CORNELL UNIVERSITY LIBRARY FROM Woodford Patterson Cornell University Library PR 5134.13 1910 Imaginary POJjrajtB, , Cornell University Library The original of this book is in the Cornell University Library. There are no known copyright restrictions in the United States on the use of the text. http://www.archive.org/details/cu31924013532563 IMAGINARY PORTRAITS MACMILLAN AND CO., Limited LONDON ■ BOMBAY ■ CALCUTTA • MADRAS MELBOURNE THE MACMILLAN COMPANY NEW YORK • BOSTON" ■ CHICAGO DALLAS • SAN FRANCISCO THE MACMILLAN CO. OF CANADA, Ltd. TORONTO BY WALTER PATER MACMILLAN AND CO., LIMITED ST. MARTIN'S STREET, LONDON 1919 A7W y/t> COPYRIGHT First Edition 1887 Second Edition 1890 Third Edition 1896 ; Reprinted 1899 Edition de Luxe igoo Fourth Edition 1901 ; Reprinted 1903, 1905, 1907, 1909 Library Edition 1910. Reprinted 1912, 1914, 1919 CONTENTS CHAPTER I FACE A Prince of Court Painters . , , .3 CHAPTER II Denys L'Auxerrois . . . , . .45 CHAPTER III Sebastian van Storck . . . . .79 CHAPTER IV Duke Carl of Rosenmold . . . . . 117 I A PRINCE OF COURT PAINTERS A PRINCE OF COURT PAINTERS EXTRACTS FROM AN OLD FRENCH JOURNAL Valenciennes, September 1 70 1. They have been renovating my father's large workroom. That delightful, tumble-down old place has lost its moss-grown tiles and the green weather-stains we have known all our lives on the high whitewashed wall, opposite which we sit, in the little sculptor's yard, for the coolness, in summertime. Among old Watteau's work- people came his son, " the genius," my father's godson and namesake, a dark-haired youth, whose large, unquiet eyes seemed perpetually wandering to the various drawings which lie exposed here. My father will have it that he is a genius indeed, and a painter born. We have had our September Fair in the Grande Place, a wonderful stir of sound and colour in the wide, open space beneath our windows. And just where the crowd was busiest young Antony was found, hoisted into one of those empty niches of the old Hotel de Ville, sketching the scene to the life, but with a 5 IMAGINARY PORTRAITS kind of grace — a marvellous tact of omission, as my father pointed out to us, in dealing with the vulgar reality seen from one's own window — which has made trite old Harlequin, Clown, and Columbine, seem like people in some fairyland ; or like infinitely clever tragic actors, who, for the humour of the thing, have put on motley for once, and are able to throw a world of serious innuendo into their burlesque looks, with a sort of comedy which shall be but tragedy seen from the other side. He brought his sketch to our house to-day, and I was present when my father questioned him and commended his work. But the lad seemed not greatly pleased, and left untasted the glass of old Malaga which was offered to him. His father will hear nothing of educating him as a painter. Yet he is not ill- to-do, and has lately built himself a new stone house, big and grey and cold. Their old plastered house with the black timbers, in the Rue des Cardinaux, was prettier ; dating from the time of the Spaniards, and one of the oldest in Valenciennes. October 1 701. Chiefly through the solicitations of my father, old Watteau has consented to place Antony with a teacher of painting here. I meet him betimes on the way to his lessons, as I return from Mass ; for he still works with the masons, 6 A PRINCE OF COURT PAINTERS but making the most of late and early hours, of every moment of liberty. And then he has the feast-days, of which there are so many in this old-fashioned place. Ah ! such gifts as his, surely, may once in a way make much industry seem worth while. He makes a wonderful progress. And yet, far from being set-up, and too easily pleased with what, after all, comes to him so easily, he has, my father thinks, too little self-approval for ultimate success. He is apt, in truth, to fall out too hastily with himself and what he produces. Yet here also there is the " golden mean." Yes ! I could fancy myself offended by a sort of irony which sometimes crosses the half-melancholy sweetness of manner habitual with him ; only that as I can see, he treats himself to the same quality. October 1701. Antony Watteau comes here often now. It is the instinct of a natural fineness in him, to escape when he can from that blank stone house, with so little to interest, and that homely old man and woman. The rudeness of his home has turned his feeling for even the simpler graces of life into a physical want, like hunger or thirst, which -might come to greed ; and methinks he perhaps overvalues these things. Still, made as he is, his hard fate in that rude place must needs touch one. And then, he profits by the