The Association of the Bar of the City of New York. : V < -^ -*- i< , V'/ ^€ ^^^ y. c(* " ^ ^ . ■' ^ '^1 'K..^. )^^x *< ^ i H< ^- '^J^""^^^^--"- --^''' V \ r 4. ' pf^ ^ rs^ ^^x% :C''' ^nt .i* . * '.C 3, 1-P n/v '^^'^"-:^ -n-'^i. "^^"^^ T7 V -^ .> ^ ^)^ y^ r-,^ 'S .,;■. , , it , W' fe>iFi ^^ fe. %«^-.|l:.4f#.#.:|^J »«-"■ te -5^', W ■.tst;':'f '•m- .4 "^Y.'f.",?.!,.*'?,^. .*.??°<='a"°" of the bar of -!?y' '♦*K^ T- ^ i 3 1924 01 KF334.N56Ta7'""""''"''"^'' 'w'it '«© ^ Cornell University Library The original of this book is in the Cornell University Library. There are no known copyright restrictions in the United States on the use of the text. http://www.archive.org/details/cu31924018771299 [R eview OF THE Association of the Bar OF THE City of New York Together with Portraits and Autographs ot Oftlcers and Members Brought Down to the Year 1900 BY FRANK THOMPSON NEW YORK : STUMPF & STEURER, Publishers. Copyrighted Iggg PRESS OF THE AMERICAN LAWYER 29 MURRAY STREET NEW YORK. ANNOUNCEMENT. There being no other illustrated review extant of the history of the Association of the Bar of the City of New York, the following- pages possess the merit of originality, and as such should appeal to the favorable consideration of the fraternity. Among the members of the New York Bar there have always been names of the highest eminence in jurisprudence. A considerable majority of the lawyers actively en- gaged in practice in the higher courts are membeis of this association at the present time. A series of photographs, and the signatures of the more prominent among these gentlemen, which this volume presents, must also enhance its interest and value. These are arranged in the sequence of the admission of their subjects to membership in the as- sociation. The building which was erected for the use of this organiza- tion is a work of the highest architectural beauty and utility. A num- ber of illustrations depicting details of its construction are given in these pages. Frank Thompson. Ill CONTENTS. PAGES Portrait of James C. Carter, President, ... vii History of the Association, . . . . 1 to IS Exterior and Interior Views of the Association Building, . 17 " 3? Group Portraits of Ex-Presidents and Otticers of the Association, 37 " 63 Autographs of Ex-Presidents and Officers, . . 6S " 68 Portraits of Members, . . . . . 69 " 108 Autographs of Members, . . . . Ill " 148 Index, 149 " 152 Note : — The date underneath each member's portrait shows year of admission to the association. '-^ (f. (^^^^:^ PRESIDENT 1S84 and 18S5. 1897 to 1900. Vll REVIEW OF THE ASSOCIATION OF THE BAR OF THE CITY OF NEW YORK. """^^ HE careful consideration of the history of those few years which inimediatelv preceded our Revolution must inevitably cause the student's attention to he directed to the unanimity which existed among members of the legal profession in New York City in opposing the exactions of the British Govern- ment. While a few members of the bar, the De Lanceys, hlarrisons and Clarkes, constituted themselves the champions of the Crown, the main body under such leaders as Livingstone, Smith, Morris and Alexander staunchly defended the cause of the people and aided in the work of preparing this state when the moment arrived to join with the other colonies in casting otf allegiance to the mother country. Though no formal association seems ever to have existed as such, there was a con- tinuous and sustained effort against royal oppression, nor was there ever a time when the cause of liberty lacked a defender from among the ranks of the bar. One of the earliest cases to which we may point for illustration was destined to settle for all time in New York the question of the liberty of the press. Upon the death of Governor Montgomery, his place was tilled for a short time by Mr. Rip Van Dam, President of the Council, until the arrival of Colonel William Cosby, his successor, in August, 1732. The first act of the new governor was to bring pro- ceedings against Van Dam to recover half of the salary received by the latter as acting governor, his claim being founded upon a]i order directed to Van Dam and emanating from the Council in England. Van Dam resisted, and at the trial was defended by William Smith and James Alexander, the leaders of the Nev/ York City bar, who boldly denied the authority of the Royal Council or even of the King himself, without the consent of Parliament, to legislate tor New York, making in fact, though not of course in name, an appeal for independence.' Chief Justice Morris delivered an opinion in favor of Mr. Van Dam, his associates De Lancey and Philipse dissenting. The enraged Governor at once removed him, appointing De Lancey in his stead. Shortly afterwards, the New York Weekly Journal was started under the patronage of Van Dam, who used it as an engine against the Government, many of its articles being written by Smith and Alexander. In 1734, a suit for libel was instituted against the publisher, John Peter Zenger, and at the trial Smith and Alexander objected to the validity of the judges' appoint- ments upon the ground that they had been made " during pleasure " and not " during good behavior." The point was also raised that Chief Justice Morris had been improperly removed from office, this having been done without the consent of Council. De Lancey immediately disbarred them. " You have brought it to the point," he said, " that either we must go from the bench or you from the bar." - Their place was immediately taken by Andrew Hamilton, a member of the Phila- delphia Bar, and in spite of the fact that the Chief Justice refused to permit the truth of the article to be shown and charged the jury that they must convict, he secured a verdict of acquittal. Undeterred by the example of his predecessors, Lieutenant Gov- ernor Cadwalader Colden, in 1763, undertook to enforce the doctrine that an appeal might be taken to himself and council from a decision of a common law court upon which not only the rulings of law but also the findings of fact might be reviewed. This action the entire bar de- clared unconstitutional, and such appeals the judges refused to admit, the Chief Justice (Horsemanden) delivering an address in Council giving his reasons for the action taken by him, which was afterwards printed and circulated to the infinite resentment of Colden.^ Not a single lawyer could be found by the Lieutenant Governor who was willing to argue his cause. This course of action upon the part of the legal fraternity induced Colden to bitterly attack the New York Bar in his correspondence with the Home Government and to complain of the (1) Meiiu.riiil Histoiy i.f the City of New York, Vi.l. II, p. ai8. (lil Memurial History of New York City. Vol. II, p. 'J40. (3) Lamb's History ot the City of New York, Tol. I, p. 712. pernicious intluence exercised by them. "Whatever be done in this place," he observed in a letter to Sir William Johnson, dated December 10, 17M, " 1 am very confident 1 shall have it in my power to humble them and to curb their licentiousness alter this, though 1 now stand alone in this dispute without any assistance." ' Mr. Henry B. Dawson traces the origin of the Sons of Liberty to a still older combination of the members of the New York City Bar, formed about the year 1744, to render the judiciary free and independ- ent from the exercise of kingly prerogative. It is of course, highly im- probable that this earlier association was anything more than a general reform movement under the guidance of a few leading minds; but while these early combinations of New York attorneys have not of course the slightest connection with our present bar association, they show the interest that the lawyers of this State have ever taken in public matters, and their continued efforts to promote the cause of good gov- ernment and the liberties of the people. The real history of the Association of the Bar may be said to begin with the year 1870. " For several years after the war," as one writer has remarked, " there was a perfect witches' Sabbath of political cor- ruption in New York City, which culminated during the mayoralty of Oakey Hall, who was elected in 1869-"" There ensued what another author has characterized as a " saturnalia of injunctions and re- ceiverships." Urged on by the " Times " and " Harpers' Weekly," a crusade was begun against the power of the Tweed Ring. " If it be the supineness, the guilty silence of the lawyers, as ofiicers of the people's courts, which have brought us to our present pass," said the " Times " in an editorial published on December 16, 1869, " it is their reawakened public spirit and activity which must help us back to a better state of things ; we must again proclaim that the bar must lead the way." For some time previous, a number of New York attorneys had con- ferred with a view to an organization directed to this end, and the fol- lowing pledge had been circulated for signatures : (1) " TIk:-. Sons of Li))ertj," ii pain-r read Ix^fnre tbe New York Hi.storiual Society, May 3, 1859, by Henry E. Dawson. Cj) Tlistoi-y ol'N'cw Ynrk City, by 'I'lieodore E. *Henry Niccill. William Allen Bullcr. *John Iv. Porter. *A. ]. Vanderpoel. *C. Van Santvoord. *Thos. C. T. Buekley. D. B. Eaton. '■'A. UnderhiU. *D. D. Lord. *F. N. Bangs. *Henry H. Anderson. * Edwards Pierrepunt. *E. H. Owen. H. J\I. Alexander. *Ashbel Green. *Wm. .Al. Prichard. Wm. G. Choate. Richard S. Emmet. *Clarkson N. Potter. *Thos. H. Rodman. *B. F. Dunning. *John J. Townsend. Sidney Webster. C. A. Seward. *Charles M. Da Costa. *Aug. F. Smith. Luther R. Marsh. Joseph H. Choate. Chas. F. Southmayd. *Waldo Hutchins. *Lucien Birdseye. *Charles P. Crosby. *Beniamin K. Phelps. Abraham R. Lawrence, Jr. *Charles Coudert, Jr. *L. L. Coudert. John Erving. *John PL Piatt. *S. J. Tdden. H. M. Ruggles. Everett P. Wlieeler. *Charles A. Rapallo. *Charles P. Kirkland. W. W. Macfarland. Charles A. Davison. F. R. Coudert. *Charles Jones. *C. J. De Witt._ J. Frederick Kernocham. *T. W. Edmunds. William Hikh-etli Field. *Charles H. ( m i\'er. Buchanan Winlhmp. '■'Frank E. Kernnchan. *Pece" Anderson. '■'Jris. B. Lawrence. "'Charles E, Stn mg. A. P. AYhitehead. '^'T. R. Strong, '■'Wm, J, Hoppin. '•'Lewis L, Delafield, '^'Charles E, Blake, '■'Livingstiin K, Miller Wm. S. Opdvke, Jolm E, Ward, Charles B, Sp'Ughton. .■Mbert Mathews, Fl;inKn B. Candler, '■'Philo T. Ruggles, '^'B. Roelker. '■'William Tracy, '■'Frederick Kapp. Edmund Weliiiorc. C. A, Hand. *h\ H. Churchill. '■'Henry E. Davies. '■'R, yi. Harrison. '^Robert Sewell. E. G. Drake, jr. Henry B. Hammond. '^'W. Q. ;\Iorton. '■'Henry Whittaker. '■'Thomas M. Wheeler. Charles E. Whitehead. '■'John N. W'hitmg. '■'t;. M. Ogden. '■ Cadwallader E. Ogden. '■Robert Benner. Elbridge T. Gerry. '■'Cliarles Tracy. '■Charles Edward Tracy. J, Evarts Tracy. '■'George De Forest Lord. '■'lohn C. Dinimick. j" S. Winter. '■'jMshua .Al. Van Cott. '■'George W. Parsons. '■'Hiram Barney. '■'John Sherwood. '■'Walter L, Livingston. .Albert Stiekney. '■'Henry .\. Tailer. .-Alfred L. Edwards. .Aug. R, Alacdonough. A\',' A\'. Goodrich. '■'S. Alerrihew. D. C. A^an Cott. '■'Beverly Robinson, AA'illiam Jay. John A. W'eeks, '''Hooper C, A'an A^orst. '■'George H, Fcjrster. James F. Dwight. James C. Carter. Tos. Laroeque. '■'W. Stanley. '''Francis C. Barlow. '■'Charles H. Hunt. John S. Davenport. '■'Jiihn J. Latting. John L. Cadwalader. '''Edward H. .Anderson. '■'Charles Nettkton. '■'Jolm .A, Foster, '■'Smith E. Lane. Thomas E, Stillman. Hlial F. Hall. *Ecls-ar S. Van Winkle. -Thomas C. Ihkitsi.H. *Jiilin M. Kiiii.K. Cli. iM-ancis Stone. Ivicli.inl 11. (.'larke. llcrhert V>. Tnrnci-. (k'orux- W. Sorcn. Thoin.is 11. Ilnljliard. *Chark-s r. Kirklanil, Jr. Ccnrue Al. Miller. '.Morns S. Miller. ^Mohn Mclveon. Wheeler !l. I'eckhain. ^'John (k Vose. *Charles I'k I'.iUler. ■Theeideire W. Dwight DwiKlit II. Olnislead. "S. V. Xash. 