' THE HISTORIC LITERATURE OF IRELAND, AN ESSAY ON THE PUBLICATIONS OF THE IRISH ARCHiilOLOGICAL SOCIETY, FouNDEn A.D. 1840, FOR THE PRINTING OF THE GENEALOGICAL, ECCLESIASTICAL, BARDIC TOPOGRAPHICAL, AND HISTORICAL REMAINS OF IRELAND. DUBLIN : W. B. KELLY, 8, GRAFTON-STREET. SIMPKIN, MARSHALL, AND CO., LONDON. OLIVER AND BOYD, EDINBURGH. 1851. "Diu nimis obscurata tenebris delituit Hibernia, nee sibi proi"sus cognita, nee aliis: diu satis eclipsin passa est rudis admodum et indigesta ; filiisque suis peregrina, se vcl fuisse hucusque dubitavit." " lam tandem diu nimis infelix Hibernia, remotis fabulis, abactisque procul commentis, ad vivum, se peritiori manu vestra impressam agnoscit; dumque labores res/'ros in ernen- dis rerum suarum annalibus, grate inceptos feliciterqne peractos intueatm*, se diu nimis obscuro sepiiltam tumulo, novosque e calamo vestro spiritus indies Lauvire novamque in- diiisse lueem fatetur." — Parrius ad Varmon. Browne & Nola>-, Printers, 21, Nassau-street, Diibiiii. ADVERTISEMENT. The favorable manner in which this Essay was received on its appearance in No. III. of the Irish Quarterly Keview, has induced the proprietors to accede to the general desire expressed for its publication in a detached form. It has long been a source of equal surprise and disap- pointment to the learned of other nations, that periodicals printed in Ireland should have hitherto conveyed no infor- mation on the literature of the country with which they are presumed to be identified. Thus, although the Irish Archaeological Society is now in its eleventh year, and has expended many thousand pounds in the production of valuable works on the history, language, and antiquities of Ireland, the present is the first notice of its publications which has appeared in any Irish literary periodical. The demand for a republication of this paper affords a pleasing evidence that literature in its best shape, or a desire of the " knowledge of ourselves," is progressing in Ireland, and would rapidly advance if proper efforts were made to exhibit, in a popular manner, the objects of our literary institutions. It may be added, that this essay contains a considerable amount of interesting collateral information, derived from various manuscript and printed sources, not to be found in the publications of the Society. 2508 ERRATA. Page 23, line 27, /or these re«c7 there Page 26, line SG, for it read il. THE HISTORIC LITERATURE OF IRELAND. A FEW Continental authors have, within the present century, effected a complete change in the style of writing history. Eschewing the dull volumes of tedious compilers, they have had recourse to the works of the old contemporary chroniclers, by a careful collation of which, with legal and official documents, they have succeeded in producing an animated and life-like picture of the manners and customs of former ages ; " in a complete narrative, exhausting texts, assembling scattered details, collecting even to the slightest indica- tions of facts and of characters, and from all these forming one body, into which science and art unite to breathe the breath of life." * The writers, to whom we are indebted for this new school of historic literature, are Augustin Thierry and his brother Amedee, Michaud, Sismondi, Guizot and Barante. Scarcely inferior to any of these great historians, in depth of research and powers of narration, Macaulay, much as he habitually allows his political prejudices to obscure his judgment, may be regarded as their English representa- tive. The way was prepared for these attractive writers by the historic antiquarians and the publishing associations which, on the Continent and in England and Scotland, have been and still continue labouring to rescue the works of the old chroniclers from the dust and neglect of centuries. But for the exertions of such literary pioneersf the * Recits des temps Merovingiens. t The following great national historical collections show how much Ireland is behind the rest of Europe in the cultivation of native history: — Andre Du Chesne, " Historian Francorum Scriptores coaetanei, ab gentis origine usque ad Phillipi IV. tempora," 5 volumes, folio, 1636-49. " Historiae Normannorum Scriptores Antiqui, res ab illis gestas expli- cantes, ab ann 838 ad ann 1220," folio, 1619. Martin Bouquet, " Re- cueil des Historiens des Gaules et de la France, &c., accompagne de 6 THE HISTORIC LITERATURE OF IRELAND. most diligent author would scarcely be able, in the period of a single life, to bring together the materials necessary for the proper illus- tration of even one important era. The history of Europe would consequently still remain arid and repulsive as the driest and most uninteresting annals. In France, the efforts of the publishing associations are ably seconded by the government, while in England and Scotland, the general appreciation of national historic researches, among the edu- cated classes, has ever afforded ample and substantial encourage- ment to the literary antiquarian. Far different has, hitherto, been the case in Ireland. Subjected, almost ever since the invention of printing, to perpetual civil war and religious persecutions, little time was there to be found for the cultivation of letters. Another no less potent cause acted against the study of Irish literature. This was the miscalculating policy which formerly dictated the eradication of the old Celtic language of the country. A short-sighted attempt, condemned equally by the evan- gelical Bedell, and the philosophic Boyle, at a time when it was most warmly pui'sued by its fanatical advocates; and which only served to make the natives cling with a fiercer and more desperate sommaires, de tables et de notes " (continue par Haudiquier, Pre- cieux, Clement, Poirier, et Brial), 1738 — 1832, 19 volumes. "Collec- tion des Memoires relatifs a I'Histoire de France depuis la fondation de la Monarchic Fran9aise jusqu'au xiiime siecle ; avec une introduction, des supplemens, des notices et des notes, par M. Guizot," 1823 — 27, 29 volumes, 8vo. " Collection complete des Memoires relatifs a I'Histoire de France, depuis le regne de Philippe Auguste jusqu'au commencement du xviie siecle avec des notices sur chaque auteur et des observations sur chaque ouvrage, par M. Petitot," 53 vols. 8vo. 1819 — 27. "Collection de Memoires relatifs a I'Histoire de France, depuis I'avenement de Henri IV. jusqu' a la paix de Paris, conclue en 1763, avec des notices sur chaque auteur et des observations par Petitot et Montmerque," (second series,) 79 vols. 8vo. 1820 — 29. " Collection de Memoires relatifs a la Revolu- tion Fran9aise, avec des notices sur leurs auteurs et des eclaircisseraents historiques par Berville et Barriere," 56 vols. 8vo. 1820 — 1826. The above are noticed, as they seldom appear in our country, and show how much superior is the historical literature of France to that of Great Britain. Of the other national collections we shall only mention Lud. Ant. Mura- tori's '' Antiquitates Italicas medii sevi, post declinationem Romani imperii ad ann 1500," 6 vols, folio, 1738—42; " Rerum Italicarum Scriptores prascipui ab anno ser^e Christianas D. ad IMD." 29 vols, folio, 1723 — 51; " Annali d' Italia dell'era volgare, sino all 1750," 17 vols, folio, 1753—6; and J. Langebek's " Scriptores rerum Danicarum medii aevi," 7 vols, folio, 1772—92. THE HISTORIC LITERATURE OF IRELAND. 