.<- 
 
 
 K'^-- 
 
 
 
 '"^.^^ 
 
 ~^>^^^'^' 
 
 
 ..iijilffiiili 
 
^ 
 ?6^ 
 
 ClorneU Unioeraitg ffithratg 
 
 Dt^ata, I7nn Qnrh 
 
 (1.:^, Hov±Vvwl5^ 
 
SlOmGE 
 
 ine aate snows wtien this volume was taken. 
 
 To renew tliis book copy the call No. and give 
 to the librarian. 
 
 HOME USE RULES 
 
 All Books subject to recall 
 All borrowers must regis- 
 ter in tha -librarv to bor- 
 row books for home use. 
 
 All books must be re- 
 turned at end of college 
 year for inspection and 
 lepaira. 
 
 Limited books must be 
 returned within the four 
 week limit and not renewed. 
 
 Students must return all 
 books before leaving town. 
 Officers should arrange for 
 the return of books wanted 
 during their absence from 
 town. 
 
 Volumes of periodicals 
 and of pamphlets are held 
 in the library as much as 
 possible. For special pur- 
 poses they are given out 
 for a limited time. 
 
 Borrowers should not use 
 their library privileges for 
 the benefit of other persons. 
 
 Books of special value 
 and gift books* when the 
 giver wishes It, are not al- 
 lowed to circulate. 
 
 Readers are asked to re- 
 port all cases of books 
 marked or mutilated. 
 
 Do not deface books by marks and writing. 
 
 Cornell University Library 
 Z5055.U4 P54 
 Bibliographvof,PhiBeta^^K^^^^^^^ 
 
 3 1924 029 572 991 
 
 olin 
 
The original of this book is in 
 the Cornell University Library. 
 
 There are no known copyright restrictions in 
 the United States on the use of the text. 
 
 http://www.archive.org/details/cu31924029572991 
 

 
 /<f/3-20 
 
 
^4^13<ro 
 
Volume 1 
 
 Natinttcr 12 
 
 (£ontent0 
 
 A Bibliography of Phi Beta Kappa 
 
 Members in Foreign Lands 
 
 The Amherst Chapter's Housewarming 
 
 Poem— The Prophecy of Youth 
 
 Henry Leland Chapman 
 
 The 13th Ai^niversary of the Delta of Pennsylvania 
 
 Respecting Institutions Applying for Charters 
 
 The Secretary's Postscript 
 
 MAY, 1913 
 
/ 
 
 THE 
 
 "STANDARD" 
 
 Phi Beta Kappa Key 
 
 MANUFACTURED BY 
 
 Uhe D. L. AULD COMPANY 
 
 Fraternity Jeivelers 
 
 Columbus, OHio 
 
 CHaracterized by the Correct- 
 ness of Design, Superior ^ 
 Die- Work and Finish. 
 
 Illustrated *Pri<x List Sent on 'H^uest 
 
 Selections of Keys forwarded" on 
 
 memotandum to Chapter 
 
 Secretaries. 
 
 MBNTION MAQAZrNB 
 
The Phi Beta Kappa Key 
 
 Volume i MAY, 1913. Number 12 
 
 Issued by authority ot the Tenth National Council of the United Chapters 
 of the Phi Beta Kappa. 
 
 Officers : President, Edwin A. Grosvenor, Amherst, Mass. ; Secretary 
 and Treasurer, Oscar M. Voorhees, 350 B. 146th St., New York, N. T. 
 
 Editorial Office, 350 E. 146th St., New York, N. T. 
 
 A BIBLIOGRAPHY OF PHI BETA KAPPA 
 
 By Professor Clark S. Northup, Cornell, '93. 
 
 Some years ago I became convinced that a bibliography of the 
 Phi Beta Kappa Society, which has now existed for more than a 
 century and a third, should be compiled, and that such a work 
 would demonstrate that the Society had had a not inconsiderable 
 influence on American letters. The present attempt, however 
 great may be its imperfections, it seems to me amply justifies my 
 belief. A large number of our best public addresses, and a re- 
 spectable number of poems of merit, have been delivered originally 
 before gatherings of the Phi Beta Kappa; and thus the aims 
 and ideals of the Society have found expression in literature of 
 enduring excellence. 
 
 I desire to express my deep gratitude to those who have co-op- 
 erated in this undertaking and whose names will appear in a list 
 at the end of the work. In some cases the amount of work 
 necessitated was considerable, and it is duly appreciated. 
 
 The following arrangement has been adopted : 
 
 1. Books and articles relating to the Fraternity in general. 
 The order is alphabetical by authors. 
 
 2. Publications relating to individual chapters. The order is 
 chronological. 
 
 a. Catalogues. 
 
 b. Orations and addresses. 
 
 c. Poems. 
 
 d. General articles. 
 
 3. Portraits contained in publications of the Fraternity. 
 
 It should be added that many of the chapter catalogues contain 
 
 3 
 
brief though well written sketches of the history of the Fra- 
 ternity. Only the more elaborate of these have been included in 
 the list under No. i. Nor has any account been rendered of 
 the college and university annuals, usually published by the 
 junior class, in which the names of the active members of the 
 various chapters are recorded. 
 
 I shall be grateful to any one who will inform me of omissions 
 -or errors in these lists. All such information will be embodied 
 in a supplementary Hst. 
 
 I. Books and Articles Relating to the Fraternity in 
 
 General. 
 
 Charles Francis Adams. Three Phi Beta Kappa addresses : 
 A college fetich, 1883; "Shall Cromwell have a statue?" 1902; 
 some modern college tendencies, 1906. Boston. Houghton, Miff- 
 lin Co. 1907. 8vo., pp. vi, 200. 
 
 See also Harvard Oration.s and Addresses. 1883 ; Chicago Orations and 
 .Vddresses, 1902 ; Columbia Orations and Addresses, 1906. 
 
 [Avery Allyn.j Ritual of Freemasonry, to which is added 
 .a key to the Phi Beta Kappa, the Orange and Odd Fellows socie- 
 ties, with notes. Boston. [1831.] i2mo. 
 
 Another edition was published in New Yorl: in 1856, i2mo., pp. 269, and 
 .a few years ago the first edition was reprinted. The part relating to Phi 
 Beta Kappa is quoted by J. D. Warner in his article in The D. K. E. Quar- 
 terly, October, 1886, v. 15-30. 
 
 William Raymond Baird. Manual of American college 
 fraternities. New York. 1879. In the 6th ed., 1905, pp. 35- 
 43. In the 7th ed., 1912, pp. 548-57. 
 
 Timothy Bigelow. See Harvard Orations and Addresses, 
 1797. 
 
 Edward A. Birge. The Latin words corresponding to the 
 initials S. P. on the medal of Phi Beta Kappa. In Plii Beta 
 Kappa Publications, N. S. 8, pp. 5-14. 1909. 
 
 The meaning of "S. P." The Nation, Oct. 24, 1907, Ixxxv, 
 374. Same in The Evening Post, Dec. 28, 1907. 
 
 Henry Leland Chapman. Historical sketch. In Catalogue 
 of the Fraternity of Phi Beta Kappa, Alpha of Maine, pp. 3-7. 
 1888. 
 
 4 
 
Arthur Copeland. Men and Days in Phi Beta Kappa. Writ- 
 ten and published for the New York Kappa Chapter of Plii Beta 
 Kappa of Syracuse University. [Newark, N. Y. Cop. 1907.J 
 8vo., pp. 143. Frontisp. and portrs. 
 
 Lincoln Cromwell. Address of welcome [at the Tenth Tri- 
 ennial Council.] In The Key, March, 1911, i. 4, 7-8. 
 
 Edwin G. Dexter. High-grade men; in college and out. In 
 The Popular Science Monthly. March, 1903, Ixii, 429-35. 
 
 Comment by A. L. Lowell in The Atlantic Monthly, October, 
 1903, xcii, 512-20. 
 
 Edward Fitch. Phi Beta Kappa. In The Classical Weekly, 
 March 6, 1909, ii, 143. 
 
 Edwin Augustus Grosvenor. Philosophy the guide of life. 
 Delivered before the Ninth Triennial Council, September 11-12, 
 1907. In Phi Beta Kappa Publications, N. S. 6, pp. 29-36. 1907. 
 
 Address [at the Tenth National Council.] In The Key, 
 March, 191 1, i, 4, 9-10. 
 
 Edward Everett Hale. A fossil from the Tertiary. In The 
 Atlantic Monthly, July, 1879, xliv, 98-106. 
 
 John Lesslie Hall. Mother land. A poem read at the 
 Ninth Triennial Council, September 11-12, 1907. In Phi Beta 
 Kappa Publications, N. S. 6, pp. 26-28. 1907. 
 
 George Birkbeck Hill. In Harvard College by an Oxonian, 
 New York. Macmillan. 1875. Chapter 6, pp. 107-119. 
 
 Albert P. Jacobs. The Greek letter societies. 
 
 George Dwight Kellogg. Historical sketch of Phi Beta 
 Kappa. In Catalogue of inembers (i8^s-i8g8). Yale Chapter 
 of Phi Beta Kappa, pp. 5-12. 1898. 
 
 The New York Literary Gazette and Phi Beta Kappa Reposi- 
 tory was published under the above title from September 10, 
 1825, till March 4, 1826. It then dropped the second part of the 
 title, on the ground that the help promised by members of the 
 Fraternity had not been given. Described by Oscar M. Voor- 
 hees in The Key, Oct., 191 1, i, 5, 36-8. 
 
 The Key [poem]. In The Key, Jan., 1912, i, 6, 15. 
 Translation by Ernest H. Riedel in same, March, 1912, i, 7, 40. 
 
 5 
 
John Adams Lowe. Eben Burt Parsons, Secretary and Treas- 
 urer, 1889-1901. In The Key, Jan., 191 1, i, 2, 23-25. 
 
 Clark Sutherland Northup. The aims of Phi Beta Kap- 
 pa. In The Cornell Era, October, 1906, xxxix, 29-31. 
 
 Eben Burt Parsons. Phi Beta Kappa : offifcers, constitution, 
 minutes, etc., of the United Chapters. Officers, customs, statis- 
 tics, etc., of the forty chapters. WilHamstown. 1897. 8vo., 
 pp. 28. 
 
 Phi Beta Kappa: handbook and general catalogue of the 
 United Chapters. North Adams, Mass. Walden & Crawley. 
 1900. 8vo., pp. 256. 
 
 As secretary Mr. Parsons edited the publications of the United 
 Chapters issued during his incumbency. 
 
 Ervin Louis Phillips. A history of the Phi Beta Kappa 
 Fraternity. A thesis submitted for the degree of A. B. at Cor- 
 nell University, 1891. Unpublished. A typewritten copy is de- 
 posited in the Cornell University Library. 
 
 John T. Pickard. General history. In Catalogue of the Al- 
 pha of Missouri, 1901-1909, pp. 5-24. Columbia, Mo., 1909. 
 
 Francis Wayland Shepardson. Historical sketch. In Cata- 
 logue of the Chicago Chapter, pp. 5-20. Chicago, 1909. 
 
 Edwiard L. Thorndike. The careers of scholarly men in 
 America. In The Century, May, 1903, Ixvi, 153-5. 
 Comment in The Evening Post, May 5, 1903. 
 
 Herbert Cushing Tolman. A brief history of the Phi Beta 
 Kappa Society. In The Yale Monthly Magazine, March, 1906, 
 i, 88-96. 
 
 — Preface. In Catalogue of the Vanderbilt chapter of Phi 
 Beta Kappa, pp. 3-8. Nashville, Tenn. 1906. 
 
 The United Chapters of Phi Beta Kappa. Constitution. [1882]. 
 32mo., pp. 4. 
 
 — Constitution and minutes of the Third Triennial Council. 
 1889. 8vo., pp. [16]. 
 The minutes were also published separately, pp. [8]. 
 — Phi Beta Kappa: Officers, constitution, etc. Compiled by 
 Rev. E. B. Parsons. WilHamstown. 1897. 8vo., pp. 28. 
 {To be continued.) 
 6 
 
volume 2 
 
 Namber 2 
 
 (Eontents 
 
 Page 
 
 Three Sonnets-^Thought, Art, Immortality . 53 
 
 New Officers of the United Chapters . . 54 
 
 The Hosts of the Council . . . 56 
 
 A Bibliography of Phi Beta Kappa, . . -59 
 
 Union College . . . . 65 
 
 The Alpha of New York . -. . . 78 
 
 Anniversary of the Alpha of Vit^inia . • 83 
 
 The Hobart Installatioh . . -. .84 
 
 The Phi Beta Kappa Association in the District 
 
 of Columbia . . . , ' • 90 , 
 
 The Secretary's Postscript . . . . ga 
 
 UNION NUMBER 
 JANUARY, 1914 
 

 ■ - 
 
 
 Makers of 
 
 Approved Standard 
 PHI BETA KAPPA 
 
 FOUR SIZES 
 
 
 #@K 
 
 N«. 4 
 $5.50 
 
 
 
 i.( 
 
 No. 1 
 
 $8.50 
 
 14-K QOLt( -^ ACTUAL SIZE 
 
 Your order will Jiave immediate attention. 
 
 Give: Name, Class and Date to be, 
 
 engraved on the back. 
 
president of the chapter, and thus has the honor of holding this 
 position thirty-tliree years, the longest term of continued service 
 of which we have any knowledge. 
 
 Professor Werner assisted in the organization of the United 
 Chapters in 1883, was chosen one of the first Senators and was 
 the first secretary and treasurer of the organization. Conse- 
 quently the earliest records are in his hand. He continued as 
 secretary of the United Chapters for two terms, when, refusing 
 reelection, Dr. Parsons was selected his successor. However he 
 continued to serve as Senator until 1907, when he asked to be 
 relieved of this office also. It was on his invitation that the 
 Council met at the City College. As chairman of the committee 
 of arrangements, he was responsible in a large measure for the 
 hospitality there manifested. 
 
 During President Finley's absence in 191 1 as exchange profes- 
 sor at the Sorbonne, Dr. Werner was Acting President of the 
 College, the position which he now holds, owing to Dr. Finley's 
 recent resignation in order to accept the responsible office of Com- 
 missioner of Education, and President of the University of the 
 State of New York. 
 
 In i860 Professor Werner received the degree of Master of 
 Science, and in 1881 that of Doctor of Philosophy was confer- 
 red by Rutgers. He is unmarried — except as he is wedded to the 
 college. He is a man of quiet tastes, is most genial in his ways, 
 and is held in high esteem by a host of graduates and students, 
 as well as by his associates in the faculty. 
 
 A BIBLIOGRAPHY OF PHI BETA KAPPA 
 
 By Prof. Clark S. Northup, Cornell, '93. 
 (Continued from Vol. i, Xo. 12, page 6). 
 
 — The National Council, Saratoga Springs, N. Y., September 
 7, 1898. 8vo, pp. [4]- 
 
 — Phi Beta Kappa: minutes of the Seventh Triennial Coun- 
 cil. 1901. 8vo. 
 
 — Phi Beta Kappa. National Council, Saratoga Springs, Sep- 
 tember 12, 1901. 8vo, pp. [7]. 
 
 59 
 
— Phi Beta Kappa : bulletin of information. 1902. 8vo, 
 pp. [4]. 
 
 — Phi Beta Kappa: bulletin of information. June, 1903. 
 8vo, pp. [7]. 
 
 — Phi Beta Kappa: information respecting institutions that 
 have applied for charters. June i, 1904. 8vo, pp. [12]. 
 
 — Phi Beta Kappa: roll of chapters. 1904. Svo, pp. [4]. 
 
 — Phi Beta Kappa: publications. New Series. Svo. 
 
 1. Proceedings of the Eighth Triennial Council held at Sara- 
 toga Springs, X. Y., September 7, 1904. Pp. [8]. 
 
 2. Organization of new chapters. June, 1905. Pp. [8]. 
 
 3. Chapter activities. May 15, 1906. Pp. [23]. 
 
 4. The meeting of the Senate, etc. May, 1907. Pp. 14. 
 
 5. The Ninth Triennial Council, etc. 1907. Pp. 15. 
 
 6. Public exercises and proceedings of the Ninth Triennial 
 Council, Williamsburg, Va., September 11 and 12, 1907. 1907. 
 Pp. 47- 
 
 7. The Phi Beta Kappa past and present. By Rev. Oscar 
 M. Voorhees. 1908. Pp. 8. 
 
 8. The Latin motto of the Society, organization of new chap- 
 ters, etc. 1909. Pp. 23. 
 
 9. The meeting of the Senate, etc. 1910. Pp. 15. 
 
 10. Brief paragraphs in Phi Beta Kappa history together with 
 a list of Senators, chapters and chapter officers. Illustrated. 
 1910. Pp. [24]. 
 
 A second edition, with some changes, was also printed. 
 
 11. The Tenth National Council, New York City, September 
 13 and 14, 1910. Officers, Senators and roll of delegates. 1910. 
 Pp. 8. 
 
 — The Phi Beta Kappa Key. Somerville, N. J. November, 
 19 ID, to date. Published quarterly. 
 
 — Preliminary report of the Committee on Fraternity Policy to 
 the Eleventh National Council of the United Chapters of Phi 
 Beta Kappa . . . n. p., n. d. [1913], 8vo, pp. 8. 
 
 Reprinted in The Key, October, 1913, ii. I. 33-38. 
 
 — Various customs, usages and forms of the Phi Beta Kappa 
 Society. [1890?]. 8vo, pp [8]. 
 
 Oscar McMurtrie Voorhees. Brief paragraphs in Phi 
 
 60 
 
Beta Kappa history. In Phi Beta Kappa Publications, N. S. lo. 
 1910. 
 
 — Chancellor James Kent. In The Key, March, 191 1, i. 3. 1-5. 
 
 — The early development of the Phi Beta Kappa in New Eng- 
 land. In The Key, May, 191 1, i. 4. 10-43. 
 
 — The Eleventh National Council. In The Key, October, 19 13, 
 ii. I. 14-40. 
 
 — Historical sketch. In Catalogue of the Alpha chapter of 
 Nezv Jersey of the Phi Beta Kappa Society, pp. 2-14. 1891. 
 
 — John James McCook. In The Key, Oct., 191 1, i. 5. 34-6. 
 
 In part reprinted from same i. i. 9. 
 
 — Members in foreign lands. In The Key, May, 1913, i. 12.7-9. 
 
 — The Phi Beta Kappa badge. In The Key, Jan., 191 1, i. 2. 
 16-23. 
 
 — Phi Beta Kappa men at Oxford. In The Key, May, 191 1, 
 i. 4. 44-6. 
 
 — The Phi Beta Kappa past and present. Its primacy among 
 American college fraternities. In The Delta Upsilon Quarterly, 
 May, 1908. 
 
 Also in Phi Beta Kappa Publications, N. S. 7. Pp. 8. 1908. 
 
 — Presidential candidates. In The Key, Jan., 1913, i. 10. 38-9. 
 
 — Respecting a Phi Beta Kappa census. In The Key, May, 
 
 1912, i. 8. 26-8. 
 
 — Respecting applications for charters. In The Key, Jan., 
 
 1913, i. ID. 39-42. 
 
 — Respecting institutions applying for charters. In The Key, 
 May, 1913, i. 12. 17-29. 
 
 — Talcott Williams, LL.D. In The Key, Oct., 1912, i. 9. 22-3. 
 Portrait. 
 
 — Stewart Lyndon Woodford. In The Key, May, 191 1, i. 4. 
 46-8. Portrait. 
 
 — Thomas Wentworth Higginson, Harvard, '41. In The Key, 
 May, 191 1, i. 4. 43-4. Portrait (frontispiece). 
 
 As secretary Mr. Voorhees has edited all the publications of the United 
 Chapters since he assumed the duties of the office. 
 
 John DeWitt Warner. The first Greek-letter fraternity. In 
 The Delta Kappa Epislon Quarterly, October, 1886, v. 15-30. 
 
 A facsimile of part of the minutes of the William and Mary Chapter 
 forms the frontispiece of the number. 
 
 Ot 
 
Adolph Werner. Phi Beta Kappa [report of the First Trien- 
 nial Council, September 5, 1883]. In The College Mercury 
 [College of the City of New York]. October 10, 1883, v. 6-9. 
 
 As secretary, Mr. Werner edited the publications of the United Chapters 
 during his incumbency. 
 
 Justin Winsor. Records of the convention of October 18, 
 
 1881. In Harvard College Library Bulletin, Cambridge, Jan. i, 
 
 1882, iii. 21. 300-1. 
 
 Stewart Lyndon Woodford. Revival of Phi Beta Kappa. In 
 The Delta Kappa Epsilon Quarterly, January, 1884, ii. 95-102. 
 
 2. Publications Relating to Individual Chapters. 
 
 THE UNIVERSITY OF ALABAMA. 
 
 Alpha of Alabama. Organized in 185 i. Became Extinct 
 about 1861. Revived in 1912. 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 
 1854. Frederick A, P. Barnard. Art culture : its relation to 
 national refinement and national morality. An oration pro- 
 nounced before the Alabama A of the * B K, at its anniversary, 
 July nth, 1854. Tuscaloosa. M. J. D. Slade. 1854. 8vo, 
 PP- 25- 
 
 i860. William Russell Smith. The uses of solitude. [Quo- 
 tation of five lines]. Printed for the Alabama Alpha of the Phi 
 Beta Kappa Society of the University at Tuscaloosa, i860. 8vo, 
 PP- 45- 
 
 Delivered July II. An errata slip appeared between pp. 44 and 45. A 
 small edition was also printed for the use of the .author, dedicated to Dr. 
 F. A. P. Barnard. Reprinted with slight changes in his Reminiscences, 
 Washington, D. C. [Press of Rufus H. Darby, i88g], pp. 345-75. 
 
 1859. William W. Lord. The wants of the South: a poem 
 pronounced before the Phi Beta Kappa Society of the University 
 of Alabama, July 12, 1859. Tuskaloosa. Independent Monitor 
 Print. 1859. 8vo, pp. 12. 
 
 62 
 
General. 
 
 Clement Richardson Wood. Alabama's chapter of Phi Beta 
 Kappa. In The Crimson-White, University, Alabama, Decem- 
 ber 2, 1908, p. 4. 
 
 Reprinted in The Key, May, 1912, i. 8. 21-23. 
 
 See also Phi Beta Kappa Publications, N. S. 8, p. 22. 
 
 ALLEGHENY COLLEGE. 
 
 Eta of Pennsylvania. Organized February 18, 1902. 
 
 Catalogues. 
 
 1904, 8vo, pp. 32. 191 1. Sm. 8vo, pp. 42. 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 
 1912. Robert W. Rogers. The recovery of the ancient Orient. 
 New York. Eaton & Mains. 1912. 
 
 Gener.\l. 
 
 William A. Elliott. See Ph. B. K. Puhl, N. S. 3, pp. 
 [19-20]. 
 
 AMHERST COLLEGE. 
 
 Beta of Massachusetts. Organized August 9, 1853. 
 
 Catalogues. 
 1909. 8vo, pp. 32. 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 
 1858. Nehemiah Adams. Our family of states. Oration 
 delivered before the Phi Beta Kappa Society in Amherst Col- 
 lege, August II, 1858. Boston and Cambridge. James Munroe 
 and Company. 1861. i6mo, pp. 32. 
 
 1866. George Stillman Hillard. The political duties of the 
 educated classes. A discourse delivered before the Phi Beta 
 Kappa Society of Amherst College, July 10, 1866. Boston. Tick- 
 nor and Fields. 1866. 8vo, pp. 48. 
 
 1867. Andrew Preston Peabody. The Positive philosophy. 
 An oration delivered before the Phi Beta Kappa Society of 
 
 63 
 
Amherst College, July 9, 1867, and before the Phi Beta Kappa 
 Society of the University of Vermont, August 6, 1867. Boston. 
 Gould and Lincoln. 1867. 8vo, pp. 28. 
 
 Reviewed in The Nczu Englandcr, January, 1868, xxvii. 213. 
 
 1868. Francis Andrew March. The scholar of to-day. An 
 address before the Phi Beta Kappa Society, at Amherst College, 
 Commencement, July, 1868. In The American Presbyterian Re- 
 view, January, 1869. 
 
 Same. Springfield. Samuel Bowles & Company. 1869. 8vo, 
 pp. 24. 
 
 1869. Jeremiah Lewis Dimax. The method of academic 
 culture, an address before the Phi Beta Kappa Society of Am- 
 herst College, July 6, 1869. In The New Englandey, October, 
 1869, xxviii. 724-747. 
 
 Same. In his Orations and addresses, Boston, 1882, pp. 76-107. 
 See also Vermont Orations and Addresses, 1869. 
 
 1884. Daniel Henry Chamberlain. Not "a college fetich."' 
 An address in reply to the address of Charles Francis Adams, 
 Jr., delivered before the Harvard chapter of the fraternity of the 
 Phi Beta Kappa, at Cambridge, June 28, 1883. With portions 
 of articles by Pro'i;ssors Zeller, Fisher, and Peabody. Boston. 
 Willard Small. 1884. 8vo, pp. 93. 
 
 Delivered before the Amherst chapter on May 2, 1884, and before the 
 Vermont chapter on June 24, 1884. 
 
 General. 
 
 Edgar W. Burrill. See Ph. B. K. Publ., N. S. 3, pp. [6-7]. 
 See also The Key, Jan., 1913, i. 10. 43. 
 
 BELOIT COLLEGE. 
 
 Beta of Wisconsin. Organized June 19, 1911. 
 
 Catalogues. 
 191 1. Sm. 8vo, pp. 8. 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 
 191 1. Edward A. Birge. Philosophy the guide of life. De- 
 livered June 19. An abstract appears in The Key, Jan., 1912, 
 i. 6. ii-i'^. 
 
 64 
 
General. 
 
 John Pitt Deane. The Beta of Wisconsin at Beloit College. 
 In The Key, Jan., 1912, i. 6. 3-15. Illustrated. 
 
 BOSTON UNIVERSITY. 
 Epsilon of Massachusetts. Organized February 8, 1899. 
 
 Poems. 
 
 1907. Katharine Aldrich W'hitinc. Cross-roads. In Bos- 
 tonia, April, 1907, viii. no. I. 
 
 1908. Alice Stone Blackwell. The Russian revolution. In 
 Bostouia, Jul)', 1908, ix. no. 2. 
 
 General. 
 
 Ada Augusta Cole. Phi Beta Kappa. In The Boston Univer- 
 sity Beacon, Thursday, November 24, 1904, vol. xxix. 
 —See also Ph. B. K. PubL, N. S. 3, p. [17]. 
 
 BOWDOIN COLLEGE. 
 
 Alpha of Maine. Organized February 22, 1825. 
 
 Catalogues. 
 
 1834, 8vo, pp. 14. 1842, 8vo, pp. i6.. 1849, '8vo, pp. 19. i860, 
 8vo, pp. 32. Lewiston, Me., 1888, 8vo, pp. yy. 1908, 8vo, pp. 
 viii, 139. 
 
 All the catalogues except as otherwise noted were published at Bruns- 
 wick ; the first four by Joseph Griffin, 
 
 (To be Continued.) 
 
 UNION COLLEGE 
 
 Br J(-hn Ira Bennett, Ph. D., '90. 
 Professor of the Greek, Language and Literature. 
 L^nion College, chartered by the Regents of the University of 
 the State of New York on February 25, 1795, was the first col- 
 lege chartered by the Regents and the second incorporated in the 
 state. Four petitions to the Legislature for a charter, the earliest 
 in 1779, and two petitions to the Regents, in 1792 and 1794 respec- 
 tively, had previously been denied. Two motives to\yard the 
 
 65 
 
foundation were very significant in their day and have determined 
 the policy of the college ever since: First, the petitions were 
 popular expressing the desire of widely scattered settlers on the 
 western frontier of the state to provide for the training of leaders 
 in church and in state ; second, the petitioners, who were of dif- 
 ferent denominations, declared the principle of liberty in religion 
 and desired that the majority of the trustees of the college should 
 not at any time be composed of persons of the same religious sect 
 or denomination, and, as an expression of this desire, they asked 
 that the college "be called and known by the name of Union Col- 
 lege." 
 
 The Rev. John Blair Smith, pastor of the Pine Street Presby- 
 terian Church of Philadelphia and formerly president of Hamp- 
 den-Sidney College, was elected first president and assumed his 
 duties on December 9, 1795. The College began in a small way in 
 the building of the Schenectady Academy, established in 1785 to 
 prepare students for the hoped-for College. The faculty consisted 
 of the president and one tutor, who together gave instruction in 
 Greek, Latin, Roman antiquities, Roman history, mathematics, 
 geography, mensuration, navigation, natural philosophy, English, 
 criticism, eloquence, the history of America and of the American 
 Revolution, the Constitution of the United States and the consti- 
 tutions of the different states, logic, moral philosophy, and met- 
 aphysics. There were nine students at first. Fifteen months later 
 there were thirty-seven, and the whole property of the college, 
 including unpaid subscriptions, unproductive real estate, and equip- 
 ment, was valued at $42,422.60. The first class, graduated in 
 May, 1797, numbered three. In the two years following, however, 
 "philosophical apparatus" was imported from London and pro- 
 gress was made in raising funds to erect a stone building ade- 
 quate to the purposes of the College. President Smith resigned in 
 January, 1799, having been invited to resume the pastorate of the 
 Pine Street Presbyterian Church in Philadelphia. He continued, 
 however, to discharge the duties of president until commencement 
 in May following. 
 
 The second president was Jonathan Edwards the Younger, who 
 began his duties in July, 1799. His brief term of ofifice, ended 
 by his death on August i, 1801, was mostly devoted to the estab- 
 lishment of good standards of conduct and scholarhsip. 
 
 66 
 
Volume 2 
 
 Number 3 
 
 Contents 
 
 
 
 Page 
 
 Samuel Hart .... 
 
 . lOI 
 
 The Fount of Castaly . . ' ^ . 
 
 103 
 
 Eafly Phi Beta Kappa Charters . 
 
 . 104 
 
 - The Beta of Connecticut . . , 
 
 no 
 
 The Gamma of Connecticut 
 
 . US 
 
 Lawrfence jCoUege . . 
 
 ,123 
 
 The Gamma of 'Wisconsin • - . 
 
 • 127 
 
 Two New Phi Beta Kappa Asspciations 
 
 135 
 
 A Phi Beta Kappa Bibliography . _ . 
 
 • W 
 
 Representative Phi Beta Kappa Orations 
 
 149 
 
 In Memoriam , . - . 
 
 . 151 
 
 Phi Beta Kappa News and Notes . ; 
 
 153 
 
 . M^^M^} 
 
 *r 
 
 ::,;^::|^^^- ■• 
 
 ' \^^^^n^4^' i/ 
 
 ' ' ' - - T'^' ^ -~ ~ 
 
 MARCH^ J9J4 
 
 
Makers of 
 
 Approved Standard 
 PHI BETA KAPPA KEYS 
 
 FOUR SIZES 
 
 It 
 
 4^BK 
 
 No. 4: 
 $5.50 I 
 
 14-K GOLD — ACTUAL SQ;E 
 
 Your order will Wve immediate attention. 
 
 Give Name, Class and Date to be 
 
 engraved on the back. 
 
 3FS 
 
By vote of the meeting the sixty-five vi^ho had subscribed to the 
 dinner were made foundation members and the same honor was 
 extended to about twenty-five others who were unable to be pres- 
 ent but who had requested that their names be included in case 
 such an association was formed. 
 
 Thus the Upper Hudson Association of Phi Beta Kappa comes 
 into existence with about ninety members all enthusiastie for its 
 success and who much desire that the number may soon include 
 all the Phi Beta Kappa men in the district. 
 
 For the ensuing year the following officers were elected : 
 
 President, John Husted Finley, Hon. Northwestern, '78, Al- 
 bany. 
 
 Vice-President, Hon. William Piatt Rudd, Union, '73, Albany. 
 
 Secretary-Treasurer, Prof. Morton Collins Stewart, Brown 
 '94, Schenectady. 
 
 Executive Committee, the officers ex-officio, and Gardner Cot- 
 trell Leonard, Williams '87, Rev. Edward Wilcox Babcock, Brown 
 '74, Dr. Albert Warren Ferris, New York University, '78, Sara- 
 toga Springs. 
 
 A PHI BETA KAPPA BIBLIOGRAPHY 
 
 By Prof. Clark S. Northup, Cornf.ll, '93. 
 (Continued from Vol. 2, page 65). 
 
 bowdoin college. 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 
 1827. AsiiuR Ware. A discourse, pronounced before the Phi 
 Beta Kappa Society, at Brunswick, on the anniversary celebra- 
 tion, September 6, 1827. Portland. Thomas Todd. 1827. 8vo, 
 pp. 36. 
 
 1834. Alexander Hill Everett. Address to the Phi Beta 
 Kappa Society of Bowdoin College, on the present state of polite 
 learning in England and America, delivered at Brunswick, Me., 
 September 3, 1834. Boston. Charles Bowen. 1834. 8vo, pp. 55. 
 
 1837. Joseph Reed Ingersoll. An address delivered before 
 the Phi Beta Kappa Society, Alpha of Maine, in Bowdoin Col- 
 
 137 
 
lege, Brunswick, September 7, 1837. Brunswick. Printed for the 
 Society. 1837. 8vo, pp. 40. 
 
 On some characteristics of our republic. 
 
 1841. Alden Bradford. Human learning favorable to true 
 religion: but the transcendental theory hostile to the Christian 
 revelation. An address delivered before the Society of $ B K in 
 Bowdoin. College, September 2, 1841. Boston. S. G. Simpkins. 
 1841. 8vo, pp. 52. 
 
 See Joseph Williamson, A bibliography of the State of Maine, Port- 
 land, 1896, i. 188. 
 
 1849. William T[heodore] Dwight. An address, delivered 
 before the Phi Beta Kappa Society, Alpha of Maine, in Bowdoin 
 College, Brunswick, September 6, 1849. Published by request. 
 Portland. Printed at the Mirror Office. 1849. 8vo, pp. 23. 
 
 On the immensity of the field of knowledge and the influence of such 
 a conviction on the student. 
 
 Reviewed by John Lord in The Christian Philosopher and Metaphysician, 
 Portland, 1852. 
 
 1850. William Buel Sprague. A discourse delivered before 
 the Phi Beta Kappa Society of Bowdoin College, September 5, 
 1850. Albany. Charles Van Benthuysen. 1850. 8vo, pp. 44. 
 
 On the perpetuity of intellectual influence. The greater part was also 
 read before the Dartmouth chapter in the same year. 
 
 1862. Benjamin Franklin Thomas. The army of the rescue. 
 Address before the Phi Beta Kappa Society of Bowdoin Col- 
 lege, August 7, 1862. In his Speeches in the second and third 
 sessions of the thirty-seventh Congress, and in the vacation (Bos- 
 ton. John Wilson & Son. 1863. 8vo, pp. 217), pp. 104-127. 
 
 1882. Daniel R. Goodwin. Longfellow: memorial address, 
 before the alumni of Bowdoin College, July 12, 1882. Portland: 
 Stephen Berry, printer. 1882. 8vo, pp. [vi], 30. 
 
 Delivered at a general meeting, under the auspices of the Phi Beta Kappa 
 and the Alumni Society. 
 
 1910. William Winter. Longfellow and American letters. 
 Delivered Feb. 28. An abstract appeared in The Lewiston Even- 
 ing Journal, March i, 1910. 
 
 Poems. 
 
 1832. Henry Wadsworth Longfellow. See Harvard Poems, 
 
 1833- 
 
 138 
 
i835- Isaac McLellan, Jr. A poem delivered before the Phi 
 Beta Kappa Society of Bowdoin College, Sept. 3rd, 1835. In The 
 Boston Pearl and Literary Gazette^ November 3, 1835. 
 
 General. 
 George T. Files. See Phi B. K. PubL, N. S. 3, p. [5]. 
 
 BROWN UNIVERSITY. 
 
 Alpha 'OF Rhode Island. Organized Judy 21, 1830. 
 
 Catalogues. 
 
 1839. 8vo, pp. 16. 1843. 8vo, pp. 16. 1850. 8vo, pp. 24. 1862. 
 8vo, pp. 28. 1877. 8vo, pp. 36. 1888. 8vo, pp. 46. 1897. 8vo, 
 pp. 68. 1904. 8vo, pp. 76. 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 
 1831. Francis Wayland. A discourse on the philosophy of 
 analogy, delivered before the Phi Beta Kappa Society of Rhode 
 Island, September 7, 1831. Boston. HilHard, Gray & Company. 
 1831. 8vo, pp. 32. 
 
 Reviewed in The New England Magazine, November, 1831, i. 445. See 
 also F. and H. L. Wayland, A Memoir of the life and labors of Francis 
 Wayland, New York, Sheldon, 1867, i. 349. 
 
 1832. Theron Metcalf. An address to the Phi Beta Kappa 
 Society of Brown University, delivered 5th September, 1832. 
 Boston. Lily, Wait, Colman and Holden. 1833. 8vo, pp. 28. 
 
 Suggestions respecting the influence of popular opinion, taste, and feel- 
 ing, on the character and pursuits of men of talents and learning. 
 
 1833. Virgil Maxcy. A discourse before the Phi Beta Kappa 
 Society of Brown University, September 4, 1833. Boston. 1833. 
 8vo, pp. 31. 
 
 1834. Asher Robbins. a discourse before the Phi Beta Kappa 
 Society of Brown University. Delivered September 3, 1834. 
 8vo, pp. 28. 
 
 Reviewed in The New England Magazine, November, 1834, vii. 426. 
 
 1835. Alexis Caswell. The importance of the mathematical 
 studies, considered as a branch of liberal education. Delivered 
 September 2, 1835. 8vo, pp. 18. 
 
 139 
 
1836. William Giles Goddard. An address before the Phi 
 Beta Kappa Society of Rhode Island, September 7, 1836. Bos- 
 ton. J. H. Eastburn. 1837. 8vo, pp. 30. 
 
 1838. Caleb Gushing. A discourse on the social influence of 
 Christianity, delivered at Providence, Rhode Island, September, 
 1838, at the instance of the Phi Beta Kappa Society of Brown 
 University. Andover. Gould & Newman. 1838. 8vo, pp. 28. 
 
 1842. Francis Galley Gray. An oration before the Phi Beta 
 Kappa Society' of Brown University, Providence, Rhode Island, 
 on Commencement Day, September 7, 1842. Providence. B. 
 Cranston & Co. 1842. 8vo, pp. 40. 
 
 Reviewed in The North American Review, October, 1842, Iv. 527. 
 
 1843. Job Durfee. The influence of scientific discovery and 
 invention on social and political progress. An oration delivered 
 before the * B K Society of Brown University, September 6, 
 1843. Providence. B. Cranston & Co. 1843. 8vo, pp. 52. 
 
 1847. Henry Wheaton. The progress and prospects of Ger- 
 many ; a discourse before the Phi Beta Kappa Society of Brown 
 University, September i, 1847. Boston. 1847. 8vo, pp. 54. 
 
 1849. George R[obert] Russell. The merchant. An oration 
 before the Rhode Island Alpha of the Phi Beta Kappa Society, 
 at Providence, September 4, 1849. Boston. Ticknor, Reed, and 
 Fields. 1849. 8vo, pp. 60. 
 
 1851. William Greene. Some of the difficulties in the admin- 
 istration of a free government; a discourse before the Rhode 
 Island Alpha of the Phi Beta Kappa Society, July 8, 1851. Prov- 
 idence. John F. Moore. 185 1. 8vo, pp. 40. 
 
 1856. Frederick Dan Huntington. 
 
 The address is said to have been published, but the chapter can find no 
 trace of it. 
 
 1858. Andrew P[reston] Peabody. The immutable right : an 
 oration delivered before the Phi Beta Kappa Society of Brown 
 University,' August 31, 1858. Published by request. Boston. Cros- 
 by, Nichols, and Company, 117 Washington street. 1858. 8vo, 
 PP- 25. 
 
 140 
 
i86o. Thomas Allen Jenckes. 
 
 The oration is said to have been published, but the chapter can find no 
 trace of it. 
 
 1862. Thatcher Thayer. The state. An oration before the 
 Rhode Island Alpha of the Phi Beta Kappa Society, at Brown 
 University, September 2, 1862. Providence. 1862. 8vo, pp. 30. 
 
 1875. Alexander H. Bullock. Intellectual leadership in 
 American history. 8vo, pp. 39. 
 
 1885. Edw^ard Everett Hale. What is the American people ? 
 Delivered in Jtily. In his Works viii, Addresses and essays, Bos- 
 ton, Little, Brown & Co., 1900, 8vo, pp. 86-112. 
 
 1887. Samuel Henson Ordway. Taxation of lands. Deliv- 
 ered June 13, 1887. 8vo. pp. 42. 
 
 1909. James Edwin Creighton. Knowledge and practice. 
 An address delivered before the Phi Beta Kappa Society of 
 Brown University, June 15, 1909. In The International Journal 
 of Ethics, October, 1909, xx. 29-48. 
 
 Also published separately, 8vo, pp. 20. 
 
 Poems. 
 
 1834. George Burgess. The martyrdom of St. Peter and St. 
 Paul. Delivered September 3, 1834. i2mo, pp. 48. 
 
 1836. Oliver Wendell Holmes. Poetry : a metrical essay. 
 See Harvard Poems, 1836; and George William Curtis, in Rob- 
 ert P. Brown and others. Memories of Brown, Providence, 1909, 
 8vo, pp. 71-2. 
 
 General. 
 Walter Cochrane Bronson. See Ph. B. K. Publ., N. S. 3, 
 pp. [5-6]. 
 
 THE UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA. 
 
 Alpha of California. Organized December 14, 1898. 
 
 Catalogues. 
 
 1910. 8vo, pp. 16. 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 1900. Robert Jones Burdette. Phi Beta Kappa address 
 
 141 
 
Delivered May 15. In The University of California Chronicle, 
 October, 1900, iii. 270-274. 
 On the necessity of faith in human life. 
 
 1902. Martin Kellogg. Language and literature. Deliv- 
 ered May 13. In The University of California Chronicle, July, 
 1902, V. 61-75. 
 
 1903. Henry Morse Stephens. The atmosphere of the past. 
 Delivered May 13. In The University of California Chronicle, 
 November, 1903, vi. 159-68. 
 
 1904. Bernard Moses. The western experiment with per- 
 sonal independence. Delivered May 17. In The University of 
 California Chronicle, September, 1904, vii. 25-40. 
 
 1905. Augustus Taber Murray. The academic life. Deliv- 
 ered May 16. In The University of California Chronicle, Sep- 
 tember, 1905, viii. 10-22. 
 
 1906. Chauncey Wetmore Wells. The literary scholar. 
 D'elivered October 16. In The University of California Chron- 
 icle, April, 1907, ix. 126-42. 
 
 1907. William Carey Jones. Present day problems. Deliv- 
 ered October 24. In The University of California Chronicle, 
 January, 1908, x. 11-31. 
 
 1909. George Malcolm Stratton. The fighting instinct. De- 
 livered May II. Parts have been published in International Con- 
 ciliation, New York : "The double standard in regard to fighting," 
 October, 1912, No. 59, sm. 8vo, pp. 14; "The control of the fight- 
 ing instinct," December, 1913, No. 73, pp. 13. 
 
 1910. Kendric Charles Babcock. The historical spirit. De- 
 livered May 18. In The University of California Chronicle, Octo- 
 ber, 1910, xii. 350-67. 
 
 1912. James Arnold Blaisdell. The evolution of purpose in 
 American education. In Bulletin of the Throop Polytechnic Insti- 
 tute, July, 1912, xxi. 23-37. 
 
 Poems. 
 
 1910. Isaac Flagg. The isle of Circe. Read at the banquet 
 
 142 
 
at Oakland in March. In The University of California Chronicle, 
 January, 1912, xiv. 25-31. 
 
 1912. Arthur William Ryder. Tolstoi — a critical sympos- 
 ium. Read May 10. In The University of California Chronicle, 
 October, 1912, xiv. 430-36. 
 
 General. 
 
 George Rapall Noyes. See Ph. B. K. Piibl, N. S. 3, p. [16]. 
 1909. 8vo, pp. 72. 
 
 THE UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO. 
 
 Beta of Illinois. Organized July i, 1899. 
 
 Catalogues. 
 
 1901. 32mo, pp. 12. 1902. 32mo, pp. 16. 1903. 32mo, pp. 
 16. 1909. 8vo, pp. 72. 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 
 1901. Benjamin Ide Wheeler. Things human. Delivered 
 June 17. In The Atlantic Monthly, November, 1902, xc. 636-42. 
 
 1902. Charles Francis Adams, Jr. "Shall Cromwell have 
 a statue?" Oration before the $ B K Society of the University 
 of Chicago, June 17, 1902. Boston. 1902. 8vo, pp. 94. 
 
 Also in The University Record, June, 1902, vii. 52-72. Also in his Three 
 Phi Beta Kappa addresses, Boston, Houghton Mifflin Co., 1907. Subject, 
 Robert E. Lee. 
 
 1903. Bliss Perry. Indifferentism. In The Atlantic Monthly, 
 September, 1903, xcii. 329-38. 
 
 Also in Tlie amateur spirit and other essays, Boston, Houghton Mifflin 
 Co., 1904, pp. 35-66. 
 
 1904. Walter Hines Page. The cultivated man in an indus- 
 trial era. In The University Record, June, 1904, ix. 48-55. 
 
 Also in The World's Work, July, 1904, viii. 4980-5. 
 Also delivered at Columbia in 1904. 
 
 1905. John Franklin Jameson. The age of erudition. De- 
 livered June 12. In The University Record, July, 1905, x. 19-28. 
 
 1906. Albion Woodbury Small. The social value of the 
 
 14.3 
 
academic career. Delivered June ii. In The University Rec- 
 ord, July, 1906, xi. 21-31. 
 
 191 1. Charles Edward Merriam. Citizenship. Delivered 
 June 13. In The University of Chicago Magazine, July, 191 1, 
 iii. 275-82. 
 
 General. 
 The golden key. May i, 1910. Pp. 4. 
 
 Program of the inauguration exercises, July i, 1899. Pp. 4. 
 Francis Wayland Shepardson. See Ph. B. K. Publ., N. S. 
 3,P- [18]. 
 
 The University of Cincinnati. 
 Delta of Ohio. Organized April ii, 1899. 
 
 Catalogues. 
 
 1900. 8vo, pp. 40. 1910. 8vo, pp. 27. 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 1913. Frederick L. Flinchbaugh. The art of Hfe. Phi 
 Beta Kappa address, McMicken Hall, May 29, 1913. In The 
 University of Cincinnati Record, July, 1913, Series i, ix. 9. 57-68. 
 
 General. 
 Lelia a. Garvin. See Ph. B. K. Publ., N. S. 3, p. [17]. 
 
 COLBY COLLEGE. 
 
 Beta of Maine. Organized January 3, 1896. 
 
 Catalogues. 
 
 1901. Prepared by J. William Black. 8yo, pp. 39. 
 
 General. 
 J. William Black. See Ph. B. K. Publ., N. S. 3, p. [14]. 
 
 COLGATE UNIVERSITY. 
 
 Eta of New^ York. Organized June 19, 1878. 
 
 Catalogues. 
 
 1912. 8vo, pp. 24. 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 
 1909. Charles E. Hughes. The value of the liberal college 
 
 144 
 
education. Delivered June 22. In The New York Tribune, 
 June 23, 1909, p. 4. 
 
 General. 
 
 W. M. Chester. See Ph. B. K. PubL, N. S. 3, p. [10]. 
 
 • COLORADO COLLEGE. 
 Beta of Colorado. Organized November ii, 1904. 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 1912. Elijah Clarence Hills. The Pike's Peak region in 
 song and myth. In Colorado College Publication^ January, 1913, 
 General series 66, Language series ii. 165-220. Read at the annual 
 meeting in June. 
 
 General. 
 Frank H. Loud. See Ph. B. K. PubL, N. S. 3, p. [21]. 
 See also same, N. S. 2, pp. [5-6]. 
 
 THE UNIVERSITY OF COLORADO. 
 
 Alpha of Colorado. Organized October 18, 1904. 
 
 Catalogues. 
 
 1906. 8vo, pp. II. Bulletin No. 5 of the Univeirsity of Colo- 
 rado, issued March 15. 1912. 8vo, pp. [8]. 
 
 General. 
 Frederic L. Paxson. See Ph. B. K. PubL, N. S. 3, p. [20]. 
 See also same, N. S. 2, p. [3] 
 
 COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY. 
 
 Delta of New York. Organized April 22, 1869. 
 