experience of 7 IMAGINARY PORTRAITS my father, who has much knowledge in matters of art beyond his own art of sculpture ; and Antony is not unwelcome to him. In these last rainy weeks especially, when he can't sketch out of doors, when the wind only half dries the pavement before another torrent comes, and people stay at home, and the only sound from without is the creaking of a restless shutter on its hinges, or the march across the Place of those weary soldiers, coming and going so interminably, one hardly knows whether to or from battle with the English and the Austrians, from victory or defeat : — Well ! he has become like one of our family. " He will go far ! " my father declares. He would go far, in the literal sense, if he might — to Paris, to Rome. It must be admitted that our Valenciennes is a quiet, nay ! a sleepy place ; sleepier than ever since it became French, and ceased to be so near the frontier. The grass is growing deep on our old ramparts, and it is pleasant to walk there — to walk there and muse ; pleasant for a tame, unambitious soul such as mine. December 1702. Antony Watteau left us for Paris this morning. It came upon us quite suddenly. They amuse themselves in Paris. A scene-painter we have here, well known in Flanders, has been engaged to work in one of the Parisian play-houses ; and young Watteau, of whom he had some slight 8 A PRINCE OF COURT PAINTERS knowledge, has departed in his company. He doesn't know it was I who persuaded the scene- painter to take him ; that he would find the lad useful. We offered him our little presents — fine thread-lace of our own making for his ruffles, and the like ; for one must make a figure in Paris, and he is slim and well-formed. For myself, I presented him with a silken purse I had long ago embroidered for another. Well ! we shall follow his fortunes (of which I for one feel quite sure) at a distance. Old Watteau didn't know of his departure, and has been here in great anger. December 1703. Twelve months to-day since Antony went to Paris ! The first struggle must be a sharp one for an unknown lad in that vast, overcrowded place, even if he be as clever as young Antony Watteau. We may think, however, that he is on the way to his chosen end, for he returns not home ; though, in truth, he tells those poor old people very little of himself. The apprentices of the M. Metayer for whom he works, labour all day long, each at a single part only, — coiffure^ or robe, or hand, — of the cheap pictures of religion or fantasy he exposes for sale at a low price along the footways of the Pont Notre-Dame. Antony is already the most skilful of them, and seems to have been promoted of late to work on church pictures. I like the thought of that. 9 IMAGINARY PORTRAITS He receives three livres a week for his pains, and his soup daily. May 1705. Antony Watteau has parted from the dealer in pictures a bon marche, and works now with a painter of furniture pieces (those headpieces for doors and the like, now in fashion) who is also concierge of the Palace of the Luxembourg. Antony is actually lodged somewhere in that grand place, which contains the king's collection of the Italian pictures he would so willingly copy. Its gardens also are magnificent, with something, as we understand from him, altogether of a novel kind in their disposition and embellishment. Ah ! how I delight myself, in fancy at least, in those beautiful gardens, freer and trimmed less stiffly than those of other royal houses. Me- thinks I see him there, when his long summer- day's work is over, enjoying the cool shade of the stately, broad-foliaged trees, each of which is a great courtier, though it has its way almost as if it belonged to that open and unbuilt country beyond, over which the sun is sinking. His thoughts, however, in the midst of all this, are not wholly away from home, if I may judge by the subject of a picture he hopes to sell for as much as sixty livres — Un Depart de Troupes^ Soldiers Departing — one of those scenes of military life one can study so well here at Valenciennes. 