7 tenacity* to the old tongue of theii* fathers, iu which their dearest and most ennoMing recollections and traditions were enshrined. There are, even in the present day, many estimable persons in Ireland of opinion that the publication of historic documents tends to revive old prejudices and to awake bad feelings. Had this idea prevailed among the more enlightened of other countries, literature would not now have to boast of the works of Scott, of Lamartine, * The attachment of the Irish to their native language is very remarkable; we learn from a manuscript cited by Dr. Leland, sometime Fellow of the University of Dublin, that when, in former times, any of the clans were unable to withstand the hostile powers of the invaders, they used to claim the assistance of their neighbouring tribes, "for the sake of the old tongue of the Gaels of Erin ;" an argument which never failed to elicit the desired reinforcements. It is a curious historical fact, that the Irish troops, who principally contributed to save the town of Louvain, in 1635, from the tremendous assault of the great French army under Marshals Chatillon and De Breze, were, in that bloody contest, marshalled and commanded in the military terms vfhich the language of their country supplied. A. Latin writer of the seventeenth century, who was conversant with most of the European tongues, tells us that the Irish language " surpasseth in gravity the Spanish, in elegance the Italian, in colloquial charms the French, it equals, if it does not surpass, the German itself in inspiring terror. From the lips of the Irish preacher it is a bolt to arrest the evil-doer in the career of guilt, and to allure by its soft and insinuating tones to the paths of vir- tue. The witticism, the jest, and the epigram it expresses briefly; and, in the hands of the poet, it is so pliant and flexible, that the ' Uraiceacht na n-eigeas,' or ' Precepts of the Poets,' lay down rules for more than a hundred different kinds of metre ; so that iu the opinion of men who are well acquainted with several languages, Irish poetry does not yield, either in variety, construction, or polish of its metres, to the poetry of any nation in Europe. Spenser himself corroborates this opinion, when he says : ' I have caused divers of Irish poems to be translated unto me, that I might understand them, and surely they savoured of sweet wit and good invention ; they are sprinkled with some pretty flowers of natural device, which gave good grace and comeliness to them.' " To maintain the manners and traditions of their fathers, against the efforts of the invaders, the Irish," says Augustin Thierry, " made for themselves monuments which neither steel nor fire could destroy ; they had recourse to the art of singing, in which they gloried in excelling, and which in the times of independence had been their pride and pleasure. The bards and minstrels became the keepers of the records of the nation. Wandering from village to village, they carried to every hearth memoirs of ancient Erin ; they studied to render them agreeable to all tastes and all ages ; they had war songs for the men, love ditties for the women, and marvellous tales for the children of the house. Every mansion preserved two harps ever ready for travellers, and he who could best celebrate the liberty of former times, the glory of patriots, and the grandeur of their cause, was rewarded by a more lavish hospitality. The kings of England endeavoured more than once to strike a blow at Ireland in this last refuge of its regrets and hopes ; the wandering poets were persecuted, banished, delivered up to tortures and death; but violence only served to irritate indomitable wills; the art of 8 THE HISTORIC LITERATURE OE IRELAND. and of Manzoni. Such an argument, moreover, strikes at the dis- semination of TRUTH, and has, we know by sad examples, led in Continental countries, to results most disastrous to the liberties of mankind. It is an incontrovertible fact, that political animosities have, in all nations, been designedly engendered and fostered by the propagation of historic falsehoods, which are ever ready to usurp the place unoccupied by truth. The contemplation of the singing and of poetry had its martyrs like religion ; and the remembrances, the destruction of which was desired, were increased by the feeling of how much they cost them to preserve." In allusion to those penal times, we find the following lines in a late anonymous writer : — " Ah, God is good and nature strong— thej' let not thus decay The seeds that deep in Irish breasts of Irish feeling lay; Still sun and rain made emerald green the loveliest fields on earth, And gave the type of deathless hope, the little shamrock, birth; Still crouching ''neath the sheltering liedge, or stretclied on mountain fern, The teacher and his pupils met, feloniously— to learn: Still round the peasant's heart of hearts his darling music twined, A fount of Irish sobs or smiles in every note ensln-ined ; And still beside the smouldering turf were fond traditions told Of heavenly saints and princely chiefs — the power and faith of old." The native poets delighted to revile " the stranger's tongue upborne by law. Whose phrase imcouth distorts the Gaelic jaw," and found endless pleasure in eulogizing their own language. As an illus- tration of this we may quote a stanza from one of the poems of Donogh O'Mahony " the blind," a Munster bard of the last century : — " As iseadh ha bJilasda, ba cneasda, bafhior-Homhtha, Ba oilte, ba aite, ba thapadh a m-btigh bin ghuib; Ba shnaighie, ba shnasghlaine racaireachd gaois-laoithe, Ni h-ionan 's glafairneach mhallaighthe ar bh-for-naimhde."' " Unlike the jargon of our foreign foe. On raptur'd ear it pours its copious flow; Most feeling, mild, polite, and poUsh'd