 Catalogues. 
 
 1907. i6mo, pp. 51. Compiled by L. F. Fuld. 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 
 1886. Stewart Lyndon Woodford. New York Delta of Phi 
 Beta Kappa. An oration by the Hon. Stewart L. Woodford. Sub- 
 ject: The labor problem. Columbia College Library, Wednesday, 
 June 2d, 1886, at 8 p. m. Printed for the Chapter. Bvo, pp. 19. 
 
 1887. Charles Sprague Smith. New York Delta of Phi 
 Beta Kappa. Annual oration by Prof. Charles Sprague Smith, 
 
 145 
 
A. M. Subject : "The American university." Thursday, June 
 2d, 1887, at 8 p. m. Printed for the chapter. 8vo, pp. 31. 
 
 1901. Buss Perry. The amateur spirit. In The Atlantic 
 Monthly, August, 1901, Ixxxviii. 270-8. 
 
 Also in The amateur spirit and other essays, Boston, Houghton Mifflin 
 Co., 1904, pp. 1-34. 
 
 1904. Walter Hines Page. The cultivated man in an indus- 
 trial age. See Chicago Orations and Addresses, 1904. 
 
 1905- [James] Brander Matthews. American character. 
 Delivered June 13. In The Columbia University Quarterly, 
 March, 1906, viii. 97-114. 
 
 Also in The American of the future and other essays, New York, Scril>- 
 ner, 1909, pp. 23-56. 
 
 1906. Charles Francis Adams. Some modern college tenden- 
 cies. Delivered June 12. In The Columbia University Quarterly, 
 September, 1906, viii. 347-371. 
 
 Also in Three Phi Beta Kappa addresses, Boston, Houghton Mifflin Co., 
 1907. 
 
 1907. Talcott Williams. A democratic economy. Deliv- 
 ered June II. In The Columbia University Quarterly, September, 
 1907, Ix. 431-42. 
 
 1909. A. Lawrence Lowell. Competition in college. Deliv- 
 ered June I. In The Columbia University Quarterly, September, 
 1909, xi. 421-38. 
 
 Also in The Atlantic Monthly, June, 1909, ciii. 822-31. 
 
 19 10. William Allen White. A theory of spiritual pro- 
 gress. An address delivered before the Phi Beta Kappa Society 
 of Columbia University in the City of New York. Emporia, Kan- 
 sas. The Gazette Press. 1910. 8vo, pp. [vi],53. 
 
 600 copies printed. The address was delivered on May 31. Also in The 
 Columbia University Quarterly, September, 1910, xii. 408-20. 
 
 191 1. Theodore E. Burton. Some prevalent misapprehen- 
 sions concerning our political life. Delivered June 6. In The Co- 
 lumbia University Quarterly, September, 191 1, xiii. 410-22. 
 
 General. 
 
 William R. Shepherd. See Ph. B. K. Ptibl. N. S. 3, pp. [9- 
 10]. 
 
 146 
 
CORNELL UNIVERSITY. 
 
 Theta of New York. Organized May 28, 1S82. 
 
 Catalogues. 
 
 1884. In The Cornell Daily Sun, June 18, pp. 3-4. 1906. 
 
 Compiled by J. McMahon and Clark S. Northup. i6mo, pp. 49. 
 
 1912. Compiled by Clark S. Northup. 8vo, pp. 39. 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 
 1890. Horatio Stevens White. Phi Beta Kappa address. 
 Delivered June 16. In The Cornell Era, November 22, 1890. 
 xxiii. 86-88. 
 
 1906. Clark Sutherland Northup. The present claims of 
 culture upon the Phi Beta Kappa. Read February 20th. An ab- 
 stract was printed, 4V0, i p. 
 
 1907. Charles William Eliot. Academic freedom : an ad- 
 dress delivered before the New York Theta Chapter of the Phi 
 Beta Kappa Society at Cornell University, May 29, 1907. Ithaca, 
 N. Y. 1907. 8vo, pp. 24. 
 
 Also in The Harvard Crimson, about May 31 ; in Science, July 5, 1907, N. 
 S. xxvi. 1-12; in The Journal of Pedagogy, September-December, 1907, xx. 
 9-28. 
 
 Comment by Rollo Ogden (Phases of academic freedom) in The Nation, 
 August 15, 1907, Ixxxv. 136. 
 
 1909. James McMahon. Address to the initiates of the Cor- 
 nell Chapter of Phi Beta Kappa, April 21, 1909. Ithaca, N. Y. 
 1909. i6mo, pp. 8. 
 
 1909. Jeremiah Whipple Jenks. Preparation for old age. 
 Delivered May 19. An abstract appeared in The Cornell Daily 
 Sun, May 20. 
 
 191 1. Lane Cooper. The function of the leader in scholar- 
 ship. An address delivered after the initiation of new members 
 May 30, 1911. Printed for the author. Ithaca, New York. 
 1911. 8vo, pp. 35. 
 
 19 12. Lane Cooper. Ancient and modern letters. An address 
 delivered after the initiation of new members, April i, 1912. In 
 The South Atlantic Quarterly, July, 1912, xi. 234-43. 
 
 Also reprinted, 8vo. pp. 12. 
 
 147 
 
1914- Jacob Gould Schurman, Dexter Simpson Kimball, 
 Henry Augustus Sill, Frank Thilly. Liberal culture. Deliv- 
 ered February 17. Abstracts appeared in The Cornell Daily Sun, 
 February 18, and The Cornell Alumni News February 26, 1914, 
 xvi. 263. 
 
 General. 
 
 Constitution of the Th€ta Chapter of the Phi Beta Kappa 
 Society at the Cornell University. 1883. 8vo, pp. 3. 1890. 
 8vo, pp. 3. 1906. i6mo, pp. 16; ed. by J. McMahon. 
 
 The Cornell Daily Sun. Phi Beta Kappa. March 20, 1909, 
 xxix. 125, 4, 6. Comment in same March 21 and 22. March 
 22, 1909, pp. 4, 6. Phi Beta Kappa and the Zeitgeist, May 29, 
 1909, pp. 4, 5. 
 
 Arthur Livingston. A manifest unfairness in Phi Beta 
 Kappa. In The Cornell Daily Sun, March 19, 191 1, xxxi. 124. 
 4-8. 
 
 Replies and comments in same, March 20, pp. 4, 8; March 21, 
 pp. 4, 8 (H. C. Elmer) ; March 22, pp. 4-5 (A. Livingston) ; 
 March 23, p. 4 (H. C. Elmer, A Leroy Andrews). 
 
 James McMahon. What Phi Beta Kappa and Sigma Xi 
 mean at Cornell. In The Cornell Daily Sun, April 17, 1907. 
 
 Clark Sutherland Northup. Elections to Phi Beta Kappa. 
 In The Cornell Era, Mid-Winter, 1911-12, xliv. 177-9. 
 
 — Phi Beta Kappa elections. In The Cornell Daily Sun, March 
 24, 1909, xxix. 127. 4, 6. 
 
 — The quarter-centennial of Phi Beta Kappa. In The Cornell 
 Era, June, 1907, xxxix. 461-463. 
 
 —See also Ph. B. K. Publ., N. S. 3, p. ,[ii]. 
 
 DARTMOUTH COLLEGE. 
 
 Alpha of New Hampshire. Organized August 20, 1787. 
 
 Catalogues. 
 
 Andover. 1806. 8vo, pp. 15. 1809. Svo, pp. 16. 1812. 8vo, 
 pp. 16. Andover. 1815. - Svo, pp. 16. 1818. Svo, pp. 16. Ha- 
 verhill, Mass. 1822. Svo, pp. 15. 1S32. Svo, pp. 23. , 1836. 
 
 -148 
 
8vo, pp. 23. 1838. 8vo, pp, 23. 1839. 8vo, pp. 24. Concord. 
 1841. 8vo, pp. 26. 1844. 8vo, pp. 28. 1851. 8vo, pp. 39. 1853. 
 8vo, pp. 40. 1856. 8vo, pp. 44. i860. 8vo, pp. 62. 1867. 8vo, 
 pp. 68. 1874. 8vo, pp. Ji. 1884. 8vo, pp. 74. 1887. 8vo, 
 pp. 76. 1897. 8vo, pp 58. 
 
 All the catalogues unless it is otherwise noted were published at Hanover 
 
 Orations and Address. 
 
 1800. Asa Burton. Sermon before the * B k Society at their 
 anniversary at Dartmouth College. . . . Aug. 26, 1800. Han- 
 over. 1801. i2mo, pp. 18. 
 
 Text, I John iv. 8. ' 
 
 1802. Asa McFarland. Oration pronounced before the so- 
 ciety of * B K at their anniversary at Hanover, Aug. 25, 1802. 
 Hanover. 1802. i2mo, p. 24. 
 
 1804 Stephen P. Webster. Oration pronounced before the 
 society of * B K at their anniversary at Hanover, Aug. 21, 1804. 
 Hanover. 1804. 8vo, pp. 15. 
 
 1805. John Vose. Oration pronounced at Hanover, Aug. 27, 
 1805, before the 4> B K Society. Hanover. 1806. i2mo, pp. 14. 
 
 1806. Daniel Webster. The state of our literature. Deliv- 
 ered August 26th. In his Works, National Edition. Boston. 
 1903. XV. 575-582. 
 
 See the Life of Webster by George Ticknor Curtis, i. 96-8. 
 
 1816. Nathaniel Appleton Haven. Address before the Phi 
 Beta Kappa Society at Dartmouth College, delivered August 18, 
 1816. In his Remains, n. p., 1827. 8vo, pp. 24-35. 
 
 ( To be Continued) 
 
 REPRESENTATIVE PHI BETA KAPPA ORATIONS 
 
 The committee charged with the preparation of a volume of 
 Phi Beta Kappa addresses (see The Key i. i. 25, ii. i. 39) find 
 that the publication of the volume will be facilitated if they can 
 guarantee the publishers a sale of five hundred copies. It is plan- 
 ned to issue a book of about five hundred pages, with a photo- 
 gravure frontispiece, in a limited edition, representing the best 
 typography and binding that can be secured. Provided arrange- 
 
 149 
 
ments can be made with authors and publishers, the contents will 
 probably be chosen from the following list: 
 
 R. W. Emerson, "The American Scholar," Harvard, 1837. 
 
 H. Bushnell, "The Principles of National Greatness," Yale, 
 
 1837. 
 
 J. Durfee, "Science and Progress," Brown, 1843. 
 
 A. P. Peabody, "The Connection Between Science and Reli- 
 gion," Harvard, 1845. 
 
 F. A. March, "The Scholar of To-Day," Amherst, 1868. 
 
 A. H. Bullock, "Intellectual Leadership in American History," 
 Brown, 1875. 
 R. G. Hoar, "Individualism," Vermont, 1880. 
 C. H. Bell, "The Worship of Success,'.' Dartmouth, 1881. 
 
 E. B. Andrews, "The Social Plaint," N. Y. Alumni, 1892. 
 
 G. C. Southworth, "The Making of Our Civilization," Kenyon, 
 1892. 
 
 A. D. White, "Evolution vs. Revolution in Politics," N. Y. 
 Alumni, 1896, Cornell, 1913. 
 
 T. N. Page, "The Hope of Democracy," William and Mary, 
 1900. 
 
 B. I. Wheeler, "Things Human," Chicago, 1901. 
 
 B. Perry, "The Amateur Spirit," Columbia, Tufts, 1901. 
 
 J. J. Chapman, "The Unity of Human Nature," Hobart, 1901. 
 
 F. E. Schelling, "Humanities Gone and to Come," Pennsyl- 
 vania, 1902. 
 
 W. H. Page, "The Cultivated Man in an Industrial Era," Chi- 
 cago, Columbia, 1904. 
 
 A. B. Hart, "The Hope of Democracy," Tufts, 1907. 
 
 C. W. Eliot, "Academic Freedom," Cornell, 1907. 
 
 E. L. Parsons, "Democracy and a Prophetic Ideal," Stanford, 
 1907. 
 
 W. Wilson, "The Spirit of Learning," Harvard,' 1909. 
 
 B. Wendell, "The Mystery of Education," Johns Hopkins, 1909. 
 E. A. Grosvenor, "The Attitude of the Scholar," North Caro- 
 lina, 1909. 
 
 J. Royce, "What is Vital in Christianity?" Vassar, 1909. 
 J. Dewey, "Humanism, New and Old," Cornell, 1912. 
 
 The price of the book will not exceed $3, and as the eciition 
 will be limited, the volume may be expected to increase in pecu- 
 niary value. If each chapter will take seven copies, the publi- 
 cation of the book will be immediately possible. Those desiring 
 the work should send their names at once to the chairman of 
 the committee, Prof. Clark S. Northup, Cornell University, 
 Ithaca, N. Y. 
 
 ISO 
 
jVotame 2 
 
 Number S 
 
 Contents 
 
 Page 
 
 Man's Triumph- Era-^A Poem , . .21 
 
 The UtoiVersity of the State of Washington . 823 
 
 The Alpha of Washington . . ; 229 
 
 Washingtoii University, St., Lrouis J . 233 
 
 The Beta of Missouri . ; . . 238 
 
 The Iota of Massachusetts at RadclifFe . 242 
 
 A Phi Beta Kappa Bibliography . . . 249 
 
 Representative Phi Beta Kappi» Orations . 251 
 
 In Memoriam ,. . . • • ^S* 
 
 Phi Beta Kappa Newis and Notes . . 255 
 
 OCTOBER, 19U 
 
I 
 
 
 Makers of 
 
 Approved Standard 
 
 PHI BETA KAPPA 
 
 FOUR SIZES 
 
 
 «BK 
 
 
 #BM 
 
 No. 4 
 $5.50 
 
 14'K GOLD -^ ACTUAL SIZE 
 
 Your order will have immediate attention. 
 
 Give Name, Glass and Date to be 
 
 engraved on the back. 
 
 
 - 
 
A PHI BETA KAPPA BIBLIOGRAPHY 
 
 By Prof. Clark S. Nortijup, Cornell '93. 
 
 (Continued from Vol. 2, page 149). 
 
 DARTMOUTH— (Continved). 
 
 1817. Daniel Dana. The connection between moral and 
 intellectual improvement : address delivered at the anniversary of 
 the New Hampshire Alpha of the "i> B K Society of Dartmouth 
 College, Aug. 26, 1817. Exeter, N. H. 1817. i2mo, pp. 20. 
 
 1824. Samuel L. Knapp. An oration pronounced before the 
 society of Phi Beta Kappa at Dartmouth College, Aug. 19, 1824. 
 Printed by request of the Society. Boston. 1824. 8vo, pp. 32. 
 
 1825. Charles B. Hadduck. An oration pronounced before 
 the * B K Society of Dartmouth College, Aug. 25th, 1825. Pub- 
 Hshed by request. Concord, N. H. Jacob B. Moore. 1825. 8vo, 
 
 PP- 35- 
 
 1828. Frederick Hall. An oration on the importance of cul- 
 tivating the sciences, delivered at Dartmouth College before the 
 New Hampshire Alpha of * B K, Aug. 21, 1828. Baltimore. 
 1828. 8vo, pp. 28. 
 
 1832. George Kent. The characteristics and claims of the 
 age in which we live : an oration, pronounced at Dartmouth Col- 
 lege, Aug. 23, 1832, before the New-Hampshire Alpha of the 
 # B K Society. Concord. Moses G. Atwood. 1832. 8vo, pp. 42. 
 
 Reviewed in The New England Magazine, November, 1832, iii, 427. 
 
 1840. Caleb Sprague Henry. 
 
 According to the records of the chapter, this address was printed; but 
 no trace of it has been found. 
 
 1841. Tayler Lewis. The believing spirit: a discourse deliv- 
 ered before the New Hampshire Alpha of the * B K Society, 
 1841. New York. 1841. 8vo, pp. 39. 
 
 Portrait in The Key, March, 1914, ii. 2.80. 
 
 1843. Levi Woodbury. An oration before the * B K Society 
 of Dartmouth College. Hanover. 1844. 8vo, pp. 37. 
 
 1845. Leonard Bacon. An oration before the * B K Society 
 of Dartmouth College, delivered July 30, 1845. Hanover. 1845. 
 Svo, pp. 23. 
 
 1846. Joel Parker. Progress: an address before the 4> B K 
 
 249 
 
Society of Dartmouth College, July 29, 1846. Hano^er. 1846. 
 8vo, pp. 26. 
 
 1847. Samuel G. Brown. The spirit of a scholar : an address 
 before the $ B K Society at Dartmouth. 1847. 
 
 1850. William B. Sprague. See Bowdoin Orations and 
 Addresses, 1850. 
 
 1851. John James Gilchrist. Classical learning in its rela- 
 tions to active life : an address before the $ B K Society of Dart- 
 mouth College, on Wednesday, July 30, 1851. Hanover. 1851. 
 Svo, pp. 28. 
 
 1862. George L. Prentice. The national crisis : being an 
 address delivered before the $ B K Society in Dartmouth Col- 
 lege at Hanover, July 30, 1862. New York. 1862. Svo, pp. 32. 
 
 1865. Alpheus Crosby. The present position of the seceded 
 states and the rights and duties of the general government in 
 respect to them: an address to the * B K Society of Dartmouth 
 College, June 19, 1865. Boston. 1865. 8vo, pp. 16. 
 
 1866. George Stillman Hillard. The political duties of 
 the educated classes : a discourse delivered before the * B K 
 Society of Dartmouth College, July 18, 1866. Boston. 1866. 
 Svo, pp. 48. 
 
 Also delivered before the Amherst Chapter on July 10, 1866. 
 
 1S75. James W. Patterson. The relations of education to 
 public questions : an address delivered before the $ B K Society 
 at Dartmouth College, June 23, 1S75. Hanover. 1875. Svo, 
 PP- 23. 
 
 1878. Alfred Russell. Some effects of the growth of cities 
 on our political system. Address before the # B K Society of 
 Dartmouth College, June 26, 1878. Lowell. 1878. Svo, pp. 
 23. Published by the Society. 
 
 1S81. Charles H. Bell. The worship of success. In An- 
 niversary of the New Hampshire Alpha of the $ B K Society 
 at Dartmouth College, June 29th, 1881, pp. 3-27. Hanover. 1S81. 
 Svo, pp. 33 [32]. 
 
 18S7. Frederick Chase, George Hoadly. Historical ad- 
 dress by Frederick Chase, Esq., and oration by the Hon. George 
 Hoadly, LL.D., delivered before the Phi Beta Kappa Society of 
 Dartmouth College, at its centennial anniversary, June 29, 1S87. 
 Cambridge. 1887. Svo, pp. 39. 
 
 {To be Continued) 
 250 
 
Volume 2 
 
 311 
 
 h '"4'' ''■''■>■ 
 
 ';*■•■ ™w 
 
 Number 6 
 
 
 Contents 
 
 i'te'N 
 
 The Alpha of North Dakota "^f*i- 
 
 The iPhi Beta Kappa Association in Japan 
 
 The Way of Fulfilment— A Poem 
 
 The Alpha of Maine at Bowdoin 
 
 Phi Beta Kappa Publications 
 
 A Phi Beta Kappa Bibliography 
 
 In Memoriam , . . 
 
 Phi Beta Kappa News and Notes 
 
 
 
 JANUARY, 1915 
 
 Page 
 269 
 
 277 
 279 
 283 
 294 
 
 302 
 306 
 
Makers of 
 
 Approved Standard 
 PHI BETA KAPPA KEYS 
 
 FOUR SIZES 
 
 
 
 No. 3 
 $(i.50 
 
 No. 2 
 $7.50 
 
 r4.K OOLO — ACTUAL SIZE 
 
 Your order will have immediate atten^ta^^; 
 
 Give Name, Class and Date to be 
 
 engraved on tke back. 
 
prepared an excellent history of the University and Chapter for 
 publication in the March number of The Key. 
 
 The Vanderbilt Catalogue was prepared by Prof. Herbert 
 Cushing Tolman, Yale '88, who was one of the two members to 
 whom the charter was granted in 1901, and one of the chapter's 
 most loyal supporters. Sixty pages, two-thirds of the whole, are 
 given over to historical matter of great interest including fac- 
 similes of early records, the Vanderbilt Charter and the chapter 
 certificate. The catalogue also contains considerable biographical 
 material respecting the 166 members of the chapter. 
 
 A PHI BETA KAPPA BIBLIOGRAPHY 
 
 By Prof. Clark S. Northup, Cornell. 
 {Continued from Vol. 2, p. 250.) 
 1905. Benjamin Ide Wheeler. Abundant Hfe. Delivered 
 June 27. In The University of California Chronicle, Decem- 
 ber; 1905, viii. 79-91. 
 
 1914. Samuel Walker McCall. The relation of constitu- 
 tional restraint to the individual. Delivered March 7. An ab- 
 stract appeared in The Dartmouth for March 8, 1914. 
 
 Poems. 
 
 1803. J. Warren Brackett. The ghost of the law or An- 
 archy and despotism: a poem before the * B K of Dartmouth 
 College at their anniversary, Aug. 23, 1803. Hanover. 1803. 
 8vo, pp. 24. 
 
 1824. Nathaniel H. Carter. The pains of the imagination, 
 a poem, read before the $ B K Society, at Dartmouth College, 
 Aug. 19, 1824. Boston. Commercial Gazette Press. 1824. 8vo, 
 
 pp. vi, 25. 
 
 1834. Ralph Waldo Emerson. See Harvard Poems, 18.^4. 
 
 1875. George A. Marden. Philosophy the guide of life: a 
 poem before the $ B K Society at Dartmouth College, June 23, 
 1875. (No. t.-p.) 
 
 1881. John Boyle O'Reilly. The three queens. In Anniver- 
 sary of the Nezv Hampshire Alpha of the * B K Society at Dart- 
 mouth College, June 29, 1881, pp. 29 [28] -33 ,[32]. Hanover. 
 
 1881. 8vo, pp. 33. 
 
 297 
 
Also in James Jeffrey Roche, Life of John Boyle O'Reilly, New York, 
 Cassell, [1891], 8vo, pp. 600-604. 
 
 General. 
 
 Frederick Chase. See above under Orations, 1887. 
 
 Francis Lane Childs. Dartmouth Chapter's 125th anniver- 
 sary. In The Key, March, 1913, i. 11. 21-26. Ilhistrated. 
 
 The Dartmouth, March 6, 1914, contained a notice of the 
 approaching anniversary and an editorial article on the Society. 
 
 James Thayer Gould. Bibliography of Dartmouth College 
 and Hanover, New Hampshire. Corjcord. 1894. 8vo. Pp. 51-54 
 include a bibliography of Phi Beta Kappa at Dartmouth. 
 
 John K. Lord. The Alpha of New Plampshire. In The 
 Key, March, 1913, i. 11. 9-21. Illustrated. 
 
 John M. Poor. See Ph. B. K. Publ, N. S. 3, p. [4]. 
 
 Oscar M. Voorhees. Dartmouth College. In The Key, 
 March, 1913, i. 11. 3-9. Illustrated. 
 
 DENISON UNIVERSITY. 
 
 Theta of Ohio. Organized January 18, 191 1. 
 
 Catalogues. 
 
 1914. 8vo, pp. 34 (in Denison University Bulletins, N. S. 49). 
 Ed. by W. A. ChamberHn. 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 
 191 1. Francis W. Shepardson. Address at the foundation 
 meeting. In The Key, March, 191:, i. 3. 9-12. 
 
 1913. George E. Horr. The new sense of humanity. An 
 address before the Phi Beta Kappa of Denison University, June 
 II, 1913. In Denison University Bulletins, N. S. 49, pp. 35-56. 
 
 General. 
 Raymond W. Pence. The Theta of Ohio at Denison Univer- 
 sity. In The Key, March, 191 1, i. 3. 6-13. Illustrated. 
 
 DEPAUW UNIVERSITY. 
 ALPpA OF Indiana. Organized December 17, 1889. 
 
 Catalogues. 
 Has published none; but the Junior Annual yearly gives the 
 names of members living and deceased. 
 
 298 
 
General. 
 William F. Swahlen. See Ph. B. K. Publ., N. S. 3, p. [12]. 
 
 DICKINSON COLLEGE. 
 Alpha of Pennsylvania. Organized April 13, 1887. 
 Catalogues. 
 1914. 8vo, pp. 19. 
 
 General. 
 John Fred Mohler. See Ph. B. K. Publ, N. S. 3, p. [11]. 
 
 FRANKLIN AND MARSHALL COLLEGE. 
 
 Theta of Pennsylvania. Organized January 30, 1908. 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 
 1908. J. Spangler Kieffer. Education and pessimism. In 
 The Reformed Church Review, October, 1908, Fourth Series, 
 xii. 433-52. 
 
 1911. [James] Brander Matthews. The American language. 
 Delivered June 7 and stenographically reported. In The Reformed 
 Church Review, July, 1911, xv. 285-95. 
 
 1912. Joseph Buffington. A recall of Benjamin Franklin. 
 An address . . . delivered at Lancaster, Pa., on June 12, 
 1912, before Theta Chapter of Pennsylvania of the Phi Beta 
 Kappa Society, in connection with Franklin and Marshall Col- 
 lege. Lancaster, Pa. The New Era Printing Co. [1912.] 8vo, 
 
 PP- 39- 
 
 General. 
 
 John B. Kieffer. The history of our charter and the purpose 
 of our organization. Read at the first public meeting, January 
 30, 1908. In The Oriflamme, 1909, xxvi. 21.1-21. 
 
 George F. Mull. See Ph. B. K. Publ., N. S. 8, pp. 19-20. 
 
 THE UNIVERSITY OF GEORGIA. 
 
 Alpha of Georgia. Organized March ^y, 1914. 
 
 299 
 
Catalogues. 
 The Key, May, 1914, ii. 4. 194-5. 
 
 General. 
 
 See Ph. B. K. Publ, N. S. ix. 5, 11, and The Key, May, 1913, 
 i. 12. 19-20, October, 1913, ii. i. 28, and May, 1914, ii. 4. 190-97. 
 Notices of the installation also appeared in the Athens Banner 
 and the Athens Herald, March 27 and 28, 1914, and the Atlanta 
 Constitution, the Augusta Chronicle, the Savannah Press, and 
 the Savannah Nezvs, March 28, 1914. 
 
 GOUCHER COLLEGE. 
 
 Beta of Maryland. Organized February 24, 1905. 
 
 General. 
 
 Johnetta Van Meter. See Ph. B. K. PubL, N. S. 3. p. [23]. 
 See also same, N. S. 2, p. [8] . 
 
 GRINNELL COLLEGE. 
 
 Beta of Iowa. Organized April ii, 1908. 
 
 Catalogues. 
 
 1910. i6mo, pp. 7. 1913. 8vo, pp. 34. 
 
 General. 
 
 The constitution was printed in 1910, 32mo, pp. 11. 
 Clara E. Millerd. See Ph. B. K. PubL, N. S. 8, p. 20. 
 
 ■HAMILTON COLLEGE. 
 
 Epsilon of New York. Organized May 24, 1870. 
 
 Catalogues. 
 
 1906. 8vo, pp. 19. 
 
 General. 
 
 Joseph D. Ibbotson, Jr. See Ph. B. K. PubL, N. S. 3, p. 
 [10]. 
 
 300 
 
HAMPDEN-SIDNEY COLLEGE. 
 
 General. 
 
 See Edward Everett Hale in The Atlantic Monthly, July, 1879, 
 xliv. 106. 
 
 HARVARD UNIVERSITY. 
 
 Alpha of Massachusetts. Organized September 5, 1781 
 Catalogues. 
 
 1806. sm. Svo (by the fold, a 4to), pp. 15. 1810. 8vo (by the 
 fold, a 4to), pp. 14. 1814. Svo, pp. 20. 1818. Svo, pp. 23. 1823. 
 Svo, pp. 23. 1826. Svo, pp. 24. 1829. Svo, pp. 26. 1833. Svo, 
 pp. 28. 1836. Svo, pp. 30. 1S39. Svo, pp. 30. 1S42. Svo, pp. 
 32. 1S46. Svo, pp. 48. 1S49. 8vo, pp. 50. 1S53. Svo, pp. 58. 
 This was the first to give the constitution ; all later issues have it. 
 1S56. Svo, pp. 60. 1S61, Svo, pp. 58. The folds of this are in 
 '6's; those of all preceding, in 4's. 1S73. Svo, pp. 66. 1885. Svo, 
 pp. 72. 1S91. Svo, pp. 75. In 1S97 a Supplement to the last, 
 1892-1S97, sm. Svo, pp. 12. 1902. Svo, pp. 85. 1912. Svo, pp. 
 V, [3], 211, with 12 plates; compiled by William Coolidge Lane. 
 
 The Catalogue of 1912 contains a transcript of the early records, includ- 
 ing much that is important for the general history of Phi Beta Kappa in 
 New England. Reviewed in The Harvard Graduates' Magazine, Dec, 
 1912, March, 1913, xxi. 365-6, S93-4; in The Nation, Nov. 28, 1912, xcv. 
 512- 
 
 The Harvard Library has a complete set of these catalogues. 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 
 178S. John Quincy Adams. 
 
 "The text of Mr. Adams's oration is included in his manuscript Diary,, 
 deposited in the library of the Massachusetts Historical Society. A type- 
 written copy is in the Phi Beta Kappa files in the Harvard Library." W.. 
 H. Tillinghast. 
 
 1789. William Emerson. On taste. 
 
 1794. Charles Coffin. The duellist. 
 
 1796. Timothy Bigelow. An oration, pronounced at Cam- 
 bridge, before the $ B K, at their annual meeting on Thursday, 
 July 21, 1796. It being the day following the public commence- 
 ment. Boston. Manning and Loring. 1797. Svo, pp. 15. 
 Deals with the origin and character of the Society. 
 
1798- John Thornton Kirkland. An oration, delivered at 
 the request of the society of 4> B K, in the chapel of Harvard Col- 
 lege, on the day of their anniversary, July 19, 1798. Boston. John 
 Russell. 1798. Bvo, pp. 24. 
 
 Deals with "those principles, manners, and institutions which are the 
 price and pledge of all America's other blessings.'' Opposed to French 
 infidelity and Godwin's Political justice. 
 
 1800. Abiel Abbot. 
 
 1805. Oliver Fiske. 
 
 1806. Thomas Boylston Adams. On philosophy. 
 
 1807. Theodore Dehon. Literature. 
 
 1808. James Richardson. An oration, describing the influ- 
 ence of commerce on the prosperity, character and genius of na- 
 tions. Written at the request of the society of <1> B K and deliv- 
 ered on their anniversary, at Cambridge, September i, 1808. Pub- 
 lished by desire. Boston. Russell and Cutler. 1808. 8vo, pp. 20. 
 
 1809. Joseph Stevens Buckminster. Discourse on the dan- 
 gers and duties of men of letters. Pronounced at Cambridge be- 
 fore the society of * B K, on Thursday, August 31, 1809. The 
 Monthly Anthology, Sept., 1809, vii. 145-58. Also in Works of 
 Joseph Stevens Buckminster, with memoirs of his life, Boston, 
 1839, ii. 339-362. 
 
 181 5. William Tudor, Jr. An address delivered to the Phi 
 Beta Kappa Society, at their anniversary meeting at Cambridge. 
 In The North American Reviezv, November, 1815, ii. 13-32. 
 
 On the subjects for poetry furnished by America. 
 
 1816. Francis Calley Gray. An address before the society of 
 # B K on Thursday, 29th August, 1816. In The North American 
 Review, September, 1816, iii. 289-305. 
 
 Subject, the obstacles which oppose the cultivation of letters. 
 (To be continued.) 
 
 IN MEMORIAM 
 
 Judge David Cross^ Dartmouth '41, "Dartmouth's grand old 
 man," and the oldest member of the Alpha of New Hampshire 
 of Phi Beta Kappa, died in Manchester, N. H., October i, 1914, 
 at the ripe old age of ninety-seven. For the past decade and 
 more Judge Cross visited Hanover every year either at Com- 
 mencement or at "Dartmouth Night," and always took part in 
 
 302 
 
■*'^^^^^^^^^??T*'*^^ 
 
 
 Volume 2 
 
 Nnmlier 7 
 
 (Eontents 
 
 
 ■\ ■ 
 
 John Heath, The Founded 
 The Alpha of Rhode Island at Brown 
 Ebb and Flow— A Poem . . 
 Representative Phi Bet^ Kappa Orations 
 Recent Phi Beta Kappa Publications . , 
 A Phi Beta Kappa Bibliography 
 In Memoriam . . 
 Phi Beta Kappa News and Notes 
 
 Page 
 
 . 317 
 
 327 
 . 342 
 
 342 
 
 . 344 
 
 345 
 . 352 
 
 354 
 
 
 
 ■::r, ^-ii.#*^^^^v' ' ' ■^' - 
 
 ■•■>-• -^ '„ : - . 
 
 
 
 '.^J.:m^^^<-,.. 
 
 :'^^''::'l''l^^ 
 
 
 MARCH, 1915 
 
 ' C '■ 
 

 Makers of 
 
 Approved Standard 
 BETA KAPPA 
 
 FOUR SIZES 
 
 No. 3 
 $6.50 
 
 14-K GOLD — ACTUAL SIZE 
 
 No. 2 
 $7.50 
 
 Your order will have immediate attention. 
 Give Name, Class and Daite to be 
 
 engraved on the back. / 
 
 C-SSSSSf/flf ^SSS 
 
 ••r^rg^rr^ 
 
ing the fact that much new material has been brought to light 
 through recent researches. Most of this information has been 
 published in The Phi Beta Kappa Key, and is available for all 
 who would know the history and development of the fraternity. 
 
 In telling of the founding of the chapter Prof. Shepardson re- 
 produces a large number of letters sent by Dr. Parsons, the Sec- 
 retary of the United Chapters, and others, to Professor, now 
 President Harry Pratt Judson, and gives a facsimile of the char- 
 ter issued in 1898. The Chapter was formally instituted July i, 
 1899. 
 
 Then follow the membership rolls arranged with especial care 
 as follows: Charter Members (11), Faculty Members (no). 
 Former Faculty Members (30), Graduate Students Affiliating 
 with the Chapter (19), Honorary Members (5), and members 
 Elected on Receiving the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy with 
 Grade Suinma cum Laude (50), Alumni Members from the 
 graduates of the Old University of Chicago (15), and Under- 
 graduate members, arranged by dates of election (518). A list 
 of the 25 who have died is also given under the heading, "The 
 Chapter Eternal." Of especial interest is a list of the twenty 
 books published by members elected in course, and another lisi 
 of Higher Degrees Conferred on Members. 
 
 It will be seen that the Chicago Chapter, in addition to the 
 three well recognized groups of members has another which may 
 be designated Post Graduate Members, owing to the rule which 
 admits students earning a Ph.D. with grade, Summa cum Laude. 
 
 A PHI BETA KAPPA BIBLIOGRAPHY 
 
 By Prof. Clark S. Northup, Cornell '93. 
 
 (Continued from Vol. 2, p. 302.) 
 
 HARVARD— (Co^tinved). 
 
 1817. William Crafts. An oration on the influence of moral 
 causes on national character, delivered before the * B K Society 
 on their anniversary, 28 August, 1817. Cambridge. Hilliard and 
 Metcalf. 1817. 8vo, pp. 16. 
 
 1821. John Chipman Gray. An oration pronounced before 
 the society of Phi Beta Kappa, at Cambridge, August 30, 1821. 
 
 345 
 
The advantages to American literature of enjoying a conformity 
 of language with the English. In The North American Reviezv, 
 October, 1821, xiii. 478-490. 
 
 1822. William Jones Spooner. An address delivered at 
 Cambridge, before the society of Phi Beta Kappa, at their an- 
 nual meeting, August 29, 1822. Boston. Oliver Everett. 1822. 
 8vo, pp. 34. 
 Deals with the prospects of American hterature. 
 
 1824. Edward Everett. An oration pronounced at Cam- 
 bridge, before the society of Phi Beta Kappa, August 2y [26], 
 1824. Published by request. Boston. Oliver Everett. 1824. 
 8vo, pp. 67. Also New York. J. W. Palmer & Co. 1824. 8vo, 
 pp. 40. 
 
 A 2d, a 3(i, and a 4th edition were published, the last (by Cummings, 
 Hilliard & Co.) in 1825. Reprinted (The circumstances favorable to the 
 progress of intellectual life in America) in his Orations and speeches on 
 various occasions, Boston, 1850, i. 9-44. Reviewed in The North American 
 Review, April, 1825, xx. 417-440, October, 1850, Ixxi. 449-451 ; by W. B. 
 Sprague in The New Englander, February, 1851, ix. 52-53. 
 
 1825. Nathaniel Langdon Frothingham. The revolutions 
 in letters. 
 
 "The manuscript of this address is in Harvard College Library." W. 
 H. Tillinghast. 
 
 1826. Joseph Story. A discourse pronounced before the Phi 
 Beta Kappa Society, at the anniversary celebration on the thirty- 
 first day of August, 1826. Boston. Hilliard, Gray, Little, and 
 Wilkins. 1826. 8vo, pp. 58. 
 
 Proposes "to trace out some of the circumstances of our age, which con- 
 nect themselves closely with the cause of science and letters." 
 
 Reprinted in Story's Miscellaneous Writings, Boston, 1835, pp. 3-33; in 
 Frank Moore's American eloquence. New York, 1857, ii. 424-437; and in 
 The world's great classics. New York, Colonial Press, 1900, orations of 
 American orators, i. 378-411. Reviewed in The North American Review, 
 January, 1827, xxiv. 129-41. 
 
 1830. Orville Dewey. An oration delivered at Cambridge 
 before the society of Phi Beta Kappa, August 26, 1830. Boston. 
 Gray and Bowen. 1830. 8vo, pp. 32. 
 
 Theme : "The loftiest attainments of the mind in every sphere of its exer- 
 tion are immediately the fruit of nothing but the deepest study." 
 
 1832. Jared Sparks. On some of the characteristics of his- 
 tory as a subject of study, and particularly the history of the 
 United States. 
 
 346 
 
On the original manuscript, whicli is among tlie Sparks papers in tlie 
 Harvard Library, has been written: "Has nearly all been printed in The 
 Boston Book, 1837, and American Museum, 1839. 
 
 1833. Edward Everett. Education of mankind. In his Ora- 
 tions mid speeches on various occasions, Boston, 1850, i. 404-441. 
 
 First delivered at New Haven, August 20, 1833, before the Yale Chapter, 
 and for the most part repeated by request (with additions) at Cambridge, 
 August 30. 
 
 1834. William Howard Gardiner. An address, delivered 
 before the Phi Beta Kappa Society of Harvard University, 28 
 August, 1834, on classical learning and eloquence. 
 
 Quid voveat dulci nutricula majus alumno 
 Quam sapere, et fari ut possit quae sentiat? 
 
 Hor. Ep. I. iv. 8. 
 
 Cambridge. James Munroe and Co. 1834. 8vo, pp. 68. 
 Reviewed in The New England Magazine, November, 1834, vii. 416-8. 
 
 1835. Theophilus Parsons. An address, delivered before 
 the Phi Beta Kappa Society of Harvard University, 27 August, 
 1835, on the duties of educated men in a republic. Boston. 
 Russell, Odiorne and Co. 1835. 8vo, pp. 28. 
 
 Reviewed in The New England Magazine, October, 1835, ix. 303-5; by 
 E. in Harvardiana, ii. 30-32. 
 
 1836. Francis Wayland. The practical uses of the principles 
 of faith. Delivered September i. 
 
 Apparently not printed. See F. and H. L. Wayland, A memoir of the 
 life and labors of Francis Wayland, New York, Sheldon, 1867, 8vo, i. 351- 
 2; J. O. Murray, Francis Wayland, Boston, 1891, p. 79. 
 
 1837. Ralph Waldo Emerson. An oration, delivered before 
 the Phi Beta Kappa Society, at Cambridge, August 31, 1837. 
 Published by request. Boston. James Munroe & Co. 1837. 
 8vo, pp. 26. Second edition, 1838, pp. 32. 
 
 Reprinted (The American scholar) in his Miscellanies, Boston, 1856, pp. 
 77-111; in Nature, addresses, and lectures, Boston, 1884, pp. 83-liS; and in 
 other editions of his miscellanies, as well as separately many times (e. g. 
 Man thinking, London, C. E. Mudie [1844] ; New York, Laurentian Press, 
 1901, 8 vo, pp. 59) ; also in Representative Ph. B. K. orations, Boston, 
 Houghton MifHin Co., 1915. 
 
 Reviewed by C. P. Cranch in The Western Messenger, November, 1837, 
 iv. 184-188; in The Democratic Review, February, 1838, i. 327-29; by 
 William Henry Channing in The Boston Quarterly Review, January, 1838, 
 i. 106-20. See also Charles F. Thwing, Emerson's "American scholar" six- 
 
 347 
 
ty jears after, The Forum, August, 1897, xxiii. 661-71 ; Emerson, Journal, 
 Boston, 1912, iv. 341 ; and Northwestern Orations and Addresses, 190,^ 
 
 1841. Frederic Henry Hedge. Conservatism and reform. 
 An oration delivered before the 4> B K Society of Harvard College, 
 
 at their first meeting after the change in their constitution en- 
 larging the terms of membership. In his Martin Luther and 
 other essays, Boston, 1888, pp. 129-165. 
 
 Comment by E. E. Hale in James Russell Lowell and his friends, Boston, 
 1899, pp. 128-g. 
 
 1843. George Stillman Hillard. The relation of the poet 
 to his age. A discourse delivered before the Phi Beta Kappa 
 Society of Harvard University, on Thursday, August 24, 1843. 
 Boston. Charles C. Little and James Brown. 1843. ^^o, PP- 
 
 53- 
 There was also a second edition, same size. 
 Reviewed in The North American Review, October, 1843, Ivii. 505-9. 
 
 1844. George Putnam. An oration delivered at Cambridge, 
 before the Phi Beta Kappa Society in Harvard University, 29 
 August, 1844. Boston. Charles C. Little and James Brown. 
 1844. 8vo, pp. 36. 
 
 Subject, The connection between intellectual and moral culture; between 
 scholarship and character, literature and life. 
 
 Strictures on the moral character of Voltaire, Byron, and Burns pro- 
 voked a reply : Remarks upon an oration delivered at Cambridge, by 
 George Putnam, before the Phi Beta Kappa Society, in Harvard University, 
 August 29, 1844. By a member of the Suffolk bar. Boston. William D. 
 Ticknor & Co. 1844. Svo, pp. 35. 
 
 1845. Andrew Preston Peabody. The connection between 
 science and religion. An oration delivered before the Phi Beta 
 Kappa Society of Harvard University, August 28, 1845. Bos- 
 ton. Charles C. Little and James Brown. 1845. 8vo, pp 29. 
 
 Reprinted in Representative Ph. B. K. orations, Boston, 1915. 
 
 1846. Charles Sumner. The scholar, the jurist, the artist, 
 the philanthropist. An address before the Phi Beta Kappa 
 Society of Harvard University, at their anniversary, August 27. 
 1846. "Then I would say to the young disciple of Truth and 
 Beauty, who would know how to satisfy the noble impulse of 
 his heart, through every opposition of the century, — I i.vould 
 say, Give the world beneath your influence a direction towards 
 the good and the tranquil rhythm of time will bring its develop- 
 
 348 
 
ment." Schiller. Boston. William D. Ticknor & Co. 1846. 
 8vo, pp. 72. 
 
 There was also a second edition in the same year. 
 
 Commemorated John Pickering, Joseph Story, Washington AUston, and 
 William Ellery Channing. See Emerson's Journal, Boston, 1912, vii. 228. 
 
 Reviewed in The North American Review, January, 1847, Ixiv. 254-7. 
 
 1847. George Perkins Marsh. Human knowledge: a dis- 
 course delivered before the Massachusetts Alpha of the Phi Beta 
 Kappa Society, at Cambridge, August 26, 1847. Boston. Charles 
 C. Little and James Brown. 1847. 8vo, pp. 42. 
 
 Also in his Life and Letters, New York, Scribner, 1888, pp. 431-452. 
 Reviewed in The New Englander, April, 1848, vi. 311-12. 
 
 1848. Horace Bushnell. An oration delivered before the 
 society of Phi Beta Kappa, at Cambridge, August 24, 1848. 
 Cambridge. George Nicholls. 1848. 8vo, pp. 39. 
 
 Third edition, 1848, same size. 
 
 Treats of work and play under various aspects. 
 
 Also printed as Work and play in his Work and play, or Literary 
 varieties. New York, Scribner, 1864, pp. 1-42. Also in his Literary varieties. 
 New York, Scribner, 1881. 
 
 Reviewed in The New Englander, October, 1848, vi. 597-598. 
 
 1849. George Washington Bethune. The claims of our 
 country on its literary men. An oration before the Phi Beta 
 Kappa Society of Harvard University, July 19, 1849. Cam- 
 bridge. John Bartlett. 1849. 8vo, pp. 52. 
 
 Also in his Orations and occasional discourses, New York, G. P. Putnam, 
 1850, 8vo, pp. 381-428. 
 
 1850. Timothy Walker. The reform spirit of the day. An 
 oration before the Phi Beta Kappa Society of Harvard Univer- 
 sity, July 18, 1850. Boston and Cambridge. James Munroe and 
 Co. 1850. 8vo, pp. 38. 
 
 1851. William Buell Sprague. An oration pronounced be- 
 fore the Phi Beta Kappa Society of Harvard University, July 
 17, 1851. Albany. Gray, Sprague and Co. 1851. 8vo, pp. 60. 
 Treats of "The American mind — her character and destiny." 
 
 1853. Henry Whitney Bellows. The ledger and the lexi- 
 con : or Business and literature in account with American educa- 
 tion. An oration before the Phi Beta Kappa Society of Har- 
 vard College, July 26, 1853. Cambridge. John Bartlett. 1853. 
 8vo, pp. S3. 
 
 Comment in The Harvard Register, Feb., 1881, iii. 61. 
 
 349 
 
i8s6. Leonard Bacon. The relation of Christianity to law 
 and government. Delivered July 17. In The New Englaiidcr, 
 August, 1856, xiv. 447-463- 
 
 1858. Thomas Hill. Liberal education. An address deliv- 
 ered before the Phi Beta Kappa Society of Harvard College, 
 July 22, 1858. Cambridge. John Bartlett. 1858. 8vo, pp. 34. 
 
 Reviewed in The North American Review, Oct., 1858, Ixxxvii. ST^-7^- 
 
 1861. George Sew all Boutwell. The conspiracy; its pur- 
 poses and its power. In his Speeches and papers relating to the 
 Rebellion, Boston, Little, Brown & Co., 1867, 8vo, pp. 94- 
 122. 
 
 1862. George William Curtis. The American doctrine of 
 liberty. An oration delivered before the # B K Society of Har- 
 vard University, July 17, 1862. In his Orations and addresses, 
 New York, Harper, 1894, i. 95-122. 
 
 Reprinted in Representative Ph. B. K. orations, Boston, 1915. 
 1867. Ralph Waldo Emerson. Progress and culture. Ad- 
 dress read before the $ B K Society at Cambridge, July 18, 1867. 
 In his Letters and social aims, Boston, 1875, pp. 183-209; 
 new and revised edition, Boston, 1884, pp. 197-222; and in 
 other editions. 
 
 1870. Oliver Wendell Holmes. Mechanism in thought and 
 morals. An address delivered before the Phi Beta Kappa So- 
 ciety of Harvard University, June 29, 1870. With notes and af- 
 terthoughts. — "Car il ne faut pas se meconnaitre, nous sommes 
 automates autant qu'esprit." — Pascal: Pensees, chap. xi. 4. — 
 Boston. James R. Osgood and Co. 1871. i2mo, pp. loi. 
 
 Reprinted in Pages from an old volume of life, 1883, 1891, 1892, pp. 260- 
 314. 
 
 Reviewed by William Dean Howells in The Atlantic Monthly, May. 1871, 
 xxvii. 653-654. 
 
 1871. Noah Porter. The science of nature versus the science 
 of man. See Trinity Orations and Addresses, 1871. 
 
 1873. Charles Francis Adams (the elder). An address de- 
 livered at Cambridge before the society of the Phi Beta Kappa, 
 26 June, 1873. Cambridge. John Wilson and Son. 1873. 8vo, 
 pp, 28. 
 
 Subject, the relation between the college and the state. 
 
 1874. Charles Carroll Everett. The gain of history. In 
 The Unitarian Review, August, 1874, ii. 16-36. 
 
 350 
 
Also in his Immortality and other essays, Boston, The American Uni- 
 tarian Association, igo2. 
 