10 A PRINCE OF COURT PAINTERS June 1705. Young Watteau has returned home — proof, with a character so independent as his, that things have gone well with him ; and (it is agreed !) stays with us, instead of in the stone- mason's house. The old people suppose he comes to us for the sake of my father's instruction. French people as we are become, we are still old Flemish, if not at heart, yet on the surface. Even in French Flanders, at Douai and Saint Omer, as I understand, in the churches and in people's houses, as may be seen from the very streets, there is noticeable a minute and scrupulous air of care-taking and neatness. Antony Watteau remarks this more than ever on returning to Valenciennes, and savours greatly, after his lodging in Paris, our Flemish cleanliness, lover as he is of distinction and elegance. Those worldly graces he seemed when a young lad almost to hunger and thirst for, as though truly the mere adornments of life were its necessaries, he already takes as if he had been always used to them. And there is something noble — shall I say ? — in his half- disdainful way of serving himself with what he still, as I think, secretly values over-much. There is an air of seemly thought — le bel serieux — about him, which makes me think of one of those grave old Dutch states- men in their youth, such as that famous William the Silent. And yet the effect of this first success 11 IMAGINARY PORTRAITS of his (of more importance than its mere money value, as insuring for the future the full play of his natural powers) I can trace like the bloom of a flower upon him ; and he has, now and then, the gaieties which from time to time, surely, must refresh all true artists, however hard-working and " painful." July 1705. The charm of all this — his physiognomy and manner of being — has touched even my young brother, Jean-Baptiste. He is greatly taken with Antony, clings to him almost too attentively, and will be nothing but a painter, though my father would have trained him to follow his own pro- fession. It may do the child good. He needs the expansion of some generous sympathy or sentiment in that close little soul of his, as I have thought, watching sometimes how his small face and hands are moved in sleep. A child of ten who cares only to save and possess, to hoard his tiny savings ! Yet he is not other- wise selfish, and loves us all with a warm heart. Just now it is the moments of Antony's company he counts, like a little miser. Well ! that may save him perhaps from developing a certain meanness of character I have sometimes feared for him. 12 A PRINCE OF COURT PAINTERS August 1705. We returned home late this summer evening — Antony Watteau, my father and sisters, young Jean-Baptiste, and myself — from an excursion to Saint-Amand, in celebration of Antony's last day with us. After visiting the great abbey-church and its range of chapels, with their costly en- cumbrance of carved shrines and golden reliquaries and funeral scutcheons in the coloured glass, half seen through a rich enclosure of marble and brass- work, we supped at the little inn in the forest. Antony, looking well in his new-fashioned, long- skirted coat, and taller than he really is, made us bring our cream and wild strawberries out of doors, ranging ourselves according to his judg- ment (for a hasty sketch in that big pocket-book he carries) on the soft slope of one of those fresh spaces in the wood, where the trees unclose a little, while Jean-Baptiste and my youngest sister danced a minuet on the grass, to the notes of some strolling lutanist who had found us out. He is visibly cheerful at the thought of. his return to Paris, and became for a moment freer and more animated than I have ever yet seen him, as he discoursed to us about the paintings of Peter Paul Rubens in the church here. His words, as he spoke of them, seemed full of a kind of rich sunset with some moving glory within it. Yet I like far better than any of these pictures of Rubens a work of that old Dutch 13 IMAGINARY PORTRAITS master, Peter Porbus, which hangs, though almost out of sight indeed, in our church at home. The patron saints, simple, and standing firmly on either side, present two homely old people to Our Lady enthroned in the midst, with the look and attitude of one for whom, amid her " glories " (depicted in dim little circular pictures, set in the openings of a chaplet of pale flowers around her) all feelings are over, except a great pitifulness. Her robe of shadowy blue suits my eyes better far than the hot flesh-tints of the Medicean ladies of the great Peter Paul, in spite of that amplitude and royal ease of action under their stiff court costumes, at which Antony Watteau declares himself in dismay. August 1705. I am just returned from early Mass. I lingered long after the office was ended, watch- ing, pondering how in the world one could help a small bird which had flown into the church but could find no way out again. I suspect it will remain there, fluttering round and round distractedly, far up under the arched roof, till it dies exhausted. I seem to have heard of a writer who likened man's life to a bird passing just once only, on some winter night, from window to window, across a cheerfully-lighted hall. The bird, taken captive by the ill-luck of a moment, re-tracing its issueless