lOTiSt A . T, iSmamMm, 'MMi 0^'Xv jimsp}lXL]^f^^3I^ ^\ /79 79 BOUGHT WITH THE INCOME, FROM THE SAGE ENDOWMENT FUND THE GIFT OF 1891 J i...ZiSlU iiCi...l.h.l.ta^.0.^ 7673-2 Cornell University Library arV17979 Another world : 3 1924 031 255 882 olin.anx Cornell University Library The original of tliis book is in tine Cornell University Library. There are no known copyright restrictions in the United States on the use of the text. http://www.archive.org/details/cu31924031255882 ANOTHER WORLD; OR, THE FOURTH DIMENSION. A. T. SCHOFIELD, M.D. •ol St KaTaitudei/res toS atwyot iKetroy nocew.' THIRD EDITION SWAN SONNENSCHEIN & CO., LIM. 25 HIGH STREET, BLOOMSBURV 190S First Edition, /««<;, 1888 ; Second Edition, May, 1897; Third Edition, August, 1905. To PROFESSOR J. H. GLADSTONE, Ph.Di, F.R.S., F.G.S., Etc., ETa» IN GRATEFUL RECOGNITION OF VALUED HELP, THIS BOOK IS DEDICATED BY THE AUTHOR. ANOTHER WORLD; OR, THE FOURTH DIMENSION. INTRODUCTORY. It is undoubtedly the cherished belief of the vast majority of mankind, whether they be Christian, Mohammedan, Hindoo, or Heathen, whether they be savage or civilized, in every quarter of the globe, that there is another world besides the material universe in which we live. All unite in considering that world to be a higher sphere than ours, and its inhabitants to be more or less spiritual beings. It is also generally believed that the beings of that spirit world can and do visit ours, B The Fourth Dimension manifesting themselves in a human or animal shape. When we come, however, to further details of this higher world, we have every diversity of belief and superstition. The only account and description of it to which we, as Christians, attach any credence, is found in the Bible, a book which we regard as a revelation of its rulers, inhabitants, and laws, given to man by the supreme Ruler, not only of the spiritual, but of our material world, God. In our own persons we get confirmation of the existence of a higher sphere, in being able consciously to distinguish between our spiritual, intellectual, and moral selves and our bodies and brains, through which we act and by which we live. Materialists will, we know, have none of this. To them, if true to their creed, there is, and can be, nothing beyond the material. Mind, Introductory. morals, feelings, passions, are to them only protoplasmic changes of ganglion nerve cells, producing carbonic acid gas and water. To them the almost universal consensus of opinion in favour of a spirit world goes for nothing, unless such a world can be demon- strated, handled, and weighed. We therefore propose, in the following pages to discuss from a somewhat new point of view the question of the existence of such a world, what are its powers, its laws, and its relation- ship, with this universe, and in doing so, will observe how far these powers and laws, deduced by analogy from mathematics, correspond to the spiritual claims of the Christian religion. I would here take the opportunity of acknow- ledging my deep indebtedness to the anony- mous author of a small book, called "Flatland," which I have used extensively throughout, and without which I am quite sure the public would never have been troubled with these remarks ; The Fourth Dimension. my object being to carry on the line of argu- ment there brought forward, to what seems to me its true and necessary conclusion. Finally, let me ask the indulgence of my more advanced mathematical readers for the many fallacies and " non-sequiturs " that doubt- less abound, in spite of my true endeavours simply and impartially to draw none but legitimate and logical conclusions from the arguments and facts I have advanced. PREFACE TO THIRD EDITION. Many speculations concerning the fourth di- mension have been made since this book was first issued, notably that by Mr. Wells that it is " Time." But no theory carries conviction, and indeed the whole is a speculation, the interest however of which remains untouched in the close parallel afforded between what would be true of a fourth dimension and all that is written or known concerning the spirit world. A few additions have been made in this edition. A. T, SCHOFIELD. 6 Harley Street, W., August, 1905. CHAPTER I. THE LAND OF NO DIMENSIONS. We are all so habituated to take visible realities around us as a matter of course, and so accustomed to every variety of solid or material form, that why all the universe should be limited to solidity, or three dimensions, is only asked at rare intervals by a few of the more thoughtful among us. To make this plain. Even those unac- customed to algebra will understand that if x represents three inches, or a line of this length, sf {x square) represents 3x3, or nine square inches on a flat surface, three inches each way ; x^ (x cube), again, represents 3 x 3 x 3, or twenty- seven cubic or solid inches, or a solid body measuring three inches every way. Hence we The Fourth Dimension. consider x as representing lines, ^ squares, x? solids, and then comes the question, What does x^ represent? for mathematics passes as easily from x^ to x^ as from x? to x^, and yet while X, xf, x^, refer to objects known to all of us, the wisest can form no possible conception of what X*, or a world of four dimensions, is like. Perhaps, however, before disturbing our minds, and entering seriously upon the question as to whether there can be and is any object or world represented by x*, and whether or no we can comprehend it, my reader will not be offended if, for the benefit of those less learned than himself, I labour in the simplest language further to explain these various dimensions. To begin : No dimension, or size in no direc- tion, is represented mathematically by a point, which is an object described as having no parts or magnitude, thus : — One dimension {x), or size in one direction. The Land of No Dimensions. is represented mathematically by a straight line, which is described as having length with- out breadth, thus : — Two dimensions {xf), or size in two directions, is represented mathematically by a superficies or surface, which is described ,as having