 S 98 M defective f 98 M new title 98 M complaint 176 lien good m 225NT lOlM 33 1070 419 420 335 622 142 38 '^^^!lMIJ^^^i^i^f-^^^-^ N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division Vols, 172, 173 597 specially |858 s 158S 183 605 „ s 158S 8 226NY 616 consideratn s 158 S 780 f 173 96 634 waiver B 159 S do 98 M 653 „ s 158 S r 220 NT 670 s 158 S s 153 S 97 M limitation f 175 922!s"l59S 125 r 225NY 0.0866 848s 158S 630 a 224NY 873 s 158 S f 173 f 173 632 417 851 case 11 a 224NY case 12 s 157 S a 220 NY case 13 284 225 796 344 424 810 147 946 725 s 173 1021 980 981 882 trial ev. case 1 s 156 S a 220NY 176 884 s 156 S s 218 NY 885 case 1 a 224NY 317 612 55 877 664 675 joinder 887 case 1 s 159 S 1118 r 224NY 97 M 181 single cause 889 178 466 case 5 98 M 682 683 f 173 690 s 158S a 225NY B 158 S a 220NY 705 s 158S a 225NY 7l36nforcenient s 158 S 220 NY a 225NY 729 arrest unlawful 181 117 7371egis. power * 219 NT 628 s 158 S 1024 173 890 case 658 s 155 S 647 s 219 NT m 224NT case 9 1038 a 217NY 722 891 case 10 241 a 224NY 682 623 893 nuisance ,^,,^ case 3 I33 r 22 3 NY 82 894 case 1 a 222NY case 3 s 156 S * 218 NY case 7 *222NY 174 99 M 740 s 159S a 225NY 780 order s 158 S f 173 condtnl. sale 179 lien 179 rescission 179 784 s 159S a 220NY 793 S 159 S s 173 984 480 76 563 648 736 643 643 644 126 587 169 991 800 accounting s 159S 140 907 r 221NY 8(9 B 159S a 225NY 826 s 159 S a 219 NY 1139 624 407 691 187 668 1124 249 13C' 908 case 2 a 224NY case 6 a 224NY case 9 a 224NY case 11 a 224NY 909 case 5 s 173 173 case 7 s 157 S r 218 NY case 9 s 157 S a 218 NT 912 case 3 »220NT case 5 s 173 case 7 s 156 S a 220 NY case 10 r 224NY 913 case 6 r 221NY case 8 173 case 10 a 219 NY 426 655 682 656 691 692 1127 451 1134 630 567 921 1125 299 421 179 386 210 914 case 6 a 219 NT case 8 719 r 219 NT 1138 915 895 case 6 *224NT case 9 a 223NT 898 case 2 a 224NT case 3 *224NT 694 903 case 1 a 223NT 63i 906 case 1 s 157 S 1119 a 218 NT 173 case 2 s 173 case 12 s 156 S a 220NT case 13 a 224NY 321 960 320 1138 588 242 case 3 178 case 4 818 8 157 S 709 175 case 7 8 158 S 1073 a 219 NY 222 case 9 a 224NY 438 case 4 224NT case 15 a 225NT 916 case 4 a 223NT 917 case 3 219NY 180 919 "~~ case 2 a 218NT 923 case 2 a 219 NY 924 case 4 r 218 NT 925 case a 224NT case 4 a 224NT 927 case 1 a 218NY 929 case 3 554 200 663 684 640 374 241 714 650 218 685 674 705 ;-r case o 641 a 228NY 615 1128 930 567 case 3 a 218 NY 672 s 175 615 502 i 175 case 5 f 172 931 case 1 a 224NY case 3 a 221NY case 5 a 224NT 173 932 case 7 225NT case 14 224NT 933 case 2 a 221NT case 7 179 934 case 8 a 224NT 936 case 3 a 224NT case 5 r 225NT 940 case 6 r 225NT case 9 a 102M 941 case 7 a 224NT 942 case 4 a 225NY case 5 a 224NT 943 case 8 * 218 NT 950 case 1 a 224NT case 2 a 220NY case 3 a 224NY case 6 a 223NY case 7 * 217 NT 951 case 10 a 219 NT 952 case 3 a 218NT 954 case 3 a 219 NT case 10 s 218 NT a 224NT case 11 a 224NT case 12 a 224NT 955 case 1 s 224NT a 225NT case 3 a 225NT case 4 a 22 INT 956 case 6 a 224NT 502 941 717 619 721 914 691 583 489 306 173 62 705 676 635 719 604 700 573 591 698 497 718 671 695 622 680 608 578 957 case 3 a 219 NT case 12 218 NT 960 case 1 a 219 NT 961 case 8 s 218NT 962 case 2 22 INT 965 case 2 219 NT case 4 218 NT 967 case 3 221NY case 4 a 218NT case 5 22 INT 221NT 968 case 6 a 220NT 969 case 1 a 220NY 970 case 2 s 175 case 6 a 219NY 576 619 573 509 569 694 514 652 618 94 593 VOL. 173 residents s 158S 915 219NT 557 99M 588 f 99M 596 99M 611, 612 5 replevin s 158 S 1034 175 183 9 new trial 160 S 45 175 118 15 159 S 173 183 set-off 186 s 159 S a 219NT 173 do 173 set-off 186 57 159S a 225NT 65 claim ev 158S 970 179 513 distinction d 178 178 192 s 159 S f 173 194 s 159S a 225NT 484 8" 565 678 32cnmpensption 478 399 17 31 673 454 657 29 31 263 25l» 450 719 199niust answer s 159 S 405 f 98 M 444 445 no privilege 176 94 214 B 158S a 223NY 217 s 159 S a 220 NT 672 605 439 77 22 1 presumptn, 102M 559 232 s 159S a 224NT 363 582 256 trial judge s 159S 261 180 864 259 B 159S |a 218NY 253 750 75 s 158S a 225NT 79 motion 158S 219NT 85 s 159S 225NT 730 727 708 554 861 510 263 s 159S 560 a 224NT 646 1 00 obligation s 159 S 401 a 219 NT 563 f 99M 642 sufficient 179 36 108 recovery s 159 S 381 s 175 856 181 27 I 13 q. meruit s 158S 399 184 385 228NT 399 |27no violation s 1S9S 435 181 42 penalty do 181 43 129 mech. lien s 158S 158 r 225NT 137 153 s 159S a 224NT 164 s 159 S r 220 NT 285 s 159S a 22SNT 292 s 159S 225NT 305 s 159 S a 220 NT 323 creditor 159S 707 a 225NT 625 180 844 contingency 180 844 valid debt 180 846 840 728 179 assault s 158 S 819 f 178 178 new trial do 179 980 l89information s 159S 23 174 111 385 728 500 653 751 459 327 B 158S 888 a 219NT 585 333 one half finger s 158S 759 177 30 182 287 award 179 570 336 appealable s 158S 617 177 384 one motion cost f 179 863 338 a 22 INT 349 B 159 S 175 503 469 949 355 no defense s 159S 300 178 557 365 s 159S 471 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distingfuished : f. followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, not*; •.criticised; 1, limited; e, eicplained ; o, overruled; s, aamecase; do, dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, quMiioncrf Vol. 173^ N. Y. Supreme Court Reports-^Appellate Division .-.-,». --r-i £_«■ a 225NY 714 528 mun. corpn 788 injunction 912 a 225NY 699 979 a 225NY 634 ..