tongue, That learned sage e'er spoke or poet simg." Mr. Christopher Anderson, a learned Scotch author, in his recently pub- lished work on the " Native Irish," labours to prove that the neglect of the Irish language has been alike injurious to the progress of English and that of general knowledge. Speaking of the natives, he says, " the Irish is still the language of their hearts, and even of the best part of their understand- ing. In it they still continue to express their joy or sorrow ; for this is the language which is associated with their earliest' recollections. In it their mothers hushed them to rest in the days of their infancy ; and in youth, if they loved music, they were charmed with the numbers of the ' Culan,' or of ' Erin go Bragh.' " Bopp, Grimm, Diefenbach, and other profound German philologists, have borne testimony to the special importance of the Irish language, as being the richest in its vocabulary and grammatical forms, at the same time that it possesses the most ancient and numerous records, of the nature of histories, laws, and poems ; and we may add, that the number of vocables in the Irish language exceeds 50,000. THE HISTORIC LITERATURE OF IRELAND. 9 history of our ancestors, their misfortunes, their virtues, their eiTors and their crimes, cannot fail to exercise a beneficial influence on us, their descendants, inasmuch as one of the great masters of the human mind has told us that "history is philosophy, teaching by example." Despite all obstacles, it is, however, pleasing to recollect, that even in the worst times, a few men were to be found who, under most discouraging circumstances, at considerable personal sacrifices, and actuated solely by a love of their country's literature, essayed and achieved much for the preservation of our historic documents. The names of Ussher, Ware, Colgan, Fleming, and Ward must ever be remembered vnih gratitude as the first who, by their elegant Latin treatises, rendered the ancient history of Ireland familiar to the learned of Europe. Since the seventeenth century, the study of Irish literature has never been entirely neglected, but notwithstanding all the efi'orts of individuals, the greatest and most important monu- ments of the early history of the country are still unpublished and inaccessible. A short view of these documents will give an idea of the obstacles which still continue to oppose the production of a true '* History of Ireland." From the earliest period of which we have any account, to the commencement of the seventeenth centmy, the native Irish, or Gaels, were governed by a peculiar written code, known as the Brehon laws. These laws are referred to by Venerable Bede, by the ante-Danish poets, by Cenfaelad in the seventh century, by Probus in the tenth, by Tighernach in the eleventh, and by the Magnates Hiberni^ in the fourteenth century. Placed in the extremity of Eui-ope, seclu- ded from the rest of the world, unconquered, unmixed, and never aifected by the concussions of the fall of the Roman Empire, the Irish must have possessed primeval institutions, which these docu- ments are best calculated to unfold.* Many copies of these laws are still preserved in our public libraries, and are in general accom- panied by elaborate glosses and commentaries, written for the most part by the Irish jurists of the fourteenth and fifteenth centimes. The contents of the Brehon laws still remaining to usf "are very * Bibliotheca Manuscripta Stouensis. t Suggestions with a view to the Transcription and Publication of the MSS. of the Brehon Laws, now in the Libraries of the British Museum, 10 THE HISTORIC LITERATURE OF IRELAND. various, and may be found to have important bearings upon the existing condition of society in Ireland. Some relate to offences against person and property; and regulate in the most minute manner, the fines to be paid by the ofi*enders, as well as the com- pensations to be received by the injured parties, or their representa- tives. Others prescribe the prices to be paid for work done, or articles purchased. A very interesting class of laws lays down the privileges attaching to persons in the different ranks of society. Others have reference to the distribution and transfer of land. It must be apparent that documents of such a nature are of great importance; not only as illustrating the customs and character of the ancient Irish, but even as throwing light upon the earliest and most obscure part of European history. As the Celtic nations re- tired westward before the pressure of new colonizing swarms, they carried with them into the British islands much of their primitive language and usages. The former remains to this day. It is therefore unreasonable to deny the probability of their having also preserved such remnants of the latter, as might serve to supply the philosophic historian with valuable materials. It ought to be added, that the study of comparative philology would be promoted in no ordinary way by the publication of the ancient Irish laws. They are written in a dialect almost as different from the vernacular Irish of the present day, as Anglo-Saxon is from English.* They the University of Oxford, the Royal Irish Academy, and Trinity College, Dublin. 12mo. London: 1851. * The name of Brehon is cognate with the Celtic noun Breath or Break, which signifies a judicial decision. The language of those laws is so peculiar and so long obsolete, that there are but two scholars to be found capable of deciphering and translating them, with accuracy and precision ; it is scarcely necessary to say, that we refer to Dr. John O'Donovan and Mr, Eugene Curry. The latter gentleman, whose examination before the Parliamentary Committee of Public Libraries, in 1849, excited so much interest in England relative to the ancient literature of Ireland, has amassed an immense amount of collateral illustrative matter, for the elucidation of the laws of the Brehons, and has also compiled extensive and invaluable glossaries of the most unusual and obscure terms with which they abound. Although Mr. Curry has not hitherto taken a prominent public part in the Irish literary world, those who are competent to form a judgment, coincide in pronouncing him the most erudite Celtic palaeographer ever produced by Ireland ; not even excepting Mac Firbis, the O'Clerighs, or the O'Maoil- chonaires. His critical knowledge of the older and more obscure dialects of the country, is perfectly unequalled and unprecedented. There is scarcely an important Irish manuscript in Great Britain or Ireland, or in the rich THE HISTORIC LITERATURE OF IRELAND. 