THE MARTIN P. CATHERWOOD LIBRARY OF THE NEW YORK STATE SCHOOL OF INDUSTRIAL AND LABOR RELATIONS AT CORNELL UNIVERSITY ^OIISMEFS C0!!?E1TSATI0^ PUSirCITY I^J-^l^l 1-WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION AND EMPLOYERS' LIABILITY PROBLEM. History of the Movement in Missouri; Statistical Pacts and Figures Relating to Accidents Which Occurred in 1913, Gathered and Com- piled in 1914. — ^Work of the Missouri Free Employment Department, St. Louis, Kansas City and St. Joseph, During the Fiscal Year Which Closed September 30, 19 14. —Accomplishment of the Women's Department of the St. Louis State Free Employment Bureau During the Year 1914. A PRELUDE, AND SUPPLEMENTARY TO THE 1914 RED BOOK. 'to'criri'*' Prepared and Published by the Missouri Bureau of Labor Statistics, Jefferson City, Mo. JOHN T, FITZPATRICK, Commissioner. A. T, Edmonston, Supervisor of Statistics — ^John L. Bradley, Deputy Commissioner. DISTRIBUTED, 1915. Property of MMm. P. CATHERWOOD LIBRAI JE...HSON CITY ■^ YORK STATE SCHOOL The Hugh Stephens Co.||||JSJU|L AND LABOR RELATION^ Printers #<. m 1 . Cisrnell L.iivarsit^' U7 STATE FREE EMPLOYMENT DEPARTMENT OF MISSOURI. Send Your Requests for HELP To the NEAREST STATE FREE EMPLOYMENT BUREAU The Service is FREE, Make Use of It Write, Wire or Telephone. Gratuitous Service Given to All — Farm Help and Timbermen Supplied. Missouri maintains a free employment de- partment as a part of the Bureau of Labor Statistics — offices in St. Louis, Kansas City and St. Joseph — with a view of keeping the unemployed in close touch with those needing help of any kind, male or female. The service is free of charge, with the only requirement that any one out of employment and applying for a situation report promptly when work is found; Employers are supposed to notify when they have filled vacancies. There is no Hmit to the class of help the Bureau can fur- nish, supplying professional men, skilled trade workers and any number of men or women for positions lower in rank. Special attention is given to calls for farm help and timbermen. Employers in small towns are also cor- dially invited to make free use of 'the service with no cost to them. When in need of help, write to the ^nearest State Free Employment Bureau. St. Louis — F. J. O'Keefe, Superintendent, 917a Pine street. Kansas City — Harvey Osborne, Assistant Commissioner, Sheidley Building. St. Joseph — G. J. Kamler, Superintendent, 110 North Seventh Street. Main Office — John T. Fitzpatrick, Commissioner, State Labor Exchange, 215 Sheidley Building, Kansas City. P .\y WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION AND EM- PLOYERS' LIABILITY PROBLEM. HISTORY OF THE MOVEMENT IN MISSOURI: STATISTICAL FACTS AND FIGURES RELATING TO ACCIDENTS WHICH OCCURRED IN 1913. The urgent need of Missouri for an adequate workmen's compensation law which will amply provide for the dependents of those who meet death while toiling as wage-earners In factories, workshops and elsewhere In the State; supply a just, suiHcient remuneration to those Injured so seriously that they never fully recover and are therefore unable to return to their former callings, or to take up another calling equally as lucrative; and to care for the injured and their dependents during the convalescence period until such a time as the un- fortunates can resume their duties, caused the Bureau of Labor Statistics in 1914 to collect statistical information on all factory and workshop accidents, fatal and otherwise, occurring during the year 1913, which would prove useful in basing and determining the extent of liability of the employer for all mishaps to employes while at work, and in fixing a com- petent compensation. Approximately twenty thousand special interrogation schedules were sent by the Bureau of Labor Statistics to those coming under the scope of the State-wide query as to accidents and their causes. In all, 2,237 Missouri factories, workshops, electric light plants, breweries and distilleries, gas manufacturing companies and other employers of labor, chiefly the larger extablishments — not including public service companies such as telegraph, telephone corporations, electric and steam railroads — made either full or partial returns, many such furnishing valuable informa- tion concerning the different phases of the employers' liability and workmen's compensation problem. The establishments considered gave employment during 1913-14 to 184,098 salaried employes and wage-earners, consisting of 151,204 male workers and 32,894 female. There were 25,959 accidents reported as occurring among this large army of employes, 82 of which proved fatal, leaving 25,877 who recovered, but with 82 who were more or less permanently disabled. These returns, if they are accurate, suggest that 25,795 of the injured fully re- covered and were physically able to resume work where they left off when the mishaps befell them. The point on which there is doubt Is the reliability of the information that 25,795 "fuUy recovered" and were as able-bodied as before the accident. For some occupations the loss of a finger would prove a permanent disability for one following it, but the loss of a toe or even a portion of a foot would not interfere with the earning abilities and usefulness of such a worker. What constitutes a permanent disability, if the maiming is not extensive, differs for the various industries of the State. The number "permanently disabled," as re- ported for 1913 by car shops, smelters, founjiries and machine shops and several other in- dustries where the work of the wage-earners is regarded as hazardous, were low when com- pared to those reported Injured and fully recovering. COST OF "PROTECTION" WAS HIGH IN 1913. The establishments which reported accidents or supplied information relating to the subject of this chapter paid during the year under consideration 8534,595 for accident and liability