- s 160S 179 s 160S 69 c^se 4 case 9 ,case 12 warranty 377: hazardous a 225NY 180 f 17-7 457 a' 225NY 634 a 219NY 565 *21&NY 585 citWI 13 « 159S 162 177 269 lOOM 175 22Si*Y 72 179 522 do 177 271 ibOM 420 916 949 ease 1 980 case 14 99M 363 lien complete /enforceable case 9 a a20NY 665 case' 5 104M 252 distinction 105M 332 lOOM 420 a' 224NY- 720 98 M 160 a 2'19NY 645 case 16 d 179 522 case 2 case 6 B 219NY 548 * 179 949 534appointment 797 sale 917 S'175 688 a 219NY 587 a 223NY 627 . vacated property case 8 950 case. a 225NY 637 403 s 159 S 1025's 1608" 480 ai 225NY 70,3 1 981 case 1 contrib. negl. « 159 S 887 176 185 f 178 793 a', 218NY 717 a 221NY 580 185 200 a 219 NY 638 Stat, not apply' 918 case 5 176 185 ai09 case 10 a; 225NY 699 982 . 1004 407 security Is 160S 231 s 178 414 . case 5 case 2 a 159S 997 I'OOM 180 r 22SNY 41-0 952 a 221NY 645 a 223NY 624' a 219NY 584 1 9^19 case 1 case 8 'T.'rii',*-®'?*^, 538 jurisdiction' 821 s 173 1002 r 224NY 696 98f 411 s 159S 906!s 160S 834 a: 219NY 562 953 case 1 case 7 s 1S9S 1009 178 663 a 223NY 728 case 8 a 219NY 558 a 219NY 578 182 296 liability 840 a- 221NY 290 a' 223NY case 3 581 case 10 r 219 NY 383 413' contract fi l'59S 1038 f 178 956 8 160S a 221NY 183 506 920 case 7 -175 case 6 951 984 case 1 to -1- U i-f hj JU \/ t*!*^ S 179 403 552 s 159S 676 847 a 225NY case 9 692 a' 2i9NY 582 177 case 5 745 425' trust est. r 225NY 159 s 160 S 306 a 220NY 682 S5^- a 224NY 563 s 159S 264 p 173 855 case 7 case 9 d 181 751 583 f 173 858 921 *219NY 550 r 22SNY 271 distribution 181 608 s 160S 287 r 224NY 302 873 commnnsns fe 160 S 147 case 2 a 224NY 726 case 9 *220NY 680 case 10 a 223NY 626 beneficiaries 224NY 262 intenit d 186 277 432 no award s.M-g s 1047 f 1-76 86 436 eharit, use 610 as penalty s 160 S 616 a 220NY 655 97 M 356 oremature 177 473, 541 do 177 547 damages 186 13 175 176 886 a 224NY 887 case 3 *224NY case 7 365 191 693 575 922 case 10 r 218NY case 12 r 219 NY~ 925 case 1 *224NY 927 case 414 322 730 1 955 case 3 r- 224NY 226 956 case 1 *224NY 546 case 2 and 3 173 526 985 case 1 a 225NY case 8 a 219NY fli, NY 987' 689 602 423 S,159S 1003 105M 153 resid'ry legatee 105M 153 618 s 160 S 590 r 219 NY 252 1 224NY 652 a 224NY 888 case 6 685 a 218NY case 2 s 182 530 849 dase 4 *220NY case 10 a 224NY 591 574 case 7 a 223NY 988 case 4 645 440 othe-p e-v. t 139 S 308 lOOM 438 451 notice « 159 S 920 174 615 633 conclusive s 160S 346 f 178 20 counterclaim 182 656 a 218NY 889 case 8 a 223NY case 12 r 224NY 530 634 56 930 case 3 a 223NY 931 case 3 a 220NY 616 578 ^66 case 15 a 225NY 967 case r 225NY case 4 329 1 469 a 220NY 184 case 5 m 219 NY a 219NY case 11 a'221NY 672 821 326 580 608 463 estoppel B 159S 357 103M 79 personalty 185 467 663 s 160S 326 r 225NY 435 703 decree s 160 S 131 a 22SNY 717 890 case 6 *218NY case 9 ■*219NY case 11 a 224NY 731 560 593 932 case 6 a 218NY case 7 * 218 NY 935 509 691 r 225NY case 5 a 225NY caise 7 r 224NY case 10 r 225NY 323 37 440 118 989 case; 16 a 225NY 990 case 2 679 469 e 159S 720 98 M 529 case 15 case 13 a 219NY 647 . 891 a 225NY, 688 a 224NY 641 case 6 r 224NY 334 709 award Case 3 case 16 case 14 a 225NY 680 a 223NY 566 181 235 a 225NY- 624 a 225NY 683 ease 7 477questn, fact 714 „ 900 936 cage ]' 968 *210NY case 9 549 B 159S 439 s 159 S 641 case 11 a 225NY 639 case 6 r 221NY 409 186 201 a 219 NY 641 s 218NY 697 case 4 a 225NY 641 a 225NY 620 *218NY 699 case 11 9Fl case 1 482 notice 719 a 219NY 205 99M:. 395, 396 a 159S 289 s 159S 1027 902 937 case 4 d 176 848 a 223NY 697 case 3 969 995 ordin. care for jury a 223NY 615 a 221NY 625 case 9 case 1 do 176 849 734 case 9 1* 225NY 268 185 869 497 authority a 218NY 684 905 case 1 s 219NY 550 *221NY 636 970 degree care 185 8761 S--160 S 67 739 for court a 224NY 720 938 repair Bt. case 4 do 176 403 s 1S9S 947 case 12 a 225NY 725 996' case 1 a 220NY 590 906 r 219 NY 286 s 159 S 1117 SOI do 177 592 case 2 971 174 576 »il59 S 1063 a 220NY 728 942- case 1 case 2 98 M 86 T;ai8 NY 578 746 no review case 4 99M 391 r 219NY 359 s 160S 314 r 224NY 449 case 2 case 5 997 512 r 225NY 189 case 6 a 224NY 591 r 219 NY 280 case 15 » 159S 1006 a 224NY 723 a. 220NY 575 aa2SNY 625 752 s 160 S 318 907 945 case 9 972 case 1 1001 515 no award a 219 NY 627 case 2 181 944 r 219 NY 451 case 2 > reo s 2 103M 445 r 219NY 188 1176 86 764 inequitable 946 977 r 225NY 197 hazardous s 159S 258 908 case 2 case 4 case 9 do 176 87 180 667 case 4 f 173 908 r 225NY 454 r 218NY 5S6 *219NY 551 524 773 948 978 1003 E 160S 574 s 159S 1021 910 case 5 case 10 tiase 5 *221NY 633 a 219NY 570 case 8 f 173 950 a 2 23 NY 723 i 222NY 582 lOOM 112 180 9 case- 11 ABUREVIAT10NS: a, affirmed; d^ distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed ; m^- modified; \ disnii6Sed;i n* note; c. criticised; 1, limited; e. explained; o. overruled ; s, ».inu case; do^ dissenting.opimon^ p^, paralle^oase-; q, qnctti(»B«4 ». T. Supreme^ Court Reports— Appellate Division Vol. 174 VOL. 174 t responsible not necessary s 160 S i 175 allegations a2aNY '5 s 160 S s 175 23 8 160S r 225NY 29 s 160S *2a5NY 357 438 380 3?5 934 179 254 3 160S a 220NY 265 s 160 S a 220NY 247 76 341 627 938 297 677 389 692 442' s 160S a 219NY 281 discharge 172 629 39 s 160S a 219 NY next of kin 184 793 44 negligence s 159S 249 178 68-2 48 voidable s 160S 2.56 184 256 86 duty court _ 160 S \ 222NY do 174 287 5 160S a 222NY 291 s 160S a 225NY 427 537 291 431 538 894 561' 2^1 621 446 authority s 161S 384 180 445 must prove 103M 580 103M 674 463 iustificatn. s 161S 356 106M 162, 163 office innuendo 226NY 91 470 new trial s 160S 459 a 220NY 597 f 177 895 a 220NY i lOlM 