'Oscar Smedberg. *James 1. ko(.)se\ell. *Sanuiel K. L\on. ■■■dlenr\- J. Scudder. ''Frederick Iv Aiather. *Alexander Hamilton, Jr. '' Townseiid Scndder. William Watson. *David Dudley Field. himes P. Fo\vre\-. John II. Kislev. *F. W. Stougiiton. "fleiiry D. Seikguick. C. Ik Wdieeler. *Janies hkiiott. ''Richard H. Bouiie. '''Edgar Kelehum. Bcnj. D. Silliman. '''Smith Clift. A. P. Ketclnim. -''John Slosson. Charles D. Eiirrilk E. Ketehum. Jr. Charles .\. reabi.dy. George C. Barrett. '''John iMtch. '"F. Louis Lowe. Henry R. Beekman. '''Saintiel C,. Classey. *Geor,ge X. Titus. '''Charles B. Aloorc. '''James R. Jessu[). *Johii P. Crosby. Noah Davis. '''Joseph B. Varnum. ''Albon Ik Man. Julien T. Danes. '''P. A\k Turney. John F. Parsons. Gerard Beekman. '''Osborne Iv Bright. '''E. C. Benedict. Eugene II. Pomeroy. Benj. T. Kissam. '''J. S. Bosworth, '''Ilarnikun .Morton. Henry P. Townsend. *Dee<-asei]. In the latter part of December, 1869, a committee previously ap- pointed for such purpose, consistino- of Messrs. James C. Carter, Albert Mathews and Edmund Randolph Robinson proceeded to call a meetino-, which was held on the evening- of the first of February, 1870. The speakers were : James Emott, William M. Evarts, Henry Nicoll, Samuel J. Tilden and Edwards Pierrepont. " It is not to be concealed," observed Judge Emott in addressing the meeting-, " that there is a deep undertone of feeling among' the law- yers who have signed this call and who make up this signihcant meeting, upon certain subjects. There is an undertone in what has been said which would require but little to bring into distinct utterance. We, as lawyers, feel deeply the complaints wliich are rife of abuses in the practice of law and the administration of the law." Another of the speakers, the Hon. Samuel J. Tilden, going' even further, made use of these words : "As a class, as a portion of the community, 1 do not desire to see the bar combined except for two objects, the one is to elevate itself, to elevate its ov/n standards, the other is for the common and public good. For itself nothing ; for that noble and generous and elevated profession of which it is the representative, everything'. It cannot be doubted, we can none of us shut our eyes to the fact, that there has been, in the last quarter of a century, a serious decline in the character, in the training-, in the education and in the morality of our bar, and the tlrst work for this association to do is to elevate the profession to a hig-her and better standard. If the bar is to become merely a method of making- money, making it in the most convenient way possible, but making it at all hazards, then the bar is degraded, if the bar is to be merely an institution that seeks to win causes, and to win them by back-door access to the judiciary, then the bar is not only degraded but it is corrupt. The bar, if it is to continue to exist, if it would restore itself to the dignity and honor which it once possessed, must be bold in defense, and, if need be, bold in aggression. If it will do its duty to itself, if it will do its duty to the profession which it follows and to which it is devoted, the bar can do everything else. It can have re- formed constitutions, it can have a reformed judiciary, it can have the administration of justice made pure and honorable, and can restore both the judiciary and the bar until it shall be once more, as It formerly was, an honorable and an elevated calling." A second meeting was held on February 15", 1870, at which per- manent organization was effectuated under the name of the " Associa- tion of the Bar of the City of New York," a constitution and by-laws were adopted and the following officers chosen : President, William M. Evarts ; Vice-Presidents, Samuel J. Tilden, James W. Gerard, Joseph S. Bosworth, John Slosson and Edgar S. Van Winkle ; Treasurer, Albon P. Man ; Corresponding Secretary, John Bigelow. In the constitution, which was then adopted, the following were defined to be the objects of the association : "To maintain the honor and dignity of the profession of the law; to increase its usefulness in promoting the due administration of justice, and to cultivate social intercourse among its members." The admission to membership of unworthy individuals was care- fully guarded against in the by-laws. Candid-ates against whom five negative votes were cast in the committee on admissions (which con- sisted of twenty members) were not to be recommended, and candi- dates, even if so recommended, would be excluded by one negative vote in every five which should be cast by the members at large. The association was not regularly incorporated as such until the passage by the Legislature of this State on April 28th in the following year of an act providing that " The Members of the Bar Association of the City of New York, of which William M. Evarts is president .... and all persons who shall hereafter be associated with them, are hereby created a body corporate under the name of ' The Association of the Bar of the City of New York,' for the purpose of maintaining the honor and dignity of the profession of the law, of cultivating social relations among its members, and increasing its usefulness in promot- ing the due administration of justice." in the summer of 1871, the New York "Times" began the pub- lication of the city's accounts, and in the next November, Tweed alone of all the members of the ring, succeeded in procuring an election, but great as was his audacity, did not dare to assume the duties of office. Seven days after the election (which that year took place on No- vember 7) a special meeting of the association was held, at which a committee was appointed consisting of Wheeler H. Peckham, William M. Prichard, James C. Carter, Noah Davis, John Slosson, Gilbert M. Speir and Joshua M. Van Cott, who were instructed " to inquire into the truth of the charges that have gained credit in this comnmnity re- flecting upon the administration of justice in this city, and to ascertain whether the same have a just foundation in trustworthy evidence, . . . . and to report whether it is expedient for this association to take any and what measures in the premises." On January 4, 1872, the committee handed in a report advocating the removal from ofltce of the guilty judges whose oiTenses, say the committee, consisted of gross abuse of the powers of such judges and the courts held by them, respectively, in the granting of injunctions, in the creating of receiver- ships and the appointment of receivers, and transferring to them vast amounts of property, both of corporations and individuals ; in abusing the power to appoint referees, and in making excessive allowances to receivers, referees and others for purposes not justihed by law ; in abusing their authority in the manner of holding courts ; in making improper ex-parte orders out of court, and in deciding causes and mo- tions without a hearing in court; in abusing the writ of habeas corpus. by using- and permittino- its use for unlawful purposes and in improp- erly withholding- relief under the writ; in attempting the intimidation of counsel in the discharge of duty toward their clients, and in show- ing undue favoritism to other counsel and attorneys for their personal or professional advancement; in gross and indecorous conduct while sit- ting in court, tending to bring- the oftke of judge into popular con- tempt; in various acts indicating the influence of corruption upon their official conduct and decisions, and finally, in so perverting judicial au- thority by the use of devices under the forms of law as to enable indi- viduals and corporate officers to usurp and exercise unlawful powers, seize and convert property, accomplish nefarious designs and evade justice." The association having approved the report, a memorial was pre- pared urging a rigid investigation of the charges by the Legislature and a committee selected by whom such memorial might be presented. This committee consisted of Messrs. Joseph H. Choate, Stewart L. Wood- ford, George M. Gilbert, John E. Parsons, Henry Nicoll, Morris L Mil- ler, Noah Davis, Charles Tracy, Andrew Boardman, Charles H. Hunt, Stephen P. Nash, E. R. Lawrence, Jr., William R. Martin, John McKeon, E. Randolph Robinson and Joshua M. Van Cott. In the early part of February, 1872, the Assembly, through its Ju- diciary Committee, began the taking of testimony in proceedings looking to the removal of Justices George G. Barnard and Albert Cardozo of the Supreme Court. Subsequent action was also taken against John H. McCunn, a Judge of the Superior Court of Nev/ York City. John E. Parsons, Joshua M. Van Cott, and Albert Stickney represented the Bar Association throughout. The result is well known. On May 2d, Judge Cardozo resigned to avoid impeachment, the appeals of his friends added to his own, pre- venting his disbarment. He promised to leave for the West but broke his word and resumed practice in New York City. On July 2d, Judge McCunn was removed from oftfce by unanimous vote of the Senate. Barnard materially injured his own cause by appearing before the committee in person and demonstrating the truth of the charges of unseemly behavior on the bench, and by showing- his hearers how low an opinion of his functions, it is possible for a magistrate to have.' " The Judge," he said, " who holds the chambers owns the patronage ; it belongs to him, and he selects whom he pleases regardless of any suggestion of counsel or dictation from them I have suc- ceeded in life by aiding my friends and not my enemies." On August 19th he was adjudged guilty by a Court of Impeachment, consisting of the Senate and Court of Appeals, the decision being unanimous, and in addition, was, by a nearly unanimous vote, forever disqualified from again holding public ofiice.- The expense of these prosecutions amounted to nearly thirty thousand dollars, the greater portion of which was contributed by members of the association. One effect which they had was to cause a strong popular feeling to arise in favor of the abolition of an elective Judiciary and the substitution of an appointive one which found ex- pression in the submission to the people in 1873, of the following con- stitutional amendment couched in the form of two questions: First. " Shall the Chief Justice and the Associate Judges of the Court of Appeals and the Justices of the Supreme Court be hereafter elected or appointed?" Second. "Shall the Judges of the Superior Courts of New York City and Brooklyn, of the Court of Common Pleas of Buffalo, and the several County Judges throughout the State be here- after elected or appointed ? " While this was fa\ored by the Association, it was, nevertheless, defeated at the subsequent election.'' In 1872, numerous complaints having been made with regard to the method of administration in vogue in many of the public offices, a committee was appointed and an investigation made which revealed a state of corruption second only to that of Tweed and his associates. In the Register's ohice over sixty thousand dollars a year was shown to have been realized from illegal lees. In 1874, Messrs. Wheeler H. Peckham, John McKeon, Clifford A. Hand and Charles Tracy repre- (1) Memorial History of the City of Kew York, Vol. III., pajje 560. (2) The vote stood 33 to '.;. (3) The vote stood; For election of higher .judges, 31'J,1J7U ; lor appointment, 115,337 ; for election ol' lower Judges, :UU,iiGU; for appointiiicrt, llij,7-."i. senting the association, appeared before tlie Legislature in advocacy of a change in the existing law which would abolish the fee system as far as practicable, and substitute in its place the payment of regular salaries to public officials, all fees still permitted to exist being paid into the city treasury. A few years later, formal charges of " neglect of duty in ofTice, malversation in office, malfeasance in offke and extortion " were brought against the Sheriff, County Clerk and Register.