circle till it A PRINCE OF COURT PAINTERS expires within the close vaulting of that great stone church :— human life may be like that bird too ! Antony Watteau returned to Paris yesterday. Yes ! — Certainly, great heights of achievement would seem to lie before him ; access to regions whither one may find it increasingly hard to follow* him even in imagination, and figure to one's self after what manner his life moves therein. January 1709. Antony Watteau has competed for what is called the Prix de Rome, desiring greatly to profit by the grand establishment founded at Rome by King Lewis the Fourteenth, for the encourage- ment of French artists. He obtained only the second place, but does not renounce his desire to make the journey to Italy. Could I save enough by careful economies for that purpose ? It might be conveyed to him in some indirect way that would not offend. February 17 12. We read, with much pleasure for all of us, in the Gazette to-day, among other events of the great world, that Antony Watteau had been elected to the Academy of Painting under the new title of Peintre des Fetes Galantes, and had been named also Peintre du Roi. My brother, 15 IMAGINARY PORTRAITS Jean-Baptiste, ran to tell the news to old Jean- Philippe and Michelle Watteau. A new manner of painting ! The old furniture of people's rooms must needs be changed throughout, it would seem, to accord with this painting ; or rather, the painting is designed exclusively to suit one particular kind of apartment. A manner of painting greatly prized, as we understand, by those Parisian judges who have had the best opportunity of acquainting themselves with whatever is most enjoyable in the arts : — such is the achievement of the young Watteau ! He looks to receive more orders for his work than he will be able to execute. He will certainly relish — he, so elegant, so hungry for the colours of life — -a free intercourse with those wealthy lovers of the arts, M. de Crozat, M. de Julienne, the Abbe de la Roque, the Count de Caylus, and M. Gersaint, the famous dealer in pictures, who are so anxious to lodge him in their fine hotels, and to have him of their company at their country houses. Paris, we hear, has never been wealthier and more luxurious than now : and the great ladies outbid each other to carry his work upon their very fans. Those vast fortunes,, however, seem to change hands very rapidly. And Antony's new manner ? I am unable even to divine it — to conceive the trick and effect of it — at all. Only, something of lightness and coquetry I discern there, at variance, methinks, 16 A PRINCE OF COURT PAINTERS with his own singular gravity and even sadness of mien and mind, more answerable to the stately apparelling of the age of Henry the Fourth, or of Lewis the Thirteenth, in these old, sombre Spanish houses of ours. March 171 3. We have all been very happy, — Jean-Baptiste as if in a delightful dream. Antony Watteau, being consulted with regard to the lad's training as a painter, has most generously offered to receive him for his own pupil. My father, for some reason unknown to me, seemed to hesitate at the first ; but Jean-Baptiste, whose enthusiasm for Antony visibly refines and beautifies his whole nature, has won the necessary permission, and this dear young brother will leave us to- morrow. Our regrets and his, at his parting from us for the first time, overtook our joy at his good fortune by surprise, at the last moment, just as we were about to bid each other good- night. For a while there had seemed to be an uneasiness under our cheerful talk, as if each one present were concealing something with an effort ; and it was Jean-Baptiste himself who gave way at last. And then we sat down again, still together, and allowed free play to what was in our hearts, almost till morning, my sisters weep- ing much. I know better how to control myself. In a few days that delightful new life will have c 17 IMAGINARY PORTRAITS begun for him : and I have made him promise to write often to us. With how small a part of my whole life shall I be really living at Valenciennes ! January 1 7 14. Jean- Philippe Watteau has received a letter from his son to-day. Old Michelle Watteau, whose sight is failing, though she still works (half by touch, indeed) at her pillow-lace, was glad to hear me read the letter aloud more than once. It recounts — how modestly, and almost as a matter of course ! — his late successes. And yet ! — does he, in writing to these old people, purposely underrate his great good fortune and seeming happiness, not to shock them too much by the contrast between the delicate enjoyments of the life he now leads among the wealthy and refined, and that bald existence of theirs in his old home ? A life, agitated, exigent, unsatisfy- ing !