674 s 161S a 220NY 298 state taoc s 160S 96 179 395 jurisdiction 179 396 304 apply rents 159S' lOOM 88 s 160S a 223NY ro2 s 160S *219NY 106 s 160S a 226NY (08 *220NY d 178 113 s 160S m 221NY 118 s 160S a 220NY 131 s 160S a. 22 3 NY a 223NY (44 s 160S a 221NY t 176 (52 s 160S a 223NY 273 523 266 692 931 655 916 623 760 29 93 T 268 478 taxpayer's suit s 160 S 542 225NY 649 99 M 69 484 obligation _ 160S lOOM 306 s 160S 176 3(0 160S 223NY 3(3' s 160S a 223NY 344 s 160S a 219NY 448 716 947 946 38T 235 474 628 762 637 353 employee s 160 S 791 176 133 134 959 593 553 643 643 - 177 rehearing- 182 360 s 160 S f 176 57 451 37 ( ownership s 161S lOOM 378 s 161S 942: a 221NY 502 949 69S 398 s 159S .1 221NY 403 s 160S 225NY (60 adequate notice 159S 954 408 no alimony 8l48' 773 d 176 distinction 184 I8(brdn. servn<11 s 159S 1031 f 179 666 parol evidence e 179 6-67' 1 85 constitutnl. s 160S 3:6-2: r 219NY 44 *219NY 5-43! 200 inadimissble s 160S 179 938 661 140 1016 678 685 take risk s 161S 9L_ 105M 731 694 corporatns, s 162S 70 177 690 221NY 481 r 221NY 483 702 violation s 162 S 56 do 174 701 corpn. agent s 158S 183 491 s 160S r 226NT 518 award s 160S r 219NY 520 s 160 S s 162 S 534 s 161S a 219NY 539 s 161S a 220NY 580 m 221NY 569 s 160S a 220NY 1129 656 445 13 64 328 1137 996 120 435 203 679 295 902 675 174 732 s 161S a 220NY 736 s 161S 220NY 743 161S 220NY 746 s 161S 225NY 759 s 161S a 225NY o^n 574 authorize its s 161 S 771 ^ f 181 912 98 M 87 886 271 554 267 720 544 706 160S 182 967 324 424 no action s 171S 104M 786 170 160 681 434 s 161S a 220NY pers. service 103M 414 strctly followed 104M 5 440 do busin«ss 9124 s 161S 193. 105M 697 557 689 484 660 439 654 494 602 469 675 767 no costs s 161S a 225NY 77R arrest .s 161S 182 786 s 161S *220NY 795 s 161 S i 98 M 634 305 622 502 551 653 f 99M; 858 case 1 _. 224NY case 3 a 219NY case 7 223NY 860 case 9 a 221NY 865 case 2 *224NY case 5 a 225NY case 8 a 221NY 866 case 2- a 220NY case 4 a 220 NY 868 case 5 a 219NY 177 869 case 4 220NY 87 ( case 13 .. aasNY case 16 a 219NY 872 case 2 a 223NY case 3 lOlM ease 6 a 225NY case 10 a 225NY case 11 a 223NY 502 641 603 620 604 575 629 651 584 259 691 420 58 ( interest s 161 S 326 176 883 after maturity 168S 517 equitable 180 727 f 180 909 f 180 paid up class 180 720 ineffective 180 amended 180 185 "a" shares do 185 39 cancel shares do 185 31 weight evidence son no power s 161S a 220NY s 223NY 179 694 690 362 610 728 910 911 724 722 29 do 185 608 s 161S *222NY 66 ( s 161S a 223NY 40 718 521 196 638 665 defense good 95|s- 161S RI3 mutualitv 103M 62 838 proof 161S ,J6 amendment 186 853 case r 219NY 855 case 2 a 219NY 856 case 3 a 223NY case 7 s 219NY a 225NY case 9 a 224NY 857d6livery chk case 5 98 M case 10 173 case 11 jurisdiction 873 case 3 s 219NY a 225NY 878 case 4 a 220NY 882 case 2 a 225NY case 5 a 219NY 4-89 181 182 192 632 619 560 682 731 625 237 885 sufficiency case 4 176 886 case 11 a 223NY 912 635 895 s 179 case 2 219NY case 3 equity owner 179 10 897 case 1 a 219NY 377 898 case 1 225NY 900 case 221NY case 3 a 225NY case 12 184 222 682 559 342 727 480 631 695 174 643 628 693 635 622 583 660 641 90 ( compensatn case 1 r 220NY case 2 176 219NY case 3 a 219NY case 10 *220NY 932 case 5 a 221NY case 8 a 220NY 933 case 9 a 220NY s 223NY 180 935 judges disqualified case 1 176 case 2 _ 223NY do 184 f 184 624 592 565 153 27 376 572 460 918 71 579 646 591 170 623 78 645 887 jurisdiction case 2 102M 890 case 6 a 225NY 891 case 4 a 221NY 892 case 6 a 225NY 894 case 9 a 225NY 902 case 4 r 226NY case 8 225NY case 9 225NY 903 case 4 '219NY 904 case 9 a 219NY 907 case s 219NY a 225NY 908 case 1 a 220NY case 2 & a 220NY 917 case 3 s 219NY a 223NY 9(9 case 8 219«Y 920 case *-220NY 922 case 9 a 223NY t 177 923 case 3 a- 225NY 924 case 1 a 22'5NY 925 case 1 1.75 642 642 718 644 622 619 547 635 600 622 596 572 596 740 646 912 926 new trial case 2 175 927 case *219NY 930 case 5 f 178 118 932 ABIiREVIATIONS-: a, affirmed; d; distinguished; f, foUowed; r, reversed; tu, modified-; *, dismissed; n, note C-. criticised: I, limited; ev-explained;>o. overruled; s, sa-mecase; do, dissenting^ opinion: p. parallel case; q. 181 443 17 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division Vols, 175, 176 97 1 case 1 VOL. 176 175 contract B 177 896 668 order 892 921 case 1 182 598 s 162S 581 f 176 671 case 3 r 221NY 162 case 3 1 225NY 221 412 177 89C r 221NY 589 a 220NY 684 s 162S 408 practl. constn. s 162S 999 681 bill partic. case 7 a 221NY 496 a 221NY 601 325NY 571 a 221NY 490 s 163S 819 a 225NY 730 974 notice 182 244 923 case 1 case 2 6 accidental inj 186 185 606 893 s 220NY 781 a 221NY 593, s 162S 313 s 162S 544 697 artifice case 2 a 223NY 644 182 445 s 220NY 652 418 s 163S 1059 f 181 950 case 2 975 af&rmance a 220NY 773 s 164S 71 * 221NY 637 s 179 251 case 2 186 846 178 24 s 162S 1032 179 720 894 case 9 r 221NY 127 a 221NY 598 case 6 a 225NY 697 case 3 13 failure 187 equity court 726 a 220NY 399 case 13 a 221NY 641s 162S 337 s 162 S 543 f 181 202 s 163S 1019 a 221NY 607 case 6 |184 699 s 176 186 s 176 725 897 *220NY "^^Uo 178 24 430 case 2 924 case 10 123 presumption s 163S 640 729 appeal * 221NY 576 case 8 *220NY 572 181 143 193 s 162S 613 a 225NY 727 s 163S 1034 f 176 732 case 4 a 221NY 599 m 221NT 276 976 28 *224NY 543 455 prove facts 925 case 1 case 9 s 162S 520 s 162S 828 733 spl. session 898 a 220NY 644 a 220NY 594 a 220NY 674 209 damages s 162 S 1145 1 176 786 aifirmative ev. 182 649 case 2 a 221NY 510 