insurance and other similar protection against liability for injury to the 184,098 men and women they had on their pay rolls. One of the questions put to employers of labor requested information as to whether or not men and women in their employ had mutual protection funds and whether or not the employer contributed, more or less, to the ^ame. Only 452 establishments replied in the affirmative to this interrogation, probably for the reason that many employers did not realize that employes who were members of a labor union had a national or international fund on which they draw in case of accident, sickness, death or any other mishap which took them away from their work. Nearly all employes of car shops, smelters, foundries and machine shops, cigar factories, woodworking establish- ments and planing mills, stone yards and quarries, printing and publishing houses, engraving and electrotyplng companies, clothing manufacturers and other pmrsuits which require highly skilled workers, are members of labor organizations which have mutual benefit funds (3) Bureau of Labor Statistics, 1914-15. conducted entirely independently of their employers. Many large corporations with hundreds of men and women on their pay rolls have benevolent funds for employes in case of mis- ^ fortune to which employes contribute regularly but with the corporations as the chief bearers of this burden. Further along in this article are cited instances of this kind. Fiu-ther information deahng with the returns made by the 2,237 establishments included in the inquiry can be gleaned from a close study of the following table — better, perhaps, than by giving the facts and figures in any other manner. By a coincidence, the number of fataUties and the number of permanently injured, as appearing in the compilation, are the same. RESUME— INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENTS, MISSOURI FACTORIES AND WORK- SHOPS. 1913 — BASED ON INFORMATION GATHERED IN 1914. TABLE A. Number of establishments reporting accidents, 1913-14. Number of male employes in establishments considered . . Number of female employes in estabUshments considered . Total number of employes in establishments considered . Total accidents among all employes, establishments considered, 1913 Percentage of accidents, fatal and otherwise, compared to number of em- ployes, 1913 Percentage of accidents not fatal compared to number of employes Total number of fatalities reported among employes considered, 1913 Percentage of fatahties as compared with total number of employes con- sidered, 1913 Percentage of fatalities as compared to number of accidents, 1913 Number of persons injured and permanently disabled, 1913 Number of persons injured who fully recovered Percentage of permanently disabled as compared to number of accidents, fatal and otherwise, 1913 Percentage of persons reported permanently injured as compared to those fully recovering, 1913 Percentage of persons injured and fully recovering as compared to number of employes, 1913 Percentage of injured who fully recovered from their injuries, not including those fatally injured, 'l913 Percentage of those who were permanently injured as compared to nonfatal accidents, 1913 ! Percentage of persons Injured and fully recovering as compared to total num- ber of injured, fatally and otherwise, 1913 , . Percentage of those fully recovering as compared to those permanently dis- abled. 1913 Number of estabhshments reported carrying accident or liability insurance or other protection , Number of estabhshments reporting no accident insurance or which failed to answer the interrogation Cost of "protection" to establishments carrying accident insurance Number of establishments reporting paying wages or having other ".benefits for employes during disability Number of estabhshments which did not pay wages or maintain other beneflts for disability or which failed to answer interrogation Number of establishments reporting that employes have mutual funds for their own protection f Number of estabUshments reporting that employes had no mutual protection fund or failed to answer on this interrogation . Number of estabhshments reporting that they contributed ' to a mutual em- ployes protection fund Number of establishments which did not contribute to such failed to answer interrogation Number of establishments reporting pensions for length of service,' or' having other philanthropic innovations Number of estabUshments that reported they' did not have or contribute to a pension fund or which failed to answer interrogation I fund or which 2 237 151 32 204 894 184 098 25,959 14.1 % 14.05 % 82 . 0445 of 1 % .316 of 1 % 82 25,795 .316 of 1 % .318 of 1 % 14.01 % 99.68 % .317 of 1 % 99.37 % 99.68 % 2,015 222 $534 ,595 1 063 1 174 452 1 785 50 2 187 86 2 151 Workmen's Compensation and Employers' Liability. 5 MANY ACCIDENTS PROBABLY NOT REPORTED. Employers of labor who had no accidents and carried no "protection" were not supposed to fill the special Bureau of Labor Statistics accident interrogation schedules. There is no- doubt but that there were accidents among the employes of some of the smaller factories and workshops which failed to report, but it can be stated that most of them were undoubt- edly of such sUght nature that not much time was lost by the injured. How correct the statistical information which follows is depends upon the accuracy and care exercised by the representative of the factory, public service company, workshop or other employer of labor who indited the report. The returns were received through mail, and none could be taken up for individual investigation as to their exactness and other points owing to the lack of funds to completely carry out a Herculanean task which the Bureau of Labor Statistics had volun- tarily imposed upon Itself for the enlightenment of those who are interested in the problem of employers' liability and what constitutes a just, fair compensation for an employe in case of a mishap. STYLE OF INTERROGATION SCHEDULE. 