^ An investi- gation was thereupon had, resulting in the removal of the County Clerk (Gumbleton), the Governor deciding, however, that the charges against the Register and SheritT were not sutfkiently proven. It is to be noted that the association during the campaigns of 1871 and 1872 studiously refrained from assuming an attitude that might, by any possibility, be construed as partisan. Its only aim then was, and has since been, to see to it that there exists a bench and bar which shall, as far as possible be kept pure and uncorrupt. In I88I its position was thus stated : " Any active participation in a canvass for judicial oftlces would be distasteful to us, but it has been necessary in the past, and it may be necessary in the future. If so, we shall not shrink from it. We felt justified in taking an active part in the impeachment and removal of two judges. We cannot doubt that this association will think it within its province to take all steps necessary to insure the choice of suitable successors."" But two other instances appear in which the association has had occasion to interfere with the judiciary. On March 8, 1892, a com- mittee of nine was appointed consisting of Frederick R. Coudert, James C. Carter, John E. Parsons, Clifford A. Hand, Edmund Ran- dolph Robinson, John L. Cadwalader, William B. Hornblower, Elihu Root, and Albert Stickney to investigate the conduct of Isaac N. May- {]) The Comiaittee appoiuted by the associatiou to look al'ter the popular interest in thiw matter consisted of Artemas H. Hohue^^, Henry K. Knox, Geoj^e De Forest Lord, Charles F. ilac Lean and J. Adriance Bush. (■2) The follomng provision is contained in Section XVII. of the By-Laws and is worthy of note in this con- nection. ' ' At each annual meeting there shall be appointed by the pre.sidiDsj officer a committee of ten, to be known as the committee on judicial nominations, whose duty it shall be to consider the titoess of candidatea nominated or Iiroposed to be nominated by political parties or otherwise, for election or appointment to judicial ofl&ce, and to con- fer on that subject with other organizations or with nominating conventions, and with power to I'ecommend to the association, at a special meeting or otherwise, such action in respect to candidates as they may deem neceBsiiry cr proper." 10 nard as Deputy Attorney-General in regard to the Dutchess County election returns. What the acti(jn of the latter had been in this regard is too well known to need repetition here. While no steps were taken by the association at the time the oiTense was committed, it was felt upon the appointment of Mr. Maynard to a Judgeship in the Court of Appeals that the matter could not lightly be passed over. On March 22d, 1892, the Committee handed in its report setting forth in full the acts of Judge Maynard,' and recommending the adoption of the fol- lowing resolution by the association, which was done : " Resolved, that a copy of this report be transmitted to the Senate and Assembly, and that those bodies be respectfully requested to con- sider whether the conduct of Judge Isaac H. Maynard, therein men- tioned, does not demand an exercise of the power to remove judges vested by the Constitution in the Legislature." While no otticial notice was taken of this by the Legislature, and in that respect, the action of the association may be said to have pro- duced no results, it undoubtedly contributed greatly in the subsequent campaign to bring about Judge Maynard's defeat at the polls. Reierence must also be made to the course adopted by the associa- tion during the election of 1898. At a special meeting held on Sep- tember 20th of that year, a resolution was pas:.ed instructing the Com- mittee on Judicial nominations to invite delegates from the several political parties to the conference, "with a view to securing the nomi- nation and election of suitable candidates." After full consideration, the Committee also prepared and caused to be circulated a petition to the Judiciary Committee of the Democratic and Republican parties endorsing the candidacy of Judges Joseph F. Daly and William N. Cohen. This petition was signed by over 3,500 members of the New York Bar, somewhat more than two-thirds of the signers being lawyers (1) The report of the Committee, in referring to the conduct of .ludije Maynard, states that: " These extraordinary proceeding.s have a niornentoiis political iiit(U'Hat to the people of tlie whole State and may well arrest their attenlion and call for their ac ion. Ilie memln-TH of this association, as citizeDs, may take such views of these proceediogs as their conrictions iii;iy ajiprove. I'-ut with the political results we have no con- cerD, except such aa we have in common with our fellow citizens. "This Association has, howev-er, hy the resohitinn undier which this <'0Tumittec derives its authority, taken the view that there is ont; teutiii'e of these tiUEsactiniis in T^ hiih it has an especial iDterest. It has taken notice of the fact that Mr. Maynard, who took an important pai't in them, has since heen elevated tti tlip. heucli of oui' highest Judicial tribunal ; and that hy reason of this participation his titness for that office, so important to the whole com- munity, and especially important to us, lias been seriously drawn in question." 11 not members of the association, and it was in due time presented to the nominating conventions of the several parties. While the Demo- cratic party refused to nominate Judges Daly and Cohen, the candi- dates actually nominated by them in the main, met with the approval of the Committee as to their character and titness, with one exception, who, the association resolved, was not a tit person to be a Justice of the Supreme Court. A resolution was adopted condemning the action of the Democratic party, especially in the case of Justice Daly, and providing further for the appointment of a committee of fifty members charged " with the duty of actively promoting the canvass and election of judges Daly and Cohen." In spite of these efforts, however, both were defeated. Due to another reform movement initiated by the association, is the change that has been made in the rules for admission to the bar, though the credit for havmg brought this to completion must rather rest with the State Bar Association. Instead of a multitude of sepa- rate committees the State now has one Board of Law Examiners who conduct a uniform system of examinations. A prominent feature in the work of the association is its super- vision of proposed legislation. A copy of every act introduced in the New York Legislature is sent to it and its course followed. The By- Laws provide for the appointment of a committee " on the Amend- ment of the Law," who shall be charged with the duty of watching all proposed changes and of proposing such amendments as in their opinion should be recommended by this association. Members are invited to send to this committee at any time suggestions of existing defects in the law and of any amendment which they may think ad- visable. An illustration of this supervision which the association has ex- ercised is shown in the case of the proposed Civil Code. As is well known to members of the bar the latter was in 186^ subniLted to the legislature being designed to constitute one of five, the remainder being the Political and Penal Codes and the Codes of Civil and Crimi- nal Procedure. In 1879 the act providing for the establishment of the 12 Civil Code was passed by the Legislature, but vetoed by Governoi Robinson. A committee consisting of Cliflford A. Hand, Frederick R. Coudert, Elial F. Hall, Charles C. Beaman, Jr., David McClure and William B. Hornblower, appointed to examine the proposed act, rendered a report on March 1^, 1881, declaring that in their opinion "the passage of the Statute would be an unmixed evil, fraught with incalculable mischief to every person directly interested in the administration of the law throughout the State," and that the proposed code was one which " mingled common law, statutory law and new law in one common mass with no designation to guide those who seek the proportions of the several ingredients." The act in question, as is known, never became law. In 1881, it passed the Assembly by a vote of eighty-three to three, but was not passed by the Senate until 1882, the vote there standing twenty to eleven in its favor, but it was vetoed by the Governor. For tlve suc- ceeding years was the act presented but continually failed of passage, and the attempt to procure its enactment was fmally abandoned. It may be added that the association approved of the Penal Code which afterwards became law, but not of the proposed Code of Evidence. Not the least of the duties which the Bar Association has assumed is that of investigating complaints against the oftkial conduct of attor- neys. To the member of the Bar unjustly accused, a means is afforded whereby a complete vindication may be secured, and the attorney who may have been guilty of conduct unprofessional in its nature is called to account for his actions and made to answer for them. The report of the Committee on Grievances shows that during the year 1898- 1899, thirty-six complaints have been presented to it, involving charges against forty-two members of the bar, including one member of the association, of which nineteen have been dismissed because of their frivolous character, or because no attempt was made to substantiate them, or because they were not deemed to fall within the province or jurisdiction of the committee. Several of these, however, were referred to the Legal Aid Society, and one was referred to the Association of the Bar of Queens County. \} Twelve complaints of a substantial character, demanded and re- ceived serious and prolonged investigation. Of these, seven were dis- missed, Including one against the member of this association. Five complaints directed against six members of the bar, the com- mittee found to be well established, and in each case reported in writ- ing to the Executive Committee, that in its opinion, each was such as required prosecution in the Courts. In three of these cases prosecu- tors have been appointed by the Executive Committee, and proceedings for the disbarment of the persons charged are now pending, or are about to be instituted before the Appellate Division. In one case a prosecutor was appointed but proceedings were abandoned because of inability to procure the necessary evidence, and in another case pro- ceedings are stayed until the return of the otfender to this country. Five cases remain before the committee undisposed of. In 1896, the association left its old home in 7 West Twenty-ninth street and moved into the new building 4} West Forty-third street and 42 West Forty-fourth street. This magnitlcent structure completed and furnished at a cost of #639,9^0,^ seems destined to remain its home for many years yet to come. A magnificent law library consisting of 51,4^4 volumes is owned by the association, of which 38,427 volumes were purchased and 13,027 presented. The cost of the library for books and binding up to the present time has been $\78SS7AQ. Dur- ing the year 1898-1899 alone there have been added 2,048 volumes, of which 901 were purchased and 1,147 donated. During that time the number of volumes which have been bound and rebound has been 3,868 at a cost of ^2,991.8?. In this short resume of the history of the association, mention can necessarily only be made of the more salient points, but enough has been said to demonstrate that it has indeed existed as a power for good. Owing its origin to an occasion which called into action the exercise of every quality of good citizenship, it has freely given its aid when- ever required in the righting of any wrongs to the community among which it has its being. We have seen how it has been the motive force (1) Of this sum, $20:^,500 w:i9 puil tnr thu laad; $:3SO,70O for the building, uiid $J.J,7,'3U for furniture and haDgings. that drove from power that most contemptible of all objects, a corrupt judiciary and the endeavors made to accomplish its aim that the bench and bar of this city niay remain worthy of the trust which must from very necessity be placed in them. From a membership of 231, the as- sociation has now' grown to one of K58. Its increase in power is an added pledge of greater usefulness and a greater capacity for good to the citizens of this city. (1) isay. 15 FORTY-FOURTH STREET ENTRANCE. 