11 abound, too, in technical terms and titles of persons, which are obviously among the most unvarying parts of a language. From no source could the scholar engaged in analyzing the Celtic languages, and determining their relation to the other branches of Library of the Dukes of Burgundy, which he has not examined, collated, or transcribed, and in every Irish historical work of consequence, produced within the last quarter of a century, we find the authors expressing their numerous obligations to him for invaluable Celtic information, of which he is the sole depository. The critical and analytical Catalogues which he has compiled of the Gaelic manuscripts of th« Royal Irish Academy, and of those in the British Museum, would alone entitle him to a high lite- rary position. He has lately completed his examination and collation of the Betham manuscripts, added to our National Collection through the exertions of the Rev. Charles Graves ; to the public subscription for which we are proud to state, that the Right Hon. B. L. Guinness, Lord Mayor of Dublin, was one of the most munificent contributors; thus opening a new era in our civic annals, and giving an example, which will, we trust, not be lost on his successors in office. Mr. Curry is now engaged in col- lating the fragments of the ancient Brehon laws, preserved in the English manuscript collections; and we trust that he will soon proceed to press with his treatises on the "History of the Boromean Tribute," and the " Account of the Fir-Bolgic, or Belgic Colony in Ireland" — two documents of the greatest importance in illustrating the earlier portions of our annals. When we recollect the uncertainty of human life, and how much the records of Ireland have suffered at various periods by accidents, and con- sider that, as in the case of the Escurial, a fire of a few minutes' duration i« one of our manuscript collections, might effectually destroy the entire historical monuments of an important era, we cannot avoid expressing our deep anxiety, that public steps should be taken for the prompt publication of our ancient annals and literary remains, while they are yet in a state of safety, and while the scholars are amongst us, whose departure from the stage of life would leave the older Celtic records of Ireland a blank for ever. *' The losses of history, indeed," says Gibbon, ''are irretrievable; when the productions of fancy or science have been swept away, new poets may invent, and new philosophers may reason ; but, if the inscription of a single fact be once obliterated, it cannot be restored by the united efforts of genius and industry. The consideration of our past losses should invite the present age to cherish and perpetuate the valuable relics which have escc^ped." This is truly a national question, and demands the attention of our edu- cated classes. The literary men of Europe look to Ireland for the ancient monuments of her Celtic language; and we shall stand eternally disgraced in the republic of letters, if we make not a strenuous effort to supply them with what they have so long and so earnestly demanded. " II est temps," says Adolphe Pictet, one of the latest and most distinguished French philologers, " de trancher enfin cette question: I'anciennete de ces idiomes, le nombre et I'importance historique de leurs monuments ecrits, presque inconnus encore, le fait quils renferment une partie des origines de la langue Frangaise ; tout se reunit pour reveiller I'interet sur ces curieux debris de la primitive Europe. En attendant des travaux plus complets sur leur histoire, travaux qui ne peuvent etre entrepris avec succes que par les savants nationaux, on pent, au moyen des materiaux existants les rattacher a leur veritable souche, qui est, sans contredit, Indo-Euro- peene." 12 THE HISTORIC LITERATURE OF IRELAND. the Indo-European family, derive more abundant or precious ma- terials." The manifest injustice with which Ireland was treated by the late " Record Commission," which eflfected the publication of the Anglo-Saxon and Welsh laws, leaving the Irish legal records almost untouched, is to be attributed to our own apathy, as we believe that no proper public remonstrance was ever made against this neglect of the Commissioners. We are, however, glad to find, that at length the publication of these ancient Irish laws is about to be made a literary question, of not only National but European importance, and feel confident that the Imperial Government,* however parsimonious in its allowances to the literary institutions of Ireland, will not hesitate to undertake the preservation of the laws of the Brehons; when their publication is recommended by such scholars as Guizot, Pictet, Bunsen, and Hallam. The Anglo- Norman legal records of Ireland have hitherto fared scarcely better than the Brelion laws. There arc upwards of twelve hundred legis- lative enactments, which have never yet been pubHshed,']' and con- sequently do not appear in the defective and inaccurate printed editions of the Irish Statutes. The great body of the rolls, inquisitions, and other ofiicial documents, most important as illus- trations of history, are still reposing in their dusty and almost in- accessible repositories ; whence they are scarcely ever drawn, save when it is found necessary to consult them, for the purpose of deci- ding questions relative to property, or disputed titles. Such is the condition of our legal antiquities, which Gibbon calls * The national resources of France and Germany have long since effected the publication of the Salic law and of the Codes of the Ripuarian Franks, the Burgundians, and the Visigoths ; more recently, the Danish govern- ment furnished the means of publishing the Icelandic laws, documents remarkably similar in their nature to the ancient laws of Ireland, The government of Great Britain is at present contributing to the excavations at Nineveh, to the neglect of their own national monuments. This fact forcibly recalls what Pliny says in his epistle to Gallus: "Ad qua; noscenda iter ingredi, transmittere mare solemus, ea sub oculis posita negligimus; seu quia ita natura comparatum, ut proximorum incuriosi, longinqua sectemur. Quacunque de causa, permulta in urbe nostra, jux- taque urbem, non oculis modo, sed ne auribus quidem novimus. QuC)0 recruits of foot, at least, will be necessary, besides those to be made in Ireland!" But this amount of 35,289 soldiers for Ireland was found to be insufficient : for the number of privates belonging to the infantry, horse, and dragoon regiments, of the army of William III., for