Cornell University Library The original of tiiis book is in the Cornell University Library. There are no known copyright restrictions in the United States on the use of the text. http://www.archive.org/details/cu31924013574763 THE JOURNAL OF ENGLISH AND GERMANIC PHILOLOGY EDITED ' BB- ' » GUSTAF E. KAESXEK and J AME& MORGAN HART ySriVERSITY OF litlNOlS > , ' '■' COEKEI,!, XMIVEESITY WITH THE 09-OPERAT1ON;\6f ,, ; GEORGE T. FLOM, University of IpwA PAUL H. GEUMMANN, University, or Nebraska OTTO HELLER, Vashinqton UNiviifisiW XJEORG HOLZ, University op Leipzig, Germany CLARK S. NORTHUP, GoR*r:EiA, Univeksity HORATIO S. WHITE, Habvarp University ' Volume y'i, .No. '2\ ' ,Janua:ry, 1907 . , PUBLISHED QUARTERLY BX THJ^ JOURNAL PUBLISHING COJVIPANY Urban a, Tit., U.S.A. ' tJNBER THE AuSPICES OF THE UNIVERSITY^ OF ILLINOIS Subscription Price r$3. 00- JER Volume i Single;, Numbers, $1.00, , ' EUROPEAN AGENT ', Ad6iLFWEIGEL, Leipzig, Germ an y- Entered a^ tlje Urbana, 111;, Fp/toffice^aS'Seopnd-cla^s mail matter. CONTENTS. Laue Cooper, ' Some Wordsworthian Similes , Fb. Klaebbe, 'Minor Notes on thei Beowulf.. - ■;,' Cynewulf's Elene 1262 {:■ ' .' , .' -. ' ^^-me»i.,886 . , ./■ ,,. . . EjtikST VpSSjI^S^ehiiaplian . . . — . PI. S. V. Jones,- The CUomiM's, theMSliacin, and the Arabian Tale of ' r, the " Enchanted Horse " . . .■ . .■.../,'.. . : ' . Edwin W. Fay, Gothic and English Etymologigs , . . . , . Hermann Colmtz, jSusfimer ,6der Grermanisclie Namen in Keltische'm >, Gewaiide . . . .-'...,.' . . ... './. 179 190 198 199 221 244 253 , REVIEWS. . George O. Cubme : Engelien- Jantzen, Granimjitik der neuhochdeutschen Sprache ; , Siitterlin and Waag, Deutpclje ' Sprachlehre f iir hohere ... Lehranstalten ;' H"agl, Deutsche Sprachlehre f fir Mittelschuleli ;' . . 307; J. M. McBbyde, Jr. : Kinard; English Grammar for Beginners . . 313- ClARK S. NoRTHtJR : Kiiige, Mittelenglisches Lesebueh . ~ .' . 815 B. S. M6NRaE: Emerson, A Middle English Beadei*, . . . . 319 CURRENT LITERATURE. Georg Edward r Xeuere Deutsche Literatur 324 NOTICE. •Editorial matter may be sent to-any. member of the Editorial Staft Material fpr No. 4 should be submitted as promptly as possible. Suitable advertisements will be inserted at the following rates : FOR ONE IKSERTIONi jrwo INSERTIONS. i page ........-..■, ,i20>00 , $35.00"' i page.... ; t' .: 12.00 20,00 , i page....... ,;8.00' ,. 15.00 .Address all business qommunioations to. THREE INSERTIONS. 140:00 25.00 20.00 FOUR INSERTIONS. 145.00 30.00 , 24.00 TliB JotTENAL Publishing Company, Urbana, 111., U. S. A. Copyright, 190G, by Gustap E. -Karsten. ■K SOME WOEDSm>RTHIA]Sr SIMILES. SPEAKING of an earlier stage in the growth of his imagina- tion, the author of " The Prelude " remarks to Coleridge (" Prelude," ii, 377-386) : Nor should this, perchance, Pass unrecorded, that I still had loved The exercise and produce of a toil. Than analytic industry to me More pleasing, and whose character I deem Is more poetic as resembling more Oeative agency. The song would speak Of that interminable building reared By observation of affinities In objects where no brotherhood exists To passive minds. What his amplifying song could not here refrain from utter- ing struck Wordsworth, ' perchance,' as a matter that might go almost without discussion — ^at least in a poem addressed to the reflective Coleridge. Yet had Wordsworth been writing a prose treatise for the public, and had he been dealing with the psychology of literary artists in general, instead of the mind of one individual artist, however representative, his pronouncement might have properly taken on a form even more explicit and assured. At all events he would have had good precedent for such assurance. The work on poetics commonly attributed to Aristotle, although it assumes poets to be ' makers of plots ' — rather than ' makers of verse ' — ^nevertheless regards the imagi- native faculty as lurking, after the final analysis, in an innate command