 1875. Theodore Dwight Woolsey. The relations of honor 
 to poHtical life. An address delivered before the society of the 
 Phi Beta Kappa of Harvard College, July i, 1875. New Haven. 
 Judd and White. 1875. 8vo, pp. 28. 
 
 1876. Jeremiah Lewis Diman. The alienation of the edu- 
 cated class from politics. An oration before the Phi Beta Kappa 
 Society at Cambridge, June 29, 1876. Providence. Sidney S. 
 Rider. 1876. 8vo, pp. 37. 
 
 Reprinted in his Orations and essays, Boston, Houghton, Mifflin & Co., 
 1882, pp. 41-75. 
 
 1877. Thomas Francis Bayard. "Unwritten law." An ad- 
 dress delivered before the Phi Beta Kappa Society of Harvard 
 University, at Cambridge, Massachusetts, June 28, 1877. Bos- 
 ton. A. Williams and Co. 1877. 8vo, pp. 47. 
 
 1878. John William Dawson. The present rights and du- 
 ties of science. In The Princeton Review, Nov., 1878, vii. 674- 
 696. 
 
 Also reprinted. 
 
 1880. Richard Salter Storrs. The recognition of the super- 
 natural in letters and in life. An oration. Delivered July i, 
 
 1880. New York. Anson D. F. Randolph and Co. [1881.] 
 
 8vo, pp. 57. 
 
 An abstract was printed in The Harvard Register, August, 1880, ii. lSS-7- 
 
 1881. Wendell Phillips. The scholar in a republic. Ad- 
 dress at the centenary anniversary of the Phi Beta Kappa of 
 Harvard College, June 30, 1881. Boston. Lee and Shepard. 
 New York. Charles T. Dillingham. 8vo, pp. 36. 
 
 Also printed in The Boston Daily Advertiser, July i, 1881, and in The 
 Boston Commonwealth, July 9, 1881. Also in Carlos Martyn, Wendell 
 Phillips, New York, Funk and Wagnalls, 1890, 8vo, pp. 570-94; and in 
 Representative Ph. B. K. orations, Boston, 1915. 
 
 Comment by George William Curtis in Harper's Magazine, September, 
 
 1881, Ixxiii. 625-626; reprinted (Wendell Phillips at Harvard, 1881) in 
 his From, the Easy Chair, pp. 129-138. Parts quoted by Copeland in Men 
 and days in Phi Beta Kappa, pp. 101-102. 
 
 1882. Carl Schurz. The condition and prospects of Ameri- 
 can society. Delivered June 29, 1882. In The Boston Daily Ad- 
 vertiser, June 30, 1882. 
 
 (To be Continued) 
 
 351 
 
IN MEMORIAM 
 
 Charles Greene Rockwood, Ph.D., Yale '64, died at Cald- 
 well, N, J., July 2, 1913, in his seventieth year. From 1868 to 
 1873 he was Professor of Mathematics and Natural Philosophy 
 at Bowdoin, and of Mathematics and Astronomy at Rutgers the 
 next four years. During this period he became an Associate mem- 
 ber of the Alpha of New Jersey. In 1877 he accepted an invita- 
 tion to the chair of Mathematics in Princeton, where he served 
 until 1905. He was instrumental in securing a Phi Beta Kappa 
 charter for Princeton, was president of the chapter a number of 
 years, and its delegate to the Council. He was a member of sev- 
 eral learned societies, and an honorary member of the British 
 Association for the Advancement of Science. His Ph.D. was 
 conferred by Yale in 1866. 
 
 Prof. Katherine Coman, Ph.D., Michigan '80, died at her 
 home, Wellesley, Mass., January 11, 1914, in her fifty-seventh 
 year. Miss Coman came to Wellesley on her graduation as in- 
 structor in English, and continued in the service of the college 
 until her death. In 1883 she became professor of history, and in 
 1900 was made head of the new Department of Economics and 
 Sociology. In 1913 she retired from active service, being made 
 emeritus professor. Thus her active service at Wellesley con- 
 tinued for a third of a century. Professor Coman was an author 
 of note, her last work, published in 1912, being entitled "Economic 
 Beginnings of the Far West," in two volumes. At the time of 
 her death she was working on an "Industrial History of New 
 England." She became a member of the Eta of Massachusetts 
 .at its organization in 1904. 
 
 Judge Willard Penfield Voorhees, LL.D., Rutgers '71, died 
 at his home. New Brunswick, N. J., May 31, 1914, in his sixty- 
 third year. Soon after graduation he began the study of law 
 in the office of the late Judge B. R. Woodbridge Strong, a 
 fellow alumnus of the class of 1847, was admitted to the bar in 
 1874, and practiced continuously in New Brunswick, his native 
 ■city. In 1908 he was appointed an Associate Justice of the 
 New Jersey Supreme Court, and continued in this office until 
 his death. He had been since 1909 a Trustee of his alma mater. 
 He was an accomplished musician, and for many years was 
 ■organist in the First Presbyterian Church. Rutgers conferred on 
 him the LL.D in 1910. 
 
 Ho.N. John Langbourne Williams, Litt.D., Virginia '51, died 
 in Richmond, his native city, on February 13, 1915, in his eighty- 
 third year. He was graduated from the University of Virginia 
 
 352 
 
Volume 2 
 
 Number 8 
 
 Contents 
 
 Page 
 
 John Heath, The Founder— Concluded . 365 
 
 Activities of the Harvard Chapter -. . 373 
 
 The New Scholarship .... 376 
 
 The Upper Hudson Association . . 382 
 
 Additions to Phi Beta Kappa Membership . 383 
 
 W^ar and Civilization — A Poem. . • 387 
 
 Representative Phi Beta Kappa Orations . 394 
 
 A Phi Beta Kapa Bibliography . . 395 
 
 In Memoriam ..... 398 
 
 Phi Beta Kappa News and Notes . . 401 
 
 MAY, 1915 
 
im^il^^^i^i^mffi 
 
 Makers of 
 
 Approved Standard 
 PHI BETA KAPPA KEYS 
 
 
 
 FOUR SIZES 
 
 
 $BK 
 
 No. 4 I 
 $5.50 
 
 ** 
 
 No. 3 = 
 $6.50 f 
 
 14-K GOLD — ACTUAL SIZE 
 
 No. 2 
 $7.50 
 
 Your order will have immediate attention. 
 
 Give Name, Class and Date to be 
 
 engraved on the back. 
 
 
tions given date from the famous year of 1837, which marl<ed 
 not only the beginning of the Victorian era, but also, in view of 
 the influence of Emerson's address, the dawn of American liter- 
 ary independence. It is believed that all orations will be found 
 to discuss topics that in some way or other are still of vital inter- 
 est to us at the present day, and will be found to represent such a 
 diversity of opinions as to compel the attention of the thoughtful 
 reader. 
 
 The edition is limited to one thousand copies, of which five 
 hundred have by special agreement been purchased by the United 
 Chapters. About two-thirds of these have already been subscrib- 
 ed for, and the officers of the United Chapters hope that the 
 worth of the book will be so fully appreciated by the members of 
 Phi Beta Kappa and others that the remaining copies will find 
 ready sale, and both the Society and the publishers secured from 
 loss in the venture. 
 
 The ad'i'ance price has been withdrawn, but a reduced price 
 in connection with a three year subscription to the Phi Beta Kap- 
 pa Key is still offered ; i. e. $3.50. The publishers' price is $3.00 
 net. 
 
 For subscription blank see page 406. 
 
 A PHI BETA KAPPA BIBLIOGRAPHY 
 
 Bv Prof. Clark S. Northrup, Cornell '93. 
 
 (Continued from Vol. 2, p. J§J.) 
 
 HARVARD— (CoKTmuED) . 
 
 1883. Charles Francis Adams, Jr. A college fetich. An 
 address delivered before the Harvard Chapter of the fraternity 
 of the Phi Beta Kappa, in Sanders Theatre, Cambridge, June 
 28, 1883. Boston. Lee and Shepard. New York. Charles T. 
 Dillingham. 1883. 8vo, pp. 38. 
 
 Second edition, 1883. Third edition, with supplementary matter, 1884. 
 Pp. 71. Also printed in The Boston Herald, June 29, 1883, and in The In- 
 dependent, Aug. 9, 1883 ; also in his Three Phi Beta Kappa addresses, Bos- 
 ton, Houghton, Mifflin & Co., 1907, pp. 3-48. A bibliography of the dis- 
 cussion of the address will be found in A list of the publications of Harvard 
 University and its officers, etc.. 1880-85, Cambridge, 1886, pp. 9-12. See 
 also Amherst Orations and Addresses, 1884, Vermont Orations and Ad- 
 dresses, 1884. 
 
 395 
 
1884. Richard Claverhouse Jebb. Some ancient organs 
 of public opinion. An address delivered before the members of 
 the * B K Society at Harvard College, June 26, 1884. Cam- 
 bridge [England]. Printed at the University Press. 1884. 8vo, 
 pp. 24. 
 
 1885. William Henry Rawle. The case of the educated un- 
 employed. An address delivered before the Harvard chapter 
 of the fraternity of the Phi Beta Kappa Society [sic] in Sanders 
 Theatre, Cambridge, June 25th, 1885. Philadelphia. Porter and 
 Coaks. 1885. 8vo, pp. 31. 
 
 Second edition. Boston. Little, Brown and Co. London. Sampson 
 Low, Marston, Searle and Rivington. 1885. 8vo, pp. 31. 
 
 1886. Daniel Coit Oilman. An address before the Phi Beta 
 Kappa Society of Harvard University, July i, 1886. [Balti- 
 more. John Murphy & Co., printers.] 1886. 8vo, pp. 33. 
 
 Subject, the characteristics of a university. Also delivered before the 
 Yale Chapter in 1886. Also in his University problems in the United States, 
 New York, The Century Co., 1898, 8vo, pp. 77-106. 
 
 1888. Charles William Eliot. The working of the Amer- 
 ican democracy. An address delivered before the fraternity $ 
 B K of Harvard University, June 28, 1888. Cambridge. John 
 Wilson and Son. 1888. 8vo, pp. 24. 
 
 Also in his American contributions to civilization and other essays and 
 addresses. New York, The Century Co., 1897, 8vo, pp. 69-100. 
 
 1889. Edward John Phelps. International relations. Ad- 
 dress before the Phi Beta Kappa Society of Harvard University, 
 June 29 [27], 1889. Burlington [Vt.]. Free Press Association. 
 1S89. L. 8vo, pp. 31. 
 
 Also printed in The Boston Daily Advertiser and The Boston Post, June 
 28, 1889. 
 
 1890. Henry Codman Potter. The scholar and the state. 
 Oration delivered June 26, 1890, before the Phi Beta Kappa Chap- 
 ter of Harvard University. New York. E. P. Button and Co. 
 1890. 8vo, pp. 32. 
 
 Reprinted in The scholar and the state, and other orations and addresses. 
 New York, The Century Co., 1897, pp. 1-29. 
 
 1891. William Watson Goodwin. The present and future 
 of Harvard College; an address delivered before the Phi Beta 
 Kappa Society at Cambridge, Mass., June 25, 1891. Boston. 
 Ginn & Co. 1891. 8vo, pp. 42. 
 
 396 
 
Also printed in The Boston Post. Noticed by Herbert Weir Smith in 
 The Harvard Graduates' Magazine, September, 1912, xxi. 27. 
 
 1892. William Jewett Tucker. The new movement in hu- 
 manity, from liberty to unity; an oration delivered before the 
 4> B K Fraternity of Harvard University, June 30, 1892. Bos- 
 ton, etc. Houghton, Mifflin & Co. 1892. Sm. 8vo, pp. 24. 
 
 Also printed in The Harvard Graduates' Magazine, Oct., 1892, i. 17-30. 
 
 1893. Francis Amasa Walker. College athletics. Oration 
 delivered before the Phi Beta Kappa Society, in Sanders Thea- 
 tre, Thursday, June 29, 1893. In The Boston Transcript, June 
 30, 1893; The Harvard Graduates' Magazine, Sept., 1893, ii. 
 i-i8 (also reprinted separately); and The Technology Quar- 
 terly, July, 1893, vi. 116-131. 
 
 1894. Henry Cabot Lodge. True Americanism. Oration de- 
 livered before the Phi Beta Kappa Society, in Sanders Thea- 
 tre, Thursday, June 28, 1894. In The Harvard Graduates' 
 Magazine, September, 1894, iii. 9-23. 
 
 Reprinted (A liberal pducation) in his Certain accepted heroes and other 
 essays in literature and politics, New York, etc.. Harper & Bros., 1897, pp. 
 155-185- 
 
 1895. John Fiske. The cosmic roots of love and self-sac- 
 rifice. In his Through nature to God, Boston, Houghton, Miff- 
 lin & Co., 1899, sm. 8vo, pp. 57-130. 
 
 Originally called "Ethics in the cosmic process.'' A few slight changes 
 were made in the printing. Intended as a reply to Huxley's Romances lec- 
 ture at Oxford in 1893. 
 
 1896. George Shattuck Morison. The new epoch and 
 the university: oration delivered before the Phi Beta Kappa So- 
 ciety in Sanders Theatre, Cambridge, Thursday, June 25, 1896. 
 In The Harvard Graduates' Magazine, Sept., 1896, v. 1-18. 
 
 Also reprinted. 8vo, pp. 18. Also appears as chap. vi. of his The new 
 epoch as developed by the manufacture of power, Boston, Houghton, Miff- 
 lin & Co., 1903. 
 
 Same. La nueva epoca y la universidad; discurso pronuncia- 
 do ante la Sociedad "* B K" en el teatro de Sanders, Cambridge, 
 el jueves 25 de junio de 1896. Traducido del ingles por Agustin 
 Aragon. Mexico. 1896. 8vo, pp. 24. 
 
 {To be Continued) 
 397 
 
IN MEMORIAM 
 
 Joseph Tomlixson, AI. D., ^Villiams 75, died at the Jefferson 
 Hospital, Philadelpliia, Pa., following an operation for cancerous 
 affection, on May 19, 1913, in his fifty-eighth year. He was a 
 native of New Jersey, and after his college course studied at the 
 College of Physicians and Surgeons, Xew York City, and was 
 graduated in 1878. After two years of hospital experience he 
 practiced in Plainfield, X. J., New York City, Shiloh, N. J., where 
 he succeeded to his father's practice, and, since 1893, at Bridge- 
 ton, N. J., where he had an extensive practice and enjoyed a high 
 reputation in medical circles. He was a Fellow of the American 
 Academy of Medicine and a member of local, the New Jersey 
 State, and the American A'ledical Associations. He was a mem-- 
 ber of the Bridgeton Board of Education, and in many other 
 ways showed his deep interest in public affairs. A widow and 
 two sons survive him. 
 
 William Alexander Platt, AI. A., Williams '76, died in 
 Alontclair, Denver, Colorado, Alarch 22, 1914, in his fifty-ninth 
 year. He was born at Zanesville, Ohio, but spent his boyhood 
 in Bath, N. Y., where his father was pastor of the Presbyterian 
 Church. After his college course he taught for six years and then 
 took up newspaper work on the editorial staff of the Nczi' York 
 Mail and Express. After nine years of strenuous labor failing 
 health compelled him to seek a change of climate. In 1893 he 
 removed to Colorado and for several years had charge of the 
 Colorado Springs Gazette. During the free silver controversy 
 his was the only paper in the state to advocate the gold standard. 
 Thus he rose to a leading position in the councils of his party 
 and in 1903 was given a position in the office of the Secretary 
 of State, and was later made Commissioner of Public Printing, 
 which office he held until 1908. His death occurred after a long 
 struggle with disease. A widow and two sons survive him. 
 
 John Ellsworth Goodrich, D. D., Vermont '53, died at 
 Burlington, Vt., February 23, 1915, in his eighty-fifth year. Prof. 
 Goodrich was a native of Massachusetts, but spent the greater 
 part of his active life in \^ermont. After his graduation he 
 studied Theology at Andover and was graduated in i860. He 
 was Chaplain of the ist Vermont Cavalry during the latter por- 
 tion of the Civil War. With this exception teaching was his life 
 work. In 1868 he became Superintendent of Schools in Burling- 
 ton, and two years later accepted the professorship of Rhetoric 
 and Latin in the University. After fiUing this chair for five years 
 he was professor of Greek and Latin for five years, and of Latin 
 
 39^' 
 
Volume 2 
 
 Nnmber 9 
 
 Contenta 
 
 The Alpha of Vermont 
 
 The Old Songs 
 
 Athene — A Poem 
 
 A Phi Beta Kappa Bibliography . 
 
 In Memoriam • 
 
 Phi Beta Kappa News and Notes 
 
 VERMONT NUMBER 
 OCTOBER, 1915 
 
 Page 
 
 413 
 430 
 431 
 433 
 441 
 
 450 
 
Sfl 
 
 Makers of 
 
 Approved Standard 
 PHI BETA KAPPA KEYS 
 
 FOUR SIZES 
 
 r f 
 
 • * 
 
 #eK 
 
 No. 4 
 $5.50 
 
 it 
 
 No. 3 , 
 $6.50 . 
 
 U-K GOLD — ACTUAL SIZE 
 
 No. 2 
 $7.50 
 
 Your order will have immediate attention. 
 
 Give Name, Class and Date to be 
 
 engraved on the back. 
 
 PETROIT 
 
 
 CSJga a Raig 
 
A PHI BETA KAPPA BIBLIOGRAPHY 
 
 By Prof. Clark S. Northup, Cornell, '93. 
 (Continued from Vol. 2, p. S97-) 
 
 1898. Seth Low. The trend of the century. Oration dehv- 
 ered before the Harvard Chapter of Phi Beta Kappa, in Sanders 
 Theatre, June 30, 1898. In The Harvard Graduates' Magazine, 
 Sept., 1898, vii. 1-20. 
 
 Same. Reprinted in The Atlantic Monthly, August, 1898, Ixxxii. 153-65. 
 Same. New York. Thomas Y. Crowell & Co. [Cop. 1899.] Sra. 8vo, 
 
 PP- 31- 
 
 Same. The outlook. "The trend of the century.'' [With foreword by 
 C. F. Home.] New York, [Cop. 1907.] 8vo, pp. 25. Frontisp. The mean- 
 ing of modern Hfe; issued under the auspices of the National Alumni, 
 no. I. 
 
 1899. Charles Joseph Bonaparte. Our national dangers, 
 real and unreal. Oration delivered in Sanders Theatre before 
 the Harvard Chapter of Phi Beta Kappa, Thursday, June 29, 
 1899. In The Harvard Graduates' Magazine, September, 1899, 
 viii. 1-15. 
 
 Also reprinted. 8vo, pp. 15. 
 
 1900. William Everett. Patriotism. Oration delivered in 
 Sanders Theatre, before the Harvard Chapter of Phi Beta Kappa, 
 Thursday, June 28, 1900. In The Harvard Graduates' Maga- 
 zine, September, 1900, ix. 1-19. 
 
 Same. Boston. W. B, Clarke Co. 8vo, pp. 23. 
 
 Same. Philadelphia. Peace Association of Friends. 1901. 8vo, pp. 23. 
 
 1901. Wayne MacVeagh. The value of ethical ideals in 
 American politics; an address delivered before the society of the 
 Phi Beta Kappa of Harvard University, June 27, 1901. Wash- 
 ington, D. C. Judd and Detweiler. 1901. L. 8vo, pp. 32. 
 
 Also in The Harvard Graduates' Magazine, September, 1901, x. 1-22, 
 and in The Arena, October, 1901, xxvi. 337-61. 
 
 1902. George Herbert Palmer. A study of self-sacrifice. 
 Delivered June 26, 1902. In The Harvard Graduates' Magazine, 
 Sept., 1902, xi. 12-27. 
 
 Also included in chap. vi. of his The nature of goodness, Boston, Hough- 
 ton MifHin & Co., 1904. 
 
 1903. Carroll Davidson Wright. The course and influence 
 
 433 
 
of romantic socialism. Delivered June 25, 1903. In The Har- 
 vard Graduates' Magazine, September, 1903, xii. 8-23. 
 
 1904. Samuel Walker McCall. The newspaper press. De- 
 livered June 30, 1904. In The Harz'ard Graduates' Magazine, 
 September, 1904, xiii. 22-44. 
 
 Also reprinted. 8 vo, pp. 23. 
 
 1905. James Burrill Angell. The European concert and the 
 Monroe doctrine; a discourse before the Phi Beta Kappa So- 
 ciety of Harvard University, June 28 [29], 1905. Ann Arbor. 
 1905. 8vo, pp. 16. (University Bulletin, N. S. vi. 15.) 
 
 Also in The Harvard Graduates' Magazine, September, 1905, xiv. 13-24. 
 
 1906. Edward Charles Pickering. The aims of an astrono- 
 mer. Delivered June 28, 1906. In The Harvard Graduates' 
 Magazine, September, 1906, xv. 12-21. 
 
 Also reprinted. 8vo, pp. 10. 
 
 1907. James Bryce. What is progress? Delivered June 27, 
 1907. In The Harvard Graduates' Magazine, September, 1907, 
 xvi. 1-19. 
 
 Also in The Atlantic Monthly, August, 1907, c. 145-56. 
 
 1908. Horace Howard Furness. On Shakespeare, "or. What 
 you will." Delivered June 25, 1908. In The Harvard Gradu- 
 ates' Magazine, September, 1908, xvii. 1-25. 
 
 Comment by G. Bradford, Jr., in The Nation, Oct. 15, 1908, Ixxxvii. 358. 
 
 1909. WooDROw Wilson. The spirit of learning. Delivered 
 July I. In The Harvard Graduates' Magazine, September, 1909, 
 xviii. 1-14. 
 
 Reprinted in Essays for college men. New York, Holt, 1913, 8vo, pp. 3- 
 27; and in Representative Ph. B. K. orations, Boston, 1915, pp. 466-80. 
 Also summarized in The Beta Theta Pi, November, 1909, xxxvii. 220-4. 
 
 1910. Charles Evans Hughes. Some aspects of our democ- 
 racy. Delivered June 30. In The Harvard Graduates' Magazine, 
 September, 1910, xix. i-io. 
 
 Summarized in The Tribune, July i, 1910, p. 4, and in The Evening 
 Post, June 30, 1910. 
 
 191 1. JosiAH RoYCE. James as a philosopher. Delivered June 
 29. In The Harvard Graduates' Magazine, September, 191 1, 
 XX. 1-18. 
 
 Also in his William James and other essays on the philosophy of life. 
 New York, Macmillan, 191 1, 8vo, pp. 1-45. 
 
 1912. Jean Adrien Antoine Jules Jusserand. Rocham- 
 beau in America. Delivered June 17. In The Harvard Gradu- 
 
 434 
 
ates' Magazine^ September, December, 1912, xxi. 1-17, 212-29. 
 
 Also published separately as follows : Rochambeau in America. From 
 unpublished documents. An address delivered before the society of the 
 Phi Beta Kappa of Harvard University, June 17, 1912. Washington. 1912. 
 8vo, pp. 52. 
 
 1913. Samuel jMcChord Crothers. The charm of English 
 prose in the seventeenth century. DeUvered June 16. In The 
 Harvard Graduates' Magasinc, September, 1913, xxii. 1-15. 
 
 1914. William Howard Taft. The Supreme Court of the 
 United States and popular self-government. Delivered June 15. 
 In The Harvard Graduates' Magadne, September, 1914, xxiii. 
 
 1-14. 
 
 191 5. James Ford Rhodes. Lincoln in some phases of the 
 Civil War. DeHvered June 21. In The Harvard Graduates' 
 Magazine, September, 191 5, xxiv. 1-19. 
 
 Poems. 
 
 1797. Thomas Paine (afterward Robert Treat Paine). The 
 ruling passion : an occasional poem. Written by the appointment 
 of the society of the * B K and spoken, on their anniversary, in 
 the chapel of the University, Cambridge, July 20, 1797. By 
 Thomas Paine, A. M. Published according to Act of Congress. 
 Boston. Manning and Loring. 1797. Sm. 4to, pp. 32. 
 
 1798. Charles Pinckney Sumner. 
 
 "The manuscript of Sumner's poem is preserved in the Phi Beta Kappa 
 collection in the Harvard Library, but no precise subject is indicated." W. 
 H. Tillinghast. 
 
 1799. William Biglow. Education: a poem, spoken at Cam- 
 bridge, at the request of the Phi Beta Kappa, July i8th, 1799.— 
 Train up a child in the way he should go, and when he is old 
 he will not depart from it. Solomon. — Salem. Joshua Cushing. 
 1799. 8vo, pp. 17. 
 
 Extracts were reprinted in The Key, October, 191 1, i. 5. 29-32. 
 1803. William Jenks. The social principle. 
 
 1805. Thaddeus Mason Harris. On American patronage. 
 Addressed to the $ B K Society on the anniversary meeting, Au- 
 gust 29, 1805. In The Literary Miscellany, Cambridge, 1806, 
 ii. 196-198. 
 
 1806. Benjamin Whitwell. Experience, or, Folly as it 
 
 435 
 
flies. A poem, delivered at Cambridge, on the anniversary of the 
 $ B K Society, Aug. 28, 1806. 
 
 Purus 
 
 non eget 
 
 venatis gravida sagittis 
 
 pharetra. Hor. 
 
 Boston. Anthology Office. 1806. Svo, pp. 23. 
 
 1809. Joseph Head. Enthusiasm. An occasional poem, writ- 
 ten by appointment of the society of # B K, and delivered at Cam- 
 bridge, on the anniversary of their institution, August 31, 1809. 
 
 Its track . 
 
 Glory pursues and generous shame, 
 
 The unconquerable mind, and freedom's holy flame. 
 
 Gray. 
 Boston. Anthology Press. 1809. 8vo, pp. 10. 
 
 Also in The Monthly Anthology, Sept., 1809, vii. 145-58; and in his 
 Works, Boston, 1839, ii. 339-62. 
 
 1810. Washington Allston. 
 
 "Allston's Poems appeared in 1813, but nothing in the volume distin- 
 guishes the Phi Beta Kappa poem, and the same is true of the enlarged 
 edition published in 1850." Tillinghast. 
 
 181 1. Jacob Bigelow. A poem on professional life, deliv- 
 ered by appointment of the society of Phi Beta Kappa, at their 
 anniversary, August 29, 181 1. ' Boston. J. Belcher. 181 1. Svo, 
 
 pp. IS- 
 
 1812. Edward Everett. American poets. [Boston.] 1812. 
 Svo, pp. II. 
 
 Printed by Hilliard & Metcalf for private distribution. 
 
 1813. N.-VTHANiEL Langdon Frothingham. Genius. In The 
 General Repository and Revieiv, Oct., 1813, iv. 379-87. 
 
 181 5. Samuel Oilman. Human life. In his Contributions to 
 literature, descriptive, critical, humorous, biographical, philosoph- 
 ical, and poetical, Boston, 1856, pp. 512-543. 
 
 1817. John Ware. Poem, delivered before the * B K Society 
 of Harvard University, on their anniversary, August 28, 1817. A 
 few introductory lines, and some other passages, which were 
 spoken, are omitted- in printing. Cambridge. Hilliard & Met- 
 calf. 1817. Svo, pp. II. 
 
 Also in The North American Review, November, 1817, vi. 109-115. 
 
 A criticism of contemporary fiction, 
 
 1821. William Cullen Bryant. The ages. In his Poems, 
 
 436 
 
Cambridge, Hilliard & Metcalf, 1821, pp. 7-24. Also in later 
 editions. 
 
 Reviewed in Tlie North American Review, Oct., 1821, xiii. 381-83. 
 
 1823. George Bancroft. Rome. In his Poems, Cambridge, 
 Hilliard & j\[etcalf, 1823, pp. 63-77. 
 
 In Bancroft's Poems published in 1823, the Phi Beta Kappa poem is not 
 designated; Dr. Pierce, however, noted the subject in his diary. 
 
 1824. Henry Ware, Jr. The vision of liberty; recited before 
 the Phi Beta Kappa Society of Harvard University, August 26, 
 1824. Piiblished by request. Boston. Oliver Everett. 1824. 
 8vo, pp. 12. 
 
 Reviewed in The North American Review, Oct., 1824, xix. 468-70. 
 
 1828. Frederic Henry Hedge. Modern poetry. 
 
 A manuscript copy, by Mrs. Hedge, is in the Harvard Library. 
 
 1829. Charles Sprague. Curiosity: a poem, delivered at Cam- 
 bridge before the Phi Beta Kappa Society, August 27, 1829. Bos- 
 ton. J. T. Buckingham. 1829. 8vo, pp. 30. 
 
 Second edition, July, 1834. 
 
 Also in his Writings, New York, Charles S. Francis, 1841, pp. g-35, 
 and in later editions. 
 
 Reviewed in The North American Review, April, 1841, lii. 534. 
 
 1830. Grenville Mellen. The age of print : a poem deliv- 
 ered before the Phi Beta Kappa Society, at Cambridge, 26 Au- 
 gust, 1830. Boston. Carter and Hendee. 1830. 8vo, pp. 40. 
 
 1831. Benjamin Kent. Poem delivered before the Alpha of 
 the $ B K Society, at Cambridge, September i, 1831. 
 
 Not printed. A ms., 4to, pp. 8, is in the Harvard University Library. 
 On liberality. 
 
 1833. Henry Wadsworth Longfellow. The past and the 
 present. 
 
 Subject, education. Does not appear in his published works. A revised 
 form of a poem delivered in 1832 before the Bowdoin Chapter. See S. 
 Longfellow, The life of Henry Wadsworth Longfellow, Boston, 1891, 
 i. 195. An extract (The soul) was published in The Knickerbocker Maga- 
 zine, January, 183S, v. 71. See The Key ii. 6, 293. 
 
 1834. Ralph W.vldo Emerson. 
 
 Not published. The original manuscript is in the Harvard Library. A 
 few lines at the end describing Webster are printed in his Poems, Works, 
 Riverside edition, Boston, 1884, ix. 312; Centenary edition, Boston, 1904, 
 ix. 398-9. Also reprinted by A. Copeland, in his Men and days in Phi 
 Beta Kappa, Newark, N, Y., 1907, 8vo, p. 56. Cf. J. E. Cabot, Memoir, i. 
 228; Dartmouth Poems, 1834. 
 
 437 
 
Somewhat less than half of the poem is printed in The Key, Jan., 1913, 
 i. 10. 25-8. 
 
 1835. Ephraim Peabody. New England emigration westward. 
 Delivered before the Phi Beta Kappa Society, Cambridge, Mass., 
 September 27, 1835. In The Western Messenger, December, 
 1835, i. 409-422. 
 
 1836. Oliver Wendell Holmes. Poetry: a metrical essay. 
 In his Poems, Boston, 1836, pp. 3-39. 
 
 Reviewed by Horatio Hale in Harvardiana iii. 147-50. See Ives's Bibliog- 
 raphy, p. 61. 
 
 1837. William Parsons Lunt. Psyche. In The United 
 States Magazine and Democratic Review, April, 1838, ii. 17-31. 
 
 1839. James Flint. Change: a poem delivered before the Phi 
 Beta Kappa Society of Harvard University, August 29, 1839. 
 Printed, not published. Salem. The Observer Press. 1848. 8vo, 
 pp. 24. 
 
 1840. Francis Calley Gray. Poem spoken at Cambridge, 
 before the Phi Beta Kappa Society of Harvard University, Au- 
 gust 27, 1840. Boston. Charles C. Little and James Brown. 
 1840. 8vo, pp. 36. 
 
 "Is there no Music in this Western world? 
 No brow round which the Poet's wreath is curled? 
 
 Is all here dark and grovelling?" 
 
 A forecast of the future of poetry in America. 
 
 Reviewed in The North American Review, January, 1841, Iii. 262-5. 
 
 1843. At the annual dinner Oliver Wendell Holmes read An 
 after-dinner poem. Printed (as Terpsichore) in Graham's Mag- 
 azine, January, 1844, xxiv. lo-ii, and in his Poems, London, 
 1846. In the Household edition of his Poems, 1877, entitled An 
 after-dinner poem. See Ives's Bibliography, p. jy. 
 
 1844. William Wetmore Story. Nature and art: a poem de- 
 livered before the Phi Beta Kappa Society of Harvard Univer- 
 sity; August 29, 1844. Boston. Charles C. Little and James 
 Brown. 1844. 8vo, pp. 48. 
 
 At the annual dinner Oliver Wendell Holmes read his Lines recited 
 at the Phi Beta Kappa dinner. Printed in his Poems, London, 1846, In 
 his Poems, 1849, entitled Verses for after-dinner. See Ives's Bibliog- 
 raphy, pp. 42-3. 
 
 438 
 
i845- Charles Timothy Brooks. A poem pronounced before 
 the Phi Beta Kappa Society, at Cambridge, August 28, 1845. 
 Boston. Charles C. Little and James Brown. 1845. 8vo, pp. 36. 
 
 Chiefly on the immortality of poetry and the poetic impulse. 
 
 1846. James Freeman Clarke. A poem, delivered before the 
 Phi Beta Kappa Society, Alpha of Massachusetts, on its anniver- 
 sary, August 27, 1846. Boston. Wm. Crosby and H. P. Nich- 
 olls. 1846. 8vo, pp. 24. 
 
 "Our Country and its Hopes, the theme I choose." 
 
 1849. John Brooks Felton. The horse-shoe: a poem spoken 
 before the Phi Beta Kappa Society in Cambridge, July 19, 1849. 
 Cambridge. John Bartlett. 1849. 8vo, pp. 29. 
 
 Reviewed in The North American Review, October, 1849, Ixix. 528-30. 
 
 1850. Bayard Taylor. The American legend. A poem before 
 the Phi Beta Kappa Society of Harvard University, July 18, 1850. 
 Pubhshed by request. Cambridge. John Bartlett. 1850. i2mo, 
 pp. 27. 
 
 Not included in Taylor's collected works. See his Life and letters, i. 
 173- 
 
 1855. William Henry Hurlbut. Wealth and beauty. A 
 poem read before the Phi Beta Kappa Society in Cambridge, July 
 19, 1855. Cambridge. John Bartlett. 1855. i2mo, pp. 31. 
 
 Reviewed in The North American Review, October, 1855, Ixxxi. 546-9. 
 
 1861. Elbridge Jefferson Cutler. Reveille. A poem read 
 before the Phi Beta Kappa Society at Cambridge, July 18, 1861. 
 In his War poems, Boston, Little, Brown and Company, 1867, 
 pp. 9-17. 
 
 Same. Liberty and law. A poem for the hour. Army Series. No. 
 4. [Boston.] American Unitarian Association. 1861. 8vo, pp. 11. 
 
 Noticed by Edward Everett Hale in The Christian Examiner, Septem- 
 ber, 1861. See also the Memoir of Mr. Cutler. 
 
 A ms. note in the copy of War poems in the Harvard University Library 
 says : "Reveille was reprinted in the South during the war, with such 
 changes as made it serve the Confederate cause. It was afterward re- 
 printed in England as evidence of the spirit which animated the Con- 
 federacy." 
 
 1862. Samuel Francis Smith. 
 
 The original manuscript is in the Harvard Library. 
 1865. George Henry Boker. Our heroic themes. A poem 
 read before the Phi Beta Kappa Society of Harvard University, 
 July 20, 1865. Boston. Ticknor and Fields. 1865. i2mo, pp. 20. 
 
 439 
 
1867. At the annual dinner Oliver Wendell Holmes read his 
 Chanson without music, by the Professor Emeritus of Dead and 
 Live Languages. Printed in The Atlantic Monthly, November, 
 1867, XX. 543-544. Reprinted in Songs of many seasons, 1875. 
 
 1868. William Everett. Hesione: or Europe unchained. A 
 poem delivered before the $ B K Fraternity of Harvard College, 
 July 16, 1868. Boston. Little, Brown and Co. 1868. 8vo, large 
 paper, pp. 28. 
 
 1870. William Reed Huntington. The child's supremacy: 
 a dream. In his Quinquaginta, privately printed, 1888. 
 
 Also in his Sonnets and a dream, Jamaica, N. J., The Marion Press, 
 1899, pp. 47-60. 
 
 1871. Francis Bret Harte. Aspiring Miss DeLaine. (A 
 chemical narrative.) In his Poetical works. Household edition, 
 Boston, Houghton, MifBin and Co., [1882], pp. 212-218. 
 
 1873. At the annual dinner on June 26 Oliver Wendell Holmes 
 read A poem served to order. Printed in The Atlantic Monthly, 
 .'September, 1873, xxxii. 296-297. Reprinted in Songs of many 
 .seasons, 1875. 
 
 1874. Christopher Pearse Cranch. The century and the 
 nation. Read before the Phi Beta Kappa Society of Harvard Col- 
 lege, June 25, 1874. In his The bird and the bell, and other 
 poems, Boston, Jas. R. Osgood & Co., 1875, pp. 251-269. 
 
 1875. Walter Mitchell. The mocking-bird. Delivered July 
 I, 1875. In Scribner's Monthly, December, 1875, xi. 171-176. 
 
 A part of Edward Everett Hale's poem at the dinner was published 
 as follows : Alma Mater's roll. A part of an historical speech at the 
 Phi Beta Kappa dinner at Cambridge, July i, 1875. In Scribner's Monthly, 
 September, 1875, x. 623. 
 
 1877. Edmund Clarence Stedman. Hawthorne. Read June 
 28. In his Hawthorne and other poems, Boston, James R. Os- 
 good and Co., 1877, 8vo, pp. 9-25. 
 
 Also in later editions of his poems. 
 
 See Stedman and Gould's Life, ii. 287, 293-94- 
 
 1878. Richard Henry Stoddard. History. In his Poems, 
 New York, Charles Scribner's Sons, 1880, 8vo, pp. 437-44. 
 
 {To be continued.) 
 
 440 
 
Volume 2 
 
 Number 10 
 
 Contenta 
 
 Some Pamphlets and What They Reveal 
 The Vassar-Lafayette Inaugurations 
 James Monroe Taylor 
 Brotherhood — A Poem 
 Elgin Ralston Lovell Gould 
 A Phi Beta Kappa Bibliography . 
 In Memoriam .... 
 Phi Beta Kappa News and Notes . 
 
 Page 
 
 461 
 
 467 
 
 469 
 
 471 
 
 475 
 
 480 
 
 488 
 
 494 
 
 JANUARY, 1916 
 
Makers of 
 
 Approved Standard 
 PHI BETA KAPPA KEYS 
 
 FOUR SIZES 
 
 No. 2 
 $7.50 
 
 U-K GOLD — ACTUAL SIZE 
 
 Your order will have immediate attention. 
 
 Give Name, Class and Date to be 
 
 engraved on the back. 
 
 
distinguished success in cleansing New York politics of narrow 
 partisanism and venality. 
 
 As Chamberlain, Dr. Gould was a commanding figure, — coun- 
 selor of the mayor on fiscal matters, leader in constructive plan- 
 ning and expert administrator of his own office. The defeat of 
 Alayor Low in 1903 was a mighty set back to civic progress in 
 New York, and in no respect more lamentable than because it took 
 from the service of the city a high-minded, skilled and exceptional 
 public servant in the person of Dr. Gould. 
 
 In the intervening years between his withdrawal from office and 
 his death, Dr. Gould organized a bank, participated in the con- 
 tinuing work of the Citizens' Union, and kept always in effective- 
 ness the company which he had built up for bettering housing 
 conditions. It was in this period that I came to know him and to 
 experience his friendly counsel and support at crucial times in my 
 own public work. 
 
 His death was in every sense untimely. It came when America 
 was more fully realizing the need of the services of men of Dr. 
 Gould's quality in its public affairs. 
 
 The Universities of America are being increasingly requisi- 
 tioned for public service. The great state institutions that have 
 grown so rapidly in recent years, supported as they are by public 
 taxes and guided by public opinion, are making higher education 
 more democratic than it was a generation ago, and hence less a 
 barrier to pubHc service. 
 
 Six years after Dr. Gould retired from the chamberlainship, 
 Mayor Gaynor took great pride in announcing that he had ap- 
 pointed a number of college men to important public positions. 
 Now it is so commonplace that no comment is made on it. We 
 have gone further in that we are now expecting our colleges and 
 universities specifically to train for public service. And so we 
 look back to Dr. Gould as a pioneer by whose example and life 
 we gain a prophetic insight into the future of American city 
 government. 
 
 To those younger Americans who look with confident hope to 
 a future civic democracy, skilled, effective, of sane but courageous 
 ideals, the life and public services of E. R. L. Gould stand forth 
 as an inspiration for future achievements. Living we loved and 
 honored him. Dead we reverve and shall emulate him. 
 
 479 
 
MEMORIAL RESOLUTIONS. 
 
 The Phi Beta Kappa Alumni in New York desire to place on record 
 their deep sense of the loss sustained by the City and by themselves in 
 the death in August last of Dr. Elgin Ralston Lovell Gould, for many 
 years an honored member of their Association and of late its President 
 and member of its Council. His was a life of true social service. 
 
 "Laboriously tracing what must be, 
 .Ind what may yet be better — " 
 
 he worked unceasingly in many fields with breadth of vision and with 
 scientifically trained intelligence for the permanent good of the com- 
 munity. 
 
 In grateful memory of so noble a life, in profound sorrow that he was 
 tiaken in the fullness of his powers, the Alumni attest anew their faith 
 in the ideals for which Phi Beta Kappa stands, and honor the man whose 
 many-sided civic usefulness has enlarged and quickened their under- 
 standing of the ways in which those ideals may be realized. 
 
 A PHI BETA KAPPA BIBLIOGRAPHY 
 
 By Prof. Clark S. Northup, Cornell '93. 
 
 (Continued from Vol. 2, p. 440.) 
 
 1880. Edgar Fawcett. The republic. Read before the Phi 
 Beta Kappa Society of Harvard College, June [sic], 1880. In 
 his Song and story, later poems, Boston, James R. Osgood 
 and Co., 1884, 8vo, pp. 51-65. 
 
 , Also in The Harvard Register, August, 1880, ii. 157-159. 
 
 , 1881. Charles Godfrey Leland. 
 
 The poem was never published. See Mrs. Elizabeth Robins Pennell's 
 biography of Leland, Boston, 1906, ii. 115-118, where is printed a letter 
 from Dr. Holmes on the poem and the reception given it. 
 ' At the annual dinner Oliver Wendell Holmes read his Post-prandial. 
 Printed in The Atlantic Monthly, September, 1881, xlviii. 365, and in his 
 Poems, Riverside edition, 1891. 
 
 1883. Robert Grant. Yankee Doodle. A poem delivered be- 
 fore the Phi Beta Kappa Society of Harvard University, June 28, 
 1883. Boston. Cupples, Upham and Co. 1883. i6mo, pp. 31. 
 
 1885. John White Chadvi^ick. A legend of good poets. A 
 poem delivered June 25th, 1885, to the Phi Beta Kappa Frater- 
 inity of Harvard University. Boston. Geo. H. Ellis. 1885. 8vo, 
 pp. 20. 
 
 480 
 
At the annual dinner Oliver Wendell Holmes read his poem To the. 
 poets who only read and listen. Printed in Ttu Atlantic Monthly, Au- 
 gust, i88s, Ivi. 264-265. 
 
 1890. Richard Watson Gilder. Ode: read before the society 
 of the Phi Beta Kappa, Harvard University, June 26th, 1890. 
 [Cambridge. 1890.] 8vo, pp. [8]. 
 
 Printed on only one side of the leaf. Subject, an address to "the spirit 
 of beauty." 
 
 Also in The Critic, June 28, 1890, xiii, 323. Also in his Two worlds 
 and other poems. New York, The Century Co., 1891, pp. 105-112, and in 
 his Five hooks of song. New York, The Century Co., 1894, pp. 183-187. 
 
 1891. Henry Grafton Chapman. Poem delivered before the 
 Phi Beta Kappa Society of Harvard University, June 25, 1891. 
 {1891.] L. 8vo, pp. 12. 
 
 Also in The Boston Advertiser, June 26, 1891. 
 
 1892. Ernest Francisco Fenollosa. East and West. A poem 
 delivered before the Phi Beta Kappa Society at Harvard Univer- 
 sity, June 30, 1892. In his Eas.t and West, The discovery of 
 America and other poems, Newr York, Thomas Y. Crowell and 
 Co., 1893, pp. 1-47. 
 
 1893. Maurice Thompson. Lincoln's grave. Delivered. June 
 
 -29, 1893. Cambridge, etc. Stone and Kimball. 1894. i6mo, pp 
 
 [49]. 
 
 A part was also printed in The Harvard Graduates' Magazine, Sep- 
 tember, 1893, ii. 45-47. 
 
 1894. Theodore Chickering Williams. The making of man ; 
 poem delivered before the Phi Beta Kappa Society at Harvard 
 University, June 28th, 1894. Oxford. B. H. Blackwell. 1894. 
 Sm. 8vo, pp. 15. 
 
 1895. At the annual dinner William Everett read a poem on 
 Holmes, Winthrop, Hoar. Printed in The Harvard Graduates' 
 Magazine, September, 1895, iv. 17-18. 
 
 1897. Edward Waldo Emerson. The winning game ; a poem 
 recited before the Phi Beta Kappa Society of Harvard Univer- 
 sity, in the Memorial Hall, July ist, 1897. Cambridge. Riverside 
 Press. 1897, Sm. 8vo, pp. 14. 
 
 1898. Edward Sandford Martin. The kingdom, the power, 
 and the glory. Read before the Harvard Phi Beta Kappa at Cam- 
 bridge, June 30, 1898. In his Poems and verses, New York, etc.. 
 Harper & Brothers, 1902, pp. 66-75. 
 
 481 
 
, Also in The Harvard Graduates' Magazine, September, 1898, vii. 26-29, 
 and in Harper's Weekly, July 12, 1898, xlii, 635. 
 
 1899. Owen Wister. My country : 1899, written for the $ B K 
 Society, Harvard, June, 1899. In Harper's Weekly, July i, 1899, 
 xliii. 640-41. 
 
 1900. Clinton Scollard. Lawton ; an ode. [Read before the 
 Phi Beta Kappa Society of Harvard College, June 28, 1900. Clin- 
 ton, N. Y. The Osborn Press. 1900.] 8vo, pp. [ii], 17. 
 
 Printed on only one side of the leaf. 
 
 1901. George Santayana. Spain in America. In his A hermit 
 of Carmel and other poems, New York, Charles Scribner's Sons, 
 
 1901, 8vo, pp. 216-31. 
 
 1902. Nathaniel Southgate Shaler. Valor; * B K poem, 
 June 26, 1902. In The Harvard Graduates' Magazine, September, 
 
 1902, xi. 5-12. 
 
 Also reprinted. 8vo, pp. 8. 
 
 See his Autobiography, Boston, 1909, p. 443. 
 
 1903. LeBaron Russell Briggs. Mater fortissima. Deliv- 
 ered June 25, 1903. In The Harvard Graduates' Magazine, Sep- 
 tember, 1903, xii. 1-5. 
 
 Also in his Routine and ideals, Boston, etc., Houghton, Mifflin and Co., 
 1904, pp. 223-232. 
 
 1904. Thomas Wentworth Higginson. Now and then. De- 
 livered June 30, 1904. In The Harvard Graduates' Magazine, 
 September, 1904, xiii. 45-47. 
 
 1906. George Cabot Lodge. The soul's inheritance. In Scrib- 
 ner's Magazine, September, 1906, xl. 362-65. 
 
 Also in his The soul's inheritance and other poems, Boston, Houghton, 
 Mifflin & Co., 1909, 8vo, pp. i-ii. 
 
 1907. John Tyler Wheelwright. The field of stars. Phi 
 Beta Kappa poem (Jamestown Exposition year), 1907. In The 
 Harvard Graduates' Magazine, December, 1908, xvii. 370-371. 
 
 1908. Percy Mackaye. An ode to the universities. Delivered 
 June, 1908. In The Evening Post, New York, June 25, 1908. 
 
 Also in The Harvard Graduates' Magazine, September, 1908, xvii. 213- 
 218. Also (Ode to the American universities) in his Poems, New York, 
 Macmillan, 1909, pp. 24-37. 
 
 1909. Barrett Wendell. De praeside magnifico. Deliv- 
 ered July I. In The Harvard Graduates' Magazine, September, 
 1909, xviii. 15-18. 
 
 482 
 
Also in The mystery of education and other academic performances, 
 New York, Scribner, 1909, pp. 255-64. 
 
 [910. Henry Van Dyke. Who follow the flag. New York. 
 Charles Scribner's Sons. 191 1. 8vo, pp. 14. 
 