1. Name or title of estabUshment. 2. Name of corporation, firm or individual owner. 3. Location of factory: Name of city (or town); street and number; general office, where located. 1. While working at their occupation, how many employes sustained accidents during 19137 A, fatal; B, nonfatal; C, total; D, nature of accident; E, how many fully recovered? F, how many only partially recovered? G, cause of accident. 2. Does your company carry accident insurance for the benefit and protection of and to indemnify injured employes? If so, give particulars as to the class or kind, benefits paid employes, etc. 3. "What provisions have you made to protect and indemnify yourselves against accidents to employes? Give full particulars. 4. How much did all "protection" cost in 1913? 3 5. Are injured emiployes paid wages while unable to work? If so, give particulars. 6. Have employes any mutual fund for use in case Qf accident, sickness, etc., to meet loss of wages? Give particulars. Do you contribute to this fund? How much, give partic- ulars? 7. Have you a pension roll for length of service, etc.? If so, give particulars. 8. Give particulars concerning any other innovation, benefits, philanthropic enter- prises, etc., your company, firm or corporation supports, contributes to or espouses in favor of employes. ACCIDENTS FEW IN SMALL ESTABLISHMENTS. In Table B, which follows, establishments which failed to answer certain interrogations are included in those listed as reported negatively. No returns were received from the ma- jority of saw and lumber mills of the State, but these were the smaller establishments when compared, individually, with the larger ones which did report. For the reason that the larger the sawmill the more hazardous are the surroundings of the workers, it was impossible to make a conservative estimate for accidents in the smaller establishments which did not re- port. In the compilation, totals are firSt given for the factories and workshops of the State, and then, the totals for the telephone companies and steam railroads and electric railways returns. Industries are grouped according to their classifications. In Missouri there are probably 20,000 factories, workshops, public service companies and other employers of labor, large and small, who make annual reports to the Bureau of Labor Statistics under the provisions of the laws governing this department. Over half are estabUshments which employ less than ten wage-earners, male and female, and especially is this true as to those of the smaller cities and towns. It is foimd that the more numerous the employes the greater the number of accidents, not for the reason that such larger corpo- rations expose their employes more than do the smaller establishments, or that employes, being more numerous, are more careless, but probably for the reason that the larger the estabUshment the more intricate the fast moving machinery, which, in many cases, is not amply safeguarded, and the more exacting are the requirements under which toilers must work. Section 7827, (E. S. 1909), requires "that all accidents in manufacturing, mechanical, mercantile and other establishments, or places within this State where labor is employed, which prevent the injured person or persons from returning to work for two weeks after the injury, or which result in death, shall be reported by the person in charge of such establish- ment or place to the State Factory Inspector * * * which notice may be given by mail." No accidents to employes of mercantile establishments, either wholesale or retail, or which occurred to elevator conductors and other employes of large office buildings or steamboat lines, express companies, telegraph companies, construction, building and contracting com- panies and individuals, and several other industries and pursuits, are included in the facts and figures this article deals with. (Continued on page 11.) L— 2 Bureau of Labor Staiisiics, 1914-15. c/2 W >^ o w Q < ;z; o I— I <: :^ w o u !/3 :z; ^ H w 1-J pq n p^ P^ p Pm ^ 1^ r/i — 1 1— 1 1 — 1 p pq o < CO h u u I — I CO I — I CO H " X-" ;:. 5 M CJ to ^ O E-i W fe o o I r<-i On HP (=3 !«"" H 00 H ^ P3 H CO fe H w o O 2 - m«^2 !§-§ !? n H P5 S h O S Oto 15 ^QS H Hg ^ X HH IH «fa^«! B e^ >H ;? £ H :? Q SS O H *«! ri H ^ s W W •»! ^ S <» H " H H > ft J Eh '^ „ft M gSH° |z H EhH WK«M to E-i H H 3 o o h f^toHO. oiz; ^H HW Bo Smog lz; o oo 50h£ |gss cj H r f^ M to g S <-< U3 CD 0> < N "* I> M CO I O C4 (O •>«• t^ M t^ OO (N CO ( Workmen's Compensation and Employers' Liability. ' ^ (M (M " ; -■ '- -■ -^ (M o 1-1 CO 00 ^ S o Oi us l> m •M sg ■* r-o ^'^- -^ lo m oo m m < t- M CO i-H CO iph CO CO tH (N t^ ' t-. M t^ ' I CO CD CO 00 Tl W QO CO ^- OS ( ^H CO M »-i M t^ l-H O t^ . (M lO CO o o cq •-" I t^MOOOSMOSMOO OT -H t» 00 OO in *Hoio<-icoi-ti-i'*oo^coi-ioa — O CO O (M .-( OS CO (-P. nn »i-i 1,^ i.™ iJ: i-H •«*< CO ifr-OCOOSUBOTtlcOOl ph S ixj [^ Bureau of Labor Statistics, 1914-15. , ««««« g!'-g§?3SS'^S5""S'"S2S : 1 !i-§s-sl A !S as th loyer isiona pensio length arvice. i M ■ -' • ■ : M '. '■ ^ ^ OA ^ ; : 1 't)h ■ ■ 1-t !« i-H DO 00 t^ t^ „„c.„„ 3i-Sa3-'?3"S"^SS : Does th employe contribu to any such fun * A (M • : i ; " : : M ; : -^ tN ■# rt ■ "* ■ r~t 1 "tO e- 6 1 III ^ ^ Companies paying wages to employes during disabihty. CO N t-- iO N M ■* ■ Iz; * cor^Of-HtM eo ioeoo.-ioopoccco• 11 Mt-i -fl* N co^*c^^ iii-i '■'•'■'•'■'■'• e^ < How , many only partially re- o- - '• 1-1 % How many of the injured fully 13 O 1-1 -»0t^t» mmco oo S CQ 1-H W »-( CO CO i-i a> »o No. of estab- lish- ments 13 S3S2SS gaa^s 3! '^ § s g "S " s " s s s -" : :| 1 '' • ■s . ; " S : : 3) 1 t— 1 1 ji Hats, caps House furnishings Ice and cold storage Iron, architectural and 1 Jewelry, repairing Leather products Lenses and ontical sroods Liquors, distilling, rec blending Liquors, vinous 'p. 11 1 Musical instruments Novelties Oils, greases, rendering. . Paint, varnish Patterns, models Petroleum products Workmen's Compensation and Employers' Liability. 