- That is what this letter really discloses, below so attractive a surface. As his gift ex- pands so does that incurable restlessness one sup- posed but the humour natural to a promising youth who had still everything to do. And now the only realised enjoyment he has of all this might seem to be the thought of the inde- pendence it has purchased him, so that he can escape from one lodging-place to another, just as it may please him. He has already deserted, somewhat incontinently, more than one of those 18 A PRINCE OF COURT PAINTERS fine houses, the liberal air of which he used so greatly to affect, and which have so readily re- ceived him. Has he failed truly to grasp the fact of his great success and the rewards that lie before him ? At all events, he seems, after all, not greatly to value that dainty world he is now privileged to enter, and has certainly but little relish for his own works — those works which I for one so thirst to see. March 1714. We were all — Jean-Philippe, Michelle Wat- teau, and ourselves — half in expectation of a visit from Antony ; and to-day, quite suddenly, he is with us. I was lingering after early Mass this morning in the church of Saint Vaast. It is good for me to be there. Our people lie under one of the great marble slabs before the jute, some of the memorial brass balusters of which are engraved with their names and the dates of their decease. The settle of carved oak which runs all round the wide nave is my father's own work. The quiet spaciousness of the place is itself like a meditation, an "act of recollection," and clears away the confusions of the heart. I suppose the heavy droning of the carillon had smothered the sound of his footsteps, for on my turning round, when I supposed myself alone, Antony Watteau was standing near me. Constant observer as he is of the lights and shadows of things, he visits 19 IMAGINARY PORTRAITS places of this kind at odd times. He has left Jean-Baptiste at work in Paris, and will stay this time with the old people, not at our house ; though he has spent the better part of to-day in my father's workroom. He hasn't yet put off, in spite of all his late intercourse with the great world, his distant and preoccupied manner — a manner, it is true, the same to every one. It is certainly not through pride in his success, as some might fancy, for he was thus always. It is rather as if, with all that success, life and its daily social routine were somewhat of a burden to him. April 1 7 14. At last we shall understand something of that new style of his — the Watteau style — so much relished by the fine people at Paris. He has taken it into his kind head to paint and decorate our chief salon — the room with the three long windows, which occupies the first floor of the house. The room was a landmark, as we used to think, an inviolable milestone and landmark, of old Valenciennes fashion — that sombre style, indulging much in contrasts of black or deep brown with white, which the Spaniards left behind them here. Doubtless their eyes had found its shadows cool and pleasant, when they shut themselves in from the cutting sunshine of their own country. But in our country, 20 A PRINCE OF COURT PAINTERS where we must needs economise not the shade but the sun, its grandiosity weighs a little on one's spirits. Well ! the rough plaster we used to cover as well as might be with morsels of old figured arras-work, is replaced by dainty panelling of wood, with mimic columns, and a quite aerial scrollwork around sunken spaces of a pale-rose stuff and certain oval openings — two over the doors, opening on each side of the great couch which faces the windows, one over the chimney-piece, and one above the buffet which forms its vis-a-vis — four spaces in all, to be filled by and by with " fantasies " of the Four Seasons, painted by his own hand. He will send us from Paris arm-chairs of a new pattern he has devised, suitably covered, and a painted clavecin. Our old silver candlesticks look well on the chimney-piece. Odd, faint- coloured flowers fill coquettishly the little empty spaces here and there, like ghosts of nosegays left by visitors long ago, which paled thus, sym- pathetically, at the decease of their old owners ; for, in spite of its new-fashionedness, all this array is really less like a new thing than the last surviving result of all the more lightsome adornments of past times. Only, the very walls seem to cry out : — No ! to make delicate insinuation, for a music, a conversation, nimbler than any we have known, or are likely to find here. For himself, he converses well, but very