 1912. John Jay Chapman. Phi Beta Kappa poem. Read June 
 17. In The Harvard Graduates' Magazine, September, 1912, xxi 
 18-21. 
 
 1913. George Edward Woodberry. In memoriam: Charles 
 Eliot Norton. Read June 16. In The Harvard Graduates' Maga- 
 zine, September, 1913, xxii. 35-8. 
 
 Reprinted in his The flight and other poems, New York, Macmillan, 
 1914, 8vo, pp. 151-7. 
 Comment in The Dial, July i, 1913, Iv. 42. 
 
 1914. [William] Bliss Carman. Phi Beta Kappa poem. 
 
 Read June 15. In The Forum, November, 1914, Hi. 677-83. 
 
 Reprinted in W. S. Braithwaite, Anthology of magazine verse for 
 1914, Cambridge, Mass., 1914, 8vo, pp. 3-9. 
 
 191 5. Alfred Noyes. The Phi Beta Kappa poem. Read June 
 21. In The Harvard Graduates' Magazine, September, 1915, xxiv. 
 40-46. 
 
 General. 
 
 Timothy Alden, Jr. List of orations and poems before the 
 Phi Beta Kappa. In his Catalogue of the library of the Massachu- 
 setts Historical Society, Boston, John Eliot, Jr., 181 1. 
 
 See Proceedings of the Mass. Hist. Soc, Boston, 1879, i. 221-2. 
 
 Thomas Gushing. Undergraduate life sixty years ago. In 
 The Harvard Graduates' Magazine, July, 1893, i. 547-60. 
 
 On Phi Beta Kappa, p. 557. 
 
 Ralph Waldo Emerson. In his Journal, Boston, Houghton, 
 Mifflin Co., 1912, 8vo, ii. 404, iii, 333, iv. 341, v. 30, vi. 230, vii. 
 228. 
 
 Edward Everett Hale. The founder of Harvard's Phi Beta 
 Kappa. In The Harvard Graduates' Magazine, September, 1906, 
 XV. 200-1. 
 
 Albert Bushnell Hart. The $ B K Society and the Boston 
 police force. In The Harvard Register, March, 1880, i. 67-8. 
 
 The Harvard Crimson. The Alpha of Massachusetts. Re- 
 printed in The Key, March, 191 1, i. 3. 28-30. 
 
 The Harvard Graduates' Magazine, beginning with Septem- 
 ber, 1893, has regularly printed reports of the meetings of Phi Beta 
 
 483 
 
Kappa. See ii. 88, iii. 52-3, iv. 629, v. 53-4, vi. 107, 559, vii. 
 1 13-4, viii. 104-5, i-^- Qij X- 95. ^i- 102-3, xii. 77-8, 440, xiii. 96-7,. 
 xiv. 81-2, XV. 77-8, 445, xvi. 207-8, xvii. 87-8, xviii. 90-1, xix. 
 79-80, 468-9, XX. 95-7, xxi. 489, xxii. 94-5, 466, xxiii. loo-i. 
 
 William Coolidge Lane. Anniversary of the Alpha of Mas- 
 sachusetts. In The Key^ October, 1912, i. 9. 24-7. Activities of 
 the Harvard Chapter. In The Key, May, 1915, ii. 8. 373-& 
 Illus. 
 
 See also Ph. B. K. Publ., N. S. 3, p. [4I • 
 
 Laurence Bradford Packard. Phi Beta Kappa at Harvard. 
 In The Key, January, 191 3, i. 10. 5-25. lUustrated. 
 
 John Pierce. Some notes on the anniversary meetings of the 
 Phi Beta Kappa Society, Alpha of Massachusetts, 1803-1848. In 
 Proceedings of the Massachusetts Historical Society 1892-4 
 [June, 1894], 2d series, ix. 110-43. 
 
 Reprinted by Mr. Lane in his Catalogue of 1912, pp. 145-169. 
 
 Josiah Quincy. In his The history of Harvard University^ 
 Cambridge, John Owen, 1840, 8vo, ii. 397-9. 2d ed. Boston. 
 Crosby, Nichols, Lee & Co. i860. 
 
 Records, documents and memoranda. In the Catalogue of 1012,. 
 ed, by William Coolidge Lane, pp. 85-180. 
 
 Report on the choice of undergraduate members of the $ B K 
 Society. In The Harvard Graduates' Magazine, December, 1906,. 
 XV. 216-21, 349. 
 
 William Hopkins Tillinghast. The orators and poets of 
 Phi Beta Kappa, Alpha of Massachusetts, with a bibliographical 
 description of those orations and poems which are in Harvard 
 College Library. In The Harvard Library Bulletin, May, 1891,. 
 vi. 265-70. 
 
 Reprinted in revised form in the Catalogue of the Harvard Chapter.. 
 19 12, pp. 62-78. 
 
 The William and Mary College Quarterly, January, iBg'>i, 
 vi. 199. 
 
 On the return of the Harvard charter to Cambridge. 
 
 HAVERFORD COLLEGE. 
 Zeta of Pennsylvania. Organized January 20, 1899. 
 Catalogues. 
 1904, November. i6mo, pp. 15. 1909, January. i6mo, pp. 16- 
 
 484 
 
Orations and Addresses. 
 
 1904. George Herbert Palmer. George Herbert as a religious 
 poet. Appears substantially in his edition of Herbert, Boston, 
 Houghton, Mifflin & Co., 1905, i. 85-120. 
 
 General. 
 Wilfred P. Mustard. See Ph. B. K. Publ, N. S. 3, p. [16]. 
 
 HOBART COLLEGE. 
 
 Zeta of New York. Organized July 6, 187 1. 
 
 Catalogues. 
 
 1894, April. 8vo, pp. 24. Supplement, June 27, 1894, i p. 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 
 1880. Francis Philip Nash. The mission of American col- 
 leges and the relations of the Phi Beta Kappa Society to that sub- 
 ject. An address delivered before the Phi Beta Kappa Society in, 
 Hobart College, Geneva, N. Y., June 22, 1880. Geneva, N. Y. 
 College Press Print. 1880. 8vo, pp. 22. 
 
 1883. George William Douglas. The function of a church col- 
 lege in the sphere of modern culture. Delivered June 26. Cam- 
 bridge, Mass. 1883. 4to, pp. 24. 
 
 1885. Charles Andrews. An address commemorative of the 
 Hfe of the late Hon. Charles J. Folger, LL.D. Delivered by Hon. 
 Charles Andrews, Associate Judge of the Court of Appeals, at 
 Geneva, N. Y., before the Hobart College Chapter of the Phi Beta 
 Kappa Society, June 23, 1885. Geneva : W. F. Humphrey, Print- 
 er. [1885.] 8vo, pp. 23. 
 
 1886. Delano Chipman Calvin. An address in memory of 
 the Hon. Horatio Seymour, LL.D., delivered by Hon. Delano 
 C. Calvin, LL.D., at Geneva, N. Y., before the Associate Alumni- 
 of Hobart College and the Phi Beta Kappa Society, June 23, 1886. 
 Geneva: W. F. Humphrey, Printer. 1886. 8vo, pp. 31. 
 
 1888. William Clark. The formation of opinion. An ad-' 
 dress delivered before the Phi Beta Kappa Society at Hobart Col- 
 
 48s 
 
lege, June 28, 1888, by the Rev. Prof. Wm. Clark, M. A., LL.D. 
 Published by request of the Phi Beta Kappa Society of the Cor- 
 poration of the College. [Cambridge, Mass. William H. Wheel- 
 er, Printer. 1888.] 4to, pp. 20. 
 
 1898. Edward Patterson. A successful life. Address in 
 memory of Clarence Armstrong Seward, Delivered before the 
 Phi Beta Kappa Society at Hobart College, Geneva, N. Y., June 
 22, 1898, by Hon. Edward Patterson, LL.D., one of the Justices 
 of the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York. 
 Geneva: Press of W. F. Humphrey. 1898. 8vo, pp. [ii], 38. 
 
 1900. John Jay Chapman. The unity of human nature. An 
 address delivered before the Phi Beta Kappa Society at Hobart 
 College. Delivered June 20. In The International Journal of 
 Ethics, January, 1901, xi. 158-67. 
 
 Also reprinted, 5vo, pp. 10. Also in his Learning and other essays, New 
 York, Moffat, Yard & Co., 1910, 8vo, pp. 173-90; in Representative Ph. B. K. 
 orations, Boston, 1915, 8vo, pp. 254-62; and in Richard Rice, Jr., College 
 and the future : essays for the undergraduate on problems of character 
 and intellect. New York, Charles Scribner's Sons, 1915, 8vo, pp. 359-70. 
 
 1902. Frank Warren Hackett. The attitude of the scholar 
 
 towards men in public life. An address delivered June 18, 1902, 
 
 before the Phi Beta Kappa Society of Hobart College. Geneva, 
 
 New York. Press of W. F. Humphrey. 1902. 8vo, pp. 26. 
 
 1905. Edward Everett Hale, Jr. Modern standards of crit- 
 icism. Delivered June 21. In Hobart College Bulletins, July, 
 1905, iii. 4. 5-22. 
 
 1906. Oscar McMurtrie Voorhees. Our Phi Beta Kappa 
 father and their fraternity. See William and Mary, General. 
 
 1906. Frank Engs Blackwell. The theatre. Delivered 
 June 20. In Hobart College Bulletins, July, 1906, iv. 4. 5-18. 
 
 1908. Arthur Gordon Webster. The creed of a scientist. 
 Delivered June 17. In Hobart College Bulletins, July, 1908, vi. 
 4- 7-31- 
 
 1909. Dickinson Sergeant Miller. The practical man. De- 
 livered June 16. In Hobart College Bulletins, October, 1909, 
 viii. I. 6-26. 
 
 1910. Henry Rutgers Marshall. Sub-consciousness. De- 
 livered June 16. In Hobart College Bulletins, July, 1910, viii. 
 4. 8-24. 
 
 486 
 
ipii. Charles Downer Hazen. The college and the citizen. 
 Delivered June 15. In Hobart College Bulletins, July, 191 1, ix. 
 4. 8-28. 
 
 1912. Frederick Winslow Taylor. Principles of scientific 
 management. Delivered June 20. In Hobart College Bulletins, 
 July, 1912, X. 4. 7-46. 
 
 1913. Joseph Alexander Leighton. A defence of reason 
 and a plea for the theoretic life. Delivered June 19. In Ho- 
 bart College Bulletins, July, 191 3, xi. 4. 8-27. 
 
 1914. George McAneny. Phi Beta Kappa oration. Deliv- 
 ered June 18. In Hobart College Bulletins, July, 19 14, xii. 
 4. 6-17. 
 
 On opportunities for the college man in the public service. 
 
 1915. Joseph French Johnson. College products and by- 
 products. Delivered June 17. In Hobart College Bulletins, July, 
 1915, xiii. 4. 8-15. 
 
 General. 
 
 Clark Sutherland North up. The Hobart installation. In 
 The Key, January, 1914, ii. 2. 84-9. 
 
 Milton Haight Turk. See Ph. B. K. Publ, N. S., 3, p. [10]. 
 See also The Key, January, 1913, i. 10. 43, October, 1914, ii. 5. 
 258-9. 
 
 THE UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS. 
 
 Gamma of Illinois. Organized November ii, 1907. 
 
 Catalogues. 
 
 1908. Sq. i6mo, pp. 15. 
 
 General. 
 
 Frances Simpson. See Ph. B. K. Publ, N. S. 8, pp. 17-18. 
 (To be continued.) 
 
 487 
 
IN MEMORIAM 
 
 ^^'ILLIAM Stokes Wvjian, LL. D., Alabama "51, died at his 
 home, Tuscaloosa, Alabama, October 20, 19 15, having nearly com- 
 pleted his eighty-fifth year. Of Xew England ancestry, he was 
 born at iMontgomery, Ala., studied one year at Harvard, anrl 
 received his A. B. at the University of Alabama in 1851. After 
 a brief experience as a teacher at Carrollton, he was called to teach 
 Latin and Greek in his alma mater, and from 1855 to 1901 was 
 professor of Latin. On six occasions he declined the presidency 
 of the university. He served as president pro tcni. four times, 
 and was president one year, 1901-2, when he retired from active 
 service. As a teacher he attained marked distinction and was 
 highly esteemed by all his colleagues. He served in the General 
 Assembly of Alabama, 1870-72, and continued to manifest a 
 marked interest in public affairs. He was a profound student of 
 the historic sources of the southwestern and gulf states, was an 
 author, and contributor to several magazines. A few poems and 
 translations of the Odes of Horace are of marked power. 
 
 When the movement for the reorganization of the Alpha of 
 Alabama was fostered he was one of the three surviving members 
 who met to carry the plan through. The meeting was held at his 
 home August 18, 1912, and he acted as secretary. By the aid of 
 his private records and his clear and accurate memory it was 
 possible to secure a fairly complete list of the members of the 
 chapter during its activity from 1851 to 1861, for he was associated 
 with it practically all the time. See The Key, Vol. i, No. 8, pp. 
 21-23. 
 
 The LL. D. degree was conferred on him in 1882 by his alma 
 mater. 
 
 William Henry Bowen, D. D., Brown 57, died in Providence,. 
 R. L, February 13, 1915, having nearly completed his eightieth 
 year. After a brief experience abroad and at teaching he studied 
 for a year in Andover, and in 1859 was ordained to the ministry. 
 He served several Free Baptist Churches in Maine and Massa- 
 chusetts, and in 1888 removed to Providence where he made his 
 home. He occupied a number of influential positions including the 
 presidency of the Board of Overseers of Bates College. The 
 degree of Doctor of Divinity was conferred by Hillsdale College,. 
 Michigan, in 1874, and by Bates in 1907. Two sons and a daugh- 
 ter survive. 
 
 Elijah Washburn Coy, Ph. D., Brown "58, died in Cincinnati,. 
 Ohio, March 29, 1915, aged eighty-two. He entered Brown from 
 Hebron, Me., and won Phi Beta Kappa at the conclusion of his 
 junior year. For nine years he was principal of the Peoria, 
 Illinois, High School. In the meantime he s}:udied law and was- 
 
 488 
 
Volume 2 
 
 Nnmber 11 
 
 Contents 
 
 Page 
 
 Western Reserve University . . . 505 
 
 The Alpha of Ohio .... 515 
 
 The Golden Key — A Poem . . 517 
 
 The By-Products of the Modern College . 518 
 
 The Meeting of the Phi Beta Kappa Senate . 526 
 
 A Phi Beta Kappa Bibliography . . 529 
 
 In Memoriam ..... 537 
 
 Phi Beta Kappa News and Notes . 543 
 
 WESTERN RESERVE NUMBER 
 MARCH, 1916 
 
Makers of 
 
 Approved Standard 
 PHI BETA KAPPA KEYS 
 
 FOUR SIZES 
 
 ft 
 
 No. 
 $5 
 
 ' — &-= * 
 .'so la 
 
 * 
 
 No. 3 3 
 
 $6.50 U: 
 
 « 
 ** 
 
 No. 2 
 $7.50 
 
 14-K GOLD — ACTUAL SIZE 
 
 Your order will have immediate attention. 
 Give Name, Class and Date to be 
 ' engraved on the back. 
 
 ^■5 5 gg5 
 
A PHI BETA KAPPA BIBLIOGRAPHY, 
 
 By Professor Clark S. Northup, Corxf.ll '93. 
 (Continued from Vol. 2, p. 4SJ.) 
 
 INDIANA UNIVERSITY, 
 
 Gamma of Indiana. Organized January 20, 191 1. 
 
 Catalogues. 
 
 A list of the charter and foundation members is given in The 
 Key, March, 191 1, i. 3. 15-16. 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 
 1911. Andrew Cunningham McLaughlin. PoHtical parties 
 and popular government. Delivered June 20. Published by the 
 Chapter. X. p. N. d. 8vo, pp. 22. 
 
 1913. Wilfred Pirt Mustard. The pastoral, ancient and 
 modern. Delivered in June. In The Classical Jl'cckly, March 27, 
 1915, viii. 161-7. 
 
 General. 
 
 \\'arner Fite. The Gamma of Indiana. In The Key, March, 
 191 1, i. 3. 14-22. Illus. 
 See also Ph. B. K. Publ, N. S. 9, p. 10. 
 
 THE STATE UNIVERSITY OF IOWA. 
 
 Alpha of Iowa. Organized September 30, 1895. 
 
 General. 
 
 Laen.as G. Weld. See Ph. B. K. Publ., N. S. 3, pp. [13-14]. 
 
 JOHNS HOPKINS UNIVERSITY 
 
 Alpha of Maryland. Organized October id, 1895. 
 
 Catalogues. 
 
 1904. 8vo, pp. 56. From this the revised constitution was re- 
 printed in 1906, pp. 4. 
 
 'The original manuscript of the bibliography from Indiana to Pomona 
 inclusive was lost in the mails. In preparing a duplicate of this part, it is 
 possible that the compiler has omitted some items. He will be grateful 
 for notices of any errors or omissions. 
 
 529 
 
OraTIOXS and ADDRliSSI-IS. 
 
 1909. Barrett ^^'I•:^•DELL. The mysiery of education. Delivered 
 April 24. In The in\slci-v of education and other academic per- 
 formances, New York, Scribner, 1910, 8vo, pp. 7-78. 
 
 Reprinted in Representative Phi Beta Kappa orations, Boston, Hough- 
 ton Alifflin Co., 191S, 8vo, pp. 442-65. Comment in The Dial, July 16, 1910, 
 xlix. 27-^9. 
 
 191 4. Henry Holt. On the cosmic relation.s. Substantially 
 included in his On the cosmic relations, Boston, Floughton Mifflin 
 Co., 1914, 8vo, 2 vols. 
 
 General. 
 
 A circular letter wa.s published in 1896 giving "facts relative to 
 the history of the fraternity and the chapter." i sheet. 
 
 Edward C. Armstrong. See Ph. B. K. Piibl., X. S. 3, p. [14]. 
 J. Elliott Gilpin. See Ph. B. K. bulletin of information, 
 
 1903- P- [3]- 
 
 THE UNIVERSITY OF KANSAS. 
 
 Alpha of K.\nsas. Organized April 2, 1890. 
 
 Catalogues. 
 
 [1896.] 8vo, pp. [8]. 1903. 8vo, pp. 41. 
 
 Or.\tions and Addresses. 
 
 1896. Frank Heywood Hodder. The duty of the scholar in 
 the writer's responsibility. In The Kansas University Quarterly, 
 July, [896, V. 55-78. 
 
 Same. Lawrence, Kan. 1896. Svo, pp. 24. 
 
 1898. Arthur Graves Canfield. The tone of literature and 
 the writer's responsibility. In The Kansas Universit\ Quarterly, 
 July, 1898, vii. 3. 39-55. 
 
 1903. Kate Stephens. The University of Hesperus. Deliver- 
 ed in June. In her .--hnerican thumb-prints : mettle of our men and 
 women, Philadelphia, J. E. Lippincott Co., 1905, sm. Svo, pp. 
 
 [33] -84. 
 
 Miss Stephens believes this to have been the first Phi Beta Kappa ora- 
 tion delivered by a woman ; it was probably the only one down to 1915, 
 when Miss Gildersleeve was the orator at Columbia. 
 
 530 
 
General. 
 
 Wilson Sterling. See Ph. B. K. Publ, N. S. 3, p. [12]. 
 
 KENYOX COLLEGE. 
 
 Beta of Ohio. Organized June 29, 1858. 
 
 Catalogues. 
 
 1899. Compiled by Lewis Caleb Williams and George Parkin 
 Atwater. 8vo, pp. 102. 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 
 1892. George C. S. Southworth. The making of our civiliza- 
 tion. An oration before the Phi Beta Kappa of Kenyon College, 
 June 22, 1892. Salem, O. Press of Harris & Co. 1892. 8vo, 
 PP- 25- 
 
 General. 
 
 Maxwell B. Lang. See Ph. B. K. Publ., N. S. 3, p. [7] . 
 
 LAFAYETTE COLLEGE. 
 
 Gamma of Pennsylvania. Organized April 5, 1890. 
 
 General. 
 
 Oscar McMurtrie Voorhees. The A'assar-Lafayette inaugu- 
 rations. In The Key^ January, 1916, ii. 10. 467-9. 
 R. B. Youngman. See Ph. B. K. Publ, N. S. 3, pp. [12-13]; 
 
 LAWRENCE COLLEGE. 
 
 Gamma of Wisconsin. Organized February 20, 1914. 
 
 Catalogues. 
 
 A partial list of members is given in The Key^ March, 1914, 
 ii. 3. 130-31. ; 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 
 1914. Edward Asahel Birge. College and life. Delivered 
 February 20. An abstract is given in The Key, March, 1914, 
 ii. 3. 131-32. 
 
 531 
 
General. 
 
 Albert Augustus Trever. The Gamma of Wisconsin. In 
 The Key, March, 1914, ii. 3. 127-134. 
 
 . Lawrence College. In The Key, March, 1914, ii. 3. 
 
 123-6. lUus. 
 
 See also The Key, May, 1913, i. 12, 23-4. 
 
 LEHIGH UNIVERSITY. 
 Beta of Pennsylvania. Organized April 5, 1887. 
 Catalogues. 
 ' [1889.] 8vo, p. [i]. 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 
 1904. William Peterfield Trent. Literature and science.. 
 In Greatness in literature and other papers, New York, Crowell,, 
 1905, 8vo, pp. 109-46. 
 
 19 10. Charles Joseph Bonaparte. Statesmanship in the ad- 
 ministration of justice. Delivered June 11. In The Key, Janu- 
 ary, 1912, i. 6. 19-31. 
 
 General. 
 
 Charles J. Goodwin. Phi Beta Kappa at Lehigh University. 
 In The Key, January, 1912, i. 6. 16-19. Hlus. 
 
 Albert G. Rau. See Ph. B. K. bulletin of information, 1903, 
 
 P- [3]- 
 
 MARIETTA COLLEGE. 
 
 Gamma of Ohio. Organized June 9, i860. 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 
 1869. Israel Ward Andrews. The American college: an ad- 
 dress before the * B K Society of Marietta College, June 29, 1869. 
 Marietta, O. Register Office. 1869. 8vo, pp. 22. 
 
 1875. Franklin W. Fisk. The unity of the professions. De- 
 livered June 29. In The New Englander, July, 1876, xxxv. 534-47. 
 
 MIAMI UNIVERSITY. 
 
 Iota of Ohio. Organized June 14, 191 1. 
 532 
 
General. 
 
 Archer Everett Young. The Iota of Ohio at Miami Univer- 
 sity. In The Key, October, 191 1, i. 5. 16-29. 
 
 THE UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN. 
 
 Alpha of Michigan. Organized November 13, 1907. 
 
 Catalogues. 
 
 1909. In The Michigan Ahtiiinus, April, 1909, xv. 276-8 (list of 
 alumni), December, 1909, xvi. 116-20. 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 
 191 1. James Bryce. The study of ancient literature: address 
 to the University of Michigan Chapter of the $ B K Society, April, 
 191 1. In his Uniz'ersity and historical addresses delivered during 
 a residence in the United States as ambassador of Great Britain, 
 New York, Macmillan, 1913, 8vo, pp. 317-38. 
 Also summarized in The Michigan ^-lluninus, May, IQII, xvii. 473-4. 
 
 General. 
 
 Alfred H. Lloyd. Phi Beta Kappa, Alpha of Michigan. In 
 The Michigan Alitninns, December, 1907, xiv, 100-103. 
 
 See also Ph. B. K. Puhl, N. S. 8, pp. 18-19. 
 
 The Michigan Alumnus. The Michigan Chapter of Phi Beta 
 Kappa. April, 1909, xv. 276-8. 
 
 Gives a list of alumni members and the constitution. See also pp. 330- 
 31- 
 
 The Phi Beta Kappa Society and the University of Michigan. 
 
 November, 1899, xi. 47-53. 
 
 Se£ also April, 1907, xiii. 276-7 (on the application for a char- 
 ter) ; December, 1909, xv. 116-20 (on alumni elections ; see also 
 
 pp. lOO-IOl). 
 
 Frederic Logan Paxson. Elections to the Michigan Chapter 
 of Phi Beta Kappa. In The Michigan Alumnus, March, 1909, 
 XV. 229-30. 
 
 See also Ph. B. K. Publ, N. S. 4, P- U- 
 
 MIDDLEBURY COLLEGE. 
 
 Beta of Vermont. Organized August 17, 1868. 
 
 533 
 
Orations and Addresses. 
 
 1901. Walter Seth Logan. A more socialistic state; oration 
 before the $ B K Society of Middlebury College, Vermont, de- 
 livered June 25, 1901. New York. 1901. 8vo, pp. 28. 
 
 THE UNIVERSITY OF MINNESOTA. 
 
 Alpha of Minnesota. Organized December 13, 1892. 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 
 1908. Edward Asahel Birge. See Wisconsin Orations and 
 Addresses, 1908. 
 
 General. 
 
 Hope McDonald. See Ph. B. K. bulletin of information, 1903, 
 
 p. [S]- 
 
 Cora E. Marlowe. See Ph. B. K. Publ, N. S. 3, p. [13]. 
 
 THE UNIVERSITY OF MISSOURI. 
 
 Alpha of Missouri. Organized December 5, 1901. 
 
 Catalogues. 
 
 1909. 8vo, pp. III. 2 woodcuts. 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 
 1909. Charles William Eliot. The contemporary American 
 conception of equality among men as a social and polished ideal. 
 Oration delivered by President Charles William Eliot of Harvard 
 University June 2, 1909, before the Alpha of Missouri. N. p. N. 
 d. 8vo, pp. 24. 
 
 1911. Frank Thilly. The characteristics of the present age. 
 In The Hibbert Journal, October, 191 1, x. 253-66. 
 
 General. 
 
 James Thayer Gerould. See Ph. B. K. bulletin of informa- 
 tion, 1903, p. [i] ; Ph. B. K. Publ., N. S. 3, p. [19]. 
 
 MOUNT HOLYOKE COLLEGE. 
 
 Theta of Massachusetts. Organized January 30, 1905. 
 
 534 
 
Catalogues. 
 The secretary is preparing a catalogue. 
 
 General, 
 
 Carrie A. Harper. Mount Holyoke College and its seventy- 
 fifth anniversary. In The Key, January, 191 3, i. 10. 28-34. 
 [Helen Elizabeth Hoag.] See Ph. B. K. Publ., N. S. 2, 
 
 P- [?]■ 
 
 MiGNON Talbot. See Ph. B. K. Publ., N. S. 3, p. [22]. 
 
 See also Ph. B. K. : information resp. institutions that have applied for 
 charters, 1904, pp. [1-2]. 
 
 THE UNIVERSITY OF NEBRASKA. 
 
 Alpha of Nebraska. Organized December 23, 1895. 
 
 Catalogues. 
 
 1906. i6mo, pp. 23. 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 
 1910. James Westfall Thompson. History, tradition, and 
 culture. Delivered June 16. A summary appeared in The Ne- 
 braska State Journal for June 17. 
 
 General. 
 
 Frederic C. Clements. See Ph. B. K. bulletin of information, 
 1903, P- [3] ; Ph. B. K. Publ., N. S. 3, p. [14]. 
 
 COLLEGE OF THE CITY OF NEW YORK. 
 
 Gamma of New York. Organized July 24, 1867. 
 
 Catalogues. 
 
 1893. 8vo, pp. 6. 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 
 1880. John Hampden Dougherty. The influence of our gen- 
 eration upon education. Delivered November 18. In Papers read 
 before the New York Gamma Chapter of Phi Beta Kappa at the 
 College of the City of New York, 1880- 1 (New York, Lehmaier, 
 8vo, pp. 56), pp. 3-15- 
 
 1881. Gilbert Holmes Crawford. The opposing policies, of 
 i\Ir. Gladstone and Lord Beaconsfield. Delivered January 28. 
 
 535 
 
In Papers read before the New York Gamma Chapter of Phi 
 Beta Kappa at the College of the City of Nezv York, 1880-1, pp. 
 
 17-31- 
 
 1881. Adolphus Henrv Stoiber. The establishment of an in- 
 ternational tribunal. Delivered April 26. In Papers read before 
 the New York Gamma Chapter of Phi Beia Kappa at the College 
 of the City of Nezv York, 1880-1, pp. 33-56. 
 
 1882. John Bach Mcmaster. French society during the reign 
 of Louis XIV. Delivered January 27. In Papers read before the 
 Gamma Chapter of Phi Beta Kappa at the College of the City of 
 New York, 1882 (New York, Lehmaier, n. d., 8vo, pp. 62), pp. 
 
 5-21. 
 
 1882. EflVi'AED Morse Shepard. Dishonor in American public 
 life. Delivered April 27. In Papers read before the Gamma 
 Chapter of Phi Beta Kappa at the College of the City of New 
 York, 1882, pp. 22-46. 
 
 1882. Henry Snyder Carr. Emerson as seen through his 
 prose. A paper read before the Phi Beta Kappa Society at the 
 College of the City of New York, October 28, 1882. New York. 
 Lehmaier & Co. 1882. 8vo, pp. 16. 
 
 Also in Papers read before the Gamma Chapter of Phi Beta Kappa at 
 the College of the City of New York, 1882, pp. 47-62. 
 
 1892. Leigh Harrison Hunt. On the making of etchings; 
 and also a few characteristics of some great etchers. Delivered 
 in November. New York. Goldman. 1892. 8vo, pp. 25. 
 
 1893. William Burnet Tuthill. Environment in architec- 
 ture. Read before the Gamma Chapter of the Phi Beta Kappa 
 Society April twenty-fifth, MDCCCXCIII. New York. 1893. 
 8vo, pp. 39. 
 
 1894. Edward Martin Colie. John Ruskin as an ethical teach- 
 er. Read before the Phi Beta Kappa Society, December 18, 1894. 
 New York. 1894. 8vo, pp. 22. 
 
 1896. Charles A. Doremus. A page from the chemistry of 
 to-day. 
 
 1896. Gustave LeGras. The evolution and philosophy of the 
 infinitesimal calculus. Read to the Gamma Chapter of the Phi 
 Beta Kappa Society May 4th, 1896. New York. 1896. 8vo, pp. 
 
 31- 
 
 {To be continued.) 
 536 
 
-=■ — ^ — 
 
 Volume 3 
 
 Number 2 
 
 Content0 
 
 Con cerhing the Twelfth Council . 
 Niagara— 7A Poem 
 
 Darwin P. Kihgsley . . . . 
 
 Phi Beta Kappa and Intellectual Culture 
 Th^ Delta of Pennsylvania . 
 Respecting Phi Beta Kappa Keys 
 A Phi Beta Kappa Bibliography . 
 The Flat Hat Club at William and Mary 
 In Memctriamv . . . . 
 
 Phi Beta Kappa News and Notes ., 
 
 PENNSYLVANIA NUMBER 
 JANUARY. 1917 
 
 Page 
 51 
 55 
 56 
 58 
 62 
 78 
 80 
 87 
 89 
 94 
 
The Phi Beta Kappa Fraternity 
 
 OmECTORY OF CHAPTERS 
 
 ' With number in the order of establishment, the Setretary, and date. 
 
 IJ Alabama— Mpba, ,ot Alabama, University, Prof. J. J. Boater, A. M. ,...1*851 
 
 64 Allegllieny—Eta, of Pennsylvania, McadvUle, Prof. W. A. Elliott, L. H. D.....190Z 
 
 13 Amhertt — ^Beta of Massacbu»>tts, Amherst, Prof. lievi B. Elwel), A. M 18SS. 
 
 78 BeMt — Beta of Wisconsin, Beioit, Prof. Eirastus G. BnOtb/Fh. D;.. . . . .....1911 
 
 46 Boston — ^Epsilon of Massacimsetts, Boston, Ada A. Cole, Ph. B.. . i ..189S 
 
 < Boiodainr^Alpha. of Katne, Brunswick, Prof. Geo. T. Files, Ph. D...>..^....182E 
 7 BrownJ-MpSa, of Btaode Island, Providence, Prof. James Q. Dealey, Ph. D..1880 
 
 43 Odlifornia-^Mpba, of California, Berkeley, Prof. Perdval B, Fsty, Ph, D.. ..1891 
 
 82 Carleton — ^Beta of Minnesota, Northfield, Prof . Curvta H. Gingrich, Ph. D 1914 
 
 ei CMoago — ^Beta of Illinois, Chlca«o, Prof . Francis :W. Shepardson, Hit. D...>..1899 
 
 48 Pincinnati-^Delta of Ohio, Cincinnati,' Mrs. M. O. Hartmann, B. U. 1899 
 
 39 OoZ6y-fBeta of Maine. Watervllle, Prof. J. William Blacic, Ph. t> . . . .189* 
 
 24 boljtote— Eta of New Tork, Hamilton, Prof. F. C. French, Ph. D ...il878 
 
 65 Colorado Vniversity — Alpha of Colbraaoi Boulder, Prof. F. Ramaley, Ph. D..19&4 
 S9 Colorado College — ^Beta -of Colorado, Colorado Springs, Prof. H. E. Wood- 
 bridge, M. A. ....T ; ..1994 
 
 21 Oohimbia-r-t>eita, of New York, New York City, Preston Wm. Slosson, A. B. .1869 
 S5 Cornell — theta of New York, Ithaca, Albert IieRoy Andrews, Ph. D ..1882 
 
 4 I>artmoutftT-Alpha of New BamiMhlre, Hanovei* Harolil G. Bugg, A. B....'.1787 
 
 74 DerUaon—Tbeta, of Ohio, Granville, Prof. W. A. Obamberlla, Ph. D. :... .1911 
 
 29 be Pouw^— Alphfi of Indiana, Greencastle, Prof. A- B<. CauldwelU A. M.. . . .'V.1S89 
 
 26 Dioklnaon — -lAlpha of Pennsylvania, Carlisle, Prof . Joim F.Mohler.Ph. D..'.1887 
 S9 FrankUn and Uarshall — ^Theta of Pennsylvania, Lancaster, Prof. A. Thomas 
 
 G. Apple, Ph. D. ....... , 19«» 
 
 81 Georfflio— Alpha of Georgia, Athens, Prof. W. D. Hooper, A. M. 1914 
 
 64 Gouohsr^Beta of Maryland, Baltimore,: Misa Eklna F. Schwarz, A^ B...'. 1996 
 
 76 Grinnell — ^Beta of Iowa, Grinnell, Prof. Caroline Sheldon,, A. M. 1991 
 
 22 Bamilton — ^Epsllon of New York, Clinton, Prof. J. .IX Ibbdtson, Jr., A. M... ..1879 
 3 Harvard — ^Alpha of MJassaShusetts, CarnbridgCr William C. Lane, A. S.. . . . . .1711 
 
 44 Haverford — Zeta of Pennsylvania, Haverford, Prof. L. W. Reid, Ph. D .1896 
 
 23 Hobart — Zeta of New York, Geneva, Prof. Willis P. Woodman, Ph. D ,1871 
 
 67 illtoois — Gamma of niinoii^ tTrbana,' Prof. -Jacob Zeitllh, Ph. D ....1967 
 
 75 Indiana — Gamma of Indiana, Bloomhigtoh, PTof: ,F. 'W. Tilden, A. M.. . . ;. . . .1911, 
 
 36 Iowa — ^Alpha of Iowa, Iowa City, Miss Beryl G. Hart, A. B.. 1896 
 
 '37 Joftns Bopkina — ^Alpba of Maryland, Bslhimore, Prof. John C. French, PhrD.189B 
 
 31 Kansa<>.^Alpha of Kansas, lawrence. Prof. E. D. Cressman, Ph. D..... ., ..1896 
 
 14 vKemj/ojt^-Beta of OUST Gambler, WiUlam Clinton -Settz, A^ B.....:.. .1858 
 
 32 Lafayette— Gajoma, at Pennsylvania; Easibn, Prof. Wm. 9. Ball, Ph. D. . ... . .1890 
 
 79 Lauirence — ^^Gamma of Wisconsin, APPleton, Prof. Ix>uls A. Youti, Ph. t>..r..l914 
 
 27 Lehigh — Beta of f'ennsylvanla. South Bethlehem, I^of. C. L. Thomburg, 
 
 Ph. D. .,;....... ;lm 
 
 16 Marietta — Qamnia of Ohio, Marietta, iProf. Arthur G. Beach, A, M.. , . . ..J. .1860 
 ■71 affcMnir-Iota.of.Ohl.o, Oxford, Prof. Harlan Si3iwab, B. A. .j.*.i.l911 
 
 68 Michigan — Alpha of MlchigaiC Ann Arbor, Prof. Johft G. Winter, Ph. D. ...1907 
 19 Mlddleburj/ — B,eta of Vermont, Mlddlebury, Prof. Chas. B. Wright, Lltt. D. .1868 
 35 Minneaota — Alpha of Minnesota, Minneapolis,, William H.. Bussey, Fh. D..'.1892 
 53 Miasouri—Mptiarot Missouri, Columbia, Prof." Guy B..Colbum,''Hi. D.. . . i i . . .1991 
 *2 wt. Molvoke — ^eta- of Massachusetts. South Hadley, Asso. Prof. Margaret 
 
 S. Morriss, Ph. D,...,. >.. , ......1906 
 
1917 Respecting Phi Beta Kappa Keys 79 
 
 In accordance with the authority thus granted the Secretary has 
 secured bids from eight reputable manufacturing jewelers, includ- 
 ing all those who have been advertising in The Key, and in the 
 course of a few weeks he hopes to announce the decision, and the 
 award of a contract for the manufacture of all the keys needed 
 by the members of Phi Beta Kappa for a period of three years. 
 In this decision he has asked the assistance of the Treasurer, and 
 has consulted by letter several members of the Senate. 
 
 From bids at hand it is evident that both the members and the 
 Fraternity will profit, for a reduction will be made in the price of 
 keys to members, and still a royalty be reserved for the Treasury 
 of the United Chapters. 
 
 The officers of the Chapters are hereby advised of this pending 
 arrangement, and requested to plan such steps as shall put their 
 chapters in line with the new regulations. There seems no rea- 
 son why the plan should not pi^ove successful from the beginning. 
 
 The propriety of this action is evident to all who have studied 
 the key problem. While all keys are supposed to be of 14 k. gold,, 
 several have been found on analysis to be of 10 k. or thereabouts, 
 and the grotesque forms that were put out for a time seem shock- 
 ing to all those who have any respect for the simple design of the 
 early medal, the prominent features of which are all retained in 
 the standard key. While the adoption of the standard key has 
 done much to correct this it has not prevented jewelers from of- 
 fering for sale keys of smaller size and lighter weight in order to 
 secure local trade. On two occasions during the last triennium 
 the Secretary has been under the necessity of requesting jewelers 
 to withdraw from sale undersized keys. In another case a firm 
 sold to one of our larger chapters a supply of keys for an entire 
 delegation that were manifestly inferior in design and workman- 
 ship, on the assurance that they were standard. Of this inferiority 
 the Chapter officers were not aware until I called their attention 
 to it. While I also went in person to the firm and protested, all I 
 could secure was the verbal assurance that they would thereafter 
 conform more nearly to the standard design. But they would 
 not make a public assertion to this effect by placing an advertise- 
 ment in the Phi Beta Kappa Key. 
 
 Respecting those jewelers who have advertised in The Key 
 
8o Phi Beta Kappa Key January 
 
 we have had no complaint. We believe they have delivered only 
 standard keys of competent workmanship, and it will not be an 
 easy task to select one or more as official jewelers, for that will 
 in effect be refusing to select the others. The action of the Coun- 
 cil leaves us no option. We must fall back upon the fact that Phi 
 Beta Kappa has made possible for the jewelers the business of 
 manufacturing Phi Beta Kappa keys — aggregating in recent years 
 between $7,000 and $8,000 per year. In paying for their keys 
 members have in reality paid advertising and marketing charges 
 in addition to the first cost and the profits of manufacture. What 
 is proposed is to eliminate the marketing charge, or rather to di- 
 vide it between the purchasers and the United Chapters. That is, 
 the Fraternity that in reality originates the business is to be rec- 
 ognized as entitled to a share in its profits. 
 
 It is well to understand that the successful working out of this 
 plan will require the hearty co-operation of the Chapter officers. 
 Under legislation in force a certificate signed by a Chapter officer 
 is necessary to secure from a reputable jeweler the delivery of a 
 Phi Beta Kappa key. If officers will sign certificates directed to 
 the official jeweler only, the arrangement will go into full effect at 
 ■once. The loyalty and good faith of all Chapter officers in this as 
 in all other matters is confidently anticipated. 
 
 A PHI BETA KAPPA BIBLIOGRAPHY 
 
 By Professor Clark S. Northup, Cornell '93. 
 
 {Continued from Vol. 2, p. 536.) 
 
 COLLEGE OF THE CITY OF NEW YORK— Continued. 
 
 1897. George C. Lay. The preliminary period of the American 
 Revolution: a paper read before the Gamma Chapter of the Phi 
 Beta Kappa, College of the City of New York, November 15, 
 1897. 8vo, pp. 31. 
 ' Reprinted from Godey's Magazine, 1898. 
 
 1902. GuSTAVE LeGras. Mathematics as a means of culture. 
 Read in April. 
 
 1905. John Huston Finley. Higher education in the 
 
igij A Phi Beta Kappa Bibliography 8i 
 
 United States. Delivered November 24, 1905. An abstract ap- 
 peared in The City College Quarterly, March, 1906, ii. 16-21. 
 
 1906. Charles Baskerville. The chemical elements and their 
 transmutation. Read January 29, 1906. An abstract appeared in 
 The City College Quarterly, March, 1906, ii. 22-6. 
 
 1906. E. CosENZA Mario. The American student at Rome. 
 Delivered jNIarch 30, 1906. In The City College Quarterly, June, 
 1906, ii. 105-17. 
 
 1907. Melatiah Everett Dwight. Japhet in search of a 
 grandfather. Delivered January 28, 1907. An abstract appeared 
 in The City College Quarterly, March, 1907, iii. 53-4. 
 
 1907. Henry Mottet. An outing in Iceland. An abstract ap- 
 peared in The City College Quarterly, June, 1907, iii. 107, October, 
 
 PP- 173-4- 
 
 1909. Louis E. Van Norman. A moral satisfaction in the 
 writing of a book. Delivered in March. In The City College 
 Quarterly, March, 1909, v. 15-25. 
 
 General. 
 
 The College of the City of New York. In The Key, October, 
 1913, ii. I. 40-44. 
 See also The Key, January, 1916, ii. 10. 494, 497. 
 
 NEW YORK UNIVERSITY. 
 
 Beta of New York. Organized December 23, 1858. 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 
 1886. Charles W. Baird. Phi Beta Kappa oration. The 
 scholar's duty and opportunity. By Charles W. Baird, D. D. 
 New York: W. M. Halsted, Printer, No. 8 Spruce Street, 1886. 
 8vo, pp. [ii], 17. 
 
 Delivered June 14, 1886. 
 
 1903. Robert MacDougall. University training and the doc- 
 toral degree. Delivered June 3. In Education, January, 1904, 
 xxiv. 262-76. 
 
 General. 
 
 Henry Mitchell McCracken. See Ph. B. K. PubL, N. S. 
 
 3.P- [8]. 
 
82 Phi Beta Kappa Key January 
 
 THE UNIVERSITY OF NORTH CAROLINA. 
 
 Alpha of North Carolina. Organized November 7, 1904. 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 
 1905. J.\MES Wilson Bright. Aleridies, or The new South. 
 Delivered January 27. Three stanzas forming a part of the 
 address were printed by the author for private distribution ; and a 
 report was printed in The Tar Heel, February i, 1905. 
 
 1909. Edwin Augustus Grosvenor. The attitude of the 
 scholar. Delivered May 29. In The University Record, June, 
 1909, no. 74, pp. 6-16. 
 
 Reprinted in Representative Ph. B. K. orations, Boston, Houghton 
 Mifflin Co., 191S, 8vo, pp. 395-403. Also delivered before the Rutgers 
 Chapter, igog. 
 
 General. 
 
 R. H. McLain. See Ph. B. K. Pnbl, N. S. 3, p. [21]. 
 I. C. Wright. See Ph. B. K. Publ, N. S. 2, pp. [4-5]. 
 
 See also Ph. B. K. . information resp. institutions that have applied for 
 charters, 1904, p. [3]. 
 
 THE UNIVERSITY OF NORTH DAKOTA. 
 
 Alpha of North Dakota. Organized June 13, 1914. 
 
 General 
 
 A'ernon Purinton Squires. The Alpha of North Dakota. In 
 The Key, January, 1915, ii. 6. 269-77. IH^s. 
 See also The Key, May, 1913, i. 12. 22. 
 
 NORTHWESTERN UNIVERSITY. 
 
 Alpha of Illinois. Org.\nized Febru.\ry 18, 1890. 
 
 Catalogues. 
 
 1894. i2mo, pp. 18. 1896. Supplement. 1910. 8vo, pp. 57. 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 
 1891. Lewis Henry Boutell. Thomas Jefferson, the man of 
 letters. Printed by the Chapter. 
 
 1893. William Frederick .Poole. The university library and 
 
1917 -J f/" Beta Kappa Bibliography 83 
 
 the university curriculum. Phi Beta Kappa address, Northwest- 
 ern University, June 13, 1893. Chicago, etc. Fleming H. Revell 
 Co. 1894. i6mo, pp. 55. 
 
 1895. James Taft Hatfield. James Russell Lowell, the flow- 
 er of American culture. In Addresses delivered at the Loivell 
 coiiuncmoration, Berlin, ]\Iayer & Miiller, 1897, pp. 11-28. 
 
 1902. Frederick Jackson Turner. Western contributions to 
 democracy. In The Atlantic Monthly, January, 1903, xci. 83-96. 
 
 1903. William Morton Payne. The American scholar in the 
 twentieth century. In The International Quarterly, December, 
 1903, viii. 262-79. 
 
 Also reprinted, pp. 20. See Harvard Orations and Addresses, 1837. 
 1906. GusTAV E. Karsten. Folklore and patriotism. Deliv- 
 ered in June. In The Journal of English and Germanic Philology 
 vii. 2. 61-78. 
 
 Posthumously printed. An extension or sequel to Herder and the Volks- 
 lied, in the Bulletin of the Washington University Association, No. 3, 
 pp. lOlff. 
 
 1910. Felix Emanuel Schelling. The humanities gone and 
 to come. See Pennsylvania Orations and Addresses, 1902. 
 
 General. 
 
 Omera Floyd Long. See Ph. B. K. Publ, N. S. 3, p. [12]. 
 
 OBERLIN COLLEGE. 
 
 Zeta of Ohio. Organized November 8, 1907. 
 
 Catalogues. 
 
 Roll of Phi Beta Kappa. In The Oberlin Alumni Magazine, 
 
 June, 1910, vi. 367-73. 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 
 1910. Edward Increase Bosworth. Address of welcome to 
 the new members of Phi Beta Kappa. Delivered May 31. In 
 The Oberlin Alumni Magazine, June, 1910, vi. 363-65. 
 
 1910. Paul Shorey. The unity of the human spirit. De- 
 livered May 31. In The Oberlin Alumni Magazine, June, 1910, 
 vi. 343-62. 
 
 Reprinted in Representative Ph. B. K. orations, Boston, 19x5, 8vo, pp. 
 481-500. 
 
84 Phi Beta Kappa Key January 
 
 General. 
 
 Charles Nelson Cole. Phi Beta Kappa. In The Obcrlin 
 Alumni Magazine iv. 94-8. 
 
 The Oberlin Alumni Magazine. A depreciation. June, 
 1910, vi. 373-76. 
 
 Charles Henry Adams Wager. See Ph. B. K. Publ., N. S. 8, 
 
 P- 15- 
 
 See also Ph. B. K. Publ, N. S. 4, pp. 9-10. 
 
 OHIO STATE UNR'ERSITY. 
 
 Epsilon of Ohio. Organized December 8, 1904. 
 
 General. 
 
 [W. E. Henderson.] See Ph. B. K. Publ, N. S. 2, pp. [6-7]. 
 Henry R. Spencer. See Ph. B. K. Publ., N. S. 3, pp. [21-22]. 
 See also Ph. B. K. : information rcsp. institutions that have applied for 
 charters, 1904, p. [5]. 
 
 OHIO WESLEYAN UNIVERSITY. 
 
 Eta of Ohio. Organized November 9, 1907. 
 
 General. 
 
 William E. Smyser. See Ph. B. K. Publ., N. S. 8, pp. 15-17. 
 See also Ph. B. K. : information resp. institutions that have applied for 
 charters, 1904, p. [6] ; Ph. B. K. Publ, N. S. 4, p. 10. 
 