102M 572 980 40 f 176 216 176 786 735 relief 929 case 1 case 2 s 162S 355 attachment 180 554 899 case 14 s 177 s 177 897 s 220NY r 225NY 571 104 r 220NY 438 182 860 460 for jury s 163S 562 747 election 939 case 5 178 453 case 11 48 weigth of ev. 2l7highest rate 179 836 s 163S 1022 r 221NY 15 s 220NY 759 s 161 S 186 s 162 S 972 181 22 900 case 6 176 378 a 220NY 770 470 consideration case 2 * 223NY 621 981 f 176 520 s 163S 505 181 23 s 224NY 542 case 8 s 220NY 622 a 225NY 696 984 duty atty. 58 validity s 162S 799 r 221NY 611 178 366 80 s 162S 505 a 226NY Mem 1 230 s 162S 1026 a 223NY 653 liability 185 658 servant's work 186 435 a 223NY 631 473 new trial s 162S 432 f 178' 934 77 1 demurrer s 163S 1119 180 413 case 3 s 177 901 case 7 952 930 case 3 a 221NY 934 case 502 1 case 1 176 986 case 5 a 223NY case 10 r 221NY 10411 case 11 a 223NY 901 490 negligent s 163S 553 774 liability 179 776 r 224NY r 225NY 114 294 f 177 case 5 s 178 895 163 716 190 663 701 87 award 3 162S 225 184 821 91 s 162S 291 *221NY 574 241 s 163S 114 a 225NY 543 250 s 162S 1081 s 224NY 601 a 225NT 506 f -183 471 new trial f 186 71 500 s 163S 252 f 181 931 785 coercion s 163S 426 180 205 weight of evid. 185 147 807 rule tender s 163S 833 906 case 2 a 220NY 908 case 6 a 222NY case 11 774 531 935 case 7 * 223NY 936 case 4 s 178 679 311 fl62S 653'285 ., 225NY 713 s 1^|3S ^ J 503 E 179 58 s 222NY 520 s 163S 263 *221NY 625 829 s 163S 516 case 15 * 220NY 702 937 case 2 a 225NY 713 512 a 221NY 581 909 domiciled case 5 '""^on ,„^ 315 dismissal s 163S 239 case 5 s 178 931 s 162S 475 ? i62q 444 f 180 934 f J^f It! a 223NY 709 840 inspection s 163S 261 183 185 4o; 39!i 939 517 186 908 106M 444 case 7 case 8 ■^ 106 no power 318 s 163S 309 a 224NY 590 s 221NY 574 s 162 S 467 s 162S 443 a 221NY 611 case 9 176 597 *220NY 704 842 ratify a 223NY 633 940 second offender 520 for jury case 5 124 award 103M 333 s 163S 498 s Ibati -^ri 911 r 221NY 005 s 162S 603 first offender a 223NY 698 a aasJN)! vaa case 4 case 10 182 126 103M 334 182 316 lOlM 732 * 222NY 644 a 222NY 537 183 500 iesentence no authority case 11 (act question hg2 880 541 directors 183 442 912 a 224NY 669 183 501 s 163S 484 case 8 ■V" " ,„_ 1326 contingency lOlM 306 850 mark value s 221NY 333 941 employee 127 s 160 S 1029 s 163S 974 102M 132 3 162S 385 181 396 577 authority 182 481 913 a 221NT 492 f^'gg jj igg 3 163S 917 case 1 942 accid. injury 180 445 867 fact a 22oNY 720 a 221NY 656 182 445 343 question case 4 s 1B3S 51 588 reversal s 163S 786 r 220NY 373 943 128 give notice r 220NY 337 f 170 . 597 179 155 case 2 s 162S 288: dissatisfaction 914 a 223NY 032 180 140 ^49 302 coustitutnl. 185 132 case 3 *220NY 770 s 163S 910 * 221NY 635 946 1 3 1 employee f lOOM 449 882 case 8 case 13 r 221NY 28 352 storing case 2 f 176 914 f 180 919 3 162S 244 goods 620 acceptance * 220NY 716 case 10 r 226NY 61 i m 57 s 162S 911 a 225NY 712 3 163S 382; 1 179 370,883 reduction | * 221NY 575 947 141 guardian 99M 563 case 7 915 case 2 s 161S 1100 637 next kin 180 729 case 3 s 177 049 !■ 220NY 532 371 3 163S 873 distribution a 221NY 12 case 11 s 162S 792 r 222NY 222 losses 185 353 * 221NY 634 '45 „ „„ a 224NY 686 f 177 843 do 185 39 case 5 3 161S 1029 a 221NY 64? 949 1 223NY 649 338 mandamus 657 885 186 107 case 3 r 219NY 195 s 163S 559 case 3 186 11] m 221NY 389 166 take risk 1 225NY 724 r 220NY 123 3 161S 1094 393 case 6 916 960 a 225NY 697 s 162S 1091 660 valid * 220NY 568 case 3 case 5 - 1G5M 731 s 164S 707 agyement ^ a 221NY 60C r 221NY 60S '" violations 1 ~ -, 163S 214| 887 105M 732I407 1 178 1801 case 9 918 case 1 SR2 '3 162S IO35I 1 a 226NY 57 a 225NY- 721 'r221NY 657 ABBRE\'I,\T10NS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f. lollo\\ed: r. reversed; fn, modified; *, dismissed;vri, rinte; c, criticised: 1, limitt-r). e. explained: o. overruled: s. same ca-^e; do. JUsf^ntina ooinionin." parallel case; q. mesiioned Vols, 177, 178 N. Y. 'Stpareme Cxiur>t R^orts — A^pel]£bt« Division VOL. 177 I a 221NT 600 256 s 163S a a23NY 16 a 221NY 262 expectancy 570 suspension 585 18 substantial rights r 221NY 29 award ITS 179 finger lost 182 41 s 163S a 22111T * 'employee' do 184 71 265 not apply s 165S 184 320 570 28'7 •■S8« ■34-4 47 commission s 163S 185 56 award s 163S 182 57- „ B 163S a 221NY "wages" f 184 688 684 944 907 904 491 631 69 accidental 179 559 186 192 73 use hand 179 414 earning capac 179 do 181 award e 183 76 „ s 164S r 221NT 107 citizen 102M liability do 183 within the act 571 914 164 37 585 1*3 899 565 . 997 s 164S 699 a 224NY s 164S 223NY 1 a 221NY 513 102M 653 perpetuities 105M 276 munic. -225NY 9a9 578 Corp. 185 296 no equit. jurisdiction '164S 626 186 798 36 1 no damages 180 457 remedy 103M 316 limit rule 103M 31'6 374 a 221NY 378 „ s 166S a 220NY 380 a 224NY s 177 385 _ a 223NY 602 "I accept" s 164S 303. 