Ireland in 1691, are in the official list set down at not less than 40,000 men ! And to these an addition of several thousands must be made for officers, and men and officers, connected with the great train of Williamite artillery, which, as far as we can karn, amounted, with cannon and mortars, to a total from 90 to 100 pieces. Such was the overwhelming force against which the small Irish army so long, and so bravely, contended ; and in the words of their gallant countryman, the Chevalier Charles Wogan, they may be truly said " to have buried the synagogue with honor." * " The Irish soldiers during whole winters had existed without any pay, at times on horse flesh, at other times on half a pound of bread per day ; had been clothed in rags, bare-headed, and bare-footed ; quartered in huts inundated with water, with scarce any covering but the canopy of heaven, benumbed by the cold, diseased by the moisture of a wet climate, and without fuel to })reserve animal heat. They had made those sacrifices to their king and country; and when their officers and great men were 56 THE HISTORIC LITERATURE OF IRELAND. of the Freucli Minister Louvois, the supplies and assistance received from France were contemptible. The Irish had thus to stand alone against an overwhelming army, composed of the finest soldiers in the world. We may further observe, for the information of per- sons who have been taught to consider these campaigns as disgrace- ful to the memory of the Irish adherents of King James, that some of the best regiments, and even the private guai'ds, of the Prince of Orange, consisted, in gi'eat part, of Roman Catholics. The history of Ireland, at this period, had been so ingeniously falsified, in the published contemporary works, that our most labo- rious literary antiquaries, who had not hesitated to undertake the illustration of the early and most obscm-e portion of our annals, refrained from entering on the examination of authorities which, to them, appeared indisputable. Mr. O'Callaghan, however, conceiving it improbable that the sol- diers, whose bravery had won the admu-ation of Europe, at Marsaglia, Cremona, Luzzara, and Ramillies, should have behaved so inglo- riously, as had been represented, at home, when they were in arms for their country and their king, commenced his researches among the Continental and British manuscript repositories ; and a portion of the results of his labors appears in the notes to this edition* of the " Destruction of Cyprus" deserting, true to their colours, and faithful to their engagements, had never swerved from the fidelity they had sworn to; and following the fortunes of their king, they submitted to the sacrifices he required, in exile and adversity. Noble and generous men, taken from the hum- blest life, you want but an historian to rescue your fame from the calumnies of your conquerors, and to elevate you to a level with the soldiers of the republics of antiquity !" — Military History of the Irish Nation. 8vo. Dublin- 1845. * The " Camden Society," in 1841, published an edition of the " Destruc- tion of Cyprus," in which the notes, by the editor, Mr. T. Crofton Croker, did not exceed thirty pages ; while those of Mr. O'Callaghan, in the edition published by the Irish Archfeological Society, occupy upwards of three hundred and fifty pages, in type nearly as small as that used in the present notes. We Avould gladly have seen him give more copious illustrations, as the value of the critical examination of so minute an investigator can only be appreciated by those students who are conversant with the accounts hitherto received of the same events. Mr. Croker's annotations consist almost entirely of extracts from the notoriously false " London Gazette," and other government publications equally mendacious. This demonstrates clearly, that Irish history can only be written and produced properly in Ireland. The day has happily passed when one-sided accounts THE HISTORIC LITERATURE OF IRELAND. 57 We there fiud the most minute and important information on all the controverted points, derived from the unquestionable authority of muster rolls, original government documents, and official despatches; coupled with a critical investigation and profound analyzation of the printed contemporary publications, unincumbered with super- fluous comment, and all set forth in a calm and truth-seeking spirit of historical research. The Editor has thus perfectly succeeded in re- moving from the Irish the stigma of having " always fought badly at home," and has identified his name with the military history of our country.* In accomplishing this arduous task he must have felt, with Sismondi, that he " should have to beat down many an idol which men have delighted to worship ; that he should have to dispel many favorite illusions, neither consulting feelings, nor sparing prejudices. Full well did he know that he should be rarely praised ; but an historian has a sterner duty to fidfil than that of pleasing his readers — a far more noble object than success." The Society's edition of the " Destruction of Cyprus'^ must not, however, be regarded as a history solely of the campaigns of 1689-91. In the "notes and illustrations" will be found profound and lucid essays on the most important portions of our annals ;"j* and were eagerly received. The spirit of inquiry is abroad, and no historical document will now be accepted with confidence, which does not fairly give the authorities on both sides. Mr. Croker is an elegant poet, and a charm- ing illustrator of " Fairy Legends ;" but his edition of Colonel O'Kelly's v^ork has shown that he is totally incompetent for the task of an impartial historical investigator. * It is perfectly evident, that the editor of the Archaeological Society's edition of the " Destruction of Cyprus" has before him the materials for illustrating the affairs of Ireland during the times of James II. The bare collection and examination of such a mass of documents must necessarily have been the labor of many years on the Continent, and in Great Britain and Ireland. We therefore trust that Mr. J. C. O'Callaghan will give us a history of that period, in a narrative form, copiously illustrated with original docu- ments on both sides of the question. Such a work, on the last great national and legitimate war in this country, would at once assume a standard posi- tion in the Irish historical library, and moreover, form a necessary introduc- tion to the " History of the Irish Brigades in the Service of France," on which, we understand, he is at present engaged. t There