of figurative detail ; as residing, therefore, less in the gross structure of a poem than in particular images. Accord- ing to this view, and to play a Kttle with etymology, we may credit the poet or maker with beiug a creator of figures or imagery even before he is a creator of fiction or plot : 179 180 Cooper, [Vol. VI 'It is a great matter,' says Aristotle (Poetics, xxni, 9 ; Butcher's translation, p. 87), 'to observe propriety in these several modes of expression — compound words, strange (or rare) words, and so forth. But the greatest thing by far is to have a command of metaphor ; it is the mark of genius, — ^for to make good metaphors implies an eye for resemblances.' In this paper I wish merely to bring together some of the marks of Wordsworth's genius, choosing from the wealth of his imagery a number of those figures in which, as it seems to me, his originality, and boldness of vision, and, if they are contem- plated steadily, his justice of vision also, are most strikingly exemplified. Undoubtedly, his eye for resemblances may be appreciated best through his similes and direct comparisons ; in these the affinities that he discovers between ' objects where no brotherhood exists to passive minds ' are most plainly affirmed ; more plainly, of course, than in his metaphors, if the latter term be restricted to its technical usage. Inasmuch as the similes here collected represent to me ultimate elements in Wordsworth's style, I have made no systematic effi3rt to find external ' sources ' for them, — although here and there they may remind one of Virgil or Shakespeare or the Bible. Nor have I tried to arrange them according to any plan suggestive of analytic industry. Obviously, they might be grouped under a few main heads, for example : similes or comparisons implying a ' brotherhood ' existent between man and the lower animals, or between man and inanimate nature, so-called, or between inanimate nature and the lower animals ; yet even this arrangement might savor of a partition in the great whole of nature such as Wordsworth would hardly countenance. It is, in fact, his active sense of a vital unity pervading the great whole that enables him to assert so strong, often so startling, a bond of affinity among the parts. Accordingly, I shall content myself with presenting this mate- rial as I have noted it, supplying now and then a word of expla- nation where the sense demands it, but trusting that the separate comparisons by tbemselves will be enough ' to startle and way- lay ' the reader, and afterwards ' to haunt ' him, without further literary artifice. No. 2] Some Wordsworthian Similes. 181 The first 'creative' synthesis to summon our attention belongs to the early period described by Wordsworth in the lines at the beginning. It is extremely characteristic : Calm is all nature as a resting wheel. ( " Written In Very Early Youth," 1. 1. ) • In their present connection the following need no comment. Free as a colt at pasture on the hill, I ranged at large, through London's wide domain. Month after month. ( " Prelude," Book ix, 11. 23-25. ) ^ She shall be sportive as the fawn That wild with glee across the lawn Or up the mountain springs. ("Three years she grew in sun and shower," 11. 13-15.)' Here is the seductive and alluring half-breed pictured in "Euth": He waa a lovely Youth ! I guess The panther in the wilderness Was not so fair as he ; And, when he chose to sport and play, No dolphin ever was so gay Upon the tropic sea. ("Buth," 11. 37-42.)* Wordsworth's cloud-similes are familiar : Soft as a cloud is yon blue Bidge — ° I wandered lonely as a cloud That floats on high o'er vales and hills, When all at once I saw a crowd, A host, of golden daffodils. ("I wandered lonely as a cloud," 11. 1-4.) * 1 Wordsworth, Poetical Works, Aldine Edition, Vol. I, p. 4. Other refer- ences to Wordsworth's poems in this article are to the Aldine Edition, simply by volume and page, thus : P. W., i. 4. 