 THE UNIVERSITY OF PENNSYLA'ANIA. 
 
 Delta of Pennsylvania. Organized December 9, 1892. 
 
 Catalogues. 
 
 1897. 8vo, pp. 16. 1902. 8vo, pp. 26. 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 
 1898. George Wharton Pepper. Our national Constitution 
 as related to national growth ; a consideration of certain aspects of 
 the war with Spain. [Philadelphia.] 1898. 8vo, pp. 16. 
 
 Delivered June 7. 
 
 1899. Walter George Smith. Education and morality in 
 
1917 --^ -P'" Beta Kappa Bibliography 85 
 
 America. Delivered June 15. Publislied with the poem of that 
 3'ear in an 8vo pamphlet, pp. 20. 
 
 1900. DwiGHT M. LowREY. Mr. Zangwill and the Jew. De- 
 livered June 13. Published with the poem of that year in an Bvo 
 pamphlet, pp. 18. 
 
 1902. Felix Emanuel Schelling. Humanities, gone and to 
 come. Delivered June 18. Published with the poem of that 
 3'ear in an Bvo pamphlet, pp. 22; see pp. 3-16. 
 
 Also delivered before the Northwestern Chapter in 1910. Reprinted in 
 Representative Ph. B. K. orations, Boston, 1915, 8vo, pp. 286-97. 
 
 1903. Jesse Young Burk. The culture of our founders. De- 
 livered June 17. In The Alumni Register, July, 1903, vii. 482-92. 
 
 1904. Martin Grove Brumbaugh. Words and things. Ad- 
 dress before the societies of Phi Beta Kappa and Sigma Xi, June 
 15, 1904. In The University Bulletin, June, 1904, pp. 60-71. 
 
 1906. Clarence Griffin Child. Scholar and teacher. Ad- 
 dress before the societies of Phi Beta ELappa and Sigma Xi, June 
 12, 1906. In The Alumni Register, July, 1906, x. 478-93. 
 
 1909. Horace Clark Richards. The structure of the world- 
 stuff. Address delivered before the joint meeting of Phi Beta 
 Kappa and Sigma Xi, June 16, 1909. In Old Penn, October 2, 
 1909, viii. pp. [3-8]. 
 
 1916. John Huston Finley. Mobilization. In The Univer- 
 sity Record, New Series, Chicago, July, 1916, ii, 184-192. 
 
 Delivered also before the Chicago Chapter on June S, 1916. Also printed 
 (in part) in The New York Times Maga/^ine, July 9, 1916, pp. 4-5. Portrait. 
 
 Poems. 
 
 1899. Harrison S. Morris. Destiny. Read June 15. Pub- 
 lished with Mr. Smith's address ; see above. 
 
 1900. John Hall Ingham. The citizen. Read June 13. Pub- 
 lished with Mr. Lowrey's address ; see above. 
 
 1902. Francis Howard Williams. Ad astra, an ode. Read 
 June 18. Published with Mr. Schelling's address; see above; see 
 pp. 17-22. 
 
 1903. Hugh A. Clark. Art and life. Read June 17. In The 
 Alumni Register, July, 1903, vii. 492-4. 
 
86 Phi Beta Kappa Key January 
 
 General. 
 
 George DePue HiADZsits. The University of Pennsylvania. 
 In The Key, October, 1916, iii. 35-38. 
 
 Walton B. McDaniel. See Ph. B. K. Publ, N. S. 3, p. [13]. 
 Arthur H. Quinn. See Ph. B. K. bulletin of information, 
 
 1903. P- [3]- 
 
 The thirteenth annual dinner of the Delta of Pennsylvania. In 
 The Old Penn Weekly Review. Reprinted in The Key, May, 
 
 1913, i. 12. 16. 
 
 POMONA COLLEGE. 
 
 Gamma of California. Organized March 7, 1914. 
 
 Catalogues. 
 A list of members is given in The Key, May, 1914, ii. 4. 177-9. 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 
 1914. George Herbert Palmer. Address at the installation, 
 March 7. An abstract is printed in The Key, May, 1914, ii. 4. 
 174-5- 
 
 Poems. 
 
 19 14. Alice Maria Parker. The way of fulfilment. Read 
 June 15. In The Key, January, 1915, ii. 279-83. 
 
 1915. Harry A. Brandt. An ode to man. Read June 14. In 
 The Pomona College Quarterly Magazine, June, 1915, iii. 146-9. 
 
 General. 
 
 D. Herbert Colcord. Pomona College. In The Key, May, 
 
 1914, ii. 4. 171-3. Illus. 
 
 Alice Maria Parker. The Gamma of California. In The 
 Key, May, 1914, ii. 4. 173-81. 
 See also The Key, May, 1913, i. 12. 25-7, October, 1915, ii. g. 450-51. 
 
 (To he Continued.) 
 
Volume 3 
 
 Number 3,2 
 
 , Contente 
 
 The Delta of Illinois at Knox 
 Fraternity Journalism 
 Views of Washington University 
 VirgilV First Eclogue Remembered 
 The Passing of Three Senators ,. 
 A Phi Beta Kappa Bibliography . 
 InMemoriam . . . . 
 
 Phi Beta Kappa News and'Notes^ . 
 
 Pace 
 
 99 
 110 
 115 
 119 
 122 
 124 
 132 
 135 
 
 KNOX CHAPTER NUMBER 
 MARCH, 1917 
 
v^ The Phi Beta Kappa Fraternity 
 
 DIRECTORY OF CHAPTERS , 
 
 With mmilier in the^^^order ot estafcllshtawtiji the Secretary^: and date. 
 
 12 AlabdinaT^Mpba. at AlalBcma, TJnlversltiy, Prof. J. irr^Doster, A. M 1861 
 
 54 Alle^jheny— Eta^of Pennwriratiia, Meadvim, Prof. W. A. Elliott, L. H. D 1902 
 
 IS Amherst— Beta of Massachusetts, Amherst. . . , . .^, . i .". .1853 
 
 78 BeZoie— Beta of Wisconsin, Beloit, Prof. ErastUs G. Smith; Ph. D. ..,..>'... .',1911, 
 
 48 Soaton — ^Epsilon of Massachusetts, Boston, Ada A. Cole, Ph. B. ij . . . . .1899, 
 
 a SowdoinT-~Alpha of Maine, prunswicki Prof; aeorivT, Files, Ph. D.^. ;....,.. .1J2 5 
 
 7 BroiOTt-TfAltha of Rhodb Island, Providence, Srof. James Q. Pealey, ph/;D. . . .ISSO 
 
 4a CoW/ornio— Alpha of California, Berkeley, Prof. Percival B. Fay, Ph. J>......\%^ 
 
 82 Oorleton— Beta of Minnesota, Njorthfleld, Prof. Ctirwin H. ajngrich. Ph. D 191i 
 
 51 Chicago — Beta of Illinois. Chicago,. Erofi. Francis W. Sliepardson, LL. D.... .1899 
 48 Cinci1^naU — Delta of Ohio, Cincinnati, Mrs. H. G, Hartmann, B. ti.i. .,..,.. .1899 
 39 Colfti/— Beta of Maine, Waterville, Prof. J. William Black, Ph:'!). :. .*- 1896 
 
 24 Gotoote— Eta of New Tprk, Hamilton, Prof. F. C. French, Ph. D. . , i 1878 
 
 65 Colotado XJnimersity — Alpha. of Colorado; Boulder,''Prof.' F: Bamaley, Ph. D. . . .1904^ 
 m. Colorado Oolleg'e—'Beta. of Colorado, Colorado Springs, Prof.?H. B. Woodbridee; 
 
 iL A. ; '., ^.-^ .'. . . . . . , ........ .1904 
 
 21 Columbia — Pelta of New ToTk, jkevr Tork City, Cla,rencerA. Manning, Ph, D,. .1869 ' 
 
 25 Corneil — Theta of New York, Ithaca, Albert LeRoy Andrewat P'h' Di ....... . .1882 ' 
 
 i: flurtmoufili — ^Alpha of New Hampshire, Hanover, HarialSjGr, Rusg, A.- B. . ...1787 
 
 74 Den«9»rv-Theta of, Ohio, Granville, Prof. W. A. Chaniberite, Wn.-Tlj .1911 
 
 iV'Pe Pauia. — ^Alpha of Indiana, Greencastle, Prof. A. P. Cauldwell, A. M.. , 1*89 
 
 26 Djcfcjoaon— Alpha of Pennsylvaifla, Carli^e, .Prof. Jjohn F. MOWer; Ph. D....18S7 
 69 Franklin ana, MarahaW — ^Theta of Pennsylvania, Lancaster, i Prof ., A. Thomas 6. 
 
 Apple, Ph. D. ..i >...".... ^.,..1903 
 
 81' a-eorgia — ^Alpha of Qiotgla., Athens, Prof. W. J). H*oper,^.'M ..> .. . .1914 
 
 64 Gaucher — Beta of Maaylarid,, Baltimore, Miss Edna P. Sdl^warz, A. B;. . , . . . .1906 
 
 70: Orinnell — Beta of Iowa, Grinnpll, Prof. Caroline Sheldon, A. M '. 1908 
 
 Z2 Hamilton — Epsilon of Now York, Clinton, Prof., J. D. Ibbotson, Jr., AT" M. ,..1870 
 3 Harvard — Alpha of Massachusetts, ' Cambridge, William C. Lajne, A. B. .. .:.1781 
 
 44 Haverford — Zeta of Pennsylvania, HstveipforB, Prof, l! W. Reid, Ph. D. . . . . . . .1890 
 
 23: HobartT-r-Zeta. of New Yorl?, Geneva, Prof. Willis P., Woodman, Ph. D 1871 
 
 67 Illinois — Gamma, of Illinoia, Urbina, Prof. Jacob ZeitlinJPh. D 19(f7 
 
 15 Indiana — Gatnma of Indiana, Bloomington, Prof. P. W. TiWen, A. M- ...... .1911 
 
 36, Iowa — ^Alpha of Ipw4, Iowa, City, Miss Beryl jG; Hart, A, B *.' .1896 
 
 ^T Johns Hopkins- — ^Alpha of ifaryland, Baltimore, Prof . John C. French, Ph. n"i.l895 
 31 Kanaaa — Alpha of Kansas, Lawrence, ErcSi E. D. Cressman, ph,, B. .'....;. .,.1890 
 
 14 Kenyon — Beta of Ohio, Gambler, William Cllntojri Seitz, A. B. 18?'S 
 
 8^7 Kmox — Delta of Illinois, Galesburg, 1?r<3i. James A. Campbell, A. M.. /. 1917 
 
 v32 Laffiyette — Gamma of Penh'sylvat^^, Baston, Prtff. Wm. S. Hall, Ph., D. .... .'.4890 
 
 19 Litwrenee — ^Gamma of Wlscoftsln, Aispleton, Pro;p; Louis A. Youtz, Ph. D 1914 
 
 27£ieAiffh— Beta of Penjisylvanla, South BetWehemi Prof. C. L. T^ornburg', Ph. D.18'87 
 
 16 marietta — KSamma of Ohio, Marietta, Prof. Arthur G. Beach, A. Mt>. . .r .i860 
 
 77 Miamt— Iota of Ohio, Oxford, Prof. Harlan Schwab, B. A. . . i ;..... i'. . ,1911 
 
 68 afic»iffo»i— Alpha of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Prof. John G. Winter, Ph. © . ;1907 , 
 
 19 Middlelmri—^ata. of Vermont, Middlebury,rProf. dhas; B, Wright,' Lltt.D. .. .1863 
 
 35 Minfiesota—Aipha. of Minnesota, Minneapolis, William H. Bussey, Ph. D 1892 
 
 53 MiaaoUrir—Alplia, of Missouri, Columbia, Prof. Guy A Colburn, Ph. D.;-. . . .^.1901 
 62 Mt. HoZj/ofce-'— Theta of Massachusetts, South Hadley, Asso. Prof, Margaret S. 
 
 MorriBB^ Ph. D, 1906 
 
FRANCIS BROWN, LL.D., Dartmo-uth '70 
 
 For over thirty-seven years connected with the Faculty of Union The- 
 ological Seminary, New York 
 
124 Plii Beta Kappa Key March 
 
 glad to print as frontispiece the portrait that accompanies the 
 article in The Outlook. 
 
 In the January number of The Key appeared In Memoriam 
 notes respecting three members of Phi Beta Kappa who had ex- 
 erted wide influence as editors of prominent periodicals — Dr. Wil- 
 liam Hayes ^^'ard, Amherst '56, of The Independent, Horace 
 \Mi!te, Beloit '53, of the New York Evening Post, and Hamilton 
 W. Mabie, of The Outlook. This suggests the propriety of an 
 article on Phi Beta Kappa in Journalism. 
 
 A PHI BETA KAPPA BIBLIOGRAPHY 
 
 P'v Prof. Cl.\rk S. Xorthup, Corxell '93 
 
 (Continued from page 86). 
 
 PRINCETON UNIVERSITY. 
 
 Beta of New Jersey. Organized June 7, 1899. 
 
 General. 
 
 Samuel R. Winans. See Ph. B. K. Pubi, N. S., 3, pp. [17-18]. 
 
 RADCLIFFE COLLEGE. 
 
 Iota of Massachusetts. Organized May ii, 1914. 
 General. 
 
 Caroline Barnard Shaw. The Iota of Massachusetts at 
 Radclifife College. In The Key, October, 1914, ii. 5. 242-8. Illus. 
 See also The Key i. 12. 19. 
 
 THE UNIVERSITY OF ROCHESTER. 
 Iota of New York. Organized April 20, 1887. 
 Catalogues. 
 1904. 8vo, pp. 31. 1914. 8vo, pp. 30. 
 
1917 A Phi Beta Kappa Bibliography 125 
 
 OrATIOXS and ADDI-tESSKS. 
 
 i8qo. Edward Everett Hale. The professor of America. In 
 his Works, Boston, Little, Brown & Co., T900, vol. viii, Addresses 
 and essays, pp. 65-85. 
 
 1903. Talcott Williams. Education and combination. Ora- 
 tion delivered before the Phi Beta Kappa Society at the Univer- 
 sity of Rochester, June 15, 1903. 8vo, pp. 13. 
 
 1906. Oscar McMurtie Voorhees. Our Phi Beta Kappa 
 fathers and their fraternity. Delivered March 16. See William 
 and Mary, General. 
 
 1911. Benjamin Ide Wheeler. The races and tongues of 
 men. Delivered June ig. In The Uniz'ersity Chronicle, Berkeley, 
 Cal, Jan., 1912, xiv. 13-24. 
 
 1912. Thomas Frederick Crane. Address before the New 
 York Iota of the Phi Beta Kappa May 25, 1912. [Rochester. 
 1912.] 8vo, pp. 13. 
 
 On continuing liberal studies after leaving college. 
 
 1915. Bliss Perry. Phi Beta Kappa's famous day [August 31, 
 
 1837, at Harvard]. Delivered June 13. 
 
 Comment in Bulletin of the UniversJv of Riiclu'S'cr, November, 1915, 
 xi. 4. 4-5. 
 
 Generai 
 Charles Hoeing. See Ph. B. K. Piibl., X. S., 3, p. [11]. 
 
 RUTGERS COLLEGE. 
 
 Alpha of Xew Jersey. Organized Feliruary 22. 186'^;. 
 
 Catalogues. 
 
 1891. Svo, pp. yj, iii. Includes a historical sketch of the Phi 
 Beta Kappa Society, b}- Oscar J\I. Voorhees. 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 
 1876. CoRTLANDT Parker. The Open Bible, or Tolerant Chris- 
 tianity the source and security of Am'erjcan freedom and pro- 
 gress : an address delivered before the Phi Beta Kappa Society of 
 Rutgers College, New Brunswick, N. J., June 20th, 1876. By Cort- 
 
126 Phi Beta Kappa Key March 
 
 landt Parker, Esq., of the class of 1836. Printed for the Society. 
 8vo, pp. 29. 
 
 1909. Enwr.v Augustus Grosvenor. An address on the atti- 
 tude of the scholar by Prof. Edwin A. Grosvenor, LL.D., Presi- 
 dent of the United Chapters of Phi Beta Kappa, delivered at the 
 fortieth anniversary of the founding of the Alpha Chapter of Phi 
 Beta Kappa in Xew Jersey at Rutgers College, New Brunswick, 
 New Jersey, June 21, 1909. N. p. N. d. Svo, pp. [ii], 8. 
 Delivered also before the North Carolina Chapter, 1909. 
 
 General. 
 
 Francis K. W. Drury. See Ph. B. K. bulletin of information, 
 
 1903. P- [4]- 
 CuLLEN W. Parmelee. See Ph. B. K. PiibL, X. S. 3, pp. [8-9]. 
 See also The Key ii. 8. 404. 
 
 ST. LAWRENCE UNIVERSITY. 
 
 Lamud.v of Xew York. Organized June 24, 1899. 
 
 Or.xtions and Addresses. 
 
 1903. Elon Rowse Brown. The small college and society. De- 
 livered June 23. In Literary exercises of the Phi Beta Kappa 
 Society, Lambda of New York, at St. Lawrence University, June 
 23, 1903, Canton, X, Y., 1903, pp. 3-12. 
 
 Poems. 
 
 1902. Irving Bacheller. The New World. Read June 24. 
 In The Laurentian, July, 1902, xv. 162-3. 
 
 Also in his hi various moods. New York, Harper, lyio, Svo, pp. 5-8. 
 
 1903. John Langdon Heaton. Demeter. Read June 23. In 
 Literary exercises of the Phi Beta Kappa Society, Lambda of New 
 York, at St. Lazvrence University, June 23, 1903, pp. i3-r6. 
 
 Also in Tlic Laurentian, July, 1903, xvi. 169-72. 
 
 1904. Charles Kelsey Gaines. Our own. In The Lauren- 
 tian, July, 1904, xvii. 157-9. 
 
1917 -"^ ^'" Beta Kappa Bibliography 127 
 
 General. 
 Robert D. Ford. See Phi B. K. Publ., N. S. 3, p. [18]. 
 
 SMITH COLLEGE. , /' 
 
 Zeta of }i1assachusetts. Organized October 19, 1904.' 
 
 General. 
 
 Elizabeth Deering Hanscom. See Ph. B. K. Publ., N. S. 3, 
 
 p. [20]. 
 
 See also Ph. B. K. : information resp. institutions that have applied for 
 charters, 1904, p. [2] ; Ph. B. K. Publ, N. S. 2, p. [3]. 
 
 LELAND STANFORD, JR., UNIVERSITY. 
 
 Beta of California. Organized November i, 1904. 
 
 Catalogues. 
 
 1905. i6mo, pp. 21. 1909, April. 8vo, pp. 32. 1913. 8vo, 
 pp. 41. 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 
 1906. William Ernest Hocking. The necessary and suffi- 
 cient conditions of human happiness. Delivered October 13. In 
 Annual open meeting of the Plii Beta Kappa Society at Stanford 
 University, October 13, 1906 (Stanford University Press, 1907, 
 8vo, pp. 31), pp. 3-28. 
 
 1907. Edward Lambe Parsons. Democracy and a prophetic 
 idealism. Delivered May 21. In Phi Beta Kappa: annual open 
 meeting of the Beta of California Chapter at Stanford University, 
 May 21, 1907 (Printed by the Chapter, 1907, 8vo, pp. 26), 3-21. 
 
 Reprinted in Representative Ph. B. K. orations, Boston, 1915, 8vo, pp. 
 377-94- 
 
 i9e)8r'JosEPH Worcester. The dual nature of all things. De- 
 livered ]\Iay 19. In Phi Beta Kappa : annual open meeting of the 
 
128 Phi Beta Kappa Key March 
 
 Beta of California Chapter at Stanford University, May I0, 
 1908 (Printed by the Chapter, 1909, 8vo, pp. 30), pp. 3-12. 
 
 1909. Horace Davis. A'ocational training. DeHvered May 18. 
 In Phi Beta Kappa, Beta of California Chapter, fifth annual open 
 meeting at Stanford University, May 18, 1909 (Printed by the 
 Chapter, 1910, 8vo, pp. 24), pp. 3-18. 
 
 191 1. Chester Harvey Rcwell. Education and the new 
 democracy. Dehvered May 20. In Piii Beta Kappa, Beta of 
 California Chapter, seventh annual open meeting at Stanford 
 University, May 20, 191 1 (Printed by the Chapter, 191 1, 8vo, pp. 
 
 23), PP- 3-17- 
 
 1912. Alvin Saunders- Johnso-n. An ethical aspect of the 
 
 new industriaHsm. Dehvered May 18. In Phi Beta Kappa, Beta 
 of California: eighth annual open meeting, Stanford University, 
 May 18, 1912 (Printed by the Chapter, 1912, 8vo, pp. 21), pp. 
 
 3-17- 
 
 Also appeared in The Soutli Atlantic Quarterly. January, 1913, xii. i-ii. 
 
 1913. Edward Bull Clapp. Epictetus. Delivered May 18. 
 In Phi Beta Kappa, Beta of California: ninth annual open -meet- 
 ing, Stanford University, May 18, 1913 (Printed by the Chapter, 
 1913, 8vo, pp. 22), pp. 3-16. 
 
 1914. Edwin Holt Hughes. Culture and power. Delivered 
 May 16. In Phi Beta Kappa, Beta of California : tenth annual 
 open meeting, Stanford University, May 16, 1914 (Printed by the 
 Chapter, 1914, 8vo, pp. 26), pp. 3-19. 
 
 1915. Benjamin F. Bledsoe. The new humanism in the law. 
 Delivered May 15. In Phi Beta Kappa, Beta of California: 
 eleventh annual open meeting, Stanford University, May 15, 1915 
 (Printed by the Chapter, 1915, 8vo, pp. 29), pp. 3-22. 
 
 Poems. 
 
 1905. Raymond Macdonald Alden. The golden key: "Phil- 
 osophy the guide of life." Read May 22. In The Key, January, 
 1911, i. 2. 13-15. 
 
 1906. Charles Kellogg Field. Prayer. Read October 13. 
 In Annual open meeting of the Phi Beta Kappa Society at Stan- 
 ford University, October 13, 1906, pp. 29-31. 
 
1917 -^ Phi Beta Kappa Bibliography 129 
 
 1907. Alphonso Gerald Newcomer. Plato passes. Read 
 May 21. In Phi Beta Kappa: annual open meeting of the Beta of 
 California Chapter at Stanford University, May 21, 1907, pp. 
 22-26. 
 
 1908. Charles Augustus Keeler. Ithuriel's spear. Read 
 May 19. In Phi Beta Kappa : annual open meeting of the Beta 
 of California Chapter at Stanford University, May 19, 1908, pp. 
 13-30- 
 
 1909. Clarence Wing. Choral ode to Beauty. Read May 18, 
 In Phi Beta Kappa, Beta of California Cliapter, fifth annual open 
 meeting at Stanford University, May 18, 1909, pp. 19-24. 
 
 1910. Melville Best Anderson. The happy teacher. New 
 York. B. W. Huebsch. 1910. 8vo, pp. 54. 
 
 Read May 21. 
 
 191 1. Henry David Gray. Verses. Read May 20. In Phi 
 Beta Kappa, Beta of California Chapter, seventh annual open 
 meeting at Stanford University, May 20, 191 1, pp. 18-23. 
 
 1912. Frank Walter Weymouth. Earth. Read May 18. 
 In Phi Beta Kappa, Beta of California : eighth annual open meet- 
 ing, Stanford University, May 18, 1912, 8vo, pp. 18-21. 
 
 1913. David Starr Jordan. In the wilderness. Read May 18. 
 In Phi Beta Kappa, Beta of California : ninth annual open meet- 
 ing, Stanford University, May 18, 1913, 8vo, pp. 17-22. 
 
 1914. Irene Hardy. The scholar and the world. Read May 
 16. In Phi Beta Kappa, Beta of California : tenth annual open 
 meeting, Stanford University, May 16, 191 4, 8vo, pp. 21-26. 
 
 191 5. Frank Ernest Hill. The saving fire. Read May 15. 
 In Phi Beta Kappa, Beta of California: eleventh annual open 
 meeting, Stanford University, May 15, 1915, 8vo, pp. 23-29. 
 
 General. 
 
 Orrin Leslie Elliott. See Ph. B. K. Publ., N. S. 3, pp. 
 
 [20-21]. 
 
 See also Ph. B. K. : information resp. institutions that have applied for 
 charters, 1904, p. [i] ; Ph. B. K. Publ, N. S. 2, p. [4] ; and The Key, Jan- 
 uary, 191S, ii. 6. 295-0, January, 1916, ii. 10. 496-7. 
 
130 Phi Beta Kappa Key March 
 
 SWARTHMORE COLLEGE. 
 Epsilon of Pennsylvania. Organized June 9, 1896. 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 1898. Benjamin Ide Wheeler. The Old World in the New. 
 In The Atlantic Monthly, August, 1898, Ixxxii. 145-53. 
 
 1903. Oscar M. Voorhees.. Our Phi Beta Kappa fathers and 
 their fraternity. Substantially as printed in Phi Beta Kappa 
 Publications, N. S. 6, pp. ;i-26. . , >- 
 
 1905. Edwin A. Grosvenor. The evolution of the Russian 
 government. In The National Geographic Magazine, July, 1905, 
 xvi. 309-32. 
 
 1906. Joseph Fitch. Scholar and citizen. In The Swarth- 
 morean, June 6 and 14, 1906. 
 
 1907. Franklin Spencer Edmonds. Ethics and politics. A 
 summary appeared in The Phoenix, 5th month, 1907, xxvi. 121. 
 
 1909. RuFUS M. Jones. The function and value of the de- 
 nominational college. In The American Friend, 8th month 12, 
 1909. 
 
 Poems 
 
 1904. J. Russell Hayes. The scholar's ideal. In The Friends' 
 Intelligencer and Journal, 6th month 11, 1904. 
 
 1906. Ferris W. Price. Libertino patre natum: an Horatian 
 reverie. In The Swarthmorean, October 11, 1906. 
 
 1907. Elizabeth Powell Bond. Blest of the gods. In The 
 Phoenix, May, 1907, xxvi. 120-1. 
 
 John Russell Hayes. Golden volumes. Read on the same 
 occasion. In same, p. 123. 
 
 1908. Wilbur Macey Stine. The souls of peace — a sonnet 
 series. Some of the sonnets appeared in Croivn of toil, a book 
 of sonnets, Philadelphia, The Acorn Press, 1910, i2mo, pp. vii. 
 120. 
 
 1909. Mary Wolverton Green. The spirit of peace. In The 
 Friends' Intelligencer and Journal, 5th month 15, 1909. 
 
 General. 
 Abby Mary Hall (now Mrs. C. Roberts). See Ph. B. K 
 PmR, N. S. 3, p. [15]. 
 See also Ph. B. K. bulletin of information, 1903, p. [4]. 
 {To be Continued.) 
 
Volume 3 
 
 Number 4 
 
 Contents 
 
 Paae 
 
 Dr. Hale's Contribution to Phi Beta Kappa History 147 
 A Fossil From the Tertiary . . . . 1 52 
 
 The Sword of Lafayette— Poem . ' 
 The Bronze Liberty — Poem 
 Princeton Phi Beta K^appa. Activities 
 Randolph-Macon Woman's College 
 The Delta of Virginia Instituted 
 A Phi Beta Kappa Bibliography 
 InMemoriam . . . . '. 
 Phi Beta Kappa News and Notes 
 
 156 
 158 
 459 
 165 
 174 
 177 
 182 
 187 
 
 
 RANDOLPH-MACON CHAPTER NUMBER 
 
 MAY, 1917 
 
The Phi B^ta Kappa Fraternity 
 
 DIRECTORY OF CHAPTERS 
 
 , with number In the order of est?,bUshinent, the Saprete,F3^, and date. 
 
 12 Alabama — ^Alpha pf Alabama, TJnIversity, Prof. J. J. jDoster. -A-'II- • • , 1851 ; 
 
 5i. Allegheny— ^ta. of Pennsylvania, Meadville, Pr6f> W, A. Elliott, L. K.p 1902 
 
 13 Amherst — Beta of Massachusetts, "Amherst .1853 
 
 89 Sates — ^Ganima of Maine, Lewistown, Prof. Arthur N. Leonard, Ph. D .1917 
 
 T8 BeloU — Beta of Wisconsin, Beloit, Prof. ErastijS G. Siiiith, pfi. D l^lly. 
 
 46 Boston— Epsilon of Massachusetts, Boston, Ada A. Cole, -PK B". , 1899 
 
 -6 Bowdoin — ^Alpha of Maine, &unsvl<d£, Pro£,Geo. T. Files/ Ph. D.... 1825 
 
 1 Brown — ^Alpha of Rhode Island, jrovidence, Prof, James Q. Dealey, Ph. D....18S0 
 
 43 California — ^Alpha of California, Berkeley, Prof. Percivar-B. Fay, ^. D .1898 
 
 82 Carleton — Beta of Minnesota, Nortbfleld, Prof. Curvta H. Gingrich, Ph'D. .. .1914, 
 
 51 CfticaffO— Beta off Illinois, Chicago, Prof . -Francis W. Shepardson, LL. D. 1899 
 
 48 Cincinnati, — Delta ot,Ohio, Cincinnati, Mrs.. H. G. Hartmann, B. L..... .1899. 
 
 39 Co;6i/—Bd'ta. of Maine, TVatM^Ule, Prof. J.'Willlam BlafcK, Ph.\I5, . . .i. ^. ;.1896 
 
 .24 CoZffate-^Eta of New.Tork, Hamilton, Prof. F. C. French, Fk-^t). , , ..;... ..i. .1878 
 
 65 Colorag.0 University — Alpha of Colorado, Boulder, Prof. F. Ramaley, Ph.D. .. .1904. 
 
 59 OoJoraeio OoEIeper— Beta of Colorado, Colorado Sprirfgs, ProfwH. E. Woodbridge, 
 
 ' M. A v................ ..1904, 
 
 21 CoJMmftia^pfelta of New York, New York City, Clarence, A. Manning, Ph. D.. .1869 . 
 
 25 Cornell — ^Theta of New T6»k, Ithaca, Albett LeRoy Andrpwa, Ph,,D 1882 
 
 4 Z)artmo«t?8-^Alpha of New Hampshire, Hanover^ Harold G, Rugg, A. B;...i787 
 74, BeAjsoM— Theta of Ohio, Sranvilje, Prof., W. A. 'Ghamberlin, ph. Dy ......... .1911' 
 
 29 Be Pauw — Alpha of Indiana, Greertcastle, Prof. A, F. ■ Cauldwell, A. M.......i889 
 
 26 D<cfcin*o*i— Alpha of Pennsylvania, Carlisle, Prof. John P. Mo^ler, Ph. jS 1887 
 
 69 Uranlclin and iWorsftoZZ-^Theta of Pennsylvania, Lanpaster, Prof. A. Thomas G. 
 
 L Ajiple, Ph. t)^, ..,..../. ...^ ......;. ..,.;'..,.. ...:.-,,,...".....'.., .1903 
 
 81 Georgia — Alpha of Georgia, Athens, Prof. W. D. Hooper, A. M. .i;,, '. . 1914- 
 
 64 Qoucher — Beta of MarylaJiidj Baltimore, Miss Edna 'FrScTm^ii, -X. B.. . 1 . . . .1905 
 
 70,Cfrinnell — Beta -of Iowa, ■ Grinnell, P(gf. Ca*oline, Sheldon',, A. M, , . , ,i. . . . . .1908 
 
 iZ Hamilton — Epsilon of New York, Clinton,' Prof . J, D. ' I*bptsoi>, jr.. A.- M 1870 
 
 5 Harvard— Alvha, of MsCsSachuset^, fcanttbridge, William C, Lane, A. B. . . i. .I'Jsi j 
 
 44 Hd-yer/ord—^Zeta of. Pennsylvania, Haverford; Prof. L. W. Reid, Ph., t). !......, .1890 
 
 ZiiJSobart — Ze'ta of ySew York, GerieV^, t'rof . Willis P. Woodman, Pb.' D. . . . .-..,1871 
 
 67 IlUnois — Gamma of .IlIinois,~Urbah4i, Prof. Jacob Zeitlin, Ph. D. 1^07 
 
 75 /ndiamo-^^Garama of Indiana, Bloomjngton, Prof. F. W. TlMen, A. M ....1911 
 
 36 Iowa — Alpha of iQwaf Iowa .>City, l^jss Beryl G. Hart,. A. M. , . . . ,. .1895 
 
 37.rohW ffojifcjms— Alpha of Maryland, Baltimore, pr&f. John C. French,'Ph. D. iiS95 
 
 31 p:ansas — Alpha of Kansas, Lawrence, PrOK B. D. Cressman, Ph. D .1890 
 
 14 Kenyon — Beta of Ohio, Gambler, William Cljnton Seitz, Al B ;,..... .'.1858 - 
 
 , 87 Knox — iDelta of IHinois, Galesburg, Prof. James A. Campbell, A. M. ...'.. ..1917 
 
 32 Lafayette — Giannna of PehnSylva-nia, Easton, Prof. Vm. S. Hall, Ph. D. . 1 1890 
 
 79 Lawrence — Gamma of "^Wisconsin, Appleton, Prof. Louis A. Toutz, Pli. D .1914 
 
 27 Lehigh — Beta of Pennsylvania, South Bethlehem, Prof. C, L. Tho^nburg, Ph. D.1887 
 
 16 Marietta-^Ga-mma. of Ohid, Marietta, Prof. Arthur G.Beach, A/ M 1860 
 
 77 Miami— Iota, of Ohio, Oxford, Prof. Harlan Schwab, B. A...... ,. . 1911 
 
 68 Michigan — Alpha of Michigan. Ann Arbor, Prof. Johp G. Wiilter, Ph. D.. ....1907 
 
 19 Middlebury— Beta, of Vermont, Middlebupy, Prof. Chas. fe. Wright, Litt. D..,-.'.1863 
 35 Mimnesoia — Alpha pf Miiine'sota, Minneapolis; William H. BUssey, Ph. D..:.-..1892 
 53 Missouri — Alpha of Missouri, Columbia, Prof. Guy B, Colburn, Ph. D. ...... .1901' 
 
 62 Mt. Solyoke—*rbeta. of Massachusetts, South Hadley, Asso. 'Prof; Margare.t, S. i 
 
 Morriss, Ph. D. .,..., .^. '. . . . . , 1906 
 
1917 ^ ■^''^** Beta Kappa Bibliography 177 
 
 for scholarly and earnest study vivified by emotional appreciation 
 of the subject. He concluded that the classics, especially Greek, 
 are best fitted as a medium for the larger education, as they by 
 their restraint, purity, and other qualities are fitted to give the 
 universal expression which modern literature lacks. Finally he 
 held up as an ideal the love of knowledge as he had defined it, a 
 philosophia which may well, in truth, be the guide of life. The 
 prolonged applause that greeted the end of Dr. Shorey's address 
 was a remarkable tribute to his ability and personality. 
 
 After the singing of "The Star Spangled Banner" by the au- 
 dience. Dr. Booker pronounced the benediction. 
 
 A PHI BETA KAPPA BIBLIOGRAPHY 
 
 By Prof. Clark S. Northup, Cornell '93 
 
 {Continued from page 130). 
 
 SYRACUSE UNIVERSITY. 
 
 Kappa of New York. Organized February id, 1896. 
 
 Catalogues. 
 
 1905. 8vo, pp. 58. 
 
 1907. (Men and days in Phi Beta Kappa, by Arthur Cope- 
 land), 8vo, pp. 143. 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 
 191 5. David Jayne Hill. The American conception of the 
 state. Delivered March 12. In part printed in The Syracuse 
 Post-Standard, March 13, 1915. 
 
 Published in full in his . huericanism, what it is, New York, Appleton, 
 1916, 8vo, pp. [1-46]. 
 
 General. 
 
 Edgar C. Morris. See Ph. B. K. Publ., N. S. 3, pp. [14-15]. 
 
 THE UNIVERSITY OF TEXAS. 
 
 Alpha of Texas. Organized February 2, 1905. 
 
 Catalogues. 
 
 [1905. J i6mo, pp. II. [1913-] 8vo, pp. 42. 
 
i;/8 Phi Beta Kappa Key May 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 
 1908. Edwin W Fay. Address delivered to the initiates of 
 Phi Beta Kappa, ]\Iay 21, 1908. In The University of Texas 
 Record, June, 1908, viii. 116-119. 
 
 General. 
 
 Sylvester Prijier. The Alpha Chapter of the Phi Beta 
 Kappa Society in the State of Texas, the University of Texas, 
 Austin, Texas. In The Uiiiz'ersity of Texas Record, August, 
 1905, vi. 107-13. 
 
 Also reprinted, 8vo, pp. 8. 
 
 . Phi Beta Kappa. [An undated circular.] 8vo, pp. 3. 
 
 See also Ph. B. /v.: information rcsp. institutions that have applied for 
 charters, 1904, pp. 2-3; Ph. B. K. Puhl, N. S. 2, p. [8], N. S. 3, pp. [22-23]. 
 
 TRINITY COLLEGE. 
 
 Beta of Connecticut. Organized July 2, 1845. 
 
 Catalogues. 
 
 1853. 8vo, pp. 21-24, 3-t the end of Air. Harwood's oration; 
 see below. 1895. 8vo, pp. 36. 1905. 8vo, pp. 43. 191 5. 8vo, 
 pp. 48. 
 
 Nlcticed in The Key, Oct., 1915, ii. 9. 452. 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 
 1S51. Thomas M. Clark. See below under Union Orations 
 and Addresses, 1851. 
 
 1852. AIark Anthony DeWolfe Howe. Public opinion, 
 directed and impelled by conflicting influences. An oration, de- 
 livered before the Connecticut Beta of the Phi Beta Kappa So- 
 ciety, in Christ Church, Hartford, July 28, 1852. Published by 
 request of the Society. Hartford. S. Hanmer & Co. — Calendar 
 Press. 1852. 8vo, pp. 18. 
 
 1853. Edwin Harwood. The relation of the Incarnation to 
 the progress of human thought. An oration before the Con- 
 necticut Beta of the Phi Beta Kappa, at Trinity College, Hart- 
 ford, July 2y, 1853. Hartford : Press of Case, Tiffany and Com- 
 
1917 '4 Phi Beta Kappa Bibliography 179 
 
 pany. 1853. 8vo, pp. 20. Followed by: Catalogue of the officers 
 and members of the Connecticut Beta of the Phi Beta Kappa, 
 which received its charter June 16, 1845. Pp- 21-24. 
 
 1856. Benjamin Apthorp Gould, Jr. An American uni- 
 versity. An oration before the Connecticut Beta of the Phi Beta 
 Kappa Fraternity at Trinity College; Hartford, 1856, July 15. 
 Hartford. Case, Tiffany and Co. 1856. 8vo, pp. 32. 
 
 See comment in The Key, Jan., 1916, ii. 10. 462-7. 
 
 1868. William Rudder. The mutual relations of natural 
 science and theology. An oration pronounced before the Con- 
 necticut Beta of the Phi Beta Kappa Society, in Christ Church, 
 Hartford, Conn., July 7th, 1868. Philadelphia. Henry B. Ash- 
 mead. 1869. 8vo, pp. 48. 
 
 1871. Noah Porter. The sciences of nature versus the 
 science of man. New York. Dodd & Mead. 1871. i2mo, pp. 
 98. "Portions of the following essay were delivered as an ad-- 
 dress, before the societies of Ph. B. K., at Harvard and Trinity 
 Colleges, in June and July last." 
 
 Also 'in Science and sentiment, with other essays, New York, 1882, 
 pp. 38-76. 
 
 General. 
 
 Samuel Hart. In Ph. B. K. Publ., N. S. 3, p. [6]. 
 
 . In The Key, March, 1914, ii. 3. 101-2. Portrait. 
 
 . The Beta of Connecticut. In The Key, March, 1914, 
 
 ii. 3. 111-15. lUus. 
 
 For the charter see The Key ii. 3. 107-g. 
 
 TUFTS COLLEGE. 
 
 Delta of Massachusetts. Organized November 18, 1892, 
 
 Catalogues. 
 
 1910. 8vo, pp. 38. 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 
 1901. Bliss Perry. The amateur spirit. Delivered June 18. 
 See Columbia Orations and Addresses, 1901. 
 
 1903. Samuel Walker McCall. The scholar in politics a 
 
i8o Phi Beta Kappa Key May 
 
 conservative. Delivered June i6. In The Tufts College Gradu- 
 ate i. 2. 32-44. 
 Also reprinted, i2mo, pp. 15. 
 
 1904. Frank Benjamin Sanborn. American education be- 
 fore and after George Washington. Delivered June 14. In The 
 Tufts College Graduate ii. 2. 65-84. 
 
 1905. Henry Blanchard. The seat of learning the helper 
 of the Hfe of the spirit. Delivered June 19. In The Tufts Col- 
 lege Graduate iii. 2. 60-76. 
 
 1907. Albert Bushnell Hart, The hope of democracy. De- 
 livered June 18. In The Tufts College Graduate, July, 1907, v. 
 
 2. 57-73- 
 
 Also in his National ideals historically traced, 1607-1907, New York,. 
 Harper & Bros., 1907 (vol. xxvi. of The A^nerican nation, a history), pp. 
 341-60. Also in Representative Ph. B. K. orations, Boston, Houghboa 
 Mifflin Co., 191S, 8vo, pp. 362-76. 
 
 1908. George Thompson Knight. Culture and humanity. 
 Delivered June 16. In The Tufts College Graduate vi. 2. 56-76. 
 
 1909. Curtis Guild, Jr. The soldier of peace. Delivered 
 May 5. In The Tufts College Graduate vii. 2. 49-58. 
 
 1913. Philip Stafford Moxom. The educated man. De- 
 livered May 7. 
 
 This is substanitially the samie as Dr. Moxom's commenoement address at 
 Atlanta University, May 26, 1910, which wias published as Atlanta Univer- 
 sity Leaflet no. 25, 32010, pp. 24. 
 
 iPoEMS. 
 
 1902. Oscar Fay Adams. Sicut patribus. [A poem read at 
 the annual meeting of Tufts Chapter, Phi Beta Kappa, June 17, 
 1902.] [Boston. New England Anti-Imperialist League. 1902. J 
 8vo, pp. [8]. 
 
 1903. Henry Nehemiah Dodge. The mystery of the West. 
 Read June 16. In The Tufts College Graduate i. 2. 20-32. 
 
 1905. DwiGHT MuNSON HoDGE. Das Gemeine. Read June 
 19. In The Tufts College Graduate iii. 2. 76-81. 
 
 1906. James Harcourt West. Man's triumph-era. Read 
 June 18. In The Tufts College Graduate iv. 2. 59-75. 
 
 Selections were reprinted jn The Key, Oct., 1914, ii. 5. 221-3. Printed 
 in full in his Pnenis of human progress and other pieces, Boston, Th;» 
 
^91/ A Phi Beta Kappa Bibliography i8i 
 
 Tufts College Press, 1914, 8vo, pp. 3-26. See The Key, Oct., 1914, ii. 5. 
 259-60. 
 
 1909. Frederick Allison Tupper. The golden carillon. Read 
 May 5. In The Tufts College Graduate vii. 2. 58-66. 
 
 1910. Percy Mackaye. Tennyson. Read May 11. In his 
 Poems and Plays l, New York, Macmillan, 1916. The Sistine 
 Eve and other poems, pp. 16-20. 
 
 1912. John Albert Macy. The voices of the books. Read 
 May 8. In The Tufts College Graduate, July, 1912, x. no. 4. 
 
 1913. Robert Haven Shauffler. The crucible. Read May 
 7- 
 
 1915. Robert Frost. The road not taken. The. sound of 
 trees. Birches. Read May 5. In The Atlantic Monthly, August, 
 1915, cxvi. 221-4. 
 
 The first two were reprinted in Current Opinion. Sept., 1915, lix. 199. 
 The first was reprinted in The Literary Digest, Diec. 4, 1915, Ii. 1302. 
 
 General. 
 Frank G. Wren. See Ph. B. K. Publ., N. S. 3, p. [13]. 
 
 TULANE UNIVERSITY OF LOUISIANA 
 
 Alpha of Louisiana. Organized February 26, 1909. 
 
 Catalogues. 
 
 1912. Sm. 8vo, pp. 23. 1914. Sm. 8vo, pp. 16. 
 
 Orations and Addresses 
 
 1911. Edward Asahel Birge. Science and wisdom. An ad- 
 dress delivered before the Phi Beta Kappa Society, Alpha of 
 Louisiana, Tulane University, May 15, 1911. Published by the 
 Society. New Orleans. 191 1. 8vo, pp. 23. 
 
 Also delivered before the Grinnell Chapter. 
 
 1912. Edwin Whitfield Fay. Culture in education. Deliv- 
 ered May 27. In The Tulane Graduates' Magazine, July, 19 12, 
 i. 91-108. 
 
 Also, as delivered in an earlier form, in The University of Texas Rec- 
 ord xi. 357-69. 
 
 (To be Continued.) 
 
IN MEMORIAM 
 
 Wayne MacVeagh, LL.D., Yale '53, died at his home, Washington, 
 D. C, January 11, 1917, in his eighty-third year. He was born in Penn- 
 sylvania and began the prcatice of law in Chester County, where he was 
 District Attorney from 1859 to 1864. He saw service in the Civil War as 
 Captain of Infantry in 1862 and Captain of Cavalry in 1863, when the in- 
 vasion of Pennsylvania was threatened. President Grant appointed him 
 Minister to Turkey in 1870. He remained abroad a year, and in 1872 be- 
 came a member of the Pennsylvania Constitutional Convention. In 1877 
 President Hayes sent him to Louisiana as head of a commission to en- 
 deavor to adjust disputes of contending parties. President Garfield ap- 
 pointed him Attorney-General of the United States in 1881, but he re- 
 signed on the accession of President Arthur and resumed the practice of 
 law in Philadelphia. President Cleveland in 1893 appointed him Ambassa- 
 dor to Italy, where he remained four years. In 1903 he was chief counsel 
 for the United States in the Venezuela Arbitration before the Hague Tri- 
 bunal. He wrote much in favor of international peace. Amherst con- 
 ferred the LL.D. in 1881, as did the University of Pennsylvania in 1897, 
 and Harvard in 1901. A widow and three children survive; also his 
 brother, Franklin MacVeagh, Yale '62, Secretary of the Treasury in the 
 cabinet of President Taft. 
 
 RiCHAED Olney, LL.D., Brown '56, died at his home, Boston, Mass., 
 April 8, 1917, in his eighty-second year. A native of Massachusetts, Mr. 
 Olney returned after graduation to his native state, studied law at Har- 
 vard, and had practiced law in Boston since his admission to the bar in 
 1859, except four years during which he served in President Cleveland's 
 cabinet as Attorney-General, 1893-95, and Secretary of State, 1895-97. His 
 only other public service was as member of the Massachusetts House of 
 Representatives in 1874. In 1913 he declined appointment as Ambassador 
 to England ; and in 1914, the governorship of the Federal Reserve Board. 
 The following year, however, he accepted membership for the United 
 States on an International Commission under treaty with France. He was 
 for a term a fellow of Brown University, and was regent of the Smith- 
 sonian Institute, 1900-08. He was also a member of the Massachusetts His- 
 torical Society and the American Philosophical Society. Harvard in 1893, 
 Brown in 1893, and Yale in 1900, conferred the LL.D. His most conspic- 
 uous service as Secretary of State was his insistence that Great Britain 
 arbitrate claims with Venezuela. 
 