17 FORTY-THIRD STREET ENTRANCE. _1 < m U z < 21 C/) Qi z < Q H Z m < _J u. Oi (^ O () , 1 _J u- < f- h- C/J uu Q Lu 23 DETAIL OF STAIRS. SECOND FLOOR LANDING. 25 < CD an < 27 >• a: < S z < 29 u Z O O O a; <; z 31 < g m O a, 33 IS) O —1 < a. 35 S:.^^^^. ■^■-_^ )7 39 41 t"™iTrrim.r.-Tr.[ ^ m, i«grv y;tB:agaiaaii[,a^^^^^^^^^ i 43 47 49 51 I 53 ^■C'^fYxVi/ ^^ \r/^:% '"^-^^^ "5\^ ^ '± f 55 57 ES BYRNE '..."^i*^- 39 Jir v<<9lil*ar_'~ , ^ ^ ^^^':C^-^ ^-^^ ^ /^^^^^^,y^,,/JC U- f^. C^J/^ 5^^S/._. c^ / u ^:^^^-^,_^ .r ;^<^;i-^fe-=^-'^^f>^ ■^(^j^-r-^^ ^^^ua-.-^^i^ gIc^ L / 'i-c■1:^^o^^. ^J^- C^ .^J^/:T^ OFFICERS. 68 Samuel J. Tii_oen. William M. Evarts. David Dudley Field. C. A. Seward. Luther R. Marsh. Stephen P. Nash. John M. Knox. Robert Sewell. Gharles a. Rapallo. J. E. Burrill. Henry H. Anderson. Edgar Ketchum. -k- Henry E. Davies. George M. Mill-er. Francis N . Bangs. John K. Porter. SIGNERS OF THH CALL FOR ORGANIZATION I869. Deceased. 69 Charles E. Strong. James C Carter. Thomas H. Hubbard. William Allen Butler. Frederic R. Coudert. Joseph H. Choate. John E. Parsons. William H. Arnoux. ¥ M^^ DoRMAN B. Eaton. William Hildreth Field. Flamen B. Candler. Thomas E. Stillman. [ r,- Charles A. Peabody. Henry R, Beekman. Benjamin D. Silliman. Albert Stiokney. SIGNERS OF THE CALL FOR ORGANIZATION 1869. Deceased. 70 \ N>,. H ERBERT B. Turner. Everett P. Wheeler. Edmund Wetmore . Theodore W. Dwight . WiLi-fAM W. M acFaruand. William G. Choate. Elbridge T. Gerry William Jay. Dwight H. Olmstead. Henry Hilton. Noah Davis. J, Frederic Kernochan. Richard H. Clarke. J. EvARTS Tracy. Franklin A. Wilcox SIGNERS OV THE CALE EOR ORGANIZATION l.S6a Deceased /■"^^ Jui-iEN T. Davies. Benjamin T. Kissam. A. P. Ketchum John H". Ward. :^^^ «:■; E. L. Fancher. Frederick Smyth. Edward Patterson. Chas. E. Whitehead. T> Wheeler H. Reckham . E. Ellerv Anderson. George Wales Soren. SIGNERS OF THE CALL FOR ORGANIZATION I869. 72 ^ ,1 ^ ^ •■^1,01 ^^ Charles A. Reabody. Jr. William H. Butterworth. Freling H. Smith. -a^ ^\ Benjamin F" . L^ee. Charles C Seaman. Simon Sterne. Charles H. Tweed. George B. Goldschmidt. ISTO. 1870. Edmund Coffin. 1870. Ira D. Warren. 1870, Henry E. Howland. is;ii. Grosvenor S. Hubbard. is;(i. ^•7v^ Elizur B. Hinsdai-e l'<7ll. F-REDERIC H. BeTTS. cm Oliver P. Bueu. Charles A. d ackson . IMU. MEMBHRS. 73 Peter B. Oi-ney, 1S70. V\Jit-t-iAM Warner Hoppin. George W. Van Slyck. 1S7II. lS7n. Samuel. Riker. 18711. ■^■ ^ * Augustus C. Brown. William M. Hoes. KW. 1870. Henry Lewis Morris. Charles £. Miller. 1S70. 1870. f "*- Edward Mitchell. John M. Scribner. 1870. Henry Edwin Tremain. 1870. William C. Whitney. 1870. William P. Dixon. Carlisle Norwood. Simeon B. Chittenden. Pordham Morris. 1S70. 1870. 1S70. 1870. MEMBERS. 74 Thatcher M . Adams- George V. N. Baldwin, ISiO. Charles W. Bangs. William Irwin. 1S71. George William Lroi\ 1S71. George H. Yeaman. 1871. Wilson M. Powell. 1S71. John H. V . Arnold. 1871. >. \ X ^ William B. Ross. 1871. John C. O' Conor, Jr. 1S71. M/^flLTe/? R. T. Jones. 1S71. Edwin W. Coggeshall. 187-'. Charles W. Dayton. J. H. Montgomery. K'd. 1S7',>. Nelson Smith. ••T^:, n i Duncan Smith. MEMBERS. 75 \%feAV"l Payson Merrill. Thomas S. Moore. 1872. "5^^ w John J. McCook. m 3t ¥' Henry L-. Burnett. 1872. ^' Charles W. Gould. James C. Spencer. David J. Newland. 1872. 1872. ^f^ Randolph W. Townsend. 1872. Charles L. Atterburv. William G, Reckham. ist::, int:;. Robert P. Lee. Edward S. Clinch, la;:). ^' '\ P'^ Charles H. Knox. 1S73. Osc»R S. Straus. 1873. William C. Witter. 1873. Richard M. Henry. 1873. MEMBERS. 76 V' ■^ ^'^:; ; j*;^ g(*fe> if Chari-es F'rankuin Wells. £'Div,q/?D R. Bacon. IST.i. Michael H. Cardozo. is;::. John M. Bowers. 1S73. Allen W, Evarts. 1S7S. i-UTHER UaFLIN KELLOGG. 1871. (7, Adriance Bush. 1871. George L. Rives. 1874. Frederick A, Pell. Hamilton Bullock Tompkins. William C. Gulliver. 1^71. 1874. 1871. Charles S- Rairchild. is;-). .-*<*^ Clark Brooks. 1S75. Z-UDLOiv Ogde/v. UV/li_m/w H. Helme-Moore. John B. Irelanl \m:. 187:"). 18;o. MEMBERS. 77 «m w^^ \ Joseph C. Levi. E , Ritzema De Grove iSTJ. is7(;. E, Francis Hyde. 1876. Wai-ter D. Edmonds. 1876. r^ w'. Edward S. Hatch. William Forse Scott. Ifi7li. 1876. Frederic W. Adee. 1876. Charles G, Coe. 1876. Henry L. Sprague. 1S76. Delancey Nicoll. 1876. Benjamin W. Franklin. 1876. J. Tredwell Richards. 1S76. Gilbert M. Speir. 1876. John W, Simpson. 1S76. John Frankenheimer John Brooks Leavitt. 1377. is7;. MEMBERS. 78 Eugene H. Lewis. F rederiok H. Comstock. Frederick S. Wait. James S. Murray. l^n. is;;, IS77. isis. G. Wii-i-ETT Van Nest. Henry B. B. Stapl-er. Charles C. Bull. Perry Belmont. 1S7S. ^-"^^^^ Joseph F. Randolph. George B. Bonney. Camillas G. Kidder. is;s. i^'^i- i^"^'' Henry \AJ . Hayden. Theodore Sutro. is;;). Julius J. Lyons. J. Van Vechten Olcott. George M, Baker. MEMBERS. 79 Arthur H. Masten. Samuel. Greenbau^ Wager Swayne, Edward Lyman Short. ISSII, Jefeerson Ci-ark. Edwin Baldwin. IKSII. Charles Robinson Smith. George W. Ellis. issn. Chauncey S. Truax JSSII. Henry W. De Forest. Herbert Valentine. Charles Howland Russell. imsu. ihsii, Eugene Frayer. Frederick S. Parker. Lemuel H. Arnold. \9.'^\. issi. R. Clarence Dorsett. MEMBERS. 80 Henry F. Homes. issi. Stuart F, Randolph. F, De Peyster Foster. ISSl. IS^l. George H. Adams. issi. 1^ George Folger Canfield. Wili-iam D. Guthrie. issi. issi,. William Allen Butler, Jr. Chas. Wheeler Barnes. ISSl. ISSl. Arthur Berry. ^^ -«| Thomas G. Evans. IS8I. m Edward Winslow Paige. ISSl. Clarence Lexow. ISSl. -^ ^^ William L. Findley. William Houston Kenyon. Rollin M. Morgan. George N . Messiter. 1SS2. MEMBERS. 81 J. Hampden Dougherty. Clarence D. Ashley Henry S. Glover. ISSJ. Thomas F . Wentworth. 1883. Samuel A, Blatchford. 1882. Henry W. Sackett. 1882. Rudolf Dulon. 1S82. Edward W. Bell. 1882. ^= Geo. Whitfield Brown, Jr. 1882. Victor Morawetz. 1882. John Duer. 1882. WiNTHROp Parker. 1882. Georbe L. Sterling. William C. Cloptow. William V. Leary. 1883. George W. Wickersham. 1SS3. MEMBERS. 82 Andrew Shiland, Jr. Rastus S. Ransom iss;). 1SS3. Bartow S. Weeks. Chari-es Henry Butuer. ISM). 1SS3. John O. Mott. ink:! William H. Beam. Middleton S. Burrill. L-ewis Sayre Burchard. L & ^ George W. Seligman. William C. Demorest. iss:}. |,ss;i. J. Archibald Murray. Charles E. I-ydecker. /^ v; / Edmund L. Baylies. James D. Fessenden. 1SS4 issl. Francis i-. Minton. issj. ■f* "5fv 3»™ X-li' Alan D. Kenyon. MEMBERS. 83 ^" George C. Kob 1SS4. D 4S^^ John M . Sheod. 13S4. W. Harris Roome. John Murray Mitchell. 1S.X4. Frank J . Goodnow. ISS-I. William Travers Jerome. 1SS4. John F . Dillon. 1S.S4. Bradford W, Hitchcock. 1S84. Robert W. Hawkesworth. 1SS4. \. L'S Frederick H . Allen Richard W. G. Welling. 1SS4. 1SS4. EoaAR J. Nathan. 1S,S4. Percy L. Klock. Charles E. Rushmore. Frank Sullivan Smith. Charles MacVeagh 1SS4. 1SS4. 1SS4. 1884. MEMBERS. 84 John Notman. IN.S4. George A. Miller. IHSl. WiNSLOw S. Pierce. ISM. 4^ Stanlev W. Dexter. 1XS4. John B. Kerr. IKS I. Edward K. Jones. HenRV MEt-VILt-E George Strong Daniels. INSO. m^ r^' Sherburne Blake Eaton. Charles E. Manierre. William Gilbert Davies. Marcus Stine. 1S85, IsiSo. I'^y.''. 1SS5. R. Floyd Clarke. George S. Coleman. issr,. William M. Barnum. *j3 Newbold LeRov Edgar. ISS;-,. MEMBERS. 85 '\Md!i^(^ II Louis B. Rot-STON, is«. Horace E. Deming. William Ford Upson. William N. Cohen. ISSn. Philip Carpenter. Nathan Bijur. i8s:.. Sylvester L. H. Ward. Julius H. Seymour. 1^86. Frederick M. Littlefield. 13S6. Louis Marshall. 1SS6. George M. Pinney, Jr. George E. Blackwell. 1836. ^*»^ Thaddeus D. Kenneson. 1386. Ira Adelbert Place. Noah Cornwell Rogers. 1S36. 188i;. Randolph Parmly. 1886. MEMBERS. 86 Elif>halet Nott Anable. Benjamin S. Harmon. James A. Blanchard. iy>^fi. i^isii. issfi. Silas Wooell. Charles H. Edgar. issi;. %■ Augustus T. Gurlitz. George F". Harriman . Henry Ei-sworth Gregory. ISS6. 1S86. James M. Gifford. Adrian H. Joline. Edward C. James. Eliphalet Williams Tyler, ISS7. ISs;. iss;. icis7. V s; '^ ^^^:^ Samson Lachman. 1.SS7. BouDiNOT Keith. 1887. Charles A. Deshon. I^s7. George Hoadly. 1887. MEMBERS. 87 George A. Clement. 1SS7. Henry C. De Witt. Charles Walter Artz. William D. Leonard. 1887. Frederick Spiegelberg. Paul D, Cravath. George C. Austin. 1S8B. Henry H. Whitman, 1S8S. Louis Werner. ISSS. Robert Shaw Minturn. 1.S5S. S V Howard A. Taylor. ISSS. Edward P. Sohell, ISSS. Lucius Hart Beers. ISSS. Bdmond B. Wise ISSS, Zdward L. Heydecker. ISW. Wayland E. Benjamin. 1888. MEMBERS. '""^3^^ '"^^^t'^ff^!^^^'-:'W'. J. AsPiNWALL. Hodge. Jr. isys. Jamin S. Morse. ISSS. Walter H. Crittenden. 18SS. Julian B. Shope. 4f Lm ■^ John T. Sherman. ISss, John C- Gulick. William J. Lardner. 18s:i; A. Walker Otis. 18SU. Z-'^!^^" Emile Schultze, Jr. 1SS9, Charles F. Bostwick. 13S:i. Hugh R. Garden. Abraham Goldsmith. ISS'.i. \1 -^ fn^ 5 V Fulton McMahon. 1889. John A. We ekes, Jr. 1880. iDivyiRD F*. Lyon. 18^9. James W. Hawes. 138'J. MEMBERS. 89 Jonathan M. Wainwright. James L. Skillin. Sidney Smith. ZowiN B. Root. 1SS9. Robert Nelson Kenyon. VJaldo Grant Morse. William C. Timm. Wm. White Niles, Jr. 1SS9. Jared G. Baldwin. Jr. Madison Grant. Robert D. Murray Henry Sayre Van Duser. 1«»9. Harry Hubbard. ISSll. Rush Taggart. ISW). Alfred W. Kiddle. 159(1. Herman C Kudlich. ISUO. MEMBERS. 90 'I ^ Eugene Fishel. Joseph H. Adams. ] Silt I. Z\JERETT J. ESSELSTYN . Arthur von Briesen. Abraham I. Elkus. isitn Byram L. Winters. 1 S',11 1, Charles C Nadal. Robert Forsyth Littue. John Sergeant Wise. Ernest F. Ayrault. George M. Van Hoesen. IS'.III. John W. Boothby. Noel Gale. John Jay McKelvey. IHUIJ. iy«i. MEMBERS. 91 Henry B. Gayley. Benjamin F, Carpenter- Thomas C. T. Grain. ISilO. W1L.I-IAM WiLI-IAMS 1890. dOHN LlNCOt-N WiLKIE. isyii. William Church Osborn. 1890. ip» «s- H t ■f'-'-V. George E. Gartlanl I Sim. John Whalen. Willi. Frederick Geller, 1S90. Edward Hassett. 1891. William Temple Emmet. William H. Page, Jr. IXII. ISU. TowNSEND Jones. 1891. Herbert H. Gibbs. 1891. Angel J^ Simpson, 189 1. Charles Eox. 1S9I. Joseph R. Guernsey. Joseph M. Keatince. IS'.il, 1891 MEMBERS. 