9 to »• • CO so t- (M 00 I (N 1-H »0 OO CO t^ ■ lO i> Ti< CO CO CO M >n 01Mi-( CO' Tji cq »N cq ^ (M O TJH t^ .-I t- Tji rH C30 l-t GC CO I i-H Cfl *0 t- OJ CO *H " '^ M «OCOWt-09t-' t^ O O "* 1 t— i-H CO 00 1-H T-l (M l-H 1-1 eo ■ locaiocoococoto cq t^ CO »o (OTj^MQOcot-oqoo CO CO on C-l C4 *"* CO cq cq S CO cq Ol tn CD o e» OJ s CO : ;l ; ^ • s.a ; •T3 d ■ cd 'S il^^ t ^ ^ m til .s ^ c8 1 1 00 >, rt ft ■s a g 2 a j:1 ^ g- o w M O H tin O ■j U o'§ rt • S «> " 2 <2 " fl S 1 u in ea s Pu es] LO t- SS •-4 «o Has the em ployer pro- visions foi pensions, length of service, etc. ^ j: m" ;S 00 -♦— ■*- 00 s Does the employer lontribute to any uch fund? d * (?q *o t- w" s oo ■ ^ oo oo " ai i» , '^ (V. O CO cr. 9S i IJ 1 .§ i '-' -1— -1— OS 5 * -S s ■ O tM '-' H- -1— a s M o ^ :S ft >* ft Companies paying wages to employes during disability. i 00 ■ - - 00 g A '^ 4_ ■*"■ - ! Cost of rotection" employer during the year under 'S § Bin- CO ■* i S "^ w o. o - ■+J M .2 6 No. of ompanies carrying accident osurance. r — ea , ■^ 05 u .^ ^ ^— +- o 1 How many only partially re- £^ N c s o 1 g How ' many of the injured fully ^ m CO CC J _ i 1 s S'^.^ ^ c i M ■»** i-H CT u s >n s, 3 Ca CD :i ^3 " rt (M CO o c 3 CD 'o oo o_ l ° "^^ u 13^2 n c- t- OS 1 t- "^ c a li. s -a — .a « <£> •* • c 5 Tfl No. of employes reported. ■a 1 5 S 1 O lO O 0( C O t^ S oj Oa CD ^ r- H t r* ■3 CO eo O t: 1. is s oT o c 3 C 3 ^ Tjt C •1 t (M -i CO « ■3 -• U3 . a M e 1 I O t- gl^a ° ■'i W 1 ;|: ~ 1 1 V i 1 >. ■ t3 g s M ■ _■ s i s s 9 ti . ' t^ M •* -ii •« Tt< lO CO CO « -* « > • OS rt 00 00 oc to a a a o -e lO U3 lO to c h- ft m ft T^ s »0 (M rH Ol « IN ^fl 3 a a g » c iH 1^ N O Tf) IM IN Th « -^ t^ t- ^ -3 *^^ .2 ?; » a T-l N IN g „ >. ■ CD w O t- « lO .S 2 t. o 12 t> M O o> c O ft 3 £ ft S fts-" a a 01 iH CD to cr O fH iH ci ■* % %% ^ (N Oi lO lO 10 ■<* Ol 03 01 rH o o o oc 00 Num of plac unflU cc « rt CO o o O oc 00 lO u ^ S M . I> (N 03 00 c 00 00 CT l> O S Tj CD CO m to -^ o O (N CO i°«| CD lO CO 00 O! o> t> CO 1 ft-a lO tH -* ■* ^ Tt< C^] b- rM M IN cq (N S? ft iH -.^^ 00 m c m CO :*■ CD B '&'$ CD lO 10 t^ ■<: rH iH r- ■<* 00 oo 00 ■<* CO la < & M IN N CO ,f%k. 00 o c 00 tc Tf T|< CC o 3 d 3 o -^ o -^ c -* oc M CO N i-H App; cants suppl empli men 00 t^ ■* 05 r- OO oo' r- O)' S3 „ .^ ^- (N c 00 c 00 00 O l> CD CD o; to -^ O o c^. CO io!i&| CO lO cc 00 Ol c:i t> CD f3 ^ CM M lO Tfi Tf* ■^ ■* ^ c t> N IN (N cq 1 plica- ons :or ploy- ent. lO (N O- to tc IN (N If t^ l^ o er rH ^ ^ ■^ c ^ ^ ;o c « Cv o o c o ^•^ as |> IC u- s CO ■^ CO CO 4:> . a to a >> o ft ^ a s H d a S&3 s t4 o 'i Locatii e empl burea a ■1 c ■« h "S > 'l ■> 1 i i: 2 a cd 'S to Jl %. . a p-l Q fg e B e c ^^'iS 1- I 1 c ;l i a a . CO 0) •3:3 tS "^ IB © 43 to *^ 9 S 05 si t> Eh Eh CO o = '£■2 1 ts a|.° ^ O to S *H c3 Q p, O 2 :a S •^ a ° rt 3 S O — I to a.S'" tS 43 M ° S .iH u 3 %-a si fi " '" 05 43 _ .3 . o .22 tD 2^3 2 t« iJ O 43 -^ ■^ ©-0 ■ '-^ -* *t3 t3 J^ V. rt „- o •« %-a S -^ !S o s» 5 o ^ ffl a 8 " C5 43 13 a *^ asS 2 a ■« 2-1=1 I^ 3 - "^ o 5 t» m to rt .2 " 3 o >■ o >f S a|. >» 35 20 Bureau of Labor Statistics, 1914-15, O z o X! SS w > O H Z. Ed H ■< Oh Q H O o CQ H H tffl Oj o CO CO « 00 o a '^ O O «5 ze is of. h U IF^ 8. UU Ss. Z U B BM H© .. b , d Z » U H >• a "m zS". "S-z J "> a. 4II.0 S2h u n ij UZu h Id S s h g OStB sz^ wzS ggo z*H ^ W ;y U H « A^Z z , w « fain 5*Z H U S Q ta fa !ia '. z u use nJ H h OS < &; 01 O •« OJ « CO l> 00 i* r^ l^sl OS rl (N 00 00 OS o So s § rH iH iH I- H 00 Z ag 1 » • -* O 03 CM -^ C IS 00 S g M t^ lO CO l> (N c a^^l Ol O O CD CO t ^ o« r-l .-1 rH rt C q 01 g A CD -* <£) 1-C Ol P 5 01 til ft o a CO ec o lo o <- H t> 1 rH m OS "3 CD Ci 3 rH ft-43 t. (N (N rH (N CO T h t^ rt »0 CC t> (N C 1 « 01 O O (D CO b o fi s r-l rH rH tH C 1 01 K« a a K 5 a ft o o ft S ■^ OJ tH I> rH tf s o M 01 ■* CO C-l C i a CO Tji (N rH 00 C ) rH S-'S*' a a rH rH rH (N rH -^d ■< (N 1 w d (N 00 ■* Tf CO "■ S CD r- b- ■° a a CO IN O N rH C ) n a- C^ Num of plac rH O W « O C b- CO W 1> CO ■'J > CD c CD oc rH rH ^ U3 t4 S » ■' o ■* w -^ »o 0( CO oc ■^ ■° H TI ^ ^ t^ O rH C U3 OC ■* Num of plac rH CO 00 O 00 O « c OS CD OS 10 CO (N •<* rH rH C^ b- rH s.a (N (N 0> 00 00 P" (N 03 ^ O ■* t> (N « O Tt< ^ CD i ft'S Sj CO cq 00 o o a OS b- CD ■< S M rH CO rH O. rH tH CO s s ^ *H rH mber .n- .ced. »0 O lO 00 i> -^ OS N ^ CO O O N (M Cf M CO CD 00 CD OS IM -* r- >H O 3 PS ^ ft co CO CO CO rH a CO CO i>r c^ w 11 O tH U3 Tt< XO QC CD 00 -* Th rH t> O rH C IC 00 ■^ rH CO 00 »o 00 a 00 O OS r- CD Ol »0 CO (N -^ eq" OS rH rH rH C^ i> 00 Applica- tions for employ- ment. W ■* O (N (N (S w o tC t^ rH « CO ■^ ■«* 00 t> (N C OS .- C^l OS CO OS CD -^ C co" « 0^" rH r-( rH er OS rH o rA - i c c CT V ^ g OS OS 01 OS 5 1^ ^ 1908- 1909 1910 1911 1912 1913 >, a " Kb o 43 tl t4 t4 h fJ' t st -0 ti ei ei :9 ^ a> o s 9,0} o: f»J t>» (>» ^ t>> t> >' ii g iscal iscal iscal iscal iscal iscal i 43 09 » U l^ft? > d S O ° 8 <^ «■ >. * o o d " TJ a '^ O H "^ ® © S S (B o " f- t^ d d Ml b ^r s a o I- S p " * o ^ > 5 « E b 3 2|a^. u ft a sh S «> ■- o. §« g S ■d ^ S rt " »n a DO "^ a^ O - .a .s * ^ Q 3 O 5 DQ O (!< o S'ggB 1 1^ " a ° £ s !>.^'* O, ^ a (D s * 0& § " fl .S >. a ^ © o to a 18 . S .2 d u)'S a 2 is t* mSo » 4h a o n c8 ^ b! S^ ^ a S ? S o " a =3 '■3 i? a ■? a ri 43 d » ^ S §|8 u d!3 I -w'^^ d ^d GQ d -^ •d o c < < u z u s u Q Z u S >< o >J cu S u u u tt fa u oc ■* to 1-i N N (M rH rH M CD eq CO Appli- cants not supplied employ- ment. rH rH CO N (N rH CO 1 g ■^ rH IN rH O) -^ l> 00 (N (N 01 rH O CO lO 01 CO p,§|q § 5- a a <1 CD rH CO « 00 IN rH CO CO 00 00 CO rH r-l CO to pq CO 1 »■=; r-l CO t^ (N rH 1> ■* CD © W M Oi CO rH to CO 01 l> O) IN CO 1 Sd a-sjl rt< rH •^t^lCOQOOOCCCCb- ■># iH r-( ■^ O r-l tH r-i rHrHCOlOeOrHlOCOCOrH I> (N Ir^rHrHWtNrH r-l a T^ rH CO 01 CO rH n o .fl »n iH t>coir:coa>>OMNco <0 rH cc »o ^ t^rHOOUJlOrHCOeOTPC^ 01 Cq -^rHrHlNQO-* W 01 TT* rH OI rH Appli- cants not supplied employ- ment. ^ 1-i (MC0Tj IN t>rHrH(N(NrH rH 01 iH CO 01 CO to CO n o £ p, s CD(NTHT}5 ^1 ■ C 1 C C V 1 > •I c C E ;: 'I ii 1 1 1 ! c 1 I c J !i 1 1 i C c 1 1 i 1 ■a d <3 S S t 2 ll State Pree Employment Department, 1914. 