2 P. W., VII. 170. »P. TT., n. 96. »P- Tr.,iv. 143. ♦P. W., n. 112. 'P. W., u. 96. 182 Cooper, [Vol. VI He told of the magnolia, spread High as a cloud, high over head I The cypress and her spire. ("Buth,"ll. 61-63.)' With these compare : The Knight had ridden down from Wensley Moor With the slow motion of a summer's cloud. ("Hart-Leap WeU," 11. l-%.y In the next two, it is probable, we have .reminiscences of Wordsworth's reading in the Arctic explorers. He is seeking for violent figures with which to depict phases of the French Kevolution. . . . zeal, which yet Had slumbered, now in opposition burst Forth like a Polar summer. ("Prelude," Book rs, U. 254-256. )3 Look ! and behold, from Calpe's sunburnt cliffs To the flat margin of the Baltic sea, Long-reverenced titles cast away as weeds ; Laws overturned ; and territory split. Like fields of ice rent by the polar wind. ("Excursion," Bookix, U. 336-340.)* In the following, however, he seems to be drawing on his own observation — let us say, of Rydal or Grasmere : Calm as a frozen lake when ruthless winds Blow fiercely, agitating earth and sky. The Mother now remained. ("Excursion," Book m, 11. 650-652.) * Our poet's objective and passionless contemplation of death is typical in "Matthew" : Poor Matthew, all his frolics o'er, Is silent as a standing pool. ("Matthew," 11. 17-18.) 6 Wordsworth's line on Milton is classical : ip. W., n. 112. ^P. W., II. 133. sp. W., vn. 176. *P. W., VI. 297. ^P. W., VI. 95. ep. W., IV. 211. No. 2] Some Wordsworthian Similes. 183 Thy soul was like a Star, and dwelt apart. ("London, 1802," 1. 9.)' His image of our western Indian is probably less familiar : Free as the sun, and lonely as the sun. ("Excursion," Book in, 1. 941.)' His description of his wife, again, will be generally recognized : Her eyes as stars of Twilight fair ; Like Twilight's, too, her dusky hair. ( " She was a Phantom of delight," 11. 5-6. ) » Likewise his daffodils : Continuous as the stars that shine And twinkle on the milky way. They stretched in never-ending, line Along the margin of a bay. (" I wandered lonely as a cloud," U. 7-10.)* Curious is his recollection of the room in Paris where he slept at the outbreak of the Revolution : The place, all hushed and silent as it was. Appeared unfit for the repose of night. Defenceless as a wood where tigers roam. ("Prelude," Book x, U. 91-93. )5 Curious also his remembrance of that noble revolutionist, his friend Beaupuy : . . . while he read. Or mused, his sword was haunted by his touch Q)ntinually, like an uneasy place la his own body. ("Prelude," Book ix, 11. 158-161.)* I have already noticed several Wordsworthian similes of calm. None is more famous than this : ip. W., m. 134. *-P- W., n. 98. , >P. W., yi. 104. '-P- ^•. vn. 190. 'P. W., II. 94. 'P- W-> vn- 174. 184 Cooper, [Vol. VI It is a beauteous evening, calm and free, The holy time is quiet as a Nun Breathless with adoration. ("It is a beauteous evening . . . ," IL 1-3.)' Similes of agitation are likewise typical : Surprised by joy — impatient as the Wind, I turned to share the transport — Oh I with whom But Thee, deep buried in the silent tomb. ("Surprised by joy . . . ," U. 1-3. )» . . . but the man, Who trembled, trunk and Umbs, like some huge oak By a fierce tempest shaken, soon resumed The steadfast quiet natural to a mind Of composition gentle and sedate. ("Excursion," Book VI., 11. 143-147.)' As a matter of fact, the rapid transition from tumult to repose is one of Wordsworth's favorite devices. So here : . . . that Soul, Which with the motion of a virtuous act Flashes a look of terror upon guilt. Is, after conflict, quiet as the ocean. By a miraculous finger stilled at once. ("Borderers," A^t I, U. 169-173.)* And here : This Sea that bares her bosom to the moon ; The winds that will be howling at all hours, And are up-gathered now like sleeping fliowers ; For this, for everything, we are out of tune. ("The world is too much with us ... ^" 11. 