sparingly. He assures us, indeed, that the 21 IMAGINARY PORTRAITS " new style " is in truth a thing of old days, of his own old days here in Valenciennes, when, working long hours as a mason's boy, he in fancy reclothed the walls of this or that house he was employed in, with this fairy arrange- ment — itself like a piece of " chamber-music," methinks, part answering to part ; while no too trenchant note is allowed to break through the delicate harmony of white and pale red and little golden touches. Yet it is all very comfortable also, it must be confessed ; with an elegant open place for the fire, instead of the big old stove of brown tiles. The ancient, heavy furni- ture of our grandparents goes up, with difficulty, into the garrets, much against my father's inclination. To reconcile him to the change, Antony is painting his portrait in a vast perruque, and with more vigorous massing of light and shadow than he is wont to permit himself. June 1 7 14. He has completed the ovals : — The Four Seasons. Oh ! the summerlike grace, the freedom and softness, of the " Summer " — a hayfield such as we visited to-day, but bound- less, and with touches of level Italian archi- tecture in the hot, white, elusive distance, and wreaths of flowers, fairy hayrakes and the like, suspended from tree to tree, with that wonder- ful lightness which is one of the charms of his 22 A PRINCE OF COURT PAINTERS work. I can understand through this, at last, what it is he enjoys, what he selects by pre- ference, from all that various world we pass our lives in. I am struck by the purity of the room 1 he has re-fashioned for us — a sort of moral purity ; yet, in the forms and colours of things. Is the actual life of Paris, to which he will soon return, equally pure, that it relishes this kind of thing so strongly ? Only, methinks 'tis a pity to incorporate so much of his work, of himself, with objects of use, which must perish by use, or disappear, like our own old furniture, with mere change of fashion. July 1714. On the last day of Antony Watteau's visit we made a party to Cambrai. We entered the cathedral church : it was the hour of Vespers, and it happened that Monseigneur le Prince de Cambrai, the author of Telemaque, was in his place in the choir. He appears to be of great age, assists but rarely at the offices of religion, and is never to be seen in Paris ; and Antony had much desired to behold him. Certainly it was worth while to have come so far only to see him, and hear him give his pontifical blessing, in a voice feeble but of infinite sweetness, and with an inexpressibly graceful movement of the hands. A veritable grand seigneur! His refined old age, the impress of genius and 23 IMAGINARY PORTRAITS honours, even his disappointments, concur with natural graces to make him seem too dis- tinguished (a fitter word fails me) for this world. Omnia vanitas! he seems to say, yet with a profound resignation, which makes the things we are most of us so fondly occupied with look petty enough. Omnia vanitas! Is that indeed the proper comment on our lives, coming, as it does in this case, from one who might have made his own all that life has to bestow ? Yet he was never to be seen at court, and has lived here almost as an exile. Was our " Great King Lewis " jealous of a true grand seigneur or grand monarque by natural gift and the favour of heaven, that he could not endure his presence ? July 1 7 14. My own portrait remains unfinished at his sudden departure. I sat for it in a walking- dress, made under his direction — a gown of a peculiar silken stuff, falling into an abundance of small folds, giving me "a certain air of piquancy " which pleases him, but is far enough from my true self. My old Flemish faille, which I shall always wear, suits me better. I notice that our good-hearted but sometimes difficult friend said little of our brother Jean- Baptiste, though he knows us so anxious on his account — spoke only of his constant industry, 24 A PRINCE OF COURT PAINTERS cautiously, and not altogether with satisfaction, as if the sight of it wearied him. September 1 7 14. Will Antony ever accomplish that long- pondered journey to Italy ? For his own sake, I should be glad he might. Yet it seems desolately far, across those great hills and plains. I remember how I formed a plan for providing him with a sum sufficient for the purpose. But that he no longer needs. With myself, how to get through time becomes sometimes the question, — unavoidably ; though it strikes me as a thing unspeakably sad in a life so short as ours. The sullenness of a long wet day is yielding just now to an outburst of watery sunset, which strikes from the far horizon of this quiet