 Samuel Dickson, LL.D., Pennsylvania '55, died suddenly from an attack 
 of heart disease at his home in Philadelphia, May 28, 1915, in his seventy- 
 ninth year. He was a native of Newburgh, N. Y., and was valedictorian of 
 his class. After his graduation he studied law, and was admitted to the 
 
 182 
 
Volume 3 
 
 Numbers 6 and 7 
 
 Contents 
 
 P«Be 
 
 From Alice of Monmouth — A Poem . . 243 
 
 Cent«iary of the Alpha of New York . 244 
 
 A Plea for the Humanities — An Oration .. / 245 
 
 -ReunionOde . . . . . 253 
 
 Patriotism in Am^can Colleges . . . -254 
 
 Our Country's Call>^-A Poem . . . 255 
 
 The Beta of New York at Nfew York University . 256 
 
 Breaking a Precedent in Chapter Organization 271 
 To Our Captain' — A Poem . ., i .273 
 
 The Delta of New York at Columbia University 273 
 
 Thrfee Distinguished College Presidents . . 286 
 
 A Fossil From the Tertiar^— Concluded . . 292- 
 
 A Phi Beta Kappa Bibliograj^y— Continued ., 300 
 
 In Memorial . . . * . 308 
 Phi Beta Kappa News and Notes . . .316 
 
 JANUARY and MARCH, 1918 
 
The Ph! Beta Kappa Fraternity 
 
 DIRECTORY OF CHAI^TERS 
 
 With number In the order of establishment, the Secretai*y, and date. ' 
 
 12 Alabama'— Alpha of Alabama,' University, l>rof^ J. JL.Doster, A. U .1861 
 
 S4 Alleghenv— Eta. of Pennsylvania, MeadviHe, Prof. W. A. Elliott, L. Hi. D.'. . .1902 
 
 13 Amherst-:-Beta. of Massachusetts, Amher^, Prof. Charles B. Bennett, Ph. D. . .1853 
 89 Bates — Qamiina of MalneV Lewiaton. Prof. Arthur N. Leonard, Ph. D .1917 
 
 78 Beloit^— Beta o;r Wisconsin, Beloit, Prof. Erastua-G. Smith, Fh« D. .......... .1911 
 
 4-6 Boston — Bpsilon.Of Massachusetts, Bostbn, Ada A. Cole, Ph, B. ...;.,.?..... .l»»9i 
 
 6 BowdoiH — ^Alpha of Maine, Brunswick, Prof, Geo. T. Files, Ph. it . .'. 1826 
 
 7 Brown — ^Alpha of Rhode Island, Providence, Prof, Barnes Q, Dealey, P&, D. . . ,1830 
 
 43 Cali/omfo— Alpha of California, Berkeley,\Prof . PercivaJ B. Pay, Ph. b.,....189l 
 82 Carleton — Beta of Minnesota, Northfleld, Profi Curvin H. Gingrich, Ph. D....1914 
 Bl^OWcoffO — ^Beta of Illinois, ChlcaKpi trof. Francis W. Shepardspn, IiLr. D... ..1899 
 48 Cindinnati — ^Delta of Ohio,, Cincinnati, Mi^s Helen A. Stanley, 3676 Zumsteln 
 
 Ave. ..:;:.. i '. ..,./..;. .1899 
 
 29 Colfty— Beta of Maine, Waterville, Prof. J. WiHiain Blick, Ph. Di.. ,i*.189« 
 
 *4 CoIffote-^Etft of New York, Hami]|tOn, Prof. P. C. French, Ph. D 187» 
 
 E5 Colorado XJniversitji — ^Alpha of Colorado, Houlder,. Prof. ^. Ramaley, Ph. C.,.1904 
 69 Colorado College — Beta of Coloradd, Colorado Springs, Pnjf. Albert R. BlWftg- 
 
 wood, B. C. L... ; , . . , ,. . . .,..,.. ..'. 1901 
 
 21 CotemBiO'-Delta of New Tork, New York City, Edward Gluclt, A. B ...1869 
 
 25 Cornell — Theta of New York, Ithaca, Albert IfeRoy. Andrews^ Ph.,D. r^. .. .. . ..1882 
 
 4 Dortmowtft— Alpha of New Hampshire^ Hanover, Harold G. Bugg, A. B.... 1787 
 
 74 Uenisojt— Theta of Ohio, Gra.nVille, Prof. W; A. Chamber/ini, Plk !>.''..,..■.,.. 1911 
 29 De'Pauw — ^Alpha of Indiana, Greencastle, Prof. A.. P. Cauldwell,,^ M.. .....1889 
 
 26 Dickinson — ^Alpha Of Pennsylvania, Carlisle, PrSf. John F. l&abibT, Ph. I> 1887 
 
 69 Frdnklin and Marshall — Theta of Pennsylvania, Lancaster, , Prpf. W. E. Weis-- 
 
 gerber, Ph. M .^. .. i ..-........_..'..'............ .i .1903 
 
 81 Oeo^flJo-^Alpha of Georgia, Athens, Prof. W. D. Hooper, A. M. ...... ,"".ii... .. .1914 
 
 64 Goitcfter-^Beta of Maryland, Baltimore, Miss Edna P. Sohwara, 'A. B.. , , . . . .1905 
 
 70 Grinnell — Beta of iQwa, Grinhell, Prof. Caroline ' Sheldon, ; A. M. ...,;.;.,. .1908 
 - 22 Bamilton — ^^Epsilon of New Yof'k, Clinton, Prof , J. D. Ibbofson, Jr., A. M....187fl 
 
 3 Harvard — ^Alpha of Massachusetts, Cambridge, WllHam C. LanS, A. B. .-. ...1781 
 
 44 Haverford — Zeta of Pennsylvania, Hayerfbrd, Prof; L.-W. Iteid, Ph. D. . . .... ,1890 
 
 23 Boidrt—Zeta, of New York, Geneva, ;P>of. Willis P. Wpodman.Ph, D. ...■;..; 1871 
 
 67 Illinois; — Gamma of Illinois, Urbana," Pj-of. Jacob Zeltliij;: Ph. D, ............ . .1907 
 
 75 Indiana— rGsiTonma. pf Indiana, ^loomingtoh, Miss Kat^Prlne Basley, A. B 1911 
 
 36 Iowa — ^Aipha of Ipyita, Iowa City; Miss Hertha ~L. Vos^Ph; ;B: .... 1 . i .... t.. .^**^ 
 
 37 Johns Bopkins-^Alpba, of Maryland, 'fealtimore. Prof. John d, French, Ph. D.,1896j, 
 31 Kansas — ^Alpha of Kansas, 'I,awrdnce;; Prof. J. G. Brandt, Ph. D...... .1890 
 
 14 Kenyonr-^B&ta, of Ohio, Gambler, Luth^r'H.-Tate. ...... . , , .,,. .1868 
 
 87 Knox — ^Delta of Illinois, Galesburg, Prof. Ja^es A. Campbell, A.- M . , . .V'i . - 191T 
 
 ^42 Lafayette — Gamma of Pennsylvania,^ Easton, Prof . Wm. S. Hall, Ph. D. .'.IV-'tlSSO 
 
 79 Laiorence — Gamma of Wisconsin, Appleton. frPf. Loiiis C. Baker, Ph., D. . . '. /.'.lOli 
 
 27 ieftix/TiT-Beta of Pennsylvania,," South Bethlehem, Prof. C. L. Thornburg, Ph. D.188T 
 16 Marietta — GftWima pf Ohio, Marietta, Miss Mary, S. Newton. ... i ............. .i860 
 
 TT Mianii — ipta, Pf Ohip, Gxfprd, Prpf. -Harlan Schwab, B. A.:, ........ .-v.. .... .1911 
 
 68 Michigan — Alpha pf Michigan, Ann ArbPr; Prof. J. "Vp. SchPll, Ph. D. . .\>>. /, .1907 
 19 Middlebury — Beta of Vermont, Middlebury, Prof. phas. B. Wright; Lltt. D....1863 
 35 Minnesota — Alpha of Minnesota, Minriestpplis, Frederic K. Butters,, Ph. D. . , . .1892 
 es Missouri — Alpha pf Misspuri,. CPlumbla, Prpf, Guy B. Cplbum,- Plu^ D. . . .. . . .1901 
 
 ( Ponolmled on third page of cover) 
 
Volume 3 
 
 \'. 
 
 Numbers 6 and 7 
 
 Contents 
 
 From AKce of iMomnouth-^A Poem 
 
 Centenary of the Alpha of New York 
 
 A Plea for. the Humaniti^ — An Oration ^ 
 
 Rewu<»i Ode . .. . v • 
 
 Patriotism in American Colleges . 
 
 Oiir Country's Call— A Poem . . . 
 
 The Belaof New York at New York University , 
 
 Breaking a Precedent in Chapter Oi^ganization 
 
 To Our Captain — ^A Poem .'' . . 
 
 The Delta of New York at Columbia University 
 
 -Three Distinguished College Presidents . 
 
 A Fossil From the Tertiary-— Concluded . 
 
 A'Phi Beta Kappa Bibliojgrapy — Continued 
 
 InMemoriattt • . . 
 
 IHii Beta Kappa News and Notes . . ~ ; 
 
 \ 
 
 Page 
 
 243 
 244 
 245 
 253 
 254 
 255 
 256 
 271 
 273 
 273 
 286 
 292 
 300 
 308 
 316, 
 
 JANUARY and MARCH, 1918 
 
 j HJ..^ 
 
The Phi Beta Kappa Fraternity 
 
 DIRECTORY OF CHAPTERS- 
 
 With number in the order of i^tablisltment, the Secretary, s,n4 date. 
 
 '12 Alabama — ^Alphi^ of Alabtima, University, Prof. J. J. Doster, A. M.... 1851 
 
 54 Alleghenv— Eta. of Pennsylvania, MeadvlIIe, Prof. W. A. Elliott, L. H. D 1902 , 
 
 13 Amherst — Beta of Massachusetts, Amherst, Prof. Charles E. Bennett, Ph. D...1863 
 89 Bates — Gamma of Matoei, Lewlaton. Pi-of. Arthur N. Leonard, Ph. !D, .'^. . .1917 
 
 78 BeiiWt— Beta of Wisconsin, Belolt, Prof. B|;astus G. Smith, Ph. D r, ...1911 
 
 46 jBostbn-^Epsllon of Massachusetts, Boston, A^ A. Cole, Ph. B. ...... ..r; .. .1899 
 
 6 Sowdpinr^Alpha. of Maine, Brunswick, Prof. Geo. T. Files, Ph. b. ......... . .182S 
 
 7 Brown — ^Alpha of Rhode Island, Providence, I'rof. j'anies Q. Dealey, Ph. V.,. .1830 " 
 
 43 CoK/oT-nio— A^pha- of California, Berkeley, Prof. Percival B. Fay, Ph. iD ..ISSi 
 
 82 OorletojtT-fieta of Minnesota, Northfleld, Prof. Curyln H. Gingrich, Ph. D. ...1914 
 51 CWcoffo— ^Beta of Illinois) Chicago, Prof. Francis ^W. Shepardson, LL. D... ..1899 
 48 Cincmnati — -Delta df Ohio, Cincinnati, Miss Helen A. Stanley, 357fi 2umstein 
 
 Ave. .',;*,. ; 1899 
 
 39 Colby— Beta, of Maine, Watervllle, Prof. J. WillUtm Black, Ph. D. . . . ; 1896 
 
 24 Colgate — Eta of New York, Hamilton, Jrof. F. C. Fren61i,^Ph. D. . . . . ., 1878 
 
 55 Colorado University — ^Alpha of Colorado, Boulder, Prof. F. Hamaley, Ph. I>>...19d4, 
 59 Coloraplo College — Beta of Colorado, Colorado Springs, Prof, Albert R. Elllng- 
 
 /wobd, B. C; L.. . . . .,. .'. . .,. .7., . .-.' , . . .1904 
 
 21 OdteniMo— Delta of New York, New York City, Edward Glnck,.-A. B. ... ; . ^. .1869 
 .25 OorneW-rTbeta of New York, Ithaca, Albei^t LeRoy Andrews, Ph. D. li82 . 
 
 4 DortmoMfft-rAlpha of New Hampshire, Hanover^ Harold G. Rvigg, A. B....1787 
 
 74 Denison — Theta of Ohio, Granville, Prof. W. A. Chamberllh, Ph. D-. /'.ISrJ. 
 
 29 De PavM — ^Alpha of Indiana, Greencastle, Prof. A. F. Cauldwell, A. 1^.. .. .. .1889 
 
 26 DJoftJnson— Alpha of Pennsylvania, Carlisle, Prof. John F. Mohler^Ph. p. ...1887 
 69 Pranklin and MarsHatU—Thetsi. of Pennsylvania, Lancaster, Prof . W, B. Weis- ;^^' 
 
 gerber, Ph. Si , : ^ .......,,' /.... .1903 
 
 81 Georoio.— Alpha of Georgia, Atljens, Prof. W. D, Hooper, A. M ........ . .-. . '» . . . 1914 , 
 
 64 GoMcfter— Beta of Maryland; Baltimore, Miss Edna F. Sbhwarz, A. .B.-. il905" 
 
 70, Grm«elZ^Beta of lowa^ Grinnell, Prof. Caroline Sheldon, A. M. ...j. 19,08 
 
 22 Samilto^ — Epsilon of Jsfew'York, Clinton, Prof. J. D. Ibbot^on, Jr., A. M.. ..1870 
 3. Harvard^— Alpha of Massachusetts, Canibridge, WlUiara C. Lane, A. B 1781 
 
 44 Hover/orif-^Zeta, of Penijsylvania, Haverford, Prof. L. W. Reld, Ph. D. . . . ... .1890 
 
 23 ffo&or^— Zeta 6^ New YorkPOeneva, Prof. Willis P. Woodman, Ph. D. . . ,. . ..1871 
 
 67 IZZMmis— Gamhia of Illinois, Urbana, Prof. Jacob Zel;tHn, Ph. D..,., ,.....^1907 
 
 ,75 Indiana — €lamma of Indiana, Bloomlngtonj Mis^ Katherine Easley, A. B. . . . . . .1911 
 
 36 lotua— Alpha of lowa, Iowa. City, Miss Hertha L. Voss, Ph. B. ..-/;. 1895 
 
 37 Johns Hopki'iis — A-lpha of Maryland, Baltimore, Prof. John Ci French, Ph.^'D. .1896 
 
 31 Konsffls-^Alpha of Kansas, Lawrence, Prof. J. G. Brandt,, Ph. D ....1890 
 
 14 Ken j/oM— Beta of Ohio,' Gambler, Luther H. Tate . . . i .;..;, 1858 
 
 il Knox — ^Delta of JUinois, Qa'lesburg, plrof. James Al Campbell, A. , M ....... . 1917 
 
 32 Lafayette— <isi,mia& ot Pennsylvania, Baston, Prof. Wnk ?. Hall, Pli. D. . ..i. .189(J 
 
 79 Lawrenke — Gamma of'Wisconsin, Appleton, Prof. Louis C. Baker, Ph. D......1914 
 
 27 Lehigh — Beta , of Pennsylvania, South Bethlehem, Prof. C. L. Thornburg, Ph. D.1887 
 
 16 Marietta — Gamma of Ohio, Marietta, Miss Mary S. Newton .i.860 
 
 IT Miami— tota, of Ohio, Oxford, Pfof. Harlan Schwab, B. A .1911 
 
 68 JfficTiJffom— Alpha of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Prof. J. W. Scholl, Ph. D ......1907 
 
 19 Middlehurjf-r-Beta, of Vermont, Middlebury, Prof., Chas. B. Wright, Lltt B/-, . .^1863 
 35 Minnesota — Alpha of Minnesota, Minneapolis, Frederic K. Butters; Ph. D... . .' .1892 
 F3 Missouri — Alpha Of Missouri, Columbia, Trof. Guy Bt Colburn, Ph. D/. . ,. . ..1901 
 
 (Concluded on third page of cover) 
 
19^8 ^ Fossil from- the Tertiary 299 
 
 like them, and withdraw, do you engage on the honor of gentlemen to 
 keep them secret? 
 
 "Second. Is it of your own free choice that you offer to become mem- 
 bers of this society? 
 
 "Third. Will you approve yourselves worthy members of it by encour- 
 aging friendship, morality, and literature? 
 
 "Fourth. Will you regard the members of this society as your brethren? 
 
 "Fifth. Will you kindly assist them if you should ever see any of them 
 in distress?"* 
 
 There was once a Betaf (second state chapter) of Phi Beta 
 Kappa at Hampden-Sidney, Va. It is now extinct, and, on the 
 spot, forgotten. The Dartmouth branch was established in 1787, 
 and in 1790 a charter was refused to Brown, simply on the 
 ground that the Providence college had admitted as "Sophi- 
 mores" persons who would not rank as Freshmen at Cambridge. 
 "Sophimores" is the New Haven, and perhaps the Cambridge 
 spelling of that day. After this, charters were granted to Bow- 
 doin and Brown in i829,§ and at the present moment there are 
 nineteen:]: chapters, connected with as many leading colleges in 
 the Union. 
 
 *For additional paragraphs of the ritual see The Key, vol. i, no. 4, pp. 
 19, 20. 
 
 fl have seen no evidence of the organization of this branch, though a 
 charter was granted July 10, 1779,' to Samuel Hardy. The record does not 
 state that it was intended for Hampden-Sidney. 
 
 §Bowdoin's charter bears the date October 25, 1824. See The Phi Beta 
 Kappa Key, vol. 2, p. 289. The chapter was organized February 22, 1825. 
 The chapter at Brown was organized July 21, 1830. See The Key, vol. 
 
 2, P- 333- 
 
 JThere were in reality at the time twenty-two active chapters and two in- 
 active — the Alpha of Virginia at William, and Mary and the Alpha of Ala- 
 bama at the University, 1851. They were, in addition to those already 
 mentioned, the Alpha of New York at Union College, 1817; the Beta and 
 Gamma of Connecticut at Trinity and Wesleyan respectively, 1845 ; the 
 Beta and Gamma of Massachusetts at Amherst and Williams, 1857 and 
 1864 respectively; the Beta of New York at New York University, 1858; 
 the Beta and Gamma of Ohio at Kenyon and Marietta, 1858 and i860 re- 
 spectively; the Gamma and Delta of New York at City College and Co- 
 lumbia, 1867 and 1869; the Alpha of New Jersey at Rutgers, 1869; the Ep- 
 silon, Zeta, and Eta of New York at Hamilton, Hobart, and Madison, now 
 Colgate, 1870, 1871, and 1878, respectively. How it happened that Dr. Hale 
 was ignorant of three chapters we cannot now explain. 
 
A PHI BETA KAPPA BIBLIOGRAPHY 
 
 By Prof. Clark S. Northup, Cornell '93 
 
 (Continued from page 181) 
 
 TULANE UNIVERSITY— Concluded 
 
 1913. Brown Ayres. A plea for greater idealism in American 
 education. Delivered June 3. In The Tulane Graduates' Maga- 
 zine, July, 1913, ii. 42-49. 
 
 1914. John McLaren McBryde, Jr. Past days in Phi Beta 
 Kappa. Delivered June 2. Published with additions and changes 
 in The Sezvanee Review, April, 191 5, xxiii. 209-229. 
 
 Also reprinted. Comment in The Key, May, 1915, ii. 8. 403. 
 
 191 5. Archibald Henderson. The South's awakening. De- 
 livered June I. In The Nezvcomb Arcade, June, 1915, vii. 42-54. 
 
 Comment in The Dial, Jan. 6, 1916, Ix. 10. 
 
 Poems. 
 
 1909. Fanny Heaslip Lea (Mrs. Hamilton P. Agee). The 
 runners. Read at the inaugural exercises, February 26. In The 
 Key, Nov., 1910, i. 1.5-7. 
 
 General. 
 
 Pierce Butler. See Ph. B. K. Publ., N. S. 8, pp. 21-22. 
 A notice of the installation appeared in The Tulane Alumni 
 Bulletin, June, 1909. 
 
 See also Ph. B. K. : information resp. institutions that have applied for 
 charters, 1904, pp. 4-5. 
 
 UNION UNIVERSITY. 
 
 Alpha of New York. Organized in July, 1817. 
 
 Catalogues. 
 
 1827. 8vo, pp. 16. 1831. Pp. 18. 1832. 8vo, pp. 20. 1833. 
 8vo, pp. 20. 1837. Pp. 24. 1852. 8vo, pp. 40. i860. 8vo, pp. 
 48. 1872. 8vo, pp. 54. 1882. 8vo, pp. 56. 
 
 Orations and Addresses 
 
 1821. Samuel Latham Mitchill. A discourse on the state 
 and prospects of American literature, delivered at Schenectady, 
 
 300 
 
igiS A Phi Beta Kappa Bibliographv 301 
 
 July 24, 1821, before the New York Alpha of the Ph. B. K. 
 Society. Albany. Websters & Skinners. 1821. 8vo, pp. 36. 
 
 1823. DeWitt Clinton. A discourse delivered at Schene 
 tady, July 22d, A. D. 1823, before the New York Alpha of the 
 Phi Beta Kappa. Albany. Websters & Skinners. 1823. 8vo, 
 PP- 47- 
 
 A second (26 pages) and a third edition (30 pages) were published. On 
 the achievements and responsibilities of the age. Reviewed in The New 
 York Literary Gazette, Sept. 24, 1825, i. 3. 43-45. 
 
 1826. Samuel Young. A discourse delivered at Schenectady, 
 July 25, A. D. 1826, before the New- York Alpha of the Ph. B. 
 K. Ballston Spa. Printed by J. Comstock. 1826. 8vo, pp. 
 70, [2], xvi. 
 
 On some principles of sociology and pohtical economv. 
 
 1828. Alfred Conkling. A discourse commemorative of the 
 talents, virtues, and services of the late DeWitt Clinton ; delivered 
 at Schenectady, before the Society of the Phi Beta Kappa, July 
 22d, 1828. Albany : Printed by Webster & Skinners. 1828. 8vo, 
 
 PP- 31- 
 
 1833. Benjamin Franklin Joslin. A discourse on the privi- 
 leges and duties of man as a progressive being, delivered before 
 the New- York Alpha of the Ph. B. K. Society, July 23, 1833. 
 Schenectady: Printed by S. S. Riggs. 1833. 8vo, pp. 28. 
 
 1837. Daniel Dewey Barnard. A discourse pronounced at 
 Schenectady, before the New York Alpha of the Society of Phi 
 Beta Kappa July 2Sth, 1837. Albany : Printed by Hoffman & 
 White. 1837. 8vo, pp. 51. 
 
 1841. William Kent. An address, pronounced before the 
 Phi Beta Kappa Society of Union College, at Schenectady, on 
 Tuesday, July 27th, 1841. Published at the request of the Society. 
 New- York: Printed by James Van Norden & Co. 1841. 8vo, 
 pp. 30. 
 
 On the prospects of our country and the tendencies and efifects of its 
 institutions. 
 
 1844. William Henry Seward. The elements of empire in 
 America. New York. C. Shepard. 1844. 8vo, pp. 39. 
 
 George E. Baker in his Life, New York, Redfield, 1855, p. 91, gives the 
 date of this as 1843; but in Seward's Works, Boston, 1861, iii. 11, and in 
 
302 Phi Beta Kappa Key January-March 
 
 his Autobiography, ed. F. W. Seward, New York, Appleton, 1877, p. 721, 
 the date of delivery is given as 1844. 
 
 1848. Charles Sumner. The law of human progress: an 
 oration, before the Phi Beta Kappa Society of Union College, 
 Schenectady, July 25th, 1848. Boston. W. D. Ticknor & Co. 
 
 1849. 8vo, pp. 48. 
 
 1849. Tayler Lewis. Nature, progress, ideas. A discourse 
 on naturalism, in its various phases, as opposed to the true Scrip- 
 tural doctrine of the Divine Imperium. Delivered at Union Col- 
 lege, Schenectady, July 24, 1849, before the New- York Alpha of 
 the Phi Beta Kappa Society. Schenectady. G. Y. Van Debogert. 
 
 1850. 8vo, pp. 56. 
 
 1851. Thomas M. Clark. The influence of thought. An ora- 
 tion before the New- York Alpha of the Phi Beta Kappa Society. 
 Delivered at Union College, Schenectady, July 22, 1851. Schenec- 
 tady. G. Y. Van DeBogert. 1851. 8vo, pp. 36. 
 
 Also delivered before the Trinity Chapter on July 30 (or 29?), 1851. 
 
 1852. Benjamin Nicholas Martin. Science and the Scrip- 
 tures; a discourse before the New York Alpha of the Ph. B. 
 K. Society, delivered at Union College July 27, 1852. Sche- 
 nectady. G. Y. Van Debogert. 1852. 8vo, pp. 44. 
 
 1857. George William Clinton. An oration, pronounced at 
 Schenectady, July 21, 1857, before the New-York Alpha of the 
 Phi Beta Kappa Society. [Published by request.] Schenectady. 
 Van DeBogert. 1858. 8vo, pp. 29. 
 
 On the nature of wisdom, especially in politics. 
 
 1 86 1. Horatio Gates Warner. Free government: an ad- 
 dress, delivered before the New York Alpha of the Phi Beta Kap- 
 pa Society, Union College, July 25, 1861, by Hon. Horatio Gates 
 Warner. Published by the Society. Schenectady. 1861. 8vo, 
 
 PP- 32- 
 
 1862. William Tracy. Philosophia biou kubernetes; anni- 
 versary address before the New York Alpha of the Phi Beta Kap- 
 pa Society at Union College, July 23, 1862. Published by the 
 Society. Schenectady. 1862. 8vo, pp. 32. 
 
 On the philosophy of history. 
 
 1865. Robert J. Breckinridge. The great deliverance and the 
 
1918 A Phi Beta Kappa Bibliography 303 
 
 new career. An oration, delivered before the Phi Beta Kappa So- 
 ciety of Union College at Schenectady, N. Y., on the 25th July, 
 1865. Philadelphia. James S. Glaxton. 1865. 8vo, pp. [ii], 32. 
 Cover title. 
 
 1868. Clarkson N. Potter. Address before the New York 
 A-lpha of the Phi Beta Kappa at Union College. Schenectady, June 
 30, 1868, by Clarkson N. Potter, Esq., A. M. Printed for the 
 Society. 8vo, pp. 35. 
 
 On the development of government in New York State. 
 
 1874. Charles J. Jenkins. Anniversary oration before the 
 New York Alpha of the Phi Beta Kappa Society ; delivered at Un- 
 ion University, June 23d, 1874, by Hon. Charles J. Jenkins, LL.D. 
 Pubhshed by the Society. Schenectady. 1874. 8vo, pp. 36. 
 
 "A cursory review of the civilization of the nineteenth century, and 
 chiefly of its American type." 
 
 1882. George Alexander. Tayler Lewis, the conservative 
 scholar. A commemorative address delivered before the New 
 York Alpha of the Phi Beta Kappa Society, at Union College, by 
 George Alexander, June 27, 1882. 8vo, pp. 21. 
 
 1917. George Alexander. The centennial oration. Delivered 
 June II. In The centenary of Alpha of New York of Phi Beta 
 Kappa. Schenectady, N. Y., 1917, pp. 20-29. 
 
 Pleads for a revival of interest in the things of the spirit. 
 
 Poems. 
 
 1842. Alfred Billings Street. The burning of Schenectady, 
 a poem, before the Alpha of the Phi Beta Kappa Society of Union 
 College, July 26, 1842. Published by request of the Society. Al- 
 bany:. Printed by C. Van Benthuysen & Co. 1842. i2mo, 
 pp. 64. 
 
 1852. Ralph Hoyt. The Koh-i-noor : or, Mountain of Light. 
 A poem delivered before the New York Alpha of the Phi Beta 
 Kappa Society, at Union College, Schenectady, July 27, 1852. 
 Schenectady. G. Y. Van Debogert. 1852. 8vo, 6 leaves, 
 pp. [12]. 
 
 1917. John Franklin Genung. A muse that would not be 
 amusing. Read at the centenary dinner, June 12. In The cent en- 
 
304 Plii Beta Kappa Key January-March 
 
 ary of Alpha of Ncz^' York of Phi Beta Kappa, Schenectady, 1917, 
 
 PP- 45-47- 
 
 General. 
 
 John Ira Bennett. Union College. In The Key, Jan., 1914, 
 ii. 2. 65-78. Illus. 
 
 . The Alpha of New York. In The Key, Jan., 1914, ii. 
 
 2. 78-82. Illus. 
 
 See also Phi Beta Kappa Publ, N. S. 3, p. [s]- 
 
 The centenary of Alpha of New York of Phi Beta Kappa 
 celebrated at Union College June 11 and 12, 1917. Schenectady, 
 N. Y. The Gazette Press. November, 1917. 8vo, pp. 68. 
 
 Cover title. A complete record of the public exercises and the remarks 
 at the dinner. 
 
 Circular to the members of the New-York Ph. B. K. Society, in 
 relation to literary and scientific transactions. Schenectady. S 
 S. Riggs, Printer, no. 10, Union-Street. 1833. 8vo. pp. 8. 
 
 See also The Key ii. 3. 155. 
 
 VANDERBILT UNIVERSITY. 
 
 Alpha of Tennessee. Organized November 5, 1901. 
 
 Catalogues. 
 
 1901. Pp. 41. 1906. 4to, pp. 54. 1914. 8vo, pp. 85. All 
 edited by Herbert C. Tolman. 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 
 1901. William Robertson Garrett. Phi Beta Kappa at 
 William and Mary College, Virginia. Delivered December 5. 
 Extracts in The William and Adary College Quarterly Historical 
 Magazine, January, 1902, x. 251-7. 
 
 General. 
 
 J. T. McGiLL. See Ph. B. K. Puhl, N. S. 3, p. [19] . 
 
 A Vanderbilt chapter of Phi Beta Kappa. In The Vander- 
 bilt University Quarterly, October, 1901, i. 271-9. 
 
 An account of the public foundation meeting was pubhshed in 
 The Nashville American, December 6, 1901. 
 
 See also Ph. B. K. bulletin of information, 1903, p. [l]. 
 
igiS A Phi Beta Kappa Bibliography 305 
 
 VASSAR COLLEGE. 
 
 Mu OF New York. Organized April 7, 1898. 
 
 Catalogues. 
 
 1905. 8vo, pp. 14. 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 
 1901. Nicholas Murray Butler. Five evidences of an edu- 
 cation. In The Educational ReviezVj November, 1901, xxii. 325- 
 
 34- 
 
 1903. Whitelaw Reid. a coinmencement address before the 
 *. B. K. Society of Vassar College ; June 8, 1903. The thing to do. 
 New York. 1903. 8vo, pp. 18. 
 
 On social conditions in the United States. 
 
 1906. Andrew Dickson White. Evolution versus revolu- 
 tion as a policy. 
 
 Delivered also before the New York Alumni in 1896 and at Cornell in 
 1913. Substantially the same as in pamphlets published in 1890 and 1897, 
 the latter at Madison, Wisconsin, pp. 22. Reprinted in Representative 
 Ph. B. K. orations, Boston, 1915, pp. 233-53. 
 
 1907. Elmer Ellsworth Brown. Are we an inventive peo- 
 ple in education? In Science, August 9, 1907, n. s. xxvi. 161-70. 
 
 1909. JosiAH RoYCE. What is vital in Christianity? In The 
 Harvard Theological Review, October, 1909, ii. 408-45. 
 
 Reprinted in his William James and other essays on the philosophy of 
 life, New York, Macmillan, 191 1, 8vo, pp. 97-183, and in Representative 
 Ph. B. K. orations, Boston, 1915, pp. 404-41. 
 
 General. 
 
 Caroline E. Furness. See Ph. B. K. PuU., N. S. 3, p. [16]. 
 See also Ph. B. K. bulletin of information, 1903, p. 4, and The Key, 
 Jan., 1916, ii. 10. 467-9, 469-70. 
 
 THE UNIVERSITY OF VERMONT. 
 Alpha of Vermont. Organized March 7, 1848. 
 Catalogues. 
 1899. 8vo, pp. 52. 1902. Supplement, pp. 53-60. 1909. 8vo, 
 pp. 41. 
 
3o6 Phi Beta Kappa Key January-March 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 
 1852. RuFus Choate. The debt of the New World to the 
 Old. Delivered August 3, 1852. In The New York Times, 
 August 9, 1852, p. I. 
 
 An extract appeared also in Samuel Oilman Brown, The life of Rufus 
 Choate, Boston, Little, Brown and Company, 1881, 8vo, pp. 279-82. Selec- 
 tions also in Joseph Neilson, Memories of Rufus Choate, Boston, Hough- 
 ton, Mifflin & Co., 1884, 8vo, pp. 146-9. 
 
 1855. Erastus Cornelius Benedict. Elementary principles 
 of America institutions. Summary in The Burlington Free Press, 
 August 2, 1855. 
 
 1857. George Park Fisher. The origin and later develop- 
 ment of Protestantism. Summary in The Burlington Free Press, 
 August 4, 1857. 
 
 1859. Laurens Perseus Hickok. The activity of thinking 
 men. Summary in The Burlington Free Press, August 2, 1859. 
 
 1861. Julius Hawley Seelye. Summary in The Burlington 
 Free Press, August 8, 1861. 
 
 On the subordination of the individual to the community. 
 
 1864. RoswELL DwiGHT HiTCHCOCK. The historical devel- 
 opment and destiny of the American republic. Summary in The 
 Burlington Free Press, August 2, 1864. 
 
 1865. Asa Dodge Smith. Self-possession. Summary in 
 The Burlington Free Press, August 2, 1865. 
 
 1866. Leonard Bacon. The physical progress and material 
 prosperity of the age as related to the true well being of mankind. 
 Summary in The Burlington Free Press, August 2, 1866. 
 
 1867. Andrew Preston Peabody. The positive philosophy. 
 See Amherst Orations and Addresses, 1867. 
 
 1868. James Willis Patterson. Education in its relation 
 to the republic. Summary in The Burlington Free Press, August 
 S, 1868. 
 
 1869. Jeremiah Lewis Diman. The method of academic cul- 
 ture. Summary in The Burlington Free Press, August 4, 1869. 
 
 See also Amherst Orations and Addresses, 1869. 
 
 1870. Samuel Lunt Caldwlll. The debt of literature to 
 life. Summary in The Burlington Free Press, August 3, 1870. 
 
 In substance presumably the same as his Literature in account with life, 
 
1918 A Phi Beta Kappa Bibliography 307 
 
 delivered at Commencement at the University of Michigan June 25, 1885, 
 and published at Ann Arbor, 1885, 8vo, pp. 22, 
 
 1872. Benjamin H. Steele. The life of John Quincy Adams. 
 Summary in The Burlington Free Press, July 10, 1872. 
 
 1874. Homer Barker Sprague. The life of John iMilton. 
 Summary in The Burlington Free Press, July 8, 1874. 
 
 1876. Charles Kendall Adams. The relations of higher 
 education to national prosperity. An oration delivered before the 
 $. B. K. Society of the University of Vermont, June 27, 1876. 
 Burlington. 1876. 8vo, pp. 27. 
 
 Reprinted in Representative Ph. B. K. orations, Boston, 1815, pp. 152-73. 
 
 1878. Thomas Hill. Summary in The Burlington Free 
 Press, June 26, 1878. 
 
 A philosophical discourse. 
 
 1880. RoswELL G. HoRR. Individualism. Summary in The 
 Burlington Free Press, June 30, 1880. 
 
 1882. Gamaliel Bradford. Higher education in relation to 
 politics. Summary in The Burlington Free Press, June 28, 1882. 
 
 1884. Daniel Henry Chamberlain. Greek as a factor in 
 college education. 
 
 See Amherst Orations and Addresses, 1884. 
 
 1887. Dorman Bridgman Eaton. Political parties. Sum- 
 mary in The Burlington Free Press, June 29, 1887. 
 
 1889. Herbert Tuttle. Conservative reform. Summary 
 in The Burlington Free Press, June 26, 1889. 
 
 1892. John Adam Kasson. A higher civilization. Summary 
 in The Burlington Free Press, June 29, 1892. 
 
 1894. Everett Pepperell Wpieeler. Some aspects of the 
 social questions of the day. Summary, in Tlie Burlington Free 
 Press, June 27, 1894. 
 
 1897. Captain Guy Howard. The situation in Cuba. De- 
 livered January 15. Burlington. H. J. Shanley. 1897. 8vo, 
 pp. 30. 
 
 1899. William DeWitt Hyde. Two types of ideality. Sum- 
 mary in The Burlington Free Press, June 28, 1899. 
 
 1903. Edward Caldwell Moore. Manhood and modern edu- 
 cation. Summary in The Burlington Free Press, June 24, 1903. 
 {To be Continued.) 
 
IN MEMORIAM 
 
 RoLLiN Arthur Harris, Ph. D., Cornell '85, died suddenly on January 
 20, 1917, in the city of Washington, where he had made his home since 
 i8go. He was born in Randolph, N. Y., April 18, 1863, and received his 
 bachelor's degree in '85, specializing in mathematics and physics. He was 
 a fellow in mathematics at Cornell in 1886-7, and at Clark in 1889-90. In 
 July, 1890, he entered the service of the U. S. Coast and Geodetic Survey 
 and here the problem of the tides engaged his attention. His interest in 
 pure mathematics never flagged, as his contributions to the Annals of 
 Mathematics and other magazines attest, but his great work is found in his 
 contributions to the solution of the tidal problem. In this peculiarly ab- 
 struse branch of mathematical physics he has done notable work. His 
 "Manual of Tides," published in the Reports of the Coast and Geodetic 
 Survey for the years 1894, 1897, 1900, 1904, and 1907, comprises a monu- 
 mental work which has won high praise from scientists the world over. 
 He is survived by his wife, Emily Doty Harris. A brother, Gilbert D. 
 Harris, Cornell '86, is a professor of paleontology and stratigraphic geol- 
 ogy at Cornell University. 
 
 John Basset Chapin, M. D., LL. D., Williams '50, physician-in-chief at 
 the Pennsylvania State Hospital for the Insane in Philadelphia from 1884 
 to 1911, died at Canandaigua, N. Y., on January 17, 1917, in his eighty- 
 eighth year. He obtained his medical degree from Jefferson in 1853. He 
 was resident physician at the New York Hosp'ital from 1854 to 1859, at 
 Brigham Hall, Canandaigua, from i860 to 1869, and medical superintend- 
 ent of the State Hospital at Willard, N. Y., from 1869 to 1884. It was Dr. 
 Chapin who in 1862 proposed changes in asylum construction which would 
 provide for segregation of the insane in detached blocks according to 
 classes and conditions ; these views have been widely adopted. He was 
 author of "A Compendium of Insanity for Physicians and Students'' (1899) 
 and of many articles on insanity, and had been president of the American 
 Psychological Association. 
 
 George Alvah Kittredce, M. A,, Yale '55, died at his home in Brook- 
 line, Mass., on December 26, 1917. He was born in Boston on March 29, 
 1833. At seventeen he went to Syria in a sailing vessel of less than two 
 hundred tons. After graduation he studied at Yale for a year, then spent 
 a year in the west as a traveler and tutor. From 1857 to 1862 he was con- 
 nected with Naylor and Company of Boston. Then he went to India. For 
 forty years he was a merchant and leading citizen of Bombay. He in- 
 troduced street cars into India in 1873. For ten years he was a member 
 of the board of trustees for the port of Bombay, resigning about 1882. He 
 was also active in the movement to allow women in India to study medi- 
 cine. He made forty-one trips to and from India and went around the 
 world twice. 
 
 308 
 
Volume 3 , 
 
 Number 8 
 
 Contents 
 
 .■■-'• Page 
 
 Belgium — A Poem . . . i .. . 323 
 
 . The Original Phi Beta Kappa Recoi-ds . J 325 
 
 The King— Translation from The Iliad . . 336 
 
 The Endowment Fund Campaign . 337 
 
 Meeti|ng of tJbie Senate . . . . 343v 
 
 A Phi Beta Kappa Bibliograpy— Continued • 344 
 InMemoriam . . .... 349 
 
 Phi Beta Kappa News and Notes ."^ . 357 
 
 ';?•;- 
 
 Nn 
 
 ^'\. 
 
 ^ 
 
 MAY, 1918 
 
The Phi Beta Kappa Fraterni^ 
 
 DIRECTORY OF CHAPTERS ^ 
 
 With the number in the orderof establishment, theiS^fefetary, and t^e date. 
 
 la 4io&<M>wt— Alpha of Alabama, University, Prof. J. J. DOster. A. M. ....'....... .18&1- 
 
 64 Alieghenv—^ta, ot Pennsylvania, Meadville, Prof. W. A. BlUott, K H. D. ...1902 
 
 13 Amfterst-^Beta of lilassachuSetts, Amherst, Pr.9f. Charles B.lBennett, I>h. D. ..18B3 
 89 Botes — Gamma of Mkine, E,ewis,ton. Prof. ArtWr N. Leonard, Ph. D. ....... ..1917 
 
 78 BeipW— Beta of Wisconsin, Beloit, Prof., Jlrastus G. Smith, tb. V. .\.. . .':\ .r.l911 
 
 46 Boston — ^E^sllon of MassaciuEeits, Boston, Ada A- Col©/ Ph. B. . . ..'.^ . . . i . J .1899 
 
 6 SowdoU — ^Alpha of Maine, Brunswicfc, Prof. <}eo. ,T. Filea,, Ph. D. ,'.'. ...'.... .1826 
 
 ■7 Broum-vAlpha'of Rhode Island, Providence, Prof. James Q. Dealfey, Ph. b 1830 
 
 43 Caiiiornia^-Xlplta of Cajifomia, Berkeley, Prof. Perclvatl B. Pay, Ph. D......189* 
 
 83 Oarteton-JBeta of Minnesota,- Northfield, prof. Curvin Bf. Gingrich, Ph. t» . . y. 1914 
 61 CWcopo^^Beta of Illinois,- Chicago, Prof. Francis W. Shepardson, Lli. D.....lg9*' 
 
 48 CJncmnay— Delta of Ohio, Cincinnati, Miss Jieien A. Stanley, 3576 Zumstelh- 
 
 Ave. '..:.,, ,1899 
 
 39 Colby— B^ta of Maine, WaterVUle, Prof. J. ■William Black, Ph. D "; .-. .1896 
 
 24 Colgate— Eta, of. New York, Hamilton, Prof. F. C. Fren^, Ph. D »,f 1878 
 
 55 Colora)^o University — Alpha of Colorado, Boulder, Prof. F. Bamaley, Ph, D. . . .1904 
 69 Colorado College — Beta of Colorado, Colorado Sprin^is, Prof. Albert R. Elllng- 
 
 wood, B. C. L1..J . -•. ..... .... .,. ....'. .;.... ...... .-i . . ... ....... ^, , .1904 
 
 ^ 21 CptewBto—r Helta oi:Ne-» York, new Tork City, Edward Ghick, A.' B. ...... .1869; 
 
 ' 2Et Cor jteB-^TJieta of New Tork; Ithaca, Prof. AlberfjLeBoy Andrews, Ph. b... 4151882 
 
 4 CorfmOKtft— Alpha of Neinr Hampshire, IJanover, H%roW G', Buggr A. JS. . .yl78'r 
 
 74 13eniso«y-Theta of Ohio, Granville, Prof. W. A. Chamberlfai, Ph. D,. ..«. .j^. .1911 
 
 29 JDe Pa»4)-^Alpha of Indiana, Greericastle, Prdf, A. F. Cauldwelli A. M.. . .;'^.1889 
 
 1^26; Dickinson — Alpha of Pennsylvania; . Carlisle, Prof. John F^/Mohiei', Ph. D. ....1887 
 
 S9 Franklin and Marshall — Theta of Pennsylvania, Lancaster, Prof. W. E.'Wels-' " 
 
 Berber, Ph. M. ...!..... .....:.....;.. .1908 ' 
 
 81 Georgia — ^Alpha of GfSorgla, Atheris, Prof. W. D. Hooper* A- M. ...;..-, ...1914 
 
 Si~ Goucher- — Beta of llaryland,- Balfiinorer Miss Mary Patten, A, 3 : 7% . . ^ . ... 1905 , 
 
 • 7fl Grinneljr— Beta, of Iowa, jGrinnell, Prof. Caroline 'Sheldon, -^ M... ^.,, .....19bS 
 
 J^Z Hamllton-^Evsilon oj New york, Clinton, Prof. J. D; Ibbotsoti, :Jr„ A. M;..;,1870 
 3 Harvardj—Aipba, of Massachusetts, Cambridge,* WUlfam'-CJ. Lane, ,&„ p..... .Vlil 
 
 44 Baverford — Zeta of Pennsylvania, Haverford, Prof. L. W. Beld» Ph. 3>1 ...... .1^90 
 
 23 Hoftart — ^Zeta al_New Tork,V(3eneva, Prof. Wfllts P. Woodman, Ph. D. .. .^s . .187J. 
 
 6T Illinois — Gamma Of Illinois, -Urbanls., Prof . Jacob Z^ityn, Ph. B. . . ..:. -. * . . . ,.,19(17 
 
 ii Jtidiaina — Gamma of Indiana, Bloominfeton, Miss Katharine EaSley, A. B. ...;.., 1911 ' 
 
 ~ 3,6_ /oi«a— Alpha of Iowa, lojiva City, liIiss,Hertha L.. Vo'ssJ Ph. B. . ...... ;..... . .V'.1895 
 
 ^31 Johns H()j)fci«s^-^Alpha of Maryland, Baltiftiore, Prof. Joseph T. ^Sl)rig3Wald, ' 
 
 Ph. 3D -.!.,.. ;,.......,.,;'..........l.,., ...Vi. 1895 
 
 31 Kansas — ^Alpha of Kansa?. Lawrence, Prof. J. G. Brandt, Ph; E>. . . . . i . . .^ ,,. .^. 189fl 
 
 14 Ke«i^o»— Beta of Ohib; Gambler, Luther H. Tate... ......1858 
 
 87 Xnoa;— I?elta of Illinois, dale$bi}rg/ Prof. J. L. Cogger, Ph. D. . ...^ ......... .1917 
 
 32'Lafavette — Gamma of Pennsylvania, Easton, Prof. win. S. Ha,ll, Ph. D. ; .^ . . . 1890 
 79 Ltiwrenee — Gamma of Wisconsin; Appleton, Prof. L<?uia C. Baker, Ph. JP. ..;'.'. .1914 ' 
 27 Lehigh — Beta of Pennsylvania, South Bethlehem, Prof. C. L. Thonjburg, Ph. D.1887 
 16 Jf oHe«(i-^-Gamnia of Ohio, _Marletta, Mis^ Mary S. Newton , i . i ..... ^ ...;..., . i860-- 
 
 77 ifidwi— Iota of Ohio, Oxford, Prof. HarlSKp Schwafe, Bi A < ; . ..... . .1911 
 
 68 Michigan — ^Alpha of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Prof. J. W. Soholl, Ph. D. J ....... .1907 
 
 19 Middle^ury — Beta 6f Vermont, Mlddlebury, Prof. Chas. B. Wright, LJtt D.-i. .1864 
 35 Winnesota—Alviha, of Mlnne^ta, Minnfeapolis, Frederie^K.' Butters, Ph. D.....1892 
 
 F3 affosowri— ^Alpha of Missouri, Columbia, Prof . Guy B.- C^llburn, Ph^^b. ...... .1901 
 
 iConclude'd on third page o/' hover)) ',--.-' 
 
1918 Meeting of the Senate 343 
 
 In order to forestall any possible charge that the writer was 
 pressing the campaign from motives of a personal nature, on 
 December 5th he sent to President Grosvenor a statement of his 
 purpose to place his resignation as Secretary before the Senate 
 at its next meeting, and expressed the hope that a meeting would 
 be called at an early date so that he could be relieved not later 
 than February 28th, 1918. This action had been in contemplation 
 for some months. The enlarged duties of the office have become 
 increasingly burdensome in connection with pressing pastoral 
 responsibilities which have prior claim upon his time, but have 
 often been put aside for Phi Beta Kappa work. Being selected 
 chairman of the War Service Commission of the Reformed 
 Church in America, he could not refuse this call to patriot duty. 
 
 «(?■ c5* <5* (iJ* 
 
 MEETING OF THE SENATE 
 
 Circumstances made it inadvisable to hold a meeting of the 
 Senate before March 7th. Ten members then convened in New 
 York and listened to the report of the campaign. The Senate 
 expressed its appreciation of the efforts of the committee, and 
 while regretting the outcome, felt that the failure was due to 
 war conditions which in large measure determined the action of 
 the chapters. Hence the decision that nothing further be done 
 until after the war, and that the whole matter be referred to the 
 Council of 1919. 
 
 The Secretary's request for release was not granted, but he was 
 urged to continue the work as a matter of duty. A material in- 
 crease in his salary was voted, and an additional allowance granted 
 for clerical assistance. It was felt that being reheved from many 
 of the details he could carry the work without additional burden. 
 
 It will be noted that the action of the Council of 1916 in taking 
 over the manufacture and distribution of Phi Beta Kappa keys 
 has made it financially possible to grant this relief. Without the 
 profit accruing from this service there would have been a de- 
 crease in the cash balance for the year ending August 31, 1917, 
 of $500.00. With it there was an increase in resources of 
 $1,300.00. So much as is needed of this amount is to be used to 
 increase the efficiency of the office. 
 
A PHI BETA KAPPA BIBLIOGRAPHY 
 
 By Prof. Clark S. Northup, Cornell '93 
 
 (Continued from Page 307) 
 
 UNIVERSITY OF VERMONT— concluded 
 
 Poems. 
 