5-8.)' Occasionally in Wordsworth there is the touch of Homer : . . . far into the night The Housewife plied her own peculiar work. Making the cottage through thfe silent hours Murmur as with the sound of summer flies. ("Michael," 11. 125-128. )« ip. W., m. 20. ip. W., I. 83; cf. Mark 4: 39. ^P. W., m. 18. sp. W., m. 21. »P W., VI. 191. 6p. W., I. 308. No. 2] Some Wordsworthian Similes. 185 I add a number more without remark : Light as a sunbeam glides along the hills She vanished — eager to impart the scheme To her loved brother and his shy compeer. ("Excursion,"" Book IX, 11. 429-431.)' . . . and the boat advanced Through crystal water, smoothly as a hawk. That, disentangled from the shady boughs Of some thick wood, her place of covert, cleaves With correspondent wings the abyss of air. ( "Excursion," Book ix, 11. 490-494.) ^ No fountain from its rocky cave E'er tripped with foot so free ; She seemed as happy as a wave That dances on the sea. ("The Two April Mornings," 11. 49-52.) ' And while the Pony moves his legs. In Johnny's left hand you may see The green bough motionless and dead : The Moon that shines above his head Is not more motionless than he. ( "The Idiot Boy," 11. 77-81. ) * Perhaps he's turned himself about. His face unto his horse's tail, And still and mute, in wonder lost, All silent as a horseman-ghost. He travels slowly down the vale. ("The Idiot Boy," 11. 322-326. )5 In one way or another, Wordsworth knew a great deal about the joys of travel and discovery : Before me shone a glorious world — Fresh as a banner bright, unfurled To music suddenly. ("Ruth," 11. 169-171. )« Two lines from "The Thorn," ip. W., VI. 300. 'P. W., VI. 302. 'P. W., iv. 213. ♦P. W., I. 292. °P. W., I. 300. «P. W., II. 116. 186 Cooper, [Vol. VI Not higher than a. two years' child It stands erect, this aged Thorn ("The Thorn," U. 5-6) ' remind us of various similar passages, among them the Words- worthian couplet near the beginning of Coleridge's "Ancient Mariner " : And listens like a three years' child : The Mariner hath his will. Wordsworth rated very highly the imaginative quality in " Peter Bell." "Was this partly on account of the similes in that poem ? Three or four instances from it may not be out of place. The Ass is startled — and stops short Eight in the middle of the, thicket ; And Peter, wont to whistle loud Whether alone or in a crowd. Is silent as a silent cricket. ("Peter Bell," 11. 621-625.) = By this his heart is lighter far ; And, finding that he can account So snugly for that crimson stain. His evil spirit up again. Does like an empty hucket mount. ("Peter Bell," 11. 801-805. )« But as an oak in breathless air Will stand though to the centre hewn ; Or as the weakest things, if frost Have stiffened them, maintain their post ; So he beneath the gazing moon ! — ("Peter Bell," U. 846-850.)* But, more than all, his heart is stung To think of one, almost a child ; A sweet and playful Highland girl, As light and beauteous as a squirrel. As beauteous and as wild ! ("Peter Bell," 11. 886-890.) » 'P. W., II. 125. ^P. W., n. 241. 'P. W., 11. 247 ; cf. Shakespeare, Riehard II, iv. 1. 185. *P. W., II. 248. sp. w., n. 250. No. 2] Some Wordsworthian Similes. 187 My list would surely be incomplete without an example from the poem in which, as one of the best of "Wordsworthian critics, E. H. Hutton, averred, our poet reached the high-water mark of his power and technique, the " Song at the Feast of Brougham Castle " : Now Who is he that bounds with joy On Carrook's side, a Shepherd-boy? No thoughts hath he but thoughts that pass Light as the wind along the grass. Can this be He who hither came In secret, like a smothered flame? ( "Song at the Feast of Brougham Castle," 11. 