are many hitherto controverted historical questions finally settled in this edition of the "Destruction of Cyprus." Notes 62, 63, 64, 67, and the Appendix, demonstrate that the Irish hierarchy's formal transfer of the Kingdom of Ireland to Henry II, of England, in the Synod of Cashel, A.D. 1172, was the result of a previous correspondence of the native Prelates with the See of Rome ; even in an age, when, according to the 58 THE HISTORIC LITERATURE OF IRELAND. there are few, even the most erudite, who will not find satisfaction in consulting this valuable compendium of Iiish learning. It, indeed, clearly demonstrates the necessity of placing our history on an entirely new basis, which, to be lasting, must be founded on calm and lengthened investigation, and a thorough examination of ori- ginal documents. The appearance of this edition of the " Destruction of Cyprus'' was extremely opportune, at a time when the history of the period of which it treats was about to be brought before the public, in the brilhant and fascinating pages of Macaulay, who, if he desire to attain to the character of a faithful historian, must carefully study Mr. O'Callaghan's elaborate production. This, for his own sake, we trust he will do ; and laying aside all prejudices, treat the Irish with as much impartiality and historic justice as our gallant and honest countryman. Colonel Napier, has exhibited towards the French. John De Colton,* an ecclesiastic of importance in his day, was successively Dean of St. Patrick's, Dublin, Lord Chancellor, Justice, and finally, in 1382, Primate of all Ireland. An excellent illus- tration of the sacerdotal character of those ages, we find him, at one time enacting stringent ordinances for the regulation of his clergy ; and at another period, he is to be seen in arms, at the head of a band of knights, raised at his own expense, defending the limited tenitories of the Anglo-Normans against the vigorous as- saults of the native clans. In 1374, the King, in consideration of Italian historians, the Popes and subordinate clergy at Rome were beaten and imprisoned, or mutilated and murdered, by the nobles and people of the " eternal city." The authenticity is here clearly proved of the English Pope's Bull, which the late Rev. Dr. Lanigan erroneously stated the editors of the collection of Papal official documents were ashamed to print. Ro- deric O'Conor, King of Ireland, and the native Princes, who, contrary to all former precedents, were excluded from the Synod at Cashel, did not recognise the attempt there made by the Irish Clergy to place their country in the hands of the King of England. We learn from the letter of the Chiefs of Ireland to Pope John XXII., that the old monarchs of the country ** acknowledged no superior in temporal affairs." * Acts of Archbishop Colton in his Metropolitan Visitation of the Diocese of Derry, A.D. MCCCXCVIL ; with a Rental of the See Estates at that time. Edited, from the Original Roll, preserved in the Archiepiscopal Record Closet of Armagh, ivith an Introduction and Notes, by the Rev. William Reeves, D.D., M.R.LA.; Bachelor in Medicine of Trinity College, Dub- lin; Perpetual Curate of Kilconriola, in the Diocese of Connor. Dublin : for the Irish Archaeological Society. 1850, THE HISTOPJC LITERATURE OF IRELAND. 59 the losses he had sustained during his military expeditions, granted him the sum of forty pounds sterling. Not too large a remuneration, even taking into account the high value of money at that period, when we recollect that on many occasions he remained in the field for several days. And when Newcastle, in the County of Wicklow, was taken, and bm*ned by the Clan of O'Byrne, although there was no money in the Treasury, De Colton pawned his own goods, and and with the cash thereby obtained, he, and Nicholas Sergeaunt, a citizen of Dublin, together with thirty-five of their associates, held the castle for five days, maintaining themselves at their o"vvn cost, there being no person at that time who could be prevailed upon ta take charge of the fortress. For all which, and because, when he retired fi*om this latter place, he had lost a horse worth twenty marks, which was killed by the enemy, the king commanded that he should receive the gratuity we have mentioned. Nor were his talents limited to military afiairs; for so high an opinion had Richard II. of his diplomatic powers, that he selected him to act as Ambassador to the Court of Rome. After his retm-u, he resigned his See, and died in the year 1404, leaving behind him two works on the distracted state of the Church in his own time. His biographers represent him as a man of the most sweet and affable temper, and bestow lavish praise on his unbounded gene- rosity and hospitality. An original record of the proceedings of Primate De Colton, on the occasion of his visitation of the diocese of Deny in J 397, was some time since discovered among the archives of the See of Armagh by the Rev. William Reeves. Appreciating the value of this manuscript, in illustrating the state of the Irish Church, in the fourteenth centmy, and, with a munificence worthy of the Prelate, whose acts it chronicles, he printed the document at his own expense, and presented it to the Members of the Society for the year 1850. The highest encomium we can pass on the manner in which this book has been edited by the Rev. Dr. Reeves, is to say, that it deserves to be classed with his profound work on " Down, Connor, and Dromore;"* the most valuable contribution yet made to the 4to. Dublin ; Hodges and Smith, 1848, F 60 THE HISTORIC LITERATURE OF IRELAND. history of the ecclesiastical antiquities of Ireland. And we trust that our learned ecclesiologist will follow up his labours by the publica- tion of his promised edition of the great work on the Ecclesiastical Taxation of Ireland, A.D. 1306, from the original Exchequer Rolls, preserved in the Carlton Ryde Record Office. The value of such documents is not confined to their use in Church history. The recent works on similar subjects, printed by the Scotch Societies, demon- strate the vast amount of important information to be derived from them for illustrating the progress of civilization, and the various manners and modes of life in former ages. We have thus essayed to give an account of the works published by the Irish Archaeological Society; but, as we before stated, the limits of this paper can only be expected to furnish a brief and compendious \iew of their invaluable contents. It may, however, seiTe to indicate where precise and accurate information is to be found on