 1859. William Henry Burleigh. The mission of the poet. 
 
 Summary in The Burlington Free Press, August 2, 1859. 
 
 Apparently this was never published under the above title; but in 
 Burleigh's Poems, New York, 1871, 8vo, pp. 36-37. is a short poem en- 
 titled The poet, which may be a part of it. 
 
 1861. E. W. B. Canning. Genius, a poem. Summary in The 
 Burlington Free Press, August 8, 1861. 
 
 1878. William Cleaver Wilkinson. Eulogy of Daniel Web- 
 ster. 
 
 Published in 1882 : Webster \ an ode \ O nostrum et decus et columen I | 
 1782-1852 I New York : I Charles Scribner's Sons, 1882 | 4vo, pp. [iv], 122. 
 
 General. 
 
 Mabel L. Southwick. The Alpha of Vermont. In The Key, 
 October, 191 5, ii. 9, 413-29- 
 
 THE UNIVERSITY OF VIRGINIA. 
 
 Beta of Virginia. Organized June 16, 1908. 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 
 1914. Armistead C. Gordon. The laws of Bacon's Assembly. 
 
 An address delivered before the Beta of Virginia Chapter of 
 
 the Phi Beta Kappa Society at the University of Virginia, June 
 
 17, 1914. 8vo. 
 
 Noticed in The William and Mary College Quarterly Historical Maga- 
 zine, January, 1915, xxiii. 223. 
 
 1915. James Edwin Creighton. The social nature of think- 
 ing. Delivered June 16. In The Alumni Bulletin of the Univer- 
 sity of Virginia, April, 191 6. 
 
 Also reprinted, 8vo, pp. 22. 
 
 1916. Edward N. Calisch. The Mosaic code in the light of 
 modern law. Delivered June 12. In The Alumni Bulletin of the 
 University of Virginia, April, 1917, x. 186-200. 
 
 344 
 
19^8 A Phi Beta Kappa Bibliography 345 
 
 General. 
 
 Beta of Virginia, Phi Beta Kappa : by-laws concerning eligibil- 
 ity, election, and qualifications of members. 1910. Narrow i6mo, 
 pp. 7. 
 
 Armistead M. Dobie. See Ph. B. K. Publ., N. S. 8, pp. 20-21. 
 
 Theodore Hough. History and aims of Phi Beta Kappa at the 
 University of Virginia. N. d. 8vo, pp. 7. 
 
 See also Ph. B. K. : information resp. institutions that have applied for 
 charters, 1904, p. 3. 
 
 WABASH COLLEGE. 
 
 Beta of Indiana. Organized November 7, 1898. 
 
 .Catalogues. 
 1909. 8vo, pp. 27. 
 
 General. 
 
 Donaldson Bodine. See Ph. B. K. Publ., N. S. 3, p. [15]. 
 
 THE UNIVERSITY OF WASHINGTON. 
 
 Alpha of Washington. Organized April 29, 1914. 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 
 1914. Hiram M. Chittenden. The foundation members. 
 Delivered at the banquet, April 29. In The Key, October, 1914, 
 "• 5- 231-3- 
 
 General. 
 
 Application for charter from University of Washington. Se- 
 attle. 1910. 8vo, pp. [14]. 
 
 Application for charter from University of Washington. Se- 
 attle. 1913. 8vo, pp. [16]. 
 
 Allen Rogers Benham. The Alpha of Washington. In The 
 Key^ October, 1914, ii. 5. 229-33. 
 
 — . The University of the State of Washington. In The 
 
 Key, October, 1914, ii. 5, 223-9. Illus. 
 
 See also The Key i. 12. 21-2, ii. 8. 402, 12. 583-4. 
 
346 Phi Beta Kappa Key May 
 
 WASHINGTON UNIVERSITY. 
 
 Beta of Missouri. Organized May 13, 1914. 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 
 1914. James Hayden Tufts. The scholarship of other days 
 and now. In The ' Washington University Record, December, 
 1914, 1st ser. X. 2. 1-12. 
 
 General. 
 
 George Oscar James. Washington University, St. Louis. In 
 The Key, October, 1914, ii. 5. 233-8. Illus. 
 
 George R. Throop. The Beta of Missouri. In The Key, Oc- 
 tober, 1914, ii. 5. 238-42. Illus. 
 
 Oscar McMurtrie Voorhees. Views of Washington Uni- 
 versity. In The Key, March, 1917, iii. 3. 115-19. Illus. 
 
 See also The Key i. 12. 27-8. 
 
 WASHINGTON AND LEE UNIVERSITY. 
 
 Gamma of Virginia. Organized May 5, 191 1. 
 
 Catalogues. 
 
 A list of the foundation members appeared in The Key, Oc- 
 tober, 1911, i. 5. 13-15. 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 
 191 1. John H. Latane. Address in acceptance of the char- 
 ter, delivered May 5. In The Key, October, 191 1, i. 5. 7-10. 
 
 General. 
 
 James Lewis Howe. The Gamma of Virginia at Washington 
 and Lee University. In The Key, October, 191 1, i. 5. 6-15. 
 
 . Washington and Lee University. In same, pp. 2-6. 
 
 Illustrated. 
 
ipiS A Phi Beta Kappa Bibliography 347 
 
 WELLESLEY COLLEGE. 
 
 Eta of Massachusetts. Organized November 14, 1904. 
 
 Poems. 
 
 1905. Caroline Hazard. The illuminators. A poem read at 
 the installation of the Eta Chapter of the Phi Beta Kappa Society 
 in Massachusetts, at Wellesley College, January seventeenth, 
 1905. [Campden. Essex House Print. 1905.] Large 8vo, pp. 
 13, [i]. Illus. 
 
 One hundred fifty copies were printed. 
 
 General. 
 
 Laura E. Lockwood. See Ph. B. K. Publ., N. S. 3, p. [21]. 
 
 See also Ph. B. K. : information resp. institutions that have applied for 
 charters, 1904, p. 2, and Ph. B. K. Publ., N. S. 2, p. [6]. 
 
 WESLEYAN UNIVERSITY. 
 
 Gamma of Connecticut. Organized July 7, 1845. 
 
 Catalogues. 
 
 1906. Bvo, pp. 145. Compiled by Frank W. Nicolson. 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 
 1850. Daniel Denison Whedon. The man-republic: a Phi 
 Beta Kappa oration, delivered at the Wesleyan University, Au- 
 gust, 1850. Middletown. Barnes. 1850. 8vo, pp. 22. 
 
 General. 
 
 Frank W. Nicolson. See Ph. B. K., Publ., N. S. 3, p. [6]. 
 
 . The Gamma of Connecticut. In The Key, March, 
 
 1914, ii. 3. 115-23- Illus. 
 
 See also Ph. B. K. bulletin of information, 1903, p. S. and The Key, 
 March, 1914, ii. 3. 153. 
 
348 Phi Beta Kappa Key May 
 
 WEST VIRGINIA UNIVERSITY. 
 Alpha of West Virginia. Organized December 5, 1910. 
 
 Catalogues. 
 1914. Narrow i6mo, pp. 16. 
 
 General. 
 
 David Dale Johnson. The Alpha of West Virginia. In The 
 Key, Jan., 191 1, i. 2. 1-12. Illustrated. 
 
 West Virginia University [petition to Phi Beta Kappa. Mor- 
 gantown, W. Va. 1910]. Oblong i6mo, pp. [13]. Illustrated. 
 
 See also The Key, October, 1914, ii. S. 257. 
 
 WESTERN RESERVE UNIVERSITY. 
 
 Alpha of Ohio. Organized October 28, 1847. 
 
 Catalogues. 
 
 1850. 8vo, pp. 12. 1905. 8vo, pp. 38. Compiled by Clar- 
 ence P. Bill. 
 
 General. 
 
 Clarence P. Bill. See Ph. B. K. Publ., N. S. 3, p. [6]. 
 
 Charles E. Gehlke. " The Alpha of Ohio. In The Key, 
 March, 1916, ii. 11. 515-17. 
 
 This should follow p. 511, 1. 3 of the preceding article; cf. p. 584. 
 
 . Western Reserve University. In The Key, March, 
 
 1916, ii. II. 505-14. 
 
 Really extends only to p. 511, 1. 3; cf. p. 584. 
 
 See also Ph. B. K. : information resp. institutions that have applied for 
 charters, 1904, p. 7. 
 
Volume 3 
 
 Number 9 
 
 
 rC-- 
 
 Goiftcnts 
 
 Page 
 
 Philosophia Bioii Kubernetes — A Poem . 363 
 
 Anniven^ry Exercises at Boston University . 364 
 
 General Peyton C. March .-- ; .• ' . 368 
 
 \The Original Phi Beta Ka,ppa Records . 371 
 
 A Phi Beta Kltppa Bibliograpy— Continued -, 385 
 
 In Memoriam ^ . . - . . 389- 
 
 Phi Beta Kappa News and Notes . . 396 
 
 ■; /■ 
 
 OCTOBER, 1918 
 
The phi Beta. Kappa Fraternity 
 
 DIRECTORY OF CHAPVeRS 
 
 With the number In the order of establishment, the Secretary, and the date, 
 
 / 
 
 it Atobomo— Alpha, of Alabama, TTniverslty, Prof. J, J. Doster, A, H. .^, .,-.. ....1851 
 
 S4 Alleghtny—Eta. of PennsylT^anla, MeadvUle, Prof. W. A. ElUott, L. «. D....190a 
 
 . 13 Amherst — Beta of Massachusetts, Amherst, Prof; Charles B. Bennett, Ph. D.. .1*53' 
 
 89 iSates-^Qamma of M%irte, Lewlston. Prof. Arthur N. Leonard, Ph. T>...^^. 1917 
 
 '78 Befoit—Beta of Wlsconstn, Beldit, Prof. Brastus G. Smith, (Ph. D. . - .. i. .. .. .1911 
 
 46 Boston — EJpBilon of Massachusetts;; Boston, Ada A. Cole, Ph/ p. 1899 
 
 6 Bowdoin— Alpha of Maine^ Bruns-w^ick, Prof. GeO. T. Biles, p4i. D. ; . ^.-. . ; 1826 
 
 7 Brown — ^Alpha of Rhode Island, Providence, Prof. James Q. Dealer, Ph. C 1830 
 
 43 CoH/omlfj^Alpha of California, Berkeley, Prof. Percival B. Fay,, Ph. D...:..18tt 
 82 Carleton — Beta of Minnesota, Nbrthfleld, Prof. Corvin H. Gingrich, Ph, D. ...1914 
 
 Bl CWcaffo-T-Beta of Illinois, -Chicago/ Evelyn M. Albright, Ph. D..;., ..1899' 
 
 48 Cincinnat'fr— Delta of u Ohio, Cincinnati, Miss Helen .^ Sts^nley,- SBTfr Zumsteln 
 
 , Ave ':.' , . . : ..-. . ... .1899 
 
 39 Ootbu — Beta Of Maine, Waterville, Trof. J. 'William JBlack, Ph. t» j . . . »,• T. 18 J« 
 
 24 Colgate — ^Eta of New York, Hamilton, Prof. F. C. French, Ph. X}.,.i.',.. :Y... .1878 
 65 Colorado JIniijeraU]/ — ^Alpha of Colorado, Boulder, Prof. F, -Hamalgy, Ph, D. . . .1904 
 M Colorodo^ CoKeje-*-6^a of <3olorado, Colorado Spr^ings," Prof. Albert R. Blllng- 
 
 wood, B. C. Oi., ., . .5.'. ......:...., . . .... . . ... : . . . . ._. ... .if.1904 
 
 21 OolumMa — Delta' of New York, New Tbrk City, Frederick W. Sohblz, A. M.. .. .i«5? 
 
 25 CoraeZJ— Theta of New York,, Ithaca, Prof. Albert LeE'py Andrews, Ph. D. . . . .1882 
 4 Z)«rtjjTdut/j— Alpha of New Hampshire, Hanovir, Harold G. Rugg, A; H. .. .1787 
 
 74 Jtenlson — Theta of Ohio, ffranvllle, Prof. W. A. Chanibe'rlln, Plk;D. ..^,..:,. .1911 
 29 -De Panw — Alpha of Indiana^ Greencastle, Prof . Joseph P. Naylor, Ms.. . ..... .1|889 
 
 26 DiSckinspn — Alpha of Pennfiylvanlai Carlisle, Prof. John F; Mohler, Ph* D. .;. .1887' 
 
 69 Pr-ankUn and Harshallr-^Tbeta, of Ppnnsylyania, Lancaster, Prof. W. B. Wels- 
 
 ' gerber," Ph. M ..^. . ..,....,. '. .i 1908 
 
 81 Georgia — ^Alplia of Georgia, Athens, Prof.|W. D. fiooper, A. M.'. , . 1414 
 
 %i Gaucher — 'Beta of Maryland, Baltimore, Miss Mary Patten, A. S^.. .....1905 
 
 70 GW«»6lJ-^E6ta;.of rowa, Grliinell, Miss Inez Henley, A. B. . . .y. , •••••; 1908 
 
 22 B'omiJtoji— Bpsilon of New^ife'k.'^l'^toS' Prof. J. D. Ibbotspni, Jr., A. M..>'^1876 
 3 Haruord— A-lpha of Maspachusetts, Cambridge, William C. La.rie, A. B.,. ;,. .17fli 
 
 ii Maverford — Zeta of Pennsylvania, Haverford, Prof. L. W. Reid^ Ph..t) ...li90 
 
 23 HtfBort— Zeta of New York, Geneva, Prof . Willis p. Woodman, Ph. D. ..'.... .1871 
 
 67 IlUnpla — Gamma of IlllnqjB, XJrl;ana, Pinof. Jacob Z'eitlirii Ph. D. .. .^ .....-;.: .1907 
 
 75 Indiana:r-rGa,mrna, of Indiana, Blobmington, Prof. Guido Stempel, Ph. D. ., . . . ,1911. 
 3,6 Joioc>— Alpha of Iowa, Iowa City^, Miss Bessie L. Pierce, A. M;. . . . .......:. . . .1895 
 
 SI Ja^s Mapkins- — Alpha of Maryland, Baltimore, Prof. Joseph T. Slngew^ldl 
 
 ' Ph. D. i ...... . ;...... ^ : . . ... . . . . .1896 
 
 31 ITowsos— Alpha of Kansas, Lawrence, Prof. J. ,G. Brandt, Ph. D. . . .,,.,. ..... .1890 
 
 •14 Kenyan — Beta of Ohio, Gambler, Prof.' E^^ymond D. Cahall, Ph; D.. 1858 
 
 87 Knox — ^Delta of lUlnois, Galesburg, Prof. J. L. Conger, PfaiD.. '.^.,..1917 
 
 . S2 Lafayette — Gamma of Pennsylvania, Easton, , Prof . Wm. S. Hall, Pli. D., ^4-890 
 
 79 ZiOt«re»6e— Gamma of Wisconsin, Appleton, Profl Louis C. Baker, Pb. O, .... ;1914 
 
 27 Lehigli — Beta of Pennsylvania, South Bethlehem, Prof. C. L. Thornbnrtr, Ph. I>.1887 
 
 16 Mariettas-Gamma of Ohio, Marietta, Miss Mary S. NjSwt<)n ,1860 
 
 77 afiatJt*— Iota, of Ohio, Oxford, Prof. Harlan Schwab, B. A. . .''. 1 ... .J . . .. ,W11 
 
 68 MUshiganr-^Aivba. of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Prof, John W. Spholl, Ph. D. , 1907 
 
 19 Middle ftiiri— Beta of Vermont, Middlflbury, Prof.. Chats. B. Wright, Lltt D....1863 
 35 Minnesota — ^Alpha of Minnesota, Minneapolis, Frederic K. Butters', Ph. D.. ..,J892 
 63 Mi«so«)-i — ^Alpha of Missouri, Columbia. Prof^' F. JW. Tisdel, Ph. U/. . . . .i. . . . . .1901 
 
 (Oonciwded on third page of cover) 
 
A PHI BETA KAPPA BIBLIOGRAPHY 
 
 By Prof. Clark S. Northup, Cornell '93 
 
 {Continued from Page 348) 
 
 WILLIAM AND MARY COLLEGE. 
 
 Alpha of Virginia. Organized December 5, 1776. 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 
 1855. Hugh Blair Grigsby. The Virginia convention of 
 1776. A discourse before the Virginia Alpha of the Phi Beta 
 ]\.appa Society, WilHamsburg, July 3d, 1855. Richmond, Va. 
 Randolph. 1855. 8vo, pp. 206. 
 
 1898. Herbert Baxter Adams. The study and teaching of 
 history. Phi Beta Kappa address at William and Mary College, 
 Williamsburg, Virginia, February 18, 1898. Richmond, Va. 
 Whittet & Shepperson. 1898. 8vo, pp. 18. 
 
 1900. Thomas Nelson Page. Character the true test of a 
 civilization. Delivered in the Senate Chamber, Richmond, Feb- 
 ruary 19. 
 
 1904. Albert Shaw. Address at meeting of the Phi Beta 
 Kappa Society held in Richmond, Virginia, April 13, 1904. Svo, 
 pp. 27. 
 
 On Thomas Jefferson. Reprinted (Jefferson's doctrines under new tests) 
 in his The outlook for the average man. New York, Macmillan, 1907, 8vo., 
 pp. 185-240, and in Representative Ph. B. K. orations, Boston, 191S, pp. 
 298-325. 
 
 1904. Lyon Gardner Tyler. Early courses and professors 
 at William and Mary College. Delivered December 5. An ex- 
 tract in The William and Mary College Quarterly Historical Mag- 
 azine, October, 1905, xiv. 71-87. 
 
 1906. Daniel Coit Gilman. Address [The significance of 
 a liberal education, by D. C. Gilman], and poem [The fount of 
 Castaly, by A. C. Gordon] ; delivered before the Phi Beta Kappa 
 Society of the College of William and Mary, at Williamsburg, 
 Va., Dec. 5, 1906. Richmond. 1907. 
 
 Poems. 
 i860. Thomas Dunn English. The two voices; a poem. 
 
 385 
 
386 Phi Beta Kappa Key October 
 
 Delivered July 4. In The Southern Literary Messenger, i860, 
 xxxi. 321, where will be found also the correspondence between 
 Professor Joynes, the secretary, and the author. 
 
 1897. Thomas Wentworth Higginson. - Harvard's greeting 
 to William and Mary. An ode read at the celebration of the Phi 
 Beta Kappa Society of William and Mary College, Friday, Feb- 
 ruary 19, 1897. In The William and Mary College Monthly, 
 March, 1897, pp. 216-8. 
 
 Reprinted in The Key, May, 1912, i, 8, 5-7. 
 
 1902. Robert Underwood Johnson. Italian rhapsody. Read 
 February 10. In The Atlantic Monthly, March, 1902, Ixxxix. 
 410-13. 
 
 1906. Armistead C. Gordon. The fount of Castaly. Read 
 Dec. 5, 1906. In The Key, March, 1914, iii. 3. 103-4- 
 
 Also published in a pamphlet with Dr. Oilman's address ; see above. 
 
 General. 
 
 Anniversary at the Alpha of Virginia. In The Key, March, 
 1911,1.3.22-3. 
 
 John Beqwn. His letters to his uncle from Williamsburg in 
 1779-80 are reprinted from The Wisconsin Aegis in The William 
 and Mary College Quarterly Historical Magazine, July, October, 
 1900, ix. 18-23, 75-83. 
 
 William Robertson Garrett. See Vanderbilt Orations and 
 Addresses, 1901. 
 
 John Lesslie Hall. The Alpha of Virginia since 1849. I" 
 The Key, March, 1912, i. 7. 36-40. 
 
 James E. Heath. John Heath. In The Key, March, May, 
 191 5, ii. 7. 317-26, 8. 365-73- Illus. 
 
 For his genealogy, see The William and Mary College Quart. Hist. 
 Mag., July, 1915, xxiv. 109-15. 
 
 The Raleigh Tavern in Williamsburg. In The William and 
 Mary College Quarterly Historical Magazine; January, 1906, xiv. 
 
 213-15- 
 
 Herbert Gushing Tolman. The Phi Beta Kappa in Virginia. 
 In The Vanderbilt Observer, November, 1905, pp. 7-12. 
 
 Lyon Gardiner Tyler. The College of William and Mary. In 
 The Key, March, 191 2, i. 7. 5-7. 
 
igiS A Phi Beta Kappa Bibliography 387 
 
 Abridged from his book on the college. 
 
 The making of the Union. Richmond, Va. 1899. 8vo, pp. 36. 
 
 Pp. 11-12 on Phi Beta Kappa. 
 
 . Original records of the $. B. K. Society, 1776-1781. 
 
 Edited by Lyon G. Tyler. In The William and Mary Colle<ge 
 Quarterly Historical Magazine, April, 1896, iv. 213-61. 
 
 . William Short, president of the #. B. K. Society, 1778- 
 
 1781. In same, pp. 261-3 ; port. opp. p. 211. 
 
 Photogravure facsimiles of parts of these minutes were pubHshed by 
 J. D. Warner in The D. K. E. Quarterly, October, 1886, and by the Cornell 
 Chapter in 1890. 
 
 Oscar McMurtrie Voorhees. The original Phi Beta Kappa 
 records. In The Key, May, 1918, iii. 325-35. 
 
 Our Phi Beta Kappa fathers and their fraternity [abstract]. 
 N. p., n. d. Sm. 8vo, pp. 3. 
 
 . Our Phi Beta Kappa fathers in fraternity and public 
 
 life. Delivered at the Ninth Triennial Council, Sept. 11-12, 1907. 
 In Phi Beta Kappa Publications, N. S. 6, pp. 11-26. 1907. 
 
 . Our Phi Beta Kappa -fathers in public life. In The 
 
 Key, May, 1912, January, 1913, i. 8. 7-17, 10. 34-8. 
 
 . The Phi Beta Kappa at William and Mary. In The 
 
 Key, March, 1912, i. 7. 8-26. Illustrated. 
 
 Noticed in The William and Mary College Quart. Hist. Mag., July, 1912, 
 xxi. 73. 
 
 . The Phi Beta Kappa past and present: its primacy 
 
 among American college fraternities. In The Delta Upsilon 
 Quarterly, May, 1908. 
 
 Also in Ph. B. K. Publ, N. S. 7, 1908. 8vo, pp. 8. 
 
 John DeWitt Warner. The first Greek-letter fraternity. In 
 The Delta Kappa Epsilon Quarterly, October, 1886, v. 15-30. 
 Facsim. 
 
 James Southall Wilson. The anniversary of the Alpha of 
 Virginia. In The Key, January, 1914, ii. 2. 83-4. 
 
 See also Ph. B. K. bulletin of information, 1903, p. 5 ; Ph. B. K. 
 Publ, N. S. 3, p. [3] ; The Key ii. 3. 155, 7. 355, iii. 2. 94, 5. 236; 
 The William and Mary College Quarterly Historical Magazine, 
 January, 1898, vi. 199. 
 
388 Phi Beta Kappa Key October 
 
 See also Ph. B. K. bulletin of information, 1903, p. 5 ; Ph. B. K. Publ., 
 N. S. 3, P- [3]. 
 
 WILLIAMS COLLEGE. 
 
 Gamma of Massachusetts. Organized July 30; 1864. 
 
 Catalogues. 
 
 1868. 8vo, pp. 33. 1887. 8vo, pp. 84. 1891. 8vo, pp. [20]. 
 1904. 8vo, pp. 52. The last three were compiled by Eben B. 
 Parsons. 
 
 General. 
 
 Eben Burt Parsons. See Ph. B. K. Puhl, N. S. 3, p. [8]. 
 
 THE UNIVERSITY OF WISCONSIN. 
 
 Alpha of Wisconsin. Organized February 2, 1899. 
 
 Catologues. 
 
 1917. 8vo, pp. 103. Compiled by Homer A. Watt. 
 
 Homer Andrew Watt. Alumni elected to Phi Beta Kappa. 
 By the Secretary of the Wisconsin Chapter. In The Wisconsin 
 Alumni Magazine, June, 1913, xiv. [458]-464. 
 
 Orations and Addresses. 
 
 1900. Richard Burton. The use of the dark in literature. 
 Delivered June 7. In The Forum, February, 1901, xxx. 752-60. 
 
 1903. Arthur Twining Hadley. What constitutes a liberal 
 education? Delivered March 27, 1903. Published in part in The 
 Independent, August 4, 1904, Ivii. 254-9. 
 
 1908. Edward A. Birge. The life of the college. Delivered 
 May 21. Published (A change of educational emphasis) in The 
 Atlantic Monthly, February 1909, ciii. 189-200. 
 
 Also delivered before the Minnesota Chapter in igo8. 
 
 Horace B. Lathrop. See Ph. B. K. Publ., N. S. 3, p. [17]. 
 
 Moses Stephen Slaughter. The Wisconsin Alpha of Phi 
 Beta Kappa. In Phi Beta Kappa, Alpha of Wisconsin, Catalogue, 
 1917, pp. [43]-44- 
 
 See also Ph. B. K. bulletin of information, 1903, p. 5, and The 
 Key iii. 3. 136, iv. 191. 
 
 (To be Continued.) 
 
Volume 3 
 
 Number 10 
 
 Contente 
 
 Our Captiin— A Poem ... 
 
 The Alpha of New Jersey 
 
 France and America . . . * . 
 
 President Crawford'js Quzurter-Centenpial 
 
 The Inauguration of President Neilson 
 
 The Inauguration of President Sills 
 
 Andrew Dickson White -. 
 
 Charles Richard Van Hise ' . 
 
 The Original Phi Beta Kappa Records 
 
 A Phi Beta Kappa Bibliograpy-r-Continued 
 
 InMemoriam . 
 
 Phi Beta Kappa News and Notes 
 
 x 
 
 403 
 404 
 434 
 455 
 460 
 462 
 463 
 468 
 470 
 482 
 491s 
 499 
 
 RUTGERS ClfAPTER NUMBER 
 JANUARY, 1919 
 
The Phi jBeta Kappa Fraternity 
 
 "^ DIRECTORY OF CHAPTERS 
 
 With the numbSr In the order of esta,blishment, the Secretary, and,, the date, 
 
 12 Alabama — ^AftJha, of Alabama. ^Jnlversity, Prof. J. J. Doster, A. M 1851 
 
 54 Alleghenu-r-^in. of Pennsylvania, MeadvlUe; Prof. W. A.. Elliott, L. H, D 1»02 
 
 13 Amherst — Beta of Massaphusetts, Amherst, Prof. Charles. E.Bertnett, Ph. D. ,.1853 
 
 89" Bates — Gamma of fijalne, Lewiston., Prof. Arthur IST. 0Le6nard, Ph. D , :1917 
 
 78 Beloit-i-BeU of Wlscpnsin, Beloit, Prof. ErastUsi G, Smith, Ph. X>... 1911 
 
 46 BojtOTi — Epsilon of JM^as&achusetts, Boston, Ada A. Cole, Th. B. ....'.... .7. .. .1899 
 
 6 Btiwdoin — ^Alpha of Maliie, Brunswick,. Prof , Geo. T. Files, Ph. D. ,..,.'.. ,.y .1826 
 
 7 Brown — Alpha of Rhode Island, ^royiden<?e, Prof. James'Q. Dealey, Plj. D..,,1830 
 
 , 4? tlalifi03'n,ia — ^Alpha of California, Berkeley, Prof. Harold L. Bruce, Ph.li. . . . . . .1893 ' ^ 
 
 i2 Oarletofi — Beta of Minnesota, Northfleld, Prof. Curvin' HT. tjingrioh. Ph. D 1914 
 
 61 CMcagQ-r-Betz, of Ill(noiSf Chicago, Evelyn M, Albi-ight, Ph, D,, . .i^, .,,;..... .1899 
 
 48 Cincinnaii — ^Delta of- Ohio, Cincinnati, HJIss Helen A. Stanley, 3676 -Zumsteln 
 
 ' Ave; ._../'.■.. C'.-X :.. % ;'.S ......... ,^. . / .'l899 
 
 39 Oo{6ir— ^Betfa' of Maine, tVtaterville, Prpt. J, WlUigjn Black, Ri. H , . . . , 1898 
 
 ( 24 Colgate— Eta. of New' York, Hamilton,"Prof. F. C, French, Ph, T>..'i\ , . 1878 
 
 55 Colorado Vniveraity — Alpha of C^radS; Boulder, Prof.F, Ramaley, Ph, I>....1904 
 , 69 Colorado College — Beta of Colorado, Coloradp Springs, Prof. -Albert R, ElUng- ^ 
 
 ■ ',wood,'B. C. L .'..,./,•;•... .,.,'. ,,>/, ,. ..;l'. ;...'.;.,. ., ..'.,,. . ,-. ..l'9p4 
 
 21 doiumbior— Delta, Of New York, New York Cit*^. Frederick W, Soholz, A^M.. . ..Ig'eg 
 25 CorrtsZ!— Theta of New York, Ithaca, Prof. Albert teRoy Andrews, Ph. D;. 1882 
 
 4 CortmoutTi— Alpha of New Hampshire. Hanover, Harold G. Ruas,. A. S 17,87 
 
 74 Deni^on — Theta of Ohio, Graijville, Proic, W. A. ChamberliOr Ph, D- .|.i...i9li 
 
 -29 De Pawtu— (Alpha of Indiana, GreeTicas3tle,^Prot, Joseph P. Naylor,,M. S.. .'.'.^ .1889 
 26' IJjcfciMaon— Alpha 'oi;_ Pennsylvania, Carlisle, Prof, John F, Mohler, Ph, 0, .'. .^SSII 
 
 69 Franklin and MarshaH-^heta, of Pennsylvania\ Lancaster,- Prof, W, E, "Welsr.' 
 ''"^ ; gerbe^, .Ph- M*. , . . , , , , . . . . .,-.., , .ISOS 
 
 81 ffeoj-ffio— rAlphi of Georgia,~Athens, Prof, iW. D, Hooper, A, M .1914. 
 
 64 GoMcfter-— Beta of Maryland^Baltiraore, SCiss Mairy, Patten, A. B,, 2008 Madison 
 
 Ave. - /. . .V . .' . .-.V'. ; . ;.....,.,. ,1905 
 
 70 Orinnellr— Beta,' of Iowa, Grinnell, Miss Inez Henley, '-A. B. ..'..'.......:...., . ,1908 ' 
 
 22 ff^wiZton— Bpsilon of New York, Clinton, iProf. /J. D. Ibbotson, Jr.,, A, M.i.^lSTO 
 3 Harvard — Alpha of Massachusetts, Cambridge, \WilUam'C. Lane, A. B. .,';.. 1,781 
 
 44 Haverford — Zeta of Pennsylvania, Haverford, Prof. L. W. ,R.eid, Ph, Di. ,'.... .1890 
 
 ZZ,. Hobart — Zeta of NeW; York, Geneva, Prof. Willis P. Woodman,. Ph. D.. 1871 
 
 67 ZIHnois— Gamma of Illinois, Urbana, Prof. Jacob Zeiflin, Ph. D. .....'..,... .dSOl 
 
 . '7'5 ZiMZiaMo-T^Gamffla of, Indiana, Blobmington, S'rof. Gul&o Stempel, A. M,. 1911 , 
 
 36 JoiSo— Alpha.o£'Ipwa, Iowa City, Miss Bessici L, Pierce,, A.' M,, ...,.,, .,,, ...1896 
 
 37 Johns Hopkins — Alpha of Maryland, Baltimore, Prof. Joseph T, Singewald, 
 
 Ph, D , ., ..y^.. ; . , .'.1895 
 
 31 jKonsas-^Alpha of Kansas, Lawrence, Prof. J, G, Brandt, Ph', D, , . . , . . .-; , . . , il89Q 
 
 14 .g:e»i,3/o«.^— Beta of Ohio,,,Gambier, Prof, RayrnondjD, Cahall, Ph. T>..'. .^ ..... .A85S 
 
 87 JSTnox-^Delfa ot Illinois, Galesburg', Prof,' j,aj.. Conger, Ph, D tC.v. 1917 
 
 32Ldfayet'te — Gamma of Pennsylvania, EastOn, Prof, Wm, S. pall. Pit. rt, •';,.. ..il890 
 ISLawrenee- — Gamma of Wisoonslh, Ap^eton, Prof, Louis C< Baker, Ph, !D.,.. .. ,19i4 
 ri £,ehigh—BetSi of Pennsylvania-, Soi^th Bethlehem, Prof, C, tr.,Thornburg,,:Ph, t).i887 
 
 .16 j/orieUa— Gamma of Ohio, Marietta, Miss Mary St. Newtpri. .:,.-. ...■,^.,. ,.,, .^'.1860 
 
 ■77 Mfami—Iot& of Ohio, Oxf&rd, Prof. Harlan Schwab, B. A. '. ,..1911 
 
 68, Jlf,fcftti/ajt— ,Alpha of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Prof. Joh:^ W..SchOll, Ph. D. . , . . . .1907 
 19 mddlebury—Betk of Vermont, Midaiebury/ Prof . Clias. B. Wright, Litt. P.;. ,11863 
 35 JWinnespto— rAlph.a of Minnesota, Minneapolis, Frederic It. Butters,- ph. IC. ...1891/ 
 
 53 Jlfi|«o,Mri— 'Alpha, of Missouri, , CloVumbia; Prof. F. M. Tisdel, FH. p..^ ,,.1901^^ 
 
 >- ■ (Concluded on third page of cover) 
 
 " -- ■ - V-,' . ' . /" 
 
1919 The Original Phi Beta Kappa Records ■ 481 
 
 voice, he was not initiated. f The business being finished an ad- 
 journment took place. 
 
 At a meeting of the $ B K, October 29th, 1779. 
 
 The president being absent, one was balloted for a majority ap- 
 pearing in favour of Mr. Brown, he resumed the chair. 
 
 The Clerk being likewise absent one was balloted for and a 
 majority was for Mr. Nivison. 
 
 In consequence of one of our Laws, we proceeded to the choice 
 of .two gentlemen to declaim on the Anniversary. Mr. Short and 
 Mr. Brown were elected for that purpose. 
 
 Mr. Fitzhugh and Mr. Cocke to write, and Messrs. Stuart and 
 Brent to argue. 
 
 The business of the evening being finished, an adjournment 
 took place. 
 
 Meeting convened the 13th November, 1779. 
 
 Ordered that the Gentlemen appointed to declaim and argue at 
 this meeting be continued therefor at the ensuing meeting. 
 
 A subject is directed on the following question : Whether a 
 General Assessment for the support of Religious Establishments 
 is or is not repugnant to the principles of a Republican Govern- 
 ment. 
 
 Mr. Brown discharged from appointment at last meeting to de- 
 claim on the Anniversary, and a Ballot taken for another person 
 in his stead — Mr. Stuart elected. 
 
 Ordered that summonses issue to convene the absent members 
 on the Anniversary. 
 
 Various Causes suggesting to this Society the Necessity of ap- 
 pointing a vice-president of this Body to reside in College, and the 
 insufficiency of former laws having occasioned delays in Business 
 and other inconveniences therefrom ; It is hereby declared a future 
 law of this Society, that a standing vice-president be appointed 
 who shall have the same powers, in the absence of the efficient 
 president that is given by Law, and it is ordered that this be 
 added to the standing Laws of the Society.* So much of any 
 former law as is repugnant to this is hereby repealed. 
 
 fit will be seen that the rule requiring absolute unanimity in elec- 
 tions to mernbership was fully enforced. This is the second occasion when 
 a candidate was rejected. 
 
 ♦This addition to the laws was not incorporated in the code already 
 printed. 
 
 {Te be Continued) 
 
A BIBLIOGRAPHY OF PHI BETA KAPPA 
 
 By Prof. Clark S. Northup, Cornell '93 
 
 (Continued from Page 388) 
 
 YALE UNIVERSITY 
 Alpha of Connecticut. Organized November 13, 1780 
 
 Catalogues 
 
 1806. 8vo, pp. 15. 1808. 8vo, pp. 16. 1813. 1818. 8vo, pj). 
 22. 1821. 8vD, pp. 23. 1823. 8vo, pp. 24. 1824. 8vo. 1826. 
 8vo, pp. 31. 1829. 8vo, pp. 36. 1832. 8vQ, pp. 35. 1835. 8vo, 
 pp. 39. 1838. 8vo, pp. 46. 1841. 8vo. 1847. 8vo, pp. 47. 
 1852. 8vo, pp. 50. 1898, for 1852-98. 8vo, pp. 126. 1905. 8vo, 
 pp.292. 1915. 8vo, pp. [ii], 359. Illus. 
 
 Orations and Addresses 
 
 1797. Charles Chauncey, Jr. An oration, delivered before 
 the Society of the $ B K ; at their anniversary meeting, in the city 
 of New Haven, on the evening preceding commencement, Anno 
 Domini 1797. New Haven. [1798.] 8vo, pp. 34. 
 On the advancement of the race in science, politics, and morals. 
 1797. Ebenezer Grant Marsh. An oration, before the 
 $ B K Society at their anniversary meeting, New-Haven, on the 
 fifth of December, 1797. Hartford: Printed by Hudson & Good- 
 win. 1798. .8vo, pp. 32. 
 
 1802. Eli Ives. An oration, on chemistry and botany ; de- 
 livered before the Phi Beta Kappa Society, at New Haven, De- 
 cember 9, 1802. Published by order of the Society. New-Haven: 
 Printed by Joel Walter. 1803. 8vo, pp. 16. 
 Mainly on the new science of chemistry. 
 
 1806. Samuel Farmar Jarvis. Want of patronage the prin- 
 cipal cause of the slow progress of American literature — An ora- 
 tion, delivered before the Society of Phi Beta Kappa, upon the 
 
 482 
 
1919 'i Phi Bctii Kappa Bibliography 483 
 
 anniversary of that institution, December 5th, 1806. New-Haven. 
 1806. 8vo, pp. 22. 
 
 Reviewed [by James Savage] in The Monthly Anthology, May, 1807, iv. 
 280. 
 
 1822. James Gates Percival. Oration delivered before the 
 $ B K Society, September loth, 1822, on some of the moral and 
 political truths derivable from the study of history. New-Haven: 
 Published by A. H. Maltby and Co., No. 4, Glebe-Building. 1822, 
 8vo, pp. 19. 
 
 Also in his Life and letters, ed. by Julius H. Ward, Boston, Ticknor & 
 Fields, 1866, pp. 523-39; see also pp. 116, 131. 
 
 1825. James Gould. An oration, pronounced at New Haven, 
 before the Connecticut Alpha of the Phi Beta Kappa Society, Sep- 
 tember 13th, 1825. New Haven. T. G. Woodward & Co. 1825. 
 8vo, pp. 31. 
 
 Reviewed in The l^ew York Literary Gazette, Nov. 18, 1825, i. 11. 173; 
 in The United States Literary Gazette, Jan. i, 1826, iii. 258-62. 
 
 1826. James Abraham Hillhouse. An oration at New 
 Haven, before the Society of $ B K, September 12, 1826, on con- 
 siderations which should influence an epic or a tragic writer irj the 
 choice of an era. New Haven. A. H. Maltby & Co. 1826. 8vo, 
 
 PP- 3^- 
 
 Also in his Dramas, discourses, and other pieces, Boston, Charles C. Lit- 
 tle and James Brown, 1839, ii. [6i]-99. Reviewed in The North American 
 Review, January, 1827, xxiv. 129-41 ; in The United States Reviezv and Lit- 
 erary Gazette, March, 1827, i. 462-3. 
 
 1827. Denison Olmsted. An oration on the progressive state 
 of the present age. Delivered at New Haven, before the Con- 
 necticut Alpha, of the Phi Beta Kappa, September nth, 1827. 
 New Haven : Printed by Hezekiah Howe. 1827. 8vo, pp. 24. 
 
 1830. Thomas Smith Grimke. Oration on the advantages, 
 to be derived from' the introduction of the Bible, and of sacred 
 literature, as essential parts of all education, in a literary point of 
 view merely, from the primary school, to the university : deliver- 
 ed before the Connecticut Alpha of the <I> B K Society, on Tues- 
 day, September 7, 1830. New Haven: Printed by Hezekiah 
 Howe. 1830. 8vo, pp. 76. 
 
 Also in his Reflections on the character and objects of all science and 
 literature, and on the relative excellence and value of religious and secular 
 education, and of sacred and classical literature. New Haven, Howe, 1831, 
 8vo, pp. [iii]-i62. 
 
484 The Phi Beta Kappa Key January 
 
 1 83 1. James Kent. An address delivered at New Haven, be- 
 fore the Phi Beta Kappa Society, September 13, 1831. New- 
 Haven: Printed by Hezekiah Howe. 1831. 8vo, pp. 48. 
 
 Published at the request of the Society. On "the beneficial influence 
 which the studies and discipline of such a literary institution [as Yale] 
 are calculated to have upon the morals and manners, the intelligence and 
 public spirit of the community." 
 
 Reviewed in The New England Magazine, October, 183 1, i. 362. 
 
 1833. Edward Everett. An address, before the Phi Beta 
 Kappa Society in Yale College, August 20, 1833. Published by 
 request of the Society. New Haven. Hezekiah Howe & Co. 
 
 1833. 8vo, pp. 35. 
 
 On the nature and efficiency of education. Repeated at Harvard, Au- 
 gust 30. Reprinted (The education of mankind) in his Orations and 
 speeches on various occasions, 2d ed., Boston, Little, Brown & Co., 1878, 
 i. 404-41. 
 
 Reviewed in The New England Magazine, January, 1834, vi. 89-90. 
 
 1834. James Abraham Hillhouse. An oration, pronounced 
 at New Plaven, by request of the Common Council, August 19, 
 
 1834, in commemoration of the life and services of General Lafay- 
 ette; New Haven. H. Howe & Co. 1834. 8vo, pp. 40. 
 
 1836. James Abraham Hillhouse. The relations of litera- 
 ture to a republican government. In his Dramas, discourses, and 
 other pieces, Boston, Charles C. Little and James Brown, 1839, 
 i2mo, ii. [ioi]-i43. 
 
 1837. Horace Bushnell. An address on the principles of 
 national greatness. Delivered August 15. 8vo, pp. 27, 
 
 Reprinted (The true wealth or weal of nations) in his Work and play, 
 or Literary varieties. New York, Scribner, 1864, pp. 43-77, and in Repre- 
 sentative Ph. B. K. orations, Boston, 1915, 8vo, pp. 1-23. 
 
 1838. Heman Humphrey. A discourse delivered before the 
 Connecticut Alpha of <I> B K at New Haven, August 14, 1838. 
 New Haven. L. H. Young, No. i, Exchange Place. Hitchcock 
 & Stafford, Printers. 1839. 8vo, pp. 23. 
 
 On maintaining high standards of higher education. 
 
 1839. Leonard Bacon. The proper character and functions 
 of American literature. A discourse, before the Society of Phi 
 Beta Kappa, in Yale College, August 20th, 1839. New York. 
 Office of The Biblical Repository. 1840. 8vo, pp. 25. 
 
 1840. Albert Barnes. Oration on the progress and ten- 
 
1919 A Phi Beta Kappa Bibliography 485 
 
 dency of science, before the Connecticut Alpha of Phi Beta 
 Kappa, New Haven, August 18, 1840. Philadelphia. Printed by 
 I. Ashmead. 1840. 8vo, pp. 40. 
 
 1842. Samuel Henry Dickson, M. D. An oration, deliver- 
 ed at New Haven, before the Phi Beta Kappa Society, August 17, 
 1842. New Haven. Hamlen. 1842. 8vo, pp. 47. 
 
 On the question whether knowledge leads to happiness. Reviewed by J. 
 L. Kingsley in The New Englander, April, 1843, i. 229-30. 
 
 1843. William Buel Sprague. An address, delivered Au- 
 gust 16, 1843, before the Society of Phi Beta Kappa in Tale Col- 
 lege. Published by request of the Society. New Haven : Printed 
 by B. L. Hamlen. 1843. 8vo, pp. 48. 
 
 On the responsibilities, the temptations, and the rewards of men of let- 
 ters. Reviewed in The New Englander, April, 1844, ii. 330-3. 
 
 1844. Willis Hall. An address delivered August 14, 1844 
 before the Society of Phi Beta Kappa in Yale College. New 
 Haven. B. L. Hamlen. 1844. 8vo, pp. 32. 
 
 On the productiveness of modern learning, and on utility as a motive 
 and a rule of human conduct. 
 
 1846. Daniel Dewey Barnard. Man and the state, social 
 and political. An address, delivered before the Connecticut Alpha, 
 of the Phi Beta Kappa at Yale College, New Haven, August 19, 
 1846. New Haven. Printed by B. L. Hamlen. 1846. 8vo, 
 
 PP- 51- 
 
 1847. Simeon North. Anglo-Saxon literature. An oration, 
 before the Connecticut Alpha of the Phi Beta Kappa, New Haven, 
 August i8th, 1847. Utica. Roberts, S. & C. 1847. 8vo, pp. 
 31- 
 
 On the literature of the Anglo-Saxon race. 
 
 1848. "Charles Brickett Haddock. The patriot scholar. An 
 oration pronounced before the Phi Beta Kappa at Yale College, 
 New Haven, August 16, 1848. Published by request of the So- 
 ciety. New Haven. B. L. Hamlen. 1848. 8vo, pp. 24. 
 
 1849. AsHBEL Smith. An oration pronounced before the 
 Connecticut Alpha of the Phi Beta Kappa at Yale College, August 
 15, 1849. Published by request of the Society. New Haven. B. 
 L. Hamlen. 1849. 8vo, pp. 32. 
 
 On the permanent and unchanging identity of the human race. 
 
 1850. John. Whiting Andrews. An oration pronounced be- 
 
486 The Phi Beta Kappa Key January 
 
 fore the Connecticut Alpha of the Phi Beta Kappa at Yale Col- 
 lege, New Haven, August 14, 1850. Published by request of the 
 Society. New Haven. B. L. Hamlen. 1850. 8vo, pp. 48. 
 
 On the characteristics of the last half century. 
 
 1851. Daniel Lord. On the extra-professional influence of 
 the pulpit and the bar. An oration in New Haven, before the Phi 
 Beta Kappa Society, of Yale College, at their anniversary meet- 
 ing, July 30, 185 1. New York. S. S. Chatterton, Printer. 1851. 
 8vo, pp. 20. 
 
 1853. 'Henry Boynton Smith. An address on the problem 
 of the philosophy of history, before the Phi Beta Kappa Society 
 of Yale College, July 27, 1853. Philadelphia. 1854. 8vo, pp. 30. 
 
 1854. William Henry Seward. Address before the Phi 
 Beta Kappa at Yale College, July 26, 1854. New Haven : Printed 
 by B. L. Hamlen, Printer to Yale College. 1854. 8vo, pp. 27. 
 
 On the forces and tendency of the republic. Reprinted in his Works, 
 Boston, Houghton, Mifflin & Co., 1884, 8vo, iv. [160] -178. An extract in 
 George E. Baker, Life, New York, Redfield, 1855,. 8vo, pp. [2911-295. Com- 
 ment in same, p. 169. 
 
 1859. William Strong. American legislation. 
 1862. Charles Tracy. The true and the false. An oration, 
 by Charles Tracy, Esq. ; also The Stars and Stripes, a poem, by 
 Rev. Charles D. Helmer ; pronounced before the Phi Beta Kappa 
 Society, at Yale College, July 30, 1862. Published by the So- 
 ciety. New Haven : Printed by E. Hayes. 1862. 8vo, pp. 47. 
 
 The oration fills pp. 1-22. 
 
 1866. Andrew Dickson White. The most bitter foe of 
 nations, and the way to its permanent overthrow. An address 
 delivered before the Phi Beta Kappa Society, at Yale College, 
 July 25, 1866. New Haven: Thomas H. Pease. 1866. 8vo, 
 pp. 36. 
 
 Reviewed in The New Englander, October, 1866, xxv. 758-60. 
 
 1868. Joseph Parrish Thompson. How to build a nation. 
 An oration before the Phi Beta Kappa Society, at Yale College, 
 July 22d, 1868. New Haven. Thomas J. Stafford. 1868. 8vo, 
 pp. 30. 
 
 1869. Emory Washburne. The college as an element of the 
 state. An oration pronouncad before the * B K Society of Yale 
 College, July 21, 1869. New Haven: Published by the Society. 
 1870. 8vo, pp. 21. 
 
1919 A Phi Beta Kappa Bibliography 487 
 
 1875. Theodore Dwight Woolsey. An address on the re- 
 lations of honor to poHtical life, delivered before the Society of 
 the Phi Beta Kappa of Yale College, July i, 1875. New Haven. 
 1875. 8vo. 
 