25 CO ■ ■ lO • • N • ■ -* t^ lO 00 00 CO o 01 CO I-- 00 CD CO CO »0 »H iH i-i rH ® t^ I « CO »0 CO rH on CO ■* on o> iH (M 10 on o CO -* »o ■ l-H lO U3 ■ iO ■ iH ll^OhhP^hPkPHO'pHCQaiasaiaicocQt^E-iHEHH ^6 bureau of Labor Statistics, 1914-15. u n S u a. u w U z M a z u Pt «« u >< «< u H Z u S h< B! «< B< U Q H Z U S >• e >j h S u u u M fa u < (A in* t« M e ei< u « B f« Z o S .S3 ft ja 1? ^a U Id " sag «M'*(DO(DNCtOC0O3O5« (NrH iH iHr-CC>rH»HN (NO)COOtD«eCI>t-0 (Ni-ir-(iHi-lNMMI>>CiH05D ir3iM05CDt-00)l>Tt0>OCC»0'-cD OJi-icoeqTt;& gld d f^ (3 f< id b s t>. w State Free Employment Department, 1914. 27 OS 01 - CO ■* in N to 00 r-l I> i-( (M CO N 00 ■* iO (NC^TlCOiOCDf-U5T*1CD(M CO W M (M rH ^ rH CO to tc o U3aiQOT)ii-li-HCD01t-'<* cq 00 ^- t^ OOW'-HCTiiCh-COOO'-irt ■* OO lO ■* CO OJ-00»r (0 Oi 00 N riC0l^01(NO'*i-i-*^t>-^ IM T-l •*COWi-lrHCOeOW'HrHiHiH 00 T-l (N 10 >0 I-t ■rHU5NCSI>O' 00 •* iO iHf-lrHl-lC^THiHiH (M lO w iH to ta o »O01Q0Tt(iHrH(:001t>Thi-l|> N 00 l> t> oiO(NiHaiioi>cooo»Hr- ■* 00 iH iH O iH 050^00^«J>'*01tDOO«C O 01 Ci IN Cl(N-*MOb-00iO<-iO>-iT tH CD iH •^ ■* c (N lO t^ Tjt PO CO M OJ CO IN Oi 01 r-l lO 1-i 1-1 CO CD rH Oi iH CO CO «o c (N todoocoooicocDcoMicir OJ l^ s cc CCb-"3I>00' 00 OO X ir »oec'©i>oi-<4<05a(OiHioi> U3 -s ^ ■« lOiOrH T-HClCCCOM'DiMCv Oi i> iH '^ r^ -^ C COCDOOt-OStDCOOOO-"^-* O ■^ CO c ) o. toiococooci<^I>'*. C0iOOS»HiOC£ CO « 1- < ir lOTj1r-l r-IWC0C0O00(N01r-i(MOJO OI CO t* c Ttl.HQ0i-i(NC0COb-r-(«eO« CO w c> p" lOWiHr-INCO'^eOr-ltOM^ o If r-l U3 S; cd t>. p^ B cd t u J. iS (d cp h pt E-< ^ S < 1 a 02 IS Is 1° November December Jauuarv. . ll 1 ■; E 1 i 3 o ■*^ ai 1 O ea =8 (D 10 O (H tJ » iH cj -S 03 ■ H — (M 0) m a u m H s ^ a ts a " 5 § £ a M m S P as £ ^ >■ "o t. S "^ — S u I 'id CO I O CO © to ■ u ._- tp © m 'r^ as © j ; odS I 2 'i;'^ 28 Bureau of Labor Statistics, 1914-15. APRIL FAVORABLE TO WOMEN OUT OF WORK. When it comes to the monthly record of the State Free Employment Department during the-fiscal year which ended September 30, 1914, there were more applications for employment made, and more employment furnished men and youths during June than in any other month of the period which is embraced, due to the large number of harvest hands anxious to be put to work, who registered, and the calls from farmers for help of this kind. This condition particularly applies to Kansas City, and the three free employment biireaus when they are considered as a whole. For the St. Louis branch the month of July was the busiest, with August holding second place, also due to the preponderance in those months of men willing to assist in garnering the 1914 wheat crops of Missouri and Illinois. The best month for women who were out of employment during the year was April, more being furnished em- ployment that month than in any month of the fiscal year of 1913-14, the returns for the three bureaus being considered as a whole, St. Joseph with its large meat packing establish- ments supplied more positions to women than St. Louis and Kansas City combined. For a time in the last fiscal year a special women's department was maintained in connection with the Kansas City Free Employment Bureau. The one in St. Louis was not established until nearly the close of the fiscal year. Further facts concerning the monthly work of the St. Louis, Kansas City and St. Joseph Free Employment Bureaus are given in the tables which follow: ANNUAL REPORTS. STATE FREE EMPLOYMENT BUREAUS, 1913-14. The large number of harvest hands who were put in touch with employment diu'ing the months of May, June and July, 1914, by the Kansas City Free Employment Bureau made this branch of this important State service lead the other two when it comes to the number of men applying for situations and those who were furnished employment. Kansas City also led in the number of laborers who appUed for and were put to work. When it comes to women out of work who were furnished employment during the fiscal year which ended September 30, 1914, St. Joseph heads the Ust; Kansas City comes second and St; Louis third. There were 1,555 places ofllered to women and girls by St. Joseph fac- tories, and only 324 could be immediately furnished, leaving 1,231 places unfilled at the close of the year, when the monthly records are totaled. Out of 325 women who applied for this class of employment only one could not be given a place. This bureau also received 489 calls for female household help and supplied 460, leaving 29 places unfilled. Out of 505 women who registered for domestic service only 45 could not be immediately supplied with places. Thirty-seven nurses were put to work out of 46 who registered for employment of this charac- ter, leaving nine nurses unplaced and two places unfilled. When it comes to female ofHce help, the work of the Kansas City Bureau, which, most of that fiscal year, had a special women's employment department, was far more effective than that of the other two, 101 women and girls out of 135 applicants being supplied with clerical employment, leaving 34 who went away disappointed because places were not im- mediately available. During the year 108 such positions were offered and there were seven which remained unfilled, unless employers offering them secured this class of workers else- where. At this point it can well be said that employers, when it comes to female office help, do not use the State Free Employment Department as freely as they should, especially since all such taxpayers, through