world of ours, over fields and willow-woods, upon the shifty weather-vanes and long-pointed windows of the tower on the square — from which the Angelus is sounding — with a momentary promise of a fine night. I prefer the Salut at Saint Vaast. The walk thither is a longer one, and I have a fancy always that I may meet Antony Watteau there again, any time ; just as, when a child, having found one day a tiny box in the shape of a silver coin, for long afterwards I used to try every piece of money that came into my hands, expect- ing it to open. 25 IMAGINARY PORTRAITS September 1714. We were sitting in the Watteau chamber for the coolness, this sultry evening. A sudden gust of wind ruffled the lights in the sconces on the walls : the distant rumblings, which had con- tinued all the afternoon, broke out at last ; and through the driving rain, a coach, rattling across the Place, stops at our door : in a moment Jean- Baptiste is with us once again ; but with bitter tears in his eyes ; — dismissed ! October 1 7 14. Jean-Baptiste ! he too, rejected by Antony ! It makes our friendship and fraternal sympathy closer. And still as he labours, not less sedu- lously than of old, and still so full of loyalty to his old master, in that Watteau chamber, I seem to see Antony himself, of whom Jean-Baptiste dares not yet speak, — to come very near his work, and understand his great parts. So Jean- Baptiste's work, in its nearness to his, may stand, for the future, as the central interest of my life. I bury myself in that. February 171 5. If I understand anything of these matters, Antony Watteau paints that delicate life of Paris so excellently, with so much spirit, partly 26 A PRINCE OF COURT PAINTERS because, after all, he looks down upon it or despises it. To persuade myself of , that, is my womanly satisfaction for his preference — his apparent preference — for a world so different from mine. Those coquetries, those vain and perishable graces, can be rendered so perfectly, only through an intimate understanding of them. For him, to understand must be to despise them ; while (I think I know why) he nevertheless undergoes their fascination. Hence that dis- content with himself, which keeps pace with his fame. It would have been better for him — he would have enjoyed a purer and more real happiness — had he remained here, obscure ; as it might have been better for me ! It is altogether different with Jean-Baptiste. He approaches that life, and all its pretty nothingness, from a level no higher than its own ; and beginning just where Antony Wat- teau leaves off in disdain, produces a solid and veritable likeness of it and of its ways. March 1715. There are points in his painting (I apprehend this through his own persistently modest obser- vations) at which he works. out his purpose more excellently than Watteau ; of whom he has trusted himself to speak at last, with a wonderful self-effacement, pointing out in each of his pictures, for the rest so just and true, how 27 IMAGINARY PORTRAITS Antony would have managed this or that, and, with what an easy superiority, have done the thing better — done the impossible. February 17 16. There are good things, attractive things, in life, meant for one and not for another — not meant perhaps for me ; as there are pretty clothes which are not suitable for every one. I find a certain immobility of disposition in me, to quicken or interfere with which is like physical pain. He, so brilliant, petulant, mobile ! I am better far beside Jean-Baptiste — in contact with his quiet, even labour, and manner of being. At first he did the work to which he had set him- self, sullenly ; but the mechanical labour of it has cleared his mind and temper at last, as a sullen day turns quite clear and fine by imper- ceptible change. With the earliest dawn he enters his workroom, the Watteau chamber, where he remains at work all day. The dark evenings he spends in industrious preparation with the crayon for the pictures he is to finish during the hours of daylight. His toil is also his amusement : he goes but rarely into the society whose manners he has to re-produce. The animals in his pictures, pet animals, are mere toys : he knows it. But he finishes a large number of works, door-heads, clavecin cases, and the like. His happiest, his most genial moments, 28 A PRINCE OF COURT PAINTERS he puts, like savings of fine gold, into one par- ticular picture (true opus magnum^ as he hopes), The Swing. He has the secret of surprising effects with a certain pearl-grey silken stuff of his predilection ; and it must be confessed that he paints hands — which a draughtsman, of course, should understand at least twice as well as all other