72-77. ) ' Nor should the passage be omitted that Wordsworth intro- duces, from his own works, in his " Preface to the Edition of 1815," as an illustration of the way in which the poetic faculty is employed ' upon images in a conjunction by which they mod- ify each other ' : As a huge stone is sometimes seen to lie Couched on the bald top of an eminence ; Wonder to all who do the same espy, By what means it could thither come, and whence ; So that it seems a thing endued with sense : Like a sea-beast crawled forth, that on a shelf Of rock or sand reposeth, there to sun itself ; Such seemed this Man, not all alive nor dead. Nor all asleep — in his extreme old age. ("Resolution and Independence," 11. 57-65.)^ 'In these images,' Wordsworth explains,^ 'the conferring, the abstracting, and the modifying powers of the Imagination, immediately and mediately acting, are all brought into conjunc- tion. The stone is endowed with something of the power of life to approximate it to the sea-beast, and the sea-beast stripped of some of its vital qualities to assimilate it to the stone ; which intermediate image is thus treated for the purpose of bringing the original image, that of the stone, to a nearer resemblance to the figure and condition of the aged Man ; who is divested of ip. W., II. 142. 'P. W., II. 121-122. ' Wordsworth's Literary Criticism, ed. Nowell C. Smith, 1905, p. 160. 188 Cooper, [Vol. VI so much of the indications of life and motion as to bring him to the point where the two objects unite and coalesce in just com- parison.' As may be surmised from examples given above, Words- worth, through the boldness and rapidity of his vision, often omits such steps of assimilation or 'coalescence' as he here unfolds ; yet his most surprising comparisons are not on that account necessarily less 'just.' Similes must sometimes have flashed upon his inward eye with such a compelling claim to reality that, however remote the two objects compared might be ' to passive minds,' he was constrained to disregard all the steps of ordinary artistic gradation in uniting them. In such cases, to ' modify ' might have involved a false and miworthy manipula- tion. Wordsworth's similes, no matter how abrupt at first sight, are a part of his truest experience. ' Many of my poems,' so he tells us ', ' have been influenced by my own circumstances, when I was writing them. " The Warning " was composed on horseback, while I was riding from Moreby in a snow-storm. Hence the simile in that poem, While thoughts press on and feelings overflow And quick words round him fall like jtoAes of mow.' It is not, then, on account of a superficial interest or pecu- liarity attaching to Wordsworth's similes that I have brought some of them together for inspection, but rather on account of their deep underlying truth — truth to their author and to the constitution of things as he saw it. At first blush a few of them may appear to be literary abortions, crude excrescences. But if it be generally admitted that Wordsworth saw more profoundly into nature than any other English poet of his era, we may be unsafe in rejecting even the least expected of his comparisons — for example. Calm is all nature as a resting wheel — without a considerable pause for reflection. To the passive ' Memoirs of Wordsworth, by Christopher Wordsworth, n. 486. No. 2] Some WordswortKian Similes. 189 mind they may now and then be a stumbling-block, and to the unsympathetic, foolishness. Their truth and justice become apparent when they are dwelt upon with active sympathy by a mind that through habit is less inclined to condemn than to admire. Lane Coopee. COBNELL University. 190 Klaeber, [Vol. VI MINOR NOTES ON THE BEOWULF. 21. "TTf a paper printed in Mod. Phil. 3. 445 ff., I transla- I ted 1. 216, after Grein and Sievers (Beowulf wnd Saxo, p. 190f.), 'in his father's house ' (Grein ^: (xme, Grein ^: irnie). But recently Professor Blackburn called my atten- tion to the strong probability of . . rme having actually been the original reading of the MS. (cf. Zupitza's transliteration and note) and after considering the merits of the few available words that have been proposed {feorme pKemble], bearme [Bouterwek, in 1854, Thorpe], harme [Bouterwek, Z.f. d. A. 11. 