184 494 610 cause actn. 527 2'70 661 132 487 630 938 707 403 reversal _ 177 liability 180 eviction 105M 410 544 193 415 no contract s 164S 441 103M 173 438 insur. co 734 f^r j^^y s 164S 269 „ Tfiis I 346 184 '43 „ s 163S a 224NY a 221NY 158 equity suit s 163S 595 183 139 162 pull- policy 682 626 560 590 102M 444 164S 222NY s 163S 181 comity 183 citizen 106M estoppel 106M a 221NY 192 * 221NY f 177 208 a 223NY 225 a 221NY 246 new trial f 177 895 566 623 758 186 188 646 617 928 670 451 reference s 164S 380 182 476 105M 456 contract s 164S 289 d 102M 391 483 liability s 164S 206 102M 416 489 examinatn. s 164S S'Se 179 663 541 885 603 case 10 7 a 225NY 62 _ 223NY lien 105M 887 602 case 1 222NY case 2 221NY case 7 r 221NY 193 645 890 case 2 221NY 891 „ s 163S 224NY s 164S 184 624 164S 222NY 647 s 164S 223NY 656 s 164S .222NY 576 519 597 369 622 894 reargument case 4 1'77 ise 7 223NY 898 700 priority 102M; 273 713 depositions s 164S 865 179 616 722 allegations 181 338 725 „ s 164S a 224NY 753 629 728 damages r 221NY 206 s 164S lOIM 686 650 „,n755 owners 310 s 164S 892 184 225 pass by will 184 21 760 21 s 177 501 s 164S a 223NY 473 706 532 not restrict 178 428 amend £ 178 913 536 damages 164S d 186 547 s 163S a 223NY 551 a 221NY 466 12 305 575 786 s 165S a 223NY 803 221NY 831 a 221NY s 164S a 223NY 853 s 164S c 22 3 NY 226 766 154 • 563 662 643 963 -509 992 708 921 case 7 715 lOOM 106M 526 668 396 577 1133 618, 291 722 927 case 8 s'178 928 ease 7 221NY case 8 221NY case 12 s 177 T 2201fY 929 vase 9 s 178 i932 case !1 * i220NY case 2 a 221NY 899 case 2 221NY case 6 a sag NY case 10 s 223NY 900 case 3 m 223NY 901 case 5 * 221NY 618 634 608 660 case 2 :221NY case 4 mi. 934 case 5 * ;a21NY case 9 181 -271 653 903 error court case 3 180 569 87 1 taxation a 221NY 612 do 179 ■ 8 market value 103M 383 case 4 1 222NY 884 , case 2 629 a, 225NY 663 608 724 904 case 2 * ^aONY 906 case 2 222NY 907 easel a 224NY case 2 s 223NY case 4 a 222NY case 6 r 223NY case 7 a 225NY 908 case 1 *224NY 9[0 construe will case 10 a 221NY 913 case 6 * 220NY 914 case 8 a 221NY 917 case 2 a 224NY 918 case 2 a 221NY case 8 a 221NY 764 255 658 660 1,' 608 481 617 381 ca^e '12 a 223NT 677 56952 case 1 a 224NY 899 941 725 907 764 406 572 954 936 new trial case 4 184 589 ■case 8 223NY 183 :case 10 T .-221N(Y case 11 221NY 939 case 9 222NY case 14 a 321NY 940 case 7 a ,222NY 941 :case 6 case 9 177 944 case r SzeNY 722 946 case 222NY case 4 r 224NY 572 165 664 518 273 40 928 109 589 129 762 614 580 649 584 947 case 13 a 2211SrY 948 case 11 221NY 949 damages case 11 178 221NY case 12 a 222NY mandamus 180 486 302 594 529 456 950 case 4 a 225NY 951 case 6 a 223NY 726 601 541 4 S-164S a 223NY 12 damages s 164S s 186 19 a 221NY 370 27 a 221NY 662 special sessions 182 649 31 s 164S a 223NY 33 .illegations 102M «2 'a'221NY 190 s 166S 226NY VOL. 178 967 703 920 17 200 667 463 616 165 101 ('Invest trustee a '222NY 533 181 563 102M 281 life benefi'ciary 181 662 surplus 181 571 '677 value investmt. I-81 472 "profits" 22^4NY 224NY l'46 s 166S * 222NY 151 a 221NY 173 s 178 254 257 102 523 930 1 76>-stkholders. s 164S 1033 182 46 180 s 165S a 224NY 143 564 182 jurisdiction 165S 298 _ 222NY 564 224NY 7 103M 188 interpretation 103M 196 reverse decree 186 289. relief 186 296 duty court 186 205 s 16PS a ?22NY 228 s 165S s 223NY 236 vehicle 8 164S 1023 180 819 243 commission 455 187 546 20s 556 s 1R4S s 184 s 102M E 102M s 102M 1024 647 277 278 304 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affinned; d, dUtincuished : f. followed; r. revened; m, modified; *. diamiaied; n. Bate; c. criticised; 1, limited : e, explained; o, overruled; s, same Casr; do. dissenting opinion ; p, parallel case ; q, questioned. N. Y. Supr^Be (Court Kepoi:ts^-AppeUa1je Division Vols, 178, 179 251 423 185 15. >928 VOL. 179 185 9461535 extraordny. * 221NY 652 s "165S 57' case 1 term r 225NY 39C 845 a 222NY 5361 1 3-55 s 166S 631 267 s 166S 32a case 2 s 166S 126 fi 166S 491 do 184 840 s 165S 23C 450 one hoU 222NY 621 s 221NY 197|a 233NY lla 222NY 650|prohibition ^;221NT 577 .s 1658 51;7 184 830, SS* * 223NY 565 862 930 13 364 damages 270 quit work 104M 12C [S 166S 254 case 5 s 166S 338|s 166S 494I55I s 16SS <46S IS 223NY 655 a 225NY Mem. f 179 92f 185 60l« 166S 836 104M 46G 458 default a 223NY 622 IJ a 222NY «4S intent s 165S 504 i case 8 39 s 166S 18£ 387 106M: 55 ■184 17-5 r675 crime a 221NY 62] s 166S 24: 555 not limite* damages fi 166S 17a case 10 a 222NY 66f a 221NY 64; * 166S 874 292 106M 440 183 879 a 221NY 585 Uf U Ld tj i,^ X. \J\J\, s 178 94e do 182 144 s 165S '3 I 2^1NT 702 507 884 931 case 1 60 complaint 395 560aecidntl inj. .s 165S 608 * 233NY 661 s 166S 92 r 223NY 22' s 166S 849 2S8 a 221NY 639 a 223NY ■ 637 179 663 r 223NY 633 182 445 s 1658 234 no knowledge 934 affidavits a 223NT 711 !183 228 888 case 1 pase 3 lOlM 559 405 567 violation 301 535 liability r 223NY 490 178 934 73 burden deft s 166S 71 r 224NY 503 s 1668 858 104M 421 s 165S 436 S 165S 780 889 case 4 935 injunction s 166S 110 minors s 179 962 lOlM 143 case 9 185 607 412 loss fingers 104M 428 p. facie case a 223NY 612 181 172 s 166S 97 not a bar §"6 „^ 10 IM 13S case 10 75 law question e 183 164 185 438 * 221NY 622 550 a 221NY 603 937 case 7 s 166S 94 184 134 general welfare 185 449 309 binding s 165S «Bi5 , a 223NY 578 420 injuries prohibited s 165S 495 a 224NT 644 891 80 s'165S 104£ 185 441 d 183 123 case 3 938 case 1 s 166S 221 r 222NY 4 no consent 1^3 126 614 s 165S 566 a 221NY s 221NY 332 333 m 222NY 337 a 223NY 599 421 „ 185 444 319 award a 222NY 525 * 221NY 601 941 112 s 165S 970 593 s 1648 «69 case 9 s 166S 214 a 223NY 671 s 1668 878 J79 570 660 venue 894 a ,223NY 718 a 223NY 726 f 179 96« 'dnger lost s 165S 829 case 2 431 adjudicated 182 287 183 576 a 221NY 610 S42 127 s 165S 980 600 hazardous Vi plialange case 1 s 165S 821 184 704 6 1668 873 T85 74 690 895 case 1 8 180 194 *225NY 206 180 734 a 222NY 543 a 221NY 659 case 3 442 venue 331 s 164S 810 706 s 165S 847 case 5 a 221NY 658 a 223NY case 6 600 135 implied contract s 165S 990 185 575 607 foreclosure s 168S 702 f 178 944 896 case 2 * 221NY case 5 * 221NY a 221NY * 321NY 585 s 165S 247 r 223NY 347 342 s 165S 1097 T 223NT 83 f 179 949 s 222NT 576 * 222NY 555 709 taxable transfer s 165S 887 180 614 530 596 597 case 7 a 221NY 943 case 6 a 223NY 660 704 185 309 142 s 166S 298 a-233NY 725 453 jurisdiction s 165S 1017 * 222NY 530 f 181 915 183 670 103M 188 r 223NY 664 610 conclusive s 1668 lOOS d 181 198 compliance 345 compensatn s 164S 790 102M 178 award 184 818 104M: 120 716 906 case 3 * 221NY 543 case 9 * 221NY case 11 630 r72 award s 1663 429 r 222NY 139 103M: 618 f 181 962 618 s 165S *in a 222NY 539 179 217 219 s 165S 960 s 167S 72 o J-UMkJ v ^ A. * 221NY 367 907 944 case ] reargument 183 380 a 222NY 646 *221NY 688 347 appliance s 164S 775 720 s 165S 145 case 5 s 178 901 s 222NY 711 private • easemt. 