92 w Et-isHA K. Gamp, lS:il. «ff ■%■ \ ^ isa:;. Frank Moss. 189:.'. Philip Harwood Vernon. 1S9-.'. » 'ass- -W ">« 1^^^, v^' ^^^R' TOWNSEND SCUDDER. Louis C Whiton. Charles Goeller. l.S'.i;.'. IDM/>5RD S, Z->fl FeTRA. Caleb A. Burbank. '\ ^ >^p^ Richard T. Greene. Robert Lee Morrell. I«i:.'. is'.i:.'. Hammond Odell. is'.e. Zdmond Kelly. IS'.K. 1 '■•»' Charles E. Mitchell. icS'.i.;. Reuben L. Maynard. John Bethell Uhle. IS'.I'J. MEMBERS. 93 Wiui-iAM Carr Wilson. Charles W. Zaring. ESEK COWEN. Robert Goeller. IVI'.'. <*?) K/A^ BrONSON WirVTHROP. Barclav E. V. McCarty. Matthew Corrv Fleming. Julius Marshall Mayer. is',15. is:i3. isii:;. Alfred Lee Manierre. Howard McWilliams. Perry Davis Trafford. James Harold Warner. 18«3. lyas. 1^113 18'.i3. William P. Martin. I3',I3. ^ James VJ. Gerard, Jr. Lewis T. Knox. isii;;. is'xi MEMBERS. 94 Eeward D. O' Brien. is;i3. f^RANCIS FarQUHAR. Arthur H. Van Brunt. Charles G. F. Wahle. Augustus Parker-Smith. 18113. mi:s. 1S1I3. ^ ! Dallas Flannagan. Samuel Riker, Jr. Job E. Hedges. ivn. ls:i3. lsif3. Thomas Hunt. 1893. Jarvis H. Miller. I^:i3. Vfc- John K. Erskine, Jr. •*;►; ■#; -^y Herbert Noble. Howard C. Tracy. IS: 13. Albert Rivers Genet. George Dana Mumford Ki:;. is'.i;!. I:/ D. Walter D. Clark. Frank J. McBarron pvO ls;i3. ;MBE 95 RS. John H, Judge. ISIU. Jesse Stearns. ISlll. Glenn Ford McKinney. Francis A. WiNSL.o\fi is'jj. laii. Ml ' / :?, Henry Clinton Backus. lS'J-1. James R. Fancher. 18U-1. George 1/1/. Hubbell. 18W. i^. Parker Kirlin. 1894. Frank Dudley Tansley. 1894. Harold Binney. 1S94. -■■^(H* Rudolph Loreck. IS'.ll. John Vernou Bouvier, Ur. 1894. ^ %.^ W Seth B. Robinson. 189-1. Charles G. Kalbfleisch. Jacob Herbert Shaffer. 1S94. 1N94. iDw/iffc? H. Fallows. 1S91. MEMBERS. 96 Charles A. Terrv. Charles T. Terry. J. Du Pratt White. Seward Davis 1^9-1. IV,I4. iy,i4. 1891. Arthur E. Wal.raot. l^'J-^. Edwin I—. Kalish. WOLCOTT G. I-ANE. Richard J. Lewis- Robert J. Fox. is: 14. Edward Sturges Hosmer. is; 14. ^ > Lester W. Clark. Asa A . Alling. is;ij. .'^^ W V / ^i Hill George H. Fearons. IS'.M. John Vinton Dahlgren . Frederick L. Allen. IS'.IJ. l^i'.ll. Lawrence E. E mbree. 189j. MEMBERS. 97 WiLi-iAM Ives Washburn. IK'Jo. Allan McCulloh. Austin E. Rressinger. Woodv/lle Flemming. IS'.I.-,, ISil;-,. ]S!I5. l-ucius NoYEs Palmer. 1S95. Ernest F. E/dlitz. 1R95. Herbert Seymour Barnes. Lewis H. Hyde. 1895. Reginald H. Arnold. LSI 15. Frederick W. Mattocks. 1S95. Benjamin F. Tracy. 1X95. John A. Amundson. 1S95. m ^ , I John Sabine Smith. 1S95. Charles A. B. Pratt. lS9,i,J Vernon M. Davis. 1S95. <'■ 4> Richard H. Mitchell. 1S95. MEMBERS. John Purdon. Henry Davison Williams. Robert Welch Candler. Henry Clark Johnson. 1S9:.. JS95. 1895. Henry A. Rrinoe. George W. Schurman. Arthur L. Sherer. 1SU5. i^ii),"). i^^'.iri. Seldbn Bacon. rn' Robert C. McCormick. Edwards H. Childs. Clarence B. Mitchell. Edward E. McCall. ISIIS. I^'.'a- l^'''^'' 1S95. ^t:v Gov Van Amringe. Charles D. O'Connell. Joseph H. Spafford. Benjamin B. Kenyon. is%. MEMBERS. 99 Arthur L. Livermore. John A. Garver. 1S96. isati. Eugene Treadwell. 1836. Clarence M. Hyde. 1896. Richard U. Sweezy. 1896. Guv Richards. 1896. Joseph F. Stier. 1896. Jacob Washburn. ^ Af' George F, Butterworth. 1896. JohnZS. Eustis. 1896. Isaac N. Mills. 1896. William R. Weeks. 1896. Alphonse H. Alker. Herbert G. Whipple. Nelson L, Robinson. Richard P. Lydon. 1896. 1896. 1896. 1896. MEMBERS. 100 Henry White. David H. Sates, Jr. Wit-LiAM H. Harris. 1896. ' » «^1P 1 k 7 V %i % m^'' Ho RACE 1. Brightman 1S'.H>. Gharl-es Anderson Boston. Edward B. Amend. Alexander J. A. Oallaghan. IS'M). i>i%. IN^III. Percival. S. Jones. iy;i6. 1 Paul R. Towne. i«ii;. Alfred E. Hinrichs. UoHN P. Everett 1S9(1. Randolph Hurry. IS'.ICi WiLBER IVICdRIDE. is:i6. Herbert L.. Satterlee. Ellis B. Southworth. ISlNi. W 5K I, Elmer E. Cooley. MEMBERS. 101 mm Joseph W. Howe 18'Jli. '^W William A. McQuAiD. Harold Sturges Rankine. S. Whitney Dunscomb, Jr. 1896. IS'Jli. IS'.Ki. ^.rf'^iXjga.r, Charles P. Hallock. Thomas Gilleran. 1806. Henry Z_. Bogert. 189B. QuiNTON CORWINE. 1896. Francis B. Swayne. Wm. Gordon Ver Planck. Jacob F. Miller. 1S96. 1^96. 1S96. William R. Willcox, 1S96. r^ '^ * l^ Richard F. Goldsborough. Richard B. Kelly. John S. Sheppard, Jr. Edwin A. Jones. 1396. 1897. 189T. 1S9T. MEMBERS. 102 i ^'M Charles F . Brovi Donald McLeap Harold G.' Villard. George J. Greenfield. 1SH7. 1^'J7 P'^ 1 ■^•wm^-- 5f ■■ ^2' Robert Schell Rudd. Thomas F. Conway William C. Orr. Ambrose F. McCabe. Frederic Potter. George L. Shearer, Albridge C. Smith. George M. Wright. ■--■»a^.. Ferdinand R. Minrath. 1^07. Welton C. Percy. George E. P. Howard. Seabury C. Mastick. MEMBERS. 103 George F'liivt Warren, Ur. Samuel. Oppenheim. Charles A. Runk. 18»7. Max U. Kohler. is:,7. Charles Potter Rogers. Edward P. Mowton. Henry C. Beadleston. Samuel. S. Perry, IN'JT. IS'.IT. l897. 18«7. Thomas P. Wickes. is;!7. Herman A. Heydt. Alfred E. Holcomb, is;i7. Henry C. Quinby. ls',i7. 1 UoHN A. DuTTON. Abraham S. Gilbert. Henry A. Brann. 1897. i-«yT. 1S97 UoHN Hubbard. imz. MEMBERS. 104 Henry James Mayer. Alfred F. Seuigsberg. l«l.s. August Zinsser, Jr. IS'.IS. Joseph Larocoue, Jr. IS'.iS. Jut-ius J. Frank. istts. George B. Boyd. Alfred J aretzki. isiis. QuiNCY Ward Boese. 139S. Henry M, Earle. 189S. ■^."IS^ Frank Alexander Erwin. is'.i.s. Carl A. Hansmann. Henry J. Hemmens. 1S9S. X S.aMU£i- HoFF. 1898. J. CuLBERT Palmer, IB'.IS. IV/5LT-ER C. Flanders. 189S. W/LL//ift7 C. Breed. 1898. MEMBERS. 105 Henry G. D. de Mei-i. Henry D. Donneui-y. WiLLtAM George Wright. is:«i. I8'.I9. BoARDivjAN Wright. 1899. .Ml » ' Edwin T. Rice, Jr. 1899. John A. Mattison. 1899. Louis^C Raegener. 1399. Henry L. Soheuerman. 1899. Henry W. Mayer. George O. Redington. Charles Edw. Woodbridge. Edwin C. Dusenbury 1899. 1S99. 1899. 1899. 4; -*«|i8|*»-n> John Hardy. Walter T. Rosen. Willoughbv L. Webb. David J. Gallert IS'JU. MEMBERS. 106 1899. ^ Harcourt Bul-l. James M. Hunt. Leopold Sondheim. Eugene Sondheim. IS'J'J. IVM. Wll-I-IAM T. SCHLEy. C A. MouNTJov. Chas. Howard MacDonald. Archibai-d Dougi-as. William Beers Crowell. isaa. m^ Alexander W. Fraser. Rowland Cox. MEMBERS. 107 George P. Andrews. Justice of the Supreme Court. IS?,). R. Henry Dugro, Justice of the Supreme Court 1R85. James Pitzgerai-d, Justice of the Supreme Court. lyyy. John W. Goff. Recorder. 1S91. John J. F reeoman. Justice of the Supreme Court. James M. Varnum, Surrogate of New York, IS 1871. Martin J. Keogh, Francis M. Scott. Justice of the Supreme Court. Justice of the Supreme Court. 1883. 1871. Morgan J. O'Brien, Justice of the Supreme Court 1878. Martin T. McMahon. 1876. HONORARY MEMBERS. 108 u/fZ^^ (^ /^^'*^^''*^^C/-^^<$'>f**^ i >^^ c, .-,. to^^ 'Y/^3^.c I'C:. ./-/w 7 2O. w4''J^<'^>-v>^^^'T^<-^'> 115 r?-i^ '=^*'V 1:6 1 1: (^- ^nW.,L,rj^ ^A^.Qto*,H_3 /H//m^^c c^^U5^A;-ev^ Cl. ^( 118 ^^'^v/^^^.JCr /o^^*^ .^^■^.^.^ CLu^ l4/rf^. > ^(^i^^z^i^^^'P^^^.zAcM^ 19 i^c^ U^^.-^^^L^cW^^^*-^J 121 '^A^. Cl^a^^ li?'^>n_ / /-^ y^ idJ >4/ ^^/hl/lOxJo^r^ c^^i^ ^^^^-i^vt/^ -^^^<^^^cc4^ ^ "|V! -WAry^a^ /StuTuAvfi^ (^£^i^C^ ^^U4yK^IjUy\ /U, A^/O-v-y-P^^^^''^ 125 ■ kaZ>-s^^_^____^ ^^S^vmS^ ^O^^. .^^ ^^ /?.^AH«^- -^ 126 .( SLaaa.a^5VjC) ^Cc^t.^^ G^i2^^^ ; ^fe^ -^^^^.^^^^^^^^ ^/f^^ -^ /y^^^--^^-^— 127 ^^SA^ ^ y/^L^ ^ .A^fvny'A ^'<^'^CMA,.^r,^ (^2-i^czz:i:^C ^ ^ a.a^^^ ^J:^ cx.j.3.jv\vjv^ '-^ t;> 12S 1 iiuttf;z:^ 'TTToUc^ c. ^^ ^UhrfTT^^ /^z^^ 2I. M^^A:^^:^r~ ^UkAy^??l i/a^>c.^«^ Z%^ccar 7 a-y^L_Y 129 'i.s^C^ ^W^^^^U^ . (W J\ J^r^^^^Az::::^ _ q ^/e/^iT^. 130 ^ c- ^. /' ^/^74^A^(3<:5'^t-*-<-^tK , ^/^t^^cX ^, (L<}^yy>^-'--' (2J^^^oU)i^ oo:-/?.-^- ~^A^-^^^^ T&A-v-Z^ ^-^cUZcL/fr VoS^3CX>^:^^^^^^^ ^^^.^^^^ /.^^^^^ .X-T^i^ 131 <:i-^_^'-Tf <^^^^<^^^^ c^/b^ %^^t^ ^^:^vc;^..^Ni:^ 132 <^^ fo ^-cXoe-^ 74(, O, l^L-^ ^(y: //u.^^^ Z^.^t ^ v^ ^^ii^TT^^^T^^ 133 ->-^ ^ — ^» — ^/ / ^;^ ^ /^^^^^-..^V 139 140 chu, '^-^-t-^x. ii-^^^^ /^ ^^Wi ^-'i'Ut.^uZ^ c:x:Vk/3^^^.^2^ .^r-fx^ si^^-'Sr^i) CcK, WOsSiu ^^X^)n^X.^^ 143 ^<>^ 144 tdUl^yir^^LAA. 145 c^y^^^ &=^7v?^ ^__ ::^tffxr) ^7 ^^ \\)'^"^^^W^IiJ^^>^>-'<^Y^.^2i>- <. '(^Ziiii^fc'-T'^e^ (f.(/:Kei>f>7-t^, ^^^^i.^ ^^ 'tU^, '/T^^^^^^V^^j^ 146 ^-fs;^^^^^^^. (^//a4^7^ •147 7, bc^LZ^ he /.(i^'^>^ cL^K /^ 'Mpm,^^f7-^a£^^^ yr^^m/^^^^^ ^y%i^^\ i^^^-^i^^ '7. -/■ 148 Index and List of Members. Pur- si;:rna- XAMI-.. ciajt turr PauT Pn-f Abbott, Everett V }:y.j Abney, John Eutledi;-.- li^.i Adams, Geo. Bethum- }\:. Adams, George ti :,:,, M 1\:. Adams, Joseph 11 'jl p;,: Adams, Philip K Adams, Thatcher il ::, llij Addoms. ilortimer C Pn Adee, Frederic \V Tn Vl'j' Adriance, Henrj' E Ag-ar, John G ^~• i;.". Alexander, Chas. E l-H Alexander, Edward A 1-s Alexander, Henr\- il 12J Alexander, H. Jl'.. Jr Alexander, Rol.iert c' ^ Alexander, \\'aUer -I , t;'; Alker, Alphonse H 1i;h P> Allen, Elmer A p;ii Allen, Frederic S IPj' Allen, Frederick H M 14:. Allen, Frederick L :<: Vl', Allen, William 14j Allen, AMiliam P 12s Allint;-. A.-a A '.'7 1:^5 Amend, Edward E Id 111 Amundson, John A 1'n la:i Analjel, Courtland X Anal.iel, E. X .ST Us Anderson, Chandler P... ^. l-ii Anderson, E. Eiler>-. . .' 3, ._' i,i Anderson. Henrv H til' i;iti Anderson, H. liand^jiph Anderson, Henr\" E 141 Andrews, Aver>' D 14 IJH Andrews, Champe S Andrews, George P Ihn 13. Angell, Amasa Pilchard. ., 1-S Angell, Frank S Arnold. John H'. V 7.'. 113 Arnold, Joseph A 12s Arnold, Lemuel H. , Jr.. Ml 13. Arnol.l. Reginal.l H Hs 111 Arnoux, "William H Til Artz, Charles Walter.... ss 12,j Ashlev, Clarence D si: 12u Ashley, Georse B 125 Atkins. Thomas Astl.'y.. .. Atterburv, A:bert H 131 Atterbur'y, Charles L.. 7i; 111 Atw-ater. Henry G 131 Aub. Theodore US Auerbach, Joseph S ■^, Austin, George c ss 13s Ayrault. Ernest F !d 12. Ayres. Frank O Eabcock. Eemu.d PI Backus, Henry C '«' 1^!^ Bacon, Edward R .. 129 Bacon, Henry Bacon, Selden '■" Pj"' Baird, H. M., Jr 123 Baker, Geor.ge JI •'■' 12.. Baker, Seward 12S Baldwin, Corn. -lius A Baldwin, p:dwin s'l 133 Baldwin, p:rnest E •■ Baldwin, G. V. X '' 14. Baldwin, Henry DeF.... id i"5 Baldwin, J. G.. Jr :'■) m Baldwin, W. W 124 Balkam, George H 122 Bangs, Charles W '■> ipi P..r- signa- ; X.-YME. tri.lt lure I'll.-..' Pagu tPings, Frani-is X :;T l.li Pl.ings, Eran..is S 144 l;ar.T, Alb..rl Si.rami.' 123 IPirk'.a-. P',1. n.iamiii. Jr Pl.ilkcr. Frank Barlow, Ch.irles Ij 121 Earnard. H.irLLC- 13s Barnes, chas. ^\"ll..■..■l.-r.. si 123 Barnes, Henr>- P.. Jr Bcirnes, Herl..-rt ^^ !s i_',; Barnes, PearLc Barnett, A^"i|]iaIn E tiarniiin, "William ^1 . . . . ^. I3S Barrett. George C Barry. llerPeit IP.; P3arr\". Th.'inas G Barter. Lav,-son Aver. 11 .. 147 Bartlett. Franklin Bartlett. Philip G Bartlett. Warren S 121 Easkervillt., Thorn. is Jl. ., 143 Passett. Acton 1 'ivill Passett, Edw.ir.l ,M 143 Bates, Liavi.l H., Jr Id 141 Battle. Geor.ge G 147 Bauerdort, Charl.s F 141 Bayard, Thos. F.. Jr .^ Bavlies, Edmtin.l E s3 137 Baylor, Theo.b.r.. T 113 Ba>'ne, Howard R 11" Eaxne. Hugh A Beadleston. Henry C....I11I 147 Beall, John A Beam. \\'illiam 11 s;; ]-.; Beaman, Clias. C .3 13. Beaman. "S\in. S Bean, H.niv Willavl P'.l Beatty, Robert C 12. Beck, Howard Beckett, Charlns 11 112 Beekman, Charl.s K 143 FlL'ekman, G.iar.l ^. Beekman. ]l.nr\' R ,' 12ii Beekman, James ^\'m Beers. IjUcIus Hart ss Hi; Bell, Edward W s- El Bell, Gordon Knox Belmont, Perry '.' Benedi. t Russell Beniamin. AVavlan.l I-;.. S.3 14 i Bennett, C. G Plennett. A\'m. il 123 Benoit. Le..n J Benson, Frank S Berkeley, Eancelot il 121 Berry, Arthur s] 117 Bettens, E.lwar.l l> 121 Belts, Fredi'iic 11 7:; llti Betts, Samu.d R Bigelow, Ern.