particular portions of Irish histoiy; and if we suc- ceed in awakening a desire for the study of their country's lite- rature amongst those who have hitherto been strangers to it, our object will be fully attained. StiU, it must be recollected that the So- ciety's books are not intended to be "j^opw/ar," in the general accep- tation of that term ; such an idea is incompatible with the production of historic materials. These volumes form the foundation on which the future writer will rear the superstructure of a great national history ; and we hope henceforth to seg our countrymen contributing to the production of such a work, by assisting in the preseiTation of the monu- ments left by their fathers, instead of seconding the efforts of ephe- meral and delusive poHtical projectors. Far, however, be it from us to advocate the study of this branch of self-knowledge to the exclusion of any other. But, we would have Lishmen to remember that it was not by the cultivation of the histories and antiquities of distant coun- tries, that the author of "Waverley" raised "Caledonia stern and wild," into the land of tourists, and the favorite resort of Royalty. Nor was it by the study of a foreign literature that the thoughtful-souled Goethe, and the many-gifted Schiller, have made their German fatherland world-famous and illustrious. The moun- tain hamlet of Arqua, in Lombardy, is not now visited as the THE HISTORIC LITERATURE OF IRELAND. 61 -resting place of the Latin epic poet, but as the shrine which contains the reHcs of the Petrarca, " Whos rethorike swete Enlumined all Itaille of poetrie."* It was fortunate for the fame of the great Florentine, that the good monks of the monastery, founded by the Irish St. Columbanus, at Bobbio, persuaded him to compose his " Divina Commedia," in the " lingua volgare" of his own country — a decision which in- fluenced the fate of Italian literature, and rendered the lover of Beatrice Portinari immortal and revered as one . " Who, in times Dark and untaught, began with charming verse, To tame the rudeness of his native land."f The most unprejudiced critics have expressed their conviction, that the Irish melodies of " the sweetest lyrist of our saddest wrongs" will outliv^e his more elaborate "works on distant countries; although the latter are replete with all the graces of the most exqui- site poetry, and all the fascinating splendours of Oriental romance. If we feel a proud satisfaction in contemplating the goodly volumes issued by the Irish Archasological Society, and which must be regarded as so many " chartce periturce,^^ rescued from almost in- evitable decay and oblivion, let the honor be given to those disin- terested and enlightened men, J who, " unactuated by antiquarian pedantry, and solely instigated by a sincere desire to do their duty in a cause of national interest and importance," have organized and car- ried out their noble design of creating and fostering a native Irish literature. Despite almost insurmountable obstacles, and even at a * Chaucer ; Prologue to the " Clerkes Tale." f Akenside. X In addition to those mentioned in the text and at page 14, as having aided the national literary cause, the following demand notice : — George Petrie, V. P. R.I. A., LL.D., a name beyond all praise. George Alexander Hamilton, M.P. for the University of Dublin, to whose zeal for the promotion of learning and education Irish literature is under numerous obligations. Major Thomas A. Larcom, of the Royal Engineers. His edition of Sir William Petty's proceedings relative to the first English sur- vey of Ireland will soon be ready for presentation to the members of the Irish Archeeological Society. Aquilla Smith, M.D., Treasurer of the same Society, our most learned Irish numismatist, and author of several valuable essays published by the Royal Irish Academy. Evelyn P. Shirley, 62 THE HISTORIC LITERATURE OF IRELAND. time when our country was nearly reduced to the fearful state in which it was, when the historian of Elizabeth tells us, that, by the evil po- licy of bad ministers, " little was left in Ireland for Her Majesty to reign over but ashes and carcasses," and when "the southern province seemed totally depopulated, and, except within the cities, exhibited a hideous scene of famine and desolation." It is scarcely possible to exaggerate the good which, in a country circumstanced like Ireland, is to be derived from historical research. Truth, we know, is powerful at all times, whilst its perversion is ever attended Avith the most disastrous consequences. The falsifi- cation of history has hitherto been, perhaps, the most formidable M.P., M.R.I. A., one of the Knights of the Shire for the County of Monaghan, author of the excellent work, on the history of his patri- mony, entitled " Some Account of the Territory or Dominion of Farney, in the Province and Earldom of Ulster," 4to, 1845, He has also published, in the present year, a volume of " Original Letters, illustrative of the State of the Church of Ireland during the time of Edward VI.," from the MS. at Lambeth. ' William E. Hudson, M.R.I.A., member of the Councils of our Archaeological and Celtic Societies, and author of the critical analysis of the orthography of the early Irish scribes, ap- pended to the "Book of Rights." This gentleman's munificence to the Celtic Society (whose publications we noticed in No. II. of the Irish Quarterly Review), is fully acknowledged in the last annual Report of that body. Samuel Ferguson, M.R.I. A., author of some valuable papers among the Academy's " Transactions," and of many admirable Irish ballads and historical essays, which we hope to see published in a collected form. Frederick W. Burton, our most eminent Dublin artist, and member of the "Committee of Antiquities." A classical group from his pencil, representing Archbishop Ussher, Luke Wadding, and Roderick O'Flaherty, forms the illustrated title-page of the valuable volumes pub- lished by the Celtic Society, and is the largest and most exquisite woodcut ever executed in Ireland by a native engraver. Joseph H. Smith, M.R.I. A., who has published several essays on Irish historical subjects, among the Pro- ceedings of the Academy, and is at present engaged in editing, from the University Manuscripts, the interesting account of the Progresses of the Lords Lieutenant of Ireland. Edward Clibborn, Esq., Curator of the Aca- demy's Museum, which ow^es many of its principal ornaments to his exertions. Before his connection with the Institution its most valuable antiquities and manuscripts were huddled together in an obscure and inaccessible reposi- tory ; they are now, owing to his assiduity, classed and arranged in a style not to be excelled by any European Collection. In closing our notice of this " dotta compagnia," whose names will not be forgotten by the future historian of the revival of Irish learning, we feel bound to state, that their efforts have been ever seconded by INIessrs. Hodges and Smith, Booksellers to the University. A glance at the catalogue of their publications will show how much they have done for the pro- motion of national literature. The valuable series of Irish manuscripts brought together by them, some years ago, and still known as " Hodges and Smith's Collection," is now one of the chief glories of the Academy's library. THE HISTORIC LITERATURE OF IRELAND. 