their annual State taxes, help to support this department. St. Joseph leid in the number of female cooks who were given kitchens over which to preside, 138 situations being offered and 130 women placed. Further information concerning the work of the three State Free Employment Bureaus, and what the Jefferson City office did toward receiving applications for employment and putting the applicants in touch with situations, is reviewed in a statistical table which follows, each such compilation being accom- panied with an annual statement of its superintendent. St. Louis State Free Employment Bureau, 917a Pine Street. St. Louis, October 1, 1914. Hon. John T. Fitzpatrick, Commissioner of Labor Statistics, Jefferson City, Mo.: Dear Sir — I have the honor to submit for your inspection the annual report of the St. Louis Free Employment Department of the Bureau of Labor Statistics for the fixcal year ending September 30, 1914. Analysis of these figures show that 75.8 per cent of the number of applications for em- ployment were placed in satisfactory positions and that 93.5 per cent of the applications for help were filled. If you will compare this report with that of last year you will note that there is an increase of 28.9 per cent in the total number of applications for employment and an St. Louis Free Employment Bureau, 1914. 29 increase of 8 per cent In the total number of positions filled, this notwithstanding the fact that there has been a general depression in all lines of business during the past year. From time to time, during the past year, I have interviewed firms of all kinds with a view of increasing the business of this office, maldng it a point in each case to express as comprehensively as possible the benefits derived by all concerned; and especially to the applicant seeking employment if they would procure their situations through the free em- ployment office. I secured quite a number of positions through solicitation, but in most cases I was informed that business was not as thriving as it should have been, but, however, was assured of their future co-operation whenever they are in need of help. The Women's Department, which was established on July 1st, this year, and is in charge charge of Nelle A. Quick as Assistant Commissioner, has been of great benefit to the working women of St. Louis. Miss Quick has been an untiring worker, investigating, as far as possible, the living and working conditions, as well as securing eipployment for those who applied to her. Although this report shows an increase of but .05 per cent over last year's report in the number of positions supplied female applicants, 51.5 per c'ent of the total number of applications for female help filled this year have been filled since Miss Quick took charge of the rejuvenated Women's Department. I do not hesitate to assure you that the next year's report will overshadow, in every particular, that of the year just ended. My past experience, coupled not only with the re- newed but also increased business activities of the near future, will have its efl!ect on the result of the next year's work. Respectfully submitted, FRANK J. O'KEEFE, Superintendent. RECORD-BREAKING ACCOMPLISHMENT. A review of the work of the St. Louis Free Employment Bureau, done diuring the fiscal year which closed September 30, 1914, is as follows: Applications for employment received — 7,475 males, and 976 females; total of 8,451. Number of places filled — male, 5067, and female, 417; a total of 6,084. Applicants not supplied with employment — male, 1,808, and female, 559; total 2,367. Applications for help — male, 6,061, and female, 664; total 6,725. Number of wage-earners supplied — male, 5,667, and female, 417; total, 6,084. Number of places remaining unfilled due to the failure of having on hand for immediate services men and women following the occupations specified in the call — male, 394, and female, 247; total, 641. Kansas City State Free Employment Bureau, 22^ Mew J^elson. Building. {J^ow 215 Sheidley Building.) Kansas City, Mo., October 1, 1914. Hon. John T. Fitupatrick, Commissioner, Bureau of Labor Statistics, Jefferson City, Mo.: Dear Sir — I have the honor to submit this; my annual report, for the fiscal period ending September 30, 1914. This oSace was able to secure suitable employment for more than 15,000 men and women during the fiscal year ending September 30, 1914, by so doing saving these 15,000 people more than $25>000, which they would have paid had they secured this employment through a private employment agency, paying from SI. 00 to S5.00 for each place. More than 1,000 women applied to this office for employment and for other services which we were able to render, such as directing them to suitable places to room and board, and in a great many cases securing them positions. The attached report will show that more than 800 women secured employment through this bureau during the year. I received 97 complaints where wages were due for labor and in each case this office was able to bring about a satisfactory settlement and have the wages due the complainant paid in full at once. A total of Sl,365 was collected in these cases, most of which were misimder- standings between the employer and employe, a third party being necessary to bring about a settlement. There have been 132 complaints filed against the private labor agencies, and of these 128 were by men and 4 by women. In 113 cases the fee was returned to the complainant in' full. In 10 cases a satisfactory place of employment was furnished which was agreeable to both parties. In nine cases the claim was found to be unfounded and the private labor agents were allowed to keep the fee. In all, S383 was refimded in fees $157 in railroad fare, this $157 being fare paid by complainants to return to Kansas City, after having been sent' to various employment points, and the facts were not as represented by the private labor agencies. ,„ ^. ^ „., ^ (Continued on page 34.) 