183 382 481 s 165S 967 62 1 unprof esBuL s 1678 loy 179 549 180 717 aflHdavit sufSc. 908 assault case 6 946 award case -10 2 1 9 enf orcemnl a 222NY 363 a 222NY 651 1^ 28B 350 unforseen s 164S 767 183 241 2.26NY 25 182 907 s 166S 463 r 223NY 199 486 648 ten years s 1678 8t 224NT 21 724 a 223NY 651 a 222NY 549 949 case 2 223NY 202 s 165S 938 a 223NY 690 r 222N'Y 35S 362 void act 909 case 1 3 179 962 232over valuatn s 166S 480 653 s 164S 1037 759 a 221NY 313 case 3 489 s 167S 8S 182 157 s 166S 217 ca,se 2 * 222NY 655 179 754 s 165S 970 s 223NY 55J no power * 222NY 8 a 223NY 724 case 6 certiorari a 222NY 542 182 158 -case 7 S:178 955 a 223NY 88 jury trial 103M 101 B58cond precdt 368 no estoppel 764 s 166S 376 a 22aNY case 13 702 952 497 a 222NY 540 s 1668 107S 180 748 s 164S 915 179 866 a 224NY 586 r 223NY 519 case 8 * 223NY 521 245 claims not deducted 185 156 662 affidavits lOOM 603 780 913 s 166S 542 s 1678 as void act s 166S 193 953 m 226NY 70 181 ^94 182 157 a 222NY 658 case 4 case 13 505 good faith direct jury *326 NY Mem.| • 332NY 691 262 one year ISO 12 B67 s 1678 28 f 179 672 not liable 371 penalty s 164S 773 do 179 527 103M 608 787 case 5 178 4 428 954 case 2 s 166S 513 103M 180 distinction )ill particulars 182 237 106M 279 s 166S 304 case 6 r 223NY 31 105M 343 10 appeal L82 813 376 a 223NY 713 ' 221NY 575 » lOOM 385 184 228 no obligatioii « 164S 838 914 case 6 » 223NY 266 modify do 182 81S a 221NT 654 799 construed ■ 955 case 1 166S 464 509 lo 183 898 381 s 165S 913 186 343 653 il79 :ase 3 962 184 909 5 165S 1049 \ 222NY 648 duty city 182 818 s 164S 901 I . a33NY 653 287 not suffic. notice a.221NY 657 ( J24 barred , < )24 5 166S S47 519 186 90S £ 166S 248 ( ase 9 356 105M 414 5 165S 1014 391 £ I 224NY 269, 1 224NY 643 ^ase 3 ' 2-21NY 401 372 s 178 945 i 224NY 60-7 " 333NY 557 295 179 949 s 167S l^Si s 178 947 I 224NY 60!8 < )25 case 1 :ase 8 i 166S 375 I 221NY 688 1 222NY 103 lo 186 437 I I 221NY 655 523 421 notice li 536 no direct 38 se 4 1 ! 165S 957 377 costs 8 165S 46S tax L81 957 143 amended " 223NY 583 5 1678 19S 181 6921 166S 168! i 166S 397 186 SI ABBREVIATIONS: a, affiiTned: d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified;-*, dismissed: n. noter c ••■ 1 - t i:_ .:*-J . - .*n1o;n<.r r1 ■ n_ nverru ledrs same c ase : do. dissenting opinio n;p, parallel case ; q, questJoniZ Vols, 179, 180 N. Y. Supreme Court Reports— Appellate Division 721 s 166S a 222NY 732 J 179 746 I 167S a 221NY 887 545 735 140 414 748 discretion 890 succession case 13 •222NY 102M domicile 102M 519 46 48 892 jurisdiction case 10 179 734 , 167S a 222NT i lOlM quasbed 223NY 754 a 222NY 757 « 167S a 223NY 763 reversal 657 689 91 656 893 se 5 224NY case 7 182 8941egis. intent case 2 m 222NY 217 573 167S f 179 786 > 1&7S a 222NY 789 „ ■ 167S a 221NY 180 m t 166S * 22SNY 795 « 167S a 223NY 327 765 367 654 557 94 370 903 case 8 a 222NY f 182 905 case 8 224NY 528 929 564 906 - case 3 223NY ,_- case 7 118 a lOOM 682 9Hl 91 1 'case 4 913 * 221NY 659 912 case 6 224 NY case 5 a 223NY 950 case 9 a 223NY 570 137 VOL. ISO 9 good faith 106M 278 20 employee 951 assessment case 4 a 224NY s 224NY 952 case 182 case 2 184 187 191 445 682 s 167S do 184 32 s 167S 224NY 37 s 167S a 223NY 954 case r 222NY f 180 159 914 956 185 case 1 904 143 589 805 violation s 167S 285 a 224NY 710 105M 412 810 request 3 167S 181 814 » 167S i 181 823 a 221NY i J79 t 180 206 111 295 930 I 684 676 911 865alien enemy -». 167S a 223NY 182 1S2 102M 916 case 3 a 224NY legitimacy case 8 106M 921 f 179 923 case 1 a 223NY 617 927 case 8 ■224NY £ 957 case 1 a 223NY 958 case 1 185 case 5 a 222NY case 6 s 224NY 961 case 3 221NY case 4 a 223NY case 10 do 186 964 case 3 179 case 7 award 105M f 105M 965 case 12 * 223NY 966 case 14 r 223NY 719 930 case 6 a 222NY 199 578 514 uaou 829 106M 325' 612 93|leave appeal case 1 113 •act prosecute |g3g 181 877 s 167S t 181 531 908 881 case 1 authority 188 857 ease 2 a 223NY 692 884 ease 3 s 223NY 885 ease 5 T 224NY 476 case 5 182 case 6 f 179 939 case 5 a 222NY ' 1 222NY 942 c'iise 7 a •2?2NY 179 185 574 22 a 223NY 650 case 10 a,222NY 6581 948 cnsc Ct *.222NY 179 case 10 *2.25NY 949 I'ase 222NY 930 936 192 713 41R 417 820 524 42 n 664 306 344 486 624 483 681 45 justiflcation r 226NY 87 186 137 48 dependency s 167S 520 182 440 54 due process 528 549 548 455 668 437 966 116 117 636 342 t 131 no claim 184 disallowed 184 151 s 167S m 223NY 154 one cause s 167S 433 184 536 157 full costs 167S 183 60 s 167S r 223NY 88 „ s 167S a 222NY 223NY 90 s 167S 223NY 348 752 426 571 480 649 571 478 682 92 rehearing 519 168 564 823 900 s 167S do 182 94 injury s 167S d 180 { 185 103 tax debt s 167S 509 a 222NY 659 182 701 1 1 I award s 167S 493 184 821 120 "storage' 900 384 