people — with surpassing expression. March 1716. Is it the depressing result of this labour, of a too exacting labour? I know not. But at times (it is his one melancholy]) he expresses a strange apprehension of poverty, of penury and mean surroundings in old age ; reminding me of that childish disposition to hoard, which I noticed in him of old. And then — inglorious Watteau, as he is ! — at times that steadiness, in which he is so great a contrast to Antony, as it were accumulates, changes, into a ray of genius, a grace, an inexplicable touch of truth, in which all his heaviness leaves him for a while, and he actually goes beyond the master ; as himself protests to me, yet modestly. And still, it is precisely at those moments that he feels most the difference between himself and Antony Wat- teau. "In tliat country, all the pebbles are golden nuggets," he says ; with perfect good- humour. 29 IMAGINARY PORTRAITS June 1 716. 'Tis truly in a delightful abode that Antony Watteau is just now lodged — the hotel, or town- house of M. de Crozat, which is not only a comfortable dwelling-place, but also a precious museum lucky people go far to see. Jean- Baptiste, too, has seen the place, and describes it. The antiquities, beautiful curiosities of all sorts — above all, the original drawings of those old masters Antony so greatly admires — are arranged all around one there, that the in- fluence, the genius, of those things may imper- ceptibly play upon and enter into one, and form what one does. The house is situated near the Rue Richelieu, but has a large garden about it. M. de Crozat gives his musical parties there, and Antony Watteau has painted the walls of one of the apartments with the Four Seasons, after the manner of ours, but doubtless improved by second thoughts. This beautiful place is now Antony's home for a while. The house has but one story, with attics in the mansard roofs, like those of a farmhouse in the country. I fancy Antony fled thither for a few moments, from the visitors who weary him ; breathing the freshness of that dewy garden in the very midst of Paris. As for me, I suffocate this summer afternoon in this pretty Watteau chamber of ours, where Jean-Baptiste is at work so contentedly. 30 A PRINCE OF COURT PAINTERS May 1717. In spite of all that happened, Jean-Baptiste has been looking forward to a visit to Valen- ciennes which Antony Watteau had proposed to make. He hopes always — has a patient hope — that Anthony's former patronage of him may be revived. And now he is among us, actually at his work — restless and disquieting, meagre, like a woman with some nervous malady. Is it pity, then, pity only, one must feel for the brilliant one ? He has been criticising the work of Jean-Baptiste, who takes his judgments generously, gratefully. Can it be that, after all, he despises and is no true lover of his own art, and is but chilled by an enthusiasm for it in another, such as that of Jean-Baptiste ? as if Jean-Baptiste over- valued it, or as if some ignobleness or blunder, some sign that he has really missed his aim, started into sight from his work at the sound of praise — as if such praise could hardly be altogether sincere. June 1717. And at last one has actual sight of his work — what it is. He has brought with him certain long -cherished designs to finish here in quiet, as he protests he has never finished before. That charming Noblesse — can it be really so distinguished to the minutest point, so naturally 31 IMAGINARY PORTRAITS aristocratic ? Half in masquerade, playing the drawing-room or garden comedy of life, these persons have upon them, not less than the land- scape he composes, and among the accidents of which they group themselves with such a perfect fittingness, a certain light we should seek for in vain upon anything real. For their frame- work they have around them a veritable archi- tecture — a tree -architecture — to which those moss-grown balusters, termes, statues, fountains, are really but accessories. Only, as I gaze upon those windless afternoons, I find myself always saying to myself involuntarily, "The evening will be a wet one." The storm is always brood- ing through the massy splendour of the trees, above those sun-dried glades or lawns, where delicate children may be trusted thinly clad ; and the secular trees themselves will hardly out- last another generation. July 1717. There has been an exhibition of his pictures in the Hall of the Academy of Saint Luke ; and all the world has been to see. Yes ! Besides that unreal, imaginary light upon these scenes, these persons, which is pure gift of his, there was a light, a poetry, in those persons and things themselves, close at hand