30 Bureau of Labor Statistics, 1914-15. u 8 at o fa p < u K B ea z u S 9 >J fa s u u u B! fa u S e H K fa u K Applica- tions for help. § CO CO CD 0 IN CO r^ n fD »g cqocqrHco^ocoio-Hco iH CDCOiOiO CMOICD W CO Number of places fur- nished. CM iH Ol 03 iH O CO CM CM Ttf(Mt^Nr-(CM»OCO rH »0 ^ CT CO 3,806 60 1,043 Applica- tions for employ- ment. r< Oi t> -^ n m rt 1> M 00 o iH CMCMCMiOU500CMb-I>COCM CO t^COOiO (N^O iH U3 «H 3,806 192 1,346 d o g V Q t p: tf 1 PC 2 t 1 PC S: t. t 0. 1 c 1 1 i c 1 1 c 1 C { 1 I V ■s I 0, £ J c 1 ■1 ft c 'a .= E 1 1 1 c c j ■ P ' K "a C H 1 1 E H I i § 1 1 1 o 1 o .9 1 5^. Louis Free Employment Bureau, 1914. 31 t> »0 tJI 'tji t> CO g ^ ei ui ^- i S (13 ^ •3 'o .a •a a §5 >''2 o g ■p. Q m i!i.al5lil|l|!|ii^.l ■a £ 5 " I a a s . ^ § t<&< ID e€ 32 Bureau of Labor Statistics, 1914-15. 0> U Ea S u H u M U Z M Q Z u K < u >• u M M b -U 93 « e fa 3 4 U « s CQ H Z u S >i fa u u » fa u < in Z < M H K O fa u « «< 9 Z z 2 o te —. en ■H O S 0,3 « ft o to ,i7 A o .4 I 2 ® t>i ■ ^2 3 a a •8 10 O 13 ^ "Ht CO & .2 5 & 2 9-s*^ a a CO CD b- o w rH CC Ml CO 'H ^ CO ^ a d ■3 < a U5 rH ^ CO ^ 1 2 >" i. • a d a £? -(f n ■o b 2 d o o -is S S g o o 5 n s n 2 >> II a S 03 B p s U 13 0) t4 S g o K Kansas 'City Free. Employ meni Bureau, 1914. 33 IH t- pH lO rH CO Tjl CO • • iH O O 0 to lO o N CO O 00 « « - lO lO M IM CO CO s rH CO CO <© rH IN . CO IN s co" i-t m "-1 • rH t-r lO CO ^ CO lO ^" . r-l « CO .-( o Cd CO CO ■* lO 00 l> 10 rt 01 t- N CO rH CO • iH m rt r-1 • t- rH CO tC CO i-< lO ■ iH rH (N 00 ■^ ■ Oi « CO • t- co_ lo" rH 1 t ■a ■5 ■ ( ■ e ■ t ■ X : T ■ E ■ ■i 1 ! 1 I 9 S 2 s a 1 e 1 c I I F ( 1 s ) b 11 . D ■ ^ '. 1 . D ; X . E ■ c il j 3 D • c c •J 1 II 2 S ;! ,1 :-£ il > s >^ . t a if 1 or i: » ? Il a a "l 1 ) i \ i a 1 1 il i tr. 1 ; s • : 1 ■* I ii 11 a . 4 '. 'C • a ) a cc If 1 E- 34 Bureau of Labor Statistics, 1914-15. (Continued from page 29.) In all of these 132 cases, or complaints, against the private labor agencies a full hearing was held at the office of the State Free Employment Bureau, 224 New Nelson Building. In each case this office put forth an effort to bring out all the evidence possible, and no ruling was made in any case until all parties concerned had been notified that the hearing was to be held and that they should be present to give evidence. In some cases private labor agencies were- represented, by attorneys. There are 36 privSite labor agencies now operating in this city, as well as several free employment bureaus. The demand for men to do general labor is on the decrease at this time, and is in nowise as great as at this season in 1913. The demand for domestic help far exceeds the supply at all times, girls and women preferring office, store and factory to work in these private households. Respectfully submitted, HAKVBY OSBORNE, Assistant Commissioner. GEORGE A. MAJOR, Special Agent. A review of the work of the Kansas City State Free Employment Bureau, done during the fiscal year which closed September 30, 1914, is as follows: Applications for employment received — 15,302 males, and 1,121 females; total, 16,423. Number of places filled — male, 14,562, and female, 870; total, 15,432. Applicants not supplied with employment — male, 740; female, 251; total, 990. Applications for help — male, 17,854, and female, 1,123; total, 18,977. Number of wage-earners supplied — male, 14,562, and female, 870; total, 15,432. Number of places remaining unfilled, due to the failure of having on hand for immediate service men and women following the occupations specified in the call — male, 3,292, and female, 253; total, 3,545. St. Joseph State Free Employment ' Bureau, 110 J^orth Seventh Street. St. Joseph, October, 1914. Hon. John T. Fitzpatrick, Commissioner, Bureau of Labor Statistics, Jefferson City, Mo.: Dear Sir — I have the honor to submit herewith the second annual statistical report, for the fiscal year ending September 30, 1914, of the St. Joseph State Free Employment Bureau. We respectfully call your attention to the splendid gains the bureau has made over previous years in securing situations for unemployed men and women and placing employers in touch with desirable wage-earners, and especially emphasize the splendid showing the bureau made in securing employment for women, 1,442 having been provided with situations since our last annual report to you. The St. Joseph Bureau was especially fortunate in placing women who were anxious to work in factories in such positions, 324 out of 325 applicants being provided with work. We could have done still better if there had been more applications for work of this character, there being 1,555 places in manufactories and workshops open for female help during the year, and with only 324 placed it left 1,231 positions which remained unfilled as far as this bureau was concerned. Out of 505 women applying for situations as domestics 460 were supplied with employment. There were 489 places offered by St. Joseph famiUes to household help, and with 460 women supplied it left 29 places vacant. We are anxious to make it generally known how many positions for women that remained unfilled from month to month for the reason that we did not have immediately available the kind of help which was demanded when the applications came in. For the year there were a total of 2,826 calls for female help for which we supplied 1,442 women wage-earners, leaving 1,384 places which we could not fill. We had calls for 48 berry pickers, and placed 19; 138 family cooks, and placed 130; 63 dairy maids and other female farm help, and placed 56; nine clerks, and filled each such position ; 264 hotel and restaurant workers, and placed 248 ; 12 laundry workers, and filled all such places; 11 ladies' maids, and ffiled all such places; 39 nurses, aid supplied 37; ten office assistants, and placed