 1886. Daniel Coit Oilman. See Harvard Orations and Ad- 
 dresses, 1886. 
 
 1887. Theodore Dwight. What a Yale man ought to be. 
 8vo, pp. 29. 
 
 1887. Daniel Henry Chamberlain. Education at the South. 
 Address of D. H. Chamberlain, of New York, before the Yale 
 Chapter of the Phi Beta Kappa, at Linonia Hall, New Haven, 
 Conn., February 9, 1887. New York. Evening Post Job Print. 
 [1887.] 8vo, pp. 26. Cover-title. 
 
 1899. William Oraham Sumner. The conquest of the 
 United States by Spain. A lecture before the Phi Beta Kappa 
 Society of Yale University, January 16, 1899. Boston. Estes & 
 Co. 1899. 8vo, pp. 32. 
 Praised in The Dial, Oct. 16, 1899, xxvii. 267. 
 
 1906. Hanns Oertel. The quality of scholarship. An ad- 
 dress at the annual dinner. In The Yale Alumni Weekly, May 
 16, 1906, XV. [721]. 
 
 1907. Tracy Peck. Allocutio habita inter convivium sol- 
 lemne Societatis Phi Beta Kappa Yalensis in hospitio Neo-Por- 
 tuensi a. d. xv. Kal. Aprilis mcvii. 
 
 1908. WooDROw Wilson. The training of intellect. [An 
 address at the dinner, March 18.] In The Yale Alumni Weekly, 
 March 25, 1908, xvii. [637]-[639]. 
 
 Also in John Milton Berdan, John Richie Schulz, and Hewette Elwell 
 Joyce, Moiern essays. New York, Macmillan, 1915, 8vo, pp. 349-58. 
 
 William Oraham., Sumner. The early days of the Society 
 and what it means in Yale life. [An address at the dinner, March 
 18.] In The Yale Ahimni Weekly, March 25, 1908, xvii. [639]- 
 640. 
 
 Arthur Twining Hadley. Oermany and America and the 
 universities of the two countries. [An address at the dinner, 
 March 18.] In The Yale Alumni Weekly, March 25, 1908, xvii. 
 640. 
 
 1911. Bernadotte Perrin. Rooks. Delivered at the 131st 
 
488 The Phi Beta Kappa Key January 
 
 annual dinner, February zy. In The Key, March, 191 1, i. 3. 
 
 25-27. 
 
 Poems 
 
 1822. James Gates Percival began his Prometheus II as a 
 Phi Beta Kappa poem to be presented at the Yale meeting of this 
 year ; but his appointment was subsequently changed at his own 
 request to that of orator. Cf. Ward's Life, p. 116. 
 
 1825. James Gates Percival. Poem delivered before the 
 Connecticut Alpha of the Phi Beta Kappa Society, September 
 13, 1825. Published at the request of the Society. Boston. 
 Richardson and Lord. 1826. 8vo, pp. 40. 
 
 "Of Mind, and its mysterious agencies, And most of all its high cre- 
 ative power." Reprinted (The mind) in his Poetical works, Boston, Tick- 
 nor and Fields, 1865, ii. 126-55. 
 
 Reviewed by Henry Ware, Jr., in The North American Review, April, 
 1826, xxii. 317-33; reprinted by Julius H. Ward in his Life and letters, 
 Boston, 1866, pp. 239-41, cf. pp. 258-9. Reviewed by W. C. Bryant in The 
 United States Review, March, 1826; reprinted by Ward in his Life and 
 letters, pp. 237-g. Noticed in The Connecticut Herald, Sept. 20, 1825. See 
 also Ward, Life, pp. 116, 210, 215, 222-9, 233-9. 
 
 1826. James Gordon. Brooks. Anniversary poem delivered 
 at New Haven, Conn., before the Connecticut Alpha of the Phi 
 Beta Kappa, September 12, 1826. New York. Carvill. 1826. 
 8vo, pp. 28. 
 
 On the nature and haunts of genius. 
 
 1832. Alanson Hamlin. Poem on slavery. 
 Reviewed in The New England Magazine, September, 1832, iii. 259. 
 
 1839. Grenville Mellen. Our years. Read August 20. 
 8vo, pp. 52. 
 
 1845. Elizur Wright, Jr. A poem delivered before the Phi 
 Beta Kappa Society in Yale College, August 20, 1845. New 
 Haven : Printed by B. L. Hamlen. . 1846. 8vo, pp. 20. 
 
 1846. Daniel March. A poem delivered before the Phi Beta 
 Kappa Society in Yale College, August 19, 1846. New Haven. 
 B. L. Hamlen. 1846. 8vo, pp. 12. 
 
 On human life as a conflict. 
 
 1847. Luzerne Ray. The- coming age. A poem pronounced 
 before the Phi Beta Kappa Society of Yale College, August 18, 
 1874. New Haven. B. L. Hamlen. 1847. 8vo, pp. 16. 
 
1919 A Phi Beta Kappa Bibliography 489 
 
 Reviewed in The New Englander, April, 1848, vi. 311. 
 
 1850. Oliver Wendell Holmes. Astraea: or The balance 
 of illusions. A poem delivered before the Phi Beta Kappa So- 
 ciety of Yale College, August 14, 1850. PubHshed by request of 
 the Society. Boston. Ticknor & Fields. 1850. i2mo, pp. 39. 
 
 Never reprinted as written, except in his Poems, London, 1852. In the 
 Riverside Edition broken up into Spring, The study, The bells, Non-resist- 
 ance, The moral bully, The mind's diet. Our limitations. See Ives's Bibliog- 
 raphy, pp. 129-30. Reviewed in The New Englander, November, 1850, viii. 
 656. See William E. A. Axon, The Library, October, 191 1, 3d ser. ii. 
 356-62. 
 
 1851. Alfred Billings Street. The Pilgrim spirit. A poem, 
 delivered before the Connecticut Alpha of the Phi Beta Kappa 
 Society at Yale College, New Haven, July 30, 185 1. New Haven. 
 B. L. Hamlen. 1851. 8vo, pp. 16. 
 
 Not reprinted in his Poems, New York, 1867. 
 
 1858. William Allen Butler. Two millions. [Delivered 
 July 28.] New York. D. Appleton & Co. 1858. i6mo, 
 
 PP- 93- 
 
 Two editions were also published by Sampson Low, Son & Co., London, 
 1858, i6mo, pp. 96. 
 
 1861. Champion Bissell. A poem pronounced before the 
 Phi Beta Kappa Society at Yale College, July 24, 1861. New 
 Haven. Hayes. 1861. i2mo, pp. 18. 
 
 1862. Charles D. Helmer. The Stars and Stripes, Deliver- 
 ed July 30. See above under Orations and Addresses, 1862. 
 
 The poem fills pp. 23-47. , 
 
 1868. George Thurlow Dole. Yale revisited. A poem: 
 before the Phi Beta Kappa of Yale College, July 22d, 1868. Pub- 
 lished by the Society. New York. Thomas J. Stafford. 1869. 
 8vo, pp. 26. 
 
 1869. Edward Rowland Sill. The clocks of Gnoster-Town ; 
 or, Truth by majority. A poem, pronounced before the Phi Beta 
 Kappa Society of Yale College, July 21, 1869. New Haven: 
 Published by the Society. 1870. 8vo, pp. 11. 
 
 General 
 
 [Lyman Hotchkiss Bagg.] In his Four years at Yale, New 
 Haven, Charles C. Chatfield & Co., 1871, 8vo, pp. 223-35. 
 
490 Tlic Phi Beta Kappa Key January 
 
 Ebenezer Baldwin. In his Annals of Yale College, New 
 Haven, H. Howe, 1831, 8vo, p. 234. 
 
 Charles AIark Gill. The Phi Beta Kappa at Yale. In The 
 Key, October, 1912, i. 9. 4-21. 
 
 Phi Beta Kappa at Yale. In The Key, ]\Iarch, 1911, i. 3. 23-24. 
 
 Faron W. Wakefield. See Ph. B. K. Publ, N. S. 3, p. [3]. 
 
 The Yale Alumni Weekly. Phi Beta Kappa: an attempt to 
 interest freshmen in its work. January 13, 1904, xiii. 376-7. 
 
 Many other notes are scattered throughout the files of the Weekly, e. g. 
 xiii. 492, 780-1, xiv. 6gi-2, xv. 422, 507, 509, 580, 798-9, xvi. 521, 591, xvii. 
 490, xviii. 517, 533, 640, 657, 666-7, 988-9. For the other volumes, consult 
 the index. 
 
 Yale Chapter Phi Be"ta Kappa. Constitution, room regulations, 
 suggestions. 1898. 8vo, pp. 8. 
 
 The Yale chapter's 1320! banquet. In The Key, October, 1912, 
 i. 9. 27-9. 
 
 Condensed from The Yale News, March S, 1912. 
 
 The Yale Courant. The place of Phi Beta Kappa in academic 
 undergraduate life. Quoted in The Yale Alumni Weekly, March 
 25, 1908, xvii. 647-8. 
 
 . Recognition of scholarship. February, 1909. 
 
 Reprinted in The Yale Alumni Weekly, Feb. 10, 1909, xviii. 515-16. 
 
 See also The Key ii. 3. 155-6, 11. 543, iii. 5. 236. 
 
Volume 4 
 
 Number 3 
 
 Contents 
 
 Page 
 
 147 
 
 John Marshall ... 
 
 The Beta Chapter of Washington . .157 
 
 Theodore Roosevelt — A Poem .163 
 Some Phi Beta Kappa Administrative Problems 164 
 
 The Nu Chapter of New York . . 180 
 
 A Phi Beta Kappa BibUography .193 
 
 In Memoriam . . . . .196 
 
 Phi Beta Kappa New* and Notes . . 202 
 
 MARCH, 1920 
 
The Phi Beta Kappa Fraternity 
 
 DIRECTORY OF CHAPTERS 
 
 With the number In the order of establishment, the Secrtary, and the date. 
 
 12 Alabama — ^Alpha of Alabama, University, Prof. J. J. Doster, A. M 1851 
 
 64 Allegheny — Eta of Pennsylvania, Meadville, Prof. "W. A. Elliott, L. H. D 1902 
 
 13 Amherat — Beta of Massachusetts, Amherst, Prof. H. dePorest Smith, Ph. D..1853 
 
 89 Bates — Gamma of Maine, Lewiston, Prof. Arthur N. Leonard, Ph. D 1917 
 
 78 Beloit — Beta of Wisconsin, Beloit, Prof. Erastus G. Smith, Ph. D 1911 
 
 46 Boston — Epsilon of Massachusetts, Boston, Ada A. Cole, Ph. B 1899 
 
 6 Bowdoin — Alpha of Maine, Brunswick, Gerald G. Wilder, A. B 1825 
 
 7 Brown — ^Alpha of Rhode Island, Providence, Prof. James Q. Dealey, Ph. D..1830 
 
 43 California — Alpha of California, Berkeley, Prof. Harold L. Bruce, Ph. D 1893 
 
 82 Carleton — Beta of Minnesota, Northfleld, Prof. Curvin H. Gingrich, Ph. D....1914 
 
 51 Chicago — Beta of Illinois, Chicago, Prof. Henry W. Prescott, A. B 1899 
 
 48 Cincinnati — Delta of Ohio, Cincinnati, Miss Helen A. Stanley, 3576 Zumstein 
 
 Ave 1899 
 
 39 Colby — Beta of Maine, Waterville, Prof. J. William Black, Ph. D 1896 
 
 24 Colgate — Eta of New York, Hamilton, Prof. F. C. French, Ph. D 1878 
 
 55 Colorado University — ^Alpha of Colorado, Boulder, Prof. F. Raraaley, Ph. D....1904 
 59 Colorado College — Beta of Colorado, Colorado Springs, Roger H. Motten, A. M.1904 
 
 21 Columbia — Delta of New York, New York City, Frederick W. Scholz, A. M 1869 
 
 25 Cornell — Theta of New York, Ithaca, Leon A. Hausman, Ph. D 1882 
 
 4 Dartmouth — Alpha of New Hampshire, Hanover, Harold G. Rugg, A. B 1787 
 
 74 Dcnison — Theta of Ohio, Granville, Prof. Bunyan Spencer, B. D 1911 
 
 29 De Pauw — ^Alpha of Indiana, Greencastle, Prof. Joseph P. Naylor, M. S 1889 
 
 26 Dickinson — ^Alpha of Pennsylvania, Carlisle, Prof. H. M. Stephens, Ph. D 1887 
 
 69 Franklin and Marshall — Theta of Pennsylvania, Lancaster, Prof. W. E. Wels- 
 
 gerber. Ph. M 1908 
 
 81 Oeorgia — ^Alpha of Georgia, Athens, Prof. W. D. Hooper, A. M 1914 
 
 64 Gaucher — Beta of Maryland, Baltimore, Miss Marion Janney, A. B 1905 
 
 70 drinnell — Beta of Iowa, Grinnell, Miss Inez Henley, A. B 1908 
 
 22 Hamilton — Epsilon of New York, Clinton, Prof. J. D. Ibbotson, Jr., A. M 1870 
 
 3 Harvard — ^Alpha of Massachusetts, Cambridge, Prof. William G. Howard, A. M.1781 
 
 44 Haverford — Zeta of Pennsylvania, Haverford, Prof. L. W. Reid, Ph. D 1890 
 
 23 Hobart — Zeta of New York, Geneva, Prof. Willis P. Woodman, Ph. D 1871 
 
 92 Hunter — Nu of New York, New York, Prof. Luise Haessler, A. B 1920 
 
 67 Illinois — Gamma of Illinois, Urbana, Prof. Jacob Zeitlin, Ph. D 1907 
 
 75 Indiana — Gamma of Indiana, Bloomington, Prof. Guido Stempel, A. M 1911 
 
 36 Iowa — Alpha of Iowa, Iowa City, L. C. Raiford 1895 
 
 37 Johns Hopkins — ^Alpha of Maryland, Baltimore, Prof. Joseph T. Slngewald, 
 
 Ph. D 1896 
 
 31 Kansas — Alpha of Kansas, Lawrence, Prof. John Ise, Ph. D 1890 
 
 14 Kenyon — Beta of Ohio, Gambler, Prof. Raymond D. Cahall, Ph. D 1858 
 
 87 Knox — Delta of Illinois, Galesburg, Prof. J. L. Conger, Ph. D 1917 
 
 32 Lafayette — Gamma of Pennsylvania, Easton, Prof. Wm. S. Hall, Ph. D 1890 
 
 79 Lawrence — Gamma of Wisconsin, Appleton, Mrs. Adeline Link, Ph. D 1914 
 
 27 Lehigh — Beta of Pennsylvania, South Bethlehem, Prof. C. L. Thomburg, Ph. D.1887 
 
 16 Marietta — Gamma of Ohio, Marietta, Miss Mary L. Heller, A. B 1860 
 
 77 Miami — Iota of Ohio, Oxford, Miss Grace G. Glasgow, A. B 1911 
 
 68 Michigan — Alpha of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Prof. John W. Scholl, Ph. D 1907 
 
 19 Middlebury — Beta of Vermont, Middlebury, Prof. Chas. B. Wright, Litt. D 1863 
 
 35 Minnesota — ^Alpha of Minnesota, Minneapolis, Miss Clara Hankey, A. B 1892 
 
 63 Missouri — Alpha of Missouri, Columbia, Prof. George I. Dale, Ph. D 1901 
 
 iConcluded on third page of cover) 
 
A BIBLIOGRAPHY OF PHI BETA KAPPA 
 
 By Prof. Clark S. Northup, Cornell '93 
 
 (Concluded from Vol. in, Page 490) 
 
 PHI BETA KAPPA IN ATLANTA 
 Organized in 191 3 
 
 Has published nothing. 
 
 THE PHI BETA KAPPA ASSOCIATION OF BEIRUT, 
 
 SYRIA 
 Organized December 9, 1912 
 
 General 
 
 See The Key, Jan., 1913, i. 10. 43-4. 
 
 THE PHI BETA KAPPA CLUB OF BUFFALO 
 Organized December 2, 1909 
 
 Orations and Addresses 
 
 1919. Alexander Schwarcmann. The present state of 
 Russia. Delivered February 15. In The Illustrated Buffalo Ex- 
 press, February 15, 1919, p. 42. 
 
 Reprinted in The Key, May, 1919, iii. S72-g, under the title, The Russia 
 of the last Quarter-Century, with Special Reference to Bolshevism. 
 
 General 
 
 See Ph. B. K. Publ, N. S. 10, last p. : The Key, March, 1915, 
 ii. 356, March, 1917, iii. 135, March, 1919, iii. 565. 
 
 THE PHI BETA KAPPA ASSOCIATION OF CLEVE- 
 LAND 
 Organized March 20," 1909 
 
 General 
 
 Clarence P. Bill. See Ph. B. K. Publ, N. S. 8, p. 23. 
 See also Ph. B. K. Publ, N. S. 10, last page. 
 
 193 
 
194 The Phi Beta Kappa Key March 
 
 THE PHI BETA KAPPA ASSOCIATION IN THE DIS- 
 TRICT OF COLUMBIA 
 
 Organized December 6, 1913 
 
 Catalogues 
 
 1914. Register, etc. i6mo, pp. 20. 1917. Register, etc. i6nio, 
 pp. [22]. 
 
 Orations and Addresses 
 
 1914. James L. Slayden. Observations in Mexico Before 
 the Revolution. Delivered March 16. An abstract was printed, 
 one 8vo page, as No. 2 of the Association's Abstracts. 
 
 1914. Lieut. Clarence N. Hinkamp, U. S. N. Submarines 
 and torpedoes. Delivered November 20. An -abstract was print- 
 ed, one 8vo page, as No. 3 of the Association's Abstracts. 
 
 Poems 
 
 191 6. Percy McKaye. School. Read February 26. In his 
 The present hour, New York, Macmillan, 1914, 8vo, pp. 81-8. 
 Reprinted in his Poems and plays. New York, Macmillan, 1916, Part 
 i, pp. 81-8. 
 
 General 
 
 Frederik Atherton Fernald. The Phi Beta Kappa Associa- 
 tion in the District of Columbia. In The Key, January, 1914, 
 ii. 90-1. 
 
 See also The Key, October, 1914, ii. 256-7, May, 1915, ii. 403, 
 May, 1919, iii. 633, October, 1919, iv. 59. 
 
 PHI BETA KAPPA IN INDIANAPOIS 
 Organized in 1912 
 Has published nothing. 
 
 PHI BETA KAPPA IN KANKAKEE, ILLINOIS 
 Organized in 1912. 
 Has published nothing. 
 
1920 A Phi Beta Kappa Bibliography 195 
 
 THE PHI BETA KAPPA ASSOCIATION IN JAPAN 
 
 Organized January 8, 19 14 
 
 General 
 
 Ernest W. Clement, The Phi Beta Kappa Association in 
 Japan. In The Key, January, 1915, ii. 277-9. 
 
 The Japan Association at Tokyo. In The Key, March, 1914, 
 
 ii- 135- 
 
 See also The Key, March, 1917, iii. 136, October, 1917, iii. 
 235-6, January-March, 1918, iii. 319-20, October, 1918, iii. 397, 
 March, 1919, iii. 566. 
 
 THE PHI BETA KAPPA ASSOCIATION OF JERUSALEM 
 
 Organized July 31, 1918 
 
 General 
 
 John H. Finley. Perfume from the Orient. In The Key, 
 October, 1919, iv. 50-52. 
 
 See also The Key, January, 1919, iii. 500, May, 1919, iii. 632. 
 
 PHI BETA KAPPA IN MAINE 
 Organized Provisionally December 5, 1916 
 General 
 See The Key, May, 1917, iii. 187-8. 
 
 THE PHI BETA KAPPA ALUMNI IN MILWAUKEE 
 Organized November 24, 1916 
 Catalogues 
 1918. Pp. 24. 75 members. 
 
 General 
 See The Key, October, 1918, iii. 398-9. 
 
 THE PHI BETA KAPPA ASSOCIATION OF MONT- 
 
 PELLIER, FRANCE 
 
 Organized April i, 1919 
 
 General 
 
 Amos M. Matthews. Phi Beta Kappa meeting in France. 
 
 In The Key, October, 1919, iv. 60-1. 
 
196 The Phi Beta Kappa Key March 
 
 THE PHI BETA KAPPA ALUMNI IN NEW YORK 
 
 Organized April 28, 1877 
 
 Catalogues 
 
 1888. i6mo, pp. 17. 1897. i6mo, pp. 48. 1906. i6mo, pp. 
 85. 1908. i6mo, pp. 108. 
 
 Addresses 
 
 1879. Noah Porter. Science and sentiment. Delivered 
 April 21. In Science and sentiment, with other essays, New 
 York, 1882, pp. 9-37. 
 
 1882. Dexter A. Hawkins. Education in its relations to 
 pauperism and crime. Delivered March 13. Printed under the 
 title of The relation of education to wealth and morality, and 
 to pauperism and crime'. Bridgeton, N. J. News Power Plant. 
 1883. 8vo, pp. [ii], 20. 
 
 1883. Benjamin N. Martin. Scientific philosophy of soci- 
 ety. Delivered January 16. In The Journal of Christian Philos- 
 ophy, 1883, ii. 250. 
 
 1884. John Krom Rees. The new standard time system. 
 Delivered February 29. In The School of Mines Quarterly, Jan- 
 uary, 1884, V. 136-9. Folding map. 
 
 Reprinted in Knowledge May 16, 1884, v. 349-50. 
 
 1884. William Gilbert Davies. The law of mortmain in 
 reference to investments in real estate by corporations. Delivered 
 May 15. In his Papers and addresses. New York, 1907, pp. 175- 
 99. 
 
 Reprinted from the Statement of the Mutual Life Insurance Company 
 of New York. 
 
 1886. J. S. Newberry. The industrial arts as factors in civ- 
 ilization. Delivered May 20. A partial summary, under the 
 title, The industrial arts as factors in modern history, was print- 
 ed in Science, May 16, 1884, iii. 597-9. 
 
 1888. Borden P. Bowne. The anatomy of atheism. Deliv- 
 ered February 20. Printed under the title of The natural his- 
 tory of atheism in The Andover Review, August, 1888, x. 169-82. 
 
 1888. Richmond Mayo-Smith. Restriction of immigration. 
 Delivered May 10. In his Emigration and immigration, New- 
 York, Scribner, 1890, chap. 12, pp. 266-83. 
 
Volume 4 
 
 Number 4 
 
 Contents 
 
 Installation of the Beta of North Carolina 
 
 Theodore Roosevelt — A Poem 
 
 The Message of The Key 
 
 Morning — A Poeni ... 
 
 David Jayne Hill 
 
 Edgar Addison Bancroft 
 
 Col. Daniel Carroll Brent 
 
 Robert Edwin Peary 
 
 A Phi Beta Kappa Bibliography 
 
 Meeting of the Phi Beta Kappa Senate 
 
 In Memoriam .... 
 
 Phi Beta Kappa News and Notes 
 
 Page 
 
 211 
 226 
 227 
 234 
 235 
 238 
 239 
 240 
 245 
 251 
 254 
 266 
 
 MAY, 1920 
 
 IJ: 
 
The Phi Beta Kappa Fraternity 
 
 DIRECTORY OF CHAPTERS 
 
 With the number in the order of establishment, the Secretary, and the date. 
 
 12 Alabama — Alpha of Alabama, University, Prof. J. J. Doster, A. M 1851 
 
 64 Allegheny — Eta of Pennsylvania, Meadville, Prof. W. A. Elliott, L. H. D 1902 
 
 13 Amherst — Beta of Massachusetts, Amherst, Prof. H. deForest Smith, Ph. D..1853 
 89 Bates — Gamma of Maine, Lewiston, Prof. Arthur N. Leonard, Ph. D 1917 
 
 78 Beloit — Beta of "Wisconsin, Beloit, Prof. Brastus G. Smith, Ph. D 1911 
 
 46 Boston — ISpsilon of Massachusetts, Boston, Ada A. Cole, Ph. B 1899 
 
 6 Boiodoin— Alpha of Maine, Brunswick, Gerald G. Wilder, A. B 1825 
 
 7 Brown — Alpha of Rhode Island, Providence, Prof. James Q. Dealey, Ph. D..1830 
 
 43 California — Alpha of California, Berlceley, Prof. Harold L. Bruce, Ph. D 1893 
 
 82 Carleton — Beta of Minnesota, Northfleld, Prof. Curvin H. Gingrich, Ph. D,...1914 
 
 51 Chicago — Beta of Illinois, Chicago, Prof. Henry W. Prescott, A. B 1899 
 
 48 Cincinnati^— Delta, of Ohio, Cincinnati, Miss Helen A. Stanley, A. M., 3576 
 
 Zumstein Ave 1899 
 
 39 Colby — Beta of Maine, Waterville, Prof. J. William Black, Ph. D 1896 
 
 24 Colgate — Eta of New York, Hamilton, Prof. F. C. French, Ph. D 1878 
 
 56 Colorado University — Alpha of Colorado, Boulder, Prof. F. Ramaley, Ph. D....1904 
 59 Colorado College — Beta of Colorado, Colorado Springs, Roger H. Motten, A. M.1904 
 
 21 Colum,bia — Delta of New York, New York City, Frederick W. Soholz, A. M 1869 
 
 26 Cornell — Theta of New York, Ithaca, Leon A. Hausman, Ph. D 1882 
 
 4 Dartmouth — Alpha of New Hampshire, Hanover, Harold G. Rugg, A. B 1787 
 
 74 Denison — Theta of Ohio, Granville, Prof. Bunyan Spencer, B. D 1911 
 
 29 De Pauw — ^Alpha of Indiana, Greeneastle, Prof. Joseph P. Naylor, M. S 1889 
 
 26 Dickinson — Alpha of Pennsylvania, Carlisle, Prof. H. M. Stephens, Ph. D 1887 
 
 69 Franklin and Marshall — Theta of Pennsylvania, Lancaster, Prof. W. E. Weis- 
 
 gerber, Ph. M 1908 
 
 81 Georgia — Alpha of Georgia, Athens, Prof. W. O. Payne, Ph. D 1914 
 
 64 Ooucher — Beta of Maryland, Baltimore, Miss Marion Janney, A. B 1906 
 
 70 Grinnell — Beta of Iowa, Grinnell, Miss Inez Henley, A. B 1908 
 
 22 Hamilton — Epsilon of New York, Clinton, Prof. J. D. Ibbotson, Jr., A. M. ...1870 
 3 Harvard — ^Alpha of Massachusetts, Cambridge, Prof. William G. Howard, A. M.1781 
 
 44 Haverford — Zeta of Pennsylvania, Haverford, Prof. L. W. Reid, Ph. D 1890 
 
 23 Hobart — Zeta of New York, Geneva, Prof. Willis P. Woodman, Ph. D 1871 
 
 92 Hunter — Nu of New York, New York, Prof. Luise Haessler, A, B 1920 
 
 67 Illinois — Gamma of Illinois, Urbaina, Prof. Jacob Zeitlin, Ph. D 1907 
 
 75 Indiana — Gamma of Indiana, Bloomington, Prof. Guido Stempel, A. M 1911 
 
 36 Iowa — Alpha of Iowa, Iowa City, L. C. Raiford 1896 
 
 37 Johns Hopkins — ^Alpha of Maryland, Baltimore, Prof. Joseph T. Singewald, 
 
 Ph. D 1896 
 
 31 Kansas — Alpha of Kansas, Lawrence, Prof. John Ise, Ph. D 1890 
 
 14 Kenyan — Beta of Ohio, Gambler, Prof. Raymond D. Cahall, Ph. D 1858 
 
 87 Knox — Delta of Illinois, Galesburg, Prof. J. L. Conger, Ph. D 1917 
 
 32 Lafayette — Gamma of Pennsylvania, Easton, Prof. Wm. S. Hall, Ph. D 1890 
 
 79 Lawrence — Gamma of Wisconsin, Ajrpleton, Mrs, Adeline Link, Ph. D 1914 
 
 27 Lehigh — Beta of Pennsylvania, South Bethlehem, Prof. C. L. Thomburg, Ph. D.1887 
 
 16 Marietta — Gamma of Ohio, Marietta, Miss Mary L. Heller, A. B 1860 
 
 77 Miami — Iota of Ohio, Oxford," Miss Grace G. Glasgow, A, B 1911 
 
 68 Michigan — Alpha of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Prof. John W. SchoU, Ph. D 1907 
 
 19 Middlebury — Beta of Vermont, Middlebury, Prof. Chas. B. Wright, Lltt. D 1863 
 
 "Z Minnesota — Alpha of Minnesota, Minneapolis, Miss Clara Hankey, A. B 1892 
 
 63 Missouri — Alpha of Missouri, Columbia, Miss Emma Cauthorn, A. B 1901 
 
 (.Concluded on third page of cover) 
 
A BIBLIOGRAPHY OF PHI BETA KAPPA 
 
 By Prof. Clark S. Northup, Cornell '93 
 (Concluded from page 196) 
 
 1889. Henry Codman Potter. The place of the scholar in 
 American life. Delivered March i. In The Forum, July, 1889, 
 yii. 467-80. 
 
 See also Harvard Orations and Addresses, 1890. 
 
 1890. John Fiske. Thomas Hutchinson, last royal governor 
 of Massachusetts. Delivered March 24. In his Essays, historical 
 and literary, New York, Macmillan, 1902, i. 1-51. 
 
 1890. Augustus C. Merriam. Telegraphing among the an- 
 cients. Delivered May 26. Cambridge. J. Wilson & Son. 1890. 
 8vo, pp. 32. Papers of the Archaeological Institute of America, 
 Classical Series, iii. no. i. 
 
 1891. Thomas Randolph Price. Hedda Gabler — Ibsen's 
 dramatic method as compared vifith Shakespeare's. Delivered 
 June 2. In Shakespewiana, January, 1892, ix. i. 
 
 1892. Elisha Benjamin Andrews. The social plaint. De- 
 livered May 23. In The New World, June, 1892, i. 201-16. 
 
 Reprinted in Representative Ph. B. K. orations, Boston, 1915, pp. 216-32. 
 
 1893. RossiTER Johnson. Turning points in the American 
 Civil War. Delivered February 6. In Annual report of the 
 American Historical Asso'ciation for the year 1894, Washing- 
 ton,i89S, pp. 39-53. 
 
 1894. WooDROw Wilson. A literary politician [Walter 
 Bagehot]. Delivered November 22. In his Mere literature and 
 other essays, New York, 1894, pp. 69-103. 
 
 Also in The Atlantic Monthly, November, 1895, Ixxvi. 668-80. 
 
 1895. William R. George. The children's republic. De- 
 livered June 3. Substantially reproduced in The Junior Republic^ 
 an address delivered before the Society of Mayflower Descend- 
 ants <of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Monday, November 
 22, 1909, Philadelphia, Lippincott, 1910, 8vo, pp. 21, [i], and in 
 The George Junior Republic : its history and ideals. New York, 
 Appleton, 1909. 
 
 245 
 
246 The Phi Beta Kappa Key May 
 
 1896. Andrew Dickson White. Evolution vs. revolution 
 in politics. Delivered November 23. See Vassar Orations and 
 Addresses, 1906. 
 
 1897. Benjamin Ide Wheeler. Greece and the Eastern 
 question. Delivered February 20. In The Atlantic Monthly, 
 1907, Ixxix. 721-33. 
 
 1898. MoNCURE Daniel CoNVifAY. Personal recollections of 
 Tennyson, Carlyle, Dickens, Browning, and other English authors 
 of their day. Delivered May 20. Substantially reproduced in 
 his Autobiography, Boston, Houghton, Mifflin and Company, 
 1904, 8vo, 2 volumes. 
 
 1901. Jacob Gould Schurman. The Philippines, a retro- 
 spect and a forecast. Delivered February 27. New York. Chas. 
 Scribner's Sons. 1902. 8vo, pp. 109. 
 
 1901. Orville Hitchcock Platt. Cuba. Delivered June 
 14. Printed as Our relations to the people of Cuba and Porto 
 Rico, in the Annals of the American Academy of Political Sci- 
 ence, July, 1901, xviii. 145-59. 
 
 1902. Thomas Raynesford Lounsbury. Is English becoming 
 corrupt? Delivered February 17. In Harper's Magazine, De- 
 cember, 1903, January, 1904, cviii. 108-13, 193-8. 
 
 1904. William Elliot Griffis. Leaders of thought and 
 action in modern Japan. Delivered May 23. In part in The man 
 wh.0 rules Japan, in Hoinpier^s We'ekly, January 21, 1905, xlix. 
 
 92-3- 
 
 1905. Booker Talifferro Washington. The success of 
 negro education. Delivered March 9. Partly reproduced in 
 Twenty-five years of Tuskegee, in The World's Work, April, 
 1906, xi. 7433-50- 
 
 1905. William Hubert Burr. The Panama Canal. Deliv- 
 ered May 25. In Science, July 20, 1906, n. s. xxiv. 71-8. 
 
 1906. Barrett Wendell. The universities of France. De- 
 livered May 4. In his Impressions of contemporary France. In 
 Scribner's Magazine, March, 1907, xli. 314-26. 
 
 Also in The France of to-day, New York, Scribner, 1907, pp. 1-46. 
 
 1907. Andrew Carnegie. Peace — my plan for assuring it. 
 Delivered April 2. Substantially reproduced in A league of 
 
1920 A Phi Beta Kappa Bibliography 247 
 
 peace. A sectional address delivered to the students in the Uni- 
 versity of St. Andrews, 17th October, 1905. Boston. Ginn & 
 Co. 1906. i6mo, pp. [i], 47. See also The next stqp — a league 
 of nations in The Outlook, May 25, 1907, Ixxxvi. 151-2. 
 
 1912. Paul Elmer More. Science as a philosophy of life. 
 Delivered April 4. Published under the title of Huxley in his 
 Shelburne Essays, eighth series, Boston, Houghton Mifflin Com- 
 pany, 1913, pp. 193-244. 
 
 1914. Cassius Jackson Keyser. Science and religion, the 
 natural and the supernatural. An address delivered May 4, 
 1914, before the Phi Beta Kappa Alumni in New York. New 
 Haven, Yale University Press, 1914. Sm. 8vo, pp. [v], 75. 
 
 1914. [Edmund] Munroe Smith. Strategy versus diplo- 
 macy in 1914. Delivered December 14. Published under the title 
 of Military strategy versus diplomacy in Bismarck's time and af- 
 terwards, in The Political Science Quarterly, March, 191 5, xxx, 
 37-81, and reprinted therefrom for the Society. 
 
 Also in his Militarism and statecraft. New York, G. P. Putnam's Sons, 
 1918, pp. 1-167. 
 
 191 5. Frank Johnson Goodnow. Conditions in China. De- 
 livered March 12. Partley printed in Reform in China, in The 
 American Political Science Review, May, 191 5, ix. 209-24. 
 
 1915. John Erskine. Magic and wonder in literature. De- 
 livered May 24. In The moral obligation to be intelligent and 
 other essays. New York, Duffield and Company, 191 5, 8vo, pp. 
 [117H167I 
 
 Also delivered before the Amherst Chapter. Reviewed in The Book- 
 man, xlii. 727, The Dial, Ix. 117. 
 
 191 5. Henry Bruere. Memorial address [on Dr. Elgin Ral- 
 ston Lovell Gould]. Delivered December 9. In The Key, Jan- 
 uary, 1916, ii. 477-9- 
 
 Reprinted in the memorial volume privately printed by the League for 
 Political Education ; see The Key, March, 1917, iii. 138. 
 
 1916. Vi-Kyuin Wellington Koo. The Chinese outlook on 
 the world of to-day. Delivered March 10. Parts were substanti- 
 ally reproduced in his Chinese education, in School and Society, 
 August 5, 1916, iv. [i9i]-i94, and in What missionaries have 
 done for China, in The Missionary Reviem, October, 1916, xxxix. 
 
 763- 
 
248 The Phi Beta Kappa Key May 
 
 1917. John Huston Finley. Mobilization. Delivered March 
 26. In The University Record, University of Chicago, July, 
 1916, n. s. ii. 184-92. Also in part substantially in The Neiv 
 York Times, July 9, 1916, part 5, pp. 4-5. 
 
 Also delivered May i, 1916, before the Pennsylvania Chapter ; June S, 
 1916, before the Chicago Chapter ; and in 1917 before the Syracuse and Mt. 
 Holyoke Chapters. 
 
 1917. Fernand Baldensperger. Prophesying in time of war. 
 Delivered December 10. In The Columbia University Quarterly, 
 April, 1918, XX. 97-115. 
 
 1918. Stephane Lauzanne. France in arms. Delivered 
 May 23. Parts were substantially reproduced in France is not 
 bled white, in Current Opinion, June, I9i8,' Ixiv. 388-9, and in 
 To the last heartbeat, in The Forum, September, 1918, Ix. 310-12. 
 
 Poems 
 
 1879. Edgar Fawcett. The chorus of the rivers. Read 
 April 21. Published as The rivers in his Song and story: later 
 poems, Boston, Jas. R. Osgood & Co., 1884, 8vo, pp. 74-91. 
 
 General 
 
 Elgin Ralston Lovell Gould. In The Key, January, 1916, 
 ii. 475-80. 
 
 Nelson G. McCrea. See Ph. B. K. Publ., N. S. 3, p. [23]. 
 
 Phi Beta Kappa Alumni in New York. In The Key, May, 
 1914, ii. 182-4. 
 
 See also The Key, May, 1915, ii. 402-3. 
 
 THE PHI BETA KAPPA ASSOCIATION AT OXFORD 
 Organized in 1910 
 • General 
 
 See The Key, March, 1911, i. 3. 30, May, 191 1, i. 4. 44-6, 
 October, 1911, i. 5. 39, March, 1912, i. 7. 40-2. 
 
1920 A Phi Beta Kappa Bibliography 249 
 
 THE PHI BETA KAPPA ASSOCIATION OF PHILA- 
 DELPHIA 
 Organized April 16, 1915 
 
 Catalogues 
 
 1917. Sm. 8vo, pp. 45. 248 members. 
 
 Orations and Address 
 
 191 5. Henry Edward Crampton. Science, culture, and hu- 
 man duty. Delivered December 4. Published as Science, cul- 
 ture, and duty in The Columbia University Quarterly, June, 1916, 
 xviii. 259-71. 
 
 1916. Fairfax Harrison. The school of Hellas. Delivered 
 December 4. Previously published as The school of Hellas : an 
 address before the Virginia Classical Association, Richmond, Va., 
 November 27, 1914, by Fairfax Harrison. N. p. 1914. Cover- 
 title, pp. 16. 
 
 191 7. Alexander Meiklejohn. The college. Delivered De- 
 cember 8. Published as Freedom of the college in The Atlantic 
 Monthly, January, 1918, cxxi. 83-9. 
 
 General 
 
 1917. Nicholas Vachel Lindsay. The eyes of Esther. Pub- 
 lished as follows : The eyes of Queen Esther, and how they con- 
 quered King Ahasuerus. "Esther had not shewed her people nor 
 her kindred." — Esther ii. 10, 20. In Contemporary Verse, April, 
 1918, v. 49-51. 
 Reprinted in Current Opinion, July, 1918, Ixv. 54. 
 
 Poems 
 
 See The Key, March, 1915, ii. 355, January, 1916, ii. 495-6, 
 January, 1917,. iii. 95, January-March, 1918, iii. 319. 
 
 THE PHI BETA KAPPA ALUMNI IN SOUTHERN 
 
 CALIFORNIA 
 
 Organized in 1918 
 
 General 
 
 See The Key, October, 1919, iv. 59. 
 
250 The Phi Beta Kappa Key May 
 
 THE UPPER HUDSON ASSOCIATION OF PHI BETA 
 
 KAPPA 
 Organized February 28, 1914 
 
 Catalogues 
 
 1916. i6mo, pp. 15. 
 
 Orations and Addresses 
 
 191 6. Franklin H. Giddings. Double-entry education. In 
 The Unpopuhw Review, January, 191 7, vii. 151-63. 
 
 Poems 
 
 191 5. John Lewis March. The war and civilization. Read 
 February 27. In The Key, May, 191 5, ii. 387-94. 
 
 1917. John Huston Finley. Virgil's first eclogue remem- 
 bered. Read February 24. In The Key, March, 1917, iii. 119-22. 
 
 Parts of this were published at Thanksgiving time in 1916. New edition, 
 Thanksgiving, 1919, one additional page. 
 
 General 
 
 Morton Collins Stewart, The Upper Hudson Association. 
 In The Key, March, 1914, ii. 136-7, May, 1915, ii. 381-3. 
 
 See also The Key, May, 1916, ii. 585. 
 
 Postscript 
 
 On bringing this labor to a close, the compiler desires to thank most 
 heartily all of the chapter secretaries and his other numerous correspon- 
 dents who have helped in the making of this bibliography, and but for whom 
 it could never have been so nearly complete as it is. At the outset he 
 hoped to be able to print the names of these correspondents ; but the 
 list has grown to such proportions that this now seems to be out of the 
 question, and he trusts that all will agree with him that there would be 
 no real use in publishing such a list. 
 
 The first instalment of this biography was publised in May, 1913, and 
 the earlier parts of it are therefore quite in need of a supplement. In 
 view of this fact, and in response to some requests, the compiler hopes 
 after a time to issue a revised and enlarged edition. He will therefore 
 be most grateful for copies or notices of any works which should be 
 mentioned in such a list. He may be addressed at Cornell University, 
 Ithaca, N. Y. 
 
DIRECTORY OF CHAPTERS- (Concluded) 
 
 62 aft. Holj/ofco— Theta of Massachusetts, South Hadley, Prof. Helen E. Hoae, 
 
 ■*•• ^ • • -J , .1906 
 
 38 Weliroafca— Alpha of Nebraslta, Lincoln, Miss Margarpt, Hannah, A. M.! .'. .... !l895 
 
 18 New York City College — Gamma of New York, N.%., Prof. Alfred D. Compton, 
 
 ^b'O- ; ......r. , , ; 1867 
 
 15 New York Vninersity — Beta of New iTorK, N. T.^ Prof. W. Lyndon Wright 
 
 pii-- » .....,.....: .....'i8B« 
 
 S8 North Carolina — Alpha of Nprth. Carolina. Chapel Hill, Prof. T. J: 'W'llson, 
 
 Jr., Ph. D. , .........;i904 
 
 86 North Dafcoto— Alpha of North Dakota, Grand Forks, Martha E. Brodby, B. S..1914 
 
 30 Northwestern— Alpha, of Illinois, Byanston, Miss Margaret Mc'Cague, A. B 1890 
 
 66 0perlin — Zeta of OhfqJ'Oberlin, Prof. Frederick O. Grover, A. M 1907 
 
 61 Ohio Stcrte— Epsjlon of Ohio, Col'um^USi Prof.- Charles W. Reeder, M. A, 1904 
 
 66 Ohio Wealeyan — Eta of 6hio, Delaware, Prof. William E. Sjnyser, A. M 1907 
 
 84 Pennsylvonio— Delta of Pen'iiisylvania, Philadelphia, Prof. George Depue Hadx- 
 
 slts. Ph. D. ... .^, . .'. ......'. , .>1892 
 
 80 Pomona — Gamma , of XIalifprnia, Clariemont, Miss Grace E. Berry, Ph. D 1914 
 
 49 Prtnoeton— Beta of New Jersey, Princeton, Prof. Edmund Y.Robhins, Ph. D...1899 
 
 84 2JodeKjy«— Iota of Massachusetts, Cambridge, Caroline B, Shaw, A. & 1914 
 
 * 8> Sandoliih-ilfacon— Delta of "Virginia, Lynchburg, Prof. Herbert C. Lipscomb, 
 
 Ph. D 191J 
 
 28 Roahemtvr — Iota of New Tork, Rochester, Prof. John R. Slater, Ph. D •J;?*'' 
 
 20 But^jcrs-^Alpha of New 'Jersey, New Brunswick, Prof. A. C.^ deRegt, Ph. D. . . .1869 
 
 66 Snftth — ^Zeta of Massachusetts, Northampton, Prof, Laura S. Clarkr A. M 191)4 
 
 57 S{oi»t/or(J— Beta of California, Stanford'tJniversity, O. L. Bllidtt, A M.. ....,.> .1904 
 
 ' 60 -St! X/Owr«nce^Laiifbda of New York, Canton, Prof.vRobt. D. Ford, M. S... .. 1899 
 
 41 Swarthhmore — Epsilon of Pennsylvani?., Syrairthmorfe, Mrs. Helen B. S. Brin- 
 
 '' ton, A Mt aiedJa, Pa .\ .. .1896 
 
 40 Syracuse — ^kappa of New York, Syracuse, Prof. W. H. Metzler, Ph. D...;..1896 
 
 63 , TeirosTrrAIplia of_ Texas, Austin, Anna Belle May, A. B.. !....'.. 1905 
 
 8 Trtnity — Beta of Ct. Hartford, Prof.*ArthUr Adams, Ph. D. .'. ■ .1845 
 
 33 Tit/ts*-Delta of Massachusetts, Tufts College, Prof. W. R. Ransom, A. M....1892' 
 
 72 Tulane — ^Alpha of Louisiana, New Orleans, Prof.' Imogen ' Stone, A. ,M 1909 
 
 6 Union — ^Alpha of New York, Schenectady, Prof. Morton C. Stewart, Pti. D^. . . .1817 
 
 52 VanderWZt— Alpha of Tehnefeee, Nashville, Trof. ^. T, McGill, Ph. D....... 1901 
 
 ''47 Tosaar— ^Mu of New "S^^kl Poughkeepsie, Elizabeth W. Amen, A. B. ....'..;. .1899 ' 
 
 11 Vermont — ^Alpha of Vermont, Burlington, Mary Russell Bates, Ph. B. 1848 
 
 71 Vtrijrinta>— Beta Of Virginia, Uniyerslty, Prof.^ohii J, Luck, Pi. D. .......... .1909 
 
 42(Tt'a6dafc— Beta of Indiana, CraWfOrdsvHle, Prof . James H. . OsbornS A. M.'. ..1898 
 
 76 WasMngton and Lee-rT-aa.ram3, of Virginia, Lexington,; J. W. Kem,-Ph. D . .1911 
 
 83 WasWnfiton Stof e^-^Aft)ha,. of Washhieton, Seattle, Prof. F. M. Padelford, Ph. I>:1914 
 86 Washington Vnioersity^^^ta. of Missouri, St. Louis, Prof. Hunley W. Herring- 
 ton, Ph. b. .^.. . i .........>....,-........ 1914 _ 
 
 60 WellesTey — Eta of Massachusetts, Wellesley, ProfT Alice Wa,lton, Ph. D...*.. 19,04 
 * Wesleyan — Gamma of Connecticut, Middletown, Prof. F. W. Nioolson, A. M..1846 
 10 Western Reserve — Alpha Of Ohio, Cleveland, Prof. Charles B. Gehlke, Ph. D,,1847 ! 
 
 73 west Vtromtd^-Alpha'^f Wfest, Vi^ginia, Morgantown, Prof. M. Strathers, Ph.D.i910 
 
 Ph. D .:.........:. .^, , . , , r . . . .1910 
 
 1 William am ifory-r^Alpha of Virginia, Williamsburg, JProf.,- John L. Hall, Ph. D..1776 
 17 Williams — Gamma of Massachusetts, WlUlamatoWn, Prof. Samuel B. Allen, 
 
 A. M ^. . . .-. . .-. . . . . <. 1864 
 
 46 Wisconsin — ^Alpha'of Wisconsin, Madison, Prof. Bayard Q. Morgan, Pi. D 1899 
 
 3 YoZe-^Alpha of Coraiecticut, New Haven, Prof. HoHon A, Farr, !Ph.D 1780 
 
/^ 
 
 J. F. NEWMAN 
 
 JEWELER 
 
 New York Chicago Kansai City- San Franciico 
 
 Announcement 
 
 By . authority of the ' National 
 Council of the United Chapters of 
 Phi Beta Kappa', J. F. Newman, of 11 
 John-Street, New York, N. Y., has, 
 been appointed sole official jeweler 
 to the fraternity. All orders for 
 keys should be sent to the office of 
 the United Chapter&on order fonns 
 which m^ay be secured froih chap- 
 ter secretaries. Write your chap- 
 ter for informationbefore ordering. ; 
 
 OSCARM.VOORHEES,Sec'y. 
 
 350East 146th Street, 
 NewYork.N.Y. 
 
 ^ " ^ 
 

 
 H*^^. 
 
 -k^-i 
 
 *.* 
 
 '■y •*-■>? 
 
 
 i 
 
 si^