compliance 103M 611 571 717 430 44 185 388 appeal s 167S 185 do 185 pass book do 185 393 s 167S s 224NY s 167S 180 review 181 161 s 167S s 181 162 a 224NY s 167S 167 s 167S a 223NY 174 s 167S a 223NY 186 s 167S s 223NY a 224NY intention 186 624 161 I4S 432 916 542 288 711 675 627 «73 620 657 626 376 203 competent s 167S 498i a 223NY 582 180 865 direct jury 103M 611 weight of emd, 147 398caurt's pwr. s 167S do 183 417 „ 167S 102M s 167S 180 finding 181 no claim 184 394 146 143 571 |27not delegatd s 167S 242 a 223NY 379 130 recovery s 167S 424 184 822 133 compensatn s 167S 390 180 138 135 compensatn s 167S 391 180 134 loss fingers 183 164 138 finding s 167S 415 181 143 notice 181 143 { 181 958 959 184 735 143 incidental s 167S 397 180 125 185 217 „ s 167S 181 227 s 167S a 223NY 234 3 167S a 223NY 240 s 167S a 223NY 253 s 167S 224NY 273 s 167S f 180 719 896 654 685 722 compliance do 185 781 691 liable 29 s 168S 34 181 36 824 602 827 88 837 551 430 non assess- able 106M 693 454 damages s 167S 743 180 459 460 negligence 714 affidavit s 167S 747 183 241 719 recover s 168S 513 do 185 37 burden deft, do 185 38 not available do 185 39 claim do 185 . 41 734 contract s 168S a 224NY 743 s 168S r ■224NY s 167S 1S5 690 205 464 s 167S 222NY 181 s 182 constitutional 182 735 injunction 105M 228 poUee power 801 387 899 734 650 569 105M 470 s 167S r 224NY 494 pract. s 167S 186 515 test s 167S 183 reversal t 185 530 s 168S m 226NY 404 975 265 670 627 665 275 279 „ s 167S 181 707 47 law 767 100 981 366 390 915 214 100 454 233 305 660 752 not dispose s 168S 382 183 338 762 error law 168S 183 765 „ s 167S 224NY 822 810 140 773 certiorari s 168S 331 106M 365 807 vests lienor s 168S 125 185 268 814 taxable a 168S 95 183 716 lOSM 474 exemption 183 715 832 a s 168 180 jpeal 168 836 561 separation 715 496 949 818 546 916 s 167S f 183 184 unsafe 186 563 s 168S f IBl 585 ordin. s 167S 185 229 671 834 307 s 167S a 223NY retroactive 183 commissions 106M 120, 124 336 jurisdiction S.167S 280 104M: 386 375 for jury s 167S 925 106M 288 contrib. negl 106M - 288 328 945 care 895 869 599 pub. policy s 167S 892 105M 586 615 "permit" a 225irr 25 183 814 815 child twelve 185 .224 648 pract. law s 168S 278 186 100 669 to jury s 168S 135 103M 611 burden proof 837 erroneous s 168S 345 106M 24 not recover 106M 24 860second trial 8 168S 131 103M 604 606 reconcile 103M 605 869 new trial s 168S 285 f 180 871 883 bill partic. case 5 182 244 889ordr modify case 15 185 . 243 application 185 233 895 certiorari case 5 105M 902 case 7 180 903 intention case 6 104M 575 261 905 ^S™o^^^=S;S^^ N. Y. Supreme Court Reports — Appellate Division Vols, 180 — 182 904 case 7 i 181 905 case 3 a 224NT case 5 132 909 -case 2 * 222NT 185 do 185 -910 case * 222NT case 2 * 222NT 185 9IJ case : * 222NT 185 case 2 a 221NT case 4 a 221NY 914 case 2 T 222NT 9 1 7contrib. case 5 185 920 case 6 a 224NT 922 case 1 * 223NT 925 case 3 a 223NY 926 case 5 a 224 NY 927 case 7 a 223NY case 11 184 931 case ] s 182 932 case 11 a 223NY 933 case 10 a 223NY 934 case 1 * 223NY m 225NY 943 638 885 709 29 40 709 710 29 711 29 689 686 586 643 658 40 s 168S a 224NY VOL. 181 I perpetuities s 167S 774 105M 276 30 damages s 168S 61 a 223NY 208 203 579 61 principles s 168S 191 s 223NY 568 182 58 conduct d 182 59 75 reimburse s 168S 251 184 259 91 no duty s 168S 289 104M 45 126 constitutnl. s 168S 297 r 223NY 433 147 no review 856 250 576 680 464 935 insurance case 6 224NY case 7 1- 225NY 18 369 s 168S 103M 176 s 168S *224NY 184 8 168S a 224NY 59 419 550 755 609 193 s 168S a 223NY f 181 f 181 f 182 479 561 950 951 952 895 181 a 224NY 502 a 223NY 581 592 540 522 assault s 169S 119 a 224NY 90 538 not liable s 169S 88 182 813 recovery 105M 311 authority 184 857 544 dividend s 168S 1051 m 224NY 242 f 182 distinction 182 trust fund 1 181 217 218 750 62 1 - resident s 169S 35 106M 186 624 accounting s 168S 883 106M 183 952 666 642 8 168S a 225NY 672 a 223NY error law 183 amended 1916 d 184 457 689 822 702 elections 212 s 168S r 224NY 234 170S 224NY 104 136 1091 510 2821egal service s 168S a 223NY 309 s 168S a 225NY 322 168S f 181 385 672 739 665 472 947 s 168S a 222NY s 181 challenge f 181 705 s 168S a 222NY 706 s 168S a 222NY 222NY 712 s 168S 222NY 965 676 712 839 678 840 681 687 968 680 7 1 6 recanvass 338 constructn s 168S 760 223NY 373 367 validity 168S 866 £ 182 897 446 s 168S a 224NY 896 573 461 authority s 168S a 224NY 182 465 s 168S a 224NY 970 570 248 823 565 s 168S a 222NY a 222NY 717 s 168S a 222NY a 22,2NY a 222NY 719 5 168S a 224NY 742 rent s 168S 183 estoppel do 183 747 s 168S a 224NY 840 685 686 967 679 555 948 230 1094 284 469 intention s 168S 871 777 certiorari s 169S 139 a 224NY 167 787competnt, ev s 169S 181, 186 305 specify s 169S 183 f 184 f 184 840 E 168S a 225NY 865 s 169S a 223NY 879 s 169S s 224NY a 224NY 106M 883 case 8 - s 223NY 884 case 4 a 224NY 885 case 3 181 venue case 4 183 new trial case 5 lOSM 889 case 4 a 222NY 893 case 3 224NY case 6 224NY 898 case 3 183 900 case 1 do 180 902 case 3 223NY 910 case 4 a 223NY case 9 223NY 911 case 6 222NY case 7 a 223NY 912 case 6 s 223NY case 10 a 223NY 913 case 5 s 182 914 case 1 *225NY case 9 r 223NY 227 377 881 886 976 261 273 670 367 545 572 421 658 571 612 146 97 686 382 588 550 r 223NY 498 924 case 2 a 223NY 927 case 11 a 224NY 928 case 8 a 223NY 930 case 7 s 181 931 case 3 violations 183 case 8 r 224NY case 13 a 224NY 720 568 656 727 616 934 defense merits case 6 do 186 case 9 r 223NY 307 punishment 