length and breadth without thickness, thus : — Three dimensions {x% or size in three direc- tions, is represented mathematically by a solid body, which is described as having length, breadth, and thickness, thus :— 8 The Fourth Dimension. Four dimensions (ar»), or size in four direclions, we cannot represent mathematically, nor can we describe in what direction its fourth dimen- sion lies, nor can we draw, or even imagine it ; the fact being that the whole material world which we can see, and of which we can speak, is a world of three dimensions (or x^) and no more, nor is it possible for the mind of man to indicate or imagine any other direction than three — length, breadth, and height (or depth or thickness, etc.). On this account it is that so many have denied the possibility of there being anything higher than a solid. To show the fallacy of this argument, then, we will consider the imaginary case of an inhabitant of a country where nothing but perfectly flat objects exist, when an endeavour is made to explain to him our own world of solids ; and by putting our- selves in his place, and carefully observing the difficulty he, accustomed only to x' or flatness, The Land of No Dimensions. 9 would have in grasping x^, or solidity, which nevertheless exists, we may understand better that the difficulty we in x^, or solidity, have in our turn of grasping x^, or the fourth dimension, is no argument whatever against the existence of such a world. First of all, however, we will consider the still lower conditions of no dimensions and of one dimension. Imagine, then, a world or universe consisting entirely and absolutely of a single point, a country which therefore possesses neither length, breadth, depth, nor height. Imagine (if you can) the sole being in such a world, and observe what his experience would be, as described in " Flatland." ' " He is himself his own world, his own universe; of any other than himself he can form no conception ; he knows not length, or breadth, or height, for he has no experience of 1 "Flatland." Seeleys. lo The Fourth Dimension. them ; he has no cognizance even of the number two ; for he is himself one and all, being really nothing. Yet mark his perfect self-complacency, and hence learn this lesson, that to be self-contented is to be vile and ignorant, and that to aspire is better than to be blindly and impotently happy. Now listen! There arose from the little buzzing creature a tiny, low, monotonous tinkling, from which I caught these words. ' It fills all space, and what it fills it is, what it thinks that IT utters; and what it utters, that it hears, and it itself is thinker, utterer, hearer. It is the one, and yet the all in all.'" This then gives us an idea of what a world would be that consisted only of one being, and that being having no parts or size. Having duly performed this excruciating effort of imagination, and succeeded in realizing what nothing, or " Pointland," really is, the The Land of No Dimensions. 1 1 exhausted reader had better pause for five minutes before taking the next step higher into the more interesting world of one dimen- sion, or " Lineland," CHAPTER II. THE LAND OF ONE DIMENSION. Let now my faithful reader, somewhat re- cruited from the study of Chapter L, proceed to picture a world of one dimension — a uni- verse that consists only of innumerable straight lines, long and short, all arranged in one and the same interminable straight line — nothing else at all, no deviation to right or left, no right or left even existing to this linear world, still less any height or depth. To duly appreciate and grasp the phenomena of such a world, it would greatly assist the mind if my reader were to arrange a number of pencils or matches in one long line, end to end, and follow the fragments with his eye. The Land of One Dimension. 13 Let not any think that these preliminary studies are needless, for every link in the chain of analogy must be carefully followed, if we are to reach the important conclusions we are here aiming at. Let my reader, then, now retire into his inner consciousness, and proceed to imagine a kingdom or world, as we have said, consist- ing of an infinite number of inhabitants, each one being a shorter or longer straight line, and all arranged in one and the same straight line, thus : If one end of these creatures or lines be furnished with an eye, it is obvious they will each see the end of the line next in front of them, which will be a simple point. None, therefore, in this line (or world) can ever see anything beyond a point. To see a line one must obviously be out of the line (or the Land of One Dimension) altogether. If this is not clear, place your eye at the 14 The Fotirth Dimension. end of any straight line (a needle or knitting needle), and you will only see a single point. Let the mind now proceed to picture a being of two dimensions, such as a square (illustrating it at the same time by a piece of cardboard), furnished with an eye at one of its angles, approaching this world of Lineland (Slide the cardboard square along the table towards the long line of pencils or matches, etc.) ; and then listen to the following remarks from our un- known author. The square speaks. " I saw before me a vast multitude of small straight lines, all moving to and fro in one and the same straight line. Ap- proaching the largest, I accosted it (Here bring the square close to a match), but re- ceived no answer. Losing patience at what appeared to me intolerable rudeness, I brought my mouth into a position full in front of it {Here slide a corner of the square into the line in front of the match), and repeated my The Land of One Dimension. 15 question. ' What signifies this monotonous motion to and fro in one and the same straight line ? ' *" I am the Monarch of the World,' replied the small line. 