71]), I have come to consider bearme the most presentable candidate for admission, giving it however a new interpretation. I do not understand on bearme with reference to the geong(^yguma ('in his father's lap,' ^ ' in des Vaters Schutze noch ' Bouterwek)-— which would be very awkward — but with regard to feofigifivM^f which may be credited, I trust, with the sense of 'presenl^*- ' precious object to be given.' For bearm I venture to postu- late the meaning of 'possession' which could easily have developed from its use in connection with verbs like don, alec- gan, cuman (cf. also fcB/>m in 1, 1210 : gehwearf Aa in Francmn, fcBpm). So fromum feohgiftvim on faeder bearme would in fact correspond pretty closely to Saxo's drnnestids stipendiis (cf. Sievers, l. c). 1496-151a. Since these lines as emended by various scholars are stUl as unsatisfactory as ever, another attempt at healing them may be pardoned. The suspiciously harsh collocation gyddum (MS. gyddu) geomore is got rid of by Trautmann's emendation geomqrum, which however neither explains the gen- 'In its literal sense the phrase is found in IHal. Oreg. 289. 18 : on Ms feeder bearme. J. H. FURST COMPANY PRINTERS Off Philological and Scientific Works ARB- FULLY EQUIPPED WITH , , Special Types, Accents, &c.,,for the production of wprks in Ancient and Modern Languages, and are prepared to fill Orders promptly and accurately ' AMONG THE PUBLICATIONS PRINTED ET US ARE : The Jouknal of Engiibh and Germj^nio •^'hiijology , , ,Th3B PtTBLICATIONS OF THE MODEEN LANGUAGi:' ASSOCIATION OF AMEEICA jV^odeen ]JjANGnAGB Notes * !, . '^ .' - ' • The Johns Hopkins Univebsity Cieculaes, Eegistbe Am) Eepqbts The JoHiis Hopkins Hospital Announcements 4nd Mday other Works of Similar Character ' ' ■ SPECIAL ATTENTION GIVEN TO THE PRIJiTING OF DOCTORS' DISSERTATIONS In Greek, Latin, Anglo-Sazoh, Old Engllsli, and tlie Romance and Germanic Languages CORRESPONDENCE INVITED J. H. FURST COMPANY 23 S. Hanover Street BALTIMORE, MD. The Journal • OF ' ■ English and Gerivianic Philology (CONTIBUING THE JOURNAL OF GERMANIC PHILOLOGY.) A QuAETEEiY Devoted to the Study' and Teaching of the English, German, and Scandinavian Languages and Literatures GusTAF E. Kaksten, Managing Editor. ■ Edited by Gustaf E. Kaksten, University of Illinois and James Morgan Hart, Cornell ' Universif-y.-Hiih.ihe cooperation of^G. T. Flom, .University of Iowa, P. H. Grummann, UniiiersUy of Nebraska, Otto HELLEJt, , Washington University, G. Holz, University t>f Leipsig, Germany,' ClaSkS. N0ETHUP,,Ci)™e« University,U. S. "\Vhije, Harvard University. Subscription price $3100 per volume ; individual back volumes .the same. . Vol. 1, formally 15.00,, is no longer sold separately. Special Offer ' -„ 1. Complete sets of 5 volumes, for $l'2.00 instead of ' $-17.00. There, are now 22 complete sets left. ■ '• , -..„.,, " ■ ' 2. Volumes 2, 3, ,4 (md 5'Jo(/ether ioi- $6.00 instead of $1-2.00. 'Volume 1 may be reprinted, when a sufficient number of orders for the same is on file. _ If you accept this second offer, kindly indicate, whether you contemplate securing Volume 1 at some 'future time, for not more than |5.00, if reprinted within three' years. please address The Jquenai, Publish [nG Company, Urbana, 111. The N Y Natioai It merits the respect 4nd support of anybody .at all interested in Germanics. The Critic : Serviqeaible in placing the teaching of English and' German on a sounder an4 higher " ' Diane— a sort of scientific review of reviews. ... u- . l^ - i The Am47Hcan Journal of Philology : In general make-up it is above criticism. But not merely its exterior reflects credit upon it, etc. - .... i , The ffartfm-d Post: Libraries will And it'a highly valuable addition to their working apparatus.. Professor Calvin Thomas, Colnnibia University : It is an honor to our country. Cornell University Library PR 5896.C77 Some Wordsworthian similes. 3 1924 013 574 763