243 184 950 case 182 951 case a 223NY 559 952 case 2 a 223NY 778 739 560 VOL. 182 10 ordin. s 169S 185 care 412 870 37 consolidation s 169S a 224NY 94 s 169S r 225NY 277 525 589 579 122 liability s 169S 693 106M 605 126 award s 169S 183 705 500 1 52 competent s 169 S 645 a 224NY 30 a 224NY 539 1 53 compenstn. B 169S 645 a 224NY 540 172 reversal s 170S 310 185 390 1 76condemnatn, r 224NY 201 954 condemnatn case 10 224NY S 654 452 915 case 2 181 case 3 a 224NY 916 case 1 a 224NY case 9 143 705 957 case 2 223NY 960 case 4 s 224NY 60 961 case 9 a 223NY 61 case 11 223NY 38 962 case 3 * 224ISrY 1 read together 186 14 case 7 r 223NY 92 963 case 5 a 223NY a 224NY 964 case 6 a 224NY 966 case 3 224NY 969 case 7 222NY 683 569 723 180 s 169S a 224NY 603 s 169S a 224NY 619 bonds s 168S 182 630 s 169S s 224NY 730 costs s 170S s 186 801 s 170S *225NY 917 648 849 625 826 566 231 673 858 8 170S f 184 862cond. s 170S 186 345 886 prcdt. 275 110 87 1 conviction a 224NY 594 183 17 884 case 8 a 223NY 579 ■885 liability lease 4 577| 184 856 22 1 reversal s 169S 561 s 106M 399 30lgrd. s 169S r 223NY 357 s 169S a 223NY larceny 729 459 554 676 368 compensatn s 169S 103M 387 s 169S £ 182 438 s 169S a 223NY 430 660 49 930 584 687 445 loss eye s 169S 309 d 185 52 448 169S a 224NY 307 621 455 not aid 169S 105M 482 s 169S *224NY 622 587 762 549 533 tort action 169S do 183 572 169S a 225NY 576 169S a 225NY 527 465 968 671 884 676 580 continuance s 169S 958 887 case 4 s 186 894 case 5 a 224NY conviction case 7 s 105M 897 case 3 a 223NY case 4 224NY 11 904 case 185 case 12 * 223NY 918 905 case 3 183 897 907 case 2 r 223NY 369 case 7 a 224NY 596 912 case 7 224NY 618 915 not rescind case 3 223NY case 10 558 183 918 case 8 s 184 114 228 ABBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished; f, followed; r, reversed; m, modified; *, dismissed; n, note; • se; do, dissenting opinion; p, parallel case; q, questioned Vols. 183 — 186 N. y. -Supreme Court Beports-^Appellate Diyision VOL. 183 6 dickering 1«2 878 67 eaaianty ISS 76 77 no claim s 170S 588 ■185 763 88 s 170S a 224N.y 562 706 1 I Irght rescind ■s 170S 161 185 866 141 s 170S a 224NY 677 714 162 lose finger s 170S J142 184 -eg? 168 s 170S ,3^0 s 186 '388 (92 s 170S *225NY 753 citijen S '1>71-S 82 106M 186 769 libelous s 171S 827 105M 135 773 inference^ s 171S 605 186 276 822 employmt. s 17,18 285 a 224N.Y -712 186 434- servant's work 186 ASS commerce 186 -436 832 commissns. s 171S .404 106M 120, 121 868 s 171S 881 s i224NY 733 a 225NY 717 266 s 170S a 224NT 668 636 1119 M3 286 duty clerk a 224NY 554 104M 200 resubmission f 185 945 292 no estoppel s 170S e— 184 244 359 exemption s 169S 770 184 915 184 960 185 897 367 s 169S a 224NY 954 647 396 domicile s 170S 1024 185 396 428 s 170S -812 a 224NY 624 d 185 85'! 451 s 170S *225NY 1063 29f 456 complaint s 170S 104£ 185 ^29? 527 inquiry s 170S 228 105M 695 174S 51 882 case 10 a 224NY 561 929 case 11 182 930 case 5 a 224NY ease 7 a 225NY 931 case 7 a 224NY 938 case 2 184 939 case 5 a 224NY 707 883 case il a ;224NY case 11 183 888 890 case 17 r 2260Sr.Y 896 case 7 *224NY 897 case 4 r 224NY case 5 s 224NY case 6 224NY 908 case 3 *224NY 544 377 657 602 688 529 s 171S r 225NY 105 5 ,542 no oblign, s -170S -290 105M 730 571 burd. proof s 170S 881 184 585 708 easement 186 -462 91.1 case 6 a 223NY case 7 a 224NY 619 912 award case 2 223NY 365 913 award case 4 224NY 914 case 5 224NY case 9 r 223NY 244 916 case a 223NY 621 917 case 10 a 224NY 615 s 183 302 919 case 5 *224NY 551 921 cose 1 a 223NY 666 925 case 8 *224NY 559 628 670 556 VOL. 184 37 conclusive 547 104 705 454 i439 l908 writ .31 1627 s 171S 105M 52 s 171S a :224NY 62 s 171S 166 93 prohib. s 171S 106 M 209 order s a7is f 184 215 216 217 liability s ,171S 480 184 ■7-75, -776 274 provisions s 171S SIO 185 396 285 file scked. s 171S 379 105M 667 798 pub. -poliey s 172S 509 106 M 829 jurisdiction 932 ■626 337 386 340 file lien s 171S 186 355 s 170S a 224NY 369 a '224NY f 184 421 decree s -1718 637 105M ,721 428 validity 171S 624 226NY -76 908 case .2 s d84 911 case 9 a ,224NY 491 .559 659 925 467 s 170S 184 994 946 505 practical coijistructi^n s 1718 1052 a 224NY do 185 f 185 s 1718 106M 88 1 case s .a24NY 889 case 10 a_225NY 892 appeal case -1 224NY case 5 a 224Ny case ^1 224NT 886 case 5 a 224NY 904 case '1-0 a 224NY 600 VOL. 185 598 55 908 509 *224NY 527 s 1728 { 185 69'. 264 940 533 dismissal s ,1728 561 186 95 co-plaintiff 186 99 541 Stat, prprty s 172S 373 185 672 556 restriction 1718 a '225NY interstate do 186 l^ajcable do 186 1028 39' 43 31 not 'taxable 511 311 -448 84 s 1728 106M 763 s 1728 r 226NY 767 show guilt' s 1728 371 186 '279 791 discrimnatn r 224NY 397 567 708 914 case 1 f 184 917 case 7 '^224'NY case 10 r 225NY 919 Be 1 ■224NY 921 case 9 a 224NY 922 case 3 r 225NY case 10 r .224NY 923 case 1 a 224NY case 4 a 224NY 924 case 2 a 225NY 925 case 9 a 224NY case 11 185 926 case 8 *224NY 936 case 1 224NY 952 case 7 *224NY 960 case 2 '-225NY case 9 184 961 428 716 604 130 .321 620 123 622 614 ,519 '386 590 612 6,95 671 961 2S t ,185 f 185 41 f 186 63 custom 165 220 r SMN^ .186 .483 896 9,08 i847 631 699 263 limit liability 18,6 339 882 order lS5 883 a 226JIY>]Sfem. VOL. 186 287 duty court 186 (455 proper parties case 1 I 186 202 dismissal 186 203 AUBREVIATIONS: a, affirmed; d, distinguished ; f,. folio wed ; r, rever- criticised: 1. limited; e. explained; o, overruled; s, same case; do. dissent >H . m Tnr»difi#iH r -•. dismissed; n, note; c.