'But thou, whence intrudes! thou into my realm of Lineland ? ' "Receiving this abrupt reply, I begged pardon ; and by persevering questions ex- tracted the following facts : — "It seems that this poor ignorant monarch, as he calls himself, was fully persuaded that the straight line which he called his kingdom, and in which he passed his existence, consti- tuted the whole of the world, and indeed the whole of space. Not being able either to move or see, save in his straight line, he had no conception of anything out of it " Though he had heard my voice when I first addressed him, the sound had come to him in a manner so contrary to his own ex- perience, that he had made no answer, ' seeing 1 6 The Fourth Dimension. no "man,' as he expressed it, and ' hearing a voice, as it were, from his own inside.' " Until the moment when I placed my mouth in his world, he had not seen me ; nor had he now the least conception of the region from which I had come. Outside his world or line all was blank to him ; nay, not even a blank, for a blank implies space ; say rather, all was non-existent. Such a life, with all vision limited to a point, and all motion to a straight line, seemed to me inexpressibly dreary, and I was surprised to note the vivacity and cheer- fulness of the king." Such were the observations of our supposed living square, and such would be the only life possible, were the world but one straight line. Our square, however, rejoicing in his own two dimensions of breadth as well as length, tries to enlighten the king of Lineland, and pro- ceeds : — " Thinking that it was time to bring down The Land of One Dimension. 17 the monarch from his raptures to the level of common sense, I determined to endeavour to open up to him some glimpses of the truth ; that is to say, of the nature of flat things, or two dimensions. " So I began thus : ' Before I entered your kingdom, I noticed that some of the lines were larger ' " ' You speak of an impossibility,' interrupted the king ; ' you must have seen a vision, for to detect the difference (even) between a line and a point by the sense of sight is, as every one knows, in the nature of things, impossible. How could you see a line, that is to say, the inside of any man ? ' * " ' / can discern a line from a point, and let me prove it. Before I came into your king- dom I saw you dancing backwards and for- * A line having no breadth, its outsides (so to speak) are its two extremities, that which lies between being the inside of the line ; and this inside is naked and open to the eye of our square in two dimensions, but can never be seen by a being in one. This will become clearer as we proceed. C 1 8 The Fourth Dimension. wards, with seven lines and a dot in front of you, and eight lines and a dot behind you.' "He then proceeds to tell the king that there is another motion possible, besides backwards and forwards ; namely, from left to right. " ^ Let me ask,' said the king, ' what you mean by these words "left" and "right." I suppose it is your way of saying northward (forwards) and southward (backwards).' " ' Not so,' replied I ; ' besides your motion of forwards and backwards, there is another motion ; which I call from left to right.' " ' Exhibit to me, if you please, this motion from left to right.' " ' Nay, that I cannot do, unless you could step out of your line altogether.' " ' Out of my line ? Do you mean out of the world ? Out of space ? ' " ' Alas ! How shall I make it clear ? When you move straight on, does it not sometimes occur to you .that you could move in some The Land of One Dimension. 19 other way ? Instead of always moving in the direction of one of your extremities, do you never feel a desire to move in the direction, so to speak, of your side ? ' " ' Never ! And what do you mean ? How can a man move in the direction of his inside ? ' " ' Well then, I will try deeds ; I will gra- dually move out of Lineland in the direction which I desire to indicate to you.' " At this word I began to move my body out of Lineland. As long as any part of me re- mained in his dominion, and in his view, the king kept exclaiming, ' I see you,' But when I had at last moved myself out of his line, he cried, ' He is dead.' (Move card slowly out of the straight line.) '" I am not dead,' replied I; 'I am simply out of Lineland, that is to say, out of the straight line which you call space, and at this moment I can see your line, or side, or inside, as you ai-e pleased to call it.' 20 The Fourth Dimension. " But the monarch replied, ' If you were a man of sense, you would listen to reason. You ask me to believe that there is another line beside that which my senses indicate, and another motion beside that of which I am daily con- scious. I, in return, ask you to describe in words, or to indicate by motion, that other line of which you speak. Instead of moving, you merely exercise some magic art of vanishing and returning to sight. Acknowledge your folly, or depart from my dominion.' " Furious at his perversity, I retorted, ' Be- sotted being, ypu think yourself the perfection of existence, while you are in reality the most imperfect and imbecile. You profess to see, whereas you can see nothing but a point' " We have given these extracts at length, in order that the reader may fully grasp what would be the general conditions of life, pros- pects, and intelligence in a world of one dimen- sion, and also the necessary impossibility of The Land of One Dimension. 21 one in such a world being able to understand the existence of another by argument or illus- tration. Various other suggestive analogies present themselves here, but we will defer their discussion until we have the other dimensions before us, and then consider them all together. In the next chapter, therefore, we will move a step higher, and attentively view life in a world of two dimensions. CHAPTER III. THE LAND OF TWO DIMENSIONS. We must now again tax the imagination of our readers, and ask them to picture a country of two dimensions, where only length and breadth are known. This country our author aptly calls " Flatland," and in order to pre- sent it vividly before our readers, we must again quote extensively. Our old friend, the animated square, speaks.