63 weapon in the annoury of the political demagogue. The publica- tion of our true annals will totally deprive the mob-orator and the factious journalist of their strongest hold on the passions of an irascible and imaginative race, easily excited by exaggerated and one-sided representations of former events. Irishmen will learn, from their own history, that they have been too much the victims of mis- guiding speculators and trading politicians ; and they will find that education and industry are the only true and lasting sources of national prosperity and greatness. The foundation of the Irish Archaeological Society marks an era in our literature. From the pe- riod of its formation, we can distinctly trace the onward progress which has been made in the cultivation of national historical research ; and the many valuable works which have, since that time, issued from the Dublin press, fully attest the beneficial effects of the Society's in- fluence. An ample field still lies before om* Aixh^eologists ; numbers of the most important Celtic manuscripts still remain unpublished;* * We trust that the Council of the Society will see the necessity of un- dertaking the publication of the larger and more comprehensive manuscript works, which serve to illustrate various historical eras. Of these, one of the most important is the '' Coghadh Gaoidheal le Gallaihh," or '= Wars of the Irish with the Danes," a complete copy of which has been lately discovered in the Bibliotheque des Dues de Burgogne, at Brussels. This document contains ample information on the great struggle which terminated so gloriously for Ireland ; and the means exist of illustrating it minutely, from contemporary Irish productions. We understand that the Danish govern- ment have signified their desire to contribute to the expense of the publica- tion of this important work. A late report of the Society of Northern Antiquarians, at Copenhagen, demonstrates the interest with which Mr. Worsaae's communications relative to the old Irish manuscript accounts of the wars of the Danes in our country, were received. Mr Curry's inves- tigations prove that this History of the Danish Wars was written at a com- paratively short period after the battle of Clontarf, which is further at- tested by a fragmentary document preserved in the " Book of Leinster," a manuscript of the twelfth century, compiled by the tutor of Dermod Mac Murchad, and containing a pathetic note, written on the very day of that prince's expulsion from Ireland — an event which was attended with such important consequences. Recent researches among our ancient Irish manuscripts demonstrate that the accounts hitherto received of the circum- stances which led to the Anglo-Norman invasion of Ireland are totally false and inaccurate. The '■'Borama" or History of the " Boromean Tribute," is a ■work of great value in illustrating the earlier portion of our annals, and treats of a subject on which we possess no published information. The History of the Fir Bolgs, or early Belgic colonies in Ireland, also relates to an era on which we have as yet but imperfect accounts. The hagiographical treatises, and lives of the native Irish Saints, also well deserve publication, as no works contain more curious and valuable accounts of the manners and customs of the early inhabitants of Ireland. It must be apparent, that the 64 THE HISTORIC LITERATURE OF IRELAND. and let us trust that the more enlightened of our countrymen will, fol- lowing the example set by neighbouring nations, no longer allow the ancient records of the piety and learning of their ancestors to lie on the shelves of our collections, unknown and unappreciated, save by a few of the master-minds of our own and foreign lands. " Science and literature," says an eminent living scholar,* " have many departments, not one of which is undeserving of our regard, so long as it is cultivated in a liberal and philosophic spirit ; but the history of our own country, and of its language, has especial claims on our consideration, unless we choose to renounce the name of Irish- men. It is no morbid sentiment which leads us to tm*n, with a long- ing and affectionate interest, to the ancient history and literature of our own country. It is no fond national conceit, which inspires us with the desire to gather and to preserve those of its scattered re- cords, which have escaped the tooth of time, the ravages of barbar- ism, and the persecuting rigor of a miscalculating policy. It is, in- deed, wise in us to soar as high as we may, seeking a wide and clear view of the entire horizon of human knowledge and science ; but, even to those elevated regions let us carry with us a loving remem- brance of the spot of earth from whence we took our flight, of our birth-place, and the home, which is the sanctuary of the purest and strongest of our earthly affections." documents in the ancient Irish language, styled by the learned Pictet, "les curieux debris de la primitive Europe," are those which should be first printed ; and we have endeavoured to demonstrate the necessity of under- taking their publication during the lifetime of the Hiberno-Celtic scholars, before referred to. A Committee, we may add, has been appointed by Parliament to examine and report relative to the publication, by the Im- perial Government, of the Brehon Laws, noticed at page 9. * Rev. Charles Graves, D.D., Fellow of Trinity College, and Professor of Mathematics in the University of Dublin. Address delivered in the Royal Irish Academy, on the completion of the subscription for the pur- chase of the Betham Manuscripts, 22nd April, 1851. ti8t>& DATE DUE JUN 29 1 )93 lfAI?0, m UNIVERSITY PRODUCTS, INC. #859-5503 j~ BOSTON COLLEGE 3 9031 01276369 4 DA 908 THE HISTORIC. Bapst Library Boston College Chestnut Hill, Mass. 02167