-st A 114 Biiur. Xathan si; I3x Pillings, A\"m. E 121 Pinney, Hand.l m; 111 I3insse. Eouis E 123 Bird, John ^\':lrr. n Eisbee, Edl..n 131 Bishop, Corllan.ll F PIshop James L Pi.j Bishop, Mortimer H. Bixbv, George S Bixby. Robert F Blacitmar, Abel I'l Blackwell, Geo. E iC 132 P.ir- Si.L'.ia-i X-\MK. Il'i.it Hire | Pa.L-e Pi.ue I Pla.diw.r. \Vm. B 121 Blair, Jolni X..l.le 14:1 Elan. liar. I. Jain..s -\ . . . . s7 P.s i-;lan..'V. I li.iri.- 1- Ill Platchl..].!. S.-iml. A N2 p;l Ille.M k.-r, Charl. s yi I21.1 PlN.l.-nl.iiig, P. ni. 1; 133 Poar.lmaii. All.. at P i ;o:ir.br.aH. Pl.lw.ir..! C 13. J'.oardman. Plli.iah G Poe.-.-. miincv \V II .:. 13ii l;oma-t. 11. nr,\- E Iii2 111 Ponii.'r, I ;, .SIC..- S 14:.; r.oiiii.-y. I ;.-oig.' P 7;i iii 1 ;. ). )ra.-m . P. .uis A' Poi.ihl.v. .lohii W"...' Ill l:;.. PosL.n. . llail.'S A PI PlU P.:.su\i. k. I h:iili-s 1' s:i .123 P.jiuder. J. \Oan...ii. Jr.. '.1; 12; l;ovc..'. I.'. -V.. ,li- IP.1 Pi.w.'n, A.lna GuernsL*\". .. Pow.as J..hn .M 77 l.;o\.l, G.M.ig,' B P 3 12i; Po\-.l, P..l..aa M.. Jr PoN.l. A\"i.liam .-V p;.j p;r. liner. 1, i.3-pl!as 3. Ilraiin, H.-nrN' A PH 137 Pre. kenri.lge. Ge... P Bre..d- 1.' Pui kl.\-, .lulian cb-rar.l. . . Pud. I iliver P 7:; 1:;7 Bull, Charl. s c 7;i ni Bull. PPir.'..iirl 1117 14s Bullar.p IPiriil.l Ciiiais Burl.ank. (.3.11. !. A :i:'. lis Pur. Irir.l. P.'\\ is Siivr.o s:; ns Pur.li.di, h'ran.as Jl Burgess. E. PhiUii.s. Jr. .. P|3 Puik... Russ.ll FAy Purlingham. cpas. (.'.... 43 33 lluni.'t, Jain.'S P.".bins.in ,. ]22 Buni.tt, H.nr\" 1^ 73 Burrill. Charles D Bun ill, J. E 3!! 123 Purrill. ill.]. 11. ton S s3 131 Ilush. J. Adriance 77 119 I Btishe, Eugene L 122 For Signa- ls -VMK, Trait lure Pag.' Page Bushllell. Giles F Piul..-r. Charles llellrc.. S3 123 piul.ir. Prnscott Hall 113 Puller. Willard Parker. ^. 1:12 Puller, "William Allen. 3. .11 G.3 Puller, Wm. Allen. Jr... si 124 Butterworih, George PM. 1 142 Putterworlh. Wm. H 7:; 113 Byrne, James 3!i lit 113 I adw^Llader, John E...13 71 i.ahill, John H 143 ' aldn-.dl, J. H...pt' 11:1 . 3ilh...un. H^a^r\- \\" I allaghan, Alex. J. A...]nl 117 almali, P'a\-i..l . amn.arin, WiPiam c" IPi Camp. Elisha K ;i:; 114 C3ami). P'rederick A 112 ' ampbe-11, Alexander \'. .. 121 Campl...ll, l-'red'k B Campbell, William S.... ^. I 3in.o.a-, Flameu P: .n 112 ' andl. r. FUibert Welch.. ;i;i 112 Canheld, George i'..lger. si 112 . annon. Charles ]\1 i3inn..n, S,\l\"anus T Par:n.".n, "\\ilsi:ar i.,ee. Jr. .. ill ' 3ird..z.. ili.Piael H 77 124 Carmalt, A\'oolse\' 11. Carnoidian, A^^illlam 13 I .arpenter, Benjamin F. 1*1 13S I 3[rpenier, James E Carpenter, Philip S3 132 ( arrere, L. Si.lncy 132 carrington, Augustus 13. .. 131 i.3irter. James C, Iron- lispi.'.e anil 7.1 ill Cari.r. Samuel T.. Jr 121 I 3irusi. Charles F < 3ir\", Cl.ir..aiee 132 Case, George P I 3ise. llenrv Phelps Chanil..Tlain. E. W i'haml..'is. William P IPI ' han.ll.a-. James E 115 < hanl.r. E.wis S 113 ' luii.lin. Stewart 12n chaianan, Henry G chapman, John Jay 113 I has.a cle. nge 1 ■base. Ell. i.'U tl < hlMs. E.lwar.ls H 311 13s Chill, n.len. Sim...n P... 71 111 I b.:.ai.\ Jos. 'lib II :;, 711 6.5 I lioal... ANblllam G : 9 71 3.7 . br\slie. T. Lu.Uow P2S ciaik, Aiipletou E 119 t lark, Jefhasiin si 12 I dark, Pesi.-r W 97 133 I lark. Wall. a- D P3 131 I 3ark.., J..hn Pro.p.r 141 I diirk... ilarshall P Clark.. R. l"l.-.\-.l S3 ]:;(; Clarke, Plicbar.l H 71 IPS Clark.'. Samuel B 121 ciolau.l, Jani...s W. S lem.ait. G..org... A ss 137 lev. Pin. 1, I harl.-s I.i levchm.l, Trea.lwed 113 linch. li.lward S 73 11,3 lopton AVilliam C S2 147 'oe. Charles G 7s 133 'oflin, Pl.linund 73 lis 149 ]NJ)KX AND LIST OF MKMJ!EK8. P"f- Sigua- iviilt tun- P;ige Page \ij Coss-csh:ill, ICilwiii \V ri)-t;ill. (ii-oli;.- Cohen, Willhim X Colby, Bain))^ill^e Cole, John H 47 Coleman, Charles \V Coleman, Geors'e S n5 Coles, William 1j Colgate, James Coll>y Collier, Maurice luvi^ht .. Collins, Stephen ^\• Colt, Harris D Comstock, Freclrrii-k H'. Tli Comstock. (.Tec. Carltim. .. Conant, Ernest -Lee Coney, Geor.ge E Conger. Clarence R Connol>'. Theodore Conwa>-, I'^nstace Con\va>-, James J Conway, Thomas F....lo;j Cook, \\'illiam Wilson Cooley. Elmer E 101 Cooper, Drury \V Cornell, Robert C Corwine, Quinton I;i2 Coudert, Frederic iv...:',7 70 Coudert, Frederic R.,Jr. .. Cowen, Esek !il Cox, Rowland 107 Coxe, Mac,t;rane Crain, Thomas C, T 92 Crane, Alexander R Crane, Albert Crane, Percy Waldron.. .. Cranitch, William I. A.. .. Cravath, Paul D Ss Crawford, Frank L Crittenden, Edward W'.. .. Crittenden. Walter H.,. Nil Cromwell, Geor^^e Crowell, Eilward B Crowell. William Beers. 107 Cruikshank. Alfred B Culyer. Freilei'ic F Cunningham. Frank Curtis. F. Kingsbui"y Curtis, "\\'illiam, Edmond B:^> Curtis, AVilliam J .')7 Cushman, Archibald F.. .^ Dahl§Ten, John Vinton. 1H7 Daly, Eugene F Daly, Eugene Howell.. .. Daly, Joseph F Daly. Matthew Daniels, (;barles H Daniels, George Strung. .^.Ti Davenport. John Sidne>" .. Davenport. Timoth>' Davies. Henry E i;jr< I^avies, Julien T i2 Davies. Julien T.. Jr ^ Davies. A^'iliiam Giltiei-t. sTj Davis, Gherardi Davis, Horace A Davis, Noah 71 Davis, Seward 97 Davis, Vernon M 'iS Davison, Charles A Davison, Charles S' Day. George Lord Day. Melville C Dayton, Charles W '7, Dayton, Isaac Dayton, Robert A. B Dean, Philip S Deane, Joseph G De Forest, Henry W.. De Forest, Robert AV.. De Gersdorft, Carl A.. Degrove, E. Ritzema.. Delafield. Frederick P. Delafitld. Joseph L. . Delafield, Lewis 1^ Delahunt"\'. John de Meli, Henry G. D....1U6 Deming, Charles C Deming, Horace E .S6 Demorest, A\^illiam C... -sr! Deshon. Charles A .S7 Deuel, Joseph M Dewey, T. Plenry De Witt, Edward De Witt, George G 59 De Witt, Henry C Sx De Witt, Thpodore De Witt. AVilliam G Dexter. Stanley W S.i Deyo, Robert E Dickerson, Edward N Dickinson. A. G.. Jr Dilley, Charles H Dillon, John F « Dixon, William P .4 N.\MK. Vnr- Slgiia- li-iiit tulc, IMgc Page ISj 143 117. 147 tlli . . l:io 43 112 llX 139 iis 140 124 13-5 123 147 13S lis 12S 114 133 13S 111! 14s 14.7 133 111 ijk 67 122 12X 113 129 lis 137 127 144 122 132 il-i 121 120 123 i34 iii '68 135 137 12C 130 6.7 149 147 116 113 146 114 67 13.7 13-7 i32 130 132 125 121 Dodd, Louis F Dodd. Samu.l C. T Donnelly. Mcnry D 1U6 Dorsett. R. Clarence SO Dougherty, J. Hampden S2 Douglas, Archibalil 107 Douglass, Benjamin, Jr. .. Dow, Frederick G Dowd. Willis B Dowley, Francis I> Downer, Ben.iamin J Doyle, Louis F Drayton, J. Coleman Drysdale, John M Duer, John S2 Duer, William A Dugro, P. Henry Ins Dulon, Rudolf S2 Duncan, P^rederick S Dunn, P'^rancis E. A' Dunning. William V 47 Dunscomb. S. AV'.. Jr l'J2 Durand. J(din S Durland. Frederick L Dusenburj'. Edwin (_'.... H;U Dutton. John A 194 Dwight. Edward P" LTwight. Theodore ^^^ . . . 71 Dwight. Winthrop E.. .. Dyer. Richard N Earle, Henry M Iii5 Easton, Robert T. B Eaton. Dorman B 70 Eaton. Sherburne PI S5 Eddy. Charles B Edgar, Charles H S7 ICdgar, Ne\vV)old Le Roy s.7 Edmonds. Walter D 7S Edwards. Alfred I^ Edwards. DiUK an Edwards. Gtn' .J Eidlitz, Ernest F 9S Eisler. lOela D FDlkus. Abraham 1 9] Elliott. Robert W. i! Ellis. George \V SO Ellis. Ralidi N Elsber.g, Nathaninl A Ely, Alfred Ely, James F; A Pl]mljree. Lawrence E... 97 Emley. Jay Noble PJmmet. Richard S lilmmel, W^m. Tc'miile... 92 lilrskini:', John K.. Jr.... 95 PDrvin.g. John Erwdn. P'^rank A lo5 Esselstvn. Everett J 91 Eustis. John E 110 Evans. Thomas G SI B:varts. Allen W 77 Evarts, Maxwell Evarts, Sherman Evarts, William M....37 69 Everett. A. Leo Everett. John P liil Ewing. Hamilton JJ Fairchild. Charles S 77 Fallows. Edward H 96 Falls, Thomas J Fancher, B. L 73 Fancher. James R 96 Farquhar, Francis 9,j Fay, James H Fearons, George H,... 97 Ferris, Clarence C P"^essenden, James L) S3 Fettretch, Joseph Field, David Dudley.... 69 Field. William H 70 Findley. William L SI P'^ishel, Eugene 91 Fiske, Halev Fiske, John B. B P'iske. John W Fitzgerald. James lOS Flammer, Charles A Flanders, Walter C 105 P"^lannagan, Dallas 95 Fleming, Matthew C 94 Fleming, Woodvilli-' 9S Floyd-Jones, Edward H. .. Forbes. Francis Forster, Henry A Foster, F. De Peyster... SI Foster, Roger Foster, Tallmadge W Fowder, Edward S>'dne>' ^. Fox, Austen G ■j9 Fox, Charles 92 Fox, Robert J 97 Frank. Julius J lo5 Frankenheiiner. John... ^s Franklin, Benjamin \"\'. . 7s 125 112 136 131 lis 123 113 116 131 127 122 127 i33 66 146 125 137 129 144 131 125 116 120 115 147 146 113 145 146 132 146 113 139 117 117 66 119 111 iii 126 146 139 lis 143 114 129 12;- 65 111 113 122 US 121 116 127 114 111 135 123 115 115 140 127 iis 115 123 117 13s is; 111 13S iii 133 lii 67 13; 147 145 142 114 Por- Slgiia- \.\MK.. naif tuvc I'agu Pag.' Franklin, Ruford Eraser. Alex.ander W..107 14S I'rayer. ICugene SO 134 Freedmian, John J 12" French. Warren (_'., Jr.. .. Ill Frost. Elihu B 117 Frothingham, T. L 146 Fuller, Paul P'ldler. Williamson \\' GaiUard. William D 124 Gale, Noel 01 135 Gallaway. Morrill W 121 Gallert, David J 106 13S Gans, Howard 3 US Garden, Hugh R SO 1« Gardiner, Charles A Gardner, Alfred A Ill Gardner, John C. F 14. > Garrettson, P"^rancis T 132 Garrison, Llo^-d McKim. . . 127 Gartland. George E !i2 144 Garver. John A too 14., Gasquet. Marshall J 119 Gayley, Henry B 91 129 Geller. Frederick 92 13S Genet. Albert Rivers 95 144 Gerard. James W.. Jr... 94 133 Gerrv, Elbridge T 71 113 Gibbs, Herbert H 92 136 Gibson, Robert, Jr Gifford, James M 87 142 Gignoux, Robert Miles.. .. 139 Gilbert, Abraham S 104 126 Gillender, Augustus T 112 Gilleran, Thomas 12 12:) Gilman. Geor.ge H Gitterman. JO'hn Milton. .. 149 Gleason, John B Glover. Henr.v S 82 112 Godkin, Lawience 50 CS Goeller, Charles 93 127 Goeller, Robert 94 139 Goff. John W ins 121 Goldsborou^h, R. F 102 135 Goldsborough. W. L Goldschmidt, George B. 73 130 Goldsmith. Abraham ... 89 130 Goldsticker. \\'illiam 122 Goldthwaite, G. T 133 Goodale. John McG Goodnow, Frank J S4 120 Goodwin, Almon Goodwin, ^^'illiam B 142 Gordon. \Vm. Seton 122 Gould, lleniamin A.,Jr Gould. Charles \V 76 121 Govin. Raphael R Granger. Shi rman M Grant. Madison 90 123 Gray. Gerald Hull Green, Frederick Green, George Walton.. 61 68 Green. William A\' Greenbaum, Samuel .... S9 134 Greene. Allister Greene. F;ichard T 93 136 Greenrteld. George J 103 112 Gregory'. Henry E 87 13.j Griffin. Charles H Ill Guernse.v. Joseph R 92 IS.o Gulick. Alexander R 47 66 Gulick. John C ,89 143 Gulliver. AN'illiam (' 77 116 Gurlitz, Augustus T S7 12" Guthrie, AVilliam D SI US Hagar, Albert F 12S Haight, Charles S 148 Plaldiine, Wm. Henry Hall, David Prescott Hall, Frank L 142 Ha'l, William P"" Hallidav, Alexander B.. .. 12! Hallock. Charles P 102 131 Halsey. John R 134 Hamilton. P7. TAitber Hamilton. AVilliam H Hamlin. Geo. Newell Hamlin. George S Hammond, John H 134 Hand. Augustus Noble.. .. 112 Hand. Clifford A 141 Hanford. Solomon 116 Hansmann. Carl A Vl.-j 117 Hardfin. Henry «' Hardwick(r'. Henry Hardy. John 166 117 Hardy. AVilliam J 141 Harison, George D. L 128 Harison. William 135 Harmer, Hugh M ^ Harmon. Benjamin S — 8, 141 Harriman. George F 87 144 Harris, Charles N Harris, AVilliam H 100 136 HaiTison, Burton N 116 For- Signa- NAMK. trait ture Page Page Harrison, Robert D 47 66 Hart, George AVilliam.. .. 142 Hartridge, Clifford AV 142 HasBrouck, Howard 132 Hasln-ouck, Louis B 136 Plaslam, Lewis S 51 66 Hasselt, Pldward 92 115 Hatch p:dward S 7S 127 Hatch, RoswidI D Haviland, Charles T 13S Hawes, James A\' SO 133 Hawkes, McDougall 147 Hawkesworth, R. \A'.... 