* " Imagine a vast sheet of paper, on which straight lines, triangles, squares, and circles, *This chapter will be better understood if the reader provides himself with a few squares, 'circles, triangles, etc., cut out of cardboard, to represent the inhabitants, — the country being represented by the top of the table on which they are laid ; while a house • in Flatland may be easily made by enclosing a space with bits of cotton. The Land of Two Dimensions. 23 instead of remaining fixed in their places, move freely about on the surface — very much like shadows — and you will have a pretty correct notion of my country and countrymen. In such a country you will perceive at once that it is impossible that there should be anything of what you call a ' solid ' kind, but I daresay you will suppose that we could at least see the triangles, squares, and other figures mov- ing, about as I have described them. On the contrary, nothing was visible, nor could be visible to us, except straight lines." Our readers will see the strict analogy here : that just -as those in one dimension could only see points, not lines, — so those in two dimensions can only see lines, not squares, etc. If the eye is placed on a level (that is, in the same world) with the edge of one of the cardboard figures, whatever its shape, only a straight line will be seen ; for it is only as we rise above or go below it — 24 The Fourth Dimension. that is, enter the third dimension — that we see the shape of the figure. The houses in " Flatland," according to our author and to reason, consist of spaces en- closed by lines, openings being left for doors. Of course the idea of a roof to such houses is necessarily absurd, there being no space ex- cept in length and breadth in that world ; hence the houses are to our ideas open. There is a north, south, east and west ; the first two being equivalent to length and the latter two to breadth. Of course, any being in such a house, when the door was shut, though inaccessible and invisible to any inhabitant of Flatland, could be as easily touched and seen by us if out- side the house. (One of the pieces of card- board placed inside a circle of thread will illustrate this.) Such a world, then, being imagined, thickly peopled with flat figures gliding incessantly The Land of Two Dimensions. 25 to and fro on the surface, or in and out these spaces surrounded by lines, which they call houses, we will now try and understand the extraordinary experiences of our animated square in Flatland, when, after having tried and failed to enlighten the king of one dimension, he is, in his turn, instructed by a being from our world of solids, or three dimensions. The incident occurred thus : — "It was the last day of the year 1999 of our era. My four sons and two orphan grandchildren had retired to their several apartments, and my wife alone remained with me to see the old millennium out and the new one in. " I was wrapt m thought, pondering In my mind some words that had casually issued from the mouth of my youngest grandson. Taking nine squares, each an inch every way, I had put them together so as to form one largfi square with a side of three inches, and 26 The Fourth Dimension. I had proved to my grandson that, though it was impossible for us to see the inside of this, or indeed of any square, yet we might ascertain the number of square inches in a square, simply by squaring the number of inches in the side ; ' and thus,' said I, ' we know that 3°, or 9, represents the number of square inches in a square whose side is three inches long.' "The little Hexagon (my grandson) medi- tated on this awhile, and then said to me : ' But you have been teaching me also to raise numbers to the third power; I suppose 3* must mean something in geometry. What does it mean ? ' " ' Nothing at all,' replied I, ' not at least in geometry; for geometry has only two di- mensions.' And then I began to show the boy how a point, by moving through a length of three inches, makes a line of three inches, which may be represented by 3 ; and how The Land of Two Dimensions. 27 a line of three inches, moving parallel to itself through a length of three inches, makes a square of three inches every way, which may be represented by 3'. " Upon this my grandson, again returning to his former suggestion, took me up rather suddenly, and exclaimed, — " ' Well, then, if a point by moving three inches makes a line of three inches, represented by 3, and if a straight line of three inches moving parallel to itself makes a square of three inches every way, represented by 3°, — it must be that a square of three inches every way moving somehow parallel to itself (but I don't see how) must make a something else (but I don't see what) of three inches every way, — and this must be represented by 3V " Let the reader observe here how the Hexa- gon, by reasoning strictly by analogy, thus dis- covers and describes a cube or solid figure. 28 The Fourth Dimension. "'Go to bed,' said I, a little ruffled by his interruption. ' If you would talk less non- sense, you would remember more sense.' " So my grandson had disappeared in dis- grace. Rousing myself from my reverie, I exclaimed, ' The boy is a fool ! ' " Straightway I became conscious of a pre- sence in the room, and a chilly breath thrilled through my very being. Looking round in every direction, I could see nothing. I re- sumed my seat again, exclaiming, ' The boy is a fool, I say ; 3' can have no distinct mean- ing in geometry.' " At once there came a distinctly audible reply, * The boy is not a fool, and 3^ has an obvious geometrical meaning.' " My wife, as well as myself, heard the words, although she did not understand their meaning ; and both of us sprang forward in the direction of the sound. What was our horror when we beheld before us a figure ! The Land of Two Dimensions. 