seven; four saleswomen, and placed two; four stenographers, and filled all such places; two telephone operators, and sup- plied one ; 95 waitresses, and placed 85 ; three washerwomen, and filled all such calls. There were also 79 calls for female help of the kind classed as "special," 24 women being supplied, which left 55 situations, many desirable, which went begging for women to take them. While my annual statistical report gives full information concerning the men out of employment the St. Joseph Bureau placed, I am anxious to call attention to some of the work done along this line. We had calls for 709 male farm workers and supplied 693. Farmers of Northwfest Missouri, Northeast Kansas and Southeast Nebraska sent in calls for 735 wheat harvesters, which demand was met by immediately supplying 630. Out of 2,175 places open for laborers 2,127 were supplied, leaving 48 "jobs" unfilled for the want of workers im- mediately available for such work. St. Joseph Free Employment Bureau, 1914. 35 Further Information concerning the work done in behalf of the unemployed of St. Joseph and surrounding towns can be gleaned by a careful study of the statistical table which is attached to this report. I am anxious to call particular attention to the valuable assistance rendered by Mr. J. W. Morris, the Assistant Superintendent, who labored diligently and effectively, early and late, to make the St. Joseph Bm-eau a credit to the State of Missouri. On many occasions this ofiBcial went out of his way to secure transportation for unemployed men and women to places where situations were offered, and he also aided many such un- fortunates in securing shelter and food, often paying for these necessities out of the meager salary the State allowed him for his services. The addition of a Women's Department here would greatly stimulate this portion of the duties of the St. Joseph State Free Employment Bureau, especially since we have so many calls for female wage-earners which cannot immediately be filled. After this bureau put in operation your recommendation I noticed a great increase in calls for help from factories and workshops, hotels, restaurants, and private families needing domestics. It is an easier matter to induce unemployed men and women to accept the services of the bureau than it is to persuade employers to let us know when they need wage-earners, but we are rapidly rapidly Inducing employers to avail themselves, gratis, of the services of this State Free Employment 'Bureau. I feel certain that before another year passes, with the publicity the St. Joseph State Free Employment Bureau is constantly receiving, double the number of employers will be using its services in filling vacancies as now is the case. I take this means of thanking the two St. Joseph daily newspapers, the Gazette and the News-Press, for the many favorable notices they gave, from time to time, during the last fiscal year, to the work of the St. Joseph State Free Employment Bureau, this publicity aiding greatly in acquainting the general public with the fact that this city had such a State department and that its services were and are gratis to all anxious to profit thereby. With the hope that the fiscal year, which closes September 30, 1915, will witness the ful- fillment of all the gains and improvements I prophesy, I herewith respectfully submit to you for your consideration this letter reviewing our 1913-14 work and the statistical compilation which accompanies it. Respectfully, GEOEGE J. KAMLER, Superintendent." J. W. MORRIS, Assistant Superintendent. DAILY AVERAGE OF SITUATIONS FURNISHED WAS 19. In reviewing the work of the St. Joseph Free Employment Bureau during the fiscal year which closed September 30, 1914, Assistant Superintendent J. W. Morris states that applications for employment were received from 5,039 males and 1,600 females; a total of 6,639. Number of places filled — male, 4,639, and female, 1,442; a total of 6,081. Applicants not suppUed with employment — male, 400, and female 158; total 558. Applications for help — male, 4,^58, and female, 2,826; total, 7,784. Number of wage-earners supplied — male, 4,639, and female, 1,442; total, 6,081. Number of places remaining unfilled due to the failure of having on hand for immediate services of men and women following the occupations specified in the call — male, 319, and female, 1,384; total, 1,703. Reduced to a monthly basis, the St. Joseph State Free Employment Bureau supplied work to 506 men and women during each of the twelve months of the last fiscal year, and reduced to a daily basis, allowing twenty-six days a month, which excludes Sundays but includes holidays, 19 men and women were furnished employment each working day. There were months when the average of men and women supplied with work reached twenty-six a day In addition, probably 1,000 men and women were put in communication with employ- ers without the issuance of ofacial cSirds, which vouched that they had regularly registered at the St Joseph Free Employment Bureau. Assistant Superintendent Morris secured free transportation to places of employment for 100 men and women during the year. In addition, he donated S60 out of his own funds to help the deserving unemployed, and, as he states, in his report on this philanthropy: "I gave the money because I thought these unfortunates needed it worse than I did, and if any good hasbeen accomplished the fact that I aided in bringing it about constitutes my recompense." 36 Bureau of Labor Statistics, 1914-15. u ea S u H U a z u u ix >J u u B K O >b. S «! U Pi S n H Z u S > o s u u u K fa U H < « B B. U W •1 Iff H O h H K < z z (D (D 3 P^ o ,4 ■+-* "O I S X o P. 2 S n S 9 '^ a a Oi » o CO 00 OS 00 o n 00 io rH 1(5 O IN to (D (D 3 a o g 5 3 - 3 P< o a ft "43 ti gS gft§ ■?§ 3 a a ^ CS M C a o ^ 3^ C8 O K Pi O .Is O . iH • N Oi cc 1-1 o iH eq CO 00 I> (N ■ O t^ h- ■ CC ■* M , CO rH tfl >