84 139 Plawkins. Eugene U 130 Havden . Henry AV 79 120 Heald. John O Pleaney, Geor.ge A 12.S Heath. Henry G. K l' Hedges. Job B 05 123 Hemmens. Henry J lo.j 132 Henderson, Edward C 6i Hennessy. Forbes J Henry, Richard M 76 116 Henry, Thomas S 139 Herrick, Frederick M 139 Herriman, Alric R 121 Herzog, Paul M 12s Hess. Otto T 143 Hewitt, Erskine ■•- Heydecker, Edward L.. SS l2l Heydt, Herman A 104 113 Hicks, Louis 1^1 flill, Edward B 12 1 Hill, Frederick T ••• Hill, George m Plill, John Sprunt ■■■ Hillhouse, James H-j Hilton, Henry '1 Hemmelmann. Henry A ■ Hinrichs. Alfred E 101 136 Hinsdale. Elizur B 73 1-1 Hitchcock. Bradford W. Sf 144 Hoadley. George S. 116 Hodge. J. Aspinwall. Jr. S9 11.:. Hodges. Charles Henry. .. 130 Hoes. AVilliam M 74 141 Hoff , Samuel 1' 'j Id Holbrook, AVilliam C Holcomb, Alfred E 104 131 Holden, Daniel J Holden, John 140 Holland, Ralph H Holmes, Artemas H...^. .. 141 Holt , George C ■->:! 43 60 Holter, Edwin O Homes, Henry F 81 142 Hooker, Thomas 122 Hopkins, Milton 139 Hopkins, Sheldon Ho Hoppin, Samuel H 141 Hoppin, AVm. AVarner... .4 14] Hornblower. William B. 57 61 Hosmer, Edw'd Sturges. 0. 129 Hough, Charles M 49 6u Houghton, Augustus S.. .. 122 Houghton, Clarence S.. .. ... Houston. John AA' 134 Houston, AA'illiam, T •■• Howard, George E. P...103 124 Howe, Joseph W 102 ■■^■ Howland, Charles P 1— HOwland, Clarence Howland. Plenry E el HO Hovt, Edwin Chase "si Hoyt, Henry R ■•; Hoyt, Henry S ■■ 12;^ Hubbard, Grosvenor fc... ..j IP. Hubbard, Harry 90 l-o Plubbard, John 104 122 Hubbard, Thomas H .0 116 Hubbell, Charles B o. Hubbell, George AA' 96 124 Hudson, James A 136 Hughes, Charles E 40 66 Hume, Arthur C 128 Hunt. James M 10. 14S Hunt, Thomas 05 144 Huntington, P'rancis C .. 112 Hurry. Randolph 101 114 Hutchins, Augustus S Hutchins, AA^aldo Hutchinson, Jno. A\^, Jr. .. 143 Plyde, Clarence M 100 119 Hyde, E. Francis 78 119 Hyde, Lewis H 98 112 Ingalls, Melville E.. Jr In,gcrsoll. Charles D Ireland, John B 77 131 Irwin, AVilliam 75 136 Isaacs, Myer S 43 66 Isham, Charles 143 Ivins. AA'illiam M Jackson, Benjamin A.. .. 148 Jackson, Charles A 73 132 Jackson, Edwin E., Jr 127 .50 INDKX AiNIt LIST OF MEiMItEKS. XAMK Iniil Imc Jacobs, A)irali:im L VJ .larnby. llswalcl N 1:1' James. ICdwaril C x, li; James, UeniN" A I'M' Jane\\a>', James li Jaeqiies, Dax'iil R Jaretzki. AUie.l Kir, 1 In Jar\'is. Saml l'\, J i" l'.\\ .lav. William 71 111 J.nlxs, William W i:;:: Jinnir, William A ili; Jeunill,L;s, Freiieliek B... V.', !.,'> Jeremi-. Wm. TraN'ers... xn iiii Jnhnseii, Ali'Xancler li J.ihnsnn, Allrii \\- Jnlmsi.ii. Arlluir Jl J'llinson, i;. llahlanr Jolinsoii, Iit-aii-\- r ','11 12i J'lhnsiin, Jolm Q. A l:;i, Joline. Adrian H NT 1 In Ji.iies, <'luni.'s L J.;.' Jiiiu s. K.lwaid K xri l:;:; Jones. lOdwin A liiii 1:;:: JcniLS. John M nr, Jones, Peicival S inl IK Jones, Townsend '.il 111 Jones, \Valt.a- R, T T.""i 1-17 Judse. Jolm H ;ii; l:;:; Jndson. e'harlrs N ]i:; Jnnkin. Franeis T. A Kalbfleisch. ( 'liarles ('.. Hi! lU Kalish, Charles A 1 ill Kalisli. Edwin Ij :i7 11:; Karge, I^adislas Kaufman. Kd\^'ard 8 Keating-, Stephen II Keatin,§e, Joseph il :iL' It-I Keeler. (.'Irarh s *.' Keener. A\Mlliani A 'n tiV Keith. Rondiiiot ■n7 il.: Kellogg, Charles Sno\^" Kellog-g-, Frederick R--. •• Kellogg. Luther Lallin.. ,, 1.,.. Kellv, Edmond :i:j lul Kellv. James E i:;i Kelly, Richard B inj j-i Kenneson. Thaddeus D.. Ml 1-n Kent. William I-. Kenycin. Alan D s'l i:;o Kenyon, Ben.ianrin JJ.... an I'S, Kenj-on, Robert Nelson. !iil Kenyon, "Wm. Houston, si li^o Keogh, Martin J UK tii" Kernan, Jolm D 1-- Kernan, Nicliolas 1-7 Kernochair, J, Freib.-ric. 71 li;n Kerr, John R N7 i:;i; Kerr, Thomas B Ketcham, Henry B !■'! Ketchura, A, P 7:i l-i. Ketchum, Edgar ''.'■' 1-S Kiddt-r, Camillas (i 7!) l.u Kiddle, Alfr U.. Kiernan, Adrian T King, Arthur IM King, Da^■id Bennrtt King, James Gore 1:111 Kingsbury, Howard T.. .. ll.-i Kingsley. Charles L Kinney, Herbert B l:;ii Kip. George G Kirchwev, Geor.ge W — ."'1 Ih Kirlin. J. Park( r :h1 111:; Kissam. Ben iamin T... 7-1 111 Kling. Charles Pott.-r.. .. 117 Klock, I'ercy B s4 Uu Knapp. Wallace Percy Knauth. Antonio Ill Knox. Charles H 7i; ll!i Knox. John Mason Knox, John M HI' l-' Knox, Bewis T Id 1-5! Kobbe. George C ^1 T-J' Kohier, Max J 1"4 i::i Kohn. Sol 11" Ki-cmer. Eugene G Kudlich, Herman <' '<'' Kurzinan, Seymour P hi'.' Lachman, Samson Nc M" Ladd, William W. , Jr BaFetra. Edward B n:: l;:i Bamb, Gilbert Bi Ihi I^amb. James A Bamberton, Charles B Bane. Wolcott G :i7 111 Bardner. AVilliam J .s:i 1111 Barge. Walter l-H Barkin, Adrian H l:iu Barkin, John ^ r^arocque, Joseph :!. il.7 BarocQue, Joseph, Jr lii."i i:iu Barremore, Wilbur 119 Batting, Charles Percy, ,, 121 T. Ba«- J; Ba\\-|-cncc, Itobta-i B,. Bcai.N-, William \' Bea\-itt, ,bihn lltooks Ijcllarbi. I-, (-barlos 10. Bed.Nard. I -owls ( 'ass, Bi-i', 1 '.( n j.-i ndn 1-' Be,., Jam, s G, K" Bi-, , ,l:inios Pa rrisli. . . B,-,-, R it 1' B.-o. William II. B. ... Benohaii. .b.lm J 1 ird. Willl.-in-i L>. . Be\i. Jos.-ph c Bi \-\-. Friix H "" i-nc II M Bcwis, Rii hard J. Bcxow. t 'lar, nco Bindl,\-. John .... Biiidsa\-. John 1) Lippineotl , Haiold K Biule, John T,, Jr Bittl, , Rol.c-rt l-'orsvlh,. Ill BUtlc. StcpliHii II Lid 1, -Held. Fr.-d, rick .M . Mi Bi\-crm(.u-e. Arthur B....lnil Bi\-inKSloii. Kdw. Did'.. .. Lon.gtellow, Fi-od-k. W.. .. Boontis. l-'iank Bord. Franklin I; 1.: Lord. Nathan II Boi-i ( k. Rudolph ;ii; Bux-i'land, John W \ Bo\\-i-c\-, l-'rancis l^ntcr. ,, Buro, liobort l,ce (11 Btuilow, Jami-'S 1: I^tiri:L, Av\ htir H B>-dc-cker, I'harlos E S', \ Bydon, Rirhai'd P VM B\-man, A h-.-vaiidi-r S Byou, Edward P Mi B>-on, Gi'orge William.. 7.i B\-oiis. Julius J 7!l ilaiiierro, Alfn-d Bei., .. 91 jManien-H, < hallos B ,S.'i MausHel.l. 1 low.ird i:, Marsh, i liarles M ilaish, Blither R (Ill M.iishall, (.'harlcs c ilarshall, II, Snowd. n., ,, Marshall, IjOuis .mi Martin, Newell .71 Martin, William P 114 JIason, Alrxandrr T Mason, Jar\-is W Mastcn, Arthur H .Ml Masten. Even ti Mastick. Scaliui-y C Ki:l Mathews. Albert Mathot. William B Mattison. John A Hiil Mattocks. I"reiloi-.k W.. :i.s Maxwell. Willi.im G May. Charles :Ma\-er. lloiir\' Jam., s . . . .ln.7 .Ma\-rr. lloinv w ini; Ma\-or. Julius Marshall. ',l4 .ABt\-|ial-d. JteulH n B It; Moi;arron. Fr.-iiik J :i.7 McPridc, Will, or lul MoBuruoN-. Charles 1 McCaiie. Amlirosr F In:; ilcCall. Edward E !l!l Mel 'arty. Ban la.\- E, V . W Mc< 'lure, Dayid 5;-l ill-Cook, John J 7ii McCorklr, Walter B McCormack, Bincoln Mci 'iirmick, Robert c, ., ;i:i Moi 'o\-, Walli r I JlcCidloh, Allan 9s McCiirdy, llilos Mel -utehi'oli, S. St Jolm , . Mi-Blhin\-. \'ictoi- K., Jr .. Mai-llirlalie, Wall.-ice ... 4:1 McGrath. Koln rl H.. Jr .. ilcCull-o. i:ilw-.-ii-il J McGllire. i'llisba W Mclh'aiiic. Tompkins McK'i.'oU. .JalU'S McKolve\-. John .Ia\- 91 Macihn-ia. Hcn|-\- D Mai-donald. Cli.-iries 1 1.. 107 iMacl.'arland. Wm. W... 71 Mack. Ha|-l-\- W MacVeagh. C'b.-i rlos .... ,S4 JIallct-I'rc\-ost. Ki'Vi-1-o.. .. Mail. Albon Man. Ali-ick H Man, Frederick 11 Man, Hcni-,\- PI Man, "William Manice, Willlain Maniee, Wm, Det^oresl. .. in-r I NAMJC l|-,ill. ;i:ir I'ii.uc 1:B I McKliiiicv. Clin-iii l'"ord. nil 117 I M.-Bran. 1 loliald In:; l:;l .M.-M.-ilion. l-'iiltoii Nil 1-, McMalioli. .Alarlin T....1IIN .. . McCJuaid. ' \\ lillajii A 1112 112 ,Mi Airkar. W . B.iid 1 11 .Mi-Williams, Howard .. :U ... I Meigha n. Pulton c 114 I IMeiiiliard. I b lirv 1 142 Moll. II. C|-i;is 141 Mop.-illo. Iloiiry N.7 ... I Mcnki II. S. Slanwood l:;n Morrill. P.-i \-siin 7il i:;n ilossiiiT. cloorm- X M l.li iMi-\-iT. I h.-iili s i; 121 ! Mcj'or. Theodon- 1''. H.. .. I2.-| Mo\-irs, Jamis t'owden. .. 112 .Miildli hroiik. l"ri d. J ... Miller, I'hal-lrs K 74 l:;il Millor, Geiirgo A ,x.7 ... Millor. Gcoi-gi. il liil 12.-I ilill. r. Ill-Ill \- F l:'.2| Millor. Iloft-man 121 ililloi-. J. Ploroki I- i:;.7 ilillor, Jai-ob !•' ;i.7 li:; Millir. William Wilson.. .. lil I Mills. Isaai- N Inn Hi.l iliiiralli. l-'onlinaiid R.. In:) . . . .Minloii. l-'ra mis B .s:; i;.') illntiu-ii. Roltort Shaw.. NN it:;' Mitcbi II. char-lHs B 9:; i:;4 iliti-li, 11. ciarenco p.. .. :i9 14n iniihi 11. Edward 74 . . . I Mitcliiil John Murra\-.. S4 ... I llitclirll. Richard H. ... .N4 142 iliti-h, 11. William i::9 MolTal. R. l;il|-nhan-i...77. 47 ... I Moffett. Riibort Beslie 149 Alollo.N-, (hallos A ,,. ilonriio, Rohort Giier.,, i::l 114 I Pdont.i^omerv. J. H 77 i:;7 liMooro. Albert R 147 ilooii . ( 'assiniir D'R l:.:2 il -o. John Bassett 1:12 I Moon-, n'homas S 7(1 IK, .Mi,,,r,-. Willial-n Clift-oi-d. .. l:;i Jl,,oi,-. William BI. IB... 77 122 Morau. I'harl, s A 142 1 Moran. William J Ill ' Mori! w,-tz. \'i,-t,:,r N2 IB il,,rmiii. ( 'hai-l,-s N 97 Jliu-.gan. Bbillin il Nl 121 ' Morn-ll. Rol„-rt I :i:; ... ilorris. F,-)r,lliaiu 74 12:s il,-,rris. Heni-,\- l^cwis,... 74 147 , ilorris. Jamis ... Morris. Newb.dd 114 il,,ri-is. Roli,rt C 11.:, I iMors,'. Jamin S n9 147! Mors,-. Richard Dana 127 Jlors,-. Waldo Grant... . 9n 14i iloses. P.aphael J ... I M,,sl,-. A. Henry 12.-, Moss. l,"rank :i:; l:;n M,,tt. .I.ihn ( 1 ,\:; 11:9 il,,ultoli. Fl-alikllll W lii; ' Mounl,i,,y, C. A 1117 147, ■ Mowt,iii. E,lwar,l P KM 1-1; Mulchahcv. John II 119 Mullall.\-. Thiu-nwcll ... iluml-,,|-,l, G,'(jr,ge Liana. 9.7 , , I ilurr.i.N-. Amhros,- S.. Ji- .. 141 I ilurra.\ . Chai-lis II 1411 1 Murra\-. B)ax-i,l (;7'Murra\- G,.,,i-ge T ... .Murr,-i,\. G.oi-.ge W 17 ... ,Murni,\-, J. An h bal,l.. .. s:i ... ilurra,\-, James B 79 1:j:; ' Murra,\-, Rol,,-rt D 911 .,, ilyers, Natliaiiiol 141; Nadal, ( 'harl, s C 91 12:; Nash, John ilcBi-an ll^ Xash, Steplu-n 1' :;7 illi 12,, Nasoii, B>aiii,l 07! Nathan, E,l,gar J X4 , . , ! N'aumbur,g, Pt-rnanl , , , I Nccai-stllm,!-, II,iii-\- li2|Newhoiisi-, Waltor S ,,. ' Ncwlaiid, l>a\-ld J 711 119 Nichols, I ;,-or^,. B 119 I Nil-hols, Jain.-s ( > 1:17 Nil oil, I.ielaii,-,,^- 7,N lis' Nicols,,ii, John, Jr l:;7 Niles, Wm. Whit,-. Jr... :ill ... N,.bl,.. IIii-|,,rt 97 129! North. Thomas M 147 Nortlii-011. (-harl, s P 12:n Xolt,,ii. Eli,,t 12.N i N,,rw 1. Carlisl,' 74 . . . Notntan. Jolm N., 119 Xott. ( 'barbs C.. Jr 119 1 laki-s. Charb-s i:;:i ( iakl(-\-. Ralph ]:i:j ( rPrii-n. E,lward B 91 1:19 ir.i i:;i 1:; I 111 121 i:;i 121 12X i:;7 i2U IIN l:.(l 147 ll!l i:i,\ 141 144 (id l:;i 14,S 124 lib ii.'i 1:14 i24 124 12:; 144 112 111 ill) 111 1:59 142 127 111 i:;i; i-ii'i 147 121 114 i:;,N 12N 142 117 12:1 ]1,< Hi 127 117 12., 11:; Illi l:;o 111) 112 For- .SlKiia- \,.\\II'; trait turi^ Pajrc r;wi- O'lirien. Moigan J lUS 115 ()■( '01-111,-11. i'liarl,-s 1).... 99 142 ( )-( 'oiin.-ll. Daiii.d 1:11; I |-( 'onor. Jolm 1 '.. Jr 77 114 ( ),l,-ll. llamilt,,n 29. 7:; li.i ( ),1,11. I lanm],,ii,l 9:1 'j-'-'-J I ).u,l,al. l)a\-i,l ii 47 l,ii ( i,L^,l,'n. I'rancis Ltnlbiw. -^ < ilmst,-a,l. Dwight II 71 I Illi, \-. P,-l,u- 1; 74 1:19 (|-N,-il. I'harl, s A i.)'N,il. Wilfri,l N <)p,l\-ke. Henry ClHlyk,-. William S I )p|,,-nh,-int. Samuel ....1(14 144 (Jrdway. Samu,-1 H HI uN uriTiiston. Th,,-mas S (irr. William c Ki:; 1:12 (-)sb,>rn, William , imnh 92 11, Otis. A. Waik,-r n;i bi; i.ut, r)jOU]-.g. Eimene Ottinger. Nathan Ciulin. Lucien 112 ( iwcns. Joseph E Pa, block, Gordon 1:13 i'a, block, Robert Allan I'ag,-, A\'illiam H., Jr.... 92 12.1 Pag,-. William R Paige. E,lwai-,1 Winsbiw M 1:17 Pain,'. Willis S Palmer. J. Culbort In7 129 Palmer. Lucius No,\-,-s,, 9S 141 Paris, Ii-ying Pai-ker, Frtineis E Pai-ker, Frederick S M) 142 Parker, W'inthrop ,S2 llil Parkin, AN'illiam i:ln Parinly, Rand,,lph Mi 114 Pal-risli, Samuel L 114 Parsons, Frai-ik H Pal-sons, Herliert Pal-sons, J, E 79, 7n (17 Pal-si,ns, \\'illiam B Palters, ,11, Edward 72 121 Patt, rsoii, Edward L Patters, ,n, Jolm iji 4'attcrs,ui, -\\'illiam J l'a\-,->-, Fi-tink D 77 (17 Peabodv, Charles A 7il Peabody, Charles A,, Jr, 7:1 117 Peale, Franklin D 1:19 Peck, Edward S Peikham, Rufus W., Jr, .. ]:;:; Peckham. Wheeler II.:;7, 72 97 Pei-kham. William G.... 7il 12,1 Pell. Frederick A 77 1:14 Pendleton. Francis Key. .. Percy, A\','lton C .',,ln:; iii; Perkins, Ed-\^-ar,l c (il (,8 Perkins, Charl,-s Albert. .. 