29 "My wife retreated to her apartment. I began to approach the stranger with the in- tention of taking a nearer view. He remained motionless while I walked round him, begin- ning from his eye, and returning to it again. Circular he was throughout ; there could not be a doubt of it. Then followed a dialogue. (The reader will be much helped if he will illustrate this by first placing a cardboard square inside a large circle of thread, and then place a ball inside the circle ; or, better still, let the surface of a basin of water represent Flatland, and a floating circle of thread and piece of cardboard the house and its inhabit- ant, and then a ball, half immersed, the visitor — capable of sinking through or rising out of Flatland at will.) " /. ' Before your lordship enters into fur- ther communication, would he deign to satisfy the curiosity of one who would gladly know whence his visitor came ? ' 3© The Fourth Dimension. " Stranger. 'From space, sir ; whence else ?' " /. ' Pardon me, my lord ; but is not your lordship already in space — even at this mo- ment ? ' " Stranger. ' Pooh ! What do you know of space ? Define space.' " /. ' Space, my lord, is length and breadth, indefinitely prolonged.' " Stranger. ' Exactly. You see you do not even know what space is. You think it is of two dimensions only ; but I have come to announce to you a third — height, as well as breadth and length.' "/. 'Your lordship is. pleased to be meri-y. We also speak of length and height (which are the same), or breadth and thickness (which are the same), thus denoting two dimensions by four names. " Stranger. ' But I mean not only three names, but three dimensions.' " /. ' Would your lordship indicate or ex- The Land of Two Dimensions. 31 plain to me in what direction is the third dimension ? " Stranger. ' I came from it. It is up above and down below.' " /. ' My lord means, seemingly, that it is northward and southward.' " Stranger. ' I mean nothing of the kind. I mean a direction in which you cannot look, because you have no eye in your side.' " (If the reader makes a dot for an eye on the cardboard square, he will see that such an eye in the "side" of the square would look upwards. Observe also that the borders of the square form its outside, and all of it that can be seen by any one on the same level, and that the surface of the square is its inside, enclosed by the four borders.) " /. ' Pardon me, my lord ; a moment's in- spection will convince your lordship that I have a perfect luminary at the junction of two of my sides.' " 32 The Fourth Dimension. The reader will see the square palls his borders sides, whereas the stranger refers to the surface of the square. Both may be called sides ; thus a cardboard square has four sides, or two sides.* " Stranger. ' Yes ; but in order to see into space you ought to have an eye, not in your border, but in your side — that is, what you would probably call your inside; but we in Spaceland call it your side,' " /. 'An eye in my inside ! An eye in my stomach ! ! Your lordship jests.* " Stranger. 'I am in no jesting humour, I tell you I came from space. From that position of advantage I discerned your houses, yea, even your insides, all lying open to my view.' "/. 'Such assertions are easily made, my lord.' " Stranger. ' How shall I convince him i* Surely a plain statement of facts, followed by * By analogy these are of course " insides." The Land of Two Dimensions. 33 ocular demonstration, ought to suffice. Now, sir, listen to me. You are living in a plane. I am not a plane (or flat) figure, but a solid. You call me a circle, but I am a sphere. Your country of two dimensions is not spacious enough to represent me, — a being of three; but can only exhibit a slice or section of me> which is what you call a circle. See, now I will rise, and the effect on your eye will be that my circle will become smaller and smaller, till It dwindles to a point, and finally vanishes.' " There was no ' rising ' that I could see ; but he diminished, and finally vanished, and then, after a while, reappeared and regained his original size. He heaved a deep sigh, for he perceived I had altogether failed to comprehend him. Indeed, I was now inclin- ing to the belief that he was an extremely clever juggler. "After a long pause he continued our dia- logue D 34 i he Fourth Dimension. " ' How many sides has a square, and how many angles ? ' " /. ' Four sides and four angles,' " Sphere. ' Now stretch your imagination a little, and conceive a square in Flatland (you are a square) with its side, or what you call its inside, moving parallel to itself, up- wards.' " (The reader performs this by just gradually' raising the cardboard square from the ■ table and parallel with it.) " /. ' What ! northward ? ' " Sphere. ' No ; not northward ; upward- out of Flatland altogether.' " Restraining my impatience, I replied : ' And what may be the nature of the figure which I am to shape out by this motion which you are pleased to denote by the word " upward " ? ' " Sphere. ' A cube, with eight terminal points (or angles).' * This is exactly what the grandson suggested. The Land of Two Dimensions. 35 " /. ' And how many sides will pertain to this being whom I am to generate by the motion of my " inside " in an " upward " direction ? ' " Sphere. ' The cube which you will generate will be bounded by six sides — that is to say, six of your insides. You see it all now, eh ? ' " ' Monster ! ' I shrieked, ' be thou juggler, enchanter, dream or devil, no more will I endure thy mockeries. Either thou or I must perish.' "And saying these words, I precipitated myself upon him. It was in vain. I could feel him slowly slipping from my contact — not edging to the right or left, but moving somehow out of the world, and vanishing to nothing. But I still heard the intruder's voice. " Sphere. ' Why will you refuse to listen to reason ? I had hoped to find in you a fit apostle for the gospel of three dimensions. * Observe the inside of one dimension is always the out- side of the dimension higher. 36 The Fourth Dimension. Listen, my friend. I have told you I can see from my position in space the inside of all things that you consider closed. For ex- ample, I see in yonder cupboard, near which you are standing, several of what you call boxes (but like everything else in Flatland, they have no tops or bottoms) full of money. I see also two tablets of accounts. I am about to descend into that cupboard, and to bring you one of those tablets. I saw you lock the cupboard half an hour ago, and I know you have the key in your possession. But I descend from space ; the door, you see, remains unmoved. Now I am in the cup- board, and am taking the tablet. Now I have it. Now I ascend with it.' " I rushed to the closet, and dashed the door open. One of the tablets was gone; At the same time it appeared on the floor of the room." All this, however, failed to convince our The Land of Two Dtmensions. 37 square, who at last threw himself in impotent rage upon the apparent circle again. The sphere then, unwilling to leave him in his ignorance, as a last resource lifted our poor square right up out of Flatland — out of the land of two dimensions altogether — into our world of spar*\. of three dimensions. Here we will follow him in the next chapter. CHAPTER IV. THE LAND OF THREE DIMENSIONS. The first object that met the bewildered gaze of our square, when thus finally translated from the world of two dimensions into that of three, was the perfect figure of the sphere beside him, still appearing as a curiously shaded flat circle, this being the first surface he had ever gazed upon ; all flat objects, when in his own country, appearing, as we have seen, as straight lines. He then turned his wondering eyes down- wards, and beheld to his amazement Flatland as it really was, with its flat inhabitants of different shapes all snugly ensconced in their different rooms of their roofless houses, all of which were of course now perfectly open to 38 The Land of Three Dimensions. 39 his view. He could gaze down upon his own house and the room he had just quitted, and could see his wife and children. He, in his turn, now could look into his own locked cabinet, and discern the very tablets already spoken of But as he was carried higher he saw more. His whole native city, hitherto known to him only as lines, lay revealed, with the shape of every inhabitant equally plainly to be seen, whether in the street or within doors. Naturally he thought at first he had become a god, in thus seeing all that he had only sur- mised before. With the sphere as his guide, he then travelled on through space, till beneath him he saw the interior of the great judgment hall of Flatland, with all its wise men assembled. He then heard the following decree, to his dismay, read out before them all. " Whereas the States had been troubled by 40 The Fourth Dimension. divers ill-intentioned persons pretending to have received revelations from another world, it has been for this cause unanimously re- solved by the Grand Council to make strict search for such misguided persons, to scourge and imprison any triangle, and to arrest any one of higher rank, to be examined and judged by the council." " You hear your fate," the sphere re- marked ; " death or imprisonment awaits the apostle of the gospel of three dimensions." " Not so," replied our square ; " the matter is now so clear to me, the nature of real space so palpable, that methinks I could make a child understand it. Permit me but to de- scend at this moment and enlighten them." "Not yet," said the sphere, who then taking our friend with him further into space, pro- ceeded to introduce him to solid figures, be- ginning with a cube. Taking a number of square cards (the reader The Land of Three Dimensions. 41 can do this if he have enough), each the shape of his friend, he placed them one on another till they were as high as they were broad, and thus he built up a cube. To the uneducated eye of the square, how- ever, accustomed only to see lines and points, and to whom the sight of even a flat surface was a new revelation, this solid form (like the sphere) appeared to be an irregular six-sided flat figure thus, (i) — not a solid like this, (2)- Fig. I. Fig. 2. The reader can verify this by closing one eye, and drawing the outlines of a cube seen sideways, on paper. It was not until some time after, when he 42 The Fourth Dimension. had by the direction of his friend carefully felt its six sides and its eight angles, and walked round and round and under and over it, and had many views of it in different lights, that the stupendous fact began to dawn upon him, that this new world which he had entered, not only enabled him to see all objects in his own familiar Flatland in a new and truer light, but contained bodies of a fresh and glorious order, utterly transcending all his powers of imagination or description, and of a form so novel, so unexpected, as to be incredible, were it not that his senses convinced him of their ex- istence. It took, indeed, a long time for him to understand that the surfaces he saw of the sphere and cube, thus, — The Land of Three Dimensions. 43 were not their interiors, thus : — Once our friend the square had, however, fairly grasped, as far as he could, the fact that he now beheld in actual fact the realization of the mathematical formula of 3^, and of that problem of his grandson he had scouted as being alike unreasonable and impossible, he was not content to stop here. See now in the words of our author to what he aspired. " I thirsted," says he, " for yet deeper know- ledge than he (the sphere) was offering to me. " Pardon me," said I, " O thou whom I must no longer address as the perfection of beauty ; let me beg of thee to vouchsafe thy servant a sight of thine interior." * Observe the surface of a higher dimension appears to be the interior to the dimension below. 44 The Fourth Dimension, "Sphere. 'My what?' " /. ' Thine interior, thy stomach ! ' " Sphere. 'Whence this ill-timed, impertinent request ? And what mean you by saying that I am no longer the perfection of all beauty ? ' " /. ' My lord, your own wisdom has taught me to aspire to one even more great, more beautiful, than yourself. As you yourself, superior to all Flatland forms, combine many circles in one, so doubtless there is one above you, who combines many spheres in one supreme existence, surpassing even the solids of Spaceland. And even as we who are now in space look down on Flatland, and see the insides of all things, so of a certainty there is yet above us some higher, purer region, -whither thou dost surely purpose to lead me, from the vantage ground of which we shall look down upon the revealed insides of all solid things.' The Land of Three Dimensions. 