14s P,-i-i-y. J,,hn il 129 Perry. Samuel S 1(14 i:i:; P,-ttv. R,,l„.rt B> Plulps. Charlos Henry Pheliis. Luis James 121 Pbilljin. Eugene A l:;9 Pliilipp. Moritz B 145 Philiiis. Frederic D 1:17 Philips. Louis S 121 Pi, rce. Carlton B Pii-icc. I'h-anklin IKl I'i,-r, e. AN'inslow S S7 llii Pi, -IS, ,11. ( -barbs AV 11(1 Pincoffs. Adol],hc L 121 I'iiie. John B i:;2 Pinii,;y, Georg,- M,, Jr.., S(i 129 Place, Tra Ad,-lbert Sli 127 t-'lalt, Frank H P,,rt,-r, Aiith,uiy B 134 Porter, John K 99 P,jlt,-r, Frcd,-i-ic Ki:; Poit.-r, Mark Winsl,,w,, 71 liT P,,w,-ll, Wilson M 77 117 Pratt, Charles A, B 9N 127 Pi-,-ble, "William P,, Jr,,, , Prentice, Roliert Kelly Prentice, William P Pr,ntiss, tjeorge Lewis Prentiss, Nathaniel A Pn ssing,a-, Austin ii . . . . 9,\ llil Ihiiii-e. H,'nr\' A 9!l 125 Protheroi-. Charles C Purdon. J,ihn 99 11:; Purdy, A\'m. MacNcvcn Purrington, AA'm, A ^. 11:, l^ulnam, Harrington ,,. 79 i;,s Putnam, Robert M, S 144 Putnam, Tarrant Putney, William B 14,7 INDEX AND LIST OF MEiMBEKS. r.ir- SifTiia- NAME. liiiil, tmv Putzel, Gibson 12i; Quinn, William P H?, Qliinby, Henry C l^M m Raescner. I>cinis i' Im; ]2(i Rand, William H., Jr Ill Randall, Frank E Ranilolph, Joseph F T'.i ]:;:, Randolph, Stuart F M ]:;i Rankine, Harold S 1":; ]2s Rankine. William B Itij Ransom. Rastus S n:: 141 Rapallo, Charles A i;!i Raiiallo, Kdward S 5:1 67 Rawson. Gnstavus A\' ReddinsT, AVilliam Alls IJj Redfield. Amasa A Redfleld, Rnhert L 1L>1 Redington, Geor.ge G....liifl It.') Reed, Latham Galluj) ll.j Reeves, Alfred G 121 Reid, Charles B Rhinelander, Thomas N Rice, Edwin T., Jr Inii 12;1 Rice. Isaac L Richards, Dickinson AV Richards. George Rirhards, Guy l(i:i i;;ii Richards. J. Tredwell... 7s i^s Riker. Samuel 74 i:;7 Riker. Samuel. Jr ;i,", ni Ritch, Thomas J., Jr l-ii; Rives, George L 47, 77 i;-, Robhins. Horace W Robinson. Allan '. Robinson. Henrv A I2i; Robinson. John C jiT Robinson. Nelson L pii 131 Robinson. Seth B ;ii; ii:; Roeser, John E lis Rogers, Charles Potter. .104 j27 Rogers, Clarence DeA\'.. .. 13:j Rogers, Hubert E Rogers, Noah Cornwell. Si; i:;i Rollins, Jordan Jacksrm ,. 144 Rollins, Philip Ashton Rolston, Louis B sti 120 Romaine, Beni. F., Jr Roome. W. Harris S4 137 Roosevelt. Charles H Root. Edwin B :in 134 Root. Elihu (13 (;x Rosen, Walter T liic 12(i Ross, .Jonathan C 121 Ross. William B 7.7 13j Rounds. Arthur C 133 Rounds. Ralph S 1.3S Rowe. William V .77 6V Rowlette. Thomas M 133 Rubens. Horatio S Rublee. George Rudd. Henrv AV 131 Rudd. Robert Schell.... Iii3. 147 Runk, Charles A Iii4 12.7 Rupert. Henry L 14C Rushmore. Charles B... S4 130 Russell, Charles Howl'd xfi 120 Russell, Horace 03 OS Rvan, Richard "W Sackett, Henrv W s2 131 Saftord. Philo P Sage, "W^illiam H Ill Sands. Ben.i. Aymar.... 41 05 Sanford, Edward I Satterlee, Herbert L....1U1 320 Schell, Edward T-1 114 Schell, Edwar.l P sS 117 Scheuerman, TFenr^- T^...liio I3i; Schley, William T". Hi7 14s Schultze, Bmile, Jr so 124 Schurman, George W 00 113 Scott. Francis M ins 115 Scott. William Forse 7S 120 Scott, William Hoyt Schibner, John M 71 120 Scudder, Edward M 114 Scudder, Townsend .... 03 140 Sedgwick, Arthur G Sedgwick, Henry P) Sedgwick, Henry D.. Jr .. 110 Seligman, Eu.gene Seli.gman, George W S3 110 Seligman. Theodr.re Seligsberg. Alfred F 105 117 Semple, Lorenzo 144 Sentell. Charles E 133 Severance. Wales F 120 Seward, C. A 00 111 Sewell, Robert 00 115 Sexton, Lawrenr'e E.... 40 Go Seybel. Daniel E 142 Seymour. Julius H so 113 Seymour. Ori.gen S 142 Shack. Ferdinand Shaffer, Jacob Herbert.. 00 130 For- Slgua- N.\JIK trait ture rage Page Shaw, Charles H 110 Shearer, George L ]n3 144 Shedd, John M M 11, SIk theld, James R flhelljv, Evan Sll> Idon, Edw. AV 55 43 i;5 Slirp.ard. lOdw.anl Morse .. 131 Sleii.'i.rd, J, Wools. .\- 133 Slopord. William 11 ]]■, Sheppard. John S.. Jr...lii2 lL':i ."-^berer. Arthur L 00 125 Sluirman, Arthur O Sherman, Daniel D Sherman, Gordr.n E Sherman, J!cnr>' H Sherman, JolmT SO 115 Sherman, P. Tecums'h. .. 112 Shil.and, Andrew. Jr S3 141 Shillal.ier, AA'illiam, Jr.. .. llll Hhijunan. Nelson Shope. Julian B so 127 Short, Edward Dvmaii.. so 130 Shortt. AVilliam Allaiic'. ., 142 Sllliman, P.en.iamin D... 7ii 110 Sih-ester, Francis Simpson, Angel J 02 112 Rimiison, David B 120 Simpson, Harry A\^ 127 Simpson, John W 7s 113, Skiilmcire, I.,emuel 127 Skillin, Au.gustus H .'-"killin, James L :iO 131 S'oane, Charles W 113 Smith, Albridge C 1II3 145 Smith, Augus'tine C Smi'h. Augustus Parker 05 144 Smith. C. Terry Smith, Chas. Robinsiin Smith. Duncan 75 133 Smith, E, Monroe Smith, Edwin B Smith, Eugenc' 40 00 Smith, Frank E 112 Smith, Frank Sullivan.. SI 125 Smith. Freling H 73 141 Smith, George Putnam. .. 130 Smith, Plenry AA^ 130 Smith, Hiram Smith, John S.ibine OS 121 Sniilh, Nathaniel S 114 Pniilh, Nelson 75 115 Smith, S. Sidney 41 65 Smith, Sidney Ol> 133 Smyth, Frederick 72 Snivth, Herbert C 140 Snow. Frederick A 142 Snvder. J. Frank Soley. James Russell Sondheim, Eu.gene 107 14S Sondheim, Leopold 1(i7 14S Soren. George Wales.... 72 140 Sonthmavd. Charles F.. ., Soiithworth. Ellis I-; 1111 144 Spafford, Jos.ph H :io 13| Speir. Gilbert M 7s 135 Spencer. James C 70 Siirncer. Nelson S 131 Speyer, Samuel V Siiiegelberg, FrederiLiv, . ss 142 Sprague, Henry L 7s 140 Springs, Richard A 133 Stanton, Henry 120 Stanton, Stephen B Ill Slapler. Henrv B. B 70 112 Staton. Henry 140 Stearns, Jesse 00 110 SP'dman, Ernest G Steele, Charles 06 Steele, John A. K 141 Sterling. George L S2 Hi Sterne, Simon 73 13S Stetson. Francis Lynd.. .. Ill Steuart, James L 143 Stevenson, Preston Stevenson, Richard AA'.. .. 143 Stewart. Percy H Sticknev. Albert... 53, 43, 70 60 Stier, Joseph F ]i)i 121 Stiger, William E id OS Stillman, Thomas E 70 132 Stimson, Henry L T2.j Stine, Marcus S5 129 Stockwell, William H Stone, Charles Francis.. .. 137 Straus, Oscar S 70 Strong. Charles E 70 Strong. Charles Howard Stron.g, George A Slron.g, Theron G Stuart, Inglis Stnrcke, Louis 121 Sturgis, Robert Sullivan, Cornelius J Sullivan, George H 145 rnv- Signa- X.AMK. ivait tuiT Page Page Sutherland. John L 123 Smro, Theodore 70 114 Swann, Edward Swavne, Francis B Iii2 117 Swavne, Wagi r so 130 Sweezv, Rirh.ird L ino 112 S\-kis, McCre.idy 140 Tail, Henrv W 53 07 Taggart, Itush 00 124 Tallmad.ge. Pred'k. S 132 'I'anncr. Frederic A Tanslej', Frank Dudley, 00 133 Tanzer, Laurence A Taylor, Alfred J Taylor, George H TaVlor, Howard A SS IIS Taylor, John A 14.3 Taylor. Robert Coleman .. 13i n\-n'lor, Thomas Fenton Taylor, AA'alter F 112 Taylor, AA'illard U 'fears, Daniel AA^ade 'fi'uney, Henr.v Allen Tenny, Levi S 131 Terry, Charles A 0^ 131 Terry, Charles T Oi 133 Terry, Soth Sprague 121 'I'haeher, Alfred B Ill Thacher, Thomas 61 6S 'fha\-er, Aaron Clallin 130 ■fbaver, Albert C 126 Thitchener, AVilliam II. . .. 142 Thomas, Abner C 142 Thomas. Hector AA^ Thompson. John C 123 Tbornall. Edward V 120 'Ihorne. Robert 141 'fic'deman. Christ. G Tilden, Samuel J 60 111 'fillotson, Gouverneur .... 141 Timm. AA'illiam C 00 134 4'ison. Alexander Ill 'fodd. Robert AA- 141 Tollfs, Brainerd 145 OOmTlinson, John C Tc)mlinson, AA'illiam T 'lOonpkins, II. B 77 140 Tompkins. Leslie Jay Touccy, Donald Butler Towne. Paul R lol 130 Townsend, Howard 130 'finvnsend, Jas. M., Jr.. .. 110 Townsend. Randolph AV. 76 1'ownsend, S. V^an R Tracy, Ben.iamin B OS 120 Tracy, Howard C 05 117 Tracy, J. Evarts 71 110 Trafford. Perry Davis.. 04 134 Treadwell, Eu.gene li)0 , 110 1 Tremain, Henry Edwin. 74 147 Trimble, Walter 135 i Triiax, Chauncey S so 110 ' Trull, AA'illiam C 141 Tiuslow. Charles W 134 Turner, Herbert B,..30. 71 65 Turner, AA'illiam L 50 6S Turrell, Edgar A 132 Tuska, Benjamin 130 Tweed, Charles H 73 110 Twichell, Harry L Tyler, Eliphalet AV' S7 Tyndale, Hector H Tyndall, AVilliam D 133 'fyng, Morris AshhursL .. 131 Uhle, John Bethell 03 135 rilman. Joseph 123 I'nangst, Charles 130 Underwood, A\^. H Underw-ood, AA'illiam J ITpson, AA'illiam Ford.... SO 132 A'alentine, Herbert SO 14u A''an Amringe, Guy 0!t 117 Van Brunt. Arthur H... 05 124 A'tmderpoel, Aug. H 138 A'an Duzer. H. Sayre.... 00 131 A'an Hoesen, George M.. 01 145 A'an Nest, G. AA'illett. . . . 79 141 A'an Rensselaer, C. S A'an Santvoord, Abr 124 A'an Sinderen. Howard.. 51 67 A'an Slyck. George AV... 74 141 A'an A'echten, A. V. AV.. .. 116 A'an AA'agenen, J. A A'arnum, James M 10s 120 A'rrnon, Philip H 03 131 A'er Planck, AA'm. G 102 126 A'ieu, Henry A 133 A'illard, Harold G 103 113 A'incent. John AN'addington, George 119 W'.ahle, Charles G. P.... 05 112 AA'ainwright. J. M 00 142 Wait. Frederick S 79 117 AA'alcott, Arthur Stuart, .. 122 NAME. For- Slgna- trult ture Page Page S8 Walradt, Arthur B 97 AA'ard, Henry Galbraith, .. Ward, Henry M AA'ard, John E 72 AA'ard, Sidney jAVard, Sylvester L. H... S6 W'ardner, Henry S Warner, James Harold. 94 AA'arner, John DeAA'itt.. 63 AA'arren, G, Thornton AA'arren, Geo, Flint, Jr. 104 AA'arren, Geo. H., Jr AA'arren, Ira D 73 AA'ashburn, Jacob 100 AVashburn, AA'm. Ives... 98 AA'ebb, H. AValter 93 AVebb, AVilloughbv L...10e Weed, John W Weekes, John A.. Jr 89 AVeeks, Bartow S 83 Weeks, AA'illiam R 100 AVeiffenbach, Geo, AA' AA'eil, Arnold Charles AA'eil, Robert Welch, David AVelch, Joseph A AVelling, Robert AV, G, , 84 AVells, Chas, Franklin. 77 AVells. Edward, Jr Wells, Thomas Tileston. .. AA'entworth, Thomas F. 82 AA'erner, Louis .88 Westbrook. Charles R.. .. Wetmore, Charles D AA'etmore, Charles W AA'etmore, Edmund .39 71 AA'halen. John 92 AVheeler, Everett P.... 63 71 AA'hipple, Herbert G 100 White, Henry 101 AA'hite, Henry C AA'hite, Howard E AA'hite, J. DuPratt 97 Whitehead, Aaron P AA'hitehead, Charles E.. 72 Whitlock, Bache McE,. .. AA'hitman, Charles S AA'hitman, Henry H. AA'hitney, Edward B. AA'hitney, AA'illiam B. AA'hitney, AVilliam C....74 AVhiton, Louis C 93 AVhitridge, Frederick AA'. .. AA'ickersham. Geo. AA'... 82 Wickes, Thomas P 104 AA'ilcox, Franklin A 71 Wilkie, John Lincoln 92 AVilkinson, Giftiord AA'illcox, David AVillcox, Henry C AA'illcox, William R....102 AA'illiams, Henry D 99 AA'illiams, Mornay AA'illiams, Stephen G 44 AA'illiams, AA'illiam 92 AA'illiamson, Samuel L.. .. AA'illis, AVilliam H AA'ilmer, AA'illiam N '. AA'ilson, Lewis F AA'ilson, AA'illiam Carr. , 94 AA'ilson, AA'illiam G AVinslow, Francis A 96 AA'inston. Frederick J AA'inter, Byram L 91 AA'inthrop, Bronson 94 AA'inthrop, Buchanan AA'inthrop, E. L. Jr 61 AA'inthrop, Grenville B.. .. AVise, Edmond E .88 Wise, John Sargent 91 AVitter, AA'illiam C 76 AA'odell, Silas 87 AA'ood, Chalmers AA'ood, Joseph AA'oodbridge, Chas. E..106 Woodbury, Gordon AA'oodtord. Stewart L AA'oodruft. Charles H AA'oodruff, John S AA'oodward, Henry E AA'orcester, Edw. D., Jr. 51 AA'ork. James Henry AA'orkum, Julius F AVright, Albert Bradford .. AA'right, Boardman 106 AA'right, George M 103 AA'right, William George. 106 AA'yckoff, J, Edwards.. .. Yeaman, George H 75 Young, Charles H 57 Y'oung, J, Addison Zabriskie. George 43 Zaring, Charles W 94 Zinsser, August, Jr 105 129 113 IS-l 141 134 147 117 68 128 112 124 137 141 iii IIG 125 147 141 139 128 122 i28 129 129 127 112 112 148 65 120 68 136 134 125 isi 128 127 135 68 i.37 126 133 127 113 124 139 139 136 140 66 145 142 112 144 lis 129 114 145 138 115 68 143 142 125 114 123 111 127 60 127 143 133 131 131 123 116 67 66 123 136 1S2 ^^v jSs5 >J|<;' u^^^'v %4yk^' '': ^ J^^^'-«r^^ '^^■ KF BB^i- rT5-''' T^t-7 Author Thompson, Frank Vol. Review of the ^s.oc d¥ the har of "l^^'^^^^^.^t^'^^.^W Till /iew of +h^ ri tv nf T\r,- Con Date Borrower's Name -:k&. ^"^^\ ^.-^^^. ^^^\.. ^^ ■■X od. f^fv^Sit^ "V' »?.'^!"--'-.>-^;->'-^"