45 "Sphere. 'Pooh! Stuff! Enough of this trifling.' " /. ' Nay — deny me not what I know it is in thy power to perform. Grant me but one glimpse of thine interior.* " Sphere. 'Well then, to content and silence you, let me say at once, I cannot. Would you have me turn my stomach inside out to oblige you?' " /. ' But my lord has shown me the insides of all my countrymen in the land of two dimensions by taking me into the land of three. What therefore more easy than to take his servant a second journey into the blessed region of the fourth dimension, where I shall look down with him once more upon this land of three dimensions, and see the inside of every three-dimensioned house, and the inside of every solid living creature ? ' ''Sphere. 'But where is this land of four dimensions ? ' 46 Thi Fourth Dimension. "I. 'I know not ; but doubtless my teacher knows.' " Sphere. 'Not I. There is no such land. The very idea of it is utterly inconceivable.' " /. ' Trifle not with me, my lord. I crave and thirst for more knowledge. Doubtless we cannot see that other higher Spaceland now, because we have no eye in our stomachs. But, just as there was the realm of Flatland, though that poor puny Lineland monarch could turn neither to left nor right, and just as there was close at hand, touching my frame, the land of three dimensions, though I, blind and sense- less wretch, had no power to touch it, no eye in my interior to discern it ; so, of a surety, there is a fourth dimension, which my lord perceives with the inner eye of thought. " ' In one dimension did not a moving point produce a line with two terminal points ? "'In two dimensions did not a moving line produce a square with four terminal points ? The Land of Three Dimensions. 47 '"In three dimensions did not a moving square produce a cube with eight terminal points ? "'And in four dimensions shall not a cube — alas for analogy, and alas for the progress of truth, if it be not so-^result in a still more divine organization with sixteen terminal points ? Behold the infallible confirmation of the series, 2, 4, 8, 16. Is not this a geometrical progression strictly according to analogy ? I ask, there- fore, is it, or is it not, a fact that ere now your countrymen also have witnessed the descent of beings of a higher order than their own, entering closed rooms, even as your lordship entered mine, without the opening of doors or windows, and appearing and vanishing at will ? On the reply to this question I am ready to stake everything.' "Sphere. ' It is reported so. But men are divided in opinion as to the facts. Therefore pray have done with this trifling, and let us return to business.' 4^ The Fourth Dimension. " /. 'I was certain of it.' " Sphere. ' But most people say these visions arose from the brain.' " /. ' Say they so ? Oh ! believe them not ; or if indeed it be so, that this other space is. really Thoughtknd, then take me to that blessed region where ' " My words were cut short by a crash out- side, which impelled me through space — down — down — down to Flatland. Then a darkness, and when I came to myself, I was once more a common creeping square, in my study at home, " I awoke rejoicing, and began to reflect on the glorious career before me. I would go forth, methought, at once, and evangelize the whole of Flatland. I would begin with my wife. "Just as I had decided, I heard a herald's proclamation. Listening attentively, I recog- nized the words of the resolution of the council. The Land of Three Dimensions. 49 enjoining the arrest or imprisonment of any who should pervert the minds of the people by delusions, and by professing to have re- ceived revelations from another world. I re- flected the danger was not to be trifled with. Why not therefore make my first experiment with my little grandson, with whom I should be in perfect safety, for he would know nothing of the proclamation of the council ? " I therefore immediately sent for my grand- son, and taught him once more how a point by motion in one dimension produces a line ; and how a straight line in two dimensions pro- duces a square. After this, forcing a laugh, I said, ' And now, you scamp, you wanted to make me believe that a square may in the same way, by motion "upward, not north- ward," produce another figure, a sort of extra square in three dimensions.' " ' Dear grandpapa,' he said, ' that was only my fun, and of course I meant nothing at all 50. The Fourth Dimension. by it ; and I don't think I said anything about the third dimension; and I am sure I did not say one word about " upward, not north- ward," * for that would be such nonsense, you know. How could a thing move upward, not northward ? Even if I were a baby, I could not be so absurd as that. How silly it is! Ha! ha! hal' " ' Not at all silly,' said I, losing my temper ; ' here, for example, I take this square,' — and at the word I grasped a movable square which was lying at hand, — ' and move it, you see, not northward but, yes, I move it upward — that is to say, not northward, but I move it somewhere — not exactly like this — but somehow.' * This diagram shows what is meant by "upward, not north- ward;" upward being the direc- tion of the third dimension, a direction impossible to be even conceived by an inhabitant of two dimensi'^ns, familiar as it is to us. A. upward The Land of Three Dimensions. 51 " Here I brought my sentence to an inane conclusion, shaking the square about in a purposeless manner, much to the amuse- ment of my grandson, who burst out laughing louder than ever, and declaring I was joking with him, ran away. Thus ended my first attempt to convert a pupil to the gospel of three dimensions." Our poor square then shut himself up and tried to write a book on the subject, but was greatly hampered for want of illus- trations, which he found impossible to draw, or words to convey his meaning, which he found he could not coin. Meanwhile, his life was under a cloud. He could not help comparing what he saw in two dimensions with the reality of Flat- land as seen from three. One day he tried to see a cube with his eyes shut, but was not quite certain he had realized the original. This urged him to take some further steps 52 The Fourth Dimension, to make the revelation known, but how to begin he knew not. At times he could not restrain dangerous utterances, dropping such expressions as the "eye that discerns the interior of things," " the all-seeing one," and " the third and fourth dimensions"; and at last he was drawn at a debating society, one day, to give a full account of his glorious journey into Space and of all he had seen and learned there. He was at once arrested, and taken before the great council, to whom he retold all his story. At the close of a long examination he was finally asked two questions : — 1. Whether he could indicate the direc- tion which he meant when he used the words, " upward, not northward " ? 2. Whether, by any diagrams or descriptions (other than the enumeration of imaginary sides and angles), he could indicate the figure he called a cube ? The Land of Three Dimensions. 53 As it was obviously impossible for him to comply with either of these apparently reason- able demands, our unfortunate square was finally sentenced to perpetual imprisonment. Here, for many years, he ceaselessly tried to teach the gospel of three dimensions to his fellow-prisoners, but alas ! without the slightest effect, being universally regarded as a harmless monomaniac. Here, then, we bid our square friend a final adieu, and leave the little book in which his story is enshrined, to consider further the laws of a fourth dimension. CHAPTER V. THE LAND OF FOUR DIMENSIONS MATHE- MATICALLY CONSIDERED. In now summing up the result of all that has been said, and trying to carry the facts that have been observed in the relation of the first to the second, and the second to the third dimension into the relations of the third to the fourth, we will first of all consider this higher and unknown dimension as a mathe- matical figure, and secondly enumerate some of the probable laws of a world of such dimensions and its inhabitants, as deduced by analogy, and their possible relations with our world and its inhabitants. Then we may further consider the actual facts around us bearing on the question, and The Land of Four Dimensions. 55 compare these deduced laws of the fourth dimension with some of the claims of Christi- anity as stated in the Bible. Let us then, first of all, consider the mathematical or geometrical side of the ques- tion, and inquire what would be the character of regular figures in the fourth dimension, arguing from analogy. And in so doing, we must warn the reader that the subject is necessarily somewhat in- volved and intricate ; but that nevertheless the conclusions arrived at are so fascinating and novel, that if he will only traverse the preliminary Sahara in patience, he will prob- ably feel rewarded by the subsequent oasis he reaches in the summing up and applica- tion of the whole theory. Let us therefore proceed to set forth the facts in order. IN ONE DIMENSION we get— (i) Straight lines, 56 The Fom'th Dimension. (2) Varying only in one direction — length ; (3) Having two terminal points (or sides or outsides, the line between these being the in- side) ; and (4) Seen only (by a single eye in line with them) as points. IN r;^C> DIMENSIONS we get - (i) Surface or flat figures, (2) Varying in two directions — length and breadth, also in number of sides and angles (we also get irregular figures of one dimension, but lying in two, as curved or crooked lines ;) (3) Having not less than three * terminal points or angles, and not less than three borders or boundary lines, or sides or outsides (the surface of the figure being the inside) ; and (4) Seen only (by a single eye on a level with them) as lines. * No flat figure can have less than three angles and three borders, viz., a triangle ; for two straight lines cannot en- close a space. (Circles and curved lines are not considered, being really an infinite number of straight lines.) The Land of Four Dimensions. 57 IN THREE DIMENSIONS we get— (i) Solids, (2) Varying only in three directions — length, breadth, depth, also in number and regularity of sides and angles (we also get irregular figures of two dimensions, but lying in three, as curved or crooked surfaces) ; (3) Haying not less than four* terminal points or angles, and not less than four borders, surfaces, or sides or outsides (the contents being the insides) ; and (4) Seen only (by a single eye f) as surfaces. IN FOUR DIMENSIONS we get (by analogy) — * A solid body cannot have fewer than four angles and sides, viz., a solid triangle. (Circular and curved bodies are not considered, being composed of an infinite number of sides.) t We see bodies as solids, not surfaces, simply because we have two eyes, and can see them from two points of view at once. The stereoscope is founded on this fact. 58 The Fourth Dimension. (i) Unnamed bodies, (2) Varying only in foiir directions, lengthy breath, depth, and , also in number and regularity of size and angles (we also get irregular bodies of three dimensions, but lying in four ; as ) ; (3) Having not less than five terminal points or angles, and not less than five borders,, solids, or sides or outsides ; and (4) Seen only (by a double eye) as solids. Turning now to consider some of the pro- bable laws deducible by analogy from these data and the foregoing chapters, we may suggest the following, the general truth of which the reader will probably be now prepared to admit. Some of the relations of a being ik > J) j3 .S §■§ 3^ • p o o . . H O <'> I, 3 lis 3 _ 5 'O - o (/I OJ in — ^ '« tn (M -Si .s-s (u s IS 00 01 to « O 4-J c S2.S 2 g Si ^Sj5 »^ a> oQ c '? ^^ N ^ r! o 43 ■rt „ CD 2 U, <2 " S2 S3 X C C 2 41 o c •"fee .So" ■^;=!-g M.s .B * Pi a, ^' '.: 2 V. — "^ -* 1> CIS „ O 4J ^ •a c S3 53 13 u-S «!.fl a.S c^ fJ , •■5 p.4ji: ^ ^( 1- M ■-5 g-iiS u 3 C4 .Sf) 3 " "-5 «|dSc« n! ♦^ ri « (-1 J3 .S c 5 « TS-d a>.g*-§ £5 "O S " o !5 O 0^ E •« ft ic 00 CO ooco CO ooeooo I I ^ ^^^ d 02 C3 c^ 1 ! i 1 1 III ^CT-fOO EQ